article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
the discovery of high - energy @xmath0-radiation from extragalactic compact objects has motivated many authors to consider the effects of @xmath0-ray absorption by @xmath0-@xmath0 pair production , eventually inducing pair cascades .
the relevance of @xmath0-@xmath0 pair production to astrophysical systems has first been pointed out by nikishov ( 1962 ) .
the first investigation of the @xmath0-@xmath0 absorption probability of high - energy photons by different soft photon fields , along with some useful approximations , can be found in gould & schrder ( 1967 ) .
the energy spectrum of injected electrons and positrons due to this process has been studied by several authors ( e. g. , bonometto & rees 1971 , aharonian et al .
1983 , zdziarski & lightman 1985 , coppi & blandford 1990 ) . in most astrophysically relevant cases , simple approximations can be used for this purpose , without much loss of accuracy .
these usually rely on the high - energy photon having much higher energy than the soft photons and thus dominating the energy input and determining the direction of motion of the center - of - momentum frame of the produced pairs .
bonometto & rees ( 1971 ) used basically the same technique as we do , but restricted their analysis to the case @xmath1 , and did not solve the problem analytically .
two recipes to calculate the full energy - dependence of the injected pairs have been published ( aharonian et al .
1983 and coppi & blandford 1990 ) , but here the reader is still left with integrations to be carried out numerically .
it is the purpose of this paper to derive the full energy - spectrum of pairs , injected by @xmath0-@xmath0 pair production , exact to second order qed for the case of isotropic radiation fields . in section 2 , we give a short overview of the kinematics which are used in section 3 to calculate the pair injection spectrum . in section 4
, we compare our results to well - known approximations and specify the limitations of the various approximations .
our analysis is easily generalized to non - isotropic radiation fields .
the derivation presented here is widely analogous to the derivation of the pair annihilation spectrum , given by svensson ( 1982 ) .
we consider an isotropic photon field @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the dimensionless photon energy in a rest frame which we call the laboratory frame .
the lorentz invariant scalar product of the four - momenta @xmath4 of two photons having energies @xmath5 colliding under an angle of cosine @xmath6 in the laboratory frame is then given by @xmath7 here , @xmath8 is the photon energy in the center - of - momentum frame . in order to allow for the possibility to create an electron - positron pair ,
conservation of energy implies @xmath9 , and the condition @xmath10 determines the pair - production threshold .
@xmath11 is the lorentz factor of the electron / positron in the cm frame where the produced electrons move with speed @xmath12 and @xmath13 .
the definition of the angle variables needed in this calculation is illustrated in fig .
= 4.5 cm the cm frame moves relative to the laboratory frame with velocity @xmath14 and lorentz factor @xmath15 .
the four velocity of the laboratory frame ( @xmath16 in the cm frame ) is denoted by @xmath17 .
the lorentz factors of the produced pairs in the laboratory frame are related to the cm quantities by @xmath18 evaluating the lorentz invariant scalar product @xmath19 in the laboratory and the cm - frame , respectively , we find @xmath20 and @xmath21 inserting eq .
( 4 ) into eq . ( 2 ) and
using energy conservation ( @xmath9 ) fixes the angle cosine @xmath22 to @xmath23 the differential cross section for @xmath0-@xmath0 pair production ( see eq .
[ 11 ] ) depends on @xmath24
the differential yield of produced pairs is calculated as @xmath25 @xmath26 where @xmath27 the differential cross section has been evaluated by jauch & rohrlich ( 1959 ) : @xmath28 where @xmath29 @xmath30 @xmath31 ^ 2 } + { 1 \over [ 1 + \bcm x]^2 } \right ) \biggr\rbrace.\ ] ] we may express the solid angle element @xmath32 . using eq .
( 2 ) , we find @xmath33 this enables us to carry out the @xmath22-integration in eq .
( 9 ) immediately . if we write the denominators in eq . ( 11 ) as @xmath34 with @xmath35 we find @xmath36 @xmath37 @xmath38 ^ 2 } + { 1 \over [ a_- + b_- \cos\phi]^2 } \right ) \biggr\rbrace\ ] ] @xmath39 @xmath40 where @xmath41 @xmath42 with @xmath43 @xmath44 and we used the integrals @xmath45 @xmath46 and the identity @xmath47 which follows from eqs . ( 5 ) , ( 6 ) and ( 14 ) . now , inserting eq .
( 15 ) into eq .
( 8) yields the exact expression for the differential pair injection rate . using eq .
( 1 ) we transform the @xmath48 integration into an integration over @xmath49 .
this leads us to @xmath50 @xmath51 @xmath40 which can be calculated analytically .
the integration limits follow from @xmath52 and the condition @xmath53 which yields @xmath54 where @xmath55 @xmath56 + 1 \pm \sqrt { ( \gm [ e - \gm ] + 1)^2 - e^2 } \right).\ ] ] using the integrals 2.271.4 , 2.271.5 , 2.272.3 , 2.272.4 , and 2.275.9 , of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) , we find as final result for the differential pair yield @xmath57 @xmath58 where for @xmath59 we have @xmath60 @xmath61 @xmath62 and @xmath63 @xmath64 for @xmath65 we find @xmath66 @xmath67
now , we use the exact expression , given in eq . ( 26 ) to specify the regimes of validity and the limitations of various approximations .
the first detailed computation of the pair production spectrum was presented by bonometto & rees ( 1971 ) .
based on the neglect of the energy input of the soft photon , they basically follow the same procedure as described above , but do not carry out the angle - integration ( integration over @xmath8 in our formalism ) analytically . in the case
@xmath1 , it is in very good agreement with the exact result , but its evaluation is even more time - consuming than using the latter .
for this reason , we will not consider it in detail , but concentrate on approximations which really yield simpler expressions than the exact one .
probably the simplest expression for the pair spectrum injected by @xmath0-rays interacting with a power - law of energy spectral index @xmath69 ( @xmath70 ) is based on the assumption @xmath1 and on the well - known fact that photons of energy @xmath71 interact most efficiently with photons of energy @xmath72 which motivates the approximation for the @xmath0-@xmath0 opacity of gould & schrder ( 1967 ) using a @xmath68 function approximation for the cross section , @xmath73 since in this approach pair production takes place only near the pair production threshold ( @xmath74 ) , the produced pairs have energies @xmath75 ( bonometto & rees 1971 ) .
the resulting pair injection spectrum is therefore @xmath76 ( e. g. lightman & zdziarski 1987 ) where @xmath77 ( which , of course , reduces to @xmath78 for @xmath79 ) and @xmath80 is a numerical factor , depending only on the spectral index of the soft photon distribution .
this approximation yields useful results , if the power - law photon spectra extend over a sufficiently wide range ( @xmath81 ) and if for every high - energy photon of energy @xmath71 there is a soft photon of energy @xmath72 .
else , the injection spectrum calculated with eq .
( 30 ) cuts off at the inverse of the respective cutoff of the soft photon spectrum , seriously underpredicting the injection of pairs of higher or lower energy , respectively , where the injection spectrum declines smoothly .
nevertheless , these pairs can still carry a significant fraction of the injected power .
( 30 ) fails also to describe the injection of low - energetic pairs in case of a high lower cut - off of the @xmath0-ray spectrum even if soft photons of energy @xmath82 are present .
for example , in the case of the interaction of a power - law spectrum extending from @xmath83
@xmath84 with a soft power - law spectrum extending from @xmath85 @xmath86 eq .
( 30 ) overpredicts the injection of pairs slightly above @xmath87 by an order of magnitude and cuts off below this energy .
a similar problem arises at the high - energy end of the injection spectrum .
an example for this fact is shown in fig .
2 . in contrast ,
the approximation ( 30 ) can well be used to describe the injection of pairs at all energies if both photon fields extend up to ( and down to , respectively ) @xmath88 . for more general soft photon distributions which are different from a power - law ( e. g. a thermal spectrum ) the analogous @xmath68-function approximation
has first been introduced by kazanas ( 1984 ) . using the full cross section for @xmath0-@xmath0 pair production as given by jauch & rohrlich ( 1959 ) instead of the @xmath68-function approximation adopted in eq .
( 30 ) does not reduce the limitations of this power - law approach significantly , but other soft photon distributions can be treated more successfully with this approximation which in the limit @xmath1 reads @xmath89 where @xmath90 and the limits @xmath91 are given by eqs .
( 24 ) and ( 25 ) . here
, we have assumed that the produced electron and positron have energy @xmath92 .
this approach works equally well for power - law photon fields , but in contrast to eq .
( 30 ) , it tends to underpredict the injection of low - energetic pairs .
the same is true for the interaction of @xmath0-ray photon fields with thermal soft photon fields where the high - energy tail of the injection spectrum is described very accurately ( a few % error ) by eq .
the accuracy of this approximation improves with decreasing lower cut - off of the @xmath0-ray spectrum .
e. g. , the injection due to a power - law @xmath0-ray spectrum from @xmath93 @xmath84 interacting with a thermal spectrum of normalized termpature @xmath94 is described by eq .
( 31 ) with a deviation of less than 30 % from the exact result down to @xmath95 . for @xmath96 ,
the deviation was much less than 10 % .
we show an example for the latter situation in fig .
3 . a very useful approximation to the pair injection spectrum for all shapes of the soft photon spectrum under the condition @xmath97 has been found by aharonian et al . ( 1983 ) .
they use a different representation of the pair production cross section and end up with a one - dimensional integral over @xmath98 which is equivalent to our @xmath8 integration in eq .
they solve this integration analytically after simplifying the integrand and the integration limits according to the assumptions mentioned above .
the resulting injection spectrum is @xmath99 @xmath100 @xmath101 it describes the power - law tail of the pair spectrum injected by power - law @xmath0-ray photon fields perfectly and is much more accurate to the injection of low - energy pairs .
interaction with a power - law soft photon field is reproduced within errors of only a few % .
even if as well the @xmath0-ray as the soft photon spectrum extend to @xmath102 , the error at @xmath95 increases only to @xmath103 10 % .
problems with this approximation arise if the soft photon spectrum extends up to @xmath104 , but the @xmath0-ray spectrum has a lower cut - off @xmath105 . in this case
, the injection of low - energetic pairs is seriously overpredicted by eq .
( 32 ) . for power - law soft photon fields , the integration over @xmath106 in eq .
( 32 ) can be carried out analytically , as was found by svensson ( 1987 ) .
his equation ( b8 ) ( multiplying with the total absorption coefficient @xmath107 by which the total injection rate had been normalized to 1 ) is in perfect agreement with the numerical results according to eq .
( 32 ) .
the interaction of power - law @xmath0-ray spectra with thermal soft photon fields is generally described within an error of a few % at all electron / positron energies if the soft photon temperature is @xmath108 , even if the @xmath0-ray spectrum extends down to @xmath109 .
interestingly , even the interaction of a mildly relativistic thermal photon field ( @xmath110 ) with itself ( for which aharonian s approximation was not designed ) is reproduced reasonably well , but the result of eq .
( 32 ) differs from the exact injection rate by a roughly constant factor . when artificially introducing a factor adjusting the high - energy tails of the injection spectra , eq .
( 32 ) overpredicts the injection of low - energetic pairs by a factor of @xmath111 , but for @xmath112 there is very good agreement with the exact result .
the deviation becomes more important with increasing photon temperature , and for @xmath113 the injection of cold pairs is already overpredicted by a factor of @xmath114 .
4 illustrates the accuracy of the various approximations for a compact thermal radiation of temperature @xmath113 .
we find that all the statements on soft photon or @xmath0-ray power - law spectra made above are only very weakly dependent on the respective spectral index .
we derived the full energy spectrum of injected pairs , produced by @xmath0-@xmath0 pair production and compared the result to the various approximations known before .
we found that the simplest expressions , based on @xmath68 function approximation to the cross section can well reproduce the power - law tail of the injection spectrum , but have problems at low particle energies . | we present the first completely analytical computation of the full differential @xmath0-@xmath0 pair production rate from compact radiation fields , exact to 2nd order qed , and use this result to investigate the validity of previously known approximations . |
the understanding of irreversible phenomena including nonequilibrium ( ne ) steady state is a long - standing problem of quantum statistical mechanics . with the recent experimental developments , it is now possible to measure the transport properties through nanoscale systems
. these can be either the electronic charge transport or heat transport . both properties , i.e. thermoelectric transport
, have recently been measured simultaneously @xcite .
such properties exhibit many important new features in comparison with conduction through macroscopic systems .
in particular , the interactions , such as coulomb interaction between electrons and scattering from atomic vibrations , become critically important in nanoscale objects , especially in single organic molecules @xcite modelling such transport properties is still a challenge since one needs to be able to describe the system at the atomic level in a realistic manner , and one needs to use a formalism for the quantum transport that takes full account of the ne conditions ( full nonlinear response ) and the many - body ( mb ) interaction .
nonequilibrium green s functions ( negf ) seems , at the present moment , the best way to tackle the problem .
however , negf calculations for realistic systems are difficult to achieve , beyond mean - field - like approximations or quasi - equilibrium regime , since the calculations of the mb effects for a large number of electronic ( and vibronic ) degrees of freedom are extremely demanding
. alternatively , the density - functional ( df)-based theories can handle large systems , but unfortunately treat the interaction ( between electrons for example ) on a mean - field - like basis and the corresponding functionals are not necessarily optimized , or even valid , for the ne conditions . in this paper , we present an alternative approach based on the use of ne distribution and spectral functions . on one hand ,
such an approach is , in principle , strictly equivalent to the steady - state negf technique , since there is a one - to - one equivalence between the green s functions ( gf ) and the ne distribution and spectral functions .
one the other hand , approximations for the mb effects ( in the presence of ne conditions ) seems to be more easily introduced in the ne distribution , while keeping a clear physical interpretation .
furthermore the use of approximated ne distributions may offer an alternative approach for future implementations in df - based calculations for large systems . in earlier studies
, we have already started developing and using the concept of ne distribution functions .
this was done in a critical analysis of the applicability of landauer formalism for ne current in the presence of interactions @xcite , and in the study of the ne charge susceptibility and its relation with the nonlinear dynamical conductance @xcite . in this paper , we develop in detail our approach using ne distribution and spectral functions , and provide numerical applications .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : ness ] , we define the general steady state transport set - up .
we start by considering a model system in sec .
[ sec : onelevel ] and provide all the analytical results for the ne distributions .
[ sec : fne ] concerns the general properties of the ne distributions . in sec .
[ sec : fne_algo ] , we develop an algorithm for performing ne calculations .
numerical applications are provided in sec .
[ sec : numerics ] where we show examples of the ne distributions for a model of electron - phonon interacting system .
the performance of the exact and approximated ne distributions are studied in this section .
the generalisation of our approach to more realistic systems are provided in sec . [
sec : realistic ] .
finally we comment our results and conclude our study in sec .
[ sec : ccl ] .
we consider a system consisting of a central region @xmath0 connected to two non - interacting fermi seas .
the left ( @xmath1 ) and right ( @xmath2 ) electrodes are at their own equilibrium , with a fermi distribution @xmath3 defined by their respective chemical potentials @xmath4 and temperatures @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) .
the central region @xmath0 connected to the leads contain interaction characterized by a self - energy @xmath7 in the negf formalism .
furthermore the specific model used for the leads does not need to be specified at the moment , as long as the leads can also be described by an embedding self - energy @xmath8 in the electron gf of the central region .
the possibility of reaching a steady state regime in such a two - terminal device has been explored by many authors . the full time - dependent negf formalism and the influence of bound states in the central region
have been studied in refs .
rigorous mathematical methods based on the @xmath9 algebra have been used to study the existence and stability of such ne steady state , i.e. , its independence of the way the division into subsystems and reservoirs is performed and its stability against local perturbations , in the absence @xcite and in the presence of interaction @xcite . for an established steady state regime
, it is expected that some formal advantages may be given by an approach to ne processes in which the gibbs - like ensembles play a prominent role .
the construction of such gibbs - like ensembles for the ne steady state can be obtained either by using the maclennan - zubarev approaches @xcite or the ne density matrix approach developed by hershfield in ref .
the latter has been extensively used for calculating quantum electron transport properties , with or without interaction @xcite . in the following ,
we show that the ne statistics of the open quantum system , i.e. the central region @xmath0 contains , information not only of the ne conditions but also about the mb interaction .
we now consider a model for the central region made of a single electron level in the presence of interaction . in this section
all quantities are either real or complex number functions of a single energy argument . in a recent paper @xcite ,
we have shown , using maclennan - zubarev and hershfield approaches , that the steady state can be interpreted as an effective equilibrium state with a corresponding ne density matrix , or equivalently , with a corresponding ne statistics .
such a ne statistic can be defined by a ne distribution function @xmath11 .
it enters the relation between the different gfs defined in the central region @xmath0 as follows : @xmath12 with @xmath13 and with @xmath14 .
we recall that the spectral function @xmath15 of the central region is obtained from @xmath16 .
( [ eq : gf_and_fne ] ) bears resemblance with the so - called kadanoff - baym ansatz @xcite , but as we have shown in ref . [ ] , it is a strictly exact result for the steady state regime . at equilibrium , @xmath10 is simply the fermi distribution @xmath17 .
out of equilibrium , the distribution function will depend on the set - up , i.e. on the forces driving the system ( gradient of chemical potential and/or temperature between the leads ) , and on the interaction present in the region @xmath0 . in the absence of interaction ,
the ne distribution function for the electron is simply given by @xcite @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the spectral function of the embedding ( lead @xmath20 ) self - energy .
it is simply a double - step function , with more or less steep steps ( depending on the temperature @xmath21 and @xmath22 ) located around @xmath23 and @xmath24 , and separated by @xmath25 ( @xmath26 is the applied bias ) . in the presence of interaction in the central region @xmath0 ,
the ne distribution is given by @xcite @xmath27 using the definitions @xmath28 and @xmath29 , with @xmath30 , we obtain : @xmath31 eq . ( [ eq : fne ] ) is the `` universal '' expression of the electron ne distribution function . it is universal with respect to the interaction , in the same sense that the gfs have an universal expression via the use of the interaction self - energies . however , as expected for ne conditions , the ne distribution function is not as universal as its equilibrium counterpart , since it depends on both the set - up that drives the system out of equilibrium ( via @xmath32 ) and on the mb interaction @xmath33 ( which are themselves dependent on the ne conditions ) .
we comment more on these properties in appendix [ app : fne_withwithout_inter ] . from eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) , we can see that the ne distribution @xmath10 arises from two terms @xmath34 a dynamically renormalized distribution @xmath35 , with the renormalisation @xmath36 given by the sum of the spectral functions of the leads @xmath37 and of the interaction @xmath38 , and an extra term @xmath39 corresponding to the inelastic processes given by @xmath40 , and renormalised by the same factor @xmath36 . the non - interacting distribution @xmath32 is formed by two fermi - dirac distributions shifted by the bias @xmath26 .
however , the full ne distribution presents richer features ( peaks and dips ) characteristics of the electron population redistribution arising from both the ne and interaction effects .
one can obtain both accumulation or depletion ( i.e. population inversion ) in some energy windows , such features in the ne distribution provide information about the efficiency of relaxation / equilibration processes in the system .
furthermore , another important property of the ne distribution @xmath10 is related to its functional form .
indeed , any feynmann diagrams for the interaction self - energy @xmath41 ( taken at any order and for electron - electron e - e or electron - phonon e - ph interaction ) is expressed in terms of the different electron gfs and phonon gfs .
the renormalisation of the phonon gfs , if present , is also obtained from another set of diagrams using the electron gfs ( in the case of e - ph interaction ) . since all gfs ( either the retarded , the advanced or the lesser , the greater , or the ( anti)time - order ) can be expressed in terms of spectral function @xmath42 alone or in terms of both the spectral function and the ne distribution , see eq.([eq : gf_and_fne ] ) ,
any self - energy is a functional of the spectral functions and of the ne distribution function . in appendix [ app : fne_functional ] , we show explicitly how such a functional dependence is obtained by considering different lowest - order diagrams for the self - energies in case of both e - e and e - ph interaction . therefore , from the general expression eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) defining @xmath10 , we can conclude that @xmath43 $ ] .
the fact that @xmath10 is a functional of itself and of the spectral function permits us to devise an approach to solve self - consistently the problem by using an iterative scheme .
such a scheme is developed in the next section and bears resemblance with conventional self - consistent negf calculations .
the method we present in this section has however some advantages compared to conventional negf calculations .
first of all , we are now dealing with two real functions @xmath11 and @xmath15 instead of complex number functions for the gfs .
more importantly these two functions have well behaved ( for numerical purposes ) asymptotic limits : the spectral function @xmath15 has a finite energy - support , i.e. @xmath44 for @xmath45 $ ] otherwise @xmath46 , and @xmath47 for @xmath48 and @xmath49 for @xmath50 where the energy domain @xmath51 is roughly the bias window @xmath52 \pm$ ] several @xmath53 .
hence by using only @xmath11 and @xmath15 , we avoid having to deal with the slow decaying behaviour in @xmath54 of the real part of the advanced and retarded gfs and self - energies .
such slow decay in @xmath54 comes from the fourier transform of the heavyside function defining the causality in the retarded ( the anti - causality in the advanced ) quantities .
we are not obliged to work with large ( i.e. long ranged ) energy grids . in principle , one should work with a grid larger than @xmath51 in order to include the possible effects of `` hot electrons '' excited well above the bias window due to the interaction . in practice
, we have found that the energy grid could be only the support of the spectral function @xmath55 $ ] . the algorithm to perform ne steady state calculations
is as follows : * start with an initial ( @xmath56 ) spectral function @xmath57 and ne distribution @xmath58 , for example those corresponding to the non - interacting case : @xmath59 and @xmath60 . *
calculate the corresponding initial self - energies @xmath61 for the chosen model of mb interaction .
* calculate the next iteration ne distribution @xmath62 from eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) as follows @xmath63 with @xmath64 $ ] .
note that the quantities @xmath65 are also real functions . *
calculate the next iteration spectral function from either + @xmath66 _ method ( a ) _ : using the following expression @xmath67 + @xmath66 _ method ( b ) _ : using the definition of the spectral functions @xmath68 , we define @xmath69 where @xmath70 should be considered as intermediate ( dummy ) functions defined from the @xmath71-th iteration spectral function @xmath72 as @xmath73 \mp i \pi a_c^{(n)}(\omega ) \ , \ ] ] where @xmath74 $ ] is the hilbert transform of function @xmath75 , i.e. @xmath74= 1/\pi\ p.v .
\int dy\ f(y)/(x - y ) $ ] . + and @xmath76 is an intermediate updated version of the self - energy obtained from @xmath77 $ ] .
* ensure normalisation of @xmath78 when using approximated functionals for the ne distribution such as @xmath79 or @xmath80 ( see below ) .
* repeat the iteration process , from step 3- , until the desired convergence is achieved ( either for the ne distribution @xmath81 or for the spectral function @xmath82 or for both ) .
it should be noted that , similarly to the spectral functions , the spectral `` densities '' of the self - energy of the leads @xmath83 , and of the interaction self - energy @xmath84 are bounded , i.e. there have zero values outside an energy interval which is roughly the same as @xmath55 $ ] .
hence we do not have to worry about the long - ranged dependence in @xmath54 of the real part of @xmath70 ; and we recover spectral functions @xmath82 which exist only on a finite energy - support . furthermore _ method ( a ) _ for the calculation of the spectral function
presents the great advantage of being extremely simple , in comparison to _ method ( b ) _ @xcite .
however , we have noticed that , in some cases when the initial spectral function of the iterative loop is too different from the expected result , the convergence process might be slower ( if not possible at all ) for _ method ( a ) _ than for _ method ( b)_. hence _ method ( b ) _ appears to be more robust upon the choice of the initial conditions .
it is entirely possible to combined both schemes in the same algorithm , starting first with _
method ( b ) _ and when some degree of convergence is reached switching to _ method ( a ) _ to obtain a more accurate level of convergence .
the method devised in the previous section can appear at first glance as just another reformulation of conventional negf calculations .
one performs calculations with another set of two independent ( but inter - related ) functions : the ne distribution @xmath10 and the spectral function @xmath42 . in conventional negf technique , one deals instead with the two independent gfs @xmath85 and @xmath86 . as mentioned above
, there is indeed a one - to - one correspondence between these two sets of functions .
however , our method offers many advantages and not only on the numerical point of view as explained previously .
indeed , as the ne distribution is a functional of itself and of the spectral function , it offers a more direct and natural way of performing approximated calculations , by considering some specific subsets of inelastic processes .
such approximations are advantageous to minimize the computational cost of the calculations , which is an important point for future applications to large and more realistic systems .
ultimately @xmath10 , given by eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) , can be expressed as an infinite series expansion in terms of the non - interacting ne distribution @xmath32 , the spectral function @xmath42 and the interaction parameters ( @xmath87 or @xmath88 ) . therefore instead of performing the calculations with the exact expression eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) , we can always truncate the series expansion to a desired level of accuracy ( i.e. selecting a specific subset of inelastic processes ) , suitable for the system and the properties under study .
we provide , in the next section , some example of approximated ne distributions and compare their performance against exact calculations using the full @xmath10 distribution .
we recall that the latter are strictly equivalent to negf calculations ( with the same model of self - energies ) .
we now consider numerical applications for a model of e - ph interacting system , and we test the different approximations available for the functional forms of the ne distribution .
the hamiltonian for the region @xmath0 is @xmath89 where @xmath90 ( @xmath91 ) is the creation ( annihilation ) operator of an electron in the molecular level @xmath92 .
the electron is coupled , via its charge density @xmath93 , to the vibration mode ( phonon ) of energy @xmath94 and the strength of the coupling is given by the constant @xmath87 , and @xmath95 ( @xmath96 ) creates ( annihilates ) a quantum in the vibron mode @xmath94 . for the transport set - up , the central region @xmath0
is connected to two ( @xmath1 and @xmath2 ) one - dimensional semi - infinite tight - binding chains via the hopping integral @xmath97 and @xmath98 .
the corresponding @xmath6 self - energy is obtained from the gf at the end of the semi - infinite tight - binding chain and is given by @xmath99 .
a dispersion relation links the energy @xmath100 with the momentum @xmath101 of an electron in the lead @xmath20 : @xmath102 .
the parameters @xmath103 and @xmath104 are the on - site and off - diagonal elements of the tight - binding chains .
with such a choice of lead self - energy , we go beyond the wideband limit ( unless @xmath104 is much larger than any other parameters ) .
the self - energies @xmath41 for the interaction between the electron and the vibration mode are calculated using the born approximation @xcite .
their expressions are given in appendix [ app : scba ] .
finally , in the most general cases , the left and right contacts are different ( @xmath105 ) and there are asymmetric potential drops , i.e. @xmath106 , with the condition @xmath107 ( i.e. @xmath108 ) .
we provide typical examples of the charge redistribution in the central region induced by both the ne effects and the interaction . for a given model of interaction self - energies , the full self - consistent calculations provided by the algorithm in sec .
[ sec : algo ] are strictly equivalent to conventional negf calculations .
hence the results obtained for @xmath10 with our method ( and full self - consistency ) are equal to those obtained from negf - scba calculations @xcite .
figure [ fig:1 ] shows how the ne distribution evolves upon increasing the ne conditions , i.e. the applied bias , for a typical set of parameters characterising the off - resonant transport regime .
one can clearly observe the difference between the non - interacting ne distribution @xmath32 and the full distribution @xmath10 .
the latter presents features ( peaks and dips ) which correspond to accumulation or depletion of the electron population induced by inelastic scattering effects .
such features are directly related to the peaks in the spectral function .
this single example confirms explicitly that , generally , @xmath109 as shown analytically in appendix [ app : fne_withwithout_inter ] . as mentioned in section [ sec : approx_fne ] , for a given choice of interaction self - energies , our approach is fully equivalent to negf calculations .
both methods corresponds to a partial resummation of a family of diagrams associated with the interaction self - energy .
however , we can further approximate the expression of the ne distribution eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) .
this corresponds to another way of partially resuming the diagrams corresponding to @xmath41 . a lowest order expansion ( loe ) , in terms of the characteristic interaction parameter ,
gives an approximated ne distribution in the following form : @xmath110 using the expressions for the self - energies @xmath111 given in appendix [ app : scba ] for the limit @xmath112 , we find that : @xmath113 \right .
\\ & \left .
- a_c(\omega-\omega_0)\ [ 1-f^{\rm ne}_0(\omega-\omega_0)]\ f^{\rm ne}_0(\omega)\ \right ] \ , \end{split}\ ] ] where the terms in @xmath114 represent ne inelastic correction terms ( to the non - interacting distribution @xmath115 ) arising from phonon emission by electron and hole .
such correction terms are proportional to the ratio @xmath116 , where @xmath117 represents to total escape ( injection ) rate of electron or hole from ( into ) the central region @xmath0 .
the order of the interaction parameter is @xmath114 as in lowest order perturbation theory .
( [ eq : fne_loe2 ] ) represents the simplest functional form of the ne distribution @xmath118(\omega)$ ] .
however , it is a lowest order series expansion in terms of the parameter @xmath87 and is only valid for weak coupling , as we will show below .
it should be noted that the inelastic processes can only occur when the bias @xmath26 is larger or equal to the excitation energy , @xmath119 , otherwise the factors associated with phonon emission by electron [ @xmath120 or by hole [ @xmath121 are zero over the whole energy range @xcite .
another possible approximation is to consider eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) using only the non - interacting distribution @xmath115 in the evaluation of the self - energies @xmath122 .
one then gets @xmath123
/ \mathcal{n}(\omega ) \ , \end{split}\ ] ] with @xmath124 and @xmath125 \right . \\ & \left .
+ a_c(\omega+\omega_0)\ f^{\rm ne}_0(\omega+\omega_0 ) \right ] .
\end{split}\ ] ] in figure [ fig:2 ] , we show different ne distributions calculated with different approximations : the non - interaction distribution @xmath115 , the full self - consistent distribution @xmath10 , different approximations for the loe distribution @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
@xmath126 $ ] is calculated from eq .
( [ eq : fne_loe2 ] ) using the full self - consistent spectral function @xmath127 , @xmath128 $ ] is calculated from eq .
( [ eq : fne_loe2 ] ) using the non - interacting spectral function @xmath129 .
finally @xmath130 is obtained from a self - consistent calculation for the spectral function ( see sec . [
sec : algo ] ) using the functional form eq .
( [ eq : fne_loe2 ] ) for @xmath131loe , or eq .
( [ eq : fne_o1 ] ) for @xmath132 .
one can see in the upper panel ( a ) of figure [ fig:2 ] that , for weak e - ph coupling , any approximations for @xmath79 give the same results , and provide a good representation of the exact @xmath10 .
the distribution @xmath133 provides a better representation for @xmath10 .
the amplitude of @xmath79 is slightly different from @xmath10 , because it is obtained from a series expansion and is not fully renormalised by the factor @xmath36 such a renormalisation is however included in @xmath133 . for larger e - ph coupling , the difference between @xmath79 and @xmath10 increases , as can be expected from any perturbation series expansion .
the loe gives physical results only when the electron - phonon coupling is such as @xmath134 < 0.5 $ ] .
otherwise one gets non - physical results for the ne distribution , i.e. @xmath135 or @xmath136 , as shown in the lower panel ( c ) of figure [ fig:2 ] .
such a behaviour never occurs for the distribution @xmath133 since it contains the proper renormalisation .
therefore , in general , it is better to use an approximated distribution like @xmath80 than the loe . another important point to mention
is shown in the panels ( b ) and ( c ) in figure [ fig:2 ] : the inelastic processes ( see side band peak located around @xmath137 ) are only reproduced in the loe when some form of self - consistent has been used , i.e. either in the form of @xmath126 $ ] or @xmath138 .
the loe distribution calculated with the non - interacting spectral function @xmath129 is not able to reproduce such effects .
finally it should also be noted that all the self - consistent calculations including approximated distributions , like @xmath79 or @xmath80 , converge much more faster than the full calculation for @xmath10 ( see footnote [ ] for more details ) .
such a numerical improvement is important for the calculations of more realistic and larger systems .
figure [ fig:3 ] shows a typical result for the dynamical conductance @xmath139 obtained in the off - resonance transport regime .
the current is calculated as in ref .
[ ] using different approximations for the ne distribution function .
the conductance @xmath140 calculated with the approximated distribution @xmath80 provides a good representation of the conductance calculated with the exact distribution @xmath10 .
the peak position are well reproduced , but the amplitude of the conductance peaks is slightly larger with @xmath80 .
this is due to the lack of full renormalisation of @xmath80 in comparison to @xmath10 .
the approximated distribution @xmath80 always gives a slightly larger electron population as shown in fig .
[ fig:2 ] .
we do not show the results obtained with @xmath79 since for coupling strengths @xmath141 , @xmath79 gives non - physical results as shown in panel ( c ) of figure [ fig:2 ] .
the inelastic effects are best represented by the inelastic electron tunnelling spectra ( iets ) provided from the second derivative of the current versus the applied bias .
figure [ fig:4 ] shows such a signal normalised by the conductance . as expected for the off - resonance regime @xcite , we obtain a peak in the iets for the voltage threshold @xmath142 . the exact iets signal calculated with the distribution @xmath10
is well presented by the iets calculated with the approximated distribution @xmath80 .
more interestingly , the results obtained with the loe approximated distribution @xmath79 also give a good representation of the iets signal , even for a coupling strength @xmath143 .
we interpret such a behaviour in the following manner : for small applied bias , where the transport is mostly tunneling and away from any resonant transport mechanisms , the loe distribution @xmath79 is still realistic ( i.e. @xmath144 ) and quite close to the distribution @xmath80 .
hence both distributions provide similar results for the iets signal .
however , whenever the bias is large enough to include any resonances ( main resonance or any phonon - side band peak ) , the loe distribution will provide a non - physical behaviour as shown in panel ( c ) of figure [ fig:2 ] .
in order to extend the previous results to more realistic systems , we need to include several electron states and eventually several vibration modes in the central region . for that
, we follow the same reasoning as in section [ sec : onelevel ] , and consider the gfs as being matrices @xmath145 in the electron level ( or site ) representation .
the self - energies are also matrix in such a representation .
we then define a new matrix for the ne distribution @xmath146 as follows : @xmath147 \ .\ ] ] with a few lines of algebra , we find that @xmath148^{-1 } \\ & = \underline{g}^r_c \underline{\sigma}^ < \underline{g}^a_c \left [ \underline{g}^r_c\ [ ( \underline{g}^r_c)^{-1 } - ( \underline{g}^a_c)^{-1}]\ \underline{g}^a_c \right]^{-1 } \\ & = \underline{g}^r_c \underline{\sigma}^ < [ \underline{\sigma}^a - \underline{\sigma}^r]^{-1 } ( \underline{g}^r_c ) ^{-1 } \\ & = \underline{g}^r_c \left ( \underline{f}_0^{\rm ne } \underline{\gamma}_{l+r } - i \underline{\sigma}_{\rm int}^ <
\right ) \left [ \underline{g}^r_c \left ( \underline{\gamma}_{l+r } + \underline{\gamma}_{\rm int } \right ) \right]^{-1 } \ , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath149 . the equation eq .
( [ eq : fnenm ] ) for @xmath146 is more complicated than eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) because of the presence of the retarded gf terms which do not cancel in the general matrix form .
furthermore , the physical interpretation of @xmath150 is more complicated .
however the diagonal matrix elements @xmath151 represent the occupations of the level @xmath71 , and the off - diagonal matrix elements represent some form of probability rate of transition between states .
it should noticed that , however , all the functional analysis we have performed in section [ sec : fne ] and appendix [ app : fne_functional ] still hold for the matrix case , i.e. the interaction self - energy is functional of the spectral function and of the ne distribution .
furthermore , @xmath152 is also a functional of the spectral function , @xmath153 , which is now given in a matrix form , and @xmath154 - i \pi
a_{c , nm}(\omega)$ ] .
hence we can still use the functional property of the ne distribution , that is @xmath155 $ ] , to devise a self - consistently iterative scheme to solve the problem .
however now , we have to take into account all the different matrix elements of the ne distribution and spectral functions .
we can choose for convenience that the coupling of the central region @xmath0 to the lead @xmath20 is diagonal in the @xmath156 representation : @xmath157 .
hence the non - interacting ne distribution @xmath158 is diagonal as well , with matrix elements : @xmath159 with @xmath160 the population of the eigenvalue @xmath161 of state @xmath71 given from the statistics of the lead @xmath20 .
furthermore if the interaction is such that @xmath162 is also diagonal , the terms in @xmath163 cancel in eq .
( [ eq : fnenm ] ) ; and we end up with a set of @xmath164 equations like eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) for @xmath165 which need to be solve self - consistently for the @xmath71 distributions and the @xmath71 spectral functions @xmath166 .
however , in the most general cases , @xmath162 is not diagonal , and one would need to solve the problem in a matrix form .
for example , a generalisation of the self - energies for electron - phonon coupling , given in appendix [ app : scba ] , would be @xcite @xmath167 where the coupling matrix elements @xmath168 correspond to an excitation of the vibration mode @xmath169 ( emission or absorption of a quantum ) with electronic transition between state @xmath71 and @xmath170 .
we provide in appendix [ app:2levelmodel ] a specific example of a two - level model coupled to different vibration modes and show how to calculate the different matrix elements of @xmath150 .
as far as we know , calculations for realistic systems ( i.e. several electron levels and vibration modes ) have not yet been performed for the full range of ne and mb effects .
ne distribution functions have been used in large systems but only for non - interacting cases or for cases where the interactions are treated in a mean - field manner @xcite .
the effects of ne and mb effects for e - ph coupled realistic systems have been considered , however only at the level of a lowest order expansion for the coupling , and in conjunction with some form of self - consistency @xcite .
the really important point in the use of ne distributions for complex systems is that both the ne and mb effects are taken into account in the statistics of the finite size open quantum system ( the central region @xmath0 ) .
the ne distributions give the ( fractional ) electron population in the corresponding electronic levels in the presence of the ne conditions and for a given model of the mb effects ( self - energies ) .
one could envisage incorporating such ne statistics in density - functional - based codes able to deal with fractional occupation numbers for the corresponding kohn - sham states .
we have developed an alternative scheme to calculate the non - equilibrium ( steady state ) properties of open quantum systems .
the method is based on the use of ne distribution and spectral functions .
the method presents several advantages , but is strictly equivalent to conventional steady - state negf calculations , when using the same level of approximations for the mb interaction .
this is because there is a one - to - one correspondence with the ne distribution and spectral functions and the different gfs used in negf .
the advantages of our method resides in the fact that the ne distribution and spectral functions have well behaved features for numerical applications , and that , for the single level model , one works with purely real - number quantities . furthermore , our approach offers the possibility to introduce further approximations , not only at the level of the mb interaction ( as in negf ) , but also at the level of the functional forms used for the ne distributions .
introducing approximations at this level is important to reduce the computational cost of the method . for the model of electron - phonon
coupled system we have studied , such approximations provide a good representation of the full exact results , for either the ne distributions themselves or for physical measurable quantities such as the conductance and the iets signal .
an extension to systems consisting of several electron levels and several vibration modes has also been provided .
the concept of ne distribution functions also give more direct physical information about the open quantum system , for example in terms of depletion or accumulation of the electron population induced by the ne and mb effects .
the ne distribution is also a useful concept to study other properties of the open quantum system such as the ne charge susceptibility @xcite and the ne fluctuation - dissipation relations @xcite .
we expect that such a method will be useful for the study of large and more realistic systems @xcite , such a single - molecule thermoelectric devices , as some approximated version of the ne distributions could be implemented in density - functional - based calculations @xcite .
hn warmly thanks l.k .
dash for her precious comments and for her negf - scba code which served as the basis and as a reference tool for the present study .
hn acknowledges engaging discussions with t.n .
todorov on distribution functions for quantum transport .
from the general expression of @xmath11 in eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) , there is no _ a priori _ reason for @xmath10 to be equal to the ne non - interacting distribution @xmath32 . in the very special cases where the interaction self - energy @xmath40 follows the non - interacting statistics , i.e. in the sense that @xmath171 we obtain straightforwardly from eq .
( [ eq : fne ] ) that @xmath172 .
then all quantities , gfs and self - energies , follow the statistics given by the non - interacting case , as suggested in ref .
[ ] . however this is generally not true .
indeed , even when the interactions are present only in the central region , it is not possible to ignore their indirect mb effects which spread throughout the systems .
such effects need to be incorporated into the local statistics .
the latter can not simply arise from the ( non - interacting ) leads statistics only .
for example , in the anderson impurity model , the kondo cloud generated by electron - electron interaction expands over more than the single site where the interaction is present . for electron - phonon interaction ,
when one performs a lang - firsov unitary transformation to diagonalise the interacting part of the hamiltonian , one needs to keep the effects of such a transformation onto the effective coupling matrix elements between the ( now diagonal ) central region and the leads hamiltonians . in simple words
, one could say that the electron - phonon interaction is now crossing at the contacts between the central region and the leads .
therefore , there is no reason to assume that the corresponding statistics would be given by the non - interacting one .
moreover , there are clear indications from numerical calculations that @xmath109 .
this has been shown for electron - electron interaction ( for example , see figure 3 in ref . [ ] ) and for electron - phonon interaction ( for example , see figure 5 and 6 in ref .
[ ] , figure 6 in ref .
[ ] and figure 7 in ref .
we also provide a few examples in section [ sec : examplefnecalc ] .
we can also convince ourself that generally @xmath109 by considering the following example for electron - phonon interaction .
the lowest order diagram for which the self - energies @xmath122 are not vanishing is the fock diagram @xcite ( see appendix [ app : scba ] ) : @xmath173 .
\end{split}\ ] ] one can use the ratio @xmath174 to define a distribution function @xmath175 such as @xmath176 . at low temperature @xmath112 and the ratio @xmath177 defines a distribution @xmath178 which is clearly different from @xmath32 . indeed if @xmath179 , one has @xmath180 which is not possible from the definition of eq .
( [ eq : sigmafock_ratio1 ] ) . to further convince ourselves , let assume that @xmath181 were following the distribution @xmath32 .
then from eq .
( [ eq : sigmafock_ratio1 ] ) , we would have @xmath182 where @xmath15 is the spectral function of the central region @xmath0 . the inequality in eq .
( [ eq : sigmafock_ratio2 ] ) holds even for the symmetric electron - hole case @xcite .
hence , we can safely conclude that , in the most general cases , the two distribution functions @xmath10 and @xmath32 differ from each other .
the electron - phonon self - energies in the central region @xmath0 are calculated within the self - consistent born approximation .
the details of the calculations are reported elsewhere @xcite so we briefly recall the different expressions for the self - energies @xmath183 with @xmath184 with @xmath185 and @xmath186 and @xmath187 with the usual definitions for the bare vibron gf @xmath188 : @xmath189 \\
d_0^r(\omega ) & = \frac{1}{\omega - \omega_0 + i 0^+ } - \frac{1}{\omega + \omega_0 + i 0^+ } \ , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath190 is the averaged number of excitations in the vibration mode of frequency @xmath94 given by the bose - einstein distribution at temperature @xmath191 .
we are mostly interested to see how the inelastic effects are reproduced by our method based on the ne distribution .
therefore we ignore the contribution of the static part of the interaction , i.e. the hartree - like self - energy @xmath192 , in the calculations .
note however that since the ne distribution is defined from the lesser and greater components of the interaction self - energies , the hartree - like component is not relevant for the calculation of @xmath10 .
we analyse in this appendix the dependence of @xmath10 on the mb effects using a conventional diagrammatic ne approach for the interactions .
the lowest order non vanishing lesser and greater self - energies have the form of a convolution product of the following type : @xmath193 where @xmath194 is related to a boson propagator . for electron - phonon interaction , @xmath194
is given by @xmath195 , where @xmath196 is the phonon propagator and @xmath87 is the electron - phonon coupling constant .
different levels of approximation can be used by considering the bare phonon propagator @xmath197 , or a partially dressed phonon propagator @xmath198 or the fully dressed phonon propagator @xmath199 . for electron - electron interaction ,
@xmath194 is the screened coulomb interaction @xmath200 in which the screening is obtained according to different levels of approximation .
we describe a few of them in the following .
_ electron - phonon interaction. _ when dealing with the bare phonon , the lesser interaction self - energy becomes @xmath201 clearly such a self - energy is a functional of the ne distribution @xmath202 and of the spectral function @xmath203 .
one obtains a similar results for the greater self - energy @xmath204 . for the partially dressed @xmath205 or the fully dressed phonon propagator @xmath206
, we have the following expressions for the propagator @xmath207 or @xmath208 $ ] with @xmath209 being the polarisation function . at the lowest order ,
the polarisation is given by the electron - hole bubble diagram and its lesser and greater components are @xmath210 which is again a functional of @xmath10 and @xmath42 . therefore we find that for any phonon propagator , we have @xmath211 $ ] .
_ electron - electron interaction. _ the screened coulomb interaction @xmath212 can be calculated within different level of approximation for dielectric function @xmath213 ( @xmath88 is the fourier @xmath214-component of the bare coulomb interaction ) . in the plasmon - pole approximation @xcite , we have @xmath215 , where @xmath216 is the bulk plasmon energy and @xmath217 the plasmon dispersion relation .
the dynamic part of the screened coulomb potential @xmath218 can be rewritten as @xmath219 which involves a coupling constant @xmath220 and the bosonic propagator @xmath221 of the plasmon modes .
this corresponds to the similar case of the bare phonon propagator described above . using the same reasoning
we find that the interacting self - energy @xmath40 is a functional of @xmath10 and @xmath42 . within the @xmath222 approximation @xcite , the screened coulomb interaction is given by @xmath223 .
this expression is a formally equivalent to the case of the fully dressed phonon propagator since @xmath208= d_0(\omega ) + d_0(\omega ) \gamma_0 ^ 2 p(\omega ) \mathcal{d}(\omega)$ ] . hence applying the previous analysis
, we find again that @xmath211 $ ] .
_ vertex corrections and higher order diagrams. _ we can also consider higher order diagrams for the electron - phonon and electron - electron , as well as vertex corrections to build more elaborate self - energies . from our earlier work [ ]
, it can been seen from the expressions of the second order and vertex correction diagrams that the self - energies @xmath122 can always be expressed as functional of the ne distribution @xmath11 and of the spectral function @xmath15 @xcite .
for the two - terminal quantum devices we consider , the current @xmath224 is given by the famous meir and wingreen expression @xcite : @xmath225 , \end{split}\ ] ] where we recall that @xmath226 is the spectral function of the lead @xmath20 self - energy , i.e. @xmath227 . for the single impurity model , the trace drops off and one deals with functions only . using the definitions @xmath228 and @xmath229 , we obtain @xmath230 the lowest order expansion of the current , in terms of elastic and inelastic processes , is obtained by introducing the approximated form eq .
( [ eq : fne_loe2 ] ) for the ne distribution .
the current is built on two contribution @xmath231 with @xmath232 the second line is simply obtained from the definition of the non - interaction ne distribution eq .
( [ eq : f0ne ] ) .
we can identify @xmath233 in eq .
( [ eq : i_elas ] ) as a landauer - like current expression with the transmission given by the usual formula @xmath234 + [ \gamma_r(\omega ) g_c^r(\omega ) \gamma_l(\omega ) g^a(\omega ) ] \equiv { 2\gamma_l\gamma_r}/{\gamma_{l+r } } \ 2\pi a_c(\omega)$ ] .
this is a purely elastic transmission when the gfs or @xmath15 are calculated in the absence of interaction . in the presence of interaction
, we are dealing with elastic transport with renormalised gfs @xcite .
the second contribution to the current is given by @xmath235 \right .
\\ - & \left .
a_c(\omega ) f^{\rm ne}_0(\omega)\ a_c(\omega-\omega_0 ) [ 1-f^{\rm ne}_0(\omega-\omega_0 ) ] \ \right ] .
\end{split}\ ] ] this is simply the lowest order inelastic contribution to the current , corresponding to vibron emission by electron and hole . when eq .
( [ eq : i_inel ] ) is recast in terms of the fermi distributions @xmath236 and @xmath237 entering the definition of @xmath32 , one recovers the lowest order expansion results obtained from scattering theory @xcite and from negf @xcite if the spectral function @xmath42 is calculated in the absence of interaction .
the important point here is that our results are obtained in a rather straightforward manner by using the concept of ne distribution .
they are equivalent to others when working within with same degree of approximation for the interaction self - energy . however , with the use of approximated forms for the ne distribution , we can still perform self - consistent calculations , which go beyond second order perturbation theory .
in this appendix , we provide an example for a model of the central region consisting of two levels @xmath238 with two different kind of e - ph coupling , a local holstein - like coupling on each site and an off - diagonal su - schrieffer - heeger - like coupling between the two levels .
the interaction self - energies are non - diagonal 2x2 matrix with elements @xmath239 given ( in the limit of low temperature ) by : @xmath240 where @xmath241 and @xmath242 are the energy and coupling constant for the local e - ph interaction on level @xmath243 and @xmath244 and @xmath245 are the corresponding quantities for the non - local e - ph interaction between level 1 and 2 . for simplicity
we consider the coupling to the lead is diagonal , i.e. @xmath246 and therefore the non - interacting ne distribution matrix @xmath158 is also diagonal , with elements @xmath247 given by eq .
( [ eq : f0nen ] ) .
we focuss in the following on the loe of @xmath150 .
this approximation still shows how the different components of the ne distribution matrix are obtained in the presence of a non - diagonal interaction self - energy .
where we kept only the lowest order terms , @xmath249 is a contraction for @xmath250 and @xmath251 is the non - interacting gf of the region @xmath0 .
such a gf is diagonal with elements @xmath252 in the two - level representation .
hence we obtain the following loe for @xmath150 : @xmath253 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath254 is ratio @xmath255 and @xmath256 are the matrix elements of @xmath257 after substitution into the definition of the self - energy eq .
( [ eq : se2x2 ] ) , we obtain from eq .
( [ eq : fnm ] ) the following matrix elements of @xmath261 : @xmath262 \right .
\\ & \left .
- a_{c , ii}(\omega-\omega_i)\ [ 1-f^{\rm ne}_{0,i}(\omega-\omega_i)]\ f^{\rm ne}_{0,i}(\omega)\ \right ) \ , \end{split}\ ] ] for the diagonal elements ( @xmath243 ) and for the off - diagonal elements : @xmath263 f^{\rm ne}_{0,1}(\omega+\omega_{\rm od})\ a_{c,12}(\omega+\omega_{\rm od})\ \right .
\\ & \left .
od})\ [ 1-f^{\rm ne}_{0,1}(\omega-\omega_{\rm od})]\ f^{\rm ne}_{0,1}(\omega)\ \right ) \ . \end{split}\ ] ] the matrix element @xmath264 is obtained from the expression of @xmath265 by swapping the indices @xmath266 . from eqs .
( [ eq : fneiiloe]-[eq : fne12loe ] ) and ( [ eq : fnenmloe2 ] ) , we can see that the diagonal elements @xmath267 are real and given by an expression similar to the result eq .
( [ eq : fne_loe2 ] ) obtained for the single - level model .
the off - diagonal elements @xmath268 acquire an imaginary part via the presence of the ratio @xmath254 . in some cases ,
such an imaginary can be negligible or even vanishing .
the interesting point in the loe is that each matrix element @xmath268 is to be determined self - consistently with the corresponding matrix element @xmath269 of the spectral function .
there is no mixing between the different @xmath269 and @xmath268 .
obviously , beyond the loe , there will be some mixing between the different matrix elements of the ne distribution and the spectral function , since @xmath152 is generally not diagonal and @xmath270 is given by @xmath271 \left [ \begin{array}{cc } a_{c,11 } & a_{c,12 } \\
a_{c,21 } & a_{c,22 } \\
\end{array } \right ] \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] for convergence criteria , we calculate the difference , between successive iteration , of the quantity @xmath276 on the energy grid @xmath241 ( with @xmath277 grid points ) as follows : @xmath278 . for the conventional negf calculation the quantity @xmath279 is the retarded gf @xmath280 , for our new method
the quantity @xmath279 is either the spectral function @xmath15 or the ne distribution @xmath11 . for the calculations presented in this paper ,
the energy grid has @xmath281 points between @xmath282 and @xmath283 , while the support of the spectral function is typically within the range @xmath284 $ ] , and the leads spectral support is @xmath285=[-4.0,+4.0]$ ] . for a tolerance of @xmath286 ,
the convergence is achieved in typically @xmath287 to @xmath288 iterations for the negf ( depending on the value of the applied bias ) . for our method ( with the same number of grid points ) , the convergence is achieved in @xmath289 to 50 iterations . using the approximated ne distributions @xmath79 or @xmath80 ,
the convergence is even faster ( @xmath290 to 40 ) . for the single site model , the gain in computing ( human ) time is almost not perceivable
, however the gain should be important when the method is implemented for larger and more realistic systems .
furthermore , we usually consider an energy grid 3 or 4 times larger than the energy support @xmath285 $ ] of the leads so that the real parts of the retarded or advanced gf and self - energies are negligible at the grid ends . with our new method
, we can work with an energy grid smaller than @xmath285 $ ] .
hence , for the same energy resolution , one would gain a factor of at least 4 on the number of grid points .
this is important factor when one considers that the self - energy calculations of the first order diagrams scale as @xmath291 and as @xmath292 for the second order diagrams @xcite .
our approach could be seen as a proof of principle for the extension to the ne conditions of the spectral density functionals method developed at equilibrium in ref .
the use of the ne distributions has also been recently introduced in ne versions of the dynamical mean field theory @xcite .
equality between the two expressions in eq .
( [ eq : sigmafock_ratio2 ] ) would hold only in the limit @xmath293 .
but this corresponds to a pathological case of phonon with zero frequency and generates only an infinite static renormalisation , and no inelastic self - energies , @xmath294 , which is not relevant for any study and is far from any realistic conditions . | we derive a general expression for the electron nonequilibrium ( ne ) distribution function in the context of steady state quantum transport through a two - terminal nanodevice with interaction . the central idea for the use of ne distributions for open quantum systems
is that both the ne and many - body ( mb ) effects are taken into account in the statistics of the finite size system connected to reservoirs .
we develop an alternative scheme to calculate the ne steady state properties of such systems .
the method , using ne distribution and spectral functions , presents several advantages , and is equivalent to conventional steady - state ne green s functions ( negf ) calculations when the same level of approximation for the mb interaction is used .
the advantages of our method resides in the fact that the ne distribution and spectral functions have better analytic behaviour for numerical calculations .
furthermore our approach offer the possibility of introducing further approximations , not only at the level of the mb interaction as in negf , but also at the level of the functional form used for the ne distributions . for the single level model with electron - phonon coupling
we have considered , such approximations provide a good representation of the exact results , for either the ne distributions themselves or the transport properties .
we also derive the formal extensions of our method for systems consisting of several electronic levels and several vibration modes . |
electron scattering from nuclei is a common and powerful tool for studying the structure of nuclei .
the method relies on our superior understanding of quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) and the relative ease by which qed may be applied to a variety of processes , at least in the one - photon - exchange approximation . in inclusive @xmath3 electron scattering all nuclear - structure information
is contained in two dynamical quantities : the longitudinal and transverse response functions .
the longitudinal response is sensitive to the distribution of charge in the nucleus while the transverse response samples the distribution of currents and magnetization .
measurement of these quantities in the quasielastic region is expected to be particularly clean as the reactive content of the reaction is dominated by quasifree proton knockout .
if so , `` reduced '' longitudinal and transverse response functions , obtained from the full nuclear responses by dividing out the corresponding single - nucleon form factor , should be equal .
yet a quenching of the longitudinal response relative to the transverse one of 14% in @xmath0he and 50% in @xmath4pb has been reported from a quasielastic @xmath3 electron - scattering measurement @xcite . a similar , in fact even larger 20 - 40% ,
quenching in @xmath0he has also been reported in the semi - exclusive @xmath1 reaction at quasielastic kinematics @xcite . in order to explain the longitudinal / transverse ( l / t ) discrepancy a variety of explanations
have been proposed .
these include medium - modifications to vacuum polarization @xcite , nucleon swelling @xcite , and brown - rho scaling @xcite .
it is fair to say , however , that the l / t anomaly remains an unsolved problem in nuclear physics .
the appeal of the @xmath1 reaction is due to the perceived sensitivity of the process to the nucleon momentum distribution .
interest in this reaction has stimulated a tremendous amount of experimental work at electron facilities such as nikhef , mit / bates , and saclay , who have championed this effort for several decades .
while it is undeniable that this reaction involves the best understood theory in all of physics ( qed ) many uncertainties remain due to the strongly - interacting character of the many - body system .
it is hoped that with the advent of modern electron - scattering facilities , such as the thomas jefferson national accelerator facility ( jlab ) and mainz , some of the remaining open questions will be answered .
indeed , in an attempt to elucidate the physics of the l / t anomaly discussed earlier , a systematic study of the longitudinal and transverse response functions from @xmath5he and @xmath0he is being conducted at the mainz microton ( mami ) facility by the a1-collaboration @xcite .
their extraction of `` experimental '' spectral functions and of momentum distributions relies on a plane - wave - impulse - approximation ( pwia ) .
in such an approximation the @xmath1 cross section is proportional to the nucleon spectral function times an off - shell electron - proton cross section ( @xmath6 )
. experimental analyses of this reaction employ , almost exclusively , the de forest s @xmath7 prescription for @xmath6 with both nucleon form factors unmodified from their free - space form @xcite .
stimulated by this new experimental thrust , we report here relativistic plane - wave - impulse - approximation ( rpwia ) calculations of the @xmath1 cross section in the quasielastic region . our motivation for such a study is fourfold .
first , we employ an established rpwia formalism , first introduced in ref .
@xcite and recently extended to the kaon - photoproduction reaction @xcite , for the study of the @xmath1 reaction in the quasielastic region .
second , we use this formalism to compute the spectral function of @xmath0he in anticipation of the recently measured , but not yet fully analyzed , @xmath2-collaboration data from mainz @xcite .
third , we take advantage of the l / t separation at mainz to introduce what we regard as the cleanest physical observable from which to extract the nucleon spectral function .
lastly , we highlight some of the challenges and opportunities that remain in the calculation of quasifree observables .
there is a vast amount of literature on @xmath1 reaction in the quasifree region .
most relevant to our present discussion is the one pertaining to fully relativistic calculations @xcite .
an extensive set of these relativistic studies has been conducted by the _
`` spanish '' _ group of udias and collaborators @xcite .
these studies have shown that the many subtleties intrinsic to the relativistic approach challenge much of the `` conventional wisdom '' developed within the nonrelativistic framework and that , as a result , a radical revision of ideas may be required .
relativistic effects originating from medium modifications to the lower components of the dirac spinors and from the negative - energy part of the spectrum seem to play an important role in the quasifree process . indeed , the much debated issue of short - range correlations at large missing momenta @xcite can now be attributed , at least in part , to contributions arising from the negative - energy states @xcite .
the power of the theoretical approach employed here lies in its simplicity .
analytic expressions for the response of a mean - field ground state may be provided in the plane - wave limit .
the added computational demands placed on such a formalism , relative to that from a free on - shell proton , are minimal .
the formalism owes its simplicity to an algebraic trick , first introduced by gardner and piekarewicz @xcite , that enables one to define a `` bound '' ( in direct analogy to the free ) nucleon propagator .
indeed , the dirac structure of the bound nucleon propagator is identical to that of the free feynman propagator . as a consequence
, the power of feynman s trace techniques may be employed throughout the formalism .
the paper has been organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : formal ] some of the central concepts and ideas of the semi - exclusive @xmath1 reaction are reviewed .
special emphasis is placed on defining the bound - state propagator and the simplifications that this entails in the plane - wave limit . in sec .
[ sec : results ] we present our results for @xmath0he and discuss a ( fairly ) model - independent method for extracting the nucleon momentum distribution .
finally , a summary and conclusions are presented in sec .
[ sec : concl ] .
in refs . @xcite a general formalism has been developed for the study of a variety of quasifree processes in the relativistic plane - wave impulse approximation ( rpwia ) .
this formalism is now applied to the @xmath1 reaction in a mean - field approximation to the walecka model @xcite . although the use of a mean - field approach for a nucleus as small as @xmath0he is questionable , we allow ourselves this freedom in order to establish a baseline against which more sophisticated approaches may be compared . following a standard procedure , an expression for the unpolarized differential cross section per target nucleon for the @xmath1 reaction is derived .
we obtain , @xmath8 in the above expression @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 denote the linear momentum of the incoming electron , outgoing electron , and knocked - out proton , respectively .
the four - momentum transfer is defined in terms of the energy loss ( @xmath12 ) and the three - momentum transfer ( @xmath13 ) as @xmath14 .
the transition matrix element @xmath15 is given in a relativistic mean - field picture by @xmath16 [ msquare ] here @xmath17 is the free dirac spinor for the knocked - out proton , normalized according to the conventions of bjorken and drell @xcite , while @xmath18 is the fourier transform of the relativistic spinor for the bound proton . note that @xmath19 denotes the collection of all quantum numbers necessary to specify the single - particle orbital , except for the magnetic quantum number ( @xmath20 ) which is indicated explicitly .
we have also introduced a `` bound - state propagator ''
@xmath21 normalized according to : @xmath22 here @xmath23 is the total angular momentum quantum number and @xmath24 is the multiplicity of protons in the struck shell .
it follows from simple kinematical arguments that the missing momentum @xmath25 is , in a mean - field picture , identical to the momentum of the struck proton .
it is the possibility of mapping the nucleon momentum distribution that makes the @xmath1 reaction so appealing .
we now invoke an algebraic trick first introduced in ref .
@xcite to simplify the expression for the hadronic tensor @xmath26 .
this technique is useful in quasifree processes as it enables one to cast the bound - state propagator of eq .
( [ boundprop ] ) into a form identical in structure to that of the free feynman propagator .
that is , @xmath27 where we have defined mass- and four - momentum - like @xmath28 $ ] quantities according to @xmath29 \ ; , \label{masslike}\\ e_{\alpha } & = & \left({\pi \over p^{2}}\right ) \big[g_{\alpha}^{2}(p ) + f_{\alpha}^{2}(p)\big ] \ ; , \label{epm } \\ { \bf p}_{\alpha } & = & \left({\pi \over p^{2}}\right ) \big[2 g_{\alpha}(p ) f_{\alpha}(p)\hat{\bf p } \big ] \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , they satisfy the `` on - shell relation '' @xmath30 in these expressions @xmath31 and @xmath32 are the fourier transforms of the upper and lower components of the bound - state dirac spinor , respectively @xcite . using this form of the bound - state propagator
the hadronic tensor simplifies to : @xmath33 the obvious similarity in structure between the free and bound propagators results in an enormous simplification : powerful trace techniques developed elsewhere may now be employed here to compute all @xmath1 observables . although the focus of this paper is the unpolarized cross section [ eq .
( [ d5sigma ] ) ] the formalism may be extended without difficulty to the case in which the electron , the outgoing proton , or both , are polarized . yet , in order to automate this straightforward but lengthy procedure , we rely on the _ feyncalc 1.0_@xcite package with _
mathematica 2.0 _ to calculate all the necessary traces . for a general electromagnetic current operator for the proton ,
the output from these symbolic manipulations is transparent enough so that the sensitivity of the cross section to the various quantities in the problem may be assessed .
indeed , such a simplification will prove useful later in identifying the optimal observable from which to extract the spectral function .
it is important to note , however , that this enormous simplification would have been lost had distortions been included in the formalism .
even so , the plane - wave approach discussed here , and used in most experimental extractions of the spectral function , is qualitatively useful .
moreover , if the main effect of distortions is to induce an overall suppression of the cross section without affecting significantly the distribution of strength , the plane - wave formalism provides solid quantitative predictions for a variety of spin observables @xcite .
yet an important open question remains : what constitutes a suitable form for the nucleon electromagnetic current ?
a ubiquitous form given in the literature is @xmath34 while this form is certainly general , as only two form factors are required to fully specify the electromagnetic current for an on - shell nucleon , the form is not unique .
indeed , many other forms all of them equivalent on - shell may be used .
for example , through a gordon decomposition of the current one arrives at @xmath35 however , as soon as one of the nucleons goes off its mass shell , an off - shell choice must be made .
this decision is crucial , as various on - shell equivalent choices may yield vastly different results .
this off - shell ambiguity remains one of the most serious obstacles in the field .
several attempts have been made in the literature to overcome this hurdle .
perhaps the most celebrated treatment is due to de forest who uses physical constraints , such as current conservation , to reduce this ambiguity @xcite .
he imposes this condition on the two forms of the electromagnetic current given above [ eqs .
( [ cc2 ] ) and [ cc1 ] ] and produces what are known in the literature as the @xmath36 and the @xmath7 forms , respectively .
although noteworthy , this effort does not resolve the ambiguity .
for example , there is no unique way to impose current conservation ; one may eliminate either the time component or the longitudinal component of the three - vector current @xcite .
alternatively , one may adopt some guiding principle , such as vector - meson - dominance , to go off the mass shell .
here we adopt the `` natural '' choice by simply extrapolating off the mass shell the @xmath36-form , without imposing further constraints on the single - nucleon current .
as de forest has done in the past , we now attempt to impose some approximate form of gauge invariance .
yet rather than concentrating on the nucleon current , we focus directly on the nuclear responses .
first , however , we address some important issues in this regard . for any mean - field treatment of the @xmath1 reaction to be gauge invariant , the mean - field potential for the bound proton must be identical to the distorting potential for the emitted proton .
this represents a challenging task .
indeed , mean - field approximations to the nuclear ground state give rise to real , local and energy - independent potentials that are in contradiction to the complex and energy - dependent potentials that are needed to describe the propagations of the outgoing proton .
thus , present - day calculations of @xmath1 observables are presented with a dilemma .
calculations that use the same ( real and energy - independent ) mean fields to generate both the bound single - particle wave - function and the distorted wave satisfy gauge invariance but miss some of the important physics , such as absorption , that is known to be present in the outgoing channel . on the other hand , calculations that incorporate the correct physics via a phenomenological optical potential are known to violate current conservation @xcite .
we offer here no solution to this complicated problem .
rather , we impose gauge invariance `` ad - hoc '' by adjusting the effective nucleon mass of the emitted proton so that the `` gauge - variance '' term , @xmath37 , be minimized .
this procedure , with perhaps its unexpected outcome , is displayed in fig .
it shows that by decreasing the proton mass by about @xmath38 mev , one can restore gauge invariance in the calculation : @xmath39 .
although by no means fundamental , this `` poor - man '' distortion ensures the conservation of gauge invariance without compromising the clarity of the formalism . the essence of the experimental extraction of the spectral function is based on a nonrelativistic plane - wave result @xcite : @xmath40 however , this procedure is problematic .
first , the quasifree cross section [ the numerator in eq .
( [ speca ] ) ] suffers from the off - shell ambiguity ; different on - shell equivalent forms for the single - nucleon current yield different results .
second , the problem gets compounded by the use of an elementary electron - proton cross section ( @xmath41 ) evaluated at off - shell kinematics @xcite .
finally , the projection of the bound - state wave - function into the negative - energy sector as well as other relativistic effects spoil the assumed factorization of the cross section derived in the nonrelativistic limit @xcite .
insights into the role of relativistic corrections , particularly those concerned with negative - energy states , may be gained by introducing the completeness relation in terms of free ( plane - wave ) spinors : @xmath42 = 1\;. \label{comp}\ ] ] naively , one would expect that the projection of a positive - energy bound state into a negative - energy plane - wave state would be vanishingly small .
this , however , it is not the case @xcite .
at the very least one must recognize that the positive - energy plane - wave states , by themselves , are not complete .
moreover , it has been shown that the projection of the bound - state spinors into the negative - energy states dominate at large missing momenta and may mimic effects perceived as `` exotic '' from the nonrelativistic point of view , such as an asymmetry in the missing - momentum distribution @xcite or short - range correlations @xcite .
indeed , caballero and collaborators have confirmed that these contributions can have significant effect on various observables , especially at large missing momenta @xcite .
to `` resolve '' the off - shell ambiguity it has become ubiquitous in the field to use the de forest @xmath7 prescription for evaluating the elementary cross section @xmath41 irrespective of the form of the electromagnetic current adopted to compute the quasifree cross section .
this is the standard procedure used in comparing theoretical calculations of the spectral function to experiment .
we may elect here to conform to tradition and use the de forest @xmath7 prescription to compute @xmath41 in eq .
( [ speca ] ) , but at a cost .
a price must be paid because of the inconsistency in using one prescription for evaluating the single - nucleon current @xmath41 and a different one ( @xmath36 ) to evaluate the quasifree cross section . to illustrate this point we display in fig .
[ fig2 ] the proton momentum distribution defined by @xmath43 note that the subscript `` 2 '' in @xmath44 stands for two - body breakup .
the graph displays the `` canonical '' momentum distribution ( solid line ) obtained from the fourier transform of the @xmath45 proton wave - function [ see eq .
( [ epm ] ) ] .
note that this canonical momentum distribution has been normalized , as it is done experimentally , to the total number of protons in the shell ( 2 for the case @xmath0he ) .
the other two curves were extracted from the quasifree cross section by adopting either the de forest @xmath7 choice for @xmath41 ( dashed line ) or the @xmath36 prescription ( dot - dashed line ) . in both cases
the quasifree cross section has been computed using the `` vector - tensor '' form of the electromagnetic current , as given in eq .
( [ cc2 ] ) .
the inset on the graph shows the integrand from which the occupancy of the shell may be computed .
it is evident that the conventional @xmath7 prescription of de forest greatly overestimates @xmath44 ( it integrates to 3.6 ) .
we attribute this deficiency to the lack of consistency : the quasifree cross section has been evaluated using the @xmath36 form of the current while the elementary amplitude uses the @xmath7 form .
one can improve the situation by adopting the @xmath36 form in the evaluation of both .
yet significant differences remain ; while the off - shell ambiguity has been reduced , it has not been fully eliminated .
moreover , the factorization assumption is only approximate , as it neglects the projection of the relativistic wave function onto the negative - energy spectrum and other relativistic effects . while a consistent relativistic treatment seems to have spoiled the factorization picture obtained from a nonrelativistic analysis , and with it the simple relation between the cross - section ratio and the spectral function [ eq .
( [ speca ] ) ] , the situation is not without remedy .
having evaluated all matrix elements of the electromagnetic current analytically in the plane - wave limit , the source of the problem can be readily identified . upon evaluating the coincidence cross section
, one learns that the off - shell ambiguity is manifested in the form of several ambiguous `` kinematical '' factors . for example , one must decide what value to use for the energy of the struck proton . should it be the binding - energy of the struck proton or should it be the on - shell value ?
this is not an easy question to answer .
energy conservation demands that the energy be equal to the binding energy ( @xmath46 ) yet the equivalence between the various forms of the electromagnetic current is derived assuming the on - shell dispersion relation ( @xmath47 ) .
this is one of the many manifestations of the off - shell ambiguity : kinematical terms that are well defined for on - shell spinors become ambiguous off - shell . in ref . @xcite de forest resolves the ambiguity , by fiat , using the on - shell choice .
perhaps a better option may be looking for an observable , that even though might be more difficult to isolate experimentally , it may display a weaker off - shell dependence than the unpolarized cross section .
to do so we examine the various components of the hadronic tensor .
we find , perhaps not surprisingly , that the longitudinal component of the hadronic tensor could be such a model - independent observable . ignoring ( for now ) the anomalous part of the electromagnetic current , the dirac - dirac component of the longitudinal tensor [ see eq .
( [ hadronic ] ) ] becomes : @xmath48 = f_1 ^ 2 \left [ m_{\alpha}m + e_{\alpha } e_{p}^\prime + { \bf p}_{\alpha}\cdot{\bf p}^\prime \right]\;. \label{w00dd}\ ] ] this expression depends exclusively on @xmath49 and @xmath50 , which are unambiguous .
note that for scattering from a free on - shell nucleon the above expression becomes : @xmath51 = f_1 ^ 2 \left [ m^2 + e_p e_{p}^\prime + { \bf p}\cdot{\bf p}^\prime \right]\;. \label{w00ddfree}\ ] ] also note , as a consequence of the lower component of the bound - state spinor @xmath32 being substantially smaller than the upper component @xmath31 , that @xmath52 while @xmath53 .
this is true even though the lower - to - upper ratio @xmath54 has been enhanced considerably in the nuclear medium relative to its free - space value .
this is an important step towards isolating an observable sensitive to the spectral function .
indeed , if the longitudinal component of the hadronic tensor is computed in parallel ( @xmath55 ) kinematics , eqs .
( [ w00dd ] ) and ( [ w00ddfree ] ) reduce to the following simple expressions : @xmath56 \left[1 \pm \left(\frac{f_{\alpha}(p)}{g_{\alpha}(p)}\right ) \left(\frac{|{\bf p}^{\prime}|}{e_{p}^\prime+m}\right ) \right]^{2}\ ; , \\
\label{w00ddpar } w^{00}_{\rm dd}\big|_{\rm free } & = & f_1 ^ 2 ( e_{p}^\prime+m ) \left[\frac{1}{2}(e_p\!+\!m)\right ] \left[1 \pm \left(\frac{|{\bf p}|}{e_p+m}\right ) \left(\frac{|{\bf p}^{\prime}|}{e_{p}^\prime+m}\right ) \right]^{2}\;. \label{w00ddfreepar } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath57 sign in the above expressions corresponds to a missing momentum @xmath58 either parallel or antiparallel to @xmath59 .
we observe that up to second - order corrections in the small ( lower - to - upper ) ratios , the hadronic tensor is proportional to the energy - like ( or mass - like ) quantity given in eqs ( [ epm ] ) . yet
this energy - like quantity @xmath60 is nothing but the fourier transform of the bound - state nucleon density .
thus we conclude that , in a mean - field treatment , the nucleon spectral function is proportional to the longitudinal response .
that is , @xmath61 .
thus , the ( dirac - dirac component of the ) longitudinal hadronic tensor is , up to second - order corrections in the lower - to - upper ratios , proportional to the nucleon spectral function .
indeed , the nucleon momentum distribution may now be easily extracted from the longitudinal response .
it becomes @xmath62 the momentum distribution for @xmath0he is displayed in fig .
[ fig3 ] using various methods for its extraction .
the solid line gives the `` canonical '' momentum distribution , obtained from the fourier transform of the @xmath45 proton wave - function [ see eq .
( [ epm ] ) ] . the momentum distribution extracted from the longitudinal response as defined in eq .
( [ w00ddratio ] ) ( dot - dashed line ) is practically indistinguishable from the canonical momentum distribution .
while it appears that a suitable observable has been found from which to extract the nucleon momentum distribution , it may be argued , and justifiably so , that @xmath63 is not a physical observable ( as @xmath64 has been neglected ) .
hence , the merit of such an extraction may be put into question . to show that the above procedure is still robust
, we display in the figure ( with a dotted line ) the momentum distribution extracted from the full longitudinal response , namely , one that also includes the anomalous component of the current .
this result remains indistinguishable from the canonical momentum distribution .
although this behavior is general , it is most easily understood by limiting the discussion to the case of parallel kinematics . in this case
the longitudinal response becomes equal to @xcite @xmath65 \left[\left(f_{1}-\xi_{p}^{\prime}\bar{q } f_{2}\right ) \pm \left(\xi_{p}^{\prime}f_{1 } + \bar{q}f_{2}\right ) \left(\frac{f_{\alpha}(p)}{g_{\alpha}(p)}\right ) \right]^{2}\;. \label{w00full}\ ] ] the contribution from the anomalous form factor @xmath64 to the longitudinal response is small because it appears multiplied by two out of three``small '' quantities in the problem : the lower - to - upper ratio , @xmath66 , and @xmath67 .
thus , up to second order corrections in these small quantities , the longitudinal response is given by @xmath68 \simeq f_1 ^ 2 ( e_{p}^\prime+m ) e_{\alpha } \;.
\label{w00approx}\ ] ] the last calculation displayed in fig .
[ fig3 ] corresponds to a momentum distribution extracted from the factorization approximation using the @xmath36 form for the electromagnetic current ( long dashed line ) .
the momentum distribution extracted in this manner overestimates the canonical momentum distribution over the whole range of missing momenta and integrates to 2.9 rather than 2 ; this represents a discrepancy of 45 percent . in summary , the longitudinal response appears to be a robust observable from which to extract the nucleon momentum distribution .
experimentally , one should proceed as follows : perform a rosenbluth separation of the @xmath1 cross section so that the longitudinal response ( @xmath69 ) may be extracted .
this expression should then be divided by the corresponding single - nucleon response . up to a simple and unambiguous kinematical factor this yield , at least in the plane - wave limit , the nucleon momentum distribution : @xmath70 note that up to second order corrections in various small quantities , this form is independent of the small components of the dirac spinors and also of the negative - energy states .
moreover , it is also free of off - shell ambiguities .
indeed , we could have used the @xmath7 form of the electromagnetic current and the results would have remained unchanged .
we regard the outlined procedure as much more robust than the conventional one given in eq .
( [ speca ] ) because the transverse component of the hadronic tensor is strongly dependent on the small components of the wave - function and also sensitive to off - shell extrapolations @xcite . in fig .
[ fig4 ] a comparison is made between our results and nonrelativistic state - of - the - art calculations of the momentum distribution of @xmath0he .
the solid line displays , exactly as in fig .
[ fig3 ] , the canonical momentum distribution .
we see no need to include the momentum distribution extracted from the longitudinal response [ eq .
( [ w00ratio ] ) ] as it has been shown to give identical results .
in addition to our own calculation , we have also included the variational results of schiavilla and collaborators @xcite , for both the urbana @xcite ( dashed line ) and the argonne @xcite ( long - dashed line ) potentials , with both of them using model vii for the three - nucleon interaction .
the variational calculation of wiringa and collaborators @xcite ( dashed - dotted ) has also been included ; this uses the argonne v18 potential @xcite supplemented with the urbana ix three - nucleon interaction @xcite .
figure [ fig4 ] also shows nikhef data by van den brand and collaborators @xcite as well as preliminary data from mainz by florizone and collaborators @xcite for three different kinematical settings .
( results in final form will be submitted shortly . )
comparisons to the preliminary mainz data of kozlov and collaborators @xcite have also been made ( although the data is not shown ) .
these measurements are consistent , in the region where comparisons are possible , to the experimental data of both van den brand and florizone .
thus , high - quality data for the momentum distribution of @xmath0he is now available up to a missing momentum of about 200 mev .
we find the results of fig .
[ fig4 ] quite remarkable .
it appears that a simple relativistic mean - field calculation of the momentum distribution rivals and in some cases surpasses some of the most sophisticated nonrelativistic predictions .
the mean - field calculations reported here , with the scalar mass adjusted to reproduce the root - mean - square charge radius of @xmath0he , provide a good description of the experimental data . still , theoretical predictions of the momentum distribution overestimate the experimental data by up to 50 - 60% .
part of the discrepancy is attributed to distortion effects which are estimated at about 12% @xcite
. however , distortions are not able to account for the full discrepancy .
we have argued earlier that an additional source of error may arise from the factorization approximation [ see eq .
( [ speca ] ) ] used to extract the spectral function from the experimental cross section .
the use of an off - shell prescription , such as the @xmath7 prescription for @xmath41 , combined with the in - medium changes in the lower - component of the dirac spinors contaminate the extraction of the spectral function .
one could estimate the source of the off - shell ambiguity by monitoring the variations in the spectral function as other on - shell equivalent forms for the single - nucleon current are used .
while such an approach is useful for estimating a theoretical error , it is clearly not sufficient to eliminate it .
we are confident that the approach suggested here , based on the extraction of the spectral function from the longitudinal response , is robust . while the method adds further experimental demands , as a rosenbluth separation of the cross section is now required , the extracted spectral function appears to be weakly dependent on off - shell extrapolations and relativistic effects .
if deviations between experiment and theory still persist , these may suggest physics beyond the baseline model , such as violations to the impulse approximation or to the independent particle picture .
to summarize , we have calculated the spectral function of @xmath0he in a plane - wave approximation to the @xmath1 reaction using a fully relativistic formalism .
we have taken advantage of an algebraic trick originally introduced by gardner and piekarewicz and of our recently developed relativistic formalism for quasifree processes to arrive at transparent , analytical results for the quasifree reaction .
we have found that a simple relativistic mean - field calculation of the momentum distribution in @xmath0he rivals and in some cases surpasses some of the most sophisticated nonrelativistic predictions to date .
these calculations attempt to provide theoretical support to the recently measured , but not yet fully analyzed , @xmath2 collaboration data from mainz .
the final experimental reports are expected to be published shortly .
we have also demonstrated that a more robust procedure , relative to the conventional factorization prescription , exists for extracting the spectral function .
this procedure uses the ratio of quasifree to single - nucleon longitudinal responses , rather than the ratio of cross sections , to isolate the momentum distribution .
we have shown that the longitudinal ratio is fairly insensitive to off - shell ambiguities and to the negative - energy part of the spectrum , as both of these effects appear as second - order corrections to a `` canonical '' momentum distribution .
this ceases to be true in the case of the ratio of cross sections because the transverse response is sensitive to both effects . while this procedure relies on a rosenbluth ( l / t ) separation of the quasifree cross section , and thus presents the experimentalist with a more demanding task , the experimental field has evolved to such a level of maturity that l / t separations are now almost routine .
indeed , in a recent publication @xcite a rosenbluth separation of the @xmath71 cross sections was made in order to extract `` longitudinal '' and `` transverse '' spectral functions in the hope of resolving the anomaly in the longitudinal - transverse ratio alluded to in the introduction .
we speculate that the sensitivity of the transverse response to more complicated dynamical processes might be partially responsible for the quenching of the longitudinal transverse ratio . finally ,
although in this article we focused exclusively on the spectral function , the formalism presented here may be extended in a straightforward fashion to the calculation of spin observables in quasifree electroproduction processes .
indeed , we speculate that , because the ratio of quasifree cross sections are fairly insensitive to distortion effects , spin - observables may be a more fruitful testing ground for our relativistic plane - wave model .
moreover , our formalism may be easily extended to neutrino - induced reactions .
it has been suggested that a measurement of the ratio of neutral to charge - changing neutrino - nucleon scattering may provide a clean signature of the strange - quark content of the nucleon @xcite .
this measurement is believed to be free from most of the uncertainties , such as radiative corrections , that hinder the parity - violating electron scattering program . yet
neutrino experiments suffer from very low counting rates .
to remedy this situation neutrino experiments employ large quantities of nuclear targets ( such as organic scintillators ) that provide both the target and the detection medium .
thus neutrinos interact , not only with the free protons in the target , but also with protons and neutrons bound to nuclei ; hence , one must compute quasifree @xmath72 and @xmath73 cross sections .
( of course , one must integrate the quasifree cross section over the undetected outgoing neutrino ) .
therefore , the relativistic plane - wave formalism presented here is ideally suited , after including an additional axial - vector term in the single - nucleon current , to predict ratios of quasifree neutrino - nucleus cross sections in the quasifree region .
we are grateful to drs .
s. gilad , a. kozlov , a.j .
sarty , and the @xmath2 collaboration as well as dr . j.f.j .
van den brand for providing us with their data for this process and for many helpful discussions on this subject .
we would also like to thank drs .
r. schiavilla and r. b. wiringa for providing us with their theoretical calculations .
this work was supported in part by the united states department of energy under contract no .
de - fg05 - 92er40750 and in part by a joint fellowship from the japan society for the promotion of science and the united states national science foundation .
a. zghiche _
et al . , _ nucl
a572 * , 513 ( 1994 ) .
et al . , _ nucl .
a553 * , 697 ( 1993 ) .
c.j . horowitz and j. piekarewicz ,
lett . * 62 * , 391 ( 1989 ) ; nucl . phys . *
a511 * , 461 ( 1990 ) .
mulders , phys .
rep . * 185 * , 83 ( 1990 ) , and references therein .
brown and m. rho , phys . lett .
* b222 * , 324 ( 1989 ) .
r. neuhausen and s. gilad ( co - spokespersons ) , _ studies of the @xmath74 reaction at high missing energies _ , mainz microtron a1 collaboration experiments a1/1 - 93 and a1/3 - 96 .
florizone , ph.d .
thesis , massachusetts institute of technology ( unpublished ) .
available at : ( http://wwwa1.kph.uni-mainz.de/a1/publications/doctor/ ) .
et al . , _ to be published .
a. kozlov , ph.d .
thesis , university of melbourne ( unpublished ) .
available at : ( http://wwwa1.kph.uni-mainz.de/a1/publications/doctor/ ) .
a. kozlov _
et al . , _ nucl .
a684 * , 460 ( 2001 ) .
a. kozlov _
et al . , _ to be published .
t. de forest jr .
, nucl . phys .
* a392 * , 232 ( 1983 ) . s. gardner and j. piekarewicz , phys . rev .
c * 50 * , 2822 ( 1994 ) .
abu - raddad and j. piekarewicz , phys .
c * 61 * , 014604 ( 2000 ) .
abu - raddad , _ `` photoproduction of pseudoscalar mesons from nuclei '' _ , ph.d . thesis , florida state university ( unpublished ) .
available at : nucl - th/0005068 ( 2000 ) .
a. picklesimer , j.w .
van orden , and s.j .
wallace , phys .
c * 32 * , 1312 ( 1985 ) .
a. picklesimer , and j.w .
van orden , phys .
c * 40 * , 290 ( 1989 ) .
udias , p. sarriguren , e. moya de guerra , e. garrido , and j.a .
caballero , phys .
c * 48 * , 2731 ( 1993 ) .
udias , p. sarriguren , e. moya de guerra , and j.a .
caballero , phys .
rev . c * 53 * , 1488 ( 1996 )
. k. amir - azimi - nili , j.m .
udias , h. muther , l.d .
skouras , and a. polls , nucl . phys .
* a625 * , 633 ( 1997 ) .
caballero , t.w .
donnelly , e. moya de guerra , and j.m .
udias , nucl .
a632 * , 323 ( 1998 ) .
caballero , t.w .
donnelly , e. moya de guerra , and nucl .
a643 * , 189 ( 1998 ) .
udias , j.a .
caballero , e. moya de guerra , j.e .
amaro , and t.w .
donnelly , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 5451 ( 1999 ) .
udias , j.a .
caballero , e. moya de guerra , javier r. vignote , and a. escuderos , nucl - th/0101038 m. hedayati - poor , j.i .
johansson , and h.s .
sherif , nucl . phys . *
a593 * , 377 ( 1995 ) .
johansson , h.s .
sherif , and g.m .
lotz , nucl .
a605 * , 517 ( 1996 ) .
johansson , and h.s .
sherif , phys .
c * 59 * , 3481 ( 1999 ) .
a. meucci , c. giusti , and f.d .
pacati , nucl - th/0101034 .
w. weise , nucl .
a193 * , 625 ( 1972 ) .
g. van der steenhoven , nucl . phys . *
a527 * , 17c ( 1991 ) .
l. lapikas , nucl . phys . *
a553 * , 297c ( 1993 ) .
j. piekarewicz and r.a .
rego phys .
c * 45 * , 1654 ( 1992 ) .
j.d.walecka , ann . of phys .
( n.y . ) * 83 * , 491 ( 1974 ) ; b.d .
serot and j.d .
walecka , adv . in nucl
* 16 * , j.w .
negele and e. vogt , eds .
plenum , n.y .
james d. bjorken and sidney drell , _ relativistic quantum mechanics _ , ( mcgraw - hill , new york , 1964 ) .
r. mertig and a. hubland , _ guide to feyncalc 1.0 _ , downloaded from the internet , 1992 ; r. mertig , comp .
. comm . * 60 * , 165 ( 1991 ) ; http://www.feyncalc.org/. s. frullani and j. mougey , adv .
* 14 * , 1 ( 1984 ) .
r. schiavilla , v.r .
pandharipande , and r.b .
wiringa , nucl . phys .
* a449 * , 219 , ( 1986 )
. i.e. lagaris and v.r .
pandharipande , nucl .
a359 * , 331 , ( 1981 ) .
et al . , _ phys . rev . c * 29 * , 1207 , ( 1984 ) .
r. b. wiringa , phys .
c * 43 * , 1585 ( 1991 ) .
r. b. wiringa , private communication .
et al . , _ phys . rev .
c * 54 * 646 ( 1996 ) .
et al . , _ phys .
c * 51 * , 38 , ( 1995 ) .
b.s . publiner _
et al . , _ phys .
* 74 * , 4396 , ( 1995 ) .
j.f.j . van den brand _
* a534 * , 637 , ( 1991 ) .
j.f.j . van den brand _
et al . , _ phys .
lett . * 60 * , 2006 , ( 1988 ) .
r. schiavilla _ et al .
65 * , 835 ( 1990 ) .
le goff _ et al .
. rev . c * 55 * , 1600 ( 1997 )
horowitz , private communication . | the spectral function of @xmath0he is extracted from a plane - wave approximation to the @xmath1 reaction using a fully relativistic formalism .
we take advantage of both an algebraic `` trick '' and a general relativistic formalism for quasifree processes developed earlier to arrive at transparent , analytical expressions for all quasifree @xmath1 observables .
an observable is identified for the clean and model - independent extraction of the spectral function .
our simple relativistic plane - wave calculations provide baseline predictions for the recently measured , but not yet fully analyzed , momentum distribution of @xmath0he by the @xmath2-collaboration from mainz . yet in spite of its simplicity , our approach predicts momentum distributions for @xmath0he that rival some of the best nonrelativistic calculations to date .
finally , we highlight some of the challenges and opportunities that remain , both theoretically and experimentally , in the extraction of quasifree observables . |
debris disk systems provide a look at an intermediate stage of stellar system evolution .
they represent the transition between the early formation of stars and planets in a primordial protoplanetary disk as seen toward pre - main sequence stars , and the mature stage of an evolved system , like our solar system , which is clear of all primordial material and retains only a hint of secondary products ( e.g. , zodiacal dust ) , the final remnants of the stellar and planetary formation process .
although a debris disk has lost most of its primordial material , the observed infrared luminosity of circumstellar dust , caused by collisions of planetismals and other small bodies , is typically several orders of magnitude larger than estimated for the kuiper and asteroid belts in our solar system @xcite .
ever since the detection of dusty circumstellar material around main sequence stars via infrared excesses @xcite , researchers have been looking for circumstellar gas phase absorption @xcite . of the initial major infrared excess main sequence stars ,
only @xmath0 pic showed gas phase absorption in optical absorption lines ( e.g. , and ) , due to its disk morphology and edge - on orientation @xcite .
such on orientation provides a unique opportunity to simultaneously measure both the dust and gas components of a debris disk , at an interesting transition near the end of stellar and planetary formation .
only a few other edge - on debris disks have been found since , including @xmath0 car @xcite , hd85905 @xcite , hr10 @xcite , and au mic ( @xcite @xcite ; @xcite @xcite ) . @xcite
observed @xmath0 car , hd85905 , hr10 with the _
spitzer space telescope _ and did not find strong infrared excesses toward any of them , although an optical monitoring campaign showed clear signs of gas variability , as noted by researchers earlier .
however , the magnitude of circumstellar absorption in these systems is lower than observed toward @xmath0 pic .
long monitoring campaigns of @xmath0 pic ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , find significant short - term absorption variability .
this variability can be explained by gas clouds very close to the star , which are caused by evaporating , star - grazing , km - sized objects , simply referred to as , falling evaporating bodies ( feb s ; * ? ? ?
. a strong `` stable '' component , at rest in the stellar reference frame , is also detected toward @xmath0 pic ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the distribution of gas in this component , contrary to the variable component located very close to the star , is dispersed throughout the extended dust disk @xcite .
a `` stable '' absorption component in a gas phase resonance line can be caused by either intervening circumstellar or interstellar gas .
measuring the interstellar medium ( ism ) along the line of sight and in the locality surrounding a circumstellar disk candidate , is critical to characterizing any `` contaminating '' ism absorption @xcite . in particular
, the sun resides in a large scale ism structure known as the local bubble , whose boundary at @xmath4100pc is defined by a significant quantity of interstellar material @xcite .
if a `` stable '' absorption component is observed at the stellar radial velocity , and similar absorption is not detected toward any proximate stars , it is likely that the absorption component is caused by circumstellar material . using near - infrared scattered light observations taken with the _ hubble space telescope _ , @xcite discovered that the debris disk surrounding hd32297 has an edge - on orientation .
disk emission extends out to @xmath4400au in their observations , while radii @xmath633.6au are occulted by the coronagraphic obstacle .
optical scattered light observations by @xcite confirmed this orientation and extended the range of disk emission to @xmath41680au
. the edge - on orientation of hd32297 makes it an ideal target for gas phase absorption measurements .
observations of the d doublet ( 5895.9242 and 5889.9510 ) toward hd32297 were made over several epochs .
the doublet is among the strongest transitions in the optical wavelength band , appropriate for observing interstellar @xcite and circumstellar @xcite absorption toward nearby stars .
in addition , several stars in close angular proximity to hd32297 were observed , in order to reconstruct the ism absorption profile along the line of sight .
stellar parameters of the observed targets are given in table [ tab : basics ] , and the observational parameters are listed in table [ tab : fits ] .
high resolution optical spectra were obtained using the coud spectrometer on the 2.7 m harlan j. smith telescope at mcdonald observatory .
the spectra were obtained at a resolution of @xmath7240,000 , using the 2dcoud spectrograph @xcite in the cs21 configuration .
the data were reduced using image reduction and analysis facility ( iraf ; * ? ? ? * ) and interactive data language ( idl ) routines to subtract the bias , flat field the images , remove scattered light and cosmic ray contamination , extract the echelle orders , calibrate the wavelength solution , and convert to heliocentric velocities .
wavelength calibration images were taken using a th - ar hollow cathode before and after each target .
numerous weak water vapor lines are commonly present in spectra around the doublet , and must be modeled and removed , in order to measure an accurate interstellar ( or circumstellar ) absorption profile .
i use a forward modeling technique demonstrated by @xcite to remove telluric line contamination in the vicinity of the d lines , with a terrestrial atmosphere model ( at - atmospheric transmission program , from airhead software , boulder , co ) developed by erich grossman . with two absorption lines , it is straightforward to identify contaminating telluric absorption .
all absorption lines were fit using standard methods ( e.g. , 2.2 in * ? ? ? * ) .
gaussian absorption components are fit to both d lines simultaneously using atomic data from @xcite , and then convolved with the instrumental line spread function . fitting the lines
simultaneously reduces the influence of systematic errors , such as continuum placement and contamination by weak telluric features .
the free parameters are the central velocity ( @xmath8 ) , the line width or doppler parameter ( @xmath9 ) , and the column density ( @xmath10 ) of ions along the line of sight .
the fits are shown in figure [ fig : hd32297_figna1 ] and fit parameters with 1@xmath11 statistical errors are listed in table [ tab : fits ] .
in addition , the spectra were used to estimate the stellar radial velocity ( @xmath12 ) and projected stellar rotation ( @xmath13 ) for hd32297 , bd+07 777s , and bd+07 778 ( see table [ tab : basics ] ) , quantities not listed in simbad for these targets .
the radial velocities of all 3 objects differ significantly , and therefore it is unlikely that they are physically associated .
note that the radial velocity of hd32297 ( @xmath14 km s@xmath15 ) is measured from broad and h@xmath16 stellar absorption lines , and therefore is not tightly constrained .
the left column of figure [ fig : hd32297_figna1 ] shows that absorption is clearly detected toward hd32297 in 5 observations over 5 months .
two components are easily distinguished , a strong component at @xmath424.5 km s@xmath15 and a weaker component at @xmath420.5 km s@xmath15 .
the spectral region for 5 stars in close angular proximity to hd32297 is also shown in figure [ fig : hd32297_figna1 ] . only a single ism component , at @xmath424.2 km s@xmath15 , is detected in the 3 distant neighbors , indicating that large scale interstellar material is located at a distance between 59.4112pc .
all targets located beyond this material , including hd32297 , should have a similar ism absorption feature .
this strong ism absorption is probably associated with the boundary material of the local bubble , which is estimated to be @xmath490 pc in this direction @xcite .
if located at this distance , the physical separation of the interstellar material observed toward hd32297 and the material toward bd+07 777s ( @xmath17 0@xmath19 ) is 0.025pc , bd+07 778 ( 2@xmath14 ) is 0.064pc , and 18 ori ( 5@xmath181 ) is 8.1pc . toward hd32297
s two closest neighbors , the ism absorption is almost identical in projected velocity and column density to the strong absorption seen toward hd32297 , while toward 18 ori , the absorption differs slightly in both @xmath8 and @xmath10 , indicating that any small scale morphological variations in the local bubble shell are on scales @xmath20.1pc but @xmath68pc .
small scale variations in the local bubble shell have been detected by @xcite on scales @xmath40.5pc .
it is unlikely that the unique 20.5 km s@xmath15 feature observed toward hd32297 is caused by a small scale interstellar structure . although small ism structures ( 0.012.0pc ) have been observed ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , it is more likely that the unique feature is due to absorption in the circumstellar environment surrounding hd32297 because ( 1 ) hd32297 is known to be an edge - on debris disk , ( 2 ) no similar absorption is detected in the very close neighboring sightlines ( 0.030.08pc ) , and ( 3 ) the absorption matches the stellar radial velocity .
temporal variability is also a hallmark of circumstellar material ( e.g. , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . to search for variability , figure [ fig : hd32297_diff ]
shows difference spectra of all observations .
some indication of temporal variability on time scales of months is detected .
for example , between the 2005 sep and 2006 feb observations , the @xmath420.5 km s@xmath15 feature became stronger and the separation between the circumstellar and interstellar features became less distinct , despite the fact that the 2006 feb observations were made at a slightly higher resolving power .
the redshifted variability seen between 2005 sep and 2006 feb is @xmath45@xmath11 above the standard deviation .
the same pattern is seen in both lines , indicating that the telluric contamination is not causing the variation .
slight changes in the resolving power of our instrument could mimic this variable behavior , differentially moving light from the cores of the line to the wings ( or vice versa ) .
however , resolution variability should cause ( 1 ) symmetric features in the wings of the line whereas we see a feature only to the blue of the ism feature and not to the red , and ( 2 ) should have a stronger effect on stronger absorption features , whereas the feature is roughly identical in both lines , which could be caused if the absorbing material covers only a fraction of the stellar disk , as has been seen toward @xmath0 pic @xcite .
this data alone provides only a subtle indication of temporal variation in , partially because any significant absorption toward the red , is masked by the strong ism feature .
redshifted circumstellar absorption dominates the gas absorption variability toward @xmath0 pic ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , while no temporal variability has ever been detected in toward @xmath0 pic , only the `` stable '' absorption component is seen in this ion @xcite .
circumstellar variability in has been detected in other edge - on debris disks , e.g. , @xmath0 car , hd85905 , and hr10 @xcite . any redshifted absorption occuring in this object could cause fluctuations in the measured column density of the `` constant '' ism feature .
little evidence for variability is found toward the blue .
these observations indicate that hd32297 has the strongest circumstellar disk signature detected around a nearby main sequence debris disk star .
even compared to @xmath0 pic , the prototypical edge - on debris disk with absorption column densities of @xmath19@xmath20 @xcite , the gas disk around hd32297 , with @xmath3 , has 5@xmath21 the column density .
a crude estimate of the gas mass surrounding hd32297 can be made if it is assumed to have the same morphology and abundances as the stable gas around @xmath0 pic . although the observations of hd32297 indicate some red - shifted temporal variability , much of the gas is stable over all observations .
using @xmath0 pic as a proxy , the variable gas is likely located very close to the star @xcite , while the stable gas at rest in the stellar frame , likely traces the bulk dust disk @xcite . for this calculation ,
i assume all the gas is in the stable component , and therefore this gas mass estimate should be considered an upper limit .
the morphology of the disk is assumed to follow a broken power law density profile , as fit to the emission profile of the @xmath0 pic disk ( see equation 1 of @xcite ) , and assumed to extend out to the edge of the debris disk at @xmath41680au @xcite .
the abundances in the hd32297 disk are assumed to be similar to @xmath0 pic @xcite , where the ratio @xmath22@xmath23@xmath24 , is based on @xmath0 pic measurements by @xcite and limits by @xcite . given these assumption , i calculate a gas mass , distributed through the bulk debris disk surrounding hd32297 at @xmath25 .
future observations are planned to continue monitoring the temporal variability of the circumstellar gas toward hd32297 to determine the ratio of stable to variable gas , and measure the gas disk absorption , in order to independently measure the to ratio .
a more definitive detection of temporal variability may require monitoring excited lines which will show circumstellar absorption , but not the strong interstellar feature .
i present the first high resolution optical spectra of the doublet toward the debris disk hd32297 and stars in close angular proximity .
a summary of results include : \(1 ) two absorption components are detected toward hd32297 , while only one is detected toward its proximate neighbors located at a comparable distance .
the extra absorption component in the spectrum of hd32297 , which is also at rest in the stellar reference frame , is therefore likely caused by circumstellar material .
+ ( 2 ) the ism absorption is similar among hd32297 and its two closest neighbors , and is likely due to absorption from the shell that defines the boundary of the local bubble .
some variation in local bubble absorption is detected toward 18 ori .
+ ( 3 ) radial velocities of hd32297 , bd+07 777s , and bd+07 778 are measured and differ significantly , indicating that they are likely not physically associated .
+ ( 4 ) some indication of temporal variability is detected over several epochs of observations .
instrumental resolution variations and masking by the strong ism absorption , make a definitive detection of circumstellar variability difficult . + ( 5 ) the measured circumstellar feature toward hd32297 ( @xmath26 ) is the strongest such absorption measured toward any nearby main sequence debris disk , @xmath45 times greater than the column density of the prototypical edge - on debris disk , @xmath0 pic .
+ ( 6 ) if the morphology and abundances of the stable gas component around hd32297 are assumed to be similar to @xmath0 pic , i estimate an upper limit to the gas mass in the circumstellar disk surrounding hd32297 of @xmath40.3 @xmath5 .
support for this work was provided by nasa through hubble fellowship grant hst - hf-01190.01 awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, for nasa , under contract nas 5 - 26555 .
i would like to thank d. doss , g. harper , and a. brown , for their assistance with these observations .
the insightful comments by the anonymous referee were very helpful .
lllcllcclcc 32297 & bd+07 777 & a0 & 8.13 & @xmath4 + 20 & @xmath480 & 192.83 & 20.17 & 112@xmath27 & 0.0000 & 0.0 + & bd+07 777s & g0 & 10.2 & 55 & @xmath42 & 192.85 & 20.17 & & 0.0156 & 0.030 + 32304 & bd+07 778 & g5 & 6.87 & 1.4 & @xmath43.5 & 192.88 & 20.17 & 134@xmath28 & 0.0406 & 0.079 + 30739 & @xmath29 ori & a1vn & 4.35 & + 24 & 212 & 189.82 & 21.83 & 59.4@xmath30 & 3.2653 & 3.4 + 31295 & @xmath31 ori & a0v & 4.66 & + 13 & 120 & 189.35 & 20.25 & 37.0@xmath32 & 3.2748 & 2.1 + 34203 &
18 ori & a0v & 5.52 & 8.2 & 70 & 191.29 & 15.25 & 112.9@xmath33 & 5.1306 & 10.1 + lllcccccc 32297 & bd+07 777 & 2005 sep 15 & + 28.2 & 1.565 & 31 & 20.459 @xmath34 0.030 & 0.38 @xmath34 0.28 & 10.97@xmath35 + & & & & & & 24.546 @xmath34 0.012 & 0.742 @xmath34 0.063 & 12.388@xmath36 + 32297 & bd+07 777 & 2006 jan 26 & 22.8 & 1.253 & 17 & 20.50 @xmath34 0.27 & 1.23 @xmath34 0.55 & 11.384 @xmath34 0.077 + & & & & & & 24.30 @xmath34 0.12 & 0.84 @xmath34 0.21 & 12.16@xmath37 + 32297 & bd+07 777 & 2006 jan 28 & 23.4 & 1.266 & 22 & 20.48 @xmath34 0.23 & 1.24 @xmath34 0.42 & 11.449@xmath38 + & & & & & & 24.34 @xmath34 0.17 & 0.82 @xmath34 0.31 & 11.98@xmath39 + 32297 & bd+07 777 & 2006 jan 29 & 23.7 & 1.288 & 20 & 20.42 @xmath34 0.20 & 1.71 @xmath34 0.28 & 11.454@xmath40 + & & & & & & 24.424 @xmath34 0.086 & 0.71 @xmath34 0.23 & 12.02@xmath41 + 32297 & bd+07 777 & 2006 feb 15 & 27.5 & 1.199 & 39 & 20.51 @xmath34 0.26 & 1.14 @xmath34 0.41 & 11.297@xmath42 + & & & & & & 24.41 @xmath34 0.13 & 0.94 @xmath34 0.30 & 11.97@xmath43 + & bd+07 777s & 2006 feb 16 & 27.7 & 1.238 & 6 & 25.55 @xmath34 0.28 & 1.581 @xmath34 0.078 & 12.03@xmath44 + 32304 & bd+07 778 & 2006 feb 16 & 27.7 & 1.244 & 52 & 24.583 @xmath34 0.083 & 1.65 @xmath34 0.15 & 12.18@xmath37 + 30739 & @xmath29 ori & 2006 feb 16 & 28.3 & 1.213 & 133 & & & @xmath45 + 31295 & @xmath31 ori & 2004 oct 18 & + 21.1 & 1.761 & 100 & & & @xmath46 + 34203 & 18 ori & 2006 feb 15 & 27.3 & 1.189 & 117 & 22.464 @xmath34 0.022 & 1.150 @xmath34 0.036 & 11.403@xmath47 + | near - infrared and optical imaging of hd32297 indicate that it has an edge - on debris disk , similar to @xmath0 pic .
i present high resolution optical spectra of the doublet toward hd32297 and stars in close angular proximity .
a circumstellar absorption component is clearly observed toward hd32297 at the stellar radial velocity , which is not observed toward any of its neighbors , including the nearest only 0@xmath19 away .
an interstellar component is detected in all stars @xmath290pc , including hd32297 , likely due to the interstellar material at the boundary of the local bubble .
radial velocity measurements of the nearest neighbors , bd+07777s and bd+07778 , indicate that they are unlikely to be physically associated with hd32297 .
the measured circumstellar column density around hd32997 , @xmath3 , is the strongest absorption measured toward any nearby main sequence debris disk , even the prototypical edge - on debris disk , @xmath0 pic . assuming that the morphology and abundances of the gas component around hd32297 are similar to @xmath0 pic , i estimate an upper limit to the gas mass in the circumstellar disk surrounding hd32297 of @xmath40.3 @xmath5 . |
energy waste is a severe bottleneck in the supply of sustainable energy to any modern economy .
besides developing new energy sources , the global energy crisis can be alleviated by re - utilizing the wasted energy . in view of the fact that about 90% of the world s
energy utilization occurs in the form of heat , effective heat control and conversion become critical @xcite . to meet the desire , phononics @xcite has been proposed to control heat energy and information in a similar style as controlling electric current and signal in electronics .
various functional thermal devices such as thermal rectifiers and transistors are then designed , essentially based on two intriguing properties : the heat diode effect and negative differential thermal conductance [ e.g. , see refs . ] .
meanwhile , the investigation on interplay of spin and heat transport has attracted great interest .
in particular , spin seebeck effect has been widely observed recently @xcite ; that is , the temperature bias can produce a pure spin current _ in the absence of _ electron current .
since then , the spin seebeck effect has ignited a upsurge of renewed research interest , because it acts as a new method of functional use of waste heat as spin caloritronics @xcite and opens more possibilities for spintronics @xcite and magnonics @xcite , which allows us to realize non - dissipative information and energy transfer without joule heating @xcite and to construct thermoelectric devices upon new principles @xcite . by integrating the spin
seebeck effect with concepts from phononics @xcite , the _ asymmetric spin seebeck effect _ ( asse )
has recently been discovered both in metal / insulating magnet interfaces @xcite and magnon tunneling junctions @xcite , which leads us to spin seebeck diodes to rectify the thermal energy and spin information @xcite .
similar rectification of spin seebeck effect is also discussed in other insulating magnetic systems @xcite . beyond spin seebeck diodes , the _ negative differential spin seebeck effect _ ( ndsse ) has been further uncovered both in metal / insulating magnet interfaces @xcite and magnon tunneling junctions @xcite , i.e. , increasing thermal bias gives the decreasing spin current .
this ndsse is crucial to realize spin seebeck transistors @xcite .
developing nanoscale spin seebeck devices with such asse and ndsse is a great challenge not only for fundamental science but also for practical applications . by utilizing and controlling spin seebeck effects at atomic / molecular levels that could benefit from the scalability and tunability of nanodevices
, we may transform the field of molecular spintronics @xcite to the possible `` molecular spin caloritronics '' , where we can have flexible control of spin - mediated energy flow or thermal - mediated spin current .
such nanoscale spin caloritronics would have potential impact on a variety of new technologies but still requires a better understanding of spin seebeck effects in the test bed of nanoscale junctions .
[ 0.38 ] in this work , we study the nonequilibrium spin seebeck transport through an insulating magnetic molecular quantum dot , which is in contact with ferromagnetic leads held at different temperatures . we show that in contrast with bulk spin seebeck effect , the thermal - spin conversion in such a molecular spin caloritronic device can reach an infinite figure of merit , which indicates the ideal carnot efficiency . in the nonlinear spin seebeck transport regime , we also find that the device exhibits the asse and ndsse . in the last ,
the situations with leaking electron tunneling are also discussed .
this nanoscale thermal spin rectifier , by tuning the junction parameters , can act as a spin seebeck diode , spin seebeck transistor , and spin seebeck switch , which we believe could have substantial implications for flexible thermal and spin information control in molecular spin caloritronics .
we consider a phenomenological model that describes a localized effective spin coupled with two metallic ferromagnetic leads [ see fig .
[ fig1](a ) ] , with the total hamiltonian @xmath0 the central local spin may represent an insulating molecule magnet @xcite or a ferromagnetic nanoparticle @xcite found in a nanoscale single - domain state and thus is described by the effective macrospin @xcite , as : @xmath1 with @xmath2 the easy - axis anisotropy and @xmath3 the intrinsic energy of the local spin controlled by external fields or proximity effects .
two metallic ferromagnetic leads are severally in equilibrium with temperatures @xmath4 and are described by the stoner - model hamiltonians : @xmath5 where @xmath6 denotes the creation ( annihilation ) operator of electrons with momentum @xmath7 , spin @xmath8 , and energy @xmath9 that may have different spin - resolved density of states ( dos ) .
the spin - lead coupling is described by the local exchange interaction @xmath10 which couples the central local spin @xmath11 to the electronic spin @xmath12 in the lead .
@xmath13 denotes the exchange coupling strength to the @xmath14th lead and @xmath15 is the pauli matrix elements .
we note that the direct electron tunneling and spin exchange between two metallic leads are neglected .
the reason is that the coupling of electrons in two leads originates from the wave - function overlap , which generally decays exponentially with the distance @xcite .
the distance between two leads doubles the central spin - lead distance , which could make the lead - lead interaction a few orders of magnitude smaller compared to the central spin - lead interaction , thus negligible .
a recent work shows that , however , the cotunneling that survives only at the extremely low temperature @xcite can support the long - range tunneling .
but since the spin seebeck transport at high ( room ) temperatures is of our prime interest , the cotunneling is not included in our present scheme .
here we also neglect the possible spin - assisted electron tunneling between the two leads .
the discussion on the effect of spin - assisted electron tunneling is deferred to sec .
[ discussion ] .
our setup , reminiscent of the junction of metal / insulating magnet / metal @xcite , can be regarded as two copies of the metal / insulating magnet interface studied in ref .
@xcite , where the insulating layer has a large electron band gap so that only exchange interactions at boundaries with two leads are responsible for the spin seebeck transport without electric current .
in fact , the signal transmission through a sandwiched metal / magnetic insulator / metal junction has already been observed in experiment @xcite .
our system of a single local spin in the insulating central part is considered as the minimal phenomenological model to mimic the sandwich setup , because in ferromagnets at nanoscale spins are tightly coupled and form an effective coarse - grained macrospin , as described by eq .
( [ eq : macrospin ] ) @xcite .
note our this scheme is different from the earlier setups in refs . , where electron tunneling transports are considered and the exchange coupling is between the tunneling electron spin and the local molecular spin .
the important observation in the present work is that even in the charge insulating case , where electron transfer is essentially quenched across the junction , we can still have the spin seebeck transport assisted by the exchange coupling @xmath16 , which precisely speaking has three contributions : @xmath17 , \label{eq : coupling2}\ ] ] with @xmath18 the spin - raising ( -lowering ) operators .
the first term renormalizes the intrinsic energy @xmath3 of the central spin into a new one @xmath19 though the proximity effect .
only the last two terms are responsible for the spin seebeck transport . in practice
, multiple macrospins hosted by molecular quantum dots can be constructed in between two leads , as illustrated in fig .
[ fig1](b ) , to form parallel transport channels so as to enhance the transfer power and signal .
we start with the liouville - von neumann equation for the reduced density matrix of the central spin , which is represented in the eigenstate basis @xmath20 of @xmath21 . for the weak system - lead coupling and markovian limit , the dynamics of the central spin
is obtained as a pauli master equation @xcite : @xmath22 with @xmath23 the probability of the spin state @xmath20 .
the transition rate has two contributions from the left and right leads : @xmath24 , with the initial and final states constrained by nearest state transitions @xmath25 .
the spin current from the central system into the right can be derived from the heisenberg equation @xmath26 , yielding @xmath27 where the steady state probability @xmath28 is calculated by setting eq .
( [ eq : me ] ) equal to zero .
the spin current at left can be obtained equally .
straightforward calculations [ similar to ] lead to the rate expressions : @xmath29 with @xmath30d)\rho_{v\downarrow}(\epsilon ) \nonumber\\ & \times&f^{\pm}_{v\uparrow}(\epsilon+\omega_0+[2m\pm1]d)f^{\mp}_{v\downarrow}(\epsilon ) , \label{eq : rate11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath31 with @xmath32 the spin length ; @xmath33 denotes the dos for electrons with spin @xmath8 and energy @xmath34 in the lead @xmath35 ; @xmath36^{-1}$ ] is the fermi - dirac distribution in the lead @xmath14 with spin - dependent chemical potential @xmath37 at temperature @xmath4 .
the rates have clear physical meanings [ see fig .
[ fig1](c ) ] : @xmath38 , in which @xmath39d$ ] , depicts the scattering rate of a spin - down electron in lead @xmath14 at energy @xmath40 into a spin - up state in the same lead at energy @xmath41 , accompanied by reducing the central spin state from @xmath42 to @xmath43 . @xmath44 describes the scattering rate of a spin - up electron in lead @xmath14 at energy @xmath41 into a spin - down state in the same lead at energy @xmath40 , accompanied by increasing the central spin state from @xmath43 to @xmath42 .
these exchange transitions conserve the spin angular momentum and are responsible for the pure spin transfer as depicted in fig .
[ fig1](c ) .
they also satisfy the detailed - balance - like relation : @xmath45 with @xmath46 denoting the spin accumulation in the lead @xmath14 . to make this clear , we can rewrite eqs .
( [ eq : rate1 ] , [ eq : rate11 ] ) as @xmath47 where @xmath48 \label{eq : c}\ ] ] is an integral generally depending on the energy @xmath49 , the chemical potentials , the temperatures and the overlap between two spin - resolved dos ; @xmath50^{-1}$ ] are bose - einstein distributions with the ratio @xmath51d-{\delta}\mu^s_v}{k_bt_v})}$ ] .
note , from eqs .
( [ eq : rate1 ] , [ eq : rate11 ] ) to eqs . ( [ eq : rate2 ] , [ eq : c ] ) , we have utilized the equalities : @xmath52\equiv n_v(\varepsilon_m)[f_{v\downarrow}(\epsilon)-f_{v\uparrow}(\epsilon+\varepsilon_m)]$ ] and @xmath53f_{v\downarrow}(\epsilon)\equiv [ 1+n_v(\varepsilon_m)][f_{v\downarrow}(\epsilon)-f_{v\uparrow}(\epsilon+\varepsilon_m)]$ ] .
without loss of generality we focus on the @xmath54 case , where the anisotropy is irrelevant , although our above formulations are valid for general situations . for large spin cases , we find the large anisotropy can inverse the sign of thermal - spin transport due to the fact that large @xmath2 can invert the spin eigen - levels @xmath55 to make them parabolic instead of linearly equal - spaced at @xmath56
. however , usually the anisotropy @xmath57ev is much smaller than other energy scales ( @xmath58mev ) of interest .
thus , the effect of magnetic anisotropy will be insignificant except in the extremely low temperature regime , where the kondo effect may play a role @xcite and is beyond the scope of the present work . for large spin cases without anisotropy
, they share quantitatively the same behaviors as the spin - half case that we will discuss in detail in the following . for the @xmath54 case , the spin current can be analytically obtained from eqs .
( [ eq : is ] ) and ( [ eq : rate2 ] ) , as : @xmath59}{j^2_lc_l(\omega_0)[1 + 2n_l(\omega_0)]+j^2_rc_r(\omega_0)[1 + 2n_r(\omega_0 ) ] } , \label{eq : tlflux}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we use @xmath60 to simplify the notations @xmath61 by re - expressing the spin up and down states with state @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
clearly , the pure spin transfer is driven by the difference @xmath64 $ ] , from which we can see that , merely the spin accumulation difference ( spin voltage ) @xmath65 or the temperature bias @xmath66 is able to generate nonzero spin current , while the chemical potential difference between two leads @xmath67 can not .
this emphasizes that the spin seebeck transport here is not driven by the electric bias , but by the thermal bias or spin ( voltage ) bias .
the thermal transport can also be similarly formulated and we obtain the heat current as @xmath68 .
let us first examine the spin thermal transport coefficients in the linear response regime .
considering @xmath69 , we are able to expand the spin and heat currents to the first order of spin voltage and thermal bias ( @xmath70 ) @xcite , yielding @xmath71 where @xmath72 } , \ ] ] with @xmath73 at zero bias @xmath74 .
clearly , @xmath75 denotes the spin conductance for the pure spin transfer generated by the spin voltage @xmath76 ; @xmath77 is the spin seebeck coefficient , depicting the power of generating spin voltage by the temperature bias ; @xmath78 is the spin peltier coefficient , depicting the power of heating or cooling carried by per unit spin current .
one can see that the kelvin relation @xcite ( one sort of onsager reciprocal relations ) @xmath79 is fulfilled . clearly , only the spin transport and the thermal transport are conjugated to each other .
the thermal bias is able to generate the spin current in the absence of electron transport so that it is a pure spin seebeck effect ; the spin voltage is able to generate the heat current without electric current so that it is a pure spin peltier effect .
this situation is different from previous thermal spin transport studies where electronic current and voltage are involved @xcite .
the thermal - spin conversion efficiency is given by @xmath80 , where @xmath81 is the ideal carnot efficiency and the figure of merit is @xmath82 @xcite . here , needs to be pointed out is that in the denominator the thermal conductance is defined at zero spin current @xmath83 @xcite , not at zero spin bias @xmath84 . in other words , @xmath85 should be correctly obtained as @xmath86 , not as @xmath87 .
@xcite interestingly , since eq .
( [ eq : linear ] ) has the proportionality between the heat and spin currents : @xmath68 , one will get zero heat current at zero spin current , which leads to @xmath88 so that @xmath89 .
this infinite figure of merit @xmath90 is not unphysical .
it just tells us the efficiency of the thermal - spin conversion approaches to the ideal carnot efficiency of the device and is still upper - bounded by @xmath62 . the ideal carnot efficiency resulting from the strict proportionality between the spin and heat currents ,
was similarly discussed in other contents of energy conversions @xcite , called the thermodynamic tight - coupling limit .
note that this tight - coupling induced infinite @xmath90 originates from the strict proportionality between the spin and heat currents , which is valid for the ideal case without the magnetic anisotropy ( @xmath56 ) . in reality
, finite anisotropy will distort the linear equal - spaced spin levels , which in turn removes the strict proportionality between the heat and spin currents .
moreover , the ignored electron transfer , as well as the photon - carried radiation heat transfer in reality ( possibly with phononic thermal transfer @xcite ) , will contribute finite thermal conductances to the denominator of @xmath90 , as @xmath91 , so that the infinity will be removed although @xmath90 may still be large .
last but not least , one should be aware of the fact that @xmath90 is a linear response quantity that merely characterizes the performance close to zero power and has little meaning outside the linear response regime .
even infinite @xmath90 does not give the best performance at finite power ( for example , see ref .
@xcite and references therein ) , which depends also on the short - circuit spin current , the maximum output power , and the filling factor of the system . in
what follows , we focus on the spin seebeck effect in the nonlinear response transport regime .
we fix zero spin voltage @xmath92 for both leads and only consider the thermal - generated spin current with temperature bias .
controlling such thermal spin transport can be achieved by either tuning @xmath13 or @xmath93 , the latter of which depends on chemical potentials , temperatures and spin - resolved dos overlaps [ see eq .
( [ eq : c ] ) ] , thus offering us plenty of intriguing spin seebeck properties . without loss of generality , we assume the leads are confined in two dimension as thin films that have been used for the longitudinal spin seebeck measurement @xcite .
thus , for the up - polarized lead we can set the dos as @xmath94 while for the down - polarized lead the dos are @xmath95 .
[ 0.44 ] ev , @xmath96/@xmath97ev , @xmath98 ev , @xmath99 mev , @xmath100 mev . for ( d ) , @xmath101 with @xmath102 k. the asymmetric lead polarization offers the spin seebeck diode action .
, title="fig : " ] figure [ fig2 ] shows that one can tune the spin seebeck transport by changing the spin polarizations of two ferromagnetic leads .
it is known that thermoelectric effects depend on the magnetic configurations of ferromagnetic leads @xcite .
but the spin seebeck effect is distinct in the sense that electron transport is absent .
when the fully - polarized directions of two leads are tuned from up - up to down - down , the spin seebeck transport is dramatically enhanced [ see fig .
[ fig2](a ) , ( b ) and ( d ) ] .
this is because the dos overlap @xmath103 of the down polarization case is larger than that of the up case .
the increased dos overlap increases the effective system - lead coupling @xmath104 as indicated in eq .
( [ eq : c ] ) , which in turn increases the thermal spin current eq .
( [ eq : tlflux ] ) .
if two leads have opposite polarizations [ see fig .
[ fig2](c ) and ( d ) for the case of left being spin - up and right spin - down ] , we can even have an asymmetric @xmath105 with respect to the thermal bias @xmath106 , a rectification of spin seebeck effect .
in other words , we obtain the asse and a spin seebeck diode , which acts as a good thermal spin conductor in one direction but acts as a poor spin seebeck conductor or even an insulator in the opposite direction @xcite .
this is due to the fact that when two leads have different polarizations , the different spin - resolved dos overlaps in the integral of @xmath93 make @xmath107 and @xmath108 have different responses to temperature change .
if we keep one lead as ferromagnetic metal but set the other one as normal metal , we will have the similar asse .
moreover , fig .
[ fig2 ] shows that for different fully - polarized lead configurations , although at small temperature bias we have linear increasing of spin current , at large bias we generally have the phenomenon of ndsse , i.e. , increasing thermal bias anomalously decreases the spin seebeck current @xcite , which is essential for constructing the spin seebeck transistor @xcite .
this negative differential transport is obtained due to the suppression of thermal - excited coexistence of electrons with both spins .
the spin transport requires that electrons are scattered between spin - up and spin - down states .
although increasing one lead temperature and decreasing the other one will increase the thermal bias that subsequently increases @xmath109 , the lowering temperature of one lead will severely suppress the thermal - excited minority electronic spin . as a consequence , the effective coupling @xmath104 between the central spin and the electronic spins in the cold lead decreases , through the decreasing integral @xmath93 when decreasing temperature . once the effective coupling decreases faster than the increasing of the thermal bias , negative differential spin seebeck effect emerges .
[ 0.38](d ) . clearly , the chemical potential difference , although it acts as a control factor of the asymmetric spin seebeck effect , can not generate the thermal spin transport .
, title="fig : " ] tuning chemical potentials of two leads can also render us flexible control of thermal spin transport , as displayed in fig .
[ fig3 ] . when lifting chemical potentials but still below the band bottom of the minority electron spin , we see the spin seebeck transport is significantly enhanced , acting as a _
spin seebeck switch_. physically , this is because lifting chemical potentials increases the coexistence of two electron spins so that @xmath93 increases .
when @xmath67 , we also have the spin seebeck diode , which results from the different temperature responses of @xmath107 and @xmath108 when they have differential chemical potentials in eq .
( [ eq : c ] ) .
as we noted , the chemical potential difference , although it acts as a control factor of spin seebeck effect , can not generate the thermal spin transport [ see @xmath110 at @xmath111 in fig .
[ fig3 ] despite the fact that @xmath112 . in insulating - magnetic - molecular junctions ,
the pure spin transport ( spin voltage and spin current ) is only conjugated with the thermal transport ( temperature bias and heat current ) .
when chemical potentials are much above the bottoms of both spin - resolved electron dispersions , the leads behave as good metals and the dos can be treated as a constant @xmath113 . in this way , eq .
( [ eq : c ] ) reduces to a temperature - independent coefficient @xmath114 ( for the spin - half case , @xmath115 ) . as such
, we can no longer have the negative differential spin seebeck effect , for which the temperature - dependent @xmath93 is crucial .
nevertheless , we can achieve the spin seebeck diode if @xmath116 when two leads have different dos .
even if @xmath117 , we can still build asymmetric system - lead couplings @xmath118 so that @xmath105 is asymmetric under temperature interchange @xmath119 and the rectifying action is retained [ see eq .
( [ eq : tlflux ] ) ] .
we would like to clarify that our system , which takes a single effective spin as the insulating part in between the leads , can be regarded as a minimal phenomenological model to mimic the sandwich setup meal / insulating magnet / metal for the spin seebeck transport at nanoscale .
this macrospin picture is reasoned by the fact that for the coupled spin chain ( or cluster , network ) in nanoscale ferromagnets with a single - domain state , spins are tightly coupled and thus form an effective coarse - grained macrospin @xcite .
microscopically , the spin chain model with exchange interactions can be derived from the tight - binding electron chain model with strong coulomb interaction .
this is achieved by using the schrieffer - wolff transformation @xcite , which will naturally give the exchange coupling form eq .
( [ eq : coupling2 ] ) at boundaries .
for the two - site system , the hamiltonian after schrieffer - wolff transformation is expressed as the same as eq .
( [ eq : h ] ) , except for the new central hamiltonian with two coupled spin-@xmath120 impurities : @xmath121 this central two spin system has four eigenstates , @xmath122 : @xmath123 ; @xmath124 : @xmath125 ; @xmath126 : @xmath127 and @xmath128 : @xmath129 , with eigenvalues @xmath130 , @xmath131 , @xmath132 and @xmath133 , respectively .
the left spin 1 is coupled with the left lead through @xmath134 $ ] , which assists the spin state transitions @xmath135 , @xmath136 , @xmath137 , @xmath138 .
the right spin 2 is coupled with the right lead through @xmath139 $ ] , which assists the same transitions @xmath135 , @xmath136 , @xmath137 , @xmath138 .
the transition @xmath140 is not allowed since in the sequential tunneling regime the lead can only flip spins of the central system one by one .
this sequential dynamics is dynamically equivalent to having a phenomenological spin with a finite anisotropy @xmath2 in contact with two separate electronic baths , without electron transfer across the system . from the eigen - levels , we know that when inner spin coupling is large , we can effectively have three states , @xmath123 , @xmath125 and @xmath127 .
the fourth state will be difficult to access by the bath excitation due to the large energy gap .
as such , the dynamics of the spin seebeck transport will then be similar to that across an effective spin 1 of finite anisotropy , with excitation and relaxation by two separate electronic baths .
however , attention should be paid to the special example the single level anderson impurity model @xcite : the central impurity electrons with local coulomb interaction are hybridized with electrons in the leads . in the limit of large coulomb interaction between electrons of opposite spins on the central level , the schrieffer - wolff transformation reduces the model into a similar geometry setup @xcite as described in eq .
( [ eq : h ] ) with @xmath54 and @xmath56 .
as such , there are in principle three exchange coupling terms @xcite . among them
, two terms are the local exchange coupling of the impurity spin to conduction electron spin density in each lead individually , i.e. , @xmath141 and @xmath142 [ see eq .
( [ eq : coupling ] ) ] ; while the third term is the coupling of the impurity spin to the tunneling electron spin , which is of the form : @xmath143 this third term carries not only the spin current , but also the electric current .
therefore , the existence of this contribution in the special single level anderson model will remove the infinite property of @xmath90 since eq .
( [ eq : vlr ] ) brings finite thermal conductivity due to the additional electron transfer .
nevertheless , the properties of asse and ndsse can be still preserved .
more precisely , similar to obtaining eq .
( [ eq : rate1 ] ) , electron tunneling terms in @xmath144 with spin flipping will contribute additional transition rates : @xmath145 as illustrated in fig .
[ fig4 ] , @xmath146 describes the rate of the physical process that the local central spin flips from the down state to the up state , and meanwhile a spin - up electron tunnels from the lead @xmath14 to a spin - down electron state in the other lead @xmath147 with releasing energy @xmath19 to the flipping of the local central spin ; @xmath148 describes the rate of the similar physical process that the local central spin flips from the up state to the down state , and meanwhile a spin - down electron tunnels from the lead @xmath14 to a spin - up electron state in the other lead @xmath147 with absorbing energy @xmath19 from the flipping of the local central spin . [ 0.4 ] as such , following similar procedures as in the main text for the sequential dynamics , the new spin ( up ) current including additional contributions eqs .
( [ eq : add1 ] ) and ( [ eq : add2 ] ) is obtained as : @xmath149 the first term is reminiscent of eq .
( [ eq : tlflux ] ) , except for the denominator @xmath150 .
the second term mainly describes the contribution from electron tunnelings with spin flipping .
additionally , the electron tunneling terms in @xmath144 without spin flipping will also contribute to the thermal spin current , which , following the tunneling theory driven by temperature bias ( for example , see ref .
@xcite ) , is obtained as @xmath151 \nonumber\\ & \times[f_l(\epsilon)-f_r(\epsilon)].\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , the total spin current is @xmath152 .
for the same conditions as for the case of up - down lead configuration in fig .
[ fig2 ] , the spin seebeck effect is plotted in fig .
[ fig5](a ) , from which we see that the thermal spin current profile is clearly modified by the electron tunneling contribution .
the asse is preserved , although the ndsse does not occur for this case .
in fact , as implied by earlier discussions @xcite , the asse is robust once the left and right part are asymmetric while the ndsse will be more sensitive to the dos . for the case of choosing lorentzian type dos @xmath153 for the lead @xmath14 , the thermal spin current profile
is plotted in fig .
[ fig5](b ) .
it shows that although with quantitative changes , the properties of asse and ndsse persist . from above discussions
, we see that the electron - tunneling contribution in the single impurity anderson model ( a kondo - type local spin model ) will play an important role , which however will disappear in the coupled spin chain and network system .
we have considered a phenomenological macrospin model to mimic the coupled spin cluster in the insulating magnetic junctions , it would be interesting in the future to study the coupled microscopic spin model as in ref .
@xcite for the nanoscale spin seebeck transport .
[ 0.38 ] with additional electron tunneling contribution .
( b ) the case of lorentzian type dos , with @xmath154 mev for the left lead and @xmath155 mev , @xmath156 for the right one . in both cases , @xmath157 , so @xmath158 and the spin current is only contributed by eq .
( [ eq : is1 ] ) .
@xmath159 mev .
other parameters are the same as in fig .
[ fig2].,title="fig : " ]
in summary , we have studied the nonequilibrium spin seebeck transport across a charge insulating magnetic junction with localized effective spin .
the conjugate - converted thermal - spin transport is assisted by the exchange interactions between the effective macrospin in the center and electrons in metallic leads .
we have shown that in contrast with bulk spin seebeck effect , the figure of merit of the thermal - spin conversion in such nanoscale spin caloritronic devices can be infinite , leading to the ideal carnot efficiency in the linear response .
we have further unravelled the asse and ndsse in the model device , suggesting that the nanoscale thermal spin rectifier could act as a spin seebeck diode , spin seebeck transistor and spin seebeck switch .
cases with electron tunneling are also discussed .
these properties could have various implications in flexible thermal @xcite and spin information control @xcite .
it would be desirable in the future to use first - principles approaches to real molecular magnet systems for more realistic calculations .
this work was carried out under the auspices of the national nuclear security administration of the u.s .
department of energy ( doe ) at los alamos national laboratory ( lanl ) under contract no .
de - ac52 - 06na25396 , and supported by the lanl laboratory directed research development program ( j.r . ) , and the swedish research council and wenner - gren foundation are also acknowledged ( j.f . ) .
the work was supported , in part , by the center for integrated nanotechnologies , a u.s .
doe office of basic energy sciences user facility ( j .- x.z . ) .
j.r . thanks j. thingna for bringing ref .
@xcite to our attention .
k. uchida , s. takahashi , k. harii , j. ieda , w. koshibae , k. ando , s. maekawa , and e. saitoh , nature * 455 * , 778 ( 2008 ) . c. m. jaworski , j. yang , s. mack , d. d. awschalom , j. p. heremans , and r. c. myers , nat .
* 9 * , 898 ( 2010 ) .
c . le breton , s. sharma , h. saito , s. yuasa , and r. jansen , nature * 475 * , 82 ( 2011 ) .
k. uchida , j. xiao , h. adachi , j. ohe , s. takahashi , j. ieda , t. ota , y. kajiwara , h. umezawa , h. kawai , g. e. w. bauer , s. maekawa , and e. saitoh , nat .
* 9 * , 894 ( 2010 ) .
k. uchida , h. adachi , t. ota , h. nakayama , s. maekawa , and e. saitoh , appl .
. lett . * 97 * , 172505 ( 2010 ) .
t. kikkawa , k. uchida , y. shiomi , z. qiu , d. hou , d. tian , h. nakayama , x .- f .
jin , and e. saitoh , phys .
* 110 * , 067207 ( 2013 ) .
a. r. rocha , v. m. garca - surez , s. w. bailey , c. j. lambert , j. ferrer , and s. sanvito , nat .
mater . * 4 * , 335 ( 2005 ) .
l. bogani and w. wernsdorfer , nat .
* 7 * , 179 ( 2008 ) .
s. sanvito , chem .
soc . rev . *
40 * , 3336 ( 2011 ) .
s. jiang , k. go , c. cervetti , l. bogani , sci . china chem . * 55 * , 867 ( 2012 ) . c. timm and f. elste , phys .
b * 73 * , 235304 ( 2006 ) .
m. misiorny and j barna , phys .
b * 75 * , 134425 ( 2007 ) ; _ ibid . _ * 76 * , 054448 ( 2007 ) .
h. z. lu , b. zhou , and s. q. shen , phys . rev .
b * 79 * , 174419 ( 2009 ) .
w. liang , m. p. shores , m. bockrath , j. r. long , and h. park , nature * 417 * , 725 ( 2002 ) .
j. park , a. n. pasupathy , j. i. goldsmith , c. chang , y. yaish , j. r. petta , m. rinkoski , j. p. sethna , h. d. abruna , p. l. mceuen , and d. c. ralph , nature * 417 * , 722 ( 2002 ) .
a. f. otte , m. ternes , k. v. bergmann , s. loth , h. brune , c. p. lutz , c. f. hirjibehedin , and a. j. heinrich , nat . phys . * 4 * , 847 ( 2008 ) . c. romeike , m. r. wegewijs , w. hofstetter , and h. schoeller , phys . rev .
* 96 * , 196601 ( 2006 ) ; _ ibid . _ * 97 * , 206601 ( 2006 ) .
m. r. wegewijs , c. romeike , h. schoeller , and w. hofstetter , new j. phys .
* 9 * , 344 ( 2007 ) . m. n. leuenberger and e. r. mucciolo , phys
lett . * 97 * , 126601 ( 2006 ) .
g. gonzlez , m. n. leuenberger , and e. r. mucciolo , phys .
b * 78 * , 054445 ( 2008 ) . r. q. wang and d. y. xing , phys .
b * 79 * , 193406 ( 2009 ) .
p. s. cornaglia , g. usaj , and c. a. balseiro , phys .
b * 86 * , 041107(r ) ( 2012 ) .
y. dubi and m. di ventra , phys .
b * 79 * , 081302(r ) ( 2009 ) . m. johnson and r. h. silsbee , phys . rev .
b * 35 * , 4959 ( 1987 ) . y. takezoe , k. hosono , a. takeuchi , and g. tatara , phys . rev .
b * 82 * , 094451 ( 2010 ) .
o. kedem and s. r. caplan , trans .
faraday soc .
* 61 * , 1897 ( 1965 ) .
t. e. humphrey , r. newbury , r. p. taylor , and h. linke , phys .
lett . * 89 * , 116801 ( 2002 ) . c. van den broeck , adv .
135 , 189 ( 2007 ) .
m. krawiec and k. i. wysokiski , phys .
b * 73 * , 075307 ( 2006 ) .
r. wirkowicz , m. wierzbicki , and j. barna , phys .
b * 80 * , 195409 ( 2009 ) .
d. sothmann and m. buttiker , europhys . lett .
* 99 * , 27001 ( 2012 ) . strictly speaking , after the transformation additional direct electron tunneling terms will also be generated , but still can be removed by tuning the coulomb interaction strength and the energy level of the impurity . | the spin seebeck effect is studied across a charge insulating magnetic junction , in which thermal - spin conjugate transport is assisted by the exchange interactions between the localized spin in the center and electrons in metallic leads .
we show that , in contrast with bulk spin seebeck effect , the figure of merit of such nanoscale thermal - spin conversion can be infinite , leading to the ideal carnot efficiency in the linear response regime .
we also find that in the nonlinear spin seebeck transport regime , the device possesses the asymmetric and negative differential spin seebeck effects . in the last ,
the situations with leaking electron tunneling are also discussed .
this nanoscale thermal spin rectifier , by tuning the junction parameters , can act as a spin seebeck diode , spin seebeck transistor and spin seebeck switch , which could have substantial implications for flexible thermal and information control in molecular spin caloritronics . |
the recent measurements of the vector charmonium radiative decays to light pseudoscalars , i.e. @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 , have brought surprises and interests to us .
earlier , the cleo collaboration @xcite renewed the branching ratios for @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 , which are consistent with the averages from 2008 particle data group @xcite .
the branching ratio upper limits for @xmath20 and @xmath17 were set , which were more than one order of magnitude smaller than that for @xmath19 .
meanwhile , the upper limits for @xmath21 , where @xmath4 stands for pseudoscalar @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath7 , were set to be about @xmath22 .
the @xmath1 radiative decays are also investigated by the besiii collaboration with the newly collected 106 million @xmath1 events , and the results turn out to be tantalizing .
it shows that the branching ratios for @xmath23 and @xmath17 are only at an order of @xmath24 , which are nearly two orders of magnitude smaller than @xmath19 @xcite .
the mysterious aspects somehow are correlated with the @xmath0 and @xmath1 data .
it is found that the branching ratio for @xmath25 is much smaller than those for @xmath26 and @xmath15 @xcite .
this could be a consequence of suppressions of gluon couplings to isovector currents . as a comparison
, the observation in @xmath10 is indeed puzzling .
the immediate question is , what drives the difference of decay patterns between @xmath0 and @xmath1 . in the literature
, the radiative decays of the vector charmonia attracted a lot of theoretical efforts .
an early study by the qcd sum rules @xcite suggested the dominance of short - distance @xmath27 annihilations .
the gluon and @xmath28 transition matrix elements were computed by coupling the gluon fields to the pseudoscalar states with which the branching ratio fraction @xmath29 was satisfactorily described . in ref .
@xcite , the @xmath8 mixings with the light pseudoscalars @xmath6 and @xmath7 were extracted through the axial gluonic anomaly on the basis of chiral and large @xmath30 approach . by assuming that the partial widths of @xmath31 and @xmath15 were saturated by the @xmath8-@xmath9 mixing
, the branching ratios for @xmath31 and @xmath15 were accounted for to the correct orders of magnitude .
this issue was revisited by feldmann _
et al . _ who proposed to extract the mixing and decay constants on the quark flavor basis @xcite .
this scheme can be easily extended to accommodate the mixing of @xmath8 with @xmath6 and @xmath7 from which the @xmath8-@xmath9 mixing angles were extracted and turned out to be consistent with those from refs .
@xcite .
interestingly , the new data from besiii for @xmath32 seem to suggest a deviation from the saturation assumption .
it implies that some other mechanisms become important in @xmath10 , although they may not play a significant role in @xmath33 . in this work
, we shall show that the vector meson dominance ( vmd ) model is an ideal framework to make a coherent analysis of the @xmath8-@xmath9 mixing effects and contributions from intermediate vector mesons .
we shall show that the @xmath10 is not saturated by the @xmath8-@xmath9 mixing . instead , one important mechanism that drives the difference between @xmath0 and @xmath10 and produces the observed patterns is the sizeable coupling of @xmath34 .
as follows , we first give a brief introduction to the vmd model and lay out the correlated aspects of the @xmath8-@xmath9 mixings in sec .
ii . the detailed analysis , calculation results and discussions
will then be presented in sec .
a brief summary will be given in sec .
in the vmd model ( e.g. see review of refs .
@xcite ) the electromagnetic ( em ) current can be decomposed into a sum of all neutral vector meson fields including both isospin-0 and isospin-1 components .
the leading @xmath35 effective coupling can be written as : @xmath36 where @xmath37 denotes the vector meson field .
the photon - vector - meson coupling constant @xmath38 can be extracted from the partial decay width @xmath39 . neglecting the mass of electron and positron
, we have @xmath40^{\frac{1}{2 } } , \label{fv}\ ] ] where @xmath41 is the electron three - vector momentum in the vector meson rest frame , and @xmath42 is the em fine - structure constant . for the decays of @xmath43 , the vmd contributing diagrams are illustrated in fig .
[ fig-1 ] .
this classification is based on the photon producing mechanisms and related to the experimental measurements .
for instance , fig .
[ fig-1](a ) identifies such a process that the photon is connected to a hadronic vector meson fields .
it requires a sum over all strong transitions of @xmath44 channels . the second process in fig . [ fig-1](b ) is via charmonium electromagnetic ( em ) annihilations .
such a process generally has small contributions in comparison with the strong transitions .
however , it is likely that the em amplitudes may have significant effects in some exclusive decay channels . in recent series studies
@xcite it shows that in the hadronic decays of @xmath45 , the short ( via three gluon annihilation ) and long - distance ( fig . [ fig-1](c ) ) transition amplitudes may have a destructive interfering mode that would efficiently reduce the strong transition amplitudes in some exclusive channels . as a consequence , the em amplitudes may become compatible with the strong ones , and manifest themselves in experimental observables .
this issue is related to the so - called @xmath46 puzzle " , which questions
why the branching ratio fraction @xmath47 is so strongly suppressed in comparison with the pqcd expectation values @xcite .
a review of this subject and some recent progresses on this problem can be found in the literature @xcite . in the present work ,
our attention is to understand whether the data for @xmath48 are consistent with those for @xmath44 , and what drives the different radiative decay patterns between @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
we shall adopt the available experimental measurements of @xmath44 in the calculations of the vmd contributions .
this means we need not worry about the detailed transition mechanisms for @xmath49 at this moment . also , by adopting the experimental data for @xmath44 , we need not consider the @xmath50 mixing processes since they have been contained in the data for @xmath49 .
it is worth noting in advance another feature with this classification of fig .
[ fig-1 ] .
namely , transitions between vector charmonia may also contribute .
for instance , @xmath51 will contribute to @xmath52 .
we will show later that this process is essential for understanding the radiative decay patterns for @xmath0 and @xmath10 . apart from the transitions via fig .
[ fig-1 ] , another important transition is via fig .
[ fig-2 ] which corresponds to the @xmath8-@xmath9 mixing due to the axial vector anomaly .
note that the process of fig .
[ fig-1](a ) with an intermediate charmonium does not overlap with fig .
[ fig-2 ] at the hadronic level .
in fact , it is interesting to note their correlated features : i ) in both cases , the @xmath27 annihilate at short distances . in fig .
[ fig-1](a ) , the vector configuration of @xmath27 annihilates into a photon , i.e. @xmath27 in a relative @xmath53-wave with spin-1 , while in fig .
[ fig-2 ] the pseudoscalar @xmath27 are in a relative @xmath53-wave but with spin-0 , and then annihilates into gluons .
ii ) the process of fig .
[ fig-2 ] is through a typical magnetic dipole ( m1 ) transition of @xmath54 , which can be regarded as a non - vector - resonance contribution in respect to the vmd scenario . in the frame of vmd . ] and @xmath15 via @xmath8-@xmath9 mixing . ] with the lagrangian of eq .
( [ lag-1 ] ) , the transition amplitude can be expressed as @xmath55 where @xmath56 denotes the coupling constants for the hadronic vertex of @xmath44 , and will be determined by experimental data via @xmath57 we adopt an empirical form for the form factor @xcite : @xmath58 where parameter @xmath59 is in a range of @xmath60 mev .
this form factor can be interpreted as the wavefunction overlap which would be suppressed in a large recoil momentum region for the final state particles @xcite .
the incovariant form factor can also be regarded reasonable in this case .
the decay processes are treated in the c.m .
frame of the initial meson .
therefore , the anti - symmetric tensor structure of the interactions can always be reduced to a form of @xmath61 , which explicitly depends on the three - vector momentum of the final state vector meson .
note that for the anti - symmetric tensor couplings all the contributions to the transition amplitude can be absorbed into the effective coupling form factor . because of this , it is natural to expect that the form factor would contain information of meson wavefunction overlaps with an explicit three - vector - momentum dependence . in particular ,
a harmonic oscillator potential for the quark - antiquark system will lead to a form factor similar to eq .
( [ ff-01 ] ) .
we shall determine the form factor parameter @xmath59 combining the data for @xmath62 and @xmath3 .
it will then be fixed and adopted for the calculations of other channels . in the transition of fig .
[ fig-1](a ) , the vector meson will carry the momentum of the final state photon @xmath63 .
the transition amplitudes of fig .
[ fig-2 ] can be expressed as @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the mixing angle between pseudoscalar @xmath4 and @xmath8 .
it has been extracted in ref .
@xcite , @xmath66 and @xmath67 , which are also obtained by ref .
it should be noted that in the above equation the coupling @xmath68 is extracted from the data for @xmath69 .
the non - local effects from the off - shell @xmath8 at the mass of @xmath9 have been included in the mixing angles @xcite . in the second line , we define a reduced coupling @xmath70 , which can be directly compared with the effective coupling @xmath71 in eq .
( [ trans-1 ] ) .
we do not include the @xmath72 mixings with the @xmath9 in @xmath73 and @xmath15 since their mixing angles are relatively small .
nevertheless , the @xmath72 mixing effects will be further suppressed by the unknown but believe - to - be - small branching ratio for @xmath74 .
in table [ tab-1 ] , the data for @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath75 from pdg 2010 @xcite are listed .
it shows that most of the light @xmath76 channels have been measured for @xmath0 and @xmath1 hadronic decays .
in contrast , most of the light @xmath76 channels for @xmath77 are below the experimental precision limit except for @xmath78 .
as mentioned earlier , the @xmath62 channels are correlated with the so - called @xmath46 puzzle " in the literature .
however , our attention in the present work is different . we shall use the experimental data for @xmath44 as an input to investigate the role played by the vmd mechanisms in the vector charmonium radiative decays
this treatment means that one need not be concerned about the detailed transition mechanisms for @xmath44 at this moment since they all have been contained in the experimental data .
we emphasize that this should not be a trivial starting point .
success of such a prescription would help us clarify two major processes in the charmonium radiative decays , i.e. the relative @xmath53-wave @xmath27 annihilations would occur either via spin-1 or spin-0 configurations .
.branching ratios for @xmath79 from pdg 2010 @xcite .
the dash - " and dots @xmath80 " denote the forbidden and unavailable channels , respectively . [
cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] our investigation suggests the importance of a coherent treatment for the vmd mechanism and @xmath8-@xmath9 mixings .
note that the charmonium pole contribution has not been included by the previous studies @xcite .
meanwhile , an understanding of why the vmd and axial gluonic anomaly mechanisms play different roles in @xmath0 and @xmath1 decays would be essentially important .
the following points may help to clarify this question : \i ) as mentioned earlier , there are some interesting correspondences between the axial gluonic anomaly and vmd in this case . in the axial gluonic anomaly transitions the @xmath27 annihilate into gluon fields at short distances in a relative @xmath53-wave and spin-0 , which induces mixings with the goldstone boson @xmath6 and su(3 ) flavor singlet @xmath7 .
the photon radiation can be regarded as from non - vector - resonance m1 transitions . in the vmd transitions via the charmonium state , the @xmath27 also annihilate at short distances in a relative @xmath53-wave , but with spin-1 . in this case , the annihilated @xmath27 couple to a photon , and radiate two soft gluons which can couple to pseudoscalar states .
\ii ) the difference between those two mechanisms can be well - understood quantum mechanically . for @xmath81 , the vmd transitions via @xmath1 pole
is relative suppressed by the @xmath82 coupling since as the first radial excited state the wavefunction of @xmath1 at the origin is smaller than that of @xmath0 .
in contrast , the axial - gluonic - anomaly - driving @xmath8-@xmath9 mixings will occur via @xmath83 , where the first step is a typical em m1 transition between two ground charmonium states .
it is allowed by the quantum transition selection rule at leading order .
the situation changes in @xmath84 . on the one hand ,
the vmd transition will be dominated by the @xmath0 pole , which will be coupled to the em field . on the other hand ,
the axial gluonic anomaly transitions via the @xmath1-@xmath8 m1 transition will be suppressed by the quantum transition selection rule at leading order . for the @xmath72-mediated transition , the @xmath72 mixings with the @xmath6 and @xmath7
will then be suppressed @xcite .
the above qualitative argument explains why the vmd mechanism and axial gluonic anomaly play different roles in @xmath0 and @xmath1 decays , respectively , as manifested by the calculation .
in particular , it shows that both mechanisms are crucial for our understanding of the observed branching ratio patterns .
the successful account of the observed branching ratio patterns for @xmath11 in the vmd model has an important implication of the hadronic decay mechanisms for @xmath62 .
it shows that the puzzling " radiative decay patterns in @xmath11 have direct connections with the hadronic decay mechanisms , i.e. @xmath62 , instead of some other abnormal processes . as a consequence
, it will guide our further investigations of the transitions of @xmath62 , and impose constraints on processes such as illustrated by fig .
[ fig-1 ] .
for instance , the hadronic part of fig .
[ fig-1](c ) is found to be an important non - perturbative qcd mechanism that contributes predominantly in @xmath51 and @xmath85 @xcite .
as pointed out recently in a series of papers on the subject of non - perturbative transition mechanisms in charmonium decays @xcite , such intermediate meson loop transitions would be an natural mechanism for evading the pqcd helicity selection rule and explaining the @xmath46 puzzle " in @xmath62 .
in brief , with the available data for @xmath62 , we show that the vmd model is still useful for our understanding of the newly measured branching ratios for @xmath86 in association with the @xmath8-@xmath9 mixings via the axial gluonic anomaly .
importance of such a contribution has not been recognized before . in particular
, we stress that the intermediate vector charmonia can have significant contributions via e.g. @xmath87 .
we show that these two mechanisms behave differently in @xmath0 and @xmath10 , and can be understood by state transition selection rules .
we also emphasize that the consistency between @xmath11 and @xmath76 demonstrated in this work would impose important constraints on the non - pqcd mechanisms in @xmath62 .
it would be useful for our final understanding of the long - standing @xmath46 puzzle " in @xmath62 .
the author thanks useful discussions with h .-
li , x .- q .
li , and h .- w .
ke . this work is supported , in part , by the national natural science foundation of china ( grants no .
10491306 ) , chinese academy of sciences ( kjcx2-ew - n01 ) , and ministry of science and technology of china ( 2009cb825200 ) .
t. k. pedlar _ et al . _
[ cleo collaboration ] , phys .
d * 79 * , 111101 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.1394 [ hep - ex ] ] . c. amsler
_ et al . _
[ particle data group ] , phys .
b * 667 * , 1 ( 2008 ) .
m. ablikim _
[ besiii collaboration ] , phys .
* 105 * , 261801 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1011.0889[hep - ex ] ] ; l.l .
wang ( for besiii collaboration ) , talk given at the 4th international workshop on charm physics - charm 2010 , 2010 , beijing .
k. nakamura _ et al .
_ [ particle data group ] , j. phys .
g * 37 * , 075021 ( 2010 ) .
v. a. novikov , m. a. shifman , a. i. vainshtein and v. i. zakharov , nucl .
b * 165 * , 55 ( 1980 ) .
k. t. chao , nucl .
b * 335 * ( 1990 ) 101 .
t. feldmann , p. kroll and b. stech , phys .
b * 449 * , 339 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9812269 ] .
t. h. bauer , r. d. spital , d. r. yennie and f. m. pipkin , rev .
* 50 * , 261 ( 1978 ) [ erratum - ibid . *
51 * , 407 ( 1979 ) ] .
t. bauer and d. r. yennie , phys .
b * 60 * , 169 ( 1976 ) .
g. li , q. zhao and c. h. chang , j. phys .
g * 35 * , 055002 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0701020 ] .
q. zhao , g. li and c. h. chang , phys . lett .
b * 645 * , 173 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0610223 ] .
y. j. zhang , g. li and q. zhao , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 172001 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0902.1300 [ hep - ph ] ] .
q. zhao , nucl .
suppl . * 207 - 208 * , 347 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1012.2887 [ hep - ph ] ] . v. l. chernyak and a. r. zhitnitsky , phys .
rept . * 112 * , 173 ( 1984 ) .
x. h. mo , c. z. yuan and p. wang , high energy phys .
. phys . * 31 * , 686 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0611214 ] .
q. zhao , g. li and c. h. chang , chinese phys .
* c 34 * , 299 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0812.4092 [ hep - ph ] ] . c. amsler and f.e .
close , phys .
b * 353 * , 385 ( 1995 ) ; phys . rev . *
d53 * , 295 ( 1996 ) .
f.e . close and a. kirk , phys .
b * 483 * , 345 ( 2000 ) .
f.e . close and q. zhao , phys .
d * 71*. 094022 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0504043 ] . c. e. thomas , jhep * 0710 * , 026 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0705.1500 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. escribano and j. nadal , jhep * 0705 * , 006 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0703187 ] . h. y. cheng , h. n. li and k. f. liu , phys .
d * 79 * , 014024 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0811.2577 [ hep - ph ] ] .
v. mathieu and v. vento , phys .
b * 688 * , 314 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1003.2119 [ hep - ph ] ] .
f. k. guo , c. hanhart , g. li , u. g. meissner and q. zhao , arxiv:1008.3632 [ hep - ph ] . f. k. guo , c. hanhart and u. g. meissner , phys . rev
. lett . * 103 * , 082003 ( 2009 ) [ erratum - ibid . *
104 * , 109901 ( 2010 ) ] [ arxiv:0907.0521 [ hep - ph ] ] . | we show that the newly measured branching ratios of vector charmonia ( @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 into @xmath3 , where @xmath4 stands for light pseudoscalar mesons @xmath5 , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 , can be well understood in the framework of vector meson dominance ( vmd ) in association with the @xmath8-@xmath9 mixings due to the axial gluonic anomaly .
these two mechanisms behave differently in @xmath0 and @xmath10 . a coherent understanding of the branching ratio patterns observed in @xmath11
can be achieved by self - consistently including those transition mechanisms at hadronic level .
the branching ratios for @xmath12 are predicted to be rather small . |
it has long been known that phase transitions are uncommon in one - dimensional classical statistical mechanics .
an old argument by peierls shows that in models at non - zero temperature with local interactions and a finite number of degrees of freedom , order is not possible : the entropy gain from disordering the system will always dominate the energy loss .
there are ( at least ) three ways of avoiding this argument .
the first two are well understood . a system at zero temperature can of course order : the system just sits in its ground state .
a system with long - range interactions can have an energy large enough to dominate the entropy . in this paper
, we will discuss in depth a third way of obtaining a phase transition in one dimension .
this is to study systems with an infinite number of degrees of freedom per site .
in particular , we will study magnets with @xmath4 and @xmath3 symmetry .
we will see that there can be a phase transition in the @xmath5 limit .
we solve these one - dimensional classical systems for any @xmath0 , and show how the transition occurs only in this limit ; for finite @xmath0 all quantities depend on the temperature analytically .
the infinite number of degrees of freedom has roughly the same effect of increasing the effective dimensionality , but the phase transition is very different from those in higher dimension .
it is not a phase transition between an ordered phase and a disordered one , but rather between a disordered phase and a seriously - disordered one . in the seriously - disordered phase
, the system behaves as if it were at infinite temperature .
the entropy has dominated the energy to the point where the energy term does not affect the physics ; each spin is effectively independent .
the infinite number of degrees of freedom means that this serious disorder is possible even at finite temperature .
the paper is a companion to one by tchernyshyov and sondhi @xcite .
there it is shown that in some magnets , a mean - field calculation yields a phase transition in any dimension .
since mean - field results are exact at @xmath5 , this predicts the phase transition we observe here .
their computation also predicts that there is a first - order phase transition for the @xmath6 magnet on just three sites with periodic boundary conditions .
remarkably , this first - order transition happens only for precisely three sites ; for any other number of sites greater than 1 there is a second - order transition .
it has long been known that phase transitions can occur as @xmath5 in zero - dimensional matrix models @xcite .
phase transitions in one dimension at infinite @xmath0 were studied in @xcite . in particular , the largest eigenvalue for the @xmath2 case discussed here was computed in @xcite for any @xmath0 . here
will develop the necessary techniques systematically , and extend these results in several ways .
we explicitly find all the eigenvalues of the transfer matrix for these magnets .
all these results are completely analytic in @xmath0 and in the inverse temperature @xmath7 as long as @xmath0 is finite .
the singularity and a phase transition can develop when @xmath5 and @xmath8 with @xmath9 remaining finite .
knowing all the eigenvalues and their multiplicities explicitly for any @xmath0 lets us show that there can be a phase transition as @xmath5 even for a finite number of sites in one dimension . in section 2
, we find all the eigenvalues ( and their multiplicities ) of the transfer matrices in a variety of one - dimensional magnets . in section 3
, we use these results to study the phase transitions which occur as the number of sites and @xmath0 go to infinity .
most of these phase transitions are ferromagnetic , but one is antiferromagnetic . in section 4 ,
we study the first - order transition for the three - site @xmath2 chain . in an appendix
we collect some useful mathematical results .
to illustrate the procedure , we start with a simple rotor , the classical xy model in one dimension . the spin is defined by a periodic variable @xmath10 , and spins @xmath11 and @xmath12 on adjacent sites have energy @xmath13 to compute the partition function of this system , define a transfer `` matrix '' @xmath14 since the variables of the system take continuous values , this is nt really a matrix , but rather the kernel of an integral operator .
it takes functions of @xmath11 to functions of @xmath12 by @xmath15 to compute the partition function , we need eigenvalues @xmath16 of @xmath17 . because the spins take values on a compact space ( the circle here ) , the eigenvalues are discrete and hence labeled by a discrete index @xmath18 .
the corresponding eigenfunctions @xmath19 obey @xmath20 for the energy ( [ eo(2 ) ] ) , the @xmath19 are obviously @xmath21 the index @xmath18 must be an integer to preserve the periodicity under @xmath22 . to see that these are eigenfunctions , note that @xmath23 the integral then can be evaluated for any @xmath18 in terms of a bessel function : @xmath24 the partition function for @xmath25 sites with periodic boundary conditions is then @xmath26 when @xmath25 is large enough , the sum is dominated by largest eigenvalue , which here is the @xmath27 state .
the internal energy density @xmath28 of the system is then @xmath29 all other quantities such as correlators can easily be found as well , since we have an explicit and complete set of eigenvalues and their multiplicities .
the eigenvalues of the @xmath31 problem are found by fourier transforming the transfer matrix .
what we need to do for more general cases can be summarized as fourier analysis on manifolds more general than the circle .
in other words , we want to expand a function taking values on a manifold @xmath32 into a series , e.g. @xmath33 where the @xmath34 are complete set of orthonormal functions .
the eigenvalues of the transfer matrix are the coefficients of the expansion in this basis .
the problem of fourier analysis on all the manifolds of interest has been solved already .
the key is to exploit the symmetry .
a familiar example is where the spins take values on the two - sphere @xmath35 , where the eigenfunctions are called spherical harmonics . in coset language , the two - sphere can be described as the manifold @xmath36 : the @xmath37 group consists of rotations , while the @xmath31 subgroup is the set of rotations which leave a given point invariant .
thus different points on @xmath35 take values in @xmath38 .
we parameterize the two - sphere by the usual spherical coordinates : a unit three - vector @xmath39 . to make progress , it is crucial to consider an energy invariant under the @xmath37 rotation group , namely @xmath40 we can expand the transfer matrix energy into irreducible representations of the rotation group , labeled by an angular momentum @xmath18 and an @xmath41 component @xmath42 .
the eigenfunctions of the transfer matrix are expressed in terms of legendre polynomials @xmath43 , whose explicit definition will be given below .
one way of showing that the legendre polynomials are eigenfunctions of the transfer matrix is to show that they obey an addition theorem , for example @xmath44 where the @xmath45 are called associated legendre polynomials , with @xmath46 .
one can then expand the function @xmath47 in terms of legendre polynomials , and then use the addition theorem to split the @xmath11 and @xmath12 dependence .
this leaves an integral for the eigenvalue . to just obtain the eigenvalues of the transfer matrix
, one does not have to go to all the complications of generalized addition theorems .
mathematicians have developed more in - depth ways of deriving the eigenfunctions , and then the addition theorem comes as a consequence of the computation .
a geometric method is discussed in @xcite , while a much more explicit method is discussed in @xcite .
we will require the methods of the latter in order to treat the @xmath3 magnet , where the spins do not take values on a symmetric space .
( a symmetric space @xmath48 has @xmath49 a maximal subgroup of @xmath50 ; the importance here is that when the spins take values in a symmetric space , the transfer matrix depends on only one parameter . )
first we find the eigenvalues for an @xmath30-invariant magnet , where the spins @xmath51 take values on the manifold @xmath52 , which is the @xmath53-sphere @xmath54 .
we take the energy between nearest neighbors to be @xmath55 an eigenvalue @xmath16 associated with eigenfunction @xmath56 is given by the equation @xmath57
e^{\beta \vec{s}\cdot\vec{s ' } } f_l(\vec{s ' } ) .
\label{evon}\ ] ] where @xmath58 $ ] is the usual measure on the @xmath59 sphere , normalized so that @xmath60 = 1 $ ] .
the unit @xmath0-vector @xmath51 depends on @xmath59 angles , but the energy only depends on the angle between the two spins .
this means that to compute the eigenvalue , we need do only one integral . put in terms of the @xmath37 spherical harmonics , it means that the eigenvalues depend only the value of @xmath18 and not @xmath42 .
explicitly , if one sets @xmath61 , the integrand in ( [ evon ] ) depends on only a single angle @xmath11 .
we can then do the integral over all the other angles in ( [ evon ] ) , and the measure reduces to @xcite @xmath62 = \frac{\gamma(n/2)}{\gamma((n-1)/2)\gamma(1/2 ) } \int_0^\pi d\theta \sin^{n-2}\theta \label{measure}\ ] ] the eigenfunctions for all the magnets we study here can be written in terms of jacobi polynomials @xmath63 .
these are orthogonal polynomials of order @xmath64 , and a number of useful properties are collected in the appendix .
the eigenfunctions for the @xmath30 magnet with energy ( [ energyon ] ) are given by @xmath65 where @xmath66 . these are often called gegenbauer or ultraspherical polynomials .
they are indeed orthogonal with respect to the measure ( [ measure ] ) .
the eigenvalues are then given by @xmath67 using the integral in the appendix for @xmath68 gives @xmath69 the function @xmath70 is called kummer s function , and is a confluent hypergeometric function . its definition and
the differential equation it satisfies are given in the appendix .
using the double - argument formula for gamma functions @xcite and the identity ( [ besselm ] ) with @xmath71 gives our result @xmath72 note that the eigenvalues reduce to the rotor result ( [ evo2 ] ) when @xmath73 .
note also that @xmath30 ferromagnets and antiferromagnets are essentially the same , because redefining @xmath74 for every other spin sends @xmath75 .
this transformation @xmath76 leaves the measure of the integral invariant , and @xmath77 . as a function of @xmath7 ,
the bessel function is analytic for all @xmath7 .
moreover @xmath78 for any @xmath7 as long as @xmath79 is positive .
thus the free energy does not have any singularities as long as @xmath79 remains finite .
one might hope something interesting happens when @xmath5 , but in section [ section : infinite - n ] we will show that in this case there is still no transition .
the computation for the @xmath2 case is very similar to that of the @xmath30 case , but we will see in the next section how there is a completely new phase . the @xmath2 magnet is defined in terms of a complex @xmath0-vector @xmath80 obeying @xmath81 .
the energy for adjacent sites is @xmath82 this energy is not only invariant under global @xmath2 rotations , but is invariant under local ( gauge ) transformations @xmath83 at any site @xmath84 .
the vector @xmath80 takes values on a complex sphere @xmath85 , which as a manifold is identical to the real @xmath86-sphere @xmath87 .
however , the @xmath88 gauge symmetry can be used to effectively reduce the number of degrees of freedom in the problem by 1 .
for example , one can set the last component of @xmath80 to be real at every site , so @xmath80 effectively takes values on the manifold @xmath89 this manifold is a symmetric space , and is known as the complex projective space @xmath90 .
like the @xmath30 case , the energy between adjacent sites depends only on a single angle @xmath11 , where @xmath91 ( any phase can always be gauged away ) .
then the normalized measure can be written as @xcite @xmath92 = 2(n-1 ) \int_0^{\pi/2 } d\theta \sin^{2n-3}\theta \cos\theta \label{unmeasure}\ ] ] the eigenvectors of the @xmath90 transfer matrix are jacobi polynomials as well , namely @xcite @xmath93 the @xmath73 case reduces to the ordinary real two - sphere , and indeed the @xmath94 are ordinary spherical harmonics .
the @xmath2 symmetry means that the eigenvalues have degeneracies .
for example , we saw in section 2.1 that for @xmath73 the eigenvalue depends only on @xmath18 and not the @xmath95 value @xmath42 . for @xmath73 ,
the degeneracy @xmath96 of @xmath16 is of course @xmath97 ; the generalization to all @xmath0 is @xcite @xmath98 the eigenvalues are given by @xmath99 where @xmath100 .
using the integral in the appendix for @xmath101 , @xmath102 gives @xmath103 for finite @xmath0 and @xmath7 , these are analytic functions .
note that , unlike for @xmath30 magnets , @xmath104 and @xmath105 are not equivalent here . for positive @xmath7
, we have a ferromagnet : the energy favors aligned spins : a neighbor of @xmath106 is in the same state @xmath107 ( up to a phase ) .
however , @xmath105 does not correspond to an antiferromagnet : the energy favors the neighbor @xmath108 being in _ any _ state orthogonal to @xmath109 , i.e. , @xmath110 .
there is a unique orthogonal state only for @xmath73 .
thus , with the exception of @xmath111 , the @xmath2 model ( [ esun ] ) is ferromagnetic when @xmath104 , but is not an antiferromagnet when @xmath105 . for a proper generalization of an antiferromaget
, one needs to designate among the @xmath59 vectors orthogonal to @xmath112 one that can be called `` antiparallel '' to it , for example , @xmath113 . doing so manifestly breaks the @xmath2 symmetry , as we discuss next .
the @xmath114 magnet can be deformed in an interesting way by breaking the @xmath114 symmetry to @xmath3 .
the main novelty of this @xmath3 magnet is that the phase transition can occur at an antiferromagnetic value of @xmath7 .
the energy between adjacent sites is @xmath115 where @xmath109 is a @xmath116-dimensional complex vector , and @xmath117 is the @xmath118 dimensional matrix @xmath119 , where i is the @xmath0-dimensional identity matrix , and @xmath120 the pauli matrix .
the second term breaks the @xmath114 symmetry , but preserves an @xmath3 subgroup . the case @xmath121 reduces to the @xmath114 ferromagnet discussed above .
the case @xmath122 , studied by read and sachdev @xcite , is a large-@xmath0 generalization of an antiferromagnet .
indeed , the energy @xmath123 is minimized when vectors @xmath109 and @xmath108 are locked in adjacent flavors @xmath124 and @xmath125 , e.g. , @xmath112 and @xmath113 , analogues of spin - down @xmath126 and spin - up @xmath127 in @xmath111 .
like the @xmath2 magnet , the generalized model has a local @xmath88 symmetry .
just like the complex sphere @xmath85 is identical as a manifold to the real sphere @xmath87 , the `` quaternionic sphere '' @xmath128 is identical as a manifold to the complex sphere @xmath129 ( which in turn is equivalent the real @xmath130-sphere @xmath131 ) .
when we fix a gauge , then @xmath109 takes values on the manifold @xmath132
it is easiest to study first the special point @xmath133 , where the gauge symmetry is enhanced to @xmath134 .
the @xmath111 gauge symmetry ( a subgroup of the @xmath135 ) mixes the @xmath124 and @xmath125 components of @xmath109 and also mixes @xmath109 and @xmath136 . precisely ,
if we arrange these components into the matrix @xmath137 then all the @xmath138 transform under the gauge symmetry as @xmath139 where @xmath140 is an element of @xmath111 .
the energy is invariant under these transformations even though @xmath140 can be different at every point .
if we use this symmetry to fix a gauge ( e.g.@xmath141 , @xmath142 ) , then @xmath109 for @xmath133 takes values on the manifold @xmath143 which we call @xmath144 .
solving this case is almost the same as the @xmath2 case , because this is a symmetric space .
the energy between adjacent sites depends on only one variable , and the measure becomes @xcite @xmath145 = 4(n-1)(2n-1 ) \int_0^{\pi/2 } d\theta \sin^{4n-5}\theta \cos^3\theta \label{spnmeasure}\ ] ] the eigenfunctions of the transfer matrix are the jacobi polynomials @xmath146 @xcite . using the integral in the appendix yields @xmath147 for @xmath73 ,
this is equivalent to the @xmath148 magnet .
the calculation for @xmath149 is more complicated .
the reason is that the energy between adjacent sites depends now on two angles : the manifold ( [ spnmanifold ] ) is not a symmetric space .
luckily , the work of @xcite allows us to solve this case as well .
it is convenient to write coordinates for the quaternionic sphere @xmath128 in terms of angles @xmath150 describing an ordinary @xmath59-dimensional sphere , namely @xmath151 then we have @xmath152 the angles take values in @xmath153 setting @xmath154 corresponds to all coordinates @xmath155 except @xmath156 .
then the energy ( [ espn ] ) is @xmath157 this indeed depends on two angles , except in the @xmath111 gauge - invariant case @xmath133 . in terms of these two variables ,
the measure is @xmath158 = 8(n-1)(2n-1 ) \int_0^{\pi/2 } d\theta \sin^{4n-5}\theta \cos^3\theta \int_0^{\pi/2 } d\omega \sin\omega \cos\omega \label{spnmeasure2}\ ] ] where we have dropped the now - unnecessary subscripts and primes .
the eigenvectors of the corresponding transfer matrix are now labelled by two indices , @xmath159 .
they are written in terms of jacobi polynomials as @xcite @xmath160 one can easily check that they are indeed orthogonal with respect to the measure ( [ spnmeasure2 ] ) .
the eigenvalues @xmath161 of the transfer matrix in the read - sachdev case @xmath122 , @xmath162 are therefore given by @xmath163 using the integral in the appendix twice , we find that @xmath164 where @xmath165 this series be rewritten in terms of a confluent hypergeometric function if desired . for the ground state @xmath166 , it simplifies to @xmath167 the lowest eigenvalue is identical to that for the @xmath114 magnet , but the general eigenvalues are not the same .
in this section we study systems with the number of sites @xmath168 .
this means that the free energy follows from the largest eigenvalue @xmath169 of the transfer matrix .
we saw in the last section that in all cases , @xmath169 is analytic function of the inverse temperature @xmath7 for any finite @xmath0 .
thus the only possibility for a phase transition is if this function develops a singularity as @xmath5 .
it is useful to study the @xmath30 magnets first .
we need to use the asymptotic formula for bessel functions , valid when @xmath79 is large @xcite : @xmath170 where @xmath171 this formula implies that to have a non - trivial large @xmath0 limit , we need to take the inverse temperature @xmath7 to @xmath172 as well , leaving the model in terms of the new variable @xmath173 . using this formula and
some algebra gives the eigenvalue ratios to be @xmath174 when we write quantities as a function of @xmath175 , we mean that the expression is valid up to terms of order @xmath176 .
the two - point function is @xmath177 so @xmath178 is indeed the correlation length . at zero temperature ( @xmath179 ) ,
@xmath178 diverges , just like the one - dimensional ising model .
this is the usual zero - temperature behavior in one - dimensional classical models .
the correlation length does not diverge for any other value of temperature , but note that at infinite temperature , @xmath180 .
this is a state where the system is completely disordered : every site is essentially independent of any other site , because all configurations have the same weight in the partition sum .
it is also useful to compute the internal energy .
this is defined as @xmath181 using the asymptotic formula for the bessel function gives @xmath182 in the @xmath5 limit , the internal energy is proportional to @xmath0 , so it is the energy per component which remains finite .
the @xmath2 and @xmath3 magnets each have a phase transition when @xmath5 .
the lowest eigenvalue is given by for example @xmath183 as detailed in the last section , for the read - sachdev case @xmath184 . to find the large @xmath0 behavior , it is useful to examine the differential equation ( [ diffeq ] ) for @xmath185 directly
. then one can see how one can neglect various terms in the equation in various regimes , and then easily solve the equation .
this sort of analysis is called boundary - layer theory , and the techniques are discussed at length in @xcite . rewriting ( [ diffeq ] ) in terms of @xmath186
, one has @xmath187 in the large @xmath0 limit , we can neglect the first term as long as @xmath188 .
this shows that @xmath189 this formula can be verified by using stirling s formula in the series expression ( [ kummer ] ) for @xmath70 .
the lowest eigenvalue at large @xmath0 is therefore @xmath190 two important results are apparent from this formula .
first , there is a singularity at @xmath191 .
second , @xmath192 for @xmath188 does not grow with @xmath0 , and so the internal energy per component vanishes .
a vanishing internal energy is characteristic of infinite temperature .
the remarkable characteristic of the @xmath2 magnet is that this behavior persists all the way from infinite temperature @xmath193 to a finite temperature @xmath191 .
in fact , the correlation length vanishes for all @xmath188 .
this follows from the ratio of the first two eigenvalues : @xmath194 as @xmath5 , this vanishes if @xmath188 .
most scale - invariant critical points have diverging correlation length . at the phase transition at @xmath191 , the correlation length _
vanishes_. we call a phase with vanishing correlation length _ seriously disordered_. this distinguishes it from the @xmath195 phase , which is a conventional disordered phase with a finite , non - zero correlation length . in the seriously - disordered phase ,
the eigenfunction is @xmath196 .
this eigenfunction gives equal probabilities to all configurations .
basically , what has happened is that the energy has been swamped by the entropy . for large @xmath0
, there are so many possible spin configurations that if @xmath188 , the energy term is too small to make a difference .
this is apparent in the integral ( [ unevint ] ) .
the measure favors configurations where the angle @xmath11 between nearest - neighbor spins is near @xmath197 .
the reason is as stated before : for a fixed @xmath80 , there is only one value of @xmath198 where @xmath199 but there are many with @xmath200 .
the energy favors aligned spins , and at @xmath191 the energy term is strong enough to cause a transition to a phase with finite correlation length . the phase for @xmath195 is still a disordered phase , but a conventional one , as occurs in the @xmath30 magnets . note that this phase transition occurs in the ferromagnetic phase ( @xmath104 ) . if @xmath105 , the energy and the entropy both favor disorder , so the system is always seriously disordered . we have asserted but not yet proven that for @xmath195
, the internal energy is non - zero and the correlation length is finite .
the expression ( [ mlim ] ) for @xmath70 in the large-@xmath0 limit is not valid for @xmath195 , because the first term in the differential equation ( [ diffeqy ] ) can no longer be neglected when @xmath201 is of order @xmath202 .
to understand @xmath195 , it is useful to derive a differential equation for @xmath203 directly .
one has @xmath204 where we utilized ( [ diffeqy ] ) .
the internal energy for @xmath188 is a solution of this equation with @xmath28 finite , found by neglecting the left - hand side and the last term on the right - hand side .
it is @xmath205 the solution of the differential equation ( [ diffequ ] ) for @xmath0 large and @xmath195 comes by assuming @xmath206 is finite .
then one neglects the left - hand - side and the second term on the right - hand side , yielding @xmath207 one can find the @xmath176 corrections to these expressions systematically .
for example , one can show that the lowest eigenvalue @xmath169 for @xmath195 is to next order in @xmath0 : @xmath208 where @xmath209 .
the ratio of the first two eigenvalues for @xmath195 follows from a similar computation , yielding @xmath210 thus we see that the correlation length indeed goes to zero as @xmath211 from above .
this is a second - order phase transition : the energy is continuous but its derivative is discontinuous . for the read - sachdev @xmath3 magnets ,
the formula is similar : @xmath212 the expression for the eigenvalues in terms of the kummer function @xmath70 is valid for any value of @xmath175 and @xmath0 , but the expressions derived for the large-@xmath0 limit break down when @xmath213 is of order @xmath214 .
all the terms in the differential equations ( [ diffeqy],[diffequ ] ) need to be included in this region .
to understand the transition region , we study the physics in terms of the variable @xmath215 the differential equation for the lowest eigenvalue ( [ diffeqy ] ) becomes ( in the @xmath2 case ) @xmath216 for @xmath0 large , we can neglect the term with the @xmath202 in it . thus the subsequent analysis will be valid up to terms of order @xmath202 , as opposed to equations in the last section , which have corrections of order @xmath176 . solving this differential equation by plugging in the series @xmath217
requires that @xmath218 plugging this in and summing the series , the solution near @xmath219 for large @xmath0 is therefore @xmath220 where the @xmath70 is indeed our friend the kummer function .
thus we have shown that the eigenvalue @xmath221 near @xmath219 at large @xmath0 is related to a kummer function with different arguments .
to fix the values of @xmath222 and @xmath223 , we need to match this onto the value of @xmath169 in the high - temperature phase ( [ evsunhigh ] ) and in the low - temperature phase ( [ evsunlow ] ) . from @xcite
, we have the asymptotic formula @xmath224 matching while neglecting terms of order @xmath202 yields @xmath225 .
matching this with the numerical result for @xmath226 given in the last section gives @xmath227 the two terms in ( [ lam0 ] ) cancel when @xmath84 is large and negative , but add when @xmath84 is large and positive . with a little work
, one can now derive the specific heat @xmath228 everywhere , including at @xmath191 .
we find @xmath229 for @xmath188 , @xmath230 for @xmath188 , and @xmath231 for @xmath191 .
the traditional critical exponents can be defined when @xmath1 . for the specific heat
, we have @xmath232 , while the correlation length goes to zero logarithmically , so @xmath102 as well .
in section 2 we found all the eigenvalues and their degeneracies for the @xmath2 magnet .
this means that we can also study phase transitions where the number of sites @xmath25 is finite as well as the infinite-@xmath25 case studied in section 3 .
the phase transition persists all the way down to two sites .
a remarkable result of the mean - field - theory analysis of @xcite is that for three sites ( and only for three sites ) , the transition becomes first - order .
we verify this result in this section .
the partition function for the @xmath2 magnet with periodic boundary conditions for any number of sites @xmath25 is given by @xmath233 where the eigenvalues @xmath16 and their degeneracies @xmath96 are given by ( [ unev ] ) and ( [ degeneracy ] ) respectively . in this section
we study only the @xmath2 magnet , so we will omit the @xmath2 superscripts . if one takes @xmath168 before taking @xmath5 , the partition function is dominated by the largest eigenvalue @xmath169 no matter what the degeneracy @xmath96 is .
however , for finite @xmath25 , the fact that @xmath96 grows quite quickly with @xmath18 and @xmath0 means that the largest eigenvalue does not necessarily dominate the partition function , but instead @xmath234 for some @xmath235 which may not be zero .
all the eigenvalues with finite @xmath18 ( so that @xmath236 as @xmath5 ) have the same kind of singularity as @xmath237 .
thus if the effect of including the degeneracy merely shifts @xmath235 to some finite value , the second - order transition remains . to find a first - order transition
, we need to study the eigenvalues when @xmath5 with @xmath238 remaining finite .
it is convenient to fix the inverse temperature @xmath175 and study the problem as a function of @xmath239 , defined as @xmath240 at some value @xmath241 , @xmath242 is a maximum ; at this value the free energy is minimized ( the path integral has a saddle point ) .
the behavior of the eigenvalues at non - zero @xmath239 can be found by doing a saddle - point approximation to the integral representation of the kummer function , or by deriving a differential equation for @xmath243 in the manner of ( [ diffequ ] ) . to leading order in @xmath0 , @xmath244 where @xmath245 at large @xmath0 and @xmath18
, the degeneracy behaves as @xmath246 the degeneracy is a group - theoretical factor and is independent of the inverse temperature @xmath175 .
a first - order transition occurs if @xmath247 jumps discontinuously as @xmath175 is varied .
what can happen is that @xmath242 can develop another maximum as a function of @xmath239 . at some value @xmath248
, one can have two peaks at the same place : @xmath249_{r = r_1 } & = & \frac{d}{dr } \left[d(r)\lambda(r , y_0)^l\right]_{r = r_2}=0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if this happens , the free energy has two minima as a function of @xmath239 .
this is the mark of a first - order transition : the internal energy will not be continuous in @xmath175 because the value of @xmath247 jumps from @xmath250 to @xmath251 as @xmath175 is varied .
we find that for @xmath252 , this indeed happens . in fig .
[ fig : free - energy ] , we plot the free energy per site @xmath253}/(3y)$ ] for values of @xmath175 just below , above , and at the transitional value @xmath254 . at the phase transition , the value of @xmath247 jumps from @xmath255 to @xmath256 .
this is small , but the transition is definitely first order , as shown in @xcite .
the transition occurs for @xmath188 , so the internal energy jumps from @xmath255 to a finite value .
no transition occurs at @xmath191 , because the saddle point is already away from @xmath257 . for any other value of @xmath25 ,
the transition is second - order as before ; no second minimum seems to occur . due to the unwieldiness of the expression ( [ lamr ] ) , we have not been able to prove this in general , but it is easy to see by looking at the curves numerically . since the first - order transition is so weak for three sites , it would indeed be surprising if the effect of the degeneracies were to overcome the behavior of the eigenvalues for larger @xmath25 . to see this in more detail ,
let us examine some limits . at large @xmath239
, the eigenvalue goes to zero as @xmath258 , while the degeneracy only grows as @xmath259 .
thus @xmath247 must be finite .
the behavior for small @xmath239 crucially depends on whether @xmath175 is greater or less than @xmath260 . for @xmath188 , @xmath261 , and
the slope at @xmath257 is negative . for @xmath195 ,
@xmath262 depends on @xmath175 and the slope at @xmath257 is positive .
the simplest behavior for @xmath188 consistent with these limits is to have @xmath263 fall off monotonically from @xmath260 to zero .
the simplest behavior for @xmath195 is for @xmath263 to rise up to a single maximum at some value @xmath241 , and then fall off to zero for large @xmath239 . by studying plots of the free energy , it seems that this simple scenario is realized for all @xmath25 larger than @xmath264 . for @xmath265 and @xmath188 , @xmath266 , so the partition function is dominated by an eigenvalue with finite @xmath18 . as @xmath175
is increased past @xmath260 , @xmath247 becomes non - zero .
there is only a single peak , so @xmath247 varies continuously with @xmath175 , so the minimum value of the free energy is also varies continuously .
this means that for @xmath265 the only phase transition is a second - order one at @xmath191 .
we are very grateful to shivaji sondhi for many interesting conversations and for collaboration on @xcite .
we are also grateful to r. moessner and n. read for helpful conversations . the work of p.f . is supported by nsf grant dmr-0104799 , a doe oji award , and a sloan foundation fellowship . o.t . is supported by nsf grant dmr-9978074 .
the jacobi polynomials @xmath267 can be expressed in terms of a rodrigues formula @xmath268\ ] ] they are defined to be orthogonal with respect to the measure @xmath269 : @xmath270 many results on jacobi polynomials can be found in @xcite .
one integral we need is @xcite @xmath271 be aware that there are ( different ) typos in this formula in both @xcite and in @xcite .
another useful result is @xmath272 using these two relations we evaluate the integral @xmath273 where @xmath274 and we use the fact that @xmath275 for @xmath276 a negative integer .
the function @xmath277 is known as kummer s series : @xmath278 the kummer function is a confluent hypergeometric function because it can be obtained by taking a limit of the hypergeometric function @xmath279 where two singularities coincide .
it satisfies the differential equation @xmath280 @xmath70 is an analytic function of @xmath281 and @xmath109 ; the only way to get singularities is to take some or all of these parameters to infinity .
a fact useful for @xmath30 magnets is that the bessel function @xmath282 can be written as @xmath283 o. tchernyshyov and s. l. sondhi , `` liquid - gas and other unusual thermal phase transitions in some large - n magnets '' [ arxiv : cond - mat/0202128 ] d. j. gross and e. witten , phys .
d * 21 * ( 1980 ) 446 .
s. hikami and t. maskawa , prog .
* 67 * ( 1982 ) 1038 .
a. d. sokal and a. o. starinets , nucl .
b * 601 * ( 2001 ) 425 [ arxiv : hep - lat/0011043 ] .
s. helgason , _ groups and geometric analysis _
( academic , 1984 ) .
n. vilenkin and a. u. klimyk , _ representation of lie groups and special functions _ ,
volume 2 ( kluwer , 1991 ) .
n. read and s. sachdev , phys .
* 66 * ( 1991 ) 1773 s. sachdev and n. read , int .
j. mod .
b * 5 * ( 1991 ) 219 ; s. sachdev , phys .
b * 45 * ( 1992 ) 12377 .
, edited by m. abramowitz and i. a. stegun ( dover , 1965 ) . c.m .
bender and s.a .
orszag , _ advanced mathematical methods for scientists and engineers _ ( mcgraw - hill , 1978 ) g. szeg , _ orthogonal polynomials _
( ams , 1975 ) bateman manuscript project , _ tables of integral transforms _ ( mcgraw - hill , 1954 ) .
i.s . gradshtein and i.m .
ryzhik , _ table of integrals , series , and products _
( academic , 1980 ) . | phase transitions can occur in one - dimensional classical statistical mechanics at non - zero temperature when the number of components @xmath0 of the spin is infinite .
we show how to solve such magnets in one dimension for any @xmath0 , and how the phase transition develops at @xmath1 .
we discuss @xmath2 and @xmath3 magnets , where the transition is second - order . in the new high - temperature phase ,
the correlation length is zero .
we also show that for the @xmath2 magnet on exactly three sites with periodic boundary conditions , the transition becomes first order . |
lynds 988e ( l988e = iras 21023 + 5002 ) was identified as one of six iras point sources ( l988a - f ) observed toward the l988 dark cloud , which is located on the edge of the cygnus ob7 molecular cloud association @xcite and which contains several bright , pre - main sequence objects .
bipolar molecular outflows were discovered @xcite to be associated with the vicinity of l988e , as well as the vicinity of l988a and l988f , and there is also high velocity co emission ( blue - shifted lobe only ) to the west of l988c .
there are two lkh@xmath0 objects and related nebulosity seen both at visible and infrared wavelengths , lkh@xmath0 324-se and lkh@xmath0 324 , the brightest cluster members of a region of @xmath250 h@xmath0 emission - line stars @xcite on the edge of the heavy extinction associated with l988e s parent molecular cloud .
most of these emission - line stars lie to the east of the molecular cloud or on its eastern edge .
lkh@xmath0 324 is a herbig ae / be ( haebe ) star , close ( in projection ) to the iras coordinate , and lkh@xmath0 324-se ( misidentified as lkh@xmath0 324 in the the herbig and bell catalog @xcite ) is probably also an haebe star @xcite .
both classical t tauri stars ( ctts ) and weak - line t tauri stars ( wtts ) are included in the emission - line stellar population .
employing an average extinction of [email protected] mag for most of the population , and measured extinctions for a few objects , @xcite estimate median ages of 0.6 and 1.7 myr for the emission - line stellar population from @xmath4 and @xmath5 photometry : for these estimates they assume evolutionary isochrones from @xcite , and @xcite respectively . in this paper
, we examine properties of the entire cluster , including both the emission - line stellar population and an obscured population to the west within the molecular cloud which we have identified here , and refer to as the embedded population . at a distance of @xmath2700
pc and a far infrared luminosity of @xmath6 , the cluster of young pre - main sequence stars associated with l988e is relatively sparse , and in the bottom quartile in far - infrared luminosity of the northern young cluster sample surveyed in @xmath1co and c@xmath7o molecular gas @xcite ( see table [ littable ] ) . despite present interest in young cluster evolution as discussed , for example , in a recent review @xcite , with the exception of papers by @xcite and @xcite ,
the young cluster associated with l988e has been relatively unstudied at infrared wavelengths to date .
hereafter we refer to the young cluster as the l988e cluster , or just l988e . in this paper , we utilize mid - infrared ( mir ) images of l988e obtained with the infrared array camera ( irac ) and 24 @xmath8 m images obtained with the multi - band imaging photometer ( mips ) on the _ spitzer _ space telescope on observations made with the spitzer space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under a contract with nasa . ]
( see a composite three - color _ spitzer _ image of the l988e region , also including l988f and c in fig .
[ 13mips_fig ] ; also see fig .
[ cover_fig ] where the various fields of view are shown on a reproduction of the poss v - band image of the region ) , as well as complementary near - infrared ( nir ) ground - based images , to identify cluster members via their infrared excess emission from protostellar envelopes , and from circumstellar disks .
the _ spatial distribution _ of identified protostars and disk objects in l988e is compared with the 850 @xmath8 m continuum maps of cold dust emission obtained with submillimeter common - user bolometer array ( scuba ) on the james clerk maxwell telescope ( jcmt ) , with dust extinction maps generated using nir data , and with a @xmath1co map of the associated molecular clouds @xcite .
these data were gathered as part of a coordinated multi - wavelength young stellar cluster survey , with the goal of providing the spatial distribution of a complete census of ysos young stellar objects ( all objects with an infrared excess , including stars with disks and protostars ) in @xmath230 nearby embedded clusters chosen from a list of 73 young groups and clusters within 1 kpc of the sun @xcite .
program clusters are representative of quite diverse star - forming regions which vary in number of cluster members , member number density , luminosity , and environment .
this coordinated study , which includes nir , mid - infrared ( mir ) , submillimeter and millimeter co imaging of the regions , is designed to advance our understanding of clustered star formation .
a comprehensive paper examining yso spatial distributions in this survey is in preparation : in a few instances , where unique data and/or characteristics distinguish the object , a separate paper is written .
here , the availability of deep nir images and a published catalog of h@xmath0 emission - line stars @xcite distinguishes this object from the others in the survey .
several authors have described efforts to define irac - only @xcite , or combined irac / mips @xcite protocols which differentiate between stars with dusty circumstellar accretion disks ( class ii ) , and protostars or objects dominated by dust emission from envelopes ( class i ) .
all class i and ii objects exhibit infrared excess over photospheric emission typical of more evolved young cluster members ( diskless or optically thin disk class iii ) as well as of foreground / background normal stars . since substantial and/or variable interstellar extinction can cause ambiguity in identification of these objects using irac - only methods @xcite , and the mips 24 @xmath8 m images may not detect the faintest ysos , a more robust classification method is required .
@xcite used seven - band photometry from @xmath9-band to irac 8.0 @xmath8 m to systematically determine de - reddened sed slopes . using this classification as a standard
, methods requiring five - band detection at @xmath9 ( 1.25 @xmath8 m ) , @xmath10 ( 1.65 @xmath8 m ) , @xmath11 ( 2.15 @xmath8 m ) , [ 3.6 ] ( 3.6 @xmath8 m ) , [ 4.5 ] ( 4.5 @xmath8 m ) , or four - band detection at @xmath10,@xmath11,[3.6 ] , [ 4.5 ] also have been demonstrated in the same publication .
here we primarily employ a combination of the five - band and four - band methods , but we also use slopes deduced from irac photometry in combination with mips 24 @xmath8 m photometry , where available , to classify protostars and transition disk objects ( objects with a pronounced inner disk gap ) in l988e .
alternate methods are exploited for the young cluster ic 348 @xcite : they utilize a simple power - law fit to the observed spectral energy distribution ( sed ) from the 4 irac bands to determine a slope @xmath12 , and as well study the sed from visual to far - infrared wavelengths for all cluster members as a function of spectral class .
nir images in the @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 wavebands of l988e were first obtained by the authors on 2002 october 26 using the simultaneous quad infrared imaging device ( sqiid ) , which houses four @xmath13 insb arrays , of which only @xmath14 are used , on the 2.1-m telescope at the kitt peak national observatory , a facility of the national optical astronomical observatory .
the plate - scale of sqiid on the 2.1-m is @xmath15 pixel@xmath16 , and the circular field of view is @xmath17 in diameter .
sqiid images , obtained in an overlapping @xmath18 grid pattern , were used to construct a mosaic comparable in size to the @xmath19 _ spitzer _ irac field of view .
twelve dithered mosaics were obtained in each band with a total exposure time of 60 s per image at @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 , leading to 720 s of exposure time . with seeing ,
the typical point spread function ( psf ) was @xmath20 fwhm at @xmath9-band and @xmath21 in the other two bands , and the 90% integrated completeness limits of the final mosaics were estimated @xcite as @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 .
however , the image quality suffered because all images exhibit position - dependent coma .
psf photometry was consequently impossible , and aperture photometry with large apertures was impractical because of the crowded field . higher spatial resolution , deep , nir observations in the @xmath9 ( 1.25 @xmath8 m ) , @xmath10 ( 1.65 @xmath8 m ) , and @xmath11 ( 2.15 @xmath8 m ) wavebands were obtained on 2004 july 6 with the palomar wide - field ir camera ( wirc ) which houses a @xmath25 hgcdte array @xcite . the plate - scale of wirc is @xmath26 pixel@xmath16 , and the field of view is @xmath27 on a side .
in addition , the psf was @xmath28 in the @xmath11 band and @xmath29 in the other two bands .
the observing sequence consisted of a large ( @xmath30 offset ) five - point dither pattern .
the 90% integrated photometric completeness limits of the final mosaics were estimated @xcite to be approximately @xmath31 , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 .
basic reduction of the sqiid nir data was performed at rochester using custom idl routines , developed by the authors , which include modules for linearization , flat - field creation and application , background frame creation and subtraction , distortion measurement and correction , and mosaicking .
point source detection and synthetic aperture photometry of all point sources were carried out using photvis version 1.09 , an idl gui - based photometry visualization tool @xcite . by visual inspection ,
those detections that were identified as structured nebulosity were considered non - stellar and rejected .
aperture photometry was performed using radii of @xmath34 , @xmath35 , and @xmath36 for the aperture , inner , and outer sky annular limits , respectively .
wirc data reduction was completed at cornell using custom idl routines and in - house image processing software . processing steps included dark subtraction , linearization , sky subtraction , flat - fielding , spatial flux gradient correction ( due to a dependency of the photometric zero point on position on the array ; jarrett personal comm . ) , and mosaicking .
aperture photometry using apphot was applied to all point sources .
radii of the apertures and inner and outer limits of the sky annuli were @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 respectively .
psf fitting was attempted , but the psf varied sharply across the images , with resulting residuals larger than obtained for the aperture photometry discussed above .
aperture photometry with larger apertures was tested , but not applied because it failed in the crowded field .
wirc photometry was calibrated by minimizing residuals to corresponding 2mass detections for selected stars with magnitudes between @xmath212 - 14 mag .
outliers were rejected from the fit ( outliers are confused or unresolved multiples in the 2mass dataset ) .
the rms scatter for the @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 waveband residuals are 0.06 , 0.07 , and 0.07 mag respectively .
@xcite showed that @xmath27% of ysos toward orion a are variable : variability may contribute to the observed scatter .
photometric magnitudes for stars which were brighter than the range of magnitudes corrected by the linearization modules were replaced with 2mass photometry .
because of the superior spatial resolution , depth , image quality , yet similar field of view of the wirc dataset , we use it for classification for all sources in l988e , and include photometry in tables [ classitable ] , [ classiitable ] , [ classtdtable ] , and [ classiiitable ] .
the sqiid dataset was used only for internal verification , and is not tabulated here . for fainter magnitudes
( 14 - 16 ) after rejecting outliers beyond 3@xmath40 , the rms scatter of the @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 waveband residuals between the sqiid and wirc datasets was 0.08 , 0.11 , and 0.11 mag respectively .
we believe the wirc photometry to be more accurate for the reasons cited above .
[ nir13co_fig ] shows a three - color ( wirc @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 ) image of the region with @xmath1co line emission contours @xcite overplotted .
visual inspection of the figure shows that the stellar density to the east of the molecular cloud is considerably higher than within the extent of the molecular cloud , as expected .
mid - infrared images were obtained with _
spitzer_/irac at 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 , and 8.0 @xmath8 m and _ spitzer_/mips at 24 @xmath8 m as part of the _ spitzer _ young stellar cluster survey .
the irac images were obtained 2004 july 27 , and each image was @xmath41 on a side with @xmath42 pixels .
they were taken in 12 s high dynamic range ( hdr ) mode , whereby a 0.4 s integration is taken , immediately followed by a 10.4 s integration at the same pointing .
four dithered 3 @xmath43 4 mosaics were obtained at each wavelength .
the typical psf is approximately @xmath44 at 3.6 and 4.5 @xmath8 m , @xmath45 at 5.8 @xmath8 m , and @xmath46 at 8.0 @xmath8 m .
ninety percent completeness limits of the final mosaics are approximately @xmath47 = 14.68 $ ] , @xmath48 = 14.67 $ ] , @xmath49 = 13.72 $ ] , and @xmath50 = 12.73 $ ] , and were evaluated using the same estimation technique as used for the nir data .
the _ spitzer_/mips 24 @xmath8 m images were obtained on 2003 december 29 , using scan mode at a medium scan rate . the total area imaged is about @xmath51 .
the typical point spread function is approximately @xmath52 , and the 90% completeness limit is @xmath53 = 8.18 $ ] .
basic reduction of the _
spitzer_/irac data was executed using the _ spitzer _ science center s basic calibrated data ( bcd ) pipelines and _ spitzer_/mips data using the post - bcd product .
the irac and mips data handbooks give complete descriptions of the calibration processes for point sources .
the irac data handbook performs calibration photometry on a set of isolated standard stars using a 10 pixel ( @xmath54 ) aperture , and 10 and 20 pixel radii of the sky annulus , but notes that considerably smaller apertures are required in crowded fields , and that small off - source sky annuli are needed when the point sources are embedded in extended emission . in those cases ,
aperture corrections are required , and the data handbook 3.0 provides aperture corrections for various standard aperture and annuli configurations for pipeline version s13 .
the same considerations apply to the mips data .
post - pipeline processing of irac data was performed at rochester using custom idl routines , developed by the authors , which include modules for bright source artifact correction , cosmic ray removal and mosaicking .
point source extraction and aperture photometry were performed using photvis version 1.09 .
radii of @xmath55 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 were used for the aperture , inner , and outer sky annular limits , respectively , for the irac data and radii of @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 were used for the aperture , inner and outer sky annular limits , respectively , for the mips data . for a gaussian psf , an aperture radius equal to the fwhm contains 93.7% of the total flux . increasing
this aperture would negligibly gain signal from the source and increases total noise from the substantial mir background emission .
the two short - wave irac detector channels , 3.6 and 4.5 @xmath8 m respectively , have approximately gaussian psfs ( other than the effects of diffraction ) , so that choosing an aperture radius approximately equal to the observed fwhm implies only a small correction because of the small aperture .
point source images for the two long - wave irac detector channels , 5.8 and 8.0 @xmath8 m respectively , do not have a gaussian psf : much of the point source intensity is scattered in bands along rows and columns , as well as over the entire array and beyond ( see data handbook and @xcite ) , but is well - characterized ( see @xcite ) .
the chosen aperture of @xmath55 only gives 63% of the source flux from a 12 @xmath60 aperture in the 8.0 @xmath8 m band . in this band ,
pah emission nebulosity is very bright and often structured , necessitating use of relatively small apertures and sky annuli .
irac photometry was calibrated using zero - magnitude flux densities of @xmath61 , and @xmath62 jy in the 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 , and 8.0 @xmath8 m bands respectively @xcite in a 10 pixel ( @xmath54 ) aperture , and aperture correction factors of 1.213 , 1.234 , 1.578 , and 1.584 respectively as tabulated in the data handbook .
mips photometry was calibrated using a zero - point flux of 7.3 jy , referenced to vega @xcite .
l988e was observed with the scuba submillimeter camera at 850 @xmath8 m on the james clerk maxwell telescope ( jcmt ) on mauna kea , hawaii over the course of 5 nights from march to august 2003 in relatively poor weather conditions ( @xmath63(225 ghz ) = 0.25 - 0.5 ) .
the data were obtained in scan - mapping mode whereby a map is built up by sweeping the telescope across the source while chopping the secondary at a series of throws , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 .
to minimize striping artifacts , each set of three sweeps was performed alternately in right ascension and declination .
the surf reduction package @xcite was used to flat - field the data , remove bad pixels , and make images .
although effective at removing the high sky and instrument background , this observing technique necessarily loses all features on scales larger than the largest chopper throw , @xmath66 .
the calibration was performed by using the same observing technique to observe one or more of mars , uranus , and standard source crl 2688 .
[ scuba13co_fig ] presents the scuba map in gray - scale , with @xmath1co contours and ysos ( see below ) overplotted .
this map is presented here for morphological comparison to cluster member spatial distributions .
we derive the a@xmath67 extinction maps using the @xmath68 colors of _ all stars _ ( 11,313 ) detected in both bandpasses , using a method outlined in more detail by @xcite .
briefly , the line of sight extinction to each point on a @xmath69 grid throughout the region surrounding the l988e core was estimated using a variation of the nearest neighbor technique . at each point
the mean and standard deviation of the @xmath70 - @xmath71 colors of the @xmath72 = 20 nearest stars to each grid point were calculated , using an iterative outlier rejection algorithm that would reject any star with an @xmath68 color @xmath73 from the mean , until the mean converged .
the assumed nir portion of the reddening law @xcite given in table [ redtable ] was used to convert the @xmath68 value at each point to a@xmath67 , using a@xmath67 = 1.82(@xmath68)@xmath74 - @xmath68)@xmath75 ) , where @xmath76 = 0.2 is assumed as an average intrinsic @xmath68 color for stars in young clusters .
further , the @xmath10 - @xmath11 map was convolved with a @xmath77 gaussian kernel to match the scuba beam size .
we compare the resultant map of a@xmath67 with the @xmath1co map from @xcite in fig .
[ ak13co_fig_ha ] .
as can be seen , the wirc - derived a@xmath67 extinction map follows the general distribution of the molecular cloud as outlined by co emission , but provides considerably greater spatial detail and extent .
if stars within the molecular cloud are included in the above analysis , a biased estimation of a@xmath67 could result . in regions where cluster members dominate the @xmath72=20 number counts
, this estimation will be lower than the line of sight extinction through the entire cloud , and thsi deviation will be larger in regions of high extinction where stars beyond the cloud can not be detected . to account for this bias
, the @xmath68 derived extinction map has been augmented with an extinction map derived by estimating a@xmath67 using scuba 850 @xmath8 m flux , and utilizing a conversion factor of a@xmath67/f@xmath78 = 0.272 mag pixel mjy@xmath16 and an assumed dust temperature of 30 k @xcite . in areas where the scuba derived a@xmath67 values
exceed the @xmath68 - derived a@xmath67 values by 30% , the scuba derived values are used .
only one small region coincident with the l988e molecular core required augmentation with scuba - derived extinction values in the wirc extinction map .
@xcite has shown that by de - reddening the nir / irac colors of young cluster stars , the irac - only classification scheme @xcite can be modified to better isolate class ii from class i objects .
briefly , @xcite reevaluated the original irac - only classification scheme by considering the sed slopes from the nir to the mir .
slopes ( @xmath0 = d log@xmath79)/d log @xmath80 ) were constructed for both measured photometry and de- reddened photometry of point sources in the cluster field of view . when de - reddened photometry was utilized on six clusters , histograms of numbers of stars vs. 2 - 8
@xmath8 m sed slope separate into 3 bins corresponding to field stars or class iii ( @xmath81 ) , class ii ( @xmath82 ) , and class i ( @xmath83 ) , ( see fig .
[ yso_class ] ) .
this figure is constructed using the reddening law discussed above @xcite , derived from irac and nir cluster data : this reddening law proved measurably different from a previously published reddening law utilizing irac and nir data @xcite that is primarily associated with reddening from dust in the diffuse interstellar medium rather than from dust in a molecular cloud .
in addition , @xcite considered classification methods using @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11,[3.6],[4.5 ] photometry as well as @xmath10 , @xmath11 , [ 3.6 ] , [ 4.5 ] photometry .
where @xmath9-band detections are available , objects are de - reddened to the ( @xmath9 - @xmath10)@xmath84 vs. ( @xmath10 - @xmath11)@xmath84 ctts locus of @xcite in the former method , or lacking a @xmath9-band detection , to the ( @xmath10 - @xmath11)@xmath84 vs.([3.6 ] - [ 4.5])@xmath84 ctts locus from @xcite in the latter .
@xcite then applied the seven - band classifications to a de - reddened ( @xmath85 - [ 3.6])@xmath84 vs. ( [ 3.6 ] - [ 4.5])@xmath84 color - color diagram , where the class i and ii objects proved to be well separated . since the 5.8 and 8.0 @xmath8 m photometry is less sensitive
, we utilize de - reddened ( see table [ redtable ] for the assumed reddening law for young clusters ) @xmath86 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 , [ 3.6 ] , [ 4.5 ] photometry to classify most objects via their location on the @xmath87)_o$ ] vs. @xmath88 - [ 4.5])_o$ ] color - color diagram : these classifications are color - coded in fig .
[ k12ccd_fig ] .
where 24 @xmath8 m data are available , objects classified as class i that have @xmath89-[24 ] ) < $ ] 4 were reclassified as class ii .
additional class i and class ii objects ( hereafter class is and class iis , similarly class iiis for class iii objects ) were identified utilizing sed slopes from irac and mips photometry , even when some objects were not detected in the @xmath10 , @xmath11 , or [ 3.6 ] bands .
in addition , there are a handful of objects with nir+irac colors of class iiis , but which exhibit a 24 @xmath8 m excess ( e.g. @xmath89 - [ 24 ] ) > $ ] 1.5 and @xmath90 - [ 24 ] ) > $ ] 1.5 ) : these objects are classified as transition disk objects , ysos characterized by a cool circumstellar disk containing a substantial inner gap .
however , it must be noted that in the absence of a large 24 @xmath8 m excess , it is difficult to distinguish primordial transition disk objects ( with ages less than a few myr ) from regenerative debris disk objects ( with ages of tens of myr to a few gyr ) .
since the field of view covered by mips ( as well as [ 3.6 ] and [ 5.8 ] ) extends farther to the west than the @xmath86 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 , [ 3.6 ] , [ 4.5 ] field , additional ysos are identified outside that field .
deep nir and mir photometric detections of ysos toward molecular clouds are contaminated by detection of extragalactic objects , including pah ( polycyclic aromatic hydro - carbon)-rich galaxies and active galactic nuclei ( agn ) , both of which have colors similar to ysos .
we account for extragalactic contamination in the following way . for objects which have detections in all four of the irac bands , we deredden each object on the assumption that it lies behind the molecular cloud , utilizing the extinction map discussed in @xmath912.4 .
we then utilize ( @xmath48 - [ 5.8]$ ] ) vs. ( @xmath49 - [ 8.0]$ ] ) and ( @xmath47 - [ 5.8]$ ] ) vs. ( @xmath48 - [ 8.0]$ ] ) color - color diagrams to identify the pah - rich galaxy contaminants and the @xmath48 $ ] vs. ( @xmath48 - [ 8.0]$ ] ) color - magnitude diagram to identify the agn contaminants . the prescriptions for identification are described in detail by @xcite . for objects which only have @xmath92[4.5]$ ] photometry , we are unable to directly use those prescriptions to identify extragalactic contaminants . instead ,
inspection of the histogram of de - reddened @xmath47 $ ] magnitudes for the objects with an infrared excess utilizing the @xmath92[4.5]$ ] classification scheme ( fig .
[ ch1_hist ] ) shows a bifurcation in the distribution at @xmath47 $ ] = 13.5 .
objects with @xmath47 $ ] @xmath93 13.5 are considered as potential ysos , while objects with @xmath47 $ ] @xmath94 13.5 are considered as potential extragalactic contaminants and are rejected as potential ysos .
this scheme is in agreement with previous work stating that at magnitudes fainter than about 14 , extragalactic objects dominate number counts @xcite . in order to quantify this further
, we examine the differential number counts for sources detected in the botes region in the flamingos extragalactic survey @xcite . at @xmath47 $ ] = 13.5 ( fig . [ ch1_hist ] ) , and a mean de - reddened @xmath95)_o$ ] color of 0.79 ( typical of ysos ) , this bifurcation magnitude corresponds to @xmath11 = 14.29 . from fig . 8 in @xcite
, we estimate that there are approximately 10 extragalactic sources within our field of view at @xmath11 = 14.29 , and the number rapidly increases to fainter magnitudes .
since we are examining the spatial distribution as well as the disk fraction of the l988e population of ysos , both in - cloud and off - cloud , we want to minimize the possibility of contamination by extragalactic objects .
an examination of the @xmath11 vs. @xmath96 color - magnitude diagram ( fig .
[ kvkmh ] ) shows that even excluding @xmath9714.29 , we are still capable of detecting relatively low mass ysos .
faint cluster members ( below the hydrogen burning limit at a@xmath98=0 ) will also be excluded by these criteria : therefore brown dwarf cluster members will not be considered further .
spectroscopy is the best way to make firm brown dwarf identifications , and beyond the scope of this paper . before removing extragalactic contaminants ,
there are a total of 2293 objects in a 14.7@xmath99 field with detections in all four bands ( @xmath10,@xmath11,[3.6],[4.5 ] ) meeting the criterion that the photometric uncertainties are less than 0.1 mag in all bandpasses .
following application of the extragalactic contamination criteria noted above , there remain a total of 678 objects in the nir + irac dataset : these objects will be discussed in the following sections . of these , three are class is , 69 class iis , seven are transition disk objects , and 599 are class iiis or field stars with no obvious infrared excess . when sed slopes were computed for objects in the same field of view with only irac and/or mips detections , an additional five class is , three class iis , and 36 class iiis were found .
further , there is one object detected in only the 4.5 , 5.8 , 8.0 , and 24 @xmath8 m wavebands .
from the 4.5 - 24 @xmath8 m sed slope for this object , @xmath0=0.98 , we characterize it as class i. as discussed earlier , a total of six transition disk objects are also classified based on their ( [ 5.8 ] - [ 24 ] ) or ( [ 8 ] - [ 24 ] ) colors . in fig .
[ irac_fig ] we present a three - color irac image ( @xmath47 , [ 4.5 ] , [ 8.0]$ ] ) of the l988e region , with wirc + irac class i and ii classifications overplotted , and in tables [ classitable ] , [ classiitable ] , [ classtdtable ] , and [ classiiitable ] we present a catalog of identified objects .
the mips field of view extends far to the northwest of l988e , to include l988c , as noted above .
fortunately , irac data in two of the four bands ( 3.6 and 5.8 @xmath8 m ) were obtained to the northwest of l988e . from 3 - 24
@xmath8 m sed slopes in combination with nir data , a total of 19 class is , 73 class iis , and 643 class iiis / field stars were found in the 14.7@xmath100 field . a three - color irac + mips image ( @xmath47 , [ 5.8 ] , [ 24]$ ] ) of the extended l988e region
was presented in fig .
[ 13mips_fig ] .
early studies of the emission - line stellar populations in molecular clouds led to the classical t tauri star ( ctts ) and the weak t tauri star ( wtts ) definitions @xcite in terms of their h@xmath0 equivalent widths ew[h@xmath0 ] .
although the wttss usually show weaker h@xmath0 emission , limited both in level and profile width ( from chromospheric emission ) , cttss exhibit strong emission lines , with broad profiles , generated in the accretion process . by 1988 ,
the ctts classification was taken to be ew[h@xmath0 ] @xmath102 10 . however , in a recent study of low mass stars , @xcite suggest an empirical relationship for the critical ew[h@xmath0 ] value as a function of spectral type for low mass stars . using the presence of optical veiling to identify accretion , they propose the following improved scheme of ctts classification for spectral classes later than k0 : ew[h@xmath0 ] @xmath102 3 , for k0-k5 ; ew[h@xmath0 ] @xmath102 10 , for k7-m2.5 ; ew[h@xmath0 ] @xmath102 20 , for m3-m5.5 ; and ew[h@xmath0 ] @xmath102 40 , for m6-m7.5 . in
what follows , we first use the single equivalent width classification of ctts / wtts , and then examine whether this analysis would change appreciably with the @xcite modification . in fig .
[ ak13co_fig_ha ] , cluster stars , including the haebe emission - line stars in this cluster identified by @xcite , are overplotted on an image of the extinction at @xmath11-band ( see @xmath912.4 ) . each object in fig .
[ ak13co_fig_ha ] is coded by yso classification , deduced as outlined in @xmath913 above : green squares ( class ii ) , red squares ( class i ) , blue squares ( transition disk objects ) .
filled squares denote ysos that are h@xmath0 emission - line objects .
of course , with h@xmath0 emission line measurements , the degeneracy between field stars and pre - main sequence class iii cluster members is broken , so that class iiis with h@xmath0 emission can be identified ( blue @xmath43 s ) . the bright haebe stars
lkh@xmath0 324-se ( v=15.36 , a@xmath3 10 ) and lkh@xmath0 324 ( v= 12.61 , a@xmath98 = 3.75 ) are identified by us as class i and class ii , respectively . even though the @xmath11-band error for lkh@xmath0 324 is slightly above our error threshold ( error = 0.108 , threshold = 0.1 ) we chose to include this object because of its prominence in the cluster .
most of the cluster associated with the emission - line stars lies in a region of low extinction to the east of the molecular cloud , or on the eastern edge of the cloud , where there is modest extinction , although there are bright , heavily extinguished members in the sample . in fig .
[ slope_width_fig ] , the h@xmath0 equivalent width ew[h@xmath0 ] , a proxy for accretion strength @xcite , is plotted against the de - reddened sed slope from irac 3.6 to 8.0 @xmath8 m photometry for the 41 emission - line stars common to the list from @xcite and to our nir + irac dataset with uncertainties @xmath103 0.1 mag in all four irac bands . a vertical line at ew[h@xmath0 ] = 10 divides the plot into the single - value estimate of wtts ( @xmath93 10 ) and ctts ( @xmath102 10 ) . in their study of members of the young cluster
ic 348 , @xcite show that diskless stars ( class iii ) exhibit an irac determined sed slope of @xmath93 -2.56 , stars with optically thick disks exhibit slopes @xmath94 -1.8 , and they define sources with sed slopes between -1.8 and -2.56 to be ` anemic ' disk objects ( this class includes transition disk objects , optically thin disks etc . ) : we have adopted these parameters in fig . [ slope_width_fig ] .
generally , class iis ( or is ) in l988e with optically thick disks show the strongest h@xmath0 equivalent widths , as they do in ic 348 ( see also @xcite who correlated @xmath104 excess emission from optically thick disks with large ew[h@xmath0 ] ) . in order to compare our results with earlier studies ,
we have indicated by color our class i , ii , and iii classifications .
although there is a general correlation of class ii / i with strong h@xmath0 equivalent widths in l988e , the figure also shows three stars with h@xmath0 equivalent widths @xmath94 10 , but slopes indicating class iii according to the above definition , and three with h@xmath0 equivalent widths clearly @xmath93 10 , but slopes indicating thick disks ( class ii ) .
there are five objects in the anemic disk region .
since six objects do not obey the correlation described above , we now determine whether use of the single - valued h@xmath0 equivalent width definition of ctts / wtts is the cause of the departure . in the absence of spectroscopy for these 41 l988e cluster members , we made rough estimates of the emission line stars spectral types from their measured ( @xmath4-@xmath5 ) colors @xcite for objects where good @xmath4 and @xmath5 photometry was available . in order to do so
, we first confirm that spectral types determined from @xmath4 and @xmath5 photometry can be roughly calibrated for stars with disks in young clusters .
the @xcite study of cluster members in ic 348 included published spectroscopic data , and they provide a table of median star - disk spectral energy distributions at wavelengths from @xmath4-band to 24 @xmath8 m , all with a reddening of a@xmath3 2.5 , as a function of nine spectral type intervals . from their table , we confirm that the @xmath105 colors of both stars and objects with disks are sufficiently close for spectral typing into the nine intervals .
we also examined the @xmath106 colors for the same median star - disk population in ic 348 @xcite , and found nir colors to be unsatisfactory for rough spectral typing of ysos , because , as expected , those colors can vary widely for photospheres , stars with ` anemic disks ' and stars with thick disks .
thirty - seven of the 41 emission line stars in l988e referred to above have good @xmath4 and @xmath5 photometry .
we first de - redden the @xmath4 and @xmath5 magnitudes using our determined values of a@xmath67 , and assuming a@xmath98/a@xmath67 = 10 ( values of this ratio can vary by up to 30% @xcite ) .
although @xcite used a single value for a@xmath98 ( 2.5 ) with only a few exceptions , we found considerable variation in a@xmath67 for these stars .
thus @xmath105 colors were estimated for these 37 emission - line stars , and 62% are later than k7 as determined from those colors and the rough spectral type calibration . applying the @xcite criterion for ctts / wtts classification as a function of rough spectral type
, we found that 6 of the 37 objects yielded a different ctts / wtts classification than with the single - valued h@xmath0 equivalent width definition of ctts / wtts .
these are indicated on fig .
[ slope_width_fig ] with the appropriate symbol encircled , and color - coded ( green circle implies ctts is the correct classification rather than wtts , and a blue circle implies wtts rather than ctts ) .
the resultant correlation of class iii with wtts and class ii with ctts is superior to that obtained using the single - valued h@xmath0 equivalent width discriminator .
three transition disk objects are identified and are indicated by a blue square .
one of these is an anemic disk and one is a thick disk object .
the remaining transition disk object is found slightly below the -2.56 slope delineation , rather than above , so is marginally non - compliant with the correlation discussed above .
there are two additional objects which fall in the anemic disk region .
overall , the correlation of ctts / wtts to class ii / class iii is excellent once the revision to the equivalent width ctts / wtts definition proposed by @xcite is applied .
we now examine the statistics of the emission - line population .
in addition to the 41 objects discussed above , there are four h@xmath0 objects which do not have detections in all four irac bands and six which do have detections , but with uncertainties in irac bands @xmath94 0.1 mag .
there are also two emission - line objects in common with our irac ( 3.6 and 5.8 @xmath8 m ) + mips dataset in the vicinity of l988c . of those objects with h@xmath0 emission , 28 are class iis , two are transition disk objects , 19 are class iiis , and two are class
of the two in common with our irac ( 3.6 and 5.8 @xmath8 m ) + mips dataset , one is determined to be class i , and the other is determined to be class ii from their 3 - 24 @xmath8 m sed slopes and @xmath89-[24])$ ] colors . from these results , the disk fraction of _
just _ the emission - line population with nir + irac counterparts is 67% @xmath10720% including five which could be described as ` anemic disks ' @xcite based on irac sed slopes or mips 24 @xmath8 m detections .
this percentage is consistent with either of the two age estimates cited by @xcite , namely 0.6 and 1.7 myr , using the curve of disk fraction to age from @xcite .
young cluster environments are permeated by dust associated with the natal molecular cloud , providing extinction as well as the cool dust emission detected at submillimeter wavelengths .
all of the figures describing the molecular cloud will be used in the following discussion of the spatial distribution of the identified ysos ( figs .
[ nir13co_fig ] , [ scuba13co_fig ] , and [ ak13co_fig_ha ] ) .
the dust and molecular gas are distributed non - uniformly , and in order to characterize that distribution for comparison with the yso distribution , we map the extinction ( a@xmath67 ) in the neighborhood of l988e .
the peak of the scuba 850 @xmath8 m emission ( fig .
[ scuba13co_fig ] ) coincides with the peak intensity of @xmath1co emission , although a ne extension of the submillimeter emission does not have a parallel in the low spatial resolution molecular map : since the intensity of the emission varies on scales larger than the map size ( @xmath41 ) outside the peak , there is no information on the larger scale dust emission due to the iterative way the map is built , assuming that the edges chop into zero emission .
thus the scuba - measured emission is not ideal for illustrating the extent of the molecular cloud . despite adequately mapping the extent of the cloud , available low spatial resolution ( @xmath108 beam size ) co emission line maps @xcite are also not ideal for comparing the dust distribution with the yso distribution .
in addition to inadequate spatial resolution , there are issues associated with low signal to noise in diffuse regions ( c@xmath7o ) , and optical depth issues leading to saturation in dense cores ( @xmath1co ) , as well as co depletion due to chemistry and/or freeze - out in dense cores , and/or varying excitation temperature .
although we could in principle utilize the iras 100 @xmath8 m hires map of the dust emission , it is more useful to use the higher spatial resolution @xmath68-derived extinction maps described in @xmath912 to compare the extended dust distribution with the yso distribution .
note that the map of a@xmath67 ( fig .
[ ak13co_fig_ha ] ) , at the same spatial resolution as the scuba map , shows the ne extension from the core indicating higher dust density , as seen by scuba .
in addition , there are many small regions of enhanced extinction , and the extent of the molecular cloud defined by the a@xmath67 map exceeds that suggested by the co maps .
all cloud tracers show an abrupt eastern edge to the cloud , which bifurcates the central cluster into the relatively high surface density population embedded within the cloud core , and the somewhat lower surface density population outside the cloud .
this edge was likely produced by the two haebe stars : as stated by @xcite , lkh@xmath0 324 and 324se ` have excavated a cavity on that edge and cleared out the area to the east , thereby exposing a small cluster of h@xmath0 emission - line stars . '
classification of ysos was executed as described in @xmath913 .
we now examine the spatial distribution of the class is and iis so identified , first by overplotting their positions on a variety of images : namely , the ir images , the co image , the cold dust emission images , and primarily , the extinction map . although the overall _ stellar _ density in the composite nir image ( fig .
2 ) is substantially lower toward the molecular cloud , the peak surface density of ysos is found toward the molecular cloud core , as identified by all of the molecular cloud tracers .
lkh@xmath0324 and lkh@xmath0324se are associated with that high density region , which we call the ` embedded ' population of the cluster . to illustrate this more clearly , yso surface density distributions
are formed for all ysos , utilizing the method developed for ngc 7129 , ggd12 - 15 , and iras20050 + 2720 , three clusters previously studied in the young cluster project @xcite . because there exists a wide range in stellar surface densities over a young cluster , a method which utilizes adaptive smoothing lengths allows both the highest and lowest stellar density regions to be probed . at each sample position [ @xmath109 in a uniform grid the projected radial distance to the @xmath72th nearest star , @xmath110 is measured , and the local surface density @xmath111 is calculated . here
the grid size is 3@xmath112 , and @xmath72 = 5 .
a value of @xmath113 is chosen to retain sufficient spatial resolution .
on the other hand @xcite , @xmath72 must be as small as feasible to allow small , high density sub - groups to be properly represented .
also see @xcite .
the grid size selection of 3@xmath112 was chosen to fully resolve all structure at the smallest scales ( i.e. highest densities ) in the @xmath72 = 5 density distribution .
the surface density of ysos is compared with a scuba gray - scale image in fig .
[ scubaysocontours_fig ] of the cool dust ridge associated with the edge of the molecular cloud .
the surface density contours reveal an asymmetric cluster , with the highest surface density region ( peaking at @xmath2 1706 stars pc@xmath114 ) , including mostly class iis , concentrated at the peak of the dust emission .
lkh@xmath0 324 is located on the northern edge of this region and lkh@xmath0 324 se lies on the eastern edge . a second , less compact surface density region associated with the emission - line population ( peaking at @xmath2 747 stars pc@xmath114 )
is found to the east of the dust ridge : these are also primarily class ii objects ( note that class iii objects are not included in this figure , whereas in the emission - line selected population @xcite overplotted on the map of a@xmath67 in fig .
[ ak13co_fig_ha ] , both class ii and iii stars are included ) .
this population falls in the cavity where the molecular cloud has been excavated , presumably by the bright haebe stars lkh@xmath0 324 and 324 se .
we call this the ` exposed ' cluster population
. the exposed population of the asymmetric cluster may be somewhat older than the embedded population , as suggested by the relatively lower yso stellar densities encountered , as well as the necessity that enough time has passed to sculpt the cloud in the vicinity of the exposed cluster .
we examine this further in the next section by estimating disk fractions for the exposed and embedded populations in a circular region surrounding the surface density peaks , using standard methods .
in addition to these concentrated distributions of ysos , in both the excavated cavity , and in the dense molecular knot , a distributed halo of ysos is found mainly in the diffuse portions of the associated molecular cloud , and another to the east of the cloud .
these haloes include predominantly class iis , but the presence of class is in the diffuse molecular cloud is important to note .
a much larger study focusing on the distributed population of ysos well beyond the clusters , particularly the class is , is underway .
there we hope to determine whether the class is in the distributed population formed in situ , or were ejected from the clusters .
we show in this section that @xmath255@xmath10716% of the objects in a 1.5@xmath115 diameter circle centered at [ 21@[email protected]@xmath118 , 50@xmath11914@[email protected] ] are class iis : this region corresponds to the peak of the _ exposed _ population of the cluster ( here we have purposely not included the emission - line objects associated with substantial extinction at the edge of the l988e dark cloud , or the extended diffuse halo population , in contrast to the treatment in @xmath914 ) . this disk fraction , while estimated more rigorously than in @xmath914 , entails only a relatively small number of stars because l988e is sparsely populated .
in contrast , the disk fraction in a similar sized region centered on the _ embedded _
population s peak density ( centered at [ 21@[email protected]@xmath118 , 50@xmath12014@[email protected] ] ) is @xmath274@xmath10715% . at face value
, the higher mean disk fraction indicates the embedded population is younger than the exposed population , however , because of small number statistics , the large uncertainties overlap , so we can not be certain of the relative ages of the regions .
disk fractions were estimated in the following manner .
@xmath11-band magnitude histograms ( kmh ) were created for 1.5@xmath115 diameter regions around the peaks of the exposed and embedded populations and for three 3@xmath115 diameter regions off cloud that do not contain any known protostars , stars with disks , or h@xmath0 emission objects ( see fig .
[ cover_fig ] for the locations of these regions and fig .
[ k_hist ] for the histograms ) . to determine the magnitude at which field star contamination , begins to dominate the cluster kmh , we consider the faintest magnitude bin in the cluster kmh greater than 3@xmath122 , assuming poisson counting statistics for each magnitude bin in the kmhs .
this limit occurs at 14@xmath123 magnitude .
the average @xmath124-band extinction for the exposed population , the off - cloud regions , and the embedded population are a@xmath67 = 0.37 , a@xmath67 = 0.28 , and a@xmath67 = 1.3 , respectively , estimated from @xmath9,@xmath10,@xmath11 , colors as above ( @xmath913 ) . to account for the higher extinction toward the embedded population , the off - cloud sources are artificially extinguished to the mean extinction of the embedded population before subtracting the off - cloud kmh from the embedded population kmh . by subtracting the off - cloud kmh from the exposed population kmh for the magnitude bins less than the 14@xmath123 magnitude limit , we estimate 22 cluster members in the exposed population , and 19 cluster members in the embedded population : these values are used in the disk fraction determination above .
we restrict comparison of l988e to six young clusters @xcite which have been studied in many of the same ways as l988e , although l988e is the only cluster with exposed stars which have been studied for h@xmath0 emission . of
those six , two filamentary clusters , ggd12 - 15 and iras 20050 + 2720 , have the following properties : the class is follow closely the asymmetric distribution defined by the dust ridges in their respective molecular clouds , while the class iis are more dispersed along the filament .
the two clusters widely vary in far - ir luminosity and cloud mass , and range from moderate to relatively high spatial density ( @xmath2 1200 and 3000 pc@xmath114 peak respectively ) .
ggd 12 - 15 has 102 ysos , of which 25% are class i , while iras 20050 + 2720 has 121 yso members , of which 21% are class i : class
i number counts may be biased toward lower numbers due to the lack of mips coverage when these regions were analyzed .
two other clusters , ngc 7129 and afgl 490 , are more diffuse than the filamentary clusters , with little high density clustering and little asymmetric structure .
there are a total of 63 and 98 ysos respectively in ngc 7129 and afgl 490 , of which 17% and 13% are class i respectively , with the same bias toward lower class i number counts due to lack of mips coverage .
yso spatial distribution in the l988e exposed cluster is similar to that in the latter two clusters , especially to that of ngc 7129 : in particular , a large population of class iis clustered in a cavity in the molecular cloud near a be star lkh@xmath0234 , resembles the exposed population discussed here .
however , l988e does exhibit some asymmetry , and there is a substantial number of class is in the l988e embedded cluster population .
the distribution of class is resembles those in ggd12 - 15 and iras 20050 + 2720 : class is are found in both the high density dusty region near lkh@xmath0 324 and 324-se , and throughout the rest of the molecular cloud .
however , in contrast to ggd12 - 15 and iras 20050 + 2720 ,
only 10% of the 79 class i and ii objects identified by irac and mips in all of l988e are class i. of these four clusters , only iras 20050 + 2720 has comparable fir luminosity to l988e : the other three are @xmath2 6 - 30 times more luminous .
ngc 7129 is estimated to be @xmath2 3 myr in age , while the filamentary clusters are thought to be younger .
the final two young clusters studied in this way , cepa and monr2 , have an order of magnitude higher fir luminosity , but are otherwise different from each other .
monr2 exhibits a filamentary distribution of 49 class is ( 20% of the total ) similar to that observed for ggd12 - 15 and iras 20050 + 2720 , whereas cepa is sparsely populated by 8 class is ( only 9% of total ysos ) while the 77 class iis are anti - associated with co density enhancements .
a comprehensive spatial distribution study of the entire young cluster survey is in preparation .
spitzer _ photometry of the asymmetric l988e cluster in combination with new nir photometry reveals the presence of an embedded population associated with the molecular cloud ( the cloud is defined by co emission , cool dust emission , and a@xmath67 maps of extinction ) .
this is in addition to the previously studied exposed region of the cluster , associated with the optically studied h@xmath0 emission - line stars in a cloud cavity on the eastern edge , sculpted presumably by the haebe stars lkh@xmath0 324 and lkh@xmath0 324 se .
the disk fraction ( class ii/(class ii + class iii ) of only the emission - line objects , primarily located in the exposed region , is @xmath2 67% .
this is consistent with either of the two age estimates deduced from @xmath4 and @xmath5 photometry @xcite .
the embedded population exhibits larger surface density than the exposed population of the cluster , and is fully enshrouded within l988e s natal molecular cloud .
this , as well as the higher @xmath125 disk fraction calculated in the conventional way for all cluster members in the field ( 74% vs. 55% ) points to the probability of a somewhat younger age for the embedded population as compared with the exposed population , although the uncertainties of these disk fractions overlap . the exposed population of the cluster lies primarily in a region where the extinction a@xmath126 0.5 mag . on the other hand ,
the embedded population suffers a peak extinction of a@xmath67 = 3 , and extinctions a@xmath127 0.5 throughout the molecular cloud
in addition to the asymmetric cluster , there exists a diffuse halo population of ysos surrounding both the exposed and embedded regions of the cluster .
although the halo is dominated by class iis , class is are also found in the diffuse halo . whether these halo objects are formed in situ
is yet to be determined .
\5 . comparing these populations to six regions in the young cluster program studied in a similar manner @xcite
, we confirm the conclusion that the spatial distribution within the cluster is not strongly coupled to either the fir luminosity or the numbers of cluster members .
the younger clusters more faithfully follow the cloud density structure in which the cluster is born , and exhibit higher surface density . therefore , l988e is older than the youngest clusters in the survey because the eastern part of the cloud has had time to be excavated .
it is becoming increasingly obvious that class is are found in the haloes around clusters in regions where the molecular column density is relatively low .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac infrared science archive , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
this publication makes use of data products from the two micron all sky survey , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the national science foundation .
jpw acknowledges support from nsf grant ast-0324323 , and jlp support from sao / jpl sv4 - 74011 .
lada06 allen , l. e. , calvet , n. , dalessio , p. , merin , b. , hartmann , l. , megeath , s. t. , gutermuth , r. a. , muzerolle , j. , pipher , j. l. , myers , p. c. ; fazio , g. g. 2004 , , 154 , 363 baraffe , i. , et al .
, 1998 , , 337 , 403 clark , f. o. , 1986 , a&a , 164 , l19 carpenter , j. m. , 2001 , , 121 , 2851 dobashi , k. , bernard , j. , yonekura , y.fukui , y. , 2004 , , 95 , 419 dantona , f. & mazzitelli , i. , 1997 , cool stars in clusters and associations , ed . g. micela & r. pallavicini ( firenzw : soc . astr
. italiana ) , 807 elston , r. , j. , et al .
, 2006 , , 639 , 816 fazio , g. , g. , et al . , 2004 , , 154 , 39 flaherty , k. et al . , 2007 ,
apj . in press glass , i. , handbook of infrared astronomy ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) gutermuth , r. a. , megeath , s. t.,muzerolle , j. , allen , l. e. , pipher , j. l. , myers , p. c. , fazio , g. g. , 2004 , , 154 , 374 gutermuth , r. a. , 2005 , phd , university of rochester gutermuth , r.a . , megeath , s.t . ,
pipher , j.l . ,
williams , j.p . , allen , l.e . ,
myers , p.c . & raines , s.n .. , 2005 , , 632 , 397 gutermuth , r.a .
et al . , 2007 , in preparation .
hartmann , l. , 1998 , accretion processes in star formation , ( cambridge university press : cambridge ) , p. 124 .
herbig , g. h. & bell , k. r. , 1988 , lick obs .
bull , n.1111 , 1 herbig , g.h . & daum , s.e .
, 2006 , , 131 , 1530 .
hernandez , j. , hartmann , l. , megeath , t. , gutermuth , r. , muzerolle , j. , calvet , n. , vivas , a.k .
, briceno , c. , allen , l. , stauffer , j. , young , e. , and fazio , g. , submitted to apj .
hodapp , k. , 1994 , , 94 , 615 indebetouw , r. , mathis , j. s. , babler , b.l . ,
meade , m. r. , watson , c. , whitney , b. a. , wolff , m. j. , wolfire , m. g. , cohen , m . ,
bania , t. m. , and 10 coauthors , 2005 , , 619 , 9311 jenness , t. , lightfoot , j. f. , holland , w. s.1998 , spie 3357 , 548 lada , c. j. , & lada e. a. , 2003 , , 41 , 57 lada , c. j. , et al . , 2006 , , 131 , 1574 meyer , m. r. , calvet , n. , & hillenbrand , l. a. , 1997 , , 114 , 288 muzerolle , j. , megeath , s. t.,gutermuth , r. a. , allen , l. e. , pipher , j. l. , hartmann , l. , gordon , k. d. , padgett , d .
l. , noriega - crespo , a. , myers , p. c. , fazio , g. g. , rieke , g. h. , young , e. t.,morrison , j. e. , hines , d. c. , su , k. y. l. , engelbracht , c. w. , misselt , k. a.,2004 , , 154 , 379 pipher , j. l. , et al . , 2004 ,
spie 5487 , 234 porras , a. , christopher , m. , allen , l. , difrancesco , j. , megeath , s. t. , myers , p. c. , 2003 , , 126 , 1916 reach , w.t . , megeath , s.t . ,
cohen , m. , hora , j. , carey , s. , surace , j. , willner , s.p .
, barmby , p. , wilson , g. , glaccum , w. , lowrance , p. , marengo , m. , and fazio , g.g . , 2005 , , 117 , 978 .
ridge , n. a .. wilson , t. l. , megeath , s. t.,allen , l. e. , myers , p. c. , 2003 , , 126 , 286 .
siess , l. , dufour , e. , & forestini , m. 2000 , a&a , 358 , 593 science center .
2005 , multiband imaging photometer for _ spitzer _ ( mips ) data handbook ( pasadena : ssc ) , http://ssc.spitzer.caltech.edu/mips/dh/ white , r. j. & basri , g. 2003 , , 582 , 1109 whitney , b. a. , wood , k. , bjorkman , j. e.,cohen , m. , 2003 , , 598 , 1079 whitney , b. a. , et al . , 2004 , ,
154 , 315 wilson , j. c. , eikenberry , s. s. , henderson , c .
p. , hayward , t. l. , carson , j. c. ; pirger , b. barry , d. j. , brandl , b. r.,houck , j. r. , fitzgerald , g. j. , stolberg , t. m. , 2003 , spie , 4841 , 451 21:02:[email protected] & 50:18:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & -0.41 & & + 21:02:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & -0.48 & 623 & 26 .
+ 21:02:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & 0.020 & & + 21:02:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & 0.960 & & + 21:02:[email protected] & 50:11:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & -0.37 & & + 21:02:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & 0.080 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:21:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & 0.800 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & -0.04 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & -0.47 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & 0.470 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:09:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & -0.05 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & -0.25 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & -0.40 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:11:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 1.040 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.09 & -0.64 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.98 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:16:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 2.720 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 1.14 & 0.580 & 651 & 159 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.68 & -0.03 & 657 & 69 .
+ 21:02:[email protected] & 50:11:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & -0.66 & 624 & 29 .
+ 21:02:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & [email protected] & & -0.62 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & -1.16 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & -1.78 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2.15 & -0.70 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:09:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.53 & -2.64 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:17:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 3.56 & -1.25 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:11:[email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & -1.65 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.87 & -1.37 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 1.81 & -2.64 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2.31 & -1.26 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.07 & -1.14 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:11:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.47 & -0.90 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:16:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.40 & -1.38 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 2.31 & -2.01 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.14 & -1.41 & 631 & 55 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 3.26 & -1.55 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.18 & -1.49 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.77 & -1.36 & 632 & 39 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:16:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 1.46 & & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.99 & -1.19 & 633 & 156 + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.09 & -1.52 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:08:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.15 & -1.62 & 635 & 4.2 + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.87 & -0.49 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:11:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.19 & -1.06 & 637 & 19 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.97 & -0.91 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.27 & -1.71 & 638 & 28 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:16:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.95 & -1.72 & 639 & 6.8 + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.22 & -1.24 & 640 & 86 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 1.94 & & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 3.29 & -1.62 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 1.33 & -1.00 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 0.25 & & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:17:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.44 & -1.21 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:16:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.47 & -1.44 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 1.44 & & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 0.28 & & 643 & 43 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 1.06 & -0.84 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & 0.00 & & & 11 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 0.45 & & 644 & 15 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 1.47 & -2.06 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.49 & -0.16 & 645 & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 1.24 & & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.95 & -0.57 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.00 & -1.89 & 647 & 19 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.24 & & 648 & 31 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 0.06 & & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 2.75 & & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.35 & & 649 & 233 + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.33 & -1.47 & 652 & 53 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.75 & -1.02 & 654 & 53 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.11 & -0.96 & 655 & 98 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:17:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 1.39 & -2.93 & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:17:[email protected] & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & 2.40 & & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:17:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.58 & -1.15 & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.00 & -1.03 & 658 & 4.1 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.23 & -0.99 & 659 & 183 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & 0.27 & & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.26 & -0.58 & 660 & 121 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 0.13 & & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.12 & -0.23 & 663 & 12 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.65 & -0.81 & 664 & 9.6 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.03 & -0.84 & 666 & 46 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.00 & -0.93 & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.28 & -1.34 & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:16:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.53 & -1.01 & 670 & 28 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.73 & -0.74 & 671 & 161 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.04 & -1.38 & 672 & 101 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:18:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.32 & -1.04 & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.41 & -1.33 & 673 & 17 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.27 & -1.38 & 676 & 26 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.05 & -1.27 & 681 & 35 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:16:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 1.41 & -0.57 & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:18:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.20 & -1.15 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.88 & -1.88 & & + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.59 & -2.67 & 641 & 17 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.38 & -2.40 & 650 & 37 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:07:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.85 & -2.52 & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.36 & -1.43 & 674 & 12 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:16:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.48 & -1.17 & & + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.03 & -2.19 & & + llccccccccccccc 21:03:[email protected] & 50:19:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & 0.29 & & 628 & 1.3 + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.00 & -2.68 & 629 & 3.9 + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:20:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.12 & -2.60 & 630 & 3.5 + 21:03:[email protected] & 50:10:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.50 & -2.77 & 636 & 11 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.59 & -2.67 & 641 & 17 .
+ 21:03:[email protected] & 50:12:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0.38 & -2.40 & 650 & 37 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & 0.29 & & 656 & 9.5 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.39 & -2.33 & 662 & 4.5 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.25 & -2.61 & 665 & 19 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.50 & -2.80 & 667 & 1.8 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.21 & -2.56 & 668 & 8.6 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.39 & -2.78 & 669 & 8.6 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:14:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.22 & -2.77 & 675 & 2.7 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:09:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.07 & -2.53 & 677 & 5.1 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.27 & -2.83 & 678 & 4.3 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:20:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.74 & -2.44 & 679 & 35 .
+ 21:04:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.00 & -2.48 & 680 & 2.1 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:15:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.23 & -2.69 & 682 & 2.1 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.26 & -2.71 & 683 & 4.8 + 21:04:[email protected] & 50:13:[email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & 0.17 & -2.83 & 684 & 8.1 + | we present _ spitzer _ images of the relatively sparse , low luminosity young cluster l988e , as well as complementary near - infrared ( nir ) and submillimeter images of the region .
the cluster is asymmetric , with the western region of the cluster embedded within the molecular cloud , and the slightly less dense eastern region to the east of , and on the edge of , the molecular cloud . with these data , as well as with extant h@xmath0 data of stars primarily found in the eastern region of the cluster , and a molecular @xmath1co gas emission map of the entire region , we investigate the distribution of forming young stars with respect to the cloud material , concentrating particularly on the differences and similarities between the exposed and embedded regions of the cluster .
we also compare star formation in this region to that in denser , more luminous and more massive clusters already investigated in our comprehensive multi - wavelength study of young clusters within 1 kpc of the sun . |
epidemic models are classically phrased in ordinary differential equation ( ode ) systems for the host population divided in classes of susceptible individuals and infected ones ( sis system ) , or in addition , a class of recovered individuals due to immunity after an infection to the respective pathogen ( sir epidemics ) .
the infection term includes a product of two variables , hence a non - linearity which in extended systems can cause complicated dynamics . though these simple sis and sir models only show fixed points as equilibrium solutions , they already show non - trivial equilibria arising from bifurcations , and in stochastic versions of the system critical fluctuations at the threshold .
further refinements of the sir model in terms of external forcing or distinction of infections with different strains of a pathogen , hence classes of infected with one or another strain recovered from one or another strain , infected with more than one strain etc .
, can induce more complicated dynamical attractors including equilibria , limit cycles , tori and chaotic attractors .
classical examples of chaos in epidemiological models are childhood diseases with extremely high infection rates , so that a moderate seasonal forcing can generate feigenbaum sequences of period doubling bifurcations into chaos .
the success in analysing childhood diseases in terms of modelling and data comparison lies in the fact that they are just childhood diseases with such high infectivity .
otherwise host populations can not sustain the respective pathogens .
in other infectious diseases much lower forces of infection have to be considered leading to further conceptual problems with noise affecting the system more than the deterministic part , leading even to critical fluctuations with power law behaviour , when considering evolutionary processes of harmless strains of pathogens versus occasional accidents of pathogenic mutants @xcite . only explicitly stochastic models , of which the classical ode models are mean field versions , can capture the fluctuations observed in time series data @xcite .
more recently it has been demonstrated that the interaction of various strains on the infection of the host with eventual cross - immunities or other interactions between host immune system and multiple strains can generate complicated dynamic attractors .
a prime example is dengue fever .
a first infection is often mild or even asymptomatic and leads to life long immunity against this strain .
however , a subsequent infection with another strain of the virus often causes clinical complications up to life threatening conditions and hospitalization , due to ade .
more on the biology of dengue and its consequences for the detailed epidemiological model structure can be found in aguiar and stollenwerk @xcite including literature on previous modelling attempts , see also @xcite . on the biological evidence for ade
see e.g. @xcite . besides the difference in the force of infection between primary and secondary infection , parametrized by a so called ade parameter @xmath1 , which has been demonstrated to show chaotic attractors in a certain parameter region , another effect , the temporary cross - immunity after a first infection against all dengue virus strains , parametrized by the temporary cross - immunity rate @xmath2 , shows bifurcations up to chaotic attractors in a much wider and biologically more realistic parameter region .
the model presented in the appendix has been described in detail in @xcite and has recently been analysed for a parameter value of @xmath3 corresponding to on average half a year of temporary cross immunity which is biologically plausible @xcite . for increasing ade parameter @xmath1 first an equilibrium which bifurcates via a hopf bifurcation into a stable limit cycle and
then after further continuation the limit cycle becomes unstable in a torus bifurcation .
this torus bifurcation can be located using numerical bifurcation software based on continuation methods tracking known equilibria or limit cycles up to bifurcation points @xcite .
the continuation techniques and the theory behind it are described e.g. in kuznetsov @xcite .
complementary methods like lyapunov exponent spectra can also characterize chaotic attractor @xcite , and led ultimately to the detection of coexisting attractors to the main limit cycles and tori originated from the analytically accessible fixed point for small @xmath1 .
such coexisting structures are often missed in bifurcation analysis of higher dimensional dynamical systems but are demonstrated to be crucial at times in understanding qualitatively the real world data , as for example demonstrated previously in a childhood disease study @xcite . in such a study first the understanding of the deterministic system s attractor structure is needed , and then eventually the interplay between attractors mediated by population noise in the stochastic version of the system gives the full understanding of the data .
here we present for the first time extended results of the bifurcation structure for various parameter values of the temporary cross immunity @xmath2 in the region of biological relevance and multi - parameter bifurcation analysis .
this reveals besides the torus bifurcation route to chaos also the classical feigenbaum period doubling sequence and the origin of so called isola solutions .
the symmetry of the different strains leads to symmerty breaking bifurcations of limit cycles , which are rarely described in the epidemiological literature but well known in the biochemical literature , e.g for coupled identical cells .
the interplay between different numerical procedures and basic analytic insight in terms of symmetries help to understand the attractor structure of multi - strain interactions in the present case of dengue fever , and will contribute to the final understanding of dengue epidemiology including the observed fluctuations in real world data . in the literature the multi - strain interaction leading to deterministic chaos via ade has been described previously , e.g. @xcite but neglecting temporary cross immunity and hence getting stuck in rather unbiological parameter regions , whereas more recently the first considerations of temporary cross immunity in rather complicated and up to now not in detail analysed models including all kinds of interations have appeared @xcite , in this case failing to investigate closer the possible dynamical structures .
the multistrain model under investigation can be given as an ode system @xmath4 for the state vector of the epidemiological host classes @xmath5 and besides other fixed parameters which are biologically undisputed the parameter vector of varied parameters @xmath6 .
for a detailed description of the biological content of state variables and parameters see @xcite .
the ode equations and fixed parameter values are given in the appendix .
the equilibrium values @xmath7 are given by the equilibrium condition @xmath8 , respectively for limit cycles @xmath9 with period @xmath10 .
for chaotic attractors the trajectory of the dynamical system reaches in the time limit of infinity the attractor trajectory @xmath11 , equally for tori with irrational winding ratios . in all cases
the stability can be analysed considering small perturbations @xmath12 around the attractor trajectories @xmath13 here , any attractor is notified by @xmath14 , be it an equilibrium , periodic orbit or chaotic attractor . in this ode system
the linearized dynamics is given with the jacobian matrix @xmath15 of the ode system eq .
( [ dynamicsf ] ) evaluated at the trajectory points @xmath14 given in notation of @xmath16 .
the jacobian matrix is analyzed for equilibria in terms of eigenvalues to determine stability and the loss of it at bifurcation points , negative real part indicating stability .
for the stability and loss of it for limit cylces floquet multipliers are more common ( essentially the exponentials of eigenvalues ) , multipliers inside the unit circle indicating stability , and where they leave eventually the unit circle determining the type of limit cycle bifurcations . and for chaotic systems lyapunov exponents are determined from the jacobian around the trajectory , positive largest exponents showing deterministic chaos , zero largest showing limit cycles including tori , largest smaller zero indicating fixed points . to investigate the bifurcation structure of the system under investigation we first observe the symmetries due to the multi - strain structure of the model .
this becomes important for the time being for equilibria and limit cycles .
we introduce the following notation : with a symmetry transformation matrix @xmath17 @xmath18{c c c c c c c c c c } 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 \label{symmetrymatrix } \end{array } \right)\ ] ] we have the following symmetry : @xmath19 with @xmath20 equilibrium values or @xmath21 limit cycle for all times @xmath22 $ ] . for the right hand side @xmath23 of the ode system
( [ dynamicsf ] ) the kind of symmetry found above is called @xmath0-symmetry when the following equivariance condition holds @xmath24 with @xmath17 a matrix that obeys @xmath25 and @xmath26 , where @xmath27 is the unit matrix .
observe that besides @xmath17 also @xmath27 satisfies ( [ eqn : equivariancecondition ] ) .
the symmetry transformation matrix @xmath17 in eq .
( [ symmetrymatrix ] ) fulfills these requirements .
it is easy to verify that the @xmath0-equivariance conditions eq .
( [ eqn : equivariancecondition ] ) and the properties of @xmath28 are satisfied for our ode system . in seydel @xcite a simplified version of the famous brusselator that shows this type of symmetry is discussed .
there , an equilibrium and also a limit cycle show a pitchfork bifurcation with symmetry breaking .
an equilibrium @xmath20 is called _ fixed _
when @xmath29 ( see @xcite ) .
two equilibria @xmath30 where @xmath31 , are called @xmath17-conjugate if their corresponding solutions satisfy @xmath32 ( and because @xmath26 also @xmath33 ) . for limit cycles
a similar terminology is introduced .
a periodic solution is called _ fixed _ when @xmath34 and the associated limit cycles are also called _ fixed _ @xcite .
there is another type of periodic solution that is not fixed but called _ symmetric _ when @xmath35 where @xmath10 is the period . again
the associated limit cycles are also called _ symmetric_.
both types of limit cycles @xmath36 are @xmath17-invariant as curves : @xmath37 .
that is , in the phase - plane where time parameterizes the orbit , the cycle and the transformed cycle are equal .
a @xmath17-invariant cycle is either fixed or symmetric .
two noninvariant limit cycles ( @xmath38 ) are called @xmath17-conjugate if their corresponding periodic solutions satisfy @xmath39 .
the properties of the symmetric systems and the introduced terminology are used below with the interpretation of the numerical bifurcation analysis results .
we refer to @xcite for an overview of the possible bifurcations of equilibria and limit cycles of @xmath0-equivariant systems .
we show the results of the bifurcation analysis in bifurcation diagrams for several @xmath40 values , varying @xmath1 continuously . besides the previously investigated case of @xmath41 , we show also a case of smaller and a case of larger @xmath40 value , obtaining more information on the bifurcations possible in the model as a whole .
the above mentioned symmetries help in understanding the present bifurcation structure .
for @xmath42 the one - parameter bifurcation diagram is shown in fig .
[ fig : bifdia1phi ] a ) . starting with @xmath43 there is a stable fixed equilibrium , fixed in the above mentioned notion for symmetric systems .
this equilibrium becomes unstable at a hopf bifurcation @xmath44 at @xmath45 .
a stable fixed limit cycle originates at this hopf bifurcation .
this limit cycle shows a supercritical pitch - fork bifurcation @xmath46 , i.e. a bifurcation of a limit cycle with floquet multiplier 1 , splitting the original limit cycle into two new ones . besides the now unstable branch two new branches originate for the pair of conjugated limit cycles .
the branches merge again at another supercritical pitch - fork bifurcation @xmath46 , after which the limit cycle is stable again for higher @xmath47-values .
the pair of @xmath17-conjugate limit cycles become unstable at a torus bifurcation @xmath48 at @xmath49 .
\a ) = 3.3 cm @xmath50 b ) = 3.3 cm @xmath50 c ) = 3.3 cm @xmath50 besides this main bifurcation pattern we found two isolas , that is an isolated solution branch of limit cycles @xcite .
these isola cycles @xmath36 are not @xmath17-invariant , that is @xmath51 .
isolas consisting of isolated limit cycles exist between two tangent bifurcations .
one isola consists of a stable and an unstable branch .
the other shows more complex bifurcation patterns .
there is no full stable branch . for @xmath52 at the tangent bifurcation @xmath10 a stable and an unstable limit cycle collide .
the stable branch becomes unstable via a flip bifurcation or periodic doubling bifurcation @xmath53 , with floquet multiplier @xmath54 , at @xmath55 which is also pitchfork bifurcation for the period - two limit cycles . at the other end of that branch at the tangent bifurcation @xmath10 at @xmath56
both colliding limit cycles are unstable .
close to this point at one branch there is a torus bifurcation @xmath48 , also called neimark - sacker bifurcation , at @xmath57 and a flip bifurcation @xmath53 at @xmath58 which is again a pitchfork bifurcation @xmath59 for the period - two limit cycles .
contiuation of the stable branch originating for the flip bifurcation @xmath53 at @xmath60 gives another flip bifurcation @xmath53 at @xmath61 and one closed to the other end at @xmath58 , namely at @xmath62 .
these results suggest that for this isola two classical routes to chaos can exist , namely via the torus or neimark - sacker bifurcation where the dynamics on the originating torus is chaotic , and the cascade of period doubling route to chaos . for @xmath63 the one - parameter bifurcation diagram
is shown in fig .
[ fig : bifdia1phi ] b ) .
the stable fixed equilibrium becomes unstable at a supercritical hopf bifurcation @xmath44 at @xmath64 where a stable fixed limit cycle originates .
this stable limit cycle becomes unstable at a superciritcal pitchfork bifurcation point @xmath46 at @xmath65 for a limit cycle .
this point marks the origin of a pair of @xmath17-conjugate stable limit cycles besides the now unstable fixed limit cycle .
here one has to consider the two infected subpopulations @xmath66 and @xmath67 to distinguish the conjugate limit cycles .
because the two variables @xmath66 and @xmath67 are interchangeable this can also be interpreted as the stable limit cycles for the single variable say @xmath66 .
the fixed stable equilibrium below the hopf bifurcation where we have @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 is a fixed equilibrium . for the fixed limit cycle in the parameter interval between the hopf bifurcation and the pitchfork bifurcation we have @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75
this means that at the hopf bifurcation @xmath44 the stable fixed equilibrium becomes an unstable fixed equilibrium . in the parameter interval between the two pitchfork bifurcations @xmath46 at @xmath65 and subcritical @xmath76 at @xmath77 , two stable limit cycles coexist and these limit cycles are @xmath17-conjugate . at the pitchfork
bifurcation points the fixed limit cycle becomes unstable and remains fixed , and two stable @xmath17-conjugate limit cycles originate ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 7.7 ) ) .
the invariant plane @xmath78 forms the separatrix between the pair of stable @xmath17-conjugate limit cycles @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
the initial values of the two state variables @xmath81 and @xmath82 together with the point on the invariant plane , determine to which limit cycle the system converges .
continuation of the stable symmetric limit cycle gives a torus or neimark - sacker bifurcation at point denoted by @xmath48 at @xmath83 . at his point
the limit cycles become unstable because a pair of complex - conjugate multipliers crosses the unit circle .
observe that at this point in the time series plot ( * ? ? ?
* there fig .
12 ) the chaotic region starts . in @xcite the following route to chaos ,
namely the sequence of neimark - sacker bifurcations into chaos , is mentioned . increasing the bifurcation parameter @xmath47 along the now unstable pair of @xmath17-conjugate limit cycles leads to a tangent bifurcation @xmath10 at @xmath84 where a pair of two unstable limit cycles collide .
this branch terminates at the second pitchfork bifurcation point denoted by @xmath85 at @xmath77 . because the first fold point gave rise to a stable limit cycle and this fold point to an unstable limit cycle we call the first pitchfork bifurcation supercritical and the latter pitchfork bifurcation subcritical .
these results agree very well with the simulation results shown in the bifurcation diagram for the maxima and minima of the overall infected ( * ? ? ?
* there fig .
notice that auto @xcite calculates only the global extrema during a cycle , not the local extrema . fig .
[ fig : bifdia1phi ] b ) shows also two isolas similar to those for @xmath86 in fig .
[ fig : bifdia1phi ] a ) . for @xmath87
the bifurcation diagram is shown in fig [ fig : bifdia1phi ] c ) . in the lower @xmath47 parameter range there is bistability of two limit cycles in an interval bounded by two tangent bifurcations @xmath10 .
the stable manifold of the intermediate saddle limit cycle acts as a separatrix .
inceasing @xmath47 the stable limit cycles become unstable at the pitchfork bifurcation @xmath59 at @xmath88 . following the unstable primary branch , for larger values of @xmath47
we observe an open loop bounded by two tangent bifurcations @xmath10 .
the extreme value for @xmath47 is at @xmath89 .
then lowering @xmath47 there is a pitchfork bifurcation @xmath59 at @xmath90 .
later we will return to the description of this point .
lowering @xmath47 further the limit cycle becomes stable again at the tangent bifurcations @xmath10 at @xmath91 .
increasing @xmath47 this limit cycle becomes unstable again at the pitchfork bifurcation @xmath59 at @xmath92 .
continuation of the secondary branch of the two @xmath17-conjugated limit cycles from this point reveals that the stable limit cycle becomes unstable at a torus bifurcation @xmath48 at @xmath93 .
the simulation results depicted in ( * ? ? ?
13 ) show that there is chaos beyond this point .
the secondary pair of @xmath17-conjugate limit cycles that originate from pitchfork bifurcation @xmath59 at @xmath88 becomes unstable at a flip bifurcation @xmath53 .
increasing @xmath47 further it becomes stable again at a flip bifurcation @xmath53 .
below we return to the interval between these two flip bifurcations .
the stable part becomes unstable at a tangent bifurcation @xmath10 , then continuing , after a tangent bifurcation @xmath10 and a neimark - sacker bifurcation @xmath48 .
this bifurcation can lead to a sequence of neimark - sacker bifurcations into chaos .
the unstable limit cycles terminates via a tangent bifurcation @xmath53 where the primary limit cycle possesses a pitchfork bifurcation @xmath59 at @xmath90 . at the flip bifurcation
@xmath53 the cycle becomes unstable and a new stable limit cycle with double period emanates .
the stable branch becomes unstable at a flip bifurcation again .
we conclude that there is a cascade of period doubling route to chaos .
similarly this happens in reversed order ending at the flip bifurcation where the secondary branch becomes stable again .
\a ) = 3.3 cm @xmath50 b ) = 3.3 cm @xmath50 c ) = 3.3 cm @xmath50 fig .
[ fig : bifdia1iphidd ] a ) gives the results for the interval @xmath94 where only the minima are show . in this plot also a `` period three '' limit cycle is shown . in a small region
it is stable and coexists together with the `` period one '' limit cycle .
the cycles are shown in fig .
[ fig : bifdia1iphidd ] b ) and c ) for @xmath95 . the one in c )
looks like a period-3 limit cycle . in fig .
[ fig : bifdia1iphidd ] continuation of the limit cycle gives a closed graph bounded at the two ends by trangent bifurcations @xmath10 where a stable and an unstable limit cycle collide .
the intervals where the limit cycle is stable , are on the other end bounded by flip bifurcations @xmath53 .
one unstable part intersects the higher period cycles that originate via the cascade of period doubling between the period-1 limit cycle flip bifurcations @xmath53 at @xmath96 and @xmath97 .
this suggest that the period-3 limit cycle is associated with a `` period-3 window '' of the chaotic attractor .
we conjecture that this interval is bounded by two homoclinic bifurcations for a period-3 limit cycle ( see @xcite ) .
the bifurcation diagram shown in ( * ? ? ?
* there fig .
13 ) shows the point where the chaotic attractor disappears abruptly , possible at one of the two homoclinic bifurcations .
in that region the two conjugated limit cycles that originate at the pitchfork bifurcation @xmath59 at @xmath92 are the attractors .
these results suggest that there are chaotic attractors associated with the period-1 limit cycle , one occurs via a cascade of flip bifurcations originating from the two ends at @xmath96 and @xmath97 and one via a neimark - sacker bifurcation @xmath48 at @xmath93 .
we will now link the three studies of the different @xmath2 values by investigating a two - parameter diagram for @xmath47 and @xmath2 , concentrating especially on the creation of isolated limit cycles , which sometimes lead to further bifurcations inside the isola region .
[ fig : phialphad ] gives a two - parameter bifurcation diagram where @xmath47 and @xmath98 are the free parameters . for low @xmath47-values
there is the hopf bifurcation @xmath44 and all other curves are tangent bifurcation curves .
= 4.0 cm isolas appear or disappears upon crossing an isola variety . at an elliptic isola point
an isolated solution branch is born , while at a hyperbolic isola point an isolated solution branch vanishes by coalescence with another branch @xcite . from fig .
[ fig : phialphad ] we see that at two values of @xmath99 isolas are born .
furthermore , period doubling bifurcations appear for lower @xmath100 values , indicating the feigenbaum route to chaos .
however , only the calculation of lyapunov exponents , which are discussed in the next section , can clearly indicate chaos .
the lyapunov exponents are the logarithms of the eigenvalues of the jacobian matrix along the integrated trajectories , eq .
( [ dynamicsdeltaf ] ) , in the limit of large integration times . besides for very simple iterated maps
no analytic expressions for chaotic systems can be given for the lyapunov exponents .
for the calculation of the iterated jacobian matrix and its eigenvalues , we use the qr decomposition algorithm @xcite .
\a ) = 3.3 cm @xmath50 b ) = 3.3 cm @xmath50 c ) = 3.3 cm @xmath50 in fig .
[ fig : lyapspect6 ] we show for various @xmath2 values the four largest lyapunov exponents in the @xmath1 range between zero and one . for @xmath101 in fig .
[ fig : lyapspect6 ] a ) we see for small @xmath1 values fixed point behaviour indicated by a negative largest lyapunov exponent up to around @xmath102 . there , at the hopf bifurcation point , the largest lyapunov exponent becomes zero , indicating limit cycle behaviour for the whole range of @xmath1 , apart from the final bit before @xmath103 , where a small spike with positive lyapunov exponent might be present , but difficult to distinguish from the noisy numerical background . for @xmath104 in fig .
[ fig : lyapspect6 ] b ) however , we see a large window with positive largest lyapunov exponent , well separated from the second largest being zero .
this is s clear sign of deterministically chaotic attractors present for this @xmath1 range .
just a few windows with periodic attractors , indicated by the zero largest lyapunov exponent are visible in the region of @xmath105 . for smaller @xmath1 values
we observe qualitatively the same behaviour as already seen for @xmath101 .
for the smaller value of @xmath106 in fig .
[ fig : lyapspect6 ] c ) the chaotic window is even larger than for @xmath104 .
hence deterministic chaos is present for temporary cross immunity in the range around @xmath107 in the range of @xmath1 between zero and one .
we have presented a detailed bifurcation analysis for a multi - strain dengue fever model in terms of the ade parameter @xmath1 , in the previously not well investigated region between zero and one , and a parameter for the temporary cross immunity @xmath2 .
the symmetries implied by the strain structure , are taken into account in the analysis .
many of the possible bifurcations of equilibria and limit cycles of @xmath0-equivariant systems can be distinguished . using auto @xcite
the different dynamical structures were calculated .
future time series analysis of epidemiological data has good chances to give insight into the relevant parameter values purely on topological information of the dynamics , rather than classical parameter estimation of which application is in general restricted to farely simple dynamical scenarios .
this work has been supported by the european union under the marie curie grant mext - ct-2004 - 14338 .
we thank gabriela gomes and luis sanchez , lisbon , for scientific support .
99 , _ evolution towards criticality in an epidemiological model for meningococcal disease _ , physics letters a * 317 * ( 2003 ) 8796 .
, _ diversity in pathogenicity can cause outbreaks of menigococcal disease _ , proc .
usa * 101 * ( 2004 ) 1022910234 . ,
_ a new chaotic attractor in a basic multi - strain epidemiological model with temporary cross - immunity _ , arxiv:0704.3174v1 [ nlin.cd ] ( 2007 ) ( accessible electronically at http://arxive.org ) . ,
_ scale - free network for a dengue epidemic
_ , applied mathematics and computation * 159 * ( 2008 ) 376381 .
, _ neutralization and antibody - dependent enhancement of dengue viruses _
, advances in virus research * 60 * ( 2003 ) 42167 . , _ epidemiology of dengue fever : a model with temporary cross - immunity and possible secondary infection shows bifurcations and chaotic behaviour in wide parameter regions _ , submitted ( 2008 ) .
, _ auto 07p continuation and bifurcation software for ordinary differential equations _ ,
technical report : concordia university , montreal , canada ( 2007 ) ( accessible electronically at http://indy.cs.concordia.ca/auto/ ) .
, _ elements of applied bifurcation theory _ applied mathematical sciences * 112 * , springer - verlag , 3 edition , new york , 2004 . , _ chaotic evolution and strange attractors _ , cambridge university press , cambridge , 1989 . , _ chaos in dynamical systems _ , cambridge university press , cambridge , 2002 . , _ nonlinear time series analysis of empirical population dynamics _
, ecological modelling * 75*/*76 * ( 1994 ) 171181 . , _ the effect of antibody - dependent enhancement on the transmission dynamics and persistence of multiple - strain pathogens _ , proc .
usa * 96 * ( 1999 ) 79094 . , _ instabilities in multiserotype disease models with antibody - dependent enhancement _
, journal of theoretical biology * 246 * ( 2007 ) 1827 .
, _ ecological and immunological determinants of dengue epidemics _ , proc .
usa * 103 * ( 2006 ) 1180211807 .
, _ decreases in dengue transmission may act to increase the incidence of dengue hemorrhagic fever _ , proc .
sci * 105 * ( 2008 ) 22382243 . ,
_ practical bifurcation and stability analysis - from equilibrium to chaos _ , springer - verlag , new york , 1994 .
, _ singularities and groups in bifurcation theory _ , springer , new york , 1985 . , _ routes to chaos in high - dimensional dynamical systems : a qualitative numerical study _ , physica d * 223 * ( 2006 ) 194207 . ,
_ homoclinic and heteroclinic orbits in a tri - trophic food chain _ , journal of mathematical biology * 39 * ( 1999 ) 1938 . , _ multiple attractors and boundary crises in a tri - trophic food chain _ , mathematical biosciences * 169 * ( 2001 ) 109128 .
, _ chaotic behaviour of a predator - prey system _ , dynamics of continuous , discrete and impulsive systems , series b : applications and algorithms * 10 * ( 2003 ) 259272 . , _ consequence of symbiosis for food web dynamics _ , journal of mathematical biology * 49 * ( 2004 ) 227271 .
, _ liapunov exponents from time series _ , phys .
a * 34 * ( 1986 ) 49719 .
the complete system of ordinary differential equations for a two strain epidemiological system allowing for differences in primary versus secondary infection and temporary cross immunity is given by @xmath108 for two different strains , @xmath109 and @xmath110 , we label the sir classes for the hosts that have seen the individual strains .
susceptibles to both strains ( s ) get infected with strain @xmath109 ( @xmath66 ) or strain @xmath110 ( @xmath67 ) , with infection rate @xmath111 .
they recover from infection with strain @xmath109 ( becoming temporary cross - immune @xmath112 ) or from strain @xmath110 ( becoming @xmath113 ) , with recovery rate @xmath114 etc .. with rate @xmath98 , the @xmath112 and @xmath113 enter again in the susceptible classes ( @xmath115 being immune against strain 1 but susceptible to 2 , respectively @xmath116 ) , where the index represents the first infection strain .
now , @xmath115 can be reinfected with strain @xmath110 ( becoming @xmath117 ) , meeting @xmath67 with infection rate @xmath111 or meeting @xmath117 with infection rate @xmath118 , secondary infected contributing differently to the force of infection than primary infected , etc .. we include demography of the host population denoting the birth and death rate by @xmath119 . for constant population size
@xmath120 we have for the immune to all strains @xmath121 and therefore we only need to consider the first 9 equations of eq .
( [ ode2strain ] ) , giving 9 lyapunov exponents . in our numerical studies
we take the population size equal to @xmath122 so that numbers of susceptibles , infected etc .
are given in percentage .
as fixed parameter values we take @xmath123 , @xmath124 , @xmath125 .
the parameters @xmath1 and @xmath2 are varied . | we analyse an epidemiological model of competing strains of pathogens and hence differences in transmission for first versus secondary infection due to interaction of the strains with previously aquired immunities , as has been described for dengue fever ( in dengue known as antibody dependent enhancement , ade ) .
such models show a rich variety of dynamics through bifurcations up to deterministic chaos . including temporary cross - immunity
even enlarges the parameter range of such chaotic attractors , and also gives rise to various coexisting attractors , which are difficult to identify by standard numerical bifurcation programs using continuation methods . a combination of techniques , including classical bifurcation plots and lyapunov exponent spectra has to be applied in comparison to get further insight into such dynamical structures . here
we present for the first time multi - parameter studies in a range of biologically plausible values for dengue .
the multi - strain interaction with the immune system is expected to also have implications for the epidemiology of other diseases
. numerical bifurcation analysis , lyapunov exponents , @xmath0 symmetry , coexisting attractors , antibody dependent enhancement ( ade ) regino criado , j. vigo aguiar [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] |
for its remarkable high tensile strength and ductility @xcite , mg - based long - period stacking ordered ( lpso ) structures are considered as light - weight structural alloy for next generation . in order to clarify relationship between thier formation process and resultant properties in terms of application for structural materials , considerable number of experimental as well as theoretical studies have been carried out .
previous theoretical studies mainly address formation process and thermodynamic stability of mg - based lpso alloy , including ( i ) the tendency of phase separation confirmed by cluster variation method @xcite , ( ii ) in - plane ordering of clusters consisted of y , zn substitutional atoms @xcite , and ( iii ) systematic understanding of energetic stability with respect to variety of substitutional atoms into mg - based alloys @xcite .
although these previous theoretical works partly clarify themodynamic stability of lpso phases , they did not sufficiently discuss about ( i ) relative stability in terms of disordered phases or ( ii ) effect of lattice vibration on stability of lpso .
the former one is considered essentially important , since well - established ordering energy , determining the thermodynamic stability of ordered phase with respect to temperature , is typically reffered to the difference in mixing energy between ordered ( here , lpso ) and disordered phases . for
the latter one , vibrational effects , their significant role on phase stability has been amply demonstrated for several binary alloys , such as ref .
[ fig:18r ] is a schematic illustration of stacking sequence of 18r lpso structure , which includes mg hcp stacking and y , zn substitutional atom concentrated phase including l1@xmath1 cluster . to systematically evaluate thermodynamic stability of such structures , we need to consider energetics of multiple structures including different stacking sequence
however , most calculations confine the structural model , so calculation that does nt confine experimentally reported structures is highly required .
furthermore , it is fundamentally important to assess thermodynamic stability of lpso phase by competing disordered phase . in this study , based on dft calculation ,
we systematically study thermodynamic stability of lpso structure in terms of disordered phases .
to comprehensively address energetics of multicomponent system with various composition , we need to calculate tremendous number of structures of the system and computational cost therefore become large . in this study
, we employ special quasirandom structure ( sqs ) to assess thermodynamic stability of lpso phase competing with disordered phase .
sqs is a special microscopic state whose multiple correlation functions are numerically identical to those in perfect random structure , which therefore provides physical properties for perfect random alloy @xcite . as following procedure , we calculated correlation function of sqs of ternary system .
let us consider the system with @xmath2 lattice points for number of components , @xmath3 .
@xmath4 is a variable which specifies the occupation of lattice point @xmath5 and @xmath6 can specify any atomic arrangement and we can represent structures in following equation , which is called correlation function ; @xmath7 here , @xmath8 is complete orthonormal basis function at lattice point @xmath5 and it is obtained by applying gram - schmidt technique to the linearly independent polynominal set @xmath9 .
@xmath10 denotes a cluster included in the structure , @xmath11 is the index of basis function @xmath8 and @xmath12 is the set of index . in the case of ternary alloy system ,
the occupation of lattice point by each element , mg , y , and zn , is defined by @xmath13 respectively , leading to the basis function of eq.([eq : basis_tri ] ) @xcite : + @xmath14 by averaging @xmath15 over equivalent clusters in lattice , correlation function of sqs in mg - y - zn ternary system with compositions of each element , @xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 , @xmath19 , is represented by eq.([eq : sqs4 ] ) , @xmath20 where @xmath21 and @xmath22 denote dimension of clusters and the number of @xmath23 respectively .
the simulation was performed so that correlation functions come closer to ideal sqs correlation functions up to 4-th nearest neighbor pair ( @xmath0 6 pair clusters on hcp ) finded by eq.([eq : sqs4 ] ) .
we optimized correration functions for each clusters by performing numerical simulation @xcite and constructed sqss . to evaluate the accuracy of obtained correlation functions of sqs
, we compared the simulated values of correlation functions with standard deviation of them in configurational space .
then , most of the errors of correlation function are small enough compared with standard deviation . based on these obtained structures ,
we calculate formation free energy , @xmath24 , and bulk modulus , @xmath25 to evaluate thermodynamic stability of mg - y - zn system that has multiple stacking sequence with various composition for random mixing .
we constructed structures with various composition on mutiple stacking sequence , whose composition is shown in figure .
[ fig : phasediagram ] .
the detail of calculation condition of structure is shown in appendix .
@xmath24 is denoted by eq.([eq : form1 ] ) and we define @xmath26 by eq.([eq : form2 ] ) , @xmath27 @xmath28 where @xmath29 is total energy of @xmath30 , and we evaluate configurational entropy , @xmath31 , based on bragg - williams approximation . in order to evaluate bulk modulus , we calculate total energies of structures , whose volume is expanded at a rate of @xmath323% , @xmath326% , @xmath329% . by using @xmath33 based on debye - grneisen approximation , debye temperature , @xmath34 , can be described as @xcite @xmath35 where @xmath36 is atomic volume and @xmath12 denotes atomic mass .
based on empirical debye model , @xmath37 can be estimated by eq.([eq : fvib ] ) ; @xmath38 where @xmath39 is debye function .
we estimated the effect of phonon on mg - based alloy by calculating @xmath40 and the vibrational free energy of formation with respect to the pure constituents can be estimated by eq.([eq : vibform ] ) @xcite ; @xmath41 where @xmath5 denotes element and @xmath42 is a composition of @xmath5 . in order to evaluate the effect of stacking faults on stability
, we constructed a sqs which has stacking faults on hcp ( stacking sequence is `` ababcababcababc '' ) .
hereinafter , we call this structure `` mixed ''
. the effect of stacking difference is quantified by interfacial energy , which is defined by @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is total energy of structure including stacking faults and @xmath45 is for structures on fcc and hcp stacking .
@xmath46 denotes area of interface , which is 1.4@xmath47 @xmath48 in this calculation .
additionally , to address stability of ordered phase competeing with disordered phase , we also calculated formation energy of structures including y - zn l1@xmath1 cluster and estimated ordering temperature .
we employ first - principles calculations using a dft code , the vienna ab - initio simulation package ( vasp ) @xcite @xcite , to obtain the total energies for structures of mg - y - zn alloys .
the calculation of total energy is carried out for the structures in table .
[ table : data_type ] .
all - electron kohn - sham equations are solved by employing the projector augmented - wave ( paw ) method @xcite @xcite .
we select generalized - gradient approximation of perdew - burke - ernzerhof ( gga - pbe ) @xcite form to the exchange - correlation functional .
the plane - wave cutoff energy is set at 350 ev throughout the present calculations .
brillouin zone sampling is performed on the basis of the monkhorst pack scheme @xcite .
k - point mesh is set 4@xmath494@xmath491 for structure , c3 , and 4@xmath494@xmath494 for others and smearing parameter is 0.15 ev @xcite .
first , we evaluated formation free energy of structures with multiple compositions on hcp and fcc stacking , which is shown in fig .
[ fig : formation free energy ] . at @xmath50 , @xmath24 of structures on hcp is negative at all through composition and possesses two extreme values . through calculation of formation free energy of sqss
, mg - y - zn alloy exhibits phase separation into mg- and y - zn- rich phase and this result is consistent with previous research by iikubo @xmath51 @xmath52 @xcite , which suggests the validity of this simulation based on sqss . using these optimized sqss
, we proceed our discussion to calculate bulk modulus , ordering temperature , and the effect of stacking difference on phase stability . cluster ( f4 , g2 ) and sqss on hcp ( f1 ) and fcc ( f2 , g1 ) stacking .
the ratio of concentration of substitutional atom is denoted in each figure .
structure indices are denoted in table .
[ table : data_type],title="fig:",width=359 ] + next , in order to evaluate the effect of lattice vibration on phase stability of mg - y - zn system , we calculated bulk modulus , which is shown in figure .
[ fig : bulkmodulus ] .
dashed line represents linear averaged bulk modulus , @xmath53 .
bulk modulus for a1 , e1 h1 , f1 ( on hcp stacking ) , e2 ( on fcc stacking ) and f4 ( ordered structure ) are about 35 gpa .
the values of bulk modulus are smaller than @xmath53 through all compositions .
calculated @xmath40 at @xmath54k at ( @xmath16,@xmath17,@xmath18)=(87.5,6.25,6.25 ) was found to be negligibly small within the calculated accuracy of @xmath33 .
compared with avove results of @xmath24 , @xmath37 does not have significant influence on @xmath24 of mg - y - zn alloys with multiple stackings and compositions .
additionally , bulk modulus does not show significant dependence of mg concentration , which therefore means that the effects of phonon do not play essential role on lpso phase stability . in this study , since effect of optical mode for multicomponent system is not considered , further study including optical mode is needed to quantitively clarify the effect of phonon for stability of mg - y - zn alloys .
hereinafter , in evaluateing effects of ordering and stacking sequence difference on stability , we only consider the configurational effect . , where @xmath55 is bulk modulus of @xmath46 and @xmath56 , @xmath57
, @xmath58 denotes composition of each element .
colors correspond to the ratio of concentration of substitutional atom.,title="fig:",width=264 ] + then , we examine the effect of ordering on stability .
we constructed structure including l1@xmath1 cluster , f4 and g2 , whose atomic arrangements are shown in fig .
[ fig : l12clusterarrange ] .
formation energies of f4 and g2 are lower than sqs on hcp ( f1 ) and fcc ( g1,f2 ) stacking ( right side of fig .
[ fig : formation free energy ] ) , which shows this system is stabilized by the effect of ordering . as we estimated ordering temperature , @xmath59 , from f2 to f4 and from g1 to g2 was about 1050 k and 930 k respectively .
this results shows that transition temperature depends on the arrangement of l1@xmath1 cluster and @xmath59 of g2 is close to experimental results by okuda @xmath60 .
@xcite taking that transition temperature can be overestimated based on bragg - williams approximation into consideration . moreover
, this result indicates that mg - y - zn system form ordered phase up to melting point : mg - y - zn alloy can be regarded as intermetallic compounds . clusters .
red and blue spheres represent y and zn atom respectively .
f4 : meta - stable .
g2 : stable.,title="fig:",width=264 ] + finaly , we address the effect of stacking sequence on stability using interfacial energy .
[ fig : stackingdifference ] is interfacial energies of structures on different stacking ( f1 , f2 , f3 ) with respect to the energy of structure on fcc stacking , f2 . as shown in fig .
[ fig : stackingdifference ] , interfacial energy of disordered phase that introduces stacking fault is lower than the energy for linear average of hcp and fcc stacking .
this result indicate that when stacking fault is introduced to mg - rich hcp alloys to form `` l1@xmath1-like '' ordering , corresponding interface between original hcp and formed fcc region gains `` negative '' energy , which is contrary to the conventional tendency that interface gains positive energy .
this specific characteristics for interface energy in mg - based allos would thus be one of the fundumental prerequisite to accelaration of forming lpso phases , which should be further investigated in the future work .
in this study , we calculate preference of energetics of mg - y - zn ternary alloy system in terms of disordered phase stability . through calculation of formation free energy of sqss
, mg - y - zn alloy exhibits phase separation into mg- and y - zn- rich phase .
bulk modulus for sqss and ordered structure ranges about 35 gpa and they do not show significant dependence of mg concentration , which therefore means that the effect of phonon does not play essential role on lpso phase stability within acoustic mode .
order - disorder transition temperature is estimated about 930 k and this results is colse to the melting point that is experimentaly reported and this suggests that mg - y - zn lpso alloy can be regarded as intermetallic compounds .
the effect of stacking faults stabilized the lpso phase and this results indicate that there remains profound relationship between introducing stacking faults and the formation of long - priod stacking ordering .
this work is supported by a grant - in - aid for scientific research on innovative areas ( 26109710 ) from the ministry of education , science , sports and culture of japan .
999 y.kawamura , k.hayashi , a.inoue and t.matsumoto , mater.trans . * 42 * , 1172 ( 2001 ) .
s.iikubo , s.hamamoto and h.ohtani , mater .
trans . * 54 * , 636 ( 2013 ) .
h.kimizuka , n.fronzi and s.ogata , scripta mater . * 69 * , 594 ( 2013 ) . j.saal and c.wolverton , acta mater . * 68 * , 325 ( 2014 ) .
i.a.abrikosov , yu.h.vekilov and a.v.ruban , phys .
a * 154 * , 407 ( 1991 ) .
z.w.lu , b.m.klein , a.zunger , j.phase .
* 16 * , 36 ( 1995 ) .
k.yuge , j.phys . : condens . matter .
* 21 * , 415401 ( 2009 ) .
k.yuge , j.phys .
jpn * 84 * , 084801 ( 2015 ) .
a. van de walle and g.ceder , rev .
phys . * 74 * , 11 ( 2002 ) .
a.zunger , s .- h.wei , l.g.ferreira and j.e.bernard , phys . rev . lett .
* 65 * , 353 ( 1990 ) .
k.yuge , a.seko , y.koyama , f.oba , and i.tanaka , phys .
b * 77 * , 094121 ( 2008 ) . g.kresse and j.hafner , phys . rev .
b * 47 * , r558 ( 1993 ) . g.kresse and j.furthmuller , phys
b * 54 * , 11169 ( 1996 ) . g.kresse and d.joubert , phys . rev .
b * 59 * , 1758 ( 1999 ) .
p.e.blochl , phys .
b * 50 * , 17953 ( 1994 ) .
j.p.perdew , k.burke , and m. ernzerhof , phys .
lett * 77 * , 3865 ( 1996 ) . h.j.monkhorst and j.d.pack , phys .
b * 13 * , 5188 ( 1976 ) .
m.methfessel and a.t.paxton , phys .
b * 40 * , 3616 ( 1989 ) .
v.l.moruzzi , j.f.janak and k.schwarz , phys .
b * 37 * , 790 ( 1988 ) . v.ozolins , c.wolverton and a.zunger , phys . rev .
b * 58 * , r5897 ( 1998 ) .
h.okuda , t.horiuchi , s.hihumi , m.yamasaki , y.kawamura and s.kimura , metall .
mater . trans .
a * 45a * , 4780 ( 2014 ) .
in this study , we calculated free energy and bulk modulus of structures shown in following data . | in order to clarify thermodynamic stability of mg - based long - period stacking ordered ( lpso ) structure , we systematically study energetic preference for alloys on multiple stacking with different composition for random mixing of constituent elements , mg , y , and zn based on special quasirandom structure ( sqs ) . through calculation of formation free energy of sqs , mg - y - zn alloy exhibits phase separation into mg- and y - zn rich phase , which is consistent with previous theoretical studies .
bulk modulus of sqss for multiple compositions , stacking sequences , and atomic configurations ranges around 35 gpa , @xmath0 , they do not show significant dependence of mg concentration , which therefore means that the effects of phonon do not play significant role on lpso phase stability .
introducing stacking fault to hcp stacking gains `` negative '' energy , which indicates profound relationship between introducing stacking faults and the formation of long - period stacking ordering . |
it has been known for some time that in the limit of arbitrarily large heavy quark masses that qcd has a symmetry which relates hadrons with two heavy quarks ( anti - quarks ) to analogous states with one heavy anti - quark ( quark ) @xcite .
we will refer to this symmetry as the doubly heavy diquark
antiquark ( dhda ) symmetry .
presumably when the masses are finite , but very large , a remnant of this dhda symmetry will survive in the form of an approximate symmetry .
a key issue is how large must the masses be before such an approximate dhda symmetry is manifest in a useful way .
the issue is particularly relevant for charm quarks both because the charm quark is the lightest of the heavy quarks and hence the approximation is most likely to fail and because doubly bottomed hadrons ( or hadrons with a charm and a bottom ) are presumably more difficult to create and detect than doubly charmed ones .
the issue remained of only marginal importance in the absence of observed doubly heavy hadrons .
however , in the past several years , the selex collaboration has reported the first sighting of doubly charmed baryons @xcite .
four states , @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 ( which have been interpreted as two pairs of iso - doublets ) are reported , as shown in fig .
[ fig : specxi ] .
it should be noted that all four states were identified through their weak decay products .
this is surprising as one would ordinarily expect the excited states to decay electro - magnetically much more rapidly and thus wash out a signal for weak decays .
this issue creates a potential problem for any interpretation of the data .
additionally , most recently , babar has reported that they have not observed any evidence of doubly charmed baryons in @xmath4 annihilations @xcite .
however , we would set these issues aside and take the existence of all four states as given to ask whether the properties of these states could be understood at least qualitatively in terms of the dhda symmetry . recently refs .
@xcite and @xcite argued that the splitting between the lower doublet and the upper doublet @xmath5 states can be understood semi - quantitatively ( at the 30% level ) in terms of an approximate dhda symmetry .
spectrum of @xmath6 that have been observed by the selex collaboration @xcite . ]
this paper critically examines the extent to which an approximate dhda symmetry could be present for charm quarks .
this is of importance both for the doubly charmed states found by selex and also for the existence of putative doubly charmed tetraquarks which are known to exist in the heavy quark limit @xcite and in potential models @xcite .
we find strong evidence to suggest that the charm quark mass is _ not _ heavy enough for the symmetry to emerge automatically of color coulombic interactions .
the key issue is the degree to which scales that separate in the heavy quark limit ( and whose separations are critical to the derivation of the dhda symmetry ) in fact separate for doubly charmed systems . as we will detail below , such a scale separation
probably does not hold . despite this
, we will show that the presence of certain non - perturbative interactions could result in an approximate dhda symmetry in the charm sector . to begin the discussion ,
let us consider why one expects the dhda symmetry .
physically , it arises from a diquark pair forming a tightly bound nearly point - like object .
the attraction between the two heavy quarks in the diquark comes from a color coulombic interaction that is attractive in the color @xmath7 channel .
if the mass of the quarks is large enough , the heavy quarks move slowly and act like non - relativistic particles in a coulombic potential .
as the size of a coulombic bound state is inversely proportional to its mass ( for fixed coupling ) , in the large mass limit the diquark becomes a heavy , small object with color @xmath7 . to a good approximation
it becomes a static point - like @xmath7 color source ; in this sense it acts in essentially the same way as a heavy anti - quark . this symmetry was first discussed by savage and wise @xcite in the context of relating the properties of doubly heavy baryons , @xmath8 , to those of heavy mesons , @xmath9 . to the extent that one can treat the heavy diquark as formed , one can simply use standard heavy quark effective theory ( hqet ) to describe the properties of the doubly heavy baryons .
since the diquark in the doubly heavy baryon essentially acts as an antiquark , one can directly relate the properties of this system to heavy mesons . using the hqet effective lagrangain in ref .
@xcite , a relationship valid at large @xmath10 for the mass difference of spin excited states between the doubly heavy baryons and heavy mesons was derived : ) is different from that in ref .
@xcite by a factor of @xmath11 .
this error was observed and corrected by ref .
@xcite and @xcite . ] @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the doubly heavy anti - baryons with @xmath15 and @xmath16 , respectively , and @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the heavy mesons with @xmath19 and @xmath20 , respectively . from the prospective of hqet
, this relationship should hold to @xmath21 where @xmath22 is a typical hadronic energy and is proportional to , but not identical to @xmath23 .
however as was discussed in ref .
@xcite , the finite size of the diquark gives rise to corrections formally larger than this in the large mass regime .
at the time of the savage and wise paper , this relationship was a prediction of the theory : doubly heavy baryons had not been discovered .
the selex data will allow us to explore this relation with some real world data . before proceeding further
, we should note that this analysis is based on the assumption that a spatially small and tightly bound diquark configuration exists and remains unexcited in the dynamics .
the key question we address is the extent to which this assumption is true . to examine the issue of diquark excitations , a systematic treatment for the dynamics of two heavy quarks
is needed . at a formal level
the non - relativistic expansion of the heavy quark degrees of freedom with qcd ( nrqcd ) is the natural language to explore this issue .
nrqcd was first developed by bodwin , braaten , and lepage @xcite , where it was modeled after a similar treatment in the context of qed @xcite .
hqet is generally considered as an expansion in powers of @xmath24 , with @xmath25 .
thereby it creates two energy scales , @xmath26 and @xmath27 . on the other hand
, nrqcd requires the introduction of two new scales : the characteristic momentum , @xmath28 , and energy scale , @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the characteristic velocity of the two heavy quarks relative to each other . with the hierarchy , @xmath31 , the characteristic regimes in terms of ( energy , momentum ) of the heavy quarks are : ( @xmath26 , @xmath26 ) , ( @xmath28 , @xmath28 ) , ( @xmath29 , @xmath28 ) , and ( @xmath29 , @xmath29 ) .
these are conventionally referred to as hard , soft , potential , and ultrasoft , respectively .
traditional nrqcd has been further simplified into two different effective theories , pnrqcd and vnrqcd .
pnrqcd integrates out the soft momentum gluons to form heavy diquarks states with definite color , and uses these diquark states as the degrees of freedom @xcite . on the other hand
, vnrqcd keeps the heavy quarks as explicit degrees of freedom while matching the effective theory at the hard scale @xcite . in all forms of nrqcd
, the separation of scales creates an expansion of powers of @xmath32 . on physical grounds ,
one expects that the nrqcd at leading order of systems with two heavy quarks ( or anti - quarks ) ought to reduce to the hqet description of the dual problem_i.e .
_ , the problem related by the dhda symmetry .
recently , ref .
@xcite derived the presence of dhda symmetry in the context of pnrqcd while ref .
@xcite confirmed this for vnrqcd by showing the equivalence between vnrqcd and pnrqcd .
it should be noted that this derivation represents a qualitatively new domain for nrqcd .
traditionally , nrqcd is applied to systems with one heavy quark and one heavy anti - quark with no valance light quark degrees of freedom .
the fact that the technique may be extended to problems with two heavy quarks plus additional light quark degrees of freedom is non - trivial .
one central point , that should be stressed , is that the derivation is quite general and applies equally well to the problem of heavy tetraquarks as well as doubly heavy baryons .
the key advantage to the nrqcd formalism is that corrections to this symmetry can be systematically incorporated by working at higher order . while it is known that the dhda symmetry must emerge in the heavy quark limit , it is not immediately clear how large the corrections to the symmetry results should be for the realistic case in which heavy quarks have large but finite mass .
clearly the fundamental issue is the interplay between the diquark binding into an approximately point - like object and the extent that the diquark is point - like from the light quarks perspective ; thus both the details of the physics of the interactions between the two heavy quarks as well as the between the heavy and light quarks are essential .
previous work in this area , @xcite , have concentrated their efforts on perturbative expansions of the interactions between the two heavy quarks in the framework of nrqcd , and have not dealt with heavy / light interactions . since the interactions between the heavy and light quarks are intrinsically non - perturbative , it can not be estimated directly via the techniques of nrqcd .
the full expansion should be a combination of hqet and nrqcd that incorporates the mixing of perturbative and non - perturbative scales .
the issue of how to attack the question of the scale of these corrections for charmed or bottom quarks is the motivation for this paper .
we do this in the context of the selex data with tools motivated by nrqcd .
even though we do not fully formulate the new combined expansion in this paper , we provide strong arguments suggesting the need for such a theory when dealing with doubly heavy mesons .
this paper explores this issue both in terms of systematic treatment of the problem based on power counting in effective field theories and in terms of more heuristic phenomenological reasoning .
we divide this paper into two major sections . in the first , we work in the large quark mass limit , and develop the consequences of the spectrum in this regime . in the second section ,
we work with a finite quark mass and present arguments that show the selex data is not consistent with the large mass limit , the need for a new expansion to describe this system , and the justification beyond nrqcd of the apparent dhda symmetry seen by selex .
before addressing the key question of whether the charm quarks are too light for the dhda symmetry to be manifest , it is useful to consider just what implications the dhda symmetry has on the spectrum when the symmetry is manifest
namely , when the quarks are sufficiently heavy .
we attempt to consider the extreme limit , where all relevant scales cleanly separate .
it is unlikely that the physical world exists in this limit .
nevertheless , an understanding of the the physics in this extreme regime is useful in understanding the applicable expansions .
there has been extensive work using a variety of models in detailing the hadronic spectrum including @xcite and @xcite among others .
our focus here will be considering the spectrum in the context of a possible dhda symmetry .
we will consider a more modest regime , that is intended to describe the physical world , in the next section .
the first consequence we consider is qualitative namely , the existence of exotic states . the dhda symmetry in hqet was first used to relate doubly heavy baryons to heavy mesons @xcite .
however , the symmetry is independent of the light quarks in the problem .
formally , in nrqcd , the light quarks are govern by non - perturbative dynamics , and are thereby considered irrelevant when focusing on the heavy quarks in the large mass limit .
as the dhda symmetry applies in the heavy quark limit independent of the number and state of spectator light quarks , it is sufficient to consider an ordinary heavy baryon , @xmath33 . from dhda symmetry , this state
is directly related to a doubly heavy tetraquark state , @xmath34 .
thus in the heavy quark limit , when the dhda symmetry is exact , the existence of heavy baryons implies the existence of doubly heavy tetraquarks .
the fact that doubly heavy tetraquarks must exist in the heavy quark limit has been shown previously .
this was done both based on the simple argument discussed here and in the context of an illustrative model based on pion exchange @xcite .
it should be noted that while being in the regime of validity of dhda requires the existence of doubly heavy tetraquarks , the converse is not true : doubly heavy tetraquarks could be formed via other mechanisms .
nevertheless , the general result is significant in that the tetraquark has manifestly exotic quantum numbers in the sense that it can not be made in a simple quark model from a quark anti - quark pair .
the observation of exotic hadrons has been a longstanding goal of hadronic physics .
the prediction of the existence of an exotic particle directly from qcd , albeit in a limit of the theory , is of theoretical importance in that by direct construction qcd is compatible with exotics .
other exotic particles , such as a heavy pentaquark , have also been shown to exist in the heavy quark limit combined with the large @xmath35 limit @xcite .
let us now turn to more quantitative issues associated with the excitation spectrum .
as noted in the introduction , the formal treatment of this problem incorporates nrqcd ( for the interactions between the heavy quarks ) and hqet ( for the interactions between the heavy particles and the light degrees of freedom ) .
the dhda symmetry requires each of these effective theories to be in its domain of validity . in the heavy quark limit where both expansions will work
, one has @xmath36 where @xmath22 is a typical hadronic scale proportional to @xmath23 and @xmath32 , the relative velocity of the heavy quark , is typically of order @xmath37 and hence depends logarithmically on the quark mass .
it should be noted that the nrqcd formalism is still valid for @xmath38 as indicated by ref .
however , none of the analysis in this work depends on @xmath39 being larger than @xmath22 , and hence is consistent with the domain of validity on nrqcd .
the formalism of nrqcd and its associated power counting rules remains valid for two heavy quarks in the color @xmath7 in the presence of additional light quark degrees of freedom and not just for heavy quark anti - quark systems in the color singlet in heavy mass limit .
this was shown in ref .
@xcite and verified in ref .
@xcite .
it is important to note that these effective theories have different types of excitations with qualitatively different scales .
doubly heavy hadrons ( in the formal limit of very large quark mass ) have three characteristic types of excitation : 1
. excitations of order @xmath40 which correspond to the interaction of the spin of the diquark with the remaining degrees of freedom in the problem .
excitations of order @xmath22 which correspond to the excitations of the light degrees of freedom .
excitations of order @xmath41 which correspond to the internal excitation of the diquark . the first two types of excitations can be understood in terms of hqet while the third requires nrqcd .
the essential point is that as @xmath42 the three scales separate cleanly . since these excitations all occur at disparate scales , they do not influence each other .
dhda symmetry imposes many relations on the various types of excitations of various doubly heavy hadrons and their associated singly heavy ones . to enumerate these
, it is useful to have a naming convention for the various doubly heavy hadrons .
we will generically call the ground state a doubly heavy baryon with two @xmath43 quarks , @xmath44 , and the ground state of the tetraquark , @xmath45 , which are analogous to the heavy ( anti- ) meson , @xmath46 ( _ i.e. _ , the @xmath47 and @xmath48 mesons ) and heavy lambdas , @xmath49 .
we will use the following convention to indicate various types of hadron excitations : + @xmath50 indicates an excitation of type ( a ) ; + @xmath51 indicates an excitation of type ( b ) ; + @xmath52 indicates an excitation of type ( c ) . + + in addition
, we will indicate the dhda equivalence between associating baryons and mesons .
let us consider the phenomenological consequences of these types of excitations .
in hqet , the @xmath53 heavy spin symmetry causes states which are only different by a spin flip to have the same mass .
excitations of type ( a ) are the type which will break this symmetry creating a mass difference between these states .
for example , this will cause a mass difference between the spin-1 @xmath54 meson and the spin-0 @xmath55 meson . as this is the leading term to create the mass splitting
, hqet dictates that this splitting is @xmath56 with corrections of @xmath57 . additionally , there are corrections to this hyperfine splitting due to pnrqcd .
these corrections are related to the soft gluons that have been integrated out to construct the diquark potential .
the leading corrections contribute at two loops , as shown in ref .
@xcite , and are thus relative @xmath58 .
this implies in a correction to the mass splitting of @xmath59 , which is formally larger than the @xmath60 corrections of hqet in the infinite mass limit .
because @xmath61 is the smallest scale , these excitations should be the first excitations above the ground state .
excitations of type ( b ) are all other excitations associated with the light degrees of freedom .
these include orbital excitations between heavy and light components , as well as excitations within the light quark degrees of freedom .
due to the light quark mass , these excitations are in the non - perturbative regime of qcd , and can only be characterized by some general hadronic scale , @xmath22 .
perturbative corrections to this are , in turn , meaningless .
traditional nrqcd has not been applied to systems with valance light quark degrees of freedom , and thus has ignored these excitations .
hqet , on the other hand , combines these into the definitions of heavy fields from the outset , and thereby neglects them for the rest of the problem .
we see here that the excitations should be qualitatively the second smallest scale .
excitations of type ( c ) are internal diquark excitations .
these excitations correspond to the excited levels of the color coulombic potential that binds the diquark .
the binding potential is @xmath62 , where the factor of @xmath63 comes from color considerations .
this leads to energy levels and energy differences of : @xmath64 the last step is justified since at the heavy quark scale , @xmath65 .
this verifies that type ( c ) excitations are @xmath66 .
this type of excitation should be present in both the doubly heavy baryon and tetraquark sectors as the light quark interactions are suppressed since they are @xmath67 .
this leads to mass relations such as : @xmath68 since diquark excitations are @xmath66 , these are the largest excitations discussed here . the corrections to these relations can be found by considering the corrections to the color coulombic potential . in the context of nrqcd , it has been shown by @xcite that these corrections are @xmath69 at the heavy quark scale .
in addition to these excitations , dhda symmetry will relate heavy mesons , @xmath70 states , to doubly heavy baryons , @xmath8 states , and relate heavy baryons , @xmath33 states , to doubly heavy tetraquarks , @xmath34 states , which otherwise have the same quantum numbers .
therefore the following relations can be made : @xmath71 where @xmath55 and @xmath54 are standard spin-0 and spin-1 d - mesons , @xmath6 and @xmath72 are spin-@xmath11 and spin-@xmath73 doubly heavy baryons , @xmath49 is isospin-0 spin-@xmath11 heavy baryon , @xmath13 and @xmath74 are isospin-1 spin-@xmath11 and spin-@xmath73 heavy baryons , @xmath75 is a isospin-0 spin-0 doubly heavy tetraquark , @xmath76 , @xmath77 , @xmath78 are isospin-1 spin-0 , spin-1 , and spin-2 doubly heavy tetraquarks .
the dhda symmetry can then be used to relate the mass splittings @xcite .
equation ( [ eq : sw ] ) identifies the corrections to the mass splitting , but not to the dhda symmetry itself .
dhda symmetry relies on the interactions between the heavy diquark and the light quark(s ) .
these types of interactions , which are intrinsically non - perturbative , are not well understood in either nrqcd or hqet .
therefore , to understand the corrections to the symmetry , a new power counting scheme that combines the scales of nrqcd and hqet and is consistent with the other scales in the problem is necessary to account for these interactions systematically . at this time , such a system has not been formulated .
yet we can get a reasonable estimation of the corrections by considering the effects of the diquark structure compared with a point - like diquark on the dhda symmetry .
this consideration is exactly the form factor of the diquark relative to the scale of the light quark wave function .
the form factor can be calculated by taking the fourier transform of the square of the diquark wave function . in the limit of infinite heavy quarks ,
the diquark is in a coulombic wave function so the calculation is straightforward . assuming that the momentum transferred is @xmath67 , the form factor can be expanded to give the leading correction to dhda symmetry as follows : @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the corresponding `` bohr radius '' of the coulombic bound state of the diquark .
thus the corrections due to dhda are @xmath81 .
however , these corrections are formally smaller than the type ( a ) mass splitting correction of @xmath58 .
we can translate eq .
( [ eq : sw ] ) into the previous notation , and extend the relations to include the tetraquark splittings to have : @xmath82 where all quantities represent the mass of the corresponding particles . to summarize , the doubly heavy baryons and tetraquarks will have three types of excitations which are distinct in the heavy quark limit . from these we can construct the hadronic spectrum for these particles based upon these excitations and their relative size to one another .
additionally , these spectra are related to the hadronic spectra of heavy mesons and heavy baryons via the dhda symmetry .
these spectra are presented in figs .
[ fig : spec1 ] and [ fig : spec2 ] .
hadronic spectrum for doubly heavy baryons related to heavy mesons . ]
hadronic spectrum for doubly heavy tetraquarks related to heavy baryons . ]
in the previous section , we have worked solely in the infinite quark mass limit to determine what the spectrum would look like in this limit .
we have seen the usefulness of dhda symmetry in relating the the spectra of doubly heavy baryons to heavy mesons and doubly heavy tetraquarks to heavy baryons in this limit .
we would like to use this tool to interpret the corresponding spectra with a finite massive heavy quark . as the heavy quark mass is decreased from infinity
, we expect that the correction terms outlined above increase , until at a certain low enough quark mass , they become as dominant as the leading order resulting in a break down of the expansion .
the discovery of doubly charmed baryons by the selex collaboration provides the first experimental data to verify the heavy hadronic spectrum described .
an understanding of the selex data can provide an insight into whether dhda symmetry persists in the real world .
we can surmise that the selex data , along with real world parameters , could reveal one of three possible insights into the validity of dhda symmetry for doubly charmed states .
first , upon examining the data , we could find that the data supports a claim that the charm mass is heavy enough to be considered in the ideal large mass limit discussed in the previous section .
if this were the case the spectrum can be easily interpreted in terms of an approximate dhda symmetry .
secondly , the opposite could be true , namely that the selex data would be inconsistent with an approximate dhda symmetry .
this would indicate that the charm quark mass is simply too light for the symmetry to be manifest .
the last possibility is perhaps the most interesting , that data could suggest that charm quark mass is not heavy enough for the preceding argument to hold in full , but that data would still be consistent with some aspects of an approximate dhda symmetry .
this last option is not unreasonable as the dhda symmetry relies on the heavy diquark to be view as point - like with respect to the light degrees of freedom .
the infinite mass limit ensures the validity of this assumption , but a small - sized diquark might be achieved even with a relatively modest heavy quark mass . for this possibility
to be realized dynamics beyond the simple coulombic interaction must play a central role . to determine which of these possibilities is most consistent with the selex data , we will examine the size of each of the previously mentioned excitations , as well as their corrections , and compare them with experimentally determined parameters from the selex data . before doing this
, we should note a general word of caution .
the fact that the excited doubly charmed states were seen only via their weak decays presents a challenge to _ any _ simple interpretation of the data .
the problem is that the electro - magnetic lifetime of the excited states as estimated by any simple model should be short enough to wash out any detection of excited states via their weak decay @xcite .
any simple interpretation of the selex results can not simultaneously understand the type of excitation that is observed as well as the lack of an electro - magnetic decay channel .
therefore our focus here will be placing limitations on the type of excitation .
the excited state seen by selex shown in fig .
[ fig : specxi ] could be interpreted as either a type ( a ) spin excitation or a type ( c ) diquark excitation .
type ( b ) light quark excitations are ruled out as they occur on the scale of hadronic physics which is much larger than the reported excitation .
either interpretation , as we will discuss , explains aspects of the data , but neither provides a complete explanation .
let us consider the case where the excited states are type ( a ) spin excitations . from our discussion of the infinite mass case
, we would expect that even for a finite quark mass , these excitations would be the lowest lying occurring at @xmath56 . according to the selex data ,
the excitation energy is @xmath83mev . with this identification , the dhda mass splitting relations , eq .
( [ eq : sw ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : hdamass ] ) are satisfied with only a @xmath84 deficiency as has been pointed out elsewhere @xcite . this size of error is also consistent with the equations corrections of @xmath85 .
this appears to correspond to a success of dhda symmetry . at this point
, our predecessors , @xcite , have only verified that eq .
( [ eq : sw ] ) is satisfied .
this could be satisfied because dhda symmetry is the underlying phenomenon or because of a numerical conspiracy .
in order determine between these two scenarios , one needs to consider the other aspects of the spectrum and dhda symmetry . that is , are type ( c ) excitation larger than type ( a ) excitation as expected when a finite quark mass is considered , and is the spatial extent of the diquark small enough to consider it point - like
? we will first tackle the former condition .
for a diquark bound solely by color coulombic interactions , the excited state must by coulombic , and the excitation energy calculated from eq .
( [ eq : coloumb ] ) is justified . from eq .
( [ eq : coloumb ] ) , we can calculate the expected excitation energy of the diquark for a charm quark mass of @xmath86 gev and a velocity of @xmath87 .
this gives an excitation energy of @xmath88 mev !
this is a clear sign that the scale separation arising from the color coulombic interactions , expected for an infinite quark mass , is not present for the charm quark .
the constrains on dhda symmetry need to be examined .
the key issue in determining whether dhda symmetry could hold is the size of the diquark with regards to the light valance quark(s ) .
this can be addressed by either looking at the size of the diquark to determine if it is nearly point - like , or to determine the size of corrections of dhda symmetry as shown in eq .
( [ eq : hdacorrect ] ) .
the size of the diquark can be characterized by the rms radius of the state . for coulombic wave functions ,
the size of the diquark in the ground state is @xmath89 fm .
clearly this is not point - like on the scale of hadronic physics .
the large size of the ground state of the diquark also indicates that the excited state would be even larger .
such a spatially large excited state suggests that the excited state should extend beyond the color coulombic potential .
this invalidates the previous calculation , while emphasizing the absurdity of assuming that the diquark is bound deeply by the color coulombic interaction .
moreover , this further indicates that the diquark must be under the influence of interactions in addition the the color coulombic potential .
additionally , the corrections to dhda symmetry should be small compared with @xmath90 if the approximation is used . for the values for the charm quark ,
the correction can be calculated , from eq .
( [ eq : hdacorrect ] ) to be @xmath91 , which for a typical hadronic scale of @xmath92 gev is not much smaller than 1 .
thus both indicators show that the real world charm quark is not heavy enough to justify the point - like nature of the doubly heavy diquark which is necessary for the dhda symmetry .
it should be noted that the bottom quark has a mass marginally large enough to approach the infinite mass limit scaling .
the type ( c ) excitation is @xmath93 mev , with the type ( a ) excitation being @xmath94 mev calculated from the b - meson mass splitting .
additionally , the characteristic size is @xmath95 fm , and the correction to the dhda symmetry is @xmath96 .
all of these numbers show that for the bottom quark the scale hierarchy is as expected and corrections are relatively small , even if the scale separation is not complete .
however , presently doubly bottom baryons have not been observed experimentally . we have shown that a naive approach to dhda symmetry results in the conclusion that the charm quark is by no means heavy enough to believe that this symmetry is manifest in the real world , at least if it is to arise due to color coulombic interactions .
in other words , the relatively small charm quark mass causes the corrections to the infinite massive limit to become large enough to question the expansion for the excited states .
however , this does not completely rule out the possibility that dhda could hold approximately and that these excitations are type ( a ) .
the color coulombic interactions are not the only interactions that the charm quarks could experience as part of a diquark or a doubly heavy baryon .
since the charm quarks are not heavy enough to fall into the color coulombic region , it is reasonable to surmise that these other non - perturbative interactions could conspire in such a manner that would facilitate an approximate dhda symmetry .
however , these additional non - perturbative interactions are not systematically included in nrqcd .
therefore , in order to describe this system , a new expansion that combines the perturbative and non - perturbative scales of nrqcd and hqet in a systematic manner is needed . at present ,
such an expansion has not yet been formulated . nevertheless , by examining the properties of the interactions needed to maintain dhda symmetry , a general picture of the new theory could be made . before proceeding with a discussion of the conditions that dhda symmetry
imposes on additional non - perturbative interactions , an additional comment on the color coulombic potential is needed .
first , when we worked in the large mass limit , we were required to be in the regime of @xmath97 . however , with a finite massive quark this condition could be weakened to include @xmath38 . under this condition , the type(b ) and
type ( c ) excitation may mix since they are at the same energy scale . nevertheless , the key issue here is whether type ( a ) and type ( c ) excitations separate .
the possible inclusion of type ( b ) excitations with type ( c ) does not effect whether they are separated from type ( a ) , and hence do not effect the results discussed here .
secondly , the color coulombic potential is only the leading order term in nrqcd ; sub - leading terms might need to be included when a finite massive quark is considered .
however , since we have seen a need for a new expansion that includes the mixture of perturbative and non - perturbative effects , it is not clear whether the sub - leading terms suggested by nrqcd are the only sub - leading terms in the combined expansion . in both of these cases
though , additional interactions beyond the simple color coulombic potential are included .
it is not unreasonable that these , just like the ones hypothetically postulated above , would conspire so that the dhda symmetry would be manifest in an approximate manner in the real world . again
, a description of the conditions to obtain an approximate dhda symmetry will provide insight into these additional interactions whether they are nrqcd based or well beyond the scope of nrqcd and hqet .
there are two key places where the analysis based on the color coulombic potential fails to give rise to the dhda symmetry with real world parameters .
the assessment of these failures will provide conditions on the additional interactions to reestablish dhda symmetry .
the first is the characteristic size of the diquark .
we have already shown that for the coulombic potential , the size of the diquark is large enough not to be considered even remotely point - like from the point of view of hadronic dynamics .
secondly , the hierarchy of scales used to derive the result breaks down badly .
additional dynamics beyond color coulombic would need to create a diquark with a size much smaller than the characteristic hadronic size and to re - establish the spin excitations as the lowest lying excitations as we originally assumed .
an examination of the restrictions placed on the characteristic size of the diquark reveals the following .
the characteristic size of the diquark , which we will denote as @xmath98 , must be smaller than the size in a coulombic potential , denoted @xmath99 , and it must be small enough to allow the dhda corrections to be small . the correction term of eq .
( [ eq : hdacorrect ] ) can be rewritten in terms of this characteristic size as @xmath100 .
thus for the correction to be small @xmath101 .
@xmath99 must be larger than @xmath102 since @xmath99 already violates dhda symmetry and thus can not be smaller than @xmath102 .
therefore , in order for the diquark to be considered point - like , both @xmath103must be simultaneously satisfied . in order to insure this , in terms of size
, @xmath102 could be much smaller than @xmath99 , or @xmath102 could be of comparable size to @xmath99 .
consider the former possibility .
@xmath104 is equivalent to @xmath105 .
this implies that @xmath106 .
this relationship is never satisfied since @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
thus for dhda symmetry to occur the latter condition must hold .
it gives : @xmath109 implying @xmath110 .
as @xmath37 at the charmed quark mass scale _ is _ around @xmath111 , this relation can only be satisfied if @xmath112 .
it should be noted however , that an interaction that provides a characteristic size of the diquark which is consistent with eq .
( [ eq : ldhda ] ) is possible . for the purposes of our discussion here
, we needed to show that at least one kinematic region was possible , and the region where @xmath112 satisfies these conditions even though it should not be unique .
a couple of comments should be made about this condition .
the first is that naively appears not to occur even for the charm quark case . if one takes @xmath22 to be of the scale of @xmath23 it seems to be much smaller than @xmath113 .
however , we should note that the @xmath114 indicates `` of the same scale as '' under the assumption that the coefficients which arise in the expansion are `` natural '' _ i.e. _ of order unity .
if the dynamics are such that some of the coefficients multiplying @xmath22 are anomalously large , the condition @xmath115 could hold effectively .
the second key point is simply that if this does occur the system is clearly beyond the perturbative regime .
it should also be noted that that this should _ not _ be seen as a generic condition invalidating nrqcd .
rather it implies that _ for this particular system _ the expansion has broken down .
there is non - trivial evidence that this is in fact the case ; namely if one assumes that the expansion is working one gets inconsistent results .
the central question addressed here is not whether the expansion has broken down , rather it is whether one can still have a small diquark even if the expansion has broken down . if it indeed is the case that the condition @xmath112 is effectively met , then there is a possible characteristic size of the charmed diquark , for which dhda symmetry could be valid .
this region is simply a size that is much smaller than the length associated with the coulombic potential and smaller than the typical hadronic size .
thus far we have identified a possible kinetimatic region for which approximate dhda symmetry may be possible . however , to test whether this can occur in practice , we need to see whether plausible dynamics can drive the system into such a regime .
we do this by considering a `` reasonable '' dynamical model for the interaction between the heavy quarks . this model is not intended to be an accurate description of hadronic physics .
the goal is simply to see whether a simple model with natural scales can put the system in the regime where dhda symmetry emerges at least approximately .
the existence of a model which does this shows that an approximate dhda symmetry could be present in charm physics despite the fact that nrqcd in the coulombic regime plus hqet alone do not give rise to an approximate dhda symmetry with the real world charm quark mass . to illustrate the kind of model which brings us into this regime , we consider a linear confining potential with a string tension of @xmath116 .
such a potential , with the same string tension , can be used to get a reasonable description of the @xmath117 @xcite .
one might not believe that such a model is applicable at all distances , to which we will attempt to apply .
indeed , one may reasonably question whether any two - body potential description is sensible .
nevertheless the scales of the model are at least instructive .
any confining potential that can be introduced will cause the characteristic size of the diquark to be reduced , thus the conditions on the diquark size may be satisfied . specifically for the linear confining potential above binding charmed quarks , the characteristic length is @xmath118 fm .
this is substantially smaller than the coulombic wave function and might be small enough so that approximate dhda might emerge .
moreover , the small size of the bound state helps to justify the two - body potential description _ a posteriori _ ; the effects of the light quark between the heavy ones should be suppressed due to the small size .
unfortunately , this calculation is not part of a systematic calculation , and it is not immediately clear how to reliably estimate the size of the correction to the leading order dhda estimate for the splitting
. calculations of the energy spectrum of coulombic plus linear confining potentials in this channel reveals that the radial excitation energy is @xmath119 mev , far above the @xmath120 mev energy associated with expected spin excitations .
thus this linear confining potential satisfies both of the conditions needed to believe that an approximate dhda symmetry could be realized for charmed quarks .
we have thus found a region where an approximate dhda symmetry could be realized approximately and the lowest lying excitations are type ( a ) spin excitations .
the color coulombic interactions can not be the only relevant interactions that the heavy quarks experience ( as is assumed in the heavy quark mass limit ) .
of course the question of whether the dynamics as such is realized in nature , remains an open question .
even though we have provided a consistent argument for the observed excited states to be spin excitation , there remains a phenomenological issue with the parity of the excited state .
type ( a ) excitations do not change the parity of the excited state relative to the ground state .
ground state baryons have positive parity , thus the spin excited state should also have positive parity . experimentally , the parity of the excited states has not been determined .
the selex collaboration have argued that the orbital angular momentum of the ground state is consistent with @xmath121 ( positive parity ) , while the excited state is consistent with @xmath122 ( either positive or negative parity ) .
furthermore , selex observed an orbital excited state @xmath123 which has negative parity and decays via pion emission to @xmath124 suggesting that this state could have negative parity . if this parity assignment holds , the interpretation that the excited states were spin excitations , made here and in refs .
@xcite , would be ruled out .
now let us consider the case where the excitation is interpreted as a type ( c ) diquark excitation .
type ( c ) excitations could result in a parity flip from the ground state .
this would resolve the parity problem found with the spin excitation interpretation . as we will discuss below ,
if this scenario is correct we are almost certainly outside the regime of validity of dhda as well as outside the regime of validity of nrqcd .
moreover , it is likely to be very difficult to make such a scenario work phenomenologically . in order for diquark excitations to be smaller than the spin excitations
, there must be a break down of the heavy quark mass limit ; the system must reside in a non - perturbative regime .
therefore , as with the previous case , the diquark can be under the influence of non - perturbative interactions beyond the color coulombic interactions .
we showed that if these additional confining interactions maintained an approximate dhda symmetry , the diquark excitations were much larger than the observed @xmath83 mev excitation .
again we can illustrate this with a linearly rising potential between the heavy quarks . in order for the diquark excitations to be comparable to the observed splitting
, the linear confining interactions must have a string constant of @xmath125 , which is very small compared to the natural scales in the problem .
the small size of the linear confining interactions results in the diquark having a larger size , and makes the assumptions that it is point - like even less believable . for the string constant of 50 @xmath126 considered here
, the ground state of the diquark has an rms radius of @xmath127 fm , and the first excited state has an rms radius of @xmath128 fm .
these numbers are extremely large compared to typical hadronic sizes .
the preceding model calculation suggests that if the excitation were the excitation of the diquark , the dhda symmetry can not be valid even approximately .
it also raises a fundamental issue of self - consistency .
a large spatially extent diquark allows the light quark to come between the two heavy quarks allowing for three - body interactions to play a significant dynamical role .
to the extent that this occurs , it is meaningless as a phenomenological matter to separate the diquark excitation from excitations of the entire system .
thus , excitations of type ( b ) and ( c ) would strongly mix and the entire structure of scale separation would break down .
we note that this analysis was based on a very simple and not terribly plausible model .
however , it does incorporate the natural scales of the problem and shows that the excited state wave functions are _ much _ too large to be taken seriously .
it is also clear that it would be very hard to construct any potential model which restricts the diquark size to be much less than a fermi while having an excitation energy of @xmath83 mev .
to illustrate this point , we can consider a harmonic confining potential instead of the linear potential .
we would expect that this potential would confine the excited state and reduce its size more than the linear potential . calculating the size of the diquark under these conditions for an excitation energy of @xmath83 mev results in a ground state rms radius of @xmath129 fm and an excited state rms radius of @xmath130 fm . even though the diquark size is smaller , it is still very large in terms of hadronic physics .
furthermore , if we were able to drive the size of the excited state to a reasonable hadronic size , say , @xmath90 fm , the ground state would be even smaller .
such a small ground state size is then consistent with spin excitations discussed previously .
it thus seems difficult for this scenario to be correct .
together these two scenarios make it very difficult to understand the data in a simple way .
if the parity of the is the parity of the states is correctly interpreted by selex , there does not appear to be any simple phenomoenologically reasonable interactions yielding either small diquark excitations or dhda symmetry .
however , if we set the parity designation aside , scenario i , the assignment of type ( a ) spin excitations , seems to be the more plausible interpretation .
the selex data on doubly heavy baryons is very difficult to interpret .
as noted in the introduction , the fact the excited states were detectable through their weak decays when there were open channels for electromagnetic decays is very problematic ; normally one would expect these to dilute the strength to the point that the states would be very difficult to see . despite this problem ,
we have attempted to understand the selex states in the context of dhda symmetry .
we have shown that the data is not consistent with the heavy quark mass limit , but this does not rule out an approximate dhda symmetry .
this could emerge if diquark interactions beyond color coulombic interactions are considered . as such , a new systematic expansion , which is a hybrid of hqet and nrqcd but outside the domain of the color coulombic , would be the most appropriate to describe the physics of doubly heavy baryons .
such an expansion could help in the understanding of the selex observations . at the same time it is critical to add to our understanding of the experimental situation .
in particular , it is essential that the observed states be confirmed in other experiments ; that the parity of the states are pinned down ; and the accurate measurements of electromagnetic transitions are made .
these measurements are critical in understanding the doubly charm baryon spectrum as well as the validity of dhda symmetry in charm physics .
m. mattson _
( selex collaboration ) , phys .
lett.*89 * , 112001 ( 2002 ) ; m.a .
moinester _ et al .
_ ( selex collaboration ) , czech .
j. phys .
* 53 * , b201 ( 2003 ) ; a. ocherashvili _ et al . _
( selex collaboration ) , phys .
lett.b * 628 * , 18 ( 2005 ) ; j. a. russ , http://www-nuclear.tau.ac.il/ murrym / jimjune2003.pdf b. aubert _ et al . _
( babar colaboration ) , hep - ex/0605075 .
a. pineda and j. soto , nucl .
suppl . * 64 * , 428 ( 1998 ) ; n. brambilla , a. pineda , j. soto , and a. vairo , nucl .
* b566 * , 275 ( 2000 ) ; n. brambilla , a. pineda , j. soto , and a. vairo , re .
phys . * 77 * , 1423 ( 2005 ) . | in the limit of heavy quark masses going to infinity , a symmetry is known to emerge in qcd relating properties of hadrons with two heavy quarks to analogous states with one heavy anti - quark .
a key question is whether the charm mass is heavy enough so that this symmetry is manifest in at least an approximate manner .
the issue is crucial in attempting to understand the recent reports by the selex collaboration of doubly charmed baryons .
we argue on very general grounds that the charm quark mass is substantially too light for the symmetry to emerge automatically via colour coulombic interactions . however , the symmetry could emerge approximately depending on the dynamical details of the non - perturbative physics . to treat the problem systematically , a new expansion that simultaneously incorporates nrqcd and hqet
is needed . |
supernova sn 1993j in m81 discovered by francisco garca of lugo , spain ( @xcite ) is a type iib supernova ( sn ) whose red giant progenitor probably had a mass of 12 - 16 while on the main sequence ; at the time of the explosion , 3 - 5 likely remained in the he core and @xmath01 in the he / h envelope ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) .
the first maximum in the supernova optical light curve has been attributed to shock heating of the thin envelope and the second to radioactive decay of @xmath1co ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) .
modelling of the x - ray emission ( @xcite ) also implies a relatively low mass envelope due to interaction with a binary companion ( @xcite , @xcite ) .
+ the standard circumstellar interaction model hereafter standard model or sm for radio supernovae ( @xcite and references therein ) suggests that the radio emission arises from a shocked region between the supernova ejecta and the circumstellar material ( csm ) that results from the wind of the sn s progenitor star .
more specifically , the sm considers sn ejecta with steep density profiles ( @xmath2 ) shocked by a reverse shock that moves inwards from the contact surface and a csm with density profile @xmath3 shocked by a forward shock that moves outwards from the contact surface ( @xmath4=2 corresponds to a steady wind ) . for @xmath5@xmath65 ,
self - similar solutions are possible ( @xcite ) ; the radii of the discontinuity surface , forward shock and reverse shock are then related and all evolve in time with a power law r @xmath7 ( @xmath8 , time after explosion ) , where @xmath9=@xmath10 .
+ sn 1993j is the closest sn that is both young and radio bright ( @xcite ) and hence offers a unique opportunity for the study of its radio structure and the test of radio supernova models ( @xcite , @xcite ) .
marcaide et al .
( 1995a ) found the radio structure to be shell - like .
multiwavelength radio light curves and high resolution radio images of sn 1993j ( @xcite , @xcite , respectively ) established the self - similar nature of the expansion .
+ the technique of vlbi can , in principle , determine @xmath9 directly by simply observing the angular growth rate of the supernova .
bartel et al . ( 1994 ) and marcaide et al .
( 1995b ) found that @xmath9=1 was compatible with their results to within their respective uncertainties . in this paper , we present vlbi results for @xmath116 cm through october 1996 ( 42 months after explosion ) , combined with those already published for @xmath113.6 cm ( @xcite ) , to estimate the deceleration in the supernova expansion and to infer the density profiles of the supernova ejecta and csm .
in our @xmath116 cm vlbi observations of sn 1993j , global arrays formed by the phased - vla , antennas in effelsberg ( germany ) and medicina and noto ( italy ) , and various subsets of the 10-antenna vlba were used . for the first 3 epochs ( see table 1 ) mkiiia instrumentation and a recording bandwidth of 56 mhz were used and the data were correlated at the max planck institut fuer radioastronomie in bonn , germany . for the last 4 epochs , vlba instrumentation and a recording bandwidth of 64 mhz were used and the data were correlated at the national radio astronomy observatory in socorro , nm .
the sources 0917 + 624 , 0954 + 658 , and the nucleus of m81 were observed as calibrators , the first two as amplitude calibrators and the nucleus of m81 both as an amplitude calibrator and , for epochs later than june 1996 , as a phase calibrator . in all cases we analyzed the data using difmap ( @xcite ) in a standard way using measured system temperatures and either antenna - temperature measurements or gain - curve information from each antenna as initial calibration . for 0917 + 624
, we obtained brightness maps using self - calibration and the source structure determined by standke et al .
( 1996 ) as an initial model .
the calibration correction factors obtained with the self - calibration of 0917 + 624 were then applied to calibrate the data of sn 1993j and the nucleus of m81 .
a similar iteration was carried out using the very compact , vlbi nucleus of m81 and those new calibration corrections were also applied to the calibration of the data of sn 1993j .
+ we constructed a map of sn 1993j for each epoch , using a standard process .
we used each of the following initial models : a point source , a scaled model from a previous epoch , and a super - symmetrized scaled model ( obtained by rotating the scaled model by @xmath12 , such that 360/@xmath12 is an integer @xmath5 , then rotating by 2@xmath12 , etc . , adding all the rotated models , and rescaling the resulting flux density distribution ) .
the total flux density in each map was checked against the light curve of van dyk et al .
( 1994 ) and recent vla measurements .
agreement was found to be better than 5% except for two epochs where the discrepancy was as large as 8% .
the resultant maps were virtually independent of the starting model and are shown in plate 1 .
for this display circular convolving beams with sizes proportional to the number of days elapsed since the explosion were used ( see table 1 ) .
such beams permit both a better visualization of the self - similar expansion ( the radio structure remains similar except for a scale factor ) and a better estimate of the deceleration parameter @xmath9 . in figure 1
we show the map from the latest epoch ( 22 october 1996 ) convolved with an elliptical gaussian beam whose half - power size is given by the corresponding size of the main lobe of the interferometric beam from that epoch , so that the details of the source structure are more visible than in plate 1 .
each map of sn 1993j shows a shell - like radio source .
the inferred source size depends on how the map is constructed and how it is measured . because of the non point - like size of the vlbi beam ,
a positive bias is introduced in the size estimate of each map : the estimated size is larger than the true size . the fractional bias will systematically decrease for a source increasing in size if the same beam applies for all observations . if uncorrected , this bias introduces a bias in the estimate of the growth rate of the source .
however , for self - similar expansion , as here , a method can be found ( see below ) such that the bias can be kept approximately constant with source growth and hence does not significantly affect the estimate of the deceleration parameter .
+ if the shape of the expanding source does not change and the expansion rate is nearly constant we can largely avoid introducing a spurious deceleration by using a beam size proportional to the number of days between the explosion and the epoch of the source map .
plate 1 ( see also @xcite ) shows that we are indeed in such a situation .
an alternate mapping procedure based on using beam sizes proportional to actual source sizes would produce , in principle , a ( slight ) improvement . in practice
, other map errors would probably prevent any discernible improvement .
+ to use convolving beams as similar as feasible to the vlbi beams and still use the above - described procedure , we chose a range of convolving beam sizes so that each is always within a factor of two of its vlbi beam .
for the early epochs , we therefore chose small convolving beams and overresolved our images by almost a factor of two ; for the late epochs , we chose large convolving beams and degraded the map resolution by almost a factor of two .
we also applied the same criteria to the @xmath113.6 cm maps ( @xcite ) .
+ in table 1 , we list the measured outer radius of the supernova shell for each epoch of observation and plot the results in figure 2 .
each such size was estimated by the average of the source diameter at the 50% contour level of the map from eight uniformly - spread azimuthal cuts through the map .
the standard errors quoted in table 1 result from adding in quadrature an error twice as large as the measurement error in the diameters and an error in determining the 50% contour level location due to map noise and beam size limitations .
using r @xmath13 @xmath14 for the @xmath116 cm data yields @[email protected] ; combining the @xmath113.6 and @xmath116 cm data gives @[email protected] .
figure 2 shows only the latter result .
the reduced chi - square of the model fit is 0.9 ; the quoted error has been scaled to correspond to a reduced chi - square of unity .
in contrast , a fit of a straight line ( @xmath9=1 ) to the data gives a reduced chi - square of 6.0 .
+ we find , too , that the better the calibration and the more vlbi observations at a given epoch , the more spherical and the smoother the resultant image .
thus , some of the small emission asymmetries in the images may be artifacts .
our maps give no indication of any structures developing in the shell by the action of either raleigh - taylor instabilities ( @xcite ) or interaction with the csm .
there is also no evidence of any departure from circularity as suggested by some authors to explain the action of a putative binary companion .
we also do not see any emission above @xmath160.5 mjy from any compact source at the center of the structure ( i.e. , a pulsar as suggested by woosley et al .
( 1994 ) and shigeyama et al .
( 1994 ) ) .
+ within the framework of self - similar models , measurement of the time dependence of the attenuation of the supernova radio emission due to the circumstellar plasma allows us to estimate the exponent of a power law representation of the density profile of the csm : for free - free absorption as commonly invoked in radio supernova models ( weiler et al . 1996 and references therein ) , the opacity , @xmath17 , is proportional to the density squared integrated along the line of sight . given a supernova radius r @xmath13 @xmath14 and @xmath18 , then @xmath17 @xmath13 @xmath19 .
van dyk et al . ( 1994 ) found @xmath17 @xmath13 @xmath20 with @xmath21=@xmath22 for the homogeneous component of the csm . combining this result with @[email protected]
, we obtain @xmath4=@xmath23 . this value is lower than the @xmath4=2 in the sm for a constant stellar wind , but very close to the value @xmath4=1.7 given by fransson et al .
( 1996 ) to explain the x - ray emission ( @xcite ) .
van dyk et al . ( 1994 ) also obtain a similar time dependence for the attenuation of a clumpy medium and hence argue that the clumpy component is spatially distributed in the same way as the homogeneous component .
houck and fransson ( 1996 ) also argue in favor of a clumpy medium based on optical line profiles .
suzuki and nomoto ( 1995 ) postulate csm with homogeneous and clumpy components to explain x - ray data , but they consider two regions : ( 1 ) an inner homogeneous region with a density profile described by @xmath4=1.7 out to radii smaller than @xmath16 5@xmath24@xmath25 cm and ( 2 ) an outer clumpy region with density profile described by @xmath4=3 for the interclump medium at larger radii .
such a model of the csm allows suzuki and nomoto ( 1995 ) to fit their model to all of the available x - ray data .
specifically , the @xmath4=3 clumpy medium is needed to account for the hard x - rays and for part of the h@xmath26 emission .
the supernova explosion model of suzuki and nomoto ( 1995 ) , consisting of ejecta and a clumpy csm as described above , is very different from self - similar models ( @xcite ) .
+ the self - similar case with @xmath9=0.86 and @xmath4=1.66 gives an ejecta density profile of @xmath5=@xmath27 .
these values correspond to steep profiles , indeed much steeper than the profiles of white dwarfs ( @xmath5=7 ) , but less steep than those suggested by baron et al .
( 1995 ) from spectral analyses or those used by suzuki and nomoto ( 1995 ) . in the sm for values @xmath5=11.2 and @xmath4=1.66 ,
the reverse shock radius is @xmath162% smaller , and the forward shock radius @xmath1620% larger , than the radius of the contact surface between shocked supernova ejecta and shocked csm ( @xcite ) .
+ marcaide et al . ( 1995b ) estimate that the width of the radio shell is about 0.3 times the size of the outer radius ( or , equivalently , about 40% of the inner radius ) .
these authors also estimate expansion speeds @xmath16 15,000 km @xmath28 which are compatible with the largest velocities ( @xmath16 11,000 km @xmath28 ) measured in h@xmath26 ( @xcite , @xcite ) if ( i ) the h@xmath26 emission originates in the vicinity of the reverse shock , ( ii ) a homologous expansion is assumed in the ejecta and shocked regions , and ( iii ) the shock shell is about twice as large as predicted in the sm . in an attempt to reconcile the sm and
the observational results , houck and fransson ( 1996 ) suggest that clumpy ejecta and/or csm can broaden the shell . on the other hand ,
the region of the ejecta shocked by the reverse shock in the model of suzuki and nomoto ( 1995 ) is even larger than that of the csm shocked by the forward shock .
however , the maximum speeds of the radio outer shell and of the region of h@xmath26 emission in the model of suzuki and nomoto ( 1995 ) match those observed very well , although the density and velocity profiles in the shell are very different from those of the standard model .
+ if we consider only vlbi results from epochs more than 500 days after the explosion , we obtain @[email protected] and @xmath4=@xmath29 .
however , such an age range is in the region in which the suzuki and nomoto ( 1995 ) model suggests @xmath4=3.0 .
a contradiction is apparent and our results therefore argue against their model .
our estimate of @xmath4 based on that of @xmath9 is not dependent on a given explosion model but is a determination from the time dependence of the opacity due to an external medium ( @xcite,@xcite ) .
furthermore , such time dependence of the opacity has not changed between days 200 and 1000 ( van dyk , priv . comm . ) .
+ if the physical picture of the radio and h@xmath26 emission in the sm were correct , the @xmath1615% decrease in expansion speed measured by vlbi between months 12 and 42 after explosion should be observable in the h@xmath26 emission .
on the other hand , if the model of suzuki and nomoto ( 1995 ) were correct , a decrease in the maximum speed of h@xmath26 would not be expected . + this research is supported in part by the spanish dgicyt grants pb93 - 0030 and pb94 - 1275 and by eu contracts chgect920011 and fmgect950012 .
part of this research was carried out at the harvard - smithsonian center for astrophysics under grant ast-9303527 from the national science foundation ( nsf ) and at the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
kww wishes to thank the office of naval research for the 6.1 funding supporting this research .
the national radio astronomy observatory is a facility of the nsf operated under cooperative agreement by associated universities , inc .
26-sep-93 & 182 & 3.6 & 78.5 & 0.550.46 ( 13.6 ) & 0.26 & 464@xmath1590 22-nov-93 & 239 & 3.6 & 57.3 & 0.520.45 ( 0.7 ) & 0.34 & 612@xmath1522 20-feb-94 & 330 & 3.6 & 51.0 & 0.530.44 ( 6.5 ) & 0.46 & 824@xmath1590 29-may-94 & 427 & 3.6 & 41.5 & 0.610.52 ( 25.8 ) & 0.60 & 1071@xmath1528 20-sep-94 & 541 & 6 & 53.4 & 0.990.82 ( -47.2 ) & 0.76 & 1202@xmath1530 23-feb-95 & 697 & 6 & 44.3 & 1.110.77 ( 17.2 ) & 0.98 & 1567@xmath1533 11-may-95 & 774 & 6 & 41.8 & 1.220.88 ( 18.0 ) & 1.09 & 1701@xmath1539 01-oct-95 & 917 & 6 & 32.2 & 1.571.24 ( -27.0 ) & 1.29 & 2026@xmath1555 28-mar-96 & 1096 & 6 & 31.3 & 1.581.23 ( -58.0 ) & 1.54 & 2301@xmath1572 17-jun-96 & 1177 & 6 & 26.5 & 1.371.11 ( 30.2 ) & 1.65 & 2414@xmath15102 22-oct-96 & 1304 & 6 & 26.1 & 1.200.97 ( -6.1 ) & 1.83 & 2639@xmath15100 | a rarity among supernova , sn 1993j in m81 can be studied with high spatial resolution .
its radio power and distance permit vlbi observations to monitor the expansion of its angular structure .
this radio structure was previously revealed to be shell - like and to be undergoing a self - similar expansion at a constant rate . from vlbi observations at the wavelengths of 3.6 and 6 cm in the period 6 to 42 months after explosion , we have discovered that the expansion is decelerating .
our measurement of this deceleration yields estimates of the density profiles of the supernova ejecta and circumstellar material in standard supernova explosion models . |
entanglement is a key quantum resource for quantum information processing and it plays a critical role in many important applications in quantum communication , such as quantum key distribution @xcite , quantum dense coding @xcite , quantum teleportation @xcite , and entanglement swapping @xcite . some important goals in quantum communication
require the complete and deterministic analysis of the bell states .
in 1999 , vaidman s @xcite and l@xmath0tkenhau s @xcite groups put forward a bell - state analysis ( bsa ) for teleportation with only linear optical elements . unfortunately , with linear - optical elements , one can obtain the optimal success probability of 50% both in theory @xcite and in experiment @xcite ( of course , by guessing at random when an ambiguous result is obtained , one can technically achieve a 75% success rate in identifying the four bell states ) .
the bsa on photon pairs entangled in one degree of freedom ( dof ) attracted much attention @xcite .
the entanglement of photon pairs in several dofs @xcite , called it hyperentanglement , is useful in quantum information processing , especially in quantum communication for completing bsa on polarizations of photon pairs @xcite , performing entanglement purification @xcite , distributing entangled polarization states faithfully @xcite , or improving the channel capacity .
for example , kwiat and weinfurter @xcite first introduced the way to distinguish the four orthogonal bell states of photon pairs in the polarization dof with the hyperentanglement in both the polarization dof and the momentum dof in 1998 . in 2003 , walborn et al .
@xcite proposed a simple scheme for completing bell - state measurement for photon pairs entangled in the polarization dof or the momentum dof by using hyperentangled states with linear optics .
the experiments of a complete bsa have also been reported with polarization - time - bin hyperentanglement @xcite and polarization - momentum hyperentanglement @xcite later .
it implies a complete bsa in the polarization dof can be accomplished with hyperentanglement in a larger hilbert space by introducing other dofs . in 2008 , barreiro et al . @xcite
beat the channel capacity limit for linear photonic superdense coding with polarization - orbital - angular - momentum hyperentanglement . in 2002 ,
simon and pan @xcite proposed an entanglement purification protocol ( epp ) using hyperentanglement in both the polarization and the spatial dofs . in 2008 ,
an efficient epp based on a parametric down - conversion source was proposed , resorting to this hyperentanglement @xcite . in 2010 ,
deterministic epps were proposed with hyperentanglement @xcite . in 2010 , a faithful entanglement distribution scheme for polarization was proposed @xcite , resorting to the stability of the frequency entanglement of photon pairs . considering a large hilbert space with an additional dof , e.g. , a quantum system in a hyperentangled state in two dofs which span the hilbert space with 16 orthogonal bell states , one can not distinguish them completely with only linear optics . in 2007 , wei et al .
@xcite pointed out that 7 states in the group of 16 orthogonal bell states is distinguishable with only linear optics . in 2011 , pisenti et al .
@xcite presented a very general theoretical explanation of the inadequacy of linear evolution and local measurement in ( hyperentangled- ) bell - state analysis , and they pointed out the limitations for manipulation and measurement of entangled systems with inherently linear , unentangling devices .
if nonlinear optics is introduced , these 16 orthogonal bell states can be distinguished completely . in 2010 ,
sheng et al .
@xcite presented a complete hyperentangled bsa ( hbsa ) with cross - kerr nonlinearity . although a lot of works have been studied on cross - kerr nonlinearity @xcite , a clean cross - kerr nonlinearity in the optical single - photon regime
is still quite a controversial assumption with current technology @xcite . in recent years
, a solid state system based on an electron spin in a quantum dot ( qd ) has attracted much attention with its giant nonlinearity . in 2008 ,
@xcite proposed a quantum nondemolition method using the interaction of left - circularly and right - circularly polarized lights with a one - side qd - cavity system .
this nonlinear optics in a qd - cavity system can be used to construct multi - photon entangler @xcite and photonic polarization bsa @xcite . in 2010 ,
bonato et al .
@xcite proposed a photonic polarization bsa using quantum - dot microcavities in the weak - coupling limit . in 2011 , hu et al .
@xcite presented some interesting schemes for bsa using the nonlinear optics of a single quantum - dot spin in a one - side optical microcavity . in this article , we present complete hbsa with the nonlinear optics based on a one - side qd - cavity system .
it can be used to distinguish completely the 16 hyperentangled bell states in both the polarization and the spatial - mode dofs of two - photon systems .
this scheme divides the process for hbsa into two steps .
the first step is to distinguish the four bell states in spatial - mode dof , without destroying the two - photon system itself and its state in the polarization dof .
this task should resort to quantum nondemolition detectors ( qnds ) based on nonlinear optics of a one - side qd - cavity system . in the second step
, one can adjust the qd - cavity systems to distinguish the four bell states in the polarization dof .
this hbsa scheme can be applied to increase the channel capacity of long - distance quantum communication based on hyperentanglement , such as entanglement swapping , teleportation , and superdense coding .
we use hyperentanglement swapping as an example to show its application .
considering a singly charged qd in a cavity , e.g. , a self - assembled in(ga)as qd or a gaas interface qd inside an optical resonant microcavity , the qd is located in the center of the cavity to achieve a maximal light - matter coupling . with an excess electron injected into the qd
, the singly charged qd shows the optical resonance with the negatively charged exciton @xmath1 that consists of two electrons bound to one hole @xcite .
according to pauli s exclusion principle , @xmath1 has spin - dependent transitions @xcite .
if the excess electron in the qd is in the spin state @xmath2 , only the left circularly polarized light @xmath3 can be resonantly absorbed to create the negatively charged exciton in the state @xmath4 with two antiparallel electron spins . here
@xmath5 represents a heavy - hole spin state @xmath6 . if the excess electron in the qd is in the spin state @xmath7 , only the right circularly polarized light @xmath8 can be resonantly absorbed to create the negatively charged exciton in the state @xmath9 with two antiparallel electron spins . here
@xmath10 represents the heavy - hole spin state @xmath11 .
they have different phase shifts when the photons in these two different circularly polarized states are reflected from the qd - cavity system . .
( a ) a charged qd inside a micropillar microcavity with circular cross section .
( b ) spin selection rule for optical transitions of negatively charged exciton @xmath1 due to the pauli s exclusion principle . @xmath12 and @xmath13 represent the left and the right circularly polarized lights , respectively.,width=302 ] the whole process can be represented by heisenberg equations for the cavity field operator @xmath14 and @xmath1 dipole operator @xmath15 in the interaction picture @xcite , @xmath16 a -g\sigma_--\sqrt{\kappa}\ , a_{in } , \\
\frac{d\sigma_-}{dt } \;\ ; & = \;\ ; -[i(\omega_{x^-}- \omega ) + \frac{\gamma}{2 } ] \sigma_- - g\sigma_z \ , a,\\ a_{out } \;\ ; & = \;\ ; a_{in}+\sqrt{\kappa}\ , a , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 are the frequencies of the input probe light , cavity mode , and @xmath1 transition , respectively .
@xmath20 is the coupling strength between @xmath1 and the cavity mode , @xmath21 and @xmath22 are the decay rates of @xmath1 and the cavity field , and @xmath23 is the side leakage rate of the cavity . with a weak excitation condition ( @xmath1 stays in the ground state at most time and @xmath24 ) , the reflection coefficient for the qd - cavity system can be obtained as @xcite @xmath25}{[i(\omega_{x^-}-\omega ) + \frac{\gamma}{2}][i(\omega_c-\omega)+\frac{\kappa}{2}+\frac{\kappa_s}{2}]+g^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ]
one can get the reflection coefficient @xmath26 for a cold cavity with the uncoupled qd by taking @xmath27 as following @xcite : @xmath28 if the excess electron is in the spin state @xmath2 , the @xmath3 light feels a hot cavity ( coupled with the qd - cavity system ) and gets a phase shift of @xmath29 after being reflected ( the subscript @xmath30 represents a hot cavity ) , whereas the @xmath8 light feels a cold cavity and gets a phase shift of @xmath31 . by adjusting the frequencies @xmath17 and @xmath18 , one can get the reflection coefficients @xmath32 for a cold cavity and @xmath33 for a hot cavity . as the linearly polarized probe beam
can be regarded as the superposition of two circularly polarized components @xmath34 , the state of the reflected light becomes @xmath35 after it is reflected from the one - side qd - cavity system .
conversely , if the excess electron is in the spin state @xmath7 , the @xmath3 light feels a cold cavity and gets a phase shift of @xmath31 after being reflected , while the @xmath8 light feels a hot cavity and gets a phase shift of @xmath29 .
the linear polarized probe beam @xmath34 becomes @xmath36 after being reflected .
the polarization direction of the reflected light rotates an angle @xmath37 , which is the so - called faraday rotation .
if the electron is in a superposition spin state @xmath38 and the photon is in the state @xmath39 , after being reflected , the light - spin state evolves as @xmath40,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath41 , @xmath42 $ ] , and @xmath43 $ ] .
in a one - side cavity , due to spin selection rule above , @xmath3 and @xmath8 lights pick up two different phase shifts after being reflected from the qd - cavity system , and then the state of the system composed of the light and the excess electron becomes an entangled one .
a hyperentangled two - photon bell state in both the polarization and the spatial - mode dofs has the form as @xmath44 here , the superscripts @xmath45 and @xmath46 represent the two photons in the hyperentangled state .
the subscript @xmath47 denotes the polarization dof and @xmath48 is the spatial - mode dof .
@xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) and @xmath51 ( @xmath52 ) are the different spatial modes for the photon @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) .
we denote the four bell states in the polarization dof as @xmath53 and the four bell states in the spatial - mode dof as @xmath54 also we refer to the states @xmath55 and @xmath56 as the odd - parity states , and @xmath57 and @xmath58 as the even - parity states . .
( a ) the qnd is used to distinguish the odd - parity states @xmath59 from the even - parity states @xmath60 .
( b ) the qnd is used to distinguish the `` + '' phase state @xmath61 ( @xmath62 ) from the `` - '' phase states @xmath63 ( @xmath64 ) .
the dashed line presents the case that the photons @xmath45 coming from the spatial mode @xmath65 and @xmath46 coming from @xmath66 pass through qd@xmath67 in sequence .
the small mirror is used to reflect the photon for interacting with the cavity twice .
hwp represents a half - wave plate which is used to perform a phase - flip operation @xmath68 in the polarization dof , while hwp@xmath67 represents another half - wave plate which is used to perform a bit - flip operation @xmath69 in the polarization dof .
bs represents a 50:50 beam splitter.,width=12 ] the optical properties of a singly charged qd in a strong - coupling single - side microcavity , which has been used for a controlled - phase gate , can be used to construct a quantum nondemolition detector ( qnd ) , as shown in fig.[figure2 ] .
let us assume that the initial states of the excess electron in the cavity and a single photon injected are @xmath70 and @xmath71 , respectively . by adjusting the frequencies
@xmath72 to get the phase shift difference between the left and the right circular polarization lights as @xmath73 , the function of a single photon interacting with a qd - cavity system twice is @xmath74 one can detect whether or not there is a photon interacting with the qd - cavity system by measuring the spin state of the excess electron with the orthogonal basis @xmath75 , there is a photon interacting with the qd - cavity system ( with a phase - flip operation @xmath76 on the photon , its original polarization state is recovered ) .
otherwise , there is no photon ( or there are two photons ) interacting with the qd - cavity system when the state of excess electron does nt change .
therefore , if the state of excess electron in qd is not changed , there are an even number of photons detected by the qd - cavity system . with this principle
, the qd - cavity system can be used as a qnd to distinguish the case with an even number of photons from that with an odd number of photons .
now , we will use this photon - number qnd to construct a parity - check qnd for the spatial - mode states of a photon pair .
if the excess electrons in qd@xmath67 in fig.[figure2](a ) is prepared initially in the state @xmath77 , after the photons @xmath45 and @xmath46 pass through qd@xmath67 in sequence , the state of the excess electron is in @xmath77 with the input states @xmath59 ( odd - parity ) .
however , the state of the excess electron becomes @xmath78 if the input states are @xmath60 ( even - parity ) . by applying a hadamard gate on the excess electron spin ,
the spin superposition states @xmath79 and @xmath80 can be rotated to the states @xmath2 and @xmath7 , respectively . if we have an auxiliary photon @xmath81 in the initial state @xmath82 and let it pass through qd@xmath67 , after it is reflected from the cavity , the state of the system composed of the photon and the qd electron spin becomes @xmath83 the output state of the auxiliary photon @xmath81 can be measured in orthogonal linear polarization basis .
if the auxiliary photon @xmath81 is in state @xmath84 , the state of the excess electron in qd is @xmath2 .
otherwise the state of the excess electron in qd is @xmath7 . in this way
, one can construct a parity - check qnd for the spatial - mode states to distinguish the odd - parity states @xmath59 from the even - parity states @xmath60 by detecting the spin state of the excess electron in qd@xmath67 .
the spin state of excess electron in qd@xmath67 is changed for even - parity states and unchanged for odd - parity states . with the qnd in fig.[figure2](a ) , the four bell states in the spatial - mode dof are divided into two groups @xmath59 and @xmath60 .
the next task of bsa in spatial - mode dof is to distinguish the different relative phases in each group .
the qnd shown in fig.[figure2](b ) is used to distinguish the bell states with the relative phase zero from those with the relative phase @xmath85 .
bs can accomplish the following transformations in spatial - mode dof , @xmath86 after the operations by bss in fig.[figure2](b ) , the two groups of bell states become : @xmath87 that is , @xmath62 , @xmath64 , @xmath61 , and @xmath63 become @xmath62 , @xmath61 , @xmath64 , and @xmath63 , respectively . with the parity - check measurement shown in fig.[figure2](b ) , one can read out the information about the relative phases in the groups @xmath60 and @xmath59 .
if the states of the excess electrons in qd@xmath88 and qd@xmath89 are both changed ( unchanged ) , the state input is @xmath64 or @xmath63 , and the output ports are @xmath90 and @xmath91 ( @xmath92 and @xmath93 ) . while the state of the excess electron in qd@xmath88 is changed ( unchanged ) and the state of the excess electron in qd@xmath89 is unchanged ( changed ) , the state input is @xmath62 or @xmath61 , and the output ports are @xmath90 and @xmath93 ( @xmath92 and @xmath91 ) .
the relation between the initial spatial - mode bell states and the outcomes of the qnds is shown in table [ table1 ] .
the two - photon system is in one of the two odd - parity states @xmath94 in spatial - mode dof if the state of excess electron in qd@xmath67 is unchanged .
when the state of the excess electron in qd@xmath67 is changed , the two - photon system is in one of the two even - parity states @xmath95 . with qd@xmath88 and qd@xmath89
, we read out the information about the relative phases in the groups @xmath60 and @xmath59 .
therefore , for the state @xmath61 , the state of the excess electron in qd@xmath67 is unchanged , and the states of the excess electrons in qd@xmath88 and qd@xmath89 are in combination of one changed and the other unchanged .
if the state of the excess electron in qd@xmath67 is unchanged and the states of the excess electrons in qd@xmath88 and qd@xmath89 are both changed or unchanged , the input state of the two - photon system is @xmath63 .
for the two - photon state @xmath62 , the state of the excess electron in qd@xmath67 is changed , and the states of the excess electrons in qd@xmath88 and qd@xmath89 are in combination of one changed and the other unchanged . for the input state @xmath64 ,
the state of the excess electron in qd@xmath67 is changed , and the states of the excess electrons in qd@xmath88 and qd@xmath89 are both changed or unchanged . from the preceding analysis , one can see that the roles of the two qnds are accomplishing the task of parity check .
the first qnd can distinguish the two even - parity states in spatial - mode dof from the two odd - parity states . with two bss ,
the two states with two different relative phases are transformed into another two states with different parities .
after the second qnd , one can distinguish the four bell states in spatial -mode dof without destroying the two photons , which provides the convenience for the bsa in polarization dof .
.relation between the four bell states in the spatial - mode dof and the output results of the measurements on electron - spin states . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] [ tab2 ] by far , we have described the principle of our complete and deterministic hbsa with the nonlinear optics in one - side qd - cavity systems .
the bsa on the spatial and the polarization - mode dofs can be realized by adjusting the frequencies @xmath72 to get the phase shift @xmath73 .
as a complete and deterministic analysis on quantum states is important in quantum communication , it is interesting to discuss the applications of hbsa
. let us use hyperentanglement swapping as an example to describe its principle . and @xmath96 ( also the four photons ) .
after alice performs the hbsa on the two photons @xmath97 , bob and charlie can get the hyperentangled state between nodes @xmath45 and @xmath98.,width=11 ] hyperentanglement swapping enables two parties in quantum communication to obtain hyperentanglement between two particles which do not interact with each other initially .
suppose that the two entangled pairs @xmath99 and @xmath96 are in the following hyperentangled states : @xmath100 the superscripts @xmath45 and @xmath46 denote that the particles are in nodes @xmath45 and @xmath46 , respectively , as shown in fig .
[ figure4 ] .
alice shares a photon pair @xmath99 with bob , and she also shares a photon pair @xmath96 with charlie .
the task of this hyperentanglement - swapping protocol is to entangle the two photons @xmath45 and @xmath98 in both the polarization and the spatial - mode dofs . to complete entanglement swapping of hyperentangled states , alice performs hbsa on the two particles @xmath46 and @xmath101 in her hand , as shown in fig .
[ figure4 ] .
the state of the whole system can be rewritten as @xmath102 if the outcome of hbsa is @xmath103 , the two photons located in the nodes @xmath45 ( bob ) and @xmath98 ( charlie ) is in the hyperentangled state @xmath104 .
the other outcomes lead to the other hyperentangled states , such as @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 , @xmath108 , and @xmath109 . in principle , it is not difficult for bob and charlie to transform their hyperentangled state into the form @xmath104 .
for instance , if bob and charlie obtain the state @xmath110 , the state @xmath104 can be obtained in the way that charlie performs an operation @xmath111 in polarization ( both the two spatial modes @xmath93 and @xmath91 ) and then exchanges the two spatial modes after he introduces a phase @xmath85 in the spatial mode @xmath93 with a @xmath112 wave plate . the hyperentanglement - swapping protocol presented here is completed by two simultaneous but independent processes , including both the polarization bsa and the spatial - mode bsa .
if we only perform the bell - state measurement on the photons @xmath46 and @xmath101 in the polarization dof , photons @xmath45 and @xmath98 will be entangled in the polarization degree of freedom but leave their state in the spatial - mode dof be a mixed one .
bsa is essential in quantum communication , especially in long - distance quantum communication assisted by quantum repeater .
there are many proposals for analyzing bell states in polarization photon pairs . for the hyperentangled bsa discussed here ,
the entanglements in different dofs need to be analyzed independently .
this is different from the hyperentanglement - assisted bsa in polarization dof , in which another degree of freedom is used as an additional system and is consumed in the analysis . in our proposal ,
the bsa in the polarization and the spatial - mode dofs are completed by the relative phase shift @xmath113 of left circularly and right circularly polarized lights . in 2011 , young et al .
@xcite performed high - resolution reflection spectroscopy of a quantum dot resonantly coupled to a pillar microcavity with quality factor @xmath114 ( @xmath115 m ) , and their experiment showed that a qd - induced phase shift of 0.2 rad between an ( effectively ) empty cavity and a cavity with a resonantly coupled qd can be deduced , by using a single - photon level probe . if the cavity loss is @xmath116 @xcite , by improving the mode matching and the pillar design , this relative phase shift could achieve @xmath117 .
in an ideal condition , the fidelity of the hbsa proposal can reach 100% , but in experiment the fidelity is reduced by the limitation of techniques . when two photons are put into a cavity in sequence , the time interval @xmath118 between the two photons should be shorter than the electron spin decoherence time @xmath119 .
the electron spin decoherence time @xmath119 could be extended to @xmath120s using spin echo techniques , which is longer than the time interval @xmath118 ( @xmath121s ) with weak excitation @xcite .
the heavy - light hole mixing can reduce the fidelity @xcite , but it can be improved for charged excitons due to the quenched exchanged interaction @xcite .
the trion dephasing effect can also reduce the fidelity @xcite , but this dephasing effect of @xmath1 can be neglected with the hole spin coherence time three orders of magnitude longer than the cavity photon lifetime @xcite .
as the decoherence effects of electron spin , heavy - light hole , and @xmath1 can be neglected , the main factors that reduce the fidelity of hbsa proposal are the coupling strength and the cavity side leakage .
vs the coupling strength @xmath122 and the side leakage rate @xmath123 with @xmath124.,width=230 ] vs the coupling strength @xmath122 and the side leakage rate @xmath123 with @xmath124.,width=230 ] if the cavity side leakage is neglected , the fidelity of the hbsa proposal can reach 100% in the strong - coupling regime with @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
however , there is rigorous limitation in the qd - micropillar cavity , and the cavity side leakage should be considered . defining fidelity as @xmath125 ,
the fidelities for hbsa proposal can be calculated . here
@xmath126 is the final state of the total system which includes the external reservoirs , and @xmath127 is the final state with an ideal condition . as discussed in ref .
@xcite , the fidelity of even parity bell states is larger than odd parity bell states in polarization dof , we calculate the fidelity ( in amplitude ) and the efficiency of the present hbsa proposal for the hyperentangled state @xmath128 .
the fidelity of this state is @xmath129 ^ 2 } { ( \zeta^{10}+\xi^{10})^2 + 22\epsilon^8(\zeta^2+\xi^2)^2 + 4\epsilon^2(\zeta^8-\xi^8)^2 + 16\epsilon^6(\zeta^4-\xi^4)^2 + 9\epsilon^4(\zeta^6+\xi^6)^2 } \times\frac{1}{128},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the efficiency of this state is @xmath130 where @xmath131 , @xmath132 , and @xmath133 .
figure.[figure5 ] shows the fidelity and the efficiency of the present hbsa protocol for the hyperentangled state @xmath128 . from fig.[figure5](a ) , we can see that the hbsa proposal works with a high fidelity in both strong the coupling regime ( @xmath134 ) and the weak coupling regime ( @xmath135 ) .
however , considering the efficiency in fig.[figure5](b ) , our protocol only works effectively in the strong coupling regime . in experiment , it is easy to achieve the weak coupling , but it is challenging to observe a strong coupling in a qd - cavity system .
it has been observed the coupling strength can be increased from @xmath136 ( @xmath137 ) @xcite to @xmath138 ( @xmath139 ) @xcite for @xmath140 m micropillar microcavities by improving the sample designs , growth , and fabrication @xcite . for the strong coupling @xmath136 ,
the fidelity and efficiency are @xmath141 and @xmath142 when @xmath143 , and they are @xmath144 and @xmath145 when @xmath146 . for the strong coupling @xmath138 ,
the fidelity and the efficiency are @xmath147 and @xmath148 when @xmath143 , and they are @xmath149 and @xmath150 when @xmath151 .
the quality factors in these micropillars are dominated by the side leakage and cavity loss rate , so the top mirrors of high - q micropillars ( @xmath140 m ) are thin down to get @xmath152 and @xmath153 ( @xmath154 ) in ref .
for the strong coupling @xmath153 , the fidelity and the efficiency are @xmath155 and @xmath156 when @xmath143 , but they are @xmath157 and @xmath158 when @xmath152 . both the fidelity and the efficiency are largely reduced by the cavity side leakage . to get small @xmath123 in the strong coupling regime , high - efficiency operation
is highly demanded .
this could be quite challenging for micropillar microcavities .
the recent experiments achieve the strong coupling with large micropillars @xcite , while the side leakage is small with small micropillars . in summary
, we have proposed a complete hbsa scheme with the interaction between a circular polarization light and a one - side qd - cavity system ( the nonlinear optics of a one - side qd - cavity system ) .
we use the relative phase shift of the right and the left circularly polarized lights to construct parity - check measurements and analyze bell states in different dofs of two - photon systems .
we have also discussed its applications in long - distance quantum communication processes in two different dofs simultaneously .
this work is supported by the national natural science foundation of china under grant nos .
10974020 and 11174039 , ncet-11 - 0031 , and the fundamental research funds for the central universities . c. h. bennett , g. brassard , c. crpeau , r. jozsa , a. peres , and w. k. wootters , `` teleporting an unknown quantum state via dual classical and einstein - podolsky - rosen channels , '' phys . rev
. lett . * 70 * , 1895 - 1899 ( 1993 ) .
n. k. langford , r. b. dalton , m. d. harvey , j. l. obrien , g. j. pryde , a. gilchrist , s. d. bartlett , and a. g. white , `` measuring entangled qutrits and their use for quantum bit commitment , '' phys .
93 * , 053601 ( 2004 ) .
t. yang , q. zhang , j. zhang , j. yin , z. zhao , m. ukowski , z. b. chen , and j. w. pan , `` all - versus - nothing violation of local realism by two - photon , four - dimensional entanglement , '' phys .
lett . * 95 * , 240406 ( 2005 ) y. b. sheng , f. g. deng , and h. y. zhou , `` efficient polarization - entanglement purification based on parametric down - conversion sources with cross - kerr nonlinearity , '' phys . rev .
a * 77 * , 042308 ( 2008 ) . c. y. hu , a. young , j. l. obrien , w. j. munro , and j. g. rarity , `` giant optical faraday rotation induced by a single - electron spin in a quantum dot : applications to entangling remote spins via a single photon , '' phys .
b * 78 * , 085307 ( 2008 ) . c. bonato , f. haupt , s. s. r. oemrawsingh , j. gudat , d. ding , m. p. van exter , and d. bouwmeester , `` cnot and bell - state analysis in the weak - coupling cavity qed regime , '' phys .
lett . * 104 * , 160503 ( 2010 ) .
r. j. warburton , c. s. drr , k. karrai , j. p. kotthaus , g. medeiros - ribeiro , and p. m. petroff , `` charged excitons in self - assembled semiconductor quantum dots , '' phys .
lett . * 79 * , 5282 - 5285 ( 1997 ) . c. y. hu , w. ossau , d. r. yakovlev , g. landwehr , t. wojtowicz , g. karczewski , and j. kossut , `` optically detected magnetic resonance of excess electrons in type - i quantum wells with a low - density electron gas , '' phys .
b * 58 * , r1766-r1769 ( 1998 ) .
a. b. young , r. oulton , c. y. hu , a. c. t. thijssen , c. schneider , s. reitzenstein , m. kamp , s. hfling , l. worschech , a. forchel , and j. g. rarity , `` quantum - dot - induced phase shift in a pillar microcavity , '' phys .
a * 84 * , 011803 ( 2011 ) .
g. bester , s. nair , and a. zunger , `` pseudopotential calculation of the excitonic fine structure of million - atom self - assembled in@xmath159ga@xmath160as / gaas quantum dots , '' phys .
b * 67 * , 161306 ( r ) ( 2003 ) .
m. bayer , g. ortner , o. stern , a. kuther , a. a. gorbunov , a. forchel , p. hawrylak , s. fafard , k. hinzer , t. l. reinecke , s. n. walck , j. p. reithmaier , f. klopf , and f. schfer , `` fine structure of neutral and charged excitons in self - assembled in(ga)as/(al)gaas quantum dots , '' phys .
b * 65 * , 195315 ( 2002 )
. j. j. finley , d. j. mowbray , m. s. skolnick , a. d. ashmore , c. baker , a. f. g. monte , and m. hopkinson , `` fine structure of charged and neutral excitons in inas - al@xmath161ga@xmath162as quantum dots , '' phys .
b * 66 * , 153316 ( 2002 ) . d. heiss , s. schaeck , h. huebl , m. bichler , g. abstreiter , j. j. finley , d. v. bulaev , and d. loss , `` observation of extremely slow hole spin relaxation in self - assembled quantum dots , '' phys . rev .
b * 76 * , 241306(r ) ( 2007 ) .
b. d. gerardot , d. brunner , p. a. dalgarno , p. hberg , s. seidl , m. kroner , k. karrai , n. g. stoltz , p. m. petroff , and r. j. warburton , `` optical pumping of a single hole spin in a quantum dot , '' nature ( london ) * 451 * , 441 - 444 ( 2008 ) .
j. p. reithmaier , g. sk , a. lffler , c. hofmann , s. kuhn , s. reitzenstein , l. v. keldysh , v. d. kulakovskii , t. l. reinecke , and a. forchel , `` strong coupling in a single quantum dot - semiconductor microcavity system , '' nature ( london ) * 432 * , 197 - 200 ( 2004 ) .
t. yoshie , a. scherer , j. hendrickson , g. khitrova , h. m. gibbs , g. rupper , c. ell , o. b. shchekin , and d. g. deppe , `` vacuum rabi splitting with a single quantum dot in a photonic crystal nanocavity , '' nature ( london ) * 432 * , 200 - 203 ( 2004 ) .
s. reitzenstein , c. hofmann , a. gorbunov , m. strau , s. h. kwon , c. schneider , a. lffler , s. hfling , m. kamp , and a. forchel , `` alas / gaas micropillar cavities with quality factors exceeding @xmath163 , '' appl .
phys . lett . *
90 * , 251109 ( 2007 ) . v. loo , l. lanco , a. lematre , i. sagnes , o. krebs , p. voisin , and p. senellart , `` quantum dot - cavity strong - coupling regime measured through coherent reflection spectroscopy in a very high - q micropillar , '' appl .
. lett . * 97 * , 241110 ( 2010 ) . | bell - state analysis ( bsa ) is essential in quantum communication , but it is impossible to distinguish unambiguously the four bell states in the polarization degree of freedom ( dof ) of two - photon systems with only linear optical elements , except for the case in which the bsa is assisted with hyperentangled states , the simultaneous entanglement in more than one dof . here , we propose a scheme to distinguish completely the 16 hyperentangled bell states in both the polarization and the spatial - mode dofs of two - photon systems , by using the giant nonlinear optics in quantum dot - cavity systems .
this scheme can be applied to increase the channel capacity of long - distance quantum communication based on hyperentanglement , such as entanglement swapping , teleportation , and superdense coding .
we use hyperentanglement swapping as an example to show the application of this hbsa . |
stochastic processes made their appearance in research in physics long time ago and their theory has played an important role in the description of systems which do not behave in a deterministic manner @xcite . in particular , the study of the dynamics of particles lying inside material media has been the object of high interest .
a classical example is the study of the brownian motion @xcite .
a large deal of those investigations had a non - relativistic character and the random interactions with the background medium were considered as being dependent of the state of motion of the particle , that is , lacking invariance under the changes of the reference system @xcite .
another large class of studies in this field had been directed to show the equivalence with random processes of the solutions of quantum relativistic or non - relativistic equations , like the klein - gordon , dirac and schrodinger ones . @xcite .
two basic additional subjects in connection with stochastic processes in quantum theory are : the attempts to derive the collapse of the wave function during measurements from the existence of random perturbations in quantum mechanics ( qm ) @xcite , and the study of the decoherence processes and their role in spontaneous transitions from pure to mixed states @xcite .
the main objective of the present work is to investigate some consequences on the motion of a particle determined by the action exerted over it by a medium which random properties are defined in a relativistically invariant form .
the basic motivation is simple : it is recognized that the copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics ( qm ) , is the most successful and dominant from all the existing ones .
however , it is also accepted that its approach to measurements constitute one its more puzzling aspects , which up to now is widely debated in the literature@xcite .
let us suppose for a moment , that in opposition to the copenhagen interpretation and in accordance with einstein expectations , the particles in nature are in fact localized at definite points of the space at any moment .
then , the only way we can imagine for the quantum mechanical properties of the motion to emerge from a model , is that the action of the vacuum on the particles have a stochastic character .
but , the relativistic invariance of the vacuum , leads to expect that the acceleration felt by the particle in its proper frame should be a stationary random variable as a function of the proper time .
this circumstance motivates the study started here about the motion of particles inside a random media showing the above mentioned property . for the sake of simplicity
the one dimensional motion is considered .
it is not attempted to show the equivalence of the dynamics in the medium with the one predicted by the quantum mechanical equations .
the purpose in this first step , being redundant , is to study general properties of the motion of one and two particles assuming two main conditions : a ) they have a definite localization in the space at any moment and b ) the forces acting on the particles have the above mentioned random properties which are independent the observer s inertial reference frame .
the work will proceed as follows .
firstly , the equations of motion of the particles under the action of the medium are formulated . for this purpose
the properties which ensure the relativistic invariance of the motion under the action of the medium are stated by specifying the form of the random forces .
further , the equations of motion of a single particle are written and solved and a statistical analysis of the random properties is done .
a main conclusion following is the existence of a conservation law for a mean drift momentum and kinetic energy of a free particle propagating in the medium .
it indicates the validity of a kind of stochastic noether theorem which links the relativist invariance of the stochastic motion with the conservation of the mean 4-momentum of the particle .
further , the conservation law is studied for the mean of the addition of two four momenta associated to the scattering of two identical particles , which repel each other through an instantaneous coulomb interaction .
it is concluded that the random action of the medium does not modify the usual conservation law , valid for the impact in the absence of external forces .
a review of the results and future extensions of the work are presented in a conclusion section . some possibilities to extend the study
are advanced . in general terms
, our view is that the form of the analysis have the chance of being useful in the search for consistent hidden variables models .
the study of these possibilities will be considered elsewhere .
in this section we will obtain and solve the newton equation of motion for a particle on which a random force @xmath0 is acting . a one dimensional system will be considered to make the discussion as simple as possible .
the force will be defined as a vector in the proper reference frame of the particle and will depend on the proper time @xmath1 that means , in each instant we will consider an inertial reference frame moving relative to the observer s fixed frame ( lab frame ) with the velocity of the particle @xmath2 and having the origin of coordinates coinciding with it . in this system of reference , after a time increment @xmath3 , it is possible to write@xmath4 where @xmath5 is the proper mass of the particle .
the particle reaches a small velocity @xmath6 relative to this system and a new velocity respect to the lab frame @xmath7 , given by the equation@xmath8 where @xmath9 is the velocity of light .
thus , the variation of speed in the lab frame @xmath10 is@xmath11 from expressions ( [ fp ] ) and ( [ dif_vel ] ) the required differential equation for the motion is obtained : @xmath12 it is useful to state the relation between the strength of the force in the lab system and its proper frame counterpart , which is : @xmath13 however , since the relativistic invariance condition will be imposed on @xmath0 this will be the type of force mostly considered in what follows . integrating the equation [ dif_mov ] in the proper time it follows @xmath14 which determines the velocity the lab frame @xmath15 as a function of the proper time @xmath16 , only through the dependence of @xmath17 of the integral of the random force @xmath18 the explicit form of @xmath19 becomes @xmath20 , \label{velocidad_en_tiempo_propio}\ ] ] where @xmath21 is an arbitrary constant .
as it was mentioned in the introduction , the medium under study will be defined in the proper frame as randomly acting over the particle being at rest in it .
that is , its action in this reference system will be given by a stochastic process showing no preferential spatial direction and assumed to be produced by an external relativistic system which dynamics is unaffected by the presence of the particle .
its is also natural to impose the coincidence of the distribution function of the forces of the medium for a large sampling interval of proper time @xmath22 and the one obtained fixing the proper time @xmath17 produced by an ensemble of a large number of samples of the forces taken during long time intervals @xmath22 .
these conditions , can be assured by a random force @xmath0 being stationary , ergodic and symmetrical distributed about the zero value of the force .
a numerical realization of a band limited white noise distribution obeying these properties is implemented in reference @xcite and will be employed here .
concretely , the expression for the stochastic force given in the proper reference frame as a function of the proper time will be taken in the form @xmath23 where the @xmath24 phases @xmath25 @xmath26 are randomly chosen with a uniform distribution between @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
the integer number @xmath24 is the number of frequency components of the numerical band limited white noise distribution .
the bandwidth will be chosen as a fixed one and equal to @xmath29 .
clearly , the exact randomness for an arbitrarily large time interval only will attained in the infinite limit of @xmath24 .
the parameter @xmath30 controls the amplitude of the force values .
note that the absence of a zero frequency component is implied by the condition of the process not showing a preferential direction in space .
figure [ graficofuerzas1 ] shows the force distribution @xmath31 for a @xmath32 of the ensemble of forces for @xmath33 a @xmath32 here is called the time evolution of the force , for the set of randomly fixed phases @xmath34 at the start .
the picture qualitatively shows the stationary character of the random force .
figure [ distribucion fuerza ] depicts an interpolation curve of the data for the distribution function @xmath35 corresponding to an ensemble of random _ realizations _ of the force .
the white noise frequency spectrum was defined by @xmath36 frequency components @xmath37 @xmath38,@xmath39 .
the force amplitude fixed was as @xmath40 @xmath41 @xmath42 the picture corresponds to a large sampling time @xmath22 ( it is sufficient to be at most equal to the period of the smallest frequency of the spectrum ) .
notice the even character of the distribution and its rapid decay to zero .
of course , this occurs inside the interval defined by @xmath43 @xmath44 .
this result is natural due to the fact that the force is normalized and its absolute value can not exceed @xmath45 .
in this section the existence of a conservation law for the mean momentum ( to be also called from now on the drift momentum ) will be shown for a particle moving in the before defined random medium . to this purpose
let us employ the solution ( [ velocidad_en_tiempo_propio ] ) which was found in the previous section we will combine this expression with the results obtained from the definition of the random force ensemble in equation ( [ fuerza_estocastica ] ) , to explicitly determine @xmath46 the resulting relation links the velocity of the particle in the lab frame with the proper time measured by a clock fixed to it .
once having @xmath47 we will comment about its stationary random behavior .
the existence of a non vanishing conserved mean value of the velocity @xmath48 will be shown . starting form the method defined above , the velocity distribution function will be determined for the frequency spectrum defined before and few representative values of the arbitrary constant @xmath21 .
after that , the position of the particle @xmath49 as a function of the time @xmath50 measured at the lab frame will be evaluated .
taking @xmath0 to be given by the white noise force @xmath51
we have : @xmath52 then , integrating with respect to @xmath16 produces @xmath53\text { } d\tau,\nonumber\\ & = \frac{f_{0}}{8\pi}[\sum_{i=1}^{n}\frac{1}{i}\sin(\frac{8\pi i\text { } } { n}\tau+\varphi_{i } ) ] . \label{integral_fuerza}\ ] ] substituting ( [ integral_fuerza ] ) into ( [ velocidad_en_tiempo_propio ] ) , gives@xmath54,\\ & = c\text { } \tanh[\frac{1}{m_{0}c}(\frac{f_{0}}{8\pi}[\sum_{i=1}^{n}\frac { 1}{i}\sin(\frac{8\pi i}{n}\tau+\varphi_{i})]+\hat{c } ) ] .
\label{v(tao)}\ ] ] it can be seen that the summation within the argument of the hyperbolic tangent is symmetrically distributed around its zero value .
since the @xmath55 is an anti - symmetric function , it follows that when @xmath56 there will be a nonvanishing mean velocity of the particle in the medium .
as the mean value of the kinetic energy is also conserved , it can be said that the mean 4-momentum of the particle is conserved .
moreover , the relativistic invariance of the system also implies that the mean 4-momentum of the solutions for any two values of @xmath21 should be linked by certain lorentz transformation .
thus , the particle trajectories for the various values of @xmath21 are simply a fixed trajectory ( in the stochastic sense ) after being lorentz transformed into certain moving frame .
the picture in figure [ graficovel1 ] shows the behavior of @xmath57 for the following values of the parameters @xmath58s@xmath59 , @xmath60 s@xmath59 , @xmath61 .
note that for fixed values of @xmath21 ( that means , for certain initial conditions ) the velocity rapidly oscillates around a value being close to the quantity @xmath62 $ ] .
it illustrates the mentioned conservation of the mean drift velocity for the particle in spite of the random oscillations of the medium .
figure [ graficovel2 ] shows the same dependence for specific values of @xmath21 .
let us consider now the numerical evaluation of the distribution function @xmath63 ( for measuring a given value of the velocity @xmath19 ) for few representative values of @xmath21 .
this function is found on the basis of the ergodic property of the system , that is , by performing a large number of evaluations of the velocity s expression with time running from zero to a `` sampling '' value @xmath22 , for afterwards compute the number of times , for which @xmath19 takes values in a small neighborhood of a given value .
further , after interpolating the results , the distribution functions are obtained after dividing by the fixed size of the mentioned neighborhood . in figure ( [ distribuciones ] )
the distribution @xmath63 is plotted for a few values of @xmath21 .
these pictures correspond to the frequency spectrum @xmath64 but with the amplitude fixed by @xmath65 the almost independence of the form of these curves on the size of a large `` sampling '' time @xmath66 employed ( whenever @xmath24 is sufficiently large ) indicates the approximate validity of the ergodic property of the white noise implementation employed .
note the rapid decay away from the mean value and the deformation of the symmetry around it , of the distribution @xmath63 for different values of @xmath21 . these distributions allow to calculate the mean velocities in each of the cases .
this method will be employed in the next sections for finding the mean values as integrals over the domain of the quantity , of its value times the distribution function .
it can be noted that the explicit solution for the velocity obtained in ( [ velocidad_en_tiempo_propio ] ) corresponds to this velocity in terms of the proper time @xmath16 .
however , in order to integrate the velocity to find the random particle trajectories as functions of the time in the laboratory frame , it becomes necessary to know the functional relationship @xmath67 for the considered trajectory .
then , let us consider now the numerical determination of this relation
. the parameters of the random force will be @xmath68 @xmath69s@xmath70 , @xmath71 ( s@xmath70 , @xmath72 using the solution @xmath73 it follows @xmath74 and employing it , the values of @xmath75 were numerically found .
afterwards , finding the inverse mapping @xmath76 , this function is depicted in figure [ tiempos ] with @xmath21 as a parameter .
finding the composed function for various values of @xmath21 , the observer s time dependence of the particle velocity @xmath77 follows .
the results are illustrated in figure [ velocidad de la particula libre ] , for the chosen values of @xmath21 .
further , after integrating the calculated velocities with respect to @xmath78 @xmath79(starting at @xmath80 and imposing @xmath81 ) the values of the positions @xmath49 respect to the laboratory reference frame are obtained .
the trajectories of the particles are shown in figure [ posicion de la particula ] , for the same set of values of @xmath82 note the randomness of the motion in the case of small absolute values of @xmath21 which is not the case for the larger ones .
this property can be understood analyzing the pictures in figure ( [ velocidad de la particula libre ] ) . in the cases in which the velocity constantly changes from positive to negative values and vice versa ,
the randomness is more evident .
thus , the aleatory effect is more visible in one case than in the other , because the curve changes from a monotonous to non monotonous behavior .
but , after taking into account the relativistic invariance of the model , as noticed before , it can be seen that the curves for different values of @xmath21 should transform any one into another by a lorentz transformation ( exactly , when the same _ realization _ of the force is employed , or statistically , if another _
realization _ is used ) .
therefore , the apparent increased randomness for low @xmath21 is only a visual effect enforced by the change of sign of the velocity in frames in which its mean value is sufficiently low .
let us consider in this final section the conservation of the mean total momentum of a closed system of two particles which travel in the medium by also interacting between them .
a repulsive interaction between the two identical particles @xmath41 and @xmath83 will introduced .
the forces between the particles will be defined in the laboratory frame for studying the impact between them there .
they will be chosen as satisfying the law of action and reaction and having the coulomb form . if , for example , the forces have an electromagnetic origin , the retardation effects will be disregarded in order to assure that the field will not deliver momentum to the set of two particles .
this approximation is appropriate for low particle velocities in its random motion in the lab frame .
the system of differential equations will be written and numerically solved .
the results for the position and velocity of both particles @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , will show how after the impact , any of them deliver to the other its mean drift velocity and its type of randomness .
as it was mentioned above , the expression for the repulsive force in the lab frame will have the coulomb form@xmath88 consider now the relativistic newton equations for both particles in their respective proper frames and also the two transformations between the common laboratory time @xmath50 and the two different proper times @xmath89 and @xmath90 these relations may be written as @xmath91 in order to be consistent with the non retarded approximation for the coulomb repulsion , as mentioned above , initial velocities for the particles being relatively small with respect to @xmath9 were taken .
this assumption makes the considered approximation to be satisfied if the intensity of the repulsive force is weak so that the velocities after the impact will also be small .
employing the white noise parameters @xmath92 , @xmath93 and @xmath94 , we obtained the numerical solutions shown in figure [ choque1 ] for various initial conditions .
the conservation law of the total mean momentum of the two particles can be noticed .
figure [ choque2 ] shows the time variation of the velocities of the particles .
the process of exchange of their drift momenta is clearly illustrated and therefore the corresponding conservation of the total momentum .
this outcome follows in spite of the strong oscillations produced by the action of the medium , in opposition to what happens within a standard material media . in these systems
the stochastic action normally tends to stop the motion of the particle making the drift velocity to vanish , assumed the absence of accelerating external fields .
the calculated values for the mean velocities before and after the shock are @xmath95 which numerically confirms the conservation of the total momentum in the shock of two particles forming a closed system immersed and moving in a relativistic random medium .
the one - dimensional equation of motion for a particle moving in a medium having relativistic invariant stochastic properties is formulated and numerically solved .
the velocity of the particles in the medium is a function of the proper time only through the integral of the force in the proper reference frame .
this relation directly shows the existence of a stochastic conservation law : _ a free particle in the defined random medium conserves its mean momentum and kinetic energy along its motion . _
the problem of two particles moving in the medium is also investigated after considering a momentum conserving coulomb repulsion between them .
the evaluated solutions generalize the conservation law : _ the sum of the two drift momenta of two particles moving in the medium without any other external action conserves after a shock .
_ an interesting outcome is that for two different shocks with identical initial conditions for both particles when they are far apart , the drift velocities before the impact are not uniquely determined by the initial conditions .
these velocities also depend on the array of phases utilized for the _ realization _ of the force . _
_ therefore , it follows that the results of the impact will show a dependence on the specific _ realization _ of the random force .
this circumstance implies that the probability distribution associated to an ensemble of particles all situated at the beginning at the same point and with a fixed value of the velocity , will not define only one direction of the trajectory for large times .
the probability distributions of such an ensemble , on the other hand , should evolve in space and time in a relativistically invariant manner , as the lorentz invariance of the system indicates .
the same conclusion can be traced for any other sort of fixed boundary conditions .
therefore , the set of possible initial conditions for the particle ( considering also that they can be placed in the medium at different initial spacial and temporal points for the construction of the ensemble ) should be expected to be equivalent to the set of all possible space time evolving ensembles that can be observed .
the above remarks suggest some possible extensions of the present work , which are described below : * the indicated dependence of the ending results of the shocks , not only of the initial conditions , but also of the concrete _ realization _ of the random force , led us to think in extending the results to the 2d and 3d cases . the idea is to study the spatial and temporal behavior of the ensemble of outcomes o a series of shocks `` prepared '' with fixed initial mean velocities for both particles , and to compare the results with the corresponding predictions of the quantum scattering . *
another task of interest which is suggested by this study is to investigate the existence of preferential bounded states in the case that the coulomb interaction is considered as attractive .
@xmath79a particular simpler situation could be to assume one of the particles as very massive , that is , merely acting as an attracting center . in both cases
the study could consist in determining the statistical properties of the stationary trajectories given the initial condition . in conclusion
, we would like to underline that it seems not without sense that the realization of the above proposed studies could be of use in the justification or search for hidden variable approaches to quantum mechanics ( qm ) . as it can be seen from the discussion
, the resulting models could not show the limitations of the bohm approach ( like the absence of predictions for the `` guided '' motions of the particles for real wave functions , for example ) .
moreover , the analysis seems of interest in seeking for a theory not requiring to fix a particular random process to each stationary state , but one in which all the statistical properties can emerge from a general framework . in the imagined outcome
, the particle could propagate having a probability for transit or stay into each one of a set of stationary random motions which could be associated ( but now within the general context ) to the particular eigenfunctions of the system .
as for the allowance of the necessary generalizations needed to make contact with reality , it can guessed that the possible generalization of the statistical noether properties ( detected in the simple model considered here ) could lead to the conservation of the mean values for the angular momentum and other internal quantities , in analogy with the case of the linear momentum .
we think these possibilities deserve further examination that will be published elsewhere .
d. bohm , in _ quantum theory , radiation and high energy physics _
d. bates ( academic press , new york , 1962 ) .
p. vigier , _ lett .
nuovo cimento _ * 24 * , 528 ( 1979 ) ; * 24 * , 265 ( 1979 ) . t. e. nelson , _ phys
. rev . _ * 150 * , 1079 ( 1966 ) .
d. kershaw , _ phys .
rev . _ * 136 * , b1079 ( 1964 ) .
t. h. boyer , _ phys .
_ * 182 * , 1374 ( 1969 ) . | the dynamics of particles moving in a medium defined by its relativistically invariant stochastic properties is investigated . for this aim ,
the force exerted on the particles by the medium is defined by a stationary random variable as a function of the proper time of the particles .
the equations of motion for a single one - dimensional particle are obtained and numerically solved .
a conservation law for the drift momentum of the particle during its random motion is shown .
moreover , the conservation of the mean value of the total linear momentum for two particles repelling each other according with the coulomb interaction is also following .
therefore , the results indicate the realization of a kind of stochastic noether theorem in the system under study . possible applications to the stochastic representation of quantum mechanics are advanced . |
classical novae are rather frequently observed in our galaxy ( liller & mayer 1987 , shafter 1997 ) , and have also been studied in external galaxies ; typically @xmath2 34 per year are detected in our galaxy ( duerbeck 1995 , warner 1995 ) .
most of the discoveries and observations of galactic novae have been made by amateur astronomers with little access to spectroscopic and photometric equipment .
sky coverage has been episodic and extremely hard to calculate .
classification attempts have also been hindered . as a result , many of the most basic properties involving their global rate and distribution are surprisingly uncertain . for example , a number of arguments suggest that the galactic rate of novae must be much higher than @xmath3 : \(a ) the typical limiting apparent magnitude obtainable with amateur apparatus and methods has been increasing steadily in recent years , but for the period covered by this paper may be taken to be @xmath4 , within a very wide range , and with extremely uneven coverage .
application of the expanding - photosphere method to a subset of relatively nearby and bright novae has yielded the empirical relation @xmath5 ( warner 1995 ) for the absolute magnitude , where @xmath6 ( the _ speed class _ ) is the time taken for @xmath7 to increase by 2 from discovery .
it follows that the distance out to which amateur astronomers are detecting typical novae is @xmath8 kpc , or only about one - half the volume of the galaxy .
furthermore , the rate of discoveries at the faintest magnitudes ( @xmath9 ) is greater than what would be extrapolated from brighter novae .
this indicates that a new population presumably associated with the galactic bulge rather than the disk is present and poorly sampled ( duerbeck 1990 ; see below ) .
\(b ) even within that part of the galaxy which is effectively searched for novae , the discovery rate is blatantly incomplete
. not only does the discovery rate for novae with @xmath10 fall below the extrapolated rate for brighter events ( thus , in contrast to the preceding argument , suggesting that many events in this range are missed : duerbeck 1990 ) , but there is a marked deficiency of discoveries in the southern celestial hemisphere ( warner 1995 ) .
this is relevant to our work , since the tgrs detector is permanently pointed at the southern sky ( 2.1 ) . during its period of operation ( 19951997 )
five novae were discovered in the southern hemisphere ( harris et al .
1999 , hereafter paper i ) , but there is no way of knowing how many were missed . a few days ) which rise and fall in between successive visits to a given location . ] the possibility of detecting undiscovered novae as bright as @xmath11 ( marginally within tgrs s capabilities ) is one of the justifications for the present work .
\(c ) in galactic latitude , the distribution of classical novae is somewhat concentrated toward the equatorial plane ( scale heights for disk and bulge populations 125 and 500 pc respectively : duerbeck 1984 , 1990 ) .
they must therefore be affected to some degree by interstellar extinction , and a deficiency of discoveries close to the plane is indeed observed ( warner 1995 ) . in terms of the composition of their ejecta , novae are classified into co - rich and one - rich ; it is thought that the distinction reflects the composition of the underlying white dwarf material , with the one class coming from more massive progenitors whose cores burned beyond the early he - burning stage which yields c and o. different levels of positron annihilation line flux are expected from each class ( 4 ) .
if the progenitors of the one subclass are really more massive , they will tend to lie closer to the galactic plane , and the resulting novae will be more strongly affected by extinction and relatively under - represented in the discovered sample ( of which they compose @xmath12 : gehrz et al .
evidence of this has been detected by della valle et al .
( 1992 ) .
\(d ) the three preceding factors would all tend to enhance the true galactic nova rate above that observed .
however , a second , quite distinct approach to the problem tends to produce systematically lower rates . in this approach
, several external galaxies ( particularly the magellanic clouds , m31 and m33 ) have been monitored for novae , and their observed rates extrapolated in some fashion to the milky way ( ciardullo et al .
1987 , della valle & livio 1994 ) .
the usual basis for extrapolation is absolute blue luminosity ( della valle & claudi 1990 ) . as can be seen in table 1 , the results from this approach are systematically smaller than attempts to correct for the missing galactic novae directly .
the original explanation for this effect was provided by duerbeck ( 1990 ) , who postulated two different classes of event by spatial distribution disk and bulge novae .
it was claimed that the bulge population has a systematically slower speed class , and is therefore generally less luminous by equations ( 13 ) , which might account for the discrepancy , given a larger bulge in the main external source of novae , m31 . as will be seen ( 4.1 ) ,
our search method is probably relevant only to a disk population .
a third approach to the problem is theoretically possible , by which classical nova outbursts are assumed to be part of a life - cycle of which other cataclysmic variables are manifestations .
the galactic nova rate is then derived from the assumed space densities of these related objects , together with some model for the outburst recurrence time ( warner 1995 ) .
this approach is more reliable at predicting the galactic space density rather than the global rate , which is more directly related to the measurements we shall present .
it is important to correct for and combine these various factors into an overall global galactic nova rate , which would govern the input of novae into galactic chemical evolution , dust grains and interstellar radioactivity ( gehrz et al . 1998 ) .
however attempts to do so have yielded wildly discordant results , ranging from 11260 novae yr@xmath13 ( see table 1 ) .
we have therefore adopted in this work yet a fourth ( and simplest ) approach which is to make an _ unbiased _ search for novae in our galaxy .
the detection of @xmath14-ray lines from radioactive decays of the nucleosynthesis products produced in novae is such an approach ; these decays in general emit positrons , whose annihilation with electrons produces a line at 511 kev .
an obvious advantage of this approach is the very small absorption of @xmath14-rays in the galaxy .
we will also see that problems of uneven coverage and sensitivity are minimal .
these advantages are realised when the @xmath14-ray detector tgrs , on board the _ wind _ mission , is used ( 2.1 ) . in paper
i we determined that tgrs does indeed have the capability to perform a sky survey for classical novae .
the target of paper i was to detect the positron annihilation line in five known novae ; although none was detected , the viability of such a method was established .
the key to the method ( see 2 below ) is that the line arises in nova material expanding towards the observer , and is therefore broadened and blueshifted ( leising & clayton 1987 ) .
its peak is therefore shifted away from a strong background line at exactly 511 kev , which arises in the instrument itself from decays of unstable nuclei produced by cosmic ray spallation . in the next section
we give a brief description of the detector and data , and of our analysis .
none of these is substantially different from that of paper i , where the reader may find a more detailed description .
the tgrs experiment is very well suited to a search for the 511 kev line , for several reasons .
first , it is located on board the _ wind _ spacecraft whose orbit is so elliptical that it has spent virtually all of its mission since 1994 november in interplanetary space , where the @xmath14-ray background level is relatively low .
second , these backgrounds are not only low but very stable over time .
third , tgrs is attached to the south - facing surface of the rotating cylindrical _ wind _ body , which points permanently toward the south ecliptic pole .
the detector is unshielded , and tgrs therefore has an unobstructed view of the entire southern ecliptic hemisphere .
taken together , these three facts make possible a continuous and complete survey of the southern sky .
fourth , and most importantly , the tgrs ge detector has sufficient spectral resolution to detect a 511 kev line which is slightly doppler - shifted away from the background 511 kev line mentioned in 1 . the doppler blueshift in the nova line , for the epochs @xmath1512 hr which we consider , is predicted to be 25 kev ( hernanz 1999 , kudryashov 2000 ) , which compares with the tgrs energy resolution at 511 kev of 34 kev fwhm ( harris et al .
1998 and paper i ) .
the tgrs detector is a radiatively cooled 35 @xmath16 n - type ge crystal sensitive to energies between 20 kev8 mev . since the launch of _ wind _ in 1994 november ,
tgrs has accumulated count rates continuously in this energy range .
the few gaps in the data stream are due either to perigee passes , which are rare ( lasting @xmath17 d at several month intervals ) thanks to _ wind _ s very eccentric orbit , or to memory readouts following solar flare or @xmath14-ray burst triggers , which may last for @xmath18 hr . the data were binned in 1 kev energy bins during 24 min intervals .
we searched in data covering a period of nearly three years , from 1995 january to 1997 october . in the fall of 1997
the performance of the detector began to degrade seriously , and the energy resolution became too coarse to resolve the 511 kev background and nova lines .
this degradation is believed to result from crystal defects induced by accumulated cosmic ray impacts , which trap semiconductor holes and reverse the impurity charge status .
a region of the crystal thus becomes undepleted and the effective area is reduced ( kurczynski et al .
we terminated our search of the data when the photopeak effective area at 511 kev fell below an estimated 80% of its original value .
the total live time accumulated was about @xmath19 s , which was nominally 88% of the entire interval .
in fact , the distribution of live times among the 6 hr intervals was such that 41% of all intervals had the full 6 hr of live time , and almost 99% of intervals contained some live time .
our analysis procedure relies heavily on the most recently theoretically - predicted properties of the 511 kev line ( hernanz et al .
1999 , kudryashov 2000 ) , mainly its light - curve , energy and shape .
the timescale over which the background spectra described above are summed is set by the predicted @xmath14-ray light - curve from the `` thermonuclear flash '' which powers a nova . in this process
a degenerate accreted h layer on the surface of a co or one white dwarf ignites proton capture reactions involving both accreted material and some material dredged up from the interior of the white dwarf .
the timescale for this process is set by the @xmath0-decay timescales of the unstable nucleosynthesis products of rapid proton capture on c , o and ne .
these unstable species fall into two groups , one having very rapid decays ( @xmath20 minutes : e.g. @xmath21n , @xmath22o , @xmath23f ) and the more slow - decaying @xmath24f ( @xmath25 min ) .
the light - curve results from the convolution of these decays with the reduction of opacity to 511 kev @xmath14-rays due to envelope expansion ; it thus tends to be double - peaked at values @xmath2010100 s and @xmath2036 hr ( gmez - gomar et al .
1998 ) , with significant emission lasting for @xmath26 hr ( hernanz et al . 1999 ) .
the 10100 s peak is ultimately due to the decay of the very short - lived group of isotopes , and is thus especially prominent in the co nova light - curve ( though these isotopes are essential to the energetics of both classes ) .
the 36 hr peak reflects the survival of slower - decaying @xmath24f in both classes ( gmez - gomar et al .
1998 ) . with these timescales in mind
, we summed the 24-min background spectra into 6 hr intervals the 4005 resulting 6-hr spectra were fit by a model ( described in paper i ) containing the strong background 511 kev line at rest , and a broadened blueshifted nova line .
the energies of the nova line were fixed at the predicted values ( 516 kev after 6 hr , dropping to 513 kev after 12 hr : gmez - gomar et al .
1998 , hernanz et al .
1999 , kudryashov 2000 ) .
the widths were taken to be 8 kev fwhm and the shapes to be gaussian , as in paper i ; the shapes are poorly documented in published models , but the approximation is probably reasonable at an epoch of a few hours ( leising & clayton 1987 ) .
instrumental broadenings of these lines and of the background 511 kev line were very small during 19951997 ( harris et al .
although our analysis is somewhat sensitive to the departure of the actual line parameters from these predictions , we believe that it should be adequate to detect lines in the parameter range appropriate for fast novae .
for example , we estimate that lines with energies in the range 513522 kev are detected with @xmath27% of true amplitude , corresponding to expansion velocities 12006500 km s@xmath13 which bracket the range observed in fast novae ( warner 1995 ) .
the 4005 count spectra were fit to the above model ( plus an underlying constant term ) and the line amplitudes were divided by the photopeak effective area at 511 kev .
this photopeak efficiency was determined from monte carlo simulations as a function of energy and zenith angle ( seifert et al .
1997 ) , taking into account the effects of hole - trapping in the detector ( 2.1 ) ; we found that the efficiency remained extremely stable until the fall of 1997 , whereupon it rapidly fell to 80% of its value at launch .
the effective area is a slowly varying function of the zenith angle of the source . to calculate the average effective area
, we assumed the galactic distribution of the synthetic population of several thousand novae computed by hatano et al .
( 1997 ) , for the southern part of which the mean tgrs zenith angle is @xmath28 , corresponding to an effective area 13.6 @xmath16 .
the fits were performed by the standard method of varying the model parameters to minimize the quantity @xmath29 , with errors on the parameters computed from the parameter range where @xmath29 exceeded the minimum by + 1 ( paper i ) . with a sufficiently large sample of spectra , there is a probability that a fitted line of any given amplitude may be produced by chance .
we therefore imposed a rather high value of significance as the threshold above which a detection would be established . if the significances are normally distributed ( see 3 below ) then our sample size of 4005 spectra implies that a threshold level of @xmath30 yields a probability @xmath31% of a single false detection by chance ( abramowitz & stegun 1964 ) .
a typical fit to a 6 hr spectrum is shown in figure 1 ( there is a more detailed discussion in paper i ) .
the fits are generally acceptable , with values of @xmath29/d.o.f .
close to 1 .
the amplitudes of the nova lines are significantly positive in all cases ( see below ) .
this arises from a significant departure of the blue wing of the 511 kev background line from the gaussian shape assumed in the fits , whose origin is unclear ( paper i ) . the full series of measurements for a nova line of fwhm 8 kev and blueshift 5 kev , ( parameters corresponding to typical predicted values after 6 hr : hernanz et al .
1999 and paper i ) is shown in figure 2 .
it can be seen that the systematic positive offset mentioned above was extremely stable throughout the mission ; there are very weak linear trends on @xmath20year timescales which are almost invisible in fig .
we subtracted this quasi - constant systematic value from all nova line measurements .
a very similar time series was obtained for a nova line at position predicted for 12 hr after the explosion ( 513 kev ) , except that the error bars were very much larger ( see paper i , 3.4 ) . each fitted 6 hr line was combined with the following 12 hr fit in the proportions suggested by the light curve of hernanz et al .
the results closely resembled those of fig . 2 after subtraction of the quasi - constant systematic , since the 12 hr lines contributed little on account of their large error bars .
it is also clear from inspection of fig .
2 that there are no highly significant line amplitudes lying above the mean .
we further show in figure 3 that the distribution of significant deviations from the mean is very close to normal .
the variability in the error bars comes almost entirely from the variability in live times , which is small ( 2.1 ) .
there is therefore a well - defined mean @xmath32 error of @xmath33 photon @xmath34 s@xmath13 ( compare results of paper i for zenith angle @xmath28 ) . the @xmath30 threshold based on this average error
is shown by a dotted line in fig .
the only points lying above this line are a few 6 hr periods with low live time and large errors .
we therefore conclude that no previously - undetected novae were discovered by tgrs during 19951997 , in an almost unbiased search covering a live time of @xmath19 s.
recent developments in the theory of nucleosynthesis in classical novae ( hernanz et al .
1999 ) have been discouraging for our purpose of a positron annihilation @xmath14-ray search , since new measurements of nuclear reaction rates have led to much lower predictions of the flux in this line after 6 and 12 hr .
the discussion in paper i of the capability of constraining the global galactic nova rate using our present results was therefore over - optimistic .
nevertheless , we will discuss the application of our method in general terms , so that even though important constraints can not now be derived , it may be useful for more sensitive future experiments ( e.g. _ integral _ ) or for more optimistic theoretical predictions .
a formal expression for the number of novae detectable by tgrs is @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the galactic nova rate ; @xmath37 is a given ( time varying ) threshold flux for detection by tgrs ; @xmath38 is the fraction of the mass of the galaxy within tgrs s detection radius @xmath39 and @xmath40 ; @xmath41 is the total tgrs live time ; @xmath42 is the fraction of tgrs live time for which @xmath43 ; @xmath44 is the distribution of white dwarf masses in classical novae ; and @xmath45 is the predicted 511 kev line flux at 1 kpc for mass @xmath46 .
the white dwarf mass distribution in novae , @xmath47 , is very poorly known . whereas field white dwarf
masses appear to peak at @xmath48 and to decline in number for higher masses up to the chandrasekhar limit @xmath49 ( warner 1990 ) , the mass distribution in nova systems must be weighted towards higher masses .
this is because the thermonuclear runaway occurs when the basal pressure of the material accreted onto the white dwarf exceeds some critical value .
the critical pressure is proportional to the -4 power of the white dwarf radius , to the white dwarf mass , and to the accreted mass . since white dwarf radii decrease with increasing white dwarf mass ,
the accreted mass necessary to reach critical pressure is a strongly decreasing function of white dwarf mass .
if the accretion rate from the secondary star is roughly independent of white dwarf mass , it follows that explosions on more massive white dwarfs will recur after much shorter intervals ( gehrz et al .
there have not been reliable measurements of this effect , although theory indicates that the ratio of one : co novae of 1:2 is compatible with a distribution peaking at about @xmath50 ( truran & livio 1986 ) .
further , the mass ranges corresponding to the co and one compositions are poorly known and may well overlap ( livio & truran 1994 ) .
theoretical predictions of 511 kev line emission are only available for a few values of @xmath46 . in table 2
we show the parameters of the most recent models suitable for use in eq .
( 4 ) ( hernanz et al . 1999 ) .
earlier models suggest that emission from lower - mass co white dwarf events is considerably less ( gmez - gomar et al .
1998 ) . in view of the remarks above about the one : co ratio , we will make the crude assumption that the ratio of `` low mass '' co objects to `` high mass '' co objects to one objects is 1:1:1 , where `` high mass '' co objects have the properties given in table 2 and `` low mass '' co objects are assumed to produce no 511 kev line emission at all .
this eliminates the integral over _ m _ in eq .
the remaining integral in eq .
( 4 ) can be approximated by the value of the integrand when @xmath37 has its mean value this follows from our result in 2.1 , 3 that the variation of live times in our sample ( and therefore of the errors in fig .
2 ) is very small . for a given model in table 2 , therefore , taking @xmath51 photon @xmath34 s@xmath13 , the problem is reduced to the computation of the fraction @xmath52 of galactic mass which lies within the radius @xmath53 kpc . as an example , let us consider the hernanz et al .
( 1999 ) model of a @xmath54 co nova from table 2 . here
@xmath55 photon @xmath34 s@xmath13 , so that @xmath56 kpc . within this value of @xmath39
we determined that 0.61% of the galaxy s mass resides , according to the widely used bahcall - soneira model of the galaxy ( bahcall & soneira 1984 ) : one - half of this value ( i.e. the southern hemisphere ) gives @xmath57 . for the @xmath54 co model , eq .
( 1 ) then reduces to @xmath58 .
our upper limit for @xmath59 is @xmath60 , with 63% probability ( for poisson - distributed events : gehrels 1986 ) , and the live time is @xmath19 s ( 2.1 ) , giving us a 63% upper limit on the rate of `` high - mass '' co novae of @xmath61 yr@xmath13 .
this is quite close to the exact value 123 yr@xmath13 obtained by explicitly integrating eq .
( 4 ) over @xmath37 ( table 2 ) . in the same way we obtain an upper limit of 238 yr@xmath13 on the rate of novae occurring on one white dwarfs from hernanz et
al.s ( 1999 ) prediction .
our best result comes from the co model in table 2 , which we have assumed to be one - third of the total , from which we derive a global galactic nova rate of @xmath62 yr@xmath13 .
uncertainties in this value clearly arise from uncertainties in the nova models , in the fraction of white dwarfs in nova systems of each type , in the bahcall - soneira model , and in the possibility of distinct spheroid and disk nova populations having differing rates , since our typical detection radius @xmath31 kpc includes almost none of the bahcall - soneira spheroid .
since our results do not significantly constrain previous measurements of the nova rate ( table 1 ) , we do not make estimates of these errors , which will require attention from other , more sensitive experiments ( see next section ) .
an attempt has been made , using the batse instrument on the _ compton _ observatory , to detect 511 kev line emission from a recent nearby nova ( v382 vel ) by a similar method to that used here and in paper i ( hernanz et al .
the advantage of observing with batse over tgrs is its much larger effective area .
its disadvantages are much poorer energy resolution with a nai spectrometer , and a background varying on very short ( @xmath63 min ) timescales .
the sensitivities achieved are comparable to those obtained here .
degradation of the ge detector ( 2.1 ) prevented tgrs from achieving comparable sensitivity on v382 vel ( harris et al .
2000 ) , so future efforts in this field will rely on batse and on the _ integral _ mission , which is scheduled for launch in 2001 september carrying a ge spectrometer ( spi ) with resolution comparable to tgrs but a much larger effective area .
hernanz et al .
( 1999 ) estimated that spi could detect the model novae of table 2 out to @xmath64 kpc .
however they also pointed out that the short duration of the 511 kev line emission would make it difficult for _ integral _ to slew to a candidate event .
thus the detection rate would be limited to novae within the spi field of view , which is @xmath65 fwhm .
the search method which we have used , i.e. an _ ex post facto _ search in background spectra , ought to be perfectly feasible with _
integral_. the chief requirements for this method are very high energy resolution and a sufficiently low and stable background . while the spi detector has excellent resolution , the background level in it has not yet been rigorously computed . nevertheless , qualitative arguments suggest that the background will be no worse than that in tgrs . like _ wind
_ , _ integral _ will be in a high - altitude elliptical orbit which avoids extensive exposure to earth s trapped radiation belts and to albedo @xmath14-rays from earth s atmosphere .
the main disadvantages of _ integral _ for nova detection are the small spi field of view and the planned observing strategy which cuts down the amount of time spent pointing towards the main concentration of novae near the galactic center .
we can make use of the planned program of integral observations of the central galactic radian in the first year of operation ( winkler et al .
1999 ) to estimate the rate at which novae might be detected in the spi data . as previously
, we assume that novae follow the bahcall & soneira ( 1984 ) galactic distribution .
the planned first - year _ integral _ observations may be approximated by a @xmath66 grid with @xmath67 spacing between @xmath68 and @xmath69 , the exposure to each point being 1180 s per pass , with 12 passes per year covering the whole grid .
thus the live time for the whole grid is 0.153 yr . from the bahcall - soneira model , the pointing geometry , and the spi aperture @xmath65 we calculated that the _ integral _ detection radius @xmath64 kpc intercepts @xmath200.75% of the galactic nova distribution .
the live time 0.153 yr is then multiplied by a typical galactic nova rate @xmath70 yr@xmath13 , ( of which 2/3 are practically detectable , as assumed in 4.1 ) , and by the intercepted fraction , to imply that _ integral _ ought to detect 0.04 novae yr@xmath13 . unless theoretical estimates of the 511 kev line flux turn out to be considerably larger , the prospects for such a detection appear to be small .
the same conclusion probably applies to a different method of detecting 511 kev line emission indirectly , by observing the 170470 kev continuum produced by compton scattering in the nova envelope using spi s large - area csi shield ( jean et al .
1999 ) .
we are grateful to m. hernanz and a. kudryahov for helpful discussions and for providing pre - publication results , and to j. jordi ( the referee ) for constructive comments .
peter kurczynski ( university of maryland ) helped in assessing the instrument performance .
theresa sheets ( lhea ) and sandhia bansal ( hstx ) assisted with the analysis software .
abramowitz , m. , & stegun , i. a. 1964 , handbook of mathematical functions ( washington , dc : nbs ) allen , c. w. 1954 , mnras , 114 , 387 bahcall , j. n. & soneira , r. m. 1984 , apjs , 55 , 67 ciardullo , r. , ford , h. , neill , j. d. , jacoby , g. h. , & shafter , a. w. 1987 , apj , 318 , 520 della valle , m. , & claudi , r. 1990 , in physics of classical novae , ed .
a. cassatelli & r. viotti , springer lecture notes in physics 369 ( springer - verlag , berlin ) , 53 della valle , m. , & livio , m. 1994 , a&a , 286 , 786 della valle , m. , bianchini , a. , livio , m. , & orio , m. 1992 , a&a , 266 , 232 duerbeck , h. w. 1984 , ap&ss , 99 , 363 duerbeck , h. w. 1990 , in physics of classical novae , ed . a. cassatelli & r. viotti , springer lecture notes in physics 369 ( springer - verlag , berlin ) , 34 duerbeck , h. w. 1995 , in cataclysmic variables , ed .
a. bianchini , m. della valle , & m. orio , ( kluwer , dordrecht ) , 39 gehrels , n. 1986 , apj , 303 , 336 gehrz , r. d. , truran , j. w. , williams , r. e. , & starrfield , s. 1998 , pasp , 110 , 3 gmez - gomar , j. , hernanz , m. , jos , j. & isern , j. 1998 , mnras , 296 , 913 harris , m. j. , teegarden , b. j. , cline , t. l. , gehrels , n. , palmer , d. m. , ramaty , r. , & seifert , h. 1998 , apj , 501 , l55 harris , m. j. , naya , j. e. , teegarden , b. j. , cline , t. l. , gehrels , n. , palmer , d. m. , ramaty , r. , & seifert , h. 1999 , apj , 522 , 424 ( paper i ) harris , m. j. , palmer , d. m. , naya , j. e. , teegarden , b. j. , cline , t. l. , gehrels , n. , ramaty , r. , & seifert , h. 2000 , in proc .
fifth compton symposium , ed .
m. mcconnell , in press hatano , k. , branch , d. , fisher , a. , & starrfield , s. 1997 , mnras , 290 , 113 hernanz , m. , jos , j. , coc , a. , gmez - gomar , j. , & isern , j. 1999 , apj , 526 , l97 hernanz , m. , smith , d. m. , fishman , g. j. , harmon , b. a. , gmez - gomar , j. , jos , j. , isern , j. , & jean , p. 2000 , in proc .
fifth compton symposium , ed .
m. mcconnell , in press higdon , j. c. , & fowler , w. a. 1987 , apj , 317 , 710 jean , p. , et al . 1999 ,
lett . & comm . , 38 , 421 kudryashov , a. d. 2000 , in proc .
fifth compton symposium , ed .
m. mcconnell , in press kurczynski , p. , et al . 1999 ,
methods phys .
res . a , 431 , 141 leising , m. d. , & clayton , d. d. 1987 , apj , 323 , 159 liller , w. , & mayer , b. 1987 , pasp , 99 , 606 livio , m. , & truran , j. w. 1994 , apj , 425 , 797 seifert , h. , naya , j. e. , sturner , s. j. , & teegarden , b. j. 1997 in aip conf .
410 , proc .
fourth compton symposium , ed . c. d. dermer ,
m. s. strickland , & j. d. kurfess ( new york : aip ) , 1567 shafter , a. w. 1997 , 487 , 226 sharov , a. s. 1972 , sov .
astr . , 16 , 41 truran , j. w. , & livio , m. 1986 , apj , 308 , 721 van den bergh , s. 1988 , comments astrophys .
, 12 , 131 warner , b. 1989 , in classical novae , ed . m. f. bode & a. evans ( wiley : new york ) , 1 warner , b. 1990 , in physics of classical novae , ed
. a. cassatelli & r. viotti , springer lecture notes in physics 369 ( springer - verlag , berlin ) , 24 warner , b. 1995 , cataclysmic variable stars ( cup : cambridge ) winkler , c. , gehrels , n. , lund , n. , schnfelder , v. , & ubertini , p. 1999
, astrophys .
lett . & comm . ,
39 , 361 lcc method & rate yr@xmath13 & reference + m31 , m33 , lmc comparison & @xmath71 & ( 1 ) + extrapolate from known nearby novae & @xmath72 & ( 2 ) + correct incompleteness & extinction & @xmath73 & ( 3 ) + correct incompleteness & extinction & @xmath74 & ( 4 ) + correct incompleteness & extinction & 260 & ( 5 ) + monte carlo simulation & @xmath75 & ( 6 ) + m31 comparison & 46 & ( 7 ) + extrapolate luminosity function & @xmath76 & ( 8) + external galaxies comparison & 1146 & ( 9 ) + m31 comparison & @xmath77 & ( 10 ) + _ references _ + 1 . dellavalle & livio 1994 .
warner 1989 .
liller & mayer 1987 .
shafter 1997 .
sharov 1972 .
hatano et al .
higdon & fowler 1987 .
allen 1954 .
ciardullo et al .
van den bergh 1988 .
present work .
+ lcc model & co & one + white dwarf mass , @xmath78 & 1.25 & 1.15 + line flux at 1 kpc , & @xmath79 & @xmath80 + photon @xmath34 s@xmath13 & & + detection radius @xmath39 , kpc & 0.9 & 0.7 + galactic rate , yr@xmath13 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 + | the good energy resolution ( 34 kev fwhm ) of the transient gamma ray spectrometer ( tgrs ) on board the _ wind _ spacecraft makes it sensitive to doppler - shifted outbursts of 511 kev electron - positron annihilation radiation , the reason being that the doppler shift causes the cosmic line to be slightly offset from a strong instrumental background 511 kev line at rest , which is ubiquitous in space environments .
such a cosmic line ( blueshifted ) is predicted to arise in classical novae due to the annihilation of positrons from @xmath0-decay on a timescale of a few hours in an expanding envelope . a further advantage of tgrs its broad field of view , containing the entire southern ecliptic hemisphere has enabled us to make a virtually complete and unbiased 3year search for classical novae at distances up to @xmath1 kpc .
we present negative results of this search , and estimate its implications for the highly - uncertain galactic classical nova rate and for future space missions . |
we congratulate marek jeabek for organizing an excellent conference . we thank maria krawczyk for several useful discussions .
this research was partially supported by the polish state committee for scientific research grants 2 p03b 184 10 , 2 p03b 89 13 and by the eu fourth framework programme `` training and mobility of researchers '' , network quantum chromodynamics and the deep structure of elementary particles , contract fmrx - ct98 - 0194 .
9999 h. abramowicz , m. krawczyk , k. charchua , a. levy , u. maor , int . j. mod
a8 * ( 1993 ) 1005 and references therein .
report of the working group on @xmath12 physics , p. aurenche , g.a .
schuler ( conveners ) , in : g. altarelli , t. sjstrand , p. zwirner ( eds . ) , proceedings of the workshop on physics at lep2 , cern yellow preprint 96 - 01 , hep - ph/9601317 .
m. krawczyk , acta phys . polon . * b28 * ( 1997 ) 2659 ; m. krawczyk , a. zembrzuski , m. staszel , desy-98 - 013 , hep - ph/9806291 . t.h .
bauer et al . , rev .
* 50 * ( 1978 ) 261 and references therein .
j. kwieciski , b. badeek , z.phys . *
c43 * ( 1989 ) 251 .
b. badeek , j. kwieciski , phys . lett .
* b295 * ( 1992 ) 263 .
e. gotsman , a. levy and u. maor , z. phys .
* c40 * ( 1988 ) 117 .
a. corsetti , r.m .
godbole , g. pancheri , phys .
b435 * ( 1998 ) 441 and references therein .
m. glck , e.reya and a.vogt , phys.rev .
* d46 * ( 1992 ) 1973 .
a. donnachie and p.v .
landshoff , phys . lett .
* b296 * ( 1992 ) 227 .
berger et al . , pluto collaboration , phys . lett . * b149 * ( 1984 ) 421 ; z. phys . * c26 * ( 1984 ) 353 .
h. aihara et al . ,
tpc/2@xmath79 collaboration , phys .
* d41 * ( 1990 ) 2667 .
baru et al . , md-1 collaboration , z. phys .
* c53 * ( 1992 ) 219 . | the parametrisation of the photon structure function in the low @xmath0 region is formulated .
it includes the vmd contribution and the qcd improved parton model component suitably extrapolated to the low @xmath0 region .
the parametrisation describes reasonably well existing experimental data on @xmath1 for real photons and the low @xmath0 data on @xmath2 .
predictions for @xmath1 and for @xmath2 for energies which may be accesssible in future linear colliders are also given .
* @xmath3 at low @xmath0 + and @xmath1 at high energies * + , j. kwieciski @xmath4 and a. m. stato @xmath4 + @xmath5 _ department of physics , uppsala university , p.o.box 530 , 751 21 uppsala , sweden _
+ _ and institute of experimental physics , warsaw university , hoa 69 , 00 - 681 warsaw , poland _
+ @xmath4 _ department of theoretical physics , h. niewodniczaski institute of nuclear physics , + radzikowskiego 152 , 31 - 342 cracow , poland _
+ the structure function of the photon is described at large scales @xmath0 by the qcd improved parton model @xcite .
it is expected however that in the low @xmath0 region the vector meson dominance ( vmd ) contribution @xcite may also become important . here , as usual , @xmath6 where @xmath7 denotes the four momentum of the virtual photon probing the real photon with four momentum @xmath8 .
the cm energy squared @xmath9 of the @xmath10 system is @xmath11 .
+ in this talk we wish to present the representation of the photon structure function which includes both the vmd contribution together with the qcd improved parton model term suitably extrapolated to the low @xmath0 region .
this representation of the photon structure function is based on the extension of similar representation of the nucleon structure function to the case of the photon `` target '' @xcite .
possible parametrization of the photon structure function which extends to the low @xmath0 region has also been discussed in ref .
@xcite .
there do also exist several microscopic models describing the energy dependence of the total @xmath12 cross - section @xcite .
+ our representation of the structure function @xmath13 is based on the following decomposition : @xmath14 where in what follows we shall consider the structure function of the photon , i.e. @xmath15 . the terms @xmath16 and @xmath17 denote the vmd and partonic contributions respectively .
the vmd part is given by the following formula : @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the mass of the vector meson @xmath20 and @xmath21 denotes the @xmath22 total cross - section .
the parameters @xmath23 can be determined from the leptonic widths @xmath24 @xcite : @xmath25 the partonic contribution is expressed in terms of the structure function @xmath26 obtained from the qcd improved parton model analysis of the photon structure function in the large @xmath0 region @xcite : @xmath27 where @xmath28 with @xmath29 denoting the bjorken variable , i.e. @xmath30 .
the parameter @xmath31 should have its magnitude greater than the mass squared of the heaviest vector meson included in the vmd part and its value will be taken to be the same as in ref .
@xcite , i.e. @xmath32 gev@xmath33 .
+ the @xmath34 total cross - section @xmath2 is related in the following way to the photon structure function : @xmath35 after taking in equation ( [ sigma ] ) the limit @xmath36 ( for fixed @xmath37 ) we obtain the total cross - section @xmath38 corresponding to the interaction of two real photons .
the representation ( [ dec ] ) and equations ( [ vmd ] ) and ( [ partons ] ) give the following expression for this cross - section : @xmath39 in the large @xmath0 region the structure function given by eq .
( [ dec ] ) becomes equal to the qcd improved parton model contribution @xmath40 .
the vmd component gives the power correction term which vanishes as ( @xmath41 ) for large @xmath0 .
the modifications of the qcd parton model contribution ( i.e. replacement of the parameter @xmath29 by @xmath42 defined by equation ( [ xbar ] ) , the shift of the scale @xmath43 and the factor @xmath44 instead of 1 ) are also negligible at large @xmath0 and introduce the power corrections which vanish as @xmath41 .
+ in the quantitive analysis of @xmath45 and of @xmath38 we have taken the @xmath26 from the lo analysis presented in ref .
@xcite .
+ the vmd part was estimated using the following assumptions : 1 .
the numerical values of the couplings @xmath46 are the same as those used in ref .
@xcite .
they were estimated from relation ( [ gammav ] ) which gives the following values : @xmath47 2 .
the cross - sections @xmath48 are represented as the sum of the reggeon and pomeron contributions : @xmath49 where @xmath50 @xmath51 with @xmath52 and @xmath53 @xcite .
+ 3 .
the pomeron couplings @xmath54 are related to the corresponding couplings @xmath55 controlling the pomeron contributions to the total @xmath56 cross - sections assuming the additive quark model and reducing the total cross - sections for the interaction of strange quarks by a factor equal 2 .
this gives : @xmath57 + @xmath58 4 .
the reggeon couplings @xmath59 are estimated assuming additive quark model and duality ( i.e. dominance of planar quark diagrams ) .
we also assume that the quark couplings to a photon are proportional to the quark charge with the flavour independent proportionality factor .
this gives : @xmath60 + @xmath61 5 .
the couplings @xmath55 and @xmath62 are taken from the fit discussed in ref .
@xcite which gave : @xmath63 in fig.1 we compare our predictions with the data on @xmath64 @xcite .
we show experimental points corresponding to the `` low '' energy region ( @xmath65 10 gev ) @xcite and the recent preliminary high energy data obtained by the l3 and opal collaborations at lep @xcite .
we can see that the representation ( [ sgamgam ] ) for the total @xmath12 cross - section describes the data reasonably well . it should be stressed that our prediction is essentially parameter free .
the magnitude of the cross - section is dominated by the vmd component yet the partonic part is also non - negligible .
the latter term is in particular responsible for generating steeper increase of the total cross - section with increasing @xmath37 than that embodied in the vmd part which is described by the soft pomeron contribution .
the decrease of the total cross - section with increasing energy in the low @xmath37 region is controlled by the reggeon component of the vmd part ( see eqs .
( [ rpgv ] ) , ( [ rgv ] ) and ( [ lambda ] ) ) and by the valence part of the partonic contribution .
[ fig : fig1 ] in fig .
2 we show predictions for the total @xmath12 cross - section as the function of the total cm energy @xmath37 in the wide energy range which includes the energies that might be accessible in future linear colliders . we also show in this figure the decomposition of @xmath64 into its vmd and partonic components . we see that at very high energies these two terms exhibit different energy dependence .
the vmd part is described by the soft pomeron contribution which gives the @xmath66 behaviour with @xmath67 = 0.0808 ( [ lambda ] ) .
the partonic component increases faster with energy since its energy dependence reflects increase of @xmath68 with decreasing @xmath42 generated by the qcd evolution @xcite .
[ fig : fig2 ] this increase is stronger than that implied by the soft pomeron exchange . as the result the total @xmath12 cross - section , which is the sum of the vmd and partonic components does also exhibit stronger increase with the increasing energy than that of the vmd component .
it is however milder than the increase generated by the partonic component alone , at least for @xmath69 gev .
this follows from the fact that in this energy range the magnitude of the cross - section is still dominated by its vmd component .
we found that for sufficiently high energies @xmath37 the total @xmath70 cross - section @xmath64 described by eq .
( [ sgamgam ] ) can be parametrized by the effective power law dependence @xmath71 with @xmath72 slowly increasing with energy within the range @xmath73 for 30 gev @xmath74 10@xmath75 gev .
+ [ fig : fig3 ] in fig .
3 we compare our predictions for @xmath76 based on equations([dec ] , [ vmd ] , [ partons ] ) and ( [ sigma ] ) with the experimental data in the low @xmath0 region @xcite .
we can see that in this case the model is also able to give a good description of the data .
+ finally in fig .
4 we show our results for @xmath76 plotted as the function of @xmath0 for different values of the total cm energy @xmath37 .
we notice that for low values @xmath0 the cross - section does only weakly depend upon @xmath0 . in the large @xmath0 region
it follows the @xmath41 scaling behaviour modulated by the logarithmic scaling violations implied by perturbative qcd .
+ [ fig : fig4 ] to sum up we have presented an extension of the representation developed in refs .
@xcite for the nucleon structure function @xmath77 for arbitrary values of @xmath0 , onto the structure function of the real photon .
this representation includes both the vmd contribution and the qcd improved parton model component suitably extrapolated to the region of low @xmath0 .
we showed that it is fairly succesful in describing the experimental data on @xmath38 and on @xmath76 at low @xmath0 .
we also showed that one can naturally explain the fact that the increase of the total @xmath12 cross - section with increasing cm energy @xmath37 is stronger than that implied by soft pomeron exchange .
the calculated total @xmath12 cross - section was found to exhibit approximate power - law increase with increasing energy @xmath37 , i.e. @xmath78 with @xmath72 slowly increasing with energy within the range @xmath73 for 30 gev @xmath74 10@xmath75 gev . |
over the course of the last decade , network science has attracted an ever growing interest since it provides important insights on a large class of interacting complex systems .
one of the features that has drawn much attention is the structure of interactions highlighted by the network representation .
indeed , it has become increasingly clear that global structural patterns emerge in most real networks @xcite .
one such pattern , where links and nodes are aggregated into larger groups , is called the community structure of a network . while the exact definition of communities is still not agreed upon @xcite ,
the general consensus is that these groups should be denser than the rest of the network .
the notion that communities form some sort of independent units ( families , friend circles , coworkers , protein complexes , etc . ) within the network is thus embedded in that broader definition .
it follows that communities represent functional modules , and that understanding their layout as well as their organization on a global level is crucial to a fuller understanding of the system under scrutiny @xcite . by developing techniques to extract this organization
, one assumes that communities are encoded in the way nodes are interconnected , and that their structure may be recovered from limited , incomplete topological information . various algorithms and models
have been proposed to tackle the problem , each featuring a different definition of the community structure while sharing the same general objective .
although these tools have been used with success in several different contexts @xcite , a number of shortcomings are still to be addressed . in this report
, we show how to improve existing algorithms independent of the procedure or the definitions they use .
more precisely , we first show that present algorithms tend to overlook small communities found in the neighborhood of larger , denser ones .
then , we propose and develop a _ cascading _ approach to community detection that greatly enhance their performance .
it is known that a resolution limit exists for a large class of community detection algorithms that rely on the optimization of a quality function ( e.g. , modularity @xcite ) over non - overlapping partitions of the network @xcite .
indeed , it appears that the size of the smallest detectable community is related to the size of the network .
this leads to counterintuitive cases where clearly separated clusters of nodes are considered as one larger community because they are too small to be resolved by the detecting algorithm .
a possible solution could be to conduct a second analysis on all detected communities in order to verify that no smaller modules can be identified .
however , the optimal partition of a network should include overlapping communities , as they capture the multiplicity of functions that a node might fulfill since nodes can then be shared between many communities .
we argue that a different resolution limit , due to an effect that we refer to as _ shadowing _ , arises in detection algorithms that : 1 .
allow such _ overlapping communities _ ; 2 .
rely on some _ global resolution parameter_. shadowing typically occurs when large / dense communities act as screens hence preventing the detection of smaller / sparser adjacent communities . to illustrate this phenomenon , we study two families of detection algorithms based on two different paradigms of community structure , namely nodes and links communities .
the clique percolation algorithm ( cpa ) @xcite defines communities as maximal _
@xmath0-clique _ percolation chains , where a @xmath0-clique is a fully connected subgraphs of @xmath0 nodes , and where a percolation chain is a group of cliques that can be reached from one adjacent - cliques are said to be adjacent if they share @xmath1 nodes . ]
@xmath0-clique to another @xcite .
the complete community structure is obtained by detecting every maximal percolation chains for a given value of @xmath0 .
it is noteworthy that the definition of a community in this context is consistent with the general description of communities outlined in sec .
[ sec : intro ] .
indeed , @xmath0-clique percolation chains are dense by definition , and a sparser neighboring region is required to stop a @xmath0-clique percolation chain , ensuring that communities are denser than their surroundings .
we expect shadowing as both conditions listed in sec .
[ sec : intro ] are met : 1 .
since percolation chains communities consist of @xmath0-cliques sharing @xmath1 nodes , overlapping communities occur whenever two cliques share less than @xmath1 nodes ; 2 .
the size of the cliques , @xmath0 , acts as a global resolution parameter .
let us explain this last point . in principle ,
low values of @xmath0 lead to a more flexible detection of communities as a smaller clique size allows a wider range of configurations .
however , low values of @xmath0 often yield an excessively coarse - grained community structure of the network since percolation chains may grow almost unhindered and include a significant fraction of the nodes . in contrast
, large values of @xmath0 may leave most of the network uncharted as only large and dense clusters of nodes are then detected as communities .
an _ optimal value _ corresponding to a compromise between these two extreme outcomes must therefore be chosen . as this value of @xmath0 attempts to balance these two unwanted effects for the entire network as a whole
, a shadowing effect is expected to arise causing the algorithm to overlook smaller communities , or to merge them with larger ones .
see fig .
[ fig : cpa_shadowing ] for an illustration of this effect . and
@xmath2 are respectively colored in green and blue . from eq .
( [ eq : similarity_ahn ] ) , we have that @xmath3 .
note that apart from nodes @xmath4 and @xmath5 , the neighboring nodes of the keystone @xmath0 ( colored in yellow ) are not considered in this calculation of @xmath6 . ]
the link clustering algorithm ( lca ) @xcite aggregates links and hence the nodes they connect into communities based on the similarity of their respective neighborhood . denoting @xmath7 the link between nodes @xmath8 and @xmath9 , the similarity of two adjacent links @xmath10 and @xmath11 ( attached to a same node @xmath0 called the _ keystone _ ) is quantified through a jaccard index @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the set of node @xmath14 and its neighbors , and @xmath15 is the cardinality of the set . figure [ fig : similarity_ahn ] illustrates the calculation of @xmath16 .
once the similarity has been calculated for all adjacent pair of links , communities are built by iteratively aggregating adjacent links whose similarity exceeds a given threshold @xmath17 .
we refer to links that are left after this process ( i.e. , communities consisting of one single link ) as _ unassigned_. , @xmath18 and @xmath19 contain considerably more elements that their corresponding intersections since nodes @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath20 all have high degrees . according to eq .
[ eq : similarity_ahn ] , this implies that @xmath7 , @xmath21 and @xmath22 share lower similarities
namely @xmath23 and @xmath24than if the triangle had been isolated ( see sec . [
sec : cascading ] ) .
it is therefore likely that these three links will be left unassigned . ] again , a shadowing effect is expected , as the two aforementioned conditions are fulfilled : 1 .
because communities are built by aggregating links , this algorithm naturally allows communities to overlap ( to share nodes ) since a node can belong to as many communities as its degree ( number of links it is attached to ) can allow ; 2 .
the similarity threshold @xmath17 acts as a global resolution parameter as it dictates whether two links belong to the same community or not . to elucidate the global aspect of @xmath17
, we describe how its value is chosen ( as proposed in @xcite ) .
let us first define the density @xmath25 of community @xmath5 as @xmath26 where @xmath27 and @xmath28 are the number of links and nodes in community @xmath5 , respectively .
considering that a community of @xmath29 nodes must at least include @xmath30 links , @xmath25 computes the fraction of potential `` excess links '' that are present in the community .
the similarity threshold @xmath17 is then chosen such that it maximizes the overall density of the communities @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the set of communities detected for a given @xmath17 , @xmath33 is the total number of links assigned to communities of more than one link ( i.e. , @xmath34 ) .
note that @xmath35 is typically a well - behaved function of @xmath17 and normally displays a single maximal plateau @xcite . the value of @xmath17 corresponding to this plateau is then selected as it leads , on average , to the denser set of communities , hence its global nature .
following an analysis similar to sec .
[ sec : cfinder ] , we expect small communities to be left undetected as they are eclipsed by larger and denser ones .
this is mainly due to the use of a resolution parameter ( @xmath17 ) that can not be adjusted locally .
for instance , links in a small community could exhibit vanishing similarities because some of the associated nodes are hubs ( nodes of high degree ) .
this is especially true in the vicinity of large and dense clusters whose nodes are typically of high degree ( see fig . [
fig : ahn_shadowing ] for an illustration ) .
figures [ fig : cpa_shadowing ] and [ fig : ahn_shadowing ] suggest that the inability to detect small or sparse communities in the vicinity of larger or denser ones the shadowing effect could be circumvented by removing these structures from the networks .
we formalize this idea and propose a _ cascading _ approach to community detection that proceeds as follows : 1 . identify large or dense communities by tuning the resolution parameter accordingly using a given community detection algorithm ; 2 . remove the internal links of the communities identified in step 1 ; 3 .
repeat until no new significant communities are found .
the first iteration of this algorithm detects the communities that are normally targeted by detection algorithms , thus ensuring that the cascading approach retains the main features of the `` canonical '' community structure .
after removal of links involved in the detected communities , a new iteration of the detection algorithm is then performed on a sparser network in which previously hidden communities are now apparent .
this process is repeated until a final and more thorough partition of the network into overlapping communities is eventually obtained .
for example , in the case of the cpa , a high value of @xmath0 ( which leads to the traditional community structure ) is selected for the first iteration of the algorithm .
the network then becomes significantly sparser since all cliques of size @xmath36 are destroyed by the removal of internal links in step 2 .
subsequent iterations of the detection algorithm can thus be conducted at lower @xmath0 , unveiling finer structures , as the pathways formed by dense cluster are no longer available .
the process naturally comes to a halt at @xmath37 , since @xmath38 only detects the disjoint components of the network . in the case of the lca ,
the detection is stopped _ before _
the partition density reaches zero , for @xmath39 only detects chains of links ( the keystone ensures a non - vanishing similarity ) , which in general are not classified as significant communities .
it is worth mentioning that conducting this repeated analysis does not increase the computational cost significantly , since the cascading algorithm scales exactly like the community detection algorithm used at each iteration , and since the number of iterations that can be carried is small ( typically less than 10 ) .
moreover , the size of the networks ( number of links and nodes ) effectively decreases after each iteration , further reducing the cost .
to investigate the efficiency and the behavior of the cascading detection , we have applied our approach to 10 network datasets : arxiv cond - mat circa 2004 ( arxiv ) @xcite , brightkite online ( brightkite ) @xcite , university rovira i virgili email exchanges ( email ) @xcite , gnutella peer - to - peer data ( gnutella ) @xcite , internet autonomous systems ( internet ) @xcite , mathscinet co - authorship ( mathsci ) @xcite , pretty - good - privacy data exchange ( pgp ) @xcite , western states power grid ( power ) @xcite , protein - protein interactions ( protein ) @xcite and word associations ( words ) @xcite .
at the first iteration , leading to an immediate complete detection of the community structure .
( _ right _ ) results of a canonical use of the lca are shown in white and shades of blue correspond to subsequent iterations . the final state is again shown in black .
note that all results are normalized to the number of assignable links in the original network .
for the cpa , this corresponds to the number of links that belong to at least one 3-clique . for the lca
, a link is considered assignable if at least one of the two nodes it joins have a degree greater than one . ] first and foremost , our results show that cascading detection _ always _ improves the thoroughness of the community structure detection .
indeed , fig .
[ fig : cascading_detection ] shows that while a traditional use of the algorithms yields partitions with high fractions of unassigned links , the cascading approach leads to community structures where this fraction is significantly reduced .
more precisely , the percentage of remaining assignable links drops from 54.1% to 26.3% on average in the case of cpa , and from 41.0% to 5.3% in the case of lca .
note how cascading detection is more efficient when applied to the lca .
this is due to the fact that the effective network gets increasingly sparser with each iteration , and that link clustering works equally well on sparse and dense networks , whereas clique percolation requires a high level of clustering to yield any results .
figure [ fig : size_distribution ] confirms that as the cascading detection proceeds , smaller and previously masked
communities are detected , regardless of the algorithm used .
for instance , fig .
[ fig : size_distribution_wa_cp ] clearly shows how a significant number of 3-cliques are overlooked by `` traditional '' use of the cpa .
however , large communities are also found after many iterations , suggesting that the shadowing effect is not restricted to small communities .
+ visual inspection of the detected communities not only verifies the quality of the hidden communities , but also confirms our intuition of the shadowing effect .
for instance , fig .
[ fig : wordassahn1 ] shows a triangle detected at the third iteration ( out of five ) of the lca on the words network .
this structure was most likely missed during the initial detection due to the high degree of its three nodes , as speculated in fig .
[ fig : ahn_shadowing ] . similarly , although @xmath40 was initially chosen ( according to the criterion discussed in sec .
[ sec : cfinder ] ) for the cpa on the words network , a second iteration using @xmath37 has permitted the detection of other significant communities such as the one shown in fig . [
fig : wordasscfinder ] .
more complex structures and correlations are also brought to light using this approach .
figure [ fig : wordassahn2 ] presents a star of high - degree nodes detected at the third iteration of the lca on the word association network .
none of these nodes are directly connected to each other , but they share many neighbors . hence , once the main communities were removed here semantic fields related to toys , theatre and music the shadow was lifted such that this correlated , but unconnected structure could be detected . whether this particular structure should be defined as a relevant community is up for debate . keeping in mind that there are no consensus on the definition of a proper _ community _ in complex networks ,
the role of algorithms , and consequently of the cascading method , is to infer plausible significant structures .
internal link removal is destructive in the sense that information about shadowed communities is lost in the process , as some of the internal links are shared by more than one community @xcite .
leaving these links untouched would certainly enhance the quality of the detected communities while further reducing the uncharted portion of the network . nevertheless , without using refined algorithm and by only resorting to our simple idea ,
we obtain surprisingly good results .
this suggest that shadowing is not necessarily due to the density of the prominent communities but rather to the stiffness of the resolution parameter . indeed , by using a cascading approach , we allow this parameter to vary artificially from a region of the network to the other , as the algorithm is effectively applied to a new network partially retaining the structure of the original network at each iteration .
a once rigid global parameter can now flexibly adapt to small changes in the topology of the network to better reveal subtle structures .
in conclusion , we have managed to significantly reduce the uncharted portion of a network by assigning an important fraction of seemingly random links to relevant communities .
this significant improvement in community detection will help shrink the gap between analytical models and their real network counterparts .
the difficult problem of accurately modeling the dynamical properties of real networks might be better tackled if one includes complex community structure through comprehensive distributions or solved motifs @xcite , two applications for which a reliable and complete partition is fundamental .
moreover , this work opens the way to more subtle cascading approach , as envisioned at the end of the previous section .
for instance , we could build an extreme version of the algorithm where communities are detected one by one .
such an approach would enable a perfect adaptation of the resolution parameter to the situation at hand . and while it would certainly come to significant computational cost , it could lead to the mapping of the community detection problem unto simpler problems .
if we accept to detect communities one at a time , the detection of the most significant ones can be done through well optimized methods , such as modularity optimization @xcite , which would otherwise be incapable of detecting overlapping communities .
finally , perhaps the most significant observation that emerges from our work could be simply stated : since community structure occurs at all scales , global partitioning of overlapping communities must be done sequentially , cascading through the organizational layers of the network .
.*summary of the results presented in fig .
[ fig : cascading_detection ] . * cpa@xmath41 and lca@xmath41 are the percentages of remaining assignable links for a _
normal _ use of the cpa and lca , respectively , whereas cpa@xmath42 and lca@xmath42 are the _ final _ percentages using a cascading approach .
the number of iterations to reach the final state is also given . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
the authors wish to thank the gephi @xcite development team for their visualization tool ; yong - yeol ahn _
et al . _ for the link community algorithm ; gergely palla _ et al . _ for the clique percolation algorithm ; all the authors of the cited papers for providing the network data ; and calcul qubec for computing facilities .
this research was funded by cihr , nserc and frq nt .
e. cho , s.a .
myers , & j. leskovec , friendship and mobility : user movement in location - based social networks , _ acm sigkdd international conference on knowledge discovery and data mining ( kdd ) _ , ( 2011 ) .
m. ripeanu , i. foster , & a. iamnitchi , mapping the gnutella network : properties of large - scale peer - to - peer systems and implications for system design , _ ieee internet computing journal _ , * 6 * , 50 - 57 , ( 2002 ) . | community detection is the process of assigning nodes and links in significant communities ( e.g. clusters , function modules ) and its development has led to a better understanding of complex networks .
when applied to sizable networks , we argue that most detection algorithms correctly identify prominent communities , but fail to do so across multiple scales . as a result
, a significant fraction of the network is left uncharted .
we show that this problem stems from larger or denser communities overshadowing smaller or sparser ones , and that this effect accounts for most of the undetected communities and unassigned links .
we propose a generic cascading approach to community detection that circumvents the problem .
using real network datasets with two widely used community detection algorithms , we show how cascading detection allows for the detection of the missing communities and results in a significant drop of the fraction of unassigned links .
= 1 |
in the last few years , several studies have established the existence of a statistical excess of line - of - sight companion galaxies around high redshift quasars . although it has been suggested that these objects belong to clusters or groups which are physically associated to the quasars ( @xcite ; @xcite ) , in order to be detected at such high redshifts they should be undergoing strong luminosity evolution .
this seems unlikely on the light of the recent data on galaxy evolution obtained through the study of absorption - selected galaxy samples ( @xcite ) , which shows that the most plausible ( and often the unique ) interpretation for many of these observations is the existence of a magnification bias caused by gravitational lensing ( see the reviews @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
the density of a population of flux - limited background sources ( e.g. qsos ) behind a gravitational lens is affected by the lens magnification @xmath4 in two opposite ways .
one of the effects is purely geometrical : as the angular dimensions of a lensed patch of the sky are expanded by a factor @xmath4 , the physical size of a region observed through a fixed angular aperture will be smaller than in the absence of the lens . because of this , the qso surface density will decrease by a factor @xmath4 with respect to the unlensed background density @xcite ) . on the other hand ,
the lens will magnify faint quasars ( which would not have been detected otherwise ) into the sample and increase the number of detected qsos ( @xcite ; @xcite , etc . ) .
if the slope of the quasar number - counts cumulative distribution is steep enough , this effect would dominate over the angular area expansion and there would be a net excess of qsos behind the lens .
foreground galaxies trace the matter overdensities acting as lenses and thus there will be a correlation between the position in the sky of these galaxies ( or other tracers of dark matter as clusters ) and the background quasars .
this qso - galaxy correlation is characterized by the overdensity factor @xmath5 ( @xcite ) , which is defined as the ratio of the qso density behind a lens with magnification @xmath4 to the unperturbed density on the sky .
its dependence on the effective slope @xmath6 of the qso number counts distribution ( which has the form @xmath7 , or @xmath8 ) and the magnification @xmath4 can be expressed as ( @xcite ) @xmath9 we see that the value of q critically depends on the number counts slope of the background sources . for instance , if the number counts are shallow enough , ( @xmath10 ) , there would be negative qso - galaxy associations .
it is clear that in order to detect strong , positive qso - galaxy correlations due to the magnification bias , we have to use qso samples with very steep number counts slopes .
@xcite have shown that for a qso sample which is flux - limited in two bands ( with uncorrelated fluxes ) , @xmath6 is substituted by @xmath11 , the sum of the number counts - flux slopes in those bands .
this effect is called double magnification bias. since @xmath11 is usually @xmath12 for samples which are flux - limited in both the optical and radio bands ( e.g. radio - loud qsos ) , a strong positive qso - galaxy correlation should be expected for them .
it is important to understand when qso samples may be affected by the double magnification bias . the usual identification procedure for a x - ray or radio selected
qso sample involves setting up a flux threshold in the corresponding band and obtaining follow - up optical images and spectra of the qso candidates .
the observer is limited in this step by several circumstances ( e.g. the sensitivity of the detectors or the telescope diameter ) , and even if the qso sample was not intended to be optically selected , in the practice there will be an optical flux threshold for the qsos to enter the sample .
therefore the existence of an explicit and homogeneus flux - limit in the optical band is not as essential for the presence of the magnification bias as the vaue of the effective slope of the unperturbed number counts .
if this slope is steep enough , the effect should be detectable even in incomplete samples , and often more strongly than in complete catalogues : within such samples , the optically brightest qsos ( i.e. , those more likely to be lensed ) are usually the first to be identified , as they are easier to study spectroscopically or through direct imaging . at small angular scales , ( @xmath13 few @xmath14 ) the existence of qso - galaxy correlations
is well documented for several qso samples obtained with different selection criteria ( @xcite ; see also @xcite and @xcite for reviews ) . as expected due to the double magnification bias effect , the correlations are stronger for radio - loud quasars ( @xcite ) . in the cases where no correlation is found ,
e.g. for optically - selected and relatively faint quasars , the results are still consistent with the magnification bias effect and seem to be due to the shallowness of the qso number counts distribution at its faint end ( @xcite ) .
@xcite reviewed the studies on qso - galaxy correlations ( on both small and large scales ) . after assuming that the galaxies forming the excess are physical companions to the qso
, they showed that while the amplitude of the radio - quiet qso - galaxy correlation quickly declines at @xmath15 , the inferred radio - loud qso - galaxy correlation function steadily increases with redshift , independently of the limiting magnitude of the study .
it should be noted that such an effect will be expected , if a considerable part of the galaxy excess around radio - loud qsos is at lower redshifts . if a foreground group is erroneously considered to be physically associated with a qso , the higher the redshift of the qso , the stronger the 3-d clustering amplitude that will be inferred .
this source of contamination should be taken into account carefully when carrying out these studies , as there is evidence that part of the detected excess around high redshift radio - loud qsos is foreground and related with the magnification bias .
the association of quasars with foreground galaxies on scales of several arcmin may arise as a consequence of lensing by the large scale structure as proposed by @xcite ( see also @xcite and references therein ) .
several authors have also investigated qso - cluster correlations : @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
there are not many studies of large scale qso - galaxy correlation , mainly because of the difficulty in obtaining apropriate , not biased , galaxy samples .
besides , the results of these studies may seem contradictory , as they radically differ depending on the qso type and limiting magnitude .
@xcite found a slight anticorrelation between the positions of optically selected qsos and cosmos galaxies .
when they cross - correlated the qsos with the galaxies belonging to clusters , the anticorrelation become highly significant ( @xmath16 ) on @xmath17 scales .
although this defect was interpreted as due to the presence of dust in the foreground clusters which obscured the quasars , the recent results of @xcite and @xcite have imposed limits on the amounts of dust in clusters which seem to contradict this explanation .
it seems more natural , taking into account the rather faint flux - limit of the qsos of @xcite to explain this underdensity as a result of the magnification bias effect .
@xcite do not find any excess of foreground , @xmath18 apm galaxies around a sample of @xmath1 x - ray selected qsos .
it should be noted that although the objects in this sample are detected in two bands ( x - ray and optical ) , the expected excess should not be increased by the double magnification bias effect , because the x - ray and optical fluxes are strongly correlated ( @xcite ) . for these qsos
, the overdensity should be roughly the same as for the optically selected ones .
on the other hand , there have been strong evidences of positive large scale associations of foreground galaxies with high redshift radio - loud qsos . as e.g. , between the radio - loud quasars from the 1jy catalogue ( @xcite ) and the galaxies from the lick ( @xcite , @xcite ) , iras ( @xcite , @xcite ) and apm ( @xcite ) catalogues . in the latter paper
, we found that apm galaxies are correlated with the 1jy qso positions , but did not have enough statistics to reach the significance levels reported in the present paper .
unlike the cosmos catalogue , the apm catalogue provides magnitudes in two filters , @xmath19(blue ) and @xmath20(red ) . when we considered only the reddest , @xmath21 galaxies , the overdensity reached a significance level of @xmath22 .
afterwards , @xcite showed ( using a similar , but much more processed catalog , the aps scans of poss - i ) that the galaxies which trace the high - density cluster and filamentary regions have redder @xmath23 colors than the galaxies drawn from low - density interfilamentary regions .
if the fields containing abell clusters were removed from the sample of @xcite , the results did not change significantly , so it seems that the detected effect was caused by the large scale structure as a whole .
@xcite confirmed the existence of gravitational lensing by the large scale structure by directly detecting the large foreground invisible matter condensations responsible for the magnification of the qsos through the polarization produced by weak lensing in several 1jy fields .
these differences in the nature of the qso - galaxy associations for the several qso types seem to arise quite naturally when we take into account the effects of the double magnification bias .
there is not any strong correlation between the radio and optical fluxes for radio - loud quasars , so for these objects the overdensity will be @xmath24 ( @xcite ) , where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the number - counts slope in the optical and in radio respectively .
if we assume that @xmath25 is roughly the same for radio - loud and optically selected qsos ( although this is far from being clear ) , the overdensity of foreground galaxies should be higher for the radio - loud qsos . for optically and x - ray selected samples ( because of the x - ray - optical flux correlation ) , @xmath11 and therefore the overdensity , will be smaller . in any case , it is difficult to compare conclusively the published analyses of qso - galaxy correlations .
they have been performed using galaxy samples obtained with different filters and magnitude limits , and which therefore may not trace equally the matter distribution because of color and/or morphological segregation or varying depths . besides
, the qso samples differ widely in their redshift distributions . as the magnification of a background source depends on its redshift , qso samples with different redshift distributions
will not be magnified equally by the same population of lenses .
it would thus be desirable , in order to disentangle these factors from the effects due to the magnification bias caused by gravitational lensing , to reproduce the mentioned studies using galaxy samples obtained with the same selection criteria and qso samples which are similarly distributed in redshift .
this is the purpose of the present paper : we shall study and compare the distribution of cosmos / ukst galaxies around two qso samples , one radio - loud and the other radio - quiet with practically identical redshift distributions .
it is also interesting to mention in this context the results of @xcite .
these authors observed that a sample of flat - spectrum radio - loud quasars from the parkes catalogue ( @xcite ) displays a wide range of @xmath27 colours , apparently arising from the presence of varying amounts of dust along the line of sight .
optically selected quasars do not present such a scatter in @xmath28 and lie at the lower envelope of the @xmath28 colours , so webster and collaborators suggested that the selection criteria used in optical surveys miss the reddest quasars .
although there seems to be several other , more plausible , reasons for this phenomenon ( see for instance @xcite ) , it is not adventurous to suppose that it may be partially related to the differences between the foreground projected environments of radio - loud and optically selected quasars .
if a considerable part of the absorbing dust belongs to foreground galaxies , a greater density of these galaxies would imply more reddening .
the structure of the paper is the following : section 2 describes the selection procedures of both qso samples and galaxy fields and discuss the possible bias which could have been introduced in the data .
section 3 is devoted to the discussion of the statistical methods used in the literature for the study of this problem and applies them to our data .
section 4 discusses the results obtained in sec 3 .
section 5 lists the main conclusions of our work .
as we have explained above , the aim of our paper is the study of the distribution of foreground galaxies around two qso samples , one radio - loud and the other radio quiet , which have similar redshift distributions
. it would also be interesting to find out if these differences in the foreground galaxy density occur for the qso samples of @xcite .
this , as we have mentioned , could be related to the differential reddening of the radio - loud quasars .
therefore , in order to form a radio - loud sample suitable for our purposes but as similar as possible to the one used by @xcite , we collect all the quasars from the pks catalogue which are listed in the @xcite qso catalogue and obey the following constraints : a ) flux @xmath29 0.5jy at 11 cm ; b ) @xmath30 and c ) galactic latitude @xmath31 .
so far , we do not constrain the radio spectral index of the quasars .
this yields a preliminary sample of 276 quasars .
the galaxy sample is taken from the roe / nrl cosmos / ukst southern sky object catalogue , ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
it contains the objects detected in the cosmos scans of the glass copies of the eso / serc blue survey plates .
the ukst survey is organized in @xmath32 square degree fields on a 5 degree grid and covers the zone @xmath33 excluding a @xmath34 deg zone in the galactic plane .
cosmos scans cover only @xmath35 square degrees of a ukst field .
the scan pixel size is about 1 arcsec .
several parameters are supplied for each detected object , including the centroid in both sky and plate coordinates , @xmath36 magnitude and the star - galaxy image classification down to a limiting magnitude of @xmath37 .
we are going to study the galaxy distribution in @xmath38 radius fields centered on the quasars of our sample . due to several factors as vignetting and optical distorsions
, the quality of the object classification and photometry in schmidt plate based surveys degrades with increasing plate radius .
therefore , we constrain our fields to be at a distance from the plate center of @xmath39 degrees . besides , to avoid the presence of fields which extend over two plates we further restrict our sample to have @xmath40 degrees , where @xmath41 and @xmath42 are the distances , in the @xmath6 and @xmath43 directions respectively , from the center of the plate ( because of the ukst survey declination limits , this also constrains our quasar sample to have @xmath44 ) .
after visually inspecting all the fields , several of them ( 6 ) are excluded from the final sample because they present meteorite traces .
we end up with 147 circular fields with a @xmath45 radius centered on an equal number of parkes quasars .
this subsample of radio - loud quasars is , as far as we know , not biased towards the presence of an excess of foreground galaxies , which is the essential point for our investigation . in order to avoid contamination from galaxies physically associated with the quasars
, we also exclude three @xmath46 quasars from our radio - loud sample ( @xcite point out that only @xmath47 of @xmath48 galaxies have @xmath1 ) , which is finally formed by 144 fields .
we have excluded a region of @xmath49 around the positions of the quasars ( which may have an uncertainty up to @xmath50 arcsec ) .
this is done to avoid the possibility of counting the quasar as a galaxy ( there are six cases in which the quasar is classified as an extended object ) and because of the great number of blended objects at the quasar position .
most of these pairs of objects are classified as stars when deblended , but taking into account the pixel resolution , it would be desirable to examine the original plates or , better yet , perform high resolution ccd imaging in order to properly deblend and classify these objects as many of them could be galaxies .
the optically selected sample is taken from the large bright quasar survey as in @xcite .
this prism - selected catalogue contains 1055 quasars brighter than @xmath51 on several equatorial and southern fields ( for details see @xcite ) . in order to form an optically selected subsample of quasars we have begun by choosing the 288 quasars from the lbqs catalogue which were closest in redshift to our final sample of 144 pks quasars .
we impose to them exactly the same constraints in sky and plate position as to the radio - loud quasar fields .
finally we visually examined the fields and excluded six of them because of meteorite traces .
the resulting number of fields is 167 .
as the lbqs extends over relatively small areas of the sky , several of these fields overlap .
we have checked that their exclusion from the statistical tests performed below does not affect significantly the result , so we leave them in the sample . the resulting redshift distribution for both qso samples is plotted in fig 1 .
a kolmogorov - smirnov test can not distinguish between them at a 94.5% significance level .
we merge all the fields in each sample into two superfields which contain all the objects classified as galaxies with @xmath0 .
this is a reasonable limiting magnitude , and has been already used by other investigators ( @xcite ) .
the pks merged field contains 15235 galaxies whereas the lbqs field only contains 14266 .
this is a difference of @xmath52 in the average object background density , well over a possible poissonian fluctuation , and seems to be caused by the presence of misclassified stars in our galaxy sample at low galactic latitudes .
the parkes fields extend over a much wider range of galactic latitudes @xmath53 than the lbqs ones , which are limited to high galactic latitudes @xmath54 and thus much less affected .
in fact , we measure the existence of a significant anticorrelation between the absolute value of the galactic latitude @xmath55 of the fields and the total number of objects in each field @xmath56 .
the correlation is still stronger between @xmath56 and sec@xmath57 ) , as shown in fig .
2 , with a correlation coefficient @xmath58 .
this contamination should be randomly distributed over the field and would lower the significance of any possible correlation and make it more difficult to detect . in order to check this ,
we have correlated the overdensity @xmath59 of objects within the inner half of every individual field , ( @xmath60 is the number of objects within the inner half of the field surface and @xmath61 is the number of objects in the outer half ) with sec@xmath62 , as can be seen in fig .
3 . if anything , there might be a slight anticorrelation ( the spearman s rank correlation test only gives a significance of @xmath63 ) in the sense that the fields with more star contamination are the ones which show less excess of galaxies in the inner half of the field .
this is what could be expected if there were a genuine galaxy excess close to the qso positions ; this excess should be diluted by the presence of stars randomly distributed with respect to the qsos . excluding the fields with @xmath64 , as in @xcite , does not change significantly the main results , as we show in fig 4 .
because of this contamination by stars , there is a slight bias in the data which makes harder to detect qso - galaxy correlations for the pks qsos than for the lbqs ones .
we have also checked that there are no other correlations between @xmath65 and @xmath66 and other possible relevant parameters as the plate or sky position of the fields .
the study of qso - galaxy correlations due to the magnification bias effect is complicated by several circumstances .
the amplitude of the correlation function @xmath67 is expected to be rather weak , and strongly dependent on the limiting magnitude of the galaxies and the qsos . besides , the shape of @xmath67 as a function of @xmath68 is unknown ( it seems that the interesting theoretical estimation of @xcite has not been confirmed empirically by @xcite ) . in the past
, several methods have been used to detect and statistically establish the existence of these correlations .
one of the most simple and widespread approaches has consisted in counting the number of galaxies @xmath69 in a somehow arbitrarily defined region centered on the quasars and comparing the value found with its statistical expectation , which is measured either from the outer regions of the fields or from some other comparison fields which are assumed to have the same density of galaxies on average .
the significance can be inferred empirically ( @xcite ) or just by considering that n has a poissonian distribution with @xmath70 rms .
this last assumption seems to hold well in some cases , when the number of individual fields is very large , but for other samples , usually smaller , the rms is found to be @xmath71 , where @xmath72 ( @xcite ) .
a shortcoming of this method is that it does not extract all the information contained in the fields as it only explores the distribution of galaxies around the quasar in a small number of scales , and often uses the rest of the field just to determine the average density . besides
, if the correlation scale is comparable with the dimensions of the fields , the average density measured on the fields would be increased with respect to the unperturbed one and thus an artificially lowered signification will be obtained .
another method , the rank - correlation test was used in @xcite , @xcite .
all the individual galaxy fields are merged into a single superfield , which is subsequently divided into @xmath73 annular intervals of equal surface .
a spearman s rank order test is applied to determine if the number of galaxies in each bin @xmath74 is anticorrelated with the bin radius @xmath75 .
this test does not require any assumption about the underlying probability distribution of the galaxies and takes into account all the information contained in the fields .
however it has several drawbacks .
the rings have all equal surface , so we end up with more bins in the outer parts of the fields , which are less sensitive from the point of view of detecting the correlation .
besides , the method only senses the relative ordering of @xmath76 and @xmath75 over the whole field .
for instance if @xmath77 is very steep and goes quickly to zero , there will be only a few bins clearly over the average in the central region , and the correlation coefficient could then be dominated by the more numerous outer bins with nearly no excess galaxies .
the value of the correlation coefficient and its significance , depend thus critically on the number of chosen bins and the dimension of the fields .
however , this test can still be useful if the correlation scale is similar to the scale of the field .
recently , bartsch et al . (
1996 ) have introduced the weighted - average test .
they define the estimator @xmath78 as @xmath79 where n is the total number of galaxies in the merged field , and @xmath80 are the radius from the qso of each galaxy .
they show , under certain general assumptions , that if the galaxies in the merged field are distributed following a known qso - galaxy correlation function @xmath81 , for @xmath82 the quantity @xmath78 is optimized to distinguish such a distribution of galaxies from a random one .
they take @xmath83 from the theoretical results of @xcite ( @xmath84 mpc km s@xmath85 ) , and show with simulated fields that this method is slightly more sensitive than spearman s rank order test . however , when they study the correlation between iras galaxies and the qsos from the 1jy catalogue with the weighted - average test they obtain a much higher significance for their result than using the rank order test .
they conclude that although the iras galaxies do not seem to be clustered around the qsos following bartelmann s correlation function , the weighted average method seems to be a much more efficient estimator than the rank order test .
this is not surprising if we consider that , when calculating the estimator @xmath78 ( as long as we use a steep enough form for @xmath86 ) this test gives a much higher weight to the galaxies closer to the qso , that is , to the regions where the excess signal - to - noise is higher .
an extreme case would be to use a top hat function with a given width @xmath87 as @xmath86 ( which would be equivalent to counting galaxies in a central circle of dimension @xmath87 ) .
this arbitrariness in the choice of @xmath86 when we do not know the real shape of the qso - galaxy correlation is a drawback of this method .
another problem is that the probability distribution of @xmath78 is unknown a priori .
because of that , the significance has to be determined using simulations , and as we have seen before , the real galaxy distribution is not always easy to know and model .
nevertheless , when we know theoretically the correlation , this test should be optimal , and it may also be useful in many other cases .
we have applied a variant of the rank order test to study the distribution of galaxies around our pks and lbqs samples .
we also use the spearman s rank order test as statistical estimator ( in the implementation of @xcite ) , but instead of fixing a number of bins and dividing the field in rings of equal surface as in @xcite , the variables to be correlated will be @xmath88 and @xmath89 , where @xmath88 is the value of the empirically determined angular correlation function in rings of equal width and @xmath89 is the distance of the bins from the qso . now , in general , each ring will have a different number of galaxies , but the values of @xmath89 are going to be uniformly distributed in radius , and thus we will not give more weight to the outer regions of the field . as a statistical estimator we shall use @xmath90 , the number of times by which @xmath91 , the so - called sum squared difference of ranks , deviates from its null - hypothesis expected value .
@xmath91 has an approximately normal distribution and is defined as @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the rank of the radius of the i - th ring and @xmath94 is the rank of the density in that same ring .
trying to avoid the dependence of the result on the concrete number of bins , we have followed this procedure : we have chosen a minimal ring width ( @xmath95 ) in order to have at least @xmath96 galaxies in the first ring , and a maximal width ( @xmath97 ) so that there are at least 20 rings within the field .
then we perform 8 different binnings changing the ring width in steps of @xmath98 , estimate @xmath90 for each of them and calculate its average @xmath99 .
this estimator should be very robust as it does not depend so strongly on the concrete value obtained for a binning , and the significance can be estimated directly from the value of @xmath90 without the need of simulations .
the value for the pks field is @xmath100 , @xmath101 and for the lbqs field @xmath102 , @xmath103 .
we have also confirmed this by estimating @xmath99 for @xmath104 simulations with randomly distributed galaxies for each of both fields : the empirical significance for the pks field is @xmath105 whereas the lbqs field gives @xmath106 .
this similarity in the values of the probabilities also confirms that the distribution of the galaxies in the fields is practically poissonian . the qso - galaxy correlation function for the pks and lbqs sample
is shown in fig . 4 and 5 respectively .
error bars are poissonian and the bin width is @xmath97 . in fig
4 we also show , without error bars , the correlation function obtained for the pks fields with @xmath107 in order to further test our results , we have also applied bartsch et al .
( 1996 ) test to our data using bartelmann s @xmath86 and have estimated the significance with @xmath104 simulated fields for each sample with the same number of galaxies as the real fields randomly distributed . strictly speaking
this is an approximation , as the galaxies are clustered among themselves , but we have studied the number of galaxies on rings of equal surface ( excluding a few central rings ) and their distribution is marginally consistent with being gaussian with a rms @xmath108 , what is not surprising if we take into account the great number of fields contributing to each bin .
the existence of a positive qso - galaxy correlation for the pks sample is detected at a significance level of @xmath109 . on the other hand ,
when we apply this test to the lbqs merged field , a slight anti - correlation is found at a level of @xmath110 .
these results are comparable to the ones obtained with the previous test .
we have also tried other arbitrarily chosen variants of the function @xmath86 to see the dependence of significance of the pks excess on the concrete shape of @xmath86 : a gaussian with a @xmath111 width ( analogous to a box of this size ) yields @xmath112 and a @xmath113 law ( the slope of the galaxy - galaxy correlation function ) gives @xmath114 .
we see that for our galaxies , the shape of @xmath86 proposed by bartelmann is not optimal , and the significance depends sensitively on the shape of the function . however , tinkering with the form of @xmath86 may be dangerous , as it could lead to creating an artificially high significance if we overadjust the shape of the function to the data .
thus , it seems that there is a positive qso - galaxy correlation in the pks fields , and what appears to be a slight anticorrelation in the lbqs ones . in order to measure
how much these two radial distributions differ , we have performed a series of binnings as the one described above for our test and defined @xmath115 in each ring as @xmath116 , where @xmath117 is the number of objects in each ring of the pks field and @xmath118 is the number of objects in the same bin of the lbqs field , and normalize by the mean density of each field .
we apply the rank order test to all the resulting sequences of @xmath119 and bin radii @xmath75 as described above and find that @xmath120 , @xmath121 .
@xmath104 simulations of field pairs give a significance of @xmath122 .
this means that the density of foreground galaxies around the radio - loud quasars is higher than in front of the optically selected sample , and is anticorrelated with the distance from the qsos at a @xmath3 significance level .
as shown above , we have confirmed the existence of large scale positive correlations between high - redshift radio - loud qsos and foreground galaxies , whereas for optically selected qsos with the same redshift distribution the correlation is null or even negative .
can these results be explained by the double magnification bias mentioned in the introduction ? in order to answer this question the value of the number - counts distribution slopes in expression ( 1 ) must be determined .
these slopes can be estimated from the empirical distribution functions of our qso samples .
the cumulative number - radio flux distribution for the pks qsos is plotted in fig .
a linear squares fit gives an approximate slope @xmath123 .
the histogram of the distribution of @xmath36 magnitudes for the lbqs and the pks qsos is plotted in fig 7a . for the pks qsos we do not use the magnitudes quoted in @xcite as they have been obtained with different filters and photometric systems .
instead , we have obtained @xmath36 magnitudes from the roe / nrl cosmos / ukst catalog , which should be reasonably homogeneous and accurate for @xmath124 , apart from the intrinsic variability of the qsos .
7a shows that pks qsos extend over a wider range of magnitudes than the lbqs ones , which have @xmath125 . in fig 7b
we show the cumulative distributions of both qso samples , @xmath126 as a function of @xmath36 .
the lbqs distribution ( crosses ) can be well aproximated by a power law @xmath127 with @xmath128 .
the pks distribution ( filled squares ) is more problematic and can not be approximated reasonably by a single power law .
although at brighter magnitudes it seems to have a slope similar to the lbqs ones , it quickly flattens and has a long tail towards faint magnitudes . due to the incompleteness of the pks sample
, this distribution can be interpreted in two ways : either the flattening is caused by the growing incompleteness at fainter optical magnitudes and the slope of the underlying unperturbed distribution for the radio loud qsos is the same as for lbqs ones , or the distribution function is intrisically shallow , and we are approximately observing its true form .
fortunately this is not a critical question ; as it will be shown below , the difference between the slope values obtained in both cases is not enough to change significantly our main conclusions about the causes of the overdensity .
then , we roughly estimate the optical slope for the pks distribution function with a linear squares fit between @xmath129 which yields @xmath130 .
these slopes imply an overdensity of galaxies around the lbqs and pks qsos @xmath131 that is , @xmath132 . at e.g. @xmath133 , for the lbqs we found @xmath134 .
this yields a value for the magnification @xmath135 .
then for the pks qsos , the overdensity should be @xmath136 .
however at @xmath133 , we measure @xmath137 .
if we assume that the intrinsic pks @xmath36 number - counts slope is the same as for the lbqs qsos , @xmath138 , we still can not make both overdensities agree with a same magnification . in order to obtain these results with pure gravitational lensing
, a slope @xmath139 would be needed . for smaller scales ,
the situation does not change , since @xmath140 is still higher .
therefore , we must conclude that it is unlikely that the multiple magnification bias alone explains the results found . as mentioned above ,
some authors have explained the optically selected qso - cluster anticorrelations as due to the existence of dust in clusters ( @xcite and references therein ) .
what would be the expected overdensity when we consider the combined effects of magnification and dust absorption ?
let s consider a patch of the sky which has an average magnification of @xmath4 for background sources and an average flux extinction of @xmath141 for a given optical band , i.e. the observed flux @xmath142 from the background sources in that band would be @xmath143 , where @xmath144 is the flux that we would measure in the absence of absorption . if we consider that the radio emission suffers no attenuation by the dust , the overdensity estimations for our samples would be @xmath145 therefore , from our results on scales of @xmath111 we find @xmath146 , and @xmath147 .
this extinction is consistent with the results of @xcite .
although these values should be considered only as rough estimations , they show that considering dust absorption together with the multiple magnification bias produces new qualitative effects in the behavior of the overdensities of the different qso types .
the strength of the overdensity is attenuated in both samples of qsos , but the effect is stronger for the lbqs qsos , which have a steeper optical counts slope .
if we consider that the dust approximately traces the matter potential wells acting as lenses , i.e. that there is a strong correlation between magnification and extinction , the qsos which are more magnified are also the ones which are more absorbed .
however , if the product @xmath148 is greater than unity , the net effect for each qso will be a flux increment .
an alternative explanation is the existence of the bias suggested by @xcite and @xcite .
they interpret that the avoidance of foreground clusters by optically selected qsos is probably a selection effect due to the difficulty in identyfing quasars in crowded fields . in that case , apart from the slight qso - galaxy anticorrelation generated by this effect , the lbqs samples would avoid the zones where the lensing by the large scale structure is stronger and thus their average magnification @xmath4 would be smaller than that of the pks , which would not be affected by this selection bias . besides , if dust and magnification are correlated , radio - loud qsos would also be more reddened on average than optically selected qsos . regarding flat - spectrum qsos , if we set an additional constraint for our qsos , @xmath149 , where @xmath150 is the slope of the spectral energy distribution , the resulting sample of 107 @xmath1 qsos should be a fair representation of the radio - loud sample used by @xcite for the study of reddening in qsos .
we apply again our rank correlation test to the field obtained by merging these 107 fields and conclude that the cosmos / ukst galaxies are correlated with flat - spectrum qsos at a @xmath151 level .
the qso - galaxy correlation function is plotted in fig . 8 with @xmath152 bins .
the value of the overdensity is similar , but as we have now fewer fields , the significance level is lower .
nevertheless , if we take into account the small amounts of dust allowed by the observations of @xcite , it seems very unlikely that all the reddening measured by @xcite for the pks qsos is due to dust absorption by foreground galaxies , although in some cases this effect could contribute considerably , as it has been shown by @xcite .
this question could be clarified by cross - correlating the reddening of the qsos with the density of foreground galaxies on small scales .
we have studied the clustering of galaxies from the roe / nrl cosmos / ukst catalogue up to 15 @xmath153 scales around two qso samples with @xmath1 .
one of them contains 144 radio - loud qsos from the parkes catalogue , and the other is formed by 167 optically selected qsos obtained from the large bright quasar survey .
there is a @xmath154 significance level excess of cosmos @xmath0 galaxies around the pks qsos , whereas there is a slight defect of galaxies around the lbqs qsos .
we have compared the distribution of galaxies around both samples , and found that there is an overdensity around the pks sample with respect to the lbqs sample anticorrelated with the distance from the qso at a @xmath3 significance level . whilst this result could be thought to agree qualitatively with the theoretical predictions of the multiple magnification bias effect , we show that it is difficult to explain it through gravitational lensing effects alone , and dust in the foreground galaxies and/or selection effects in the detection of lbqs qsos must be considered . finally , we have established that the lines of sight to pks flat - spectrum qsos go through significantly higher foreground galaxy densities than the directions to lbqs quasars .
this may be related , at least partially , with the reddening of the pks qsos observed by @xcite .
the authors acknowledge financial support from the spanish dgicyt , project pb92 - 0741 .
nb acknowledges a spanish m.e.c .
ph.d . fellowship .
the authors are grateful to tom broadhurst , jos luis sanz and ignacio ferreras for carefully reading the manuscript and making valuable suggestions , and sebastian sanchez for useful comments .
they also thank d.j .
yentis for his help .
yentis , d.j , cruddace , r.g . ,
gursky , h. , stuart , b.v . , wallin , j.f .
, mac - gillivray , h.t . & thompson , e.b . , 1992 ,
digitised optical sky surveys , ed .
mac - gillivray and e.b .
thompson , kluwer , dordrecht , 67 | we have studied the distribution of @xmath0 galaxies from the roe / nrl cosmos / ukst catalogue around two samples of @xmath1 qsos with similar redshift distributions . the first sample is formed by 144 radio - loud qsos from the parkes catalogue , and the other contains 167 optically selected qsos extracted from the large bright quasar survey .
it is found that there is a @xmath2 significance level excess of cosmos / ukst galaxies around the pks qsos , whereas there is a marginal defect of galaxies around the lbqs qsos .
when the distribution of galaxies around both samples is compared , we found that there is an overdensity of galaxies around the pks sample with respect to the lbqs sample anticorrelated with the distance from the qsos at a @xmath3 significance level .
although this result apparently agrees with the predictions of the multiple magnification bias , it is difficult to explain by gravitational lensing effects alone ; dust in the foreground galaxies and selection effects in the detection of lbqs qsos should be taken into account .
it has been established that the lines of sight to pks flat - spectrum qsos go through significatively higher foreground galaxy densities than the directions to lbqs quasars , what may be partially related with the reported reddening of pks qsos . |
the higgs mechanism is an essential part of the present day formulation of the standard model .
the u(1 ) gauge model coupled to scalars is a simplification of the gauge
higgs sector of the sm , which keeps the unsolved problem of defining non perturbatively a non asymptotically free field theory .
the u(1)-higgs model has been widely studied previously .
one of the main objectives has been to determine the order of the coulomb - higgs transition , both in the cases of frozen and unfrozen modulus of the scalar field , by using analytical ( mean field , one - loop effective potential , etc ) and numerical techniques ( see @xcite and references therein ) . from those analyses
the situation could be defined in the following way . for large values of @xmath2
the transition seems to be second order , while for small values it looks first order . these results are based on monte carlo studies of the system searching for metastabilities or single / double peaked histograms . due to computational limitations , these calculations had been made with small lattices and short statistics .
here we carry out a study with much larger lattices and high statistics in order to approach the thermodynamical limit in a more reliable way , obtaining results qualitatively consistent with the previous ones .
however , in those works the conclusion that the transition is first order has been obtained by considering the presence of a double peak for a given volume @xmath4 ( or observing metastability ) . as we will show
this is not correct because even in this case , when @xmath4 is increased , both peaks approach , and the latent heat disappears in the thermodynamical limit , obtaining in this way a second order transition for @xmath2 values much smaller than previously considered .
the three parameter u(1)higgs model is described by the action @xmath5 in the @xmath6 limit , @xmath7 and the action simplifies to @xmath8 the phase diagram of that restricted version was considered first in @xcite and has been discussed by us in @xcite , and @xcite .
we discuss here the global aspects of the phase diagram in the fixed modulus case ( see figure [ phdiu1 ] ) .
point a is the pure compact @xmath9 phase transition , a well established first order point @xcite,@xcite,@xcite , even though this transition for small lattices seems to be second order .
we point out that some authors @xcite have cast a new hue on its nature , pointing out the possibility of this transition to be second order . as we showed in @xcite , particularly in the neighbourhood of the triple point c , the line joining a with the latter is also first order .
the line cd was studied by us @xcite and is a first order line ending in a second order point d. the precise location of d is @xmath10 and @xmath11 , with measured critical exponents compatible with the classical ( mean field ) values @xmath12 .
the line bc is more controversial .
the difficulty to identify the order of the coulomb
higgs phase transition was made apparent because of the large finite size effects .
the @xmath13 end of that line is the x y model phase transition , a well established second order one with mean field exponents , which has induced researchers to think the line to be a prolongation of its end point , and as such , second order @xcite .
yet , the relationship of the model to the @xmath14 version and to the @xmath15 model reported in @xcite , @xcite and @xcite points towards a possible first order transition .
however that relationship is based on perturbative arguments ( expansion around @xmath16 ) and might not be applicable . the difficulty to study directly the @xmath6 limit has lead us to study the problem at finite , variable @xmath2 .
this had been done earlier @xcite , and we intend to improve on the statistics and the lattice sizes .
we have fixed @xmath17 , which is on the coulomb higgs side of the first order confining coulomb phase transition .
if we consider larger values of @xmath18 , the system has a larger correlation length , and then in order to approach the thermodynamical limit , @xmath19 , we need very large volumes . also , a tricritical point along the coulomb
higgs transition , where the transition order changes , is not expected .
then , we select some value of @xmath2 and search for the `` critical '' @xmath20 , i.e. we are looking for the coulomb - higgs transition . as is known , for small enough values of @xmath2 the simulations on this transition show clear signals of metastability , giving place to two - peaked histograms , while for large values the metastability disappears .
of course , the simulations are made on finite lattices and then a conclusion on the order of the transition can not be extracted directly from that behaviour .
we have selected an intermediate region of @xmath2 values , ranging from the point where the two peak signal practically disappears for our lattices sizes ( @xmath21 ) to the point where the metastability is so strong that it makes the work with our computational disponibilities difficult ( @xmath22 ) .
the total set of @xmath2-values that we have used is @xmath23 on lattices @xmath24 and @xmath0 ( depending on @xmath2 ) , with statistics ranging between @xmath25 and @xmath26 monte carlo iterations per measurement , on workstations , on parallel machines at the edinburgh parallel computing centre and on our custom , 64 t800 processor computer rtn @xcite .
we have used an over - relaxed metropolis update method , with a multicanonical procedure to accelerate the flip - flop rate in some case .
we use the spectral density technique @xcite in order to improve the determination of the transition point , and the jack - knife method in the error estimation .
we have observed the different energies one can define from the action . in particular we have paid special attention to the link energy @xmath27 as we have fixed the value of @xmath18 and the transition is almost parallel to the @xmath18 axis .
all the observables we will define hereafter will be referred to this energy . in the range of @xmath2 and
@xmath28 studied , the histograms of @xmath29 present the following features ( examples can be seen in fig . [ free_energy ] ) : * two - peak structure . *
asymmetry of the peaks , with a narrow low - energy peak and a broad high - energy one .
* strong size dependence , consisting on a narrowing of the gap and width of the peaks as the lattice size @xmath28 increases , caused by a much faster displacement towards lower energy of the broad peak .
it is known that , due to finite size effects , two - peaked histograms on finite lattices can become single peaked in the thermodynamical limit and vice versa .
for instance , the transition in the @xmath30 potts model is known analytically to be second order but the simulation on finite lattices gives a double peaked structure @xcite .
on the contrary , single peaked histograms on small lattices can become double peaked when the lattice size increases , as in @xcite .
then an accurate study of finite size effects has to be made .
we will use several independent finite size scaling methods , which allow to determine correctly the order of the transition whenever one uses large enough lattices ( but not so large as if one only looked for metastability signals ) .
now we will introduce the different quantities which we have considered in order to extract our conclusions . first , coming back to the histograms , in ref .
@xcite an interesting method is proposed .
they explain how in a two - peaked structure the increment between the minima and the local maximum of the free energy is directly related to the analogous increment for the logarithm of the histogram of the energy .
the idea is that if the transition is first order the gap has to be more pronounced for larger @xmath28 , while if it is second order the depth of the gap does not grow with @xmath28 .
our procedure will be the following . from the histogram of @xmath29 obtained in the simulation
, we calculate a new histogram where the height of the two peaks is the same by using basically the spectral density method @xcite .
then we take the logarithm of it and change its sign . in this way
we obtain a figure analogous to the free energy ( see fig .
[ free_energy ] ) .
here we can measure directly the depth of the gap , let us call it @xmath31 .
a @xmath31 growing with @xmath28 indicates a first order transition , while if it is constant we have a second order one .
second , we have measured the specific heat @xmath32 its maximal value should scale with an exponent @xmath33
. it will be @xmath34 for a first order transition and @xmath35 for a mean field second order one ( in this case @xmath36 will be a constant plus logarithmic corrections ) .
third , we use the maximum of @xmath37 as definition of _ critical _ kappa @xmath38 .
the scaling of @xmath39 with @xmath28 allows us to extract @xmath40
. it will be @xmath41 if the transition is first order , and @xmath42 if we have second order with mean field exponents .
fourth , we consider the latent heat at @xmath38 , @xmath43 , as the difference between the positions of the maxima for a fit to each peak separately to a cubic spline , after the histogram has been shifted to the apparent critical point by the spectral density method . a cubic spline has been preferred to other functional shapes because of its ability to reproduce a maximum and accommodate the mixed states , whose influence on the histogram is otherwise difficult to account for .
if we have @xmath44 in the @xmath45 limit we have a first order phase transition .
fifth , we have computed the binder cumulant @xmath46 if the energy distribution is single peaked ( and then second order ) in the thermodynamical limit , this quantity can be computed exactly and becomes @xmath47 .
first of all , let us comment on which have been our limits on @xmath2 and @xmath28 .
for the biggest value of @xmath2 studied , @xmath21 , it was impossible to distinguish the two peaks on the histogram , and then we could not make the type of treatment described above . for @xmath48 two peaks
are visible but the gap is so small that it is difficult to measure with precision observables such as @xmath31 and @xmath43 ; for this value of @xmath2 we have only simulated @xmath49 . on the other hand , for the smallest value @xmath22 the metastability
is so strong that we have only been able to use @xmath50 . besides
, the simulation in the @xmath51 have been made fixing a value @xmath52 and making two different runs , one starting from a cold configuration and the other one starting from a hot one . in this case ( @xmath51 ) no flip was observed ; then we can only say that the two peaks are rather separated , but a precise estimation of the latent heat and of the other observables is not possible .
in particular , the latent heat is greatly affected by a displacement in @xmath20 ( because the broad peak is much more sensitive than the narrow one , as the displacement in the peak will be proportional to the squared width ) and a bad estimation of @xmath53 would give place to an erroneous measurement .
for the intermediate values of @xmath2 things are more feasible and we have used @xmath54 for @xmath55 and also @xmath56 for @xmath57 .
let us now present the results for the different observables .
the study of the latent heat suggests an extrapolation to zero in the thermodynamical limit for @xmath3 as shown in fig .
[ latent ] .
the specific heat @xmath37 is constant with @xmath28 for the largest @xmath2-values while it grows for the smallest ones , as shown in table [ table_heat ] . in the presence of a stable double peaked structure
( i.e. such that the peaks do not approach when changing @xmath28 ) , @xmath37 scales with the maximum possible speed , i.e. like @xmath4 , indicating a first order transition .
however in our case the peaks are not stable and then the scaling will be different . for a trivial second order transition in @xmath58 ,
it scales only logarithmically ( @xmath59 ) , then it must be almost constant .
the results indicate a crossover between this two behaviors at @xmath60 .
.specific heat for the different values of @xmath28 and @xmath2 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] finally , in table [ table_libre ] are shown the increments of the free energy @xmath31 .
again we can see that the behavior changes at @xmath60 ; for larger values @xmath31 is constant with @xmath28 , while for smaller ones it grows .
a look at fig .
[ free_energy ] shows the different kind of behavior for @xmath61 and @xmath22 ; while in the first case the gap tends to disappear when increasing the lattice size , in the second one it tends to become deeper .
we have investigated the order of the coulomb - higgs transition at fixed @xmath62 and for different values of @xmath2 .
the analysis of several observables indicates a crossover at @xmath60 , the transition being first order for smaller and second order for larger values of @xmath2 .
we remark that in order to extract this conclusion we have needed to consider different lattice sizes and , even though most of them present a two - peak structure , the latent heat goes to zero in the thermodynamical limit ( at least for @xmath3 ) .
previous works had estimated this crossover at @xmath63 @xcite or @xmath64 @xcite for @xmath65 . however for larger @xmath18 a weaker character is expected ( the correlation length grows and we approach the second order transition of the @xmath66 theory ) .
then for @xmath65 the crossover should occur at a smaller @xmath2-value than for @xmath62 .
therefore we have lowered the estimation of the values of @xmath2 for which the coulomb - higgs transition changes order .
we are very grateful to the rtn collaboration for the use of their transputer machine where we have run most of our simulations .
d.i . acknowledges the epcc and the deparment of physics of edinburgh , as well as the ministerio de educacin y cultura ( spain ) for a fellowship . this work has been partially supported by cicyt under contract numbers aen96 - 1634 and aen96 - 1670 and by the eu under contract number erb - chrx ct 92 - 0051 .
9 d. espriu , j.f .
wheater , nucl .
b258 ( 1985 ) 101 .
evertz , k. jansen , j. jersk , c. b. lang and t. neuhaus , nucl .
phys . b285 [ fs19 ] ( 1987 ) 590 .
e. fradkin and s.h .
shenker , phys .
d19 ( 1979 ) 3682 .
a. cruz , a. tarancn , l. a. fernndez , a. muoz sudupe , and j.j .
ruiz - lorenzo , nucl .
b ( p.s . ) 34 ( 1994 ) 638 . a. cruz , a. tarancn , l. a. fernndez , a. muoz sudupe , and j.j .
ruiz - lorenzo , int .
jour . of mod .
c , vol . 5 no . 2 ( 1994 ) 343 .
m. creutz , l. jacobs and c. rebbi , phys .
d20 ( 1979)1915 .
b. lautrup and m. nauenberg , phys .
l. a. fernndez , a. muoz sudupe , r petronzio , and a. tarancn , phys . lett .
b267 ( 1991 ) 100 .
j. jersak , c.b .
lang and t. neuhaus , phys .
77 ( 1996 ) 1933 .
the rtn collaboration , j.l .
alonso et al .
b405 ( 1993 ) 574 .
k. jansen et al . , nucl .
b265 [ fs15 ] ( 1986 ) 187 .
l. a. fernndez , a. muoz sudupe , j.j .
ruiz - lorenzo and a. tarancn , phys .
b312 ( 1993 ) 305 .
rtn collaboration , computing in high energy physics 92 cern 92 - 07 , geneva ( 1992 ) 353 .
m. falcioni , e. marinari , m.l .
paciello , g. parisi and b. taglienti , phys.lett .
b108 ( 1982 ) 331 ; a. m. ferrenberg and r : swendsen , phys .
61 1988 ) 2635 .
m. fukugita , h. mino , m. okawa and a. ukawa , j. phys .
( 1990 ) l561 .
alonso , j.m .
carmona , j. clemente gallardo , l.a .
fernndez , d. iiguez , a. tarancn and c.l .
ullod , phys .
b 376 ( 1996 ) 148 .
j. lee and j.m .
kosterlitz , phys .
65 ( 1990 ) 137 . | the order of the coulomb - higgs transition in the u(1)-higgs model with unfrozen modulus of the scalar field is studied .
large lattices ( up to @xmath0 in one case ) and high statistics are used .
we fix @xmath1 and explore specially a region of @xmath2-values where metastability is observed .
we study the thermodynamical limit of several observables , in particular , the latent heat , the specific heat , the decrement of the free energy between the maxima and the central minimum of the two - peaked histogram , the binder cumulant and the displacement of the critical coupling with the lattice size . the results point towards a second order transition for @xmath3 , while for smaller values of @xmath2 the strong metastability growing with the lattice size seems to derive from a first order character . _
a ) _ departamento de fsica terica , facultad de ciencias , + universidad de zaragoza , 50009 zaragoza , spain + _ b ) _ departamento de fsica terica i , facultad de ciencias fsicas , + universidad complutense de madrid , 28040 madrid , spain + _ key words : _ lattice .
monte carlo .
u(1 ) . higgs .
phase transition .
pacs : _
14.80.bn , 11.15.ha |
the arecibo l - band feed array zone of avoidance ( alfa zoa ) survey searches for 21-cm line emission from neutral hydrogen ( h ) in galaxies behind the disk of the milky way .
the survey uses the alfa receiver on the 305-m arecibo radio telescope .
this region of the sky is termed the zone of avoidance by extragalactic astronomers because of its low galaxy detection rate .
extragalactic observations at visual wavelengths struggle with high extinction levels .
near and far infrared observations suffer confusion with galactic stars , dust , and gas .
21-cm line observations are sensitive to late - type galaxies in general and are not affected by extinction . as a spectral line survey , we generally only have confusion with galactic h within approximately @xmath9100 @xmath0 .
the alfa zoa survey is sensitive to galaxies behind the milky way that go undetected at other wavelengths .
it has been suggested by loeb and narayan ( 2008 ) that undiscovered mass behind the milky way may explain the discrepancy between the cosmic microwave background dipole and what is expected from the gravitational acceleration imparted on the local group by matter in the local universe ( erdogdu et al .
2006 ) .
two large area h zoa surveys have preceded alfa zoa ; the dwingeloo obscured galaxies survey and the hi parkes zone of avoidance survey ( hizoa ) .
the dwingeloo survey detected 43 galaxies in the northern hemisphere within @xmath10 of the galactic plane .
it was sensitive only to nearby , massive objects because of its relatively high noise level of 40 mjy beam@xmath11 ( with velocity resolution of 4 km s@xmath11 ; henning et al .
more recently , hizoa covered decl .
= -90 to + 25 at 6 mjy / beam rms ( with velocity resolution of 27 km / s ) , and detected about 1000 galaxies ( donley et al .
2005 ; henning et al .
2000 , 2005 , shafi 2008 . )
the alfa zoa survey is being conducted in two phases : a shallow and a deep phase .
the shallow phase ( rms = 5 mjy with velocity resolution of 10 km / s ) covers 900 square degrees through the inner galaxy ( @xmath12 , @xmath13 ) and is expected to detect 500 galaxies .
hundreds of galaxies have been detected so far , and data reduction and analysis are ongoing .
this is complemented by a deep survey ( @xmath12 , @xmath14 , @xmath15 ) , 5 times more sensitive , in which we expect to detect thousands of galaxies ( based on the himf of davies et al . ,
2011 ) but for which observations are not yet complete .
this paper presents the discovery and the results from follow - up observations of a nearby galaxy , alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 .
section 2 describes the discovery and follow - up with the arecibo radio telescope .
section 3 describes follow - up observations with the expanded very large array ( evla ) .
section 4 describes ongoing optical follow - up with the 0.9-m southeastern association for research in astronomy ( sara ) telescope .
section 5 discusses the results from these observations .
alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 was initially detected with the shallow portion of the alfa zoa survey .
observations were taken with the mock spectrometer covering 300 mhz bandwidth in two 170 mhz sub - bands of 8192 channels each , giving a hanning smoothed velocity resolution of 10 @xmath0 at z = 0 .
the survey uses a meridian nodding mode observation technique : the telescope slews up and down in zenith angle along the meridian for an effective 8 second integration time per beam giving rms = 5 mjy per beam .
observations were taken in 2008 and 2009 .
the angular resolution of the survey is 3.4@xmath16 .
more details of the alfa zoa survey techniques are presented by henning et al .
( 2010 ) . in order to confirm this detection ,
it was followed up with the l - band wide receiver on the arecibo telescope for 180 seconds of integration time using a total power on - off observation .
data were taken with the wapp spectrometer with 4096 channels across a bandwidth of 25 mhz giving a velocity resolution of 1.3 kms@xmath11 and rms = 2.5 mjy .
the spectrum from the follow - up observation can be seen in figure 1 .
the velocity width at 50% peak flux is @xmath17 @xmath9 2 @xmath0 .
the heliocentric velocity measured at the mid - point of the velocity width is @xmath18 @xmath0 .
the integrated flux density is @xmath19 = 0.94 @xmath9 0.07 jy @xmath0 .
errors were calculated as in henning et al .
( 2010 ) following the methods of koribalski et al .
alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 has no cataloged counterparts within @xmath20 ( two arecibo half - power beamwidths ) in the nasa extragalactic database ( ned ) .
follow - up c - configuration evla observations were carried out to obtain high - resolution h imaging of alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 .
the observations were scheduled dynamically for 3 @xmath21 1 hour sessions and observed on december 3rd and 4th , 2010 .
we utilized the widar correlator with 2 mhz bandwidth over 256 spectral channels , resulting in 7.8 khz ( 1.6 @xmath0 ) channel width .
the on - source integration time was two hours .
the source 3c48 was used to calibrate the flux density scale and the source j1925 + 2106 , @xmath22 from the target source , was used to calibrate the complex gains .
the editing , calibration , deconvolution , and processing of the data were carried out in aips .
line free channels were extracted from the spectral - line data cube and averaged to image the continuum in the field of the h source and to refine the phase and amplitude calibration .
the resulting phase and amplitude solutions were applied to the spectral - line data set , and a continuum - free uv data cube was constructed by subtracting the continuum emission .
we then created a total intensity ( stokes i ) h image cube that was cleaned using natural weighting giving a synthesized beamwidth of @xmath23 and an rms noise level of 2.6 mjy beam@xmath11 channel@xmath11 .
moment 0 ( h flux density ) , moment 1 ( velocity field ) , and moment 2 ( velocity dispersion ) maps were produced from the h image cube by smoothing across 3 velocity channels ( 5 @xmath0 ) and 5 pixels spatially ( @xmath24 at @xmath25 per pixel ) and clipping at 2.6 mjy ( the 1@xmath26 level of the unsmoothed cube ) .
these maps can be seen in figure 2 .
the angular extent of the h out to 1 m@xmath6 pc@xmath27 is @xmath28 .
the h flux density shows a main peak and a secondary peak @xmath29 away that overlaps a region of high velocity as well as significant velocity dispersion .
the velocity field shows structure but non - uniform rotation .
the integrated flux from the arecibo and the evla spectra are 0.94 @xmath9 0.07 jy km s@xmath11 and 0.80 @xmath9 0.13 jy km s@xmath11 , respectively .
the evla recovered all integrated flux to within 1@xmath26 .
a comparison of the h profile between arecibo and the evla can be seen in figure 1 .
digitized sky survey ( dss ) images show what looks to be a very faint , uncataloged galaxy that may be the optical counterpart .
the dss magnitudes of this object from supercosmos are m@xmath1 = 17.5 @xmath9 0.3 mag , m@xmath30 = 17.0 @xmath9 0.3 mag .
the extinction in the area is relatively low for the zoa with values estimated to be a@xmath1 = 1.1 and a@xmath30 = 0.7 , from the dirbe/@xmath31 extinction maps ( schlegel , finkbeiner , & davis 1998 ) though these values are somewhat uncertain at such low galactic latitudes . applying extinction corrections gives @xmath32 = 0.1 mag . in order to obtain more accurate photometry , alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 was observed using a bessell @xmath2 band filter on april 12 , 2011 with the 0.9-m sara telescope at kitt peak national observatory using an apogee alta u 42 2048 @xmath21 2048 ccd .
the field of view was 13.8@xmath33 @xmath21 13.8@xmath33 , giving a plate scale of @xmath34 pixel@xmath11 .
the source was low on the horizon with an average airmass of 1.7 and an average seeing of @xmath35 .
nine 5-minute exposures were taken on source for a total exposure time of 45 minutes and calibration was done using the equatorial standard star pg1657 + 078a ( landolt 1992 ) .
the ccd images were bias - subtracted , dark - corrected , flat - fielded and co - added in iraf . the image can be seen in figure 2 .
the apphot package was used for standard star photometry .
the reduced image reached a 1@xmath26 surface brightness level of 25 mag arcsec@xmath27 .
astrometric calibration and aperture photometry of alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 were carried out interactively with the graphical astronomy and image analysis tool ( gaia ) .
flux from the galaxy could be recovered out to a radius of @xmath36 , reaching a surface brightness of 23.5 mag arcsec@xmath27 , after which stellar contamination became significant .
the recovered flux within this radius was m@xmath1 = @xmath37 magnitudes .
optical follow - up observations with the sara telescope are ongoing .
@xmath2 , @xmath38 , and @xmath3 band and h - alpha observations are planned over the coming months .
@xmath2 , @xmath38 , and @xmath3 band observations are being taken to a 1@xmath26 surface brightness of 26.5 mag arcsec@xmath27 .
this should be sufficient to see low surface brightness features that correspond to the faint outer parts of a normal spiral and will allow us to measure the galaxy s diameter at the standard 25 mag arcsec@xmath27 level .
alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 has a heliocentric velocity of @xmath39 = + 279 @xmath0 .
solving for its local group centered velocity using derivations of the solar motion with respect to the local group by courteau @xmath40 van den bergh ( 1999 ) gives @xmath41 = 491 @xmath0 .
using hubble s law with @xmath42 = 70 @xmath43 puts this source at a distance of 7 mpc . however , hubble s law is not a reliable distance indicator here because the dispersion of peculiar velocities in the local universe ( @xmath44 @xmath0 ) is @xmath45 km s@xmath11 ( masters 2008 ) .
the galaxy is probably not closer than 3 mpc as the h linear size at this distance would be smaller than most compact galaxies containing h ( huchtmeier et al .
2007 ) . for the following analysis
, we take the distance to be 7 mpc , although future observations may well revise this number .
as can be seen in the evla and sara images , the h peak is slightly offset ( @xmath46 ) from the optical emission , indicating either a false counterpart or a disturbed h distribution .
the offset is @xmath47300 pc at 7 mpc , which is not uncommon even for isolated galaxies ( c.f .
@xmath47400 pc offset in vv 124 , bellazzini et al .
this could conceivably be a pair of low - surface brightness dwarf galaxies ( c.f .
hizss 3 with separation of @xmath47900 pc , begum et al .
2005 ) , but there is no evidence for a second peak in the high signal - to - noise h spectrum shown in figure 1 .
further , alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 has half the velocity width that the pair in hizss 3 appeared to have ; w@xmath48 = 55 km s@xmath11 for hizss 3 ( henning et al . 2000 ) compared to w@xmath48 = 28 km s@xmath11 here .
any second galaxy would have to be much closer both spatially and in velocity than the pair in hizss 3 in order to escape detection .
deeper interferometric observations would be needed to be entirely conclusive .
it is possible that alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 is a high velocity cloud ( hvc ) co - incident with an optical source ( c.f .
hipass j1328 - 30 , grossi et al .
2007 ) , though this is unlikely as there is strong evidence that alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 is not an hvc .
its recessional velocity does not lie near hvcs in this part of the sky ( c.f .
figure 3a in morras et al .
the nearest population of hvcs is the smith cloud which lies @xmath49 and 170 @xmath0 away ( lockman et al .
2008 ) at its nearest point .
if alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 were an hvc , it would be a remarkable outlier .
furthermore , the velocity field of alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 shows a gradient ten times larger than those of hvcs ( begum et al .
2010 ) .
alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 appears to be a dwarf galaxy judging from its gaussian h profile and low h mass . at a distance of 7 mpc , @xmath50 = @xmath51 m@xmath6 , which is significantly lower than the gaseous content of spiral - type galaxies ( roberts and haynes 1994 )
also , its low luminosity ( @xmath7 = @xmath8 l@xmath6 at 7 mpc ) , h content , and blue colors are strong evidence that it is not an early - type galaxy .
there is no possible counterpart visible in 2mass archive images or listed within 8@xmath33 in the 2mass extended source catalog ( jarrett et al .
we plan follow - up nir observations later this year with the 1.4-m infrared survey facility in sutherland , south africa .
we will use observations by its main instrument , sirius , which has three detectors that operate simultaneously ( @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 ) with a field of view of 7.8 @xmath21 7.8 arcmin .
table 1 summarizes the observational data and derived quantities .
columns 1 and 2 give equatorial coordinates ( j2000 ) for the h peak .
columns 3 and 4 give the galactic coordinates .
column 5 gives the heliocentric velocity from the mid - point of the velocity width at 50% peak flux .
column 6 gives the velocity width at 50% peak flux .
column 7 gives the integrated flux .
column 8 gives the m@xmath4/l@xmath1 ratio using the m@xmath1 calculated from the sara telescope .
the error on l@xmath1 is dominated by the unknown uncertainty in a@xmath1 , thus we do not quote an error on m@xmath4/l@xmath1 .
column 9 gives the angular size of the h out to the 1 m@xmath6 pc@xmath27 level .
the last two columns give values as a function of the distance to the galaxy in mpc .
column 10 gives the linear size of the h at its largest extent .
column 11 gives total h mass . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] compared to other dwarf galaxies ( roberts & haynes 1994 ; oneil et al .
2000 ) , alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 is not particularly gas rich , @xmath55 = 0.3 m@xmath6/l@xmath6 , but it is very small and blue with an h linear size of 1.4 @xmath21 1.3 kpc at 7 mpc and @xmath2 - @xmath3 = 0.1 mag .
the h mass , @xmath56 ratio , blue optical colors , and linear size of alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 are similar to those of blue compact dwarf ( bcd ) galaxies ( huchtmeier et al .
bcds are small , blue , irregular dwarf galaxies which have low surface brightness features , ongoing star formation , and higher metallicities than typical dwarf galaxies .
the velocity field of alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 shows structure , but non - uniform rotation which is common in blue compact dwarf galaxies ( ramya et al .
the velocity dispersion map shown in figure 2 shows a significant amount of dispersion around the stellar looking object on the left side of the galaxy .
this could be an ionized hydrogen region .
h - alpha observations with the sara telescope will examine this and quantify the star formation in this system .
deep @xmath2 , @xmath38 , and @xmath3 band observations with the sara telescope will reveal whether there are low - surface brightness features in alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 . alternatively , there is evidence for the existence of blue , metal - poor , gas - rich dwarf galaxies on the margins of galaxy groups ( grossi et al .
these dwarfs are old ( 2 - 10 gyrs ) but have had remarkably little star formation in their history .
they are thought to be galaxies in transition between dwarf irregular and dwarf spheroidal galaxies .
alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 differs from the grossi et al .
galaxies because it has a lower @xmath56 ratio and appears to be a field galaxy , though it may be a part of a group behind the milky way that has not yet been discovered .
there is a recently discovered local group galaxy , vv124 ( bellazzini et al .
2011 ) , which is similar to alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 in size , h mass , and @xmath55 ratio .
this galaxy is isolated , as alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 appears to be .
there is only one galaxy ( 3.8@xmath57 away ) with @xmath58 @xmath0 within 10@xmath57 of alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 in ned ( though this is not unusual in the zoa ) .
vv124 also shows an offset between the h and the optical counterpart as well as a velocity field with structure but non - uniform rotation .
vv124 is considered to be a precursor of modern dwarf spheroidal galaxies that did not undergo an interaction - driven evolutionary path .
follow - up observations will reveal whether alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 has metallicity and star formation rates similar to a vv124-type galaxy .
it is possible that alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 is a local group galaxy , but it appears unlikely ; alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 does not follow the relationship between radial velocity and angle from the solar apex that most other local group members do , as can be seen in figure 3 ( courteau @xmath40 van den bergh 1999 ) . further , the linear size of the h would be 210 pc at 1 mpc , which is 4 times smaller than the smallest compact dwarfs ( huchtmeier et al .
2007 ) . there are no known galaxy groups within @xmath59 with @xmath60 1000 @xmath0 ( fouqu et al .
1992 ) , making alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 either a field galaxy or a member of an undiscovered nearby group . continued analysis of the alfa zoa data may clarify this .
begum , a. , chengalur , j. n. , karachentsev , i. d. , & sharina , m. e. 2005 , mnras , 359 , 53 henning , p. a. , staveley - smith , l. , ekers , r. d. , green , a. j. , haynes , r. f. , juraszek , s. , kesteven , m. j. , koribalski , b. , kraan - korteweg , r. c. , price , r. m. , sadler , e. m. , & schrder , a. 2000 , aj , 119 , 2686 henning , p. a. , springob , c. m. , minchin , r. f. , momjian , e. , catinella , b. , mcintyre , t. p. , day , f. , muller , e. , koribalski , b. , rosenberg , j. l. , schneider , s. , staveley - smith , l. , & van driel , w. 2010 , aj , 139 , 2130 | the arecibo l - band feed array zone of avoidance ( alfa zoa ) survey has discovered a nearby galaxy , alfa zoa j1952 + 1428 , at a heliocentric velocity of + 279 @xmath0 .
the galaxy was discovered at low galactic latitude by 21-cm emission from neutral hydrogen ( h ) .
we have obtained follow - up observations with the evla and the 0.9-m sara optical telescope .
the h distribution overlaps an uncataloged , potential optical counterpart .
the h linear size is 1.4 kpc at our adopted distance of d = 7 mpc , but the distance estimate is uncertain as hubble s law is unreliable at low recessional velocities .
the optical counterpart has m@xmath1 = 16.9 mag and @xmath2 - @xmath3 = 0.1 mag . these characteristics , including m@xmath4 = 10@xmath5 m@xmath6 and @xmath7 = @xmath8 l@xmath6 , if at 7 mpc , indicate that this galaxy is a blue compact dwarf , but this remains uncertain until further follow - up observations are complete .
optical follow - up observations are ongoing and near infrared follow - up observations have been scheduled . |
itamp is supported in part by a grant from the nsf to the smithsonian institution and harvard university .
vmm and glk were partially supported by faperj ( proceess nos .
e26/170.132 and 170.409/2004 ) and by the russian foundation for basic research ( grant no .
050818119a ) .
harber d m , mcguirk j m , obrecht j m and cornell e a 2003 _ j. low temp .
phys . _ * 133 * 229 leanhardt a e , , shin y , chikkatur a p , kielpinski d , ketterle w and pritchard d e 2003 _ phys .
lett . _ * 90 * 100404 lin y , teper i , chin c and vuleti v 2004 _ phys . rev . lett . _
* 050404 antezza m , pitaevskii l p and stringari s 2004 _ phys .
rev . _ a * 70 * 053619 carusotto i , pitaevskii l p , stringari s , modugno g and inguscio m 2005 _ phys .
lett . _ * 95 * 093202 harber d m , obrecht j m , mcguirk j m and cornell e a 2005 _ phys .
rev . _ a * 72 * 033610 oberst h , tashiro y , shimizu k and shimizu f 2005 _ phys .
rev . _ a * 71 * 052901 vill - prez i , abril i , garcia - molina r and arista n r 2005 _ phys .
rev . _ a * 71 * 052902 antezza m , pitaevskii l p and stringari s 2005 _ phys .
lett . _ * 95 * 113202 lifshitz e
m and pitaevskii l p 1980 _ statistical physics _
ii ( oxford : pergamon press ) babb j f , klimchitskaya g l and mostepanenko v m 2004 _ phys .
rev . _ a * 70 * 042901 caride a o , klimchitskaya g l , mostepanenko v m and zanette s i 2005 _ phys .
a * 71 * 042901 casimir h b g and polder d 1948 _ phys .
* 73 * 360 bostrm m and sernelius b e 2000 _ phys .
a * 61 * 052703 hinds e a , lai k s and schnell m 1997 _ phil .
lond . _ a * 355 * 2353 wu s - t and eberlein c 2000 _ proc .
lond . _ a * 456 * 1931 bordag m , mohideen u and mostepanenko v m 2001 _ phys . rep .
_ * 353 * 1 shih a and parsegian v a 1975 _ phys .
rev . _ a * 12 * 835 , ed .
palik e d 1985 ( new york : academic press ) yan z - c and babb j f 1998 _ phys .
rev . _ a * 58 * 1247 brhl r , fouquet p , grisenti r e , toennies j p , hegerfeldt g c , khler t , stoll m and walter c 2002 _ europhys .
* 59 * 357 mahanty j and ninham b w 1976 _ dispersion forces _ ( new york : academic press ) | the casimir - polder and van der waals interactions between an atom and a flat cavity wall are investigated under the influence of real conditions including the dynamic polarizability of the atom , actual conductivity of the wall material and nonzero temperature of the wall .
the cases of different atoms near metal and dielectric walls are considered .
it is shown that to obtain accurate results for the atom - wall interaction at short separations , one should use the complete tabulated optical data for the complex refractive index of the wall material and the accurate dynamic polarizability of an atom . at relatively large separations in the case of a metal wall ,
one may use the plasma model dielectric function to describe the dielectric properties of wall material .
the obtained results are important for the theoretical interpretation of experiments on quantum reflection and bose - einstein condensation .
[ [ section ] ] recently the study of dispersion interactions between an atom and a wall has assumed a new significance in connection with bose - einstein condensates of ultracold atoms [ 13 ] .
the van der waals and casimir - polder forces acting between dilute individual atoms , confined in a magnetic trap , and a wall may influence the stability of a condensate and the effective size of the trap @xcite . as was shown in ref .
@xcite , the study of the collective oscillations of the bose - einstein condensate can provide a sensitive test of dispersion forces .
this prediction was later supported both theoretically @xcite and experimentally @xcite .
dispersion interaction between an atom and a wall is also taken into account in quantum reflection of cold atoms on a surface @xcite and in dynamical interaction effects of fast atoms and molecules with solid surfaces @xcite .
currently the new asymptotic behavior of the surface - atom interaction out of thermal equilibrium has been advanced @xcite .
below we use the generic name casimir - polder " for all atom - wall interactions of dispersion nature because the pure nonretarded regime occurs at separations from zero to a few nanometers only .
the theoretical basis for the description of the casimir - polder interaction between an atom at a separation @xmath0 from a flat wall at temperature @xmath1 in thermal equilibrium is given by the lifshitz - type formula for the free energy [ 1012 ] @xmath2 \vphantom{\sum\limits_{l=1}^{\infty}}\right\}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath3 is the atomic dynamic polarizability , @xmath4 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath5 are the dimensionless matsubara frequencies , @xmath6 is the characteristic frequency of the casimir - polder interaction , and the reflection coefficients for two independent polarizations of electromagnetic field are defined as @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the permittivity of wall material computed at imaginary matsubara frequencies . for dielectrics @xmath9/[\varepsilon(0)+1]$ ] and for metals
. in most calculations of the atom - wall interaction previously performed only the limiting cases of large and short separations were considered .
the polarizability of the atom was taken into account in the static approximation @xcite or in the framework of the single - oscillator model @xcite , and the dielectric properties of the wall material were oversimplified ( for example , by considering a metal wall to be made of ideal metal ) .
the present experimental situation requires precise ( 1% accuracy ) computations of the casimir - polder interaction in a wide separation range from about 3 nm ( where the lifshitz formula becomes applicable ) to 10@xmath11 m . in this paper
we present the results of such computations clarifying the atomic and material properties which are essential to attain the required accuracy .
we have performed numerical computations of the free - energy ( [ eq1 ] ) , ( [ eq1a ] ) for metastable he@xmath12 , na , and cs atoms in ground state located near metal ( au ) , semiconductor ( si ) and dielectric ( sio@xmath13 ) walls at @xmath14k .
( the modification on account of walls in the spontaneous emission of rydberg atoms , obtained , e.g. , by means of two lasers , is discussed in refs .
. however , thermal quanta at @xmath14k are too small to excite atom from the ground state to some other states . )
three different descriptions for the dielectric properties of a metal were used : _
i _ ) as an ideal metal , _ ii _ ) using the dielectric permittivity from the free - electron plasma model @xmath15 ( where @xmath16 is the plasma frequency ) , and _
iii _ ) with @xmath17 obtained by means of dispersion relation using the tabulated optical data for the complex index of refraction @xcite .
the dielectric permittivity of a semiconductor or dielectric was described either by their static permittivity @xmath18 or by means of their tabulated optical data and the dispersion relation .
the polarizability of an atom was represented by its static value @xmath19 or by means of the highly accurate @xmath20-oscillator model @xcite @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the electron mass and charge , @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the oscillator strength and frequency of the @xmath26th excited - state to ground - state transition , respectively . a more simplified single - oscillator model [ eq . ( [ eq2 ] ) with @xmath27 was also used .
@rccccccc & & + & & + @xmath28 @xmath29(nm)@xmath30 & ( a)&(b)&(c)&(d ) & ( a)&(b)&(c ) + 3@xmath31 & 3.80@xmath32 & 1.16 & 0.956 & 0.937 & 1.61@xmath32 & 1.78 & 0.949 + 10@xmath31 & 9.95@xmath33 & 1.14&0.961&0.948 & 4.18@xmath33 & 1.73 & 0.958 + 20@xmath31 & 1.18@xmath33 & 1.14&0.973&0.959 & 4.94@xmath34 & 1.68 & 0.967 + 50@xmath31 & 6.62@xmath35 & 1.13&0.984&0.976 & 2.71@xmath35 & 1.64 & 0.983 + 100@xmath31 & 6.98@xmath36 & 1.11&0.991&0.981 & 2.76@xmath36 & 1.60 & 0.993 + 150@xmath31 & 1.77@xmath36 & 1.10&0.997&0.992 & 6.93@xmath37 & 1.57 & 0.994 + computations show that at short separations ( from 3 nm to about 150 nm ) it is necessary to use the complete tabulated optical data for the complex index of refraction in order to find the most accurate results . for the dynamic polarizability of an atom , at shortest separations
the highly accurate data for it should be used . with increasing atom - wall distance up to several tens of nanometers
the single - oscillator model becomes applicable .
these calculations are illustrated in table 1 by the example of a metastable he@xmath12 atom near au and sio@xmath38 walls ( the analogous results for na and cs atoms near au , si , and sio@xmath38 walls can be found in refs .
@xcite ) . the tabulated optical data for au and sio@xmath13 were taken from ref .
@xcite , and the values of au plasma frequency and sio@xmath13 static permittivity are @xmath39rad / s and @xmath40 .
the accurate data for the dynamic polarizability of metastable he@xmath12 ( with a relative error of order @xmath41 ) were taken from ref .
@xcite and the parameters of a single - oscillator model from ref .
@xcite were used .
as is seen in table 1 , the use of the ideal metal or the static dielectric permittivity approximations leads to errors up to 16% for metal and 78% for dielectric
. these errors slowly decrease with increasing separation between the atom and the wall .
the plasma model is a better approximation than the ideal metal approximation .
it results in errors of about 5% at the shortest separations and becomes sufficiently exact when the separation approaches 150 nm .
the use of the static atomic polarizability would result in much greater errors and for this reason it is omitted from table 1 . at large separations , from 150 nm to a few micrometers ,
the effects of the atomic dynamic polarizability play a more important role than the effects of the finite conductivity of the metal . the single - oscillator model , however , is sufficient to achieve the required accuracy . the dielectric properties of a metal
can be approximated by the plasma model . for dielectrics and semiconductors both tabulated optical data and the ninham - parsegian representation for the dielectric permittivity @xcite are suitable for obtaining accurate results .
for sufficiently large separations one can use the static dielectric permittivity of the wall .
we illustrate these features using the example of a he@xmath12 atom near an au wall . due to the strongly nonmonotonous dependence of the free energy on separation , we plot along the vertical axis the ratio of the free energy to the casimir - polder energy @xmath42 of an atom near a wall made of ideal metal at @xmath43 . as is seen from fig . 1 , at separations @xmath44
m all approaches lead to approximately equal values of the free energy . to conclude , results such as those presented in the columns labeled ( a ) in table 1 and by line 1 in fig .
1 can be used in interpretation of precision experiments on atom - surface interactions . |
two - dimensional ( 2d ) electron systems have been a fertile source of interesting physics over the past few decades , playing host to the fractional and integer quantum hall effects and cuprate superconductivity among other phenomena .
the most widely studied and most thoroughly understood 2d electron systems are those that occur near semiconductor heterojunctions . in these systems
carrier densities and disorder strengths can be adjusted using modulation doping and the electric field effect , and high sample quality can be achieved using lattice matched materials and epitaxial growth techniques .
these 2d systems are well described by fermi liquid theory , at least at magnetic field @xmath0 .
rapid recent progress in the epitaxial growth of complex transition - metal oxides@xcite foreshadows the birth of an entirely new class of 2d electron systems , one in which electronic correlations are strong even at @xmath0 and non - fermi - liquid behavior is common .
the present authors have recently argued@xcite that the modulation doping technique commonly used in semiconductor heterojunction systems can also be applied to complex - oxide heterojunctions to create high - quality two - dimensional strongly - correlated electron systems ( 2dscess ) localized near the interface between two different mott insulators .
our study was based on a generalized hubbard model which captures some key features of these systems , and on combined insights achieved by applying hartree - fock theory ( hft ) , dynamical mean - field theory ( dmft ) and thomas - fermi theory ( tft ) approaches .
this theoretical strategy echoed that adopted by okamoto and millis@xcite in addressing the two - dimensional electron systems which can occur near the interface between a mott insulator and a band insulator . in both cases
the properties of the 2d electron systems reflect a delicate balance between space - charge electric fields and strong local correlations .
these 2d systems are clearly unusual in many respects .
for instance , their quasiparticles interact with the 3d spin - excitations of the mott insulator barrier materials .
since researchers now appear to be at the cusp of achieving experimental control over this kind of 2d electron system , it is interesting to explore the possibilities theoretically in an attempt to find useful theoretical frameworks , and hopefully also to partially anticipate some of the new phenomena likely to occur .
to mention one example , it has recently been suggested that a spin - liquid insulator could be found in a mott insulators bilayer@xcite system with an appropriate doping profile .
the apparent electronic interface reconstruction ( eir ) discovered@xcite at the heterojunction between the band insulators laalo@xmath1 and srtio@xmath1 is unique in complex oxide interface studies and does not have an analog in semiconductor heterojunction systems , although there is still some uncertainty about the role of oxygen vacancies in the measured conductivity .
for example , it has been proposed @xcite that the oxygen vacancies are responsible for the insulating behavior observed at the @xmath2-type interface .
the reconstruction is forced by the polarity difference between laalo@xmath1 and srtio@xmath1 .
polarity discontinuities are normally weaker at semiconductor heterojunctions and , when present , the electric fields to which they give rise are usually screened by relaxation of atoms near the interface@xcite . in complex transition metal oxides , however , it was discovered@xcite that the polarity discontinuity field can be screened electronically by transferring electrons between surface and interface layers , changing the valence of transition metal ions in these layers .
electrons dodge the _
polar catastrophe_@xcite without essential atomic assistance .
it has been shown@xcite that such an interface can be tuned between metallic and insulating states by relatively modest electric fields , suggesting the possibility of novel electronic devices . in this paper
we examine eir at a heterostructure between model polar and nonpolar mott insulators .
we have in mind for these effects mott insulators with cubic peroskite structures .
possible materials combinations are discussed in section vi .
the long - ranged coulombic space - charge fields are treated within the hartree approximation , and strong on - site coulomb interactions are treated by solving hft , dmft , and tft equations .
we find that a minimum number of polar layers is required to induce an eir because of strong local correlations , whereas the number of nonpolar layers does not play an essential role in determining the electron distribution .
we also find that when a 2d electron system is present near the heterojunction , it is strongly localized because of strong correlations which limit the potential of the electronic system to lower its energy by spreading out in the growth direction .
tft results provide a simple way of understanding the more microscopic dmft and hft calculations and are remarkably accurate .
schematic illustration of our model for a thin film containing a polar - nonpolar mott insulator heterostructure .
the model consists of @xmath3 layers of a polar mott insulator perovskite ( @xmath4 ) and @xmath5 layers of a nonpolar mott insulator perovskite ( @xmath6 ) .
the @xmath7 direction is chosen to be the layer - by - layer growth direction and the charge density is assumed to be uniform in each @xmath8 plane .
the symbol @xmath9 represents a group iii element with nominal valence @xmath10 in the @xmath11 layer while the symbol @xmath12 represents a group ii element with nominal valence @xmath13 in the @xmath14 plane .
the @xmath11 layer therefore has a surface charge density of @xmath15 per @xmath9 atom while the @xmath14 layer is neutral .
the symbols @xmath16 and @xmath17 represent transition metal ions in group iv and v respectively .
both @xmath16 and @xmath17 have @xmath18 configuration before the electronic interface reconstruction ( eir ) . ]
[ fig : one ] illustrates the model heterostructure we investigate in this paper .
we consider a thin film composed of @xmath3 polar perovskite mott insulator layers ( @xmath4 ) and @xmath5 nonpolar perovskite mott insulator layers ( @xmath6 ) , where @xmath9 ( @xmath12 ) is a group iii ( ii ) element with a valence of + 3 ( + 2 ) in the @xmath19 layer .
@xmath16 ( @xmath17 ) is a group @xmath20 ( @xmath21 ) element which is a @xmath18 mott insulator because of strong local repulsion among the d - orbitals . in this study
we disregard the interesting complications associated with orbital degeneracy and do not account directly for hybridization between the transition metal and oxygen ions .
we therefore use a single band hubbard model to describe the @xmath22 valence electrons .
long - ranged coulomb interactions are described realistically by accounting for charges at the oxygen sites and on the @xmath9 , @xmath12 , and @xmath16 , and @xmath17 ions .
the resulting model hamiltonian is : @xmath23 \displaystyle h_d = \sum_{i\sigma } \epsilon_{d}(z_i ) \ ; d^\dagger_{i\sigma } d_{i\sigma } -\sum_{<i , j>\sigma } t_{ij } ( d^\dagger_{i\sigma } d_{j\sigma } + h.c.)\\[3 mm ] \displaystyle h_u=\sum_i \ ;
u(z_i ) \ ; \hat{n}_{i\uparrow}\hat{n}_{i\downarrow}\\[3 mm ] \displaystyle h_{coul}=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{i\neq j,\sigma,\sigma ' } \frac{e^2 \ ; \hat{n}_{i\sigma}\hat{n}_{j\sigma'}}{\epsilon \vert\vec{r}_i -\vec{r}_j\vert}\\[2 mm ] \displaystyle
\,\,\,\,-\sum_{i,\sigma}\sum_{j(j_z\leq n_p)}\frac{z^a e^2 \ ; \hat{n}_{i\sigma } } { \epsilon\vert\vec{r}_i-\vec{r}^a_j\vert } - \sum_{i,\sigma}\sum_{j(j_z >
n_p)}\,\frac{e^2 \ ; \hat{n}_{i\sigma } } { \epsilon\vert\vec{r}_i-\vec{r}_j\vert } \end{array } \label{eq : hamiltonian}\ ] ] where @xmath24 labels a metal site and ( grouping coplanar oxygen and a cation charges ) @xmath25 in the present case . the d - orbital hopping term is expressed in eq.([eq : hamiltonian ] ) as a sum over links ; most of our calculations have been performed for a model with nearest - neighbor hopping .
second nearest - neighbor hopping has little influence on our main results , but will impact the 2dsces fermi surfaces as discussed below .
the sizes and alignments of the gaps in the two @xmath26 mott insulators are fixed by the interaction and site energy parameters : @xmath27 and @xmath28 for the polar layers and @xmath29 and @xmath30 for the nonpolar layers . in an ideal cubic perovskite unit cell with lattice constant @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 respectively . the third term in @xmath34 accounts for a net effective charge per @xmath17 atom in the @xmath35 plane ; this charge is the sum of the oxygen ion charges and the @xmath36 charge of the @xmath17 ion when in a @xmath37 configuration . in this work
we have neglected the uneven distribution of charge within each layer . in this calculation
we for the most part assume that @xmath38 is constant , but emphasize that the difference between d - orbital energies on opposite sides of the heterojunction can be an important parameter . as in case of semiconductors ,
band lineups play a key role in determining heterojunction properties and are likely to be difficult to estimate with sufficient precision .
accurate values will most likely have to be determined experimentally for each heterojunction system considered .
the requirement of overall electrical neutrality in the thin film implies that the d orbital occupancy , averaged over the thin film @xmath39 , satisfies @xmath40 . throughout this study
we use the hartree approximation for the long - ranged coulomb interaction and neglect the corresponding exchange term , since our goals in studying this toy model are purely qualitative .
the self - consistently determined hartree mean - field hamiltonian is @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the electron density on site @xmath43 , @xmath44 for @xmath45 , and @xmath46 for @xmath47 . in the continuum limit
, @xmath48 becomes : @xmath49\hat{n}_{i\sigma}\ ] ] where @xmath50 .
in hft the hubbard @xmath51 term is replaced by its mean - field counterpart : @xmath52 . as pointed out @xcite previously , there are almost always a number of distinct self - consistent solutions of the hf equations , corresponding to various local - minima and saddle - points of the hf energy functional . here
we present results for solutions with @xmath53-type antiferromagnetic ( afm ) order , or @xmath54 spin order , and ferromagnetic ( fm ) order .
these solutions are representative of ordered states which occur frequently in complex transition metal oxides and are often global minima of the hf energy functional .
the philosophy of following this procedure is that hft can neither reliably judge the competition between different types of order , nor predict whether or not long - range order succumbs to fluctuations .
the results nevertheless very often provides a reasonable description of local correlations in the strongly correlated regime .
electron charge distributions for afm and fm hartree - fock states with @xmath55 , @xmath56 , and @xmath38 constant for ( a ) @xmath57 and ( b ) @xmath58 cases .
the total number of layers is @xmath59 .
eir occurs only in the model thin film with the larger number of polar layers .
confinement of the 2dsces is stronger in the afm state solution because of its stronger local correlations . ]
our hft results for @xmath57 and @xmath58 are summarized in fig .
[ fig : two ] . for the calculations reported here
, the total layer number @xmath59 and typical values were chosen for the interaction parameters .
( @xmath55 and @xmath56.)@xcite for both afm and fm states eir occurs only for the model thin film with the larger value of @xmath3 .
this feature is a result of the competition between the polar catastrophe@xcite and strong local correlations .
although the polarity discontinuity at the interface favors a transfer of electrons from the outmost surface to the interface , this charge rearrangement is opposed by the mott - hubbard gap .
it is instructive to consider space - charge induced band bending diagrams like the cartoon illustration of fig .
[ fig : three ] which contrasts the @xmath57 and @xmath58 cases . for @xmath57 , the bending of the upper and lower hubbard bands is not large enough to force the chemical potential @xmath60 at the heterojunction outside the gap region .
when more polar layers are grown , @xmath60 eventually crosses the lower hubbard band of the outermost polar layer and the upper hubbard band of the nonpolar layer nearest the interface , forcing the occurrence of an eir .
if the top layer of the polar material was a positively charged @xmath11 layer rather than a negatively charged @xmath61 layer , the charge transfer would occur from the lower hubbard band near the heterojunction to the upper hubbard band near the surface .
( color online ) cartoon illustration of band bending for ( a ) @xmath57 ( b ) @xmath58 .
the support of the upper hubbard band s spectral weight is indicated by yellow shading while the support of the lower hubbard band s spectral weight is indicated by solid red .
these illustrations reflect the spectral weight only at the @xmath16 and @xmath17 transition metal sites of @xmath62 layers with the end point on the polar side of the interface at the last @xmath61 layer and the starting point on the nonpolar side of the interface at the first @xmath35 layer .
since the last @xmath61 and the first @xmath35 layers are separated by a @xmath11 layer , the electrostatic potential reaches its minimum at the first @xmath35 layer .
( the electrostatic potential is of course continuous along the growth direction , as required by the poisson equation . )
( a ) @xmath60 lies in the gap region and no eir occurs .
( b ) @xmath60 crosses the lower hubbard band on the polar side and upper hubbard band on the nonpolar side , indicating the appearance of eir .
if the top layer of the polar material was a positively charged @xmath11 layer rather than a negatively charged @xmath61 layer , the charge transfer would occur from the lower hubbard band near the heterojunction to the upper hubbard band near the surface . ]
an analogous competition has already been discussed and studied experimentally in laalo@xmath1/srtio@xmath1 heterostructures @xcite . in that case
the energy which competes with the polar catastrophe is the energy difference between the top of oxygen @xmath2-bands in nonpolar srtio@xmath1 and the bottom of aluminum @xmath22 bands in laalo@xmath1 , instead of the correlation gap in the example studied here . since it always costs the gap energy to add more electrons on any layer of the heterostructure , electrons accumulate initially near the interface to gain the most electrostatic energy , eventually spreading out through the heterostructure to minimize kinetic energy cost .
quantum confinement of the 2dsces associated with eir is stronger for states with stronger on - site correlations because the kinetic energy is then a smaller component of the overall energy budget .
this is the reason that in fig .
[ fig : two](b ) electrons are more confined to the interface in the afm state than in the fm state . ( the fm state has larger bandwidths and smaller correlation gaps , at least within hft . )
based on the discussion above , we expect that for fixed @xmath63 and @xmath64 , the minimum number of polar layers required to achieve reconstruction @xmath65 will be smaller when @xmath66 is larger .
@xmath65 will also tend to decrease when the hubbard gap is reduced in either layer ; in fig .
[ fig : four ] we illustrate the dependence on @xmath64 when @xmath63 is fixed .
note that a smaller value of @xmath64 favors ferromagnetic hf states .
ground - state phase diagram ( a ) _ vs. _ @xmath3 and @xmath67 for @xmath68 and ( b ) _ vs. _ @xmath3 and @xmath64 for @xmath69 and @xmath56 .
the total number of layers is fixed at @xmath59 .
( a ) for fixed @xmath63 and @xmath64 , eir occurs for a smaller number of polar layers if @xmath66 is larger .
note that the fm states always have higher ground - state energy than afm states in these parameter regions .
( b ) for fixed @xmath63 and @xmath66 , eir requires more number of polar layers when @xmath64 is larger .
as indicated here , a smaller @xmath64 also favors fm states over afm states in hartree - fock theory . for both ( a ) and ( b ) the phase boundary for the occurrence of eir is accurately reproduced by the thomas - fermi approximation , eq.[nmp ] . ]
( color online ) electronic structure of the @xmath58 afm state whose charge distribution was illustrated in fig.[fig : two](b ) .
this plot was calculated with a non - zero second nearest - neighbor hopping parameter @xmath70 .
energies are measured from the chemical potential of the thin film .
( a ) all 20 2d bands along high symmetry lines of the afm brillouin zone .
( b ) crossing between the polar material surface layer lower hubbard band and the five non - polar material upper hubbard band layers .
the space charge physics implies that these six bands will be close to the chemical potential .
note that only two bands are partially occupied .
( c ) dependence of the total band occupancy on position in the brillouin - zone on a color scale with occupancy 18 in red , 20 in green , and 22 and in blue . ] a more microscopic view of eir is provided in fig.[fig : five ] where we illustrate the electronic structure of the afm solution of the hartree - fock equations for a thin film with @xmath58 .
the parameters used to construct this illustration are the same as those used for the @xmath58 case in fig.[fig : two](b ) .
the @xmath59 thin film has 20 two - fold spin - degenerate 2d bands because of the reduced translational symmetry of the afm state , and charge neutrality requires that 10 bands be occupied . in fig .
[ fig : five](a ) we can identify 10 relatively widely spaced bands which correspond at high energies to the upper hubbard band and at low energies to the lower hubbard band in the polar material .
the bands are widely spaced because of the average electric field in the polar material ; for the same reason these bands are quite highly localized in individual atomic layers .
the two groups of more narrowly spaced bands correspond respectively to the upper hubbard band and the lower hubbard band of the non - polar material . because the space - charge electric fields are much either almost fully or at least partially screened out in the non - polar material by charge accumulation at the interface , the bands are closely spaced and the corresponding eigenstates contain more inter - layer characters . when eir occurs there is a weakly avoided anticrossing between the top - most lower hubbard band state in the polar material and the upper hubbard band states of the non - polar material .
this anticrossing is apparent in fig.[fig : five](b ) which expands the region of the electronic structure close to the fermi energy . in the ground state
the polar lower - hubbard band state is lower in energy at the brillouin - zone center but higher in energy toward the brillouin - zone edges .
( for a model with only nearest - neighbor hopping the lower upper band has its maximum and the upper hubbard band has its minimum along the line from @xmath71 to @xmath72 . ) for the parameters used in this calculation ( with second nearest - neighbor hopping @xmath70 ) the eir leads to two partially occupied 2d bands illustrated in fig .
[ fig : five](c ) , a nearly full lower - hubbard band very localized on the surface and with two inequivalent hole pockets in the afm brillouin zone centered on @xmath73 and @xmath74 and a nearly empty band concentrated on the first non - polar layer with an electron pocket centered on @xmath71 .
layered oxide materials have a natural thomas - fermi approximation in which the total energy is expressed as the sum of the total electrostatic energy and a local - density - approximation for the band and correlation energies . for layered structures
the contribution to the energy from each atomic layer is approximated by the energy per layer of an electrically neutral 3d system with the average site occupancy of that layer . minimizing this energy with a fixed total density constraint leads to the following tf equation : @xmath75 where @xmath76 for this case is .
@xmath77 and @xmath78 is the overall chemical potential .
following the same approach described in ref@xcite , we can solve the tf equations for different ordered states using @xmath79 calculated from hf solutions for the three - dimensional hubbard model .
we confirmed that tft very accurately reproduces the results of hft for the charge distribution between the layers , as in the case of modulation doping@xcite .
one advantage of using this tf equation is that we can derive some key properties analytically .
for example , if we assume that the d - orbitals of polar and non - polar sides are both described by one - band hubbard models and that the charge transfer occurs from a single surface layer to a single interface layer eq.([eq : tf ] ) reduces to @xmath80 where the hubbard model chemical potentials are expressed as function of density in units of electrons per atom , @xmath81 is the charge transfer , and the on - site energies which are usually set to zero in hubbard models , restored on each side of the heterojunction .
since the left hand side is a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath81 and the right hand side is a monotonically increasing function of @xmath81 , this equation has a solution and eir will occur if @xmath82 - [ \epsilon_{d1 } + \mu_p(1- ) ] = e_{ig } \label{nmp}\ ] ] i.e. if the electric potential drop across the polar layer exceeds the spatially indirect gap @xmath83 between the bottom of the upper hubbard band in the non - polar material and the top of the lower hubbard band in the polar material .
since the variation of chemical potential with density is strongly reduced outside of the gap in strongly correlated material , it follows that the amount of charge transfered once @xmath84 exceeds the minimum value is given accurately by @xmath85 as the right hand side of eq .
[ eq : deltan ] becomes comparable to 0.5 at larger values of @xmath86 , the fundamental assumption of our simple model ( namely that the polar catastrophe is avoided by electronic rather than atomic reconstruction ) becomes increasingly suspect .
when eir occurs it is likely to lead to relatively small 2d fermi surface pockets , as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : five ] .
electron distribution calculated by hft and dmft for pm state with ( a ) @xmath57 and ( b ) @xmath58 .
other parameters are the same as those used in fig [ fig : two ] .
the comparison between hft and dmft for pm state demonstrates the role of on - site correlation in the eir .
the solutions of dmft show that eir only occurs with more polar layers and the confinement is stronger compared to hf solutions . ]
hartree - fock theory can describe the physics of strong local correlations only when the correlations are static and lead to fm or afm ordered states ; hf solutions for pm states completely miss local correlation and do not reproduce the mott - hubbard gap .
dmft captures correctly the insulating gap created by on - site correlations even for inhomogeneous multilayered systems@xcite . for this reason
dmft calculations for paramagnetic states ( pm ) provide important additional insight into eir in mott - hubbard insulator heterojunction systems . for the impurity
solver necessary in applications of dmft , we adopt the simple two - site method proposed by m. potthoff@xcite , which has been successfully applied to a variety of different transition metal oxide heterostructures@xcite .
the results for @xmath57 and @xmath58 are presented in fig .
[ fig : six ] with @xmath55 and @xmath56 .
when a paramagnetic state is described by hft , charge transfer from the surface to the interface occurs ( incorrectly ) even for @xmath57 . for @xmath58 ,
the screening of the surface layer electric field incorrectly begins immediately in the polar material .
the dmft calculations demonstrate that a larger value of @xmath3 is required even if the spin - degree of freedom is not ordered in the mott insulators .
these results confirm that a minimum thickness of polar layers is required for eir when on - site correlations are strong .
it is not so easy to determine on purely theoretical grounds which material combinations could be used to realize the eir proposed here . in the family of cubic perovskites ,
candidate @xmath87 polar materials include latio@xmath1 and ytio@xmath1 and possible @xmath87 non - polar materials include srvo@xmath1 include cavo@xmath1 .
the band offsets of the various possible materials combinations @xmath88 can be estimated from existing electronic structure calculations .
lda calculations based on wannier functions@xcite indicate that the @xmath89 bands tend to be higher in energy relative to the oxygen @xmath2 levels in latio@xmath1 and ytio@xmath1 than in cavo@xmath1 and srvo@xmath1 . assumming that the oxygen @xmath2 levels are closely aligned across the heterostructure
, we can expect that latio@xmath1 and ytio@xmath1 will have higher @xmath22 orbital energies than cavo@xmath1 and srvo@xmath1 .
another interesting observation from the lda calculations is that energy differences between different @xmath89 orbital associated with distortions of the ideal cubic perovskite structure tend to increase across the series srvo@xmath1-cavo@xmath1-latio@xmath1-ytio@xmath1 .
these additional features related to the @xmath89 orbital degree of freedom may bring in new physics which can not be explored in our single - band thin film model .
moreover , the tendency toward magnetic ordering may also be influenced by the presence or absence of @xmath89 orbital degeneracy , which will in turn be influenced by reduced symmetry near the heterojunction .
the same calculations show that cavo@xmath1 and srvo@xmath1 are metallic in the bulk . lower coordination and electric fields that reduce inter - layer hopping are likely to tip the balance toward the insulating state in thin films and especially near heterojunctions , so these materials are still candidates for realization of the physics studied here .
although sophisticated first principle calculations can provide some insight and will help with the construction of realistic phenomenological models , the consequences of orbital degeneracy or near - degeneracy for complex oxide heterojunctions may depend on subtle issues of many - particle physics .
another aspect not captured realistically in this qualitative study is the dielectric constant which in general could be a very complicated function of positions throughout the heterostructures@xcite .
experimental information when available will likely play an essential role in achieving a full understanding .
one of the most important effect of the band lineups in our model is its influence on where the electrons accumulate when eir occurs .
we have shown that in the case of constant @xmath90 electron accumulation near the heterojunction appears on the first @xmath35 layer .
this will change if @xmath90 for the polar materials is low enough so that the sum of @xmath90 and electrostatic potential is minimized at the last @xmath61 layer , instead of the first @xmath35 layer .
in this paper we have studied electronic interface reconstruction ( eir ) in polar - nonpolar mott insulator heterostructure systems .
we use a simple one - band hubbard model supplemented with long - range coulomb interactions which assumes that the polar catastrophe in layered polar materials is avoided by electronic rather than lattice reconstruction .
we find that eir occurs only if a thin film contains a minimum number of polar layers @xmath65 ; when model paramaters representative of perovskite oxides are chosen @xmath91 . in this paper ,
the electronic structure of polar - non - polar mott insulator heterojunctions was investigated using hartree - fock theory ( hft ) , thomas - fermi theory ( tft ) , and dynamical mean - field - theory ( dmft ) .
using tft we are able to derive an analytical expression for the dependence of eir on model parameters , which may be useful in selecting suitable materials . for polar and non - polar hubbard interaction parameters ( @xmath63 and @xmath64 respectively ) a stronger coulomb interaction parameter @xmath66 will reduce @xmath65 , while for @xmath63 and @xmath66 fixed , larger @xmath64 will increase @xmath65 .
strong on - site correlations enhance quantum confinement of the interface states which accompany eir , resulting in 2d systems that are nearly completely confined to an atomic plane .
when the mott insulator barrier materials have antiferromagnetic order , hartree - fock calculations demonstrate the emergence to 2d electron systems with fermi surface areas and characters that depend sensitively on the details of the model .
the quasiparticles of this system will differ from ordinary 2d electron systems because they will interact strongly with the 3d spin excitations of the antiferromagnetic mott insulators .
the unusual properties suggest the likelihood of interesting non - fermi liquid states in some regions of the model s parameter space . we have also discussed some possible material combinations which might lead to the eir we envision and the key role of the alignment of d - orbital energies across the heterojunction
. some realistic features of perovskites , for example , orbital degeneracy and lattice distortions , are not captured by the simplified model used in this work .
we note that the exchange term from the long - ranged coulomb interaction , which we have neglected in this study , should enhance the correlation gap . as a result
, the charge distribution may be somewhat different if this term is also treated self - consistently .
these features of realistic systems are likely to play an important role in practice , especially so when the charge transfer from the surface to the interface region is large enough to sensibly alter the chemical bonding as discussed previously for the mott - insulator / band - insulator heterojunction case@xcite . in our view
, it will likely never be practical to attempt a complete and accurate description of complex oxide interfaces of any type from first principles .
insights from _ ab inito _ theory , simplified tight - binding models , and most critically from experiment are all likely to play a role in achieving robust , predictive , phenomenological models of these systems .
this work is intented as a step toward establish the correct form of useful phenomenologies .
this work was supported by the national science foundation under grant dmr-0606489 and by the welch foundation .
the authors acknowledge helpful interactions with harold hwang , george sawatzky , and charles ahn .
99 a. ohtomo , d.a .
muller , j.l .
grazul , and h.y .
hwang , nature * 419 * , 378 ( 2002 ) . c. h. ahn , j .-
triscone , and j. mannhart , nature * 424 * , 1015 ( 2003 ) .
j. chakhalian , j.w .
freeland , g. srajer , j. strempfer , g. khaliullin , j.c .
cezar , t. charlton , r. dalgliesh , c. bernhard , g. cristiani , h - u .
habermeier and b. keimer , nature physics * 2 * , 244 ( 2006 ) .
l. fitting , y. hotta , t. susaki , h. y. hwang , and d. a. muller , phys .
* 97 * , 256803 ( 2006 ) .
y. hotta , y. mukunoki , t. susaki , h. y. hwang , l. fitting , and d. a. muller , appl .
. lett . * 89 * , 031918 ( 2006 ) .
a. ohtomo and h.y .
hwang , nature ( london ) * 427 * , 423 ( 2004 ) .
n. nakagawa , h. y. hwang , and d. a. muller nature materials * 5 * , 204 ( 2006 ) .
s. thiel , g. hammerl , a. schmehl , c.w .
schneider , and j. mannhart , science * 313 * , 1942 ( 2006 ) .
c . lee and a.h .
macdonald , phys .
b * 74 * , 075106 ( 2006 ) .
s. okamoto and a.j .
millis , nature ( london ) * 428 * , 630 ( 2004 ) ; s. okamoto and a.j .
millis , phys .
b * 70 * , 241104 ( r ) ( 2004 ) ; s. okamoto and a.j .
millis , _ ibid . _ * 70 * , 075101 ( 2004 ) .
t. c. ribeiro , a. seidel , j. h. han and d .- h .
lee , europhys . lett . * 76 * , 891 ( 2006 ) .
r. pentcheva and w.e .
pickett , phys .
b * 74 * , 035112 ( 2006 ) ; min sik park , s.h . rhim , and arthur j. freeman , phys .
b * 74 * 205416 ( 2006 )
. s. m. sze , _ high speed semiconductor devices _ wiley , new york , ( 1990 ) .
r. hesper , l. h. tjeng , a. heeres , and g. a. sawatzky , phys .
b * 62 * , 16046 ( 2000 )
freericks , phys .
b.*70 * , 195342 ( 2004 ) ; j.k .
freericks , v. zlatic , and a.m. shvaika , _ ibid _ * 75 * , 035133 ( 2007 ) .
m. potthoff , phys .
b * 64 * , 165114 ( 2001 ) .
e. pavarini , a. yamasaki , j. nuss , and o.k .
andersen , new j. of phys .
* 7 * , 188 ( 2005 ) .
s. altieri , l.h .
tjeng , f.c .
voogt , t. hibma and g.a .
sawatzky , phys .
b * 59 * r2517 ( 1999 ) . ; j. van den brink and g.a .
sawatzky , europhys . lett . * 50 * 447 ( 2000 ) .
d. r. hamann , d. a. muller , and h. y. hwang phys .
b * 73 * , 195403 ( 2006 ) ; s. okamoto , a. j. millis , and n. a. spaldin phys . rev
. lett . * 97 * , 056802 ( 2006 ) | we report on a theoretical study of the electronic interface reconstruction ( eir ) induced by polarity discontinuity at a heterojunction between a polar and a nonpolar mott insulators , and of the two - dimensional strongly - correlated electron systems ( 2dscess ) which accompany the reconstruction .
we derive an expression for the minimum number of polar layers required to drive the eir , and discuss key parameters of the heterojunction system which control 2dsces properties .
the role of strong correlations in enhancing confinement at the interface is emphasized . |
regular arrays of ultracold neutral atoms @xcite are a versatile tool for the quantum simulation @xcite of many - body physics @xcite .
recent experimental progress allows one to control and observe atoms with single - site resolution @xcite which makes dynamical phenomena experimentally accessible in these systems .
one promising perspective is to use this setup for investigating the rich physics of quantum magnetism @xcite and strongly correlated spin systems that are extremely challenging to simulate on a classical computer .
however , the simulation of magnetic phenomena with cold atoms faces two key challenges .
first , neutral atoms do not experience a lorentz force in an external magnetic field . in order to circumvent this problem ,
tremendous effort has been made to create artificial gauge fields for neutral atoms @xcite .
for example , artificial magnetic fields allow one to investigate the integer @xcite and fractional quantum hall effects @xcite with cold atoms , and the experimental realization of the topological haldane model was achieved in @xcite .
second , cold atoms typically interact via weak contact interactions .
spin systems with strong and long - range interactions can be achieved by admixing van der waals interactions between rydberg states @xcite or by replacing atoms with dipole - dipole interacting polar molecules @xcite . in particular
, it has been shown that the dipole - dipole interaction can give rise to topological flat bands @xcite and fractional chern insulators @xcite .
the creation of bands with chern number @xmath3 via resonant exchange interactions between polar molecules has been explored in @xcite .
recently an alternative and very promising platform for the simulation of strongly correlated spin systems has emerged @xcite . here resonant dipole - dipole interactions between rydberg atoms @xcite enable quantum simulations of spin systems at completely different length scales compared with polar molecules .
for example , the experiment in @xcite demonstrated the realisation of the @xmath4 hamiltonian for a chain of atoms and with a lattice spacing of the order of @xmath5 . at these length scales ,
light modulators allow one to trap atoms in arbitrary , two - dimensional geometries and to apply custom - tailored light shifts at individual sites @xcite .
the resonant dipole - dipole interaction is also ideally suited for the investigation of transport phenomena @xcite and can give rise to artificial magnetic fields acting on the relative motion of two rydberg atoms @xcite . here
we show how to engineer artificial magnetic fields for spin excitations in two - dimensional arrays of dipole - dipole interacting rydberg atoms .
more specifically , we consider a triangular lattice of rydberg atoms as shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] where the resonant dipole - dipole interaction enables the coherent exchange of exitations between atoms in @xmath0 and @xmath1 states .
we derive an effective spin-1/2 hamiltonian for the @xmath0 excitations with complex hopping amplitudes giving rise to artificial , staggered magnetic fields .
this results in non - zero chern numbers of the single - particle band structure , and the value of the chern number in the lowest band can be adjusted to @xmath2 or @xmath3 by changing the lattice parameters
. note that in our system all atoms comprising the lattice are excited to a rydberg state .
this is in contrast to the work in @xcite , where the atoms mostly reside in their ground states and the population in the rydberg manifold is small .
consequently , our approach is in general more vulnerable towards losses through spontaneous emission . on the other hand ,
the magnitude of the resonant dipole - dipole interaction is much stronger compared with a small admixing of van der waals interactions , and hence the coherent dynamics takes place on much shorter time scales .
in addition , the distance between the atoms can be much larger in our approach which facilitates the preparation and observation of the excitations .
this paper is organised as follows .
we give a detailed description of our system in sec .
[ model ] where we engineer an effective hamiltonian for the @xmath0 excitations .
we then investigate the single - particle band structure and provide a systematic investigation of the topological features of these bands as a function of the system parameters in sec .
[ results ] .
a brief summary of our work is presented in sec .
[ summary ] .
( color online ) triangular lattice of rydberg atoms in the @xmath6 plane .
the lattice is comprised of two rectangular sub - lattices @xmath7 and @xmath8 that are shifted by @xmath9 with respect to each other , where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the primitive basis vectors of each sub - lattice .
the sites of the @xmath8 ( @xmath7 ) lattice are indicated by blue squares ( red dots ) .
the unit cell of the whole lattice is shown by the shaded area and contains two lattice sites .
@xmath12 is the flux through the upward pointing triangle @xmath13 , and @xmath14 is the flux through the downward pointing triangle @xmath15 .
, width=302 ] we consider a two - dimensional triangular lattice of rydberg atoms in the @xmath6 plane as shown in fig .
each lattice site contains a single rydberg atom which we assume to be pinned to the site .
the triangular lattice is comprised of two rectangular sub - lattices @xmath8 and @xmath7 that are labeled by blue squares and red dots in fig .
[ fig1 ] respectively .
each sub - lattice is described by two orthogonal primitive basis vectors @xmath10 and @xmath11 , and the two sub - lattices are shifted by @xmath9 with respect to each other . in the following , we derive an effective spin-1/2 model for rydberg excitations in the @xmath0 manifold over a background of @xmath1 states with principal quantum number @xmath16 . after introducing the general hamiltonian of the system , we first engineer an effective hamiltonian for @xmath0 excitations on the @xmath8 sub - lattice .
we then apply the same procedure to the @xmath7 sub - lattice but choose a different @xmath0 state compared to the @xmath8 atoms .
finally , we show that the dipole - dipole interaction couples the two sub - lattices and the corresponding hamiltonian contains complex hopping amplitudes giving rise to artificial magnetic fields .
the atomic level scheme of each atom is comprised of two angular momentum manifolds @xmath17 and @xmath18 with principal quantum number @xmath16 as shown in fig .
the zeeman sublevels of each multiplet are denoted by @xmath19 , where @xmath20 labels the orbital angular momentum , @xmath21 is the total angular momentum and the projection of the electron s angular momentum onto the @xmath22-axis is denoted by @xmath23 .
the hamiltonian of a single atom at site @xmath24 is given by @xmath25 + \hat{l}_{\alpha}[s_{1/2 } ] \ , , \label{h0 } \ ] ] where the first line is the hamiltonian for the degenerate @xmath18 manifold in the absence of external fields , @xmath26 is the energy of the @xmath18 multiplet and we set the frequency of the @xmath17 multiplet @xmath27 . in the second line of eq .
( [ h0 ] ) , @xmath28 $ ] are level shift operators removing the zeeman degeneracy of the multiplet @xmath29 at site @xmath24 . in the following
we assume that all atoms in rows labeled by @xmath8 and indicated by a blue square in fig .
[ fig1 ] experience the same level shifts .
similarly , all atoms in rows labeled by @xmath7 and indicated by a red dot in fig .
[ fig1 ] have equivalent level schemes .
however , atoms in sites @xmath30 have a different internal level structure compared with atoms in sites @xmath31 .
the full hamiltonian for the system shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] is then given by @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the dipole - dipole interaction @xcite between atoms at sites @xmath24 and @xmath34 , @xmath35 \ , .
\label{vdd } \ ] ] here @xmath36 is the dielectric constant , @xmath37 is the electric dipole - moment operator of atom @xmath24 , @xmath38 is the relative position of the two atoms located at @xmath39 and @xmath40 , respectively , and @xmath41 is the corresponding unit vector . in the following we consider only near - resonantly coupled states and
neglect all matrix elements between two - atom states differing in energy by @xmath42 or more .
this is justified if the dipole - dipole coupling strength @xmath43 is much smaller than the fine structure interval @xmath44 , which is the case for the typical parameters based on rubidium atoms ( see sec .
[ results ] ) .
next we we focus on the @xmath8 lattice and reduce the level scheme at each site to a two - level system by a suitable choice of the shift operators in eq .
( [ h0 ] ) . to this end ,
we assume that the level shifts break the degeneracy of the zeeman sublevels as shown in fig .
[ fig2](a ) such that all dipole transitions can be addressed individually .
in particular , we require that the strength of the dipole - dipole coupling between nearest neighbours is much smaller than the splitting between zeeman sublevels . for all @xmath8 atoms ,
we choose the states @xmath45 and @xmath46 as the effective spin-1/2 system .
the dipole matrix element of the @xmath47 transition with transition frequency @xmath48 is ( see appendix [ appendixa ] ) @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the reduced dipole matrix element of the @xmath51 transition .
( color online ) the level scheme of each atom consists of the @xmath17 and @xmath18 manifolds .
dashed lines denote allowed dipole transitions .
( a ) the effective spin-1/2 system at sites @xmath8 is formed by states @xmath45 and @xmath46 . the corresponding dipole transition with transition frequency @xmath48
is indicated in blue .
( b ) the effective spin-1/2 system at sites @xmath7 is formed by states @xmath52 and @xmath46 . the associated dipole transition with transition frequency @xmath53
is indicated in red .
, width=283 ] in an interaction picture with respect to the bare atomic energies , the hamiltonian @xmath54 in eq .
( [ fullham ] ) restricted to all @xmath8 atoms can thus be written as @xmath55 where @xmath56 describes the coupling strength between two @xmath8 atoms located at @xmath39 and @xmath40 , respectively . in the following
it will be useful to characterise the strength of the dipole - dipole interaction between two atoms separated by @xmath57 , and hence we introduce the parameter @xmath58 the raising operator for a spin excitation in eq .
( [ hb ] ) is defined as @xmath59 and its adjoint is the corresponding lowering operator , @xmath60^{\dagger}$ ] .
next we follow a similar procedure within the @xmath7 lattice .
in contrast to @xmath8 atoms , we choose the states @xmath52 and @xmath46 as an effective spin-1/2 system as shown in fig .
[ fig2](b ) .
we assume that all other transitions within @xmath7 atoms are so far - detuned that the dipole - dipole interaction remains restricted to this subsystem .
we find that the dipole matrix element of the corresponding transition @xmath61 is ( see appendix [ appendixa ] ) @xmath62 the raising operator of this transition with resonance frequency @xmath53 is defined as @xmath63 and @xmath60^{\dagger}$ ] is the lowering operator . in a rotating frame where @xmath64 oscillates with the frequency @xmath48 of excitations in the @xmath8 lattice , the hamiltonian for excitations in the @xmath7 lattice can be written as @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the detuning between excitations in the @xmath7 and @xmath8 lattices and @xmath67 is defined in eq .
( [ coupling ] ) . for our given geometry and chosen transitions , we find that the dipole - dipole coupling between the two sub - lattices is different from zero .
if the detuning @xmath68 between @xmath8 and @xmath7 excitations is smaller than the strength of the dipole - dipole coupling between the two sub - lattices , the @xmath0 excitations can hop between the @xmath8 and @xmath7 sites . with the expressions for the dipole matrix elements in eqs .
( [ db ] ) and ( [ dr ] ) , the hamiltonian governing the coupling between the two sub - lattices is given by @xmath69 where @xmath70 note that the phase @xmath71 of excitation hopping between sites @xmath30 and @xmath72 is determined by the azimuthal angle of the relative position vector @xmath73 between the two sites .
in summary , by restricting the effective level scheme on each site to a two - level system we obtain @xmath74 where the definition of the spin operators @xmath75 depends on the lattice site as described by eqs .
( [ sb ] ) and ( [ sr ] ) .
the operators @xmath75 obey fermi anticommutation relations on the same site , @xmath76 and bose commutation relations between different sites , @xmath77= \left[s_{\alpha}^{+},s_{\beta}^{+}\right]= \left[s_{\alpha}^{-},s_{\beta}^{-}\right ] = 0\,,\quad \alpha\not=\beta\ , .
\label{bcom } \ ] ] it follows that the raising operator @xmath64 creates an excitation in the @xmath0 manifold that behaves like a hard - core bose particle .
an example for the dipole - dipole coupling strengths in rubidium atoms and the magnitude of the level shifts required for realising the effective hamiltonian in eq .
( [ effham ] ) is provided in appendix [ appendixb ] . here
we outline two physical implementations of the level shifts @xmath28 $ ] in eq .
( [ h0 ] ) .
first , we consider linear zeeman shifts induced by an external magnetic field @xmath78 in @xmath22 direction , @xmath79 = \frac{g[l_j]}{\hbar } \mu_b b_{\alpha } \hat{j}_z[l_j]\ , , \ ] ] where @xmath80 is the bohr magneton , @xmath81 $ ] is the @xmath22 component of the angular momentum operator restricted to the multiplet @xmath29 , and @xmath82 $ ] is the land g - factor , @xmath83 = \frac{3}{2 } + \frac{3/4-l(l+1)}{2j(j+1 ) } \ , .
\ ] ] since @xmath84=2 $ ] and @xmath85=4/3 $ ] , the magnitude of the zeeman shifts is different for the @xmath86 and @xmath87 manifolds , respectively .
we assume that atoms in lattices @xmath8 and @xmath7 experience different magnetic field strengths , @xmath88 b_{{\ensuremath{\mathcal{r}}}},&\alpha\in{\ensuremath{\mathcal{r } } } \ , , \end{array } \right . \ ] ] where @xmath89 .
exact resonance @xmath90 between the two sub - lattices can be achieved for @xmath91 , and periodic magnetic fields could be engineered by a regular array of micromagnets @xcite .
second , the effective hamiltonian in eq .
( [ effham ] ) can be realised with a uniform magnetic field across all lattice sites and static or ac stark shifts that are different for the @xmath8 and @xmath7 lattices .
for example , one could employ ac stark shifts using a standing wave with periodicity @xmath92 such that all @xmath8 and @xmath7 atoms are located at the nodes and antinodes , respectively .
since the magnitude of the ac stark shifts depends on @xmath93 , a relative shift between the @xmath61 and @xmath47 transitions can be induced such that the resonance condition @xmath94 holds .
( color online ) magnetic flux @xmath95 enclosed in an elementary triangle of the lattice in fig . [ fig1 ] as a function of @xmath96 , where @xmath92 and @xmath57 are the lattice constants of the rectangular sub - lattices .
@xmath12 ( @xmath14 ) is the flux through the upward ( downward ) pointing triangle @xmath13 ( @xmath15 ) in fig .
[ fig1 ] and for the effective hamiltonian in eq .
( [ effham ] ) with only nearest neighbour interactions taken into account .
, width=283 ] the effective hamiltonian in eq .
( [ effham ] ) exhibits complex hopping amplitudes for exciton transitions between the @xmath8 and @xmath7 lattices which correspond to an artificial vector potential @xmath97 according to the peierls substitution @xcite .
this result can be understood as follows .
excitations in the @xmath8 and @xmath7 lattices couple to different dipole transitions with complex dipole moments @xmath98 and @xmath99 , respectively .
the two different transitions on sites @xmath8 and @xmath7 are tuned into resonance through external fields that break time - reversal symmetry .
since @xmath98 and @xmath99 have a well - defined relative phase , hopping between the two sub - lattices gives rise to a complex hopping amplitude that depends on the azimuthal angle of the relative position vector @xmath100 between sites @xmath24 and @xmath34 , see eq .
( [ phasedef ] ) .
the total magnetic flux @xmath12 through the upward pointing triangle @xmath13 is shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] . for nearest neighbour interactions
only , the total flux is determined by the sum of the phases along the edges of the triangle , @xmath101 we find that the total flux is in general different from zero and can be adjusted by varying the lattice parameters .
this is shown by the red solid line in fig .
( [ fig3 ] ) , where @xmath102 is depicted as a function of ratio @xmath96 .
@xmath102 is different from zero except for @xmath103 and attains all possible values between @xmath104 and @xmath105 , which is the maximal range for the flux defined mod @xmath106 .
similarly , the total magnetic flux @xmath14 through the downward pointing triangle @xmath15 in fig . [ fig1 ] is given by @xmath107 and @xmath14 is shown by the blue dot - dashed line in fig .
since @xmath108 for all values @xmath96 , the flux in neighbouring triangles has the same magnitude but the opposite sign , and hence the complex transition amplitudes in our system correspond to a staggered artificial magnetic field .
this result is consistent with the assumed translational symmetry of the lattice , which requires that all magnetic fluxes within the unit cell must add up to zero .
next we investigate the single - particle band structure of @xmath109 using a rectangular unit cell containing two lattice sites as shown by the shaded area in fig .
it follows that the @xmath110 space hamiltonian @xmath111 is represented by a @xmath112 matrix , where @xmath113 describes a point in the first brillouin zone of the reciprocal lattice .
we include all hopping terms between sites separated by @xmath114 . through a numerical study we find that @xmath111 describes the bulk properties of our system well for @xmath115 and @xmath116 .
the band structure for the special case of equilateral triangles as in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( i.e. , @xmath117 ) is shown in fig .
there are two separate bands and the band gap varies in size across the brillouin zone .
the gap is the smallest near the following points at the zone boundary , [ kpoints ] @xmath118 the magnitude of the band gap near these points is of the order of @xmath119 , where @xmath43 is defined in eq .
( [ strength ] ) .
the broken time - reversal symmetry in our system endows the band structure with non - trivial topological properties .
we numerically calculate the chern number as described in @xcite and find that the lower and upper bands have chern numbers @xmath2 and @xmath120 , respectively .
( color online ) single - excitation band structure for @xmath90 and @xmath121 .
all hopping terms between sites within a radius of @xmath122 are taken into account .
the two bands are separated by a gap and the lower ( upper ) band has chern number @xmath2 ( @xmath120 ) .
, width=321 ] various topological regimes can be realised in our system by adjusting the lattice parameters and the detuning between the excitations on the sub - lattices @xmath8 and @xmath123 .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ fig5 ] , where we show the chern number of the lower band as a function of the ratio @xmath96 and @xmath68 .
first , we note that the phase diagram in fig .
[ fig5 ] exhibits extended regions with non - zero chern numbers that are robust with respect to small variations in @xmath68 and @xmath96 . the solid lines in fig .
[ fig5 ] indicate topological phase transitions where the lower and upper bands touch in at least two of the @xmath113 points in eq .
( [ kpoints ] ) which then represent a dirac point .
the qualitative features of the @xmath2 region marked in orange in fig .
[ fig5 ] can be understood by noting that non - zero chern numbers require an efficient coupling between the sub - lattices @xmath8 and @xmath7 . in particular
, the dipole - dipole coupling needs to be larger or comparable to the detuning @xmath68 . for fixed lattice constant @xmath57
, reducing @xmath96 corresponds to an increased dipole - dipole coupling between the sub - lattices and hence the region with @xmath2 broadens along the @xmath68 axis for @xmath124 .
the narrowing of the @xmath2 region near @xmath103 can be understood from fig .
[ fig3 ] . for nearest - neighbour interactions
only , the magnetic flux vanishes for @xmath103 and hence the corresponding bands would have chern number @xmath125 .
taking into account interactions beyond nearest neighbours gives rise to modifications as shown in fig .
in particular , these interactions are responsible for the blue wedged area with chern number @xmath3 .
( color online ) topological regimes for the lower band for @xmath126 .
the black lines indicate topological phase transitions where the chern number of the lower band changes . the red dot and magenta star correspond to the parameters of the band structures in figs .
[ fig4 ] and [ fig6 ] , respectively . ,
width=302 ] the asymmetry of the phase diagram in fig .
[ fig5 ] with respect to the @xmath90 axis can be traced back to the fact that the dipole - dipole interaction differs in strength for the @xmath8 and @xmath7 lattices . in order to illustrate this , we focus on the blue wedge with @xmath3 in fig .
[ fig5 ] and show the band structures of the uncoupled , individual sub - lattices in fig .
[ fig6 ] for @xmath127 .
both band structures are convex surfaces with their minimum at @xmath128 , but the depth of the potential well is significantly larger for the upper band .
the reason is that the strength of the dipole - dipole interaction is three times stronger for the @xmath7 lattice compared to the @xmath8 lattice for @xmath103 , see eqs .
( [ hb ] ) and ( [ hr ] ) .
a necessary condition for non - trivial topological bands is that the two sub - lattices are efficiently coupled by the hamiltonian @xmath129 in eq .
( [ hbr ] ) , which depends on the magnitude of the dipole - dipole interaction connecting the @xmath8 and @xmath7 lattices and the energy spacing between @xmath8 and @xmath7 excitations at each @xmath113 point . as can be seen in fig .
( [ fig6 ] ) , the two surfaces touch near @xmath130 , and hence @xmath129 can give rise to non - zero chern numbers for @xmath127 and @xmath103 . on the other hand ,
the distance between the two uncoupled bands increases quickly if @xmath68 is decreased from zero to negative values .
this explains why the relatively weak next - nearest neighbour interactions in @xmath129 can not induce a @xmath3 band for @xmath131 . in order to observe the topological features of our system , the excitations need to be selectively prepared in either the upper or lower band
this can be achieved in different ways .
first , one prepares an excitation in one of the sub - lattices with a large detuning @xmath68 such that the @xmath7 and @xmath8 lattices are uncoupled .
this is followed by an adiabatic reduction of @xmath132 in order to adjust the required parameter regime .
second , one could prepare all atoms in the @xmath133 state and resonantly excite a particular @xmath113 mode by applying a microwave field tuned in resonance with the @xmath113 mode of interest .
possible signatures of the topological band features include drifts in the motion of the excitation that are associated with the non - zero berry curvature in each band @xcite .
( color online ) single - excitation band structure for @xmath127 , @xmath103 and in the absence of the hamiltonian @xmath134 coupling the two sub - lattices .
the upper ( lower ) surface is the band structure for excitations on the @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) lattice .
all hopping terms between sites within a radius of @xmath122 are taken into account .
, width=302 ]
we have shown that the resonant dipole - dipole interaction between rydberg atoms allows one to engineer effective spin-1/2 models where the spin excitations experience a staggered magnetic field in a triangular lattice .
a necessary condition for engineering artificial magnetic fields is that time - reversal symmetry of the system is broken . in our system , this is achieved by external fields shifting the zeeman sublevels of the considered @xmath17 and @xmath18 manifolds . in this way we ensure that the spin excitation couples to different dipole transitions on the @xmath8 and @xmath7 lattices with dipole moments @xmath98 and @xmath99 , respectively .
these dipole moments have a well - defined relative phase which is different from zero . since @xmath98 and @xmath99 are orthogonal , we find that the phase of the hopping amplitude is determined by the azimuthal angle associated with the relative position of the two sites connected by the hop .
we find that the magnitude of the magnetic flux through an elementary triangular plaquette can be controlled by changing the ratio @xmath96 of the rectangular sub - lattices .
in addition , the staggered magnetic field endows the single - particle band structure with non - trivial chern numbers .
the chern number of the lower band can be adjusted between @xmath135 and @xmath136 and its value depends on the lattice parameters and the detuning @xmath68 between the @xmath8 and @xmath7 lattices .
the topological features of the single - particle bands could be observed by monitoring the deflection of the exciton motion induced by the non - zero berry curvature in either the lower or upper band .
the characterisation of quantum many - body states in the presence of non - zero chern numbers and for partial filling of the lower band is subject to future studies .
mk thanks the national research foundation and the ministry of education of singapore for support and tilman esslinger for helpful discussions .
the authors would like to acknowledge the use of the university of oxford advanced research computing ( arc ) facility in carrying out this work ( http://dx.doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22558 ) .
we evaluate the matrix elements of the electric - dipole - moment operator @xmath137 of an individual atom via the wigner - eckert theorem @xcite and find @xmath138 where @xmath139 are clebsch - gordan coefficients and the spherical unit vectors @xmath140 in eq .
( [ we1 ] ) are defined as @xmath141 the reduced dipole matrix element is @xcite @xmath142 where the @xmath143 matrix in curly braces is the wigner @xmath144 symbol , @xmath145 is the elementary charge and @xmath146 is a radial matrix element .
here we calculate the strength of the dipole - dipole interaction for rubidium atoms and estimate the magnitude of the level shifts required for realising our model . for @xmath147 transitions in rubidium with principal quantum number @xmath148 ,
the reduced dipole moment @xmath50 in eq .
( [ d ] ) is given by @xmath149 where @xmath145 is the elementary charge and @xmath150 is the bohr radius .
it follows that the strength of the dipole - dipole coupling @xmath43 in eq .
( [ strength ] ) for @xmath151 is @xmath152 the lifetime of the @xmath17 and @xmath18 states for @xmath148 is @xmath153 and @xmath154 , respectively .
the hopping rates vary with the lattice parameters but are typically of the order of @xmath43 .
it follows that in principle many coherent hopping events can be observed before losses due to spontaneous emission set in .
this finding is consistent with the experimental observations in @xcite .
note that the magnitude of @xmath43 can be increased by reducing the size of the lattice constant @xmath57 or by increasing @xmath155 .
next we discuss the requirements for reducing the general hamiltonian in eq .
( [ fullham ] ) to our model in eq .
( [ effham ] ) .
first , we note that the level shifts induced between zeeman substates must be large compared to @xmath43 and hence of the order of @xmath156 . shifts of this magnitude can be realised with weak magnetic fields @xcite or ac stark shifts @xcite .
furthermore , the fine structure splitting between the @xmath17 and @xmath18 manifolds is @xmath157 @xcite , which is much larger than @xmath43 and hence it is justified to neglect off - resonant terms in eq .
( [ vdd ] ) .
finally , we note that the energy difference between the @xmath18 manifold and the nearby @xmath158 manifold is approximately @xmath159 @xcite , which is also much larger than @xmath43 .
it follows that the @xmath158 states can be safely neglected . | we show that resonant dipole - dipole interactions between rydberg atoms in a triangular lattice can give rise to artificial magnetic fields for spin excitations .
we consider the coherent dipole - dipole coupling between @xmath0 and @xmath1 rydberg states and derive an effective spin-1/2 hamiltonian for the @xmath0 excitations . by breaking time - reversal symmetry via external fields we engineer complex hopping amplitudes for transitions between two rectangular sub - lattices .
the phase of these hopping amplitudes depends on the direction of the hop .
this gives rise to a staggered , artificial magnetic field which induces non - trivial topological effects .
we calculate the single - particle band structure and investigate its chern numbers as a function of the lattice parameters and the detuning between the two sub - lattices .
we identify extended parameter regimes where the chern number of the lowest band is @xmath2 or @xmath3 . |
planck scale physics is an unknown frontier where gravitational and quantum effects are closely entwined . at this scale
, it might occur that lorentz covariance is jeopardized .
such kind of idea has caught much attention mainly after some authors argued the possibility of lorentz and cpt spontaneous breaking in the context of string theory @xcite .
the detection of lorentz violation at a lower energy scale , even minuscule , could be interpreted as a signature of spontaneous lorentz violation at the underlying theory ( defined at a higher energy scale ) .
these * * remanent * * lorentz violating effects , inherited from a high energy theory , would be then employed to indicate possible features of a planck scale physics . * * the standard model extension ( sme ) @xcite is a broader version of the usual standard model that incorporates all lorentz - violating ( lv ) coefficients ( generated as vacuum expectation values of the underlying theory tensor quantities ) that yield lorentz scalars ( as tensor contractions ) in the observer frame .
such coefficients govern lorentz violation in the particle frame , where are seen as sets of independent numbers .
the sme is actually the suitable framework to investigate properties of lorentz violation on physical systems involving photons @xcite , @xcite , radiative corrections @xcite , fermions @xcite , neutrinos @xcite , topological defects @xcite , topological phases @xcite , cosmic rays @xcite , supersymmetry @xcite , particle decays @xcite , and other relevant aspects @xcite , @xcite .
the sme has also been used as framework to propose lorentz violating @xcite and cpt @xcite probing experiments , which have amounted to the imposition of stringent bounds on the lv coefficients .
concerning the fermion sector of the sme , there are two cpt - odd terms , @xmath0 , where @xmath1 are the lv backgrounds .
the influence of these terms on the dirac theory has already been examined in literature @xcite , passing through its nonrelativistic limit , with close attention on the hydrogen spectrum @xcite .
a similar study has also been developed for the case of a non - minimal coupling with the background , with new outcomes @xcite . * * atomic and optical physics is another area in which lorentz violation has been intensively studied .
indeed , there are several works examining lorentz violation in electromagnetic cavities and optical systems @xcite , @xcite , which contributed to establish upper bounds on the lv coefficients .
the present work is devoted to investigating the influence of lorentz violation induced by the coefficients @xmath2 on the physics of a semi - classical two - level system . as some fundamental concepts of two - level system are also important for the description of laser systems , some results obtained at a semi - classical level may indicate perspectives on the quantum behavior of photons on a resonant cavity .
we start from the lorentz - violating nonrelativistic hamiltonian stemming from the dirac lagrangian supplemented with the terms @xmath3 the lv terms are then considered as perturbations that may modify the dynamics of rabi oscillations on a two - level system .
the first analysis is performed for the term @xmath4 it is seen that it induces modifications on the population inversion function ( pif ) , that may be partially frustrated in some situations or modulated as a beat for other parameter values .
numerical simulations indicated the absence of lv effects on the system for @xmath5 , which thus can be taken as an upper bound for this background . * * in order to examine the effect of the term @xmath6 we have defined a four - state basis , considering the possibility of the electron spin to be up or down . as a consequence ,
both eigenenergy and spin state oscillations take place .
these backgrounds are able to induce rabi oscillations even in the absence of electromagnetic external field .
the non observation of spin oscillation in a real situation was used to set up an upper bound on the @xmath7 magnitude ( @xmath8 this paper is outlined as follows . in sec .
ii , it is presented the fermion sector lagrangian here taken into account , with the associated nonrelativistic hamiltonian . in sec .
iii , some topics of a two - level system are revisited .
further , the lorentz - violating effects on such a system are discussed and analyzed . in sec .
iv , we finish with our concluding remarks .
we begin considering the presence of the two lorentz- and cpt - violating terms ( @xmath9 in the fermion sector , @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the usual dirac lagrangian ( @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are two cpt - odd coefficients that here represent the fixed background responsible for the violation of lorentz symmetry in the frame of particles . in true , the terms @xmath15 , @xmath16 behave as a scalar and a pseudoscalar only in the observer frame , in which @xmath13 and @xmath14 are seen as genuine 4-vectors and no lorentz - violation takes place@xcite .
the euler - lagrange equation applied on this lagrangian provides the modified dirac equation : @xmath17 which corresponds to the usual dirac equation supplemented by the lorentz - violating terms associated with the background .
such equation is also attainable in the momenta space : @xmath18 with @xmath19 being the @xmath20 spinor in momentum space .
it is possible to show that each component of the spinor @xmath21 satisfies a changed klein - gordon equation which represents the dispersion relation of this model , given as follows:@xmath22 ^{2}+4b^{2}(p - v)^{2}-4[b\cdot(p - v)]\right ] = 0 , \label{dr1}\ ] ] we now asses the nonrelativistic limit of such modified dirac equation . to correctly do it , lagrangian ( [ l1 ] ) must be considered in the presence of an external electromagnetic field @xmath23 coupled to the matter field by means of the covariant derivative ( @xmath24 lagrangian ( [ l1 ] ) is then rewritten in the form : @xmath25 which implies : @xmath26 writing @xmath27 in terms of two - component spinors ( @xmath28 there follows : @xmath29 w_{b},\label{wa2}\\ \left ( e - ea_{0}+m_{e}-\text{v}_{0}-\mathbf{\sigma}\cdot\mathbf{b}\right ) w_{b } & = \left [ \mathbf{\sigma}\cdot(\mathbf{p}-e\mathbf{a}-\mathbf{v})-b_{0}\right ] w_{a}. \label{wb2}\ ] ] @xmath30 these two equations yield the free - particle solutions for this model ( see refs .
@xcite,@xcite ) .
the non - relativistic regime is realized by the well - known conditions @xmath31 @xmath32 where @xmath33 represents the nonrelativistic hamiltonian .
@xmath34now , replacing the small spinor component ( @xmath35 on the eq .
( [ wa2 ] ) , it is attained an equation for the large spinor component ( @xmath36 that governs the behavior of the system at this regime .
such equation also provides an expression for @xmath33 ( see ref
. @xcite):@xmath37 .\ ] ] to properly study the influence of this hamiltonian on a quantum system , the lorentz - violating terms ( into brackets ) should be considered into the schrdinger equation . in the next section
, it will be accomplished for a two - level system .
consider a two - level system defined by the energy eigenstates @xmath38 under the action of a semiclassical electromagnetic field @xmath39 the wavefunction for this system is : @xmath40 so that @xmath41 , @xmath42 represent the probability of finding the electron in the states @xmath43 , @xmath44 respectively .
the evolution of this system is given by the schrdinger equation , @xmath45 with @xmath33 being the associated hamiltonian , which may be written in terms of an unperturbed and an interaction part , namely : @xmath46 , where @xmath47 @xmath48 and @xmath49 whereas * * @xmath50 concerns to the atom position .
for the case when the electric field is polarized along the x - axis , @xmath51 we get the result @xmath52 observe that the electric field modulus ( @xmath53 is taken as a constant .
this is a consequence of the dipole approximation ( see ref .
@xcite ) . in order to know how the electric field acts on the system
, we should determine the state vector @xmath54 that is , the coefficients @xmath55 and @xmath56 for this , we write the hamiltonian in the basis of states @xmath57 , @xmath58 : @xmath59 @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the matrix element of the electric dipole moment .
replacing the hamiltonian and the ket @xmath62 in the schrdinger equation , two coupled differential equations for @xmath63 arise:@xmath64 where @xmath65 is the rabi frequency and @xmath66 is here supposed to be a real function
. equations ( [ ca1],[cb1 ] ) may be easily solved for the slowly varying amplitudes , @xmath67 , with which they are read as : @xmath68 here @xmath69 and we used the rotating wave approximation ( rwa ) , in which the rapidly oscillating terms , @xmath70,$ ] were neglected . under this approximation
the equations for @xmath71 and @xmath72 may be exactly solved . considering the system in the state @xmath43 at @xmath73 we get the results @xmath74 e^{i\delta
t/2},\label{sol1a}\\ b(t ) & = i\frac{\omega_{r}}{\omega}\sin(\omega t/2)e^{-i\delta t/2 } , \label{sol1b}\ ] ] with @xmath75 at resonance , the frequency of the external field coincides with the two - level frequency difference @xmath76 so that @xmath77 for more details , see ref .
the population inversion function ( pif ) , defined as @xmath78 is then equal to@xmath79 it varies from @xmath80 and @xmath81 , reflecting the alternation of the particle between the states @xmath43 , @xmath82 along the time .
our first step is to determine the role played by the hamiltonian terms stemming from @xmath15 on the two - level system , whose effect is governed by the nonrelativistic terms @xmath83 and @xmath84 .
we begin by regarding the effect of the term @xmath85 .
this can be done following the procedure of the last section .
taking on @xmath86 it results @xmath87 with @xmath88 @xmath89 the hamiltonian reads as @xmath90 where @xmath91v@xmath92 in the basis @xmath57 , @xmath93 @xmath94 has the simple form : @xmath95 with : @xmath96 @xmath97v@xmath98 replacing the modified hamiltonian in eq .
( [ schro ] ) , we obtain : @xmath99 where it was used @xmath100 in terms of the slowing varying amplitudes : @xmath101 at resonance @xmath102 , and with the initial condition @xmath103 such differential equations can be exactly solved , yielding @xmath104 these coefficients are different from the former ones ( eqs .
( [ sol1a ] ) and ( [ sol1b ] ) ) , but the amplitude probabilities @xmath105 and the population inversion ( pi ) , @xmath106 are not altered .
this shows that the lorentz - violating term @xmath85 does not modify the rabi oscillation and the physics of the two - level system , except for phase effects .
we should now investigate the effect of term @xmath107 on the two - level system . in this case , the hamiltonian is : @xmath108 where @xmath109 for an x - axis polarized electric field , the electron momentum should also be aligned along the x - axis . in this case : @xmath110v@xmath111 using the relation @xmath112 @xmath113,$ ] it results : @xmath114v@xmath115.$ ] representing such operator in the @xmath116 basis , we have@xmath117,$ ] with @xmath118v@xmath119 @xmath120 replacing all that into the schrdinger equation , we get the following system of coupled differential equations:@xmath121 writing such equations for the slowing varying amplitudes ( in the rotating wave approximation ) , we attain : @xmath122 an interesting preliminary analysis consists in analyzing the behavior of this system under the action only of the background , in a situation where the external electromagnetic field is null . in this case , it is possible to show that the lorentz - violating background is able to induce rabi oscillations , once the system has a non null electric dipole moment . in the absence of the external field , the system of eqs .
( [ a3b ] ) , ( [ b3b ] ) takes the form @xmath123 @xmath124 which implies the solution : * * @xmath125 , b(t)=\frac{-i\beta_{0}}{\sqrt{1 + 4\beta_{0}^{2}}}\left [ e^{\frac{i}{2}k_{-}\omega t}-e^{-\frac{i}{2}k_{+}\omega t}\right ] , \ ] ] with @xmath126 the corresponding population inversion is@xmath127 .
\label{wv}\ ] ] this result shows that the lorentz - violating background , by itself , is able to induce state oscillations with a fixed frequency @xmath128 , that approximates to * * @xmath69 once the background is supposed to be of small magnitude @xmath129 .
* * as the corrections induced are proportional to the factor @xmath130v@xmath131 it may then be used to impose a bound on the background magnitude .
in fact , considering that effects on the population inversion larger than @xmath132 might be experimentally detectable , we shall have @xmath130v@xmath133 taking @xmath134 it yields : v@xmath135 this is not a tight upper bound , but may be taken as a preliminary result . a more stringent bound
can be attained analyzing the system behavior in the presence of electric field @xmath136 . in the presence of the external field @xmath137 ,
( [ a3b],[b3b ] ) do not possess analytical solution even at resonance @xmath138 .
a numerical approach is then employed to provide a graphical solution for the pif of the system . to do it , it is necessary to establish a set of numerical values compatible with the physics of a typical two - level system . here
, we are working at the natural units ( @xmath139 where the relevant parameters present the following mass dimension : @xmath140=[\omega ] = [ v^{\mu}]=1,[e_{0}]=2,[p_{ab}]=[p_{ab}]=-1.$ ] as a starting step , we search for the effects of a small background , @xmath141**v**@xmath142 on the two - level system .
we take values for the electric field corresponding to a typical magnetic field @xmath143 in natural units @xmath144 @xmath145,$ ] so it results : @xmath146 for the wave frequency , we take a typical electromagnetic value : @xmath147 ( ultraviolet limit ) , which in natural units is equivalent to @xmath148 @xmath149since @xmath150 in fig .
[ [ fig1 ] ] , the effect of the background on the pif is shown in detail .
it induces alterations ( peak deformations ) on the perfect harmonic sinusoidal pattern , given by eq .
( [ w2 ] ) .
such modifications appear at the form of peak reversions and nonhomogeneities in the pif .
these alterations are present along with all sinusoidal oscillation pattern . in the absence of an analytical solution ,
it is necessary to scan the relevant parameters to gain some feeling about the role played by each one .
naturally , lorentz - violating effects on the pif increase with the background magnitude . keeping @xmath151v@xmath152 and the external frequency @xmath153 constant
, several numerical simulations revealed that the lv effects tend to diminish with @xmath154 as observed in fig . [ [ fig2 ] ] .
the variation of the electric field seems to have a cyclic effect on @xmath155 initially , while @xmath137 magnitude is reduced , increasing lv effects are implied . reducing even more @xmath151
such effects diminish , so that in the limit @xmath156 the background influence becomes tiny , recovering the weak oscillations described by eq .
( [ wv ] ) .
concerning the oscillation frequency , it continues to be sensitive to the value of @xmath157 ( the larger this product , the larger the frequency ) , but such frequency is also affected by the background magnitude , so that @xmath158 does not hold anymore .
now , it increases with the background , being larger than @xmath159 .
only when the background tends to vanish , the oscillation frequency recovers the usual value @xmath160 [ ptb ] graph1plot2d1.eps [ ptb ] graph2bplot2d1.eps moreover , for some specific parameter values , the background induces a clear modulation on the pif , which takes place only for some values of the product @xmath161 such a modulation is obviously associated with a kind of partial inversion frustration ( when the inversion is not fully accomplished ) at some stages .
in fact , the graph of fig . [ [ fig3 ] ] shows a pattern of modulation very similar to the one of a beat ( superposition of close frequencies ) . the behavior of fig .
[ [ fig3 ] ] occurs for some specific combinations of @xmath66 and @xmath137 which yield @xmath162 for @xmath163**v * * @xmath164 it was also reported for @xmath165 and @xmath166 keeping the values of @xmath167 and v unchanged .
as already commented , a @xmath66 reduction implies an attenuation on the lv effects , except when the resulting value of @xmath157 brings about a beat oscillation pattern .
finally , an important point also to be analyzed refers to the minimum background magnitude for which modifications on the pif are still present .
numerical simulations for @xmath168 @xmath169 do not reveal any effect on the usual sinusoidal rabi oscillations for the following parameter ranges : @xmath170 , @xmath171 parameter values outside these ranges could also be considered , but violate the dipolar approximation and are not suitable to simulate the physics of a two - level system ( except for frequencies smaller than @xmath172 ) .
once the lorentz - violating modifications alluded to here are not observed , we should conclude that the background magnitude can not be larger than @xmath173 @xmath174 .
we now examine the effects that the coupling @xmath175 amounts to the two - level system .
initially , we choose a purely spacelike background , @xmath176 for which there corresponds the nonrelativistic term @xmath177 . in this case , we shall adopt a four - state basis : @xmath178 where each element is a tensor product of an eigenstate of energy @xmath179 or @xmath180 with an eigenstate of spin @xmath181 or @xmath182 in this case , the general state vector is @xmath183 which formally describes a four - level system .
the hamiltonian is @xmath184 with @xmath185 in this basis , we write : @xmath186+b_{z}[|a+\rangle\langle a+|-|a-\rangle \langle a-|\nonumber\\ & + |b+\rangle\langle b+|-|b-\rangle\langle b-|]-ib_{y}[|a+\rangle\langle a-|-|a-\rangle\langle a+|+|b+\rangle\langle b-|-|b-\rangle\langle b+|]\ } , \label{h3}\ ] ] where it was taken : @xmath187 @xmath188 and @xmath189 once the operator @xmath190 does not act on spin states .
the spin operators acts as @xmath191 @xmath192 @xmath193 @xmath194 replacing all that in the schrdinger equation , we obtain four coupled differential equations for the time - dependent coefficients : @xmath195 , \label{diffcb1}\\ \overset{\cdot}{a}_{_{2 } } & = -i\left [ \omega_{a}a_{2}-e(t)p_{ab--}b_{2}+b_{x}a_{1}-b_{z}a_{2}+ib_{y}a_{1}\right ] , \\
\overset{\cdot}{b}_{_{1 } } & = -i\left [ \omega_{b}b_{1}-e(t)p_{ab++}^{\ast } a_{1}+b_{x}b_{2}+b_{z}b_{1}-ib_{y}b_{2}\right ] , \\
\overset{\cdot}{b}_{_{2 } } & = -i\left [ \omega_{b}b_{2}-e(t)p_{ab--}^{\ast } a_{2}+b_{x}b_{1}-b_{z}b_{2}+ib_{y}b_{1}\right ] , \label{diffcb4}\ ] ] such equations may be written in terms of the slow varying amplitudes @xmath196:@xmath197 , \label{diffb1}\\ \overset{\cdot}{a}_{2}(t ) & = -i\left [ -e_{0}p_{ab}e^{i(\omega-\nu)t}b_{2}(t)+b_{x}a_{1}(t)-b_{z}a_{2}(t)+ib_{y}a_{1}\right ] , \\
\overset{\cdot}{b}_{1}(t ) & = -i\left [ -e_{0}p_{ab}e^{-i(\omega-\nu)t}a_{1}(t)+b_{x}b_{2}(t)+b_{z}b_{1}(t)-ib_{y}b_{2}\right ] , \\
\overset{\cdot}{b}_{2}(t ) & = -i\left [ -e_{0}p_{ab}e^{-i(\omega-\nu)t}a_{2}(t)+b_{x}b_{1}(t)-b_{z}b_{2}(t)+ib_{y}b_{1}\right ] , \label{diffb4}\ ] ] where it was assumed that the dipolar transitions are real quantities and the same between states of different spin polarizations , that is , @xmath198 moreover , the term @xmath199 was neglected due to the rwa . considering a general situation
, it may occur both spin state oscillations and energy state oscillations , so that it is necessary to define two population inversion functions - a spin pif @xmath200 and an energy pif @xmath201 : @xmath202 as a first insight , this model is to be regarded in the absence of the lorentz - violating background @xmath203 and in the presence of the external field @xmath204 in this case , the solution for the four coupled equations has the form : @xmath205 which implies the following pifs : @xmath206 these results indicate an energy eigenstate oscillation @xmath207 , generated by the external field , and total absence of spin oscillation ( the field does not act on the spin states ) , denoted by @xmath208 on the other hand , we can search for the solution of this system in the absence of external field @xmath209 , for the background configuration @xmath210 : @xmath211 such relations obviously reflect an oscillation on the spin states , once the system undergoes alternation between @xmath212 states , and the inexistence of energy state oscillation .
the obtained pifs , @xmath213 \sin^{2}(\sqrt{b_{x}^{2}+b_{z}^{2}}t),\text { } w_{e}=1,\ ] ] confirm that this is really the case . for ( @xmath214 we have @xmath215 ( no spin oscillation ) . for ( @xmath216 we have @xmath217 this latter outcome shows that the background may itself induce spin oscillation ( even in the absence of external field ) , which may be used to establish an upper bound on @xmath218 we should now solve the system of equations ( [ diffb1]-[diffb4 ] ) in the presence both of the lorentz - violating background and external field * * @xmath137 . as a starting situation
, we regard the background as @xmath219 which provides:@xmath220 it is easy to note that the population inversion of the energy states is still equal to @xmath221 , showing that the term @xmath222 does not modify the population inversion of this system .
furthermore , it does not yield spin state oscillation as well @xmath223 , which is consistent with the fact that the operator @xmath224 does not flip the spin .
once the influence of the @xmath225-component is understood , the role played by a more general background , @xmath226 should be now analyzed . in this case , the spin inversion is an expected result . the system of eqs .
( [ diffb1]-[diffb4 ] ) also exhibits an exact solution , namely , @xmath227,\text { } a_{2}(t)=-\frac { i(b_{x}+ib_{y})}{2b}[\sin nt-\sin mt],\nonumber\\ b_{1}(t ) & = \frac{i}{2}[\sin mt+\sin nt],\text { } b_{2}(t)=-\frac { i(b_{x}+ib_{y})}{2b}[\cos nt-\cos mt].\end{aligned}\ ] ] where * * @xmath228 . carrying out the spin and energy pif , defined in eqs.([ws],[we ] ) , we get @xmath229 it is seen that the terms @xmath230 do not modify @xmath231 that is governed only by the external field , whereas the external field does not disturb the spin oscillation , which depends only on the background .
the spin population inversion has period @xmath232 so that the smaller the parameter @xmath233 the larger is such period . for a tiny @xmath234 the period may be so large that the inversion could become unobservable . here
, we take a case where such spin oscillation is undetectable ( period bigger than @xmath235 to establish an upper bound for the background : @xmath236 this upper bound holds equally as @xmath237 or @xmath238 for the cases @xmath239 or @xmath240 , respectively .
it is clear that the background @xmath241 induces effects totally similar to the ones of @xmath242 , thus requiring no special attention .
another situation of possible interest is @xmath243 for which the energy oscillation might be correlated with the spin oscillation . in this case , the system of eqs .
( [ diffb1]-[diffb4 ] ) provides the following solution : * * @xmath244,\\ b_{1}(t ) & = -\frac{1}{2bmn}[-ib^{2}(m\sin nt - n\sin mt)+ie_{0}p_{ab}b(n\sin mt+m\sin nt)+b_{z}mn(\cos nt-\cos mt)],\text { } \\ \text { } a_{2}(t ) & = -\frac{ib_{x}}{2b}[\sin nt-\sin mt],\text { \ \ } b_{2}(t)=\frac{b_{x}}{2b}[\cos mt-\cos nt],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath245 these outcomes allow one to write lengthy expressions for @xmath246 and @xmath247 which reveal the influence of @xmath248 and @xmath225 on the dynamics of the system .
pif graphs for several values of @xmath248 and @xmath225 show that these coefficients do not have much effect on the energy inversion , which remains almost invariant while @xmath248 and @xmath225 take on different values .
this is not the case for the spin inversion , however .
indeed , @xmath247 is sensitive to variations of the ratio @xmath249 being suppressed for small values of @xmath250 @xmath251 , while increasing with it , becoming total @xmath252 for the case @xmath253 .
on the other hand , it is also observed that the frequency of the spin oscillation increases with the background modulus , @xmath254 given that the coefficient @xmath255 plays a role similar to the one of @xmath256 we should conclude that the case @xmath257 presents the same general behavior of this previous case .
numerical simulations have shown that more appreciable lv effects are just attainable for high values of the background , such as @xmath284 for smaller background magnitudes , @xmath285 ( see fig .
[ [ fig6 ] ] ) , lorentz - violating effects tend to vanish .
indeed , while the energy pif tends to assume the usual sinusoidal form , the spin pif tends to collapse to 1 ( absence of spin oscillation ) , in a behavior similar to the one of fig .
[ [ fig6 ] ] .
[ ptb ] graph4plot2d1.eps [ ptb ] graph5plot2d1.eps [ ptb ] graph6plot2d1.eps
in this work , the effects of cpt- and lorentz - violating terms ( stemming from the sme model ) on a two - level system were investigated . in the first case analyzed
, it was reported that the background @xmath13 alters the rabi oscillations , implying partial population inversion frustration and some kinds of modulation .
depending on the parameter values , the induced modulation might be stronger , becoming similar to a beat .
it also occurs that @xmath13 may induce rabi oscillations even in the absence of an external electromagnetic field , but it would become a sensitive effect just for large background magnitudes . once the lorentz - violating effects here foreseen are supposed to be not observed , the minimum value below which the background yields no modifications on the pif was identified as an upper bound for this lorentz - violating coefficient ( @xmath168 @xmath286 in order to determine the effects induced by the background @xmath287 a four state basis was adopted .
it was then shown that it occurs two types of population inversion , one referred to the energy states ( determined by the external electromagnetic field ) , another concerned with the spin states ( implied by the background ) .
the supposed non observation of this spin oscillation ( relying on the validity of the dipole approximation ) was used to impose an upper bound on such a coefficient : @xmath288 a point that deserves some attention concerns to the validity of the rotating wave approximation ( rwa ) in the cases where the lorentz - violating perturbation contains terms like sin@xmath289 or cos@xmath289 , as in eqs .
( [ a2 ] , [ b2],[ab1]-[ab4 ] ) . in this case , the perturbation term oscillates at a frequency @xmath153 equal to half the frequency of the rwa - neglected term . the question is to know if the rapidly oscillating term ( with frequency equal to @xmath290 ) may be dropped out while the perturbation term ( with frequency equal to @xmath167 ) is kept . to answer this issue , some numerical calculations were performed out of the rwa , that is , maintaining the rapidly oscillating terms together .
the observed results do not differ qualitatively and appreciably from the ones previously obtained , which leads to the conclusion that rwa is still a good approximation .
finally , the cases here studied in the semiclassical viewpoint can also be considered in the context of a quantized electromagnetic field in a cavity . in this case , for the @xmath85 term the results depend on the initial state of the electromagnetic field .
for an initially excited atom in a coherent state with large number of photons , the term induces only a phase on the wavefunction coefficients .
as it does not alter the probability amplitudes , it corroborates the results obtained at sec .
iiib ( at semi - classical level ) .
we are now investigating the effects due to the background for small number of photons in the cavity , such as corrections induced on the population inversion and photon statistics .
this work is under development * * @xcite**. * * m.m .
ferreira jr expresses his gratitude both to fapema ( fundao de amparo pesquisa do estado do maranho ) and to the cnpq ( conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico ) , a. r. gomes is grateful to cnpq , and r. c. c. lopes acknowledges capes for financial support .
the authors thank b. baseia for reading the manuscript and for valuable suggestions .
v. a. kostelecky and s. samuel , _ phys .
rev . lett_.
* 63 * , 224 ( 1989 ) ; _ phys .
rev . lett_. * 66 * , 1811 ( 1991 ) ; _ phys .
_ d * 39 * , 683 ( 1989 ) ; _ phys .
_ d * 40 * , 1886 ( 1989 ) , v. a. kostelecky and r. potting , _ nucl .
_ b * 359 * , 545 ( 1991 ) ; phys . lett .
b * 381 * , 89 ( 1996 ) ; v. a. kostelecky and r. potting , _ phys .
_ d * 51 * , 3923 ( 1995 ) .
carroll , g.b .
field and r. jackiw , _ _ phys .
_ _ d * 41 * , 1231 ( 1990 ) ; c. adam and f. r. klinkhamer , _ _ nucl .
_ b * 607 * , 247 ( 2001 ) ; _ _ nucl
_ b * 657 * , 214 ( 2003 ) ; phys .
b * 513 * , 245 ( 2001 ) ; c. kaufhold and f. r. klinkhamer , _ _ nucl .
_ b * 734 * , 1 ( 2006 ) ; r. montemayor and l.f .
urrutia , phys .
d * 72 * , 045018 ( 2005 ) ; x. xue and j. wu , eur .
j. c * 48 * , 257 ( 2006 ) ; a.a .
andrianov and r. soldati , _ phys .
_ d * 51 * , 5961 ( 1995 ) ; _ phys .
_ b * 435 * , 449 ( 1998 ) ; a.a .
andrianov , r. soldati and l. sorbo , _ phys .
_ d * 59 * , 025002 ( 1998 ) ; q. g. bailey and v. a. kostelecky , phys .
d * 70 * , 076006 ( 2004 ) ; m. frank and i. turan , phys .
d * 74 * , 033016 ( 2006 ) ; b. altschul , _ phys .
_ d * 72 * , 085003 ( 2005 ) ; r. lehnert and r. potting , _ phys . rev .
lett_. * 93 * , 110402 ( 2004 ) ; r. lehnert and r. potting , _ phys .
d _ * 70 * , 125010 ( 2004 ) ; b. altschul , _ phys .
lett . _ * 98 * , 041603 ( 2007 ) ; phys.rev .
d * 72 , * 085003 ( 2005 ) ; phys.rev .
d * 73 * , 036005 ( 2006 ) ; phys . rev .
d * 73 * , 045004 ( 2006 ) .
h. belich , m. m. ferreira jr , j.a .
helayel - neto , m. t. d. orlando , phys .
d * 67 * , 125011 ( 2003 ) ; -ibid , phys .
d * 69 * , 109903 ( e ) ( 2004 ) ; h. belich , m. m. ferreira jr , j.a .
helayel - neto , m. t. d. orlando , phys .
d * 68 * , 025005 ( 2003 ) ; a. p. b. scarpelli , h. belich , j. l. boldo , j.a .
helaeyl - neto , _ phys .
_ d * 67 * , 085021 ( 2003 ) ; h. belich _ et al_. , nucl .
b * * suppl . * 127 * , 105 ( 2004 ) ; h. belich , m. m. ferreira jr and j. a. helayel - neto , _ eur . phys .
j. c _ * 38 * , 511 ( 2005 ) ; h. belich , t. costa - soares , m.m .
ferreira jr . , j. a. helayl - neto , _ eur .
j. c _ * 42 , * 127 ( 2005 ) . r. jackiw and v. a. kosteleck , _ phys .
lett . _ * 82 * , 3572 ( 1999 ) ; j. m. chung and b. k. chung _ phys .
_ d * 63 * , 105015 ( 2001 ) ; j.m .
phys.rev_. d * 60 * , 127901 ( 1999 ) ; g. bonneau , _ nucl.phys .
_ b * 593 , * 398 ( 2001 ) ; m. perez - victoria , _ phys .
rev . lett_. * 83 * , 2518 ( 1999 ) ; m. perez - victoria , _
jhep _ * 0104 * , 032 ( 2001 ) ; o.a .
battistel and g. dallabona , _ nucl .
b _ * 610 * , 316 ( 2001 ) ; o.a .
battistel and g. dallabona , _ j. phys .
g _ * 28 * , l23 ( 2002 ) ; _ j. phys .
g _ * 27 * , l53 ( 2001 ) ; a. p. b. scarpelli , m. sampaio , m. c. nemes , and b. hiller , _ phys .
_ d * 64 * , 046013 ( 2001 ) ; t. mariz , j.r .
nascimento , e. passos , r.f . ribeiro and f.a .
brito , jhep 0510 ( 2005 ) 019 .
b. altschul , _ phys .
_ d * 70 * , 056005 ( 2004 ) ; g. m. shore , nucl .
* b * 717 , 86 ( 2005 ) ; d. colladay and v. a. kostelecky , _ _ phys . lett . _
_ b * 511 * , 209 ( 2001 ) ; m. m. ferreira jr , p__hys .
_ _ d * 70 , * 045013 ( 2004 ) ; m. m. ferreira jr , p__hys . rev . _
_ d * 71 , * 045003 ( 2005 ) ; m. m. ferreira jr and m. s. tavares , int .
phys . * a * 22 , 1685 ( 2007 ) . v. barger , s. pakvasa , t.j.weiler , and k.whisnant , _ phys .
rev_. _ lett .
_ * 85 * , 5055 ( 2000 ) ; v. a. kostelecky and m. mewes , _ phys .
rev_. d * 69 * , 016005 ( 2004 ) ; _ phys .
rev_. d * 70 * , 031902 ( r ) ( 2004 ) ; v. a. kostelecky and m. mewes , _ phys .
rev_. d * 70 * , 076002 ( 2004 ) ; t. katori , v. a. kostelecky , r. tayloe , phys.rev .
d * 74 * , 105009 ( 2006 ) ; r. brustein , d. eichler , s. foffa , phys.rev .
d * 65 * , 105006 ( 2002 ) ; y. grossman , c .
kilic , j. thaler , and d.g .
e. walker , phys .
d * 72 * , 125001 ( 2005 ) ; l. b. auerbach _ et al .
d * 72 * , 076004 ( 2005 ) ; d. hooper , d. morgan , and e. winstanley , phys .
d * 72 * , 065009 ( 2005 ) .
h. belich , t. costa - soares , m.m .
ferreira jr . , j. a. helayl - neto , m.t .
d. orlando , _ phys .
b _ * 639 , * 675 ( 2006 ) ; h. belich , t. costa - soares , m.m .
ferreira jr . , j. a. helayl - neto , _ eur .
j. c _ * 41 , * 421 ( 2005 ) . o. gagnon and g. d. moore , _ phys .
d _ * 70 * , 065002 ( 2004 ) ; j.w .
moffat , _ int . j. mod
* 12 * 1279 ( 2003 ) ; f. w. stecker and s.t .
scully , astropart .
* 23 * , 203 ( 2005 ) ; f. w. stecker and s.l .
glashow , astropart .
* 16 * , 97 ( 2001 ) .
p. a. bolokhov , s. grootnibbelink , m.pospelov , _ phys .
_ d**72 , * * 015013 ( 2005 ) ; h. belich _ et al_. , phys .
d * 68 , * 065030 ( 2003 ) ; s. groot nibbelink and m. pospelov , phys .
lett . * 94 * , 081601 ( 2005 ) .
a. p. b. scarpelli and j. a. helayel - neto , phys .
d * 73 * , 105020 ( 2006 ) ; n.m .
barraz , jr .
fonseca , w.a .
moura - melo , and j.a .
helayel - neto , phys .
rev . d**76 * * , 027701 ( 2007 ) ; h. belich , m. a. de andrade , m. a. santos , mod.phys.lett .
a * 20 * , 2305 ( 2005 ) .
coleman and s.l .
glashow , _ phys .
rev_. d * 59 * , 116008 ( 1999 ) ; v. a. kostelecky and m. mewes , _ phys .
rev . lett_. * 87 * , 251304 ( 2001 ) ; v. a. kostelecky and m. mewes , _ phys .
rev_. d * 66 * , 056005 ( 2002 ) ; j. lipa , j.a .
nissen , s.wang , d. a. stricker , d. avaloff , _ phys .
_ * 90 * , 060403 ( 2003 ) .
r. bluhm , v.a .
kostelecky , and n. russell , _ phys .
rev . lett_. * 79 * , 1432 ( 1997 ) ; r. bluhm , v.a .
kostelecky , and n. russell , _ phys .
_ d * 57 * , 3932 ( 1998 ) ; r. bluhm , v.a .
kostelecky , c. d. lane , and n. russell , _ phys .
rev . lett_. * 88 * , 090801 ( 2002 ) ; r. bluhm and v.a .
kostelecky , _ phys .
rev . lett_. * 84 * , 1381 ( 2000 ) ; r. bluhm , r. bluhm , v.a .
kostelecky , and c. d. lane , _ phys .
rev . lett_. * 84 * , 1098 ( 2000 ) ; r. bluhm , v.a .
kostelecky , n .
russell , _ phys .
rev . lett_. * 82 * , 2254 ( 1999 ) ; v.a .
kostelecky and c. d. lane , _ phys .
_ d * 60 * , 116010 ( 1999 ) .
h. muller , c. braxmaier , s. herrmann , a. peters , and c. lmmerzahl,_phys .
_ d * 67 * , 056006 ( 2003 ) ; h. mller , s. herrmann , a .
saenz , a. peters , and c. lmmerzahl , p__hys .
_ _ d * 68 , * 116006 ( 2003 ) ; h. mller , _ phys . rev .
_ d * 71 * , 045004 ( 2005 ) ; n. russell , phys .
scripta * 72 * , c38 ( 2005 ) .
d. f. phillips , m. a. humphrey , e. m. mattison , r. e. stoner , r. f c. vessot , r. l. walsworth , phys.rev .
d63 , 111101 ( r ) ( 2001 ) ; d. bear , r.e .
stoner , r.l .
walsworth , v. a. kostelecky , c. d. lane , phys.rev .
lett . * 85 * , 5038 ( 2000 ) ; erratum - ibid . 89
( 2002 ) 209902 ; m.a .
humphrey , d.f .
phillips , e.m.mattison , r.f.c.vessot , r.e.stoner,r.l.walsworth , phys .
a * 68 * , 063807 ( 2003 ) . | the influence of lorentz- and cpt - violating terms of the extended standard model on a semi - classical two - level system is analyzed .
it is shown that the lorentz - violating background ( when coupled with the fermion sector in a vector way ) is able to induce modifications on the rabi oscillation pattern , promoting sensitive modulations on the usual oscillations .
as for the term involving the coefficient coupled in an axial vector way , it brings about oscillations both on energy states and on the spin states ( implied by the background ) .
it is also seen that such backgrounds are able to yield state oscillations even in the absence of the electromagnetic field .
the foreseen effects are used to establish upper bounds on the lorentz - violating coefficients . |
multiple sequence alignment ( msa ) is one of the most fundamental tasks in bioinformatics .
while there are many attempts to handle comparative sequence analyses without relying on msa , it still represents a starting point for most evolutionary biology methods .
pairwise sequence alignment has been conceptualized as early as the 1970 s , starting with global alignments that attempt to align entire sequences @xcite and then introducing a decade later local alignments that focus on the identification of subsequences sharing high similarity @xcite .
the standard computational formulation of both tasks is to maximize a scoring function obtained as the sum of the score for each aligned pair of residues ( nucleotides or amino acids , the highest scores being attributed to pairs of residues with highest similarity ) , minus some gaps penalties . since these seminal works
, an abundant literature has flourished exploring this topic in many different directions , from the pairwise problem to the more complex task of aligning more than 3 sequences ( one of the very first attempts appearing in * ? ? ?
* ) , from exact solutions that scale exponentially with sequence lengths to faster heuristic approaches used in the most common tools , and from the scoring formulation of the alignment problem that requires to choose the scoring parameters to probabilistic formulations in which those parameters are estimated @xcite .
however , manually refined alignments continue to be superior to purely automated methods and there is a continuous effort to improve the accuracy of msa tools @xcite .
we refer the reader to the reviews @xcite for more details on msa . + dynamic time warping ( dtw ) is a general version of the dynamic programing algorithm that solves exactly the pairwise biological sequence alignment problem .
it is a well - known and general technique to find an optimal alignment between two given ( time - dependent ) sequences . in time
series analysis , dtw is used for constructing an optimal alignment of two sequences with possible different lengths by stretching or contracting time intervals @xcite . in functional data analysis ,
the time warping approach consists in modeling a set of curves exhibiting time and amplitude variation with respect to a common continuous process @xcite .
thus , time warping techniques are used in many different areas concerned by sequence or curve comparisons , one of its most famous successes being on human - speech recognition @xcite . here , we propose a simple and fast procedure for msa , inspired from recent techniques of curve synchronization developed in the context of functional data analysis @xcite . in this setup
, one often observes a set of curves which are modeled as the composition of an amplitude process governing their common behavior , and a warping process inducing time distortion among the individuals .
specifically , @xmath0 , @xmath1 $ ] , @xmath2 , are observed , with @xmath3 being i.i.d .
realisations of the amplitude process @xmath4 , and @xmath5 strictly monotone functions such that @xmath6 and @xmath7 being i.i.d .
realisations of the warping process @xmath8 .
aligning pairs of curves ( that is eliminating time variation , which comes to estimating the warping functions @xmath5 ) is a first step before estimating the common amplitude process .
these authors proposed to first estimate pairwise warping functions between all possible trajectories pairs which are then used to create estimators of the underlying individual warping functions in a second step .
sample means or more robust median - based estimates come into play to solve this second step .
this procedure is an alternative to the widely used approach of template registration , that consists in aligning every observed curve to some given template , which should be a good estimate of the mean amplitude process .
the drawback of this methodology is that it heavily relies on the choice of the template , which is not straightforward .
now , in the msa context , the warping process is the insertion - deletion ( or indel ) process that stretches or contracts the initial sequence , while the amplitude process is the substitution process that modifies the value of the sequence base .
the equivalent of template registration in the msa context would be the alignment of every sequence to some estimate of the ancestral sequence , which is , of course , not available .
however , exploiting the previous ideas , we show how pairwise alignments can be combined with a simple median - based approach to obtain an estimate of the multiple alignment of the sequences .
our aim is to establish a proof of concept that our new method could be an interesting ingredient to include into refined msa techniques .
indeed , the method is able to align a large number @xmath9 of sequences ( that are assumed to share a common ancestor ) in a quite simple and fast manner , although a bit rough w.r.t . accuracy .
we would like to stress that we do not claim to be competitive with actual aligners .
let us recall that there already exist many competitors to solve the msa problem whose respective performances have been largely explored ( see for e.g * ? ? ? * and the references therein ) . here , we would rather like to point out to recent developments from curve synchronization that could open the way to new improvements in msa . while we do not pretend to propose a most accurate method , it is important to note that our approach could be used as a starting point in an iterative refinement strategy @xcite .
those strategies , included in many widely used tools such as ` probcons ` @xcite , ` muscle ` @xcite , ` mafft ` @xcite or ` mummals ` @xcite , mostly consist in repeatedly dividing the set of aligned sequences into two random groups and realign those groups by optimizing an objective function .
thus , our simple and fast procedure could be combined with similar refinement strategies that would improve its efficiency .
an advantage of our method is that it only uses pairwise comparison but ( unlike progressive aligners ) is not sensitive to any order on which we consider the sequence pairs . indeed , progressive aligners rely on a guiding tree and progressively build @xmath10 pairwise alignments from the union of the initial set of @xmath9 sequences with consensus sequences built at the internal nodes of the tree . as such ,
the consensus sequences heavily depend on the guiding tree and the sequences ordering which impacts the resulting msa . moreover , progressive aligners are known to tend to propagate errors appearing at the early stages of the method . for instance , ` clustalw ` @xcite is criticized for being responsible of the heuristic rule once a gap , always a gap that makes errors in pairwise alignments to propagate through msa .
the method proposed here is not sensitive to that issue because a gap in an alignment pair will not necessarily be selected for the msa .
the manuscript is organized as follows .
section [ sec : model ] first recalls concepts coming from the pairwise alignment and time warping problems ( section [ sec : rappels ] ) , sets our framework ( section [ sec : msa ] ) and describes our procedure ( section [ sec : estim ] ) .
then section [ sec : results ] presents our experiments , starting with synthetic datasets ( section [ sec : synthetic ] ) , then relying on a benchmark dataset ( section [ sec : balibase ] ) , namely the balibase dataset @xcite and concludes with possible extensions of our approach ( section [ sec : ext ] ) .
in what follows , we first introduce some ideas around pairwise alignment and the time warping problem .
we then explain how to use these concepts in the context of multiple sequence alignment . for any two sequences @xmath11 and @xmath12 with values in a finite alphabet @xmath13 , any ( global ) pairwise alignment of @xmath4 and @xmath14 corresponds to an increasing path in the grid @xmath15\times [ 0,m]$ ] composed by three elementary steps @xmath16 , as shown in figure [ fig : pairwise_align ] . note that for biological reasons , such path is often restricted to never contain two consecutive steps in @xmath17 ( a gap in one sequence may not be followed by a gap in the other sequence ) .
we do not use that constraint in what follows but a post - processing step could be applied to any alignment in order to satisfy it ( the simplest way is then to replace those 2 successive gaps with a ( mis)-match move ; from a graphical point of view a horizontal+vertical or vertical+horizontal move is replaced by a diagonal one ) . for notational convenience , we extend the path to @xmath18\times [ -\epsilon , m]$ ] for some small @xmath19 .
now , any such path may be viewed as an increasing function @xmath20 \to [ -\epsilon , m]$ ] with the convention that it is cd - lg ( continuous on the right , limit on the left ) . by letting @xmath21
denote the left limit of @xmath22 at @xmath23 , we moreover impose that @xmath24 and @xmath25 .
note that we can define a unique generalized inverse function @xmath26 \to [ -\epsilon , n]$ ] constrained to be cd - lg and such that @xmath27 ( the identity function ) . from a graphical point of view
, the path corresponding to @xmath28 is obtained as the symmetric of the path corresponding to @xmath29 with respect to the diagonal line @xmath30 ( see figure [ fig : pairwise_align ] ) .
functions @xmath31 may be viewed as time warping functions that describe the homology ( and thus also the indels ) between sequences @xmath32 obtained from their alignment .
let us first explain this idea on a simple example .
consider an alignment between @xmath33 and @xmath34 given as follows @xmath35 ( this alignment corresponds exactly to the thick and blue path depicted in figure [ fig : pairwise_align ] ) . in this alignment ,
any character from one sequence may be associated to a unique character from the other sequence as follows : when the position corresponds to a _
match _ or a _ mismatch _ , the character is associated to the ( mis)-matching character ( in the other sequence ) while at positions corresponding to indels , we ( arbitrarily ) associate it to the character in the previous ( mis)-matching position in the other sequence . in order to deal with the case where no such previous ( mis)-matching position exists ( namely when the alignment begins with an indel ) , we introduce extra artificial characters ( @xmath36 ) at the beginning of each sequence , these two artificial characters being aligned with each other . in other words
, we consider the alignment @xmath37 the bare alignment ( the alignment without specification of nucleotides ) of these two sequences is as follows @xmath38 here @xmath39 stands for _ base _ and we do not specify to which character it corresponds .
the bare alignment naturally appears to separate the indel process from the substitution process ( see for e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
given the sequences , the knowledge of the bare alignment is sufficient to recover the corresponding full alignment . in this context , the time warping process is exactly the indel process that stretches or contracts an initial sequence , while the amplitude process is the substitution process that modifies the value of the sequence .
we focus on the time warping process encoded in the bare alignment .
let @xmath40 denote this ( asymmetric ) relation induced by the bare alignment . in our example ,
we have that @xmath41 is associated to the artificial character @xmath42 and we denote @xmath43 . in the same way , @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 . note that no position of @xmath4 is associated to @xmath51 ( this is because of a discontinuity of the function @xmath29 at @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 ) .
more importantly , these associations are exactly encoded in the mapping @xmath29 as we have @xmath55 if and only if @xmath56 .
more generally , for any real value @xmath57 $ ] , letting @xmath58 denote the smallest integer larger or equal to @xmath23 , we set @xmath59 ( and similarly for sequence @xmath14 ) . from the ( bare ) pairwise alignment of @xmath32 , we obtain a time warping function @xmath29 such that this alignment is entirely described by the association @xmath60 . in what follows
, we denote this functional association by @xmath61 .
note that we equivalently have @xmath62 .
we also mention that when the pairwise alignment between @xmath32 is extracted from a multiple sequence alignment containing at least 3 sequences , say @xmath63 , the above relation @xmath40 should be associative in the sense that whenever @xmath64 and @xmath65 , we should also have @xmath66 .
this property will be used in the next section . in this section ,
we consider a set of sequences @xmath67 with values in a finite alphabet @xmath13 and respective lengths @xmath68 and we assume that they all share some latent ancestor sequence @xmath69 with values in @xmath13 and length @xmath70 . a multiple sequence alignment of the set of sequences @xmath67 is given by the knowledge of _ homologous _ positions as well as _ inserted _ positions .
to fix the ideas , let us consider for example the following multiple alignment of 3 sequences @xmath71 where the first line indicates homologous positions ( h ) while the other are inserted positions .
homologous positions describe the characters that derived from the ancestor sequence , so that there are exactly @xmath70 homologous positions in the alignment ( whenever an ancestral position was deleted in all the sequences , this can not be reconstructed and such position would not appear in our reconstructed ancestral sequence ) . for each homologous position , there is at most one character in sequence @xmath72 that is associated to it .
this means that homologous columns in the multiple sequence alignment may contain matches , mismatches and even gaps ( when the corresponding ancestral position has been deleted in that particular sequence ) . between two consecutive homologous positions
, each sequence might have a certain number of characters that are inserted .
these characters do not derive from an ancestral position .
note that these insert runs are not aligned in the sense that the choice of how to put the letters in the insert regions is arbitrary and most msa implementations simply left - justify insert regions .
now , given the set of sequences , this multiple alignment may be completely encoded through the knowledge of the homologous positions in the sequences ( see section [ sec : algo ] ) .
our goal is to estimate the alignment of each @xmath72 to the ancestor @xmath69 and thus the global alignment of the set of sequences @xmath67 , by relying on the set of pairwise alignments of each @xmath72 to all the other sequences @xmath73 . to do this
, we will implicitly assume that a ) the multiple sequence alignment of all the sequences @xmath72 is well approximated by the alignment we would obtain from all the sequences @xmath74 ; b ) all the pairwise alignments of @xmath75 are good approximations to the extracted pair alignments from the multiple alignment of all sequences @xmath74 .
+ first , any sequence @xmath72 is derived from the common ancestor sequence @xmath69 through an evolutionary process that can be encoded in the alignment of these two sequences .
this alignment induces a time warping process @xmath76 \to [ -\epsilon , n]$ ] such that we have @xmath77 . for the moment , we assume that the warping functions @xmath78 s are i.i.d .
realisations of the same random process @xmath79 . for identifiability reasons , we constrain @xmath79 such that @xmath80 ( see for example @xcite ) .
moreover , note that assuming the @xmath78 s are i.i.d .
realisations of the same process boils down to considering a star tree leading from the ancestor sequence to any observed sequence @xmath72 . in the case of an ultra - metric tree
, we would obtain non independent but identically distributed realisations .
we will discuss later how to handle more realistic setups .
since the ancestral sequence @xmath69 is not observed , the idea of @xcite is to estimate the warping function @xmath78 from all the pairwise alignments of @xmath72 with the other sequences .
more precisely , when considering the pairwise alignment of @xmath72 with @xmath81 , we obtain a warping function @xmath82 satisfying @xmath83 as a consequence , relying on the desired associative property of @xmath40 , we should have @xmath84 so that we can estimate the warping function @xmath85 from a pairwise alignment of @xmath86 .
note that since pairwise alignment of @xmath86 does not depend on the order of the sequences , the proposed estimators satisfy @xmath87 .
then , we want to combine these estimates @xmath88 to obtain an estimate of @xmath78 . in @xcite ,
the authors use the empirical mean and notice that this makes sense since @xmath89 and under the assumption @xmath90 ( see also * ? ? ?
let us recall that these works come from functional data analysis where the functions @xmath78 s are real - valued functions .
here , we are dealing with discrete sequences and the empirical mean of a set of paths @xmath85 would not give a proper path and thus would not correspond to an alignment of @xmath72 to the ancestor @xmath69 .
that is why instead of using empirical mean , we will rather rely on median values .
note that in general
medians have the advantage of being more robust than mean values . from an algorithmic perspective , a global alignment of @xmath11 and @xmath12 may be encoded trough the sequence of coordinates @xmath91 , where @xmath92 is the length of the alignment , @xmath93 and for any @xmath94 , we have @xmath95 .
we let @xmath96 be the set of possible alignments between @xmath4 and @xmath14 .
the link between the path sequence @xmath97 and the warping function @xmath29 is as follows @xmath98 now , considering a median path boils down to computing median coordinates of points @xmath99 as explained in the next section . in this section ,
we explain how for each sequence @xmath72 , we combine the set of pairwise alignments of @xmath72 with @xmath81 ( @xmath100 ) to obtain an estimate of the warping function @xmath78 .
we thus fix a sequence @xmath72 of length @xmath101 and consider its pairwise alignments with all the other sequences @xmath81 ( @xmath100 ) , including itself ( the alignment path is then the identical function from @xmath102 $ ] to @xmath102 $ ] ) .
we first define an estimate of the true number @xmath70 of homologous positions in our msa ( that is positions that were present in the ancestral sequence @xmath69 , which are the only positions of @xmath69 that may be recovered ) , as a median value ( constrained to be an integer number ) of the set of lengths @xmath103 , namely @xmath104 more precisely , as a convention and for the rest of this work , we set the median of a sequence of integers @xmath105 with ordered values @xmath106 as follows . whenever @xmath9 is even and the mean value @xmath107 between the ordered statistics @xmath108)}$ ] and @xmath108 + 1)}$ ] is not an integer , we ( arbitrarily ) set the median as @xmath109 .
now , we aim at defining a path from @xmath102 $ ] to @xmath110 $ ] by using all the estimated paths @xmath111 obtained by aligning @xmath112 . for any position @xmath113
, we consider the character @xmath114 throughout all the pairwise alignments .
the character @xmath114 may either be aligned with another character @xmath115 or to a gap after position @xmath116 in sequence @xmath81 , as may be viewed in figure [ fig : pos_k ] ( left part ) .
as already explained , each pairwise alignment of @xmath117 with @xmath81 corresponds to a sequence of coordinates @xmath118 as defined above , see equation .
note that we dropped the index @xmath119 on which the sequence @xmath120 also depends .
now , for each value @xmath121 , there is a unique time point @xmath122 and two integers @xmath123 such that @xmath124 in practice , either @xmath125 when @xmath114 is aligned to a character or @xmath126 when @xmath114 is aligned to a gap .
we then compute two median points @xmath127 which gives the part of the median path that concerns character @xmath128 ( figure [ fig : pos_k ] , left part ) .
note that at this step , we did not take into account the possible vertical steps in the alignments @xmath129 .
we consider this now . indeed ,
the concatenation of the positions @xmath130 is almost what we wanted , namely the median path that gives our estimate of the alignment between @xmath72 and ancestral sequence @xmath69 .
however one should notice that for each value @xmath131 , we either have @xmath132 in the first case ( @xmath133 ) , one of the two points @xmath134 or @xmath135 is redundant and should be removed to obtain a proper path in @xmath136 .
otherwise , vertical movements are included in the median path and we keep both values @xmath134 and @xmath135 .
let us note that at the last position @xmath137 , we have @xmath138 so that the median path correctly ends at @xmath139 .
we now combine the different steps to obtain our global alignment procedure as explained in pseudocode in algorithm [ algo : msa ] .
this algorithm outputs a set of homologous positions ( hom ) as well as a set of inserted positions ( ins ) .
let us recall that in each sequence , homologous positions correspond to positions that are aligned with an ancestor position @xmath140 ( @xmath141 ) .
then two homologous positions may be separated by insert runs which are not aligned .
we use a table @xmath142 with @xmath9 rows and @xmath143 columns .
each entry @xmath144 with @xmath145 of this table contains the number of insertions in @xmath72 between two homologous positions with respective ancestor positions @xmath146 and @xmath147 , while entry @xmath148 ( resp .
entry @xmath149 ) is the number of insertions before first ( resp .
after last ) homologous position .
we also use a table @xmath150 with @xmath9 rows and @xmath151 columns .
each entry @xmath144 of this table contains the position in sequence @xmath72 that is homologous to ancestor position @xmath140 .
when there is no such position ( a deletion in sequence @xmath72 ) , the entry is set to @xmath152 . for instance , going back to the example of a multiple sequence alignment of section [ sec : msa ] , we may describe this alignment with the following tables @xmath153 note that the information contained in table @xmath142 is redundant with that in table @xmath150 but we use it for convenience .
indeed , it is helpful to output the final alignment whose size ( i.e. total number of columns ) depends on the number of homologous positions plus the number of inserted positions . now for each sequence @xmath72 with @xmath154 we reconstruct its alignment with ancestral sequence @xmath69 as follows . for each position
@xmath155 , we compute the coordinates @xmath156 from equation .
we update the quantity path(@xmath119 ) that stores the alignment of sequence @xmath72 to ancestor @xmath69 up to position @xmath23 . then we either update the table @xmath142 if an inserted position has been obtained ( case @xmath157= \tilde z_2(u)[2]$ ] where @xmath158 $ ] is the second coordinate of vector @xmath4 ) or the table @xmath150 otherwise . with respect to the algorithmic complexity of the proposed procedure
, we can assume that the @xmath9 sequences have average length similar to @xmath70 .
then , the time complexity of the msa from median warping ( once the pairwise alignments are given ) is @xmath159 since we need @xmath160 iterations in which we compute ( twice ) a median over @xmath9 values ( the complexity of the median calculation being @xmath161 relying for e.g. on the ` quickselect ` algorithm @xcite ) .
we provide running time comparisons with ` mafft ` on the ` balibase ` dataset at the end of section [ sec : balibase ] .
in this section , we propose a simple synthetic experiment in order to assess the performances of our approach .
we start with an ancestral sequence @xmath69 on the set of nucleotides @xmath162 with length @xmath163 . from this ancestral sequence ,
we simulate i.i.d .
sequences @xmath164 as follows .
we rely on the simple thorne - kishino - felsenstein ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter tkf ) model that includes an insertion - deletion process and that can be combined with any substitution process . here
we set parameters for tkf @xmath165 and use the jukes - cantor substitution model ( see for e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) with substitution rate @xmath166 ( all nucleotide frequencies being set to @xmath167 ) .
that is , we are simulating @xmath9 nucleotide sequences related by a star tree and whose branch lengths are set to be equal , as done for instance in @xcite .
we repeat this experiment @xmath168 times for each @xmath9 , and we let the number of sequences vary in @xmath169 . to obtain multiple alignments with our procedure , we first conduct all the pairwise alignments between pairs of sequences through the needleman - wunsch algorithm for global alignment @xcite as implemented in the ` pairwisealignment ` function of the r ` biostrings ` library @xcite .
we set the parameters for the pairwise alignment as : gap opening penalty equal to @xmath170 , gap extension penalty equal to @xmath171 , nucleotide substitution matrix with diagonal values equal to @xmath172 and non - diagonal values equal to @xmath173 .
these are commonly used as default parameter values for the global alignment of dna sequences .
that is , we do not look at optimising the alignment parameters , but just at showing that our procedure can produce reasonable results under general conditions . in order to assess the performance of the method
, we compute for each alignment two scores that measure its overall concordance with the simulated one , sp ( sum of pairs ) and tc ( total column ) scores ( see next section for details ) , and we compare them to the scores obtained by two well established multiple alignment softwares , namely ` clustalw ` @xcite in its ` 2.1 ` version and ` t - coffee ` @xcite in its ` 10.00.r1613 ` version .
both softwares are run under default parameter values .
finally , we also run our procedure on the reference pairwise alignments , that is , those extracted from the simulated multiple alignment for each pair of sequences .
this is done to assess the performance of the method in the best case scenario , as a way to validate the proposed algorithm for combining pairwise alignments .
results are presented in figure [ fig.sim ] .
the first thing to notice is that our method , when used with the reference pairwise alignments , reaches the maximum score possible in almost every case .
although these are not realistic results since reference pairwise alignments are unknown in practice , they confirm the soundness of our method that combines pairwise alignments from median warping .
with respect to the other three methods , in all the scenarios ` t - coffee ` always provides the best performance . in general , tc scores tend to get worse as the number of sequences increases whereas sp scores are more stable .
however , when comparing our procedure ( with estimated pairwise alignments ) and ` clustalw ` ( which is a widely used software ) , we see that ` clustalw ` is better for a small number of sequences , but from @xmath174 , the performance of our method is superior .
msa methods are typically benchmarked on sets of reference alignments , the most widely used being the ` balibase ` @xcite .
it is a large scale benchmark specifically designed for multiple sequence alignment .
it contains test cases based on 3d structural superpositions of protein sequences that are manually refined to ensure the correct alignment of conserved residues .
it is organized into several reference sets , designed to represent real multiple alignment problems .
reference 1 contains alignments of equidistant sequences with 2 different levels of conservation ( rv11 and rv12 ) ; reference 2 ( rv20 ) contains families aligned with one or more highly divergent orphan sequences ; reference 3 ( rv 30 ) contains divergent subfamilies ; reference 4 ( rv 40 ) contains sequences with large n / c - terminal extensions ; and finally reference 5 ( rv 50 ) contains sequences with large internal insertions .
in addition , three separate reference sets ( 68 ) , are devoted to the particular problems posed by sequences with transmembrane regions , repeats , and inverted domains @xcite . these last 3 sets are rarely included in benchmark analyses and we exclude them from ours . for each reference set among the first five ones , except for rv 40 ,
two versions of the same multiple alignments are provided : one with the original sequences ( which is noted bb ) , and one with a shorter version of the sequences contained in the alignment ( which is noted bbs ) .
in general , bbs alignments should be easier to recover than the original ones , since the less alignable parts of the original sequences have been removed .
the ` balibase ` dataset comes with a function called ` baliscore ` used to assess the quality of a msa .
two different criteria are used to score an alignment : sp ( sum of pairs ) and tc ( total column ) scores @xcite .
these criteria only use core blocks of the alignment .
sp score is the percentage of the correctly aligned residue pairs in the alignment . it is defined as the number of correctly aligned residue pairs found in the test alignment divided by the total number of aligned residue pairs in core blocks of the reference alignment .
tc score is the percentage of the correct columns in the alignment .
it is defined as the number of correctly aligned columns found in the test alignment divided by the total number of aligned columns in core blocks of the reference alignment . in order to assess the performance of the method on the balibase data sets , we proceed as for the simulated alignments of the preceding section .
the only differences being that we now consider blosum62 as the default substitution matrix for pairwise alignments ( since we now have protein sequences ) and that for the last two reference sets ( rv40 and rv50 ) we consider overlap pairwise alignments instead of global ones . indeed , these two sets are characterized by large differences in sequences lengths so it is convenient to allow for gaps at the beginning and the end of pairwise alignments . in this section
we also report the results of ` clustalw ` and ` t - coffee ` for reference .
we refer to @xcite for a full comparison of available methods on balibase .
figure [ fig.balibase ] shows that while our method is less performant than ` clustalw ` and ` t - coffee ` , it still provides reasonable results .
these results should be put in perspective with the level of complexity of the method that is exceptionally low ( only pairwise alignments are needed as input and a simple median path is computed ) . moreover , as it was the case for the simulated alignments , the scores based on the reference pairwise alignments are almost always equal to @xmath175 in all sets for both sp and tc scores .
again , these are not realistic results since the pairwise alignments extracted from the reference multiple alignment might be far from the optimal pairwise alignment between the two sequences for which no extra information on the remaining sequences is available .
nevertheless , these results are encouraging since once again they serve to validate our method from a theoretical point of view in the sense that the median warping approach provides sound results
. finally , let us give an idea of the running times .
we ran both ` mafft ` ( in its version 7 with default values , * ? ? ?
* ) , which is a very fast and widely used tool , and our procedure on the whole ` balibase ` dataset .
on a computer with intel core i7 at frequency 3.5 ghz and 16 go ram ( on only one run ) , we obtained the alignments in 1m23.759s with ` mafft ` and 1m32.932s with our procedure . though our algorithm runs on ` r ` with no optimization of any sort and ` mafft ` was run through a command line ( outside ` r ` environment ) , these running times ( which are not exactly comparable ) are roughly the same , which confirms that our procedure is indeed very fast . in this work
, we propose a proof of concept that a simple method derived from recent techniques of curve synchronization in the context of functional data analysis could be of potential interest to msa .
our method is able to align a large number of sequences in a quite simple and fast manner , although a bit rough w.r.t . accuracy .
while we do not claim to be competitive with actual aligners , we believe that our procedure could be successfully included ( for e.g. as a starting point ) in more refined msa techniques .
while it is out of the scope of the current work to provide such a refined tool , our simulations as well as the use of the balibase dataset establish that the method has good potential , particularly when looking at the almost perfect results obtained by relying on the ( unknown ) reference pairwise alignments ( that is , the pairwise alignments extracted from the msa ) .
in particular , while our experiments rely here on exact scoring alignment with default parameter values , the method could be combined with more refined pairwise alignments , such as probabilistic methods that automatically select optimal scoring parameters for the sequences at stake . while the method implicitly assumes that a star ultra - metric tree describes the evolution of the sequences from their common ancestor ,
it could be improved to gain in robustness w.r.t .
this assumption .
in particular , let us assume that additional to the sequences one has access to a non ultra - metric guide tree describing the common evolution of these sequences . then
, we propose to weight the sequences in a way inversely proportional to their distance to the root .
let @xmath176 denote the evolutionary distance ( i.e. branch length ) from sequence @xmath72 to root and @xmath177 .
we fix @xmath19 and set the weight values to @xmath178 then our method could be generalized to the computation of a weighted median path , namely relying on weighted median values instead of simple ones . in such a way , sequences farther from the ancestor will have a lower weight in the msa .
we leave this for later investigation .
j. d. thompson , d. g. higgins , and t. j. gibson .
: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence alignment through sequence weighting , position - specific gap penalties and weight matrix choice . , 22(22):46734680 , 1994 .
for any pair of sequences @xmath112 , compute their pairwise alignment align(@xmath189 ) .
@xmath190 @xmath191 @xmath192 table of @xmath152 s with @xmath9 rows and @xmath193 columns @xmath194 table of @xmath152 s with @xmath9 rows and @xmath151 columns nbins[@xmath195 \leftarrow \max _ { i=1 , \dots , k } { \text{ins}}[i,\cdot]$ ] @xmath196 nbins[@xmath197 $ ] @xmath198 table with @xmath9 rows and @xmath199 columns filled with gaps symbols insert the homologous positions from table @xmath150 at correct positions in table @xmath92 insert the inserted positions from table @xmath142 at correct positions in table @xmath92 return(t ) | we propose an approach for multiple sequence alignment ( msa ) derived from the dynamic time warping viewpoint and recent techniques of curve synchronization developed in the context of functional data analysis . starting from pairwise alignments of all the sequences ( viewed as paths in a certain space ) ,
we construct a median path that represents the msa we are looking for .
we establish a proof of concept that our method could be an interesting ingredient to include into refined msa techniques .
we present a simple synthetic experiment as well as the study of a benchmark dataset , together with comparisons with 2 widely used msa softwares . \1 .
departamento de estadstica , universidad carlos iii de madrid , c/ madrid , 126 - 28903 getafe , spain .
e - mail : [email protected] + 2 .
sorbonne universits , universit pierre et marie curie , universit paris diderot , centre national de la recherche scientifique , laboratoire de probabilits et modles alatoires , 4 place jussieu , 75252 paris cedex 05 , france .
e - mail : [email protected] _ key words and phrases : alignment ; dynamic time warping ; multiple sequence alignment ; warping _ + |
the motivation for this paper stems from an important , but seemingly forgotten 1982 report by prof .
marshall p. tulin presented during the @xmath0 symposium on naval hydrodynamics , titled _ an exact theory of gravity wave generation by moving bodies , its approximation and its implications _
some thirty years after its publication , tulin wrote of his original motivation for pursuing the former study : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ what were the relations and connections among these various nonlinear approximations
ray , slow ship , " , second order , formal straining , and guilloton that had arisen by the end of the 1970s ? [ ... ] i had earlier in the 1970s become intrigued by the davies transformation of the nonlinear free - surface problem , which was revealed in milne - thompson s legendary banquet speech [ in 1956 ] .
my hope was that my extension of the davies theory would provide an exact result in analytical form , which even in its complexity could then be subject to various approximations , the connections of which could thereby be discerned .
and so it turned out .
_ @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in the 1982 paper , tulin sought to derive a rigorous mathematical reduction of the water wave equations in such a way that certain nonlinear contributions within the free surface equations could be preserved .
the resultant model was analytically simple , and took the form of a single complex - valued linear differential equation .
the theory was also powerful , and provided a formulation that could relate the geometry of a moving body directly with the resultant free - surface waves .
however , several important and surprising issues were raised by tulin regarding the model and its interpretation , and in particular , he had noted a paradoxical behaviour of the model at low speeds . in the years that followed , perhaps owing to the difficulty of the model s derivation , tulin s fundamental questions were never re - addressed . in this paper , we shall present an asymptotically consistent derivation that corrects tulin s model , and puts to rest many of the issues previously highlighted . more specifically
, we shall present an explicit solution written in terms of a single integral that properly describes the form of water waves produced by two - dimensional moving bodies at low speeds .
then , by applying the asymptotic method of steepest descents , we are able to observe how the production of free - surface waves will change depending on the deformation of integration contours connected to the geometry of the moving body .
this approach provides an intuitive and visual procedure for studying wave - body interactions .
the essential derivation behind tulin s model begins from bernoulli s equation applied to a free surface with streamline , @xmath1 , @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the fluid speed , @xmath4 the streamline angle , @xmath5 the potential , and the non - dimensional parameter @xmath6 is the square of the froude number for upstream speed @xmath7 , gravity @xmath8 , and length scale @xmath9 .
if the sinusoidal term is split according to the identity @xmath10 then can be written in complex - valued form @xmath11 where @xmath12 is an analytic function of the complex potential , @xmath13 , and the above is evaluated on @xmath1 where @xmath14 .
the rather curious substitution of is attributed to @xcite , who had argued that if @xmath15 is considered to be small , then yields a linearized version of bernoulli s equation ( in @xmath16 ) that preserves the essential nonlinearity ( in @xmath17 ) describing the structure of steep gravity waves .
inspired by this idea , tulin considered the extension to general free surface flows over a moving body . since the function in the curly braces of is an analytic function in @xmath18 , except at isolated points in the complex plane , then analytic continuation implies @xmath19 where by matching to uniform flow , @xmath20 and thus @xmath21 as @xmath22 .
the function @xmath23 is purely imaginary on @xmath1 . in the case of flow without a body or bottom boundary , @xmath24 , but otherwise , @xmath25 will encode the effect of the obstructions through its singular behaviour in the complex plane .
if the nonlinear contribution , @xmath15 , is neglected in , then the exact solution can be written as @xmath26{\mathrm{e}}^{-\frac{1}{{\epsilon } } \int^w { \mathcal{q}}(s ) \ , { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{s}}.\ ] ] this process seems to yield the exponentially small surface waves at low speeds .
however , tulin noted that as @xmath27 , there would be locations on the free surface where @xmath28 , and this would lead to unbounded steepness .
he wrote of _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the revelation that for sufficiently strong disturbances waves arise at discrete points on the free surface which do not become exponentially small with decreasing froude number , but rather tend to unbounded steepness as @xmath29_. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ he thus proposed the following result : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ [ tulinquote ] _ the most important comment to make
is that for given @xmath30 , no matter how small , this so - called low speed theory is not valid for sufficiently low speeds .
it is a theory valid for low , but not too low speeds ! _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the matter was left at that , and in the three decades following tulin s ingenious paper , the peculiarities surrounding the asymptotic breakdown of were never directly re - addressed ( though we mention the paper by @xcite which develops numerical solutions for the case @xmath31 and @xmath32 ) .
note that in addition to the investigation in the limit @xmath27 , tulin had also intended to produce an _ exact _ reduction , where the @xmath15 term in was handled through a theoretically posited nonlinear coordinate transformation .
however , it is never clear how this transformation is used or derived in practice , except through nonlinear computation of the full solutions . independently from tulin , e.o .
tuck later presented a series of papers @xcite where he attempted to distill the wave - making properties of wave - body problems into a linear singular equation .
the equation presented [ eqn ( 22 ) of @xcite ] was @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the height of the free surface , @xmath35 is a function related to the moving body , and @xmath36 is a integral operator known as the hilbert transform ( to be introduced in [ sec : form ] ) .
the difficulty in solving is that the hilbert transform is a _
global _ operator , requiring values of @xmath37 over the entire domain .
in the @xcite work , tuck explained how the action of @xmath36 could be viewed as similar to that of the differential operator @xmath38 .
this reduction was mostly pedagogic in nature , but tuck was motivated by the fact that @xmath36 and the differential operator will act similarly in the case of sinusoidal functions .
he went on to study the various properties of the singular differential equation @xmath39 that depend on the specification of the ` body ' given by @xmath35 .
apparently , tuck had been unaware of tulin s ( @xcite ) work , but a chance meeting of the two occured during a conference leading to the publication of @xcite .
we are fortunate enough to possess the archived questions of the meeting , where we discover that tulin had asked the following question : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ is nt it true that the two dimensional wavemaker problem can be presented in terms of an ordinary differential equation in the complex domain , at least to some higher order of approximation ? _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ tuck replied that he was unsure of the generality of the reduction to problems including different geometries , but noted the connection to the @xcite reduction : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ i do not know the answer to this question ... my f(x ) " in some way represents a very general family of wavemakers " , with structure in both spatial dimensions , and i have doubts as to whether the problem can then be converted ( exactly ) to a differential equation . on the other hand ,
a few years ago i in fact used the method that you describe , and it is associated with the approximation @xmath40 . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ although tuck s toy reduction should only be regarded as illustrative ( the governing differential equation should rather be first order ) , what is apparent in his work is the desire to systematically reduce both the nonlinearity of bernoulli s equation , and the global effect of @xmath36 into a single ordinary differential equation . in particular , it is tuck s search for a reduction of the operator , @xmath36 , that was missing from earlier works on this topic ( including @xcite ) .
certainly , tulin and tuck were not the only ones to seek simpler reductions or formulations of the nonlinear equations for wave - body interactions , and indeed , tulin relates his work to the integral models proposed by @xcite and @xcite .
reviews of these and other models were presented by @xcite and @xcite , and many others .
however , what distinguishes tulin and tuck s work is the shifted focus towards the analytic continuation of the flow problem into the complex domain ; indeed , tulin notes his strong motivation by the work of @xcite in his @xcite review . as we have noted in [ sec : subtulin ] , the low - froude or low speed limit of @xmath27 is the essential approximation in which analytical results can be derived .
the subtleties of studying this singular limit can be traced back to a seminal report by @xcite , who detailed certain oddities with the previously developed analytical approximations of free surface flow past a submerged body .
chief amongst such oddities was the fact that the individual terms of a series approximation in powers of @xmath30 would fail to predict surface waves .
thus , one might decompose the surface speed into a regular series expansion and an error term , @xmath41 , with @xmath42 + { \bar{q}}.\ ] ] the challenge , ogilvie realized , was that water waves were exponentially small in @xmath30 , with @xmath43 , and thus _ beyond - all - orders _ of any individual term of the regular series .
by linearizing about the zeroth order solution , @xmath44 for @xmath45 , and strategically perserving certain terms in bernoulli s equation , ogilvie developed a general analytical approximation for the exponentially small surface waves .
the approximation , however , was not asymptotically consistent , and the search for a complete numerical and analytical treatment of the low froude limit would inspire many papers in the subsequent years .
one of the key issues we will explore in this paper addresses the question of how many terms must be included in the linearization of in order to obtain the exponential .
originally @xcite had chosen @xmath46 , but later revised to @xmath47 in @xcite ( who quoted the work of @xcite and in particular , the study by @xcite in applying the wkb method to streamline ship waves ) .
cm _ historical significance _ & & _ papers _ + origin of the low - froude paradox & & @xcite + two - dimensional and three - dimensional linearizations & & @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite + on numerical solutions & & @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite + on exponential asymptotics applied to water waves & & @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite + review articles & & @xcite , @xcite + we shall not pursue , in great detail , the history of the low froude problem that followed ogilvie s seminal report , but instead refer to the review papers by @xcite and , particularly , @xcite where certain aspects of the low froude difficulty are discussed .
additional historical details are presented in 1 of @xcite , and a selection of papers on the problem is presented in table [ tab : res ] .
the method we apply in this paper , which combines an approach of series truncation with the method of steepest descents , is unique from the previously listed works .
we have three principal goals in this work . _
( i ) we wish to demonstrate how tulin s formulation can be systematically derived and studied in the low speed limit . _ the source of tulin s puzzling results can be resolved through better understanding of two effects : first , the _ ad - hoc _ linearization of the nonlinear @xmath15 function ; and second , the role of the forcing function , @xmath23 .
we clarify these details and demonstrate , through numerical solutions of the full nonlinear water wave equations , the convergence of different proposed models in the limit @xmath27 .
let @xmath41 be the fluid speed corresponding to the water waves , as in .
one of our principal results ( presented on p. ) is to demonstrate that the exponentially small waves , @xmath48 , are described to leading order by the first - order equation , @xmath49{\bar{q}}= r(w ; { \hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[{\bar{\theta}}]),\ ] ] where @xmath50 and @xmath48 is then given by the sum of @xmath41 and its complex conjugate .
different choices of the series truncation @xmath51 yield different versions of the right - hand side of , but only change the predicted wave amplitudes by a numerical factor .
the leading order @xmath52 contains the prescription of the moving body , and can thus be related to tuck s @xmath53 function in . the formulation in terms of the speed , @xmath3 , rather than tulin s combined function @xmath54 in is more natural , but we will relate tulin s equation to our own in [ sec : tulinconnect ] and appendix [ sec : tulinconnect2 ] . _ ( ii ) we also study the associated integral form of the solution using the method of steepest descents .
_ we shall demonstrate how the appearance of surface waves can be associated with sudden deformations of the integration contours if the solution to is analytically continued across critical curves ( stokes lines ) in the complex plane .
this process is known as the stokes phenomenon @xcite .
the novelty of this steepest descents methodology is that it will allow us to not only relate the surface waves directly to the geometry of the moving body , but it will also allow us to observe how integration contours change depending on the geometry of the obstruction .
in particular , we conclude that provided there exists a solution of the full potential flow problem , there are no issues with the approximations as @xmath27 limit . _
( iii ) our last goal is to provide a link between the tulin approximation , our corrected model , and also the current research on low - froude approximations . _
let us now turn to a brief summary of the history of the low froude problem .
let us consider steady irrotational two - dimensional flow past a moving body in the presence of gravity , @xmath8 .
the body is associated with a length scale @xmath9 , and moves at constant velocity @xmath7 .
for instance , this body may correspond to an obstacle at the bottom of the channel ( fig .
[ formstepcyl ] , left ) , a submerged object ( fig .
[ formstepcyl ] , right ) , or a surface - piercing ship ( fig .
[ formship ] , left ) .
we shall state more precise geometrical restrictions in [ sec : bdint ] . .
flows past closed bluff objects can be complicated through wake separation ( seen right ) , for which the nature of the separation points is unclear .
[ formstepcyl],scaledwidth=100.0% ] the velocity potential , @xmath5 , satisfies laplace s equation in the fluid region , @xmath55 . on all boundaries
, the kinematic condition implies the normal derivative is zero , @xmath56 , while on the free surface , bernoulli s equation requires that @xmath57 subsequently , all quantities are non - dimensionalized using the velocity and lengths scales , @xmath7 and @xmath9 , and we introduce a cartesian coordinate system @xmath58 such that the body is fixed in the moving frame of reference . with @xmath59 , we define the complex potential , @xmath13 , and the complex velocity is given by , @xmath60 here @xmath61 is the stream function , @xmath3 is the fluid speed , and @xmath4 is the streamline angle , measured from the positive @xmath62-axis . without loss of generality , we choose @xmath1 on the free surface and @xmath63 within the fluid .
we define the logarithmic hodograph variable , @xmath64 and seek to solve the flow problem inversely , that is , use @xmath18 as an independent variable and seek @xmath65 in the lower - half @xmath18-plane .
the advantage of this hodograph formulation is that with the free surface at @xmath1 , its position is known in the @xmath66-plane , even though its shape in the physical @xmath58-plane is unknown .
differentiating bernoulli s equation with respect to @xmath5 and using then yields the non - dimensionalized form . in theory , the methods we present in this paper will apply to most general two - dimensional free - surface flows . in practice , however , in order to make analytical progress , we will be constrained by problems in which the geometry of the body is known through the specification of the angle , @xmath4 , in terms of the complex potential , @xmath13 .
as specific examples , let us focus on two representative geometries : ( a ) flow past a localized obstruction on a channel bottom ( fig . [ formstepcyl ] , left ) , and ( b ) flow past a semi - infinite surface piercing ship ( fig .
[ formship ] , left ) .
for flow past a varying channel bottom with dimensional upstream depth @xmath67 , we select the length scale @xmath68 , so that the flow region in the @xmath18-plane consists of an infinite strip between @xmath69 . the strip
is then mapped to the upper - half @xmath70-plane , using @xmath71 where under , the free surface is mapped to @xmath72 , the channel bottom to @xmath73 , and the flow region to @xmath74 . for flows past a semi - infinite surface piercing body , we can choose the length scale to be @xmath75 , where @xmath76 is a representative scale of the potential along the body ( see ( 2.3 ) in @xcite for further details ) .
we assume that the free surface attaches to the body at a stagnation point , chosen without loss of generality to be @xmath77 . in the potential plane ,
the flow region consists of @xmath78 . on the boundary @xmath1
, @xmath79 corresponds to the free surface and @xmath80 to the solid body .
since the flow is already contained within a half - plane , we do not need a further @xmath81 transformation , but we shall set @xmath82 so as to use the same notation .
bernoulli s equation provides an explicit relationship between the real and imaginary parts of @xmath83 on the free surface .
however , because @xmath83 is analytic in the upper or lower - half @xmath70-plane and tends to zero far upstream , there is a further hilbert - transform relationship between its real and imaginary parts . applying cauchy s theorem to @xmath83 over a large semi - circle in the upper ( channel flow ) or lower ( surface - piercing flow ) half - planes , and taking the real part gives the principal value integral , @xmath84 where @xmath85 for flow in the channel configuration and @xmath86 for flow in the ship configuration .
the range of integration can be split into an evaluation over the solid boundary and over the free surface .
we write @xmath87(\xi ) \quad \text{for $ \xi \in\mathbb{r}$},\ ] ] where @xmath36 denotes the hilbert transform operator on the semi - infinite interval , @xmath88(\xi ) = \frac{1}{\pi } \dashint_{0}^{\infty } \frac{\theta(\xi')}{\xi ' - \xi } \ { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{\xi'}.\ ] ] we assume that for a given physical problem , the angle @xmath4 is known for the particular geometry , and thus the function @xmath89 that appears in is known through calculating @xmath90 note that it is somewhat misleading to describe @xmath91 as known " for @xmath92 since in practice , we would specify @xmath4 as a function of the physical coordinates @xmath58 .
however , specifying different forms of @xmath4 as a function of @xmath93 ( or the potential , @xmath5 ) is typically sufficient to obtain the qualitatively desired geometry shape .
for instance , we consider the step geometry , @xmath94 where @xmath95 , which corresponds to a step of angle @xmath96 .
such topographies have been considered by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , others . in this case , and yields @xmath97 similarly , a semi - infinite ship with a single corner of angle @xmath98 can be specified using @xmath99 such two - dimensional hull shapes have been considered in the works of @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and others .
choosing the dimensional length , @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the value of the potential at the corner sets its non - dimensional position to @xmath100 .
then using , the @xmath89 function is given by @xmath101 where recall the ship problem does not require an additional mapping to the half plane , so we can set @xmath82 to preserve the notation . in this paper , we will only consider geometries , as specified through @xmath89 in , which contain strong singularities in the complex plane that is , poles or branch points .
for instance , the step and ship contain singularities at solid corners and stagnation points .
we will see in [ sec : steep ] that these singularities are often responsible for the creation of the surface waves .
weaker singularities , such as for the case of flow past a smoothed hull with a discontinuity in the curvature will be the subject of a forthcoming paper ( see also 7 of @xcite ) .
flows past closed objects also present challenging cases for study because typically , the geometry is not known as a function of the potential variables , and there are further difficulties with the prediction of wake separation points .
for instance , potential flow over a circular cylinder ( fig .
[ formstepcyl ] , right ) was computed without a free surface by @xcite where it was shown that the properties of the separation points will vary depending on the froude number . in theory , the methodology discussed in this paper can be applied to these challenging flows , but may require hybrid numerical - asymptotic treatments .
we shall return to discuss such cases in [ sec : discuss ] .
in this section , we demonstrate that the regular expansion of the solution of bernoulli s equation and the boundary integral is divergent , and moreover fails to capture the free surface waves . in the limit @xmath27 , we substitute a regular asymptotic expansion , @xmath102 and @xmath103 into the two governing equations , and obtain for the first two orders , [ asym01 ] @xmath104 , & \qquad \theta_1 & = -q_0 ^ 2 { \frac{\deq_0}{{\operatorname{d\!}{}}\phi}}. \label{asym1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , at leading order , the free surface is entirely flat , @xmath105 , and this solution
is known as the rigid wall solution . the leading - order speed , @xmath106 , is given by for the step , or for the ship , but fails to capture the surface waves . because all the subsequent orders in the asymptotic scheme depend on derivatives of the leading - order solution , it stands to reason that it is impossible to encounter a sinusoidal term , despite going to any algebraic order in @xmath30 .
using the numerical algorithms outlined @xcite , we calculate the numerical solutions of and for the case of a rectangular ship , with @xmath107 and at @xmath108 in fig .
[ fig : profilestern ] .
indeed , it is seen that the leading - order asymptotic approximation fails to capture the wave - like behaviour , but provides a good fit to the mean speed .
more details of these numerical solutions will be discussed in
[ sec : numerics ] .
the leading - order approximation , @xmath52 , contains singularities in the analytic continuation of @xmath5 off the free surface , and into the complex plane , @xmath109 .
for instance , in the case of the step geometry , we see that @xmath52 contains branch points at @xmath110 and @xmath111 , which correspond to the corner and stagnation points .
because of the singularly perturbed nature of bernoulli s equation in the limit @xmath27 , we can see that at each order in the asymptotic procedure , the calculation of @xmath112 and @xmath113 will depend on differentiation of the previous order , @xmath114 and @xmath115 . since the leading - order approximation is singular , this has the effect of increasing the power of the singularities with each subsequent term in the approximation .
thus in the limit that @xmath116 , @xmath112 and @xmath113 will diverge . as argued in the work of _ e.g. _
@xcite , the divergence at @xmath117 is captured through a factorial over power ansatz , @xmath118 where @xmath119 at the particular singularity .
if there are multiple singularities contributing to the divergence ( see @xcite for an example ) , then we must include a summation over similar ansatzes of the form where @xmath119 at each individual singularity .
there exist other cases where a more general form of the divergence is required , and this is documented in @xcite . in order to derive the components , @xmath120 , @xmath121 , and @xmath122
, we can examine the @xmath123 form of the system , and take the limit @xmath116 . in this paper , the late - orders behaviour is not a crucial part of the analysis , but we collect the functional forms of the components in appendix [ sec : divergence ] .
in [ sec : reduce ] and [ sec : steep ] , we will demonstrate that the leading - order water waves can be described by an integral equation , which can then be approximated by deforming the path of integration into the complex plane
. thus it will be necessary for us to study the analytic continuation of the free surface quantities , @xmath124 and @xmath125 into the complex @xmath93-plane ( or analogously , the complex @xmath5-plane ) .
let us seek the complexified versions of bernoulli s equation and the boundary integral .
we set @xmath126 . for analytic continuation into the upper half - plane
, we can verify that in the limit @xmath127 from the upper half - plane , @xmath128 where the second integral on the right hand - side corresponds to the counterclockwise integral around @xmath129 along a small semi - circle .
an analogous argument applies for analytic continuation into the lower half - plane .
writing @xmath130 , we have that the analytic continuation of the hilbert transform , @xmath36 , is given by @xmath131(\zeta ) = { \hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[\theta](\zeta ) - { \mathrm{i}}{\mathrm{k}}\theta(\zeta),\ ] ] where @xmath132 for analytic continuation into the upper half - plane , @xmath133 for the continuation into the lower half - plane , and we have introduced the notation @xmath134 for the integral @xmath135(\zeta ) = \frac{1}{\pi } \int_{0}^{\infty } \frac{\theta(\xi')}{\xi ' - \zeta } \ { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{\xi'}.\ ] ] thus , the analytic continuation of the boundary integral equation is given by @xmath136\ ] ] there is a somewhat subtle aspect of analytically continuing @xmath3 and @xmath4 off the free surface , and the relationship of these quantities with the physical complex velocity given by @xmath137 .
the two quantities on the left hand - side of are complex - valued , but reduce to the physical speed and velocities on the free surface , @xmath138 .
although their _ combined _ values are related to the complex velocity , @xmath139 , their individual values are not known without further work . as an example of this particular subtlety
, we may consider the analytic continuation of @xmath4 , evaluated along the physical boundary , @xmath140 .
in general , this value will not be the physical angle as defined in or .
instead , the analytic continuations of the individual components , @xmath3 and @xmath4 , are related to the physical angle through @xmath141 . in the bulk of this paper , we will focus on the analytic continuation into the upper half - plane , and thus set @xmath142 .
since @xmath3 and @xmath4 are real on the axis , then their values in the lower half - plane follows from schwarz s reflection principal ( see [ sec : hankel ] ) .
then the two analytically continued governing equations are given by @xmath143 .
\label{bdint_anal } \end{gathered}\ ] ] it is possible to combine the two equations into a single complex - valued integro - differential equation .
we write write the sine term in terms of complex exponentials using , giving @xmath144 } - \left(\frac{q}{q_s}\right)^j { \mathrm{e}}^{-{\hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[\theta]}\right].\ ] ] we then simplify using @xmath50 , and substitute into bernoulli s equation to obtain the combined integro - differential formulation .
we seek to study the analytically continued equations for the speed , @xmath3 , and angle @xmath4 , off the free surface and into the upper half-@xmath70-plane .
the combined integro - differential formulation is @xmath145 } - q_s^2 { \mathrm{e}}^{{\mathrm{j}}{\hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[\theta ] } \biggr ] = 0.\ ] ] which forms two equations ( real and imaginary parts ) for the two unknowns @xmath3 and @xmath4 . in , @xmath89
is contains the problem geometry as defined by and , the analytically continued hilbert transform , @xmath134 , is defined in , and we have defined the constants @xmath146 for the channel geometry , we use the conformal map from the potential strip to the @xmath70-plane given by @xmath147 , while for the surface - piercing geometry , @xmath82 . note that in all subsequent formulae , we will sometimes use @xmath70 and @xmath18 interchangeably in the functional notation , _
e.g. _ writing @xmath148 or @xmath149 depending on the particular context . in general ,
primes ( @xmath150 ) will be used solely for differentiation in @xmath18 .
the reader will notice that we have somewhat strayed from our original motivation of studying tulin s formulation presented in
[ sec : subtulin ] , where the governing equations are posed in terms of a combined analytic quantity , @xmath151 , in .
tulin s formulation can be adjusted to use the substitution @xmath152 , where @xmath50 as in , which modifies the analytically continued bernoulli s equation to @xmath153 for function , @xmath15 with @xmath154 , which had resulted from the sine reduction , and for some @xmath25 that has yet to be specified .
the adjustment of including @xmath50 serves to orient the fluid with respect to the solid boundary , and facilitates comparison with our .
we highlight two main differences between our and tulin s formulation .
first , in ours , we have chosen to work with analytic continuations of @xmath3 and @xmath4 independently , whereas tulin has combined @xmath152 , so as to advantageously write the left hand - side of in an elegant form .
however , note the nonlinear term , @xmath15 , can not be easily written as a function of @xmath16 , and this nonlinear term will be important in the analysis to come . it is unclear whether it is possible to provide a complete formulation without independentally treating @xmath3 and @xmath4 , as we have done in our .
the second main difference is that is self - contained and thus readily solved numerically or asymptotically , whereas the @xmath25-function in is unknown . like the introduction of @xmath16 , while the introduction of the @xmath25-function is elegant in appearance , its connection to the low - froude asymptotics is difficult to elucidate .
we have included a discussion of tulin s original interpretation of the @xmath25-function in appendix [ sec : qfunc ] . to summarize the conclusions of the discussion : the @xmath25-function can be written as a boundary integral evaluated over the solid boundary and its reflected image in the potential or @xmath70-plane .
however , this resultant quantity can not be known without first solving the free - surface problem and .
thus , @xmath25 should rather be written @xmath155 and it becomes difficult to unravel components of @xmath25 that are crucial to the determination of the free - surface waves .
our formulation sidesteps this by explicitly including the local and global aspects of the problem in form that can be computed numerically and asymptotically .
once we have understood how is reduced in the @xmath27 , it will be possible to demonstrate more clearly how tulin s formulation relates .
we will do this in appendix [ sec : tulinconnect2 ] .
the study of the nonlinear integro - differential equation is primarily complicated because of the nonlocal nature of the hilbert transform @xmath134 . in [ sec : introtuck ] , we had reviewed the efforts of e.o .
tuck , who attempted to convert @xmath134 into a local operator . in this section and the next , we shall demonstrate that , while the hilbert transform is crucial for determining the corrections to the rigid - body solution ( _ c.f . _ the dotted curve in figs . [
fig : profilestern ] ) , the waves can be derived largely independently from @xmath134 .
we first introduce the truncated regular expansion [ qthetasub ] @xmath156 where @xmath157 and @xmath158 are seen to be waveless that is to say , they do not possess any oscillatory component .
the oscillatory components will be introduced via a linearization of the solution about the regular expansion .
we set , @xmath159 where we assume @xmath160 .
our strategy is to substitute into the integro - differential equation , and then separate the terms proportional to @xmath41 onto the left hand - side .
simplification then leads to the main result of this paper .
[ result : integro ] linearizing the water wave equations about a regular series expansion truncated at @xmath51 terms gives the following integro - differential equation for the perturbation , [ simpsys ] @xmath161{\bar{q}}= r(w ; { \hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[{\bar{\theta } } ] ) + { \mathcal{o}}({\bar{\theta}}^2 , { \bar{q}}^2).\ ] ] where @xmath162 ) = -{\mathcal{e}_\mathrm{bern}}+ { \mathrm{i}}{\hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[{\bar{\theta}}]\frac{\cos\theta_r}{q_r^2}. \label{rfunc}\end{gathered}\ ] ] and @xmath52 and @xmath163 are given in and , and the error term , @xmath164 , represents the error in bernoulli s equation , and is given by @xmath165 note that the function @xmath121 that appears in is precisely the same as the singulant function that describes the factorial - over - power divergence and whose value is found in appendix [ sec : divergence ] through the study of the regular asymptotic expansion of the solutions .
similarly , in the next section , @xmath166 will be related to @xmath120 , which appears in .
we will use the notation of @xmath167 and @xmath168)$ ] interchangeably , preferring the latter when we wish to emphasize that @xmath169 depends on the inclusion of the hilbert transform .
notice also that the system will undergo significant changes in its written form as soon as @xmath13 or @xmath170 approaches the free surface ( either @xmath171 or @xmath172 ) .
when this occurs , the integral @xmath173 $ ] must be written as a principal value and residue contribution , as in .
in other words , though it is written in a complex - valued form , will necessarily reduce to a real - valued equation along the free surface . the crucial decision in studying
the system is to choose how many terms to include in the truncated series , @xmath157 and @xmath158 , which determines the forcing function @xmath169 .
that is , we must choose the truncation value of @xmath51 . in early studies of the low - froude problem ,
researchers had used @xmath46 , and then later corrected to @xmath47 . however , at a fixed value of @xmath30 , the truncation error in the divergent asymptotic expansion will continue to decrease for increasing values of @xmath51 .
it reaches a minimum at an optimal truncation point , @xmath174 , and diverges afterwards . for small @xmath30 ,
the optimal truncation point is found where adjacent terms in the series are approximately equal in size , or @xmath175 . using the divergent form , we find that the optimal truncation point is given by @xmath176 thus , for a fixed point in the domain , @xmath18 , and in the limit @xmath27 , the optimal truncation point , @xmath177 , tends to infinity , and we must include infinitely many terms of the series . in [ sec : numerics ] , we will examine the effect of different truncations on the comparison between numerical solutions and asymptotic approximations .
most emphatically , we remark that apart from the hidden @xmath178 terms multiplying @xmath41 in the brackets of , this reduced equation is an exact result to all orders in @xmath30 .
we have only employed the fact @xmath179 , but the inhomogeneous term , @xmath167 is exact .
when the regular series expansions are optimally truncated , @xmath41 and @xmath180 are exponentially small , and consequently , the @xmath181 will not be needed to derive the leading - order behaviour of the exponentials . though it is now written as a first - order differential equation , the system is difficult to solve , since it involves real and complex components , in addition to the integral transforms embedded in the inhomogeneous term .
the key in the following sections will be to argue that the hilbert transform can be neglected .
the main goal in this section is to demonstrate how the reduced integro - differential equation can be written as an explicit integral , which is then approximated using the method of steepest descents ( for details of this method , see for example @xcite ) .
it is , in fact , this steepest descents analysis that rectifies the unanswered issues from tulin s work . in this paper
, we will present the main ideas of a steepest descents analysis applied to the integral solution of . in practice
, the individualized steepest descent paths must be studied for each different moving body ( as specified by the @xmath89 function in ) . in a companion paper @xcite
, we will derive the full steepest descents structure for the case of flow over a step and past the stern of a ship .
this individualized study requires careful consideration of the branch structures and numerically generated contours of the integrand , so we relegate the details to the companion study . to begin , we integrate to obtain @xmath182 in the above integral , the initial point of integration , @xmath183 , is chosen to be the particular point that causes the divergence of the late - order terms .
thus , the @xmath121 defined in matches the definition of the singulant function in the late - orders ansatz . next integrating , @xmath184 - 3{\mathrm{i}}{\mathrm{j}}\int_{w^*}^w \frac{q_1(\varphi)}{q_0 ^ 4(\varphi ) } \ , { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{\varphi},\ ] ] where @xmath185 is the constant of integration , and @xmath186 can be chosen wherever the integral is defined .
we also note that @xmath166 , given by , is related to @xmath120 given in .
thus we can write @xmath187 \exp \left ( 3{\mathrm{i}}j k \int_{w^*}^w \frac{q_1(\varphi)}{q_0 ^ 4(\varphi ) } \ , { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{\varphi}\right).\ ] ] solving now yields a solution for the integro - differential equation ( though note that it is not quite explicit due to the reliance on the hilbert transform ) , [ finalint ] @xmath188\biggl\ { i(w ) + \text{const . } \biggr\ } \times { \mathrm{e}}^{-\chi(w)/{\epsilon}}\ ] ] where we have introduced the integral @xmath189 ) \left [ \frac{1}{q(\varphi ) } + { \mathcal{o}}({\epsilon})\right ] \ , { \mathrm{e}}^{\chi(\varphi)/{\epsilon}}\ , { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{\varphi}.\ ] ] which will be used to extract the pre - factor of the exponential .
the start point , @xmath190 , can be conveniently chosen based on any additional boundary or radiation conditions . for channel flow ,
the water wave problem will naturally impose a radiation condition which requires the free surface to be flat at @xmath191 ( upstream ) , so taking @xmath192 , the constant of integration in is zero .
similarly , for the surface - piercing problem , @xmath190 can be taken to be the stagnation point attachment , @xmath193 , where @xmath194 .
for the integral , the paths of steepest descent are given by constant contours of @xmath195 .
let us envision a generic situation in which the steepest descent topology is as shown in the fig .
[ fig : steepest ] .
the valleys , where @xmath196 \geq { \operatorname{re}}[\chi(w_0)]$ ] , are shown shaded . in the illustrated case , the path of steepest descent from the initial , @xmath197 , and final point , @xmath198 ,
is joined by a single valley of the integrand .
thus , we write @xmath199 and the relevant contributions to the integral solely depend upon an expansion about the endpoints . when we perform this analytically in [ sec : endpoint ] , we will find that the @xmath200 contribution will yield further algebraic orders of the base asymptotic series , @xmath157 and @xmath158 .
in other words , contributions lead to further deflections of the free surface due to the moving body , but do not produce an oscillatory component . .
( a ) when the endpoint of integration lies to the left of the stokes line , @xmath201 ; ( b ) when the end of integration crosses the stokes line , the steepest descent path must include the contribution from the saddle .
[ fig : steepest],scaledwidth=100.0% ] in the free - surface problems we consider , the oscillatory contributions arise from the deformation of the path of integration through any critical points ( branch points , singularities , or saddle points ) of the integrand or exponential .
a typical situation is illustrated in fig . [
fig : steepest](right ) .
there , we see that if the endpoint , @xmath198 , crosses the stokes line , @xmath202 = { \operatorname{im}}[\chi(w_0)]$ ] from the point , @xmath203 , then the steepest descent paths from each individual endpoint tends to distinct valleys that must be joined by a contour through the saddle . in such cases
, we shall write @xmath204 in this work , we shall not discuss the global properties of the steepest descent curves and and the associated stokes lines .
these results require careful consideration of the riemann - sheet structure of the integrand , and can be found in the accompanying work @xcite . instead
, we will assume that the integral is approximated by , and verify the approximation for the case of the far - field waves , @xmath205 , in
[ sec : numerics ] .
it can be verified that the dominant contributions from the endpoints will re - expand the regular perturbation series to higher orders .
in particular , we see from inspection that locally near @xmath198 , the integrand is exponentially large and of order @xmath206 , and this serves to cancel the exponentially small factor in .
the form of the integral in is unwieldy , so we shall demonstrate this re - expansion for the simplest case where the regular series , @xmath157 and @xmath158 , contains only a single term . setting @xmath207 and @xmath208 from , the integral
is reduced to @xmath209 } { q_0 ^ 2 } \biggr ] \left [ \frac{1}{q(\varphi ) } + { \mathcal{o}}({\epsilon})\right ] \ , { \mathrm{e}}^{\chi(\varphi)/{\epsilon } } \ , { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{\varphi}.\ ] ] integrating by parts , we have @xmath210 } { q_0 ^ 2 } \biggr ] \left [ \frac{1}{q(w ) } + { \mathcal{o}}({\epsilon})\right ] \ , { \mathrm{e}}^{\chi(w)/{\epsilon } } \\ - { \epsilon}\int_{w_s}^w \frac{1}{\chi ' } { \frac{{\operatorname{d\!}{}}}{{\operatorname{d\!}{}}\varphi } } \left\{\biggl [ -{\epsilon}q_0 ' + \frac{{\mathrm{i}}{\hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[{\bar{\theta } } ] } { q_0 ^ 2 } \biggr ] \left [ \frac{1}{q(\varphi ) } + { \mathcal{o}}({\epsilon})\right ] \right\ } \ , { \mathrm{e}}^{\chi(\varphi)/{\epsilon } } \ , { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{\varphi},\end{gathered}\ ] ] where we have assumed that the boundary term contributions due to @xmath211 are zero from the boundary or radiation conditions ( see the discussion following ) .
repeated integration by parts to the integral term will extract further contributions .
we keep only the first term above , and re - combine with @xmath41 in to obtain @xmath212}{q_0 ^ 2 } - \frac{{\bar{\theta}}}{q_0 ^ 2}\biggr].\ ] ] where we have used and . matching real and complex parts
then yields @xmath213 $ ] and @xmath214 , which are the first correction terms derived in .
the procedure to obtain further corrections proceeds in a similar way using repeated integration by parts , and thus producing further powers of @xmath30 . including more terms from @xmath157 and @xmath158 and performing the re - expansion procedure about the endpoints will follow the same idea ; algebraically , however , it is much easier to work with the integro - differential equation , or simply with the original system of two coupled equations , as was done in
[ sec : baseasym ] . in the limit @xmath27 ,
the contributions to the contour integral associated with wave motion arises from cases where the contour is deformed past critical points in the integrand , or near saddle points , where @xmath215 .
let us assume that the contribution occurs at a point , @xmath216 , where @xmath217 .
we furthermore assume that @xmath183 lies off the free surface ( see [ sec : tulinlowspeed ] for comments on other cases ) . locally near this point
, we assume that the leading - order speed behaves as @xmath218 for some constants @xmath219 and @xmath220 , and consequently , it follows from that @xmath221 one of the key issues that underlies the tulin reduction of the water - wave equations concerns the role of the non - local hilbert transform , @xmath134 , which appears in the forcing function @xmath168)$ ] in . in the previous section
, we discovered that the hilbert transform plays an important role in the further development of the endpoint contributions .
indeed , it appears as a contributing term in each order of the asymptotic process , beginning from @xmath163 in . upon applying the method of steepest descents to the integral @xmath222
, we had separated the contributions into those due to endpoints and those due to saddle points ( assumed to lie away from the free surface ) .
let us assume that the contribution due to the saddle point is exponentially small along the free surface , so that @xmath223 in , with @xmath224 on the free surface , and similar relations for @xmath180
. then @xmath225 is at most algebraically large in @xmath30 and near the singularity , @xmath203 , and the term @xmath226
\frac{\cos \theta_r}{q_r^2}\ ] ] involves the integration of an exponentially small term along the free surface , where it remains exponentially small .
thus , this term is subdominant to the square - bracketed contributions in .
further , note that this argument does not work for the endpoint contributions , as the hilbert transform within @xmath227 is _ not _ negligible , as it involves the integration of the regular perturbative series via @xmath228 $ ] .
let us first consider the case of truncation at large @xmath51 . as discussed in
[ sec : truncation ] , it is expected that as @xmath27 , the optimal truncation point , @xmath229 . thus using the divergent form , we have that away from the real axis , @xmath230 where recall that the components , @xmath120 , @xmath122 , and @xmath121 are given in appendix [ sec : divergence ] .
thus substituting into , we have @xmath231 { \mathrm{e}}^{\chi/{\epsilon } } \ , { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{\varphi}.\ ] ] in , the contour @xmath232 corresponds to the steepest descents contour in the vicinity of the critical point , @xmath233 .
near this point , we simplify the exponential by making a coordinate transformation with @xmath234 from . using , we see that @xmath235 , and then @xmath236 we claim from the steepest descent topographies that for the ship and step problems , the relevant local contribution near @xmath233 occurs in the form of a hankel contour that is , an integral about the branch cut @xmath237 , beginning from @xmath238 , looping around the origin , and tending to @xmath239 .
these steepest descent topographies are the subject of the companion paper @xcite . by the integral definition of the gamma function ,
@xmath240 therefore , combining with , we have @xmath241 .
we may now substitute this approximation for @xmath242 into to obtain the part of @xmath41 that is switched - on by the saddle point contribution .
this yields @xmath243 { \mathrm{e}}^{-\chi(w)/{\epsilon}},\ ] ] where @xmath244 is given in . however , we recall that the functional form of integrand in changes in the limit the real axis is approached , due to the presence of the complex hilbert transform in @xmath245
. moreover , the derivation of takes account the steepest descent paths only for analytic continuation into either the upper - half @xmath18-plane ( @xmath132 ) or lower - half @xmath18-plane ( @xmath133 ) . repeating
the process for the opposite portion of the plane reflects the steepest descent paths about the real axis . rather than repeating the procedure and observing the change in signs of @xmath246
, we can note that wave component of @xmath3 or @xmath4 must be real along the physical free surface . consequently
, by the schwarz reflection principle , the leading - order wave solution must be the sum of and its complex conjugate .
thus on the free surface , where @xmath247 , @xmath248 { \mathrm{e}}^{-\chi(\phi)/{\epsilon } } + \textrm{complex conjugate.}\ ] ] note that in numerical computations , it is typically easiest to compare the wave amplitudes in the far field , where @xmath249 , and the speed , @xmath250 .
substituting into and simplifying gives the amplitude of the oscillations , @xmath251 { \mathrm{e}}^{-{\operatorname{re}}(\chi)/{\epsilon } } , \quad \text{as $ \phi \to \infty$},\ ] ] where the constant @xmath252 appears in the expression for @xmath120 and its value must be computed numerically for general nonlinear problems ( see appendix [ sec : divergence ] ) .
although the above formula seems to depend on the integral limit @xmath186 ( assumed to be chosen anywhere the integral is defined ) , this is in fact compensated by the calculation of @xmath252 . in the end , provides a closed - form formula for the amplitude of the waves , which only depends on specification of the two solutions , @xmath52 and @xmath163 , calculated from , and late - order components , @xmath252 , @xmath122 , and @xmath121 , given in appendix [ sec : divergence ] .
we will provide a numerical example of shortly . finally , we can establish an equation between the the exponentially small waves in @xmath3 and @xmath4 . from , upon substituting
, we have the connection , @xmath253{q_\mathrm{exp}},\ ] ] which allows the amplitude of the waves to be calculated , both in @xmath3 , as given by , and in @xmath4 .
in the last two sections , we derived a reduced model for the wave - body interaction , and subsequently explained how asymptotic approximations for both the wavefree surface deflection ( the regular series @xmath157 ) and the waves ( the exponentially small @xmath254 ) could be developed using the method of steepest descents . now
the question of how this model relates to both the @xcite and the @xcite , along with the other possible simplifications discussed in [ sec : otherworks ] , will depend on how we decide to truncate the model in .
the result of the hankel integration , in , which depends on the late - terms behaviour of the ansatz , was derived on the assumption that truncation of the regular series expansion occurs at optimal truncation with @xmath255 as @xmath27 . in practice , however , it may be useful to develop reduced models that truncate at pragmatic values of @xmath51 ( _ i.e. _ one or two ) ; let us discuss what loss in accuracy results from this .
as we have shown , the surface speed is expressed as @xmath256 + \bigl[\mathcal{a } f(\phi ) { \mathrm{e}}^{-\chi(\phi)/{\epsilon } } + \text{c.c.}\bigr],\ ] ] where we have expressed the exponential in a form so as to separate a numerical prefactor , @xmath257 , from the functional dependence , @xmath258 .
the case of truncation at @xmath46 is asymptotically inconsistent since if @xmath44 , then @xmath41 contains both an @xmath259 error and also the exponentially small waves we desire .
thus from and , we see that it would not be correct to ignore @xmath260 errors in deriving the linearized equation . despite these issues , however , it is still instructive to examine the truncation at @xmath261 , which yields @xmath262 and thus the solution @xmath263{\mathrm{e}}^{-\chi/{\epsilon}},\ ] ] for a start point , @xmath197 , where @xmath264 .
we then see that the exponential argument , @xmath265 , of the solution could be derived from , and indeed the steepest descent paths of [ sec : steep ] are still applicable , but we have inaccurately predicted the functional dependence , @xmath258 ( captured by the missing @xmath266 term on the left hand - side ) , and will also fail to predict the prefactor , @xmath257 ( captured by the correct right hand - side ) .
the case of truncation at @xmath47 is much more interesting .
it yields @xmath267{\bar{q}}\sim { \epsilon}^2 \left(-\frac{5{\mathrm{i}}{\mathrm{j}}q_1 ^ 2}{2 q_0 ^ 4 } + q_1 ' + 2{\mathrm{i}}\frac{{\hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[\theta_1]q_1}{q_0 ^ 3}\right).\ ] ] thus , comparing to , we have obtained the precise left hand - side required . in developing the leading - order exponential ,
the only error in is due to the replacement of the right hand - side by its @xmath47 truncation .
this only affects the integrand of , whose role was to determine the pre - factor @xmath257 . in other words ,
the linear equation allows us to develop _ nearly all _ of the leading - order exponential .
we will see in the numerical computations that this equation provides a very close fit to results from the full nonlinear model .
the two - term truncation is the closest analogy to the @xcite model ( see [ sec : discuss ] for an extended discussion ) , as well as various other models ( _ c.f . _
the review by @xcite ) .
however the fact that such two - term approximations do not accurately predict the pre - factor @xmath257 is not well established in the literature .
an even simpler formulation to can be developed at the risk of slightly increased inaccuracy .
however , this form serves as an extremely useful toy model due to the complete removal of the hilbert transform in this sense , it is the strongest analogy to the tuck reduction of . let us return to combined integro - differential equation in . approximating @xmath268 } \sim 1 $ ] , we obtain @xmath269 = 0.\ ] ] in order to avoid confusion , we shall write the solution of as @xmath270 . expressing @xmath270 as a regular series expansion @xmath271 , we find @xmath272 the leading - order solution is as expected , but ignoring the @xmath273 $ ] complex hilbert transform has the effect of changing the correction term , @xmath274 .
if we return to the correct @xmath163 in , which corresponds to the full model , we find @xmath275 - { \mathrm{i}}\theta_1\bigr ) = { \mathrm{i}}j q_0 q_0 ' + { \mathrm{j}}q_0 { \hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[\theta_1]\ ] ] upon using and the solution for @xmath276 in .
recall that near the wave - generating singularity , @xmath277 $ ] remains bounded , but @xmath52 and its derivatives are singular according to .
in other words , the simplified formulation of has replaced @xmath163 in the full model with its local behaviour near the singularity .
substitution of @xmath278 into the simplified nonlinear model yields @xmath279{\bar{q}}\sim \tilde{r}(w),\ ] ] where we have withheld the right hand - side , @xmath280 for clarity .
we can verify that as @xmath281 , @xmath282 , and thus comparing the bracketed terms in and , we see that while we have completely neglected the @xmath273 $ ] terms , we are nevertheless able to preserve the inner limit of . thus , since the limiting behaviours of the @xmath41 coefficient functions are preserved exactly , then the hankel contour analysis of [ sec : hankel ] ( which depends only on local properties ) will also be preserved exactly , with the exception of a different numerical prefactor due to the right hand - side differences . in summary
, let us assume that the leading - order exponential for the full problem is written as @xmath283 with limiting behaviour @xmath284 as @xmath285 , and for constants @xmath286 and @xmath287 .
then the exponential that results from using the simplified nonlinear formulation of is @xmath288 for some constant @xmath289 . in the study of @xcite ,
the simplified nonlinear problem was used as a toy model for the study of wave - structure interactions with coalescing singularities . by duplicating the derivation of [ sec : steep ] , the analogous formula to can be developed for .
we will provide a numerical computation of this problem in [ sec : numerics ] .
a detailed summary of the full and simplified models we have presented thus far is shown in table [ tab : models ] . in this section
, we will verify the fit of the three reduced models with the numerical solutions of the full nonlinear problem in the limit @xmath27 .
the models include ( i ) the full nonlinear problem , or more conventionally , the solution of bernoulli s equation and the boundary integral equation ; ( ii ) the @xmath47 truncated linear model in ; and ( iii ) the @xmath290 nonlinear model in .
we study the case of a semi - infinite rectangular ship given by and with @xmath107 , and thus @xmath291 which is the leading - order speed associated with a hull with a right - angled corner ( @xmath292 in the interior of the fluid ) at @xmath293 , and a stagnation point at @xmath294 .
the solution is computed in each of the three cases , and the amplitude of the water waves far downstream , with @xmath295 , is extracted .
for the two models with truncations at @xmath47 and @xmath290 , recall that the real - valued solution on the axis is formed by adding the complex - valued complex solution to its complex conjugate [ see and the surrounding discussion ] .
thus , for these two cases , the amplitude of @xmath3 is taken to be twice the amplitude of @xmath296 . in order to solve the full water wave equations
, we use the numerical algorithm described in @xcite . in brief
, a stretched grid is applied near the stagnation point , and a finite - difference approximation of the boundary integral is calculated using the trapezoid rule . at a singular point of the integral , a quadratic interpolant is applied between the point and its two neighbours , and the resultant quadratic is calculated exactly . for more details of the numerical scheme see , _
e.g. _ chap . 7 of @xcite and the references therein .
from the predicted wave amplitude , we have @xmath297 { \mathrm{e}}^{-3\pi/(2{\epsilon})},\ ] ] where @xmath298 , @xmath299 , and here , @xmath107 . the numerical pre - factor
@xmath300 requires a generic calculation ( _ c.f . _
10 of @xcite ) . both numerical amplitude measurements ( stars ) , as well as the asymptotic prediction ( upper dashed line ) ,
are shown in fig .
[ fig : numerics ] . truncated linear model , and the @xmath290 truncated nonlinear model .
for the two truncated models , the amplitude is multiplied by two to account for the analytic continuation .
the dashed lines correspond to leading - order asymptotic approximations of the full nonlinear model ( top ) and the simplified nonlinear model ( bottom ) .
[ fig : numerics ] ] the @xmath47 and @xmath290 truncated models can be solved as initial - value problems . due to the singular nature of the stagnation point , where @xmath301 , we use the coordinate transformation @xmath302 , and solve the associated differential equations in @xmath303 .
the asymptotic behaviour is used to provide the initial value for @xmath3 at a point near @xmath304 . in the simulations , we typically used @xmath305 , and the resultant amplitudes are verified to be independent of the initial condition .
the combined results are shown in fig .
[ fig : numerics ] .
the leading - order asymptotic approximations fit the data closely , and we see that both the model with simplified nonlinear ( @xmath290 , shown as circle ) and linear ( @xmath306 , shown as stars ) formulations duplicate the requisite behaviours reviewed in table [ tab : models ] .
throughout our analysis of [ sec : reduce ] to [ sec : numerics ] , we have chosen to stray from tulin s formulation , which is encapsulated in the study of .
this mode of presentation was out of necessity ; while the broad outline of tulin s reduction is ultimately correct , the use of the unknown @xmath25-function renders the equation impractical for most applications .
moreover , the @xcite substitution and subsequent truncation of the nonlinear @xmath15 does not make it clear what inaccuracies are introduced by the reduction process ( we have concluded , for example , that the pre - factor of the wave will be incorrect ) .
we have provided an extended discussion of tulin s @xmath25-function in appendix [ sec : qfunc ] , and the connections with our own formulation in [ sec : tulinconnect ] and appendix [ sec : tulinconnect2 ] . while tulin s work may have been unappreciated since its inception , the work was , in fact , ahead of its time .
indeed , the proposal of the complex - variable reduction of the water - wave equations , and the subsequent simplification of the hilbert transform would anticipate many of the more sophisticated asymptotic approaches that would later develop independently ( _ e.g. _ in @xcite ) . as we have reviewed in [ sec : otherworks ] , others have proposed integral formulations of the low - froude problem ( see _ e.g. _ the collection of models in @xcite ) , but such models typically depended on _ ad - hoc _ linearizations of the two - dimensional potential flow equations . also at the forefront of our motivation was to better understand tuck s series of papers @xcite , positing simplified toy models that could eliminate the hilbert transform , while preserving essential details of the waves . during the brief exchange between tulin and tuck , as quoted in 1.2 , tuck had indicated that it was unclear whether his reductions were related , via the complex - plane , with tulin s model .
the answer is that they are indeed related .
both tulin and tuck s formulations are intended to be ( but are ultimately incomplete ) truncated models valid at low froude numbers .
both studies attempt to produce an approximate wave solution independent of the hilbert transform . through our corrected reduction and study using steepest descents
, we were able to explain why the hilbert transform was crucial in some cases ( determining @xmath307 ) , but negligible in others ( determining @xmath308 ) .
this idea of being able to study and visualize wave - structure interactions using the method of steepest descents is a powerful one , and we believe that it has wide applicability to further developing analytical theory for more complicated geometries than the ones we have considered here .
another main result of our work relates to the presentation of table [ tab : models ] , which unifies the various truncated models under consideration .
we have shown that in the limit @xmath27 , the exponentially small water waves are of the form @xmath283 plus its complex conjugate . in order to obtain the correct @xmath121 ( and
thus preserve some of the most important aspects ) , we can solve the one - term truncated model @xmath309 this is the simplest reduction of the water wave problem . despite the fact that it will incorrectly predict @xmath310
, it still serves as a useful toy model since the steepest descent argument remains unchanged .
if we wish to obtain the correct functional form of @xmath258 , then we can instead solve the equation , @xmath311{\bar{q}}= r(w ; { \hat{{\mathscr{h}}}}[{\bar{\theta}}]),\ ] ] where @xmath169 will be truncated to @xmath178 error , as detailed in table [ tab : models ] .
it is difficult to propose any reduced equation that allows us to determine the correct numerical pre - factor , @xmath257 , since this involves inclusion of terms up to optimal truncation in @xmath157 and @xmath158 .
since this optimal truncation term tends to infinity as @xmath27 , then we must do as we have done in _
e.g. _ , and approximate @xmath169 using its divergent form .
this is the connection with previous approaches that have used exponential asymptotics .
the _ correct _ model that is to say , the one that predicts the leading - order exponential , up to the numerical pre - factor does indeed require accounting for the divergent nature of the asymptotic approximations .
tulin s paradoxical comment regarding the validity of the low speed limit , quoted on p. of our introduction , will be resolved once the specific problem geometry and integrand functions of is considered using the method of steepest descents . in this case , we have seen through the methodology of [ sec : steep ] that , for the case of ship flow , in the limit @xmath27 , the wave contributions arise from deformation of the integration contours about the saddle points , which corresponds to the corner of the ship geometry .
while the generated waves are unbounded near these critical points , they remain exponentially small order everywhere along the free surface .
indeed , it was precisely this argument that had allowed us to neglect the hilbert transform . therefore , there is no issue with taking the @xmath27 limit within the physical domain .
tulin s comment , however , has an important consequence in the case of bow flows . in this case
, we see that as the solution is analytically continued in the direction of the bow , the generated exponential , of order @xmath265 , will tend to infinite amplitude at the stagnation point .
thus there is no bounded solution in the @xmath27 limit for bow flow .
this situation was formally discussed in @xcite , but it has been known [ see _ e.g. _ @xcite ] that the numerical problem is not well - posed when a stagnation point attachment is assumed for the case of incoming flow .
we have thus demonstrated this , here , for the limiting case of @xmath27 . in an age where there are a bevy of tools and packages that can perform full numerical computations of the nonlinear water - wave problem
, the reader may be justified in wondering whether there is still applicability in studying the significance of historical works by @xcite , @xcite , and this paper itself . as summarized by table [ tab : models ]
, the differences between various truncated models are subtle , and given the current state of computation , it seems more difficult to unravel such subtleties than it would be to to solve the full model .
however , while methods of computation have improved significantly since tulin s 1982 paper , many theoretical aspects of free - surface wave - body flows are still a mystery , as evident by the review in @xcite .
for example , there is virtually no analytical theory that can distinguish between waves produced by surface - piercing bodies with sudden angular changes ( corners ) versus bodies that are smooth [ _ c.f . _ the discussion in @xcite ] .
the classic treatments using linearized theory , as it appears in _ e.g. _ @xcite and @xcite , are limited to asymptotically small bodies rather than the bluff bodies we consider in this paper . in a forthcoming work
, we will demonstrate how the steepest descent methodology developed in this paper , can be applied to the study of smooth - bodied obstructions .
the techniques and reductions presented in this paper , along with further developments in the theory of exponential asymptotics , provides hope that analytical progress can be made on the subject of time - dependent and three - dimensional wave - body problems [ _ c.f . _ recent work by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite on this topic ] .
the individual components , @xmath120 , @xmath121 , and @xmath122 , that make up the factorial - over - power divergence in can be derived by examining the governing equations at @xmath312 ) . in the limit @xmath116
, the leading - order contribution gives the _ singulant _ , @xmath121 , @xmath313 and since @xmath119 at the singularities , we write @xmath314 where @xmath216 is a particular singularity of the leading - order solution .
similarly , it can be shown that @xmath315,\ ] ] where @xmath252 is a constant of integration and @xmath186 is an arbitary point chosen wherever the integral is defined . the pre - factor @xmath316 ,
is then related to @xmath120 using @xmath317 the value of @xmath122 is derived by matching the local behaviour of @xmath112 in with leading - order @xmath52 near the singularity , @xmath216 .
if we assume that @xmath318 near the singularity , then @xmath319 for most nonlinear problems , the value of @xmath252 in embeds the nonlinearity of the governing equations near the singularity , and must be found through a numerical solution of a recurrence relation . a detailed derivation of the above quantities , including numerical values of @xmath252 , can be found in 3.1 of @xcite and 4 of @xcite .
we also refer the reader to more general reviews of exponential asymptotics by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
the most difficult aspect of tulin s work concerns section vi of the manuscript , which seeks to understand the nature of the analytically continued function , @xmath23 . we will attempt to follow the same argument as tulin ( with adjustments for changes in notation and flow geometry ) .
tulin had split the form of @xmath25 into a contribution from the uniform flow and a contribution from the geometry . in his notation
, our @xmath23 is equal to @xmath320 .
the situation of an imposed pressure distribution was also considered in his work , but we shall ignore this effect .
tulin had then written @xmath25 in terms of a cauchy integral over the solid boundary and its image reflected about the free surface in the potential plane .
this is analogous to applying cauchy s integral theorem to either @xmath16 or the hodograph variable along a counterclockwise circular contour of radius @xmath321 with a slit about the negative real axis ( see fig . [
fig : cauchy ] , right ) .
this yields @xmath322 \ , { \operatorname{d\!}{}}{t},\ ] ] where the integral along the outer circle tends to zero as @xmath321 by the boundary conditions and the integral over the slit involves @xmath323 and @xmath324 , the limiting values from the upper or lower half - planes .
however , in , only the values of @xmath4 on one side are known ( being the physical angle of the solid boundary ) .
for instance , in the case of a step , @xmath325 is given by .
the problem , however , is that the other values @xmath326 , @xmath327 , and @xmath328 are only known through analytic continuation , and it is impossible to go further with without additional information .
[ fig : cauchy],scaledwidth=80.0% ] for most practical implementations , it is preferable to instead apply cauchy s theorem to an integral over the solid boundary and the free surface ( see fig . [
fig : cauchy ] , left ) , which was the formulation in [ sec : bdint ] .
bernoulli s equation is required in order to provide a relationship between @xmath3 and @xmath4 on the free surface , and thus close the system .
tulin had posited that the value of @xmath25 might be found through a theoretically posited surrogate body whose singularities on the physical boundary alone would generate the flow ( rather than the physical boundary and its reflected image ) .
this appears as eqn ( 60 ) in his work .
however , for a given physical geometry ( _ e.g. _ for the step and ship geometries of [ sec : form ] ) , it is unclear how this surrogate body could ever be determined in an _ a priori _ fashion .
thus in the end , tulin s @xmath23 should rather be written as @xmath329 , as it involves the solution itself .
this creates a problematic argument if the intention is to treat as an ordinary differential equation to be integrated exactly , for the solution appears on both sides of the formulation .
indeed , this is precisely the issue that tuck ( [ sec : introtuck ] ) had wrestled with , in seeking a reduction of the global hilbert transform operator . in the approach to follow , we will resume our study of the formulation in [ sec : analytic ] , and we will return to discuss the connection to tulin s work in [ sec : discuss ] .
as explained in [ sec : tulinconnect ] , we have chosen to stray from tulin s formulation , which uses the combined analytic function , @xmath152 , and the unknown right hand - side , @xmath25 . our formulation separates the analytic continuations of the @xmath3 and @xmath4 variables , and is self contained .
in contrast , tulin s formulation requires the specification of the @xmath25-function , which requires additional information .
we now wish to show how tulin s equation is related to the equation for the exponential in [ sec : hankel ] , given by @xmath330{\bar{q}}\sim -{\epsilon}^n q_{n-1}',\ ] ] that is , the reduced integro - differential model with the right hand - side . in order to relate the two formulations , we multiply through by @xmath16 and
obtain @xmath331 we expand the unknown functions in the above equation into a regular perturbation expansion and an error term , using @xmath332 where for simplicity , we expand the product @xmath333 rather than the individual factors .
substitution into gives @xmath334 where we have introduced the error in the bernoulli equation , @xmath335 which can be compared to .
the expansion of @xmath336 , can also be written in terms of the expansions for @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
using @xmath152 , and expanding , we find [ g0g1 gb ] @xmath337 + { \epsilon}\bigl [ -9 { \mathrm{i}}{\mathrm{j}}q_0 ^ 2 q_1 { \bar{\theta}}- 9 { \mathrm{i}}{\mathrm{j}}q_0 ^ 2 \theta_1 { \bar{q}}+ 6 q_0 q_1 { \bar{q}}- 9 q_0 ^ 3 \theta_1 { \bar{\theta}}\bigr ] + \ldots . \label{gbexpand}\end{gathered}\ ] ] following the discussion in [ sec : tulinconnect ] and appendix [ sec : qfunc ] , we emphasize that @xmath52 , @xmath163 , @xmath276 , and the low - order terms are derived independently from that is , the single equation for @xmath16 is insufficient to close the system without inclusion of the hilbert transform .
instead , we assume that the low - order terms in are known and that provides an equation for @xmath25 .
the regular part of @xmath25 , given by @xmath338 , follows from expansion of the left hand - side of . only including up to @xmath178 terms , we obtain @xmath339 + { \mathcal{o}}({\epsilon}^2).\ ] ] we also note that in the limit @xmath27 , the optimal truncation point of the regular series expansion tends to infinity , @xmath255 , and the error in bernoulli s equation is replaced by the divergent term @xmath340 which is analogous to the argument leading to .
the result now follows by using for @xmath163 and @xmath276 , for @xmath341 , for @xmath338 , and for the right hand - side of .
we are left with @xmath342 { \bar{q}}\sim -{\epsilon}^n q_{n-1}',\ ] ] or , as desired .
thus we have shown how tulin s formulation will exactly preserve the exponentially small surface waves .
derivation of the full relationship of tulin s equation to the full system can be similarly done , but the algebra ( in expanding @xmath25 and @xmath16 , and returning to the formulation with the embedded hilbert transform ) becomes unwieldy .
2010 exponential asymptotics and stokes line smoothing for generalized solitary waves . in _
asymptotic methods in fluid mechanics : survey and recent advances _ ( ed
. h. steinrck ) , pp .
springerwiennewyork .
1990 water non - waves . in _
mini - conference on free and moving boundary and diffusion problems _
proceedings of the centre for mathematics & its applications ) , pp . 109127 .
canberra : centre for mathematics and its applications , australian national university
. 1977 computation of near - bow or stern flows using series expansion in the froude number . in _
2nd international conference on numerical ship hydrodynamics_. berkeley , california : university of california , berkeley . | in 1982 , marshall p. tulin published a report proposing a framework for reducing the equations for gravity waves generated by moving bodies into a single nonlinear differential equation solvable in closed form [ _ proc .
14th symp . on naval hydrodynamics _ , 1982 , pp.1951 ] .
several new and puzzling issues were highlighted by tulin , notably the existence of weak and strong wave - making regimes , and the paradoxical fact that the theory seemed to be applicable to flows at low speeds , _ but not too low speeds"_. these important issues were left unanswered , and despite the novelty of the ideas , tulin s report fell into relative obscurity .
now thirty years later , we will revive tulin s observations , and explain how an asymptotically consistent framework allows us to address these concerns .
most notably , we will explain , using the asymptotic method of steepest descents , how the production of free - surface waves can be related to the arrangement of integration contours connected to the shape of the moving body .
this approach provides an intuitive and visual procedure for studying nonlinear wave - body interactions .
surface gravity waves , wave - structure interactions , waves / free - surface flows |
cosmic rays ( crs ) below the knee " in the galaxy are commonly believed to be accelerated at the shock of supernova remnants ( snrs ) . however
, whether the @xmath0-rays from snrs are of hadronic or leptonic origin is still in hot debate .
although evidences for @xmath0-ray emission arising from molecular clouds ( mcs ) have been found in two snrs , ic 443 ( acciari et al . 2009 ) and w28 ( aharonian et al .
2008 ) , it is not easy yet to confirm the emission of the accelerated protons , since the competing lepton processes can also account for the high energy radiation . fortunately , emission from mcs illuminated by crs from nearby snrs ( aharonian & atoyan 1996 ; gabici et al.2009 ) can give us opportunities not only to distinguish the contribution of the hadrons from that of leptons but also to investigate the escape process of these energetic protons ( fujita et al.2009 ) .
snr w28 , with recent observation in gev and tev @xmath0-rays , is such an excellent case .
w28 ( [email protected] ) is one of the prototype thermal composite ( or mixed - morphology ) snrs , characterized by centre - filled thermal x - ray and shell - like radio emission , with large ( about @xmath2 ) apparent dimensions ( green 2009 ) .
it is considered to be an evolved snr in the radiative stage , with an age estimate spanning from 35 to 150 kyr ( kaspi et al .
snr w28 has been confirmed to be interacting with mcs with robust evidences including the 1720 mhz oh masers , morphological agreement with molecular features , molecular line broadening , etc .
( see jiang et al .
2010 ; and references therein ) .
the observations of molecular lines place it at a distance of @xmath3 ( vel@xmath4zquez et al .
2002 ) . in @xmath0-rays
, @xmath5 has revealed four tev sources in the w28 field positionally coincident with mcs ( aharonian et al .
2008 ) : hess j1801 - 233 ( denoted as source n in this letter ) , located along the northeastern boundary of w28 , and hess j1800 - 240a , b , and c ( denoted as sources a , b , and c , respectively , in below ) , located @xmath6 south of w28 . recently , _
_ lat observation ( abdo et al.2010 ) found gev sources 1fgl j1801.3 - 2322c and 1fgl j1800.5 - 2359c , which coincide with sources n and b , respectively .
more interestingly , it did not detect significant gev counterparts for sources a and c. the lat upper limits combined with the h.e.s.s .
data imply a spectral break between 10gev and 100gev .
we will show in this letter that these @xmath0-ray spatial and spectral properties can be accounted for with an accumulative diffusion process of crs which are accelerated at the dynamically evolving blast shock front .
cr diffusion models have been developed by aharonian & atoyan ( 1996 ) and gabici et al .
( 2009 ) to evaluate the cr spectrum in the vicinity of snrs . in their models ,
both cases of impulsive and continuous injection are considered on the assumption that the distance between the snr and the cloud is significantly larger than the size of the snr , so that the injection region can be approximated as a point - like source . if , however , the cloud is at or close to the snr blast shock , such as in the case of w28 , the diffusion distance for protons injected at various time , @xmath7 , and various shock radius , @xmath8 , is not a constant and the assumption of point - like source injection should be modified .
therefore , we here establish an accumulative diffusion model considering that the energetic protons colliding the given mc are a collection of the diffusive protons escaping from different @xmath8 as the snr expands .
_ small distance between the snr and mc is allowed .
_ the distribution function at an arbitrary field point c ( at radius @xmath9 ) of the energetic protons that escape from unit area at an arbitrary source point s on the spherical shock front surface ( see figure [ fig : w28cartoon ] ) is given by ( aharonian & atoyan 1996 ) @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the distance between points s and c ( figure [ fig : w28cartoon ] ) , @xmath12 is the diffusion time after the escape , @xmath13 is the diffusion radius , and @xmath14 is the total escaping rate at time @xmath7 . here
the diffusion coefficient is assumed to be in the form of @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the correction factor of slow diffusion around the snr ( fujita et al .
2009 ) and @xmath170.7 ( berezinskii 1990 ) .
the number of protons with energy @xmath18 escaping from the snr shock front surface at @xmath7 and arriving at the spherical surface of radius @xmath9 at @xmath19 is @xmath20 .
because of spherical symmetry , the distribution function of protons ( escaping from @xmath21 ) for any point ( e.g. , point c ) on the spherical surface of radius @xmath9 is @xmath22 .
therefore , the distribution function for point c accumulating all the historical contributions can be obtained as @xmath23 @xmath24 for the dynamical evolution of radius of the snr expanding in the interstellar ( intercloud ) medium of density @xmath25 , we use the sedov - taylor law @xmath26 for the adiabatic phase and @xmath27 for the radiative phase , where @xmath28 is the transition radius from the sedov phase to the radiative phase , @xmath29 is the supernova explosion energy , and @xmath30 is a factor equal to 0.24 ( blinnikov et al . 1982 ; see also lozinskaya 1992 ) .
the total energy of the escaping protons is @xmath31 @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is the fraction of the explosion energy converted into protons .
in addition to the escaping protons , we also consider the contribution of diffuse galactic protons in the solar neighborhood with flux density ( see , e.g. , dermer 1986 ) : @xmath34 in the calculation of the @xmath0-rays from the nearby mc ( of mass @xmath35 ) due to p - p interaction so as to match the observed gev and tev fluxes , we use the analytic photon emissivity @xmath36 developed by kelner et al .
( 2006 ) . at high energies ,
@xmath37 where @xmath38 is the average density of target baryons of the cloud , @xmath39 is the cross section of inelastic p - p interactions and function @xmath40 is defined by eq .
( 58 ) in kelner et al .
( 2006 ) ; while at low energies , with the modified @xmath41-function approximation as proposed in aharonian & atoyan ( 2000 ) , the emissivity of @xmath0-rays is @xmath42 where @xmath43 , and the production rate of @xmath44 mesons is @xmath45 ( see kelner et al .
2006 for the explanations of other parameters ) .
the contribution of @xmath0-rays from the secondary leptons that are created by p - p interaction is negligible , as compared with the dominant contribution of the protons themselves ( gabici et al . 2007 ; 2009 ) .
because the timescale for the secondaries to escape from the cloud is shorter than the energy loss time for particle energies between @xmath46 mev and a few 100 tev , a large amount of the secondaries produced within clouds of a wide range of parameters escape without being affected by significant losses ( gabici et al.2009 ) . in the molecular gas of density as high as @xmath47 , the magnetic field
could be assumed to be of order @xmath48 g ( crutcher 1999 ) .
extremely high energy ( @xmath49 a few 100 tev ) secondaries radiate all their energy by synchrotron peaked at tens of kev before escaping from the cloud ; but the x - rays are not in the scope of this letter .
now we use the accumulative diffusion model established above to reproduce the gev tev spectra for the four @xmath0-ray sources around snr w28 , showing that the different @xmath0-ray spectra of the four sources mainly result from the different spectra of the runaway protons , as a consequence of the different distances of the sources ( molecular clouds ) from the snr shock from which the accelerated protons escape .
the current radius of w28 is approximated as @xmath50 pc by using 2kpc as the distance to it .
the current blastwave velocity @xmath51 was inferred to be in the 60@xmath52 range based on the optical observations ( see rho & borkowski 2002 ) , and hence we adopt @xmath53
. also following rho & borkowski ( 2002 ) , we adopt the intercloud medium density @xmath54 . for the evolution in the radiative phase
, its age is estimated as @xmath55 .
the explosion energy is given by @xmath56 @xmath57 .
moreover , we assume a power - law energy spectrum of the escaping protons of index @xmath58 ( e.g. , giuliani et al . 2010 ) , and adopt @xmath59 ( fujita et al .
2009 ) and @xmath60 ( blandford & eichler 1987 ) .
therefore , there are three adjustable parameters : @xmath61 , @xmath41 , and @xmath35 .
these model parameters for the @xmath0-ray sources around snr w28 are shown in table 1 .
all the spectra of the four sources are well reproduced ( figure [ fig : w28n ] ) , as described in detail below .
.parameters of the model considered for different sources . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] + @xmath62 the adoption of the average angular diameter of each source for deriving the baryon density @xmath38 is described in the text in [ sec : dif - w28 ] .
source n is a well known shock - mc interaction region on the northeastern boundary of snr w28 .
we adopt @xmath63 for this source .
the observed gev spectrum of source n has a spectral break at @xmath64 gev with photon index 2.1 below the break and 2.7 above the break ( abdo et al .
2010 ) . as seen in
the top left panel of figure [ fig : w28n ] , this spectral break together with the tev spectrum can be naturally explained by the accumulative diffusion model without invoking either a breaking power - law proton spectrum ( see abdo et al .
2010 ) or any artificial low energy cut - off .
the model spectrum peaks at @xmath65 gev .
we note that the tev emission with a slope 2.7 implies the same power - law index for the protons , and this is unlikely to come directly from the shock accelerated protons ( because the typical accelerated particle spectral slope for acceleration process is 22.3 ) but can be obtained from a diffusion process .
source b is located right on the south of snr w28 with a projected distance of @xmath66 pc from its southern circular boundary ( aharonian et al .
2008 ) , and hence we adopt @xmath6722 pc . in source b and also in source
n , which are closely near the snr , the contribution from the diffuse galactic crs is negligible compared with that of the diffused protons from the snr . in our model , with the increase of radius @xmath61 and hence the increase of the mean diffusion distance , the spectral peak shifts to higher energies .
the peak @xmath68 gev for source b ( see the top right panel of figure [ fig : w28n ] ) is higher than the peak in source n , which implies the diffusion effect for different diffusion distances .
source b is also suggested to be associated with hii region w28a2 which may also possibly explain the @xmath0-ray emission , but requires extremely high density of gas ( abdo et al.2010 ) .
sources a and c were not found to have significant counterparts in the _ fermi _ lat observation . the lat upper limits together with the h.e.s.s
. data are indicative of a spectral break in the 10100 gev range .
this break is reproduced in figure [ fig : w28n ] ( bottom left panel ) , in which the concave @xmath0-ray spectra appears as m " shape with two peaks . the underlying proton spectra consist of two components : the galactic proton background , which is responsible for the left peak , and the protons coming from snr w28 , which are for the right one . with the increase of @xmath61 , the flux density of crs accelerated by the snr
is diluted and , compared with the snr protons , the relative significance of the diffuse galactic protons rises .
there are uncertainties in the gev fluxes for both sources a and c. the lower limits of @xmath9 ( dotted lines in the bottom left panel of figure [ fig : w28n ] ) are used for the @xmath0-rays produced by protons escaped from snr to match the upper limits of the lat data , and the upper limits of @xmath9 ( dashed line in the bottom left panel of figure [ fig : w28n ] ) are for the diffuse galactic protons to match the lat upper limits .
meanwhile , with @xmath9 increased , the ( right ) peak of the emission of the escaping snr protons now shifts to higher energy than that for source b , thus forming the spectral break at 10100gev .
although there is less confinement in the gev realm for source c , we can determine the upper and lower limits of @xmath9 of the source ( see the dotted and dashed lines in the bottom right panel of figure [ fig : w28n ] ) , in a similar way used for source a. the fitted values of @xmath9 for the both sources are much larger than those of sources n and b ( see table 1 ) , which maybe the basic reason why the gev emission for a and c looks faint .
the estimated mass of northeastern cloud ( corresponding to the @xmath0-ray source n ) from nanten data is @xmath69 and the total mass of the southern clouds ( including the clumps corresponding to sources a , b , and c ) is @xmath70 ( aharonian et al .
the values of @xmath35 fitted for the four sources in our model ( table 1 ) seem to be in agreement with the nanten observation . using the average angular diameters of sources n , a , b , and c , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath72 , and @xmath73 , respectively , as measured from the outermost contours of the tev emission in figure 1 in aharonian et al .
( 2008 ) , we give the baryon density for each molecular cloud in table 1 also .
the reproduction of the four @xmath0-ray spectra produces various values of parameter @xmath41 in the range of 0.350.7 . the diffusion process of crs results from particle scattering on random mhd waves and discontinuities .
theoretically , the power - law index of diffusion , @xmath41 , then depends strongly on the spectral energy density of interstellar turbulence which would originate from fluid instabilities and magnetic field fluctuations .
however , the mechanisms of the turbulent phenomena are still in hot debate . in general , three types of isotropic diffusion scalings ( kolmogorov , @xmath74 ; kraichnan , @xmath75 ; and bohm , @xmath76 ) may exist in the ism ( see strong et al .
the @xmath41 values obtained in our model vary just between these values and may arise from one or a combination of the three types of diffusion , in view of the fact that the escaping protons diffuse to the four mcs though a nonuniform and anisotropic interstellar environment around snr w28 .
an accumulative diffusion model has been established and well explains the @xmath0-ray spectra of the four sources around snr w28 recently obtained by @xmath5 and _ fermi_. the energetic protons colliding the nearby mcs are considered to be an accumulation of the diffusive protons escaping from the shock front throughout the history of the snr expansion . for the various distances of the mcs from the snr centre ,
the resulted proton spectra can have prominently different shapes .
we have thus fitted the @xmath0-ray spectra of the four sources and naturally explained the gev spectral break of the northeastern source n and the nonsignificant gev emissions of the southern sources a and c. the distances of sources a and c from the snr centre are found to be much larger than those of sources n and b. this also implies prospects for inferring the spatial position of the proton - illuminated mcs around snrs using the gev and tev spectra .
@xmath0-rays from molecular clouds illuminated by accumulated diffusive protons from snr w28 strongly support the scenario that hadrons accelerated by snr shocks contribute to the galactic crs .
y.c . acknowledges support from nsfc grants 10725312 and the 973 program grant 2009cb824800 . | w28 is one of the archetype supernova remnants ( snrs ) interacting with molecular clouds .
h.e.s.s .
observation found four tev sources which are coincident with the molecular clouds ( mcs ) around w28 , but _
fermi _
lat detected no prominent gev counterparts for two of them .
an accumulative diffusion model is established in this letter and the energetic protons colliding the nearby mcs are considered to be an accumulation of the diffusive protons escaping from the shock front throughout the history of the snr expansion .
we have fitted the @xmath0-ray spectra of the four sources and naturally explained the gev spectral break of the northeastern source ( source n ) and the nonsignificant gev emission of the southern sources a and c. the distances of sources a and c from the snr centre are found to be much larger than those of sources n and b , which may be the basic reason for the faint gev @xmath0-rays of the two former sources .
[ firstpage ] radiation mechanisms : non - thermal gamma rays : theory ism : supernova remnants . |
jet observables , event shapes and jet rates , revealed themselves as one of the richest laboratories to explore qcd .
being infrared and collinear safe ( irc ) , they can be predicted with perturbative ( pt ) techniques , but their high sensitivity to low energy emissions allows us to investigate the fairly unknown non - perturbative regime .
most discriminatory studies make use of distributions . in integrated distributions
@xmath0 one requires that the value of the observable @xmath1 a function of all secondary final state momenta @xmath2 and of the born momenta after recoil from the emissions @xmath3 be less than a fixed value @xmath4 @xmath5 the inclusive phase space region , where @xmath6 , is dominated by events with hard jets , which move the value of the observable far away from its born value , @xmath7 .
these events can be described with fixed order pt expansions , however they are quite rare , every additional jet being suppressed by an additional factor of @xmath8 .
more common events are characterised by a large number of soft - collinear emissions which modify only slightly the value of the observable from its born value , so that @xmath9 . here
fixed order predictions fail since every power of @xmath8 is accompanied by up to two large logarithms @xmath10 of the value of the observable . a reorganization of the pt expansion is then needed in order to resum all leading ( ll , @xmath11 ) and next - to - leading ( nll , @xmath12 ) logarithmic terms .
in the past few years the analytical resummation for a variety of observables have been presented in @xmath13-collision@xcite and dis@xcite .
the matching of resummed predictions with fixed order results allowed tests of qcd , measures of the coupling constant and studies of non - perturbative corrections@xcite .
however , the need for a separate analytical calculation for every observable has limited the experimental use of resummed predictions .
when dealing with multi - jet observables , analytical calculations become quite unfeasible , involving many integral transforms in order to write the distribution in a factorized form@xcite . also in some cases it turns out not to be possible to resum the observable analytically@xcite .
we present then here a general approach to resummation based on a preliminary automated analysis of the observable , to establish its relevant properties with respect to soft - collinear emissions ; in a subsequent step this information is used as an input of a general master formula .
we start by considering a born event consisting of @xmath14 hard partons ( ` legs ' ) , @xmath15 of which are incoming , with momenta @xmath16 .
we resum @xmath17-jet observables in the @xmath14-jet limit .
the ( positive defined ) observable should then 1 .
vanish smoothly as a single extra ( @xmath14+@xmath18 ) parton of momentum @xmath19 is made soft and collinear to a leg @xmath20 , with the functional dependence @xmath21 here @xmath22 is a hard scale of the process and the secondary emission @xmath19 is defined in terms of its transverse momentum @xmath23 and rapidity @xmath24 with respect to leg @xmath20 , and where relevant , by an azimuthal angle @xmath25 relative to a born event plane . by requiring the functional form ( in practise , almost always valid ) , the problem of analyzing the observable reduces in part to identifying , for each leg @xmath20 , the coefficients @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 and the function @xmath29 .
irc safety demands @xmath30 .
2 . be _ recursively _ irc safe , i. e. given an ensemble of arbitrarily soft and collinear emissions , the addition of a relatively much softer or more collinear emission should not significantly alter the value of the observable , condition required for exponentiation of the leading logarithms .
observables like jet - rates in the jade algorithm are then excluded , and many other examples of non - exponentiating irc safe observables exist@xcite .
3 . be continuously global@xcite this means that for a single soft emission , the observable s parametric dependence on the emission s transverse momentum ( with respect to the nearest leg ) should be independent of the emission direction . in practice
this is perhaps the most restrictive of the conditions .
it implies @xmath31 . to enable our computer program caesar ( computer automated expert semi - analytical resummation ) to establish these properties with the desired degree of reliability and precision ,
we have found it useful to make use of multiple - precision arithmetic@xcite . given the above conditions
, one can derive the following nll master resummation formula for the distribution @xmath0@xcite
\nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{\ell=1}^{n_i } \ln \frac{f_\ell(x_\ell , v^{\frac{2}{a+b_\ell } } { \mu_\textsc{f}}^2)}{f_\ell(x_\ell , { \mu_\textsc{f}}^2 ) } + \ln s\left(t(l / a\right ) ) + \ln { { \cal{f}}}(c_1 r_1',\ldots , c_n r_n ' ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 is the color factor associated with born leg @xmath20 , and @xmath34 is its energy , @xmath35 is @xmath36 for quarks and @xmath37 for gluons , @xmath38 , and for incoming legs , @xmath39 are the parton densities .
we note that is independent of the frame in which one determines the @xmath28 and ( to nll accuracy ) of the choice of hard scale @xmath22 . the functions @xmath40 , which contain all the ll ( and some nll ) terms , are @xmath41 here @xmath8 , in the bremsstrahlung scheme@xcite , runs at two - loop order .
@xmath42 and @xmath43 are relevant only at nll level @xmath44 the process dependence associated with large - angle soft radiation is described by @xmath45 , whose form depends on the number @xmath14 of legs . for @xmath46 @xmath47
\,,\ ] ] where @xmath48 and @xmath49 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 denote the ( anti)-quarks and gluon .
the simpler case @xmath52 can be read from setting @xmath53 .
the @xmath54 formulae apply then to @xmath13 , dis and drell - yan production , while a process such as @xmath55 involves simply different color factors .
the ( more involved ) @xmath56 case needed to describe hadronic dijet production can be found in@xcite .
we examine now the factor @xmath57 . without it ,
. corresponds essentially to the probability of vetoing all emissions @xmath19 with @xmath58 .
however at nll subtle effects enter : a simple veto on _ single emissions _ turns out to be insufficient , since events might have @xmath59 though all emissions separately had @xmath60 , or vice versa .
this _ multiple emission _ effect , encoded in @xmath57 , is connected to how all secondary emission coherently determine the value of the observable and can be computed in a general way in@xcite . while this talk concentrates on the method ,
new results obtained with it were presented at this conference in@xcite ( and other results can be found in@xcite ) .
this project started with the development of an algorithm to numerically compute the non - trivial nll terms associated with multiple emissions .
it was initially applied by hand to three new observables [ 6 ] .
progress since then includes the derivation of a general master formula , together with a precise , automatically verifiable list of conditions on the observable for the resummation to be valid at nll and the full numerical implementation of this . though no human intervention is needed , results have the quality of analytic nll predictions , so that any hadronisation model can be applied , studies of renormalization and factorization scale dependence can be carried out and a matching with fixed order is feasible .
the most import results obtained up to now are the first resummations in hadronic dijet production , for a variety of observable at a time .
we now aim at automating the matching with fixed order results@xcite , this will open up the possibility to carry out a vast amount of phenomenological studies .
i thank the organizers of dis2003 , in particular yuri dokshitzer , for the friendly atmosphere at the conference , and for the opportunity to visit a wonderful town .
0 s. catani , l. trentadue , g. turnock and b. r. webber , nucl .
b * 407 * ( 1993 ) 3 ; s. catani , g. turnock , b. r. webber and l. trentadue , phys .
b * 263 * ( 1991 ) 491 .
s. catani , b. r. webber and g. marchesini , nucl .
b * 349 * ( 1991 ) 635 ; + y. l. dokshitzer , v. a. khoze and s. i. troian , phys .
d * 53 * ( 1996 ) 89 .
m. dasgupta and g. p. salam , phys .
b * 512 * , 323 ( 2001 ) ; jhep * 0208 * ,
032 ( 2002 ) and references therein . s. bethke , j. phys .
g * 26 * , r27 ( 2000 ) , p. a. movilla fernandez , s. bethke , o. biebel and s. kluth , eur . phys .
j. c * 22 * , 1 ( 2001 ) , s. kluth et al .
j. c * 21 * , 199 ( 2001 ) and references therein .
a. banfi , g. marchesini , yu .
l. dokshitzer and g. zanderighi , jhep * 0007 * , 002 ( 2000 ) ; jhep * 0105 * , 040 ( 2001 ) .
a. banfi , g. p. salam and g. zanderighi , jhep * 0201 * , 018 ( 2002 ) .
a. banfi , g. p. salam and g. zanderighi , arxiv : hep - ph/0304148 and in preparation . | we present a master formula , with applicability conditions , which allows us to automate the resummation of infrared and collinear logarithms appearing in distributions of jet observables in qcd at next - to - leading logarithmic accuracy . |
the supermassive black - hole in the center of the milky way , located in the radio source sgr a * , is one of the most interesting astronomical objects : see ref .
@xcite for an extensive review .
it is now in a state of relative inactivity @xcite but there is no good reason for it to be stationary .
e.g. , there are interesting hints for a much stronger emission few 100 years ago @xcite ; on the time scale of 40,000 years , major variability episodes are expected @xcite ; fermi bubbles @xcite could be visible manifestations @xcite of its intense activity . therefore , it is reasonable to expect that a past emission from the galactic center leads to observable effects .
such scenario was recently considered in ref .
@xcite . the latest observations by the h.e.s.s . observatory @xcite , that various regions around sgr a * emit @xmath0-rays till many tens of tev , are offering us new occasions to investigate this object .
these @xmath0-rays obey non - thermal distributions , which are moreover different in the closest vicinity of sgr a * and in its outskirts . in the latter case ,
the @xmath0-rays seem to extend till very high energies ( @xmath2 tev ) without a perceivable cut - off .
the @xmath0-rays seen by h.e.s.s . can be attributed to cosmic ray collisions @xcite .
this is a likely hypothesis , but the proof of its correctness requires neutrino telescopes . in this connection , it is essential to derive reliable predictions for the search of a neutrino signal from sgr a * and its surroundings , and h.e.s.s .
observations are very valuable in this respect .
remarkably , the possibility that the galactic centre is a significant neutrino source is discussed since the first works @xcite and it is largely within expectations : indeed sgr a * is one of the main point source targets , already for the icecube observatory @xcite . in this work ,
we discuss the implications of the findings of h.e.s.s . , briefly reviewed in sect .
[ sec : gammaray ] , where we also explain our assumptions on the @xmath0-ray spectra at the source .
the effect of @xmath0-ray absorption ( due to the known radiation fields or to new ones , close to the galactic center ) is examined in details in sect . [
sec : abs ] .
the expected signal in neutrino telescopes , evaluated at the best of the present knowledge , is shown in sect .
[ sec : ripu ] and it is quantified in sect . [
sec : rates ] , while sect .
[ sec : ccc ] is devoted for the conclusion .
we argue that the pevatron hypothesis makes the case for a cubic kilometer class neutrino telescope , located in the northern hemisphere , more compelling than ever .
the excess of vhe @xmath0-rays reported by the h.e.s.s .
collaboration @xcite comes from two regions around the galactic center : a point source ( hess j1745 - 290 ) , identified by a circular region centered on the radio source sgr a * with a radius of 0.1@xmath3 , and a diffuse emission , coming from an annulus with inner and outer radii of 0.15@xmath3 and 0.45@xmath3 respectively .
the observed spectrum from the point source is described by a cut - off power law distribution , as @xmath4 while in the case of diffuse emission an unbroken power law is preferred ; in the last case , however , also cut - off power law fits are presented , as expected from standard mechanisms of particle acceleration into the galaxy .
the h.e.s.s .
collaboration has summarised its observations by means of the following parameter sets : * best fit of the point source ( ps ) region : + @xmath5 , + @xmath6 tev@xmath7 @xmath8 s@xmath7 , + @xmath9 tev ; * best fit of the diffuse ( d ) region : + @xmath10 , + @xmath11
tev@xmath7 @xmath8 s@xmath7 ; the best - fits of both the diffuse and the point source emission are shown in fig .
[ figabs ] , right panel .
however , in order to predict the neutrino spectrum , the @xmath0-ray spectrum at the source i.e . the emission spectrum is needed .
we will discuss the implication of the assumption that the emitted spectra coincide with the observed spectra as described by the previous functional forms and furthermore we will discuss the assumption that the @xmath0-ray emission at the source is described by different model parameters , namely : * point source emission with an increased value of the cut - off ( ps * ) : + @xmath12 , + @xmath13 tev@xmath7 @xmath8 s@xmath7 , + @xmath14 tev ; * diffuse emission as a cut - off ( dc ) power law with : + @xmath15 , + @xmath16 tev@xmath7 @xmath8 s@xmath7 , + @xmath17 pev .
the interest in considering an _ increased _ value of the cut - off ( the case ps * ) , that is the only case that differs significantly from the spectra observed by h.e.s.s .
, is motivated in the next section .
instead , the inclusion of a cut - off for the emission from the diffuse region agrees with the observations of h.e.s.s . and is motivated simply by the expectation of a maximum energy available for particle acceleration .
note that the @xmath0-ray observations extend till 20 - 40 tev .
this is an important region of energy but it covers only the lower region that is relevant for neutrinos : the latter one extends till 100 tev , as clear e.g. , from fig.2 and 3 of @xcite and fig.1 of @xcite . in other words , it should be kept in mind that until @xmath0-ray observations till few 100 tev will become available thanks to future measurements by hawc @xcite and cta @xcite the expectations for neutrinos will rely in part on extrapolation and/or on theoretical modeling . in this work , unless stated otherwise , we rely on a ` minimal extrapolation ' , assuming that the above functional descriptions of the @xmath0-ray spectrum are valid descriptions of the emission spectrum . a precise upper limit on the expected neutrino flux can be determined from the h.e.s.s .
measurement , assuming a hadronic origin of the observed @xmath0-rays .
the presence of a significant leptonic component of the @xmath0-rays would imply a smaller neutrino flux . in principle , however , also other regions close the the galactic center , but not probed by h.e.s.s .
, could emit high - energy @xmath0-rays and neutrino radiation , leading to an interesting signal .
one reason is that the annulus , chosen by h.e.s.s . for the analysis , resembles more a region selected for observational purposes rather than an object with an evident physical meaning ; another reason is that the ice - based neutrino telescope icecube integrates on an angular extension of about @xmath18 , which is 5 times larger than the angular region covered in @xcite . in view of these reasons ,
the theoretical upper limit on the neutrino flux that we will derive is the _ minimum _ that is justified by the current @xmath0-ray data .
moreover , there is also a specific phenomenon that increases the expected neutrino flux that can be derived from the @xmath0-ray flux currently measured by h.e.s.s . :
this is the absorption of @xmath0-rays from non standard radiation fields , as discussed in the next section .
during their propagation in the background radiation fields of the milky way , high - energy photons are subject to absorption .
consider the _ observed _ @xmath0-ray spectrum , as summarized by means of a certain functional form .
the corresponding _ emission _ spectrum is larger : this is obtained modeling and then removing the effect of absorption ( de - absorption ) .
the neutrino spectrum corresponds to the emission spectrum , and thus it is larger than the one obtained by converting the observed @xmath0-ray spectrum instead .
note that the idea that the @xmath0-rays could suffer significant absorption already at h.e.s.s .
energies was put forward in ref .
@xcite ; here , we examine it in details . the existence of a cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) , that pervades the whole space and it is uniformly distributed , is universally known ; this leads to absorption of @xmath0-rays of very high energies , around pev . for what concerns the interstellar radiation background , the model by porter et al .
@xcite , adopted e.g. , in the galprop simulation program @xcite , can be conveniently used to describe @xmath0-ray absorption due to the infrared ( ir ) and starlight ( sl ) backgrounds ( see e.g. , @xcite ) , that occurs at lower energies .
it is convenient to group these three radiation fields ( for instance cmb , ir and sl ) as ` known ' radiation fields , since it is not possible to exclude that in the vicinity of the galactic center new intense ir fields exist , and thus we should be ready to consider also hypothetical or ` unknown ' radiation fields .
the formal description of their absorption effects can be simplified without significant loss of accuracy if the radiation background field is effectively parameterized in terms of a sum of thermal and quasi - thermal distributions , where the latter ones are just proportional to thermal distributions . for the @xmath19-th component of the radiation background ,
two parameters are introduced : the temperature @xmath20 and the coefficient of proportionality to the thermal distribution , that we call the ` non - thermic parameter ' and that we denote by @xmath21 .
the reliability of this procedure for the description of the galactic absorption was already tested in @xcite .
we found that the formalism can be simplified even further without significant loss of accuracy thanks to a fully analytical ( albeit approximate ) formula , derived and discussed in details in the appendix .
we have checked the excellent consistency with the other approach based on @xcite by comparing our results with fig.3 of @xcite .
we emphasize a few advantages of this procedure , + 1 ) the results are exact in the case of the cmb distribution , that is a thermal distribution ; + 2 ) such a procedure allows one to vary the parameters of the radiation field very easily , discussing the effect of errors and uncertainties ; + 3 ) the very same formalism allow us to model the effect of new hypothetical radiation background .
a photon with energy @xmath22 emitted from an astrophysical source can interact during its travel to the earth with ambient photons , producing electron - positron pairs .
the probability that it will reach the earth is @xmath23\ ] ] where @xmath24 is the opacity . in the interstellar medium ,
different radiation fields can offer a target to astrophysical photons and determine their absorption : the total opacity is therefore the sum of various contributions , @xmath25 where the index @xmath19 indicates the components of the background radiation field that causes absorption .
these include the cmb , as well as the ir and sl backgrounds , and possibly new ones , present near the region of the galactic center .
.values of the parameters of the background radiation fields used for the computation of the absorption factor of the @xmath0-rays from the galactic center : the black body temperature @xmath20 , the non - thermic parameter @xmath21 , the typical length @xmath26 ( namely the distance of the galactic center for cmb and the exponential scales for the ir and sl radiation fields ) the total density of photons @xmath27 ( obtained from eq .
[ nonno ] ) , the typical energy @xmath28 ( obtained from eq . [ nonna ] ) . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] first , we examine the behaviour of the integrand in @xmath29 .
the function @xmath30 if @xmath31 ; on the contrary , when @xmath32 , it diverges like @xmath33 .
the divergence is compensated by the behavior of the function @xmath34 , that follows from @xmath35 at high values of @xmath36 . finally , @xmath37 at small values of @xmath36 . at this point , we study the behaviour of @xmath38 in @xmath39 : + for high @xmath39 we can consider only the first term of the expansion of @xmath34 , so the function @xmath38 is well approximated by : @xmath40 within an accuracy of 1% for @xmath41 . + for small @xmath39 the most important contribution to the integral is given when the @xmath42 diverges and the @xmath34 is not exponentially suppressed .
this condition is realized when @xmath43 and in this region @xmath44 ; for @xmath42 we can use the asymptotic expression , i.e. @xmath45 . the approximation of the function @xmath46 ) is given by : @xmath47 @xmath48 .
this implies the behavior , @xmath49 to within an accuracy of about 3% in the interval @xmath50 . a global analytical approximation of the @xmath38 , that respects the behavior for small and large values of @xmath39 , is given by eq .
[ eq : analyticapp ] .
its accuracy is @xmath51 into the interval @xmath52 .
when @xmath53 the function rapidly decreases , as we can see also from tab .
[ tab : val ] , where the values are obtained by numerically integrations without any approximation .
f. aharonian _ et al . _
[ hess collaboration ] , nature * 531 * ( 2016 ) 476 r. genzel , f. eisenhauer and s. gillessen , rev .
* 82 * ( 2010 ) 3121 g. ponti , m. r. morris , r. terrier and a. goldwurm , astrophys .
space sci .
* 34 * ( 2013 ) 331 m. freitag , p. amaro - seoane and v. kalogera , astrophys . j. * 649 * ( 2006 ) 91 m. su , t. r. slatyer and d. p. finkbeiner , astrophys .
j. * 724 * ( 2010 ) 1044 r. m. crocker and f. aharonian , phys . rev .
* 106 * ( 2011 ) 101102 y. fujita , s. s. kimura and k. murase , phys .
d * 92 * no.2 ( 2015 ) 023001 | the hypothesis of a pevatron in the galactic center , emerged with the recent @xmath0-ray measurements of h.e.s.s .
@xcite , motivates the search for neutrinos from this source .
the effect of @xmath0-ray absorption is studied : at the energies currently probed , the known background radiation fields lead to small effects , whereas it is not possible to exclude large effects due to new ir radiation fields near the very center .
precise upper limits on neutrino fluxes are derived and the underlying hypotheses are discussed . the expected number of events for antares , icecube and km3net , based on the h.e.s.s .
measurements , are calculated .
it is shown that km@xmath1-class telescopes in the northern hemisphere have the potential of observing high - energy neutrinos from this important astronomical object and can check the existence of a hadronic pev galactic accelerator . |
structure growth via mergers is one of the main predictions of cdm type cosmologies .
however , what is predicted is the merger rates of dark matter halos , which are not directly observable .
using dark matter halo merger rates to predict galaxy merger rates requires a theory of galaxy formation or at least a model of how galaxies populate dark matter halos . in a similar way ,
what can actually be observed are close galaxy pairs , disturbed galaxies , or morphological differences between galaxies , all of which can only be indirectly tied to galaxy mergers using theoretical models . thus connecting theory to observations
poses a number of difficulties which are often not given enough attention .
in particular the halo merger rate is often used as an indicator of galaxy merger rates .
if galaxy mass scaled linearly with dark matter halo mass then this could possibly be true .
but differences in the shapes of the galaxy stellar mass and halo mass functions imply that galaxy formation is much less efficient in low and high mass halos .
thus we should expect that galaxy merger statistics should differ from halo merging statistics .
the majority of theoretical studies of merger rates analyze mergers of dark matter halos in n - body simulations ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
while there has been no study comparing the results of different analysis , differing treatments at least show qualitative agreement .
a summary of the results from these studies for halos associated with galaxy are : + 1 . halos rarely have major ( greater than 1:3 ) mergers .
minor mergers ( of order 1:10 ) are very common .
the merger rate shows weak dependance on halo mass . +
these results are displayed in the left panel of figure [ fig : time ] taken from @xcite which shows the fraction of halos that have accreted an object of a given mass as a function of lookback time .
only about a third of halos have had a major merger event involving a sizable amount of the halos final mass ; however , @xmath0 of halos have had a merger with an object with a mass one tenth of the halo s final mass . creating this plot for different final halo masses results in almost no change aside from a very slight increase in the likelihood of a merger for all merger ratios .
to go from dark matter halo merger rates to galaxy merger rates requires a theory of galaxy formation .
unfortunately at this time we have no theory that matches all the observed properties of galaxies , so the best that can be done is to explore the predictions of a given model of galaxy formation .
one possibility is to study the merger rates of galaxies in hydrodynamical simulations @xcite .
however , one must keep in mind , that hydrodynamical simulations at this time do not produce the observed galaxy stellar mass function .
mergers in a hydrodynamical simulation are in most ways similar to the results of dark matter halos .
major mergers are rare .
however , the merger rate does seem to show a much stronger dependance on galaxy mass then it does on halo mass ( see * ? ? ?
* figure 9 ) .
there is some small difference in the kinematics of galaxies compared to dark matter halos , most notably in their dynamical friction time scales , but this is unlikely to be the primary source of this mass dependance .
a much more important effect is that stellar mass does not scale linearly with halo mass .
this means that the mass ratio of a galaxy merger may vary greatly from the mass ratio of the halos in which the galaxies reside .
this understanding can explain why hubble type is such a strong function of galaxy mass .
a 1:3 merger in halo mass could result in a 1:10 or a 1:1 merger in galaxy mass depending on how galaxies inhabit dark matter halos .
we do nt know exactly how to assign galaxies to halos , but we know that galaxy formation must be very inefficient for high and low mass galaxies .
this can be seen in the right panel of figure [ fig : time ] , which shows the fraction of halo mass in the central galaxy using equation 7 of @xcite , which is obtained from a sdss galaxy group catalogue . while one can argue about the details of this result , the generic shape of the function in the plot
is well established . just from the shape of this function
we can understand why hubble type is a strong function of galaxy or halo mass . for low mass halos the efficiency of galaxy formation increases with halo mass
; so if two low mass halos merge the ratio of the stellar masses will be less than that of the halos .
but for high mass halos the efficiency of galaxy formation decreases with increasing mass , which leads to more nearly equal mass galaxy mergers .
this is illustrated in figure [ fig : comp ] which shows the mean number of objects accreted above a certain mass for different mass halos .
the left panel shows the dark matter case and simply plots equation 3 from @xcite for four different halo masses . in comparison
the right panel shows the same results for galaxy mass where the function from @xcite has been used to convert halo mass to central galaxy mass .
the point of this figure is just to show the striking difference in the two cases .
while there is almost no mass dependence in the dark matter halo case , for galaxies the expected number of events can differ by almost two orders of magnitude .
thus we would expect galaxy morphology to show dependance on mass . in conclusion , mergers of dark matter halos
are largely independent of halo mass , but galaxy mergers are most likely very dependent on mass .
measurements of galaxy merger statistics can be used as direct tests of galaxy formation models .
while major mergers between halos are rather rare they can be relatively common between galaxies of certain masses depending on how galaxies inhabit dark halos . | in the cdm cosmological framework structures grow from merging with smaller structures
. merging should have observable effects on galaxies including destroying disks and creating spheroids .
this proceeding aims to give a brief overview of how mergers occur in cosmological simulations . in this regard
it is important to understand that dark matter halo mergers are not galaxy mergers ; a theory of galaxy formation is necessary to connect the two .
mergers of galaxies in hydrodynamical simulations show a stronger dependence on mass than halo mergers in n - body simulations .
if one knows how to connect galaxies to dark matter halos then the halo merger rate can be converted into a galaxy merger rate . when this is done
it becomes clear that major mergers are many times more common in more massive galaxies offering a possible explanation of why hubble type depends on galaxy mass . |
transport of molecules across cell membranes is an essential mechanism for life processes .
these molecules are often long and flexible , and the pores in the membranes are too narrow to allow them to pass through as a single unit . in such circumstances , the passage of a molecule through the pore i.e. its translocation proceeds through a random process in which polymer segments sequentially move through the pore .
dna , rna and proteins are naturally occurring long molecules @xcite subject to translocation in a variety of biological processes .
translocation is used in gene therapy @xcite , in delivery of drug molecules to their activation sites @xcite , and as an efficient means of single molecule sequencing of dna and rna @xcite .
understandably , the process of translocation has been an active topic of current research : both because it is an essential ingredient in many biological processes and for its relevance in practical applications .
translocation is a complicated process in living organisms its dynamics may be strongly influenced by various factors , such as the presence of chaperon molecules , ph value , chemical potential gradients , and assisting molecular motors .
it has been studied empirically in great variety in the biological literature @xcite .
studies of translocation as a _
biophysical _ process are more recent . in these
, the polymer is simplified to a sequentially connected string of @xmath0 monomers .
quantities of interest are the typical time scale for the polymer to leave a confining cell or vesicle , the `` escape time '' @xcite , and the typical time scale the polymer spends in the pore or `` dwell time '' , @xcite as a function of chain length @xmath0 and other parameters like membrane thickness , membrane adsorption , electrochemical potential gradient , etc . @xcite .
( large compared to the polymer s typical size ) .
the polymer repeatedly moves back and forth from one cell to the other through the pore . at any time
, exactly one monomer can be within the pore .
the kuhn length of the polymer and the lattice spacing are also set to unity .
polymers can be in three different states ( i ) state a : all monomers are in cell a ; ( ii ) state t ( threaded ) : some monomers are in cell a and the rest in cell b ; ( iii ) state b : all monomers are in cell b. the dwell time @xmath7 is defined as the pore - blockade time in experiments , i.e. , as how long the polymer spends in state t during a translocation event.[fig1 ] ] these have been measured directly in numerous experiments @xcite .
experimentally , the most studied quantity is the dwell time @xmath5 , i.e. , the pore blockade time for a translocation event . for theoretical descriptions of @xmath5 , during the last decade a number of mean - field type theories @xcite
have been proposed , in which translocation is described by a fokker - planck equation for first - passage over an entropic barrier in terms of a single `` reaction coordinate '' @xmath8 . here @xmath8 is the number of the monomer threaded at the pore ( @xmath9 ) .
these theories apply under the assumption that translocation is slower than the equilibration time - scale of the entire polymer , which is likely for high pore friction . in ref .
@xcite , this assumption was questioned , and the authors found that for a self - avoiding polymer performing rouse dynamics , @xmath10 , the rouse time . using simulation data in 2d , they suggested that the inequality may actually be an equality , i.e. , @xmath11 .
this suggestion was numerically confirmed in 2d in ref .
however , in a publication due to two of us , @xmath5 in 3d was numerically found to scale as @xmath12 @xcite .
additionally , in a recent publication @xcite @xmath5 was numerically found to scale as @xmath13 in three dimensions [ a discussion on the theory of ref .
@xcite appears at the end of sec .
[ sec3 ] ] . amid all the above results on @xmath5 mutually differing by @xmath14 ,
the only consensus that survives is that @xmath10 @xcite .
simulation results alone can not determine the scaling of @xmath5 : different groups use different polymer models with widely different criteria for convergence for scaling results , and as a consequence , settling differences of @xmath14 in @xmath15 , is extremely delicate .
an alternative approach that can potentially settle the issue of @xmath5 scaling with @xmath0 is to analyze the dynamics of translocation at a microscopic level .
indeed , the lower limit @xmath16 for @xmath5 implies that the dynamics of translocation is anomalous @xcite .
we know of only two published studies on the anomalous dynamics of translocation , both using a fractional fokker - planck equation ( ffpe ) @xcite
. however , whether the assumptions underlying a ffpe apply for polymer translocation are not clear .
additionally , none of the studies used ffpe for the purpose of determining the scaling of @xmath5 . in view of the above , such
a potential clearly has not been thoroughly exploited .
the purpose of this paper is to report the characteristics of the anomalous dynamics of translocation , _ derived from the microscopic dynamics of the polymer _ , and the scaling of @xmath5 obtained therefrom .
translocation proceeds via the exchange of monomers through the pore : imagine a situation when a monomer from the left of the membrane translocates to the right .
this process increases the monomer density in the right neighbourhood of the pore , and simultaneously reduces the monomer density in the left neighbourhood of the pore .
the local enhancement in the monomer density on the right of the pore _ takes a finite time to dissipate away from the membrane along the backbone of the polymer _ ( similarly for replenishing monomer density on the left neighbourhood of the pore ) .
the imbalance in the monomer densities between the two local neighbourhoods of the pore during this time implies that there is an enhanced chance of the translocated monomer to return to the left of the membrane , thereby giving rise to _ memory effects _ , and consequently , rendering the translocation dynamics subdiffusive .
more quantitatively , the excess monomer density ( or the lack of it ) in the vicinity of the pore manifests itself in reduced ( or increased ) chain tension around the pore , creating an imbalance of chain tension across the pore ( we note here that the chain tension at the pore acts as monomeric chemical potential , and from now on we use both terms interchangeably ) .
we use well - known laws of polymer physics to show that in time the imbalance in the chain tension across the pore relaxes as @xmath4 @xcite .
this results in translocation dynamics being subdiffusive for @xmath17 , with the mean - square displacement @xmath18 of the reaction co - ordinate @xmath19 increasing as @xmath2 ; and diffusive for @xmath20 . with @xmath21
, this leads to @xmath22 .
this paper is divided in four sections . in sec .
[ sec1 ] we detail the dynamics of our polymer model , and outline its implications on physical processes including equilibration of phantom and self - avoiding polymers . in sec .
[ sec2 ] we elaborate on a novel way of measuring the dwell time that allows us to obtain better statistics for large values of @xmath0 . in sec .
[ sec3 ] we describe and characterize the anomalous dynamics of translocation , obtain the scaling of @xmath7 with @xmath0 and compare our results with that of ref .
@xcite . in sec .
[ sec4 ] we end this paper with a discussion . ]
over the last years , we have developed a highly efficient simulation approach of polymer dynamics .
this approach is made possible via a lattice polymer model , based on rubinstein s repton model @xcite for a single reptating polymer , with the addition of sideways moves ( rouse dynamics ) and entanglement . a detailed description of this lattice polymer model , its computationally efficient implementation and a study of some of its properties and applications can be found in refs .
@xcite . in this model
, polymers consist of a sequential chain of monomers , living on a fcc lattice .
monomers adjacent in the string are located either in the same , or in neighboring lattice sites .
the polymers are self - avoiding : multiple occupation of lattice sites is not allowed , except for a set of adjacent monomers .
the polymers move through a sequence of random single - monomer hops to neighboring lattice sites .
these hops can be along the contour of the polymer , thus explicitly providing reptation dynamics .
they can also change the contour `` sideways '' , providing rouse dynamics .
time in this polymer model is measured in terms of the number of attempted reptation moves . a two - dimensional version of our three - dimensional model is illustrated in fig .
[ fig2 ] . from our experience with the model we already know that the dynamical properties are rather insensitive to the ratio of the rates for rouse vs. reptation moves ( i.e. , moves that alter the polymer contour vs. moves that only redistribute the stored length along the backbone ) .
since the computational efficiency of the latter kind of moves is at least an order of magnitude higher , we exploit this relative insensitivity by attempting reptation moves @xmath23 times more often than rouse moves ; typical values are @xmath24 , @xmath25 or 10 , which correspond to a comparable amount of computational effort invested in both kinds of moves .
certainly , the interplay between the two kinds of moves is rather intricate @xcite .
recent work by drzewinski and van leeuwen on a related lattice polymer model @xcite provides evidence that the dynamics is governed by @xmath26 , supporting our experience that , provided the polymers are sizable , one can boost one mechanism over the other quite a bit ( even up to @xmath27 ) before the polymer dynamics changes qualitatively . in order to further check the trustworthiness of this model , we use it to study the equilibration properties of polymers with one end tethered to a fixed infinite wall ( this problem relates rather directly to that of a translocating polymer
: for a given monomer threaded into the pore , the two segments of the polymer on two sides of the membrane behave simply as two independent polymer chains ; see fig .
[ fig1 ] ) .
this particular problem , wherein polymer chains ( of length @xmath0 ) undergo pure rouse dynamics ( i.e. , no additional reptation moves ) is a well - studied one : the equilibration time is known to scale as @xmath28 for self - avoiding polymers and as @xmath29 for phantom polymers . to reproduce these results with our model
we denote the vector distance of the free end of the polymer w.r.t .
the tethered end at time @xmath30 by @xmath31 , and define the correlation coefficient for the end - to - end vector as @xmath32 the angular brackets in eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) denote averaging in equilibrium .
the @xmath33 quantities appearing in fig .
[ fig3 ] have been obtained by the following procedure : we first obtain the time correlation coefficients @xmath34 for @xmath35 independent polymers , and @xmath33 is a further arithmatic mean of the corresponding @xmath35 different time correlation coefficients . for different values of @xmath0 we measure @xmath33 for both self - avoiding and phantom polymers .
when we scale the units of time by factors of @xmath36 and @xmath37 respectively for phantom and self - avoiding polymers , the @xmath33 vs. @xmath30 curves collapse on top of each other .
this is shown in fig .
note here that @xmath38 , which is sufficiently close to @xmath39 , and in simulations of self - avoiding polymers [ fig .
[ fig2](b ) ] we can not differentiate between @xmath40 and @xmath39 .
our translocation simulations are carried out only for self - avoiding polymers . for long polymers , full translocation simulations , i.e. ,
having started in one of the cells ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ) , finding the pore and distorting their shapes to enter the pore to finally translocate to the other side of the membrane are usually very slow .
an uncoiled state , which the polymer has to get into in order to pass through the pore is entropically unfavourable , and therefore , obtaining good translocation statistics for translocation events is a time - consuming process . to overcome this difficulty , in ref .
@xcite , we introduced three different time scales associated with translocation events : translocation time , dwell time and unthreading time . for the rest of this section ,
we refer the reader to fig .
[ fig1 ] . in states
a and b ( fig . [ fig1 ] ) , the entire polymer is located in cell a , resp .
b. states m and @xmath41 are defined as the states in which the middle monomer is located exactly halfway between both cells .
finally , states t and @xmath42 are the complementary to the previous states : the polymer is threaded , but the middle monomer is not in the middle of the pore . the finer distinction between states m and t , resp .
@xmath41 and @xmath42 is that in the first case , the polymer is on its way from state a to b or vice versa , while in the second case it originates in state a or b and returns to the same state . the translocation process in our simulations
can then be characterized by the sequence of these states in time ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ) . in this formulation , the dwell time @xmath7 is the time that the polymer spends in states t , while the translocation time @xmath43 is the time starting at the first instant the polymer reaches state a after leaving state b , until it reaches state b again . as found in ref .
@xcite , @xmath7 and @xmath43 are related to each other by the relation @xmath44 where @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 is the volume of cell a or b ( see fig .
[ fig1 ] ) .
the unthreading time @xmath48 is the average time that either state a or b is reached from state m ( not excluding possible recurrences of state m ) .
notice that in the absence of a driving field , on average , the times to unthread to state a equals the the times to unthread to state b , due to symmetry .
the advantage of introducing unthreading time is that when one measures the unthreading times , the polymer is at the state of lowest entropy at the start of the simulation and therefore simulations are fast and one can obtain good statistics on unthreading times fairly quickly .
additionally , the dwell and unthreading times are related to each other , as outlined below , and using this relation one is able to reach large values of @xmath0 for obtaining the scaling of the dwell time . the main point to note that the dwell time can be decomposed into three parts as @xmath49 whereas mean unthreading time can be decomposed into two parts as @xmath50 here @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 respectively are the mean first passage time to reach state m from state a , mean time between the first occurance at state m and the last occurance of state m with possible reoccurances of state m , and the mean first passage time to reach state b from state m without any reoccurance of state m. since on average @xmath54 due to symmetry , and all quantities on the r.h.s . of eqs .
( [ eq2 ] ) and ( [ eq3 ] ) are strictly positive , we arrive at the inequality @xmath55 since eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) is independent of polymer lengths , on average , the dwell time scales with @xmath0 in the same way as the unthreading time @xcite .
the reaction coordinate [ the monomer number @xmath56 , which is occupying the pore at time @xmath57 a convenient choice for the description of the microscopic movements of the translocating polymer , since the important time - scales for translocation can be obtained from the time evolution of the reaction coordinate @xmath56 as shown below . to delve deeper into its temporal behavior ,
we determine @xmath58 , the probability distribution that at time @xmath30 a polymer of length @xmath0 is in a configuration for which monomer @xmath59 is threaded into the pore , and the polymer evolves at time @xmath60 into a configuration in which monomer @xmath61 is threaded into the pore .
the subscript @xmath62 denotes our parametrization for the polymer movement , as it determines the frequency of attempted reptation moves and the sideways ( or rouse ) moves of the polymer .
[ sec1.1 ] for details . to maintain consistency , all simulation results reported here in this section are for @xmath63 , so we drop @xmath23 from all notations from here on .
this value for @xmath23 is used in view of our experience with the polymer code : @xmath63 yields the fastest runtime of our code ; this was the same value used in our earlier work @xcite .
as discussed in sec .
[ sec1.1 ] , this value of @xmath23 does not change any physics .
first , we investigate the shape of these probability distributions for various values of @xmath59 , @xmath61 and @xmath30 , for different sets of @xmath0 and @xmath62 values .
we find that as long as the @xmath30 values are such that neither @xmath59 nor @xmath61 are too close to the end of the polymer , @xmath64 depends only on @xmath65 , but the centre of the distribution is slightly shifted w.r.t .
the starting position @xmath59 by some distance that depends on @xmath59 , @xmath0 and @xmath23 .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ fig5 ] , where ( on top of each other ) we plot @xmath64 for @xmath66 and @xmath67 at @xmath68 time units , for @xmath69 , as well as the gaussian distribution .
notice in fig .
[ fig5 ] that the distribution @xmath64 differs slightly from gaussian ( the parameter for the gaussian is calculated by least - square optimization ) .
we find that this difference decreases with increasing values of @xmath30 ( not shown in this paper ) .
we now define the mean @xmath70\rangle(s_1,t)$ ] and the variance @xmath71 of the distribution @xmath64 as @xmath72\rangle(s_1,t)\,=\,\int ds_2\,p_{n}(s_1,s_2,t)\,(s_2-s_1 ) ; \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{-7.85cm}\langle\delta s^2(s_1,t)\rangle\,=\,\int ds_2\,p_{n}(s_1,s_2,t)\times\nonumber\\ & & \hspace{-5.8cm}\{(s_2-s_1)^2-\,[\langle s_2-s_1\rangle(s_1,t)]^2\}\ , , \label{eq5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the quantities within parenthesis on the l.h.s .
( [ eq5 ] ) denote the functional dependencies of the mean and the standard deviation of @xmath65 .
we also note here that we have checked the skewness of @xmath64 , which we found to be zero within our numerical abilities , indicating that @xmath64 is symmetric in @xmath65 . for @xmath69 , at @xmath68 .
note the data collapse when plotted as a function of @xmath65 .
the distribution differs slightly from gaussian .
[ fig5 ] ] in principle , both the mean and the standard deviation of @xmath65 can be used to obtain the scaling of @xmath7 with @xmath0 , but the advantage of using @xmath71 for this purpose is that , as shown in fig .
[ fig5 ] , it is independent of @xmath59 , so from now on , we drop @xmath59 from its argument . since unthreading process starts at @xmath73 , the scaling of @xmath7 with @xmath0 is easily obtained by using the relation @xmath74 in combination with the fact that the scalings of @xmath7 and @xmath48 with @xmath0 behave in the same way [ inequality ( [ eq4 ] ) ] .
note here that eq .
( [ eq6 ] ) uses the fact that for an unthreading process the polymer only has to travel a length @xmath75 along its contour in order to leave the pore . the key step in
quantitatively formulating the anomalous dynamics of translocation is the following observation : a translocating polymer comprises of _ two polymer segments tethered at opposite ends of the pore _ that are able to exchange monomers between them through the pore ; so _ each acts as a reservoir of monomers for the other . _
the velocity of translocation @xmath76 , representing monomer current , responds to @xmath77 , the imbalance in the monomeric chemical potential across the pore acting as `` voltage '' .
simultaneously , @xmath77 also adjusts in response to @xmath78 . in the presence of memory effects , they are related to each other by @xmath79 via the memory kernel @xmath80 , which can be thought of as the ( time - dependent ) ` impedance ' of the system .
supposing a zero - current equilibrium condition at time @xmath81 , this relation can be inverted to obtain @xmath82 , where @xmath83 can be thought of as the ` admittance ' . in the laplace
transform language , @xmath84 , where @xmath85 is the laplace variable representing inverse time . via the fluctuation - dissipation theorem
, they are related to the respective autocorrelation functions as @xmath86 and @xmath87 . following monomer injection at the pore corresponding to @xmath88 , with @xmath89 .
see text for details .
red circles : @xmath90 , blue circles : @xmath91 , green circles : @xmath92 , solid black line : @xmath93 with @xmath94 for self - avoiding polymers .
the steeper drop at large times correspond to the exponential decay @xmath95 ( we have checked this , but have not shown in this letter ) .
[ fig6 ] ] the behaviour of @xmath80 may be obtained by considering the polymer segment on one side of the membrane only , say the right , with a sudden introduction of @xmath96 extra monomers at the pore , corresponding to impulse current @xmath88 .
we then ask for the time - evolution of the mean response @xmath97 , where @xmath98 is the shift in chemical potential for the right segment of the polymer at the pore .
this means that for the translocation problem ( with both right and left segments ) , we would have @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is the shift in chemical potential for the left segment at the pore due to an opposite input current to it .
we now argue that this mean response , and hence @xmath80 , takes the form @xmath101 . the terminal exponential decay @xmath95 is expected from the relaxation dynamics of the entire right segment of the polymer with one end tethered at the pore [ see fig .
[ fig3](b ) ] .
to understand the physics behind the exponent @xmath102 , we use the well - established result for the relaxation time @xmath103 for @xmath104 self - avoiding rouse monomers scaling as @xmath105 . based on the expression of @xmath103 ,
we anticipate that by time @xmath30 the extra monomers will be well equilibrated across the inner part of the chain up to @xmath106 monomers from the pore , but not significantly further .
this internally equilibrated section of @xmath107 monomers extends only @xmath108 , less than its equilibrated value @xmath109 , because the larger scale conformation has yet to adjust : the corresponding compressive force from these @xmath107 monomers is expected by standard polymer scaling @xcite to follow @xmath110\sim t^{-(1+\nu)/(1 + 2\nu)}$ ] .
this force @xmath111 must be transmitted to the membrane , through a combination of decreased tension at the pore and increased incidence of other membrane contacts .
the fraction borne by reducing chain tension at the pore leads us to the inequality @xmath112 , which is significantly different from ( but compatible with ) the value @xmath113 required to obtain @xmath114 .
it seems unlikely that the adjustment at the membrane should be disproportionately distributed between the chain tension at the pore and other membrane contacts , leading to the expectation that the inequality above is actually an equality .
we have confirmed this picture by measuring the impedance response through simulations . in ref .
@xcite , two of us have shown that the centre - of - mass of the first few monomers is an excellent proxy for chain tension at the pore and we assume here that this further serves as a proxy for @xmath115 .
based on this idea , we track @xmath97 by measuring the distance of the average centre - of - mass of the first @xmath25 monomers from the membrane , @xmath116 , in response to the injection of extra monomers near the pore at time @xmath81 . specifically we consider the equilibrated right segment of the polymer , of length @xmath117 ( with one end tethered at the pore ) , adding @xmath89 extra monomers at the tethered end of the right segment at time @xmath81 , corresponding to @xmath89 , bringing its length up to @xmath75 . using the proxy @xmath116
we then track @xmath97 .
the clear agreement between the exponent obtained from the simulation results with the theoretical prediction of @xmath118 can be seen in fig .
we have checked that the sharp deviation of the data from the power law @xmath93 at long times is due to the asymptotic exponential decay as @xmath95 , although this is not shown in the figure .
having thus shown that @xmath119 , we can expect that the translocation dynamics is anomalous for @xmath17 , in the sense that the mean - square displacement of the monomers through the pore , @xmath120 for some @xmath121 and time @xmath17 , whilst beyond the rouse time it becomes simply diffusive .
the value @xmath122 follows trivially by expressing @xmath18 in terms of ( translocative ) velocity correlations @xmath123 , which ( by the fluctuation dissipation theorem ) are given in terms of the time dependent admittance @xmath124 . and hence inversely in terms of the corresponding impedance . as a function of time @xmath30 , for @xmath125 ( orange ) , 200 ( red ) and 500 ( blue ) .
the thick black line indicates the theoretically expected slope corresponding to @xmath126 .
the dashed black line corresponds to @xmath127 , which would have been the slope of the @xmath128 vs. @xmath30 curve in a double - logarithmic plot , if @xmath7 were to scale as @xmath129 .
[ fig7 ] ] indeed , as shown in fig .
[ fig7 ] , a double - logarithmic plot of @xmath18 vs. @xmath30 is consistent with @xmath130 .
the behaviour of @xmath18 at short times is an artifact of our model : at short times reptation moves dominate , leading to a transport mechanism for `` stored lengths '' @xcite along the polymer s contour in which individual units of stored length can not pass each other .
as a result , the dynamics of @xmath19 , governed by the movement of stored length units across the pore , is equivalent to a process known as `` single - file diffusion '' on a line , characterized by the scaling @xmath131 ( not shown here ) . at long times
the polymer tails will relax , leading to @xmath132 for @xmath20 . the presence of two crossovers , the first one from @xmath133 to @xmath130 and the second one from @xmath126 to @xmath134 at @xmath135 , complicates the precise numerical verification of the exponent @xmath136 .
however , as shown in fig .
[ fig7 ] , there is an extended regime in time at which the quantity @xmath137 is nearly constant .
the subdiffusive behaviour @xmath138 for @xmath17 , combined with the diffusive behaviour for @xmath139 leads to the dwell time scaling as @xmath22 , based on the criterion that @xmath140 .
the dwell time exponent @xmath141 is in acceptable agreement with the two numerical results on @xmath5 in 3d as mentioned in the introduction of this letter , and in table i below we present new high - precision simulation data in support of @xmath22 , in terms of the median unthreading time .
the unthreading time @xmath48 is defined as the time for the polymer to leave the pore with @xmath142 and the two polymer segments equilibrated at @xmath143 .
both @xmath48 and @xmath7 scale the same way , since @xmath144 [ see eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) ] . [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] table i : median unthreading time over 1,024 runs for each @xmath0 .
our results have two main significant implications : * even in the limit of small ( or negligible ) pore friction , equilibration time scale of a polymer is smaller than its dwell time scale . yet , quasi - equilibrium condition can not be assumed as the starting point to analyze the dynamics of unbiased translocation , as has been done in the mean - field theories . * since @xmath145 , the diffusion in reaction - coordinate space is anomalous .
this means that the dynamics of the translocating polymer in terms of its reaction co - ordinate _ can not _ be captured by a fokker - planck equation in the limit of small ( or negligible ) pore friction .
+ in view of our results , a fokker - planck type equation [ such as a fractional fokker - planck equation ( ffpe ) ] to describe the anomalous dynamics of a translocating polymer would definitely need input from the physics of polymer translocation .
it therefore remains to be checked that the assumptions underlying a ffpe does not violate the basic physics of a translocating polymer .
we now reflect on the theory presented in ref .
@xcite .
we have defined @xmath5 as the pore - blockade time in experiments ; i.e. , if we define a state of the polymer with @xmath146 as ` 0 ' ( polymer just detached from the pore on one side ) , and with @xmath147 as ` n ' , then @xmath5 is the first passage time required to travel from state 0 to state n _ without _ possible reoccurances of state 0 . in ref .
@xcite , the authors attach a bead at the @xmath148 end of the polymer , preventing it from leaving the pore ; and their translocation time ( @xmath149 hereafter ) is defined as the first passage time required to travel from state 0 to state n _ with _ reoccurances of state 0 .
this leads them to express @xmath149 in terms of the free energy barrier that the polymer encounters on its way from state 0 to @xmath150 , where the polymer s configurational entropy is the lowest .
below we settle the differences between @xmath149 of ref . @xcite and our @xmath5 .
consider the case where we attach a bead at @xmath148 and another at @xmath151 , preventing it from leaving the pore .
its dynamics is then given by the sequence of states , e.g. , @xmath152 where the corresponding times taken ( @xmath149 and @xmath5 ) are indicated . at state x and
x@xmath153 the polymer can have all values of @xmath8 except @xmath154 and @xmath0 ; and at states m and m@xmath153 , @xmath150 .
the notational distinction between primed and unprimed states is that a primed state can occur only between two consecutive states 0 , or between two consecutive states n , while an unprimed state occurs only between state 0 and state n. a probability argument then leads us to @xmath155 where @xmath156 , @xmath157 and @xmath158 are the probabilities of the corresponding states , @xmath159 and @xmath160 . since the partition sum of a polymer of length @xmath104 with one end tethered on a membrane is given by @xmath161 with @xmath162 a non - universal constant and @xmath163 @xcite , we have @xmath164\sim1/n$ ] .
similarly , @xmath165 @xcite .
finally , @xmath166 @xcite yields @xmath167 .
we have thus shown that the free energy barrier does not play a role for @xmath149 , implying that the theoretical expression for @xmath149 in ref .
@xcite can not be correct .
the numerical result @xmath168 in ref .
@xcite , however , confirms our theoretical expression @xmath22 .
to conclude , we have shown that for the swollen rouse chain , translocation is sub - diffusive up the configurational relaxation time ( rouse time ) of the molecule , after which it has a further fickian regime before the longer dwell time is exhausted : the mean square displacement along the chain is described by @xmath169 up to @xmath170 , after which @xmath171 .
consequently , the mean dwell time scales as @xmath172 . in future work
, we will study the role of hydrodynamics . rouse friction
may be an appropriate model for the dynamics of long biopolymers in the environment within living cells , if it is sufficiently gel - like to support screened hydrodynamics on the timescale of their configurational relaxation .
however , we should also ask what is expected in the other extreme of unscreened ( zimm ) hydrodynamics . for our theoretical discussion
the key difference is that , instead of the rouse time @xmath16 , in the zimm case the configurational relaxation times scale with @xmath0 according to @xmath173 in 3d , which upon substitution into our earlier argument would gives the lower bound value @xmath174 for the time exponent of the impedance , leading to @xmath175 ( whose resemblance to the rouse time is a coincidence note that with hydrodynamics rouse time loses all relevance ) .
these results , however , do need to be verified by simulations incorporating hydrodynamics .
j. kasianowicz _
et al . _ , pnas usa * 93 * , 13770 ( 1996 ) ; e. henrickson _
et al . _ ,
lett . * 85 * , 3057 ( 2000 ) ; a meller _ et al .
lett . * 86 * , 3435 ( 2001 ) ; m. akeson _
et al . _ ,
j. * 77 * , 3227 ( 1999 ) ; a. meller _ et al .
_ , pnas usa * 97 * , 1079 ( 2000 ) ; a. j. storm _
et al . _ ,
nanoletters * 5 * , 1193 ( 2005 ) .
strictly speaking , @xmath16 in this expression should be replaced by the characteristic equilibration time of a tethered polymer with length of @xmath177 ; since both scale as @xmath28 , we use @xmath16 here , favouring notational simplicity . in ref .
@xcite we overlooked the @xmath178 term of eq .
( [ eq2 ] ) to ( mistakenly ) deduce @xmath179 . nevertheless , due to the independence of eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) on @xmath0 our results for the scaling of @xmath7 in ref .
@xcite remain unaffected .
@xmath180 is a number slightly smaller than @xmath181 : if the polymer reaches @xmath150 from state 0 , due to the memory effects , it will have slightly higher chance to go back to state 0 rather than to proceed to state n @xcite . | in this paper , we investigate the microscopic dynamics of a polymer of length @xmath0 translocating through a narrow pore .
characterization of its purportedly anomalous dynamics has so far remained incomplete .
we show that the polymer dynamics is anomalous until the rouse time @xmath1 , with a mean square displacement through the pore consistent with @xmath2 , with @xmath3 the flory exponent .
this is shown to be directly related to a decay in time of the excess monomer density near the pore as @xmath4 . beyond
the rouse time translocation becomes diffusive . in consequence of this ,
the dwell - time @xmath5 , the time a translocating polymer typically spends within the pore , scales as @xmath6 , in contrast to previous claims . |
) by @xmath119 @xcite .
the lines represent the numerical results for the delta function ( i.e. , all nodes have same activity potential ) and power - law activity distributions .
the arrows indicate @xmath74^{-1}$ ] .
we set @xmath120 and @xmath121.,width=326 ]
we consider sis dynamics on a star graph with @xmath7 leaves and derive @xmath23 , @xmath25 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 .
let us denote the state of the star graph by @xmath122 , where @xmath123 and @xmath124 are the states of the hub and a specific leaf node , respectively , and @xmath125 is the number of infected nodes in the other @xmath126 leaf nodes .
although a general network with @xmath127 nodes allows @xmath128 states , using this notation , we can describe sis dynamics on a star graph by a continuous - time markov process with @xmath129 states @xcite .
we denote the transition rate matrix of the markov process by @xmath130 .
its element @xmath131 is equal to the rate of transition from @xmath132 to @xmath133 .
the diagonal elements are given by @xmath134 the rates of the recovery events are given by @xmath135 the rates of the infection events are given by @xmath136 the other elements of @xmath130 are equal to @xmath137 .
let @xmath138 be the probability for a star graph to be in state @xmath132 at time @xmath21 . because @xmath139 where @xmath140 is the @xmath129-dimensional column vector whose elements are @xmath138 , we obtain @xmath141 note that @xmath23 and @xmath25 are the probabilities with which @xmath142 at time @xmath6 , when the initial state is @xmath143 and @xmath144 , respectively , and that @xmath31 , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 are the probabilities that @xmath145 at time @xmath6 , when the initial state is @xmath144 , @xmath143 , and @xmath146 , respectively .
therefore , we obtain @xmath147_{\{i , y , z\},\{i , s,0\ } } \\
\sum_{y , z}\left [ \exp({\bm{m}}\tau ) \right]_{\{i , y , z\},\{s , i,0\ } } \\ \sum_{x , z}\left [ \exp({\bm{m}}\tau ) \right]_{\{x , i , z\},\{s , i,0\ } }
\\ \sum_{x , z}\left [ \exp({\bm{m}}\tau ) \right]_{\{x , i , z\},\{i , s,0\ } } \\ \sum_{x , z}\left [ \exp({\bm{m}}\tau ) \right]_{\{x , i , z\},\{s , s,1\ } } \end{pmatrix}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath76 , eq . (
[ eq : cis ] ) yields @xmath148 , \nonumber \\ \\ & & c_2=c_4= \nonumber \\ & & \frac{e^{-\tau}}{2 } \left[-e^{-\beta\tau } + e^{-\frac{1+\beta}{2}\tau}\left(\cosh\frac{\kappa\tau}{2}+\frac{1 + 3\beta}{\kappa}\sinh\frac{\kappa\tau}{2}\right)\right ] , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath149 , and @xmath33 is not defined .
when @xmath81 , we can apply an individual - based approximation @xcite .
we assume that the state of each node is statistically independent of each other , i.e. , @xmath150 where @xmath151 , for example , is the probability that the hub takes state @xmath123 .
we have suppressed @xmath21 in eq .
( [ eq : independent assumption ] ) . under the individual - based approximation ,
@xmath123 and @xmath124 obey bernoulli distributions with parameters @xmath152 and @xmath153 , respectively , and @xmath125 obeys a binomial distribution with parameters @xmath126 and @xmath154 , where @xmath155 is given by @xmath156 by substituting eq .
( [ eq : p ] ) in the time derivative of eq .
( [ pmf ] ) , we obtain @xmath157 if @xmath158 , @xmath159 obeys linear dynamics given by @xmath160 where @xmath161 in a similar fashion to the derivation of eq .
( [ eq : cis ] ) , we obtain @xmath162_{11 } \\ [ \exp({\bm{m}}^{\rm mf}\tau)]_{12 } \\
[ \exp({\bm{m}}^{\rm mf}\tau)]_{22 } \\ [ \exp({\bm{m}}^{\rm mf}\tau)]_{21 } \\
\frac{1}{m-1}[\exp({\bm{m}}^{\rm mf}\tau)]_{23 } \end{pmatrix } \nonumber \\ & = & e^{-\tau } \begin{pmatrix } { \cosh^{}(\beta{\sqrt{m}}\tau)}\\ \frac{1}{{\sqrt{m } } } { \sinh^{}(\beta{\sqrt{m}}\tau)}\\ 1+\frac{{\cosh^{}(\beta{\sqrt{m}}\tau)}-1}{m } \\
\frac{1}{{\sqrt{m}}}{\sinh^{}(\beta{\sqrt{m}}\tau)}\\ \frac{1}{m}{({\cosh^{}(\beta{\sqrt{m}}\tau)}-1)}\end{pmatrix}. \label{eq : cis for large m}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we estimate the extent to which eq .
( [ eq : cis for large m ] ) is valid as follows .
first , we need @xmath81 , because the initial condition @xmath163 should satisfy @xmath158 .
second , @xmath164 must satisfy @xmath165 because @xmath166 in eq .
( [ eq : pdotmf ] ) . to satisfy @xmath158 ,
we need @xmath167 . these two conditions are sufficient for this approximation to be valid .
at the epidemic threshold , the largest eigenvalue of @xmath168 is equal to unity .
let @xmath169 be the corresponding eigenvector of @xmath168 .
we normalize @xmath170 such that @xmath171 . by substituting eq .
( 7 ) in @xmath172 , we obtain the system of equations @xmath173 equation ( [ v3 ] ) gives @xmath174 where @xmath175 by combining eqs .
( [ v2 ] ) and ( [ eq : vj ] ) , we obtain @xmath176v_2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath177 because @xmath170 is normalized , we obtain @xmath178\left [ 1-(1+qs)r \right]}{r+{\langle a^{}\rangle}+(1+qs)\left [ q-{\langle a^{}\rangle}\right]r } \\ \frac{\left [ 1-\frac{q}{{\langle a^{}\rangle } } \right](q+r)}{r+{\langle a^{}\rangle}+(1+qs)\left [ q-{\langle a^{}\rangle}\right]r } \\
\frac{\frac{q}{{\langle a^{}\rangle}}\left [ 1-\frac{q}{{\langle a^{}\rangle } } \right](q+r)}{r+{\langle a^{}\rangle}+(1+qs)\left [ q-{\langle a^{}\rangle}\right]r } \\
\frac{\left(\frac{q}{{\langle a^{}\rangle}}\right)^2\left [ 1-\frac{q}{{\langle a^{}\rangle } } \right](q+r)}{r+{\langle a^{}\rangle}+(1+qs)\left [ q-{\langle a^{}\rangle}\right]r}\\ \vdots \end{pmatrix}. \label{eq : v}\ ] ] equation ( [ v1 ] ) leads to @xmath179v_1 = { \langle a^{}\rangle}\left [ ss + ( 1+qs)u \right]v_2 , \label{eq : v12}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , @xmath180 by substituting eq .
( [ eq : v ] ) in eq .
( [ eq : v12 ] ) , we obtain @xmath181 which is eq .
( 8) in the main text . if all nodes have the same activity potential @xmath20 , eq .
( [ eq : f derivation ] ) is reduced to @xmath182
when @xmath81 , the epidemic threshold can be obtained by the individual - based approximation @xcite .
we assume that all nodes have the same activity potential @xmath20 . by substituting eq .
( [ eq : cis for large m ] ) in eq .
( [ eq : f for same activity ] ) , we obtain @xmath183 equation ( [ eq : et for large m ] ) agrees with the value derived in @xcite .
note that this approximation is valid only for small @xmath6 ( @xmath184 ) .
in the limit @xmath185 , we obtain @xmath98 ( @xmath186 ) . for general activity distributions
, @xmath187 leads to @xmath188 where @xmath189^{-3}\left[2-(m+1){\langle a^{}\rangle}\right]s\left(\frac{{\langle a^{}\rangle}}{1-m{\langle a^{}\rangle}}\right)\nonumber\\ & + & m{\langle a^{}\rangle}\left [ 1-m{\langle a^{}\rangle}\right]^{-2}\left [ m+1-(m^2 + 1){\langle a^{}\rangle}\right],\\ d & = & m^2{\langle a^{}\rangle}^2\left [ 1-m{\langle a^{}\rangle}\right]^{-3}\left[1-(m+1){\langle a^{}\rangle}\right]s\left(\frac{{\langle a^{}\rangle}}{1-m{\langle a^{}\rangle}}\right)\nonumber\\ & -&m^2{\langle a^{}\rangle}^2\left [ 1-m{\langle a^{}\rangle}\right]^{-2}. \end{aligned}\ ] ]
at @xmath191 , an infinitesimal increase in @xmath6 from @xmath137 to @xmath192 does not change the @xmath60 value . for general activity distributions , by setting @xmath193 for @xmath67 given by eq .
( [ eq : f derivation ] ) , we obtain @xmath194
( eq . ( [ eq : tau star for clique ] ) ) and @xmath103 , respectively .
all nodes are assumed to have the same activity potential given by eq .
( [ eq : a for clique ] ) .
we set @xmath116.,width=326 ] we consider the case in which an activated node creates a clique ( a fully - connected subgraph ) with @xmath7 randomly chosen nodes instead of a star graph .
this situation models a group conversation among @xmath127 people .
we only consider the case in which all nodes have the same activity potential @xmath20 . the mean degree for a network in a single time window is given by @xmath195 .
the aggregate network is the complete graph .
we impose @xmath196 so that cliques in the same time window do not overlap . as in the case of the activity - driven model
, we denote the state of a clique by @xmath197 , where @xmath123 and @xmath124 are the states of the activated node and another specific node , respectively , and @xmath125 is the number of infected nodes in the other @xmath126 nodes .
the transition rate matrix of the sis dynamics on this temporal network model is given as follows .
the rates of the recovery events are given by eqs .
( [ eq : recovery1 ] ) , ( [ eq : recovery2 ] ) , and ( [ eq : recovery3 ] ) .
the rates of the infection events are given by @xmath198 we obtain @xmath34 @xmath99 from @xmath130 in the same fashion as in the case of the activity - driven model . because of the symmetry inherent in a clique , we obtain @xmath199 and @xmath200 .
therefore , eq . ( [ eq : f for same activity ] ) is reduced to @xmath201 calculations similar to the case of the activity - driven model lead to @xmath202 the phase diagram shown in fig .
[ fs2 ] is qualitatively the same as those for the activity - driven model ( fig .
note that , in fig .
[ fs2 ] , we selected the activity potential value @xmath20 to force @xmath60 to be independent of @xmath7 at @xmath203 , i.e. , @xmath204 although eq .
( [ eq : tau star for clique ] ) coincides with the expression of @xmath117 for the activity - driven model ( eq .
( 10 ) ) , @xmath117 as a function of @xmath7 is different between the activity - driven model ( solid line in fig .
3(a ) ) and the present clique network model ( solid line in fig .
[ fs2 ] ) .
this is because the values of @xmath20 are different between the two cases when @xmath205 .
5ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/18/7/073013
[ * * , ( ) ] https://www.amazon.com/guide-temporal-networks-complexity-science-ebook/dp/b01kjcomfw{%}3fsubscriptionid{%}3d0jyn1nvw651kca56c102{%}26tag{%}3dtechkie-20{%}26linkcode{%}3dxm2{%}26camp{%}3d2025{%}26creative{%}3d165953{%}26creativeasin{%}3db01kjcomfw[__ ] ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1007/s00285 - 010 - 0344-x [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevx.5.021005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.87.925 [ * * , ( ) ] | social contact networks underlying epidemic processes in humans and animals are highly dynamic
. the spreading of infections on such temporal networks can differ dramatically from spreading on static networks .
we theoretically investigate the effects of concurrency , the number of neighbors that a node has at a given time point , on the epidemic threshold in the stochastic susceptible - infected - susceptible dynamics on temporal network models .
we show that network dynamics can suppress epidemics ( i.e. , yield a higher epidemic threshold ) when nodes concurrency is low , but can also enhance epidemics when the concurrency is high .
we analytically determine different phases of this concurrency - induced transition , and confirm our results with numerical simulations .
_ introduction : _ social contact networks on which infectious diseases occur in humans and animals or viral information spreads online and offline are mostly dynamic .
switching of partners and ( usually non - markovian ) activity of individuals , for example , shape network dynamics on such temporal networks @xcite .
better understanding of epidemic dynamics on temporal networks is needed to help improve predictions of , and interventions in , emergent infectious diseases , to design vaccination strategies , and to identify viral marketing opportunities .
this is particularly so because what we know about epidemic processes on static networks @xcite is only valid when the timescales of the network dynamics and of the infectious processes are well separated .
in fact , temporal properties of networks , such as long - tailed distributions of inter - contact times , temporal and cross - edge correlation in inter - contact times , and entries and exits of nodes , considerably alter how infections spread in a network @xcite .
in the present study , we focus on a relatively neglected component of temporal networks , i.e. , the number of concurrent contacts that a node has .
even if two temporal networks are the same when aggregated over a time horizon , they may be different as temporal networks due to different levels of concurrency .
concurrency is a long - standing concept in epidemiology , in particular in the context of monogamy / polygamy affecting sexually transmitted infections @xcite .
modeling studies to date largely agree that a level of high concurrency ( e.g. , polygamy as opposed to monogamy ) enhances epidemic spreading in a population .
however , this finding , while intuitive , lacks theoretical underpinning .
first , some models assume that the mean degree , or equivalently the average contact rate , of nodes increases as the concurrency increases @xcite . in these cases , the observed enhancement in epidemic spreading is an obvious outcome of a higher density of edges rather than a high concurrency .
second , other models that vary the level of concurrency while preserving the mean degree are numerical @xcite . in the present study , we build on the analytically - tractable activity - driven model of temporal networks @xcite to explicitly modulate the size of the concurrently active network with the structure of the aggregate network fixed . with this machinery , we show that the dynamics of networks can either enhance or suppress infection , depending on the amount of concurrency that individual nodes have . note that analysis of epidemic processes driven by discrete pairwise contact events , which is a popular approach @xcite , does not address the problem of concurrency because we must be able to control the number of simultaneously active links possessed by a node in order to examine the role of concurrency without confounding with other aspects .
_ model : _ we consider the following continuous - time susceptible - infected - susceptible ( sis ) model on a discrete - time variant of activity - driven networks , which is a generative model of temporal networks @xcite . the number of nodes is denoted by @xmath0 .
each node @xmath1 @xmath2 is assigned an activity potential @xmath3 , drawn from a probability density @xmath4 @xmath5 .
activity potential @xmath3 is the probability with which node @xmath1 is activated in a window of constant duration @xmath6 . if activated , node @xmath1 creates @xmath7 undirected links each of which connects to a randomly selected node ( fig .
[ f1 ] ) .
if two nodes are activated and send edges to each other , we only create one edge between them . however , for large @xmath0 and relatively small @xmath3 , such events rarely occur .
after a fixed time @xmath6 , all edges are discarded .
then , in the next time window , each node is again activated with probability @xmath3 , independently of the activity in the previous time window , and connects to randomly selected nodes by @xmath7 undirected links .
we repeat this procedure .
therefore , the network changes from one time window to another and is an example of a switching network @xcite .
a large @xmath6 implies that network dynamics are slow compared to epidemic dynamics . in the limit of @xmath8 , the network blinks infinitesimally fast , enabling the dynamical process to be approximated on a time - averaged static network , as in @xcite .
.,width=326 ] for the sis dynamics , each node takes either the susceptible or infected state . at any time , each susceptible node contracts infection at rate @xmath9 per infected neighboring node .
each infected node recovers at rate @xmath10 irrespectively of the neighbors states .
changing @xmath6 to @xmath11 @xmath12 is equivalent to changing @xmath9 and @xmath10 to @xmath13 and @xmath14 , respectively , whilst leaving @xmath6 unchanged .
therefore , we set @xmath15 without loss of generality . _
analysis : _ we calculate the epidemic threshold as follows . for the sake of the analysis , we assume that star graphs generated by an activated node , which we call the hub , are disjoint from each other . because a star graph with hub node @xmath1 overlaps with another star graph with probability @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is the mean activity potential , we impose @xmath18 .
we denote by @xmath19 the probability that a node with activity @xmath20 is infected at time @xmath21 .
the fraction of infected nodes in the entire network at time @xmath21 is given by @xmath22 .
let @xmath23 be the probability with which the hub in an isolated star graph is infected at time @xmath24 , when the hub is the only infected node at time @xmath21 and the network has switched to a new configuration right at time @xmath21 .
let @xmath25 be the probability with which the hub is infected at @xmath24 when only a single leaf node is infected at @xmath21 .
the probability that a hub with activity potential @xmath20 is infected after the duration @xmath6 of the star graph , denoted by @xmath26 , is given by @xmath27 in deriving eq .
( [ eq : rho1 ] ) , we considered the situation near the epidemic threshold such that at most one node is infected in the star graph at time @xmath21 ( and hence @xmath28 ) . the probability that a leaf with activity potential @xmath20 that has a hub neighbor with activity potential @xmath29 is infected after time @xmath6 is analogously given by @xmath30 where @xmath31 , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 are the probabilities with which a leaf node with activity potential @xmath20 is infected after duration @xmath6 when only that leaf node , the hub , and a different leaf node is infected at time @xmath21 , respectively .
we derive formulas for @xmath34 @xmath35 in the supplemental material .
the probability that an isolated node with activity potential @xmath20 is infected after time @xmath6 is given by @xmath36 . by combining these contributions
, we obtain @xmath37 to analyze eq .
( [ eq : rho ] ) further , we take a generating function approach . by multiplying eq .
( [ eq : rho ] ) by @xmath38 and averaging over @xmath20 , we obtain @xmath39{g^{}(z ) } , \label{eq : theta}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 is the probability generating function of @xmath20 , @xmath46 , and throughout the paper the superscript @xmath47 represents the @xmath48-th derivative with respect to @xmath49 .
we expand @xmath19 as a maclaurin series as follows : @xmath50 let @xmath51 be the fraction of initially infected nodes , which are uniformly randomly selected , independently of @xmath20 .
we represent the initial condition as @xmath52 .
epidemic dynamics near the epidemic threshold obey linear dynamics given by @xmath53 by substituting @xmath54 and @xmath55 in eq .
( [ eq : theta ] ) , we obtain @xmath56 a positive prevalence @xmath57 ( i.e. , a positive fraction of infected nodes in the equilibrium state ) occurs only if the largest eigenvalue of @xmath58 exceeds @xmath59 .
therefore , we get the following implicit function for the epidemic threshold , denoted by @xmath60 : @xmath61 where @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 ( see supplemental material for the derivation ) .
note that @xmath67 is a function of @xmath9 ( @xmath68 ) through @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , and @xmath72 , which are functions of @xmath9 .
in general , we obtain @xmath60 by numerically solving eq .
( [ eq : implicit eq ] ) , but some special cases can be determined analytically . in the limit @xmath73 , eq .
( [ eq : implicit eq ] ) gives @xmath74^{-1}$ ] , which coincides with the epidemic threshold for the activity - driven model derived in the previous studies @xcite .
in fact , this @xmath60 value is the epidemic threshold for the aggregate ( and hence static ) network , whose adjacency matrix is given by @xmath75 @xcite , as demonstrated in fig .
s1 . for general @xmath6 , if all nodes have the same activity potential @xmath20 , and if @xmath76 , we obtain @xmath60 as the solution of the following implicit equation : @xmath77 \nonumber \\ & -&e^\tau+1 - 2a=0 , \label{eq : et for 1 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath78 .
the theoretical estimate of the epidemic threshold ( eq . ( [ eq : implicit eq ] ) ; we use eq . (
[ eq : et for 1 ] ) in the case of @xmath76 ) is shown by the solid lines in figs .
[ f2](a ) and [ f2](b ) .
it is compared with numerically calculated prevalence values for various @xmath6 and @xmath9 values shown in different colors .
equations ( [ eq : implicit eq ] ) and ( [ eq : et for 1 ] ) describe the numerical results fairly well .
when @xmath76 , the epidemic threshold increases with @xmath6 and diverges at @xmath79 ( fig .
[ f2](a ) ) . furthermore , slower network dynamics ( i.e. , larger values of @xmath6 ) reduce the prevalence for all values of @xmath9 . in contrast , when @xmath80 , the epidemic threshold decreases and then increases as @xmath6 increases ( fig .
[ f2](b ) ) .
the network dynamics ( i.e. , finite @xmath6 ) impact epidemic dynamics in a qualitatively different manner depending on @xmath7 , i.e. , the number of concurrent neighbors that a hub has . note that the estimate of @xmath60 by the individual - based approximation ( @xcite , see supplemental material for the derivation ) , which may be justified when @xmath81 , is consistent with the numerical results and our theoretical results only at small @xmath6 ( dashed lines in fig .
[ f2](b ) ) .
( ( a ) , ( c ) , and ( e ) ) and @xmath80 ( ( b ) , ( d ) , and ( f ) ) . in ( a ) and ( b ) , all nodes have the same activity potential value @xmath20 .
the solid lines represent the analytical estimate of the epidemic threshold ( eq .
( [ eq : implicit eq ] ) ; we plot eq .
( [ eq : et for 1 ] ) instead in ( a ) ) .
the dashed lines represent the epidemic threshold obtained from the individual - based approximation ( supplementary material ) .
the color indicates the prevalence . in ( c ) and
( d ) , the activity potential ( @xmath82 , @xmath83 ) obeys a power - law distribution with exponent @xmath84 . in ( a)(d ) , we set @xmath85 and adjust the values of @xmath20 and @xmath86 such that the mean degree is the same ( @xmath87 ) in the four cases . in ( e ) and
( f ) , the activity potential is constructed from workspace contact data obtained from the sociopatterns project @xcite
. this data set contains contacts between pairs of @xmath88 individuals measured every @xmath89 seconds .
we calculate the degree of each node averaged over time , denoted by @xmath90 , and define the activity potential as @xmath91/m$ ] .
we simulate the stochastic sis dynamics using the quasistationary state method @xcite , as in @xcite , and calculate the prevalence averaged over @xmath92 realizations after discarding the first @xmath93 time steps .
we set the step size @xmath94 in ( a)(d ) and @xmath95 in ( e ) and ( f).,width=326 ] the results shown in figs . [ f2](a ) and [ f2](b ) are qualitatively simillar when the activity potential @xmath20 is power - law distributed ( figs .
[ f2](c ) and [ f2](d ) ) and when @xmath4 is constructed from empirical data obtained from the sociopatterns project @xcite ( figs .
[ f2](e ) and [ f2](f ) ) . to illuminate the qualitatively different behaviors of the epidemic threshold as @xmath6 increases , we determine a phase diagram for the epidemic threshold .
we focus our analysis on the case in which all nodes share the activity potential value @xmath20 , noting that qualitatively similar results are also found for power - law distributed activity potentials ( fig .
[ f3](b ) ) .
we calculate the two boundaries partitioning different phases as follows .
first , we observe that the epidemic threshold diverges for @xmath96 . in the limit @xmath97 ,
infection starting from a single infected node in a star graph immediately spreads to the entire star graph , leading to @xmath98 @xmath99 . by substituting @xmath98 in eq .
( [ eq : implicit eq ] ) , we obtain @xmath100 , where @xmath101 when @xmath102 , infection always dies out even if the infection rate is infinitely large .
this is because , in a finite network , infection always dies out after sufficiently long time due to stochasticity @xcite .
second , although @xmath60 eventually diverges as @xmath6 increases , there may exist @xmath103 such that @xmath60 at @xmath104 is smaller than the @xmath60 value at @xmath105 .
motivated by the comparison between the behaviour of @xmath60 at @xmath76 and @xmath80 ( fig .
[ f2 ] ) , we postulate that @xmath103 ( @xmath106 ) exists only for @xmath107 .
then , we obtain @xmath108 at @xmath109 .
the derivative of eq .
( [ eq : implicit eq ] ) gives @xmath110 . because @xmath108 at @xmath111 , we obtain @xmath112 , which leads to @xmath113 when @xmath114 , network dynamics ( i.e. , finite @xmath6 ) always reduce the prevalence for any @xmath6 ( figs .
[ f2](a ) , [ f2](c ) , and [ f2](e ) ) .
when @xmath115 , a small @xmath6 raises the prevalence as compared to @xmath105 ( i.e. , static network ) but a larger @xmath6 reduces the prevalence ( figs .
[ f2](b ) , [ f2](d ) , and [ f2](f ) ) . the phase diagram based on eqs .
( [ eq : tau star ] ) and ( [ eq : mc ] ) is shown in fig .
[ f3](a ) .
the @xmath60 values numerically calculated by solving eq .
( [ eq : implicit eq ] ) are also shown in the figure .
it should be noted that the parameter values are normalized such that @xmath60 has the same value for all @xmath7 at @xmath105 .
we find that the dynamics of the network may either increase or decrease the prevalence , depending on the number of connections that a node can simultaneously have , extending the results shown in fig .
[ f2 ] .
these results are not specific to the activity - driven model .
the phase diagram is qualitatively the same for a different model in which an activated node induces a clique instead of a star ( fig .
s2 ) , modeling a group conversation event as some temporal network models do @xcite .
, when the activity potential is ( a ) equal to @xmath20 for all nodes , or ( b ) obeys a power - law distribution with exponent @xmath84 ( @xmath82 ) .
we set @xmath116 at @xmath76 and adjust the value of @xmath20 and @xmath86 such that @xmath60 takes the same value for all @xmath7 at @xmath105 . in
the `` die out '' phase , infection eventually dies out for any finite @xmath9 . in the `` suppressed '' phase , @xmath60 is larger than the @xmath60 value at @xmath105 . in the `` enhanced '' phase , @xmath60 is smaller than the @xmath60 value at @xmath105 .
the solid and dashed lines represent @xmath117 ( eq .
( [ eq : tau star ] ) ) and @xmath103 , respectively .
the color bar indicates the @xmath60 values . in the gray regions , @xmath118.,width=326 ] _ discussion : _
our analytical method shows that the presence of network dynamics boosts the prevalence ( and decreases the epidemic threshold @xmath60 ) when the concurrency @xmath7 is large and suppresses the prevalence ( and increases @xmath60 ) when @xmath7 is small , for a range of values of the network dynamic timescale @xmath6 .
this result lends theoretical support to previous claims that concurrency boosts epidemic spreading @xcite .
the result may sound unsurprising because a large @xmath7 value implies that their exists a large connected component at any given time .
however , our finding is not trivial because a large component consumes many edges such that other parts of the network at the same time or the network at other times would be more sparsely connected as compared to the case of a small @xmath7 .
our results confirm that monogamous sexual relationship or a small group of people chatting face - to - face , as opposed to polygamous relationships or large groups of conversations , hinders epidemic spreading , where we compare like with like by constraining the aggregate ( static ) network to be the same in all cases . for general temporal networks , immunization strategies that decrease
concurrency ( e.g. , discouraging polygamy ) may be efficient . restricting the size of the concurrent connected component ( e.g. , size of a conversation group ) may also be a practical strategy .
another important contribution of the present study is the observation that infection dies out for a sufficiently large @xmath6 , regardless of the level of concurrency . as shown in figs . 3 and s1 ,
the transition to the `` die out ''
phase occurs at values of @xmath6 that correspond to network dynamics and epidemic dynamics having comparable timescales .
this is a stochastic effect and can not be captured by existing approaches to epidemic processes on temporal networks that neglect stochastic dying out , such as differential equation systems for pair formulation - dissolution models @xcite and individual - based approximations @xcite .
our analysis methods explicitly consider such stochastic effects , and are therefore expected to be useful beyond the activity - driven model ( or the clique - based temporal networks analyzed in the supplemental material ) and the sis model .
we thank leo speidel for discussion .
we thank the sociopatterns collaboration ( http:// www.sociopatterns.org ) for providing the data set .
t.o . acknowledges the support provided through jsps research fellowship for young scientists .
j.g . acknowledges the support provided through science foundation ireland ( grant numbers 15/spp
/ e3125 and 11/pi/1026 ) .
n.m . acknowledges the support provided through jst , crest , and jst , erato , kawarabayashi large graph project .
41ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physrep.2012.03.001 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) https://www.amazon.com/guide-temporal-networks-complexity-science-ebook/dp/b01kjcomfw{%}3fsubscriptionid{%}3d0jyn1nvw651kca56c102{%}26tag{%}3dtechkie-20{%}26linkcode{%}3dxm2{%}26camp{%}3d2025{%}26creative{%}3d165953{%}26creativeasin{%}3db01kjcomfw[__ ] ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1017/cbo9780511791383 [ _ _ ] ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.87.925 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 3 - 319 - 26641 - 1 [ _ _ ] , , vol .
( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/0378 - 8733(95)00268-s [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0025 - 5564(95)00093 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] arxiv:1611.04800 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1551000 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1097/01.olq.0000194586.66409.7a [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.mbs.2016.09.009 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase
10.1016/j.mbs.2004.02.003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1098/rspb.2000.1244 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/qad.0000000000000676 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/srep00469 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1038/srep03006 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.112.118702 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.117.228302 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.83.045102 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 1 - 4612 - 0017 - 8 [ _ _ ] , systems and control : foundations and applications ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.188701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1137/120893409 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/18/7/073013 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1017/nws.2015.10 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.71.016129 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1098/rsif.2007.1106 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s00285 - 010 - 0344-x [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1145/1281192.1281269 [ ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1371/journal.pone.0028116 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s10461 - 010 - 9787 - 8 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevx.5.021005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/srep31456 [ * * , ( ) ] * supplemental material for `` concurrency - induced transitions in epidemic dynamics on temporal networks '' * |
gravity is a universal and fundamental force .
anything which has energy creates gravity and is affected by it , although the smallness of newton s constant @xmath1 often means that the associated classical effects are too weak to be measurable .
an important prediction of various theories of quantum gravity ( such as string theory ) and black hole physics is the existence of a minimum measurable length @xcite .
the prediction is largely model - independent , and can be understood as follows : the heisenberg uncertainty principle ( hup ) , @xmath2 , breaks down for energies close to the planck scale , when the corresponding schwarzschild radius is comparable to the compton wavelength ( both being approximately equal to the planck length ) .
higher energies result in a further increase of the schwarzschild radius , resulting in @xmath3 . at this point
, it should be stressed that limits on the measurement of spacetime distances as well as on the synchronization of clocks were put in much earlier studies @xcite .
these limitations showed up when quantum mechanics ( qm ) and general relativity ( gr ) were put together under simple arguments .
it is more than obvious that in this context where one attempts to reconcile the principles of qm with those of gr there are several and even diverging paths to follow @xcite . in this framework ,
two of the authors ( sd and ecv ) tracked a new path and showed that certain effects of quantum gravity are universal , and can influence almost any system with a well - defined hamiltonian @xcite . although the resultant quantum effects are generically quite small , with current and future experiments , bounds may be set on certain parameters relevant to quantum gravity , and improved accuracies could even make them measurable @xcite . one of the formulations , among those existing in the literature , of the _ generalized uncertainty principle _ ( gup ) and which holds at all scales , is represented by @xcite x_i p_i [ 1 + ( ( p)^2 + < p>^2 ) + 2 ( p_i^2 + < p_i>^2 ) ] , i=1,2,3 [ uncert1 ] where @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 planck mass , and @xmath7 planck energy @xmath8 .
it is normally assumed that the dimensionless parameter @xmath9 is of the order of unity .
however , this choice renders quantum gravity effects too small to be measurable . on the other hand , if one does not impose the above condition _ a priori _ , current experiments predict large upper bounds on it , which are compatible with current observations , and may signal the existence of a new length scale .
note that such an intermediate length scale , @xmath10 can not exceed the electroweak length scale @xmath11 ( as otherwise it would have been observed ) .
this implies @xmath12 .
therefore , as stated above , quantum gravity effects influence all quantum hamiltonians @xcite .
moreover , some phenomenological implications of this interesting result were presented in @xcite .
the recently proposed _ doubly special relativity _ ( or dsr ) theories on the other hand ( which predict maximum observable momenta ) , also suggest a similar modification of commutators @xcite .
the commutators which are consistent with string theory , black holes physics , dsr , _ and _ which ensure @xmath13=0=[p_i , p_j]$ ] ( via the jacobi identity ) under specific assumptions lead to the following form @xcite = i [ comm01 ] where @xmath14 . equation ( [ comm01 ] ) yields , in @xmath15-dimension , to @xmath16 x p [ uncert2 ] where the dimensional constant @xmath17 is related to @xmath18 that appears in equation ( [ uncert1 ] ) through dimensional analysis with the expression @xmath19 = [ \alpha^2]$ ] .
however , it should be pointed out that it does not suffice to connect the two constants @xmath17 and @xmath18 through a relation of the form @xmath20 in order to reproduce equation ( [ uncert1 ] ) from ( [ uncert2 ] ) , or vice versa .
equations ( [ uncert1 ] ) and ( [ uncert2 ] ) are quite different and , in particular , the most significant difference is that in equation ( [ uncert1 ] ) all terms appear to be quadratic in momentum while in equation ( [ uncert2 ] ) there is a linear term in momentum .
commutators and inequalities similar to ( [ comm01 ] ) and ( [ uncert2 ] ) were proposed and derived respectively in @xcite .
these in turn imply a minimum measurable length _ and _ a maximum measurable momentum ( to the best of our knowledge , ( [ comm01 ] ) and ( [ uncert2 ] ) are the only forms which imply both ) x & & ( x)_min _ 0_pl + p & & ( p)_max .
it is normally assumed as in the case of @xmath9 that the dimensionless parameter @xmath21 is of the order of unity , in which case the @xmath22 dependent terms are important only when energies ( momenta ) are comparable to the planck energy ( momentum ) , and lengths are comparable to the planck length . however ,
if one does not impose this condition _ a priori _ , then using the fact that all quantum hamiltonians are affected by the quantum gravity corrections as was shown in @xcite and applying this formalism to measure a single particle in a box , one deduces that all measurable lengths have to be quantized in units of @xmath23 @xcite .
in order to derive the energy - time uncertainty principle , we employ the equations x & ~ & c + p & ~ & where @xmath24 is a characteristic time of the system under study , and it is straightforward to get x p e .
[ energytime1 ] substituting equation ( [ energytime1 ] ) in the standard hup , one gets the energy - time uncertainty principle e .
[ energytime2 ] it should be stressed that the characteristic time @xmath24 is usually selected to be equal to the planck time @xmath25 in the context of cosmology . the scope of the present work is to investigate in a cosmological setup what corrections , if any
, are assigned to physical quantities such as the mass and energy of the universe at the planck time .
in particular , our present approach , regarding the quantum gravity corrections at the planck time , has been based on a methodology that presented in the book of coles and lucchin @xcite . simply , in our phenomenological formulation instead of using the standard hup for deriving the planck time ( as done in [ 11 ] )
, we let ourselves to utilize various versions of the gup and basically apply the methodology presented in the previously mentioned book .
+ the significance of planck time _ per se _ is due to the fact that it is really a `` turning point '' because from the birth of the universe till the planck time quantum gravity corrections are significant ( classical general relativity does not work at all ) while after that general relativity seems to work properly .
in this section we investigate the effects of quantum gravity on the planck era of the universe . by employing the different versions of gup presented before ,
we evaluate the modifications to several quantities that characterize the planck era , i.e. planck time , length , mass , energy , density , effective number density and entropy .
this will enhance our understanding of the consequences of the quantum gravity in the universe during the planck epoch and afterwards . without wanting to appear too pedagogical ,
we briefly present how one can derive some physical quantities at the planck epoch starting from the hup . following the methodology of @xcite ( see page 110 ) , we first write the hup in the form e [ hup1 ] and we adopt as characteristic time @xmath24 of the system under study the planck time , i.e. @xmath25 , for which the quantum fluctuations exist on the scale of planck length , i.e. @xmath26 . in addition , the uncertainty in energy can be identified with the planck energy and thus @xmath27 .
thus , the hup as given in equation ( [ hup1 ] ) is now written as m_pl c^2 t_pl .
[ hup2 ] since the universe at planck time can be seen as a system of radius @xmath28 , the planck mass can be written as m_pl _ pl _ pl^3 [ mass2 ] where by employing the first friedmann equation the planck density , on dimensional grounds , reads
[ density1 ] substituting equations ( [ mass2 ] ) and ( [ density1 ] ) in equation ( [ hup2 ] ) , one gets _
pl^3 c^2 t_pl and therefore one can easily prove that the planck time is t_pl10 ^ -43sec .
[ plancktime ] all the other parameters are defined in terms of the planck time modulus some constants .
indeed , the planck length , density , mass , energy , temperature and effective number density are given by the following expressions _
pl1.710 ^ -33 cm , _ pl 410 ^ 93gcm^-3 , [ plancklen ] m_pl_pl l^3_pl2.510 ^ -5 g , e_plm_pl c^2 1.210 ^ 19gev , [ planckener ] t_pl k^-1_b 1.410 ^ 32k , n_pll^-3_pl ( ) ^3/2 10 ^ 98 cm^-3 .
[ plancktep ] the corresponding energy - time gup of equation ( [ uncert1 ] ) e _ pl [ gup2 ] where we have kept only the first gup - induced term of order @xmath30 .
note that the tilde denotes quantities with respect to the gup .
as expected , for @xmath31 the gup boils down to the standard form dictated by the heisenberg result ( @xmath32 ) . from the previously presented formalism ( see section i ) , the uncertainty in energy @xmath29 at the planck time is of order of the modified planck energy , i.e. @xmath33 , where the modified planck mass lies inside the universe s horizon of scale of the modified planck length , i.e. @xmath34 , and expands as _ pl=_pl^ _
[ mass1 ] the modified planck density can be easily derived from the first friedmann equation ( or , from the definition of the dynamical time scale ) and be given by _
pl [ rho1 ] modulus some constants . substituting equations ( [ mass1 ] ) and ( [ rho1 ] ) in equation ( [ gup2 ] ) ,
one gets an equation for the planck time which now has been affected by the quantum gravity corrections , namely _
pl_pl^3c^2 _ pl & & + c^2 _ pl & & + ^2_pl & &
. therefore , after some simple algebra , one gets the following equation ( ) ^2 ^ 4_pl - ( ) ^2_pl + 0 .
[ equation1 ] it is easily seen that if we choose @xmath35 to be strictly equal to zero then the current solution of the above equation reduces practically to that of the standard planck time ( cf .
( [ plancktime ] ) ) . on the other hand , @xmath36
$ ] equation ( [ equation1 ] ) has two real solutions of the form _ pl & = & f_(_0 ) + & = & t_pl f_(_0 ) [ solution ] where f_(_0)=^1/2 .
it is worth noting that for @xmath37 [ or , equivalently , @xmath38 we find @xmath39 , despite the fact that we have started from a completely different uncertainty principle .
this implies that in this specific case , i.e. @xmath37 , the gup - induced effects in equation ( [ solution ] ) can not be observed .
now we must first decide which is the important term when @xmath9 takes values in the set @xmath40 $ ] ; is it @xmath41 or @xmath42 ?
using some basic elements from calculus , one can prove that the function @xmath41 is continuous and increases strictly in the range of @xmath43 which implies that @xmath44 $ ] , where @xmath45 .
therefore , the modified planck time lies in the range t_pl _ pl t_pl . in the left panel of figure 1
, we present in a logarithmic scale the @xmath41 ( dashed line ) as a function of @xmath35 . practically speaking
, the @xmath41 term has no effect on the planck time . on the other hand , following the latter analysis , we find that the @xmath42 function ( solid line ) decreases strictly in the range @xmath43 which means that @xmath46 , where @xmath47 .
it becomes evident that as long as @xmath48 [ or , equivalently , @xmath49 the current gup can affect the planck quantities via the function @xmath42 .
for example , in the case where @xmath50 we find that @xmath51 . from a cosmological point of view , the ratio of the modified planck density , i.e. @xmath52 , versus the measured dark energy , i.e. @xmath53 with @xmath54 ( for details see @xcite ) , is given as ( 10 ^ 119 - 10 ^ 121 ) .
one now is interested to investigate if and how the main planck quantities related to the planck time are affected by the above quantum gravity corrections .
the corresponding relations are [ quantities ] = = = ( ) ^1/2= ( ) ^1/3= f_+ . finally , it should be stressed that the dimensionless entropy enclosed in the cosmological horizon of size @xmath55 now reads _
pl _ pl . [ entropy1 ] it is evident that the entropic content of the universe behind the cosmological horizon at the planck time is unaltered when quantum gravity corrections are taken into account .
therefore , the information remains unchanged : one particle " of planck mass is stored " in the planck volume of the universe at the planck time behind the cosmological horizon of size @xmath55 .
the corresponding energy - time gup of equation ( [ uncert2 ] ) becomes e _
. [ gup22 ] as it is anticipated , for @xmath56 ( or , equivalently , @xmath57 since @xmath58 ) the gup boils down to the standard form dictated by hup .
evidently , performing the same methodology as before ( see subsection b ) , we obtain the following equation [ new22 ] 2 ^ 2_0 ( ) ^2 ^ 4_pl- ( 1+_0)^2_pl+ 0 . in deriving equation ( [ new22 ] ) we have substituted the various terms as @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 , and @xmath58 . in this framework ,
equation ( [ new22 ] ) has two real solutions @xmath62 $ ] . these are _ pl = t_pl f_(_0 ) [ solution22 ] where f_(_0)= ^1/2 .
[ solution22 ] again it is routine to estimate the limiting values of @xmath63 @xmath64 therefore , the function @xmath65 does not play a significant role ( see the dashed line in the right panel of figure 1 ) , since the modified planck time tends to the usual value ( @xmath66 ) . on the contrary , if we consider the case of @xmath67 ( see the solid line in the right panel of figure 1 ) , then it becomes evident that for small values of @xmath68 the function @xmath69 goes rapidly to infinity . as an example for @xmath70 we find that @xmath71 .
thus the ratio of the modified planck density versus the measured dark energy now reads ~o ( 10 ^ 115 - 10 ^ 119 ) .
the main planck quantities related to the planck time are affected by the above quantum gravity corrections exactly in the same way as shown in equation ( [ quantities ] ) employing the current form of @xmath72 defined in equation ( [ solution22 ] ) .
furthermore , it is interesting to point out that the dimensionless entropy enclosed in the cosmological horizon of size @xmath55 remains unaltered @xmath73 .
this result is in accordance with the result derived in previous subsection ( see equation ( [ entropy1 ] ) ) .
therefore , the information in the planck volume remains unchanged even if one takes into account the quantum gravity effects , i.e. one particle " of planck mass is stored " in the planck volume of the universe at the planck time behind the cosmological horizon of size @xmath55 .
in this work we have investigated analytically the quantum gravity corrections at the planck time by employing a methodology that was introduced in the book of coles and lucchin @xcite .
specifically , in this work instead of using the standard hup for deriving the planck time ( as done in [ 11 ] ) , we let ourselves to utilize various versions of the gup . from our analysis , it becomes evident that the planck quantities , predicted by the generalized uncertainty principle gup , extends nicely to those of the usual heisenberg uncertainty principle ( hup ) and connects smoothly to them . we also find that under of specific circumstances the modified planck quantities defined in the framework of the gup are larger by a factor of @xmath74 with respect to those found using the standard hup .
these results indicate that we anticipate modifications in the framework of cosmology since changes in the planck epoch will be inherited to late universe through quantum gravity ( or quantum field theory ) . as an example
, the calculation of the density fluctuations at the epoch of inflation sets an important limit on the potential of inflation .
indeed , in the context of slow - roll approximation , one can prove that the density fluctuations are of the form @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the scalar field called inflaton , @xmath77 stands for the hubble parameter and @xmath78 is the potential energy of the scalar field .
assuming that @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the inflaton mass , and @xmath81 , we obtain @xmath82 . in order to achieve inflation
the scalar field has to satisfy the inequality @xmath83 @xcite . combining the above equations and utilizing the observational value @xmath84
, one gets @xmath85 . employing the quantum gravity corrections , the latter condition becomes @xmath86 . from the latter calculations it becomes evident that the quantum gravity corrections affect directly the main cosmological quantities ( such as the inflaton mass ) in the early universe , via the @xmath87 factor . due to the fact that the @xmath88 factor is the consequence of the quantum gravity _
per se _ ( based on the gup ) implies that it can not be re - absorbed by a redefinition of units . from the observational point of view
one can study the latter corrections in the context of the primordial gravitational waves which can be detected with very sensitive measurements of the polarization of the cmb ( see page 5 in @xcite ) .
it is interesting to mention here that the polarization of the cmb will be one of the main scientific targets of the next generation of the cmb data based on the planck satellite .
therefore , if in the near future the observers measure such an effect in the cmb data then we may open an avenue in order to understand the transition from the mainly - quantum gravitational regime to the mainly - classical regime .
we have already started to investigate theoretically the above possibility and we are going to present our results in a forthcoming paper . furthermore , it was also shown that the dimensionless entropy enclosed in the cosmological horizon does not feel " the quantum gravity corrections and thus the information remains unaltered .
therefore , the entropic content of the universe at the planck time remains the same .
this is quite important since entropy is the cornerstone for one of the basic principles of quantum gravity named holographic principle and for its incarnation known as ads / cft .
+ * acknowledgments * the authors thank the anonymous referee for useful comments and suggestions .
sd was supported in part by the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada and by the perimeter institute for theoretical physics .
d. amati , m. ciafaloni , g. veneziano , phys .
b * 216 * ( 1989 ) 41 ; m. maggiore , phys .
b * 304 * ( 1993 ) 65 [ arxiv : hep - th/9301067 ] ; m. maggiore , phys .
d * 49 * ( 1994 ) 5182 [ arxiv : hep - th/9305163 ] ; m. maggiore , phys .
b * 319 * ( 1993 ) 83 [ arxiv : hep - th/9309034 ] ; l. j. garay , int .
j. mod .
phys . a * 10 * ( 1995 ) 145 [ arxiv : gr - qc/9403008 ] ; f. scardigli , phys . lett .
b * 452 * ( 1999 ) 39 [ arxiv : hep - th/9904025 ] ; s. hossenfelder , m. bleicher , s. hofmann , j. ruppert , s. scherer and h. stoecker , phys .
b * 575 * ( 2003 ) 85 [ arxiv : hep - th/0305262 ] ; c. bambi and f. r. urban , class . quant .
* 25 * ( 2008 ) 095006 [ arxiv:0709.1965 [ gr - qc ] ] ; r. banerjee and s. ghosh , phys .
b * 688 * ( 2010 ) 224 [ arxiv:1002.2302 [ gr - qc ] ] . c. a. mead , phys .
* 135 * ( 1964 ) b849 ; t. padmanabhan , class .
grav . * 4 * ( 1987 ) l107 . g. amelino - camelia , mod .
lett . a * 9 * ( 1994 ) 3415 [ arxiv : gr - qc/9603014 ] ; y. j. ng and h. van dam , mod .
lett . a * 9 * ( 1994 ) 335 .
s. das , e. c. vagenas , phys .
* 101 * ( 2008 ) 221301 [ arxiv:0810.5333 [ hep - th ] ] .
g. amelino - camelia , int .
j. mod .
d * 11 * ( 2002 ) 35 [ arxiv : gr - qc/0012051 ] .
j. magueijo and l. smolin , phys .
* 88 * ( 2002 ) 190403 [ arxiv : hep - th/0112090 ] ; j. magueijo and l. smolin , phys .
d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 044017 [ arxiv : gr - qc/0207085 ] . | we investigate the effects of quantum gravity on the planck era of the universe . in particular
, using different versions of the generalized uncertainty principle and under specific conditions we find that the main planck quantities such as the planck time , length , mass and energy become larger by a factor of order @xmath0 compared to those quantities which result from the heisenberg uncertainty principle .
however , we prove that the dimensionless entropy enclosed in the cosmological horizon at the planck time remains unchanged .
these results , though preliminary , indicate that we should anticipate modifications in the set - up of cosmology since changes in the planck era will be inherited even to the late universe through the framework of quantum gravity ( or quantum field theory ) which utilizes the planck scale as a fundamental one .
more importantly , these corrections will not affect the entropic content of the universe at the planck time which is a crucial element for one of the basic principles of quantum gravity named holographic principle . |
in recent years , indirect evidence for the presence of convection in sunspot penumbral filaments has been growing ( e.g. , scharmer 2009 ) .
e.g. , the twisting motion of penumbral filaments is taken as a signature of overturning convection ( ichimoto et al .
2007 ; zakharov et al . 2008 ; spruit et al . 2010 ; bharti et al . 2010 ) . using high resolution spectropolarimetric observations ,
zakharov et al . ( 2008 ) estimated that such motions can provide sufficient heat to the surface layers of the penumbra to explain its relatively high brightness .
the correlation of the apparent velocity of the twisting motion with the local brightness of the filaments obtained by bharti et al .
( 2010 ) , supports convection as a major source of heat transport in sunspot penumbral filaments .
overturning convection in penumbral filaments is a natural and important feature in three - dimensional mhd simulations of sunspots ( rempel et al .
2009a , b ; rempel 2011 ) .
in particular , rempel et al .
( 2009b ) found upflows along the central axes and downflows at the edges of the filaments .
direct observational evidence for this scenario is , however , so far missing , because downflows have not been measured in the body of a penumbra , although the twisting filaments provide indirect support .
the simulations indicate that the convective structures and motions are restricted to the subsurface and surface layers .
since most spectral lines used for diagnostic purposes sample mid - photospheric heights , this may explain why it has not been possible to obtain direct evidence of overturning convection in penumbral filaments ( see , e.g. , franz & schlichenmaier 2009 ; bellot rubio et al .
in particular , downflows at the sides of penumbral filaments have not been reported . in this study
we probe the deep layers of the photosphere in search of such downflows by analyzing high resolution observations in [email protected] , obtained at the 1-m swedish solar telescope . in the quiet sun
, [email protected] has a mean formation height of around 40 km above the continuum optical depth @xmath1 at 500 nm ( stuerenburg & holweger 1990 ) making it ideal for this purpose .
we observed a decaying sunspot with a one - sided penumbra in active region noaa 11019 ( cf .
1 ) with the 1-meter swedish solar telescope ( sst ) on 2009 , june 02 . the center of the field of view ( fov ) was located at @xmath2 ( heliocentric angle = 32.7 ) . during the observations the seeing conditions were good to excellent , with only few interruptions by poorer seeing .
we carried out consecutive spectral scans of the photospheric [email protected] , [email protected] and the chromospheric ca@xmath0ii8542 spectral lines using the crisp imaging spectropolarimeter . here
we analyze only the [email protected] linei5250.2 line is used only to identify `` quiet sun '' locations , where the polarization signal in this line is below a given threshold . ] .
two liquid crystal variable retarders , used to modulate the light beam , and two 1k@xmath31k - pixel sarnoff ccd cameras , mounted behind a polarizing beam splitter , were used to record the full stokes vectors at each spectral position .
a third ccd camera was used to record broad - band images .
all three cameras were synchronized in order to allow post - facto image restoration .
we recorded the c@xmath0i5380 line at 8 wavelength positions ( @xmath4$]m ) .
scanning the line in all four stokes parameters required 14 s for the [email protected] line .
the cadence of these observations , including the [email protected] and ca@xmath0ii8542 scans ( not considered in the present study ) is 29s .
40m from average line center ) of the fe@xmath0i5250 line is greater than 4 % .
colored boxes ( @xmath5 ) show the different quiet sun fields used to calculate the velocity reference value .
the thick white rectangle marks the portion of the image shown in fig . 5 in detail.,scaledwidth=65.0% ] ( see eq . ( 1 ) ) .
the dotted curve represents the @xmath6 , i.e. , the fourier transform of a gaussian of @xmath7 width . , scaledwidth=60.0% ] to achieve near diffraction limited spatial resolution ( @xmath8 ) , images were reconstructed using the multi - object multi - frame blind deconvolution ( momfbd ) method ( van noort et al . 2005 ; lfdahl 2002 ) .
images observed in c@xmath0i5380 and fe@xmath0i5250 were aligned with sub - pixel accuracy by cross - correlating the corresponding continuum images .
we determined doppler velocities by fitting a gaussian function to the c@xmath0i line . due to the low land factor ( @xmath9 , solanki & brigljevic 1992 ) and large thermal width of the line ,
this is an acceptable approach even in a sunspot .
the good quality of the gaussian fit throughout the penumbra suggests that the line is unblended there , unlike in the umbra ( see sect .
another reason for expecting that the line is unblended ( or at the most rather weakly blended ) in the penumbra is that the line strength increases strongly with temperature , a nearly unique property of c@xmath0i lines among photospheric spectral lines .
the resulting velocity maps show variations of the mean quiet sun velocities across the fov caused by the absolute wavelength positions varying across the fov due to cavity errors of the etalons of crisp .
these wavelength shifts are smeared out in a continuously changing manner due to varying seeing conditions .
the applied calibration data ( flat fields ) , which are well defined in pixel space , are no longer connected to pixel space of the science data after restoration ( schnerr et al .
therefore , the cavity errors can not be fully removed with the flat fields .
the absolute wavelength shifts caused by the cavity errors are wavelength dependent and the residuals after correction for flat - field cavity shifts are much higher in the 5380 band than in the 6300 and 6560 bands , used in previous studies carried out with crisp ( see , e.g. , scharmer et al .
2008 ; rouppe van der voort et al . 2010 ; ortiz et al .
since the residual wavelength shifts across the fov are expected to be large - scale , however , they do not rule out a study of penumbral fine structure . in order to determine a confidence level of the resulting absolute velocity reference point of the doppler velocities we selected 19 quiet sun subfields of @xmath10 size throughout the fov , indicated by the colored squares in fig .
the relative quietness of the selected subfields was assured by a threshold value ( 4 % ) of spectrally averaged absolute circular polarization in the line wings ( @xmath11 40m from average line center ) of [email protected] .
we calculated mean doppler velocities of c@xmath0i5380 by spatially averaging the line profiles in each subfield and repeated this procedure for all the observed sequences , i.e. , over 20 min .
the results from this procedure are shown in fig . 2 .
the velocity in each subfield fluctuates randomly , but does not exhibit a systematic variation with time .
in order to get a mean quiet sun velocity reference , we fitted a gaussian to the velocity distribution and obtained a mean value of @xmath12480ms@xmath13 and a full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of 580ms@xmath13 for the c@xmath0i5380 line , i.e. , the residual uncertainty ( @xmath14 ) in the absolute doppler velocities is @xmath11248ms@xmath13 . after applying this procedure ,
the mean values of the obtained velocity maps are calibrated for a convective blueshift of @xmath12922ms@xmath13 for [email protected](de la cruz rodrguez et al .
2011 ) . for the further analysis we selected the scan of [email protected] made under the best seeing conditions .
ground - based observations are strongly affected by straylight , so that , e.g. , contrasts are significantly lower than in data recorded above the earth s atmosphere ( see , e.g. , danilovic et al .
2008 ; hirzberger et al .
we also expect the velocity to be reduced through straylight . the amount of straylight and the shape of the corresponding straylight point spread function is strongly dependent on the seeing conditions and on the instrument design .
the straylight point spread functions can be approximated from fitting observations of the solar limb ( aureolas , see , e.g. , sobotka et al . 1993 ) or from fitting the profiles of planetary limbs during transits ( see , e.g. , bonet et al .
1995 ; mathew et al . 2009
; wedemeyer - bhm & rouppe van der voort 2009 ) .
since we do not have these auxiliary data , we applied a rough estimation , assuming that the biggest amount of the straylight stems from regions within @xmath7 around the respective positions ( approximately the tenfold of the spatial resolution of the data ) , i.e. , we approximated the straylight point spread function with a gaussian of @xmath7 width . for deconvolving the images we used the wiener filter given in sobotka et al .
( 1993 ) and applied a slight modification , so that it has the shape @xmath15 where mtf is the modulation transfer function ( the modulus of the fourier transform of the point spread function ) , @xmath16 is the spatial wavenumber and @xmath17 is a free parameter which defines the straylight contribution that has to be deconvolved .
@xmath18 for different choices of @xmath17 is plotted in fig .
3 . the advantage of the present form of the filter compared to the one used in sobotka et al . ( 1993 ) is that it converges to unity for large @xmath16 , i.e. , it does not affect the small - scale structures of the images . in the present study
the value of parameter @xmath17 has been chosen equal to 2.0 , so that the resulting quiet sun rms image contrast for the continuum point ( at @xmath19m ) of the best scan increases from 8.5% in the original image to 13.0% in the deconvolved image , which is closer to , but still somewhat smaller than the contrast obtained from data at a similar wavelength that are much less contaminated by straylight ( continuum at 5250.4 in imax / sunrise observations , see martnez pillet et al .
we finally used this conservative choice , although we also tested other straylight functions , including broad gaussians with widths up to @xmath20 .
the results of using stronger straylight removal ( larger @xmath17 ) or broader gaussians , remained similar , but provided stronger downflows and , for larger @xmath17 , also stronger contrast .
stronger straylight removal also led to bigger scatter in the velocities and somewhat more distorted line profiles , which was another reason to keep to the conservative value of straylight .
we selected a @xmath21 field in the quiet sun to compare velocities before and after straylight removal .
results are shown in fig .
4 . the redshift in inter - granular lanes increases disproportionately through straylight removal ( see panels ( b ) , ( c ) and ( d ) of fig .
downflows are particularly affected by straylight because they are narrower and are present in darker features .
the fact that the downflows remain weaker than upflows also after our standard straylight removal confirms that we have been conservative in the removed amount of straylight .
panels ( a ) and ( c ) of fig . 5 show a portion of the observed penumbra as seen in the continuum intensity ( at @xmath22 m ) , before and after straylight removal , respectively .
the corresponding maps of doppler velocity are plotted in panels ( b ) and ( d ) .
obviously both blue- and redshifts are present in the penumbra , in particular after straylight removal . a striking feature in fig
5b is the localized patches of strong blueshift , up to 3.3 kms@xmath13 , coinciding with the bright heads of penumbral filaments .
these bright heads are surrounded by lanes of gas nearly at rest or slightly redshifted . in panel
( b ) significant redshifts are visible only at two locations , once at the side of a filament reaching into the umbra ( at @xmath23 and @xmath24 ) and once , rather weakly around the bright and strongly blueshifted head of a filament ( at @xmath25 and @xmath26 ) .
a number of new redshifted patches are found in the doppler map after straylight removal ( panel d ) , appearing dominantly at locations previously seemingly at rest in panel ( b ) .
we have grayed out areas where intensity is below 0.6 times that of the quiet sun , because @xmath27 values of the gaussian fits to the line profiles are high in these areas since the line is very weak there and possibly blended ( as suggested by the fact that we obtain mainly strong blueshifts in the umbra contrary to all previous studies based on other spectral lines ) .
redshifts ( largest value 2.0 kms@xmath13 ) show a tendency to be located in dark regions , as can be judged by considering the white contours in panel ( c ) .
these contours outline the redshift of panel ( d ) .
redshifts are now found clearly around the head of multiple filaments ( e.g. , at @xmath28 and @xmath29 and around the filaments protruding into the umbra ) .
narrow redshifted areas are also found in the middle and outer penumbra beside and between bright filaments .
clearly , in the lower photosphere redshifts are present at many different locations in the penumbra .
we expect that only a part of redshifted features actually present in the penumbra has been detected .
we have provided the first direct measurements of downflows ( reaching 2.0 kms@xmath13 ) in the body of a penumbra .
the studied sunspot , located at @xmath30 , had only a partial penumbra , on the disk - center side of the spot , so that all well - defined filaments partially point to disk center .
hence the evershed flow contributes a blueshift , so that redshifts in fig .
5d must be caused by downflows ( or inflow , which appears rather unlikely , however ) .
the c@xmath0i5380 line reveals a highly structured velocity pattern , with large variations in velocity around the head of filaments .
typical blueshift of 3kms@xmath13 found in the bright head of the filaments , surrounded by gas displaying redshift ( after straylight removal ) or no shift .
we interpret them as strong localized upflows of hot gas in the head of the filaments following rimmele & marino ( 2006 ) , , but can not rule out that they are due to evershed flow .
a fraction of this gas starts moving along the axis of the filaments and forming the evershed flow ( scharmer et al .
the rest of the gas moves to the sides of the filaments and flows downward .
further downflows are found alongside bright filaments in the middle and outer part of this penumbra .
such downflows have been predicted by models of penumbral convection ( e.g. , rempel et al .
2009a , b ; scharmer & spruit 2006 ) .
earlier observational studies have provided only indirect evidence for such downflows ( ichimoto et al .
2007 ; zakharov et al . 2008 ; bharti et al . 2010 ; spruit et al . 2010 ) .
the velocity at the heads of the filaments reaches values up to 3.3kms@xmath13 , interpreted here as upflows , agrees with earlier observational results ( rimmele 1995 ; rimmele & marino 2006 ; hirzberger & kneer 2001 ; hirzberger et al . 2005 ) .
such upflows are also consistent with the moving flux tube model presented by schlichenmaier et al .
( 1998 ) , which predicts an upflow of 4kms@xmath13 at the footpoints of the penumbral filaments , but equally with the interpretation of scharmer et al .
( 2008 ) that the evershed flow is a horizontal flow component of overturning convection . in recent years
, convection has become an important candidate to explain the heat transport in penumbrae . based on the observed 1kms@xmath13 upflow at the axis of the filament in the upper layers of the photosphere , zakharov et al .
( 2008 ) estimated the heat transport by convection in the penumbra to be sufficient for maintaining the brightness of the penumbra .
the upflows up to 3.3kms@xmath13 in the bright heads of penumbral filaments with downflows at the filament sides , found in the present study , and the coincidence of the strongest upflows with bright filaments and downflows with dark filaments strongly support that the heat transport in the penumbra is accomplished by convection . in the outer sections of penumbral filaments
( i.e. further from the umbra ) we found maximum blueshifts of up to 3.0kms@xmath13 .
if we assume that of this blueshift is due to the evershed effect , its projection in the direction of disk center and parallel to solar surface gives 8.5kms@xmath13 of radial outflow .
this upper limit agrees well with results from the simulation by rempel ( 2011 ) which shows evershed flow speeds above 8kms@xmath13 near @xmath31 .
the true strength of the penumbral downflows are expected to be larger than found here for the following reasons . for the same reasons we expect
a number of the locations still seemingly at rest , in reality be filled with downflowing gas . 1
. incomplete removal of straylight .
we have been rather conservative when removing straylight , since the assumed granular contrast of 13% is smaller than values found by mathew et al .
( 2009 ) at 5550 from hinode and martnez pillet et al .
( 2011 ) at 5250 from sunrise .
2 . a blueshift imposed by the los - component of the evershed flow .
the major axis of most of the filaments makes an angle of @xmath32 with the line joining the sunspot and the disk center .
thus , we expect radial outflow due to evershed effect to contribute as @xmath33 ( where @xmath34 represents the evershed velocity ) to the los velocity .
the evershed flow probably hides a significant amount of the redshift due to downflowing gas ( cf .
bharti et al .
3 . the geometry of the filaments . as proposed by zakharov et al . ( 2008 ) the penumbral @xmath35 surface is strongly corrugated , so that we see the disk center side of the filaments more clearly than the other side ( see their fig .
hence , in our sunspot we might expect the downflows to be better visible on the diskward side of a filament where they may be partly covered by the filament lying in front of them .
this interpretation is supported by the fact that the strongest downflows are found on the diskward side of a filament extending into the umbra , where no other filament can block the view of its edge .
this work has been partially supported by wcu grant no .
r31 - 10016 funded by the korean ministry of education , science and technology .
the swedish 1-m solar telescope is operated on the island of la palma by the institute for solar physics of the royal swedish academy of sciences in the spanish observatorio del roque de los muchachos of the instituto de astrofsica de canarias .
jj acknowledges a phd fellowship of the international max planck research school on physical processes in the solar system and beyond . , j. , feller , a. , riethmller , t. l. , schssler , m. , borrero , j. m. , afram , n. , unruh , y. c. , berdyugina , s. v. , gandorfer , a. , solanki , s. k. , barthol , p. , bonet , j. a. , martnez pillet , v. , berkefeld , t. , knlker , m. , schmidt , w. , & title , a. m. 2010 , , 723 , l154 , v. , del toro iniesta , j. c. , lvarez - herrero , a. , domingo , v. , bonet , j. a. , gonzlez fernndez , l. , lpez jimnez , a. , pastor , c. , gasent blesa , j. l. , mellado , p. , piqueras , j. , aparicio , b. , balaguer , m. , ballesteros , e. , belenguer , t. , bellot rubio , l. r. , berkefeld , t. , collados , m. , deutsch , w. , feller , a. , girela , f. , grauf , b. , heredero , r. l. , herranz , m. , jernimo , j. m. , laguna , h. , meller , r. , menndez , m. , morales , r. , orozco surez , d. , ramos , g. , reina , m. , ramos , j. l. , rodrguez , p. , snchez , a. , uribe - patarroyo , n. , barthol , p. , gandorfer , a. , knoelker , m. , schmidt , w. , solanki , s. k. , & vargas domnguez , s. 2011 , , 268 , 57 | we study the velocity structure of penumbral filaments in the deep photosphere to obtain direct evidence for the convective nature of sunspot penumbrae .
a sunspot was observed at high spatial resolution with the 1-m swedish solar telescope in the deep photospheric c@xmath0i5380 absorption line .
the multi - object multi - frame blind deconvolution ( momfbd ) method is used for image restoration and straylight is filtered out .
we report here the discovery of clear redshifts in the c@xmath0i5380 line at multiple locations in sunspot penumbral filaments .
for example , bright head of filaments show larger concentrated blueshift and are surrounded by darker , redshifted regions , suggestive of overturning convection .
elongated downflow lanes are also located beside bright penumbral fibrils .
our results provide the strongest evidence yet for the presence of overturning convection in penumbral filaments and highlight the need to observe the deepest layers of the penumbra in order to uncover the energy transport processes taking place there . |
the lattice provides a useful tool for studying the gluon propagator because it is a first principles treatment that can , in principle , access any momentum window .
there is tremendous interest in the infrared behavior of the gluon propagator as a probe into the mechanism of confinement @xcite and lattice studies focusing on its ultraviolet behavior have been used to calculate the running qcd coupling @xcite .
such studies can also inform model hadron calculations @xcite .
although there has recently been interest in coulomb gauge @xcite and generic covariant gauges @xcite , the usual gauge for these studies has been landau gauge , because it is a ( lattice ) lorentz covariant gauge that is easy to implement on the lattice , and its popularity means that results from the lattice can be easily compared to studies that use different methods .
finite volume effects and discretization errors have been extensively explored in lattice landau gauge @xcite .
unfortunately , lattice landau gauge suffers from the well - known problem of gribov copies . although the ambiguity originally noticed by gribov @xcite is not present on the lattice , the maximization procedure used for gauge fixing does not uniquely fix the gauge .
there are , in general , many local maxima for the algorithm to choose from , each one corresponding to a gribov copy , and no local algorithm can choose the global maximum from among them . while various remedies have been proposed @xcite , they are either unsatisfactory or computationally very intensive . for a recent discussion of the gribov problem in lattice gauge theory , see ref . @xcite .
an alternative approach is to operate in the so - called laplacian gauge @xcite .
this gauge is `` landau like '' in that it has similar smoothness and lorentz invariance properties @xcite , but it involves a non - local gauge fixing procedure that avoids lattice gribov copies .
laplacian gauge fixing also has the virtue of being rather faster than landau gauge fixing on the lattice .
the gluon propagator has already been studied in laplacian gauge in refs .
@xcite and the improved staggered quark propagator in laplacian gauge in ref .
@xcite . in this report
we explore three implementations of the laplacian gauge and their application to the gluon propagator on coarse , large lattices , using an improved action as has been done for landau gauge in ref .
we study the gluon propagator in quenched qcd ( pure @xmath1 yang - mills ) , using an @xmath2 mean - field improved gauge action . to assess the effects of finite lattice spacing
, we calculate the propagator on a set of lattices from @xmath3 at @xmath4 having @xmath5 fm to @xmath6 at @xmath7 having @xmath0 fm . to assist us in observing possible finite volume effects ,
we add to this set a @xmath6 lattice at @xmath8 with @xmath5 , which has the very large physical size of @xmath9 .
the infrared behavior of the laplacian gauge gluon propagator is found to be qualitatively similar to that seen in landau gauge . like refs .
@xcite , little volume dependence is seen in the propagator , but , unlike landau gauge , the laplacian gauge displays strong sensitivity to lattice spacing , making large volume simulations difficult .
we conclude that further work involving an improved gauge fixing is desired .
laplacian gauge is a nonlinear gauge fixing that respects rotational invariance , has been seen to be smooth , yet is free of gribov ambiguity .
it reduces to landau gauge in the asymptotic limit , yet is computationally cheaper than landau gauge .
there is , however , more than one way of obtaining such a gauge fixing in @xmath10 .
the three implementations of laplacian gauge fixing discussed are 1 .
@xmath11 gauge ( qr decomposition ) , used by alexandrou _
_ in ref .
2 . @xmath12 gauge ( maximum trace ) , where the laplacian gauge transformation is projected onto @xmath1 by maximizing its trace .
also used in ref .
@xmath13 gauge ( polar decomposition ) , the original prescription described in ref .
@xcite and tested in ref .
@xcite .
all three versions reduce to the same gauge in @xmath14 .
the gauge transformations employed in laplacian gauge fixing are constructed from the lowest eigenvectors of the covariant lattice laplacian @xmath15 where @xmath16,\ ] ] @xmath17 for @xmath10 and @xmath18 labels the eigenvalues and eigenvectors . under gauge transformations of the gauge field ,
@xmath19 the eigenvectors of the covariant laplacian transform as @xmath20 and this property enables us to construct a gauge fixing that is independent of our starting place in the orbit of gauge equivalent configurations . the three implementations discussed differ in the way that the gauge transformation is constructed from the above eigenvectors . in all cases
the resulting gauge should be unambiguous so long as the nth and ( n+1)th eigenvectors are not degenerate and the eigenvectors can be satisfactorily projected onto @xmath10 . a complex @xmath21 matrix can be uniquely projected onto @xmath14 , but this is not the case for @xmath10 . here
we can think of the projection method as defining its own , unambiguous , laplacian gauge fixing . in the original formulation @xcite , which we shall rather perversely refer to as @xmath13
, the lowest @xmath22 eigenvectors are required to gauge fix an @xmath10 gauge theory .
these form the columns of a complex @xmath23 matrix , @xmath24 which is then projected onto @xmath10 by polar decomposition .
specifically , it is possible to express @xmath25 in terms of a unitary matrix and a positive hermitian matrix : @xmath26 .
this decomposition is unique if @xmath27 is invertible , which will be true if @xmath25 is non - singular , i.e. , if the eigenvectors used to construct @xmath25 are linearly independent .
the gauge transformation @xmath28 is then obtained by factoring out the determinant of the unitary matrix @xmath29.\ ] ] the gauge transformation @xmath28 obtained in this way is used to transform the gauge field ( i.e. , the links ) to give the laplacian gauge - fixed gauge field .
@xmath28 can be uniquely defined by this presciption except on a set of gauge orbits with measure zero ( with respect to the the gauge - field functional intregral ) .
note that if we perform a random gauge transformation @xmath30 on the initial gauge field used to define our laplacian operator , then we will have @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
we see that @xmath33 and hence @xmath34 .
when this is applied to the transformed gauge field it will be taken to exactly the same point on the gauge orbit as the original gauge field went to when gauge fixed .
thus all points on the gauge orbit will be mapped to the same single point on the gauge orbit after laplacian gauge fixing and so it is a complete ( i.e. , gribov - copy free ) gauge fixing .
this method was investigated for @xmath35 and @xmath14 @xcite .
it is clear that any prescription for projecting @xmath25 onto some @xmath36 , which preserves the property @xmath34 under an arbitrary gauge transformation @xmath30 , will also be a gribov - copy free laplacian gauge fixing .
every different projection method with this property is an equally valid but distinct form of laplacian gauge fixing .
the next approach was used in ref .
@xcite , and we shall refer to it as @xmath11 gauge .
there it was noted that only @xmath37 eigenvectors are actually required . to be concrete , we discuss @xmath38 .
first , apply a gauge transformation , @xmath39 , to the first eigenvector such that @xmath40_1 = || v(x)^1 ||\ ] ] and @xmath40_2 = \bigl [ g(x)^1 v(x)^1 \bigr]_3 = 0,\ ] ] where subscripts label the vector elements , i.e. , the eigenvector - with dimension 3 - is rotated so that its magnitude is entirely in its first element .
another gauge transformation , @xmath41 , rotates the second eigenvector , @xmath42 , such that @xmath43_2 = \sqrt{(v_2 ^ 2)^2 + ( v_3 ^ 2)^2},\ ] ] and @xmath43_3 = 0.\ ] ] this second rotation is an @xmath14 subgroup , which does not act on @xmath44 .
the gauge fixing transformation is then @xmath45 .
compare this to qr decomposition , where a matrix , @xmath46 , is rewritten as the product of an orthogonal matrix and an upper triangular matrix .
the gauge transformations are thus like householder transformations .
in addition , we explore a third version , @xmath12gauge , where @xmath28 is obtained by projecting @xmath47 onto @xmath10 by trace maximization .
@xmath47 is again composed of the @xmath22 lowest eigenvectors and the trace of @xmath48 is maximized by iteration over cabbibo - marinari subgroups .
we extract the gluon field from the lattice links by @xmath49 which differs from the continuum field by terms of @xmath2 .
@xmath50 is then transformed into momentum space , @xmath51 where the available momenta , @xmath52 , are given by @xmath53 .
\label{eq : qhat}\ ] ] @xmath54 is the number of lattice sites in the @xmath55 direction .
the momentum space gluon propagator is then @xmath56 note that this definition includes a factor of @xmath57 from eq . ; this is the same normalization that was used in ref .
@xcite . in the continuum , the gluon propagator has the tensor structure into @xmath58 compared to ref .
@xcite . ] @xmath59 in landau gauge the longitudinal part will be zero for all @xmath60 , but this will not be the case in laplacian gauge .
we note that @xmath61 and use this to project out the longitudinal part .
this , unfortunately , makes it impossible to directly measure the scalar propagator at zero four - momentum , @xmath62 .
we are , however , able to measure the full propagator , @xmath63 . in a covariant gauge @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the bare gauge fixing parameter . on the lattice
the bare propagator is measured , which is related to the renormalized propagator by , @xmath66 where @xmath55 is the renormalization point . in a renormalizable theory such as qcd ,
the renormalized quantities become independent of the regularization parameter in the limit where it is removed .
@xmath67 is then defined by some renormalization prescription , such as the off - shell subtraction ( mom ) scheme , where the renormalized propagator is required to satisfy , @xmath68 it follows that @xmath69 with covariant gauge fixing , the longitudinal part is usually treated by absorbing the renormalization into the gauge parameter , @xmath70 .
we shall not discuss the renormalized propagator in this paper , but only consider relative normalizations for the purpose of comparing different data sets .
lcccdr & dimensions & @xmath71 & @xmath72 & & configurations + 1 & @xmath73 & 4.60 & 0.125 & 1.50 ^ 3 3.00 & 100 + 2i & @xmath74 & 4.60 & 0.125 & 2.00 ^ 3 4.00 & 100 + 2w & @xmath74 & 5.85 & 0.130 & 2.08 ^ 3 4.16 & 80 + 3 & @xmath74 & 4.38 & 0.166 & 2.64 ^ 3 5.28 & 100 + 4 & @xmath73 & 4.10 & 0.270 & 3.24 ^ 3 6.48 & 100 + 5 & @xmath3 & 3.92 & 0.353 & 3.53 ^ 3 7.06 & 100 + 6 & @xmath74 & 3.92 & 0.353 & 5.65 ^ 3 11.30 & 89 + the ensembles studied are listed in table 1 . to help us explore lattice artifacts , some of the following figures will distinguish data on the basis of its momentum components .
data points that come from momenta lying entirely along a spatial cartesian direction are indicated with a square while points from momenta entirely in the temporal direction are marked with a triangle .
as the time direction is longer than the spatial directions any difference between squares and triangles may indicate that the propagator is affected by the finite volume of the lattice .
data points from momenta entirely on the four - diagonal are marked with a diamond .
a systematic separation of data points taken on the diagonal from those in other directions indicates a violation of rotational symmetry . in the continuum ,
the scalar function is rotationally invariant .
although the hypercubic lattice breaks o(4 ) invariance , it does preserve the subgroup of discrete rotations z(4 ) . in our case , this symmetry is reduced to z(3 ) as one dimension will be twice as long as the other three in each of the cases studied .
we exploit this discrete rotational symmetry to improve statistics through z(3 ) averaging @xcite .
as has become standard practice in lattice gluon propagator studies , we select our lattice momentum in accordance with the tree - level behavior of the action . with this improved action , @xmath75 this
is discussed in more detail in ref .
we start by checking that our finest lattice , at @xmath76 fm , is `` fine enough '' , by comparing the propagator with that of alexandrou _ et al . _
[ fig : lap1_usandthem_polcut ] shows the momentum - enhanced propagator , @xmath77 , in @xmath11 gauge for ensemble 2i ( improved action ) compared to the data from ref .
@xcite for the wilson action at @xmath78 gev for @xmath78 . ] .
the two are in excellent agreement . .
[ fig : lap1_usandthem_polcut ] as the gluon propagator has been extensively studied in landau gauge , it makes sense to understand the laplacian gauge propagator by comparing it to that in landau gauge . in accordance with custom
, we will discuss the momentum - enhanced propagator , @xmath79 .
we define the relative @xmath67 renormalization constant @xmath80 and choose to perform this matching at @xmath81 gev .
the purpose of this is simply to make the ( bare ) gluon propagators agree in the ultraviolet for easy comparison between the gauges .
we show the gluon propagator in both landau and @xmath12 gauges in fig .
[ fig : comp_b460_cut ] . in this figure ,
the data is for the largest finer lattices , 2i and 3 .
the data has been cylinder cut @xcite to make comparison easier . as was seen in ref .
@xcite , the gluon propagator in laplacian gauge looks very similar to the landau gauge case matching up in the ultraviolet but with a somewhat lower infrared hump .
having compared the gluon propagator in @xmath12 gauge to landau gauge , we now compare it to other implementations of the laplacian gauge .
we expect each implementation to provide a well defined , unambiguous , but different gauge . as we saw when comparing landau and @xmath12 gauges , there is some difference in normalization between the propagators in the different gauges , so we define , again at @xmath81 gev @xmath82 in fig .
[ fig : lap12_b460_cut ] , the momentum - enhanced propagator is plotted in @xmath11 and @xmath12 gauges for one of the fine lattices ( ensemble 2i ) .
there is a small relative normalization ( @xmath83 ) , but otherwise there is no significant difference between them , neither in the ultraviolet nor the infrared .
@xmath11 and @xmath12 also show comparable performance in terms of rotational symmetry .
one difference between landau and laplacian gauge is that in the former , the gluon propagator has no longitudinal component .
we see in fig .
[ fig : comp_b460_long_all ] that the longitudinal part of the propagator does indeed vanish in the ultraviolet , which is consistent with approaching landau gauge , but gains strength in the infrared . comparing @xmath11 and @xmath12 gauges we note that while the transverse parts look alike , the longitudinal behavior is quite distinct .
the separation of squares and triangles in @xmath12 gauge suggests that @xmath58 has stronger volume dependence in that gauge . for a comparison between landau , @xmath11 and @xmath12 gauges for the quark propagator see ref .
@xcite .
@xmath13 gauge works badly , failing even to reproduce the correct asymptotic behavior .
[ fig : lap3_b585_all ] shows data from only 76 configurations as the gauge fixing failed entirely on four of them . in @xmath1 ,
the polar decomposition involves calculating determinants which , to our numerical precision , can become vanishingly small , in some cases even turning negative at some sites .
gauge was also seen to be a very poor gauge for studying the quark propagator @xcite . when comparing results from ensembles with different simulation parameters we need to consider three possible effects : 1 .
the dependence of @xmath67 on the lattice spacing , 2 .
errors due to the finite lattice spacing , especially when probing momenta near the cutoff , 3 .
finite volume effects , especially in the infrared . in landau gauge ,
the dependence of the gluon propagator renormalization , @xmath84 , on the cutoff is very weak .
@xmath67 is approximately constant with respect to the lattice spacing @xcite . in this case
it is easy to compare propagators produced on a wide range of lattice spacings . in fig .
[ fig : lap2_comp_cut ] we plot the momentum - enhanced propagator on four lattices , which have @xmath0 , 0.166 , 0.270 and 0.353 fm .
we see a very different situation to the one observed in landau gauge @xcite : the propagators appear to agree in the the deep infrared , yet diverge as the momentum increases .
the difference is small for the two finest lattices - and non - existent in fig .
[ fig : lap1_usandthem_polcut ] - but quite dramatic for the coarsest .
the correct way to compare the propagators is to normalize them at some common , `` safe '' momentum , i.e. , one where we expect finite lattice spacing and finite volume effects to both be small .
we choose @xmath85 gev and show the results in fig .
[ fig : lap2_coarse_normpol ] . multiplying the propagator by @xmath60 in constructing the momentum - enhanced propagator
@xmath77 reveals a rapid divergence in the ultraviolet .
yet normalizing at higher momenta results in data sets that agree nowhere except for at the scale @xmath55 .
it is interesting that the propagators from ensembles 5 and 6 , which have the same lattice spacing , have slightly different normalizations .
also , as the lattice spacing is increased , the relative normalization between the gluon propagators in @xmath11 and @xmath12 gauges slowly diverges from one . as was seen above ( fig .
[ fig : comp_b460_long_all ] ) , these two laplacian gauges produce gluon propagators with rather different longitudinal components .
the longitudinal part of the gluon propagator , multiplied by @xmath60 , is plotted in @xmath11 and @xmath12gauges for ensembles 4 - 6 in fig .
[ fig : comp_coarse_long ] , using the same normalization determined for the transverse parts .
interestingly , the longitudinal part appears to be more affected by the finite volume of the lattice than the transverse part . in @xmath12 gauge @xmath86 may return to zero as @xmath87 , while in @xmath11 gauge a small , non - zero value appears likely , however , more work is required .
in previous studies @xcite it was observed that the infrared gluon propagator saturates at a small volume ( @xmath88 ) . to further explore this
, we also study the propagator at zero four - momentum .
as previously discussed , only the full propagator , @xmath63 , can be calculated at zero four - momentum . in order to compare results on all of our lattices
we normalize the data at 1 gev .
this represents a compromise and is certainly not ideal for all the data sets , hence there is some systematic error .
these results are shown in table [ tab : zeromom ] .
.[tab : zeromom]the full propagator at zero four - momentum in @xmath11 and @xmath12 gauges , normalized at 1 gev for comparison . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] if we restrict ourselves to ensembles 1 - 5 , we see that , given the uncertainties discussed , the sensitivity of @xmath63 to volume is indeed small .
we also see the trend , already noted above , for @xmath11 and @xmath12 gauges to become more different as the lattice spacing increases , another example of the discretization sensitivity of the laplacian gauge . in the case of the very large lattice , ensemble 6 ,
this sensitivity has become extreme .
we examine this another way through the transverse propagator , shown in fig .
[ fig : lap2_all_prop ] for ensembles 2i , 3 - 6 .
the data here corresponds to table [ tab : zeromom ] , having been normalized at 1 gev .
the propagators are consistent down to low momenta , @xmath89 mev , where we strike trouble .
not only is there a spread between the data sets , but for ensemble 6 , the point from purely temporal momentum is much lower than that from spatial momentum .
the situation is the same in @xmath11 gauge .
we have made a detailed study of the gluon propagator on coarse lattices with an improved action in laplacian gauges .
we have described and tested three implementations of laplacian gauge .
@xmath11 ( qr decomposition ) and @xmath12 ( maximum trace ) gauges produce similar results for the scalar transverse gluon propagator , but rather different longitudinal components . @xmath13 for numerical reasons , works very poorly in @xmath1 . at sufficiently small lattice spacing ,
the transverse part of the gluon propagator is very similar in laplacian gauge to that in landau gauge .
laplacian gauge , however , exhibits great sensitivity to the lattice spacing , making results gained from coarse lattices difficult to compare with those from finer lattices .
this is very different to the situation in landau gauge . by comparing the coarse data sets at sufficiently low momentum
, however , we have seen a great deal of consistency . in the deep infrared ,
the results from the largest lattice are difficult to reconcile with the other data . excluding that lattice , the total propagator shows little sign of volume dependence .
the most likely explanation of the ( unimproved ) laplacian gauge results seen here is that on our coarsest lattices ( improved lattices with @xmath4 , 4.10 , and to some extent even @xmath90 ) , the lattice artifacts are much more severe than in the improved landau gauge case . on the very coarse @xmath4 and 4.10 lattices , it seems very likely that finite volume and discretization errors are actually being coupled together by the laplacian gauge fixing . by implementing an improved laplacian gauge fixing on these lattices
we anticipate that these errors will decouple on these lattices and we will be in a better position to estimate the infinite volume and continuum limits of the different implementations of laplacian gauge - fixing . further studies , including an improved laplacian gauge fixing , will hopefully clarify these issues .
the authors would like to thank constantia alexandrou for helpful discussions during the lattice hadron physics workshop in cairns , australia .
computational resources of the australian national computing facility for lattice gauge theory are gratefully acknowledged .
the work of umh and pob was supported in part by doe contract de - fg02 - 97er41022 .
dbl and agw acknowledge financial support from the australian research council .
jeffrey e. mandula , _ the gluon propagator _ , hep - lat/9907020 ; l. von smekal and r. alkofer , _ what the infrared behavior of qcd green functions can tell us about confinement in the covariant gauge _ , hep - ph/0009219 ; for a recent demonstration of the connection between the gluon propagator and confinement , see e.g. , kurt langfeld , hep - lat/0204025 . | the laplacian gauge is a nonperturbative gauge fixing that reduces to landau gauge in the asymptotic limit . like landau gauge ,
it respects lorentz invariance , but it is free of gribov copies ; the gauge fixing is unambiguous . in this paper
we study the infrared behavior of the lattice gluon propagator in laplacian gauge by using a variety of lattices with spacings from @xmath0 to 0.35 fm , to explore finite volume and discretization effects .
three different implementations of the laplacian gauge are defined and compared . the laplacian gauge propagator has already been claimed to be insensitive to finite volume effects and this is tested on lattices with large volumes . |
there is strong evidence that most giant elliptical galaxies should possess nuclear supermassive black holes , relics of an earlier quasar phase .
quasar counts and integrated luminosities suggest masses above @xmath1 @xmath2 .
given this fact , there is a major puzzle surrounding quiescent giant ellipticals which was first illuminated by fabian & canizares ( 1988 ) .
a massive black hole in the centre of an elliptical galaxy would accrete from the interstellar medium ( which forms a hot hydrostatic atmosphere in the potential well of the galaxy ) .
the accretion rate would be expected to be at least that given by bondi s spherical accretion formula ( bondi 1952 ) .
if the resulting accretion flow into the hole proceeds via a standard accretion disk ( with a radiative efficiency of @xmath3 per cent ) , all such nuclei should be seen to possess quasar - like luminosities .
this is contrary to observation .
the nearby giant elliptical galaxy m87 ( ngc 4486 ) might be considered a counter example because it has long been known to host an active nucleus that powers a jet and the giant radio lobes of virgo a. furthermore , _
observations have now provided a direct dynamical determination of the nuclear black hole mass of @xmath4 ( ford et al .
1995 ; harms et al .
in fact , m87 illustrates the problem of quiescent black holes in giant ellipticals and , we suggest , illuminates the solution .
qualitative evidence for the relative quiescence of m87 comes from a comparison to the quasar 3c273 , which presumably contains a black hole of comparable mass .
while both have core , jet and lobe emission , the luminosity of m87 in all wavebands falls 5 orders of magnitude below that of 3c273 ( see below ) .
the contrast between m87 and 3c273 can not be completely ascribed to a smaller mass accretion rate in the former , as can be seen by an estimate of the bondi accretion rate in m87 .
imaging x - ray observations provide information on the hot interstellar medium ( ism ) .
a deprojection analysis of data from the _ rosat _ high resolution imager ( hri ) shows that the ism has a central density @xmath5 and sound speed @xmath6 ( c. b. peres , private communication ) .
the resulting bondi accretion rate onto the central black hole is @xmath7 .
following standard practice , we define a dimensionless mass accretion rate by @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the mass accretion rate and @xmath10 is the eddington accretion rate assuming a radiative efficiency of @xmath11 . for m87
, the eddington limit is @xmath12 corresponding to @xmath13 .
the bondi accretion rate corresponds to @xmath14 and so , assuming a radiative efficiency @xmath11 , would produce a radiative luminosity of @xmath15 .
observationally , the nucleus is orders of magnitude less active .
the observed radiative power does not exceed @xmath16 ( biretta , stern & harris 1991 ; also see section 2 of this letter ) and the time - averaged kinetic luminosity of the jet can not exceed much more than @xmath17 ( reynolds et al .
1996 ) .
the recent interest in advection - dominated accretion disks ( narayan & yi 1995 ; abramowicz et al . 1995 ; narayan , yi & mahadevan 1995 ) prompted fabian & rees ( 1995 ) to suggest that such disks exist around the nuclear black holes in quiescent giant elliptical galaxies . in this mode of accretion ,
the accretion flow is very tenuous and so a poor radiator .
( the possibility of similarly tenuous ` ion - supported tori ' had been discussed in the context of radio galaxies by rees et al .
1982 and for the galactic centre by rees 1982 ) .
much of the energy of the accretion flow can not be radiated and is carried through the event horizon .
fabian & rees ( see also mahadevan 1996 ) realised that the resulting low radiative efficiency provides a possible solution to the elliptical galaxy problem described above .
they identify the weak parsec - scale radio cores seen in most elliptical galaxies ( sadler et al .
1989 ; wrobel & heeschen 1991 ; slee et al .
1994 ) with synchrotron emission from the plasma of the advection - dominated disks ( add ) . in this _
we present a detailed examination of the possibility that the massive black hole in m87 accretes via an add .
in particular , we compute the spectrum of the add and show that it is consistent with the observations for physically reasonable mass accretion rates . in section 2
we compile data from the literature on the full - band spectrum of the core of m87 and present some additional data on the x - ray flux from the core .
care is taken to limit the effect of contaminating emission from the jet and/or the galaxy . despite this
, the spectrum we obtain must still be considered as a set of upper limits on the spectrum of the accretion flow with the non - thermal emission from the jet representing the main contaminant .
we make a direct comparison to the quasar 3c 273 .
section 3 describes some details of our add model spectrum calculation .
section 4 compares this model spectrum with the data and finds that accretion rates comparable with the bondi rate do not overproduce radiation and are thus acceptable .
section 5 discusses some further astrophysical implications of this result .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in order to examine the nature of the accretion flow in m87 , we have attempted to compile the best observational limits on the full band spectrum of the core emission .
our aim is to obtain good observational limits on the core flux over a wide range of frequencies rather than to compile a comprehensive list of all previous observations . for radio through optical , we use the highest spatial resolution data available from the literature in order to minimize the contribution to the flux from the synchrotron emitting jet and the galaxy .
however , contributions from the jet and the underlying galaxy are unavoidable and so the derived spectrum should be considered an upper limit to that of the accretion flow at the core of m87 .
these data are summarized in table 1 .
the situation with regard to hard x - ray emission from the agn in m87 has been confused and deserves some comment . the overall x - ray emission from m87
is highly extended and clearly of thermal origin , arising from diffuse gas with average kt@xmath18 .
several observations with wide - field x - ray instruments indicated the presence of an x - ray power law component , which was suggested to be associated with the nuclear region of m87 ( lea et al .
1981 , matsumoto et al . 1996 and
references therein ) , but were probably confused by the hard x - ray emission from the nearby seyfert 2 galaxy ngc 4388 ( hansen 1990 ; takano & koyama 1991 ) . a reanalysis of soft x - ray _ einstein _
hri observations with arc second resolution by biretta , stern & harris ( 1991 ) found emission from a core point source at a level more than an order of magnitude below that found by the wide - field x - ray instruments . we have examined the _ rosat hri _ and asca data sets in order to constrain further the nuclear x - ray flux of m87 . the _ rosat _
data were retrieved from the public archive situated at the goddard space flight center and result from a 14200s exposure performed on 1992-june-7 .
figure 1 shows the _ rosat _ hri image of the central regions of m87 .
emission from the core and knot - a ( @xmath19arcsecs west of the core ) are clearly separated from each other as they were in the _ einstein _ hri image ( biretta , stern & harris 1991 ) .
the _ rosat _
hri count rate is @xmath20ctss@xmath21 ( determined using the ximage software package ) . assuming the spectrum to be a power - law with a canonical photon index @xmath22 ( mushotzky , done & pounds 1993 ) modified by the effects of galactic absorption ( with column density @xmath23 ; stark et al . 1992 )
, this count rate implies a flux density at 1kev of @xmath24jy .
this result is fairly insensitive to choosing a different power - law index .
asca observed m87 during the pv phase : 12600s of good data were obtained in 1993 june .
independent analysis was performed by matsumoto et al .
a 3arcmin radius circle centered on the nucleus of m87 contains approximately 50000 counts in a single sis detector .
we performed a variety of fits to the spectrum in the central regions , incorporating multiple thermal components , possible excess low - energy absorption , and possible cooling - flow emission . in no case
does the addition of a power law component give a noticeable improvement in the fit ( we fix the power law index at @xmath22 ) . our limit ( at 90 per cent confidence )
is listed in table 1 .
it is somewhat below the value ( whose significance is not stated ) reported by matsumoto et al .
the _ einstein _ and _ rosat _ hri fluxes differ somewhat . given the well known variability of agn in the x - ray band ( mushotzky , done & pounds 1993 ) ,
time variability is a plausible explanation for this difference .
high resolution vlbi observations probably provide the strongest constraints on the core emission ( since they can separate the core emission from knots of jet emission even within the innermost parsec of the source ) .
high resolution optical ( hst ) and x - ray ( _ rosat _ hri ) measurements are likely to be free of galactic contamination but may still possess a significant contribution from the inner jet .
sub - mm and far - ir studies provide uninteresting limits on the core flux : the comparatively poor spatial resolution leads to severe contamination from galactic emission ( predominantly thermal emission by dust ) . for comparison with m87 , the open squares on fig . 2 show data for the radio - loud quasar 3c 273
these data are from the compilation of lichti et al .
( 1995 ) and are simultaneous or near - simultaneous . much of this emission is likely to originate from the jet and be relativistically beamed .
however , the fact that we see a big blue bump and optical / uv emission lines from 3c 273 implies that a significant part of the optical / uv emission is unbeamed and likely to originate from the accretion flow .
it is well known that sub - eddington accretion can proceed via a thin accretion disk ( see review by pringle 1981 and references therein ) .
such disks are characterised by being radiatively efficient so that the energy generated by viscous dissipation is radiated locally . as a consequence ,
such disks are cold in the sense that the gas temperature is significantly below the virial temperature . however ,
for sufficiently low mass accretion rates ( @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the standard disk viscosity parameter ) there is another stable mode of accretion ( see narayan & yi 1995 and references therein ) . in this second mode ,
the accretion flow is very tenuous and , hence , a poor radiator .
the energy generated by viscous dissipation can no longer be locally radiated a large fraction of this energy is advected inwards in the accretion flow as thermal energy and , eventually , passes through the event horizon .
these are known as advection - dominated disks ( adds ) . for convenience , we rescale the radial co - ordinate and define @xmath27 by @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the radial coordinate and @xmath30 is the schwarzschild radius of the hole .
it is an important feature of adds that , in the region @xmath31 , the ions and electrons do not possess the same temperature .
the ions attain essentially the virial temperature .
they couple weakly via coulomb interactions to the electrons which , due to various cooling mechanisms , possess a significantly lower temperature . by assuming that the system is undergoing advection - dominated accretion
, we can predict the radio to x - ray spectrum of the accretion flow .
since the gas is optically - thin , the emission in different regions of the spectrum is determined by synchro - cyclotron , bremsstrahlung and inverse compton processes .
the amount of emission from these different processes and the shape of the spectrum can be determined as a function of the model variables : the viscosity parameter , @xmath26 , the ratio of magnetic to total pressure , @xmath32 , the mass of the central black hole , @xmath33 , and the accretion rate , @xmath34 . for the moment
, we take @xmath35 and @xmath36 ( i.e. magnetic pressure in equipartition with gas pressure ) , although see discussion in section 5 . the electron temperature at a given point in the add , @xmath37 ,
can then be determined self - consistently for a given @xmath34 and @xmath33 by balancing the heating of the electrons by the ions against the various radiative cooling mechanisms . within @xmath31
, it is found that @xmath38 . to determine the observed spectrum , we must integrated the emission over the volume and take account of self - absorption effects . we have taken the inner radius of the disk to correspond with the innermost stable orbit around a schwarzschild black hole , @xmath39 , and the outer radius to be @xmath40 .
the spectrum is rather insensitive to the choice of @xmath41 since most of the radiation originates within @xmath42 .
details of the model , which is based on that of narayan & yi ( 1995 ) , can be found in di matteo & fabian ( 1996 ) . in fig .
2 we show the spectrum of the advection - dominated disk for @xmath43 and @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
the peak in the radio band is due to synchro - cyclotron emission by the thermal electrons in the magnetic field of the plasma .
the x - ray peak is due to thermal bremsstrahlung emission .
the power - law emission extending through the optical band is due to comptonization of the synchro - cyclotron emission : more detailed calculations show this emission to be comprised of individual peaks corresponding to different orders of compton scattering .
the positions at which the synchrotron and bremsstrahlung peaks occur and their relative heights depend on the parameters of the model .
the synchrotron radiation is self - absorbed and gives a black body spectrum , up to a critical frequency , @xmath46 . above the peak frequency
the spectrum reproduces the exponential decay in the emission expected from thermal plasma ( mahadevan & narayan 1996 ) .
the bremsstrahlung peak occurs at the thermal frequency @xmath47 .
figure 2 demonstrates the comparison between the core data and the advection dominated disk model described above .
the accretion rate for all three models shown is comparable ( within an order of magnitude ) to the bondi rate .
each of these models represents a physically plausible accretion rate .
the two lower model curves ( @xmath48 ) are completely acceptable in the sense that they do not exceed any observational bounds .
furthermore , it can be seen that a substantial portion of the vlbi core flux may originate from an advection dominated disk . in particular two of the vlbi data points seem to reproduce almost exactly the slope of self - absorbed cyclo - synchrotron spectrum .
we note that radio observations of early - type galaxy cores typically show rising or flat spectra with very similar slope ( @xmath49 ) ( slee et al .
1994 ) , which is well accounted for by the spectrum of an add ( fig . 2 and mahadevan 1996 ) .
the core as seen in the 100ghz vlbi data , the hst data and the _ rosat _ hri x - ray data requires some additional component .
the synchrotron jet would be a candidate for this additional component ( provided the jet becomes self - absorbed at frequencies @xmath50ghz or less ) .
figure 2 shows the contrast between m87 and 3c 273 .
3c 273 is observed to be at least 5 orders of magnitude more luminous than m87 at all wavelengths .
the big blue bump in the spectrum of this quasar is often interpreted to be thermal emission from a standard thin - disk . assuming a thin - disk efficiency of @xmath11 , the inferred accretion rate is @xmath51 .
thus , it is possible that the mass accretion rates in m87 and 3c 273 differ by only 2 orders of magnitude despite the fact that the luminosities differ by 56 orders of magnitude .
we conclude that accretion from the hot gas halo at rates comparable with the bondi rate is compatible with the low - luminosity of this core provided the final stages of accretion ( where most of the gravitational energy is released ) involve an advection dominated disk .
this is in complete accord with the suggestion of fabian & rees ( 1995 )
. an important test of this model will be the micro - arcsec radio imaging such as is promised by the vlbi space observatory program ( vsop ) .
this will provide the capability to image the core of m87 on scales comparable to the schwarzschild radius of the black hole .
any advection - dominated disk should be directly revealed as a synchrotron self - absorbed structure with a position angle that is perpendicular to the jet axis . in constructing our add model ,
we have assumed a large value of the viscosity parameter , @xmath35 .
it should be stressed that the add model remains compatible with the core data even for smaller values of @xmath26 . for @xmath52
, we have to postulate that the magnetic field in the disk is below its equipartition value ( i.e. @xmath53 ) in order that an add with @xmath54 does not violate the vlbi limits .
given the recent mhd disk simulations of stone et al .
( 1996 ) , this is not an unreasonable relaxation of our basic assumptions .
in fact , all that is required is that @xmath26 is sufficiently large so as to make the add solution accessible for the accretion rates present in m87 . if @xmath54 , then we require @xmath55
. the consistency of this model with the data allows us to explore some astrophysical implications of adds in giant elliptical galaxies .
rees et al .
( 1982 ) have argued that electromagnetic extraction from black holes surrounded by ion - supported tori ( which share many of the basic physical properties of adds ) can power relativistic jets in radio galaxies .
the jets can be collimated in the inner regions of the ion - supported torus .
if we apply the blandford - znajek ( 1977 ) mechanism to m87 , we predict that the amount of energy extracted from a kerr black hole is of the order of @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the usual angular momentum of the black hole ( in dimensionless units ) , @xmath58 is the mass of the black hole ( @xmath59 ) and @xmath60 g is the magnetic field in the vicinity of the hole . from our model
( assuming equipartition ) , we determine @xmath61 to be @xmath62 this determination of @xmath63 is completely consistent with the kinetic luminosity of m87 jet ( @xmath17 ) obtained by reynolds et al .
( 1996 ) .
adds may be relevant to the creation of a unified model for radio - loud agn .
we are suggesting that m87 , a classic fr - i radio source , possesses an add .
however , _ asca _
observations of broad iron k@xmath26 fluorescence lines in the two fr - ii sources 3c 390.3 ( eracleous , halpern & livio 1996 ) and 3c 109 ( allen et al .
1996 ) strongly point to the presence of standard cold ( thin ) accretion disks in these objects .
this leads to the speculation that the fr - i / fr - ii dichotomy is physically the dichotomy between advection - dominated and standard disks : i.e. fr - i sources possess adds whereas fr - ii sources possess ` standard ' thin accretion disks . in this sense , the accretion disks in fr - ii sources and seyfert nuclei
would be intrinsically similar ( seyfert nuclei also display broad iron emission lines that are believed to originate from the central regions of a thin accretion disk . )
we note that a very similar unification scheme ( in the context of ion - supported tori versus thin accretion disks ) has been discussed by begelman , blandford & rees ( 1984 ) and begelman ( 1985 ; 1986 ) .
the only difference is the increased observational evidence . extending this unified scheme to all agn
, the two fundamental classes of agn would be those with adds and those with thin accretion disks .
within these two classes , some currently unknown physical difference ( possibly black hole spin parameter or galactic environment ) would create the dichotomy between radio - loud and radio - quiet objects .
it has recently been suggested that narrow emission line galaxies ( nelgs ) are radio - quiet nuclei possessing adds ( di matteo & fabian 1996 ) . within the context of our unified scheme ,
this leads us to identify nelg and fr - i radio galaxies as basically the same objects , differing only in the fact that fr - i objects possess radio - jets .
it is interesting to note that broad optical emission lines are not observed from either fr - i sources or ` genuine ' nelg . indeed
, optical spectroscopy of the core of m87 by the faint object spectrograph ( fos ) on _ hst _ fails to reveal broad ( fwhm@xmath64 ) h@xmath32 line emission ( harms et al .
thus , the presence of an add may preclude the formation of a broad emission line region , possibly due to the lack of any strong photoionizing continuum .
the most likely control parameter determining which mode of accretion operates is the mass accretion rate @xmath65 .
the accretion could be advection - dominated at low accretion rates ( @xmath66 ) and via a standard disk for larger accretion rates .
the smaller radiative efficiency of adds provides a natural explanation for the fact that fr - i sources are of lower power than fr - ii sources .
however , the situation can be much more complex .
the mode of accretion may depend on the thermal state of the inflowing material . in an elliptical galaxy ,
accretion from a hot ism may favour the add mode ( provided @xmath65 is sufficiently low ) simply because the material does not have time to cool ( see a detailed discussion of this , in the context of ion - supported tori , by begelman 1986 ) .
furthermore , the mode of accretion could be history dependent . as discussed by fabian & crawford ( 1990 ) ,
a thin disk is a prolific radiator of optical / uv radiation , so that hot infalling material would be compton cooled by these soft photons and enter the accretion disk pre - cooled . by this mechanism ,
a thin disk could remain intact even if the accretion rate were to drop into the regime in which an add is allowed . some catastrophic event
( such as a galaxy or sub - cluster merger ) would be required to make the transition from a thin disk to an add .
both fabian & rees ( 1995 ) and di matteo & fabian ( 1996 ) have suggested that adds are important for understanding the demise of quasars since early cosmological epochs ( @xmath67 ) . a decrease in the average mass accretion rate ( associated with the galactic systems becoming more relaxed and mergers / interactions becoming less frequent ) , or an increase in the temperature of the accreting gas ( perhaps due to a decrease in compton cooling following disruption of a thin - disk ) could lead quasars to undergo a transition and accrete via add .
after the transition , the luminosity could be lower by orders of magnitude , even though the mass accretion rate may only have dropped by a relatively small fraction .
such objects would thus be undetectable at cosmological distances .
this suggestion has important implications for estimates of the black hole mass .
even quiescent galaxies might contain black holes that are doubling their mass on timescales of @xmath68 ( using the parameters of m87 : note that an m87-like object placed at cosmological distances would be considered to be a weakly active object ) .
shorter term behaviour of agn might also reflect changes in accretion mode .
it is known that radio - loud objects are not steady over cosmological timescales but undergo bursts of duration @xmath69@xmath70 .
it is normally thought that these bursts have to be caused by large changes in mass accretion rate .
however , a burst could be caused by a relatively small increase in @xmath65 if that increase were sufficient to force an add to a thin - disk transition .
csr and tdm acknowledge pparc and trinity college , cambridge , for support .
acf thanks the royal society for support . uh thanks the nrc for support .
crc acknowledges partial support from nasa ltsa grant nagw 2681 through smithsonian grant sv2 - 62002 and contract nas8 - 38249 .
abramowicz m. , chen x. , kato s. , lasota j. p. , regev o. , 1995 , apj , 438 , l37 allen s. w. , fabian a. c. , idesawa e. , inoue h. , kii t. , otani c. , 1996 , submitted .
bth l. b. et al . , 1992 ,
a&a , 257 , 31 begelman m. c. , blandford r. d. , rees m. j. , 1984 , rev .
phys . , 56 , 255 begelman m. c. , 1985 , in astrophysics of active galaxies and quasi - stellar objects , eds miller j. s. , university science books , mill valley , p411 begelman m. c. , 1986 , nat , 322 , 614 biretta j. a. , stern c. p. , harris d. e. , 1991 , aj , 101 , 1632 blandford r. d. , znajek r. , 1977 , mnras , 179 , 433 bondi h. , 1952 , mnras , 112 , 195 di matteo t. , fabian a. c. , 1996 , submitted eracleous m. , halpern j. p. , livio m. , 1996 , apj , 459 , 89 fabian a. c. , canizares c. r. , 1988 , nat , 333 , 829 fabian a. c. , crawford c. s. , 1990 , mnras , 247 , 439 fabian a. c. , rees m. j. , 1995 , mnras , 277 , l55 ford h. c. et al .
1995 , apj , 1994 , 435 , l27 hansen c. , skinner g. , eyles c. , wilmore a. 1990 , mnras , 242 , 262 harms r. j. et al . , 1994 ,
apj , 435 , l35 lea s. , mushotzky r.,holt s. , 1982 , apj , 262 , 24 lichti g. g. et al . , 1995 , a&a , 298 , 711 mahadevan r. , narayan r. , 1996 , apj , 465 , 327 mahadevan r. , 1996 , preprint .
matsumoto h. , koyama k. , awaki h. , tomida h. , tsuru t. , mushotzky r. , hatsukade i. , 1996 , pasj , 48 , 201 mushotzky r. f. , done c. , pounds k. a. , 1993 , araa , 31 , 717 narayan r. , yi i. , 1995 , apj , 452 , 710 narayan r. , yi i. , mahadevan r. , 1995 , nat , 374 , 623 pauliny - toth i. i. k. , preuss e. , witzel a. , graham d. , kellerman k. i. , ronnang b. , 1981 , aj , 86 , 371 pringle j. e. , 1981 , araa , 19 , 137 rees m. j. , 1982 , in riegler g. , blandford r. , eds , the galactic center . am .
phys . , new york , p. 166 .
rees m. j. , begelman m. c. , blandford r. d. , phinney e. s. , 1982 , nat .
, 295 , 17 reid m. j. , biretta j. a. , junor w. , muxlow t. w. b. , spencer r. e. , 1989 , apj , 336 , 112 reynolds c. s. , fabian a. c. , celotti c. , rees m. j. , 1996 , mnras , in press sadler e. m. , jenkins c. r. , kotanji c. g. , 1989 , mnras , 240 , 591 slee o. b. , sadler e. m. , reynolds j. e. , ekers r. d. , 1994 , mnras , 269 , 928 spencer r. e. , junor w. , 1986 , nat . , 321 , 753 stark a. a. , gammie c. f. , wilson r. w. , bally j. , linke r. a. , heiles c. , hurwitz m. , 1992 , apjs , 79 , 77 stone j. m. , hawley j. f. , gammie c. f. , balbus s. a. , 1996 , apj , 463 , 656 takano s. , koyama k. , 1991 , pasj , 43 , 1 wrobel j. m. , heeschen d. s. , 1991 , aj , 101 , 148 | it is believed that most giant elliptical galaxies possess nuclear black holes with masses in excess of @xmath0 .
bondi accretion from the interstellar medium might then be expected to produce quasar - like luminosities from the nuclei of even quiescent elliptical galaxies .
it is a puzzle that such luminosities are _ not observed_. motivated by this problem , fabian & rees have recently suggested that the final stages of accretion in these objects occurs in an advection - dominated mode with a correspondingly small radiative efficiency . despite possessing a long - known active nucleus and dynamical evidence for a black hole , the low radiative and kinetic luminosities of the core of m87
provide the best illustration of this problem .
we examine an advection - dominated model for the nucleus of m87 and show that accretion at the bondi rate is compatible with the best known estimates for the core flux from radio through to x - ray wavelengths .
the success of this model prompts us to propose that fr - i radio galaxies and quiescent elliptical galaxies accrete in an advection dominated mode whereas fr - ii type radio - loud nuclei possess radiatively efficient thin accretion disks .
ps .
# 1to 0pt#1 galaxies : individual : m87 , galaxies : active , accretion , accretion discs |
gauge / gravity duality has been a very insightful tool used to study many properties of strongly coupled non - abelian plasmas , especially after many indications that the quark - gluon plasma created in heavy ion collisions at the rhic collider is a strongly coupled system @xcite .
the ads / cft correspondence @xcite is a duality between a ( 3 + 1)-dimensional @xmath0 @xmath1 super - yang - mills ( sym ) gauge theory and type iib string theory on @xmath2 spacetime . using this conjecture and by taking the limit @xmath3 , one can study this gauge theory at strong coupling by studying classical , two - derivative ( super)gravity . due to phenomenological differences between thermal @xmath0 sym plasma and finite - temperature qcd
, it is important to consider gravity duals to nonconformal gauge theories @xcite .
however , since the information about the medium ( on the field theory side ) is fully encoded in the spacetime metric ( on the string side ) , in this work we will keep our results as general as possible by considering a general metric @xmath4 and only use the @xmath5 metric for final numerical evaluations . in recent years
, an important application of the ads / cft correspondence has been to study the phenomenon of jet quenching @xcite in strongly coupled systems , especially after the pioneering work of @xcite and @xcite , who studied energy loss of heavy quarks in a strongly coupled @xmath0 sym plasma . to study the plasma at a finite temperature @xmath6 ,
one introduces a black hole in the @xmath5 geometry with an event horizon at some radial coordinate @xmath7 , proportional to @xmath8 @xcite .
then , one introduces degrees of freedom in the fundamental representation ( `` quarks '' ) in sym by introducing a d7-brane in the @xmath9-bh geometry , which spans from @xmath10 ( boundary ) to some @xmath11 @xcite ; on the field theory side , this procedure corresponds to the introduction of an @xmath12 hypermultiplet whose mass @xmath13 is proportional to @xmath14 .
dressed quarks are then dual to strings in the bulk with one or both endpoints on the d7-brane and the physics of the quark energy loss ( on the field theory side ) will be directly related to the dynamics of these strings . in the large @xmath15 and large @xmath16 limit , one can neglect the backreaction of the metric due to the introduction of the string ( the probe approximation ) and neglect the quantum corrections to the motion of the strings .
this means that we need to study the motion of classical strings in the background given by a spacetime metric @xmath4 . for a review of ads
/ cft correspondence and especially its applications to heavy ion phenomenology , the reader is referred to @xcite .
recently , in the light of rhic results , as well as the new lhc results @xcite on the suppression of light hadrons in aa collisions , a more consistent grasp on the energy loss of light quarks in gauge / gravity duality has become necessary , in order to be able to compute jet energy loss observables such as the nuclear modification factor @xmath17 and the elliptic flow parameter @xmath18 and directly compare them to the experimental results @xcite .
if we wish to describe a strongly coupled medium with light quarks , the d7-brane will fill the entire @xmath9-bh geometry . on this d7-brane
we can then study open strings whose endpoints source a d7 gauge field which in turn `` induces '' ( in the sense of the field / operator correspondence ) an image baryon density current in the field theory . in other words , these open strings will represent dressed @xmath19 pairs on the field theory side .
then the main idea , advocated in @xcite , is that by studying the free motion of these falling strings , we can study the energy loss of light quarks .
this application is just one example of the need to understand the details of energy loss in ( explicitly ) time - dependent string configurations , such as the falling strings .
the hope is that , by examining such configurations , we can model phenomena associated with the energy loss more realistically , since in the quark gluon plasma formed in heavy ion collisions , quarks slow down and phenomena such as the instantaneous energy loss are expected to depend on the details of this nonstationary motion .
heavy quarks in such nonstationary situations have already been studied in @xcite .
the authors of @xcite have elegantly obtained one of the first results for light quark energy loss in gauge / gravity duality .
they have shown , by analyzing null geodesics in the @xmath9-bh spacetime and relating them to the energy of the falling string , that the maximum stopping distance of light quarks scales with energy as @xmath20 .
a similar result was obtained in @xcite for energy loss of adjoint degrees of freedom ( `` gluons '' ) in @xmath0 sym plasma .
however , we emphasize that this maximum stopping distance is not a _ typical _ stopping distance of light quarks .
it is , as such , a rather crude quantity , that can be used as a phenomenological guideline , but can not be used to extract the instantaneous energy loss that enters in , for example , calculations of @xmath17 or @xmath18 observables . to study the instantaneous energy loss
, one needs to analyze the spacetime momentum currents on the string worldsheet , which , as demonstrated in @xcite , in case of falling strings become nontrivial , time - dependent quantities . in this paper
we will extend the analysis of the worldsheet currents from @xcite and suggest a perhaps more appropriate definition of the energy loss ( in the sense of its identification with particular current components ) , in which the details of the geometry on the worldsheet become important .
this small , but crucial detail will lead to potentially important phenomenological consequences : as we will see , in particular , the instantaneous energy loss will not exhibit a well - pronounced late - time bragg - like peak , as previously believed .
let us start by considering a classical string propagating in a five - dimensional spacetime described by the metric @xmath4 .
the dynamics of the string is described by the polyakov action : @xmath21 where @xmath22 , the squared fundamental string length ; @xmath23 are the coordinates on the string worldsheet ; @xmath24 are the spacetime coordinates of the string ( the embedding functions ) ; and @xmath25 is the worldsheet metric , which is considered as a dynamical variable in this action ( here @xmath26 ) .
if we vary this action with respect to @xmath27 , we get @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the induced worldsheet metric . plugging this equation of motion in the polyakov action
, we obtain the usual nambu - goto string action , which means that these two actions are classically equivalent .
the polyakov action can thus be viewed as a classical field theory action of five scalar fields @xmath30 on a curved two - dimensional manifold described by the metric @xmath25 .
this is the reason why we will be using that action instead of the much more common nambu - goto action , since in the derivation of the energy loss formula it will be necessary to consider coordinate transformations on the worldsheet and see how the worldsheet vectors and tensors change under them . in practice , this action will also be useful for numerical evaluations , since a clever choice of the worldsheet metric will greatly improve the stability of the numerics @xcite , as we will see later .
the equations of motion for the @xmath30 fields from the polyakov action are @xmath31=\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{-h}h^{ab}(\partial_\mu g_{\nu\rho})\partial_ax^\nu\partial_bx^\rho\ , .\ ] ] the expression in the brackets on the lhs are just the canonical momentum densities : @xmath32 this definition can differ by a factor of @xmath33 from the usual definition of these momenta found in the literature , which is here just to ensure that the quantity in is a proper worldsheet vector . from now on , we will assume that the spacetime metric is diagonal and we will consider only @xmath34 s such that the metric does not depend on @xmath30 . in that case ,
equations of motion are in fact just the covariant conservation law for the momentum densities : @xmath35=\sqrt{-h}\nabla_a\pi_\mu^a=0\ , .\ ] ] in this case , the momentum densities are just the conserved noether currents on the worldsheet , associated with the invariance of the action to the constant spacetime translations @xmath36 . due to this origin , these worldsheet currents describe the flow of the @xmath34 component of the spacetime momentum of the string along the @xmath37 direction on the worldsheet @xcite and that is the reason why they are important in the study of energy loss in the field theory dual @xcite . because of
that it is also necessary to understand how these currents transform under a generic change of coordinates on the worldsheet .
a general coordinate transformation on the worldsheet @xmath38 can be defined by the following matrix : @xmath39 the worldsheet currents and the worldsheet metric then transform as proper worldsheet tensors : @xmath40 in practice , one solves the equations of motion with constraints and an appropriate set of boundary conditions in some parametrization where the numerics are well behaved ( by choosing a convenient @xmath25 at the beginning of the calculation ) and then , using formulas and , transforms to some more `` physical '' coordinate system on the worldsheet ( for example @xmath41 , the radial @xmath9 coordinate ) . from now on
, we assume that , through this procedure , a specific parametrization @xmath42 has been chosen , where @xmath43 is the physical time ( i.e. we are in the static gauge @xmath44 ) and that @xmath45 $ ] for all @xmath43 , i.e. the @xmath46 coordinate parametrizes the string at some fixed time @xmath43 .
in general , whenever we have a covariant conservation law on a differentiable manifold , such as , one defines the charge ( whose flow is described by @xmath47 ) that passes through some hypersurface @xmath48 as ( following conventions in @xcite ) @xmath49 where the second equation is written in terms of the one - form @xmath50 and in the second equation , @xmath51 is the induced volume element on the hypersurface @xmath48 and @xmath52 is the unit vector field normal to the hypersurface . in our case , we have a two - dimensional manifold , and @xmath48 represents an ( open ) curve on the worldsheet and @xmath53 is the @xmath34 component of the spacetime momentum that flows through this curve . here
one should think of @xmath34 as merely an index that denotes different kinds of conserved currents on the worldsheet .
therefore , in our case , we can simply write @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the line element of the curve @xmath48 . + in our choice of coordinates on the worldsheet @xmath56 , we can now ask what is the total @xmath34 component of the momentum of the string at some fixed time @xmath43 .
this means that we need to take the curve @xmath48 to be the curve of constant @xmath43 , which means that its tangent vector @xmath57 is in the @xmath46-direction , i.e. @xmath58 , where the first entry is the @xmath46 coordinate and the second the @xmath43 coordinate .
the normal vector @xmath59 can then be found by requiring its orthogonality to the tangent vector and the usual normalization condition : @xmath60 where the dot products are taken with the worldsheet metric @xmath25 .
using these two equations , we can solve for the components of the normal vector : @xmath61 finally , since for this particular curve we have @xmath62 , we can express the line element @xmath55 as @xmath63 using and in , we have @xmath64 note that this is true no matter what the parametrization of the string is . the only requirement here is that we are dealing with a constant-@xmath43 curve .
similarly , we can repeat the same procedure for a constant-@xmath46 curve , integrating over some period of time : @xmath65 which then gives the momentum that has flown down the string ( i.e. in the direction of increasing @xmath46 ) at position @xmath46 during the time @xmath66 . both and are the well - known formulas that can be found in e.g. @xcite and @xcite .
now consider an open string with free endpoint boundary conditions : @xmath67 then , take a closed loop @xmath48 on the string worldsheet , composed of two constant-@xmath43 curves at times @xmath68 and @xmath69 , going from @xmath70 to some chosen @xmath71 , connected by the two corresponding constant-@xmath46 curves . since the worldsheet currents are conserved , we have , again following conventions in @xcite : @xmath72 due to the free endpoint boundary condition , the third term on the rhs is zero , while the integrals over time , according to , represent the spacetime momentum of the part of the string between @xmath70 and @xmath71 at times @xmath68 and @xmath69 : @xmath73 this equation clearly shows how the momentum of some part of the string can change only if the @xmath74 component of the worldsheet current carries it away .
the negative sign on the rhs indicates that , for a positive @xmath74 , the momentum of that part of the string will decrease , consistent with the fact that this current component describes the flow of the momentum in the direction of increasing @xmath46 , i.e. away from the part of the string .
incidentally , if we take a string configuration which is symmetric around @xmath75 , then , due to this symmetry , @xmath76 must vanish . in that case @xmath77
represents the momentum of half of the string and , from , we see that this momentum for such a symmetric string configuration does not change with time .
to obtain the usual expression for the instantaneous energy loss , we can let @xmath78 in : @xmath79 this quantity gives the flow of the @xmath34 component of the momentum along the string at a position @xmath46 at time @xmath43 .
we note again that this is the well - known expression for energy loss from @xcite and @xcite , but the previous analysis gave us insight into its validity ; namely , it pointed out that is valid only for constant-@xmath46 curves . now , let us do the following coordinate transformation on the worldsheet : @xmath80 i.e. we stay in the static gauge and only change the string parametrization using some well - defined function @xmath81 .
we can then repeat the analysis from the previous paragraph and see that in this coordinate system , for a constant-@xmath82 curve , we also have @xmath83 we can relate these to the corresponding quantities in the @xmath56 coordinate system by using and , which for this particular transformation are given by @xmath84 where @xmath85 and @xmath86 . plugging this
in we have @xmath87_{(\sigma(\tilde{\sigma},t),t)}\ , .\ ] ] if we want to evaluate the energy loss at different times , we have to make a choice of what points on the string ( at different times ) we are going to evaluate the currents in on .
we choose that these points on the string have a constant @xmath82 coordinate at all times ( i.e. this is how we define the , so far , arbitrary @xmath82-parametrization ) , while in the @xmath46-parametrization , these points are defined by a function @xmath88 . the physical motivation behind such a choice is to say that , at some time @xmath43 , the jet is defined as the part of the string between the endpoint @xmath70 and @xmath89 . in @xcite , for falling strings in @xmath5 , this choice was such that the spatial distance ( i.e. the @xmath90 coordinate in @xmath5 , assuming that the string is moving in the @xmath91 plane ) between the string endpoint and those points was of the order @xmath92 .
now , since @xmath93 is constant at all times , we have @xmath94_{\sigma=\sigma_\kappa(t)}\ , .\ ] ] plugging this in we arrive at @xmath95_{(\sigma_\kappa(t),t)}\ , .\ ] ] this is the central result of this paper .
this formula gives the appropriate expression for energy loss in terms of quantities expressed in any parametrization @xmath56 in which the function @xmath88 is known .
here we were making use of the simple expression for the energy loss in the special @xmath82-parametrization ( in which the coordinate of the points on which we evaluate the currents is constant ) , but in using this formula one does not need to know what that parametrization really is , since the rhs of is given only in terms of quantities in @xmath56 parametrization .
now , the argument for calling some quantity @xmath96 the energy loss comes from the idea that , when integrated over some period of time @xmath66 , this integral should give the amount of energy that the jet ( that is , some predefined part of the string ) has lost over some period of time @xmath66 : @xmath97 by identifying @xmath96 with @xmath98 in the @xmath99 parametrization ( essentially just the @xmath100 component of the worldsheet current ) , as implied in @xcite , means that this amount of energy lost should be given by @xmath101 where the subscript _ app _ stands for `` apparent '' and where @xmath102 corresponds to the points at a fixed spatial distance @xmath92 from the string endpoint at all times .
however , this formula ( i.e. that the energy loss is given only by the @xmath46 component of the worldsheet current ) , as we showed before , is valid only if one uses a constant-@xmath46 curve , which is not the case in this parametrization .
then , in order to be able to use that simple expression , we need to find a parametrization @xmath82 in which the coordinates of the points given by @xmath102 are constant . in this case , the energy lost would indeed be @xmath103 the difference between this and the apparent energy loss is then explicitly given by : @xmath104_{(r_\kappa(t),t)}\ , .\ ] ] in the following section we will numerically examine the effect of this correction in the case of falling strings in @xmath5 spacetime , dual to @xmath0 sym .
in this section we will largely follow the procedure described in @xcite , but for consistency we will review it here .
we will work in the @xmath5-bh geometry with the conformal boundary located at @xmath10 : @xmath105\ , , \ ] ] where @xmath106 , with @xmath7 being the radial position of the horizon of the black hole .
we choose the worldsheet metric @xmath25 to have the following form : @xmath107 here @xmath108 is the `` stretching function '' , which is chosen in such a way that the numerical computation is well behaved .
choosing the worldsheet metric in this way represents merely a choice of parametrization on the worldsheet ( i.e. a `` choice of gauge '' ) and the constraint equations are there to ensure that the embedding functions change accordingly .
explicitly , the constraint equations are @xmath109 where @xmath110 , @xmath111 and , in general , @xmath112 .
we assume that the string is moving in the @xmath91 plane and choose the `` pointlike '' initial conditions , where the string is initially a point at some radial coordinate @xmath113 : @xmath114 then @xmath115 , which automatically satisfies the first constraint equation , and now we have to choose an initial velocity profile ( i.e. functions @xmath116 ) such that the second constraint equation @xmath117 and the free string endpoint boundary conditions are satisfied . following @xcite , we choose @xmath118 where @xmath119 is a constant determining the `` amplitude '' of the velocity profile
. then @xmath120 is determined by the constraint equation : @xmath121 for this set of initial conditions we choose the following stretching function : @xmath122 in particular , its most important feature is that it matches the singularity of the @xmath123 metric component near the horizon @xmath7 , so that the embedding functions can remain well behaved as parts of the string approach the horizon . initial conditions , and have been chosen as in @xcite ( and in @xcite ) , in order to be able to exactly compare the effect of the correction on the results from that work . as discussed in @xcite and @xcite , the physical motivation behind
the choice of initial conditions is that they should resemble a quark - antiquark pair produced by some local current , with the quarks having enough energy to move away in the opposite directions .
the velocity profiles and are one of the simplest profiles that satisfy the open string endpoint boundary conditions and uniformly evolve the string towards the black hole ( which should resemble the process of thermalization of the interaction energy described by the body of the string ) with the endpoints moving away in the opposite directions .
the energy density profile in the boundary theory dual to such a string evolution will have two peaks concentrated around the endpoints , and the smooth u - shaped profile between the peaks will slowly decrease in magnitude . with this choice of initial and boundary conditions
, we can solve the equations of motion numerically , obtain the embedding functions @xmath24 and then evaluate the energy loss in the radial @xmath41 parametrization with and without the correction in . to obtain the actual energy loss
, we simply use the formula with the worldsheet fluxes expressed in the static gauge @xmath56 using and : @xmath124_{(\sigma_\kappa(t),t)}\ , .\ ] ] the apparent energy loss is given by in the @xmath125 parametrization , so we need to use formulas and again , giving @xmath126_{(\sigma_\kappa(t),t)}\ , .\ ] ] the results are shown in fig .
one can clearly see that the correction , derived in , becomes especially important at late times , when @xmath127 grows , as the relevant parts of the string start falling towards the black hole faster and faster .
comparison of the ( normalized ) instantaneous energy loss as a function of time with and without the correction in .
the dashed red curve shows the apparent energy loss @xmath128 in the radial @xmath41 parametrization ( eq . ) , while the solid blue curve is the actual energy loss @xmath96 , as given by .
the energy loss was evaluated at points at a fixed spatial distance from the string endpoint , chosen in such a way that the correction in appears clearly .
the normalization constant @xmath129 is the energy of half of the string and @xmath130 is the temperature .
the numerical parameters used are @xmath131 and @xmath132.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] we should note that the energy of the part of the string between @xmath70 and @xmath133 at the thermalization time @xmath134 ( when the string endpoint stops moving in the @xmath90-direction ) , is generally nonzero .
this means that the area under the solid blue curve in fig .
[ fig ] is always less than 1 , and represents the relative amount of energy lost from the part of the string defined by @xmath88 , as evident from . on the other hand ,
the area under the dashed red curve is not known _ a priori _ , and could be @xmath135 or @xmath136 , depending on the magnitude of the correction in .
specifically , if we decrease the spatial distance from the endpoint at which we evaluate the energy loss ( keeping the same initial conditions ) , the area under the red curve increases and eventually becomes @xmath136 ( in the figure it is already slightly higher than 1 ) .
also note that the `` jet definition '' we are using here is taken from @xcite , where the jet is defined as the part of the string within a certain @xmath137 distance from the endpoint . as discussed in @xcite ,
the physical motivation behind this is that the baryon density in the boundary theory should be well localized on scales of order @xmath138 .
there are also other physically well - motivated jet definitions @xcite , exploration of which is left for future work .
we have derived , by analyzing transformations of spacetime momentum fluxes on the classical string worldsheet , a general expression for calculating the instantaneous energy loss for time - dependent string configurations valid in any choice of worldsheet parametrization .
this formula shows that the energy loss in time - dependent string configurations receives a correction to the simple @xmath74 expression .
this correction comes from the fact that the points on the string at which we want to evaluate the energy loss at different times do not necessarily have constant coordinates in the chosen worldsheet parametrization .
the importance of the correction depends on how fast the coordinates of these points change in time in that parametrization , i.e. on the magnitude of the @xmath139 function . in the example of falling strings
, we have seen that this correction becomes especially important at late times and substantially decreases the magnitude of the bragg - like peak ( fig .
[ fig ] ) .
one should point out that this correction does not affect the results of @xcite for the maximum stopping distance @xmath140 , since this expression was derived from purely kinematical considerations , by analyzing the equations of motion and relating the total energy of the string to the approximate endpoint motion described by the null geodesics .
in other words , the worldsheet currents ( actually , their identification with the energy loss ) were not used in that derivation .
we should also point out that this correction does not affect the well - established drag force results of @xcite and @xcite , since the trailing string is a stationary string configuration where @xmath141 .
one is tempted to speculate about the implications of the results shown in fig .
[ fig ] to the jet quenching phenomena .
our preliminary numerical studies suggest that , although the early time behavior of the energy loss is susceptible to the initial conditions ( as noted in @xcite ) , the linearity of it seems to be a remarkably robust feature .
of course , a more thorough numerical analysis is needed to confirm such a claim ( and is left for future work ) , but if this indeed remains to be true and @xmath96 scales like @xmath142 , then taking into account that @xmath140 , it can be shown that this is similar to the typical qualitative behavior of energy loss of light quarks in pqcd in the strong lpm regime @xcite .
this suggests a tempting idea that the phenomenon of light quark jet quenching may have a roughly universal qualitative character , regardless of whether we are dealing with a strongly or a weakly coupled medium .
however , as emphasized before , a more thorough quantitative analysis and estimate of the relative magnitude of energy loss and stopping distances are necessary . it would be also interesting to more thoroughly examine the effects of varying the string initial conditions , as well as choosing a different @xmath88 function ( i.e. a different jet definition ) , on the shape of the instantaneous energy loss . by choosing some set of these , one
can then compute the @xmath17 in a dynamical , expanding medium with a realistic set of nuclear initial conditions , and , finally , inspect the robustness of that result by varying the string initial conditions and the @xmath88 choice and seeing how much @xmath17 would be affected .
we especially thank j. noronha and m. gyulassy for valuable input and help .
we also thank m. mia , s. endlich , a. buzzatti , c. herzog and s. gubser for helpful discussions .
we acknowledge support by u.s .
doe nuclear science grant no .
de - fg02 - 93er40764 .
s. s. gubser , a. nellore , s. s. pufu and f. d. rocha , `` thermodynamics and bulk viscosity of approximate black hole duals to finite temperature quantum chromodynamics '' , _ phys .
lett . _ * 101 * ( 2008 ) 131601 , arxiv:0804.1950 [ hep - th ] .
j. adams et al .
( star collaboration ) , `` experimental and theoretical challenges in the search for the quark gluon plasma : the star collaboration s critical assessment of the evidence from rhic collisions '' , _ nucl .
a _ * 757 * ( 2005 ) 102 - 183 , arxiv : nucl - ex/0501009 . k. adcox et al .
( phenix collaboration ) , `` formation of dense partonic matter in relativistic nucleus - nucleus collisions at rhic : experimental evaluation by the phenix collaboration '' , _ nucl .
a _ * 757 * ( 2005 ) 184 - 283 , arxiv : nucl - ex/0410003 .
m. gyulassy , i. vitev , x. n. wang and b. w. zhang , `` jet quenching and radiative energy loss in dense nuclear matter '' , _ quark gluon plasma 3 _ , world scientific , singapore ( 2004 ) , p. 123
, arxiv : nucl - th/0302077 .
c. p. herzog , a. karch , p. kovtun , c. kozcaz and l. g. yaffe , `` energy loss of a heavy quark moving through @xmath145=4 supersymmetric yang - mills plasma '' , _ jhep _ * 0607 * ( 2006 ) 013 , arxiv : hep - th/0605158 .
k. aamodt et al .
( alice collaboration ) , `` suppression of charged particle production at large transverse momentum in central pb
pb collisions at @xmath146 tev '' , _ phys .
b _ * 696 * ( 2011 ) 30 , arxiv:1012.1004 [ nucl - ex ] .
p. m. chesler , k. jensen , a. karch and l. g. yaffe , `` light quark energy loss in strongly - coupled @xmath145=4 supersymmetric yang - mills plasma '' , _ phys .
* 79 * ( 2009 ) 125015 , arxiv:0810.1985 [ hep - th ] .
the string momenta @xmath148 ( defined later in ) can be identified with the momenta of the boundary gauge theory , essentially because they are momenta defined with respect to the killing vectors @xmath149 . for more details , see k. skenderis , `` asymptotically anti - de sitter spacetimes and their stress energy tensor '' , _ int . j. mod .
a _ * 16 * ( 2001 ) 740 - 749 , arxiv : hep - th/0010138 . | we analyze spacetime momentum currents on a classical string worldsheet , study their generic connection via ads / cft correspondence to the instantaneous energy loss of the dual field theory degrees of freedom and suggest a general formula for computing energy loss in a time - dependent string configuration . applying this formula to the case of falling strings , generally dual to light quarks , reveals that the energy loss does not display a well - pronounced bragg peak at late times , as previously believed . finally , we comment on the possible implications of this result to the jet quenching phenomena in heavy ion collisions . |
one of the most exciting yet observationally challenging scientific objectives of the large area telescope ( lat ) on board the _ fermi gamma - ray space telescope _
@xcite , is the indirect detection of particle dark matter @xcite
. however , limited gamma - ray statistics make diffuse signals arising from the pair - annihilation of dark matter difficult to differentiate from astrophysical processes .
the limitation of using a diffuse signal to search for non - standard emission stems from difficulties in controlling the instrumental background and formulating a rigorous model for the astrophysical diffuse foregrounds .
an intriguing excess of microwave radiation in the wmap data has been uncovered by @xcite and @xcite .
the morphology and spectrum of the wmap haze indicates a hard electron - positron injection spectrum spherically distributed around the galactic center . while the origin of this haze need not be related to _ new _ particle physics , the possibility that the wmap haze corresponds to synchrotron radiation of stable leptons produced by dark matter has been explored in several studies ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
a potentially conclusive way to determine whether the wmap haze originates from a population of energetic leptons is to observe gamma - rays produced by inverse compton up - scattering ( ic ) of photons in the interstellar galactic radiation field ( isrf ) .
recently , @xcite ( hereafter d09 ) examined the lat gamma - ray sky and reported an excess emission morphologically similar to the wmap haze .
d09 s observations suggest a confirmation of the _ haze hypothesis _ : that excess microwave emission stems from relativistic electron synchrotron with a spherical source distribution and a hard injection spectrum . in the type 2 " and type 3 " fits of d09 ,
the excess was claimed over a best - fit background using spatial templates which employed the gas map of @xcite ( sfd ) to trace gamma - ray emission from @xmath0 decay , and the 408 mhz haslam synchrotron map to trace ic emission from galactic cosmic ray electrons .
the spatial templates ( plus an isotropic component obtained by mean - subtracting the residual skymap ) were used to fit the observed gamma - ray sky in energy bins spanning 2 - 100 gev .
this analysis uncovered a residual gamma - ray emission above and below the galactic center with a morphology and spectrum similar to that found in the wmap dataset @xcite . in this @xmath1 , we test the following assumptions used in d09 for the removal of astrophysical foregrounds at gamma - ray energies : * that line of sight ism maps are adequate tracers for the morphology of @xmath0 emission , and * that the 408 mhz synchrotron map is an adequate tracer for the morphology of the galactic ic emission .
assumption ( 1 ) entails neglecting the morphology of galactic cosmic - ray sources , since the observed @xmath0 emission results from the line - of - sight integral of the gas density ( `` target '' ) times the cosmic - ray density ( `` beam '' ) .
assumption ( 2 ) neglects the difference between the morphology of the isrf and the galactic magnetic fields . on theoretical grounds ,
we expect that any detailed galactic cosmic - ray model would predict _ systematic deviations _ from the templates used in d09 . utilizing the galactic cosmic - ray propagation code galprop
, we find that the procedure based on spatial templates creates deviations comparable to the amplitude of the d09 residual .
furthermore , we find that these deviations are morphologically similar to the fermi haze .
we thus conclude that the determination of an excess gamma - ray diffuse emission can not reliably be assessed from the spatial template proxies used in the type 2 " and type 3 " fits of d09 .
we stress that our results do not claim that there is no `` haze '' in the fermi data .
in particular , the systematic effects we study here are not relavent to explain the puzzling excess emission in the `` type 1 '' fit of d09 , which employes fermi - lat data in the 1 - 2 gev range as a proxy for the morphology of the @xmath0 component .
we comment on this `` type 1 '' approach in section [ sec : discussion ] .
employing the cosmic ray propagation code galprop ( v 50.1p ) @xcite , we compute the line - of - sight emission for galactic synchrotron , ic and @xmath0 decay predicted by a galprop model that is consistent with all cosmic ray and photon observations ( see * ? ? ?
* for further detail ) .
except where noted , we employ standard parameters given by the galdef file 599278 throughout this work .
a large uncertainty in the propagation of cosmic rays relates to the intensity and orientation of galactic magnetic fields as the intensity of synchrotron radiation varies with the square of the local magnetic field intensity . in our default simulation
we assume a magnetic field of random orientation and an intensity that exponentially decays in both @xmath2 and @xmath3 with scale radii of 10 kpc and 2 kpc respectively , normalized to 5 @xmath4 g at the solar position @xcite . to determine the accuracy of the d09 spatial templates for astrophysical foreground emission , we generate line - of - sight skymaps for the input gas density , as well as the outputs of emission due to @xmath0 decay , synchrotron and ic .
note that the gas density maps we employ here differ from the sfd map used in d09 .
most notably , the sfd map traces dust , while our map traces galactic gas .
the difference between these approaches is expected to be small , but might introduce additional systematic deviations . by dividing , pixel by pixel , the line - of - sight map for @xmath0 decay by the input gas map , and the map of ic emission by the synchrotron map , we can assess the size of any systematic effects produced by assumptions ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) of section [ sec : introduction ] .
we normalize each map over pixels of @xmath5b@xmath5 @xmath6 5@xmath7 , using equal area weighting to determine the normalization constant .
this is equivalent to the masking procedure of d09 - though we do not mask out the galactic plane in our plots .
we select several regions of the sky for which we provide numerical analyses of each map we present , with a background normalized as in d09 .
we first evaluate d09 s claim of an excess emission in the southern galactic plane between -30@xmath7 @xmath8 b @xmath8 -10@xmath7 and @xmath5l@xmath5 @xmath8 15@xmath7 , indicated as the _ d09 haze_. we add the symmetric _ d09 northern haze _ region ( 10@xmath7 @xmath8 b @xmath8 30@xmath7 and @xmath5l@xmath915 ) .
d09 defines their haze to begin at 10@xmath7 , but only masked the region @xmath5b@xmath5
@xmath8 5@xmath7 .
in order to determine the importance of this choice , we include both northern and southern regions following 5@xmath7 @xmath8 @xmath5b@xmath5 @xmath8 25@xmath7 and @xmath5l@xmath5 @xmath8 15@xmath7 , which we denote as the _ inner haze _ region . since d09 models the morphology of the haze with a bivariate gaussian that decays exponentially in both latitude and longitude
, we further consider a map weighting the value at each unmasked pixel using a bivariate gaussian of 25@xmath7 in latitude and 15@xmath7 in longitude , and dubbed the _ gaussian haze_. finally , in order to ascertain the variation of each map , we consider the galactic anticenter region 5@xmath10b@xmath9 25@xmath7 and @xmath5l@xmath5 @xmath6 170 .
in figure [ pi0divgas ] we show the normalized line - of - sight skymap for @xmath0 decay divided by the normalized line - of - sight gas density input into our galprop simulations .
the results are shown on a linear scale ( left ) and a logarithmic scale ( right ) , and both are smoothed using a gaussian of 2@xmath7 width .
we find that the resultant skymap displays significant deviations from unity , with factors of approximately two above and below the galactic center , to values of about 0.3 near the galactic anti - center . in table
[ tab : regions ] ( top row ) , we provide both the average value in the d09 background region , as well as the numeric ratios in each of our defined regions . while this map for @xmath0 decay is taken at a test energy of 1 gev ,
the variation of the ratio across four decades in energy ( 0.1 gev - 1 tev ) is less than 2% .
while we find a deviation between the d09 haze region and the d09 background of only 4% , we find a difference of 15% between the southern inner haze region and the d09 background .
these changes stem from the removal of a slight deficit in @xmath0 decay at approximately 30@xmath7 , and more importantly , the addition of increased emission between 5 - 10@xmath7 . because the galactic gas distribution is not symmetric above and below the galactic plane
, we expect some north - south variation , and we indeed find substantially higher values in the northern hemisphere . finally , we calculate the ratio of the entire skymap weighted by the bivariate gaussian employed in d09 . we find a 17% excess in this measurement , which implies that using the gas map to account for the emission from @xmath0 decay in the fermi - lat signal would create a residual structure that could be fit by a bivariate gaussian with a mean intensity 17% as large as the overall neutral pion gamma - ray emission . since the latter vastly dominates the gamma - ray sky at low energies , this is a very significant effect between 0.1 and a few gev .
as remarked in @xcite , the comparison of preliminary galactic gamma - ray diffuse models with the lat source - subtracted sky data implies residuals which are likely much smaller than the systematic effect we point out here . in figure [ icsdivsync ]
we show the normalized line - of - sight ratio of ic emission at four energies ( 3.55 gev , 7.08 gev , 14.1 gev and 35.5 gev ) divided by synchrotron emission at 408 mhz .
the maps are again smoothed using a gaussian of 2@xmath7 , although in this case the intrinsic discreteness of galprop simulation grids makes the effect of this smoothing minimal .
we note a pronounced structure above and below the galactic center which corresponds to an excess emission at low energies , but a deficit of emission at high energies . returning to table [ tab : regions ] ( rows 2 - 5 )
, we note that the ratios of ic and synchrotron emission remain relatively constant in all of the sky regions we consider .
this occurs for two reasons : ( 1 ) the galprop model is nearly symmetric around the galactic plane , and ( 2 ) synchrotron emission dies off quickly at high latitudes , making the deviation just as prominant in the d09 regions as the inner regions .
the morphology of these skymaps , however , has a pronounced energy dependence . at 3.55 gev ,
there is a 16% overabundance in ic emission above and below the galactic center , while at 35.5 gev , this changes to an approximately 5% deficit in ic emission . at all energies we see a deficit in ic near the galactic anti - center of between 5 - 17% .
the systematic effect stemming from assumption ( 2 ) would thus play a role in the determination of a gamma - ray haze spectrum , since the spatial template would change significantly with energy .
the morphology of these systematic effects is intuitively reasonable .
both ic and synchrotron emission depend on the same input population of high energy electrons ( here modeled according to the results of @xcite ) .
thus , the morphology of the ic to synchrotron ratio depends primarily on the morphology of the energy density in the interstellar - radiation field ( isrf ) compared to the galactic magnetic field ( though we note that electrons at a given energy do not upscatter photons to a single energy , as the isrf is composed of photons across a large range of frequencies ) .
the magnetic field model we employ falls off sharply at high latitudes , but only weakly with changing radii , explaining its relative brightness near the galactic anti - center , and dimness at high galactic latitude .
we note that the ratio of @xmath0 emission to the input gas map is fairly independent of the galprop propagation setup , as it depends primarily on the cosmic - ray density throughout space , which is constrained by local observations of cosmic ray fluxes and primary - to - secondary ratios .
while the ratio of ic to synchrotron emission depends on the same source of high energy leptons , the morphology depends on the morphology of the isrf compared to the magnetic fields .
thus , one important feature which greatly affects the ratio of ic to synchrotron emission is the assumed morphology of the galactic magnetic fields , which are highly uncertain away from the sun s local neighborhood . in figure
[ icsdivsync.blargeradii ] , we show the resulting ratio of ic to synchrotron emission for a magnetic field which decays exponentially with scale radii of 20.0 kpc in r and 2.0 kpc in z , tuned to a magnitude of 5 @xmath4 g at the solar position . we note that this magnetic field setup increases the haze structure above and below the galactic pole by comparatively decreasing synchrotron radiation in that region , creating ratios greater than two in the galactic center and a gaussian deviation ranging from 1.54 at 3.55 gev to 1.40 at 35.5 gev .
furthermore , this setup decreases the height of the haze structure to approximately 45@xmath7 , which is in good agreement with the observed haze in d09 . in table
[ tab : regions ] ( rows 6 - 9 ) we show the resulting haze ratios at each energy cutoff , finding ratios between 1.4 - 1.6 depending on the given energy level and region .
another feature which may artificially yield greater uniformity in the ratio of the ic to synchrotron emission is the height of the diffusion zone . for small diffusion boxes ,
our high latitude gamma ray emission would be dominated by local cosmic rays , decreasing the variability of our results .
however , this modeling trick can not be used to support the haze hypothesis , since the conjecture states that a flux of high energy leptons exists between 10@xmath7 to 30@xmath7 above and below the galactic center . a smaller diffusion region such as that at 2 kpc ,
will shut off emission at more than 14@xmath7 latitude above the galactic plane , surpressing almost all emission from the haze region .
while a complete study of the diffuse emission detected by fermi - lat in terms of foreground templates is outside the scope of this @xmath1 , work is currently ongoing that will also include the possible contribution to gamma radiation of nearby structures such as loop i @xcite which are not modeled within galprop . whether improved spatial templates could conclusively pinpoint an excess diffuse emission in the fermi - lat data is hard to assess , as changes in the spatial morphology of each input will influence the best fit intensities of each component .
however , we note that if the gas and synchrotron templates used in d09 were appropriate matches to @xmath0 and ic emission , we would expect ratios very close to unity across the entire skymap .
we instead find significant deviations with an intensity comparable to the fermi haze at low energies .
moreover , these deviations are not randomly distributed across the sky , but instead contain a structure resembling the bivariate gaussian reported by d09 .
thus , our results point to the possibility that the fermi haze determined by the `` type 2 '' and `` type 3 '' templates of d09 is the result of systematic effects in the spatial template fitting procedure as opposed to the existence of a new source class .
we have shown that the use of the gas map would create a best match bivariate gaussian intensity approximately 17% as strong as the @xmath0 decay amplitude .
since we expect @xmath0 decay to dominate the diffuse gamma - ray sky below 10 gev , this error can explain a large fraction of the d09 haze .
similarly , ic due to ordinary galactic cosmic rays is expected to show an excess of approximately 20% in the haze region , with large variances depending on the assumed magnetic field model . at high energies
( @xmath6 10 gev ) , @xmath0 decay is weaker , and thus a 15% error is not expected to dominate astrophysical ic or haze signals .
furthermore , some magnetic field models create synchrotron templates which would overestimate ic emission in this region .
thus , the remaining amplitude of a d09 haze may in fact be larger or smaller than reported in this region .
we note additional errors may be present at high energies both due to low photon counts as well as instrumental effects such as cosmic ray contamination .
in addition , nearby cosmic rays such as those in the giant radio feature loop i can fake a diffuse gamma - ray emission in the direction of the galactic center unrelated to a wmap haze counterpart .
d09 additionally adopts another template , dubbed `` type i '' , where they use the fermi - lat data in the 1 - 2 gev range as a proxy for the morphology of @xmath0 emission . using this template
, d09 finds an excess emission that becomes more prominent at higher energies , indicating a residual with a harder spectrum than @xmath0-decay emission .
they note that this excess has a morphology comparable with those found by their astrophysical template fits , except with a more peaked structure that may be due to the subtraction of the 1 - 2 gev components of the ics and bremsstrahlung maps .
this emission template does not claim to subtract any @xmath11-ray foregrounds except for those due to @xmath0-decay , but notes that the residual has a morphology which is peculiar for models such as ics of high energy astrophysical leptons .
as this template does not make use of either the synchrotron or sfd maps , it falls outside the scope of our analysis .
we agree that the emission is likely not due to @xmath0 , and it is difficult to construct an astrophysical source distribution which is more pronounced towards high latitudes than near the galactic plane .
any galactic electron sources should lie close to the galactic plane , and would primarily upscatter starlight to gev energies . in figure
[ fig : isrf ] , we show the isrf used in our galprop models integrated over the line - of - sight .
we see that the isrf is also strongest along the galactic plane , extended in longitude rather than latitude by a ratio from 5 - 4 at 12.4ev to 9 - 1 at 0.0124ev .
we further note that the isrf dims by between 63 - 72% between 10@xmath7 - 30@xmath7 latitude .
this decay is itself slightly stronger than the decay in diffuse emission used in the d09 gaussian template .
this isrf is morphologically identical to the ic morphologies obtained by comvolving the input isrf with a isotropic and monochromatic input electron spectrum .
since this spectrum is much broader than the haze determined by d09 , and falls slightly more quickly at high galactic latitudes , the input source class would have to be significantly peaked above and below the galactic plane , with very little extent along the plane .
furthermore , the source class must have a flux at 4.25 kpc above the galactic center , which is almost equvalent to the flux at 1.5 kpc above the galactic center , in order that the product of the lepton flux and isrf fall off by a ratio comparable to the gaussian haze . the characteristics of this input source spectrum is not similar to those of expected galactic sources .
this problem night be overcome by several ad hoc changes in the isrf around the galactic center region , or by changes in the convection currents and diffusion constants away from the galactic plane @xcite .
however , these same changes will greatly alter the assumed morphology of astrophysical ics as well , possibly eliminating the need for an extra diffuse component . in summary
, we showed that significant systematic effects make it difficult to reliably assess a diffuse gamma - ray emission in the region associated to the wmap haze .
a fully self - consistent galactic cosmic - ray model is necessary to model the astrophysical diffuse emission from the galaxy and to compare it to the fermi - lat data .
we thank troy porter and andy strong for feedback regarding galprop models , as well as gregory dobler and douglas finkbeiner for useful discussions regarding the template construction in d09 .
tl is supported by a gaann fellowship by the department of education .
sp is supported by an oji award from the us department of energy ( doe contract defg02 - 04er41268 ) , and by nsf grant phy-0757911 .
ccccccccc model i d & background & & d09 haze & d09 n. haze & inner haze & n. inner haze & gaussian haze & anticenter + + + * @xmath0 decay * & 0.97 & & 1.04 & 1.15 & 1.15 & 1.21 & 1.17 & 0.79 + + * base ic - 3.55 gev * & 0.95 & & 1.16 & 1.16 & 1.16 & 1.16 & 1.16 & 0.83 + * base ic - 7.08 gev * & 0.96 & & 1.09 & 1.09 & 1.10 & 1.09 & 1.10 & 0.86 + * base ic - 14.1 gev * & 0.98 & & 1.03 & 1.03 & 1.04 & 1.04 & 1.05 & 0.89 + * base ic - 35.5 gev * & 1.00 & & 0.94 & 0.94 & 0.95 & 0.95 & 0.96 & 0.95 + + * alt .
ic - 3.55 gev * & 0.88 & & 1.47 & 1.46 & 1.57 & 1.56 & 1.54 & 0.62 + * alt .
ic - 7.08 gev * & 0.89 & & 1.42 & 1.41 & 1.53 & 1.51 & 1.49 & 0.65 + * alt . ic - 14.1 gev * & 0.90 & & 1.38 & 1.37 & 1.49 & 1.48 & 1.46 & 0.68 + * alt .
ic - 35.5 gev * & 0.92 & & 1.31 & 1.30 & 1.43 & 1.41 & 1.40 & 0.74 + + + + , e. a. , berenji , b. , bertone , g. , bergstrm , l. , bloom , e. , bringmann , t. , chiang , j. , cohen - tanugi , j. , conrad , j. , edmonds , y. , edsj , j. , godfrey , g. , hughes , r. e. , johnson , r. p. , lionetto , a. , moiseev , a. a. , morselli , a. , moskalenko , i. v. , nuss , e. , ormes , j. f. , rando , r. , sander , a. j. , sellerholm , a. , smith , p. d. , strong , a. w. , wai , l. , wang , p. , & winer , b. l. 2008 , journal of cosmology and astro - particle physics , 7 , 13 | recent claims of a gamma - ray excess in the diffuse galactic emission detected by the fermi large area telescope made use of spatial templates from the interstellar medium ( ism ) column density and the 408 mhz sky as proxies for neutral pion and inverse compton ( ic ) gamma - ray emission , respectively .
we identify significant systematic effects in this procedure that can artificially induce an additional diffuse component with a morphology strikingly similar to the claimed gamma - ray haze .
to quantitatively illustrate this point we calculate sky - maps of the ratio of the gamma - ray emission from neutral pions to the ism column density , and of ic to synchrotron emission , using detailed galactic cosmic - ray models and simulations . in the region above and below the galactic center ,
the ism template underestimates the gamma - ray emission due to neutral pion decay by approximately 20% .
additionally , the synchrotron template tends to under - estimate the ic emission at low energies ( few gev ) and to over - estimate it at higher energies ( tens of gev ) by potentially large factors that depend crucially on the assumed magnetic field structure of the galaxy .
the size of the systematic effects we find are comparable to the size of the claimed `` fermi haze '' signal . we thus conclude that a detailed model for the galactic diffuse emission is necessary in order to conclusively assess the presence of a gamma - ray excess possibly associated to the wmap haze morphology . |
in the field of superconductivity , symmetry of the cooper - pair wavefunction in spin- , time- , and orbital - spaces has attracted much attention for the past few decades . within the framework of superconductivity theory developed by bardeen , cooper and schrieffer ( bcs),@xcite it is established that a cooper pair is formed by two electrons with momentums @xmath5 and @xmath6 near the fermi surface . due to the fermi - dirac statistics ,
the cooper - pair wavefunction must have sign change in the exchange of the two electrons . in the spin space
, cooper pair can be classified into either singlet or triplet type . as for the orbital part of the pair wavefunction ,
when we focus on the symmetry with respect to the exchange of two momentums @xmath5 and @xmath6 , i.e. , @xmath7 , one can define the parity of the cooper pair .
for the conventional bcs superconductors like al , pb and nb , in the presence of the translational symmetry ( @xmath8 ) and together with the space- , time - inversion and spin - rotational symmetries , the cooper pairs are in the singlet even - frequency even - parity state , in consistent with the fermi - dirac statistics . here , even / odd frequency refers to the situation that the pair wavefunction is even / odd with respect to the exchange of time coordinates . in 1974 , berezinskii considered the possibility of the triplet even - frequency pairing with even parity in the observed phase of @xmath9he.@xcite after that , the possibilities of the cooper pair with other symmetries are extensively studied , and from the symmetry analysis,@xcite cooper pairs can be classified into ( i ) singlet even - frequency ( se ) with even parity ; ( ii ) singlet odd - frequency ( so ) with odd parity ; ( iii ) triplet odd - frequency ( to ) with even parity ; ( iv ) triplet even - frequency ( te ) with odd parity . specifically , after the proposal by berezinskii , to pairing has been discussed in a wide variety of theoretical models with spin - rotational and time - inversion asymmetries,@xcite e.g. , kondo model,@xcite hubbard model@xcite and heavy fermion system.@xcite meanwhile , several proposals about the so pairing have also been reported in the inhomogeneous systems with space- and time - inversion asymmetries by introducing effective @xmath1-wave electron - electron ( e - e ) interaction.@xcite in the presence of the odd - frequency pairings , by considering the retardation effect of the electron interaction , odd - frequency gaps or odd - frequency order parameters are theoretically suggested.@xcite however , up till now , odd - frequency bulk superconductor has not yet been realized experimentally .
moreover , it is now commonly believed that the pairing in superfluid @xmath9he is in the te type.@xcite recently , much effort has been focused on the superconductivity in material sr@xmath10ruo@xmath11 due to the generally recognized similarity to that in @xmath9he.@xcite the pairing and order parameter in superconducting sr@xmath10ruo@xmath11 are theoretically suggested@xcite and primarily confirmed from recent experiments@xcite to be the @xmath1-wave te type .
furthermore , it is reported very recently that the te pairing and order parameter can also be realized in the non - centrosymmetric superconductor@xcite with spin - orbit coupling ( soc ) existing in nature,@xcite whose experimental confirmations are still in progress .
although it is not easy so far to realize odd - frequency superconductivity and/or triplet one in the uniform bulk system , it is more promising to induce these pairings in the inhomogeneous systems with lower symmetry .
specifically , in the last decade , the proximity effect has been studied intensively in multilayered structures consisting of superconductors and non - superconducting systems and it is well known that the superconducting correlation can penetrate into the normal region . in superconductor - ferromagnet structure , with the time - inversion and spin - rotational asymmetries , it is well established that the to pairing is induced in ferromagnet.@xcite moreover , it was predicted that with the inhomogeneous ferromagnet , the induced to pairing can diffuse into the ferromagnet with the longer diffusion length than that of the se one.@xcite nevertheless , with the conventional @xmath0-wave e - e interaction , the to gap ( i.e. , the to order parameter ) is zero .
similar to the magnetization , the soc can also break the spin - rotational symmetry .
together , with the broken space - inversion symmetry by the soc , the te pairing is expected to be induced,@xcite which was first pointed out by gorkov and rashba in @xmath0-wave superconductor with the soc induced by the absorption of ion.@xcite then , a great deal of efforts have been devoted to the multilayered structures consisting of superconductors and spin - orbit - coupled non - superconducting systems as a natural extension.@xcite the induced te pairing is further proved to possess parallel spin projection to the effective magnetic field due to the soc.@xcite however , even in the presence of the te pairing , with the momentum - independent @xmath0-wave e - e interaction , no te gap ( te order parameter ) is realized .
nevertheless , de gennes pointed out that in the non - superconducting material proximity to superconductor , the pairing penetrating from superconductor experiences the many - body interaction,@xcite and hence order parameter can be induced even with a repulsive effective e - e interaction . following the work by de gennes,@xcite it is reported by yu and wu very recently that the te order parameter is induced in the spin - orbit coupled quantum well ( qw ) in proximity to @xmath0-wave superconductor.@xcite specifically , with the induced te pairing in qw by the soc , they showed that from the self - energy of the e - e coulomb interaction , the te order parameter can be induced . except for the multilayered structures ,
the study of the mixed types of cooper pairs in superconductors with vortex structure , where the translational symmetry is broken , has a long history.@xcite it is known that due to the translational asymmetry , the so pairing is induced near the vortex core.@xcite moreover , except for the extrinsic breakdown of the translational symmetry by vortex , there exists a high - magnetic - field phase in the superconductor , referred as fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov ( fflo ) phase,@xcite where the translational symmetry is spontaneously broken by inducing a finite center - of - mass ( cm ) momentum @xmath12 of the cooper pair . in the fflo phase , the zeeman energy leads to different fermi surfaces for spin - up and -down electrons , and then by inducing a finite cm momentum of the cooper pair , the pairing region between the spin - up and -down electrons near the fermi surfaces can be maximized , leading to the free energy minimized .
consequently , there exist pairing electrons and unpairing ones in the fflo phase .
furthermore , with translational and spin - rotational asymmetries by the magnetic field , all four types of pairings are expected to be induced.@xcite nevertheless , with the conventional symmetric @xmath0-wave e - e interaction , only the se order parameter exists in the fflo phase .
it is natural to consider the possibility to induce and manipulate all four types of order parameters , which may lead to rich physics especially for the quasiparticles .
furthermore , besides the fflo phase , the translational symmetry can also be broken by the supercurrent in superconductors , which also leads to the cm momentum of cooper pair , as revealed both experimentally@xcite and theoretically@xcite in recent works .
multilayered structures consisting of non - superconducting systems and @xmath0-wave superconductors in fflo phase or with a supercurrent hence naturally come to our attention . in this work ,
we show that the order parameters containing all four types of symmetry , i.e. , the se , so , te and to , can be realized in the two - dimensional electron gas ( 2deg ) of the spin - orbit - coupled insb ( 110 ) qw@xcite in proximity to @xmath0-wave superconductors in fflo phase or with a supercurrent .
specifically , the se order parameter can be induced in qw through the proximity effect .
we show that there exist unpairing regions in the momentum space , where the proximity - induced se order parameter vanishes .
it is further revealed that the unpairing regions arise from the fflo - phase - like blocking in qw . with this proximity - induced se order parameter , so ( te ) pairing is induced due to the broken translational ( spin - rotational ) symmetry by the cm momentum of cooper pair ( soc ) . with the translational and spin - rorational asymmetries , the to pairing can also be induced .
then , we show that from the self - energy due to the e - e coulomb interaction with the dynamical screening,@xcite the corresponding order parameters can be induced and the proximity - induced se order parameter is also renormalized .
particularly , we reveal that the odd - frequency order parameters are induced due to the retardation effect of the coulomb interaction from the dynamic screening in 2deg , where the plasmon effect is important .
in addition , the induced triplet order parameters are shown to possess parallel spin projections to the effective magnetic field due to the soc , similar to the previous works.@xcite differing from the vanishing proximity - induced se order parameter in the unpairing regions , it is found that through the renormalization due to the e - e coulomb interaction , the se , so , te and to ones in qw all have small strengths in the unpairing regions . moreover , in the pairing regions , rich behaviors of the order parameters containing all four types of symmetry are revealed .
specifically , the se order parameter @xmath13 exhibits an @xmath0-wave behavior in the momentum space , while the induced so ( te ) one @xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) shows a @xmath1-wave character .
particularly , with the broken translational symmetry by the cm momentum of cooper pair , the @xmath1-wave character of the induced so order parameter shows anisotropy with respect to the direction of the cm momentum .
this is very different from the te one , which is determined by the soc and hence is independent on the direction of cm momentum .
as for the induced to order parameter @xmath16 , the unconventional @xmath2-wave character in the momentum space is revealed and particularly , when the cm momentum is along the @xmath17 $ ] and @xmath18 $ ] directions , the @xmath3-wave and @xmath4-wave characters can be obtained , respectively .
this anisotropy of the to order parameter is further proved to arise from the unique soc structure in insb ( 110 ) qw .
the specific behaviors of the order parameters containing all four types of symmetry are summarized in table [ torder ] .
furthermore , we show that at proper density , the se order parameter can be efficiently suppressed through the renormalization from the repulsive e - e coulomb interaction , as revealed in the previous work,@xcite and the induced so , te and to order parameters can be detected and distinguished experimentally .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ model ] , we introduce our model and lay out hamiltonian . in sec .
[ analytic ] , we present the analytical results including the se , so , te and to pairing functions and the calculation of the self - energy due to the e - e coulomb interaction .
the specific numerical results in insb ( 110 ) qw and analytic analysis are presented in sec .
[ numerical ] .
we summarize in sec .
[ summary ] .
.order parameters behaviors in the momentum space .
@xmath19 stands for the proximity - induced se order parameter .
@xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath24 are independent on the orientation of the momentum . [
cols="<,<",options="header " , ] + @xmath25 refs . .
@xmath26 ref . .
@xmath27 ref . .
@xmath28 refs . .
in this section , by calculating eqs .
( [ deltas ] ) and ( [ deltat ] ) explicitly , we investigate the order parameters in 2deg of the spin - orbit - coupled insb ( 110 ) qw in proximity to @xmath0-wave superconductor in fflo phase or with a supercurrent .
all the material parameters used in our calculation are listed in table [ parametertable ] . as mentioned above ,
the frequency @xmath29 in the calculation is chosen to be smaller than @xmath30 . at ( a ) @xmath31 , ( b ) @xmath32 , ( c ) @xmath33 and ( d ) @xmath34 .
@xmath35.,title="fig:",width=321 ] in this part , we investigate the se order parameters in qw , including the proximity - induced and renormalization - induced ones .
the proximity - induced se order parameter is obtained from eq .
( [ pso ] ) while the renormalization - induced one is obtained based on eqs .
( [ deltas ] ) and ( [ se ] ) .
we first focus on the proximity - induced se order parameters , whose momentum dependences at different cm momentums @xmath12 are plotted in fig .
[ figyw1 ] at @xmath35 .
we find that when @xmath36 , the proximity - induced se order parameters @xmath37 show an @xmath0-wave character in the momentum space .
moreover , with the increase of the momentum , the strengths of the proximity - induced se order parameters are marginally influenced when @xmath38 but decrease when @xmath39 , as shown in figs .
[ figyw1](a ) and ( b ) .
this can be understood from eq .
( [ pso ] ) .
specifically , @xmath40 ( @xmath41 ) is much larger than the kinetic energy @xmath42 when @xmath38 , hence @xmath43 is almost unchanged with the variation of the magnitude of the momentum when @xmath38 . when @xmath39 , from eq .
( [ pso ] ) , @xmath43 decreases monotonically with increasing the momentum .
moreover , when @xmath39 , one has @xmath44 .
consequently , the dependence of @xmath37 on @xmath12 is indistinguishable , as shown by the comparison between figs .
[ figyw1](a ) and ( b ) .
furthermore , it is found that when @xmath45 , there exist unpairing regions in the momentum space , where the proximity - induced se order parameters vanish , as shown by the blue regions in figs .
[ figyw1](c ) and ( d ) at @xmath46 .
this is justified by the fact that the positions of the unpairing regions in the momentum space coincide with those of the regions where the depairing operator is zero ( shown in appendix [ ap - mo ] ) . in the pairing region
when @xmath45 , the proximity - induced se order parameter shows the similar behaviors to that at @xmath36 .
consequently , the proximity - induced se order parameter in the pairing region in qw can be considered as a constant @xmath19 when @xmath47 .
it is further noted that this conclusion is in consistent with the constant approximation in the previous works.@xcite at ( a ) @xmath31 , ( b ) @xmath48 , ( c ) @xmath49 and ( d ) @xmath50 .
@xmath35.,title="fig:",width=321 ] at different cm momentums @xmath51 .
the light - blue dotted curve is calculated from eq .
( [ deltas - sim ] ) .
@xmath35.,title="fig:",width=340 ] we next discuss the renormalization - induced se order parameter .
the momentum dependences of the renormalization - induced se order parameter at different cm momentums are plotted in fig .
[ figyw2 ] when @xmath35 . as shown in figs .
[ figyw2](a ) and ( b ) , when @xmath52 , the renormalization - induced se order parameters in the momentum space exhibit an @xmath0-wave character : @xmath53 with @xmath54 being independent on the orientation of the momentum , similar to the proximity - induced one .
moreover , we find that @xmath55 is always in the opposite sign against the proximity - induced se order parameter as the renormalization from the repulsive e - e coulomb interaction .
when @xmath45 , we find that there exist four regions in the momentum space where the renormalization - induced se order parameters have smaller strengths than those in the region nearby [ shown by the four yellow regions in the regime @xmath56 in figs .
[ figyw2](c ) or ( d ) ] .
the positions of these regions exactly correspond to the unpairing regions where the proximity - induced se order parameters vanish [ shown by the blue regions in figs .
[ figyw1](a ) and ( b ) correspondingly ] .
this can be understood from the fact that the renormalization of the e - e coulomb interaction to the se order parameter leads to the contribution from the pairing regions to the unpairing ones .
the momentum - magnitude dependences of the strength for the renormalization - induced se order parameter @xmath57 are shown in fig .
[ figyw3 ] at @xmath35 .
it is first noted that at @xmath49 ( black chain curve ) , two valleys at @xmath58 and @xmath59 are observed in the momentum - magnitude dependence , which correspond to the unpairing regions mentioned above .
whereas in the pairing regions , it is found that @xmath57 decreases with the increase of the momentum monotonically .
the vanishing order parameter at large momentum can be understood as follows .
it has been pointed out in the previous works@xcite that the pairing function vanishes in qw when @xmath60 . moreover , with the renormalization - induced order parameter @xmath61 , one has @xmath62 since the coulomb interaction @xmath63 is very strong at @xmath64 and can be approximated by a delta - function : @xmath65 in the analytic analysis .
therefore , the order parameter vanishes at large momentum when @xmath66 due to the vanishing pairing function .
then , the momentum - magnitude dependence of the renormalization - induced se order parameter can be analyzed .
specifically , by approximately taking the coulomb interaction @xmath63 in eq .
( [ se - re ] ) as a delta - function @xmath84 for the analytic analysis , one has @xmath85 .
then , at @xmath86 ( @xmath87 ) , with @xmath88 ( @xmath89 ) , @xmath90 is marginally changed ( decreases ) with the increase of the momentum , as shown in fig .
[ figyw3 ] .
this conclusion is in agreement with the one from the analysis of the pairing function proposed above .
furthermore , from eq .
( [ se - re ] ) the cm momentum dependence of @xmath55 can also be understood . in the integral of eq .
( [ se - re ] ) , the third term makes the important contribution only when @xmath91 ( @xmath92 ) where @xmath93 .
hence , the increase of @xmath94 leads to the decrease of @xmath95 , as shown in fig .
[ figyw3 ] . versus density @xmath96 at different frequencies @xmath29 .
black chain line : results for @xmath19 .
@xmath97,title="fig:",width=340 ] we then address the density dependence of the renormalization - induced se order parameter . the strengths of the renormalization - induced se order parameter @xmath98 versus density @xmath96 when @xmath97 are plotted in fig .
[ figyw4 ] at different frequencies @xmath29 .
as shown from the figure , @xmath98 decreases monotonically with the increase of the density .
the vanishing renormalization - induced se order parameter at large density comes from the vanishing pairing function at @xmath99 as mention above , similar to the case at large momentum . at small density ,
the attractive potential @xmath100 is efficiently suppressed , leading to the enhanced coulomb interaction and hence the renormalization - induced se order parameter .
this behavior can also be understood from eq .
( [ se - re ] ) . by approximately taking the coulomb interaction @xmath63 as a delta - function , at large density
, the increase of the density and hence @xmath101 leads to the monotonic decrease of @xmath102 . at small density , with the decrease of the density , the decrease of the plasma frequency @xmath103 and hence the second term in eq .
( [ se - re ] ) leads to the enhanced renormalization - induced se order parameter . furthermore
, it is noted that with the decrease of the density , the strength of the renormalization - induced se order parameter @xmath104 becomes close to that of the proximity - induced one @xmath19 ( black chain line ) . since @xmath105 is always in the opposite sign against @xmath19 , the se order parameter @xmath106 in qw
can be efficiently suppressed , as pointed out in the previous work,@xcite providing the possibility for the experimental observation for so , te and to ones .
additionally , from fig . [ figyw4 ] , it is found that at fixed density , the strength of the renormalization - induced se order parameter @xmath98 decreases monotonically with the increase of the frequency , in consistent with the analytic results in eq .
( [ se - re ] ) . in this part , we investigate the induced so order parameter in qw by calculating eqs .
( [ deltas ] ) and ( [ so ] ) explicitly .
for the analytic analysis , similar to the study on the renormalization - induced se order parameters in sec .
[ se - order ] , by taking the same approximation in eq .
( [ deltas ] ) , from eq .
( [ so ] ) , the so order parameter is written as @xmath107 then , by further approximately taking @xmath108 as small quantities , eq .
( [ soo - sim ] ) is simplified into @xmath109 with @xmath110 the first term @xmath111 in eq .
( [ soo ] ) comes from the broken translational symmetry by the cm momentum of cooper pair ( @xmath112 ) in the system . whereas the second one @xmath113 is induced due to the coupling between the cm momentum and soc from the high order expansion .
hence , @xmath111 makes the leading contribution in eq .
( [ soo ] ) .
additionally , it is noted that @xmath114 arises from the retardation effect in the effective attractive potential @xmath115 , in consistent with the previous works.@xcite in the following , we show that from eq .
( [ soo ] ) , the momentum and density dependences of the so order parameter can be analyzed , in good agreement with the full numerical results . at ( a ) @xmath116 , ( b ) @xmath117 , ( c ) @xmath118 and ( d ) @xmath50 .
@xmath35.,title="fig:",width=321 ] at different cm momentums @xmath51 .
the inset ( a ) [ ( b ) ] shows the calculated results for @xmath119 [ @xmath120 from eq .
( [ sok ] ) [ eq .
( [ sos ] ) ] .
@xmath35.,title="fig:",width=340 ] in this part , we focus on the momentum dependences of the so order parameter @xmath121 at different cm momentums @xmath12 .
the full numerical results are plotted in fig .
[ figyw5 ] at @xmath35 .
as seen from the figure , it is found that the so order parameter in the momentum space exhibits a @xmath1-wave character : @xmath122 with @xmath123 being independent on the orientation of the momentum ( demonstrated in appendix [ ap - md ] ) .
this can be understood as follows .
with the fermi - dirac statistics for the so order parameter , one finds @xmath124 .
in addition , the system in qw has the spatial - rotational symmetry around the @xmath12 axis in the momentum space , and then one has @xmath125 when @xmath126 .
hence , the vanishing @xmath127 at @xmath126 is immediately obtained and the so order parameter exhibits as @xmath128 at small @xmath94 . from eq .
( [ soo ] ) , one can obtain the same conclusion . specifically , by approximately taking the coulomb interaction @xmath129 as a delta - function , one has @xmath130 from eq .
( [ sok ] ) . as for @xmath131 , when @xmath12 is along the @xmath132 ( @xmath133 ) direction , one has @xmath134 ( @xmath135 ) in eq .
( [ sos ] ) .
hence , the so order parameter exhibits as @xmath136 .
additionally , it is noted that small strengths of the so order parameter are observed in the unpairing regions at @xmath46 [ shown by the four green regions in fig .
[ figyw5](d ) ] due to the renormalization of the e - e coulomb interaction , similar to the renormalization - induced se order parameter .
the momentum - magnitude dependences of the so order parameter are shown in fig .
[ figyw6 ] at different cm momentums @xmath137 . as seen from the figure , when @xmath138 , with the translational symmetry , the so order parameter @xmath139 ( blue dashed curve ) . when @xmath46 ( black chain curve ) , two valleys are observed at @xmath140 and @xmath141 , exactly corresponding to the unpairing regions , similar to the results of the renormalization - induced se order parameter .
when @xmath142 , it is shown that the strength of the so order parameter exhibits double - peak behavior with the increase of the momentum .
specifically , for the so order parameter with odd parity in the momentum space , one finds that @xmath143 and @xmath144 increases with increasing momentum at small @xmath145 .
in addition , due to the vanishing pairing function at @xmath87 mentioned in sec .
[ se - order ] , one has @xmath146 at large @xmath145 .
hence , peaks of the strength for the so order parameter in between are expected .
similarly , peaks for @xmath147 and @xmath148 are also expected . to elucidate the role of the contribution of the two terms in eq .
( [ soo ] ) , we plot @xmath149 and @xmath150 in the insets ( a ) and ( b ) in fig . [ figyw6 ] , respectively . as seen from the insets , the peak of @xmath151 and the valley of @xmath152 ( i.e. , the peak of @xmath153 )
are observed in the momentum - magnitude dependence , in agreement with the analysis mentioned above .
hence , the strength of the so order parameter @xmath154 exhibits the double - peak structure in the momentum - magnitude dependence .
particularly , it is found that at the case @xmath155 , with @xmath156 , the strength of the so order parameter @xmath157 shows one - peak structure ( not shown in the figure ) . from eq .
( [ sok ] ) [ eq .
( [ sos ] ) ] , the peak behaviors for @xmath147 and @xmath148 at @xmath137 can be seen more clearly .
specifically , by considering the coulomb interaction @xmath158 as a delta - function for the analytic analysis , one has @xmath159 ( @xmath160 ) .
then , at @xmath161 with @xmath162 , @xmath163 and @xmath164 both increase with the increase of the momentum . with
further increasing the momentum at @xmath165 , the increase of @xmath166 leads to the suppression on @xmath163 and @xmath167 .
hence , @xmath168 and @xmath167 both exhibit one - peak behavior in the momentum - magnitude dependence . by calculating the maximum of @xmath169 ( @xmath170 ) , the peak position for @xmath163 ( @xmath167 )
is determined at @xmath171 [ @xmath172 , very close to the one from the numerical calculation shown in the inset ( a ) [ ( b ) ] of fig .
[ figyw6 ] .
then , the valley position between the two peaks in the momentum - magnitude dependence for @xmath173 can be determined at @xmath174 , close to the one from full numerical results shown in fig .
[ figyw6 ] . furthermore , due to the broken translational symmetry by the cm momentum @xmath12 , the strength of the induced so order parameter increases with the increase of @xmath94 as shown in fig .
[ figyw6 ] , in consistent with eq .
( [ soo ] ) . versus density @xmath96 at different frequencies .
@xmath97.,title="fig:",width=340 ] we next address the density dependence of the so order parameter .
the strengths of the so order parameter @xmath175 as function of the density @xmath96 are plotted in fig .
[ figyw7 ] at different frequencies when @xmath97 .
as seen from the figure , with the increase of the density @xmath96 , @xmath175 first increases when @xmath176 then decreases when @xmath177 , leading to a peak around @xmath178 .
the peak behavior can be understood as follows . at small ( large ) density with @xmath179 ( @xmath180 ) , the strength for the so order parameter
is enhanced ( suppressed ) due to the enhanced effective attractive potential @xmath181 ( suppressed pairing potential as mentioned in sec . [ se - order ] ) , and then a density peak of the strength for the so order parameter is expected .
this can also be understood from eq .
( [ soo ] ) , by approximately taking the coulomb interaction @xmath182 as a delta - function , it is found @xmath183 . at small ( large ) density with @xmath179 ( @xmath180 ) and hence @xmath184 ( @xmath185 ) , one finds that @xmath186 [ @xmath187 increases ( decreases ) with the increase of the density . by calculating the maximum of @xmath188 with respect of the density , the density peak position can be determined at @xmath189 , close to the one from the numerical calculation shown in fig .
[ figyw7 ] . moreover , from fig .
[ figyw7 ] , it is found that at fixed density , the strength of the so order parameter @xmath175 increases with the frequency , in consistent with the analytic results in eq .
( [ soo ] ) . at ( a ) @xmath31 , ( b ) @xmath48 , ( c ) @xmath49 and ( d ) @xmath50 .
@xmath35.,title="fig:",width=321 ] at different cm momentums @xmath51 .
@xmath35.,title="fig:",width=340 ] in this part , we show the momentum dependences of the te order parameter @xmath195 at different cm momentums @xmath12 .
the full numerical results are plotted in fig .
[ figyw8 ] at @xmath35 .
as seen from the figure , the te order parameter exhibits a @xmath1-wave character in the momentum space : @xmath196 with @xmath197 being independent on the orientation of the momentum ( demonstrated in appendix [ ap - md ] ) .
differing from the @xmath1-wave character of the so order parameter which shows anisotropy with respect to the direction of @xmath198 ( as shown in fig .
[ figyw5 ] ) [ @xmath199 , the @xmath1-wave character of the te order parameter is independent on the direction of @xmath12 .
this is because that the te order parameter is induced due to the spin - rotational asymmetry by the soc .
this can also be understood from eq .
( [ te - re ] ) by approximately taking the coulomb interaction @xmath63 as a delta - function , one has @xmath200 .
moreover , it is noted in fig .
[ figyw8](c ) that small strengths of the te order parameter are observed in the unpairing regions at @xmath46 ( shown by the four green regions with the smaller order parameters than the region nearby ) due to the renormalization of the e - e coulomb interaction , similar to the renormalization - induced se and so ones .
the momentum - magnitude dependences of the te order parameter @xmath201 are shown in fig .
[ figyw9 ] at different cm momentums @xmath137 when @xmath35 . as seen from the figure , when @xmath46 , two valleys are observed at @xmath140 and @xmath141 in the momentum - magnitude dependence ( black chain curve ) ,
corresponding to the unpairing regions mentioned above .
when @xmath202 , with the increase of the momentum , @xmath203 first increases when @xmath204 then decreases after @xmath205 , leading to a peak around @xmath206 .
the peak behavior can be understood as follows . since the te order parameter
is induced by the soc , with the increase of the momentum at small ( large ) momentum , the te order parameter is enhanced ( suppressed ) by the enhanced soc ( suppressed pairing function mentioned in sec .
[ se - order ] ) , leading to the peak in the momentum - magnitude dependence .
this conclusion is in good agreement with eq .
( [ te - re ] ) , from which one finds that @xmath207 , proportional to @xmath208 ( @xmath209 ) at small ( large ) momentum . then through the similar analysis of the momentum - magnitude peak for the strength of the so order parameter in sec .
[ so - order ] , the equation of the momentum - magnitude peak position @xmath210 for the strength of the te order parameter can be obtained : @xmath211 from eq .
( [ pte ] ) , one has @xmath212 , very close to the position from the full numerical calculation shown in fig .
[ figyw9 ] .
moreover , the cm momentum dependence of the te order parameter can also be analyzed .
specifically , from eq .
( [ te - re ] ) , by approximately taking the coulomb interaction @xmath63 as a delta - function , one finds that with the increase of @xmath94 , @xmath213 increases when @xmath214 and decreases when @xmath215 , in consistent with the numerical results in fig .
[ figyw9 ] . versus density @xmath96 at different frequencies .
@xmath97.,title="fig:",width=340 ] we next address the density dependence of the te order parameter .
the strengths of te order parameters @xmath216 versus the density @xmath96 are plotted in fig .
[ figyw10 ] at different frequencies . as shown from the figure , with the increase of the density , @xmath217 first increases when @xmath218 then decreases after @xmath219 , leading to a peak around @xmath220 , similar to the results of the so order parameter .
the density dependence of @xmath216 can be understood from the momentum - magnitude dependence , since the increase of the density leads to the increase of @xmath221 .
then , the density dependence shows similar behavior of the momentum - magnitude dependence , and the density peak corresponds to the momentum - magnitude peak above . additionally , as mentioned above , one has @xmath222 from eq .
( [ te - re ] ) . by calculating the maximum of @xmath223 with respect of the density
, the position of the density peak can be determined at @xmath224 , larger than the one from the full numerical results in fig .
[ figyw10 ] .
the inconsistency in the density dependence between the analytic estimation and numerical calculation comes from the fact that with the decrease of the density , @xmath225 becomes larger than @xmath226 , and the expansion of @xmath79 in eq .
( [ deltat - sim ] ) is improper for the quantitative analysis .
in addition , we also find that at fixed density , the strength of the te order parameter @xmath227 decreases with the increases of the frequency , as shown in fig .
[ figyw10 ] , in agreement with eq .
( [ te - re ] ) well .
in this part , we investigate the to order parameters in qw through the numerical calculation from eqs .
( [ deltat ] ) and ( [ to ] ) . as for the analytic analysis ,
similar to the study on the te order parameter in sec .
[ te - order ] , by taking the same approximation in eq .
( [ deltat ] ) , from eq .
( [ to ] ) , the to order parameter can be written as : @xmath228 it is noted that the to order parameter is induced due to the spin - rotational asymmetry by the soc ( @xmath194 ) and the translational asymmetry ( @xmath112 ) . additionally , the to order parameter comes from the retardation effect in the effective attractive potential @xmath229 , in consistent with the previous works.@xcite in the following , we show that from eq .
( [ toe ] ) , the momentum and density dependences of the to order parameter can be analyzed , in good agreement with the numerical results . at ( a ) @xmath116 , ( b ) @xmath117 , ( c ) @xmath118 and ( d ) @xmath50 .
@xmath35.,title="fig:",width=321 ] at @xmath230 and ( b ) @xmath231 at @xmath232 . @xmath35 .
@xmath233 is the unit vector along the @xmath234 direction.,title="fig:",width=340 ] in this part , we focus on the momentum dependences of the to order parameter at different cm momentums @xmath12 , which are plotted in fig .
[ figyw11 ] at @xmath35 .
we find that the to order parameter shows a @xmath2-wave character in the momentum space : @xmath235 with @xmath236 and @xmath237 being independent on the orientation of the momentum ( demonstrated in appendix [ ap - md ] ) .
particularly , when @xmath238 ( @xmath232 ) , the to order parameters show a @xmath3-wave ( @xmath4-wave ) character in the momentum space : @xmath239 [ @xmath240 , as shown in fig .
[ figyw11](b ) [ ( c ) ] .
this is due to the unique soc in insb ( 110 ) qw .
specifically , by approximately taking the coulomb interaction @xmath241 as a delta - function in eq .
( [ toe ] ) , one has @xmath242 $ ] , in good agreement with the full numerical results .
additionally , it is noted that small strengths of the to order parameter are observed in the unpairing regions at @xmath46 [ four concave parts shown in fig .
[ figyw11](d ) ] due to the renormalization of the e - e coulomb interaction , similar to the renormalization - induced se , so and te ones .
the momentum - magnitude dependences of the to order parameter are shown in fig .
[ figyw12 ] at different cm momentums @xmath12 when @xmath35 .
we first discuss the case at @xmath238 .
it is noted that at @xmath46 , a valley and a peak of the to order parameter in the momentum - magnitude dependence are observed at @xmath140 and @xmath141 [ black chain curve in fig .
[ figyw12](a ) ] , respectively , which exactly correspond to the unpairing regions mentioned above , similar to the previous results of se , so and te ones . in addition , as shown in fig .
[ figyw12](a ) at @xmath238 , when @xmath202 , with the increase of the momentum , the to order parameter @xmath243 , possessing same sign with @xmath30 at @xmath244 , first increases when @xmath245 then decreases when @xmath246 , leading to a peak around @xmath247 .
moreover , when @xmath246 , it is noted that @xmath243 has a sign change at @xmath248 , and shows opposite sign against @xmath30 when @xmath249 . with further increasing the momentum when @xmath250 , the to order parameter tends to zero , leading to a valley around @xmath141 .
this momentum - magnitude dependence of the to order parameter is more complex than the previous se , so and te ones .
nevertheless , we show that from eq .
( [ toe ] ) , this dependence can be well understood .
specifically , by approximately taking the coulomb interaction @xmath251 as a delta - function , at @xmath238 , one has @xmath252/f^4_k,\ ] ] with same sign to @xmath30 at @xmath244 .
when @xmath253 ( @xmath254 ) , the increase of the momentum at @xmath245 ( @xmath255 ) causes the increase ( decrease ) of @xmath256 in eq .
( [ totrend ] ) , leading to the increase ( decrease ) of @xmath257 and the peak around @xmath247 .
moreover , when @xmath258 , it is noted that the to order parameter @xmath259 has a sign change at @xmath260 where one has @xmath261 in eq .
( [ totrend ] ) , and then @xmath262 is in opposite sign against @xmath30 at @xmath263 . with
further increasing the momentum , the suppression of the pairing function , i.e. , the increase of @xmath264 , leads to the suppression on the to order parameter , and hence @xmath262 tends to zero , leading to the valley observed .
the valley position can be determined by calculating the minimum of @xmath262 at @xmath265 , again very close to the one from the full numerical results in fig . [
figyw12](a ) . for the case at @xmath232 , it is found that @xmath266 ( @xmath233 is defined as the unit vector along @xmath234 direction ) , similar to eq .
( [ totrend ] ) at @xmath238 .
consequently , by using the similar analysis , one may understand the behavior in fig .
[ figyw12](b ) well .
furthermore , with the translational asymmetry broken by the cm momentum @xmath12 , it is found that the strengths of the induced to order parameters @xmath267 increase with the increase of the cm momentum from eq .
( [ toe ] ) , as shown in fig .
[ figyw12 ] . versus density @xmath96 at different frequencies when @xmath268.,title="fig:",width=340 ]
we then address the density dependence of the to order parameter .
the strengths of to order parameter are plotted against the density @xmath96 in fig .
[ figyw13 ] at different frequencies . as shown from the figure , with the increase of the density
, a peak is observed in the density dependence of @xmath269 , similar to the previous results of the so and te order parameters . with the similar analysis for the density dependence of the so and te order parameter ,
the strength for the to one is enhanced ( suppressed ) by the increase of the density at small ( large ) density due to the enhanced effective attractive potential @xmath270 and soc @xmath271 ( suppressed pairing potential as mentioned in sec .
[ se - order ] ) , leading to a peak observed .
moreover , from fig . [ figyw13 ] , it is found that at fixed density , the strength of the to order parameter @xmath272 increases with the frequency , in consistent with the analytic results in eq .
( [ toe ] ) . .
it is also found that @xmath273 from the full numerical results at @xmath274 ( not shown in the figure ) . @xmath275 and @xmath276.,title="fig:",width=340 ] finally
, we compare the four types of the order parameters in qw and propose several tentative ways to distinguish these order parameters in the experiment . as mentioned in sec .
[ se - order ] , at small density , due to the suppressed attractive potential @xmath100 , the renormalization - induced se order parameter @xmath55 , with its sign being opposite against the proximity - induced one @xmath19 , is markedly enhanced .
then the se order parameter @xmath106 is efficiently suppressed . in this case , the so ( induced by cm momentum of cooper pair ) , te ( induced by the soc ) and to ( induced by the soc and cm momentum ) order parameters are dominant . specifically , as mentioned in sec .
[ so - order ] ( sec .
[ te - order ] ) , the so ( te ) order parameter in the momentum space exhibits a @xmath1-wave character : @xmath277 [ @xmath278 while the to one exhibits a @xmath2-wave character : @xmath235 , as addressed in sec .
[ to - order ] . therefore , at small density , when @xmath232 , the order parameter along the @xmath132 ( @xmath279 ) direction is dominated by the te ( so ) one since @xmath280 ( @xmath281 ) and @xmath282 .
the full numerical results of the four types of the order parameters at small density @xmath275 are plotted against the momentum @xmath145 in fig .
[ figyw14 ] when @xmath274 . in this case , due to the small density and hence small @xmath94 , the unpairing regions mentioned in sec .
[ se - order ] is absent here .
moreover , as seen from the figure , the se order parameter @xmath13 ( red solid curve ) is efficiently suppressed , and as expected above , the te ( so ) order parameter ( blue long - dashed curve ) [ ( green short - dashed curve ) ] dominates along @xmath132 ( @xmath133 ) direction , providing the possibility to distinguish this order parameter from the total one by detecting along special direction .
nevertheless , along @xmath234 , i.e. , @xmath233 direction , the maximum of the strength of the @xmath4-wave to order parameter ( black chain curve ) is comparable to that of the so ( gray double - dotted curve ) and te ( light - blue dotted curve ) ones . with the experimentally obtained order parameter @xmath283
, we propose several methods to distinguish different order parameters .
specifically , the so ( te ) order parameter in the momentum space can be obtained by determining @xmath284 [ @xmath285 at @xmath232 , as mentioned above .
in addition , one can also obtain the so ( te ) order parameter in the momentum space by using partial wave method : @xmath286 moreover , the so order parameter has been revealed to leads to plenty of anomalous phenomena@xcite including enhanced josephson current,@xcite dispersionless zero - energy andreev bound states@xcite and anomalous proximity effect,@xcite which can also be used to confirm the existence of this order parameter proposed in our work . while the te order parameter is associated with the conventional triplet superconductivity.@xcite as for the @xmath4-wave to order parameter at @xmath232 , since the se order parameter
is suppressed at small density and the so and te ones can be obtained above , one finds @xmath287 or @xmath288 by using partial waves method .
moreover , with the strength comparable to the so one , the to order parameter has been shown to provide significant protection to the zero - energy states including the andreev bound state and majorana fermion state due to the even parity,@xcite and promises to lead to rich physics@xcite including the long - range proximity effect@xcite and anomalous features of quasiparticle.@xcite
in summary , we have demonstrated that the se , so , te and to pairings and the corresponding order parameters can be realized in spin - orbit - coupled insb ( 110 ) qw in proximity to @xmath0-wave superconductor in fflo phase or with a supercurrent .
specifically , the se order parameter can be induced in qw through the proximity effect .
nevertheless , it is found that there exist unpairing regions in the momentum space , in which the proximity - induced se order parameter vanishes .
we further reveal that the unpairing regions arise from the fflo - phase - like blocking in qw . in the presence of this proximity - induced se order parameter , the so pairing
is induced due to the broken translational symmetry by the cm momentum of cooper pair whereas the te one is induced due to the broken spin - rotational symmetry by the soc . moreover , with the translational and spin - rotational asymmetries , the to pairing is induced . then , the corresponding order parameters can be induced from the self - energy of the e - e coulomb interaction with the dynamic screening , and the proximity - induced se order parameter is also renormalized . particularly , we reveal that the odd - frequency order parameters are induced due to the retardation effect of the coulomb interaction from the dynamic screening in 2deg , where the plasmon effect is important . differing from the vanishing proximity - induced se order parameter in the unpairing regions , we show that through the renormalization , the se , so , te and to order parameters in qw all have small strengths in the unpairing regions . in the pairing regions , the se and te order parameters
are revealed to show the conventional @xmath0-wave and @xmath1-wave characters , respectively . as for the odd - frequency order parameters , which are difficult to realize in bulk superconductors ,
the induced so and to order parameters in insb ( 110 ) qw exhibit the @xmath1-wave and @xmath2-wave characters , respectively .
specifically , with the broken translational symmetry by the cm momentum of cooper pair , the @xmath1-wave character of the so order parameter shows anisotropy with respect to the direction of the cm momentum .
this is very different from the te one , which is determined by the soc and hence is independent on the direction of the cm momentum . as
for the unconventional @xmath2-wave to order parameter , it is interesting to find that @xmath3-wave and @xmath4-wave to order parameters can be obtained when the cm momentum is along the @xmath17 $ ] and @xmath18 $ ] directions , respectively .
it is further demonstrated that this anisotropy of the to order parameter arises from the unique soc structure in insb ( 110 ) qw .
furthermore , we show that at proper density , the se order parameter can be efficiently suppressed . then , the induced so , te and to order parameters can be detected experimentally .
our work provides an idea platform where rich physics , including the enhanced josephson current,@xcite dispersionless zero - energy andreev bound states@xcite and anomalous proximity effect@xcite related to the so order parameter ; the conventional triplet superconductivity@xcite associated with the te one ; the long - range proximity effect@xcite and anomalous features of quasiparticle@xcite due to the to one , can be realized .
this work was supported by the national natural science foundation of china under grant no .
11334014 and 61411136001 , and the strategic priority research program of the chinese academy of sciences under grant no.xdb01000000 . and
( b ) @xmath50 .
@xmath35.,title="fig:",width=264 ] and ( b ) @xmath289 . @xmath35 . @xmath290 and @xmath291 .
red solid , blue long - dashed and black chain curves denote the full numerical results of the so , te and to order parameters , respectively .
green short - dashed curve ( light - blue dotted curve ) : fitted results for the so ( te ) order parameter by using @xmath292 [ @xmath293 .
grey double - dotted curve : fitted results for the to one by using @xmath294 . , title="fig:",width=302 ]
we derive eq .
( [ ggll ] ) in this part . by neglecting the frequency dependence of the self - energy due to the proximity effect as mentioned in sec .
[ sdpe ] , eq .
( [ amp ] ) can be expressed as @xmath295 where @xmath296 represents the debye frequency of superconductor and @xmath297 . moreover , with the small momentum @xmath298 in qw , one has @xmath299 and hence the restriction @xmath300 in the integral of eq .
( [ apd1 ] ) can be approximated as @xmath301 .
then by using the mean value theorem for the integral in eq .
( [ apd1 ] ) , one gets @xmath302 with @xmath303 . as mentioned in sec .
[ se - order ] , it is found that @xmath304 , and hence @xmath305 in @xmath306 can be neglected due to the small cm momentum @xmath94 in this work .
then , eq . ( [ ggll ] )
is obtained with the effective tunneling matrix element @xmath307 .
in this part , we show the momentum dependences of the depairing operator @xmath308 at different cm momentums , which are plotted in fig .
[ figyw15 ] .
we find that at @xmath35 , when @xmath309 , there always exist zero - value regions of the depairing operator in the momentum space ( shown by the blue regions in fig .
[ figyw15 ] at @xmath46 ) , which exactly correspond to the unpairing regions in sec .
[ se - order ] [ blue regions in figs . [ figyw1](c ) and ( d ) ] . nevertheless , due to the existence of the soc , there exist four unpairing regions in the momentum space at fixed @xmath12 when @xmath309 .
this is very different from the conventional fflo superconductor,@xcite where only two unpairing regions exist .
this can also be understood from the four non - degenerate quasi - particle energy spectra addressed in sec .
[ spec ] , differing from the two double - degenerate quasi - particle energy spectra in the conventional fflo superconductors.@xcite
in this part , we show the momentum - orientation dependences of the four order parameters at different cm momentums , which are plotted in fig .
[ figyw16 ] at @xmath35 .
as seen from the figure , the full numerical results of the so ( red solid curve ) , te ( light - blue dotted curve ) and to ( gray double - dotted curve ) order parameters can be fitted well by using the analytic analyses addressed in table [ torder ] : @xmath292 ( green short - dashed curve ) , @xmath310 ( blue long - dashed curve ) and @xmath294 ( black chain curve ) , respectively .
j. bardeen , l. n. cooper , and j. r. schrieffer , phys . rev . * 106 * , 162 ( 1957 ) . v. l. berezinskii , jetp lett . *
20 * , 287 ( 1974 ) .
y. tacd rinaka , m. sato , and n. nagaosa , j. phys .
jpn . * 81 * , 011013 ( 2012 ) .
p. coleman , e. miranda , and a. tsvelik , phys .
lett . * 70 * , 2960 ( 1993 ) .
n. bulut , d. j. scalapino , and s. r. white , phys .
b * 47 * , 14599 ( 1993 ) .
p. coleman , e. miranda , and a. tsvelik , phys .
b * 49 * , 8955 ( 1994 ) .
m. vojta and e. dagotto , phys .
b * 59 * , r713 ( 1999 ) .
k. shigeta , y. tanaka , k. kuroki , s. onari , and h. aizawa , phys .
140509 ( 2011 ) . h. kusunose , y. fuseya , and k. miyake , j. phys .
jpn . * 80 * , 04711 ( 2011 ) .
h. kusunose , y. fuseya , and k. miyake , j. phys .
80 * , 054702 ( 2011 ) .
t. hotta , j. phys .
. jpn . * 78 * , 123710 ( 2009 ) .
a. balatsky and e. abrahams , phys .
b * 45 * , 13125 ( 1992 ) .
e. abrahams , a. balatsky , j. r. schrieffer , and p. b. allen , phys .
b * 47 * , 513 ( 1993 ) .
p. coleman , a. georges , and a. m. tsvelik , j. phys .
matter * 9 * , 345 ( 1997 ) .
y. fuseya , h. kohno , and k. miyake , j. phys .
jpn . * 72 * , 2914 ( 2003 ) .
k. shigeta , s. onari , k. yada , and y. tanaka , phys .
b * 79 * , 174507 ( 2009 ) .
e. abrahams , a. balatsky , d. j. scalapino , and j. r. schrieffer , phys .
b * 52 * , 1271 ( 1995 ) .
v. ambegaokar , p. g. de gennes , and d. rainer , phys .
rev . a * 9 * , 2676 ( 1974 ) .
l. j. buchholtz and g. zwicknagl , phys .
b * 23 * , 5788 ( 1981 ) .
y. nagato , m. yamamoto , and k. nagai , j. low temp .
phys . * 110 * , 1135 ( 1998 )
. y. aoki , y. wada , m. saitoh , r. nomura , y. okuda , y. nagato , m. yamamoto , s. higashitani , and k. nagai , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 075301 ( 2005 ) .
s. murakawa , y. tamura , y. wada , m. wasai , m. saitoh , y. aoki , r. nomura , y. okuda , y. nagato , m. yamamoto , s. higashitani , and k. nagai , phys . rev
* 103 * , 155301 ( 2009 ) .
s. murakawa , y. wada , y. tamura , m. wasai , m. saitoh , y. aoki , r. nomura , y. okuda , y. nagato , m. yamamoto , s. higashitani , and k. nagai , j. phys .
. jpn . * 80 * , 013602 ( 2011 ) .
k. nagai , y. nagato , m. yamamoto , and s. higashitani , j. phys .
* 77 * , 111003 ( 2008 ) .
s. higashitani , y. nagato , and k. nagai , j. low temp . phys . * 155 * , 83 ( 2009 ) .
a. layzer and d. fay , int .
* 1 * , 135 ( 1971 ) .
p. w. anderson and w. f. brinkman , phys .
lett . * 30 * , 1108 ( 1973 ) .
w. f. brinkman , j. w. serene , and p. w. anderson , phys .
rev . a * 10 * , 2386 ( 1974 ) .
y. maeno , h. hashimoto , k. yoshida , s. nishizaki , t. fujita , j. g. bednorz , and f. lichtenberg , nature ( london ) * 372 * , 532 ( 1994 ) .
t. m. rice and m. sigrist , j. phys .
matter * 7 * , l643 ( 1995 ) .
k. ishida , y. kitaoka , k. asayama , s. ikeda , s. nishizaki , y. maeno , k. yoshida , and t. fujita , phys .
b * 56 * , r505(r ) ( 1997 ) .
n. read and d. green , phys .
b * 61 * , 10267 ( 2000 ) .
d. a. ivanov , phys .
* 86 * , 268 ( 2001 ) .
a. p. mackenzie and y. maeno , rev .
phys . * 75 * , 657 ( 2003 ) .
v. m. edelstein , phys .
b * 67 * , 020505(r ) ( 2003 ) .
i. eremin , d. manske , s. g. ovchinnikov , and j. f. annett , ann .
( n.y . ) * 13 * , 149 ( 2004 ) .
m. sigrist and k. ueda , rev .
* 63 * , 239 ( 1991 ) .
p. a. frigeri , d. f. agterberg , a. koga , and m. sigrist , phys .
92 * , 097001 ( 2004 ) .
e. bauer and m. sigrist , _ non - centrosymmetric superconductors : introduction and overview _ ( springer science and business media , berlin , 2012 ) .
f. s. bergeret , a. f. volkov , and k. b. efetov , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 4096 ( 2001 ) .
a. i. buzdin , rev .
phys . * 77 * , 935 ( 2005 ) .
y. tanaka and a. a. golubov , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 037003 ( 2007 ) .
y. tanaka , a. a. golubov , s. kashiwaya , and m. ueda , phys .
* 99 * , 037005 ( 2007 ) .
y. tanaka , y. tanuma , and a. a. golubov , phys .
b * 76 * , 054522 ( 2007 ) .
m. eschrig , t. l " ofwander , t. champel , j. cuevas , and g. sch " on , j. low temp . phys . * 147 * , 457 ( 2007 ) . f. s. bergeret and i. v. tokatly , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 117003 ( 2013 ) ; phys .
b * 89 * , 134517 ( 2014 ) .
a. d. bernardo , s. diesch , y. gu , j. linder , g. divitini , c. ducati , e. scheer , m. g. blamire , and j. w. a. robinson , nat .
* 6 * , 8053 ( 2015 ) .
y. kalcheim , o. millo , a. dibernardo , a. pal , and j. w. a. robinson , phys .
b * 92 * , 060501(r ) ( 2015 ) .
l. p. gorkov and e. i. rashba , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 037004 ( 2001 ) .
z. h. yang , j. wang , and k. s. chan , supercond .
* 22 * , 055012 ( 2009 ) .
x. liu , j. k. jain , and c. x. liu , phys .
lett . * 113 * , 227002 ( 2014 ) . c. r. reeg and d. l. maslov , phys .
b * 92 * , 134512 ( 2015 ) . c. triola , d. m. badiane , a. v. balatsky , and e. rossi , phys . rev .
lett . * 116 * , 257001 ( 2016 ) . s. h. jacobsen , i. kulagina , and j. linder , sci .
* 6 * , 23926 ( 2016 ) .
t. yu and m. w. wu , phys .
b * 93 * , 195308 ( 2016 ) .
p. g. de gennes , rev .
36 * , 225 ( 1964 ) . c. caroli , p. g. de gennes , and j. matricon , phys
* 9 * , 307 ( 1964 ) .
f. hess , r. b. robinson , r. c. dynes , j. m. valles , and j. v. waszczak , phys .
62 * , 214 ( 1989 ) .
f. gygi and m. schl " uter , phys .
b * 43 * , 7609 ( 1991 ) .
y. g. makhlin and g. e. volovik , jetp lett . * 62 * , 737 ( 1995 ) .
n. b. kopnin and g. e. volovik , phys .
79 * , 1377 ( 1997 ) .
n. hayashi , t. isoshima , m. ichioka , and k. machida , phys .
* 80 * , 2921 ( 1998 ) .
a. i. larkin and y. n. ovchinnikov , phys .
b * 57 * , 5457 ( 1998 ) .
g. e. volovik , jetp lett . * 70 * , 609 ( 1999 ) .
t. yokoyama , y. tanaka , and a. a. golubov , phys .
b * 78 * , 012508 ( 2008 ) .
y. tanuma , n. hayashi , y. tanaka , and a. a. golubov , phys .
rev . lett . *
102 * , 117003 ( 2009 ) .
p. fulde and a. ferrell , phys
. rev . * 135 * , a550 ( 1964 ) .
a. i. larkin and y. n. ovchinnikov , sov .
jetp * 20 * , 762 ( 1965 ) . c. f. chan and m. gong , phys .
b * 89 * , 174501 ( 2014 ) .
f. rohlfing , g. tkachov , f. otto , k. richter , d. weiss , g. borghs , and c. strunk , phys .
b * 80 * , 220507 ( 2009 ) .
t. yu and m. w. wu , arxiv:1607.07161 [ phys . rev .
b * 94 * , 2016 , in press ] . h. takayanagi and t. kawakami , phys . rev .
* 54 * , 2449 ( 1985 ) . t. akazaki , h. takayanagi , j. nitta , and t. enoki , appl . phys
. lett . * 68 * , 418 ( 1996 ) .
k. m. h. lenssen , m. matters , c. j. p. m. harmans , j. e. mooij , m. r. leys , w. van der vleuten and j. h. wolter , appl .
. lett . * 63 * , 2079 ( 1993 ) .
t. d. moore and d. a. williams , phys .
b * 59 * , 7308 ( 1999 ) . z. wan , a. kazakov , m. j. manfra , l. n. pfeiffer , k. w. west , and l. p. rokhinson , nat . commun .
* 6 * , 7426 ( 2015 ) .
a. a. abrikosov , l. p. gorkov , and i. e. dzyaloshinski , _ methods of quantum field theory in statistical physics _ ( prentice hall , englewood cliffs , nj , 1963 ) .
a. l. fetter and j. d. walecka , _ quantum theory of many particle systems _ ( mcgraw - hill , new york , 1971 )
. g. d. mahan , _ many particle physics _ ( plenum , new york , 1990 ) . t. d. stanescu , r. m. lutchyn , and s. das sarma , phys . rev .
b * 84 * , 144522 ( 2011 )
. h. y. hui , p. m. r. brydon , j. d. sau , s. tewari , and s. das sarma , sci .
rep . * 5 * , 8880 ( 2015 ) .
j. danon and k. flensberg , phys .
b * 91 * , 165425 ( 2015 ) . , edited by o. madelung , landolt - b " ornstein , new series vol .
17a ( springer , berlin , 1987 )
. j. m. jancu , r. scholz , e. a. de andrada e silva , and g. c. l. rocca , phys . rev .
b * 72 * , 193201 ( 2005 ) .
w. martienssen and h. warlimont , _ springer handbook of condensed matter and materials data _ , bd . 1 ( springer , new york , 2005 ) .
a. n. chantis , m. van schilfgaarde , and t. kotani , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 086405 ( 2006 ) .
j. hara and k. nagai , prog .
phys . * 76 * , 1237 ( 1986 ) .
s. kashiwaya and y. tanaka , rep .
63 * , 1641 ( 2000 ) .
t. l " ofwander , v. s. shumeiko , and g. wendin , supercond .
* 14 * , r53 ( 2001 ) .
y. asano , y. tanaka , and s. kashiwaya , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 097007 ( 2006 ) .
w. l. mcmillan , phys .
* 175 * , 537 ( 1968 ) .
j. m. rowell and w. l. mcmillan , phys .
* 16 * , 453 ( 1966 ) .
y. tanaka and s. kashiwaya , phys .
b * 70 * , 012507 ( 2004 ) .
y. tanaka , s. kashiwaya , and t. yokoyama , phys .
b * 71 * , 094513 ( 2005 )
. j. linder , y. tanaka , t. yokoyama , a. sudbo , and n. nagaosa , phys .
lett . * 104 * , 067001 ( 2010 ) .
j. linder , y. tanaka , t. yokoyama , a. sudbo , and n. nagaosa , phys .
b * 81 * , 184525 ( 2010 ) .
t. yokoyama , y. tanaka , and a. a. golubov , phys .
b * 72 * , 052512 ( 2005 ) .
t. yokoyama , y. tanaka , and a. a. golubov , phys .
b * 75 * , 134510 ( 2007 ) . | we show that all the singlet even - frequency , singlet odd - frequency , triplet even - frequency and triplet odd - frequency pairings , and together with the corresponding order parameters ( gaps ) can be realized in insb ( 110 ) spin - orbit - coupled quantum well in proximity to @xmath0-wave superconductor in fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov phase or with a supercurrent .
it is revealed that with the singlet even - frequency order parameter induced by the proximity effect , triplet even - frequency pairing is induced due to the broken spin - rotational symmetry by the spin - orbit coupling . since the translational symmetry is broken by the center - of - mass momentum of cooper pair in the fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov phase or with a supercurrent , the singlet odd - frequency pairing can be induced . with the translational and spin - rotational asymmetries ,
the triplet odd - frequency pairing is also realized .
then , we show that the corresponding order parameters can be obtained from the self - energy of the electron - electron coulomb interaction with the dynamic screening .
the singlet and the induced triplet even - frequency order parameters are found to exhibit the conventional @xmath0-wave and @xmath1-wave characters in the momentum space , respectively .
whereas for the induced odd - frequency order parameters in quantum well , the singlet and triplet ones show the @xmath1-wave and @xmath2-wave characters , respectively . moreover , the @xmath1-wave character of the singlet odd - frequency order parameter exhibits anisotropy with respect to the direction of the center - of - mass momentum . while for the triplet one
, we find that @xmath3-wave and @xmath4-wave characters can be obtained with respect to the direction of the center - of - mass momentum .
we show that at proper density , the singlet even - frequency order parameter is suppressed and the induced singlet odd - frequency , triplet even - frequency and triplet odd - frequency ones can be detected experimentally . |
string repetitions called runs and the lempel - ziv factorization are structures that are of a great importance for data compression and play a significant role in stringology . recall that a run of a string is a nonextendable ( with the same minimal period ) substring whose minimal period is at most half of its length .
the definition of the lempel - ziv factorization is given below . in the decision tree model , a widely used model to obtain lower bounds on the time complexity of various algorithms , we consider algorithms finding these structures .
we prove that any algorithm finding the lempel - ziv factorization on a general ordered alphabet must perform @xmath3 denotes the logarithm with the base @xmath6 .
] comparisons in the worst case , where @xmath1 denotes the length of input string and @xmath2 denotes the number of distinct letters in it . since until recently , the only known efficient way to find all runs of a string was to use the lempel - ziv factorization , one might expect that there is a nontrivial lower bound in the decision tree model on the number of comparisons in algorithms finding all runs .
these expectations were also supported by the existence of such a bound in the case of unordered alphabet . in this paper
we obtain a somewhat surprising fact : in the decision tree model with an ordered alphabet , there exists a linear algorithm finding all runs .
this can be interpreted as one can not have lower bounds on the decision tree model for algorithms finding runs ( a similar result for another problem is provided in @xcite for example ) but on the other hand , this result supports the conjecture by breslauer ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 4 ) that there is a linear ram algorithm finding all runs .
the lempel - ziv factorization @xcite is a basic technique for data compression and plays an important role in stringology .
it has several modifications used in various compression schemes .
the factorization considered in this paper is used in lz77-based compression methods .
all known efficient algorithms for computation of the lempel - ziv factorization on a general ordered alphabet work in @xmath0 time ( see @xcite ) , though all these algorithms are time and space consuming in practice .
however for the case of polynomially bounded integer alphabet , there are efficient linear algorithms @xcite and space efficient online algorithms @xcite
. repetitions of strings are fundamental objects in both stringology and combinatorics on words .
the notion of run , introduced by main in @xcite , allows to grasp the whole periodic structure of a given string in a relatively simple form . in the case of unordered alphabet , there are some limitations on the efficiency of algorithms finding periodicities ; in particular , it is known @xcite that any algorithm that decides whether an input string over a general unordered alphabet has at least one run , requires @xmath7 comparisons in the worst case . in @xcite , kolpakov and kucherov
proved that any string of length @xmath1 contains @xmath5 runs and proposed a ram algorithm finding all runs in linear time provided the lempel - ziv factorization is given .
thereafter much work has been done on the analysis of runs ( e.g. see @xcite ) but until the recent paper @xcite , all efficient algorithms finding all runs of a string on a general ordered alphabet used the lempel - ziv factorization as a basis .
bannai et al .
@xcite use a different method based on lyndon factorization but unfortunately , their algorithm spends @xmath0 time too .
clearly , due to the found lower bound , our linear algorithm finding all runs does nt use the lempel - ziv factorization yet our approach differs from that of @xcite .
the paper is organized as follows .
section [ sectprel ] contains some basic definitions used throughout the paper . in section [ sectlempelziv ]
we give a lower bound on the number of comparisons required to construct the lempel - ziv factorization . in section [ sectruns ] we present additional definitions and combinatorial facts that are necessary for section [ sectlin ] , where we describe our linear decision tree algorithm finding all runs .
a _ string of length @xmath1 _ over the alphabet @xmath8 is a map @xmath9 , where @xmath1 is referred to as the length of @xmath10 , denoted by @xmath11 .
we write @xmath12 $ ] for the @xmath13th letter of @xmath10 and @xmath14 $ ] for @xmath12w[i{+}1]\ldots w[j]$ ] .
let @xmath14 $ ] be the empty string for any @xmath15 .
a string @xmath16 is a _ substring _ ( or a _ factor _ ) of @xmath10 if @xmath17 $ ] for some @xmath13 and @xmath18 .
the pair @xmath19 is not necessarily unique ; we say that @xmath13 specifies an _ occurrence _ of @xmath16 in @xmath10 .
a string can have many occurrences in another string .
an integer @xmath20 is a _ period _ of @xmath10 if @xmath21 and @xmath12 = w[i{+}p]$ ] for @xmath22 . for any integers @xmath23 , the set @xmath24 ( possibly empty )
is denoted by @xmath25 .
the only computational model that is used in this paper is the _ decision tree _ model .
informally , a decision tree processes input strings of given _ fixed _ length and each path starting at the root of the tree represents the sequence of pairwise comparisons made between various letters in the string .
the computation follows an appropriate path from the root to a leaf ; each leaf represents a particular answer to the studied problem .
more formally , a decision tree processing strings of length @xmath1 is a rooted directed ternary tree in which each interior vertex is labeled with an ordered pair @xmath19 of integers , @xmath26 , and edges are labeled with the symbols `` @xmath27 '' , `` @xmath28 '' , `` @xmath29 '' ( see fig . [
fig : tree ] ) .
height _ of a decision tree is the number of edges in the longest path from the root to a leaf of the tree .
consider a path @xmath20 connecting the root of a fixed decision tree to some vertex @xmath30 .
let @xmath31 be a string of length @xmath1 .
suppose that @xmath20 satisfies the following condition : it contains a vertex labeled with a pair @xmath19 with the outgoing edge labeled with @xmath27 ( resp .
, @xmath29 , @xmath28 ) if and only if @xmath32<t[j]$ ] ( resp . ,
@xmath32>t[j]$ ] , @xmath32=t[j]$ ] ) .
then we say that the vertex @xmath30 is _ reachable _ by the string @xmath31 or the string @xmath31 _ reaches _ the vertex @xmath30 .
clearly , each string reaches exactly one leaf of any given tree . processing strings of length @xmath33 . the strings @xmath34 and @xmath35 reach the shaded vertex .
the lempel - ziv factorization of a string @xmath31 is the decomposition @xmath36 , built by the following greedy procedure processing @xmath31 from left to right : * @xmath37 $ ] ; * let @xmath38 $ ] ; if @xmath39 $ ] does not occur in @xmath40 $ ] , put @xmath41 $ ] ; otherwise , put @xmath42 to be the longest prefix of @xmath43 $ ] that has an occurrence starting at some position @xmath44 .
for example , the string @xmath45 has the lempel - ziv factorization @xmath46 .
let @xmath31 and @xmath47 be strings of length @xmath1 .
suppose @xmath48 and @xmath49 are their lempel - ziv factorizations .
we say that the lempel - ziv factorizations of @xmath31 and @xmath47 are equivalent if @xmath50 and @xmath51 for each @xmath52 .
we say that a decision tree processing strings of length @xmath1 finds the lempel - ziv factorization if for any strings @xmath31 and @xmath47 of length @xmath1 such that @xmath31 and @xmath47 reach the same leaf of the tree , the lempel - ziv factorizations of @xmath31 and @xmath47 are equivalent .
the construction of the lempel - ziv factorization for a string of length @xmath1 with at most @xmath2 distinct letters requires @xmath3 comparisons of letters in the worst case .
[ lempelziv ] let @xmath53 be an alphabet . to obtain the lower bound , we construct a set of input strings of length @xmath1 such that the construction of the lempel - ziv factorization for these strings requires performing @xmath54 binary searches on the @xmath55-element alphabet . without loss of generality , we assume that @xmath1 and @xmath2 are even and @xmath56 .
denote @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 .
we view @xmath60 as a `` dictionary '' containing all letters @xmath61 with even @xmath13 .
note that @xmath62 . consider a string @xmath31 of the following form : @xmath63 informally , the string @xmath31 represents a sequence of queries to our `` dictionary '' @xmath60 ; any decision tree finding the lempel - ziv factorization of the string @xmath64 must identify each @xmath65 of @xmath31 with some letter of @xmath60 .
otherwise , we can replace @xmath65 with the letter @xmath66 or @xmath67 thus changing the lempel - ziv factorization of the whole string ; the details are provided below .
obviously , @xmath68 and there are @xmath69 possible strings @xmath31 of the form .
let us take a decision tree which computes the lempel - ziv factorization for the strings of length @xmath1 .
it suffices to prove that each leaf of this tree is reachable by at most one string @xmath64 with @xmath31 of the form .
indeed , such decision tree has at least @xmath69 leafs and the height of the tree is at least @xmath70 .
suppose to the contrary that some leaf of the decision tree is reachable by two distinct strings @xmath71 and @xmath72 such that @xmath31 and @xmath47 are of the form ; then for some @xmath73 , @xmath74 \ne r[l]$ ] .
obviously @xmath75 for some @xmath76 and therefore @xmath77 = a_p$ ] for some even @xmath78
. suppose @xmath74
< r[l]$ ] .
let @xmath79 be the set of all integers @xmath80 such that for any string @xmath81 of the form , if the string @xmath82 reaches the same leaf as the string @xmath83 , then @xmath84 = r_0[l]$ ] .
consider a string @xmath85 that differs from @xmath83 only in the letters @xmath86 , \ldots , r''[l_m]$ ] and put @xmath86 = \ldots = r''[l_m ] = a_{p-1}$ ] .
let us first prove that the string @xmath85 reaches the same leaf as @xmath83 . consider a vertex of the path connecting the root and the leaf reachable by @xmath83 .
let the vertex be labeled with a pair @xmath19 .
we have to prove that the comparison of @xmath87 $ ] and @xmath88 $ ] leads to the same result as the comparison of @xmath89 $ ] and @xmath90 $ ] .
the following cases are possible : 1 .
@xmath91 for all @xmath92 ; then @xmath89 = r''[i]$ ] and @xmath90 = r''[j]$ ] ; 2 .
@xmath93 for some @xmath92 and @xmath89 < r[j]$ ] ; then since @xmath94 = a_{p-1 } < a_p = r[l_q ] = r[i]$ ] and @xmath90 = r''[j]$ ] , we obtain @xmath87 < r''[j]$ ] ; 3 .
@xmath93 for some @xmath92 and @xmath89 > r[j]$ ] ; then we have @xmath95 because @xmath96 = r'[p/2 ] = a_{p-1 } > r'[i]$ ] while @xmath97 > r'[j]$ ] , and thus since @xmath89 = a_p > r[j]$ ] , we see that @xmath98 > r[j ] = r''[j]$ ] ; 4 .
@xmath93 for some @xmath92 and @xmath89 = r[j]$ ] ; then , by definition of the set @xmath99 , @xmath100 for some @xmath101 and @xmath87 = r''[j ] = a_{p-1}$ ] ; 5 .
@xmath102 for some @xmath92 ; this case is symmetric to the above cases .
thus @xmath85 reaches the same leaf as @xmath83 .
but the strings @xmath83 and @xmath85 have the different lempel - ziv factorizations : the lempel - ziv factorization of @xmath85 has one letter factor @xmath103 at position @xmath104 while @xmath83 does not since @xmath105 = a_\sigma a_pa_\sigma$ ] is a substring of @xmath106 $ ] .
this contradicts to the fact that the analyzed tree computes the lempel - ziv factorization .
in this section we consider some combinatorial facts that will be useful in our main algorithm described in the following section .
the _ exponent _ of a string @xmath31 is the number @xmath107 , where @xmath20 is the minimal period of @xmath31 .
run _ of a string @xmath31 is a substring @xmath108 $ ] of exponent at least @xmath6 and such that both substrings @xmath109 $ ] and @xmath110 $ ] , if defined , have strictly greater minimal periods than @xmath108 $ ] .
a run whose exponent is greater than or equal to @xmath33 is called a _
cubic run_. for a fixed @xmath111 , a _ @xmath112-short run _ of a string @xmath31 is a substring @xmath108 $ ] which can be represented as @xmath113 for nonempty strings @xmath114 and @xmath115 such that @xmath116 , @xmath117 is the minimal period of @xmath108 $ ] , and both substrings @xmath109 $ ] and @xmath110 $ ] , if defined , have strictly greater minimal periods .
the string @xmath118 has four runs @xmath119 = aa$ ] , @xmath120 = aa$ ] , @xmath121 = aabaaba$ ] , @xmath122 = abab$ ] and one @xmath123-short run @xmath124 = aba$ ] .
the sum of exponents of all runs is equal to @xmath125 .
as it was proved in @xcite , the number of all runs is linear in the length of string .
we use a stronger version of this fact .
the number of all runs in any string of length @xmath1 is less than @xmath1 .
[ runsnum ] the following lemma is a straightforward corollary of ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 1 ) . for a fixed @xmath111 ,
any string of length @xmath1 contains @xmath5 @xmath112-short runs .
[ almostrunsnum ] we also need a classical property of periodic strings .
suppose a string @xmath10 has periods @xmath20 and @xmath126 such that @xmath127 ; then @xmath128 is a period of @xmath10 .
[ finewilflemma ] let @xmath129 and @xmath130 be substrings with the periods @xmath131 and @xmath132 respectively
. suppose @xmath129 and @xmath130 have a common substring of the length @xmath133 or greater ; then @xmath129 and @xmath130 have the period @xmath134 .
[ stringsintersect ] it is immediate from lemma [ finewilflemma ] .
unfortunately , in a string of length @xmath1 the sum of exponents of runs with the minimal period @xmath20 or greater is not equal to @xmath135 as the following example from @xcite shows : @xmath136 .
indeed , for any @xmath137 , the string @xmath136 contains at least @xmath138 runs with the shortest period @xmath20 or greater : @xmath139 for @xmath140 .
however , it turns out that this property holds for cubic runs .
for any @xmath141 and any string @xmath31 of length @xmath1 , the sum of exponents of all cubic runs in @xmath31 with the minimal period @xmath20 or greater is less than @xmath142 .
[ cubicrunexp ] consider a string @xmath31 of length @xmath1 .
denote by @xmath143 the set of all cubic runs of @xmath31 .
let @xmath144 $ ] and @xmath145 $ ] be distinct cubic runs such that @xmath146 .
for any string @xmath16 , @xmath147 denotes the exponent of @xmath16 and @xmath148 denotes the minimal period of @xmath16 .
it follows from lemma [ stringsintersect ] that @xmath129 and @xmath130 can not have a common substring of length @xmath149 or longer .
let @xmath150 be a positive integer .
suppose @xmath151 ; then either @xmath152 or @xmath153 .
the later easily implies @xmath154 and therefore @xmath155 .
moreover , we have @xmath156 .
hence @xmath157 and then @xmath158 .
denote @xmath159 and @xmath160 .
evidently @xmath161 .
finally , we obtain @xmath162 .
we say that a decision tree processing strings of length @xmath1 _ finds all runs with a given property @xmath163 _ if for each distinct strings @xmath129 and @xmath130 such that @xmath164 and @xmath129 and @xmath130 reach the same leaf of the tree , the substring @xmath165 $ ] is a run satisfying @xmath163 iff @xmath166 $ ] is a run satisfying @xmath163 for all @xmath167 .
we say that two decision trees processing strings of length @xmath1 are equivalent if for each reachable leaf @xmath168 of the first tree , there is a leaf @xmath169 of the second tree such that for any string @xmath31 of length @xmath1 , @xmath31 reaches @xmath168 iff @xmath31 reaches @xmath169 .
the _ basic height _ of a decision tree is the minimal number @xmath170 such that each path connecting the root and a leaf of the tree has at most @xmath170 edges labeled with the symbols `` @xmath27 '' and `` @xmath29 '' . for a given positive integer @xmath20
, we say that a run @xmath83 of a string is _
@xmath20-periodic _ if @xmath171 and @xmath20 is a ( not necessarily minimal ) period of @xmath83 .
we say that a run is a _
@xmath20-run _ if it is @xmath126-periodic for some @xmath126 which is a multiple of @xmath20 .
note that any run is @xmath123-run .
let us describe a `` naive '' decision tree finding all @xmath20-runs in strings of length @xmath1 .
denote by @xmath31 the input string .
our tree simply compares @xmath32 $ ] and @xmath172 $ ] for all @xmath167 such that @xmath173 is a multiple of @xmath20 .
the tree has the height @xmath174 and the same basic height .
note that a decision tree algorithm finding runs does nt report runs in the same way as ram algorithms do .
the algorithm only collects sufficient information to conclude where the runs are ; once its knowledge of the structure of the input string becomes sufficient to find all runs without further comparisons of symbols , the algorithm stops and does nt care about the processing of obtained information . to simplify the construction of an efficient decision tree , we use the following lemma that enables us to estimate only the basic height of our tree .
suppose a decision tree processing strings of length @xmath1 has basic height @xmath170 .
then it is equivalent to a decision tree of height @xmath175 .
[ equalcomp ] to construct the required decision tree of height @xmath176 , we modify the given decision tree of basic height @xmath170 .
first , we remove all unreachable vertices of this tree . after this
, we contract each non - branching path into a single edge , removing all intermediate vertices and their outgoing edges .
indeed , the result of a comparison corresponding to such an intermediate vertex is determined by the previous comparisons .
so , it is straightforward that the result tree is equivalent to the original tree .
now it suffices to prove that there are at most @xmath177 edges labeled with the symbol `` @xmath28 '' along any path connecting the root and some leaf .
observe that if we perform @xmath177 comparisons on @xmath1 elements and each comparison yields an equality , then either all elements are equal or the result of at least one comparison can be deduced by transitivity from other comparisons .
suppose a path connecting the root and some leaf has at least @xmath1 edges labeled with the symbol `` @xmath28 '' . by the above observation
, the path contains an edge labeled with `` @xmath28 '' leaving a vertex labeled with @xmath19 such that the equality of the @xmath13th and the @xmath18th letters of the input string follows by transitivity from the comparisons made earlier along this path .
then this vertex has only one reachable child .
but this is impossible because all such vertices of the original tree were removed during the contraction step .
this contradiction finishes the proof . for any integers @xmath1 and @xmath20 ,
there is a decision tree that finds all @xmath20-periodic runs in strings of length @xmath1 and has basic height at most @xmath178.[construn ] denote by @xmath31 the input string .
the algorithm is as follows ( note that the resulting decision tree contains only comparisons of letters of @xmath31 ) : 1 .
assign @xmath179 ; 2 .
if @xmath32 \ne t[i{+}p]$ ] , then assign @xmath180 , @xmath181 and for @xmath182 , compare @xmath183 $ ] and @xmath184 $ ] until @xmath183 \ne t[i'{+}p]$ ] ; [ lst : pnt ] 3 .
increment @xmath13 and if @xmath185 , jump to line [ lst : pnt ] .
obviously , the algorithm performs at most @xmath178 symbol comparisons yielding inequalities .
let us prove that the algorithm finds all @xmath20-periodic runs .
let @xmath186 $ ] be a @xmath20-periodic run .
for the sake of simplicity , suppose @xmath187 . to discover this run , one must compare @xmath188 $ ] and @xmath189 $ ] for each @xmath190 .
let us show that the algorithm performs all these comparisons .
suppose , to the contrary , for some @xmath191 , the algorithm does nt compare @xmath188 $ ] and @xmath189 $ ] .
then for some @xmath192 such that @xmath193 , the algorithm detects that @xmath194 \ne t[i_0{+}p]$ ] and `` jumps '' over @xmath195 by assigning @xmath196 at line [ lst : pnt ] .
obviously @xmath197 . then @xmath198 and
hence for each @xmath199 , the algorithm compares @xmath183 $ ] and @xmath184 $ ] . since @xmath200 ,
@xmath188 $ ] and @xmath189 $ ] are compared , contradicting to our assumption .
there is a constant @xmath201 such that for any integer @xmath1 , there exists a decision tree of height at most @xmath202 that finds all runs in strings of length @xmath1 . by lemma [ equalcomp ] ,
it is sufficient to build a decision tree with linear basic height .
so , below we count only the comparisons yielding inequalities and refer to them as `` inequality comparisons '' .
in fact we prove the following more general fact : for a given string @xmath31 of length @xmath1 and a positive integer @xmath20 , we find all @xmath20-runs performing @xmath203 inequality comparisons .
to find all runs of a string , we simply put @xmath204 .
the algorithm consists of five steps .
each step finds @xmath20-runs of @xmath31 with a given property .
let us choose a positive integer constant @xmath205 ( the exact value is defined below . )
the algorithm is roughly as follows : 1 .
find in a straightforward manner all @xmath20-runs having periods @xmath206 ; 2 .
using the information from step 1 , build a new string @xmath47 of length @xmath207 such that periodic factors of @xmath31 and @xmath47 are strongly related to each other ; 3 .
find @xmath20-runs of @xmath31 related to periodic factors of @xmath47 with exponents less than @xmath33 ; 4 .
find @xmath20-runs of @xmath31 related to periodic factors of @xmath47 with periods less than @xmath112 ; 5 .
find @xmath20-runs of @xmath31 related to other periodic factors of @xmath47 by calling steps 15 recursively for some substrings of @xmath31 .
* initially , we split the string @xmath31 into @xmath207 contiguous blocks of length @xmath20 ( if @xmath1 is not a multiple of @xmath20 , we pad @xmath31 on the right to the required length with a special symbol which is less than all other symbols . ) for each @xmath208 and @xmath209 , we denote by @xmath210 the minimal @xmath211 such that @xmath212 \ne t[(i{-}1)p{+}k{+}jp]$ ] and we put @xmath213 if @xmath214 or there is no such @xmath170 . to compute @xmath210 , we simply compare @xmath212 $ ] and @xmath215 $ ] for @xmath216 until @xmath212 \ne t[(i{-}1)p{+}k{+}jp]$ ] .
[ texample ] let @xmath217 , @xmath218 , @xmath219 .
the following table contains @xmath210 for @xmath220 : @xmath221 & bbba & aada & aaaa & aaaa & aada & aaaa & aaab & bbbb & bbbb \\
\hline m_{i,1},m_{i,2 } & 1,1 & 3,3 & -1,3 & 3,-1 & 3,3 & 4,1 & 1,1 & -1,-1 & -1,-1\\ \end{array}\ ] ] to compute a particular value of @xmath210 , one needs at most one inequality comparison ( zero inequality comparisons if the computed value is @xmath222 . )
further , for each @xmath208 and @xmath209 , we compare @xmath223 $ ] and @xmath224 $ ] ( if defined ) for @xmath225 until @xmath223 \ne t[ip{-}k{+}jp]$ ] ; similar to the above computation of @xmath210 , this procedure performs at most one inequality comparison for any given @xmath13 and @xmath18 .
hence , the total number of inequality comparisons is at most @xmath226 .
once these comparisons are made , all @xmath227-periodic runs in the input string are determined for all @xmath228
. * step 2 .
* now we build an auxiliary structure induced by @xmath210 on the string @xmath31 . in this step ,
no comparisons are performed ; we just establish some combinatorial properties required for further steps .
we make use of the function : @xmath229 we create a new string @xmath47 of length @xmath207 .
the alphabet of this string can be taken arbitrary , we just describe which letters of @xmath47 coincide and which do not .
for each @xmath230 , @xmath231 = t'[i_2]$ ] iff for each @xmath232 , either @xmath233 or the following conditions hold simultaneously : @xmath234 , t[(i_1{-}1)p{+}m_{i_1,j}{+}jp ] ) = { \operatorname{sgn}}(t[(i_2{-}1)p{+}m_{i_2 } ] , t[(i_2{-}1)p{+}m_{i_2,j}{+}jp])\enspace . \end{array}\ ] ] note that the status of each of these conditions is known from step 1 .
also note that the values @xmath235 are not used in the definition of @xmath47 ; we computed them only to find all @xmath236-periodic @xmath20-runs .
denote @xmath237 , t[(i{-}1)p{+}m_{i,1}{+}p])$ ] .
let @xmath238 be a new alphabet for the string @xmath47 .
the following table contains @xmath239 , @xmath240 , and @xmath47 : @xmath241 & bbba & aada & aaaa & aaaa & aada & aaaa & aaab & bbbb & bbbb \\
\hline m_{i,1 } & 1 & 3 & -1 & 3 & 3 & 4 & 1 & -1 & -1 \\
\hline s_i & 1 & 1 & - & -1 & 1 & -1 & -1 & - & - \\
\hline t'[i ] & j & e & f & g & e & h & i & f & f \end{array}\ ] ] if @xmath31 contains two identical sequences of @xmath112 blocks each , i.e. , @xmath242 = t[(i_2{-}1)p{+}1 .. (i_2{-}1{+}d)p]$ ] for some @xmath243 , @xmath244 , then @xmath245 for each @xmath232 and hence @xmath231 = t'[i_2]$ ] .
this is why @xmath246 = t'[5]$ ] in example [ texample ] . on the other hand , equal letters in @xmath47
may correspond to different sequences of blocks in @xmath31 , like the letters @xmath247 = t'[8]$ ] in example [ texample ] .
the latter property makes the subsequent argument more involved but allows us to keep the number of inequality comparisons linear .
let us point out the relations between periodic factors of @xmath31 and @xmath47 .
let for some @xmath248 , @xmath249 $ ] be a @xmath227-periodic @xmath20-run , i.e. , @xmath249 $ ] is a @xmath20-run that is not found on step 1 .
denote @xmath250 .
since @xmath249 $ ] is @xmath227-periodic , @xmath47 has some periodicity in the corresponding substring , namely , @xmath251 $ ] has the period @xmath126 ( see example below ) .
let @xmath252 $ ] be the largest substring of @xmath47 containing @xmath16 and having the period @xmath126 .
since @xmath253 , @xmath252 $ ] is either a @xmath112-short run with the minimal period @xmath126 or a run whose minimal period divides @xmath126 .
consider fig .
[ fig : corrun ] .
let @xmath254 , @xmath255 .
the string @xmath249 = a\cdot aada\cdot aaaa\cdot aaaa\cdot aada\cdot aaaa\cdot aaa$ ] is a @xmath20-run with the minimal period @xmath256 ( here @xmath257 ) .
denote @xmath258 , @xmath259 , and @xmath260 .
the string @xmath261 = t'[k_1 .. k_2 ] = t'[2 .. 5 ] = efge$ ] is a @xmath112-short run of @xmath47 with the minimal period @xmath262 .
-run corresponding to @xmath112-short run @xmath252 = efge$ ] , where @xmath259 , @xmath260 , @xmath218 , @xmath219 , @xmath262 , @xmath254 , @xmath263 , @xmath264 , @xmath265 . ]
conversely , given a run or @xmath112-short run @xmath252 $ ] with the minimal period @xmath126 , we say that a @xmath20-run @xmath249 $ ] _ corresponds to @xmath252 $ ] _ ( or @xmath266 $ ] is a @xmath20-run _ corresponding to @xmath252 $ ] _ ) if @xmath249 $ ] is , for some integer @xmath83 , @xmath267-periodic and @xmath261 $ ] , where @xmath250 , is a substring of @xmath252 $ ] ( see fig . [
fig : corrun ] and example [ texample ] ) .
the above observation shows that each @xmath20-run of @xmath31 that is not found on step 1 corresponds to some run or @xmath112-short run of @xmath47 .
let us describe the substring that must contain all @xmath20-runs of @xmath31 corresponding to a given run or @xmath112-short run @xmath252 $ ] .
denote @xmath268 and @xmath269 .
now it is easy to see that if @xmath249 $ ] is a @xmath20-run corresponding to @xmath252 $ ] , then @xmath249 $ ] is a substring of @xmath108 $ ] . for @xmath254 and @xmath255 ,
the string @xmath249 = a\cdot aada\cdot aaaa\cdot aaaa\cdot aada\cdot aaaa\cdot aaa$ ] is a @xmath20-run corresponding to @xmath252 = efge$ ] , where @xmath259 , @xmath260 .
indeed , the string @xmath261 = t'[2 .. 5]$ ] , for @xmath270 , is a substring of @xmath252 $ ] .
denote @xmath271 , @xmath272 .
observe that @xmath249 = t[4 .. 27]$ ] is a substring of @xmath108 = t[1 .. 28]$ ] .
it is possible that there is another @xmath20-run of @xmath31 corresponding to the string @xmath252 $ ] .
consider the following example .
[ twocorr ] let @xmath273 , @xmath274 , @xmath219 .
denote @xmath237 , t[(i{-}1)p{+}m_{i,1}{+}p])$ ] .
let @xmath275 be a new alphabet for the string @xmath47 .
the following table contains @xmath239 , @xmath240 , and @xmath47 : @xmath276 & fa & bc & de & da & bc & de & da & ai & fj & fa & ai & fj & ff \\
m_{i,1 } & 1 & 1 & 2 & 1 & 1 & 2 & 1 & 1 & 2 & 1 & 1 & 2 & -1 \\ s_i & 1 & -1 & 1 & 1 & -1 & 1 & 1 & -1 & 1 & 1 & -1 & 1 & - \\ t'[i ] & x & y & z & x & y & z & x & y & z & x & y & z & w \end{array}\ ] ] note that @xmath20-runs @xmath277 = abcded\cdot abcded$ ] and @xmath278 = aaifjf\cdot aaifjf$ ] correspond to the same @xmath20-run of @xmath47 , namely ,
@xmath279 = xyz\cdot xyz\cdot xyz\cdot xyz$ ] . thus to find for all @xmath248 all @xmath227-periodic @xmath20-runs of @xmath31
, we must process all runs and @xmath112-short runs of @xmath47 .
* step 3 . *
consider a noncubic run @xmath252 $ ] .
let @xmath126 be its minimal period .
denote @xmath268 and @xmath269 .
the above analysis shows that any @xmath20-run of @xmath31 corresponding to @xmath252 $ ] is a @xmath280-periodic run of @xmath108 $ ] for some @xmath281 , where @xmath282 . since @xmath283
, we have @xmath284 . hence to find all @xmath20-runs of @xmath108
$ ] , it suffices to find for each @xmath281 all @xmath280-periodic runs of @xmath108 $ ] using lemma [ construn ] .
thus the processing performs @xmath285 inequality comparisons .
analogously we process @xmath112-short runs of @xmath47 .
therefore , by lemmas [ runsnum ] and [ almostrunsnum ] , only @xmath286 inequality comparisons are required to process all @xmath112-short runs and noncubic runs of @xmath47 .
now it suffices to find all @xmath20-runs of @xmath31 corresponding to cubic runs of @xmath47 .
* step 4 . *
let @xmath252 $ ] be a cubic run with the minimal period @xmath126 . in this step
we consider the case @xmath287 .
it turns out that such small - periodic substrings of @xmath47 correspond to substrings in @xmath31 that are either periodic and discovered at step 1 , or aperiodic .
therefore this step does not include any comparisons .
the precise explanation follows .
suppose that @xmath288 for all @xmath289 .
then @xmath288 for all @xmath290 by periodicity of @xmath252 $ ] .
therefore by the definition of @xmath291 , we have @xmath292 = t[k{+}pq]$ ] for all @xmath293 . hence the substring @xmath294 $ ] has the period @xmath227 .
now it follows from lemma [ stringsintersect ] that any @xmath20-run of @xmath31 corresponding to @xmath252 $ ] is @xmath227-periodic and therefore was found on step 1 because @xmath295 .
suppose that @xmath296 for some @xmath289 .
denote @xmath297 , @xmath298 .
let @xmath299 . since @xmath300 = t'[k{+}rq]$ ] , we have @xmath301 and @xmath302 , t[s{+}pq ] ) = { \operatorname{sgn}}(t[s{+}rpq ] , t[s{+}(r{+}1)pq])$ ] ( see fig . [
fig : cubicrun ] ) .
therefore , one of the following sequences of inequalities holds : @xmath303
< t[s{+}pq ] < t[s{+}2pq ] < \ldots < t[s{+}lpq ] , \\
t[s ] > t[s{+}pq ] > t[s{+}2pq ] > \ldots > t[s{+}lpq]\enspace .
\label{eq : chains } \end{array}\ ] ] with the shortest period @xmath304 , where @xmath218 , @xmath259 , @xmath305 , @xmath306 , @xmath307 , @xmath308 , @xmath309 . ]
let @xmath280 be a multiple of @xmath227 such that @xmath310 .
now it suffices to show that due to the found `` aperiodic chain '' , there are no @xmath280-periodic @xmath20-runs of @xmath31 corresponding to @xmath252 $ ] .
suppose , to the contrary , @xmath311 $ ] is a @xmath280-periodic @xmath20-run corresponding to @xmath252 $ ] ( see fig .
[ fig : cubicrun ] ) . denote @xmath312 and @xmath313 . by the definition of corresponding @xmath20-runs ,
@xmath314 $ ] is a substring of @xmath252 $ ] . since @xmath315 and @xmath310
, we have @xmath316 .
therefore , @xmath317 and the inequalities imply @xmath318 \ne t[r'p{+}m_{r'{+}1,q } + p']$ ] , a contradiction .
* step 5 . *
let @xmath252 $ ] be a cubic run with the minimal period @xmath126 such that @xmath319 .
denote @xmath268 and @xmath269 . to find all @xmath20-runs corresponding to the run @xmath252 $ ]
, we make a recursive call executing steps 15 again with new parameters @xmath320 , @xmath321 , and @xmath322 $ ] . after the analysis of all cubic runs of @xmath47 , all @xmath20-runs of @xmath31 are found and the algorithm stops .
now it suffices to estimate the number of inequality comparisons performed during any run of the described algorithm . *
time analysis .
* as shown above , steps 14 require @xmath203 inequality comparisons .
let @xmath323 , \ldots , t'[i_k .. j_k]$ ] be the set of all cubic runs of @xmath47 with the minimal period @xmath112 or greater .
for @xmath324 , denote by @xmath325 the minimal period of @xmath326 $ ] and denote @xmath327 .
let @xmath328 be the number of inequality comparisons required by the algorithm to find all @xmath20-runs in a string of length @xmath1 .
then @xmath328 can be computed by the following formula : @xmath329 for @xmath330 , the number @xmath331 is , by definition , the exponent of @xmath326 $ ] .
it follows from lemma [ cubicrunexp ] that the sum of exponents of all cubic runs of @xmath47 with the shortest period @xmath112 or larger is less than @xmath332 .
note that for any @xmath330 , @xmath333 and therefore @xmath334 . thus assuming @xmath335
, we obtain @xmath336 .
finally , we have @xmath337 .
the reference to lemma [ equalcomp ] ends the proof .
it remains an open problem whether there exists a linear ram algorithm finding all runs in a string over a general ordered alphabet .
however , it is still possible that there are nontrivial lower bounds in some more sophisticated models that are strongly related to ram model .
abouelhoda , s. kurtz , e. ohlenbusch .
_ replacing the suffix trees with enhanced suffix arrays _ , j. discrete algorithms 2 ( 2004 ) 5386 .
aho , d.s .
hirschberg , j.d .
_ bounds on the complexity of the longest common subsequence problem _ , j. acm 23(1 ) ( 1976 ) 112 .
h. bannai , t. i , s. inenaga , y. nakashima , m. takeda , k. tsuruta . _
the `` runs '' theorem _ , preprint ( 2014 ) arxiv : 1406.0263v4 d. breslauer .
_ efficient string algorithmics _ , ph.d . thesis ( 1992 ) .
g. chen , s.j .
puglisi , w.f .
_ lempel - ziv factorization using less time and space _ , mathematics in computer science 1(4 ) ( 2008 ) 605623 .
m. crochemore . _ transducers and repetitions _ , theoret .
45(1 ) ( 1986 ) 6386 .
m. crochemore , l. ilie , w.f .
_ a simple algorithm for computing the lempel - ziv factorization _ , data compression conference 18 ( 2008 ) 482488 .
m. crochemore , l. ilie , l. tinta . _
the `` runs '' conjecture_. theoretical computer science 412(27 ) ( 2011 ) 29312941 .
m. crochemore , m. kubica , j. radoszewski , w. rytter , t. wale .
_ on the maximal sum of exponents of runs in a string _ , journal of discrete algorithms 14 ( 2012 ) 2936
. s. even , v.r .
pratt , m. rodeh . _
linear algorithm for data compression via string matching _ , j. acm 28(1 ) ( 1981 ) 1624 .
fiala , d.h .
_ data compression with finite windows _ , communications of the acm 32(4 ) ( 1989 ) 490505 .
n. j. fine , h. s. wilf . _ uniqueness theorem for periodic functions _ , proc .
( 1965 ) 109114 . r. kolpakov . _ on primary and secondary repetitions in words _ , theoretical computer science 418 ( 2012 ) 7181 .
r. kolpakov , g. kucherov .
_ finding maximal repetitions in a word in linear time _ , focs 40 ( 1999 ) 596604 .
r. kolpakov , m. podolskiy , m. posypkin , n. khrapov .
_ searching of gapped repeats and subrepetitions in a word _ , combinatorial pattern matching ( 2014 ) 212221 .
a. lempel , j. ziv .
_ on the complexity of finite sequences _ , ieee trans .
inform . theory 92(1 ) ( 1976 ) 7581 .
_ detecting leftmost maximal periodicities _ , discrete appl
25 ( 1989 ) 145153 .
main , r.j .
lorentz . _ linear time recognition of squarefree strings _ , combinatorial algorithms on words ( 1985 ) 271278 .
d. okanohara , k. sadakane . _ an online algorithm for finding the longest previous factors _ , algorithms - esa 2008 .
springer berlin heidelberg ( 2008 ) 696707
. t. starikovskaya .
_ computing lempel - ziv factorization online _ , mfcs 2012 ( 2012 ) 789799 .
j. yamamoto , t. i , h. bannai , s. inenaga , m. takeda .
_ faster compact on - line lempel - ziv factorization _
, preprint ( 2013 ) arxiv : 1305.6095v1 | the complexity of computing the lempel - ziv factorization and the set of all runs (= maximal repetitions ) is studied in the decision tree model of computation over ordered alphabet .
it is known that both these problems can be solved by ram algorithms in @xmath0 time , where @xmath1 is the length of the input string and @xmath2 is the number of distinct letters in it .
we prove an @xmath3 lower bound on the number of comparisons required to construct the lempel - ziv factorization and thereby conclude that a popular technique of computation of runs using the lempel - ziv factorization can not achieve an @xmath4 time bound .
in contrast with this , we exhibit an @xmath5 decision tree algorithm finding all runs in a string .
therefore , in the decision tree model the runs problem is easier than the lempel - ziv factorization .
thus we support the conjecture that there is a linear ram algorithm finding all runs . |
over the last decade , a great deal of effort has been devoted to show the importance of antiferromagnetic ( af ) dynamical correlations for the physical properties of high-@xmath0 cuprates and consequently for the microscopic mechanism responsible for superconductivity@xcite . to elucidate how these electronic correlations are relevant ,
it is then necessary to put the spectral weight of af fluctuations on a more quantitative scale .
inelastic neutron scattering ( ins ) provides essential information on this matter as it directly measures the full energy and momentum dependences of the spin - spin correlation function .
recently , efforts have been made to determine them in absolute units by comparison with phonon scattering .
the following definition , corresponding to @xmath2 of the total spin susceptibility , is used@xcite , @xmath3>\ ] ] our results are then directly comparable with both nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr ) results and theoretical calculations . here , some aspects of the spin dynamics obtained in bilayer system will be presented in relation with recent results reported by other groups@xcite .
however , it is before useful to recall the main features of magnetic correlations in the @xmath4 ( ybco ) system over doping and temperature@xcite .
we first emphasize the energy dependence of the spin susceptibility at the af wave vector , @xmath5 , for x @xmath6 0.6 ( or @xmath7 60 k ) .
@xmath8 in the normal state is basically well described in the underdoped regime by a broad peak centered around @xmath9 30 mev ( see fig .
[ sqw692])@xcite . upon heating ,
the af spin susceptibility spectral weight is reduced without noticeable renormalization in energy . going into the superconducting state , a more complex line shape
is observed essentially because a strong enhancement of the peak susceptibility occurs at some energy .
this new feature is referred to as the resonance peak , as it is basically resolution - limited in energy ( see e.g. @xcite ) . with increasing doping , the resonant peak becomes the major part of the spectrum@xcite . at each doping , the peak intensity at the resonance energy is characterized by a striking temperature dependence displaying a pronounced kink at @xmath0 @xcite .
therefore , this mode is a novel signature of the unconventional superconducting state of cuprates which has spawned a considerable theoretical activity .
most likely , the magnetic resonance peak is due to electron - hole pair excitation across the superconducting energy gap @xcite .
the resonance peak may or may not be located at the same energy as the normal state peak . fig .
[ sqw692 ] displays a case where both occurs at different energies .
however , at lower doping , these two features are located around similar energies , @xmath10 30 - 35 mev for x @xmath1 0.6 - 0.8@xcite .
indeed , the resonance energy more or less scales with the superconducting temperature transition@xcite whereas the normal state maximum does not shift much over the phase diagram for x @xmath6 0.6@xcite .
apart from the sharp resonance peak , the broad contribution ( around @xmath1 30 mev ) is still discernible below @xmath0 as a shoulder , shown around @xmath11 35 mev in fig .
[ sqw692]@xcite . in the superconducting state
, the situation looks more complex as the low energy spin excitations are removed below a threshold , so - called spin gap@xcite , likely related to the superconducting gap itself .
the non - resonant contribution has not received much attention so far .
however , its spectral weight in the normal state is important and may be crucial for a mechanism for the high-@xmath0 superconductivity based on antiferromagnetism@xcite . with increasing doping ,
the latter peak is continuously reduced : it becomes too weak to be measured in ins experiments in the overdoped regime ybco@xmath12@xcite .
using the same experimental setup and the same sample@xcite , no antiferromagnetic fluctuations are discernible in the normal state above the nuclear background .
consistently , in the sc state , an isolated excitation around 40 mev is observed corresponding to the resonance peak . above @xmath0 , an upper limit for the spectral weight can be given@xcite which is about 4 times smaller than in ybco@xmath13@xcite .
assuming the same momentum dependence as ybco@xmath13 , it would give a maximum of the spin susceptibility less than 80 @xmath14 at @xmath15 in our units .
therefore , even though ybco@xmath12 may be near a fermi liquid picture@xcite with weak magnetic correlations , the spin susceptibility at @xmath16 can still be @xmath1 20 times larger than the uniform susceptibility measured by macroscopic susceptibility or deduced from nmr knight shift@xcite .
therefore , @xmath8 is then naturally characterized in the superconducting state by two contributions having opposite doping dependences , the resonance peak becoming the major part of the spectrum with increasing doping .
the discussion of im@xmath17 in terms of two contributions has not been emphasized by all groups@xcite .
however , we would like to point out that this offers a comprehensive description consistent with all neutron data in ybco published so far .
in particular , it provides an helpful description of the puzzling modification of the spin susceptibility induced by zinc substitution@xcite by noticing that , on the one hand , zinc reduces the resonant part of the spectrum and , on the other hand , it restores af non - resonant correlations in the normal state@xcite .
interestingly , the incommensurate peaks recently observed below the resonance peak in ybco@xmath18@xcite support the existence of two distinct contributions as the low energy incommensurate excitations can not belong to the same excitation as the commensurate sharp resonance peak .
finally , these two contributions do not have to be considered as independent and superimposed excitations : the occurrence of the sharp resonance peak clearly affects the full energy shape of the spin susceptibility@xcite .
we shall see below that the spin susceptibility q - shape is also modified below @xmath0 .
in momentum - space , although both contributions are most generally peaked around the commensurate in - plane wavevector @xmath15 , they exhibit different q - widths .
the resonance peak is systematically related to a doping independent q - width , @xmath19 @xmath20@xcite ( hwhm ) , and hence to a larger real space distance , @xmath21 in real space .
recent data @xcite agree with that conclusion .
in contrast , the non - resonant contribution exhibits a larger and doping dependent q - width , so that , the momentum width displays a minimum versus energy at the resonance peak energy@xcite .
recently , in the underdoped regime @xmath22 , dai et al@xcite reported low temperature q - scans at @xmath23= 24 mev which were peaked at an incommensurate wavevector . later , mook et al@xcite have detailed the precise position of these features , displaying a complex structure of the incommensurability with a squared - like shape with more intense four corners at @xmath24 and @xmath25 with @xmath26= 0.21 .
interestingly , the energy where this structure is reported is systematically located in a small energy range below the resonance energy , @xmath27= 34 mev@xcite .
further , this structure is only clearly observed at temperatures below @xmath0 . in the normal state ,
its existence remains questionable owing to background subtraction difficulties in such unpolarized neutron experiments@xcite .
a broad commensurate peak is unambiguously recovered above 75 k in polarized beam measurements@xcite .
to clarify that situation , we have performed a polarized neutron triple - axis experiment on an underdoped sample ybco@xmath28 with @xmath0= 67 k@xcite .
the experiment on in20 at the institut laue langevin ( grenoble ) with a final wavevector @xmath29= 2.662 @xmath20 ( experimental details will be reported elsewhere@xcite ) .
[ qscan ] displays q - scans at @xmath23= 24 mev in the spin - flip channel at two temperatures : t=14.5 k and t= @xmath0 + 3 k. the polarization analysis , and especially the comparison of the two guide field configurations ( h // q and h @xmath30 q ) , allows unambiguously to remove the phonon contributions@xcite .
surprisingly , the magnetic intensity is basically found commensurate at both temperatures .
tilted goniometer scans have been performed to pass through the locus of the reported incommensurate peaks@xcite : less magnetic intensity is measured there meaning that there is no clear sign of incommensurability in that sample
. however , fig .
[ qscan ] shows different momentum shapes at both temperatures : a flatter top shape is found at low temperature indicating that the momentum dependence of the spin susceptibility evolves with temperature .
3 underlines this point as it displays the temperature dependence of the intensity at both the commensurate wavevector and at the incommensurate positions ( along the ( 310 ) direction as reported in ref .
two complementary behaviors are found : at the commensurate position , the peak intensity is reduced at @xmath0@xcite whereas at the incommensurate position the intensity increases at a temperature which likely corresponds to @xmath0 . as quoted by dai _
et al_@xcite , on cooling below @xmath0 , the spectrum rearranges itself with a suppression at the commensurate point accompanied by an increase in intensity at incommensurate positions .
[ inc - tdep ] therefore , even though our ybco@xmath28 sample does not exhibit well - defined incommensurate peaks , quite similar temperature dependences are observed in both samples .
superconductivity likely triggers a redistribution of the magnetic response in momentum space , that may marginally result in an incommensurate structure in a narrow energy range .
interestingly , the sharp resonance peak simultaneously occurs .
so that , superconductivity affects the spin susceptibility shape in * both * the momentum and the energy spaces .
then , the interplay between the resonant and the non - resonant contributions may induce the incommensurate structure . in this respect ,
the magnetic incommensurability found in the la@xmath31sr@xmath32cuo@xmath33 system would have a different origin as the wavevector dependence of im@xmath17 in lsco remains essentially the same across the superconducting transition@xcite .
energy and momentum dependences of the antiferromagnetic fluctuations in high @xmath0 cuprates ybco have been discussed .
the sharp resonance peak occurs exclusively below @xmath0 .
it is likely an intrinsic feature of the copper oxides as it has been , recently , discovered in @xmath34@xcite .
this resonance peak is accompanied in underdoped samples by a broader contribution remaining above @xmath0 .
p. bourges in _ the gap symmetry and fluctuations in high temperature superconductors _ edited by j. bok , g , deutscher , d. pavuna and s.a . wolf .
( plenum press , 1998 ) ( cond - mat/9901333 ) ; l.p . regnault _
et al . _ , in _ neutron scattering in layered copper - oxide superconductors
_ , edited by a. furrer , 85 ( kluwer , amsterdam , 1998 ) . | key features of antiferromagnetic dynamical correlations in high-@xmath0 superconductors cuprates are discussed . in underdoped regime , the sharp resonance peak , occuring exclusively in the sc state , is accompanied by a broader contribution located around @xmath1 30 mev which remains above @xmath0 .
their interplay may induce incommensurate structure in the superconducting state . |
to solve a conformal field theory ( cft ) amounts to finding its spectrum and 3-point correlation functions , since higher point functions may be obtained using the operator product expansion ( ope ) . in the former case
this means finding the anomalous dimensions of the operators of the theory , while in the latter case it means finding the couplings in 3-point correlation functions , whose space - time dependence is otherwise fixed by conformal invariance . in the simplest case of scalar primary operators
the 3-point function has the simple form _ a(0)o_b(x)o_c(y)= . where @xmath11 is the dimension of the operator @xmath2 , and so on .
the definition of the couplings @xmath12 requires that the operators diagonalise the anomalous dimension matrix and depends on the choice of normalisation in the 2-point function of each operator .
our main interest is to explore new methods to compute the couplings @xmath12 for certain single trace operators in @xmath4 sym . in recent years
there have been great progresses in finding the spectrum of this theory , in the planar limit and for any value of the coupling constant , using integrability @xcite-@xcite .
on the other hand , much remains to be done in the computation of the couplings @xmath12 . at weak coupling these
may be evaluated , order by order in perturbation theory , by computing feynman diagrams @xcite-@xcite .
although this approach is essential to uncover new structures and to verify new exact results , it is unpractical to obtain exact results for general operators .
a more promising approach is to explore integrability of planar @xmath4 sym .
however , how integrability will enter computations of the couplings @xmath12 remains unclear .
one strategy to compute the couplings in a cft is to deform the theory from its fixed point with a marginal or irrelevant operator @xmath0 .
we will show in section 2 that this deformation introduces new divergences in the renormalised operators of the critical theory , which are determined by the couplings @xmath1 .
more precisely , to leading order in the deformation parameter , the entry of the deformed anomalous dimension matrix between operators @xmath2 and @xmath3 is determined by the coupling @xmath1 .
thus , in planar @xmath4 sym , finding the action of such matrix on operators diagonalized by means of the bethe ansatz is a new method to compute the couplings @xmath1 . in practice
, we will show in section 3 how to implement these ideas in the case of the coupling deformation , which is considerably easier since it is an exact deformation .
another example , that is expected to work in a similar fashion is the @xmath13 deformation of @xmath4 @xcite .
more general deformations may also be considered . whether this technique will be useful in unveiling new integrability structures in the perturbative computation of the couplings
@xmath12 remains an open problem . at strong t hooft coupling
we may use the ads / cft duality @xcite to compute the couplings @xmath12 .
the duality relates the @xmath14 string partition function , computed with suitable boundary condition , to the generating functional for correlation functions of the gauge theory @xcite .
however , in practice this relation has been useful only to compute , at strong coupling , correlation functions of chiral operators that are dual to the supergravity fields @xcite .
recently , a path integral approach to compute the string theory partition function for a heavy string state propagating between two boundary points has been developed @xcite ( see also @xcite ) . in this case
the string path integral is dominated by a classical saddle point , giving a new method to compute at strong coupling the 2-point function of single trace operators with a large number of basic fields @xcite . in section 4
we shall extend this computation to the case of a 3-point function with an additional chiral operator .
the basic idea is that , taking into account the coupling between the heavy string worldsheet and the supergravity fields , the path integral giving the aforementioned 2-point function can be extended to include the interaction with light fields . in practice
all one needs to do is to compute a witten diagram with a supergravity field propagating from the @xmath14 boundary to the heavy string worldsheet , which acts as a tadpole for this field .
we will show how this computation works for the dilaton field and several heavy string configurations , obtaining couplings of the form @xmath15 , in complete agreement with the value predicted by renormalisation group arguments .
we conclude in section 5 with comments and open problems .
the goal of this section is to show how to relate the 3-point correlation function in a cft to the anomalous dimension matrix obtained from deforming the cft with a marginal or irrelevant operator @xmath0 of dimension @xmath16 at the cft fixed point .
we emphasise that the results presented in this section are valid at a cft fixed point with coupling @xmath17
. we shall explore basic ideas given in @xcite ( see also appendix in @xcite ) .
the example that we have in mind , and that we will work in detail in the following sections , is @xmath4 sym , so we shall stick to four dimensions . in this case
, the dimension @xmath16 of the operator @xmath0 satisfies @xmath18 . in the case of @xmath4 sym
we have a line of cft s parameterised by the coupling constant @xmath17 , so we may wish to take the coupling to be finite and large , or to expand to arbitrary order in the coupling constant . we may also wish to consider an operator @xmath0 of protected dimension , but that is not necessary . our starting point is a cft with action @xmath19 .
we consider the deformed theory with action @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the dimensionless deformation parameter at the cut - off scale @xmath22 of dimension inverse length , and the operators that appear in this action are the renormalized operators of the undeformed theory .
the beta function for the coupling @xmath21 has the form , @xmath23 where @xmath24 represents terms quadratic , or of higher powers , in the couplings to all operators around the fixed point . for what we are doing it will be sufficient to work to linear order in @xmath21 ,
so we keep only the first term in the beta function @xmath25 with @xmath16 computed at the fixed point .
sending the cut - off to infinity , the coupling @xmath26 at a fixed scale @xmath27 is constant for @xmath28 ( marginal deformation ) and vanishes for @xmath29 ( irrelevant deformation ) . for simplicity we shall consider the operator @xmath0 to be a scalar primary . but
this can be generalised to more operators , for instance , @xmath0 could be the energy - momentum tensor , in which case @xmath21 would be a tensor valued deformation parameter . for the sake of clarity
, we shall consider in what follows the case of an operator @xmath0 with dimension @xmath28 at the fixed point .
since we are interested in the case of @xmath4 sym at any value of the coupling , this means the operator has protected dimension . in the appendix
we extend our results to the case of irrelevant deformations .
we decided to separate the discussion because in the following sections we shall be working with the marginal case , therefore avoiding the duplication of formulae in the main text . a final introductory word about notation
, we shall use the label @xmath21 to denote quantities computed in the deformed cft with action given by ( [ deformedaction ] ) .
quantities without the label @xmath21 are computed at the undeformed theory for which @xmath30 .
we now analyse the divergences that appear in the deformed theory , in terms of renormalized quantities of the undeformed theory .
let @xmath2 be any renormalized operator of the undeformed theory .
we shall denote its full dimension ( classical + quantum ) , at the fixed point , by @xmath11 . when computing the correlation function of this operator with any other operators , we obtain in the deformed theory to linear order in @xmath21 , @xmath31 where the right hand side of this equation is computed in the undeformed theory .
in general new divergences can appear in equation ( [ expansionn - pf ] ) , that can be cancelled by renormalizing the operators @xmath32 , and that come from the behaviour of the correlation function involving @xmath33 , when @xmath34 approaches any of the positions of the other operators .
the form of this divergences is entirely determined by the ope in the undeformed theory of the operator @xmath0 with the operators appearing in the correlation function . for the operator @xmath35 we have @xmath36 where the constants @xmath1 are precisely the couplings appearing in the 3-point function @xmath37 .
we remark that for now we assume that the complete basis of operators @xmath38 is diagonal with unit norm , i.e. @xmath39 the physically meaningful couplings @xmath1 are defined with respect to operators satisfying this normalisation . using the ope expansion ( [ ope ] ) , we conclude that the divergence in the @xmath34 integral of ( [ expansionn - pf ] ) , arising from the region of integration @xmath40 , is given by @xmath41 hence , powerlike divergences arise from operators that enter the ope of @xmath2 and @xmath0 , and whose dimensions satisfy @xmath42 . by the unitarity bounds this is a finite number of operators , for instance
, for scalar operators in four dimensions we must have @xmath43 .
logarithmic divergences appear from operators in the ope with @xmath44 .
we are now in position to define renormalized operators @xmath45 of the deformed theory , expressed in terms of renormalized operators of the undeformed theory , such that the general correlation function ( [ expansionn - pf ] ) is finite .
this is quite simple , because there is a finite number of operators @xmath3 entering the ope ( [ ope ] ) and contributing to the divergences in ( [ divergences ] ) .
we define the renormalized operators @xmath46 as usual , we see that operator mixing occurs for @xmath47 . in terms of bare operators of the undeformed theory , then , in a theory without dimensional couplings , mixing will only occur between operators of the same classical dimension , i.e. for @xmath48 .
then , the last term in ( [ renormalized ] ) only concerns operators with different anomalous dimensions , since the power like divergence becomes logarithmic when expanding in the coupling @xmath17 . ] with this renormalization scheme , correlation functions @xmath49 computed at the fixed value of the coupling @xmath17 , and to linear order in @xmath21 for the theory with action ( [ deformedaction ] ) , are finite
. of particular importance to us will be the case of 2-point functions .
for operators @xmath2 and @xmath3 with the same dimension in the undeformed theory , it is simple to see that @xmath50 for @xmath51 this gives @xmath52 if there are different operators @xmath2 and @xmath3 of equal dimension , we see that the effect of turning on the deformation is to induce operator mixing , since the above 2-point function is no longer diagonal .
it is also simple to see that the 2-point function for operators @xmath2 and @xmath3 of different dimension still vanishes .
we now wish to better understand the basis of renormalized operators introduced in the previous section , by defining a deformed anomalous dimension matrix . we will then verify the callan - symanzik equation for correlation functions in the deformed theory .
let us start by defining renormalized operators of the deformed theory using the usual renormalization matrix @xmath53 where we omitted the summation in @xmath54 .
from ( [ renormalized ] ) we can read the entries of this matrix , @xmath55 it is now simple to compute the anomalous dimension matrix associated to the deformation , defined by @xmath56 its non - vanishing entries are _ ab = u 2 ^ 2 a_dab ^_a-_b , [ deformedgamma ] for @xmath57 .
we remark that the anomalous dimension matrix @xmath58 is defined with respect to renormalized operators of the undeformed theory with total dimension given by @xmath11 at the fixed point . if we order the operators in blocks with descending value of dimension , the non - diagonal top - right blocks of the anomalous dimension matrix @xmath59 have zero entries .
it is then clear that its eigenvalues @xmath60 are independent of the cut - off @xmath22 , although the eigenvectors do depend in general on @xmath22 ( when there is mixing between operators of different dimension ) .
thus , in the diagonal basis we have , as usual , @xmath61 . an alternative way of deriving the relation between the anomalous dimension @xmath58 and the couplings @xmath62 is to verify the callan - symanzik equation .
this is simpler for a marginal deformation , and to linear order in @xmath21 , because the beta function @xmath25 vanishes ( in the appendix we consider the case of irrelevant deformations ) . for the non - renormalized two - point function of the deformed theory , computed using renormalized operators of the cft at the fixed point
, the callan - symanzik equation has the form @xmath63 using ( [ expansionn - pf ] ) and the form of the divergences given in ( [ divergences ] ) this equation is satisfied provided ( [ deformedgamma ] ) holds . for practical perturbative computations it is useful to relate the couplings @xmath62 to the anomalous dimension matrix computed with respect to bare operators of the cft ( not renormalized ) .
let us denote a basis of such operators by @xmath64 .
now assume that we manage to diagonalize the anomalous dimension matrix of the critical theory , so that in the basis @xmath64 we have @xmath65 , where @xmath66 are the eigenvalues ( for instance , in @xmath4 sym we can use integrability techniques to do that quite effectively ) . in this basis , and denoting by @xmath67 the classical dimension of operators , it is simple to see that the renormalization matrix @xmath68 relating bare operators to the renormalized operators of the deformed theory in the usual way , @xmath69 , has entries @xmath70 the corresponding deformed anomalous dimension matrix has entries ^u_ab = _ ab _ a + u 2 ^ 2 a_dab ^^0_a-^0_b .
[ deformedh ] note that these are the entries of the matrix @xmath71 in the basis @xmath64 that diagonalizes the anomalous dimension matrix of the critical theory .
again , it is important to realize that the structure of the matrix @xmath71 , given by ( [ deformedh ] ) , implies that its eigenvalues are independent of the cut - off @xmath22 , although the eigenvectors may depend on @xmath22 .
let us show explicitly how the knowledge of the deformed anomalous dimension @xmath71 allows to relate the couplings @xmath1 to the deformed anomalous dimensions and renormalized operators @xmath45 expressed in terms of the bare quantities .
first we write the anomalous dimension matrix as @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the anomalous dimension matrix of the critical theory , and @xmath74 is the term arising from the deformation which we treat as a perturbation . for simplicity
we assume that the operators @xmath65 and @xmath75 do not have the same anomalous dimension at the critical point ( they may or may not have the same classical dimension ) .
then , writing the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of @xmath71 respectively as @xmath76 basic quantum mechanics formulae gives @xmath77 where the matrix elements are computed in the basis @xmath38 with unit normalised operators . from the explicit form of the deformed anomalous dimension matrix in the basis @xmath64 given in ( [ deformedh ] ) , we conclude that @xmath78 note that ( [ final2 ] ) has the correct dependence in the cut - off @xmath22 to relate operators @xmath2 and @xmath79 of different dimension , as required by ( [ quantummechanics ] ) .
it is now clear that if we have a way of determining the action of the perturbation matrix @xmath80 on the bare operators , we may then compute the corresponding couplings using ( [ final ] ) and ( [ final2 ] )
. this will be the case in the next section , where we consider coupling deformations of @xmath4 sym and the known form of the integrable anomalous dimension matrix at a given order in the coupling constant .
we finish this section with a word on normalization of operators . in the next section
it will actually be convenient to perform computations with operators that are not normalized to unit , i.e. after diagonalizing the eigenvectors of the undeformed theory we will have @xmath81 with this normalization , to obtain the physically meaningful couplings for the unit normalized operators , we need to divide the operators in equations ( [ final ] ) and ( [ final2 ] ) by their norm .
in this section we consider the simplest case of @xmath4 sym deformed by the lagrangian operator , since this theory is actually a line of fixed points parametrised by the coupling constant .
we shall use integrability to show how to compute the couplings in the 3-point function of the lagrangian with any two operators of the theory . for simplicity , we restrict our analysis to the @xmath82 scalar subsector , and consider in detail operators corresponding to two - magnon excitations in the spin chain language .
we shall use the following convention for the @xmath4 sym action @xmath83 ^ 2 + { \rm fermions}\big)\ , , \label{action}\ ] ] where @xmath84 and the covariant derivative is defined by @xmath85 $ ] . all fields are in the adjoint representation and the @xmath86 generators are normalized with @xmath87 .
we will be considering the @xmath82 sector with complex scalars @xmath88 now consider the theory at some fixed value of the t hooft coupling , defined by @xmath89 we will consider ( planar ) perturbation theory to some order in the coupling @xmath90 .
we are therefore considering the cft at the fixed point with coupling @xmath90 .
then , to deform the theory with @xmath91 , it is clear from ( [ action ] ) that we should write @xmath92 hence , making this replacement in the anomalous dimension matrix of @xmath4 , to a given order in @xmath90 , and then keeping only the linear terms in @xmath21 , we obtain the form of the deformed anomalous dimension matrix @xmath71 .
we may then use the results ( [ final ] ) and ( [ final2 ] ) to compute the couplings .
alternatively , we can also compute the derivative of @xmath93 or @xmath45 with respect to @xmath21 or , instead , the derivative @xmath94 of @xmath95 or @xmath2 to a given order in @xmath90 .
finally , note that the two - point function of the lagrangian is ( dropping the @xmath96 correction ) @xmath97 we shall compute the couplings with respect to this normalization , but it is simple to re - scale with respect to the unit normalised lagrangean @xmath98 . in that case
we would obtain that all the couplings @xmath99 computed in this paper are of order @xmath96 , for fixed t hooft coupling , as expected .
as an example consider single trace operators made by @xmath100 fields of the @xmath82 sector and regard the fields @xmath101 as impurities in the vacuum state @xmath102 . for operators with @xmath103 impurities , we use the integers @xmath104 to indicate the position of the impurities in the corresponding spin chain , @xmath105
the anomalous dimension matrix is that of an integrable spin chain and may be diagonalized by solving the bethe equations @xcite . then the operator @xmath2 , with anomalous dimension @xmath95 , is given by @xmath106 where the wave function @xmath107 is parameterized by the momenta @xmath108 of the magnons , which in general can be complex , sum to zero mod @xmath109 , and depend on the t hooft coupling .
then , the contribution of the @xmath110-th magnon to the anomalous dimension of the operator @xmath2 is given by @xcite @xmath111 this formula is believed to be correct to all orders in the t hooft coupling , provided wrapping effects , that become important at order @xmath112 , are neglected .
the interactions between magnons are responsible for the dependence of their momenta on the t hooft coupling .
this effect appears in the computation of the anomalous dimension at two - loop order , while is appears at one - loop in the computation of the coupling @xmath113 .
thus , neglecting wrapping effects , ( [ final ] ) gives the all - loop result @xmath114 where prime denotes derivative with respect to @xmath90 .
we remark that the normalised coupling @xmath115 scales with @xmath96 as expected .
we shall compute in the next section this coupling up to order @xmath116 , in the simple case of operators with two - magnons .
next we consider the dilute limit of @xmath117 . in this limit
the magnons propagate freely on the spin chain and their momentum is trivially quantised as @xmath118 in this case the second term in the numerator of ( [ alllooplaa ] ) can be dropped .
one may now study both weak and strong coupling limits .
the leading order term in @xmath90 , which comes from the 1-loop correction to the anomalous dimension of @xmath2 , is given by @xmath119 and can be derived simply by doing wick contractions between @xmath120 , @xmath2 and @xmath121 . on the other hand , at strong coupling and neglecting wrapping effects ,
we have @xmath122 in section [ sec : strongcoup ] we shall confirm this computation of the coupling @xmath113 , by directly computing this 3-point function using the ads / cft duality in the gravity limit .
we shall now illustrate how one can use integrability techniques and the general results given in ( [ final ] ) and ( [ final2 ] ) to compute the couplings of two operators , each with two magnons , and the lagrangian .
we will compute 1-loop corrections to these couplings , which correspond to diagonalizing the anomalous dimension matrix at two - loop order .
the corresponding spin chain hamiltonian includes next to neighbour interactions @xcite , @xmath123 where @xmath124 is the permutation operator . at this order ,
the bethe wave function includes a contact term and can be written in the following form @xcite @xmath125 with @xmath126 since for two magnons the total momentum vanishes , we have @xmath127
. we shall now write the formulae for the contact function and for the s - matrix in this simpler case @xcite . for the contact function @xmath128
, we have @xmath129 which satisfies @xmath130 .
the s - matrix @xmath131 , can be written as @xmath132 with @xmath133 it is clear that @xmath134 .
the momenta that solve the bethe equation @xmath135 are given by @xmath136 where @xmath137 is an integer .
it is now a mechanical calculation to replace this expression in ( [ alllooplaa ] ) , to obtain @xmath138 + o(g^6)\ , .
\label{twolooplaa}\ ] ] next we consider the coupling @xmath139 , where @xmath2 is an operator with two magnons of momenta @xmath140 and @xmath141 , and @xmath3 is an operator with two magnons of momenta @xmath142 and @xmath143 .
this amounts to computing the matrix element @xmath144 . using the two - loop anomalous dimension matrix given in ( [ anomalousdimmatrix ] ) we have @xmath145
now we argue that the first two terms in this expression do not contribute to @xmath144 .
first recall that @xmath146 and @xmath147 are eigenstates of @xmath73 , with terms of order @xmath148 and @xmath90 . since @xmath73 is diagonalized by these eigenstates , the contribution from the first term in @xmath80 vanishes .
moreover , since the second term in @xmath80 starts at order @xmath116 , for this term we may consider the eigenstates @xmath146 and @xmath147 only at order @xmath148 .
thus , this term is proportional to the hamiltonian @xmath73 at one - loop , and it will also give a vanishing contribution .
we are therefore left with the contribution from the last term in ( [ derivativeh ] ) , which we can compute with the eigenstates @xmath146 and @xmath147 of order @xmath148 .
a computation shows that @xmath149 since we are working with states with norm @xmath150 , after normalising to unit we obtain @xmath151 the example given in this section shows that one can use integrability of @xmath4 sym to compute quite effectively the couplings of operators to the lagrangian . of course one can try to compute these couplings to higher orders in the t hooft coupling @xmath90 , to consider operators with more magnons and also operators outside the @xmath82 sector .
another generalization would be to consider the beta deformation of @xmath4 sym , computing the couplings involving the operator that generates such deformation .
it would be very interesting to study the deformed anomalous dimension matrix associated to operators that are not exact , and whose deformation does not lead to an integrable theory .
in particular , having a representation of @xmath80 acting on the spin chain associated to operators of the cft at the fixed point would allow for quite effective computations of the corresponding couplings .
in this section we compute 3-point correlation functions of @xmath4 sym at strong coupling using the ads / cft duality .
so far , computations of correlation functions in the gauge / gravity duality use the field theory limit of strings propagating in ads . in this case
, the computation of witten diagrams involves only supergravity fields , giving correlation functions of chiral operators @xcite . on the other hand , here we shall compute 3-point correlation functions involving two insertions of an operator @xmath2 dual to a very massive string @xcite , with a chiral operator @xmath0 dual to a supergravity field .
the corresponding witten diagram is given in figure [ wittendiagram ] , where a heavy string state propagates between boundary points at @xmath152 and @xmath153 , and interacts with a light field sourced at the boundary point @xmath34 .
this computation can be done for the supergravity fields that couple to a heavy string worldsheet .
clearly one can also generalise this computation to higher point functions with more supergravity fields . to compute the string partition function
we shall use different approaches to treat the heavy and light string fields . for
the heavy string state we shall consider the action for a string ( or particle ) in the first quantised theory and compute its contribution to the partition function by summing over classical trajectories , while for the light fields we shall use the supergravity approximation .
it is therefore convenient to represent the source for the operator @xmath2 dual to the heavy string field by @xmath154 , and the source for the chiral operators @xmath0 dual to the supergravity fields by @xmath155 .
the gauge theory generating functional for diagrams with insertions of @xmath2 at @xmath152 and at @xmath153 can then be written as @xmath156 by varying with respect to the sources @xmath155 we may compute correlation functions with many chiral operators . in this section
we are interested in the simplest case of taking one such derivative to compute the 3-point function @xmath157 for some chiral operator @xmath0 . the ads / cft duality states that the gauge theory generating functional for correlation functions of local operators equals the string partition function with suitable boundary conditions @xcite . in particular , at strong coupling , the generating functional ( [ generatingfunctional ] ) can be approximated by @xmath158 + s_{sugra}[\phi ] \right)}\ , , \label{stringgeneratingfunctional}\ ] ] where we use the string polyakov action @xmath159 to describe the propagation of the heavy string state . the corresponding worldsheet starts and ends very close to the boundary , i.e. in poincar coordinates @xmath160 it obeys the boundary conditions @xmath161 where @xmath162 is a regulator .
the effect of these boundary conditions is to generate two functional derivatives with respect to the source @xmath154 of the heavy field , justifying the identification between ( [ generatingfunctional ] ) and ( [ stringgeneratingfunctional ] ) .
the supergravity fields in ( [ stringgeneratingfunctional ] ) are represented by @xmath163 and approximate the gauge theory sources @xmath164 near the boundary , in the sense that @xmath165 as @xmath166 .
the propagation of the light fields is determined by the supergravity action around the @xmath167 vacuum , which we denote below by @xmath168 .
the vacuum value for the ten - dimensional einstein metric @xmath169 is given by @xmath170 where the ads radius satisfies @xmath171 .
then , it is simple to show that the five - dimensional supergravity action in the einstein s frame has the form @xmath172 where @xmath24 represents terms in the action other than the metric and dilaton fields . the gravitational coupling is given by @xmath173 .
the propagation of the heavy string state , and its coupling to the supergravity fields , is determined from the polyakov action s_p[x , , ] = - g d^2 ^ _ x^a _
x^b g_ab e^/2 + , [ polyakov ] where @xmath169 is the ten - dimensional metric in the einstein frame , @xmath174 represents the fluctuations of the dilaton field and @xmath24 includes other terms like worldsheet fermions and other supergravity fields .
the heavy string will have the worldsheet topology of a cylinder . working in the conformal gauge ,
the integration over worldsheet metrics becomes simply an integration over the modular parameter @xmath175 of the cylinder , i.e. [ gammatos ] d^2 ^ _
-s/2^s/2d_0 ^ 2 d^. to compute the generating functional ( [ stringgeneratingfunctional ] ) it is convenient to perform first the path integral over the supergravity fields . we write ( [ stringgeneratingfunctional ] ) as @xmath176 } \int d\phi \,e^{i \left(s_{sugra}[\phi ] + \int d^2\sigma\left .
\frac{\delta s_{p}[x , s,\phi]}{\delta \phi}\right|_{\phi=0}\,\phi + \cdots\right ) } \ , .
\label{stringgeneratingfunctional2}\ ] ] for a fixed off - shell string worldsheet , the supergravity functional can be computed with witten diagrams , after boundary sources for the supergravity fields are specified .
the new ingredient are the extra terms localized along the string worldsheet that add to the supergravity action .
these terms determine the coupling between the light fields and the heavy string state . in ( [ stringgeneratingfunctional2 ] )
we wrote just the leading term , which acts as a simple tadpole for the supergravity fields ( it comes from a cubic interaction in string field theory ) .
these terms can be treated perturbatively and do not affect the free propagators of light fields .
before computing diagrams with a supergravity field , let us recall the computation of the 2-point function for the operator @xmath2 dual to a heavy field , as done in @xcite . to obtain the correct scaling of the 2-point function
it is necessary to convolute the generating functional ( [ stringgeneratingfunctional2 ] ) with the wave function of the classical field we are considering . in the wkb approximation this amounts to changing the measure in the string path integral such that the action determining the propagator of the heavy field is actually @xmath177 \ , , \label{newaction}\ ] ] where we use letters @xmath178 and @xmath179 respectively for the @xmath180 and @xmath181 indices .
the worldsheet canonical momentum is @xmath182 , and @xmath183 and @xmath184 are the @xmath180 zero modes @xmath185 the arbitrariness in the definition of these zero modes requires a precise prescription . in @xcite
it was proposed to use the embedding coordinates of @xmath180 , therefore preserving the @xmath186 symmetry of the conformal group . for a number of particular examples , it was shown in @xcite the following result , which is expected to be general , @xmath187 } \approx \frac{p}{|x_i - x_f|^{2\delta_a}}\,,\ ] ] where we absorbed the cut - off dependence in the measure .
the path integral is dominated by the classical saddle point , which yields the correct conformal dependence for the 2-point function of the operator @xmath2 . the pre - factor @xmath124 , which is associated to the integration of fluctuations of the classical solution ,
will define the normalization of @xmath2 .
since the 3-point function is defined with respect to unit normalized operators , we shall see below that to leading order we actually do not need to evaluate this pre - factor .
next let us consider the 3-pt function @xmath188 , where @xmath189 is a chiral operator of dimension @xmath16 dual to some particular supergravity field @xmath190 .
this field may have some tensor structure in @xmath180 and also some kk structure from the @xmath181 compactification .
the functional integral for the supergravity fields in ( [ stringgeneratingfunctional2 ] ) can be computed using witten diagrams .
if the field @xmath190 has a source at the boundary , ( [ stringgeneratingfunctional2 ] ) leads to [ 3pt - function ] .
k_(x ( , ) ; y ) , [ i_integral ] and @xmath191 is the bulk - to - boundary propagator of the field @xmath190 .
equation ( [ 3pt - function ] ) states that the 3-point function is simply the expectation value over the heavy string trajectories of the interaction term @xmath192 $ ] , weighted by the action @xmath193 .
note that the measure used for the propagation of the heavy string is that defined by the computation of the 2-point function as described above , i.e. after the convolution with the heavy state wave function . on the other hand , the coupling @xmath192 $ ]
is determined by the polyakov action @xmath159 . as usual , to compute this path integral one expands around the classical saddle point x ( , ) = |x ( , ) + , s=|s + s , where we rescaled the quantum fluctuations for @xmath194 so that the t hooft coupling @xmath90 does not enter in the quadratic terms arising from the expansion of the action @xmath193 around the saddle point solution @xmath195 .
it is then clear that , after expanding the interaction term @xmath192 $ ] around this saddle point , the dominant contribution in ( [ 3pt - function ] ) for large @xmath196 is given by .
i _ , where the pre - factor @xmath124 coincides precisely with that in the computation of the 2-point function of @xmath2 .
thus , defining @xmath2 to have a unit normalised 2-point function , we conclude that at strong coupling [ result ] _
a(x_i)o_a(x_f)d_(y ) . equation ( [ result ] ) is one of the main results of this paper .
the approximations that led to ( [ result ] ) assume that the initial and final heavy string states are the same .
this means that interactions with supergravity fields that change conserved charges of the heavy string , such as @xmath197-charge or @xmath14 spin , are not taken into account .
it would be interesting to consider a heavy string with different initial and final boundary conditions and include the effect of the light supergravity field on the string saddle point .
to fix our conventions let us remark that in the simple case of a scalar field @xmath190 , normalised such that @xmath198 its bulk - to - boundary propagator is given by @xmath199 in this simple case the normalisation of the 2-point function of the operator @xmath189 appearing in ( [ result ] ) is given by _
( x)d_(y ) = .
[ 2pt - functiond ] in the remainder of this section we shall compute 3-point functions of the type @xmath200 .
we will consider the simplest case where the operator @xmath0 is dual to the dilaton field , i.e. we will consider the operator @xmath201 .
this will allow us to check our results since , as shown in sections 2 and 3 , this correlation function can be obtained from the derivative of @xmath202 with respect to the coupling constant .
we need to be careful with normalisations , since the dilaton field in the sugra action has a factor of @xmath203 multiplying the canonical kinetic term . instead , we should compute the witten diagram with the canonically normalised field @xmath204 , whose propagator is given by ( [ kprop ] ) with @xmath28 .
the final result should then be multiplied by @xmath205 , since @xmath206 . in practice
, when computing @xmath207 in ( [ i_integral ] ) , this amounts to taking the derivative of the action @xmath159 with respect to @xmath174 , while using the normalised propagator @xmath208 as given in ( [ kprop ] ) . in what follows
we shall refer to @xmath207 in ( [ i_integral ] ) with that abuse of notation .
finally , let us remark that in our conventions the 2-point function of @xmath120 is given at large @xmath209 by ( [ normalisationl ] ) , which can also be verified at strong coupling using the duality .
let us consider first the limit where the heavy string field dual to the operator @xmath2 can be approximated by a point - particle of mass @xmath210 . in the einstein frame ,
the nambu - goto action for a particle coupled to the dilaton takes the form @xmath211= - m \int_0 ^ 1 d\tau \ , e^{\phi/4 } \sqrt { - \dot{x}^a \dot{x}^b g_{ab } } \,,\ ] ] where dot denotes derivative with respect to the worldline parameter @xmath212 . on dimensional grounds
one concludes that massive string states will have @xmath213 .
we shall be working with the usual poincar coordinates @xmath214 and for simplicity assume only motion in the @xmath180 part of the space .
the corresponding polyakov action , depending on both the particle trajectory and the einbein @xmath215 , is @xmath216= \frac{1}{2 } \int_0 ^ 1 d\tau \ , e^{\phi/4 } \left ( \frac{1}{{\rm e } } \,\dot{x}^a \dot{x}^b g_{ab } - { \rm e}\ , m^2 \right ) \,.\ ] ] the functional integration over the einbein @xmath215 can be substituted by a simple integration over the modular parameter @xmath175 , @xmath217= \frac{1}{2 } \int_{-s/2}^{s/2 } d\tau \ , e^{\phi/4 } \left(\dot{x}^a \dot{x}^b g_{ab } - m^2 \right ) \,,\ ] ] analogously to ( [ gammatos ] ) .
we may now apply the procedure to obtain the 3-point function starting from ( [ stringgeneratingfunctional2 ] ) . for spacelike separation on the boundary along a direction @xmath218
, the particle action on the @xmath14 vacuum simplifies to [ spnodilaton ] s_p[x , s,=0 ] = _ -s/2^s/2 d ( - m^2 ) .
the computation of the 2-point function for the point particle , using this action , was performed in @xcite .
the procedure is as follows : ( i ) determine a solution @xmath219 to the particle equations of motion , @xmath220 ( ii ) impose that the endpoints of the motion approach the boundary , @xmath221 , which implies [ kappabc ] , where we have set @xmath222 and @xmath223 ; ( iii ) compute the action s_p[|x , s,=0 ] = ( ^2 - m^2 ) s ; ( iv ) perform the integration over the modular parameter @xmath175 by taking the saddle point , [ saddleparticle ] |s = - i , which corresponds to the `` virasoro constraint '' for the einbein .
this computation leads to the correct dependence of the 2-point function , because at the saddle point e^i s_p[|x,|s,=0 ] = ( ) ^2_a , where we considered the large @xmath11 limit , for which @xmath224 . to compute the 3-point function @xmath225
, we need to evaluate @xmath226 $ ] , as given by ( [ i_integral ] ) . taking care of the correct normalization
, we have i_= i _
-s/2^s/2 d ( - m^2 ) ( ) ^4 . for small @xmath162 , at the saddle point trajectory ( [ xzparticle ] ) we obtain i_= . at the modular parameter saddle point ( [ saddleparticle ] ) , this expression becomes simply i_=- .
we conclude from ( [ result ] ) that _
a(0)o_a(x_f)l(y ) - .
[ resultparticle ] this expression has the spacetime dependence required by conformal invariance . the coupling @xmath15 is determined for large @xmath11 , and it agrees with the expectation from the renormalization group result ( [ final ] ) . to see this , notice that since @xmath227 , we have 2 ^ 2 a_laa = - g^2 - . in agreement with ( [ resultparticle ] ) .
the simplest example after the point particle is the circular rotating string with two equal spins @xcite , whose 2-point function was also computed in @xcite .
we start with the polyakov action coupled to the metric and the dilaton field ( [ polyakov ] ) .
the solution @xmath219 for the circular rotating string is given by ( [ xzparticle ] ) in the @xmath180 part of the geometry . in the @xmath181 part , with line element ds^2_s^5 = d^2 + ^2d_3
^ 2 + ^2(d^2 + ^2d_1 ^ 2 + ^2 d_2 ^ 2 ) , it is given by = , _ 3=0 , = , _ 1=_2=. the conserved angular momenta of the solution are @xmath228 .
this configuration is dual to an operator of the type @xmath229 .
let us apply now the procedure in @xcite .
we have @xmath230 & = g \int_{-s/2}^{s/2 } d\tau \int_{0}^{2\pi } d\sigma \left ( \frac{\dot{x}^2 + \dot{z}^2}{z^2 } - \psi'^2 + \cos^2 \psi \,\dot{\phi_1}^2 + \sin^2 \psi \,\dot{\phi_2}^2 \right ) \nonumber \\ & = 2 \pi g \left ( \frac{4}{s^2 } \log^2\frac{x_f}{\epsilon } + ( \omega^2 - 1 ) \right)s \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where prime denotes derivative with respect to @xmath231 , and we have imposed the relation ( [ kappabc ] ) . as detailed in @xcite , there is a subtlety in obtaining the string propagator , so that the classical solution for the cylinder coincides with the classical state .
this amounts to considering ( [ newaction ] ) , _
p[|x , s,=0 ] = 2 g ( ^2 -(1+^2 ) ) s .
the saddle point in the modular parameter @xmath175 is given by [ saddlecircular ] |s = - i .
looking at ( [ kappabc ] ) this implies the virasoro constraint @xmath232 .
we conclude that at the saddle point , we have e^i _ p[|x,|s,=0 ] = ( ) ^8 g .
this gives the correct dimension @xmath233 .
now we will obtain the 3-point function .
first we evaluate @xmath234 & = i\ , \frac{3\ , g}{\pi^2 } \int_{-s/2}^{s/2 } d\tau \int_{0}^{2\pi } d\sigma \left ( \frac{\dot{x}^2 + \dot{z}^2}{z^2 } - \psi'^2 + \cos^2 \psi \,\dot{\phi_1}^2 + \sin^2 \psi \,\dot{\phi_2}^2 \right ) \times \nonumber \\ & \hspace{5 cm } \times \left ( \frac{z}{z^2 + ( x - y)^2}\right)^4 \nonumber \\ & = i\,\frac{g}{4\pi}\ , \displaystyle { \frac{\left ( \frac{4}{s^2}\log^2\frac{x_f}{\epsilon}+(\omega^2 - 1)\right)s}{\log\frac{x_f}{\epsilon}}\ ; \frac{x_f^4}{y^4\,(x_f - y)^4 } } \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] at the saddle point ( [ saddlecircular ] ) , we have i_=- .
therefore , we conclude that _
a(0 ) o_a(x_f)l(y ) - .
as happened in the point particle case , the spacetime dependence is the one required by conformal invariance .
the coupling @xmath15 determined in this way agrees with the expectation , since 2 ^2 a_laa = - g^2 - g^2 2 = - , where we kept the angular momentum @xmath235 fixed when taking the derivative .
following the same steps , we move to the more complicated case of the giant magnon where the string rotates on a @xmath236 subspace of @xmath237 @xcite .
we remark that although an operator with a single magnon is not gauge invariant , we are implicitly computing the contribution of a single magnon to the 3-point coupling @xmath113 involving an operator @xmath2 in the dilute limit .
since the contribution of a magnon to the 2-point function of some operator was not computed in @xcite , we will present first this calculation and then concentrate on the 3-point function .
let us start by writing the solution in poincar coordinates .
the @xmath14 part is the same as in the two previous cases given in .
parametrizing the @xmath181 as ds^2_s^5 = d^2 + ^2d^2 + ^2 d_3 ^ 2 , the giant magnon has non - trivial worldsheet fields in the @xmath238 part , given by @xmath239 where @xmath240 and @xmath241 is the momentum of the magnon . the virasoro constraints , which we will not impose at this stage , require @xmath242 , where @xmath243 given in characterises the @xmath14 motion .
then we have @xmath244 & = g \int_{-s/2}^{s/2 } d\tau \int_{-l}^{l } d\sigma \left ( \frac{\dot{x}^2 + \dot{z}^2}{z^2 } + ( \dot{\theta}^2 - \theta'^2 ) + \sin^2 \psi \,(\dot{\varphi}^2 - \varphi'^2 ) \right ) \nonumber \\ & = g \int_{-\frac{s}{2}}^{\frac{s}{2}}d\tau \int_{-l}^{l } d\sigma \left[\kappa^2 + \omega^2 - 2 \omega^2 \cosh^{-2 } ( \omega u)\right]\ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] using we convolute with respect to the wave function of the rotating string state , which will change the @xmath181 action into its energy .
we obtain @xmath245= g \int_{-\frac{s}{2}}^{\frac{s}{2}}d\tau \int_{-l}^{l } d\sigma \left(\kappa^2 - \omega^2 \right ) = 2\ , g \ , s \left(\kappa^2 - \omega^2 \right ) l \ , .\ ] ] taking into account the condition for @xmath243 , it is possible to perform the remaining integration over the modular parameter @xmath175 by saddle point , with the result [ saddle - gm ] |s = -i .
again , this corresponds to the virasoro constraint , which in this case reads @xmath242 , and leads to [ conv - polyakov - gm ] _
p[|x,|s,=0]= i 8 g l .
it is convenient now to introduce the angular momentum , @xmath246 where we took the large @xmath100 approximation ( notice that the above saddle point defines a @xmath212 integration with @xmath247 real ) . substituting in and exponentiating
, we obtain the expected behaviour for the 2-point function , [ 2p - gm ] e^i _ p[|x,|s,=0 ] = ( ) ^2 ( j + 4 g ) , in particular , @xmath248 , which agrees with ( [ gmall - loop ] ) .
now it is straightforward to compute the 3-point function .
we evaluate @xmath249 & = i\ , \frac{3\ , g}{\pi^2 } \int_{-\bar{s}/2}^{\bar{s}/2 } d\tau \int_{-l}^{l } d\sigma \big ( \kappa^2 + \omega^2 - 2 \omega^2 \cosh^{-2 } ( \omega u ) \big ) \left ( \frac{z}{z^2 + ( x - y)^2}\right)^4 \nonumber \\ & = \frac{12\,g}{\pi^2 } \,\sin \frac{p}{2}\ , \int_{-\bar{s}/2}^{\bar{s}/2 } d\tau \ ; \frac { \sinh{\left(2 \omega l \csc{\frac{p}{2 } } \right ) } } { [ \cos{\left(2 \omega\ , i\tau \cot{\frac{p}{2}}\right ) } + \cosh{\left(2 \omega l \csc{\frac{p}{2}}\right ) } ] } \times\\ & \phantom{aaaaaaaaaaaaa } \times \frac{x_f^{4 } } { \left[(2y^2 - 2y\ , x_f + x_f^2 ) \cosh(\omega\ , i\tau)+(x_f^2 - 2y x_f)\sinh(\omega\,i\tau)\right]^4}\ , .
\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] taking the large @xmath100 approximation , as in ( [ jmagnon ] ) , we obtain i_= - .
therefore , we conclude that the one - magnon contribution to the 3-point function is @xmath250 which agrees with the expected result 2 ^ 2 a_laa = - g^2 - 2 g . the examples considered in the previous three sections only dealt with relatively simple string configurations with particle - like motion in the @xmath180 part .
we are interested in testing our approach in a more general setup , where the bulk - to - boundary propagator for the supergravity field varies along the string worldsheet for fixed worlsheet time @xmath212 .
we shall study the spinning string solution with angular momenta both in the @xmath181 and the @xmath180 factors @xcite , whose 2-point function was also computed in @xcite .
the study of this solution is necessarily more intricate , because the way in which the string approaches the boundary depends non - trivially on the @xmath180 rotation . in this case
it is convenient to use embedding coordinates .
again , the starting point of this calculation is the polyakov action in the conformal gauge , coupled to the metric and dilaton , @xmath252 = -g \int_{-s/2}^{s/2 } d\tau \int_{0}^{2\pi } d\sigma\,e^{\phi/2}\,\big[\eta^{\alpha\beta } \partial_{\alpha } y^{a}\partial_{\beta } y^{b}g_{ab}+\eta^{\alpha\beta}\partial_{\alpha } x^{i } \partial_{\beta } x^{j}\ , g_{ij}+ \\ \tilde{\lambda } \,(y^2 + 1)+\lambda\ , ( x^2 - 1)\big]\,,\ \ \ \ \label{eq : embedding}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where , as before , we have set the @xmath180 length and the radius of the @xmath181 to unity and @xmath253 is the embedding metric .
the classical solution representing a spinning string is given by @xmath254 , \nonumber \\ & y^2 + y^0= \cosh \rho _ 0 \left(\frac{r}{2}+\frac{e^{\kappa \tau } } { r}\right)\,,\qquad y^3-y^4 = e^{\kappa \tau } \cosh \rho _ 0\ , , \nonumber \\ & y^4 = \sinh \rho _ 0 \cos ( \tilde{\omega}\ , \tau+\sigma)\ , , \qquad y^1 = y^5 = 0\,,\qquad \tilde{\lambda } = -\kappa^2\ , , \nonumber\\ & x^1+i\ , x^2 = e^{i\ , ( \omega\,\tau-\sigma)}\ , , \qquad x^i = 0,\text { for } i > 2\ , , \qquad \lambda = \omega^2 - 1\,,\label{eq : tute}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath255 . the conserved charges of this solution can be readily obtained as functions of @xmath256 , @xmath257 and @xmath243 , and are given by @xmath258 , @xmath259 and @xmath260 , where @xmath235 , @xmath19 and @xmath261 are the angular momentum on the @xmath181 , angular momentum on the @xmath180 and energy , respectively .
this solution has the required boundary conditions if we further identify @xmath262 and @xmath263 where , as in @xcite , we have conveniently absorbed a factor of @xmath264 in @xmath162 . in order to calculate the 2-point function , we have to apply the procedure described in @xcite , which amounts to considering ( [ newaction ] ) instead of @xmath265 $ ] defined in ( [ eq : embedding ] ) .
note , however , that the @xmath180 part in ( [ eq : tute ] ) also depends on @xmath231 , which will lead to non - zero values of the zero - modes defined in ( [ zeromodes ] ) .
a computation shows that ( [ newaction ] ) becomes @xmath266= 4 \pi g \left[\kappa-\frac{s \sqrt{1-\kappa ^2}}{2 \pi g\kappa } -\frac{1}{\kappa}\left(1+\frac{j^2}{16 \pi^2 g^2}\right)\right]\log\frac{x_f}{\epsilon}\,.\ ] ] it will be more convenient to evaluate the saddle point with respect to @xmath243 instead of the modular parameter @xmath175 .
the saddle point in @xmath243 yields the following condition @xmath267 this condition is exactly the virasoro constraint for the spinning string ( [ eq : tute ] ) . at the saddle point
we recover the usual 2-point function behaviour @xmath268 } = \left(\frac{\epsilon}{x_f}\right)^{8 \pi g \left(\kappa _ s+\frac{s \kappa _ s}{4 \pi
g \sqrt{\kappa _ s^2 + 1}}\right)}\,,\ ] ] which gives the correct scaling dimension @xmath269 , where we have defined @xmath270 . note that in the @xmath271 limit we recover the circular spinning string of section 4.2 , as we should .
now we will obtain the 3-point function .
first we need to evaluate ( [ i_integral ] ) .
in contrast to the other cases , the integrand in this case strongly depends on @xmath231 , and the integrals might appear to be very complicated .
however , because we are integrating @xmath231 from @xmath272 to @xmath109 we can rewrite our integral as an integral in the complex plane by considering the complex variable @xmath273 .
the integral can then be computed using the residues theorem . for fixed wordsheet time @xmath212 , the integrand has two poles , one of which has zero residue and the other gives the relevant contribution .
the intermediate steps are too cumbersome to be presented here , so we just state the final result @xmath274 = -\frac{\delta_a}{4\pi^2 \kappa_s^2 } \left(1+\frac{s}{2\pi g \tilde{\omega}}\right)\frac{x_f^4}{y^4(x_f - y)^4}\,.\ ] ] therefore , we conclude that , to leading order in @xmath196 , _
a(0 ) o_a(x_f)l(y ) - . as happened in the previous cases ,
the spacetime dependence is the one required by conformal invariance .
moreover , to leading order in @xmath196 , the coupling @xmath15 determined in this way agrees with the rg expectation , since 2 ^2 a_laa = - g^2 - , where we kept the angular momenta @xmath19 and @xmath235 fixed when taking the derivative .
we used ( [ eq : saddlerot ] ) to determine @xmath275 , which leads to @xmath276 .
one of the present challenges in the gauge / gravity duality is to search for new techniques to compute correlation functions of single trace operators in @xmath4 sym , therefore leading to the exact solution of this theory possibly using integrability , at least in the planar limit .
this paper is focused on such new search , both at weak and strong coupling .
we started by presenting generic arguments based on the renormalization of operators when a cft is deformed by a marginal or irrelevant operator @xmath0 .
these arguments were independent of the value of the coupling at the cft fixed point ( a fixed line in the case of @xmath4 sym ) .
to linear order in the deformation parameter @xmath21 , we can write the anomalous dimension matrix as ^u = h + u h. we showed that the matrix element @xmath277 for two operators @xmath2 and @xmath3 is determined by the coupling @xmath1 .
for @xmath4 sym and at weak t hooft coupling , we can start by diagonalizing @xmath73 using integrability to some order in the coupling .
then the problem of computing @xmath1 amounts to determining the matrix elements @xmath277 .
we saw how to implement these ideas for the simplest case of the exact lagrangian deformation , where the action of the matrix @xmath278 on the basis of operators represented as a spin chain is known ( it is just the derivative with respect to the coupling of the anomalous dimension matrix at the critical point ) . in this case
one needs to compute the matrix elements of @xmath278 between bethe roots .
a very interesting open problem is to extend this procedure to other deformations , therefore allowing for a systematic computation of the couplings @xmath1 in perturbation theory using integrability .
when @xmath0 is a chiral operator in the same multiplet of the lagrangian , for example the energy - momentum tensor , we expect that the action of @xmath279 on the basis represented as a spin chain can be obtain acting with the supersymmetry algebra on @xmath278 .
it would be very interesting to see how far one can go with this type of approach .
the gauge / gravity duality can be used to compute @xmath4 sym correlation functions at strong coupling , but in practice one is limited to the supergravity approximation which only includes chiral operators .
we have improved on this limitation , by including two insertions of an operator dual to a heavy string state , and then studied the case of 3-point correlation functions with one extra chiral operator .
we considered specific examples with the lagrangian operator , checking agreement with the expected result from renormalization group arguments , since in this case the coupling @xmath15 is simply related to the derivative with respect to the t hooft coupling of @xmath11 .
this is an important check , since it gives confidence that the method can be applied to other chiral operators .
our computation of the string theory partition function is based on a saddle point approximation to the string path integral that describes the propagation of the heavy state , generalising the analysis of the 2-point function introduced in @xcite .
other chiral operators can be included because the heavy string acts as a tadpole for the supergravity fields , which may then propagate to the boundary of @xmath14 if sources are present therein .
an alternative way to think of this computation is to realise that the supergravity fields act as sources in the equations of motion for the worldsheet fields of the heavy string worldsheet , therefore deforming it .
in fact , the same occurs in the case of three large operators , whose 3-point function at strong coupling ought to be determined by a string worldsheet with fixed boundary condition on three points in the boundary of @xmath14 . in @xcite
this was shown to yield the correct conformal dependence of the 3-point function on the boundary points , but the evaluation of the coupling @xmath12 , related to the area of the string worlsheet minimal surface , is still an open problem .
it is expected that such computation will show a direct relation with integrability , but that remains to be seen . * acknowledgements * the authors are grateful to joo penedones and pedro vieira for helpful discussions .
we also thank konstantin zarembo for sharing with us a draft of his work @xcite , which has some overlap with section 4 of this article . m.s.c . wishes to thank nordita for hospitality during the programme _ integrability in string and gauge theories ; ads / cft duality and its applications_. d.z .
is funded by the fct fellowship sfrh / bpd/62888/2009 .
this work was partially funded by the research grants ptdc / fis/099293/2008 and cern / fp/109306/2009 .
centro de fsica do porto _ is partially funded by fct .
in this appendix we re - write the formulae of section 2 for the case of irrelevant deformations .
the main results for the renormalization of operators are essentially the same , so we shall be brief .
the first modification is that we must be careful with the running of the coupling @xmath21 , so that correlation functions involving a renormalized operator of the undeformed theory @xmath2 become @xmath280 where we work to linear order in the deformation parameter @xmath21 , as defined at the cut - off scale @xmath22 . using the ope expansion between @xmath0 and @xmath2 given in ( [ ope ] ) , we conclude that the region of integration @xmath40 contributes with @xmath281 for @xmath57 .
we renormalize the operators of the deformed theory according to @xmath282 so that the correlation functions @xmath283 are finite . with this prescription
the two - point function between operators @xmath284 remains the same .
this is expected because the deformation is irrelevant and therefore , to leading order in @xmath21 , it is not expected to change the anomalous dimension of operators .
we remark that the constant renormalization in ( [ irr_renormalized ] ) for @xmath44 guarantees that this two - point function remains diagonal and with the same normalization .
the above renormalization scheme corresponds to a renormalization matrix ( [ rmatrix ] ) with entries z_ab = _ ab + u 2 ^ 2 a_dab .
the corresponding anomalous dimension matrix @xmath58 defined in ( [ gamma ] ) is the same as for the marginal case given in ( [ deformedgamma ] ) .
the callan - symanzik equation will now include the running of the coupling @xmath21 .
for example , for 2-point functions we have @xmath285 with @xmath286 .
this equation is verified provided ( [ deformedgamma ] ) holds . finally , it is useful to define the renormalized operators starting from the undeformed bare theory . in this case
the renormalization matrix @xmath68 has entries _
ab = _ ab _ a+ u 2 ^ 2 a_dab .
the anomalous dimension matrix again has entries given by ( [ deformedh ] ) .
the relation between the entries of the deformed anomalous dimension matrix @xmath80 , computed in a diagonal basis of the anomalous dimension matrix of the critical theory , and the couplings @xmath1 is as for the marginal case presented at the end of section 2 .
i. bena , j. polchinski and r. roiban , phys .
d * 69 * ( 2004 ) 046002 [ arxiv : hep - th/0305116 ] .
j. a. minahan and k. zarembo , jhep * 0303 * ( 2003 ) 013 [ arxiv : hep - th/0212208 ] .
v. a. kazakov , a. marshakov , j. a. minahan and k. zarembo , jhep * 0405 * ( 2004 ) 024 [ arxiv : hep - th/0402207 ] .
n. beisert , v. dippel and m. staudacher , jhep * 0407 * , 075 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0405001 ] . g. arutyunov , s. frolov and m. staudacher , jhep * 0410 * ( 2004 ) 016 [ arxiv : hep - th/0406256 ] .
n. beisert and m. staudacher , nucl .
b * 727 * ( 2005 ) 1 [ arxiv : hep - th/0504190 ] .
n. beisert , adv .
* 12 * ( 2008 ) 945 [ arxiv : hep - th/0511082 ] .
r. a. janik , phys .
d * 73 * ( 2006 ) 086006 [ arxiv : hep - th/0603038 ] .
n. beisert , r. hernandez and e. lopez , jhep * 0611 * ( 2006 ) 070 [ arxiv : hep - th/0609044 ] .
n. beisert , b. eden and m. staudacher , j. stat .
mech . * 0701 * ( 2007 ) p021 [ arxiv : hep - th/0610251 ] . g. arutyunov and s. frolov , jhep * 0903 * ( 2009 ) 152 [ arxiv:0901.1417 [ hep - th ] ] .
n. gromov , v. kazakov and p. vieira , phys .
* 103 * ( 2009 ) 131601 [ arxiv:0901.3753 [ hep - th ] ] .
d. bombardelli , d. fioravanti and r. tateo , j. phys .
a * 42 * ( 2009 ) 375401 [ arxiv:0902.3930 [ hep - th ] ] .
n. gromov , v. kazakov , a. kozak and p. vieira , lett .
* 91 * ( 2010 ) 265 [ arxiv:0902.4458 [ hep - th ] ] . g. arutyunov and s. frolov , jhep * 0905 * ( 2009 ) 068 [ arxiv:0903.0141 [ hep - th ] ] .
g. arutyunov , s. frolov and r. suzuki , jhep * 1005 * ( 2010 ) 031 [ arxiv:0911.2224 [ hep - th ] ] . c. kristjansen , j. plefka , g. w. semenoff and m. staudacher , nucl .
b * 643 * , 3 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0205033 ] .
n. r. constable , d. z. freedman , m. headrick , s. minwalla , l. motl , a. postnikov and w. skiba , jhep * 0207 * , 017 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0205089 ] .
n. beisert , c. kristjansen , j. plefka , g. w. semenoff and m. staudacher , nucl .
b * 650 * , 125 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0208178 ] . k. okuyama and l. s. tseng , jhep * 0408 * , 055 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0404190 ]
. l. f. alday , j. r. david , e. gava and k. s. narain , jhep * 0509 * ( 2005 ) 070 [ arxiv : hep - th/0502186 ] .
y. casteill , r. a. janik , a. jarosz and c. kristjansen , jhep * 0712 * ( 2007 ) 069 [ arxiv:0710.4166 [ hep - th ] ] .
g. georgiou , v. l. gili and r. russo , jhep * 0910 * ( 2009 ) 009 [ arxiv:0907.1567 [ hep - th ] ] .
a. grossardt and j. plefka , arxiv:1007.2356 [ hep - th ] .
r. g. leigh and m. j. strassler , nucl .
b * 447 * ( 1995 ) 95 [ arxiv : hep - th/9503121 ] .
j. m. maldacena , adv .
theor . math .
* 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) [ int .
j. theor .
phys . * 38 * , 1113 ( 1999 ) ] [ arxiv : hep - th/9711200 ] .
s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov and a. m. polyakov , phys .
b * 428 * , 105 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9802109 ] .
e. witten , adv .
* 2 * , 253 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9802150 ] .
d. z. freedman , s. d. mathur , a. matusis and l. rastelli , nucl .
b * 546 * , 96 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9804058 ] .
s. lee , s. minwalla , m. rangamani and n. seiberg , adv .
* 2 * , 697 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9806074 ] .
g. arutyunov and s. frolov , phys .
d * 61 * , 064009 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9907085 ]
. s. lee , nucl .
b * 563 * ( 1999 ) 349 [ arxiv : hep - th/9907108 ] .
r. a. janik , p. surowka and a. wereszczynski , jhep * 1005 * ( 2010 ) 030 [ arxiv:1002.4613 [ hep - th ] ] .
e. i. buchbinder and a. a. tseytlin , jhep * 1008 * ( 2010 ) 057 [ arxiv:1005.4516 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov and a. m. polyakov , nucl .
b * 636 * ( 2002 ) 99 [ arxiv : hep - th/0204051 ] . s. frolov and a. a. tseytlin , nucl .
b * 668 * ( 2003 ) 77 [ arxiv : hep - th/0304255 ] ; jhep * 0206 * ( 2002 ) 007 [ arxiv : hep - th/0204226 ] .
a. a. tseytlin , [ arxiv : hep - th/0311139 ] .
k. zarembo , jhep * 1009 * ( 2010 ) 030 .
[ arxiv:1008.1059 [ hep - th ] ] .
d. z. freedman , m. headrick and a. lawrence , phys .
d * 73 * , 066015 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0510126 ] .
d. e. berenstein , j. m. maldacena and h. s. nastase , jhep * 0204 * ( 2002 ) 013 [ arxiv : hep - th/0202021 ] .
d. j. gross , a. mikhailov and r. roiban , annals phys .
* 301 * ( 2002 ) 31 [ arxiv : hep - th/0205066 ] .
a. santambrogio and d. zanon , phys .
b * 545 * ( 2002 ) 425 [ arxiv : hep - th/0206079 ] .
n. beisert , c. kristjansen and m. staudacher , nucl .
b * 664 * ( 2003 ) 131 [ arxiv : hep - th/0303060 ] .
m. staudacher , jhep * 0505 * , 054 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0412188 ] .
a. a. tseytlin , phys .
b * 251 * ( 1990 ) 530 .
d. m. hofman and j. m. maldacena , j. phys .
a * 39 * , 13095 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0604135 ] .
g. arutyunov , j. russo and a. a. tseytlin , phys .
d * 69 * ( 2004 ) 086009 [ arxiv : hep - th/0311004 ] . | we study the effect of marginal and irrelevant deformations on the renormalization of operators near a cft fixed point .
new divergences in a given operator are determined by its ope with the operator @xmath0 that generates the deformation .
this provides a scheme to compute the couplings @xmath1 between the operator @xmath0 and two arbitrary operators @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
we exemplify for the case of @xmath4 sym , considering the simplest case of the exact lagrangian deformation . in this case
the deformed anomalous dimension matrix is determined by the derivative of the anomalous dimension matrix with respect to the coupling .
we use integrability techniques to compute the one - loop couplings @xmath5 between the lagrangian and two distinct large operators built with magnons , in the su(2 ) sector of the theory .
then we consider @xmath6 at strong coupling , and show how to compute it using the gauge / gravity duality , when @xmath0 is a chiral operator dual to any supergravity field and @xmath2 is dual to a heavy string state .
we exemplify for the lagrangian and operators @xmath2 dual to heavy string states , showing agreement with the prediction derived from the renormalization group arguments .
miguel s. costa@xmath7 , ricardo monteiro@xmath8 , jorge e. santos@xmath8 , dimitrios
zoakos@xmath7 + _ @xmath9 centro de fsica do porto + departamento de fsica e astronomia + faculdade de cincias da universidade do porto + rua do campo alegre 687 , 4169007 porto , portugal _ + _
@xmath10damtp , centre for mathematical sciences + university of cambridge + wilberforce road , cambridge cb3 0wa , uk _ |
the standard model ( sm ) had been tested in many experiments at lep , slc and tevatron with a high accuracy .
in particular , the yield of lepton pairs produced mainly via drell - yan processes , i.e. quark - antiquark annihilation by exchange of photons or z bosons , is predicted by the sm with a per mille precision .
so far , the experimental data have shown no significant deviations from sm predictions for the drell - yan continuum up to tev - energy - scale .
the high - order calculations of lepton pair production cross section in the mass region of @xmath0 tev/@xmath1 are in good agreement with lep and d0 data @xcite . at present , however , there are many theoretical attempts to extend the bounds of the sm in order to reach unification of strong and electroweak interactions or remove an arbitrariness in values of coupling constants in some other way and also to pull through known disadvantages of sm like the mass hierarchy problem , cp - violation problem etc .
supersymmetry is the most popular theoretical extension of the sm , however , some other alternatives also exist . between them
one can consider extended gauge models ( what contain extended sector of gauge bosons in comparison with the sm ) .
consideration of symmetry groups wider than in the sm and appearance of extra gauge bosons is common feature of various left - right symmetric models , all variants of grand unification theories and models of composite gauge bosons @xcite .
for all of these cases new vector bosons , neutral @xmath2 and charged @xmath3 , would appear at the mass scale of order of one tev/@xmath4 what can be observed at the lhc . another alternative way to go beyond
the sm can be to consider so - called tev - scale gravity models , as given by brane world scenarios with large or compact extra spatial dimensions ( led ) @xcite .
these models give in particular a set of new particle - massive kaluza - klein modes of graviton what can interact with the usual matter and contribute to the sm processes causing some new interesting physics at the tev energy scale ( for more details and a phenomenology review see , for example @xcite ) . in our consideration
we touch on only one of the possible led scenarios , the randall - sundrum ( rs1 ) approach @xcite .
the standard setup for this approach contains two three - branes embedded into the external curve five - dimensional space , one brane is with negative tension ( our world with all usual sm fields ) and another one is with positive tension ( planckian brane ) what is needed to reproduce the sm mass hierarchy .
the usual assumption is that all the sm fields and fields from the planckian sector are confined on corresponding branes and effectively four - dimensional .
graviton is only really multidimensional field what can travel freely through the whole space ( the bulk space ) . because of nonzero curvature of the bulk space
( what is represented by a slice of the five - dimensional ads space bounded by two branes ) and the specific space - time geometry new very interesting physics can be realized at our brane . in particular
, in any model with compact extra spatial dimensions each matter field will have an infinite tower of massive excitations called kaluza - klein modes ( four - dimensional `` projections '' of multidimensional fields from our point of view ) .
these modes can be visible at energy above the fundamental theory scale , say , from energies above one or a few tev .
then our usual massless four - dimensional graviton can be treated as the zero mode from the kk - tower .
but the distinctive feature of particular rs1 phenomenology is that excited massive graviton states are strongly coupled to ordinary particles ( not suppressed below the planckian scale like for ordinary graviton in usual description of gravity ) and can contribute significantly to the sm processes above the fundamental scale .
mass splitting between kk - modes of graviton is of order @xmath5 @xcite , and values of masses start from the tev scale .
so , at least the first kaluza - klein mode ( called rs1 graviton below ) can in principle be observed at the lhc as individual heavy ( quite narrow or not ) resonance . at this point
it is interesting to note that there exist also some realizations of tev - scale gravity models where fields other than graviton can have kaluza - klein modes , see for example a number of papers @xcite . in the papers
interesting scenarios based on superstring theory were proposed in which all gauge bosons and higgses as far as their superpartners had kk - excitations .
we will not touch on such scenarios in our further discussion but we would stress that study of phenomenological consequences of the existence of kk - modes of @xmath6 or photon can be done exactly in the same spirit as it is presented in subsections 2.1 2.2 below for @xmath2 including an asymmetry analysis . for both of the conceptions considered , @xmath2 and rs1 graviton , a width of predicted resonances is not fixed but it can vary widely depending on the model parameters .
it implies that these states can appear as individual resonances or can affect the high-@xmath7 lepton pair continuum leading to an excess of drell - yan production .
thus , the distinctive experimental signature for these processes is a pair of well - isolated high-@xmath7 leptons with opposite charges coming from the same vertex .
such the measurements can be performed at the both of lhc experiments , atlas and cms , which are expected to be able to trigger and identify hard muons with a transverse momentum up to several tev .
the ability of the lhc experiments to detect rs1 graviton in the dielectron mode was investigated as described in ref .
@xcite . in this paper
, we present the analysis of the lhc discovery limit on @xmath2 and rs1 gravitons in dimuon mode in assumption of the cms acceptance .
the signal simulation is done for the parton subprocess @xmath8 in the leading order of qcd without higher order corrections . to generate @xmath2 boson and its decay to a muon pair as well as
the relevant background events , the pythia 6.217 package @xcite with the cteq5l parton distribution function was used .
there exist a number of possible non standard model scenarios which predict appearance of heavy neutral @xmath2 and/or charged @xmath3 gauge bosons ( for review see @xcite ) .
but only following @xmath2 models were used in our analysis : 1 .
the left - right model ( lr ) @xcite based on the electroweak gauge group symmetry @xmath9 with an additional left - right symmetry ( here , @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the baryon and lepton numbers ) with default pythia couplings which are the same for both left- and right - handed type of fermions and are set to the same values as in the sm , @xmath12 = @xmath13 = 0.64 .
the number of extra fermion generations is equal to three . 2 .
@xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 - models which naturally arise as a result of sequential breaking of so(10 ) or @xmath17 symmetry group in grand unified theories ( gut ) @xcite : @xmath18 @xmath19 .
the linear combination of the hypercharges under the two groups @xmath20 gives the charge of the lightest @xmath2 at the symmetry - breaking energies @xmath2 = @xmath21 .
numerical values of the couplings for these models are taken from ref .
3 . for monte
carlo studies the sequential standard model ( ssm ) @xcite was also used in which heavy bosons ( @xmath2 and @xmath3 ) are assumed to couple only to one fermion type ( left ) with the same parameters ( couplings and total widths ) as for ordinary @xmath22 and @xmath23 in the standard model .
the non - reducible background considered is the sm drell - yan process @xmath24 which gives nearly 95 @xmath25 of the standard model muon continuum .
contributions from other reaction ( vector boson pair production @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , quark - antiquark production @xmath29 etc ) are very small and neglected in this study . in the sm
the expected number of dimuon events is not very large and the @xmath2 resonance peak exceeds the background by above a factor ten ( fig . [ fig1 ] , the left plot ) .
the mass dependence of @xmath2 production cross secrion times on dimuon branching are given in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( the right plot ) . for comparison
the cross section for standard drell - yan muon pair production as a function of their invarinat masses is also presented on the same figure .
event samples for seven mass values were generated with above - mentioned model parameters .
to take into account the detector response the parametrization of a muon momentum ( @xmath30 ) resolution , 4@xmath25/@xmath31 @xcite , was used .
the dimuon is accepted when both decay muons are within detector system covering the pseudorapidity region of @xmath32@xmath33@xmath32 @xmath34 2.4 .
in addition , the cut @xmath35 gev / c was applied on each muon .
no cuts were made on isolation of muons in the tracker and the calorimeter .
the total efficiency dimuon selection , @xmath36 , is about @xmath37 @xmath25 . to estimate the @xmath2 discovery limit expected significance of the signal , @xmath38=@xmath39-@xmath40 ,
was computed , where @xmath41 is the number of signal events passed through all kinematics cuts and @xmath10 is the number of background events .
the discovery limits for a five @xmath42 signal are presented in fig .
[ fig2 ] .
detection of the @xmath2 peak itself and precise measurement of its mass and width does not allow an underlying theoretical model describing the @xmath2 to be identified . to test a helicity structure of the boson and
discriminate between a number of @xmath2 models , a leptonic forward - backward asymmetry can be used ( see , for example , @xcite ) .
the asymmetry is defined as the ratio @xmath43 , where @xmath44 and @xmath10 are the numbers of events in the forward and backward directions , respectively .
forward ( backward ) is defined as the hemisphere with @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) , where @xmath47 is an angle between the outgoing negative lepton and the quark @xmath48 in the @xmath49 rest frame .
such a definition assumes that the original quark direction is known , but this is not the case for the pp - experiment . in ref .
@xcite , however , it was shown that it is possible to identify the quark direction with the boost direction of the dimuon system with respect to the beam axis .
one of the features of the asymmetry , @xmath50 , is the distinctive rapidity - dependence for different @xmath2 models .
such a dependence is shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] for the @xmath51 ( the left picture ) and the @xmath52 ( the right picture ) under assumption of a mass @xmath53 = 2.0 tev/@xmath4 , for 100 @xmath54 of an integrated luminosity .
logic of such an analysis looks quite consequent but it is not complete in general as another one possibility is not accounted by it . as it was yet pointed out ( see comments on the theme in introduction above ) one can image a situation when we will see a resonance at collider with a mass about tev and quantum numbers of gauge boson what can be in principle not @xmath2 from the extended gauge sector but kaluza - klein excitation @xmath55 coming from models with extra spatial dimensions . the only way to distinguish these quite different cases when will be to look for other kk - excitations of other gauge bosons ( photon , gluon ) what must exist in the presence of extra dimensions @xcite .
as it was mentioned above the rs1 model predicts massive kk - modes of graviton ( @xmath56 a few tev ) which can been observed in experiments as heavy narrow resonance states ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ) .
it is necessary to note here that an effect from kk - gravitons can also been extracted from changing of higgs boson rates because of mixing of them with radion ( see ref .
@xcite ) the ability to test experimentally rs1 scenario predictions depends on the model parameter @xmath57 which controls coupling of graviton to the ordinary particles and a width of the resonance @xmath58@xmath59@xmath60 ; where the constant @xmath61 is determined by the number of open decay channels .
results of the combined analysis in the rs1 scenario @xcite show that a value of the dimensionless coupling constant @xmath62 and a corresponding value of graviton mass is restricted due to the experimental tevatron data and theoretical constraints to assure the model hierarchy ( @xmath63 @xmath64 10 tev ) .
these limitations lead , in particular , to the conclusion that the constant @xmath62 can not be less than 0.027 , for the graviton mass of one tev/@xmath4 , and less than 0.1 , for the mass of 3.7 tev/@xmath4 .
we operated in our consideration the range for coupling constant @xmath65 .
graviton resonances can be produced via quark - antiquark annihilation @xmath66 as well as gluon - gluon fusion @xmath67 .
the first of these processes is identical to the standard model s - channel exchange by an intermediate @xmath68 or @xmath69 vector boson , while the second one has no sm analogue .
other partonic sub - processes are also possible , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , which form real graviton production via the @xmath73-channel exchange ( graviton emission ) . to simulate both real and virtual graviton production in the proton - proton collisions at 14 tev center - of - mass energy , pythia 6.217
was used in which the rs1 scenario was implemented with cteq5l parton distribution functions .
the graviton production cross section for all five possible diagrams is presented in table [ rs1_crs ] . here , two extreme possibilities for model parameter @xmath62 were considered .
the first one was the most optimistic scenario when @xmath62 is equal to 0.1 .
the second number in each row ( in brackets ) corresponds to the most difficult for experimental observation case when the coupling value @xmath62 = 0.01 . the majority ( at least 50@xmath7460 @xmath25 depending on a mass ) of gravitons was produced in the process of gluon - gluon fusion with real graviton emission , whereas virtual graviton production added only up to 15 @xmath25 of the total cross - section .
the standard model background for this channel was the same as for the @xmath2 case .
.[rs1_crs ] leading - order cross section of @xmath75 production in fb .
the cteq5l parton distributions have been used . [
cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] simulation of the detector response for graviton decay into muon pair is similar to the @xmath2 case . to estimate the discovery limit for
rs1 graviton excitations the same procedure as for the @xmath2 case was applied .
the cross section of @xmath76 production and corresponding cross section limits to observe a five @xmath42 signal for various integrated luminosity cases are presented in fig .
as shown in the figure , the lhc can test the rs1 scenario in the whole range of the model parameter @xmath62 up to the mass of 2.0 tev/@xmath4 even at the low luminosity of 10 @xmath54 . in the more favourable case with @xmath62 = 0.1 the accessible mass region
is extended up to 3.7 tev/@xmath4 . with 100 @xmath54 of integrated luminosity
the reach increases up to 2.6 tev/@xmath4 for @xmath62=0.01 and 4.8 tev/@xmath4 for @xmath62=0.1 . the direct comparison of results on an allowed region for @xmath62 with the data of the fig .
[ fig5 ] shows that the whole space of the rs1-model parameters is accessible at the luminosity of 100 @xmath54 , and rs1 graviton can be discovered with the five @xmath42 significance .
these conclusions , however , are not definitive , since initial theoretical constraints are very arbitrary . under the assumption that a new resonance state was observed at the lhc , nature of this object should be understood in further analysis ( in principle , the resonance can come from the extended gauge sector as well as from some version of extra dimension models ) .
the major difference between @xmath2 and rs1 graviton should appear in the @xmath77 distribution ( where @xmath78 is the polar angle of muons in the center - of - mass system of the dimuon pair ) which is strongly spin dependent .
course , these distributions will be distorted by acceptance cuts , especially in the region of large angles , and expected theoretical predictions will differ from experimental ones . nevertheless fig .
[ fig6 ] shows the distinct difference between the spin-1 ( @xmath2 ) and the spin-2 ( rs1 graviton ) curves obtained for muons after all cuts . to ease the comparison ,
these plots were obtained for resonance states with the same masses of 1.5 tev/@xmath4 and normalized to 6000 events that correspond to the approximate integrated luminosity of 10 @xmath54 for graviton production with @xmath62=0.1 and 100 @xmath54 for @xmath2 boson .
in this work we present the discovery potential of @xmath2 gauge bosons as well as rs1 gravitons in the muon channel at the lhc experiments .
the estimated discovery limit for @xmath2 is about @xmath79 tev/@xmath4 depending on the couplings for 100 @xmath54 integrated luminosity . at the same luminosity
the first kk - mode of rs1 graviton can be observed up to the mass values of 2.6 tev/@xmath1 and 4.8 tev/@xmath4 for @xmath62 = 0.01 and 0.1 , respectively .
the angular distribution of muons in the final state can be used to distinguish the spin-1 and the spin-2 resonance states , at least in the mass region up to 2.3 tev/@xmath4 .
the different @xmath2 models can be distinguished ( up to the mass value of 2.5 tev/@xmath4 ) using the leptonic forward - backward asymmetry .
further detailed studies are required on the theoretical side in order to identify other possible physics observables .
this would be helpful to better understand the lhc discovery conditions and limits .
m. cvetic and s. godfrey , summary of the working subgroup on extra gauge bosons of the pdf long - range planning study to electro - weak symmetry breaking and beyond standard model , eds .
t. barklow et al . , world scientific , 1995 ; hep - ph/9504216 ; t.g .
rizzo , proceedings of the 1996 dpf / dpb summer study on new directions for high energy physics - snowmass96 , snowmass , co , 25 june - 12 july , 1996 .
n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , and g. dvali `` the hierarchy problem and new dimensions at a millimeter '' , phys .
lett . b429
( 1998 ) 263 , hep - ph/9803315 ; i. antoniadis , n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , and g. dvali `` new dimensions at a millimeter to a fermi and superstrings at a tev '' , phys .
lett . b436
( 1998 ) 257 , hep - ph/9804398 .
+ _ phenomenology and astrophysics limits of the model can be found in _ + n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , and g. dvali `` phenomenology , astrophysics and cosmology of theories with sub - millimeter dimensions and tev scale quantum gravity '' , phys .
d59 ( 1999 ) 086004 , hep - ph/9807344 .
+ _ superstring realization of the model can be found in _
+ d. cremades , l.e .
ibanez , f. marchesano `` standard model at intersecting d5-branes : lowering the string scale '' , nucl .
b643 ( 2002 ) 93 , hep - th/0205074 ; c. kokorelis `` exact standard model structures from intersecting d5-branes '' , nucl.phys .
b677 ( 2004 ) 115 , hep - th/0207234 .
l. randall and r. sundrum `` a large mass hierarchy from a small extra dimension '' , phys .
83 ( 1999 ) 3370 , hep - ph/9905221 ; `` an alternative to compactification '' , phys
83 ( 1999 ) 4690 , hep - th/9906064 .
i. antoniadis `` a possible new dimension at a few tev '' , phys .
b246 ( 1990 ) 377 ; i. antoniadis and k. benakli `` limits on extra dimensions in orbifold compactifications of superstrings '' , phys .
b326 ( 1994 ) 69 ; i. antoniadis , k. benakli and m. quiros `` production of kaluza - klein states at future colliders '' , phys . lett .
b331 ( 1994 ) 313 .
k. huitu , j. maalampi , a. pietila , m. raidal `` doubly charged higgs at lhc '' , nucl .
b487 ( 1997 ) 27 , hep - ph/9606311 ; f. feruglio , l. maiani , and a. masiero `` right - handed vector bosons in p anti - p collisions as a source of anomalous events '' , phys . lett . b233
( 1998 ) 512 .
wells `` extra dimensions and the universal suppression of higgs boson observables at high energy collaiders '' , hep - ph/0205328 , to appear in the proceedings of the 10th intl .
`` supersymmetry and unification of fundamental interactions ( susy-02 ) '' , 17 - 23 june 2002 , hamburg , germany . | in this article we carry out an analysis of lhc potential to search for new dimuon resonance states from extended gauge models and the randall - sundrum scenario of tev - scale gravity . * search for new heavy resonances at the lhc * + i. golutvin , , m. savina , s. shmatov + jonit institute for nuclear research , dubna , russia + |
there are many problems concerning electronic structure where attention is focussed on a small region of a larger system , at surfaces or defects in crystals being perhaps the most common .
let us call this region i , figure [ fig:1 ] , and the rest of the system region ii .
although not of primary interest region ii can not be ignored , since in general the electron wave functions in i will be sensitive to the contents of region ii .
some time ago inglesfield @xcite derived an embedding scheme which enables the single - particle schrdinger equation to be solved explicitly only in region i. the influence of region ii is taken into account exactly by adding an energy - dependent non - local potential to the hamiltonian for region i , which constrains the solutions in i to match onto solutions in ii .
this embedding method has been developed into a powerful tool most notably for surface electronic structure problems @xcite where it has found widespread application especially to situations where an accurate description of the spectrum of electron states is necessary .
examples include studies of image states @xcite , surface states at metals surfaces @xcite , static and dynamic screening @xcite , atomic adsorption and scattering at surfaces @xcite , studies of surface optical response @xcite and field emission @xcite .
recent applications to transport problems have also been described @xcite . for a review of the embedding method
see inglesfield @xcite .
= 80 mm in the case of materials containing heavier elements , relativistic effects can be significant @xcite and lead to important deviations from the electronic structure as predicted by the schrdinger equation shifts in inner core levels of 5d elements are typically several 100 or 1000 ev , valence bands shifts are on the ev scale and spin orbit splitting is often measured in tenths of ev . even ignoring the concomitant changes in electron wave functions these shifts can reorder levels and so affect calculated densities , fundamental to the determination of ground state properties within the density functional framework @xcite .
for this reason most of the conventional electronic structure techniques developed for accurately solving the single - particle schrdinger equation in solids have subsequently been modified to deal with the dirac equation , including the relativistic augmented plane wave method @xcite , relativistic linear muffin - tin orbital method @xcite , relativistic augmented spherical wave method @xcite and the relativistic multiple - scattering method @xcite , and each has subsequently been used in studying a diverse range of problems .
the last method alone has formed the basis of calculations of photoemission @xcite , magnetocrystalline anisotropy @xcite , hyperfine interactions @xcite and magnetotransport @xcite amongst other topics .
inglesfield s embedding method has particular advantages that encourage its extension to the relativistic case .
it permits the inclusion of extended substrates for surface and interface calculations , enables the study of isolated point defects in solids and being a basis set technique is highly flexible and permits full - potential studies with relative ease . at surfaces extended substrates ( as against the use of the supercell or thin - film approximation in which the crystal is approximated by a small number of layers , typically 5 - 7 ) enable the proper distinction between surface states , resonances and the continuum of bulk states @xcite .
the behaviour of the w(110 ) surface @xcite where the addition of half a monolayer of li is observed to _ increase _ the spin - orbit splitting of a surface state by @xmath2 ev ( resulting in fermi surface crossings separated by @xmath3% of the brillouin zone dimension ) typifies a type of problem a relativistic embedding scheme could address .
indeed each of the topics mentioned at the end of the previous paragraph are relevant at surfaces and/or interfaces , and could be usefully investigated within a relativistic embedding framework . in this paper
we develop an embedding scheme for the dirac equation that parallels inglesfield s scheme for the schrdinger equation .
inglesfield s starting point is the expectation value of the hamiltonian using a trial wave function which is continuous in amplitude but discontinuous in derivative across the surface @xmath1 separating i and ii .
the first order nature of the dirac equation precludes the use of a similar trial function .
instead , in the following section we use a trial function in which the large component is continuous and the small component discontinuous across @xmath1 .
continuity in the small component is restored when the resulting equations are solved exactly . using the green function for region
ii we are able to derive an expression for the expectation value purely in terms of the trial function in i. in section [ section : app ] the application of the method is illustrated by calculating the eigenstates of a hydrogen atom within a cavity and in section [ section : green ] we determine the green function for the embedded region .
section [ section : monolayer ] briefly illustrates the method applied to a sandwich structure where relativistic effects are marked .
we conclude with a brief summary and discussion .
in this section we consider region i joined onto region ii ( figure [ fig:1 ] ) , and derive a variational principle for a trial wave function @xmath4 defined explicitly only within region i. we are primarily interested in the positive energy solutions of the dirac equation @xcite , and so we refer to the upper and lower spinors of the dirac bi - spinor solutions as the large and small components of the wave function respectively .
we notionally extend @xmath4 into ii as @xmath5 , an exact solution of the dirac equation at some energy @xmath6 , with the large components of @xmath4 and @xmath5 ( @xmath7 and @xmath8 ) matching on the surface @xmath1 separating i and ii , but with no constraint upon the small components ( @xmath9 and @xmath10 ) , figure [ fig:2 ] .
the expectation value for the energy @xmath11 is then @xmath12 } { \langle\varphi|\varphi\rangle_{\mathrm{i}}+ \langle\chi|\chi\rangle_{\mathrm{ii } } } \label{eqn : exp}\ ] ] where @xmath13 .
( for clarity we omit the interaction @xmath14 which appears in the relativistic density functional theory @xcite neglecting orbital and displacement currents , where @xmath15 is a `` spin - only '' effective magnetic field containing an external and exchange - correlation contribution .
its inclusion has no consequences for the derivation . )
the first two terms in the numerator are the expectation value of the hamiltonian through regions i and ii , and the third the contribution due to the discontinuity in the small component of the wave function on @xmath1 ( in this and the following , surface normals are directed from i to ii ) .
= 60 mm we eliminate reference to @xmath5 by introducing two relations .
firstly , for @xmath16 , @xmath5 satisfies the dirac equation at energy @xmath6 @xmath17\chi=0 \label{eqn : dirii}\ ] ] and differentiating with respect to @xmath6 the energy derivative of @xmath5 , @xmath18 , satisfies @xmath19\dot{\chi}=\chi\qquad \bi{r}\in\mathrm{ii}. \label{eqn : eder}\ ] ] multiplying the hermitian conjugate of the first equation by @xmath20 from the right , multiplying the second from the left by @xmath21 , subtracting and integrating over region ii gives a relation between the normalisation of @xmath5 in ii and the amplitude on @xmath1 : @xmath22 we have assumed that @xmath5 vanishes sufficiently strongly at infinity . for the second relation
we introduce the green function ( resolvant ) @xmath23 corresponding to equation ( [ eqn : dirii ] ) : @xmath24g=-\delta(\bi{r}-\bi{r } ' ) \qquad \bi{r},\bi{r}'\in \mathrm{ii}. \label{eqn : gf}\ ] ] multiplying the hermitian conjugate of this equation by @xmath5 from the right , and subtracting @xmath25 times equation ( [ eqn : dirii ] ) , integrating over region ii and then using the reciprocity of the green function gives @xmath26 we see that the green function relates the amplitude of the wave function on @xmath1 to the amplitude at any point within ii .
in particular , we can obtain a relation between the large and small components of @xmath5 on s. writing the @xmath27 green function as @xmath28 where each entry is a @xmath29 matrix , substituting into equation ( [ eqn : chis ] ) , and rearranging the two equations coupling the small and large components of @xmath5 gives @xmath30 where @xmath31 it follows from ( [ eqn : chis ] ) that the green functions in ( [ eqn : gam ] ) are the limiting forms of @xmath32 as @xmath33 from within ii .
equations ( [ eqn : norm ] ) and ( [ eqn : cgc ] ) are the desired results that enable us to express the expectation value @xmath11 in ( [ eqn : exp ] ) in terms of @xmath4 alone .
after substitution and use of the continuity of the large components @xmath34 on @xmath1 we obtain @xmath35 } { \langle\varphi|\varphi\rangle_{\mathrm{i}}- c^2\hbar^2 \int_s \rmd\bi{r}_s\cdot \varphi_{\rm l}^\dag \bsigma \int_s \rmd\bi{r}'_s \cdot \dot{\gamma } \bsigma\ , \varphi_{\rm l } } .
\label{eqn : exp2}\ ] ] this is an expression for the expectation value of the energy @xmath11 , given purely in terms of the trial function @xmath4 in region i and on the surface @xmath1 , with all details of region ii entering via @xmath36 and its energy derivative . following the convention in the non - relativistic embedding scheme we shall refer to @xmath36 as the embedding potential . to see what this variational principle means in practice , we consider variations in @xmath37 , whereby @xmath38 } { \langle\varphi|\varphi\rangle_{\mathrm{i}}- c^2\hbar^2\int_s \rmd\bi{r}_s\cdot \varphi_{\rm l}^\dag \bsigma \int_s \rmd\bi{r}'_s \cdot \dot{\gamma } \bsigma\ , \varphi_{\rm l } } , \nonumber\\ \label{eqn : de1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] so that solutions @xmath4 stationary with respect to arbitrary variations @xmath39 satisfy @xmath40 the first expression indicates @xmath4 is a solution of the dirac equation at energy @xmath11 in region i. comparing the second with ( [ eqn : cgc ] ) shows that @xmath4 also possesses the correct relationship between large and small components on @xmath1 , the surface separating i and ii , to match onto solutions in ii .
the term @xmath41 provides a first order correction to @xmath42 so that the boundary condition is appropriate for energy @xmath11 . in practice expression ( [ eqn : exp2 ] ) may be used to obtain solutions of the dirac hamiltonian by inserting a suitably parameterised trial function and varying the parameters to obtain a stationary solution .
this is conveniently achieved by expanding the trial solution in a finite basis of separate large and small component spinors @xmath43 + \sum_{n=1}^{n_{\rm s } } a_{{\rm s},n } \left[\begin{array}{c}0\\ \psi_{{\rm s},n}(\bi{r})\end{array}\right ] = \left[\begin{array}{cc } \bpsi_{\rm l}(\bi{r } ) & 0 \\ 0 & \bpsi_{\rm s}(\bi{r } ) \end{array}\right ] \left [ \begin{array}{c } \bi{a}_{\rm l } \\ \bi{a}_{\rm s } \end{array } \right].\ ] ] the matrix in the final expression is @xmath44 by @xmath45 , and the column vector contains the @xmath45 coefficients .
substituting into ( [ eqn : exp2 ] ) we find states @xmath46 that are stationary with respect to variations in the expansion coefficients @xmath47 are then given by the eigenstates of a generalised eigenvalue problem of the form @xmath48 \left [ \begin{array}{c } \bi{a}_{\rm l } \\
\bi{a}_{\rm s } \end{array } \right ] = w \left [ \begin{array}{cc } { o}_{\rm ll } & 0 \\ 0 & { o}_{\rm ss } \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array}{c } \bi{a}_{\rm l } \\
\bi{a}_{\rm s } \end{array } \right ] , \label{eqn : a1}\ ] ] where @xmath49_{nn'}= \int_i \psi_{{\rm l},n}^\dag(\bi{r } ) \left(v(\bi{r})+mc^2 \right ) \psi_{{\rm l},n'}(\bi{r } ) \rmd\bi{r } \nonumber \\
\fl \phantom{\left[{h}_{\rm ll}\right]_{nn'}=}{}+c^2\hbar^2\!\int_s \rmd\bi{r}_s\cdot \psi_{{\rm l},n}^\dag(\bi{r}_s)\bsigma\ ! \int_s \rmd\bi{r}'_s \!\cdot\ ! \left [ \gamma(\bi{r}_s,\bi{r}'_s;w)\ ! - \ !
w \dot{\gamma}(\bi{r}_s,\bi{r}'_s;w)\right ] \bsigma\psi_{{\rm l},n'}(\bi{r}'_s ) \label{eqn : h2}\\ \fl \left[{h}_{\rm ls}\right]_{nn'}= \int_i \psi_{{\rm l},n}^\dag(\bi{r } ) c\bsigma\cdot \widehat{\bi{p } } \psi_{{\rm s},n'}(\bi{r } ) \rmd\bi{r}+\rmi c\hbar\int_s \rmd\bi{r}_s\cdot \psi_{{\rm l},n}^\dag(\bi{r}_s)\bsigma\psi_{{\rm s},n'}(\bi{r}_s)\label{eqn : h3}\\ \fl \left[{h}_{\rm sl}\right]_{nn'}= \int_i \psi_{{\rm s},n}^\dag(\bi{r } ) c\bsigma\cdot\widehat{\bi{p } } \psi_{{\rm l},n'}(\bi{r } ) \rmd\bi{r } \label{eqn : h4}\\ \fl \left[{h}_{\rm ss}\right]_{nn'}= \int_i \psi_{{\rm s},n}^\dag(\bi{r } ) \left(v(\bi{r})-mc^2 \right ) \psi_{{\rm s},n'}(\bi{r } ) \rmd\bi{r } \label{eqn : h5}\\ \fl \left[{o}_{\rm ll}\right]_{nn'}= \int_i \psi_{{\rm l},n}^\dag(\bi{r } ) \psi_{{\rm s},n'}(\bi{r } ) \rmd\bi{r}\nonumber\\ \fl \phantom{\left[{o}_{\rm ll}\right]_{nn'}= } { } -c^2\hbar^2\int_s \rmd\bi{r}_s\cdot \psi_{{\rm l},n}^\dag(\bi{r}_s)\bsigma \int_s \rmd\bi{r}'_s \cdot \dot{\gamma}(\bi{r}_s,\bi{r}'_s;w ) \bsigma\psi_{{\rm l},n'}(\bi{r}'_s ) \label{eqn : h6}\\ \fl \left[{o}_{\rm ss}\right]_{nn'}= \int_i \psi_{{\rm s},n}^\dag(\bi{r } ) \psi_{{\rm s},n'}(\bi{r } ) \rmd\bi{r}.\label{eqn : h7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] of course the spectrum of the dirac hamiltonian is unbounded below , and care must be taken to prevent solutions collapsing to negative energies .
this can be avoided through the use of a kinetically balanced basis @xcite in which there is a one - to - one relationship between large and small component spinors , @xmath50 , and where the small component spinors are given by @xmath51 the upper half of the spectrum of the @xmath52 eigenstates of ( [ eqn : a1 ] ) then provide approximations to the spectrum of electronic states .
= 80 mm to illustrate the application of the relativistic embedding scheme we consider a model problem of a hydrogen atom within a spherical cavity , finding bound states of the dirac equation corresponding to the potential illustrated in figure [ fig:3 ] : @xmath53 where @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
we choose this model as the bound states may also be found straightforwardly by alternative methods .
region i , the region to be treated explicitly , is the sphere of radius @xmath56 centered on @xmath57 .
the external region ii where @xmath58 is replaced by an embedding potential acting on the surface of the sphere .
the value of the embedding potential is most readily evaluated from equation ( [ eqn : cgc ] ) . a general solution to the dirac equation at some energy @xmath6 in region
ii and satisfying the appropriate boundary conditions is @xcite @xmath59 where @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 a spin - angular function , @xmath63 a modified spherical bessel function of the third kind @xcite , @xmath64 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 the spherical symmetry of region ii means the the embedding potential @xmath36 may be expanded on @xmath1 as @xmath67 and substituting ( [ eqn : a2b ] ) and ( [ eqn : a2 ] ) into ( [ eqn : cgc ] ) leads to @xmath68 using ( [ eqn : gam ] ) with the green function for constant potential ( @xmath69 ) @xmath70 gives the same result but after rather more involved manipulations .
@xmath71 is a modified spherical bessel function of the first kind . because of the spherical symmetry we can determine separately states with a given angular character @xmath72 . using as a basis set for the large component spinors @xmath73 so that the small component spinors ensuring kinetic balance are @xmath74 e^{-r } , \label{eqn : bas2}\ ] ] the matrix elements become @xmath75_{nn'}= \int_0^r g_{n}(r)\left[-\frac{\lambda}{r}+mc^2\right ] g_{n'}(r ) \rmd r
\nonumber\\ + \hbar^2c^2r^2g_{n}(r)g_{n'}(r ) \left[\gamma_\kappa(w)-w\dot{\gamma}_\kappa(w)\right ] \\
\fl \left[{h}^{(\lambda)}_{\rm ss}\right]_{nn'}= \int_0^rf_{n\kappa}(r)\left[-\frac{\lambda}{r}-mc^2\right]f_{n'\kappa}(r ) \rmd r\\ \fl \left[{h}^{(\lambda)}_{\rm ls}\right]_{nn'}=-\hbar c
\int_0^r g_{n}(r)\left[\frac{\rmd f_{n'\kappa}(r)}{\rmd r}- \frac{\kappa}{r}f_{n'\kappa}(r)\right ] \rmd r + \hbar c g_{n}(r)f_{n'\kappa}(r)\\ \fl \left[{h}^{(\lambda)}_{\rm sl}\right]_{nn'}=\hbar c
\int_0^r f_{n\kappa}(r)\left[\frac{\rmd g_{n'}(r)}{\rmd r}+ \frac{\kappa}{r}g_{n'}(r)\right ] \rmd r \\
\fl \left[{o}^{(\lambda)}_{\rm ll}\right]_{nn'}= \int_0^r g_n(r)g_{n'}(r ) \rmd r -\hbar^2c^2r^2g_n(r)g_{n'}(r)\dot{\gamma}_\kappa(w )
\\ \fl \left[{o}^{(\lambda)}_{\rm ss}\right]_{nn'}= \int_0^r f_{n\kappa}(r)f_{n'\kappa}(r ) \rmd r\end{aligned}\ ] ] the eigenvalues only depend upon the quantum number @xmath76 . in table
[ table:1 ] the lowest two eigenvalues of @xmath77 symmetry ( corresponding to the @xmath78 and @xmath79 of free hydrogen ) are shown as a function of basis set size and for different values of the energy @xmath6 at which the embedding potential is evaluated , for the case @xmath80 , @xmath81 .
for comparison also given are the values found by matching the external solution ( [ eqn : a2 ] ) to the regular internal solution , which can be expressed in terms of confluent hypergeometric functions@xcite . for
a given fixed @xmath6 the eigenvalues converge from above to values that are equal or above the exact values .
the further @xmath6 lies from the eigenvalue , the larger the difference between the limiting value for large basis sets and the correct value .
however , the influence of the @xmath82 terms in ( [ eqn : exp2 ] ) means the error is relatively small . when @xmath83 , the lowest eigenvalue found with @xmath84 is @xmath85 ha and in error by only 0.0000044 ha , a factor @xmath86 smaller than the error in @xmath6 .
@cccc @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath83 & @xmath89 + 2 & -0.4111620 , 1.6980995 & -0.4111527 , 1.6949300 & -0.4111624 , 1.6896482 + 4 & -0.4451482 , 0.9129418 & -0.4451439 , 0.9126817 & -0.4396204 , 0.9714775 + 6 & -0.4455519 , 0.8914789 & -0.4455477 , 0.8912219 & -0.4455520 , 0.8910268 + 8 & -0.4455532 , 0.8912708 & -0.4455488 , 0.8910141 & -0.4455532 , 0.8908194
+ `` exact '' & -0.4455532 , 0.8908194 & -0.4455532 , 0.8908194 & -0.4455532 , 0.8908194 + differentiating ( [ eqn : exp2 ] ) with respect to the trial energy @xmath6 shows the expectation value is stationary at @xmath90 . in this case @xmath11 is given by the solutions of @xmath91 } { \langle\varphi|\varphi\rangle_{\mathrm{i } } } .
\label{eqn : exp3}\ ] ] eigenfunctions @xmath4 solving this equation satisfy the dirac equation within i and the relationship between small and large components on @xmath1 ( [ eqn : de2 ] ) is exact . the final column in table [ table:1 ]
shows the lowest two positive energy eigenvalues of ( [ eqn : exp3 ] ) , again as a function of basis set size .
the eigenvalues again converge from above , and by @xmath84 reproduce the exact values by at least 7 significant figures .
it is worth noting that with this particular basis set increasing @xmath87 much further leads to some numerical difficulties due to overcompleteness . for more accurate
work a more suitable basis set should be used .
it should also be noted that conventional finite basis set calculations using a basis satisfying kinetic balance can given eigenvalues that lie below exact limiting values by an amount of order @xmath92 @xcite , and similar behaviour is expected in this embedding scheme .
most practical applications of the schrdinger embedding scheme have actually used the green function of the embedded system .
this is a more convenient quantity when dealing with systems where the spectrum is continuous , such as at surfaces or defects in solids .
we therefore consider the green function for the embedded dirac system
. differentiating ( [ eqn : exp2 ] ) with respect to @xmath6 shows @xmath11 is stationary when @xmath90 , as would be expected . in this case
stationary solutions satisfy the embedded dirac equation @xmath93 where , introducing @xmath94 , the component of @xmath95 in the direction normal to the surface @xmath1 ( from i to ii ) at @xmath96 , the additional term @xmath97 enforcing the embedding is @xmath98 .
\label{eqn : gf2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the corresponding green function satisfies @xmath99 for @xmath100 .
a similar line of argument to that given by inglesfield @xcite for the embedded schrdinger equation shows that this green function is identical for @xmath100 to the green functions @xmath101 for the entire system i@xmath102ii . for simplicity assuming i@xmath102ii constitute a finite system so that the spectrum is discrete , the green function @xmath101 is given by @xmath103 where @xmath104 is the eigenvalue corresponding to eigenstate @xmath105 of the entire system , normalised to unity over i@xmath102ii . for a given @xmath11 , the green function solving ( [ eqn : gf3 ] )
can be expanded in terms of the eigenstates @xmath106 of the corresponding homogeneous equation @xmath107 normalised to unity over i , as @xmath108 clearly @xmath109 has poles at @xmath110 . at these energies ( [ eqn : gf5 ] ) becomes the exact embedded dirac equation ( [ eqn : gf1 ] ) so as we have seen the poles will occur at eigenstates of the entire system and the spectrum of @xmath109 and @xmath101 coincide . it remains to show the poles of @xmath109 have the appropriate weight .
the residue of @xmath109 at @xmath111 is @xmath112 the second term in the denominator is precisely the additional factor necessary to correctly normalise the states ( see ( [ eqn : norm ] ) , ( [ eqn : cgc ] ) ) so that @xmath113 the residues of the green function of the embedded system and those of the entire system are identical .
hence the two green functions are identical for @xmath114 i. for practical calculations the green function can be expanded using a double - basis of separate large and small component spinors : @xmath115{g}(w ) \left[\begin{array}{cc } \bpsi_{\rm l}(\bi{r } ' ) & 0 \\ 0 & \bpsi_{\rm s}(\bi{r } ' ) \end{array}\right]^\dag.\ ] ] the matrix elements of the matrix of coefficients @xmath116 may be found by substituting into ( [ eqn : gf3 ] ) , multiplying from the right by the vector of basis functions , multiplying from the left by the hermitian transpose of the vector of basis functions , and integrating over region @xmath117 .
this leads to @xmath118^{-1}\ ] ] where the overlap and hamiltonian matrices have their previous definitions ( [ eqn : h2]-[eqn : h7 ] ) with @xmath119 . as an illustration
we calculate the local density of states for the confined hydrogen model at energies above @xmath120 where the spectrum is continuous . integrating over the embedded region this
is given by @xmath121 figure [ fig:4 ] shows the @xmath122 wave local density of states for @xmath80 , @xmath123 , calculated with varying number of basis functions .
the basis functions ( [ eqn : bas1 ] ) , ( [ eqn : bas2 ] ) are not particularly appropriate for representing the continuum wave solutions , and so convergence is only achieved using a relatively large set ; however the results serve to illustrate the systematic improvement that accompanies an increasing number of basis functions .
the local density of states shows two resonances , the precursors of bound states that exist when any of @xmath56 , @xmath124 or @xmath120 are increased sufficiently .
as a further example , one that provides a test of the relativistic embedding scheme when applied to a more challenging problem , we use it to calculate the local density of states on a silver monolayer in a au(001)/ag / au(001 ) sandwich structure . using the embedding scheme only the region occupied by the ag monolayer
is explicitly treated .
this is region i , with the two au halfspaces to either side entering the calculation via embedding potentials expanded on planar surfaces .
then , using bloch s theorem the calculation is performed within a unit cell containing one atom .
the full technical details will be described elsewhere , but briefly the green function at two - dimensional wave vector @xmath125 is expanded in a set of linearised augmented relativistic plane waves .
we use large component basis functions @xmath126\omega_\lambda(\widehat{\bi{r } } ) & & \bi{r } \in \mbox{muffin - tin } \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where @xmath127 is a pauli spinor , @xmath128 , with @xmath129 a two - dimensional reciprocal lattice vector and @xmath130 , @xmath131 and where @xmath132 exceeds the width of the embedded region ensuring variational freedom in the basis .
the function @xmath133 is the large component of the wavefunction that satisfies the radial dirac equation for the spherically symmetric component of the potential at some pivot energy ; @xmath134 is the energy derivative of @xmath135 .
the matching coefficients @xmath136 , @xmath137 ensure continuity of the basis function in amplitude and derivative at the muffin - tin radius .
the small component basis functions are chosen to satisfy kinetic balance .
overlap and hamiltonian matrix elements follow directly from these basis functions
. the embedding potential is obtained from ( [ eqn : cgc ] ) using the general expression for a wavefunction outside a surface at wave vector @xmath125 .
this gives for the embedding potential describing the left au half space @xmath138_{\bi{g}\sigma\bi{g}'\sigma'}\nonumber\\ \times \exp(\rmi(\bi{k}+\bi{g})\cdot \bi{r}_s ) \exp(-\rmi(\bi{k}+\bi{g}')\cdot \bi{r}'_s ) \,\varphi_\sigma
\otimes \varphi_{\sigma ' } \label{eqn : embpot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath139 the reflection matrix @xmath140 is found using standard layer - scattering methods @xcite
. a similar approach may be used to obtain an embedding potential for the right half space , which unlike the non - relativistic case differs from that for the left half space .
figure [ fig:5 ] compares the local density of states calculated using the relativistic embedding technique for an embedded ag monolayer using embedding potentials corresponding to au(001 ) with that found for an au(001)/ag / au(001 ) sandwich geometry using relativistic scattering theory @xcite .
the same au and ag potentials has been used in each case , and the local density of states found within the same muffin - tin volume .
therefore the results obtained with the two methods should be comparable , and we find that they are indistinguishable .
this confirms that the embedding potential ( [ eqn : embpot ] ) imposes the correct variational constraint upon wave functions for the embedded ag monolayer so that they replicate the behaviour of an extended au(001)/ag / au(001 ) sandwich structure .
the inset in figure [ fig:5 ] shows the local density of states in the non - relativistic limit ( @xmath141 ) , indicating the significant relativistic effects on the electronic structure which are correctly reproduced with this dirac - embedding scheme .
we have outline above an embedding scheme for the dirac equation .
it enables the dirac equation to be solved within a limited region i when this region forms part of a larger system , i@xmath102ii .
region ii is replaced by an additional term added to the hamiltonian for region i , and which acts on the surface @xmath1 separating i and ii .
the embedding scheme is derived using a trial function in which continuity in the small component across @xmath1 is imposed variationally .
expanding the wave function in a basis set of separate large and small component spinors , the problem of variational collapse is avoided by using a basis satisfying kinetic balance . calculating the spectrum of a confined hydrogen atom , the method is shown to be stable and converge to the exact eigenvalues .
we have also derived the green function for the embedded hamiltonian and illustrated its use in the continuum regime of the same confined hydrogen system and an au / ag / au sandwich structure .
these are demonstration calculations
future applications are likely to be to defects and surfaces of materials containing heavier ( typically 5@xmath142 ) elements , within the framework of density functional theory .
it is worthwhile to discuss further the use of a trial function that is discontinuous in the small component , since such a wave function gives rise to a discontinuous probability density and so would normally be dismissed in quantum theory . in non - relativistic quantum mechanics
discontinuous trial functions are not permitted , since they possess infinite energy .
however the dirac equation is first order in @xmath143 and as we have seen a perfectly regular expectation value of @xmath0 results . exploiting this freedom
, the embedding scheme outlined above leads to solutions that are continuous in both large and small component _ only _ when the embedding potential @xmath144 is evaluated at the same energy @xmath6 as the energy @xmath11 that appears in the dirac equation itself , for then the relationship between small and large components on @xmath1 inside ( equation [ eqn : de2 ] ) and outside ( equation [ eqn : cgc ] ) coincide , the large components matching by construction .
this may be achieved for example via the iterative scheme used in connection with equation ( [ eqn : exp3 ] ) and the final column of table [ table:1 ] , or explicitly when determining the green function as in section [ section : green ] .
these are the methods in which the non - relativistic embedding scheme has been most widely used .
when @xmath6 and @xmath11 do not coincide , the solutions obtained via this embedding scheme will retain small components that are discontinuous across @xmath1 .
this may be unacceptable for certain applications , but the solutions continue to be valid approximations at least in as much as they provide estimates of the energies of the solutions of the dirac equation , and so could suffice e.g. for interpreting spectroscopic measurements .
this embedding scheme places no greater emphasis on a discontinuity in the small amplitude at @xmath1 than on an incorrect ( but continuous ) amplitude elsewhere within the embedded region .
it aims merely to optimise the energy of the state , and will retain a discontinuity in the small component if in doing so it can better ( in terms of energy ) approximate the solution inside the embedded region . in the non - relativistic embedding scheme
the discontinuous derivative of the trial function implies a probability current ( and electric current ) that is discontinuous across the embedding surface .
this is similarly unphysical , yet numerous applications such as those cited above have demonstrated the utility and accuracy of the method . indeed , there have been many applications in which this scheme has been used to determine currents and or transport properties , such as in relation to surface optical response @xcite and electron transport in electron waveguides or through domain walls @xcite .
the reason for the success of these calculations is that they employed schemes in which the embedding potential was evaluated at the correct energy , ensuring that the derivative of the wavefunction was continuous across @xmath1 . in practise
there have been few calculations using the non - relativistic embedding scheme in which the energies did not coincide .
there are a number of aspects of the method which are worthy of further consideration .
we started with a trial function in which by construction the large component was continuous and the small component discontinuous across the surface @xmath1 dividing i and ii .
we could have reversed these conditions , leading to a similar embedded dirac equation but with a modified embedding term .
the particular choice was motivated by the wish to have a theory which behaves reasonably in the limit @xmath141 when the small component becomes negligible a discontinuous amplitude is not permissible in trial solutions to the schrdinger equation .
however , the behaviour of the alternative formulation should be investigated . perhaps in connection with this there is the question of the spectrum of negative energy solutions , to which we have paid scant attention .
exploring the @xmath141 limit it might be possible to identify how to embed a relativistic region i within a region ii treated non - relativistically
a 5@xmath142 overlayer on a simple metal substrate might be a physical system where such a treatment is appropriate
. there could be benefits in terms of computational resources expended if the embedding potential could be determined within the framework of a non - relativistic calculation , and there might also be useful insights in terms of simple models .
finally , in terms of implementation for realistic systems , some of the novel schemes for deriving embedding potentials @xcite could certainly be adapted to the relativistic case .
it would also be worthwhile to consider whether it is possible to use a restricted electron - like basis , in which the large and small component spinors are combined .
this is common practice in most relativistic electronic structure calculations for solids when using basis set techniques ( e.g. @xcite ) , and would result in significant computational efficiencies . | an embedding scheme is developed for the dirac hamiltonian @xmath0 . dividing space into regions i and ii separated by surface @xmath1 ,
an expression is derived for the expectation value of @xmath0 which makes explicit reference to a trial function defined in i alone , with all details of region ii replaced by an effective potential acting on @xmath1 and which is related to the green function of region ii .
stationary solutions provide approximations to the eigenstates of @xmath0 within i. the green function for the embedded hamiltonian is equal to the green function for the entire system in region i. application of the method is illustrated for the problem of a hydrogen atom in a spherical cavity and an au(001)/ag / au(001 ) sandwich structure using basis sets that satisfy kinetic balance . |
there is strong observational evidence that active galactic nuclei ( agn ) play an important role in the formation and growth of galaxies ( e.g. @xcite ) .
most supermassive black hole growth takes place during an obscured quasar phase , as suggested by the integrated energy density of the cosmic x - ray background @xcite . to understand the evolution of galaxies and to trace the energy output due to accretion and its cosmological evolution , it is critical to map the history of obscured accretion .
x - ray surveys with _ xmm - newton _ and _ chandra _ at energies @xmath810 kev are sensitive to all but the most heavily obscured agn ( e.g. @xcite ) . in compton - thick agn ( rest - frame column densities exceeding @xmath9 ) the observed flux below 10 kev can be as low as a few % of the intrinsic nuclear flux . in the compton - thick regime the high energy photons that survive the photoelectric absorption get scattered in the absorber losing part of their energy ( compton down - scattering ) .
this is an important effect that can significantly suppress the transmitted continuum ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
the ongoing swift / bat and integral / ibis all - sky surveys at energies 15 - 200 kev are providing the least biased samples of absorbed agn in the local universe ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
however , even these surveys are biased against the most heavily absorbed compton - thick agn @xcite .
surveys at mid - infrared ( hereafter mir ) wavelengths ( @xmath105@xmath0 m ) are much less affected by extinction since the obscuring dust re - emits the nuclear optical - to - x - ray radiation at infrared wavelengths .
clumpy torus models predict nearly isotropic emission in the mir at wavelengths @xmath1012@xmath0 m ( @xcite ) .
thus , mir - based surveys ( or the combination of mir and data at shorter wavelengths ) can potentially trace the elusive obscured accretion missed by hard x - ray surveys ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . for example
, it has been claimed that objects showing excess emission at @xmath1124@xmath0 m over that expected from star formation , termed `` infrared - excess galaxies '' , might host heavily obscured and compton - thick agn ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) .
however the exact contribution of heavily obscured agn to the infrared - excess galaxy population remains an open issue ( e.g. @xcite ) .
several mir - based agn selection techniques have been developed with data from the spitzer space telescope infrared array camera ( irac ; @xcite ) using colours and power - law selection ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
these techniques are very effective and reliable .
galaxies dominated by agn emission typically exhibit a characteristic red power - law spectral energy distribution ( sed ) in the mir ( @xmath12 with @[email protected] ; @xcite ) .
thus , mir power - law selection provides the cleanest samples of luminous agn ( e.g. @xcite ) .
however , this technique is very sensitive to the reliability of the estimated photometric errors @xcite .
the wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ) has now completed the first sensitive ( @xmath11100 - 1000@xmath15 deeper than iras ) coverage of the entire sky in the mir@xcite .
several colour - based regions , aimed at identifying luminous agn , have already been proposed .
these works have shown that @xmath1 can robustly separate agn from normal galaxies and stars ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
@xmath1 will be extremely efficient in identifying the rare highly luminous agn up to the crucial epoch when the accretion power of the universe peaked ( @xmath16@xmath111 - 2 ) .
the all - sky @xmath1 survey will complement the deep spitzer surveys , aimed to characterize the accretion phenomenon in the distant universe .
this paper presents a highly reliable and complete mir - based colour selection of agn with wise .
our technique is designed to select objects with red mir power - law seds and properly accounts for the estimated typical errors in the photometry and deviations of the mir seds from a pure power - law .
the agn wedge is defined using the wide - angle bright ultra - hard _ xmm - newton _ survey ( buxs ; mateos et al . 2012c , in preparation ) .
this survey is one of the largest complete flux - limited samples of bright `` ultra - hard '' ( 4.5 - 10 kev ) x - ray selected agn to date .
surveys such as ` buxs ` are extremely efficient in selecting agn bright enough for reliable optical identifications and for detailed studies of their properties and evolution ( e.g. hbs28 , @xcite ; hbss , @xcite ) . `
buxs ` covers the region of the agn redshift - luminosity parameter space that @xmath1 will sample .
thus , ` buxs ` offers a unique opportunity to define a highly complete and reliable mir - based agn selection with wise .
thanks to the optical spectroscopic identifications available for @xmath1197% of the ` buxs ` objects , and the high quality x - ray spectra , we have maximized the completeness of our mir selection without compromising its reliability . in a forthcoming paper we will present and discuss the main properties of the optical / near - ir / mir seds of the agn in ` buxs ` ( mateos et al . 2012c , in preparation ) .
this paper is organized as follows .
sections 2 and 3 briefly summarize the data sets . in section 4
we present our mir selection of agn candidates using the three shorter wavelength bands of @xmath1 and the complete four bands , respectively and we discuss the completeness of the selection .
we show the reliability of our agn selection in section 5 .
the results are summarized in section 6 . throughout this paper errors
are 90% confidence for a single parameter and we assume @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 .
@xmath1 observed the entire sky in the mir , achieving 5@xmath20 point source sensitivities better than 0.08 , 0.11 , 1 , and 6 mjy at 3.4 , 4.6 , 12 , and 22 @xmath0 m , respectively .
the angular resolution is 6.1@xmath21 , 6.4@xmath21 , 6.5@xmath21 , and 12.0@xmath21(fwhm ) , respectively , and the astrometric precision for high signal - to - noise ( hereafter snr ) sources is better than 0.15@xmath21(wright et al .
we use here the march 2012 publicly available all - sky data release that covers @xmath2299% of the sky and incorporates the best available calibrations and data reduction algorithms ( cutri et al .
2012 ) .
in what follows we compute flux densities in the @xmath1 bands using profile fitting photometry and the magnitude zero points of the vega system : @xmath23=309.124 jy , 171.641 jy , 30.988 jy , and 8.346 jy for 3.4 , 4.6 , 12 , and 22 @xmath0 m , respectively .
these values are computed with the flux correction factors that correspond to a power - law spectrum ( @xmath12 ) with spectral index @xmath24=@xmath141 presented in @xcite .
we note that using the flux correction factors that correspond to constant power - law spectra the difference in the computed flux densities would be less than 0.2% at 3.4 , 4.6 , and 22 @xmath0 m and @xmath112% at 12 @xmath0 m .
we added a 1.5% uncertainty to the catalogued flux errors in all bands to account for the overall systematic uncertainty from the vega spectrum in the flux zeropoints . to account for the existing discrepancy between the red and blue calibrators used for the conversion from magnitudes to janskys , an additional 10% uncertainty was added to the 12@xmath0 m and 22@xmath0 m fluxes ( wright et al .
2010 ) . throughout this paper
we use monochromatic mir flux densities ( @xmath25 ) in janskys , unless otherwise specified . [ cols="^,^ " , ] in the previous sections we presented the @xmath1 expected colours for agn / star - forming galaxies derived from a library of templates .
here we investigate in more detail the colour trends in the three - band agn wedge for the ` buxs ` type-1 and type-2 agn .
[ fig4 ] shows the mir colours of the agn in ` buxs ` as a function of their x - ray luminosity .
as expected , there is a strong dependence of log(@xmath26 ) on the x - ray luminosity , with less luminous sources having the bluest mir colours . for less powerful agn the host galaxy can substantially contribute to the mir emission ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) .
host galaxy dilution is expected to be more important in type-2 agn , especially at low luminosities , as type-2 agn should show a higher degree of extinction at the shortest wavelengths of wise .
these objects , with mir colours consistent with normal galaxies , lie outside of the agn wedge and thus , they are missed from a pure mir selection .
[ fig2 ] and fig .
[ fig4 ] both show that most agn in ` buxs ` missed by the 3-band wedge are type-2 agn . as noted in sec .
[ completeness ] , in flux - limited x - ray surveys , such as ` buxs ` , type-2 agn are overall intrinsically less luminous than type-1 agn ( see fig .
[ fig1 ] , bottom ) .
thus , due to the strong dependence of the mir selection completeness on the luminosity of the objects ( see fig .
[ fig3 ] , top ) , our agn wedge will preferentially pick out ` buxs ` type-1 agn .
however , at luminosities @xmath27 , where the agn is expected to dominate the mir emission ( unless it is heavily absorbed ) , the completeness of the selection of type-1 and type-2 agn is comparable within the uncertainties . at such luminosities both type-1 and type-2 agn
are preferentially located above the power - law locus ( see also fig . [ fig6 ] ) .
this indicates that the observed 3.4@xmath0 m to 12@xmath0 m mir seds of powerful agn deviate from a pure power - law .
we do not find a strong dependence of the log(@xmath28 ) colour on the x - ray luminosity .
however , we find a large scatter in the distribution of log(@xmath28 ) colours , especially for objects at low luminosities , where the host galaxy significantly contributes to the mir emission . a broad range of log(@xmath29 ) colours is expected for agn with an important host galaxy contribution as the very wide 12@xmath0 m filter of @xmath1 is very sensitive to both prominent pah emission features and silicate absorption ( 10@xmath0 m ) in star - forming galaxies over a broad range of redshifts .
we present a mir power - law based selection of luminous agn candidates using the 3.4 , 4.6 , and 12 @xmath0 m bands of the @xmath1 survey .
we defined an agn wedge in the log(@xmath26 ) vs. log(@xmath30 ) colour - colour diagram using the bright ultra - hard _ xmm - newton _ survey ( ` buxs ` ) .
this is one of the largest complete flux - limited samples of bright ( @xmath31 ) `` ultra - hard '' ( 4.5 - 10 kev ) x - ray selected agn to date . `
buxs ` includes 258 objects detected over a total sky area of 44.43 deg@xmath3 : 251 ( 97.3% ) are spectroscopically identified and classified , with 145 being type-1 agn and 106 type-2 agn . our technique is based on a mir power - law selection and properly accounts for the errors in the photometry and deviations of the mir spectral energy distributions from a pure power - law . in flux - limited x - ray surveys , such as ` buxs ` , type-2 agn are intrinsically less luminous than type-1 agn .
thus , due to the strong dependence of the mir selection completeness on the luminosity of the objects , a mir agn wedge necessarily picks out ` buxs ` type-1 agn .
however , at 2 - 10 kev luminosities above @xmath32 the completeness of our mir selection of type-1 and type-2 agn is high and comparable for both types within the uncertainties .
our selection is highly complete at luminosities @xmath4 where our mir wedge recovers @xmath1197% and @xmath1177% of the ` buxs ` type-1 and type-2 agn , respectively .
we identify 2755 agn candidates in the 44.43 deg@xmath3 ` buxs ` survey area of which 38.5% have detection in x - rays . in the ` buxs ` area where the x - ray observations have exposures @xmath2240ks ,
the x - ray detection fraction rises to 49.8% .
this is reasonable , as long x - ray exposures are required to detect intrinsically less luminous and/or heavily obscured agn .
a substantial fraction of the mir agn candidates remain undetected at 2 - 10kev energies with the typical exposures in the 2xmm catalogue .
these objects are the best candidates to account for the most heavily obscured / absorbed luminous agn missed by hard x - ray surveys .
assuming that a 2 - 10 kev x - ray detection is a good tracer of agn activity we demonstrate that our @xmath1 selection shows one of the highest reliability amongst those in the literature .
this is crucial to obtain a clean mir selection of powerful agn .
furthermore , going down to a snr@xmath75 limit in the @xmath1 flux densities , we substantially increase the efficiency of detection of agn with the reddest mir colours .
we also investigate a @xmath1 four - band agn selection .
we show , however , that by including the 22@xmath0 m @xmath1 band neither the completeness nor the reliability of the selection improves .
this is likely due to both the significantly shallower depth at 22@xmath0 m compared with the first three bands of @xmath1 and star - formation contributing to the 22@xmath0 m emission at the @xmath1 22@xmath0 m sensitivity .
this work is based on observations obtained with _ xmm - newton _ , an esa science mission with instruments and contributions directly funded by esa member states and nasa .
based on data from the wide - field infrared survey explorer , which is a joint project of the university of california , los angeles , and the jet propulsion laboratory / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration .
funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england .
the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. based on observations collected at the european organisation for astronomical research in the southern hemisphere , chile , programme ids 084.a-0828 , 086.a-0612 , 087.a-0447 .
based on observations made with the william herschel telescope -operated by the isaac newton group- , the telescopio nazionale galileo -operated by the centro galileo galilei and the gran telescopio de canarias installed in the spanish observatorio del roque de los muchachos of the instituto de astrofsica de canarias , in the island of la palma .
sm , fjc and xb acknowledge financial support by the spanish ministry of economy and competitiveness through grant aya2010 - 21490-c02 - 01 . a.a .-
h . acknowledges support from the universidad de cantabria through the augusto g. linares program .
acknowledges a royal society wolfson research merit award . j.l.d .
acknowledges support from the lanl director s fellowship . p.s . acknowledges financial support from asi ( grant no .
i/009/10/0 ) .
the authors wish to thank the anonymous referee for constructive comments . | we present a highly complete and reliable mid - infrared ( mir ) colour selection of luminous agn candidates using the 3.4 , 4.6 , and 12 @xmath0 m bands of the @xmath1 survey .
the mir colour wedge was defined using the wide - angle bright ultra - hard _ xmm - newton _ survey ( buxs ) , one of the largest complete flux - limited samples of bright ( @xmath2 ) `` ultra - hard '' ( 4.5 - 10 kev ) x - ray selected agn to date .
buxs includes 258 objects detected over a total sky area of 44.43 deg@xmath3 of which 251 are spectroscopically identified and classified , with 145 being type-1 agn and 106 type-2 agn .
our technique is designed to select objects with red mir power - law spectral energy distributions ( sed ) in the three shortest bands of @xmath1 and properly accounts for the errors in the photometry and deviations of the mir seds from a pure power - law .
the completeness of the mir selection is a strong function of luminosity . at @xmath4 , where the agn is expected to dominate the mir emission , @xmath5 and @xmath6 of the ` buxs ` type-1 and type-2 agn meet the selection .
our technique shows one of the highest reliability and efficiency of detection of the x - ray selected luminous agn population with @xmath1 amongst those in the literature . in the area covered by the ` buxs `
survey our selection identifies 2755 agn candidates detected with snr@xmath75 in the three shorter wavelength bands of wise with 38.5% having a detection at 2 - 10 kev x - ray energies .
we also analyzed the possibility of including the 22@xmath0 m @xmath1 band to select agn candidates , but neither the completeness nor the reliability of the selection improves .
this is likely due to both the significantly shallower depth at 22@xmath0 m compared with the first three bands of @xmath1 and star - formation contributing to the 22@xmath0 m emission at the @xmath1 22@xmath0 m sensitivity .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : active - quasars : general - infrared : galaxies |
there is already a considerable but widely varying literature on the application of category theory to the life and cognitive sciences such as the work of robert rosen ( @xcite , @xcite ) and his followers as well as andre ehresmann and jean - paul vanbremeersch @xcite and their commentators .
the approach taken here is based on a specific use of the characteristic concepts of category theory , namely universal mapping properties .
one such approach in the literature is that of franois magnan and gonzalo reyes which emphasizes that `` category theory provides means to circumscribe and study what is universal in mathematics and other scientific disciplines . ''
their intended field of application is cognitive science . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ we may even suggest that universals of the mind may be expressed by means of universal properties in the theory of categories and much of the work done up to now in this area seems to bear out this suggestion .... by discussing the process of counting in some detail , we give evidence that this universal ability of the human mind may be conveniently conceptualized in terms of this theory of universals which is category theory . @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ another current approach that emphasizes universal mapping properties ( `` universal constructions '' ) is that of s. phillips , w. h. wilson , and g. s. halford ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) .
in addition to the focus on universals , the approach here is distinctive in the use of heteromorphisms which are object - to - object morphisms between objects if different categories in contrast to the usual homomorphisms or homs between objects in the same category . by explicitly adding heteromorphisms to the usual homs - only presentation of category theory
, this approach can directly represent interactions between the objects of different categories ( intuitively , between an organism and the environment ) .
but it is still early days , and many approaches need to be tried to find out `` where theory lives . ''
before developing the concept of a brain functor , we need to consider the related concept of a pair of adjoint functors , an adjunction .
the developers of category theory , saunders maclane and samuel eilenberg , famously said that categories were defined in order to define functors , and functors were defined in order to define natural transformations @xcite .
a few years later , the concept of universal constructions or universal mapping properties was isolated ( @xcite and @xcite ) . adjoints were defined a decade later by daniel kan @xcite and the realization of their ubiquity ( `` adjoint functors arise everywhere '' maclane : cwm ) and their foundational importance has steadily increased over time ( lawvere @xcite and lambek @xcite )
. now it would perhaps not be too much of an exaggeration to see categories , functors , and natural transformations as the prelude to defining adjoint functors .
as steven awodey put it : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the notion of adjoint functor applies everything that we have learned up to now to unify and subsume all the different universal mapping properties that we have encountered , from free groups to limits to exponentials .
but more importantly , it also captures an important mathematical phenomenon that is invisible without the lens of category theory .
indeed , i will make the admittedly provocative claim that adjointness is a concept of fundamental logical and mathematical importance that is not captured elsewhere in mathematics .
@xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ other category theorists have given similar testimonials .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ to some , including this writer , adjunction is the most important concept in category theory .
@xcite the isolation and explication of the notion of adjointness is perhaps the most profound contribution that category theory has made to the history of general mathematical ideas . "
@xcite nowadays , every user of category theory agrees that [ adjunction ] is the concept which justifies the fundamental position of the subject in mathematics . @xcite
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
how do the ubiquitous and important adjoint functors relate to the universal constructions ?
mac lane and birkhoff succinctly state the idea of the universals of category theory and note that adjunctions can be analyzed in terms of those universals . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the construction of a new algebraic object will often solve a specific problem in a universal way , in the sense that every other solution of the given problem is obtained from this one by a unique homomorphism .
the basic idea of an adjoint functor arises from the analysis of such universals . @xcite
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ we can use some old language from plato s theory of universals to describe those universals of category theory ( ellerman @xcite ) that solve a problem in a universal or paradigmatic way so that `` every other solution of the given problem is obtained from this one '' in a unique way . in plato s theory of ideas or forms ( @xmath0 ) , a property @xmath1 has an entity associated with it , the universal @xmath2 , which uniquely represents the property .
an object @xmath3 has the property @xmath1 , i.e. , @xmath4 , if and only if ( iff ) the object @xmath3 _ participates _ in the universal @xmath2 .
let @xmath5 ( from @xmath6 or _ methexis _ ) represent the participation relation so `` @xmath7 '' reads as `` @xmath3 participates in @xmath2 ''
. given a relation @xmath5 , an entity @xmath2 is said to be a _
universal _ for the property @xmath1 ( with respect to @xmath5 ) if it satisfies the following universality condition : for any @xmath3 , @xmath7 if and only if @xmath4 .
a universal representing a property should be in some sense unique .
hence there should be an equivalence relation ( @xmath8 ) so that universals satisfy a uniqueness condition : if @xmath2 and @xmath9 are universals for the same @xmath1 , then @xmath2 @xmath8 @xmath9 .
the two criteria for a _ theory of universals _ is that it contains a binary relation @xmath5 and an equivalence relation @xmath8 so that with certain properties @xmath1 there are associated entities @xmath2 satisfying the following conditions : \(1 ) _ universality condition _ :
for any @xmath3 , @xmath7 iff @xmath4 , and \(2 ) _ uniqueness condition _ : if @xmath2 and @xmath9 are universals for the same @xmath1 [ i.e. , satisfy ( 1 ) ] , then @xmath2 @xmath8 @xmath9 .
a universal @xmath2 is said to be _ non - self - predicative _ if it does not participate in itself , i.e. , @xmath10 .
a universal @xmath2 is _ self - predicative _ if it participates in itself , i.e. , @xmath11 . for the sets in an iterative set theory ( boolos @xcite ) , set membership is the participation relation , set equality is the equivalence relation , and those sets are never - self - predicative ( since the set of instances of a property is always of higher type or rank than the instances ) .
the universals of category theory form the `` other bookend '' as always - self - predicative universals .
the set - theoretical paradoxes arose from trying to have _
one _ theory of universals ( `` frege s paradise '' ) where the universals could be _ either _ self - predicative or non - self - predicative , instead of having two opposite `` bookend '' theories , one for never - self - predicative universals
( set theory ) and one for always always - self - predicative universals ( category theory ) . for the self - predicative universals of category theory ( see @xcite or @xcite for introductions ) ,
the participation relation is the _ uniquely - factors - through _ relation .
it can always be formulated in a suitable category as : `` @xmath7 '' means `` there exists a unique arrow @xmath12 '' .
then @xmath3 is said to _ uniquely factor through _ @xmath2 , and the arrow @xmath12 is the unique factor or participation morphism . in the universality condition , for any @xmath3 , @xmath7 if and only if @xmath4 , the existence of the identity arrow @xmath13 is the self - participation of the self - predicative universal that corresponds with @xmath14 , the self - predication of the property to @xmath2 . in category theory , the equivalence relation used in the uniqueness condition is the isomorphism ( @xmath15 ) .
we will later use a specific heterodox treatment of adjunctions , first developed by pareigis @xcite and later rediscovered and developed by ellerman ( @xcite , @xcite ) , which shows that adjoints arise by gluing together in a certain way two universals ( left and right representations ) .
but for illustration , we start with the standard hom - set definition of an adjunction . the category @xmath16 has all sets as objects and all functions between sets as the homomorphisms so for sets
@xmath17 and @xmath18 , @xmath19 is the set of functions @xmath20 . in the product category @xmath21 ,
the objects are ordered pairs of sets @xmath22 and homomorphism @xmath23 is just a pair of functions @xmath24 where @xmath25 and @xmath26 .
for an example of an adjunction , consider the _ product functor _
@xmath27 which takes a pair of sets @xmath28 to their cartesian product @xmath29 ( set of ordered pairs of elements from @xmath17 and @xmath30 ) and takes a homomorphism @xmath31 to @xmath32 where for @xmath33 and @xmath34 , @xmath35 .
the maps @xmath25 in @xmath16 go from one set to one set and the maps @xmath36 in @xmath21 go from a pair of sets to a pair of sets .
there is also the idea of a _ cone _ @xmath37 : c\rightarrow\left ( a , b\right ) $ ] of maps that is a pair of maps @xmath38 and @xmath39 going from one set @xmath40 ( the point of the cone ) in @xmath16 to a pair of sets @xmath22 ( the base of the cone ) in @xmath21 . before the notion of a adjunction was defined by kan @xcite , the product of sets @xmath29 was defined by its universal mapping property .
the projection maps @xmath41 and @xmath42 define a canonical cone @xmath43 : a\times b\rightarrow(a , b)$ ] that is universal in the following sense .
given any other cone @xmath37 : c\rightarrow(a , b)$ ] from any set @xmath40 to @xmath22 , there is a unique homomorphism @xmath44 in @xmath16 such that the two triangles in the following diagram commute .
fig1-product-sets.eps figure 1 : universal mapping property for the product of sets . in terms of the self - predicative universals considered in the last section ,
the property in question is the property of being a cone @xmath37 : c\rightarrow(a , b)$ ] to @xmath22 from any set @xmath40 .
the canonical cone of projections @xmath45 : a\times
b\rightarrow ( a , b)$ ] is the self - predicative universal for that property .
the participation relation @xmath37 \
\left [ \pi_{a},\pi_{b}\right ] $ ] is defined as `` uniquely factoring through '' ( as in figure 1 ) .
the universal mapping property of the product can then be restated as the universality condition : for any cone @xmath37 $ ] from any set to a pair of sets , @xmath37 \
\left [ \pi_{a},\pi_{b}\right ] $ ] if and only if @xmath37 $ ] is a cone to @xmath22 .
ump of @xmath29 stated as a universality condition . the hom - set definition of the adjunction for the product functor uses the auxiliary device of a diagonal functor to avoid mentioning the cones and to restrict attention only to the hom - sets of the two categories .
the _ diagonal functor _
@xmath46 in the opposite direction of the product functor just doubles everything so @xmath47 and @xmath48 .
then the product functor is said to be the _
right adjoint _ of the diagonal functor , the diagonal functor is said to be the _ left adjoint _ of the product functor , and the two functors together form an _ adjunction _ if there is a natural isomorphism between the hom - sets as follows : @xmath49 .
hom - set definition of the adjunction between the product and diagonal functors .
the diagonal functor @xmath46 also has a ( rather trivial ) ump that can be stated in terms of cones @xmath50 except now we fix @xmath40 and let @xmath22 vary .
there is the canoncial cone @xmath51 : c\rightarrow\left ( c , c\right ) $ ] and it is universal in the following sense . for any cone @xmath37 : c\rightarrow\left ( a , b\right ) $ ] from the given @xmath40 to any pair of sets @xmath22 , there is a unique homomorphism in @xmath21 , namely @xmath52 that factors through the canonical cone @xmath53 .
fig2-diagonal-ump.eps figure 2 : universal mapping property for diagonal functor .
this product - diagonal adjunction illustrates the general @xmath54-set definition .
given functors @xmath55 and @xmath56 going each way between categories @xmath57 and @xmath58 , they form an adjunction if there is a natural isomorphism ( for objects @xmath59 and @xmath60 ) : @xmath61 @xmath54-set definition of an adjunction . to further analyze adjoints , we need the notion of a `` heteromorphism . ''
we have seen that there are two umps ( often one is trivial like @xmath62 in the above example ) involved in an adjunction and that the object - to - object maps were always within one category , e.g. , in the `` hom - sets '' of one category or the other . using object - to - object maps between objects of
_ different _ categories ( properly called `` heteromorphisms '' or `` chimera morphisms '' ) , the notion of an adjunction can be factored into two representations ( or `` half - adjunctions '' in ellerman ellerman : whatisct ) , each of which expresses a universal mapping property .
we have already seen one standard example of a _ heteromorphism _ or _ het _ , namely a cone @xmath37 : c\rightarrow\left ( a , b\right ) $ ] that goes from an object in @xmath16 to an object in @xmath63 .
the hets are contrasted with the homs or homomorphisms between objects in the same category . to keep them separate in our notation
, we will henceforth use single arrows @xmath64 for hets and double arrows @xmath65 for homs . ) while the homomorphisms or homs between objects in the same category are represented by double arrows ( @xmath65 ) .
the functors between whole categories are also represented by single arrows ( @xmath66 )
. one must be careful not to confuse a functor @xmath55 from a category @xmath57 to a category @xmath58 with its action on an object @xmath59 which would be symbolized @xmath67 .
moreover since a functor often has a canonical definition , there may well be a canonical het @xmath68 or @xmath69 but such hets are no part of the definition of the functor itself .
] then the ump for the product functor can be represented as follows .
fig3-right-rep-product.eps figure 3 : ump for the product functor it should be particularly noted that this het - formulation of the ump for the product does not involve the diagonal functor . if we associate with each @xmath70 and each @xmath71 , the set @xmath72 of cones or hets @xmath37 : c\rightarrow\left ( a , b\right ) $ ] then this defines a @xmath73__-bifunctor _ _ in the same manner as the usual @xmath54-bifunctor @xmath74 or @xmath75 [ see the appendix for more details ] .
then the ump for the product functor gives a natural isomorphism based on the pairing : @xmath37 \mapsto \left\langle f , g\right\rangle $ ] , so that the @xmath16-valued functor @xmath72 is said to be _ represented on the right _ by the @xmath16-valued @xmath76 : @xmath77 right representation of the hets @xmath78 by the homs @xmath79 .
the trivial ump for the diagonal functor can also be stated in terms of the cone - hets without reference to the product functor .
fig4-left-rep-diagonal.eps figure 4 : ump for the diagonal functor this ump for the diagonal functor gives a natural isomorphism based on the pairing @xmath80 $ ] , so the @xmath16-valued functor @xmath81 is said to be _ represented on the left _ by the @xmath16-valued @xmath82 : @xmath83 @xmath81 left representation of the hets @xmath78 by the homs @xmath84
. then the right and left representations of the hets @xmath72 can be combined to obtain as a consequence the hom - set definition of the adjunction between the product and diagonal functors : @xmath83 @xmath85 heteromorphic presentation of the product - diagonal adjunction . in the general case of adjoint functors @xmath86 , the hets @xmath87 from objects @xmath59 to objects @xmath60 have left and right representations : @xmath88 heteromorphic presentation of a general adjunction .
this is the heterodox treatment of an adjunction first published by pareigis @xcite and later rediscovered and developed by the author ( @xcite and @xcite ) .
it is `` heterodox '' since the morphisms between the objects of _ different _ categories are not `` officially '' recognized in the standard presentations of category theory ( e.g. , @xcite or @xcite ) even though such hets are a common part of mathematical practice ( see the appendix for further discussion ) .
hence the standard hom - set definition of an adjunction just deletes the @xmath73-middle - term @xmath87 to obtain just the het - free or homs - only presentation of an adjunction .
the important advance of the heteromorphic treatment of an adjunction is that the adjunction can be parsed or factored into two parts , the left and right representations , each of which only involves one of the @xmath54-functors .
fig5-landr-reps-xa.eps figure 5 : left and right representations each involving on one of the adjoints @xmath1 and @xmath89 .
moreover , the diagrams for the two representations can be glued together at the diagonal het @xmath90 into one diagram to give the simple _ adjunctive square diagram _ for an adjunction .
fig6-adj-square-xa.eps figure 6 : adjunctive square diagram for the het - treatment of an adjunction .
every adjunction can be represented ( up to isomorphism ) in this manner @xcite so the molecule of an adjunction can be split into two atoms , each of which is a ( left or right ) representation of a @xmath73-functor .
this means that the importance and ubiquity of adjunctions ( emphasized above ) also passes to the atoms , left or right representations , that make up those molecules .
moreover , it should be noted that each left or right representation defines a self - predicative universal as indicated in the previous example of the het - cones @xmath91 .
the main point of this paper is that those atoms , the left and right representations can be recombined in a new way to define a `` recombinant construction '' cognate to an adjunction , and that is the concept of a `` brain functor . ''
in many adjunctions , the important fact is expressed by either the left or right representation ( e.g. , the ump for the product functor or for the free - group functor considered in the appendix ) , with no need for the `` auxiliary device '' ( such as a diagonal or forgetful functor ) of the other representation used to express the adjunction in a het - free manner .
another payoff from analyzing the important but molecular concept of an adjunction into two atomic representations is that we can then reassemble those atomic parts in a new way to define the cognate concept speculatively named a `` brain functor . ''
the basic intuition is to think of one category @xmath57 in a representation as the `` environment '' and the other category @xmath58 as an `` organism . '' instead of representations within _ each _ category of the hets going _ one way _ between the categories ( as in an adjunction ) , suppose the hets going _ both ways _ were represented within _ one _ of the categories ( the `` organism '' ) . intuitively , a het from the environment to the organism is say , a visual or auditory stimulus . then a left representation would play the role of the brain in providing the re - cognition or perception ( expressed by the intentionality - of - perception slogan : `` seeing is seeing - as '' ) of the stimulus as a perception of , say , a tree where the internal re - cognition is represented by the homomorphism @xmath65 inside the `` organism '' category .
fig7-brain-left-rep.eps figure 7 : perceiving brain presented as a left representation . perhaps not surprisingly , this mathematically models the old philosophical theme in the platonic tradition that external stimuli do not give knowledge ; the stimuli only trigger the internal perception , recognition , or recollection ( as in plato s _ meno _ ) that is knowledge .
in _ de magistro _ ( the teacher ) , the neo - platonic christian philosopher augustine of hippo developed an argument ( in the form of a dialogue with his son adeodatus ) that as teachers teach , it is only the student s internal appropriation of what is taught that gives understanding . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ then those who are called pupils consider within themselves whether what has been explained has been said truly ; looking of course to that interior truth , according to the measure of which each is able .
thus they learn, . but
men are mistaken , so that they call those teachers who are not , merely because for the most part there is no delay between the time of speaking and the time of cognition . and
since after the speaker has reminded them , the pupils quickly learn within , they think that they have been taught outwardly by him who prompts them .
( augustine , _ de magistro _ , chapter xiv ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the basic point is the active role of the mind in generating understanding ( represented by the internal hom ) .
this is clear even at the simple level of understanding spoken words .
we hear the auditory sense data of words in a completely strange language as well as the words in our native language . but the strange words bounce off our minds , like @#$% , with no resultant understanding while the words in a familiar language prompt an internal process of generating a meaning so that we understand the words .
thus it could be said that `` understanding a language '' means there is a left representation for the heard statements in that language , but there is no such internal re - cognition mechanism for the heard auditory inputs in a strange language .
dually , there are also hets going the other way from the `` organism '' to the `` environment '' and there is a similar distinction between mere behavior ( e.g. , a reflex ) and an action that expresses an intention .
mathematically that is described by dualizing or turning the arrows around which gives an acting brain presented as a right representation .
fig8-brain-right-rep.eps figure 8 : acting brain as a right representation . in the heteromorphic treatment of adjunctions ,
an adjunction arises when the hets from one category @xmath57 to another category @xmath58 , @xmath92 for @xmath59 and @xmath60 , have a right representation , @xmath93 , and a left representation , @xmath94 . but
instead of taking the same set of hets as being represented by two different functors on the right and left , suppose we consider a single functor @xmath95 that represents the hets @xmath92 on the left : @xmath96 , and represents the hets @xmath97 [ going in the opposite direction ] on the right : @xmath98 .
if the hets each way between two categories are represented by the same functor @xmath95 as left and right representations , then that functor is said to be a _
brain functor_. thus instead of a pair of functors being adjoint , we have a single functor @xmath95 with values within one of the categories ( the `` organism '' ) as representing the two - way interactions , `` perception '' and `` action , '' between that category and another one ( the `` environment '' ) .
the use of the adjective `` brain '' is quite deliberate ( as opposed to say `` mind '' ) since the universal hets going each way between the `` organism '' and `` environment '' are part of the definition of left and right representations .
in particular , it should be noted how the `` turn - around - the - arrows '' category - theoretic duality provides a mathematical model for the type of `` duality '' between : * sensory or afferent systems ( brain furnishing the left representation of the environment to organism heteromorphisms ) , and * motor or efferent systems ( brain furnishing the right representation of the organism to environment heteromorphisms ) . in view of this application ,
those two universal hets , representing the afferent and efferent nervous systems , might be denoted @xmath99 and @xmath100 as in the following diagrams for the two representations .
fig9-brain-landr.eps figure 9 : left and right representation diagrams for the brain functor @xmath101 .
we have seen how the adjunctive square diagram for an adjunction can be obtained by gluing together the left and right representation diagrams at the common diagonal @xmath90 .
the diagram for a brain functor is obtained by gluing together the diagrams for the left and right representations at the common values of the brain functor @xmath95 .
if we think of the diagram for a representation as right triangle , then the adjunctive square diagram is obtained by gluing two triangles together on the hypotenuses , and the diagram for the brain functor is obtained by gluing two triangles together at the right angle vertices to form the _ butterfly diagram .
_ fig10-butterfly-xa.eps figure 10 : butterfly diagram combining two representations at the common @xmath102 if both the triangular `` wings '' could be filled - out as adjunctive squares , then the brain functor would have left and right adjoints . thus all functors with both left and right adjoints are brain functors ( although not vice - versa ) .
the previous example of the diagonal functor @xmath103 is a brain functor since the product functor @xmath104 is the right adjoint , and the coproduct or disjoint union functor @xmath105 is the left adjoint .
the underlying set functor ( see appendix ) that takes a group @xmath89 to its underlying set @xmath106 is a rather trivial example of a brain functor that does not arise from having both a left and right adjoint .
it has a left adjoint ( the free group functor ) so @xmath107 provides a right representation for the set - to - group maps or hets @xmath108 .
also it trivially provides a left representation for the hets @xmath109 but has no right adjoint . in the butterfly diagram
below , we have labelled the diagram for the brain as the language faculty for understanding and producing speech .
fig11-butterfly-language-faculty.eps figure 11 : brain functor butterfly diagram interpreted as language faculty .
wilhelm von humboldt recognized the symmetry between the speaker and listener , which in the same person is abstractly represented as the dual functions of the `` selfsame power '' of the language faculty in the above butterfly diagram .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ nothing can be present in the mind ( seele ) that has not originated from one s own activity
. moreover understanding and speaking are but different effects of the selfsame power of speech .
speaking is never comparable to the transmission of mere matter ( stoff ) . in the person comprehending as well as in the speaker
, the subject matter must be developed by the individual s own innate power .
what the listener receives is merely the harmonious vocal stimulus.@xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
a non - trivial mathematical example of a brain functor is provided by the functor taking a finite set of vector spaces @xmath110 over the same field ( or @xmath111-modules over a ring @xmath111 ) to the product @xmath112 of the vector spaces .
such a product is also the coproduct @xmath113 @xcite and that space may be written as the biproduct : @xmath114 .
the het from a set of spaces @xmath115 to a single space @xmath116 is a _
cocone _ of vector space maps @xmath117 and the canonical such het is the set of canonical injections @xmath118 ( taking the `` brain '' as a coproduct ) with the `` brain '' at the point of the cocone . the perception left representation then might be taken as conceptually representing the function of the brain as integrating multiple sensory inputs into an interpreted perception . fig12-biprod-left-rep.eps figure 12 : brain as integrating sensory inputs into a perception .
dually , a het from single space @xmath116 to a set of vector spaces @xmath115 is a _ cone _
@xmath119with the single space @xmath116 at the point of the cone , and the canonical het is the set of canonical projections ( taking the `` brain '' as a product ) with the `` brain '' as the point of the cone : @xmath120 . the action right representation then might be taken as conceptually representing the function of the brain as integrating or coordinating multiple motor outputs in the performance of an action .
fig13-biprod-right-rep.eps figure 13 : brain as coordinating motor outputs into an action . putting the two representations together
gives the butterfly diagram for a brain .
fig14-biprod-brain.eps figure 14 : conceptual model of a perceiving and acting brain .
this gives a conceptual model of a single organ that integrates sensory inputs into a perception and coordinates motor outputs into an action , i.e. , a brain .
in view of the success of category theory in modern mathematics , it is perfectly natural to try to apply it in the life and cognitive sciences .
many different approaches need to be tried to see which ones , if any , will find `` where theory lives '' ( and will be something more than just applying biological names to bits of pure math ) . the approach developed here differs from other approaches in several ways , but the most basic difference is the use of heteromorphisms to represent interactions between quite different entities ( i.e. , objects in different categories ) .
heteromorphisms also provide the natural setting to formulate universal mapping problems and their solutions as left or right representations of hets . in spite of abounding in the wilds of mathematical practice ,
hets are not recognized in the orthodox presentations of category theory .
one consequence is that the notion of an adjunction appears as one atomic concept that can not be factored into separate parts .
but that is only a artifact of the homs - only treatment .
the heteromorphic treatment shows that an adjunction factors naturally into a left and right representation of the hets going from one category to another where , in general , one representation might exist without the other .
one benefit of this heteromorphic factorization is that the two atomic concepts of left and right representations can then be recombined in a new way to form the cognate recombinant concept of a brain functor .
the main conclusion of the paper is that this concept of a brain functor seems to fit very well as an abstract and conceptual but non - trivial description of the dual universal functions of a brain , perception ( using the sensory or afferent systems ) and action ( using the motor or efferent systems ) .
since the concept of a brain functor requires hets for its formulation , it is important to consider the role of hets in category theory . the homomorphisms or homs between the objects of a category @xmath57
are given by a hom bifunctor @xmath121 .
in the same manner , the heteromorphisms or hets from the objects of a category @xmath57 to the objects of a category @xmath58 are given by a het bifunctor @xmath122.-valued _ profunctors _ @xcite , _ distributors _ @xcite , or _ correspondences _ @xcite are formally the same as het bifunctors . ]
the @xmath73-bifunctor gives the rigorous way to handle the composition of a het @xmath123 in @xmath124 [ thin arrows @xmath66 for hets ] with a homomorphism or hom @xmath125 in @xmath126 [ thick arrows @xmath127 for homs ] and a hom @xmath128 in @xmath129 .
for instance , the composition @xmath130 is the het that is the image of @xmath131 under the map : @xmath132 .
similarly , the composition @xmath133 is the het that is the image of @xmath131 under the map : @xmath134 .. ] this is all perfectly analogous to the use of @xmath54-functors to define the composition of homs .
since both homs and hets ( e.g. , injection of generators into a group ) are common morphisms used in mathematical practice , both types of bifunctors formalize standard mathematical machinery .
the homs - only orientation may go back to the original conception of category theory `` as a continuation of the klein erlanger programm , in the sense that a geometrical space with its group of transformations is generalized to a category with its algebra of mappings . ''
eilenberg - macl : gentheory while chimeras do not appear in the orthodox `` ontological zoo '' of category theory , they abound in the wilds of mathematical practice . in spite of the reference to `` working mathematician '' in the title of maclane s text @xcite , one might seriously doubt that any working mathematician would give , say , the universal mapping property of free groups using the `` device '' of the underlying set functor @xmath107 instead of the traditional description given in the left representation diagram ( which does not even mention @xmath107 ) as can be seen in most any non - category - theoretic text that treats free groups .
for instance , consider the following description in nathan jacobson s text @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ to summarize : given the set @xmath135 we have obtained a map @xmath136 of @xmath126 into a group @xmath137 such that if @xmath89 is any group and @xmath138 , @xmath139 is any map of @xmath126 into @xmath89 then we have a unique homomorphism of @xmath140 into @xmath89 , making the following diagram commutative : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in jacobson s diagram , only the @xmath142 morphism is a group homomorphism ; the vertical and diagonal arrows are called `` maps '' and are set - to - group hets so it is the diagram for a left representation .
the notion of a homomorphism is so general that hets can always be recast as `` homs '' in a larger category variously called a _ directly connected category _
@xcite ( since pareigis calls the het bifunctor a `` connection '' ) , a _ cograph _
category @xcite , or , more colloquially , a _ collage _ category ( since it combines quite different types of objects and morphisms into one category in total disregard of any connection to the erlangen program ) . the _ collage category _ of a het bifunctor @xmath143 , denoted @xmath144 @xcite , has as objects the disjoint union of the objects of @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
the _ homs _ of the collage category are defined differently according to the two types of objects . for @xmath3 and @xmath145
objects in @xmath57 , the homs @xmath146 are the elements of @xmath147 , the hom bifunctor for @xmath57 , and similarly for objects @xmath17 and @xmath18 in @xmath58 , the homs @xmath148 are the elements of @xmath149 . for the different types of objects such as @xmath3 from @xmath57 and @xmath17 from @xmath58 , the `` homs '' @xmath150 are the elements of @xmath151 and there are no homs @xmath152 in the other direction in the collage category .
does the collage category construction show that `` hets '' are unnecessary in category theory and that homs suffice ?
since all the information given in the het bifunctor has been repackaged in the collage category , any use of hets can always be repackaged as a use of the `` @xmath57-to-@xmath58 homs '' in the collage category @xmath144 . in any application , like the previous example of the universal mapping property ( ump ) of the free - group functor as a left representation
, one must distinguish between the two types of objects and the three types of `` homs '' in the collage category .
suppose in jacobson s example , one wanted to `` avoid '' having the different `` maps '' and group homomorphisms by formulating the left representation in the collage category formed from the category of @xmath16 , the category of groups @xmath153 , and the het bifunctor , @xmath154 , for set - to - group maps .
since the ump does not hold for arbitrary objects and homs in the collage category , @xmath155 , one would have to differentiate between the `` set - type objects '' @xmath126 and the `` group - type objects '' @xmath89 as well as between the `` mixed - type homs '' in @xmath156 and the `` pure - type homs '' in @xmath157 .
then the left representation ump of the free - group functor could be formulated in the het - free collage category @xmath158 as follows .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ for every set - type object @xmath126 , there is a group - type object @xmath159 and a mixed - type hom @xmath160 such that for any mixed - type hom @xmath161 from the set - type object @xmath126 to any group - type object @xmath89 , there is a unique pure - type hom @xmath162 such that @xmath163 .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the answer to the question `` are hets really necessary ? ''
is `` no!''since one can always use sufficient circumlocutions with the _ different _ types of `` homs '' in a collage category . jokes aside , the collage category formulation is essentially only a reformulation of the left representation ump using clumsy circumlocutions . working mathematicians use phrases like `` mappings '' or `` morphisms '' to refer to hets in contrast to homomorphisms and `` mixed - type homs '' does not seem to be improved phraseology for hets
. there is , however , a more substantive point , i.e. , the general umps of left or right representations show that the hets between objects of different categories can be represented by homs _ within _ the codomain category or _ within _ the domain category , respectively .
if one conflates the hets and homs in a collage category , then the point of the representation is rather obscured ( since it is then one set of `` homs '' in a collage category being represented by another set of homs in the same category ) .
there is another het - avoidance device afoot in the homs - only treatment of adjunctions . for instance
, the left - representation ump of the free - group functor can , for each @xmath164 , be formulated as the natural isomorphism : @xmath165 .
but if we fix @xmath89 and use the underlying set functor @xmath166 , then there is trivially the right representation : @xmath167 .
putting the two representations together , we have the heteromorphic treatment of an adjunction first formulated by pareigis @xcite : without any mention of hets .
moreover , the het - avoidance device of the underlying set functor @xmath107 allows the ump of the free group functor to be reformulated with sufficient circumlocutions to avoid mentioning hets .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ for each set @xmath126 , there is a group @xmath159 and a set hom @xmath170 such that for any set hom @xmath171 from the set @xmath126 to the underlying set @xmath106 of any group @xmath89 , there is a unique group hom @xmath162 over in the other category such that the set hom image @xmath172 of the group hom @xmath173 back in the original category satisfies @xmath174 . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ such het - avoidance circumlocutions have no structural significance since there is a general adjunction representation theorem ellerman : whatisct that _ all _ adjoints can be represented , up to isomorphism , as arising from the left and right representations of a het bifunctor . even though the homs - only formulation of an adjunction only ignores the underlying hets ( due to the adjunction representation theorem ) , is that formulation sufficient to give all umps ? or are there important universal constructions that are not either left or right adjoints ?
probably the most important example is the tensor product .
the universal mapping property of the tensor product is particularly interesting since it is a case where the heteromorphic treatment of the ump is forced ( under one disguise or another ) .
the tensor product functor @xmath175 is _ not _ a left adjoint so the usual device of using the other functor ( e.g. , a forgetful or diagonal functor ) to avoid mentioning hets is not available . for @xmath176 modules ( over some commutative ring @xmath111 ) , one category is the product category @xmath177 where the objects are ordered pairs @xmath178 of @xmath111-modules and the other category is just the category @xmath179 of @xmath111-modules .
the values of the @xmath73-bifunctor @xmath180 are the bilinear functions @xmath181
. then the tensor product functor @xmath182 given by @xmath183 gives a left representation : @xmath141{ccc}\left\langle a , b\right\rangle & & \\ ^{\eta_{\left\langle a , b\right\rangle } } \downarrow^ { { } } & \searrow^{f } & \\ a\otimes b & \underset{\exists!\text { } f_{\ast}}{\longrightarrow } & c \end{array }
$ ] for instance , in maclane and birkhoff s _ algebra _ textbook @xcite , they explicitly use hets ( bilinear functions ) starting with the special case of an @xmath111-module @xmath129 ( for a commutative ring @xmath111 ) and then stating the universal mapping property of the tensor product @xmath188 using the left representation diagram @xcite like any other working mathematicians . for any @xmath111-module @xmath129
, there is an @xmath111-module @xmath189 and a canonical bilinear het @xmath190 such that given any bilinear het @xmath191 to an @xmath111-module @xmath192 , there is a unique @xmath111-module hom @xmath193 such that the following diagram commutes .
lambek , j. 1981 . the influence of heraclitus on modern mathematics . in _ scientific philosophy today : essays in honor of mario bunge _ , edited by j. agassi and r. s. cohen , 11121 .
boston : d. reidel publishing co. louie , a. h. 1985 .
categorical system theory . in
_ theoretical biology and complexity : three essays on the natural philosophy of complex systems _ , edited by robert rosen , 68163 .
orlando fl : academic press .
magnan , francois and gonzalo e. reyes 1994 .
category theory as a conceptual tool in the study of cognition . in _
the logical foundations of cognition_. john macnamara and gonzalo e. reyes eds . , new york : oxford university press : 57 - 90 .
makkai , michael .
structuralism in mathematics . in _
language , logic , and concepts : essays in memory of john macnamara _ , edited by r. jackendoff , p. bloom , and k. wynn , 4366 .
cambridge : mit press ( a bradford book ) .
phillips , steven , and william h. wilson . 2014 . chapter 9 : a category theory explanation for systematicity : universal constructions . in _ systematicity and cognitive architecture _ , edited by p. calvo and j. symons , 22749 .
cambridge , ma : mit press .
wood , richard j. 2004 .
ordered sets via adjunctions . in
_ categorical foundations .
encyclopedia of mathematics and its applications vol .
97_. maria cristina pedicchio and walter tholen eds .
, cambridge : cambridge university press : 5 - 47 . | there is some consensus among orthodox category theorists that the concept of adjoint functors is the most important concept contributed to mathematics by category theory .
we give a heterodox treatment of adjoints using heteromorphisms ( object - to - object morphisms between objects of different categories ) that parses an adjunction into two separate parts ( left and right representations of heteromorphisms ) .
then these separate parts can be recombined in a new way to define a cognate concept , the brain functor , to abstractly model the functions of perception and action of a brain .
the treatment uses relatively simple category theory and is focused on the interpretation and application of the mathematical concepts .
the mathematical appendix is of general interest to category theorists as it is a defense of the use of heteromorphisms as a natural and necessary part of category theory . |
multiple astrophysical and cosmological observations have demonstrated that a significant fraction of the matter content of the universe is in the form of new particles not included in the standard model , but belonging to the so - called dark sector ( see @xcite for reviews ) .
the dark matter ( dm ) particles were presumably produced during the very early stages of the universe and must have a relic abundance today @xmath0 @xcite . among the various production mechanisms proposed , the freeze - out mechanism stands among the most appealing and predictive ones . in this framework ,
the dark matter particles were in thermal equilibrium with the standard model particles at very early times , but went out of equilibrium when the temperature reached a value @xmath1 .
below this temperature , the expansion rate became larger than the annihilation rate and therefore the number density of dark matter particles per comoving volume remained practically constant until today , the value being inversely proportional to their annihilation cross section into standard model particles .
the annihilations that lead to the freeze - out of dark matter particles in the early universe presumably continue today , at a much smaller rate , in regions with high dark matter density , such as in galactic centers .
there exists then the possibility of testing the freeze - out mechanism if the flux of energetic particles produced in the annihilations is detected at the earth .
unfortunately , the expected flux from annihilations is typically much smaller than the background fluxes from astrophysical processes , which makes a potential signal difficult to disentangle from the still poorly understood backgrounds .
a promising strategy to identify a dark matter signal is the search for sharp gamma - ray spectral features , such as gamma - ray lines @xcite , internal electromagnetic bremsstrahlung @xcite or gamma - ray boxes @xcite .
most dark matter models predict rather faint sharp spectral features , however , the predicted signatures are qualitatively very different to the ones expected from known astrophysical processes , thus allowing a very efficient background subtraction . as a result , searches for sharp gamma - ray spectral features provide limits on the model parameters which are competitive , and sometimes better , than those from other approaches to indirect dark matter detection .
recent works have thoroughly investigated the generation of sharp gamma - ray spectral features in simplified models , as well as the complementarity of the searches for spectral features with other search strategies , in scenarios where the dark matter particle is a majorana fermion that couples to a standard model fermion via a yukawa coupling @xcite , or in the inert doublet dark matter model @xcite . in this paper , we investigate the generation of sharp gamma - ray spectral features in the toy model of real scalar dark matter considered in ref .
@xcite , where the standard model is extended with a real singlet scalar @xmath2 , candidate for dark matter , and an exotic vector - like fermion @xmath3 , which mediates the interactions with the standard model fermions . in this model ,
the stability of the dark matter particle is ensured by imposing a discrete @xmath4 symmetry , under which @xmath2 and @xmath3 are odd while the standard model particles are even .
we assume for simplicity that the new sector only couples to a right - handed lepton of one generation , @xmath5 , @xmath6 or @xmath7 , in order to suppress potential contributions to lepton flavor violating processes such as @xmath8 . under these simplifying assumptions
the interaction lagrangian of the dark matter particle with the standard model particles reads : @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the standard model higgs doublet .
this model has the peculiarity that the cross section for the tree - level two - to - two annihilation process @xmath11 , which sets the relic abundance over large regions of the parameter space , is d - wave suppressed in the limit @xmath12 .
on the other hand , the processes generating gamma - ray lines at the one loop level @xmath13 or internal bremsstrahlung @xmath14 proceed in the s - wave .
therefore , for values of the parameters leading to the correct relic abundance , the expected indirect detection signals are relatively large compared to other models and , under some conditions , at the reach of present instruments @xcite .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : gamma - ray ]
we present the result for the cross sections and we discuss the relative strength of both signals . in section [ sec : constraints ] we present constraints on the model from perturbativity , thermal production , direct detection , indirect detection with charged cosmic rays and collider experiments . in section [ sec : numerics ] we present a numerical analysis showing the complementarity of all these constraints , under the assumption that the dark matter particle was thermally produced .
finally , in section [ sec : conclusions ] we present our conclusions .
the gamma - ray flux generated by the annihilation of scalar dark matter particles receives several contributions . in this paper
we will concentrate on the generation of sharp gamma - ray spectral features , which , if observed , would constitute a strong hint for dark matter annihilations .
we will neglect , however , the gamma - ray emission generated by the inverse compton scattering of the electrons / positrons produced in the annihilation on the interstellar radiation field , and will only briefly discuss the gamma - rays produced by the decay and hadronization of higgs or gauge bosons since they do not generate sharp features in the gamma - ray spectrum .
the scalar @xmath2 does not have tree - level electromagnetic interactions .
nevertheless , annihilations into one or two photons are possible via higher order effects mediated by the standard model fermion @xmath15 and the exotic fermion @xmath3 , which do carry electroweak charges .
more specifically , the interaction lagrangian with photons of the charged fermions of the model reads : @xmath16 while the interaction lagrangian with the @xmath17 boson reads : @xmath18 the annihilations @xmath19 and @xmath20 are generated at the one loop level , through the diagrams shown in fig .
[ fig : box ] . in the milky way center ,
dark matter particles are expected to be very non - relativistic , @xmath21 , thus generating a monoenergetic photon in the annihilation process . in the limit of zero relative velocity
, the transition amplitude for the annihilation @xmath19 can be cast as @xmath22 as required by gauge invariance .
here , @xmath23 is the polarization vector of the photon , @xmath24 is the electromagnetic fine structure constant , defined as @xmath25 and @xmath26 is a form factor .
the explicit expression for the form factor @xmath26 at the one loop level is rather complicated and is reported in the appendix .
the form factor greatly simplifies in the limit @xmath27 and reads amplitude was calculated for a scenario of mev dark matter , but for the case of couplings to both left- and righthanded fermions , to leading order in @xmath28 . ] : @xmath29 with @xmath30 .. ] finally , the annihilation cross section for @xmath19 is given by @xmath31 on the other hand , the transition amplitude for @xmath32 can be cast , in the zero velocity limit , as @xmath33 where @xmath34 , @xmath35 are the polarization vectors of the @xmath17 boson and the photon , respectively , and @xmath36 is the corresponding form factor , which is reported in the appendix .
the cross section is in this case given by @xmath37 on the other hand , the two - to - three annihilation into a fermion - antifermion pair with the associated emission of a photon results from feynman diagrams shown in fig .
[ fig : vib ] , where the photon can be attached to either of the charged fermions .
the differential cross section for this process reads : @xmath38,\ ] ] with @xmath39 , while the total cross section is given by @xmath40 .
\label{eq : sigmatotal2to3}\ ] ] as it is well known , the gamma - ray spectrum for the two - to - three process displays a sharp peak close to the kinematical endpoint of the spectrum , which becomes more and more prominent as @xmath41 @xcite .
the relative importance of the one loop processes @xmath42 , with @xmath43 , and the three body process @xmath44 is determined by @xmath30 and by @xmath45 .
this dependence is explicitly shown in fig .
[ fig : ratio ] , where we have taken @xmath46 gev for definiteness . for @xmath47
the cross section for the two - to - three process is @xmath48 ( @xmath49 ) times larger than the cross section for @xmath50 ( @xmath20 ) . as @xmath51 increases
, @xmath52 decreases and eventually changes sign at @xmath53 .
accordingly , at this point the @xmath54 cross section vanishes . for larger mass splittings , the relative importance of the one loop processes increases and they become the dominant process when @xmath55 ( @xmath56 ) .
a similar behavior arises in scenarios with majorana dark matter particles coupling to leptons via a yukawa coupling with a scalar field , as discussed in ref .
@xcite .
( or @xmath20 ) and the two - to - three annihilation into @xmath57 , as a function of the parameter @xmath30 . for the plot
it was assumed @xmath58 gev . ]
+ the gamma - ray flux generated by the two - to - three and the one loop annihilation processes depends on the cross sections in those channels .
the dependence of these cross sections on the different parameters of the model is shown in fig .
[ fig : vib_vs_loop ] , where we have fixed in all the plots the yukawa coupling @xmath59 to 1 .
approximate analytic expressions for the cross sections when @xmath60 are @xmath61 from where it is apparent the different dependence of the two - to - three and the loop - induced two - to - two processes with @xmath51 .
as mentioned above , for ( moderately ) small mass splittings @xmath62 between the fermionic mediator and the scalar dark matter particle , the two - to - three process has the largest cross section , while for @xmath55 the one loop processes dominate the annihilation .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : vib_vs_loop ] , top plots , where we show the annihilation cross sections for the relevant processes as a function of the dark matter mass for @xmath63 ( left plot ) and for @xmath64 ( right plot ) .
it is important to note that the values of the cross section when the loop processes dominate are fairly small .
however , this does not imply that the one loop processes can be neglected in this model . as we will show below
, gamma - ray lines can dominate the total gamma - ray energy spectrum , even for smaller values of @xmath51 , due to the sharpness of the gamma - ray line signal compared to the internal bremsstrahlung signal and the fairly good energy resolution of present gamma - ray telescopes , @xmath65 .
we further investigate the dependence of the cross sections with the parameters of the model in fig .
[ fig : vib_vs_loop ] , bottom plots , where we show the cross sections as a function of the degeneracy parameter @xmath51 for two choices of the dark matter mass , @xmath66 gev ( left plot ) and @xmath46 gev ( right plot ) .
again , and as apparent from the plots , for choices of parameters where the one loop processes dominate , the resulting cross section is rather small .
the total energy spectrum of the channels leading to sharp spectral features reads : @xmath67 \,.\ ] ] to investigate the relative strength of the gamma - ray line and the internal bremsstrahlung features , we have calculated the gamma - ray energy spectrum for various choices of @xmath51 assuming a gaussian energy resolution of @xmath68 ; the result is shown in fig .
[ fig : spectrum ] for @xmath63 ( top left ) , 4 ( top right ) , 9 ( bottom left ) and 25 ( bottom right ) .
it is interesting that the gamma - ray lines give a significant contribution to the spectrum for @xmath69 and totally dominate the high energy part of the spectrum when @xmath70 , despite the smaller cross section .
therefore , in the search for gamma - ray spectral features the contribution from gamma - ray lines ought not to be neglected .
the relative importance of the gamma - ray lines will increase with the next generation of gamma - ray telescopes , such as gamma-400 @xcite and dampe @xcite , that aim to an energy resolution of @xmath71 at @xmath72 .
the possibility of observing a spectral feature in the gamma - ray sky arising from scalar dark matter annihilations is subject to a series of theoretical and observational constraints . in this section ,
we discuss each of these constraints individually , while we will study their complementarity in section [ sec : numerics ] , along with the results of the searches for gamma - ray spectral features .
demanding perturbativity of the model translates into an upper bound on the yukawa coupling @xmath59 .
we will use the common condition @xmath73 as a conservative upper limit , however , and since the perturbative calculation of the annihilation and scattering rates is performed as an expansion in @xmath74 , we will also use the condition @xmath75 .
the freeze - out of the dark matter particles from the thermal bath , and accordingly the dark matter relic density , is determined by the following annihilation processes : _
i ) _ the two - to - two annihilation @xmath76 through the yukawa coupling @xmath59 , _ ii ) _ the higher order processes @xmath77 via @xmath78-channel exchange of the heavy fermion @xmath3 and the one loop annihilations @xmath79 ( with @xmath80 ) , _ iii ) _ the two - to - two annihilation @xmath81 via the higgs portal interactions , where @xmath82 , @xmath83 are standard model particles .
we note that the two - to - three annihilation channels @xmath77 ( and to a lesser extent also the one loop annihilations into a pair of gauge bosons ) can contribute significantly to the total cross section at the time of freeze - out , due to the d - wave suppression of the annihilation into @xmath84 .
furthermore , for mass ratios @xmath85 , the relic density is not set by the annihilation channels listed above , but by other ( co-)annihilation processes , the most relevant ones being @xmath86 and @xmath87 , where @xmath88 can be any standard model fermion . in particular , the latter process is present even for @xmath89 .
consequently , for a given mass ratio @xmath62 , there is a lower bound on the dark matter mass @xmath90 , below which these annihilation processes are sufficiently strong to suppress the relic density to values smaller than the observed one .
leading to the observed dark matter relic density , for @xmath91 , and for different values of the mass ratio @xmath62 . ]
we fully take into account all relevant annihilation and coannihilation channels by adapting the micromegas code @xcite for the solution of the boltzmann equation , taking @xmath92 as measured by planck @xcite . in this way , also the increase of the annihilation cross section close to the higgs resonance is included , which suppresses the relic density for @xmath93 and values slightly below . for @xmath94 ,
our results agree reasonably well with @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : ythermal ] we show the yukawa coupling @xmath59 leading to the observed dark matter relic density , for @xmath91 and different choices of the mass ratio @xmath62 . setting the scalar coupling @xmath95 to non - zero values leads to a decrease of @xmath96 with respect to the values shown in fig .
[ fig : ythermal ] . this will be further discussed in section [ sec : numerics ] . the dark matter particle @xmath2 can scatter off nuclei via @xmath78-channel higgs exchange with quarks are possible ; however , the corresponding scattering cross section is heavily suppressed as the first non - zero contribution arises from two - loop diagrams @xcite . ]
. the corresponding spin independent scattering cross section with nucleons is given by @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the dm - nucleon reduced mass , and @xmath99 is the higgs - nucleon coupling .
the latter is subject to significant nuclear uncertainties , in particular it is sensitive to the strangeness content @xmath100 of protons and neutrons . in the following
we use the value @xmath101 , as determined in the recent study @xcite .
furthermore , we fix the higgs mass to be @xmath102 gev .
the present upper limit from the lux experiment @xcite on the spin independent cross section can be used to set a limit on the scalar coupling @xmath95 as a function of the dark matter mass @xmath90 , independently of the values of @xmath59 and @xmath103 .
this limit will be improved in the future by the xenon1 t experiment @xcite , which will have a sensitivity to @xmath104 which is approximately a factor 100 better than the current xenon100 experiment @xcite . the present lux limit , as well as an estimate on the projected sensitivity to @xmath95 of the xenon1 t experiment ,
are shown in fig .
[ fig : lamdaconstraintsdd ] as a solid and a dashed line , respectively . as a function of the dark matter mass derived from the lux data ( solid line ) as well as the prospected sensitivity of the xenon1 t experiment ( dashed line ) . ] in addition to the sharp gamma - ray spectral features , the scalar dark matter model we consider in this paper leads to other potentially observable signals in indirect detection experiments , such as exotic contributions to the antimatter fluxes or the continuum gamma - ray flux .
we will consider first the scenario where the higgs portal coupling is set to zero and will discuss later on the impact of a sizable @xmath95 on the fluxes .
the annihilation channel @xmath105 is necessarily accompanied by the process @xmath106 , leading to the production of antiprotons via the decay and hadronization of the @xmath17 boson ; this has been studied in detail in the context of majorana dark matter @xcite . in the case of the scalar dark matter model at hand , we find for the differential cross section the expression @xmath107+\frac{\xi}{4}(x^2 - 2x+2)\right\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath108 , @xmath109 and @xmath110 .
note that , while the differential cross section for @xmath105 in the case of scalar dm is simply a factor of 8 larger than for majorana dm , this expression for @xmath106 has a different functional dependence on @xmath111 and @xmath59 compared to the corresponding process for majorana dm ( see e.g. @xcite for the latter ) .
the one loop annihilations into @xmath20 and @xmath112 also contribute to the antiproton flux , however , these channels are only relevant when @xmath113 .
in this regime , the resulting antiproton flux is too small to be observed , therefore , the one loop annihilation channels will be neglected in our analysis .
we use calchep @xcite interfaced with pythia @xcite to produce the corresponding injection spectrum of antiprotons .
the propagation to the earth is implemented by using the standard two - zone diffusion model , neglecting energy losses and reacceleration ; hereby , we use the same setup as in @xcite to which we refer the reader for details .
we employ the min , med and max propagation parameters from @xcite in order to bracket the uncertainty arising from the different possible parameters of the propagation model ; furthermore , the analysis is done assuming a nfw halo profile , although this choice does not affect the limits significantly .
finally , solar modulation is included by means of the force - field approximation @xcite with @xmath114 mev .
we then compare the sum of the propagated antiproton spectrum and the expected spallation background , which we take from @xcite , with the pamela @xmath115 data @xcite . we perform a @xmath116-test at @xmath117 c.l . in order to obtain the corresponding constraints on the yukawa coupling @xmath59 .
the resulting limit is shown in fig [ fig : antimatter_constraints ] as a function of the dark matter mass for @xmath118 ( left plot ) , 1.1 ( middle plot ) and 2 ( right plot ) .
we also show for comparison the values of the yukawa coupling @xmath59 leading to the observed relic abundance via thermal freeze - out for any values of @xmath90 and @xmath103 . as apparent from the plots ,
present experiments are not sensitive enough to detect the antiprotons produced in the annihilations of scalar dark matter particles .
besides antiprotons , also electrons and positrons can be produced in the annihilation processes .
however , in contrast to the case of antiprotons , the observed positron fraction @xmath119 is not compatible with the expectation from purely secondary positron production by spallation of cosmic rays .
while the reason for the unexpected rise of the positron fraction as observed by pamela @xcite , fermi - lat @xcite and ams-02 @xcite remains unclear , the extremely precise data from ams-02 can be used for setting strong limits on the annihilation cross section of dark matter into leptonic final states , notably when @xmath120 gev @xcite . in our scenario , for @xmath121 and @xmath122 , the injection spectrum of the positrons arising in the annihilation process @xmath123 exhibits a pronounced spectral feature towards the kinematical end point , which makes it separable from the smooth background , even after taking into account propagation effects . in the following ,
we use the limits on @xmath124 derived in @xcite , and convert them into limits on the yukawa coupling @xmath59 , neglecting the subdominant process @xmath125 .
it is important to note that the limit in @xcite was derived under the assumption @xmath126 , leading to the above - mentioned sharp spectral feature in the positron spectrum .
up to mass ratios @xmath85 , the spectrum of the positrons does not change significantly and our procedure of obtaining the corresponding limits on the yukawa coupling is applicable ; for larger values of @xmath62 , the positron spectrum becomes broader , making it harder to distinguish from the background .
the limits for @xmath127 and 1.1 are shown , respectively , in the left and middle plots of fig .
[ fig : antimatter_constraints ] and , as for the antiprotons , are well above the value required by the freeze - out mechanism . from the lux experiment , together with bounds from pamela and fermi - lat . ] for @xmath128 , new annihilation channels mediated by the standard model higgs open up , the most relevant ones being @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 . in the limit @xmath132 , the annihilation cross sections read @xmath133 \right)^2 \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath134 gev being the vacuum expectation value of the standard model higgs .
these annihilation channels contribute to the antiproton flux , and also lead to a featureless gamma - ray spectrum . in fig .
[ fig : indirectconstraintsmaxlambda ] , we show the annihilation cross sections into these final states , fixing @xmath95 to be the upper limit deduced from the lux experiment ( as shown in fig .
[ fig : lamdaconstraintsdd ] ) .
when comparing to the upper bounds derived in @xcite from the pamela data on the antiproton - to - proton fraction , as well as the latest fermi - lat limits obtained by searches for gamma - ray emission from dwarf galaxies @xcite , we find that these limits from indirect detection are always superseded by the upper limit on @xmath95 from the lux experiment .
note that for simplicity , we only show the pamela and fermi - lat bounds for the annihilation channel @xmath135 ; the constraints for the relevant annihilation channels listed above are all comparable @xcite , leading to the same conclusion .
the scalar dark matter model can be probed at colliders , most notably at the lhc .
a full analysis of the collider constraints is beyond the scope of this work , and we focus on the drell - yan production of a pair of heavy fermions @xmath136 . these particles in turn both decay into the dark matter particle @xmath2 and the standard model lepton @xmath15 ( or @xmath137 ) , leading to a charged lepton pair plus missing energy .
this signal is similar to the slepton search at lhc , however the production cross section for the charged fermion is about one order of magnitude larger than for a charged scalar @xcite , leading to tighter constraints .
we calculate the production cross section @xmath138 using calchep @xcite , and compare it with the upper bound of the production cross section along with the analysis in ref .
the computed production cross section depends only the heavy fermion mass @xmath103 .
the experimental data is taken from atlas with the integrated luminosity of @xmath139 and @xmath140 @xcite . additionally , we estimate a bound from the lep experiment , based on a search for the right - handed selectron in the minimal supersymmetric standard model , with data collected in the energy range @xmath141 @xcite .
this bound does not exactly apply to the model discussed in this work , and hence only serves as an estimation .
we present in this section the constraints on the parameter space of the scalar dark matter model from the negative searches for gamma - ray spectral features , assuming that the dark matter density was generated via thermal freeze - out , as well as the complementarity of these constraints with those discussed in section [ sec : constraints ] from direct detection and collider experiments .
let us discuss separately the scenario where the scalar coupling @xmath95 is small and where it is sizable .
let us discuss first the case where the coupling @xmath95 between the dark matter particle @xmath2 and the standard model higgs doublet is very small , concretely @xmath142 . in this limit , and as argued in section [ sec : constraints ] , the higgs portal interaction is too suppressed to lead to observable signatures in the direct detection experiments lux and xenon1 t or in the indirect detection experiments ams-02 or pamela . in this case ,
the requirement of reproducing the observed dark matter abundance via thermal production fixes the yukawa coupling of the model as a function of @xmath90 and @xmath103 .
we show in fig .
[ fig : sigmav_thermal ] the annihilation cross sections into @xmath105 and @xmath54 for @xmath91 and for @xmath143 ( left plot ) and 3 ( right plot ) as a function of @xmath90 in the scalar dark matter scenario .
these cross sections can be compared to the searches for sharp spectral features in the gamma - ray sky performed by the fermi - lat @xcite and h.e.s.s .
@xcite collaborations .
upper limits on the combined annihilation cross section @xmath144 were derived in @xcite , employing the spectrum of gamma - rays originating from a region close to the galactic center , for a model of majorana dark matter which couples to a heavy scalar and a right - handed standard model fermion @xmath145 via a yukawa coupling .
since the normalized energy spectrum of gamma - rays from the two - to - three processes is identical for the cases of scalar and majorana dark matter , we adopt those limits for our analysis .
these constraints are shown in fig .
[ fig : sigmav_thermal ] , together with the prospected sensitivity of cta @xcite , which we also take from @xcite .
, namely when the two - to - three annihilations into @xmath105 dominate over the one loop annihilations into two photons . for larger mass ratios , @xmath113 , the relative importance of the two - to - three and one loop annihilations is different for majorana and for scalar dark matter and the limits for the former can not be straightforwardly applied for the latter .
due to the mild dependence of the upper limits on @xmath146 on the mass ratio @xcite , we estimate that for @xmath147 the actual upper limits for the scalar dark matter model deviate from these results by at most a factor of two . ]
it follows from fig .
[ fig : sigmav_thermal ] that the fermi - lat and h.e.s.s
. observations are currently probing regions of the parameter space where the scalar dark matter particle is thermally produced , as first mentioned in @xcite .
we also show for comparison the corresponding thermal annihilation cross sections for the analogous model involving a majorana dark matter candidate , as studied in e.g. @xcite , and which is not expected to produce any observable signal in current- or next - generation experiments searching for gamma - ray spectral features , unless a boost factor of the galactic gamma - ray signal is invoked @xcite .
the complementarity of the various search strategies is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : lambda_zero ] , where we show the excluded regions in the parameter space of the scalar dark matter model , spanned by the mass ratio @xmath62 and dark matter mass @xmath90 ( assuming thermal production ) . in the left panel ,
the blue shaded regions enclosed by the solid lines are excluded by fermi - lat or h.e.s.s . , while the red shaded regions surrounded by dashed lines are excluded by collider searches .
the dark gray shaded regions in the right upper part of each plot are ruled out by the conservative perturbativity requirement @xmath148 while the dotted black line shows the points with @xmath149 .
lastly , the gray shaded regions in the lower left corners of the parameter space correspond to choices of parameters where the measured dark matter abundance can not be generated via thermal freeze - out , due to very efficient coannihilations .
it follows from the figures that the parameter space for thermally produced scalar dark matter particles is considerably constrained by the requirement of perturbativity of the theory , by collider searches and by the searches for sharp gamma - ray spectral features . in the right panel of fig .
[ fig : lambda_zero ] , we show the reach of cta on the scalar dark matter model , assuming again thermal production .
remarkably , cta has good prospects to probe practically the whole parameter space , in particular values of the dark matter mass which are inaccessible to present and projected collider searches .
if the coupling @xmath95 is sizable , the direct detection signals can be significantly enhanced , as discussed in section [ sec : constraints ] .
moreover , the higgs portal coupling opens new additional annihilation channels at the time of freeze - out .
therefore , and in order to reproduce to observed dark matter abundance , the yukawa coupling @xmath59 must be smaller compared to the case @xmath91 .
accordingly , the intensity of the gamma - ray spectral features is expected to be smaller in this case than when @xmath91 .
+ we show in fig .
[ fig : lambda_finite ] the parameter space of the scalar dark matter model , spanned by @xmath62 and @xmath90 , for the value of the yukawa coupling @xmath59 leading to the observed dark matter abundance for a fixed value of the coupling @xmath150 ( upper panels ) or 0.1 ( lower panels ) . compared to fig
[ fig : lambda_zero ] , which assumed @xmath91 , we also include in the plots the choices of parameters excluded by the lux experiment ( left panels ) and the projected sensitivity of the xenon1 t experiment ( right panels ) , shown as a hatched region .
moreover , depending on the value of @xmath95 , there is a range of dark matter masses @xmath90 for which the higgs - mediated annihilation channels are sufficiently strong to suppress the relic density below its observed value , independently of the yukawa coupling @xmath59 .
this is indicated in fig .
[ fig : lambda_finite ] by the ( nearly ) vertical gray shaded strips . in particular , it is impossible to obtain the observed relic density for dark matter masses around @xmath151 gev , even for very small values of @xmath95 , due to the resonantly enhanced annihilation processes mediated by the exchange of a higgs particle in the s - channel .
it follows from fig .
[ fig : lambda_finite ] an interesting complementarity between direct detection and collider constraints on the one hand , and searches for gamma - ray spectral features on the other hand : the lux experiment and the lhc constrain the model for dark matter masses below @xmath152 gev ( depending on the value of @xmath95 ) , while the fermi - lat and h.e.s.s .
provide the strongest constraints for larger dark matter masses .
interestingly , some regions of the parameter space have been probed both by direct and indirect searches ( and in some cases also by collider searches ) .
the non observation of a dark matter signal then allows to more robustly exclude that part of the parameter space , in spite of the astrophysical uncertainties that plague the calculation of the direct and indirect detection rates .
conversely , some regions of the parameter space will be probed in the next years both by the xenon1 t experiment and by cta , thus opening the exciting possibility of observing dark matter signals in more than one experiment .
we have studied the generation of sharp gamma - ray spectral features in a toy model consisting in a scalar particle as dark matter candidate , that couples to a heavy exotic vector - like fermion and a standard model fermion via a yukawa coupling .
more specifically , we have calculated the cross section for the processes generating gamma - ray lines at the one loop level and generating line - like features through the two - to - three annihilation into two standard model fermions with the associated emission of a gauge boson .
we have showed that the cross section for the two - to - three process is larger than for the loop annihilation when the fermionic mediator is degenerate in mass with the dark matter particle , the importance of the latter increasing as the ratio between the mediator mass and the dark matter mass becomes larger and larger .
we have also calculated the expected intensity of the sharp spectral features for a dark matter population produced via the freeze - out mechanism . in this model ,
the annihilation cross section into a fermion - antifermion pair proceeds in the d - wave , therefore reproducing the correct relic abundance via thermal production requires a rather large yukawa coupling , which in turn translates into relatively intense indirect detection signals .
in fact , we find that large parts of the parameter space are already excluded by the fermi - lat and h.e.s.s .
searches for line - like features .
we have also investigated the limits on the model from other indirect dark matter searches , direct searches and collider searches , and we have discussed the complementarity of these limits with those from the non - observation of sharp features in the gamma - ray sky .
during the completion of this work , we learned about an analysis of gamma - ray spectral features in the scalar dark matter model @xcite .
their results agree with ours , in the aspects where our analyses overlap .
we are grateful to federica giacchino , laura lopez - honorez and michel tytgat for communications and for sharing with us the results of @xcite .
we also thank celine boehm and stefan vogl for useful discussions .
tt acknowledges support from the european itn project ( fp7-people-2011-itn , pitn - ga-2011 - 289442-invisibles ) .
ai , mt and sw were partially supported by the dfg cluster of excellence `` origin and structure of the universe '' , and sw further acknowledges support from the tum graduate school and the studienstiftung des deutschen volkes .
in this appendix we provide the complete expressions for the form factors @xmath153 and @xmath36 ( see eq . ( [ eq : mgammagamma ] ) and ( [ eq : mgammaz ] ) for its definitions ) .
we work exclusively in the limit @xmath154 , i.e. we only keep the ( dominant ) s - wave term of the annihilation cross sections .
as already mentioned in the main text , our result differs from the one reported in @xcite .
we have checked that our full expression of @xmath160 satisfies the ward identity , and we also cross - checked the imaginary part of @xmath153 with the one deduced from the optical theorem @xcite . in the limit @xmath161 , one can explicitly evaluate all passarino - veltman functions in eq .
( [ eq : exact_gamma ] ) , leading to the result given in eq .
( [ eq : loop - f ] ) .
@xmath163 b_0\left(m_\chi^2;m_f^2,m_\psi^2\right)\nonumber\\ & & -\frac{\epsilon}{1+\mu-\epsilon}\frac{\xi}{4-\xi } b_0\left(4m_\chi^2;m_f^2,m_f^2\right ) -\frac{2\mu}{1+\epsilon-\mu}\frac{\xi}{4-\xi } b_0\left(4m_\chi^2;m_\psi^2,m_\psi^2\right)\nonumber\\ & & + m_\chi^2\left\ { \frac{\epsilon}{2}\frac{4 - 4\epsilon-\xi}{1+\mu-\epsilon } c_0\left(m_z^2,4m_\chi^2,0;m_f^2,m_f^2,m_f^2\right ) + \mu\frac{4 - 4\mu-\xi}{1+\epsilon-\mu } c_0\left(m_z^2,4m_\chi^2,0;m_\psi^2,m_\psi^2,m_\psi^2\right)\right.\nonumber\\ & & + \frac{\epsilon}{2}\left[\frac{\left(4+\xi\right)\left(-2 + 2\mu+2\epsilon+\xi\right ) } { \left(1+\mu-\epsilon\right)\left(4\epsilon-4\mu+\xi\right ) } + \frac{1}{2}\frac{4 - 4\epsilon-\xi}{1+\mu-\epsilon } \right ] c_0\left(-m_\chi^2+\frac{m_z^2}{2},m_\chi^2,0;m_f^2,m_\psi^2,m_f^2\right)\nonumber\\ & & + \frac{\mu}{2}\left[\frac{\left(4+\xi\right)\left(-2 + 2\epsilon+2\mu+\xi\right ) } { \left(1+\epsilon-\mu\right)\left(4\mu-4\epsilon+\xi\right ) } -\frac{8\epsilon}{4\mu-4\epsilon+\xi } \right ] c_0\left(-m_\chi^2+\frac{m_z^2}{2},m_\chi^2,0;m_\psi^2,m_f^2,m_\psi^2\right)\nonumber\\ & & + \left [ \frac{2\xi\left(1+\mu\right)+\epsilon\left(4\mu-\xi\right)}{4\left(1+\mu-\epsilon\right ) } -\frac{4\left(1+\mu\right)}{4-\xi}+\frac{4\mu\left(1+\mu-2\epsilon\right)}{4\mu-4\epsilon+\xi } \right]c_0\left(-m_\chi^2+\frac{m_z^2}{2},m_\chi^2,m_z^2;m_f^2,m_\psi^2,m_f^2\right)\nonumber\\ & & + \left.\left [ \frac{2\mu\left(1-\mu+3\epsilon\right)+\xi\left(1+\epsilon\right ) } { 2\left(1+\epsilon-\mu\right ) } -\frac{4\left(1+\mu+\epsilon\right)}{4-\xi } + \frac{4\epsilon\left(1 + 3\mu+\epsilon\right)}{4\epsilon-4\mu+\xi } \right ] c_0\left(-m_\chi^2+\frac{m_z^2}{2},m_\chi^2,m_z^2;m_\psi^2,m_f^2,m_\psi^2\right ) \right\},\nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] g. bertone , d. hooper and j. silk , phys .
* 405 * ( 2005 ) 279 [ hep - ph/0404175 ] .
l. bergstrom , rept .
* 63 * ( 2000 ) 793 [ hep - ph/0002126 ] .
p. a. r. ade _ et al .
_ [ planck collaboration ] , arxiv:1303.5076 [ astro-ph.co ] .
m. srednicki , s. theisen and j. silk , phys .
* 56 * ( 1986 ) 263 [ erratum - ibid .
* 56 * ( 1986 ) 1883 ] .
s. rudaz , phys .
* 56 * ( 1986 ) 2128 .
l. bergstrom and h. snellman , phys .
d * 37 * ( 1988 ) 3737 .
l. bergstrom , phys .
b * 225 * ( 1989 ) 372 .
r. flores , k. a. olive and s. rudaz , phys .
b * 232 * ( 1989 ) 377 .
t. bringmann , l. bergstrom and j. edsjo , jhep * 0801 * ( 2008 ) 049 [ arxiv:0710.3169 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. ibarra , s. lopez gehler and m. pato , jcap * 1207 * ( 2012 ) 043 [ arxiv:1205.0007 [ hep - ph ] ] .
t. bringmann , x. huang , a. ibarra , s. vogl and c. weniger , jcap * 1207 * ( 2012 ) 054 [ arxiv:1203.1312 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. garny , a. ibarra , m. pato and s. vogl , jcap * 1312 * , 046 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1306.6342 [ hep - ph ] ] . s. chang , r. edezhath , j. hutchinson and m. luty , phys . rev .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 015011 [ arxiv:1307.8120 [ hep - ph ] ] .
h. an , l. -t .
wang and h. zhang , arxiv:1308.0592 [ hep - ph ] .
y. bai and j. berger , jhep * 1311 * ( 2013 ) 171 [ arxiv:1308.0612 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. difranzo , k. i. nagao , a. rajaraman and t. m. p. tait , jhep * 1311 * ( 2013 ) 014 [ arxiv:1308.2679 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. kopp , l. michaels and j. smirnov , jcap * 1404 * ( 2014 ) 022 [ arxiv:1401.6457 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. garny , a. ibarra , s. rydbeck and s. vogl , arxiv:1403.4634 [ hep - ph ] .
m. gustafsson , e. lundstrom , l. bergstrom and j. edsjo , phys .
* 99 * ( 2007 ) 041301 [ astro - ph/0703512 [ astro - ph ] ] .
l. lopez honorez , e. nezri , j. f. oliver and m. h. g. tytgat , jcap * 0702 * ( 2007 ) 028 [ hep - ph/0612275 ] . c. garcia - cely and a. ibarra , jcap * 1309 * ( 2013 ) 025 [ arxiv:1306.4681 [ hep - ph ] ] .
t. toma , phys .
lett . * 111 * , 091301 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1307.6181 [ hep - ph ] ] .
f. giacchino , l. lopez - honorez and m. h. g. tytgat , jcap * 1310 * , 025 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1307.6480 [ hep - ph ] ] . c. boehm , j. orloff and p. salati , phys .
b * 641 * ( 2006 ) 247 [ astro - ph/0607437 ] .
g. bertone , c. b. jackson , g. shaughnessy , t. m. p. tait and a. vallinotto , phys .
d * 80 * , 023512 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.1442 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
s. tulin , h. -b .
yu and k. m. zurek , phys .
d * 87 * , 036011 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1208.0009 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. m. galper , o. adriani , r. l. aptekar , i. v. arkhangelskaja , a. i. arkhangelskiy , m. boezio , v. bonvicini and k. a. boyarchuk _ et al .
_ , adv .
space res .
* 51 * ( 2013 ) 297 [ arxiv:1201.2490 [ astro-ph.im ] ] .
http://dpnc.unige.ch/dampe/index.html .
g. belanger , f. boudjema , a. pukhov and a. semenov , comput .
commun .
* 185 * ( 2014 ) 960 [ arxiv:1305.0237 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. m. cline , k. kainulainen , p. scott and c. weniger , phys .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 055025 [ arxiv:1306.4710 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. kopp , v. niro , t. schwetz and j. zupan , phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 083502 [ arxiv:0907.3159 [ hep - ph ] ] .
d. s. akerib _ et al . _
[ lux collaboration ] , arxiv:1310.8214 [ astro-ph.co ] .
e. aprile [ xenon1 t collaboration ] , arxiv:1206.6288 [ astro-ph.im ] .
e. aprile _ et al .
_ [ xenon100 collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 109 * ( 2012 ) 181301 [ arxiv:1207.5988 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
m. kachelriess , p. d. serpico and m. a. .solberg , phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 123533 [ arxiv:0911.0001 [ hep - ph ] ] .
p. ciafaloni , m. cirelli , d. comelli , a. de simone , a. riotto and a. urbano , jcap * 1106 * ( 2011 ) 018 [ arxiv:1104.2996 [ hep - ph ] ]
. m. garny , a. ibarra and s. vogl , jcap * 1107 * ( 2011 ) 028 [ arxiv:1105.5367 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. garny , a. ibarra and s. vogl , jcap * 1204 * ( 2012 ) 033 [ arxiv:1112.5155 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. pukhov , e. boos , m. dubinin , v. edneral , v. ilyin , d. kovalenko , a. kryukov and v. savrin _ et al .
_ , hep - ph/9908288 .
a. pukhov , hep - ph/0412191 .
t. sjostrand , s. mrenna and p. z. skands , comput .
commun .
* 178 * ( 2008 ) 852 [ arxiv:0710.3820 [ hep - ph ] ] .
f. donato , n. fornengo , d. maurin and p. salati , phys .
d * 69 * ( 2004 ) 063501 [ astro - ph/0306207 ] .
gleeson , l. j. and axford , w. i. , astrophys .
j. 149 ( 1967 ) l115 , and astrophys .
j. 154 ( 1968 ) 1011 .
o. adriani _ et al .
_ [ pamela collaboration ] , phys . rev .
* 105 * ( 2010 )
121101 [ arxiv:1007.0821 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
o. adriani _ et al . _
[ pamela collaboration ] , nature * 458 * ( 2009 ) 607 [ arxiv:0810.4995 [ astro - ph ] ] .
m. ackermann _ et al .
_ [ fermi lat collaboration ] , phys . rev . lett .
* 108 * ( 2012 ) 011103 [ arxiv:1109.0521 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
m. aguilar _ et al . _
[ ams collaboration ] , phys .
* 110 * ( 2013 ) 141102 .
l. bergstrom , t. bringmann , i. cholis , d. hooper and c. weniger , phys .
* 111 * ( 2013 ) 171101 [ arxiv:1306.3983 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
a. ibarra , a. s. lamperstorfer and j. silk , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 063539 [ arxiv:1309.2570 [ hep - ph ] ] .
n. fornengo , l. maccione and a. vittino , jcap * 1404 * ( 2014 ) 003 [ arxiv:1312.3579 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. ackermann _ et al .
_ [ fermi - lat collaboration ] , phys . rev .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 042001 [ arxiv:1310.0828 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
y. bai and j. berger , arxiv:1402.6696 [ hep - ph ] .
s. chang , r. edezhath , j. hutchinson and m. luty , arxiv:1402.7358 [ hep - ph ] .
the atlas collaboration , atlas - conf-2013 - 049 .
lepsusywg , aleph , delphi , l3 and opal experiments , note lepsusywg/04 - 01.1 , + ( http://lepsusy.web.cern.ch/lepsusy/welcome.html ) .
m. ackermann _ et al . _ [ fermi - lat collaboration ] , phys . rev .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 082002 [ arxiv:1305.5597 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
a. abramowski _ et al .
_ [ h.e.s.s .
collaboration ] , phys .
* 110 * ( 2013 ) 041301 [ arxiv:1301.1173 [ astro-ph.he ] ] . k. bernlhr , a. barnacka , y. becherini , o. blanch bigas , e. carmona , p. colin , g. decerprit and f. di pierro _ et al . _ ,
astropart .
* 43 * ( 2013 ) 171 [ arxiv:1210.3503 [ astro-ph.im ] ]
. f. giacchino , l. lopez - honorez and m. tytgat , submitted to arxiv .
r. mertig , m. bohm and a. denner , comput .
commun .
* 64 * ( 1991 ) 345 .
t. hahn and m. perez - victoria , comput .
commun .
* 118 * ( 1999 ) 153 [ hep - ph/9807565 ] . | the search for sharp features in the gamma - ray spectrum is a promising approach to identify a signal from dark matter annihilations over the astrophysical backgrounds . in this paper
we investigate the generation of gamma - ray lines and internal bremsstrahlung signals in a toy model where the dark matter particle is a real scalar that couples to a lepton and an exotic fermion via a yukawa coupling .
we show that the fermi - lat and h.e.s.s .
searches for line - like spectral features severely constrain regions of the parameter space where the scalar dark matter is thermally produced .
finally , we also discuss the complementarity of the searches for sharp spectral features with other indirect dark matter searches , as well as with direct and collider searches . |
there have been many reviews of positron physics over the years @xcite .
more recently @xcite and @xcite considered the subject with an emphasis on experimental measurements involving noble gas targets .
the related topic of antihydrogen formation has also been thoroughly reviewed @xcite .
resonances and the closely related bound states of positrons with atoms and molecules has also been extensively discussed @xcite .
this work concentrates on the progress in application of theoretical methods to scattering processes in a quantum few - body system involving positrons as projectiles and multi - electron atomic targets with explicit treatment of positronium formation .
particular emphasis is on the developments taken place since the comprehensive review of positron physics by @xcite .
it begins by describing the currently available theories of low - energy positron collisions with atoms and simple molecules .
then it describes the development and application of the two - centre convergent close - coupling method , which explicitly treats the ps - formation processes .
developments in positron physics have resulted in several technologies in medicine and material science . in medicine , the use of the positron emission tomography ( pet ) scanners help to make diagnoses of cancer detection and of certain brain function disorders .
material science uses positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy ( pals ) , to analyze and design specific materials .
the critical component is positronium ( ps ) formation with its annihilation providing the key signature of its origin .
ps is a short - lived exotic atom of a bound positron - electron pair that has similar structure to atomic hydrogen .
scattering experiments are the main tool of modern physics to learn about the structure of matter . by analyzing collision products we can extract useful information about the objects being studied .
historically , ordinary matter particles like electrons and protons were predominantly used as scattering particles in experimental atomic and molecular physics . with
the development of positron and antiproton beams , studies of interactions of these particles with matter became possible .
the last decade has seen significant progress in low - energy trap - based positron beams @xcite .
new high - resolution experimental measurements have been performed for a range of atomic and molecular targets including he @xcite , ne and ar @xcite , xe @xcite , kr @xcite h@xmath0 @xcite and h@xmath0o @xcite .
the development of positron beams motivated novel experimental and theoretical studies .
particularly important are the positronium - formation cross sections , see the recent recommendations of @xcite . in addition
, interest has been motivated by possible binding of positrons to atoms @xcite . theoretical description of electron - impact ionisation ( and excitation ) processes has seen significant progress in recent years due to the development of various highly sophisticated methods including the exterior complex scaling ( ecs ) @xcite , r - matrix with pseudo - states ( rmps ) @xcite , time - dependent close - coupling ( tdcc ) @xcite and convergent close coupling ( ccc ) @xcite .
a review of electron - induced ionisation theory has been given by @xcite .
such problems are examples of a class where there is only one `` natural '' centre , namely the atomic centre .
all coordinates are readily written with the origin set at the atomic centre .
yet there are many atomic collision systems of practical and scientific interest that involve at least two centres , such as the positron - hydrogen scattering system .
this is a three - body system where all the particles are distinguishable , and which allows for their rearrangement .
here we have two `` natural '' centres , the atomic centre and the positronium ( ps ) centre . for positron - hydrogen scattering ionisation
now splits into two separate components : the rearrangement process of ps - formation and the three - body breakup process .
a proper formulation of ps - formation processes requires a combined basis consisting of two independent basis sets for each of the centres which makes theoretical studies considerably more challenging than for electron - scattering .
furthermore , the positron - atom system is an ideal prototype of the ubiquitous collision systems such as proton - atom scattering , where charge - exchange processes also require a two - centre treatment , see @xcite for example .
every positron - atom scattering system has an ionisation ( breakup ) threshold above which an electron may be freely ejected . at 6.8 ev below this threshold
is the ps formation threshold . at higher energies excitation or ionization of the target
can take place .
in addition , for multi - electron targets there could be many more reaction channels such as multiple ionisation and ionisation - with - excitation .
for molecular targets there could be rovibrational excitation and dissociation .
another reaction channel is the positron - electron pair annihilation , which can occur at any scattering energy . in this process
the positron collides with one of the target s electrons and annihilates into 2 or 3 gamma rays .
theoretical @xcite and experimental studies @xcite of the annihilation process have shown that its cross section is up to 10@xmath1 times smaller than the elastic - scattering cross section
. therefore the annihilation channel is often omitted from scattering calculations . the elastic scattering , excitation , ps formation and ionisation are the dominant channels of primary interest .
the first theoretical studies of positron scattering from atoms date back to the 1950s , when @xcite used the first born approximation ( fba ) to describe ps - formation in e@xmath2-h collisions .
the born method is based on the assumption that the wavefunction for the scattering system can be expanded in a rapidly convergent series .
this approximation consists in using plane waves to describe the projectile and scattered particles .
the born approximation is reliable when the scattering potential is relatively small compared to the incident energy , and thus is applicable only at high energies .
therefore this method is mainly focused on high - energy excitation and ionization processes .
one of the most successful methods applied to the low - energy e@xmath2-h elastic - scattering problem is the kohn variational method .
the method was initially developed for scattering phase shifts in nuclear reactions by @xcite .
later this method was extended to positron - hydrogen scattering by @xcite .
a detailed description of the method was given by @xcite .
the method is based on finding the form of the functional ( called kohn functional ) involving the phaseshift as a parametric function of the total wavefunction . requiring the functional to be stationary with respect to the variations of the parameters , generates equations for the linear parameters .
the phaseshifts can be accurately obtained by performing iterative calculations and finding the values of the nonlinear parameters that make the functional stationary .
the many - body theory of @xcite utilizes techniques that originated from quantum field theory . using the feynman - diagram technique
the perturbation series in the interaction between particles can be written in an intuitive way . when it is applied to positron - atom scattering , however , difficulties arise due to necessity to take into account ( virtual ) ps formation
. however , a finite number of perturbation - theory terms can not describe a bound ps state .
@xcite developed a sophisticated method based on the many - body perturbation theory .
they used an approximation by considering virtual ps formation only in the ground state .
the calculations with this method showed that for elastic scattering of positrons on hydrogen ( and helium atoms ) , the virtual ps - formation contribution was almost 30% and 20% of the total correlation potential , respectively . @xcite
have further improved the method by introducing the techniques for the exact summation of the electron - positron ladder diagram series .
the method was applied to @xmath3 scattering below the ps - formation threshold , and resulted in good agreement with accurate variational calculations .
the momentum - space coupled - channel optical ( cco ) potential method was first developed for electron - atom scattering in the 1980s by @xcite .
the method relies on constructing a complex equivalent local potential to account for the ionization and the ps - formation channels .
the cco method gave excellent ionization @xcite , total and ps formation @xcite cross sections for positron scattering on hydrogen .
@xcite used the cco method to study excitation of atomic hydrogen from the metastable 2s state .
following @xcite @xcite developed the so - called two - center two - channel eikonal final state - continuum initial distorted - wave model to calculate ps formation in the ground and the lowest excited states .
they also presented a @xmath4 scaling law for formation of ps(@xmath5 ) cross sections on the entire energy range with @xmath6 varying as a function of the positron incident energy .
a hyperspherical hidden crossing ( hhc ) method has been applied to positron - impact ionization of hydrogen near the threshold by @xcite .
they have calculated the ionization cross - section for s , p and d - waves .
the hhc has also been used to calculate partial - wave ps(1@xmath6)-formation cross sections for low - energy positron collisions with h , li and na atoms @xcite .
one of the most sophisticated and commonly used methods is the close - coupling ( cc ) formalism , which is based on the expansion of the total wavefunction using the target - state wavefunctions .
substitution of this expansion into the schrdinger equation yields coupled differential equations in coordinate space , or lippmann - schwinger integral equations for the t - matrix in momentum space . by solving these equations
the transition amplitudes are obtained for all open channels .
considerable pioneering work in this field has been done by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , who demonstrated the success of using two - centre expansions consisting of ps and atomic states . here and below
when we discuss close - coupling calculations we denote the combined two - centre basis , used to expand the total scattering wavefunction , as ( @xmath7 ) , where @xmath8 is the number of atomic ( negative - energy ) eigenstates and @xmath9 is the number of positronium eigenstates .
we also use a bar to indicate ( negative- and positive - energy ) pseudostates .
for instance , cc(@xmath10 ) refers to close - coupling calculations with a combined basis made of @xmath8 pseudostates for the atomic centre supplemented by @xmath9 ps eigenstates .
@xcite performed the first accurate two - state cc(1,1 ) calculation .
this work known as the static - exchange approximation showed a giant spurious resonance near 40 ev incident positron energy .
absence of such a resonance was demonstrated by @xcite using a larger cc(@xmath11 ) calculation that included @xmath6 , @xmath12 , and @xmath13-type pseudostates for both centres .
however , the cc(@xmath11 ) gave new spurious resonances above the ionization threshold .
an energy - averaging procedure was used to get smooth results for the cross sections to get rid of the pseudoresonances .
considerable progress in the description of e@xmath2-h has been made by @xcite by using the close - coupling approach .
@xcite have performed convergence studies for the full positron - hydrogen problem at low energies . below the ionization threshold they showed good agreement of sufficiently large pseudostate close - coupling calculations and the benchmark variational calculations of ps formation by @xcite .
the convergent close - coupling ( ccc ) method was first developed for e@xmath14-h scattering by @xcite .
its modification to positron scattering in a one - centre approach was trivial in that electron exchange was dropped and the interaction potentials changed sign @xcite .
the ccc method with a ( @xmath15 ) basis , i.e. a single atomic - centre expansion without any ps states , gave very good results for the total , elastic , excitation and ionization cross sections at higher incident energies where the ps - formation cross section is small allowing for distinction between two experimental data sets @xcite .
the ccc calculations showed no pseudoresonances so long as a sufficiently large basis was taken .
following the success of the large single - centre ccc calculations , @xcite and @xcite used a large basis for the atomic centre supplemented by a few eigenstates of ps .
calculations with the ( @xmath16 ) and ( @xmath17 ) bases , made of a large atomic basis similar to that of @xcite and the three lowest - lying eigenstates of ps , gave results significantly better than those from the ( @xmath11 ) basis @xcite .
the ccc method with a ( @xmath18 ) basis was developed by @xcite to study convergence in two - centre expansions .
this was applied to positron scattering on hydrogen within the s - wave model retaining only @xmath6-states in the combined basis .
this work for the first time demonstrated the convergence of the ( non - orthogonal ) two - centre expansions .
the convergence in all channels was only possible when two independent near - complete laguerre bases are employed on both of the centres .
interestingly , the total ionisation cross section had two independently converged components .
one component was coming from the atomic centre and represented direct ionisation of the hydrogen atom , the other came from the ps centre and represented ps formation in the continuum .
the convergence in the case of the full positron - hydrogen scattering problem was demonstrated by @xcite .
the ccc calculations with such a combined two - centre basis have shown very good agreement with the experimental measurements of @xcite and @xcite .
theoretical investigations of positron scattering from helium has an additional challenge due to the complexity of the target structure . in multi - electron targets two - electron excitation ( or ionization with excitation ) channels are usually excluded .
this is a good approximation as the contribution of these channels is typically two orders of magnitude smaller than the corresponding one - electron excitation processes @xcite
. first calculations of e@xmath2-he scattering have been performed by @xcite in the fba .
they used only the ground states for he and ps and obtained cross sections for elastic scattering and ps formation in its ground state .
their study highlighted the importance of the ps - channel coupling with the elastic channel and thereby motivated further studies .
another extensive study based on the born approximation was presented by @xcite , to estimate ps - formation cross section in arbitrary s - states . from the fba studies it became clear that more sophisticated approaches to the problem were required . the distorted - wave born approximation ( dwba ) results are obtained by using distorted wavefunctions in first - order calculations .
this method can give more accurate results than the fba down to lower energies .
studies utilizing the dwba by @xcite were applied to the helium @xmath19 and @xmath20 excitations by positrons in the energy range from near the threshold up to 150 ev . although the agreement with the experimental data was not very satisfactory , the method indicated the importance of the inclusion of the polarization potential in the excitation channels at low energies .
the most systematic study of the ionisation process within the framework of dwba was carried out by @xcite .
they used coulomb and plane waves and also included exchange effects .
they obtained good agreement with the experimental results of @xcite and @xcite over the energy range from near - threshold to 500 ev .
however , the most important and difficult channel , ps formation , was not included in the early dwba studies .
@xcite calculated the differential and total cross sections for the excitation of the helium @xmath21 state using the second - order dwba method .
another dwba method including ps channels has been reported by @xcite for intermediate to high scattering energies .
they have calculated ps - formation cross section and achieved good agreement with available experimental data above 60 ev . however , their results were not accurate for ps formation below 60 ev .
considering the fact that ps formation starts at 17.8 ev and reaches its maximum around 40 ev , the applicability of this method is quite limited .
@xcite applied the random - phase approximation ( rpa ) , based on many - body theory @xcite , to positron - helium scattering at low energies . by using an approximate account of virtual ps formation they obtained good agreement with the elastic - scattering experimental data of @xcite and @xcite at the lowest energies .
a similar rpa method was used by @xcite to calculate positron impact excitation of he into 2@xmath22s and 2@xmath22p states . as mentioned above
, @xcite developed a more sophisticated method based on the many - body perturbation theory .
the calculations with this method showed that the contribution from virtual ps formation was significant .
applications of the method to various atomic targets were reported by @xcite and @xcite .
the kohn variational method was first applied to positron - helium collisions by humberston et al .
a comprehensive study of positron - helium scattering with the kohn variational method was given by @xcite .
they obtained very accurate cross sections at low energies .
however , agreement with the experimental results of @xcite and @xcite for ps - formation cross section was qualitative , with a similar energy dependence but with almost 25% difference in magnitude .
nevertheless , very good agreement was obtained for the total cross section below the ps - formation threshold .
the cco method , mentioned earlier , was applied to positron scattering on helium by @xcite .
they calculated the total and ps - formation cross sections from the ps - formation threshold to 500 ev .
the calculated results agreed well with the corresponding experimental data except for the data of @xcite for the total cross section in the energy range from 50 to 100 ev .
@xcite applied a polarized - orbital approximation method to low - energy elastic positron - helium scattering and obtained good agreement with the experimental results .
other calculations using optical potentials were presented by @xcite and by @xcite for slow - positron scattering from helium .
elastic - scattering cross sections of both reports were in good agreement with experimental data .
in general , the optical - potential methods proved to be useful for calculations of total cross sections .
they are problematic , however , when applied to more detailed cross sections like target excitation and ps formation in excited states .
@xcite utilized the classical - trajectory monte - carlo ( ctmc ) technique to model positron scattering .
the method is described fully for ion - atom collisions by @xcite and by @xcite . using this technique , @xcite calculated differential ionization cross section for positron - helium and also positron - krypton collisions .
the main advantage of this method is that it can describe dynamic effects occurring in collisions .
for instance , the ctmc calculations showed that the probability of positron scattering to large angles after ionising the target , may be comparable , or even much greater than , the probability of positronium formation .
they suggested that the disagreement between theory and experiment above 60 ev might be resolved by accounting for the flux in the experiments measuring positronium formation due to positrons scattered to angles that allow them to escape confinement .
@xcite also applied the ctmc method to helium ionization by positron impact .
they obtained good agreement with experimental data of @xcite .
results of ctmc reported by @xcite overestimate the recent experimental data by @xcite for the ps - formation cross section below 60 ev .
this questions the applicability of the classical trajectory approach to positron scattering at low and intermediate energies .
a very comprehensive study of positron - helium scattering using the close - coupling method was carried out by @xcite .
they used two kinds of expansions , the first one consisting of 24 helium eigen- and pseudostates and the lowest three ps eigenstates , and the second one with only 30 helium eigen- and pseudo - states .
the helium - target structure was modeled using a frozen - core approximation , which can produce good excited states , but a less accurate ground state .
the atomic pseudostates were constructed using a slater basis . for the 27-state approximation ,
only results in the energy range above the positronium - formation threshold were given .
results for lower energies were unsatisfactory , and it was suggested that this might be due to the lack of convergence from the use of an inaccurate helium ground - state wavefunction .
the total cross sections from both the 27- and 30-state approaches agreed well with the experimental results of @xcite , @xcite and @xcite for the energy range above the threshold of positronium formation .
for lower energies , qualitative agreement was obtained in terms of the shape and the reproduction of the ramsauer - townsend minimum near 2 ev , while the theoretical results were a factor of 2 larger than the experimental data .
the ps - formation cross section from the 27-state approximation was in good agreement with the experimental data of @xcite up to about 60 ev and with the data of @xcite and @xcite up to 90 ev .
above 100 ev the calculations were much lower than the experimental data of @xcite and @xcite while being closer to the data of @xcite .
another close - coupling calculation by @xcite , using a few helium and positronium states with a one - electron description of the helium atom , showed less satisfactory agreement with the experimental data .
chaudhuri and adhikari @xcite performed calculations using only 5 helium and 3 positronium states in the expansion .
their results for ps formation agreed well with the experimental results by @xcite at energies near the ps threshold and displayed a better agreement with the data of @xcite at the higher energies .
however , the theoretical results were much lower than the experimental data at energies near the maximum of the cross section .
@xcite applied the hyper - spherical cc approach to the problem .
however , they also considered helium as a one - electron target , and thus the excitation and ps - formation cross sections were multiplied by factor of 2 .
satisfactory results were obtained for the total ps - formation and he(2@xmath22s ) and he(2@xmath22p ) excitation cross sections .
the method was not able to describe low - energy scattering mainly because a one - electron approach to helium is not realistic at low energies . despite the obvious advantages of the above - mentioned close - coupling calculations in handling many scattering channels simultaneously , none was able to describe low - energy elastic scattering .
in addition , the presence of pseudo - resonances in cross sections below the ionization threshold @xcite indicated that there was room for improvement .
the use of the frozen - core he states also needed some attention as this yielded an inaccurate result for the ground state of helium .
the first application of the single - centre ccc method to positron scattering on helium was made by @xcite , using very accurate helium wavefunctions obtained within the multi - core approximation .
very accurate elastic cross section was obtained below the ps - formation threshold by using orbitals with very high angular momenta .
it was suggested that the necessity for inclusion of very high angular - momentum orbitals was to mimic the virtual ps - formation processes .
the method also gave accurate results for medium to high - energy scattering processes except that it was unable to explicitly yield the ps - formation cross section .
interestingly , the method was not able to produce a converged result at the ore - gap region ( where only the elastic and ps - formation channels are open ) , which we shall discuss later in sec .
[ intcont ] .
comparison of the frozen - core and the multi - core results showed that the frozen - core wavefunctions lead to around 10% higher cross sections .
@xcite demonstrated that single - centre expansions can give correct results below the ps - formation threshold and at high energies where the probability of ps formation is small , but for the full solution of the problem inclusion of the ps centre into expansions was required .
the initial application of the two - centre ccc approach to the problem was within the frozen - core approximation @xcite .
it was then extended to a multi - core treatment @xcite . while generally good agreement was found with experiment from low to high energies certain approximations made need to be highlighted .
the key problematic channels are those of the type ps - he@xmath2 .
electron exchange between ps and he@xmath2 is neglected .
excitation of he@xmath2 is also neglected . while these may seem reasonable approximations for the helium target due to its very high ionisation threshold ( 24.6 ev for he and 54.4 ev for he@xmath2 ) , they become more problematic for quasi two - electron targets such as magnesium , discussed below . positron scattering from the helium @xmath23 metastable state has been theoretically studied for the first time by @xcite at low and intermediate energies
. converged results for the total , ps - formation and breakup cross sections have been obtained with a high degree of convergence .
the obtained cross sections turned out to be significantly larger than those for scattering from the helium ground state .
alkali atoms have an ionisation threshold that is lower than 6.8 ev .
consequently , for positron scattering on alkalis the elastic and ps - formation channels are open at all incident - positron energies .
for this reason , theory has to treat appropriately the `` competition '' for the valence electron between the two positively charged centers , the singly - charged ionic core and the positron .
positron scattering on the lithium target was investigated by @xcite using a one - center expansion . however , convergence was poor due to the absence of ps - formation channels @xcite .
two - center expansion was employed by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . as expected , these approaches gave better agreement with the experiment .
for positron - lithium case the two - center ccc approach to positron collisions with lithium was reported by @xcite .
this is the most comprehensive study of the problem on an energy range spanning six orders of magnitude .
while convergence was clearly established , and agreement with experiment for the total ps - formation cross section @xcite is satisfactory , smaller experimental uncertainties would be helpful to provide a more stringent test of the theory .
positron scattering from atomic sodium has been intensively studied for more than two decades .
the first theoretical calculations relied on simple two - center decomposition of the system wavefunction with only the ground states of sodium and ps atoms taken into account @xcite .
then , @xcite conducted more complex close - coupling calculations , adding several low - lying excited states for each positively - charged center .
the obtained results turned out to be in reasonably good agreement with experimental data for both total @xcite and ps - formation @xcite cross sections .
further enlargement of the number of channels in the close - coupling calculations revealed that the theoretical ps - formation cross sections @xcite deviated systematically from the experimental results for low impact energies .
the experiment showed that the ps - formation cross section became larger with decreasing energy while the most refined theoretical calculations utilizing different methods of solution predicted consistently the opposite . to resolve the discrepancy @xcite conducted the experimental study on ps formation in positron collisions with li and na atoms .
this experiment confirmed the earlier results of @xcite .
the authors managed to extend the impact - energy range down to 0.1 ev where the discrepancy between the theory and experiment was even larger for sodium . in striking contrast , for lithium the reasonable agreement of the measured cross section with the theoretical predictions was obtained with the use of the same methodology .
@xcite applied the optical - potential approach .
they found that their theoretical cross section increases with the decrease in the impact energies below 1 ev , but faster than the experimental results .
unfortunately , this result was obtained with the use of some approximations , whose validity were not analyzed .
it would be instructive if the same optical - potential approach was applied to the case of positron scattering on lithium .
@xcite calculated ps - formation in positron - alkali collisions with the use of the hyper - spherical close - coupling method .
their results support the previous theoretical data @xcite .
large two - center ccc calculations of positron scattering by atomic sodium were reported by @xcite . despite being the most comprehensive to date
there was no resolution of the discrepancy with experiment for ps formation at low energies , which we will highlight in sec [ alkali - results ] .
while the lighter alkali atoms are well - modeled by a frozen - core hartree - fock approximation , or even an equivalent local core potential , the heavier ones become more problematic . with a reduced ionisation threshold positron interaction with the core electrons , either directly or via exchange of the valence and the core electrons , becomes a more important component of the interaction . to the best of our knowledge
this has not been addressed to a demonstrable level of convergence by any theory . nevertheless , assuming that such problems are more likely to be a problem at the higher energies , @xcite considered threshold behaviour of the elastic and ps - cross sections , and their convergence properties at near - zero energies for li , na and k. this work confirmed the expected threshold law proposed by @xcite , but was unable to resolve the discrepancy with the positron - sodium experiment at low energies .
some earlier studies by @xcite and @xcite at low to intermediate energies were performed at a time when convergence was computationally impossible to establish .
@xcite further developed the cco method to study positron scattering on rubidium at intermediate and high energies .
they calculated the ps - formation and total cross sections .
their total cross section results appear to overestimate the experiment . though outside the scope of this review we note that the complex scaling method was recently used to study resonance phenomena in positron scattering on sodium @xcite and potassium @xcite .
magnesium can be thought of as a quasi two - electron target with the core electrons being treated by the self - consistent field hartree - fock approach .
positron scattering on magnesium is particularly interesting due to a large resonance in elastic scattering identified at low energies by @xcite .
this was confirmed , though at a slightly different energy , by the one - centre calculations of @xcite which were able to be taken to convergence in the energy region where only elastic scattering was possible .
minor structure differences are likely to be responsible for the small variation in the position of the resonance .
two - centre ccc calculations @xcite also reproduced the resonance , but had to make substantial approximations when treating the ps - mg@xmath2 interaction .
this is even more problematic than in the case of helium discussed above since now we have a multi - electron hartree - fock core .
agreement with experiment is somewhat variable , but there are substantial experimental uncertainties , particularly in the ps - formation cross section . other theoretical studies of positron - magnesium scattering include those by @xcite .
inert gases heavier than helium represent a particular challenge for theory , which is unfortunate because they are readily accessible experimentally @xcite .
just the target structure is quite complicated , but some good progress has been made in the case of electron scattering by @xcite .
for positron scattering once ps forms , the residual ion is of the open - shell type making full electron exchange incorporation particularly problematic .
the relatively high ionisation thresholds for such targets mean that there is always a substantial ore gap where the ps - formation cross section may be quite large , but unable to be obtained in one - centre calculations which are constrained to have only elastic scattering as the open channel .
nevertheless , outside the extended ore gap , formed by the ps - formation and the ionisation thresholds , one - centre ccc calculations can yield convergent results in good agreement with experiment @xcite .
there are also first - order perturbative calculations by @xcite and some based on close - coupling with convergence not fully established , see @xcite .
@xcite studied positron scattering and annihilation on noble - gas atoms using many - body theory at energies below the ps - formation threshold .
they demonstrated that at low energies , the many - body theory is capable of providing accurate results .
@xcite used an impulse approximation to describe ps scattering on inert gases and provided quantitative theoretical explanation for the experimentally - observed similarity between the ps and electron scattering for equal projectile velocities @xcite . according to @xcite this happens due to the relatively weak binding and diffuse nature of ps , and the fact that electrons scatter more strongly than positrons off atomic targets .
@xcite developed a model - potential approach to positron scattering on noble - gas atoms based on an adiabatic method that treats the positron as a light nucleus .
the method was applied to calculate the elastic cross section below the ps - formation threshold .
positron collisions with molecular hydrogen have been studied extensively by various experimental groups over the last 30 years @xcite .
theoretical studies of this scattering system are challenging because of the complexities associated with the molecular structure and its non - spherical nature .
rearrangement processes add another degree of complexity to the problem . until recently theoretical studies
@xcite have been focused only at certain energy regions .
in addition , there are few theoretical studies which include the ps - formation channels explicitly .
the first calculations of ps - formation cross section @xcite were obtained with the use of the first born approximation .
@xcite used a coupled - static model , which only included the ground states of h@xmath0 and ps .
this simple model was until recently the only coupled - channel calculation available .
comprehensive review of the positron interactions with atoms and molecules has been given by @xcite .
@xcite have recently reported the total cross section for positron scattering from the ground state of h@xmath0 below the ps - formation threshold using density functional theory with a single - center expansion .
their results are in good agreement with recent single - centre ccc calculations of @xcite below 1 ev .
@xcite have also performed analysis of experimental and theoretical uncertainties using a modified effective range theory ( mert ) .
they concluded that a practically constant value of the total cross section between 3 ev and the ps - formation threshold is likely to be an effect of virtual ps formation .
the recent single - centre ccc calculations of positron scattering on molecular hydrogen by @xcite and antiproton collisions with h@xmath0 by @xcite have shown that the ccc formalism can also be successfully applied to molecular targets . in order to obtain explicit ps - formation cross section a two - centre approach is required , with the first attempt presented by @xcite .
they found some major challenges associated with the ps - h@xmath24 channel .
some severe approximations were required in order to manage the non - spherical h@xmath24 ion . nevertheless , some good agreement with experiment was found , see sec .
[ h2-results ] , but considerably more work is required . a major application of positron - hydrogen scattering is to provide a mechanism for antihydrogen formation .
the idea is fairly simple , with some accurate calculations performed quite some time ago @xcite .
the basic idea is to time reverse the ps - formation process to hydrogen formation from ps scattering on a proton , and then to use the resultant cross sections for the case where the proton is replaced by an antiproton , and hence forming antihydrogen @xmath25 the advantage of antihydrogen formation via this process is that it is exothermic and so the cross section tends to infinity as the relative energy goes to zero @xcite .
this behaviour is enhanced in the case of excited states with degenerate energy levels @xcite .
antihydrogen formation is presently particularly topical due to several groups ( aegis @xcite , gbar @xcite , atrap @xcite , asacusa @xcite and alpha @xcite ) attempting to make it in sufficient quantity in order to perform spectroscopic and gravitational experiments .
@xcite provided ccc results for ps energy starting at @xmath26 ev , which suffices for currently experimentally accessible energies of around 25 mev .
recent calculations of the cross sections for these processes will be discussed in sec .
[ antih ] . in this section
we gave a general historical overview of various theoretical developments related to positron scattering on atomic targets and the h@xmath0 molecule .
in the next section we consider in some detail basic features of the coupled - channel formalism mainly in the context of convergent close - coupling method and discuss the latest results .
here we describe basics of the close coupling approach based on the momentum - space integral equations .
we consider the simplest case of scattering in a system of three particles : positron ( to be denoted @xmath27 ) , proton ( @xmath28 ) and electron ( @xmath29 ) .
let us also call @xmath27 the pair of proton with electron , @xmath28 - positron with electron and @xmath29 - positron with proton .
we neglect spin - orbit interactions . in this case
spacial and spin parts of the total three - body wavefunction separate .
the latter can be ignored as it has no effect on scattering observables .
the spacial part of the total three - body scattering wavefunction satisfies @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the full hamiltonian , @xmath32 is the three - free - particle hamiltonian , @xmath33 is the coulomb interaction between particles of pair @xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) .
the total hamiltonian can also be expressed in the following way @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the hamiltonian of the bound pair @xmath38 , @xmath39 is the momentum of free particle @xmath38 relative to c.m . of the bound pair , @xmath40 is the reduced mass of the two fragments and @xmath41 is the interaction potential of the free particle with the bound system in channel @xmath38 ( @xmath42 ) .
coupled - channel methods are based on expansion of the total wavefunction @xmath43 in terms of functions of all asymptotic channels .
however , since the asymptotic wavefunction corresponding to 3 free particles has a complicated form @xcite , this is not practical .
therefore , we approximate @xmath43 by expansion over some negative and discrete positive energy pseudostates of pairs @xmath27 and @xmath28 especially chosen to best reproduce the corresponding physical states .
suppose we have some @xmath44 pseudostates in pair @xmath27 and @xmath45 in pair @xmath28 satisfying the following conditions @xmath46 and @xmath47 where @xmath48 is a pseudostate wavefunction of pair @xmath38 and @xmath49 is the corresponding pseudostate energy . then we can write @xmath50 where @xmath51 is an unknown weight function , @xmath52 is the relative position of the particles in pair @xmath53 , @xmath54 is the position of particle @xmath53 relative to the centre of mass ( c.m . ) of pair @xmath53 ( @xmath55 ) , see fig .
[ fig1jacobi ] . for convenience
, here we use the same notation not only to denote a pair and a corresponding channel , but also a quantum state in this pair and the channel .
so , the indices of functions @xmath56 and @xmath48 , additionally refer to a full set of quantum numbers of a state in the channel . in the case of vectors @xmath54 and @xmath52 , the indices still refer only to a channel and a pair in the channel , respectively . in principle , at this formal stage one could keep the continuum part only for one of the pairs in order not to double up the treatment of the three - body breakup channel .
however , a symmetric expansion of the type ( [ phi ] ) , with the continuum states on both centres , was found to give fastest convergence in calculations with a manageable number of states @xcite . ) , proton ( @xmath28 ) , and electron ( @xmath29).,width=321 ] now we use the bubnov - galerkin principle @xcite to find the coefficients @xmath51 so that the expansion ( [ phi ] ) satisfies eq .
( [ seh ] ) the best possible way .
accordingly , we substitute the expansion ( [ phi ] ) into eq .
( [ seh ] ) and require the result to be orthogonal to all ( @xmath57 ) basis states , i.e. @xmath58 in this equation subscript @xmath59 indicates integration over all variables except @xmath59 . now taking into account conditions ( [ diag1 ] ) and ( [ diag2 ] )
we can write eq .
( [ ls1 ] ) in the following form : @xmath60 the potential operators @xmath61 are given by @xmath62 the condition imposed above in eq .
( [ ls2 ] ) is a system of coupled equations for unknown expansion coefficients @xmath63 .
these functions carry information on the scattering amplitudes .
we transform these integro - differential equations for the weight functions to a set of coupled lippmann - schwinger integral equations for transition amplitudes @xmath64 . to this end
we define the green s function in channel @xmath38 @xmath65 to describe the relative motion of free particle @xmath38 and bound pair @xmath38 with binding energy @xmath66 .
we can now write the formal solution of the differential equation ( [ ls2 ] ) as @xmath67 the addition of positive @xmath68 defines the integration path around the singularity point at @xmath69^{1/2}$ ] , which is real for @xmath70 , and corresponds to the outgoing wave boundary conditions .
taking eq .
( [ f - eq2 ] ) to the asymptotic region one can demonstrate @xcite that latexmath:[\ ] ] where @xmath223 , @xmath224 is the dipole polarizability and @xmath225 are adjustable parameters to fit some physical quantities ( e.g. , energies of the valence electron ) .
mg is modelled as a he - like system with two active electrons above a frozen hartree - fock core @xcite .
the interaction between an active electron and the frozen hartree - fock core is calculated as a sum of the static part of the hartree - fock potential and an exchange potential between an active and the core electrons as described in the previous subsection .
details of the two - centre ccc method for positron - mg collisions are given in @xcite .
wavefunctions for the inert gases of ne , ar , kr , and xe are described by a model of six p - electrons above a frozen hartree - fock core .
discrete and continuum target states are obtained by allowing one - electron excitations from the p - shell in the following way . taking ne as an example
, self - consistent hartree - fock calculations are performed for the ne@xmath2 ion , resulting in the 1s,2s,2p orbitals .
the 1s and 2s orbitals are treated as the inert core orbitals , while the 2p hartree - fock orbital is used as the frozen - core orbital to form the target states . a set of laguerre functions is used to diagonalize the quasi - one - electron hamiltonian of the ne@xmath226 ion , utilising the nonlocal hartree - fock potential constructed from the inert core orbitals .
the resulting 2p orbital differs substantially from the hartree - fock 2p orbital .
a one - electron basis suitable for the description of a neutral ne atom is built by replacing the 2p orbital from diagonalisation with the hartree - fock one , orthogonalized by the gram - schmidt procedure .
the six - electron target states are described via the configuration - interaction ( ci ) expansion .
the set of configurations is built by angular momentum coupling of the wavefunction of 2p@xmath227 electrons and the laguerre - based one - electron functions .
the coefficients of the ci expansion are obtained by diagonalization of the target hamiltonian . the target orbital angular momentum @xmath90 , spin @xmath6 , and parity @xmath228
are conserved quantum numbers and diagonalization of the target hamiltonian is performed separately for each target symmetry \{@xmath229}. full details of the single centre ccc calculations for noble gas atoms are given in ref .
a two - centre approach to inert gases has not yet been attempted .
positron - h@xmath0 scattering can be treated somewhat similar to the helium case .
we consider h@xmath0 within the born - oppenheimer approximation where the two protons are considered to be at a fixed internuclear distance denoted as @xmath13 .
expansion for the total scattering wavefunction ( after separation of the spin part ) is similar to eq .
( [ twfex7 ] ) for he .
however , the wavefunctions for the target in the first term and the residual ion in the ps - formation channel depend on @xmath13 . the residual ion of h@xmath230 , with same internuclear distance @xmath13 , is considered to be only in its ground state .
we only use a few ps eigenstates so as to take advantage of their analytical form .
the target states are obtained by diagonalizing the h@xmath0 hamiltonian in a set of antisymmetrized two - electron configurations , built from laguerre one - electron orbitals , for each target symmetry characterized by the projection of orbital angular momentum , parity and spin . to calculate h@xmath0 states , we use the fixed - nuclei approximation .
calculations are performed at the ground - state equilibrium internuclei distance taken to be @xmath13 = 1.4 a@xmath231 .
when @xmath13 is set to 0 one should obtain the he results .
we used this test for both structure and scattering calculations .
details of h@xmath0 structure calculations can be found in @xcite .
the derivation of the rearrangement matrix elements are somewhat more difficult than for he because of their dependence on the nuclear separation and target orientation .
another difference is that partial wave expansion is done over the total angular momentum projection @xmath93 .
it is convenient to choose the z - axis to be along the @xmath232 vector ( body - frame ) .
then it is possible to transform the obtained results with this choice of z - axis to any given orientation of the molecule . to facilitate the calculations only the spherical part of the nuclear potential
is considered when calculating the rearrangement matrix elements : @xmath233 where @xmath234 .
then the momentum space representation of the above positron - nucleus potential can be shown to be @xmath235 with these one further follows the procedure used for positron - he calculations @xcite .
for positron collisions with the ground state of h@xmath0 only states with zero total spin are required and so @xmath236 .
@xmath237-matrix elements are used for obtaining body - frame scattering amplitudes .
these are then rotated by euler angles to transform them to lab - frame scattering amplitudes .
orientationally - independent cross sections are calculated by averaging over all rotations of the molecule @xcite .
an orientationally averaged analytic born subtraction method @xcite is employed for h@xmath0 direct transition channels .
this helped reduce the number of partial waves requiring explicit calculation .
fundamentally , in order for a theory to be useful it needs to be predictive . in the close - coupling approach to electron / positron / proton scattering on relatively simple targets , where the structure is readily obtained ,
there are two computational problems that need to be overcome .
the first , is that for a given set of states used to expand the total wavefunction the resulting equations need to be solved to an acceptable numerical precision .
the second is to systematically increase the size of the expansion and demonstrate that the final results converge to a unique answer that is independent of the choice of the expansion , so long as it is sufficiently large .
only once this is achieved can we be in a position to claim that the results are the true solution of the underlying schrdinger equation and hence predictive of what should happen in the experiment .
in the case of electron scattering there are only one - centre expansions because electrons do not form bound states with the electrons of the target .
electron exchange is handled within the potential matrix elements all based on the coordinate origin at the nucleus .
accordingly , establishing convergence in just the one - centre approach is all that needs to be done , though historically this was a major challenge @xcite .
though convergence was shown to be to a result that disagreed with experiment @xcite , subsequent experiments showed excellent agreement with the ccc theory @xcite , which lead to reanalysis of the original data @xcite yielding good agreement with the ccc theory and new experiments .
a similar situation occurred in the case of double photoionisation of helium @xcite , which in effect is electron scattering on the singly charged helium ion @xcite . for positron and proton scattering
the issue of convergence is even more interesting due to the capacity of the projectile to form a bound state with a target electron .
this leads to a second natural centre in the problem which also requires treatment to convergence . for positron scattering on atomic hydrogen
the ps - formation threshold is at 6.8 ev , while the ionisation threshold is 13.6 ev .
however , ps formation is also a form of ionisation of the target except that the electron is captured to a bound state of the projectile .
any expansion of the ps centre using a complete basis will result in negative- and positive - energy states , with the latter corresponding to three - body breakup . however , expansion of the atomic centre will also generate independent positive - energy states corresponding to three - body breakup .
hence , expansions using a complete basis on each centre , will yield independent , non - orthogonal states corresponding to the same physical three - body breakup process . while this may appear to be a fundamental problem , in practice it is an interesting strength of the method which allows to check internal consistency of the results . by this
we mean that the same results must be obtained from a variety of calculations utilising independent one- and two - centre expansions as detailed below .
we begin by considering two extremes : the first attempts to obtain convergence using only the atomic centre , while the second attempts convergence using two complete expansion on both centres .
will either converge , and if they do , will the convergence be to the same result ? and @xmath238 , arising upon diagonalisation of the respective hamiltonians , in the ccc(12@xmath239,12@xmath0 ) positron - hydrogen calculations . here
@xmath240 states were obtained for each @xmath90 with @xmath241 for h states and @xmath242 for ps states , see kadyrov _ et al .
_ @xcite . [ energies ] ] arising from one - centre ( left ) and two - centre ( right ) ccc positron - hydrogen calculations .
@xmath243 is the number of h states in the one - centre calculation which has no explicit ps states .
@xmath244 is the number of h states in the two - centre calculation with @xmath245 explicit ps states .
first presented by bray _ et al . _
@xcite . ] in fig .
[ energies ] typical energies arising in two - centre calculations are given .
we see a similar spread of negative- and positive - energy states on both the h and the ps centres .
a single centre expansion based on the atomic centre would not have any ps states included in the calculation .
the results of the two types of calculations may be readily summarised by fig .
[ picture ] . on the left
we have one - centre cross sections @xmath246 , where @xmath247 .
taking the initial state to be the ground state of h ( @xmath248 ) then @xmath249 is the elastic scattering cross section , and @xmath250 corresponds to excitation whenever @xmath251 and ionisation whenever @xmath252 .
the elastic and excitation cross sections need to converge with increasing @xmath243 individually .
however , the ionisation cross sections converge as a sum , yielding the total ionisation cross section @xmath253 for @xmath254 .
convergence of the one - centre ccc calculations , where there are no ps states , has been studied extensively @xcite .
briefly , at energies below the ps - formation threshold the important contribution of virtual ps formation is adequately treated via the positive - energy atomic states of large angular momentum @xmath255 .
this allows for convergence of elastic scattering cross section to the correct value . at energies above the ionisation threshold ,
the positive - energy atomic pseudostates take into account both breakup and ps - formation cross section in a collective way yielding the correct electron - loss and excitation cross sections .
however , in the extended ore gap region between the ps - formation and ionisation thresholds no convergence is possible due to all positive - energy pseudostates being closed .
convergence in two - centre calculations is potentially problematic at all energies due to two independent treatments of the breakup processes . in practice
this manifests itself as an ill - conditioned system which requires high - precision matrix elements and limits the size of the calculations i.e. @xmath256 and @xmath245 are typically substantially smaller than @xmath243 .
it is for this reason that we have drawn the one - center matrix to be substantially larger in fig .
[ picture ] .
furthermore , the h - ps matrix elements take at least an order of magnitude longer to calculate due to the non - separable nature of the radial integrals @xcite . accordingly , even with much smaller number of states ( with smaller @xmath257 ) the two - centre calculations take considerably longer to complete .
nevertheless convergence is obtained for individual transitions involving discrete states , explicit ps formation , and explicit breakup @xcite .
internal consistency is satisfied if at energies outside the extended ore gap , for discrete ( @xmath258 ) atomic transitions the two approaches independently converge such that @xmath259 furthermore , at energies above the breakup threshold @xmath260 where for some initial state @xmath34 @xmath261 in the extended ore gap only the two - centre calculations are able to yield convergent results .
the great strength of the internal - consistency check is that it is available ( outside the extended ore gap ) for every partial wave of the total orbital angular momentum .
checking that eq .
( [ eloss ] ) is satisfied for every partial wave provides confidence in the overall results of the two completely independent calculations , which will typically have very different convergence properties with increasing @xmath8 and @xmath90 . due to the unitarity of the close - coupling theory agreement for eq .
( [ eloss ] ) suggests agreement for other channels , and so eq . ( [ disc ] )
will also hold .
obtained using the one- and two - centre ccc calculations , see text .
the indicated points corresponding to the energies at which the calculations were performed are connected with straight lines to guide the eye .
the vertical lines are the ps - formation and breakup thresholds , spanning the extended ore gap .
the experimental data in the bottom left panel are due to @xcite .
first presented by @xcite .
[ p - h ] ] in fig .
[ p - h ] we give the example of an internal - consistency check , presented by @xcite .
we see that outside the extended ore gap the two calculations are generally in very good agreement .
one systematic exception is at just above the ionisation threshold . here
the breakup cross section is almost zero , but the ps - formation cross section is near its maximum .
even with @xmath262 the one - centre calculation does not have enough pseudostates of energy just a little above zero which would be necessary to reproduce the what should be step - function behaviour in one - centre ccc calculations . due to explicit ps - formation in the two - centre calculations
there are no such problems here or within the extended ore gap .
having checked the individual partial waves , and summing over all to convergence , excellent agreement is found with experiment .
having performed the internal consistency checks we remain confident in the theoretical results even if there is potentially a discrepancy with experiment at the lowest energy measured . establishing convergence in the cross sections with a systematically increasing close - coupling expansion places a severe test on the scattering formalism .
this is as relevant to positron scattering as it is for electron scattering .
pseudoresonances must disappear with increased size of the calculations , and uncertainty in the final results can be established via the convergence study .
one of the earliest successes of the two - centre ccc method for positron - hydrogen @xmath171-wave scattering was to show how the higgins - burke pseudoresonance @xcite disappeared utilising a ( @xmath18 ) basis of only @xmath6-states on each centre @xcite .
the cross sections for all reaction channels were shown to converge to a few % with a ( @xmath263 ) basis of @xmath6-states .
interestingly , the symmetric treatment of both centres was particularly efficient in terms of reaching convergence and eliminating pseudoresonances , with no double - counting problems .
the question of convergence in the case of the full positron - hydrogen scattering problem was investigated by @xcite .
setting @xmath264 , states of higher angular momentum were increased systematically .
the same level of convergence as in the @xmath171-wave model case was achieved with the ( @xmath265 ) basis made of ten @xmath6- , nine @xmath12- , eight @xmath13- and seven @xmath266-states for each centre , for scattering on the ground state .
the largest calculations performed had a total of 68 states , 34 each of h and ps states .
the convergence was checked for the total and other main cross sections corresponding to transitions to negative - energy states .
reasonably smooth cross sections were obtained for all bases with @xmath90-convergence being rather rapid .
for the three cases considered @xmath266-states contribute only marginally .
[ fig6]-[fig8 ] show the ccc results in comparison with other calculations and experimental data of detroit @xcite and london @xcite groups .
the ccc results agree well with experiment .
so do cc(@xmath17 ) calculations of @xcite and cc(@xmath16 ) calculations of @xcite .
note that in these calculations the @xmath267 scaling rule was used to estimate the total ps formation .
also , an energy - averaging procedure was used to smooth the cc(@xmath11 ) calculations of @xcite . in the ccc method convergence
is established without such procedures being used . for the breakup cross section the ccc results have two comparable contributions , one from the excitation of the positive - energy h pseudostates ( shown in fig .
[ fig8 ] as direct ionization ) , and the other from excitation of positive - energy ps pseudostates .
this was also noted by kernoghan et al .
@xcite using the cc(@xmath11 ) calculations .
by contrast , in cc(@xmath10)-type calculations the contribution to breakup comes only from from direct ionisation . at the maximum of the cross section
the separately converged indirect contribution to the breakup cross section is approximately a third of the total .
however , the cc(@xmath17 ) cross section of @xcite is only a marginally smaller , indicating that absence of ps positive - energy states is absorbed by the positive - energy h states .
[ fig1prl ] shows the ccc results of fig .
[ fig8 ] , but against excess ( total ) energy to emphasize the lower energies .
the full ccc(h+ps ) results with breakup cross sections coming from both the h and ps centres are contrasted with those just from h and twice h ( labeled as ccc(h+h ) ) .
we see that below about 20 ev excess energy the ccc(h+ps ) and ccc(h+h ) curves are much the same , indicating that the ps and h contributions to breakup converge to each other as the threshold is approached .
h breakup cross section as a function of excess energy calculated using the two - center ccc method , first presented by @xcite .
the argument to the ccc label indicates which center s positive - energy states were used , see text .
the experiment is due to @xcite . ]
utilising the ccc method @xcite reported calculations of positron - hydrogen scattering near the breakup threshold in order to examine the threshold law .
the results are given in fig .
[ fig2prl ] .
the wannier - like threshold law , derived by @xcite , is in good agreement with the ccc results below 1 ev excess energy .
this law was derived for the @xmath268 partial wave , and @xcite showed the same energy - dependence holds in all partial waves .
as for the full problem the contributions from both centres to the breakup cross section converge to each other with decreasing excess energy , without any over - completeness problems .
h @xmath171-wave model breakup cross section as a function of excess energy calculated using the two - center ccc method , from @xcite . as in fig .
[ fig1prl ] , the argument to the ccc label indicates which center s positive - energy states were used .
the wannier - like threshold law is due to @xcite ] .
[ fig2prl ] helium in its ground state is the most frequently used target in experimental studies of positron - atom scattering .
first measurements on positron - helium scattering were carried out by @xcite in 1972 . since
then many other experimental studies have been conducted @xcite .
further developments of positron beams in terms of energy resolution and beam intensities have recently motivated more experimental studies @xcite . in general , the results from the experiments agree well with each other . a complete theoretical approach from low to high energies
had been lacking until the development of the ccc method for the problem by @xcite .
a vast amount of experimental data is available for integrated cross sections for positron scattering from the helium ground state .
the total ccc - calculated cross section is shown in fig .
[ tcs - exp ] in comparison with experimental data and other calculations .
considerable discussion on the topic has been presented by @xcite .
it suffices to say that so long as an accurate ground state is used , obtained from a multi - core ( mc ) treatment , agreement with experiment is outstanding across all energies .
we expect the frozen - core ( fc ) treatment of helium to result in systematically larger excitation and ionization cross sections because it understimate the ionization potential by around 0.84 ev .
generally , a larger ionisation potential leads to a smaller cross section .
in the ccc method we are not free to replace calculated energies with those from experiment , as this leads to numerical inconsistency .
consequently , there is no way to avoid the extra complexity associated with the mc calculations if high accuracy is required .
the total ps - formation , breakup and electron - loss cross sections are given in fig .
[ fig3in1](a ) , ( b ) and ( c ) , respectively .
beginning with ps formation , given the minor variation in the measurements agreement between the various theories and experiment is satisfactory .
however , turning our attention to the breakup cross section we see that ( mc ) ccc appears to be substantially higher than experiment . yet
when these cross sections are summed to form the electron - loss cross section , the agreement with the experiment of @xcite which measured this directly , is good . given the complexity of the problem and the experimental uncertainties , the agreement with experiment is very satisfying .
s ) and ( b ) he(2@xmath22p ) excitations by positron impact .
experiment is due to @xcite .
the fc ccc and mc ccc results are from @xcite , other calculations are due to @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . ] the cross sections of 2@xmath22s and 2@xmath22p excitation of helium are presented in fig .
[ figex]a and b , respectively .
the mc ccc result for @xmath269s is in good agreement with the data of @xcite while the @xmath269p result is somewhat lower than experiment .
the fact that the fc ccc @xmath269p results agree better with the experimental data is fortuitous .
other available theories show some systematic difficulties for these relatively small cross sections .
the cross sections for the rather exotic ps formation in the 2@xmath6 and 2@xmath12 excited states are presented in fig .
[ figpsex](a ) and ( b ) respectively .
the cross sections are particularly small .
nevertheless , agreement with the sole available experiment of @xcite is remarkable . and ( b ) 2@xmath12 states . experimental data for ps(2@xmath12 )
are due to @xcite .
the fc ccc and mc ccc results are from @xcite and other calculations are due to @xcite and @xcite . ]
thus we have seen that there is good agreement between theory and experiment for the integrated cross sections for positron scattering on helium and hydrogen in their ground states . in both cases
the ionisation thresholds are well above 6.8 ev , and so a one - centre calculation is applicable at low energies where elastic scattering is the only open channel . though experimentally challenging positron scattering on either h or he metastable excited states results in ps formation being an open channel at all energies . taking the example of positron scattering from the @xmath270s metastable state of helium
the ps threshold is negative ( -2.06 ev ) .
this collision system has been extensively studied by @xcite . as far as we are aware
, no experimental studies have been conducted for positron scattering on metastable states of helium .
given the experimental work on electron scattering from metastable helium @xcite , in a group that also has a positron beam , we are hopeful that in the future there might be experimental data available for such systems . as there are still unresolved discrepancies between theory and experiment regarding electron scattering from metastable states of he @xcite , using positrons instead of electrons may assist with their resolution .
just like for h and he in metastable states , for positron collisions with alkali - metal atoms in their ground state , both elastic and ps(1s ) formation channels are open even at zero positron energy accordingly , we require two - centre expansions even at the lowest incident energies .
@xcite conducted two - centre calculations with different basis sets to achieve results that are independent of the laguerre exponential fall - off parameter @xmath271 , and convergent with the laguerre basis size @xmath272 for target orbital angular momentum @xmath273 .
-li along with the experimental points by @xcite and theoretical calculations by @xcite .
the truncated basis ( ccc tr ) calculation is an attempt to reproduce the states used by @xcite , see @xcite for details .
[ fig:4li ] ] figure [ fig:4li ] shows the positronium - formation cross section .
agreement between the various calculations is quite good , while comparison with the experimental data of @xcite is rather mixed .
the key feature is that the ps - formation cross section diminishes with decreasing energy , supported by all theories , and consistent with experiment .
overall , it appears there is no major reason to be concerned .
unfortunately , changing the target to sodium , substantial discrepancies between theory and experiment arise , and remain unresolved to date .
one of the motivations for extending the ccc theory to two - centre calculations of positron - alkali scattering was to address this problem .
@xcite performed the most extensive study of this problem that included one- and two - centre calculations . despite establishing convergence and consistency of the two approaches no improvement on previous calculations
was found .
-na scattering .
experiment is due to @xcite , and the calculations due to @xcite and @xcite .
[ fig:4na ] ] we begin by considering the total cross section for positron - sodium scattering , presented in fig . [ fig:2na ] .
we see good agreement between various two - centre calculations , with the one - centre ccc(217,0 ) calculation behaving as expected : agreeing with ccc(116,14 ) only above the ionisation threshold , and not being valid ( or even convergent ) below the ionisation threshold .
all of the two - centre calculations are considerably above the experiment at low energies .
curiously , the situation is reversed for the total ps - formation component of the total cross section , presented in fig .
[ fig:4na ] , where now all of the theories are considerably below the experiment .
given that the total cross section at the lowest energies considered is the sum of elastic and ps - formation cross sections , the presented discrepancies with experiment imply that the theoretical elastic scattering cross sections are overwhelmingly high @xcite .
why this would be the case remains a mystery .
( lower panel ) and scaled ps - formation @xmath274 ( upper panel ) cross sections for positron - lithium scattering , as a function of energy ( 13.6@xmath275 ) , for the zeroth partial wave calculated with the indicated ccc(@xmath276 ) laguerre basis parameters , as presented by @xcite .
[ li ] ] faced with the problems identified above , @xcite considered threshold behaviour in positron scattering on alkali atoms . following
@xcite we expect exothermic reactions such as ps formation in positron - alkali scattering to result in a cross section that tends to infinity as @xmath277 as the positron energy ( @xmath275 ) goes to zero .
this is not yet evident in fig .
[ fig:4li ] or fig .
[ fig:4na ] for the considered energies .
nevertheless , @xcite did obtain the required analytical behaviour , but only in the zeroth partial wave . in fig .
[ li ] the ps - formation cross section is presented for the zeroth partial wave multiplied by @xmath278 so as to demonstrate the expected threshold behaviour .
the convergence study of @xcite is also presented , where the effect of adding the ps(@xmath279 ) state was able to be reproduced by atomic pseudostates of high orbital angular momentum .
@xcite found that higher partial waves @xmath79 become major contributors to ps formation at energies above @xmath280 ev , and have a threshold behaviour as @xmath281 , and so rise rapidly with increasing energies .
it is the contributions of the higher partial waves that is responsible for the behaviour in the ps - formation cross section seen in fig .
[ fig:4li ] .
but for positron - sodium scattering .
[ na ] ] we find the same is the case for positron - sodium scattering . in fig .
[ na ] we present @xmath282 and @xmath283 for the zeroth partial wave , demonstrating the expected threshold behaviour .
details of the convergence study are discussed by @xcite .
it suffices to say that there is a range of combinations of atomic and ps states that should yield convergent results , with such studies being considerably easier at the lower energies where there are only two open channels . as in the case of lithium
the zeroth partial wave is dominant only below @xmath280 ev , with the results presented in fig .
[ fig:4na ] being dominated by the higher partial waves .
but for positron - potassium scattering .
[ k ] ] lastly , having been unable to explain the discrepancy between experiment and theory for positron - sodium scattering @xcite also considered the positron - potassium scattering system
. however , much the same behaviour as for the lighter alkalis was found , see fig .
consequently , the discrepancy between experiment and theory for low - energy positron scattering on sodium remains unresolved .
one interesting aspect of the presented elastic cross sections for positron scattering on the alkalis are the minima . in the case of li and
na they are at just above 0.001 ev , whereas for k the minimum is at around 0.04 ev .
given that in all cases we have just two channels open , elastic and ps formation , we have no ready explanation for the minima , or their positions .
the generally smaller ps - formation cross section shows no structure in the same energy region , which is surprising given the substantial minima in the elastic cross section .
for experimentalists the transition from say sodium to magnesium for the purpose of positron scattering is relatively straightforward , not so in the case of theory .
two valence electrons on top of a hartree - fock core makes for a very complicated projectile - target combination to treat computationally .
however , with an ionization energy of 7.6 ev the single - centre approach is valid below 0.8 ev allowing for a test of the two - centre method in this energy region .
this is an important test because in the single centre approach there are no approximations associated with explicit ps formation , and the core is fully treated by the hartree - fock approach rather than an equivalent local core potential approximation .
one - centre positron - magnesium ccc calculations were presented by @xcite , and two - centre ones by @xcite .
the results confirmed the existence of a low - energy shape - resonance predicted earlier by @xcite .
the results are presented in fig .
[ figure3 mg ] .
given that the resonance is at a very low energy and that a slight energy difference in the target structure may affect its position the agreement between the theories is very encouraging .
as explained in sec .
[ intcont ] , one - centre calculations are unable to yield convergent results within the extended ore gap ( presently between 0.8 ev and 7.6 ev ) .
the unphysical structures displayed within this energy region in the calculations of @xcite depend on the choice of basis with just one example presented .
unfortunately , the agreement with the experiment of @xcite for the total cross section has the unexpected feature of being good above the ionisation threshold and poor below , see fig .
[ figure4 mg ] .
given that the validity of the two - centre ccc approach should be energy independent we are unable to explain the discrepancy .
-mg elastic - scattering cross section.the first vertical line is at the ps - formation threshold , the second one is at the mg - ionization threshold .
the ( two - centre ) ccc calculations are due to @xcite , the one - centre due to @xcite , and the variational ones due to @xcite .
[ figure3 mg ] ] -mg total scattering cross section .
the vertical line indicates the mg - ionization threshold .
experimental data are due to @xcite , and the calculations are as for fig .
[ figure3 mg ] . ] the ps - formation cross section is presented in fig .
[ figure5 mg ] , where there are large experimental uncertainties .
the experimental data of @xcite are preliminary estimations for the upper and the lower limits of the ps - formation cross section .
the ( two - centre ) ccc results are compared with the previous calculations . while there is substantial variation the theories tend to favour the upper limit estimates .
-mg ps - formation cross section .
experimental data for upper and lower limits of the ps - formation cross section are due to @xcite .
the vertical line indicates the position of the ps - formation threshold .
the calculations are due to @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , walters ( data taken from ref .
@xcite ) and @xcite .
[ figure5 mg ] ] positron scattering on inert - gas atoms has been studied using the single - centre ccc method @xcite . as discussed in the introduction the complexity of adding the second ( ps ) centre is immense , and has not yet been attempted within a convergent close - coupling formalism .
the large ionisation thresholds mean that the single centre calculations are valid for elastic scattering on the substantial energy range below the ps - formation threshold , as well as above the ionisation threshold , but no explicit ps - formation cross section may be determined .
this is particularly unfortunute in light of the intriguing cusp - like behaviour observed by @xcite across the ps - formation threshold . due to the small magnitude of the structures a highly accurate theoretical treatment
is required , but does not yet exist .
the experimental and theoretical situation for positron - noble gas collision systems has been recently reviewed extensively by @xcite .
if we allow the internuclear separation of the two protons in h@xmath0 to be fixed then the extra complexity , relative to the helium atom , is somewhat manageable .
various cross sections for @xmath284 scattering have been recently calculated by @xcite using the two - center ccc method .
this represents the most complex implementation of the two - centre formalism to date .
issues regarding convergence with laguerre - based molecular and ps states have been discussed in some detail .
calculations with only up to three ps(@xmath184 ) , ps(@xmath279 ) and ps(@xmath285 ) states on the ps centre were presented above 10 ev . at lower energies
the current implementation of the two - centre formalism fails to pass the internal consistency check with the single - center calculations of @xcite .
the low energies are particularly sensitive to the approximations of the treatment of the ( virtual ) ps formation in the field of the highly structured h@xmath24 ion . here
we just present the key two - centre results in comparison of experiment and theory .
experimental data are due to @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
the single centre ccc(@xmath286 ) results are due to @xcite .
the two - centre ccc calculations are due to @xcite .
[ figure3h2 ] ] in fig .
[ figure3h2 ] the theoretical results are compared with the available experimental data for the grand total cross section . good agreement between the two- and one - centre calculation above the ionisation threshold is very satisfying , even if in this energy region the theory is somewhat below experiment .
good agreement with experiment of the two - centre ccc results below the ionisation threshold , dominated by the elastic and ps - formation cross sections , is particularly pleasing .
[ figure4h2 ] shows the ps - formation cross section which is a substantial component of the gtcs , particularly near its maximum around 20 ev . there is a little variation between the three ccc calculations particularly at the lower energies , with the largest ccc calculation being uniformly a little lower than experiment .
h@xmath0 collisions .
experimental data are due to @xcite ( shaded region incorporates upper and lower limits with their uncertainties ) , @xcite and @xcite .
coupled static model calculations are due to @xcite .
the ccc calculations are due to @xcite .
[ figure4h2 ] ] h@xmath0 collisions .
experimental data are due to @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
the ccc calculations are due to @xcite .
[ figure5h2 ] ] h@xmath0 collisions .
experimental data are due to @xcite and @xcite .
the ccc calculations are due to @xcite ( one - centre ) and @xcite ( two - centre ) .
[ figure6h2 ] ] in fig .
[ figure5h2 ] the ccc results for the direct total ionization cross section ( tics ) are compared with the available experimental data .
the experimental data of @xcite and @xcite are in agreement with each other but differ from measurements of @xcite between 30 and 100 ev .
the largest ccc calculation ccc(14@xmath0,3 ) , which contains @xmath6- , @xmath12- and @xmath13-atomic orbitals together with the three lowest - energy ps states , is in better agreement with the measurements of @xcite .
the ccc(14@xmath287,1 ) and ccc(14@xmath287,3 ) are systematically lower , primarily due to the absence of the @xmath13-atomic orbitals . due to the unitarity of the close - coupling formalism ,
larger @xmath90-orbitals are likely to only marginally increase the tics .
once we have convergence in the elastic scattering ( large @xmath90-orbitals not required ) the gtcs is set , with the distribution between elastic , electron - excitation , ps - formation and total ionisation cross sections thereby being constrained @xcite .
finally , the total electron - loss cross section is given in fig .
[ figure6h2 ] , and is the sum of tics and ps - formation cross sections .
it is useful because the one - centre ccc approach is able to yield this cross section at energies above the ionisation threshold .
this provides for an important internal - consistency check .
we see that around 50 ev the largest two - centre ccc calculation is somewhat lower than the one - centre calculation .
given the increase in the cross section due to the inclusion of @xmath13-orbitals adding @xmath266-orbitals would go someway to reduce the discrepancy . increasing
the laguerre basis @xmath288 in the one - centre calculations would increase the cross section just above the ionisation threshold due to an improving discretisation of the continuum . despite the immense complexity of the positron - molecular - hydrogen scattering problem
considerable progress in obtaining reasonably accurate cross sections has been made .
as stated earlier , via eq .
( [ antihform ] ) , antihydrogen formation is effectively the time - reverse process of ps formation upon positron - hydrogen scattering .
accordingly , it only takes place at positron energies above the ps(@xmath5 ) formation threshold , where @xmath5 indicates the principal quantum number .
furthermore , we require two - centre calculations because only these have explicit ps and h states .
given that we are interested in as large cross sections as possible , and that the exothermic transition cross sections go to infinity at threshold @xcite the primary energy range of interest is within the extended ore gap , as given in fig .
[ p - h ] . , scattering on ( anti)protons calculated using the ccc method , first presented by @xcite . for ps(1s ) , the variational calculations @xcite are for ( anti)hydrogen formation in the 1s state only ( ccc - calculated unconnected points presented for comparison ) , while the uba calculations of @xcite and @xcite , and the ccc calculations generally , are for ( anti)hydrogen formation in all open states .
the three experimental points are due to @xcite . ]
there are few calculations of antihydrogen formation that are accurate at low energies .
as far as we are aware , apart from the ccc method @xcite , only the variational approach of @xcite has yielded accurate results . the unitarised born approximation ( uba )
calculations @xcite are not appropriate at low energies , and neither are first order approximations @xcite . large cross sections for antihydrogen formation occur for transitions between excited states of ps and h. to have these states accurate the laguerre bases @xmath289 for both h and ps need to be sufficiently large .
@xcite used @xmath290 , with the resultant energies given in fig .
[ energies ] .
while it is trivial to have larger @xmath289 as far as the structure is concerned , the primary limiting factor is to be able to solve the resultant close - coupling equations . in fig .
[ energies ] the positive energies correspond to the breakup of h and also of ps , and yet the two represent the same physical process .
this leads to highly ill - conditioned equations . @xcite
considered non - symmetric treatments of the two centres by dropping the ps positive - energy states .
while these also satisfy internal - consistency checks they have not proved to be more efficient in yielding convergence , with increasing @xmath289 , in the cross sections of present interest . a comprehensive set of antihydrogen formation cross sections for low - energy ps incident on an antiproton has been given by @xcite .
they used the original numerical treatment of the green s function in eq .
( [ lskmat ] ) . in fig .
[ p - ps ] , we present the summary of the total antihydrogen formation cross sections for specified initial ps(@xmath291 ) as presented by @xcite . excellent agreement with the variational calculations @xcite , available only for the ground states of h and ps , gives us confidence in the rest of the presented ccc results .
as predicted by @xcite the ground state cross section goes to infinity as @xmath292 at threshold , whereas for excited states this is modified to @xmath293 at threshold due to the long - range dipole interaction of degenerate ps @xmath294 states , as explained by @xcite .
the cross sections increase steadily with increasing principle quantum number of ps , with the transition to the highest available principal quantum number of h being the most dominant contribution @xcite .
consequently there is considerable motivation to push the calculations even further to larger @xmath289 .
there is a second source of ill - conditioning of the close - coupling equations to that discussed previously .
given that we are particularly interested in low energies i.e. , just above the various thresholds , the singularity in the green s function of eq .
( [ lskmat ] ) occurs very close to zero energy .
a typically used symmetric treatment on either side of the singularity results in very large positive and negative values which contribute to the ill - conditioning via precision loss . )
formation cross sections for @xmath295 in p - ps(@xmath296 ) scattering for the zeroth partial wave .
the `` old '' results arise from solving the original ccc equations ( [ lskmat ] ) .
the `` new '' results are due to the solution with the green s function being treated analytically , see @xcite . ]
very recently @xcite showed that the green s function of the coupled lippmann - schwinger equations ( [ lskmat ] ) can be treated analytically .
the method that was previously used in calculating the optical potential in the coupled - channel optical method @xcite was applied directly to the green s function in the lippmann - schwinger equation ( [ lskmat ] ) . in doing so
, they showed that they could improve on the above @xmath290 basis to reach @xmath297 , and thereby consider transitions from ps(@xmath298 ) states . in fig .
[ new ] we compare the `` old '' and the `` new '' numerical formulations and find that the latter is quite superior .
in fact , for @xmath297 @xcite were unable to obtain numerical stability in the original formulation with variation of integration parameters over the momentum in eq .
( [ lskmat ] ) , and presented just a combination that yielded somewhat reasonable agreement with the results of the `` new '' numerical method .
the new technique also proved to be particularly advantageous in studying threshold phenomena in positronium-(anti)proton scattering @xcite .
we have presented an overview of recent developments in positron - scattering theory on several atoms and molecular hydrogen , with particular emphasis on two - centre calculations that are able to explicitly treat positronium formation .
while considerable progress has been made there remain some major discrepancies between theory and experiment such as for low - energy positron - sodium scattering .
considerable technical development is still required for complicated atoms such as the heavier inert gases to incorporate ps formation in a systematically convergent way . a general scheme for doing so for molecular targets is also required .
it is also important to state that there are still fundamental issues to be addressed in the case of breakup .
while no overcompleteness has been found in two - centre calculations with near - complete bases on both centres , determining the resulting differential cross sections remains an unsolved problem .
@xcite considered the simplest energy - differential cross section which describes the probablity of an electron of a certain energy being ejected .
if we have contributions to this process from both centres , how do we combine them ?
furthermore , diagonalising the ps hamiltonian yields pseudostates of positive - energy ps rather than the energy of the individual electron or positron .
it may be that the only practical way to obtain differential ionisation cross sections is to restrict the ps centre to just negative - energy eigenstates , and obtain differential cross sections solely from the atomic centre positive - energy pseudostates , as is done for electron - impact ionisation @xcite
. however , this kind of approach may not be capable of describing the phenomenon of ps formation in continuum as seen by @xcite .
this is currently under investigation .
support of the australian research council and the merit allocation scheme on the national facility of the australian partnership for advanced computing is gratefully acknowledged .
this work was supported by resources provided by pawsey supercomputing centre with funding from the australian government and the government of western australia .
acknowledges partial support from the u.s .
national science foundation under award no .
phy-1415656 .
274 natexlab#1#1[2]#2 , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , , in : ( ed . ) , , volume , , , pp . .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , ( ) . , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , , in : , ( eds . ) , , , , , pp . . , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) .
, , in : , ( eds . ) , , , , , pp . . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , ( ) . . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , ( ) .
, et al . , , ( ) .
, et al .
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ( ) . , et al .
, , , cern , , .
, et al . , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ( ) .
, et al . , , ( ) .
, et al . , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , edition , .
, , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , , , , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , , ( ) .
, , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , , ( ) . , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) . | much progress in the theory of positron scattering on atoms has been made in the ten years since the review of @xcite .
we review this progress for few - electron targets with a particular emphasis on the two - centre convergent close - coupling and other theories which explicitly treat positronium ( ps ) formation .
while substantial progress has been made for ps formation in positron scattering on few - electron targets , considerable theoretical development is still required for multielectron atomic and molecular targets . |
a central goal of the gaia mission is to teach us how the galaxy functions and how it was assembled .
we can only claim to understand the structure of the galaxy when we have a dynamical model galaxy that reproduces the data .
therefore the construction of a satisfactory dynamical model is in a sense a primary goal of the gaia mission , for this model will encapsulate the understanding of galactic structure that we have gleaned from gaia .
preliminary working models that are precursors of the final model will also be essential tools as we endeavour to make astrophysical sense of the gaia catalogue .
consequently , before launch we need to develop a model - building capability , and with it produce dynamical models that reflect fairly fully our current state of knowledge .
the modern era of galaxy models started in 1980 , when the first version of the bahcall - soneira model appeared @xcite .
this model broke new ground by assuming that the galaxy is built up of components like those seen in external galaxies .
earlier work had centred on attempts to infer three - dimensional stellar densities by directly inverting the observed star counts . however , the solutions to the star - count equations are excessively sensitive to errors in the assumed obscuration and the measured magnitudes , so in practice it is essential to use the assumption that our galaxy is similar to external galaxies to choose between the infinity of statistically equivalent solutions to the star - count equations .
bahcall & soneira showed that a model inspired by data for external galaxies that had only a dozen or so free parameters could reproduce the available star counts .
@xcite did not consider kinematic data , but @xcite updated the classical work on mass models by fitting largely kinematic data to a mass model that comprised a series of components like those seen in external galaxies .
these data included the oort constants , the tangent - velocity curve , the escape velocity at the sun and the surface density of the disk near the sun .
@xcite were the first to fit both kinematic and star - count data to a model of the galaxy that was inspired by observations of external galaxies .
they broke the disk down into seven sub - populations by age .
then they assumed that motion perpendicular to the plane is perfectly decoupled from motion within the plane , and further assumed that as regards vertical motion , each subpopulation is an isothermal component , with the velocity dispersion determined by the observationally determined age - velocity dispersion relation of disk stars .
each sub - population was assumed to form a disk of given functional form , and the thickness of the disk was determined from the approximate formula @xmath0/\sigma^2\}$ ] , where @xmath1 is an estimate of the overall galactic potential .
once the thicknesses of the sub - disks have been determined , the mass of the bulge and the parameters of the dark halo were adjusted to ensure continued satisfaction of the constraints on the rotation curve @xmath2
. then the overall potential is recalculated , and the disk thicknesses were redetermined in the new potential .
this cycle was continued until changes between iterations were small .
the procedure was repeated several times , each time with a different dark - matter disk arbitrarily superposed on the observed stellar disks . the geometry and mass of this disk
were fixed during the interations of the potential .
star counts were used to discriminate between these dark - matter disks ; it turned out that the best fit to the star counts was obtained with negligible mass in the dark - matter disk .
although in its essentials the current ` besanon model ' @xcite is unchanged from the original one , many refinements and extensions to have been made .
in particular , the current model fits near ir star counts and predicts proper motions and radial velocities .
it has a triaxial bulge and a warped , flaring disk .
its big weakness is the assumption of constant velocity dispersions and streaming velocities in the bulge and the stellar halo , and the neglect of the non - axisymmetric component of the galaxy s gravitational field . a consensus that ours is a barred galaxy formed in the early 1990s @xcite and models of the bulge / bar started to appear soon after .
@xcite and @xcite modelled the luminosity density that is implied by the ir data from the cobe mission , while @xcite and @xcite used extensions of schwarzschild s ( 1979 ) modelling technique to produce dynamical models of the bar that predicted proper motions in addition to being compatible with the cobe data .
there was an urgent need for such models to understand the data produced by searches for microlensing events in fields near the galactic centre .
the interplay between these data and galaxy models makes rather a confusing story because it has proved hard to estimate the errors on the optical depth to microlensing in a given field .
the recent work of the basel group @xcite and the microlensing collaborations @xcite seems at last to have produced a reasonably coherent picture .
@xcite fit a model to structures that are seen in the @xmath3 diagrams that one constructs from spectral - line observations of hi and co. the model is based on hydrodynamical simulations of the flow of gas in the gravitational potential of a density model that was fitted to the cobe data @xcite .
they show that structures observed in the @xmath3 plane can be reproduced if three conditions are fulfilled : ( a ) the pattern speed of the bar is assigned a value that is consistent with the one obtained by @xcite from local stellar kinematics ; ( b ) there are four spiral arms ( two weak , two strong ) and they rotate at a much lower pattern speed ; ( c ) virtually all the mass inside the sun is assigned to the stars rather than a dark halo .
@xcite go on to construct a stellar - dynamical model that reproduces the luminosity density inferred by @xcite .
the model , which has no free parameters , reproduces both ( a ) the stellar kinematics in windows on the bulge , and ( b ) the microlensing event timescale distribution determined by the macho collaboration @xcite .
the magnitude of the microlensing optical depth towards bulge fields is still controversial , but the latest results agree extremely well with the values predicted by bissantz & gerhard : in units of @xmath4 , the eros collaboration report optical depth @xmath5 at @xmath6 @xcite while bissantz & gerhard predicted @xmath7 at this location ; the macho collaboration report @xmath8 at @xmath9 @xcite , while bissantz & gerhard predicted @xmath10 at this location .
thus there is now a body of evidence to suggest that the galaxy s mass is dominated by stars that can be traced by ir light rather than by invisible objects such as wimps , and that dynamical galaxy models can successfully integrate data from the entire spectrum of observational probes of the milky way .
since 1980 there has been a steady increase in the extent to which galaxy models are dynamical .
a model must predict stellar velocities if it is to confront proper - motion and radial velocity data , or predict microlensing timescale distributions , and it needs to predict the time - dependent , non - axisymmetric gravitatinal potential in order to confront spectra - line data for hi and co. some progress can be made by adopting characteristic velocity dispersions for different stellar populations , but this is a very poor expedient for several reasons .
( a ) without a dynamical model , we do not know how the orientation of the velocity ellipsoid changes from place to place .
( b ) it is not expected that any population will have gaussian velocity distributions , and a dynamical model is needed to predict how the distributions depart from gaussianity .
( c ) an arbitrarily chosen set of velocity distributions at different locations for a given component are guaranteed to be dynamically inconsistent .
therefore it is imperative that we move to fully dynamical galaxy models .
the question is simply , what technology is most promising in this connection ?
the market for models of external galaxies is currently dominated by models of the type pioneered by @xcite .
one guesses the galactic potential and calculates a few thousand judiciously chosen orbits in it , keeping a record of how each orbit contributes to the observables , such as the space density , surface brightness , mean - streaming velocity , or velocity dispersion at a grid of points that covers the galaxy .
then one uses linear or quadratic programming to find non - negative weights @xmath11 for each orbit in the library such that the observations are well fitted by a model in which a fraction @xmath11 of the total mass is on the @xmath12th orbit .
schwarzschild s technique has been used to construct spherical , axisymmetric and triaxial galaxy models that fit a variety of observational constraints .
thus it is a tried - and - tested technology of great flexibility .
it does have significant drawbacks , however .
first the choice of initial conditions from which to calculate orbits is at once important and obscure , especially when the potential has a complex geometry , as the galactic potential has .
second , different investigators will choose different initial conditions and therefore obtain different orbits even when using the same potential .
so there is no straightforward way of comparing the distributon functions of their models .
third , the method is computationally very intensive because large numbers of phase - space locations have to be stored for each of orbit .
finally , predictions of the model are subject to discreteness noise that is larger than one might naively suppose because orbital densities tend to be cusped ( and formally singular ) at their edges and there is no natural procedure for smoothing out these singularities . in oxford over a number of years we developed a technique in which orbits are not obtained as the time sequence that results from integration of the equations of motion , but as images under a canonical map of an orbital torus of the isochrone potential .
each orbit is specified by its actions @xmath13 and is represented by the coefficients @xmath14 that define the function @xmath15 that generates the map .
once the @xmath16 have been determined , analytic expressions are available for @xmath17 and @xmath18 , so one can readily determine the velocity at which the orbit would pass through any given location .
since orbits are labelled by actions , which define a true mapping of phase space , it is straightforward to construct an orbit library by systematically sampling phase space at the nodes of a regular grid of actions @xmath19 . moreover , a good approximation to an arbitrary orbit can be obtained by interpolating the @xmath20 .
if the orbit library is generated by torus mapping , it is easy to determine the distributon function from the weights . when the orbit weigts are normalized such that @xmath21 , and the distribution function is normalized such that @xmath22 , then @xmath23 if the action - space gid is regular with spacing @xmath24 , we can obtain an equivalent smoothed distribution function by replacing @xmath25 by @xmath26 if @xmath13 lies within a cube of side @xmath24 centred on @xmath27 , and zero otherwise .
different modellers can easily compare their smoothed distribution functions .
finally , with torus mapping many fewer numbers need to be stored for each orbit just the @xmath16 rather than thousands of phase - space locations @xmath28 .
the drawbacks of torus mapping are these .
first , it requires complex special - purpose software , whereas orbit integration is trivial .
second , it has to date only been demonstrated for systems that have two degrees of freedom , such as an axisymmetric potential @xcite , or a planar bar @xcite . finally , orbits are in a fictitious integrable hamiltonian @xcite rather than in the , probably non - integrable , potential of interest .
i return to this point below . in both the schwarzschild and torus modelling strategies
one starts by calculating an orbit library , and the weights of orbits are determined only after this step is complete .
@xcite suggested an alternative stratey , in which the weights are determined simultaneously with the integration of the orbits .
combining these two steps reduces the large overhead involved in storing large numbers of phase - space coordinates for individual orbits .
moreover , with the syer tremaine technique the potential does not have to be fixed , but can be allowed to evolve in time , for example through the usual self - consistency condition of an n - body simulation . to describe the syer
tremaine algorithm we need to define some notation .
let @xmath29 denote an arbitrary point in phase space .
then each observable @xmath30 is defined by a kernel @xmath31 through @xmath32 for example , if @xmath33 is the density at some point @xmath34 , then @xmath35 would be @xmath36 . in an orbit model
we take @xmath37 to be of the form @xmath38 and the integral in the last equation becomes a sum over orbits : @xmath39 if we simultaneously integrate a large number of orbits in a common potential @xmath1 ( which might be the time - dependent potential that is obtained by assigning each particle a mass @xmath40 ) , then through equation ( [ discy ] ) each observable becomes a function of time .
let @xmath33 be the required value of this observable , then syer & tremaine adjust the value of the weight of the @xmath12th orbit at a rate @xmath41\over z_\alpha } \left({y_\alpha\over y_\alpha}-1\right).\ ] ] here the positive numbers @xmath42 are chosen judiciously to stress the importance of satisfying particular constraints , and can be increased to slow the rate at which the weights are adjusted .
the numerator @xmath43 $ ] ensures that a discrepancy between @xmath44 and @xmath33 impacts @xmath11 only in so far as the orbit contributes to @xmath30 .
the right side starts with a minus sign to ensure that @xmath11 is decreased if @xmath45 and the orbit tends to increase @xmath30 . @xcite
have recently demonstrated the value of the syer & tremaine algorithm by using it to construct a dynamical model of the inner galaxy in the pre - determined potential of @xcite .
n - body simulations have been enormously important for the development of our understanding of galactic dynamics . to date
they have been of rather limited use in modelling specific galaxies , because the structure of an n - body model has been determined in an obscure way by the initial conditions from which it is started .
in fact , a major motivation for developing other modelling techniques has been the requirement for initial conditions that will lead to n - body models that have a specified structure ( e.g * ? ? ? * ) .
nothwithstanding this difficulty , @xcite was able to find an n - body model that qualitatively fits observations of the inner galaxy
. it will be interesting to see whether the syer tremaine algorithm can be used to refine a model like that of fux until it matches all observational constraints .
when trying to understand something that is complex , it is best to proceed through a hierarchy of abstractions : first we paint a broad - bruish picture that ignores many details .
then we look at areas in which our first picture clearly conflicts with reality , and understand the reasons for this conflict .
armed with this understanding , we refine our model to eliminate these conflicts
. then we turn to the most important remaining areas of disagreement between our model and reality , and so on .
the process terminates when we feel that we have nothing new or important to learn from residual mismatches between theory and measurement .
this logic is nicely illustrated by the dynamics of the solar system .
we start from the model in which all planets move on kepler ellipses around the sun .
then we consider the effect on planets such as the earth of jupiter s gravitational field . to this point
we have probably assumed that all bodies lie in the ecliptic , and now we might consider the non - zero inclinations of orbits .
one by one we introduce disturbances caused by the masses of the other planets
. then we might introduce corrections to the equations of motion from general relativity , followed by consideration of effects that arise because planets and moons are not point particles , but spinning non - spherical bodies . as we proceed through this hierarchy of models ,
our orbits will proceed from periodic , to quasi - periodic to chaotic .
models that we ultimately reject as oversimplified will reveal structure that was previously unsuspected , such as bands of unoccupied semi - major axes in the asteroid belt .
the chaos that we will ultimately have to confront will be understood in terms of resonances between the orbits we considered in the previous level of abstraction .
the impact of hipparcos on our understanding of the dynamics of the solar neighbourhood gives us a flavour of the complexity we will have to confront in the gaia catalogue .
when the density of stars in the @xmath46 plane was determined @xcite , it was found to be remarkably lumpy , and the lumps contained old stars as well as young , so they could not be just dissolving associations , as the classical interpretation of star streams supposed .
now that the radial velocities of the hipparcos survey stars are available , it has become clear that the hyades - pleiades and sirius moving groups are very heterogeous as regards age @xcite . evidently these structures do not reflect the patchy nature of star formation , but have a dynamical origin . they are probably generated by transient spiral structure @xcite , so they reflect departures of the galaxy from both axisymmetry and time - independence .
such structures will be most readily understod by perturbing a steady - state , axisymmetric galaxy model .
a model based on torus mapping is uniquely well suited to such a study because its orbits are inherently quasi - periodic structures with known angle - action coordinates .
consequently , we have everything we need to use the powerful techniques of canonical perturbation theory . even in the absence of departures from axisymmetry or time - variation in the potential
, resonances between the three characteristic frequencies of a quasi - periodic orbit can deform the orbital structure from that encountered in analytically integrable potentials .
important examples of this phenomenon are encountered in the dynamics of triaxial elliptical galaxies , where resonant ` boxlets ' almost entirely replace box orbits when the potential is realistically cuspy @xcite , and in the dynamics of disk galaxies , where the 1:1 resonance between radial and vertical oscillations probably trapped significant numbers of thick - disk stars as the mass of the thin disk built up @xcite .
@xcite has shown that such families of resonant orbits may be very successfully modelled by applying perturbation theory to orbits obtained by torus mapping .
if the resonant family is exceptionally large , one may prefer to obtain its orbits directly by torus mapping @xcite rather than through perturbation theory .
figures [ fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] show examples of each approach to a resonant family .
both figures show surfaces of section for motion in a planar bar . in figure [ fig1 ]
a relatively weak resonance is successfuly handled through perturbation theory , while in figure [ fig2 ] a more powerful resonance that induces significant chaos is handled by directly mapping isochrone orbits into the resonant region .
these examples demonstrate that if we obtain orbits by torus mapping , we will be able to discover what the galaxy would look like in the absence of any particular resonant family or chaotic region , so we will be able to ascribe particular features in the data to particular resonances and chaotic zones .
this facility will make the modelling process more instructive than it would be if we adopted a simple orbit - based technique .
a dynamical model galaxy will consist of a gravitational potential @xmath47 together with distribution functions @xmath48 for each of several stellar populations .
each distribution function may be represented by a set of orbital weights @xmath11 , and the populations will consist of probability distributions in mass @xmath49 , metallicity @xmath50 and age @xmath51 that a star picked from the population has the specified characteristics .
thus a galaxy model will contain an extremely large number of parameters , and fitting these to the data will be a formidable task .
since so much of the galaxy will be hidden from gaia by dust , interpretation of the gaia catalogue will require a knowledge of the three - dimensional distribution of dust .
such a model can be developed by the classical method of comparing measured colours with the intrinsic colours of stars of known spectral type and distance . at large distances from the sun , even gaia s small parallax errors will give rise to significantly uncertain distances , and these uncertainties will be an important limitation on the reliability of any dust model that one builds in this way . dynamical modelling offers the opportunity to refine our dust model because newton s laws of motion enable us to predict the luminosity density in obscured regions from the densities and velocities that we see elsewhere , and hence to detect obscuration without using colour data .
moreover , they require that the luminosity distributions of hot components are intrinsically smooth , so fluctuations in the star counts of these populations at high spatial frequencies must arise from small scale structure in the obscuring dust .
therefore , we should solve for the distribution of dust at the same time as we are solving for the potential and the orbital weights .
in principle one would like to fit a galaxy model to the data by predicting from the model the probability density @xmath52 of detecting a star at given values of the catalogue variables , such as celestial coordinates @xmath53 , parallax @xmath54 , and proper motons @xmath55 , and then evaluating the likelihood @xmath56 , where the product runs over stars in the catalogue and @xmath57 with @xmath58 the measured values and @xmath59 the associated uncertainties .
unfortunately , it is likely to prove difficult to obtain the required probability density @xmath60 from an orbit - based model , and we will be obliged to compare the real catalogue to a pseudo - catalogue derived from the current model . moreover , standard optimization algorithms are unlikely to find the global maximum in @xmath61 without significant astrophysical input from the modeller . in any event , evaluating @xmath62 for each of @xmath63 observed stars is a formidable computational problem . devising efficient ways of fitting models to the data
clearly requires much more thought .
fine structure in the galaxy s phase space may provide crucial assistance in fitting a model to the data .
two inevitable sources of fine structure are ( a ) resonances , and ( b ) tidal streams .
resonances will sometimes be marked by a sharp increase in the density of stars , as a consequence of resonant trapping , while other resonances show a deficit of stars .
suppose the data seem to require an enhanced density of stars at some point in action space and you suspect that the enhancement is caused by a particular resonance .
by virtue of errors in the adopted potential @xmath1 , the frequencies will not actually be in resonance at the centre of the enhancement . by appropriate modification of @xmath1
it will be straightforward to bring the frequencies into resonance . by reducing the errors in the estimated actions of orbits , a successful update of @xmath1
will probably enhance the overdensity around the resonance .
in fact , one might use the visibility of density enhancements to adjust @xmath1 very much as the visibility of stellar images is used with adaptive optics to configure the telescope optics .
a tidal stream is a population of stars that are on very similar orbits
the actions of the stars are narrowly distributed around the actions of the orbit on which the dwarf galaxy or globular cluster was captured .
consequently , in action space a tidal stream has higher contrast than it does in real space , where the stars diverging angle variables gradually spread the stars over the sky .
errors in @xmath1 will tend to disperse a tidal stream in action space , so again @xmath1 can be tuned by making the tidal stream as sharp a feature as possible .
dynamical galaxy models have a central role to play in attaining gaia s core goal of determining the structure and unravelling the history of the milky way .
even though people have been building galaxy models for over half a century , we are still only beginning to construct fully dynamical models , and we are very far from being able to build multi - component dynamical models of the type that the gaia will require .
at least three potentially viable galaxy - modelling technologies can be identified .
one has been extensively used to model external galaxies , one has the distinction of having been used to build the currently leading galaxy model , while the third technology is the least developed but potentially the most powerful . at this point
we would be wise to pursue all three technologies .
once constructed , a model needs to be confronted with the data . on account of the important roles in this confrontation that will be played by obscuration and parallax errors , there is no doubt in my mind that we need to project the models into the space of gaia s catalogue variables @xmath64 .
this projection is simple in principle , but will be computationally intensive in practice .
the third and final task is to change the model to make it fit the data better .
this task is going to be extremely hard , and it is not clear at this point what strategy we should adopt when addressing it .
it seems possible that features in the action - space density of stars associated with resonances and tidal streams will help us to home in on the correct potential .
there is much to do and it is time we started doing it if we want to have a reasonably complete box of tools in hand when the first data arrive in 20122013 .
the overall task is almost certainly too large for a single institution to complete on its own , and the final galaxy - modelling machinery ought to be at the disposal of the wider community than the dynamics community since it will be required to evaluate the observable implications of any change in the characteristics or kinematics of stars or interstellar matter throughout the galaxy .
therefore , we should approach the problem of building galaxy models as an aspect of infrastructure work for gaia , rather than mere science exploitation .
i hope that in the course of the next year interested parties will enter into discussions about how we might divide up the work , and define interface standards that will enable the efforts of different groups to be combined in different combinations .
it is to be hoped that these discussions lead before long to successful applications to funding bodies for the resources that will be required to put the necessary infrastructure in place by 2012 . | techniques for the construction of dynamical galaxy models should be considered essential infrastructure that should be put in place before gaia flies .
three possible modelling techniques are discussed .
although one of these seems to have significantly more potential than the other two , at this stage work should be done on all three .
a major effort is needed to decide how to make a model consistent with a catalogue such as that which gaia will produce . given the complexity of the problem , it is argued that a hierarchy of models should be constructed , of ever increasing complexity and quality of fit to the data .
the potential that resonances and tidal streams have to indicate how a model should be refined is briefly discussed . |
nearly all gaseous objects that shine are also observed to generate gaseous flows .
this includes the jets of protostars , the stellar winds of massive o and b stars , the gentle solar wind of our sun , the associated absorption of bright quasars , and the spectacular jets of radio - loud agn .
these gaseous outflows regulate the metal and dust content and distribution within the objects and their surroundings , moderate the accretion of new material , and inject energy and momentum into gas on large scales . developing a comprehensive model for these flows is critical to understanding the evolution of the source and its impact on the surrounding environment .
starburst galaxies , whose luminosity is dominated by regions and massive stars , are also observed to drive gaseous outflows .
these flows are generally expected ( and sometimes observed ) to have multiple phases , for example a hot and diffuse phase traced by x - ray emission together with a cool , denser phase traced by h@xmath6 emission ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
several spectacular examples in the local universe demonstrate that flows can extend to up to @xmath7 kpc from the galaxy @xcite carrying significant speed to escape from the gravitational potential well of the galaxy s dark matter halo ( e.g. * ? ? ?
galactic outflows are also revealed by uv and optical absorption lines , e.g. , , and transitions . with the galaxy as a backlight
, one observes gas that is predominantly blue - shifted which indicates a flow toward earth and away from the galaxy .
these transitions are sensitive to the cool (; @xmath8k ) and warm (;
@xmath9k ) phases of the flow .
the incidence of cool gas outflows is nearly universal in vigorously star - forming galaxies ; this includes systems at low @xmath10 which exhibit and absorption @xcite , @xmath11 star - forming galaxies with winds traced by and transitions @xcite , and @xmath12 lyman break galaxies ( lbgs ) that show blue - shifted , , and transitions @xcite . the observation of metal - line absorption is now a well - established means of identifying outflows .
furthermore , because the x - ray and h@xmath6 emission generated by winds is faint , absorption - line analyses have traditionally been the only way to probe outflows in distant galaxies .
however , very little research has been directed toward comparing the observations against ( even idealized ) wind models ( e.g. * ? ? ?
instead , researchers have gleaned what limited information is afforded by direct analysis of the absorption lines .
the data diagnose the speed of the gas relative to the galaxy , yet they poorly constrain the optical depth , covering fraction , density , temperature , and distance of the flow from the galaxy . in turn , constraints related to the mass , energetics , and momentum of the flow suffer from orders of magnitude uncertainty . both the origin and impact of galactic - scale winds , therefore , remain open matters of debate @xcite
. recent studies of @xmath13 star - forming galaxies have revealed that the cool outflowing gas often exhibits significant resonant - line emission ( e.g. , ) in tandem with the nearly ubiquitous blue - shifted absorption @xcite .
the resultant spectra resemble the p - cygni profile characteristic of stellar winds .
this phenomenon was first reported by @xcite , who observed blue - shifted absorption and red - shifted emission for the transition in the spectrum of the local starburst galaxy ngc 1808 .
more recently , @xcite , who studied absorption in @xmath14 galaxies , reported emission in a small subset of the individual galaxy spectra of their large sample .
these were excluded from the full analysis on concerns that the emission was related to agn activity .
the stacked spectra of the remaining galaxies , however , also indicated emission , both directly and when the authors modeled and ` removed ' the @xmath15 absorption component .
the authors suggested the emission could be related to back - scattered light in the wind , but presumed that it was related to weak agn activity .
very similar emission was observed by @xcite who repeated the analysis of @xcite on a set of lower redshift galaxies .
bright line emission has also been reported for individual galaxies at @xmath16 by ( * ? ? ?
* see also rubin et al 2011 , in prep . ) . in their analysis of a single galaxy spectrum
, @xcite further demonstrated that the line emission is spatially extended , and used the size of the emission to infer that the wind extends to at least 7kpc from the galaxy .
these authors additionally detected line emission from non - resonant @xmath17 transitions , and attributed the emission to fluorescence powered by resonant absorption .
in other words , these photons are re - emitted by the wind into our sightline , and are analogous to the emitted photons in a p - cygni profile .
line - emission that may be related to outflows is also observed for @xmath4 lbgs in the resonant transition and non - resonant @xmath17 transitions . ]
this emission likely arises from a completely different physical process than those generating x - ray and h@xmath6 emission ( e.g. , shocks ) , and presumably probes both the cool gas at the base of the wind and the outskirts of the flow ( i.e. , wherever a given transition is optically thick ) .
a comprehensive analysis of the scattered and fluorescent emission related to galactic - scale outflows ( e.g. via deep integral - field - unit [ ifu ] observations , @xcite ) may offer unique diagnostics on the spatial extent , morphology , and density of the outflow from distant galaxies , eventually setting tighter constraints on the energetics of the flow .
although astronomers are rapidly producing a wealth of observational datasets on galactic - scale winds , a key ingredient to a proper analysis is absent . just as comparisons between observed supernova lightcurves and spectra and radiative transfer calculations of of sne models have provided crucial insight into the physics driving , e.g. , standard candle relationships for both type ia and iip sne @xcite , modeling of the observable signatures of galactic outflows
is necessary for understanding the physical properties of the gas and ultimately the physics driving the flows . in this paper , we take the first steps toward modeling the absorption and emission properties of cool gas outflows as observed in one dimensional spectra and by ifus . using monte carlo radiative transfer techniques , we study the nature of and absorption and emission for winds with a range of properties , accounting for the effects of resonant scattering and fluorescence .
although the winds are idealized , the results frequently contradict our intuition and challenge the straightforward conversion of observables to ( even crude ) physical constraints .
these findings have a direct bearing on recent and upcoming surveys of galactic outflows , particularly those which make use of and transitions to probe outflow properties .
the paper is organized as follows . in @xmath18 [
sec : method ] , we describe the methodology of our radiative transfer algorithms .
these are applied to a fiducial wind model in @xmath18 [ sec : fiducial ] and variations of this model in @xmath18 [ sec : variants ] . in @xmath18 [
sec : alternate ] , we explore wind models with a broader range of density and velocity laws .
we discuss the principal results and connect to observations in @xmath18 [ sec : discuss ] .
a brief summary is given in @xmath18 [ sec : summary ] .
this section describes our methodology for generating emission / absorption profiles from simple wind models .
lcccccc uv1 & 38458.98 & 0.00 & 9/2 & 9/2 & 2600.173 & 2.36e+08 + & 38458.98 & 384.79 & 9/2 & 7/2 & 2626.451 & 3.41e+07 + & 38660.04 & 0.00 & 7/2 & 9/2 & 2586.650 & 8.61e+07 + & 38660.04 & 384.79 & 7/2 & 7/2 & 2612.654 & 1.23e+08 + & 38660.04 & 667.68 & 7/2 & 5/2 & 2632.108 & 6.21e+07 + & 38858.96 & 667.68 & 5/2 & 5/2 & 2618.399 & 4.91e+07 + & 38858.96 & 862.62 & 5/2 & 3/2 & 2631.832 & 8.39e+07 + + [ -1.5ex ] & 35760.89 & 0.00 & 3/2 & 0 & 2796.351 & 2.63e+08 + & 35669.34 & 0.00 & 1/2 & 0 & 2803.528 & 2.60e+08 + doublet and the uv1 multiplet of transitions ( based on figure 7 from @xcite ) .
each transition shown is labeled by its rest wavelength ( ) and einstein a - coefficient ( s@xmath19 ) .
black upward arrows indicate the resonance - line transitions , i.e. those connected to the ground state .
the 2p@xmath203p configuration of mg@xmath21 is split into two energy levels that give rise to the @xmath0 doublet . both the 3d@xmath204s ground state and 3d@xmath204p upper level of fe@xmath21 exhibit fine - structure splitting that gives rise to a series of electric - dipole transitions .
the downward ( green ) arrows show the * transitions that are connected to the resonance - line transitions ( i.e. they share the same upper energy levels ) .
we also show a pair of transitions ( @xmath22 ; red and dashed lines ) that arise from higher levels in the z @xmath20d@xmath23configuration .
these transitions have not yet been observed in galactic - scale outflows and are not considered in our analysis . , width=336 ] in this paper , we focus on two sets of radiative transitions arising from fe@xmath21 and mg@xmath21 ions ( table [ tab : atomic ] , figure [ fig : energy ] ) .
this is a necessarily limited set , but the two ions and their transitions do have characteristics shared by the majority of low - ion transitions observed in cool - gas outflows .
therefore , many of the results that follow may be generalized to observational studies that consider other atoms and ions tracing cool gas .
the mg@xmath21 ion , with a single 3s electron in the ground - state , exhibits an alkali doublet of transitions at @xmath24 analogous to the doublet of neutral hydrogen .
figure [ fig : energy ] presents the energy level diagram for this @xmath0 doublet . in non - relativistic quantum mechanics ,
the 2p@xmath203p energy level is said to be split by spin - orbit coupling giving the observed line doublet .
these are the only electric - dipole transitions with wavelengths near 2800 and the transition connecting the @xmath25 and @xmath26 states is forbidden by several selection rules .
therefore , an absorption from 2p@xmath203s @xmath27 2p@xmath203pis followed @xmath28 of the time by a spontaneous decay ( @xmath29s ) to the ground state .
our treatment will ignore any other possibilities ( e.g. absorption by a second photon when the electron is at the 2p@xmath203p level ) . in terms of radiative transfer ,
the @xmath0 doublet is very similar to that for , the @xmath30 doublet , and many other doublets commonly studied in the interstellar medium ( ism ) of distant galaxies .
each of these has the ground - state connected to a pair of electric dipole transitions with nearly identical energy .
the doublets differ only in their rest wavelengths and the energy of the doublet separation . for
, the separation is sufficiently small ( @xmath31 ) that most radiative transfer treatments actually ignore it is a doublet .
this is generally justifiable for because most astrophysical processes have turbulent motions that significantly exceed the doublet s velocity separation and effectively mix the two transitions . for ( @xmath32 ) , ( @xmath33 ) , and most of the other doublets commonly observed , the separation is large and the transitions must be treated separately .
iron exhibits the most complex set of energy levels for elements frequently studied in astrophysics .
the fe@xmath21 ion alone has millions of energy levels recorded @xcite , and even this is an incomplete list .
one reason for iron s complexity is that the majority of its configurations exhibit fine - structure splitting .
this includes the ground - state configuration ( a @xmath20d@xmath23 ) which is split into 5 levels , labeled by the total angular momentum @xmath34 , with excitation energies @xmath35 ranging from @xmath36k ( figure [ fig : energy ] ) .
transitions between these fine - structure levels are forbidden ( magnetic - dipole ) and have spontaneous decay times of several hours . in this paper
, we examine transitions between the ground - state configuration and the energy levels of the z @xmath20d@xmath23configuration .
this set of transitions ( named the uv1 multiplet ) have wavelengths near 2600 . there are two resonance - line transitions . ]
associated with this multiplet ( @xmath37 ) corresponding to @xmath38 ; these are indicated by upward ( black ) arrows in figure [ fig : energy ] .
the solid ( green ) downward arrows in figure [ fig : energy ] mark the non - resonant * transitions that are connected to the upper energy levels of the resonance lines .
these transitions may occur following the absorption of a single photon by fe@xmath21 in its ground - state .
this process may also be referred to as fluorescence .
note that two of these transitions ( * @xmath39 ) are close enough in energy that their line profiles can overlap .
the figure also shows ( as dashed , downward arrows ) two of the * transitions that connect to higher energy levels of the z @xmath20d@xmath23configuration . ignoring collisions and recombinations
, these transitions may only occur after the absorption of two photons : one to raise the electron from the ground - state to an excited state and another to raise the electron from the excited state to one of the z @xmath20d@xmath23 levels with @xmath40 .
the excitation of fine - structure levels by the absorption of uv photons is termed indirect uv pumping ( e.g * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and requires the ion to lie near an intense source of uv photons .
even a bright , star - forming galaxy emits too few photons at @xmath41 to uv - pump fe@xmath21 ions that are farther than @xmath42pc from the stars . in the following
, we will assume that emission from this process is negligible .
our calculations also ignore collisional processes , i.e. collisional excitation and de - excitation of the various levels .
for the fine - structure levels of the a @xmath20d@xmath23 configuration , the excitation energies are modest ( @xmath43k ) but the critical density @xmath44 is large . for the a @xmath20d@xmath23@xmath45a @xmath20d@xmath23@xmath46 transition , the critical density @xmath47 . at these densities
, one would predict detectable quantities of which has not yet been observed in galactic - scale outflows .
if collisional excitation is insignificant then one may also neglect collisional de - excitation .
furthermore , observations rarely show _ absorption _ from the fine - structure levels of the a @xmath20d@xmath23 configuration and that material is not significantly blue - shifted ( rubin et al .
, in prep ) . in the following , we assume that electrons only occupy the ground - state , i.e. the gas has zero opacity to the non - resonant lines .
regarding the doublet , its excitation energy is significantly higher implying negligible collisional processes at essentially any density .
nearly all of the absorption studies of galactic - scale outflows have focused on intensely , star - forming galaxies .
the intrinsic emission of these galaxies is a complex combination of light from stars and regions that is then modulated by dust and gas within the ism . for the spectral regions studied here ,
the hottest stars show a featureless continuum , but later spectral types do show significant and absorption .
in addition , asymmetric and/or blue - shifted absorption is exhibited in these transitions in a and f stars driving stellar winds @xcite .
p cygni profiles are observed in a handful of f stars by @xcite , who attribute the emission to chromospheric activity rather than mass - loss effects .
regions , meanwhile , are observed to emit weakly at the @xmath0 doublet , primarily due to recombinations in the outer layers @xcite .
it is beyond the scope of this paper to properly model the stellar absorption and region emission , but the reader should be aware that they can complicate the observed spectrum , independently of any outflow , especially at velocities @xmath48 . in the following ,
we assume a simple flat continuum normalized to unit value .
the size of the emitting region @xmath49 is a free parameter , but we restrict its value to be smaller than the minimum radial extent of any gaseous component .
lastly , the source does not absorb any scattered or emitted photons .
we calculated spectra using a 3d monte carlo radiation transport code originally designed for supernova outflows @xcite but modified to treat resonant line transport on a galactic scale @xcite .
our methods are similar to those used in several other codes which focus on ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , except that here we include the effects of multiple line scattering and fluorescence . for our 3-dimensional calculations ,
the wind properties ( density , temperature and velocity ) were discretized on a @xmath50 cartesian grid ( for certain 1-d calculations , the wind properties were simply computed on the fly from analytic formulae ) .
the radiation field was represented by @xmath51 photon packets ( typically @xmath52 ) which were initially emitted isotropically and uniformly throughout the source region ( @xmath53 ) .
the wavelengths of the packets were sampled from a flat spectral energy distribution .
photon packets were tracked through randomized scattering and absorption events until they escaped the computational domain .
the distance to the next packet interaction event was determined by doppler shifting packets to the comoving frame and sampling the mean free path to each resonance line ( and dust , if present ) .
the resonant line opacity followed a voigt profile which was determined using the analytic fits of @xcite .
non - resonant lines were assumed to be completely optically thin , and the dust opacity was assumed to be wavelength independent and completely absorbing ( @xmath18 [ sec : dust_method ] ) . because of the relatively low optical depths encountered in these models , no `` core - skipping '' scheme was applied to accelerate the resonant line transport , and recoil effects were ignored . in a resonant line interaction ,
a photon excites an atom from the ground state to an excited level .
the end result is either scattering ( i.e. , de - excitation back to the ground state ) or fluorescence ( de - excitation to another excited level ) .
the probability that the atom de - excites to lower level @xmath54 is @xmath55 , where the @xmath56 are the einstein spontaneous emission coefficients and the sum runs over all levels accessible from the upper state @xmath57 . for each interaction event
, a random number was drawn to sample the final state from this probability distribution .
if the result was a scattering , the process was assumed to be coherent in the comoving frame .
if the result was fluorescence , the packet was reemitted at the line center wavelength of the new transition . natural line broadening in fluorescence
was ignored given the high velocity gradients in our models . in all cases ,
the angular redistribution was assumed to be isotropic .
to generate multi - dimensional images and spectra of the system , an escape probability method was used . at the initiation of a packet , and at every subsequent interaction event , we calculated the probability @xmath58 , that the packet de - excited into state @xmath54 and escaped the domain in some pre - specified direction . here @xmath59 is the optical depth to infinity , which was constructed by integration along the path to escape , taking into account the relevant doppler shifts and possible absorption by lines or dust . the contribution of the packet to the final spectrum was then added in for every possible final state , each shifted to the proper observer - frame wavelength and weighted by the probability @xmath60 .
lying above an opaque emitting surface at velocity coordinate 100 km s@xmath19 . the wind extended to 2,000 km s@xmath19 and the sobolev optical depth had values of @xmath61 ( black lines ) , @xmath62 ( red lines ) , and @xmath63 ( blue lines ) .
discrepancies in the @xmath63 case are likely due to the breakdown of the sobolev approximation ( @xmath18 [ sec : sobolev ] ) at high optical depth . ,
width=336 ] to validate the monte carlo code , we calculated a series of test problems consisting of a point source embedded in a spherical , homogenous medium of varying resonant line optical depth .
the resulting resonant line profiles ( see * ? ? ?
* ) were found to be in good agreement with the standard analytic solutions @xcite . as a further test
, we calculated line profiles for the case of an extended spherical source embedded in a homologously expanding wind with large velocity gradient .
these model spectra ( figure [ fig : oneline_test ] ) are in good agreement with ones determined by direct numerical integration of the radiation transport equation under the sobolev approximation ( @xmath18 [ sec : sobolev ] ; e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . for the majority of models studied in this paper , we assume the gas contains no dust .
this is an invalid assumption , especially for material associated with the ism of a galaxy .
essentially all astrophysical environments that contain both cool gas and metals also show signatures of dust depletion and extinction .
this includes the ism of star - forming and -selected galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , strong metal - line absorption systems @xcite , and the galactic winds traced by low - ion transitions @xcite . extraplanar material likely associated with a galactic - scale outflow has been observed to emit ir radiation characteristic of dust ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in addition , @xcite have argued from a statistical analysis that dust is distributed to many tens of kpc from @xmath64 galaxies and have suggested it was transported from the galaxies by galactic - scale winds .
although the galactic winds traced specifically by and transitions have not ( yet ) been demonstrated to contain dust , it is reasonable to consider its effects . for analysis on normalized spectra ( i.e. absorption lines ) ,
the effects of dust are largely minimized ; dust has a nearly constant opacity over small spectral regions and all features are simply scaled together . for scattered and resonantly trapped photons , however , the relative effect of dust extinction can be much greater .
these photons travel a much longer distance to escape the medium and may experience a much higher integrated opacity from dust .
indeed , dust is frequently invoked to explain the weak ( or absent ) emission from star - forming galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
although the transitions studied here have much lower opacity than , dust could still play an important role in the predicted profiles . in a few models ,
we include absorption by dust under the following assumptions : ( i ) the dust opacity scales with the density of the gas ( i.e. we adopt a fixed dust - to - gas ratio ) ; ( ii ) the opacity is independent of wavelength , a reasonable approximation given the small spectral range analyzed ; ( iii ) dust absorbs but does not scatter photons ; ( iv ) the photons absorbed by dust are re - emitted at ir wavelengths and are ` lost ' from the system .
the dust absorption is normalized by @xmath65 , the integrated opacity of dust from the center of the system to infinity .
the ambient ism of a star - forming galaxy may be expected to exhibit @xmath65 values of one to a few at @xmath66 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
a photon propagating through a differentially expanding medium interacts with a line only when its comoving frame wavelength is doppler - shifted into near resonance with the line center rest wavelength . for a wind with a steep velocity law ( i.e. a large gradient @xmath67 ) and/or a narrow intrinsic profile ( i.e. a small doppler parameter )
, the spatial extent of the region of resonance may be much smaller than the length scale of the wind itself .
the interaction can then be considered to occur at a point . in this case
, @xcite introduced a formalism that gives the line optical depth @xmath68 at a given point in terms of the density and velocity gradient of the flow at that radius . for a wind in homologous expansion , this optical depth is independent of the direction of propagation and is given by @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the integrated line opacity , @xmath71 the line - center rest wavelength , @xmath72 the oscillator strength and @xmath73 the density in the lower level of the transition .
we have neglected corrections for stimulated emission .
this optical depth applies to a photon with wavelength @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the direction of propagation .
the probability that such a photon is scattered / absorbed at the point of resonance is simply @xmath76 $ ] .
we find that the sobolev approximation applies for nearly all of the models presented in this paper , and therefore provides a convenient approach to estimating the optical depth .
in this section , we study a simple yet illustrative wind model for a galactic - scale outflow .
the properties of this wind were tuned , in part , to yield a absorption profile similar to those observed for @xmath11 , star - forming galaxies @xcite .
we emphasize , however , that we do not favor this fiducial model over any other wind scenario nor do its properties have special physical motivation .
its role is to establish a baseline for discussion .
the fiducial wind is isotropic , dust - free , and extends from an inner wind radius @xmath77 to an outer wind radius @xmath78 .
it follows a density law , @xmath79 and a velocity law with a purely radial flow @xmath80 for the fiducial case , the hydrogen density at the inner radius is @xmath81 and the velocity at the outer radius is @xmath82 .
turbulent motions are characterized by a doppler parameter only tends to modify the widths and modestly shift the centroids of emission lines . ]
we convert the hydrogen density @xmath84 to the number densities of mg@xmath21 and fe@xmath21 ions by assuming solar relative abundances with an absolute metallicity of 1/2 solar and depletion factors of 1/10 and 1/20 for mg and fe respectively , i.e. @xmath85 and @xmath86=@xmath87/2 . at the center of the wind
is a homogeneous source of continuum photons with size @xmath49 .
the parameters for the fiducial wind model are summarized in table [ tab : fiducial ] .
ccl density law & @xmath88 & @xmath89 + velocity law & @xmath90 & @xmath91 + inner radius & @xmath77 & 1kpc + outer radius & @xmath78 & 20kpc + source size & @xmath49 & 0.5kpc + density normalization & @xmath92 & @xmath93 at @xmath77 + velocity normalization & @xmath94 & 1000at @xmath78 + turbulence & @xmath95 & 15 + mg@xmath21
normalization & @xmath87 & @xmath96 + fe@xmath21 normalization & @xmath86 & @xmath87/2 + in figure [ fig : fiducial_nvt ] we plot the density and velocity laws against radius ; their simple power - law expressions are evident .
the figure also shows the optical depth profile for the @xmath97 transition ( @xmath98 ) , estimated from the sobolev approximation first as a function of velocity by summing the opacity for a series of discrete and small radial intervals between @xmath77 and @xmath78 .
we then mapped @xmath98 onto radius using the velocity law ( equation [ eqn : vel ] ) .
this optical depth profile is shown as the black dotted line in figure [ fig : fiducial_nvt ] . ]
( equation [ eqn : sobolev ] ) . the @xmath98 profile peaks with @xmath99 at a velocity @xmath100 corresponding to @xmath101 . the optical depth profile for the @xmath102 transition ( not plotted )
is scaled down by the @xmath103 ratio but is otherwise identical .
similarly , the optical depth profiles for the @xmath37 transitions are scaled down by @xmath104 and the @xmath86/@xmath87 ratio . for the spatially integrated ( i.e. , 1d ) spectra ,
the actual dimensions and density of the wind are unimportant provided they scale together to give nearly the same optical depth .
therefore , one may consider the choices for @xmath105 , and @xmath106 as largely arbitrary .
nevertheless , we adopted values for this fiducial model with some astrophysical motivation , e.g. , values that correspond to galactic dimensions and a normalization that gives @xmath107
. optical depth profiles ( solid and dotted ; black ) for the fiducial wind model ( see table [ tab : fiducial ] for details ) .
the density and velocity laws are simple @xmath108 and @xmath109 power - laws ; these curves have been scaled for plotting convenience .
the optical depth profile was calculated two ways : ( i ) using the sobolev approximation ( equation [ eqn : sobolev ] ; solid black curve ) and ( ii ) summing the opacity at small and discrete radial intervals in velocity space and then converting to radius with the velocity law ( doted black curve ) .
these give very similar results .
the wind parameters were set to give an optically thick medium at the inner radius ( @xmath110kpc ) that becomes optically thin at the outer radius ( @xmath111kpc ) . ,
height=336 ] ccr mgii 2796 & [ @xmath112 & 2.96 + & [ @xmath113&@xmath114 + mgii 2803 & [ @xmath115 & 1.29 + & [ @xmath116&@xmath117 + feii 2586 & [ @xmath118 & 0.59 + & [ @xmath119&@xmath120 + feii 2600 & [ @xmath121 & 1.16 + & [ @xmath122&@xmath123 + feii * 2612 & [ @xmath124&@xmath125 + feii * 2626 & [ @xmath126&@xmath127 + feii *
2632 & [ @xmath128&@xmath129 + using the methodology described in @xmath18 [ sec : method ] , we propagated photons from the source and through the outflow to an ` observer ' at @xmath130 who views the entire wind+source complex .
figure [ fig : fiducial_1d ] presents the 1d spectrum that this observer would record , with the unattenuated flux normalized to unit value .
the doublet shows the canonical ` p - cygni profile ' that characterizes a continuum source embedded within an outflow .
strong absorption is evident at @xmath131 in both transitions ( with equivalent widths @xmath132 and @xmath133 ) and each shows emission at positive velocities . for an isotropic and dust - free model ,
the total equivalent width of the doublet must be zero , i.e. every photon absorbed eventually escapes the system , typically at lower energy .
the wind simply shuffles the photons in frequency space .
a simple summation of the absorption and emission equivalent widths ( table [ tab : fiducial_ew ] ) confirms this expectation .
focusing further on the absorption , one notes that the profiles lie well above zero intensity and have similar depth even though their @xmath103 values differ by a factor of two . in standard absorption - line analysis ,
this is the tell - tale signature of a ` cloud ' that has a high optical depth ( i.e.is saturated ) which only partially covers the emitting source ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . our fiducial wind model , however , _ entirely covers the source _ ;
the apparent partial covering must be related to a different effect .
figure [ fig : noemiss ] further emphasizes this point by comparing the absorption profiles from figure [ fig : fiducial_1d ] against an artificial model where no absorbed photons are re - emitted . as expected from the @xmath98 profile ( figure [ fig : fiducial_nvt ] ) , this ` intrinsic ' model produces a strong @xmath0 doublet that absorbs all photons at @xmath134 , i.e. @xmath135 .
the true model , in contrast , has been ` filled in ' at @xmath136 by photons scattered in the wind . an absorption - line analysis that ignores these effects
would ( i ) systematically underestimate the true optical depth and/or ( ii ) falsely conclude that the wind partially covers the source .
we will find that these are generic results , even for wind models that include dust and are not fully isotropic . turning to the emission profiles of the @xmath0 doublet ,
one notes that they are quite similar with comparable equivalent widths .
this is because the gas is optically thick yielding comparable total absorption .
the flux of the @xmath102 transition even exceeds that for @xmath97 because the wind speed is greater than the velocity separation of the doublet , @xmath137 .
therefore , the red wing of the @xmath97 emission profile is partially absorbed by @xmath102 and re - emitted at lower frequency .
this yields a line ratio that is far below the @xmath138 ratio that one may have naively expected ( e.g. if the line - emission resulted from recombinations ) , and leads us to conclude that the relative strengths of the emission lines are sensitive to both the opacity and velocity extent of the wind .
now consider the transitions : the bottom left panel of figure [ fig : fiducial_1d ] covers the majority of the uv1 transitions and several are shown in the velocity plot .
the line profile for @xmath139 is very similar to the @xmath0 doublet ; one observes strong absorption to negative velocities and strong emission at @xmath140 producing a characteristic p - cygni profile . splitting the profile at @xmath141
, we measure an equivalent width @xmath142 in absorption and @xmath143 in emission ( table [ tab : fiducial_ew ] ) for a total equivalent width of @xmath144 .
in contrast , the @xmath145 resonance line shows much weaker emission and a much higher total equivalent width ( @xmath146 ) , even though the line has a @xmath147 lower @xmath103 value .
these differences between the resonance lines ( and between and ) occur because of the complex of non - resonant * transitions that are coupled to the resonance lines ( figure [ fig : energy ] ) .
specifically , a resonance photon absorbed at @xmath37 has a finite probability of being re - emitted as a non - resonant photon which then escapes the system without further interaction .
the principal effects are to reduce the line emission of @xmath37 and to produce non - resonant line - emission ( e.g.*@xmath148 ) .
the reduced @xmath145 emission relative to @xmath139 is related to two factors : ( i ) there is an additional downward transition from the z @xmath20d@xmath23@xmath46 level and ( ii ) the einstein a coefficients of the non - resonant lines coupled to @xmath145 are comparable to and even exceed the einstein a coefficient of the resonant transition .
in contrast , the * @xmath149 transition ( associated with @xmath139 ) has an approximately @xmath150 smaller a coefficient than the corresponding resonance line .
therefore , the majority of photons absorbed at @xmath1 are re - emitted as @xmath139 photons , whereas the majority of photons absorbed at @xmath151 are re - emitted at longer wavelengths ( * @xmath148 or @xmath152 ) .
if we increase @xmath153 ( and especially if we include gas with @xmath154 ) then the @xmath139 emission is significantly suppressed ( e.g. @xmath18 [ sec : ism ] ) .
the total equivalent width , however , of the three lines connected to the z @xmath20d@xmath23@xmath46 upper level must still vanish ( photons are conserved in this isotropic , dust - free model ) .
transition for the source+wind complex of the fiducial model .
the middle panel shows the 1d spectrum with @xmath155 corresponding to @xmath156 and the dotted vertical curves indicate the velocity slices for the emission maps .
the source has a size @xmath157kpc , traced by a few pixels at the center of each map . at @xmath158
, the wind has an optical depth of @xmath159 and the source contributes roughly half of the observed flux . at @xmath160
the wind absorbs all photons from the source and the observed emission is entirely due to photons scattered by the wind .
amazingly , this emission exceeds the integrated flux at @xmath161 such that the @xmath97 line center is offset from the ( intrinsic ) peak in optical depth . at @xmath162 ,
both the source and wind contribute to the observed emission .
at all velocities , the majority of emission comes from the inner @xmath163kpc .
, width=336 ] the preceding discussion emphasizes the filling - in of resonance absorption at @xmath164 and the generation of emission lines at @xmath165 by photons scattered in the wind .
we also mapped the emission of the fiducial model to sudy its spatial extent ( see @xmath18 [ sec : monte ] for a description of the algorithm ) .
the output is a set of surface - brightness maps in a series of frequency channels yielding a dataset analogous to integral - field - unit ( ifu ) observations . in figure
[ fig : fiducial_ifu_mgii ] , we present the output at several velocities relative to the @xmath97transition . at @xmath166 , where the wind has an optical depth @xmath167 ( figure [ fig : fiducial_nvt ] ) , the source contributes roughly half of the observed flux . at @xmath168
, however , the wind absorbs all photons from the source and the observed emission is entirely from photons scattered by the wind .
this scattered emission actually exceeds the source+wind emission at @xmath166 such that the absorption profile is negatively offset from the velocity where @xmath98 is maximal ( figure [ fig : fiducial_nvt ] ) .
the net result is weaker absorption that peaks blueward of the actual peak in the optical depth profile .
table [ tab : line_diag ] reports several kinematic measurements of the absorption and emission features . clearly , these effects complicate estimates for the speed , covering fraction , and total column density of the wind . at @xmath169 ,
the wind and source have comparable total flux with the latter dominating at higher velocities .
transition for the source+wind complex .
the results are very similar to those observed for the @xmath0 doublet ( figure [ fig : fiducial_ifu_mgii ] ) .
( lower ) surface - brightness emission maps around the @xmath170 transition for the source+wind complex . in this case , the source is unattenuated yet scattered photons from the wind also make a significant contribution . ,
width=336 ] similar results are observed for the resonance transitions ( figure [ fig : fiducial_ifu_feii ] ) . for transitions to fine - structure levels of the a @xmath20d@xmath23configuration ,
the source is unattenuated but there is a significant contribution from photons generated in the wind . at all velocities
, the majority of light comes from the inner regions of the wind .
the majority of emission occurs within the inner few kpc , e.g. @xmath171 of the light at @xmath172 to @xmath173 comes from @xmath174kpc .
the emission is even more centrally concentrated for the transitions .
a proper treatment of these distributions is critical for interpreting observations acquired through a slit , i.e. where the aperture has a limited extent in one or more dimensions . a standard longslit on 10m - class telescopes , for example , subtends @xmath175 corresponding to @xmath176kpc for @xmath11 .
we return to this issue in @xmath18 [ sec : discuss ] .
the results presented in figures [ fig : fiducial_ifu_mgii ] and [ fig : fiducial_ifu_feii ] are sensitive to the radial extent , morphology , density and velocity profiles of this galactic - scale wind .
consequently , ifu observations of line emission from low - ion transitions may offer the most direct constraints on galactic - scale wind properties .
steradians as viewed from @xmath177 ( source uncovered ) to @xmath178 ( source covered ) .
one detects significant emission for all orientations but significant absorption only for @xmath179 .
the velocity centroid of the emission shifts from positive to negative velocities as @xmath180 increases and one transitions from viewing the wind as lying behind the source to in front of it .
the velocity centroid of emission , therefore , diagnoses the degree of anisotropy for the wind .
, width=336 ]
in this section , we investigate a series of more complex wind scenarios through modifications to the fiducial model .
these include relaxing the assumption of isotropy , introducing dust , adding an ism component within @xmath77 , and varying the normalization of the optical depth profiles .
the fiducial model assumes an isotropic wind with only radial variations in velocity and density .
angular isotropy is obviously an idealized case , but it is frequently assumed in studies of galactic - scale outflows ( e.g. * ? ? ?
there are several reasons , however , to consider anisotropic winds .
firstly , galaxies are not spherically symmetric ; the sources driving the wind ( e.g. supernovae , agn ) are very unlikely to be spherically distributed within the galaxy .
secondly , the galactic ism frequently has a disk - like morphology which will suppress the wind preferentially at low galactic latitudes , perhaps yielding a bi - conic morphology ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
lastly , the galaxy could be surrounded by an aspherical gaseous halo whose interaction would produce an irregular outflow . with these considerations in mind , we reanalyzed the fiducial model with the 3d algorithm after departing from isotropy .
it is beyond the scope of this paper to explore a full suite of anisotropic profiles .
we consider two simple examples : ( i ) half the fiducial model , where the wind density is set to zero for @xmath181 steradians ( i.e. a hemispherical wind ) .
this model is viewed from @xmath177 ( source uncovered ) to @xmath178 ( source covered ) ; and ( ii ) a bi - conical wind which fills @xmath182 both into and out of the plane of the sky and that is viewed along the axis of rotational symmetry ( @xmath183 is defined along this axis ) .
is a full wind ) . for modest angles ,
one observes similar results to the fiducial model but larger angles ( @xmath184 ) the emission is significantly suppressed at all velocities .
, width=336 ] the resulting and profiles for the half wind are compared against the fiducial model ( isotropic wind ) in figure [ fig : anisotropic ] . examining the @xmath0 doublet , the @xmath177 model only shows line - emission from photons scattered off the back side .
these photons , by definition , have @xmath185 relative to line - center ( a subset have @xmath186 because of turbulent motions in the wind ) .
when viewed from the opposite direction ( @xmath178 ) , the absorption lines dominate , but there is still significant line - emission at @xmath187 and at @xmath188 from photons that scatter through the wind which fills in the absorption . the key difference between this and the isotropic wind is the absence of photons scattered to @xmath189 ; this also implies deeper @xmath102 absorption at @xmath190 .
the shifts in velocity centroid and asymmetry of the emission lines serve to diagnose the degree of wind isotropy , especially in conjunction with analysis of the absorption profiles .
the results are similar for the @xmath37 resonance lines .
the @xmath191 line , meanwhile , shows most clearly the offset in velocity between the source unobscured ( @xmath177 ) and source covered ( @xmath178 ) cases .
the offset of the * lines is the most significant difference from the fully isotropic wind .
we have also analyzed the predicted profiles for a series of bi - conical winds with @xmath192 , each viewed along the axis of rotational asymmetry with the wind covering the source .
figure [ fig : biconical ] and table [ tab : line_diag ] summarizes the results for several cases . for @xmath193 ,
the results are very similar to the fiducial model ; the profiles show similar equivalent widths for absorption and emission .
the key quantitative difference is that the * line - emission is modestly suppressed at @xmath194 because the portion of the wind with that projected velocity has been removed .
for more highly collimated winds @xmath195 , however , the line - emission is several times weaker than the fiducial model .
similarly , the absorption - line profiles more closely track the intrinsic optical depth of the outflow . of course , these same models when viewed ` sideways ' would show no absorption but strong line - emission . such events are sufficiently rare ( rubin et al .
, in prep ) that we consider this level of anisotropy to be uncommon .
nevertheless , the results for a bi - conic clearly have important implications for the nature of absorption and line - emission in our fiducial model . ) . the primary effect of dust
is to suppress the line - emission relative to the continuum .
a more subtle but important effect is that the redder photons in the emission lines ( corresponding to positive velocity offsets relative to line - center ) suffer greater extinction .
this occurs because the ` redder ' photons that we view have travelled farther to scatter off the backside of the wind .
note that the absorption lines are nearly unmodified until @xmath196 , a level of extinction that would preclude observing the source altogether .
, width=336 ] as described in @xmath18 [ sec : dust_method ] , one generally expects dust in astrophysical environments that contain cool gas and metals .
this dust modifies the observed wind profiles in two ways .
first , it is a source of opacity for all of the photons .
this suppresses the flux at all wavelengths by @xmath197 but because we re - normalize the profiles , this effect is essentially ignored .
second , photons that are scattered by the wind must travel a greater distance to escape and therefore suffer from greater extinction .
a photon that is trapped for many scatterings has an increased probability of being absorbed by dust .
section [ sec : dust_method ] describes the details of our treatment of dust ; we remind the reader here that we assume a constant dust - to - gas ratio that is normalized by the total optical depth @xmath65 photons would experience if they traveled from the source to infinity without scattering .
line - emission from the fiducial wind model , as attenuated by dust with a range of @xmath65values .
the black ( solid ) curve shows the model results .
the dashed ( green ) curve shows @xmath198 .
it is obvious that the equivalent widths ( i.e. , the flux relative to the continuum ) do not follow this scaling .
the dotted ( red ) line , meanwhile , plots @xmath199 .
this simple approximation is a good representation of the results for our radiative transfer calculations .
, height=336 ] in figure [ fig : dust ] , we show the and profiles of the fiducial model ( @xmath200 ) against a series of models with @xmath201 .
for the transitions , the dominant effect is the suppression of line emission at @xmath202 .
these ` red ' photons have scattered off the backside of the wind and must travel a longer path than other photons .
dust leads to a differential reddening that increases with velocity relative to line - center .
this is a natural consequence of dust extinction and is most evident in the * @xmath148 emission profile which is symmetrically distributed around @xmath169 in the @xmath203 model .
the degree of suppression of the line - emission is relatively modest , however .
specifically , we find that the flux is reduced by a factor of the order of ( 1+@xmath65)@xmath19 ( figure [ fig : dust_tau ] ) , instead of the factor exp(@xmath65 ) that one may have naively predicted . in terms of absorption , the profiles are nearly identical for @xmath204 .
one requires very high extinction to produce a deepening of the profiles at @xmath190 .
we conclude that dust has only a modest influence on this fiducial model and , by inference , on models with moderate peak optical depths and significant velocity gradients with radius ( i.e. scenarios in which the photons scatter only one to a few times before exiting ) . for qualitative changes ,
one requires an extreme level of extinction ( @xmath196 ) . in this case
, the source would be extinguished by 15magnitudes and could never be observed .
even @xmath205 is larger than typically inferred for the star - forming galaxies that drive outflows ( e.g. * ? ? ?
for the emission lines , the dominant effect is a reduction in the flux with a greater extinction at higher velocities relative to line - center . in these respects ,
dust extinction crudely mimics the behavior of the anisotropic wind described in section [ sec : anisotropic ] . in the emission lines from @xmath48 for the fiducial model to @xmath206 for the ism+wind model .
the profiles , meanwhile , show several qualitative differences .
the @xmath37 resonance transitions each exhibit much greater absorption at @xmath48 than the fiducial model .
the resonant line - emission is also substantially reduced , implying much higher fluxes for the non - resonant lines ( e.g.*@xmath148,2626 ) .
lastly , we note that the @xmath145 absorption profile provides a good ( albeit imperfect ) representation of the wind opacity and therefore offers the best characterization of an ism component . , width=336 ] the fiducial model does not include gas associated with the ism of the galaxy , i.e. material at @xmath207kpc with @xmath208 .
this allowed us to focus on results related solely to a wind component . the decision to ignore the ism
was also motivated by the general absence of significant absorption at @xmath187 in galaxies that exhibit outflows ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
on the other hand , the stars that comprise the source are very likely embedded within and fueled by gas from the ism .
consider , then , a modification to the fiducial model that includes an ism .
specifically , we assume the ism component has density @xmath209 for @xmath210 with @xmath211kpc , an average velocity of @xmath212 , and a larger turbulent velocity @xmath213 .
the resultant optical depth profile @xmath98 is identical to the fiducial model for @xmath214kpc , has a slightly higher opacity at @xmath215kpc , and has a very large opacity at @xmath216kpc . in figure
[ fig : ism_spec ] , the solid curves show the and profiles for the ism+wind and fiducial models . in comparison ,
the dotted curve shows the intrinsic absorption profile for the ism+wind model corresponding to the ( unphysical ) case where none of the absorbed photons are scattered or re - emitted .
focus first on the doublet . as expected , the dotted curve shows strong absorption at @xmath187 and blueward .
the full models , in contrast , show non - zero flux at these velocities and even a normalized flux exceeding unity at @xmath187 .
in fact , the ism+wind model is nearly identical to the fiducial model ; the only quantitative difference is that the velocity centroids of the emission lines are shifted redward by @xmath217 .
we have also examined the spatial distribution of emission from this model and find results qualitatively similar to the fiducial wind model ( figures [ fig : fiducial_ifu_mgii ] and [ fig : fiducial_ifu_feii ] ) .
there are , however , several qualitative differences for the transitions .
first , the @xmath145 transition in the ism+wind model shows much stronger absorption at @xmath218 to @xmath219 .
in contrast to the doublet , the profile is not filled in by scattered photons . instead ,
the majority of @xmath145 photons that are absorbed are re - emitted as * @xmath220 photons .
in fact , the @xmath145 profile very nearly matches the profile without re - emission ( compare to the dotted lines ) ; this transition provides a very good description of the intrinsic ism+wind optical depth profile .
we conclude that resonant transitions that are coupled to ( multiple ) non - resonant , electric dipole transitions offer the best diagnosis of ism absorption .
the differences in the absorption profiles are reflected in the much higher strengths ( @xmath221 ) of emission from transitions to the excited states of the a @xmath20d@xmath23 configuration .
this occurs because : ( 1 ) there is greater absorption by the @xmath37resonance lines ; and ( 2 ) the high opacity of the ism component leads to an enhanced conversion of resonance photons with @xmath222 into * photons .
this is especially notable for the @xmath139 transition whose coupled * transition shows an equivalent width nearly @xmath223 stronger than for the fiducial model .
the relative strengths of the @xmath139 and * @xmath149 lines provide a direct diagnostic of the degree to which the resonance line photons are trapped , i.e. the peak optical depth of 2600 and the velocity gradient of the wind . because of the high degree of photon trapping within the ism component , this model does suffer more from dust extinction than the fiducial model .
we have studied the ism+wind model including dust with @xmath224 ( normalized to include the ism gas ) .
all of the emission lines are significantly reduced .
the emission is affected most because these lines are resonantly trapped .
the * emission is also reduced relative to the dust - free model , but the absolute flux still exceeds the fiducial model ( table [ tab : line_diag ] ) . at large negative velocity offsets from systemic , the two profiles are nearly identical .
we conclude that a dusty ism model could show significant absorption at @xmath194 in resonance lines ( including ) with strong line - emission in the * transitions . . as expected , the strength of absorption increases with increasing @xmath106 ; this also results in stronger line - emission .
note that the @xmath145 emission is always weak .
only its absorption increases with @xmath106 and actually exceeds the depth of @xmath139 for @xmath225 .
the depth of the doublet , meanwhile , always falls below a relative flux of 0.3 while the @xmath102 emission rises steadily with @xmath106 .
, width=336 ] ccrccccccccccc mgii 2796 + & fiducial&[@xmath226 & 4.78 & 2.83&0.94&@xmath227&@xmath228&[@xmath229&@xmath230 & 2.48&@xmath231&@xmath232 & 215 + & @xmath233&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&[@xmath235&@xmath117 & 2.10&@xmath236&@xmath237 & 483 + & @xmath238&[@xmath112 & 4.78 & 2.98&1.03&@xmath239&@xmath240&[@xmath241&@xmath242 & 1.78&@xmath243&@xmath244 & 107 + & @xmath245&[@xmath112 & 4.78 & 3.55&0.91&@xmath246&@xmath247&[@xmath248&@xmath249 & 1.78&@xmath250&@xmath251 & 215 + & @xmath252&[@xmath253 & 4.78 & 4.79&2.19&@xmath254&@xmath255&[@xmath256&@xmath257 & 1.07&@xmath250&@xmath258 & 54 + & @xmath65=1&[@xmath259 & 4.77 & 2.94&0.95&@xmath227&@xmath260&[@xmath261&@xmath262 & 1.90&@xmath231&@xmath263 & 193 + & @xmath65=3&[@xmath264 & 4.78 & 3.07&1.03&@xmath265&@xmath266&[@xmath267&@xmath268 & 1.48&@xmath250&@xmath269 & 150 + & ism&[@xmath270 & 6.36 & 2.67&0.90&@xmath271&@xmath272&[@xmath273&@xmath274 & 2.36&@xmath275&@xmath276 & 236 + & ism+dust&[@xmath277 & 6.42 & 4.06&1.06&@xmath265&@xmath278&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234 + mgii 2803 + & fiducial&[@xmath279 & 3.29 & 1.19&0.76&@xmath280&@xmath265&[@xmath281&@xmath282 & 2.55&@xmath283&@xmath284 & 449 + & @xmath233&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&[@xmath285&@xmath286 & 1.93&@xmath287&@xmath288 & 482 + & @xmath238&[@xmath289 & 3.29 & 1.82&0.97&@xmath290&@xmath291&[@xmath292&@xmath293 & 1.81&@xmath294&@xmath295 & 107 + & @xmath245&[@xmath296 & 3.29 & 1.33&0.65&@xmath297&@xmath298&[@xmath299&@xmath300 & 2.12&@xmath301&@xmath302 & 535 + & @xmath252&[@xmath289 & 3.29 & 2.60&1.74&@xmath303&@xmath297&[@xmath304&@xmath305 & 1.33&@xmath301&@xmath306 & 562 + & @xmath65=1&[@xmath307 & 3.28 & 1.41&0.83&@xmath290&@xmath308&[@xmath309&@xmath310 & 1.95&@xmath283&@xmath311 & 417 + & @xmath65=3&[@xmath312 & 3.26 & 1.67&0.94&@xmath313&@xmath308&[@xmath314&@xmath315 & 1.50&@xmath283&@xmath316 & 375 + & ism&[@xmath317 & 6.49 & 1.03&0.67&@xmath318&@xmath319&[@xmath320&@xmath321 &
2.57&@xmath322&@xmath323 & 439 + & ism+dust&[@xmath324 & 6.51 & 2.59&1.02&@xmath290&@xmath325&[@xmath326&@xmath327 & 1.03&@xmath328&@xmath328 & 21 + feii 2586 + & fiducial&[@xmath329 & 0.82 & 0.61&1.01&@xmath330&@xmath331&[@xmath332&@xmath120 & 1.11&@xmath333&@xmath334 & 128 + & @xmath233&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&[@xmath335&@xmath120 & 1.06&@xmath236&@xmath336 & 232 + & @xmath238&[@xmath118 & 0.82 & 0.60&1.01&@xmath337&@xmath338&[@xmath339&@xmath340 & 1.06&@xmath341&@xmath342 & 87 + & @xmath245&[@xmath343 & 0.82 & 0.96&1.57&@xmath337&@xmath280&[@xmath119&@xmath120 & 1.09&@xmath336&@xmath344 & 203 + & @xmath252&[@xmath343 & 0.82 & 1.03&1.88&@xmath337&@xmath325&[@xmath345&@xmath346 & 1.03&@xmath336&@xmath347 & 58 + & @xmath65=1&[@xmath329 & 0.82 & 0.61&1.04&@xmath330&@xmath348&[@xmath349&@xmath350 & 1.06&@xmath301&@xmath336 & 116 + & @xmath65=3&[@xmath351 & 0.94 & 0.60&1.06&@xmath330&@xmath352&[@xmath353&@xmath346 & 1.04&@xmath354&@xmath342 & 58 + & ism&[@xmath355 & 1.90 & 1.60&2.75&@xmath356&@xmath357&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234 + & ism+dust&[@xmath358 & 1.84 & 1.63&2.96&@xmath301&@xmath359&[@xmath360&@xmath361 & 1.03&@xmath362&@xmath363 & 12 + feii 2600 + & fiducial&[@xmath364 & 1.87 & 1.18&1.08&@xmath365&@xmath366&[@xmath367&@xmath368 & 1.70&@xmath231&@xmath369 & 312 + & @xmath233&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&@xmath234&[@xmath370&@xmath371 & 1.46&@xmath372&@xmath373 & 346 + & @xmath238&[@xmath374 & 1.87 & 1.18&1.31&@xmath375&@xmath376&[@xmath377&@xmath378 & 1.39&@xmath379&@xmath295 & 87 + & @xmath245&[@xmath380 & 1.87 & 1.72&1.07&@xmath381&@xmath382&[@xmath383&@xmath384 & 1.49&@xmath385&@xmath386 & 404 + & @xmath252&[@xmath380 & 1.87 & 2.12&2.71&@xmath375&@xmath271&[@xmath387&@xmath388 & 1.15&@xmath385&@xmath389 & 346 + & @xmath65=1&[@xmath390 & 1.87 & 1.20&1.14&@xmath365&@xmath391&[@xmath392&@xmath393 & 1.45&@xmath231&@xmath394 & 265 + & @xmath65=3&[@xmath364 & 1.95 & 1.25&1.31&@xmath395&@xmath318&[@xmath396&@xmath397 & 1.22&@xmath398&@xmath251 & 196 + & ism&[@xmath399 & 3.12 & 1.88&1.19&@xmath395&@xmath400&[@xmath401&@xmath402 & 1.15&@xmath403&@xmath404 & 242 + & ism+dust&[@xmath405 & 3.06 & 2.12&1.40&@xmath398&@xmath406&[@xmath407&@xmath361 & 1.02&@xmath408&@xmath409 & 12 + feii * 2612 + & fiducial&&&&&&&[@xmath410&@xmath411 & 1.24&@xmath412&@xmath413 & 241 + & @xmath233&&&&&&&[@xmath414&@xmath129 & 1.22&@xmath415&@xmath372 & 172 + & @xmath238&&&&&&&[@xmath416&@xmath129 & 1.21&@xmath417&@xmath418 & 172 + & @xmath245&&&&&&&[@xmath419&@xmath420 & 1.29&@xmath417&@xmath341 & 316 + & @xmath252&&&&&&&[@xmath421&@xmath422 & 1.10&@xmath423&@xmath424 & 144 + & @xmath65=1&&&&&&&[@xmath425&@xmath397 & 1.21&@xmath417&@xmath426 & 207 + & @xmath65=3&&&&&&&[@xmath427&@xmath428 & 1.16&@xmath417&@xmath429 & 184 + & ism&&&&&&&[@xmath430&@xmath431 & 2.66&@xmath356&@xmath432 & 138 + & ism+dust&&&&&&&[@xmath433&@xmath434 & 1.53&@xmath356&@xmath435 & 161 + feii * 2626 + & fiducial&&&&&&&[@xmath436&@xmath437 & 1.29&@xmath417&@xmath413 & 217 + & @xmath233&&&&&&&[@xmath438&@xmath439 & 1.16&@xmath283&@xmath440 & 171 + & @xmath238&&&&&&&[@xmath441&@xmath439 & 1.16&@xmath442&@xmath443 & 143 + & @xmath245&&&&&&&[@xmath444&@xmath445 & 1.41&@xmath442&@xmath446 & 314 + & @xmath252&&&&&&&[@xmath447&@xmath448 & 1.14&@xmath283&@xmath269 & 114 + & @xmath65=1&&&&&&&[@xmath449&@xmath378 & 1.23&@xmath417&@xmath341 & 194 + & @xmath65=3&&&&&&&[@xmath450&@xmath428 & 1.17&@xmath417&@xmath451 & 194 + & ism&&&&&&&[@xmath452&@xmath453 & 4.10&@xmath356&@xmath356 & 103 + & ism+dust&&&&&&&[@xmath454&@xmath455 & 1.70&@xmath356&@xmath456 & 137 + feii * 2632 + & fiducial&&&&&&&[@xmath457&@xmath129 & 1.12&@xmath458&@xmath459 & 194 + & @xmath233&&&&&&&[@xmath460&@xmath448 & 1.09&@xmath461&@xmath398 & 142 + & @xmath238&&&&&&&[@xmath462&@xmath448 & 1.11&@xmath463&@xmath464 & 142 + & @xmath245&&&&&&&[@xmath465&@xmath397 & 1.14&@xmath458&@xmath466 & 285 + & @xmath252&&&&&&&[@xmath467&@xmath468 & 1.14&@xmath469&@xmath470 & 684 + & @xmath65=1&&&&&&&[@xmath471&@xmath472 & 1.10&@xmath442&@xmath473 & 160 + & @xmath65=3&&&&&&&[@xmath474&@xmath350 & 1.08&@xmath463&@xmath463 & 103 + & ism&&&&&&&[@xmath475&@xmath476 & 1.81&@xmath413&@xmath477 & 137 + & ism+dust&&&&&&&[@xmath478&@xmath479 & 1.30&@xmath413&@xmath459 & 148 + the final modification to the fiducial model considered was a uniform variation of the normalization of the optical depth profiles . specifically , we ran a series of additional models with @xmath106 at 1/3 , 3 , and 10 times the fiducial value of @xmath480 .
the resulting and profiles are compared against the fiducial model in figure [ fig : norm ] .
inspecting , one notes that the models with 1/3 and @xmath481 behave as expected .
higher / lower optical depths lead to greater / weaker @xmath97 absorption and stronger / weaker @xmath102 emission . in the extreme case of @xmath482 , the @xmath102 absorption and @xmath97emission have nearly disappeared and one primarily observes very strong @xmath97 absorption and @xmath102 emission .
in essence , this wind has converted all of the photons absorbed by the doublet into @xmath102 emission .
similar behavior is observed for the transitions .
interestingly , the @xmath145 transitions never show significant emission , only stronger absorption with increasing @xmath106 .
in fact , for @xmath483 the peak optical depth of @xmath145 actually exceeds that for @xmath139 because the latter remains significantly filled - in by scattered photons . by the same token , the flux of the * @xmath148emission increases with @xmath106 .
table [ tab : line_diag ] presents a series of quantitative measures of the and absorption and emission lines for the fiducial model ( @xmath18 [ sec : fiducial ] ) and a subset of the models presented in this section .
listed are the absorption and emission equivalent widths ( @xmath484 ) , the peak optical depth for the absorption @xmath485 , the velocity where the optical depth peaks @xmath486 , the optical depth - weighted velocity centroid @xmath487 / \int dv \ln[i(v)]$ ] , the peak flux @xmath488 in emission , the velocity where the flux peaks @xmath489 , and the flux - weighted velocity centroid of the emission line @xmath490 .
we discuss several of these measures in @xmath18 [ sec : discuss ] .
this section presents several additional wind scenarios that differ significantly from the fiducial model explored in the previous sections . in each case
, we maintain the simple assumption of isotropy . the lyman break galaxies ( lbgs ) , uv color - selected galaxies at @xmath4 , exhibit cool gas outflows in , , etc . transitions with speeds up to 1000(e.g .
* ; * ? ? ?
researchers have invoked these winds to explain enrichment of the intergalactic medium ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the origin of the damped systems @xcite , and the formation of ` red and dead ' galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
although the presence of these outflows was established over a decade ago , the processes that drive them remain unidentified .
similarly , current estimates of the mass and energetics of the outflows suffer from orders of magnitude uncertainty .
recently , ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter s10 ) introduced a model to explain jointly the average absorption they observed along the sightlines to several hundred lbgs and the average absorption in gas observed transverse to these galaxies .
their wind model is defined by two expressions : ( i ) a radial velocity law @xmath491 ; and ( ii ) the covering fraction of optically thick ` clouds ' @xmath492 . for the latter ,
s10 envision an ensemble of small , optically thick @xmath493 clouds that only partially cover the galaxies . for the velocity law , they adopted the following functional form : @xmath494 with @xmath495 the constant that sets the terminal speed , @xmath77 the inner radius of the wind ( taken to be 1kpc ) , and @xmath6 the power - law exponent that describes how steeply the velocity curve rises .
their analysis of the lbg absorption profiles implied a very steeply rising curve with @xmath496 .
this velocity expression is shown as a dotted line in figure [ fig : lbg_sobolev]a .
the covering fraction of optically thick clouds , meanwhile , was assumed to have the functional form @xmath497 with @xmath498 and @xmath499 the maximum covering fraction . from this expression and the velocity law
, one can recover an absorption profile @xmath500 $ ] , written explicitly as @xmath501 the resulting profile for @xmath502 , @xmath503 , @xmath504 , and @xmath505 is displayed in figure [ fig : lbg_sobolev]b . in the following ,
we consider two methods for analyzing the lbg wind .
both approaches assume an isotropic wind and adopt the velocity law given by equation [ eqn : lbg_vlaw ] . in the first model
, we treat the cool gas as a diffuse medium with unit covering fraction and a radial density profile determined from the sobolev approximation .
we then apply the monte carlo methodology used for the other wind models to predict and line profiles . in the second lbg model ,
we modify our algorithms to more precisely mimic the concept of an ensemble of optically thick clouds with a partial covering fraction on galactic scales . to highlight the evolution in the quantities at small radii . for example , note how rapidly the velocity rises from @xmath506 to 2kpc .
the solid curve shows the sobolev solution for the mg@xmath21 gas density derived from the average absorption profile of lbg galaxies ( see below ) .
the density falls off initially as @xmath507 and then steepens to @xmath508 .
( b ) the average profile for lbg cool gas absorption as measured and defined by s10 ( black solid curve ) .
overplotted on this curve is a ( red ) dotted line that shows the @xmath97 absorption profile derived from the density ( and velocity ) law shown in the upper panel .
, width=336 ] as demonstrated in figure [ fig : lbg_sobolev ] , the wind velocity for the lbg model rises very steeply with increasing radius before flattening at large radii . under these conditions
, the sobolev approximation provides an accurate description of the optical depth for the flowing medium .
the sobolev line optical depth profile can be derived from the absorption profile ( equation [ eqn : lbg_i ] ) , @xmath509 this simple expression assumes that the source size is small compared the wind dimensions and neglects the effects of light scattered in the wind ( for more general inversion formulae that do not make these assumptions , see @xcite ) .
the sobolev approximation ( equation [ eqn : sobolev ] ) provides a simple expression for the optical depth at each radius in terms of the local density and velocity gradient .
in general , the velocity gradient must be taken along the direction of propagation of a photon , however in this model the central source is relatively small and the radiation field is therefore primarily radially directed . in this case
the velocity gradient in the radial direction , @xmath510 , is the relevant quantity , and we may use equation [ eqn : sobolev ] to invert the optical depth and determine the density profile , @xmath511 the solid curve in figure [ fig : lbg_sobolev]a shows the resultant density profile for mg@xmath21 assuming that the @xmath97 line follows the intensity profile drawn in figure [ fig : lbg_sobolev]b .
this is a relatively extreme density profile . from the inner radius of 1kpc to 2kpc
, the density drops by over 2 orders of magnitude including nearly one order of magnitude over the first 10pc . beyond 2kpc ,
the density drops even more rapidly , falling orders of magnitude from 2 to 100kpc .
we verified that the sobolev - derived density profile shown in figure [ fig : lbg_sobolev]a reproduces the proper absorption profile by discretizing the wind into a series of layers and calculating the integrated absorption profile .
this calculation is shown as a dotted red curve in figure [ fig : lbg_sobolev]b ; it is an excellent match to the desired profile ( black curve ) . to calculate the optical depth profiles for the other and transitions , we assume @xmath512 and also scale @xmath513 by the @xmath103 product . ) , scattered and re - emitted photons significantly modify the absorption profiles ( especially and @xmath139 ) and produce strong emission lines .
the result , for especially , is a set of profiles that do not match the average observed lbg absorption profile .
, width=336 ] we generated and profiles for this lbg - sobolev wind using the 1d algorithm with no dust extinction ; these are shown as red curves in figure [ fig : lbg_spec ] . for this analysis , one should focus on the @xmath97 transition .
the dotted line in the figure shows the intensity profile when one ignores re - emission of absorbed photons . by construction ,
it is the same profile and for the reduced fe@xmath21 abundance . ] described by equation [ eqn : lbg_i ] and plotted in figure [ fig : lbg_sobolev]b . in comparison ,
the full model ( solid , red curve ) shows much weaker absorption , especially at @xmath514 to @xmath515 because scattered photons fill in the absorption profile . in this respect ,
our lbg - sobolev model is an inaccurate description of the observations which show more uniform equivalent widths among differing transitions ( s10 ) .
the model also predicts significant emission in the lines and several of the @xmath17 transitions .
emission associated with cool gas has been observed for @xmath17 transitions in lbgs @xcite , but the @xmath17 transitions modeled here lie in the near - ir and have not yet been investigated . on the other hand , there have been no reported detections of significant line - emission related to low - ion resonance transitions ( e.g. ) in lbgs , only @xmath516 star - forming galaxies @xcite .
the principal result of the lbg - sobolev model is that the scattering and re - emission of absorbed photons significantly alters the predicted absorption profiles for the input model .
this is , of course , an unavoidable consequence of an isotropic , dust - free model with unit covering fraction . ) .
the remaining panels show the cumulative mass , energy , and momentum of this flow .
all of the curves rise very steeply at small radii and then rise steadily to large radii .
the principal result is that the majority of mass , energy , and momentum in the wind are contained at large radii .
we derive similar results for the lbg - partial covering model if we assume the wind is composed of identical clouds optically thick to strong metal - line transitions ( e.g. 1526 ) .
the energy and momentum in the outer regions of the outflow may be very difficult to generate with standard galactic - scale wind scenarios .
, height=336 ] because we have explicit velocity and density profiles for the lbg - sobolev model , it is straightforward to calculate the radial distributions of mass , energy , and momentum of this wind .
these are shown in cumulative form in figure [ fig : lbg_cumul ] . before discussing the results
, we offer two cautionary comments : ( i ) the conversion of @xmath87 to @xmath84 assumes a very poorly constrained scalar factor of @xmath517 .
one should give minimal weight to the absolute values for any of the quantities ; ( ii ) the sobolev approximation is not a proper description of the s10 lbg wind model ( see the following sub - section ) .
these issues aside , we may inspect figure [ fig : lbg_cumul ] to reveal global properties of this lbg - sobolev wind .
one obvious result is that all of the curves rise very steeply at small radii .
we find , for example , that @xmath518 of the mass is contained within the inner 2kpc .
all of the curves continue to rise , however , such that the majority of energy , mass , and momentum in the wind is transported by its outermost layers ( i.e. , @xmath519kpc ) .
this is somewhat surprising given that the density is @xmath520 orders of magnitude lower at these radii than at @xmath521pc .
more importantly , we question whether any physical process could produce a wind with such extreme profiles . in the previous sub - section , we described a sobolev inversion that reproduces the average absorption profile of lbgs in cool gas transitions when scattered photons are ignored . a proper analysis that includes scattered photons , however , predicts line - profiles that are qualitatively different from the observations because scattered photons fill - in absorption and generate significant line - emission ( similar to the fiducial wind model ; @xmath18 [ sec : fiducial ] ) .
we also argued that the implied mass , energy , and momentum distributions of this wind ( figure [ fig : lbg_cumul ] ) were too extreme .
this lbg - sobolev model , however , is not precisely the one introduced by s10 ; those authors proposed an ensemble of optically thick clouds with a partial covering fraction described by equation [ eqn : covering ] .
in contrast , the lbg - sobolev model assumes a diffuse medium with a declining density profile but a unit covering fraction .
one may question , therefore , whether these differences lead to the failures of the lbg - sobolev model . to more properly model the lbg wind described in s10
, we performed the following monte carlo calculation .
first , we propagate a photon from the source until its velocity relative to line - center resonates with the wind ( the photon escapes if this never occurs ) .
the photon then has a probability @xmath522 of scattering .
if it scatters , we track the photon until it comes into resonance again for a scattered @xmath97 photon . ] or escapes the system . in this model ,
all of the resonance transitions are assumed to have identical ( infinite ) optical depth at line center .
the results of the full calculation ( absorption plus scattering ) are shown as the black curve in figure [ fig : lbg_spec ] .
remarkably , the results are essentially identical to the lbg - sobolev calculation for the @xmath97 transition ; scattered photons fill - in the absorption profiles at @xmath48 and yield significant emission lines at @xmath523 .
similar results are observed for the other resonance lines and significant emission is observed for the * transitions , centered at @xmath187 .
in contrast to the profiles , the @xmath145 line much more closely resembles its intrinsic profile ( dotted curves ) .
this occurs because most of these absorbed photons fluoresce into * emission .
the equivalent width of @xmath145 even exceeds that for @xmath139 , an inversion that , if observed , would strongly support this model .
a robust conclusion of our analysis is that these simple models can not reproduce the observed profiles of resonantly trapped lines ( like the doublet ) because of the emission from scattered photons . in particular , the observations show much greater opacity at velocities within @xmath524 of systemic ( s10 ) . in order to achieve a significant opacity at @xmath187
, one must either suppress the line - emission ( e.g. with severe dust extinction or anisotropic winds ) or include a substantial ism component that absorbs light at @xmath185 ( e.g. @xmath18 [ sec : ism ] ) .
absent such corrections ( which may be insufficient ) , we conclude that the lbg model introduced by s10 is not a valid description of the data . also , similar to our lbg - sobolev calculation ( figure [ fig : lbg_sobolev ] ) , this clump model predicts the majority of mass , energy , and momentum are carried in the outer regions of the wind .
in fact , for clumps that are optically thick to strong metal - line transitions ( e.g. 1526 ) we estimate because the latter assumes a diffuse medium with unit filling factor . ] that the wind would carry nearly a total mass of @xmath525 , with the majority at large radii .
the resonant line - emission predicted for should also arise in other transitions .
indeed , we caution that the line - emission observed in lbg spectra ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) may result from the galactic - scale outflow , not only the stellar winds of massive stars .
a proper treatment of these radiative transfer effects is required to quantitatively analyze these features . as discussed in the introduction ,
the importance of various physical mechanisms in driving galactic outflows remains an open question .
several studies advocate a primarily energy - driven wind scenario , in which the hot wind produced by the thermalized energy from sne ejecta entrains cool clouds via ram pressure ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
alternatively , momentum deposition by photons emitted by luminous star clusters onto dust grains in the ism may also play an integral role in driving large - scale outflows ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
both of these mechanisms likely contribute more or less significantly in a given galaxy ; however , the latter ( radiation - pressure driving ) has the added advantage that it does not destroy cool gas clouds as it acts . here
we explore the line - profiles produced by a radiation - pressure driven wind model as described by @xcite . ) . at these velocities ,
the absorption is not filled - in by scattered photons and one recovers absorption lines that closely resemble the intrinsic optical depth profile ( dotted curve ) .
although the absorption profiles are very different from the fiducial model , the line - emission has similar peak flux and velocity centroids the * emission also has a similar equivalent width , yet the lines are much broader in the radiation - driven model . , width=336 ] these authors start by assuming the galaxy has luminosity @xmath526 and is an isothermal sphere with mass profile @xmath527 , where @xmath528 is the velocity dispersion .
the gas mass profile is simply @xmath529 , with @xmath530 a constant gas fraction .
the dust has opacity @xmath531 and is optically thin , such that the force per unit mass of wind material due to radiation is @xmath532 . ignoring gas pressure , and assuming a steady state for the flow ( i.e.
, the mass outflow rate , @xmath533 , is constant ) , the momentum equation for the wind is @xmath534 substituting @xmath535 for @xmath536 and solving for @xmath537 , @xcite find @xmath538 ( their equ .
26 ) , where @xmath539 at @xmath540 and @xmath541 .
the corresponding density profile for the gas is given by @xmath542 with @xmath543 the mass of the hydrogen atom .
similar to the fiducial wind model , this wind has a decreasing density law with @xmath84 roughly proportional to @xmath108 .
in contrast to the fiducial model , the velocity law is nearly constant with radius before decreasing sharply at large radii . to produce a wind whose @xmath97 optical depth profile peaks at @xmath544 , we set @xmath545 , @xmath546 , and @xmath547 . the density peaks at @xmath548 where @xmath549 .
the velocity , meanwhile , peaks at @xmath550 with @xmath551 .
this corresponds to a mass flow of @xmath552 .
figure [ fig : rad_spec ] presents the and profiles for this radiation - driven wind model compared against the fiducial wind model .
in contrast to the fiducial model , the optical depth peaks at much larger velocity ( here @xmath553 ) . at these velocities ,
the absorption is not filled - in by scattered photons and one recovers absorption lines that more closely follow the intrinsic optical depth profile ( dotted curve ) .
the line - emission , meanwhile , has similar peak flux and velocity centroids to the fiducial model ( see also table [ tab : plaw_diag ] ) . the * emission also has a similar equivalent width , yet the lines of the radiation - driven model are much broader .
this reflects the fact that the majority of absorption occurs at @xmath554 .
the kinematics of * line - emission , therefore , independently diagnose the intrinsic optical depth profile of the flow .
we conclude that the radiation - driven model has characteristics that are qualitatively similar to the fiducial model ( e.g. strong blue - shifted absorption and significant line - emission ) with a few quantitative differences that , in principle , could distinguish them with high fidelity observations .
the fiducial model assumed power - law descriptions for both the density and velocity laws ( equations [ eqn : density],[eqn : vel ] ) .
the power - law exponents were arbitrarily chosen , i.e. with little physical motivation . in this sub - section ,
we cursorily explore the results for a series of other power - law expressions , also arbitrarily defined .
our intention is to illustrate the diversity of and profiles that may result from modifications to the density and velocity laws .
we consider three different density laws ( @xmath555 ) and three different velocity laws ( @xmath556 ) for nine wind models ( table [ tab : plaw_parm ] , figure [ fig : plaws]a ) .
each of these winds extends over the same inner and outer radii as the fiducial model .
the density and velocity normalizations @xmath557 have been modified to yield a @xmath97 optical depth profile that peaks at @xmath558 and then usually decreases to @xmath167 ( figure [ fig : plaws]b ) .
this choice of normalization was observationally driven to yield significant absorption lines .
all models assume a doppler parameter @xmath559 , full isotropy , and a dust - free environment .
lastly , the abundances of mg@xmath21 and fe@xmath21 scale with hydrogen as in the fiducial model ( table [ tab : fiducial ] ) . , dotted
@xmath560 , dot - dash
@xmath561 ) and velocity laws ( colored ; green
@xmath562 , red
@xmath563 , blue
@xmath564 ) for a series of power - law models ( table [ tab : plaw_parm ] ) . for comparison
we also plot the velocity and density laws for the fiducial model ( thin , black curves ) .
panel ( b ) plots the optical depth profiles of the @xmath97 line for the nine models built from the density and velocity laws of panel ( a ) .
each of these were normalized to have peak optical depths of 10 to 1000 and to be optically thin at small or large velocity .
, width=336 ] cccccc a & @xmath565 & 0.4000 & @xmath566 & 2.0 & 0.8 + b & @xmath565 & 0.5000 & @xmath567 & 50.0 & 1.1 + c & @xmath565 & 0.3000 & @xmath568 & 100.0 & 1.8 + d & @xmath569 & 0.0100 & @xmath566 & 2.0 & 2.1 + e & @xmath569 & 0.0100 & @xmath567 & 50.0 & 1.7 + f & @xmath569 & 0.0200 & @xmath568 & 100.0 & 1.6 + g & @xmath570 & 0.0100 & @xmath566 & 2.0 & 4.4 + h & @xmath570 & 0.0010 & @xmath567 & 50.0 & 3.2 + i & @xmath570 & 0.0001 & @xmath568 & 100.0 & 1.8 + figure [ fig : plaws_spec ] presents the and profiles for the full suite of power - law models ( see also table [ tab : plaw_diag ] ) .
although these models differ qualitatively from the fiducial model in their density and velocity laws , the resultant profiles share many of the same characteristics .
each shows significant absorption at @xmath571 , extending to the velocity where @xmath98 drops below 0.1 ( figure [ fig : plaws]b ) .
all of the models also exhibit strong line - emission , primarily at velocities @xmath572 .
this emission fills - in the absorption at @xmath573 such that the profiles rarely achieve a relative flux less than @xmath574 at these velocities .
similar to the radiation - driven wind ( @xmath18 [ sec : radiative ] ) , the power - law models that have significant opacity at @xmath575 tend to have larger peak optical depths .
another commonality is the weak or absent line - emission at @xmath145 ; one instead notes strong * @xmath148 emission that generally exceeds the equivalent width of the fiducial model .
one also notes that the width of the * emission is systematically higher for models where the optical depth in absorption peaks at large velocity from the systemic .
one of the few obvious distinctions between these models and the fiducial wind is the higher peak optical depth of absorption in the @xmath139transition .
this occurs primarily because these models have higher intrinsic optical depths ( i.e. higher @xmath86 values ) .
2796 + & fiducial&[@xmath226 & 4.78 & 2.83&0.94&@xmath227&@xmath228&[@xmath229&@xmath230 & 2.48&@xmath231&@xmath232 & 215 + & lbg sob.&[@xmath576 & 2.62 & 1.35&0.45&@xmath577&@xmath578&[@xmath248&@xmath579 & 1.84&@xmath580&@xmath581 & 193 + & lbg cov.&[@xmath582 & 2.67 & 1.40&0.41&@xmath583&@xmath584&[@xmath585&@xmath586 & 2.23&@xmath356&@xmath587 & 172 + & radiation&[@xmath588 & 2.86 & 1.72&3.00&@xmath589&@xmath590&[@xmath591&@xmath592 & 2.13&@xmath593&@xmath594 & 236 + & a&[@xmath595 & 9.29 & 5.02&2.92&@xmath596&@xmath597&[@xmath598&@xmath599 & 3.30&@xmath580&@xmath600 & 118 + & b&[@xmath601&11.08 & 7.54&3.00&@xmath602&@xmath603&[@xmath604&@xmath605 & 2.89&@xmath356&@xmath606 & 172 + & c&[@xmath607 & 2.54 & 1.82&1.86&@xmath271&@xmath608&[@xmath609&@xmath610 & 2.09&@xmath356&@xmath611 & 247 + & d&[@xmath612 & 4.21 & 2.14&1.11&@xmath243&@xmath613&[@xmath614&@xmath615 & 3.58&@xmath250&@xmath616 & 172 + mgii 2803 + & fiducial&[@xmath279 & 3.29 & 1.19&0.76&@xmath280&@xmath265&[@xmath281&@xmath282 & 2.55&@xmath283&@xmath284 & 449 + & lbg sob.&[@xmath617 & 1.53 & 0.46&0.24&@xmath618&@xmath618&[@xmath619&@xmath620 & 1.58&@xmath301&@xmath621 & 332 + & lbg cov.&[@xmath622 & 2.56 & 0.98&0.37&@xmath623&@xmath624&[@xmath625&@xmath626 & 2.35&@xmath627&@xmath628 & 396 + & radiation&[@xmath629 & 2.32 & 1.29&2.65&@xmath630&@xmath631&[@xmath632&@xmath633 & 1.86&@xmath461&@xmath634 & 246 + & a&[@xmath635 & 7.06 & 1.98&0.78&@xmath636&@xmath637&[@xmath638&@xmath639 & 5.03&@xmath640&@xmath641 & 610 + & b&[@xmath642 & 5.74 & 1.80&1.27&@xmath228&@xmath643&[@xmath644&@xmath645 & 4.20&@xmath627&@xmath646 & 749 + & c&[@xmath647 & 2.17 & 1.49&1.85&@xmath318&@xmath648&[@xmath649&@xmath650 & 1.94&@xmath287&@xmath651 & 246 + & d&[@xmath652 & 3.69 & 0.19&0.77&@xmath432&@xmath435&[@xmath653&@xmath626 & 3.33&@xmath283&@xmath654 & 332 + feii 2586 + & fiducial&[@xmath329 & 0.82 & 0.61&1.01&@xmath330&@xmath331&[@xmath332&@xmath120 & 1.11&@xmath333&@xmath334 & 128 + & lbg sob.&[@xmath655 & 0.18 & 0.04&0.07&@xmath656&@xmath400&[@xmath657&@xmath327 & 1.05&@xmath356&@xmath342 & 35 + & lbg cov.&[@xmath658 & 2.38 & 1.93&0.65&@xmath659&@xmath613&[@xmath660&@xmath411 & 1.33&@xmath342&@xmath661 & 313 + & radiation&[@xmath662 & 1.00 & 0.00&0.02&@xmath356&@xmath356&[@xmath663&@xmath472 & 1.09&@xmath333&@xmath664 & 220 + & a&[@xmath665 & 1.88 & 1.66&0.33&@xmath666&@xmath667&[@xmath668&@xmath669 & 1.12&@xmath301&@xmath670 & 197 + & b&[@xmath671 & 2.20 & 1.97&0.60&@xmath672&@xmath673&[@xmath674&@xmath388 & 1.09&@xmath342&@xmath675 & 429 + & c&[@xmath676 & 0.79 & 0.71&2.51&@xmath313&@xmath677&[@xmath678&@xmath120 & 1.08&@xmath251&@xmath679 & 174 + & d&[@xmath680 & 0.88 & 0.68&3.00&@xmath354&@xmath466&[@xmath681&@xmath327 & 1.03&@xmath679&@xmath682 & 35 + feii 2600 + & fiducial&[@xmath364 & 1.87 & 1.18&1.08&@xmath365&@xmath366&[@xmath367&@xmath368 & 1.70&@xmath231&@xmath369 & 312 + & lbg sob.&[@xmath683 & 0.55 & 0.24&0.11&@xmath684&@xmath685&[@xmath686&@xmath687 & 1.23&@xmath688&@xmath689 & 208 + & lbg cov.&[@xmath690 & 2.43 & 1.38&0.44&@xmath260&@xmath691&[@xmath692&@xmath693 & 2.02&@xmath694&@xmath695 & 381 + & radiation&[@xmath696 & 2.21 & 1.44&3.00&@xmath697&@xmath577&[@xmath698&@xmath699 & 1.59&@xmath398&@xmath394 & 242 + & a&[@xmath700 & 4.61 & 3.51&1.05&@xmath701&@xmath702&[@xmath703&@xmath704 & 2.34&@xmath694&@xmath705 & 612 + & b&[@xmath706 & 5.10 & 4.20&1.88&@xmath707&@xmath708&[@xmath709&@xmath710 & 1.86&@xmath294&@xmath711 & 935 + & c&[@xmath712 & 1.34 & 1.09&2.04&@xmath713&@xmath714&[@xmath715&@xmath716 & 1.43&@xmath717&@xmath718 & 219 + & d&[@xmath719 & 1.68 & 1.13&3.00&@xmath720&@xmath721&[@xmath722&@xmath723 & 1.47&@xmath398&@xmath724 & 219 + feii * 2612 + & fiducial&&&&&&&[@xmath410&@xmath411 & 1.24&@xmath412&@xmath413 & 241 + & lbg sob.&&&&&&&[@xmath725&@xmath257 & 1.07&@xmath356&@xmath459 & 115 + & lbg cov.&&&&&&&[@xmath726&@xmath727 & 1.79&@xmath356&@xmath333 & 563 + & radiation&&&&&&&[@xmath728&@xmath393 & 1.26&@xmath356&@xmath435 & 425 + & a&&&&&&&[@xmath729&@xmath730 & 1.35&@xmath356&@xmath731 & 735 + & b&&&&&&&[@xmath732&@xmath730 & 1.14&@xmath283&@xmath733 & 873 + & c&&&&&&&[@xmath734&@xmath268 & 1.20&@xmath735&@xmath459 & 241 + & d&&&&&&&[@xmath736&@xmath455 & 2.37&@xmath356&@xmath435 & 103 + feii * 2626 + & fiducial&&&&&&&[@xmath436&@xmath437 & 1.29&@xmath417&@xmath413 & 217 + & lbg sob.&&&&&&&[@xmath353&@xmath340 & 1.06&@xmath301&@xmath415 & 57 + & lbg cov.&&&&&&&[@xmath737&@xmath738 & 1.22&@xmath356&@xmath415 & 434 + & radiation&&&&&&&[@xmath739&@xmath740 & 1.42&@xmath356&@xmath243 & 343 + & a&&&&&&&[@xmath741&@xmath274 & 1.71&@xmath356&@xmath742 & 720 + & b&&&&&&&[@xmath743&@xmath744 & 1.22&@xmath356&@xmath278&1039 + & c&&&&&&&[@xmath745&@xmath420 & 1.24&@xmath746&@xmath747 & 217 + & d&&&&&&&[@xmath748&@xmath749 & 3.53&@xmath356&@xmath747 & 103 + feii * 2632 + & fiducial&&&&&&&[@xmath457&@xmath129 & 1.12&@xmath458&@xmath459 & 194 + & lbg sob.&&&&&&&[@xmath750&@xmath327 & 1.07&@xmath751&@xmath751 & 46 + & lbg cov.&&&&&&&[@xmath752&@xmath753 & 1.36&@xmath413&@xmath477 & 479 + & radiation&&&&&&&[@xmath754&@xmath397 & 1.12&@xmath413&@xmath354 & 353 + & a&&&&&&&[@xmath755&@xmath293 & 1.19&@xmath751&@xmath756 & 581 + & b&&&&&&&[@xmath757&@xmath371 & 1.17&@xmath758&@xmath759 & 741 + & c&&&&&&&[@xmath760&@xmath402 & 1.10&@xmath440&@xmath413 & 228 + & d&&&&&&&[@xmath761&@xmath397 & 1.63&@xmath413&@xmath477 & 91 + while there is commonality between models , the specific characteristics of the absorption / emission profiles do exhibit significant diversity .
table [ tab : plaw_diag ] compares measures of the absorption and emission profiles against the fiducial model . in detail , the line profiles differ in their peak optical depths , the velocity centroids of absorption / emission , and their equivalent widths .
we find that many of the differences are driven by differences in the velocity laws , i.e. the kinematics of the outflow . at the same time
, models with very different density / velocity laws can produce rather similar results .
for example , profiles that have declining opacity with increasing velocity offset from systemic can be obtained with a radial velocity law that increases ( e.g. the fiducial model ) or decreases ( model d ) .
the implication is that absorption profiles alone are likely insufficient to fully characterize the physical characteristics of the outflow .
we now discuss the principal results of our analysis and comment on the observational consequences and implications .
the previous sections presented idealized wind models for cool gas outflows , and explored the absorption / emission profiles of the @xmath0 doublet and the uv1 multiplet .
in addition to the ubiquitous presence of blue - shifted absorption , the wind models also predict strong line - emission in both resonance and non - resonance transitions . for isotropic and dust - free scenarios ,
this is due to the simple conservation of photons : every photon emitted by the source eventually escapes the system to maintain zero total equivalent width .
a principal result of this paper , therefore , is that galaxies with observed cool gas outflows should also generate detectable line - emission .
indeed , line - emission from low - ion transitions has been reported from star - forming galaxies that exhibit cool gas outflows .
this includes emission related to @xcite , emission @xcite , * emission from lbgs @xcite , and , most recently , significant * emission @xcite .
a variety of origins have been proposed for this line - emission including agn activity , recombination in regions , and back - scattering off the galactic - scale wind .
our results suggest that the majority of the observed line - emission is from scattered photons in the cool gas outflows of these star - forming galaxies .
indeed , line - emission should be generated by all galaxies driving a cool gas outflow .
on the other hand , there are many examples of galaxies where blue - shifted absorption is detected yet the authors report no significant line emission .
this includes flows @xcite , and absorption in ulirgs @xcite , and the extreme outflows identified by @xcite .
similarly , there have been no reports of resonance line - emission from low - ion transitions in the lbgs , and many @xmath13 galaxies show no detectable or * emission despite significant blue - shifted absorption ( rubin et al . , in prep ) .
these non - detections appear to contradict a primary conclusion of this paper .
we are motivated , therefore , to reassess several of the effects that can reduce the line - emission and consider whether these prevent its detection in many star - forming galaxies .
dust is frequently invoked to explain the suppression of line - emission for resonantly trapped transitions ( e.g. ) .
indeed , a photon that is trapped for many scatterings within a dusty medium will be preferentially extincted relative to a non - resonant photon . in @xmath18 [
sec : dust ] , we examined the effects of dust extinction on and emission . the general result ( figure [ fig : dust_tau ] ) is a modest reduction in flux that scales as ( 1+@xmath65)@xmath19 instead of exp(@xmath65 ) .
although the photons are resonantly trapped , they require only one to a few scatterings to escape the wind thereby limiting the effects of dust .
this reflects the moderate opacity of the doublet ( e.g. relative to ) and also the velocity law of the fiducial wind model . in scenarios
where the photons are more effectively trapped , dust does suppress the emission ( e.g. in the ism+wind model from @xmath18 [ sec : ism ] ) .
in contrast to , the resonance photons may be converted to non - resonant photons that freely escape the wind .
therefore , a wind model that traps photons for many scatterings does not similarly trap @xmath37 photons . the effects of dust are much reduced and , by inference , the same holds for any other set of transitions that are coupled to a fine - structure level ( e.g./ * ) . in summary
, dust does reduce the line flux relative to the continuum , but it generally has only a modest effect on the predicted emission and a minor effect on * emission .
another factor that may reduce line - emission is wind anisotropy .
the flux is lower , for example , if one eliminates the backside to the wind ( e.g. the source itself could shadow a significant fraction of the backside ) .
similarly , a bi - conical wind can have significantly lower line - emission , at least for the fiducial model ( @xmath18 [ sec : anisotropic ] ) .
for the anisotropic winds explored in this paper , the line - emission scales roughly as @xmath762 where @xmath763 is the angular extent of the wind . because we require that the wind points toward us , it is difficult to reduce @xmath763 much below @xmath764 and , therefore , anisotropy reduces the emission by a factor of order unity
similarly , an anisotropically emitting source would modify the predicted line - emission .
for example , if the backside of the galaxy were brighter / fainter then would one predict brighter / fainter emission relative to the observed continuum . to reduce the emission
, the brightest regions of the galaxy would need to be oriented toward earth .
although this would not be a generic orientation , most spectroscopic samples are magnitude - limited and biased towards detecting galaxies when observed at their brightest . in principle , this might imply a further reduction of order unity .
together , dust and anisotropic models may reduce the line - emission of and by one to a few factors of order unity .
for some galaxies , these effects may explain the absence of significant line - emission , but they may not be sufficient to preclude its detection . there is another ( more subtle ) effect that could greatly reduce the observed line - emission : slit - loss .
as described in figure [ fig : fiducial_ifu_mgii ] , emission from the wind is spatially extended with a non - zero surface brightness predicted at large radii .
this implies a non - negligible luminosity emitted beyond the angular extent of the galaxy .
the majority of observations of star - forming galaxies to date have been taken through a spectroscopic slit designed to cover the brightest continuum regions .
slits with angular extents of @xmath765 subtend roughly @xmath766kpc for galaxies at @xmath767 .
therefore , a @xmath768 slit covering a galaxy with our fiducial wind would cover less than half the wind .
the result is reduced line - emission when compared to the galaxy continuum . )
relative to the observed absorption equivalent width ( @xmath769 ) for a series of transitions : ( solid
@xmath97 ; dotted
@xmath102 ; dashed
@xmath139 ) .
the @xmath770/@xmath769 ratio is plotted as a function of slit width relative to twice the radius @xmath771 , defined to be where the sobolev optical depth @xmath772 .
the black curves correspond to the fiducial wind model ( @xmath18 [ sec : fiducial ] ; @xmath773kpc ) , the red curves are for the lbg - partial covering scenario ( @xmath18 [ sec : covering ] ; @xmath774kpc ) , and the radiation - driven wind ( @xmath18 [ sec : radiative ] ; @xmath775kpc ) has blue curves . for all of the wind models ,
the @xmath776/@xmath769 ratio rises very steeply with slit width and then plateaus at @xmath777 .
therefore , a slit that exceeds @xmath778 will admit nearly all of the photons scattered to our sightline .
, height=336 ] we explore the effects of slit - loss as follows .
we model the slit as a perfect , infinitely - long rectangle centered on the galaxy .
we then tabulate the equivalent width of the line - emission through slits with a range of widths , parameterized by @xmath771 : twice the radius where the wind has a sobolev optical depth of @xmath772
. the line - emission will be weak beyond this radius because the photons have only a low probability of being scattered .
for the fiducial wind model , the @xmath97 transition has @xmath773kpc ( figure [ fig : fiducial_nvt ] ) . the predicted equivalent width in emission @xmath770 relative to the absorption equivalent width @xmath769
is presented in figure [ fig : obs_slit ] for a series of transitions for the fiducial wind model ( black curves ) .
the @xmath770/@xmath769 curves rise very steeply with increasing slit width and then plateau when the slit width reaches @xmath777 . for the fiducial model ,
the emission is concentrated toward the source ; this derives from the density and velocity profiles but is also a simple consequence of geometric projection .
figure [ fig : obs_slit ] reveals similar results for other wind models .
the curves rise so steeply that the effects of slit - loss are minor ( order unity ) unless the slit - width is very small .
nevertheless , the results do motivate extended aperture observations , e.g. integral field unit ( ifu ) instrumentation , that would map the wind both spatially and spectrally .
although several effects can reduce the line - emission relative to the absorption of the outflow , our analysis indicates that detectable line - emission should occur frequently .
furthermore , the line - emission could be suppressed so that it does not exceed the galaxy continuum yet still ( partially ) fills - in the absorption profiles .
indeed , dust and anisotropic winds preferentially suppress line - emission at @xmath140 ( figures [ fig : anisotropic],[fig : dust ] ) .
the remaining emission would still modify the observed absorption profiles ( e.g.figure [ fig : noemiss ] ) and may complicate conclusions regarding characteristics of the flow .
_ an analysis of cool gas outflows that entirely ignores line - emission may incorrectly conclude that the source is partially covered , that the gas has a significantly lower peak optical depth , and/or that a @xmath572 component is absent . _ we now examine several quantitative effects of line - emission . which includes the flux of scattered photons and the ` intrinsic ' equivalent width @xmath779 that ignores photon scattering .
the dashed ( dotted ) curves trace a 50% ( 10% ) reduction in @xmath769relative to @xmath779 .
one notes a reduction in @xmath769 by @xmath780 for the @xmath97 transition ( the effect is generally larger for @xmath102 ) .
the effects of scattered photons are reduced for the transitions because a fraction ( in fact a majority for @xmath145 ) of the absorbed photons fluoresce as * emission at longer wavelengths and do not ` fill - in ' the absorption profiles .
the figure shows results for all of the models presented in tables [ tab : line_diag ] and [ tab : plaw_diag ] .
, height=336 ] figure [ fig : obs_ew ] demonstrates one observational consequence : reduced measurements for the absorption equivalent width @xmath769 of the flow . in the case of , which has the most strongly affected transitions , @xmath769
is reduced by @xmath781 from the intrinsic equivalent width ( the equivalent width one would measure in the absence of scattered photons ) . in turn , one may derive a systematically lower optical depth or velocity extent for the wind , and therefore a lower total mass and kinetic energy .
the effects are most pronounced for wind scenarios where the peak optical depth occurs near @xmath169 .
geometric projection limits the majority of scattered photon emission to have @xmath782 ; therefore , the absorption profiles are filled - in primarily at these velocities .
$ ] for @xmath97 profiles of the wind models studied in this paper ( tables [ tab : line_diag ] , [ tab : plaw_diag ] ) with @xmath783 the minimum normalized intensity of the absorption profile .
cases where @xmath485 exceeds 3 are presented as lower limits .
the @xmath485 values are plotted against the velocity @xmath486 where @xmath784 . in all of the models , the true peak optical depth @xmath785 .
the much lower ` observed ' @xmath485 values occur because scattered @xmath97photons have filled - in the absorption profiles at velocities @xmath786 .
these effects , therefore , are greatest for wind models where the optical depth peaks near @xmath572 because the majority of scattered photons have this relative velocity .
indeed , models with @xmath787 all show @xmath788 .
, height=336 ] another ( related ) consequence is the reduction of the peak depth of absorption . in figure
[ fig : obs_peaktau ] , we plot the observed peak optical depth @xmath485 for @xmath97 versus the velocity where the profile has greatest depth for the various wind models ( i.e.@xmath485 vs. @xmath486 from tables [ tab : line_diag ] and [ tab : plaw_diag ] ) . in every one of the models , the true peak optical depth @xmath789 . for the majority of cases with @xmath790 , one observes @xmath791 and would infer the wind is not even optically thick ! this occurs because photons scattered by the wind have ` filled - in ' the absorption at velocity @xmath187 .
in contrast , wind models with @xmath787 all yield @xmath792 .
the results are similar for the @xmath102 profile .
in fact , one generally measures a similar @xmath485 for each line and may incorrectly conclude that the source is partially covered . in the case of , one may even observe a ( non - physical ) inversion in the apparent optical depths of @xmath145 and @xmath139 ( e.g.figure [ fig : norm ] ) . and @xmath97 absorption profiles have greatest depth .
results for all of the models studied in this paper are presented ( tables [ tab : line_diag ] , [ tab : plaw_diag ] ) .
it is evident that wind models with a peak optical depth near the systemic velocity have a @xmath97 absorption profile shifted blueward by one to several hundred .
analysis of such profiles may lead to the false conclusion that ( i ) the majority of mass in the wind is travelling at a higher velocity ; and ( ii ) there is no gas with @xmath572 .
the dashed curve traces the one - to - one line .
, height=336 ] these effects are reduced for the absorption profiles , especially for @xmath145 .
this is because a significant fraction ( even a majority ) of the emission is florescent * emission at longer wavelengths which does not affect the absorption profiles .
therefore , the absorption equivalent widths ( @xmath769 ) more closely follow the intrinsic values , one derives more accurate peak optical depths , and the absorption kinematics more faithfully reflect the motions of the flow .
regarding the last point , one also predicts a velocity offset between the and absorption - line centroids ( figure [ fig : obs_vtau ] ) .
this affects the analysis of gas related to the ism of the galaxy and also material infalling at modest speeds .
figure [ fig : obs_vtau ] also emphasizes that the profiles may misrepresent the kinematics of the bulk of the gas .
analysis of these lines , without consideration of line - emission , may lead to incorrect conclusions on the energetics and mass flux of the wind . ) and noise has been added to give a s / n=7 per pixel . note the suppressed peak in line - emission ; one may even infer the flux of @xmath97 exceeds that of @xmath102 .
the @xmath97 absorption is also shifted to shorter wavelengths , i.e. to a greater velocity offset from systemic .
( b ) the solid curve shows a stack of 100 spectra of the ism+wind profile , each degraded to a s / n=2 per pixel , and offset from systemic by a normal deviate with @xmath793 to mimic uncertainty in the redshift of the galaxies .
this treatment is meant to illustrate the implications of stacking galaxy spectra to study outflows ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the main difference from the single galaxy observation shown in panel ( a ) is the smearing of line - emission and absorption that reduces the height / depth of each .
the effects would likely be even more pronounced if one studied spectra with a diversity of profiles .
, height=336 ] we emphasize that all of these effects are heightened by the relatively low spectral resolution and s / n characteristic of the data commonly acquired for @xmath794 star - forming galaxies .
figure [ fig : obs_lris]a shows one realization of the @xmath0 doublet for the ism+wind model convolved with the line - spread - function of the keck / lris spectrometer ( a gaussian with fwhm=250 ) and an assumed signal - to - noise of s / n=7 per 1 pixel . both the absorption and emission
are well detected , but it would be difficult to resolve the issues discussed above ( e.g. partial covering , peak optical depth ) with these data .
one also notes several systematic effects of the lower spectral resolution , e.g. reduced peak flux in the line - emission and a systematic shift of @xmath97 absorption to more negative velocity .
we have also modelled an observation of the ism+wind model using a stacked galaxy spectrum ( figure [ fig : obs_lris]b ) . specifically , we averaged 100 identical profiles from the fiducial model degraded to a s / n=2pix@xmath19 and shifted by a random velocity offset with @xmath795 .
this treatment illustrates the effects of using stacked galaxy spectra to study outflows ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the main difference between this and the single galaxy observation shown in panel ( a ) is the smearing of line - emission and absorption that reduces the height / depth of each
. the effects would be even more pronounced if one studied spectra with a diversity of profiles .
special care is required , therefore , to interpret properties of the wind ( and ism ) from such spectral analysis .
( solid ) and * @xmath149 ( dotted ) transitions .
both profiles peak at small radii and decrease by several orders of magnitude before reaching the outer edge of the wind .
the profiles are sufficiently shallow , however , that the azimuthally integrated flux declines by only a factor of @xmath796 from @xmath521kpc to @xmath797kpc . therefore , a sensitive ifu observation could map the emission ( and , in principle , the kinematics ) from @xmath77 to approximately @xmath78 . ,
height=336 ] the previous few paragraphs sounded a cautionary perspective on the implications for absorption - line analysis of galactic - scale outflows in the presence of ( expected ) significant line - emission . while this is a necessary complication , we emphasize that such analysis remains one of the few observational techniques at our disposal to study outflows .
furthermore , direct analysis of the line - emission offers new and unique constraints on the characteristics of the outflow .
and , when coupled with the absorption - line data , the two sets of constraints may break various degeneracies in the physical characteristics of the outflow .
we now consider a few examples .
the most obvious characteristics probed by the line - emission are the size and morphology of the outflow @xcite .
line emission is predicted to extend to radii where the sobolev optical depth exceeds a few tenths .
the principle challenge is to achieve sufficient sensitivity to detect the predicted , low surface - brightness emission .
as figure [ fig : obs_sb ] demonstrates , the surface brightness at the inner wind radius of our fiducial wind exceeds that at the outer radius by several orders of magnitude .
nevertheless , an instrument that sampled the entire wind ( e.g. a large format ifu or narrow band imager ) may detect the emission in azimuthally - averaged apertures . for the fiducial wind model , for example , the azimuthally integrated flux falls by only a factor of 10 for projected radii of 1 to 15kpc .
of the transitions considered in this paper , emission is preferred for this analysis because ( i ) it has the largest equivalent width in absorption and ( ii ) there are fewer emission channels per absorption line than for . the lines ( especially @xmath102 ) frequently have the highest peak and integrated fluxes ( figure [ fig : obs_sb ] ) . on the other hand ,
the transitions are more susceptible to the effects of dust extinction and for some galaxies * emission could be dominant . in either case
, the study of spatially - extended line - emission from photons scattered by a galactic - scale wind offers a direct means to study the morphology and radial extent of these phenomena .
the next generation of large - format optical and infrared integral - field - units are well - suited to this scientific endeavor ( e.g. kcwi on keck , muse on the vlt ) .
the kinematic measurements of the line - emission also offer insight into physical characteristics of the wind . in @xmath18 [
sec : dust ] , we emphasized that dust extinction preferentially suppresses photons scattered off the backside of the wind ( e.g. @xmath140 ) so that the line - centroid is shifted to negative velocities .
similarly , anisotropic models with reduced emission off the backside yield emission lines that are centered blueward of the galaxy s systemic redshift .
these effects are most prominent in the * emission .
the centroids of the lines , meanwhile , are sensitive to the optical depth profile of the wind . for example
, a wind with flows exceeding @xmath798 will shift the @xmath97 centroid to bluer wavelengths ( e.g. figure [ fig : norm ] ) .
although these effects are modest ( tens of ) , they may be resolved by moderate resolution spectroscopy . ) of * @xmath148 emission versus the velocity where the resonance lines achieve peak optical depth @xmath486 in absorption .
the @xmath799 values rise steadily with increasing offset of @xmath486 from systemic .
the width of the * @xmath148emission line , therefore , offers an independent diagnostic of the wind speed .
, height=336 ] the emission - line velocity widths also reveal characteristics of the wind .
in particular , the * emission - line widths are sensitive to the optical depth of the wind at large velocity offsets from systemic .
this is illustrated in figure [ fig : obs_edelv ] which plots the 90% velocity width @xmath799 of * @xmath148 versus the velocity where the wind optical depth is maximal ( @xmath486 ) .
we find that @xmath799 increases with @xmath486 such that a large width for * emission requires a wind profile with large optical depths at @xmath800 .
the broadening of * emission occurs because this emission is dominated by single scatterings which trace all components of the wind .
lastly , the line flux ratios of pairs of transitions are sensitive to characteristics of the wind .
the most obvious example is the relative emission of the @xmath0doublet .
specifically , an outflow whose velocity exceeds the doublet spacing ( @xmath32 ) will convert @xmath97 photons into @xmath102 emission resulting in a flux ratio that is inverted relative to the intrinsic optical depth profiles ( e.g.figure [ fig : norm ] ) .
another important example is the relative flux of * emission relative to .
a dusty medium with velocity near systemic ( e.g. an ism component ) may significantly suppress emission yet have a significant * line flux because the latter is not resonantly trapped .
in this paper , we have explored the predicted absorption and emission - line profiles of a set of simple galactic - scale outflow models .
this analysis implemented monte carlo radiative transfer techniques to propogate resonant photons through an expanding medium , allowing for their conversion to non - resonant photons ( e.g. * ) .
our work focused on the @xmath0 and uv1 multiplet of rest - frame uv transitions , but the results apply to most other lines used to probe cool gas .
our primary findings are summarized as follows : 1 .
isotropic , dust - free wind models conserve photon flux . therefore , the blue - shifted absorption - line profiles commonly observed in star - forming galaxies are predicted to be accompanied by emission - lines with similar equivalent width .
this holds even for non - extreme anisotropic and dust - extincted scenarios .
2 . the line - emission occurs preferentially at the systemic velocity of the galaxy and ` fills - in ' the absorption profiles at velocity offsets @xmath782 from systemic . for transitions that are only coupled to the ground - state ( e.g. , , ) ,
this implies much lower , absorption - line equivalent widths ( by up to @xmath2 ) and observed absorption profiles that are significantly offset in velocity from the intrinsic optical depth profile .
3 . analysis of cool gas outflows that entirely ignores this line - emission may incorrectly conclude that the source is partially covered , that the gas has a significantly lower peak optical depth , and/or that gas with velocities near systemic ( e.g. from the ism or even an infalling component ) is absent .
resonance transitions that are strongly coupled to non - resonant lines ( e.g. , ) produce emission dominated by the optically - thin , fine - structure transitions . as such
, these resonance absorption lines offer the best characterization of the opacity of the wind and also of gas with velocities near systemic .
5 . dust extinction modestly affects models where resonance photons are trapped for only a few scatterings .
models with high opacity at small radii and at systemic velocity ( e.g. with an optically thick , ism component ) can effectively extinguish resonantly trapped emission ( ) but have weaker effect on non - resonant lines ( * ) .
we examined two scenarios designed to mimic the wind model proposed by @xcite for @xmath4 lyman break galaxies .
our implementation of this model genreates substantial line - emission from scattered photons that greatly modifies the predicted line - profiles so that this model does not reproduce the observed line - profiles .
significant line - emission is a generic prediction of simple wind models , even in the presence of dust , anisotropic flows , and when viewed through finite apertures .
we have explored the 2d emission maps ( figure [ fig : fiducial_ifu_mgii ] ) and surface brightness profiles ( figure [ fig : obs_sb ] ) of the winds .
sensitive , spatially - extended observations will map the morphology and radial extent of the outflows .
these data afford the best opportunity to estimate the energetics and mass - flux of galactic - scale outflows .
the kinematics and flux ratios of the emission lines constrain the speed , opacity , dust extinction , and morphology of the wind . when combined with absorption - line analysis
, one may develop yet tighter constraints on these characteristics . | we analyze the absorption and emission - line profiles produced by a set of simple , cool gas wind models motivated by galactic - scale outflow observations .
we implement monte carlo radiative transfer techniques that track the propagation of scattered and fluorescent photons to generate 1d spectra and 2d spectral images .
we focus on the @xmath0 doublet and uv1 multiplet at @xmath1 , but the results are applicable to other transitions that trace outflows ( e.g. , , ) . by design ,
the resonance transitions show blue - shifted absorption but one also predicts strong resonance and fine - structure line - emission at roughly the systemic velocity .
this line - emission ` fills - in ' the absorption reducing the equivalent width by up to @xmath2 , shift the absorption - lin centroid by tens of , and reduce the effective opacity near systemic .
analysis of cool gas outflows that ignores this line - emission may incorrectly infer that the gas is partially covered , measure a significantly lower peak optical depth , and/or conclude that gas at systemic velocity is absent ( e.g. an interstellar or slowly infalling component ) . because the lines are connected by optically - thin transitions to fine - structure levels , their profiles more closely reproduce the intrinsic opacity of the wind .
together these results naturally explain the absorption and emission - line characteristics observed for star - forming galaxies at @xmath3 .
we also study a scenario promoted to describe the outflows of @xmath4 lyman break galaxies and find prfiles inconsistent with the observations due to scattered photon emission .
although line - emission complicates the analysis of absorption - line profiles , the surface brightness profiles offer a unique means of assessing the morphology and size of galactic - scale winds .
furthermore , the kinematics and line - ratios offer powerful diagnostics of outflows , motivating deep , spatially - extended spectroscopic observations .
# 1 10^#1 5 ly-5 6 ly-6 7 ly-7 @xmath5 |
as the most common stellar remnants , white dwarfs ( wd ) provide an invaluable tracer of the early evolution of the galaxy .
their current density and distribution reflects the disposition of their progenitor main sequence stars and their colors indicate their ages , which are consistent with many of them having been formed when the galaxy was quite young ( e.g. wood 1992 ) . until recently , it has been assumed that halo wds contribute a negligible fraction of the total mass of the galaxy ( e.g. gould , flynn & bahcall 1998 ) .
this view is supported by the constraint that the formation of @xmath210.6m@xmath15 wds is accompanied by the release of several solar masses of gas , heavily enriched in cno elements ( e.g. charlot & silk 1995 ; gibson & mould 1997 ; canal , isern & ruiz - lapuente 1997 ) . yet
local stars and interstellar gas , which only comprise @xmath25% of the total galaxy mass , contain only 23 percent of these elements by mass . based on these metalicity arguments , most recently fields , freese & graff ( 2000 )
have argued that @xmath26@xmath27@xmath28 from c and n element abundances , adopting h@xmath29=70kms@xmath5mpc@xmath5 .
wds can therefore not comprise more than 110% percent of the dark matter in the galactic halo within 50 kpc , if @xmath30 ( e.g. bahcall et al . 2000 ) .
however , this argument can be circumvented if significant metal outflow from the galaxy , due to supernovae , accompanies the formation of these wds , thereby removing most of the produced metals from the galaxy ( e.g. fields , mathews & schramm 1997 ) .
these considerations are important because the macho collaboration ( e.g. alcock et al . 2000 ) report a frequency of large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) microlensing events that is suggestive of 850% ( 95% c.l ) of the halo mass in @xmath31m@xmath15 compact objects inside a 50 kpc galacto - centric radius .
faint stars and brown dwarfs seem to comprise only a few percent of the galaxy mass ( e.g. bahcall et al .
1994 ; graff & freese 1996a , 1996b ; mera , chabrier & schaeffer 1996 ; flynn , gould & bahcall 1996 ; freese , fields & graff 1998 ) and are therefore unlikely to be responsible for these microlensing events .
the only remaining candidates with similar masses , known to us , are wds .
alternative explanations for these microlensing events , based on stellar self - lensing in the lmc have been put forward ( wu 1994 ; sahu 1994 ; salati et al . 1999 ; aubourg et al .
1999 ; evans & kerins 2000 ) .
a comparable microlensing survey done by the eros collaboration only claims an upper limit of 40% ( 95% c.l . ) of the halo mass in compact objects with mass less than 1 m@xmath15 ( lasserre et al . 2000 ; see afonso et al .
1999 for smc results ) .
because the eros survey targets the outer regions of the lmc , in contrast to the macho survey , this could indeed suggest some self - lensing contribution .
there have also been claims of a number of high proper - motion objects in the hdf , which were suggested to be old wds in the galactic halo at a distance of @xmath212 kpc ( ibata et al .
1999 ) , with blue colors that were consistent with revised white - dwarf atmosphere models ( hansen 1999 ) .
more locally , ibata et al .
( 2000 ) found two high proper - motion wds . if the hdf results had been confirmed , they alone would have been sufficient to explain the observed microlensing optical depth towards the lmc .
however , recent third - epoch observations have shown that these `` objects '' were misidentifications and _ not _ moving objects ( richer 2001 ) .
the topic has become interesting again , though , with the recent discovery by oppenheimer et al ( 2001 ) of 38 nearby , old wds , with de - projected horizontal velocities in excess of 94 kms@xmath5 ( see sect.2 ) .
they concluded that at least two percent of the halo is composed of these cool wds .
this conclusion has been challenged , however , by reid , sahu & hawley ( 2001 ) , who claim that these wds could be the high - velocity tail of the thick disk .
in addition , hansen ( 2001 ) has argued that these wds follow the same color - magnitude relation as those of the disc , which might be unexpected if they are a halo population . in this paper , we take the observations of oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) at face value and examine their conclusions in more detail .
we assume that the high proper motion objects have correctly been identified as wds and that their inferred distances are statistically unbiased . however , it is important that additional observations be performed to validate this .
we also discuss how to set more precise bounds on the halo wd density .
the high proper motion wds were selected from digitized photographic plates from the supercosmos sky survey ( hambly et al .
2001 ) , covering an effectively searched area of 4165 square degree around the south galactic pole ( sgp ) , upto @xmath32@xmath33@xmath3445@xmath35 . objects with proper motions between @xmath36=0.33 and 10.0 arcsec yr@xmath5 were selected , that were brighter than @xmath37=19.8 mag and seen at three epochs in each field . from these objects a sample of 126 potential halo wds
was drawn based on their reduced proper motion ( @xmath38=@xmath37 + 5@xmath39 + 5 ) and their color @xmath40 .
after spectroscopic observations of 69 of the 92 wds without spectra ( 34 had published spectra ) , a sample of 99 wds remained . for a full discusion of the sample , its selection criteria and completeness
, we refer to oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) .
distances to each of these wds were ascribed using the photometric parallax relation derived by bergeron et al .
this was checked in two cases using measured distances and the relative uncertainty was estimated at 20 percent . using these distances , oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) subsequently performed a velocity selection on the wd sample .
the proper motions were converted into a velocity in galactic coordinates relative to the local standard of rest , ( lsr ) , with @xmath41 directed towards the galactic center ( gc ) , @xmath42 along the direction of the circular velocity and @xmath43 towards the north galactic pole ( ngp ) , see fig.2 .
the absence of a measured radial velocity ( @xmath44 ) was compensated by assuming that @xmath43=0 and deprojecting onto the @xmath45 plane .
it was then argued that 95 percent for a 2d rayleigh distribution .
] of the thick - disc wds have velocities in the plane within 94 km s@xmath5 ( @xmath46 ) from the asymmetric drift point @xmath47=@xmath48 and consequently all such wds were eliminated , leaving a sample of 38 high - velocity wds of which 26 are new discoveries and 14 exhibit hydrogen lines and are believed to be younger .
these wds have velocities in the galactic plane that are enclosed within a circle of radius @xmath49 centered on @xmath50 km s@xmath5 corresponding to a non - rotating halo distribution .
the density of wds in the magnitude - limited sample was then estimated to be @xmath51 m@xmath15 pc@xmath10 , roughly ten times the expected density ( e.g. gould , flynn & bahcall 1998 ) and equivalent to 2 percent of the nominal local halo mass density ( e.g. gates , gyuk & turner 1995 ) .
this procedure has been criticised by reid , sahu & hawley ( 2001 ) who de - project the velocity vector by setting the radial velocity ( @xmath44 ) to zero , thereby reducing the number of high velocity wds .
this procedure , however , also places several lower velocity wds outside the 94 km s@xmath5 cut .
reid et al . ( 2001 ) also note that the high velocity wds are not concentrated around @xmath50 km s@xmath5 as might be expected from a halo population and argue that the wds are mostly associated with the high velocity tail of the thick disc plus a few wds from the traditional halo stellar population .
essentially the same point has been made by graff ( 2001 ) .
in addition , gibson & flynn ( 2001 ) identified a number of errors in the original table of white - dwarf properties and argued that the oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) densities are further overestimated by a factor 310 , bringing them more into line with the results from other surveys . in this paper , we analyse the full sample of 99 wds , not only those 38 with the highest space velocities , thereby avoiding potential pitfalls associated with arbitrary cuts in the sample and analysing only subsamples .
the photometric parallax method to obtain distances hides a potential problem for the oldest wds ( @xmath5210 gyr ) .
although these white dwarfs continue to cool and fade away , their @xmath53 color remains nearly constant at @xmath331.9 for @xmath54@xmath5218 ( fig.1 ; e.g. chabrier et al .
2000 ) . blindly applying the linear color - magnitude relation given in oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) to the oldest wds would therefore lead to a severe overestimate of their intrinsic luminosity and distance . even if old wds are present in the sample , it might not be surprising that they do nt show up in the color - magnitude relation by hansen ( 2001 ) .
wds that move onto the horizontal branch of the cooling curve have increasingly overestimated luminositities and consequently move up in the color - magnitude diagram much closer to the sequence of younger ( @xmath5510 gyr ) wds .
fortunately , only 5% of the sample of wds have colors @[email protected] ( fig.1 ) and it should therefore not create a major problem . however , it is potentially dangerous to create color - magnitude diagrams , using distances that have been derived by forcing the wds to follow the color - magnitude relation of relatively young wds , and from those to conclude that the wd are young .
this is a circular argument .
a better argument is to plot the age sequence on a two - color diagram ( fig.1 ; see also oppenheimer et al .
again , there is no evidence for wds older than @xmath25 gyr and the high - velocity wds appear to be drawn from the same population as the low - velocity wds which are presumably relics of ongoing star formation in the disc .
this appears to argue against there being a substantial white - dwarf halo population ( e.g. hansen 2001 ) , although if there exists a mechanism that preferentially gives wds a high space - velocity during its formation / evolution one might not expect a correlation between age and velocity .
the latter would only be expected if velocities increased with time due to slower scattering processes .
we return to this in sect.7 .
we should emphasize , however , that the implied ages and distances are only as good as the assumed underlying white - dwarf color - magnitude relation , in this case that from bergeron et al .
( 1997 ) , and that independent measurements of their distances are necessary , preferentially through parallax measurements , even though that will be difficult given their large proper motions .
for each wd , we transform its equatorial coordinates ( @xmath57,@xmath58 ) in to galactic coordinates ( @xmath59,@xmath32)=122.932@xmath35 for the galactic longitude of the celestial pole . ] . using the distances ascribed by oppenheimer et al .
2001 , we then transform the observed proper motion vector in galactic coordinates into a vector @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is velocity component along the @xmath59-direction and @xmath62 is the velocity component along the the @xmath32-direction ( fig.2 ) .
the resulting vector is orthogonal to the line - of - sight , i.e. the direction of the radial velocity ( @xmath44 ) , which is unknown to us .
the transformation from the observed velocities to galactic velocities ( @xmath41,@xmath42,@xmath43 ) with respect to the local standard of rest ( lsr ) , is @xmath63 where @xmath64 km s@xmath5 is the solar motion with respect to the lsr ( dehen & binney 1998b ) .
we can use eq.([coordtrans ] ) to transform the velocity distribution function @xmath65 ( 4.6 ) in to @xmath66 , or visa versa , at the position of any wd with a measured proper - motion vector and distance .
fig.3 shows velocity vector ( @xmath61,@xmath62 ) for each wd at its corresponding galactic coordinates .
the velocity vectors point preferentially in the direction opposite to galactic rotation , which reflects the asymmetric drift ( 4.2 ) , whereby a stellar population that is significantly pressure supported , rotates slower than its lsr .
if many of the high proper motion objects had been misidentied on the photometric plates , one does not expect a collective movement of these objects in the same direction .
before introducing a model for the phase - space density of wds in the solar neighborhood in 4.6 , we first ( i ) describe a simple global potential model that we will employ to derive some of the characteristic orbital parameters of the sample of wds , ( ii ) reprise epicyclic theory , in order to clarify the discussion and some of the concepts that we will use in this paper , ( iii ) derive some characteristic quantities of the white - dwarfs data set , ( iv ) examine the properties of the white - dwarf orbits and ( v ) discuss some general properties of the galactic disc components . for definiteness
we assume a spherically symmetric potential for the galaxy @xmath67 in cylindrical coordinates , where @xmath68 is the distance from the rotation axis of the galaxy and @xmath69 is the height above the plane .
the simplification of spherical symmetry is not inconsistent with observations of the galaxy and external galaxies , even though a wide range of values for the flattening of the galactic halo is allowed , often strongly dependent on the method used to derive it ( see olling & merrifield 2000 ) .
this potential , although a clear simplification , it is to first order also consistent with the relatively flat galactic rotation curve ( e.g. dehnen & binney 1998a ) and allows us to gain insight in the kinematics and properties of the white - dwarf sample .
the circular velocity @xmath70=@xmath71 in this potential is constant in the plane of the galaxy ( @xmath69=0 ) .
one can subsequently introduce the effective potential @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the angular momentum of a wd and @xmath74 is its tangential velocity in the plane of the galaxy .
if a particle is `` at rest '' in the minimum of the effective potential , i.e. @xmath75=0 , one readily finds that @xmath74=@xmath70 , hence the wd moves on a circular orbit with a constant velocity @xmath70=@xmath76 , where @xmath77 is the angular velocity .
most stars and stellar remnants , however , do not move on perfect circular orbits , but have an additional random velocity and move on orbits around the minimum in their effective potential .
if these excursions have relatively small amplitudes , the taylor expansion of the effective potential around this minimum can be terminated at the second - order derivative and the stars or wds will exhibit sinusoidal ( i.e. epicyclic ) motions around the circular orbit
. the frequency of these epicyclic motions are @xmath78 in the tangential and radial directions and @xmath79 in the direction out of the plane .
the radius of the guiding centre is @xmath80 ( see 4.2 ) .
because these frequencies depend on local higher - order derivatives of the potential , we can not use our simple potential model , eqn.([eq : potentialeff ] ) , but have to rely on observational constraints ( 4.2 ) .
one can introduce the oort s constants @xmath81 and @xmath82 , whose values have observationally been determined to be @xmath81=14.5kms@xmath5kpc@xmath5 and @xmath82=@xmath3412kms@xmath5kpc@xmath5 in the solar neighborhood . ]
( bt87 ) . from this
is follows that @xmath83 , i.e. @xmath84kms@xmath5kpc@xmath5 , and @xmath85 the frequency of the epicyclic motion is therefore constant at 1.3 times its orbital frequency , irrespective of the amplitude of the orbit around the minimum of its effective potential . in comparison ,
the potential given by eq.([eq : potential ] ) gives @xmath86 . under the epicyclic approximation , stars undergo retrograde , elliptical , orbits in the plane about their guiding centers , which move on circular orbits .
the ratio of the radial velocity amplitude to the azimuthal velocity amplitude is @xmath87 , where @xmath88 km s@xmath5 kpc@xmath5 is the circular angular frequency ( e.g. bt87 ) and @xmath89 is given above .
the individual orbits are elongated azimuthally
. however , at a given point , retrograde motion by stars with interior guiding centers that orbit faster than the lsr , must be combined with prograde motion executed by stars with exterior guiding centers that orbit more slowly .
the net result is that the ratio of the radial velocity dispersion to the azimuthal velocity dispersion is predicted to be @xmath90=@[email protected] .
this prediction is supported by observations of different stellar populations ( e.g. dehnen & binney 1998b ; dehen 1998 ; chiba & beers 2000 ) .
superimposed on this horizontal motion is a vertical oscillation with angular frequency , @xmath92 , which is uncoupled to the horizontal motion at this level of approximation .
the amplitude of this oscillation is determined by the past history including scattering off molecular clouds and spiral arms , and is measured to be approximately @[email protected] ( e.g. dehnen & binney 1998b ; dehen 1998 ; chiba & beers 2000 ) .
the velocity ellipsoid appears to maintain these dispersion ratios even for velocities where the epicyclic approximation ought to be quite inaccurate . at the next level of approximation
, we must include the radial density variation and this will contribute a mean tangential velocity , relative to the lsr , at a point , as there are more stars with interior guiding centers moving backwards than exterior stars moving forwards .
this is the asymmetric drift , @xmath94=@xmath95@xmath42@xmath96=@xmath97 , which is the velocity lag of a population of stars with respect to the lsr .
this can be estimated from the fluid ( jeans ) equations by observing that the circular velocity of a group of stars will be reduced by a quantity proportional to the pressure gradient per unit density .
this should scale @xmath98 and it is found ( dehen & binney 1998b ) that @xmath99 roughly consistent with a calculation using the disc density variation . later in the paper ( 5.1 )
, we use this expression as a self - consistency check of our results .
in addition , moving groups or non - axisymmetric density variations ( e.g. spiral structure ) could be responsible for a second effect , a rotation of the velocity ellipsoid in the horizontal plane , known as vertex deviation .
this effect is quite small for old stars ( i.e. @xmath5510@xmath35 ; dehen & binney 1998b ) and we shall therefore ignore it .
we notice here a key simplification that follows from the realization that we can observe stars moving with relative azimuthal sky velocity @xmath100 out to a distance @xmath101 .
by contrast , the amplitude of the radial excursion is @xmath21@xmath102 .
we can therefore ignore curvature of the stellar orbits and spatial gradients in the stellar density over the sample volume .
a corollary is that we can also ignore a small rotational correction when relating the proper motion to the space velocity .
there is a standard procedure for finding the mean velocity of a sample of stars with known proper motions and distances , even when their distribution on the sky is far from isotropic ( bm98 ) .
we define a projection matrix @xmath103 in galactic cartesian coordinates , where @xmath104 is unit vector in the direction of the n - th star .
the velocity that minimises the dispersion about its projection onto the measured tangential velocity @xmath105 is easily shown to be @xmath106_{ij}<p>_j$ ] .
carrying out this operation for the full 99 wd sample gives a mean velocity , essentially the asymmetric drift velocity relative to the lsr , of @xmath107 km s@xmath5 .
this result is fairly robust in the sense that it is not seriously changed if we remove a few very high velocities whose reality could be suspect .
the sample has no significant motion either radially or perpendicular to the plane of the galaxy , but clearly shows the asymmetric drift in @xmath42 .
such an asymmetric drift , according to eqn.([eq : asymdrift ] ) , would naively imply a velocity dispersion for the complete sample of @xmath108kms@xmath5 .
the absence of a velocity drift in the @xmath41 and @xmath43 directions also supports the notion that this wd population is near equilibrium .
the values of the velocity dispersion and asymmetric drift of a kinematically unbiased sample , however , will be lower than found above , because a proper - motion limited sample will preferentially bias toward the high - velocity wds ( see sect.5 ) . because wds can move distances from the sun that are at least @xmath212 orders of magnitude larger than their observed distances ( 4.2 ) , the majority originate far from the lsr . to quantify this
, we have calculated the inner and outermost radii ( @xmath109 and @xmath110 ) of the white - dwarf orbits in the simplified galactic potential , eqn.([eq : potential ] ) , using the velocities @xmath41 and @xmath42 , and explicitly assuming @xmath43=0 ( i.e. the wds move only in the galactic plane ) .
the assumption @xmath43=0 leads to a tight scatter of the wds around the relation @xmath111 , whereas the assumption @xmath44=0 leads to results are similar within a few percent .
statistically , these two different assumptions are therefore expected to lead to only minor differences .
the results , shown in fig . 4 , indicate that as many as 98 , 72 , 29 and 14 of the 99 wds make excursions more than 1 , 3 , 5 and 7 kpc , respectively .
none of the wds have both the inner and outermost radii inside the volume probed by the most distant observed wd ( at @xmath21150pc ) . hence , even under the restrictive assumption that these wds do not move out of the galactic plane , the majority are not of local origin , but come from a volume at is at least 3 to 4 orders of magnitude larger than that probed by the survey .
to illustrate this more graphically , we have plotted the orbits of two white dwarfs in the sample in fig . 5 , assuming firstly that the wds lies in a thin , equatorial disk , i.e. @xmath112 , and secondly that they are drawn from the bi - maxwellian velocity distribution discussed below ( 4.6 ) .
one wd has a high velocity and moves on a nearly radial orbit , the other moves on a nearly circular orbit .
it is clear that the epicyclic approximation is unlikely to provide an accurate description for the orbits of most high velocity wds . in general the disc of our galaxy
is thought to be composed of two major dynamically distrinct components ; the thin disc and a thick stellar disc , which supposedly comprises several percent of the stellar disc mass ( e.g. gilmore & reid 1983 ; gilmore , wyse , & kuijken 1989 ) . whereas the thin disc has a relatively low velocity dispersion of @xmath113@xmath2120 kms@xmath5 in the vertical direction and is only several hundred pc thick , the thick disc has velocity dispersion that is @xmath113@xmath2145 kms@xmath5 and has an asymmetric drift of @xmath94@xmath2140 kms@xmath5(e.g .
gilmore et al .
1989 ; chiba & beers 2000 ) . if discs are treated as massive self - gravitating slabs , such that @xmath114 , thick - disc stars typically move @xmath115@xmath211 kpc out of the plane for the appropriate galactic disc surface densities @xmath116 , consistent with observations ( e.g. reid & majewski 1993 ; robins et al . 1996 ; ojha 2001 ) . maybe surprisingly
, recently analyzed observations suggest ( i ) that wds which kinematically appear to belong to the thin disc , have a scale height that might be twice that of the traditional thin disc and ( ii ) that the wd sky - density towards to north galactic pole is an order of magnitude higher than found in previous surveys ( majewski & siegel 2001 ) . in comparison , about @xmath2150% of the high proper - motion wds move at least 4 kpc from the lsr ( 4.4 ) .
hence , wds with velocities several times the velocity dispersion of the thick disc with respect to the lsr could , in principle , move many kpc out of the galactic plane as well , if their velocity distribution function is not extremely flattened in the vertical direction .
wds observed in the solar neighborhood are therefore a mixed population from the thin disc and the thick disc .
because of the proper - motion cut , we expect only a few wds from the thin disc in the sample .
if the halo contains a significant population of wds , it will also contribute to the local white - dwarf density .
each of these populations have their own kinematic properties , although there could be a continuous transition , for example , from the thick disc to the halo ( e.g. gilmore et al .
1989 ) .
whereas , epicycle theory ( 4.2 ) indicates that excursions in the radial and tangential direction are related through conservations of angular momentum , unfortunately , we have little information about the velocities perpendicular to the plane .
however , if most wds are born in the disc , one expects that scattering processes in the plane of the galaxy result in comparable radial , azimuthal and vertical velocities .
this is observationally borne out by the fact that the velocity ellipsoid is isotropic within a factor @xmath212 ( 4.2 ) and not extremely flattened .
similarly , if wds occupy the halo as the result of a merger and/or violent relaxation process , during galaxy formation , or if wds are ejected into the halo from the disc ( see 7.2 ) the velocity ellipsoid is also expected to be nearly isotropic
. theoretically nor observationally is there any evidence or indication that a velocity distribution can be extremely flattened in the vertical direction . if one accepts this conclusion , it is difficult to escape the consequence that the majority of the observed wds with large @xmath41 and @xmath42 velocities also have large @xmath43 velocities and make comparably large vertical excursions .
even , if we conservatively assume that the vertical excursions are only half that in the radial and tangential direction , one finds that @xmath2150% of these ` local ' wds in the sample are expected to move @xmath117 kpc out of the plane , twice the thick disk scale height of @xmath115@xmath211 kpc , although this conclusion could be modified if a proper potential model for the stellar disc and bulge is included ( e.g. 7.2 ) . in the following subsection
we will examine this in more detail , in the context of a local velocity distribution function and show more generally how these results can be translated into a global halo density of wds .
the small sample of wds and lack of radial velocities does not allow us to derive the phase - space density of this population , @xmath118 , where @xmath119 and @xmath120 are position and velocity vectors , respectively ( e.g. bt87 ) .
we must therefore make some simplifying assumptions : ( i ) the phase - space density is locally separable , such that @xmath121 , ( ii ) the velocity distribution function ( vdf ) with respect to an observer at the lsr can be described by a normalized schwarzschild distribution function ( svdf ) @xmath122 where @xmath120=@xmath123 and ( iii ) @xmath124 is constant in the volume probed by the survey .
the adopted coordinates system is shown in fig.2 .
both the velocity vector ( @xmath41,@xmath42,@xmath43 ) , with respect to an observer at the lsr , and the velocity dispersions @xmath125,@xmath126 and @xmath113 are defined along the principle axes of the galactic coordinate system . in the remainder of this paper
, we adopt a bimodal schwarzschild velocity distribution function ( bsvdf ) model @xmath127 where the definitions are as in eqn.([eq : vdf ] ) and @xmath128 is the number - density ratio of wds in the thick disc and halo .
the velocity dispersions , asymmetric drifts and number - density ratio are free parameters .
we emphasize that the adopted bsvdf model is not a unique choice and the real vdf could be a continuous superposition of svdfs or have a form different from maxwellian .
experiments with more general forms of the vdf ( power laws ) , however , give essentially similar results .
in addition , the svdf is locally a solution of the collisionless boltzmann equation and also internally consistent with epicyclic theory ( bt87 ) .
the same is true for a superposition of svdfs .
to calculate the probability of a set of model parameters , @xmath129=\{@xmath130,@xmath131,@xmath132,@xmath133,@xmath134 } , given the set of constraints @xmath135 , i.e. the proper motion @xmath36 and position angle @xmath136 from the @xmath137-th white dwarf , we use bayes theorem @xmath138 we assume that @xmath139 is a constant and set it equal to unity , although this might not the case . in particular , the efficiency of detecting wds might be a function of its proper motion and position on the sky ( oppenheimer , private communication ) . if the values of @xmath140 are statistically independent , the log - likelihood sample becomes @xmath141 where @xmath142 and @xmath143 is the number of wds in the sample .
the probability @xmath140 for each wd in a _ fully _ proper - motion limited is given by the function @xmath144 where @xmath145=@xmath146 is the velocity vector on the sky in galactic coordinates ( see eqn.1 ) and @xmath147 is the unit vector in the radial direction away from the observer ( graff and gould , private communications ) . the weight function @xmath148 and @xmath149 indicates that area in velocity space for which @xmath150 , where @xmath151 is the distance to the wd and @xmath152 arcsec yr@xmath5 is the proper - motion lower limit of the survey .
the weight function is proportional to the maximum volume ( @xmath153 ; see sect.6 ) in which the wd could have been found and therefore biases a proper - motion limited survey towards high - velocity wds . in case @xmath154
, the likelihood function reduces to that of a kinematically unbiased survey ( e.g. dehnen 1998 ) . in practice , only @xmath2190% of the wds in the sample are proper - motion limited , whereas only @xmath2110% of the observed wds would first drop out of the sample because of the survey s magnitude limit ( fig.7 ; see sect.6 for a more detailed discussion ) .
these wds are also those with highest observed velocities ( fig.7 ) .
if we assume that these wds are also proper - motion limited , we would overestimate the volume ( i.e. @xmath155 ) in which these wds could have been detected and thus bias the results towards lower velocities and lower halo densities ( gould , private communications ) , the latter by about 4050% .
of the ten wds that are magnitude limited , eight have nearly identical values of @xmath153 ( and therefore absolute magnitude ) , whereas the other two have much smaller values .
conservatively , we assume that all ten wds have similar and constant values of @xmath153 , which might slightly underestimate the halo density of wds . in practice
this effect is only @xmath2110% and we therefore neglect it in light of all the uncertainties .
it is important to remember , however , that strictly speaking eq.([eq : pdm ] ) is only valid for completely proper - motion limited surveys .
the notion that this is the case for @xmath2190% of the wds allows us to make the simple adjustment above without explicit knowledge of the white - dwarf luminosity function , which is roughly speaking assumed to be a delta function . for each wd , @xmath137 , we now know the velocity vector @xmath145 ( see fig.3 ) .
we then evaluate @xmath140 using eqn.([eq : pdm ] ) and the transformation between @xmath156 and @xmath157 , as discussed in sect.3 and from those we can evaluate @xmath158 , given a set of model parameters @xmath129 .
we maximize the likelihood @xmath158 , given the bsvdf model introduced in 4.6 and the proper - motion data set from the 99 observed wds . before the optimisation
, we first remove three of the wds that contribute most ( @xmath2180% ) to the wd density determined from the complete sample .
a justification for this is given in sect.6 .
the removal changes the results only a few percent compared to the dataset of 99 wds .
the resulting dataset from 96 wds is designated @xmath159 .
we optimize by varying all five parameters @xmath129=\{@xmath130,@xmath131,@xmath160,@xmath161,@xmath134}. for definiteness we assume that the velocity ellipsoid has ratios @xmath125:@xmath126:@xmath113=1:2/3:1/2 , close to what is observed for the smooth background of stars in the local neighborhood ( e.g. dehnen 1998 ; see 4.2 ) .
the resulting model parameters are listed in table 1 .
the errors indicate the 90% confidence level , determined by re - optimizing , whereby we allow all parameters to vary , but keep the parameter of interest fixed .
.the most likely bsvdf model for the full ( @xmath159 ) .
the errors indicate the 90% confidence interval . [
cols="<,<",options="header " , ] fig.6 shows the likelihood contours of thick - disc and halo velocity dispersions around the most likely models in table 1 .
we maximize the likelihood for each set of velocity dispersions . in the case @xmath159
, one can conclude that vdf is bimodal at the more than 99% c.l . due to the position of the wds close to the south galactic pole ,
only poor constraints are obtained on the @xmath113 .
our particular choice of the ratio @xmath162=@xmath163 could potentially underestimate the density of wds in the halo . by varying the ratio @xmath164 and re - optimizing the likelihood
, we find @xmath165 at the 90% c.l .
, with no sensible lower limit .
this exemplifies the poor constraints on velocities perpendicular to the galactic plane . within this range
the parameters in table 1 vary by only a few percent .
note also that the maximum - likelihood estimate of the thick - disc asymmetric drift , @xmath160=50 kms@xmath5 , agrees well with that estimated from the asymmetric - drift relation in eqn.(5 ) , which gives 48 kms@xmath5 .
if we make the velocity vector isotropic , for example , this is no longer the case and the resulting asymmetric drift and radial velocity dispersion of the thick - disc population ( i.e. @xmath125=51 kms@xmath5 and @xmath166=49 kms@xmath5 ) are inconsistent with the empirical relation in eqn.(5 ) .
the likelihood of the model also decreases by a six orders of magnitude .
this might be regarded as a consistency check that the sample of thick - disc wds and the likelihood results are in agreement with the kinematics of other local stellar populations , whereas this is not the case for an isotropic velocity distribution .
the flattening of the velocity ellipsoid in the @xmath42 direction also naturally explains the apparent scarcity of wds in the regions around @xmath50 kms@xmath5 and @xmath167 kms@xmath5 , noticed by reid et al .
we must now turn to estimating the local space density which is needed to normalize the stellar distribution function .
our approach follows that of oppenheimer et al ( 2001 ) by taking into account the proper motion selection , as well as the flux selection . we continue to ignore errors , which can introduce significant biases , and suppose that a star with proper motion @xmath36 , magnitude @xmath37 and distance @xmath168 , could have been seen out to a distance @xmath169 $ ] where the proper - motion distance limit is @xmath170 , with @xmath171=0.33 arcsec yr@xmath5 , and the magnitude distance limit is given by @xmath172 and still been included in the sample .
the maximum volumes in which the wd could have been found are then @xmath173 , where @xmath174 is solid angle covered by the survey . in fig.7 , we plot the ratio @xmath175 versus observed velocity ( @xmath176 ) .
one observes that 89 out of the sample of 99 wds are proper motion - limited ; there is a conspicuous absence of faint wd in the sample relative to a true magnitude - limited sample .
note that the absence of faint wds is even more prominent for the slowly moving stars ( fig.8 ) .
there are two possible explanations .
either the photometry is inaccurate and the selection is quite incomplete close to the survey limit @xmath177 .
alternatively , the density of old , low luminosity wds is so small that there are no more than a few that are close enough for us to see them move . for this second explanation to be viable
, the logarithmic slope of the luminosity function @xmath178 must be greater ( and in practice much greater ) than @xmath179 . in order to distinguish between these two explanations
we have evaluated @xmath180 for the whole sample .
we find a value @xmath181 .
this is quite close to the expect value of 0.5 that we suspect that although incompleteness is present , the distribution in @xmath182 parameter space reflects the whole population , where @xmath183 is the luminosity of the wd .
if we ignore possible photometric incompleteness , our estimator of the total space density is @xmath184 where @xmath185 is the fraction of the sky surveyed and @xmath186 is the estimated spectroscopic incompleteness of the 99 wd sample .
the result is @xmath187 pc@xmath10 .
the result is quite robust with respect to changes in the limiting magnitude although 30% of the density is contributed by a single wd , and 80% by three wds ( i.e those with @xmath188 mag ; fig.8 ) .
this estimator refers to stars whose luminosities and transverse velocities are actually included in the sample although the variance can be quite large if there are significant contributions from wd near the boundaries of this distribution . from fig.1
it is apparent that this range translates into absolute magnitudes , @xmath18919 and ages in the range of about @xmath190 gyr .
the three brightest wds that dominate the density estimate are most likely part of the thin - disc population .
because this component was not included in the vdf model used in the likelihood analysis , we have to remove these objects from the density estimate to avoid a severe overestimate of @xmath191 , the normalisation of the local phase - space density , @xmath192 , of the thick - disc and halo wds .
we therefore remove all wds with observed velocities @xmath193 kms@xmath5 from the sample ( three in total ) , which should remove all thin - disc wds .
their removal from the sample has a negligible effect on the likelihood analysis ( see 5.1 ) .
we subsequently find @xmath194 pc@xmath10 ( 1@xmath195 ) , which then represents the local density of thick - disk and halo white dwarfs that have @xmath196 kms@xmath5 .
to normalise @xmath197 we calculate the fraction , @xmath198 , of the vdf @xmath199 for which the observed velocity @xmath196 kms@xmath5 .
the correct normalisation of the local density of thick - disk and halo wds then becomes @xmath200 .
given the bsvdf model listed in table 1 , for the full data - set ( @xmath159 ) , we find @xmath201 , hence @xmath202 finally , the _ local _ halo density of wds becomes @xmath203 with @xmath134=16.0@xmath204 ( table 1 ) . this density estimate for the halo white dwarfs is about half that found by oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) . for completeness
, we quote a thick - disc white - dwarf density of @xmath205 which corresponds within @xmath206 to the thick - disc number density @xmath207 pc@xmath10 that was estimated by reid et al .
( 2001 ) on the basis of only seven wds within a sphere of 8 pc from the sun .
note that our estimate takes the contribution from wds outside the 94 kms@xmath5 cut in to account .
we therefore self - consistently recover the local thick - disc density within acceptable errors , from the sample of high - proper motion wds discovered by oppenheimer et al .
we therefore do not expect this sample to be significantly incomplete or biased in a way unknown to us .
concluding , the likelihood result that there are two kinematically distinct populations , at the 99% c.l , gives us confidence that there is indeed a contribution of @xmath216% of the thick - disk wd density or @xmath210.8% of the local halo density , by a population of wds that exhibits kinematic properties that are not dissimilar to that expected from a nearly pressure - supported halo population . to place the results obtained above in perspective , we now turn to a comparison of the local density of wds that we derived with other local densities .
summarising , the local mass densities of wds , derived in this paper , were @xmath208 , @xmath209 and @xmath210 m@xmath15 pc@xmath10 , respectively , for the halo , thick - disc and total mass density ( including thin disc ) , if we convert number densities to densities using an average wd mass of 0.6 m@xmath15 . the local wd density derived from direct observations is @xmath211 m@xmath15 pc@xmath10 ( holberg , oswalt & sion 2001 ) .
these direct observations compare well with our total wd density estimate . because of the very small volume probed by the proper - motion limited survey of oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) for the lowest velocity thin - disc wds , the error on our estimate is very large .
we found @xmath213 plausible thin - disc wds ( sect.6 ; fig.8 ) .
if we had found one wd less , with comparable or lower velocities , the total density estimate could easily have halfed .
the low number statistics of thin - disc wds , which dominate the local wd density , makes the integrated density estimate of local wds very uncertain .
this is much less of a problem for both the thick - disc and halo density estimates , because in both cases the probed volume is significantly larger ( 23 orders of magnitude ) and consequently also the number of wds from both populations .
the local stellar density is around @xmath212 m@xmath15 pc@xmath10 ( e.g. pham 1997 ; creze et al .
1998 ; holmberg & flynn 2000 ) . the mass density ratio of wds to stars is therefore about 46% .
this fraction is 23 times less than the @xmath2113% estimated by hansen ( 2001 ) .
we find @xmath2115% from a more sophisticated population synthesis model that self - consistently takes metallicity - dependent yields , gas in- and outflow , stellar lifetimes and delayed mixing into account , under the same assumption that the stellar imf is salpeter from 0.1 to 100 m@xmath15 .
the result is almost independent of any assumption , except for the shape and lower mass limit of the imf .
we return to this apparent discrepancy in 7.2 . the local halo density in dark matter is estimated to be @xmath213 m@xmath15 pc@xmath10 ( gates et al . 1995 ; where we take the result that does _ not _ include the microlensing constraints ) .
this result agrees with those determined by other authors .
our local halo wd density estimate would therefore correspond to @xmath210.8% of the local halo mass density , slightly higher than that estimated by oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) , for the reasons outlined previously .
the local density in hydrogen - burning halo stars is estimated to be @xmath214 m@xmath15 pc@xmath10 , whereas the wd density estimated from this population , based on population synthesis models , is @xmath215 m@xmath15 pc@xmath10 ( gould et al .
our density estimate of wds is therefore @xmath215 times larger than that previously estimated and is comparable in mass to the local stellar halo density .
such a high density in halo wds demands a non - standard explanation , other than that based on simple population synthesis models and/or a standard imf .
we discuss this in more detail in 7.2 .
first , however , we examine the contribution of these high - velocity wds to the non - local halo mass density , which allows us to estimate their total mass contribution to the galaxy , under some simplifying assumptions .
combining the results of sections 5 and 6 we now have a normalised halo distribution function in the form @xmath216 evaluated at the solar radius ( @xmath217 kpc ) .
what does this tell us about the total white - dwarf density throughout the halo ?
the connection is provided by the collisionless boltzmann ( or vlasov ) equation which states that the distribution function does not vary along a dynamical trajectory .
therefore , if we knew the halo potential @xmath218 as well as the local velocity distribution function , we would know the halo distribution function at radius @xmath134 and colatitude @xmath219 for all velocities that connect to the solar radius .
( we assume that the distribution functions is symmetric . )
we now make a further simplification and assume that the galactic potential , @xmath218=@xmath220 , is spherically symmetric .
specifically , we adopt eqn.([eq : potential ] ) although our results are not particularly sensitive to this choice . in making this assumption
, we are ignoring the effects of the disk matter which will retard the wds as they move to high latitude , an effect that is relatively small for the high velocity , halo stars of interest .
however , this is a bad approximation for the two disc components
. a wd on a high latitude orbit will oscillate in radius between a minimum and a maximum radius determined by energy and angular momentum conservation .
as the orbit does not close , the ap- and perigalacticons ( @xmath221 ) will eventually become arbitrarily close to the galactic disk .
therefore as we are assuming axisymmetry , ( and the orbital precession that would be present in a more realistic non - spherical potential will obviate the need for this assumption ) , we are locally sampling the halo velocity distribution at @xmath222 for halo velocities @xmath223 for which @xmath224 .
for exterior radii , the region of velocity space that is not sampled is a hyperboloid of revolution of one sheet , @xmath225 for interior radii , the excluded volume is an oblate spheroid @xmath226 two examples of exluded regions are shown in fig.9 . the connection between the solar neighborhood and the halo is effected using the constants of the motion ( e.g. may & binney 1986 ) , for which a convenient choice is the energy , squared angular momentum and the angular momentum resolved along the symmetry axis : @xmath227\nonumber\\ l_z&=&r_c(v_c+v).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this enables us to compute @xmath228 in the halo at @xmath222 , within the sampled volume of velocity space , using @xmath229 making these substitutions , we discover that the velocity distribution function in the halo at @xmath222 is also a gaussian , @xmath230\right ) \nonumber \\
\times \exp\left({-v_\phi^2 \over 2}\left[{{1-x^2 } \over { \sigma_u^2}}+ { { x^2 \sin^2\theta } \over { \sigma_v^2 } } + { { x^2 \cos^2\theta } \over { \sigma_w^2}}\right]\right ) \nonumber \\ \times \exp\left({{v_\phi(v_c - v_a)x \sin\theta } \over { \sigma_v^2 } } - { { ( v_c - v_a)^2 } \over { 2\sigma_v^2}}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath231 is the difference in the potential between the point @xmath222 in the halo and the solar neighborhood .
our particular choice for the potential gives @xmath232 , with @xmath233 .
although this choice for the potential is particularly convenient , the above vdf for the halo can be used with any spherical symmetric potential model and locally constrained schwarzschild velocity distribution function . now in order to compute the density .
we must make an assumption about the velocity distribution function within the excluded volume .
the natural assumption is that it is the same gaussian function as within the connected volume .
we emphasize that this is probably a pretty good assumption when the excluded region of velocity space is small , though quite suspect when it is not .
performing the elementary , if tedious , integrals , we obtain @xmath234^{-1/2}\nonumber\\ & \times&\left[{1-x^2\over\sigma_u^2}+{x^2\sin^2\theta\over\sigma_v^2 } + { x^2\cos^2\theta\over\sigma_w^2}\right]^{-1/2}\\ & \times&\exp\left[- { ( v_a - v_c)^2 \left[{(1-x^2 ) \over \sigma_u^2}+{x^2\cos^2\theta \over \sigma_w^2}\right ] \over { { 2\sigma_v^2 } \left [ { ( 1-x^2 ) \over
\sigma_u^2}+{x^2\sin^2\theta \over \sigma_v^2}+ { x^2\cos^2\theta \over \sigma_w^2}\right]}}\right],\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the factor @xmath235 comes from the potential , i.e. @xmath236$]=@xmath237 $ ] .
this procedure can only be self consistent for @xmath238 $ ] when @xmath239\}^{-1/2}$ ] , otherwise the computed density is unbounded .
( indeed there appears to be a physical limit on the vertical velocity dispersion of a halo population within the galactic plane . )
the density distributions of the halo and thick disc of the most likely model are plotted in fig.10 .
the halo density distribution can be seen to be roughly in the form of an oblate flattened spheroidal distribution with axis ratio , @xmath240 at the solar radius .
we expect @xmath241 is decrease slightly if a more realistic flattened potential is used , including constributions from the bulge and disc ( 7.2 ) .
if we assume that the average wd mass is @xmath242 m@xmath15 , then the mass contained within a shell 0.33@xmath243 is @xmath211.5@xmath244 m@xmath15 . the total wd mass inside 50 kpc is @xmath212.6@xmath244 m@xmath15 for our most likely model .
the radial variation of density is @xmath245 as argued on the basis of the fluid model and the mass per octave varies only slowly .
this result shows that the mass fraction of wds decreases as @xmath246 , in the particular potential that we adopted .
of course the bulge and the disk must certainly be included within @xmath247 kpc and we do not expect the circular velocity to be remain roughly constant beyond @xmath248 kpc and our model is quite primitive , relative to what could be created with a more extensive data set and a more sophisticated form for @xmath249 .
even so , if we were to believe the simple potential model , the total wd mass corresponds to @xmath210.4% of the total mass enclosed by 50 kpc , hence , we find @xmath22 , if @xmath250 ( e.g. bahcall et al . 2000 ) .
this corresponds to @xmath210.4% of the total baryon budget in the universe .
clearly the halo wds are dynamically unimportant .
a halo mass of @xmath212.6@xmath244 m@xmath15 in wds corresponds to @xmath2514.3@xmath252 wds in total .
the expected luminosity of this population in @xmath68-band is @xmath253 where @xmath254 is the average absolute @xmath68-band magnitude of the sample of wds . if we take @xmath255 from the sample of observed wds by oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) , this reduces to @xmath256 .
similarly , if the luminosity of halo stars is @xmath257 l@xmath15 ( bm98 ; conveniently assuming solar colors for the halo stars ) and @xmath258=4.3 , one finds @xmath259 .
if these values are typical for l@xmath260 galaxies , then the integrated luminosity of halo wds in @xmath68-band will be @xmath215 mag fainter that that of halo stars , both of which are of course significantly fainter than the stellar disc .
we conclude that it will be exceedingly difficult to observed such a faint halo around external galaxies .
this is made even harder , because this emission is spread over a much larger solid angle on the sky than for example the stellar disc .
we now turn the crucial question : if the density of halo wds is as high as the observations , taken at face value , and our subsequent calculations indicate , where did all these wds come from ?
the apparent similarity in magnitude , color and age between the high - velocity halo and low - velocity thick - disc wds ( fig.1 ; hansen 2001 ) , suggests that the halo wds originate in the disc and are subsequently ejected into the halo , through a process yet unknown to us .
their disc - origin is supported by the low density of halo stars ( e.g. gould et al .
if halo stars and wds come from the same ( halo ) population , there should be significantly more stars than wds in the halo for any reasonable imf .
one possibility is that binary or triple star interactions eject stars into the halo with high velocities ( socalled runaway stars ) , although not preferentially wds .
alternatively , it is possible that a large population of wds were born in globular clusters on radial orbits or satellite galaxies that have been destroyed by tidal forces over the past 10 gyr , through which most of their stars end up in the bulge .
both scenarios are speculative and also do not satisfactory explain why the ratio of wds to stars is so high in the halo .
we propose another possible mechanism , in which most of the high - velocity wds orginate from unstable triple stellar systems .
observations indicate that a high fraction ( @xmath2130% ) of binary stars in the solar neighborhood have a companion and are in fact triples ( e.g. petri & batten 1965 ; batten 1967 ) .
if for example the third outer - orbit star , or one of the binary stars , evolves into a wd or goes supernova , or if matter can flow between the different stars ( e.g. through roche - lobe overflows and/or stellar winds ) an initially stable system can change its ratio of orbital periods and at some point become unstable , if the ratio of orbital periods ( @xmath261 , the ratio of the largest over smallest orbital period ) exceeds a critical value ( e.g. anosova & orlov 1989 ; kiseleva , eggleton , & anosova 1994 ; anosova , colin , & kiseleva 1996 ) that depends on the mass ratio of the outer star and the inner binary .
the outer - orbit star , often an evolved star itself , can then be ejected from the triple system with a high spatial velocity ( e.g worrall 1967 ) , giving the inner compact binary system a `` kick '' in opposite direction , with a typical velocity observed for compact binaries in the disc ( e.g. iben & tutukov 1999 ) and comparable to the orbital velocity of the compact binary .
a second possibility is that the most massive star of the inner binary evolves into a wd , without the binary merging ( iben & tutukov 1999 ) , changing the orbital period and making the system unstable .
also in this case the wd can be ejected , leaving behind a recoiled binary .
besides explaining why even young wds ( few gyr ) are observed with high velocities , a consequence of such a mechanism is that the total mass in high - velocity wds ( e.g. those in the halo ) , must be related to the integrated stellar mass in our galaxy and the fraction of the stellar imf in unstable multiple ( e.g. triple ) systems .
the estimated stellar mass in our galaxy is roughly @xmath262 m@xmath15 ( bt87 ) .
if @xmath2115% of the stellar mass equals the total galactic wd mass , based on simple population synthesis models ( 6.1 ) , the inferred galactic wd mass should be @xmath263 m@xmath15 . in
6.1 , we estimated from observations that the local wd mass fraction was only @xmath215% , which then corresponds to @xmath264 m@xmath15 if this fraction holds throughout the disc .
we estimated @xmath265 m@xmath15 for the mass in halo wds ( sect.7 ) , which then adds to a total wd mass of @xmath266 m@xmath15 .
there are , however , a number of difficulties associated with the process described above .
first , it implies that one out of every two wds must be ejected from the disc , with an average rate of one wd every @xmath214 years , for an assumed galactic age of @xmath25 gyr .
second , it is not known what the birth rate and orbital parameters of triple ( or higher - order ) systems are .
in particular , a large fraction of stellar systems could be intrisically unstable when they form .
such systems have been observed ( e.g. ressler & barsony 2001 ) , although their ultimate fate is unknown .
the instability of triple systems is particularly evident when comparing their orbital periods ( e.g. tokovinin 1997 ; iben & tutkov 1999 ) , which shows a complete absence of triple systems with @xmath267 ( i.e. the lowest theoretical limit for stability ; e.g. kiseleva 1994 ) , whereas there is no a priori reason to suspect that systems with these orbital period ratios are not formed .
a more typical ratio @xmath261 where systems becomes unstable is @xmath214 .
examining the distribution of @xmath268 in more detail reveals some clustering of triple stellar systems close to the stability limit for larger orbital periods ( tokovinin 1997 ; iben & tutukov 1999 ) , although it is not clear whether that could be a selection effect . for the lower period systems this clustering is
not the case .
third , because evolving triple stars have not been studied in as much detail as binaries , for example , the velocity of the ejected wds is not well known in these processes , although it can be estimated from analytical models and numerical simulations . as a rough rule of thumb
, stable triple systems can be separated into a close binary ( masses @xmath269 and @xmath270 ) and a more distant companion ( mass @xmath271 ) with period ratio exceeding @xmath272 ( see above ) .
let us consider two options .
firstly , suppose that @xmath269 is the most massive star and that it evolves to fill its roche lobe and transfer mass , conservatively , onto @xmath270 .
this will initially shrink the orbit and increase the period ratio until @xmath273 when the separation is @xmath274 .
further mass transfer will then lead to an increase of the close binary orbit and a reduction of the period ratio @xmath275 . as the close binary orbit expands , the proto
wd speed @xmath276 will initially increase @xmath277 and then decrease .
for example , with @xmath278 m@xmath15 , @xmath279 m@xmath15 initially the close binary period could decrease by a factor @xmath247 by the time @xmath280 m@xmath15 and , provided that the companion s orbital radius @xmath281 , the orbit can become unstable at this point . if @xmath269 is ejected by a slingshot effect involving @xmath271 , then a characteristic velocity at infinity is @xmath282 .
higher speeds are possible with favorable orbits , especially retrograde companion orbits .
secondly , suppose that @xmath283 .
the mass transfer is less likely to be conservative although there is likely to be a net loss of orbital angular momentum associated with the loss of mass .
the net result is that the outer binary orbit will initially shrink , again promoting instability .
general analytical and numerical analyses of triple - star systems , randomly placed in a spherical volume , show that most ( @xmath5280% ) systems are unstable and typically eject the lowest mass star with a median velocity comparable to their orbital velocity ( e.g. standish 1972 ; monaghan 1976a , b ; sterzik & durisen 1998 ) , as also indicated above .
a more detailed analysis by sterzik & durisen ( 1998 ) , where the ejection velocity distribution is weighted by the stellar mass function , shows that @xmath2110 percent of the ejected stars ( e.g. wds ) have velocities @xmath523 times the typical orbital velocity .
given their stellar mass function , the typical mass of an evolved triple - star systems is then @xmath215 m@xmath15 . as we saw previously ,
if the orbital radius is of the order of the stellar radius ( i.e. orbital periods of several days ) , escape velocities of several hundred kms@xmath5can be reached . for orbital periods of several hundred days ( e.g. tokovinin 1997 )
, the typical orbital velocity will still be @xmath2180 kms@xmath5 .
wds have to gain a velocity of @xmath21100150 kms@xmath5 ( in addition to their orbital velocity and velocity with respect to their lsr ) to atain velocities comparable to the observed high - velocity wds .
hence , the proposed mechanism quite easily reaches the required velocities . even in those systems with longer orbital periods ( @xmath211000 days )
, several tens of percent of the escaping stars will atain very high velocities ( e.g. sterzik & durisen 1998 ) .
additional support for the notion that these processes might be quite common , could be the good agreement which valtonen ( 1998 ) recently found between the observed mass ratio of binaries and that determined from a statistical theory of three - body disruption ( monaghan 1976a , b ) .
this might indicate that many stars are born in triple or higher - order systems , which become unstable and eject stars until only a stable binary is left . in order to explore this hypothesis
further , we have constructed a relatively simple model of the galaxy as follows ; we suppose that the mass comprises a spherical halo @xmath284 with @xmath285 kpc , which generates a logarithmic potential , and a disc @xmath286 with @xmath287 kpc and a bulge , which we for simplicity flatten onto the galactic plane , @xmath288 with @xmath289 kpc .
the combination of these potentials gives a nearly flat rotation curve beyond several kpc ( e.g. dehnen & binney 1998a ) , with circular velocity @xmath290 kms@xmath5 .
as the potential is no longer spherically symmetric , the total angular momentum is not an integral of motion . given this model of the galaxy , it is then a straighforward matter to follow the trajectories of observed wds back in . in order to measure the contemporary wd source velocity distribution ( per unit disk mass , per unit time , per unit speed ) , which we denote by @xmath291
, we must make some assumptions . to keep matters simple ,
we suppose that @xmath291 is independent of radius and decreases with lookback time , @xmath292 $ ] , where @xmath293 as indicated by the data exhibited in fig . 1 .
as individual orbits quickly sample a large range of disk radii it is not easy to derive the radial launch rate from the local wd distribution function .
the best approach utilizing the present data set is to fit the halo distribution function from table . 1
. we use again jeans theorem to relate the observed vdf @xmath294 to that at the source .
adopt one point in local velocity space and relate to @xmath291 through @xmath295,\ ] ] where the sum takes account of @xmath296 disk crossings along the orbit .
the weights @xmath297 are given by @xmath298}{4\pi v_j^2v_{jz}}\ ] ] and @xmath299 , @xmath300 and @xmath301 are evaluated at the j - th disk crossing .
we next discretize @xmath302 using 50 kms@xmath5 bins and develop a least squares solution to eq.(22 ) @xmath303 where we sample the distribution function at n random points .
the result indicates that the mean speed of the wd at launch is very high , @xmath304=250300 km s@xmath5 , with a birth rate of @xmath2110@xmath305 ( m@xmath15 kms@xmath5 gyr)@xmath5 at these velocities , consistent with @xmath2110% of the stellar mass in the galactic disc having been transformed in wds .
the low rotational velocity of the observed wds requires them to originate in the inner 23 kpc of the galactic disk , so they loose most of their rotational velocity when climbing out of the galactic potential to the solar neighborhood .
the latter result is not unexpected , because most stellar mass ( @xmath2175% for a disk scale length of @xmath3063 kpc ) lies inside the solar radius and in addition @xmath307 peaks at @xmath308 .
hence a typical wd is expected to originate in the disc at @xmath309 kpc .
these calculations are consistent with , though do not require , that the wds are a product of stellar evolution in the disk .
three lines of evidence support this conclusion .
( i ) the age distribution is just about what would be expected from a population of main sequence stars with a reasonable mass function from @xmath210.8 m@xmath15 to @xmath216 m@xmath15 .
the stars are born at a rate consistent with stellar evolution .
the most populous stars are of mass @xmath310 m@xmath15 and take @xmath311 gyr to evolve .
even if the galaxy is @xmath312 gyr old , we do not expect a large proportion of stars with ages @xmath313 gyr .
a more careful , galactic synthesis model is consistent with these statements .
( ii ) the velocities are isotropic with no discernible asymmetric drift .
this is just what would be expected from a disk population that launches wds in random directions .
the median speed observed is @xmath21200300 km s@xmath5 .
( iii ) the radial variation of white - dwarf sources appears to fall with radius in a similar fashion to the the stellar distribution .
of course , the situation is far more complex than this .
however , the similarities between the characteristic escape speed and the halo velocity dispersion , together with the shortage of viable alternatives makes this a scenario that is worth investigating further .
but it should again be emphasized that a much larger sample of halo wds is needed to place the above simple estimates on a more firm basis .
the next question to ask is whether the population of wds in the halo can explain the observed microlensing events towards the large magellanic cloud , with optical depth @xmath314 ( alcock et al .
2000 ) . using the local density and the global density profile of the population of wds in the halo , derived in the previous sections ,
it is possible to integrate over the density profile along the line - of - sight toward to lmc ( @xmath315 , @xmath316 and @xmath317 kpc ) and obtain the optical depth for any arbitrary set of parameters for the local vdf . for the most likely model , listed in table 1 ( full data set ) , we compute a microlensing optical depth of the halo wds , @xmath318 .
the optical depth of the thick disc is @xmath319 .
hence , even in the most optimistic case , the integrated thick - disc plus halo wds have an optical depth that is still 12 orders of magnitude below that observed .
this difference can not be made up by a , most likely small , incompleteness of high - velocity wds .
if we scale the results in section 6 and 7 to the lmc itself , assuming ( i ) a similar shape of the velocity ellipsoid , ( ii ) velocities that scale with a factor @xmath320 ( @xmath321 kms@xmath5 ; e.g. alves & nelson 2000 ) and distances that scale as @xmath322=constant , and ( iii ) the ratio of total wd mass to stellar mass in the lmc is similar to that inferred in our galaxy ( @xmath219% from @xmath323 m@xmath15 ; e.g. alves & nelson 2000 ) , we find a self - lensing microlensing optical depth for the center of the lmc of @xmath324 , lower than the results from the macho collaboration ( alcock et al .
we find that the results are quite sensitive to the assumped parameters , especially the velocity dispersion .
the wd density is @xmath325 and gets unbounded if the velocity dispersion is lower somewhat .
this illustrates that a `` shroud '' of white dwarfs around the lmc ( e.g. evans & kerins 2000 ) , in principle , could account for the observed optical depth , although it does require that 50% of the halo wd mass is concentrated in the inner 0.7 kpc and rather fine - tuned model parameters .
the latter could be overcome if the mass profile of the lmc has a finite core .
a similarly rough scaling for the edge - on spiral gravitational lens b1600 + 434 where we assume 4 times more mass in wds than in b1600 + 434 suggests @xmath326 along the line - of - sight towards lensed image a , at 6 kpc above the galaxy plane .
this optical depth appears insufficient to explain the apparent radio - microlensing events in this system ( e.g. koopmans & de bruyn 2000 ; koopmans et al . 2001 ) .
we stress the large uncertainties associated with these extrapolated calculations .
as we have discussed , the main reason why it is hard to determine the halo density of the observed wd is that the sample surrounds the sgp and that we have poor resolution of the vertical velocity @xmath43 . in order to choose between various possible local distribution functions , it is necessary to repeat the survey at lower galactic latitude .
we discuss two potential surveys for the near future that allow a rigorous test of some of these underlying assumptions . in fig.11 , we show the probability distribution of proper motions , seen in the direction of the galactic anti - center ( @xmath327 and @xmath328 ) . for simplicity
we adopt the same survey limits as used by oppenheimer et al ( 2001 ) and a standard - candle wd with an average absolute magnitude @xmath329 .
the latter translates into a maximum survey depth of @xmath21125 pc .
we used our most - likely model in the calculation .
if a wd survey in this particular direction shows a proper - motion distribution similar to that in fig.11 , it would be strong support to the notion that the wds with high velocities in the @xmath45 plane also have high velocities in the @xmath43direction and therefore form a genuine halo population .
a significantly flattened proper - motion distribution would support a thick - disc interpretation of the sample found by oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) , but requires a rather artificial vdf . a new opportunity to measure wd proper motions
is presented by the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) .
it is likely that it will be proper - motion limited , rather than magnitude limited .
scaling from the astrometry carried out by ibata et al .
( 1999 ) on the hdf , and requiring that the transverse velocities be measured to an accuracy @xmath2130 kms@xmath5 , we estimate that a `` wide '' survey to a depth @xmath211.2 mag shallower than the hdf(n ) could be carried out to a limit @xmath330 over @xmath331 ster rad ( @xmath210.3 square degree ) and a `` deep '' survey could reach @xmath332 to a depth @xmath333 mag deeper than the hdf(n ) over @xmath334 ster rad ( @xmath21120 square arcmin ) .
the expected number of halo wds in these fields is @xmath335 where @xmath336 measures the distance along the line of sight . evaluating this integral for the direction of the hdf(n )
, we find that @xmath337 for the wide survey and @xmath338 for the deep survey .
evaluating the luminosity for the high - velocity wds , we find that the number density per magnitude is roughly constant in the range 13@xmath27@xmath339@xmath2716 mag .
this gives us @xmath340 the wide survey will typically observe to a distance of @xmath210.5 kpc , whereas the deep survey should see to @xmath211 kpc .
the expected number in the existing wfpc2 observations of the hdf(n ) is @xmath210.1 and the negative report of richer ( 2001 ) is not surprising .
of course , these calculations are only illustrative .
more wds are expected to be found associated with the thick disc and would be seen along lines of sight that look closer to the inner galaxy .
however , it is clear that if we can measure the white - dwarf colors and proper motions over a few directions , then we can use the distribution function approach , outlined above , to measure the wd density throughout a major portion of the halo .
we have analysed the results of oppenheimer et al . ( 2001 ) and argued that there appear to be at least two kinematically distinct populations of wds ( at the @xmath9699% c.l . ) , which one might term a thick disc and a flattened halo population , respectively .
in contrast , these populations are indistinguishable in their luminosity , color and age distribution .
our most likely model indicates that the halo wds constitute @xmath210.8 percent of the nominal local halo density , although this fraction decreases as @xmath341@xmath342 with increasing galacto - centric radius @xmath343 , for an assumed galactic density profile @xmath344 . a more conservative lower limit of 0.3 percent ( 90% c.l .
) can be placed on the local halo mass fraction in wds .
this wd density is 5.0@xmath345 ( 90% c.l . ) times higher than previously thought and comparable to the local stellar halo density ( gould et al .
this is in conflict with the estimates of wd densities , based on population synthesis models and salpeter initial mass functions , and requires a non - standard explanation if one requires these wds to be formed in the halo .
based on the notion that 90% of the wds , found by oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) , are proper - motion limited ( sect.6 ) , we do not expect the white - dwarf luminosity function to rise sharply beyond the survey magnitude limit ( i.e. wds with ages @xmath9610 gyr ) , although a distinct very faint population of wds with ages @xmath34610 gyr , which are not related to the presently observed population , can not be excluded .
we find that the halo wd population is flattened ( @xmath347 ) , and expect @xmath241 to become somewhat smaller once a more realistic flattened potential of the disk , bulge and halo is used in the models .
the value for @xmath241 that we quote should be regarded as an upper limit .
the microlensing optical depth inferred from the halo wd population is estimated at @xmath348 . even if we include the contribution from the thick disk , the optical depth remains @xmath555% of that observed toward the lmc ( @xmath349 ; alcock et al .
we conclude that the population of halo wds , observed by oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) and on orbits that are probed by the velocity distribution function in the solar neighborhood , do not contribute significantly to the observed microlensing events toward the lmc .
one avoids this , if either @xmath2125 times more wds are on orbits with perigalacticons well outside the solar neighborhood ( for example a mass shell ) or on resonant orbits .
both types of orbits could be undersampled locally . similarly , as mentioned above , if there exists yet another population of very faint old ( @xmath2115 gyr ) wds in the halo , they could also increase the number of microlensing events towards the lmc .
however , we regard both solutions as unlikely and artificial . in addition
, both solutions would violate constraints from metal abundances ( see sect.1 ) and ( simple ) population synthesis models .
in sect.8 , we showed that a similar `` shroud '' of white dwarfs around the lmc itself , in principle , can account for the observed optical depth , although the result is strongly model dependent .
we have performed a number of consistency checks of the data .
for example , we find excellent agreement between the maximum - likelihood value of the asymmetric drift , the statistical value and the value inferred from other stellar population in the solar neighborhood .
there is also no evidence for either a drift of the wd population in the @xmath41 or @xmath43 direction , which could have indicated that the population was not in dynamic equilibrium or could be part of a stellar stream or group . in both cases
our approach , based on the collisionless boltzmann ( or vlasov ) equation , would have been invalid .
in addition , the thick - disc likelihood results agree well with the empirical relation between the asymmetric drift ( @xmath166 ) and the radial velocity dispersion ( @xmath125 ) , determined from a range of local stellar populations .
we also find that the asymmetric drift of the halo population is close to that ( i.e. @xmath350 ) expected for a population that is mostly pressure supported ( i.e. @xmath351 ) .
if we assume that @xmath125=@xmath126 for the wd population , the likelihood decreases by a factor @xmath352 and the thick - disc result no longer agree with the empiral relation .
a flattened velocity ellipsoid ( @xmath125@xmath27@xmath126 ) naturally explains the relative scarcity of wds in the regions around @xmath50 kms@xmath5 and @xmath167 kms@xmath5 , noticed by reid et al .
( 2001 ) .
the absence of any clear correlations of velocity with color , absolute magnitude or age , and the dynamical self - consistency checks give us confidence that the population of wds found by oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) does not contain a significantly hidden bias .
especially , the fact that the survey is 90% proper - motion limited , not magnitude - limited , underlines that we do not miss many wds that are too faint ( but see the comments above ) .
the range of luminosities should thus provide a reasonable representation of the underlying luminosity function of this particular population of halo wds .
these internal and external consistency checks should make our results quite robust .
however , there are uncertainties associated with errors in the photometric parallaxes which feed into both the densities and velocities . in addition
, several of the wds in this sample might belong to binaries , although an inspection of the two - color diagram ( fig.1 ) suggests that also this is unlikely to be a major problem .
only a systematic overestimate of distances by a factor @xmath522.5 would move most high - velocity wds into the thick - disc regime , but would also result in a typical velocity dispersion of the sample only half that of the thick disc and average wd luminosities that are too small .
the absence of apparent correlations with the wd velocities , makes it unlikely that distance overestimates would preferentially occur for the highest velocity wds .
another way out of the conclusion that there exists a significant population of halo wds , would be to accept that the velocity ellipsoid of these high proper - motion wds is significantly flattened in the vertical direction .
although , this would be consistent with the observations , as we indicated in sect.5 , it would require a highly unusual vdf , unlike what is observed for both young and old stellar populations in the solar neighborhood .
we have also provided further evidence that the fast and slow wds come from the same population .
this would not be a surprise if they were mostly born in the disk and then deflected dynamically to high altitude .
we have proposed a possible mechanism that could preferentially eject wds from the disc , involving orbital instabilities in evolving multiple ( e.g. triple ) stellar systems ( 7.2 ) .
we showed that the total halo plus disc wd mass of the galaxy ( i.e. @xmath2115% of its stellar mass ) is roughly consistent with that expected from the total stellar mass in our galaxy , based on standard population synthesis models .
the agreement suggests that not a re - thinking of galactic starformation models is required , but that the real question is how to eject disc wds into the halo with high velocities .
we propose that this can be achieved through the orbital instabilities in evolving multiple stellar systems .
the key to understanding the wd distribution with more confidence is undoubtedly to measure the component of velocity perpendicular to the galactic disk and this is best accomplished with a proper motion survey at lower latitude .
we have suggested two possible surveys for the near future : one towards to galactic anti - center , similar to the survey discussed in this paper , and one that could be done with the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) on hst .
the first survey could unambiguously show that the velocity dispersion perpendicular to the disc is comparable to that parallel to the disc . measuring the density of wds as a function of galacto - centric radius ( for example with the acs ) , together with a local wd density calibration , can provide strong constraints on the shape of the galactic potential , as is apparent from eqns ( 17 ) and ( 18 ) in sect.7 .
these constraints improve dramatically if we can also constrain the vdf at the same points in the halo .
this is especially relevant in case of the halo wds , even though they are faint , because their high velocity dispersion allows one to probe large ( tens of kpc ) galacto - centric distances and still be in dynamic contact with the solar neighborhood .
the relation between the vdfs at different radii is then given through the integrals of motion that are conserved along orbits between these points and the galactic potential .
measuring the density and vdfs along these orbits can then , in principle , be used to reconstruct the galactic potential .
it is also surprising that the scale height of wds , kinematically belonging to the thin disc , appears at least twice that previously thought ( majewski & siegel 2001 ) .
could this population form a bridge to a flattened white - dwarf halo population ? we conclude that the discovery of a surprisingly large population of high velocity , old wds , made possible by advances in understanding their atmospheres and colors , is a significant accomplishment and seems to opens up a new unexpected window into the stellar archaeology of our galaxy . however , to confirm or reject the ideas put forward by oppenheimer et al .
( 2001 ) and in this paper a significantly large sample is required , not only out of the galactic plance , but also in the galactic plane .
in addition deeper surveys ( e.g. with the acs ) could probe much farther into the halo and possibly even detect wds that are significantly fainter .
deeper surveys would also be able to probe the transition between thick - disc and halo and be less ` contaminted ' by disc wds .
the authors thank ben oppenheimer for many valuable discussions and providing tables with their results prior to publication .
lvek thanks dave chernoff for several discussions .
the authors are indebted to david graff and andy gould for bringing our attention to a mistake in the normalisation of the likelihood function .
this research has been supported by nsf ast9900866 and stsci go06543.0395a .
koopmans , l. v. e. , de bruyn , a. g. , wambsganss , j. , fassnacht , c. d. , to appear in microlensing 2000 : a new era of microlensing astrophysics , eds j.w . menzies and p.d .
sackett , asp conference series , 2001 , preprint astro - ph/0004285 | we analyse the kinematics of the entire spectroscopic sample of 99 recently discovered high proper - motion white dwarfs by oppenheimer et al . using a maximum - likelihood analysis , and
discuss the claim that the high - velocity white dwarfs are members of a halo population with a local density at least ten times greater than traditionally assumed .
we argue that the observations , as reported , are consistent with the presence of an almost undetected thin disc plus a thick disc , with densities as conventionally assumed .
in addition , there is a kinematically distinct , flattened , halo population at the more than 99% confidence level .
surprisingly , the thick disc and halo populations are indistinguishable in terms of luminosity , color and apparent age ( 110 gyr ) . adopting a bimodal , schwarzschild model for the local velocity ellipsoid , with the ratios @xmath0:@xmath1:@xmath2=1:2/3:1/2 ,
we infer radial velocity dispersions of @xmath3=62@xmath4 kms@xmath5 and 150@xmath6 kms@xmath5 ( 90% c.l . ) for the local thick disc and halo populations , respectively .
the thick disc result agrees with the empirical relation between asymmetric drift and radial velocity dispersion , inferred from local stellar populations .
the local thick - disc plus halo density of white dwarfs is @xmath7=@xmath8@xmath9 pc@xmath10 ( 90% c.l . ) , of which @xmath11=1.1@xmath12@xmath13@xmath14 pc@xmath10 ( 90% c.l . ) belongs to the halo , a density about five times higher than previously thought . adopting a mean white - dwarf mass of 0.6 m@xmath15 , the latter amounts to 0.8@xmath16@xmath1310@xmath17 ( 90% c.l . ) of the nominal local halo density . assuming a simple spherical logarithmic potential for the galaxy , we infer from our most - likely model an oblate halo white - dwarf density profile with @xmath18 and @xmath19 .
the halo white dwarfs contributes @xmath20
m@xmath15 , i.e. a mass fraction of @xmath210.004 , to the total mass inside 50 kpc ( @xmath22 ) .
the halo white dwarf population has a microlensing optical depth towards the lmc of @xmath23 .
the thick - disc white dwarf population gives @xmath24 .
the integrated galactic optical depth from both populations is 12 orders of magnitude below the inferred microlensing optical depth toward the lmc .
if a similar white - dwarf population is present around the lmc , then self - lensing can not be excluced as explanation of the macho observations .
we propose a mechanism that could preferentially eject disc white dwarfs into the halo with the required speeds of @xmath21200 kms@xmath5 , through the orbital instability of evolving triple star systems .
prospects for measuring the density and velocity distribution of the halo population more accurately using the _ hubble space telescope _
advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) appear to be good .
stars : white dwarfs galaxy : halo stellar content structure gravitational lensing
dark matter |
the southern ara ob1 association shows evidence of recent star formation that may have been triggered by a supernova event ( herbst & havlen 1977 , hereafter hh77 ; arnal et al .
the remarkable young stellar cluster ngc 6193 lies near the center of ara ob1 and was first studied optically by whiteoak ( 1963 ) .
a more comprehensive optical study was undertaken by hh77 who determined the foreground reddening and derived a distance of 1.32 @xmath10 0.12 kpc .
they identified the higher mass o , b , and a star cluster members , but lower mass members have not yet been isolated .
the cluster is undoubtedly young with age estimates in the range @xmath111.5 - 3.1 myr ( moffat & vogt 1973 , hh77 , vzquez & feinstein 1992 ) .
the central part of the cluster is dominated by two luminous o - type stars hd 150135 and hd 150136 , separated by only @xmath810@xmath3 .
the optical properties of these two o stars are very similar , as summarized in table 1 .
their intense ionizing radiation may be influencing star - formation in the nearby rcw 108 molecular cloud ( comern et al . 2005 ) .
hd 150136 is unusual in several respects .
it is a massive spectroscopic binary ( sb2 ) consisting of two o stars in a close 2.662 day orbit and has recently been classified as o3 @xmath2 o6v ( niemela & gamen 2005 , hereafter ng05 ) .
the luminosity class of the primary is not well - determined . for typical o star masses ,
the short 2.662 day period implies a separation of just a few stellar radii . at this close separation
, wind - wind interaction is expected .
in addition , hd 150136 is a strong centimeter radio source , and most of its radio flux is nonthermal ( benaglia et al . 2001 ) . a fainter object ( v = 9.0 mag ) is visible @xmath81.6@xmath3 north of hd 150136 ( mason et al .
1998 ) , and we show here that this source is also visible in the near - infrared ( sec .
3.3 ) . by comparison , hd 150135 is slightly fainter than hd 150136 in the optical and radio .
its binary status is uncertain , but it has been classified as a possible spectroscopic binary ( garmany et al .
1980 ; arnal et al . 1988 ) .
although ngc 6193 has been studied optically , there are no previous pointed x - ray observations .
however , a bright x - ray source was detected near the position of hd 150136 (= hr 6187 ) in the _ rosat _ all sky survey ( rass ) .
this x - ray source was identified with hd 150136 by berghfer et al .
( 1996 ) who obtained a luminosity in the 0.1 - 2.4 kev band of log l@xmath12 ( ergs s@xmath5 ) = 33.05 , making it the most luminous o star detected in the rass .
this bright source was also serendipitously detected in a 8460 s _ rosat _ pspc exposure ( image rp900554n00 ) at a @xmath820@xmath0 off - axis position with a count rate of 0.36 c s@xmath5 , which is 40% less than reported from the rass detection .
the presence of a luminous ( and possibly variable ) x - ray source in the _ rosat _ images at or near the hd 150136 position motivated us to undertake a more detailed x - ray study of the ngc 6193 cluster core with the _ chandra _ x - ray observatory ( cxo ) .
our primary objectives were to use _
chandra s _ high angular resolution to determine the precise origin of the bright x - ray emission detected by _
rosat _ and to acquire a grating spectrum capable of identifying the x - ray emission process .
in addition , the sensitive ( 90 ksec ) _ chandra _ observation provides the first high - quality x - ray image of the region immediately surrounding the central o stars hd 150135 and hd 150136 , allowing us to catalog the x - ray emitting population in the cluster core .
_ chandra _ resolves the bright central x - ray source into two components corresponding to separate but unequal contributions from hd 150135 and hd 150136 .
thus , the luminous x - ray source detected by _
rosat _ is found to be the superimposed contribution of the two bright o stars lying 10@xmath3 apart .
interestingly , the long _ chandra _ exposure shows that the emission of hd 150136 is slowly variable on a timescale of @xmath91 day .
grating x - ray spectra of hd 150135 and 150136 are similar ( but not identical ) and soft emission is prevalent in both stars , implying a wind shock origin .
we identify 43 x - ray sources in the central @xmath82@xmath0 @xmath1 2@xmath0 region of the cluster .
all of these have near - ir counterparts and about one - third show x - ray variability , thus being viable candidates for low - mass cluster members .
the _ chandra _ observation of ngc 6193 began on 27 june 2002 at 05:20 ut and ended on 28 june at 07:12 ut , yielding an exposure live time of 90,337 seconds .
the high energy transmission grating ( hetg ) was used along with the acis - s ccd detector in faint - timed telemetry mode .
the nominal pointing position was ( j2000.0 ) ra = 16@xmath13 41@xmath14 18.89@xmath15 , decl .
= @xmath1648@xmath17 45@xmath0 39.3@xmath3 , which is 16.7@xmath3 northwest of hd 150136 .
further information on _ chandra _ and its instruments can be found in weisskopf et al .
( 2002 ) .
data reduction used standard data processing ( `` pipeline '' ) products and ciao processing scripts supplied by the _
chandra _ x - ray center .
data were reduced using ciao vers .
3.0.2 and calibration data caldb vers .
our post - pipeline processing included steps to make use of observation - specific bad pixel files , removal of faint point sources in the regions used to extract grating spectra , destreaking of the acis - s4 ccd , and energy filtering to reduce the effects of low and high - energy background .
x - ray source detection was accomplished using the ciao wavelet - based tool @xmath18 applied to full - resolution images ( 0.49@xmath3 @xmath1 0.49@xmath3 pixels ) .
the images were first energy - filtered to include only photons in the [ 0.5 - 7.0 ] kev energy range , which reduces both soft and hard background emission .
we ran @xmath18 using pixel scales of 1,2,4,8 , and 16 pixels , and compared results for various values of the input parameter @xmath19 , which determines the false alarm probability .
images were visually inspected for missed or spurious detections , and we found that @xmath19 = 1.5 @xmath1 10@xmath20 produced good results . at this value
, only one spurious detection is expected in the 2.1@xmath0 @xmath1 2.1@xmath0 ( 256 @xmath1 256 pixels ) core region analyzed here ( fig .
the unabsorbed x - ray luminosity detection limit corresponding to a 6 count on - axis detection in the 0th order acis - s image is log l@xmath4 ( 0.5 - 7 kev ) = 29.99 ( ergs s@xmath5 ) at the cluster distance of 1.3 kpc .
this value was determined from the portable interactive mult - mission simulator ( _ pimms _ ) , assuming an isothermal raymond - smith plasma with a characteristic temperature kt = 2 kev and absoprtion column density n@xmath21 = 4 @xmath1 10@xmath22 @xmath23 .
these spectral parameters are typical of x - ray sources in the region ( sec .
a total of 43 x - ray sources were detected in the core region ( table 2 ; figure 1 ) .
event lists were extracted for each source using the elliptical source regions output by @xmath18 .
the energy - filtered event lists were then used for further statistical analysis of source properties ( sec .
background - subtracted first order grating spectra from the medium energy gratings ( meg ) and high energy gratings ( heg ) were extracted for hd 150135 and hd 150136 using standard ciao threads .
the roll angle of the observation was favorable and provided adequate separation of the grating arms of hd 150135 and hd 150136 on the acis - s detector .
however , we used a slightly narrower mask than the default value to extract the grating spectra of each star in order to avoid any possible cross - contamination .
the ciao tool _ psextract _ was used to extract zeroth order spectra of selected bright sources ( including hd 150135 and hd 150136 ) along with background spectra from adjacent source - free regions .
we used the 2mass all - sky data release to identify near - ir counterparts to x - ray sources in the central cluster region ( table 2 ) .
a few x - ray sources lacked 2mass counterparts but these were identified using more sensitive near - ir images obtained with the 1.6 m perkin - elmer telescope at the observatrio do pico dos dias , laboratrio nacional de astrofsica , brazil ( fig .
the observations were acquired on 23 july 2002 under photometric conditions ( @xmath90.7@xmath3 seeing ) with the camiv near - ir camera .
the camera uses a 1024@xmath11024 pixels hawaii hgcdte detector with 0.24@xmath3 pixels , providing a 4@xmath0@xmath14@xmath0 field - of - view .
the central region of ngc 6193 was imaged in j , h , and a narrow filter with a central wavelength @xmath24=2.14 @xmath25 m ( @xmath26=0.018 @xmath25 m ) . flux calibration was achieved by observing near - infrared standard stars from persson et al .
the data were processed in the _ iraf _ environment and the images were linearized , dark frame subtracted , flat - fielded , sky subtracted , and corrected for bad pixels .
final images were constructed by co - adding twelve exposures of 5 seconds each . limiting magnitudes of the final images were j = 19.5 , h = 17.9 , and 14.35 at 2.14 @xmath25 m .
we present here the main observational results including images , light curves and spectra .
figure 1 shows the _ chandra _ acis - s 0th order image of the central 2.1@xmath0 @xmath1 2.1@xmath0 region of ngc 6193 centered on the optically bright o stars hd 150135 and hd 150136 .
although the 0th order image covers a larger region , we restrict our analysis here to the central 2.1@xmath0 @xmath1 2.1@xmath0 core where the _ chandra _ point - spread function is sharpest ( thus providing reliable source identification ) and where the probability of cluster membership is high .
_ chandra _ clearly detects both o stars .
furthermore , their emission is well - separated at _
chandra s _ high angular resolution and they are the two brightest x - ray sources in the field .
@xmath27 detected 42 x - ray sources in this central region , and one additional source ( no .
26b ) was found by visual inspection .
table 2 summarizes the properties of these 43 sources along with their ir / optical identifications .
near - ir counterparts were found for all 43 x - ray sources .
the two faintest sources recovered by @xmath18 have 4 counts each ( sources 8 and 16 ) , and are classified as possible detections .
however , both have near - ir counterparts and the x - ray detections are likely real .
a search of the _ hst _ guide star catalog ( gsc ) and usno b1.0 catalogs revealed optical counterparts within 1@xmath3 of the x - ray positions for 11 sources .
four of the gsc counterparts are classified as non - stellar .
included among the stellar identifications are hd 150135 , hd 150136 , cd@xmath1648 11069 ( b0 - 1 ) , cd@xmath1648 11071 ( b0v ) , and the v = 12.3 mag star ngc 6193 - 9 . to obtain a quantitative measurement of variability , we computed the k - s statistic from the unbinned energy - filtered event list of each source .
further information on the k - s statistic can be found in press et al .
fourteen sources were found to be variable ( table 2 ) , based on the criterion that they have a probability of constant count rate p@xmath28 @xmath29 0.05 .
two of the four ob stars are variable .
these are hd 150136 ( p@xmath28 = 1.4 @xmath1 10@xmath30 ) and cd@xmath1648 11069 ( p@xmath28 = 0.02 ) .
a moderate x - ray flare was detected in source no .
25 , which has a k = 11.4 mag 2mass counterpart .
since short - term ( @xmath111 day ) variability is rarely detected in extragalactic agns , it is likely that that most of the twelve variable sources other than hd 150136 and cd@xmath1648 11069 are stellar . to distinguish between soft and hard sources , the mean photon energy @xmath6e@xmath7 of each source ( table 2 )
was computed from energy - filtered event lists .
figure 2 is a histogram showing the distribution of @xmath6e@xmath7 .
most sources have @xmath6e@xmath7 @xmath8 1.8 - 2 kev , which is typical of coronal emission from low - mass stars .
three of the massive ob stars show a much softer photon energy distribution that is suggestive of a different x - ray emission process , probably related to shocks in their winds .
these are hd 150135 , hd 150136 , and cd@xmath1648 11071 .
the latter star has spectral type b0v and was the softest source detected in the central region with @xmath6e@xmath7 = 0.87 kev .
an interesting exception is the early b star cd@xmath1648 11069 ( source 26a ) , which shows a harder energy distribution @xmath6e@xmath7 = 2.09 kev than the other three ob stars as well as variable x - ray emission .
it has been variously classified as b0 - 1 v or b0 iv ( reed & beatty 1995 ) , and radial velocity variations ( arnal et al .
1988 ) indicate that it is a binary .
it is thus possible that the x - rays are due to a lower mass companion . except for the two bright o stars , only five other x - ray sources in table 2 have @xmath31100 counts ( sources 5 , 14 , 25 , 26a , 34 ) .
thus , spectral fitting is in most cases not practical because of insufficient counts .
however , we did fit the ccd spectra of the above five sources with simple absorbed one - temperature ( 1 t ) and two - temperature ( 2 t ) @xmath32 optically thin plasma models in xspec version 11.3.1 .
the fit parameters have large uncertainties but acceptable 2 t fits were obtained with a cool component at kt@xmath33 @xmath8 0.1 - 0.4 kev and a hotter component at kt@xmath34 @xmath8 1.6 - 4.5 kev .
the highest temperatures were inferred for sources 14 and 25 , both of which are variable and thus likely to be magnetically - active low - mass stars .
the mean ( median ) absorption from 2 t fits of these five stars was n@xmath21 = 5.0 ( 3.5 ) @xmath1 10@xmath22 @xmath23 , with a range of a factor of @xmath113 .
this absorption is similar to that determined for the much brighter source hd 150136 ( table 3 ) . for the b0 - 1
star cd@xmath1648 11069 noted above , a 2 t spectral fit gives log n@xmath21 = 21.2 ( @xmath23 ) and a dominant hot component at kt @xmath8 2.5 kev .
both 2mass and pico dos dias ( pd ) near - ir images show that the field near the cluster center ( @xmath35 = 336.7@xmath17 , @xmath36 = @xmath161.57@xmath17 ) is crowded ( fig .
1 ) . as a result
, confusion flags are set in one or more 2mass bands for all but 10 of the sources listed in table 2 .
we thus provide here only a brief summary of the ir properties and defer a complete discussion until higher resolution images become available .
the near - ir colors of those 10 2mass sources other than the two central o stars without confusion flags at j , h , or k are plotted in fig .
we also show the colors of 4 2mass sources with a confusion flag set only at j band ( not at h or k ) , but with j magnitudes that were still in good agreement ( @xmath37j @xmath29 0.2 mag ) with pico dos dias photometry .
the 14 sources in fig . 3 range from k = 7.91 ( source 41 = cd @xmath1648 11071 ) to k = 13.16 ( source 2 ) , with a mean ( median ) k = 11.36 ( 11.49 ) . of the 14 sources in fig .
3 , only one shows a near - ir excess .
this is source 30 , which is associated with a k = 11.19 2mass counterpart and a r = 13.5 mag _ hst _ guide star catalog ( gsc ) source .
the gsc classifies the object as non - stellar .
thus , the most reliable jhk data presently available suggest that the fraction of x - ray sources with near - ir excesses is quite low .
however , higher spatial resolution near - ir photometry is needed to obtain reliable colors for closely spaced sources along with mid - ir photometry to search for cooler dust emission that might be present .
the pico dos dias images confirm a previously detected optical source ( v = 9.0 ) located just north of hd 150136 ( mason et al .
this source is clearly visible in our 2.14@xmath25 image ( fig .
4 ) at an offset of @xmath81.7@xmath3 north of hd 150136 .
we estimate from pico dos dias photometry that it is @xmath82.4 mag fainter than hd 150136 at 2.14 @xmath25 m , but higher angular resolution will be needed to clearly separate the two .
if this star is at the same distance as hd 150136 and has similar a@xmath38 , then it would correspond to an early b spectral type for a main sequence object .
no significant x - ray emission is seen from this star , which is in the wings of the _ chandra _ psf of hd 150136 .
although the two closely - spaced o stars hd 150135 and hd 150136 have similar optical properties , their x - ray properties show differences , as discussed below .
the unabsorbed x - ray luminosity ( l@xmath12 ) of hd 150136 is about 4 times larger than hd 150135 ( table 1 ) .
the high l@xmath12 of hd 150136 is exceptional , making it one of the brightest ( if not _ the _
brightest ) x - ray sources in the o star class .
but , the hd 150136 sb2 system has a larger bolometric luminosity ( l@xmath39 ) than hd 150135 by virtue of its earlier o3 primary and o6v companion . as a result ,
the l@xmath12/l@xmath39 ratios of hd 150135 and hd 150136 are nearly identical ( table 1 ) .
the rass study of ob stars by berghfer et al .
( 1996 , 1997 ) established a correlation log l@xmath12 = 1.13 log l@xmath39 @xmath16 11.89 , with a standard deviation of 0.40 dex for stars with log l@xmath39 ( ergs s@xmath5 ) @xmath31 38 .
however , many ob stars were not detected in the short rass exposures , so the mean l@xmath12 deduced from rass data is probably too high .
a similar correlation was found in _ einstein _
data for o stars by sciortino et al .
( 1990 ) . as shown in figure 5 , the ( l@xmath12 , l@xmath39 ) values for hd 150135 and hd 150136 are well within the scatter of the rass sample , which is quite large .
thus , the ( l@xmath12 , l@xmath39 ) values for these two o stars do not seem unusual , but the high l@xmath12 of hd 150136 is extreme for an o star .
figure 6 shows the 0th order acis - s light curves of both hd 150135 and hd 150136 .
we have considered the effects of pileup , which occurs when two or more photons are detected as a single event .
based on _ pimms _ count rate simulations using fluxes determined from the meg1 spectra ( unpiled ) , we estimate that 0th order pileup was @xmath89% in hd 150136 and @xmath81% in hd 150135 .
the low pileup level in hd 150135 is negligible and the moderate level in hd 150136 will cause the count rate to be slighly underestimated in the 0th order light curve but does not significantly affect our results .
the grating data are unaffected .
no significant variability was detected in hd 150135 , but hd 150136 is clearly variable .
its count rate dropped slowly by about 38% during the first 39 ksec of the observation .
it then increased slowly back to levels near the initial value .
the first order meg1 light curve shows similar behavior .
in addition , we extracted a light curve using a small rectangular extraction region of size 6 @xmath1 3 pixels ( 2.9@xmath3 ew @xmath1 1.5@xmath3 ns ) centered on hd 150136 .
this region excluded the faint optical / ir source located 1.7@xmath3 to the north , which in any case is not clearly detected in the x - ray images .
the x - ray light curve variability is still present , implying that the faint optical / ir companion is not the cause of the x - ray variability .
a k - s analysis of the 0th order light curve of hd 150136 using events in the 0.5 - 5 kev range gives a probability of constant count rate p(const ) = 2.4 @xmath1 10@xmath30 .
to further investigate the nature of the variability , we extracted energy - filtered light curves of hd 150136 in soft ( 0.3 - 1.5 kev ) and hard ( 1.5 - 5 kev ) bands .
we found no significant variation in the hardness ratio during the light curve dip .
in addition , we extracted and fitted 0th order spectra of hd 150136 during the light curve dip ( t = 24 - 48 ksec ) and after the dip ( t = 55 - 90 ksec ) .
fits of these spectra with two - temperature optically thin plasma models show no significant differences in temperature or absorption .
however , the total emission measure ( sum of both temperature components ) during the light curve dip is only 27% of that in the post - dip spectrum .
the above analysis shows that the x - ray variability in hd 150136 was linked to a drop in the emission measure and was not accompanied by any significant temperature change .
this suggests that the variability may have resulted from a partial obscuration of the x - ray emitting region , as discussed further in section 5.8 .
figure 7 shows the 0th order spectra of hd 150135 and hd 150136 , and figures 8 - 9 show their meg1 spectra .
we have analyzed the 0th order and 1st order hetg spectra of both hd 150135 and hd 150136 using a variety of different models .
these include discrete temperature models with one ( 1 t ) , two ( 2 t ) , and three ( 3 t ) temperature components , and differential emission measure ( dem ) models .
spectra were rebinned to a minimum of 20 counts per bin for spectral fitting .
all models included an absorption component based on morrison & mccammon ( 1983 ) cross sections .
discrete temperature models were based on the @xmath40 module in xspec , which utilizes the recent aped atomic data base and includes a @xmath41 fit parameter that accounts for line broadening .
the dem was constructed using a modified version of the xspec chebyshev polynomial model @xmath42 ( lemen et al .
1989 ) , as discussed below .
overall , our most robust results are based on fits of the meg1 spectrum of hd 150136 , which provides good spectral resolution and high signal - to - noise ( s / n ) data .
measurements of line properties of some lines were also possible using heg1 spectra of hd 150136 ( table 4 ) , which provides higher spectral resolution than meg1 at lower s / n . because of its lower flux , our spectral fits of hd 150135 are restricted to 0th order and meg1 spectra only .
acceptable fits of 0th order spectra can be obtained using 2 t models , as summarized in table 3 .
the spectra of both hd 150135 and hd 150136 are quite soft with characteristic temperatures of kt @xmath8 0.2 - 0.3 kev .
the meg1 spectrum of hd 150135 can be acceptably fit with a 1 t model having kt = 0.3 kev , and the 2 t model ( table 3 ) provides only a slight improvement .
in contrast , the 2 t model provides a significant improvement over 1 t in hd 150136 .
further modest fit improvement can be obtained with a 3 t model in hd 150136 , which includes a third temperature component at kt @xmath8 1.6 kev , but only 9% of the total emission measure is attributed to this component . the dem distribution of hd 150136 based on modeling of its meg1 spectrum ( 8780 net counts ) is shown in figure 10 .
the dem was determined by a global fit of the spectrum using a modified version of the @xmath42 chebyshev polynomial algorithm in xspec that incorporates recent aped atomic data .
this global fitting strategy takes the underlying continuum into account in reconstructing the dem .
line broadening was modeled by applying the gaussian smoothing function @xmath43 .
abundances were varied and converged to values close to those obtained for the 2 t model ( table 3 ) , with an inferred iron abundance fe = 0.32 @xmath10 0.09 ( @xmath101@xmath44 ) solar . as seen in figure 10 ,
the dem of hd 150136 is quite soft , with a single peak near kt @xmath8 0.2 kev .
the precise value of the peak is somewhat uncertain , but is very likely below 0.4 kev .
we find no evidence of a second hotter emission peak but some plasma up to at least kt @xmath8 1 kev is inferred from the dem profile .
we also attempted to reconstruct the dem of hd 150135 using the chebyshev polynomial method applied to its meg1 spectrum ( 1100 net counts ) .
the inferred dem is very similar to that of hd 150136 , showing a single soft peak below kt @xmath8 0.4 kev , with almost all fits peaking at kt @xmath8 0.2 - 0.3 kev .
one discernible difference is that the dem of hd 150135 seems to be more sharply peaked , with less fractional contribution from hotter plasma at temperatures above the peak .
this is consistent with the results of our discrete temperature models , which also indicate a slightly cooler plasma distribution in hd 150135 .
the emission line properties of hd 150135 and hd 150136 are quite similar .
both stars show broadened lines with typical broadening of fwhm @xmath82400 - 2500 km s@xmath5 ( table 3 ) , no significant line centroid shifts , and little or no asymmetry .
table 4 summarizes the line properties of hd 150136 , which are more reliably determined than for the fainter line emission of hd 150135 .
even so , the o vii line in hd 150136 is faint and the uncertainties in its width and centroid are larger than for the other lines .
a notable result is that the higher temperature s xv and si xiv lines were detected in hd 150136 ( fig .
9 ) , but not in hd 150135 ( fig . 8) .
meg1 spectral simulations show that if the temperature structure of hd 150135 were the same as that of hd 150136 , these two lines should have been detected in hd 150135 in spite of its lower count rate .
we thus conclude that the plasma of hd 150136 is slightly hotter than that of hd 150135 , as already suggested by discrete temperature models . observed fluxes were measured for the resonance ( @xmath45 ) , intercombination ( @xmath46 ) , and forbidden ( @xmath47 ) line components in he - like triplets of hd 150136 using 1st order grating spectra .
the flux ratios @xmath48 = @xmath49 and @xmath50 = ( @xmath47 @xmath2 @xmath46)/@xmath45 are given in table 4 , and the si xiii triplet is shown in figure 11 . to measure the fluxes of individual components ,
he - like triplets were fitted with 3-component gaussian models plus a constant term to account for the underlying continuum . to reduce the number of free parameters in the fit , the ratios of the wavelengths of the @xmath45 , @xmath47 , and @xmath46 lines were held fixed during the fitting process at their laboratory values . in addition
, line broadening was taken into account .
the line width was allowed to vary during the fit , but the widths of all three components were constrained to be equal . the @xmath50 ratio is sensitive to temperature and the @xmath48 ratio is sensitive to the electron density ( @xmath51 ) and stellar uv radiation field ( gabriel & jordan 1969 ) . if @xmath52 is the photoexcitation rate from the 1@xmath152@xmath15 @xmath53 @xmath47 level to the 1@xmath152@xmath54 @xmath55 @xmath46 level , then @xmath48 = @xmath56/[1 @xmath2 ( @xmath52/@xmath57 ) @xmath2 ( @xmath51/@xmath58 ) ] , where @xmath57 and @xmath58 are the critical photoexcitation rate and critical density ( blumenthal , drake , & tucker 1972 ; porquet et al .
if photoexcitation and collisions are both negligible , then @xmath48 @xmath59 r@xmath60 , where r@xmath60 is referred to as the low - density limit .
either high electron densities or strong photoexcitation can lead to @xmath48 @xmath9 r@xmath60 .
we obtain @xmath48 @xmath9 r@xmath60 for all he - like triplets measured in hd 150136 , with s xv being a possible exception ( table 4 ) .
as discussed above , the suppressed @xmath48 values could be due to high electron densities or intense uv radiation ( or both ) .
however , it is unlikely that the suppression can be explained by high densities . as an example , consider ne ix @xmath61 13.447 , for which @xmath58 @xmath11 10@xmath62 @xmath63 ( porquet & dubau 2000 ) . assuming a spherically symmetric homogeneous solar - abundance wind , mass loss parameters as in table 5 , and a conventional wind velocity profile @xmath64 = @xmath65[1 @xmath16 ( r@xmath66/r)]@xmath67 with @xmath68 = 1 , densities @xmath51
@xmath69 @xmath58 are anticipated only at radii @xmath45 @xmath70 1.2 r@xmath66 for an o3v primary , and the corresponding radius for o3i is about 30% larger .
however , it is clear that the ne ix line can not originate at @xmath45 @xmath70 1.2 r@xmath66 because the radius of optical depth unity for o3v at the ne ix line energy 0.92 kev is r@xmath71(0.92 kev ) @xmath8 5.5 r@xmath66 , and about five time larger for o3i . to estimate r@xmath71 ,
we have used solar abundance cross - sections ( balucinska - church & mccammon 1992 ; anders & grevesse 1989 ) along with the o3 stellar parameters in table 5 .
thus , the optical depth constraint places the region of line formation for ne ix outside the radius at which density suppression would be important .
we emphasize that this conclusion rests on the assumption of a spherical homogeneous wind .
if the wind is clumped ( sec .
5.4 ) , then r@xmath71 is reduced and line formation could occur at smaller radii than inferred above .
it is more likely that the low r values result from photoexcitation by the strong uv field of the o3 @xmath2 o6v system .
the distance at which uv effects become significant is measured by the critical radius r@xmath72 , where the photoexcitation rate from the upper level of the @xmath47 transition equals the spontaneous decay rate from that same level .
triplets forming at @xmath45 @xmath9 r@xmath72 will have uv - suppressed r ratios .
values of r@xmath72 for o3v are given in table 4 for each he - like triplet .
figure 12 shows r@xmath71 and r@xmath72 values for he - like triplets in hd 150136 .
in general , uv - suppressed triplets could form at radii r@xmath71 @xmath9 @xmath45 @xmath9 r@xmath72 , as shown graphically by the solid lines in figure 12 .
but , in hd 150136 the r ratios are strongly suppressed and it is more likely that @xmath45 @xmath73 r@xmath72 . in any case , it is apparent from figure 12 that triplets with higher maximum line power temperatures such as s xv and si xiii are formed closer to the star than lower temperature lines such as ne ix and o vii .
the meg1 spectrum of hd 150136 is of sufficient quality to derive basic abundance information ( table 4 ) , the strongest result is that fe is underabundant with respect to the solar photospheric value by a factor of @xmath84 - 5 , and quite likely ne as well .
the fe underabundance is also clearly seen in the meg1 spectrum of hd 150135 .
low fe abundances have also been reported for other massive young stars such as trapezium ob stars ( schulz et al .
2003 ) . for hd 150136 ,
o and s abundances have the largest uncertainties .
we summarize here the stellar properties of hd 150135 and hd 150136 that are relevant to the x - ray analysis , and discuss the implications of the new _ chandra _ results for our understanding of the x - ray emission in massive young stars .
the orbital period of the o3 @xmath2 o6v system is 2.662 @xmath10 0.002 days , the orbit is nearly circular ( @xmath74 = 0.03 @xmath10 0.02 ) , and the inclination is probably low since optical eclipses have not been seen ( ng05 ) .
the luminosity class of the o3 primary is not well - determined , and we consider both o3i and o3v .
adopting the o star parameters listed in table 5 , the orbital semi - major axis from kepler s 3rd law is @xmath75 = 0.165 au for a o3v primary and @xmath75 = 0.173 au for o3i . in units of o3 star radii , this separation equates to only 2.1 - 2.7 r@xmath66 .
thus , this remarkable o @xmath2 o system is nearly in contact .
as a result of the close separation , interaction of the o3 and o6v winds seems unavoidable and may lead to x - ray emission from a colliding wind ( cw ) shock , as discussed further below .
the binary status of hd 150136 is firmly established ( ng05 ) but the evidence for binarity in hd 150135 is not as conclusive .
garmany et al .
( 1980 ) classified it as a possible sb1 based on large radial velocity differences in three spectra .
arnal et al . (
1988 ) obtained 17 radial velocity measurements over 10 days and classified it as a possible sb2 .
the radio continuum emission of hd 150135 ( and hd 150136 ) is unusually strong for a star of its spectral type , giving further reason to suspect binarity .
the flux density of hd 150135 increases with frequency with a 3.5 cm value s@xmath76 = 0.28 @xmath10 0.03 mjy ( benaglia et al . 2001 ) . if this flux is attributed entirely to free - free wind emission , then the inferred mass loss rate at d = 1.3 kpc is log @xmath77 = @xmath165.4 m@xmath78 yr@xmath5 .
this value is about an order of magnitude larger than determined for other o6.5v stars ( garmany et al .
1981 ; lamers & leitherer 1993 ) .
it is thus possible that some of the radio flux is nonthermal , as is the case for hd 150136 .
the above results point toward binarity in hd 150135 , but nothing is known about the putative companion .
the _ chandra _
data do not show any telltale hints of binarity such as variability or hard x - ray emission that might arise in a colliding wind shock .
its l@xmath12/l@xmath39 ratio is high , but within the scatter of the rass sample and nearly on the regression line for o stars determined by sciortino et al .
( 1990 ) ( fig . 5 ) .
an estimate of the terminal wind speed is available for hd 150136 ( prinja et al .
1990 ) but not for hd 150135 .
both stars are radio continuum sources ( benaglia et al .
2001 ) , but hd 150136 contains a nonthermal contribution , as may hd 150135 ( sec .
thus , estimates of the mass loss rates based on radio continuum fluxes are likely to be incorrect . in the absence of reliable observational data ,
we have adopted the mass loss parameters given in table 5 , which are representative of o3 and o6v stars in general .
the line widths of hd 150136 in table 4 reveal interesting trends the widths of all lines are similar , with a mean @xmath79 = 2100 km s@xmath5 . then , @xmath80 = 1050 km s@xmath5 , or @xmath80 @xmath8 v@xmath81/3 ( table 5 ) .
thus , the lines are broadened , but not nearly as broad as might be expected if they were formed in the outer wind where the wind is at terminal speed .
a similar situation exists for hd 150135 , whose mean line width as determined from meg1 spectra is nearly identical to that found in hd 150136 .
recent _ chandra _ grating observations of other young o stars such as @xmath44 ori ab ( o9.5v ) also show very moderate line broadening with hwhm @xmath8 @xmath65/4 ( skinner et al . 2004 ) .
if one attributes the broadening to x - ray line formation in an outflowing stellar wind ( owocki & cohen 2001 ) , then a @xmath68 = 1 wind acceleration profile ( sec . 4.3.4 ) gives @xmath64 = @xmath80 = 1050 km s@xmath5 at @xmath45 @xmath8 1.5 r@xmath66 .
comparing against figure 12 , it is apparent that higher temperature lines could form at such small radii but cooler lines such as ne ix and o vii are expected to form further out because of their larger r@xmath71 values .
thus , there is an apparent contradiction .
moderately broadened lines suggest that the lines are formed in the wind acceration zone close to the star , but optical depth calculations require larger formation radii for cooler lines , where the wind should be at or near its terminal speed
. the above inconsistency may be due to our imprecise knowledge of the mass loss parameters , wind opacities , and wind structure .
the wind acceleration profile is not empirically determined , and the mass - loss rate , which enters into the optical depth unity calculation , is poorly - known .
lastly , the assumption of a spherical homogeneous wind may be overly simplistic .
it has been suggested that o star winds may be clumped and that clumping could account for discrepancies in o star mass loss rates determined by different methods ( fullerton et al .
2004 ; repolust et al .
if the wind is clumped then the optical depth at a given line energy would be reduced and line photons could escape from smaller radii than indicated by figure 12 , resulting in less broadening than expected for a homogeneous wind ( owocki & cohen 2001 ) .
the close separation in the hd 150136 o3 @xmath2 o6 system virtually assures wind - wind interaction .
we would thus like to know if some or all of its prodigious x - ray emission could be due a colliding wind shock , which is expected to form in the harsh radiation environment between the two o stars .
there are indeed signs that the x - ray emission of hd 150136 may be influenced by binarity . as we have seen , its x - ray emission is slightly hotter and a factor of four more luminous than its optical twin hd 150135 .
in addition , its strong nonthermal radio emission may signal shock processes .
because of the close binary separation , the radiation - hydrodynamics problem is coupled and is challenging to model numerically . the temperature of shocked gas at the shock interface in an _
adiabatic _ colliding wind shock is proportional to the square of the pre - shock wind velocity component normal to the interface ( eq . [ 1 ] . of luo
et al 1990 ) . for wind speeds typical of o stars ( table 5 ) , x - ray temperatures of several kev
are expected and have been observed in such wide systems as the 7.9 year wr @xmath2 o binary wr 140 ( zhekov & skinner 2000 ) .
in contrast , we detect very little hot plasma above @xmath111 kev in hd 150136 ( fig .
because of its closer separation , the winds will not have reached terminal speeds before colliding and radiative cooling will be important . as a result , colliding wind shock emission could be present at lower temperatures than predicted in the adiabatic case .
the parameter used to determine whether a colliding wind shock is adiabatic or non - adiabatic is the ratio @xmath82 = t@xmath83/t@xmath84 , where t@xmath83 is the characteristic cooling time for shock - heated gas and t@xmath84 is the escape time for gas to flow out of the intershock region .
if @xmath82 @xmath69 1 then the system is adiabatic while @xmath82 @xmath73 1 implies the system is non - adiabatic and radiative cooling is important .
adopting o3v wind parameters for hd 150136 ( table 5 ) and a @xmath68 = 1 velocity law , we obtain @xmath82(o3v ) = 0.2 ( eq . [ 8 ] of stevens et al .
1992 , hereafter sbp92 ) .
thus , hd 150136 is a non - adiabatic system .
the numerical hydrodynamic simulation of colliding winds in closely - spaced non - adiabatic systems is complex .
cooling processes and wind acceleration must be taken into account .
also , radiative braking may be important , whereby the radiation of one o star slows the wind of its companion ( owocki & gayley 1995 ) . the presence of a mathematical singularity at the stagnation point on the line - of - centers has hindered the development of rigorous numerical hydrodynamic models , as discussed by myasnikov et al .
( 1998 ) .
because of the above complexities , we have only developed simplified hydrodynamic cw simulations of hd 150136 to date .
we assume o3v @xmath2 o6v wind parameters , a @xmath68 = 1 velocity law , and the orbit solution of ng05 .
the simulations invoke wind momentum balance and the shock surfaces are assumed to follow the contact discontinuity ( luo et al .
1990 ; sbp92 ) , as expected for efficient cooling .
cooling from an optically thin plasma was included using the approach of myasnikov et al .
( 1998 ) , as well as cooling from comptonization ( myasnikov & zhekov 1993 ) .
the simulations indicate that a cw shock model alone can not account for all of the observed x - ray properties of hd 150136 .
specifically , the cw model underestimates n@xmath21 by about an order of magnitude , and also places a larger fraction of the emission measure in hot plasma ( kt @xmath85 1 kev ) than expected from the observationally determined dem ( fig .
the above results indicate that if cw shock emission is present , then it is supplemented by an additional cool component , which would most likely originate in the o stars themselves .
x - ray emission from cool plasma in the shocked line - driven winds of the individual o stars is indeed expected ( lucy & white 1980 ; lucy 1982 ) . to test this idea
, we attempted to fit the meg1 spectrum of hd 150136 using a hybrid 1 t @xmath2 cw model , where the isothermal 1 t thin plasma component accounts for cool shocked plasma in the o - star winds .
this hybrid model provides a much better fit to the spectrum than does the pure cw model , resulting in a 37% decrease in reduced @xmath86 ( @xmath86/dof = 213/377 ) .
the hybrid model satisfactorily reproduces the overall spectral shape , observed flux , and n@xmath21 , and converges to abundances that are very close to those obtained in discrete 2 t fits ( table 3 ) .
the 1 t component in the hybrid model converges to kt @xmath8 0.3 kev , consistent with expectations from cool shocked plasma in the o star winds .
roughly half of the observed flux could come from the o stars themselves .
however , we note that our _ a priori _ estimate of the emission measure from the cw shock is a few times larger than needed to accurately reproduce the meg1 spectrum .
several factors could account for this including inaccuracies in the orbit solution or the assumed mass loss rates , or oversimplifications in the cw hydrodynamic model .
the hybrid 1 t @xmath2 cw model offers a potential explanation of the x - ray properties of hd 150136 .
but , additional refinements in the cw model as well as a more accurate orbit solution and determination of the luminosity class of the primary will probably be needed to determine if the hybrid model can be fully reconciled with the data .
further refinements in the cw shock model will include radiative braking and accounting for the effects of orbital motion on the emission line properties .
x - ray grating spectra recently obtained for several massive young stars have sparked renewed interest in the possibility that their winds might in some cases be magnetically confined .
this has been the result of the detection of narrow emission lines and hot plasma ( kt @xmath69 2 kev ) in young objects such as the o star @xmath87 ori c ( schulz et al . 2000 ) and the unusual b star @xmath88 sco ( cohen et al . 2003 ) .
narrow unshifted lines and hot plasma are usually associated with magnetically trapped plasma and are difficult to explain in the context of classical ( non - magnetic ) wind shock theory . the influence of a dipole magnetic field on the outflowing wind of a luminous hot star has been discussed by ud - doula & owocki ( 2002 ) .
the degree to which the wind is confined by the field is measured by the confinement parameter @xmath89 = ( 0.4 b@xmath90r@xmath91)/(@xmath92@xmath93 ) where b@xmath94 is the equatorial magnetic field surface strength in units of 100 g , r@xmath95 is the stellar radius in units of 10@xmath96 cm , @xmath92 is the mass loss rate in units of 10@xmath97 m@xmath78 yr@xmath5 , and @xmath93 is the wind speed in units of 10@xmath98 cm s@xmath5 . if @xmath89 @xmath31 1 ( strong confinement ) then the wind is confined by the b field and is channeled toward the magnetic equator , where the wind components from each hemisphere collide to form a magnetically confined wind shock ( mcws ) , accompanied by hard x - ray emission ( babel & montmerle 1997 ) . if @xmath89 @xmath9 1 ( weak confinement ) , the field is opened by the dominant wind and no hard x - rays are predicted .
since hd 150135 and hd 150136 are massive young stars , we ask if the above model could be relevant to their x - ray emission .
it is clear that we do not detect the hot ( kt @xmath69 2 kev ) plasma or the very narrow lines that the mcws model attempts to explain in other stars .
thus , there is no compelling reason to invoke this model in the present case , at least in the strong confinement limit where @xmath89 @xmath31 1 .
if this model is relevant at all for the o stars studied here , it must be in the weak confinement regime where @xmath89 @xmath9 1 .
for critical confinement ( @xmath89 = 1 ) the mass loss parameters in table 5 ( o3v ) give b@xmath99 @xmath8 400 g. thus , surface fields no larger than a few hundred gauss would be expected for hd 150136 .
similarly , the magnetically confined wind model of usov & melrose ( 1992 ) gives a surface field estimate of @xmath8 140 g in the weak - field approximation .
previous studies of ngc 6193 gave age estimates of @xmath111.5 - 3.1 myr ( moffat & vogt 1973 ; hh77 ; vzquez & feinstein 1992 ) .
we can now compare these with estimates of the ages of the central o stars based on updated evolutionary models for this purpose , we use the grids of schaller et al .
( 1992 ) . because of the complications of determining the photometric and spectroscopic properties of the two o stars in the hd 150136 sb2 system , we consider hd 150135 as a more reliable age indicator ( but keeping in mind that it may also be a binary ) .
its absolute magnitude is m@xmath100 = @xmath165.33 ( hh77 ) .
the o star parameters of vacca et al .
( 1996 ) for luminosity class v then give log t@xmath101 = 4.66 , log ( l / l@xmath78 ) = 5.727 , and an evolutionary mass m@xmath102 = 56.6 m@xmath78 . using these stellar parameters , the schaller et al .
tracks for metallicity z = 0.020 and 60 m@xmath78 give an age of @xmath111 myr . a similar age
is expected for hd 150136 because of its close association with hd 150135 .
the age of @xmath111 myr deduced for hd 150135 and , by association , for hd 150136 is a few times larger than the estimated age of @xmath110.3 myr for trapezium ob stars , which may still be on the zero - age main sequence ( schulz et al .
it is notable that several high - mass stars in the trapezium such as @xmath87 ori c show signs of magnetic behavior such as hot plasma , very narrow emission lines , and periodic x - ray variability ( schulz et al . 2003 , feigelson et al . 2002 , gagn et al . 1997 ) .
in contrast , we do not detect obvious x - ray magnetic signatures in hd 150135 or hd 150136 , although periodic x - ray variability in the latter is not yet ruled out due to limited time monitoring . in the absence of any recognizable magnetic x - ray behavior
, it may well be that any primordial magnetic fields that were initially present in hd 150135 or hd 150136 have already decayed to low levels .
if that is the case , then the estimated age of @xmath111 myr suggests that the timescale for magnetic decay is quite short , and the possibilities for studying magnetic behavior in o stars may be limited to the very youngest objects that are still on the zero - age main sequence . as discussed in section 4.2 , hd 150136 shows slow x - ray variability in the form of a dip in its light curve spanning at least @xmath1130 ksec ( fig .
the variability was detected at high statistical significance in both the 0th order and meg 1st order light curves .
simultaneous light curves of hd 150135 lying 10@xmath3 away on the same detector show no significant variability .
these factors leave little doubt that the x - ray variability of hd 150136 is real .
x - ray variability in o stars has been known since early observations with the _ einstein _ observatory , but its origin is not yet understood and more than one mechanism may be involved .
collura et al . ( 1989 ) detected significant variability in three of twelve ob stars observed with the _ einstein _ ipc .
the variability occurred on timescales of a few days with typical variability amplitudes of @xmath817% - 34% .
we find a similar variability amplitude for hd 150136 , whose count rate fluctuated @xmath216%/@xmath1622% about the mean .
lower amplitude variability at the 6% level was reported from _ rosat _
observations of the o4 supergiant @xmath103 puppis ( berghfer et al .
variability was also detected in three o stars in the orion nebula cluster ( onc ) observed by _
( feigelson et al . 2002 ) .
these were @xmath87 ori c ( o6pe ) , @xmath87 ori a ( o7 ) , and @xmath104 ori a ( o9.5vpe ) .
the latter star underwent a rapid flare .
there are several possibilities for explaining x - ray variability in o stars .
these can be broadly categorized as ( i ) magnetic processes , ( ii ) changes in the wind ( e.g. density variations or time - variable shock structures ) , and ( iii ) dynamical effects .
the latter category is quite broad and is meant to include phenomena such as ( partial ) eclipses of the x - ray emitting region by a companion , changes in x - ray absorption caused by the wind or atmosphere of a companion moving into the line of sight , changes in orbital separation in cw systems , and rotational modulation of x - ray emitting structures on or near the star .
intrinsic variability associated with magnetic processes is usually accompanied by high - temperature plasma ( kt @xmath105 1 kev ) and/or rapid magnetic reconnection flares .
dramatic temperature changes can occur on timescales of minutes to hours in magnetic flares .
we do not detect high - temperature plasma in hd 150136 , nor do we see any significant temperature changes or rapid impulsive flares .
thus , the existing data for hd 150136 do not obviously point toward a magnetic origin for the slow variability .
but the temporal coverage is so far quite limited and spans only 39% of the 2.662 day orbit .
observations spanning a longer time period are needed .
changes in the wind density at the base of the wind were cited as a possible explanation of the x - ray variability detected by _
rosat _ in the o4 supergiant @xmath103 pup ( berghfer et al .
however , the mechanism that would drive such density perturbations is not known .
along similar lines , feldmeier et al .
( 1997 ) have attributed the x - ray variability in o stars to the collision of dense shells of gas in their winds .
this model predicts short x - ray variability timescales of @xmath11500 s. this is much shorter than the variability timescale of several hours observed in hd 150136 , but one might argue that variability timescales of @xmath11hours could result from successive collisions of dense shells ( fig . 19 of feldmeier et al .
apart from the timescale question , the high x - ray luminosity of hd 150136 may be even more problematic for the shell - collision picture .
typical x - ray luminosities predicted by shell - collision simulations are log l@xmath4 @xmath8 32.3 ( ergs s@xmath5 ) , with model - dependent standard deviations of @xmath100.4 to @xmath100.6 .
this predicted l@xmath4 is about an order of magnitude less than determined for hd 150136 , even after halving the total l@xmath4 ( table 1 ) to account for two stars in the system .
it thus remains to be shown that the shell - collision mechanism can account for the very high x - ray luminosity and slow variability of hd 150136 . finally , we consider dynamic effects .
these are indeed relevant because hd 150136 is known to be a 2.662 d binary . during our observation ,
the orbital phase of hd 150136 ranged from @xmath52 = 0.1 - 0.5 , where the primary is in front at @xmath52 = 0.5 ( ng05 ) .
the dip in the light curve is centered near @xmath52 @xmath8 0.27 ( fig . 6 ) . at this phase ,
the system is near quadrature , with the o3 primary approaching the observer and the o6 secondary receding . in colliding wind systems ,
x - ray variability can be induced by orbital motion .
the intrinsic luminosity of a cw shock is predicted to scale inversely as the distance between the two components ( sbp92 ) , but the orbit of hd 150136 is nearly circular ( @xmath74 = 0.03 ; ng05 ) so no significant variability due to changes in orbital separation is expected .
also , a reduction in the observed x - ray flux can occur in colliding wind binaries from increased wind absorption as the primary moves in front of the secondary .
again , this does not explain the dip in the hd 150136 light curve , which occurs near quadrature and not when the primary is in front .
to explain the light curve dip at quadrature in terms of colliding wind geometry , one would have to postulate that some of the cw shock emission on the downstream side of the secondary is being shadowed by the secondary itself .
a possible clue to the origin of the x - ray variability comes from the optical spectra of ng05 .
they note that the radial velocity changes in the he i absorption lines of hd 150136 do not follow the orbital motion of either the primary or secondary .
furthermore , they detect an _ additional _ faint absorption component redward of the he i absorption lines when the secondary of the sb2 system has maximum positive radial velocity , which occurs at phase @xmath52 = 0.25 .
this may signal the presence of a third massive star in the system .
we emphasize that this putative third component in the spectroscopic system is _ not _ the faint star lying 1.7@xmath3 to the north ( fig .
4 ) , whose position is well - known from optical studies ( mason et al .
1998 ) .
it may not be a coincidence that the appearance of the additional optical absorption component occurs at @xmath52 = 0.25 , where the dip in the x - ray spectrum is also observed ( fig .
if the additional absorption feature is due to a massive third component moving in front at @xmath52 = 0.25 , then this third star ( or its wind ) could be partially occulting the x - ray emitting region .
such an occultation would be consistent with the observed decline in emission measure , without an accompanying temperature change .
however , a physical connection between the x - ray variability and the putative third star remains quite speculative .
it might be argued that a physical connection is unlikely , since it seems to require that the orbit of the third star be synchronous with that of the sb2 system .
clearly , further observational work is needed to determine if there is a connection .
this would include confirmation of the existence of the putative third star , determination of its spectral type and orbit , and extended time monitoring to search for periodicity in the x - ray light curve .
a final possibility worth mentioning is that the x - ray variability of hd 150136 might be due to rotational modulation of an x - ray emitting structure that is close to the star .
in that case , the observed variability could result from self - occulation , rather than from occultation by a putative third star in the system .
rotational self - occultation has been invoked to explain the x - ray variability of @xmath87 ori c ( gagn et al . 2005 ) .
its variability is caused by a change in emission measure without an accompanying temperature change , which is qualitatively similar to the behavior that we see in hd 150136 .
the key question that remains is whether the x - ray variability in hd 150136 is periodic and if so , what is the period ?
we have presented results of the first x - ray observation targeted at the center of the young stellar cluster ngc 6193 in the ara ob1 association , supplemented by ground - based near - ir images .
the main results of this study are summarized as follows : 1 .
_ chandra _ detected 43 x - ray sources in a @xmath82@xmath0 @xmath1 2@xmath0 region centered on the o stars hd 150135 and hd 150136 .
the strong x - ray emission previously seen by _ rosat _ is now attributed to separate but unequal contributions from hd 150135 and hd 150136 .
the x - ray luminosity of hd 150136 is exceptional ( log l@xmath4 = 33.39 ergs s@xmath5 ) making it one of the most x - ray luminous o stars known .
all 43 x - ray sources in the central cluster region have near - ir counterparts , but only eleven have optical identifications .
one of these , the early b star cd@xmath1648 11069 , shows an unusually hard photon energy distribution , raising the possibility that its x - ray emission arises in a low - mass companion .
the population of fainter x - ray sources surrounding the central o stars is characterized by moderately hard emission with mean photon energies @xmath6e@xmath7 @xmath8 2 kev and about one - third are variable .
the variable objects are promising candidates for low - mass pre - main - sequence stars in the cluster , but membership remains to be determined .
the available jhk photometry suggest that the fraction of x - ray sources in the central cluster region with near - ir excesses is low .
further searches for excesses in the mid - ir are needed .
high - quality x - ray grating spectra of hd 150135 and hd 150136 show similar , but not identical , spectral properties . in both stars ,
the emission is dominated by cool plasma ( kt @xmath8 0.3 kev ) .
the emission lines show no significant centroid shifts and are moderately broadened to hwhm @xmath8 @xmath65/3 . broadened lines and cool plasma implicate wind shock emission as the origin of the x - rays .
forbidden lines in he - like triplets are strongly suppressed by the hd 150136 uv radiation field , implying that some high - temperature lines such as s xv form in the wind - acceleration zone within a few radii of the star .
optical depth and line broadening considerations hint that the wind may be clumped .
the exceptionally high x - ray luminosity of hd 150136 , along with nonthermal radio emission , suggest that colliding wind shocks may be present in this closely - spaced o3
@xmath2 o6v binary .
however , simplified numerical simulations show that a cw shock alone can not account for all of the observed x - ray properties .
if cw emission is present , then it is supplemented by another cool x - ray component , which likely originates in the shocked winds of the individual o stars .
an unexpected result is that the x - ray emission of hd 150136 is slowly variable on a timescale of @xmath701 day .
the variability is due to a change in the emission measure , with little or no change in x - ray temperature , suggesting that it is an occultation effect .
the mechanism responsible for the occultation is not yet known , but self - occultation due to stellar rotation or partial occultation of the x - ray emitting region by a putative third star in the hd 150136 system are possibilities
. further observational work , including long - term x - ray monitoring , will be needed to identify the origin of the x - ray variability .
this research was supported by nasa / sao grant go2 - 3025x .
this publication makes use of data products from the two micron all sky survey ( 2mass ) , which is a joint project of the univ . of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the national science foundation .
the results presented here are partially based on observations made at observatrio do pico dos dias / lna .
sz and fp acknowledge partial financial support from the bulgarian academy of sciences - consiglio nazionale delle ricerche bilateral cooperation program .
cb thanks fapesp and inst .
do milnio for financial suport .
99 anders , e. , grevesse , n. , 1989 , geochim .
acta , 53 , 197 + arnal , e.m . , cersosimo , j.c .
, may , j. , bronfman , l. , 1987 , a&a , 174 , 78 + arnal , m. , morrell , n. , garcia , b. , levato , h. , 1988 , pasp , 100 , 1076 + babel , j. , montmerle , t. , 1997 , apj , 485 , l29 + balucinska - church , m. , mccammon , d. , 1992 , apj , 400 , 699 + benaglia , p. , cappa , c.e . , koribalski , b.s . , 2001 , a&a , 372 , 952 + berghfer , t.w . ,
baade , d. , schmitt , j.h.m.m . ,
kudritzki , r .-
p . , puls , j. , hillier , d.j . ,
pauldrach , a.w.a . , 1996b , a&a , 306 , 899 + berghfer , t.w . ,
schmitt , j.h.m.m . ,
cassinelli , j.p . , 1996 , a&as , 118 , 481 + berghfer , t.w . ,
schmitt , j.h.m.m . ,
danner , r. , cassinelli , j.p .
, 1997 , a&a , 322 , 167 + bessell , m.s . , brett , j.m . , 1988 , pasp , 100 , 1134 + blumenthal , g.r . ,
drake , g.w . ,
tucker , w.h .
, 1972 , apj , 172 , 205 + cohen , d.h .
et al . , 2003 , apj , 586 , 495 + collura , a. et al .
, 1989 , apj , 338 , 296 + comern , f. , schneider , n. , russeil , d. , 2005 , a&a , in press + feigelson , e.d .
et al . , 2002 ,
apj , 574 , 258 + feldmeier , a. , puls , j. , & pauldrach , a.w.a . , a&a , 322 , 878 + fullerton , a.w . ,
massa , d.l . , prinja , r.k .
, 2004 , baas , 36 ( no .
5 ) , 1425 + gabriel , a.h . , jordan , c. , 1969 , mnras , 145 , 241 + gagn , m. , caillault , j .- p . ,
stauffer , j.r . ,
linsky , j.l . , 1997 ,
apj , 478 , l87 + gagn , m. et al . , 2005 ,
apj , in press .
+ garmany , c.d . ,
conti , p.s . ,
massey , p. , 1980 ,
apj , 242 , 1063 + garmany , c.d . , olson , g.l . ,
conti , p.s .
, van steenberg , m.e . , 1981 , apj , 250 , 660 + gorenstein , p. , 1975
, apj , 198 , 95 + herbst , w. , havlen , r.j . , 1977 , a&as , 30 , 279 ( hh77 ) + hillenbrand , l.a . , 1997 , aj , 113 , 1733 + kahn , s.m .
et al . , 2001 , a&a , 365 , l312 + lamers , h.j.g.l.m . ,
leitherer , c. , 1993 , apj , 412 , 771 + lemen , j.r . ,
mewe , r. , schrijver , c.j . , fludra , a. , 1989 , apj , 341 , 484 + lucy , l.b . , 1982 , apj , 255 , 286 + lucy , l.b . , white , r.l . , 1980 , apj , 241 , 300 + luo , d. , mccray , r. , maclow , m .-
, 1990 , apj , 362 , 267 + mason , b.d .
et al . , 1998 , aj , 115 , 821 + moffat , a.f.j . ,
vogt , n. , 1973 , a&as , 10 , 135 + morrison , r. , mccammon , d. , 1983 , apj , 270 , 119 + myasnikov , a.v . , zhekov , s.a .
, 1993 , mnras , 260 , 221 + myasnikov , a.v . , zhekov , s.a . , belov , n.a . , 1998 , mnras , 298 , 1021 + niemela , v.s . , gamen , r.c . , 2005 , mnras , 356 , 974 ( ng05 ) + owocki , s.p .
& cohen , d.h .
, 2001 , apj , 559 , 1108 + owocki , s.p . &
gayley , k.g . , 1995 ,
apj , 454 , l145 + persson , s.e . ,
murphy , d.c . ,
krzeminski , w. , roth , m. , rieke , m.j . , 1998 ,
aj , 116 , 2475 + porquet , d. , dubau , j. , 2000 , a&as , 143 , 495 + porquet , d. , mewe , r. , dubau , j. , raassen , a.j.j .
, kaastra , j.s . , 2001 , a&a , 376 , 1113 + press , w.h . ,
teukolsky , s.a .
, vetterling , w.t . , flannery , b.p .
, 1992 , numerical recipes in fortran : the art of scientific computing ( 2nd ed . ,
new york : cambridge univ . press ) + prinja , r.k . ,
barlow , m.j . ,
howarth , i.d . , 1990 ,
apj , 361 , 607 + reed , b.c . ,
beatty , a.e .
, 1995 , apjs , 97 , 189 + repolust , t. , puls , j. , & herrero , a. , 2004 , a&a , 415 , 349 + rieke , g.h . ,
lebofsky , m.j . , 1985 ,
apj , 288 , 618 + schulz , n.s . , canizares , c.r . ,
huenemoerder , d. , lee , j.c . , 2000 , apj , 545 , l135 + schulz , n.s . , canizares , c.r . ,
huenemoerder , d. , tibbets , k. , 2003 , apj , 595 , 365 + schaller , g. , schaerer , d. , meynet , g. , maeder , a. , 1992 , a&as , 96 , 269 + sciortino , s. et al . , 1990 , apj , 361 , 621 + skinner , s . ,
cohen , d. , gagn , m. , owocki , s. , townsend , r. , 2004 , baas , 36 ( no .
5 ) , 1520 + stevens , i.r . ,
blondin , j.m . ,
pollock , a.m.t . , 1992 ,
apj , 386 , 265 ( sbp92 ) + ud - doula , a. , owocki , s.p . , 2002 ,
apj , 576 , 413 + usov , v.v . & melrose , d.b . , 1992 ,
apj , 395 , 575 + vacca , w.d . , garmany , c.d . ,
shull , j.m .
, 1996 , apj , 460 , 914 + vzquez , r.a . , feinstein , a. , 1992 , a&as , 92 , 863 + weisskopf , m.c . , brinkman , b. , canizares , c. , garmire , g. , murray , s. , van speybroeck , l. , 2002 , pasp , 114 , 1 + whiteoak , j.b .
, 1963 , mnras , 125 , 205 + zhekov , s.a . , skinner , s.l . , 2000 , apj , 538 , 808 | a 90 ksec _ chandra _ hetg observation of the young stellar cluster ngc 6193 in the southern ara ob1 association detected 43 x - ray sources in a 2@xmath0 @xmath1 2@xmath0 core region centered on the massive o stars hd 150135 ( o6.5v ) and hd 150136 ( o3 @xmath2 o6v ) .
the cluster is dominated by exceptionally bright x - ray emission from the two o stars , which are separated by only 10@xmath3 .
the x - ray luminosity of hd 150136 is log l@xmath4 = 33.39 ( ergs s@xmath5 ) , making it one of the most luminous o - star x - ray sources known .
all of the fainter x - ray sources in the core region have near - ir counterparts , but existing jhk photometry provides little evidence for near - ir excesses .
these core sources have typical mean photon energies @xmath6e@xmath7 @xmath8 2 kev and about one - third are variable .
it is likely that some are young low - mass stars in the cluster , but cluster membership remains to be determined .
grating spectra show that the x - ray properties of hd 150135 and hd 150136 are similar , but not identical .
both have moderately broadened unshifted emission lines and their emission is dominated by cool plasma at kt @xmath8 0.3 kev , pointing to a wind - shock origin . however , the emission of hd 150136 is slightly hotter and four times more luminous than its optical twin hd 150135 .
we discuss the possibility that a radiative colliding wind shock contributes to the prodigious x - ray output of the short - period ( 2.66 d ) spectroscopic binary hd 150136 .
a suprising result is that the x - ray emission of hd 150136 is slowly variable on a timescale of @xmath91 day .
the origin of the variability is not yet known but the observed behavior suggests that it is an occultation effect .
[ firstpage ] open clusters and associations : individual ( ngc 6193 , ara ob1 ) stars : formation stars : early - type stars : individual ( hd 150135 , hd 150136 ) x - rays : stars . |
the first galaxies and their environments differed substantially from those locally , often involving multiple interactions as seen in the _ hst _ ultra deep field ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
compared to all other nearby environments , present - day compact galaxy groups most closely reproduce the interaction environment of the early universe ( @xmath5 ) when galaxies assembled through hierarchical formation ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , and galaxy groups combined to form proto - clusters ( in dense regions ; e.g. , rudick+06 ) or massive ellipticals ( in the field ; white ) . because of their high space densities ( with comparable surface densities to the centers of rich galaxy clusters ; e.g. , rubin+91 ) and low velocity dispersions ( @xmath6 ) , compact groups of galaxies are ideal environments for studying the mechanisms of interaction - induced star formation and nuclear activity . from optical spectroscopic surveys , hickson compact groups ( hcgs ) are known to host a population of galaxies with emission - line nuclear spectra characteristic of star - formation and/or active galactic nuclei ( agns ) .
based on the optical spectroscopic survey of @xcite , the agn fraction in hcgs is found to be @xmath7 , perhaps consistent with the @xmath8 nuclear activity level found for nearby @xmath9 galaxies ( with greater detection sensitivity ; hoetal97a ) and significantly higher than the @xmath10 agn fraction identified optically in cluster galaxies ( with @xmath11 ; dressler85 ) .
further , hcg agns ( including low - luminosity agns , hereafter llagns ; hcgs host no known seyfert 1-luminosity agns ) are preferentially found in optically luminous , early - type galaxies with little or no ongoing star formation in the cores of evolved groups .
similarly , many galaxies in clusters host llagns in the local universe ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , in particular brightest cluster galaxies @xcite . typically , the most active star - forming galaxies are late - type spirals in the outskirts of groups .
@xcite interpreted relative distributions of star - forming and agn - hosting galaxies as indicating a clear evolutionary scenario whereby group cores are mature collapsed systems in which the high galaxy densities led to increased gravitational interactions and hence more rapid exhaustion of gas reservoirs in the past through star formation .
( the radiatively weak agns in the evolved group cores require only a small amount of gas for fueling . )
a similar study by @xcite found that the fraction of emission - line hcg galaxies was comparable to the field , and conversely concluded that the hcg environment does _ not _ trigger either star formation or agn activity .
the initial expectation that the interactions evident in the compact group environment would naturally lead to markedly enhanced levels of star formation compared with the field has not been satisfied , and a coherent understanding of the history of gas and cold dust in compact groups has proven elusive .
an analysis of the co content in hcg galaxies found them to be similar to those in the field , in loose groups , and in other environments ; a notable exception is the @xmath12 of hcg spirals that are co deficient .
this suggests less , not more , star formation in hcgs compared to other environments @xcite . at the same time , the detection of a few hcg elliptical and s0 galaxies in both co and the far - infrared ( unlike typical galaxies of these types ) suggests that tidal interactions are influencing galaxy evolution to some extent . while the far - infrared power is similar to comparison samples , the ratios of 25 to 100 _ iras _ fluxes implies a greater number of intense , nuclear starbursts in hcg galaxies @xcite .
clearly , a robust and consistent understanding of the impact of the compact group environment on galaxy properties has not yet emerged .
one possible difficulty to date is the predominant use of optical emission - line studies to identify activity both star - forming and accretion - dominated .
ground - based studies of bright galaxies can easily obscure low - contrast emission lines through their dilution by a strong stellar contribution ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) ; intrinsic absorption can also mask spectroscopic signatures .
the clear discrepancy between the @xmath10 agn fraction in galaxy clusters from optical spectroscopic surveys ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) compared to the larger fraction ( @xmath13 for luminous galaxies ) revealed by x - ray observations ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) is illustrative of this problem .
as highlighted by @xcite , mismatched sample selection and detection techniques can create apparent ( and false ) discrepancies in agn fractions between environments .
in this paper , we take an alternate approach , focusing on the mid - infrared spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of individual galaxy nuclei to clearly identify the thermal , hot dust continua that signify neutral gas heated by ionizing photons from either young stars or an agn . the clear discrepancy between a blue
, quiescent galaxy sed where the mid - infrared is dominated by the raleigh - jeans tail of stellar photospheres and the red , mid - infrared sed of warm to hot dust emission offers promise for reducing the ambiguity of previous compact group studies .
* hereafter j07 ) have presented the first results from a cycle 1 _ spitzer _ irac ( 3.68.0 ) and mips ( 24 ) imaging survey of 46 galaxies in 12 nearby hcgs . in brief , this work revealed trends between the evolutionary states of compact groups ( determined from their dynamical and masses ) , and their mid - infrared colors and luminosities .
galaxies in relatively gas - rich groups tend to have colors most indicative of star formation and agn activity , and galaxies in gas - poor groups predominantly exhibit a narrow range of mid - infrared colors that are consistent with the light from quiescent stellar populations .
the galaxies in this sample of 12 compact groups also occupy infrared color space in a distinctly different way than the population of galaxies in the _ spitzer _ first look survey ( fls ; e.g. , lacy04 ) , notably exhibiting a `` gap '' in their color distribution not found in the fls sample .
all of these results suggest that the environment of a compact group is intimately connected to the mid - infrared activity of the member galaxies .
we present additional analysis of the nuclei of these galaxies , focusing in particular on developing diagnostics for identifying quantitative measures of mid - infrared activity with the ultimate goal of exploring the nature of mid - infrared emission , i.e. , quiescent , star - forming , and/or accretion - powered .
we also explore the connections between mid - infrared nuclear properties and other features of individual galaxies including morphology , optical spectral type , and the host group s evolutionary stage . because of their proximity ( @xmath14 )
, we can spatially extract nuclear photometry for the hcg galaxies to reduce contamination from the extended galaxy that is inevitable in surveys of more distant galaxies . throughout
we assume a @xmath15-cdm cosmology with @xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18mpc@xmath19 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
target compact galaxy groups for the _ spitzer _ program were selected on the basis of distance , angular extent , and membership ( at least three members with accordant redshifts , i.e. , within 1000 of the group mean ) .
all hcgs were considered at redshifts @xmath20 , and the sample includes all of the nearest ones with only a few exceptions three nearby groups are too extended to realistically cover with small - field imagers .
the morphologies of the individual galaxies in the groups include tidal arms and tails , polar rings , ellipticals with boxy isophotes and central disks , and disturbed features ; typical spiral and elliptical galaxies are also present . in table
[ tab : groups ] , we list the groups , average recession velocities , membership by morphology , mass in neutral hydrogen ( @xmath21 ) , a qualitative description of the evolutionary stage of each group based on the scenario proposed by @xcite , and the type from j07 .
groups are divided into types of i ( rich ; @xmath22 ) , ii ( intermediate ; @xmath230.9 ) , and iii ( poor ; @xmath24 ) , where @xmath25 is the group dynamical mass ( j07 and references therein ) .
the observations and image reduction are described in detail in j07 , where the extended source photometry is presented .
for this project , we focus on the nuclear regions in particular . the nuclear flux density is obtained using a circular aperture centered on the nucleus ( with some exceptions ; see below ) with a 7 radius which corresponds to 1.11.8 kpc for our groups .
determining the absolute background in these crowded environments is not straightforward .
we elected to use a uniform method in which background is taken from an annulus with inner and outer radii of 50 and 60 , respectively .
this annulus is well outside the 3@xmath26 contour levels of nearly all of the galaxies in the sample with the exception of galaxies in close projected proximity with overlapping contours .
however , since the mode of the annulus is used to determine the background level in all cases , partial contamination from a nearby source will not affect the measured background values .
for the purposes of comparing photometry at different wavelengths , the irac and mips images were cross - convolved with their respective point response functions ( prfs ) to obtain images with matched spatial resolution .
no aperture corrections have been applied . for reference
, a 7 radius aperture corresponds to @xmath27 of the encircled energy of the 24 prf . in most cases ,
the nuclear aperture is centered on the location of the central flux peak of a galaxy . however , in the case of disrupted / merging / irregular galaxies , some discretion is required .
for example , for the galaxies 31a , c , and e in hcg 31 , the infrared peak apparently at the galaxy collision interface is designated as the nucleus of the main interacting pair .
the relative errors listed for the nuclear regions in table [ tab : fluxes ] are conservatively set at 10% .
the main source of relative uncertainty between the bands is the agreement of the relative astrometry ; this translates into how well - centered the nuclear region is in each band .
empirically , this is found to be @xmath28 , and usually 23% .
the formal uncertainties derived from the image statistics are negligible by comparison .
this photometry procedure is different than the method used for the entire galaxies presented in j07 , which used isocontour levels . in some cases ,
the flux density of the entire galaxy @xmath29 ( to roughly account for an aperture correction ) is actually less than the ` nuclear ' region , and this is because the isocontour levels used for the extended galaxy photometry fell within the 7 radius used for the nuclear regions .
however , frequently the aperture - corrected flux of the nuclear region is essentially equal to that of the galaxy ; this indicates that at this angular resolution the galaxies are pointlike at 24 .
the nuclear photometry from the near - infrared through 24 is presented in table [ tab : fluxes ] .
seds for each galaxy nucleus are plotted in rest - frame units in figure [ fig : sed ] , along with the morphological type and optical spectroscopic classification ( as available ) .
also overplotted is the total galaxy photometry and three sed templates , that of an elliptical galaxy @xcite , a type 1 ( i.e. , broad emission - line ) agn @xcite , and the local starburst galaxy m82 @xcite .
these three templates encompass the range of expected mid - infrared spectral shapes for galaxies in the local universe . in general , the shape of the seds is comparable for the total galaxy and nuclear photometry . to investigate nuclear activity in hcgs further , we calculate several values from the photometry to categorize the galaxies .
first , we measure the luminosities at several wavelengths chosen to characterize the contribution from different emission mechanisms .
the @xmath3-band luminosity , @xmath30 , is a measure of the luminosity in stars of a galaxy . unlike in previous studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) that used a blue luminosity , @xmath31 , ongoing star - formation does not significantly alter @xmath30 .
the luminosity at 4.5 , @xmath32 , measures the stellar continuum plus any contribution from hot ( @xmath33 k ) dust .
this bandpass has the advantage of containing no significant polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon ( pah ) features .
however , the stellar contribution can still be quite significant , and so we also calculate the fraction of 4.5 emission from hot dust : @xmath34@xmath35 , where @xmath36 is the light from stars expected from the elliptical galaxy template of @xcite normalized to the @xmath3 and @xmath37-band photometry .
though not all galaxies in the sample are ellipticals , we use this template to represent the stellar population , as templates from spirals and irregulars will include warm dust emission .
the @xcite elliptical template contains a contribution from cooler dust attributed to galactic cirrus , but this component is not significant for @xmath38 .
additional fiducial luminosities are measured at 8 and 24 .
the former includes pah emission ( if present ) , and the latter is sensitive to cooler dust in a frequency regime near the minimum of the elliptical galaxy template .
the value , @xmath4 , the fraction of 24 luminosity not attributed to starlight , is calculated in the same manner as @xmath34 .
finally , we also calculate the spectral index , @xmath1 , for a power - law model fit to the 4.58.0 data , @xmath39 .
the 3.6 photometry is not included because of the dominant stellar contribution . in addition , an 8 to 24 spectral index , @xmath40=0.477@xmath41 , can reveal cooler dust or dust emission diluted by a strong stellar continuum at shorter wavelengths .
all of these values are listed in table [ tab : props ] . in order to evaluate the role (
if any ) of the hcg environment on mid - infrared activity , a comparison galaxy sample is required .
for this purpose , we use the _ spitzer _ nearby galaxy sample ( sings ) photometry presented in @xcite .
this is the largest sample of comparable _ spitzer _ data available in the literature for galaxies in the local universe with known distances .
the sings sample was chosen to be diverse , covering a large parameter space of optical luminosities , masses , metallicities , star - formation rates , and morphologies . in an attempt to identify a reasonable comparison sample of galaxies within sings , we have filtered the sings sample to match the values of @xmath30(gal ) ( from j07 for the entire galaxy , not just the nucleus ) found in our sample , @xmath4230.17 hz@xmath19 .
this leaves 61 out of the total sings sample of 75 .
the majority of those filtered from the sings sample are low - luminosity dwarfs ; the hcg sample comprises primarily 35 bright galaxies per group .
the distributions of @xmath30(gal ) for the hcg and sings samples are plotted in figure [ fig : hists]a . for all of the sings galaxies , we use the photometry in tables 2 and 3 of @xcite and calculate the same parameters as for the hcg galaxies detailed in
[ sec : params ] .
the extended source photometry for the hcg galaxies includes aperture corrections to correct for scattered light in the irac bands following eq . 2 of @xcite , and therefore the two datasets are directly comparable ( see j07 for further details ) .
from a visual examination of the near through mid - infrared seds ( fig . 1 ) , the close correspondence of the @xmath3-band through 3.6photometric data points with an elliptical galaxy template indicates that stellar emission dominates in this wavelength regime in every galaxy . to account for this , we normalize a 13 gyr elliptical galaxy template @xcite to the @xmath3 and @xmath37 band flux densities . with this simple normalization ,
the elliptical galaxy sed predicts the 3.68.0 flux densities for 21 of the 46 ( 46% ) galaxies remarkably well .
these include the entire membership of the evolved and x - ray - bright hcgs 42 and 62 .
the remaining 25 galaxies ( counting hcg 31ace as 3 galaxies ) , have mid - infrared continua that rise to longer wavelengths .
this clear qualitative difference is illustrated quantitatively with the histogram of @xmath1 values shown in figure [ fig : hists]b .
no hcg galaxy nuclei inhabit the parameter space between @xmath1 values of @xmath43 and 0.25 ; for the integrated hcg galaxy seds , the distribution is comparable , with none found in the range of @xmath1(gal ) of @xmath43 to 0.12 .
this is in stark contrast to the distribution of @xmath1 values of the sings galaxies ( plotted in the same figure ) that shows a significant fraction within the hcg gap .
we also point out a noticeable peak near @xmath1@xmath44 for the sings galaxies whereas the hcg galaxies ( and nuclei ) are more evenly distributed from @xmath45 to @xmath46 .
the larger number of hcg objects with @xmath1@xmath47 compared to sings galaxies likely reflects the larger number of early types in the former sample . however , morphological differences do not account for all of the discrepancy , as a direct comparison of the spirals in the two samples finds that while 11 of 47 ( 23% ) of the sings spirals have @xmath1 values in the range from 1.3 to 0 , none of the 17 hcg spirals do .
a kolmogorov - smirnov analysis confirms the overall differences in the populations , giving only 0.12% and 0.35% probabilities that the sings galaxies are drawn from the same distribution as the hcg nuclei and galaxies , respectively .
( the hcg nuclei and galaxies are consistent with eachother at 22.5% probability . )
hereafter , we will utilize the break in the hcg @xmath1 distribution to distinguish `` mid - infrared active '' ( @xmath1@xmath48 ) from `` mid - infrared quiescent '' ( @xmath1@xmath49 ) nuclei and galaxies .
we investigate this difference in more detail by plotting @xmath1 vs. @xmath50 for both the hcg and sings galaxies , coded by galaxy morphology in figure [ fig : alphalum24 ] .
it is perhaps most illuminating to compare the sings and hcg spiral galaxies ( @xmath51 symbols in fig .
[ fig : alphalum24 ] ) .
while the two groups cover a comparable range of @xmath50 , the hcg galaxies are systematically redder in the mid - infrared , i.e. , with more negative values of @xmath1 . within the hcg galaxies , morphology is evidently a strong predictor of @xmath1 , with elliptical and s0 galaxies almost exclusively populating the parameter space of @xmath1@xmath47 .
we next consider the utility of measuring @xmath34 , the fraction of @xmath32 attributable to non - stellar ( i.e. , hot dust ) emission .
a plot of @xmath34 vs. @xmath52 shows a clear positive correlation in the hcg population , with higher values of @xmath52 corresponding to larger values of @xmath34 , as shown in figure [ fig : fracd]a .
this correlation is highly significant according to the non - parametric spearman s @xmath53 test which gives a probability , @xmath54 , of @xmath55 for @xmath56 that these parameters are uncorrelated .
while the hcg nuclei known to have optical absorption - line spectra ( filled circles ) all have values of @xmath34@xmath57 consistent with purely stellar emission and @xmath52@xmath58 hz@xmath19 , there is no clear separation in this parameter space between galaxies identified as agns or star - forming .
this is perhaps surprising , as one might expect agns to have larger values of @xmath34 than star - forming galaxies because of the typically hotter temperatures of dust emission associated with harder ionizing continua .
this is true even for seyfert 2 galaxies that are typically assumed to have intrinsic absorption that blocks the direct line of sight to the accretion disk ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
one source of hot dust emission in star - forming galaxies that may contribute significantly at @xmath59 is from dust shells around agb stars , ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the five known low - ionization nuclear emission region ( liner ) galaxies ( open squares ) , which can be powered by either star - formation or accretion ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , also do not lie in a distinct region within this parameter space .
the recent mid - infrared spectroscopic survey of @xcite found two distinct liner populations separable by infrared luminosity ; the two populations can be divided at @xmath60@xmath61 ( where @xmath62 is integrated from 81000 ) . in brief , infrared emission lines ,
continuum shape , and pah features indicate that infrared - luminous liners are more closely linked to starburst galaxies , while infrared - faint liners were identified primarily with agns
. however , the presence of high ionization lines such as [ ] seems to indicate that as many as 90% of all liners in their sample contain agns , though accretion power is not energetically dominant in the majority of cases .
the two liners in our sample with no evidence for mid - infrared activity , 42a and 62a , are known x - ray sources , and therefore likely do host agns .
their low mid - infrared luminosities and weak emission - line signatures in the optical indicate that the agns are not particularly powerful .
given that their values of of 4.0@xmath63 and 6.6@xmath63@xmath61 are also the two lowest in the sample , they might be identified with the infrared - faint liners of @xcite .
the other three ( 16a , 16d , and 90d ) may therefore be star - formation powered , though this remains ambiguous without mid - infrared spectra .
focusing on longer wavelengths , three galaxies show evidence for dust emission at 24 that is not evident when only considering the irac data .
in particular , a plot of @xmath40 vs. @xmath4 reveals a clear separation between galaxies at @xmath4@xmath64 , see figure [ fig : fracd]b . with only one exception ( 62d ) ,
all known hcg absorption - line galaxies have @xmath4@xmath65 and @xmath40@xmath66 .
none of the identified star - forming galaxies is in that region , while two liners ( 42a and 62a ) and one optical agn ( 22a ) are . while all of the galaxies identified as mid - infrared - active from their values of @xmath1@xmath67 have @xmath40@xmath68 and @xmath4@xmath69 , an additional three galaxies , the seyfert 2s 16b and 61a and the absorption - line galaxy 62d , appear as 24-excess sources .
an examination of their mid - infrared seds ( fig .
[ fig : sed ] ) indicates that these galaxies likely include a strong contribution from stellar photospheric emission throughout most of the irac bands , and only at 24 , near a minimum of the elliptical template sed , is there sufficient contrast to see the low - luminosity dust continuum .
hereafter , we designate all sources with @xmath4@xmath70 and @xmath40@xmath68 as `` 24-active '' . combining diagnostics of mid - infrared and 24 activity , @xmath40 vs. @xmath1
is shown in figure [ fig : alphas ] , coded by both richness ( as listed in column 9 of table [ tab : groups ] ) and galaxy morphology . in this plot , it is clear again that all nuclei designated as mid - infrared - active are also 24-active , though the converse is not true for three objects .
the dashed line represents @xmath1=@xmath40 , and the elliptical galaxy nuclei ( with the exception of 62d ) are all tightly clustered near this line .
these objects are also typically in -poor groups .
nuclei from each of the most -rich ( type i ) groups , 2 , 16 , 31 , and 61 , have the most negative ( reddest ) @xmath1 values .
this implies a connection between the availability of and 24activity from both agns and star formation .
however , not all nuclei within an -rich group are 24-active , though the fraction is quite high ranging from 67 to 100% for the four -rich groups ( see table [ tab : groups ] ) . evaluating the relationship between the fraction of 24-active ( @xmath4@xmath70 ) nuclei and group mass as shown in figure [ fig : gas]a
, the non - parametric spearman s @xmath53 test gives a probability , @xmath54 , of only @xmath71 for @xmath72 that these parameters are uncorrelated .
considering only mid - infrared - active galaxies , the correlation is less significant ( @xmath73 ; @xmath74 ) , though still present .
thirty - one of the 46 hcg galaxies have @xmath75 masses ( including 14 upper limits ) calculated from co surveys @xcite .
( of these , 90bd and 31ace were unresolved in the radio images . ) in a plot of @xmath75 vs. @xmath50 , the most mid - infrared luminous nuclei have large amounts of @xmath75 , however , there is quite a large scatter as shown in figure [ fig : gas]b . in fact ,
not all mid - infrared luminous galaxies have large @xmath75 reservoirs .
however , more complete and deeper molecular gas surveys are needed to explore this relationship in further detail .
given the proximity of our targets , the _ spitzer _
angular resolution offers a handle on investigating the difference between nuclear and integrated galaxy parameters for identifying potential nuclear activity .
this is particularly relevant for survey work , where more distant objects are typically unresolved with _
spitzer_. using the criterion that values of @xmath1@xmath48 indicate mid - infrared activity , the galaxy and nuclear data for the hcg sample are completely consistent ( see figure [ fig : hists]b ) . at longer wavelengths , however , there are some discrepancies . in particular , @xmath4@xmath70 as the discriminant for a 24 excess yields some differences depending on whether the integrated galaxy light or nuclear light is considered .
though all galaxies with @xmath4@xmath76 also have @xmath4@xmath77 , four additional galaxies 7b , 42a , 42b , and 90b have 24 excesses in their integrated galaxy light .
this is also evident from visual inspection of their seds as plotted in figure [ fig : sed ] .
the values of @xmath4 of the integrated galaxy vs. nuclear light are shown in figure [ fig : galnuc ] .
the four discrepant galaxies are all early type ( sb0 , e3 , sb0 , and e0 , respectively ) ; the 24 excess is thus evidence of low - level star formation occurring outside of the nuclei in these galaxies .
if such objects were at a much greater distance such as typical of large area surveys , the corresponding lack of spatial resolution could therefore lead to inaccuracies in the nuclear classification based on mid - infrared data alone .
no activity would be missed , but some objects would be classified as 24- active ( and therefore potentially hosting llagns ) where extranuclear star formation is in fact responsible .
of the complete set of 46 hcg galaxies presented in the _ spitzer _ imaging survey of j07 , we have identified 25 with red ( @xmath1@xmath48 ) mid - infrared continua .
all eight known , spectroscopically identified star - forming galaxies ( 7a , 16c , 19c , 22c , 31ace , and 31b ) are within this group .
an additional three galaxies ( 16b , 61a , and 62b all optically identified agns ) are apparently quiescent in the irac bands but show evidence for a 24-excess above a stellar continuum , bringing the total number of 24-active hcg galaxies to 61% ( as all of the mid - infrared active galaxies are also 24-active ) .
this is higher than the fraction of emission - line galaxies ( including agns and star - forming galaxies ) identified in optical spectroscopic surveys of hcgs @xcite , and highlights the utility of multiwavelength studies to capture all activity . though the mid - infrared analysis presented here has the advantage of being unambiguous in terms of identifying mid - infrared activity
the distribution of hcg nuclei is clearly bimodal in terms of both @xmath1 and @xmath4 distinguishing between accretion and star formation as the dominant source of mid - infrared power remains challenging .
the evident trend in figure [ fig : alphalum24 ] between @xmath1 and @xmath50 seen in mid - infrared active galaxy nuclei could be interpreted as an increasing contribution from star formation at higher @xmath50 and redder ( more negative ) values of @xmath1 .
establishing this would be extremely powerful for interpreting photometric data of fainter objects in wide field surveys .
however , the significant correlation between @xmath34 and @xmath52 , which might similarly be read to imply a stronger agn component ( because of the greater hot dust contribution at 4.5 ) at larger values of @xmath52 , is not generally consistent with the known nuclear identifications from optical spectroscopy .
this implies that simple measures of the steepness of the mid - infrared continuum are not diagnostic underscoring the difficulty of using mid - infrared photometry alone to categorize objects .
even with high signal - to - noise mid - infrared spectroscopy , the underlying source of mid - infrared power can remain ambiguous in some objects ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
furthermore , the strong stellar contamination at 3.6 in all of these galaxies means that color - color diagnostics that use the ratio of 3.6 to 4.5fluxes to isolate agns ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) likely miss a large fraction of them , particularly at lower infrared luminosities .
selection criteria with a wider dynamic range in color will be less sensitive to this effect ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) .
however , as noted by j07 , none of our sample would fulfill the agn mid - infrared color - color selection criteria of @xcite or @xcite , which were designed to target objects where the agn dominates the mid - infrared sed .
our entire sample would also fail the power - law agn selection criterion of @xcite that required a monotonic flux increase from 3.6 to 8.0 .
a few optically identified llagns
22a , 42a , and 62a show no evidence for any excess mid - infrared ( including 24 ) emission , indicating that warm to hot dust emission does not always accompany accretion onto a black hole
. however , without a reservoir of cold material , an optically detectable agn may be short - lived . in any case
, such a system is unlikely to contribute significantly to the luminous energy budget of its host galaxy . given their weak emission lines ( which would be strongly diluted by host galaxy light at larger distances ; moran02 ) , these three galaxies may be identified with the optically dull but x - ray detected agns found in clusters @xcite .
the evolved nature of their host groups and the x - ray detections of 42a and 62a in particular are consistent with identifying these systems as mini - clusters . in contrast , the less evolved compact groups may be less likely to host x - ray bright , optically quiet galaxies , as found in the loose group survey of @xcite . at present
, the lack of a complete suite of optical spectroscopy and high quality x - ray observations of our galaxy sample complicates definitively fitting the compact groups in context with the agn surveys in the loose group and cluster environments done to date .
the striking difference between the distribution of @xmath1 values for the hcg and sings galaxies supports the role of environment in affecting hcg galaxies a conclusion consistent with the marked difference in the mid - infrared color - color distribution of hcg and fls galaxies noted by j07 .
in particular , the strongly bimodal nature of hcg nuclear ( and galaxy ) @xmath1 values as well as the correlation between group content and 24 activity suggests that star formation in a compact group galaxy , likely induced by interactions , occurs in a burst that then exhausts its reservoir of cold gas , as suggested previously from far - infrared @xcite and optical spectroscopic @xcite studies .
the end result is a group dominated by mid - infrared quiescent galaxies .
if local compact galaxy groups are analogous to the building blocks of clusters in the early universe , this implies that the exhaustion of cold gas through enhanced star - formation occurs as a result of interactions ( though not necessarily mergers ) prior to cluster infall .
any agn activity in those galaxies at that point would proceed in a low - luminosity , x - ray bright mode @xcite .
however , tully - fisher @xcite and fundamental plane studies @xcite of hcg galaxies reveal that they are consistent with control galaxy populations .
therefore , there is no strong evidence for a significant effect of the compact group environment on the current states of galaxy morphology in such a significant way that would alter the end states of galaxy evolution . from a stellar population study of hcg ellipticals
, @xcite concluded that these galaxies showed evidence for truncated star formation in comparison to a ( very small ) sample of field ellipticals .
while this may be the case , the mechanism for star formation truncation is unlikely to be extensive feedback from agn activity .
none of the optically known agns in any hcg has sufficient luminosity to clear a galaxy of its interstellar medium .
the sole possible exception to this observation is 62a , where x - ray cavities in the intragroup medium suggest that a relativistic jet has ejected a sigificant amount of kinetic energy from a radiatively quiet agn ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . however , this ongoing process likely postdates the epoch of star formation in this evolved group .
we thank justin howell for helpful suggestions , and karen peterson for contributions to an early version of this work .
we thank paul martini and varoujan gorjian for their useful feedback .
this work is based on observations made with the _ spitzer _ space telescope , which is operated by jpl / caltech under a contract with nasa .
support for this work was provided by nasa through an award issued by jpl / caltech .
k. e. j. gratefully acknowledges partial support for this research for this research provided by nsf / career grant ast-0548103 .
this project has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) and the infrared science archive ( irsa ) , operated by jpl / caltech , under contract with nasa .
this publication also makes use of 2mass ( http://www.ipac.caltech.edu/2mass ) data products .
lcccccrccr 2 & 4309 & 0 & 0 & 2 & 1 & 10.53 & early & i & 3/3 + 7 & 4233 & 0 & 1 & 3 & 0 & 9.68 & early & ii & 3/4 + 16 & 3957 & 0 & 0 & 2 & 2 & 10.42 & int & i & 3(1)/4 + 19 & 4245 & 1 & 0 & 2 & 0 & 9.31 & early / int & ii & 2/3 + 22 & 2686 & 1 & 0 & 2 & 0 & 9.13 & early & ii & 1/3 + 31 & 4094 & 0 & 0 & 4 & 2 & 10.35 & int & i & 6/6 + 42 & 3976 & 3 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 9.40 & late & iii & 0/4 + 48 & 3162 & 2 & 1 & 1 & 0 & 8.52 & late & iii & 1/4 + 59 & 4058 & 1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & 9.49 & early / int & ii & 3/4 + 61 & 3907 & 0 & 2 & 1 & 0 & 9.96 & early / int & i & 1(1)/3 + 62 & 4122 & 2 & 2 & 0 & 0 & 9.06 & late & iii & 0(1)/4 + 90 & 2644 & 2 & 0 & 1 & 1 & 8.60 & int & iii & 2/4 + lrrrrrrrr 2a & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 + 2b & @xmath86 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 + 2c & @xmath94 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 + 7a & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 + 7b & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & @xmath112 & @xmath87 & @xmath113 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 + 7c & @xmath78 & @xmath90 & @xmath117 & @xmath118 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 & @xmath121 & @xmath122 + 7d & @xmath123 & @xmath124 & @xmath95 & @xmath125 & @xmath116 & @xmath99 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 + 16a & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 & @xmath134 & @xmath135 + 16b & @xmath136 & @xmath137 & @xmath138 & @xmath139 & @xmath140 & @xmath141 & @xmath142 & @xmath143 + 16c & @xmath144 & @xmath145 & @xmath146 & @xmath147 & @xmath148 & @xmath149 & @xmath150 & @xmath151 + 16d & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & @xmath147 & @xmath154 & @xmath155 & @xmath156 & @xmath157 & @xmath158 + 19a & @xmath159 & @xmath160 & @xmath161 & @xmath162 & @xmath163 & @xmath164 & @xmath165 & @xmath166 + 19b & @xmath167 & @xmath168 & @xmath169 & @xmath170 & @xmath125 & @xmath164 & @xmath171 & @xmath172 + 19c & @xmath173 & @xmath125 & @xmath97 & @xmath174 & @xmath175 & @xmath176 & @xmath177 & @xmath170 + 22a & @xmath178 & @xmath179 & @xmath180 & @xmath181 & @xmath182 & @xmath183 & @xmath184 & @xmath185 + 22b & @xmath186 & @xmath187 & @xmath188 & @xmath185 & @xmath189 & @xmath190 & @xmath191 & @xmath192 + 22c & @xmath193 & @xmath194 & @xmath115 & @xmath195 & @xmath116 & @xmath190 & @xmath196 & @xmath118 + 31ace & @xmath197 & @xmath198 & @xmath80 & @xmath194 & @xmath185 & @xmath199 & @xmath200 & @xmath201 + 31b & @xmath202 & @xmath203 & @xmath125 & @xmath204 & @xmath205 & @xmath206 & @xmath207 & @xmath208 + 31 g & @xmath209 & @xmath208 & @xmath194 & @xmath189 & @xmath97 & @xmath210 & @xmath211 & @xmath212 + 31q & @xmath213 & @xmath214 & @xmath116 & @xmath175 & @xmath215 & @xmath216 & @xmath217 & @xmath218 + 42a & @xmath219 & @xmath220 & @xmath221 & @xmath136 & @xmath222 & @xmath223 & @xmath184 & @xmath81 + 42b & @xmath139 & @xmath224 & @xmath225 & @xmath226 & @xmath227 & @xmath228 & @xmath229 & @xmath204 + 42c & @xmath230 & @xmath231 & @xmath232 & @xmath233 & @xmath234 & @xmath235 & @xmath236 & @xmath125 + 42d & @xmath237 & @xmath188 & @xmath117 & @xmath170 & @xmath238 & @xmath239 & @xmath240 & @xmath241 + 48a & @xmath242 & @xmath243 & @xmath244 & @xmath245 & @xmath246 & @xmath247 & @xmath248 & @xmath170 + 48b & @xmath249 & @xmath250 & @xmath251 & @xmath79 & @xmath127 & @xmath252 & @xmath253 & @xmath254 + 48c & @xmath255 & @xmath121 & @xmath256 & @xmath198 & @xmath118 & @xmath257 & @xmath258 & @xmath205 + 48d & @xmath78 & @xmath259 & @xmath198 & @xmath82 & @xmath260 & @xmath261 & @xmath240 & @xmath241 + 59a & @xmath262 & @xmath263 & @xmath172 & @xmath113 & @xmath264 & @xmath247 & @xmath265 & @xmath266 + 59b & @xmath267 & @xmath268 & @xmath90 & @xmath269 & @xmath125 & @xmath270 & @xmath271 & @xmath215 + 59c & @xmath272 & @xmath82 & @xmath273 & @xmath204 & @xmath205 & @xmath274 & @xmath275 & @xmath276 + 59d & @xmath277 & @xmath204 & @xmath205 & @xmath175 & @xmath215 & @xmath278 & @xmath279 & @xmath276 + 61a & @xmath280 & @xmath281 & @xmath282 & @xmath283 & @xmath284 & @xmath247 & @xmath285 & @xmath286 + 61c & @xmath287 & @xmath288 & @xmath289 & @xmath290 & @xmath291 & @xmath292 & @xmath293 & @xmath294 + 61d & @xmath295 & @xmath296 & @xmath297 & @xmath298 & @xmath299 & @xmath300 & @xmath301 & @xmath214 + 62a & @xmath302 & @xmath303 & @xmath304 & @xmath305 & @xmath306 & @xmath307 & @xmath308 & @xmath203 + 62b & @xmath254 & @xmath309 & @xmath254 & @xmath310 & @xmath311 & @xmath312 & @xmath313 & @xmath203 + 62c & @xmath314 & @xmath315 & @xmath316 & @xmath268 & @xmath126 & @xmath317 & @xmath275 & @xmath204 + 62d & @xmath318 & @xmath319 & @xmath320 & @xmath118 & @xmath203 & @xmath321 & @xmath191 & @xmath97 + 90a & @xmath322 & @xmath323 & @xmath324 & @xmath325 & @xmath326 & @xmath327 & @xmath328 & @xmath329 + 90b & @xmath330 & @xmath331 & @xmath332 & @xmath333 & @xmath334 & @xmath335 & @xmath336 & @xmath208 + 90c & @xmath337 & @xmath338 & @xmath339 & @xmath340 & @xmath341 & @xmath342 & @xmath343 & @xmath269 + 90d & @xmath344 & @xmath345 & @xmath346 & @xmath347 & @xmath348 & @xmath349 & @xmath350 & @xmath351 + lrrrrrrrrrrrl 2a & sbd & r & @xmath329 & @xmath352 & @xmath353 & 28.33 & 28.03 & 28.88 & 29.13 & @xmath354 & 1.00 & 1 + 2b & ci & r & @xmath329 & @xmath355 & @xmath356 & 28.64 & 28.43 & 29.46 & 29.99 & @xmath357 & 1.00 & 1 + 2c & sbc & ? & @xmath329 & @xmath358 & @xmath359 & 28.01 & 27.53 & 28.19 & 28.14 & @xmath360 & 0.98 & + 7a & sb & hii & @xmath361 & @xmath362 & @xmath363 & 29.14 & 28.79 & 29.52 & 29.82 & @xmath364 & 0.99 & 2 + 7b & sb0 & ?
& @xmath365 & @xmath366 & @xmath367 & 28.99 & 28.44 & 28.09 & 27.59 & @xmath368 & 0.34 & + 7c & sbc & ? & @xmath369 & @xmath370 & @xmath371 & 28.31 & 27.92 & 28.73 & 28.84 & @xmath372 & 0.99 & + 7d & sbc & ? & @xmath373 & @xmath374 & @xmath375 & 28.11 & 27.61 & 28.25 & 28.20 & @xmath376 & 0.98 & + 16a & sbab & lnr , x , r & @xmath377 & @xmath378 & @xmath379 & 29.23 & 28.90 & 29.72 & 29.87 & @xmath380 & 0.99 & 1 , 3 , 6 + 16b & sab & sy2 & @xmath381 & @xmath382 & @xmath383 & 29.11 & 28.57 & 28.52 & 28.54 & @xmath384 & 0.90 & 3 + 16c & i m & sbng & @xmath385 & @xmath386 & @xmath387 & 29.04 & 28.98 & 30.12 & 30.49 & @xmath388 & 1.00 & 3 + 16d & i m & lnr & @xmath389 & @xmath390 & @xmath391 & 28.97 & 28.94 & 29.96 & 30.63 & @xmath392 & 1.00 & 3 + 19a & e2 & abs & @xmath329 & @xmath393 & @xmath394 & 28.94 & 28.36 & 28.05 & 27.48 & @xmath395 & 0.25 & 3 + 19b & scd & ? & @xmath329 & @xmath396 & @xmath397 & 28.21 & 27.85 & 28.68 & 28.68 & @xmath398 & 0.99 & 4 + 19c & sdm & elg & @xmath329 & @xmath399 & @xmath400 & 27.66 & 27.26 & 27.86 & 28.01 & @xmath401 & 0.99 & + 22a & e2 & dsy2 & @xmath402 & @xmath403 & @xmath404 & 29.01 & 28.47 & 28.21 & 27.74 & @xmath405 & 0.50 & 3 + 22b & sa & abs & @xmath406 & @xmath407 & @xmath408 & 28.05 & 27.52 & 27.19 & 26.85 & @xmath409 & 0.57 & 4 + 22c & sbcd & elg & @xmath410 & @xmath411 & @xmath384 & 27.76 & 27.21 & 27.72 & 27.70 & @xmath409 & 0.97 & 4 + 31ace & sdm & hii & @xmath412 & @xmath413 & @xmath414 & 28.25 & 28.14 & 29.16 & 30.03 & @xmath388 & 1.00 & 2 + 31b & sm & hii & @xmath415 & @xmath416 & @xmath417 & 27.85 & 27.33 & 27.86 & 28.24 &
@xmath418 & 0.99 & 2 + 31 g & i m & ? & @xmath419 & @xmath420 & @xmath421 & 28.21 & 27.71 & 28.32 & 28.92 & @xmath422 & 1.00 & + 31q & i m & ? & @xmath329 & @xmath423 & @xmath354 & 27.57 & 27.09 & 27.31 & 27.09 & @xmath376 & 0.92 & + 42a & e3 & dlnr , x & @xmath329 & @xmath424 & @xmath425 & 29.39 & 28.86 & 28.55 & 28.09 & @xmath426 & 0.46 & 3 , 6 + 42b & sb0 & abs & @xmath329 & @xmath427 & @xmath428 & 28.81 & 28.24 & 27.94 & 27.49 & @xmath429 & 0.45 & 4 + 42c & e2 & abs & @xmath329 & @xmath430 & @xmath408 & 28.96 & 28.40 & 28.11 & 27.76 & @xmath397 & 0.58 & 4 + 42d & e2 & abs & @xmath329 & @xmath431 & @xmath432 & 28.29 & 27.73 & 27.35 & 26.58 & @xmath397 & 0.05 & 4 + 48a & e2 & abs & @xmath433 & @xmath434 & @xmath435 & 29.09 & 28.54 & 28.24 & 27.75 & @xmath368 & 0.41 & 4 + 48b & sc & x & @xmath436 & @xmath437 & @xmath395 & 28.39 & 27.97 & 28.83 & 28.84 & @xmath438 & 0.99 & + 48c & s0a & ? & @xmath439 & @xmath440 & @xmath441 & 28.38 & 27.83 & 27.53 & 27.08 & @xmath397 & 0.47 & + 48d & e1 & ? & @xmath442 & @xmath443 & @xmath432 & 28.06 & 27.50 & 27.15 & 26.38 & @xmath395 & 0.05 & + 59a & sa & ? & @xmath444 & @xmath445 & @xmath446 & 28.63 & 28.37 & 29.10 & 30.09 & @xmath447 & 1.00 & + 59b & e0 & ? & @xmath448 & @xmath449 & @xmath450 & 28.35 & 27.78 & 27.50 & 27.08 & @xmath451 & 0.51 & + 59c & sc & ? & @xmath415 & @xmath452 & @xmath453 & 27.87 & 27.33 & 27.88 & 27.81 & @xmath426 & 0.97 & + 59d & i m & ? & @xmath454 & @xmath455 & @xmath456 & 27.46 & 27.09 & 27.46 & 27.82 & @xmath457 & 0.99 & + 61a & s0a & sy2,r & @xmath458 & @xmath459 & @xmath460 & 29.22 & 28.72 & 28.58 & 28.45 & @xmath409 & 0.84 & 2 , 5 + 61c & sbc & agn , r & @xmath461 & @xmath462 & @xmath463 & 28.92 & 28.81 & 29.71 & 29.86 & @xmath464 & 1.00 & 2 , 5 + 61d & s0 & abs & @xmath465 & @xmath466 & @xmath467 & 28.82 & 28.28 & 28.01 & 27.61 & @xmath397 & 0.55 & 2 , 6 + 62a & e3 & dlnr , x & @xmath329 & @xmath468 & @xmath435 & 29.19 & 28.62 & 28.33 & 27.85 & @xmath429 & 0.42 & 2 , 3 + 62b & s0 & abs , x & @xmath329 & @xmath469 & @xmath470 & 29.07 & 28.49 & 28.24 & 27.85 & @xmath383 & 0.56 & 2 , 4 + 62c & s0 & abs & @xmath329 & @xmath471 & @xmath472 & 28.81 & 28.21 & 27.89 & 27.52 & @xmath473 & 0.49 & 2 , 4 + 62d & e2 & abs & @xmath329 & @xmath474 & @xmath475 & 28.42 & 27.85 & 27.58 & 27.70 & @xmath476 & 0.87 & 4 + 90a & sa & sy2,x , r & @xmath477 & @xmath478 & @xmath479 & 28.87 & 29.02 & 29.48 & 30.03 & @xmath472 & 1.00 & 3 + 90b & e0 & abs , x & @xmath480 & @xmath481 & @xmath482 & 29.08 & 28.53 & 28.29 & 27.85 & @xmath397 & 0.55 & 4 + 90c & e0 & abs & @xmath483 & @xmath484 & @xmath367 & 28.97 & 28.41 & 28.11 & 27.61 & @xmath397 & 0.39 & 4 + 90d & i m & lnr , r & @xmath480 & @xmath485 & @xmath486 & 28.80 & 28.42 & 29.02 & 29.30 & @xmath487 & 0.99 & 3 + | we present a sample of 46 galaxy nuclei from 12 nearby ( @xmath0 ) hickson compact groups ( hcgs ) with a complete suite of 124 2mass+_spitzer _ nuclear photometry .
for all objects in the sample , blue emission from stellar photospheres dominates in the near - infrared through the 3.6 irac band .
twenty - five of 46 ( 54% ) galaxy nuclei show red , mid - infrared continua characteristic of hot dust powered by ongoing star formation and/or accretion onto a central black hole .
we introduce @xmath1 , the spectral index of a power - law fit to the 4.58.0 irac data , and demonstrate that it cleanly separates the mid - infrared active and non - active hcg nuclei .
this parameter is more powerful for identifying low to moderate - luminosity mid - infrared activity than other measures which include data at rest - frame @xmath2 that may be dominated by stellar photospheric emission . while the hcg galaxies clearly have a bimodal distribution in this parameter space , a comparison sample from the _ spitzer _ nearby galaxy survey ( sings ) matched in @xmath3-band total galaxy luminosity is continuously distributed .
a second diagnostic , the fraction of 24 emission in excess of that expected from quiescent galaxies , @xmath4 , reveals an additional three nuclei to be active at 24 .
comparing these two mid - infrared diagnostics of nuclear activity to optical spectroscopic identifications from the literature reveals some discrepancies , and we discuss the challenges of distinguishing the source of ionizing radiation in these and other lower luminosity systems .
we find a significant correlation between the fraction of mid - infrared active galaxies and the total mass in a group , and investigate possible interpretations of these results in light of galaxy evolution in the highly interactive system of a compact group environment . |
low surface brightness ( lsb ) spiral galaxies are defined as having central disk surface brightnesses @xmath3 23 mag arcsec@xmath4 , indicating low stellar surface densities . however , despite their faint optical appearances , the majority of lsb spirals show evidence for ongoing star formation , including blue colors , h@xmath5 emission and/or resolved populations of young stars ( e.g. , schombert et al .
1992 ; gallagher & matthews 2002 ) .
signatures of star formation are frequently coupled with large atomic gas fractions ( @xmath61 ) , underscoring that lsb spirals are not the faded remnants of brighter galaxies . in a number of cases ,
evidence is also seen for stellar populations spanning a wide range of ages ( e.g. , van den hoek et al . 2000 ) , implying that lsb spirals have been forming stars for a significant fraction of a hubble time but with low efficiency .
lingering questions regarding the evolutionary history of lsb spirals are _ why _ their star formation has remained suppressed , and what physical processes regulate the type of low - level star formation that is observed in these systems . given that lsb spirals comprise a significant fraction ( @xmath750% ) of the local disk galaxy population ( e.g. , minchin et al .
2004 ) , answers to these questions are crucial for our overall understanding of the star formation history of the universe .
in addition , they are relevant to understanding star formation in other low - density and/or low - metallicity environments , including protogalaxies , the outskirts of giant galaxies , and damped ly@xmath5 absorption systems .
key to understanding the process of star formation in lsb spirals is an improved knowledge of the composition and structure of their interstellar medium ( ism ) . to date , most of our knowledge of the ism in lsb spirals comes from studies of their gas , which appears to be by far the dominant component of their ism ( 95% by mass ) .
studies have shown that while is typically present throughout the stellar disk of lsb spirals , surface densities often fall below the critical threshold for instability - driven star formation throughout most or all of their disks ( e.g. , van der hulst et al . 1993 ; de blok et al .
1996 ) .
in a broad sense , the low densities of lsb spirals seem to account naturally for their inefficient star formation . however , this explanation is not entirely satisfactory for several reasons .
first , important ism parameters including the gas scale height , volume density , and turbulent velocity remain poorly constrained .
secondly , we know some star formation is occurring in lsb spirals in spite of subcritical surface densities .
furthermore , it is ultimately from the molecular , not the atomic gas that stars form .
it is clear that a more comprehensive picture of star formation in lsb spirals requires a more complete knowledge of their multi - phase ism .
unfortunately , direct searches for molecular gas in lsb spirals have proved to be challenging .
indeed , initial searches for co emission from late - type , lsb spirals failed to yield any detections ( schombert et al .
1990 ; de blok & van der hulst 1998 ) , leading to the suggestions that the metallicities of typical lsb spiral may be too low for the formation of co molecules or efficient cooling of the gas , that the interstellar pressures may be insufficient to support molecular clouds , or that star formation may occur directly from the atomic medium ( schombert et al .
1990 ; bothun et al .
1997 ; mihos et al .
1999 ) . to partially circumvent the challenges of detecting co emission from lsb spirals , my collaborators and i began surveying examples of lsb spirals viewed _
edge - on _ , using observations 2 - 3 times deeper than previous studies .
our targets comprised extreme late - type ( scd - sm ) lsb spirals with redshifts @xmath82000 km s@xmath2 .
two advantages of our approach are : ( 1 ) the column depth of the molecular gas is enhanced for an edge - on geometry ; and ( 2 ) an edge - on viewing angle allows complementary studies of the vertical structure of various ism and stellar components of the galaxies at other wavelengths . in a pilot survey with the nrao 12-m telescope , we detected for the first time @xmath9co(1 - 0 ) emission from three late - type , lsb spiral galaxies ( matthews & gao 2001 ) .
more recently , we followed up with a more extensive survey of 15 lsb spirals in both the @xmath9co(1 - 0 ) and @xmath9co(2 - 1 ) lines using the iram 30-m telescope ( matthews et al .
2005 ; hereafter m05 ) . in this latter survey , we detected co emission from the nuclear regions of four lsb spirals , one of which was previously detected by matthews & gao ( 2001 ; fig .
[ fig : spectra ] ) . for the galaxies detected in these two surveys
, we estimate the molecular hydrogen content of the nuclear regions ( central 1 - 3 kpc ) to be @xmath10 , assuming a standard galactic co - to - h@xmath11 conversion factor . while the conversion of co flux to h@xmath11 mass in low - density
, low - metallicity galaxies can be rather uncertain , _
these observations have clearly established that at least some bulgeless , late - type , lsb spirals contain modest amounts of molecular gas in their nuclear regions , and that co traces at least some fraction of this gas .
_ in addition , our results establish that a bulge is not a prerequisite for the presence of molecular gas at the centers of low - density lsb galaxies .
therefore our surveys extend the realm of co - detected lsb spirals from the giant , bulge - dominated lsb systems detected by oneil et al .
( 2000,2003 ) and oneil & schinnerer ( 2004 ) to the more common , low - mass , pure - disk lsb systems . while the samples of late - type , lsb spirals surveyed in co are still small , already some interesting trends are emerging . here
i briefly describe two of our key findings . for further results and discussion ,
i refer the reader to m05 . for bright ,
massive spiral galaxies , there is a well - established correlation between far - infrared ( fir ) luminosity and h@xmath11 mass ( or co luminosity ; e.g. , young & scoville 1991 ) .
this correlation is assumed to arise from heating of dust grains embedded in giant molecular clouds ( gmcs ) by hot young stars .
there are a number of reasons why this correlation might break down for lsb spirals ; for example , if molecular gas in lsb spirals resides primarily outside gmcs , if their stellar mass function is biased toward low - mass stars ( lee et al .
2004 ) , or if the appropriate co - to - h@xmath11 conversion factor for these galaxies is very different from what we have assumed .
[ fig : fir ] shows a plot of the nuclear h@xmath11 masses ( or 3@xmath12 upper limits ) for our co survey galaxies , versus the fir luminosity derived from _
iras _ data . also plotted is a sample of extreme late - type spirals recently surveyed in co by boeker et al .
( 2003 ; hereafter b03 ) .
the b03 sample comprises the same range of redshifts and hubble types as our lsb spiral co surveys , but covers a wide range in surface brightness , including two lsb spirals [ @xmath13 mag arcsec@xmath4 ] , 15 intermediate surface brightness ( isb ) spirals [ @xmath15 mag arcsec@xmath4 ] , and 25 high surface brightness ( hsb ) spirals .
also overplotted as a solid line on fig .
[ fig : fir ] is the h@xmath11-fir relation derived by b03 for a sample of brighter , more massive galaxies .
[ fig : fir ] reveals that the co - detected lsb spirals delineate a remarkably tight extension of the h@xmath11-fir defined by brighter galaxies .
only a handful of the lsb / isb galaxies undetected in co show evidence of possible deviation from this correlation .
our findings suggest that as in brighter galaxies , the co detected in lsb spirals is associated with dense molecular clouds and sights of massive star formation rather than a more diffuse molecular medium . [
[ a - link - between - disk - rotational - velocity - and - the - detectability - of - co - in - low - mass - galaxies ] ] a link between disk rotational velocity and the detectability of co in low - mass galaxies ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ fig .
[ fig : w20 ] plots the nuclear h@xmath11 mass versus the inclination - corrected total linewidth ( @xmath16 ) for the same samples shown in fig .
[ fig : fir ] .
@xmath17 is related to the maximum rotational velocity of disk galaxies as @xmath18 ( see m05 ) .
we see that for larger rotational velocities ( @xmath19 km s@xmath2 ) , the quantities plotted on fig .
[ fig : w20 ] shows a nearly flat correlation .
however , for galaxies with @xmath20 km s@xmath2 ( corresponding to @xmath190 km s@xmath2 ) , the inferred nuclear h@xmath11 mass ( i.e. , the co detectability ) begins to drop significantly , and no isb or lsb spirals below this limit have so far been detected in co. as discussed by m05 , it appears that neither decreasing mean surface density , nor decreasing metallicity among the lower mass galaxies can fully account for this trend .
[ fig : w20 ] therefore points toward a decreasing concentration of molecular gas in the inner regions of galaxies with decreasing rotational velocity .
this trend seems to depend only weakly on optical central surface brightness in the sense that both lsb and isb galaxies show similar declines in co detectability with @xmath21 , although a few hsb systems with low @xmath21 do have co detections .
it is interesting to note that the characteristic velocity , @xmath2290
km s@xmath2 , below which we see a decline in the detectability of co among late - type spirals is similar to the velocity characterizing a slope change in the optical tully - fisher relation for -rich , extreme late - type disks found by matthews et al .
( 1998 ) ( @xmath2390 km s@xmath2 ) , the characteristic rotational velocity below which star formation appears to have been suppressed at high redshift ( @xmath23100 km s@xmath2 ; jimenez et al .
2005 ) , and the rotational velocity below which galaxy dust lanes are seen to disappear ( @xmath24120 km s@xmath2 ; dalcanton et al .
_ all of these results are consistent with fundamental changes in some key parameter(s ) governing the ism conditions and the regulation of star formation in low - mass galaxies_. possible causes could include : a decreasing fraction the disk unstable to gmc formation ( e.g. , li et al . 2005 ) , a change in the characteristic velocity for turbulence ( dalcanton et al .
2004 ) , an increasing fraction of the disk below the critical pressure needed for the existence of a cold ism phase ( elmegreen & parravano 1994 ) , the increasing dominance of gas relative to stars in the underlying disk potential , and/or decreasing effects of rotational shear ( e.g. , martin & kennicutt 2001 ) .
we are presently undertaking additional multiwavelength observations of our co survey sample to better constrain the importance of these various effects .
mass for extreme late - type spiral galaxies .
@xmath0 was derived from a single measurement with a telescope beam subtending @xmath70.2 - 2 kpc toward each galaxy s center .
open symbols are lsb spirals taken from three different sources : triangles ( matthews & gao 2001 ) ; diamonds ( m05 ) ; squares ( b03 ) . ` + ' symbols are hsb spirals and ` x ' symbols are isb spirals , both taken from b03.[fig : fir ] , height=360 ] | i summarize some results from the recent co survey of late - type , low surface brightness ( lsb ) spiral galaxies by matthews et al .
( 2005 ) .
we have now detected co emission from six late - type , lsb spirals , demonstrating that despite their typical low metallicities and low mean gas surface densities , some lsb galaxies contain a molecular medium that is traced by co. we find that the co - detected lsb spirals adhere to the same @xmath0-fir correlation as brighter galaxies .
we also find a significant drop - off in the detectability of co among low - to - intermediate surface brightness galaxies with @xmath190 km s@xmath2 , pointing toward fundamental changes in the physical conditions of the ism with decreasing disk mass . |
the phase diagram structure of spin - glasses remains an open field of inquiry , since most approaches to the problem rely on approximations . any exact analytical result in
this area is thus very valuable , both for the direct information it provides and as a test for approximation methods . over the last few years
striking progress has been made combining the replica method , duality , and symmetry arguments @xcite , an approach which has yielded the exact locations of the multicritical points in the ising and potts spin - glasses on the square lattice and in the four - dimensional random - plaquette gauge model .
the most recent result in this series @xcite is a general conjecture relating the multicritical point locations of any spin - glasses on a pair of mutually dual lattices . in support of the conjecture , estimates based on monte carlo simulations were given for ising spin - glasses , in @xmath2 , on the dual pairs of triangular and hexagonal lattices and , in @xmath3 , on the dual pairs of bilinear and lattice - gauge interactions on the cubic lattice . in both cases , within the numerical limitations ,
the conjecture is approximately satisfied .
we propose here to extensively test the conjecture in an alternative fashion using hierarchical lattices @xcite , by looking at ising spin - glasses on mutually dual pairs @xcite of such lattices .
these constitute ideal testing grounds , since an exact renormalization - group transformation for the quenched bond probability distribution can be constructed for such lattices , yielding global phase diagrams and critical properties .
accordingly , the location of the phase boundaries and of the multicritical points are precisely determined .
we thus investigate three pairs of hierarchical lattices , and in the end find that the conjecture is very nearly satisfied for all of them .
the ising spin - glass is given by the hamiltonian @xmath4 where @xmath5 at each site @xmath6 , @xmath7 denotes a sum over nearest - neighbor pairs of sites , and the bond strengths @xmath8 are equal to @xmath9 with probability @xmath10 and @xmath11 with probability @xmath12 . the limits @xmath13 and @xmath14 correspond to purely ferromagnetic and purely antiferromagnetic systems respectively . to give a brief overview of the conjecture ,
let us consider the model on an arbitrary lattice , and treat the randomness through the replica method , where the system is replicated @xmath15 times and the @xmath16 limit is eventually taken , in order to get results for the physical system .
the partition function of the @xmath15-replicated system after averaging over randomness , @xmath17 , can be expressed entirely as a function of @xmath18 `` averaged '' combinations of edge boltzmann factors , @xmath19 , associated with nearest - neighbor bonds @xcite .
these averaged boltzmann factors , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , have the form @xmath22 where the @xmath23th factor corresponds to a configuration with a parallel - spin bond in @xmath24 replicas and an antiparallel - spin bond in @xmath23 replicas @xcite .
thus , @xmath25 the partition function on the dual lattice , @xmath26 , can be expressed in a similar form , @xmath27 with the dual counterparts to the averaged boltzmann factors given by @xmath28 for @xmath29 .
@xmath17 and @xmath30 are related as @xcite @xmath31 where @xmath32 is a constant , which can be eliminated by using eq
. evaluated at two different sets of parameters , @xmath33 and @xmath34 , giving a relationship of the form @xmath35 the individual partition functions @xmath17 can be rewritten by extracting @xmath36 , the averaged boltzmann factor corresponding to an all - parallel spin state , thus effectively measuring the energy of the system relative to this state @xcite : @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the number of bonds in the lattice , and the reduced variables are @xmath39 .
. becomes @xmath40^{n_b } { \cal z}_n(u_1(p_1,j_1),\,\ldots,\,u_n(p_1,j_1))\\ & \qquad \cdot { \cal z}_n^\ast(u_1(p_2,j_2),\,\ldots,\,u_n(p_2,j_2))\\ & = [ x^\ast_0(p_1,j_1)x^\ast_0(p_2,j_2 ) ] ^{n_b } { \cal z}_n^\ast(u^\ast_1(p_1,j_1),\,\ldots,\,u^\ast_n(p_1,j_1))\\ & \qquad \cdot { \cal z}_n(u^\ast_1(p_2,j_2),\,\ldots,\,u^\ast_n(p_2,j_2))\ , . \end{split}\ ] ] in general , the form of eq .
is too complicated to yield useful information relating the locations of phase transitions .
however , the multicritical points in both original and dual systems are expected to lie @xcite on the nishimori line @xcite , which simplifies the relation .
furthermore , the conjecture advanced in ref .
@xcite states that , for the multicritical points @xmath41 of the original system and @xmath42 of its dual , eq . is satisfied when the leading boltzmann factors @xmath36 from each side are equal , @xmath43 since @xmath41 and @xmath42 lie on the nishimori line , @xmath44 from eqs .
and , eq . gives @xmath45 finally taking the limit , @xmath46 , one obtains the condition @xmath47 where @xmath48 .
as expressed in eq . , the conjecture is asserted to hold for multicritical points of ising spin - glasses on any pair of mutually dual lattices @xcite .
hierarchical lattices @xcite are constructed by replacing every single bond , in a connected cluster of bonds , with the connected cluster of bonds itself , and repeating this step an infinite number of times .
these provide models exactly solvable by renormalization group , with which complex problems have been studied and understood .
for example , frustrated @xcite , spin - glass @xcite , random - bond @xcite and random - field @xcite , schrdinger equation @xcite , lattice - vibration @xcite , dynamic scaling @xcite , aperiodic magnet @xcite , complex phase diagram @xcite , and directed - path @xcite systems , etc . ,
have been solved on hierarchical lattices . to test the conjecture of eq . , we study ising spin - glasses on the dual pairs of hierarchical lattices , depicted in figs .
[ lfig1 ] , [ lfig2 ] , and [ lfig3 ] .
each lattice in a given pair is the dual of the other .
these particular choice of lattices are motivated by their properties under renormalization - group transformation as related to physical lattices .
the hierarchical lattices of fig .
1(a ) and ( b ) yield the two variants of the migdal - kadanoff recursion relations @xcite for dimension @xmath2 with length rescaling factor @xmath49 .
similarly , the lattice in fig .
2(a ) yields a migdal - kadanoff recursion relation for @xmath3 , @xmath49 .
its dual lattice in fig .
2(b ) has @xmath50 .
( the two variants of the migdal - kadanoff recursion relations correspond to mutually dual hierarchical lattices only in @xmath2 . )
lastly , the hybrid lattice in fig .
3(a ) is interesting because it has been shown to give very accurate results for the critical temperatures of the @xmath3 isotropic and anisotropic ising model @xcite .
this lattice has @xmath51 , while its dual in fig .
3(b ) has @xmath50 .
, @xmath49 migdal - kadanoff recursion relations are exact . ] , @xmath49 . its dual lattice , in ( b ) , has @xmath52 , @xmath53 . ] , @xmath49 and @xmath52 , @xmath53 respectively . ] for a pure system , the renormalization - group transformation on a hierarchical lattice consists of a decimation by summing over the internal sites in each of the connected clusters making up the lattice ( the right - hand sides of figs . [ lfig1]-[lfig3 ] ) .
thus , the hierarchical lattice construction process is reversed , as each connected cluster is replaced by a single renormalized bond .
the decimation can be expressed as a mapping , @xmath54 where the set @xmath55 are all the bonds within the connected cluster of the original system and @xmath56 is the renormalized bond between sites @xmath57 and @xmath58 of the rescaled system . in the pure case ,
all @xmath8 bonds are independent for @xmath59 , and the implementation of eq .
is straightforward .
when quenched randomness is added to the system , the renormalization - group transformation is expressed in terms of quenched probability distributions @xcite , where the quenched probability distribution @xmath60 in the rescaled system is calculated from @xmath61 in the original system through the convolution @xmath62
\delta\left(j^\prime_{i^\prime j^\prime } - r(\{j_{ij}\})\right)\,.\ ] ] here the product runs over all the bonds @xmath59 in the connected cluster of the original system between sites @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
the recursion of the quenched probability distribution , eq . , is implemented numerically .
the probability distribution is represented by histograms , each histogram being specified by a bond strength and an associated probability .
thus , for the spin - glass problem , the starting distribution consists of two histograms , one at @xmath63 with probability @xmath10 , and one at @xmath11 with probability @xmath12 .
. dictates the convolution of 9 probability distributions for the lattices of fig .
[ lfig1 ] , and the convolution of 27 distributions for the lattices of figs .
[ lfig2 ] and [ lfig3 ] . in this task ,
computational storage limits can be maximally exploited by factorizing eq . into an equivalent series of pairwise convolutions , each of which involves only two distributions convoluted using an appropriate @xmath64 function .
the types of pairwise convolutions needed are a `` bond - moving '' convolution , with @xmath65 and a decimation convolution , with @xmath66\,,\ ] ] which is just the standard decimation transformation for a two - bond ising segment .
consider the hierarchical lattice in fig .
[ lfig1](a ) . if @xmath67 is the initial probability distribution , a series of pairwise convolutions which yields the total convolution of eq . for this lattice
is : ( i ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath68 with itself , yielding @xmath69 ; ( ii ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath69 with @xmath68 , yielding @xmath70 ; ( iii ) a decimation convolution of @xmath71 with itself , yielding @xmath72 ; ( iv ) a decimation convolution of @xmath72 with @xmath70 , yielding @xmath73 . for the lattice in fig .
[ lfig2](a ) , the series is : ( i ) a decimation convolution of @xmath68 with itself , yielding @xmath69 ; ( ii ) a decimation convolution of @xmath69 with @xmath68 , yielding @xmath70 ; ( iii ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath70 with itself , yielding @xmath72 ; ( iv ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath74 with itself , yielding @xmath75 ; ( v ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath75 with itself , yielding @xmath76 ; ( vi ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath76 with @xmath70 , yielding @xmath77 . for the lattice in fig .
[ lfig3](a ) , the series is : ( i ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath68 with itself , yielding @xmath69 ; ( ii ) a decimation convolution of @xmath69 with itself , yielding @xmath71 ; ( iii ) a decimation convolution of @xmath70 with @xmath78 , yielding @xmath72 ; ( iv ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath72 with itself , yielding @xmath75 ; ( v ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath75 with itself , yielding @xmath76 ; ( vi ) a decimation convolution of @xmath68 with itself , yielding @xmath79 ; ( vii ) a decimation convolution of @xmath80 with @xmath68 , yielding @xmath81 ; ( viii ) a bond - moving convolution of @xmath81 with @xmath76 , yielding @xmath77 . as for the dual lattices in figs .
[ lfig1](b ) , [ lfig2](b ) , and [ lfig3](b ) , the series of pairwise convolutions are identical to their counterparts above , except that each bond - moving is replaced by a decimation , and vice versa .
since the number of histograms that constitute the probability distribution increases rapidly with each renormalization iteration , a binning procedure is used when the desired ( large , namely up to @xmath0 ) number of histograms is reached : before every pairwise convolution , the histograms are placed on a grid , and all histograms falling into the same grid cell are combined into a single histogram in such a way that the average and the standard deviation of the probability distribution are preserved .
histograms falling outside the grid , representing a negligible part of the total probability , are similarly combined into a single histogram .
any histogram within a small neighborhood of a cell boundary is proportionately shared between the adjacent cells . in the current study
, the binning procedure is done separately for @xmath82 and @xmath83 .
after the convolution , the original number of histograms is reattained . in the current study ,
40,000 bins are generally used , representing the renormalization - group flows of 80,000 variables , requiring the calculation of 40,000 local renormalization - group transformations at each renormalization - group iteration .
the numerical results converge rapidly with increasing bin number . for maximal accuracy in determining the exact locations of the multicritical points , in the immediate vicinity of these points we used at least 1,000,000 histograms , representing the renormalization - group flows of 2,000,000 variables , requiring the calculation of 1,000,000 local renormalization - group transformations at each renormalization - group iteration .
it should thus be noted that our analysis is an exact numerical solution of ising spin - glasses on hierarchical lattices .
and @xmath84 probability bins were used in ( a ) and ( b ) respectively . ] global phase diagrams for the various hierarchical lattices are obtained from the renormalization - group flows of the probability distributions .
each phase has a corresponding sink , namely a completely stable fixed distribution .
the boundaries between phases flow to unstable fixed distributions , analysis of which yields the order of the phase transition and the values of the critical exponents of second- and higher - order transitions .
all the phase diagrams are plotted in terms antiferromagnetic bond concentration @xmath12 versus temperature @xmath86 .
the diagrams are symmetric around @xmath87 , with the ferromagnetic phase in the @xmath88 half - space mapping onto the antiferromagnetic phase in the @xmath89 half - space .
thus in the figures only the @xmath88 portions are shown .
4(a ) and ( b ) show the phase diagrams for the dual pair of hierarchical lattices in fig .
1(a ) and ( b ) respectively .
the phase structure of both diagrams is topologically identical to that of the @xmath2 ising spin - glass on a square lattice , which is only natural considering that the @xmath2 , @xmath49 migdal - kadanoff recursion relations are exact on these hierarchical lattices.@xcite the @xmath13 transition temperatures of the two models are related by the duality algebra @xcite which is also true for the two other pairs of mutually dual hierarchical models .
furthermore , the @xmath13 transition temperatures in fig .
4(a ) and ( b ) are related @xcite by @xmath91 since the mappings of the interaction constant in the repetition of renormalization - group transformations differs only by an initial bond strengthening by a factor of @xmath92 ; note that eq .
does not apply to @xmath93 , since there the bond - moving is not a mere multiplicative strengthening , but a @xmath94-fold convolution of the probability distributions that alters this distribution in a non - simple way .
. is also not applicable to the two other pairs of mutually dual models , since the repetition of renormalization - group transformations are not differentiated by only a preliminary bond - moving . in each of fig .
4(a ) and ( b ) , a ferromagnetic phase at low temperatures and low @xmath12 is separated from the disordered paramagnetic phase by two second - order phase boundaries , meeting at a multicritical point .
( in a narrow neighborhood of all multicritical points in our results , reentrance is observed : paramagnetic , then ferromagnetic , then paramagnetic or spin - glass phases are encountered as temperature is lowered at fixed @xmath12 . )
the two second - order boundaries flow to distinct unstable probability distributions with different critical exponents , constituting a strong violation of universality @xcite and consistent with the prediction , generally , of the absence of first - order transition under quenched randomness in @xmath2 .
@xcite as expected from symmetry considerations , the multicritical points fall @xcite precisely on the nishimori line @xcite as seen in table i. as also seen in table i , @xmath95 , so that the conjecture is realized to a very good approximation .
5 shows the phase diagrams for the dual pair of hierarchical lattices in fig . 2 .
while fig .
5(b ) has the same phase topology as the diagrams in fig . 4
, being at @xmath52 below the spin - glass lower - critical dimension , a different structure occurs in fig .
5(a ) . here the @xmath3
, @xmath49 migdal - kadanoff relations are exact on the hierarchical lattice , and for low temperatures in the vicinity of @xmath96 there exists a spin - glass phase .
the multicritical point occurs where the ferromagnetic , paramagnetic , and spin - glass phases meet .
as expected both multicritical points lie directly on the nishimori line . from table
i we see that @xmath97 , so that the conjecture is realized to a very good approximation , even when the mutually dual models belong to different dimensionalities @xmath1 and have different phase diagram topologies at the multicritical points of the conjecture . the phase diagram structures in fig . 6 , corresponding to the dual pair of hierarchical lattices in fig . 3 , are similar to those of fig . 5 , illustrating dimensions above and below the spin - glass lower - critical dimension .
again the multicritical points for both cases lie directly on the nishimori line . in this case @xmath98 , and the conjecture is realized to a very good approximation , again for mutually dual models belonging to different dimensionalities @xmath1 and having different phase diagram topologies at the multicritical points of the conjecture .
thus , we find that for all three mutually dual pairs of hierarchical lattices , the conjecture relating the locations of the multicritical points is satisfied to a very good approximation .
this is all the more remarkable , since , as seen in table i , the contributions of @xmath99 and @xmath100 to the conjecture are strongly asymmetric . however , it should be noted that ( 1.0172,0.9829,0.9911 ) , while being very close to 1 , are different from integer 1 . in our numerical implementation of the convolutions of the probability distributions ,
the results have converged to the precision of the digits shown in table i. further increase of the already very large number of probability bins does not change the entries in the table .
further tests of the conjecture , using other systems , would be very useful .
similar to our current study , the use of hierarchical lattices to study phenomena linked to mutually dual lattices , e.g. , ref .
@xcite , would also be very useful .
we thank h. nishimori and k. takeda for useful correspondance .
this research was supported by the scientific and technical research council of turkey ( tbitak ) and by the academy of sciences of turkey .
mh gratefully acknowledges the hospitality of the feza grsey research institute and of the physics department of istanbul technical university .
h. nishimori , prog .
. phys . * 66 * , 1169 ( 1981 ) .
h. nishimori and k. nemoto , j. phys .
japan * 71 * , 1198 ( 2002 ) .
maillard , k. nemoto , and h. nishimori , j. phys .
a : math . gen . * 36 * , 9799 ( 2003 ) .
k. takeda and h. nishimori , nucl .
b * 686 * , 377 ( 2004 ) .
k. takeda , t. sasamoto , and h. nishimori , j. phys .
gen . * 38 * , 3751 ( 2005 ) .
a.n . berker and s. ostlund , j. phys .
c * 12 * , 4961 ( 1979 ) .
m. kaufman and r.b .
griffiths , phys .
b * 24 * , 496 ( 1981 ) .
m. kaufman and r.b .
griffiths , phys .
b * 30 * , 244 ( 1984 ) . m. kaufman and d. andelman , phys . rev .
b * 29 * , 4010 ( 1984 ) .
m. kaufman , phys .
b * 30 * , 413 ( 1984 ) . c. itzykson and j.m .
luck , proceedings of the brasov international summer school ( 1984 ) .
h. ottavi and g. albinet , j. phys .
a * 20 * , 2961 ( 1987 ) .
le doussal and a. georges , yale university report no .
yctp - p1 - 88 ( 1988 ) .
p. le doussal and a.b .
harris , phys .
lett . * 61 * , 625 ( 1988 ) .
hartford and s.r .
mckay , j. appl .
70 * , 6068 ( 1991 ) .
mckay , a.n .
berker , and s. kirkpatrick , phys .
48 * , 767 ( 1982 ) .
g. migliorini and a.n .
berker , phys .
b * 57 * , 426 ( 1998 ) .
d. andelman and a.n .
berker , phys .
b * 29 * , 2630 ( 1984 ) .
a. falicov , a.n .
berker , and s.r .
mckay , phys .
b * 51 * , 8266 ( 1995 ) .
e. domany , s. alexander , d. bensimon , and l.p .
kadanoff , phys .
b * 28 * , 3110 ( 1983 ) . j .-
langlois , a .- m.s .
tremblay , and b.w .
southern , phys .
b * 28 * , 218 ( 1983 ) .
stinchcombe and a.c .
maggs , j. phys .
a * 19 * , 1949 ( 1986 ) .
haddad , s.t.r .
pinho , and s.r .
salinas , phys .
e * 61 * , 3330 ( 2000 ) .
x . le and z.r .
yang , phys .
e * 69 * , 066107 ( 2004 ) .
da silveira and j .- p .
bouchaud , phys .
93 * , 015901 ( 2004 ) .
migdal , zh .
. fiz . * 69 * , 1457 ( 1975 ) [ sov .
jetp * 42 * , 743 ( 1976 ) ] .
kadanoff , ann .
( n.y . ) * 100 * , 359 ( 1976 ) .
a. erba , a. tuncer , b. ycesoy , and a.n .
berker , phys .
e * 72 * , 026129 ( 2005 ) .
i. syozi , in phase transitions and critical phenomena , c. domb and m.s .
green , eds .
( academic , london , 1972 ) , vol.1 , pp.270 - 329 . k. hui and a.n .
berker , phys .
* 62 * , 2507 ( 1989 ) .
f. camia and c.m .
newman , j. stat .
phys * 114 * , 1199 ( 2004 ) . | the ising spin - glasses are investigated on three dual pairs of hierarchical lattices , using exact renormalization - group transformation of the quenched bond probability distribution .
the goal is to investigate a recent conjecture which relates , on such pairs of dual lattices , the locations of the multicritical points , which occur on the nishimori symmetry line . towards this end
we precisely determine the global phase diagrams for these six hierarchical spin - glasses , using up to @xmath0 probability bins to represent the quenched distribution subjected to an exact renormalization - group transformation .
we find in all three cases that the conjecture is realized to a very good approximation , even when the mutually dual models belong to different spatial dimensionalities @xmath1 and have different phase diagram topologies at the multicritical points of the conjecture and even though the contributions to the conjecture from each lattice of the dual pair are strongly asymmetric . in all six phase diagrams , we find reentrance near the multicritical point . in the models with @xmath2 or 1.5 , the spin - glass phase does not occur and the phase boundary between the ferromagnetic and paramagnetic phases is second order with a strong violation of universality .
pacs numbers : 75.10.nr , 64.60.kw , 05.45.df , 05.10.cc |
the arecibo oh megamaser ( ohm ) survey selects candidates from the pscz redshift catalog ( saunders et al .
2000 ) with the criteria : ( 1 ) @xmath0 jy , ( 2 ) @xmath1 , and ( 3 ) @xmath2 ( darling & giovanelli 2000 ) . with a detection rate of 1 ohm in 6 candidates ,
the complete survey will double the sample of ohms to roughly 100 objects .
the survey has identified 35 new ohms in luminous infrared galaxies to add to the sample of 55 found in the literature .
there is a strong bias for the most fir - luminous galaxies to host ohms , and a weak fir color dependence ( see figure 1 ) .
ohms are detectable out to @xmath35 with modern instruments , and can thus be used to measure the high luminosity tail of the luminous ir galaxy luminosity function for redshifts spanning the epoch of major galaxy mergers ( @xmath4 ) .
blank field surveys for ohms at various redshifts can also measure the galaxy merger rate as a function of cosmic time ( briggs 1998 ) .
variability has been detected in several ohms , and is currently under investigation .
the variability appears over time scales of months in individual spectral features rather than in broad - band modulation which could be attributed to antenna calibration or pointing errors .
variability in ohms constrains the sizes of the variable and quiescent spectral features , regardless of the source of modulation ( intrinsic to the source or due to propagation effects ) .
intrinsically variable regions would have sufficiently small angular sizes that they would also be expected to scintillate ( see walker 1998 ) .
we thus attribute the variability to interstellar scintillation , which gives a weaker constraint on the sizes of emission regions than intrinsic variability .
variability in ohms , particularly those with @xmath5 , will provide a powerful tool for understanding the small - scale physical settings and mechanisms of masers which can be observed at cosmological distances .
briggs , f. 1998 , , 336 , 815 darling , j. & giovanelli , r. 2000 , , 119 , 3003 saunders , w. , et al .
2000 , in cosmic flows : towards an understanding of the large - scale structure in the universe , ed .
s. courteau , m. strauss & j. willick ( san francisco : asp ) , in press walker , m. a. 1998 , , 294 , 307 | we present the current results of a survey for oh megamasers ( ohms ) underway at the arecibo observatory .
the survey is 2/3 complete and has produced a high ohm detection rate ( 1 in 6 ) from a redshift - selected sample of _ iras _ galaxies .
the survey will relate the ohm luminosity function to the galaxy merger rate , allowing subsequent blind ohm surveys to measure the galaxy merger rate as a function of cosmic time .
the survey has also made the first detection of strong variability in ohms .
variability will provide a powerful tool for understanding the small - scale physical settings and mechanisms of ohms . |
the analysis of dynamic processes taking place in complex networks is a major research area with a wide range of applications in social , biological , and technological systems @xcite .
the spread of information in online social networks , the evolution of an epidemic outbreak in human contact networks , and the dynamics of cascading failures in the electrical grid are relevant examples of these processes .
while major advances have been made in this field , most modeling and analysis techniques are specifically tailored to study dynamic processes taking place in static networks .
however , empirical observations in social @xcite , biological @xcite , and financial networks @xcite illustrate how real - world networks are constantly evolving over time @xcite .
unfortunately , the effects of temporal structural variations in the dynamics of networked systems remain poorly understood . in the context of temporal networks , we are specially interested in the interplay between the dynamics on networks ( i.e. , the dynamics of processes taking place in the network ) and the dynamics of networks ( i.e. , the temporal evolution of the network structure ) . although the dynamics on and of networks are usually studied separately , there are many cases in which the evolution of the network structure is heavily influenced by the dynamics of processes taking place in the network .
one of such cases is found in the context of epidemiology , since healthy individuals tend to avoid contact with infected individuals in order to protect themselves against the disease a phenomenon called _ social distancing
_ @xcite . as a consequence of social distancing
, the structure of the network adapts to the dynamics of the epidemics taking place in the network .
similar adaptation mechanisms have been studied in the context of power networks @xcite , biological and neural networks @xcite and on - line social networks @xcite . despite the relevance of network adaptation mechanisms , their effects on the network dynamics are not well understood . in this research direction , we find the seminal work by gross et al . in @xcite , where a simple adaptive rewiring mechanism was proposed in the context of epidemic models . in this model , a susceptible node can cut edges connecting him to infected neighbors and form new links to _ any _ randomly selected susceptible nodes without structural constraint in the formation of new links . despite its simplicity
, this adaptation mechanism induces a complex bifurcation diagram including healthy , oscillatory , bistable , and endemic epidemic states @xcite .
several extensions of this work can be found in the literature @xcite , where the authors assume homogeneous infection and recovery rates in the network .
another model that is specially relevant to our work is the adaptive susceptible - infected - susceptible ( asis ) model proposed in @xcite . in this model , edges in a given contact network can be temporarily removed in order to prevent the spread of the epidemic .
an interesting feature of the asis model is that , in contrast with gross model , it is able to account for arbitrary contact patterns , since links are constrained to be part of a given contact graph . despite its modeling flexibility ,
analytical results for the asis model @xcite are based on the assumption of homogeneous contact patterns ( i.e. , the contact graph is complete ) , as well as homogeneous node and edge dynamics ( i.e. , nodes present the same infection and recovery rates , and edges share the same adaptation rates ) . as a consequence of the lack of tools to analyze network adaptation mechanisms ,
there is also an absence of effective methodologies for actively utilizing adaptation mechanisms for containing spreading processes .
although we find in the literature a few attempts in this direction , most of them rely on extensive numerical simulations @xcite , on assuming a homogeneous contact patterns @xcite , or a homogeneous node and edge dynamics @xcite .
in contrast , while controlling epidemic processes over static networks , we find a plethora of tools based on game theory @xcite or convex optimization @xcite . in this paper , we study adaptation mechanisms over arbitrary contact networks .
in particular , we derive an explicit expression for a lower bound on the epidemic threshold of the asis model for arbitrary networks , as well as heterogeneous node and edge dynamics . in the case of homogeneous node and edge dynamics
, we show that the lower bound is proportional to the epidemic threshold of the standard sis model over a static network @xcite . furthermore , based on our results ,
we propose an efficient algorithm for optimally tuning the adaptation rates of an arbitrary network in order to eradicate an epidemic outbreak in the asis model .
we confirm the tightness of the proposed lower bonds with several numerical simulations and compare our optimal adaptation rates with popular centrality measures .
in this section , we describe the adaptive susceptible - infected - susceptible ( asis ) model over _ arbitrary _ networks with _ heterogeneous _ node and edge dynamics ( heterogeneous asis model for short ) .
we start our exposition by considering a spreading process over a time - varying contact graph @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the set of nodes and @xmath2 is the time - varying set of edges . for any @xmath3
, @xmath4_{i , j}$ ] corresponds to the adjacency matrix of @xmath5 , and the neighborhood of node @xmath6 at time @xmath7 is defined as @xmath8 . in the standard sis epidemic model ,
the state of node @xmath6 at time @xmath7 is described by a bernoulli random variable @xmath9 , where node @xmath6 is said to be _ susceptible _ if @xmath10 , and _ infected _ if @xmath11 .
when the contact graph evolves over time , the evolution of @xmath12 is described by a markov process with the following transition probabilities : @xmath13[.8\linewidth ] { p}(x_i(t+h ) = 1 \mid x_i(t ) = 0 ) = \beta_i\ \sum_{\mathclap{k \in { \pazocal{n}}_i(t)}}\ x_k(t)\,h + o(h ) , \end{multlined } \nonumber \\ & { p}(x_i(t+h ) = 0 \mid x_i(t ) = 1 ) = \delta_i h + o(h ) , \label{eq : recovery}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the parameters @xmath14 and @xmath15 are called the _ infection _ and _ recovery _ rates of node @xmath6 . in the heterogeneous asis model ,
the epidemics takes place over a time - varying network that we model as a continuous - time stochastic graph process @xmath16 , described below .
let @xmath17 be an initial connected contact graph with adjacency matrix @xmath18_{i , j}$ ] .
we assume that @xmath19 is strongly connected .
edges in the initial graph @xmath19 appear and disappear over time according to the following markov processes : @xmath13[.9\linewidth ] { p}(a_{ij}(t+h ) = 0 \mid a_{ij}(t ) = 1)=\vspace{.1 cm } \\
\phi_{ij}x_i(t ) h+ \phi_{ji}x_j(t ) h + o(h ) , \end{multlined}\label{eq : cut } \\ & { p}(a_{ij}(t+h ) = 1 \mid a_{ij}(t ) = 0 ) = a_{ij}(0)\psi_{ij } h + o(h ) , \label{eq : rewire}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the parameters @xmath20 and @xmath21 are called the _ cutting _ and _ reconnecting _ rates .
notice that the transition rate in depends on @xmath12 and @xmath22 , inducing an adaptation mechanism of the network structure to the state of the epidemics .
the transition probability in can be interpreted as a protection mechanism in which edge @xmath23 is stochastically removed from the network if either node @xmath6 or @xmath24 is infected . more specifically , because of the first summand ( respectively , the second summand ) in , whenever node @xmath6 ( respectively , node @xmath24 ) is infected , edge @xmath25 is removed from the network according to a poisson process with rate @xmath26 ( respectively , rate @xmath27 ) . on the other hand ,
the transition probability in describes a mechanism for which a ` cut ' edge @xmath25 is ` reconnected ' into the network according to a poisson process with rate @xmath28 ( see figure [ fig : adaptive ] ) .
notice that we include the term @xmath29 in to guarantee that only edges present in the initial contact graph @xmath19 can be added later on by the reconnecting process .
in other words , we constrain the set of edges in the adaptive network to be a part of the arbitrary contact graph @xmath19 .
in this section , we derive a lower bound on the epidemic threshold for the heterogeneous asis model . for @xmath30 , let @xmath31 denote a poisson counter with rate @xmath32 @xcite . in what follows , we assume all poisson counters to be stochastically independent .
then , from the two equations in , the evolution of the nodal states can be described by the following set of stochastic differential equations @xmath33 for all @xmath34 .
similarly , from and , the evolution of the edges can be described by the following set of stochastic differential equations : @xmath35 for all @xmath36 . by
, the expectation @xmath37 $ ] obeys the differential equation @xmath38 = -\delta_i e[x_i ] + \beta_i \
\sum_{\mathclap{k\in{\pazocal{n}}_i(0)}}\ e[(1-x_i)a_{ik}x_k].\ ] ] let @xmath39 $ ] and @xmath40 $ ] .
then , it follows that @xmath41 where @xmath42\ ] ] contains positive higher - order terms . in what follows ,
we derive a set of differential equations to describe the evolution of @xmath43 . from and
, we obtain the following equation using it rule for jump processes ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) @xmath44 therefore , @xmath45 for all @xmath46 , where @xmath47\\ & + \beta_i\ \sum_{\mathclap{k\in{\pazocal{n}}_i(0)}}\ e\bigl [ x_i(t)x_k(t)a_{ik}(t ) \\ & + ( 1-a_{ij}(t))a_{ik}(t)x_k(t)\bigr],\end{aligned}\ ] ] which contains positive higher - order terms .
the differential equations and describe the joint evolution of the spreading process and the network structure . for further analysis , it is convenient to express the differential equations and using vectors and matrices . for this purpose ,
let us introduce the following notation .
let @xmath48 and @xmath49 be , respectively , the @xmath50 identity matrix and the @xmath51-dimensional column vector of all ones . given two matrices @xmath52 and @xmath53 , their kronecker product @xcite
is denoted by @xmath54 . given a sequence of matrices @xmath55 , their direct sum , denoted by @xmath56 , is defined as the block diagonal matrix having @xmath55 as its block diagonals @xcite . if @xmath55 have the same number of columns , then the matrix obtained by stacking @xmath55 in vertical ( @xmath57 on top ) is denoted by @xmath58 .
based on this notation , we define the vector - variable @xmath59 , which contains the infection probabilities of all the nodes in the graph .
similarly , let @xmath60 and define the column vector @xmath61 .
define @xmath62 as the unique row - vector satisfying @xmath63 note that the length of the row vector @xmath62 and the column vector @xmath64 equals @xmath65 , where @xmath66 is the number of the edges in the initial graph @xmath19 . using this notation
, we define the following matrices : @xmath67 where @xmath68 denotes the degree of node @xmath6 in the initial graph @xmath19 .
furthermore , we also define the following matrices @xmath69 stacking the set of @xmath70 differential equations in into a single vector equation , and ignoring the negative higher - order term @xmath71 , we obtain the following entry - wise vector inequality for the probabilities of infection : @xmath72 also , stacking the set of differential equations in with respect to @xmath73 , and ignoring the negative term @xmath74 , we obtain the following entry - wise vector inequality : @xmath75 where @xmath76 . we can further stack the above inequalities with respect to the index @xmath6 to obtain the following entry - wise vector inequality : @xmath77 combining this inequality and , we obtain @xmath78/dt } \frac{d}{dt}\begin{bmatrix } p
q \end{bmatrix } \leq m \begin{bmatrix } p
\\ q \end{bmatrix},\ ] ] where @xmath79 is an irreducible matrix ( see appendix [ appx : pf : irreducibility ] for the proof of irreducibility ) defined as @xmath80 therefore , the evolution of the joint vector variable @xmath81 is upper - bounded by the linear dynamics given by the matrix @xmath79 . moreover ,
the upper bound is tight around the origin , since both @xmath82 and @xmath83 consist of higher - order terms . from
, we conclude that the epidemics dies out exponentially fast in the heterogeneous asis model if @xmath84 where @xmath85 is defined as the maximum among the real parts of the eigenvalues of @xmath79 . furthermore
, since @xmath79 is a metzler matrix ( i.e. , has nonnegative off - diagonals ) and irreducible , there is a real eigenvalue of @xmath79 equal to @xmath85 @xcite .
in the homogeneous case , where all the nodes share the same infection rate @xmath86 and recovery rate @xmath87 , and all the edges share the same cutting rate @xmath88 and reconnecting rate @xmath89 , the condition reduces to the following inequality : @xmath90 where @xmath91 is the spectral radius of the initial graph @xmath19 and @xmath92 which we call the _ effective cutting rate_. the proof of the extinction condition is given in appendix [ appx : pf : thm : stbl : homo ] .
we remark that , in the special case when the network does not adapt to the prevalence of infection , i.e. , when @xmath93 , we have that @xmath94 and , therefore , the condition in is identical to the extinction condition @xmath95 corresponding to the homogeneous networked sis model over a static network @xcite .
it is worth comparing the condition in with the epidemic threshold @xmath96 given in @xcite for the case in which @xmath19 is the complete graph : @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the link - creating rate , @xmath99 is the link - breaking rate , and @xmath100 is a positive and `` slowly varying '' function depending on the metastable long - time average of the number of infected nodes ( for details , see @xcite ) .
we first notice that our lower bound in can be checked directly from the parameters of the model , namely , the adjacency matrix of the initial graph @xmath19 and the relevant rates of the model .
this is in contrast with the threshold in , since it depends on the metastable average of the number of infected nodes and , thus , can only be computed via numerical simulations .
we also remark that the lower bound on the epidemic threshold in and the epidemic threshold in both exhibit affine dependence on the effective link - breaking rates @xmath101 and @xmath102 , respectively .
finally , we see that the recovery rate @xmath103 appears in different places in the two conditions , namely , inside the expression of @xmath101 in and inside the function @xmath100 in .
however , the consequences of this difference are not obvious , since @xmath100 is defined via the metastable state and , therefore , does not allow an analytical investigation . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] once the cost functions are selected , we must solve the problem of finding the optimal tuning investment to achieve a desired exponential decay rate in the probabilities of infection . from the inequality in ,
the infection probabilities @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 decay exponentially at a rate ( at least ) @xmath107 if @xmath108 since @xmath79 is an irreducible and metzler matrix , we can use perron - frobenius theory @xcite to prove that is satisfied if there exists an entry - wise positive vector @xmath109 satisfying the following entry - wise vector inequality ( see @xcite for more details ) : @xmath110 therefore , problem [ prb : ] can be reduced to the following equivalent optimization problem : @xmath111 as we show in appendix [ appx : gp ] , we can equivalently transform this optimization problem into a geometric program @xcite , which can be efficiently solved using standard optimization software .
the computational complexity of solving the resulting geometric program is @xmath112 , where @xmath70 is the number of nodes and @xmath66 is the number of edges in the initial network @xmath19 . in the rest of this section ,
we compute the optimal tuning profiles for three different graphs and compare our results with several network centralities . in our simulations , we consider the following three graphs with @xmath113 nodes : _ 1 _ ) an erds - rnyi graph with @xmath114 edges , _ 2 _ ) a barabsi - albert random graph with @xmath115 edges , and _ 3 _ ) a social subgraph ( obtained from facebook ) with @xmath116 edges . for simplicity in our simulations , we assume that all nodes share the same recovery rate @xmath117 and infection rate @xmath118 , where @xmath91 denotes the spectral radius of each initial graph . since @xmath119 , the extinction condition indicates that the infection process does not necessarily die out without adaptation , i.e. , when @xmath120 .
the rest of parameters in our simulations are set as follows : we let @xmath121 , @xmath122 , and @xmath123 . also , the parameters in the cost functions are @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
the desired exponential decay rate is chosen to be @xmath126 . using this set of parameters , we solve the optimization problem following the procedure described in appendix [ appx : gp ] .
our numerical results are illustrated in various figures included in table [ table : ] .
each figure is a scatter plot where each point corresponds to a particular edge @xmath46 ; the ordinate of each point corresponding to its optimal cutting rate @xmath26 , and the abscissa of each point corresponds to a particular edge - centrality measure . in these figures , we use three different edge - centrality measures : a ) the product of the degrees of nodes @xmath6 and @xmath24 ( left column ) , b ) the product of the eigenvector - centralities of nodes @xmath6 and @xmath24 ( center column ) , and c ) the betweenness centralities of edge @xmath25 ( right column ) . in our numerical results ,
we observe how both degree - based and eigenvector - based edge - centralities are good measures for determining the amount of investment in tuning cutting rates .
in contrast , betweenness centrality does not show a significant dependency on the optimal cutting rates .
in particular , for the synthetic networks in rows 1 ) and 2 ) in table [ table : ] , we observe an almost piecewise affine relationship with the centrality measures in columns a ) and b ) . in particular , in these subplots
we observe how edges of low centrality require no investment , while for higher - centrality edges , the tuning investment tends to increase affinely as the centrality of the edge increases as expected .
for the real social network in row c ) , the relationship between investment and centralities is still strong although not as clear as in synthetic networks . in the scatter plot corresponding to the relationship between the optimal investment and the eigenvector - based centrality in the real social network ( lower center figure in table [ table : ] ) , we observe a collection of several stratified parallel lines .
we conjecture that each line corresponds to a different community inside the social network ; in other words , the relationship between centrality and optimal investment is almost affine inside each community .
we have studied an _ adaptive _ susceptible - infected - susceptible ( asis ) model with heterogeneous node and edge dynamics and arbitrary network topologies .
we have derived an explicit expression for a lower bound on the epidemic threshold of this model in terms of the maximum real eigenvalue of a matrix that depends explicitly on the network topology and the parameters of the model . for networks with homogeneous node and edge dynamics , the lower
bound turns out to be a constant multiple of the epidemic threshold in the standard sis model over static networks ( in particular , the inverse of the spectral radius ) .
furthermore , based on our results , we have proposed an optimization framework to find the cost - optimal adaptation rates in order to eradicate the epidemics .
we have confirmed the accuracy of our theoretical results with several numerical simulations and compare cost - optimal adaptation rates with popular centrality measures in various networks .
43ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1038/30918 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _
( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1007/s00779 - 005 - 0046 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * ( ) in link:\doibase 1102.0629v1 [ _ _ ] ( ) pp .
link:\doibase 10.1093/bib / bbp057 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nature02555 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nbt.1522 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epjb / e20020151 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physrep.2012.03.001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.3201/eid1201.051371 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1098/rsif.2010.0142 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1209/epl / i2004 - 10533 - 6 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/304158a0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1161/01.atv.0000069625.11230.96 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1186/s40649 - 015 - 0023 - 6 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.208701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1098/rsif.2007.1229 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s10867 - 008 - 9060 - 9 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.82.036116 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.83.026102 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1742 - 5468/2012/08/p08018 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s00285 - 012 - 0555 - 4 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.90.022801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.88.042802 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.92.030801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.88.042801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1186/1471 - 2458 - 12 - 679 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.85.036108 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1109/tcns.2015.2426755 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.jcss.2006.02.003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1109/mcs.2015.2495000 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1109/tcns.2014.2310911 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1109/tnet.2008.925623 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _
( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.87.062816 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s11081 - 007 - 9001 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1109/cdc.2013.6761078 [ _ _ ] ( ) pp . @noop _ _ ( , ) ( )
we show that the matrix @xmath79 defined in is irreducible , that is , there is no similarity transformation that transforms @xmath79 into a block upper - triangular matrix . for this purpose ,
define @xmath127 where @xmath128 , @xmath129 , and @xmath130 . since the rates @xmath131 and @xmath28 are positive , if @xmath132 , then @xmath133 for all distinct @xmath6 and @xmath24 .
therefore , to prove the irreducibility of @xmath79 , it is sufficient to show that @xmath134 is irreducible . in order to show that @xmath134 is irreducible , we shall show that the directed graph @xmath135 on the nodes @xmath136 , defined as the graph having adjacency matrix @xmath137 , is strongly connected .
we identify the nodes @xmath138 , @xmath105 , @xmath139 and variables @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath140 ( @xmath141 ) , @xmath105 , @xmath142 ( @xmath143 ) .
then , the upper - right block @xmath144 of the matrix @xmath134 indicates that the graph @xmath135 contains the directed edge @xmath145 for all @xmath146 and @xmath147 .
similarly , from the matrices @xmath148 and @xmath149 in @xmath79 , we see that @xmath135 contains the directed edges @xmath150 and @xmath151 for all @xmath146 and @xmath152 . using these observations , let us first show that @xmath135 has a directed path from @xmath153 to @xmath154 for all @xmath155 . since @xmath19 is strongly connected , it has a path @xmath156 such that @xmath157 and @xmath158 .
therefore , from the above observations , we see that @xmath135 contains the directed path @xmath159 . in the same way
, we can show that @xmath135 also contains the directed path @xmath160 for every @xmath161 .
these two types of directed paths in @xmath135 guarantees that @xmath135 is strongly connected . hence the matrix @xmath134 is irreducible , as desired .
in the homogeneous case , the matrix @xmath79 takes the form @xmath162 in what follows , we show that @xmath163 if and only if holds true .
since @xmath19 is strongly connected by assumption , its adjacency matrix @xmath164 is irreducible and therefore has an entry - wise positive eigenvector @xmath109 corresponding to the eigenvalue @xmath91 ( see @xcite ) . define the positive vector @xmath165 .
then , the definition of @xmath62 in shows @xmath166 and therefore @xmath167 . in the same manner , we can show that @xmath168 .
moreover , it is straightforward to check that @xmath169
. therefore , for a real number @xmath170 , it follows that @xmath171 hence , if a real number @xmath172 satisfies the following equations : @xmath173 then @xmath174 is an eigenvector of @xmath79 . since @xmath79 is irreducible ( shown in appendix [ appx : pf : irreducibility ] ) , by perron - frobenius theory @xcite , if @xmath175 then @xmath176 ( see ( * ? ? ? * theorem 17 ) ) .
this , in particular , shows that @xmath163 if and only if there exist @xmath175 and @xmath177 such that holds . the two equations in have two pairs of solutions @xmath178 and @xmath179 such that @xmath180 , and @xmath181 .
therefore , we need to show @xmath182 if and only if holds true . to see this
, we notice that @xmath183 and @xmath184 are the solutions of the quadratic equation @xmath185 following from . since @xmath186
, we have @xmath187 if and only if the constant term @xmath188 of the quadratic equation is positive , which is indeed equivalent to .
this completes the proof of the extinction condition stated in .
we first give a brief review of geometric programs @xcite .
let @xmath189 , @xmath105 , @xmath190 denote positive variables and define @xmath191 .
we say that a real function @xmath192 is a _ monomial _ if there exist @xmath193 and @xmath194 such that @xmath195 .
also , we say that a function @xmath196 is a _ posynomial _ if it is a sum of monomials of @xmath197 ( we point the readers to @xcite for more details ) . given a collection of posynomials @xmath198 , @xmath105 , @xmath199 and monomials @xmath200
, @xmath105 , @xmath201 , the optimization problem @xmath202 is called a _ geometric program_. a constraint of the form @xmath203 with @xmath196 being a posynomial is called a posynomial constraint .
although geometric programs are not convex , they can be efficiently converted into equivalent convex optimization problems @xcite . in the following , we rewrite the optimization problem into a geometric program using the new variables @xmath204 and @xmath205 .
by , these variables should satisfy the constraints @xmath206 also , using these variables , the cost function @xmath207 can be written as @xmath208 , where @xmath209 are posynomials . in order to rewrite the constraint ,
we first define the matrices @xmath210 we also introduce the positive constants @xmath211 , @xmath212 , @xmath213 . now ,
adding @xmath214 to both sides of , we equivalently obtain @xmath215 where @xmath216 is given by summarizing , we have shown that the optimization problem is equivalent to the following optimization problem with ( entry - wise ) positive variables : @xmath218 in this optimization problem , the objective function is a posynomial in the variables @xmath219 , @xmath220 , and @xmath221 .
also , the box constraints , , and can be written as posynomial constraints @xcite .
finally , since each entry of the matrix @xmath222 is a posynomial in the variables @xmath219 , @xmath220 , and @xmath221 , the vector - constraint yields @xmath139 posynomial constraints .
therefore , the optimization problem is a geometric program , as desired .
furthremore , a standard estimate on the computational complexity of solving geometric program ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 3 ) ) shows that the computational complexity of solving the optimization problem in is given by @xmath112 .
finally we remark that @xmath222 contains both the terms @xmath28 and @xmath223 so that we can not use @xmath28 as the decision variable in the geometric program due to the positivity constraint on decision variables . by this reason , we can not design the reconnecting rates @xmath28 under the framework presented in this paper .
this issue is left as an open problem . | in this paper , we study the dynamics of epidemic processes taking place in adaptive networks of arbitrary topology .
we focus our study on the adaptive susceptible - infected - susceptible ( asis ) model , where healthy individuals are allowed to temporarily cut edges connecting them to infected nodes in order to prevent the spread of the infection . in this paper
, we derive a closed - form expression for a lower bound on the epidemic threshold of the asis model in arbitrary networks with heterogeneous node and edge dynamics . for networks with homogeneous node and edge dynamics , we show that the resulting lower bound is proportional to the epidemic threshold of the standard sis model over static networks , with a proportionality constant that depends on the adaptation rates .
furthermore , based on our results , we propose an efficient algorithm to optimally tune the adaptation rates in order to eradicate epidemic outbreaks in arbitrary networks .
we confirm the tightness of the proposed lower bounds with several numerical simulations and compare our optimal adaptation rates with popular centrality measures . |
cassiopeia a is the brightest shell - type galactic supernova remnant ( snr ) in x - rays and radio , and the youngest snr observed in our galaxy .
the radius of the approximately spherical shell is @xmath15 , which corresponds to @xmath16 pc for the distance @xmath17 kpc ( reed et al .
the supernova which gave rise to cas a was probably first observed in 1680 ( ashworth 1980 ) .
it is thought to be a type ii supernova caused by explosion of a very massive wolf - rayet star ( fesen , becker & blair 1987 ) .
optical observations of cas a show numerous oxygen - rich fast - moving knots ( fmk ) , with velocities of about 5000 km s@xmath4 , and slow - moving quasi - stationary flocculi , with typical velocities of about 200 km s@xmath4 , which emit h@xmath18 and strong lines of nitrogen .
x - ray observations of cas a show numerous clumps of hot matter emitting strong si , s , fe , ar , ne , mg and ca lines ( holt et al .
1994 , and references therein ) .
because this snr lies at the far side of the perseus arm , with its patchy distribution of the interstellar gas , the interstellar absorption varies considerably across the cas a image ( e.g. , keohane , rudnick & anderson 1996 ) .
numerous radio , optical and x - ray measurements of the hydrogen column density ( e.g. , schwarz , goss & kalberla 1997 ; hufford & fesen 1996 ; jansen et al .
1988 ; favata et al .
1997 ) show a strong scatter within a range @xmath19 , where @xmath20 .
based on recent results , we consider @xmath21 as plausible values for the central region of the cas a image . in spite of considerable efforts to detect
a compact remnant of the supernova explosion only upper limits on its flux had been established at different wavelengths until a pointlike x - ray source was discovered close to the cas a center ( tananbaum et al .
1999 ) in the first light observation with the x - ray observatory ( see weisskopf et al .
1996 for a description ) . after this discovery ,
the same source was found in the hri image of 199596 ( aschenbach 1999 ) and hri images of 1979 and 1981 ( pavlov & zavlin 1999 ) . in this letter we present the first analysis on the central source spectrum observed with ( 2 ) , together with the analysis of the , , and _ asca _ observations ( 3 ) .
various interpretations of these observations are discussed in 4 .
the snr cas a was observed several times during the orbital activation and calibration phase . for our analysis
, we chose four observations of 1999 august 2023 with the s array of the advanced ccd imaging spectrometer ( acis ; garmire 1997 ) . in these observations
cas a was imaged on the backside - illuminated chip s3 . the spectral response of this chip
is presently known better that those of the frontside - illuminated chips used in a few other acis observations of cas a. we used the processed data products available from the public data archive .
the observations were performed in the timed exposure mode , with a frame integration time of 3.24 s. the durations of the observations were 5.03 , 2.04 , 1.76 , and 1.77 ks .
because of telemetry saturation , the effective exposures were 2.81 , 1.22 , 1.06 , and 1.05 ks , respectively . since the available acis response matrices were generated for the set of grades g02346 , we selected events with these grades .
events with pulse height amplitudes exceeding 4095 adu ( @xmath22 of the total number ) were discarded as generated by cosmic rays .
the images of the pointlike source look slightly elongated , but this elongation is likely caused by errors in the aspect solution , and the overall shapes of the images is consistent with the assumption that this is a point source .
its positions in the four observations are consistent with that reported by tananbaum et al .
( 1999 ) : @xmath23 , @xmath24 . for each of the images
, we extracted the source+background counts from a @xmath25 radius circle around the point source center , and the background from an elliptical region around the circle , with an area of about 10 times that of the circle . after subtracting the background
, we obtained the source countrates @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 ks@xmath4 ( counts per kilosecond ) .
the countrate values and the light curves are consistent with the assumption that the source flux remained constant during the 4 days , with the countrate of @xmath30 ks@xmath4 . for the analysis of the point source spectrum , we chose the longest of the acis - s3 observations .
we grouped the pulse - height spectrum for 306 source counts into 14 bins in the 0.85.0 kev range ( fig . 1 ) .
each bin has more than 20 counts ( except for the highest - energy bin with 8 counts ) .
the spectral fits were performed with the xspec package .
if the source is an active pulsar , we can expect that its x - ray radiation is emitted by relativistic particles and has a power - law spectrum . the power - law fit ( upper panel of fig .
2 ) yields a photon index @xmath31 ( all uncertainties are given at a @xmath32-@xmath33 confidence level ) that is considerably larger than @xmath342.1 observed for x - ray radiation from youngest pulsars ( becker & trmper 1997 ) .
the hydrogen column density , @xmath35 , inferred from the power - law fit somewhat exceeds estimates obtained from independent measurements ( see 1 ) .
the ( unabsorbed ) x - ray luminosity in the 0.15.0 kev range , @xmath36 erg s@xmath4 , where @xmath37 , is lower than those observed from very young pulsars ( e.g. , @xmath38 and @xmath39 erg s@xmath4 for the crab pulsar and psr b054069 , in the same energy range ) .
if the source is a neutron star ( ns ) , but not an active pulsar , thermal radiation from the ns surface can be observed .
the blackbody fit ( middle panel of fig .
2 ) yields a temperature @xmath40 mk and a sphere radius @xmath41 km , which correspond to a bolometric luminosity @xmath42 erg s@xmath4 .
( we use the superscript @xmath43 to denote the observed quantities , distinguishing them from those at the ns surface : @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , where @xmath47^{1/2}= [ 1 - 0.41 m_{1.4}r_6^{-1}]^{1/2}$ ] is the gravitational redshift factor , @xmath48 and @xmath49 cm are the ns mass and radius ) .
the temperature is too high , and the radius is too small , to interpret the detected x - rays as emitted from the whole surface of a cooling ns with a uniform temperature distribution .
the inferred hydrogen column density , @xmath50 , is on a lower side of the plausible @xmath51 range .
since fitting observed x - ray spectra with light - element ns atmosphere models yields lower effective temperatures and larger emitting areas ( e. g. , zavlin , pavlov & trmper 1998 ) , we fit the spectrum with a number of hydrogen and helium ns atmosphere models ( pavlov et al .
1995 ; zavlin , pavlov & shibanov 1996 ) , for several values of ns magnetic field .
these fits show that the assumption that the observed radiation is emitted from the whole surface of a 10-km radius ns with a uniform temperature still leads to unrealistically large distances , @xmath5250 kpc .
thus , both the blackbody fit and h / he atmosphere fits hint that , if the object is a ns , the observed radiation emerges from hot spots on its surface ( see 4 ) .
an example of such a fit , for polar caps covered with a hydrogen atmosphere with @xmath53 g , is shown in the bottom panel of figure 2 .
the model spectra used in this fit were obtained assuming the ns to be an orthogonal rotator ( the angles @xmath18 , between the magnetic and rotation axes , and @xmath54 , between the rotation axis and line of sight , equal @xmath55 ) .
the inferred effective temperature of the caps is @xmath56 mk ( which corresponds to @xmath57 mk ) , the polar cap radius @xmath58 km , and @xmath59 .
the bolometric luminosity of two polar caps is @xmath60 erg s@xmath4 .
the temperature @xmath61 can be lowered , and the polar cap radius increased , if we see the spot face - on during the most part of the period extreme values , @xmath62 mk ( @xmath63 mk ) and @xmath64 km , at @xmath65 , correspond to @xmath66 .
the fits with the one - component thermal models implicitly assume that the temperature of the rest of the ns surface is so low that its radiation is not seen by acis .
on the other hand , according to the ns cooling models ( e.g. , tsuruta 1998 ) , one should expect that , at the age of 320 yr , the ( redshifted ) surface temperature can be as high as 2 mk for the so - called standard cooling ( and much lower , down to 0.3 mk , for accelerated cooling ) .
to constrain the temperature outside the polar caps , we repeated the polar cap fits with the second thermal component added , at a fixed ns radius and different ( fixed ) values of surface temperature @xmath67 . with this approach we estimated upper limits on the lower temperature , @xmath682.3 mk ( at a 99% confidence level ) , depending on the low - temperature model chosen .
these fits show that the model parameters are strongly correlated the increase of @xmath67 shifts the best - fit @xmath61 downward , and @xmath69 upward .
for example , using an iron atmosphere model for the low - temperature component and assuming a hydrogen polar cap , we obtain an acceptable fit ( see fig .
1 ) for @xmath70 mk , @xmath71 km , @xmath72 mk , @xmath73 km , @xmath74 . note that this @xmath67 is consistent with the predictions of the standard cooling models , and @xmath51 is close to most plausible values adopted for the central region of the snr .
we reanalyzed the archival data on cas a obtained during a long hri observation , between 1995 december 23 and 1996 february 1 ( dead - time corrected exposure 175.6 ks ) .
the image shows a pointlike central source at the position @xmath75 , @xmath76 ( coordinates of the center of the brightest @xmath77 pixel ) , consistent with that reported by aschenbach ( 1999 ) .
its separation from the point source position , @xmath78 , is smaller than the absolute pointing uncertainty ( about @xmath79 ; briel et al .
measuring the source countrate is complicated by the spatially nonuniform background .
another complication is that the 40-day - long exposure actually consists of many single exposures of very different durations . because of the absolute pointing errors , combining many single images in one leads to additional broadening of the point source function ( psf ) . to account for these complications
, we used several apertures ( with radii from @xmath25 to @xmath80 ) for source+background extraction , measured background in several regions with visually the same intensity as around the source , discarded short single exposures , and used various combinations of long single exposures for countrate calculations .
this analysis yields a source countrate of @xmath81 ks@xmath4 ( corrected for the finite apertures ) .
we also re - investigated the archival data on cas a obtained with the hri in observations of 1979 february 8 ( 42.5 ks exposure ) and 1981 january 2223 ( 25.6 ks exposure ) . in each of the data sets there is a pointlike source at the positions @xmath82 , @xmath83 , and @xmath84 , @xmath85 , respectively , consistent with those reported by pavlov & zavlin ( 1999 ) .
the separations from the position , @xmath86 and @xmath87 , and from the position , @xmath88 and @xmath89 , are smaller than the nominal absolute position uncertainty ( @xmath90 for ) . since the observations were short , estimating the source countrates is less complicated than for the hri observation .
the source+background counts were selected from @xmath91-radius circles , and the background was measured from annuli of @xmath92 outer radii surrounding the circles .
the source countrates , calculated with account for the hri psf ( harris et al . 1984 ) , are @xmath93 ( feb 1979 ) , @xmath94 ks@xmath4 ( jan 1981 ) , and @xmath95 ks@xmath4 ( for the combined data ) .
the countrate is consistent with the upper limit of @xmath96 ks@xmath4 , derived by murray et al .
( 1979 ) from the longer of the two observations . to check whether the source radiation varied during the two decades
, we plotted the lines of constant and hri countrates in figure 2 .
for all the three one - component models , the domains of model parameters corresponding to the hri countrates within a @xmath97 range are broader than the 99% confidence domains obtained from the spectra .
the 1-@xmath33 domains corresponding to the hri countrate overlap with the 1-@xmath33 confidence regions obtained from the spectral data .
thus , the source countrates detected with the three instruments do not show statistically significant variability of the source .
we also examined numerous archival _ asca _ observations of cas a ( 19931999 ) and failed to detect the central point source on the high background produced by bright snr structures smeared by poor angular resolution of the _ asca _ telescopes . in the longest of the _ asca _ sis observations ( 1994 july 29 ; 15.1 ks exposure ) the point source would be detected at a 3-@xmath33 level if its flux were a factor of 8 higher than that observed with , , and .
the _ asca _
observations show that there were no strong outbursts of the central source .
the observed x - ray energy flux , @xmath98 , of the compact central object ( cco ) is 3.6 , 6.5 , and @xmath99 erg @xmath100 s@xmath4 in 0.32.4 , 0.34.0 and 0.36.0 kev ranges , respectively .
upper limits on its optical - ir fluxes , @xmath101 erg @xmath100 s@xmath4 and @xmath102 erg @xmath100 s@xmath4 , can be estimated from the magnitude limits , @xmath103 and @xmath104 , found by van den bergh & pritchet ( 1986 ) .
this gives , e.g. , @xmath105 for the energy range , and @xmath106 for the and ranges .
the flux ratios are high enough to exclude coronal emission from a noncompact star as the source of the observed x - ray radiation . a hypothesis that cco is a background agn or a cataclismic variable
can not be completely rejected , but its probability looks extremely low , given the high x - ray - to - optical flux ratio , the softness of the spectrum , and the lack of indications on variability . the strong argument for cco to be a compact remnant of the cas
a explosion is its proximity to the cas a center . in particular
, this source lies @xmath80@xmath107 south of the snr geometrical center determined from the radio image of cas a ( see reed et al . 1995 , and references therein ) .
the source separation , @xmath108@xmath91 , from the snr expansion center , found by van den bergh & kamper ( 1983 ) from the analysis of proper motions of fmks , corresponds to a transverse velocity of 50250 km s@xmath4 ( for @xmath5 kpc , @xmath109 yr ) .
much higher transverse velocities , 8001000 km s@xmath4 , correspond to the separation , @xmath110@xmath111 , from the position of the apparent center of expanding snr shell derived by reed et al .
( 1995 ) from the radial velocities of fmks .
thus , if cco is the compact remnant of the sn explosion , it is moving south ( or sse ) from the cas a center with a transverse velocity of a few hundred km s@xmath4 , common for radio pulsars .
if cco is an isolated ( nonaccreting ) object , it might be an active pulsar with an unfavorable orientation of the radio beam ( a limit on the pulsed flux of 80 mjy at 408 mhz was reported by woan & duffett - smith 1993 ) .
however , a lack of a plerion or a resolved synchrotron nebula , together with the steep x - ray spectrum and low luminosity ( see 2 ) do not support this hypothesis .
the lack of the pulsar activity has been found in several x - ray sources associated with young compact remnants of sn explosions ( e.g. , gotthelf , vasisht & dotani 1999 ) ; it may be tentatively explained by superstrong ( @xmath112 g ) magnetic fields which may suppress the one - photon pair creation in the pulsar s acceleration gaps ( baring & harding 1998 ) .
if cco is an isolated ns without pulsar activity , one may assume that the observed x - rays are emitted from the ns surface .
in this case , we also have to assume an intrinsically nonuniform surface temperature distribution to explain the small size and high temperature of the emission region .
slight nonuniformity of the surface temperature can be caused by anisotropy of heat conduction in the strongly magnetized ns crust ( greenstein & hartke 1983 ) .
however , this nonuniformity is not strong enough to explain the small apparent areas of the emitting regions .
some nonuniformity might be expected in magnetars , if they are indeed powered by decay of their superstrong magnetic fields ( thompson & duncan 1996 ; heyl & kulkarni 1998 ) and a substantial fraction of the thermal energy is produced in the outer ns crust . in this case , the hotter regions of the ns surface would be those with stronger magnetic fields .
if additional investigations will demonstrate quantitatively that the observed luminosity of @xmath113 erg s@xmath4 can be emitted from a small fraction , @xmath114 , of the magnetar s surface , we should expect that the radiation is pulsed , with a probable period of a few seconds typical for magnetars .
we can also speculate that cco is a predecessor of a soft gamma - repeator ( such a hypothesis has been proposed by gotthelf et al .
1999 for the central source of the kes 73 , which shows a spectrum similar to cco , albeit emitted from a larger area ) .
higher temperatures of polar caps can be explained by different chemical compositions of the caps and the rest of the ns surface .
light - element polar caps could form just after the sn explosion via fallback of a fraction of the ejected matter onto the magnetic poles .
due to fast stratification in the strong gravitational field , the upper layers of the polar caps will be comprised of the lightest element present .
the thermal conductivity in the liquid portion of thin degenerate ns envelopes , which is responsible for the temperature drop from the nearly isothermal interior to the surface , is proportional to @xmath115 , where @xmath116 is the ion charge ( yakovlev & urpin 1980 ) .
this means that low-@xmath116 envelopes are more efficient heat conductors than high-@xmath116 ones , so that a light - element ( h , he ) surface has a higher effective temperature for a given temperature @xmath117 at the outer boundary of the internal isothermal region
. approximately , the effective surface temperature is proportional to @xmath118 if the chemical composition of the envelope does not vary with depth , so that the surface of a hydrogen envelope can be @xmath119 times hotter than that of an iron envelope . numerical calculations of chabrier , potekhin & yakovlev ( 1997 ) give a smaller factor ( 1.61.7 for temperatures of interest ) , with account for burning of light elements into heavier ones in the hot bottom layers of the envelope , but neglecting the effects of strong magnetic fields which can somewhat increase this factor ( heyl & hernquist 1997 ) .
hence , the light - element cap should be hotter than the rest of the ns surface .
for instance , for @xmath120 mk , the effective temperatures of the h cap and fe surface are @xmath121 mk and @xmath122 mk , for @xmath123 , @xmath71 km .
as we have shown in 2 , a two - component model spectrum with such temperatures is consistent with the observed cco spectrum , for @xmath124 km .
the thickness of the hydrogen cap , @xmath125 g @xmath100 , needed to provide such a temperature difference , corresponds to the total cap mass @xmath126 . for lower @xmath127 , the temperature difference will be smaller , but still appreciable for @xmath128 .
such an explanation of the cco radiation is compatible only with the standard cooling scenario the difference of chemical compositions could not account for a large ratio , @xmath129 , of the cap and surface temperatures required by the accelerated cooling .
let us consider the hypothesis that the observed x - ray radiation is due to accretion onto a ns or a black hole ( bh ) . to provide a luminosity @xmath130 erg s@xmath4 , the accretion rate should be @xmath131 g s@xmath4 , where @xmath132 is the accretion efficiency ( @xmath133 for accretion onto the surface of a ns ) .
although the luminosity and the accretion rate are very small compared to typical values observed in accreting binaries , they are too high to be explained by accretion from circumstellar matter ( csm ) very high csm densities and/or low object velocities relative to the accreting medium are required .
for instance , the bondi formula , @xmath134 , gives the following relation between the csm baryon density @xmath135 and velocity @xmath136 km s@xmath4 : @xmath137 @xmath138 .
even at @xmath139 , which is lower than a typical pulsar velocity , the required density exceeds that expected in the cas a interiors by about 34 orders of magnitude , unless the ns or bh moves within a much denser ( and sufficiently cold ) csm concentration . this estimate for @xmath135 can be considered as a lower limit because accretion onto a bh , or onto a ns in the propeller regime , is much less efficient .
we can not , however , exclude that cco is accreting from a secondary component in a close binary or from a fossil disk which remained after the sn explosion .
we can rule out a massive secondary component from the above - mentioned @xmath140 and @xmath141 limits , we estimate @xmath142 , @xmath143 .
we can also exclude a persistent low - mass x - ray binary ( lmxb ) or a transient lmxb in outburst the object would have a much higher x - ray luminosity than observed , and the accretion disk would be much brighter in the ir - optical range ( van paradijs & mcclintock 1995 ) .
however , cco might be a compact object with a fossil disk , or an lmxb with a dwarf secondary component , in a long - lasting quiescent state ( e.g. , an m5 dwarf with @xmath144 would have @xmath145 , for the adopted distance and extinction ) . an indirect indication that cco could be a compact accreting object is that its luminosity and spectrum resemble those of lmxbs in quiescence , although we have not seen variability inherent to such objects .
if the accreting object were a young ns , it would be hard to explain how the matter accretes onto the ns surface a very low magnetic field and/or long rotation period , @xmath146 s , would be required for the accreting matter to penetrate the centrifugal barrier .
the criterion suggested by rutledge et al .
( 1999 ) to distinguish between the ns and bh lmxbs in quiescence , based on fitting the quiescent spectra with the light - element ns atmosphere models , favors the bh interpretation , although the applicability of this criterion to a system much younger than classical lmxbs may be questioned . on the other hand , in at least some of bh binaries optical radiation emitted by the accretion flow
was detected in quiescence ( e.g. , narayan , barret & mcclintock 1997 ) at a level exceeding the upper limit on the cco optical flux .
finally , one could speculate that the cco progenitor was a binary with an old ns , and this old ns has sufficiently slow rotation and low magnetic field to permit accretion onto the ns surface from a disk of matter captured in the aftermath of the sn explosion . in this case
, cco could have properties of an accreting x - ray pulsar with a low accretion rate .
( a similar model was proposed by popov 1998 for the central source of rcw 103 , although he assumed accretion from the ism . ) to conclude , we can not firmly establish the nature of cco based on the data available it can be either an isolated ns with hot spots or a compact object ( more likely , a bh ) accreting from a fossil disk or from a dwarf binary companion .
although the cco spectrum and luminosity strongly resemble those of other radio - quiet compact sources in snrs , these sources may not necessarily represent a homogeneous group e.g. , the central source of kes 73 shows 11.7 s pulsations and remarkable stability , and was proposed to be a magnetar ( gotthelf et al .
1999 ) , whereas the central source of rcw 103 shows long - term variability and no pulsations ( gotthelf , petre & vasisht 1999 ) .
we favor the isolated ns interpretation of cco because it has not displayed any variability .
critical observations to elucidate its nature include searching for periodic and aperiodic variabilities , deep ir imaging , and longer acis observations which would provide more source quanta for the spectral analysis .
we are grateful to norbert schulz for providing the acis response matrices , to gordon garmire , leisa townsley and george chartas for their advices on the acis data reduction , and to niel brandt , sergei popov , and jeremy heyl for useful discussions .
the and data were obtained through the high energy astrophysics science archive research center online service , provided by the nasa s goddard space flight center . the work was partially supported through nasa grants nag5 - 6907 and nag5 - 7017 . | the central pointlike x - ray source of the cas a supernova remnant was discovered in the first light observation and found later in the archival and images .
the analysis of these data does not show statistically significant variability of the source . because of the small number of photons detected , different spectral models can fit the observed spectrum .
the power - law fit yields the photon index @xmath04.1 , and luminosity @xmath1@xmath2@xmath3 erg s@xmath4 , for @xmath5 kpc .
the power - law index is higher , and the luminosity lower , than those observed from very young pulsars .
one can fit the spectrum equally well with a blackbody model with @xmath68 mk , @xmath7@xmath8 km , @xmath9@xmath10 erg s@xmath4 .
the inferred radii are too small , and the temperatures too high , for the radiation could be interpreted as emitted from the whole surface of a uniformly heated neutron star
. fits with the neutron star atmosphere models increase the radius and reduce the temperature , but these parameters are still substantially different from those expected for a young neutron star .
one can not exclude , however , that the observed emission originates from hot spots on a cooler neutron star surface .
because of strong interstellar absorption , the possible low - temperature component gives a small contribution to the observed spectrum ; an upper limit on the ( gravitationally redshifted ) surface temperature is @xmath112.3 mk , depending on chemical composition of the surface and star s radius . amongst several possible interpretations , we favor a model of a strongly magnetized neutron star with magnetically confined hydrogen or helium polar caps ( @xmath12 mk , @xmath13 km ) on a cooler iron surface ( @xmath14 mk ) . such temperatures are consistent with the standard models of neutron star cooling .
alternatively , the observed radiation may be interpreted as emitted by a compact object ( more likely , a black hole ) accreting from a fossil disk or from a late - type dwarf in a close binary .
submitted to _ the astrohysical journal _ |
star and planet formation are connected through disks .
disk formation , long thought to be a trivial consequence of angular momentum conservation during core collapse and star formation ( e.g. , bodenheimer1995 ) , turned out to be much more complicated than originally envisioned .
the complication comes from magnetic fields , which are observed in dense , star - forming , cores of molecular clouds ( see crutcher2012 for a recent review ) .
the field can strongly affect the angular momentum evolution of core collapse and disk formation through magnetic braking .
there have been a number of studies aiming at quantifying the effects of magnetic field on disk formation . in the ideal mhd limit
, both analytic considerations and numerical simulations have shown that the formation of a rotationally supported disk ( rsd hereafter ) is suppressed by a realistic magnetic field ( corresponding to a dimensionless mass - to - flux ratio of @xmath4 a few ; trolandcrutcher2008 ) during the protostellar mass accretion phase in the simplest case of a non - turbulent core with the magnetic field aligned with the rotation axis ( allen+2003 ; galli+2006 ; pricebate2007 ; mellonli2008 ; hennebellefromang2008 ; dappbasu2010 ; seifried+2011 ; santos - lima+2012 ) .
the suppression of rsds by excessive magnetic braking is termed `` magnetic braking catastrophe '' in star formation .
rotationally supported disks are routinely observed , however , around evolved class ii young stellar objects ( see williamscieza2011 for a review ) , and increasingly around class i ( e.g. , jorgensen+2009 ; lee2011 ; takakuwa+2012 ) and even one class 0 source ( tobin+2012 ) .
when and how such disks form in view of the magnetic braking catastrophe is unclear .
the current attempts to overcome the catastrophic braking fall into three categories : ( 1 ) non - ideal mhd effects , including ambipolar diffusion , ohmic dissipation and hall effect , ( 2 ) misalignment between magnetic and rotation axes , and ( 3 ) turbulence .
ambipolar diffusion does not appear to weaken the braking enough to enable large - scale rsd formation under realistic conditions ( krasnopolskykonigl2002 ; mellonli2009 ; duffinpudritz2009 ; li+2011 ) .
ohmic dissipation can produce small , au - scale , rsd in the early protostellar accretion phase ( machida+2010 ; dappbasu2010 ; dapp+2012 ; tomida+2013 ) .
larger , @xmath5-scale rsds can be produced if the resistivity or the hall coefficient of the dense core is much larger than the classical ( microscopic ) value ( krasnopolsky+2010,krasnopolsky+2011 ; see also braidingwardle2012a , braidingwardle2012b ) .
@xcite explored the effects of tilting the magnetic field away from the rotation axis on disk formation ( see also machida+2006 ; pricebate2007 ; hennebelleciardi2009 ) .
they concluded that keplerian disks can form for a mass - to - flux ratio @xmath6 as low as @xmath7 , as long as the tilt angle is close to @xmath2 ( see their fig .
the effects of turbulence were explored by @xcite , who concluded that a strong enough turbulence can induce enough magnetic diffusion to enable the formation of a @xmath5-scale rsd . @xcite and
@xcite considered supersonically turbulent massive cores .
they found rotationally dominated disks around low - mass stars , although in both cases the turbulence - induced rotation is misaligned with the initial magnetic field by a large angle , which may have contributed to the disk formation ( see also joos+2013 ) .
the goal of this paper is to revisit the role of magnetic field - rotation misalignment in disk formation .
the misalignment is expected if the angular momenta of dense cores are generated through turbulent motions ( e.g. , burkertbodenheimer2000 ; myers+2012 ) .
it is also inferred from the misalignment between the field direction traced by polarized dust emission and the outflow axis , which is taken as a proxy for the direction of rotation ( hull+2012 ) .
indeed , in the carma sample of @xcite , the distribution of the angle @xmath8 between the magnetic field and jet / rotation axis is consistent with being random .
if true , it would indicate that in half of the sources the two axes are misaligned by a large angle of @xmath9 ( see however chapman+2013 and discussion in [ disk ] )
. such a large misalignment would be enough to allow disk formation in dense cores magnetized to a realistic level ( with @xmath6 of a few ; trolandcrutcher2008 ) according to @xcite .
if the alignment angle @xmath8 is indeed random and @xcite s conclusions are generally true , the magnetic braking catastrophe would be largely solved .
given their far - reaching implications , it is prudent to check @xcite s conclusions , using a different numerical code
. it is the task of this paper .
we carry out numerical experiments of disk formation in dense cores with misaligned magnetic and rotation axes using non - ideal mhd code zeus - tw that includes self - gravity .
we find that a large misalignment angle does indeed enable the formation of rsds in weakly magnetized dense cores with dimensionless mass - to - flux ratios @xmath1 , but not in dense cores magnetized to higher , more typical levels .
our conclusion is that while the misalignment helps with disk formation , especially in relatively weakly magnetized cores , it may not provide a complete resolution to the magnetic braking catastrophe by itself .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in [ setup ] , we describe the model setup .
the numerical results are described in [ misalignment ] and [ strong ] .
we compare our results to those of @xcite and discuss their implications in [ discussion ] and conclude with a short summary in [ summary ] .
we follow @xcite and @xcite and start our simulations from a uniform , spherical core of @xmath10 and radius @xmath11 in a spherical coordinate system @xmath12 .
the initial density @xmath13 corresponds to a molecular hydrogen number density of @xmath14 .
we adopt an isothermal equation of state with a sound speed @xmath15 below a critical density @xmath16 , and a polytropic equation of state @xmath17 above it . at the beginning of the simulation ,
we impose a solid - body rotation of angular speed @xmath18 on the core , with axis along the north pole ( @xmath19 ) .
it corresponds to a ratio of rotational to gravitational binding energy of 0.025 , which is typical of the values inferred for nh@xmath20 cores ( goodman+1993 ) .
the initial magnetic field is uniform , tilting away from the rotation axis by an angle @xmath8 .
we consider three values for the initial field : @xmath21 , @xmath22 and @xmath23 , corresponding to dimensionless mass - to - flux ratio , in units of @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 and @xmath27 , respectively , for the core as a whole .
the mass - to - flux ratio for the central flux tube @xmath28 is higher than the global value @xmath6 by @xmath29 , so that @xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 for the three cases respectively .
the effective mass - to - flux ratio @xmath33 should lie between these two limits .
if the star formation efficiency per core is @xmath34 ( e.g. , alves+2007 ) , then one way to estimate @xmath33 is to consider the ( cylindrical ) magnetic flux surface that encloses @xmath35 of the core mass , which yields @xmath36 , corresponding to @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 for the three cases respectively ; the fraction @xmath35 is also not far from the typical fraction of core mass that has accreted onto the central object at the end of our simulations ( see table 1 ) . for the tilt angle
, we also consider three values : @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath2 .
the @xmath40 corresponds to the aligned case , with the magnetic field and rotation axis both along the @xmath42-axis ( @xmath19 ) .
the @xmath43 corresponds to the orthogonal case , with the magnetic field along the @xmath44-axis ( @xmath45 , @xmath46 ) .
models with these nine combinations of parameters are listed in table 1 ; additional models are discussed below .
lllllll a & 9.72 & 13.7 & 0@xmath47 & 1 & 0.24 & no + b & 4.86 & 6.85 & 0@xmath47 & 1 & 0.22 & no + c & 2.92 & 4.12 & 0@xmath47 & 1 & 0.33 & no + d & 9.72 & 13.7 & 45@xmath47 & 1 & 0.21 & yes / porous + e & 4.86 & 6.85 & 45@xmath47 & 1 & 0.35 & no + f & 2.92 & 4.12 & 45@xmath47 & 1 & 0.27 & no + g & 9.72 & 13.7 & 90@xmath47 & 1 & 0.38 & yes / robust + h & 4.86 & 6.85 & 90@xmath47 & 1 & 0.46 & yes / porous + i & 2.92 & 4.12 & 90@xmath47 & 1 & 0.47 & no + m & 9.72 & 13.7 & 90@xmath47 & 0 & 0.10 & yes / robust + n & 9.72 & 13.7 & 90@xmath47 & 0.1 & 0.26 & yes / robust + p & 4.03 & 5.68 & 90@xmath47 & 1 & 0.25 & yes / porous + q & 3.44 & 4.85 & 90@xmath47 & 1 & 0.14 & no + as in @xcite , we choose a non - uniform grid of @xmath48 . in the radial direction , the inner and outer boundaries are located at @xmath49 and @xmath11 , respectively .
the radial cell size is smallest near the inner boundary ( @xmath50 or @xmath51 ) .
it increases outward by a constant factor @xmath52 between adjacent cells . in the polar direction , we choose a relatively large cell size ( @xmath53 ) near the polar axes , to prevent the azimuthal cell size from becoming prohibitively small ; it decreases smoothly to a minimum of @xmath54 near the equator , where rotationally supported disks may form .
the grid is uniform in the azimuthal direction .
the boundary conditions in the azimuthal direction are periodic . in the radial direction , we impose the standard outflow boundary conditions .
material leaving the inner radial boundary is collected as a point mass ( protostar ) at the center .
it acts on the matter in the computational domain through gravity . on the polar axes ,
the boundary condition is chosen to be reflective .
although this is not strictly valid , we expect its effect to be limited to a small region near the axis .
we initially intended to carry out simulations in the ideal mhd limit , so that they can be compared more directly with other work , especially @xcite .
however , ideal mhd simulations tend to produce numerical `` hot zones '' that force the calculation to stop early in the protostellar mass accretion phase , a tendency we noted in our previous 2d ( mellonli2008 ) and 3d simulations ( krasnopolsky+2012 ) .
to lengthen the simulation , we include a small , spatially uniform resistivity @xmath55 .
we have verified that , in the particular case model g ( @xmath56 and @xmath43 ) , this resistivity changes the flow structure little compared to either the ideal mhd model m ( before the latter stops ) or model n , where the resistivity is reduced by a factor 10 , to @xmath57 .
to illustrate the effect of the misalignment between the magnetic field direction and rotation axis , we first consider an extreme case where the magnetic field is rather weak ( with a mass - to - flux ratio @xmath56 for the core as a whole and @xmath58 for the inner @xmath35 of the core mass ) . in this case ,
a well - formed rotationally supported disk is present in the orthogonal case with @xmath43 ( model g in table 1 ) .
such a disk is absent in the aligned case ( with @xmath40 , model a ) . the contrast is illustrated in fig .
[ contrast ] , where we plot snapshots of the aligned and orthogonal cases at a representative time @xmath59 , when a central mass of @xmath60 and @xmath61 , respectively , has formed .
the flow structures in the two cases are very different in both the equatorial ( panels [ a ] and [ b ] ) and meridian ( panels [ c ] and [ d ] ) plane . in the equatorial plane ,
the aligned case has a relatively large ( with radius @xmath62 ) over - dense region where material spirals rapidly inward .
on the ( smaller ) scale of @xmath63 , the structure is dominated by expanding , low - density lobes ; they are the decoupling enabled magnetic structures ( dems for short ) that have been studied in detail by @xcite and @xcite .
no rotationally supported disk is evident .
the equatorial structure on the @xmath64 scale in the orthogonal case is dominated by a pair of spirals instead .
the spirals merge , on the @xmath63 scale , into a more or less continuous , rapidly rotating structure a rotationally supported disk .
clearly , the accretion flow in the orthogonal case was able to retain more angular momentum than in the aligned case .
why is this the case ?
a clue comes from the meridian view of the two cases ( panels [ c ] and [ d ] of fig .
[ contrast ] ) . in the aligned case
, there is a strong bipolar outflow extending beyond @xmath65 at the relatively early time shown .
the outflow forces most of the infalling material to accrete through a flattened equatorial structure an over - dense pseudodisk ( gallishu1993 ; see panel [ a ] for a face - on view of the pseudodisk , noting the difference in scale between panel [ c ] and [ a ] ) .
it is the winding of the magnetic field lines by the rotating material in the pseudodisk that drives the bipolar outflow in the first place .
the wound - up field lines act back on the pseudodisk material , braking its rotation .
it is the efficient magnetic braking in the pseudodisk that makes it difficult for rotationally supported disks to form in the aligned case .
the prominent bipolar outflow indicative of efficient magnetic braking is absent in the orthogonal case , as was emphasized by @xcite .
it is replaced by a much smaller , shell - like structure inside which the @xmath63-scale rotationally supported disk is encased ( panel [ d ] ) . to understand this difference in flow structure pictorially , we plot in fig .
[ 3d ] the three - dimensional structure of the magnetic field lines on the scale of @xmath66 ( or @xmath67 ) , which is @xmath29 larger than the size of panels ( a ) and ( b ) of fig .
[ contrast ] , but half of that of panels ( c ) and ( d ) .
clearly , in the aligned case , the relatively weak initial magnetic field ( corresponding to @xmath68 ) has been wound up many turns by the material in the equatorial pseudodisk , building up a magnetic pressure in the equatorial region that is released along the polar directions ( see the first panel of fig .
the magnetic pressure gradient drives a bipolar outflow , which is evident in panel ( c ) and in many previous simulations of magnetized core collapse , including the early ones such as @xcite and @xcite .
in contrast , in the orthogonal case , the equatorial region is no longer the region of the magnetically induced pseudodisk . in the absence of rotation ( along the @xmath42-axis ) , the dense core material would preferentially contract along the field lines ( that are initially along the @xmath44-axis ) to form a dense sheet in the @xmath69-@xmath42 plane that passes through the origin .
the twisting of this sheet by rotation along the @xmath42-axis produces two curved `` curtains '' that spiral smoothly into the disk at small distances , somewhat analogous in shape to two snail - shells ( see the second panel of fig .
[ 3d ] ) .
the snail - shaped dense curtain in the orthogonal case naturally explains the morphology of the density maps shown in panels ( b ) and ( d ) of fig .
[ contrast ] .
first , the two prominent spiral arms in the panel ( a ) are simply the equatorial ( @xmath44-@xmath69 ) cut of the curved curtains . an interesting feature of the spirals ( and the snail - shaped dense curtain as a whole ) is that they are the region where the magnetic field lines change directions sharply .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ pinch ] , which is similar to panel ( b ) of fig .
[ contrast ] , except that the magnetic vectors ( rather than velocity vectors ) are plotted on top of the density map .
clearly , the spirals separate the field lines rotating counter clock - wise ( lower - right part of the figure ) from those rotating close - wise ( upper - left ) .
the sharp kink is analogous to the well - known field line kink across the equatorial pseudodisk in the aligned case , where the radial component of the magnetic field changes direction .
it supports our interpretation of the spirals and , by extension , the curtain as a magnetically induced feature , as is the case of pseudodisk . in other words ,
the spirals are not produced by gravitational instability in a rotationally supported structure ; they are `` pseudospirals '' in the same sense as the `` pseudodisks '' of @xcite .
the field line kinks are also evident across the dense curtain in the 3d structure shown in the second panel of fig .
[ 3d ] .
the 3d topology of the magnetic field and the dense structures that it induces lie at the heart of the difference in the magnetic braking efficiency between the aligned and orthogonal case .
in particular , a flattened , rotating , equatorial pseudodisk threaded by an ordered magnetic field with an appreciable vertical component ( along the rotation axis ) is more conducive to driving an outflow than a warped curtain with a magnetic field predominantly tangential to its surface .
the outflow plays a key role in angular momentum removal and the suppression of rotationally supported disks , as we demonstrate next . to quantify the outflow effect
, we follow @xcite ( @xcite ; see also joos+2012 ) and compare the rates of angular momentum change inside a finite volume @xmath70 through its surface @xmath71 due to infall and outflow to that due to magnetic torque .
the total magnetic torque relative to the origin ( from which a radius vector @xmath72 is defined ) is @xmath73\,dv,\ ] ] where the integration is over the volume @xmath70 .
typically , the magnetic torque comes mainly from the magnetic tension rather than pressure force .
the dominant magnetic tension term can be simplified to a surface integral ( matsumototomisaka2004 ) @xmath74 over the surface @xmath71 of the volume .
this volume - integrated magnetic torque is to be compared with the rate of angular momentum advected into the volume through fluid motion , @xmath75 which will be referred to as the advective torque below .
since the initial angular momentum of the dense core is along the @xmath42-axis , we will be mainly concerned with the @xmath42-component of the magnetic and advective torque which , for a spherical volume inside radius @xmath76 , are given by @xmath77 and @xmath78 the advective torque consists of two parts : the rates of angular momentum advected into and out of the sphere by infall and outflow respectively : @xmath79 and @xmath80 an example of the magnetic and advective torques is shown in fig . [ torque ] .
the torques are evaluated on spherical surfaces of different radii , at the representative time @xmath59 . for the aligned case ,
the net torque close to the central object is nearly zero up to a radius of @xmath81 , indicating that the angular momentum advected inward is nearly completely removed by magnetic braking there . at larger distances , between @xmath82 and @xmath62 ,
the net torque @xmath83 is negative , indicating that the angular momentum of the material inside a sphere of radius in this range decreases with time .
this is in sharp contrast with the orthogonal case , where the net torque is positive in that radial range , with the angular momentum there increasing ( rather than decreasing ) with time .
one may think that the difference is mainly due to a significantly larger magnetic torque @xmath84 in the aligned case than in the orthogonal case .
although this is typically the case at early times , the magnetic torques in the two cases become comparable at later times ( see the lowest solid lines in the two panels of fig .
[ torque ] ; a movie of the torques is available on request from the authors ) .
a bigger difference comes from the total ( or net ) angular momentum @xmath85 advected inward , which is substantially smaller in the aligned case than in the orthogonal case ( see the uppermost solid lines in the two panels ) .
the main reason for the difference is that a good fraction of the angular momentum advected inward by infall @xmath86 is advected back out by outflow @xmath87 in the former , but not the latter .
this is helped by the fact that @xmath86 is somewhat smaller in the aligned case to begin with ( compare the dotted lines in the two panels ) .
the lack of appreciable outward advection of angular momentum by outflow , which is itself a product of field - winding and magnetic braking in the aligned case , appears to be the main reason for the orthogonal case to retain more angular momentum at small radii and form a rotationally supported disk in this particular case of relatively weak magnetic field .
the formation of a rotationally supported disk can be seen most clearly in fig .
[ rotation ] , where we plot the infall and rotation speed , as well as specific angular momentum as a function of radius along 4 ( @xmath88 and @xmath89 ) directions in the equatorial plane . in the orthogonal case ,
the infall and rotation speeds display the two tell - tale signs of rotationally supported disks : ( 1 ) a slow , subsonic ( although nonzero ) infall speed much smaller than the free fall value , and ( 2 ) a much faster rotation speed close to the keplerian value inside a radius of @xmath90 .
the absence of a rotationally supported disk in the aligned case is just as obvious .
it has a rotation speed well below the keplerian value and an infall speed close to the free fall value , especially at small radii up to @xmath90 .
this corresponds to the region dominated by the low - density , strongly magnetized , expanding lobes ( i.e. , dems ; see panel [ a ] of fig [ contrast ] ) where the angular momentum is almost completely removed by a combination of magnetic torque and outflow ( see the third panel in fig .
[ rotation ] ) . also evident from the panel
is that the specific angular momentum of the equatorial inflow drops significantly twice : near @xmath91 and @xmath62 respectively .
the former corresponds to the dems - dominated region , and the latter the pseudodisk ( see panel [ a ] of fig . [ contrast ] ) .
the relatively slow infall inside the pseudodisk allows more time for magnetic braking to remove angular momentum .
it is the pseudodisk ( and its associated outflow ) working in tandem with the dems that suppresses the formation of a rotationally supported disk in the aligned case .
interestingly , there is a bump near @xmath62 for the specific angular momentum of the orthogonal case , indicating that the angular momentum in the equatorial plane is transported radially outward along the spiraling field lines from small to large distances ( see fig .
[ pinch ] ) .
the spiraling equatorial field lines in the orthogonal model g have an interesting property : they consist of two strains of opposite polarity .
as the strains get wound up more and more tightly by rotation at smaller and smaller radii , field lines of opposite polarity are pressed closer and closer together , creating a situation that is conducive to reconnection , either of physical or numerical origin ( see the first panel of fig .
[ magnetic ] ) .
model g contains a small but finite resistivity ( @xmath55 ) .
it does not appear to be responsible for the formation and survival of the keplerian disk , because a similar disk is also formed at the same ( relatively early ) time for a smaller resistivity of @xmath92 ( model n ) and even without any explicit resistivity ( model m ) .
numerical resistivity may have played a role here , but it is difficult to quantify at the moment . in any case
, the magnetic field on the keplerian disk appears to be rather weak , as can be seen from the second panel of fig .
[ magnetic ] , where the plasma @xmath93 is plotted along 4 ( @xmath88 and @xmath89 ) directions in the equatorial plane . on the keplerian disk in the orthogonal model g ( inside @xmath90 ) , @xmath93 is of order @xmath94 or more , indicating that there is more matter accumulating in the disk than magnetic field , either because the matter slides along the field lines into the disk ( increasing density but not the field strength ) or because of numerical reconnection that weakens the field , or both .
this situation is drastically different from the aligned case , where the inner @xmath95 region is heavily influenced by the magnetically - dominated low - density lobes .
we have seen from the preceding section that , in the weakly magnetized case of @xmath56 , the @xmath5-scale inner part of the protostellar accretion flow is dominated by two very different types of structures : a weakly magnetized , dense , rotationally supported disk ( rsd ) in the orthogonal case ( @xmath43 , model g ) and magnetically dominated , low - density lobes or dems in the aligned case ( @xmath40 , model a ) , at least at the relatively early time discussed in [ misalignment ] , when the central mass reaches @xmath96 .
this dichotomy persists to later times for these two models and for other models as well , as illustrated by fig .
[ all ] , where we plot models a i at a time when the central mass reaches @xmath97 .
it is clear that the rsd for model g becomes even more prominent at the later time , although a small magnetically dominated , low - density lobe is evident close to the center of the disk : it is a trapped dems that is too weak to disrupt the disk . in this case
, the identification of a robust rsd is secure , at even later times ( up to the end of the simulation , when the central mass reaches @xmath98 or @xmath99 of the initial core mass ) . in the aligned case ( model a )
, the inner accretion flow remains dominated by the highly dynamic dems at late times , with no sign of rsd formation . for the intermediate tilt angle case of @xmath100 ( model d ) , the inner structure of the protostellar accretion flow is shaped by the tussle between rsd and dems .
[ all ] shows that , at the plotted time , model d has several spiral arms that appear to merge into a rotating disk .
there are , however , at least three low - density `` holes '' near the center of the disk : they are the magnetically dominated dems .
movies show that the highly variable dems are generally confined close to the center , although they can occasionally expand to occupy a large fraction of the disk surface .
overall , the circumstellar structure in model d is more disk - like than dems - like . we shall call it a `` porous disk , '' to distinguish it from the more filled - in , more robust disk in the orthogonal model g. even though most of the porous disk has a rotation speed dominating the infall speed , the infall is highly variable , and often supersonic .
the rotation speed also often deviates greatly from the keplerian value .
such an erratic disk is much more dynamic than the quiescent disks envisioned around relatively mature ( e.g. , class ii ) ysos .
the intermediate tilt angle case drives a powerful bipolar outflow , unlike the orthogonal case , but similar to the aligned case .
this is consistent with the rate of angular momentum removal increasing with decreasing tilt angle ( i.e. , from @xmath2 to @xmath41 ; see also ciardihennebelle2010 ) . as the strength of the initial magnetic field in the core increases ,
the dems becomes more dominant .
this is illustrated in the middle column of fig .
[ all ] , where the three cases with an intermediate field strength corresponding to @xmath101 ( and @xmath102 ) are plotted . in model h , where the magnetic and rotation axes are orthogonal , a relatively small ( with radius of @xmath103 ) rotationally dominated disk is clearly present at the time shown .
as in the weaker field case of model g , it is fed by prominent `` pseudo - spirals '' which are part of a magnetically - induced curtain in 3d ( see the second panel of fig .
[ 3d ] ) . compared to model g
, the curtain here is curved to a lesser degree , which is not surprising because the rotation is slower due to a more efficient braking and the stronger magnetic field embedded in the curtain is harder to bend .
the disk is also smaller , less dense , and more dynamic .
it is more affected by dems , which occasionally disrupt the disk , although it always reforms after disruption .
overall , the circumstellar structure in model h is more rsd - like than dems - like . as in model d
, we classify it as a `` porous disk . '' as the tilt angle decreases from @xmath2 to @xmath41 ( model e ) and further to @xmath104 ( model b ) , the rotationally dominated circumstellar structure largely disappears ; it is replaced by dems - dominated structures . even though there is still a significant amount of rotation in the accretion flow , a dense coherent disk
is absent .
we conclude that for a moderately strong magnetic field of @xmath101 the formation of rsd is suppressed if the tilt angle is moderate . in the cases of the strongest magnetic field corresponding to @xmath105 ( and @xmath106 ) , the formation of rsd is suppressed regardless of the tilt angle , as can be seen from the last column of fig . [ all ] . for the orthogonal case ( model i ) ,
the prominent `` pseudo - spirals '' in the weaker field cases of model g ( @xmath56 ) and h ( @xmath101 ) are replaced by two arms that are only slightly bent .
they are part of a well - defined pseudodisk that happens to lie roughly in the @xmath107 ( or @xmath44-@xmath42 ) plane ( see the second panel of fig . [ 3db1e-5 ] ) . in the absence of any initial rotation
, one would expect the pseudodisk to form perpendicular to the initial field direction along the @xmath44-axis , i.e. , in the @xmath108 ( or @xmath69-@xmath42 ) plane . over the entire course of core evolution and collapse ,
the rotation has rotated the expected plane of the pseudodisk by nearly @xmath2 .
nevertheless , at the time shown ( when the central mass reaches @xmath97 ) , there is apparently little rotation left inside @xmath109 to warp the pseudodisk significantly .
except for the orientation , this pseudodisk looks remarkably similar to the familiar one in the aligned case ( model c ; see the first panel of fig .
[ 3db1e-5 ] ) .
in particular , there are low - density `` holes '' in the inner part of both pseudodisks which are threaded by intense magnetic fields and surrounded by dense filaments : they are the dems . in the intermediate tilt angle case of @xmath41 ( model f , not shown in the 3d figure ) , the pseudodisk is somewhat more warped than the two other cases , and its inner part is again dominated by dems .
it is clear that for a magnetic field of @xmath6 of a few , the inner circumstellar structure is dominated by the magnetic field , with rotation playing a relatively minor role ; the rsd remains suppressed despite the misalignment .
to better estimate the boundary between the cores that produce rsds and those that do not , we carried out two additional simulations with @xmath43 ( models p and q in table 1 ) .
we found a porous disk in model p ( @xmath110 and @xmath111 ) , as in the weaker field case of model h , but no disk in model q ( @xmath112 and @xmath113 ) , as in the stronger field case of model i. from this , we infer that the boundary lies approximately at @xmath114 ( or @xmath115 ) .
our most important qualitative result is that the misalignment between the magnetic field and rotation axis tends to promote the formation of rotationally supported disks , especially in weakly magnetized dense cores .
this is in agreement with the conclusion previously reached by @xcite ( @xcite ; jhc12 hereafter ) , using a different numerical code and somewhat different problem setup .
their calculations were carried out using an adaptive mesh refinement ( amr ) code in the cartesian coordinate system , with the central object treated using a stiffening of the equation of state , whereas ours were done using a fixed mesh refinement ( fmr ) code in the spherical coordinate system , with an effective sink particle at the origin . despite the differences ,
these two distinct sets of calculations yield qualitatively similar results .
the case for the misalignment promoting disk formation is therefore strengthened .
quantitatively , there appears to be a significant discrepancy between our results and theirs . according to their fig .
14 , a keplerian disk is formed in the relatively strongly magnetized case of @xmath116 if the misalignment angle @xmath43 .
formally , this case corresponds roughly to our model i ( @xmath105 and @xmath43 ) , for which we can rule out the formation of a rotationally supported disk with confidence ( see fig . [ all ] ) .
we believe that the discrepancy comes mostly from the initial density profile adopted , which affects the degree of magnetization near the core center for a given global mass - to - flux ratio @xmath6 . @xcite adopted a centrally condensed initial mass distribution @xmath117 with the characteristic radius @xmath118 set to @xmath35 of the core radius @xmath119 , so that the central - to - edge density contrast is 10 ( see also ciardihennebelle2010 ) .
it is easy to show that , for this density profile and a uniform magnetic field , the mass - to - flux ratio for the flux tube passing through the origin is @xmath120 where @xmath121 and @xmath6 is the global mass - to - flux ratio for the core as a whole .
for @xmath122 , we have @xmath123 . in other words ,
the central part of their core is substantially less magnetized relative to mass than the core as a whole , due to the initial mass condensation . for the @xmath116 case under consideration
, we have @xmath124 , which makes the material on the central flux tube rather weakly magnetized ( relative to mass ) .
the magnetization of the central region is important , because the central part is accreted first and the star formation efficiency in a core may not be 100% efficient ( e.g. , alves+2007 ) . if we define as in [ setup ] an effective mass - to - flux ratio for the ( cylindrical ) magnetic flux surface that encloses @xmath35 of the core mass , then @xmath125 for the density distribution adopted by jhc12 ( equation [ [ profile ] ] ) .
it is significantly different from the effective mass - to - flux ratio of @xmath36 for the uniform density that we adopted .
the above difference in @xmath33 makes our strongest field case of @xmath105 ( @xmath106 ) more directly comparable to jhc12 s @xmath126 ( @xmath127 ) case .
there is agreement that , in both cases , the formation of a rsd is suppressed , even when the tilt angle @xmath43 .
these results suggest that rsd formation is suppressed when the effective mass - to - flux ratio @xmath128 , independent of the degree of field - rotation misalignment , consistent with the conclusion we reached toward the end of [ strong ] based on models p and q. similarly , jhc12 s @xmath116 ( @xmath129 ) models may be more directly comparable to our @xmath101 ( @xmath102 ) models .
our calculations show that a ( more or less ) rotationally supported disk is formed in the extreme @xmath43 case for @xmath102 ( model h , see fig .
[ all ] ) but not in the intermediate tilt angle @xmath100 case ( model e ) .
this is consistent with their fig .
14 , where a keplerian disk is formed for @xmath43 for @xmath129 , but not for @xmath100 . in the latter case
, jhc12 found a disk - like structure with a flat rather than keplerian rotation profile .
they attributed the flat rotation to additional support from the magnetic energy , which dominates the kinetic energy at small radii .
we believe that their high magnetic energy comes from strongly magnetized , low - density lobes ( i.e. , dems ) , which are clearly visible in our model e ( see fig . [ all ] ) .
although there is still significant rotation on the @xmath5 scale in model e , we find the morphology and kinematics of the circumstellar structure too disorganized to be called a `` disk . ''
we conclude that for a moderate field strength corresponding to @xmath130@xmath131 , a rotationally supported disk does not form except when the magnetic field is tilted nearly orthogonal to the rotation axis . our weak - field case of @xmath56 ( @xmath58 )
can be compared with jhc12 s @xmath132 ( @xmath133 ) case . in both cases ,
a well - defined rotationally supported disk is formed when @xmath43 ( see our fig . [ all ] and their fig .
12 ) . for the intermediate tilt angle @xmath100
, jhc12 obtained a disk - like structure with a flat rotation curve , with the magnetic energy dominating the kinetic energy at small radii .
this is broadly consistent with our intermediate tilt angle model d , where a highly variable , `` porous '' disk is formed , with the central part often dominated by strongly magnetized , low - density lobes .
there is also agreement that the disk formation is suppressed if @xmath134 even for such a weakly magnetized case .
it therefore appears that , for the weak - field case of @xmath135 , a rotationally supported disk can be induced by a relatively moderate tilt angle of @xmath136 .
the result that a misalignment between the magnetic field and rotation axis helps disk formation by weakening magnetic braking may be counter - intuitive .
@xcite showed analytically that , for a uniform rotating cylinder embedded in a uniform static external medium , magnetic braking is much more efficient in the orthogonal case than in the aligned case .
this analytic result may not be directly applicable to a collapsing core , however . as emphasized by jhc12 ,
the collapse drags the initially uniform , rotation - aligned magnetic field into a configuration that fans out radially .
jhc12 estimated analytically that the collapse - induced field fan - out could in principle make the magnetic braking in the aligned case more efficient than in the orthogonal case .
the analytical estimate did not , however , take into account of the angular momentum removal by outflow , which , as we have shown in [ torque ] , is a key difference between the weak - field ( @xmath56 , @xmath137 ) aligned case ( model a ) where disk formation is suppressed and its orthogonal counterpart ( model g ) that does produce a rotationally supported disk ( see figs . [ contrast ] and [ torque ] , and also ciardihennebelle2010 ) .
the generation of a powerful outflow in the weak - field aligned case ( model a ) is facilitated by the orientation of its pseudodisk , which is perpendicular to the rotation axis ( see fig . [ 3d ] ) .
this configuration is conducive to both the pseudodisk winding up the field lines and the wound - up field escaping above and below the pseudodisk , which drives a bipolar outflow .
when the magnetic field is tilted by @xmath2 away from the rotation axis , the pseudodisk is warped by rotation into a snail - shaped curtain that is unfavorable to outflow driving ( see fig .
the outflow makes it more difficult to form a rotationally supported disk in the aligned case .
disk formation is further hindered by magnetically dominated , low - density lobes ( dems ) , which affect the inner part of the accretion flow of the aligned case more than that of the perpendicular case , at least when the field is relatively weak ( see fig .
[ contrast ] and [ all ] ) . for more strongly magnetized cases ,
the dems becomes more dynamically important close to the central object , independent of the tilt angle @xmath8 ( see fig .
[ 3db1e-5 ] ) . dems - like structures
were also seen in some runs of jhc12 ( e.g. , the case of @xmath126 and @xmath40 ; see their fig .
19 ) but were not commented upon . as stressed previously by @xcite and @xcite and confirmed by our calculations , the dems presents a formidable obstacle to the formation and survival of a rotationally supported disk .
while there is agreement between jhc12 and our calculations that misalignment between the magnetic field and rotation axis is beneficial to disk formation , it is unlikely that the misalignment alone can enable disk formation around the majority of young stellar objects .
the reason is the following .
@xcite obtained a mean dimensionless mass - to - flux ratio of @xmath138 through oh zeeman observations for a sample of dense cores in nearby dark clouds near the center relative to that in the envelope . ] .
for such a small @xmath33 , disk formation is completely suppressed , even for the case of maximum misalignment of @xmath43 .
@xcite argued , however , that there is a flat distribution of the total field strength in dense cores , from @xmath139 to some maximum value @xmath140 ; the latter corresponds to @xmath141 , so that the mean @xmath142 stays around 2 .
if this is the case , some cores could be much more weakly magnetized than others , and disks could form preferentially in these cores . however , to form a rotationally supported disk , the core material must have ( 1 ) an effective mass - to - flux ratio @xmath33 greater than about 5 _ and _ ( 2 ) a rather large tilt angle ( see discussion in the preceding section ) . if one assumes that the core - to - core variation of @xmath33 comes mostly from the field strength rather than the column density ( as done in crutcher+2010 ) , then the probability of a core having @xmath143 ( or @xmath144 ) is @xmath145 . since a large tilt angle of @xmath146
is required to form a rsd for @xmath130@xmath131 , the chance of disk formation is reduced from @xmath145 by at least a factor of 2 ( assuming a random orientation of the magnetic field relative to the rotation axis ) , to @xmath147 or less . the above estimate is necessarily rough , and can easily be off by a factor of two in either direction .
it is , however , highly unlikely for the majority of the cores to simultaneously satisfy the conditions on both @xmath33 and @xmath8 for disk formation .
the condition @xmath143 is especially difficult to satisfy because , as noted earlier , it implies that the dense cores probed by oh observations must have a total field strength @xmath148 , less than or comparable to the well - defined median field strength inferred by @xcite for the much more diffuse , cold neutral _ atomic _ medium ( cnm ) .
it is hard to imagine a reasonable scenario in which the majority of dense cores have magnetic fields weaker than the cnm .
we note that @xcite independently estimated a range of @xmath149@xmath29 for the fraction of dense cores that would produce a keplerian disk based on fig . 14 of jhc12 .
their lower limit of @xmath147 is in agreement with our estimate ; in both cases , the fraction is dominated by weakly magnetized cores that have mass - to - flux ratios greater than @xmath150 and moderately large tilt angles .
their upper limit of @xmath151 is much higher than our estimate , mainly because it includes rather strongly magnetized cores with mass - to - flux ratios as small as @xmath152 .
since our calculations show that such strongly magnetized cores do not produce rotationally supported disks even for large tilt angles , we believe that this upper limit may be overly generous .
whether dense cores have large tilt angle @xmath8 between the magnetic field and rotation axis that are conducive to disk formation is unclear .
@xcite measured the field orientation on the @xmath109-scale for a sample of 16 sources using millimeter interferometer carma .
they found that the field orientation is not tightly correlated with the outflow axis ; indeed , the angle between the two is consistent with being random . if the outflow axis is aligned with the core rotation axis and if the field orientation is the same on the core scale as on the smaller , @xmath109-scale , then @xmath8 would be randomly distributed between @xmath153 and @xmath2 , with half of the sources having @xmath154 . however , the outflow axis may not be representative of the core rotation axis .
this is because the ( fast ) outflow is thought to be driven magnetocentrifugally from the inner part of the circumstellar disk ( on the au - scale or less ; shu+2000 ; koniglpudritz2000 ) .
a parcel of core material would have lost most of its angular momentum on the way to the outflow launching location ; the torque ( most likely magnetic or gravitational ) that removes the angular momentum may also change the direction of the rotation axis . similarly , the field orientation on the @xmath109-scale may not be representative of the initial field orientation on the larger core scale .
the magnetic field on the @xmath109 scale is more prone to distortion by collapse and rotation than that on the core scale .
indeed , @xcite found that the field orientation on the core scale measured using single - disk telescope cso is within @xmath155 of the outflow axis for 3 of the 4 sources in their sample ; the larger angle measured in the remain source may be due projection effects because its outflow axis is close to the line - of - sight .
if the result of @xcite is valid in general and if the outflow axis reflects the core rotation axis , then dense cores with large tilt angle @xmath8 would be rare . in this case
, disk formation would be rare according to the calculations presented in this paper and in jhc12 , even in the unlikely event that the majority of dense cores are as weakly magnetized as @xmath143 .
rotationally supported disks are observed , however , routinely around evolved class ii ysos ( see williamscieza2011 for a recent review ) , and increasingly around younger class i ( e.g. , jorgensen+2009 ; lee2011 ; takakuwa et al . 2012 ) and even class 0 ( tobin+2012 ) sources . when and how such disks form remain unclear .
our calculations indicated that the formation of large observable ( @xmath5-scale ) rotationally supported disks .
small disks may be needed to drive fast outflows during the class 0 phase , and may form through non - ideal mhd effects ( machida+2010 ; dappbasu2010 ; dapp+2012 ) . ]
is difficult even in the presence of a large tilt angle @xmath8 during the early protostellar accretion ( class 0 ) phase ( e.g. , alves+2007 ) . ] .
this may not contradict the available observations yet ( maury+2010 ) , since only one keplerian disk is found around a ( late ) class 0 source so far ( l1527 ; tobin+2012 ) ; it could result from a rare combination of an unusually weak magnetic field and a large tilt angle @xmath8 .
if it turns out , through future observations using alma and jvla , that large - scale keplerian disks are prevalent around class 0 sources , then some crucial ingredients must be missing from the current calculations .
possible candidates include non - ideal mhd effects and turbulence .
the existing calculations indicate that realistic levels of the classical non - ideal mhd effects do not weaken the magnetic braking enough to enable large - scale disk formation ( mellonli2009 ; li+2011 ; krasnopolsky+2012 ; see also krasnopolskykonigl2002 and braidingwardle2012a , braidingwardle2012b ) , although misalignment has yet to be considered in such calculations .
supersonic turbulence was found to be conducive to disk formation ( santos - lima+2012,santos - lima+2013 ; seifried+2012 ; myers+2012 ; joos+2013 ) , although dense cores of low - mass star formation typically have subsonic non - thermal line - width and it is unclear whether subsonic turbulence can enable disk formation in dense cores magnetized to a realistic level .
if , on the other hand , it turns out that large - scale keplerian disks are rare among class 0 sources , then the question of disk growth becomes paramount : how do the mostly undetectable class 0 disks become detectable in the class i and ii phase ? if the magnetic braking plays a role in keeping the early disk undetectable , then its weakening at later times may promote rapid disk growth .
one possibility for the late weakening of magnetic braking is the depletion of the protostellar envelope , either by outflow stripping ( mellonli2008 ) or accretion ( machida+2011 ) .
it deserves to be better quantified .
we carried out a set of mhd simulations of star formation in dense cores magnetized to different degrees and with different tilt angles between the magnetic field and the rotation axis .
we confirmed the qualitative result of @xcite that misalignment between the magnetic field and rotation axis tends to weaken magnetic braking and is thus conducive to disk formation .
quantitatively , we found however that the misalignment enables the formation of a rotationally supported disk only in dense cores where the star - forming material is rather weakly magnetized , with a dimensionless mass - to - flux ratio @xmath1 ; large misalignment in such cores allows the rotation to wrap the equatorial pseudodisk in the aligned case into a curved curtain that hinders outflow driving and angular momentum removal , making disk formation easier . in more strongly magnetized cores ,
disk formation is suppressed independent of the misalignment angle , because the inner part of the protostellar accretion flow is dominated by strongly magnetized , low - density regions .
if dense cores are as strongly magnetized as inferred by @xcite ( @xcite ; with a mean mass - to - flux ratio @xmath3 ) , it would be difficult for the misalignment alone to enable disk formation in the majority of them .
we conclude that how protostellar disks form remains an open question .
we thank mark krumholz for useful discussion .
this work is supported in part by nasa grant nnx10ah30 g and the theoretical institute for advanced research in astrophysics ( tiara ) in taiwan through the charms project .
allen , a. , li , z .- y . , & shu , f. h. 2003 , , 599 , 363 alves , j. , lombardi , m. , & lada , c. j. 2007 , , 462 , 17 bodenheimer , p. 1995
, , 33 , 199 braiding , c. r. , & wardle , m. 2012 , , 422 , 261 braiding , c. r. , & wardle , m. 2012 , , 427 , 3188 burkert , a. , & bodenheimer , p. 2000 , , 543 , 822 chapman , n. et al .
2013 , , submitted ciardi , a. , & hennebelle , p. 2010
, , 409 , l39 crutcher , r. m. 2012 , , 50 , 29 crutcher , r. m. , wandelt , b. , heiles , c. , falgarone , e. , & troland , t. h. 2010 , , 725 , 466 dapp , w. b. , & basu , s. 2010 , , 521 , 56 dapp , w. b. , basu , s. , & kunz , m. w. 2012 , , 541 , a35 duffin , d. f. & pudritz , r. e. 2009 , , 706 , l46 galli , d. , lizano , s. , shu , f. h. , & allen , a. 2006 , , 647 , 374 galli , d. , & shu , f. h. 1993 , , 417 , 243 goodman , a. a. , benson , p. , fuller , g. a. , & myers , p. c. 1993 , , 406 , 528 heiles , c. , & troland , t. h. 2005 , , 624 , 773 hennebelle , p. , & ciardi , a. 2009 , , 506 , l29 hennebelle , p. , & fromang , s. 2008 , , 477 , 9 hull , c. l. h. et al .
2012 , arxiv1212.0540 joos , m. , hennebelle , p. , & ciardi , a. 2012 , , 543 , a128 joos , m. , hennebelle , p. , ciardi , a. , & fromang , s. 2013 , , submitted , arxiv:1301.3004 jrgensen , j. k. , van dishoeck , e. f. , visser , r. , bourke , t. l. , wilner , d. j. , lommen , d. , hogerheijde , m. r. , & myers , p. c. 2009 , , 507 , 861 knigl , a. & pudritz , r. 2000 , in protostars and planets iv , eds .
v. mannings et al .
( univ . of arizona press ) , 759 krasnopolsky , r. , & knigl , a. 2002 , , 580 , 987 krasnopolsky , r. , li , z .- y . , & shang , h. 2010 , , 716 , 1541 krasnopolsky , r. , li , z .- y . , & shang , h. 2011 , , 733 , 54 krasnopolsky , r. , li , z .- y . , shang , h. , & zhao , b. 2012 , , 757 , 77 krumholz , m. r. , crutcher , r. m , & hull , c. l. h. 2013 , , submitted lee , c. f. 2011 , , 741 , 62 li , z .- y . , krasnopolsky , r. , & shang , h. 2011 , , 738 , 180 machida , m. n. , inutsuka , s. , & matsumoto , t. 2010 , arxiv:1009.2140 machida , m. n. , inutsuka , s. , & matsumoto , t. 2011 , , 63 , 555 machida , m. n. , matsumoto , t. , hanawa , t. , & tomisaka , k. 2006 , , 645 , 1227 matsumoto , t. , & tomisaka , k. 2004 , , 616 , 266 maury , a. j. , andr , p. , hennebelle , p. , motte , f. , stamatellos , d. , bate , m. , belloche , a. , duchne , g. , & whitworth , a. 2010 , , 512 , a40 myers , a. t. , mckee , c. f. , cunningham , a. j. , klein , r. i. , & krumholz , m. r. 2012 , arxiv:1211.3467 ( submitted to ) mellon , r. r. , & li , z .- y .
2008 , , 681 , 1356 mellon , r. r. , & li , z .- y .
2009 , , 698 , 922 mouschovias , t. ch . , &
paleologou , e. v. 1979 , , 230 , 204 price , d. j. , & bate , m. r. 2007 , , 311 , 75 santos - lima , r. , de gouveia dal pino , e. m. , & lazarian , a. 2012 , , 747 , 21 santos - lima , r. , de gouveia dal pino , e. m. , & lazarian , a. 2013 , , in press seifried , d. , banerjee , r. , klessen , r. s. , duffin , d. , & pudritz , r. e. 2011 , , 417 , 1054 seifried , d. , banerjee , r. , pudritz r. , & klessen , r. s. 2012 , , 423 , 40 shu , f. h. , najita , j. r. , shang , h. , & li , z .- y .
2000 , in protostars and planets iv , eds .
v. mannings et al .
( univ . of arizona press ) , 789 takakuwa , s , saito , m. , lim , j. , saigo , k. , sridharan , t. k. , & patel , n. a. 2012 , , 754 , 52 tobin , j. j. , hartmann , l. , chiang , h .- f . ,
wilner , d. j. , looney , l. w. , loinard , l. , calvet , n. , & dalessio , p. 2012
, , 492 , 83 tomida , k. , tomisaka , k. , matsumoto , t. , hori , y. , okuzumi , s. , machida , m. n. , & saigo , k. 2013 , , 763 , 6 tomisaka , k. 1998 , , 502 , l163 troland , t. h. , & crutcher , r. m. 2008 , , 680 , 457 williams , j. p. , & cieza , l. a. 2011 , , 49 , 67 zhao , b. , & li , z .- y .
2013 , , 763 , 7 zhao , b. , li , z .- y . , nakamura , f. , krasnopolsky , r. , & shang , h. 2011 , , 742 , 10 | stars form in dense cores of molecular clouds that are observed to be significantly magnetized . in the simplest case of a laminar ( non - turbulent ) core with the magnetic field aligned with the rotation axis
, both analytic considerations and numerical simulations have shown that the formation of a large , @xmath0-scale , rotationally supported protostellar disk is suppressed by magnetic braking in the ideal mhd limit for a realistic level of core magnetization .
this theoretical difficulty in forming protostellar disks is termed `` magnetic braking catastrophe . '' a possible resolution to this problem , proposed by @xcite and @xcite , is that misalignment between the magnetic field and rotation axis may weaken the magnetic braking enough to enable disk formation .
we evaluate this possibility quantitatively through numerical simulations .
we confirm the basic result of @xcite that the misalignment is indeed conducive to disk formation . in relatively weakly magnetized cores with dimensionless mass - to - flux ratio @xmath1 , it enabled the formation of rotationally supported disks that would otherwise be suppressed if the magnetic field and rotation axis are aligned . for more strongly magnetized cores ,
disk formation remains suppressed , however , even for the maximum tilt angle of @xmath2 .
if dense cores are as strongly magnetized as indicated by oh zeeman observations ( with a mean dimensionless mass - to - flux ratio @xmath3 ) , it would be difficult for the misalignment alone to enable disk formation in the majority of them .
we conclude that , while beneficial to disk formation , especially for the relatively weak field case , the misalignment does not completely solve the problem of catastrophic magnetic braking in general . |
the complexity of a large variety of systems , from infrastructures to the cell , is rooted in a network of interactions between their constituents @xcite .
quantifying the robustness of complex networks is one of the main challenges of network of networks with implications in fields as different as biology or policy making and risk assessment . in the last fifteen years
it has been shown @xcite that the structure of a single network is strictly related to its robustness .
but only recently @xcite , attention has been drawn toward a previously neglected aspects of complex systems , namely the interactions between several complex networks .
rarely single networks are isolated , while it is usually the case that several networks are interacting and interdependent on each other .
for example , in infrastructures , the banking systems are interdependent with the internet and the electric power - grid , public transport , such as subway , is dependent on the power - grid , which relies on its turn on the water supply system to cool the power - plants , etc . in the cell
the situation is much similar : all cellular networks , such as the metabolic networks , the protein - protein interaction networks , the signaling networks , and the gene transcription networks are all dependent on each other , and the cell is only alive if all these networks are functional
. these are examples of network of networks , i.e. , networks formed by several interdependent networks . a special class of network of networks
are multiplex networks @xcite , which are multilayer structures in which each layer is formed by the same set of nodes @xmath3 interconnected by different kinds of links for different layers . in other words , these are graphs with all nodes of one kind and with links of different colors .
multiplex networks are attracting great interest as they represent a large variety of systems such as social networks where people can be linked by different types of relationships ( friendship , family tie , collaboration , citations , etc . ) or , for example , in transportation networks , where different places can be linked by different types of transportation ( train , flight connections , flight connection of different airline companies , etc . ) .
multiplex network datasets @xcite are starting to be analysed , several modelling framework for these networks have been proposed @xcite and the characterization of a large variety of dynamical processes is getting a momentum @xcite . at this point
we emphasize the principal difference between the interdependent and so - called interconnected networks .
this difference is not about structural organization of connections between these networks but rather about the function of these interlinks .
interlinks connecting different interdependent networks ( interdependencies ) show the pairs of nodes that can not exist without each other . in the present paper we consider variations of this kind of complex networks . on the other hand , in the interconnected networks @xcite , the interlinks play the same role as links in single networks , enabling one to consider , e.g. , various percolation problems , disease spreading , etc .
a major progress in understanding the robustness of multilayer interdependent networks has been made in a series of seminal papers @xcite , where it has been proposed that a natural measure for evaluating the robustness of these structures to random failure is the size of a mutually connected giant component .
the mutually connected giant component is the component that remains after breakdowns propagate back and forth between different interdependent networks ( layers ) generating a cascade of failure events .
a node is in the mutually connected component of a multilayer network if all the nodes on which it depends are also in the mutually connected network and if at least one neighbor node in its own network ( layer ) belongs to the mutually connected component @xcite .
clearly , the giant mutually connected component naturally generalizes the giant connected component ( percolation cluster ) in a single network .
the robustness properties of multiplex networks have been right now well understood @xcite , including effects of degree correlations , the overlap of the links or antagonistic effects in this novel type of percolation problem @xcite . as the fraction of @xmath4 of removed nodes``igniters''increases ,
multiplex networks are affected by cascading failures , until they reach a point for @xmath5 where the network abruptly collapses , and the size of the mutually connected component shows a discontinuous transition @xcite . in this case if a small fraction @xmath6 of nodes in the multiplex are not interdependent , then the transition can change from discontinuous to continuous @xcite . although the issue of interest in the present article is the giant mutually connected component , other special giant components can be introduced for these networks . here
we mention only the so - called giant viable cluster @xcite between each two nodes of which , there is a complete set of interconnecting paths running through every layer .
it is easy to see that the viable cluster is a subgraph of the mutual component . .
interdependencies ( interlinks between nodes from different levels ) are shown by the black dashed lines .
intralinks between nodes within layers are shown as solid red lines . in each individual layer ( label @xmath7 ) , all nodes ( @xmath8 ) have the same number of interlinks ( superdegree @xmath9 ) .
interlinks connect only nodes with the same label @xmath10 in different layers , forming @xmath3 `` local supernetworks '' @xmath11 .
each of these local supernetworks is an uncorrelated random graph with a given superdegree sequence @xmath12 , @xmath13 , defined as the standard configuration model ( uniformly random interconnections for a given sequence of superdegrees ) . ]
several works have considered afterwards a more general ( than multiplex ) case of a network of networks in which the layers are formed by the same number of nodes , where each node has a replica node in each other network and might depend only on its replica nodes . despite the major interest on the topic @xcite , only recently the following key circumstance become clear @xcite . when the interdependencies between the nodes are such that if a network depends on another network , all its nodes depend on the replica nodes of the other network , it turns out that the mutually connected component coincides with that in the corresponding fully connected network of networks , which is actually a particular case of a multiplex network . here
we show , nevertheless , that the situation changes if the interdependence links are distributed between layers more randomly , i.e. , if we remove the above constraint that all nodes in each layer are dependent on their replicas in the same set of other layers .
we consider the situation in which a superdegree @xmath1 is assigned to each layer @xmath0 , so that each node of the network depends only on other @xmath1 replica nodes , but now these replica nodes are chosen randomly and independently from different layers , see fig .
we call this construction the configuration model of a network of networks .
the reason for this term is that for each set of nodes with given @xmath10 , consisting of nodes @xmath14 in all the layers @xmath13 , our definition provides the standard configuration model of a random network with a given sequence of superdegrees @xmath9 , @xmath13 , ( `` local supernetwork '' @xmath10 ) .
let us compare this construction to the model of ref . @xcite .
while in ref .
@xcite , all @xmath3 `` local supernetworks '' coincided , in the configuration model of network of networks defined in the present work , the `` local supernetworks '' differ from each other ; only their superdegrees @xmath9 coincide in the particular case of @xmath15 .
depending on the superdegree sequence , `` local supernetworks '' can contain a set of finite connected components and a giant one .
we consider specifically the case in which all the layers have the same internal degree distribution @xmath16 and where the superdegree distribution is @xmath17 .
we derive equations for the order parameter of this problem . solving them numerically and analytically we show for this network of networks that if @xmath15 , the layers with increasing superdegree @xmath18 have a percolation transition at different values of @xmath19 , where @xmath19 is the fraction of not damaged nodes in the network , see fig .
[ fig : fig1a ] . in other words , as @xmath19 increases , in layers with higher and higher @xmath18 , giant clusters of the mutual component emerge progressively , or , one can also say , the mutual component expands to layers with higher @xmath18 , see fig .
all these transition are abrupt but also they are characterized by a singularity of the order parameter . finally we show that for @xmath20 , i.e. when interlinks between layers are removed with probability @xmath6 , each of these transitions involving the layers with @xmath21 can become continuous for @xmath22 . in the case of @xmath20
, nodes in the same layer have different number of interlinks to other layers , which essentially generalizes the problem .
a network of networks is formed by @xmath23 networks ( layers ) , @xmath24 , each formed by @xmath3 nodes , @xmath25 , where @xmath3 is infinite .
in fact , in this work we also set @xmath26 , which enables us to use an analytical technique developed for the standard configuration model .
these calculations exploit the locally tree - like structure of infinite uncorrelated networks .
a more realistic case of a finite @xmath23 is a challenging problem .
every node @xmath14 is connected with a number of nodes @xmath27 in the same layer and with a number of its `` replica nodes '' @xmath28 in other layers . for two layers ,
this framework was proposed in ref .
it was generalized to an arbitrary number of layers in refs .
we consider the situation in which each layer @xmath0 is interdependent on @xmath1 other networks , so that each node @xmath10 in layer @xmath0 has exactly @xmath9 interlinks , which connect node @xmath10 only to its replica nodes in @xmath9 of other layers .
we call @xmath1 the superdegree of the nodes of layer @xmath0 .
we stress that the superdegree is associated with the nodes of a layer , and each node @xmath14 in a layer has the same superdegree @xmath9 .
interlinks connecting replica nodes within different sets , say , interlink @xmath29 and interlink @xmath30 are assumed to be independent ( uncorrelated ) .
for example , if a node @xmath14 of layer @xmath0 is interdependent on node @xmath28 of layer @xmath31 , then although another node @xmath27 of layer @xmath0 may in principle occur interdependent on node @xmath32 , in general , it depends on @xmath1 replica nodes @xmath33 sitting in any @xmath1 layers . following refs .
@xcite , we define the network of networks with a super - adjacency matrix of elements @xmath34 if there is a link between node @xmath14 and node @xmath32 and zero otherwise . in these networks
we have always @xmath35 if both @xmath36 and @xmath37 . for each node @xmath10 and all its replicas ,
we introduce a `` local supernetwork '' , whose nodes are the layers and the links are interdependencies within this set of replicas . this network was discussed in refs .
this local supernetwork is determined by the adjacency matrix @xmath38 parametrized by the node @xmath10 .
this network may consist of a number of connected components .
connected components from different local supernetworks are connected with each other through links within individual layers . in this work
we explore this complicated system of interconnected components , which is necessary to describe the emergence of the giant mutually connected component and its expansion ( percolation ) over different layers .
we define the mutually connected component as the following .
each node @xmath14 is in the mutually connected component if it has at least one neighbor @xmath27 which belongs to the mutually connected component and if all the linked nodes @xmath28 in the interdependent networks are also in the mutually connected component . in these problems ,
the giant ( i.e. , containing a finite fraction of nodes ) mutually connected component is single
. it immediately follows from this definition that , remarkably , within each connected component of any local supernetwork , all its replica nodes either together belong to the mutually connected component or not . in our considerations
, we will essentially exploit this strong consequence .
given a network of networks it is easy to construct a message passing algorithm @xcite determining if node @xmath14 is in the mutually connected component .
let us denote by @xmath39 the message within a layer , from node @xmath14 to node @xmath27 and indicating ( @xmath40 ) if node @xmath14 is in the mutually connected component when we remove the link @xmath41 in network @xmath0 .
furthermore , let us denote by @xmath42 the message between the `` replicas '' @xmath14 and @xmath28 of node @xmath10 in layers @xmath0 and @xmath31 .
the message @xmath43 indicates if the node @xmath14 is in the mutually connected component when we remove the link between node @xmath14 and node @xmath28 .
in addition to that we assume that the node @xmath14 can be damaged and permanently removed from the network .
this removal will launch an avalanche of failures ( removals of nodes ) spreading over the layers .
note that , of course , the node removal retains its interdependence links .
we indicate with @xmath44 a node that is damaged , otherwise we have @xmath45 .
the message passing equations for these messages are given by _
ij&=&s_i__i()s_ii + & & , + s_ii&=&s_i__i()s_ii + & & , [ mp1 ] where @xmath46 indicates the set of nodes @xmath47 which are neighbors of node @xmath10 in network @xmath0 , and @xmath48 indicates the layers @xmath31 such that the nodes @xmath28 are interdependent on the node @xmath14 . finally @xmath49 indicates if a node @xmath14 is in the mutually interdependent network ( @xmath50 ) and this indicator function can be expressed in terms of the messages as s_i&=&s_i__i()s_ii + & & .
[ s ] the solution of the message passing equations is given by the following closed expression , _
ij&= & _ ( i,)\{s_i } + & & s_i , [ mesf ] where @xmath51 is the connected cluster of the `` local supernetwork '' of node @xmath10 , i.e. , the network between layers determined by the adjacency matrix @xmath38 parametrized by the node @xmath10 .
finally @xmath49 is given by s_i&=&s_i_(i , ) .
[ s2 ] for detailed derivation and explanation of this solution see our work @xcite and appendix .
we assume here that each network ( layer ) @xmath0 is generated from a configuration model with the same degree distribution @xmath52 , and that each node @xmath14 is connected to @xmath1 other `` replica '' nodes @xmath28 chosen uniformly randomly .
moreover we assume that the degree sequence in each layer is @xmath53 and that the degrees of the replicas of node @xmath10 are uncorrelated .
this implies that we are considering a network of networks ensemble , such that every network of networks with a super - adjacency matrix @xmath54 has a probability @xmath55 given by p(*a*)&=&_=1^m_i=1^n\{(k^_i,_j=1^na_i , j)(q_,_=1^ma_i , i ) .
+ & & . } , [ pa ] where @xmath56 indicates the kronecker delta and @xmath57 is a normalization constant .
moreover we assume that nodes @xmath14 are removed with probability @xmath4 , i.e. , we consider the following expression for the probability @xmath58 of the variables @xmath59 p(\{s_i})=_=1^m_i=1^n p^s_i(1-p)^1-s_i .
[ ps ] in order to quantify the expected size of the mutually connected component in this ensemble , we can average the messages over this ensemble of the network of networks .
the message passage equations for this problem are given by eqs .
( [ mesf ] ) .
therefore the equations for the average message within a layer are given in terms of the parameter @xmath60 and the generating functions @xmath61 given by g_0^k(z)=_k p(k ) z^k , & g_1^k(z)=_k z^k-1 , + g_0^q(z)=_q p(q ) z^q , & g_1^q(z)=_q z^q-1 .
in particular , if we indicate by @xmath62 the average messages within a layer @xmath0 of degree @xmath21 we obtain _ q&=&p_sp(s|q)^s-1 + & & , [ sq ] where @xmath63 indicates the probability that a node @xmath10 in layer @xmath0 with @xmath21 is in a connected component @xmath51 of the local supernetwork of cardinality ( number of nodes ) @xmath64 . similarly , the probability that a node @xmath10 in a layer @xmath0 with superdegree @xmath21 is in the mutually connected component @xmath65 is given by s_q&=&p_sp(s|q)^s-1 + & & .
[ sq ] equations ( [ sq ] ) and ( [ sq ] ) are valid for any network of networks ensemble described by eqs .
( [ pa])([ps ] ) . in the following we study in particular the limiting case
in which the number of layers @xmath26 , and the local supernetwork is sparse . in order to find a solution for eqs .
( [ sq ] ) , we define @xmath66 as b= p _ q [ 1-g_0(1-_q ) ] . inserting this expression in eq .
( [ sq ] ) we get _ q&=&p _ sp(s|q)b^s-1 [ 1-g_1(1-_q ) ] .
[ sq2 ] from the definition of @xmath66 we see that @xmath67 and that @xmath68 only if both @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
this implies that in all the cases in which the layers are not all formed by a single giant component or in which @xmath71 , we have @xmath72 .
moreover if @xmath72 , we can neglect in eq .
( [ sq ] ) the contribution coming from the giant component of the local supernetworks in the large @xmath23 limit .
therefore in eq .
( [ sq2 ] ) we can replace @xmath63 with the probability @xmath73 that a node of degree @xmath18 belongs to a finite component of size @xmath74 in the supernetwork . note that in our model , the statistics of all local supernetworks coincide .
let us consider the quantity @xmath75p_f(s|q)$ ] .
since @xmath76 only depends on the distribution of finite components , we have p(s)=_q_s_1,s_2,
s_q_=1^qp(s_)(_=1^qs_,s-1 ) . therefore @xmath76 has the generating function @xmath77 that satisfies the equation h(z)=z g^q_1(h(z ) ) . moreover , since p_f(s|q)=_s_1,s_2,
s_q_=1^qp(s_)(_=1^qs_,s-1 ) , we find _ sp_f(s|q)b^s-1=[h(b)]^q
. therefore eqs .
( [ sq ] ) become _ q&=&p [ h(b)]^q [ 1-g_1^k(1-_q ) ] , + h(z)&=&zg^q_1(h(z ) ) , + b&= & p_q [ 1-g_0^k(1-_q ) ] .
[ e150 ] putting @xmath78 , we can express eqs .
( [ sq ] ) and eqs .
( [ sq ] ) in the following simplified way , _
q&=&p()^q[1-g_1^k(1-_q ) ] , + s_q&=&p()^q[1-g_0^k(1-_q ) ] , + & = & + & & _ q()^q-1 . [ e160 ] therefore , given a configuration model of a network of networks , the parameter @xmath79 determines both @xmath62 and @xmath80 for any value of the superdegree @xmath18 .
for this reason we can call @xmath79 the order parameter for the entire network of networks .
let us consider for simplicity the case in which each layer is formed by a poisson network with average degree @xmath81 .
in this situation the previous equations become _ q & = & s_q= p ( ) ^q(1-e^-c_q ) , + & & = _ q()^q-1 . [ ps ] in particular , if the local supernetwork is regular , i.e. , @xmath82 we have @xmath83 satisfying , = p^q/2(1-e^-c ) .
this special random regular network of interdependent poisson networks was recently considered in ref .
@xcite . in the general case of an arbitrary @xmath17 distribution
the problem defined in eqs .
( [ ps ] ) continues to have a single order parameter given by @xmath79 .
in fact the first equation in eqs .
( [ ps ] ) has a solution expressed in terms of the principal value of the lambert function @xmath84 , which is given by _
q=. inserting this solution back into the equation for @xmath79 in eqs .
( [ ps ] ) we find = g_1^q ( ) .
[ op ] this equation can be written as @xmath85 . by imposing both @xmath85 and @xmath86
we can find the set of critical points @xmath5 in which discontinuities ( jumps ) of the function @xmath87 take place .
the equation @xmath86 reads as = _
q(1-e^-c_q)_q ^q-2+cp g_1^q()_q < q_max e^-c_q , [ e220 ] with @xmath88 $ ] .
here @xmath89 $ ] stands for the integer part .
analysing eq .
( [ op ] ) for the order parameter we can show that , in addition to a jump , the order parameter @xmath79 has a singularity at each @xmath90 where both @xmath91 and @xmath92 . for every topology of the network of network , we have -_c(p - p_c)^1/2 , similarly to multiplex networks @xcite . in the special situation
in which the minimal superdegree @xmath93 of the local supernetworks is greater or equal to 2 , i.e. , @xmath94 , each local supernetwork only has a giant connected component and does not have finite components .
therefore in this case we found that in the limit @xmath26 the only viable solution for the order parameter is @xmath95 for any @xmath19 and @xmath96 and any superdegree distribution @xmath17 . in another special case in which @xmath97 there are layers that are not interacting ( @xmath98 ) with other layers .
these layers can be treated separately without losing the generality of the treatment .
therefore the only non - trivial case is the case of @xmath99 , which we explore in detail .
( fraction of nodes in a layer of superdegree @xmath18 , belonging to the mutual component ) vs. @xmath19 for different values @xmath100 in the configuration model of the network of networks having a poisson @xmath16 distribution with average @xmath101 and a scale - free @xmath17 distribution with @xmath102 , minimal superdegree @xmath99 and maximal superdegree @xmath103 . for each value of @xmath100 , @xmath62 emerges discontinuously , with a jump , which becomes smaller and smaller with increasing @xmath18 .
the emergence of @xmath104 is accompanied by a discontinuity of @xmath105 .
the emergence of @xmath106 is accompanied by discontinuities of @xmath105 and @xmath107 .
these curves are obtained by solving numerically eq .
( [ op ] ) and substituting the result into eq .
( [ e160 ] ) . ]
we solve numerically eq .
( [ op ] ) for the order parameter using various superdegree distributions @xmath17 and a poisson distribution @xmath16 for connections within layers .
this gives @xmath87 , from which we find the observable fraction @xmath108 of the vertices in layers characterising by superdegree @xmath18 that belong to the mutual component .
since the distribution @xmath16 is poissonian , @xmath109 according to eq .
( [ e160 ] ) . in fig .
[ fig : fig1a ] we show the resulting order parameter @xmath79 vs. @xmath19 for a configuration model with a poisson @xmath16 distribution with @xmath110 and a scale - free distribution @xmath111 for @xmath112 $ ] with @xmath102 and @xmath113 , minimal superdegree @xmath99 and maximal superdegree @xmath103 .
the supernetwork with @xmath102 is above the ordinary percolation phase transition in the supernetwork ( i.e. , it has a giant component ) while the supernetwork with @xmath113 is below the ordinary percolation phase transition ( i.e. , it consists only of finite components ) .
notice that if the supernetwork has no giant component , then @xmath114 , otherwise , @xmath115 .
the order parameter displays a series of discontinuous jumps corresponding to the transitions in which layers with increasing values of @xmath18 start to percolate . in other words , in layers with higher and higher superdegree @xmath18 ,
giant clusters of the mutually connected component emerge progressively . in order to see this
, we observe that @xmath116 for all values of @xmath79 such that @xmath117 ( note that for power - law superdegree distributions the minimal degree is always @xmath118 ) . in fig .
[ fig : fig1a ] we plot the maximal superdegree of the percolating layers as @xmath119 $ ] , where in this expression @xmath120 $ ] indicates the integer part . from fig .
[ fig : fig1a ] it is clear that the discontinuities in the curve @xmath121 correspond to the percolation transitions of layers of increasing superdegree @xmath122 . for @xmath102 the first , second and third transitions occur at @xmath123 , @xmath124 , and @xmath125 .
we found these values by solving numerically eqs .
( [ op ] ) and ( [ e220 ] ) .
one can see that for @xmath113 the activations of layers of increasing superdegree @xmath122 become much more rapid .
for these parameters the first , transitions occur at @xmath126 . for the case of @xmath102 , which we discussed above
, we plot the observables @xmath127 ( fraction of nodes in a layer of superdegree @xmath18 , belonging to the mutual component ) vs. @xmath19 for different values of @xmath18 , see fig .
this figure demonstrates how giant clusters of the mutually connected component emerge progressively in layers with higher and higher @xmath18 as we increase the control parameter @xmath19 .
note that , as is natural , each discontinuous emergence of a fraction of the mutual component nodes in layers of superdegree @xmath18 is accompanied by discontinuities of the dependencies @xmath128 for all smaller superdegrees @xmath129 . as a second example of the configuration model
, we have taken a network of networks ensemble with a poisson @xmath16 distribution characterized by @xmath81 and a poisson distribution @xmath130 , where we take @xmath131 $ ] , excluding the layers with @xmath98 that are not interacting , and using the superdegree cutoff @xmath103 for performing the numerical calculations .
solving numerically eq .
( [ op ] ) we obtained the following results . in fig .
[ fig : fig2a ] we have chosen @xmath132 and @xmath133 as examples of the supernetwork below ( @xmath134 ) and above ( @xmath135 ) the ordinary percolation phase transition in the poisson supernetwork . in order to see at which value of @xmath19 the layers with superdegree @xmath122 become percolating , in fig . [
fig : fig2a ] we also plot the maximal superdegree of the percolating layers @xmath136 $ ] vs. @xmath19 .
the transition points and the corresponding values of the order parameter are obtained by solving numerically eqs .
( [ op ] ) and ( [ e220 ] ) .
for @xmath134 the first transitions are @xmath137 , @xmath138 , and @xmath139 .
for @xmath135 the first transitions are @xmath140 , @xmath141 , and @xmath142 . for a range of the network of networks parameters ,
the giant mutual component is absent at any value of @xmath19 , including @xmath69 . in fig .
[ fig : fig3a ] we plot the phase diagram containing a phase in which @xmath95 ( white region ) and a phase in which @xmath143 ( shaded region ) for @xmath69 .
this phase diagram was obtained by numerical analysis of the equation for the order parameter . in particular , the phase diagram @xmath144 is plotted for a scale - free supernetwork with power - law exponent @xmath145 and superdegrees @xmath112 $ ] with @xmath99 and @xmath103 and the phase diagram @xmath146 is plotted for a poisson supernetwork with average superdegree @xmath147 and the minimal and maximal superdegrees given respectively by @xmath148 . as is natural , figs .
[ fig : fig1a ] and [ fig : fig2a ] correspond to points within the shaded areas in fig .
[ fig : fig3a ] .
in this section we consider an interesting variation of the percolation problem in the configuration model of the network of networks .
in particular we assume that the superdegree adjacency matrix @xmath54 has probability @xmath55 given by eq .
( [ pa ] ) , while the probability of @xmath58 is given by eq .
( [ ps ] ) .
in addition to that we assume that an interlink between replicas @xmath14 and @xmath28 is damaged and permanently removed with probability @xmath6 .
in this case the nodes in a layer @xmath0 with superdegree @xmath21 can be interdependent on @xmath149 $ ] other randomly chosen layers . in this case
the message passing equations are given by _
( i,)\{s_i } + & & s_i , where @xmath51 is the connected cluster of the local supernetwork of node @xmath10 when we consider only interdependencies , i.e. , only the interlinks that are not damaged .
we can therefore indicate by @xmath62 the average messages within a layer @xmath0 of degree @xmath21 , obtaining _ q&=&p_s_n=0^qr^n(1-r)^q - np(s|n)b^s-1 + & & .
[ sqpr ] here , @xmath150 indicates the probability that a node @xmath10 in layer @xmath0 with @xmath21 and @xmath151 interdependent layers is in a connected component @xmath51 of the local supernetwork of interdependent layers of cardinality @xmath64 .
moreover , @xmath66 is defined as b= p_q [ 1-g_0^k(1-_q ) ] .
[ b2 ] similarly , the probability that a node @xmath10 in a layer @xmath0 with superdegree @xmath21 is in the mutually connected component @xmath152 is given by s_q&=&p_s_n=0^qr^n(1-r)^q - n p(s|n)b^s-1 + & & .
[ sqpr ] if the layers are not all formed by a single giant component or if @xmath71 we have @xmath72 , and therefore we can neglect in eqs .
( [ sqpr])([sqpr ] ) the contribution coming from the giant component of the local supernetworks in the large @xmath23 limit .
therefore in eq .
( [ sqpr ] ) we can replace @xmath63 with the probability @xmath73 that a node of degree @xmath18 belongs to a finite component of size @xmath74 in the supernetwork . let us consider the quantity @xmath153 \sum_{n=0}^q\binom{q}{n}r^q ( 1-r)^{q - n}p_f(s|n)$ ] . since @xmath76 only depends on the distribution of finite components we have p(s)&=&_q_n=0^qr^q ( 1-r)^q - n + & & _ s_1,s_2, s_n_=1^np(s_)(_=1^qs_,s-1 ) .
therefore @xmath76 has a generating function @xmath77 that satisfies the equation h(z)=z g^q_1(rh(z)+1-r ) .
[ hr ] moreover , since p_f(s|n)=_s_1,s_2,
s_n_=1^np(s_)(_=1^ns_,s-1 ) . we find & & _ s_n=0^qr^q ( 1-r)^1-np_f(s|n)b^s-1 + & & = [ rh(b)+1-r]^q
. therefore eqs .
( [ sqpr ] ) , ( [ hr ] ) , and ( [ b2 ] ) have the form _
q&=&p [ rh(b)+(1-r)]^q [ 1-g_1^k(1-_q ) ] , + h(z)&=&zg^q_1(rh(z)+1-r ) , + b&= & p_q [ 1-g_0^k(1-_q ) ] .
putting @xmath78 we find that eqs .
( [ sq ] ) and eqs .
( [ sq ] ) become _
q&=&p(r+1-r)^q[1-g_1^k(1-_q ) ] , + s_q&=&p(r+1-r)^q[1-g_0^k(1-_q ) ] , + & = & + & & _ q(r+1-r)^q-1 .
let us consider for simplicity the case in which each layer is formed by a poisson network with average degree @xmath81 .
then the previous equations become _ q & = & s_q = p(r+1-r)^q(1-e^-c_q ) , + & = & + & & _ q(r+1-r)^q-1 . [ psp ] in the case in which the local supernetwork is regular , i.e. @xmath82 , we have @xmath154\sigma_m=\sigma$ ] satisfying the following equation = p^q(1-e^-c ) . for an arbitrary distribution @xmath17 , the problem defined in eqs .
( [ ps ] ) still has a single order parameter @xmath79 . as in section [ s3 ] , the first equation in eqs .
( [ ps ] ) has solution expressed in terms of the principal value of the lambert function @xmath84 , namely , _ q = .
inserting this solution back in the equation for @xmath79 in eqs .
( [ ps ] ) we find = g_1^q(r+1-r ) .
[ op2 ] similarly to section [ s3 ] , we write this equation as @xmath155 . by imposing @xmath155 and @xmath156 we can find the set of critical points @xmath5 at which the function @xmath87 turns out to be discontinuous .
the equation @xmath156 reads as = _ q(1-e^-c_q)_q [ r1-r]^q-2 + cp g_1^q(r1-r ) _ q < q_max e^-c_q . where @xmath157 $ ] .
note that in contrast to the case of @xmath15 , for @xmath158 all values of the minimal superdegree @xmath159 provide non - trivial network of networks .
indeed , for @xmath160 , even if @xmath161 , local supernetworks have finite connected components .
in addition to the abrupt phase transitions , this model displays also a set of continuous phase transition for different @xmath18 , where the order parameter @xmath62 acquires a non - zero value .
these transitions occur at p = p_c=. these transitions are only stable for @xmath2 below some special value @xmath162 , and at @xmath163 they become discontinuous .
the value @xmath162 can be obtained by solving simultaneously the following set of equations & = & p , + f_2(,p , r)&=&0 , + & = & 0 .
in this paper we have characterized the robustness properties of the configuration model of network of networks by evaluating the size of the mutually connected component when a fraction @xmath4 of nodes have been damaged and removed .
the configuration model of network of networks is an ensemble of multilayer networks in which each layer is formed by a network of @xmath3 nodes , and where each node might depend only on its `` replica nodes '' on the other layers .
we assign to each layer @xmath0 a superdegree @xmath1 indicating the number of interdependent nodes of each individual node @xmath14 of the layer @xmath0 and take these @xmath1 `` replica nodes '' in @xmath1 uniformly randomly chosen layers , independently for each node @xmath14 .
we have shown that percolation in this ensemble of networks of networks demonstrate surprising features . specifically , for low values of @xmath19 , only the layers with low enough value of the superdegree are percolating , and as we raise the value of @xmath19 several discontinuous transition can occur in which layers of increasing value of superdegree @xmath18 begin percolate . here
we observe a sharp contrast to ordinary percolation in which nodes of high degree belong to the giant connected component ( percolation cluster ) with higher probability .
this principal difference is explained by the definition of the mutual component according to which a node is in a mutual component only if all the nodes interdependent with this node belong to the mutual component .
this condition makes more difficult the entrance into the mutual component for layers with a high superdegree .
the non - trivial point here is that a layer of each given degree enters the mutual component not smoothly but through a discontinuous transition .
the networks of networks which we considered in this paper differ from those we studied in our previous work @xcite in one key aspect . in the present work ,
interdependence links of different nodes of a layer are not lead to the same other layers as in ref .
@xcite , but they are distributed over the other layers essentially more randomly , independently for different nodes of a layer . we have found that this additional randomness dramatically change results and leads to new effects . we obtained our results assuming that the number @xmath23 of layers in the network is infinite .
a more realistic case of finite @xmath23 is a challenging problem .
we would also like to stress that multiple discontinuous phase transitions in models for complex networks is a rear but not unique phenomenon .
for example , multiple discontinuous transitions were recently reported in another network model @xcite .
one should note that interlinking of only `` replica nodes '' is actually a great , very convenient simplification which has enabled us to solve the problem analytically .
moreover , we have first assumed that all nodes in the same layer have equal superdegree ( number of interdependencies ) , which is a strong constraint . on the next step ,
we however have removed this restriction by introducing the probability @xmath6 that an interdependence link is removed .
we found that when a fraction @xmath164 of interdependent links are removed , each of these specific transitions can change from discontinuous to continuous . in summary ,
we have found novel percolation phenomena in a more general model of a network of networks than the network models which were considered previously .
the multiple transitions , accompanying the expansion of mutual component over the layers of such a network of networks , are in dramatic contrast to ordinary percolation and to more simple interdependent and multiplex networks , e.g. , for a pair of interdependent networks . we suggest that our findings should be valid even for more general networks of networks .
_ note added in proof _ we recently considered a network of networks in which interlinks between each two layers connect randomly selected nodes and not only `` replica nodes''.remarkably , it turned out that the results for this model are exactly the same as in the present article .
this work was partially supported by the fct project ptdc / mat/114515/2009 and the fet proactive ip project multiplex number 317532 .
in ref . @xcite the percolation transition in a network of network in which all the local adjacency matrices are the same , i.e. , @xmath165 , was considered , implying that the local supernetwork is the same for every node @xmath10 . in this
setting , the percolation properties are determined by the message passing eqs .
( [ mp1 ] ) with @xmath166 indicating the set of layers @xmath31 which are neighbors of layer @xmath0 in any local supernetwork . for this network of networks , it was shown in ref .
@xcite that eqs .
( [ mp1 ] ) can be written as + s_ii & = & _ ( ) \{s_i } , + _ ij&= & _ ( ) \{s_i } + & & s_i , [ msfa ] where @xmath167 indicates the connected component of the supernetwork to which layer @xmath0 belongs .
moreover in ref . @xcite it has been shown that @xmath49 is given by s_i&=&s_i _
( ) . [ s2a ]
now we observe that all the steps performed in ref .
@xcite to obtain eqs .
( [ msfa ] ) and ( [ s2a ] ) are in fact only operations acting in the local supernetwork of node @xmath10 .
it follows immediately that for the network of networks coming from the configuration models , the same equations should be valid , where we replace @xmath167 with the connected component of the local supernetwork @xmath51 of node @xmath10 passing through layer @xmath0 .
therefore for the configuration model of a network of networks the solution to the message passing eqs .
( [ mp1 ] ) and ( [ s ] ) is given by eqs .
( [ mesf ] ) and eqs .
( [ s2 ] ) . | recently much attention has been paid to the study of the robustness of interdependent and multiplex networks and , in particular , networks of networks .
the robustness of interdependent networks can be evaluated by the size of a mutually connected component when a fraction of nodes have been removed from these networks . here
we characterize the emergence of the mutually connected component in a network of networks in which every node of a network ( layer ) @xmath0 is connected with @xmath1 its randomly chosen replicas in some other networks and is interdependent of these nodes with probability @xmath2 .
we find that when the superdegrees @xmath1 of different layers in the network of networks are distributed heterogeneously , multiple percolation phase transition can occur .
we show that , depending on the value of @xmath2 , these transition are continuous or discontinuous . |
at the 14th of september 2015 , the advanced ligo detectors registered for the first time a gravitational wave ( * ? ? ?
* ( abbott 2016 ) ) .
according to the analysis of the waveform , this wave testified the event of two merging black holes ( bhs ) of @xmath2 and @xmath3 at a distance of about 400mpc .
the immediate conclusion , and even the prediction prior to the measurement , was that such heavy bhs can only form by stellar evolution at low metallicity , where the mass - loss due to stellar winds is low and hence the stellar remnants can be more massive ( * ? ? ? * ( belczynski 2016 ) ) .
still heavily debated is whether such bhs form separately in dense clusters and then combine into a close pair by dynamical interactions , or whether they evolve as close binaries all the time .
since both scenarios have their problems , a primordial origin has also been suggested ( see postnov , these proceedings ) .
massive stars may end their life in a gravitational collapse while being in the red - supergiant ( rgs ) phase or as wolf - rayet ( wr ) stars .
the sample of putatively single and optically un - obscured galactic wr stars has been comprehensively analyzed with increasing sophistication ( cf.fig.[fig:hrd-galwr ] ) .
it became clear that the wn stars ( i.e. the wr stars of the nitrogen sequence ) actually form two distinct groups .
the very luminous wns with @xmath4 are slightly cooler than the zero - age main sequence and typically still contain hydrogen in their atmosphere ( often termed wnl for late ) .
in contrast , the less luminous wne stars are hotter ( `` early '' wn subtypes ) and typically hydrogen free .
the wr stars of the carbon sequence ( wc ) are composed of helium - burning products and share their location in the hertzsprung - russell diagram ( hrd ) with the wne stars . from this empirical hrd
one can deduce the evolutionary scenario ( * ? ? ? * ( sander 2012 ) ) .
the wnl stars evolve directly from o stars of very high initial mass ( @xmath5 ) . in the mass range
@xmath6 the o stars first become rsgs and then wne stars and finally wcs . stars with initially less then @xmath7 become rsgs and explode there as type ii supernova before having lost their hydrogen envelope .
evolutionary tracks still partly fail to reproduce this empirical hrd quantitatively , despite of all efforts , e.g. with including rotationally induced mixing .
the wne and wc stars are observed to be much cooler than predicted ; this is probably due to the effect of `` envelope inflation '' ( * ? ? ?
* ( grfener 2012 ) ) .
moreover , the mass ( and luminosity ) range of wne and wc stars is not covered by the post - rsg tracks .
evolutionary calculations depend sensitively on the mass - loss rates @xmath8 that are adopted as input parameters .
empirical @xmath8 suffer from uncertainties caused by wind inhomogeneities : when clumping on small scales ( `` microclumping '' ) is taken into account , lower values for @xmath8 are derived from observed emission - line spectra .
large - scale inhomogeneities ( `` macroclumping '' ) , on the other hand , can lead to underestimating mass - loss rates ( * ? ? ?
* ( oskinova 2007 ) ) . due to the open questions of mixing and the true @xmath8 , it is still uncertain which is the highest bh mass that can be produced from single - star evolution at galactic metallicity .
for instance , the luminosities of the two wo stars included in fig.[fig : hrd - galwr ] would correspond to masses as high as @xmath9 if they were chemically homogeneous , while the displayed evolutionary track for initially @xmath10 ends with only @xmath11 at core collapse .
the population of massive stars depends critically on their metallicity @xmath12 .
this becomes obvious , e.g. , from the wr stars in the small magellanic cloud ( smc ) where @xmath12 is only about 1/7 of the solar value .
in contrast to the galaxy , _ all _ putatively single wn stars in the smc show a significant fraction of hydrogen in their atmosphere and wind , like the galactic wnl stars . however , the wn stars in the smc are all hot and compact , located in the hrd ( fig.[fig : hrd - smc - wn ] ) between the zero age main sequence for helium stars ( he - zams ) and the h - zams ( or at least , in two cases , close the latter ) .
such parameters can not be explained with standard evolutionary tracks , unless very strong internal mixing is assumed which makes the stars nearly chemically homogeneous .
corresponding tracks are included in fig.[fig : hrd - smc - wn ] .
quantitatively , they still do not reproduce the observed hydrogen mass fractions .
stellar winds from hot massive stars are driven by radiation pressure intercepted by spectral lines .
the literally millions of lines from iron and iron - group elements , located in the extreme uv where the stellar flux is highest , play a dominant role .
hence a metallicity dependence is theoretically expected . for o stars ,
such @xmath12 dependence is empirically established ( * ? ? ?
* ( e.g. mokiem 2007 ) ) . for wn stars
, @xcite found a surprisingly steep dependence , probably due to the multiple - scattering effect ( see also hainich , these proceedings ) .
colors code in both cases for the hydrogen mass fraction ( see inlet ) . from @xcite , width=326 ]
hence , the lower mass - loss for massive o stars in the smc , compared to the galaxy , might reduce the angular - momentum loss and thus maintain the rapid rotation which causes the mixing and quasi - homogeneous evolution to the wr regime .
alternatively , one might speculate that the low @xmath8 in the smc is insufficient to remove the hydrogen envelope , and thus prevents the formation of single wr stars .
this would imply that the observed single wns have all formed through the binary channel , possibly as merger products .
but what happens with smc stars of slightly lower mass ? we have analyzed about 300 ob stars in the region of the supergiant shell sgs1 ( ramachandran in prep . ) .
their hrd positions are included in fig.[fig : hrd - smc - massivestars ] , together with `` normal '' tracks with less rotational mixing .
as the comparison shows , the o and b - type stars with initial masses below @xmath13 are consistent with `` normal '' evolution to the rsg stage .
only the more massive of stars might also be consistent with quasi - homogenous evolution , as are the wn stars discussed above .
, as are the quasi - homogeneous evolutionary tracks .
the `` normal '' tracks are also from @xcite but with slower initial rotation ( @xmath14km / s ) .
, width=326 ]
in their majority , massive stars are born in binary systems .
@xcite suggested a scenario of `` massive overcontact binary ( mob ) evolution '' that could lead to a tight pair of massive black holes as observed in the gw events .
two massive stars which are born as tight binary would evolve fully mixed due to their tidally induced fast spin and interaction .
they would swap mass several times , making their masses about equal , but under lucky circumstances they might avoid early merging .
figure[fig : hrd - pablo ] shows two such evolutionary tracks from marchant ( priv . comm . ) . in both examples ,
the tracks end at core collapse with a pair of @xmath15 objects .
we have calculated synthetic spectra for representative points along the evolutionary tracks ( marked by asterisks in fig.[fig : hrd - pablo ] ) and found that such spectra would look unspectacular if observed ; in the advanced stages , the stars would appear as wn - type ( with hydrogen , like those in the smc discussed above ) or , towards the end of the track for @xmath16 , as a hot wc type , always with otherwise weak metal lines due to the low abundances .
the only characteristic differences compared to single stars would be the doubled luminosity and , if the orbital inclination is favorite , the radial - velocity variation in the double - lined spectrum with short period . and
metallicity of 1/20 solar , and the another one for @xmath17 and metallicity of 1/10 solar .
the asterisks mark positions for which we calculated representative synthetic spectra ( hainich in prep . ) .
, width=326 ] | the recent discovery of a gravitational wave from the merging of two black holes of about 30 solar masses each challenges our incomplete understanding of massive stars and their evolution .
critical ingredients comprise mass - loss , rotation , magnetic fields , internal mixing , and mass transfer in close binary systems .
the imperfect knowledge of these factors implies large uncertainties for models of stellar populations and their feedback . in this contribution
we summarize our empirical studies of wolf - rayet populations at different metallicities by means of modern non - lte stellar atmosphere models , and confront these results with the predictions of stellar evolution models . at the metallicity of our galaxy , stellar winds are probably too strong to leave remnant masses as high as @xmath030m@xmath1 , but given the still poor agreement between evolutionary tracks and observation even this conclusion is debatable . at the low metallicity of the small magellanic cloud , all wn stars which are ( at least now ) single are consistent with evolving quasi - homogeneously .
o and b - type stars , in contrast , seem to comply with standard evolutionary models without strong internal mixing .
close binaries which avoided early merging could evolve quasi - homogeneously and lead to close compact remnants of relatively high masses that merge within a hubble time . |
the hall sensor array resides in the center of a printed circuit board ( pcb ) .
there is a hole in the pcb and the hall sensor is glued directly on a copper plate cold finger , which extends from the dr mixing chamber .
gold wire bonding connects the sensors and the leads on the pcb .
all wires are thermally connected to the mc .
typical sample dimensions are 3 @xmath18 2 @xmath71 1 mm@xmath31 .
the samples have clear facets and are oriented with the easy axis parallel to the applied field .
they are covered by a thin layer of super glue and placed directly on the surface of the hall sensor with apizon - n grease , which is used to protect the sample from disintegration and hold it in place .
the array backbone has a resistance of @xmath72 k@xmath73 at our working temperatures , and is excited with a 10@xmath74a dc current .
no effect of the sensors excitation on the dr - mixing chamber temperature was detected .
the hall voltage from each sensor is filtered with a 30 hz low - pass filter for hysteresis measurements and a 200 hz high - pass filter for the avalanche measurements .
the voltage is amplified @xmath75 times by a differential amplifier .
it is digitized with an ni usb 6251 a / d card at a rate of @xmath76 hz and @xmath77 khz for the hysteresis and avalanche measurements respectively .
the thermal diffusivity measurements are performed using two thermometers mounted on opposite sides of the sample and a heater on the hot side of the sample , whose configuration is shown in fig.[fig7 ] .
the hot side is attached to the cold finger and is hot only after the heat pulse .
the thermometers are ruo@xmath82 films .
the heater is a 2.2k@xmath73 resistor .
the hot side thermometer is between the heater and the sample .
the cold side thermometer is between the sample and a teflon plate .
it has a weak thermal link to the cold plate via the measurement wires only .
a heat pulse is generated by applying @xmath81 v to the 2.2k@xmath73 resistor using a function generator , which also gives the trigger for the ruo@xmath82 voltage measurement .
the system has been tested by repeating the measurement without the sample to ensure that the recorded heat on the cold side flows through the sample and not through the wires .
99 caneschi a , gatteschi d , sessoli r , barra al , brunel lc , guillot m. 1991 . j. am .
chem . soc .
113:5873 sessoli r , tsai h - l , schake ar , wang s , vincent jb , et al . 1993 .
115:1804 y. suzuki , m. p. sarachik , e. m. chudnovsky , s. mchugh , r. gonzalez - rubio , n .
avraham , y. myasoedov , e. zeldov , h. shtrikman , n. e. chakov and g. christou , phys .
95 * , 147201 ( 2005 ) .
p. subedi , s. vlez , f. maci , s. li , m. p. sarachik , j. tejada , s. mukherjee , g. christou , and a. d. kent , phys .
110 , 207203 ( 2013 ) .
a. hernndez - mnguez,1 j. m. hernandez,1 f. maci,1 a. garca - santiago , j. tejada , and p.v .
santos , phys .
lett * 95 * , 217205 ( 2005 ) .
d. a. garanin and e. m. chudnovsky , phys .
102 , 097206 ( 2009 ) .
; d. a. garanin , phys . rev .
b80 , 014406 ( 2009 ) .
w. decelle , j. vanacken , and v.v .
moshchalkov , j. tejada , j. m. hernndez , and f. maci , phys .
* 102 * , 027203 ( 2009 ) ; m. modestov , v. bychkov , and m. marklund phys .
lett . * 107 * , 207208 ( 2011 ) .
w. wernsdorfer , r. sessoli , a. caneschi , d. gatteschi , a. cornia , and d. mailly , j. appl .
87 , 5481 ( 2000 ) .
a caneschi , d gatteschi , c sangregorio , r sessoli , l sorace , a cornia , m.a novak , c paulsen , w wernsdorfer , journal of magnetism and magnetic materials , volume 200 , issues 13 , october 1999 , pages 182 - 201 . t. leviant , in preparation .
d. a. garanin and e. m. chudnovsky , phys .
b76 , 054410 ( 2007 ) .
w. wernsdorfer and r. sessoli , science 284 , 133 ( 1999 ) ; a. mukhin , b. gorshunov , m. dressel , c. sangregorio , and d. gatteschi , phys . rev .
b 63 , 214411 ( 2001 ) a .- l .
barra , p. debrunner , d. gatteschi , ch .
e. schulz , and r. sessoli , europhys .
35 , 133 ( 1996 ) .
r. caciuffo , g. amoretti , a. murani , r. sessoli , a. caneschi , and d. gatteschi , phys .
81 , 4744 ( 1998 ) .
k. park , m. a. novotny , n. s. dalal , s. hill , and p. a. rikvold , phys .
b 66 , 144409 ( 2002 ) . a. d. kent et al . , europhys .
49 , 521 ( 2000 ) .
e. del barco , a.d .
kent , s. hill , j.m .
north , n.s .
dalal , e. rumberger , d.n .
hendrikson , n. chakov , and g. christou , j. low temp .
140 , 119 ( 2005 ) .
j. r. friedman and m. p. sarachik , annu .
. condens .
matter phys . 1 , 109 ( 2010 ) | we report spatially resolved , time - dependent , magnetization reversal measurements of an fe@xmath0 single molecular magnet using a microscopic hall bar array . we found that under some conditions the molecules reverse their spin direction at a resonance field in the form of an avalanche .
the avalanche front velocity is of the order of @xmath1 m / sec and is sensitive to field gradients and sweep rates .
we also measured the propagation velocity of a heat pulse and found that it is much slower than the avalanche velocity .
we therefore conclude that in fe@xmath0 , the avalanche front propagates without thermal assistance .
single molecular magnets ( smm ) are an excellent model system for the study of macroscopic quantum phenomena and their interplay with the environment . in recent years , the focus of these studies shifted from single molecule to collective effects . while there are two famous smm that show quantum behavior , namely , fe@xmath0 and mn@xmath2 , most of the work on collective effects has been focused on mn@xmath2 .
indeed , in mn@xmath2 intriguing effects were found , such as deflagration @xcite , quantum assisted deflagration @xcite , and detonation @xcite .
in all these cases , a spin reversal front propagates through the sample as an avalanche .
although showing some signs of quantum behavior hernandez2005 , these processes are based on over - the - barrier magnetization reversal . here , we focus on the spin avalanche phenomena in fe@xmath0 , where pure quantum effects exist at dilution refrigerator ( dr ) temperatures .
we measure the avalanche velocity @xmath3 for various sweep rates and applied field gradients .
we also determine the thermal diffusivity .
we find that @xmath4 is much faster than the velocity at which heat or matching field propagates through the sample .
moreover , @xmath3 is affected by field gradients .
therefore , the avalanche in fe@xmath0 is a quantum effect sometimes called cold deflagration @xcite .
fe@xmath0 provides the first experimental manifestation of such cold deflagration .
the fe@xmath0 smm has spin @xmath5 ground state , as does mn@xmath2 .
the magnetic anisotropy correspoding to an energy barrier between the spin projection quantum number @xmath6 and @xmath7 is @xmath8 k worensdorferscience99,mukhin2001,barra1996,caciuffo1998,park2002 ; in mn@xmath9 this anisotropy is @xmath10 k @xcite .
fe@xmath0 molecules show temperature - independent hysteresis loops at @xmath11 mk , with magnetization jumps at matching fields that are multiples of @xmath12 twernsdorfer2000,wernsdorfer1999 . however , when tunneling is taking place from state @xmath13 to @xmath14 , where @xmath15 , the excited state can decay to the ground state @xmath16 , releasing energy in the process . in a macroscopic sample
, this energy release can increase the temperature and support a deflagration process by assisting the spin flips .
spontaneous deflagration in mn@xmath2 takes place at various and not necessarily matching fields higher than @xmath1 t. the deflagration velocity starts from @xmath1 m / sec and increases with an increasing ( static ) field up to @xmath17 m / sec suzuki2005 .
our avalanche velocity measurements are based on local and time - resolved magnetization detection using a hall sensor array .
the array is placed at the center of a magnet and gradient coils . a schematic view of the array and coils is shown in the inset of fig . [ fig1 ] .
the array is made of hall bars of dimensions 100@xmath18100 @xmath19m@xmath20 with 100 @xmath19 m intervals ; the active layer in these sensors is a two - dimensional electron gas formed at the interface of gaas / algaas heterostructures .
the surface of the hall sensors is parallel to the applied field .
consequently , the effect of the applied field on the sensor is minimal and determined only by the ability to align the array surface and field . the sample and sensors
are cooled to @xmath21 mk using a dr .
more details on the hall measurements can be found in the supplemental material .
a magnetic field gradient could also be produced by two superconducting coils wound in the opposite sense .
they are placed at the center of the main coil and produce @xmath22 mt / mm per ampere .
since there is no option of adjusting the sample position after it has been cooled it is reasonable to assume that the sample is not exactly in the center of the main magnet .
in addition , the sample has corners and edges .
therefore , a field gradient is expected even when the gradient coils are turned off . in the experiments ,
the molecules are polarized by applying a magnetic field of @xmath23 t in the @xmath24 direction .
afterwards , the magnetic field is swept to @xmath25 t. the sweep is done at different sweep rates and under various applied magnetic field gradients . during the sweep ,
the amplified hall voltage from all sensors and the external field are recorded . from the raw field - dependent voltage of each sensor ,
a straight line is subtracted .
this line is due to the response of the hall sensor to the external field .
the line parameters are determined from very high and very low fields where no features in the raw data are observed . in our experiments , we found that fe@xmath0 samples can be divided into two categories : those that do not show avalanches , which have multiple magnetization steps regardless of the sweep rate , and those that show avalanches where the number of magnetization steps depends on the sweep rate . in fig .
[ fig1 ] , we present the normalized hall voltage as detected by one of the hall sensors from a sample of the first category .
the normalization is by the voltage at a field of 1 t where the molecules are fully polarized .
thus , the normalized voltage provides @xmath26 , where m is the magnetization and @xmath27 is the saturation magnetization .
the bottom abscissa is for a sweep where the field decreases from @xmath1 t. the top abscissa is for a sweep where the field increases from @xmath28 t. the magnetization shows typical steps at intervals of 0.225 t. no step is observed near zero field . in addition , the hysteresis loop s coercivity increases as the sweep rate increases .
these results are in agreement with previous measurements on fe@xmath0 @xcite .
they are presented here to demonstrate that the hall sensors are working properly , that their signals indeed represent the fe@xmath0 magnetization , and that in some samples all magnetization steps are observed .
the hysteresis loop of a sample from the second category is plotted in the bottom inset of fig .
[ fig1 ] . in this case
, there is a small magnetization jump at zero applied field , followed by a nearly full magnetization reversal at a field of @xmath29 t in the form of an avalanche . in all samples tested in this and other experiments in our groupleviantphotons ,
avalanches occurred only at the first matching field .
we could not tell in advance whether a sample was of the first or second category .
we always worked with samples of approximately the same dimensions ( @xmath30 mm@xmath31 ) .
this is in contrast to mn@xmath2 , where avalanches are associated with large samples @xcite .
avalanche velocity measurements in fe@xmath0 should be done with extra care . in an avalanche
there is , of course , a propagating front where spins flip .
but since our measurement in fe@xmath0 are done by sweeping the field through resonance , there is a similar front even without avalanche .
this is demonstrated in the inset of fig .
[ fig2 ] . in this inset , a sample placed off the symmetry point of a symmetric field profile
is shown .
thus , the sample experiences a field gradient . due to this gradient ,
tunneling of molecules will start first at a particular point in the sample where the local field is at matching value .
the spin reversal front will then propagate from that point to the rest of the sample as the external field is swept . in this case , pausing the field sweep will stop the magnetization evolution .
this is demonstrated in fig .
[ fig2 ] for an avalanche free sample .
the left ordinate is the normalized hall voltage ( solid symbols ) from three different sensors on the array .
each symbol represents a different sensor .
the right ordinate is the applied magnetic field ( line ) .
the voltage and field are plotted as a function of time .
we focus on fields before , near , and after the third transition in fig .
[ fig1 ] . for the most part
, the magnetization changes only when the field changes , even in the middle of a magnetization jump .
this means that the sample is subjected to some field gradients and a tunneling front propagates through the sample even without an avalanche .
it is possible to estimate the matching field front velocity of @xmath32 m / sec from a typical transition width ( @xmath33 t ) , a typical sweep rate ( @xmath34 mt / sec ) and the sample length ( @xmath35 mm ) . in fig .
[ fig3 ] , we zoom in on the magnetization jump of samples from the second category at a @xmath29 t field . in this figure , we show the time - resolved hall voltage from five different sensors along the array .
the three middle sensors show a peak in the hall voltage , which is experienced by each sensor at different times .
the two outer sensors experience a smoother variation of the hall voltage , in the form of cusps , also at different times .
this type of behavior is a clear indication of a magnetization reversal avalanche propagating from one side of the sample to the other .
the peaks and cusps are due to a zero magnetization front , where the magnetization @xmath36 changes sign due to tunneling . at the same front
, the magnetic induction @xmath37 from the sample is forced to point outward and toward the sensors , to maintain zero divergence friedman2010 .
this is demonstrated in the inset of fig .
[ fig2 ] . by following the time evolution of the peaks and cusps
, we can determine the front velocity .
since the sensors are spaced by parts of a millimeter and the peaks are spaced by parts of a millisecond , the avalanche velocity @xmath38 is of the order of @xmath1 m / sec , which is much higher than @xmath39 .
we found that the avalanche propagation direction can be affected by applying field gradients as long as the sweep rate is low .
this is demonstrated in fig .
[ fig4 ] . in this figure
, we show for each detector location the time at which it experiences a peak or a cusp .
the slope of each line is the avalanche velocity . for the lowest sweep rate of 0.83
mt / sec with no gradient , the velocity is negative .
it becomes positive as the gradient is switched on to 0.14 mt / mm , but becomes slower as the gradient increases to 0.69 mt / mm .
the effect of the gradient is opposite and weaker for our highest sweep rate of 8.3 mt / sec . in this case , all velocities are positive and increase as the gradient increases . only at the intermediate sweep rate of @xmath40
mt / sec does the gradient have no effect on the velocity .
although we find it challenging to explain the gradient dependence of the avalanche velocity , we do learn from this experiment that the safest sweep rate from which one can estimate the avalanche velocity is around @xmath41 mt / sec . in this case
, the external gradient does not affect the velocity .
the ratio between sweep rates and gradient ( when it is on ) is a quantity with units of velocity of the order of tens of millimeters per second .
this is much lower than @xmath3 .
therefore , the gradient experiment is another indication , but with an avalanching sample , that the propagation of the external magnetic field does not determine the avalanche velocity , and that @xmath4 is an internal quantity of the molecules .
in addition , our ability to affect @xmath3 with the gradient field rules out the possibility that the avalanche is due to over - the - barrier spin flips . finally , in fig .
[ fig5 ] we depict the avalanche velocities @xmath3 as a function of sweep rate with zero applied gradient .
the field was swept from positive to negative and vice versa .
the sample used in this experiment was of the second category and produced avalanches only for sweep rates higher than 3 mt / sec .
slower sweep rates generated the usual magnetization jumps , as shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] .
although there is some difference between the velocity for different sweep directions , it is clear that the velocity tends to increase with increasing sweep rate , and perhaps saturate . in light of the gradient experiment , the most representative avalanche velocity of fe@xmath42 is @xmath43 m / sec . to clarify the role of heat propagation in the avalanche process of fe@xmath0
, we also measured the thermal diffusivity @xmath44 between @xmath45 mk and @xmath1 k. this is done by applying a heat pulse on one side of the sample for a duration of @xmath46 msec , and measuring the time - dependent temperature on the hot side ( @xmath47 ) and on the cold side ( @xmath48 ) of a sample of length @xmath49 mm .
more experimental details are provided in the supplemental material .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] .
the thermal diffusivity is defined via the heat equation @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the location and time dependent temperature along the sample . for a long rod @xmath52
, one has that @xmath53we fit this expression to our @xmath54 data with @xmath55 and @xmath44 as fit parameters .
@xmath55 accounts for the coupling of the two thermometers to the sample .
the fit is shown by the solid line in fig .
[ fig6 ] .
although the fit is not perfect , it does capture the data quite well .
the @xmath44 obtained with this method at a few different temperatures is depicted in the inset of fig.[fig6 ] .
@xmath44 and @xmath56 obey the long rod condition .
it is much smaller than @xmath44 of mn@xmath2 , which is estimated to be @xmath57 to @xmath58 m@xmath20/sec @xcite .
now , we can generate a heat velocity @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the sample cross section . at @xmath61
mk we find that @xmath62 m / sec .
this is roughly @xmath63 divided by the time between the peak of @xmath64 and that of @xmath65 .
our experiments show that @xmath66 .
this means that the spin reversal front outruns the matching field as it crosses the sample .
more important , the avalanche outruns the heat generated in its wake .
every new molecular spin that tunnels does so at the dr temperature .
although heat is produced in the process , this heat does not propel the tunneling front forward .
moreover , the avalanche starts only at the first matching field and it s velocity is affected by a field gradient .
therefore , the avalanche properties are sensitive to the resonance conditions .
all these observations render the avalanche in fe@xmath0 a quantum mechanical phenomena .
the open question is then what sets its velocity . a natural guess , of tunnel splitting @xmath67 sec@xmath68 times
unite cell size of @xmath69 nm , namely , @xmath70 m / sec is too slow @xcite . therefore , to address this question , more profound considerations have to be taken into account .
this study was partially supported by the russell berrie nanotechnology institute , technion , israel institute of technology . |
the layered ruthenate - cuprate compound rusr@xmath0gdcu@xmath0o@xmath1 ( ru-1212 ) is a subject of intense interest as a unique model system to study the interplay between superconductivity and ferromagnetism . a ferromagnetic
( fm ) moment of the ru - o layers coexists with superconductivity originating from the cu - o bilayers over a broad temperature range.@xcite long - range magnetic - order in ru-1212 is established at t@xmath7 = 133 k. recent neutron - diffraction and magnetization studies@xcite display that in zero external magnetic field the magnetic order of the ru moments is predominately antiferromagnetic along the @xmath4-axis with spin canting in the @xmath8-plane .
the net in - plane magnetic moment is most likely due to the rotations of the ruo@xmath9 octahedra .
it is suggested that there is a field - induced spin reorientation , and that already at moderate fields the order becomes predominately ferromagnetic . at the same time @xmath10 transport and heat - capacity
measurements show that ru-1212 behaves like a typical underdoped cuprate superconductor with the onset of superconductivity at @xmath2 = 45 k and clearly exhibits a number of features arising from the presence of a normal state pseudogap .
@xcite the importance of @xmath4-axis charge dynamics for the high @xmath11 superconductivity still remains controversial.@xcite many aspects of the @xmath4-axis transport properties of superconducting ( sc ) bilayer compounds like yba@xmath0cu@xmath12o@xmath13 ( y-123 ) have been explained with a model invoking the onset of inter- and intrabilayer josephson junctions.@xcite from this point of view , ru-1212 presents a unique opportunity to investigate , how the sc cu - interbilayer coupling propagates through magnetic ru - layers . a more specific question concerns the hole doping of the cuo@xmath0 planes required for the superconductivity in ru-1212 compound .
the hole doping obtained from bond - valence summations based on the refined crystal structure amounts @xmath140.4 per cu atom , and results from an overlap of the ru:@xmath15 and the cu:3d@xmath16 bands .
@xcite however , the hole doping of the cuo@xmath0 planes derived from @xmath10 transport and heat - capacity measurements points towards @xmath17 @xmath180.1.@xcite this discrepancy probably reflects hole - trapping and/or strong scattering by the ferromagnetic ru moments . the present work aims to address these issues by studying the critical behavior in the infrared ( ir ) optical conductivity of the ru-1212 ceramics near the superconducting ( @xmath2 ) and magnetic ( @xmath3 ) transition temperatures .
the optical conductivity of ru-1212 reveals the typical features of the @xmath4-axis optical conductivity of underdoped multilayer superconducting cuprates : namely , the transformation of the cu - o bending mode into an additional broad absorption peak below a characteristic temperature @xmath6 = 90 k , significantly above @xmath2 , which is accompanied by the relative suppression of the optical conductivity spectral weight at low frequencies .
in addition , a distinct polaron - shaped band at about 4800 @xmath5 dominates the mid - ir conductivity .
on decreasing temperature the increase of the total spectral weight associated with the intraband transitions is significantly enhanced below @xmath3 .
the correlated shifts of the phonon mode at 190 @xmath5 and the mid - ir band to lower frequencies below @xmath3 = 133 k provide experimental evidence in favor of strong electron - phonon coupling of the charge carriers in the ru - o layers which is governed by the magnetic order .
polycrystalline ru-1212 samples were synthesized by solid - state reaction from high purity ruo@xmath0 , srco@xmath12 , gd@xmath0o@xmath12 , and cuo powders , as described in details elsewhere.@xcite at the final stage of the preparation the sample in the form of a pressed pellet was annealed at 1060 @xmath19c for 6 days in flowing oxygen and was polished to optical quality .
x - ray diffraction confirms that the sample is single - phased with a tetragonal @xmath20 structure .
the temperature - dependent magnetization@xcite of the ru-1212 samples reveals a magnetic transition temperature @xmath3 = 133 k. a large value of diamagnetic shielding is seen below 28 k. the @xmath10 resistivity @xmath21 is similar to that reported recently by tallon _
et al._,@xcite and shows the onset of a superconductivity at @xmath2 = 45 k with zero resistivity below 32 k. the temperature dependence of the resistitvity above @xmath2 exhibits two different regimes with @xmath22 for @xmath23 and @xmath24 for @xmath25 with a crossover temperature @xmath26 90 k. near - normal incidence reflectivities in the far - ir region from 30 to 750 @xmath5 were measured using a `` bruker '' ifs 133v spectrometer with the newly designed ge - coated 6 @xmath27 mylar beamsplitter .
this significantly increased the signal - to - noise ratio and avoided to merge the spectra at phonon frequencies . to extend the reflectivity measurements to higher frequencies ,
a `` bruker '' ifs 66v / s spectrometer was used covering the frequency range from 600 to 16000 @xmath5 , the higher frequency limit being restricted by calibrating the reflectivity against the gold - coated sample .
the sample was mounted in the `` oxford optistat '' he bath cryostat for the measurements from 10 to 300 k.
the reflectivity spectra of ru-1212 for wavenumbers up to 9000 @xmath5 and for different temperatures from 10 k to 300 k are shown in fig .
1 . as the temperature decreases from 300 to 10 k , the reflectivity displays a gradual increase , consistent with an increase of the sample conductivity . below the sc transition temperature
the far - ir reflectivity is noticeably enhanced .
this increase is reproducible and amounts 3% .
the reflectivity becomes close to unity at frequencies below 70 @xmath5 in the sc state .
comparing to the reflectivity spectra of ru-1212 ceramics reported recently by litvinchuk _
et al._,@xcite our data show a noticeably higher ( up to 10 - 20 % ) reflectivity level in the spectral range under investigation . at
all temperatures investigated five optical phonon modes near 128 , 151 , 190 , 288 , and 654 @xmath5 are clearly observed .
it is well established@xcite that the modes appearing in the spectra of anisotropic ceramics correspond to phonon modes polarized along @xmath4-axis .
the @xmath8-plane response from phonons in the reflectivity spectra ( left panel , fig .
1 ) becomes apparent as additional small step - like features at 225 , 352 , and 520 @xmath5 . to obtain the optical conductivity via kramers - kronig analysis
, we used a continuous low - frequency extrapolation of the reflectivity to @xmath28 , utilizing the formula @xmath29 , with @xmath30 .
the lower and upper limits of @xmath31 correspond to the hagen - rubens extrapolation for the normal state and the extrapolation for the sc state , respectively . however , there is no influence of the different extrapolations on the resulting optical conductivity for wavenumbers @xmath32 70 @xmath5 . for wavenumbers higher than 16000 @xmath5 ,
an extrapolation using a @xmath33 frequency dependence was used .
the real part of the optical conductivity @xmath34 of ru-1212 for different temperatures is shown in fig . 2 ( @xmath35 : upper panels ; @xmath36 : lower panels ) . at room temperature
the five distinct ir - active phonon modes at 128 , 151 , 190 , 288 , and 654 @xmath5 are superimposed on a featureless electronic background of 100 @xmath37@xmath5 , consistent with the room temperature @xmath10 conductivity value .
the electronic background extends to higher frequencies and a broad mid - ir band appears at 4800 @xmath5 .
the infrared - active phonons observed in the ru-1212 ceramics ( fig.2 , left panels ) can be assigned similarly as reported for the @xmath4-axis optical phonons in y-123 crystals.@xcite indeed , ru-1212 is structurally similar to the rare - earth cuprate superconductors like y-123 except that the cu - o chain layers are replaced by ruo@xmath0 square planar layers .
ignoring the rotations of the ruo@xmath9 octahedra , an approximate structure is then of tetragonal symmetry @xmath38 .
a comparison with the ir - spectra of y-123 suggests that the phonon mode at 654 @xmath5 involves primarily the apical oxygen vibrations , whereas that at 288 @xmath5 is related to the cu - o bending mode which involves vibrations of the oxygen ions of the cuo@xmath0 planes .
we suggest the three low - frequency modes at 128 , 151 , and 190 @xmath5 to be assigned to the displacements of cu , gd , and ru , respectively . indeed , the cu - related mode at 128 @xmath5 is close in frequency to the in - plane cu vibrations at 104 @xmath5 in y-123 crystals .
the eigenfrequency of the gd mode at 151 @xmath5 agrees with that of rear - earth ( r ) related phonon mode in r-123 cuprates , where it is strongly r - dependent decreasing from 193 @xmath5 in y-123 to 162 @xmath5 in er-123 in accordance with mass ratio of the r ion .
the assignment is confirmed by shell - model calculations for ru-1212 with a @xmath39 space group , reported recently by litvinchuk _
et al._.@xcite these model calculations also suggest that the mode at 190 @xmath5 involves primarily ru - ion vibrations against the cu ions .
in order to determine the resonant frequencies of the observed phonon modes and the mid - ir band parameters at all temperatures , we applied a quantitative dispersion analysis by fitting both the reflectivity and optical conductivity spectra .
the model dielectric function consists of a sum of lorentzian functions , accounting for the contributions from the low - frequency phonon modes at 128 , 151 , and 190 @xmath5 and the mid - ir band as well .
additionally , the almost featureless electronic background at frequencies below 800 @xmath5 was included in a kramers - kronig consistent way into the fitting procedure using a sum of five broad lorentzian bands with halfwidths more than 150 @xmath5 .
we have found that the two high - frequency phonon modes , mostly related to oxygen vibrations , are noticeably asymmetric in shape .
the asymmetric phonon feature at 654 @xmath5 can be described by the fano profile ( see e.g. ref.@xcite ) , given by @xmath40 , with @xmath41 , @xmath31 and @xmath42 are the line - width and the resonant frequency , and @xmath43 denotes the amplitude which is related to the oscillator strength as @xmath44 . the dimensionless fano parameter @xmath45 is a measure of the asymmetry of the peak and for @xmath46 a lorentzian line shape is recovered .
the asymmetry of the band at 654 @xmath5 yields @xmath47 0.19 at all temperatures in accordance with the fano - profile description .
a single resonance description fails for the strongly asymmetric phonon feature around 288 @xmath5 , and we used two lorentzian profiles to describe this band .
the complex nature of the asymmetric structure involving the cu - o bending mode at 288 @xmath5 will be verified by a detailed analysis of its temperature dependence .
analyzing the temperature dependence of the optical conductivity of ru-1212 , we emphasize its striking resemblance of the @xmath4-axis conductivity of strongly underdoped sc y-123 cuprates .
figure 3 shows the most apparent feature related to the onset of superconductivity which is the transformation of the bending mode at 288 @xmath5 ( light solid curve in fig .
3(a ) : @xmath48 = 100 k ) to a broad band centered at 308 @xmath5 ( heavy solid curve in fig .
3(a ) : @xmath48 = 10 k ) . figure 3(b ) shows the detailed temperature dependence of the peak position of the asymmetric structure involving the 288 @xmath5 mode and of the lorentzian damping factor of the fitting curve , which properly describes the low - frequency wing of the structure .
the transformation of the band profile starts at around 90 k , close to @xmath6 defined above , being well below the magnetic transition temperature @xmath3 = 133 k , but also well above @xmath2 = 45 k. the most pronounced changes are observed at @xmath2 , as can be clearly seen from the temperature dependence of the band position ( open squares in fig .
this behavior involving an anomaly of the cu - o bending mode , accompanied by the formation of an additional broad absorption band at phonon frequencies , is well studied in the @xmath4-axis ir - conductivity of underdoped layered cuprates.@xcite the mechanism of this phenomenon is a subject of ongoing discussions.@xcite the most favored explanation is based on a model where the bilayer cuprate compounds are treated as a superlattice of inter- and intrabilayer josephson junctions.@xcite in this model the additional absorption peak is related to the transverse bilayer plasmon , while the anomalous softening and the loss of the spectral weight of the cu - o bending mode are explained to be due to the drastic changes of the local electrical fields acting on the in - plane oxygen ions as the josephson current sets in .
the gradual onset of the anomalies above @xmath2 is explained due to the persistence of a coherent superconducting state within the individual copper - oxygen bilayers , whereas the steep and sudden changes at @xmath2 occur when the macroscopically coherent superconducting state forms .
this effect is strongly dependent on the doping level and is not observed in the optimally doped and overdoped y-123 samples . for the strongly underdoped yba@xmath0cu@xmath12o@xmath49 , the transverse optical plasmon and the bending mode merge , forming a single highly - asymmetric peak .
comparing the temperature dependence of the asymmetric peak in ru-1212 at 288 @xmath5 with the data reported by munzar _
et al . _ for yba@xmath0cu@xmath12o@xmath49 ( see fig . 3 of ref.@xcite ) we find a striking similarity .
the present observation suggests a strongly underdoped character of the weakly coupled cuprate biplanes and a strong anisotropy of the ru-1212 compound . at the same time , the pronounced anomaly of the bending mode observed right at @xmath2 implies that the ru-1212 is a bulk superconductor at lower temperatures .
this experimental evidence is important seeing the onset of a bulk superconductivity in ru-1212 is still very much disputed.@xcite another well - known feature of the underdoped cuprate superconductors is a suppression of spectral weight ( sw ) at low frequencies already above @xmath2 due to the opening a normal state pseudogap.@xcite this feature is not clearly observed in ru-1212 . on the contrary , as shown in the left panels of fig .
2 the electronic background at low frequencies increases continuously as the temperature is lowered from 300 k to 100 k , and remains almost constant below 100 k. the weak suppression in the electronic background conductivity below 400 @xmath5 for @xmath50 100 k is shown in fig .
4 . however , the actual value of the effect depends on the assumptions made when the phonon - related features are subtracted .
the relative suppression of the low frequency sw ( lsw ) evaluated below @xmath51 800 @xmath5 becomes more evident when compared with the total sw ( tsw ) evaluated up to frequencies of @xmath51 9500 @xmath5 .
the inset of fig .
4 shows the relative changes of the sw with decreasing temperature from 300 k , expressed in terms of the effective electron density per unit cell @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the ir conductivity after subtraction of the phonons and the volume of the unit cell ( @xmath38 ) is @xmath54 .
the effective carrier densities with @xmath55 = 9500 @xmath5 and @xmath55 = 800 @xmath5 evaluated at 300 k are 0.12 and 0.005 , respectively . as shown in the inset of fig .
4 , the temperature dependence of the lsw fully reproduces that of tsw for @xmath56 . on further decreasing temperatures
the tsw continues to increase , whereas the lsw remains constant or even slightly decreases .
we suggest that the discrepancy in the temperature dependences of the lsw and tsw reflects the opening of the pseudogap in ru-1212 superconductor .
however , the effect is not very pronounced because of a significant contribution from the polaron - like mid - ir band to the lsw .
the mid - ir band reveals the shape of a small polaron with a clearly resolved maximum at 4800 @xmath5 at 300 k corresponding to a polaron binding energy of about 0.3 ev . the most remarkable features of this band are the anomalies which occur at the onset of ferromagnetic order within the ru - o layers at @xmath3 = 133 k , namely , the shift to lower energies from 4800 @xmath5 at @xmath57 k to 4400 @xmath5 at @xmath58 k and a strong increase in the sw .
the inset of fig .
4 shows that the tsw contributed mainly from the mid - ir band increases continuously on decreasing temperature and reveals an anomaly at @xmath3 , as indicated by a significant deviation from the guideline which roughly approximates the high - temperature dependence .
the ferromagnetism in ru - o layers is believed to have the same origin as in srruo@xmath12 , which , in turn , is explained by itinerant - electron ferromagnetism based on band theory.@xcite the ru ion in srruo@xmath12 is in a tetravalent low - spin state @xmath59 ( @xmath60 = 1 ) .
the ferromagnetic coupling between ru ions is transmitted via the itinerant electrons of the minority @xmath15 band , the charge carrier transport being strongly dependent on the core spin alignment . in ru-1212 the @xmath15 minority band is partially occupied due to the hole doping of the cuo@xmath0 biplanes resulting in weak itinerant ferromagnetism . assuming that the mid - ir band is associated with the hopping conductivity of the minority @xmath15 electrons , the strong carrier - spin interaction can naturally explain the temperature behavior of the band . as t
is decreased below @xmath3 the resulting onset of ferromagnetic correlations leads to an increase of the kinetic energy of the charge carriers , which , in turn , results in a decrease of the effective electron - phonon coupling . as a result ,
an increase in the tsw and a shift of the polaronic band to lower frequencies are observed .
note that this behavior of the sw is typical of magnetoresistive fm compounds like the doped manganites,@xcite and has been discussed in terms of a temperature - dependent competing effects between electron - phonon coupling and double - exchange interaction of core spins mediated by itinerant electrons.@xcite a further important feature associated with the magnetic transition in ru-1212 is the anomalous shift of the ru - related phonon mode at 190 @xmath5 as shown in fig .
5(a ) . in fig.5(b )
we show the relative shifts of the low - frequency phonon modes at 128 , 151 , and 190 @xmath5 along with the shift of the apical oxygen phonon mode at 654 @xmath5 and the broad mid - ir band at 4800 @xmath5 observed on decreasing temperature from 300 k. among all phonon modes , only the apical oxygen mode exhibits the classical inharmonic increase of the eigenfrequency on decreasing temperature , revealing anomalies neither at @xmath2 nor at @xmath3 . at the same time
the low - frequency phonon modes show a characteristic softening at @xmath2 as observed in y-123 related compounds , and as discussed in terms of the resonance - frequency renormalization of the phonon modes lying below the sc gap.@xcite however , the most pronounced effect is the anomalous softening of the mode at 190 @xmath5 which is related to the magnetic transition temperature in ru-1212 compound , as shown in fig .
the anomalous shift of the phonon mode at 190 @xmath5 , reaching a relative value of 10% at the lowest temperatures , can not be explained by structural changes of the bond lengths observed in ru-1212 , @xcite all being less than 0.5% .
this fact indicates that the ru - related phonon mode is strongly affected by the interaction with the electronic system .
it is important to note that the shifts of the phonon mode at 190 @xmath5 and the polaronic band at 4800 @xmath5 exhibit apparently correlated character , indicating a strong coupling of this phonon mode to the low - energy electronic excitations , as clearly demonstrated in fig .
5(b ) the onset of this effect at the magnetic transition temperature and the decrease of the electron excitation energy on lowering temperature below t@xmath7 can be explained by the renormalization of the electron - phonon coupling : the kinetic energy of the itinerant electrons increases due to the onset of the ferromagnetic correlations in the ru - o layers .
this scenario can in turn explain the underdoped character of the stoichiometric ru-1212 superconductor , where the strong hole depletion of the cuprate bilayers is caused by the charge carrier self - trapping on the ru moments .
we should note finally that as seen in fig 5(b ) , the 4800 @xmath5 band has the anomaly at @xmath3 on decreasing temperature with saturation below @xmath2 , while the 190 @xmath5 mode exhibits a singularity at about 90 k and further steep softening associated with the sc transition .
this suggests that the bilayer plasmon - phonon coupling responsible for the anomaly of the cu - o bending mode could also play a role in the softening of the 190 @xmath5 mode . to shed light on the origin of the predominant contribution ,
the detailed analysis of the mode eigenvectors is necessary , as well as of the temperature dependence of the oscillator strength and the damping factor .
the accurate analysis of the temperature dependences will be possible after ru-1212 single crystals have been prepared .
on the other hand , the ru-1212 system could provide an intriguing opportunity to develop the model of the bilayer josephson plasmon for the case when the ferromagnetic moment is in the insulating ruo@xmath0 plane mediated the cuprate bilayers .
further investigations of the phonon anomalies in ru-1212 is promising to study the effect of the ru magnetic moment ordering tuned by applying an external magnetic field on the interbilayer coupling .
in conclusion , we have investigated the optical conductivity of ru-1212 .
the transformation of the cu - o bending phonon mode at 288 @xmath5 in the normal state to an absorption `` bump '' at 308 @xmath5 in the sc state has been observed .
this observation strikingly resembles data reported recently for the strongly underdoped yba@xmath0cu@xmath12o@xmath49 crystals , which were explained with a model invoking the onset of interbilayer and intrabilayer josephson junctions .
the present observation evidences a strongly underdoped character of the bulk superconductivity originated in weakly coupled cuprate biplanes .
the optical conductivity of ru-1212 is discussed in terms of a two - fluid model , the far - ir and @xmath10 conductivity being predominantly associated with the conductivity in the cuo@xmath0 planes , whereas the mid - ir conductivity being associated with the hopping conductivity in the ru - o layers .
the correlated anomalous shifts of the ru - related phonon mode at 190 @xmath5 and the polaron band at 4800 @xmath5 to lower frequencies have been observed on decreasing temperature below the @xmath3 = 133 k. the underdoped character of the stoichiometric ru-1212 superconductor is explained by the strong hole depletion of the cuprate bilayers caused by the charge carrier self - trapping on the ru moments . c. bernhard _ et al .
rev . b*59 * , 14099 ( 1999 ) . c. bernhard , j. l. tallon , e. brcher and r. k. kremer , phys .
rev . b*61 * , r14960 ( 2000 ) .
a. c. mclaughlin _
et al . _ ,
rev . b*60 * , 7512 ( 1999 ) .
o. chmaissam _
et al . _ ,
rev . b*61 * , 6401 ( 2000 ) .
j. l. tallon , j.w .
loram , g. v. m. williams , c. bernhard , phys
. rev . b*61 * , r6471 ( 2000 ) .
j. w. lynn _
et al . _ ,
rev . b*61 * , r14964 ( 2000 ) .
g. v. m. williams , s. krmer , phys . rev . b*62 * , 4132 ( 2000 ) .
m. grninger , d. van der marel , a. a. tsvetkov , and a. erb , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 1575 ( 2000 ) .
l. b. ioffe and a. j. millis , phys .
b * 61 * , 9077 ( 2000 ) .
d. munzar _ et al .
_ , solid state commun . * 112 * , 365 ( 1999 ) . c. bernhard _ et al .
b * 61 * , 618 ( 2000 )
. j. hemberger _
et al . _ ,
a. p. litvinchuk _
et al . _ ,
b * 62 * , 9709 ( 2000 ) .
a. p. litvinchuk , c. thomsen , and m. cardona , in _ physical properties of high temperature superconductors iv _ , edited by d. m. ginsberg ( world scientfic , singapore , 1994 ) , p. 375 and references therein .
r. henn , t. strach , e. schnherr , and m. cardona , phys . rev .
b * 55 * , 3285 ( 1997 ) .
j. schtzmann _
et al . _ ,
b * 52 * , 13665 ( 1995 ) .
a. damascelli , k. skulte , and d. van marel , a. a. menovsky , phys .
b * 55 * , r4863 ( 1997 ) .
c. c. homes _ et al . _ , physica c * 254 * , 265 ( 1995 ) .
r. hauff , s. tajima , w .- j .
jang , and a. i. rykov , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 4620 ( 1996 ) .
tom timusk and bryan statt , rep . on progress in phys .
* 62 * , 61 ( 1999 ) .
jian - xin zhu , c.s .
ting , and c.w .
chu , phys .
b * 62 * , 11369 ( 2000 ) .
s.c . gausepohl _
_ , phys . rev .
b * 52 * , 3459 ( 1995 ) ; i.i .
mazin , d.j .
singh , phys .
b * 56 * , 2556 ( 1997 ) ; j.s .
et al . _ ,
b * 60 * , r6987 ( 1999 ) .
et al . _ , phys . rev .
b * 59 * , r697 ( 1999 ) .
a.j . millis , r. mueller , and boris .
i. shraiman , phys .
b * 54 * , 5405 ( 1996 ) ; a. chattopadhyay , a.j .
millis , s. das sarma , phys .
b * 61 * , 10738 ( 2000 ) . | critical behavior of the infrared reflectivity of rusr@xmath0gdcu@xmath0o@xmath1 ceramics is observed near the superconducting @xmath2 = 45 k and magnetic @xmath3 = 133 k transition temperatures .
the optical conductivity reveals the typical features of the @xmath4-axis optical conductivity of strongly underdoped multilayer superconducting cuprates .
the transformation of the cu - o bending mode at 288 @xmath5 to a broad absorption peak at the temperatures between @xmath6 = 90 k and @xmath2 is clearly observed , and is accompanied by the suppression of spectral weight at low frequencies .
the correlated shifts to lower frequencies of the ru - related phonon mode at 190 @xmath5 and the mid - ir band at 4800 @xmath5 on decreasing temperature below @xmath3 are observed .
it provides experimental evidence in favor of strong electron - phonon coupling of the charge carriers in the ru - o layers which critically depends on the ru core spin alignment .
the underdoped character of the superconductor is explained by strong hole depletion of the cuo@xmath0 planes caused by the charge carrier self - trapping at the ru moments . |
ram pressure ( and related processes ) by the intracluster medium ( icm ) can remove a galaxy s gas ( gunn & gott 1972 ) .
this process has been observed in various stages ; for example , vollmer ( 2009 ) separates virgo galaxies into pre - peak , peak , and post - peak ram pressure groups .
the amount of time that a galaxy has been stripped can be estimated using the length of the observable tail and the velocity of the galaxy ( e.g. oosterloo & van gorkom 2005 ; sun et al .
this calculation is uncertain due to difficulties in determining the three dimensional galaxy velocity .
another assumption implicit in this calculation is that the observed tail provides the true length of the stripped gas .
in fact , tails have been observed in h@xmath0 , h@xmath1 , and x - ray emission , although never all from the same tail ( e.g. oosterloo & van gorkom 2005 ; koopmann et al . 2008 ; kenney et al .
2008 ; yoshida et al . 2002 ; yoshida et al .
2004a , b ; sun et al . 2007 ; sun et al .
2006 ; sun et al .
2010 ; machacek et al .
2006 ; sun & vikhlinin 2005 ) .
the lengths of tails observed in different wavelengths can be quite different ; for example the h@xmath0 tail of ngc 4388 is nearly three times as long as the observed h@xmath1 tail ( oosterloo & van gorkom ; yoshida et al .
another method used to calculate the age of a tail is to use the estimated survival time of h@xmath1 , as in gavazzi et al .
( 2001 ) . however , it is still not clear what dictates cloud survival or even what conditions are necessary to produce the various types of emission ( h@xmath1 , x - ray , and h@xmath0 ) .
can all three types of emission coexist ?
what physical processes dominate the heating and mixing of stripped gas into the icm ?
these processes include : turbulent mixing , which can generate intermediate temperature and density gas at constant pressure ; shock heating , which heats the ism ; radiative cooling , which can lead to recompression of heated gas , and heat conduction , which can evaporate small clouds . in this work we focus on answering these questions by simulating gas stripping and comparing our simulated tail to a single observed stripped galaxy , eso 137 - 001 , which has been studied observationally in some detail .
eso 137 - 001 is in a3627 , which is the closest massive cluster ( z=0.0163 , @xmath2 = 925 km s@xmath3 and kt = 6 kev ) , similar to coma and perseus in mass and galaxy content ( sun et al .
2009 and references therein ) .
eso 137 - 001 is a small ( 0.2l@xmath4 ; sun et al .
2006 ) , blue emission - line galaxy ( woudt et al .
2004 ) , that is @xmath5200 kpc from the center of the cluster in projection . because its radial velocity is close to the average velocity of a3627 ( woudt et al . 2004
; woudt et al .
2008 ) , most of its motion is likely in the plane of the sky , and therefore the stripping process is seen edge - on .
sun et al .
( 2006 ) found a @xmath570 kpc x - ray tail pointing away from the cluster center using _ chandra _ and xmm-_newton _ data .
sun et al .
( 2007 ) then discovered a 40 kpc h@xmath1 tail with over 30 emission - line regions extending through the length of the h@xmath1 tail , and concluded that the emission - line regions are giant h@xmath0 regions . in a recent follow - up paper , sun et al .
( 2009 ) used deep _
chandra _ data and _ gemini _ spectra to characterize the x - ray tail and h@xmath0 regions in detail .
they found a narrower secondary x - ray tail with a similar length .
they also confirmed that 33 emission - line regions are h@xmath0 regions , with the furthest seven regions beyond the tidally - truncated halo of 15 kpc that is calculated in sun et al .
( 2007 ) using simulations by gnedin ( 2003 ) .
in addition to these distinct h@xmath0 regions , they find diffuse h@xmath1 emission .
vollmer et al .
( 2001 ) searched for h@xmath0 in a3627 , and did not detect any h@xmath0 in or around eso 137 - 001 with a limiting column density of 2 @xmath6 10@xmath7 @xmath8 and a resolution of 15 " .
in fact , of the @xmath580 galaxies identified by woudt et al .
( 1998 ) in their search region , vollmer et al .
( 2001 ) detected only 2 in h@xmath0 , finding that the h@xmath0 detection rate in a3627 is similar to that in coma .
sivanandam et al .
( 2009 ) observed eso 137 - 001 with irac and irs on _ spitzer_. the irs data extended to 20 kpc from the galaxy along the x - ray tail , and warm ( @xmath5160 k ) molecular hydrogen was detected throughout the length of the observed region .
the observed region contains @xmath52.5 @xmath6 10@xmath9 m@xmath10 warm h@xmath11 gas .
they also identify star - forming regions using 8 @xmath12 m data , which coincide with h@xmath1 emitting regions .
there has been a substantial amount of theoretical work investigating ram pressure stripping in general ( e.g. schulz & struck 2001 ; quilis , bower & moore 2000 ; roediger & brggen 2008 , kronberger et al .
2008 ; kapferer et al .
2009 ) see tonnesen & bryan ( 2009 , 2010 ; hereafter tb09 and tb10 ) for a more detailed discussion .
there have also been simulations designed to predict or interpret observational characteristics of ram pressure stripped tails and the remaining disks ( e.g. vollmer et al .
2005 , 2006 , 2008 ) , but detailed , quantitative predictions of all three observational probes have been missing to date ( h@xmath0 , diffuse h@xmath1 , and x - ray emission ) . in our previous work ( tb10 ) , we ran a set of high resolution simulations ( about 38 pc resolution , which is small enough to marginally resolve giant molecular clouds ) to understand how a multiphase ism could affect the survival and structure of ram pressure stripped gas .
we focused on how density fluctuations that are observed in the multiphase ism of galaxies can affect gas tails .
including radiative cooling allowed us to estimate the density of and emission from h@xmath0 , h@xmath1 , and x - ray gas separately .
we found that both the morphology and velocity structure of our tails agreed with observations of long gas tails ( e.g. oosterloo & van gorkom 2005 ) .
our simulations also resulted in observable amounts of h@xmath0 and h@xmath1 emission .
however , the x - ray tail had a low surface brightness , which we attributed to the low pressure of the surrounding icm .
in this paper we will use the same method as in tb10 , but have chosen icm parameters comparable to the icm around eso 137 - 001 . by focusing on the level of agreement between our simulations and the observations of eso 137 - 001 we will be able to discuss the importance of physical mechanisms such as heat conduction , as well as predict the conditions under which h@xmath0 , h@xmath1 , and x - ray emission are produced in stripped tails .
the paper is structured as follows . after a brief introduction to our methodology
, we provide the characteristics of our simulations and our method of producing simulated observations ( 2 ) . we then ( 3 ) present our results , specifically focusing on the comparison with eso 137 - 001 . in
4 we discuss the broader implications of our simulation , and discuss our choice of radiative cooling floor and resolution in 5.1 - 2 .
finally , we conclude in 6 with a summary of our results and predictions for observers .
c | c variable & value + m@xmath4 & @xmath13 m@xmath14 + a@xmath4 & 4 kpc + b@xmath4 & 0.25 kpc + m@xmath15 & @xmath16 m@xmath14 + r@xmath15 & 0.4 kpc + r@xmath17 & 23 kpc + @xmath18 & @xmath19 g @xmath20 +
we use the adaptive mesh refinement ( amr ) code _ enzo _ ( bryan 1999 ; norman & bryan 1999 ; oshea et al . 2004 ) .
our simulated region is 311 kpc on a side with a root grid resolution of @xmath21 cells .
we allow an additional 6 levels of refinement , for a smallest cell size of 38 pc .
we refine our simulation based on the local gas mass , such that a cell was flagged for refinement whenever it contained more than about @xmath22 @xmath23 .
we found that this refined most of the galactic disk to 38 pc resolution by the time the wind hit ; dense clumps in the wake were also refined to 38 pc resolution , while more diffuse components had lower resolution .
the simulation includes radiative cooling using the sarazin & white ( 1987 ) cooling curve extended to low temperatures as described in tasker & bryan ( 2006 ) . to mimic effects that we do not model directly
( such as turbulence on scales below the grid scale , uv heating , magnetic field support , or cosmic rays ) , we cut off the cooling curve at a minimum temperature @xmath24 so that the cooling rate is zero below this temperature . in the simulations described here we use
either @xmath25 k , or @xmath26 k. both allow gas to cool below the threshold for neutral hydrogen formation . in tb09 , we found that the minimum temperature affected the range of masses and sizes of clouds forming in the disk , and the distribution of clouds throughout the disk , although the range of gas densities was very similar .
the @xmath26 k case resulted in a more fragmented disk whose small clouds took longer to strip . therefore the timescales for gas stripping differed , although the total amount of gas lost was similar . in the simulations presented in this paper , we find that the cooling floor affects the amount of fragmentation in the disks , but not the mass - distribution of gas densities
. the larger radii of the remaining gas disks in the two @xmath26 k runs are due to the survival of dense clouds in the outer disk ( figures [ fig : xrayproj ] , [ fig : haproj ] , and [ fig : hiproj ] ) . in tb10 , we found that the structure of the wake also depends somewhat on @xmath27 . since the publication of tb10 , we found and corrected an error in our implementation of the cooling rate that resulted in a slight shift in the peak of the cooling curve around @xmath28 k , but did not significantly affect cooling at low and high temperatures ( this affected only the @xmath26 k simulation ) .
tests showed that this had only a small impact on the dynamics of the flow , and on the predicted h@xmath0 and x - ray measures , but did strongly affect the predicted h@xmath1 emission , which is extremely sensitive to the gas temperature around @xmath28 k. this explains the enhanced h@xmath1 emission in this paper for the @xmath26 k run as compared to tb10 .
c | c variable & value + m@xmath29 & @xmath16 m@xmath14 + a@xmath29 & 7 kpc + b@xmath29 & 0.4 kpc + c | c | c | c | c | c run & v@xmath30 ( km / s ) & p@xmath30 ( dyne/@xmath31 ) & t@xmath30 ( k ) & p@xmath32 ( dyne/@xmath31 ) & t@xmath33 ( myr ) + t80vh & 1900 & 4.2 @xmath6 10@xmath34 & 8.3 @xmath6 10@xmath35 & 11.6 @xmath6 10@xmath34 & 85 + t3vh & 1900 & 4.2 @xmath6 10@xmath34 & 8.3 @xmath6 10@xmath35 & 11.6 @xmath6 10@xmath34 & 75 + t3vl & 1413 & 2.66 @xmath6 10@xmath34 & 7.3 @xmath6 10@xmath35 & 5.29 @xmath6 10@xmath34 & 110 + sun et al .
2010 & & 1.8 @xmath6 10@xmath34 & @xmath57 @xmath6 10@xmath35 & & + our galaxy model is the same as in tb10 and tb09 , which used the spiral galaxy model described in roediger & brggen ( 2006 ) .
we list the model parameters for our galaxy in tables [ tbl - const4 ] and [ tbl - gconst4 ] .
the stellar and dark matter components of the galaxy are static potentials . as in tb09 and tb10 ,
our galaxy position and box size allows us to follow gas 200 kpc above ( in the wind , or z , direction ) the galaxy . to identify gas that has been stripped from the galaxy
, we also follow a passive tracer which is initially set to 1.0 inside the galaxy ( defined as gas that is above the icm density ) and @xmath36 outside .
in the following analysis , we will use a minimum tracer fraction of 0.25 to find gas stripped from the galaxy ( as in tb10 ) .
the galaxy initially evolves in a static , high - pressure icm with @xmath37 8.7 @xmath6 10@xmath38 g @xmath20 and @xmath39 9.069 @xmath6 10@xmath40 k ( @xmath377.57 @xmath6 10@xmath38 g @xmath20 and @xmath39 1.04294 @xmath6 10@xmath9 k for the slower wind case ) , to allow cool , dense gas to form in the galaxy ( each of our three runs has about 3 @xmath6 10@xmath41 m@xmath10 of gas with densities at or above 10@xmath42 g @xmath20 when the wind hits the disk ) .
this naturally generates a multiphase ism ( see tasker & bryan 2006 and tb09 for more discussion of the ism properties ) .
after 155 myrs , we reset the boundary conditions to generate a constant icm inflow along the inner z - axis , which is always face - on to the galaxy . in table
[ tbl - runs ] we show the details of each of the three runs .
the table includes the icm parameters and the time after the wind has hit the galaxy at which the x - ray tail is 80 kpc long ( this is how we choose the outputs to compare to the observations of eso 137 - 001 ) .
` t80 ' indicates cooling to 8,000 k and ` t3 ' indicates cooling to 300 k , while ` vh ' and ` vl ' indicate high and low velocity wind , respectively .
see tb09 for other details regarding the general numerical setup , and tb10 for a discussion of the general impact of the cooling floor on the tail structure . in order to compare with both observations and our previous work , we use a face - on wind direction .
_ enzo _ outputs the density and temperature of the gas in each cell .
to transform these values into h@xmath0 column density and h@xmath1 intensity , we used cloudy , version 08.00 of the code last described by ferland et al .
( 1998 ) . using a table of temperatures and densities
, we calculated the hydrogen neutral fraction and h@xmath1 emissivity .
this table is then used to calculate the observational quantities for each cell , which are then summed to generate an image .
this is described in detail in tb10 , but briefly , we included cmb radiation , the cosmic ray background , bremsstrahlung radiation from the icm and the 2005 version of the haardt & madau ( 2001 ) @xmath43 metagalactic continuum , as implemented by cloudy .
we chose to calculate the neutral fraction and h@xmath1 emissivity for a plane - parallel gas cloud of width 100 pc .
we selected this width because it loosely corresponds to the cell size of most of the gas in the tails , and accounts approximately for attenuation of the ionizing background radiation .
if we assumed the radiative thin limit ( by using a very small cloud size in cloudy ) , it would somewhat decrease the amount of h@xmath0 we predict , and increase the h@xmath1 emission for dense , low - temperature gas .
we discuss the use of different cloud sizes in detail in tb10 , however , in the simulations in this paper we find that using a 10 pc cloud does not significantly change our h@xmath1 flux nor our h@xmath0 column densities because of the higher densities in our tail gas .
this indicates that radiative transfer effects are not that important for this work . to create x - ray surface brightness projections
, we use a spectral lookup table that depends on temperature and density , assuming a constant metallicity of 0.3 solar , as computed using a raymond - smith code ( raymond & smith 1977 ) , as updated in xspec ( arnaud 1996 ) .
the x - ray band we use is 0.5 kev to 2.0 kev , following sun et al .
in this section , we compare our simulated stripped tail to observations of eso 137 - 001 .
we choose an output time at which the x - ray tail length is about 80 kpc in order to match the observations of sun et al .
( 2010 ) ; this time is shown in table [ tbl - runs ] .
we are using this comparison with the observations of eso 137 - 001 to better understand the physics at work in producing x - ray , h@xmath1 , and h@xmath0 tails , so we have not tuned our simulation specifically to find an exact match to the galaxy and tail of eso 137 - 001 . while our icm parameters are similar to those of the icm near eso 137 - 001 , they are not the same .
the final row in table [ tbl - runs ] displays the icm parameters from the observations of sun et al .
we have not attempted to model the exact angle between the galaxy s disk and orbital motion ( woudt et al .
( 2008 ) find a position angle of 125@xmath44 ) , and instead use a face - on wind , and we are using a larger galaxy ( initially our galaxy has a radius of 26 kpc , and in the comparison projections the radius is about 15 kpc , while the 2mass isophotal radius for eso 137 - 001 is 6.1 kpc ( skrutskie et al . 2006 ) ) . in the following comparisons we will take note of the differences between our simulations and the observations of sun et al .
( 2006 ; 2007 ; 2010 ) .
we have chosen the output time at which each simulation has an x - ray tail whose length is about 80 kpc .
this means that the length of time that each galaxy has been stripped in the different simulations is not the same . in table
[ tbl - tempmass ] , we list the amount of gas in the tail in three different temperature ranges .
these masses include all of the gas above 10 kpc from the disk with tracer fractions of at least 25% , so some of the gas included is at low density , as shown in figure [ fig : rhot ] ( too low to be observable ) .
nevertheless , it can be very loosely stated that longer stripping times may result in more mixing of hot gas into the icm , and in more dense gas being stripped and condensing into clouds in the tail .
this can be seen by comparing t80vh or t3vl with t3vh ( of course there are also other differences in the simulations that influence the tail gas , such as cooling floor and icm pressure ) .
however , we stress that in this paper we mainly focus on what causes a tail to be bright in x - ray and h@xmath1 emission , so focus more on icm pressure than the amount of time a galaxy has been stripped ( although we do consider this timescale in our discussion of heat conduction ) .
c | c | c | c run & t @xmath45 10@xmath46 k & 10@xmath46 @xmath45 t @xmath45 10@xmath47 k & 7 @xmath6 10@xmath47 @xmath45 t @xmath45 4 @xmath4810@xmath9 k + & 10@xmath41 m@xmath10 & 10@xmath41 m@xmath10 & 10@xmath41 m@xmath10 + t80vh & 1.4 & 1.6 & 6.0 + t3vh & 1.1 & 1.2 & 9.1 + t3vl & 4.2 & 2.9 & 5.9
+ we first compare the x - ray characteristics of our simulations to observations .
the x - ray surface brightness projections of our runs are shown in figure [ fig : xrayproj ] .
as in sun et al .
( 2006 ; 2010 ) , we measure the x - ray emission between 0.5 - 2.0 kev .
the surface brightness profiles along the tails are in rough agreement with that of eso 137 - 001 , which is bright near the disk and has a second bright region about 40 kpc from the disk before becoming less luminous to the end of the tail .
our model does not reproduce the exact x - ray surface brightness profiles : we do not have a model that includes both the bright emission near the disk and a surface brightness decrease across the entire tail before the second brightness peak .
c | c | c | c | c run or & _
l @xmath6 w _ & l@xmath49 & l@xmath50 corrected@xmath51 & t + observation & ( kpc @xmath6 kpc ) & ( 10@xmath52 erg s@xmath3 ) & ( 10@xmath52 erg s@xmath3 ) & ( 10@xmath9 k ) + t80vh & 80 @xmath6 26 & 66.3 & 4.8 & 2.5 + t3vh & 80 @xmath6 30 & 93.0 & 5.1 & 2.1 + t3vl & 80 @xmath6 30 & 41.9 & 3.6 & 1.4 + sun et al .
2010 & 80 @xmath6 8 , 80 @xmath6 7 & ( 8.3 @xmath53 0.4 ) & ( 8.3 @xmath53 0.4 ) & 0.93 @xmath53 0.05 + to make the x - ray projections , we adopted a minimum observable surface brightness of 7.1 @xmath6 10@xmath54 erg @xmath8 s@xmath3 , which we estimated from the total luminosity of the observed tail and brightness profiles in sun et al .
( 2010 ) ( our cluster background is about 3.6 @xmath6 10@xmath54 erg @xmath8 s@xmath3 ) .
this results in a luminosity difference of an order of magnitude between the lowest and highest surface brightness features in all of our simulated tails , similar to that in the observed tail of eso 137 - 001 .
our tails are narrow and show a nearly constant width along the entire tail , in agreement with the x - ray morphology reported in sun et al .
( 2006 ; 2010 ) .
this is in contrast to simulations that do not include radiative cooling and produce flared tails ( e.g. roediger , brggen & hoeft 2006 ) however , it is clear that we do not have separated x - ray tails as in the observations .
this is not surprising given the explanation of sun et al .
( 2010 ) that the two tails likely result from the stripping of two spiral arms . as we discuss in detail in tb09 , our disks fragment but do not form spiral arms . in table
[ tbl - xtail ] , we list some of the characteristics of our simulated x - ray tails to compare with the observed tail . to calculate the luminosity of the tail , we find the total energy emitted and subtract the background emission from the icm
. as the table demonstrates , the simulated tails are wider , more luminous , and have a higher average ( emission - weighted ) temperature than the ( spectroscopic ) temperature measured by sun et al .
we now address these differences .
the tail is most likely wider because we are modeling a large spiral galaxy , while eso 137 - 001 is thought to be a @xmath5 0.2l@xmath4 galaxy , with a smaller galactic radius ( sun et al .
2006 and references therein ) .
in fact , the entire volume of the tail in any of our three runs is nearly an order of magnitude larger than the tail of eso 137 - 001 ( we assume that the tails are cylindrical with the heights and diameters denoted in table [ tbl - xtail ] ) .
the other difference is that our icm pressure is also somewhat larger than calculated in sun et al .
( 2010 ) by either a factor of 1.47 ( t3vl ) or 2.33 ( t3vh and t80vh ) . these differences in tail volume and icm pressure impact the observables in two ways .
first , as we discuss in tb10 and below , the compression of stripped gas by the icm determines the temperature and density distribution of gas in the tail .
therefore , a higher icm pressure results in higher - density hot gas ( @xmath55 k ) , which will have a higher x - ray emissivity . as we argue in the next section
, this makes the x - ray luminosity proportional to the icm pressure .
second , if we assume that the filling factor of x - ray emitting gas is the same in our simulations as in the tail of eso 137 - 001 , then the total luminosity is also directly proportional to the volume of the entire tail .
the x - ray luminosity after applying these corrections is also shown in table [ tbl - xtail ] ( assuming x - ray luminosity is directly proportional to both the icm pressure and the volume of the tail ) .
when we account for these differences , our measured luminosities are within about a factor of two of the x - ray luminosity of eso 137 - 001 .
as shown in table [ tbl - xtail ] , there is also a factor of two difference between the temperatures of the simulated and observed x - ray tails ; however , this is most likely due to the different ways in which this quantity is determined in simulations as compared to observations .
we use luminosity - weighted temperatures , which tend to be higher than spectroscopic temperatures when there is a range of gas temperatures ( see mazzotta et al .
sun et al .
( 2010 ) discuss how the spectral fitting of the iron - l hump biases their temperatures low if there are significant emission components at _ _
k__t = 0.4 - 2 kev , which is certainly the case in our simulation and in the tail of eso 137 - 001 ( sun et al .
2010 ; sivanandam et al .
therefore , the agreement is probably considerably better than indicated in table [ tbl - xtail ] . in this section
, we examine what lights up an x - ray bright tail , and explain why some observed tails , like eso 137 - 001 , exhibit x - ray emission , while others do not . in figure
[ fig : rhot ] we show the mass - weighted distribution of density and temperature of gas in the wake that originated from the galaxy from our t3vl run ( left ) and from the @xmath26 k run from tb10 using the corrected cooling curve ( right ) .
the plots include all of the gas located between 10 kpc and 240 kpc above the disk that has at least 25% of it s mass originating in the galaxy ( as determined by the tracer fraction ) .
we choose to highlight these two cases because the icm pressure is the only difference between the two simulations ( the thermal pressures differ by a factor of 15 ) . as discussed in more detail in tb10 , the ( @xmath56 k ) gas in the wake
is largely in pressure equilibrium and so falls roughly along a line of constant pressure .
the impact of the higher icm pressure can be seen as a shift to higher density and temperature in the left panel .
+ in red we also plot two contours of constant luminosity per mass ( or emissivity per density ) .
the lower contour is at 10@xmath57 erg s@xmath3 g@xmath3 .
if the minimum observable x - ray surface brightness is 10@xmath58 erg s@xmath3 @xmath8 , then in order for x - ray emission to reach this level , there must be a sufficient amount of gas at or above the red contour .
more precisely , we need a column density of hot gas of 10@xmath59 @xmath8 in order to produce observable emission ( this corresponds to about 10@xmath46 m@xmath10 along a single line of sight through our 38 pc @xmath6 38 pc cells ) . in general ,
only the colder gas ( t @xmath60 10@xmath46 k ) in the tail has these high surface densities ( 10@xmath59 @xmath8 ) , so we also plot an emissivity line which only requires a surface density of 10@xmath7 @xmath8 in order to be observable ( the upper 10@xmath3 erg s@xmath3 g@xmath3 contour ) .
gas that is hot enough to emit x - rays ( hotter than @xmath57 @xmath6 10@xmath47 k ) has this lower surface density in the tail ( 10@xmath7 @xmath8 ) .
this figure shows that gas at higher densities and lower temperatures than the icm ( but above @xmath5 10@xmath40 k ) will be emitting the most strongly in x - rays .
as galactic gas is stripped it either cools into clouds ( @xmath61 k ) or is compressed to the icm pressure and begins to mix with icm gas . while the tail gas is at the high icm pressure but before it is completely mixed with the icm it will be x - ray bright .
the mixing occurs along the line of constant pressure seen in figure [ fig : rhot ] .
the separation between cold clouds and x - ray emitting gas is seen clearly in the left panel of figure [ fig : slices ] , which shows a thin slice from a detailed section above the disk .
the cold clouds are black in this figure , indicating no x - ray emission , while the x - ray emitting gas is not confined to regions close to the dense clouds .
most of the x - ray bright cells in our simulation have between 70% and 90% of their gas originating from the galaxy . in the lower left panel of figure
[ fig : slices ] we show the gas temperature , which when compared with the x - ray slice again highlights that while some mixing and radiative cooling can enhance the x - ray emission , but too much lowers the density of the hot gas to the point where the x - ray emissivity is low .
the x - ray bright gas may have either been stripped as hot gas from the disk and slowly mixed , or stripped from the dense clouds in the tail and mixed into the icm .
next , we turn to h@xmath1 emission , shown in figure [ fig : haproj ] .
the minimum observable surface brightness that we adopt for these maps is 2 @xmath6 10@xmath62 erg s@xmath3 @xmath8 arcsec@xmath57 ( see sun et al .
( 2007 ) and references therein ) .
as described earlier , we use cloudy to determine the h@xmath1 emissivity given a gas temperature and density .
we find , as shown in figure [ fig : haproj ] , highly structured , long tails of h@xmath1 emission .
note that we do not include uv radiation from star formation or agn ( except from the metagalactic background , as described in section [ sec : projection ] ) .
figure [ fig : slices ] shows that h@xmath1 emission peaks around the edges of cold clouds , which can be seen by comparing the upper right panel of h@xmath1 emission with the lower right panel showing gas surface density .
the @xmath63 k and @xmath26 k runs show a similar amount of h@xmath1 emission .
this is because , while the minimum temperature affects the temperature in the central regions of the clouds , it does not strongly affect the cloud edges in the simulation , whose characteristics are more determined by the interaction between the cloud and the icm .
we find that changing the cloud size parameter in our cloudy run has only a small effect on the total h@xmath1 flux ( less than 10% in all three runs ) .
this is because most of our emission is produced by collisional processes rather than photoionization , and so is mostly dependent on the gas temperature , not the optical depth to ionizing photons ( recall that we do include star formation in the simulation and so do not model hii regions within the tail ) .
c | c | c | c run or & _
l @xmath6 w _ & f@xmath64 & f@xmath64 corrected@xmath51 + observation & ( kpc @xmath6 kpc ) & ( erg s@xmath3 @xmath8 ) & ( erg s@xmath3 @xmath8 ) + t80vh & 67 @xmath6 27 & 75.8 & 2.23 + t3vh & 65 @xmath6 29 & 75.9 & 2.00 + t3vl & 80 @xmath6 30 & 97.9 & 1.96 + sun et al .
( 2007 ) & @xmath540 @xmath6 6 & 4.4 & 4.4 + because we do not include star formation , we can not compare our h@xmath1 emission to the 33 h@xmath0 regions seen by sun et al .
we do compare the total flux from our tail to the observed diffuse h@xmath1 emission in table [ tbl - hatail ] .
again , the volume of our diffuse tail is much larger than that observed by sun et al .
( 2007 ) , and we show the corrected h@xmath1 flux by dividing by the volume ratio in the table . the difference in tail widths is from the difference in galaxy sizes , while the length of the observed tail is the minimum length of the diffuse emission because there is a bright star in the field ( sun et al .
2007 ) . when we take the different volumes of the tail into account ,
our simulated h@xmath1 flux is less than that observed from the tail of eso 137 - 001 , but in all three cases , the simulated h@xmath1 flux is within a factor of 2.5 of the observed flux .
there are a number of possible explanations for our slightly lower predicted h@xmath1 flux , including the possibility that some unresolved h@xmath0 regions are counted as diffuse flux in the observations .
other heating sources such as thermal conduction an effect we do not include in the simulations could give rise to more h@xmath1 flux than we see in our simulations .
we also find that numerical resolution plays a role in the total h@xmath1 emission , as we will discuss in section [ sec - resolution ] . in this section
we consider h@xmath0 column density , comparing projections of our simulations to observations . in figure
[ fig : hiproj ] we show the h@xmath0 column density at the best resolution of our simulation . as discussed in section [ sec : projection ] , we use cloudy to determine the neutral fraction given a temperature and density ( with the assumed metagalactic uv flux ) and then apply that value in our projection routine . in figure [
fig : atcav01 ] we only show a projection comparable to the observations performed by vollmer et al .
( 2001 ) , using a resolution of 30 " and a minimum column density of 2 @xmath6 10@xmath7 @xmath8 .
we also correct for the difference in disk sizes by dividing our column densities by a factor of 3 ( the ratio of x - ray tail diameters ) . only the tail of t3vl would have been observed by vollmer et al .
this is because in the slower velocity case there is a smaller velocity difference between the clouds and the icm wind and the icm is slighty less dense ( 83% of the icm density in the higher velocity cases ) , which results in less cloud ablation and more high density gas ( both a slightly higher maximum density of gas and slightly more gas at any particular density above @xmath65 @xmath20 ) .
this difference between the non - detection by vollmer et al .
( 2001c ) and our prediction that t3vl would be detected implies that eso 137 - 001 is most likely moving more quickly through the icm than 1413 km s@xmath3 .
the h@xmath0 column densities in t3vh and t80vh are within a factor of 3 and 1.3 respectively below the maximum column density as determined by the non - detection of vollmer et al .
( 2001 ) .
figure [ fig : slices ] clearly shows that bright h@xmath1 emission is produced only at the edges of dense neutral clouds .
this spatial correspondence between neutral and h@xmath1 emitting gas agrees with the observations of sivanandam et al .
( 2009 ) , who found molecular hydrogen in the tail to the farthest distance they could search20 kpc .
we predict that with a deeper observation h@xmath0 will be observed to at least 40 kpc ( the length of the observed h@xmath1 tail ) , and likely even farther ( our shortest h@xmath0 tail is 65 kpc in t3vh ) , unless heat conduction is quite efficient .
in this section , we comment on the likelihood of finding more x - ray tails . in order for a tail to have observable x - ray emission
, it must be in a high pressure icm .
we can estimate the pressure necessary to produce bright x - ray emission simply by shifting our mass - weighted distribution of gas until the lowest mass contour lies along the upper 10@xmath3 erg s@xmath3 g@xmath3 contour .
we choose this contour because in every simulation we have run , projections of surface density have shown that most of the tail has a column density of at least 10@xmath7 @xmath8 .
gas in the tail with higher surface densities tends to be in cold clouds ( t @xmath45 10@xmath46 k ) ( see tb10 ) , while x - rays are emitted by hot ( t @xmath66 10@xmath40 k ) , diffuse gas with lower column densities ( figure [ fig : rhot ] ) .
this method results in a minimum icm pressure of 9 @xmath6 10@xmath67 erg @xmath20 . in table
[ tbl - clusterrad ] we show the cluster radius at which the icm pressure falls below our minimum value . in general , we calculated the cluster radius using a @xmath68-model and constant temperature from the papers cited in column 3 .
there are three exceptions to this .
first , the x - ray intensity contours in figure 17 of wang et al .
( 2004 ) denote the highest density icm region ( and are not spherically symmetric ) , which is the only region of a2125 with a high enough density to produce our minimum icm pressure for x - ray bright tails .
second , we find the radius of perseus with our minimum icm pressure directly from figure 9 in ettori et al .
finally , we use the entropy measurements of cavagnolo et al .
( 2009 ) to find that as close as 100 kpc from m87 the icm pressure is below 9 @xmath6 10@xmath67 erg @xmath20 . note that these are first estimates generally using spherically symmetric cluster profiles , which oversimplify the structure of the icm .
we can now comment on whether observed x - ray tails are in high pressure icms ( defined here as at or above 9 @xmath6 10@xmath67 dyn @xmath8 ) .
the two x - ray tails in a3627 , eso 137 - 001 and eso 137 - 002 , are both within the high pressure icm ( sun et al . 2007 ; sun et al .
. however , sun et al . (
2010 ) find that using their spectroscopic temperatures , the tail gas is over - pressured with respect to the icm .
this might indicate that the spectroscopic temperature does not correctly model the tail temperature .
we find that turbulent pressure is not strong enough to greatly increase the gas pressure in the tail ( figure [ fig : rhot ] and tb10 ) .
c153 is near the x - ray peak of a2125 ( wang et al .
ugc 6697 in a1367 is at least 450 kpc from the x - ray peak of the cluster , outside of our calculated high - pressure radius .
however , it is near an infalling subcluster and in a higher - density icm than predicted using the @xmath68-model centered on the x - ray peak of a1367 .
using the fit to the subcluster by donnelly et al .
( 1998 ) , sun & vikhlinin ( 2005 ) calculated the surrounding pressure to be 7.9 @xmath6 10@xmath67 dyn @xmath8 , very close to our minimum pressure for observable x - ray emission .
c | c | c cluster & outer radius ( kpc ) & reference + a3627 & 250 _ h@xmath69 _ & bohringer et al .
( 1996 ) ; + & & sun et al .
( 2010 ) + a2125 & 28.5 - 89 _ h@xmath70 _ & wang et al .
( 2004 ) + a1367 & 274 _ h@xmath69 _ & mohr et al .
( 1999 ) + cl 0024 + 0016 & 250 _ h@xmath71 _ & zhang et al .
( 2005 ) + coma & 613 _ h@xmath69 _ & briel et al .
( 1992 ) + perseus & 2000 _ h@xmath69 _ & ettori et al . (
1998 ) + virgo ( m87 ) & @xmath45 100 _ h@xmath71 _ & cavagnolo et al .
( 2009 ) + heat conduction , which we do not include in these simulations , could be important for the survival of cool clouds in the icm and h@xmath1 emission ; however , it can be suppressed by magnetic fields ( e.g. vollmer et al .
if it is an efficient way to transport heat from the icm to cold , stripped gas , then the survival time of h@xmath0 clouds would be less than predicted in this paper , and the length of the tails would be shorter .
we can estimate the efficiency of heat conduction by comparing an analytic calculation of the evaporation time of the most dense clouds in our simulations to the length of time we expect clouds have survived in order to produce the observations of eso 137 - 001 .
first , we estimate the evaporation time for a typical cloud if heat conduction is not suppressed , and we will define this calculated evaporation time as the time for cloud evaporation if heat conduction is 100% efficient .
we follow cowie & mckee ( 1977 ) , as in vollmer et al .
( 2001 ) . in our clouds , we find that the mean free path for ions is comparable to or greater than the temperature scale length , so we need to use the saturated heat flux equations .
evaporation time is proportional to @xmath72 @xmath73 , where @xmath74 is the conduction efficiency relative to spitzer . solving for the evaporation time for each of our three runs , we find that using a cloud radius of 100 pc , and the maximum gas density in our tails at the time of our comparison , the evaporation times of our three runs are @xmath75 myr for t80vh , @xmath76 myr for t3vh , and @xmath77 myr for t3vl .
we choose to use the highest density found in our tails because we want to calculate the longest plausible evaporation time in order to find the most conservative estimates for the maximum efficiency of heat conduction .
the @xmath78 k runs have a maximum density in their tails of 2 @xmath6 10@xmath79 g @xmath20 and t80vh has a maximum density of 10@xmath79 g @xmath20 .
we have shown that diffuse h@xmath1 emission directly traces neutral clouds ( figure [ fig : slices ] ) , which means that the dense clouds must not be entirely evaporated before they reach 40 kpc above the disk .
we are also able to measure the velocity of gas in our tails ( see tb10 for details ) , so can estimate the time it would take for a cloud to reach 40 kpc above the disk .
we use generous estimates of 1200 km s@xmath3 for the high velocity cases and 900 km s@xmath3 for the lower velocity run in order to calculate the shortest time it would take these clouds to reach 40 kpc above the disk ( which will maximize the value we find for the efficiency of heat conduction ) .
therefore , the efficiency of heat conduction must be less than 24% ( t3vl and t3vh ) , or 12%(t80vh ) . once there is a deep observation of the h@xmath0 tail
, we will be able to compare the length of eso 137 - 001 s tail to the lengths of our simulated tails to find a _ minimum _
efficiency of heat conduction . to do this
we will use a similar argument to the one above ; namely , compare the amount of time a cloud takes to reach its height above the disk to the evaporation time , assuming that heat conduction is responsible for destroying the clouds .
it is important to consider our simulations in this calculation , because they show that even without heat conduction , h@xmath0 may not extend along the entire length of the x - ray tail .
the simulations also show the limitations of using a simple velocity and distance argument to calculate the length of time a galaxy has been stripped using 900 km s@xmath3 and the length of the h@xmath0 tail we find that the galaxy in t3vl has been stripped for 87 myr , while the actual time after the wind has hit the galaxy is 110 myr .
the high velocity cases have an even larger discrepancy between the actual stripping time and the time calculated using the h@xmath0 tail length .
despite these caveats , we can make a very rough first estimate using figure [ fig : atcav01 ] ( t3vl ) and the non - detection result of vollmer et al .
the h@xmath0 in our smoothed projection begins about 50 kpc above the disk .
if the non - detection of vollmer et al .
( 2001 ) means that there are no neutral clouds at this height above the disk , then we can calculate a minimum efficiency for heat conduction , which is 18.5% .
however , as we discussed above , we expect that a deeper observation will find h@xmath0 beyond this height above the disk .
as noted earlier , we used two different values for our radiative cooling floor ( 8000 k and 300 k ) in order to explore in a simple way the potential impact of processes which we do not include in the simulation .
we discuss the physical motivations for the two cooling floors in tb10 .
we find that the change in the minimum temperature makes only a relatively minor change in the morphology of the flow , and does nt significantly change the resulting length of the tail .
this also translates into only a relatively small difference in the predicted observables , with changes of less than 30% in both x - ray and h@xmath1 luminosities .
k run predicted lower h@xmath1 emission by more than an order of magnitude .
this incorrect conclusion was reached because of the cooling curve error for that run discussed in section [ sec - methodology ] . ]
the biggest difference is in the survival of h@xmath0 clouds , with @xmath26 k predicting longer lived clouds .
still , the impact on h@xmath0 observations is quite small . the ratios of the three observables is also quite constant , generally to within 30% , as can be see from an inspection of the right two panels of figures [ fig : xrayproj ] , [ fig : haproj ] , and [ fig : hiproj ] , and from tables [ tbl - xtail ] and [ tbl - hatail ] .
resolution is most likely to affect the survival and structure of our dense clouds in the tail .
the most direct results would be different amounts of neutral gas and h@xmath1 emission .
a number of examinations of the survival of clouds with a variety of physics included have been performed .
mellema et al .
( 2002 ) and yirak et al .
( 2009 ) include radiative cooling .
fragile et al .
( 2004 ) also discuss how including self - gravity increases the lifetime of clouds .
nakamura et al . ( 2006 ) discuss the impact of using smooth cloud boundaries on the growth of instabilities .
they ( and yirak et al .
2009 ) find that a low density gradient results in slower growth of instabilities , which can retard cloud destruction .
our most dense clouds have an analytically calculated destruction timescale due to turbulent viscous stripping ( using eq .
( 22 ) in nulsen 1982 ) of more than 1 gyr , so resolution should not have a large impact over the timescales we consider in these simulations .
we use the same cloud parameters as in the evaporation time calculation , although even with an order of magnitude lower density clouds ( @xmath5 10@xmath80 g @xmath20 ) , the destruction timescale is still about 200 myr , which is much longer than the time at which we make our projections .
we use a relative velocity difference of 400 km s@xmath3 ( although we do not show velocity plots in this paper , see tb10 for a detailed discussion of the tail velocity )
. however , lower density clouds in our simulated tails cool and are compressed by the icm , which may instead be destroyed by the icm wind if we had better resolution that resulted in a steeper density gradient at the cloud edge .
although we do not perform a detailed resolution study of the runs in this paper , we do compare t3vl to a run with only 5 allowed levels of refinement , to a minimum cell size of 76 pc , a factor of two worse in resolution .
we compare outputs with the same amount of gas stripped from the galaxy .
the total x - ray luminosity of the lower resolution tail is @xmath590% of the luminosity of t3vl ( i.e. only a 10% change ) , while the total h@xmath1 flux is only 28% of t3vl .
the total hi flux is also decreased by a similar amount ( to 33% of the value in t3vl ) .
for both resolutions , there is a good correspondence between the relative hi and h@xmath1 level and morphology ; therefore , we argue that the ratio of hi to h@xmath1 is more robust than the absolute level of either .
both the small discrepancy in the x - ray luminosity and larger discrepancy in the h@xmath1 flux can be explained by considering what gas is producing the emission .
x - ray emission is produced by gas that is mixed with the icm and is not localized near the dense clouds in the tail , and so is not very dependent on high resolution .
one explanation for the slightly lower x - ray luminosity is that mixing happens more quickly and the gas is heated out of the x - ray bright regime . unlike the diffuse nature of the x - ray emitting gas
, h@xmath1 emission occurs at the edges of clouds .
we find that in projection the range of h@xmath1 intensities is the same as t3vl , meaning that the different resolution element size does not strongly affect the density and temperature at the edges of the dense clouds ( and therefore does not strongly affect the h@xmath1 emission ) .
the main difference is that there are fewer dense clouds in the less - resolved wind .
in fact , the total h@xmath0 column density in the low resolution tail is about 30% of the total h@xmath0 column density in t3vl very similar to the h@xmath1 flux fraction . in projection , there are about half as many pixels with h@xmath0 column densities over 10@xmath81 @xmath8 .
since we expect the total h@xmath0 column density to also depend on the number of clouds along the line of sight of the projection , we find that there should be roughly 26% as many clouds ( by simply squaring the 51% we find in the projection plane ) .
of course , clouds are more than a single pixel , so this is a rough approximation .
however , this indicates that the amount of h@xmath1 emission closely follows the amount of h@xmath0 column density , and likely the number of h@xmath0 clouds .
there are fewer h@xmath0 clouds in the low resolution run because with lower resolution the maximum density is lower and therefore the clouds are destroyed and mixed more quickly into the icm .
deep , high resolution observations in h@xmath0 will allow us to determine how many and for how long dense clouds survive , which will point to one of these mixing scenarios .
we have run detailed galaxy simulations including radiative cooling and made comparisons to the observed tail of eso 137 - 001 to understand the physical mechanisms at work in the icm .
we compare three cases in which we vary our cooling floor between 8,000 k or 300 k and the icm parameters as shown in table [ tbl - runs ] .
our main conclusions are as follows : \1 ) the x - ray luminosity of our simulated tails are an excellent match to the x - ray luminosity of the tail of eso 137 - 001 .
this suggests that we are correctly modeling the phase distribution of gas in the tail , and that the mixing of the hotter stripped ism ( t @xmath66 10@xmath47 k ) is being accurately modeled in the simulations .
\2 ) we find that bright x - ray emission depends upon a high surrounding icm pressure , and find a minimum necessary pressure of 9 @xmath6 10@xmath67 erg @xmath20 .
this conclusion agrees well with the local environment in clusters where bright x - ray tails are observed .
\4 ) we predict that deeper observations will find h@xmath0 gas to at least 40 kpc above the disk , because diffuse h@xmath1 emission directly traces neutral clouds ( and has been observed to 40 kpc above the disk ) .
the observations of molecular hydrogen by sivanandam et al .
( 2009 ) strengthen this prediction .
we also conclude that the mismatch between t3vl and vollmer et al .
( 2001 ) indicates that the higher velocity cases better match the observations .
\5 ) using the fact that h@xmath1 traces neutral gas and calculating the evaporation times of our simulated clouds ( based on their sizes and densities ) , we calculated a maximum efficiency for heat conduction of 24% ( t3vh and t3vl ) or 12% ( t80vh ) . by modeling a simulation using a high icm pressure ,
we have shown that x - ray emission can coexist with h@xmath0 and h@xmath1 emission .
we have also found that h@xmath0 and h@xmath1 emission spatially coincide because h@xmath1 is mostly produced at the edges of neutral clouds ( figure [ fig : slices ] ) , while x - ray emission is generated in hot , diffuse gas that is mixing with the icm .
this is seen by the more even distribution in the tail ( figures [ fig : xrayproj ] and [ fig : slices ] ) , and by the fact that the x - ray tail can be longer than the h@xmath0 and h@xmath1 tails .
our excellent agreement with x - ray observations gives us confidence that we are correctly modeling the mixing , cooling and heating rate of x - ray emitting gas .
this in turn means that heat conduction is not acting strongly to heat the diffuse gas in the tail , and that small scale turbulence ( below our resolution scale ) is not quickly mixing stripped gas .
both of these mechanisms would act to heat the gas in the tail out of the x - ray bright range and therefore lower the total luminosity , which would make our agreement to the observations worse .
we can not rule out the possibility that we have less gas mass at higher emissivities than in eso 137 - 001 .
we also find excellent agreement between our simulated h@xmath1 flux and observations of diffuse h@xmath1 emission .
we robustly conclude that diffuse h@xmath1 emission coincides with h@xmath0 gas , and we find that h@xmath1 emission outlines h@xmath0 clouds in all of our simulations .
the agreement between the total h@xmath1 emission in our cases with different cooling floors underscores the fact that the edges of clouds , which are interacting with the icm , emit the most strongly in h@xmath1 , not the central regions of the clouds , which are more likely to have radiatively cooled to the minimum allowed temperature .
although our agreement with observations indicates that we may also be correctly modeling the edges of dense clouds , we can not dismiss the possibility that we are not fully resolving the cloud edges . in section [ sec - resolution ]
we discuss how lower resolution results in fewer h@xmath0 clouds , and less h@xmath1 emission .
therefore , we can not rule out that properties of our simulations that have not converged at our current resolution the number of clouds , the rate of the decline of density at the edge of the cloud and the smallest scale of turbulent heating have combined with the lack of heat conduction in our simulations to result in an accidental , and incorrect , agreement with observations .
observations of h@xmath0 in the tail will provide an important check to these results .
this work highlights the importance of comparing simulations to detailed , multi - wavelength observations of individual systems .
we are able to make predictions about this particular galaxy , such as the existence of h@xmath0 gas in the tail and that its three - dimensional velocity relative to the icm is probably larger than 1413 km s@xmath3 .
however , our simulation is not able to make any prediction about why there is a separated tail in eso 137 - 001 .
we also do not reproduce the exact surface brightness distribution along the x - ray tail .
as we have discussed , our goal was not to reproduce this specific tail . in order to do this , we would recommend modeling a smaller galaxy and matching the inclination angle between the galaxy and the icm wind .
using our comparison with the observations of eso 137 - 001 , we also draw more general conclusions about the importance of turbulence and the efficiency of heat conduction in the icm .
we conclude that the mixing rate of the hot stripped ism ( t @xmath66 10@xmath47 k ) is well - modeled in our simulations using only adiabatic compression and turbulent mixing down to the resolution of our simulations ( 38 pc ) .
we call upon observers to test our predictions of where in clusters tails will be x - ray bright , and to use deep observations to verify the connection between h@xmath1 and h@xmath0 gas
. observations of the h@xmath0 tail of eso 137 - 001 can be used to test mixing of cold clouds into the icm in our simulations .
we acknowledge support from nsf grants ast-0547823 , ast-0908390 , and ast-1008134 , as well as computational resources from the national center for supercomputing applications , nsf teragrid , and columbia university s hotfoot cluster .
we thank jacqueline van gorkom , jeffrey kenney and the referee bernd vollmer for useful discussions , as well as elizabeth tasker for invaluable help setting up the initial conditions . | some tails of ram - pressure stripped galaxies are detected in h@xmath0 , some in h@xmath1 , and some in x - ray ( but never all three so far ) .
we use numerical simulations to probe the conditions for the production of x - ray bright tails , demonstrating that the primary requirement is a high pressure intracluster medium ( icm ) .
this is because the stripped tail is mostly in pressure equilibrium with the icm , but mixing leaves it with densities and temperatures intermediate between the cold gas in the disk and the hot icm . given a high enough icm pressure , this mixed gas lies in the x - ray bright region of the phase diagram .
we compare the simulations to observations of the ram pressure stripped tail of eso 137 - 001 , showing excellent agreement in the total measured x - ray and h@xmath1 emission and non - flaring morphology of the tail , and consistent h@xmath0 measurements . using these comparisons
we constrain the level of mixing and efficiency of heat conduction in the intracluster medium ( icm ) . |
chiral perturbation theory ( chpt ) provides a means of implementing , in the most general way , the constraints on low - energy processes of the symmetries of qcd @xcite .
the effects of resonances , and other heavy degrees of freedom , are encoded in the low - energy constants ( lecs ) which appear in the resulting effective chiral lagrangian multiplying those operators allowed by these constraints . in the even - intrinsic - parity sector , at next - to - leading order ( nlo ) in the chiral counting , the @xmath8 lagrangian involves @xmath9 in - principle - measurable lecs , the @xmath10 introduced in ref .
the next - to - next - to - leading order ( nnlo ) form was first considered in ref .
@xcite , and a reduced minimal set of operators subsequently found in refs .
the minimal nnlo @xmath3 form involves @xmath11 additional lecs , @xmath12 in contact and @xmath13 in non - contact terms . in what follows
, we work with the dimensionful versions , @xmath14 , of the nnlo lecs introduced in refs .
@xcite . to make the nnlo chiral lagrangian fully predictive
, existing determinations of the @xmath10 must be supplemented with model - independent experimental and/or theoretical determinations of the @xmath14 . to date
a limited number of such determinations exist .
first attempts at obtaining what is now called @xmath15 were made in refs .
@xcite , with a more robust chiral sum rule determination , involving the flavor - breaking ( fb ) @xmath1-@xmath2 vector current correlator , obtained in ref .
@xcite . @xmath16 and the combination @xmath17 were determined via phenomenological @xcite and lattice @xcite analyses of the scalar @xmath18 form factor , and @xmath19 and @xmath20 from analyses of the quark - mass - dependence of lattice data for @xmath21 @xcite ( some aspects of these latter analyses employing , in addition , large-@xmath22 arguments ) .
generally less precise constraints on the combinations @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 were obtained from analyses of the charged @xmath26 and @xmath27 electromagnetic form factors @xcite , and on the combinations @xmath28 , @xmath29 and @xmath30 from analyses of the curvature of the @xmath26 and strangeness - changing @xmath18 scalar form factors @xcite . an overconstrained ( but , with current data , not yet fully self - consistent ) determination of the set @xmath31
was also made @xcite , using a combination of four of the subthreshold coefficients of the @xmath32 scattering amplitudes determined in ref .
@xcite and two of the low - energy @xmath33 scattering parameters determined in ref
. @xcite .
the four remaining @xmath33 scattering parameters and six remaining @xmath32 subthreshold coefficients provide ten additional constraints on the @xmath34 nnlo lecs @xmath35 and @xmath36 @xcite . finally , @xmath37 has been determined from analyses of the light - quark v - a current - current correlator @xcite . in the absence of clean theoretical and/or data - based determinations , it is common to use estimates of the @xmath14 obtained in model - dependent approaches .
one such strategy is to extend the resonance chpt ( rchpt ) approach @xcite ( often held to work well in estimating nlo lecs @xcite ) to nnlo @xcite .
this approach typically employs , in addition to long - distance chiral constraints , short - distance qcd and large-@xmath22 constraints .
evidence exists that at least some @xmath38-suppressed lecs can not be neglected @xcite ( we will comment below on another such piece of evidence ) . a second approach to estimating the @xmath14 , in a large-@xmath22 gauge - invariant non - local quark model framework , was presented in ref .
comparisons performed in refs .
@xcite between predicted @xmath14 values and those known from experiment expose some shortcomings in both approaches . in light of this situation ,
additional model - independent nnlo lec determinations are of interest , first as part of the ongoing long - term program of pinning down the parameters of the low - energy effective lagrangian , and second , as a means of further testing , and constraining , models used to estimate additional as - yet - undetermined lecs . in this paper , we update the earlier determination of @xmath15 @xcite and provide a new high - precision determination of the combination @xmath39 . with input for @xmath16 from other sources ( such as those noted above ) this yields also a determination of @xmath40 . a direct determination of the combination @xmath41 which , with the @xmath38-suppressed combination @xmath42 , is needed to complete the determination of the nlo lec @xmath43 from an nnlo analysis of the low - energy behavior of the light quark v - a correlator @xcite is also obtained . combining this determination with the continuum light - quark v - a correlator analysis of ref .
@xcite and lattice analysis of ref .
@xcite turns out to make possible a high - precision ( @xmath44 ) determination of @xmath43 .
this level of precision requires careful consideration of the lec combination @xmath42 which , though nominally subleading in @xmath38 , turns out to have a non - zero value comparable to that of the non-@xmath38-suppressed combination @xmath45 ( although with large errors ) @xcite .
this non - zero value has a non - trivial impact on the determination of @xmath43 , shifting the magnitude of the result by @xmath46 compared to what is obtained if @xmath42 is instead set to zero on the grounds of its @xmath38 suppression @xcite .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in section [ imsr ] ,
we introduce , and give the explicit forms of , the chiral sum rules to be employed . in section [ input ]
the experimental , nlo lec , and ope inputs to these sum rules are specified .
section [ results ] contains the results and a comparison to model predictions for the lec combinations in question .
section [ summary ] , finally , contains a brief summary .
details of the ope contributions and errors are gathered in an appendix .
the key objects for the analysis described in this paper are the flavor @xmath47 vector ( @xmath48 ) and axial vector ( @xmath49 ) current - current two - point functions , @xmath50 , and their spin @xmath51 components , @xmath52 .
these are defined by @xmath53 where @xmath54 are the standard flavor @xmath55 @xmath56 currents , and @xmath57 .
@xmath58 individually have kinematic singularities at @xmath59 , but their sum , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 are both kinematic - singularity - free .
the associated spectral functions , @xmath62 , are accessible experimentally through the normalized differential distributions , @xmath63 , @xmath64/ \gamma [ \tau^- \rightarrow \nu_\tau e^- { \bar \nu}_e ( \gamma)]\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] measured in flavor @xmath55 @xmath48- or @xmath49-current - induced hadronic @xmath0 decays .
explicitly @xcite @xmath65\ , \label{basictaudecay}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 a known short - distance electroweak correction @xcite , and @xmath70 the flavor @xmath55 ckm matrix element .
the dominant contributions to @xmath71 are the accurately known , chirally unsuppressed , @xmath26 and @xmath27 pole terms .
the remaining @xmath72 @xmath56 spectral contributions are proportional to @xmath73 , hence numerically negligible for @xmath74 .
@xmath75 is thus determinable directly from the non - strange differential decay distribution . for @xmath76 ,
phenomenological determinations strongly constrained by the known strange quark mass are available for the small continuum scalar @xmath77 @xcite and pseudoscalar @xmath78 @xcite contributions in the region @xmath79 relevant to hadronic @xmath0 decays . with the contributions proportional to @xmath80 in eq .
( [ basictaudecay ] ) thus fixed , @xmath81 can be determined from the strange differential decay distribution .
the @xmath56 separation for the @xmath1 and @xmath2 cases will be discussed further in the next section .
the contour underlying the chiral sum rules of eq .
( [ imsrbasic]),width=192 ] given a correlator , @xmath82 , free of kinematic singularities , and the corresponding spectral function , @xmath83 , application of cauchy s theorem to the contour shown in fig .
[ f1 ] yields the inverse moment ( chiral ) finite energy sum rule ( imfesr ) relation , valid for any choice of weight function , @xmath84 , analytic in the region of the contour , @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the relevant physical threshold
. we will work below with values of @xmath87 and fb correlator combinations , @xmath88 , such that the @xmath83 needed on the rhs are accessible from hadronic @xmath0-decay data .
a determination of the combination of lecs occurring in the chiral representation of @xmath89 is then obtained by inputting the chiral representation on the lhs and evaluating both terms on the rhs . for large enough @xmath87 ,
the first term on the rhs can be evaluated using the ope representation of @xmath88 , while , for @xmath90 , the second term can be evaluated using experimental spectral data .
previous sum rule studies have , however , found that , even for @xmath91 , integrated duality violations ( ope breakdown ) can be sizeable for @xmath84 which are not zero at the timelike point @xmath92 on the contour @xcite .
we thus further restrict our attention to @xmath84 satisfying @xmath93 .
we will consider two choices for the weight @xmath94 , @xmath95 : @xmath96 \ , \nonumber\\ \hat{w}(y)&=&(1-y)^3 \ . \label{weightdefns}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first of these was considered in ref .
both weights satisfy @xmath97 and are `` triply pinched '' ( _ i.e. _ , have a triple zero at @xmath92 ) , strongly suppressing duality violating contributions to the first term on the rhs of eq .
( [ imsrbasic ] ) . an additional advantage of the triple zero is the suppression of contributions to the weighted spectral integrals ( the second term on the rhs of eq .
( [ imsrbasic ] ) ) from the high-@xmath98 part of the spectral functions , where the @xmath2 data currently available suffers from low statistics and large @xmath56 separation uncertainties @xcite .
the strong suppression at large @xmath98 for these weights is thus doubly beneficial to the goal of this article , which is to determine as accurately as possible the lhss , @xmath99 , of eq .
( [ imsrbasic ] ) for various fb combinations , @xmath100 , of the @xmath1 and @xmath2 @xmath48 and @xmath49 correlators ( see eq .
( [ deltapidefns ] ) below ) . from the non - fb @xmath1 @xmath48 and @xmath49 correlators .
the need for high ( @xmath101 or less ) precision on the theoretical side of the sum rules employed in that case favors a restriction to weights of lower degree , which minimize the number of @xmath102 ope condensates that need to be fit to data , but have less pinching than those in the present case . as the level of pinching decreases ,
the possibility for significant integrated duality violations increases . as explained in detail in ref .
@xcite , the inclusion of unpinched weights in that analysis allowed for the modelling and constraining of these contributions , providing a means for investigating quantitatively the level of integrated duality violation not only in that case but also in earlier pinched - weight analyses . here
, the situation is different , as the use of triply pinched polynomials @xmath94 in the full weights , @xmath103 , used to access the low-@xmath98 physics of interest to us , not only strongly suppresses duality violating contributions , as already noted above , but also significantly reduces the errors on the weighted @xmath2 spectral integrals .
the additional @xmath104 factor in the weights further helps by reducing the maximum dimension of ope condensates which have to be considered in the analysis .
the final important difference between the present case and that of the @xmath105 analysis is the precision required for the ope contributions . here
, ope contributions turn out to play a smaller numerical role , greatly reducing the level of precision required for the evaluation of these contributions . ]
the value of @xmath106 in eq .
( [ imsrbasic ] ) should , of course , be independent both of @xmath87 and the choice of weight , @xmath84 .
verifying that these independences are in fact realized provides non - trivial tests of the self - consistency of the theoretical and spectral input to the analysis . in the rest of the paper , we concentrate on imfesrs involving one of the three choices , @xmath107 , @xmath108 , of the fb @xmath109 combinations of @xmath110 @xmath48 and @xmath49 correlators , @xmath111 the corresponding spectral functions
are denoted @xmath112 .
versions of the @xmath113 correlator and spectral - function combinations having their @xmath26 and @xmath27 pole contributions subtracted will be denoted by @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
the restriction to the @xmath110 combination is predicated on the very bad behavior of the ope representation of @xmath116 on the contour @xmath117 for all @xmath87 accessible using @xmath0 decay data @xcite .
it is worth commenting on the differences in the ope contributions for the two weights @xmath118 and @xmath119 .
we focus here on @xmath120 contributions ( @xmath121 contributions will be discussed in more detail later , as will @xmath122 contributions higher order in @xmath105 ) . for a general polynomial @xmath123 , writing @xmath124^{ope}_{d\ge 4}$ ] in the form @xmath125 , with @xmath126 an effective dimension-@xmath127 condensate , the integrated @xmath120 ope contributions to the rhs of eq .
( [ imsrbasic ] ) become @xmath128^{ope}_{d\ge 4}=\sum_{k\ge 2}(-1)^ka_k\ , \frac{c^t_{2k}}{s_0^k}\ , \label{higerdopeint}\ ] ] up to logarithmic corrections suppressed by additional powers of @xmath105 . since @xmath119 has degree three , only ope contributions up to @xmath129 contribute , if we ignore the @xmath105-suppressed logarithmic corrections . in contrast , @xmath118 , which has degree five , produces contributions at leading order in @xmath105 up to @xmath130 . in this sense
, @xmath119 is preferred over @xmath118 , since the latter involves additional unknown or poorly known @xmath131 and @xmath130 condensates . for @xmath118 ,
these contributions are expected to be small , partly because the coefficients @xmath132 , @xmath133 are small enough to avoid unwanted enhancements , and partly because of the @xmath134 suppression of such higher @xmath127 contributions for @xmath135 , but this expectation can ( and should ) be tested .
performing the imfesr analysis for a range of @xmath87 provides a means of doing so and , in fact , provides a test of the reliability of any approximations employed in evaluating the rhs , including also the neglect of integrated duality violations .
the @xmath87 dependence of the rhs of eq .
( [ imsrbasic ] ) will be considered for the combinations of eq .
( [ deltapidefns ] ) for both weights in sec . [ results ] below .
an advantage of the weight @xmath118 over @xmath119 is that the @xmath136 contributions to the integral in eq .
( [ higerdopeint ] ) are better behaved for @xmath118 .
in addition , as can be seen from eq .
( [ higerdopeint ] ) , since @xmath137 , the leading - order @xmath122 contribution , and associated error , are both a factor of @xmath138 larger for @xmath119 .
analogous , though somewhat smaller , enhancement factors , @xmath139 and @xmath140 are operative for the leading order @xmath119 @xmath121 and @xmath129 contributions and errors . @xmath136 and @xmath141 contributions , and hence total ope errors , are thus significantly larger for @xmath119 than for @xmath118 from this effect alone .
the nominal convergence of the known terms in the integrated @xmath121 ope series is also significantly slower for @xmath119 .
the larger ope errors turn out to produce total errors for @xmath119 which are similar to those for @xmath118 ( _ cf_. table [ table2 ] in sec .
[ results ] ) .
the differences in the relative sizes of spectral integral and ope contributions to the rhss of the @xmath118 and @xmath119 imfesrs also means that the tests of self - consistency provided by the agreement of the results of the two analyses are indeed non - trivial . below
, the magnitude of the @xmath129 contributions will be estimated using the vacuum saturation approximation ( vsa ) with very generous errors , and @xmath131 and @xmath130 contributions will be assumed negligible . and
@xmath142 condensates @xmath143 for the @xmath1 @xmath48 and @xmath49 correlators can be used to evaluate the @xmath1 contributions to the fb @xmath144 differences .
these results will be used as a very conservative bound for the corresponding fb combinations . ]
the fact that higher @xmath127 contributions vary more strongly with @xmath87 than do integrated lower dimension @xmath136 contributions means that these assumptions can also be tested , provided a range of @xmath87 is employed in the analysis .
as already emphasized above , such @xmath87-stability tests play an important role in all such sum - rule analyses . for @xmath113 , @xmath26 and @xmath27 pole contributions
appear on both sides of eq .
( [ imsrbasic ] ) .
the lecs of interest in these cases , in fact , appear only in the pole - subtracted parts , @xmath114 , of the @xmath145 , and it is thus convenient to move all the pole contributions to the corresponding rhss . with @xmath146 , the three imfesrs of interest ,
for @xmath147 or @xmath148 , then take the form @xmath149^{ope}\ , + \ , \int_{th}^{s_0}ds\ , { \frac{w(s)}{s}}\,\delta{\rho}_v(s)\ , \label{dkvsr}\\ \delta\overline{\pi}_{v\pm a}(0 ) & & = { \frac{1}{2\pi i}}\,\oint_{\vert s\vert = s_0 } ds\ , { \frac{w(s)}{s}}\ , \left[\delta\pi_{v\pm a } ( q^2)\right]^{ope}\ , + \ , \int_{th}^{s_0}ds\ , { \frac{w(s)}{s}}\,\delta\overline{\rho}_{v\pm a}(s ) \nonumber\\ & & \ \ \ \ \
\pm \left[{\frac{f_k^2}{s_0}}\ , f^w_{res}(y_k)\ , -\ , { \frac{f_\pi^2}{s_0}}\ , f^w_{res}(y_\pi ) \right]\ , \label{vpmaimsralt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , owing to the pole subtraction , @xmath86 is now the continuum threshold @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 , @xmath153 and @xmath154 .
the normalization of the decay constants is such that @xmath155 mev .
note that it is the full correlators @xmath145 , including the @xmath26/@xmath27 pole contributions , which occur in the first term of the rhs of eq .
( [ vpmaimsralt ] ) .
we discuss the inputs to the rhss of eqs .
( [ dkvsr ] ) and ( [ vpmaimsralt ] ) in the next section .
we conclude this section with the nnlo low - energy representations of the lhss of eqs .
( [ dkvsr ] ) and ( [ vpmaimsralt ] ) .
the general structure of these representations is @xmath156_{lec}$ ] , with @xmath157_{lec}\ , = \ , \sum_{k=5,9,10}c^t_k l^r_k\ , + \
, 32(m_k^2-m_\pi^2)\ , \sum_{k=12,61,80 } a^t_k c^r_k\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath158 , the nlo lecs @xmath159 and the nnlo lecs @xmath160 all depending on the chiral renormalization scale @xmath161 .
the @xmath158 combine all one- and two - loop contributions involving only lo vertices , and are completely fixed by the pseudoscalar meson masses , decay constants and @xmath161 .
their forms are rather lengthy ( especially for the @xmath113 cases ) and hence not presented here .
they can be reconstructed from the results of sections 4 , 6 and appendix b of ref .
nlo contributions proportional to the @xmath162 cancel in the fb combinations considered here .
the coefficients @xmath163 are generated by one - loop graphs with a single nlo vertex , and thus also @xmath161-dependent . the @xmath164 are , in contrast , @xmath161-independent at this order . fixing the chiral scale @xmath161 to the conventional scale choice @xmath165 gev ,
the explicit forms of the @xmath166_{lec}$ ] become @xmath167_{lec}\ , = \ , -0.7218\ , l_5^r\ , + \ , 1.423\ , l_9^r\ , + \ , 1.062\ , l_{10}^r % \nonumber\\&&\qquad\qquad\qquad \ , + \ , 32(m_k^2-m_\pi^2)c_{61}^r\ , \nonumber\\ & & \left[\delta{\overline{\pi}}_{v+a}(0)\right]_{lec}\ , = \ ,
-0.7218\ , l_5^r\ , + \ , 1.423\ , l_9^r % \nonumber\\&&\qquad\qquad\qquad \ , + \ , 32(m_k^2-m_\pi^2)\left [ c_{12}^r+c_{61}^r + c_{80}^r\right]\ , \nonumber\\ & & \left[\delta{\overline{\pi}}_{v - a}(0)\right]_{lec}\ , = \
, -0.7218\ , l_5^r\ , + \ , 1.423\ , l_9^r\ , + \ , 2.125\ , l_{10}^r\nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad -\ , 32(m_k^2-m_\pi^2)\left [ c_{12}^r - c_{61}^r + c_{80}^r\right]\ , \label{nlonnlolectermcontributions}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the renormalized lecs are all understood to be evaluated at @xmath168 , and @xmath169 and @xmath170
have been taken to be the charged pion mass and , for definiteness , the average of the charged and neutral kaon masses .
( taking instead @xmath170 to be the charged @xmath27 mass has no impact on our final results . )
the corresponding values for the lec - independent @xmath171 contributions are @xmath172
pdg 2012 values @xcite are used for @xmath175 , @xmath169 , @xmath170 and @xmath176 ( the latter is required in evaluating some of the nnlo contributions ) .
explicitly , @xmath177 mev , @xmath178 mev and @xmath179 mev , the latter being the average of the charged and neutral masses . for the normalization used here , @xmath180
mev @xcite .
@xmath181 is obtained by combining this value with the current flag assessment of @xmath182 lattice results , @xmath183 @xcite .
the nnlo representation of @xmath184 does not involve @xmath7 , so the only nlo lecs required as input to the determination of the corresponding nnlo lec combination @xmath5 are @xmath185 and @xmath186 .
the @xmath187 and @xmath188 imfesrs , in contrast , also require input on @xmath7 . for @xmath185 and @xmath186
, we employ the values @xmath189 and @xmath190 .
the former is the result of the recommended _ all _ fit from the most recent nnlo analysis of the nlo lecs @xmath191 , given in table 5 of ref . @xcite .
the latter was obtained in an nnlo analysis of the @xmath26 and @xmath27 electromagnetic form factors @xcite .
the contributions proportional to @xmath185 in the three imfesrs under consideration are numerically rather small , and the resulting contributions to the errors on the corresponding nnlo lec combinations negligible in comparison to the contributions from other sources .
the situation with @xmath7 is somewhat more complicated since the nnlo determination of @xmath7 is not independent of the nnlo lecs appearing in the @xmath192 and @xmath193 imfesrs .
the standard route to an experimental determination of @xmath7 has been through a dispersive or imfesr determination of the value of the @xmath26-pole - subtracted light - quark v - a correlator , @xmath194 , at @xmath59 .
an early imfesr analysis , employing chpt to nlo may be found in ref .
two nlo determinations using lattice data for @xmath195 also exist @xcite . a very precise determination ,
@xmath196 has been obtained in ref .
@xcite using the results of refs .
@xcite in combination with the updated version of the opal non - strange spectral distributions @xcite reported in ref .
a similar result for @xmath197 has been obtained in ref .
@xcite using the non - strange aleph , rather than opal , data @xcite .
the error on the result of ref .
@xcite is , unfortunately , not reliable , owing to an error in the publicly posted covariance matrices for the version of the aleph data used in that analysis @xcite .
it is now known that the nlo approximation provides a very poor representation of the low-@xmath198 dependence of @xmath194 @xcite .
this result , which is not unexpected in view of a similar observation about the nlo representation of the @xmath1 v correlator @xcite , clearly calls into question the results for @xmath7 obtained from nlo analyses .
the nnlo representation of @xmath199 required to extend the nlo analyses to nnlo has the form @xcite @xmath200 where @xmath201 is the sum of one- and two - loop contributions involving only lo vertices , @xmath202 with @xmath203 the usual chiral logarithm , and @xmath204\ , , \nonumber\\ { \cal c}^r_1\ , & & = \ , 32\left ( m_\pi^2 + 2m_k^2\right)\ , \left [ c_{13}^r - c_{62}^r+c_{81}^r\right]\ .
\label{nnlolecudvma}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath201 , @xmath205 and @xmath206 are all fixed by the chiral scale @xmath161 and pseudoscalar masses and decay constants .
the nnlo lecs appearing in @xmath207 are lo in @xmath38 , those in @xmath208 @xmath209-suppressed . note that @xmath207 involves precisely the combination of nnlo lecs appearing in @xmath188 . for @xmath168 , the results of ref .
@xcite for @xmath199 and ref .
@xcite for @xmath210 yield the very precise constraint @xmath211 on @xmath212 , @xmath213 and @xmath214 . ) and that , @xmath215 , quoted in eq .
( 4.9 ) of ref .
@xcite , results from the inadvertent use in ref .
@xcite of the less precise determination of the quantity @xmath216 , given by eq .
( 4.1 ) of that reference , in place of the most precise determination , eq . ( 4.2b ) .
switching instead to the most precise determination , eq .
( 4.2b ) , leads to the result quoted in eq .
( [ udvmaq20constraint ] ) . ]
information on @xmath213 and @xmath214 is , however , required to turn this into a determination of @xmath212 .
the differing dependences of @xmath205 , @xmath206 , @xmath207 and @xmath208 on the meson masses makes it natural to approach this problem using the lattice , where the pseudoscalar meson masses can be varied by varying the input quark masses .
such an analysis has been carried out in ref .
the first stage of this analysis uses lattice and continuum data for @xmath194 in combination with the constraint , eq .
( [ udvmaq20constraint ] ) , obtained from the already published result for @xmath199 , eq .
( [ pivmaudzero ] ) . for low euclidean @xmath198 ,
the errors on the lattice data for @xmath194 are currently larger than those on the continuum version .
the consequence is that , while use of the lattice data in combination with the @xmath199 constraint , eq .
( [ udvmaq20constraint ] ) , _ does _ allow all three of @xmath7 , @xmath217 and @xmath218 to be determined , the errors that result from this first stage analysis are at the @xmath219 , @xmath220 and @xmath221 levels for @xmath7 , @xmath217 and @xmath218 , respectively .
the @xmath193 imfesr , which involves a distinct combination of two of these three quantities , @xmath7 and @xmath207 , provides an additional constraint , and allows an extended ( second stage ) version of the analysis of ref .
@xcite to be carried out
. the extended analysis , which employs our results below for the @xmath193 imfesr constraint as input , produces results ( quoted in eqs .
( [ l10rcombined ] ) , ( [ scriptc0combined ] ) and ( [ scriptc1combined ] ) below ) with significantly reduced errors . in presenting the results of the imfesr analyses below , we will thus first quote the result for @xmath5 from the @xmath222 imfser , which is independent of the treatment of @xmath7 , and then quote the result for the constraint on @xmath7 and @xmath207 arising from the @xmath193 imfesr .
the @xmath222 and @xmath193 imfesrs can , of course , also be combined to obtain the related ( but not independent ) @xmath192 and @xmath223 imfesrs .
the former constrains the combination of @xmath7 and @xmath4 noted above , the latter an analogous combination of @xmath7 and @xmath224 .
to go further , and turn these constraints into explicit determinations of the corresponding nnlo lec combinations , requires input on @xmath7 .
we will employ for @xmath7 the result of the second stage combined lattice - continuum analysis of ref .
this analysis , incorporates the @xmath225 version of the @xmath193 imfesr constraint , in addition to the @xmath199 constraint , eq .
( [ udvmaq20constraint ] ) , and the constraints generated by data from four different lattice ensembles .
the resulting error for @xmath7 is dominated by lattice errors , and hence independent of those in the present analysis . with this input for @xmath7
, @xmath4 follows from the @xmath192 imfesr constraint and @xmath224 from the @xmath223 imfesr constraint .
external input on @xmath226 then allows us to also fix @xmath227 .
the correlator combinations entering the imfesrs under consideration are all flavor - breaking and thus have vanishing @xmath228 ope series .
we include @xmath121 and @xmath12 contributions for all channels , treat @xmath129 and @xmath142 contributions as discussed below , and assume that @xmath130 and higher contributions can be neglected for imfesrs based on either @xmath225 or @xmath148 .
integrated duality violations will also be neglected .
since integrated ope contributions of @xmath229 scale , up to logarithms , as @xmath230 ( see eq . ( [ higerdopeint ] ) ) , and integrated duality violations typically produce contributions with oscillatory @xmath87-dependence , these assumptions can be tested by studying the imfesrs ( [ dkvsr ] ) and ( [ vpmaimsralt ] ) over a range of @xmath87 and ensuring that the resulting @xmath59 correlator values are independent of @xmath87 , as well as of the choice of weight , as they should be .
the @xmath121 ope series for the flavor @xmath47 , @xmath110 , v and a correlators are known to four loops .
the explicit expressions to three loops , including light - quark mass corrections , may be found in ref .
@xcite , and the @xmath231 terms in the four - loop contributions in ref .
expressions for the corresponding @xmath122 and @xmath141 contributions may be found in refs .
@xcite . omitting , for presentational simplicity
, corrections suppressed by one or more powers of @xmath232 , these results imply , for @xmath121 , @xmath233^{ope}_{d=2}\ , = \ , { \frac{3}{4\pi^2 } } { \frac{m^2_s(q^2)}{q^2}}\ , \left [ 1\ , + \ , { \frac{7}{3}}\bar{a } \ ,
+ \ , 19.9332\bar{a}^2\ , + \ , 208.746\bar{a}^3\ , + \ , \cdots\right]\ , , \nonumber\\ & & \left[\delta\pi_{v+a}(q^2)\right]^{ope}_{d=2}\ , = \ , { \frac{3}{2\pi^2 } } { \frac{m^2_s(q^2)}{q^2}}\ , \left [ 1\ , + \ , { \frac{7}{3}}\bar{a } \ , + \ , 19.9332\bar{a}^2\ ,
+ \ , 208.746\bar{a}^3\ , + \
, \cdots\right]\ , , \nonumber\\ & & \left[\delta\pi_{v - a}(q^2)\right]^{ope}_{d=2}\ , = \ , { \frac{3}{2\pi^2 } } { \frac{m_u(q^2 ) m_s(q^2)}{q^2}}\ , \left [ { \frac{2}{3}}\bar{a } \ , + \ , 8.7668\bar{a}^2\ , + \ , \cdots\right]\ , , \label{d2opeforms}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath234 , with @xmath235 the @xmath236 running coupling , and @xmath237 and @xmath238 are the @xmath236 running @xmath239 and @xmath98 quark masses . for @xmath122 , one has , omitting numerically negligible contributions fourth order in the quark masses and terms suppressed by @xmath232 , @xmath233^{ope}_{d=4}\ , = \ , -{\frac{1}{q^4}}\ , \left({\frac{m_s}{\hat{m}}}\right)\ , \langle \hat{m}\bar{u}u\rangle \ , \left [ r_c\ , + \ , \bar{a}\left({\frac{4}{3}}-r_c\right ) \ , + \ , \bar{a}^2\left({\frac{59}{6}}-{\frac{13}{3}}r_c\right)\right]\ , , \nonumber\\ & & \left [ \delta\pi_{v+a}(q^2)\right]^{ope}_{d=4}\ , = \ , -{\frac{2}{q^4}}\ , \left({\frac{m_s}{\hat{m}}}\right)\ , r_c \ , \langle \hat{m}\bar{u}u\rangle \ , \left [ 1-\bar{a}-{\frac{13}{3}}\bar{a}^2\right]\ , , \nonumber\\ & & \left[\delta\pi_{v - a}(q^2)\right]^{ope}_{d=4}\ , = \ , -{\frac{1}{q^4}}\ , \left({\frac{m_s}{\hat{m}}}\right)\ , \langle \hat{m}\bar{u}u\rangle \ , \left [ { \frac{8}{3}}\bar{a}+{\frac{59}{3}}\bar{a}^2\right]\ , , \label{d4opeforms}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath240 and @xmath241 .
@xmath129 contributions are expected to be dominated by contributions from four - quark condensates .
these condensates are not known experimentally for the flavor @xmath2 correlators , but can be roughly estimated using the vsa . in this approximation
one has @xcite @xmath242^{ope}_{d=6,vsa}\ , = \ , { \frac{32\pi}{81}}\ , { \frac{\alpha_s}{q^6}}\ , \left [ \mp 9\langle \bar{q}_iq_i\rangle\langle \bar{q}_jq_j\rangle + \langle \bar{q}_iq_i\rangle^2 + \langle \bar{q}_jq_j\rangle^2\right]\ , \label{d6opeudus0p1va}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from which the vsa approximations to @xmath243^{ope}_{d=6}$ ] and @xmath244^{ope}_{d=6}$ ] are easily obtained . with these estimates ,
one finds that @xmath129 contributions are numerically very small , particularly so for the @xmath48 and @xmath173 imfesrs , where they could be safely neglected even if the vsa were to be in error by an order of magnitude .
contributions much smaller than the corresponding estimated errors . to the number of digits quoted below
, our final results are , in fact , unchanged if we shift from our vsa estimates to zero for the @xmath129 contributions . ]
the vsa estimates for the @xmath129 contributions to the fb imfesrs , being proportional to the fb factor @xmath245 , display quite strong cancellations .
some care must thus be exercised in assigning errors to these estimates .
here it is possible to take advantage of recent results for the effective @xmath129 and @xmath131 condensates appearing in the ope representations of @xmath246 , @xmath247 and @xmath248 , obtained in the course of the analyses described in refs .
these allow a determination of the sum of @xmath129 and @xmath142 contributions to the @xmath1 parts of the relevant imfesr ope integrals .
although the corresponding flavor @xmath2 contributions are not known , some degree of cancellation will certainly be present in the fb @xmath109 differences .
the flavor @xmath1 @xmath144 ope sums can thus be used to provide a very conservative estimate of the uncertainties on the central fb @xmath109 @xmath144 ope contributions described above .
the inputs required to evaluate the @xmath249 ope contributions are as follows . for the running coupling and masses we employ the exact solutions generated using the four - loop - truncated @xmath250 and @xmath251 functions @xcite .
the initial condition for @xmath105 is taken to be @xmath252 , obtained from the @xmath253 pdg 2012 assessment @xmath254 via standard four - loop running and three - loop matching at the flavor thresholds @xcite .
for the initial conditions for the running masses we take the results for @xmath255 contained in the latest flag assessment @xcite .
the gmor relation @xmath256 is used for the light - quark condensate . for the ratio of strange to light condensates , the recent lattice result , @xmath257 @xcite , is in good agreement with the value @xmath258 obtained by updating the sum rule result of ref .
@xcite for modern @xmath182 values of the ratio @xmath259 . to be conservative
, we will take the larger of the two errors . in the case of the @xmath48 and @xmath173 imfesrs , the largest source of uncertainty in the ope contribution turns out to lie in the treatment of the integrated @xmath121 series . since @xmath260
, one sees from eqs .
( [ d2opeforms ] ) that , in these cases , the convergence of the known terms in the @xmath121 series is marginal at best : at the spacelike point on the contour , the four - loop ( @xmath261 ) @xmath121 term in fact exceeds the three - loop ( @xmath262 ) one for all @xmath87 accessible using @xmath0-decay data
. the rather problematic convergence behavior of the @xmath121 series manifests itself not only in a similarly problematic behavior for the integrated @xmath121 series , but also in a large difference , increasing with truncation order , between the results of evaluations of the integrated truncated series obtained using the fopt ( fixed - order perturbation theory ) and cipt ( contour - improved perturbation theory ) prescriptions .
the two prescriptions differ only by contributions of order higher than the truncation order , the former involving the truncation of the integrated series at fixed order in @xmath263 , the latter the summation of logarithms point - by - point along the contour via the local scale choice @xmath264 and truncation at the same fixed order in @xmath235 for all such @xmath198 .
the problematic convergence behavior and increase in the fopt - cipt difference with increasing truncation order both suggest the @xmath121 series may already have begun to display its asymptotic character at three- or four - loop order , complicating an assessment of the error to be assigned to the integrated truncated series .
this issue has been raised previously in the context of the determination of @xmath265 from fb hadronic @xmath0 decay sum rules @xcite .
fortunately , the lattice provides a means of investigating the reliability of various treatments of the @xmath121 ope series . in refs .
@xcite lattice data for the fb @xmath173 combination was shown to favor the fixed - scale over local - scale treatment of the @xmath121 series , hence fopt over cipt for the imfesr integrals . moreover , with the three - loop - truncated , fixed - scale version of the @xmath121 series , the ope was found to provide a good representation of the lattice data for @xmath198 in the range from @xmath266 down to @xmath267 @xcite .
in view of these results , the integrated @xmath121 ope contribution has been evaluated using the fopt prescription truncated at three loops .
the associated error is taken to be the quadrature sum of ( i ) the three - loop fopt - cipt difference , ( ii ) the magnitude of the last ( three - loop ) term retained in the integrated fopt series , ( iii ) the error associated with the uncertainty in the input @xmath268 , and ( iv ) the error associated with the uncertainty in the input @xmath269 .
the resulting error is dominated by the fopt - cipt difference for @xmath118 , while both the fopt - cipt difference and last - term - retained contributions are important for @xmath119 .
based on the lattice results , this approach should , in fact , yield a rather conservative assessment of the @xmath121 error .
further details of our assessments of the errors on the various ope contributions may be found in the appendix .
the weighted spectral integrals needed to complete the evaluations of the rhss of the imfesrs eqs .
( [ vpmaimsralt ] ) are @xmath270 with @xmath147 or @xmath148 , and the range @xmath271 ( the lower bound reflecting the binning of the aleph data ) employed to carry out the @xmath87-stability ( self - consistency ) tests noted above .
an update of the opal results for @xmath272 and @xmath273 @xcite , reflecting changes to the exclusive - mode branching fractions since the original opal publication , was performed in ref .
this update employed non - strange branching fractions from an hfag fit incorporating standard model expectations based on @xmath274 and @xmath275 decay widths and then - current strange branching fractions from the same fit . since then
, belle has produced a new result for @xmath276 $ ] @xcite which shifts slightly the previous world average for this mode . to restore the sum over all branching fractions to one after this shift , and in the absence of an update of the previously used hfag fit which takes this shift into account
, a common global @xmath277 rescaling has been performed on the @xmath1 @xmath48 and @xmath49 distributions of ref .
being so close to one , this rescaling , not surprisingly , has negligible effect .
the @xmath56 separation for the non - strange modes was performed by opal using g - parity . the main uncertainty in this separation results from @xmath278 contributions , for which g - parity can not be used . a conservative , fully anticorrelated @xmath279 @xmath56 breakdown was assumed .
while the @xmath278 @xmath56 separation uncertainty can , in principle , be significantly reduced through angular analyses @xcite of the much higher statistics b - factory data on these modes , such an improvement is irrelevant for our purposes since this uncertainty plays a negligible role in the present analysis
. the differential decay distribution @xmath280 has been measured , and its exclusive mode contributions made available , by the aleph collaboration @xcite .
much higher statistics b - factory results now exist for the relative ( unit - normalized ) distributions of the @xmath281 @xcite , @xmath282 @xcite , @xmath283 @xcite and @xmath284 @xcite exclusive modes , the latter in preliminary form only .
we employ the b - factory results for these four modes , using current branching fraction values to fix the overall normalizations .
results used here is preliminary , having been read off from fig . 2 of the report , ref .
@xcite , prepared by the belle collaboration for the tau 2012 proceedings .
the errors take into account the uncertainty in the reported branching fraction in addition to those shown in the figure . while this should ( and will ) be updated once the final version of the belle analysis is released , the @xmath284 uncertainties errors play a negligible role in the @xmath48 and @xmath174 analyses ( where they are swamped by the much larger @xmath56 separation uncertainties ) and a very small role in the @xmath173 analysis ( where @xmath18 error contributions are dominant ) .
the preliminary nature of the belle data should thus have no relevant impact on the present analysis . ] for all other modes the aleph results , rescaled to current branching fraction values , are used .
the @xmath72 subtraction of the @xmath280 distribution , required to extract the @xmath110 component contribution thereof , and hence the combination @xmath285 is , as noted above , performed using the results of refs .
@xcite . for @xmath265 ( needed to convert from @xmath286 to the spectral function ) we employ the value , @xmath287 , implied by three - family unitarity and the hardy - towner determination @xmath288 @xcite . the @xmath56 separation of the @xmath2 , @xmath173 distribution is more complicated than in the analogous @xmath1 case .
while the @xmath27 pole contribution is pure @xmath49 , and the @xmath18 distribution pure @xmath48 , chirally unsuppressed @xmath48 and @xmath49 contributions are both present for all the higher multiplicity @xmath289 ( @xmath290 ) modes . for @xmath291 ,
the @xmath56 separation could be performed , up to small chirally suppressed corrections , by a relatively simple angular analysis @xcite , but this has yet to be done .
fortunately , for phase space reasons , the @xmath291 and higher multiplicity strange mode distributions lie at relatively high @xmath98 , increasingly so with increasing multiplicity .
their contributions to the imfesr spectral integrals are thus strongly suppressed by the combination of the @xmath104 factor in the overall weight , @xmath292 , and the triple - zeros of @xmath225 and @xmath148 at @xmath92 .
the suppression of such high-@xmath98 contributions , of course , grows stronger as @xmath87 is decreased .
the strong high-@xmath98 suppression is also welcome in view of the low statistics , and consequent large errors , for the high-@xmath98 part of the aleph @xmath2 distribution and the fact that the @xmath98-dependences of the aleph @xmath293 , @xmath294 , @xmath295 and @xmath296 distributions were fixed from monte carlo rather than by direct measurement .
the high-@xmath98 suppression is , in fact , strong enough to allow the analyses to proceed with a @xmath279 ( fully anticorrelated ) @xmath56 breakdown assigned to contributions from all modes other than @xmath27 and @xmath18 . as noted in refs .
@xcite , however , the @xmath291 distributions contain contributions from the axial @xmath297 , the axial @xmath298 and the vector @xmath299 resonances . while the latter two can not be disentangled without an angular analysis , the former lies in a distinct part of the spectrum , and can be unambiguously assigned to the @xmath49 channel .
this observation allows an improvement to be made on the @xmath56 separation for the @xmath291 modes .
drr and kambor @xcite , following aleph @xcite , modelled the @xmath291 distribution as a sum of two resonant contributions , one from the @xmath297 and one from a single effective @xmath300 region resonance with mass and width equal to the average of the corresponding @xmath298 and @xmath299 parameters .
the resulting @xmath300 region contribution was then assigned @xmath279 each to the @xmath48 and @xmath49 channels . for the @xmath48 channel considered by drr and kambor ,
the resulting aleph - based @xmath291 imfesr contribution was found to be only @xmath301 ( @xmath302 ) of the corresponding @xmath18 one at @xmath303 ( @xmath304 ) .
this approximate separation of @xmath48 and @xmath49 contributions to the @xmath291 spectral distribution can be carried out even more convincingly with the much higher precision babar @xmath283 @xcite and belle @xmath284 @xcite data , both presented at tau 2012 .
[ kpipidistribs ] shows the @xmath2 spectral function contributions produced by these data sets .
the @xmath297 peak is clearly visible for both modes . performing the aleph / drr - kambor analysis
, one finds @xmath56 breakdowns of @xmath305 @xmath306 @xmath48/@xmath307 @xmath49 for the @xmath118- and @xmath119-weighted imfesr integral contributions from the combination of these two modes , the precise value varying by a few percent with variations in the choice of weight , the input effective @xmath300 width and fit window employed , and by @xmath308 over the range of @xmath87 considered in this analysis . while the reduction from @xmath309 to @xmath310 , accomplished by taking into account the presence of the @xmath297 contributions , represents a significant improvement in the @xmath56 separation uncertainty for the @xmath291 component of the @xmath2 spectral integrals , one should bear in mind that the @xmath291 contribution is much smaller than the @xmath27 and/or @xmath18 ones , making the impact of this improvement on the errors in the total @xmath2 spectral integrals much more modest . in the absence of high - statistics
b - factory results for the distributions of the much smaller @xmath311 mode , and all higher - multiplicity modes , we take the maximally conservative approach and assume a fully anti - correlated @xmath279 @xmath48/@xmath279 @xmath49 breakdown for the corresponding spectral integral contributions . because of the anticorrelation , both for these modes , and in the separation of the @xmath300 region @xmath291 contributions , the total @xmath2 spectral integral error is magnified for the @xmath174 difference . for the @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath174 channels , where the @xmath56 separation uncertainty plays a role , the suppression of contributions from the high-@xmath98 region produced by the triple zeros of @xmath225 and @xmath148 at @xmath92 and the @xmath104 factor in the full weight @xmath292 is especially important . the @xmath56 separation uncertainty is , of course , absent for the v+a combination .
the rhss of the imfesrs of eqs .
( [ dkvsr ] ) and ( [ vpmaimsralt ] ) are evaluated using the input specified in the previous section .
included in this input is the choice of the three - loop - truncated fopt prescription for evaluating the @xmath121 series . since
this choice was predicated on an agreement of the corresponding ope representation and lattice data for euclidean @xmath198 extending from @xmath266 down to , but not below , @xmath267 , we restrict our attention to @xmath87 lying safely in this interval . with the aleph @xmath2 data binning , this corresponds to @xmath312 .
for @xmath87 in this range , experience with sum rules involving weights with a double zero at @xmath92 suggests integrated duality violations should also be negligible @xcite .
ope contributions are very small for the @xmath225 version of the @xmath193 imfesr , but less so for the @xmath148 version , where enhanced @xmath122 contributions reach up to @xmath313 of the rhs in the @xmath87 window employed .
ope contributions are numerically relevant for both versions of the @xmath192 and @xmath222 imfesrs , reaching @xmath314 and @xmath315 , respectively , of the rhss for the @xmath225 case , and @xmath316 and @xmath317 , respectively , of the rhss for the @xmath148 case . the dependences on @xmath87 of the ope , continuum spectral integral and residual @xmath26/@xmath27-pole term contributions to the rhss of the @xmath225 @xmath222 and @xmath193 imfesrs , eq .
( [ vpmaimsralt ] ) , are shown , for illustration , in figs .
[ vpaimsrrhsbreakdown ] and [ vmaimsrrhsbreakdown ] .
as noted already , ope contributions are negligible for the latter , but not the former .
also shown are the totals of all three contributions , which should be independent of @xmath87 and equal to @xmath184 and @xmath188 , respectively .
the @xmath87 stability of these results is obviously excellent .
similarly good @xmath87 stability is found for the @xmath225 @xmath192 imfesr and all three @xmath148 imfesrs .
the corresponding figures are thus omitted for the sake of brevity .
given that ope contributions to the @xmath225 @xmath174 imfesr are numerically negligible , the stability of @xmath188 with respect to @xmath87 for this case supports the treatment of the exclusive @xmath2 spectral integral contributions and @xmath56 separation .
the stability in the @xmath173 cases tests , in addition , the treatment of the ope contributions .
the @xmath87 stability in all cases also supports the neglect of higher @xmath127 ope and residual duality violating contributions in the analysis .
the values for @xmath187 , @xmath184 and @xmath188 obtained from the @xmath225 analysis are as follows : @xmath318 where , to be specific , the central values quoted represent the average over the @xmath87 window employed .
the subscripts @xmath319 , @xmath320 and @xmath321 identify error components associated with ope , continuum spectral integral and ( where present ) residual @xmath26/k - pole contributions , while the additional component labelled by the subscript @xmath87 specifies the small residual variation of the total over the @xmath87 analysis window .
the agreement between the results of eqs .
( [ q2eq0correlatorresultswdk ] ) and ( [ q2eq0correlatorresultswhat ] ) represents a further non - trivial test of the treatment of theoretical and spectral integral contributions .
the total errors on @xmath187 , @xmath184 and @xmath188 are rather similar for the @xmath225 and @xmath148 determinations , with spectral integral errors somewhat smaller and ope errors somewhat larger for the @xmath148 case . in view of the similarity of the errors , and the fact that the @xmath148 analyses involve both significantly larger ope contributions and integrated @xmath121 and @xmath122 ope series having much slower convergence behavior , we take our final results to be those obtained from the @xmath225 imfesrs , whose errors are dominantly experimental
. the results of eqs .
( [ q2eq0correlatorresultswdk ] ) , combined with the lec contributions of eqs .
( [ nlonnlolectermcontributions ] ) , the lec - independent contributions of eqs .
( [ nonlecudmusrzerovalues ] ) , and the input values for @xmath323 , yield the final versions of the imfesr constraints on the nnlo lec combinations and ( for @xmath324 ) @xmath7 .
we now discuss in more detail the version of this analysis based on the weight @xmath118 .
the @xmath119-based analysis is analogous , and , due to the good agreement between the results of eqs .
( [ q2eq0correlatorresultswdk ] ) and ( [ q2eq0correlatorresultswhat ] ) , leads to very similar results for the nnlo lecs .
these will be displayed , together with those from the @xmath118 analysis , in table [ table2 ] below .
the @xmath225 @xmath325 imfesr becomes @xmath326 where the subscripts @xmath185 and @xmath186 label errors associated with the uncertainties on the input @xmath327 values and the labelling of all other sources of error is as specified above .
the @xmath225 @xmath328 imfesr , similarly , yields @xmath329\nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad = \ , -0.00346\ , ( 145)_{cont } ( 15)_{res } ( 31)_{ope } ( 8)_{s_0 } ( 9)_{l_5^r } ( 61)_{l_9^r } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad = \ , -0.00346\ , ( 161)\ , \label{vmaimfesrlecconstraint}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the @xmath225 @xmath107 constraint @xmath330 in ref .
@xcite , a combined fit incorporating the constraint , eq .
( [ vmaimfesrlecconstraint ] ) , the @xmath197 constraint , eq .
( [ udvmaq20constraint ] ) , and lattice @xmath195 results for four @xmath182 , domain - wall fermion rbc / ukqcd ensembles ( two with inverse lattice spacing @xmath331 and pion masses @xmath332 , and @xmath333 , and two with @xmath334 and @xmath335 and @xmath336 ) , was shown to yield @xmath337 the result ( [ scriptc0combined ] ) corresponds to @xmath338 equation ( [ l10rcombined ] ) , combined with the @xmath107 constraint , eq .
( [ vecimfesrlecconstraint ] ) , then implies @xmath339 there is some correlation between the continuum spectral integral errors and @xmath7 , but the impact of this correlation does not show up in the combined error , to the number of significant figures shown , since the error on @xmath7 is strongly dominated by the errors on the lattice data . and @xmath186 in the @xmath328 imfesr constraint are also very small . as an example , doubling the @xmath186 uncertainty of ref .
@xcite , and rerunning the fit of ref .
@xcite , we find the errors in eqs .
( [ l10rcombined ] ) , ( [ scriptc0combined ] ) and ( [ scriptc1combined ] ) shifted to @xmath340 , @xmath341 and @xmath342 respectively , with no change in the central fitted values . ] taking into account the correlations between the @xmath48 and @xmath173 analysis inputs ( or , equivalently , performing the fb @xmath109 @xmath49 imfesr analysis directly ) , one finds , from ( [ vpaimfesrlecresult ] ) and ( [ c61value ] ) , @xmath343 the determination of @xmath226 in ref .
@xcite has been recently updated to reflect new values for the main inputs @xmath344 and @xmath21 @xcite , with the result @xmath345 eqs .
( [ c12pc80value ] ) and ( [ mj13c12 ] ) yield @xmath346 replacing the inputs from eqs .
( [ q2eq0correlatorresultswdk ] ) with those from eqs .
( [ q2eq0correlatorresultswhat ] ) and repeating the steps just described yields the alternate @xmath119 imfesr determinations of the same nnlo lec combinations shown in table [ table2 ] .
these are in excellent agreement with those obtained from the @xmath118 imfesr analysis .
a number of estimates exist in the literature for the three nnlo lecs , @xmath347 , entering the combinations determined above .
@xmath4 was also obtained directly in an earlier version @xcite of the fb @xmath48 channel imfesr analysis , differing from that in table [ table1 ] was also given in ref . @xcite .
this was meant to represent a translation of the drr - kambor result @xcite , which was not given directly in terms of @xmath4 , into the explicit @xmath4 form .
the two values turn out to differ because of a minor sign transcription error in the translation process .
thanks to bachir moussallam for clarifying the situation , and tracking down the source of the discrepancy . ] and @xmath348 ( not determined here ) in the lattice analysis of ref .
@xcite and an updated version @xcite of the coupled - channel dispersive analysis of ref .
these estimates / results are compiled in table [ table1 ] . for the quark model results of ref .
@xcite , we quote , for simplicity , the larger of the two asymmetric errors from the original publication . in ref .
@xcite , a number of different results were presented for @xmath226 , corresponding to different fit strategies and inputs . here
only the result of fit iv , which did not employ data from the heavier @xmath349 ensemble and which used updated nlo lec input ( the preliminary version of the results of ref .
@xcite ) , has been tabulated . comparing the quark model and rchpt estimates to the imfesr results above
, one sees that the quark model does well for @xmath227 but badly for @xmath4 , while rchpt somewhat overestimates @xmath4 and significantly overestimates @xmath227 . for @xmath325
there are strong cancellations between the separate @xmath48 and @xmath49 contributions , with the result that the central value of the @xmath144 @xmath1 @xmath173 sum is much smaller than the corresponding uncertainty .
no such strong cancellation occurs in either of the @xmath48 or @xmath174 channels . to maintain our @xmath144 bound as a conservative one for all three cases , we have thus taken as the final versions of the error bounds on the fb @xmath109 @xmath144 contributions , the sum of the absolute values of the corresponding central @xmath1 contribution and its error .
these can be read off directly from the results quoted in the table .
the resulting @xmath144 error is the largest of the ope error components for the @xmath48 and @xmath174 channels , and non - negligible , but somewhat smaller than the @xmath121 error , for @xmath173 .
99 s. weinberg , physica * a96 * 327 ( 1979 ) .
j. gasser and h. leutwyler , ann .
phys . * 158 * 142 ( 1984 ) .
j. gasser and h. leutwyler , nucl .
b250 * 465 ( 1985 ) .
fearing and s. scherer , phys .
rev . * d53 * 315 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9408346 ]
. j. bijnens , g. colangelo and g. ecker , jhep * 02 * 020 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9902437 ] ; ann .
* 280 * 100 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9907333 ] .
m. knecht , b. moussallam and j. stern , nucl .
b429 * 125 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9402318 ] .
e. golowich and j. kambor , phys . rev .
* d53 * 2651 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9509304 ] . k. maltman , phys . rev .
* d53 * 2573 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9504404 ] ; k. maltman and c.e .
wolfe , phys . rev . * d59 * 096003 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9810441 ] .
s. drr and j. kambor , phys . rev .
* d61 * 114025 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9907539 ]
. m. jamin , j.a .
oller and a. pich , jhep * 0402 * 047 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0401080 ] .
v. bernard and e. passemar , phys . lett . *
b661 * 95 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0711.3450 ( hep - ph ) ] . v. bernard and e. passemar , jhep * 1004 * 001 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0912.3792 ( hep - ph ) ] .
g. ecker , p. masjuan and h. neufeld , phys .
b692 * 184 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1004.3422 ( hep - ph ) ] . g. ecker , p. masjuan and h. neufeld , phys . lett . *
b692 * 184 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1310.8452 ( hep - ph ) ] .
j. bijnens and p.
talavera , jhep * 0203 * 046 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0203049 ] .
j. bijnens and p. dhonte , jhep * 0301 * 061 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0307044 ] . k. kampf and b. moussallam , eur .
j. * c47 * 723 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0604125 ] .
p. bttiker , s. descotes - genon and b. moussallam , eur .
j * c33 * 204 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0310283 ] .
g. colangelo , j. gasser and h. leutwyler , nucl .
phys . * b603 * 125 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0103088 ] . m. gonzlez - alonso , a. pich and j. prades , phys . rev .
* d78 * 116012 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0810.0760 ( hep - ph ) ] .
d. boito _ et al .
d87 * 094008 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1212.4471 ( hep - ph ) ] . g. ecker , j. gasser , a. pich and e. de rafael , nucl .
b321 * 311 ( 1989 ) .
see , e.g. , a. pich , arxiv:0812.2631 ( hep - ph ) and references cited therein .
see , e.g. , m. knecht and a. nyffeler , eur .
j. * c21 * 659 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0106034 ] ; v. cirigliano , _ et al .
b573 * 139 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0603205 ] ; i. rosell , j.j .
sanz - cillero and a. pich , jhep * 0701 * ( 2007 ) 039 [ hep - ph/0610290 ] ; a. pich , i. rosell and j.j .
sanz - cillero , jhep * 0807 * 014 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0803.1567 ( hep - ph ) ] ; a. pich , i. rossell and j.j .
sanz - cillero , jhep * 1102 * 109 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1011.5771 ( hep - ph ) ] .
j. gasser , c. haefeli , m.a .
ivanov and m. schmid , phys .
b652 * 21 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0706.0955 ( hep - ph ) ] .
j. bijnens and i. jemos , nucl .
b854 * 631 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1103.5945 ( hep - ph ) ] .
jiang , y. zhang , c. li and q. wang , phys .
* d81 * 014001 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0907.5229 ( hep - ph ) ] .
et al . _ , in preparation ; see also p.a .
et al . _ , pos lattice2012 156 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1301.2565 ( hep - lat ) ] , and the link to the slides of the lattice 2013 talk by k. maltman , www.lattice2013.uni-mainz.de/static/smr.html#contrib3842 .
y .- s . tsai , phys .
* d4 * , 2821 ( 1971 ) .
j. erler , rev .
. fis . * 50 * , 200 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0211345 ] .
m. jamin , j.a .
oller and a. pich , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b587 * 331 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/0006045 ] ; _ ibid . _ * b622 * 279 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0110193 ] ; and _ phys . rev . _
* d74 * 074009 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0605095 ] .
k. maltman and j. kambor , _ phys .
rev . _ * d65 * 074013 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0108227 ]
. k. maltman , phys . lett . *
b440 * 367 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9901239 ] ; c.a .
dominguez and k. schilcher , phys .
b448 * 93 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9811261 ] .
d. boito , _ et al .
* d84 * 113006 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1110.1127 ( hep - ph ) ] .
d. boito , _ et al .
_ , phys . rev . *
d85 * 093015 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1203.3146 ( hep - ph ) ] .
k. maltman , phys . rev . *
d58 * 093015 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9804298 ] .
k. maltman and j. kambor , phys . rev . * d64 * 093014 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0107187 ]
. g. amoros , j. bijnens and p. talavera , nucl . phys . *
b568 * 319 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9907264 ] .
j. beringer , _ et al .
_ , phys . rev . *
d86 * 010001 ( 2012 ) .
see g. colangelo , _ et al .
j. * c71 * 1695 ( 2011 ) ; a. jttner , _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1109.1388 ; and updates accessible from the main page of the 2013 flag compilation , which may be found at itpwiki.unibe.ch/flag/index.php/ review_of_lattice_result_concerning_low_energy_particle_physics .
m. davier , l. girlanda , a. hcker and j. stern , phys . rev . *
d58 * 096014 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9802447 ] .
m. jamin and b.o .
lange , phys . rev . *
d65 * 056005 ( 2002 ) .
e. shintani , _ et al .
* 101 * 202004 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv : 0806.4222 ( hep - lat ) ] .
boyle , l. del debbio , j. wennekers and j.m .
zanotti , phys . rev .
* d81 * 014504 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0909.4931 ( hep - lat ) ] .
k. ackerstaff , _ et al . _
[ opal collaboration ] , eur .
j. * c7 * 571 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ex/9808019 ] .
r. barate , _ et al . _
[ aleph collaboration ] , z. phys .
* c76 * 15 ( 1997 ) ; r. barate , _ et al .
_ [ aleph collaboration ] , eur . phys .
j * c4 * 409 ( 1998 ) ; s. schael _
[ aleph collaboration ] , phys .
* 421 * 191 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ex/0506072 ] .
d. boito , _ et al .
. suppl . * 218 * 104 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1011.4426 ( hep - ph ) ] . c. aubin and t. blum , phys
* d75 * 114502 ( 2006 ) [ hep - lat/0608011 ] .
chetyrkin and a. kwiatkowski , z. phys .
* c59 * 525 ( 1993 ) and hep - ph/9805232 .
baikov , k.g .
chetyrkin and j.h .
kuhn , phys .
lett . * 95 * 012002 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0412350 ] .
d.j . broadhurst and s.c .
generalis , open university preprint out-4102 - 12(1984 ) ; s.c .
generalis , _ j. phys .
_ * g15 * l225 ( 1989 ) ; k. g. chetyrkin , s.g .
gorishnii and v.p .
spiridonov , _ phys .
lett . _ * b160 * 149 ( 1985 ) .
e. braaten , s. narison and a. pich , nucl . phys .
* b373 * 581 ( 1992 ) . t. van ritbergen , j.a.m . vermaseren and s.a .
larin , _ phys .
_ * b400 * ( 1997 ) 379 ; k.g .
chetyrkin , _ phys .
* b404 * ( 1997 ) 161 ; t. van ritbergen , j.a.m .
vermaseren and s.a .
larin , _ phys .
lett . _ * b405 * ( 1997 ) 327 ; m. czakon , _ nucl
. phys . _ * b710 * ( 2005 ) 485 k.g .
chetyrkin , b.a .
kniehl and m. steinhauser , phys .
lett . * 79 * 2184 ( 1997 ) [ hep - ph/9706430 ] .
c. mcneile , _ et al .
_ , phys . rev . *
d87 * 034503 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1211.6577 ( hep - lat ) ] .
e.g. _ , k. maltman , nucl . phys
. proc . suppl . * 218 * 146 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1011.6391 ( hep - ph ) ] and references cited therein .
boyle , _ et al .
_ , pos confinementx , 100 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1301.4930 ( hep - ph ) ] and the link to the slides of the talk by k. maltman at phipsi13 , agenda.infn.it/contributiondisplay.py?sessionid=26&contribid=10&confid=5428 .
j.h . khn and e. mirkes , z. phys .
* c56 * 661 ( 1992 ) ; erratum : _ ibid . _
* c67 * 364 ( 1995 ) .
r. barate , _ et al .
j. * c11 * 599 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ex/9903015 ] .
thanks to shaomin chen for providing the details of the exclusive mode contributions to the inclusive distribution .
b. aubert , _ et al .
_ [ the babar collaboration ] , phys . rev . *
d76 * 051104 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0707.2922 ( hep - ex ) ] .
d. epifanov , _ et al . _
[ the belle collaboration ] , phys .
b654 * 65 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0706.2231 ( hep - ex ) ] .
thanks to denis epifanov for providing access to the @xmath353 invariant mass spectrum , which may be found at belle.kek.jp/belle/preprint/2007-28/tau_kspinu.dat .
nugent , `` precision measurement of @xmath0 lepton decays '' , university of victoria phd thesis , 2009 .
nugent , arxiv:1301.7105 ( hep - ex ) .
thanks to ian nugent for providing the unfolded @xmath354 distribution and covariances presented in this paper .
s. ryu , for the belle collaboration , arxiv:1302.4565 ( hep - ex ) .
j.c . hardy and i.s .
towner , phys . rev . *
c79 * 044402 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0812.1202 ( nucl - ex ) ] .
v. cirigliano , _ et al .
_ , jhep * 0504 * 006 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0503108 ] .
r. unterdorfer and h. pichl , eur .
j. * c55 * 273 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0801.2482 ( hep - ph ) ] .
k. maltman and t. yavin , phys . rev . *
d78 * 094020 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0807.0650 ( hep - ph ) ] .
matthias jamin , private communication .
the new result reflects updated flag values for the inputs @xmath355 and @xmath21 of the original analysis .
a. adametz , `` measurement of @xmath0 decays into charged hadron accompanied by neutral @xmath26 mesons and determination of the ckm matrix element @xmath265 '' , university of heidelberg phd thesis , july 2011 and the babar collaboration , in progress . | using spectral data from non - strange and strange hadronic @xmath0 decays , flavor - breaking chiral sum rules involving the flavor @xmath1 and @xmath2 current - current two - point functions are constructed and used to determine the @xmath3 nnlo low - energy constant combinations @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 . the first of these determinations updates the results of an earlier analysis by drr and kambor , while the latter two are new .
the error on the @xmath5 is particularly small .
comparisons are made to model estimates for these quantities .
the role of the third combination in significantly improving the determination of the nlo low - energy constant @xmath7 from nnlo analyses of the flavor @xmath1 v - a correlator is also highlighted . |
characterizing the thermodynamic properties of matter composed of strongly interacting particles has been the premier objective of heavy ion collision experiments at the relativistic heavy ion collider ( rhic ) at brookhaven and the large hadron collider ( lhc ) at cern @xcite .
relativistic hydrodynamics has played a very important role in analyzing the data from these collisions @xcite and providing a viable description of the collective dynamics of the produced matter .
recently , the observation of a large elliptic flow(@xmath3 ) of hadrons in 200 agev au - au collisions at rhic could be explained quantitatively using a small but finite value of shear viscosity over entropy density ( @xmath4 ) @xcite .
however , a consistent formulation of relativistic dissipative fluid dynamics is far from trivial .
the first order theories are seen to lead to instabilities due to acausal propagation of perturbations .
the second - order theory due to israel and stewart @xcite currently appears to be the most consistent macroscopic formulation to study collective phenomena in heavy ion collisions @xcite .
though the hydrodynamic equations may be derived from entropy considerations using the second law of thermodynamics , a microscopic approach is necessary in order to determine the parameters e.g. the coefficients of shear and bulk viscosity , thermal conductivity and the relaxation times of the corresponding fluxes .
the boltzmann transport equation has been used extensively as the underlying microscopic theory to estimate the transport coefficients of relativistic imperfect fluids . in this approach
the ( differential ) scattering cross - section in the collision integral is the dynamical input and plays a significant role in determining the magnitude of the transport coefficients .
the case of a pion gas has received some attention and several estimates of the transport coefficients exist in the literature . in all the cases the @xmath0 cross - section corresponds to the one in vacuum .
either the chiral lagrangian has been used @xcite to derive the scattering amplitude or it has been parametrized from phase shift data @xcite .
in general , medium effects affect the collision integral in two competing ways
. the larger phase space occupancy due to the bose factors @xmath5 for the final state pions results in an increase of the collision rate .
this is compensated to some extent by a smaller effective cross - section on account of many - body effects ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
recently , the effect of the medium on the viscosities @xcite and thermal conductivity @xcite was studied using the chapman - enskog approach and significant modification in the temperature dependence of the coefficients was observed .
in addition to the coefficients of viscosity and thermal conductivity the corresponding relaxation times @xmath6 also go as input in the viscous hydrodynamic equations @xcite .
they indicate the time taken by the fluxes to relax to their steady state values and consequently play an important role in determining the space - time evolution of relativistic heavy ion collisions .
this is more so for systems where @xmath6 is of the same order or larger than the mean collision time @xmath7 of the particles since several collisions may occur during the relaxation of the dissipative flows to their steady state values as in the case of a strongly interacting system like the one created in heavy ion collisions .
moreover , though the magnitude of the shear viscosity is usually much larger than the bulk viscosity , the corresponding relaxation times may be comparable . also , the ratios of the viscous coefficients to their relaxation times are found @xcite to behave differently with respect to temperature .
there are a few estimates of the relaxation times available in the literature .
the temperature dependence of the relaxation times have been evaluated in @xcite with a parametrized cross section which is independent of temperature .
constant values of transport coefficients have been used in @xcite and in @xcite these quantities have been obtained using conformal field theory . in the present study
we investigate the effect of the medium on the relaxation times of the dissipative flows .
as is well known , the chapman - enskog approach leads to a linear relationship between the thermodynamic forces and the corresponding irreversible flows . because of the parabolic nature of the equations of motion this results in infinite speeds of these flows . in order to have access to the relaxation times we use the more general 14-moment method due to grad @xcite . with the inclusion of the viscous pressure tensor and the heat flow to the original ( five ) hydrodynamic variables
the relations between fluxes and forces contain time derivatives of the fluxes and cross - couplings between them .
the hyperbolic nature of the equations of motion in this case result in finite relaxation times of the dissipative flows .
our aim in this work is to estimate the change in the temperature dependence of the relaxation times for the shear and bulk viscous flows and the heat flow for a hot pion gas on account of the in - medium cross - section .
we thus evaluate the @xmath0 scattering amplitude with an effective lagrangian in a thermal field theoretic framework and use it in the uehling - uhlenbeck collision integral which contains the bose enhancement factors for the final state pions .
in addition to a significant medium dependence we find the relaxation times for the viscous and heat flows for a chemically frozen pion gas to be of comparable magnitude . the formalism to obtain the relaxation times of the dissipative fluxes using the 14-moment method is described in the next section .
this is followed by a discussion on the medium dependent @xmath0 cross - section in sec.iii .
the results are given in sec .
iv and a summary in sec.v .
details of calculations are given in appendices a , b and c.
we begin with the relativistic transport equation for the phase space density p^_f(x , p)=c[f ] [ treq ] where the collision integral is given by c[f]&=&d_k d_p d_k[f(x , p)f(x , k ) \{1+f(x , p ) } \{1+f(x , k ) } + & & -f(x , p)f(x , k)\{1+f(x , p)}\{1+f(x , k ) } ] w , in which @xmath8 , @xmath9 and the term @xmath10 contains the differential scattering amplitude @xmath11 .
the factor @xmath12 is to account for the indistinguishability of the initial state particles which are pions in our case . in the moment method one attempts to obtain an approximate solution of the transport equation ( [ treq ] ) by expanding the distribution function @xmath13 in momentum space around its local equilibrium value when the deviation from it is small .
we write f(x , p)=f^(0)(x , p)+f(x , p ) , f(x , p)=f^(0)(x , p)[1+f^(0)(x , p)](x , p ) [ ff ] where @xmath14 is the deviation function .
the local equilibrium distribution function is given by f^(0)(x , p)=^-1 [ f0 ] in which @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 are identified with the temperature , fluid four - velocity and pion chemical potential respectively .
the latter arises on account of conservation of the number of pions due to chemical freeze - out in heavy ion collisions and is not associated with a conserved charge ( see later ) . putting ( [ ff ] ) , the left hand side of ( [ treq ] ) splits into a term containing derivative over the equilibrium distribution and another containing derivative over @xmath14 , p_^f^(0)+f^(0)(1+f^(0))p_^=-[tt2 ] where the collision term reduces to = & & f^(0)(x , p)d_k d_p d_kf^(0)(x , k ) \{1+f^(0)(x , p)}\{1+f^(0)(x , k ) } + & & [ ( x , p)+(x , k)-(x , p)-(x , k ) ] w . to simplify the first term on the left hand side of eq .
( [ tt2 ] ) the partial derivative over @xmath18 is decomposed with respect to the fluid four - velocity into a temporal and spatial part by writing @xmath19 . here
@xmath20 is the convective time derivative and @xmath21 is the spatial gradient .
the projection operator is defined as @xmath22 where the metric @xmath23 . using this , the local rest frame , where @xmath24 , is defined following eckart as @xmath25 . in this frame
the spatial components of the particle four - current @xmath26 vanishes .
when the derivative over @xmath18 is taken with the above prescription we obtain a set of terms containing space and time derivatives over the thermodynamic quantities .
while the space gradients of thermodynamic variables lead to thermodynamic forces , the time derivatives are eliminated using the equations of motion containing the dissipative fluxes .
these are discussed in appendix - a . after some simplification we get ^_f^(0)&=&f^(0)(1+f^(0 ) ) + & & with @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 , where , @xmath30 .
the notation @xmath31t_{\alpha_\beta}$ ] indicates a spacelike , symmetric and traceless form of the tensor @xmath32 .
the reduced enthalpy per particle is defined as , @xmath33 and @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 stand for the pressure , particle density and heat flow vector respectively .
the @xmath37 s and the @xmath38 s are defined in appendix - a . for the remaining two terms in ( [ tt2 ] )
we need to define the deviation function @xmath14 and its derivative .
since the distribution function is a scalar depending on the particle momentum @xmath39 and the space - time coordinate @xmath40 , the deviation function is expressed as a sum of scalar products of tensors formed from @xmath39 and tensor functions of @xmath40 . following @xcite we write @xmath14 as ( x , p)=a(x,)-b_(x,)^+c_(x,)^^[phi ] where @xmath41 and @xmath42\pi_\alpha\pi_\beta$ ] .
now the @xmath43 and @xmath6-dependent coefficient functions @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 are further expanded in a power series in @xmath6 such that the last power is the one which gives a non - zero contribution to the collision term , getting a(x,)=a_0+a_1(x)+a_2(x)^2=_s=0 ^ 2a_s(x)^s , [ a ] b_(x,)=b_0(x)+b_1(x)=_s=0 ^ 1(b_s)_(x)^s , [ b ] c_(x,)=c_0(x ) [ c ] where in the last equation @xmath47 .
this leaves us with six @xmath43-dependent coefficients @xmath48 , @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 .
it is convenient to express them in terms of the thermodynamic fluxes ( irreversible flows ) .
let us start with the viscous pressure which is defined as , = d_p_p^p^f^(0)(1+f^(0 ) ) .
putting @xmath14 from eq .
( [ phi ] ) we get = -t^2 a_2_p ^2 f^(0)(1 + f^(0 ) ) in which terms containing @xmath54 and @xmath55 vanish due to the properties of summation invariance .
note that only the scalar coefficients of @xmath14 appear owing to the fact that only inner product of irreducible tensors of same rank survive @xcite .
defining @xmath56 we finally get = nt_2a_2 .
[ bulk1 ] we next turn to the energy 4-flow which is defined as i_q^=d _
p p_^ ( pu - h ) f^(0)(1+f^(0 ) ) . on putting @xmath14 it retains only the vector coefficients in it by virtue of inner product properties of irreducible tensors and yields i_q^&=&-t^2(b_1)_p ^^_(-)^f^(0)(1 + f^(0 ) ) + & = & ntb_1^_1 , [ th1 ] with @xmath57 .
finally we have the traceless viscous tensor defined by ^=_p ( _ ^ _ ^
-_^ ) p^p^ f^(0)(1+f^(0 ) ) . proceeding as before we define the tensor coefficient in @xmath14 as ^=-
_ 0 c_0^ , [ shear1 ] with @xmath58 and @xmath59 is the mass density . to obtain the remaining coefficients @xmath60 , @xmath61 and @xmath62 of equation ( [ a ] ) and ( [ b ] ) we utilize the conservation laws obtained by asserting that the number density , energy density and the hydrodynamic 4-velocity can be completely determined by the equilibrium distribution function
this leads to the following constraint equations for the deviation function @xmath14 d_p p^u_f^(0)(1+f^(0))=0 , [ con1 ] + d_p ( p^u_)^2 f^(0)(1+f^(0))=0 , [ con2 ] + d_p p^f^(0)(1+f^(0))=0 .
[ con3 ] putting the value of @xmath14 in the eqs .
( [ con1 ] ) and ( [ con2 ] ) we obtain relations involving coefficients @xmath44 giving , a_1a_0+a_2a_1+a_3a_2=0 , [ a1 ] + a_2a_0+a_3a_1+a_4a_2=0 , [ a2 ] with @xmath63 . since @xmath50 is known from ( [ bulk1 ] ) the other two @xmath44 s can be determined .
similarly the relation between the coefficients @xmath64 coming from eq .
( [ con3 ] ) is , b_^0^b_0+b_^1^b_1=0 , [ b1 ] with @xmath65 .
details of the calculation are discussed in appendix - b .
using equations ( [ bulk1],[th1],[shear1],[a1],[a2],[b1 ] ) we obtain the complete set of coefficient functions in terms of the thermodynamic flows .
these are given by a_0= & & + a_1= & & + a_2= & & + b_0=&&(- ) + b_1= & & + c_0^=&&-^ .
defining all the space - time dependent coefficients appearing in eq .
( [ phi ] ) in terms of the known functions it is now possible to specify the deviation function @xmath14 completely .
we now use it in eq .
( [ tt2 ] ) to evaluate the equations of motion for the dissipative fluxes .
taking inner product of both sides of eq .
( [ tt2 ] ) with @xmath66 and applying the ( inner product ) properties of irreducible tensors @xcite we obtain the equation of motion for bulk viscous pressure , = , [ bulk11 ] where _ = & & \{+a_5 } , + _ = & & [ ( -b_3)+(1-)()a_4 + \{((-1)-)()-}a_3 ] .
the terms @xmath67 appearing above are defined as @xmath68 , @xmath69 denoting the modified bessel function of order @xmath70 with @xmath71 .
the integrals @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 have been defined earlier .
their explicit forms as well as those of the @xmath37 s and @xmath38 s expressed in terms of @xmath67 appear in appendices d and a respectively .
also the number density @xmath35 can be expressed as @xmath76 .
retaining only the first term on the right hand side of ( [ bulk11 ] ) the equation for the bulk viscous pressure reduces to the same as in the first order theory of dissipative fluids .
the coefficient of this term corresponds to the bulk viscous coefficient @xmath77 and is given by = t. [ zeta ] the quantity @xmath78 in the denominator of ( [ zeta ] ) stems from the collision integral containing the interaction cross section and is described in appendix c. note that eq .
( [ bulk11 ] ) contains the time derivative of the bulk viscous pressure and is hyperbolic .
this yields a relaxation time for bulk viscous flow given by _
= _ .
in this case we take the inner product of both sides of equation ( [ tt2 ] ) with @xmath79 . following similar techniques as above
we get the equation for heat flow , i_q^=t , with _ = & & -\{(b_3-)-3 } , + _ = & & \{+ } , + _ = & & [ \{b_1+b_2+b_3}+ ] . the factors @xmath80 and
@xmath81 expressed in terms of @xmath67 are given in appendix - d .
the reduced enthalpy per particle @xmath82 can be expressed as @xmath83 .
the thermal conductivity in this approach is given by = - , where @xmath84 follows from the collision term and is defined in appendix - c .
so from the above equation the relaxation time for heat flow is obtained as _
= t _ . multiplying both sides of equation ( [ tt2 ] ) with @xmath85 and using similar techniques as before produces the equation of motion for shear viscous pressure and is given by , ^= , [ sheareq ] with _ = , + _ = [ -(6+z ) ] . the shear viscosity @xmath86 is defined as the coefficient of the first term of ( [ sheareq ] ) . in this approach it is obtained as = .
here again @xmath87 contains the dynamics of interaction and is described in appendix - c . from ( [ sheareq ] ) the relaxation time for shear viscous flow
is given by _
scattering with self - energy corrections ] it is clear from the above expressions that the microscopic dynamics concerning the @xmath0 interaction which governs the transport coefficients enters through the cross - section appearing in the collision integral . adopting a phenomenological approach we consider @xmath0 interaction to occur via @xmath2 and @xmath1 meson exchange using the well - known interaction @xcite = g_^_+g_m_where @xmath88 and @xmath2 denote the isovector pion and scalar sigma fields respectively and the couplings are given by @xmath89 and @xmath90 . as indicated in fig .
[ one_loop ] , the meson propagators in the @xmath91-channel diagrams are replaced with effective ones obtained by a dyson - schwinger sum of one loop self - energy diagrams involving the pion . the matrix - elements for @xmath0 scattering in the isospin basis is then given in terms of the mandelstam variables @xmath91 , @xmath92 and @xmath93 as _ i=0&=&2g_^2 + & + & g_^2 m_^2 +
_ i=1&=&g_^2 + & + & g_^2 m_^2 .
[ amp ] where we have ignored the non - resonant @xmath94 contribution .
the terms @xmath95 and @xmath96 appearing in the isoscalar and isovector amplitudes respectively denote the vacuum self - energies of the @xmath2 and @xmath1 involving only the pion in the loop diagrams .
the cross - section obtained from the isospin averaged amplitude @xmath97 is shown by the dashed line in fig .
[ sigmafig ] and agrees very well with the estimate based on measured phase - shifts given in @xcite . in this way it is ensured that the dynamical model used above is normalized against experimental data in vacuum . in order to obtain the in - medium cross - section the self - energy diagrams are now evaluated at finite temperature using the techniques of thermal field theory in the real - time formalism @xcite . for the @xmath2 meson
only the @xmath0 loop diagram is calculated in the medium whereas in case of the @xmath1 meson in addition to the @xmath0 loop graph , @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 self - energy graphs are evaluated using interactions from chiral perturbation theory @xcite .
in contrast to @xmath95 which is scalar , @xmath96 has longitudinal and transverse parts and are defined as @xcite ^t=-(_^+_00 ) , ^l=_00 , _ 00u^u^ _ [ pitpil ] where @xmath101 is the 4-velocity of the thermal bath and @xmath102 . the momentum dependence being weak
@xcite we take an average over the polarizations , _
= [ 2^t+q^2^l ] . the imaginary part of the self - energy obtained by evaluating the loop diagrams can be expressed as @xcite & & i m ( q_0,)=- + & & [ impi_a ] where @xmath103 is the be distribution function with arguments @xmath104 and @xmath105 .
the terms @xmath106 and @xmath107 relate to factors coming from the vertex etc , details of which can be found in @xcite .
the angular integration is done using the @xmath108-functions which define the kinematic domains for occurrence of scattering and decay processes leading to loss or gain of @xmath1 ( or @xmath2 ) mesons in the medium . in order to account for the substantial @xmath109 and @xmath110 branching ratios of the unstable particles in the loop
the self - energy function is convoluted with their spectral functions @xcite , ( q , m_h)&= & ^(m_h+2_h)^2_(m_h-2_h)^2dm^2 + & & ( q , m ) with n_h&=&^(m_h+2_h)^2_(m_h-2_h)^2dm^2 + & & in which @xmath111 and @xmath112 stand for the vacuum mass and width of the unstable meson @xmath113 . the contribution from the loops with these unstable particles can thus be looked upon as multi - pion effects in @xmath0 scattering .
cross - section as a function of @xmath114 .
the dashed line corresponds to scattering in vacuum .
dot - dashed line refers to the in - medium cross - section involving only the pion loop for the @xmath2 and @xmath1 mesons .
the solid line corresponds to the additional loops in the @xmath1 meson self - energy . ] in relativistic heavy ion collisions , below the crossover temperature inelastic reactions cease and this leads to chemical freeze - out of hadrons . since only elastic collisions occur the number - density gets fixed at this temperature and to conserve it a phenomenological chemical potential is introduced which increases with decreasing temperature until kinetic freeze - out is reached @xcite . in this work we use the numerical results of the temperature - dependent pion chemical potential from the work of @xcite where the above scenario is implemented .
it is depicted by the parametric form ( t)=a+bt+ct^2+dt^3 with @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 , @xmath118 and @xmath119 , @xmath120 in mev .
we plot in fig .
[ sigmafig ] the total @xmath0 cross - section defined by @xmath121 with @xmath122 .
the increase in the imaginary part of the self - energy due to scattering and decay processes in the medium results in enlarged widths of the exchanged @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
this is manifested in a suppression of the magnitude of the cross - section and a small downward shift in the peak position as a function of the c.m .
the effect is larger when more loops are included in the @xmath1 self - energy compared to the pion loop as shown by the solid and dash - dotted lines in fig .
[ sigmafig ] .
we now present the results of numerical evaluation of the relaxation times .
we start with the relaxation time of the bulk viscous flow @xmath123 , as a function of temperature . in fig .
[ bulk ] two sets of curves are displayed which correspond to two different values of the pion chemical potentials .
the curves in the lower set ( with circles ) are evaluated with a constant value of pion chemical potential .
we take this value to be @xmath124 mev which is representative of the kinetic freeze - out in heavy ion collisions . the upper set consisting of curves with triangles
show results for the temperature dependent pion chemical potential @xmath125 .
the three different curves in each set show the effect of the medium on account of the @xmath0 cross section .
the dotted curves show results where the vacuum cross - section is used .
we have checked that our estimates for this case agree with @xcite for constant values of the pion chemical potential .
the dashed curves depict medium effects corresponding to the pion loop in the @xmath2 and @xmath1 propagators .
the relaxation times appear enhanced with respect to the vacuum ones indicating the effect of the thermal medium on @xmath123 .
finally the uppermost solid curves correspond to the situation when the heavy mesons are included in the @xmath1 propagator , i.e. for @xmath126 loops where @xmath127 .
the larger effect of the medium on @xmath123 seen in this case is brought about by a larger suppression of the cross - section which appears in the denominator .
the clear separation between the curves in each set displays a significant effect brought about by the medium dependence of the @xmath0 cross section .
also the two sets of curves appear nicely separated showing the significant difference caused by a constant value of the pion chemical potential @xmath124 mev and a temperature dependent one which decreases from 85 mev at kinetic freeze - out ( @xmath128 mev ) to zero at chemical freeze - out ( @xmath129 mev ) @xcite .
consequently the upper set is seen to merge with the lower one at @xmath128 mev . 0.2 in ]
next we plot in fig .
[ lambda ] the relaxation time for the irreversible heat flow , @xmath130 against temperature for the same two different values of pion chemical potentials mentioned above . in each set
the curves are plotted for different @xmath0 cross sections .
similar to the earlier case here also we notice that the medium modified cross sections evaluated at finite temperature influence the temperature dependence of @xmath130 which appear enhanced for the in medium cases with respect to the vacuum ones .
the multi - pion loop contribution due to heavier mesons in the @xmath1 propagator turns out to be more significant than the @xmath0 loop . 0.2 in finally we present the results for @xmath131 , i.e , the relaxation time of the shear viscous flow in fig . [ shear ] .
the curves are seen to follow the same trend corresponding to the cases described above though the magnitudes are a little lower . for the case of constant @xmath120 , given by the lower set of curves ,
this has already been seen in @xcite . recalling that @xmath132 , its smaller variation with temperature is due to the fact that the increase of @xmath86 with @xmath119 is largely compensated by the decrease in @xmath133 , @xmath134 remaining approximately constant in the temperature range shown .
when @xmath125 is used , the density @xmath35 is larger at higher temperatures where @xmath120 is smaller .
consequently , this compensating effect is enhanced resulting in an almost insignificant variation of @xmath135 with temperature .
note that the relaxation times for dissipative flows which have been plotted in figs .
[ bulk ] , [ lambda ] and [ shear ] on the same scale come out to be of similar magnitude .
the first order coefficients however are quite largely separated .
the bulk viscosity @xmath77 is generally much smaller than @xmath86 as seen in e.g. @xcite .
consequently , bulk viscosity and thermal conductivity are usually ignored in the set of hydrodynamic equations .
in this work we have evaluated the relaxation times of dissipative fluxes in the kinetic theory approach using grad s 14-moment method for the case of a pion gas .
our aim has been to estimate the in - medium effects on the temperature dependence of the relaxation times .
using an effective lagrangian the @xmath0 scattering amplitudes involving @xmath1 and @xmath2 meson exchange have been evaluated in which one - loop self - energy corrections were incorporated to obtain the in - medium propagators . the consequent decrease in the effective cross - section
is found to have an appreciable effect on the temperature dependence of the relaxation times of the irreversible flows .
since these go as inputs in the second order viscous hydrodynamic equations it is expected that the space - time evolution of heavy ion collisions will be affected significantly .
so a realistic evaluation of these quantities is essential to obtain the proper temperature profile and consequently the cooling laws of the evolving system .
in addition it is found that the relaxation times of the bulk viscous flow and the heat flow to be of similar magnitude to that of the shear viscous flow which suggests that they should all be taken into consideration in dissipative hydrodynamic simulations .
the equations of motion of the thermodynamic variables follow from the conservation of particle number and energy - momentum along with the contraction of the last quantity with the hydrodynamic four - velocity @xmath136 and the projection operator @xmath137 .
the evolution equations of particle number , four - velocity and energy density along with those of temperature and chemical potential for a dissipative fluid are respectively given by dn=&&-nu .
[ con ] + hndu^=&&^p-^__^-^_di_q^ + ( hn)^-1^_p + & & -i_q^u - i_q^_u^ , [ eqmtn ] + nde=&&-pu- _ i_q^+^_u _ , [ eqen ] + t^-1dt=&&(1-)[u+\{_i_q^-^_u _ } ] , [ eqtem ] + td\{}=&&\{(-1)h- t}[u+\{_i_q^ -^_u _ } ] + & & -\{_i_q^-^_u_}. [ eqchm ] where , = = 1 + = = + =. in the first order theory
all the flows and dissipative quantities are ignored in the above equations of motion since these are first order in the gradients , while the thermodynamic variables are of zeroth order @xcite .
so in chapman - enskog method the equations of motion ( [ con]-[eqchm ] ) have been used as thermodynamic identities excluding the dissipative terms like @xmath138 and @xmath139 as given in @xcite . in case of the second order theory the space of thermodynamic quantities
is expanded to include the dissipative quantities which are treated as thermodynamic variables in their own right .
however , close to equilibrium the gradients of macroscopic variables may be treated as small quantities of the order of @xmath14 . also ,
terms like @xmath140 and @xmath141 which are products of the fluxes and gradients are of higher order in @xmath14 . following @xcite we neglect such higher order terms in equations ( [ con]-[eqchm ] ) .
the zeroth order distribution function @xmath18 contains a few arbitrary parameters which are identified with the temperature , chemical potential and hydrodynamic 4-velocity of the system by asserting that the number density , energy density and the hydrodynamic velocity are completely determined by the equilibrium distribution function .
we thus write the number and energy densities as n = g_p p^u_f = g_p p^u_f^(0 ) , + en = g_p ( p^u_)^2f = g_p ( p^u_)^2f^(0 ) where @xmath142 is the isospin degeneracy of pions . furthermore , from eckart s definition of the hydrodynamic velocity we get , ^n_=_p^p_f^(0)=0 . from the above three equations
we obtain equations ( [ con1]),([con2 ] ) and ( [ con3 ] ) which on substitution in the expression for @xmath14 results in , & & _ p a(x , ) f^(0)(1+f^(0))=0 , + & & _ p ^2 a(x , ) f^(0)(1+f^(0))=0 , + & & _ p ^b_(x , ) ^f^(0)(1+f^(0))=0 . expanding the coefficients @xmath44 and @xmath64 according to equations ( [ a ] ) and ( [ b ] ) , we finally obtain ( [ a1 ] ) , ( [ a2 ] ) and ( [ b1 ] ) .
here we elaborate on the coefficients of bulk viscosity , thermal conductivity and shear viscosity which are given by & = & t + & = & - + & = & .
the numerators have been defined earlier .
the quantities @xmath78 , @xmath84 and @xmath87 are defined in terms of the collision bracket = d_p d_k d_p d_kf^(0)(p)f^(0)(k ) \{1+f^(0)(p)}\{1+f^(0)(k)}(f)(g ) w [ bracket ] with ( f)&=&f(p)+f(k)-f(p)-f(k ) + ( g)&=&g(p)+g(k)-g(p)-g(k ) . in particular , a_22=&&[^2,^2 ] , + b_11=&&_[^,^ ] , + c_00=&&[__,^^ ] .
they can be expressed in terms of the integral @xmath143 as a_22=z^2x_3(z ) b_11=-z[x_2(z)+x_3(z ) ] and c_00=2[x_1(z)+x_2(z)+x_3(z ) ] where @xcite x_(z)&= & e^(-2/t)_0^d ^3 ^ 7_0^d(,)_0 ^ 2 d + & & _ 0^d^2 _ 0^d m _ ( , ) with e&=&z(-)-/t + f&=&z(-)-/t + g&=&e+2z + h&=&f+2z .
the functions @xmath144 stand for m_1(,)&=&1-^2 , + m_2(,)&=&^2+^2 -2 , + m_3(,)&=&[^2-^2]^2 and =- .
in this appendix we provide explicit forms of some integrals which have appeared in the expressions for the transport coefficients in the text . recall that @xmath63 from which we obtain a_1=&&\ { } , + a_2=&&\{z-1 } , + a_3=&&z^2\{+3z^-1 } , + a_4=&&z^3\{15z^-2 + 2z^-1 + } , + a_5=&&z^4[6z^-1\{+15z^-2}+\{+15z^-2 } ] , and from @xmath65 we have b_0=- & & , + b_1=-&&z , + b_2=-&&\{5z+z^2 } , + b_3=-&&\{30z+5z^2+z^3}. | the relaxation times over which dissipative fluxes restore their steady state values have been evaluated for a pion gas using the 14-moment method .
the effect of the medium has been implemented through a temperature dependent @xmath0 cross - section in the collision integral which is obtained by including one - loop self - energies in the propagators of the exchanged @xmath1 and @xmath2 mesons . to account for chemical freeze out in heavy ion collisions ,
a temperature dependent pion chemical potential has been introduced in the distribution function .
the temperature dependence of the relaxation times for shear and bulk viscous flows as well as the heat flow is significantly affected . |
dichroism is a well known concept in classical optics where it denotes the property shown by certain materials of having absorption coefficients which depend on the state of polarization of the incident light @xcite .
this concept has been further extended to the case of atomic or molecular interactions with a radiation field .
in particular , the notion of circular dichroism in angular distribution ( cdad ) refers to the difference between the differential cross sections ( dcs ) of laser assisted signals for _ left _ ( @xmath0 ) and _ right _
( @xmath1 ) circularly polarized ( @xmath2 ) light @xcite . here
we investigate the effect of the photon state of polarization , _ i.e. _ of its helicity , in laser - assisted high energy electron - hydrogen scattering .
we show under what conditions cdad is observable at high scattering energies as a result of _ target dressing _ by the laser field .
we consider optical frequencies and moderate field intensities and apply a hybrid calculational approach @xcite .
the interaction between the projectile and the field is treated exactly , while the interaction between the atom and the field is treated in perturbation theory .
first order born approximation is used to evaluate the scattering amplitude .
we demonstrate that cdad is encountered , provided i ) the electromagnetic field is a superposition of two laser beams , one of which is linearly polarized ( @xmath3 ) and the other is a @xmath2 field , ii ) second order dressing of the target by the electromagnetic field is included .
in addition , iii ) the role of the virtual transitions to the continuum is shown to be essential for the observation of cdad .
finally , we demonstrate that for a special configuration not only cdad but also cd for the integrated cross sections can be observed .
atomic units are used .
we consider electron - hydrogen scattering in the presence of an electromagnetic field that is a superposition of two laser beams .
one beam is @xmath3 , with polarization vector @xmath4 , while the other is @xmath2 with polarization vector @xmath5 .
the beams can have different directions of propagation .
for simplicity , we discuss the case where the two beams have the same frequency @xmath6 and intensity @xmath7 . in dipole approximation
the resulting field is @xmath8 where the intensity @xmath9 .
we want to know whether the dcs are sensitive to the helicity of the @xmath2 photons , defined by @xmath10 which explicitly depends on the direction @xmath11 of propagation of the @xmath12 beam . as shown in @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , for high energies of the projectiles cdad does not occur for a @xmath2 laser field _
alone , _ since the first order born approximation leads to real scattering amplitudes .
we therefore present the theory for the above superposition of fields . according to @xcite , at moderate laser field intensities
the field - atom interaction can be described by time - dependent perturbation theory ( tdpt ) .
we consider _ second order _ _ dressing _ of the hydrogen ground state by the field ( [ field ] ) .
the approximate solution for an atomic electron in an electromagnetic field reads @xmath13 , \label{fun}\ ] ] where @xmath14 is the unperturbed ground state of hydrogen , of energy @xmath15 . @xmath16
denote first and second order corrections , respectively . on account of @xcite and @xcite these corrections can be expressed in terms of @xmath17 and @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the coulomb green s function and @xmath20 the momentum operator of the bound electron . for the field ( [ field ] ) there are five values of the argument of the green s functions necessary in order to write down the approximate solution ( [ fun ] ) , namely @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 . a projectile of kinetic energy @xmath24 and momentum @xmath25 , moving in the field ( [ field ] ) , is described by the volkov solution @xmath26 @xmath27 represents the classical oscillation of the electron in the field @xmath28 , its amplitude is @xmath29 . using graf s addition theorem @xcite , the fourier expansion of ( [ vol ] ) yields a series in terms of ordinary bessel functions @xmath30 @xmath31 according to the definitions of the arguments and phases given in watson s book @xcite , we have @xmath32 and @xmath33 @xmath34 and @xmath35 refer to the @xmath2 field alone , while @xmath36 and @xmath37 are related to the superposition ( [ field ] ) . using ( [ exp1 ] ) , we recognize that a change of helicity of the @xmath2 photons , _ i.e. _ @xmath38 , leads to a change in sign of the dynamical phases @xmath35 and @xmath37 . therefore , looking for the signature of helicity in the angular distributions of laser - assisted signals , we have to observe the presence of these dynamical phases in their dcs . for high scattering energies ,
the first order born approximation in terms of the interaction potential is reliable . neglecting exchange effects , this potential is @xmath39 , and the @xmath40matrix element reads @xmath41 where @xmath42 and @xmath43 are given by ( [ fun ] ) and ( [ vol ] ) .
@xmath44 are the initial(final ) electron momenta .
the dcs for a process in which @xmath45 photons are involved is @xmath46 the scattered electrons have the final energy @xmath47 where @xmath45 is the net number of photons exchanged between the colliding system and the field ( [ field ] ) .
@xmath48 refers to absorption , @xmath49 to emission and @xmath50 describes the elastic process .
the nonlinear transition matrix elements @xmath51 in ( [ sed ] ) have the general structure @xmath52 .
\label{tm - cp}\ ] ] @xmath53 is the dynamical phase in ( [ exp1 ] ) evaluated for the momentum transfer @xmath54 . the first term in ( [ tm - cp ] ) , @xmath55 yields the bunkin - fedorov formula @xcite ( target dressing is neglected ) . here @xmath56 and the bessel function @xmath57 contains all the field intensity dependences of the transition matrix element .
@xmath58 is the amplitude of elastic scattering in the first order born approximation , @xmath59 .
the remaining terms in ( [ tm - cp ] ) describe the dressing of the atom by the field ( [ field ] ) , they were discussed in detail in @xcite . in the case of @xmath60
_ one _ of the @xmath45 photons exchanged between the colliding system and the field is interacting with the bound electron , while in @xmath61 _ two _ of the @xmath45 photons interact with the atomic electron .
these dressing terms in ( [ tm - cp ] ) are @xmath62{\cal j}_{1,0,1}(\tau ^{+},\tau ^{-},q ) \label{t1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath63 \\ + j_{n+2}({\cal z}_q)[{|\vec{q}\cdot \vec{e}+\vec{q}\cdot \vec{\varepsilon}|^2% } { q^{-2}}{\cal t}_1+(1 + 2\vec{e}\cdot { \vec{\varepsilon}}^{\;*})e^{2i\psi _ q}% { \cal t}_2 ] \\ + j_n({\cal z}_q)[{|\vec{q}\cdot \vec{e}+\vec{q}\cdot \vec{\varepsilon}|^2}{% q^{-2}}\widetilde{{\cal t}}_1 + 2(1+{\rm re\;}\vec{\varepsilon}^{\;*}\cdot \vec{e})\widetilde{{\cal t}}_2]\}. \end{array } \label{t2}\ ] ] the five radial integrals , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 in ( [ t1])-([t2 ] ) , depend on @xmath69 and on the parameters of the coulomb green s functions .
the integral @xmath64 is a function of the two parameters @xmath70 through @xmath71 ( see @xcite ) , while @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath72 and @xmath68 depend on four parameters @xcite .
@xmath73 and @xmath66 are multiplied by @xmath74 if both photons are absorbed / emitted by the atomic electron . in the last line of ( [ t2 ] ) , @xmath67 and @xmath68 are multiplied by @xmath30 . here
two photons interact with the atomic electron , but one is emitted and the other is absorbed . for our numerical calculations we used the analytic expressions for the above five radial integrals presented in @xcite and @xcite-@xcite .
equivalent expressions were published for the case of single photon transitions in @xcite-@xcite and for two photon absorption / emission in @xcite .
the transition matrix elements for first and second order dressing in ( [ t1])-([t2 ] ) are written in a form that permits to analyze their dependence on the dynamical phase @xmath53 .
we see that @xmath75 and @xmath76 do not depend on the helicity ( [ hel ] ) . on the other hand
, @xmath77 has an explicit dependence on @xmath78 determined by the phase factors that multiply @xmath66 in ( [ t2 ] ) . due to the structure of @xmath77 ,
it is evident that in the absence of the @xmath3 component of the field ( [ field ] ) the dynamical phase @xmath53 is absent and hence there is no cdad .
indeed , both polarization terms multiplying @xmath66 would be zero since @xmath79 .
this demonstrates the essential role of the @xmath3 beam and the necessity to include second order dressing of the target . in order to stress the important role of the virtual transitions to the continuum
, we shall consider small scattering angles . here
the dressing of the target is considerable and the cdad effect can be large .
for small arguments of the bessel functions , _ i.e_. either for weak fields at any scattering angle or for moderate fields at small scattering angles , we can keep the leading terms in ( [ tm - cp ] ) only .
we discuss in some detail the case @xmath80 .
the corresponding matrix element is @xmath81 , \label{abs}\ ] ] where the amplitudes @xmath82 and @xmath83 depend on @xmath84 and on @xmath6 @xmath85 , \label{a } \\ { \cal b}\left ( q;\omega \right ) & = & { \omega ^2}{\cal t}_2 .
\label{b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the dcs derived from ( [ abs ] ) are @xmath86\}. \label{fin}\end{aligned}\ ] ] they depend on the change of helicity only if @xmath87 and @xmath88 . as shown in @xcite and @xcite , this is true if virtual transitions to continuum states are energetically allowed , _
i.e_. if @xmath89 or @xmath90 .
cdad , defined as the difference between the dcs for @xmath91 and @xmath92 , follows from ( [ fin ] ) as @xmath93 where @xmath94 and thus @xmath95 gives the angular depence of @xmath96 .
we easily verify that the three conditions i)-iii ) , quoted in the introduction , are all necessary to have @xmath97 , namely ( i ) @xmath98 if the @xmath3 field is absent , ( ii ) @xmath99 stems from second order target dressing , and ( iii ) @xmath82 and @xmath99 become real as soon as @xmath100 .
next we study the angular dependence of @xmath101 .
two cases are of major interest : @xmath102 if @xmath103 , then the superposition of @xmath3 and @xmath104 is equivalent to elliptic polarization ( @xmath105 ) and we write @xmath106 .
hence @xmath107 where @xmath108 are the projections of @xmath109 on the axes @xmath110 of the @xmath2 vector @xmath111 .
here @xmath112 leads to cdad but integrating it over @xmath113 in the azimuthal plane yields zero .
expression ( [ edad ] ) is comparable to that of elliptic dichroism in photoionization @xcite .
@xmath114 if @xmath115 , then cdad reads @xmath116 { \rm % im}\left ( { \cal a}^{\;*}{\cal b}\right ) .
\label{cd}\ ] ] taking in addition @xmath117 , then the term proportional to @xmath118 gets @xmath113-independent and its contribution survives in the azimuthally integrated cross sections .
thus , the choice of a privileged direction in the problem , namely that of @xmath119 , introduces an additional asymmetry .
therefore , the signature of the photon helicity prevails not only in the angular distribution but also in the integrated cross sections . to the best of our knowledge ,
this is the first case of a laser - assisted process in which cd in the integrated cross sections is encountered .
finally , we stress the importance of the form of our @xmath120-matrix element ( [ abs ] ) , since a more general structure @xmath121 was also found in discussions of dichroism in other processes , like two - photon ionization @xcite-@xcite , two - photon detachement of h@xmath122 @xcite or elastic x - ray scattering by ground state atoms @xcite .
of course , the meaning of the vectors @xmath123 is specific to each process . in all these cases dichroism
is caused by interferences between the real and imaginary parts of the amplitude and two terms with different angular behavior are needed to get such interferences . in the examples above , @xmath124 and @xmath45 were complex quantities . our conditions , @xmath125 or @xmath90 ,
serve the same purpose .
contrary to our problem , in photoionization or photodetachment of unpolarized systems there is no equivalent for our privileged direction @xmath126 and hence only cdad is observable .
we present numerical results for cdad and cd in laser - assisted electron - hydrogen scattering at high energies .
we analyze the dcs for @xmath127 since here the cdad effects are large enough . using the above formalism
, we evaluated the dcs ( [ sed ] ) in the azimuthal plane as a function of @xmath128 for a fixed scattering angle @xmath129 and for the initial scattering energy @xmath130 ev .
our laser frequency was @xmath131 ev , taken close to an atomic resonance in order to enhance the cd effects , and we chose the moderate field intensity @xmath132 w@xmath133 .
the initial electron momentum @xmath134 was taken parallel to the @xmath3 vector @xmath135 , both pointing along the @xmath136axis and the @xmath3 beam propagated in the @xmath137-plane . in case
@xmath102 the @xmath2 beam propagated in the @xmath138direction and the corresponding @xmath2 vector @xmath139 has helicity @xmath140 known as @xmath141 while @xmath142 has opposite helicity @xmath143 , representing @xmath92 .
in this configuration we have @xmath144 . in figure 1(a ) we present for @xmath80 with @xmath145 the @xmath146dependence of the dcs at @xmath129 .
the data for @xmath91 are shown by a dotted line and for @xmath92 by a dashed line .
clearly , the laser - assisted signals depend on the helicity of the photon . in figure 1(b ) we present the results for cdad ( [ edad ] ) . since here @xmath147 , the @xmath148 and @xmath149 in the two lobes indicate this dependence . if @xmath150 gets integrated over @xmath113 , the net cd effect is zero .
similar results and conclusions are obtained for @xmath151 . for case @xmath114 the @xmath2 beam propagated in the @xmath152direction and the @xmath2 vector
is @xmath153 so that now @xmath154 the @xmath3 beam propagated as before .
figure 2 shows the dcs ( [ sed ] ) and the cdad ( [ cd ] ) for @xmath80 in panel ( a ) and for @xmath151 in panel ( b ) .
dotted lines are for @xmath91 and dashed ones for @xmath92 .
full lines are used for @xmath101 ( [ cd ] ) where explicitly @xmath155 due to this angular dependence , the integration of @xmath101 over @xmath128 does not vanish .
since the final momentum @xmath156 depends on @xmath45 , the shape of the azimuthal dependence of @xmath101 is different for absorption and emission .
our data show that the maximum value of dichroism can amount up to @xmath157 of the assisted signal .
this is comparable to or even larger than the effect predicted for x - ray scattering @xcite or for two - photon ionization @xcite .
similar to the case of x - ray scattering , the dichroism in our case is increasing with increasing laser frequency .
in free - free transitions at high scattering energy the dichroic effects stem from target dressing , which is increasing with the photon frequency .
target dressing is significant for rather small scattering angles .
we therefore expect that dichroism is large in this angular domain , and not near @xmath158 as for x - ray scattering and two - photon ionization .
summarizing , we considered scattering of high energy electrons by hydrogen atoms in the presence of a laser field of moderate power but higher frequencies .
the field had two components of equal frequency and intensity .
one of the components was circularly , the other linearly polarized .
the two laser beams were permitted to propagate in different directions . in the first order
born approximation we showed that in the above scattering configuration cdad becomes observable in two - photon transitions if laser - dressing of the atomic target is carried out in second order tdpt and transitions between atomic bound and continuum states are energetically allowed , requiring higher laser frequencies . since the scattering probabilities decrease with increasing @xmath6 , we prefered to choose @xmath159 close to an atomic resonance to enhence the signals .
thanks to the above laser configuration and second order target dressing , the @xmath120-matrix elements become complex as a prerequisite for predicting cdad in the born approximation , since the elastic born - amplitude is real .
we conclude that at high projectile energies cdad in free - free transitions is a second order field - assisted effect occurring under special conditions only .
in particular , the matrix elements of the process considered have to be complex .
similar effects might occur , if higher order terms of the born series are taken into account , since we know that then the scattering matrix elements become complex .
finally , we stress the role of the two asymmetries which were introduced into the scattering configuration in order to obtain helicity dependent nonlinear signals .
one asymmetry came in by the @xmath3 laser .
this was sufficient to achieve cdad .
a second asymmetry was determined by the momentum @xmath134 of the ingoing electrons .
the two asymmetries together , more precisely @xmath160 , then led to cd that even persists if the dcs are integrated over @xmath113 . in photoionization and photodetachement there is no equivalent to @xmath161 . hence ,
in those processes only cdad is encountered .
the analysis of the structure of the two photon transition matrix element led us to a general formula for cdad and to our undestanding of the physical reasons of the configuration necessary to obtain cdad and cd , respectively .
1 : refers to case @xmath102 , _
i.e. _ @xmath162 .
we present for @xmath80 the dcs as function of the angle @xmath113 at the scattering angle @xmath129 .
the initial electron energy is @xmath130 ev , the radiation frequency is @xmath163 ev and its intensity @xmath132 w@xmath133 .
the panel ( a ) shows the data for _ lcp _ as dotted line and the data for _ rcp _ as dashed line . clearly , the laser - assisted signals depend on the helicity of the photons . in panel
( b ) the cdad effect is visible but integration over @xmath128 yields zero.fig .
2 : treats case @xmath114 , _
i.e. _ latexmath:[$\vec{k}_i||\stackrel{\rightarrow } { e}% fig . 1
, we show the @xmath113-dependence of the dcs in panel ( a ) for @xmath80 and ( b ) for @xmath151 .
signals for _ lcp _ are dotted lines and signals for _ rcp _ are dashed lines .
the cdad effects are represented by full lines .
integrating these data over @xmath165 a non - vanishing cd effect remains .
the dependence of the effects on photon emission / absorbtion is apparent . | we consider high energy electron scattering by hydrogen atoms in the presence of a laser field of moderate power and higher frequencies .
if the field is a superposition of a linearly and a circularly polarized laser beam in a particular configuration , then we can show that circular dichroism in two photon transitions can be observed not only for the differential but also for the integrated cross sections , provided the laser - dressing of the atomic target is treated in second order perturbation theory and the coupling between hydrogenic bound and continuum states is involved .
pacs numbers : 34.80.qb ; 34.50.rk ; 32.80.wr this is the revtex shell . |
electronically tuned microwave oscillators are key components used in a wide variety of microwave communications systems @xcite . the phase of the output signal exhibits fluctuations in time about the steady state oscillations giving rise to phase noise a very important characteristic that influences the overall performance especially at higher microwave frequencies . in order to understand the oscillator phase behaviour ,
a statistical model for a non - linear oscillating circuit has to be developed and presently , no accurate theoretical model for phase noise characterization is available because of the particularly difficult nature of this problem .
this is due to the hybrid nature of non - linear microwave oscillator circuits where distributed elements ( pertaining usually to the associated feeding or resonator circuits ) and non - linear elements ( pertaining usually to the amplifiying circuit ) have to be dealt with simultaneously @xcite .
the main aim of this report is to establish a theoretical framework for dealing with the noise sources and non- linearities present in these oscillators , introduce a new methodology to calculate the resonance frequency and evaluate the time responses ( waveforms ) for various voltages and currents in the circuit without or with the noise present .
once this is established , the phase noise spectrum is determined and afterwards the validity range of the model is experimentally gauged with the use of different types of microwave oscillators @xcite .
this report is organised in the following way : section ii covers the theoretical analysis for the oscillating circuit , reviews noise source models and earlier approches .
section iii presents results of the theoretical analysis and highlights the determination of the resonance frequency for some oscillator circuits without noise . in section iv ,
phase noise spectra are determined for several oscillator circuits and section v contains the experimental results .
the appendix contains circuit diagrams and corresponding state equations for several non - linear oscillator circuits .
in standard microwave analysis , it is difficult to deal with distributed elements in the time domain and difficult to deal with non - linear elements in the frequency domain .
non- linear microwave oscillator circuits have simultaneously non- linear elements in the amplifying part and distributed elements in the resonating part [ non - linearity is needed since it is well known that only non - linear circuits have stable oscillations ] . before we tackle , in detail , the determination of the phase noise , let us describe the standard procedure for dealing with the determination of resonance frequency of non - linear oscillator circuits : * the first step is to develop a circuit model for the oscillator device and the tuning elements .
the equivalent circuit should contain inherently noiseless elements and noise sources that can be added at will in various parts of the circuit .
this separation is useful for pinpointing later on the precise noise source location and its origin @xcite .
the resulting circuit is described by a set of coupled non- linear differential equations that have to be written in a way such that a linear sub - circuit ( usually the resonating part ) is coupled to another non - linear sub - circuit ( usually the oscillating part ) . *
the determination of the periodic response of the non- linear circuit . *
the third step entails performing small signal ac analysis ( linearization procedure ) around the operating point .
the result of the ac analysis is a system matrix which is ill - conditioned since a large discrepency of frequencies are present simultaneously ( one has a factor of one million in going from khz to ghz frequencies ) .
the eigenvalues of this matrix have to be calculated with extra care due to the sensitivity of the matrix elements to any numerical roundoff @xcite .
we differ from the above analysis , by integrating the state equations directly with standard / non- standard runge - kutta methods adapted to the non - stiff / stiff system of ordinary differential equations .
the resonance frequency is evaluated directly from the waveforms and the noise is included at various points in the circuit as johnson or shot noise .
this allows us to deal exclusively with time domain methods for the noiseless / noisy non - linear elements as well as the distributed elements .
the latter are dealt with through an equivalence to lumped elements at a particular frequency .
as far as point 3 is concerned , the linearization procedure method is valid only for small - signal analysis whereas in this situation , we are dealing with the large signal case .
previously , several methods have been developed in order to find the periodic response .
the most well established methods are the harmonic balance and the piecewise harmonic balance methods @xcite .
schwab @xcite has combined the time - domain ( for the non - linear amplifier part ) with the frequency domain ( for the linear resonating part ) methods and transformed the system of equations into a boundary value problem that yields the periodic response of the system .
for illustration and validation of the method we solve 6 different oscillator circuits ( the appendix contains the circuit diagrams and the corresponding state equations ) : * the standard van der pol oscillator . * the amplitude controlled van der pol oscillator . * the clapp oscillator . * the colpitts oscillator .
* model i oscillator .
* model ii oscillator .
we display the time responses ( waveforms ) for various voltages and currents in the attached figures for each of the six oscillators .
all oscillators reach periodic steady state almost instantly except the amplitude controlled van der pol ( acvdp ) and the colpitts circuits .
for instance , we need , typically , several thousand time steps to drive the acvdp circuit into the oscillatory steady state whereas several hundred thousand steps are required for the colpitts circuit .
typically , the rest of the circuits studied reached the periodic steady state in only less a couple of hundred steps .
once the oscillating frequency is obtained , device noise is turned on and its effect on the oscillator phase noise is evaluated .
all the above analysis is performed with time domain simulation techniques .
finally , fourier analysis is applied to the waveform obtained in order to extract the power spectrum as a function of frequency .
very long simulation times ( on the order of several hundred thousand cycles ) are needed since one expects inverse power - law dependencies on the frequency @xcite .
we use a special stochastic time integration method namely the 2s-2o-2 g runge - kutta method developed by klauder and peterson , and we calculate the psd ( power spectral density ) from the time series obtained .
it is worth mentioning that our methodology is valid for any type of oscillator circuit and for any type of noise ( additive white as it is in johnson noise of resistors , mutiplicative and colored or @xmath0 with @xmath1 arbitrary as it is for shot noise stemming from junctions or imperfections inside the device ) .
in addition , the approach we develop is independent of the magnitude of the noise . regardless of the noise intensity we evaluate the time response and later on the power spectrum without performing any perturbative development whatsoever .
recently , kartner @xcite developed a perturbative approach to evaluate the power spectrum without having to integrate the state equations .
his approach is valid for weak noise only and is based on an analytical expression for the power spectrum .
nevertheless one needs to evaluate numerically one fourier coefficient @xmath2 the spectrum depends on .
microwave oscillators are realised using a very wide variety of circuit configurations and resonators .
we plan to design , fabricate and test microstrip oscillators with gaas mesfet devices with coupled lines and ring resonators @xcite .
the measured phase noise of these oscillators will be compared with the theoretical prediction from the above analysis .
we also plan to apply the above analysis to the experimental phase results obtained from various electronically tuned oscillators that have been already published in the literature @xcite .
+ * acknowledgments * : the author would like to thank fx kartner and w. anzill for sending several papers , reports and a thesis that were crucial for the present investigation .
thanks also to s.o .
faried who made several circuit drawings and s. kumar for suggesting two additional circuits ( model i and ii ) to test the software .
v. gngerich , f. zinkler , w. anzill and p. russer , `` noise calculations and experimental results of varacytor tunable oscillators with significantly reduced phase noise , '' ieee transactions on microwave theory and techniques * mtt-43 * 278 ( 1995 ) .
s. heinen , j. kunisch and i. wolff , `` a unified framework for computer - aided noise analysis of linear and non - linear microwave circuits , '' ieee transactions on microwave theory and techniques * mtt-39 * 2170 ( 1991 ) .
in addition , we have : @xmath15 .
+ * state - space equations of clapp oscillator * : + @xmath16\\ \frac{dv_{cte}}{dt } & = & \frac{1}{c_{te } } [ -i_{p } - ( \frac{v_{cte}-v_{ce}}{r_{e}})]\\ \frac{dv_{cta}}{dt } & = & \frac{1}{c_{ta } } [ i_{p } - ( \frac{v_{cta}-v_{ca}}{r_{a}})]\\ \frac{dv_{ca}}{dt } & = & \frac{1}{c_{a } } [ i_{q } + ( \frac{v_{cta}-v_{ca}}{r_{a } } ) - \frac{v_{ca}}{r_{l } } ] \\
\frac{di_{p}}{dt } & = & j_{p } \nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] * state - space equations of coplitts oscillator * : + @xmath22\\ \frac{dv_{2}}{dt } & = & \frac{1}{c_{2 } } [ i_{2 } - i_{b } + ( \frac{v_{0}-v_{2 } -v_{3}}{r_{2 } } ) ] \\
\frac{dv_{3}}{dt } & = & \frac{1}{c_{3 } } [ - i_{b } + ( \frac{v_{0}-v_{2 } -v_{3}}{r_{2 } } ) ] \\
\frac{dv_{4}}{dt } & = & ( \frac{v_{1}-v_{4}}{r_{l}c_{4 } } ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] | we have developed a new methodology and a time - domain software package for the estimation of the oscillation frequency and the phase noise spectrum of non - linear noisy microwave circuits based on the direct integration of the system of stochastic differential equations representing the circuit .
our theoretical evaluations can be used in order to make detailed comparisons with the experimental measurements of phase noise spectra in selected oscillating circuits . |
let @xmath2 be independent and identically distributed ( i.i.d . ) @xmath3-variate random vectors generated from the following model : @xmath4 where @xmath5 is a @xmath3-dimensional unknown vector of means , @xmath6 and @xmath7 are i.i.d .
random vectors with zero mean and common covariance @xmath8 . for the @xmath9th sample
, @xmath10 is a sequence of weakly stationary dependent random variables with zero mean and variances @xmath11 .
motivated by the high - dimensional applications arising in genetics , finance and other fields , the current paper focuses on testing high - dimensional hypotheses @xmath12 the specifications for the sparsity and faintness in the above @xmath13 are the following .
there are @xmath14 nonzero @xmath15 s ( signals ) for a @xmath16 , which are sparse since the signal bearing dimensions constitute only a small fraction of the total @xmath3 dimensions . also under the @xmath13 ,
the signal strength is faint in that the nonzero @xmath17 for @xmath18 .
these specification of the @xmath13 have been the most challenging `` laboratory '' conditions in developing novel testing procedures under high dimensionality .
@xcite pioneered the theory of the higher criticism ( hc ) test which was originally conjectured in @xcite , and showed that the hc test can attain the optimal detection boundary established by @xcite for uncorrelated gaussian random vectors ( @xmath19 ) .
the optimal detection boundary is a phase - diagram in the space of @xmath20 , the two quantities which define the sparsity and the strength of nonzero @xmath15 s under the @xmath13 , such that if @xmath20 lies above the boundary , there exists a test which has asymptotically diminishing probabilities of the type i and type ii errors simultaneously ; and if @xmath20 is below the boundary , no such test exists .
hall and jin ( @xcite , @xcite ) investigated the impacts of the column - wise dependence on the hc test .
in particular , @xcite found that the hc test is adversely affected if the dependence is of long range dependent .
if the dependence is weak , and the covariance matrix is known or can be estimated reliably , the dependence can be utilized to enhance the signal strength of the testing problem so as to improve the performance of the hc test .
the improvement is reflected in lowering the needed signal strength @xmath21 by a constant factor .
@xcite evaluated the hc test under a nonparametric setting allowing column - wise dependence , and showed that the detection boundary of @xcite for the hc test can be maintained under weak column - wise dependence .
@xcite showed that the standard hc test based on the normality assumption can perform poorly when the underlying data deviate from the normal distribution and studied a version of the hc test based on the @xmath22-statistics formulation .
@xcite considered detecting gaussian mixtures which differ from the null in both the mean and the variance .
arias - castro , bubeck and lugosi ( @xcite ) established the lower and upper bounds for the minimax risk for detecting sparse differences in the covariance .
we show in this paper that there are alternative test procedures for weakly dependent sub - gaussian data with unknown covariance which attain the same detection boundary as the hc test established in @xcite for gaussian distributed data with @xmath23 .
the alternative test statistics are obtained by first constructing , for @xmath24 and @xmath25 , @xmath26 which threshold with respect to @xmath27 at a level @xmath28 for @xmath29 , where @xmath30 , @xmath31 is the sample mean of the @xmath32th margin of the data vectors and @xmath33 is the indicator function .
we note that @xmath24 and @xmath25 correspond to the @xmath0 and @xmath1 versions of the thresholding statistics , respectively ; and @xmath34 corresponds to the hc test statistic . in the literature ,
the @xmath0 statistic is called the hard thresholding in @xcite and @xcite , and the @xmath35 statistic is called the clipping thresholding in @xcite .
we then maximize standardized versions of @xmath36 with respect to @xmath37 over @xmath38 , a subset of @xmath39 , which results in the following maximal @xmath40-thresholding statistics : @xmath41 where @xmath42 and @xmath43 are , respectively , estimators of the mean@xmath44 and standard deviation @xmath45 of @xmath46 under @xmath47 , whose forms will be given later in the paper . by developing the asymptotic distributions of @xmath48 ,
the maximal @xmath49-thresholding tests are formulated for @xmath50 and @xmath25 with the maximal @xmath35-test being equivalent to the hc test .
an analysis on the relative power performance of the three tests reveals that if the signal strength parameter @xmath51 , the maximal @xmath1-thresholding test is at least as powerful as the maximal @xmath0-thresholding test , and both the @xmath0 and @xmath1-thresholding tests are at least as powerful as the hc test . if we allow a slightly stronger signal so that @xmath52 , the differential power performance of the three tests is amplified with the maximal @xmath1-test being the most advantageous followed by the maximal @xmath0-test .
in addition to the connection to the hc test , the maximal @xmath53-thresholding test , by its nature of formulation , is related to the high - dimensional multivariate testing procedures , for instance , the tests proposed by @xcite and @xcite . while these tests can maintain accurate size approximation under a diverse range of dimensionality and column - wise dependence , their performance is hampered when the nonzero means are sparse and faint .
the proposed test formulation is also motivated by a set of earlier works including @xcite for selecting significant wavelet coefficients , and @xcite who considered testing for the mean of a random vector @xmath54 with i.i.d .
normally distributed components .
we note that the second step of maximization with respect to @xmath55 is designed to make the test adaptive to the underlying signals strength and sparsity , which is the essence of the hc procedure in @xcite , as well as that of @xcite .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec2 ]
we provide basic results on the @xmath1-thresholding statistic via the large deviation method and the asymptotic distribution of the single threshold statistic .
section [ sec3 ] gives the asymptotic distribution of @xmath56 as well as the associated test procedure .
power comparisons among the hc and the maximal @xmath0 and @xmath1-thresholding tests are made in section [ sec4 ] .
section [ sec5 ] reports simulation results which confirm the theoretical results .
some discussions are given in section [ sec6 ] .
all technical details are relegated to the .
let @xmath57 be an independent random sample from a common distribution @xmath58 , and @xmath59 , where @xmath60 is the vector of means and @xmath61 is a vector consisting of potentially dependent random variables with zero mean and finite variances .
the dependence among @xmath62 is called the column - wise dependence in @xmath63 .
those nonzero @xmath15 are called `` signals . ''
let @xmath64 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 be the sample variance for the @xmath32th margin .
the signal strength in the @xmath32th margin can be measured by the @xmath22-statistics @xmath67 or the @xmath68-statistics @xmath69 if @xmath70 is known . for easy expedition ,
the test statistics will be constructed based on the @xmath68-statistics by assuming @xmath71 is known and , without loss of generality , we assume @xmath72 . using the @xmath22-statistics actually leads to less restrictive conditions for the underlying random variables since the large deviation results for the self - normalized @xmath22-statistics can be established under weaker conditions to allow heavier tails in the underlying distribution as demonstrated in @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
see @xcite for analysis on the sparse signal detection using the @xmath22-statistics .
we assume the following assumptions in our analysis : the dimension @xmath73 as @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
there exists a positive constant @xmath76 such that , for any @xmath77 , @xmath78 for @xmath79\times[-h , h]$ ] and @xmath80 . for each @xmath81 , @xmath82 is a weakly stationary sequence such that @xmath83 and @xmath84 does not depend on @xmath32 for any integer @xmath85 . and @xmath86 where @xmath87 . among the @xmath3
marginal means , there are @xmath88 signals for a @xmath89 and the signal @xmath90 for a @xmath91 .
the signals locations @xmath92 are randomly selected from @xmath93 without replacement so that @xmath94 \\[-8pt ] \eqntext{\mbox{for all $ 1 \le p_1 < p_2 < \cdots < p_m \le p$}.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( c.1 ) specifies the growth rate of @xmath3 relative to the sample size @xmath95 is in the paradigm of `` large @xmath3 , small @xmath95 . ''
that @xmath96 is the rate we can attain for gaussian data or cases where we can attain `` accurate '' enough estimation of @xmath97 , which satisfies equation ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) .
when data are not gaussian and the `` accurate '' estimators are not attainable , the growth rate of @xmath3 will be more restrictive at @xmath98 ( @xmath99 ) , as will be discussed in the next section .
( c.2 ) assumes the joint distributions of @xmath100 is sub - gaussian , which implies each marginal @xmath101 is sub - gaussian as well .
( c.3 ) prescribes weak dependence among @xmath82 .
the first part of ( c.4 ) reiterates the sparse and faint signal setting .
the range of the signal strength includes the case of @xmath51 , representing the most fainted detectable signal strength , which has been considered in @xcite and other research works .
the second part of ( c.4 ) provides a random allocation mechanism for the signal bearing dimensions , which is the same as the one assumed in @xcite . existing research on the detection boundary of the hc test for the sparse mean problem [ @xcite ; @xcite ]
is largely conducted for the case of @xmath102 when the data are gaussian .
this is understandable since the sample means are sufficient statistics and there is no loss of generality when we treat the problem as @xmath102 , even if we have multiple observations .
however , when the underlying distributions are as specified in ( c.2 ) , we can not translate the test problem to @xmath102 without incurring a loss of information .
we first consider the @xmath1 version of the thresholding statistic @xmath103 in this section .
the study of the @xmath104 version is outlined in section [ sec4 ] when we compare the power performance to the hc test .
let @xmath105 .
then , the @xmath1-thresholding statistic can be written as @xmath106 where @xmath37 is the thresholding parameter that takes values over a range within @xmath39 .
there is no need to consider @xmath107 in the thresholding since large deviation results given in @xcite imply that under @xmath47@xmath108 define a set of slowing varying functions : @xmath109 , @xmath110 , @xmath111 , @xmath112 , @xmath113 and @xmath114 .
let @xmath115 and @xmath116 be the density and survival functions of the standard normal distribution .
let @xmath117 and @xmath118 be the mean and variance of @xmath119 under @xmath47 , respectively , and @xmath120 and @xmath121 be those , respectively , under the @xmath13 as specified in ( c.4 ) .
the following proposition depicts the mean and variance of @xmath119 by applying fubini s theorem and the large deviation results [ @xcite and lemma a.1 in zhong , chen and xu ( @xcite ) ] .
[ chap4-cor2 ] under , @xmath122 and @xmath123 are , respectively , @xmath124 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad= p\bigl\{2{\lambda_p^{1/2}(s ) } \phi \bigl({\lambda ^{1/2}_p(s)}\bigr)+2\bar{\phi}\bigl ( { \lambda^{1/2}_p(s)}\bigr)\bigr\ } \bigl\{1+o\bigl\ { n^{-1/2}{\lambda^{3/2}_p(s)}\bigr\}\bigr\ } , \\
\label{eq : vartn0}&&\sigma_{t_{2n},0}^2 ( s ) \nonumber \\[-8pt ] \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad= p\bigl\{2\bigl [ \lambda^{3/2}_p(s)+3{\lambda ^{1/2}_p(s ) } \bigr]\phi\bigl({\lambda^{1/2}_p(s)}\bigr)+6\bar{\phi}\bigl ( { \lambda ^{1/2}_p(s)}\bigr)\bigr\ } \bigl\{1+o(1)\bigr\ } \ ] ] under the @xmath47 ; and @xmath125 under the @xmath13 specified in . expressions ( [ eq : meantn0 ] ) and ( [ eq : vartn0 ] ) provide the first and the second order terms of @xmath117 and @xmath126 , which are needed when we consider their empirical estimation under @xmath47 when formulating the @xmath1 thresholding test statistic . note that @xmath127 and @xmath128 .
only the first order terms for the variance are needed under @xmath13 , but the approximation to @xmath129 has to be more accurate so as to know the order of the difference between @xmath129 and @xmath130 .
proposition [ chap4-cor2 ] indicates that the column - wise dependence as specified in ( c.3 ) does not have much leading order impact on the variance of @xmath131 .
the leading order variance is almost the same when @xmath132 are column - wise independent .
the difference only appears in the coefficients of the slow - varying functions @xmath133 , @xmath134 and @xmath135 , while their orders of magnitude remain unchanged .
the reason behind this phenomena is the thresholding .
it can be understood by an analogue for multivariate gaussian distributions with nonzero correlation . despite the dependence in the gaussian distribution , exceedances beyond high thresholds are asymptotically independent [ @xcite and @xcite ] .
we now study the asymptotic distribution of @xmath136 to prepare for the proposal of the maximal @xmath1-thresholding statistic .
write @xmath137 where @xmath138 and @xmath139 .
@xmath140 $ ] such that @xmath141 , define @xmath142 as the @xmath143-algebra generated by @xmath144 and define the @xmath145-mixing coefficients @xmath146 see @xcite for comprehensive discussions on the mixing concept .
the following is a condition regarding the dependence among @xmath147 . for any @xmath29 ,
the sequence of random variables @xmath148 is @xmath149-mixing such that @xmath150 for some @xmath151 and a positive constant @xmath152 .
the requirement of @xmath153 being @xmath149-mixing for each @xmath37 is weaker than requiring the original data columns @xmath154 being @xmath149-mixing , whose mixing coefficient @xmath155 can be similarly defined as ( [ eq : mixing ] ) .
this is because , according to theorem 5.2 in @xcite , @xmath156 the following theorem reports the asymptotic normality of @xmath119 under both @xmath47 and @xmath13 . [ th1 ] assume .
then , for any @xmath157 , @xmath158 from ( [ eq : meantn0 ] ) and ( [ eq : vartn0 ] ) , define the leading order terms of @xmath159 and @xmath160 , respectively , @xmath161\phi\bigl({\lambda^{1/2}_p(s)}\bigr)+6\bar{\phi}\bigl ( { \lambda ^{1/2}_p(s)}\bigr)\bigr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is clear that the asymptotic normality in theorem [ th1](i ) remains if we replace @xmath162 by @xmath163 . to formulate a test procedure based on the thresholding statistic @xmath131
, we need to estimate @xmath164 by a @xmath165 , say .
ideally , if @xmath166 the first part of theorem [ th1 ] remains valid if we replace @xmath130 with @xmath167 .
an obvious choice of @xmath167 is @xmath168 , which is known upon given @xmath3 and @xmath37 . indeed ,
if @xmath101s are the standard normally distributed , we have @xmath169 implying the leading order is exactly @xmath164 for the gaussian data . hence , if we take @xmath170 , ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) is satisfied for the gaussian data . for non - gaussian observations ,
the difference between @xmath130 and@xmath171 may not be a smaller order of @xmath162 . specifically , from ( [ eq : meantn0 ] ) and ( [ eq : vartn0 ] ) , we have @xmath172 to make the above ratio diminishing to zero , the strategy of @xcite can be adopted by restricting @xmath98 and @xmath173 for a positive @xmath174 , where @xmath175 if @xmath176 and @xmath177 if @xmath178 . under this circumstance , @xmath179 clearly , for a not so high dimension with @xmath180 , ( [ eq : restrict ] ) holds for all @xmath29 , and @xmath181 satisfies ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) . for higher dimensions with @xmath182 , the thresholding level @xmath37 has to be restricted to ensure ( [ eq : restrict ] ) .
the restriction can alter the detection boundary of the test we will propose in the next section .
this echoes a similar phenomena for the hc test given in @xcite . to expedite our discussion , we assume in the rest of the paper that ( [ eq : cri1 ] )
is satisfied by the @xmath167 .
we note such an arrangement is not entirely unrealistic , as a separate effort may be made to produce more accurate estimators .
assuming so allows us to stay focused on the main agenda of the testing problem .
the asymptotic normality established in theorem [ th1 ] allows an asymptotic test that rejects @xmath47 if @xmath183 where @xmath184 is the upper @xmath185 quantile of the standard normal distribution .
while the asymptotic normality of @xmath119 in theorem [ th1 ] ensures the single thresholding level test in ( [ eq : test1 ] ) a correct size asymptotically , the power of the test depends on @xmath37 , the underlying signal strength @xmath21 and the sparsity @xmath186 .
a test procedure is said to be able to separate a pair of null and alternative hypotheses asymptotically if the sum of the probabilities of the type i and type ii errors converges to zero as @xmath74 .
let @xmath187 be a sequence of the probabilities of type i error , which can be made converging to zero as @xmath74 .
the sum of the probabilities of the type i and type ii errors for the test given in ( [ eq : test1 ] ) with nominal size @xmath187 is approximately @xmath188 which is attained based on the facts that ( i ) the size @xmath187 is attained asymptotically and ( ii ) @xmath165 and @xmath189 are sufficiently accurate estimators in the test procedure ( [ eq : test1 ] ) .
our strategy is to first make @xmath190 such that @xmath191 for an arbitrarily small @xmath192 and a constant @xmath193 .
the second term on the right - hand side of ( [ eq : errors ] ) is @xmath194 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \hspace*{34pt}\qquad\leq z_{\alpha_n } \frac { \sigma_{t_{2n } , 0}(s)}{\sigma_{t_{2n } , 1}(s)}-\frac{\mu_{t_{2n},1}(s)-\mu_{t_{2n},0}(s ) } { \sigma_{t_{2n } , 1}(s ) } \biggr).\end{aligned}\ ] ] because @xmath195 is slowly varying , @xmath196 and @xmath197 is stochastically bounded , a necessary and sufficient condition that ensures @xmath198 is @xmath199 from proposition [ chap4-cor2 ] , it follows that , up to a factor @xmath200 , @xmath201 where @xmath202 , @xmath203 , @xmath204 and @xmath205 .
let @xmath206 as demonstrated in @xcite and @xcite , the phase diagram @xmath207 is the optimal detection boundary for testing the hypotheses we are considering in this paper when the data are gaussian and @xmath208 . here
the optimality means that for any @xmath209 , there exists at least one test such that the sum of the probabilities of the type i and type ii errors diminishes to zero as @xmath74 ; but for @xmath210 , no such test exists . for correlated gaussian data such that @xmath211 , @xcite found that the detection boundary @xmath212 may be lowered by transforming the data via the inverse of cholesky factorization @xmath213 such that @xmath214 .
more discussion on the optimality is given in section [ sec6 ] . from the expression of @xmath215 given above ,
it can be shown ( see the proof of theorem [ detect - upper - bound ] in the ) that if @xmath216 there exists at least one @xmath29 for each pair of @xmath217 such that ( [ detectable - condition ] ) is satisfied and , hence , the thresholding test would be powerful .
this is the key for the maximal @xmath1-thresholding test that we will propose later to attain the detection boundary .
it is clear that we have to make the thresholding level @xmath37 adaptive to the unknown @xmath21 and @xmath186 .
one strategy is to use a range of thresholding levels , say , @xmath218 , so that the underlying @xmath217 can be `` covered . ''
this is the very idea of the hc test .
let @xmath219 be the standardized version of @xmath119 .
define the maximal thresholding statistic @xmath220 where @xmath221 $ ] for an arbitrarily small positive @xmath222 .
let @xmath223 since both @xmath167 and @xmath224 are monotone decreasing functions of @xmath37 , it can be shown that @xmath225 can be attained on @xmath226 , namely , @xmath227 this largely reduces the computational burden of @xmath228 .
the asymptotic distribution of @xmath56 is established in the following theorem .
[ asy - gumbel ] assume , and ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) hold . then , under @xmath47 , @xmath229 where @xmath230 and @xmath231 .
the theorem leads to an asymptotic @xmath185-level test that rejects @xmath47 if @xmath232 where @xmath233 is the upper @xmath185 quantile of the gumbel distribution @xmath234 .
we name the test the maximal @xmath1-thresholding test .
the following theorem shows that its detection boundary is @xmath207 .
[ detect - upper - bound ] under conditions and assuming ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) holds , then if @xmath235 , the sum of the type i and ii errors of the maximal @xmath1-thresholding tests converges to 0 when the nominal sizes @xmath236 for an arbitrarily small @xmath192 as @xmath237 . if @xmath238 , the sum of the type i and ii errors of the maximal @xmath1-thresholding test converges to 1 when the nominal sizes @xmath239 as @xmath240 .
it is noted that when @xmath235 in part ( i ) of theorem [ detect - upper - bound ] , we need to restrict the rate of the nominal type i error @xmath241 s convergence to 0 , since the conclusion of part ( i ) may not be true for all @xmath239 . however , in part ( ii ) where @xmath242 , no restriction for @xmath187 is required , which has to be the case , as otherwise there is no guarantee that @xmath243 is the detection boundary of the test .
if the estimator @xmath244 can not attain ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) and @xmath245 is used as the estimator , we have to restrict @xmath98 for a @xmath246 and limit @xmath247 . in this case
, the above theorem is valid if we replace @xmath248 by @xmath249 , where @xmath250 which is clearly inferior to @xmath248 .
the boundary @xmath249 is the same as the one in @xcite based on the marginal @xmath22-statistics , whereas our result is based on the @xmath68-statistics .
the @xmath22-statistic formulation reduces the demand on the tails of the distributions as shown in @xcite .
we note that if @xmath180 , theorem [ detect - upper - bound ] remains so that the gaussian detection boundary is still valid .
we compare the power of the maximal @xmath1-thresholding test with those of the hc test and the maximal @xmath0-thresholding test in this section .
let us first introduce these two tests .
the hc test is based on @xmath251 where @xmath252 . like @xcite , we consider here a two - sided hc test instead of a one - sided test treated in @xcite . with the same reasoning as donoho and jin [ ( @xcite ) , page 968 ] , we define the hc test statistic @xmath253 where @xmath254 $ ] for an arbitrary small @xmath222 and is the same as the maximal @xmath1-thresholding statistic . using the same argument for the maximal @xmath1-thresholding statistic
, it can be shown that @xmath255 attains its maximum value on @xmath256 given in ( [ eq : sn ] ) as well . according to @xcite , under @xmath47 , @xmath257 with the same normalizing sequences as those in theorem [ asy - gumbel ] .
let @xmath258 be the same as that of the maximal @xmath1-thresholding test given in ( [ eq : l2test ] ) .
an @xmath185 level hc test rejects @xmath47 if @xmath259 let us introduce the maximal @xmath0-thresholding test statistic . recall that @xmath260 it can be shown that the mean and variance of * @xmath261 * under @xmath47 are , respectively , @xmath262 define @xmath263 where @xmath264 is a sufficiently accurate estimator of @xmath265 in a similar sense to ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) and @xmath266 .
the maximal @xmath0-thresholding statistic is @xmath267 where , again , @xmath254 $ ] .
it can be shown that @xmath268 for the same @xmath269 in ( [ eq : sn ] ) . using a similar approach to that in theorem [ asy - gumbel ]
, we can show that @xmath270 hence , an @xmath185-level maximal @xmath0-thresholding test rejects the @xmath47 if @xmath271 from ( [ eq : l2test ] ) , ( [ eq : hctest ] ) and ( [ eq : l1test ] ) , the three tests have the same critical values @xmath272 at nominal level @xmath185 .
this brings convenience for the power comparison .
let us define the power of the three tests @xmath273 for @xmath274 and @xmath25 , respectively .
notice that @xmath275 where @xmath276 and @xmath277 in which @xmath278 , @xmath279 and @xmath280 . as shown in ( [ l2 - 100 ] ) , ( [ hc-100 ] ) and ( [ l1 - 100 ] ) in the , @xmath281 and @xmath282 where @xmath283 .
derivations given in the proof of theorem [ th4 ] in the show that for @xmath284 and @xmath25 , @xmath285 where `` @xmath286 '' means that the @xmath287 .
this implies that we only need to compare @xmath288 in the power comparison . from the established expressions of @xmath289 , we note two facts .
one is that if @xmath290 , for any @xmath291 , @xmath292 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber \delta_{1,0}(s;r,\beta)/ \delta_{0,0}(s;r,\beta)&=&(r / s)^{1/4}>1.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the other is if @xmath293 $ ] , asymptotically , @xmath294 hence , when @xmath217 lies just above the detection boundary , the three @xmath295 functions are the same . if @xmath296 moves further away from the detection boundary so that @xmath297 , there will be a clear ordering among the @xmath298 functions .
the following theorem summarizes the relative power performance .
[ th4 ] assume and ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) hold .
for any given significant level @xmath151 , the powers of the hc , the maximal @xmath0 and @xmath1-thresholding tests under @xmath13 as specified in satisfy , as @xmath74 , @xmath299 and @xmath300s are asymptotic equivalent for @xmath301 $ ] .
the theorem indicates that when @xmath217 is well above the detection boundary such that @xmath297 , there is a clear ordering in the power among the three tests , with the @xmath1 being the most powerful followed by the @xmath0 test .
however , when @xmath217 is just above the detection boundary such that @xmath302 $ ] , the three tests have asymptotically equivalent powers . in the latter case , comparing the second order terms of @xmath48 may lead to differentiations among the powers of the three tests .
however , it is a rather technical undertaking to assess the impacts of the second order terms .
the analysis conducted in theorem [ th4 ] is applicable to the setting of gaussian data with @xmath102 and @xmath8 satisfying ( c.3 ) , which is the setting commonly assumed in the investigation of the detection boundary for the hc test [ @xcite ; @xcite and arias - castro , bubeck and lugosi ( @xcite ) ] .
specifically , the power ordering among the three maximal thresholding tests in theorem [ th4 ] remains but under lesser conditions ( c.3)(c.5 ) .
condition ( c.1 ) is not needed since the gaussian assumption allows us to translate the problem to @xmath102 since the sample mean is sufficient .
condition ( c.2 ) is automatically satisfied for the gaussian distribution .
the condition ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) is met for the gaussian data , as we have discussed in section [ sec2 ] .
we report results from simulation experiments which were designed to evaluate the performance of the maximal @xmath0 and @xmath1-thresholding tests and the hc test .
the purpose of the simulation study is to confirm the theoretical findings that there is an ordering in the power among the three tests discovered in theorem [ th4 ] .
independent and identically distributed @xmath3-dim random vectors @xmath303 were generated according to @xmath304 where @xmath305 is a stationary random vector and @xmath82 have the same marginal distribution @xmath58 . in the simulation , @xmath63
was generated from a @xmath3-dimensional multivariate gaussian distribution with zero mean and covariance @xmath306 , where @xmath307 for @xmath308 and @xmath309 , respectively .
the simulation design on @xmath310 had the sparsity parameter @xmath311 and @xmath312 , respectively , and the signal strength @xmath313 and @xmath314 , respectively .
we chose two scenarios on the dimension and sample size combinations : ( a ) a large @xmath3 , small @xmath95 setting and ( b ) both @xmath3 and @xmath95 are moderately large .
for scenario ( a ) , we chose @xmath315 , where @xmath316 and @xmath317 so that the dimensions @xmath3 were 2000 and 20,000 , and the sample sizes @xmath95 were @xmath318 and 100 , respectively .
we note that under the setting @xmath319 , there were only @xmath320 and 7 nonzero means , respectively , among the 2000 and 20,000 dimensions . and
those for @xmath321 were @xmath322 and @xmath323 , respectively , and those for @xmath324 were @xmath325 and @xmath326 , respectively .
these were quite sparse .
for scenario ( b ) , we chose @xmath327 such that @xmath328 and @xmath329 .
the maximal @xmath1-test statistic @xmath56 was constructed using @xmath330 and @xmath331 given in ( [ eq : meantn0 ] ) and ( [ eq : vartn0 ] ) , respectively , as the mean and standard deviation estimators . the maximal @xmath0 test statistic and the hc test statistic , @xmath332 and @xmath333 ,
were constructed similarly using the leading order mean and standard deviation under @xmath47 .
the set of thresholding level @xmath38 was chosen to be @xmath334 $ ] with @xmath335 .
figures [ figure1][figure4 ] display the average empirical sizes and powers of the hc , the maximal @xmath0 and @xmath1-thresholding tests based on 20,000 simulations , with figures [ figure1][figure2 ] for scenario ( a ) and figures [ figure3][figure4 ] for scenario ( b ) . to make the power comparison fair and conclusive , we adjusted the nominal level of the tests so that the simulated sizes of the tests were all around @xmath336 , with the hc having slightly larger sizes than those of the maximal @xmath0 test , and the sizes of the maximal @xmath0 test were slightly larger than those of the maximal @xmath1 test . these were designed to rule out potential `` favoritism '' in the power comparison due to advantages in the sizes of the maximal @xmath1 and/or @xmath0 tests .
- ( dashed lines with dots ) and @xmath1- ( solid lines with circles ) thresholding tests when @xmath337 and @xmath338 with the marginal distribution the standard normal . ]
- ( dashed lines with dots ) and @xmath1- ( solid lines with circles ) thresholding tests when @xmath339 and @xmath340 with the marginal distribution the standard normal . ]
- ( dashed lines with dots ) and @xmath1- ( solid lines with circles ) thresholding tests when @xmath341 and @xmath340 with the marginal distribution the standard normal . ]
- ( dashed lines with dots ) and @xmath1- ( solid lines with circles ) thresholding tests when @xmath342 and @xmath343 with the marginal distribution the standard normal . ]
figures [ figure1][figure4 ] show that the power of the tests were the most influenced by the signal strength parameter @xmath21 , followed by the sparsity @xmath186 .
the powers were insensitive to the level of dependence @xmath149 , which confirmed our finding that the thresholding largely removes the dependence . the observed ordering in the empirical power shown in figures [ figure1][figure4 ] were consistent to the conclusions in theorem [ th4 ] .
we observed that in all the simulation settings , despite some size advantages by the hc test and/or the maximal @xmath0 test , the maximal @xmath1 test had better power than the maximal @xmath0 and the hc test , and the maximal @xmath0 test had better power than the hc test .
we find that for each fixed level of sparsity @xmath186 , when the signal strength @xmath21 was increased so that @xmath344 moved away from the detection boundary @xmath207 , the difference among the powers of the three tests was enlarged .
this was especially the case for the most sparse case of @xmath319 and was indeed confirmatory to theorem [ th4 ] .
the simulated powers of the three tests were very much the same at @xmath345 and were barely changed even when both @xmath95 and @xmath3 were increased .
this was consistent with the fact that @xmath345 is below the detection boundary for @xmath321 and 0.8 considered in the simulation .
our analysis shows that there are alternative @xmath0 and @xmath1 formulations to the hc test which attain the detection boundary @xmath207 of the hc test .
the tests based on the @xmath0 and @xmath1 formulations are more powerful than the hc test when the @xmath346 pair is away from the detection boundary such that @xmath52 .
the three tests have asymptotically equivalent power when @xmath217 is just above the detection boundary .
the detection boundary @xmath207 coincides with that of the hc test discovered in @xcite for the gaussian data with independent components . that the three tests considered in this paper attain the detection boundary @xmath207 under the considered sub - gaussian setting with column - wise dependence
can be understood in two aspects .
one is that the three test statistics are all directly formulated via the marginal sample means @xmath27 which are asymptotically normally distributed ; the other is that the thresholding statistics are asymptotically uncorrelated as implied from proposition [ chap4-cor2 ] . according to @xcite and @xcite
, @xmath243 is the optimal detection boundary for gaussian distributed data with independent components .
however , it may not be optimal for the dependent nonparametric setting considered in this paper .
indeed , for weakly dependent gaussian data , @xcite showed that the detection boundary @xmath207 can be lowered by utilizing the dependence .
the latter was carried out by pre - transforming the data with @xmath213 , the inverse of the cholesky decomposition of @xmath8 , or an empirical estimate of @xmath213 and then conducting the hc test based on the transformed data .
it is expected that the main results of this paper on the relative performance of the three tests would remain valid for the transformed data .
@xcite and @xcite studied the detection boundary for dependent data and @xcite studied the boundary for detecting mixtures with a general known distribution .
however , the optimal detection boundary under the dependent sub - gaussian distribution setting is still an open problem .
in this appendix we provide proofs to theorems [ asy - gumbel ] , [ detect - upper - bound ] and [ th4 ] reported in sections [ sec3 ] and [ sec4 ] . throughout this appendix
we use @xmath347 to denote slow varying functions for some constant @xmath348 and positive constant @xmath152 , and @xmath115 and @xmath116 for the density and survival functions of the standard normal distribution , respectively .
let @xmath349 be the correlation coefficient between @xmath350 and @xmath351 , and write @xmath352 for simplicity and @xmath353 for @xmath354 and @xmath355 . put @xmath356 .
proof of theorem [ asy - gumbel ] let @xmath357 .
write @xmath358 and @xmath359}\hat{\mathcal { t}}_{2,n}(s)=\max_{u\in[u_0 , 1/2)}\mathcal{j}_2(u),\ ] ] where @xmath360 . using the same technique for the proof of theorem 1 in zhong , chen and xu ( @xcite )
, it may be shown that the joint asymptotic normality of @xmath361 at any finite points @xmath362 .
this is equivalent to the joint asymptotic normality of @xmath363 at @xmath364 for @xmath365 .
we want to show the tightness of the process @xmath366 .
let @xmath367 , where @xmath368 , @xmath369 and @xmath370 .
write @xmath371 based on the finite dimensional convergence of @xmath366 and theorem 1.5.6 in van der vaart and wellner ( @xcite ) , we only need to show the asymptotically equicontinuous of @xmath366 , that is , for any @xmath192 and @xmath372 there exists a finite partition @xmath373 such that @xmath374 where @xmath375 is the outer probability measure .
define @xmath376 and @xmath377^{1/2}$ ] .
it can be shown that if @xmath378 , @xmath379 thus , for every @xmath380 , @xmath381 , which implies that for each @xmath382 , @xmath383 can be partitioned into finitely many sets @xmath384 satisfying @xmath385 let @xmath386 be the bracketing number , the smallest number of functions @xmath387 in @xmath388 such that for each @xmath389 in @xmath390 there exists an @xmath391 ( @xmath392 ) satisfying @xmath393 .
applying theorem 2.2 in @xcite , if the following two conditions hold for an even integer @xmath394 and a real number @xmath395 such that @xmath396 we have for @xmath95 large enough @xmath397 . invoking the maximal inequality of @xcite
, it follows that @xmath398 now using the markov inequality , we get for @xmath95 large enough @xmath399 hence , the condition ( [ equaconti ] ) holds and @xmath366 is asymptotically tight . it remains to show ( [ condi-1 ] ) and ( [ condi-2 ] ) hold . for ( [ condi-2 ] )
, we note that @xmath390 is a v - c class for each @xmath95 .
this is because @xmath400 is a v - c class with vc index 2 .
let @xmath401 . then @xmath402 is a v - c class by lemma 2.6.18 in van der vaart and wellner ( @xcite ) .
let @xmath403 be the envelop function for class @xmath390 .
clearly , we can take @xmath404 .
it is easy to see that @xmath405 for a constant @xmath406 . applying a result on covering number of v - c classes [ theorem 2.6.7 , van der vaart and wellner ( @xcite ) ]
, we get @xmath407 for a universal constant @xmath408 .
it can be verified that if @xmath409 , then ( [ condi-2 ] ) holds .
the condition ( [ condi-1 ] ) follows from the assumption that . as a result , @xmath366 converge to a zero mean gaussian process @xmath410 with @xmath411\biggr)\ ] ] for @xmath412 .
it can be shown that there exists an ornstein uhlenbeck ( o u ) process @xmath413 with mean zero 0 and @xmath414 such that @xmath415 .
therefore , by a result for the o u process in leadbetter , lindgren and rootzn [ ( @xcite ) , page 217 ] , @xmath416 where @xmath417 , @xmath418 , @xmath419 and @xmath420 . from ( [ eq : vartn0 ] ) , we have @xmath421 . since @xmath422 \\ & & { } + \frac{a(\tau_n)}{a(\log p)}b^*(\log p)-b^*(\tau_n),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath423 and @xmath424 \\ & & { } + b^*(\tau_n)\biggl[\frac{a(\tau_n)}{a(\log p)}-1\biggr]\to-\log \frac { ( 1-\eta)}{2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have @xmath425 finally , note that @xmath426 .
this finishes the proof of theorem [ asy - gumbel ] .
proof of theorem [ detect - upper - bound ] ( i ) . the proof is made under four cases . for each case , we find the corresponding detectable region and the union of the four regions are the overall detectable region of the thresholding test .
basically , we show for any @xmath427 above @xmath428 within one of the four cases , there exists at least one threshold level @xmath37 such that @xmath13 is detectable . for notation simplification ,
we only keep the leading order terms for @xmath429 , @xmath430 , @xmath431 and @xmath215 .
_ case _ 1 : @xmath432 and @xmath433 . in this case ,
@xmath434 and @xmath435 . hence , @xmath436 so to make @xmath437 , we need @xmath438 .
it follows that the detectable region for this case is @xmath439 .
specifically , if we select @xmath440 , we arrive at the best divergence rate for @xmath215 of order @xmath441 .
_ case _ 2 : @xmath432 and @xmath442 . in this case , @xmath434 , @xmath443 , and @xmath444 .
then , @xmath445 so the detectable region in the @xmath427 plane is @xmath446 . in this region ,
the best divergence rate of @xmath447 is of order @xmath448 for any @xmath449 .
_ case _ 3 : @xmath450 and @xmath451 .
the case is equivalent to @xmath452 and @xmath453 , @xmath454 . then @xmath455 to ensure ( [ 4:eq:3 ] ) diverging to infinity , we need @xmath456 thus , the detectable region must satisfy @xmath457 this translates to @xmath458 _ case _ 4 : @xmath450 and @xmath459
this is equivalent to @xmath460 . in this case , @xmath453,@xmath461 .
then @xmath462 hence , it requires that @xmath463 in order to find an @xmath37 , we need @xmath464 . if @xmath465 , namely , @xmath446 , the above inequality is obviously true . if @xmath466 , then @xmath467 is equivalent to @xmath468 .
so the detectable region is @xmath468 in this case . in summary of cases 14 ,
the union of the detectable regions in the above four cases is @xmath469 , as illustrated in figure [ figure5 ]
. threshold test .
case 1 : the union of \{i , ii , iii , iv } ; case 2 , the region is i ; case 3 : the union of \{ii , iii , iv , v , vi , vii } ; case 4 : the union of \{i , ii , iii , vi , vii}. ] now we are ready to prove the theorem .
we only need to show that the sum of type i and ii errors of the maximal test goes to 0 when @xmath469 .
because the maximal test is of asymptotic @xmath187 level , it suffices to show that the power goes to 1 in the detectable region as @xmath240 and @xmath190 .
recall that the @xmath187 level rejection region is @xmath470 . from theorem [ asy - gumbel
] , we notice that @xmath471 .
then , it is sufficient if @xmath472 at every @xmath427 in the detectable region . since @xmath473 for any @xmath474 , therefore , ( [ 4:infty ] ) is true if for any point in the detectable region , there exists a @xmath30 such that @xmath475 therefore , we want to show @xmath476 because @xmath477 and @xmath478 , ( [ 4:infty:1 ] ) is true if @xmath479 .
as we have shown in the early proof , for every @xmath217 in the detectable region , there exists an @xmath37 such that @xmath480 for any slow varying function @xmath481 .
this concludes ( [ t2ninfinity ] ) and hence ( [ 4:infty ] ) , which completes the proof of part ( i ) .
( ii ) note that @xmath482 where @xmath483 and @xmath484 are defined in ( [ th4decom ] ) and @xmath485 if @xmath486 , then @xmath487 and @xmath488 . hence , @xmath489 it is also noticed that @xmath486 implies that @xmath490 .
therefore , for all @xmath491 , @xmath492 .
if @xmath486 , then @xmath493 . hence , @xmath494 as @xmath495 . if @xmath486 and @xmath496 , then @xmath497 .
it follows that , for all @xmath498 , @xmath499 if @xmath486 and @xmath500 , then for all @xmath498 , @xmath501 hence , @xmath502 as @xmath503 . in summary
, we have @xmath492 and@xmath504 if @xmath486 .
therefore , together with assumption ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) , @xmath505 .
we note that , by employing the same argument of theorem [ asy - gumbel ] , it can be shown that @xmath506 where @xmath507 is defined just above ( [ tn1order ] )
. then the power of the test @xmath508 thus , the sum of type i and ii errors goes to 1 .
this completes the proof of part ( ii ) .
proof of theorem [ th4 ] we first prove that @xmath509 , which will be proved in two parts : @xmath510 where @xmath511 . to show ( [ th4part1 ] ) , note the decomposition for @xmath48 in ( [ th4decom ] ) .
let @xmath512 .
we can first show that @xmath513 because of the following inequality : @xmath514 under condition ( [ eq : cri1 ] ) , that is , @xmath515 , hence , @xmath516 .
second , we can show @xmath517 . note the following inequality : @xmath518 under conditions ( c.1)(c.4 ) , @xmath519 .
so we have @xmath520 in summary , we have @xmath521 .
therefore , @xmath522 .
the path leading to ( [ th4part2 ] ) is the following .
first of all , it can be shown using an argument similar to the one used in the proof of theorem [ asy - gumbel ] that @xmath523 where @xmath524 .
thus , for @xmath50 and @xmath25 , @xmath525 equations ( [ delta0-sigma - ratio - l2 - 1 ] ) to ( [ delta0-sigma - ratio - l2 - 8 ] ) in the following reveal that for all @xmath526 and @xmath469 , we can classify @xmath527 into two sets @xmath528 and @xmath529 such that @xmath530 where `` @xmath531 '' means that @xmath532 for some @xmath533 . because @xmath21 is above the detection boundary @xmath534 , there exists at least one @xmath535 such that @xmath536 .
hence , @xmath537 namely , the maximum of @xmath538 is reached on set @xmath528 where @xmath538 diverges at a much faster rate than that of @xmath539 , if the latter ever diverges .
let @xmath540 . combining ( [ tn1order ] ) and ( [ delta - r - order ] )
, we have @xmath541 this implies that @xmath542 .
together with the following inequality : @xmath543 we conclude that ( [ th4part2 ] ) holds .
it remains to show the existence of @xmath528 and @xmath529 in arriving at ( [ delta - r - order ] ) .
we only prove it for the @xmath1 test . to complete that
, we compare the relative order between @xmath544 and @xmath545 for three regions above the detection boundary @xmath248 : ( i ) @xmath446 ( ii ) @xmath546 $ ] and ( iii ) @xmath547 $ ] . in regions ( i ) and ( ii ) with @xmath468 , we can show that @xmath548 in region ( ii ) with @xmath549 , we have @xmath550 \\[-8pt ] & & \eqntext{\mbox{and $ ( 2\sqrt{r}+\sqrt{1 + 2r-2\beta})^2<s < 1$}.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath551 $ ] in region ( iii ) . if @xmath552 , define @xmath553 and @xmath554 .
then it may be shown that @xmath555 if @xmath549 , define @xmath556 and @xmath557 .
then , it can be shown that @xmath558 the results in ( [ delta0-sigma - ratio - l2 - 1])([delta0-sigma - ratio - l2 - 8 ] ) indicate that in each region listed above , @xmath559 will be attained in situations covered by ( [ delta0-sigma - ratio - l2 - 1 ] ) , ( [ delta0-sigma - ratio - l2 - 3 ] ) , ( [ delta0-sigma - ratio - l2 - 6 ] ) and ( [ delta0-sigma - ratio - l2 - 8 ] ) , which together imply ( [ delta - r - order ] ) . next , we compute @xmath538 for the hc ( @xmath34 ) and the @xmath0 ( @xmath24 ) test . for the hc test ,
let @xmath560 . under assumptions ( c.1)(c.2 )
, applying the large deviation results [ @xcite ] , it may be shown that @xmath561 the mean and variance of @xmath562 under @xmath47 are @xmath563 and @xmath564 respectively .
the mean and variance of @xmath562 under the @xmath13 as specified in ( c.4 ) are , respectively , @xmath565 these imply that , up to a factor @xmath566 , @xmath567 and @xmath568 hence , @xmath569 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & { } + ( s\pi\log p)^{1/4}p^{1/2-\beta+s/2}i(r > s).\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the @xmath0 test , the mean and variances of @xmath261 under @xmath13 specified in ( c.4 ) are , respectively , up to a factor @xmath200 , @xmath570 it follows that , up to a factor @xmath200 , @xmath571 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & { } + ( \sqrt{2r\log p } ) p^{1-\beta}i(r > s ) \ ] ] and @xmath572 therefore , @xmath573 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & { } + ( s\pi\log p)^{{1}/{4}}(r / s)^{{1}/{4 } } p^{1/2-\beta + s/2}i(r > s).\end{aligned}\ ] ] replicating the above proof for the @xmath1 test , it can be shown that , for @xmath34 and 1 , @xmath574 at last , we will compare @xmath288 for @xmath284 and 2 when @xmath290 .
let @xmath575 be a threshold in @xmath576 that is closest to @xmath21 .
then the maximal value of @xmath577 over @xmath226 is attained at @xmath578 .
note that such @xmath579 exists with probability 1 . to show this point , it is enough to show that @xmath580 , which is equivalent to showing that @xmath581 .
let @xmath582 be a sub - sequence such that @xmath583 and @xmath584 .
let @xmath585 . by mixing assumption ( c.5 ) and the triangle inequality
, it can be seen that @xmath586 as @xmath240 .
then it follows that @xmath587 where we used @xmath588 for all @xmath589 . comparing ( [ l2 - 100 ] ) , ( [ hc-100 ] ) and
( [ l1 - 100 ] ) , we see that @xmath590 .
it follows that , for @xmath290 , @xmath591 therefore , asymptotically with probability 1 , @xmath592 , which results in @xmath593 .
this completes the proof .
the authors thank the editor , an associate editor and two referees for insightful and constructive comments which have improved the presentation of the paper .
we are also very grateful to dr .
jiashun jin and dr .
cun - hui zhang for stimulating discussions . | we consider two alternative tests to the higher criticism test of donoho and jin [ _ ann .
statist . _
* 32 * ( 2004 ) 962994 ] for high - dimensional means under the sparsity of the nonzero means for sub - gaussian distributed data with unknown column - wise dependence .
the two alternative test statistics are constructed by first thresholding @xmath0 and @xmath1 statistics based on the sample means , respectively , followed by maximizing over a range of thresholding levels to make the tests adaptive to the unknown signal strength and sparsity .
the two alternative tests can attain the same detection boundary of the higher criticism test in [ _ ann .
statist . _
* 32 * ( 2004 ) 962994 ] which was established for uncorrelated gaussian data .
it is demonstrated that the maximal @xmath1-thresholding test is at least as powerful as the maximal @xmath0-thresholding test , and both the maximal @xmath1 and @xmath0-thresholding tests are at least as powerful as the higher criticism test . , |
we thank g. kohring , d. stauffer and c. tsallis for interesting discussions .
this work was performed within the sfb 341 kln
aachen jlich supported by the dfg .
[ fig2 ] time - dependence of the activity for @xmath42 and various values of @xmath13 .
the system size is @xmath72 . concerning the statistical error we observe that all runs using different random numbers yield curves that are indistinguishable on this scale .
[ fig3 ] determination of @xmath43 : the system size is @xmath73 , @xmath42 and @xmath68 ( lower curve ) , @xmath57 ( middle curve ) and @xmath74 ( upper curve ) .
the straight line in the middle is the function @xmath75 .
we conclude that @xmath76 .
[ fig5 ] time - dependence of the distance for @xmath77 and @xmath78 ( lower curve ) , @xmath69 ( upper curve ) .
the system size is @xmath79 .
the curve for @xmath69 shows that @xmath80 is well inside the chaotic region , whereas @xmath81 lies within the frozen phase .
this fact stronly supports reentrance .
the emerging phase diagram in the vicinity of the tricritical point is depticted in the insert the two black dots represent the parameter values for the two curves shown . | we present numerical and analytical results for a special kind of one - dimensional probabilistic cellular automaton , the so called domany - kinzel automaton .
it is shown that the phase boundary separating the active and the recently found chaotic phase exhibits reentrant behavior .
furthermore exact results for the @xmath0=0-line are discussed .
pacs numbers : 87.10.+e , 02.50.+s , 89.80.+h cellular automata have been an intensive research field in recent years @xcite due to their computational simplicity and the wide range of applications in various areas . even in one dimension
a particular probabilistic variant ( domany - kinzel automaton ) of the originally deterministic cellular automata shows a rich phase diagram including directed percolation and other critical phenomena @xcite . only recently
a new phase in this model has been explored numerically exhibiting chaotic behavior @xcite .
this region of the diagram , up to a deterministic corner - point , is not accessible to exact treatments up to now .
nevertheless sophisticated approximation - methods , which systematically go beyond mean - field theory , have been applied successfully @xcite . in the so called tree - aproximation @xcite one
finds reentrant behavior in two directions , which is not fully understood yet .
this phenomenon has never been observed in numerical simulations up to now @xcite .
therefore one might ask , whether this reentrant behavior is a real feature of the model or just an artifact of the tree - approximation .
this issue is the main topic of the present paper , where we try to clearify this point with an alternative approximation method ( the cluster - approximation ) as well as with large scale monte - carlo simulations ( up to @xmath1 sites ) . to state the final results already at this place : the cluster - approximation again yields reentrant behavior in two directions and the simulations show clear evidence for reentrance near the tricritical point .
the model we consider is defined as follows : the domany - kinzel pca consists of a one - dimensional chain of @xmath2 binary variables , @xmath3 , @xmath4 taking on the values @xmath5 ( empty , occupied ) .
all sites are updated simultaneously ( i.e.parallel ) at discrete time steps and the state of each site at time @xmath6 depends only upon the state of the two nearest neighbors at time @xmath7 according to the following rule : @xmath8 \right\ } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the ( time - independent ) conditional probability that site @xmath10 takes on the value @xmath4 given that its neighbors have the values @xmath11 and @xmath12 at the previous time step .
@xmath13 ( @xmath0 ) is the probability that site @xmath10 is occupied if exactly one ( both ) of its neighbors is ( are ) occupied .
if neither neighbor is occupied , the site @xmath10 will also become empty , therefore the state with all sites empty is the absorbing state of the pca . the @xmath14-phase diagram , as it is known up to now , consists of three different phases .
most of it ( small enough @xmath13 ) is dominated by the _ frozen _
phase , where all initial conditions eventually lead into the absorbing state .
with other words , the activity @xmath15 tends to zero for @xmath16 within the frozen phase . for large enough @xmath13
one enters the @xmath17 phase , where , starting from a random initial condition , the system ends up in a state with a finite density of active sites . within this active phase
one can distinguish between a chaotic and a non - chaotic part .
this difference can be seen by starting with two slighly different ( random ) initial conditions @xmath18 and
@xmath19 subjected to the same external noise ( local updating rules ) . calculating the normalized distance @xmath20 of these two systems @xmath21 during the update of the replicated systems according to the rule displayed in equation ( 2 ) of reference @xcite one
observes a sharp transition from the chaotic phase , characterized by @xmath22 , to the active phase with @xmath23 ( in the following we call the active / non - chaotic phase simply the active phase ) .
the underlying picture is that in the latter case the system is characterized by only one attractor , which nevertheless depends strongly on the external noise . with other words , in this phase the noise ( and not the initial condition ) dominates the dynamics completely .
this is not true for the chaotic phase , where the system memorizes the initial state even after infinite time .
first we present analytical results obtained by the application of the so - called cluster - approximation already known in different contexts @xcite as probability path method @xcite or local structure theory @xcite . in this way we check earlier results @xcite derived with a different approximation scheme ( the tree - approximation ,
see @xcite ) .
the problem with the dynamical rules defined above is that one can not write down the probability distribution of the stationary state since no simple detailed balance condition can be derived .
therefore , in principle , it is necessary to solve the dynamics completely in order to obtain the equilibrium properties .
this is not possible in general .
one way out of this dilemma is to take into account systematically all possible correlations between @xmath24 neighboring sites ( @xmath24-cluster approximation ) and to treat interactions over longer distances by conditional probabilities .
more formally , given the probability @xmath25 for the configuration @xmath26 in an @xmath24-cluster - approximation the probabilitiy for configuration @xmath27 with @xmath28 is approximated to be : @xmath29 here @xmath30 denotes the conditional probability to find site @xmath31 in state @xmath32 given that the @xmath33 sites to the left are in the state @xmath34 .
a factorisation of this kind can describe the stationary state exactly only if the interactions extend over not more than @xmath24 sites .
a natural choice for the conditional probaility @xmath35 is @xmath36 with @xmath37 simple examples of one - dimensional systems which can be described exactly by a finite value of @xmath24 are the @xmath38-spin - ising - model where one needs @xmath39 for the exact equilibrium distribution ( @xmath40 being the standard one - dimensional ising model with next - neighbour interactions only ) @xcite .
another example is the the parallel asymmetric exclusion process where again @xmath41 leads to the exact result for the stationary state @xcite the phase diagram resulting from a calculation based on the cluster approximation with @xmath41 is shown in figure 1 .
since during one update step according to the rules equation 1 the even ( odd ) sites only depend on the odd ( even ) sites at the timestep before we performed two timesteps at once to deal with sites of only one fixed parity .
one firstly observes that @xmath41 is still far from the exact solution for the stationary state .
unfortunately higher approximations are very hard to obtain due to the exponentially growing number of equations to be analysed simultaneously ( especially for the distance @xmath20 with two replicated systems ) .
furthermore even for @xmath41 the resulting equations can not be solved analytically with final closed expressions but have to be iterated until one finds a fixed point of the system of equations . in order to obtain a better localisation of the phase boundaries we applied the same method described below to analyse the numerical data from the monte - carlo - simulations . as can be seen from the figure we find reentrant behaviour both in @xmath13- and @xmath0-direction comparable to the result from the tree approximation @xcite .
it seems that the tricritical point has moved upwards , but a detailed analysis of the results suggests that it remains on the @xmath42-line . for the frozen / active - phase boundary one can go to larger clusters with higher values of @xmath24 . in tabular 1 the critical values @xmath43 ( @xmath42 ) for of @xmath44
are given : @xmath45 a simple least square fit leads to a limiting value for @xmath43 of about @xmath46 which is significantly larger than the known values from the simulations @xcite . in order to test the predictions of both approximation schemes mentioned above we performed large - scale monte - carlo simulations of the domany - kinzel cellular automaton with probabilities @xmath13 and @xmath0 in the vicinity of the two end - points of the phase boundary of the chaotic phase ( i.e. : @xmath47 and @xmath48 ) , where reentrance could occur according to the above calculations .
the system - sizes were up to @xmath49 sites with periodic boundary conditions , and the number of iterations @xmath50 were maximally @xmath51 . in this way
one avoids self - correlations ( finite size effects ) , since after @xmath7 updates those sites separated by a distance smaller than @xmath7 are correlated .
therefore @xmath50 has to be smaller than @xmath2 . by choosing @xmath2 much larger than @xmath50 one improves the statistics significantly ( for obvious reasons , since one can devide the system into many statistically independent subsystems ) .
therefore no finite - size effects are present in our data ( which was checked by comparing results for different system sizes ) and we need not to perform a ( non - trivial ) extrapolation the infinite system @xmath52 .
furthermore the probability that the system gets trapped by the absorbing state ( @xmath53 ) after time @xmath7 increases with decreasing system size .
this renders the simultaneous limit @xmath52 and @xmath54 to a delicate point , which we also avoid by our approach .
looking at the data obtained from the simulations it turned out to be rather unreliable to try to discriminate between two phases by looking at the long - time limit of the order parameter ( activity @xmath55 or distance @xmath20 ) . apart from the two phase - boundaries we expect exponential decay of @xmath55 and @xmath20 to their asymptotic values .
exactly on the phase - boundary we expect the spectrum of relaxation times to extend to infinity and thus the decay to become algebraic .
this behavior is illustrated in figure 2 : the activity as a function of time is depicted in a log - log plot for increasing values of @xmath13 ( @xmath42 ) .
we see that below a certain value the curves are bended downwards , whereas above this value the curves are bended upwards reflecting exactly the behaviour explained above .
the curve just in the middle corresponding to @xmath56 is closest ( as defined quantitatively by a least square fit ) to a straight line . to determine @xmath43 more accurately we performed longer runs with larger system sizes and depict the result in figure 3 . the middle curve , corresponding to @xmath57 , is nicely approximated by an algebraic decay with an exponent @xmath58 .
this exponent agrees well with the universal order parameter exponent @xmath59 determined in reference @xcite . from figure 3
we determined @xmath43 to be @xmath60 .
this is the most accurate estimate of @xmath43 so far .
surprinsingly it is significantly larger than the value @xmath61 obtained with a different method but with system sizes of around @xmath62 @xcite .
it seems that in the latter reference the long transient times ( @xmath63 ) together with the small system sizes lower the critical value due to larger correlations in the system as known from similar systems @xcite . as we have mentioned above the finite size scaling analysis of small systems
is by no means straightforward and can not be done without further ad hoc assumptions , from which our method is free .
hence , from our point of view , the results we quote seem to be more reliable .
note that there is no overlap even of the error bars of the two critical values . in figure 4
we show the same scenario for @xmath64 . by the same arguments as above we now locate the critical value of @xmath13 ( i.e.the value at which the transition from vanishing to finite activity takes place ) to be @xmath65 , which is significantly lower than @xmath43 . for larger increasing values of @xmath0
the phase boundary between frozen and active phase bends down monotonically to smaller values of @xmath13 terminating at the point ( @xmath66 , @xmath67 ) which is exactly known since the whole @xmath67-line is exactly solvable . in figure 5
a comparison of the two curves for @xmath20 at @xmath68 , which is below @xmath43 , for @xmath42 and @xmath69 is shown .
note that ( 0.8090,0 ) lies within the frozen phase .
the upper curve bends upwards , which means that ( 0.8090,0.03 ) lies within the chaotic phase .
this is indicated by the schematic phase diagram depicted in the insert of figure 5 and which has been supported by simulations of various parameters @xmath14 in this region .
the two black dots represent the two curves shown and along the arrow connecting them one finds clear evidence for reentrant behavior .
the phase boundary of the chaotic phase therefore bends to the left up to values around @xmath69 and for larger values of @xmath0 it bends monotonically to the right until it terminates at the point @xmath48 .
one reason for the fact that this phenomenon was not seen in earlier simulations is that it is in fact a marginal effect observable only in high - precision simulation - data .
we also performed large scale simulations around the other endpoint of the chaotic / active phase boundary . here
it is quite evident that the reentrant behaviour parallel to the @xmath13-axis at @xmath48 is in fact an artifact of the approximation schemes and not existent in the actual system . concerning the question of the conjugate field for the order - parameter of the chaotic phase posed in reference @xcite one can make on the @xmath0=0-line exact statements .
since both the activity and the chaos order parameter obey exactly the same evolution equations @xcite it is easy to conclude that the conjugated fields also should be equivalent . for the activity one chooses independent random numbers at each site and each timestep ( on the @xmath0=0-line
this is just the role of @xmath13 ) .
accordingly one chooses for the chaotic order parameter independant random numbers at each site and each timestep ( rule @xmath70 in ref.@xcite ) .
the absorbing state now corresponds to identical variables states in the two replicas yielding the same update since the same noise has to be applied for equal configurations in the two systems .
this picture remains valid for @xmath71 although the evolution equations are no longer identical , but the absorbing state has the same properties .
note that on the line @xmath42 the critical exponents of the order - paramater are also the same .
if universality holds away from this line this statement should be true also for @xmath71 ( for @xmath67 it is known , that the critical exponents are different @xcite ) . in summary
we have shown in this letter that , in contradiction to previous findings , the chaotic phase in fact shows reentrant behaviour in the vicinity of the tricritical point as predicted by approximative analytical methods .
the effect was not seen before since it is relatively small and large scale simulations have to be made to detect it . on the other hand in the near of the @xmath13=1-line the predicted reentrant behaviour
is absent .
furthermore one can see that simulations of small systems with long transient times can lead to erroneous conclusions about the locations of the critical point as well as the shape of the phase boundary since it is difficult to estimate the error due to self correlations .
therefore the error - bars in reference @xcite seem to neglect these systematic errors and should be larger ( which could lead to an agreement with our results ) .
finally we have seen that the conjugate field to the chaotic order parameter can directly be identified from the equivalence to the activity order parameter on the @xmath0=0-line . |
star - formation rates ( sfrs ) are among the most fundamental measurements for constraining the physics of galaxy formation and evolution .
the past decade has seen a multitude of studies that trace sfrs out to high redshift ( * ? ? ? * and references therein ) , and examined their correlation with other galaxy properties , such as stellar masses ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the _ spitzer space telescope _ and _ herschel space observatory _ opened a new window into measuring bolometric sfrs by allowing us to directly correct the widely - used sfrs(uv ) for dust - obscured star formation ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . however , despite their common use , the uv+ir sfrs have several disadvantages : first , due to the limited spatial resolution and sensitivity of _ spitzer _ and _ herschel _ , most of the individual distant galaxies are not detectable in ir images , and second , the empirical templates used to convert the mid - ir ( restframe 8@xmath3 m ) fluxes to total ir luminosities result in systematic biases @xcite .
hydrogen balmer emission lines are considered to be another gold standard for tracing robust sfrs in local galaxies ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* among many others ) .
until recently , high - redshift studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) only detected h@xmath2 with no ( or very limited ) h@xmath7 measurements , which are required for accurate dust corrections .
however , with the new generation of multi - object near - ir ( nir ) spectrographs , both h@xmath2 and h@xmath7 are now detectable for normal star - forming galaxies at @xmath0 @xcite . while dust - corrected sfrs(h@xmath2 ) using balmer decrements ( hereafter , sfrs(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) )
are commonly used at low redshift , we still need to investigate how well balmer lines trace sfr at high redshifts , as galaxies were more star - forming at @xmath0 , the peak of the sfr density evolution @xcite .
in particular , it has been argued that balmer lines may miss optically thick star - forming regions at these high redshifts ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . in order to investigate this possible bias , one needs to compare the sfrs(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) with independently measured uv - to - far - ir ( uv - to - fir ) sfrs for star - forming galaxies at @xmath0 .
fortunately , such dusty systems are among the luminous tail of the galaxy distribution within reach of _ herschel_. in this paper , we use the unique dataset of the mosfire deep evolution field ( mosdef ) survey @xcite in combination with _ herschel _ and
_ spitzer _ data , to investigate how well sfrs(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) agree with uv - to - fir sfrs at @xmath0 . for the latter , we use the flexible stellar population synthesis ( fsps ) models @xcite , which utilize energy balance to fit the stellar and dust emission simultaneously @xcite . throughout this paper
, we assumed a @xcite initial mass function ( imf ) , and h@xmath9 .
the mosdef survey is a multi - year project that uses the mosfire spectrometer on the keck i telescope to study the stellar and gaseous content of @xmath10 galaxies and agns at @xmath11 .
the survey covers the candels fields , for which extensive deep multi - wavelength data are available @xcite . for details of the survey strategy ,
observations , data reduction , and sample characteristics see @xcite .
the current study is based on data from the first two years of the mosdef survey .
we selected a sample of mosdef galaxies based on their balmer emission and ir luminosities .
the h@xmath2 and h@xmath7 luminosities were estimated by fitting gaussian functions to the line profiles .
flux uncertainties were derived using monte carlo simulations . the spectra were flux calibrated by comparing the spectrum of a slit star with the total photometric flux @xcite in the same filter . to account for the fact that galaxies are resolved ,
an additional slit - loss correction was applied using the _ hst _ profiles for each galaxy ( see * ? ? ?
* ) . the uncertainties on the total slit - loss corrected fluxes were 16% and 20% for h@xmath2 and h@xmath7 , respectively @xcite .
h@xmath2 and h@xmath7 fluxes were corrected for underlying balmer absorption as determined from uv - to - nir sed modeling @xcite . the h@xmath2 luminosity was converted to sfr using the @xcite relation and was corrected for dust attenuation using the balmer decrement ( h@xmath2/h@xmath7 ) , assuming the @xcite galactic extinction curve . for those galaxies with undetected h@xmath7 , we used @xmath1 upper - limits on the h@xmath7 fluxes that translate to lower - limits on h@xmath2/h@xmath7 and thus lower - limits on dust - corrected sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) .
for the ir measurements we used data from _ spitzer_/mips and _ herschel_/pacs and spire in the cosmos ( pi : m. dickinson ) , goods - n , and goods - s fields @xcite .
we measured ir fluxes simultaneously using scaled point - spread functions ( psfs ) @xcite , which enable us to more robustly recover fluxes of confused objects . in brief , for each image we used a prior list of objects from higher resolution images to determine the location of all sources in the field .
for the mips images we used @xmath1 irac sources ; for the pacs images we used @xmath1 mips sources ; and for the spire images we used the pacs sources detected at @xmath1 ( for the 250 and 350@xmath3 m bands ) and @xmath12 ( for the 500@xmath3 m band ) . in order to perform the photometry , a subimage centered on each target was constructed and the psf was fitted simultaneously to all the objects in the subimage ( including the target ) and one random background position , which was chosen to be at least 1 fwhm away from any source .
we repeated this procedure for 20 random background positions .
the standard deviation of the background fluxes was adopted as the flux uncertainty .
the accuracy of our photometry was tested by simulating 500 sources with a large range of fluxes that were added to the original images .
the simulated fluxes were recovered successfully with a given scatter that , as expected , decreased with increasing flux .
based on this scatter , we estimated a correction factor to be applied to the background - estimated errors for each individual source .
these corrections ranged from a factor of @xmath13 , depending on the filter .
we selected galaxies whose ir photometry was not significantly affected by nearby sources and had robust detections ( signal - to - noise ratio ( s / n ) @xmath14 ) in h@xmath2 , mips 24@xmath3 m , and at least one pacs filter ( 100 or 160@xmath3 m ) .
the final sample consists of 13 galaxies with both h@xmath2 and h@xmath7 detections and 4 h@xmath7-undetected galaxies .
only three of these galaxies were detected in the spire filters .
we did not include objects that were classified as agns based on their x - ray emission , irac colors , or optical emission lines ( with the criterion of [ nii]/h@xmath2@xmath15 , @xcite ) .
as seen in figure [ fig : ms ] , most of our galaxies lie above the median sfr-@xmath16 relation by @xcite with @xmath17 .
in this section we derive total sfrs by comparing the panchromatic seds - composed of the uv - to - irac photometry from 3d - hst @xcite combined with ir photometry ( previous section ) - with stellar population models .
we generated composite stellar populations using the fsps code ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* v2.5 ) , assuming a chabrier imf and solar metallicity . for the star - formation history ( sfh )
we assumed a delayed - tau model of the form @xmath18 , in which @xmath19 is the age of the galaxy and @xmath20 is the e - folding time .
@xmath20 was allowed to vary from @xmath21myr in steps of 0.2dex .
we set a 50myr lower limit on age corresponding to the typical dynamical timescale at @xmath0 @xcite .
we adopted a @xcite attenuation curve , in which the dust optical depth at 5500 was allowed to vary from 0.0 to 4.0 in steps of 0.1 .
the dust emission in the fsps code follows the @xcite ( dl07 ) models . in these dust models ,
the radiation field strength , @xmath22 , is described by a delta function at @xmath23 ( the radiation intensity to which the dust in the diffuse ism is exposed ) and a power - law component for the radiation from dust heated by more intense starlight ( ob associations ) .
the parameter @xmath24 represents the fraction of dust that is heated by the intense starlight .
as was suggested in dl07 , we allowed @xmath23 to vary between 0.1 to 25.0 in 10 logarithmic steps , the @xmath24 grid was set to @xmath25 $ ] , and we explored pah fractions of @xmath26% .
we shifted the models to the spectroscopic redshift of each galaxy , applied the @xcite prescription to correct the seds for the intergalactic medium absorption , and then , adopting a @xmath27 minimization method ( using the original photometric errors ) , fit the models to the uv - to - fir photometry .
the optical photometry was corrected for contamination by bright emission lines ( h@xmath2 , [ oiii ] , [ oii ] , etc . ) as measured from the mosdef spectra @xcite .
we perturbed the photometry according to the measurement uncertainties for 100 realizations and the dispersion in each best - fit parameter was adopted as the associated uncertainty .
the best - fit models of the h@xmath2+h@xmath7-detected candidates are displayed in figures [ fig : seds1 ] and [ fig : seds2 ] .
we would have found similar sfrs if instead we modeled the ir emission by a single blackbody sed . in order to assure that our best - fit models are not skewed by the smaller 24@xmath3 m errors compared to the pacs errors , we tested the sed fitting with equal weighting for the 24 , 100 , and 160@xmath3 m fluxes .
for all but two galaxies ( galaxies 1 and 13 ) , the corresponding sfrs and ir luminosities were within @xmath28 uncertainty of the original sfr and l(ir ) values .
in this section we investigate how the sfrs derived from different diagnostics compare with each other . fitting the stellar and dust seds simultaneously using energy balance
is thought to give a robust estimate of the total sfr .
figure [ fig : sfrs](a ) shows that sfrs(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) are in good agreement with the full sed - inferred sfrs ( sfr@xmath29 ) .
the tightness of the correlation between @xmath30(sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) ) and @xmath30(sfr@xmath29)(sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) ) and @xmath30(sfr@xmath29 ) relation has 0.17dex scatter about the unity line and spearman @xmath31 with @xmath32 from a null correlation . ] , its consistency with the unity line , and the absence of any systematic correlation as a function of @xmath16 ( see the inset plot [ fig : sfrs](a ) ) , imply that the dust - corrected l(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) is an unbiased tracer of the total sfr for @xmath0 star - forming galaxies with sfrs up to @xmath33 .
there is a systematic uncertainty associated with our choice of the attenuation curve . assuming the calzetti curve instead of the cardelli curve to correct the observed h@xmath2 predicts higher sfrs by an average factor of 1.2 ( as high as 1.4 for the galaxy with the highest sfr ; diamonds in figure [ fig : sfrs]a ) .
the larger dust correction is expected as the calzetti curve has a higher normalization at 6563 .
we adopted the cardelli curve as it was derived based on the line - of - sight measurements of hii regions , and therefore preferable for the extinction correction of nebular lines .
given that the majority of the @xmath0 galaxies are not detected with _
herschel _ , it is important to know how well we can recover the total sfr with only 24@xmath3 m data .
we fit the fsps models to the uv - to-24@xmath3 m data and set the dust emission parameters to the default values ( pah fraction = 3.5% , @xmath34 , and @xmath35 ) .
the result is shown in figure [ fig : sfrs](b ) .
there is a larger ( 0.22dex ) scatter between sfr@xmath36 and sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) , and sfr@xmath36 underestimates sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) for the highest star - forming galaxies in our sample . in figure
[ fig : sfrs ] , panels c and d , we estimated the bolometric sfr by adding unobscured sfr(uv ) to obscured sfr(ir ) .
the sfr(uv ) is derived from luminosity at 1600 by fitting a power - law function of the form @xmath37 to the photometry at rest wavelengths @xmath38 , and using the @xcite conversion between l(uv ) and sfr . in order to estimate the total l(ir ) , we fit the locally calibrated @xcite templates ( hereafter , ce01 ) to the 24 , 100 , and 160@xmath3 m fluxes in figure [ fig : sfrs](c ) , and in figure [ fig : sfrs](d ) we converted the 24@xmath3 m to total l(ir ) using the luminosity - independent conversions of @xcite ( hereafter , w08 ) .
the scatter between both the sfr(ir ) indicators and sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) is larger than the scatter in figure [ fig : sfrs](a ) by @xmath39dex .
incorporating the spire photometry in the ce01 fitting does not change the results , as most of our galaxies are undetected in the spire bands .
whether the increased scatter is due to the limited parameter space of the ir templates or because of ignoring energy balance is an open question that can not be addressed with the limited data used in this study .
moreover , we tested the @xcite empirically - derived coefficients to infer total sfrs by combining observed h@xmath2 and ir luminosities .
the combined sfrs were systematically lower than our sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) and sfr@xmath40 by @xmath39dex .
the @xcite sample of nearby galaxies have a higher contribution of evolved populations of stars heating the dust , and therefore , their scaling factor underestimates the total sfr for our star - forming galaxies .
our sample contains 4 galaxies without h@xmath7 detections , for which we determined @xmath1 lower limits on the sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) .
the low sfr@xmath29 of the h@xmath7-undetected galaxies compared to the rest of the sample indicates that we are not biased against galaxies in which h@xmath7 is suppressed by dust attenuation . the h@xmath7 line in all four galaxies happened to fall close to a bright skyline , which likely explains their low s / n in h@xmath7 . , based on uv - to - nir sed ) to the measured ( l(ir)@xmath41 ) ir luminosities as a function of rest - frame @xmath42 color .
the good agreement between the two estimated ir luminosities suggests that there is not a dominant obscured stellar population that is missing from the uv - to - nir sed .
galaxies with undetected h@xmath7 are shown with crosses .
numbers correspond to the seds in figures [ fig : seds1],[fig : seds2 ] . ]
one concern regarding the use of energy - balance sed modeling is that for a galaxy with two distinct stellar populations , with one enshrouded by dust , and hence , bright in ir , and the other population less dusty and brighter in uv , the ir and uv - to - nir parts of the spectrum will be decoupled . for such cases ,
an energy - balance method would underestimate the true sfr and l(ir ) . to address this issue , we calculated l(ir ) based on the the uv - to - nir sed and compared it to the observed @xmath43 m photometry ( using the same stellar population models and fitting assumptions as for the full modeling , section [ sec : fullsed ] ) .
we used the estimated total extinction value at 1600 ( @xmath44 ) and unobscured sfr(uv ) measured from the luminosity at 1600 , to calculate the _ obscured _ sfr : @xmath45 using the @xcite relation , we converted the obscured sfr to total l(ir ) at @xmath4 m and compared it to the l(ir ) based on our best - fit full sed model , integrated from 8 to 1000@xmath3 m .
the results are shown in figure [ fig : lir ] .
for all galaxies in our sample , the uv - to - nir sed - derived l(ir ) is within a factor of @xmath46 of the integrated full sed l(ir ) , suggesting that there is not a dominant stellar population that is completely obscured and thus missed from the uv - to - nir sed .
the results of the uv - to - nir sed - inferred ir luminosities are sensitive to the assumed sfh and the sed - predicted ages .
if instead of a delayed - tau sfh we use a rising sfh of the form @xmath47 , the best - fit sed model predicts a high amount of dust obscuration for our most massive galaxies . because of the high dust obscuration inferred from the stellar sed , l(ir ) and sfr
are overpredicted by a factor of @xmath48 . additionally , as found in previous studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , without a minimum age of 50myr the best - fit uv - to - nir seds result in unrealistically young ages and high dust values for a subset of our galaxies .
the l(ir ) comparison test is similar to comparing the uv - to - nir and full sed sfrs . with a physically reasonable age range and the delayed - tau sfhs ,
the uv - to - nir sed and full sed sfrs are in good agreement ( @xmath49 , @xmath50 away from a zero correlation ) .
both tests illustrate that the sfr derived from the stellar emission alone is not biased compared to the uv - to - fir sed - based sfr for @xmath0 galaxies with @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
uv - inferred sfrs are susceptible to missing or underestimating the sfr of galaxies for which the bulk of the star formation is obscured and the uv slope is decoupled from the total obscuration @xcite .
although for a given column of dust h@xmath2 and h@xmath7 are less attenuated than the uv , hii regions may also be optically thick at these wavelengths .
we show in this paper that for galaxies with @xmath53yr@xmath54 the h@xmath2 luminosity , once properly corrected for dust attenuation using the balmer decrement , do not underestimate the sfr .
the same result holds for uv - to - nir sed inferred sfrs , assuming delayed - tau sfhs .
this conclusion does not necessarily hold at higher sfrs ( i.e. , submillimeter galaxies ) owing to highly obscured nebular and/or stellar regions .
such ir - luminous galaxies are likely missed in our study due to their low number density or highly obscured emission lines . to test the latter
, we checked the mosdef target sample for galaxies with ir detections and undetected h@xmath2 lines , and found two . due to uncertain redshifts and noisy spectra
we did not include them in this study . however , deeper and/or wider wavelength range spectra are needed to confirm these systems .
there are additional caveats to our analysis which need to be explored in more detail in future studies .
first , both the sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) and the sfr@xmath29 suffer from systematic uncertainties in the assumed imf , metallicity , and sfh .
second , the sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) is affected by the choice of the assumed dust attenuation curve ( section [ sec : sfrs ] ) , and the sfr@xmath29 by the assumed dust emission models .
once we have the complete mosdef dataset in hand , we will build upon the results of this study by stacking _
spitzer _ and _ herschel _ measurements for our full sample .
thanks mostafa khezri and ali khostovan for useful discussions and feedback on the manuscript .
the authors thank mark dickinson for providing part of the ir data .
n.a.r are supported by a national science foundation graduate research fellowship dge-1326120 and an alfred p. sloan research fellowship , respectively .
the mosdef survey is funded by nsf aag collaborative grants ast-1312780 , 1312547 , 1312764 , and 1313171 and archival grant ar-13907 , provided by nasa through a grant from the space telescope science institute . | we present the first direct comparison between balmer line and panchromatic sed - based sfrs for @xmath0 galaxies . for this comparison we used 17 star - forming galaxies selected from the mosfire deep evolution field ( mosdef ) survey , with @xmath1 detections for h@xmath2 and at least two ir bands ( _ spitzer_/mips 24@xmath3 m and _ herschel_/pacs 100 and 160@xmath3 m , and in some cases _ herschel_/spire 250 , 350 , and 500@xmath3 m ) .
the galaxies have total ir ( @xmath4 m ) luminosities of @xmath5 and star - formation rates ( sfrs ) of @xmath6 .
we fit the uv - to - far - ir seds with flexible stellar population synthesis ( fsps ) models which include both stellar and dust emission and compare the inferred sfrs with the sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) values corrected for dust attenuation using balmer decrements .
the two sfrs agree with a scatter of 0.17 dex .
our results imply that the balmer decrement accurately predicts the obscuration of the nebular lines and can be used to robustly calculate sfrs for star - forming galaxies at @xmath0 with sfrs up to @xmath8 .
we also use our data to assess sfr indicators based on modeling the uv - to - mid - ir seds or by adding sfr(uv ) and sfr(ir ) , for which the latter is based on the mid - ir only or on the full ir sed .
all these sfrs show a poorer agreement with sfr(h@xmath2,h@xmath7 ) and in some cases large systematic biases are observed .
finally , we show that the sfr and dust attenuation derived from the uv - to - near - ir sed alone are unbiased when assuming a delayed exponentially declining star - formation history . |
one long - standing problem in the study of nuclear activity in galaxies is to understand how mass is transferred from galactic scales down to nuclear scales to feed the supermassive black hole ( hereafter smbh ) inside .
many theoretical studies and simulations ( shlosman et al . 1990 ; emsellem et al . 2003 ; knapen 2005 ; emsellem et al .
2006 ) have shown that non - axisymmetric potentials efficiently promote gas inflow towards the inner regions ( englmaier & shlosman 2004 ) .
recent observations have revealed that structures such as small - scale disks or nuclear bars and associated spiral arms are frequently observed in the inner kiloparsec of active galaxies ( erwin & sparke 1999 ; pogge & martini 2002 ; laine et al .
2003 ) . in a recent work ,
lopes et al .
( 2007 ) have shown a strong correlation between the presence of nuclear dust structures ( filaments , spirals and disks ) and activity in galaxies .
nuclear spirals , in particular , are estimated to reside in more than half of active galaxies ( martini et al .
martini & pogge ( 1999 ) have shown that nuclear spirals are not self - gravitating , and that they are likely to be shocks in nuclear gas disks .
simulations by maciejewski ( 2004a , b ) demonstrated that , if a central smbh is present , spiral shocks can extend all the way to the smbh vicinity and generate gas inflow consistent with the accretion rates inferred in local agn .
the above studies support the hypothesis that nuclear spirals are a mechanism for fueling the nuclear smbh , transporting gas from kiloparsec scales down to a few tens of parsecs of the active nucleus ( knapen et al .
2000 ; emsellem et al .
2001 ; maciejewski et al . 2002 ; marconi et al . 2003 ; crenshaw et al . 2003 ; fathi et al .
this hypothesis has recently been confirmed by our group ( fathi et al .
2006 ) in the specific case of the liner / seyfert 1 galaxy ngc1097 . using integral field spectroscopy at the gemini telescope we mapped the velocity field of the ionized gas and detected streaming motions towards the nucleus along nuclear spiral arms .
ngc1097 is the only case so far in which streaming motions along nuclear spiral arms have been mapped . in order to verify
if such spirals are always associated with inward streaming motions it is necessary to map the gas kinematics in more galaxies . with this goal in mind ,
we have obtained gemini integral field spectroscopic observations of a few more active galaxies with nuclear spirals observed in hst images .
the sample was selected from nearby galaxies ( [email protected] ) with intermediate inclinations , to facilitate study of the gas kinematics on linear distance scales of tens of parsecs . in the present paper
we report the results for ngc6951 , a galaxy with hubble type sab(rs)bc , at a distance of 24mpc ( tully 1988 ) , such that 1 arcsec corresponds to 96pc at the galaxy .
originally it was argued that ngc6951 has a liner type nucleus ( filippenko & sargent 1985 ) , but more recently it has been suggested that actually its activity is intermediate between liner and seyfert ( prez et al .
ngc6951 hosts a large scale bar ( with total extent of @xmath44kpc ) , and at about 5 ( 480pc ) from the nucleus , there is a conspicuous star - forming ring , previously observed in h@xmath0 ( mrquez & moles 1993 ; prez et al . 2000 ) and showing also strong co and hcn emission ( kohno et al . 1999 , garcia - burillo et al .
2005 , krips et al .
continuum radio emission has also been observed from the nucleus and star - forming ring by saikia et al .
( 1994 ) , while a higher resolution radio image can be found in ho & ulvestad ( 2001 ) .
our ifu measurements show that , similarly to ngc1097 , the gas kinematics inside the nuclear ring of ngc6951 , although dominated by circular rotation , shows deviations in the measured radial velocities which can be interpreted as at least partially due to streaming inward motions along nuclear spiral arms .
our results strenghten the case that nuclear spirals are indeed channels to feed the supermassive black hole in active galaxies .
the present paper is organized as follows . in section 2
we describe the observations and reductions . in section 3
we present the flux and kinematic measurements . in section 4
we discuss the results and in section 5 we present our conclusions .
the observations were obtained with the integral field unit of the gemini multi - object spectrograph ( gmos - ifu , allington - smith et al .
2002 ) at the gemini north telescope , on the nights of august 31 and september 1 , 2006 .
the observations consisted of three adjacent ifu fields ( covering @xmath9 each ) resulting in a total angular coverage of @xmath10 around the nucleus .
three exposures of 500s were obtained for each of the 3 ifu fields , slightly shifted in order to correct for detector defects .
observations of the three ifu fields were obtained consecutively on the same night .
the fluxes in adjacent ifu pixels from neighbouring fields were found to be consistent within 10% .
therefore , no shifts or scaling were applied when combining the three fields to obtain the final mosaic .
the longest extent of the three adjacent ifu fields was oriented along position angle ( hereafter pa ) 140@xmath11 , selected to approximately coincide with the major axis of the galaxy , ( pa=138 according to mrquez & moles 1993 ) , while the large scale bar is oriented approximately along e w .
each ifu fiber has a diameter which corresponds to 0.2 in the sky , while the seeing during the observations ranged between 0.4 and 0.5 , corresponding to a spatial resolution at the galaxy of @xmath1240pc .
the selected wavelength range was 56007000 , in order to cover the h@xmath0+[nii]@xmath26548,84 and [ sii]@xmath26716,31 emission lines , observed with the grating gmos r400-g5325 ( set to central wavelength @xmath12 6300 ) , with an instrumental fwhm of 2.9 , corresponding to a spectral resolution of r@xmath13 ( @xmath14kms@xmath7 ) .
the data reduction was performed using the specific tasks developed for gmos data in the gemini.gmos package as well as generic tasks in iraf .
the reduction process comprised bias subtraction , flat - fielding , trimming , wavelength calibration , sky subtraction , relative flux calibration , building of the data cubes at a sampling of 0.1@[email protected]@xmath15 , and finally the alignment and combination of the 9 data cubes .
as we have obtained only relative flux calibration ( what is called in gemini `` baseline calibrations '' ) , we have normalized the flux levels using the h@xmath0 nuclear flux reported by perez et al .
in figure [ image ] we show the acquisition image with the location of the three ifu fields , together with an image obtained from the ifu data in the continuum adjacent to the h@xmath0 emission - line .
the ifu observations cover the nuclear region out to the star - forming ring , more clearly seen in the h@xmath0 and [ nii ] images shown in fig .
[ flux_ratios ] .
the h@xmath0 and [ nii ] emission lines could be measured over most of the @xmath10 field , except for a few locations which appear in black in fig .
[ flux_ratios ] .
for the [ sii ] emission lines , there are more locations where the lines could not be measured due to the low signal - to - noise ratio in these lines . in figure [ spectra ]
we show a sample of spectra : one from the nucleus , one from the star - forming ring and two from locations between the nucleus and the ring .
the emission - lines present in most spectra are h@xmath0 , [ nii]@xmath26548,84 and [ sii]@xmath26717,31 .
the lines [ oi]@xmath26300,63 were marginally detected only in a few spectra , and were not considered in our analysis due to the poor signal - to - noise ratio ( in these lines ) .
the emission - line spectrum from the nucleus is liner - like ( [ nii]@xmath16584 stronger than h@xmath0 ) , as already known from previous works ( e.g. filippenko & sargent 1985 ) .
more recently , ho , fillipenko & sargent ( 1997 ) have argued that the nuclear activity is better classified as seyfert 2 , after an analysis of the nuclear spectrum taking into account the effect of the underlying stellar absorption in the fluxes of the balmer lines .
prez et al .
( 2000 ) , after a similar analysis , conclude that the nuclear activity of ngc6951 is intermediate between liner and seyfert 2 .
our data are consistent with all these classifications , as our restricted wavelength coverage does not allow the observation of additional line ratios necessary to distinguish between the different types of activity .
the emission - line ratios in the star - forming ring are typical of hii regions , while in the regions between the nucleus and the ring , the line - ratios are also mostly liner - like , turning to `` hii - like '' as the star - forming ring is approached .
the line fluxes , radial velocities and velocity dispersions were obtained by fitting gaussians to the emission - lines , which accurately represent the observed line profiles . the h@xmath0 image , obtained from the integrated h@xmath0 flux is shown in fig . [ flux_ratios ] , together with the image in the adjacent continuum .
most spectra have signal - to - noise ratios in the h@xmath0 and [ nii ] emission lines larger than 50 .
the star - forming ring is clearly seen in the h@xmath0 image , formed by several hii regions which appear as emission - line knots along the ring .
the ring is more extended along the major axis of the galaxy ( pa@xmath4140 ) , where it reaches @xmath12 4.5 from the nucleus ( 430pc at the galaxy ) , while in the perpendicular direction it reaches only @xmath12 2.5 .
the line ratio map [ nii]/h@xmath0 , obtained from the ratio of the images in [ nii]@xmath16584 and h@xmath0 , as well as the [ sii]@xmath16717/@xmath16731 ratio map are also shown in fig .
[ flux_ratios ] .
prior to the construction of the map [ nii]/h@xmath0 we have corrected the h@xmath0 line fluxes by an average underlying absorption due to the stellar population with an equivalenth width of 0.75 .
this procedure is necessary in order to avoid unphysical very high ratios of [ nii]/h@xmath0 and is supported by the inspection of a few spectra which reveal that where h@xmath0 emission is very faint the line is indeed obviously filling an absorption .
the average value of 0.75 was adopted from the work of prez et al .
( 2000 ) who estimated an absorption equivalent width of h@xmath0 of 1 at the nucleus and 0.5 at the ring on the basis of the analysis of the stellar population .
we thus decided to adopt an average value between that of the nucleus and that of the ring , as the resulting corrected fluxes did not change by more than @xmath420% at the nucleus and @xmath410% at the ring if we change the underlying absorption by 0.25 .
the highest [ nii]/h@xmath0 line ratios reach values of 4 - 5 within a @xmath121 radius from the nucleus , decreasing to 2 - 3 between 1 and 2 and down to @xmath120.3 at the circumnuclear ring .
the ratio [ sii]@xmath16717/@xmath16731 reaches a minimum value of @xmath120.8 , implying a maximum gas density of @xmath16@xmath17 within @xmath121 from the nucleus ( osterbrock 1989 ) . at the star - forming ring , the [ sii ] ratio ranges from 1 to 1.4 , with typical values at most locations between 1.1 and 1.2 , implying gas densities in the range 250400@xmath17 . at the borders of the ring
, the low - density limit value of 1.4 ( @xmath8100@xmath17 ) is reached . in most locations between the nucleus and the ring , the signal - to - noise ratio was too low to get a reliable value for the [ sii ] ratio . in many location where it could be measured , it was in the low - density limit . in order to investigate this further
, we have binned 9 spectra together ( which corresponds to [email protected]@xmath18 , and thus approximately to the angular resolution of the data ) in several locations and got ratios in the range 1.2@xmath8[sii]6717/[email protected] , thus somewhat above the low - density limit , implying ionized gas densities of @xmath4100@xmath17 , which we will adopt as the typical value for this region .
the central wavelengths of the gaussian curves fitted to the emission - lines were used to obtain the gas radial velocities , while the full widths at half maxima ( fwhm ) were used to obtain the gas velocity dispersions ( @xmath19fwhm/2.355 ) .
the accuracy of the velocity measurements is @xmath1210kms@xmath7 .
the radial velocity field obtained from h@xmath0 is shown in the top left panel of fig .
[ radial_vel ] .
it is dominated by rotation , as evidenced by its similarity to the classical `` spider diagram '' ( binney & merrifield 1998 ) .
( the pixels for which we could not measure the kinematics due to low signal - to - noise ratio in the emission lines are shown in black in the figure . )
there are , nevertheless , clear deviations from simple rotation in the radial velocity field . in order to isolate these deviations ,
we have fitted an exponential thin disk kinematic model to the h@xmath0 radial velocity data , assuming that the density profile is exponential and its kinematics is circular rotation ( freeman 1970 ; binney & tremaine 1987 ) .
the procedure is similar to the one we have adopted in modelling the circumnuclear gas kinematics of ngc1097 ( fathi et al . 2005 ; fathi et al . 2006 ) .
the velocity field corresponding to the best fit is shown in the top right panel of fig .
[ radial_vel ] .
the fit to the model gives a systemic velocity of 1450@xmath2020kms@xmath7 , a deprojected maximum velocity amplitude of 220@xmath2010kms@xmath7 , a disk scale length of [email protected](390pc at the galaxy ) and a position angle for the line of nodes of pa=125@xmath2010 .
we have adopted a disk inclination of @xmath21 , a value derived from photometry ( mrquez & moles 1993 ) , because the inclination is not well constrained in our multi - parameter space fitting procedure .
a comparison between the measured radial velocity field and the disk model reveals deviations from simple rotation .
these deviations are observed along the star - forming ring as well as inside the ring , where , in particular , we have identified two features resembling partial spiral arms marked by two white curved lines with arrows in fig .
[ radial_vel ] . in order to investigate
if these deviations correspond to real features in the galaxy , we have constructed a structure map ( pogge & martini 2002 ) using an hst image of the nuclear region of ngc6951 obtained through the filter f606w ( hst proposal 8597 , pi m. regan ) .
the structure map is useful to enhance the contrast in the images , thus showing more clearly both dark structures
regions obscured by dust , as well as bright regions such as hii regions , a compact bright nucleus or star clusters .
the structure map is shown in the bottom left panel of fig .
[ radial_vel ] , where we have drawn the same white lines of the top left panel , showing that the partial spiral arms follow the dusty spiral structure seen in the structure map .
although there are more spiral arms in the structure map than the two we see in the velocity residual map , this difference can be understood as due to the poorer angular resolution of the ifu data ( @xmath120.4 ) compared to that of the hst ( 0.05 ) , which precludes us from establishing a more detailed correspondence . in the bottom right panel of fig .
[ radial_vel ] we show the residuals between the observed and the model velocity field , where the white lines correspond again to the partial arm structures .
the top arm ( hereafter called w arm ) corresponds to a blueshifted region in the residual map , while the bottom arm ( hereafter e arm ) corresponds to a redshifted region .
there are aditional blue- and redshift residuals in the star forming ring as well as close to the nucleus .
the aditional velocity residuals close to the nucleus in fig .
[ radial_vel ] are approximately delimited by the borders of a `` bi - cone '' , sketched in white in the figure , which corresponds to regions in which we see an increase in the values of the velocity dispersion , as discussed below . the gas velocity dispersion ( @xmath22 ) maps in h@xmath0 and [ nii ] are shown in fig.[sigma ] .
the instrumental @xmath22 is @xmath1250kms@xmath7 , thus it can be concluded that many values , particularly for h@xmath0 , are at the resolution limit of the instrument .
the low values obtained for h@xmath0 in some regions are due to the fact that , in the region between the nucleus and the star - forming ring h@xmath0 emission is strongly affected by the underlying stellar absorption ( discussed above ) , which makes the observed emission line weaker and narrower . on the other hand , the [ nii ] profile provides a reliable measure of @xmath22 because it is free of the contamination by stellar absorption .
most @xmath22 values range between 60 and 80kms@xmath7 but there are larger values reaching 140kms@xmath7 in two blobs within @xmath121 from the nucleus to the s - se and n - nw
. what could be the origin of these enhancements in @xmath22 ?
our experience with previous ifu observations ( of other targets ; e.g. riffel et al . 2006 ; barbosa et al . 2007 ) , reveal that increases in @xmath22 in the gas surrounding agn are usually related to the presence of a passing radio jet .
we searched the literature for a possible nuclear radio jet and found that vla observations by saikia et al .
( 2002 ) of the inner region of ngc6951 indeed suggest the presence of a resolved nuclear radio source presenting an angular size of [email protected]@xmath18 along pa=156 .
we show a representation of this small radio source as a bar with arrows in fig.[sigma ] as well as in the bottom right panel of fig.[radial_vel ] .
notice that the extent and orientation of this radio structure coincide with those of a bright similarly elongated nuclear structure seen in the structure map ( bottom left panel of fig.[radial_vel ] ) .
as the f606w filter used to obtain the hst image includes h@xmath0 , this coincidence suggests that we are resolving enhanced h@xmath0 emission associated with the radio structure in this image .
it can be seen that the estimated extent of the radio source fits well in between the two regions of enhanced @xmath22 values in fig.[sigma ] .
we have sketched ( in white in the figure ) the borders of a bi - cone which includes the regions of largest @xmath22 values .
we notice that the corresponding locations in fig .
[ radial_vel ] approximately delimitate also a redshifted h@xmath0 emitting region to the n nw and a blue - shifted region to the s se observed in the residual h@xmath0 velocity map ( bottom right panel ) . the observed increase in @xmath22 along the bi - cone and the presence of associated
blue- and reshifts suggests that these two structures are due to an outflow driven by the radio jet . the delineated bi - cone in figs .
[ radial_vel ] and [ sigma ] approximately separates the regions affected by the outflow from the regions affected by the residual motion along the spiral arms .
an extensive photometric and spectroscopic study of the galaxy ngc6951 has been presented by prez et al .
( 2000 , hereafter p00 ) .
they adopt the disk major axis pa=138 and have obtained longslit spectra ( slit width of 1 arcsecond ) along this pa as well as along pa=48 ( minor axis ) and pa=84 .
p00 quote line ratio values of [ nii]/h@xmath0 larger than unity within the inner 2 , reaching @xmath125 at the nucleus , in agreement with our results .
they present data within the nuclear region at a sampling of 0.5 ( although the seeing was 1.2 during their observations ) .
p00 report electron density values increasing from n@xmath23300@xmath17 at the ring to @xmath241000@xmath17 at the nucleus , also in agreement with our results . in order to further investigate the excitation ,
we have plotted in fig.[excitation ] the ratio [ nii]/h@xmath0 vs. the velocity dispersion obtained from the width of the [ nii]@xmath16584 emission - line @xmath25}$ ] . we have separated the data from the ring and from the region inside the ring using the h@xmath0 image to identify the region dominated by the ring . in order to do this ,
we have fitted two ellipses : one to the inner border of the ring and another to the outer border . along the longest extent of the ring ( approximately along the vertical axis of the figures ) ,
the inner border is located at 2.8 from the nucleus and the outer border at 6.8 , while along the shortest extent of the ring the inner border is at 2.0 and the outer border at 3.6
. it can be seen that the behavior of the two regions is clearly different : while for the ring most values of [ nii]/h@xmath0 are in the range 0.30.4 , typical of hii regions and show just a weak correlation with @xmath25}$ ] , in the region inside the ring the [ nii]/h@xmath0 values are much higher and present a strong correlation with @xmath25}$ ] . this behavior has been observed previously in other galaxies ( e.g. keppel et al .
1991 ; sokolowski et al . 1991 ; storchi - bergmann et al .
1996 ) , meaning that the gas excitation is related to its kinematics , and suggest in particular that at least part of the ionization is produced by shocks as shocks do enhance the [ nii]/h@xmath0 ratio ( viegas & contini 1994 ; sutherland et al . 1993 ) , as well as broaden the emission - lines .
the presence of shocks in the vicinity of the nucleus is particularly evident in fig.[sigma ] , where we have shown that two regions which have the highest observed @xmath22 values are located at the ends of the nuclear radio structure , and can be interpreted as gas from the interstellar medium of the galaxy shocked by a radio jet .
garcia - burillo et al .
( 2005 , hereafter gb05 ) have obtained molecular co radio images of the inner region of ngc6951 , showing that most of the co emission is concentrated in `` two winding nuclear spiral arms which end up as a pseudo - ring at @xmath4350pc from the nucleus '' , with an estimated molecular gas mass of @xmath26m@xmath6 .
this nuclear spiral seen in molecular gas corresponds in fact to the h@xmath0 ring , whose strongest h@xmath0 emission seems to be a bit external to the strongest molecular gas emission .
gb05 also report the observation of `` an unresolved nuclear complex '' within 50pc from the nucleus , estimating its mass to be a few @xmath27m@xmath6 .
the presence of a relatively large molecular gas mass at the nucleus is supported also by the recent mm - interferometric observations by krips et al . ( 2007 ) who have found compact hcn emission at the nucleus and estimate an even larger mass for the corresponding molecular complex , of @xmath4210@xmath28m@xmath6 .
these observations support the recent inflow of molecular gas to the nuclear region . besides the nuclear complex
, gb05 have also `` tentatively detected '' ( their words ) low level co emission bridging the gap between the nuclear source and the n part of the ring , with an estimated molecular mass of @xmath29m@xmath6 .
gb05 argue that this structure could be the molecular counterpart of the filamentary spiral structure identified in a j h color map of ngc6951 obtained from hst images . their j h map ( fig .
4a in gb05 ) is very similar to the structure map we show in the lower left panel of fig.[radial_vel ] . a comparison of this structure map with both our h@xmath0 velocity map ( upper left panel of fig .
[ radial_vel ] ) and fig.4 of gb05 shows that their `` molecular bridge '' seems to partially coincide with the w arm structure seen in our kinematic map , in particular with the `` inner end '' of our partial w arm .
a close look shows that the molecular bridge seems to be associated with the darker regions of the structure map closer to the nucleus ( an thus with the dust structure ) while our w partial arm is better coincident with the brighter portions of the structure map , a bit more distant from the nucleus .
a possible interpretation is that we are seeing two parts of a spiral arm : a more external one , traced by h@xmath0 emission , and a more internal one , seen only in molecular gas emission , probably due to the absence or faintness of ionized gas emission .
the rotation pattern in the h@xmath0 radial velocity field ( fig.[radial_vel ] ) shows that the se side of the galaxy is receding while the nw side is approaching . under the assumption that the spiral arms are trailing , and that the approaching side of the bar piles up the dust in front of it , it can be concluded that the near side of the galaxy is the sw , and the far side is the ne . the deviations from circular rotation along the two partial spiral arms in the inner 23 from the nucleus
blueshifted residuals along the w arm and redshifted residuals along the e arm can thus be interpreted as streaming motions along nuclear spiral arms towards the nucleus .
nevertheless , the residuals in this inner region extend beyond the region covered by the e and w arms drawn in fig.[radial_vel ] : in particular , there are additional blueshifts observed to the s se of the nucleus and redshifts observed to the n nw , which seem to be a continuation of the e and w arms .
nevertheless , at @xmath41n nw and s se of the nucleus , they are not consistent with streaming motions towards the nucleus . we conclude that these residuals are in fact outflows due to the interaction of the radio source at the nucleus ( saikia et al .
2002 ) with the circumnuclear ism of the galaxy .
this hypothesis is supported by the increase in the velocity dispersion of the gas from 70kms@xmath7 to 140kms@xmath7 along the position angle of the radio structure ( pa=156 ) , approximately within a region delineated by two white lines representing the borders of a bi - cone in fig.[sigma ] . from the location of this bi - cone in fig.[radial_vel ] , we conclude that the residual blueshifts at @xmath121n - nw and redshifts at @xmath121s - se of the nucleus are observed in the regions corresponding to those with enhanced @xmath22 and can be interpreted as outflows related to the radio source .
the residuals from circular motion in the inner 3 thus include two components : ( 1 ) streaming motions towards the nucleus along spiral arms and ( 2 ) an outflow due to the interaction of a radio source with the circumnuclear ism of the galaxy . from the relative intensity of the continuum observed in the structure map in the location of the radio structure , which is brighter to the side to which the residuals are blueshifts , we suggest that the near side of the jet is projected against the near side of the galaxy , which is possible only if its angle relative to the galaxy plane is smaller than 48 , for the adopted inclination of the galaxy of 42 . in the regions corresponding to the ring , there are also radial velocity residuals relative to the circular rotation which could be due to outflows from the starbursts along the ring and/or deviations due to the accumulation of the gas in the inner lindblad ressonance .
the kinematics we have obtained for the nuclear region of ngc6951 can be compared with that obtained in previous works , in particular by p00 , who have studied the large scale kinematics from long - slit spectroscopy along three position angles ( over a radius of up to 100 from the nucleus ) : one along the photometric major axis ( 138 ) , one along the perpendicular direction ( 48 ) and one along pa=84 . on the basis of the kinematics along these three pas ,
p00 obtain a systemic velocity of @xmath304kms@xmath7 and an amplitude of the rotation curve of @xmath12200kms@xmath31 , after de - projection ( see , for example , fig .
13 of p00 ) .
these parameters are similar to our values of @xmath3220kms@xmath7 and amplitude @xmath33kms@xmath7 of the rotation curve .
these paramenters are also similar to those previously obtained by mrques & moles ( 1993 ) on the basis of longslit spectra along the major and minor axes of the galaxy , in spite of the fact that our kinematic data is two - dimensional but covers a much smaller radial extent ( 3.5@xmath34 ) .
this difference in angular coverage may explain the difference between the major axis orientation obtained in previous studies and the one derived from our kinematic modelling of 125@xmath2010 .
p00 report a `` peculiar structure '' in the velocity field along the minor axis ( pa=48 ) , which they argue could be due to a nuclear outflow or to a structure related to the `` internal inner lindblad ressonance ( iilr ) '' .
they adopt the second hyppothesis , suggesting counter rotation of an inner disk , which they argue could be related to the iilr , calculated to occur at 180pc ( 2 ) .
they argue that this would fit into a scenario of disk nested within disks .
our data , with a complete 2d coverage , favors best the nuclear outflow hypothesis , but in combination with streaming motions along nuclear spirals .
gb05 have used near - ir hst images of the nuclear region where they found a stellar oval in combination with the co observations , in order to estimate whether torques produced by the non - axisymmetric stellar potential would be efficient enough to drain the gas angular momentum allowing its inflow to the nuclear region .
gb05 conclude that the inflow is efficient only down to the star forming ring , approximately . inside the ring ,
the torques are positive and can not drive gas inflow . as molecular gas is observed much closer to the nucleus , gb05 conclude that , inside the ring , other mechanisms should be responsible to drive the agn fueling , such as viscous torques .
englmaier & shlosman ( 2000 ) have used 2d numerical simulations to show that nuclear gaseous spirals are generated as as result of the gas response to the gravitational potential of a galactic disk with a large scale stellar bar .
both ngc6951 and ngc1097 ( fathi et al .
2006 ) present similar large scale stellar bars , which could thus play a role in the formation of the nuclear spirals . more recently ,
maciejewski ( 2004 ) has considered the effect of a smbh in nuclear gaseous spirals .
the fact that the smbh does play a role is supported by the ubiquitous presence of nuclear spirals in seyfert galaxies ( martini & pogge 1999 ; pogge & martini 2002 ) , and , in particular , by the strong correlation of their presence with the nuclear activity ( lopes et al .
maciejewski concludes that , if the asymmetry is strong , spiral shocks are produced , and the central smbh can allow the spiral shocks to extend all the way to its immediate vicinity , generating gas inflow of up to 0.03m@xmath6yr@xmath7 . the cases of ngc6951 presented here and ngc1097 presented by fathi et al .
( 2006 ) seem to support the models of maciejewski ( 2004a , b ) .
we can use the residual velocities observed along the nuclear spiral to estimate the rate of mass flowing to the nucleus . in order to do that ,
we assume that the mass flows along two nuclear spiral arms .
the cross section of these arms can be estimated assuming an opening angle of 20 subtended by the spiral arms at 100pc from the nucleus .
this opening angle corresponds to a radius for an assumed circular cross section of the spiral arm calculated as : @xmath35 + the flux of matter crossing the circular cross section can be calculated as : @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the electron density , @xmath38 is the streaming velocity of the gas towards the nucleus , @xmath39 is the number of spiral arms , @xmath40 is the mass of the proton , and @xmath41 is the filling factor .
the filling factor was estimated from : @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the h@xmath0 luminosity emitted by a volume @xmath44 and @xmath453.534@xmath46erg@xmath17s@xmath7 ( osterbrock 1989 ) .
in the region covered by the partial spiral arms we obtain an average flux per pixel ( of angular size [email protected] ) of 4.8@xmath47erg@xmath48s@xmath7 . in order to calculate the h@xmath0 luminosity in the region covered by a partial arm
, we adopt an area of 2@xmath31 which corresponds to 200 pixels .
we thus obtain @[email protected]@xmath50erg@xmath48s@xmath51mpc)@xmath18=6.62@xmath310@xmath52ergs@xmath7 . adopting an approximate volume for the region ( from fig.[radial_vel ] ) of 2@xmath31@xmath531 , or @xmath44=2000@xmath49(9.6pc)@xmath54
, we obtain @xmath550.004 .
the velocity residuals in the region of the partial nuclear arms , which we have interpreted as streaming motions , range from @xmath1220kms@xmath7 to @xmath1250kms@xmath7 ( fig.[radial_vel ] ) . assuming that these streaming motions occur in the plane of the galaxy , we need to correct these values for the inclination of the galaxy @xmath21 .
the resulting average velocity for the streaming motions is @xmath56=40kms@xmath7 . for @xmath57@xmath17 ( fig.[flux_ratios ] ) ,
@xmath58kms@xmath7 and @xmath59 , we obtain the value for the flux of matter along the nuclear spirals of @xmath60gs@[email protected]@xmath128@xmath61m@xmath62yr@xmath7 .
we note that the above calculation is only a rough estimate , as it depends on uncertain parameters , such as the geometry of the flow . under the assumption that the gas moving along the spiral is reaching the nucleus
, we can compare the above calculated rate of ionized gas flow to the accretion rate necessary to reproduce the luminosity of the liner nucleus of ngc6951 , calculated as follows .
the nuclear luminosity can be estimated from the h@xmath0 luminosity of l(h@xmath0)@xmath63ergs@xmath7 ( from the nuclear flux and reddening quoted by p00 ) using the approximation that the bolometric luminosity is @xmath64 100@xmath65(h@xmath66ergs@xmath7 ( ho 1999 ; ho et al .
this estimate is consistent also with the upper limit on the x - ray luminosity of this galaxy , @xmath67ergs@xmath7 ( fabbiano et al .
1992 ; ho 1999 ) .
the mass accretion rate can then be estimated as : @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the efficiency of conversion of the rest mass energy of the accreted material into radiation . for a `` standard '' geometrically thin , optically thick accretion disk , @xmath700.1 ( e.g. frank et al .
2002 ) , but for liners it has been concluded that the accretion disk is geometrically thick , and optically thin ( ho 2005 ; nemmen et al .
2006 , yuan 2007 ) .
this kind of accretion flow is known as riaf ( radiatively inefficient accretion flow ; narayan 2005 ) , and has a typical value for @xmath700.01 .
we use this value to derive an accretion rate of @xmath71gs@xmath7 , or 2.8@xmath72m@xmath73yr@xmath7 . comparing this accretion rate @xmath74 with the mass flow of ionized gas along the nuclear spirals derived above @xmath75
, we conclude that @xmath76 3@xmath74 .
thus the flow of ionized gas along the spiral arms is of the order of the one necessary to feed the agn in ngc6951 .
we should nevertheless point out that this flow is most probably a lower limit to the actual inward flow of matter , as we are observing only the ionized gas , which may be just the `` tip of the iceberg '' .
neutral and molecular gas may also be flowing in , as suggested by the @xmath7710@xmath78m@xmath6 of molecular gas mass detected at the nucleus by gb05 and krips et al .
( 2007 ) .
we now compare the above results obtained for ngc6951 with those obtained for ngc1097 .
storchi - bergmann ( 2007 ) has calculated the mass flow rate along the nuclear spirals of ngc1097 on the basis of similar ifu observations , but for a filling factor f=1 . if we adopt a more realistic value of @xmath4 10@xmath79 , it can be concluded that the mass flow rate of ionized gas is again similar to the accretion rate necessary to power the liner nucleus of ngc1097 .
similarly to the case of ngc6951 , the total mass flow is probably larger , and could include neutral and molecular gas
. a larger mass flow rate would be consistent with the presence of a young starburst ( age@xmath410@xmath80yr ) with mass 10@xmath80m@xmath62 discovered in the nuclear hst - stis uv nuclear spectrum of ngc1097 and estimated to be closer than 9pc from the nucleus ( storchi - bergmann et al .
the gas flowing to the nuclear region is thus not only feeding the nucleus but has also accumulated enough mass to give origin to a circumnuclear starburst in the last 10@xmath80yrs .
the association of recent star - formation with nuclear activity has been claimed in many recent studies ( e.g. cid fernandes et al .
2001 , storchi - bergmann et al . 2001 ) and its association in particular with dust structures in early - type galaxies has been also supported by the recent work of ferrarese et al .
we have presented ifu - gmos observations of the ionized gas in the inner region of the galaxy ngc6951 which evidence the presence of streaming motions along nuclear spiral arms towards its liner nucleus .
the streaming motions are observed over an extent of @xmath12200pc along two partial spiral arms down to @xmath12100pc from the nucleus .
this is so far only the second galaxy in which such streaming motions have been mapped , the first being ngc1097 also by our group ( fathi et al .
the relevance of this result stems from the fact that the presence of dusty nuclear structures correlates strongly with nuclear activity ( lopes et al .
2007 ) , what suggests that these structures are associated with the actual fuel on its way in to feed the nuclear smbh .
nevertheless , until recently , there were no kinematic measurements which showed that these spirals do carry gas inwards .
such kinematic measurements are difficult to obtain due to the fact that the gas kinematics of the nuclear region of active galaxies is usually dominated by outflows from the narrow - line region .
most kinematic studies do reveal outflows and no inflows ( e.g. crenshaw & kraemer 2007 and references therein ) . in order to observe colder gas that can fall inwards
it is necessary to obtain gas kinematics around nuclei with low levels of activity , such that the outflows are small , if present .
this seems to be the case of ngc6951 : a liner nucleus , with a small jet , such that it was possible to disentangle the outlow related to the jet from streaming motions along nuclear spirals .
additional observational constraints to observe such motions around a galaxy nucleus include a favorable orientation of the galaxy to allow the measurement of the kinematics and strong enough gas emission to allow such measurements up to several hundred parsecs from the nucleus , so that we can constrain the disk rotation and on top of it measure the residuals from circular motion . with the present results for ngc6951 we can now say that there are two galaxies with confirmed inward streaming motions along nuclear spirals ngc1097 and ngc6951 giving strong support to the hypothesis that these spirals are indeed channels through which the matter flows inwards to feed the smbh .
the kinematic measurements and an estimated geometry derived from the observations has allowed us to estimate the ionized gas mass flow rate along the nuclear spirals of ngc1097 and ngc6951 .
we obtain values which are similar to the accretion rate necessary to power the agn .
the total mass flow rate is most probably larger , including neutral and molecular gas . in the case of ngc6951 ,
molecular gas has been recently observed both at the star forming ring and inside the ring . in the case of ngc1097 , the young nuclear starburst found by storchi - bergmann et al .
( 2005 ) supports also a larger flow of matter to the nucleus in the last 10@xmath80yrs .
thus it may be that the inflows observed along nuclear spiral arms not only feed nuclear smbh but at the same time contribute to the growth of the bulge via star formation . as a result ,
both the stellar component of the galaxy and its smbh at the nucleus grow after each activity cycle , in agreement with the scenario implied by the m@xmath81 relation ( e.g. tremaine et al .
2002 ) .
we acknowledge the referee for relevant suggestions which have improved the paper .
this work was based on observations obtained at the gemini observatory , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under a cooperative agreement with the nsf on behalf of the gemini partnership : the national science foundation ( usa ) , the particle physics and astronomy research council ( uk ) , the national research council ( canada ) , conicyt ( chile ) , the australian research council ( australia ) , cnpq ( brazil ) and conicet ( argentina ) .
kf acknowledges support from the werner - gren foundations , the royal swedish academy of sciences and project p3/86 from the instituto de astrofsica de canarias .
this work is also based on observations with the nasa / esa hubble space telescope obtained at the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , incorporated , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
tsb , old and rar acknowledge support from the brazilian institutions cnpq and capes . | we report the discovery of gas streaming motions along nuclear spiral arms towards the liner nucleus of the galaxy ngc6951 .
the observations , obtained using the gmos integral field spectrograph on the gemini north telescope , yielded maps of the flux distributions and gas kinematics in the h@xmath0 , [ nii]@xmath16584 and [ sii]@xmath26717,31 emission lines of the inner 7@xmath315 of the galaxy .
this region includes a circumnuclear star - forming ring with radius @xmath4500pc , a nuclear spiral inside the ring and the liner nucleus .
the kinematics of the ionized gas is dominated by rotation , but subtraction of a kinematic model of a rotating exponential disk reveals deviations from circular rotation within the nuclear ring which can be attributed to ( 1 ) streaming motions along the nuclear spiral arms and ( 2 ) a bipolar outflow which seems to be associated to a nuclear jet . on the basis of the observed streaming velocities and geometry of the spiral arms we estimate a mass inflow rate of ionized gas of @xmath5m@xmath6yr@xmath7 , which is of the order of the accretion rate necessary to power the liner nucleus of ngc6951 .
similar streaming motions towards the nucleus of another galaxy with liner nucleus
ngc1097 have been reported by our group in a previous paper . taken together
, these results support a scenario in which nuclear spirals are channels through which matter is transferred from galactic scales to the nuclear region to feed the supermassive black hole . |
recent advances in the controlled fabrication and manipulation of ultra - low temperature trapped bose gases @xcite has finally made it possible to experimentally investigate the existence of off - diagonal long - range order ( odlro ) , i.e. , bose - einstein condensation ( bec ) , in dimensions lower than three .
this remarkable experimental achievment has rekindled an interest in the classic theoretical problem concerning the existence of bec in two - dimensions ( 2d ) .
although it is well known that finite - temperature bec can never occur in a homogeneous 2d bose gas @xcite , the ideal trapped bose gas can undergo bec below some critical temperature @xmath3 . in the case of a 2d isotropic harmonic trap with confining frequency @xmath4 ( unless stated otherwise , we always implicitly assume this confinement geometry ) , bagnato and kleppner have shown that @xmath5 @xcite , where @xmath6 ; shevchenko later extened this result to include more general power law potentials @xcite . in the thermodnyamic limit , viz .
, @xmath7 , @xmath8 , such that @xmath9 , bec is also known to theoretically occur with the critical temperature remaining unchanged .
note that this is not the usual thermodynamic limit , which in 2d would demand that @xmath10 , resulting in no bec ( see also ref .
@xcite for an alternative thermodynamic limit in the case of an interacting bose gas ) .
if repulsive interactions between bosons are included , ( we only consider repulsive interactions in this paper ) , then a definitive answer to the question of bec in the trapped 2d gas is not so clear .
in fact , there is no _ a priori _ reason for the existence of bec in a confined two or three - dimensional system bec is a purely kinematical phenomenon in the sense that even the ideal bose gas can undergo the phase transition .
in contrast , a transition to the superfluid state is wholey dynamical and _ can not _
occur without interactions .
therefore , one could sensibly assume that interactions prevent the spatial redistribution of atoms required to achieve bose gas degeneracy , and therefore destroy the bec phase transition altogether .
it is only recently that a rigorous proof has been given to show that there is no finite temperature bec in the interacting trapped 2d bose gas in the thermodynamic limit @xcite .
of course , in actual experiments , the theormodyamic limit is never fully realized , and it becomes necessary to consider systems consisting of a _ finite _ number of atoms confined in a trap . in this
regard , lieb and seiringer @xcite have proved that the finite , interacting trapped bose gas does have 100% bec at @xmath11 .
to date however , no irrefutable case has been made ( experimentally or theoretically ) in support of finite temperature bec in an interacting finite 2d system . in a recent paper , petrov _
et al . _
@xcite have suggested that that there are in fact two bec regimes for finite , trapped , ( quasi)-2d systems .
the general argument supporting their claim hinges on an approximate analytical calculation of the one - particle density martix from which information about the phase correlations of the condensate can be obtained . for large particle number and sufficiently low temperatures , petrov _ et al .
_ deduce that the phase fluctuations are governed by @xmath12 @xcite .
thus , at temperatures well below @xmath13 , fluctuations in the phase are supressed and one has a `` true condensate '' whereas for @xmath14 , the phase fluctuations are enhanced and one has a `` quasi - condensate '' .
similar results have recently been obtained by bogliubov _
et al . , _ in strictly two - dimenions @xcite
. however , bhaduri _ et al . _
@xcite have suggested that there is no bec phase transition in a finite , interacting 2d bose gas ( see also refs .
@xcite for similar conclusions ) . in their investigation ,
a semiclassical approximation to the hartree - fock - bogliubov ( hfb ) mean - field theory was used to investigate the thermodynamics of the trapped 2d bose gas .
although the semiclassical hfb approach could not shed any light on the question of phase fluctuations , it was shown that the hfb equations could be solved self - consistently all the way down to @xmath11 provided one _ does not _ invoke the presence of a condensate .
this finding seems to indicate that that if no _ a priori _ assumption of a condensate is made ( as it should be ) , the system remains in the same _ uncondensed phase _ at all temperatures .
( note that applying the same hfb approach in 3d requires a condensate in order to obtain self - consistent solutions below @xmath0 . ) in spite of the absence of a condensate order - parameter however , the density distribution for the uncondensed phase was found to clearly exhibit a large spatial accumulation of atoms near the center of the trap for @xmath15 , similar to what is found in systems with a condensate .
this suggests that there may be some sort of `` revival '' of odlro in the system , even though it does not lead to the formation of a condensate .
since the off - diagonal one - particle density matrix can provide information about phase correlations and odlro in the system , an investigation of the off - diagonal density martix within the hfb approximation needs to be performed .
this is indeed the central motivation for the present work .
the rest of our paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ noninteracting ] we investigte the noninteracting 2d gas in a harmonic trap where an exact expression for the finite temperature correlation function can be obtained . in sec .
[ interacting ] , we calculate the correlation function for the interacting system within the semiclassical hfb approximation and investigate its temperature dependence both above and below @xmath0 . finally , in sec .
[ conclusions ] , we present our concluding remarks .
in this section , we wish to pay special attention to the off - diagonal , one - particle density matrix @xmath16 of the noninteracting , confined 2d bose gas .
our motivation lies in the fact that odlro in the one - particle density matrix and bec are interrelated @xcite ( see below for details ) . for the isotropic ho ,
@xmath16 can be calculated analytically , and we have an exact result from which we can quantitatively test the validity of the semiclassical approximation .
we will be particularly interested how well the seimclassical approximation describes the phase correlations of the gas below the bec critical temperature @xmath17 .
to the best of our knowledge , this is the first such study in two - dimensions . by definition , the off - diagonal one - particle density matrix is given by @xcite ^(0)(,*r* ; ) =
_ j ^(0)_j ( ) ^(0)_j()^ n^(0)_j , [ green ] where @xmath18 are exact eigenfunctions of the @xmath19-dimensional harmonic oscillator ( ho ) and @xmath20 is the bose distribution function .
it is most convenient to evaluate ( [ green ] ) for the 1d case , and then use the separability of the ho potential to obtain the general result .
explicitly , we have ^(0)(x , x ; ) = _ n=0^e^- ( x^2 + x^2 ) , [ green2 ] where @xmath21 are the energy levels of the ho , @xmath22 is the chemical potential , and we have scaled all energies and lengths by @xmath23 and @xmath24 , respectively .
we now set the zero of energy to correspond to the lowest trap level , viz . , @xmath25 , and obtain from ( [ green2 ] ) ^(0)(x , x ; ) = _ j=1^e^j _ n=0^e^- ( x^2 + x^2)e^-jn , where we have used @xcite _
j=1^e^je^-jn = .
the summation over trap levels can be perfomed exactly @xcite , and we finally obtain in any dimension ^(0)(, ; ) = _
j=1^ e^-1/4[|+|^2(j/2)+|-|^2(j/2 ) ] . putting @xmath26 in the above equation
reproduces the result obtained by barnett _
et al_. , @xcite .
the chemical potential is obtained by enforcing that the total particle number @xmath27 , remain fixed , viz .
, n = _ j=1^ .
the diagonal part of the one - particle density matrix yields the exact quantum - mechanical finite temperature density , @xmath28 , of the trapped gas .
the densities for various temperatures are shown in fig . 1 for @xmath29 and @xmath30 atoms .
figure 1 illustrates that even though we are not in the thermodynamic limit , the single - particle density distribution exhibits an enormous accumulation of atoms near the center of the trap for @xmath31 .
this type of behaviour is consistent with the confined gas having undergone a phase transition to the bec state .
the usual approach for confirming that this phase transition is indeed bec is to examine the temperature dependence of the fractional occupancy of the lowest oscillator level , @xmath32 .
the inset to fig .
1 shows that below @xmath33 , the ground state of the system becomes macroscopically occupied , with already @xmath34 of the atoms in the lowest level at @xmath35 .
remarkably , even at @xmath30 atoms , the fractional occupancy closely follows the quadratic temperature dependence obtained strictly in the thermodynamic limit ( dashed line in figure inset ) , viz .
, = 1 - ( ) ^2 .
although @xmath32 gives us a strong indication that the finite system has a bec transition at @xmath33 , it does not provide us with a definitive test for the presence of odlro in the system .
it is well known since the early work of penrose and onsager @xcite that for a _ homogeneous _ system , the phenomenon of bec is intimately related to the presence of odlro in the off - diagonal one - particle density matrix , namely , _
|-|^(0)(, ; ) 0 .
in fact , the low temperature behaviour of @xmath36 is directly related to the phase fluctuations of the condensate @xcite and the non - zero limiting value of eq .
( 8) yields the value of the order parameter ( i.e. , condensate fraction ) in the system . for finite inhomogeneous systems however , the above criterion has to be modified to account for the fact that odlro can not extend beyond the physical size of the system .
this is accomplished by defining a normalized correlation function ( sometimes called the first - order coherence function ) by g^(0)(, ; ) = , such that _ |-|g^(0)(,;)0 .
the above correlation function describes a local measure of coherence in the system .
for example , the ability of two bec s , intially separated by @xmath37 , to form an interference pattern is quantified by @xmath38 @xcite . in this sense , the correlation function also characterizes local fluctuations of the phase of the condensate order - parameter .
the quantity @xmath39 is the large - distance length - scale over which the odlro of the finite system is manifested . at zero temperature , @xmath40 , whereas for @xmath41 , @xmath39 is taken to be the spatial extent of the single - particle density @xmath28 . to simplify our calculations , we fix one of the coordinate , @xmath42 to be at the center of the trap .
note that in eq .
( 9 ) , dividing the off - diagonal density matrix by the square root of the single - particle densities removes any effects of the local - density of particles on the correlation function , and gives @xmath43 in the case of perfect coherence . the solid curves in fig .
2 depict the correlation function @xmath44 for @xmath29 and @xmath30 at various temperatures . from left to right , we have @xmath45 . above the critical temperature ,
the atoms remain in the uncondensed phase and the system shows no odlro .
however , as the gas is cooled below the transition temperature , we see an abrupt jump in the large - distance decay of the spatial correlations . a direct application of eq . ( 10 ) yields condensate fractions of @xmath46 , for temperatures @xmath47 , respectively .
thus , below @xmath17 , the finite noninteracting 2d bose gas contains a non - zero order - parameter ( i.e. , a bec ) .
it also proves very useful to compare the spatial extent of the single - particle density , @xmath28 , to the spatial decay of the correlation function @xmath44 .
this information is also presented in fig . 2 where the exact quantum mechanical densities are represented by dashed lines .
these densities have been scaled by their value at @xmath48 to allow for a comparison of the length scales between @xmath28 and @xmath44 . from right to left , the dashed lines correspond to densities at @xmath49 .
densities at lower temperatures are almost indistinguishable on the scale of the figure .
we note that at low temperatures , the correlation function is practically a constant @xmath50 over the entire region for which the density ( i.e. , physical size of the system ) of the gas is nonzero .
this means that phase fluctuations are very small , and the density distribution corresponds to that of a `` true condensate '' . at higher temperatures
( i.e. , @xmath51 ) the single - paricle density can become comparable to that of @xmath44 , and the gas can be said to be a `` quasi - condensate '' in the sense that the phase correlations do not extend to all of the atoms in the trap . for @xmath52 , the spatial extent of the single - particle density greatly exceeds
characteristic length of the correlations , and system is in the normal state . having obtained the exact expression for @xmath53 , we now wish to examine its semiclassical approximation , namely , its behaviour when @xmath54 .
it is easy to show that eq ( 5 ) reduces to @xmath55/2\right]^j\exp\left[-|\bfr-\bfr'|^2)/2\beta\right]^{1/j}\\ & = & \frac{1}{(2\pi\beta)^{d/2}}g_{d/2}(\exp\left [ \beta(\mu- [ v(\bfr)+v(\bfr')]/2)\right],\exp\left[-|\bfr-\bfr'|^2)/2\beta\right])~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath56 , and as in ref .
@xcite we have introduced the generalized bose function g_(x , y ) = _
j=1^ . for @xmath57 and @xmath29 , eq .
( 12 ) becomes ^(0 ) ( ) = , with the normalization condition n = ^(0 ) ( ) d^2 .
if one attempts to solve eqs .
( 14,15 ) for all @xmath58 , it is readily shown that there exists a temperature @xmath59 below which the equations can no longer be satisfied @xcite .
in fact , the temperature @xmath59 is identical to the the critical temperature @xmath3 obtained by bagnato and kleppner @xcite .
thus , in order to obtain solutions below @xmath3 , a condensate order parameter is required .
we introduce the macroscopic occupation of the ground state in the one - particle density matrix according to the _ ansatz _ ^(0)(, ) = n_0 ^(0)_0 ( ) ^(0)_0( ) + g_d/2 ( , ) , where @xmath60 is the zero temperature ground - state eigenfunction of the ho and n_0 = .
the 2d density is then given by eq .
( 16 ) with @xmath57 , ^(0 ) ( ) = n_0|^(0)_0()|^2 + .
the semiclassical densities obtained from eq . ( 18 ) are indistinguishable from the exact densities obtained from eq .
the semiclassical correlation function , eq .
( 16 ) , at various temperatures is represented in fig . 2 as filled circles .
the superb agreement between the exact ( solid curves ) and semiclassical results shows that the semiclassical approximation is valid well below the critical temperature provided one takes into account the macroscopic occupation of the ground state separately . if the atoms had remained in the uncondensed phase , eqs .
( 14,15 ) would have been sufficient to describe the gas for all @xmath61 .
the thermodynamic properties of the interacting bose gas are most commonly described by the self - consistent mean - field hfb equations . in most calculations ( see ref .
@xcite and references therein for details ) , the semiclassical approximation is applied to the discrete set of coupled bogliubov equations , leading to the considerably simplified semiclassical hfb theory .
the semiclassical hfb approximation is well - known to be an excellent tool for describing the interacting 3d bose gas @xcite .
the 2d version of the semiclassical hfb theory is formally identical to the 3d version and has already been examined by mullin @xcite .
we present only the essentials of the model here for completeness . in the semiclassical hfb approach ,
the condensed and uncondensed atoms are described by a set of coupled , self - consistent equations .
the macroscopic condensate wavefunction , @xmath62 , is characterized by the finite - temperature gross - pitaevskii equation which is given by _ 0 ( ) = 0 , where @xmath63 is the coupling constant associated with the assumed repulsive zero - range two - body pseudo - potential .
the total density , @xmath64 , is made up of a condensate @xmath65 , and a noncondensate density , _ t ( ) = \ { f ( , ) + v^2 ( , ) } d^2 , where f ( , ) = , u^2 ( , ) = , v^2 ( , ) = , = + r^2 - + 2 ( ) , and ( , ) = .
the total number of particles satisfies n = [ _ 0 ( ) + _ t ( ) ] d^2 . in the absence of a condensate ,
it is easy to show that the above set of hfb equations reduce to _ t ( ) = , with n = _ t ( ) d^2 . equations ( 27,28 ) are equivalent to the so - called self - consistent thomas - fermi approximation used in refs . @xcite .
putting @xmath66 in eq .
( 27 ) yields an expression that is identical to the semiclassical approximation of the exact diagonal density matrix , viz . , eq .
( 14 ) , found in the previous section ; recall from sec .
[ noninteracting ] that below @xmath17 , eqs .
( 27,29 ) can not be solved self - consistently . however , if one puts any finite @xmath67 in eq .
( 27 ) , self - consistent solutions to the hfb equations can be obtained all the way down to @xmath68 @xcite . to illustrate this , we show in fig .
3 the density and chemical potential ( figure inset ) of the gas for @xmath69 ( long - dash - short - dashed line ) , @xmath70 ( solid line ) , and @xmath71 ( dashed line ) .
in contrast to the noninteracting 2d gas ( where a condensate order - parameter has to be introduced below @xmath17 ) , the interacting system remains in the uncondensed phase for all @xmath61 .
although no condensation occurs , it is interesting to compare the densities of the noninteracting ( fig . 1 ) and interacting gases ( fig .
3 ) just above and below @xmath17 . the essential point to be made from this comparison is that in both cases , there is an increase in the density of atoms near the center of the trap for @xmath72 .
while the noninteracting density shows a much larger enhancement at @xmath48 , the interacting gas also displays a similar ( albeit diminished ) behaviour . since an increase in the density of atoms near the center of the trap
is associated with odlro in the noninteracting gas , it is worthwhile investigating the off - diagonal density matrix for the interacting 2d gas within the semiclassical hfb approximation .
the 2d semiclassical hfb off - diagonal density matrix can be obtained from the leading order term in the wigner - kirkwood semiclassical expansion of the quantum mechanical off - diagnonal density matrix @xcite .
the noncondensed particles are treated as bosons in an effective potential , and we obtain ( , ; ) = g_1 ( , ) , where v_eff ( ) = r^2 + 2 ( ) . since there is no condensate for @xmath73 , we _ have not _ included the first term in eq .
of course , for @xmath74 , eq . ( 29 ) reduces to eq .
( 27 ) . as in sec .
[ noninteracting ] , the normalized correlation function for the finite sized system is given by g(,0 ; ) = , where again , we have fixed @xmath75 .
the temperature dependence of @xmath76 is shown in figs . 4 , 5 for coupling strengths @xmath77 , respectivley . above @xmath17 , the interacting and noninteracting ( see fig .
2 ) systems have similar correlations .
however , as we cool the gas to temperatures just below @xmath17 , there is an drastic change in the behaviour of the interacting off - diagonal density matrix , which to the best of our knowledge , has never been noticed before . in particluar
, we observe that the decay of the correlations in the interacting system are qualitatively different from the noninteracting gas .
for the interacting gas , values of @xmath78 lead to the tail of the correlation function decreasing slowler than the noninteracting case .
in contrast , for @xmath79 , the interacting correlation function has a much faster spatial decay than the noninteracting system .
we have already discussed the fact that the near constancy of the noninteracting correlation function , @xmath38 , over the size of the sample ( @xmath80 ) is indicative of negligible phase fluctuations in the condensate @xcite .
thus , the re - appearance of odlro in @xmath81 below @xmath17 suggests that there may be larger fluctuations in the phase as compared to the noninteracting gas .
if we apply eq .
( 10 ) to @xmath81 ( with @xmath70 ) , we obtain @xmath82 at @xmath83 respectively , for the asymptotic behaviour of the correlation fucntion . even though we may not be able to interpret these numbers as condensate fractions , it is tempting to conjecture that they represent a nonzero value of an order - parameter in the system
. we can be more quantitative about the nature of the correlations displayed by @xmath81 below @xmath17 as follows . in the interacting _ homogeneous _
2d bose gas , popov @xcite has already calculated the low temperature correlation function : g(, ; ) r^- , where r , = , and @xmath84 is the so - called superfluid density .
algebraic _ odlro exhibited by @xmath81 implies that at low temperature , correlations can extend over macroscopic ( i.e. , size of the system ) distances , although phase fluctutations will be nonzero .
this is reminiscent of the quasi - condensate described in ref .
@xcite , and it is only identically at @xmath11 that the system will attain a `` true condensate '' . if the system is finite ( i.e. , in a 2dho potential ) , then bogliubov _ et al . _
@xcite , have shown that r , = , where @xmath85 .
( 34 ) is formally identical to ( 33 ) except for the slowly varying factor @xmath86 which is the inhomogeneous boson density .
this additional spatial dependence results in a deviation from the strict power law dependence of the uniform gas . we have found that at low temperatures , the power law dependence in eq . (
34 ) agrees well with the observed numerical behaviour of @xmath87 .
this suggests that at low temperatures , the interacting system exhibits algebraic odlro similar to that of the superfluid state in the uniform bose gas . at exactly @xmath11
, the gas will have a true condensate .
we have investigated the finite - temperature correlations in both the ideal and interacting trapped , 2d bose gas .
our study of the noninteracting gas provided an exact framework from which we could compare the validity of the semiclassical approximation over a wide temperature range .
our results indicate that the semiclassical approach works extremetly well , even below the critical temperature , provided the macroscopic occupations of the ground state is treated separately .
a careful examination of the correlation function reveals that , as in ref .
@xcite , there are two bec regimes for the noninteracting gas .
namely , for temperatures @xmath51 , the system is a quasi - condensate in the sense that the phase correlations are comparable to the spatial extent of the single - particle density . on the other hand , when the temperature is lowered to @xmath88 ,
phase fluctuations become negligible , and the gas is a true condensate .
it is straightforward to apply our results to study the finite @xmath27 dependence on the coherence properties of trapped gases in dimensions @xmath89 .
( see e.g. , ref .
@xcite for work relating to 3d ) . in the interacting gas
, we found that even though the system does not contain a condensate , there is a revival of odlro for @xmath90 .
the low temperature behaviour of the interacting correlation function was found to be consistent with an algebraic ( i.e. , power law ) decay in the phase correlations , similar to what is found in the uniform 2d superfluid bose gas .
whether or not this re - entrant odlro is to the superfluid state is presently being investigated . finally , it is interesting to note that margo and ceperely @xcite have found conclusions analgous to ours for the uniform 2d charged bose fluid ( cbf ) with @xmath91 interactions .
specifically , they found that even though the 2d cbf _ does not _
undergo a condensation , the noncondensed fluid exhibits a power - law decay of the one - particle density matrix similar to what is found in the present work .
it is not immediately clear what relevance their findings may have on our results for the interacting , inhomogeneous 2d bose gas .
it is a pleasure to thank drs .
wonkee kim , rajat bhaduri and j. p. carbotte for illuminating discussions .
this work was supported in part by the national sciences and the engineering research council of canada ( nserc ) and by the canadian institute for advanced research ( ciar ) . | we investigate the presence of off - diagonal long - range order in a harmonically confined two - dimensional bose gas . in the noninteracting case , an analytical calculation of the the finite - temperature one - particle density martix
provides an exact description of the spatial correlations known to be associated with the existence of a bose - einstein condensate below the transition temperature @xmath0 .
we treat the effects of repulsive interactions within the semiclassical hartree - fock - bogliubov approximation and find that even though the system remains in the same _ uncondensed phase _ for all @xmath1 , there appears to be a revival of off - diagonal long - range order for temperatures @xmath2 .
we suggest that this reentrant order is related to a phase transition in the system which _ is not _ the bec state . |
according to the braneworld hypothesis , our observable universe can be considered as a three - dimensional space sheet ( a @xmath2-brane ) embedded in a larger spacetime with @xmath3 dimensions ( the bulk ) @xcite .
brane is a concept inherited from high energy physics and unification models .
testing the existence of branes or extra dimensions is therefore becoming a fundamental challenge .
such evidences are expected to be obtained through high energy collisions @xcite , but it has been also demonstrated that some detectable effects could also be observed at low energy @xcite . this is the topic of the present paper . some authors have early underlined or suggested that the particles of the standard model could be able to escape out of our visible world @xcite .
many effects can be considered and have been explored until now along this line of thought .
for instance , in some approaches , particles are expected to leak into the bulk through a tunnel effect @xcite . other works also considered that fluctuations of our home - brane could yield small bubbles branes , which carry chargeless matter particles ( such as neutrons for instance ) into the bulk @xcite . in another context ,
other approaches consider some coupling between certain particles of the standard model and some hidden or dark sectors @xcite .
it is sometimes suspected that such hidden sectors could live in other branes .
it is the case with the photon - hidden photon kinetic mixing @xcite .
a @xmath4 field on a hidden brane can be coupled to the @xmath4 photon field of our brane through a one - loop process in a stringy context @xcite . in the mirror world
approaches , the matter - mirror matter mixing is also considered ( with neutron and mirror neutron @xcite for instance ) though , in the best of our knowledge , a full derivation through a brane formalism is still lacking . actually , ultracold neutron ( ucn ) experiments related to the neutron disappearance are then fundamental since they could allow to quantify or to distinguish among the different predicted phenomenologies @xcite . in previous works @xcite , two of the present authors ( sarrazin and petit ) have shown that for a bulk containing at least two parallel 3-branes hidden to each other , matter swapping between these two worlds should occur .
the particle must be massive , can be electrically charged or not , but must be endowed with a magnetic moment .
this swapping effect between two neighboring 3-branes is triggered by using suitable magnetic vector potentials .
more important , this new effect @xmath0 different from those previously described in literature @xmath0 could be detected and controlled with present day technology which opens the door to a possible experimental confirmation of the braneworld hypothesis . for charged particles , the swapping is possible though a few more difficult to achieve @xcite . as a consequence , for a sake of simplicity and in order to be able to distinguish the swapping effect with other kind of predicted phenomena , we suggested the use of neutron for a prospective experiment . in the present work we discuss the possibility that an astrophysical magnetic vector potential could lead to such a matter swapping .
the basic argument is that the astrophysical vector potentials are considerably larger than any other counterpart generated in a laboratory
. a possible consequence for free neutrons would be then high frequency and small amplitude oscillations of the matter swapping probability between the two branes .
ultracold neutrons stored in a vessel would therefore have a non - zero probability @xmath1 to escape from our brane toward the hidden brane at each wall collision .
such a process would be perceived as a neutron disappearance from the point of view of an observer located in our brane .
the purpose of this paper is to assess an upper limit on @xmath1 based on already published data in literature .
this upper limit is then used to constrain the parameters of the model .
on the basis of this assessment , more sensitive experiments are suggested and described . in section [ model ] , the model describing the low - energy dynamics of a neutron in a two - brane universe is recalled .
the conditions leading to matter swapping between branes are given .
we discuss the origin @xmath0 and the magnitude @xmath0 of the ambient magnetic vector potential , which is required to observe matter exchange between branes . the gravitational environment that can impede the swapping to occur ,
is also discussed . in section [ sec3 ] , available data from literature
are analyzed and used to constrain the parameters of the two - brane universe model .
finally , in section [ further ] improvements of the experimental setup are suggested .
a variable - collision - rate experiment is proposed .
a long timescale experiment as well as a laser - induced matter swapping experiment are also discussed .
in previous works @xcite , it was shown that in a universe containing two parallel braneworlds invisible to each other , the quantum dynamics of a spin@xmath5 fermion can be described by a two - brane pauli equation at low energies . for a neutron outside a nucleus , in electromagnetic and gravitational fields
, the relevant equations can be written as @xcite : @xmath6 where the indices @xmath7 are purely conventional and simply allow to discriminate the two branes . @xmath8 and @xmath9 are usual pauli spinors corresponding to the wave functions in the @xmath10 and @xmath11 branes respectively , and where @xmath12 and @xmath13 such that @xmath14 and @xmath15 correspond to the magnetic vector potentials in the branes @xmath10 and @xmath11 respectively .
the same convention is applied to the magnetic fields @xmath16 and to the gravitational potentials @xmath17 .
@xmath18 is the magnetic moment of the particle .
each diagonal term of @xmath19 is simply the usual pauli hamiltonian for each brane .
in addition to these usual terms , the two - brane hamiltonian comprises also a new term @xmath20 fully specific of a universe with two branes @xcite .
@xmath20 implies that matter exchange between branes depends on the magnetic moment and on the difference between the local ( i.e. on a brane ) values of the magnetic vector potentials .
@xmath20 leads to a phenomenology which shares some similarities with the mirror matter paradigm @xcite or other approaches involving some hidden or dark matter sectors @xcite .
nevertheless the present approach differs in several ways : * in the mirror ( or hidden ) matter formalism , it is often considered by implication that only one four - dimensional manifold exists and that particles split into two families : the standard and the mirror sectors . by contrast , in the present model , particles are restricted to those of the standard model but they have access to two distinct @xmath2-branes ( i.e. two distinct four - dimensional manifolds ) . as a consequence ,
in the mirror matter approach , matter and mirror matter particles undergo the same gravitational fields ( i.e. @xmath21 ) whereas in the present braneworld approach , matter is subjected to the gravitational fields of each brane ( i.e. @xmath22 ) that possess their own gravitational sources . *
the coupling between the particles of each brane occurs in a specific way without recourse of the coupling considered in the mirror matter concept .
the coupling term @xmath20 is specific to the braneworld approach @xcite .
since its value can be changed by modifying the local value of the magnetic vector potential , it can be consequently controlled by artificial means .
the effects related to @xmath20 @xcite can be then distinguished from those related to coupling from other models @xcite .
however , instead of considering artificial ( i.e. generated in a laboratory ) vector potentials we are now focusing on the case of an ambient magnetic potential with an astrophysical origin ( section [ magvect ] ) .
let @xmath23 be the difference of ambient magnetic potentials of each brane .
assuming that @xmath24 , i.e. one can neglect the magnetic fields in the branes ( especially one assumes that @xmath25 ) , then by solving the pauli equation , it can be shown that the probability for a neutron initially localized in our brane to be found in the other brane is : @xmath26 where @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
( [ rabi ] ) shows that the neutron in the potential @xmath29 undergoes rabi - like oscillations between the branes .
note that the probability does not depend on the neutron spin state by contrast with the magnetic vector potential direction in space . as detailed in previous papers @xcite , the environmental interactions ( related to @xmath17 ) are usually strong enough to almost suppress these oscillations .
this can be verified by considering eq .
( [ rabi ] ) showing that @xmath30 decreases as @xmath31 increases relatively to @xmath32 .
since no such oscillations have been observed so far , we can assume that the ratio @xmath33 is usually very small .
as a consequence , the oscillations present a weak amplitude and a high angular frequency of the order @xmath34 .
let us now consider a neutron gas in a vessel . in the general case ,
it is in a superposition of two states : neutron in our brane vs. neutron in the other brane .
a collision between the neutron and a wall of the vessel acts therefore as a measurement and the neutron collapses either in our brane with a probability @xmath35 or in the other invisible brane with a probability @xmath1 .
it is therefore natural to consider that the neutron swapping rate @xmath36 into the other brane is related to the collision rate @xmath37 between the neutron and the vessel walls , i.e. @xmath38 with @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the average flight time of neutrons between two collisions on vessel walls .
the probability @xmath1 is the average of @xmath30 according to the statistical distribution of the free flight times , i.e. @xmath41 equations ( [ 6 ] ) and ( [ proba ] ) are valid provided a large number of oscillations occur during a given time interval .
this must be verified for @xmath42 ( i.e. @xmath43 ) but also during the duration @xmath44 of a neutron collision on a wall ( i.e. @xmath45 ) .
can be estimated as the time needed for a neutron to make a round trip along the penetration depth @xmath46 of the wall ( typically @xmath47 nm @xcite ) . with @xmath48 ( where @xmath49 is the ucn velocity , here @xmath50 m@xmath51s@xmath52 ) , one gets @xmath53 ns . ] as shown hereafter , the lowest considered energies @xmath54 are about @xmath55 ev , i.e. @xmath56 hz , while @xmath57 hz and the greatest values of @xmath37 are about @xmath58 hz . as a consequence , the eqs .
( [ 6 ] ) and ( [ proba ] ) are legitimate in the present context .
let us now consider that a natural astrophysical magnetic vector potential @xmath59 may have on the neutron dynamics in the vessel .
the magnitude of such a potential was recently discussed in literature since it allows to constrain the photon mass @xcite .
of course , in the present work , we are not concerned by such exotic property of photon , which is assumed to be massless .
@xmath60 corresponds typically to a sum of individual contributions coming from astrophysical objects ( star , planet , galaxy , ... ) that surround us . indeed ,
each astrophysical object endowed with a magnetic moment @xmath61 induces a magnetic potential : @xmath62 from which the magnetic field @xmath63 produced by the object can be deduced .
we get @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the typical distance from the astrophysical source . in the vicinity of earth for instance , and at large distances from sources , we note that @xmath66 is then almost constant ( i.e. @xmath67 ) and can not be canceled with magnetic shields @xcite .
the magnitude of the main expected contributions to @xmath59 can be easily deduced .
for instance , the earth contribution to @xmath29 is about @xmath68 t@xmath51 m while it is only @xmath69 t@xmath70 m for the sun @xcite .
now , if we consider the galactic magnetic field * * ( * * about @xmath71 * * * * @xmath18 g @xcite * * ) * * relatively to the milky way core * * ( * * at * * * * about @xmath72 * * * * m * * ) * * one gets @xmath73 t@xmath51 m @xcite . note that in refs .
@xcite a value of @xmath74 t@xmath51 m was derived for the coma galactic cluster .
unfortunately , other authors ( see goldhaber and nieto in ref .
@xcite for instance ) , underlined that substantial inhomogeneities can exist in the field distributions such that @xmath29 may strongly vary in different regions .
as a consequence , there is a lack of knowledge concerning the magnitude of contributions from extragalactic scales @xcite .
therefore the value given in @xcite can not be presently considered as reliable enough to be used here .
in addition , eq .
( [ coupling ] ) shows that it is the difference @xmath75 between the vector potentials of the two braneworlds that is relevant .
since @xmath76 depends on unknown sources in the other brane , we can not assess its value .
for all these reasons , we should consider @xmath77 as an unknown parameter of the model .
nevertheless , we will admit that a value of @xmath78 t@xmath51 m is probably of the right order of magnitude @xcite . in the present context , @xmath80 and
only gravitational interactions are relevant .
it is difficult to specify the value of @xmath81 . indeed , since the gravitational contribution of the hidden world ( @xmath82 ) is unknown , @xmath79 must be therefore an unknown parameter of the model .
however , according to the estimations given in previous works @xcite , @xmath83 could be of the order of @xmath84 ev due to the milky way core gravitational potential acting on neutron .
by contrast , the sun , the earth and the moon contribute for about @xmath85 ev , @xmath86 ev and @xmath87 mev . as a consequence
, one can fairly suppose that the value of @xmath79 is included in a range from few mev up to few kev .
at last , one notes that @xmath79 must be also time - dependent .
let us consider the significant motion of earth around the sun .
owing to the sun gravitational potential only , the energy of a neutron varies from @xmath88 ev to @xmath89 ev between the aphelion and the perihelion .
this corresponds to an absolute shift of @xmath90 of about @xmath91 mev per day .
of course , the full time - dependence of @xmath79 could also have other origins .
for instance , the relative neutron motion with respect to the unknown matter distribution in the hidden brane . nevertheless , it seems unlikely that our own solar system is close enough to a similar mass distribution ( in the other brane ) to induce a time - dependence on a timescale of the order of one day or one year . in this context
, the most likely time - dependence will be induced by the earth motion around the sun , such that @xmath92 ev on one year . from eq .
( [ proba ] ) , one can then expect a relative variation of the measured probability @xmath1 about @xmath93 .
if the neutron oscillation between branes is detected and presents an annual dependence through @xmath94 , since we can estimate @xmath95 we can therefore expect specifying the value of @xmath79 .
.summary of ucn storage experiments , with measured ucn storage time and wall collision rate taken from the original literature .
the maximum loss probability at wall collision is derived for each experiment . [ cols="<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] in a typical experiment , ultracold neutrons are stored in a bottle , with a mean wall collision rate @xmath37 which is typically in the range from 1 hz to 100 hz .
the number of stored neutrons decays by following a nearly exponential law with a decay time @xmath96 .
this storage time @xmath97 is measured by counting the remaining neutrons after a storage period of variable duration .
the inverse of the storage time is the sum of the neutron beta decay rate and the loss rate due to wall collisions : @xmath98 here we have separated the contribution from the normal loss rate @xmath99 ( due to inelastic scattering of neutrons at the surface for example ) and that corresponding to a disappearance in the other brane @xmath100 .
the purpose of trap experiments is to measure the beta decay lifetime of the neutron @xmath101 , by extrapolating the storage time to the ideal case where there is no extra losses .
the extrapolation procedure is far from trivial and , as stated in the particle data group compilation @xcite , the different experimental results are contradictory . here
we reinterpret some of the performed experiments to provide an upper limit on the exotic disappearance probability @xmath1 .
since the extrapolation procedure is in question , we will not try to account for the normal losses .
instead we shall attribute all the losses to the exotic phenomenon , and treat the obtained value for the loss as an upper limit on @xmath1 : @xmath102 . this way the presented analysis
is not concerned by the present dispute about the neutron decay lifetime ( the normal losses certainly satisfy @xmath103 ! ) .
the idea of the analysis is to compare the neutron decay rate measured in the absence of brane swapping and the storage time of stored ultracold neutrons where swapping occur at a rate @xmath104 .
when measuring @xmath105 with the beam method , one really measures the beta decay channel : one measures the absolute proton activity of a cold neutron beamline .
et al _ @xcite measured the rate of proton production of a well - defined section of a cold neutron beam at the ill and have reported a neutron lifetime of @xmath106 . using the same improved technique , nico _
et al _ @xcite measured @xmath107 .
the two independent results can be combined : @xmath108 of @xmath109 ( a ) and @xmath110 ( b ) for @xmath111 t@xmath51 m .
grey domains are excluded.,title="fig:",height=396 ] next we consider the ucn trap experiments @xcite performed at the ultracold neutron beamline pf2 at the institut laue langevin , using ucn traps coated with fluorinated polyether oil ( fomblin ) .
we also consider the experiment @xcite performed at the saint petersburg institute of nuclear physics using a trap coated with solid oxygen . in these experiments , the geometry of the ucn trap
could be changed ( thus changing @xmath112 ) and several measurements of @xmath113 are done corresponding to different @xmath112 values .
table [ storageexp ] shows the results extracted from the publications using only the data with the best storage time . in the last column ,
the maximal allowed probability for a neutron to escape in the other brane @xmath114 is extracted for each storage experiment using ( [ taust ] ) and the pure beta decay lifetime value ( [ taun ] ) .
this analysis allows us finally to conclude @xmath115 this conservative bound could be made even more robust by considering also @xmath116 value extracted from magnetic trapping of ucns when available . indeed ,
when neutrons are magnetically trapped they can not swap to the other brane , thus the lifetime value measured with magnetic traps could eventually be combined with the beam average ( [ taun ] ) . as a consequence of eqs .
( [ proba ] ) and ( [ result ] ) , it becomes possible to constrain the values of the coupling constant @xmath110 between the two braneworlds , and also the environmental potential @xmath90 .
1a shows @xmath109 limits as a function of the confining energy @xmath90 .
similarly , fig .
1b shows the limit for @xmath110 and varying @xmath90 ( assuming @xmath117 t@xmath51 m ) .
the resulting constraint is much better than our previous assessment in earlier works where the upper limit of @xmath110 was obtained from considerations about millicharged particles @xcite . in this case
, it was shown that the upper constraint on millicharge @xmath118 is given by @xmath119 @xmath120 ( @xmath121 is the absolute value of the electron charge and @xmath122 the electron mass ) . from ref .
@xcite , we get @xmath123 m@xmath52 from the millicharge constraint @xmath124 @xcite .
even with more recent and stringent constraints @xcite , we get @xmath125 m@xmath52 from @xmath126 ( see berezhiani and lepidi in ref .
@xcite ) . as a result
, ultracold neutron experiments appear as a relevant approach to constrain @xmath110 ( some other possibilities are not considered for obvious reasons but are not relevant for now .
constraint from the primordial nucleosynthesis @xcite can not be obtained since the value of a primordial cosmological magnetic vector potential can not be assessed at present . in addition ,
constraint from disappearance of bound neutrons in nuclei @xcite would need for a rigorous expression of the swapping probability in this case .
there is no simple relation between the disappearance probabilities of free neutron and neutron in nuclei and this complex topic is far beyond the scope of the present paper @xcite . ]
against the confinement energy @xmath127 .
dashed - doted line : expected limits for a yearly experiment . dashed line : expected limits for a resonant experiment ( laser - induced ) .
grey domain is excluded.,title="fig:",height=226 ] the most simple further experiment relies on a device with variable geometry , such that the ratio _
volume / surface _ of the vessel can be controlled .
the collision rate @xmath37 then varies as the geometrical ratio .
obviously , the broader the sampling of @xmath37 is , the more accurate the knowledge of @xmath1 .
moreover , for a given collision rate , the statistical sensitivity on the loss probability is @xmath128 it is then relevant to increase the value of @xmath37 to decrease @xmath94 .
for instance , the statistical sensitivity of present ucn storage experiments is about @xmath129 s when measuring the neutron lifetime @xmath130
s. with a current wall collision rate of @xmath131 hz , this translates into @xmath132 .
by contrast , with @xmath133 hz , @xmath134 is a fair reachable sensitivity .
such an experimental approach can be accepted with confidence .
indeed , the lowest considered frequencies of the swapping probability are about @xmath135 hz in relation to @xmath90 ( see section [ model ] ) .
this is far to the highest expected collision rates , and then eqs .
( [ 6 ] ) and ( [ proba ] ) are still valid .
as suggested in section [ envpot ] , it would be highly beneficial to perform the experiment on a long timescale ( typically one year ) to take into account the motion of earth around the sun and the related time - dependence of @xmath79 .
such a motion should lead to a time - modulation of the swapping probability @xmath1 .
if one can detect such a modulation it would be a strong indication that matter swapping really occurs . indeed , with such an experiment it could be possible to discriminate the exotic losses due to matter swapping from normal losses , which are not time - dependent , in the neutron trap .
in addition , if the neutron swapping between braneworlds is detected and presents an annual dependence through @xmath94 , since one can estimate @xmath136 one could then assess the value of @xmath79 .
moreover , a clear benefit of any long time experiment would be to constrain the unknown value of @xmath94 against time .
this allows to improve the constraints on @xmath137 ( or @xmath110 ) against @xmath90 by contrast with experiments related to the upper limit of @xmath1 only . in the present paper , in order to underline the relevance of the yearly experiment , we can just suggest a test value for the limit of @xmath94 .
as shown from ( [ sensi ] ) , @xmath132 when @xmath138 hz .
since the uncertainty varies as @xmath139 , @xmath134 is a fair reachable upper experimental limit neutrons per @xmath140 are reachable .
@xmath84 neutrons per @xmath140 are expected soon .
in addition , a one year experiment would allow to obtain at least ten times more of measurements . as a consequence , the number of events @xmath141 would be hundred times greater than now . ] for a one year experiment . if we assume that @xmath92 ev on one year ( see section [ envpot ] ) from the above values and since @xmath142 , we can then further improve the constraint on @xmath137 ( or @xmath110 ) against @xmath143 .
2 shows the expected limits for the coupling constant @xmath144 against @xmath79 for a yearly experiment ( dashed - doted line ) .
the result is compared with that found previously in section [ analysis ] .
it becomes obvious that a yearly experiment allows getting a much better assessment of @xmath145 when @xmath146 .
the rule is clearly that the weaker the relative uncertainty of @xmath1 is , the better the constraint is . from the above benchmark values
, one deduces that the yearly experiment could offer a better estimation when @xmath147 ev by contrast with the present experimental constraints ( solid line ) . for the lower values of @xmath79 considered here ,
the gain could reach two orders of magnitude .
in previous works @xcite , it has been suggested that a rotative magnetic vector potential could be considered instead of a static one . in that case a resonant swapping occurs with rabi oscillations given by : @xmath148 where @xmath149 is the angular frequency of the magnetic potential .
equation ( [ rabir ] ) shows that a resonant matter exchange between branes occurs whenever the magnetic vector potential rotates with an angular frequency @xmath150 . of course ,
in this case , we do not consider an astrophysical field , and the rotative magnetic potential is supplied by an electromagnetic wave .
in a recent paper @xcite , it has been suggested that a set of coherent electromagnetic pulses ( a frequency comb ) could artificially induce the swapping of a neutron into a hidden braneworld .
the neutron swapping rate @xmath151 is then given by @xcite : @xmath152 where @xmath153 is the frequency of repetition of the pulses , @xmath154 is the pulse duration , @xmath141 is the number of pulses felt by neutrons , @xmath155 is the intensity of the pulse . in the above expression , @xmath90 is given in ev , @xmath156 in ghz , @xmath155 in pw@xmath157@xmath158 , @xmath154 in fs , and @xmath159 ( in the relevant units ) . from the uncertainty on ( [ taun ] ) , a relevant criterion to confirm the reality of this effect is to achieve @xmath160 . in fig .
2 , one shows the expected limits for such a resonant experiment assuming that the laser frequency can be continuously tuned ( dashed line ) .
this figure was derived assuming the following values for the frequency comb source : @xmath161 ps , @xmath162 ghz , @xmath163 , @xmath164 pw@xmath157@xmath158 .
these values are quite usual for some frequency comb sources ( see references in @xcite ) . though the intensity is more specific to certain pulsed sources ( see discussions in refs .
@xcite ) , such a value could be achieved for a frequency comb as well .
it is striking that the theoretical limit ( dashed line ) is very close to the present experimental limit ( solid line ) . due to the regular improvement of laser sources
, we expect that such a resonant experiment will become relevant in the next decades by contrast to passive experiments to explore the space of parameters @xmath165 .
using results from performed experiments , we have assessed an upper limit on the probability for a stored ultracold neutron to disappear into another braneworld .
this limit has been used to constrain the parameters of the brane model introduced in recent theoretical works @xcite , which had shown the possibility of matter exchange between two braneworlds invisible to each other .
we have discussed the sensibility of further experiments to probe the existence of a neighboring brane through an annual study .
it is also suggested that a laser - induced matter swapping towards a hidden braneworld could be tested in the next decades .
during the process of publication of this paper , we learned about the work of berezhiani and nesti @xcite whose results could be reminiscent of ours . nevertheless , the results of ref .
@xcite are independent of ours .
indeed , our present work rests on a different physical approach , which is fully specific to the braneworld concept @xcite .
in addition , our present model allows for enhanced induced matter exchange between parallel braneworlds by artificial means @xcite . in this case , the efficiency of the matter swapping rate is not limited and is proportional to the intensity of the available laser sources ( see eq .
( [ 18 ] ) ) @xcite .
the authors are grateful to gia dvali and vladimir tretyak for their useful advices and comments .
99 k. akama , lect .
notes phys . 176 ( 1983 )
267 , arxiv : hep - th/0001113 ; + v.a .
rubakov , m.e .
shaposhnikov , phys .
lett . 125b
( 1983 ) 136 ; + m. pavsic , phys . lett . 116a ( 1986 ) 1 , arxiv : gr - qc/0101075 ; + p. horava , e. witten , nucl .
b460 ( 1996 ) 506 , arxiv : hep - th/9510209 ; + a. lukas , b.a .
ovrut , k.s .
stelle , d. waldram , phys .
d 59 ( 1999 ) 086001 , arxiv : hep - th/9803235 ; + l. randall , r. sundrum , phys . rev
83 ( 1999 ) 3370 , arxiv : hep - ph/9905221 ; + r. davies , d.p .
george , r.r .
volkas , phys .
d 77 ( 2008 ) 124038 , arxiv:0705.1584 [ hep - ph ] ; + y .- x .
liu , l .- d .
zhang , l .- j .
zhang , y .- s .
duan , phys .
d 78 ( 2008 ) 065025 , arxiv:0804.4553 [ hep - th ] . n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , g. dvali , phys . lett .
b 429 ( 1998 ) 263 , arxiv : hep - ph/9803315 ; + i. antoniadis , n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , g. dvali , phys . lett .
b 436 ( 1998 ) 257 , arxiv : hep - ph/9804398 ; + n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , g. dvali , phys
d 59 ( 1999 ) 086004 , arxiv : hep - ph/9807344 .
j. chiaverini , s.j .
smullin , a.a .
geraci , d.m .
weld , a. kapitulnik , phys .
( 2003 ) 151101 , arxiv : hep - ph/0209325 ; + y. shtanov , a. viznyuk , class .
( 2005 ) 987 , arxiv : hep - th/0312261 .
dubovsky , v.a .
rubakov , p.g .
tinyakov , phys .
d 62 ( 2000 ) 105011 , arxiv : hep - th/0006046 ; + s.l .
dubovsky , jhep 0201 ( 2002 ) 012 , arxiv : hep - th/0103205 ; + c. ringeval , p. peter , j .-
uzan , phys .
d 65 ( 2002 ) 044016 , arxiv : hep - th/0109194 .
p. crivelli , a. belov , u. gendotti , s. gninenko , a. rubbia , jinst 5 ( 2010 ) p08001 , arxiv:1005.4802 [ hep - ex ] ; + r. foot , s.n .
gninenko , phys .
b 480 ( 2000 ) 171 , arxiv : hep - ph/0003278 ; + s.n .
gninenko , n.v .
krasnikov , a. rubbia , phys .
d 67 ( 2003 ) 075012 , arxiv : hep - ph/0302205 .
i. altarev , et al .
d 80 ( 2009 ) 032003 , arxiv:0905.4208 [ nucl - ex ] ; + a.p .
serebrov , et al .
instrum . meth . a 611 ( 2009 ) 137 ,
arxiv:0809.4902 [ nucl - ex ] ; + a.p .
serebrov , et al .
b 663 ( 2008 ) 181 , arxiv:0706.3600 [ nucl - ex ] ; + g. ban , et al .
99 ( 2007 ) 161603 , arxiv:0705.2336 [ nucl - ex ] .
g. dvali , g. gabadadze , m. shifman , phys .
b 497 ( 2001 ) 271 , arxiv : hep - th/0010071 ; + g. dvali , g. gabadadze , m. porrati , phys . lett .
b 485 ( 2000 ) 208 , arxiv : hep - th/0005016 ; + s.l .
dubovsky , v.a .
rubakov , int .
phys . a 16 ( 2001 ) 4331 , arxiv : hep - th/0105243 .
z. berezhiani , a. lepidi , phys .
b 681 ( 2009 ) 276 , arxiv:0810.1317 [ hep - ph ] ; + a. melchiorri , a. polosa , a. strumia , phys . lett .
b 650 ( 2007 ) 416 , arxiv : hep - ph/0703144 ; + s. davidson , s. hannestad , g. raffelt , jhep 0005 ( 2000 ) 003 , arxiv : hep - ph/0001179 . g.j .
mathews , t. kajino , t. shima , phys .
d 71 ( 2005 ) 021302 , arxiv : astro - ph/0408523 ; + j.s .
nico , w.m .
snow , ann .
nucl . part .
55 ( 2005 ) 27 , arxiv : nucl - ex/0612022 ; + z. berezhiani , l. bento , phys .
b 635 ( 2006 ) 253 , arxiv : hep - ph/0602227 . v.i .
nazaruk , int . j. mod
e 20 ( 2011 ) 1203 , arxiv:1004.3192 [ hep - ph ] ; + v. kopeliovich , i. potashnikova , eur .
j. c 69 ( 2010 ) 591 , arxiv:1005.1441 [ hep - ph ] ; + v.i .
nazaruk , phys .
c 58 ( 1998 ) 1884 , arxiv : hep - ph/9810354 .
a. ipp , j. evers , c.h .
keitel , k.z .
hatsagortsyan , phys .
b 702 ( 2011 ) 383 , arxiv:1008.0355 [ physics.ins-det ] ; + t. heinzl , j. phys . :
( 2009 ) 012005 ; + s .- w .
bahk , et al . ,
( 2004 ) 2837 . | recent theoretical works have shown that matter swapping between two parallel braneworlds could occur under the influence of magnetic vector potentials . in our visible world
, galactic magnetism possibly produces a huge magnetic potential . as a consequence ,
this paper discusses the possibility to observe neutron disappearance into another braneworld in certain circumstances .
the setup under consideration involves stored ultracold neutrons @xmath0 in a vessel @xmath0 which should exhibit a non - zero probability @xmath1 to disappear into an invisible brane at each wall collision .
an upper limit of @xmath1 is assessed based on available experimental results .
this value is then used to constrain the parameters of the theoretical model .
possible improvements of the experiments are discussed , including enhanced stimulated swapping by artificial means .
brane phenomenology , braneworlds , matter disappearance , ultracold neutrons |
the strong observational evidence for an accelerating universe @xcite has sparked a widespread search for a dynamical explanation . beyond a bare cosmological constant ,
a plethora of other models have been proposed , with quintessence - a dynamical scalar field that behaves essentially as a modern day inflaton field , - being perhaps the simplest example ( see @xcite ) . in this context , many potentials have been introduced that yield late - time acceleration and tracking behaviour ( see @xcite ) . among other approaches ,
modified gravity models have attracted great interest ( see @xcite ) but also some criticism , partly because they were introduced as purely phenomenological models , but more seriously because it was not clear that they possessed a satisfactory newtonian limit in the solar system , or that they were free of ghosts ( see @xcite ) . in this paper
, we investigate the propagating degrees of freedom of the so - called cddett model @xcite . there already exist detailed studies of the newtonian limit @xcite and the supernovae contraints @xcite for this model . here
we derive conditions that they be free of ghosts , and that they have a real propagation speed less than or equal to that of light . as we review below
, a transformation of the action shows that modified gravity models are equivalent to a number of scalar fields linearly coupled to higher order curvature invariants . in the case
in which these curvature invariants are fourth order , the relevant one for the modified gravity models of refs .
@xcite , we obtain conditions for the propagating degrees of freedom to be well - behaved in their late - time attractor solutions ( friedmann - robertson walker spacetimes with accelerating expansion ) .
this extends previous work which established their consistency in de sitter backgrounds @xcite .
we find that while untroubled by ghosts , the accelerating power - law attractors in general have superluminal tensor and scalar modes , which may place severe theoretical constraints on these models .
our starting point is the action proposed in @xcite , which we write in the form @xmath0 \ , \label{starta}\ ] ] where @xmath1 is a constant , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
we have introduced @xmath5 for generality , but note that its presence does not change the late time behaviour of the accelerating attractors , since for an accelerating universe both the @xmath6 ( einstein - hilbert ) term and the dark matter density become negligible ( in other words the exponent of the power law attractor does not depend on @xmath7 , see @xcite ) .
finally , we take the function @xmath8 to be of the form @xmath9 where a sum over @xmath10 is implied .
the action ( [ starta ] ) can be written as that of einstein gravity coupled to a scalar field , a form more suitable for analysing the propagating degrees of freedom ( see the appendix for a general analysis ) .
consider @xmath11\ , \label{step1}\ ] ] where , of course , @xmath12 , otherwise the action is not finite .
the variation of this action with respect to @xmath13 leads to @xmath14 and , using this relation , action ( [ step1 ] ) and action ( [ starta ] ) yield the same equations of motion .
note that when @xmath15 and @xmath16 , this action is equivalent to einstein - hilbert gravity coupled to a single scalar through a gauss - bonnet ( gb ) term @xmath17 .
the coupling of a scalar field with a quadratic expression of the curvature invariants emerges naturally in the context of string theory .
in particular , as was shown in @xcite by gross and sloan , in the low - energy effective action the dilaton is coupled to a gauss - bonnet term .
it is well known that such a term , expanded about a minkowski vacuum , ensures that the theory is ghost - free ( see @xcite ) .
it might then seem that taking the @xmath18 to be the gb combination is a sensible choice , because string theory predicts such a coupling to exist and string theory does not have ghosts .
however , in models like ours , for which minkowski spacetime is not a solution , choosing the gb combination of parameters @xmath18 is not a sufficient condition for the non - existence of ghosts .
a ghost is a propagating degree of freedom whose propagator has the wrong sign , and which therefore gives rise to a negative norm state on quantisation .
such states are allowed off - shell in gauge field perturbation theory , but are unacceptable as physical particles . a theory of gravity with fourth order derivatives in the kinetic term inevitably has ghosts @xcite , but even a theory with second order derivatives alone has other potential problems .
once we break lorentz invariance , as in a friedmann - robertson - walker ( frw ) background , the kinetic terms of a field , even though second order in derivatives , may still have the wrong sign , or may give rise to a propagation speed which is greater than 1 , or imaginary . to see this in more detail ,
consider the action for a scalar field @xmath13 , s = d^4 x ( 12t(t ) ^2 - 12s(t ) ^2 ) .
[ e : problem_action ] the propagation speed of this scalar is @xmath19 .
one may wish to impose one or more of the following conditions 1 . a real propagation speed : @xmath20 , otherwise all perturbations have exponentially growing modes . 2 .
a propagation speed less than light : @xmath21 , we will talk about this issue more in detail in section iii .
3 . no ghosts : @xmath22 , to ensure a consistent quantum field theory . clearly ,
unless @xmath23 and @xmath24 are positive , and their ratio less than one , we will have instabilities , superluminal propagation , or ghosts .
we will see that in studying the action for small perturbations of the metric in modified gravity theories we will generally encounter actions of the form ( [ e : problem_action ] ) .
if @xmath25 , the action ( [ starta ] ) can be written in terms of an einstein - hilbert term plus a particular extra piece involving two new scalar fields . furthermore , because of the special properties of the gauss - bonnet term , the equations of motion are no longer 4th order , but remain 2nd order in the fields .
taking the action ( [ step1 ] ) and introducing a new scalar field @xmath26 , we have s = d^4 x\{[+2bf()]r - u()-b^2f()+f()r^2_gb } [ hn1 ] , where u()&=&_^4n+2 + f()&=&a_3_^4n+2n^n+1 , with @xmath27 , and @xmath28 the gauss - bonnet invariant . making a field redefinition @xmath29 , the equation of motion for @xmath30 is @xmath31 , and the gravitational equations then become & ( + ) r _ - _ _ + g_-2r__f + 2g_rf + 8r_(_)^f & + & -4r_f-4g_r^__f - 4r_(^_)__f-12g_=0 . & independent of the background , after application of the bianchi indentities these equations are second - order in derivatives of the fields , thanks to the gauss - bonnet combination . it is known that adding terms quadratic in the curvature invariants to the einstein - hilbert action with a cosmological constant yields an extra scalar mode and a spin-2 mode , which is generically a ghost because of its fourth - order field equation ( see @xcite ) .
thus , provided we are expanding around a constant @xmath13 background , such as de sitter space , we can directly infer that modifed gravity models are generically afflicted by spin-2 ghosts .
however , in our case , it is clear that the higher derivative terms cancel out identically because @xmath15 , as was already found in @xcite .
the remaining extra scalar degree of freedom , @xmath30 , is due to the presence of the extra @xmath32 term in the lagrangian , which vanishes if @xmath16 .
crucially though , the vanishing of the fourth order term is a necessary but not sufficient condition for the absence of ghosts in the spin-2 sector . as we described above
, one must also separately check the signs of the second order derivatives with respect to both time and space ( a check was not performed in @xcite ) . in this paper
we derive and study the kinetic terms for both the spin 0 and spin 2 fields in time - dependent backgrounds , to which derivatives of @xmath33 contribute .
we find that both fields may be afflicted by instabilities or ghosts , contrary to the claim of the absence of ghosts in frw spacetimes made in @xcite .
we show that the special case of an empty accelerating universe the late - time attractor of an frw cosmology in the modified gravity model under consideration the propagating states are generically ( but not universally ) superluminal over the @xmath34 parameter space .
if the second order derivatives of the spin-2 and spin-0 fields do not have the correct signs in frw spacetimes , then the theory may be inconsistent .
the existence of a ghost mode would lead , for example , to the over - production of all particles coupled to it .
one may think of a theory with ghosts as an effective theory , with no ghosts above some cutoff , thereby restoring consistency ( see @xcite ) . however , this cut - off must be less than about 3 mev @xcite .
a further condition that one may wish to impose is that the propagation speeds be less than or equal to unity .
one worry is that the existence of superluminal modes on the relevant cosmological backgrounds may lead to a catastrophic signature of causality violation ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
other authors @xcite ) have discussed the problem of superluminal propagation in non - lorentzian backgrounds and , in particular , have suggested that the presence of superluminal modes would introduce a second horizon , the so called sound horizon , different from the light causal horizon , which may lead to ambiguities and inconsistencies in black - hole thermodynamics @xcite .
furthermore , it has been pointed out ( @xcite ) that for some set of initial conditions , superluminal modes may yield ill - posed cauchy problems . in particular , in our case , nothing prevents @xmath35 and @xmath36 - the respective speeds of the scalar and tensor modes - becoming infinite . in general
this would lead to causally connected spatial sections and eventually to an ill - posed cauchy problem . on the other hand , in the context of non - commutative geometry
, other authors have studied superluminal propagation and shown that there is no causality violation if there is a preferred reference frame @xcite .
given these different possibilities , in this paper we will present the constraints from superluminal propagation in a clearly distinct way from those arising from ghosts , so as to allow readers to impose fewer or more constraints , depending on the particular theory they are working with . in this section
we begin with the special case @xmath37 which we refer to as the modified gb action .
we vary with respect to @xmath13 and @xmath38 , write @xmath39 , so that @xmath40 , and use the many useful identities contained in ref .
@xcite to derive @xmath41\right .
\nonumber\\ & & - r^{\mu\nu } \left [ \left ( \ga - 4 \ , \box f \right)\de^\al_\mu\de^\be_\nu - 4 ( \na_\nu\na_\mu f ) g^{\al\be } + 8 ( \na^\rh\na_\mu f ) \de^{(\al}_\rh\de^{\be)}_\nu \right ] \nonumber\\ & & \left .
+ { { r^\al}_{\nu\rho}}^\be ( 4 \na^\rh\na^\nu f ) - { \frac12}u(\phi)g^{\al\be } \right\ } h_{\al\be } \ .
\label{e : deltag}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to establish whether the theory is stable and ghost free , we must examine the second variation of the action . this can be organized as before , @xmath42 the easiest term is @xmath43 and we can simplify the mixed term using the field equation for @xmath13 , to obtain @xmath44 , where @xmath45 .
after integration by parts we then have @xmath46 \na_\rh\na_\si\de f \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we simplify the final term using the field equation for @xmath38 , and organise according to the number of derivatives of @xmath47 . in order to check that the original action is ghost free , we need to establish that the fourth order terms vanish , and that terms involving two derivatives of the metric have the appropriate sign .
it is already straightforward to see from eq .
( [ e : deltag ] ) that there can be no fourth order derivatives , as the terms containing derivatives of the riemann and ricci tensors , and the ricci scalar , have already cancelled .
the remaining second order terms are _
g^2 s_(2 ) & = & d^4x h_\ { - ( h + ^^h _ ) .
+ & + & 12 + & & ( h^ + ^^h - ^a^- ^a^ ) + & + & .
12 ( ^^h^ + ^^h^ - ^^h^ - ^^h^ ) } , where @xmath48 . in an frw space - time , the background fields break lorentz invariance , with g _ & = & a^2 ( ) _ , + _ _ f & = & ^0_^0_b ( ) + g _ g^00c ( ) , where @xmath49 , @xmath50 ( and where we have assumed spatial flatness ) . here
a prime denotes a derivative with respect to conformal time @xmath51 , and @xmath52 . in this background
it is convenient to decompose the metric perturbation into scalar , vector and tensor modes in the usual way . to check the sign of the kinetic term for the spin-2 particle ,
we first identify it in the expansion of the metric h_ij = g^(3)_ij+ _ |ij + c_(i|j ) + h_ij , ( where the symbol @xmath53 denotes covariant differentiation with respect to the spatial metric @xmath54 ) as the transverse , traceless ( @xmath55 , @xmath56 ) tensor mode @xmath57 .
it is straightforward to show that the tensor part of the second variation which is second order in derivatives of @xmath58 is _ g^2
s^t_(2 ) & = & d^4x . rearranging and using @xmath59 to display the time and space derivatives separately , we find _
g^2 s^t_(2 ) & = & d^4x . we therefore have two conditions for a stable theory free of ghosts : + ( f - f)>0 , + f > 0 . [ condeta ]
the ratio of the coefficients of the second derivatives is the propagation velocity squared of the spin-2 mode .
therefore , in terms of physical time , @xmath60 and planck units @xmath61 , the condition that a background have a real and non - superluminal spin-2 propagation speed is 0c_2 ^ 2 = 1 , [ spin2speed ] [ cond1 ] where a dot indicates a derivative with respect to @xmath62 , and @xmath63 .
further , the condition that the spin-2 mode not be a ghost is 0 < 1 + 8 hf,[cond2 ] .
the same strictures apply to the scalar ( spin-0 ) mode , whose kinetic term is much more difficult to evaluate .
fortunately , our lagrangian is a special case of a class of theories studied in ref .
there it was shown that the gauge - invariant combination @xmath64 ( one of the bardeen scalars ) satisfies ( a^3 q ) - p = 0 , where q & = & , + p & = & . if the spin-2 propagator is well behaved , the sign of the scalar time derivatives is also correct thanks to eq .
( [ cond2 ] ) , and there are no spin-0 ghosts . finally , the condition that the scalar propagation speed be real and non - superluminal reads 0c_0 ^ 2 = ( 1 + 43)-83 1 . [ spin0speed ] [ cond3 ] having established these results , let us now focus on the particular class of models in hand .
we have f = a241^n+1 , where @xmath65 . without loss of generality
, we fix to unity the coefficient of the square of the riemann tensor in the lagrangian , i.e. @xmath66 , and note that the @xmath13 equation of motion , in a flat frw background , then yields = r^2_gb=24h^2a .
since we are interested in the behaviour of these actions in the universe at late times , we study the attractor solutions for the cddett model when the matter is diluted away because of the expansion . in general @xcite
the attractor solutions can be written as @xmath67 , with @xmath68 .
for the gauss - bonnet combination , it was found that the relevant accelerating power - law attractor is given by @xmath69 .
we see that = ( p-1 ) , with @xmath70 for an accelerating universe , and therefore f & = & 4(n+1)(p-1)a^n+2 , + f&=&96(n+1)(4n+3)(p-1)^2a^n+3=tf .
thus , it is clear that , if @xmath71 or @xmath72 , ( [ condeta ] ) are satisfied for an accelerating universe ( @xmath68 ) .
however , the spin-2 propagation speed is c_2 ^ 2 = , which for the pure gb theory approaches 1 from above , and so the graviton propagates faster than light
. for the scalar , condition ( [ cond3 ] ) amounts to 0c_0^ 2 = ( 1 - ) + 83 1 .
a sufficient condition to satisfy these relations is ( 4,n+7/4 ) < p < 4n+3 , which is clearly satisfied for the pure gb theory for any @xmath73 . to summarise : there are no ghosts or instabilities for the modified gb attractor solutions for any @xmath73 .
however , the graviton propagates superluminally , which may render the pure gb theory inconsistent .
finally , the pure gb combination is not phenomenologically viable . in this case
, @xmath74 and @xmath13 vanishes as @xmath75 approaches to zero .
this means that , for this combination , in the cddett model @xmath76 is a singularity of the equations of motion , and it not possible to change the sign of @xmath75 .
the universe can never change from deceleration to acceleration .
( this is reminiscent of the problem encountered in some other modified gravity theories @xcite . ) in this section we study the propagation of the spin-2 and spin-0 modes when matter is present , which changes the background cosmology and hence the coefficients of the second derivatives in the action . as we discovered in the previous subsection
, a realistic model should have @xmath25 so that the modification is not pure gauss - bonnet .
the conditions ( [ cond1],[cond2],[spin2speed],[cond3],[spin0speed ] ) can be generalized in a straightforward but lengthy way ( see @xcite ) , and depend on the parameter @xmath77 ( recall we are assuming that @xmath78 as required to cancel fourth - order derivatives ) .
the correct signs in the spin-2 propagator are assured if 1 + 4bfr + 8 f & > & 0,[cond_gen1 ] [ e : realtensorspeedmatter ] + 1 + 4bfr+8hf & > & 0,[cond_gen2 ] [ e : noghostmatter ] with the propagation speed condition reading c_2 ^ 2 = 1 .
[ e : sublumgraviton ] the coupling of @xmath79 to the ricci scalar outside the gb combination gives an extra propagating scalar degree of freedom @xmath80 ( see @xcite ) , the other bardeen scalar .
the two scalar modes have the same speed of propagation @xmath35 and , once again , if the graviton propagator is well behaved , there is only the following extra condition to be satisfied 0c_0 ^ 2=1+fh-(f - fh ) , [ cond_gen3 ] where q_1=4b(fr+fr)+8fh^2q_2=1 + 4bfr+8hf .
these conditions put additional bounds on the parameter space spanned by the @xmath81 which define the cddett modified gravity theories , if we require that they hold at all times during the evolution of the universe .
in particular , we may require that they hold when the universe expands with a power - law , @xmath82 , for which & = & + r&= & + f&=&_3t^4n+4 .
where _ 1&=&12p^2[3b(2p-1)^2 + 2p(p-1 ) ] + _ 2&=&6p(2p-1 ) + _ 3&= & .
therefore we have that c_2 ^ 2&=&1 + 4_3t^4n+2[b_2 + 8p(n+1 ) ] , [ latet2 ] + c_0 ^ 2 & = & 1 - - [ latet0 ] this relation holds for any power - law behaviour , unless either @xmath83 or @xmath84 becomes zero .
we expect power - law expansion at early time , where the universe should behave as an ordinary friedmann model , and at late time where it approaches an accelerating attractor solution .
let us consider a matter - dominated universe , @xmath85 , assuming a positive @xmath86 to ensure the no - ghost conditions are satisfied . in this case
it is clear that the tensor modes are superluminal , and their speed tends to one as @xmath87 . on the other hand , for a late - time attractor solution , the accelerating power law is given by @xcite p= , where @xmath88 .
the exponent @xmath89 is real , for large @xmath90 , if @xmath91 or @xmath92 .
furthermore at late times , eq . ( [ latet2 ] ) takes the approximate form c_2 ^ 2 , which means that for non - superluminal behaviour we require p>4n+3 .
it should be noted that the value @xmath93 can not be considered , because this would imply that @xmath94 . for large @xmath90 , one requires , -85 to avoid superluminal tensor modes . at late times , eq .
( [ latet0 ] ) takes the approximate form c_0 ^ 2 & = & 1 - - , [ scalla ] for large @xmath90 , eq .
( [ scalla ] ) , implies that the scalar modes are not superluminal if -51 . for large @xmath90 , in the region @xmath95 both tensor and scalar modes are not superluminal . in the case of @xmath96
one can see that the allowed region is @xmath97 , where the lower bound is given by @xmath98 and the upper one by @xmath99 .
this additional constraint would rule out the region @xmath100 ( where @xmath89 is real ) identifed by mena at al . as producing cosmologies consistent with supernovae data . a plot of the allowed values of @xmath101 and @xmath90 ,
after imposing the no - ghost constraint , or the no - superluminal constraint or both , is shown in fig . [
f : guarda ] .
[ ] [ ] [ 1][-90]@xmath90 plane for the constraints .
the light grey area corresponds to the region in which only the no - ghost constraint ( eq . [ e : noghostmatter ] ) holds .
the darker area represents the points at which both the no - ghost and the positive - squared - velocity conditions ( eqs .
[ e : realtensorspeedmatter ] , [ e : noghostmatter ] , [ cond_gen3 ] ) hold at the same time .
finally the darkest region is the region of the plane at which all the constraints ( no - ghost , @xmath102 , eqs . [ e : realtensorspeedmatter ] , [ e : noghostmatter ] , [ cond_gen3 ] , [ e : sublumgraviton ] ) hold for both scalar and tensor modes.,title="fig : " ] [ f : guarda ]
the search for a satisfactory model for the acceleration of the universe has been pursued in many different ways .
recently , models attempting to explain such behavior by changing the gravity sector have been proposed @xcite . in particular , the cddett model @xcite , has the attractive feature of the existence of accelerating late - time power - law attractors , while satisfying solar system constraints @xcite . in this paper
we have investigated the consistency of the propagating modes ( tensor and scalar ) for the action @xmath103\ .\ ] ] in order for this action to be ghost - free , it is necessary but not sufficient , to set @xmath15 @xcite so that there are no fourth derivatives in the linearised field equations .
what remained was the possibility that the second derivatives might have the wrong signs , and also might allow superluminal propagation at some time in a particular cosmological background .
for example , for the case @xmath16 , for which the modification is a function of the gauss - bonnet term , we found that the accelerating power - law attractor solutions give propagators with the correct signs , but with a spin-2 mode propagating faster than light .
we have also examined the general second order cddett modified gravity theory in a frw background with matter , which is parametrized by the energy scale @xmath7 and by @xmath104 - the deviation of the ricci scalar - squared term from that appearing in the gauss - bonnet combination - or equivalently @xmath105 .
we found that the theories are ghost - free , but contain superluminally propagating scalar or tensor modes over a wide range of parameter space . in conclusion , we note that there are likely to be further constraints from compatibility with cmb data as we have changed gravity on large scales quite significantly . to investigate this point is beyond the remit of the current paper .
we want to thank gianluca calcagni , sean carroll , gia dvali , renata kallosh , kei - ichi maeda , shinji mukhoyama , burt ovrut , paul saffin , karel van acoleyen and richard woodard for helpful comments and discussions .
adf is supported by pparc .
mt is supported in part by the nsf under grant phy-0354990 and by research corporation .
99 a. g. riess _ et al .
_ [ supernova search team collaboration ] , astron .
j. * 116 * , 1009 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9805201 ] . s. perlmutter _ et al .
_ [ supernova cosmology project collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. * 517 * , 565 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9812133 ] .
a. g. riess _ et al .
_ [ supernova search team collaboration ] , astrophys . j. * 607 * , 665 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0402512 ]
. j. l. tonry _ et al . _
[ supernova search team collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. * 594 * , 1 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0305008 ] .
d. n. spergel _ et al .
_ , arxiv : astro - ph/0603449 . l. page _ et al .
_ , arxiv : astro - ph/0603450 .
g. hinshaw _ et al .
_ , arxiv : astro - ph/0603451 . n. jarosik _ et al .
_ , arxiv : astro - ph/0603452 .
c. b. netterfield _ et al .
_ [ boomerang collaboration ] , astrophys . j. * 571 * , 604 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0104460 ]
. n. w. halverson _ et al .
_ , astrophys . j. * 568 * , 38 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0104489 ] . n. weiss , phys . lett .
b * 197 * , 42 ( 1987 ) . c. wetterich , nucl .
b * 302 * , 668 ( 1988 ) .
b. ratra and p. j. e. peebles , phys .
d * 37 * , 3406 ( 1988 ) .
p. j. e. peebles and b. ratra , astrophys .
j. * 325 * , l17 ( 1988 ) .
j. a. frieman , c. t. hill , a. stebbins and i. waga , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 2077 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9505060 ] . k. coble , s. dodelson and j. a. frieman , phys . rev .
d * 55 * , 1851 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9608122 ] .
p. j. e. peebles and a. vilenkin , phys .
d * 59 * , 063505 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9810509 ] .
p. j. steinhardt ,
l. m. wang and i. zlatev , phys .
d * 59 * , 123504 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9812313 ] .
i. zlatev , l. m. wang and p. j. steinhardt , phys .
lett . * 82 * , 896 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9807002 ] .
p. g. ferreira and m. joyce , phys .
lett . * 79 * , 4740 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9707286 ] .
a. r. liddle and r. j. scherrer , phys .
d * 59 * , 023509 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9809272 ] .
e. j. copeland , a. r. liddle and d. wands , phys .
d * 57 * , 4686 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/9711068 ] .
s. c. c. ng , n. j. nunes and f. rosati , phys .
d * 64 * , 083510 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0107321 ] .
s. bludman , phys . rev .
d * 69 * , 122002 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0403526 ] .
s. m. carroll , v. duvvuri , m. trodden and m. s. turner , phys .
d * 70 * , 043528 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0306438 ] .
s. m. carroll , a. de felice , v. duvvuri , d. a. easson , m. trodden and m. s. turner , phys .
d * 71 * , 063513 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0410031 ]
. s. capozziello , s. carloni and a. troisi , arxiv : astro - ph/0303041 . c. deffayet , g. r. dvali and g. gabadadze , phys .
d * 65 * , 044023 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0105068 ] .
k. freese and m. lewis , cardassian expansion : a model in which the universe is flat , matter phys .
b * 540 * , 1 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0201229 ] .
n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , g. dvali and g. gabadadze , arxiv : hep - th/0209227 . g. dvali and m. s. turner , arxiv : astro - ph/0301510 . s. nojiri and s. d. odintsov , mod .
a * 19 * , 627 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0310045 ] .
n. arkani - hamed , h. c. cheng , m. a. luty and s. mukohyama , jhep * 0405 * , 074 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0312099 ] .
m. c. b. abdalla , s. nojiri and s. d. odintsov , class .
* 22 * , l35 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0409177 ] .
d. n. vollick , phys .
d * 68 * , 063510 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0306630 ]
. g. r. dvali , g. gabadadze and m. porrati , phys .
b * 485 * , 208 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0005016 ] . c. deffayet , g. r. dvali , g. gabadadze and a. i. vainshtein , phys .
d * 65 * , 044026 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0106001 ] .
a. nunez and s. solganik , phys .
b * 608 * , 189 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0411102 ] .
t. chiba , jcap * 0503 * , 008 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0502070 ] .
a. nicolis and r. rattazzi , jhep * 0406 * , 059 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0404159 ] . m. a. luty , m. porrati and r. rattazzi , jhep * 0309 * , 029 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0303116 ] . k. koyama , phys . rev .
d * 72 * , 123511 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0503191 ] .
d. gorbunov , k. koyama and s. sibiryakov , arxiv : hep - th/0512097 . i. navarro and k. van acoleyen , phys . lett .
b * 622 * , 1 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0506096 ] .
o. mena , j. santiago and j. weller , arxiv : astro - ph/0510453 .
d. j. gross and j. h. sloan , nucl .
b * 291 * , 41 ( 1987 ) .
b. zwiebach , phys .
b * 156 * , 315 ( 1985 ) .
n. h. barth and s. m. christensen , phys .
d * 28 * , 1876 ( 1983 ) .
k. s. stelle , gen .
* 9 * , 353 ( 1978 ) .
a. hindawi , b. a. ovrut and d. waldram , phys .
d * 53 * , 5583 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9509142 ] .
n. boulanger , t. damour , l. gualtieri and m. henneaux , nucl .
b * 597 * , 127 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0007220 ] .
r. p. woodard , arxiv : astro - ph/0601672 . i. navarro and k. van acoleyen , arxiv : gr - qc/0511045 . s. m. carroll , m. hoffman and m. trodden , phys . rev .
d * 68 * , 023509 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0301273 ] .
j. m. cline , s. jeon and g. d. moore , phys .
d * 70 * , 043543 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0311312 ] .
a. adams , n. arkani - hamed , s. dubovsky , a. nicolis and r. rattazzi , arxiv : hep - th/0602178 .
a. hashimoto and n. itzhaki , phys .
d * 63 * , 126004 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0012093 ] .
e. babichev , v. f. mukhanov and a. vikman , arxiv : hep - th/0604075 .
a. d. rendall , class .
* 23 * , 1557 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0511158 ] .
a. vikman , arxiv : astro - ph/0606033 .
c. bonvin , c. caprini and r. durrer , arxiv : astro - ph/0606584 .
s. l. dubovsky and s. m. sibiryakov , arxiv : hep - th/0603158 . c. armendariz - picon and e. a. lim , jcap * 0508 * , 007 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0505207 ] . j. c. hwang and h. noh , phys .
d * 61 * , 043511 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9909480 ] .
d. a. easson , f. p. schuller , m. trodden and m. n. r. wohlfarth , phys .
d * 72 * , 043504 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0506392 ] .
j. c. hwang and h. noh , phys .
d * 71 * , 063536 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0412126 ] .
in this appendix we demonstrate how actions for non - standard models of gravity can be rewritten in the form of einstein gravity with a non - minimal coupling to one or more scalar fields .
this is not a new result ( see most recently e.g. @xcite ) , but the modified gravity action ( [ barba ] ) is a special case which needs separate consideration . consider the action @xmath106 where @xmath107 are monomials in the curvature invariants , with @xmath108 , @xmath109 and @xmath110 defined earlier , but where we allow the possibility of higher order terms .
if the function @xmath111 is at least twice differentiable ( except possibly at isolated points ) , then this is easily seen to be equivalent to the action @xmath112 \ , \label{scalargenact}\ ] ] where @xmath113 are a set of auxiliary scalar fields , one for each of the terms @xmath107 , and @xmath114 .
the first variation is @xmath115 , \label{first var}\ ] ] where @xmath116 .
we immediately see that , provided the matrix of second derivatives @xmath117 is non - singular , @xmath118 , and we return to the original action ( [ genact ] ) .
this was one of the results in @xcite .
however , the possibility of a singular matrix was not considered . in models of the form ( [ barba ] ) , there exist degeneracies in the parameters of the form @xmath119 where @xmath120 are arbitrary constants , and @xmath121 are orthonormal vectors in the space of curvature invariants . in this case ,
@xmath122 , @xmath123 , and higher derivatives also vanish .
as our modified gravity example suggests , we can reduce the number of scalar fields by taking linear combinations of the @xmath107 normal to the subspace spanned by the @xmath121 .
if this subspace is spanned by @xmath127 , then we can define a new set of variables @xmath128 , @xmath129 .
the function @xmath130 is now independent of @xmath131 , so we can write @xmath132=\int d^4x\,\sqrt{-g}\,[f(\phi'_a ) + ( z^{\prime}_{a } - \phi'_a)f_a(\phi ' ) ] \ .\ ] ] in the cddett model , the lagrangian density depends on @xmath108 , @xmath109 , and @xmath110 only through the combinations @xmath108 , @xmath133 .
there is one degeneracy , and so there are only two scalar fields required to put the action into the linearised form of eq .
( [ scalargenact ] ) . when @xmath134 in ( [ hn1 ] ) , the field associated with @xmath135 may be trivially solved for to give the einstein - hilbert term . | we consider modified gravity models involving inverse powers of fourth - order curvature invariants . using these models equivalence to the theory of a scalar field coupled to a linear combination of the invariants , we investigate the properties of the propagating modes . even in the case for which the fourth derivative terms in the field equations vanish , we find that the second derivative terms can give rise to ghosts , instabilities , and superluminal propagation speeds .
we establish the conditions which the theories must satisfy in order to avoid these problems in friedmann backgrounds , and show that the late - time attractor solutions generically exhibit superluminally propagating tensor or scalar modes . |
when imperative programmers think of lists , they commonly choose doubly linked lists , instead of the singly linked lists that logic and functional programmers use . in the same way ,
it is extremely common for trees to be given parent links , whether they are really needed or not .
a typical c example might be .... typedef int datum ; typedef struct treerec * treeptr ; struct treerec { treeptr left , right , up , down ; datum datum ; } ; .... where ` down ' points to the first child of a node , ` up ' to its parents , and the children of a node form a doubly linked list with ` left ' and ` right ' pointers .
essentially this representation is required by the document object model @xcite , for example .
cyclically linked trees in imperative languages such as java provide constant time navigation in any of the four directions ( up , down , left , right ) and also constant time and constant space editing ( insert , delete , replace ) .
they do so at a price : each element is rigidly locked into place , so that any kind of space sharing ( such as hash consing ) is made impossible .
some logic programming languages have been designed to support cyclically linked terms . that does provide constant time navigation , but not editing .
the locking into place that is a nuisance in imperative languages is a very serious difficulty in logic programming languages .
additionally , reasoning about the termination of programs that traverse cyclic graphs is harder than reasoning about programs that traverse trees , whether in prolog dialects or in lazy functional languages , so it is useful to get by with trees if we can .
this article has two parts .
in the first part , i present `` fat pointers '' that can be used to navigate around pure trees .
the tree itself remains unmodified throughout .
the main predicates i define have the form from_to(from , to ) . if one of the arguments is ground and the other is uninstantiated , the time and space cost is o(1 ) per solution . in the second part , i present `` edit pointers '' that can be used to navigate around trees and edit them , in o(1 ) amortised time and space per step and edit . the type declarations are mycroft / okeefe @xcite type declarations using the syntax of mercury @xcite .
the predicate declarations are also mycroft / okeefe declarations giving argument types and modes .
the code has been type - checked by the mercury compiler .
the clauses are edinburgh prolog .
this paper provides evidence that using different definitions for different modes is useful , but that is difficult in mercury , so the modes were not converted to mercury syntax and the code does not pass mercury mode - checking .
this is a generalisation of a method for o(1 ) left and right navigation in a list shown to me by david h. d. warren in 1983 , in a text editor he wrote in prolog .
a companion paper @xcite presents this technique in a functional context .
it was rejected on the grounds that the data structure had already been published by huet as the zipper in @xcite
. however , the two data structures described in this paper and in @xcite are different from the zipper , and the issues discussed here are different .
the key idea is to distinguish between a tree and a pointer into a tree .
the usual c / java approach blurs this distinction , and that has misled some logic programmers into thinking that cyclically linked trees are necessary in order to obtain a certain effect in pointers .
a tree just has to represent certain information ; a pointer has to know how to move .
a suitable data type for trees is .... : - type tree(datum ) --- > node(datum , list(tree(datum ) ) ) .
: - pred tree_datum(tree(d ) , d ) .
tree_datum(node(datum , _ ) , datum ) .
: - pred tree_children(tree(d ) , list(tree(d ) ) ) .
tree_children(node(_,children ) , children ) .
.... like a c pointer , a `` fat pointer '' points to a specific ( sub)tree ; unlike a c pointer , a `` fat pointer '' carries a context : the ( sub)tree s left siblings ( ordered from nearest to furthest ) , its right siblings ( ordered from nearest to furthest ) , and a parent fat pointer , if this is not the root . .... : - type pointer(d ) --- > ptr(tree(d ) , list(tree(d ) ) , list(tree(d ) ) , pointer(d ) ) ; no_ptr .
.... the predicates we define will never be true of a ` no_ptr ' argument .
.... : - pred top_pointer(tree(d ) , pointer(d ) ) .
top_pointer(tree , ptr(tree,[],[],no_ptr ) ) .
: - pred pointer_tree(pointer(d ) , tree(d ) ) .
pointer_tree(ptr(tree , _ , _ , _ ) , tree ) .
: - pred pointer_datum(pointer(d ) , d ) .
pointer_datum(ptr(tree , _ , _ , _ ) , datum ) : - tree_datum(tree , datum ) .
: - pred at_left(pointer ( _ ) ) .
at_left(ptr ( _ , [ ] , _ , _ ) ) .
: - pred at_right(pointer ( _ ) ) .
at_right(ptr ( _ , _ , [ ] , _ ) ) .
: - pred at_top(pointer ( _ ) ) .
at_top(ptr(_,_,_,no_ptr ) ) . :
- pred at_bottom(pointer ( _ ) ) .
at_bottom(ptr(tree , _ , _ , _ ) ) : - tree_children(tree , [ ] ) .
: - pred left_right(pointer(d ) , pointer(d ) ) .
left_right(ptr(t , l,[n|r],a ) , ptr(n,[t|l],r , a ) ) .
: - pred up_down_first(pointer(d ) , pointer(d ) ) .
up_down_first(p , ptr(t,[],r , p ) ) : - % p = ptr(tree(_,[t|r ] ) , _ , _ , _ ) .
p = ptr(tree , _ , _ , _ ) , tree_children(tree , [ t|r ] ) . .... the ` top_pointer/2 ' predicate may be used to make a fat pointer from a tree , or to extract a tree from a fat pointer positioned at_top .
the ` at_/1 ' predicates recognise whether a fat pointer is positioned at a boundary .
the query ` left_right(left , right ) ' is true when left and right are pointers to adjacent siblings , left on the left , and right on the right .
the query ` up_down_first(up , down ) ' is true when up is a pointer and down is a pointer to up s first child ; it is o(1 ) time and space in either direction provided that the list of children of a node is stored in that node and not recomputed .
the query ` up_down(up , down ) ' is to be true when up is a pointer and down is a pointer to any of up s children .
it uses mode - dependent code . .... : - pred up_down(pointer(d ) , pointer(d ) ) .
up_down(p , ptr(t , l , r , a ) ) : - ( var(p ) - > a = ptr ( _ , _ , _ , _ ) , % not no_ptr , that is .
p = a ; a = p , p = ptr(tree , _ , _ , _ ) , tree_children(tree , children ) , % split children++ [ ] into reverse(l)++[t]++r split_children(children , [ ] , l , t , r ) ) .
: - pred split_children(list(t ) , list(t ) , list(t ) , t , list(t ) ) .
split_children([t|r ] , l , l , t , r ) .
split_children([x|s ] , l0 , l , t , r ) : - split_children(s , [ x|l0 ] , l , t , r ) . .... we could write this clearly enough as ....
up_down_specification(p , ptr(t , l , r , p ) ) : - p = ptr(tree(_,children ) , _ , _ , _ ) , split_children(children , [ ] , l , t , r ) .
.... but then the cost of moving up would not be o(1 ) .
this is an interesting predicate , because getting efficient behaviour in multiple modes is not just a matter of subgoal ordering . in the ( + , - ) mode
, it is acceptable to call ` split_children/5 ' , because that will be o(1 ) space and time per solution . in the ( -,+ ) mode ,
we must bypass that call .
if the code is encapsulated in a module and type checked , it is clear that the bypassed call must succeed , but that would not be obvious to a compiler .
queries in sgml and xml often ask for ( not necessarily adjacent ) preceding or following siblings of a node . testing
whether one node is a following sibling of another does not require mode - dependent code .
however , in order to prevent unbounded backtracking in the reverse direction , the code below uses the technique of passing a variable ( l2 ) twice : once for its value , and once so that its length can act as a depth bound . .... : - pred siblings_before_after(pointer(d ) , pointer(d ) ) .
siblings_before_after(ptr(t1,l1,r1,a ) , ptr(t2,l2,r2,a ) ) : - right_move([t1|l1 ] , r1 , l2 , [ t2|r2 ] , l2 ) .
: - pred right_move(list(t ) , list(t ) , list(t ) , list(t ) , list(t ) ) .
right_move(l , r , l , r , _ ) .
right_move(l1 , [ x|r1 ] , l2 , r2 , [ _ |b ] ) : - right_move([x|l1 ] , r1 , l2 , r2 , b ) .
.... moving from left to right , this costs @xmath0 per following sibling . moving from right to left , it costs @xmath1 per preceding sibling because the second clause builds up patterns of @xmath1 average length and the first clause unifies them against the known lists for each solution .
the ` left_right_star/2 ' predicate below fixes this using mode - dependent code .
i do not know whether @xmath0 cost per solution can be obtained with bidirectional code .
next we have transitive ( _ plus ) and reflexive transitive ( _ star ) closures of the basic predicates . once again
, we want to execute different code for the ( + , - ) and ( -,+ ) modes of the ` * _ plus/2 ' predicates . .... : - pred left_right_star(pointer(d ) , pointer(d ) ) .
left_right_star(l , r ) : - ( l = r ; left_right_plus(l , r ) ) .
: - pred left_right_plus(pointer(d ) , pointer(d ) ) .
left_right_plus(l , r ) : - ( var(l ) - > left_right(x , r ) , left_right_star(l , x ) ; left_right(l , x ) , left_right_star(x , r ) ) .
: - pred up_down_star(pointer(d ) , pointer(d ) ) .
up_down_star(a , d ) : - ( a = d ; up_down_plus(a , d ) ) .
: - pred up_down_plus(pointer(d ) , pointer(d ) ) .
up_down_plus(a , d ) : - ( var(a ) - > up_down(x , d ) , up_down_star(a , x ) ; up_down(a , x ) , up_down_star(x , d ) ) .
a simple benchmark is to build a large tree and traverse it . .... : - pred run .
run : - mk_tree(10 , t ) , time((direct_datum(t , x ) , atom(x ) ) ) , time((any_pointer_datum(t , x ) , atom(x ) ) ) , time(labels(t , _ ) ) , time(collect(t , _ ) ) .
: - pred mk_tree(integer , tree(integer ) ) .
mk_tree(d , node(d , c ) ) : - ( d > 0 - > d1 is d - 1 , c = [ t , t , t , t ] , mk_tree(d1 , t ) ; c = [ ] ) .
: - pred direct_datum(tree(d ) , d ) .
direct_datum(node(d , _ ) , d ) .
direct_datum(node(_,c ) , d ) : - member(n , c ) , direct_datum(n , d ) .
: - pred any_pointer_datum(tree(d ) , d ) .
any_pointer_datum(t , d ) : - top_pointer(t , p ) , up_down_star(p , n ) , pointer_datum(n , d ) .
: - pred labels(tree(d ) , list(d ) ) .
labels(tree , labels ) : - labels(tree , labels , [ ] ) .
: - pred labels(tree(d ) , list(d ) , list(d ) ) .
labels(node(label , children ) ) -- > [ label ] , labels_list(children ) .
: - pred labels_list(list(tree(d ) ) , list(d ) , list(d ) ) .
labels_list ( [ ] ) -- > [ ] . labels_list([tree|trees ] ) -- >
labels(tree ) , labels_list(trees ) . :
- pred collect(tree(d ) , list(d ) ) .
collect(tree , labels ) : - top_pointer(tree , ptr ) , collect(ptr , labels , [ ] ) .
: - pred collect(pointer(d ) , list(d ) , list(d ) ) .
collect(ptr , [ datum|labels1 ] , labels ) : - pointer_datum(ptr , datum ) , ( at_bottom(ptr ) - > labels1 = labels2 ; up_down_first(ptr , child ) , collect(child , labels1 , labels2 ) ) , ( at_right(ptr ) - > labels2 = labels ; left_right(ptr , sibling ) , collect(sibling , labels2 , labels ) ) . .... this builds a tree with 1,398,101 nodes , and traverses it using a backtracking search ( both directly and using `` fat pointers '' ) , and by building a list ( both directly and using `` fat pointers '' ) .
.traversal times in seconds , by methods and languages [ cols= " > , > , > , > ,
< " , ] table [ traversal - table ] shows the times for this benchmark , as measured on an 84 mhz sparcstation 5 .
the last two rows of table [ traversal - table ] refer to lazy functional languages : haskell ( ghc ) , and clean ( clm ) .
both of those compilers use whole - program analysis , inlining , and strong type information , unlike the incremental , direct , and untyped prolog compilers .
the first draft of this article included measurements for findall/3 .
they were horrifying .
this data structure is bad news for findall/3 and its relatives . to understand why ,
let s consider three queries : .... q1(p , l ) : - findall(q , p1(p , q ) , l ) .
q2(p , l ) : - findall(t , p2(p , t ) , l ) .
q3(p , l ) : - findall(d , p3(p , d ) , l ) .
p1(p , q ) : - up_down_star(p , q ) .
p2(p , t ) : - p1(p , q ) , q = ptr(t , _ ) .
p3(p , d ) : - p1(p , q ) , pointer_datum(q , d ) . .... for concreteness ,
suppose that p points to a complete binary tree with @xmath2 nodes , and that the node data are one - word constants .
query q3 requires @xmath1 space to hold the result .
query q2 requires @xmath3 space to hold the result .
this is because fragments of the tree are repeatedly copied .
query q1 requires at least @xmath4 space to hold the result .
every pointer holds the entire tree to simplify movement upwards , so the entire tree and its fragments are repeatedly copied .
if findall/3 copied terms using some kind of hash consing , the space cost could be reduced to @xmath1 , but not the time cost , because it would still be necessary to test whether a newly generated solution could share structure with existing ones .
one referee suggested that mercury s ` solutions/2 ' would be cleverer . a test in the 0.10 release showed that it is not yet clever enough .
this is related to the problem of costly pointer unification : a fat pointer contains the entire original tree and many of its fragments as well as the fragment it directly refers to .
but that is only a problem when you try to copy a fat pointer or unify it with something .
the ` siblings_before_after/2 ' predicate is efficient if one of the arguments is ground and the other uninstantiated . with two ground arguments ,
it is expensive , because because testing whether two fat pointers are the same fat pointer is expensive in this representation .
two fat pointers are the same if and only if they unify , but that may involve comparing the source tree with itself ( and its subtrees with themselves , perhaps repeatedly ) . after reading an earlier draft of this ,
thomas conway @xcite suggested a variant in which unifying fat pointers would be @xmath1 instead of @xmath4 .
i have not adopted his code , because it makes moving up take more time and turn over more memory .
he stores just enough of a parent to reconstruct it , given the child , instead of the entire parent .
conway s code is very nearly huet s zipper @xcite .
thomas conway @xcite has pointed out that it would be useful to form sets of ( pointers to ) nodes , and that fat pointers are not suitable for that because they are so costly to unify .
sets of nodes are required for the hytime query language and by other query languages , including xpath @xcite .
when one wants to form a set of subtrees , one might want a set of tree values , or a set of occurrences of tree values . using a pointer
forces you to work with occurrences rather than values , and that is not always appropriate .
the comparison of subtrees can be made more efficient by preprocessing the main tree so that every node contains a hash code calculated from its value .
preprocessing the main tree so that every node has a unique number would make pointer comparison fast too .
the ` pair ' type here is standard in mercury , tracing back to ` keysort/2 ' in dec-10 prolog . .... : - type ntree(d ) = tree(pair(integer , d ) ) .
: - type npointer(d ) = pointer(pair(integer , d ) ) .
: - pred number_tree(tree(d ) , ntree(d ) ) .
number_tree(tree , numbered ) : - number_tree(tree , numbered , 0 , _ ) .
: - pred number_tree(tree(d ) , ntree(d ) , integer , integer ) .
number_tree(node(datum , children ) , node(n0-datum , numberedchildren ) , n0 , n ) : - n1 is 1 + n0 , number_children(children , numberedchildren , n1 , n ) .
: - pred number_children(list(tree(d ) ) , list(ntree(d ) ) , integer , integer ) . number_children ( [ ] , [ ] , n , n ) .
number_children([c|cs ] , [ d|ds ] , n0 , n ) : - number_tree(c , d , n0 , n1 ) , number_children(cs , ds , n1 , n ) .
: - pred same_pointer(npointer(d ) , npointer(d ) ) .
same_pointer(p1 , p2 ) : - pointer_datum(p1 , n- _ ) , pointer_datum(p2 , n- _ ) .
: - pred compare_pointers(order , npointer(d ) , npointer(d ) ) .
compare_pointers(o , p1 , p2 ) : - pointer_datum(p1 , n1- _ ) , pointer_datum(p2 , n2-
_ ) , compare(o , n1 , n2 ) . ....
prolog , having no type classes , would require special purpose set operations for sets of fat pointers using this technique .
mercury , having type classes , would not require special code .
the data structure described in the previous section implements pointers that point at particular nodes in trees , may exist in large numbers , and may be stepped in any direction at o(1 ) cost .
it is useful for navigating around trees that are not to be changed .
if you are writing an editor , it is a blunder to try to point _ at _ nodes .
instead , it is advisable to point _ between _ nodes , as emacs does .
we need a different data structure , and different operations .
the real challenge , as huet understood well in @xcite , is to show that declarative languages can handle editing effectively .
the title of this article promised @xmath0 reversible navigation ; it did not promise @xmath0 reversible editing .
reversible editing is attainable , and so is @xmath0 editing .
my attempts to discover a data structure that supports @xmath0 reversible editing have so far failed . because these operations are not reversible
, i show input ( + ) and output ( - ) modes in the : - pred@xcite declarations . the normal way in prolog to `` change '' a node at depth @xmath5 in a tree is to build a new tree sharing as much as possible with the old one ; that takes @xmath6 time and space . the trick that permits @xmath0 cost edit operations is not to rebuild the new tree at once , but to interleave rebuilding with editing and navigation .
an ` edit_ptr ` records the subtrees to either side of the current position , whether the sequence at this level has been edited , and what the parent position was . to `` change '' trees ,
we need a new operation that creates a new node with the same information as an old one , except for a new list of children . .... : - pred tree_rebuild(+list(tree(d ) ) , + tree(d ) , -tree(d ) ) .
tree_rebuild(c , node(d , _ ) , node(d , c ) ) . .... the ` extract/2 ' predicate extracts the edited tree from an ` edit_ptr ` . since these predicates are not reversible , mode information is shown in the : -pred declarations .
.... : - type nlr(p ) --- > no_parent % this is the root ; left_parent(p ) % came down on the left ; right_parent(p ) .
% came down on the right .
: - type changed --- >
n ; y. : - type edit_ptr(d ) --- > edit_ptr(list(tree(d ) ) , list(tree(d ) ) , changed , nlr(edit_ptr(d ) ) ) .
.... an edit pointer contains a list of the nodes preceding the current position ( in near - to - far order ) , a list of the nodes following the current position ( in near - to - far order ) , a ` changed ' flag , and a parent pointer tagged so that we know whether we came down on the left or the right .
one of the differences between this data structure and the zipper @xcite is that the zipper builds new retained structure as it moves , while this data structure uses a ` changed ' flag to revert to the original structure if nothing has happened but movement . .... : - pred start(+tree(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
start(t , edit_ptr([],[t],n , no_parent ) ) .
: - pred at_top(+edit_ptr ( _ ) ) .
at_top(edit_ptr(_,_,_,no_parent ) ) . :
- pred at_left(+edit_ptr ( _ ) ) .
at_left(edit_ptr ( [ ] , _ , _ , _ ) ) .
: - pred left_datum(+edit_ptr(d ) , ?
left_datum(edit_ptr([t| _ ] , _ , _ , _ ) , d ) : - tree_datum(t , d ) .
: - pred left(+edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
left(edit_ptr([t|l],r , c , p ) , edit_ptr(l,[t|r],c , p ) ) .
: - pred left_insert(+tree(d ) , + edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
left_insert(t , edit_ptr(l , r,_,p ) , edit_ptr([t|l],r , y , p ) ) .
: - pred left_delete(-tree(d ) , + edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
left_delete(t , edit_ptr([t|l],r,_,p ) , edit_ptr(l , r , y , p ) ) . :
- pred left_replace(+tree(d ) , + edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
left_replace(t , edit_ptr([_|l],r,_,p ) , edit_ptr([t|l],r , y , p ) ) . : - pred left_down(+edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
left_down(p , edit_ptr([],k , n , left_parent(p ) ) ) : - p = edit_ptr([t| _ ] , _ , _ , _ ) , tree_children(t , k ) . : - pred left_promote_children(+edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
left_promote_children(edit_ptr([t|l],r,_,p ) , edit_ptr(l1,r , y , p ) ) : - tree_children(t , k ) , reverse_append(k , l , l1 ) .
: - pred reverse_append(+list(t ) , + list(t ) , -list(t ) ) .
reverse_append ( [ ] , r , r ) .
reverse_append([x|s ] , r0 , r ) : - reverse_append(s , [ x|r0 ] , r ) .
: - pred at_right(+edit_ptr ( _ ) ) .
at_right(edit_ptr ( _ , [ ] , _ , _ ) ) .
: - pred right_datum(+edit_ptr(d ) , -d ) .
right_datum(edit_ptr(_,[t| _ ] , _ , _ ) , d ) : - tree_datum(t , d ) .
: - pred right(+edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
right(edit_ptr(l,[t|r],c , p ) , edit_ptr([t|l],r , c , p ) ) .
: - pred right_insert(+tree(d ) , + edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
right_insert(t , edit_ptr(l , r,_,p ) , edit_ptr(l,[t|r],y , p ) ) .
: - pred right_delete(-tree(d ) , + edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
right_delete(t , edit_ptr(l,[t|r],_,p ) , edit_ptr(l , r , y , p ) ) .
: - pred right_replace(+tree(d ) , + edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
right_replace(t , edit_ptr(l,[_|r],_,p ) , edit_ptr(l,[t|r],y , p ) ) .
: - pred right_down(+edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
right_down(p , edit_ptr([],k , n ,
right_parent(p ) ) ) : - p = edit_ptr(_,[t| _ ] , _ , _ ) , tree_children(t , k ) .
: - pred right_promote_children(+edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
right_promote_children(edit_ptr(l,[t|r],_,p ) , edit_ptr(l , r1,y , p ) ) : - tree_children(t , k ) , append(k , r , r1 ) .
: - pred up(+edit_ptr(d ) , -edit_ptr(d ) ) .
up(edit_ptr(_,_,n , left_parent(p ) ) , p ) .
up(edit_ptr(_,_,n , right_parent(p ) ) , p ) .
up(edit_ptr(x , y , y , left_parent(edit_ptr([t|l],r,_,p ) ) ) , edit_ptr([n|l],r , y , p ) ) : - reverse_append(x , y , k ) , tree_rebuild(k , t , n ) .
up(edit_ptr(x , y , y , right_parent(edit_ptr(l,[t|r],_,p ) ) ) , edit_ptr(l,[n|r],y , p ) ) : - reverse_append(x , y , k ) , tree_rebuild(k , t , n ) .
: - pred extract(+edit_ptr(d ) , -tree(d ) ) .
extract(edit_ptr(_,[t|_],_,no_parent ) , tree ) : - ! , tree = t. extract(p , tree ) : - up(p , p1 ) , extract(p1 , tree ) . ....
it is easy to see that each of these operations except ` up ' and ` extract ' requires @xmath0 time and @xmath0 space , assuming that ` tree_children ' is @xmath0 .
moving ` up ' from a position with @xmath7 nodes to its left takes @xmath1 time and space , but that position must have been reached by a minimum of @xmath7 ` right/2 ' and/or ` left_insert/3 ' operations , so in the single - threaded case all the basic operations are @xmath0 amortised time and space .
essentially , because the editing operations destroy information . we can easily reverse the operations `` move right '' or `` move down '' , because the only thing that has changed is the position , and the name of the predicate tells us what the old position must have been .
suppose , however , we tried to make insertion and deletion the same operation : .... : - pred indel_right(d , edit_ptr(d ) , edit_ptr(d ) ) .
indel_right(t , edit_ptr(l , r , fs , p ) , edit_ptr(l,[t|r],fw , p ) ) : - ?
.... we would not know how to define fs and fw .
the edit_pointer data structure may not have reversible operations , but it is a persistent data structure , so that an editor using it can easily support unbounded undo .
imagine an application to html , where we might have .... : - type html_info --- > element(atom , list(pair(atom , string ) ) ) ; pcdata(string ) .
: - type html_tree = = tree(html_info ) .
.... the ` < font > ` tag is almost always misused , and is not allowed in `` strict '' html4 or xhtml .
so we might want to replace every ` < font > ` element by its contents . .... : - pred unfont(+html_tree , -html_tree ) .
unfont(html0 , html ) : - start(html0 , ptr0 ) , unfont_loop(ptr0 , ptr ) , extract(ptr , html ) .
: - pred unfont_loop(+edit_ptr(html_info ) , -edit_ptr(html_info ) ) .
unfont_loop(p0 , p ) : - ( at_right(p0 )
- > p = p0 ; right_datum(p0 , element(font , _ ) ) - > right_promote_children(p0 , p1 ) , unfont_loop(p1 , p ) ; right_down(p0 , p1 ) , unfont_loop(p1 , p2 ) , up(p2 , p3 ) , right(p3 , p4 ) , unfont_loop(p4 , p ) ) . ....
we do nt need cyclic links or mutable objects in declarative languages to support efficient multiway traversal and editing of trees , including models of xml . 4 conway , t. , ( 2000 ) . private communication .
huet , g. ( 1997 ) .
functional pearl : `` the zipper '' , _ j. functional programming _ * 7 * ( 5 ) : pp .
549554 , september 1997 .
mycroft , a. and okeefe , r. a. ( 1984 ) a polymorphic type system for prolog .
_ artificial intelligence _ , vol.23 , pp295307 .
okeefe , r. ( 2000 ) .
`` lifting the curse of dom '' , submitted for publication .
somogyi , z. , henderson , f. , and conway , t. ( 1995 ) .
`` mercury : + an efficient purely declarative logic programming language '' , in _ proceedings of the australian computer science conference _ , glenelg , australia ,
february 1995 , pp 499512 .
http://www.cs.mu.oz.au/mercury/ has this and other mercury papers .
world wide web consortium ( 1998 )
. `` document object model level 1 recommendation '' .
url : ` http://www.w3.org/tr/rec-dom-level-1/ ` world wide web consortium ( 1999 ) .
`` xml path language ( xpath ) version 1.0 '' .
url : ` http://www.w3.org/tr/xpath/ ` world wide web consortium ( 2000 ) .
`` document object model level 2 recommendation '' , november 2000 .
url : ` http://www.w3.org/tr/rec-dom-level-2/ ` | imperative programmers often use cyclically linked trees in order to achieve o(1 ) navigation time to neighbours .
some logic programmers believe that cyclic terms are necessary to achieve the same in logic - based languages .
an old but little - known technique provides o(1 ) time and space navigation without cyclic links , in the form of reversible predicates .
a small modification provides o(1 ) amortised time and space editing .
[ firstpage ] |
as hetnet provides flexible and efficient topology to boost spectral efficiency , it has recently aroused immense interest in both academia and industry . as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : hetnet_2tiers ] , a hetnet consists of a diverse set of regular macro base stations ( bs ) overlaid with low power pico bss .
since this overlaid structure may lead to severe interference problem , it is extremely critical to control interference via rrm in hetnet .
there has been much research conducted on rrm optimization for traditional cellular networks . in @xcite ,
the authors considered power and user scheduling in single - carrier cellular networks . in @xcite ,
the game theoretical approaches are proposed for distributed resource allocation . in @xcite , the authors proposed a dynamic fractional frequency reuse scheme to combat the inter - sector interference under a game - based optimization by each sector .
the coordinated multipoint transmission ( comp ) @xcite is another important technique to handle the inter - cell interference .
for example , in @xcite , the authors exploited the uplink - downlink duality to do joint optimization of power allocation and beamforming vectors . in @xcite ,
a wmmse algorithm is proposed to find a stationary point of the weighted sum - rate maximization problem for multi - cell downlink systems .
while the above algorithms achieve comparably good performance , they require global channel state information ( csi ) for centralized implementation @xcite or over - the - air iterations and global message passing for distributed implementation @xcite .
it is quite controversial whether comp is effective or not in lte systems due to large signaling overhead , signaling latency , inaccurate csit , and the complexity of the algorithm . on the other hand ,
solutions for traditional cellular networks can not be applied directly to hetnet due to the unique difference in hetnet topology .
first , the inter - cell interference in hetnet is more complicated , e.g. , there is _ co - tier interference _ among the pico bss and among the macro bss as well as the _ cross - tier interference _ between the macro and pico bss .
furthermore , due to load balancing , some of the mobiles in hetnet may be assigned to a pico bs which is not the strongest bs @xcite and the mobiles in the pico cell may suffer from strong interference from the macro bss . to solve these problems , some eicic techniques , such as the abs control @xcite ,
have been proposed in lte and lte - a @xcite . in @xcite ,
the authors analyzed the performance for abs in hetnet under different cell range extension ( re ) biases .
however , they focused on numerical analysis for the existing heuristic eicic schemes , which are the baselines of this paper .
in @xcite , the authors proposed an algorithm for victim pico user partition and optimal synchronous abs rate selection .
however , they used a universal abs rate for the whole network , and as a result , their scheme could not adapt to dynamic network loading for different macro cells . in this paper , we focus on the resource optimization in the downlink of a hetnet without comp .
we consider _ dynamic abrb _ for interference control and dynamic user scheduling to exploit _ multi - user diversity_. the abrb is similar to the abs but it is scheduled over both time and frequency domain .
unlike @xcite , we do not restrict the abrb rate to be the same for all macro bss and thus a better performance can be achieved .
however , this also causes several new technical challenges as elaborated below . * * exponential complexity for dynamic abrb : * optimization of abrb patterns is challenging due to the combinatorial nature and exponentially large solution space .
for example , in a hetnet with @xmath0 macro bss , there are @xmath1 different abrb pattern combinations . hence , brute force solutions are highly undesirable . * * complex interactions between dynamic user scheduling and dynamic abrb * : there is complex coupling between the dynamic user scheduling and abrb control .
for instance , the abrb pattern will affect the user sets eligible for user scheduling .
furthermore , the optimization objective of abrb control depends on user scheduling policy and there is no closed form characterization . * * challenges in rrm architecture : * most existing solutions for resource optimization of hetnet requires global knowledge of csi and centralized implementations . yet ,
such designs are not scalable for large networks and they are not robust with respect to ( w.r.t . )
latency in backhaul . to address the above challenges ,
we propose a two timescale control structure where the long term controls , such as dynamic abrb , are adaptive to the large scale fading . on the other hand ,
the short term control , such as the user scheduling , is adaptive to the local csi within a pico / macro bs .
such a multi - timescale structure allows _ hierarchical rrm _ design , where the long term control decisions can be implemented on a rrm server for inter - cell interference coordination .
the short - term control decisions can be done locally at each bs with only local csi .
such design has the advantages of low signaling overhead , good scalability , and robustness w.r.t .
latency of backhaul signaling . while there are previous works on two timescale rrm @xcite , those approaches are heuristic ( i.e. the rrm algorithms are not coming from a single optimization problem ) .
our contribution in this paper is a formal study of two timescale rrm algorithms for hetnet based on optimization theory . to overcome the exponential complexity for abrb control
, we exploit the sparsity in the _ interference graph _ of the hetnet topology and derive structural properties for the optimal abrb control .
based on that , we propose a _ two timescale alternative optimization _
solution for user scheduling and abrb control .
the algorithm has low complexity and is asymptotically optimal at high snr .
simulations show that the proposed solution has significant performance gain over various baselines .
_ notations _ : let @xmath2 denote the indication function such that @xmath3 if the event @xmath4 is true and @xmath5 otherwise .
for a set @xmath6 , @xmath7 denotes the cardinality of @xmath6 .
consider the downlink of a two - tier hetnet as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : hetnet_2tiers ]
. there are @xmath0 macro bss , @xmath8 pico bss , and @xmath9 users , sharing @xmath10 ofdm subbands .
denote the set of the macro bss as @xmath11 , and denote the set of the pico bss as @xmath12 . a two - tier heterogeneous network with macro and pico base stations , width=332 ] the hetnet topology ( i.e. , the network connectivity and csi of each link ) is represented by a topology graph as defined below .
[ hetnet topology graph]define the _ topology graph _ of the hetnet as a bipartite graph @xmath13 , where @xmath14 denotes the set of all macro and pico bs nodes , @xmath15 denotes the set of all user nodes , and @xmath16 is the set of all edges between the bss and users .
an edge @xmath17 between bs node @xmath18 and user node @xmath19 represents a wireless link between them .
each edge @xmath17 is associated with a csi label @xmath20 , where @xmath21 represents the channel coefficient between bs @xmath22 and user @xmath23 on subband @xmath24 . for each bs
node @xmath22 , let @xmath25 denote the set of associated users . for each user
node @xmath23 , define @xmath26 as the set of neighbor macro bss and @xmath27 as the set of neighbor pico bss . in the topology graph
, @xmath28 means that the path gain between user @xmath23 and bs @xmath22 is sufficiently small compared to the direct link path gain , and thus the interference from bs @xmath22 will have negligible effect on the data rate of user @xmath23 .
we have the following assumption on the channel fading process @xmath29 .
[ asm : fory]the channel fading coefficient has a two timescale structure given by @xmath30 .
the small scale fading process @xmath31 is identically distributed w.r.t .
the subframe and subband indices ( @xmath32 ) , and it is i.i.d .
user and bs indices ( @xmath33 ) .
moreover , for given @xmath34 , @xmath31 is a continuous random variable .
the large scale fading process @xmath35 is assumed to be a slow ergodic process ( i.e. , @xmath36 remains constant for several _ _ super - frames _ _ subframes ] . ) according to a general distribution .
the two timescale fading model has been adopted in many standard channel models .
the large scale fading @xmath36 is usually caused by path loss and shadow fading , which changes much slowly compared to the small scale fading .
we consider the following _ biased cell selection _ mechanism to balance the loading between macro and pico bss @xcite .
let @xmath37 denote the serving bs of user @xmath23 .
let @xmath38 denote the cell selection bias and let @xmath39 denote the transmit power of bs @xmath22 on a single sub - band .
let @xmath40 and @xmath41 respectively be the strongest macro bs and pico bs for user @xmath23 . if @xmath42 , user @xmath23 will be associated to pico cell @xmath43 , i.e. , @xmath44 ; otherwise @xmath45 .
if a user only has a single edge with its serving bs , it will not receive inter - cell interference from other bss and thus its performance is noise limited ; otherwise , it will suffer from strong inter - cell interference if any of its neighbor bss is transmitting data and thus its performance is interference limited .
this insight is useful in the control algorithm design later and it is convenient to formally define the interference and noise limited users . [
interference / noise limited user][def : inuser]if a user @xmath23 has a single edge with its serving bs @xmath37 only , i.e. , @xmath46 , then it is called a _ noise limited user _ (
n - user ) ; otherwise , it is called an _ interference limited user _ ( i - user ) . fig .
[ fig : abs_intro ] illustrates an example of the hetnet topology graph . in fig .
[ fig : abs_intro](a ) , an arrow from a bs to a user indicates a direct link and the dash circle indicates the coverage area of each bs .
an i - user which lies in the coverage area of a macro bs is connected to this macro bs , while a n - user does not have connections with the neighbor macro bss in the topology graph as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : abs_intro](b ) .
we consider a two timescale hierarchical rrm control structure where the control variables are partitioned into _ long - term _ and _ short - term _ control variables .
the long - term control variables are adaptive to the large scale fading @xmath47 and they are implemented at the radio resource management server ( rrms ) .
the short - term control variables are adaptive to the instantaneous csi @xmath48 and they are implemented locally at each macro / pico bs .
abs is introduced in lte systems @xcite for interference mitigation among control channels in hetnet .
it can also be used to control the _ co - tier _ and _ cross - tier interference _ among the data channels . in lte systems ,
abs is only scheduled over time domain . in this paper
, we consider dynamic abrb control for interference coordination .
the abrb is similar to abs but it is scheduled over both time and frequency domain . it is a generalization of abs and enables more fine - grained resource allocation .
when an abrb is scheduled in a macro bs , a rb with blank payload will be transmitted at a given frequency and time slice and this eliminates the interference from this macro bs to the pico bss and the adjacent macro bss .
hence , as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : abs_intro ] , scheduling abrb over both time and frequency domain allows us to control both the _ macro - macro _ bs and _ macro - pico _ bs interference .
we want to control the abrb dynamically w.r.t .
the large scale fading because the optimal abrb pattern depends on the hetnet topology graph .
for example , when there are a lot of pico cell i - users , we should allocate more abrbs at the macro bs to support more pico cell i - users . on the other hand , when there are only a few pico cell i - users
, we should allocate less abrbs to improve the spatial spectrum efficiency .
for any given subframe , define @xmath49 to indicate if abrb is scheduled ( @xmath50 ) for subband @xmath24 at macro bs @xmath22 .
let @xmath51^{t}\in\mathcal{a}$ ] be the abrb pattern vector for subband @xmath24 and @xmath52 is the set of all possible abrb patterns macro bss can either schedule an abrb or not for the @xmath53-th rb ( i.e. , subframe @xmath54 and subband @xmath24 ) , there are @xmath1 possible abrb patterns . hence , the size of @xmath52 is @xmath1 . ] . in the proposed dynamic abrb control , each macro bs
is allowed to dynamically change the ratio of abrb transmission on each subband and this ratio can be any positive real number . to facilitate implementation , we consider randomized abrb control policy as defined below .
[ randomized abrb control policy ] an abrb control policy of the @xmath24-th subband @xmath55 is a mapping from the abrb pattern space @xmath52 to a probability in [ 0,1 ] . at any subframe ,
the instantaneous abrb pattern vector for subband @xmath24 is stochastically determined according to the probabilities @xmath56 , where @xmath57 denote the probability that the @xmath58 subband is in abrb pattern @xmath59 . to facilitate structural abrb design
, we partition the users into two types .
[ partitioning of user set][def : user - set - partition ] the mobile user set is partitioned into two subsets @xmath60 , where @xmath61 denotes the set of _ type a users _ and is defined as @xmath62 and @xmath63 denotes the set of _ type b users_. the type a users include all pico cell users and macro cell n - users , while the type b users include all macro cell i - users . for type a users , it will not lose optimality by imposing a _
synchronous abrb structure _ where the transmissions of the abrb at all macro bss are aligned as much as possible . the formal definition of the synchronous abrb structure is given in theorem [ thm : absreduce ] .
as will be shown in theorem [ thm : absreduce ] , if there is only type a users , imposing the synchronous abrb structure can dramatically reduce the number of abrb control variables from exponential large ( @xmath1 ) to only @xmath0 and this complex reduction is achieved without loss of optimality .
on contrast , the performance of the macro cell i - users is very poor under the synchronous abrb structure because aligning the data transmissions of all macro bss will cause strong inter - cell interference for macro cell i - users .
motivated by these observations , we partition the @xmath10 subbands into two groups , namely @xmath64 and @xmath65 , and use different abrb control policies for type a and type b users on these two groups of subbands respectively .
the variable @xmath66 controls the fraction of _ type a _ subbands . at each subframe , each bs @xmath22 dynamically selects a user from @xmath25 for each subband @xmath24 based on the knowledge of current abrb pattern @xmath59 and channel realization @xmath67 to exploit _ multi - user diversity_. let @xmath68 be the user scheduling variable ( of user @xmath23 at bs @xmath37 ) of subband @xmath24 and @xmath69 $ ] be the associated vectorized variable .
the set of all feasible user scheduling vectors at bs @xmath22 for the @xmath24-th subbands with abrb pattern @xmath59 is given by @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the set of users that can not be scheduled on a type a subband under abrb pattern @xmath59 ; and @xmath72 .
the physical meaning of @xmath73 is elaborated below .
first , if a macro bs is transmitting abrb , none of its associated users can be scheduled for transmission . moreover , due to large cross - tier interference from macro bss , a pico cell i - user can not be scheduled for transmission if any of its neighbor macro bss @xmath74 is transmitting data subframe ( i.e. , @xmath75 ) .
as will be seen in section [ sub : structural - properties - ofpa ] , explicitly imposing this user scheduling constraint for the pico cell i - users is useful for the structural abrb design .
the user scheduling policy @xmath76 of the @xmath24-th sub - band is defined below .
[ user scheduling policy][def : randomized - user - scheduling ] a user scheduling policy of the @xmath22-th bs and @xmath24-th sub - band @xmath77 is a mapping : @xmath78 , where @xmath79 is the csi space .
specifically , under the abrb pattern @xmath59 and csi realization @xmath67 , the user scheduling vector of bs @xmath22 is given by @xmath80 .
let @xmath81 denote the overall user scheduling policy on sub - band @xmath24 .
assuming perfect csi at the receiver ( csir ) and treating interference as noise , the instantaneous data rate of user @xmath23 is given by : @xmath82 where @xmath83 , @xmath84 ; @xmath85 is the mutual information of user @xmath23 contributed by the @xmath24-th subband ; and @xmath86 is the interference - plus - noise power at user @xmath23 on subband @xmath24 . for a given policy @xmath87 and large scale fading state @xmath88 ,
the average data rate of user @xmath23 is given by : @xmath89=\sum_{m\in\mathcal{m}\left(k\right)}\overline{\mathcal{i}}_{m , k}\left(q_{m},\pi_{m}\right),\ ] ] where the average mutual information on subband @xmath24 is @xmath90 and @xmath91 $ ] .
for conciseness , the abrb pattern @xmath59 for a specific subband @xmath24 is denoted as @xmath92 $ ] when there is no ambiguity .
the performance of the hetnet is characterized by a utility function @xmath93 , where @xmath94 $ ] is the average rate vector .
we make the following assumptions on @xmath93 .
[ asm : ufun]the utility function can be expressed as @xmath95 , where @xmath96 is the weight for user @xmath23 , @xmath97 is assumed to be a concave and increasing function . moreover , for any @xmath98 such that @xmath99 and @xmath100 belongs to the domain of @xmath97 , @xmath101 satisfies @xmath102 where @xmath103 and @xmath104 are some scalar functions of @xmath105 .
the above assumption is imposed to facilitate the problem decomposition in section [ sub : problem - decomposition ] .
this utility function captures a lot of interesting cases below . *
* weighted sum throughput : * the utility function is @xmath106 . * * @xmath107-fair @xcite : * @xmath107-fair can be used to compromise between the fairness to users and the utilization of resources .
the utility function is * * @xmath108 * * proportional fair @xcite : * this is a special case of @xmath107-fair when @xmath109 . due to the statistical symmetry of the @xmath10 subbands ,
there is no loss of optimality to consider symmetric policy @xmath110 , where @xmath111 ( @xmath112 ) and @xmath113 ( @xmath114 ) if @xmath115 ( @xmath65 ) .
[ optimality of symmetric policy][lem : optimality - of - symmetric]there exists a symmetric policy @xmath116 such that it is the optimal solution of the following optimization problem : @xmath117 please refer to appendix [ proof - of - lemma symp ] for the proof . moreover , we have @xmath118 and @xmath119 . as a result , the utility function under a symmetric policy @xmath120 can be expressed as : @xmath121 where @xmath122 , @xmath123 , and @xmath124 ( @xmath125 ) can be any type a ( type b ) subband .
finally , for a given hetnet topology graph @xmath13 , the two timescale rrm optimization is given by : @xmath126 where ( [ eq : qeccon1a ] ) and ( [ eq : qeccon2a ] ) ensure that @xmath127 and @xmath128 satisfy the definition of probability mass function ( pmf ) .
using primal decomposition , problem @xmath129 can be decomposed into the following subproblems . *
subproblem a * ( * cross - tier interference control * ) : optimization of abrb @xmath130 and user scheduling @xmath131 . @xmath132 * subproblem b * ( * co - tier interference control * ) : * * optimization of abrb @xmath112 and user scheduling @xmath114 .
@xmath133 * subproblem c * ( * subband partitioning * ) : optimization of subband partitioning @xmath134 . @xmath135 note that the solution of @xmath136/@xmath137 is independent of the value of @xmath134 because both @xmath138 and @xmath139 are independent of @xmath134 . after solving @xmath136 and @xmath137 ,
the optimal @xmath134 can be easily solved by bisection search . on the other hand ,
the optimization of @xmath131/@xmath114 is a stochastic optimization problem because the @xmath140/@xmath141 involves stochastic expectation over csi realizations and they do not have closed form characterization .
furthermore , the number of abrb control variables in @xmath136/@xmath137 is exponential w.r.t . the number of macro bss @xmath0 .
we shall tackle these challenges in section [ sec : solution - of - pa ] and [ sub : solution - of - subproblempb ] .
in this section , we first derive structural properties of @xmath136 and reformulate @xmath136 into a simpler form with reduced solution space .
then , we develop an efficient algorithm for @xmath136 . we require the following assumption to derive the results in this section . [
asm : picoiedge]for any @xmath142 , let @xmath143 denote the set of all pico cell i - users in pico cell @xmath22 .
then we have @xmath144 and define @xmath145 as the set of neighbor macro bss of pico cell @xmath22 .
the above assumption states that a macro bs will interfere with all the i - users in a pico cell as long as it interferes with any user in the pico cell .
this is reasonable since the coverage area of a macro bs is much larger than that of a pico bs .
we exploit the interference structure in the hetnet topology @xmath146 to derive the structural properties of @xmath136 . throughout this section
, we will use the following example problem to illustrate the intuition behind the main results .
[ exm - problema]consider @xmath147 for the hetnet in fig .
[ fig : abs_intro ] with @xmath148 macro bss and @xmath149 pico bs .
the set of type a users is @xmath150 and the objective function is specified as @xmath151 ( i.e. , we consider sum - rate utility ) . for illustration ,
we focus on the case when the marginal probability that a macro bs is transmitting abrb is transmitting abrb is @xmath152 . ]
is fixed as @xmath153^{t}=[0.7,0.5]^{t}$ ] .
define two sets of abrb patterns @xmath154 and @xmath155 for each bs @xmath22 . for macro bs , @xmath154 is the set of abrb patterns under which macro bs @xmath22 is transmitting data .
for pico bs , @xmath154 is the set of abrb patterns under which all of its neighbor macro bss is transmitting abrb . using the configuration in example [ exm - problema ] , we have @xmath156,\left[1,1\right]\right\ } $ ] , @xmath157,\left[1,1\right]\right\ } $ ] and @xmath158,\left[1,0\right]\right\ } $ ] ( the formal definition of @xmath154 and @xmath159 for general cases is in appendix [ sub : spageneral ] ) . in observation
[ clm : effect - of - abrb - mi ] , we find that the abrb pattern @xmath160 only affects the data rate of a type a user in cell @xmath22 by whether @xmath161 or not . based on that , we find that the policy space for both the abrb control @xmath130 and user scheduling @xmath131 can be significantly reduced in observation [ clm : qareduction ] and [ clm : policy - space - reductionpia ] . while these observations are made for the specific configuration in example [ exm - problema ] , they are also correct for general configurations and are formally stated in lemma [ lem : sysman ] , theorem [ thm : absreduce ] and theorem [ thm : policy - space - reductionpia ] in appendix [ sub : spageneral ] . finally , using the above results , we transform the complicated problem @xmath136 to a much simpler problem with @xmath162 as the optimization variables .
[ clm : effect - of - abrb - mi]for given csi @xmath163 and a feasible user scheduling vector @xmath164 , the mutual information @xmath165 of a type a user @xmath23 in cell @xmath22 only depends on whether the abrb pattern @xmath161 or not , i.e. , @xmath166,@xmath167 ( or @xmath168 )
. moreover , we have @xmath169 for any @xmath170 .
let us illustrate the above observation using the configuration in example [ exm - problema ] .
there are 4 type a users : @xmath150 . for user 1 in macro cell 1
( n - user ) , it is scheduled for transmission whenever macro bs 1 is not transmitting abrb ( i.e. , @xmath171 ) .
hence the mutual information is @xmath172 , which only depends on whether @xmath171 ( i.e. , @xmath173 ) or not .
moreover , the mutual information is higher if @xmath173 because @xmath174 . for user 4 in pico cell 3 ( i - user ) , if @xmath175 , its neighbor macro bs 2 is transmitting abrb and the mutual information is @xmath176 ; otherwise ( @xmath177 ) , macro bs 2 is transmitting data and we have @xmath178 and @xmath179 .
similar observations can be made for user 2 and 3 .
based on observation [ clm : effect - of - abrb - mi ] , the abrb control policy space can be significantly reduced .
[ clm : qareduction]consider @xmath147 for the configuration in example [ exm - problema ] .
the optimal abrb control of @xmath147 conditioned on a given marginal probability vector @xmath180^{t}$ ] , denoted by @xmath181 , has the _ _ synchronous abrb structure__. ] where the transmissions of abrb at the macro bss are aligned as much as possible . as a result , there are only @xmath182 active abrb patterns @xmath183,[0,1],[1,1]\right\ } $ ] and the corresponding pmf @xmath184 is given by a function of @xmath185 as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : abs_reduction ] .
illustration of the structure of the optimal @xmath186 conditioned on a given @xmath185,width=332 ] in general , for a hetnet with @xmath0 macro bss , there are only @xmath187 active abrb patterns under synchronous abrb structure , which is significantly smaller than the number of all possible abrb patterns @xmath1 . as a result , the optimization @xmath147
w.r.t @xmath130 ( with @xmath1 variables ) can be reduced to an equivalent optimization w.r.t . @xmath185
( with @xmath0 variables ) with much lower dimensions .
observation [ clm : qareduction ] can be understood as follows . by observation [ clm :
effect - of - abrb - mi ] , a higher average mutual information can be achieved for user @xmath188 under the abrb patterns @xmath161 .
hence , for given marginal probabilities @xmath180^{t}$ ] , the average mutual information region will be maximized if we can simultaneously maximize @xmath189 for all bss @xmath190 . for macro bss @xmath191 , we have @xmath192 , which is fixed for given @xmath185 . for pico bss @xmath193 , we have @xmath194 , and the equality holds if and only if @xmath130 has the synchronous abrb structure in fig .
[ fig : abs_reduction ] .
similarly , we can reduce the user scheduling policy space using observation [ clm : effect - of - abrb - mi ] .
[ clm : policy - space - reductionpia]consider @xmath147 for the configuration in example [ exm - problema ] . for given csi @xmath163 and abrb pattern @xmath160 ,
the optimal user scheduling at bs @xmath22 is given by @xmath195 by observation [ clm : effect - of - abrb - mi ] , if @xmath196 solves the maximization problem ( [ eq : argmaxruo ] ) for certain @xmath161 , it solves ( [ eq : argmaxruo ] ) for all @xmath161 .
hence , it will not loss optimality by imposing an additional constraint on the user scheduling such that @xmath197 ( or @xmath168 ) . for convenience ,
let @xmath198 denote the set of all feasible user scheduling policies satisfying the above constraint in observation [ clm : policy - space - reductionpia ] ( the formal definition of @xmath198 is given in theorem [ thm : policy - space - reductionpia ] ) .
then for given @xmath185 , @xmath199 and under the synchronous abrb , the corresponding objective function of @xmath136 can be rewritten as @xmath200 , where @xmath201 and @xmath202 is the corresponding average mutual information given in ( [ eq : ibarak ] ) of appendix [ sub : spageneral ] . as a result
, the subproblem @xmath147 can be transformed into a simpler problem with @xmath203 solution space .
[ equivalent problem transformation of @xmath147][cor : equivalent - problem - pa]let @xmath205 denote the optimal solution of the following joint optimization problem .
@xmath206 where @xmath207,\forall j\right\ } $ ] .
then @xmath208 , @xmath209 is the optimal solution of problem @xmath147 .
furthermore , problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) is a bi - convex problem , i.e. , for fixed @xmath131 , problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) is convex w.r.t .
@xmath185 , and for fixed @xmath185 , problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) is also convex w.r.t . @xmath131 .
please refer to appendix [ sub : proof - of - corollaypa ] for the proof . by corollary [ cor : equivalent - problem - pa ] , we only need to solve the equivalent problem of @xmath136 in ( [ eq : plare ] ) .
since problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) is bi - convex , we propose the following _ two timescale alternating optimization ( ao ) _ algorithm . for notation convenience , time index @xmath54 and @xmath210
are used to denote the subframe index and super - frame index respectively , where a super - frame consists of @xmath211 subframes .
_ algorithm ao_a _ ( two timescale ao for @xmath147 ) : * * initialization * * : choose proper initial @xmath212,@xmath213 . set @xmath214 . * * step 1 * * ( short timescale user scheduling optimization ) : for fixed @xmath215 , let @xmath216 , where @xmath217 is given by @xmath218 where @xmath219 is the average data rate of user @xmath23 under @xmath215 and user scheduling policy @xmath220 . for each subframe
@xmath221 $ ] , the user scheduling vector of bs @xmath22 is given by @xmath222 , where @xmath163 and @xmath223 are the csi and abrb pattern at the @xmath54-th subframe .
* step 2 * ( long timescale abrb optimization ) : * * find the optimal solution @xmath224 of problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) under fixed @xmath220 using e.g. , ellipsoid method .
let @xmath225 .
* * return to step 1 until @xmath226 * * or the maximum number of iterations is reached . while ( [ eq : plare ] ) is a bi - convex problem and ao algorithm
is known to converge to local optimal solutions only , we exploit the hidden convexity of the problem and show below that algorithm ao_a can converge to the global optimal solution under certain conditions .
[ global convergence of algorithm ao_a][thm : global - convergence - la]let @xmath227=\mathcal{f}\left(\left[\mathbf{q}_{a}^{(t)},\pi_{a}^{(t-1)}\right]\right)$ ] denote the iterate sequence of algorithm ao_a began at @xmath228 , and denote the set of fixed points of the mapping @xmath229 as @xmath230\right.$ ] @xmath231\right)\right\ } $ ] . for
any @xmath232 that is not a fixed point of @xmath229 , assume that @xmath233 , where @xmath234=\mathcal{f}\left(\left[\mathbf{q}_{a},\pi_{a}\right]\right)$ ] .
then : 1 .
algorithm ao_a converges to a fixed point @xmath235\in\delta$ ] of @xmath229 .
any fixed point @xmath235\in\delta$ ] is a globally optimal solution of problem ( [ eq : plare ] )
. please refer to appendix [ sub : proof - of - theoremla ] for the proof .
step 1 of algorithm ao_a requires the knowledge of the average data rate @xmath236 under @xmath215 and @xmath220 .
we adopt a reasonable approximation on @xmath236 using a moving average data rate @xmath237 $ ] given by @xcite @xmath238 where @xmath239 is the data rate delivered to user @xmath23 at subframe @xmath54 .
if we replace @xmath236 in step 1 of algorithm ao_a with the approximation @xmath240 in ( [ eq : rbarappr ] ) , the global convergence result in theorem [ thm : global - convergence - la ] no longer holds .
however , it has been shown in @xcite that @xmath240 converges to @xmath236 as @xmath241 . hence , with the approximation @xmath240 , algorithm ao_a is still asymptotically optimal for large super frame length @xmath211 . in step 2 of algorithm ao_a ,
the average mutual information @xmath242 in the optimization objective contains two intermediate problem parameters @xmath243 and @xmath244 defined under ( [ eq : ibarak ] ) in appendix [ sub : spageneral ] .
the calculation of @xmath243 s and @xmath244 s requires the knowledge of the distribution of all the channel coefficients , which is usually difficult to obtain offline .
however , these terms can be easily estimated online using the time average of the sampled data rates delivered to user @xmath23 under abrb patterns @xmath245 and @xmath246 respectively . the abrb control @xmath224 is then obtained by solving the long timescale problem in step 2 with say , the ellipsoid method based on these estimates .
the number of abrb control variables @xmath247 is exponentially large w.r.t . @xmath0 . to simplify @xmath137
, we introduce an auxiliary variable called the _ abrb profile _ and decompose @xmath137 .
we first define the abrb profile .
[ abrb profile ] the abrb profile @xmath248 is a subset of abrb patterns for type b subbands . using the notion of abrb profile and primal decomposition , @xmath249 can be approximated by two subproblems : * optimization of @xmath112 and @xmath114 for a given abrb profile @xmath250 .
* @xmath251 * optimization of abrb profile @xmath250 . * @xmath252 in @xmath253 , we restrict the size of @xmath250 to be no more than @xmath254 . in appendix
[ sub : proof - of - theoremequpb ] , we prove that at the asymptotically optimal solution of @xmath249 as snr becomes high , the number of active abrb patterns is indeed less than or equal to @xmath254 .
let @xmath256 denote the @xmath257 abrb pattern in @xmath250 .
then the average mutual information @xmath141 can be rewritten as @xmath258 where @xmath259 $ ] with @xmath260 denoting the probability that the abrb pattern @xmath256 is used .
hence @xmath261 can be reformulated as @xmath262 similar to ( [ eq : plare ] ) , we propose a two timescale ao to solve for problem ( [ eq : plbequ ] ) w.r.t . @xmath114 and @xmath263 .
_ algorithm ao_b _ ( two timescale ao for @xmath261 ) : * * initialization * * : choose proper initial @xmath264,@xmath265 . set @xmath214 . * * step 1 * * ( short timescale user scheduling optimization ) : for fixed @xmath266 , let @xmath267 , where @xmath268 is given by @xmath269 where @xmath270 is the average data rate of user @xmath23 under @xmath266 and user scheduling policy @xmath271 . for each subframe
@xmath221 $ ] , the user scheduling vector of bs @xmath22 is given by @xmath272 , where @xmath273 and @xmath274 are the csi and abrb pattern at the @xmath54-th subframe .
* step 2 * ( long timescale abrb optimization ) : * * find the optimal solution @xmath275 of problem ( [ eq : plbequ ] ) under fixed @xmath276 s using e.g. , interior point method .
let @xmath225 .
* * return to step 1 until @xmath277 * * or the maximum number of iterations is reached . using similar proof as that in appendix [ sub : proof - of - theoremla ] , it can be shown that algorithm ao_b converges to the global optimal solution for problem ( [ eq : plbequ ] ) under similar assumption as in theorem [ thm : global - convergence - la ] .
the average data rate @xmath236 and the mutual information @xmath276 can be estimated online in a similar way as in algorithm ao_a .
problem @xmath253 is a difficult combinatorial problem and the complexity of finding the optimal abrb profile is extremely high . in this section ,
we illustrate the top level method for finding a good abrb profile .
the detailed algorithm to solve @xmath253 is given in appendix [ sub : proof - of - theoremequpb ] .
a good abrb profile can be found based on an _ interference graph _ extracted from the topology graph .
[ interference graph][def : igraph]for a hetnet topology graph @xmath13 , define an undirected interference graph @xmath278 , where @xmath279 is the vertex set and @xmath280 is edge set with @xmath281 denoting the edge between @xmath282 and @xmath283 . for any @xmath284 , if @xmath285 , @xmath286 , otherwise , @xmath287 , where @xmath288 is the void set .
[ fig : ifc_graph1 ] illustrates how to extract the interference graph from the topology graph using an example hetnet . given an interference graph @xmath289 for the hetnet , any two links @xmath290 having an edge ( i.e. , @xmath286 )
should not be scheduled for transmission simultaneously . on the other hand , we should `` turn on '' as many `` non - conflicting '' links as possible to maximize the spatial reuse efficiency .
this intuition suggests that the optimal abrb profile is highly related to the _ maximal independent set _ of the interference graph @xmath289 .
an example of extracting the interference graph from the hetnet topology graph , width=332 ] [ maximal independent set ( mis)]a subset @xmath291 of @xmath292 is an _
independent set _ of @xmath278 if @xmath293 .
maximal independent set _
( mis ) is an independent set that is not a proper subset of any other independent set . for any mis @xmath291 ,
define @xmath294 as the _ maximal independent macro bs set _ corresponding to @xmath291 .
let @xmath295 denote the set of all miss of @xmath289 .
for example , the set of all miss of the interference graph in fig .
[ fig : ifc_graph1 ] is @xmath296 .
define a set @xmath297 then the top level flow of finding a good abrb profile is summarized in table . [
tab : flowpb ] . in step 2 , we need to find a set of miss @xmath298 . for the example in fig .
[ fig : ifc_graph1 ] , @xmath299 has a unique element given by @xmath300 and thus @xmath301 . in step 3 , the mapping from @xmath302 to the abrb profile @xmath303 is @xmath304 , where @xmath305 $ ] with @xmath306 and @xmath307 .
for example , for the hetnet in fig .
[ fig : ifc_graph1 ] , we have @xmath301 and thus @xmath308 , where @xmath309 $ ] , @xmath310 $ ] and @xmath311 $ ] . since @xmath312 in this case , @xmath303 can be reduced to @xmath313,\left[0,1,0\right]\right\ } $ ] .
.[tab : flowpb]top level flow of finding a good abrb profile [ cols= " < " , ] fig .
[ fig : conva ] shows the utility @xmath314 in ( [ eq : plare ] ) of the type a users versus the number of super - frames .
the utility increases rapidly and then approaches to a steady state after only @xmath315 updates .
the figure demonstrates a fast convergence behavior of algorithm ao_a .
similar convergence behavior was also observed for algorithm ao_b and the simulation result is not shown here due to limited space .
utility of the type a users versus the number of super - frames , width=321 ] we compare the complexity of the baselines and proposed rrm algorithms .
the complexity can be evaluated in the following 3 aspects .
\1 ) for the short term user scheduling , the proposed scheme and baseline 1 - 3 have the same complexity order of @xmath316 , while the baseline 4 has a complexity of @xmath317 @xcite , where @xmath318 is a proportionality constant that corresponds to some matrix and vector operations with dimension @xmath319 , and @xmath320 is the number of bss in each cooperative cluster .
\2 ) for the long term abrb control variables @xmath185 and @xmath263 , as they are updated by solving standard convex optimization problems in step 2 of algorithm ao_a and ao_b respectively , the complexities are polynomial w.r.t .
the number of the associated optimization variables .
specifically , for control variable @xmath185 , the complexity is polynomial w.r.t . the number of macro bss @xmath0 . for control
variable @xmath321 , the complexity is polynomial w.r.t .
the size of the abrb profile @xmath303 : @xmath322 .
in addition , they are only updated once in each super - frame .
\3 ) the abrb profile @xmath303 is computed using algorithm b2 in every several super - frames to adapt to the large scale fading . in step 1 of algorithm b2 ,
the complexity of solving the convex problem ( [ eq : fixthetapdet ] ) is polynomial w.r.t .
@xmath323 . in step 2 of algorithm b2 ,
if the mwis algorithm in @xcite is used to solve problem ( [ eq : mwisp ] ) , the complexity is @xmath324 , where @xmath325 is the number of edges in the interference graph @xmath278 .
we propose a two - timescale hierarchical rrm for hetnet with dynamic abrb . to facilitate structural abrb design for cross - tier and co - tier interference ,
the @xmath10 subbands are partitioned into type a and type b subbands .
consequently , the two timescale rrm problem is decomposed into subproblems @xmath136 and @xmath137 which respectively optimizes the abrb control and user scheduling for the type a and type b subbands .
both subproblems involve non - trivial multi - stage optimization with exponential large solution space w.r.t . the number of macro bss @xmath0 .
we exploit the sparsity in the hetnet interference graph and derive the structural properties to reduce the solution space .
based on that , we propose two timescale ao algorithm to solve @xmath136 and @xmath137 .
the overall solution is asymptotically optimal at high snr and has low complexity , low signaling overhead as well as robust w.r.t .
latency of backhaul signaling .
define the average rate region as @xmath326\in\mathbb{r}_{+}^{k}:\ : x_{k}\le\overline{r}_{k}\left(\lambda\right),\forall k\right\ } .\ ] ] for any utility function that is concave and increasing w.r.t . to the average data rates @xmath327
, the optimal policy of @xmath328 must achieve a pareto boundary point of @xmath329 .
hence , we only need to show that any pareto boundary point of @xmath329 can be achieved by a symmetric policy .
define the average rate region under fixed @xmath134 as @xmath330\in\mathbb{r}_{+}^{k}:\\ & & x_{k}\le\overline{r}_{k}\left(\left\ { q_{s},\left\ { q_{m}\right\ } , \left\ { \pi_{m}\right\ } \right\ } \right),\forall k\bigg\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then we only need to show that any pareto boundary point of @xmath331 can be achieved by a symmetric policy @xmath110 .
define the average mutual information region _ _ for subband @xmath115 as : @xmath332_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}}\in\mathbb{r}_{+}^{\left|\mathcal{u}_{a}\right|}:\nonumber \\ & & x_{k}\le\overline{\mathcal{i}}_{m , k}\left(q_{m},\pi_{m}\right),\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}\bigg\}.\label{eq : ratereg1g-1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] define the average mutual information region _
_ for subband @xmath333 as : @xmath332_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{b}}\in\mathbb{r}_{+}^{\left|\mathcal{u}_{b}\right|}:\nonumber \\ & & x_{k}\le\overline{\mathcal{i}}_{m , k}\left(q_{m},\pi_{m}\right),\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{b}\bigg\}.\label{eq : ratereg2g-1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it can be verified that @xmath334 is a convex region in @xmath335 and @xmath336 is a convex region in @xmath337 . moreover , due to the statistical symmetry of the subbands , we have @xmath338 let @xmath339 and @xmath340
. from the convexity of @xmath341 and ( [ eq : ra]-[eq : rb ] ) , we have @xmath342 hence , for any pareto boundary point @xmath343^{t}$ ] of @xmath331 , @xmath344_{k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}}\in\mathbb{r}_{+}^{\left|\mathcal{u}_{a}\right|}$ ] is a pareto boundary point of @xmath345 and @xmath346_{k\in\mathcal{u}_{b}}\in\mathbb{r}_{+}^{\left|\mathcal{u}_{b}\right|}$ ] is a pareto boundary point of @xmath347 . due to the statistical symmetry of the subbands
, there exists an abrb control policy and a user scheduling policy @xmath348 such that @xmath349 can be achieved for all subbands @xmath115 .
similarly , there exists an abrb control policy and a user scheduling policy @xmath350 such that @xmath351 can be achieved for all subbands @xmath333 .
hence , @xmath352 can be achieved using the symmetric policy @xmath353 .
this completes the proof . [
[ structural - properties - of - mathcalp_a - for - general - casessubspageneral ] ] structural properties of @xmath136 for general cases[sub : spageneral ] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1 .
@xmath167 , we have @xmath358 and @xmath359 @xmath360 .
the same is true if we replace @xmath154 with @xmath159 .
2 . for given abrb patterns
@xmath170 and user scheduling vector @xmath361 , there exists @xmath362 such that @xmath363 . by definition [ def : inuser ] , there is no inter - cell interference for macro cell n - users . by the definition of @xmath364 ,
a pico cell i - user @xmath357 can not be scheduled for transmission if any of the neighbor macro bss in @xmath365 is transmitting data subframe ( i.e. , the current abrb pattern @xmath366 ) . on the other hand ,
if all of the neighbor macro bss is transmitting abrb ( i.e. , the current abrb pattern @xmath161 ) , the interference from the macro bss is negligible .
finally , by definition [ def : inuser ] , there is no inter - cell interference for pico cell n - users .
then lemma 1 follows straightforwardly from the above analysis and the definition of @xmath367 .
[ rem : usefulassumptions]note that in the proof of lemma [ lem : sysman ] , we have used the fact that the inter - cell interference seen at a n - user is negligible .
we have also used assumption [ asm : picoiedge ] , which states that the sets of neighbor macro bss of the pico cell i - users belonging to the same pico cell are identical .
[ policy space reduction for @xmath130][thm : absreduce]given a marginal probability vector that each macro bs is transmitting abrb @xmath369 , the optimal abrb control policy of @xmath147 conditioned on has the following synchronous abrb structure : by lemma [ lem : sysman ] , for given marginal probabilities @xmath185 , the average mutual information region will be maximized if we maximize @xmath189 for all @xmath382 . for @xmath383
, we have @xmath192 . for @xmath384
, we have @xmath385 , where the equality holds if and only if @xmath130 has the structure in theorem [ thm : absreduce ] .
this completes the proof .
define the _ achievable mutual information region _ for subband @xmath390 as @xmath391_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}}:x_{k}\le\overline{\mathcal{i}}_{m_{a},k}\left(q_{a},\pi_{a}\right)\right\ } , \label{eq : ratereg1g}\ ] ] where @xmath392 .
it can be verified that @xmath393 is a convex region in @xmath335 . since the utility function @xmath138 is concave and increasing w.r.t .
@xmath394 , the optimal policy @xmath395 must achieve a pareto boundary point of @xmath393 . for given abrb pattern @xmath160 and bs @xmath22 ,
define a region as @xmath396_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}\cap\mathcal{u}_{n}}:\ : x_{k}\le i_{m_{a},k}\left(\pi_{a},\mathbf{a}\right)\right\ } .\ ] ] it can be verified that @xmath397 is a convex region . from lemma [ lem :
sysman ] , we have @xmath398 for convenience , define @xmath399 then @xmath400 , we have @xmath401 . from ( [ eq : rma]-[eq : rmabar ] ) and the fact that @xmath402_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}}$ ] is a pareto boundary point of @xmath393 , it follows that @xmath403_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}\cap\mathcal{u}_{n}}$ ] is a pareto boundary point of @xmath404 and @xmath405_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}\cap\mathcal{u}_{n}}$ ] is a pareto boundary point of @xmath406 .
hence , there exists user scheduling policy @xmath407 satisfying @xmath408 and @xmath409 for all @xmath410 .
then it follows that @xmath402_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}}$ ] can be achieved by the control policy @xmath411 .
[ [ proof - of - corollary - corequivalent - problem - pa - subproof - of - corollaypa ] ] proof of corollary [ cor : equivalent - problem - pa ] [ sub : proof - of - corollaypa ] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ the first part of the corollary follows straightforward from theorem [ thm : absreduce ] and [ clm : policy - space - reductionpia ] .
we only need to prove that problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) is bi - convex .
the average mutual information in ( [ eq : uaobj ] ) can be expressed as @xmath412 where @xmath413 , @xmath414 , @xmath415 is the set of macro cell n - users , @xmath416 is the set of pico cell n - users , and @xmath417 is the set of pico cell i - users .
it is easy to verify that @xmath418 is a concave function w.r.t . @xmath185 for fixed @xmath131 .
using the vector composition rule for concave function @xcite , the objective in ( [ eq : plare ] ) is also concave w.r.t .
@xmath185 and thus problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) is convex w.r.t . @xmath185 for fixed @xmath131 . for fixed @xmath185 , @xmath418 is a linear function of the user scheduling variables @xmath419 .
hence problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) is also convex w.r.t . @xmath131 for fixed @xmath185 . [
[ proof - of - theorem - thmglobal - convergence - lasubproof - of - theoremla ] ] proof of theorem [ thm : global - convergence - la][sub : proof - of - theoremla ] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ it is clear that @xmath420 . by the assumption in theorem [ thm : global - convergence - la ] , we have @xmath421 if @xmath422 is not a fixed point of @xmath229 . combining the above and the fact that @xmath314 is upper bounded , ao_a must converge to a fixed point @xmath235\in\delta$ ] .
the rest is to prove that any @xmath235\in\delta$ ] is globally optimal for problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) .
note that problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) is equivalent to the problem @xmath423_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}}\in\mathcal{r}_{m_{a}}.\label{eq : equplapre}\ ] ] since the objective in ( [ eq : equplapre ] ) is a concave function w.r.t .
@xmath424 , and @xmath393 is a convex region , the following lemma holds . [ optimality condition for ( [ eq : plare])][lem : opt - cond - pa]a solution @xmath425 , @xmath209 is optimal for problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) if and only if its average mutual information @xmath426 satisfies @xmath427_{\forall k\in\mathcal{u}_{a}}\in\mathcal{r}_{m_{a}}\ ] ] according to the step 1 of ao_a , for any abrb pattern @xmath428 and csi realization @xmath355 , the user scheduling vector @xmath429 of bs @xmath22 under @xmath430 is the optimal solution of @xmath431 where @xmath432 and @xmath433 is the average mutual information under @xmath434 . combining ( [ eq : optpiatuta ] ) and the fact that @xmath435 is the optimal solution of problem ( [ eq : plare ] ) with fixed @xmath430 , we have @xmath436 .
this implies that @xmath434 satisfy the optimality condition in lemma [ lem : opt - cond - pa ] , and thus is the globally optimal solution .
* * step 1 * * ( update the coefficients @xmath442 ) : for fixed @xmath443 , obtain the optimal solution @xmath444_{j=1, ... ,\left|\theta^{(i)}\right|}$ ] of the following convex optimization problem @xmath445,\forall j\:\textrm{and}\:\sum_{j=1}^{\left|\theta^{(i)}\right|}\check{q}_{j}=1,\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath446_{j=1, ...
,\left|\theta^{(i)}\right|}$ ] , and @xmath447 is the @xmath257 mis in @xmath443 .
[ asymptotically optimal abrb profile][thm : asymptotic - equivalence - ofpb]algorithm b2 always converges to an abrb profile @xmath303 with @xmath322 .
furthermore , the converged result is asymptotically optimal for high snr .
i.e. @xmath456 , where @xmath457 for some positive constants @xmath458 s , and @xmath459 is the optimal objective value of @xmath249
. consider problem @xmath460 which is the same as @xmath249 except that there are two differences : 1 ) the fading channel @xmath461 is replaced by a _ deterministic channel _ with the channel gain between bs @xmath22 and user @xmath23 given by the corresponding large scale fading factor @xmath462 ; 2 ) an additional constraint is added to the user scheduling policy such that any two links @xmath290 having an edge ( i.e. , @xmath286 ) in the interference graph @xmath289 can not be scheduled for transmission simultaneously .
it can be shown that the optimal solution of problem @xmath460 is asymptotically optimal for @xmath249 at high snr . moreover , using the fact that the achievable mutual information region in the deterministic channel is a convex polytope with @xmath463 as the set of _ pareto boundary _ vertices , it can be shown that @xmath460 is equivalent to the following problem @xmath464 where @xmath465 is the @xmath257 mis in @xmath448 . to complete the proof of theorem [ thm : asymptotic - equivalence - ofpb ] , we only need to further prove that algorithm b2 converges to the optimal solution of problem ( [ eq : pdet ] ) . using the fact that any point in a @xmath466-dimensional convex polytope can be expressed as a convex combination of no more than @xmath254 vertices , it can be shown that there are at most @xmath254 non - zero elements in @xmath467 in step 1 of algorithm b2 .
hence @xmath468 .
moreover , it can be verified that @xmath469 if @xmath443 is not optimal for ( [ eq : pdet ] ) . combining the above and the fact that @xmath470 is upper bounded by @xmath471
, algorithm b2 must converge to the optimal solution of ( [ eq : pdet ] ) .
this completes the proof . in step 2 of algorithm b2 , problem ( [ eq : mwisp ] ) is equivalent to finding a _ maximum weighted independent set _ ( mwis ) in the interference graph @xmath289 with the weights of the vertex nodes given by @xmath472 .
the mwis problem has been well studied in the literature @xcite .
although it is in general np hard , there exists low complexity algorithms for finding near - optimal solutions @xcite .
although the asymptotic global optimality of algorithm b2 is not guaranteed when step 2 is replaced by a low complexity solution of ( [ eq : mwisp ] ) , we can still prove its monotone convergence .
d. gesbert , s. kiani , a. gjendemsj _ et al .
_ , `` adaptation , coordination , and distributed resource allocation in interference - limited wireless networks , '' _ proceedings of the ieee _ , vol . 95 , no . 12 , pp . 23932409 , 2007 .
a. l. stolyar and h. viswanathan , `` self - organizing dynamic fractional frequency reuse in ofdma systems , '' in _
infocom 2008 .
the 27th conference on computer communications .
ieee_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2008 , pp .
691699 .
r. irmer , h. droste , p. marsch , m. grieger , g. fettweis , s. brueck , h. mayer , l. thiele , and v. jungnickel , `` coordinated multipoint : concepts , performance , and field trial results , '' _ ieee communications magazine _ , vol .
49 , no . 2 ,
pp . 102111 , 2011 .
q. shi , m. razaviyayn , z .- q . luo , and c. he , `` an iteratively weighted mmse approach to distributed sum - utility maximization for a mimo interfering broadcast channel , '' _ ieee trans . signal processing _
59 , no . 9 , pp .
43314340 , sept .
2011 .
y. wang and k. i. pedersen , `` performance analysis of enhanced inter - cell interference coordination in lte - advanced heterogeneous networks , '' in _ vehicular technology conference ( vtc spring ) , 2012 ieee 75th_. 1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2012 , pp .
j. pang , j. wang , d. wang , g. shen , q. jiang , and j. liu , `` optimized time - domain resource partitioning for enhanced inter - cell interference coordination in heterogeneous networks , '' in _ wireless communications and networking conference ( wcnc ) , 2012 ieee_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2012 , pp .
16131617 .
m. hong , r .- y .
sun , h. baligh , and z .- q .
luo , `` joint base station clustering and beamformer design for partial coordinated transmission in heterogenous networks , '' 2012 .
[ online ] .
available : http://arxiv.org/abs/1203.6390 r. ghaffar and r. knopp , `` fractional frequency reuse and interference suppression for ofdma networks , '' in _ proceedings of the 8th international symposium on modeling and optimization in mobile , ad hoc and wireless networks _ , 2010 , pp .
273277 .
o. somekh , o. simeone , y. bar - ness , a. haimovich , and s. shamai , `` cooperative multicell zero - forcing beamforming in cellular downlink channels , '' _ ieee trans .
inf . theory _
55 , no . 7 , pp .
32063219 , 2009 . | interference is a major performance bottleneck in heterogeneous network ( hetnet ) due to its multi - tier topological structure .
we propose almost blank resource block ( abrb ) for interference control in hetnet .
when an abrb is scheduled in a macro bs , a resource block ( rb ) with blank payload is transmitted and this eliminates the interference from this macro bs to the pico bss .
we study a two timescale hierarchical radio resource management ( rrm ) scheme for hetnet with _
dynamic abrb _ control .
the long term controls , such as dynamic abrb , are adaptive to the large scale fading at a rrm server for co - tier and cross - tier interference control .
the short term control ( user scheduling ) is adaptive to the local channel state information within each bs to exploit the _ multi - user diversity_. the two timescale optimization problem is challenging due to the exponentially large solution space .
we exploit the sparsity in the _ interference graph _ of the hetnet topology and derive structural properties for the optimal abrb control . based on that
, we propose a _ two timescale alternative optimization _
solution for the user scheduling and abrb control .
the solution has low complexity and is asymptotically optimal at high snr .
simulations show that the proposed solution has significant gain over various baselines .
heterogeneous network , dynamic abrb control , two timescale rrm |
open dielectric resonators have received great attention due to numerous applications @xcite , e.g. , as microlasers @xcite or as sensors @xcite , and as paradigms of open wave - chaotic systems @xcite .
the size of dielectric microcavities typically ranges from a few to several hundreds of wavelengths .
wave - dynamical systems that are large compared to the typical wavelength have been treated successfully with semiclassical methods .
these provide approximate solutions in terms of properties of the corresponding classical system . in the case of dielectric cavities ,
the corresponding classical system is an open dielectric billiard . inside
the billiard rays travel freely while , when impinging the boundary , they are partially reflected and refracted to the outside according to snell s law and the fresnel formulas .
the field distributions of resonance states of dielectric cavities can be localized on the periodic orbits ( pos ) of the corresponding billiard @xcite and the far - field characteristics of microlasers can be predicted from its ray dynamics @xcite .
semiclassical corrections to the ray picture due to the goos - hnchen shift @xcite , fresnel filtering @xcite , and curved boundaries @xcite are under investigation for a more precise understanding of the connections between ray and wave dynamics @xcite .
one of the most important tools in semiclassical physics are trace formulas , which relate the density of states of a quantum or wave - dynamical system to the pos of the corresponding classical system @xcite .
recently , a trace formula for two - dimensional ( 2d ) dielectric resonators was developed @xcite .
the trace formula was successfully tested for resonator shapes with regular classical dynamics in experiments with 2d dielectric microwave resonators @xcite and with polymer microlasers of various shapes @xcite .
however , typical microlasers like those used in refs . @xcite are three - dimensional ( 3d ) systems .
while trace formulas for closed 3d electromagnetic resonators have been derived @xcite and tested @xcite , hitherto there is practically no investigation of the trace formula for 3d dielectric resonators .
the main reason is the difficulty of the numerical solution of the full 3d maxwell equations for real dielectric cavities .
the case of flat microlasers is special since their in - plane extensions are large compared to the typical wavelength , whereas their height is smaller than or of the order of the wavelength . even in this case
complete numerical solutions are rarely performed . in practice ,
flat dielectric cavities are treated as 2d systems by introducing a so - called effective index of refraction @xcite ( see below ) .
this approximation has been used in refs .
@xcite and a good overall agreement between the experiments and the theory was found .
however , it is known @xcite that this 2d approximation ( called the @xmath0 model in the following ) introduces certain uncontrolled errors .
even the separation between transverse electric and transverse magnetic polarizations intrinsic in this approach is not , strictly speaking , valid for 3d cavities @xcite . to the best of the authors knowledge , no _
a priori _ estimates of such errors are known even when the cavity height is much smaller than the wavelength .
the purpose of the present work is the careful comparison of the experimental length spectra and the trace formula computed within the 2d @xmath0 approximation .
furthermore , the effect of the dispersion of the effective index of refraction on the trace formula is investigated as well as the need for higher - order corrections of the trace formula due to , e.g. , curvature effects .
the experiments were performed with two dielectric microwave resonators of circular shape and different thickness like in ref .
these are known to be ideal testbeds for the investigation of wave - dynamical chaos @xcite and have been used , e.g. , in refs .
the results of these microwave experiments can be directly applied to dielectric microcavities in the optical frequency regime if the ratio of the typical wavelength and the resonator extensions are similar .
the paper is organized as follows . the experimental setup and the measured frequency spectrum
are discussed in .
section [ sec : theo ] summarizes the @xmath0 model for flat 3d resonators , the semiclassical trace formula for 2d resonators and how these are combined here .
the experimental length spectra are compared to this model in and concludes with a discussion of the results .
two flat circular disks made of teflon were used as microwave resonators .
the first one , disk a , has a radius of @xmath1 mm and a thickness of @xmath2 mm so @xmath3 .
its index of refraction is @xmath4 .
a typical frequency of @xmath5 ghz corresponds to @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the wave number and @xmath8 the speed of light .
the second one , disk b , has @xmath9 mm , @xmath10 mm ( @xmath11 ) , and @xmath12 , with @xmath13 ghz corresponding to @xmath14 .
the values of the indices of refraction @xmath15 of both disks were measured independently ( see ref .
@xcite ) and validated by numerical calculations @xcite .
they showed negligible dispersion in the considered frequency range .. ] figure [ sfig : setupphoto ] shows a photograph of the experimental setup .
the circular teflon disk is supported by three pillars arranged in a triangle .
the prevalent modes observed experimentally are whispering gallery modes ( wgms ) that are localized close to the boundary of the disk @xcite .
therefore , the pillars perturb the resonator only negligibly because their position is far away from the boundary .
additionally , @xmath16 cm of a special foam ( rohacell 31ig by evonik industries @xcite ) with an index of refraction of @xmath17 is placed between the pillars and the disk as isolation [ see ] .
the total height of the pillars is @xmath18 mm so the resonator is not influenced by the optical table .
two vertical wire antennas are placed diametrically at the cylindrical sidewalls of the disk ( cf .
they are connected to a vectorial network analyzer ( pna n5230a by agilent technologies ) with coaxial rf cables .
the network analyzer measures the complex scattering matrix element @xmath19 , where @xmath20 is the ratio between the powers @xmath21 coupled out via antenna @xmath22 and @xmath23 coupled in via antenna @xmath24 for a given frequency @xmath25 . plotting @xmath26 versus @xmath25 yields the frequency spectrum .
the measured frequency spectrum of disk b is shown in .
it consists of several series of roughly equidistant resonances .
the associated modes can be labeled with their polarization and the quantum numbers of the circle resonator , which are indicated in . here
, @xmath27 are the azimuthal and radial quantum number , respectively ; tm denotes transverse magnetic polarization with the @xmath28 component of the magnetic field , @xmath29 , equal to zero ; and te denotes transverse electric polarization with the @xmath28 component of the electric field , @xmath30 , equal to zero .
each series of resonances consists of modes with the same polarization and radial quantum number .
the free spectral range ( @xmath31 ) for each series is in the range of @xmath32@xmath33 mhz . only modes with @xmath34 , that is , wgms , are observed in the experiment .
the quantum numbers were determined from the intensity distributions , which were measured with the perturbation body method ( see ref .
@xcite and references therein ) . to determine the polarization of the modes
a metal plate was placed parallel to the resonator at a variable distance @xmath35 [ see ] .
figure [ fig : polmeas ] shows a part of the frequency spectrum with two resonances for different distances of the metal plate to the disk .
the metal plate induces a shift of the resonance frequencies , where the magnitude of the frequency shift increases with decreasing distance @xmath35 .
notably , the direction of the shift depends on the polarization of the corresponding mode : te modes are shifted to higher frequencies and tm modes to lower ones , so the polarization of each mode can be determined uniquely .
this behavior is attributed to the different boundary conditions for the @xmath30 field ( tm modes ) and the @xmath29 field ( te modes ) at the metal plates .
the former obeys dirichlet , the latter neumann boundary conditions . a detailed explanation is given in appendix [ sec : polmeascalc ] .
the open dielectric resonators are described by the vectorial helmholtz equation @xmath36 \left\ { \begin{array}{c } \vec{e } \\ \vec{b } \end{array } \right\ } = \vec{0}\ ] ] with outgoing - wave boundary conditions , where @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the electric and the magnetic field , respectively , and @xmath39 is the index of refraction at the position @xmath40 .
though all components of the electric and magnetic fields obey the same helmholtz equation , they are not independent but rather coupled in the bulk and at the boundaries as required by the maxwell equations .
the eigenvalues @xmath41 of are complex and the real part of @xmath41 corresponds to the resonance frequency @xmath42 of the resonance @xmath43 , while the imaginary part corresponds to the resonance width @xmath44 ( full width at half maximum ) . for the infinite slab geometry ( see ) ,
the vectorial helmholtz equation can be simplified by separating the wave vector @xmath45 into a vertical @xmath28 component , @xmath46 , and a component parallel to the @xmath47-@xmath48 plane , @xmath49 .
thus , @xmath50 , and the angle of incidence on the top and bottom surface of the resonator is @xmath51 . for a resonant wave inside the slab the wave vector component @xmath52 must obey the resonance condition @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the fresnel reflection coefficient .
the solutions of yield the quantized values of @xmath52 .
the effective index of refraction @xmath0 is defined as @xmath55 and corresponds to the phase velocity with respect to the @xmath47-@xmath48 plane . in the experiments only modes trapped due to total internal reflection ( tir ) are observed . in this case , the reflection coefficient @xmath54 can be written as @xmath56 with @xmath57 where @xmath58 for tm modes and @xmath59 for te modes . with these definitions ,
the quantization condition for @xmath52 can be reformulated as an implicit equation for the determination of @xmath0 , @xmath60\ ] ] with @xmath61 being the order of excitation in the @xmath28 direction @xcite .
the @xmath62 term in corresponds to the fresnel phase due to the reflections and the @xmath63 term to the geometrical phase . in the framework of the @xmath0 model the flat resonator
is treated as a dielectric slab waveguide and the vectorial helmholtz equation [ ] is accordingly reduced to the 2d scalar helmholtz equation @xcite by replacing @xmath15 by the effective index of refraction @xmath0 , @xmath64 where the wave function @xmath65 inside , respectively , outside of the resonator corresponds to @xmath30 in the case of tm modes and to @xmath29 in the case of te modes .
the boundary conditions at the boundary of the resonator in the @xmath47-@xmath48 plane ( i.e. , the cylindrical sidewalls ) , @xmath66 , are @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the unit normal vector for @xmath66 , @xmath69 for tm modes , and @xmath70 for te modes . equation ( [ eq : helmholtzscal ] ) can be solved analytically for a circular dielectric resonator @xcite .
however , it should be stressed that is not exact for flat 3d cavities .
it defines the 2d @xmath0 approximation whose accuracy is unknown analytically but which has been determined experimentally in ref .
our purpose is to investigate the precision of this approximation for the length spectra of simple 3d dielectric cavities .
the effective index of refraction for the tm modes with the lowest @xmath28 excitation @xmath71 of disk a and b is shown in .
obviously , @xmath0 depends strongly on the frequency , and this dispersion plays a crucial role in the present work .
it should be noted that also te modes and modes with higher @xmath28 excitation exist in the considered frequency range , however , in the following we focus on tm modes .
the density of states ( dos ) in a dielectric resonator is given by @xcite @xmath72 ^ 2 + [ { \mathrm{im}\left(k_j\right)}]^2 } \
, , \ ] ] where the summation runs over all resonances @xmath43 .
the dos can be separated into a smooth , average part @xmath73 and a fluctuating part , @xmath74 .
the smooth part is well described by the weyl formula given in ref .
@xcite and depends only on the area , the circumference and the index of refraction of the resonator . the fluctuating part , on the other hand
, is related to the pos of the corresponding classical dielectric billiard . for a 2d dielectric resonator with regular classical dynamics ,
the semiclassical approximation for @xmath74 is @xcite @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the length of the po , @xmath77 is the product of the fresnel reflection coefficients for the reflections of the rays at the dielectric interfaces , @xmath78 denotes the phase changes accumulated at the reflections [ i.e. , @xmath79 and at the conjugate points of the corresponding po , and the amplitude @xmath80 is proportional to @xmath81 , where @xmath82 is the area of the billiard covered by the family of the po . it should be noted that this semiclassical formula fails to accurately describe contributions of pos with angle of incidence close to the critical angle for tir , @xmath83 , as concerns the amplitude . consequently , higher - order corrections to the trace formula need to be developed for these cases @xcite .
we restrict the discussion to the experimentally observed tm modes and compare the results with the trace formula obtained in ref .
@xcite . to select the tm modes with @xmath71 the polarization and the quantum numbers of all resonances had to be determined experimentally as described in .
the trace formula for 2d resonators is applied to the flat 3d resonators considered here by inserting the frequency - dependent effective index of refraction @xmath84 instead of @xmath15 into . to test the accuracy of the resulting trace formula we computed the fourier transform ( ft ) of @xmath74 . in ref .
@xcite it was shown that it is essential to fully take into account the dispersion of @xmath0 in the ft for a meaningful comparison of the resulting length spectrum with the geometric lengths of the pos .
therefore , we define @xmath85 where the quantity @xmath86 is a geometrical length and @xmath87 is , thus , called the length spectrum
. we will compare it to the ft as defined in using @xmath84 instead of @xmath15 of the trace formula , @xmath88 .
the resonance parameters @xmath41 are obtained by fitting lorentzians to the measured frequency spectra , and @xmath89 correspond to the frequency range considered .
since in a circle resonator the resonance modes with @xmath90 are doubly degenerate , the measured resonances are counted twice each .
note that even though only the most long - lived resonances ( i.e. , the wgms ) are observed experimentally , and these comprise only a fraction of all resonances , a comparison of the experimental length spectrum with the trace formula is meaningful @xcite .
figure [ fig : lspektsclhkreis ] shows the experimental length spectrum evaluated using and the ft of the semiclassical trace formula , , for disk a. a total of @xmath91 measured tm modes with radial quantum numbers @xmath92@xmath93 from @xmath94 ghz to @xmath95 ghz was used .
the pos in the circle billiard are denoted by their period @xmath96 and their rotation number @xmath97 and have the shape of polygons and stars ( see insets in ) .
their lengths are indicated by the solid arrows .
the pos with @xmath98 and @xmath99 were used to compute the trace formula . only pos with @xmath100
are indicated in for the sake of clarity .
the pos with @xmath101 only add small contributions to the right shoulder of the peak corresponding to the @xmath102 and @xmath103 orbits .
the amplitudes are @xmath104 and the phases are @xmath105}\ ] ] with the angles of incidence of the pos ( with respect to the surface normal ) being @xmath106 the overall agreement between the experimental length spectrum and the semiclassical trace formula is good and the major peaks in the length spectrum are close to the lengths of the @xmath107@xmath103 orbits .
however , no clear peaks are observed at the lengths of the @xmath108 and the @xmath109 orbit in the experimental length spectrum .
note that in the experimental length spectrum only orbits that are confined by tir are observed ( cf .
this is not the case for the @xmath108 and the @xmath109 orbits in the frequency range of interest , where their angle of incidence @xmath110 is smaller than the critical angle @xmath111 as depicted in .
the length spectrum of disk b is shown in .
altogether @xmath112 resonances with @xmath92@xmath93 from @xmath113 ghz to @xmath114 ghz were used .
the semiclassical trace formula was again computed for @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
the agreement of the experimental length spectrum and the ft of the trace formula is good and comparable to that obtained for disk a. as in the case of disk a , the experimental length spectrum exhibits no peaks for the @xmath108 orbit , whose length is not within the range depicted in , and for the @xmath109 orbit since they are not confined by tir in the considered frequency range . a closer inspection of figs .
[ fig : lspektsclhkreis ] and [ fig : lspektsclbkreis ] shows two unexpected effects . first , the peak positions of the ft of the semiclassical trace formula deviate slightly from the lengths of the pos .
this can be seen best in the bottom parts of figs .
[ fig : lspektsclhkreis ] and [ fig : lspektsclbkreis ] , where the contributions of the individual pos to the trace formula are depicted .
second , there is a small but systematic difference between the peak positions of the experimental length spectrum and those of the ft of the trace formula .
we will demonstrate that the first effect is related to the dispersion of @xmath0 and the second effect to the systematic error of the @xmath0 model .
cccc @xmath115 & @xmath76 ( m ) & @xmath116 ( m ) & @xmath117 ( m ) + disk a + @xmath107 & @xmath118 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 + @xmath121 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 & @xmath124 + @xmath102 & @xmath125 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 + @xmath103 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 + @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 & @xmath134 + @xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath137 & @xmath138 + + disk b + @xmath107 & @xmath139 & @xmath140 & @xmath141 + @xmath121 & @xmath142 & @xmath143 & @xmath144 + @xmath102 & @xmath145 & @xmath146 & @xmath147 + @xmath103 & @xmath148 & @xmath149 & @xmath150 + @xmath131 & @xmath151 & @xmath152 & @xmath153 + @xmath135 & @xmath154 & @xmath155 & @xmath151 + the difference between the peak positions of the trace formula and the lengths of the pos can be understood by considering the exponential term in the ft of the semiclassical trace formula , which for a single po is @xmath156 \}}\ ] ] with @xmath78 given by .
the crucial point is that the phase @xmath78 is frequency dependent because it contains the phase of the fresnel coefficients , which , in turn , depends on @xmath84 .
the modulus of the ft will be largest for that length @xmath86 for which the exponent in is stationary , i.e. , its derivative with respect to @xmath157 vanishes .
this leads to the following estimate @xmath116 for the peak position , @xmath158 where @xmath159 is related to the fresnel coefficients via .
the wave number @xmath160 at which is evaluated is the center of the relevant wave number / frequency interval , which is @xmath161 with @xmath162 .
the frequency @xmath163 is defined by @xmath164 , i.e. , it corresponds to the minimum frequency at which the considered po is confined by tir ( cf . ) .
below @xmath165 the fresnel phase vanishes .
the estimated peak positions @xmath116 are indicated by the dashed arrows in figs . [ fig : lspektsclhkreis ] and [ fig : lspektsclbkreis ] and agree well with the peak positions @xmath117 of the individual po contributions in the bottom parts of the figures .
a list of the lengths of the pos , the peak positions of the single po contributions , and the estimates @xmath116 according to for disks a and b is provided in . in general
, the estimate @xmath116 deviates only by @xmath24@xmath22 mm from the actual peak position @xmath117 ( about @xmath166 of @xmath117 ) .
the @xmath108 and the @xmath109 orbits are not confined by tir . therefore , for these orbits the fresnel phase vanishes and accordingly @xmath167 .
furthermore , their contributions to the length spectrum are symmetric with respect to @xmath168 , while those of the other pos are asymmetric with an oscillating tail to the left ( see bottom parts of figs . [
fig : lspektsclhkreis ] and [ fig : lspektsclbkreis ] ) .
these tails are attributed to the frequency dependence of the fresnel phase .
they can lead to interference effects , as can be seen for example in . there ,
e.g. , the peak positions of the semiclassical trace formula ( dashed line in the top part ) for the @xmath107 and the @xmath121 orbit deviate from the peak positions @xmath117 of the corresponding single orbit contributions ( dashed and dotted lines in the bottom part ) due to interferences between the contributions of a po and the side lobes of those of the other pos . in order to identify such interferences ,
it is generally instructive to compare the ft of the semiclassical trace formula with those of its single orbit contributions .
it should be noted that the effect discussed in this paragraph also occurs for any 2d resonator made of a dispersive material .
it was shown in the previous paragraph that the dispersion of @xmath0 plays an important role .
furthermore , the semiclassical trace formula is known to be imprecise for pos with angles of incidence close to the critical angle .
this is especially crucial here since several pos are close to the critical angle in at least a part of the considered frequency regime ( see ) .
these deficiencies of the semiclassical trace formula indicate the necessity to implement modifications of it . to pursue this presumption we will compare the experimental length spectrum with the ft of the exact trace formula for the 2d dielectric circle resonator using a frequency - dependent index of refraction @xmath169 in order to investigate the deviations between it and the ft of the semiclassical trace formula .
the trace formula is called exact since it is derived directly from the quantization condition for the dielectric circle resonator and without semiclassical approximations .
it is given by @xmath170 with the definitions @xmath171
@xmath172 @xmath173 @xmath174 and @xmath175 here , @xmath176 , @xmath177 are the hankel functions of the first and second kinds , respectively , and the prime denotes the derivative with respect to the argument .
equation ( [ eq : trformexact ] ) is essentially eq .
( 67 ) of ref .
@xcite with an additional factor @xmath178 in the term @xmath179 .
a detailed derivation is given in appendix [ sec : exacttraceform ] .
in the semiclassical limit , the term @xmath180 in turns into the product of the fresnel reflection coefficients , the term @xmath181 into the oscillating term @xmath182 , and @xmath183 contributes to the amplitude @xmath80 . for pos close to the critical angle , i.e. , when the stationary point of the integrand in is @xmath184 , the term @xmath180 varies rapidly with @xmath185 , whereas it is assumed to change slowly in the stationary phase approximation used to derive the semiclassical trace formula @xcite . therefore ,
including curvature corrections in the fresnel coefficients does not suffice for an accurate calculation of the contributions of these pos to @xmath74 .
consequently , we compute the integral entering in numerically . figure [ fig : lspektexacthkreis ] shows the comparison of the experimental length spectrum ( solid line ) , the ft of the semiclassical trace formula ( dashed line ) , , and that of the exact trace formula ( dotted line ) , , for disk a. the latter was computed for @xmath186 and @xmath99 .
the other two curves are the same as in the top part of .
the main difference between the semiclassical and the exact trace formula are the larger peak amplitudes of the exact trace formula , where this is mainly attributed to the additional @xmath187 factor .
the differences between the peak amplitudes of the experimental length spectrum and those of the exact trace formula are actually expected since the measured resonances comprise only a part of the whole spectrum ( cf .
@xcite ) , though they are not very large . on the other hand ,
the peak positions @xmath188 of the exact trace formula differ only slightly from those of the semiclassical one , and still deviate from those of the experimental length spectrum , @xmath189 ( see inset of ) .
the difference @xmath190 is in the range of @xmath191@xmath16 mm , i.e. , about @xmath192 of the periodic orbit length @xmath76 .
similar effects are observed in , which shows the experimental length spectrum and the ft of the semiclassical trace formula and that of the exact trace formula ( computed for @xmath186 and @xmath99 ) for disk b. the peak amplitudes of the exact trace formula are , again , somewhat larger than those of the experimental length spectrum , and the peak positions @xmath188 of the exact trace formula differ from those of the experimental length spectrum by @xmath193 mm for the @xmath107 and the @xmath121 orbits .
the relative error @xmath194 is , thus , slightly smaller than in the case of disk a. since the trace formula itself is exact , the only explanation for these deviations is the systematic error of the @xmath0 model .
therefore , we compare the measured ( @xmath195 ) and the calculated ( @xmath196 ) resonance frequencies for disk a in .
the resonance frequencies were calculated by solving the 2d helmholtz equation [ ] for the circle as in ref .
the difference between the measured and the calculated frequencies in ( a ) is as large as half a fsr ( i.e. , the distance between two resonances with the same radial quantum number ) and slowly decreases with increasing frequency .
this is in accordance with the result that the fsr of the calculated resonances in ( b ) is slightly larger than that of the measured ones .
since the frequency spectrum consists of series of almost equidistant resonances , the effect of this systematic error on the peak positions in the length spectrum can be estimated by considering a simple 1d system with equidistant resonances whose distance equals @xmath31 .
the peak position in the corresponding length spectrum is @xmath197 , and a deviation of @xmath198 leads to an error , @xmath199 of the peak position . with @xmath200 mhz
compared to @xmath201 mhz we expect a deviation of @xmath202 or @xmath203 mm in the peak positions , which agrees quite well with the magnitude of the deviations found in . for disk b , the comparison between the measured and the calculated fsr ( not shown here ) yields @xmath204 , which also agrees well with the deviations of @xmath194 found in .
thus , we may conclude that the deviations between the peak positions of the experimental length spectrum and that of the trace formula indeed arise from the systematic error of the @xmath0 model .
unfortunately , we know of no general method to estimate the magnitude of this systematic error beforehand .
it should be noted that the exact magnitude of the systematic error contributing to the deviations found in figs .
[ fig : lspektexacthkreis ] and [ fig : lspektexactbkreis ] depends on the index of refraction used in the calculations .
still , it was shown in ref .
@xcite and also checked here that deviations remain regardless of the value of @xmath15 used , which is known with per mill precision for the disks a and b @xcite .
furthermore , ( b ) demonstrates that the index of refraction of a disk can not be determined without systematic error from the measured @xmath31 even if the dispersion of @xmath0 is fully taken into account .
the resonance spectra of two circular dielectric microwave resonators were measured and the corresponding length spectra were investigated .
in contrast to previous experiments with 2d resonators @xcite , flat 3d resonators were used .
the length spectra were compared to a combination of the semiclassical trace formula for 2d dielectric resonators proposed in ref .
@xcite and a 2d approximation of the helmholtz equation for flat 3d resonators using an effective index of refraction ( in accordance with ref .
the experimental length spectra and the trace formula showed good agreement , and the different contributions of the pos to the length spectra could be successfully identified .
the positions of the peaks in the experimental length spectrum are , however , slightly shifted with respect to the geometrical lengths of the pos .
we found that this shift is related to two different effects , which are , first , the frequency dependence of the effective index of refraction and , second , a systematic inaccuracy of the @xmath0 approximation . in the examples considered here ,
the former effect is as large as @xmath205 of the po length while the latter effect is as large as @xmath192 of @xmath76 , and the two effects cancel each other in part .
the results and methods presented here provide a refinement of the techniques used in refs .
@xcite and allow for the detailed understanding of the spectra of realistic microcavities and -lasers in terms of the 2d trace formula .
furthermore , many of the effects discussed here also apply to 2d systems made of a dispersive material .
some open problems remain , though .
the comparison of the semiclassical trace formula with the exact one for the circle showed that the former needs to be improved for pos close to the critical angle .
furthermore , there are some deviations between the experimental length spectra and the trace formula predictions due to the systematic error of the effective index of refraction approximation .
its effect on the length spectra proved to be rather small and , thus , allowed for the identification of the different po contributions .
however , the computation of the resonance frequencies of flat 3d resonators based on the combination of the 2d trace formula and the @xmath0 approximation would lead to the same systematic deviations from the measured ones as in ref .
another problem with this systematic error is that its magnitude can not be estimated _ a priori_. the comparison of the results for disk a and disk b seems to indicate that it gets smaller for @xmath206 , but there are not enough data to draw final conclusions yet , especially since the value of @xmath207 is of similar magnitude for both disks .
in fact , ref .
@xcite rather indicates that the systematic error of the @xmath0 model increases with decreasing @xmath207 .
this could be attributed to diffraction effects at the boundary of the disks that become more important when @xmath208 gets smaller compared to the wavelength .
on the other hand , the exact 2d case is recovered for @xmath209 , i.e. , an infinitely long cylinder . in conclusion
the accuracy of the @xmath0 model in the limit @xmath206 remains an open problem .
an analytical approach to the problem of flat dielectric cavities that is more accurate than the @xmath0 model would be of great interest .
another perspective direction is to consider 3d dielectric cavities with the size of all sides having the same order of magnitude and to develop a trace formula for them similar to those for metallic 3d cavities @xcite .
the authors wish to thank c. classen from the department of electrical engineering and computer science of the tu berlin for providing numerical calculations to validate the measured resonance data .
this work was supported by the dfg within the sonderforschungsbereich 634 .
the placement of a metal plate parallel to the dielectric disk influences the effective index of refraction , thus , leading to a shift of the resonance frequencies . in order to determine the change of @xmath0
, we , first , calculate the reflection coefficient @xmath210 for a wave traveling inside the dielectric and being reflected at the dielectric - air interface with the metal plate at a distance @xmath35 .
the geometry used here is depicted in .
the ansatz for the @xmath30 field ( tm polarization ) and , respectively , the @xmath29 field ( te polarization ) is @xmath211 where @xmath212 fulfills @xmath213 , @xmath214 is the angular frequency , @xmath215 , @xmath216 are constants , and @xmath54 is the reflection coefficient .
the different wave numbers are connected by @xmath217 for the case of tir considered here , @xmath96 is real , and the penetration depths @xmath218 of the field intensity into region ii is @xmath219 . for the case of tm polarization
the electric field is @xmath220 } e^{-i \omega t}\ ] ] since it obeys neumann boundary conditions at the metal plate , where @xmath221 is a constant .
the boundary conditions at the interface between region i and ii are that @xmath222 and @xmath223 are continuous , which yields @xmath224 for the case of te polarization the magnetic field in region ii is @xmath225 } e^{-i \omega t}\ ] ] since it obeys dirichlet boundary conditions at the metal plate . with the condition that @xmath29 and @xmath226 are continuous at the dielectric interface , @xmath227 is obtained .
analogous to we define @xmath228}$ ] and obtain @xmath229 } = \nu \sqrt{\frac{{n_{\mathrm{eff}}}^2 - 1}{n^2 - { n_{\mathrm{eff}}}^2 } } h[{d}/ ( 2 { l})]\ ] ] with @xmath230 for @xmath231 , is recovered .
this explains why the optical table does not disturb the resonator . by inserting @xmath232 into
we obtain @xmath233 as condition for @xmath234 , where @xmath235 refers to . in order to determine the effect of a change of @xmath35 on the effective index of refraction
, we compute @xmath236 where @xmath237 } h'[{d}/(2 { l } ) ] \ , .\ ] ] the derivative of @xmath238 is @xmath239 which approaches @xmath240 for @xmath241 with @xmath242 for tm and @xmath243 for te polarization .
then , for @xmath231 , @xmath244 with @xmath245 given as @xmath246 accordingly , for large distances of the metal plate , @xmath247 i.e. , for tm modes @xmath0 increases for decreasing distance @xmath35 of the metal plate from the resonator and for te modes it gets smaller .
this qualitative behavior is found for the whole range of @xmath35 , even when is no longer valid .
since the resonance frequencies of the disk are to first - order approximation @xmath248 , the tm modes are shifted to lower and the te modes to higher frequencies as observed in .
the dos for the tm modes of the 2d circular dielectric resonator is @xmath249 where the eigenvalues @xmath250 are the roots of @xcite @xmath251\ ] ] with @xmath252 .
the factor @xmath47 ensures that @xmath253 has no poles .
informally one can write @xmath254 , where @xmath255 is a certain smooth function without zeros and poles .
this means that the dos can be written as @xmath256 the smooth term contributes to the weyl expansion and requires a separate treatment @xcite . in the following we ignore all such terms .
the derivative @xmath257 in contains two terms , @xmath258 the first term is @xmath259 where the second derivatives of the bessel and hankel functions were resolved via the bessel differential equation .
the second term is @xmath260 \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath261 was replaced by @xmath262 since @xmath263 .
we approximate @xmath264 and obtain @xmath265 it was checked numerically that this approximation is very precise , which is why we still call the result an exact trace formula . combining both terms yields @xmath266 with @xmath267
the dos is , thus , @xmath268 we replace the bessel functions @xmath269 in @xmath270 by @xmath271 and extract a term @xmath272 $ ] with @xmath273 defined in to obtain @xmath274 \
, , \ ] ] where @xmath275 , @xmath276 , and @xmath277 are defined in eqs .
( [ eq : trerm ] ) , ( [ eq : tream ] ) , and ( [ eq : trebm ] ) , respectively . with the help of the geometric series @xmath278 is rewritten as @xmath279 with @xmath280 using the wronskian @xcite @xmath281 = \frac{4 i}{\pi z}\ ] ] this simplifies to @xmath282 and we obtain @xmath283 + \mathrm{c.c . } \ , . \end{array}\ ] ] the first term , @xmath284 , corresponds to the smooth part of the dos .
since we are only interested in the fluctuating part , we drop the term and apply the poisson resummation formula to the rest to obtain @xmath285 with @xmath183 defined in . replacing @xmath286 with @xmath287 and ignoring those @xmath115 combinations that are not related to any pos and , thus ,
do not give significant contributions finally yields .
taking the semiclassical limit as described in ref .
@xcite results in with an additional factor of @xmath187 .
this means that the dispersion of @xmath15 leads to slightly higher amplitudes in the semiclassical limit .
43ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop ( ) \doibase doi:10.1063/1.106688 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.20.002093 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.76.023830 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1807967 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.31.001896 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nnano.2011.99 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 3 - 540 - 85859 - 1_23 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.27.000824 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.67.015207 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.78.016201 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.19.001693 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/385045a0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.79.013830 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/andp.19474360704 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.27.000007 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.65.045603 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.88.094102 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/84/10008 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.82.026202 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase doi:10.1063/1.1665328 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1665596 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _
( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.78.056202 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1751 - 8113/44/15/155305 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.81.066215 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.83.036208 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0003 - 4916(77)90334 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.53.4166 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.89.064101 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1109/jstqe.2005.853848 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.80.023825 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/josab.22.002295 [ * * , ( ) ] in @noop _ _ , , vol . ,
( , , ) pp .
@noop _ _ ( , , ) \doibase doi:10.1088/1367 - 2630/8/3/046 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/13/2/023013 [ * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1109/iceaa.2010.5653856 [ _ _ ] ( ) p.
link : www.rohacell.com [ ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.66.056207 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ , edited by , vol .
( , , ) | the length spectra of flat three - dimensional dielectric resonators of circular shape were determined from a microwave experiment .
they were compared to a semiclassical trace formula obtained within a two - dimensional model based on the effective index of refraction approximation and a good agreement was found .
it was necessary to take into account the dispersion of the effective index of refraction for the two - dimensional approximation .
furthermore , small deviations between the experimental length spectrum and the trace formula prediction were attributed to the systematic error of the effective index of refraction approximation . in summary , the methods developed in this article enable the application of the trace formula for two - dimensional dielectric resonators also to realistic , flat three - dimensional dielectric microcavities and -lasers , allowing for the interpretation of their spectra in terms of classical periodic orbits . |
the characterization of states and operations at the quantum level plays a leading role in the development of quantum technology .
a state reconstruction technique is a method that provides the complete description of a physical system upon the measurements of an observable or a set of observables @xcite .
an effective reconstruction technique gives the maximum possible knowledge of the state , thus allowing one to make the best , at least the best probabilistic , predictions on the results of any measurement that may be performed on the system . at a first sight
, there is an unavoidable tradeoff between the complexity of the detection scheme and the amount of extractable information , which can be used to reconstruct the quantum state @xcite .
currently , the most effective quantum state reconstruction technique for the radiation field is quantum homodyne tomography @xcite , which requires the measurement of a continuous set of field quadrature and allows for the reliable reconstruction of any quantity expressible in terms of an expectation value @xcite .
a question arises on whether the tradeoff may be overcome by a suitable experimental configuration or it corresponds to some fundamental limitations . here
we demonstrate that no specific discrimination power is required to the detector in either amplitude or phase , and that full state reconstruction is possible by a suitable processing of the data obtained with detectors revealing light in the simplest way , i.e. on / off detectors , such as single - photon avalanche photodiodes . of course , some form of phase and/or amplitude modulation is necessary , which , in our scheme , is imposed to the field before the detection stage .
in fact , our technique is built on the completeness of any set of displaced number states @xcite and the reliable maximum likelihood reconstruction of arbitrary photon - number distributions @xcite from on / off data .
the paper is structured as follows . in section [ s : rec ] we describe our reconstruction method , whereas in section [ s : exp ] the experimental setup used in the reconstruction is described in some details .
results are illustrated in section [ s : res ] and the error analysis is reported in section [ s : err ] . in section [ s : dis ]
we discuss few additional topics while section [ s : out ] closes the paper with some concluding remarks .
we start to describe our reconstruction technique by observing that the modulation of a given signal , described by the density matrix @xmath0 , corresponds to the application of a coherent displacement ( probe ) @xmath1 , @xmath2 . in practice
, it can be easily obtained by mixing the state under investigation with a known coherent reference in a beam - splitter or a mach - zehnder interferometer @xcite . upon varying amplitude and phase of the coherent reference and/or the overall transmissivity of the interferometer
, the modulation may be tuned in a relatively broad range of values . the main idea behind our method is simple : the photon distributions of coherently modulated signals , i.e. the diagonal elements @xmath3 of the density matrix @xmath4 , contain relevant information about the complete density matrix of the original signal @xmath0 . upon measuring or reconstructing the photon distribution @xmath5 for different values of the modulation one has enough information for full state reconstruction .
by re - writing the above relation as @xmath6 , the off diagonal matrix elements may be recovered upon inversion by least square method , i.e. @xcite @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the number of modulating phases , @xmath9 the truncation dimension of the fock space , and @xmath10 depends only on @xmath11 @xcite .
state reconstruction by the above formula requires , in principle , only phase modulation of the signal under investigation .
maximum likelihood methods and iterative procedures may be also used @xcite .
on the other hand , the wigner function may be reconstructed using its very definition in terms of displacement @xcite @xmath12 = \sum_n ( -)^n\ , p_n ( \alpha)\:.\ ] ] as a matter of fact , the measurement of the photon distribution is challenging as photo - detectors that can operate as photon counters are rather rare and affected either by a low quantum efficiency @xcite or require cryogenic conditions , thus impairing common use @xcite .
therefore , a method with displacement but without photo - counting has been used so far only for states in the 0 - 1 subspace of the fock space @xcite . on the other hand ,
the experimental reconstructions of photon - number distributions for both continuous - wave and pulsed light beams is possible using simple on / off single - photon avalanche photodetectors .
this requires the collection of the frequencies of the _ off _ events , @xmath13 at different quantum efficiencies of the detector , @xmath14 .
the data are then used in a recursive maximum likelihood reconstruction algorithm that yields the photon - number distributions as @xmath15),\ ] ] where @xmath16 and @xmath17 is the probability of _ off _ events calculated from the reconstructed distribution at the @xmath18th iteration @xcite .
the effectiveness of the method has been demonstrated for single - mode @xcite and multimode fields @xcite , and also applied to improve quantum key distribution @xcite . since the implementation of the modulation is relatively easy , we have thus a reconstruction technique which provides the quantum state of radiation modes and requires only avalanche detectors , without any phase or amplitude discrimination power . here
, we develop the idea into a proper reconstruction technique and demonstrate the reconstruction of the wigner function @xcite and the density matrix for different states of the optical field .
we have performed two experiments for the reconstruction of the wigner function and the density matrix respectively . in fig .
[ f : setup ] we sketch the corresponding experimental setups : the upper panel for the measurement of the wigner function and the lower panel for the density matrix ( lower panel ) . the first set of measurements was performed on ps - pulsed light fields at 523 nm wavelength .
the light source was the second - harmonic output of a nd : ylf mode - locked laser amplified at 5 khz ( high q laser production ) delivering pulses of @xmath19 ps duration .
the field , spatially filtered by means of a confocal telescope , was split into two parts to give both signal and probe .
the photon - number distribution of the probe was kept poissonian , while the coherent photon - number distribution of the signal field was modified in order to get suitable states of light . in particular , we have generated two phase - insensitive classical states , namely a phase - averaged coherent state and a single - mode thermal state .
the first one was obtained by changing the relative phase between signal and probe fields at a frequency of @xmath20 hz by means of a piezoelectric movement ( pz in the upper panel of fig .
[ f : setup ] ) , covering 1.28 @xmath21 m span . on the other hand , to get the single - mode thermal state we inserted an arecchi s rotating ground glass disk on the pathway of the signal field followed by a pin - hole that selected a single coherence area .
signal and probe fields were mixed in an unpolarizing cube beam - splitter ( bs ) and a portion of the exiting field was sent , through a multimode optical fiber ( 600 @xmath21 m core - diameter ) , to a hybrid photodetector module ( hpd , mod .
h8236 - 40 , hamamatsu , maximum quantum efficiency @xmath22=0.4 at 550 nm ) .
although the detector is endowed with partial photon resolving capability , we used it as a simple on / off detector by setting a threshold at the value corresponding to zero detected photons .
its output current pulses were suitably gate - integrated by a sr250 module ( stanford research systems , ca ) and sampled to produce a voltage , which was digitized and recorded at each shot . in order to modulate the amplitude of the probe field ,
a variable neutral density filter was placed on its pathway .
the maximum overall detection efficiency , calculated by including the losses of the collection optics , was @xmath23 .
we used a polarizer put in front of the fiber to vary the quantum efficiency of the detection chain from @xmath24 to 0 .
here we illustrate the reconstruction obtained for the wigner function and the density matrix of phase - averaged coherent states and thermal states , as obtained by our method after recording the on / off statistics of amplitude- and/or phase - modulated signals . .
the two insets show the reconstructed photon distributions for @xmath25 and @xmath26 , corresponding to the off distributions indicated by the arrows .
the vertical black bars denote the mean value of the photon number for the two distributions ( @xmath27 , upper , and @xmath28 , lower ) . in the lower left plot
we report the corresponding reconstructed wigner function . in the lower right plot
we report the wigner functions for signals in ( blue ) thermal state and ( yellow , with sharper peak ) vacuum .
[ f : wsamm ] ] in fig .
[ f : wsamm ] we report the reconstructed wigner functions for a phase - averaged coherent state with real amplitude @xmath29 and a thermal state with average number of photons @xmath30 . the wigner function of the vacuum state is also reported for comparison . as it is apparent from the plots all the relevant features of the wigner functions
are well recovered , including oscillations and the broadening due to thermal noise . in this case
raw data are frequencies of the _ off _ event ( collected over 30000 laser shots ) as a function of detector efficiency , taken at different amplitudes of the modulating field , whereas the intermediate step corresponds to the reconstruction of the @xmath5 .
the insets of fig .
[ f : wsamm ] display @xmath5 for the phase - averaged coherent state at two values of the modulation . and @xmath31 .
in the lower left plot ( left ) we report the corresponding reconstructed density matrix in the fock representation ( diagonal and subdiagonal elements ) . in the lower right plot
we report the density matrix for the signal excited in a thermal state .
[ f : dmphm ] ] the second set of measurements has been performed to achieve state reconstruction with phase modulation . here
the light source was a he - ne laser beam attenuated to single - photon regime by neutral density filters .
the spatial profile of the beam was purified from non - gaussian components by a spatial filter . beyond a beam - splitter ,
part of the beam was addressed to a control detector in order to monitor the laser amplitude fluctuations , while the remaining part was sent to a mach - zehnder interferometer .
a piezo - movement system allowed changing the phase between the `` short '' and `` long '' paths by driving the position of the reflecting prism with nanometric resolution and high stability .
the beam on the short arm represented the probe , while the beam on the long arm was the state to be reconstructed . in the first acquisition
the signal was the coherent state itself while in the second acquisition it was a pseudo - thermal state generated as described above .
the detector , a perkin - elmer single photon avalanche photodiode ( spcm - aqr ) with quantum efficiency @xmath32 , was gated by a 20 ns time window at a repetition rate of 200 khz . to obtain a reasonable statistics , a single run consisted of 5 repetitions of acquisitions lasting 4 s each . in the bottom part of fig .
[ f : dmphm ] we report the reconstructed density matrix in the fock representation ( diagonal and subdiagonal ) for a coherent state with real amplitude @xmath33 and a thermal state with average number of photons equal to @xmath34 . as it is apparent from the plots the off - diagonal elements are correctly reproduced in both cases despite the limited visibility . here
the raw data are frequencies of the _ off _ event as a function of the detector efficiency , taken at different phase modulations , @xmath35 , whereas the intermediate step corresponds to the reconstruction of the photon distribution for the phase - modulated signals . in our experiments
we used @xmath36 and @xmath37 for the coherent state and @xmath38 for the thermal state .
the use of a larger @xmath8 would allow the reliable reconstruction of far off - diagonal elements , which is not possible in the present configuration . in the insets of fig .
[ f : dmphm ] we report the reconstructed distributions at the minimum and maximum of the interference fringes .
the evaluation of uncertainties on the reconstructed states involves the contributions of experimental fluctuations of on / off frequencies as well as the statistical fluctuations connected with photon - number reconstruction .
it has been argued @xcite that fluctuations involved in the reconstruction of the photon distribution may generally result in substantial limitations in the information obtainable on the quantum state , e.g. in the case of multipeaked distributions @xcite . for our purposes
this implies that neither large displacement amplitudes may be employed , nor states with large field and/or energy may be reliably reconstructed , although the mean values of the fields measured here are definitely non - negligible . on the other hand , for the relevant regime of weak field or low energy , observables characterizing the quantum state
can be safely evaluated from experimental data , including e.g. the parity operator used to reconstruct the wigner function in the phase - space . in our experiments ,
the errors on the reconstructed wigner function are of the order of the size of the symbols in fig .
[ f : dmphm ] whereas the absolute errors @xmath39 on the reconstruction of the density matrix in the fock basis are reported in fig .
[ f : err ] . between reconstructed and theoretical values of the density matrix elements for the coherent ( left ) and thermal ( right ) states used in our experiments .
we have so far reconstructed the wigner function and the density matrix for coherent and thermal states . the extension to highly nonclassical states
does not require qualitative changes in the setups .
the only difference stays in the displacement , which should be obtained with high transmissivity beam splitter in order to avoid mixing of the signal @xcite . as our method involves a beam splitter where the signal interferes with a reference state in order to obtain the displacement , we have optimized the effectiveness of mode matching and of the overall scheme by standard visibility test . we note that in this point our technique is similar to quantum homodyne tomography ( qht ) , where the signal is amplified by the mixing at a beam splitter with a strong local oscillator .
the main difference with standard qht , however , is the spectral domain of the measurement , which for qht is confined to the sideband chosen for the measurement , while it is not in our case . the use of pulsed temporal homodyning @xcite would remove this limitation of qht
however , this technique is still challenging from the experimental point of view and thus of limited use .
the effect of photodetectors efficiency should be also taken into account .
this is a crucial issue for qht , which may even prevent effective reconstruction @xcite . for the present on / off reconstrucion
, it does not dramatically affect the accuracy @xcite .
notice also that any uncertainty in the nominal efficiency @xmath24 of the involved photodetectors does not substantially affect the reconstruction @xcite .
we stress that our method is especially suited for low excited states , as it does not involve intense fields and delicate balancing to reveal the relevant quantum fluctuations .
in conclusion , we have demonstrated a state reconstruction technique providing wigner function and density matrix of a field mode starting from on / off photodetection of amplitude- and/or phase - modulated versions of the signal under investigation .
our scheme is little demanding as to the detectors , with the amplitude and phase control required for full state characterization transferred to the optical setup , and appears to be reliable and simple especially for states with small number of photons .
we foresee a possible widespread use in emerging quantum technologies like quantum information , metrology and lithography .
this work has been partially supported by the cnr - cnism agreement , eu project qucandela , compagnia di san paolo , miur - prin-2007fyetby ( ccqots ) , and regione piemonte ( e14 ) .
99 g. m. dariano , l. maccone , and m. g. a. paris , j. phys .
a , * 34 * , 93 ( 2001 ) . y. bogdanov et al . , jetp lett . *
82 * , 180 ( 2005 ) ; c. marquardt et al . , phys .
lett . * 99 * , 220401 ( 2007 ) .
d. g. welsch et al . , prog . opt . * 39 * , 63 ( 1999 ) . , lect . not .
* 649 * , m. g. a. paris and j. rehacek eds .
( springer , berlin , 2004 ) ; a. i. lvovsky and m. g. raymer , rev .
phys . * 81 * , 299 ( 2009 ) .
d.t . smithey et al . , phys .
lett . * 70 * , 1244 ( 1993 ) ; g. breitenbach et al . ,
nature * 387 * , 471 ( 1997 ) ; m. vasilyev et al .
lett . * 84 * , 2354 ( 2000 ) ; i. lvovsky et al .
87 * , 050402 ( 2001 ) ; v. parigi et al . ,
science * 317 * , 1891 ( 2008 ) ; v. dauria et al .
* 102 * , 020502 ( 2009 ) .
s. wallentowitz and w. vogel , phys .
a * 53 * , 4528 ( 1996 ) .
k. banaszek and k. wodkiewicz , phys .
76 * , 4344 ( 1996 ) .
d. leibfried et al .
lett . * 77 * , 4281 ( 1996 ) .
t. opatrny and d. g. welsch , phys .
rev a * 55 * , 1462 ( 1997 ) .
t. opatrny , d. g. welsch , and w. vogel , phys .
rev a * 56 * , 1788 ( 1997 ) .
k. banaszek et al . , phys .
a * 60 * , 674 ( 1999 ) ; act .
. slov . * 49 * , 643 ( 1999 ) .
g. zambra et al . , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 063602 ( 2005 ) ; g. brida et al . , las
* 16 * , 385 ( 2006 ) ; g. brida et al .
, open syst . & inf . dyn .
* 13 * , 333 ( 2006 ) ; m. bondani et al . ,
( in press ) arxiv:0810.4026 .
m. g. a. paris , phys .
a * 217 * , 78 ( 1996 ) .
z. hradil , d. mogilevtsev , and j. ehek , phys .
96 * , 230401 ( 2006 ) ; new j. phys . *
10 * , 043022 ( 2008 ) .
k. e. cahill and r. j. glauber , phys . rev . *
177 * , 1882 ( 1969 ) .
g. zambra , m. bondani , a. s. spinelli , and a. andreoni , rev .
* 75 * , 2762 ( 2004 ) .
j. kim , s. takeuchi , y. yamamoto , and h.h .
hogue , appl .
. lett . * 74 * , 902 ( 1999 ) ; a. peacock et al . ,
nature * 381 * , 135 ( 1996 ) ; a.e.lita et al . ,
opt . exp . 16
( 2008 ) 3032 .
g. di giuseppe , a. v. sergienko , b. e. a. saleh , and m. c. teich in _ quantum information and computation _
, e. donkor , a. r. pirich , and h. e. brandt eds .
, proceedings of the spie * 5105 * , 39 ( 2003 ) .
a. r. rossi , s. olivares , and m. g. a. paris , phys .
a * 70 * , 055801 ( 2004 ) .
g. brida et al . , opt . lett . * 31 * , 3508 ( 2006 ) .
t. moroder et al . , arxiv:0811.0027v1 k. laiho , m. avenhaus , k. n. cassemiro , ch .
silberhorn , new j. phys . * 11 * , 043012 ( 2009 ) .
k. banaszek and k. wodkiewicz , j. mod .
* 44 * , 2441 ( 1997 ) .
k. banaszek , j. mod . opt . * 46 * , 675 ( 1999 ) .
g. zambra and m. g. a. paris , phys .
a * 74 * , 063830 ( 2006 ) .
h. hansen , t. aichele , c. hettich , p. lodahl , a. i. lvovsky , j. mlynek , s. schiller , opt .
* 26 * , 1714 ( 2001 ) .
a. zavatta , m. bellini , p .
l. ramazza , f. marin , f. t. arecchi , j. opt .
1189 ( 2002 ) . t. hirano , h. yamanaka , m. ashikaga , i. konishi , r. namiki , phys .
a68 , 042331 ( 2003 ) .
j. wenger , r. tualle - brouri , p. grangier , opt .
* 29 * 1267 ( 2004 ) .
y. eto , t. tajima , y. zhang y , t. hirano , opt .
lett . * 32 * , 1698 ( 2007 ) .
g. m. dariano , m. g. a paris , and m. f. sacchi , adv .
. phys . * 128 * , 205 ( 2003 ) . | we demonstrate a state reconstruction technique which provides either the wigner function or the density matrix of a field mode and requires only avalanche photodetectors , without any phase or amplitude discrimination power .
it represents an alternative to quantum homodyne tomography of simpler implementation . |
cosmological general relativity ( cgr ) is a 5-d time - space - velocity theory@xcite of the cosmos , for one dimension of cosmic time , three of space and one of the universe expansion velocity .
cosmic time is taken to increase from the present epoch @xmath32 toward the big bang time @xmath33 , where @xmath3 is the hubble - carmeli time constant .
the expansion velocity @xmath34 at the present epoch and increases toward the big bang . in this paper the cosmic time @xmath35
is held fixed ( @xmath36 ) and measurements are referred to the present epoch of cosmic time .
this is a reasonable approach since the time duration over which observations are made is negligible compared to the travel time of the emitted light from the distant galaxy .
hence , in this paper we examine the four - dimensional ( 4-d ) space - velocity of cgr .
a general solution to the einstein field equations in the space - velocity domain is obtained , analogous to the friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker ( flrw ) solution of space - time cosmology .
the main emphasis herein is to develop a cosmology having a scale factor @xmath37 dependent on the expansion velocity which in turn can be expressed in terms of the cosmological redshift @xmath38 .
this will enable a set of well defined tools for the analysis of observational data where the cosmological redshift plays a central role .
the resulting cosmology is used to model a small set of sne ia data .
we will derive carmeli s cosmology as a special case where the scale factor is held fixed .
two principal results of carmeli s cosmology is the prediction of the accelerated expansion of the universe@xcite and the description of spiral galaxy rotation curves without additional dark matter@xcite . we continue to support those results within this paper with a theoretical framework that accommodates a more varied parameter space . for our purposes , a vacuum mass density @xmath11 is defined in terms of a cosmological constant @xmath12 by @xmath39 where the carmeli gravitational coupling constant @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the speed of light in vacuum and @xmath3 is the hubble - carmeli time constant . in a previous article@xcite
we hypothesized that the observable universe is one of two black holes joined at their event horizons . from this perspective
we show that the vacuum density of the observable universe and the universe black hole entropy have the relation @xmath40 , where @xmath41 is the bekenstein - hawking entropy@xcite of the black hole .
we also will use an evolving two parameter equation of state @xmath42 , dependent on the scale factor @xmath37 , which allows for the evolution of the effect of dark energy on the pressure@xcite .
assuming the matter in the universe to be isotropically distributed we will adopt a metric that is spatially spherical symmetric . furthermore , the spatial coordinates will be co - moving such that galaxies expanding along the same geodesic curve are motionless with respect to one another . in this manner
we can compare observations between galaxies moving along different geodesic paths .
a general derivation of the metric we will use was given by tolman@xcite and is taken in the simplified form defined by @xmath43 where @xmath1 is the metric tensor .
the comoving coordinates are @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the hubble - carmeli time constant , @xmath4 is the universe expansion velocity and @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the spatial coordinates .
assume that the functions @xmath8 and @xmath9 are functions of coordinates @xmath10 and @xmath5 .
the constant @xmath3 is related to the hubble constant @xmath44 at zero distance and zero gravity by the relation @xmath45 where measurements of @xmath44 at very close ( local ) distances are used to determine the value of @xmath46 . at this writing
the accepted value@xcite is @xmath47 therefore @xmath48 from ( [ eq : tolman - line - element ] ) the non - zero components of the metric tensor @xmath1 are given by @xmath49 the choice of the particular metric ( [ eq : tolman - line - element ] ) determines that the 4-velocity of a point moving along the geodesic curve is given by @xmath50 the universe expands by the null condition @xmath51 . for a spherically symmetric expansion one has @xmath52 .
the metric ( [ eq : tolman - line - element ] ) then gives @xmath53 which yields @xmath54 to determine the functions @xmath8 and @xmath9 we need to solve the einstein field equations .
the einstein field equations with a cosmological constant @xmath12 term are taken in the form @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the ricci tensor , @xmath57 is the energy - momentum tensor , @xmath58 is its trace and @xmath59 is carmeli s gravitational coupling constant given by @xmath60 where @xmath25 is newton s gravitational constant and @xmath15 is the speed of light in vacuum .
if we add the tensor @xmath61 to the ricci tensor @xmath56 , the covariant derivative of the new tensor is still zero . that is @xmath62 since the covariant derivatives of the ricci tensor and the metric tensor are both zero .
we will move the cosmological constant term from the left hand side ( l.h.s . ) to the right hand side ( r.h.s . ) of ( [ eq : field - eqs-0 ] ) to make it a component of the energy - momentum tensor giving @xmath63 since the covariant derivative of the energy - momentum tensor @xmath64 , the covariant derivative of the r.h.s . of ( [ eq : field - eqs-1 ] ) equals zero .
the @xmath12 term is absorbed into a new energy - momentum tensor by the form @xmath65 , \label{eq : tuv_def}\ ] ] where @xmath18 is the mass density , @xmath19 is the pressure and @xmath66 is the 4-velocity .
the @xmath67 factor on the r.h.s . of ( [ eq : tuv_def ] ) is an artifact of convenience in solving the field equations . taking the trace @xmath68 of the new energy - momentum tensor yields @xmath69 \label{eq : t - trace-1 } \\
\nonumber \\ & = & \tau^2 \rho - 3 \frac { \tau } { c } p - 4 \tau^2 \left ( \frac{\lambda } { \tau^2 \kappa } \right ) .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] define the vacuum mass density @xmath11 in terms of the cosmological constant @xmath12 , @xmath70 by this definition we are defining @xmath11 to be a negative density , unless @xmath12 is negative .
this is contrary to the design of the standard model but is in keeping with the behar - carmeli cosmological model@xcite .
then in terms of the vacuum mass density @xmath11 , define the effective mass density and effective pressure , @xmath71 and @xmath72 with the definitions for the effective mass density and the effective pressure the energy - momentum tensor ( [ eq : tuv_def ] ) becomes @xmath20 .
\label{eq : t_uv_eff}\ ] ] in terms of the effective mass density and pressure the only non - zero components of @xmath73 are given by @xmath74 the trace of @xmath73 in terms of the effective mass density and pressure is @xmath75 substituting for the defined values of @xmath76 and @xmath77 , the trace ( [ eq : t - eff ] ) expands out to @xmath78 which is equal to ( [ eq : t - trace-1 ] ) .
with our definition for the new energy - momentum tensor the field equations now take the form @xmath79 here we write out the nonvanishing components of the ricci tensor .
a dot @xmath80 denotes partial differentiation with respect to @xmath81 and a prime @xmath82 denotes partial differentiation with respect to @xmath83 .
this follows@xcite , ( sect . 4.3 . ) @xmath84 expanding the r.h.s . of the field equations ( [ eq : field - eqs - new ] )
yields @xmath85 we obtain our first independent field equation by multiplying ( [ eq : r11=t11-g11t/2 ] ) by @xmath86 and adding the result to ( [ eq : r00=t00-g00t/2 ] ) .
this operation will eliminate the @xmath87 and @xmath88 terms leaving @xmath89 by multiplying ( [ eq : r22=t22-g22t/2 ] ) by @xmath90 and adding the result to ( [ eq : basic-1a ] ) , the @xmath91 and @xmath77 terms will be eliminated leaving @xmath92 = \kappa \tau^2 \rho_{eff}. \label{eq : basic-1b}\ ] ] the next basic independent field equation is obtained by substituting for the value of the expression @xmath93 in ( [ eq : basic-1b ] ) . to do that , multiply ( [ eq : r22=t22-g22t/2 ] ) by @xmath94 and move all other terms to the r.h.s . leaving @xmath95 substitute the expression in ( [ eq : basic-2a ] ) for its corresponding expression in ( [ eq : basic-1b ] ) . after eliminating some terms , combining other terms , multiplying both sides by @xmath96 and then simplifying , we obtain the next basic field equation
@xmath97 we restate the last basic field equation we need , which is ( [ eq : r01=t01-g01t/2 ] ) , @xmath98 equations ( [ eq : basic-1b ] ) , ( [ eq : basic-2b ] ) , ( [ eq : basic-3 ] ) correspond to carmelis@xcite eqns .
( 4.3.31 ) , ( 4.3.29 ) and ( 4.3.30 ) respectively .
equation ( [ eq : basic-3 ] ) can be partially integrated with respect to @xmath81 , keeping @xmath5 constant . integrating it we have @xmath99 with the result @xmath100 which can be put in the form @xmath101 where @xmath102 is an arbitrary function .
the integration constants @xmath103 and @xmath104 are both evaluated at some particular value of coordinate @xmath105 so they can only be functions of coordinate @xmath5 . thus @xmath102 is a function of @xmath5 only . we can then write ( [ eq : int - mu-1b ] ) in the useful form @xmath106 since the l.h.s
. of ( [ eq : int - mu-1c ] ) is positive definite , the r.h.s .
is likewise , implying that the condition on @xmath107 is @xmath108 the solution ( [ eq : int - mu-1c ] ) is the same as@xcite , eqn .
( 4.3.16 ) . for the function @xmath9 we assume the general form @xmath109 where @xmath110 is a function of @xmath5 only and @xmath111 is a function of coordinate @xmath10 only .
before proceeding with the solution of ( [ eq : basic-2b ] ) , which has the pressure @xmath77 , we first determine the relevant partial derivatives of ( [ eq : r = rrv ] ) , @xmath112 substituting for @xmath113 and the above derivatives into ( [ eq : basic-2b ] ) yields @xmath114 - \left ( r^{'}_r \right)^2 r^2_v \label{eq : basic-2b - sol-1a } \\
\nonumber \\ & = & -\kappa \frac{\tau}{c } \left ( \frac{\left ( r^{'}_r \right)^2 r^2_v } { 1 + f \left ( r \right ) } \right ) r^2_r r^2_v p_{eff}. \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] multiply ( [ eq : basic-2b - sol-1a ] ) by @xmath115 , gather terms and simplify to obtain @xmath116 assuming the pressure @xmath77 is not a function of @xmath5 , then since the l.h.s . of ( [ eq : basic-2b - sol-1b ] ) is a function of @xmath81 only and the r.h.s .
is a function of @xmath5 only , they both must equal a constant @xmath117 . from the r.h.s .
we conclude that @xmath118 we next solve ( [ eq : basic-1b ] ) which contains the mass density @xmath76 .
however , we need to first determine the derivatives of the function @xmath8 . using ( [ eq : int - mu-1c ] ) we obtain @xmath119 substituting for the functions and derivatives in ( [ eq : basic-1b ] ) we obtain in unsimplified form @xmath120 \nonumber \\ \nonumber \\ & & + \left ( \frac { 2 \dot{r}_v } { r_v } \right ) \left ( \frac { r_r \dot{r}_v } { r_r r_v } \right ) + \left ( \frac { r_r \dot{r}_v } { r_r r_v } \right)^2 + \frac { 1 } { r^2_r r^2_v } = \kappa \tau^2 \rho_{eff}. \label{eq : basic-1b - sol-1a } \end{aligned}\ ] ] this simplifies to @xmath121 - \frac { 1 } { r^2_r } = { \cal f } \left ( v , r \right ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where in general @xmath122 is a function of @xmath4 and @xmath5 . for the function
@xmath123 we now assume the simple form @xmath124 then we have for its derivatives , @xmath125 as we can see , @xmath126 implies that its terms along with the @xmath127 factor drops out of ( [ eq : cal - f - equation ] ) . substituting the solution values ( [ eq : r_r - solution ] ) , ( [ eq : r_r - prime ] ) and ( [ eq : r_r - doubleprime ] ) into the r.h.s . of ( [ eq : cal - f - equation ] ) and simplifying we obtain a first order differential equation of the function @xmath102 given by @xmath128 where @xmath129 because the r.h.s . of ( [ eq : cal - f - equation ] )
has become a function of @xmath5 only , while the l.h.s . is a funcion of @xmath4 only , so they both must equal the constant @xmath130 . by ( [ eq : f - function - form ] ) and ( [ eq : r_r - solution ] ) we obtain @xmath131 which implies that , for this solution of @xmath132 , @xmath133 if @xmath134 then ( [ eq : f(r)-inhomo - sol ] ) is the solution to the inhomogeneous differential equation ( [ eq : f - differential ] ) . if @xmath135 then the homogeneous solution is @xmath136 where the coordinate system is centered on the central mass @xmath137 .
the general solution to ( [ eq : f - differential ] ) is the sum of ( [ eq : f(r)-inhomo - sol ] ) and ( [ eq : fr)-homo - sol ] ) , @xmath138 from ( [ eq : cal - f - equation ] ) we have @xmath139 to obtain a value for @xmath117 from ( [ eq : basic-1b - sol-1b ] ) , assuming @xmath140 and @xmath141 , multiply the l.h.s .
by @xmath142 and rearrange the result to obtain @xmath143 where @xmath144 is the hubble parameterdefined by @xmath145 and @xmath146 is the critical density defined by @xmath147 notice that ( [ eq : fo - val-1a0 ] ) is true at any epoch of coordinate @xmath148 , so we will evaluate it at @xmath149 .
we define the scale factor @xmath37 , the hubble parameter @xmath144 , the effective mass density @xmath76 and the critical density @xmath146 to have the values at the present epoch , @xmath150 where @xmath151 is the mass density and @xmath152 is the critical density at the present epoch @xmath34 . with the values from ( [ eq : rv0])-([eq : rho_c0 ] ) put into ( [ eq : fo - val-1a0 ] ) we have @xmath153 \label{eq : fo - val-1a } \\
\nonumber \\ & = & \frac{-1 } { c^2 \tau^2 } \left [ \omega_m + \omega_{\lambda } - 1 \right ] \nonumber \\ \nonumber \\ & = & -k , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath154 where @xmath155 is the matter mass density parameter at the present epoch ( @xmath34 ) , @xmath156 is the constant vacuum mass density parameter , and @xmath157 is the curvature .
note that the curvature @xmath157 has the dimension of @xmath158^{-2}$ ] .
as will be shown , the type of spatial geometry , hyperbolic ( open ) , euclidean ( flat ) or spherical ( closed ) , is determined by the curvature @xmath157 which in turn depends on the mass and vacuum densities .
this compares with the standard model where the type of geometry is determined by the dimensionless curvature parameter @xmath159 or @xmath160 , for open , flat or closed , respectively .
the scale radius @xmath161 is given by @xmath162 with the value for @xmath117 from ( [ eq : fo - val-1a ] ) , with no central mass @xmath137 , @xmath113 takes the form @xmath163
for @xmath51 , ( [ eq : dr / dv-0 ] ) describes the isotropic expansion of the universe . using ( [ eq : emu ] ) for @xmath113
, the expansion can be described by @xmath164 @xmath165 to show the relation of the scale factor @xmath37 to the cosmological redshift @xmath38 , suppose an observer in a galaxy a measures the expansion velocities of two other galaxies `` g '' and `` g+@xmath166 '' which is nearby galaxy `` g '' . the velocities for the galaxies are @xmath167 and @xmath168 respectively .
suppose that another observer in another galaxy o measures expansion velocities for galaxies `` g '' and `` g+@xmath166 '' and obtains the values @xmath169 and @xmath170 respectively .
we assume that @xmath171 and @xmath172 are small compared to @xmath167 and @xmath169 , respectively , since galaxies `` g '' and
`` g+@xmath166 '' are near each other .
what can we say about the relationship between these measured velocities from galaxies a and o ? assume the distance to galaxy a is @xmath173 and the distance to galaxy o is @xmath174 .
the galaxies are comoving which implies that the distance @xmath175 between them is constant .
for the galaxy `` g '' , we integrate ( [ eq : drar = dvbv-00 ] ) between the points @xmath176 and @xmath177 @xmath178 for the galaxy `` g+@xmath166 '' we integrate ( [ eq : drar = dvbv-00 ] ) between the points @xmath179 and @xmath180 , @xmath181 subtracting ( [ eq : int - galax - g ] ) from ( [ eq : int - galax - g+dg ] ) we obtain @xmath182 after some manipulations of the integrals ( [ eq : int - galax - diff - vel ] ) reduces to @xmath183 where @xmath184 is the approximate value of the assumed slowly varying scale factor over the small velocity interval @xmath185 , and likewise for @xmath186 over the small interval @xmath187 . ( [ eq : int - delta - vo , delta - va ] ) can be put into the form @xmath188 if in galaxy a the distance @xmath189 is determined by the measurement of @xmath190 of the wavelength of photons from galaxy `` g + @xmath191 '' , then in galaxy o the corresponding measurement of the photons from the same galaxy will have a wavelength @xmath192 . the ratio of the two wavelengths is assumed to be given by ( [ eq : distance - ratio-1 ] ) , @xmath193 where @xmath38 is the cosmological redshift of the photon .
if we take galaxy o to be the local galaxy then @xmath194 and we set the scale factor of the local galaxy to unity , @xmath195 . then setting @xmath196 for the velocity of a general galaxy
a , ( [ eq : distance - ratio-3 ] ) can be put into the familiar form of the scale factor redshift relation , @xmath197 where @xmath198 where @xmath190 is the photon wavelength detected by distant galaxy a and @xmath192 is the wavelength observed in the local galaxy .
by substituting the r.h.s . of ( [ eq : basic-1b - sol-1b ] ) into its relevant term in ( [ eq : basic-2b - sol-1b ] ) and simplifying we obtain @xmath199 we can obtain another expression for @xmath200 by differentiating ( [ eq : basic-1b - sol-1b ] ) with respect to ( w.r.t . ) @xmath148 which , after simplifying gives @xmath201 combining ( [ eq : r - doubledot-1 ] ) and ( [ eq : r - doubledot-2 ] ) and simplifying gives us the effective mass density continuity equation @xmath202 simplifying ( [ eq : eff - mass - continuity ] ) yields @xmath203 this mass density continuity equation ( [ eq : mass - continuity ] ) is identical in form to the energy density continuity equation of the standard flrw model except that here the rate of mass density change is w.r.t .
expansion velocity @xmath4 while the standard model rate is w.r.t .
cosmic time @xmath35 .
we choose an evolving equation of state parameter@xcite @xmath204 such that the pressure @xmath19 is related to the mass density @xmath18 by @xmath205 where @xmath206 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are constants .
the second term on the r.h.s . of ( [ eq : we - def ] ) represents the evolution of the equation of state as a function of expansion velocity .
in particular , this functional form allows for a state equation to vary from low dark energy influence when the scale factor @xmath37 was small into becoming dominated by dark energy at the current unity scale factor . substituting for @xmath19 from ( [ eq : p - w - rho ] ) into ( [ eq : mass - continuity ] ) we obtain @xmath207 ( [ eq : mass - w - cont ] )
can be put into the form @xmath208 which upon integration yields @xmath209 divide ( [ eq : rho = rho0*rv ] ) by @xmath152 to get the mass density parameter @xmath210 converting @xmath37 in terms of the redshift @xmath38 from ( [ eq : cosmo - redshift - relation ] ) , ( [ eq : omega = omega_m*r_v ] ) for @xmath211 becomes @xmath212
with the equation of state ( [ eq : p - w - rho ] ) the effective pressure becomes @xmath213 by substituting the r.h.s . of ( [ eq : basic-1b - sol-1b ] ) into its relevant term in ( [ eq : basic-2b - sol-1b ] ) and simplifying we obtain @xmath214 substitute for effective pressure from ( [ eq : eqn - of - state-1 ] ) into ( [ eq : r - doubledot-3 ] ) and simplify to obtain the scale factor acceleration equation @xmath215 r_v .
\label{eq : r - doubledot-3 - 0}\ ] ] this can be put into the form @xmath216 where @xmath217 is given by ( [ eq : omega = omega_m*r_v ] ) and @xmath156 is the vacuum mass density parameter .
( [ eq : r - doubledot-3 - 2 ] ) exhibits a range of possible senarios for accelerating and decelerating expansions depending on @xmath204 and on the values for @xmath155 and @xmath156 .
it was discovered experimentally that the expanding universe makes a transition from accelerating to decelerating@xcite .
assume that the transition took place at velocity @xmath218 corresponding to a redshift @xmath219 .
then , taking ( [ eq : r - doubledot-3 - 2 ] ) and setting @xmath220 at @xmath221 we have an expression for @xmath204 in terms of the transition redshift @xmath219 , @xmath222 \omega_{z_t } - 2 \omega_{\lambda } = 0 , \label{eq : w_e - formula}\ ] ] where @xmath223 .
this expression can be used to obtain a value for @xmath219 in terms of the fitted parameters @xmath155 , @xmath156 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
we will encounter the transition redshift in the section on modeling .
the scale radius of the universe given by ( [ eq : scale - radius - r0-def ] ) can be put into the form @xmath224 the value of @xmath155 is the mass density at the present epoch of cosmic time @xmath32 , recalling that in cgr the cosmic time is measured from the present time @xmath32 increasing toward the big bang time @xmath225 . assuming the universe is a black hole@xcite of radius @xmath161 , then the event horizon surface area @xmath226 is given by @xmath227 then the bekenstein - hawking@xcite entropy @xmath41 of the black hole universe is given by @xmath228 where @xmath229 is boltzmann s constant and @xmath230 is planck s constant over @xmath231 .
multiplying the r.h.s .
of ( [ eq : s - entropy - critical - mass ] ) by @xmath232 and simplifying we obtain @xmath233 where @xmath234 , @xmath235 and @xmath236 is the cosmological planck mass density defined by @xmath237 where @xmath238 is the cosmological planck mass and @xmath239 is the cosmological planck length . by eqs .
( [ eq : s - entropy - critical - mass]-[eq : planck_length ] ) , since @xmath240 observationally , and since the entropy is always non - negative , then a positive vacuum mass density implies a positive cosmological planck mass density and visa - versa for a negative vacuum density .
a deeper analysis into the relation between black hole entropy and the vacuum mass density is beyond the scope of this paper .
( [ eq : basic-1b - sol-1b ] ) can be put into the form @xmath241 where we used ( [ eq : rho_eff_fin ] ) for @xmath242 , @xmath217 is given by ( [ eq : omega = omega_m*r_v ] ) and @xmath243 is the curvature density parameter .
we select the minus sign in the r.h.s . of ( [ eq : drv / dv ] ) because @xmath37 is assumed to be a decreasing function of @xmath4 .
( [ eq : dr / dv-0 ] ) describes the isotropic expansion of the universe . using ( [ eq : emu ] ) for @xmath113
, the expansion can be described by @xmath244 from ( [ eq : drv / dv ] ) we obtain @xmath245 substituting for @xmath246 from ( [ eq : dv = drv / c ] ) into the l.h.s . of ( [ eq :
drar = dvbv ] ) and simplifying we derive @xmath247 from ( [ eq : cosmo - redshift - relation ] ) the scale factor @xmath37 is related to the cosmological redshift @xmath38 by @xmath248 differentiating ( [ eq : rv - z ] ) w.r.t .
@xmath38 gives @xmath249 substituting for @xmath37 and @xmath250 from ( [ eq : rv - z ] ) and ( [ eq : drv / dz ] ) into ( [ eq : dvbv = drar ] ) and simplifying yields the differential for the comoving distance relation @xmath251 where @xmath211 is given by ( [ eq : omega = omega_m*z ] ) . the spatial geometry defined by the r.h.s .
of ( [ eq : dzbz = drar ] ) is either hyperbolic ( open ) , euclidean ( flat ) or spherical ( closed ) depending on curvature @xmath252 , @xmath253 or @xmath254 , respectively . since @xmath157 is dependent on the mass and vacuum densities then the geometry of the universe is determined by @xmath155 and @xmath156 .
the expansion defined by ( [ eq : drar = dvbv ] ) when substituted for the l.h.s . of ( [ eq : dzbz = drar ] ) and combined with ( [ eq : rv - z ] ) yields the differential equation for the expansion velocity @xmath255 integrating ( [ eq : dv / c ] ) we get for the expansion velocity as a function of redshift @xmath256
the hubble parameter defined by ( [ eq : h_v - def ] ) , using ( [ eq : drv / dv ] ) , is expressed in terms of velocity @xmath4 , @xmath257 where @xmath45 , @xmath217 . in terms of redshift , using ( [ eq : rv - z ] ) for @xmath37 , @xmath258 where @xmath211 is defined by ( [ eq : omega = omega_m*z ] ) .
the comoving distance @xmath259 is the integral of ( [ eq : dzbz = drar ] ) and can be written in terms of the hubble parameter using ( [ eq : h - func - of - z ] ) , @xmath260 the transverse comoving distance @xmath261 is the coordinate distance @xmath5 which is obtained from the inversion of ( [ eq : comoving_distance ] ) , i.e. , @xmath262 .
it takes the form @xmath263 a physical source of size @xmath264 subtends an observed angle of @xmath265 on the sky given by the relation @xmath266 where @xmath267 is the proper distance from the coordinate system origin to the source .
since @xmath268 is the scale factor and @xmath269 is the coordinate distance , we define the angular diameter distance , @xmath270 in can be shownthat the source luminosity @xmath271 transforms due to the universe expansion as @xmath272 .
then the flux @xmath41 from a source of luminosity @xmath271 at proper distance @xmath273 is given by @xmath274 where we used @xmath275 .
the bolometric flux @xmath41 can also be defined for a source of luminosity @xmath271 at distance @xmath276 by @xmath277 eliminating @xmath41 between ( [ eq : s_bolo_flux_def1 ] ) and ( [ eq : s_bolo_flux_def2 ] ) we have the luminosity distance in terms of the redshift @xmath278 where we also used the l.h.s . of ( [ eq : comoving_distance ] ) ,
( [ eq : d_m_def ] ) and the hubble parameter defined by ( [ eq : h - func - of - z ] ) , @xmath279 where @xmath211 from ( [ eq : omega = omega_m*z ] ) , @xmath280
we give a view of the cosmology by applying it to a small combined set@xcite total of 157 high redshift sne ia data , distance moduli and errors ( @xmath281 ) but not systematic errors .
since we are expecting a scale factor transition from accelerated to decelerated expansion at low redshift we require that at the origin the scale factor acceleration @xmath282 . the standard distance modulus relation @xmath283 is given by @xmath284 where @xmath285 is the absolute magnitude of a standard supernova at the peak of its light - curve , @xmath286 is the luminosity distance ( [ eq : d_l_z - def ] ) and @xmath287 is an arbitrary zero point offset@xcite . for all our examples , the set of parameters
are pre - selected by trial and error and then a final fit is made of the distance modulus relation to the data varying only the offset parameter @xmath287 .
for the first example we take for the mass density parameter @xmath288 where @xmath289 is the baryon density parameter , and @xmath290 . from ( [ eq : h - value ] ) this gives @xmath291 .
we use a value of @xmath292 from@xcite .
therefore , our value for the mass density parameter is @xmath293 by a few trials we found a good fit for a value of the vacuum density parameter @xmath294 this defines an open universe since the curvature @xmath295 .
we consider an evolving dark energy state with @xmath296 and @xmath297 .
[ fig : scalfac - accel ] shows that the acceleration @xmath298 starts out positive at @xmath299 and transitions to negative around @xmath300 .
the detail at the acceleration transition is displayed by fig .
[ fig : scalfac - accel - trans - z ] . in fig .
[ fig : mub - vs - z ] is the plot of the distance moduli for the sne ia data .
the theoretical distance modulus ( [ eq : m(z)-theoretical ] ) is shown by the solid line .
we obtained a fitted value @xmath301 with @xmath302 . figs .
[ fig : trnsv - dist]-[fig : angdiam - dist ] display the various distance relations all with the same parameters from this first example .
distances are in units of @xmath303 . for the second example we select no dark matter @xmath304 with positive vacuum density @xmath305 this again defines an open universe since @xmath306 .
the equation of state parameters are @xmath307 and @xmath308 . for the third examle we select baryonic and dark matter @xmath309 with positive vacuum density @xmath310 where @xmath311 which gives a flat space curvature @xmath312 as in the standard flrw lambda - cold - dark - matter ( lcdm ) model .
we use the same equation of state @xmath313 and @xmath308 as the second example .
the results of these two examples are combined in the plots .
[ fig : scalfac - accel - trans - z - darkmatterdarkenergy ] shows details of the acceleration @xmath298 .
the thick curve is for @xmath314 , @xmath315 , @xmath316 and @xmath317 with transition @xmath318 .
the thin curve is for @xmath319 , @xmath320 , @xmath316 and @xmath317 with transition @xmath321 as was reported@xcite .
( we actually varied @xmath31 to get a smaller @xmath322 and in the process honed in on @xmath323 . ) fig .
[ fig : mub - vs - z - darkmatterdarkenergy ] shows the plots of the distance moduli for the sne ia data fitted to these two sets of parameters .
the thick ( upper ) curve is for @xmath314 , @xmath315 , @xmath307 , @xmath317 and fitted offset @xmath324 with @xmath325 .
the thin ( lower ) curve is for @xmath319 , @xmath320 , @xmath307 , @xmath317 and fitted offset @xmath326 with @xmath327 .
the examples and parameters are summarized in table [ tb : examples-1 - 2 - 3 ] . for a brief summary ,
example ( ex . ) 2 has the smallest @xmath328 where @xmath329 , while ex .
1 has the largest @xmath330 , with ex . 3 in between with a @xmath331 .
however , both ex.2 and ex .
3 have exceptionally high evolution ( @xmath296 , @xmath308 ) toward higher redshift , of what may be termed a `` anti - phantom '' energy , which might be characterized as physically unlikely because it has not been observed so far . on the other hand , ex .
1 has an evolution ( @xmath296 , @xmath297 ) of `` anti - dark '' energy toward higher redshift which cancels the dark energy development , which is physically more plausible since it involves dark energy for which there is observable evidence .
thus , qualitatively , ex .
1 is given a best fit " rating overall . ref .
( riess , et al.@xcite , sect .
4.3 ) for a nice exposition on dark energy .
these three examples provide a glimpse at the cosmology .
consider that there are @xmath332 possible categories of the parameter space : @xmath155 with no dark matter or dark matter , @xmath156 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 each either negative , zero or positive .
obviously , systematic analyses and larger data sets are required to narrow down the parameter space .
.curve fit parameters . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tb : examples-1 - 2 - 3 ]
the 4-d space - velocity cosmology of carmeli@xcite is based on the premise of a constant scale factor @xmath37 .
assume @xmath333 with @xmath334 the key equations are ( [ eq : basic-2b - sol-1b ] ) , ( [ eq : cal - f - equation ] ) and ( [ eq : f - differential ] ) . with the values eqs .
( [ eq : r - carmeli])-([eq : r - dub - prime - carmeli ] ) substituted into ( [ eq : cal - f - equation ] ) we get @xmath335 where @xmath130 is a constant since @xmath76 is assumed to be a constant with respect to @xmath4 and @xmath5 .
however , it is assumed that @xmath76 is a function of the cosmic time .
for the inhomogeneous case where @xmath336 the solution of ( [ eq : carmeli - f_o - equation ] ) is @xmath337 where @xmath117 is a constant . and , for the homogeneous case where @xmath338 the solution is @xmath339 where @xmath137 is a constant point mass centered at the origin of coordinates .
the general solution is the sum of ( [ eq : f - carmeli - inhomo - sol ] ) and ( [ eq : f - homo - carmeli - sol ] ) , @xmath340 where the system of coordinates is centered on the central mass @xmath137 . using ( [ eq : f - general - carmeli - sol ] ) in ( [ eq : carmeli - f_o - equation ] ) gives the value @xmath341 from ( [ eq : basic-2b - sol-1b ] ) , with @xmath342 and @xmath343 we get @xmath344 substituting for @xmath107 from ( [ eq : f - general - carmeli - sol ] ) into ( [ eq : carmeli - basic-1 ] ) gives the effective pressure @xmath345 the value of @xmath117 is obtained from ( [ eq : basic-1b - sol-1b ] ) with @xmath346 and @xmath343 , so that at @xmath34 it gives us @xmath347 with this value for @xmath117 we obtain from ( [ eq : carmeli - pressure - val ] ) the effective pressure @xmath348 where @xmath349 is the central mass density , which at this point is a convenient mathematical construct .
the function ( [ eq : int - mu-1c ] ) for @xmath113 is now given by @xmath350 where @xmath351 we make note that carmeli did not define an effective pressure , but simply used an ordinary pressure . in our analysis the effective pressure is used .
we could setup an equation of state for carmeli cosmology that is defined , taking the central mass @xmath352 in ( [ eq : basic-2b - sol - carmeli ] ) , @xmath353 where @xmath354 .
looking at ( [ eq : p - w - rho ] ) this implies that @xmath355 and @xmath356 .
in carmeli cosmology the effective mass density @xmath357 , so we equate it with our definition ( [ eq : rho_eff_fin ] ) and obtain @xmath358 from which , with @xmath359 , we get @xmath360 where @xmath361 is the critical density defined by ( [ eq : rho_c_def ] ) . using ( [ eq : rho_v - def ] ) this yields @xmath362 allowing for the @xmath363
this is the relation for @xmath12 which was reported@xcite .
however , this does not fix the value of @xmath12 but it appears to experimentally have the same order of magnitude@xcite . using ( [ eq : carmeli - rho_eff ] ) and ( [ eq : carmeli - rho_lambda ] ) , the effective mass density parameter @xmath242 is given by @xmath364 where @xmath365 and @xmath366 with no central mass , @xmath352 , and using eqs .
( [ eq : omega_eff_carmeli])-([eq : omega_lambda - carmeli ] ) then ( [ eq : int - mu - carmeli ] ) takes the form @xmath367 equation ( [ eq : int - mu - carmeli - form-1 ] ) is written in that form because @xmath368 at the present epoch . the curvature @xmath369 which implies that the carmeli universe has a hyperbolic ( open ) spatial geometry . setting @xmath51 in ( [ eq : dr / dv-0 ] ) for the expansion of the universe gives the differential equation @xmath370 upon integration , assuming @xmath371 , ( [ eq : expansion - carmeli ] ) yields for the expansion velocity @xmath372 inverting ( [ eq : expan - carmeli - solve ] ) we obtain the velocity - distance relation @xmath373 when the central mass @xmath374 , the expression ( [ eq : int - mu - carmeli ] ) takes the form @xmath375 then the differential equation for the universe expansion ( [ eq : dr / dv-0 ] ) takes the form @xmath376 the velocity - distance relation is then given by @xmath377 where the expansion is centered on the point mass @xmath137 .
this model was recently described by hartnett@xcite .
this is the basics of the cosmology .
for @xmath368 the curvature @xmath378 defines an open universe . since the scale factor @xmath37
is assumed to be constant , a velocity - redshift relation must be obtained by other methods .
the special relativistic doppler velocity - redshift relation @xmath379 is often used .
however , since here the scale factor @xmath37 is constant , the redshift @xmath38 is assumed to be a function of the cosmic time .
also , the evolution of the mass density parameter @xmath155 is assumed to be in the time domain and its variation also must be obtained by other methods .
a further limitation is that in ( [ eq : expansion - carmeli ] ) , the restriction that @xmath380 requires @xmath381 approximately .
this makes it difficult for high redshift data analysis@xcite . on the other hand , when cosmic time is added as
a fifth dimension the cgr 5-d time - space - velocity model is applicable to galaxy dynamics because the cosmological redshift across a galaxy region is nearly constant@xcite .
a general solution to the einstein field equations has been obtained for the four dimensional space - velocity cosmological general relativity theory of carmeli .
this development provides the tools necessary for the analysis of astrophysical data .
in particular , a redshift - distance relation is given , analogous to the standard flrw cosmology , and an evolving equation of state is provided .
an analysis of high redshift sne ia data was made to show the efficacy of the cosmology .
model examples were given with only baryonic matter and dark energy in hyperbolic space and with baryonic plus dark matter and dark energy in flat space . finally , carmeli s cosmology in 4-d was obtained .
oliveira , f. j. , and hartnett , j. g. : carmeli s cosmology fits data for an accelerating and decelerating universe without dark matter or dark energy . found .
. lett . * 19*(6 ) , 519 - 535 ( 2006 ) .
arxiv : astro - ph/0603500 riess , a. g. , et al . :
type ia supernova discoveries at @xmath382 from the hubble space telescope : evidence for past deceleration and constraints on dark energy evolution .
j. * 607 * , 665 - 687 ( 2004 ) riess , a. g. , et al .
: new hubble space telescope discoveries of type ia supernovae at @xmath383 : narrowing constraints on the early behavior of dark energy . astrophs .
j. * 659*(1 ) ( 2007 ) .
arxiv : astro - ph/0611572(2006 ) astier , p. , et al . :
the supernova legacy survey : measurement of @xmath384 , @xmath385 and @xmath386 from the first year data set .
& astrophs . *
447*(1 ) , 31 - 48 ( 2006 ) .
doi : 10.1051/0004 - 6361:20054185 .
arxiv : astro - ph/0510447 | in this paper the four - dimensional ( 4-d ) space - velocity cosmological general relativity of carmeli is developed by a general solution of the einstein field equations .
the tolman metric is applied in the form @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the metric tensor .
we use comoving coordinates @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the hubble - carmeli time constant , @xmath4 is the universe expansion velocity and @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the spatial coordinates .
we assume that @xmath8 and @xmath9 are each functions of the coordinates @xmath10 and @xmath5 .
the vacuum mass density @xmath11 is defined in terms of a cosmological constant @xmath12 , @xmath13 where the carmeli gravitational coupling constant @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the speed of light in vacuum .
this allows the definitions of the effective mass density @xmath16 and effective pressure @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the mass density and @xmath19 is the pressure . then the energy - momentum tensor @xmath20 , \label{abs : t_uv_eff}\ ] ] where @xmath21 is the 4-velocity .
the einstein field equations are taken in the form @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the ricci tensor , @xmath24 is carmeli s gravitation constant , where @xmath25 is newton s constant and the trace @xmath26 . by solving the field equations ( [ abs : field - eqs - new ] ) a space - velocity cosmology
is obtained analogous to the friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker space - time cosmology .
we choose an equation of state such that @xmath27 with an evolving state parameter @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the scale factor and @xmath30 and @xmath31 are constants .
carmeli s 4-d space - velocity cosmology is derived as a special case . |
since quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) was established as the fundamental theory of strong interaction @xcite , it has been an important problem in theoretical physics to clarify color confinement and spontaneous chiral - symmetry breaking @xcite .
however , in spite of many and various studies , these two nonperturbative phenomena have not been well understood directly from qcd .
dynamical chiral - symmetry breaking in qcd is categorized as well - known spontaneous symmetry breaking , which widely appears in various phenomena in physics .
the standard order parameter of chiral symmetry breaking is the quark condensate @xmath8 , and it is directly related to low - lying dirac modes , as the banks - casher relation indicates @xcite . here
, dirac modes are eigenmodes of the dirac operator @xmath9 , which directly appears in the qcd lagrangian .
in contrast to chiral symmetry breaking , color confinement is a quite unique phenomenon peculiar in qcd , and the quark confinement is characterized by the area law of the wilson loop , i.e. , non - zero string tension , or the zero polyakov loop , i.e. , infinite single - quark free energy .
the polyakov loop @xmath0 is one of the typical order parameters , and it relates to the single - quark free energy @xmath10 as @xmath11 at temperature @xmath12 .
the polyakov loop is also an order parameter of spontaneous breaking of the @xmath13 center symmetry in qcd @xcite .
in addition to the study of each nonperturbative phenomenon , to clarify the relation between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking is one of the challenging important subjects in theoretical physics @xcite , and their relation is not yet clarified directly from qcd .
a strong correlation between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking has been suggested by almost coincidence between deconfinement and chiral - restoration temperatures @xcite , although slight difference of about 25mev between them is pointed out in recent lattice qcd studies @xcite .
their correlation has been also suggested in terms of qcd - monopoles @xcite , which topologically appear in qcd in the maximally abelian gauge . by removing the monopoles from the qcd vacuum , confinement and chiral symmetry breaking
are simultaneously lost @xcite , which indicates an important role of qcd - monopoles to both phenomena , and thus these two phenomena seem to be related via the monopole . as another type of pioneering study , gattringer and bruckmann _
_ showed that the polyakov loop can be analytically expressed with the dirac eigenvalues under the temporally twisted boundary condition for temporal link - variables @xcite .
although temporal ( nontwisted ) periodic boundary condition is physically required for link - variables in real qcd at finite temperature , such an analytical formula would be useful to consider the relation between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking . in a series of our recent studies @xcite
, we have numerically investigated the wilson loop and the polyakov loop in terms of the `` dirac - mode expansion '' , and have found that quark confinement properties are almost kept even in the absence of low - lying dirac modes .
( also , `` hadrons '' appear without low - lying dirac modes @xcite , suggesting survival of confinement . )
note that the dirac - mode expansion is just a mathematical expansion by eigenmodes @xmath14 of the dirac operator @xmath15 , using the completeness of @xmath16 .
in general , instead of @xmath9 , one can consider any ( anti)hermitian operator , e.g. , @xmath17 , and the expansion in terms of its eigenmodes @xcite . to investigate chiral symmetry breaking ,
however , it is appropriate to consider @xmath9 and the expansion by its eigenmodes . in this paper
, we derive analytical formulae of the polyakov and the wilson loops with the dirac modes in the lattice qcd formalism @xcite , and discuss the relation between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking .
the organization of this paper is as follows . in sect .
2 , we briefly review the lattice qcd formalism for the dirac operator , dirac eigenvalues and dirac modes . in sect . 3
, we derive an analytical formula between the polyakov loop and the dirac modes in lattice qcd where the temporal size is odd - number . in sect . 4
, we investigate the properties of the obtained formula , and discuss the contribution from the low - lying dirac modes to the polyakov loop . in sect . 5 , we consider the relation between the wilson loop and dirac modes on arbitrary square lattices , without restriction of odd - number size .
section 6 will be devoted to the summary .
to begin with , we state the setup condition of lattice qcd formalism adopted in this study .
we use an ordinary square lattice with spacing @xmath18 and size @xmath19 .
the normal nontwisted periodic boundary condition is used for the link - variable @xmath20 in the temporal direction , with the gluon field @xmath21 , the gauge coupling @xmath22 and the site @xmath23 .
this temporal periodicity is physically required at finite temperature . in this paper
, we take su(@xmath24 ) with @xmath24 being the color number as the gauge group of the theory .
however , arbitrary gauge group @xmath25 can be taken for most arguments in the following . in the euclidean lattice formalism , the qcd generating functional
is expressed with the qcd action @xmath26 as @xmath27+{\bar q}k[u]q\ } } = \int du e^{-s_{\rm gauge}[u]}{\rm det } k[u ] , \label{eq : qcdgf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath28 $ ] denotes the lattice gauge action and @xmath29 $ ] a fermionic kernel . in this study
, one can freely choose any type of lattice fermions such as the wilson fermion , the kogut - susskind fermion , the overlap fermion , and so on @xcite .
as importance sampling for the generating function @xmath30 , one can generate gauge configurations @xmath31 using monte carlo simulations .
the expectation value of any operator @xmath32 $ ] is given by the gauge ensemble average as @xmath33 \rangle = \frac{1}{{z}_{\rm qcd } } \int du e^{-s_{\rm gauge}[u]}{\rm det } k[u ] \cdot o[u ] = { \rm lim}_{n \rightarrow \infty } \frac{1}{n}\sum_{k=1}^n o[u_k].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this study , we consider some analytical relations between dirac modes and confinement properties for the gauge configurations @xmath31 , generated in full qcd or quenched qcd with setting @xmath34=1 $ ] . in this paper , we perform anatomy " for the nonperturbative qcd vacuum , i.e. , the gauge ensemble which is in principle generated for the qcd generating functional @xmath35 . in our approach , we do not change the qcd action @xmath26 or @xmath35 , but analyze the qcd vacuum for @xmath35 in terms of the dirac modes .
this approach is similar to our previous works @xcite and the works by lang et al .
@xcite , where low - lying dirac modes are removed from the lattice qcd configurations , after their numerical generation in standard monte carlo simulations for @xmath35 . in these studies , @xmath35 is not changed at all .
our approach is also similar to that of abelian dominance @xcite and monopole dominance @xcite for the argument of quark confinement in the ma gauge . after generating qcd configuration in the ma gauge , off - diagonal gluons or monopoles
are removed from the qcd vacuum , and confinement properties are investigated in the processed qcd vacuum . in these studies ,
@xmath35 is also unchanged .
( if off - diagonal gluons are removed from @xmath35 at the action level , the system becomes qed , which is no more meaningful for the study of qcd .
) in fact , the main interest is the qcd vacuum , and it has been investigated from the viewpoint of some relevant modes , such as low - lying dirac modes , monopoles and so on . in this work , we analyze the lattice gauge ensemble , generated for @xmath35 , in terms of the dirac modes . here
, we mathematically define the dirac operator @xmath9 , dirac eigenvalues @xmath1 , and dirac eigenmodes @xmath14 in lattice qcd . in lattice qcd ,
the dirac operator @xmath36 is expressed with @xmath20 . in our study
, we take the lattice dirac operator of @xmath37 , \label{eq : latticedirac}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath38 is the unit vector in @xmath39-direction in the lattice unit , and @xmath40 . adopting hermitian @xmath41-matrices as @xmath42 , the dirac operator @xmath9 is anti - hermitian and satisfies @xmath43 .
( note that the dirac operator @xmath44 defined here is not identical with the fermionc kernel @xmath45 $ ] in sec .
the relation between @xmath9 and @xmath29 $ ] will be discussed in sec . 2.4 . )
we introduce the normalized dirac eigen - state @xmath14 as @xmath46 with the dirac eigenvalue @xmath47 ( @xmath48 ) . because of @xmath49
, the state @xmath50 is also an eigen - state of @xmath9 with the eigenvalue @xmath51 . here
, the dirac eigen - state @xmath14 satisfies the completeness of @xmath52 for the dirac eigenfunction @xmath53 , the dirac eigenvalue equation @xmath54 is expressed by @xmath55 in lattice qcd , and its explicit form is written by @xmath56 = i\lambda_n \psi_n(s).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the dirac eigenfunction @xmath57 can be numerically obtained in lattice qcd , besides a phase factor . by the gauge transformation of @xmath58 , @xmath57 is gauge - transformed as @xmath59 which is the same as that of the quark field , although , to be strict , there can appear an irrelevant @xmath60-dependent global phase factor @xmath61}$ ] , according to arbitrariness of the phase in the basis @xmath14 @xcite .
note that the spectral density @xmath62 of the dirac operator @xmath9 relates to chiral symmetry breaking in continuum qcd . for example
, from banks - casher s
relation @xcite , the zero - eigenvalue density @xmath63 leads to @xmath64 as @xmath65 with space - time volume @xmath66 .
( in lattice qcd , the use of the dirac operator @xmath9 in eq.([eq : latticedirac ] ) accompanies an overall degeneracy factor @xmath67 , which will be discussed in sec.2.4 . ) in any case , the low - lying dirac modes can be regarded as the essential modes responsible to spontaneous chiral - symmetry breaking in qcd .
now , we present the operator formalism in lattice qcd @xcite . to begin with ,
we introduce the link - variable operator @xmath68 ( @xmath69 ) defined by the matrix element of @xmath70 because of @xmath71 , @xmath72 are hermite conjugate each other and satisfy @xmath73 with the link - variable operator @xmath72 , the covariant derivative is written as @xmath74 and the dirac operator defined by eq.([eq : latticedirac ] ) is simply expressed as @xmath75 both @xmath76 and @xmath77 are anti - hermite operators .
the dirac - mode matrix element of the link - variable operator @xmath78 ( @xmath79 ) can be expressed with @xmath57 : @xmath80 note that the matrix element is gauge invariant , apart from an irrelevant phase factor .
actually , using the gauge transformation ( [ eq : gtdwf ] ) , we find the gauge transformation of the matrix element as @xcite @xmath81 to be strict , there appears an @xmath60-dependent global phase factor , corresponding to the arbitrariness of the phase in the basis @xmath14 .
however , this phase factor cancels as @xmath82 between @xmath14 and @xmath83 , and does not appear for physical quantities such as the wilson loop and the polyakov loop @xcite . in this subsection
, we discuss the relation between the dirac operator @xmath9 defined in eq.([eq : latticedirac ] ) or ( [ eq : dop ] ) and the fermionic kernel @xmath29 $ ] in lattice qcd in eq.([eq : qcdgf ] ) . in lattice
qcd , the simple dirac operator @xmath9 has @xmath85 degeneracy with @xmath86 being the number of space - time dimension @xcite . in the fermionic kernel
@xmath29 $ ] , the doubler contribution is effectively removed in some way . for a typical example of the wilson fermion , a large extra energy of @xmath87 is added only for doublers , which makes the doublers inactive in the low - energy region .
then , 16 degenerate low - lying dirac modes of @xmath9 correspond to one low - lying mode and 15 doubler modes in terms of the fermionic kernel @xmath29 $ ] .
in fact , each low - lying mode of @xmath29 $ ] is expected to have a large overlap with an eigenmode of @xmath9 , but the chiral property is largely different between @xmath9 and @xmath29 $ ] . actually , if @xmath9 is misleadingly used instead of @xmath29 $ ] in eq.([eq : qcdgf ] ) , the theoretical structure may be largely changed due to many flavors of 16 species @xcite . in addition , the axial anomaly is totally different , since it is not broken in the dirac operator @xmath9 due to the cancellation from the doublers @xcite .
here , we denote by @xmath88 the normalized mode of the fermionic kernel @xmath29 $ ] , to distinguish it from the dirac mode @xmath14 .
because of @xmath89 , one finds the identity , latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } in this paper , we assume that each low - lying mode of the fermionic kernel @xmath29 $ ] is mainly expressed with the low - lying dirac modes of @xmath9 .
this assumption does not mean one - to - one correspondence between a low - lying dirac mode and a low - lying mode of @xmath29 $ ] , but saturation of each low - lying mode of @xmath29 $ ] by low - lying dirac modes of some range .
in fact , for each low - lying mode @xmath88 , we assume @xmath91 which means @xmath92 here , @xmath93 denotes the sum over low - lying dirac modes .
this assumption would be natural , however , it is desired to examine ( [ eq : assumption ] ) quantitatively in lattice qcd @xcite . from this assumption , if the low - lying dirac modes of @xmath9 are removed , the low - lying modes @xmath88 of the fermionic kernel @xmath29 $ ] are also removed approximately .
in fact , this assumption links the dirac - mode expansion to the low - lying modes of @xmath29 $ ] , which is more directly connected to chiral symmetry breaking . in this subsection
, we investigate the dirac operator and the polyakov loop in finite temperature qcd . in the imaginary - time formalism , the finite - temperature system requires periodicity for bosons and anti - periodicity for fermions in euclidean temporal direction @xcite . here
, we consider such a temporally-(anti)periodic lattice with the temporal size @xmath3 , which corresponds to the temperature @xmath94 . in this thermal system ,
any fermion field @xmath95 obeys @xmath96 with @xmath97 , and the temporal anti - periodicity of quarks also reflects in the dirac operator @xmath98 .
in fact , the temporal structure of the matrix @xmath99 which acts on quarks is expressed as @xcite @xmath100 where @xmath101 ( @xmath102 ) is an abbreviation of the temporal link - variable .
the additional minus sign in front of @xmath103 and @xmath104 reflects the anti - periodicity of quarks in the temporal direction . for the thermal system , the link - variable operator @xmath72 is basically defined by the matrix element ( [ eq : lvo ] ) .
however , taking account of the temporal anti - periodicity in @xmath99 acting on quarks , it is convenient to add a minus sign to the matrix element of the temporal link - variable operator @xmath105 at the temporal boundary of @xmath106 : @xmath107 here , @xmath108 is satisfied . for thermal qcd , by using this definition of the link - variable operator @xmath72 , the dirac operator and the covariant derivative are also simply expressed as @xmath109 which are consistent with eq.([eq : explicit - dirac ] ) . the polyakov loop @xmath0 is also simply written as the functional trace of @xmath110 , @xmath111 with the four - dimensional lattice volume @xmath112 . here
, `` @xmath113 '' denotes the functional trace of @xmath114 with the trace @xmath115 over color index .
the minus sign stems from the additional minus on @xmath116 in eq.([eq : lvthermal ] ) .
now , we consider lattice qcd with odd - number temporal lattice size @xmath3 , as shown in fig.1 . here , we use an ordinary square lattice with the normal nontwisted periodic boundary condition for the link - variable in the temporal direction .
( of course , this temporal periodicity is physically required at finite temperature . )
the spatial lattice size @xmath117 is taken to be larger than @xmath3 , i.e. , @xmath118 . note that , in the continuum limit of @xmath119 and @xmath120 , any number of large @xmath3 gives the same physical result .
then , in principle , it is no problem to use the odd - number lattice .
case ) . only gauge - invariant quantities such as closed loops and
the polyakov loop survive or do not vanish in qcd , after taking the expectation value , i.e. , the gauge - configuration average . geometrically , closed loops have even - number links on the square lattice . ] in general , only gauge - invariant quantities such as closed loops and the polyakov loop survive in qcd , according to the elitzur theorem @xcite . all the non - closed lines are gauge - variant and their expectation values are zero .
note here that any closed loop , except for the polyakov loop , needs even - number link - variables on the square lattice , as shown in fig.1 .
note also that , from the definition of the link - variable operator @xmath68 ( @xmath121 ) in eq.([eq : lvo ] ) , the functional trace of the product of @xmath122 along any non - closed trajectory is zero , i.e. , @xmath123 for the non - closed trajectory with @xmath124 .
( here , @xmath125 can take positive or negative direction as @xmath126 , and any closed loop satisfies @xmath127 . ) in lattice qcd with odd - number temporal size @xmath3 , we consider the functional trace of @xmath128 where @xmath129 includes @xmath115 and the trace @xmath130 over spinor index .
its expectation value @xmath131 is obtained as the gauge - configuration average in lattice qcd . in the case of enough large volume @xmath132
, one can expect @xmath133 for any operator @xmath134 at each gauge configuration . from eq.([eq
: dop ] ) , @xmath135 is expressed as a sum of products of @xmath3 link - variable operators , since the dirac operator @xmath76 includes one link - variable operator in each direction of @xmath136 . then , @xmath135 includes many trajectories with the total length @xmath3 in the lattice unit on the square lattice , as shown in fig.2 . note that all the trajectories with the odd - number length @xmath3 can not form a closed loop on the square lattice , and thus give gauge - variant contribution , except for the polyakov loop . .
for each trajectory , the total length is @xmath3 , and the `` first step '' is positive temporal direction corresponding to @xmath5 .
all the trajectories with the odd - number length @xmath3 can not form a closed loop on the square lattice , and therefore they are gauge - variant and give no contribution in @xmath137 , except for the polyakov loop . ] therefore , among the trajectories stemming from @xmath138 , all the non - loop trajectories are gauge - variant and give no contribution , according to the elitzur theorem @xcite .
only the exception is the polyakov loop .
( see figs.2 and 3 . ) for each trajectory in @xmath139 , the first step is positive temporal direction corresponding to @xmath5 , and hence @xmath138 can not include the anti - polyakov loop @xmath140 .
thus , in the functional trace @xmath141 , only the polyakov - loop ingredient can survive as the gauge - invariant quantity , and @xmath137 is proportional to the polyakov loop @xmath0 .
, only the polyakov - loop ingredient can survive as a gauge - invariant quantity . here
, @xmath142 does not include @xmath140 , because of the first factor @xmath5 . ] actually , we can mathematically derive the following relation : @xmath143 here , a minus appears from eq.([eq : pl ] ) , which reflects the temporal anti - periodicity of @xmath9 .
we thus obtain the relation between @xmath144 and the polyakov loop @xmath0 , @xmath145 on the other hand , we calculate the functional trace in eq.([eq : ftv ] ) using the complete set of the dirac - mode basis @xmath4 satisfying @xmath146 , and find the dirac - mode representation of @xmath147 combing eqs.([eq : fttopl ] ) and ( [ eq : fttod ] ) , we obtain the analytical formula between the polyakov loop @xmath0 and the dirac eigenvalues
@xmath47 : @xmath148 for each gauge configuration . taking the gauge - configuration average ,
we obtain @xmath149 this is a direct relation between the polyakov loop @xmath150 and the dirac modes in qcd , and is mathematically valid in lattice qcd with odd - number temporal size in both confinement and deconfinement phases . the formula ( [ eq : plvsd ] ) is a dirac spectral representation of the polyakov loop , and we can investigate each dirac - mode contribution to the polyakov loop individually , based on eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) .
( for example , each contribution specified by @xmath60 is numerically calculable in lattice qcd @xcite . ) as a remarkable fact , because of the factor @xmath6 , the contribution from low - lying dirac - modes with @xmath151 is negligibly small in the dirac spectral sum of rhs in eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) , in comparison with the other dirac - mode contribution . in fact , the low - lying dirac modes have fairly small contribution to the polyakov loop in eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) , regardless of confinement or deconfinement phase .
this is consistent with the previous numerical lattice qcd result that confinement properties are almost unchanged by removing low - lying dirac modes from the qcd vacuum @xcite .
in this section , we consider the dirac spectral representation of the polyakov loop , i.e. , the formula ( [ eq : plvsd ] ) between the polyakov loop and dirac modes , and discuss its physical meaning .
in particular , we consider the contribution from low - lying dirac modes to the polyakov loop .
first , we note that eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) is a manifestly gauge - invariant formula .
actually , the matrix element @xmath152 can be expressed with the dirac eigenfunction @xmath57 and the temporal link - variable @xmath153 as @xmath154 and each term @xmath155 is manifestly gauge invariant , because of the gauge transformation property ( [ eq : gtdwf ] ) . here
, the irrelevant global phase factors also cancel exactly as @xmath156 between @xmath157 and @xmath14 @xcite .
second , we note the chiral property and nontriviality of eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) .
in rhs of eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) , there is no cancellation between chiral - pair dirac eigen - states , @xmath14 and @xmath158 , because @xmath159 is even , i.e. , @xmath160 , and @xmath161 . third , eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) is correct for any odd number @xmath162 and is applicable to both confinement and deconfinement phases .
then , eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) obtained on the odd - number lattice is expected to hold in the continuum limit of @xmath119 and @xmath120 , since any number of large @xmath3 gives the same physical result .
finally , we comment on generality and wide applicability of eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) . in the argument to derive eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) , we only use a few setup conditions : * square lattice ( including anisotropic cases ) * odd - number temporal size @xmath163 * temporal periodicity for link - variables . accordingly
, eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) is widely correct in the case of _ arbitrary gauge group of the theory .
_ for example , eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) is applicable in the su(@xmath24 ) gauge theory for the arbitrary color number @xmath24 .
in addition , regardless of presence or absence of dynamical quarks , eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) is formally correct as the dirac - mode expansion . in fact , eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) can be derived also for the gauge configuration after integrating out quark degrees of freedom .
of course , the dynamical quark effect appears in the polyakov loop @xmath0 , the dirac eigenvalue distribution @xmath62 and @xmath152 .
however , the formula ( [ eq : plvsd ] ) holds even in the presence of dynamical quarks .
therefore , the formula ( [ eq : plvsd ] ) is applicable at finite density and finite temperature . in this subsection
, we consider the contribution from low - lying dirac modes to the polyakov loop based on eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) . due to the factor @xmath6 ,
the contribution from low - lying dirac - modes with @xmath151 is negligibly small in rhs in eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) , compared with the other dirac - mode contribution , so that the low - lying dirac modes have small contribution to the polyakov loop in both confinement and deconfinement phases .
if rhs in eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) _ were _ not a sum but a product , low - lying dirac modes , or the small @xmath164 region , should have given an important contribution to the polyakov loop as a crucial reduction factor of @xmath165 . in the sum , however , the contribution ( @xmath166 ) from the small @xmath164 region is negligible .
even if @xmath152 behaves as the @xmath167-function @xmath168 , the factor @xmath165 is still crucial in rhs of eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) , because of @xmath169 .
in fact , without appearance of extra counter factor @xmath170 from @xmath152 , the crucial factor @xmath165 inevitably leads to small contribution for low - lying dirac modes .
note here that the explicit @xmath3-dependence appears as the factor @xmath165 in rhs of eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) , and the matrix element @xmath152 does not include @xmath3-dependence in an explicit manner .
then , it seems rather difficult to consider the appearance of the counter factor @xmath170 from the matrix element @xmath152 .
one may suspect the necessity of renormalization for the polyakov loop , although the polyakov loop is at present one of the typical order parameters of confinement , and most arguments on the qcd phase transition have been done in terms of the simple polyakov loop . even in the presence of a possible multiplicative renormalization factor for the polyakov loop like @xmath171 ,
the contribution from the low - lying dirac modes , or the small @xmath164 region , is relatively negligible compared with other dirac - mode contribution in the sum of rhs in eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) .
it is notable that all the above arguments can be numerically confirmed by lattice qcd calculations . in this subsection
, we briefly mention the numerical confirmation with lattice qcd monte carlo calculations @xcite .
using actual lattice qcd calculations at the quenched level , we numerically confirm the analytical formula ( [ eq : plvsd ] ) , non - zero finiteness of @xmath172 for each dirac mode , and negligibly small contribution of low - lying dirac modes to the polyakov loop , i.e. , the polyakov loop is almost unchanged even by removing low - lying dirac - mode contribution from the qcd vacuum generated by lattice qcd simulations , in both confinement and deconfinement phases @xcite . as for the matrix element @xmath173
, its behavior is different between confinement and deconfinement phases . in the confinement phase ,
we find a `` positive / negative symmetry '' on the distribution of the matrix element @xmath173 @xcite , i.e. , its actual value seems to appear as `` pair - wise '' of plus and minus , and this symmetry is one of the essence to realize the zero value of the polyakov loop @xmath0 . in fact , due to this symmetry of @xmath173 in the confinement phase , the contribution from partial dirac modes in arbitrary region @xmath174 leads to @xmath175 . in particular , the high - lying dirac modes do not contribute to the polyakov loop @xmath0 , in spite of the large factor @xmath165 .
this behavior is consistent with our previous lattice qcd results @xcite , which indicate that the `` seed '' of confinement is distributed in a wider region of the dirac eigenmodes unlike chiral symmetry breaking . in the deconfinement phase
, there is no such symmetry on the distribution of @xmath173 , and this asymmetry leads to a non - zero value of the polyakov loop @xcite . in any case ,
regardless of the behavior of @xmath173 , we numerically confirm that the contribution from low - lying dirac modes to the polyakov loop is negligibly small @xcite in both confinement and deconfinement phases , owing to the factor @xmath165 in eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) . from the analytical formula ( [ eq : plvsd ] ) and the numerical confirmation , low - lying dirac - modes have small contribution to the polyakov loop , and are not essential for confinement , while these modes are essential for chiral symmetry breaking .
in this section , we attempt a similar consideration to the wilson loop and the string tension on arbitrary square lattices ( including anisotropic cases ) with any number of @xmath3 , i.e. , without restriction of odd - number size .
we consider the ordinary wilson loop on a @xmath176 rectangle , where @xmath12 and @xmath177 are arbitrary positive integers .
the wilson loop is expressed by the functional trace @xcite @xmath178 where we introduce the `` staple operator '' @xmath179 as @xmath180 here , the wilson - loop operator is factorized as a product of @xmath179 and @xmath181 , as shown in fig.4 .
we note that @xmath182 for enough large volume lattice @xcite .
defined on a @xmath176 rectangle .
the right figure shows the factorization of the wilson - loop operator as a product of @xmath183 and @xmath181 .
here , @xmath12 , @xmath177 , and the lattice size are arbitrary . ] in the case of even number @xmath12 , let us consider the functional trace of @xmath184 from the similar arguments in sect.3 , we obtain @xmath185 and @xmath186 therefore , we obtain for even @xmath12 the simple formula of @xmath187 again , owing to the factor @xmath188 , the contribution from low - lying dirac modes is expected to be small also for the wilson loop , although the matrix element @xmath189 includes explicit @xmath12-dependence and its behavior is not so clear , unlike the formula ( [ eq : plvsd ] ) for the polyakov loop . in the case of odd
number @xmath12 , the similar results can be obtained by considering @xmath190 instead of @xmath191 . actually , one finds @xmath192 and @xmath193 so that one finds for odd @xmath12 the similar formula of @xmath194 finally , for even @xmath12 case , we show the inter - quark potential @xmath195 and the string tension @xmath7 . from the expression ( [ eq : wilson ] ) for the wilson loop @xmath196 , we obtain the inter - quark potential @xmath195 and the string tension @xmath7 : @xmath197 @xmath198 because of the factor @xmath188 in the sum , the low - lying dirac - mode contribution is to be small for the wilson loop @xmath196 , the inter - quark potential @xmath195 and the string tension @xmath7 , unless the extra counter factor @xmath199 appears from @xmath200 . also for odd @xmath12 case ,
similar arguments can be done with eq.([eq : wilsonodd ] ) . in this way ,
the string tension @xmath7 , or the confining force , is expected to be unchanged by the removal of the low - lying dirac - mode contribution , which is consistent with our previous numerical works of lattice qcd @xcite .
taking the assumption ( [ eq : assumption ] ) in sec.2.4 , the removal of low - lying dirac modes of @xmath9 leads to an approximate removal of low - lying modes of the fermionic kernel @xmath29 $ ] , which largely reduces the chiral condensate .
then , the above suggested insensitivity of confinement to low - lying dirac modes indicates no direct one - to - one correspondence between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking in qcd .
we have derived an analytical gauge - invariant formula between the polyakov loop @xmath0 and the dirac eigenvalues @xmath1 as @xmath2 in lattice qcd with odd - number temporal size @xmath3 , by considering @xmath201 , on the ordinary square lattice with the normal ( nontwisted ) temporally - periodic boundary condition for link - variables . here , @xmath4 denotes the dirac eigenstate , and @xmath5 temporal link - variable operator .
this formula is a dirac spectral representation of the polyakov loop in terms of dirac eigenmodes @xmath4 , and expresses each contribution of the dirac eigenmode to the polyakov loop .
because of the factor @xmath6 in the dirac spectral sum , this formula indicates fairly small contribution of low - lying dirac modes to the polyakov loop in both confinement and deconfinement phases , while these modes are essential for chiral symmetry breaking .
next , we have found a similar formula between the wilson loop and dirac modes on arbitrary lattices , without restriction of odd - number size .
this formula suggests a small contribution of low - lying dirac modes to the string tension @xmath7 , or the confining force .
thus , it is likely that low - lying dirac - modes have fairly small contribution to the polyakov loop and the string tension , and are not essential modes for confinement , while these modes are essential for chiral symmetry breaking .
this suggests no direct one - to - one correspondence between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking in qcd . note here that the independence of confinement and chiral symmetry breaking would be natural , because heavy quarks are also confined even without light quarks or the chiral symmetry . also for thermal qcd
, we have investigated the relation between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking using the ratio of the susceptibility of the polyakov loop @xcite , of which importance for the deconfinement transition has been pointed out @xcite . finally , we state some cautions and future works in this framework in order . in sec.2.4 , for the strict connection to chiral symmetry breaking , we have assumed that each low - lying mode of the fermionic kernel @xmath29 $ ] is mainly expressed with the low - lying dirac modes of @xmath9 .
we are now investigating this assumption ( [ eq : assumption ] ) quantitatively in lattice qcd @xcite . in this paper
, we have derived the dirac - mode expansion such as eq.([eq : plvsd ] ) , which is mathematically correct . in this expansion , each dirac - mode contribution is explicitly expressed , and we have focused on this explicit contribution
. this treatment would be appropriate in quenched qcd . for more definite argument in full qcd , however , we have to clarify an implicit contribution of the dirac modes in the fermionic determinant , which can actually alter the properties of the qcd vacuum @xcite .
it is important to take the continuum limit of the mathematical formulae obtained on the lattice , although it seems a difficult problem .
it is also interesting to compare with other lattice qcd result on the important role of infrared gluons ( below about 1gev ) for confinement in the landau gauge @xcite , in contrast to the insensitivity of confinement against low - lying dirac - modes .
this work suggests some possible independence between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking in qcd , and this may lead to richer phase structure of qcd in various environment .
in fact , there is an interesting possibility that qcd phase transition points can be generally different between deconfinement and chiral symmetry restoration , e.g. , in the presence of strong electromagnetic fields , because of their nontrivial effect on the chiral symmetry @xcite .
h.s . thanks prof . e.t .
tomboulis for useful discussions and his brief confirmation on our calculations .
is supported in part by the grant for scientific research [ ( c ) no.23540306 , 15k05076 , e01:21105006 ] from the ministry of education , science and technology of japan .
h. suganuma et al . , proc .
, qcd - tnt - ii , 044 ( 2011 ) ; proc .
sci . , lattice 2012 , 217 ( 2012 ) ; proc .
, confinement x , 081 ( 2013 ) .
s. gongyo , t. iritani and h. suganuma , phys .
d*86 * , 034510 ( 2012 ) .
t. iritani and h. suganuma , prog .
phys . * 2014 * , 033b03 ( 2014 ) ; t. iritani , s. gongyo and h. suganuma , proc .
sci . , lattice 2012 , 218 ( 2012 ) ; proc .
confinement x , 053 ( 2013 ) . | we derive an analytical gauge - invariant formula between the polyakov loop @xmath0 and the dirac eigenvalues @xmath1 in qcd , i.e. , @xmath2 , in ordinary periodic square lattice qcd with odd - number temporal size @xmath3 . here , @xmath4 denotes the dirac eigenstate , and @xmath5 temporal link - variable operator .
this formula is a dirac spectral representation of the polyakov loop in terms of dirac eigenmodes @xmath4 . because of the factor @xmath6 in the dirac spectral sum
, this formula indicates negligibly small contribution of low - lying dirac modes to the polyakov loop in both confinement and deconfinement phases , while these modes are essential for chiral symmetry breaking .
next , we find a similar formula between the wilson loop and dirac modes on arbitrary square lattices , without restriction of odd - number size .
this formula suggests a small contribution of low - lying dirac modes to the string tension @xmath7 , or the confining force .
these findings support no crucial role of low - lying dirac modes for confinement , i.e. , no direct one - to - one correspondence between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking in qcd , which seems to be natural because heavy quarks are also confined even without light quarks or the chiral symmetry . |
the thermal spectra of neutron stars during thermonuclear x - ray bursts have been used during the last three decades in numerous attempts to measure the neutron - star masses and radii ( e.g. , van paradijs 1978 , 1979 ; foster , fabian & ross 1986 ; sztajno et al .
1987 ; van paradijs & lewin 1987 ; damen et al . 1989 , 1990 ) .
such efforts were often hampered by large systematic uncertainties in the estimated distances to the bursters and in the theoretical models for their x - ray spectra .
moreover , the relatively small number of x - ray bursts observed by early satellites from each individual source made it impossible to assess systematic uncertainties related to the degree of anisotropy of the thermonuclear burning on the neutron - star surface , or of the obscuration by and the reflection off the accretion flow .
the situation has changed dramatically in the last few years .
the distances to several globular clusters that contain bursting neutron stars has been narrowed down with the use of observations by the hubble space telescope ( see , e.g. , kuulkers et al .
2003 ; zel , gver , & psaltis 2009 ; gver et al .
the distances to x - ray bursters in the galactic disk and halo have also been determined using alternate methods ( e.g. , gver et al .
theoretical models of the x - ray spectra of bursting neutron stars have been greatly improved and can account for the subtle effects of the presence of heavy metals in their atmospheres ( e.g. , london , taam , & howard 1986 ; foster , fabian , & ross 1986 ; ebisuzaki 1987 ; madej , joss , & raska 2004 ; majczyna et al .
2005 ; suleimanov , poutanen , & werner 2011 ) . finally , the high signal - to - noise observations of the x - ray spectra of several hundreds of bursts with the rossi x - ray timing explorer ( galloway et al .
2008a ) allow for the formal uncertainties of individual measurements to be substantially reduced .
the combination of these developments led recently to the measurement of the masses and radii of several neutron stars ( zel et al .
2009 ; gver et al . 2010a , 2010b ;
steiner , lattimer , & brown 2010 ) which are already sufficient to provide broad constraints on the equation of state of neutron - star matter ( zel , baym , & gver 2010 ) . in some cases , the formal uncertainties in the spectroscopic measurements are as low as a few percent ( gver et al .
2010b ) suggesting that their accuracy might be limited by systematic effects rather than by counting statistics . in this series of articles
, we use the large database of x - ray bursts observed with the rxte in order to assess the systematic effects in various spectroscopic measurements of their properties . in the first article
, we focus on the measurements of the apparent surface areas of 12 neutron stars as inferred from their x - ray spectra during the cooling tails of the bursts .
our goal is to quantify the degree to which : _ ( i ) _ the x - ray burst spectra observed in the rxte energy range can be described by blackbody functions ( the so - called color correction arising from atmospheric effects are then applied a posteriori ) ; _ ( ii ) _ the entire surface area of each neutron star burns practically uniformly during the cooling of the bursts ; _ ( iii ) _ the accretion flows make minor contributions to the emission during the bursts .
lccccc 4u 0513@xmath140 & 05 14 06.60 & @xmath140 02 37.0 & 6 & 0.014@xmath2 & gc + 4u 1608@xmath152 & 16 12 43.00 & @xmath152 25 23.0 & 26 & [email protected]@xmath4 & x - ray edges + 4u 1636@xmath153 & 16 40 55.50 & @xmath153 45 05.0 & 162 & 0.44@xmath5 & x - ray edges + 4u 1702@xmath1429 & 17 06 15.31 & @xmath143 02 08.7 & 46 & 1.95 & x - ray continuum + 4u 1705@xmath144 & 17 08 54.47 & @xmath144 06 07.4 & 44 & [email protected]@xmath6 & x - ray edges + 4u 1724@xmath1307 & 17 27 33.20 & @xmath130 48 07.0 & 3 & 1.08@xmath2 & gc + 4u 1728@xmath134 & 17 31 57.40 & @xmath133 50 05.0 & 90 & 2.49 @xmath30.14@xmath7 & x - ray edges + ks 1731@xmath1260 & 17 34 12.70 & @xmath126 05 48.5 & 24 & 2.98 & x - ray continuum + 4u 1735@xmath144 & 17 38 58.30 & @xmath144 27 00.0 & 6 & 0.28@xmath8 & x - ray edges + exo 1745@xmath1248 & 17 48 56.00 & @xmath124 53 42.0 & 22 & [email protected]@xmath9 & x - ray continuum + 4u 1746@xmath137 & 17 50 12.7 & @xmath137 03 08.0 & 7 & 0.36@xmath10 & gc + sax j1748.9@xmath12021 & 17 48 52.16 & @xmath120 21 32.4 & 4 & 0.79@xmath10 & gc + sax j1750.8@xmath12900 &
17 50 24.00 & @xmath129 02 18.0 & 4 & 4.97 & x - ray continuum + 4u 1820@xmath130 & 18 23 40.45 & @xmath130 21 40.1 & 5 & 0.25 @xmath30.03@xmath11 & x - ray edges + aql x@xmath11 & 19 11 16.05 & @xmath1200 35 05.8 & 51 & [email protected]@xmath13 & counterpart [ sourcestable ] we base our study on the x - ray burst catalog of galloway et al .
( 2008a ) .
we chose 12 out of the 48 sources in the catalog based on the following criteria : _ ( i ) _ we considered sources that show at least two bursts with evidence for photospheric radius expansion , based on the definition of the latter used by galloway et al .
( 2008a ) .
this requirement arises from our ultimate aim , which is to measure both the mass and the radius of the neutron star in each system using a combination of spectroscopic phenomena ( as in , e.g. , zel et al .
2009 ) .
_ ( ii ) _ we excluded dippers , adc sources , or known high - inclination sources .
this list includes exo 0748@xmath1676 , mxb 1659@xmath1298 , 4u 1916@xmath105 , grs 1747@xmath1312 , 4u 1254@xmath169 , and 4u 1710@xmath1281 , for which it was shown that geometric effects related to obscuration or reflection significantly affect the flux from the stellar surface that is measured by a distant observer ( galloway , zel , & psaltis 2008b ) . _
( iii ) _ we did not consider the known millisecond pulsars sax j1808.4@xmath13658 and hete j1900.1@xmath12455 because the presence of pulsations in their persistent emission implies that their magnetic fields are dynamically important and , therefore , may affect the properties of x - ray bursts . _
( iv ) _ we excluded the sources grs 1741.9@xmath12853 and 2e 1742.9@xmath12929 as well as a small number of bursts from aql x-1 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1746@xmath137 , for which there is substantial evidence that their emission is affected by source confusion ( galloway et al . 2008a ; keek et al .
2010 ) . _
( v ) _ for each source , we considered only bursts for which the flux in the persistent emission prior to the burst is at most 10% of the inferred eddington flux for each source , i.e. , @xmath14 , as calculated by galloway et al .
( 2008a ) .
because we subtract the pre - burst persistent emission from the decay spectrum of each x - ray burst , this requirement reduces substantially the systematic uncertainties introduced by potential changes in the emission from the accretion flow during the burst .
table [ sourcestable ] lists all the x - ray bursters that fulfill the above requirements , together with the number of bursts observed by rxte for each source . this is the complete list of sources for which the masses and radii can be measured , in principle , using the spectroscopic method of zel et al .
( 2009 ) , with currently available data .
our analyses of the bursts from exo 1745@xmath1248 , 4u 1608@xmath152 , and 4u 1820@xmath130 have been reported elsewhere ( zel et al .
2009 ; gver et al .
2010a , 2010b ) and will not be repeated here .
we analyzed the burst data for the 12 sources shown in table [ sourcestable ] following the method outlined in galloway et al .
( 2008a ; see also zel et al .
2009 ; gver et al . 2010a , 2010b ) .
for each source , we extracted time resolved [email protected] kev x - ray spectra using the _ seextrct _ ftool for the science event mode data and the _ saextrct _ ftool for the science array mode data from all of the rxte / pca layers .
science mode observations provide high count - rate data with a nominal time resolution of 125@xmath15s in 64 spectral channels over the whole energy range ( 2@xmath160 kev ) of the pca detector . following galloway et al .
2008a , we extracted spectra integrated over 0.25 , 0.5 , 1 , and 2 s time intervals , depending on the source count rate during the burst , so that the total number of counts in each spectrum is roughly constant .
( in a few cases , data gaps during the observations result in x - ray spectra integrated over shorter exposure times ) .
we took the spectrum over a 16 s time interval prior to the onset of each burst as the spectrum of the persistent emission , which we subtracted from the burst spectra as background .
we generated separate response matrix files for each burst using the pcarsp version 11.7 , heasoft release 6.7 , and heasarc s remote calibration database and took into account the offset pointing of the pca during the creation of the response matrix files .
this latest version of the pca response matrix makes the instrument calibration self - consistent over the pca lifetime and yields a normalization of the crab pulsar that is within 1@xmath16 of the calibration measurement of toor & seward ( 1974 ) for that source . in 4 ,
we discuss in some detail the effect of the uncertainties in the absolute flux calibration on the measurement of the apparent surface area of neutron stars . finally , we corrected all of the x - ray spectra for pca deadtime following the method suggested by the rxte team .
to analyze the spectra , we used the interactive spectral interpretation system ( isis ) , version 1.4.9 - 55 ( houck & denicola 2000 ) . for each fit , we included a systematic error of 0.5% as suggested by the rxte calibration team .
we fit each spectrum with a blackbody function using the _ bbodyrad _ model ( as defined in xspec , arnaud 1996 ) and multiplied it by the _ tbabs _ model ( wilms , allen , & mccray 2000 ) that takes into account the interstellar extinction , assuming ism abundances .
the model of the x - ray spectrum for each burst , therefore , depends on only three parameters : the color temperature of the blackbody , @xmath17 , the normalization of the blackbody spectrum , @xmath18 , and the equivalent hydrogen column density , @xmath19 of the interstellar extinction . allowing the hydrogen column density @xmath19 to be a free parameter in the fitting procedure leads to correlated uncertainties between the amount of interstellar extinction and the temperature of the blackbody .
moreover , for every 10@xmath20 @xmath21 overestimation ( underestimation ) of the column density , the inferred flux of the thermal emission is systematically larger ( smaller ) by @xmath22 10@xmath23 erg @xmath21 s@xmath24 ( galloway et al .
reducing the uncertainties related to the interstellar extinction for each burster is , therefore , very important in controlling systematic effects .
a recent analysis of high resolution grating spectra from a number of x - ray binaries ( miller , cackett , & reis 2009 ) showed that the individual photoelectric absorption edges observed in the x - ray spectra do not show significant variations with source luminosity or spectral state .
this result strongly suggests that the neutral hydrogen column density is dominated by absorption in the interstellar medium and does not change on short timescales . in order to reduce this systematic uncertainty and given the fact that there is no evidence of variable neutral absorption for each system , we fixed the hydrogen column density for each source to a constant value that we obtained in one of the following ways . _
( i ) _ for a number of sources , the equivalent hydrogen column density was inferred independently using high - resolution spectrographs . _
( ii ) _ in cases where only an optical extinction or reddening measurement exists , we used the relation given by gver & zel ( 2009 ) to convert it to the equivalent hydrogen column density . _ ( iii ) _ finally , for three sources ( 4u 1702@xmath1429 , ks 1731@xmath1260 , sax
j1750.8@xmath12900 ) there are no independent hydrogen column density measurements published in the literature . in these cases
, we fit the x - ray spectra obtained during all the x - ray bursts of each source allowing the n@xmath25 value to vary in a wide range .
we then found the resulting mean value of n@xmath25 and used this as a constant in our second set of fits to all the x - ray bursts . in table
[ sourcestable ] , we show the adopted values for the hydrogen column density together with the measurement uncertainties , the method with which the values were estimated , and the appropriate references . future observations of these sources with x - ray grating spectrometers onboard chandra and xmm@xmath1_newton _ can help decrease the uncertainty arising from the lack of knowledge of the properties of the interstellar matter towards these sources .
our goal in this article is to study potential systematic uncertainties in the measurement of the apparent area of each neutron star during the cooling tails of x - ray bursts .
hereafter , we adopt the following working definition of the cooling tail .
it is the time interval during which the inferred flux is lower than the peak flux of the burst or the touchdown flux for photospheric radius expansion bursts . for the purpose of this definition , we use as a touchdown point the first moment at which the blackbody temperature reaches its highest value and the inferred apparent radius is lowest . in order to control the countrate statistics
, we also set a lower limit on the thermal flux during each cooling tail of 5@xmath2610@xmath23 erg s@xmath24 @xmath21 ( or 5@xmath2610@xmath27 for the exceptionally faint sources 4u 1746@xmath137 and 4u 0513@xmath1401 ) . in 3 and 4 ,
we discuss in detail our approach of quantifying the systematic uncertainties in the measurements of the apparent radii during the cooling tails of thermonuclear bursts , using the sources ks 1731@xmath1260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 as case studies . for another analysis of the cooling tails of x - ray bursts from 4u 1636@xmath1536 ,
see zhang , mendez , & altamirano ( 2011 ) . in 5 , we repeat this procedure systematically for seven additional sources from table [ sourcestable ] .
finally , the cooling tails of the bursts observed from 4u 0513@xmath140 and aql x-1 show irregular behavior , and we report our analysis of them in the appendix .
our first working hypothesis is that the spectra of neutron stars during the cooling tails of thermonuclear bursts can be modeled by blackbody functions in the observed energy range .
the fact that x - ray spectra can be described well with blackbody functions has been established since the first time resolved x - ray spectral studies of thermonuclear bursts ( see , e.g. , swank et al .
1977 ; lewin , van paradijs , & taam 1993 ; galloway et al . 2008a and
references therein ) . under that assumption ,
the temperature measured by fitting blackbodies to the spectra are then corrected for the effects of the atmosphere by applying a numerical prefactor called the color correction factor @xmath28 , which is the ratio of the color to the effective temperature .
this approach is expected to be only an approximation for a number of reasons .
first , theoretical models of the atmospheres of neutron stars in radiative equilibrium invariably show that the emerging spectra are broader than blackbodies , especially at low temperatures and towards low photon energies ( e.g. , madej et al .
2004 ; majczyna et al .
moreover , for neutron stars that are rapidly spinning , the spectra measured by an observer at infinity will be broader and more asymmetric with respect to those at the stellar surface ( zel & psaltis 2003 ) . the expected degree of broadening and asymmetry will be at most comparable to @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the spin frequency of the neutron star and @xmath31 is its radius . this is an uncertainty that can , in principle , be corrected for by fitting the x - ray data with theoretical models of the x - ray spectra emerging from the atmospheres of rapidly spinning neutron stars .
second , the accretion flow in the vicinity of the neutron star may alter in a number of ways the observed spectrum .
it may act as a mirror , reflecting a fraction of the emerging radiation towards the observer and , therefore , increasing the apparent surface area of emission .
it might occult a fraction of the stellar surface , reducing the apparent surface area of emission ( see galloway et al .
if the accretion flow is surrounded by a hot corona , comptonization of the surface emission will alter its spectrum as well as the relation between energy flux and apparent surface area ( e.g. , boutloukos , miller , & lamb 2010 ) .
finally , the residual emission of the accretion flow , which we attempt to remove by subtracting the pre - burst spectrum of the source , might change during the duration of the burst , introducing systematic changes in the net spectrum .
all of the above effects have the potential of changing the shape of the x - ray spectrum of a burster and , perhaps more importantly , lead to stochastic changes in the inferred apparent radii . their overall effect ,
however , is expected to be significantly reduced by the fact that the intense radiation field during each x - ray burst should either disrupt the inner accretion flow or cool any corona to the compton temperature of the radiation .
such a phenomenon has been observed during a superburst from 4u 1820@xmath130 ( ballantyne & strohmayer 2004 ) .
moreover , these effects are expected to be the strongest for high inclination systems ( as was inferred by , e.g. , galloway et al.2008b ) .
this is why we not only limited our sample to bursts for which the ratio of the persistent flux prior to the burst to the eddington flux @xmath32 in order to minimize accretion - related uncertainties but also selected the known high inclination sources out of our sample ( see 2 ) .
values obtained from fitting 1309 , 2519 , and 4596 x - ray burst spectra observed from the sources ks 1731@xmath1260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 , respectively .
the solid lines show the expected @xmath33/d.o.f .
distributions for the number of degrees of freedom used during the fits .
the vertical dashed lines correspond to the highest values of @xmath34/d.o.f . that we considered as statistically acceptable for each source .
the vast majority of spectra are well described by blackbody functions.,title="fig : " ] /d.o.f .
values obtained from fitting 1309 , 2519 , and 4596 x - ray burst spectra observed from the sources ks 1731@xmath1260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 , respectively .
the solid lines show the expected @xmath33/d.o.f .
distributions for the number of degrees of freedom used during the fits .
the vertical dashed lines correspond to the highest values of @xmath34/d.o.f . that we considered as statistically acceptable for each source .
the vast majority of spectra are well described by blackbody functions.,title="fig : " ] /d.o.f .
values obtained from fitting 1309 , 2519 , and 4596 x - ray burst spectra observed from the sources ks 1731@xmath1260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 , respectively .
the solid lines show the expected @xmath33/d.o.f .
distributions for the number of degrees of freedom used during the fits .
the vertical dashed lines correspond to the highest values of @xmath34/d.o.f . that we considered as statistically acceptable for each source .
the vast majority of spectra are well described by blackbody functions.,title="fig : " ] a final source of systematic uncertainties in the determination of the x - ray spectral shape of a burster is related to errors in the response matrix of the detector .
these are expected to be @xmath35% , according to the rxte calibration team ( see 2.2 ) . in order to quantify the degree to which any of these effects influence the spectra of x - ray bursters , we fit all cooling - tail spectra from each source with a blackbody model , allowing for a level of systematic uncertainty @xmath36 , determined in the following way .
we reduced the degree of freedom in this procedure by setting @xmath36 in each spectral bin to be a constant fraction @xmath37 of the poisson error @xmath38 and fixed the value of @xmath37 to a constant for each source .
we then added this systematic uncertainty to the formal poisson error of each measurement in quadrature , i.e. , @xmath39 , and defined a statistic @xmath34 such that @xmath40 here , @xmath33 is the standard statistic calculated for each fit
. the posterior distribution of the new statistic @xmath34 may not be the same as that of the @xmath33 statistic and will depend on the nature of the systematic uncertainties . in order to explore the degree and nature of systematic uncertainties , we fit for each source the @xmath34 distribution with the @xmath33 distribution expected for the number of degrees of freedom used in the fits , with @xmath37 as a free parameter .
note that the expected distribution that we use is formally correct if the countrate data in the individual spectral bins have uncorrelated errors .
the expected @xmath33 and the observed @xmath34 distributions for the optimal @xmath37 value for ks 1731@xmath1260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 are shown in figure [ fig : chi2 ] .
the @xmath37 value required to make the observed @xmath34 distributions for ks 1731@xmath1260 consistent with the expected ones is 0.55 ( see table [ chi2table ] ) .
this value corresponds to systematic uncertainties that are very small . as an example
, we consider a typical 0.25 s integration for ks 1731@xmath1260 , when its spectrum is characterized by a color temperature of 2.5 kev . in this case , the average number of counts in each spectral bin in the 3 - 10 kev energy range is 110 ct and the corresponding poisson uncertainty is @xmath41% .
multiplying this by the inferred value @xmath42 for this source leads to the conclusion that the systematic uncertainties required to render the observed spectrum consistent with a blackbody are @xmath43% . for the case of 4u 1728@xmath134 , which is brighter than ks 1731@xmath1260 , the formal uncertainties are @xmath44% and the systematic uncertainties amount to @xmath45% .
figure [ fig : chi2 ] shows that the resulting @xmath34 distributions can be well approximated by the @xmath33 distribution but have weak tails extending to higher values .
these tails most likely arise from the inconsistency of only a small number of spectra with blackbody functions even though we can not rule out the possibility that the @xmath34 statistic follows a different posterior distribution than @xmath33 .
figure [ fig : chi2 ] allows us also to identify the x - ray spectra that are statistically inconsistent with blackbodies . for each source
, there is a maximum value of @xmath34 per degree of freedom beyond which the distribution of @xmath34 values deviates from the theoretical expectation . for the case of ks 1731@xmath1260 ,
this limiting value of the reduced @xmath34 is 1.7 , for 4u 1728@xmath134 it is 1.7 , and for 4u 1636@xmath1536 is 1.9 ( see table [ chi2table ] ) .
the spectra with high reduced @xmath34 values often occur at the late stages of the cooling tails , where the subtraction of the persistent emission is the most problematic .
however , unacceptable @xmath34 values may also be found in other , seemingly random places of the cooling tails . nevertheless , the fraction of spectra that is inconsistent with blackbodies are @xmath46% , @xmath47% , and @xmath48% for ks 1731@xmath1260 , for 4u 1728@xmath134 , and for 4u 1636@xmath1536 , respectively .
hereafter , we consider only the spectra that we regard to be statistically acceptable , given the values of the reduced @xmath34 .
lcccc source & number of & @xmath37 & @xmath34/dof limit & fraction of + & spectra & & & acceptable spectra + 4u 0513@xmath140 & 94 & 0.44 & 1.7 & 93.6% + 4u 1636@xmath153 & 4579 & 0.59 & 1.9 & 99.3% + 4u 1702@xmath1429 & 285 & 0.21 & 2.0 & 99.3% + 4u 1705@xmath144 & 694 & & 1.5 & 87.5% + 4u 1724@xmath1307 & 58 & 0.44 & 1.5 & 91.4% + 4u 1728@xmath134 & 2532 & 0.57 & 1.7 & 93.4% + ks 1731@xmath1260 & 1312 & 0.52 & 1.7 & 98.2% + 4u 1735@xmath144 & 40 & & 2.0 & 97.5% + 4u 1746@xmath137 & 187 & & 1.6 & 85.0% + sax j1748.9@xmath12021 & 104 & 0.26 & 1.9 & 99.0% + sax j1750.8@xmath12900 & 82 & 0.54 & 1.7 & 100% + aql x@xmath11 & 2191 & 0.45 & 1.6 & 92.1% + [ chi2table ]
our second working hypothesis is that , during the cooling tail of each burst , the entire neutron star is emitting uniformly with negligible lateral temperature variations .
this assumption is again expected to be violated at some level for a number of reasons .
the non - uniformity of accretion onto the neutron star ( e.g. , inogamov & sunyaev 1999 ) , the finite time of propagation of the burning front around the star ( see , e.g. , nozakura , ikeuchi , & fujimoto 1984 ; bildsten 1995 ; spitkovsky , levin , & ushomirsky 2002 ) , as well as the excitation of non - radial modes on the stellar surface ( heyl 2004 ; piro & bildsten 2005 ; narayan & cooper 2007 ) are all expected to lead to some variations in the effective temperature of emission at different latitudes and longitudes on the stellar surface . the characteristics of burst oscillations observed during the cooling tails of x - ray bursts , however , imply that any variations in the surface temperatures of neutron stars can only be marginal .
indeed , any component of the variation in the surface temperature that is not symmetric with respect to the rotation axis leads to oscillations of the observed flux at the spin frequency of the neutron star .
such oscillations have been observed in the tails of bursts from many sources ( galloway et al .
the r.m.s .
amplitudes of burst oscillations in the tails of bursts can be as large as 15% , although the typical amplitude is @xmath43% ( muno , zel , & chakrabarty 2002 ) .
the stringent upper limits on the observed amplitudes at the harmonics of the spin frequencies can be accounted for only if the temperature anisotropies are dominated by the @xmath49 mode in which exactly half the neutron star is hotter than the other half ( muno et al .
moreover , the rather weak dependence of the r.m.s.amplitudes on photon energy ( muno , zel , & chakrabarty 2003 ) requires that any temperature variation between the hotter and cooler regions of the neutron star is @xmath50 kev , even for the bursts that show the largest burst oscillation amplitudes .
all of the above strongly suggest that the expected flux anisotropy during the cooling tail of an x - ray burst is @xmath51% and , therefore , the expected systematic uncertainties in the inferred apparent stellar radius will be half of that value , since the latter scales as the square root of the flux . on the color temperature of the x - ray spectrum for two sequences of models by madej et al .
( 2004 ) , majczyna et al .
( 2005 ) , and suleimanov et al .
( 2011 ) with different metal abundances and surface gravities . between 1 kev and 2.5 kev ,
the color correction factor depends weakly on the color temperature .
+ + ] a final inherent systematic uncertainty in the spectroscopic measurement of the apparent surface area of a neutron star arises from the dependence of the color correction factor on the effective temperature of the atmosphere . in figure
[ fig : fcolor ] we show the predicted evolution of the color correction factor as a function of the color temperature of the spectrum as measured by an observer at infinity , for calculations by different groups for different neutron star surface gravities and atmospheric compositions ( madej et al.2004 ; majczyna et al . 2005 ; and suleimanov et al .
2011 ) . to make the models comparable to the observed evolution of the blackbody normalizations presented in the next section , we plot the color correction factor against the most directly observed quantity , i.e. , the color temperature at infinity .
when the color temperature at infinity is less than 2.5 kev , purely helium or low metallicity models show @xmath52 evolution of the color correction factor per kev of color temperature at infinity , while above 2.5 kev , they show an evolution of 12@xmath120% per kev . in contrast , solar metallicity models show a steady increase with color temperature in the @xmath53 kev range . ) which correspond only to neutron stars with radii @xmath54 km . ]
we infer the apparent surface area @xmath55 of a neutron star by measuring the x - ray flux @xmath56 and the color temperature @xmath57 at different intervals during the burst , so that @xmath58 here , @xmath59 is the stefan - boltzmann constant , @xmath60 is the distance to the source , and @xmath61 is the color correction factor .
the value of the color correction factor is dictated by the predominant source of absorption and emission in the neutron - star atmosphere .
it , therefore , depends on the effective temperature , which determines primarily the ionization levels , and on the effective gravitational acceleration , which determines the density profiles of the atmospheric layers .
both these quantities decrease as the cooling flux decreases .
if we were to assume a constant value for the color correction factor , as it is customary , we would obtain a systematic change in the inferred apparent surface area as the cooling flux of the burst decreases with time .
such variations have been discussed in damen et al .
( 1989 ) and in bhattacharyya , miller , & galloway ( 2010 ) .
note that this systematic effect can be corrected , in principle , if the data are fit directly with detailed models of neutron - star atmospheres ( see , e.g. , majczyna & madej 2005 ) .
a potentially important source of uncertainty in the measurements is introduced by the errors in the absolute flux calibration of the rxte / pca detector .
the current calibration of the pca and the cross - calibration between x - ray satellites have been carried out using the crab nebula as a standard candle ( jahoda et al .
2006 ; see also toor & seward 1974 ; kirsch et al . 2005 ;
weisskopf et al .
the uncertainties in the flux calibration can be due to a potential overall offset between the inferred and the true flux of the crab nebula , which may be as large as 10% ( kirsch et al .
2005 ; weisskopf et al .
this can only change the mean value of the inferred apparent area in each source and does not alter the observed dispersion .
we will explore this issue as well as uncertainties related to the variability of the crab nebula itself ( wilson - hodge et al .
2011 ) in more detail in paper iii of this series .
+ figure [ fig : kt_flux_detail ] ( left panels ) show the dependence of the emerging flux on color temperature for all the spectra in the cooling tails of ks 1731@xmath1260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 that we consider to be statistically acceptable ( see 3 ) .
we chose these three sources to use as detailed examples because of the high number spectra obtained for each and the fact that they span the range of behavior in cooling tracks that we will discuss below .
if the whole neutron star is emitting as a single - temperature blackbody and the color correction factor is independent of color temperature , then @xmath56 should scale as @xmath62 .
our aim here is to investigate the systematic uncertainties on the measurement of the apparent surface area in each source at different flux levels .
we , therefore , divided the data into a number of flux bins and plotted in the same figure ( right panels ) the distribution of the blackbody normalization values for some representative bins .
the blackbody normalization for each spectrum is defined formally as @xmath63 , although in practice this is one of the two measured parameters and the flux is derived from the above definition . according to equation ( [ eq : rapp ] ) , the blackbody normalization is equal to @xmath64 and we report it in units of ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 . if we do not correct for the dependence of the color correction factor on the flux , we expect the normalization @xmath18 to show a dependence on color temperature that is the mirror symmetric of that shown in figure 2 .
the flux - temperature diagrams of ks 1731@xmath1260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 share a number of similarities but are also distinguished by a number of differences . in all three cases , the vast majority of data points lie along a very well defined correlation .
this reproducibility of the cooling curves of tens of x - ray bursts per source , combined with the lack of large amplitude flux oscillations during cooling tails of bursts , provides the strongest argument that the thermal emission engulfs the entire neutron - star surface with very small temperature variations at different latitudes and longitudes . in 4u 1728@xmath134
, a deviation of the data points from the @xmath65 correlation is evident at high fluxes and color temperatures ( @xmath66 kev ) , which may be due to the evolution of the color correction factor at high eddington fluxes ( see the discussion in 4 and fig .
[ fig : fcolor ] ) .
the same deviation is not evident in ks 1731@xmath1260 or 4u 1636@xmath1536 , for which the highest temperatures encountered in the cooling tails were @xmath67 kev .
finally , in all three sources , a number of outliers exist at the lowest flux levels , with normalizations that deviate from the above correlation . in ks 1731@xmath1260 and 4u 1636@xmath1536
, the outliers correspond to higher normalization values , whereas in 4u 1728@xmath134 they correspond to lower normalization values with respect to the majority of the data points .
any combination of the effects discussed earlier in this and in the previous section may be responsible for the outliers .
non - uniform cooling of the neutron star surface will lead to a reduced inferred value for the apparent surface area .
reflection of the surface x - ray emission off a geometrically thin accretion disk will cause an increase in the inferred value for the apparent surface area . finally , comptonization of the surface emission in a corona may have either effect , depending on the compton temperature of the radiation .
our goal in this work is not to understand the origin of the outliers , but rather to ensure that their presence does not introduce any biases in the measurements of the apparent surface areas inferred from the vast majority of spectra . indeed , including the outliers in a formal fit of the flux - temperature correlation will cause a systematic increase of the apparent surface area with decreasing flux in ks 1731@xmath1260 and in 4u 1636@xmath1536 and a systematic decrease in 4u 1728@xmath134 ( c.f .
damen et al .
1990 ; bhattacharyya et al .
this issue was largely avoided in our earlier work ( zel et al.2009 ; gver et al . 2010a , 2010b ) by considering only the relatively early time intervals in the cooling tail of each burst , which correspond only to the brightest flux bins . in order to go beyond this limitation here ,
we consider all spectral data for each burst and employ a bayesian gaussian mixture algorithm , which is a standard procedure for outlier detection in robust statistics ( e.g. , titterington , smith , & makov 1985 ; mclachlan & peel 2000 ; huber & ronchetti 2009 ) .
our working hypothesis that the main peak of normalizations in each flux interval corresponds to the signal and the remainder are outliers is shaped by two aspects of the observations .
first , at high fluxes , each histogram can be described by a single gaussian with no evidence or room for a second distribution of what we would call outliers . at lower fluxes ,
when the histograms can be decomposed into two gaussians , the distribution with the highest peak has properties that smoothly connect to those of the single gaussians at higher fluxes .
second , the gaussians that we call our signal always contain the majority of the data points compared to the distribution of what we call the outliers .
we take these as our criteria for defining our signal .
the algorithm , which we describe below in detail , allows us also to measure the degree of intrinsic variation in the apparent surface area for each source that is consistent with the width of the flux - temperature correlation . even though we compare spectra in relatively narrow flux bins , the different observing modes as well as the different number of pcus used in each observation result in a wide range of count rates and , hence , in a wide range of formal errors .
this necessitates the use of the bayesian approach we describe below as opposed to , e.g. , performing @xmath33 fits of the distributions over blackbody normalization .
consider first the situation in which there are no systematic uncertainties and the inferred blackbody normalization from every spectrum reflects the apparent surface area of the entire neutron star .
if this were the case , the intrinsic distribution of blackbody normalizations would be a delta function , while the observed distribution would be broader , with a width equal to the average formal uncertainties of the measurements . in a more realistic situation
, there is an intrinsic range of the inferred blackbody normalizations , caused by a combination of the various effects discussed earlier .
we assume that , in each flux bin , the intrinsic distribution of normalization values is the gaussian @xmath68\ ; , \label{eq : int_dist}\ ] ] where @xmath69 is its mean and @xmath70 is its standard deviation .
the observed distribution of blackbody normalizations will be again broader than the intrinsic distribution because of the formal uncertainties in each measurement .
moreover , at low flux levels , a small number of outliers exists , which skews and introduces tails to the observed distribution . our goal here is to quantify the most probable value of the blackbody normalization , i.e. , the parameter @xmath69 in the distribution ( [ eq : int_dist ] ) , as well as the intrinsic range of values in each flux bin , i.e. , the parameter @xmath70 , while excluding the outliers .
[ fig:1728_detail ] when the inspection of an observed distribution requires an outlier detection scheme ( as , e.g. , in the lower right panels of fig .
[ fig : kt_flux_detail ] ) , we model the distribution of outliers by a similar gaussian , i.e. , @xmath71\;,\ ] ] with a mean @xmath72 and a standard deviation @xmath73 .
our model distribution function is , therefore , in general the gaussian mixture @xmath74 where @xmath75 measures the relative fraction of outliers in our sample .
we are looking for the parameters in these distributions that maximize the posterior probability @xmath76 , which measures the likelihood that a particular set of parameters is consistent with the data . using bayes theorem
, this probability distribution is @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the posterior probability that the particular set of normalization data have been measured for a given set of parameters and the last five terms are the prior probabilities for the model parameters ; the constant @xmath79 ensures that the probability density is normalized .
we consider a flat prior probability distribution for the central value of each gaussian in an interval that extends beyond the observed range of normalization values for each source .
we also consider a flat prior probability distribution for the standard deviation for each gaussian from @xmath80 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 ( which is practically zero ) to a value equal to the width of the range of normalizations . finally , we take a flat prior distribution of @xmath75 between zero and one .
our results are extremely weakly dependent on the ranges of parameter values we considered . given a set of @xmath81 observed normalization values @xmath82 and their uncertainties @xmath83 , we calculate the posterior probability of the data given a set of model parameters as @xmath84 \left[p_{\rm int}(a| a_{\rm int } , \sigma_{\rm int } ) + \eta p_{\rm out}(a| a_{\rm out } , \sigma_{\rm out})\right]\;. \label{eq : post_prob_data}\ ] ] here , @xmath82 is the value of each measurement and @xmath83 is its corresponding uncertainty , which we assume to be normally distributed ; @xmath85 is a normalization constant . using this posterior probability distribution , we identify the most probable values of the model parameters , as well as their uncertainties , following standard procedures .
figure [ fig:1728_detail ] shows , as an example , the application of the gaussian mixture algorithm to the distribution of blackbody normalizations obtained from fitting the spectra of 4u 1728@xmath134 , when the burst flux was in the range @xmath86 erg @xmath21 s@xmath24 . the histogram shows the distribution of blackbody normalizations measured in this flux interval .
the parameters of the gaussian mixture that maximize the posterior probability distribution calculated using equation ( [ eq : post_prob ] ) correspond to an intrinsic distribution with a mean and standard deviation of @xmath87 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 and @xmath88 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 , respectively , and a distribution of outliers with a mean of @xmath89 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 , a standard deviation of @xmath90 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 , and a relative normalization of @xmath91 . in order to compare the gaussian mixture with the observed histogram
, we first convolve it with a third gaussian distribution with a standard deviation of @xmath92 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 that is equal to the average formal errors of all measurements in this flux interval .
the result is shown as a red solid line in figure [ fig:1728_detail ] , which demonstrates that our assumption of a gaussian distribution for the majority of the data and for the outliers is consistent with the observations .
we can appreciate the importance of excluding the outliers from the sample using the bayesian gaussian mixture algorithm in the following way .
if we repeat the above procedure for the same flux interval in 4u 1728@xmath134 but do not allow for the presence of outliers , the parameters of the intrinsic distribution will be @xmath93 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 and @xmath94 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 , which are significantly different than the results quoted above .
moreover , had we assumed that there are no systematic errors but that the underlying distribution was a delta function , the most probable value would have been @xmath95 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 . the formal errors in such a measurement would have been substantially smaller compared to the systematic uncertainties . in the following ,
we show in detail the application of this gaussian mixture algorithm to all the flux intervals for the three sources .
260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 , when the outliers have been removed .
each dot represents the most likely centroid of the intrinsic distribution , while each error bar represents its most likely width , as calculated using the procedure outlined in 4.2 and depicted in figure [ fig:1728_detail ] . in each panel ,
the solid and dashed horizontal lines show the best - fit normalization and its systematic uncertainty inferred using the flux bins that do not correspond to near - eddington fluxes and are denoted by filled circles on the error bars.,title="fig : " ] 260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 , when the outliers have been removed .
each dot represents the most likely centroid of the intrinsic distribution , while each error bar represents its most likely width , as calculated using the procedure outlined in 4.2 and depicted in figure [ fig:1728_detail ] . in each panel ,
the solid and dashed horizontal lines show the best - fit normalization and its systematic uncertainty inferred using the flux bins that do not correspond to near - eddington fluxes and are denoted by filled circles on the error bars.,title="fig : " ] 260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 , when the outliers have been removed .
each dot represents the most likely centroid of the intrinsic distribution , while each error bar represents its most likely width , as calculated using the procedure outlined in 4.2 and depicted in figure [ fig:1728_detail ] . in each panel ,
the solid and dashed horizontal lines show the best - fit normalization and its systematic uncertainty inferred using the flux bins that do not correspond to near - eddington fluxes and are denoted by filled circles on the error bars.,title="fig : " ] [ fig : norm_vs_flux ] lccccccccccc & & + source & 0.51 & 12 & 23 & 34 & 45 & 56 & 67 & 78 & 89 & 910 & average + 4u 1636@xmath1536 & 112.6 & 124.6 & 126.9 & 142.7 & 144.2 & 145.7 & 145.7 & 149.5 & & & 130.7 + & 18.7 & 16.1 & 12.4 & 22.4 & 18.4 & 15.1 & 14.1 & 4.6 & & & 20.9 + 4u 1702@xmath1429 & 151.0 & 167.6 & 180.4 & 184.2 & 185.7 & 171.4 & 151.0 & 119.3 & 98.2 & & 176.6 + & 13.9 & 10.1 & 9.9 & 4.1 & 3.9 & 8.1 & 8.1 & 17.2 & 12.4 & & 11.6 + 4u 1705@xmath144 & 80.2 & 86.9 & 86.9 & 82.4 & & & & & & & 83.9 + & 9.9 & 7.1 & 10.9 & 7.4 & & & & & & & 9.1 + 4u 1724@xmath1307 & 98.7 & 108.3 & 120.4 & 127.4 & 125.4 & 102.8 & & & & & 113.8 + & 7.1 & 4.6 & 12.6 & 3.7 & 19.4 & 15.4 & & & & & 15.4 + 4u 1728@xmath134 & 114.1 & 126.1 & 137.4 & 145.0 & 135.2 & 137.4 & 133.7 & 126.1 & 117.8 & 93.7 & 134.4 + & 15.6 & 13.4 & 10.9 & 8.9 & 18.2 & 18.4 & 16.4 & 13.1 & 15.4 & 13.1 & 14.9 + ks 1731@xmath1260 & 72.6 & 89.9 & 93.0 & 95.2 & 95.2 & & & & & & 96.0 + & 6.1 & 5.4 & 4.1 & 9.6 & 1.9 & & & & & & 7.9 + 4u 1735@xmath144 & 71.6 & 71.6 & 72.6 & & & & & & & & 72.1 + & 4.6 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & & & & & & & & @xmath98 + 4u 1746@xmath137 & 12.9 & 16.3 & 17.3 & 15.6 & 15.2 & 15.2 & 19.9 & & & & 15.7 + & 1.9 & 0.5 & 0.4 & 2.4 & 2.4 & 1.6 & 6.4 & & & & 2.4 + sax j1748.9@xmath12021 & 92.7 & 87.7 & 91.7 & 87.7 & & & & & & & 89.7 + & 11.9 & 6.6 & 7.6 & 15.4 & & & & & & & 9.6 + sax j1750.8@xmath12900 & 126.9 & 110.8 & 106.8 & 97.2 & 86.2 & & & & & & 93.2 + & 40.5 & 19.9 & 10.1 & 8.1 & 8.6 & & & & & & 9.4 + [ results ] [ cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] figure [ fig : norm_vs_flux ] shows the result of the outlier detection procedure as applied to the various flux intervals of ks 1731@xmath1260 , 4u 1728@xmath135 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 ( see also table [ results ] ) .
each dot represents the most likely centroid of the intrinsic distribution of blackbody normalizations , while each error bar represents its most likely width .
the normalization of the blackbody in the case of 4u 1728@xmath134 shows a strong dependence on flux when the source is emitting at near - eddington rates .
this is not seen in ks 1731@xmath1260 and 4u 1636@xmath1536 , for which the color temperature never reached temperatures above 2.5 kev .
in fact , in our observed sample , the strong dependence of the normalization on the flux is seen in all three sources with color temperatures in excess of 2.5 kev , namely 4u 1728@xmath134 , 4u 1702@xmath1429 , and
4u 1724@xmath1307 ( see fig .
6 below ) but is absent from the other sources .
the evolution of the blackbody normalization at near - eddington fluxes depends on the local gravitational acceleration ( @xmath99 ) on the neutron - star surface and on its composition .
therefore , modeling the decline of the blackbody normalization at large fluxes would allow us , in principle , to measure the combination @xmath100 of the mass and radius of the neutron star , as has been attempted by majczyna & madej ( 2005 ) and by suleimanov et al .
( 2011 ) .
+ + + + + + at low burst fluxes , the observed normalizations show a small albeit statistically significant trend towards lower values . in the case of 4u 1728@xmath134 , where the potential decrease is the largest , the normalization changed from @xmath101 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 to @xmath102 ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 as the flux declined from @xmath103 erg s@xmath24 @xmath21 to @xmath104 erg s@xmath24 @xmath21 .
this corresponds to a @xmath105% reduction in the normalization . in other sources ,
the decline is even smaller .
this weak dependence seen in the data argues against the models with solar composition , as shown in figure [ fig : fcolor ] .
the decline in the normalization can , in principle , be accounted for with a @xmath106% increase in the color correction factor ( see eq .
[ [ eq : rapp ] ] ) towards low temperatures .
as can be seen in figure [ fig : fcolor ] , current atmosphere models do not predict such an evolution . however , as we discussed in the beginning of 4 , a number of effects related to the physics of bursts on the neutron star surface ( uneven cooling and burst oscillations ) , as well as the reduced sensitivity of the pca at low energies , are capable of causing the observed trend in the normalization .
moreover , the @xmath107 effect in the data we would aim to model is comparable to the uncertainty in inferring theoretically the color correction factor from the atmosphere models and is also comparable to the deviation of the observed and theoretical spectra from blackbodies .
the latter concern can be remedied by fitting directly theoretical model spectra to the data , but reducing the theoretical uncertainties present in the models to less than @xmath108 few percent is significantly more challenging .
an alternative approach is to allow for a range of values for the color correction factor that span the spread of theoretical uncertainties , metallicities , and fluxes of the cooling tails . in earlier work ( gver et al .
2010a , 2010b ) we allowed for a 7% range in the color correction factor ( from 1.3 to 1.4 ) , which is adequate to account for the evolution in the blackbody normalizations shown by the data . following this approach ,
we need to identify the range of blackbody normalizations we obtained from the data at different flux intervals as a systematic uncertainty in the measurement . in order to achieve this
, we applied the bayesian gaussian mixture algorithm to the combined data set for each source for all flux intervals that correspond to a color temperature @xmath109 kev .
this way , we computed the most probable value for the blackbody normalization for each source in a wide flux range as well as the systematic uncertainties in that measurement , which account for the potential decline of the normalization with decreasing flux . in figure
[ fig : norm_vs_flux ] , we identify the flux intervals we used for each source with a filled circle in the middle of each error bar . we also depict with a solid line the most probable value of the normalization in this wide flux range and with dashed lines the range of systematic uncertainties .
our results are summarized in table 3 .
the blackbody normalizations for ks 1731@xmath1260 , 4u 1728@xmath134 , and 4u 1636@xmath1536 are [email protected] ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 , [email protected] ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 , and [email protected] ( km/10 kpc)@xmath4 , respectively , with the uncertainties dominated entirely by systematics .
figures [ fig : radii1][fig : radii3 ] and tables [ chi2table][results ] show the results obtained after applying the procedure outlined in 4 to seven more sources from table [ sourcestable ] .
the last two sources , 4u 0513@xmath140 and aql x-1 show large variations in the cooling tails of individual bursts and are discussed in detail in the appendix .
moreover , in the appendix we also discuss a number of bursts from 4u 1702@xmath1429 and a long burst from 4u 1724@xmath1307 , which we did not include in the analysis . as in the case of the three sources discussed in the previous section ,
the vast majority of the spectra observed during the cooling tails of x - ray bursts are very well described by blackbody functions , with only marginal allowance for systematic variations . in the flux - temperature diagrams ,
the cooling tails largely follow a well defined and reproducible track .
finally , in each flux interval of most sources , the range of blackbody normalizations obtained from a large number of bursts is consistent with a small degree of systematic uncertainties .
the measurements of the average blackbody normalizations in all sources are dominated by systematic uncertainties ( the main exception is 4u 1735@xmath144 ) . however , these uncertainties are small , ranging from @xmath44% in the case of 4u 1702@xmath1429 to @xmath110% in the case of 4u 1636@xmath1536 .
the apparent radius of each neutron star scales as the square root of the blackbody normalization . as a result ,
the errors in the spectroscopic determination of neutron - star radii introduced by systematic effects in the cooling tails of x - ray bursts are in the range @xmath0% ( see table [ radii_table ] ) .
such small errors by themselves do not preclude distinguishing between different equations of state of neutron - star matter .
a total of 46 bursts have been observed from the source 4u 1702@xmath1429 .
six of these bursts reach high fluxes and have been categorized as photospheric radius expansion bursts by galloway et al .
( 2008a ) .
the remaining 40 bursts typically reach lower fluxes . in the main body of this paper , we focused on the 6 bright bursts from this source and exclude the remaining for two reasons that we explore in this appendix .
the left panel of figure [ fig:1702_appendix ] shows the histogram of @xmath33/dof values for the 880 spectra observed during the cooling tails of the 40 bursts and compares them to the expected distribution given the number of degrees of freedom .
it is evident that blackbody functions provide statistically unacceptable fits to the majority of the spectra .
had we not considered these spectra unacceptable , we would find that , approximately 4 seconds after the bursts start , the inferred blackbody normalizations increase rapidly to large values .
the increase in normalization is , in fact , correlated with an increase in the @xmath111/dof values , as shown in the right panel of figure [ fig:1702_appendix ] , rendering them even more suspect .
these two arguments strongly suggest that the spectra of the 40 weak x - ray bursts from 4u 1702@xmath1429 are not dominated by the thermal emission from the neutron star .
the first x - ray burst observed from 4u 1724@xmath1307 on 1996 november 08 during observation 10090 - 01 - 01 - 02 is very different compared to the other two x - ray bursts that we used in the main text .
the first burst is unusually long ( @xmath112 s ) , while the other two bursts are much shorter ( @xmath113 s range , as is typical for the vast majority of the type - i bursts observed ) .
moreover , while the spectra of the short bursts are accurately modeled with blackbody functions ( see top panels of fig .
[ fig : radii1 ] ) , fitting the spectra during the cooling tail of the long burst results in unacceptably large values of @xmath33/dof and the distritubiton of the resulting @xmath33/dof values do not follow the expected @xmath33 distribution ( see left panel of fig .
[ fig:1724_appendix ] ) . adding a certain amount of systematic uncertainty to the data can in principle result in a decrease in the individual @xmath33/dof values ; however , it can not change the fact that the resulting @xmath33/dof distribution does not follow the expected distribution .
if we went ahead and further analyzed these statistically unacceptable spectra , we would have obtained values for the blackbody normalization that are larger compared to those of the shorter bursts ( see right panel of fig . [ fig:1724_appendix ] ) .
the large values and the seemingly random distribution of @xmath33/dof suggest that the x - ray spectra in the cooling tail of the long burst from 4u 1724@xmath1307 are not dominated by the thermal emission from the neutron star .
in fact , int zand & weinberg ( 2010 ) found evidence for atomic edges and a reflection component in the spectra of this burst , which they attributed to the presence of heavy metals in the ashes of previous bursts that were exposed by the long radius - expansion episode . for these reasons , we excluded the long x - ray burst observed from 4u 1724@xmath1307 from our analysis .
note that suleimanov et al.(2011 ) chose the spectra from this burst in order to infer the mass and radius of the neutron star in 4u 1724@xmath1307 .
had they chosen the other two bursts from the same source , the spectra of which are actually well described by blackbody functions , they would have obtained a radius of the neutron star that is @xmath114% smaller , making their result consistent with the radii inferred for the other sources using this method ( zel et al .
2009 ; gver et al .
2010a , 2010b ) as well as with radii inferred from quiescent neutron stars in globular clusters ( e.g. , webb & barret 2007 ; guillot , rutledge , & brown 2010 ) .
six bursts have been observed from the source 4u 0513@xmath140 . while most of the x - ray spectra during the cooling tails of these bursts can be described well by blackbody functions ( left panel of fig .
[ fig:0514 ] ) , the flux - temperature diagrams show irregular behaviour for the cooling tails ( right panel of fig .
[ fig:0514 ] ) .
in particular , two of the bursts show a cooling tail that is reminiscent of the long burst from 4u 1724@xmath1307 discussed above : early in the cooling phase the temperature of the blackbody decreases while the flux remains constant and , when the flux starts decreasing , the cooling occurs with blackbody normalizations that are on average larger compared to the other bursts .
it is plausible that the spectra of these bursts from 4u 0513@xmath140 are also affected by the presence of atomic lines , but the relatively low flux of 4u 0513@xmath140 ( which is a factor of @xmath115 smaller compared to that of 4u 1724@xmath1307 at similar temperatures ) still allows us to fit the observed spectra with blackbody functions .
we do not consider this source suitable for a radius measurement based on the burst data .
the transient source aql x-1 has shown 51 x - ray bursts , from which we extracted 2191 spectra .
most of these spectra are well fit by blackbody functions , but their cooling tracks in the flux - temperature diagram depend strongly on the properties of the bursts ( see fig .
[ fig : aqlx1 ] ) .
in particular , a large number of bursts are relatively short and reach modest fluxes ( typically @xmath116 erg s@xmath24 @xmath21 ) with cooling tracks in the flux - temperature diagram that are reproducible . on the other hand , many bursts , which are relatively longer , reach fluxes that are a factor of @xmath117 higher , are often characterized by radius expansion episodes , and follow a range of cooling tracks in the flux - temperature diagram with blackbody normalizations that are typically larger than those of the other bursts .
one plausible exlanation is related to the fraction of the neutron star surface that is engulfed by the thermonuclear flash . in weak flashes
, the burning front may not propage across the entire surface and , therefore , only a fraction of the stellar surface contributes to the normalization of the blackbody . on the other hand , in stronger flashes , a larger fraction of the neutron star surface is covered .
the source aql x-1 is one of the two main examples ( the other being the source 4u 1636@xmath1536 ) discussed by bhattacharrya et al .
( 2010 ) as evidence for systematic variations in the burning area during thermonuclear x - ray bursts .
it is important to emphasize here , however , that the case of aql x-1 is very unusual compared to the remaining sources that we analyzed and is , perhaps , related to the presence of a weak but dynamically important magnetic field in this source , as inferred from the observation of intermittent persistent pulsations ( casella et al .
2008 ) .
houck , j. c. , & denicola , l. a. 2000 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol .
216 , astronomical data analysis software and systems ix , ed .
n. manset , c. veillet , & d. crabtree , 591+ | the masses and radii of low - magnetic field neutron stars can be measured by combining different observable quantities obtained from their x - ray spectra during thermonuclear x - ray bursts .
one of these quantities is the apparent radius of each neutron star as inferred from the x - ray flux and spectral temperature measured during the cooling tails of bursts , when the thermonuclear flash is believed to have engulfed the entire star . in this paper , we analyze 13,095 x - ray spectra of 446 x - ray bursts observed from 12 sources in order to assess possible systematic effects in the measurements of the apparent radii of neutron stars .
we first show that the vast majority of the observed x - ray spectra are consistent with blackbody functions to within a few percent .
we find that most x - ray bursts follow a very well determined correlation between x - ray flux and temperature , which is consistent with the whole neutron - star surface emitting uniformly during the cooling tails .
we develop a bayesian gaussian mixture algorithm to measure the apparent radii of the neutron stars in these sources , while detecting and excluding a small number of x - ray bursts that show irregular cooling behavior .
this algorithm also provides us with a quantitative measure of the systematic uncertainties in the measurements .
we find that those errors in the spectroscopic determination of neutron - star radii that are introduced by systematic effects in the cooling tails of x - ray bursts are in the range @xmath0% .
such small errors are adequate to distinguish between different equations of state provided that uncertainties in the distance to each source and the absolute calibration of x - ray detectors do not dominate the error budget . |
the x - ray emission from normal elliptical galaxies has two major components : soft ( @xmath0 kev ) emission from diffuse gas and harder ( @xmath1 kev ) emission from populations of accreting ( low - mass ) stellar x - ray binaries ( lmxb ) .
the x - ray properties of the lmxb component have been difficult to determine , due to their spatial confusion with diffuse gaseous emission and to spectral hardness which places much of the lmxb emission outside the effective bandpasses of most imaging x - ray satellite spectrometers .
the presence of the lmxb component has been inferred in part through observations of spectral hardening in ellipticals with progressively smaller x - ray to optical luminosity ratios ( kim , fabbiano , & trinchieri 1992 ) , indicating that they have relatively little gas , exposing the harder lmxb component .
populations of lmxbs are also expected in ellipticals simply by analogy with detections of discrete lmxb sources in nearby spheroids such as the bulges and halos of our galaxy and m31 ( forman , jones & tucker 1985 ; canizares , fabbiano & trinchieri 1987 ) , as well as in the radio galaxy centaurus a ( turner et al . 1997 ) .
a simple argument suggests that the total x - ray luminosities of lmxb populations in ellipticals might be proportional to the stellar luminosities of the galaxies : if the properties of low mass binary stellar systems ( such as the fraction of stars in binaries , the distributions of binary separations and mass ratios , etc . )
are largely independent of their galactic context , the number of lmxbs ( hence their aggregate x - ray luminosity ) should be simply proportional to the number of stars in the galaxy ( and thus their total optical luminosity ) . high angular resolution _
observations are now allowing individual lmxbs to be resolved out of the diffuse gaseous x - ray emission in nearby ellipticals ( kraft et al .
2000 , 2001 ; sarazin , irwin , & bregman 2000 , 2001 ; angelini , loewenstein , & mushotzky 2001 ; finoguenov & jones 2001 ) , which makes their composite spectral analysis much easier .
the bulk of the hard emission in normal ellipticals indeed comes from lmxbs , rather than from advection - dominated accretion flows onto massive , central black holes , proposed by allen , di matteo & fabian ( 2000 ) .
until _ chandra _ observes more nearby ellipticals , the strongest spectral constraints to date on the hard stellar lmxb component in a large sample of ellipticals will still come from _ asca _ spectra ( matsumoto et al . 1997 ; white 2000 , 2001 , 2002 ) .
since the effective angular resolution of _ asca _ imaging spectrometers is @xmath4 ( half - power diameter ) , confusion prevents individual lmxbs from being easily resolved out of the diffuse gas in ellipticals .
the hard lmxb component can be spectrally distinguished from the softer gaseous component , however .
matsumoto et al . ( 1997 ) separated the hard lmxb component in ellipticals from softer gaseous emission by considering _
gis spectral energies above 4 kev . stacking 4 - 10 kev gis spectra for 12 ellipticals
, they found a best - fit thermal bremsstrahlung model with @xmath5 kev ( where errors are 90% confidence limits ) ; a power - law with photon index @xmath6 fit equally well .
matsumoto et al . ( 1997 ) found that the x - ray luminosities of the lmxb components were proportional to the optical luminosities of the ellipticals , but with a surprisingly large scatter ( a factor of @xmath7 ) .
some of the ellipticals included in the sample have significant x - ray emission from active galactic nuclei ( agn ) , which may account for some of the scatter .
white ( 2000 , 2001 , 2002 ) performed a similar _ asca _ analysis , but with a larger spectral bandwidth ( 0.7 - 10 kev ) , on six normal ellipticals ( i.e. , ellipticals without significant agn emission ) .
spectra were extracted from within metric radii of 6@xmath8 from the galactic centers , where @xmath8 is the optical effective radius of a galaxy .
the gis spectra of the six ellipticals were simultaneously fit with both soft ( gaseous ) and hard ( lmxb ) emission components .
( only gis data were used because the gis detectors have twice the effective area of the sis detectors above 7 kev . ) the temperatures ( or power - law indices ) of the hard components in the galaxies were tied together , while the temperatures of the soft components ( if present ) were allowed to vary individually .
much tighter spectral model constraints were provided by the increased spectral bandwidth compared to the 4 - 10 kev bandwidth in the stacked spectral study of matsumoto et al .
the spectra of the lmxb components were fit equally well by a bremsstrahlung model with @xmath9 kev or a power - law model with photon index @xmath10 ( errors are 90% confidence limits ) .
individual fits to each galaxy in the set were consistent with the results of the joint fits and fluxes were obtained by adopting the best jointly fit temperature .
these are the tightest constraints to date on the global spectral properties of the stellar lmxb component in ellipticals .
gis x - ray fluxes were determined for the lmxb components in an additional 8 ellipticals which had poorer photon statistics by fixing the temperature of the hard component to 6.4 kev .
the resulting x - ray luminosities of the lmxb components in the 14 galaxies were found to be proportional to the optical luminosities of the galaxies , with a factor of @xmath11 scatter .
recent _ chandra _ observations ( sarazin et al .
2000 , 2001 : angelini et al .
2001 ; blanton , sarazin , & irwin 2001 ) also show that the x - ray luminosities of the resolved lmxb components in ellipticals exhibit significant scatter at a given optical luminosity .
( the composite spectra of these lmxb components are also consistent with the hard _ asca _ spectral results described above . )
although their scatter in luminosity is much smaller than that of the softer gaseous component ( which ranges a factor of 100 in x - ray / optical flux ratio ) , it is still larger than expected if the lmxb component is strictly proportional to the stellar component . following a preliminary study by white ( 2000 , 2001 ) ,
we next consider two possible sources of variance in the x - ray luminosities of lmxb populations in elliptical galaxies : age differences among ellipticals and differences in their globular cluster populations .
if lmxb populations are a subset of the primordial binary systems in a galactic stellar field , then the evolution of an lmxb population should be tied to the evolution of visible stars .
the evolution of the aggregate x - ray luminosity of an lmxb population is best assessed with a population synthesis calculation ( wu 2001 ) . a simpler
, more phenomenological approach was adopted by white & ghosh ( 1998 ) .
the luminosity of an lmxb population ( neglecting burst sources ) is expected to rise for about a gyr ( white & ghosh 1998 ) , driven by the time it takes the less massive secondaries in binaries to evolve off the main sequence , overflow their roche lobes , and start dumping mass onto the more massive ( primary ) compact stellar remnants in the binaries .
after this gyr ramp - up , the luminosity of an lmxb population is expected to slowly decline ( white & ghosh 1998 ; wu 2001 ) .
2.45truein the optical stellar luminosities of galaxies are also slowly declining with time .
figure 1 of bruzual & charlot ( 1993 ) shows that the ( visual ) optical luminosity of an elliptical galaxy declines as @xmath12 . this time dependence is close enough to estimates for the temporal decline in the x - ray luminosity of lmxb populations that it is difficult to assess how the x - ray to optical ratio of the lmxb component is evolving at the present epoch . for our purposes , ambiguity in the theoretical expectation for the temporal evolution of @xmath3 does not matter
we can deduce the evolution empirically .
if variations in the x - ray properties of the lmxb component for galaxies of a given optical luminosity are correlated with independent age estimates , the @xmath3 ratio itself might then be used as an indicator of galactic age . to test this possibility ,
we compare the @xmath3 ratio for the lmxb components from the elliptical sample of white ( 2002 ) to recent stellar age estimates for elliptical galaxies ( trager et al . 2000 ) .
the stellar age estimates were derived by comparing the strengths of optical stellar spectral line indices of @xmath13fe@xmath14 , mg b and h@xmath15 ( which were corrected for the effects of non - solar abundance ratios ) , to the single - burst stellar population models of worthey ( 1994 ) . for their sample of 50 ellipticals , trager et al .
( 2000 ) find ages ranging from @xmath16 gyr . in figure
[ fig : age ] , the relevant optical stellar age estimates ( ranging from @xmath17 gyr ) are compared to the @xmath3 ratios for the lmxb populations in the eight ellipticals of ( the fourteen in ) white ( 2002 ) that were included in the trager et al .
( 2000 ) sample .
the x - ray luminosities were calculated in the 0.5 - 4.5 kev range and their errors are 90% confidence limits .
there is apparently no correlation , so variations in the @xmath3 ratios for lmxb populations are not likely to be due to galactic age differences .
0.2truein alternatively , most lmxbs may be formed in globular clusters , rather than in the stellar field of a galaxy .
observations of lmxbs in our own galaxy show that it is very difficult to make lmxbs in the field .
there are comparable numbers of high mass x - ray binaries ( hmxbs ) and lmxbs , but hmxb lifetimes are only @xmath18 yr , which are @xmath19 times shorter than lmxb lifetimes .
thus , the formation of lmxbs in our galaxy is @xmath19 times less efficient than the formation of hmxbs .
meanwhile , globular clusters are the most efficient formation site for lmxbs in our galaxy : @xmath20 of all lmxbs in our galaxy reside in globular clusters , yet globular clusters contain @xmath21 of the stars in our galaxy ( katz 1975 ) .
thus , globular clusters form lmxbs @xmath22 times more efficiently than the rest of the galaxy , through tidal capture during close stellar encounters ( clark 1975 ) . given this , it is reasonable to consider whether @xmath23 lmxbs are formed in globular clusters .
grindlay ( 1984 ) suggested that x - ray bursting binaries in the bulge of our galaxy ( not residing in globular clusters ) were formed in globular clusters which were later destroyed by tidal shocks while passing through the galaxy s disk .
this disruption mechanism is not relevant to globulars residing in elliptical galaxies , but if globulars are on eccentric orbits , they may still lose stars due to galactic tides at perigalacticon .
vesperini ( 2000 ) estimates that only @xmath24 of globular clusters are disrupted in the most luminous ellipticals , but the fraction disrupted increases considerably for progressively smaller elliptical luminosities .
also , some lmxbs formed in globular clusters may be ejected by the velocity kicks imparted by supernovae during the formation of neutron stars .
typical supernovae kick velocities are thought to range from @xmath25 km / s ( kalogera 1996 ; terman , taam , & savage 1996 ; fryer , burrows , & benz 1998 ) , while the escape velocities of globular clusters range from @xmath26 km / s ( webbink 1985 ) .
since lmxb lifetimes can be quite long ( @xmath27 yr ) , lmxbs ejected from globular clusters can be visible outside the clusters for a long time .
if lmxbs are made primarily in globular clusters , we would expect their number to be proportional to the number of globular clusters , regardless of the fraction ejected from clusters . with the excellent angular resolution of _ chandra _ , it is possible to determine positions of lmxbs with sufficient accuracy to determine if they coincide with globular clusters .
observations of ellipticals show that a significant fraction are located in globulars ( sarazin et al .
2000 , 2001 ; angelini et al . 2001 ; randall , sarazin , & irwin 2001 ; white , davis & hanes 2002 ) .
the fraction ranges from @xmath2820 to 70% . these are lower limits , since deeper _ chandra _ exposures may detect fainter x - ray sources in additional globulars . in the same region of these galaxies ,
the globular clusters typically provide only @xmath29% of the optical light , which implies that optical stars in globular clusters are much more likely to be the donor stars in lmxbs than in the field .
the primary limitation with identifying lmxbs with globulars in ellipticals at present is the lack of _ hubble space telescope _
( hst ) globular cluster lists for many of the _ chandra _ observed ellipticals .
since elliptical galaxies exhibit an order of magnitude range of globular cluster populations for a given galaxian luminosity , we can assess whether these variations are correlated with variations in @xmath3 . in figure
[ fig : gc ] , we compare the specific frequency of globular clusters @xmath30 ( the number of globular clusters per galaxy visual luminosity in units of the luminosity of a @xmath31 galaxy ) from the compilation of kissler - patig ( 1997 ) to the @xmath3 ratio for the lmxb populations in the elliptical sample described above .
the kissler - patig ( 1997 ) compilation includes error estimates for @xmath30 , as indicated in the figure , for all but one elliptical in this sample .
there appears to be a strong correlation ( white 2000 , 2001 ) , and the relationship is consistent with direct proportionality : @xmath32 .
thus , lmxb populations may indeed be controlled by globular cluster populations .
2.45truein 0.2truein
this study suggests that globular cluster populations in ellipticals control the evolution of their populations of low mass stellar x - ray binaries . at the present epoch
, age differences among the ellipticals in the small sample described above do not seem to be correlated with the variations in their x - ray binary populations
. it would be useful to compare the lmxbs in early - type galaxies with more detailed properties ( such as color and magnitude ) of their globulars ( other than just the number ) , to see if the history of star formation in the globular affects the lmxb population .
the _ chandra _
observations of ngc 1399 suggested that lmxbs are more likely to be found in redder globular clusters ( angelini et al .
there also is evidence that lmxbs are more likely to be found in brighter globulars ( angelini et al .
2001 ) , although it is unclear whether this is just due to the larger number of stars in brighter globulars , or indicates a higher probability per star in more massive clusters .
it is possible that most or all lmxbs in early - type galaxies are formed in globular clusters . in this scenario ,
any field lmxbs in ellipticals would have escaped from globulars .
the field lmxbs might have been ejected by the kick velocities resulting from supernovae , by stellar dynamical processes such as superelastic encounters in which internal binding energy in the binaries is converted into kinetic energy of motion of the binary , or by the dissolution of the globular due to tidal effects .
there is some evidence that the lmxbs in globular clusters in elliptical galaxies are brighter in x - rays than those in the field ( angelini et al .
if all of the lmxbs were formed in globular clusters , this would require that the less luminous and presumably less massive lmxbs systems were preferentially ejected from globular clusters .
alternatively , if a significant fraction of the field lmxbs were formed in the field , this would imply differing stellar and binary evolution histories in the field and in globular clusters .
many sources associated with globulars have x - ray luminosities which exceed the eddington luminosity of a 1.4 @xmath33 neutron star , @xmath34 ergs s@xmath35 ( sarazin et al .
2000 , 2001 ; angelini et al . 2001
; blanton et al . 2001 ; randall et al .
2001 ; white et al .
in general , lmxb luminosity functions within early - type galaxies have a break at a luminosity very close to @xmath36 ( sarazin et al .
2000 , 2001 ; blanton et al . 2001 ; randall et al .
this break may separate accreting black holes , at higher luminosities , from accreting neutron stars at lower luminosities ( sarazin et al .
if the sources are eddington - limited single binaries , then the brightest sources associated with globular clusters must contain quite massive ( @xmath37 ) black holes ( sarazin et al .
it is not clear how globular clusters would form and retain such massive black holes in lmxbs and also not have them form binary black hole systems ( e.g. , portegies zwart & mcmillan 2000 ) . on the other hand
, these super - eddington sources might be globular clusters containing multiple x - ray sources ( angelini et al .
the difficulty with this suggestion is that the fraction of globulars which contain at least one x - ray source is low ; the fraction is about 3 - 4% in ngc 1399 ( angelini et al .
2001 ) , ngc 4697 ( sarazin et al .
2000 , 2001 ) , and in ngc 4649 .
( it is interesting that this fraction is almost the same in these three ellipticals . )
the luminosity function of the lmxbs is nt steep enough that multiple sources should affect the luminosity function at the high end , given this low fraction .
on the other hand , if the lmxbs are mainly confined to a smaller subset of globular clusters ( e.g. , very bright and/or very red and/or core collapsed systems ) , then the fraction of the relevant subset of globulars with x - ray sources and the probability of multiple sources might be much higher .
there is some evidence that these luminous super - eddington x - ray sources are associated with globular clusters in elliptical and s0 galaxies , but not with the bulges of spiral galaxies .
there are no super - eddington lmxbs associated with globular clusters in the bulge of our galaxy ( e.g. , hut et al .
the same is true of the central 5 of the bulge of m31 ( shirey et al .
the luminosity of lmxbs in the nearby large spiral bulge ngc 1291 has a cut - off at a luminosity which is very close to @xmath36 .
unless this is the result of statistical fluctuations and the large populations of globular clusters in elliptical galaxies , this suggests that the binaries in globulars in ellipticals have different histories than those in spiral bulges .
in general , the specific frequency of globular clusters @xmath30 increases along the hubble sequence from late to early - type spirals , from spirals to s0s , from s0s to ellipticals , and from normal giant ellipticals to cds ( e.g. , harris 1991 ) .
if lmxbs all are born in globular clusters , then one would expect the specific frequency of lmxbs and their x - ray to optical ratio to increase along the same sequence .
in particular , a number of central dominant ellipticals in galaxy clusters are notable for having enormous populations of globular clusters .
white ( 1987 ) suggested that these unusually populous systems belong to the galaxy clusters , rather than individual galaxies : globular clusters will have been tidally stripped from individual galaxies during the collapse of a galaxy cluster and will then virialize along with other cluster constituents .
if lmxbs are formed primarily in globular clusters , then central dominant galaxies with high specific globular cluster frequencies ( such as m87 , ngc 1399 , ngc 3311 and ngc 4874 ) should be particularly rich in lmxbs , as well .
_ chandra _ observations have already confirmed the large populations of lmxbs in ngc 1399 ( angelini et al .
2001 ) , and in the region of this galaxy with a globular cluster list based on hst observations , 70% of the lmxbs are located in globular clusters . r. e. w. was supported in part by a national research council senior research associateship at nasa / goddard and by the national aeronautics and space administration through @xmath38 award numbers go 0 - 1144x and go 1 - 2095x issued by the _ chandra _ x - ray observatory center , which is operated by the smithsonian astrophysical observatory for and on behalf of nasa under contract nas8 - 39073 . c. l. s. was supported in part by @xmath38 awards go0 - 1141x and go1 - 2078x and by _ xmm / newton _ award nag5 - 10074 .
allen , s. w. , di matteo , t. , & fabian , a. c. 2000 , , 311 , 493 angelini , l. , loewenstein , m. , & mushotzky , r. f. 2001 , , 557 , l35 blanton , e. l. , sarazin , c. l. , & irwin , j. a. 2001 , apj , 552 , 106 bruzual , g. , a. , & charlot , s. 1993 , , 405 , 538 canizares , c. r. , fabbiano , g. , & trinchieri , g. 1987 , , 312 , 503 clark , g. w. 1975 , , 199 , l143 finoguenov , a. , & jones , c. 2001 , , 547 , l107 forman , w. , jones , c. , & tucker , w. 1985 , , 293 , 102 fryer , c. , burrows , a. , & benz , w. 1998 , , 496 , 333 grindlay , j. e. 1984 , adspr , 3 , 19 harris , w. e. 1991 , araa , 29 , 543 kalogera , v. 1996 , , 471 , 352 katz , j. i. 1975 , , 253 , 698 kim , d .- w . , fabbiano , g. , trinchieri , g. 1992 , , 393 , 134 kissler - patig , m. 1997 , , 319 , 83 kraft , r. p. , et al .
2000 , , 531 , l9 kraft , r. p. , kregenow , j. m. , forman , w. r. , jones , c. , & murray , s. s. 2001 , , 560 , 675 matsumoto , h. , koyama , k. , awaki , h. , tsuru , t. , loewenstein , m. , & matsushita , k. 1997 , , 482 , 133 portegies zwart , s. f. , & mcmillan , s. l. w. 2000 , apj , 528 , l17 randall , s. w. , sarazin , c. l. , & irwin , j. a. 2001 , preprint sarazin , c. l. , irwin , j. a. , & bregman , j. n. 2000 , , 544 , l101 sarazin , c. l. , irwin , j. a. , & bregman , j. n. 2001 , , 556 , 533 shirey , r. , et al .
2001 , a&a , 365 , l195 terman , j. l. , taam , r. e. , & savage , c. o. 1996 , , 281 , 552 trager , s. , faber , s. m. , worthey , g. , & gonzalez , j. j. 2000 , , 120 , 165 turner , t. j. , george , i. m. , mushotzky , r. f. , & nandra , k. 1997 , , 475 , 118 vesperini , e. 2000 , , 318 , 841 webbink , r. f. 1985 , in _ dynamics of star clusters _ , eds .
p. hut & j. goodman , ( reidel : dordrecht ) p. 541
white , n. e. & ghosh , p. 1998
, , 504 , l31 white , r. e. iii 1987 , , 227 , 185 white , r. 2000 , american astronomical society , head meeting 32 , 15.12 white , r. e. iii 2001 , in _ high energy universe at sharp focus : chandra science symposium _ ,
s. vrtilek , e. m. schlegel , & l. kuhi , asp conference series , 18 white , r. e. iii 2002 , submitted to white , r. e. iii , davis , d. s. & hanes , d. a. 2002 , in preparation | the x - ray emission from normal elliptical galaxies has two major components : soft ( @xmath0 kev ) emission from diffuse gas and harder ( @xmath1 kev ) emission from populations of accreting ( low - mass ) stellar x - ray binaries ( lmxb ) .
if the lmxb population is intimately tied to the field stellar population in a galaxy , its aggregate x - ray luminosity is expected to be simply proportional to the optical luminosity of the galaxy .
however , recent _ asca _ and _ chandra _ x - ray observations show that the global luminosities of lmxb components in ellipticals exhibit significant scatter ( a factor of @xmath24 ) at a given optical luminosity .
this scatter may reflect a range of evolutionary stages among x - ray binary populations in elliptical galaxies of different ages .
if so , the ratio of the global lmxb x - ray luminosity to the galactic optical luminosity , @xmath3 , may in principle be used to determine when the bulk of stars were formed in individual ellipticals . to test this
, we compare variations in @xmath3 for lmxb populations in ellipticals to optically - derived estimates of stellar ages in the same galaxies .
we find no correlation , which suggests that variations in @xmath3 are not a good age indicator for ellipticals . alternatively
, lmxbs may be formed primarily in globular clusters ( through stellar tidal interactions ) , rather than comprise a subset of the primordial binary star population in a galactic stellar field . since elliptical galaxies
exhibit a wide range of globular cluster populations for a given galaxian luminosity , this may induce a dispersion in the lmxb populations of ellipticals with similar optical luminosities . indeed , we find that @xmath3 ratios for lmxb populations are strongly correlated with the specific globular cluster frequencies in elliptical galaxies .
this suggests that most lmxbs were formed in globular clusters .
if so , _ chandra _ observations of central dominant galaxies with unusually large globular cluster populations should find proportionally excessive numbers of lmxbs . |
supernova remnants ( snrs ) are believed to be the primary sites for cosmic ray acceleration up to the ` knee ' of the cosmic rays spectrum .
x - ray observations revealed that shells of several young snrs are synchrotron x - ray emitters , implying that they are the acceleration sites of particles @xcite . on the other hand , the number of snrs with a synchrotron x - ray emitting shell
is limited @xcite .
recent very high energy ( vhe ) gamma - ray observations with _ h.e.s.s .
_ , _ magic _ , and _ veritas _ are continually revealing snrs as sites for energetic particles accelerated at snr shocks up to the tev range @xcite .
furthermore , recent _ fermi _ observations show that , not only young , but also middle - aged snrs are gev gamma - ray emitters @xcite .
some of these gamma - ray emitting snrs are not covered by deep x - ray observations .
we need a larger sample of x - ray studied snrs with gev and vhe gamma - ray emission to understand the nature of these cosmic ray accelerators .
[email protected] ( kes 78 ) was discovered by @xcite in the radio band at 11 cm wavelength .
oh masers were detected from the snr @xcite , suggesting an interaction with an adjacent molecular cloud @xcite .
observations of @xmath9co @xcite reveal a dense molecular cloud on the eastern side of the snr .
@xcite derived a kinematic distance to the snr of 4.8 kpc .
significant gev emission was also found close to this snr , with 2fgl j1850.7@xmath00014 in the 2nd fermi source catalog @xcite suggested to be related to [email protected] .
more recently , @xcite studied [email protected] using 52 months of data with _
fermi _ ; however , given the uncertainties in the @xmath10-ray background model and contamination by other nearby sources , they were unable to confirm the excess of gev emission from the snr .
the 3rd fermi source catalog @xcite confirmed the source again and revised the position and its error .
a vhe extended gamma - ray source , hess j1852@xmath0000 , was found by the h.e.s.s .
team outside the eastern edge of the remnant @xcite .
this emission partly overlaps with the radio shell of the snr and with the molecular cloud seen in co. while the interaction between the snr and the molecular cloud had been suggested as a plausible scenario for the tev emission seen with h.e.s.s .
, an alternative , but less likely , scenario proposed was its association with a pulsar wind nebula ( pwn ) associated with a nearby pulsar ( psr j18530004 ) .
the gamma - ray emission from the snr implies that there is some high - energy activity from this remnant , despite its nature being still unresolved .
this snr therefore provides another example snr with potential gev and with vhe gamma - ray emission . in x - rays , the only information we have so far published on the remnant comes from an _ xmm - newton _ study of the northern part of the snr shell @xcite .
we still lack an x - ray detection of the whole remnant which is necessary to understand the properties of this snr and shed light on its multi - wavelength emission . in this paper
, we report on the first detailed x - ray imaging and spectroscopy study of the entire snr , [email protected] , using _ suzaku _ @xcite .
we also report on a transient source which went into outburst during our observation .
the observation details are summarized in [ sec : obs ] .
a first analysis of the _ suzaku _ x - ray data for these sources is presented in [ sec : results ] , the results of which are discussed in [ sec : discuss ] .
[email protected] was observed by _ suzaku _ with two pointings , on 2011 , apr .
the coordinates of two pointings are listed in table [ tab : obslog ] .
_ suzaku _ has two active instruments : four x - ray imaging spectrometers ( xis0xis3 ; @xcite ) , with each at the focus of an x - ray telescope ( xrt ; @xcite ) , and a separate hard x - ray detector ( hxd ; @xcite ) .
only three xiss could be operated for this study due to a problem with xis2 .
xis1 is a back - illuminated ccd , whereas the others are front - illuminated .
the xis instruments were operated in normal full - frame clocking mode with spaced - row charge injection @xcite , whereas the hxd was operated in normal mode .
data reduction and analysis were made with headas software version 6.13 and xspec version 12.8.0 .
the data was reprocessed with the calibration database version 2013 - 03 - 05 for xis , 2011 - 09 - 05 for hxd , and 2011 - 06 - 30 for xrt . in the xis data screening
, we followed the standard screening criteria ; filtering out data acquired during passage through the south atlantic anomaly ( saa ) , with an elevation angle to the earth s dark limb below 5 deg , or with elevation angle to the bright limb below 25 deg in order to avoid contamination by emission from the bright limb .
table [ tab : obslog ] shows the remaining exposure time . as for the hxd dataset
, we also followed ths standard screening criteria ; filtering out data obtained during passage through the saa , with an elevation angle to the earth s limb below 5 deg , and cutoff rigidity smaller than 8 gv .
the resultant exposure time for each observation is shown in table [ tab : obslog ] .
we adopted the lcfit model of @xcite for the non - x - ray background ( nxb ) model .
the cosmic x - ray background ( cxb ) flux is estimated from the _ heao1 _ results @xcite , and treated as an additional background component .
the xis 0.52.0 kev and 2.08.0 kev mosaic images are shown in figure [ fig : xrayimage ] the vignetting has been corrected in each image using _ xissim _ @xcite after subtracting the nxb @xcite .
one can see clearly a clumpy shell - like structure elongated in the north - south direction in the 0.52.0 kev band image . on the other hand ,
the 28 kev band image is dominated by a bright point source detected in our observation in the northern part of the remnant .
we find that this point source is positionally coincident with the second _ xmm - newton _ serendipitous source catalog source , 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 @xcite .
this source is now cataloged in the 3xmm data release 5 ( http://xmm-catalog.irap.omp.eu ; zolotukhin et al .
, in prep . ) as 3xmm j1851@xmath0000002 , with the best position of ( ra , dec . )
= ( 282.80961 , @xmath00.00080 ) with the position error od 0.63 arcsec . in this paper , we stick to the 2xmm name since the simbad database uses only 2xmm source lists .
figure [ fig : multi - band](a ) shows archival vla galactic plane survey ( vgps ) continuum data at 1.4 ghz @xcite together with the 0.52 kev _ suzaku _ , 0.58 kev _ xmm - newton _
@xcite , and the _ fermi _ source region .
we highlight in this image the diffuse x - ray emission detected by _ xmm - newton _ is the northern part of the snr shell .
as seen in figure [ fig : multi - band](a ) , the x - ray emission traces the radio shell emission ; in particular the _ suzaku _ emission follows the morphology of the elongated bright radio emission in the southern part of the remnant .
figure [ fig : multi - band](b ) shows the @xmath9co ( j=10 ) image in the velocity range of 8084 km s@xmath11 taken by the purple mountain observatory at delingha ( pmod ) in china @xcite , with the 0.52 kev _ suzaku _ image and the _ fermi _ source region overlapped .
this image reveals the molecular cloud emission surrounding the x - ray shell .
we note that the dent seen in the eastern part of the shell is likely caused by the interaction between the snr and the molecular cloud . on the other hand
, the elongation towards the south may be caused by the expansion of the shell into a relatively lower density medium void of the molecular cloud .
the position of the gev emission is on the western part , and although the position error is large , there is no overlap between the gev source and the molecular cloud plus x - ray emission to its east @xcite . here , we present our spatially resolved spectroscopic study of the diffuse emission below 10 kev with xis .
we divided the remnant into two parts ( north and south ) and selected a nearby background region , as shown in figure [ fig : xrayimage ] .
the simplest way for the background estimation in the source regions is to subtract the spectrum extracted from the background region , but this sometimes introduces an uncertainty due to vignetting .
we thus reproduce the background spectrum in the source region as described next .
the background emission contains the non - x - ray background ( nxb ) , plus the cosmic x - ray background ( cxb ) , galactic ridge x - ray emission ( grxe ) , and emission from the local hot bubble ( lhb ) .
the first component is uniform in the field of view , whereas the others are affected by vignetting .
the nxb in the background region is generated by xisnxbgen @xcite , and was subtracted from the spectrum after adjusting the normalization above 10 kev , where we expect no emission except for the nxb .
the nxb - subtracted spectra is shown in figure [ fig : background - spec ] .
we fit it with an absorbed cxb + grxe + lhb model . to reproduce the cxb emission , we assumed the power - law shape with a photon index of 1.4 , and the surface brightness in the 210 kev band of 5.4@xmath12 erg s@xmath11@xmath13arcmin@xmath14 @xcite .
note that the background region has an area of 73.7 arcmin@xmath15 .
the hydrogen column density of the cxb in this direction was fixed to @xmath16 @xmath13 , as determined by h@xmath17 observations @xcite .
we also added an absorbed thermal @xmath18 component for the emission from the lhb @xcite , and an absorbed two - temperature @xmath18 component for the grxe emission ( for example , * ? ? ? * ) .
the best - fit model and parameters are shown in figure [ fig : background - spec ] and table [ tab : background - spec ] , respectively .
the best - fit parameters are roughly consistent with the known components in other regions @xcite . assuming that the background spectrum has the same shape and surface - brightness in the background and nearby source regions , we simulate the background spectrum in addition to the nxb spectrum in the source region , using the fakeit command in xspec .
we assumed a similar exposure for the simulated background as for the source spectra .
this is a similar method to what s described in @xcite .
we then use this background spectrum in the following analysis .
we initially perform the spectral analysis of the global snr using the total emission detected with @xmath19 from the snr ( i.e. the north+south regions shown in fig . 1 ) .
figure [ fig : diffuse_spectra ] shows the background - subtracted spectra for the total emission .
the spectrum shows emission lines from highly ionized ne , mg , and si , implying that the emission contains a thermal component .
we thus fit the spectra initially with an absorbed thermal model from collisionally - ionized plasma ( apec in xspec ) . for the absorption model
, we applied the phabs model , which includes the cross sections of @xcite with solar abundances @xcite .
the fit was rejected with a reduced @xmath20/d.o.f . of 405.4/122 even when the abundances of metals were treated as free parameters . introducing a non - equilibrium ionization model ( vnei and vvrnei in xspec ) , we got a better reduced @xmath20/d.o.f . of 232.0/122 and 381.1/123 , respectively , but the fit was still rejected .
the best fit we found with the nei model required a very high temperature , @[email protected] kev , for the snr as shown in table [ tab : total - spec ] .
this result suggests that the emission contains a hard tail .
we then tried a two - temperature nei model and a single temperature nei model plus a power - law component .
the former model ( nei+nei ) returned a smaller reduced @xmath20 of 208.6/122 , but required a high temperature ( @xmath222 kev ) and a small ionization timescale ( @xmath23 @xmath24 @xmath13 s ) . on the other hand ,
the ( nei + power - law ) component model , while giving a slightly larger @xmath20 of 223.1/121 , yielded parameters that are reasonable for x - ray emission from an snr . with the available data and complications from the background emission
, we can not easily conclude whether the hard tail is thermal or non - thermal , and so we discuss both models in the following section .
the best - fit models and parameters are shown in table [ tab : total - spec ] and in figure [ fig : diffuse_spectra ] ( for the vnei+power - law model ) .
we have made same analysis with another plasma model , vpshock , and found that the results are basically same with the same best - fit parameters and reduced @xmath20 within errors .
we further verified whether the hard - tail component is real or not .
the residuals in the hard x - ray band remain even when we subtract the background photons accumulated from the background region directly .
the background was simulated with the best - fit parameters in the background region fitting ( table [ tab : background - spec ] ) , which may introduce systematic uncertainty .
we tried fitting with another simulated background set with different parameters within the range of table [ tab : background - spec ] , and found that the results for the source spectra do not change within error .
under - estimation of the nxb component can cause such a residual emission , but the nxb count rate in the 35 kev ( mainly from the power - law component by cxb , figure [ fig : diffuse_spectra ] ) is around 10% of that of the total emission , thus it is difficult to consider the hard - tail component as due to the mis - estimation of the nxb , since the nxb reproduceability is around 10% @xcite .
the possibility of the contamination from the bright and hard northern point source , 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 , is unlikely since the best - fit photon index of the diffuse emission is much softer than that of the point source ( see [ sec:2xmm ] ) .
we thus conclude that the hard - tail component most likely originates from the snr shell .
we also conducted a spatially resolved spectroscopy of the diffuse emission .
as shown in figure [ fig : xrayimage ] , we divided the shell into a northern and southern region and extracted spectra for each region .
for the background subtraction , we used the simulated background for the total emission ( as described above ) . due to the limited statistics
, we allowed the normalization of vnei and power - law components to vary , but the other parameters were fixed to the best - fit value of the total emission .
the best - fit models and parameters are shown in figure [ fig : diffuse_spectra_2 ] and table [ tab : diffuse_spectra_2 ] , respectively .
the fitting gave a similar reduced @xmath20/d.o.f to the total emission , even with the smaller number of the free parameters .
it is difficult to judge the emission on the 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 region is point - like or not due to the contamination of patchy thermal emission @xcite .
we assume it is a point source in the following analysis , and this assumption is supported by the time variability as shown in
[ sec : timing ] .
we extracted the source photons from a 3 arcmin - radius region .
the background region is the source - free region common to the diffuse emission analysis .
the background - subtracted spectrum is shown in figure [ fig:2xmmspec ] .
below @xmath63 kev , we see line emission which we believe is associated with contamination from the thermal emission of the snr .
this emission very difficult to subtract correctly due to its patchy distribution .
we thus used only the 310 kev band for the spectral analysis of the point source , since the diffuse emission is significantly fainter than the point source above 3 kev ( see figure [ fig : diffuse_spectra ] and figure [ fig:2xmmspec ] ) .
the spectrum extends up to 10 kev , is heavily absorbed , and shows no line - like emission .
an absorbed power - law model was thus adopted as the spectral model .
the absorption model includes the cross sections of @xcite with solar abundance @xcite .
the power - law model yielded an acceptable fit with a hard photon index , @[email protected] , and a reduced @xmath20 of 191.5/175 .
the best - fit parameters are listed in the second column of table [ tab : spec_2xmm ] .
we also checked whether there is any significant iron - line emission .
for that , we added a narrow gaussian model with the center energy of 6.4 kev in the fitting , and found a tight upper - limit on the equivalent width of 15 ev .
for the timing analysis of this point source , we also used the 38 kev band and extracted photons from a 3-arcmin radius region .
the left panel of figure [ fig : xislightcurve ] shows the light curve of 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 , which reveals a highly time - variable source that decays slowly during the observation .
one can also see rapid flares with a timescale of a few hundred seconds .
the short flares look rather periodic with a timescale of @xmath67000 s , but this variability is not significant in our dataset with the null hypothesis of 20% .
we exclude the thermal wobbling of the satellite as a possible source for the flaring @xcite , since this tentative period is not the same as the suzaku satellite s orbital period ( @xmath696 min ) .
we conclude that this is real time - variability of the source . in order to examine the spectral changes during the flares
, we compared the count rates in each bin of the light - curve for the 35 kev and 58 kev bands ( i.e. using bands where the source photons are dominant compared with background photons ) .
the right panel shows the 38 kev count rate versus the hardness ratio between these bands .
one can see that there is no strong trend , implying that there is no significant spectral change during the flares .
a coherent pulsation search was also performed although the time resolution of xis is only 8 s @xcite .
no significant pulsations were found in the scanned period range of 16@xmath25 s with the null hypothesis of 31% .
we also analyzed the hxd p - i - n type diode ( pin ) dataset to search for a signal from the source in the energy range above 10 kev .
after background ( nxb+cxb ) subtraction , the remaining count rate in the 1540 kev band in each observation is @xmath26 cnts s@xmath11 for obsid=507035010 and @xmath27 cnts s@xmath11 for obsid=507036010 .
this is 9.0% and 5.4% of the nxb count rate in this band , respectively .
the systematic nxb uncertainty is 35% @xcite , thus we conclude that we detect significant emission from the northern part .
the observing region is on the galactic plane , thus we have to carefully account for the galactic ridge x - ray emission ( grxe ) .
@xcite reports that the 1240 kev hxd pin count rate of the galactic center is @xmath60.5 count s@xmath11 .
@xcite shows that the surface brightness of grxe is a few percent of that in the gc region , thus the expected count rate is @xmath28 count s@xmath11 , which is significantly lower than our detection .
moreover , the detection level should be the same in the two observations if the emission is from grxe .
we thus conclude that the emission is not from the grxe .
figure [ fig : pinlc ] shows the pin 1520 kev light curve after the subtraction of the nxb .
we can see the decay of the emission , which is similar to the light curve of 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 below 10 kev ( figure [ fig : xislightcurve ] ) .
this result confirms that the emission is from 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 .
we have extracted the pin spectrum above 10 kev as shown in the left panel of figure [ fig : pinspec ] .
we fit it with an absorbed power - law model .
the absorption column density was fixed to 11.0@xmath29 @xmath13 , under the assumption that the emission is from 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 .
the fit was acceptable with a reduced @xmath20 of 12.4/10 .
the best - fit photon index and flux are 4.2 ( 1.76.7 ) and 3.3 ( 2.64.1)@xmath30 erg @xmath13s@xmath11 in the 1520 kev band , respectively .
the photon index is relatively soft , but consistent within the error range of the xis result on 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 , which also supports our conclusion on the emission origin .
we thus carried out the combined spectral fitting of xis and pin for 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 which is shown in the right panel of figure [ fig : pinspec ] .
we fit the spectra with an absorbed power - low model again , and the fit was acceptable with a reduced @xmath20 of 208.6/183 .
the best - fit models and parameters are shown in the right panel of figure [ fig : pinspec ] and the third column in table [ tab : spec_2xmm ] .
we note that we also attempted a absorbed broken - power - low model , but this model did not improve the fit .
hxd has a good timing capability with a 61 @xmath31s time resolution and an accuracy of @xmath32ss@xmath11 per day @xcite .
we thus search for any coherent pulsations of this source using the pin dataset .
we used the 1520 kev range to maximize the signal - to - noise ratio .
after barycentric correction , we used the powspec command in the xronos package to search the coherent pulsation .
however , we could not detect any coherent signal in the period of 61 @xmath31s to 512 s. we also tried the timing analysis with the xis ( 38 kev ) and pin ( 1520 kev ) combined , and found no significant signal .
we have detected the x - ray shell structure from [email protected] for the first time .
the best - fit absorption column of @xmath33 @xmath13 is marginally smaller than the absorption column in this direction , 1.51.9@xmath29 @xmath13 . assuming an average density of 0.51 @xmath4 , the expected distance is in the 1.54.6 kpc range .
this is roughly consistent with the distance estimated from the co association .
we thus use hereafter 4.8 kpc for the distance to the remnant .
the size of the x - ray shell is 14@xmath34@xmath3522@xmath34 , which coincides with the radio shell .
the physical size and total luminosity are @xmath36 pc and @xmath37 erg s@xmath11 ( 0.510 kev ) , assuming the kinematic distance of 4.8 kpc . in order to estimate the density and shock age of the low - temperature plasma in this snr
, we assumed that the shape of the emitting plasma is an ellipsoid shell with dimensions of 7 , 7 , 10 arcmin , with a width of 0.7 arcmin , which correspond to 10 , 10 , and 15 pc with a width of 1 pc ( at the assumed distance of 4.8 kpc ) .
the width of 1/12th the snr radius is a rough estimation from the sedov solution .
the total volume is then @xmath38 @xmath39 , where @xmath40 refers to the distance in the unit of 4.8 kpc . assuming a uniform density over the region
, we can derive the average electron density ( @xmath41 ) from the emission measure as @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the volume filling factor and we assumed @xmath44 .
we used the vnei+power - law model here ( see table 3 ) ( the two - temperature nei model will not change our parameters estimate within error ) .
the ambient density @xmath45 is 1/4 of @xmath41 , thus @xmath46 this is a rather low density when compared with interstellar medium and other snrs even with the smaller distance estimate inferred from the absorption .
this is suggestive of expansion of [email protected] into its progenitor s wind bubble .
this is a similar situation to rcw 86 , which expands into the wind bubble with the density of @xmath7@xmath8 @xmath4 @xcite , although rcw 86 is much younger than [email protected] @xcite .
the anti - correlation with the molecular clouds and existence of oh masers further support this scenario .
together with the @xmath41 estimate and the ionization time - scale derived from the spectral analysis , we can estimate the shock age of this plasma .
adopting @xmath41 of @xmath47 , the resultant shock age ( @xmath48 ) becomes @xmath49 which suggests that [email protected] is a middle - aged snr .
its low luminosity further supports this conclusion @xcite . in the spatially resolved spectroscopy
, we derived the emission measure of thermal emission in the northern and southern regions ( table [ tab : diffuse_spectra_2 ] ) .
the surface brightness is similar in each region since the area scale of the northern region is around 40% that of the southern region .
together with the same temperature in these regions , we conclude that there is no substantial difference in their density .
note that our observations did not fully cover the eastern part of the remnant , where the molecular cloud dominates .
a more complete mapping of the remnant will reveal a clearer correlation between the morphology of the molecular cloud and that of the snr .
the first possibility we consider is the contamination of hard point sources in this region , since the suzaku angular resolution is not so excellent , around 2 arcmin in half power diameter .
we have checked the _
rosat _ pspc image in this region and did not find any bright point source in the field .
furthermore , the power - law component is significant in both the southern and northern snr regions , which would be difficult to explain with point source contribution .
we thus conclude that this emission is not from a point source , although we can not rule out the existence of obscured hard sources .
the second possibility is that it is truly diffuse , but caused ( at least partly ) by the mis - estimation of the cosmic background level .
as shown in figure [ fig : background - spec ] , the main background emission above 2 kev is the high - temperature component of the grxe .
the fitting with the two - temperature vnei model shows that the temperature is consistent with the high - temperature component of the grxe .
we thus checked whether the power - law component can be explained by the grxe high - temperature component , and found that we need 27% increase in the flux of the grxe s high - temperature component to reproduce this power - law component .
it is slightly a higher fluctuation than the dispersion of grxe ( uchiyama , h. , 2014 , private communication , see also @xcite ) , but we can not dismiss this possibility .
we need more statistics in the hard x - ray band to distinguish this scenario .
an interesting possibility is a pwn origin .
the photon index and luminosity are typical for middle - aged pwne @xcite . a pwn origin for the h.e.s.s .
emission from the snr region has been also suggested ( kosack et al .
however it is hard to explain both the northern and southern regions having a power - law component ; on the other hand , it is possible that at least part of the emission has a pwn origin .
high - resolution x - ray observations with @xmath50 will be needed to resolve the emission and find any putative pwn or contaminating hard point sources .
the more interesting possibility is that the hard - tail emission is truly diffuse emission originating from the snr . in the scenario where the hard - tail is of thermal nature ,
the high @xmath21 and very small ionization timescale ( @xmath51 , see table 3 ) , imply that the plasma was recently heated and has a low density .
similar high @xmath21 and small @xmath51 plasma was found in rcw 86 @xcite ; it is the ejecta heated by the reverse shock very recently
. this may be the case of [email protected] , although it is much older than rcw 86 assuming the latter is associated with sn 185 @xcite .
this scenario fits the multi - wavelength observations , and is consistent with the picture that the snr is expanding into a cavity and has hit the molecular cloud recently .
next we consider the non - thermal interpretation of the hard tail as originating from the snr shell .
shocks of snrs accelerate particles up to 10@xmath9 ev , and accelerated electrons emit synchrotorn x - rays @xcite .
the power - law component in [email protected] can be the synchrotron emission from accelerated electrons .
this scenario is supported by the tev detection.the luminosity of the hard component , 9.7@xmath52 in the 210 kev band , is however rather small for synchrotron x - rays from young snrs ( @xmath53 ergs s@xmath11 in the 210 kev band ; * ? ? ?
* ) , which further supports the middle - aged scenario .
an explosion in a cavity would keep the shock velocity high for longer which would then lead to a high maximum energy of electrons @xcite .
the average shock velocity inferred from the shock age and the snr radius is 57@xmath54 cm s@xmath11 , which is also consistent with a middle - aged snr and slower than typical value to emit synchrotron x - rays .
since synchrotron x - rays from shocked plasma are expected to have very thin filament - like structures @xcite , x - ray observations with excellent spatial resolution , such as with _
chandra _ , are needed to confirm this scenario and would further allow for an estimate of the magnetic field .
several snrs have been detected in the gev range by _ fermi _ ( see funk 2011 for a review ) .
their soft gev emission may suggest the escape of high energy particles @xcite .
many of these sources are associated with molecular clouds , and particles accelerated at the shock emit gamma - rays via pion decay with the dense material in the molecular clouds .
our target [email protected] is interacting with a molecular cloud ( figure [ fig : multi - band ] ) , which is further supported by the existence of oh masers @xcite .
however , the association between the molecular cloud and gev gamma - ray emission is unclear ; the peak of the molecular cloud is in the eastern and northern region whereas the gamma - ray peak is on the western side without any overlap with molecular cloud and x - ray emission .
( figure [ fig : multi - band ] ) .
the vhe tev gamma - ray emission , on the other hand , coincides with the molecular cloud peak in the eastern part of the snr , and is therefore likely associated with the snr . here ,
we introduce two snrs with gamma - rays , w28 and rcw 86 for a comparison to [email protected] .
w28 is a middle - aged snr with gev and vhe gamma - rays @xcite detected on the north - eastern x - ray shell @xcite .
@xcite suggest that the gev / vhe gamma - ray emission is from high - energy particles that recently escaped from the shock and are interacting with a molecular cloud , giving also rise to oh masers @xcite .
the x - ray emitting plasma in the shell region is in ionization equilibrium @xcite , in contrast to the central emission @xcite .
the vhe gamma - rays from [email protected] may have a similar origin to w28 .
@xcite suggest the presence of a hard x - ray tail in the w28 shell , which may be related to the hard tail in [email protected] .
another example , rcw 86 , is a bright shell - like snr in the radio and x - ray bands @xcite expanding in a cavity @xcite .
this snr has non - thermal emission in x - rays , gev , and vhe gamma - rays @xcite , which is similar to our case . on the other hand
, we have no information on the molecular cloud interaction .
more data for such a sample are needed to understand the multi - wavelength and intrinsic properties of these sources .
young snrs with vhe gamma - rays often have no significant thermal x - rays @xcite , suggesting a low - density environment .
such a low density would keep a fast - moving shock speed for a relatively long time and would accelerate particles more efficiently .
we suggest a similarly low density here for [email protected] .
@xcite reported the swift burst alert telescope detection of the outburst of 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 on 2012 jun 17 15:46:55 ut . the mean count - rate in the promptly - available xrt data is 0.56 count s@xmath11 , whereas the catalogued count - rate of this source is equivalent to approximately 0.013 xrt count s@xmath11 .
no optical counterpart has been found with the uvot observation onboard _
swift_. we also searched for the infrared counterpart in the 2mass point source catalog @xcite .
the nearest 2mass source is 2mass 18511447@xmath00000036 , but the separation between these sources is 2.6 arcsec , which is larger than the position error of the 3xmm source ( 0.63 arcsec ) and the 2mass source ( 0.08 arcsec ) .
we conclude that the source has no infrared counterpart . with the assumption that the spectral shape is same in the _ swift _ observation and our observation
, we derived the 210 kev flux in the _ swift _ observation to be @xmath55 erg @xmath13s@xmath11 using webpimms .
this is 1.51.6 count s@xmath11 in _ suzaku _ xis 310 kev band .
these values are about one order of magnitude larger than the average flux in the _ suzaku _ observation ( table [ tab : spec_2xmm ] ) , and twice the peak flux ( figure [ fig : xislightcurve ] ) .
the absorption column of 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 is significantly larger than that of the snr , implying that this point source is unrelated to the snr . assuming a distance of 10 kpc , the intrinsic average luminosity is @xmath56 erg s@xmath11 in the 210 kev band .
the absorption column is much higher than the total galactic h i column density toward the source ( 1.51.8@xmath29 @xmath13 ; * ? ? ?
* ) , which implies the source has a local absorption matter .
recently , a new class of galactic transients has been emerging with fast and bright flaring x - ray activity , which is referred to as the supergiant fast x - ray transients ( sfxt ; * ? ? ?
* for a review ) .
these objects are believed to be high - mass x - ray binaries with ( a few - hour long ) hard x - ray spectra , and short and bright flares .
the fast and large time variability , and the hard spectra of 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 , suggest that this source is one of the sfxts . a rather large luminosity and no strong spectral change
further support this scenario @xcite , although @xcite reported the change of hardness in the case of ax j1841.0@xmath00536 .
some sfxts show coherent pulsations from 4.7 s @xcite to 1276 s @xcite , but our analysis did not show any evidence for pulsations .
the short timescale flares within a few hundreds second is common in other sfxts @xcite .
the origin of the 7000 s intervals of short flares is unknown .
this timescale is not the _ suzaku _ orbital period ( @xmath696 min , * ? ? ?
* ) , so it is not an artificial feature .
it is longer than the coherent pulsations of other sfxts , or and shorter than their orbital periods ( 3.3165 days ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
another possibility is a flaring low mass x - ray binaries ( lmxb ) .
some lmxbs show rapid time variability and hard x - ray spectra ( c.f . , xss j12270@xmath04859 ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
however , they show spectral hardening during flares , whereas 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 did nt show any significant spectral change during its flare . furthermore , the spectra of flaring lmxbs are not deeply absorbed , which is also different from our source .
recently , @xcite reported that hmxbs with slow pulsations can be accreting magnetars , and our source can be a similar source .
however , such sources show only interstellar absorption , which is not the case here . a gamma - ray binary can be a candidate for our source given their high variabilities and hard spectra . however , these objects show spectral hardening when they become brighter ( * ? ? ? * for example ) , which is again not in the case of 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 . in summary ,
follow up high - resolution and deep observations are needed to improve our understanding of this intriguing source .
we would like to thank the anonymous referee for the fruitful comments .
we thank t. sakamoto for comments on _ swift _ data .
we also thank m. ishida for comments on the time variability of the background due to the thermal wobbling of the satellite .
this work was supported in part by grant - in - aid for scientific research of the japanese ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) of japan , no .
22684012 and 15k05107 ( a. b. ) .
s.s.h . acknowledges support from the canadian space agency and from the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada ( nserc ) through the canada research chairs and discovery grants programs . this research has made use of nasa s astrophysics data system bibliographic services , and the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france .
abdo , a. a. , ackermann , m. , ajello , m. , et al .
2009a , , 706 , l1 abdo , a. a. , et al . 2009b , , 183 , 46 abdo , a. a. , ackermann , m. , ajello , m. , et al .
2010a , science , 327 , 1103 abdo , a. a. , ackermann , m. , ajello , m. , et al . 2010b , , 712 , 459 acero , f. , ackermann , m. , ajello , m. , et al .
2015 , , 218 , 23 acciari , v. a. , aliu , e. , arlen , t. , et al .
2010 , , 714 , 163 aharonian , f. a. , & atoyan , a. m. 1999 , , 351 , 330 aharonian , f. a. , akhperjanian , a. g. , aye , k .- m . , et al .
2004 , , 432 , 75 aharonian , f. , akhperjanian , a. g. , bazer - bachi , a. r. , et al .
2007 , , 661 , 236 aharonian , f. , et al .
2008 , , 481 , 401 aharonian , f. , akhperjanian , a. g. , de almeida , u. b. , et al .
2009 , , 692 , 1500 albert , j. , aliu , e. , anderhub , h. , et al .
2007 , , 474 , 937 anders , e. , & grevesse , n. 1989 , , 53 , 197 auchettl , , k. , slane , p. , & castro , d. 2014 , , 783 , 32 balucinska - church , m. , & mccammon , d. 1992 , , 400 , 699 bamba , a. , koyama , k. , & tomida , h. 2000 , , 52 , 1157 bamba , a. , yokogawa , j. , ueno , m. , koyama , k. , & yamauchi , s. 2001 , , 53 , 1179 bamba , a. , yamazaki , r. , ueno , m. , & koyama , k. 2003 , , 589 , 827 bamba , a. , yamazaki , r. , yoshida , t. , terasawa , t. , & koyama , k. 2005 , , 621 , 793 bamba , a. , phlhofer , g. , acero , f. , et al .
2012 , , 756 , 149 barthelmy , s. d. , baumgartner , w. h. , burrows , d. n. , et al .
2012 , grb coordinates network , 13367 , 1 boldt , e. , & leiter , d. 1987 , , 322 , l1 broersen , s. , chiotellis , a. , vink , j. , & bamba , a. 2014 , , 441 , 3040 claussen , m. j. , frail , d. a. , goss , w. m. , & gaume , r. a. 1997 , , 489 , 143 de martino , d. , belloni , t. , falanga , m. , et al .
2013 , , 550 , a89 dickey , j. m. , & lockman , f. j. 1990 , , 28 , 215 ellison , d. c. , & bykov , a. m. 2011 , , 731 , 87 frail , d. a. , goss , w. m. , & slysh , v. i. 1994 , , 424 , l111 fujinaga , t. , mori , k. , bamba , a. , et al .
2013 , , 65 , 61 fukazawa , y. , mizuno , t. , watanabe , s. , et al .
2009 , , 61 , 17 funk , s. 2011 , talk in tev particle astrophysics 2011 albanova university center , sweden green , a. j. , frail , d. a. , goss , w. m. , & otrupcek , r. 1997 , , 114 , 2058 helder , e. a. , vink , j. , bamba , a. , et al .
2013 , , 435 , 910 hoffman , i. m. , goss , w. m. , brogan , c. l. , & claussen , m. j. 2005 , , 620 , 257 ishisaki , y. , maeda , y. , fujimoto , r. , et al .
2007 , , 59 , 113 jain , c. , paul , b. , & dutta , a. 2009 , , 397 , l11 kalberla , p. m. w. , burton , w. b. , hartmann , d. , et al .
2005 , , 440 , 775 kargaltsev , o. , & pavlov , g. g. 2008 , 40 years of pulsars : millisecond pulsars , magnetars and more , 983 , 171 kawabata nobukawa , k. , nobukawa , m. , tsuru , t. g. , & koyama , k. 2012 , , 64 , 99 kishishita , t. , tanaka , t. , uchiyama , y. , & takahashi , t. 2009 , , 697 , l1 koralesky , b. , frail , d. a. , goss , w. m. , claussen , m. j. , & green , a. j. 1998 , , 116 , 1323 kosack , k. , chaves , r. c. , & acero , f. 2011 , international cosmic ray conference , 7 , 76 koyama , k. , petre , r. , gotthelf , e. v. , et al .
1995 , , 378 , 255 koyama , k. , kinugasa , k. , matsuzaki , k. , et al .
1997 , , 49 , l7 koyama , k. , tsunemi , h. , dotani , t. , et al . 2007a , , 59 , 23 koyama , k. , uchiyama , h. , hyodo , y. , et al .
2007b , , 59 , 237 long , k. s. 1983 , supernova remnants and their x - ray emission , 101 , 525 mattana , f. , falanga , m. , gtz , d. , et al .
2009 , , 694 , 12 mitsuda , k. , bautz , m. , inoue , h. , et al .
2007 , , 59 , 1 nakajima , h. , yamaguchi , h. , matsumoto , h. , et al .
2008 , , 60 , 1 nakamura , r. , bamba , a. , dotani , t. , et al .
2012 , , 746 , 134 nakamura , r. , bamba , a. , sawada , m. , et al .
2014 , , 66 , 6210 nava , l. , & gabici , s. 2013 , , 429 , 1643 nolan , p. l. , abdo , a. a. , ackermann , m. , et al .
2012 , , 199 , 31 ohira , y. , murase , k. , & yamazaki , r. 2011 , , 410 , 1577 reig , p. , torrejn , j. m. , & blay , p. 2012
, , 425 , 595 ryu , s. g. , koyama , k. , nobukawa , m. , fukuoka , r. , & tsuru , t. g. 2009 , , 61 , 751 saitou , k. , tsujimoto , m. , ebisawa , k. , et al .
2011 , , 63 , 759 sawada , m. , tsuru , t. g. , koyama , k. , & oka , t. 2011 , , 63 , 849 sawada , m. , & koyama , k. 2012 , , 64 , 81 serlemitsos , p. j. , soong , y. , chan , k .- w .
, et al .
2007 , , 59 , 9 sidoli , l. 2011 , advances in space research , 48 , 88 skrutskie , m. f. , cutri , r. m. , stiening , r. , et al .
2006 , , 131 , 1163 slane , p. , hughes , j. p. , edgar , r. j. , et al .
2001 , , 548 , 814 stil , j. m. , taylor , a. r. , dickey , j. m. , et al .
2006 , , 132 , 1158 takahashi , t. , abe , k. , endo , m. , et al .
2007 , , 59 , 35 tawa , n. , hayashida , k. , nagai , m. , et al .
2008 , , 60 , 11 telezhinsky , i. , dwarkadas , v. v. , & pohl , m. 2012 , , 541 , a153 terada , y. , enoto , t. , miyawaki , r. , et al .
2008 , , 60 , 25 uchiyama , y. , maeda , y. , ebara , m. , et al .
2008 , , 60 , 35 uchiyama , h. , ozawa , m. , matsumoto , h. , et al .
2009 , , 61 , 9 uchiyama , h. , nobukawa , m. , tsuru , t. g. , & koyama , k. 2013 , , 65 , 19 ueda , y. , takahashi , t. , inoue , h. , et al .
1999 , , 518 , 656 velusamy , t. , & kundu , m. r. 1974 , , 32 , 375 vink , j. , & laming , j. m. 2003 , , 584 , 758 vink , j. , bleeker , j. , van der heyden , k. , et al .
2006 , , 648 , l33 walter , r. , zurita heras , j. , bassani , l. , et al .
2006 , , 453 , 133 watson , m. g. , schrder , a. c. , fyfe , d. , et al .
2009 , , 493 , 339 whiteoak , j. b. z. , & green , a. j. 1996 , , 118 , 329 yamauchi , s. , & koyama , k. 1993 , , 404 , 620 yamaguchi , h. , koyama , k. , & uchida , h. 2011 , , 63 , 837 yamazaki , r. , kohri , k. , bamba , a. , et al .
2006 , , 371 , 1975 yoshino , t. , mitsuda , k. , yamasaki , n. y. , et al .
2009 , , 61 , 805 yuan , q. , huang , x. , liu , s. , & zhang , b. 2014 , , 785 , l22
yuasa , t. , tamura , k .- i .
, nakazawa , k. , et al .
2008 , , 60 , 207 zirakashvili , v. n. , & aharonian , f. 2007 , , 465 , 695 zhou , j .- j . , zhang , x .- z . , zhang , h .- b . , et al .
2007 , zhou , p. , & chen , y. 2011 , , 743 , 4 zhou , p. , safi - harb , s. , chen , y. , et al .
2014 , , 791 , 87 p8pcc cxb component & + @xmath57 [ @xmath58 @xmath13 ] & 1.82 ( fixed ) + photon index & 1.4 ( fixed ) + surface brightness & 5.4@xmath60 ( fixed ) + lhb component & + @xmath57 [ @xmath58 @xmath13 ] & 0.42 ( 0.140.69 ) + @xmath21 [ kev ] & 0.07 ( 0.040.11 ) + @xmath61 & 0.16 ( 0.0026.3 ) + grxe component & + @xmath57 [ @xmath58 @xmath13 ] & 0.87 ( 0.840.94 ) + @xmath62 [ kev ] & 0.59 ( 0.560.62 ) + @xmath63 & 1.5 ( 1.21.8 ) + @xmath64 [ kev ] & 6.3 ( 5.57.6 ) + @xmath65 & 1.1 ( 1.01.2 ) + @xmath20/d.o.f . &
389.0/236 p8pcccc @xmath57 [ @xmath58 @xmath13 ] & 0.55 ( 0.480.61 ) & 0.74 ( 0.710.82 ) & 0.59 ( 0.480.71 ) + @xmath66 [ kev ] & 3.1 ( 2.35.0 ) & 0.63 ( 0.370.73 ) & 0.65 ( 0.440.97 ) + ne & 1 ( fixed ) & 1 ( fixed ) & 1.3 ( 1.11.5 ) + mg & 0.69 ( 0.550.94 ) & 1 ( fixed ) & 1 ( fixed ) + si & 0.41 ( 0.300.58 ) & 1 ( fixed ) & 1 ( fixed ) + fe & 0.22 ( 0.050.57 ) & 1 ( fixed ) & 0.28 ( 0.130.49 ) +
nt [ @xmath67@xmath4s ] & 1.3 ( 1.11.6 ) & 19 ( 1159 ) & 6.0 ( 3.517.1 ) + @xmath61 & 5.8 ( 4.27.5 ) & 10 ( 8.926 ) & 10 ( 525 ) + @xmath68 [ kev ] & & 3.4 ( 2.24.7 ) & + nt [ @xmath69@xmath4s ] & & 2.7 ( 1.93.4 ) & + @xmath61 & & 5.2 ( 4.09.2 ) & + @xmath5 & & & 2.3 ( 2.02.6 ) + @xmath70 [ @xmath71 erg @xmath13s@xmath11 ] & & & 3.5 ( 2.84.2 ) + @xmath20/d.o.f . &
232.0/122 & 208.3/122 & 223.1/121 p8pccc @xmath5 & 1.61 ( 1.471.75 ) & 1.57 ( 1.441.69 ) + flux [ @xmath74erg @xmath13s@xmath11 ] & 9.8 ( 9.210.4 ) & 9.6 ( 9.010.2 ) + @xmath57 [ @xmath58h @xmath13 ] & 11.0 ( 9.712.2 ) & 10.7 ( 9.511.8 ) + @xmath20/d.o.f . &
191.5/175 & 208.6/183 | we present the first dedicated x - ray study of the supernova remnant ( snr ) [email protected] ( kes 78 ) with _ suzaku_. x - ray emission from the whole snr shell has been detected for the first time .
the x - ray morphology is well correlated with the emission from the radio shell , while anti - correlated with the molecular cloud found in the snr field .
the x - ray spectrum shows not only conventional low - temperature ( @xmath1 kev ) thermal emission in a non - equilibrium ionization state , but also a very high temperature ( @xmath2 kev ) component with a very low ionization timescale ( @xmath3 @xmath4 s ) , or a hard non - thermal component with a photon index @[email protected] .
the average density of the low - temperature plasma is rather low , of the order of @xmath7@xmath8 @xmath4 , implying that this snr is expanding into a low - density cavity .
we discuss the x - ray emission of the snr , also detected in tev with h.e.s.s .
, together with multi - wavelength studies of the remnant and other gamma - ray emitting snrs , such as w28 and rcw 86 .
analysis of a time - variable source , 2xmm j185114.3@xmath0000004 , found in the northern part of the snr , is also reported for the first time . rapid time variability and
a heavily absorbed hard x - ray spectrum suggest that this source could be a new supergiant fast x - ray transient . |
the diffuse galactic @xmath0-ray emission ( dge ) from the full sky has recently been analyzed and compared with the observations with the _ fermi _ large area telescope ( _ fermi_-lat ) for high energies ( he ; @xmath1 ) @xcite .
the dge had been modeled using the galprop code ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
for a review , see @xcite .
these phenomenological models were constrained to reproduce directly measured cosmic ray ( cr ) data and were then used iteratively to calculate the dge ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . to construct a model for the expected total @xmath0-ray emission , the @xmath0-ray emission from the resolved point sources together with the residual instrumental @xmath0-ray background and the extragalactic diffuse @xmath0-ray background both assumed to be isotropic @xcite
were added to the dge model . in the inner galaxy ,
the emission of the resolved sources apparently reaches a fraction of @xmath2 percent of the expected overall spectral energy flux density at @xmath3 gev @xcite .
these overall emission models describe the _
fermi_-lat data well at high and intermediate latitudes and thereby show that the so - called egret gev excess ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) does not exist in the form previously inferred @xcite .
in the galactic plane these models systematically underpredict the data above a few gev , and they do so increasingly above about 10 gev until 100 gev ( see fig . 15 of * ? ? ?
in the present paper this difference between data and model will be called the `` _ fermi_-lat galactic plane surplus '' ( fl - gps ) .
it is most pronounced in the inner galaxy . according to @xcite ,
it can however also be seen in the outer galaxy , with even a small excess at intermediate latitudes .
the galprop code is constrained by the charged energetic particles directly measured in the neighborhood of the solar system which are by assumption truly diffuse crs .
therefore the above discrepancy is not too surprising , because in this comparison the @xmath0-ray emission from particles _ within _ the cr sources is only taken into account for those @xmath0-ray sources that are resolved by the instrument . the dominant part of the @xmath0-ray sources resolved by the _
fermi_-lat , with 1451 items listed in the _
fermi_-lat 1fgl catalog and taken into account in the ackermann et al .
( 2012 ) analysis , are pulsars , as far as the galaxy is concerned .
except for the crab nebula and vela x the he @xmath0-ray emission from pulsar wind nebulae may actually be again pulsar radiation , even though most recently three more pulsar wind nebulae have been identified with _
fermi_-lat @xcite . for purposes of their @xmath0-ray emission
these objects are assumed in the present paper to be sources of energetic electrons and positrons , but not sources of nuclear crs .
of the latter presumably only a handful have been resolved , and are thus included in the overall _ fermi_-lat emission model @xcite . in all probability
the majority of nuclear cr sources remains unresolved , and is therefore excluded from that model . as a consequence
the fl - gps can be expected to be a physical , not an instrumental effect . independently of whether they are resolved or not , the nuclear cr sources
are presumably concentrated in the galactic disk , if they are the consequence of star formation processes .
they are assumed in the present paper to be the shell - type supernova remnants ( snrs ) , regardless whether they are isolated or embedded in stellar associations , e.g. in superbubbles .
the fact that the fl - gps is concentrated in the inner galaxy is then the result of the well - known concentration of sn explosions in the inner galaxy ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and in the inner parts of other galaxies @xcite . this concentration is also confirmed by the galactic distribution of pulsars as compact remnants of core - collapse sn explosions @xcite .
the total @xmath0-ray emission does not have such a strong radial gradient in the galactic plane , as observed at comparatively low energies were the purely diffuse emission should dominate , by e.g. the cos - b satellite for @xmath4 mev @xcite and the egret instrument on the cgro satellite for @xmath5 mev @xcite .
this difference has also been discussed by @xcite .
a weak gradient of the diffuse emission has been interpreted theoretically as the consequence of preferential ( faster ) convective cr removal from the disk into the halo in the inner galaxy , where the higher cr source density and the decrease of the galactic escape velocity with increasing galactic radius drive a faster _ galactic wind _
this is a nonlinear propagation effect .
therefore the concentration of the fl - gps in the inner galaxy is largely the result of the radial gradient in the cr source density , because the diffuse cr density is largely independent of radius - to-@xmath6 scaling factor , regarding the gas target for the gamma - ray emission , on account of a radial decrease of the metallicity in the galactic disk inferred from observations in external galaxies @xcite . ] .
the dependence of the fl - gps on @xmath0-ray energy is another aspect which is suggested to be due to the difference between the diffuse particle spectra and the particle source spectra . in a selfconsistent model for energetic particle propagation in such a galactic wind @xcite , where nonlinear damping of the scattering magnetic irregularities balances their growth due to the outward cr streaming , this spectral difference is naturally explained .
the theoretical interpretation of the location of the fl - gps in the galaxy and of its energy dependence , presented here , is therefore entirely based on the _ propagation characteristics of the diffuse cr population in the galaxy _ , both in its dependence on the radial distance from the axis of rotation as well as in its variation with particle energy . from a purely phenomenological point of view
it is only necessary to assume that the dge is essentially independent of radius in the galactic plane and that the diffuse energy distribution of the charged energetic particles is significantly softer than the energy distribution in their sources . indeed , starting with the work of @xcite on the decrease of the flux ratio of secondary to primary nuclear particles with increasing rigidity , as observed in the neighborhood of the solar system , the particle energy spectra inside these sources have been inferred to be substantially harder than the energy spectrum of the average crs in the interstellar medium ( ism ) ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* for a recent review ) .
even though the volume fraction of the active sources is presumably quite small , the energy density of the energetic particles there is very high , coexisting together with a thermal gas density comparable to that in the average ism . in this context
an active source is meant to be one which still basically contains the particles it has accelerated .
these particles shall be called source cosmic rays ( scrs ) .
as demonstrated for the first time in @xcite , the contribution of scrs to the dge from accelerated crs - still confined in their parent snrs - progressively increases with energy due to their hard spectrum .
therefore this contribution becomes unavoidably significant the latest at vhe energies .
in a subsequent paper the scr contribution was studied in more detail @xcite . for the following these papers
will be referred to as bv00 and bv04 , respectively .
a later study of the contribution of unresolved source populations has been made by @xcite .
shell - type snrs have been observed , especially at very high energy ( vhe ; @xmath7 gev ) , to be important sources of @xmath0-rays ( e.g. * ? ? ?
it is less clear , in which phase of their lifetime they lose most of the accelerated particles .
this is determined by a complex interplay of the dissipation of magnetic field fluctuations inside ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and the hydrodynamic break - up of the overall expanding snr shell .
the shell - type snrs are not the only vhe @xmath0-ray sources in the galaxy .
in fact , the most abundant resolved galactic @xmath0-ray sources at vhe are pulsar wind nebulae ( pwn ) ( e.g. * ? ? ?
these are in all probability the result of the winds from young , energetic pulsars with characteristic ages @xmath8 yrs , and of the accelerated population of electrons in them which , in particular , emit inverse compton ( ic ) @xmath0-rays in an almost calorimetric fashion @xcite . the particle acceleration and resulting emission is quite complex and poorly understood .
pwn observations , including the radio and x - ray range , are often fitted by a phenomenological model going back to @xcite which assumes an energy distribution of the radiating electrons in the form of a power law with a cutoff , in a uniform magnetic field and in a radiation field approximately equal to the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) ( e.g. * ? ? ?
the @xmath0-ray spectral energy densities of pwns are therefore assumed to be typically peaked with a cutoff at a few tev .
the lifetime @xmath9 of tev emitting leptons in typical pwns has been estimated to be @xmath10 kyr @xcite . in a rough sense
the total number @xmath11 of pwns in the galaxy is then @xmath12 , where @xmath13 denotes the galactic vhe - emitting pwn rate in units of core collapse events per century @xcite .
this is at least as large as the number of active shell - type snrs ( see below ) . as a result
the population of unresolved pwns may contribute to the fl - gps , and substantially to the total vhe emission , even though this is difficult to estimate for the reasons given above .
the relative size of the contributions of the unresolved parts of the various @xmath0-ray source populations is an important question . presumably at energies beyond about 10 tev
the pwn fraction is small due to the cutoff in the electron spectra as a result of radiative losses .
the spectra of nuclear particles in shell - type snrs can , on the other hand , extend to energies of many hundreds of tev with differential energy spectra close to a power law @xmath14 , where @xmath15 .
such an extent in energy is in particular expected in young objects , like the type ia objects sn1006 @xcite or tycho s snr @xcite , where the escape of the highest - energy particles is arguably still weak . in very energetic ,
young core collapse supernovae , @xmath0-ray energies well in excess of 100 tev might be reached @xcite .
however , the corresponding supernova rate is expected to be so low @xcite ( less than about 1% of the total supernova rate ) that their contribution is disregarded here . in this paper
only the contribution of unresolved shell - type snrs to the galactic @xmath0-ray emission will be discussed in detail , following the earlier work by bv00 and bv04 .
as will be shown , the radiation from these scrs which extends with a hard power - law - type energy spectrum to multi - tev @xmath0-ray energies can readily explain the above - mentioned fl - gps and predicts its monotonic increase from @xmath16 gev into the multi - tev region .
the evaluation of the contribution of the unresolved pwn population is left for a future study .
the _ fermi_-lat overall emission model corresponds to a spectral energy distribution ( sed ) @xmath17 , where @xmath18 denotes the sum of the truly diffuse hadronic plus inverse compton plus bremsstrahlung emission spectra , @xmath19 is the contribution from the resolved sources , and @xmath20 corresponds to that of the isotropic backgrounds .
the resolved sources which include few shell - type snrs , many pulsars , and , at energies @xmath21 gev , the resolved pwns are expected to have a harder spectrum than the dge .
therefore @xmath22 corresponds to a harder spectrum than the approximate @xmath23-dependence of the modeled dge in the inner galaxy at energies @xmath24 gev below any cutoff . to a large degree
this is due to the contribution of the ic component and especially , that of the resolved sources .
given the representation by the fermi - lat collaboration , the most reasonable initial extension beyond 100 gev of @xmath22 appears to be an extrapolation by a power - law distribution @xmath25 of the same spectral index @xmath0 which it has between @xmath26 gev and @xmath27 gev .
however , the @xmath0-ray spectral energy densities of pwns are assumed to be typically peaked with a cutoff at several tev .
the truly diffuse leptonic emission is expected to cut off at similar energies
. therefore the component @xmath28 is multiplied by an exponential term @xmath29 .
@xmath22 extrapolated in this form is shown by the dashed curve in fig.[fig1]-ray binaries , which may reach significantly higher @xmath0-ray energies beyond 10 tev ( e.g. * ? ? ?
] . from its construction @xmath22
is an approximate lower limit to the expected sed without unresolved sources .
the program of the present paper is then to calculate the contribution of the unresolved shell - type snrs in order to predict a lower limit to the total emission in the inner galaxy in the gev range and above .
as will be shown , this lower limit implies an increasing discrepancy between measured and expected diffuse galactic emission in the region of few gev @xmath30 100 gev , and thus can explain the fl - gps .
the discrepancy is predicted to increase up to energies @xmath31 tev in the vhe range . beyond that @xmath0-ray energy
the contribution of the unresolved shell - type snrs goes down due to energy dependent escape of crs from shell - type snrs that makes for a shorter confinement time of crs with higher energy .
in fig.[fig1 ] a calculated @xmath0-ray spectrum @xmath32 of the low latitude inner galaxy ( @xmath33 , @xmath34 ) is presented . besides the overall emission model @xmath22 , discussed in the previous section , it includes the contribution @xmath35 of scrs confined within unresolved snrs .
the scr contribution is calculated based on the approach developed in bv04 : @xmath36 where @xmath37 depends on the galactocentric distance as a result of the non - uniform distribution of the galactic snrs ( see introduction ) .
@xmath35 comprises the @xmath38-decay component due to hadronic scrs @xmath39 and the inverse compton ( ic ) component due to electron scrs @xmath40 . here
@xmath41 is chosen as the @xmath38-decay component due to hadronic gcrs . at @xmath0-ray energy @xmath42
gev the quantity @xmath43 , determined by @xcite , and its power law extrapolation @xmath44 to higher energies @xmath45 gev is used .
the dimensionless ratio @xmath46 according to bv04 has the form @xmath47 where @xmath48 and @xmath49 are the gas number density in the galactic disk and inside snrs , respectively . the first factor in this expression , @xmath50 , represents the ratio of target nuclei for the two populations of crs .
the second factor , @xmath51 , represents the fact that the number of snrs , wich confine scrs with energy @xmath52 , is proportional to @xmath53 .
the third factor @xmath54 is due to the harder scr spectrum compared with the gcr spectrum .
contrary to the earlier considerations of bv00 and bv04 , where the interior snr magnetic field was assumed to be time independent , the proton confinement time @xmath55 inside the expanding snr is determined taking into account magnetic field amplification and its time dependence @xmath56 . magnetic field amplification in strong shocks
is a general theoretical concept arising from the expected nonlinear growth of unstable magnetic irregularities produced by the accelerating crs themselves @xcite .
field amplification is however also clearly observed in a number of snr sources ( e.g. * ? ? ?
here it is assumed to be a universal effect in shell - type snrs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
in this case the maximum energy of scr protons , accelerated at a given snr evolutionary epoch , decreases with time according to the relation @xmath57 .
this leads to the following expression for the proton confinement time @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the time until which snrs can confine the main fraction of accelerated particles , @xmath60 is the maximal energy of protons that can be accelerated in snrs , achieved at the beginning of the sedov phase @xmath61 .
the decrease of the proton confinement time @xmath51 with energy @xmath52 is due to the diminishing ability of the snr shock to produce high - energy crs during the sedov phase , which implies the escape of the highest energy crs from the snr @xcite .
therefore the description in terms of the escape time @xmath51 is equivalent to an initial production of the scr spectrum @xmath62 for @xmath63 in the evolving snr , following the sn explosion proper .
subsequently this spectrum is confined over the time - scale @xmath53 .
this weighs the fraction of the highest energies @xmath60 with the sedov time @xmath64 , lower - energy particles with a larger time that increases with decreasing @xmath52 , and `` low - energy '' particles with @xmath59 .
note that , due to the considerably harder scr energy spectrum compared with the gcr spectrum , the factor @xmath65 grows with energy up to a maximal energy @xmath66 of @xmath0-rays produced by scrs confined in snrs for the whole active evolutionary time @xmath67 .
the spectrum @xmath68 at @xmath69 is predominantly produced by snrs of ages @xmath70 .
therefore it is only weakly sensitive to the details of snr evolution at the epochs @xmath71 . at higher energies @xmath72 ,
the ratio @xmath73 goes down with energy and the scr contribution decreases due to the decrease of the confinement time @xmath51 . the ratio @xmath74 is calculated as described in bv04 with a time - independent interior magnetic field value @xmath75 @xmath76 g . since the dominant part of snrs in our galaxy is due to type ii sne with a relatively low progenitor star mass , which do not form extended wind bubbles during their evolution , here only the contribution of snrs expanding into a uniform ism
will be considered .
the calculations presented in fig.[fig1 ] have been performed with the following values of the relevant physical parameters : sweep up time @xmath77 yr , confinement time of scrs inside snrs @xmath78 yr , electron to proton ratio @xmath79 , effective scr power law index @xmath80 , and 10 percent efficiency of scr production in snrs , the choice of an effective @xmath80 for the scr @xmath0-ray -production allows the approximate inclusion of he @xmath0-ray emission from localised strong gas density enhancements overrun by the snr shock , as one might interpret snr - associated @xmath0-ray emissions observed , limited largely to the he range ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
since the scrs are confined inside the snrs within a thin shell behind the shock , where also the shock - compressed ism gas is situated , the interior snr gas number density @xmath81 is used , where @xmath48 is the ism gas number density .
since during the last ten years convincing observational evidence of considerable snr magnetic field amplification @xcite leading to the production of crs with energy up to @xmath82 gev @xcite has been found , the value @xmath83 gev is used here .
it is considerably larger compared with bv00 and bv04 . due to the cutoff introduced for the component
@xmath84 the calculated sed @xmath85 represents a lower limit for the expected @xmath0-ray background at energies @xmath86 tev .
it should nevertheless be emphasized here that @xmath87 is given in terms of the ratios @xmath88 and @xmath89 , and that @xmath41 is determined by the diffuse nuclear cr distribution which is rather well - known at least until the `` knee '' of the all - particle gcr spectrum .
therefore @xmath35 does not depend on the form of the extrapolation of @xmath22 beyond 100 gev . as demonstrated in bv04
there are two physical parameters which significantly influence the expected @xmath0-ray emission from the ensemble of shell - type snrs : the cr confinement time @xmath59 and the mean magnetic field strength @xmath90 inside the snrs . for a conventional value @xmath91
@xmath76 g the expected @xmath0-ray flux from snrs exceeds the hegra upper limit considerably if the scr confinement time is as large as @xmath92 yr .
the contradiction can be resolved either if one suggests an appreciably higher postshock magnetic field @xmath93 @xmath76 g or if the scr confinement time is as small as @xmath94 yr .
these possibilities can be attributed to field amplification by the scrs themselves .
in fact , nonlinear field amplification may also lead to a substantial decrease of the scr confinement time : according to @xcite maximal turbulent alfv@xmath95n wave damping with its corresponding increase of cr mobility could make the scr confinement time as small as @xmath94 yr . the only physical parameter which strongly influences the ic @xmath0-ray production rate for given synchrotron emission rate is the snr magnetic field @xmath90 : @xmath96 . due to the high magnetic field
@xmath75 @xmath76 g the overall contribution of the hadronic scrs to the @xmath0-ray flux dominates over that of the electron scrs : at tev - energies @xmath97 . as shown in fig.[fig1 ] , the discrepancy between the observed `` diffuse '' intensity and standard model predictions at energies above a few gev @xcite can be attributed to the scr contribution alone up to @xmath98 gev . unfortunately , existing vhe measurements do not coincide well in their longitude ( l ) and latitude ( b ) coverage with the corresponding ranges for _
fermi_-lat that correspond to @xmath99 and @xmath100
. therefore the following comparisons must be taken with reservations , and for this reason the observational results from these measurements are indicated in grey color in fig.[fig1 ] 1 . : as one can see , the expected @xmath0-ray flux at @xmath101 tev is consistent with the hegra upper limit , the whipple upper limits @xcite , the tibet - as upper limits @xcite , and with the fluxes measured by the milagro detector @xcite at @xmath102 tev , as well as with those obtained with the argo - ybj detector @xcite in the tev range , taken at face value .
these considerations demonstrate that the scrs inevitably make a strong contribution to the `` diffuse '' @xmath0-ray flux from the galactic disk at all energies above a few gev , if the population of shell - type snrs is the main source of the gcrs .
this explains the _
fermi_-lat galactic plane surplus .
the quantitative estimates show in addition that the scr contribution dominates over the extrapolated fermi - lat model for the total diffuse emission - which includes detected sources and isotropic backgrounds - at energies greater than 100 gev due to its substantially harder spectrum .
the diffuse emission measured by milagro at 15 tev and by argo - ybj at tev energies provide limited evidence for that
. it will be interesting to see if , and then to which extent , tev observations will show an even higher total emission than the one calculated here .
if this was the case it is suggested that such a difference should be attributed to the emission from pulsar wind nebulae , or even to other particle sources , some of which were mentioned above .
a full consideration of the potential particle sources is beyond the scope of this paper .
the galactocentric variation of any surplus over the purely diffuse emission above a few gev should correspond to the galactocentric variation of the ratio @xmath37 between the @xmath38-decay components of source cosmic rays and truly diffuse galactic cosmic rays as a result of the observed snr distribution .
this implies a concentration in the inner galaxy . the authors would like to thank the referee , olaf reimer , for a number of critical and insightful comments that helped to improve the manuscript
this work has been supported in part by the department of federal target programs and projects ( grant 8404 ) , by the russian foundation for basic research ( grants 13 - 02 - 00943 and 13 - 02 - 12036 ) and by the council of the president of the russian federation for support of young scientists and leading scientific schools ( project nsh-1741.2012.2 ) . | recent observations of the diffuse galactic @xmath0-ray emission ( dge ) by the _ fermi _ large area telescope ( _ fermi_-lat ) have shown significant deviations , above a few gev until about 100 gev , from dge models that use the galprop code for the propagation of cosmic ray ( cr ) particles outside their sources in the galaxy and their interaction with the target distributions of the interstellar gas and radiation fields .
the surplus of radiation observed is most pronounced in the inner galaxy , where the concentration of cr sources is strongest .
the present study investigates this `` _ fermi_-lat galactic plane surplus '' by estimating the @xmath0-ray emission from the sources themselves , which is disregarded in the above dge models .
it is shown that indeed the expected hard spectrum of crs , still confined in their sources ( scrs ) , can explain this surplus .
the method is based on earlier studies regarding the so - called egret gev excess which by now is generally interpreted as an instrumental effect .
the contribution from scrs is predicted to increasingly exceed the dge models also above 100 gev , up to @xmath0-ray energies of about ten tev , where the corresponding surplus exceeds the hadronic part of the dge by about one order of magnitude . above such energies the emission surplus should decrease again with energy due to the finite life - time of the assumed supernova remnant sources .
observations of the dge in the inner galaxy at 15 tev with the milagro @xmath0-ray detector and , at tev energies , with the argo - ybj detector are interpreted to provide confirmation of a significant scr contribution to the dge . |
stellar multiplicity plays a crucial role in many fields of astronomy . star formation and evolution , galactic chemical evolution , nuclear astrophysics , and cosmology
are all influenced by our understanding of the multiplicity properties of an underlying stellar population .
binary interactions lead to phenomena as diverse as cataclysmic variables , classical novae , x - ray binaries , gamma - ray bursts , and type ia supernovae .
stellar interactions are also the cause of the anomalous surface abundances measured in ba stars , ch stars , and the majority of carbon - enhanced metal - poor stars @xcite .
the rates of these phenomena depend on the multiplicity properties such as the fraction of stars with companions and the distributions of separations and mass ratios .
how these properties are in turn affected by variables such as stellar age , metallicity , and dynamical environment remains poorly understood .
@xcite find no significant trends with metallicity for o- and b - stars , but more work is needed for lower - mass stars .
the recent review by @xcite summarizes the state of the art in multiplicity studies .
the fraction of systems with companions is known to be a strong function of stellar mass @xcite , and there are hints that lower mass systems have smaller separations @xcite .
studies of the solar neighborhood also indicate that lower metallicity stars are more likely to have stellar companions @xcite .
these results are based on heterogeneous samples of a few hundred stars at most , often dominated by wide systems which will never become interacting binaries .
the spectroscopic surveys that reach small periods are labor intensive because large numbers of radial velocities ( @xmath2 ) are required to find the orbital solution of each target .
this leads to small sample sizes , which have only increased modestly in the past two decades , from 167 in @xcite to 454 in @xcite .
the drive to collect complete samples has limited previous spectroscopic studies to the solar neighborhood or specific stellar clusters , but neither of these strategies can probe the full range of metallicities and ages spanning the field stars of the milky way ( mw ) disk and halo components .
these limits bias the interpretation of data against the global properties of , and variation within , the mw field .
thus , we are motivated to take a statistical approach with a sample of stars located throughout the field in order to investigate their multiplicity properties with respect to age , @xmath3}$ ] , and component membership . with the advent of multiplexed spectroscopic surveys like sdss @xcite and lamost @xcite
, we can use multiple @xmath4 measurements of thousands of stars to study the properties of stellar multiplicity that are more representative of the entire galaxy .
sdss data release 8 @xcite contains over 1.8 million optical spectra from the original sdss spectrographs including over 600,000 stellar spectra . in this work
we employ a lesser known sdss feature , the time - resolved dimension . to facilitate cosmic ray removal
, spectra were constructed through co - addition of several individual sub - exposures , typically 15 minutes in duration .
although under - utilized , the benefit of the sub - exposure domain is recognized in works such as @xcite and @xcite .
portions of the sky were also re - observed for calibration and scientific purposes .
these additional pointings , combined with the sub - exposures , yield a time dimension where single stars have exposure coverage ranging from 3 sub - exposures up to over 40 sub - exposures , and time gaps from hours to nearly a decade .
the techniques employed herein follow the time - resolved work by @xcite and @xcite .
f - type dwarfs are chosen for our sample because of the large number of stars targeted by sdss with repeat observations , and their relatively mild variability and activity . additionally , f - stars have main sequence ( ms ) lifetimes greater than @xmath5 , allowing us to select ms stars from both the younger disk and older halo .
the sloan stellar parameter pipeline ( sspp ; @xcite ) was developed to determine parameters for stellar spectra in the sdss archive , including metallicity @xmath3}$ ] , effective temperature @xmath6 , and surface gravity @xmath7 .
sample selection began with identifying science primary objects from segue-1 @xcite and segue-2 ( rockosi et al .
, in prep . )
in the sspp that were classified as an f - type star by the `` hammer '' classification code @xcite . to minimize the effects of stellar evolution on multiplicity , we selected only dwarf stars ( @xmath8 ) .
stars with multiple fiber pluggings were identified astrometrically and joined with the appropriate science primary fibers . after measuring stellar @xmath2 ( section [ ssec : rv ] ) , systematics were revealed in the sdss sub - exposure spectra .
these correlations appear as similar shifts in @xmath2 for many fibers located on the same plate , typically affecting neighboring fibers on the ccd . after plate - wide comparisons of f - stars ,
@xmath4 correlations were corrected where possible .
corrections applied to the @xmath9 @xmath2 are as large as @xmath10 with a standard deviation of @xmath11 .
not all correlations could be identified automatically because of multiple groups of correlated shifts , opposite in direction , on some plates .
visual inspection of plates containing numerous false binary detections lead to the removal of 25 plates including 1155 stars .
we urge individuals using sub - exposure spectroscopy in sdss to consider these systematic shifts in the wavelength solutions .
quality control consisted of the removal of : stars without valid parameters in sspp , fibers located on ` bad ' plates , sub - exposures with a median pixel signal - to - noise ratio ( @xmath12 ) less than 20 or with fewer than 3000 unflagged pixels , stars with time lags @xmath13 , stars with less than three clean sub - exposures , and corrupt or misclassified spectra ( from visual inspection of stars with the largest rv variation or non - characteristic @xmath6 ) .
the final sample consists of 14,302 stars ( 16,894 fibers ) with as many as 47 sub - exposures , spanning up to nine years of observations ( figure [ fig : feh_baseline ] ) .
our cleaned sample is characterized by metallicities ranging from @xmath14}}}\leq+0.52 $ ] .
to aid comparison in our analysis , the final sample was sub - divided into three groups of equal size by cuts in metallicity at @xmath15}}}={\ensuremath{-1.43}}$ ] and @xmath15}}}={\ensuremath{-0.66}}$ ] ( figure [ fig : feh_baseline ] ) .
the majority of the stars have three or four sub - exposures ( @xmath16 ) , typically taken about 15 minutes apart .
the median time lag for a star is 2 hours , however more than three years between observations can be seen in more than 250 stars ( figure [ fig : feh_baseline ] ) . @xmath12s for sub - exposures lie in the range @xmath17 with a median value of @xmath18 .
@xmath4 measurements were attained through cross - correlation of sub - exposures with a master template constructed from 7207 sample - star , co - added spectra where the co - added @xmath19 .
the spectra were de - shifted using the redshift value assigned to the co - adds by the sdss pipeline , continuum - normalized , and averaged together .
sub - exposures were independently prepared and cross - correlated with the template .
spectra were continuum - normalized by dividing the spectrum with a highly smoothed version of itself using a fft smoothing algorithm , and then cross - correlated with the template at various integer pixel lags .
each spectrum had a cross - correlation function ( ccf ) that was fit with a smooth spline interpolation
. with spectral resolution of @xmath20 , the peak lag in pixels translates to the spectrum s redshift at @xmath21
. the mean and standard deviation of @xmath2 for individual stars are shown in the figure [ fig : comborv ] distributions .
the velocity dispersion of the mean rvs decreases with increasing @xmath3}$ ] , indicating that our @xmath3}$]-groups sample both the disk and halo components of the mw .
the standard deviation of @xmath2 within individual stars is larger for the metal - poor group ; however , empirically estimated uncertainties also show larger measurement errors for metal - poor stars .
this underscores the importance of the use of proper error analysis in a method such as ours .
it is well known that uncertainties in ccf peaks must be estimated empirically or through some monte carlo method ( e.g. , @xcite ) . for this work we determined @xmath4 uncertainties empirically by quantifying the spread in measurements for spectra of similar quality . the median absolute deviation ( @xmath22 )
is a robust measure of the variability of a sample and is related to the standard deviation by @xmath23 , where @xmath24 @xcite .
all measurements were de - shifted into the rest frame using the sdss estimates of the co - add redshift , and placed into bins of similar metallicity ( @xmath15}}}\pm 0.25 $ ] ) and signal - to - noise ( @xmath25 ) .
initial tests showed no correlations between measurement spreads and either @xmath7 or @xmath6 .
estimates for the uncertainty of @xmath4 measurements within a bin were calculated using @xmath22 values . here , it is assumed that the majority of stars do not have detectable variability over the observed time baseline , and that effects from intrinsic variations in @xmath4 are minimized by adopting median values . after performing this process for all bins , a functional form for assigning @xmath4 measurement uncertainties @xmath26 was fit with an inverse proportionality to @xmath12 , and with a linear correction in @xmath3}$ ] .
the measurement uncertainty as a function of @xmath3}$ ] and @xmath12 is , in @xmath27 , @xmath28}}},{\ensuremath{\mathrm{snr}}}\right ) = \frac{(-26.51{\ensuremath{\mathrm{[fe / h]}}}+ 50.52)}{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{snr } } } } + 1.23.\ ] ] uncertainties are sub - pixel , falling below the spectral resolution of @xmath21 . for exposures with @xmath29 ,
uncertainties range from @xmath30 to @xmath31 , with a median value of @xmath32 .
exposures with @xmath33 have uncertainties in the range @xmath34 to @xmath35 , with a median value of @xmath36 .
the probability of a star having a companion was determined through model comparison using a trans - dimensional , hierarchical , markov chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) method .
two models were compared : a single - star model @xmath37 , and a binary - star model @xmath38 .
the hyperparameter @xmath39 , indexes the model choice at each step in the mcmc chain .
we evaluated the hierarchical model using the python package _ emcee _
, a mcmc ensemble sampler @xcite .
the single - star model @xmath37 , fits a star with non - varying @xmath2 , parameterized by a systemic velocity @xmath40 .
because intra - plate systematics are known to exist , it is reasonable to assume inter - plate systematics exist as well . in light of this ,
@xmath41 additional parameters @xmath42 , were included for each star , where @xmath43 is the number of plate - mjd pluggings composing the star .
these plate - shift parameters allow all @xmath2 from plate @xmath44 to shift by some amount @xmath42 , relative to the first plate @xmath45 . for the majority of stars @xmath46 ,
no plate - shift parameters are necessary , and @xmath37 is a 1-parameter model . in the binary star model @xmath38 ,
the sparsely sampled @xmath2 are fit by a sinusoid defined by four - parameters : the log of the semi - amplitude @xmath47 , the log of the period @xmath48 , the phase @xmath49 , and the systemic velocity @xmath40 .
we assume circular orbits ( eccentricity , @xmath50 ) , which is a safe assumption for tidally circularized , short - period orbits ( @xmath51 days ; @xcite ) , where we are most sensitive .
a small number of the binaries found in this study may have longer periods and could have non - zero eccentricities , but this does not affect our results .
plate - shift parameters were also adopted in @xmath38 wherever @xmath52 .
uninformative priors were used in the mcmc .
the model index @xmath39 , has a flat prior from 0 to 1 , where @xmath53 denotes @xmath37 and @xmath54 denotes @xmath38 .
the semi - amplitude prior is log - uniform from @xmath55 , comparable to the measurement uncertainties where @xmath37 and @xmath38 become degenerate , to @xmath56 , greater than the largest @xmath4 differences in the sample .
the prior on the period is uniform in the range @xmath57 .
the lower limit @xmath58 is equal to the orbital period at which stellar contact is certain for low - mass companions . above @xmath59 ,
@xmath4 amplitudes in binary systems are comparable to the measurement uncertainties . combined with the sparsity of the @xmath4 data , systems with periods longer than @xmath59 are outside our range of sensitivity .
priors are also uniform for the phase ( @xmath60 ) and systemic velocity ( @xmath61 ) .
markov chains were run independently on every star with an ensemble of @xmath62 parallel chain `` walkers '' for a total of @xmath63 samples , then burned and thinned to @xmath64 independent samples of the posterior .
evidence for detection of a companion star is reflected by the relative probabilities of @xmath39 .
we define the probability for the binary model , @xmath65 as the fraction of samples in the marginalized posterior having @xmath66 .
we note that the value of @xmath65 is dependent on the choice of priors , and is sensitive to the treatment of the sdss systematics .
moreover , a degeneracy arises as the @xmath4 curve of a long - period , low - amplitude system becomes indistinguishable from a single - star system . with this mind
, we stress that values for @xmath65 are not absolute probabilities of a system having a companion , but reflect the ability of the data to rule out models under the given prior . however , the @xmath3}$]-groups can be compared , relatively , by considering the fraction of systems where @xmath65 is large and @xmath37 is strongly disfavored .
the results are shown in figure [ fig : etahist ] we also investigated the @xmath67 parameter proposed by @xcite as a metric for identifying the stars with large @xmath4 variations .
we find that the @xmath67 parameter singles out many of the same stars as our more sophisticated mcmc - based inference .
our method not only takes into account deviations in @xmath4 from the mean , but also how well the data fit the expected periodicity of a binary system .
analysis of the posterior , and visual inspections of the binary model fits , show that 681 stars with @xmath68 are true spectroscopic binaries , though given the sparsity of the rv curve sampling , there are sometimes large uncertainties in the fitted values for specific model parameters .
another natural break point is @xmath69 ; these are 209 stars for which the determination and analysis of accurate individual model parameters should be possible ( and will be characterized in future work ) .
an intermediate cut at @xmath70 is a compromise between these limits , yielding a larger sample of stars ( 406 ) with modest model constraints .
the values of the binary fractions that we derive below are insensitive , within the uncertainties , to the exact choice of cut in @xmath65 .
this implies that the @xmath4 variations for our binary detections are sufficiently above the measurement uncertainties , and that the binary fractions reported are not biased due to differences in @xmath12 or absorption features .
figure [ fig : logp ] shows the @xmath48 posteriors for each @xmath3}$]-group , marginalized over all binary systems ( @xmath70 ) .
the posterior distributions of @xmath48 for many of these stars are complex : many are multimodal , affected by aliasing or other issues related to the sparse , biased time sampling .
one such effect is the increase in probability at @xmath71 . here
the metal - rich and -intermediate groups contain more stars than the metal - poor group with @xmath72 .
systems with periods as short as this are extremely rare @xcite , and our increased probability in this area may be due to overfitting . additionally , the gap at @xmath73 ( figure [ fig : feh_baseline ] ) may affect the estimate of a period .
we defer a more sophisticated analysis to a future paper , but these effects should not alter the ability to rule out a single - star model . for now , figure [ fig : logp ] illustrates that we are mainly sensitive to periods in the range @xmath74 , or less than about 12 days .
we emphasize that a more detailed analysis will be necessary to estimate the true underlying @xmath48 distribution in our sample .
in figure [ fig : binaryfractions ] we show @xmath75 , the measured lower bound for the fraction of stars with short - period companions @xmath76 for each metallicity group , normalized to the metal - rich binary fraction .
@xmath75 is a lower limit because of non - detections as a result of sparsely sampled @xmath2 and high orbital inclinations , resulting in low amplitudes .
we see agreement in @xmath75 measured for all three choices in @xmath65 cutoff ( 0.65 , 0.80 , 0.95 ) . with a cutoff of @xmath77 , values of @xmath75 for the metal - poor , -intermediate , and -rich groups respectively are :
@xmath78 , @xmath79 , and @xmath80 .
since the observational biases that affect binary detection are mostly due to the sparsity of the rv coverage , which is nt metallicity - dependent , we conclude that the field f - type ms stars in our metal - rich sample are , at a 2-sigma level , @xmath1 more likely than those in our metal - poor sample to have close binary companions .
our metal - rich and metal - poor samples mostly trace the mw disk and halo .
differences in the fraction of short - period systems can stem from differences in the star - formation process , dynamical interactions after star formation , or some combination of the two .
three - dimensional hydrodynamic models from @xcite actually suggest a _ higher _ frequency of binaries formed through cloud fragmentation for metal - poor clusters , due to the decreased requirement of a cloud s initial rotation energy to fragment .
moreover , their models yield systems with shorter initial separations at lower metallicities .
the increased @xmath75 observed for metal - rich stars in this work can more likely be explained by dynamical processes than by formation processes .
the observed differences in @xmath75 could be explained if the clusters that yielded halo field stars had larger stellar densities and/or gas densities than those of the disk .
@xcite explore the effects of gas - induced orbital decay on period distributions in clusters .
they note that an increased density of gas in a newly formed cluster will lead to a larger number of short - period system mergers shortly after formation .
@xcite describe how clusters with higher stellar densities destroy wide binaries through dynamical interactions .
an increase in the destruction of high - mass , wide - binary systems leads to the ejection of former f - star secondaries into the field .
these orphaned , single - star systems would increase the total number of f - star systems in the halo field , effectively decreasing the short - period binary fraction measured .
observational evidence of these denser cluster environments is needed to support these arguments for a lower @xmath75 in the halo . additionally , some close binaries may also transfer mass and covert themselves into blue stragglers @xcite .
evidence for an abundance of blue stragglers in the halo has been seen @xcite , and may contribute to the lower @xmath75 observed in the metal - poor group . also ,
@xcite show a decrease in @xmath75 with age for solar - type stars , although this result is based on visual binaries with wider periods , and is poorly constrained due to limited sample sizes .
we note that the recent results of @xcite and @xcite , using data from sdss , show a larger binary fraction for metal - poor than metal - rich fgk stars in the field .
in addition to probing longer periods , the former work does not make use of sub - exposure information ( using only two @xmath4 epochs per star ) and relies on the correctness of model values for the period distribution , mass ratio distribution , and initial mass function . the latter work , which uses photometric color deviations to infer companions , shows a modest metallicity dependence on total binary fraction . since their method is not sensitive to period , the binary fractions they report are strongly dominated by more common , wider - period systems near the peak of a log - normal period distribution ( @xmath81 for nearby , solar - like stars ; @xcite ) .
it is clear that conclusions about binary fraction depend on a number of factors , especially the range of periods to which the search is sensitive and assumptions made about the overall period distribution .
our mcmc analysis yields posterior probabilities in parameter space , allowing for a more detailed study of binary properties ( e.g. , period and separation distributions ) , which will be presented in future work .
the techniques in this work have direct applications for current and future multiplexed spectroscopic surveys .
we thank ewan cameron , dan maoz , jeffrey newman , chad schafer , and the referee for useful discussions .
t.h . and t.c.b .
acknowledge partial support from grants phy 08 - 22648 ; physics frontier center / jina , and phy 14 - 30152 ; physics frontier center / jina center for the evolution of the elements ( jina - cee ) , awarded by the us national science foundation .
funding for sdss - iii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , and the u.s .
department of energy office of science . | stellar multiplicity lies at the heart of many problems in modern astrophysics , including the physics of star formation , the observational properties of unresolved stellar populations , and the rates of interacting binaries such as cataclysmic variables , x - ray binaries , and type ia supernovae .
however , little is known about the stellar multiplicity of field stars in the milky way , in particular about the differences in the multiplicity characteristics between metal - rich disk stars and metal - poor halo stars . in this study
we perform a statistical analysis of @xmath014,000 f - type dwarf stars in the milky way through time - resolved spectroscopy with the sub - exposures archived in the sloan digital sky survey .
we obtain absolute radial velocity measurements through template cross - correlation of individual sub - exposures with temporal baselines varying from minutes to years .
these sparsely sampled radial velocity curves are analyzed using markov chain monte carlo techniques to constrain the very short - period binary fraction for field f - type stars in the milky way .
metal - rich disk stars were found to be @xmath1 more likely to have companions with periods shorter than 12 days than metal - poor halo stars . |
advection - dominated accretion flows ( hereafter adafs ) have been studied extensively ( e.g , narayan & yi 1994 , 1995 ; abramowicz et al .
1995 ; see narayan , mahadevan & quataert 1998 and kato , fukue & mineshige 1998 for reviews ) .
it is now rather well established that this accretion mode exists in the quiescent and hard states of black hole x - ray binaries and low - luminosity active galactic nuclei ( see narayan 2005 , yuan 2007 , ho 2008 , and narayan & mcclintock 2008 for recent reviews ) .
adafs only exist below a critical mass accretion rate . below this accretion rate ,
the rate of radiative cooling is so weak that the viscous heating is balanced by the advection . with the increase of accretion rate ,
radiation becomes more and more important until it becomes equal to the viscous heating at this critical rate .
in this case , the energy advection is equal to zero ( narayan , mahadevan & quataert 1998 ) . above this critical accretion rate ,
up to another limit close to the eddington accretion rate , another hot accretion solution luminous hot accretion flows ( lhafs)was found which is a natural extension of adafs ( yuan 2001 , 2003 ) . in this solution ,
the flow is able to remain hot because the radiative cooling rate , although it is strong , is still lower than the sum of compression work and viscous heating .
note that the cool thin solution standard thin disk always exists in the whole range of accretion rates of adafs and lhafs . in the present work we only focus on the hot accretion flows adafs , but
our discussion should hold for lhafs . in the early version of adafs
, the accretion rate is assumed to be a constant , i.e. , there is no outflow throughout the region .
the magnetic field is included , but only its stochastic component , while the large - scale ordered field is not considered .
great developments have been achieved since the discovery of adafs .
one is the realization of the existence of outflows in adafs , i.e , only some fraction of the accretion material available at the outer boundary is actually accreted into the central black hole ( narayan & yi 1994 , 1995 ; blandford & begelman 1999 ; stone , begelman , pringle 1999 ; igumenshchev & abramowicz 1999 ; stone & pringle 2001 ) .
the physical reason for the origin of the outflow is believed to be that the bernoulli parameter of the flow is positive ( narayan & yi 1994 ; blandford & begelman 1999 ) .
another possible mechanism of the outflow origin is associated with large - scale ordered magnetic fields , e.g. , through the magnetocentrifugal force ( blandford & payne 1982 ; henriksen & valls - gabaud 1994 ; fiege & henriksen 1996 ) .
observations in the center of our galaxy supply strong evidence for the existence of outflows . from @xmath0 observations combined with bondi accretion theory
, we can predict the accretion rate at the bondi radius .
polarization observations at radio wavebands , however , indicate that the accretion rate at the innermost region must be significantly smaller than the bondi value ( yuan , quataert & narayan 2003 ) .
therefore , a large amount of material must be lost into outflows .
another interesting result of numerical magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) simulations of the hot accretion flow is that a large - scale ordered magnetic field exists in the inner regions of adafs .
independent of the initial configuration of the magnetic field * ( toroidal or poloidal ) * in the main body of the accretion flow the field is primarily toroidal , with weak radial and vertical components .
this large - scale structure is imposed on the stochastic component of the magnetic field on small scales ( machida , hayashi & matsumoto 2000 ; hirose et al .
2004 ) .
both outflows and large - scale magnetic fields can affect the dynamics of adafs significantly .
for example , both of them can effectively transfer angular momentum .
these are alternative mechanisms in addition to the turbulence mechanism associated with the magnetorotational instability ( mri ) proposed by balbus & hawley ( 1991 ; 1998 ) .
stone & norman ( 1994 ; see also mouschovias & paleologou 1980 ) investigate the angular momentum transfer by magnetic braking effects associated with a large - scale magnetic field . if the specific internal energy of the outflow is different from that of the inflow where the outflow originates , the outflow acts as an extra cooling or heating term in the accretion flow , as discussed phenomenologically by blandford & begelman ( 1999 ) .
xie & yuan ( 2008 ) parameterize the outflow properties and systematically investigate the effects of the outflow on the dynamics of the inflow , in absence of the large - scale magnetic field .
it is thus necessary to investigate the dynamics of adafs with coexistent outflows and large - scale magnetic fields .
several works have been done recently under the self - similar approximation ( akizuki & fukue 2006 ; abbassi , ghanbari & najjar 2008 ; zhang & dai 2008 ) or global solution ( oda et al .
all these works consider the dynamical effects of the outflow by adopting the form @xmath1 ( e.g. , eq .
( [ mdot ] ) ; blandford & begelman 1999 ) to describe the accretion rate while all other effects such as the probable angular momentum transfer by outflows are neglected . in akizuki & fukue ( 2006 ) ,
oda et al . ( 2007 ) , and abbassi , ghanbari & najjar ( 2008 ) , only the toroidal component of the large - scale magnetic field is considered ; thus , the large - scale magnetic field in their model only supplies an additional force in the radial direction , while it is unable to transfer angular momentum . in zhang & dai ( 2008 ) , although all the three components of the large - scale magnetic field are included explicitly , their solutions unfortunately violate the magnetic divergence - free condition when @xmath2 . in this paper
, we investigate the self - similar solutions of adafs with coexistent outflows and large - scale magnetic fields .
we assume the large - scale magnetic field has both @xmath3 and @xmath4 components , hence , the large - scale magnetic field does not only affect the radial force balance of the accretion flow , but also helps to remove angular momentum . following xie & yuan ( 2008 ) ,
we take into account the dynamical effects of outflows by considering the differences of specific angular momentum and specific internal energy between inflow and outflow .
the paper is organized as follows . in @xmath5
we present the basic mhd equations , which include ordered magnetic fields and outflows .
we address in @xmath6 further assumptions , and achieve a set of self - similar equations .
numerical results are presented in @xmath7 .
we summarize the paper in @xmath8 .
in cylindrical coordinates ( @xmath9 ) , we investigate the steady - state , axisymmetric ( @xmath10 ) magnetized advection - dominated accretion flows with outflows .
the general mhd equations in gaussian units read ( e.g. , lovelace , romanova , & newman 1994 ) , @xmath11 @xmath12 @xmath13 @xmath14 the induction equation of the magnetic field reads , @xmath15 the final equation is the energy equation , @xmath16 here @xmath17 is the gravitational potential ; @xmath18 is the viscous force per unit volume ; @xmath19 is the magnetic field ; @xmath20 is the magnetic diffusivity ; @xmath21 is the current density ; @xmath22 is the specific internal energy of the accretion flow ; @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the viscous heating and radiative cooling rates ; @xmath25 , @xmath26 and @xmath27 have their usual meanings . for simplicity
, we use the newtonian potential and neglect the self - gravity of the accreting gas .
the advection factor , @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) , describes the fraction of the viscous dissipation energy which is stored in the accretion flow and advected into the central black hole rather than radiated away . from the numerical mhd simulations ( e.g. , machida , hayashi & matsumoto 2000 ;
hirose et al .
2004 ) , it is reasonable to decompose the magnetic field into one large - scale component and one fluctuating or turbulent component .
the general picture that emerged from the simulations is that the main body of the accretion flow is governed by a toroidal magnetic field , especially in its inner region , while regions near the poles are primarily governed by a poloidal magnetic field ( see fig .
6 in hirose et al . 2004 ) , which is mainly in the vertical direction .
thus , we only consider the @xmath4 and @xmath3 components ( @xmath30 ) of the large - scale magnetic field and neglect the radial component ( @xmath31 ) .
we describe the effects of the fluctuating component of the magnetic field in transferring the angular momentum and in dissipating the energy through the usual @xmath32 description . specifically , the viscous heating rate @xmath23 in eq .
( [ energy ] ) is associated with the turbulent component instead of the large - scale ordered component of the magnetic field .
this is because numerical simulations show that the dissipation mainly comes from the thermalization of the magnetic energy via magnetic reconnection ( hirose et al .
2006 ) , which is obviously associated with the turbulent component .
following lovelace , romanova & newman ( 1994 ) , we assume @xmath33 is an even function of @xmath3 .
furthermore , we neglect the vertical gradient of @xmath33 in the disc .
we take @xmath34 to be an odd function of @xmath3 .
we therefore have , @xmath35 @xmath36 @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the half - height of the accretion disc defined as @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is the isothermal sound speed , @xmath41 is the keplerian velocity and @xmath42 is defined below in eq . (
. it will reduce to its traditional form of @xmath43 in absence of the toroidal component ( @xmath34 ) of the ordered magnetic field ( eq . ( [ zmon2 ] ) ) . under the above assumptions , the divergence - free condition of the magnetic field ( eq .
( [ diver ] ) ) is automatically satisfied .
the specific angular momentum and specific internal energy of the outflow are in general different from those of the inflow where the outflow originates .
a two - dimensional calculation is ideal but complicated and out of the scope of our current work .
instead , we follow the method illustrated in xie & yuan ( 2008 ) and use several parameters ( @xmath44 ; see below for definitions ) to characterize the properties of the outflow . in this way
, we integrate the above mhd equations in the vertical direction and get the following 1.5-dimensional equations to describe the inflow dynamics ( xie & yuan 2008 ) .
the equations of the conservation of mass and momentum are , @xmath45 @xmath46,\label{rmon2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath47 the static equilibrium in the vertical direction is achieved between the @xmath3-component of the gravitational force and the ( gas and magnetic ) pressure gradient force , @xmath48 the tension term associated with @xmath33 is @xmath49 .
it is neglected since we have assumed @xmath50 .
the energy equation is @xmath51 here @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 denote the @xmath55 , @xmath4 and @xmath3 components of the velocity of the outflow when it is just launched from the accretion flow ( xie & yuan 2008 ) , and @xmath56 and @xmath22 correspond to the specific internal energy of the outflow and that of the inflow , respectively . following xie & yuan ( 2008 ) , we assume @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
parameter @xmath59 is the ratio of the specific heats , which goes from the relativistic value @xmath60 to the typical monatomic gas value @xmath61 . in our calculations we set @xmath62 .
we find our results are not sensitive to the value of @xmath59 .
the second terms on the left - hand side of eqs .
( [ rmon2 ] ) & ( [ phimon2 ] ) are the momenta ( radial and angular ) taken away from or deposited into the inflow by the outflow ( xie & yuan 2008 ) , and the third term on the left - hand side of eq .
( [ energy2 ] ) is the internal energy taken away from or deposited into the inflow by the outflow .
if all these @xmath63s are equal to unity , our model will reduce to those neglecting the discrepancies of specific momenta and internal energy between the inflow and the outflow ( e.g. , akizuki & fukue 2006 ; abbassi , ghanbari & najjar 2008 ; zhang & dai 2008 ) .
now we discuss the induction equation ( eq .
( [ induc ] ) ) .
this equation describes the growth or escape rate of the magnetic field by dynamo and diffusion .
we define the advection rates of the two components of the magnetic flux as , @xmath64 @xmath65 for a steady - state accretion system considered here , if the dynamo and the diffusion effects are neglected , the above two quantities will be constant .
however , in a realistic accretion disc , the above two quantities can vary with radius due to the presence of the dynamo and the diffusion effects .
we seek self - similar solutions in the following forms ( e.g. , narayan & yi 1995 ) , @xmath66 @xmath67 @xmath68 we assume the surface density ( @xmath69 ) to have the form , @xmath70 where @xmath71 and @xmath72 are two constants , so the accretion rate takes the form , @xmath73 note that @xmath74 will lead to solutions without outflows .
we assume the magnetic pressure on the surface of the accretion flow to be proportional to the gas pressure in the following way , @xmath75 @xmath76 @xmath42 and @xmath77 are two parameters .
the induction equations will be satisfied if the dynamo and the diffusion of the magnetic field satisfy the self - similar conditions required by the advection rate ( eqs .
( [ induc1 ] ) & ( [ induc2 ] ) ) .
typical values of @xmath42 and @xmath77 lie in the range @xmath78 in hot accretion flows ( e.g. , de villiers , hawley & krolik 2003 ; beckwith et al .
2008 ) , but here we also consider the magnetically - dominated case ( @xmath79 ) . on one hand , the mhd numerical simulation by machida , nakamura & matsumoto ( 2006 ) shows that when thermal instability happens in an adaf , the thermal pressure rapidly decreases while the magnetic pressure increases due to the conservation of magnetic flux
. this will result in large @xmath42 and @xmath77 and forms a magnetically - dominated accretion flow .
in addition , an initially weak large - scale field at the outer region can be amplified due to the compression of the flow as it is accreted inward .
this can also result in large @xmath42 and @xmath77 .
of course , in this case , the mri will be suppressed , but we still keep @xmath32 in equations for simplicity and this treatment will not affect our results significantly for our purpose
. + the momentum conservation and the vertical equilibrium equations ( eqs .
( [ rmon2 ] [ zmon2 ] ) ) now reduce to , @xmath80 @xmath81 @xmath82 the energy equation becomes , @xmath83 = \frac{9}{4}f c_2 ^ 2.\label{energy3}\ ] ] obviously for given values of @xmath84 and @xmath77 , eqs .
( [ rmon3 ] ) , ( [ phimon3 ] ) and ( [ energy3 ] ) form a closed set of equations of @xmath85 and @xmath86 , which will determine the dynamics of the accretion flow .
+ the first and the second terms on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ phimon3 ] ) are angular momentum transfer due to turbulent - viscosity ( mri ) and the large - scale magnetic field , respectively .
we define a new parameter @xmath87 to account for the ratio of angular momentum transport due to these two mechanisms , @xmath88 the large - scale magnetic field will be the dominant mechanism in angular momentum transport when @xmath87 is below unity .
we first show in fig .
[ f1 ] the effects of the large - scale magnetic field on the accretion flow .
we set @xmath89 and @xmath90 ( no outflows ) .
the solid , dotted and long - dashed lines correspond to @xmath91 and @xmath92 , respectively .
we can see from the figure that as @xmath34 ( @xmath42 ) increases , the radial ( @xmath93 ) and angular ( @xmath94 ) velocities increase , while the temperature ( @xmath86 ) and the turbulent - viscosity contribution to angular momentum transport ( @xmath87 ) decrease .
the decrease of @xmath87 is obvious and easy to understand , since the large - scale magnetic field should be more important in transporting angular momentum as its strength increases .
we find that the magnetic pressure gradient force ( the fourth and fifth terms on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ rmon3 ] ) ) is a centrifugal force , while the magnetic stress force ( the sixth term on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ rmon3 ] ) ) is a centripetal force . for the wide range of @xmath42 and @xmath77 considered here , the gradient of the total pressure ( gas plus magnetic pressure ) serves as a centrifugal force , and it exceeds the magnetic centripetal force .
all these terms are proportional to the sound speed ( or , equivalently , the temperature @xmath86 ) . the solutions to eqs .
( [ rmon3])-([energy3 ] ) , as shown in fig .
[ f1 ] , indicate that an increase in @xmath34 ( @xmath42 ) results in a decrease in temperature ( @xmath86 ) .
this in turn leads to a decrease of the effective centrifugal force , and subsequently an increase of the infalling velocity @xmath95 , as shown in the upper - left panel of fig .
[ f1 ] . combined with the energy equation ( eq .
( [ energy3 ] ) ) , the angular velocity will increase correspondingly .
the change of the @xmath3 component of the ordered magnetic field has similar effects .
it is evident from figure [ f1 ] that an increase in the @xmath3 component of the magnetic field @xmath33 ( @xmath77 ) will lead to a decrease in temperature ( @xmath86 ) . due to the decrease of temperature , the effective centrifugal force decreases , so the infalling velocity increases . from the energy equation ( eq .
( [ energy3 ] ) ) , the angular velocity will increase correspondingly .
we thus come to a general conclusion that , the stronger the magnetic field is , the faster the accretion flow rotates and falls into the central object , and the lower the temperature will be ( see figs .
( [ f2 ] ) & ( [ f3 ] ) for situations with outflows ) .
the decrease of temperature of adafs after taking into account the large - scale magnetic field may have an important observational implication .
the x - ray spectra of the hard state of black hole x - ray binaries and some agns ( such as type 1 seyfert galaxies ) are well described by a power - law form with a high - energy cutoff .
this kind of spectrum is widely accepted as originating from the thermal comptonization process in a hot plasma which is likely to be the region of a hot accretion flow where most of the radiation originates ( see review by zdziarski & gierliski 2004 ) .
the value of the cutoff energy is determined by the temperature of the accretion flow , while the slope of the power - law distribution is determined by the product of temperature and optical depth . from fitting the observed x - ray spectrum
, we can well constrain these two parameters , namely the optical depth and temperature . on the other hand
, we can also calculate their values from the hot accretion flow model .
yuan & zdziarski ( 2004 ) find that while the theoretical prediction is roughly consistent with observational results , for some sources the temperature obtained from observation , @xmath96 kev , is significantly lower than that the lowest value predicted by the hot accretion flow models , @xmath97 kev ( see fig . 1 in yuan & zdziarski 2004 ) .
our current work indicates that this discrepancy may be solved by including the large - scale magnetic field ( fig .
[ f1 ] ) and the outflow ( figs .
[ f2]&[f3 ] ) .
unfortunately , it is difficult to give a quantitative estimation of how strong the magnetic field is required to be to solve the discrepancy .
this is because our current work is based on the self - similar assumption which does not hold in the innermost transonic region of the accretion flow where most of the radiation originates . before examining in detail the effects of the outflow on the dynamics of the inflow
, we first check the effects of the discrepancy of the radial velocity between the outflow and the inflow ( indicated by @xmath98 ) .
consistent with xie & yuan ( 2008 ) , we find that for relatively weak outflows ( e.g. , @xmath99 ) and reasonable values of @xmath98 , the effects are of minor importance .
thus for the discussions below , we set @xmath100 .
+ we present in fig .
[ f2 ] the effects of angular momentum discrepancy between the inflow and the outflow .
we set @xmath101 and @xmath102 .
parameter @xmath103 means @xmath104 , which corresponds to a relatively strong outflow ( blandford & begelman 1999 ) .
the dotted , solid and long - dashed lines correspond to @xmath105 and @xmath106 , respectively .
parameter @xmath107 means that the outflow helps to remove angular momentum from the inflow .
the accretion flow has distinctive properties between @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
when @xmath42 is below unity , the effects of the large - scale magnetic field can be neglected . as @xmath110 increases from @xmath111 to @xmath106
, we can see from fig .
[ f2 ] that the radial and angular velocities increase while the temperature decreases .
we can understand these results in the following way . from eq .
( [ energy3 ] ) , we see that @xmath93 and @xmath94 will increase or decrease together ( note the magnetic terms are negligible ) .
if both of them would decrease , from eq .
( 24 ) we know that @xmath86 must increase ; while this is in conflict with what eq .
( 25 ) implies if @xmath110 increases .
thus both @xmath93 and @xmath94 , i.e. , the radial and angular velocities , must increase when @xmath110 increases , and the temperature decreases .
physically , the increase of the radial velocity is explained by the decrease in the gas pressure gradient force with the decreasing temperature .
we note that these self - similar results are consistent with the global solutions of xie & yuan ( 2008 ) .
we can understand the results for @xmath109 in a similar way , except that in this case the magnetic force ( magnetic pressure and stress forces ) exceeds the gas pressure gradient force .
the critical value of @xmath42 corresponds to the balance between the forces of gas pressure and magnetic pressure , and the value is related to the strength of the outflow . for cases considered here ( @xmath112 ) , this critical value is @xmath113 . from the upper - right panel of fig .
[ f2 ] , we see that the accretion flow will be super - keplerian when the toroidal magnetic field is very strong ( i.e. , @xmath109 ) . this is because the strong magnetic stress force serves as a centripetal force .
figure [ f3 ] shows the case when the specific internal energy of the outflow is different from that of the inflow .
we take parameters @xmath114 and @xmath115 , as before . unlike the case shown in fig .
[ f2 ] , here we set @xmath116 .
the dotted , solid and long - dashed lines correspond to @xmath117 and @xmath106 , respectively .
the outflow then plays an extra cooling role for the inflow if its specific internal energy is higher than that of the inflow ( @xmath118 ) , or a heating role otherwise .
we can see from the figure that for the case of a weak magnetic field ( @xmath119 ) , when @xmath120 increases from @xmath111 to @xmath106 , the temperature ( @xmath86 ) and radial velocity of the inflow decrease while the angular velocity increases .
the reason is as follows . from eq .
( [ phimon3 ] ) we know @xmath93 and @xmath86 must increase or decrease together . if both would increase with increasing @xmath120 , from eq .
( [ rmon3 ] ) we know that @xmath94 must decrease , which is in conflict with eq .
( [ energy3 ] ) .
the results of a strong magnetic field ( @xmath121 ) can be understood in a similar way . unlike the case without outflows ( fig .
[ f1 ] ) , we find from figs .
[ f2 ] & [ f3 ] that , when the toroidal component of the large - scale magnetic field is strong ( e.g. , @xmath122 ) , the accretion flow is super - keplerian .
this is because , for the cases of strong outflows ( @xmath123 ) considered in figs .
[ f2 ] & [ f3 ] , the `` centrifugal force '' ( gradient of the gas plus magnetic pressure ) is much weaker than in the case without outflows ( fig .
[ f1 ] ) ; while the `` centripetal force '' ( magnetic stress force ) does not vary too much .
finally , we note that in the limits of @xmath124 , @xmath125 and @xmath126 , i.e. , the accretion flow is radiatively efficient , and is devoid of outflows and magnetic fields , our equations will lead to the solution with @xmath127 , @xmath128 and @xmath129 , which corresponds to a standard thin disc , as expected .
numerical mhd simulations show that both large - scale ordered magnetic fields and outflows exist in the inner regions of an adaf . in this paper
, we have investigated their influences on the dynamics of the accretion flow in a self - similar approach .
we assume that in addition to the stochastic component , the magnetic field has a strong large - scale ordered component .
the magnetic pressure and stress forces associated with the large - scale field thus will affect the dynamics of the accretion flow .
we adopt the conventional @xmath32 description to mimic the angular momentum and heating effects associated with the tangled magnetic field .
we find that when the large - scale magnetic field gets stronger , the radial and angular velocities of the accretion flow increase , while the temperature decreases . the large - scale field will be more important than the turbulent - viscosity in transferring angular momentum even when the field is moderately strong ( fig .
[ f1 ] ) .
we have obtained the self - similar solutions with both large - scale magnetic fields and outflows . the outflow does not only change the radial profile of the mass accretion rate , but is also able to take away angular momentum and energy from the inflow .
we parameterize the physical properties of the outflow , namely its radial velocity , specific angular momentum and specific internal energy .
we find that when the specific angular momentum of the outflow increases , the temperature of the inflow decreases , while the radial and angular velocities increase ( decrease ) when the magnetic field is weak ( strong ) ( fig .
[ f2 ] ) . when the specific internal energy of the outflow increases , the temperature and radial velocity of the inflow decrease , while the angular velocity increases ( decreases ) when the large - scale magnetic field is weak ( strong ) ( fig . [ f3 ] ) . when both outflows and large - scale magnetic fields are present , we find that the inflow could be super - keplerian if the field is very strong .
the decrease in temperature of the inflow in presence of large - scale magnetic fields and/or outflows could explain a puzzle that the predicted temperature of hot accretion flows is higher than that obtained from fitting the observational data .
we are grateful for a discussion with ramesh narayan .
we thank the anonymous referee for his / her helpful suggestions and careful reading , which improve the manuscript .
this work was supported in part by the natural science foundation of china ( grants 10773024 , 10833002 , 10821302 , and 10825314 ) , one - hundred - talent program of chinese academy of sciences , and the national basic research program of china ( 2009cb824800 ) .
abbassi , s. , ghanbari , j. , & najjar , s. 2008 , mnras , 388 , 663 abramowicz , m. a. , chen , x. , kato , s. , lasota j .-
p . , & regev , o. 1995 , apj , 438 , l37 akizuki , c. , & fukue , j. 2006 , pasj , 58 , 469 blandford , r. d. , & begelman , m. c. 1999 , mnras , 303 , l1 blandford , r. d. , & payne , d. g. 1982 , mnras , 199 , 883 balbus , s. , & hawley , j. f. 1991 , apj , 376 , 214 balbus , s. , & hawley , j. f. 1998 , rvmp , 70 , 1 beckwith , k. , hawley , j. f. , & krolik , j. h. 2008 , apj , 678 , 1180 de villiers , j .-
p . , hawley , j. f. , & krolik , j. h. 2003 , apj , 599 , 1238 fiege , j. d. , & henriksen , r. n. 1996 , mnras , 281 , 1005 hirose , s. , krolik , j. h. , de villiers , j. p. , & hawley , j. f. 2004 , apj , 606 , 1083 hirose , s. , krolik , j. & stone , j. 2006 , apj , 640 , 901 henriksen , r. n. , & valls - gabaud , d. 1994 , mnras , 266 , 681 ho , l. 2008 , ara&a , in press ( arxiv:0803.2268 ) igumenshchev , i. v. & abramowicz , m. a. 1999 , mnras , 303 , 309 kato , s. , fukue , j. , & mineshige , s. , 1998 , black hole accretion disks , kyoto univ .
press , kyoto lovelace , r. v. e. , romanova , m. m. , & newman , w. i. 1994 , apj , 437 , 136l machida , m. , hayashi , m. r. , & matsumoto , r. 2000 , apj , 532 , l67 machida , m. , nakamura , k. e. , & matsumoto , r. 2006 , pasj , 58 , 193 mouschovias , t. ch . , &
paleologou , e. v. 1980 , apj , 237 , 877 narayan , r. 2005 , apss , 300 , 177 narayan , r. , mahadevan , r. , & quataert , e. 1998 , in `` theory of black hole accertion discs '' , eds .
abramowicz , g. bjornsson , j. e. pringle , cambridge univ .
press , cambridge , p. 148
narayan , r. , & mcclintock , j. e. 2008 , in `` jean - pierre lasota , x - ray binaries , accretion disks and compact stars '' new astronomy reviews , eds .
m.a . abramowicz and o.
straub ( elsevier , 2008 ) .
arxiv:0803.0322 narayan , r. , & yi , i. 1994 , apj , 428 , l13 narayan , r. , & yi , i. 1995 , apj , 452 , 710 oda , h. , machida , m. , nakamura , k. e. , & matsumoto , r. 2007 , pasj , 59 , 457 stone , j. m. , & norman , m. l. 1994 , apj , 433 , 746 stone , j. m. , & pringle , j. e. 2001 , mnras , 322 , 461 stone , j. m. , pringle , j. e. , & begelman , m. c. 1999 , mnras , 310 , 1002 xie , f. g. , & yuan , f. 2008 , apj , 681 , 499 yuan , f. 2001 , mnras , 324 , 119 yuan , f. 2003 , apj , 594 , l99 yuan , f. 2007 , in `` the central engine of active galactic nuclei '' , asp conference series , vol .
373 , eds .
luis c. ho and jian - min wang , p.95 yuan , f. , quataert , e. , & narayan , r. 2003 , apj , 598 , 301 yuan , f. , & zdziarski , a. a. 2004 , mnras , 354 , 953 zdziarski , a. a. , & gierliski , m. 2004 , pthps , 155 , 99 zhang , d. , & dai , z. g. 2008 , mnras , 388 , 1409 | observations and numerical magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) simulations indicate the existence of outflows and ordered large - scale magnetic fields in the inner region of hot accretion flows . in this paper
we present the self - similar solutions for advection - dominated accretion flows ( adafs ) with outflows and ordered magnetic fields . stimulated by numerical simulations , we assume that the magnetic field has a strong toroidal component and a vertical component in addition to a stochastic component .
we obtain the self - similar solutions to the equations describing the magnetized adafs , taking into account the dynamical effects of the outflow .
we compare the results with the canonical adafs and find that the dynamical properties of adafs such as radial velocity , angular velocity and temperature can be significantly changed in the presence of ordered magnetic fields and outflows .
the stronger the magnetic field is , the lower the temperature of the accretion flow will be , and the faster the flow rotates .
the relevance to observations is briefly discussed .
accretion , accretion discs magnetohydrodynamics : mhd ism : jets and outflow black hole physics |
large scale magnetic fields are widespread in the universe . from galaxies to clusters of galaxies
coherent magnetic fields are detected , with intensities that range from @xmath3gauss to tenth of @xmath3gauss .
our galaxy as well as nearby galaxies show magnetic fields coherent on the scale of the whole structure , while in galaxy clusters the coherent length is much less than the cluster s size @xcite . a remarkable fact recently discovered by observations , is that high redshift galaxies also posses coherent fields with the same intensitis as present day galaxies @xcite .
this result challenges the generally accepted mechanism of magnetogenesis , namely the amplification of a primordial field of @xmath4 gauss by a mean field dynamo @xcite acting during a time of the order of the age of the structure : either the primordial fields are more intense so the galactic dynamo saturates in a shorter time , or the dynamo does not work as it is currently thought .
it is hoped that future observations of high redshift environments will shed more light on the features of primordial magnetic fields @xcite . in view of the lack of success in finding a primordial mechanism for magnetogenesis that produces a sufficiently intense field , either to feed an amplifying mechanism , or to directly explain the observations ( see refs .
@xcite as recent reviews ) , researchers began to delve on magnetohydrodynamical effects that could compensate the tremendous dilution of the field due to flux conservation during the expansion of the universe . among the possibilities
there is primordial turbulence @xcite .
possible scenarios for it are the reheating epoch , the phase transitions ( at least the electroweak one ) and possibly the epoch of reionization , all dominated by out of equilibrium processes .
a key ingredient to produce stable , large scale magnetic fields in three - dimensional mhd turbulence , is the transfer of magnetic helicity from small scales to large scales , at constant flux @xcite ( see also ref . @xcite and references therein ) .
magnetic helicity , @xmath5 , is defined as the volume integral of the scalar product of the magnetic field @xmath6 with the vector potential @xmath7 @xcite . in three dimensions , and in the absence of ohmic dissipation , it is a conserved quantity that accounts for the non - trivial topological properties of the magnetic field @xcite , such as the twists and links of the field lines . unlike the energy that performs a natural , direct cascade , i.e. , from large scales toward small ones where it is dissipated , magnetic helicity has the remarkable property of _ inverse cascading _ , that is , magnetic helicity stored in small scales evolves toward larger scales @xcite .
the fact that magnetic energy and magnetic helicity spectra are dimensionally related as @xmath8 @xcite produces a dragging of the former toward large scales , thus enabling the field to re - organize coherently at large scales .
it must be stressed that in a cosmological context , the inverse cascade mentioned above operates on scales of the order of the particle horizon or smaller .
this is due to the fact that turbulence is a causal phenomenon .
magnetic helicity on the other hand can be induced at any scale , the topology of the fields then remains frozen if the scales are super - horizon and if there is no resistive decay .
for subhorizon scales it is a sufficient condition for its conservation that the conductivity of the plasma be infinite @xcite .
the interpretation of @xmath5 as the number of twists and links must be considered with care because from its very definition it is clear that @xmath5 is gauge dependent . in their seminal work ,
berger and field @xcite proved that if the field lines do not cross the boundaries of the volume of integration , i.e. , the field lines close inside the considered volume , then @xmath5 as defined _ is _ a gauge invariant quantity .
these authors also addressed the case of open field lines , and wrote down a definition of gauge invariant magnetic helicity based on the difference of two such quantities for field configurations that have the same extension outside the considered volume . in this case the quantity obtained can be interpreted as the numbers of links inside the volume . in general
it is not difficult to find early universe mechanisms that produce magnetic fields endowed with magnetic helicity : generation of helical magnetic fields has been already addressed in the framework of electroweak baryogenesis @xcite and of leptogenesis @xcite .
the main problem is still in the low intensities obtained in more or less realistic scenarios .
the magnetic fields we consider in this work are induced by stochastic currents of scalar charges created gravitationally during the transition inflation - reheating @xcite ( see @xcite for more details ) , and such field configuration is of open lines . in the light of the analysis of berger and field , we shall discuss a criterion by which the result obtained can be considered as gauge invariant .
the fields induced are random , the mean value of the magnetic helicity is zero , but not the corresponding rms deviation .
we assume that those fields are weak enough to neglect their backreaction on the source currents , and show that the rms magnetic helicity can be written as the sum of four sqed feynman graphs , one of them representing the mean value of @xmath0 and consequently identically null .
the remaining three add to a non null value .
we compute the value of the helicity for large scales and find that the number density of links scales with the distance @xmath9 from a given point as @xmath10 , which means that their fractal dimension is @xmath11 this number density takes into account defects due to both regular and random fields .
we also calculate the value of @xmath0 due to regular fields on a large scale . in this case the number density scales as @xmath12 , the corresponding fractal dimension being @xmath2 . using the relation @xmath13 ,
we compare the associated helical intensity to the one obtained by computing directly the correlation function of the magnetic field at the same scale @xmath14 .
we find that both expressions coincide , which means that the fields generated by the considered mechanism are indeed helical .
we estimate the intensity of those smooth fields on a galactic scale , finding an intensity too small to seed the dynamo .
we finally address the evolution of fields generated at scales of the order of the particle horizon at the end of reheating , through the inverse cascade of magnetic helicity mechanism , until matter - radiation equilibrium .
this evolution is based on the assumption that during radiation dominance the plasma is in a ( mild ) turbulent state .
we find that the number density of magnetic links scales as @xmath15 , the corresponding fractal dimension then being @xmath16 .
the field intensity as well as the scale of coherence are in a range that could have and impact on the process of structure formation @xcite .
we work with signature @xmath17 and with natural units , i.e. , @xmath18 , @xmath19 .
we use the hubble constant during inflation , @xmath20 , which we assume constant , to give dimensions to the different quantities , i.e. we consider spacetime coordinates @xmath21 = h^{-1}$ ] , lagrangian density @xmath22 = h^{4}$ ] , four vector potential @xmath23 = h$ ] , field tensor @xmath24 = h^{2}$ ] , scalar field @xmath25=h$ ] .
the paper is organized as follows : section [ sed ] contains a brief description of scalar electrodynamics in curved spacetime . in section [ mh ]
we define magnetic helicity and describe briefly its main properties . in section [ mhrf ]
we develope the formalism to study magnetic helicity of random fields and estimate its rms value in different scenarios : in subsection [ demh ] we compute the sqed feynman graphs that describe the magnetic helicity two - point correlation function . in subsection [ dim ] we provide some physical quantities relevant for our study . in subsection [ hm - tir ]
we describe the transition inflation - reheating and quote some useful formulae for our work . in subsection [ gd ]
we apply the analysis of berger and field to our fields and show the gauge invariance of our results . in subsection [ mhls ]
we calculte the magnetic helicity rms value on large scales , and compute the density and fractal dimension of the distribution of defects . in subsection [ hmgal ]
we compute the rms value of magnetic helicity due to solely smooth fields , and find that the fields induced by the mechanism considered in this work are completely helical , but very weak .
finally in subsection [ hm - ss ] we analyze the evolution of fields induced on scales of the order of the horizon at reheating along radiation dominance . by considering conservation of magnetic helicity and assuming full inverse cascade is operative
, we find at decoupling a magnetic field of intensity and coherence that could impact on the process of structure formation .
in section [ dc ] we sumarize and discuss our results .
we leave details of the calculations to the appendices .
in curved spacetime the action for a charged scalar field coupled to the electromagnetic field is given by @xmath26 \label{a-1}\ ] ] with the lagrangian density @xmath27 \label{a-2}\ ] ] with @xmath28 being the metric tensor that for a spatially flat friedmann - robertson - walker spacetime reads @xmath29 , @xmath30 the covariant derivative , @xmath31 the scalar curvature , @xmath32 the coupling constant of the scalar field to the curvature and @xmath33 the electromagnetic field tensor . due to the conformal invariance of the electromagnetic field in the spatially flat frw universe , it is convenient to work with conformal time , defined as @xmath34 , with @xmath35 being the cosmological ( or physical ) time .
the metric tensor then reads @xmath36 , with @xmath37 .
we shall be dealing with fields in inflation , reheating and radiation dominance .
in those epochs the scale factors in physical time are respectively @xmath38 , @xmath39 and @xmath40 , while in dimensionless conformal time , @xmath41 they read @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 . we note that @xmath45 corresponds to the end of inflation ( in that epoch @xmath46 ) and consequently the scale factor at that moment is @xmath47 .
we rescale the fields according to @xmath48 which means that @xmath49 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 are dimensionless . working with the coulomb gauge , @xmath52 ( considering also @xmath53 ) ,
we obtain after taking variations of action ( [ a-1 ] ) the following evolution equations for the scaled scalar and electromagnetic fields @xmath54@xmath55 with @xmath56 the electric current due to the scalar field , given by @xmath57 \label{a-7}\ ] ] which , writing the complex field in term of real fields as @xmath58 , can be expressed as @xmath59 \label{a-7b}\ ] ] in a first approximation we consider that the induced fields @xmath60 are weak enough to discard their coupling to the scalar field given by the last two terms in eq .
( [ a-5 ] ) and the last term in eq .
( [ a-6 ] ) . also , we consider minimal coupling of scalar fields to gravity , for it will produce maximal particle creation @xcite .
( [ a-5 ] ) then turns into the klein - gordon equation for a free field in frw universe , @xmath61 \varphi = 0 \label{a-5b}\ ] ] whose solutions are given in appendix [ apa ] . for a realistic evolution of @xmath62 dissipative effects
must be taken into account .
this we do by assuming that ohm s law in its usual form , @xmath63 , is valid . in the lack of a clear knowledge about the early universe plasma
, we assume a traditional form for the electric conductivity considered in the literature , namely , that it is proportional to the plasma temperature , i.e. , @xmath64 , with @xmath65 for a relativistic plasma .
this assumption amounts to adding to the l.h.s . of eq .
( [ a-6 ] ) a term of the form @xmath66 , and so the evolution equation for @xmath67 reads @xmath68 \mathcal{a}_{i}=\mathcal{j}_{i}\label{a-8}\ ] ] by taking curl of this equation we obtain the one corresponding to the magnetic field , i.e. @xmath68 \mathcal{b}_{i}=\epsilon_{ijk}\partial _
{ j}\mathcal{j}_{k } \label{a-9}\ ] ] where @xmath69 is the levi - civita tensor density .
( [ a-8 ] ) and ( [ a-9 ] ) can be readily integrated to give the fields in terms of their sources , i.e. @xmath70 @xmath71 with @xmath72 the solution of ( see appendix [ apb ] ) @xmath73g_{ret}\left ( \bar{x},\bar{s},\eta , \tau \right ) = \delta \left ( \bar{x}-\bar{s}\right ) \delta \left ( \eta -\tau \right ) \label{a-12}\ ] ] the electric currents we are considering consist of scalar charges created due to the change of the universe s geometry during the transition inflation - reheating .
this change makes the scalar field vacuum state during inflation to correspond to a particle state in the subsequent phase @xcite .
this process of `` particle creation '' is an out - of - equilibrium one , the resulting particle currents being stochastic . in the case of a charged field
the mean value of the electric current is zero , but not its rms deviation , which sources a random magnetic field , whose magnetic helicity we are going to compute .
classically , magnetic helicity is defined as the volume integral of the scalar product between magnetic field and magnetic vector potencial @xcite , i.e. @xmath74 which in view of the dimensions of @xmath75 and @xmath76 it is already a dimensionlessl quantity . as stated in the introduction , it is a measure of the non - trivial topology of the magnetic field inside the volume @xmath77 , or in other words , eq .
( [ b-1 ] ) represents the number of twists and links of the field lines inside @xmath77 .
this interpretation , however , must be considered with care , because @xmath78 is not gauge invariant unless the boundaries of the volume of integration are not intersected by @xmath79-lines , i.e. the field lines close inside @xmath77 . on the other hand
if the magnetic flux across the boundaries of @xmath77 is not zero , as in our case , it is still possible to define a gauge invariant measure of the links of the field inside @xmath77 @xcite by considering the difference between two field configurations that coincide outside @xmath77 .
we shall discuss this issue in a following paragraph . considering the conformal transformation of the fields and coordinates given by eq .
( [ a-4 ] ) and writing the physical volume as @xmath80 , eq .
( [ b-1 ] ) can be written as @xmath81 where we see that this is not diluted by the expansion , i.e. , expansion does not erase or create the topology of the field , as it is to be expected . in classical magnetohydrodynamics
@xmath78 is one of the ideal invariants , i.e. it is a conserved quantity in the absense of ohmic dissipation @xcite .
this means that magnetic helicity can not be created or destroyed by turbulence or non - dissipative evolution , being then a property of the magnetic field created at its birth . unlike other ideally conserved quantities in 3-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics ,
magnetic helicity performs an _ inverse cascade _ @xcite .
this means that instead of travelling towards small scales ( large wavenumber ) where it would be dissipated , it makes its way toward large scales ( small wavenumbers ) , carrying with it a bit of magnetic energy .
mathematically , this is expressed by the spectral relation quoted above , i.e. , @xmath82 . in a framework of decaying turbulence ( that could exist at the earliest epochs of the universe ) , there would be a self - organization of the magnetic field at large scales , with the total energy contained in the considered volume decaying as @xmath83 and coherence length increasing as @xmath84 @xcite . for primordial magnetogenesis
this fact can be of great help in obtaining stronger fields than the ones found up to now to seed subsequent amplifying mechanisms , or even to directly explain the observations .
but on the other hand , the conservation of @xmath85 crucially constraints the operation of further amplifying mechanisms such as the mean field dynamo @xcite .
as we are dealing with random fields , generated from stochastic quantum electric currents whose mean value is zero , we must evaluate a rms value of the helicity by calculating a two - point correlation function given by @xmath86 where angle brackets denote stochastic and quantum average .
we shall consider the volume of integration @xmath87 as the commoving space occupied by the structure of interest ( i.e. , a galaxy , a cluster , particle horizon at a certain epoch , etc . ) .
we begin by writing @xmath88\ ] ] where @xmath89 with @xmath90 to avoid cumbersome notation , repeated momenta other than @xmath15 are assumed to be integrated over .
the volume integrals can be readily evaluated , giving @xmath91 the different fields in ( [ c-3 ] ) can be written as @xmath92 and @xmath93 ( integration in @xmath94 is understood ) .
the electric currents @xmath95 can be expressed in terms of the scalar fields as @xmath96 gathering all expressions , @xmath97 is written as @xmath98 after integrating out the time delta functions the magnetic helicity correlation function spectrum reads @xmath99 each scalar field can be decomposed in its positive and negative frequency components , that respectively include the annihilation and the creation operator , namely @xmath100 when replacing this decomposition in expression ( [ c-9 ] ) it can be seen that in each bracket the only terms that contribute to the mean value are @xmath101 which in the end combine to form the scalar positive frequency operator , @xmath102 the first term on the r.h.s . of expression ( [ c-11 ] ) gives @xmath103 while the second term gives @xmath104 when performing the products of the two brackets we obtain nine terms that can be represented by the following graphs ( full lines indicate scalar fields , dotted lines vector potential and dashed lines magnetic fields ) . , width=240 ] , width=240 ] , width=240 ] observe that of the two vertices of scalar electrodynamics , only one contributes to these graphs : the one similar to the qed vertex .
this is so because we disregarded the backreaction of @xmath105 on the scalar fields .
observe also that the first graph , being the product of two mean values , vanishes identically .
the multiplicity of the `` square '' graph is 4 , of the `` cross '' diagram is 2 and of the `` two - bubble '' figure is also 2 . after replacing the expressions for the scalar positive frequency operators and solving all the dirac delta functions we obtain a @xmath106 , which means that the momentum of the electromagnetic field is conserved .
writing each graph as @xmath107 we have the following expressions for the prefactor of the non - null graphs : @xmath108 \left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}_{1}\times \bar{q}_{2}^{\prime } \right ) \right ] \label{c-15 } \\ & & \phi \left ( \bar{q}_{1},\tau _ { 1}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( -\bar{q}_{1},\tau _ { 2}^{\prime } \right ) \phi \left ( \bar{\kappa}-\bar{q}_{1},\tau_{2}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( \bar{q}_{1}-\bar{\kappa},\tau _ { 1}^{\prime}\right ) \notag \\ & & \phi \left ( \bar{p}-\bar{q}_{1},\tau _ { 1}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( \bar{q}_{1}-\bar{p},\tau _ { 2}\right ) \phi \left ( \bar{q}_{2}^{\prime } , \tau_{1}^{\prime } \right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( -\bar{q}_{2},\tau _ { 2}^{\prime}\right ) , \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the square graph , which vanishes when the momenta integrals are peformed .
\left [ \left ( \bar{p}-\bar{q}_{3}\right ) \cdot \left ( \bar{\kappa}\times \bar{q}_{1}\right ) -2\bar{q}_{1}\cdot \left ( \bar{p}\times \bar{q}_{3}\right ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \phi \left ( \bar{q}_{1},\tau _ { 1}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( -\bar{q}_{1},\tau _ { 2}^{\prime } \right ) \phi \left ( \bar{q}_{3},\tau _ { 2}\right)\phi ^{\ast } \left ( -\bar{q}_{3},\tau _ { 1}^{\prime } \right ) \label{c-16 } \\ & & \phi \left ( \bar{p}-\bar{q}_{1},\tau _ { 1}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( \bar{q}_{1}-\bar{p},\tau _ { 1}^{\prime } \right ) \phi \left ( \bar{\kappa}-\bar{p}-\bar{q}_{3},\tau _ { 2}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( -\bar{\kappa}+\bar{p}+ \bar{q}_{3},\tau _ { 2}^{\prime } \right ) \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the `` cross '' diagram and @xmath110 ^{2 } \label{c-17 } \\ & & \phi \left ( \bar{q}_{1},\tau _ { 1}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( -\bar{q } _ { 1},\tau _ { 1}^{\prime } \right ) \phi \left ( \bar{q}_{3},\tau _ { 2}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( -\bar{q}_{3},\tau _ { 2}^{\prime } \right ) \notag \\ & & \phi \left ( \bar{p}-\bar{q}_{1},\tau _ { 1}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( \bar{q } _ { 1}-\bar{p},\tau _ { 1}^{\prime } \right ) \phi \left ( \bar{\kappa}-\bar{p}- \bar{q}_{3},\tau _ { 2}\right ) \phi ^{\ast } \left ( p+\bar{q}_{3}-\bar{\kappa } , \tau _ { 2}^{\prime }
\right ) \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the `` two bubbles '' figure .
it is clear that for a given volume , the flux of magnetic field across its boundary is not zero ; in other words , the boundary of @xmath87 is not a magnetic surface . in principle
, this fact renders @xmath78 as defined in ( [ b-1 ] ) , a gauge dependent quantity .
as stated above , berger and field @xcite gave a gauge - independent measure of magnetic helicity suitable for this situation , based on the difference between the magnetic helicities of two field configurations that have a common extension outside the considered volume .
the only constraint that definition must satisfy is that the sources of the fields must be bounded in order to guarantee that the surface at infinity is a magnetic one , which is equivalent to say that the magnetic field at infinity must vanish .
the fact that in our model @xmath111 at infinity @xcite allows us to consider the boundary at infinity as a magnetic surface , in spite of the fact that the stochastic currents exist in the whole space ( cosmological particle creation is not restricted to the particle horizon @xcite ) .
below , in section [ gd ] we discuss how to apply berger s criterion to our fields . in this subsection we provide some ( dimensional ) quantities that will be used later to obtain concrete values of magnetic intensities .
we are interested in two scales : one is large , e.g. , of the order of the galactic commoving scale ( or larger ) for which , due to the fact that it remains outside the particle horizon during most of radiation dominance , we can consider diffusive evolution of the magnetic field .
the other is of the order of the horizon at reheating , where the magnetic field may be subjected to an inverse cascade of magnetic helicity if the medium is turbulent . in view of the fact that reheating happens in a very short period of time
, we can consider that during it the particle horizon remains practically constant and equal to the one in inflation , i.e. , @xmath112 .
when the universe enters into the radiation dominated regime , the horizon grows as @xmath113 , a fact that in terms of the temperatures can be expressed as @xmath114 . in the presence of turbulence ,
the viscous dissipation scale is usually estimated as @xmath115 with @xmath116 the reynolds number . according to ref .
@xcite , during reheating can be taken as @xmath117 and smaller for later epochs @xcite .
concerning the galactic size we have that today a galactic commoving scale ( i.e. , a not - collapsed scale that contains all the matter of a milky way - like galaxy ) is @xmath118 mpc . for the hubble constant during inflation we consider @xmath119 ; the mass of the scalar field can be taken as @xmath120 ; we also have @xmath121 cm ; the electric conductivity takes the usual form considered in the literature , @xmath122 ^{1/4}\simeq 1.37~\times 10^{19/2}gev$ ] , @xmath123 , where we considered @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
finally , the temperature at matter - radiation equilibrium can be taken as @xmath126 ev .
thus the different quantities that appear in the formulae lay in te intervals @xmath127 when the transition from inflation to reheating occurs , the vacuum state of the fields during inflation turns into a particle state @xcite .
mathematically , this means that the positive frequency modes of the field in the inflationary epoch can be expressed as a linear combination of positive and negative frequency modes in reheating . as we are dealing with a charged scalar field , electric charges will appear and , as there are equal numbers of positive and negative carriers the mean value of the induced electric current is zero , but not its rms deviation , which will source the stochastic magnetic field .
therefore in order to evaluate @xmath128 we express the @xmath129 fields of inflation in terms of the ones in reheating by the usual bogoliubov transformation @xcite : @xmath130@xmath131 and @xmath132 being the bogoliubov coefficients satisfying the normalization condition @xmath133 .
the different field products then read @xmath134 \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term represents the vacuum - to - vacuum transition , the second and third account for a mixing of positive and negative frequency modes , while the fourth , proportional to @xmath135 , is due to solely the negative frequency modes , i.e. to the transition vacuum to particle state .
as the main contribution comes from this term from now on we consider only it . in a non - instantaneous transition
the creation of small scale modes depends on the details of the transition , while for superhorizon modes details of the transition do not matter . for subhorizon modes we have
@xcite @xmath136 while for @xmath137 this coefficient reads ( see appendix [ apa ] ) @xmath138 @xmath139 we see that the contribution of subhorizon modes to the magnetic helicity correlation function will be suppressed relative to the one of superhorizon ones . however , according to the results of ref .
@xcite subhorizon fluctuations are responsible for a mildly turbulent flow on scales of the order of the horizon size , with reynolds numbers @xmath140 . an important comment about the infrared limit in expr .
( [ d-4a ] ) is in order .
it is clear that that expression blows out for @xmath141 .
this is due to the approximations made to solve klein - gordon equation during reheating . to give a physical lower limit
we must consider the largest homogenous patch created during inflation as the largest possible scale , which according to refs .
@xcite can be considered as about 10 times the horizon during inflation . in principle
, the dependence of the rms value of @xmath85 on the gauge could be analised by adding to @xmath142 a term of the form @xmath143 to the r.h.s . of expression [ c-5 ]
, @xmath144 being an arbitrary scalar function .
then in @xmath145 there will appear a term proportional to @xmath146 \left[\mathcal{b}_j\left(\bar\kappa^{\prime } - \bar p^{\prime},\eta^{\prime}\right ) p^{\prime j}\right]$ ] that cancels indentically when the angular integrals are performed .
this means that only `` on average '' our result is gauge invariant .
if we consider a gauge term like @xmath147 , with @xmath148 an arbitrary magnetic correlation function , generally it will satisfy that @xmath149 , and consequently the associated magnetic helicity will not be statistically gauge independent
. we then reason according to berger and field as follows . for any volume
@xmath87 we were interested in ( a galaxy , a galaxy cluster , horizon at a certain epoch , etc ) , its surrounding region corresponds to the rest of the embedding space whose characteristic scale is very much larger than @xmath150 .
if the magnetic correlation tends to zero from a certain scale on , i.e. , if for @xmath151 it is proportional to a power of @xmath15 , then for an observer inside @xmath87 the field outside is statistically equivalent to a vanishing field .
consequently we could interpret @xmath152 as the difference between two magnetic field configurations : one being the calculated through the diagrams above , and the other a null configuration . to quantify this assertion
, we begin by noting that the trace of the magnetic field correlation function is given by @xmath153 where we again assume integration over @xmath154 and over repeated momenta other than @xmath15 . using again decomposition ( [ c-10 ] ) for the scalar fields we have that from each mean value the only non - null contribution is @xmath155 the integration of the delta functions in eq .
( [ g-1 ] ) produce again a @xmath156 , i.e. momentum conservation . writing the trace of the magnetic field correlation as @xmath157
we obtain the following expression for the prefactor for trace of the magnetic field correlation function @xmath158 ^ 2 \phi\left(\bar q_1,\tau_1\right)\phi^{\ast}\left(-\bar q_1,\tau_2\right ) \phi\left(\bar\kappa - \bar q_1,\tau_1\right)\phi^{\ast}\left(\bar q_1-\bar\kappa , \tau_2\right ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] as above , for any considered volume @xmath87 we are interested in , its surrounding region , @xmath159 corresponds to the rest of the embedding space and satisfies @xmath160 .
the magnetic field configuration in those regions corresponds to superhorizon modes whose evolution is in general diffusive . therefore to estimate the rms magnetic intensity at a certain time on a comoving scale @xmath161 we use expressions ( [ apb-4 ] ) for the retarded propagators , ( [ apa-7b ] ) for the modes and ( [ d-4a ] ) for the bogoliubov coefficients .
we then write @xmath162}{\left(1+\tau/2\right)^2 } \frac{\left[1-e^{-\sigma_0\left(\eta^{\prime } - \tau^{\prime}\right)/h}\right]}{\left(1 + \tau^{\prime}/2\right)^2}\label{g-4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath163 is the lifetime of the stochastic electric current . as @xmath164
, it can be neglected in the denominator of each of the time integrals , which can then be estimated as @xmath165 \simeq \tau_f \left [ 1 + e^{-\sigma_0\eta / h}\right]\ ] ] we can estimate the order of magnitude of the integral in the momenta by counting powers . in the numerator we have 5 powers of @xmath15 and 5 powers of @xmath166 ( three from the integration meassure and two from the square of the cross product ) . in the denominator
there are 3 powers of @xmath166 and 3 powers of @xmath15 .
consequently the overall contribution of the integrals in the momenta is a factor @xmath167 . to estimate their numerical value we must filter out the length scales smaller than those corresponding to @xmath168 because they oscillate inside @xmath159 , and so the main contribution from the momentum integrals is @xmath169 .
finally , taking the coincidence limit @xmath170 we have @xmath171 ^ 2\kappa_s^4\label{g-5}\ ] ] thus we see that for @xmath172 , i.e. , for large volumes as those outside the considered structure , the magnetic field vanishes and so does their associated magnetic helicity
. therefore we can interpret our expression for the rms value of the magnetic helicity in a given volume @xmath87 in the spirit of the work by berger and field , as the substraction of two magnetic configurations , one of them being effectively zero . in this section
we evaluate the magnetic helicity on large scales due to both smooth and fluctuating fields on that scale . from the form of the bogoliubov coefficients , eqs .
( [ d-3a])-([d-5a ] ) we see that the main contribution is due to the modes with @xmath173 , i.e. , eq .
( [ d-4a ] ) . in this case
the modes are given by eq .
( [ apa-7b ] ) , whereby @xmath174\right\ } } { \left ( 1+\tau /2\right)\left ( 1+\tau^{\prime } /2\right)}\label{h-1}\ ] ] we are interested in the value of the magnetic helicity at present time . in this limit , and for small momenta , the retarded propagators are given by eq .
( [ apb-5 ] ) , namely @xmath175 .
the lifetime of the electric currents was calculated in ref .
@xcite in physical time ( see eq . ( 4.9 ) of that reference ) . in conformal ( dimensionless )
time it reads @xmath176 and from the reference mentioned just above we have @xmath177^{1/6}}{\left[\left(3/2\right)\left(h / m\right)^3\tau_0 ^ 2 + \left ( 9/16\right)^4 \right]^{1/3}}\label{h-2}\ ] ] with @xmath178 the duration of the transition inflation - reheating and where we considered that @xmath179 around that transition .
considering the values for @xmath180 quoted in section [ dim ] and the smallest possible value for @xmath178 , namely the planck time , it is seen that @xmath181 , and for @xmath173 expr .
( [ h-2 ] ) gives @xmath182 observe that @xmath183 .
this fact allows us to neglect @xmath184 in front of 1 in expr .
( [ h-1 ] ) reducing the time integrals in each of the non - trivial graph to simply @xmath185 .
this simplification permits to write the sum @xmath186 as @xmath187\label{h-4}\ ] ] with @xmath188 the factor @xmath189 $ ] was solved in appendix [ apc ] giving the non - null result @xmath189= \left\{\bar\kappa\cdot \left[\bar q\times\left(\bar q_1 + \bar q_3\right)\right]\right\}^2 $ ] , with @xmath190 . replacing expression ( [ d-4a ] ) for the bogoliubov coefficients and ( [ h-3 ] ) for @xmath163 , the magnetic helicity correlation function ( [ h-4 ] ) for large scales and long times becomes @xmath191 \right\}^2}{q_1 ^ 3q_3 ^ 3q^3\vert \kappa - \bar q - \bar q_1 - \bar q_3\vert^3}\label{h-7}\ ] ] there remain the integrations over the momenta other than @xmath15 . as before ,
their contribution can be roughly estimated by counting powers as before .
since we are considering scales such that @xmath192 , we can disregard @xmath15 in the denominator of expr .
( [ h-7 ] ) .
then we have that the power of the scalar field momenta in the numerator is 13 ( nine from the integration meassures plus 4 from the square of the cross product ) while in the denominator their power is 12 ( three from each of the four bogoliubov factor ) , giving as result a factor of the form @xmath193 . as the maximum value allowed by the approximations is @xmath194 the result is @xmath195 according to definition ( [ c-1 ] ) there remain the integration over @xmath15 s , wich gives an extra factor @xmath12 , and the two integrations over the volume , which according to expr .
( [ c-4 ] ) each one gives a factor of @xmath196 .
then the contribution of all non - null graphs to the magnetic helicity is @xmath197 finally , the rms value of the magnetic helicity in a comoving volume @xmath196 can be considered as simply the squareroot of expr .
( [ h-9 ] ) giving @xmath198 note that this helicity corresponds to regular as well as irregular fields on the considered volume , i.e. to the total magnetic field due to fluctuations up to the scale @xmath180 .
the density of defects on a scale @xmath15 is found by multiplying expr .
( [ h-10 ] ) by @xmath12 , finding that it varies as @xmath10 . using the fact that a fractal of dimension @xmath199 embedded in a spherical volume has a number density that scales with the radius @xmath14 from an occupied point as @xmath200 we estimate the fractal dimension of the distribution of topological defects as being @xmath201 . in this section
we evaluate the magnetic helicity and its corresponding magnetic field on large scales due to smooth fields only .
the estimates will be the values that they would have today if they were not affected by the galaxy formation process .
the expression we are seeking for is obtained directly from eq .
( [ h-7 ] ) , estimating the integrals in the momenta other than @xmath15 by filtering the frequencies higher than the one associated to the considered scale , say @xmath202 .
we obtain @xmath203 i.e. , a scale independent number .
as before , we estimate the magnetic helicity on the considered scale by simply taking the squareroot of expression ( [ d-1b ] ) and , after replacing @xmath204 from ( [ h-3 ] ) we obtain @xmath205 using the numbers given by ( [ c-151])-([c-171 ] ) we have on a galactic scale @xmath206 which is a very small number . from eq .
( [ d-3 ] ) we obtain the number density of links of the smooth field by multiplying by @xmath207 , obtaining @xmath208 , which means that the fractal dimension of the distribution is @xmath2 .
this would mean that for large scales the number of defects becomes independent of the scale .
it is interesting to estimate the order of magnitude of the coherent magnetic field associated to this helicity on a galactic scale .
we can crudely do that by taking @xmath209 with @xmath210 , whereby @xmath211 , i.e. @xmath212 recalling that the physical field is @xmath213 and that 1 gev@xmath214 gauss we obtain that on a galactic scale the helical fields have an intensity of the order @xmath215 which is a very small value , that however agrees with previous estimates in the literature @xcite .
observe however that expr .
( [ d-4 ] ) coincides with the squareroot of expr .
( [ g-5 ] ) when @xmath163 is replaced by expr .
( [ h-3 ] ) and the limit @xmath216 is taken .
this means that the magnetic fields smooth on large scales induced by the mechanism considered in this paper are indeed helical .
the important feature of magnetic helicity for large scale magnetogenesis is the fact that it performs an inverse cascade if the medium where it evolves is turbulent .
we shall then make the hypothesis that after reheating the plasma is in a state of decaying turbulence , where self - organization of magnetic structures can happen .
the intensity of the turbulence is determined by the reynolds number , which during reheating was estimated in ref .
@xcite to be @xmath217 , while for times around electron - positron annihilation was calculated to be @xmath218 @xcite .
therefore a decaying turbulence scenario in the early universe is possible , the turbulence being mild .
turbulence is a causal phenomenon , i.e. , it happens on scales equal or smaller than the particle horizon .
we must evaluate the intensity of magnetic helicity in regions of size of at most the particle horizon at the time @xmath163 , when the sources of magnetic field vanish .
after that moment the evolution of the field intensity and coherence scale will be considered to be due to the inverse cascade of magnetic helicity .
we shall analize that evolution in the light of the simple model discussed in ref .
@xcite ( see also ref .
@xcite ) , whereby the comoving coherence length of the magnetic field grows as @xmath219 and the total comoving energy @xmath220 contained in a given volume decays as @xmath221 .
moreover , when the volume is fixed that law can be applied to the comoving magnetic energy density , i.e. , we can consider @xmath222 .
those laws arise from the conservation of magnetic helicity during the process of inverse cascade .
observe that the comoving coherence length remains always smaller than the comoving horizon , which after inflation grows as @xmath223 ( the physical horizon growing as @xmath224 ) .
we begin by estimating the dimensionless time interval elapsed between the end of reheating and matter - radiation equilibrium .
knowing that the horizon grows as @xmath225 , that interval can be estimated as @xmath226 . for the horizon at matter - radiation equilibrium we take it as @xcite @xmath227 . for reheating
, we assume that the transition inflation - reheating was fast enough , and that the electric currents vanished in a very short time , @xmath163 , to assume that the horizon at the end of reheating is not very different from @xmath228 , with @xmath20 the hubble constant during inflation .
therefore @xmath229 .
using the values for @xmath20 quoted in section [ dim ] that period of time would be in the interval @xmath230 . to evaluate the magnetic helicity correlation we firstly note that the modes that will contribute the most are those such that @xmath231 .
this is due to the form of the bogoliubov coefficients ( [ d-3])-([d-5 ] ) .
because of the different intervals used to find the scalar field modes and the corresponding bogoliubov coefficients , we must consider two intervals : @xmath232 , with bogoliubov coefficient given by expr .
( [ d-4 ] ) and @xmath233 with bogoliubov coefficient given by expr .
( [ d-3 ] ) . in the first interval
@xmath234 is an infrared cut - off that corresponds to the scal of the largest inflationary patch discussed above . in the second interval ,
the upper limit @xmath235 is considered for consistency with the approximations made in appendix [ apb ] to find the retarded propagator for large scales , eq .
( [ apb-4 ] ) . with these considerations in the momenta and for the short time
periods we consider , we can disregard the time dependence in the corresponding mode functions , eqs .
( [ apa-7b ] ) and ( [ apa-10 ] ) because @xmath236 .
therefore the mode functions during reheating to be used to evaluate the integrals in the momenta read @xmath237 for @xmath173 and @xmath238 for @xmath239 .
the contribution of the `` cross '' plus the `` two bubbles '' diagrams is then similar to the corresponding to large scales , namely @xmath240\right\}^2 \vert\beta_{q_1}\vert^2 \vert\beta_{q_3}\vert^2\vert\beta_{q - q_1}\vert^2\vert\beta_{\kappa - q -q_3}\vert^2\label{e-1}\\ & & g^{+}\left(q_1,\tau_1,\tau_1^{\prime}\right)g^{+}\left(q_3,\tau_2,\tau_2^{\prime}\right ) g^{+}\left(q - q_1,\tau_1,\tau_1^{\prime}\right)g^{+}\left(\kappa - q - q_3,\tau_2,\tau_2^{\prime}\right)\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath241 .
as the time dependence of the momenta has dissappeared , the time integrals involve only the expressions for the retarded propagators . for @xmath242 and time intervals @xmath243 they are given by expr .
( [ apb-6 ] ) below , i.e. , @xmath244 .
the integration between @xmath245 and @xmath246 is then straightforward , giving each propagator a contribution of @xmath247 , the overall time contribution thus being @xmath248 . replacing the corresponding expressions for the bogoliubov coefficients and the modes , eq .
( [ e-1 ] ) can be written as @xmath249 with @xmath250 corresponding to the momentum interval @xmath173 and @xmath251 to @xmath252 .
explicitly we have @xmath253\right\ } ^2}{q_1 ^ 3q_3 ^ 3q^3\vert \bar\kappa - \bar q - \bar q_1 - \bar q_3\vert^3}\label{e-2}\ ] ] and @xmath254\right\}^2}{q_1 ^ 9q_3 ^ 9q^9 \vert \bar\kappa
- \bar q - \bar q_1 - \bar q_3\vert^9}\label{e-3}\ ] ] to roughly estimate all momentum integrals we again count powers .
as @xmath255 we begin by neglecting the @xmath256 s in front of @xmath15 in both expressions .
for @xmath257 we obtain a contribution of the form @xmath258 and considering the contribution that gives the largest value , namely @xmath259 we obtain @xmath260 for @xmath261 the counting of powers give a factor of the form @xmath262 . and
in the corresponding interval @xmath263 we consider the contribution of the lower limit , i.e. again @xmath180 , as it gives the largest value . te
result is @xmath264 an important comment is in order : according to the approximations made to solve the klein - gordon equation during reheating in appendix [ apa ] , the intervals @xmath265 and @xmath266 determined the two different sets of solutions that were used to calculate the bogoliubov coefficients ( [ d-4 ] ) and ( [ d-5 ] ) . taking the limit @xmath267 in both of those expressions , we see that they are not continuous in that limit , which means that the mentioned approximations break down .
consequently both @xmath257 and @xmath261 found using that value of momentum must be considered as upper bounds to the possible realistic values .
we see that the main contribution to the rms value of the magnetic helicity is due to @xmath261 , which after replacing the expression ( [ h-3 ] ) reads @xmath268 we estimate the magnetic helicity on a volume @xmath196 again by taking the squareroot of ( [ e-6 ] ) , and thus see that the number of links scales as @xmath269 and their density as @xmath270 .
the associated fractal dimension is @xmath271 .
we now turn our attention to the evolution of the magnetic field from its value induced at the end of reheating in a scale of the order of the horizon up to matter - radiation equilibrium .
that evolution will be due to a possible turbulent state during radiation dominance , which would allow an inverse cascade of magnetic helicity .
we thus estimate again the comoving magnetic energy density as @xmath272 , and for @xmath273 it is simply @xmath274 . at matter - radiation equilibrium
we would then have a comoving magnetic field intensity of the order @xmath275 with a corresponding ( dimensionless ) comoving coherence length @xmath276 . to obtain the value of the physical field and coherence scale we must take into account the expansion of the universe , which for the field means a dilution by a factor of @xmath277 and for the coherence scale an expansion by a factor @xmath278 .
adding also the dimensions through the corresponding powers of @xmath20 we finally have @xmath279 and @xmath280 . using
the figures given above and in subsection [ dim ] we obtain at the beginning of matter dominance , a field intensity in the range @xmath281 with a corresponding coherence length of @xmath282 these values could impact the process of early structure formation @xcite .
in this work we have investigated the generation of magnetic helicity in primordial magnetogenesis .
we considered a specific mechanism for magnetic field generation , developed in refs .
@xcite ( see also @xcite ) , where stochastic magnetic fields were induced by electric currents that appeared due to particle creation at the transition inflation - reheating .
the charges correspond to a scalar field minimally coupled to gravity , as in this case the number of particles created is maximal
. there would be support for such a field in the supersymmetric theory of particles @xcite . as the induced magnetic fields are random , the mean values of the different quantities are null , and consequently we had to calculate a rms deviation of @xmath0 .
we could write it as the sum of four different sqed feynman graphs of differente multiplicities .
our main result is that the fields induced by stochastic currents generated by cosmological particle creation are helical . on large scales as
e.g. the galactic ones , we considered that the evolution of the magnetic helicity is diffusive because that scales are larger than the horizon during magnetogenesis , entering the horizon by the end of the radiation era or during matter dominance .
we also investigated the generation of magnetic helicity at a scales with a size of the order of the horizon during reheating , where inverse cascade can be operative .
we made the naive hypothesis that throughout radiation dominance the plasma flow is endowed with decaying turbulence and applied the model for magnetic energy and coherence scale evolution developed in refs . @xcite .
the estimation of the resulting magnetic field intensities at equilibrium between matter and radiation gives values and coherence scales that could be of importance for structure formation @xcite .
the importance of primordial magnetic fields endowed with magnetic helicity is that fields coherent on scales equal or shorter than the particle horizon , would self - organize on larger scales .
this is due to the fact that when the plasma where the field evolves possesses some degree of ( decaying ) turbulence , magnetic helicity performs an inverse cascade instead of a direct one , thus thus self - organizing at large scales . for large scales , as e.g. the galactic ones , there can also operate the inverse cascade , but even if there were not such a process , the operation of further amplifying mechanisms , as galactic dynamos , would be crucially affected by the topological properties of the seed fields @xcite
. in conclusion , generation of magnetic helicity in the early universe seems to be quite easily achieved in different scenarios @xcite .
the problem still remains in the intensities . in the mechanism considered here
the fields obtained are indeed helical , but their intensities on large scales are too small , or have a marginal value to have an astrophysical impact , while on smaller scales they can be important provided that inverse cascade of magnetic helicity is operative in the early universe .
e.c . aknowledges suport from conicet , uba and anpcyt .
thanks cnpq / capes for financial help through the procad project 552236/2011 - 0 .
in this appendix we find the solutions of eq .
( [ a-5b ] ) in the two epochs of the universe considered in the paper , i.e. , inflation and reheating , and calculate the bogoliubov coefficients .
the fourier transformed eq .
( [ a-5b ] ) reads @xmath283 \varphi _ { p}=0 \label{apa-1}\ ] ] whose solutions in each epoch will be labeled as @xmath284 ( inflation ) and @xmath285 ( reheating ) . the fact that they are different in each epoch tells that a given quantum state in the first epoch will not coincide with a same state in the subsequent epoch .
more concretely , a vacuum state during inflation will appear as a particle state in reheating .
mathematically this is expressed as @xcite @xmath286 the fact that @xmath287 , shows that the two quantum states are not equivalent . @xmath288 and @xmath289 are the bogoliubov coefficients @xcite . for modes corresponding to scales larger than the horizon size at the epoch of transition , that transition can be considered as instantaneous and the coefficients can be calculated by demanding continuity of @xmath290 and @xmath291 at that instant .
this gives @xmath292 for scales shorter than the horizon , i.e. , @xmath293 , the calculation is more involved , as details of the transition do matter ( see ref . @xcite and references therein ) . for completion
we only quote here the result and refer the reader to the references for the calculations . @xmath294}{p^5},\qquad p > 1 \label{apa-0d}\ ] ] where @xmath178 is the lasting of the transition . considering that the scale factor at the end of inflation is equal to unity , we can write @xmath295 and eq .
( [ apa-1 ] ) reads @xmath296 \varphi _ { p}^{i}=0 \label{apa-2}\ ] ] writing @xmath297 eq .
( [ apa-2 ] ) transforms into a bessel equation for @xmath298 and therefore the normalized , positive frequency solutions of eq .
( [ apa-2 ] ) are @xmath299 \label{apa-3}\ ] ] with @xmath300 .
as we shall be considering the case @xmath301 we can approximate @xmath302 and in this case the hankel function has a polinomic expression , namely @xmath303 \label{apa-4}\ ] ] in this case @xmath304 and eq .
( [ apa-1 ] ) is given by @xmath305 \varphi _ { p}^{r}=0 \label{apa-5}\ ] ] which can not be reduced to a known equation , unless some approximations are made . in this sense
we consider two situations : @xmath173 and @xmath306 . in both cases
the modes correspond to wavelengths larger than the size of the particle horizon and hence detais of the transition between the two considered epochs do not matter .
the corresponding bogoliubov coefficients can be calculated considering an instantaneous transition at @xmath245 , and demanding continuity of the modes and their first derivatives at that moment . in this limit
( [ apa-5 ] ) reads @xmath308 \varphi _ { p}^{r}=0 \label{apa-6}\ ] ] proposing a solution of the form @xmath309 $ ] eq . ( [ apa-7 ] ) transforms into a bessel equation for @xmath298 , and so the normalized , positive frequency solutions of eq .
( [ apa-6 ] ) are @xmath310 \nonumber\\ & = & -\sqrt{\frac{6}{\pi}}\frac{\exp\left[i\left ( 2m/3h\right)\left(1 + \tau/2\right)^3\right]}{\left ( 1+\tau/2\right)}\label{apa-7b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using expr .
( [ apa-0c ] ) we obtain @xmath311 this case still corresponds to modes outside the particle horizon , but their form is different from the one corresponding to the previous momentum interval .
( [ apa-4 ] ) reads @xmath312 \varphi _ { p}^{r}=0 \label{apa-9}\ ] ] writing @xmath313 $ ] we again obtain a bessel equation for @xmath314 .
in this case the normalized , positive frequency modes are @xmath315\nonumber\\ & = & -\frac{1}{\sqrt{2p}}e^{i2p\left(1+\tau /2\right)}\left[1-\frac{i}{4p\left(1+\tau /2\right)}\right ] \label{apa-10}\end{aligned}\ ] ] replacing again in expr .
( apa-0c ) we have @xmath316
the fourier transform of the retarded propagator for the electromagnetic field satisfies the following equation @xmath317 g_{ret}\left ( \kappa , \eta , \tau \right ) = \delta \left ( \eta -\tau \right ) \label{apb-1}\ ] ] whose homogeneous solutions are of the form @xmath318 , with @xmath319 .
we therefore propose @xmath320 \theta \left ( \eta -\tau \right ) \label{apb-2}\]]which is continuous in @xmath321 .
demanding @xmath322 gives @xmath323 , whence @xmath324 \theta \left ( \eta -\tau \right ) \label{apb-3}\ ] ] in this case we can take @xmath326 and thus @xmath327\theta \left ( \eta -\tau \right ) \label{apb-4}\ ] ] in the limit @xmath328 eq .
( [ apb-4 ] ) simply reads @xmath329 while for @xmath330 we have @xmath331 in this case @xmath333 and then @xmath334}{\kappa } \theta \left ( \eta -\tau \right ) \label{apb-7}\ ] ] which for finite @xmath15 and @xmath335 gives @xmath336
we must evaluate @xmath337 \label{apd-1}\]]with@xmath338@xmath339@xmath340we have that@xmath341and @xmath342defining @xmath343 we can write@xmath344and@xmath345for the different terms in the integrand we thus have@xmath346 \left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}_{1}\times \bar{q}\right ) \right ] + \left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}_{3}\times \bar{q}_{1}\right ) \right ] \left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}_{3}\times \bar{q}\right ) \right ] \label{apd-9}\]]that integrates to zero because the first term is odd in @xmath347 and the second in @xmath348 .
for the same reasons , the same happens with the term@xmath349 \left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}_{1}\times \bar{q}% \right ) \right ] + 2\left [ \bar{q}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}_{1}\times \bar{q}% _ { 3}\right ) \right ] \left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}_{3}\times \bar{q}% \right ) \right ] \label{apd-10}\]]there remains the term@xmath350 \left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}_{1}\times \bar{q}% \right ) \right ] -\left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}\times \bar{q}% _ { 3}\right ) \right ] ^{2 } \label{apd-11}\ ] ] we define @xmath351 hence @xmath352 ^{2}+2\left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}\times \bar{q}_{+}\right ) \right ] \left [ \bar{\kappa}\cdot \left ( \bar{q}\times \bar{q}_{-}\right ) \right ] \label{apd-13}\]]the term odd in @xmath353 integrate to zero , hence there only remains the first one , i.e.@xmath352 ^{2 } \label{apd-14}\]]which is clearly non - null . | we study the possibility that primordial magnetic fields generated in the transition between inflation and reheating posses magnetic helicity , @xmath0 .
the fields are induced by stochastic currents of scalar charged particles created during the mentioned transition .
we estimate the rms value of the induced magnetic helicity by computing different four - point sqed feynman diagrams . for any considered volume ,
the magnetic flux across its boundaries is in principle non null , which means that the magnetic helicity in those regions is gauge dependent .
we use the prescription given by berger and field and interpret our result as the difference between two magnetic configurations that coincide in the exterior volume . in this case
the magnetic helicity gives only the number of magnetic links inside the considered volume .
we calculate a concrete value of @xmath0 for large scales and analyze the distribution of magnetic defects as a function of the scale .
those defects correspond to regular as well as random fields in the considered volume .
we find that the fractal dimension of the distribution of topological defects is @xmath1 .
we also study if the regular fields induced on large scales are helical , finding that they are and that the associated number of magnetic defects is independent of the scale . in this case
the fractal dimension is @xmath2 .
we finally estimate the intensity of fields induced at the horizon scale of reheating , and evolve them until the decoupling of matter and radiation under the hypothesis of inverse cascade of magnetic helicity .
the resulting intensity is high enough and the coherence length long enough to have an impact on the subsequent process of structure formation . |
[ sec:1 ] * remark .
* notation @xmath0 is equivalent to @xmath1 where @xmath2 } _ { n\times 1 } \ , & \rho & = & \rho_{ij } & = & \underbrace { \left [ \begin{array}{c } \rho_{1j } \\ \vdots \\ \rho_{nj } \\ \end{array } \right ] } _ { n \times 1 } \ . \end{array}\ ] ] notation @xmath3 is equivalent to @xmath4 where @xmath5}_{n \times n } } \ .
\end{array}\ ] ] let us consider ( e.g. for @xmath6 ) variance of the difference @xmath7 of two random variables @xmath8 and @xmath9 , where @xmath10 , in terms of covariance @xmath11 introducing the estimation statistics @xmath12 @xmath13 in terms of correlation function @xmath14 @xmath15 if @xmath16 and @xmath17 or @xmath18 if @xmath19 and @xmath20 the unbiasedness constraint ( i condition ) @xmath21 is equivalent to @xmath22 the minimization constraint @xmath23 where @xmath24 produces @xmath25 equations in the @xmath26 unknowns : kriging weights @xmath27 and a lagrange parameter @xmath28 ( ii condition ) @xmath29}_{n\times(n+1 ) } } & \cdot & \underbrace { \left [ \begin{array}{c } \omega_j^1
\\ \vdots \\ \omega_j^n \\ \mu_j \\ \end{array } \right ] } _ { ( n+1)\times 1 } & = & \underbrace { \left [ \begin{array}{c } \rho_{1j } \\ \vdots \\ \rho_{nj } \\ \end{array } \right ] } _ { n \times 1 } \end{array}\ ] ] multiplied by @xmath30 @xmath31 and substituted into @xmath32 @xmath33 ^ 2\}-\underbrace{e^2\{v_j-\hat{v}_j\}}_0 \\ & = & e\{[(v_j - m)-(\hat{v}_j - m)]^2\ } \\ & = & e\{[v_j - m]^2\}-2(e\{v_j\hat{v}_j\}-m^2)+e\{[\hat{v}_j - m]^2\ } \\ & = & \sigma^2 -2 \sigma^2 |\omega^i_j \rho_{ij}| + \sigma^2 |\omega^i_j \rho_{ii } \omega^i_j| \\ & = & \sigma^2 \pm 2 \sigma^2 \omega^i_j \rho_{ij } \mp \sigma^2 \omega^i_j \rho_{ii } \omega^i_j \end{array}\ ] ] give the minimized variance of the field @xmath8 under estimation @xmath34 ^ 2\ } = \sigma^2 ( 1 \pm ( \omega^i_j \rho_{ij } + \mu_j ) ) \ ] ] and these two conditions produce @xmath26 equations in the @xmath26 unknowns @xmath35}_{(n+1)\times(n+1 ) } } & \cdot & \underbrace { \left [ \begin{array}{c } \omega_j^1 \\ \vdots \\ \omega_j^n \\ \mu_j \\ \end{array } \right ] } _ { ( n+1)\times 1 } & = & \underbrace { \left [ \begin{array}{c } \rho_{1j } \\ \vdots \\ \rho_{nj } \\ 1 \\ \end{array } \right ] } _ { ( n+1 ) \times 1 } \ . \end{array}\ ] ]
since @xmath36 then @xmath37 and ( since ) @xmath38 then @xmath39 the minimized variance of the field @xmath8 under estimation @xmath34 ^ 2\ } = \sigma^2 ( 1\pm(\omega^i_j \rho_{ij } + \mu_j))\ ] ] has known asymptotic property @xmath40 ^ 2\ } = \lim_{n \rightarrow \infty } e\{[v_j-\omega^i_j v_i]^2\ } = e\{[v_j - m]^2\ } = \sigma^2 \ .\ ] ]
let us consider the field @xmath8 under estimation @xmath41 where for auto - estimation holds @xmath42 with minimized variance of the estimation statistics @xmath43 ^ 2\ } & = & cov\{(\omega^i_j v_i)(\omega^i_j v_i)\ } \\ & = & \sum_i\sum_l\omega^i_j \omega^l_j cov\{v_i v_l\ } \\ & = & \sigma^2 |\omega^i_j \rho_{ii } \omega^i_j| \\ & = & \mp\sigma^2(\omega^i_j \rho_{ij}-\mu_j ) \ , \end{array}\ ] ] where for auto - estimation holds @xmath44 ^ 2\ } = e\{[v_i - m]^2\ } = \sigma^2\ ] ] that means outcoming of input value is unknown for mathematical model , with minimized variance of the field @xmath8 under estimation @xmath45 ^ 2\ } & = & \sigma^2(1\pm(\omega^i_j \rho_{ij } + \mu_j ) ) \end{array}\ ] ] where for auto - estimation holds @xmath46 ^ 2\ } = \underbrace{e\{[v_i - m]^2\}}_{\sigma^2 } - \underbrace{2(e\{v_i\hat{v}_i\}-m^2)}_{2\sigma^2 } + \underbrace{e\{[\hat{v}_i - m]^2\}}_{\sigma^2 } = 0\ ] ] that means variance of the field is equal to variance of the ( auto-)estimation statistics ( not that auto - estimation matches observation ) .
for @xmath47 @xmath48 } _ { n \times 1 } = \xi \underbrace { \left [ \begin{array}{c } 1 \\
\vdots \\ 1 \\ \end{array } \right ] } _ { n \times 1 } \qquad \xi \rightarrow 0 ^ - ~(\mbox{or } ~\xi \rightarrow 0^+ ) \ ] ] and a disjunction of the minimized variance of the field @xmath8 under estimation @xmath49 ^ 2\ } - \underbrace{(e\{v_j\hat{v}_j\}-m^2)}_{\mp\sigma^2\xi } + \underbrace{e\{\hat{v}_j[\hat{v}_j - v_j]\}}_{\mp\sigma^2\xi } \quad \mbox{if } \quad \rho_{ij } \omega^i_j + \mu_j = \xi+ \mu_j=0\ ] ] which fulfills its asymptotic property the kriging system @xmath50}_{(n+1)\times(n+1 ) } } & \cdot & \underbrace { \left [ \begin{array}{c } \omega^1 \\ \vdots \\ \omega^n \\ - \xi \\ \end{array } \right ] } _ { ( n+1)\times 1 } & = & \underbrace { \left [ \begin{array}{c } \xi \\ \vdots \\ \xi \\ 1 \\ \end{array } \right ] } _ { ( n+1 ) \times 1 } & \end{array}\ ] ] equivalent to @xmath51 and @xmath52 where : @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 , has the least squares solution @xmath56 and @xmath57 with a mean squared error of mean estimation @xmath58 ^ 2\ } = \mp\sigma^2 2\xi \ .\ ] ]
for white noise @xmath45 ^ 2\ } & = & e\{[v_j - m]^2\}+e\{[\hat{v}_j - m]^2\ } \\ * remark .
* precession of arithmetic mean can not be identical to @xmath62 cause a straight line fitted to high - noised data by ordinary least squares estimator can not have the slope identical to @xmath62 .
for this reason the estimator of an unknown constant variance @xmath63 in fact is the lower bound for precession of the minimized variance of the field under estimation @xmath34 ^ 2\ } = \sigma^2\left(1+\frac{1}{n}\right)\ ] ] to increase ` a bit ' the lower bound for @xmath64 we can effect on weight and reduce total counts @xmath25 by @xmath65 because @xmath65 is the closest positive integer number to @xmath62 so it is easy to find the closest weight such that @xmath66 then the so - called unbiased variance @xmath67 in fact is the simplest estimator of minimized variance of the field under estimation . | we present statistics ( s - statistics ) based only on random variable ( not random value ) with a mean squared error of mean estimation as a concept of error . |
this paper investigates the connection between symplectic geometry and those parts of representation theory which revolve around the notion of categorification .
the existence of such a connection , in an abstract sense , follows from simple general ideas .
the difficult thing is to make it explicit . on the symplectic side ,
the tools needed for a systematic study of this question are not yet fully available .
therefore we concentrate on a single example , which is just complicated enough to indicate the depth of the relationship .
the results can be understood by themselves , but a glimpse of the big picture certainly helps to explain them , and that is what the present section is for .
let @xmath5 be a category .
action of a group @xmath6 on @xmath5 _ is a family @xmath7 of functors from @xmath5 to itself , such that @xmath8 and @xmath9 for all @xmath10 ; here @xmath11 denotes isomorphism of functors on @xmath12 a full - fledged action comes with preferred isomorphisms @xmath9 that satisfy obvious compatibility relations . ] .
we will not distinguish between two actions @xmath13 and @xmath14 such that @xmath15 for all @xmath16 .
a particularly nice situation is when @xmath5 is triangulated and the @xmath17 are exact functors .
then the action induces a linear representation of @xmath6 on the grothendieck group @xmath18 .
the inverse process , in which one lifts a given linear representation to a group action on a triangulated category , is called categorification ( of group representations ) . the connection with symplectic geometry is based on an idea of donaldson .
he proposed ( in talks circa @xmath19 ) to associate to a compact symplectic manifold @xmath20 a category @xmath21 whose objects are lagrangian submanifolds @xmath22 , and whose morphisms are the floer cohomology groups @xmath23 .
the composition of morphisms would be given by products @xmath24 which are defined , for example , in @xcite .
let @xmath25 be the group of symplectic automorphisms of @xmath26 .
any @xmath27 determines a family of isomorphisms @xmath28 for @xmath29 which are compatible with the products . in other words
, @xmath30 induces an equivalence @xmath31 from @xmath21 to itself .
this is just a consequence of the fact that @xmath21 is an object of symplectic geometry , hence natural under symplectic maps .
assume for simplicity that @xmath32 , so that all symplectic vector fields are hamiltonian .
then a smooth isotopy of symplectic automorphisms @xmath33 gives rise to distinguished elements in @xmath34 for all @xmath35 this means that the @xmath31 define a canonical action of the symplectic mapping class group @xmath36 on @xmath21 . as a consequence , any symplectic fibre bundle with fibre @xmath37 and base @xmath38 gives rise to a @xmath39-action on @xmath21 , through the monodromy map @xmath40 .
interesting examples can be obtained from families of smooth complex projective varieties . while it is thus easy to construct potentially interesting group actions on the categories @xmath21 , both the group actions and the categories themselves are difficult to understand .
a particularly intriguing question is whether , in any given case , one can relate them to objects defined in a purely algebraic way . in homological algebra there is a standard technique for approaching similar comparison problems ( an example is beilinson s work @xcite on coherent sheaves on @xmath41 ) .
a very crude attempt to adapt this technique to our situation goes like this : pick a finite number of lagrangian submanifolds @xmath42 which , for some reason , appear to be particularly important . using the product on floer cohomology , turn @xmath43 into a ring .
now associate to an arbitrary lagrangian submanifold @xmath44 the @xmath45-module @xmath46 .
this defines a functor from @xmath21 to the category of @xmath45-modules .
as it stands the functor is not particularly useful , since it does not take into account all the available structure . to begin with ,
floer cohomology groups are graded , and hence @xmath45 is a graded ring ( depending on @xmath26 , this may be only a @xmath47-grading for some finite @xmath48 ) . to make more substantial progress one needs to refine the category @xmath21 .
this theory is as yet under construction , and we can only give a vague outline of it .
as pointed out by fukaya @xcite , working directly with the floer cochain complexes should enable one to construct an @xmath49-category underlying @xmath21 .
kontsevich @xcite suggested to consider the derived category of this @xmath49-category .
this `` derived fukaya category '' is expected to be triangulated , and to contain @xmath21 as a full subcategory ; we denote it by @xmath50 ( which is an abuse of notation ) .
the action of @xmath36 on @xmath21 should extend to an action on @xmath50 by exact functors .
moreover , it seems natural to suppose that the grothendieck group of @xmath50 is related to @xmath51 ; that would mean that the group actions coming from families of projective varieties could be considered as categorifications of the classical monodromy representations .
returning to the rings , one expects to get from fukaya s construction a canonical ( up to quasi - isomorphism ) @xmath49-algebra @xmath52 with cohomology @xmath45 .
the functor introduced above would lift to an @xmath49-functor from the @xmath49-category underlying @xmath21 to the @xmath49-category of @xmath49-modules over @xmath52 . in a second step , this would induce an exact functor @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the derived category of @xmath49-modules .
a standard argument based on exactness indicates that this functor , when restricted to the triangulated subcategory of @xmath50 generated by @xmath55 , would be full and faithful .
this is a much stronger comparison theorem than one could get with the primitive approach which we had mentioned first .
we will not say more about this ; what the reader should keep in mind is the expected importance of the rings @xmath45 .
it should also be mentioned that there is a special reason to study actions of braid groups and mapping class groups on categories . in 19921994
a number of mathematicians independently suggested extending the formalism of tqfts to manifolds with corners .
while three - dimensional extended tqfts are rather well understood , there has been much less progress in the four - dimensional case .
part of the data which make up a four - dimensional extended tqft are categories @xmath56 associated to closed surfaces @xmath57 ; these would govern the process of cutting and pasting for the vector spaces associated to closed three - manifolds .
the mapping class group of @xmath57 should act on @xmath56 in a natural way , and for interesting tqfts this action is likely to be highly nontrivial . as a matter of historical interest , we note that the categories @xmath21 were invented by donaldson in an attempt to make gauge theory fit into the extended tqft formalism ; see @xcite for more recent developments .
there is a version of this for invariants of two - knots , where the categories are associated to punctured discs and carry actions of the braid groups .
the papers @xcite and @xcite go some way towards constructing such extended tqfts in a representation - theoretic way . in the algebraic part of the paper , we study the derived categories @xmath58 for a particular family @xmath0 ( @xmath59 ) of graded rings .
the definition of @xmath0 starts with the quiver ( oriented graph ) @xmath60 shown in figure [ fig : quiver ] , whose vertices are labelled @xmath61 . recall that the path ring of an arbitrary quiver @xmath62 is the abelian group freely generated by the set of all paths in @xmath62 , with multiplication given by composition .
paths of length @xmath63 in @xmath60 correspond to @xmath64-tuples @xmath65 of numbers @xmath66 such that the difference of any two consecutive ones is @xmath67 .
therefore , the path ring of @xmath60 is the abelian group freely generated by such @xmath64-tuples for all @xmath68 , with the multiplication @xmath69 the paths @xmath70 of length zero are mutually orthogonal idempotents , and their sum is the unit element .
we make the path ring of @xmath60 into a graded ring by setting @xmath71 and @xmath72 for all @xmath73 , and extending this in the obvious way ( this is _ not _ the same as the grading by lengths of paths ) . finally , @xmath0 is the quotient of the path ring of @xmath60 by the relations @xmath74 for all @xmath75 .
these relations are homogeneous with respect to the above grading , so that @xmath0 is a graded ring . as an abelian group
@xmath0 is free and of finite rank ; a basis is given by the @xmath76 elements @xmath77 .
+ let @xmath78 be the category of finitely generated graded left @xmath0-modules , and @xmath58 its bounded derived category .
we will write down explicitly exact self - equivalences @xmath79 of @xmath58 which satisfy @xmath80 these are the defining relations of the braid group @xmath4 , which means that the functors @xmath81 generate an action @xmath82 of @xmath4 on @xmath58 .
the first step in analyzing this action is to look at the induced linear representation on the grothendieck group @xmath83 .
the category @xmath78 carries a self - equivalence @xmath84 which raises the grading of a module by one ( this should not be confused with the translation functor @xmath85 $ ] in the derived category ) .
the action of @xmath84 makes @xmath86 into a module over @xmath87 $ ] .
in fact @xmath88 \otimes { \mathbb{z}}^{m+1};\ ] ] a basis is given by the indecomposable projective modules @xmath89 .
the functors @xmath90 commute with @xmath91 therefore the induced representation is a homomorphism @xmath92)$ ] .
a computation shows that this is the well - known burau representation .
+ at this point , it is helpful to recall the topological meaning of the burau representation . take a closed disc @xmath93 and a set @xmath94 of @xmath3 marked points on it .
let @xmath95 be the infinite cyclic cover of @xmath96 whose restriction to a small positively oriented loop around any point of @xmath97 is isomorphic to @xmath98 . fix a point @xmath99 on @xmath100 , and let @xmath101 be its preimage .
let @xmath102 be the group of diffeomorphisms @xmath103 of @xmath93 which satisfy @xmath104 and @xmath105 .
any @xmath106 can be lifted in a unique way to a @xmath107-equivariant diffeomorphism of @xmath95 which acts trivially on @xmath108 .
the burau representation can be defined as the induced action of @xmath109 on @xmath110 \otimes { \mathbb{z}}^{m+1}$ ] .
our first result will show that the action @xmath111 itself , or rather certain numbers attached to it , admits a similar topological interpretation .
for any @xmath112 and @xmath113 consider the bigraded abelian group @xmath114\{-r_2\}).\ ] ] fix a collection of curves @xmath115 on @xmath116 as in figure [ fig : basic - curves ] ; this determines a preferred isomorphism @xmath117 .
take some @xmath118 and a diffeomorphism @xmath119 representing it .
the geometric intersection number @xmath120 counts the number of essential intersection points between the curves @xmath121 and @xmath122 . the exact definition , which is a slight variation of the usual one , will be given in the body of the paper .
[ th : gin ] the total rank of the bigraded group is @xmath123 .
we will actually prove a slightly stronger result , which describes up to isomorphism in terms of _ bigraded intersection numbers _ invented for that purpose .
theorem [ th : gin ] , together with standard properties of geometric intersection numbers , has an interesting implication .
call a group action @xmath124 on a category @xmath5 faithful if @xmath125 for all @xmath126 .
[ th : faithful ] @xmath82 is faithful for all @xmath59 . note that this can not be proved by considerations on the level of grothendieck groups , since the burau representation is not faithful ( in the usual sense of the word ) for @xmath127 @xcite .
corollary [ th : faithful ] can be used to derive the faithfulness of certain braid group actions on categories which occur in algebraic geometry @xcite . on the symplectic side we will study the milnor fibres of certain singularities .
the @xmath128-dimensional singularity of type @xmath129 , for @xmath130 , is the singular point @xmath131 of the hypersurface @xmath132 in @xmath133 . to define the milnor fibre one perturbs the defining equation , so as to smooth out the singular point , and then intersects the outcome with a ball around the origin .
in the present case one can take @xmath134 where @xmath135 $ ] is a polynomial with no multiple zeros , with @xmath136 small .
equip @xmath26 with the restriction @xmath137 of the standard symplectic form on @xmath133 , and its boundary with the restriction @xmath138 of the standard contact one - form on @xmath139 .
assume that the disc @xmath93 considered above is in fact embedded in @xmath140 as the subset @xmath141 , and that the set of marked points is @xmath142 .
then one can associate to any curve @xmath143 in @xmath116 a lagrangian submanifold @xmath144 of @xmath145 .
we postpone the precise definition , and just mention that @xmath144 lies over @xmath143 with respect to the projection to the @xmath146-variable .
in particular , from curves @xmath115 as in figure [ fig : basic - curves ] one obtains lagrangian submanifolds @xmath147 .
these are all @xmath128-spheres except for @xmath148 , which is an @xmath128-ball with boundary in @xmath149 ; they intersect each other transversally , and @xmath150 the case @xmath151 and @xmath152 is shown in figure [ fig : vanish ] .
+ by varying the polynomial @xmath153 one gets a family of milnor fibres parametrized by an open subset @xmath154 .
parallel transport in this family , for a suitable class of connections , defines a _
symplectic monodromy map _
@xmath155 the actual construction is slightly more complicated than this rough description may suggest .
similar maps can be defined for general hypersurface singularities . in our particular case , there are isomorphisms @xmath156 the first one comes from a canonical embedding @xmath157 , the second one is well - known and again canonical , and the third one is determined by the choice of curves @xmath115 as before . using these isomorphisms , one can consider @xmath158 as a homomorphism from the braid group to @xmath159 .
we mention , although this has no relevance for the present paper , that there is a more direct definition of @xmath158 in terms of generalized dehn twists along @xmath160 .
this is explained in ( * ? ? ? * appendix ) for @xmath161 , and the general case is similar .
take some @xmath112 and a map @xmath162 which represents @xmath163 in the sense of ( [ eq : isos ] ) . if @xmath152 we also assume that @xmath164 has a particular property called @xmath165-exactness , which will be defined in the body of the paper ; this assumption is necessary because in that dimension @xmath166 .
the floer cohomology @xmath167 is a finite - dimensional vector space over @xmath168 constructed from the intersection points of @xmath169 and @xmath170 , and it is independent of the choice of @xmath164 . [
th : gin - two ] the dimension of @xmath167 is @xmath123 . here
@xmath171 is as in theorem [ th : gin ] .
there is also a faithfulness result analogous to corollary [ th : faithful ] : [ th : faithful - two ] @xmath158 is injective for all @xmath130 .
it is instructive to compare this with the outcome of a purely topological consideration .
the classical geometric monodromy @xmath172 is the composition @xmath173 \\ { b_{m+1 } } \ar@/^/[rru]^-{\rho_s } \ar[rr]^-{\rho_g } & & { \pi_0({\mathrm{diff}}(m,\partial m ) ) } } \ ] ] where the vertical arrow is induced by inclusion . for @xmath152 this arrow
is an isomorphism , and the injectivity of @xmath172 is an old result of birman and hilden @xcite ( see proposition [ th : birman - hilden ] ) .
the situation changes drastically for @xmath161 , where brieskorn s simultaneous resolution @xcite implies that @xmath172 factors through the symmetric group @xmath174 .
the difference between @xmath158 and @xmath172 in this case shows that the symplectic structure of the milnor fibre contains essential information about the singularity , which is lost when one considers it only as a smooth manifold .
the situation for @xmath175 is less clear - cut .
one can use unknottedness results of haefliger @xcite , together with an easy homotopy computation , to show that @xmath172 is not injective for all @xmath176 if @xmath177 is even , and for all @xmath178 if @xmath179 , @xmath180 ( with more care , these bounds could probably be improved ) . by combining theorems [ th : gin ] and [ th : gin - two ]
one sees that the dimension of @xmath167 is equal to the total rank of .
one can refine the comparison by taking into account the graded structure of floer cohomology , as follows : [ th : comparison ] for all @xmath112 , @xmath181 , and @xmath182 , @xmath183\{-r_2\ } ) \otimes { \mathbb{z}}/2.\ ] ] strictly speaking , the grading in floer theory is canonical only up to an overall shift ( in fact , for @xmath152 there is an even bigger ambiguity ) , and the isomorphism holds for a particular choice .
one can cure this problem by using kontsevich s idea of graded lagrangian submanifolds .
we will not state the corresponding improved version of corollary [ th : comparison ] explicitly , but it can easily be extracted from our proof . note that if one looks at the graded groups @xmath184 in isolation , they appear to depend on @xmath128 in a complicated way ; whereas the connection with the bigraded group makes this dependence quite transparent .
one can see this collapsing of the bigrading on a much simpler level , which corresponds to passing to euler characteristics on both sides in corollary [ th : comparison ] .
namely , the representation of the braid group on @xmath185 induced by @xmath158 is the specialization @xmath186 of the burau representation .
while our proof of corollary [ th : comparison ] is by dimension counting , it is natural to ask whether there are canonical homomorphisms between the two graded groups ; these should be compatible with the product structures existing on both sides .
unfortunately , the techniques used here are not really suitable for that ; while an inspection of our argument suggests a possible definition of a homomorphism in , showing that it is independent of the various choices involved would be extremely complicated . and there is no easy way to adapt the proof of theorem [ th : gin - two ] to include a description of the product on floer cohomology .
it seems that to overcome these problems , one would have to use a more abstract approach , in line with the general picture of section [ subsec : generalities ] . while the details of this are far from clear , an outline can easily be provided , and we will do that now .
it is convenient to modify the algebraic setup slightly .
let @xmath187 be the graded algebra obtained from @xmath0 by multiplying the grading with @xmath128 and changing the coefficients to @xmath168 ; regard this as a differential graded algebra @xmath188 with zero differential , and take the derived category of differential graded modules @xmath189 .
from the way in which @xmath190 intersect each other , and standard properties of floer cohomology , one can see that @xmath191 ( actually , this was the starting point of our work ) .
it seems reasonable to assume that the @xmath49-algebra of floer cochain complexes underlying the right hand side should be formal ( see @xcite for much more about this ) , which would make its derived category of @xmath49-modules equivalent to @xmath189 . as mentioned in section [ subsec
: generalities ] , the general features of the construction should imply that one has an exact functor @xmath192 , which would be full and faithful on the triangulated subcategory of @xmath50 generated by @xmath147 .
@xmath158 defines a braid group action on @xmath21 , and there should be an induced action on @xmath50 . on the other hand , one can define a braid group action on @xmath189 in a purely algebraic way , in the same way as we have done for the closely related category @xmath58 .
it is natural to conjecture that the exact functor should intertwine the two actions . this would imply corollary [ th : comparison ] , in a stronger form which repairs the deficiencies mentioned above .
finally , the reader may be wondering whether the objects which we have considered can be used to define invariants of two - knots .
the category @xmath58 is certainly not rich enough for this .
however , it has been conjectured @xcite that one can construct invariants of two - knots from a certain family of categories , of which @xmath58 is the simplest nontrivial example .
the homology groups for classical knots introduced in @xcite are part of this program .
_ during the final stage of work on this paper we learned of a preprint @xcite by rouquier and zimmermann .
they construct a braid group action in the derived category of modules over multiplicity one brauer tree algebras , which are close relatives of @xmath0 ( the idempotent @xmath193 of @xmath0 is set to zero ; these smaller algebras also appear in @xcite and @xcite ) .
our action essentially coincides with the one of rouquier and zimmermann .
_ acknowledgements .
_ m.k . would like to thank maxim vybornov who introduced him to the algebras @xmath0 by pointing out that they describe perverse sheaves on projective spaces .
the construction of the lagrangian submanifolds @xmath144 was suggested to p.s . by simon donaldson .
most of this work was done at the institute for advanced study , during the year 97/98 and two shorter visits later on .
we are very grateful to the institute , and to robert macpherson in particular , for making this collaboration possible . m.k . was supported by nsf grants dms 96 - 27351 and dms 97 - 29992 and , later on , by the university of california at davis .
p.s . was supported by nsf grant dms-9304580 and by the institut universitaire de france .
fix @xmath59 .
we recall some of the objects introduced in section [ subsec : results ] : * the graded ring @xmath0 . in future
all left modules , right modules , or bimodules over @xmath0 are understood to be graded ; * the category @xmath78 , whose objects are finitely generated @xmath0-modules , and whose morphisms are grading - preserving module homomorphisms . in future , we call the objects of @xmath78 just @xmath0-modules , and write @xmath195 instead of @xmath196 ; throughout the paper , all homomorphisms are assumed grading - preserving unless otherwise mentioned .
* the self - equivalence @xmath84 of @xmath78 which shifts the grading upwards by one ; * the @xmath0-modules @xmath197 these are indecomposable and projective .
in fact , if one considers @xmath0 as a left module over itself , it splits into the direct sum @xmath198 .
conversely , any indecomposable projective @xmath0-module is isomorphic to @xmath199 for some @xmath73 and @xmath200 .
similarly , if one considers @xmath0 as a right module over itself , it splits into the direct sum of the indecomposable projective right modules @xmath201 .
[ prop : finite - hom - dim ] @xmath0 has finite homological dimension . introduce @xmath0-modules @xmath202 as follows . as
a graded abelian group @xmath203 is isomorphic to @xmath204 placed in degree @xmath205 the idempotent @xmath70 acts as the identity on @xmath206 and all other paths in the quiver act as zero .
any @xmath0-module has a finite length composition series with subsequent quotients isomorphic , up to shifts in the grading , to @xmath203 or @xmath207 for various @xmath73 and primes
@xmath208 moreover , @xmath207 has a resolution by modules @xmath203 : @xmath209 therefore , the proposition will follow if we construct a finite length projective resolution of @xmath206 for each @xmath210 consider the commutative diagram @xmath211 of projective @xmath0-modules .
the maps go from @xmath212 to @xmath213 for various @xmath214 and are given by right multiplications by @xmath215 which maps @xmath216 to @xmath217 the commutativity of the diagram follows from the relations @xmath218 moreover , every row and every column is a complex , since @xmath219 so that , after inserting minus signs in appropriate places , the diagram above becomes a bicomplex .
the associated total complex is a finite length projective resolution of the module @xmath203 ( use that every column is acyclic except in the uppermost component ) .
@xmath220 for @xmath222 let @xmath223 be the @xmath0-bimodule obtained by tensoring @xmath224 and @xmath225 over @xmath226 let @xmath227 be the functor of tensoring with this bimodule , @xmath228 this functor is exact ( since @xmath229 is right projective ) and takes projective modules to projective modules case is excluded , for although @xmath230 can be defined , it does not satisfy the isomorphisms in theorem [ tl - relations ] . ] .
[ tl - relations ] there are functor isomorphisms @xmath231 we will consider only ( [ three - u ] ) ; the other isomorphisms are proved by similar arguments .
the functor on the left hand side of ( [ three - u ] ) is given by tensoring with the bimodule @xmath232 the graded abelian groups @xmath233 and @xmath234 are free cyclic , one in degree @xmath235 , the other in degree @xmath236 thus @xmath237 is isomorphic to the composition of tensoring with @xmath238 and shifting the grading by @xmath239 this is exactly the functor on the right hand side of ( [ three - u ] ) .
@xmath220 the functors @xmath221 provide a functor realization of the temperley - lieb algebra ( compare to section [ tl - algebra ] and ( * ? ? ?
* section 4.1.2 ) ) . for
an abelian category @xmath240 denote by @xmath241 the homotopy category of bounded complexes of projective objects in @xmath242 an object @xmath26 of @xmath241 is a bounded complex of projective objects : @xmath243 a morphism @xmath103 from @xmath26 to @xmath48 is a collection of maps @xmath244 that intertwine differentials in @xmath26 and @xmath245 @xmath246 for all @xmath210 two morphisms @xmath247 are equal ( homotopic ) if there are maps @xmath248 such that @xmath249 for all @xmath210 as usual , @xmath250 $ ] denotes the self - equivalence of @xmath251 which shifts a complex @xmath200 degrees to the left : @xmath252^i = m^{k+i } , { \hspace{0.03in}}\partial_{m[k ] } = ( -1)^{k } \partial_m.$ ] given a map of complexes @xmath253 the cone of @xmath103 is the complex @xmath254\oplus n$ ] with the differential @xmath255 we refer the reader to @xcite for more information about homotopy and derived categories .
if @xmath240 has finite homological dimension , then @xmath241 is equivalent to the bounded derived category @xmath256 of @xmath242 this applies to @xmath257 by proposition [ prop : finite - hom - dim ] .
we will use @xmath258 instead of @xmath58 throughout , and denote it by @xmath259 the shift automorphism @xmath260 of @xmath78 extends in the obvious way to an automorphism of @xmath261 which we also denote by @xmath260 . note that @xmath260 and @xmath250 $ ] are quite different .
in fact , if we forget about the module structure and differential , objects of @xmath262 are bigraded abelian groups , so that it is natural to have two shift - like functors .
correspondingly , for any two such objects @xmath263 there is a bigraded morphism group ( of finite total rank ) @xmath264\{-r_2\}).\ ] ] let @xmath265 be a bounded complex of @xmath0-bimodules which are left and right projective , i.e. each @xmath266 is a projective left @xmath0-module and a projective right @xmath0-module .
one associates to @xmath267 the functor @xmath268 of tensoring with @xmath269 @xmath270 define homomorphisms @xmath272 of @xmath0-bimodules @xmath273 by @xmath274 ( when @xmath275 we omit the term @xmath276 from the sum for @xmath277 ) these homomorphisms induce natural transformations , also denoted @xmath278 between the functor @xmath221 , suitably shifted , and the identity functor : @xmath279 let @xmath280 be the complex of bimodules @xmath281 with @xmath0 in degree @xmath205 denote by @xmath282 the complex of bimodules @xmath283 with @xmath0 in degree @xmath205 next , we introduce functors @xmath271 and @xmath284 of tensoring with the complexes @xmath280 and @xmath282 respectively : @xmath285 the functor @xmath271 can be viewed as the cone of @xmath286 and @xmath284 as the cone of @xmath287 shifted by @xmath288.$ ] [ inverse ] the functors @xmath271 and @xmath284 are mutually inverse equivalences of categories , i.e. , there are functor isomorphisms @xmath289 the functor @xmath290 is given by tensoring with the complex @xmath291 of @xmath0-bimodules .
we write down this complex explicitly below .
first consider a commutative square of @xmath0-bimodules and @xmath0-bimodule homomorphisms @xmath292 here @xmath293 is the graded abelian group @xmath294 it is a free group of rank @xmath295 with a basis @xmath296 the maps @xmath297 and @xmath298 are given by @xmath299 define a map @xmath300 as the composition of @xmath301 and the map @xmath302 given by @xmath303 notice that @xmath304 we make the diagram ( [ cd - simple ] ) anticommutative by putting a minus sign in front of @xmath305 denote by @xmath306 the complex of bimodules , associated to this anticommutative diagram .
it has @xmath307 nonzero components @xmath308 and the differential @xmath309 reads @xmath310 it is easy to verify that @xmath48 is isomorphic to the complex @xmath311 thus , we want to show that , in the homotopy category of complexes of @xmath0-modules , tensoring with @xmath48 is equivalent to the identity functor , i.e. , to the functor of tensoring with @xmath312 considered as an @xmath0-bimodule .
we will decompose @xmath48 as a direct sum of a complex isomorphic to @xmath0 and an acyclic complex .
namely , @xmath48 splits into a direct sum of @xmath307 complexes , @xmath313 where @xmath314 @xmath315 is a subcomplex of @xmath48 generated by @xmath316 notice that @xmath317 is injective ( since @xmath318 a composition of @xmath319 and a projection , is injective ) and , therefore , @xmath315 is acyclic .
the complex @xmath320 is nonzero only in degrees @xmath235 and @xmath236 its degree @xmath235 component is @xmath321 considered as a subbimodule of @xmath322 and the degree @xmath323 component is @xmath324 the differential of @xmath320 induces an isomorphism between degree @xmath235 and degree @xmath323 components , and , thus , @xmath320 is acyclic .
finally , the complex @xmath325 is concentrated in horizontal degree @xmath326 and consists of the set of pairs @xmath327 where @xmath328 clearly , @xmath325 is isomorphic to the complex which has @xmath0 in horizontal degree @xmath235 and is trivial in all other degrees . therefore
, tensoring with @xmath325 is equivalent to the identity functor , while tensoring with @xmath329 is equivalent to tensoring with the zero complex .
it now follows that @xmath330 is isomorphic to the identity functor .
a similar computation gives an isomorphism of @xmath331 and the identity functor .
we have seen that the functor @xmath271 is invertible , with the inverse functor isomorphic to @xmath332 in view of this and for future convenience we will denote @xmath284 by @xmath333 [ theorem - braid ] there are functor isomorphisms @xmath334 the commutativity relation ( [ braid-2 ] ) follows at once from the obvious isomorphism @xmath335 of complexes of bimodules . indeed ,
both complexes are isomorphic to the complex @xmath336 therefore , we concentrate on proving ( [ braid-3 ] ) , which is equivalent to @xmath337 the functor on the left side is given by the tensor product with the complex of bimodules @xmath338 isomorphic to the cone of the map of complexes @xmath339 from the proof of proposition [ inverse ] we know that @xmath340 is isomorphic to the direct sum of an acyclic complex and the complex @xmath341 factoring out by the acyclic subcomplex we get a complex of bimodules ( quasi - isomorphic to ( [ onemore ] ) ) @xmath342 notice that @xmath343 is isomorphic to the complex of left modules @xmath344 where @xmath224 sits in the horizontal degree @xmath345 and @xmath346 is isomorphic to the complex of right modules @xmath347 where @xmath348 sits in degree @xmath205 therefore , the map ( [ slide1 ] ) has the form @xmath349 for some map @xmath350 of bimodules .
@xmath350 is completely described by two integers @xmath351 and @xmath352 where @xmath353 the condition @xmath354 implies @xmath355 moreover , if @xmath356 we can quickly come to a contradiction by picking a prime divisor @xmath357 of @xmath358 reducing all modules and functors mod @xmath357 and concluding that the functor @xmath359 ( invertible over any base field ) decomposes as a nontrivial direct sum in characteristic @xmath208 thus , @xmath360 or @xmath361 multiplying each element of the bimodule @xmath0 by @xmath362 if necessary , we can assume that @xmath360 and @xmath363 the right hand side functor of ( [ braid-3a ] ) is given by tensoring with the complex of bimodules @xmath364 since @xmath365 is isomorphic to @xmath366 and @xmath367 is isomorphic to @xmath368 the right hand side of ( [ braid-3a ] ) is isomorphic to the functor of tensoring with the cone @xmath369 for some bimodule map @xmath370 using the same argument as for @xmath350 we can assume that @xmath371 and @xmath372 therefore , @xmath373 and the two functors in ( [ braid-3a ] ) are isomorphic .
@xmath220 a weak action of a group @xmath6 on a category @xmath374 is a choice of functors @xmath375 for each @xmath376 such that @xmath377 is the identity functor and functors @xmath378 and @xmath379 are isomorphic for all @xmath380 to each element @xmath381 of the braid group @xmath4 we associate a complex @xmath382 of graded @xmath0-bimodules as follows . to @xmath383 associate the complex @xmath384 and to @xmath385 the complex @xmath386 in general ,
fix a decomposition of @xmath381 as a product of generators @xmath383 of the braid group and their inverses , @xmath387 then define @xmath382 as the tensor product of corresponding complexes : @xmath388 finally , define @xmath389 as the functor of tensoring with the bimodule @xmath382 : @xmath390 proposition [ inverse ] and theorem [ theorem - braid ] together are equivalent to the functors @xmath391 for @xmath392 define a weak action of the braid group on the category @xmath393 a weak action of @xmath6 on a category @xmath374 is called _ faithful _
if for any @xmath394 the functor @xmath17 is not isomorphic to the identity functor .
we will prove in section [ normal - complex ] that the above braid group action is faithful . in this subsection
we link the burau representation with the braid group action in the derived category @xmath395 we also relate @xmath0 and highest weight categories .
recall that the grothendieck group @xmath397 of the category @xmath396 is the group formed by virtual graded @xmath0-modules @xmath398-[n],$ ] with a suitable equivalence relation .
the functor @xmath399 makes @xmath397 into a module over @xmath87.$ ] in fact , it is a free @xmath87$]-module of rank @xmath400 as a basis one can take the images of projective modules @xmath401 the functor @xmath221 is exact and induces a @xmath87$]-linear map @xmath402 $ ] on @xmath403 the functor @xmath271 is the cone of @xmath404 and so it induces a linear map @xmath405= [ \mbox{id}]-[{\mathcal u}_i]$ ] on @xmath403 since the @xmath271 satisfy braid group relations , the operators @xmath405 $ ] define a representation of the braid group on @xmath403 the generators of the braid group act as follows : @xmath406 & = & - q [ p_i ] , \\
\sigma_i [ p_{i+1 } ] & = & [ p_{i+1}]-[p_i ] , \\
\sigma_i [ p_{i-1 } ] & = & [ p_{i-1}]-q[p_i ] , \\ \sigma_i [ p_j ] & = & [ p_j ] \mbox { for } |i - j|>1 .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the braid group action on the grothendieck group preserves the @xmath87$]-submodule of @xmath397 spanned by @xmath407 , [ p_2 ] , \dots , [ p_m].$ ] denote this submodule by @xmath408 comparing with the burau representation ( see @xcite ) we obtain the representation on @xmath397 is equivalent to the burau representation , and its restriction to @xmath409 is equivalent to the reduced burau representation .
let @xmath410 be the lie algebra of traceless @xmath411-matrices with complex coefficients .
let @xmath412 be the subalgebra of traceless diagonal matrices and @xmath413 be the subalgebra of matrices with zeros in all off - diagonal entries of the first column .
let @xmath414 be the center of the universal enveloping algebra @xmath415 and denote by @xmath416 the maximal ideal of @xmath414 which is the kernel of the augmentation homomorphism @xmath417 denote by @xmath418 the category whose objects are finitely - generated @xmath415-modules that are @xmath419-diagonalizable , @xmath420-locally finite and annihilated by some power of the maximal central ideal @xmath421 morphisms are @xmath415-module maps ( a @xmath415-module @xmath26 is said to be @xmath420-locally finite if for any @xmath422 the vector space @xmath423 is finite - dimensional ) . by a base change
we can make the ring @xmath0 into an algebra over the field of complex numbers , @xmath424 let @xmath425-mod denote the category of finitely - generated left @xmath425-modules ( no grading this time ) .
we learned the following result and its proof from maxim vybornov : [ highest - weight ] the categories @xmath418 and @xmath426 are equivalent .
the category @xmath418 consists of modules from a regular block of the bernstein - gelfand - gelfand category @xmath427 for @xmath410 which are locally @xmath420-finite , where @xmath413 is the parabolic subalgebra described above .
let @xmath428 be indecomposable projective modules in @xmath429 one for each isomorphism class of indecomposable projectives .
form the projective module @xmath430 the category @xmath418 is equivalent to the category of modules over the algebra @xmath431 we claim that @xmath432 is isomorphic to @xmath433 indeed , from @xcite we know that @xmath432 has a structure of a @xmath434-graded algebra , @xmath435 such that @xmath432 is multiplicatively generated by @xmath436 over @xmath437 with quadratic defining relations .
moreover , @xmath432 is koszul and the category of representations of its koszul dual algebra @xmath438 is equivalent to a certain singular block of the category @xmath427 for @xmath410 ( this is just a special case of the beilinson - ginzburg - soergel parabolic - singular duality @xcite ) .
the algebra @xmath439 describing this singular block , was written down by irving ( see ( * ? ? ?
* section 6.5 ) ) . recall that @xmath0 is the quotient ring of the path ring of the quiver associated to the graph @xmath60 by certain relations among paths of length @xmath440 the algebra @xmath438 is the quotient algebra of the path algebra of the quiver with the same graph @xmath60 but different set of quadratic relations : @xmath441 an easy computation establishes that the koszul dual to @xmath438 is isomorphic to @xmath433 therefore , algebras @xmath432 and @xmath425 are isomorphic .
@xmath220 _ remark : _ the grading which makes @xmath0 into a quadratic and koszul algebra is the grading by the length of paths .
this is different from the grading on @xmath0 defined in section 1b and used throughout this paper . an alternative proof of proposition [ highest - weight ] , which also engages koszul duality , goes as follows .
the category @xmath418 is equivalent to the category of perverse sheaves on the projective space @xmath442 which are locally constant on each stratum @xmath443 of the stratification of @xmath444 by a chain of projective spaces @xmath445 ( this is a special case of ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.5.3 ) ) .
since the closure of each strata is smooth , the simple perverse sheaf @xmath446 is , up to a shift in the derived category , the continuation by @xmath235 of the constant sheaf on @xmath447 the ext algebra @xmath448 can be easily written down , in particular , @xmath449 this algebra is then seen to be koszul dual to @xmath425 , which implies proposition [ highest - weight ] .
we thus matched the category of @xmath425-modules with the category @xmath450 the functors @xmath221 in the category @xmath451 have a simple interpretation in the framework of highest weight categories .
this interpretation is easy to guess , since the @xmath221 s are exact functors while translation functors , and , more generally , projective functors ( see @xcite and references therein ) constitute the main examples of exact functors in @xmath452 precisely , under the equivalence of categories @xmath453 the functor @xmath221 ( formula ( [ uu : equation ] ) becomes the functor of translation across the @xmath73-th wall . @xmath221 is the composition of tensoring with @xmath348 over @xmath0 and then tensoring with @xmath224 over @xmath454 translation across the wall functor , on the other hand , is the composition of translation on and off the wall functors . for our particular parabolic subcategory of a regular block ,
translation on the wall functor takes it to the category equivalent to the category of @xmath140-vector spaces . translation on and off the @xmath73-th wall functors
are two - sided adjoints , and the adjointness morphisms give rise to natural transformations between @xmath221 and the identity functor .
these transformations should coincide with natural transformations @xmath455 and @xmath301 ( see formulas ( [ beta ] ) and ( [ gamma ] ) ) .
the bimodule homomorphism @xmath457 is simply a direct summand of the multiplication map @xmath458 the homomorphism @xmath459 which goes the other way , is only slightly more mysterious and can be interpreted as follows . for simplicity of the discussion change the base ring from @xmath107 to a field @xmath460 and ignore the grading of @xmath2 one checks that for @xmath461 the projective module @xmath224 is also injective , and for any @xmath0-module @xmath26 there is a nondegenerate pairing @xmath462 which defines an isomorphism @xmath463 functorial in @xmath464 armed with the latter , we can rewrite the evaluation morphism @xmath465 as a functorial map @xmath466 which , in turn , determines a bimodule map @xmath467 this map is precisely @xmath468 the temperley - lieb algebra @xmath469 has generators @xmath470 and defining relations @xmath471 the temperley - lieb algebra is a quotient of the hecke algebra of the symmetric group . just like the hecke algebra ,
the temperley - lieb algebra is semisimple for a generic @xmath472 and acquires a radical at certain roots of unity .
let @xmath473 and @xmath474 .
a theorem of paul martin ( see @xcite , chapter 7 , for the exact statement ) says that @xmath469 is isomorphic to the direct sum of matrix algebras and algebras morita equivalent to @xmath2 alternative proofs of this result can be found in westbury @xcite , goodman and wenzl @xcite .
this part of the paper collects the necessary results about curves on surfaces .
the first section , in which geometric intersection numbers are defined , is a mild generalization of ( * ? ? ?
* expos iii ) . as an easy application
, we give a proof of the theorem of birman and hilden which was mentioned in section [ subsec : results ] .
after that we introduce the bigraded version of geometric intersection numbers . finally , we consider a way of decomposing curves on a disc into certain standard pieces .
the basic idea of this is again taken from ( * ? ? ?
* expos iv ) .
let @xmath57 be a compact oriented surface , possibly with boundary , and @xmath475 a finite set of marked points .
@xmath476 is the group of diffeomorphisms @xmath477 with @xmath478 and @xmath105 . by a _ curve in @xmath479 _ we mean a subset @xmath480 which is either a simple closed curve in @xmath481 and essential ( not contractible in @xmath482 ) , or else the image of an embedding @xmath483 \longrightarrow s$ ] which is transverse to @xmath484 and such that @xmath485 .
thus , our curves are smooth and unoriented .
two curves @xmath486 are called isotopic if one can be deformed into the other by an isotopy in @xmath476 ; we write @xmath487 for this . note that endpoints on @xmath484 may not move during an isotopy .
let @xmath488 be two curves in @xmath479 .
we say that they have _ minimal intersection _ if they intersect transversally , satisfy @xmath489 , and the following condition is satisfied : take any two points @xmath490 in @xmath491 which do not both lie in @xmath97 , and two arcs @xmath492 , @xmath493 with endpoints @xmath494 , such that @xmath495 .
let @xmath496 be the connected component of @xmath497 which is bounded by @xmath498 .
then if @xmath496 is topologically an open disc , it must contain at least one point of @xmath97 . + among the examples in figure [ fig : minimal - intersection ] , ( a ) and ( b ) do not have minimal intersection while ( c ) and ( d ) do .
[ th : no - maps ] assume that @xmath499 .
let @xmath486 be two curves in @xmath500 which intersect transversally and satisfy @xmath489 .
they have minimal intersection iff the following property holds : there is no continuous map @xmath501 ^ 2 \longrightarrow s$ ] with @xmath502 , @xmath503 , @xmath504 and @xmath505 for all @xmath506 , where @xmath490 are points of @xmath491 . the proof is a very slightly modified version of the equivalence @xmath507 of ( * ? ? ?
* proposition iii.10 ) .
note that one of the implications is obvious .
there is a similar result for @xmath508 but we will not need it . given two curves @xmath488 in @xmath479 with @xmath489 , one can always find a @xmath509 which has minimal intersection with @xmath510 , by successively killing the unnecessary intersection points .
we define the geometric intersection number @xmath511 to be @xmath512 if @xmath486 are simple closed curves with @xmath513 , and by the formula @xmath514 in all other cases . in words , one counts the intersection points of @xmath510 and @xmath515 , common endpoints in @xmath97 having weight @xmath516 . the exceptional case in the definition can be motivated by floer cohomology , or by looking at the behaviour of @xmath517 on double branched covers ( see section [ subsec : branched - cover ] ) .
the fact that @xmath518 is independent of the choice of @xmath515 follows from the next two lemmas . once this has been established , it is obvious that it is an invariant of the isotopy classes of @xmath510 and @xmath519 .
[ th : minimal - intersection ] let @xmath510 be a curve in @xmath479 .
let @xmath520 be two other curves such that both @xmath521 and @xmath522 have minimal intersection , and with @xmath523 .
assume moreover that @xmath524 .
then there is an isotopy rel @xmath510 which carries @xmath515 to @xmath525 ( more formally , there is a smooth path @xmath526 in @xmath476 such that @xmath527 for all @xmath528 , @xmath529 , and @xmath530 ) . for closed curves
this is ( * ? ? ?
* proposition iii.12 ) ; the proof of the general case is similar . the assumption that @xmath531 can not be removed , but there is a slightly weaker statement which fills the gap : [ th : isotopic - curves ] let @xmath486 be two curves in @xmath479 which are isotopic and have minimal intersection ( by definition , this implies that the @xmath532 are either closed , or else that their endpoints all lie in @xmath97 ) .
then there is an isotopy rel @xmath510 which carries @xmath519 to one of the curves @xmath520 shown ( in the two cases ) in figure [ fig : isotopic ] .
+ the geometric intersection number can be extended to curves @xmath488 which intersect on @xmath484 , as follows : take a nonvanishing vector field on @xmath484 which is positively oriented , and extend it to a smooth vector field @xmath414 on @xmath57 which vanishes on @xmath97 .
let @xmath533 be the flow of @xmath414 .
set @xmath534 for some small @xmath535 , and define @xmath536 .
this depends on the orientation of @xmath57 , and is also no longer symmetric .
let @xmath93 be a closed disc , with some fixed orientation , and @xmath537 a set of @xmath538 marked points .
@xmath539 denotes the configuration space of unordered @xmath3-tuples of points in @xmath540 as in section [ subsec : results ] we write @xmath102 .
there is a well - known canonical isomorphism @xmath541 defined as follows : take the evaluation map @xmath542 , @xmath543 .
this is a serre fibration , with the fibre at @xmath97 being exactly @xmath544 , and is the boundary map in the resulting sequence of homotopy groups . from now on , by a curve we mean a curve in @xmath116 , unless otherwise specified .
a _ basic set of curves _ is a collection of curves @xmath115 which looks like that in figure[fig : basic - curves ] ( more rigorously , this means that the @xmath121 can be obtained by applying some element of @xmath544 to the collection drawn in figure [ fig : basic - curves ] ) .
[ th : curves - and - diffeos ] let @xmath115 be a basic set of curves . if @xmath106 satisfies @xmath545 for all @xmath73 , then @xmath546 \in \pi_0({\mathcal{g}})$ ] is the identity class .
the proof is not difficult ( it rests on the fact that one can isotop such an @xmath103 to a @xmath16 which satisfies @xmath547 for all @xmath73 ) .
a basic set of curves determines a preferred isomorphism between @xmath4 , which we think of as an abstract group defined by the standard presentation , and @xmath548 resp .
concretely , the @xmath73-th generator @xmath383 ( @xmath550 ) of @xmath4 goes to the isotopy class @xmath551 \in \pi_0({\mathcal{g}})$ ] of the half - twist along @xmath121 .
this half - twist is a diffeomorphism which is trivial outside a small neighbourhood of @xmath121 , which reverses @xmath121 itself , and such that the image of @xmath552 is as shown in figure [ fig : half - twist](a ) .
the corresponding element in the fundamental group of the configuration space is the path which rotates the two endpoints of @xmath121 around each other by @xmath553 , see figure [ fig : half - twist](b ) .
+ fix a basic set of curves @xmath115 .
a curve @xmath143 will be called admissible if it is equal to @xmath554 for some @xmath106 and @xmath555 .
the endpoints of an admissible curve must lie in @xmath556 ; conversely any curve with such endpoints is admissible .
there is an obvious action of @xmath548 on the set of isotopy classes of admissible curves .
lemma [ th : curves - and - diffeos ] is a faithfulness result for this action : it shows that only the identity element acts trivially .
[ th : like - ck ] let @xmath143 be an admissible curve .
assume that there is a @xmath557 such that @xmath558 for all @xmath559 .
then @xmath560 here @xmath561 are the positive dehn twists along the closed curves @xmath562 shown in figure [ fig : loops ] .
+ we will only explain the proof for @xmath563 ; the other cases are similar .
we may assume that @xmath176 , since the statement is fairly obvious for @xmath564 .
let @xmath143 be a curve satisfying the conditions in the lemma . since @xmath565 is not integral , @xmath143 and @xmath566 have precisely one endpoint in common
. this common endpoint could either be @xmath567 or @xmath568 , but the first case is impossible because @xmath569 .
we have now shown that @xmath143 and @xmath570 have one endpoint in common .
it follows that the other endpoints of these two curves must also be the same , since @xmath571 is integral .
next , we can assume that @xmath143 has minimal intersection with all the @xmath121 ( this is because the `` shortening moves '' which kill unnecessary points of @xmath572 do not create new intersection points with any other @xmath573 ) .
again by using geometric intersection numbers , it follows that only the endpoints of @xmath143 lie on @xmath574 .
this means that we can consider @xmath143 as a curve on the surface obtained by cutting @xmath93 open along @xmath575 .
the rest is straightforward .
[ th : detect - identity ] if @xmath106 satisfies @xmath576 for all @xmath577 , then @xmath546 \in \pi_0({\mathcal{g}})$ ] is the identity class . applying lemma [ th : like - ck ] to @xmath578 shows that there are numbers @xmath579 and @xmath580 , such that @xmath581 since the @xmath582 commute , and @xmath583 for all @xmath584 , the map @xmath585 satisfies @xmath586 for all @xmath214 . by lemma
[ th : curves - and - diffeos ] it follows that @xmath103 and @xmath16 lie in the same isotopy class .
applying the same argument to @xmath587 shows that it can be written , up to isotopy , as a product @xmath588 with numbers @xmath589 satisfying the same properties as @xmath590 . in @xmath548
we have therefore @xmath591 = [ f^2 ] = [ \tau_0^{\mu_0 } \dots \tau_{m-1}^{\mu_{m-1}}].\ ] ] since the @xmath582 generate a free abelian subgroup of rank @xmath592 in @xmath548 , one has @xmath593 for all @xmath214 . now
@xmath594 which implies that @xmath595 , hence that @xmath546 = [ { \mathrm{id}}]$ ] . in this section
we assume that @xmath93 is embedded in @xmath140 .
the double cover of @xmath93 branched along @xmath97 is , by definition , @xmath596 where @xmath597 $ ] is a polynomial which has simple zeros exactly at the points of @xmath97 .
[ th : preimage ] let @xmath143 be a curve in @xmath116 such that @xmath598 ( in future , we will say that @xmath143 meets @xmath97 if this is the case ) .
then @xmath599 is a curve in @xmath500 .
let @xmath99 be a point of @xmath600 , and @xmath601 a local parametrization of @xmath143 near that point .
one can write @xmath602 for some @xmath603 .
choose a square root @xmath604 .
then a local smooth parametrization of @xmath599 near @xmath605 is given by @xmath606 , @xmath607 .
the smoothness of @xmath599 at all other points is obvious . as for the topology , there are ( because of the assumption @xmath598 ) only two possibilities : either @xmath143 is a path joining two points of @xmath97 , and then @xmath599 is a simple closed curve which is not homologous to zero ; or @xmath143 connects a point of @xmath97 with a point of @xmath100 , and then @xmath599 is a path connecting two points of @xmath484 .
[ th : lifting - curves ] let @xmath486 be curves on @xmath116 , both of which meet @xmath97 .
assume that they have minimal intersection and are not isotopic .
then @xmath608 also have minimal intersection .
it is clear that @xmath609 and @xmath610 intersect transversally , and do not intersect on @xmath484 .
let @xmath611 be a thickening of @xmath612 , such that @xmath613 is a surface with corners .
more precisely , the thickening ( shown in figure[fig : corners ] ) should be done in such a way that a point of @xmath614 gives rise to four corners of @xmath613 , and a point of @xmath615 to two corners .
take some connected component @xmath496 of @xmath613 which satisfies @xmath616 .
then at least one of the following three assertions is true : ( 1 ) @xmath496 is not contractible ; ( 2 ) it has at least three corners ; ( 3 ) it has two corners and contains at least one point of @xmath97 .
the point here is that @xmath496 can not be a @xmath295-gon ( a disc with two corners ) and disjoint from @xmath97 , since our assumptions exclude all the four situations shown in figure [ fig : minimal - intersection ] : ( a),(b ) because of the minimal intersection , ( c ) because @xmath617 , and ( d ) because @xmath486 are not closed curves . + if ( 1 ) holds then the preimage @xmath618 may consist of one or two connected components , but none of them can be contractible . if ( 2 ) holds the connected components of @xmath618 may be contractible , but each of them has at least three corners . if ( 3 ) holds then @xmath618 is connected with at least four corners , since its boundary is a double cover of the boundary of @xmath496 .
we have now shown that no connected component of @xmath619 can be a @xmath295-gon and disjoint from @xmath484 . essentially by definition
, this means that @xmath609 and @xmath610 have minimal intersection .
[ th : lifting - isotopies ] let @xmath488 be two curves on @xmath116 , both of which meet @xmath97 , such that @xmath620 .
assume that @xmath617
. then @xmath621 . then @xmath622 , because we have assumed that the intersection of these two sets is zero .
it follows that @xmath623 , so these two curves can not be isotopic .
* case 2 : * _ @xmath486 are contained in @xmath624_. this means that both of them are paths joining two points of @xmath97 . since the statement is one about isotopy classes , we may assume that @xmath486 have minimal intersection .
then the same holds for @xmath608 by lemma [ th : lifting - curves ] .
assume that , contrary to what we want to show , @xmath625 .
then lemma [ th : isotopic - curves ] implies that @xmath626 , so that @xmath627 , and in particular @xmath628 .
but then @xmath609 and @xmath610 are not even homologous , which is a contradiction . [
th : comparing - gin ] let @xmath486 be curves in @xmath116 , both of which meet @xmath97 .
then @xmath629 it is enough to prove the statement for @xmath630 , since the other situation reduces to this by definition .
* case 1 : * @xmath513 .
because we are assuming that @xmath630 , this means that @xmath486 are paths connecting two points of @xmath97 ; then @xmath631 . on the other hand @xmath609 and @xmath610
are simple closed curves and isotopic , so that @xmath632 .
* case 2 : * @xmath617
. then @xmath633 by lemma [ th : lifting - isotopies ] .
choose a @xmath509 which has minimal intersection with @xmath510 .
by lemma [ th : lifting - curves ] one has @xmath634 .
any @xmath106 can be lifted in a unique way to a homeomorphism @xmath635 of @xmath57 with @xmath636 .
if @xmath103 is holomorphic in some neighbourhood of each point of @xmath97 , then @xmath635 is again smooth .
this defines a lifting homomorphism @xmath637 .
[ th : birman - hilden ] the lifting homomorphism is injective .
choose a set of basic curves
@xmath638 in @xmath116 .
consider a map @xmath639 which is holomorphic near each point of @xmath97 , and assume that @xmath546 $ ] lies in the kernel of the lifting homomorphism .
then @xmath640 for any curve @xmath143 which meets @xmath97 .
therefore , by lemma [ th : comparing - gin ] , @xmath641 for @xmath642 .
the same clearly holds for @xmath587 .
lemma [ th : detect - identity ] shows that @xmath546 $ ] must be the identity class .
we have chosen this proof , which is not the most direct one , because it serves as a model for later arguments .
one can in fact avoid geometric intersection numbers entirely , by generalizing lemma [ th : lifting - isotopies ] to the case when @xmath643 is not necessarily empty , and then using lemma [ th : curves - and - diffeos ] . birman and
hilden s original paper @xcite contains a stronger result ( they identify the image of the lifting homomorphism ) and their approach is entirely different .
let @xmath644 be the ( real ) projectivization of the tangent bundle of @xmath645 .
we want to introduce a particular covering of @xmath646 with covering group @xmath647 .
take an oriented trivialization of @xmath648 ; this allows one to identify @xmath649 . for every point @xmath650 choose a small loop @xmath651 winding positively once around it .
the classes @xmath652 $ ] together with @xmath653 $ ] form a basis of @xmath654 .
let @xmath655 be the cohomology class which satisfies @xmath656 ) = ( -2,1)$ ] and @xmath657 ) = ( 1,0)$ ] .
define @xmath658 to be the covering classified by @xmath659 , and denote the @xmath647-action on it by @xmath660 .
this is independent of the choices we have made , up to isomorphism .
any @xmath106 induces a diffeomorphism of @xmath646 which , since it preserves @xmath659 , can be lifted to an equivariant diffeomorphism of @xmath658 .
there is a unique such lift , denoted by @xmath661 , which acts trivially on the fibre of @xmath658 over any point @xmath662 , @xmath663 . for any curve @xmath143
there is a canonical section @xmath664 given by @xmath665 .
a _ bigrading _ of @xmath143 is a lift @xmath666 of @xmath667 to @xmath658 .
pairs @xmath668 consisting of a curve and a bigrading are called _ bigraded curves _ ; we will often write @xmath669 instead of @xmath668 . @xmath660 defines a @xmath647-action on the set of bigraded curves , and the lifts @xmath670 yield a @xmath544-action on the same set .
there is an obvious notion of isotopy for bigraded curves , and one obtains induced actions of @xmath647 and @xmath548 on the set of isotopy classes . an alternative formulation is as follows .
assume that @xmath93 is embedded in @xmath140 , and let @xmath597 $ ] be as in the previous section .
the embedding @xmath671 gives a preferred trivialization of @xmath672 which we use to identify @xmath646 with @xmath673 the map @xmath674 represents @xmath659 .
hence one can take @xmath658 to be the pullback of the universal covering @xmath675 , @xmath676 .
then a bigrading of a curve @xmath143 is just a continuous lift @xmath677 of the map @xmath678 , @xmath679 ; and the @xmath647-action is by adding constant functions to @xmath669 . to put it even more concretely ,
take an embedding @xmath680 which parametrizes an open subset of @xmath681 .
then the map which one has to lift can be written as @xmath682 a curve @xmath143 admits a bigrading iff it is not a simple closed curve . if @xmath143 is not a simple closed curve , @xmath681 is contractible , so that the pullback @xmath683 is the trivial covering .
conversely , if @xmath143 is a simple closed curve and bounds a region of @xmath93 containing @xmath684 points of @xmath97 , then @xmath685 ) = \pm ( 2 - 2k , k ) \neq 0 $ ] , which means that @xmath686 does not admit a section .
[ th : self - isotopy ] the @xmath647-action on the set of isotopy classes of bigraded curves is free .
equivalently , a bigraded curve @xmath669 is never isotopic to @xmath687 for any @xmath688 .
let @xmath143 be a curve which connects two points @xmath689 .
let @xmath690 be an isotopy in @xmath544 with @xmath529 and @xmath691 . without any real loss of generality we may assume that @xmath692 .
* claim : * _ the closed path @xmath693 \longrightarrow d \setminus \delta$ ] , @xmath694 is freely nullhomotopic for each @xmath695_. the free homotopy class of @xmath696 is evidently independent of @xmath99 . on the other hand , for @xmath99 close to @xmath697
it must be a multiple of the free homotopy class of @xmath698 , and the corresponding statement holds for @xmath99 close to @xmath699 ; which proves our claim . as a consequence one can deform the isotopy @xmath526 , rel endpoints , into another isotopy @xmath700 such that @xmath701 agrees with @xmath143 in a neighbourhood of @xmath702 for all @xmath528 .
by considering the preferred lifts @xmath703 one sees immediately that @xmath704 for any bigrading @xmath669 .
the proof for the remaining types of curves , which satisfy @xmath705 , is much easier , and we leave it to the reader .
[ th : self - shift ] let @xmath143 be a curve which joins two points of @xmath97 , @xmath706 the half twist along it , and @xmath707 its preferred lift to @xmath658 .
then @xmath708 for any bigrading @xmath669 of @xmath143 .
since @xmath709 , one has @xmath710 for some @xmath711 .
take an embedded smooth path @xmath712 \longrightarrow d \setminus \delta$ ] from a point @xmath713 to the unique point @xmath714 which is a fixed point of @xmath715 ; figure [ fig : self - shift ] illustrates the situation . consider the closed path @xmath716 \longrightarrow p$ ] given by @xmath717 for @xmath718 , and by @xmath719 for @xmath720 .
it is not difficult to see that ( with respect to the basis of @xmath654 which we have used before ) @xmath721 = -[{{\mathbb{r}}{\mathrm p}^{1 } } \times point ] - [ point \times \lambda_z]$ ] , where @xmath99 is one of the endpoints of @xmath143 .
therefore @xmath722 ) = c([{{\mathbb{r}}{\mathrm p}^{1 } } \times point ] ) + c([point \times \lambda_z ] ) = ( -1,1)$ ] .
+ let @xmath723 and @xmath724 be two bigraded curves , and @xmath725 a point where @xmath510 and @xmath519 intersect transversally ; @xmath99 may lie in @xmath97 or not .
fix a small circle @xmath726 around @xmath99 .
let @xmath727 \longrightarrow l$ ] be an embedded arc which moves clockwise around @xmath63 , such that @xmath728 and @xmath729 .
if @xmath650 then @xmath138 is unique up to a change of parametrization ; otherwise there are two possibilities , which are distinguished by their endpoints ( see figure [ fig : local - index ] ) .
take a smooth path @xmath730 \longrightarrow p$ ] with @xmath731 for all @xmath528 , going from @xmath732 to @xmath733 , such that @xmath734 for all @xmath528 .
one can picture @xmath735 as a family of tangent lines along @xmath138 which are all transverse to @xmath63 ( see again figure[fig : local - index ] ) .
lift @xmath735 to a path @xmath736 \longrightarrow { \widetilde{p}}$ ] with @xmath737 ; necessarily @xmath738 for some @xmath739 .
we define the local index of @xmath740 at @xmath99 to be @xmath741 ; it is not difficult to see that this is independent of all choices .
+ now let @xmath742 , @xmath743 be two bigraded curves such that @xmath744 .
choose a @xmath509 which has minimal intersection with @xmath510 .
there is a bigrading @xmath745 of @xmath515 , which is unique by lemma [ th : self - isotopy ] , such that @xmath746 .
the bigraded intersection number @xmath747 $ ] is defined by @xmath748 where @xmath749 . the proof that this is independent of the choice of @xmath515 , and is an invariant of the isotopy classes of @xmath750 , is basically the same as for ordinary geometric intersection numbers .
the only non - obvious case is when @xmath510 and @xmath519 are isotopic , because then there are two essentially different choices for @xmath515 .
however , an explicit computation shows that both choices lead to the same result .
bigraded intersection numbers can be extended to curves with @xmath751 just like ordinary ones , by taking a flow @xmath533 which moves @xmath100 in the positive sense , lifting the induced flow on @xmath646 to one @xmath752 on @xmath658 such that @xmath753 and setting @xmath754 for small @xmath535 .
we list some elementary properties of @xmath755 : @xmath518 is obtained from @xmath756 by setting @xmath757 and dividing by two ; [ item : bigraded - map ] @xmath758 for any @xmath106 ; [ item : bigraded - shift ] @xmath759 .
[ item : symmetry ] if @xmath630 and @xmath760 then @xmath761 . the only item which requires some explanation is the last one .
assume that @xmath486 have minimal intersection .
the local index has the following symmetry property : @xmath762 one sees immediately that [ item : symmetry ] holds for the contributions coming from points of @xmath763 .
now take a point @xmath764 , and assume for simplicity that @xmath765
. then the contribution of @xmath99 to @xmath756 is @xmath766 .
since @xmath767 , the same point contributes @xmath768 to @xmath769 , which is in agreement with [ item : symmetry ] .
we point out that the term @xmath770 in the definition of bigraded intersection numbers was essential in this computation .
fix a set of basic curves @xmath771 .
in addition choose curves @xmath772 as in figure [ fig : bc ] which divide @xmath93 into regions @xmath773 .
we say that an admissible curve @xmath143 is in normal form if it has minimal intersection with all the @xmath774 .
this can always be an achieved by an isotopy .
the corresponding uniqueness theorem is a slight generalization of lemma [ th : minimal - intersection ] : + [ th : normal - form ] let @xmath486 be two isotopic admissible curves , both of which are in normal form .
then there is an isotopy rel @xmath775 which carries @xmath510 to @xmath519 .
let @xmath143 be a curve in normal form .
each connected component of @xmath776 belongs to one of finitely many classes or types . for @xmath777
there are six such types , denoted by @xmath323 , @xmath778 , @xmath295 , @xmath779 , @xmath307 , @xmath780 ( see figure [ fig : typesa ] ; the numbers @xmath781 here and in the subsequent figures are for later use , and the reader should ignore them at present ) . for @xmath782
there are two types , which are analogues of the types @xmath295 and @xmath307 considered before ; we use the same notation for them ( figure [ fig : typesb ] ) . for @xmath783
there is a single type , for which we will not need a proper name ( figure [ fig : typesc ] ) .
conversely , it is not difficult to prove that an admissible curve @xmath143 which intersects all the @xmath774 transversally , and such that each connected component of @xmath776 belongs to one of the types listed in figures [ fig : typesa][fig : typesc ] , is already in normal form . for a completely accurate formulation
, one should consider the group @xmath784 of diffeomorphisms @xmath785 which satisfy @xmath786 , @xmath787 , @xmath788 , and @xmath789 .
our list of types classifies each connected component of @xmath776 up to an isotopy in @xmath784 .
lemma [ th : normal - form ] implies that the number of connected components of each type , as well as their relative position and the way in which they join each other , is an invariant of the isotopy class of @xmath143 . for the rest of this section
, @xmath143 is an admissible curve in normal form .
the points of @xmath790 are called _ crossings _ , and those in the subset @xmath791 are called _
@xmath200-crossings _ of @xmath792 the connected components of @xmath793 @xmath794 are called _ segments _ of @xmath792 a segment is _ essential _ if its endpoints are both crossings ( as opposed to points of @xmath795 ) .
thus , the essential segments are precisely those of type @xmath796 or @xmath797 note that the basic curves @xmath771 have no essential segments .
@xmath143 can be reconstructed up to isotopy by listing its crossings , plus the types of essential segments bounded by consecutive crossings aw one travels along @xmath143 from one end to the other .
conversely , lemma [ th : normal - form ] shows that this combinatorial data is an invariant of the isotopy class of @xmath792 we now discuss how the normal form changes under the half - twist @xmath798 along @xmath799 the curve @xmath800 in general , is not in normal form .
@xmath800 however , has minimal intersection with each @xmath801 for @xmath802 to bring @xmath803 into normal form we only need to simplify its intersections with @xmath804 more precisely , there is a bijection between connected components of the intersection of @xmath143 and @xmath803 with @xmath805 take a connected component @xmath806 of @xmath807 and deform ( inside @xmath808 ) the twisted component @xmath809 keeping its intersection with @xmath810 fixed , so that it has minimal intersection with @xmath804 after simplifying each connected component of @xmath807 in this way we end up with normal form for @xmath811 we collect our observations into the following [ bijections ] ( a ) the normal form of @xmath803 coincides with @xmath143 outside of @xmath812 the curve @xmath803 can be brought into normal form by an isotopy inside @xmath812 \(b ) now assume that @xmath803 is in normal form .
there is a natural bijection between @xmath73-nodes of @xmath143 and @xmath803 for each @xmath802 there is a natural bijection between connected components of intersections of @xmath143 and @xmath803 with @xmath805 define a @xmath200__-string of _ _ @xmath143 as a connected component of @xmath813 denote by @xmath814 the set of @xmath200-strings of @xmath792 define a @xmath200__-string _ _ as a curve in @xmath815 which is a connected component of @xmath816 for some admissible curve @xmath143 ( recall that we assume @xmath143 to be in normal form ) .
we say that two @xmath200-strings are isotopic ( or belong to the same isotopy class ) if there is a deformation of one into the other via diffeomorphisms @xmath103 of @xmath817 which satisfy @xmath818 and @xmath819 isotopy classes of @xmath200-strings can be divided into types as follows : there are five infinite families @xmath820 , @xmath821 , @xmath822 , @xmath823 , @xmath824 @xmath825 and five exceptional types @xmath826 , @xmath827 , @xmath828 , @xmath829 and @xmath830 . the exceptional types , and the members @xmath831 of the families , are drawn in figure [ fig : infinite - typesa ] .
the rule for generating the other members is that the @xmath832-st is obtained from the @xmath833-th by applying @xmath798 . as an example
, figure [ fig : itype - example ] shows type @xmath834 . for @xmath563 there is a similar list , which consists of two families and two exceptional types ( figure [ fig : infinite - typesb ] ) .
finally , for @xmath783 there are just five exceptional types ( figure[fig : infinite - typesc ] ) . + according to our definition
, @xmath200-strings are already assumed to be in `` normal form , '' i.e. to have minimal intersection with @xmath804 define _ crossings _ and _ essential segments _ of @xmath200-strings in the same way as for admissible curves in normal form .
denote by @xmath835 the set of crossings of a @xmath200-string @xmath836 [ th : almost - normal - i ] if @xmath837 , the geometric intersection number @xmath838 can be computed as follows : every @xmath200-string of @xmath143 which is of type @xmath820 , @xmath821 , @xmath822 or @xmath830 contributes @xmath323 , those of type @xmath823 , @xmath824 contribute @xmath516 , and the rest zero .
similarly , for @xmath783 the types @xmath839 and @xmath840 contribute @xmath323 , the types @xmath841 and @xmath842 contribute @xmath516 , and @xmath843 zero .
we will discuss only the case @xmath837 .
the first step is the following result , which is quite easy to prove : there is an isotopy rel @xmath844 which brings @xmath143 into minimal intersection with @xmath845 .
this yields a lower bound for the geometric intersection number under discussion .
for instance , if @xmath846 has a @xmath200-string of type @xmath847 , this gives rise to one intersection point with @xmath845 which can not be removed by our isotopy .
conversely , one can construct an explicit isotopy whereby this lower bound is attained .
we will now adapt the discussion to bigraded curves .
choose bigradings @xmath848 of @xmath849 for @xmath850 , such that @xmath851 these conditions determine the bigradings uniquely up to an overall shift @xmath852 .
let @xmath669 be a bigrading of an admissible curve @xmath143 ( as before , @xmath143 is assumed to be in normal form ) .
let @xmath853 be a connected component of @xmath776 for some @xmath200 , and @xmath854 the part of @xmath669 which lies over @xmath855 .
evidently , @xmath854 is determined by @xmath855 together with the local index @xmath856 or @xmath857 at any point @xmath858 ( if there is more than one such point , the local indices determine each other ) .
the resulting classification of the pieces @xmath859 into various types , together with the local indices , is indicated by the pairs of integers in figures [ fig : typesa][fig : typesc ] .
for example , if we have a connected component @xmath859 of type @xmath860 whose endpoints are @xmath861 and @xmath862 , the local indices are @xmath863 and @xmath864 . in section [ subsec : bigraded - curves ] we described a canonical lift @xmath670 of a diffeomorphism @xmath865 to a diffeomorphism of @xmath866 denote by @xmath867 the canonical lift of the twist @xmath798 along the curve @xmath799 [ t - action ] diffeomorphisms @xmath868 for @xmath869 induce a braid group action on the set of isotopy classes of admissible bigraded curves . in particular , if @xmath669 is an admissible bigraded curve , the following pairs of bigraded curves are isotopic @xmath870 a crossing of @xmath143 will also be called a _ crossing _ of @xmath871 we denote by @xmath872 the set of crossings of @xmath873 it is the same set as @xmath874 crossings of @xmath669 come with more information than crossings of @xmath875 namely , each crossing comes with a local index , which is an element of @xmath876 the local index @xmath781 of a crossing @xmath877 of @xmath669 will be denoted @xmath878 to emphasize that the index is a function of the crossing .
let @xmath879 denote the index of the vertical curve which contains the crossing : @xmath880 _ essential segments _ of @xmath669 are defined as essential segments of @xmath143 together with bigradings ; the bigrading can be expressed by assigning local indices to the ends of the segment .
define a @xmath200__-string _ _ of @xmath669 as a connected component of @xmath881 together with the bigrading induced from that of @xmath871 denote by @xmath882 the set of @xmath200-strings of @xmath871 define a _ bigraded _
@xmath200__-string _ _ as a bigraded curve in @xmath815 which is a connected component of @xmath883 for some bigraded curve @xmath871 figures [ fig : infinite - typesa][fig : infinite - typesc ] depict the isotopy classes of bigraded @xmath200-strings .
the types @xmath830 and @xmath842 do not fit immediately into our notational scheme , since they do not intersect @xmath884 . instead , given a bigraded @xmath200-string @xmath885 with the underlying @xmath200-string @xmath16 of type @xmath830 or @xmath842 ( @xmath885 is then a bigraded admissible curve )
, we say that @xmath885 has type @xmath886 respectively @xmath887 if @xmath888 the next result is the bigraded analogue of lemma [ th : almost - normal - i ] .
[ th : boring ] let @xmath668 be a bigraded curve
. then @xmath889 can be computed by adding up contributions from each bigraded @xmath200-string of @xmath871 for @xmath837 the contributions are listed in the following table : @xmath890 and the remaining ones can be computed as follows : to determine the contribution of a component of type , say , @xmath891 one takes the contribution of @xmath892 and multiplies it by @xmath893 .
a parallel result holds for @xmath894 where the relevant contributions are @xmath895 the proof consists of a series of tedious elementary verifications , which we omit . the only point worth while discussing is the dependence of the parameter @xmath833 . by combining lemma [ th : self - shift ] with properties [ item : bigraded - map ] and [ item : bigraded - shift ] of @xmath755 ,
one computes that @xmath896 the same holds for the local contributions coming from a single @xmath200-string , which explains the occurrence of the factor @xmath897 .
the bigraded intersection number of @xmath898 and a bigraded @xmath200-string @xmath885 ( denoted by @xmath899 ) is defined as the contribution , described in lemma [ th : boring ] , of @xmath885 to the bigraded intersection number @xmath900 note that @xmath899 depends only on the isotopy class of @xmath901
in this section we prove theorem [ th : gin ] and corollary [ th : faithful ] of the introduction . in section [ complex - to - a - curve ] we associate a complex of @xmath0-modules to a bigraded curve . in section [ twist - twist ]
we prove that this construction relates the braid group actions on bigraded curves and in the category of complexes .
section [ subsec : bigrdim ] interprets bigraded intersection numbers as dimensions of homomorphisms spaces between complexes associated to bigraded curves . throughout this section
@xmath669 denotes a bigraded admissible curve in normal form .
we associate to @xmath669 an object @xmath902 of the category @xmath393 it is a complex of projective modules , containing one suitably shifted copy of @xmath224 for every @xmath73-crossing of @xmath871 start by defining @xmath902 as a bigraded @xmath0-module : @xmath903 where @xmath904\ { x_2\}$ ] ( see section [ normalform ] , after proposition [ t - action ] , for definition of @xmath905 ) . for every @xmath906 define @xmath907 by the following rules * if @xmath877 and @xmath806 are the endpoints of an essential segment and @xmath908 then 1 . if @xmath909 ( then also @xmath910 ) then @xmath911\ { 1\}\ ] ] is the multiplication on the right by @xmath912 2 .
if @xmath913 then @xmath914 is the right multiplication by @xmath915 * otherwise @xmath916 now define the differential as @xmath917 @xmath918 is a complex of graded projective @xmath0-modules with a grading - preserving differential .
the equation @xmath919 follows from relations @xmath920 for any triple @xmath921 of crossings , which are implied by defining relations in the ring @xmath0 : if there is an arrow from @xmath877 to @xmath806 and from @xmath806 to @xmath99 then @xmath922 is the right multiplication by a certain product of generators @xmath923 of @xmath0 , and this product is equal to zero in all cases ( the whole point is that @xmath924 can never be followed by @xmath925 since that would mean that we re dealing with a closed curve around one point of @xmath926 and that has been excluded ) .
@xmath927 is grading - preserving since each @xmath914 is .
the latter property is easily checked on a case by case basis , for each type of essential segments .
@xmath220 here is a less formal way to describe this complex .
assign the module @xmath224 to each intersection of @xmath143 with @xmath928 notice ( see figures [ fig : typesa][fig : typesc ] ) that @xmath929 if @xmath877 and @xmath806 are two ends of an essential segment .
consequently , every essential segment can be oriented in a canonical way , from the endpoint @xmath877 to the endpoint @xmath806 with @xmath930 if the segment has type @xmath931 the orientation is from left to right ; if type @xmath932 the orientation is from right to left ; if type @xmath295 or @xmath933 the orientation is clockwise . in general ,
the orientation is clockwise around the marked point in the center of the region @xmath934 containing the segment .
there is a natural choice of a homomorphism from @xmath935 to @xmath936 depending on the type of the segment , the homomorphism is the right multiplication by @xmath937 or @xmath938 namely , if @xmath939 ( i.e. , both crossings belong to the same vertical line @xmath801 ) , the homomorphism is the right multiplication by @xmath940 if @xmath941 ( i.e. , the two crossings lie on neighbouring vertical curves @xmath801 and @xmath942 ) , the homomorphism is the right multiplication by @xmath943 this construction gives us a chain of projective modules and maps between them , as an example in figures [ fig : curve - c][fig : straighten ] indicates .
the composition of any two consecutive homomorphisms is zero .
the homomorphisms are not grading - preserving , in general .
we can fix that by starting with one of these modules and appropriately shifting the grading of its neighbours in the chain , then the grading of the neighbours of the neighbours , etc .
we get different results by starting with different modules , but , in fact , the difference could only be in the overall shift of the grading .
fold the resulting diagram made of projective modules and arrows ( homomorphisms ) between them so that all arrows go from left to right .
we call this diagram the _ folded diagram _ of @xmath871 by summing up modules in different columns of the folded diagram we get a complex of projective @xmath0-modules . for the example depicted in figures [ fig : curve - c][fig : shifty - shifts ] the complex is @xmath944 this object is defined only up to an overall shift by @xmath945\ { k\}.$ ] this is where the bigrading of @xmath669 kicks in .
we pick a crossing @xmath877 of @xmath669 and make the overall shift in the bigrading so that the projective module @xmath946 corresponding to @xmath947 gets the bigrading @xmath948\ { x_2\}.$ ] the resulting complex , @xmath949 defined earlier more formally , does not depend on the choice of a crossing @xmath950 [ lemma : shifts - relation ] an @xmath781 shift of a bigraded curve translates into the @xmath951\ { r_2\}$ ] shift in the category @xmath952 : @xmath953\ { r_2\}.\ ] ] immediately follows from formula ( [ define - l ] ) and description of the differential in @xmath954 @xmath220 just like admissible curves , @xmath200-strings have crossings and essential segments ( see section [ normalform ] ) .
in particular , to a bigraded @xmath200-string @xmath885 we will associate an object @xmath955 of the category @xmath393 as a bigraded abelian group , @xmath956 where the sum is over all crossings of @xmath957 i.e. intersections of @xmath16 with @xmath958 and the differential is read off the essential segments of @xmath16 in the same way as for admissible curves .
_ example : _ the folded diagram of the bigraded @xmath200-string @xmath892 ( see figure [ fig : infinite - typesa ] ) is depicted in figure [ fig : foldstring ] . [
fig : foldstring ] the complex @xmath959 is @xmath960 _ remark : _ if @xmath885 is a bigraded @xmath200-string of @xmath873 then @xmath955 is an abelian subgroup of @xmath949 but not , in general , a subcomplex or a quotient complex .
_ remark : _
lemma [ lemma : shifts - relation ] holds for bigraded @xmath200-strings as well : @xmath961\ { r_2\}.\ ] ] in the previous section we associated an element of @xmath952 to an admissible bigraded curve . here
we will prove that this map intertwines the braid group action on bigraded curves with the braid group action in the category @xmath962 [ main - theorem ] for a braid @xmath963 and an admissible bigraded curve @xmath669 the objects @xmath964 and @xmath965 of the category @xmath952 are isomorphic .
it suffices to prove the theorem when @xmath381 is an elementary braid , @xmath966 in our notations ( see proposition [ t - action ] ) , the braid @xmath967 acts on bigraded curves as the dehn twist @xmath867 and on an element of @xmath952 by tensoring it with the complex of bimodules @xmath968 thus , we want to prove [ curve - curve ] for an admissible bigraded curve @xmath669 and @xmath969 the objects @xmath970 and @xmath971 of @xmath952 are isomorphic .
_ proof of the proposition . _
denote @xmath902 by @xmath35 the complex @xmath972 is the cone of the map @xmath973 we start by carefully analyzing @xmath974 note that @xmath975 in particular , if a crossing @xmath877 of @xmath669 does not belong to any @xmath200-string of @xmath669 then @xmath976 pick a bigraded @xmath200-string @xmath885 of @xmath871 we have an inclusion of abelian groups @xmath977 [ applied ] the functor @xmath978 applied to this inclusion of groups , produces an inclusion of complexes @xmath979 _ proof of the lemma . _ to prove that @xmath980 is a subcomplex of @xmath981 we check that @xmath982 is zero whenever crossings @xmath877 and @xmath806 do not lie in the same @xmath200-string of @xmath792 indeed , for such @xmath877 and @xmath806 there are two possibilities 1 .
either @xmath877 or @xmath806 do not lie in a @xmath200-string of @xmath792 then @xmath983 respectively @xmath984 and @xmath985 2 .
@xmath877 and @xmath806 belong to different @xmath200-strings .
then either @xmath986 or @xmath987 and the homomorphism @xmath988 is the right multiplication by @xmath989 applying @xmath990 to this homomorphism produces the trivial homomorphism .
the lemma follows .
@xmath220 from this lemma
we deduce there is a natural direct sum decomposition of complexes @xmath991 earlier we established a bijection between @xmath200-strings of @xmath669 and @xmath992 ( proposition [ bijections ] ) from the same proposition we have a natural bijection between @xmath214-crossings of @xmath669 and @xmath993 for each @xmath214 such that @xmath994 if @xmath877 is such a crossing of @xmath669 and @xmath995 is the associated crossing of @xmath996 then @xmath997 and @xmath998 therefore , the complexes @xmath999 and @xmath1000 have a large common piece , namely , the abelian group @xmath1001 where the sum is over all crossings @xmath877 of @xmath669 such that @xmath1002 denote this direct sum by @xmath1003 we want to contruct a homotopy equivalence @xmath1004 we will obtain it as a composition of homotopy equivalences @xmath1005 every intermediate complex @xmath1006 will have a structure similar to that of @xmath1007 and @xmath1008 as an @xmath0-module , @xmath1006 will be isomorphic to the direct sum of @xmath1009 and @xmath0-modules underlying certain complexes @xmath1010 homotopy equivalent to @xmath1011 over all bigraded @xmath200-strings @xmath885 in @xmath1012 @xmath1013 elementary homotopies @xmath1014 will be of two different kinds : \(i ) homotopies `` localized '' inside @xmath1010 for some bigraded @xmath200-string @xmath901 namely , the homotopy will be the identity on @xmath1009 and on @xmath1015 for all @xmath200-strings @xmath1016 of @xmath669 different from @xmath901 the complexes @xmath1017 and @xmath1018 will differ as follows : @xmath1018 will be the quotient of @xmath1017 by an acyclic subcomplex , or @xmath1018 will be realized as a subcomplex of @xmath1017 such that the quotient complex is acyclic .
the `` localized '' homotopy @xmath1019 will respect the position of these complexes as subcomplexes of @xmath1020 and @xmath1021 and will naturally extend to homotopy equivalence @xmath1022
\(ii ) isomorphisms of complexes @xmath1022 these will come from natural isomorphisms of @xmath0-modules that underlie complexes @xmath1006 and @xmath1021 and a direct sum decomposition of the module @xmath1023 the isomorphism will take @xmath1024 to @xmath1025 from now on we proceed on a case by case basis , working with different types of bigraded @xmath200-strings ( figures [ fig : infinite - typesa]-[fig : infinite - typesc ] ) .
we start with some easy cases . * case 1 . *
if @xmath885 is of type @xmath1026 then @xmath1027 up a shift in the bigrading .
the half twist @xmath992 shifts the bigrading by @xmath1028 on the other hand , the complex @xmath1029 is chain homotopic to @xmath1030\ { 1\}.$ ] the topological shift matches the algebraic ( see lemma [ lemma : shifts - relation ] and formula ( [ eqn : shifts - strings ] ) ) .
this gives an isomorphism @xmath1031 * case 2 .
* if @xmath885 has one of the types @xmath1032 or @xmath829 then the half - twist @xmath867 preserves @xmath901 at the same time , we have if @xmath885 is of type @xmath1033 or @xmath1034 then the complex @xmath980 is acyclic . _
proof of the lemma .
_ explicit computation .
for instance , if @xmath885 has type @xmath1035 then @xmath955 is the complex @xmath1036 the functor @xmath990 is the tensor product with the bimodule @xmath1037 first we tensor over @xmath0 with the right module @xmath1038 which gets us a complex of abelian groups .
then we tensor the result with @xmath1039 over @xmath226 the tensor product of the complex ( [ not - quite - exact ] ) with @xmath1040 over @xmath0 is an acyclic complex of abelian groups ( exercise for the reader ) .
the lemma follows for @xmath885 of type @xmath1041 similar computations establish the lemma for the other three types of @xmath901 @xmath220 since @xmath1042 we have a natural isomorphism of complexes @xmath1043 moreover , @xmath1044 which is a direct summand of the complex @xmath1045 is acyclic , and we see that the complex @xmath1046 is homotopic to its subcomplex obtained by throwing away @xmath1047 for all @xmath885 of types iv , iv,v and v. * case 3 . * types @xmath1048 and @xmath1049 assume @xmath885 has type @xmath1050 the homotopies constructed below commute with shifts in the bigrading , and , without loss of generality , we set @xmath1051 we will also set @xmath1052 in our treatment of types @xmath1053 and @xmath1054 consider first the case @xmath1055 a @xmath200-string of type @xmath1056 is depicted on figure [ fig : typeiii3 ] .
[ fig : typeiii3 ] the complex @xmath955 is @xmath1057 let us understand the relation between @xmath955 and @xmath35 the complex @xmath999 contains @xmath955 as an abelian subgroup . the part of the folded diagram of @xmath669 that contains the folded diagram of @xmath885 has the form @xmath1058 where @xmath1059 denotes the complement to @xmath955 in @xmath35 more precisely , @xmath1059 denotes the direct sum @xmath1060 over all crossings @xmath877 of @xmath669 that do not belong to @xmath901 notation @xmath1061 means that @xmath1059 relates to @xmath955 through the module @xmath1062 namely , in the folded diagram of @xmath999 there might be an arrow @xmath1063 or an arrow @xmath1064 where @xmath877 is a crossing of @xmath669 which does not belong to @xmath901 we will use this notation throughout the rest of the proof of proposition [ curve - curve ] .
@xmath1059 will denote either such a complement to @xmath955 in @xmath1065 or the complement to @xmath1066 in @xmath1067 or any similar complement , and the meaning will always be clear from the context . whenever we modify @xmath1068 to a homotopy equivalent complex @xmath1069
we will do so relative to @xmath1070 so that our homotopy equivalence extends to a homotopy equivalence between @xmath1046 and the complex naturally built out of @xmath1071 and @xmath1072 when we are in such situation , we say that the homotopy _ respects _ @xmath1072 the complex @xmath1073 written as a bicomplex , and considered as a part of @xmath1067 has the form @xmath1074 note that , in view of lemma [ applied ] , @xmath1059 connects to @xmath1066 only through the module @xmath1075 in the bottom right corner of the diagram .
complex @xmath1076 ( the top row in the above diagram ) is isomorphic to the direct sum of @xmath1077 and acyclic complexes @xmath1078 ( we leave this as an exercise for the reader , it follows at once after the differential in @xmath1076 is written down ) , so that @xmath1079 is homotopic to @xmath1080 which is exactly @xmath1081 ( note that the homotopy respects @xmath1059 ) . we next treat the case @xmath823 where @xmath1082 as before , set @xmath1083 this does not reduce the generality since our homotopies will commute with bigrading shifts .
the complex @xmath955 ( considered as a part of @xmath999 ) has the form ( compare to figure [ fig : typeiiiminus3 ] ) @xmath1084 the complex @xmath1073 in relation to @xmath1085 has the form @xmath1086 the complex @xmath1076 ( top row in the diagram above ) is isomorphic to the direct sum of @xmath1087 and acyclic complexes @xmath1088 therefore , @xmath1066 is homotopic to the folding of @xmath1089 ( an explicit computation shows that the vertical arrow is the identity map ) .
this complex has an acyclic subcomplex @xmath1090 and the quotient is isomorphic to @xmath1091 this sequence of two homotopy equivalences respects @xmath1072 our consideration of case @xmath1048 is now complete .
type @xmath1092 can be worked out entirely parallel to @xmath1093 and we omit the computation .
* types @xmath1094 and @xmath1095 let @xmath885 has type @xmath1096 without loss of generality we can specialize to @xmath1051 we start with the case @xmath1097 figure [ fig : typeii2 ] depicts an example of a @xmath200-string of that type .
[ fig : typeii2 ] the complex @xmath955 has the form ( the first line of arrows continues into the third , and the second into the fourth ) @xmath1098 we next write down the complex @xmath1099 @xmath1100 it is easily checked that this complex is isomorphic to direct sum of acyclic complexes @xmath1101 ( two complexes for each @xmath1102 and one for @xmath1103 ) and the complex @xmath1104 where @xmath1105 is the projection onto the first summand , taken with the minus sign .
denote by @xmath1071 the subcomplex of @xmath1066 which , as an abelian group , in the direct sum of @xmath955 and ( [ asubcomplex ] ) .
note that @xmath1071 is homotopy equivalent to @xmath1073 and that this homotopy equivalence respects @xmath1072 complex @xmath1071 consists of the `` central part '' @xmath1106 and two chains of @xmath1107 s going to the left and right of the center .
@xmath1108 is given by @xmath1109 the differential in this complex is injective on @xmath1110 situated in the center of the top row of ( [ complex - prime ] ) .
thus , @xmath1110 generates an acyclic subcomplex @xmath1111 of @xmath1112 the quotient of @xmath1071 by this acyclic subcomplex is isomorphic to ( the diagram below only depicts the central part of the complex , do nt forget to add two tails of @xmath1039 s ) @xmath1113 denote this quotient by @xmath1114 the @xmath0-modules underlying complexes @xmath1115 and @xmath1081 are canonically isomorphic .
the two differentials differ only in one place : in @xmath1115 there is a minus sign in the left arrow .
we can get rid of this minus sign with the isomorphism @xmath1116 that takes @xmath1117 to @xmath1118 depending on whether @xmath1119 is to the left or right of the `` minus '' arrow .
we next treat the case @xmath1120 the complex @xmath955 is @xmath1121 and the complex @xmath1073 for @xmath885 of type @xmath1122 is the folding of @xmath1123 we want to find a homotopy equivalence with the complex @xmath1124 which is @xmath1125 in fact , these two complexes are isomorphic , via the isomorphism which takes an element @xmath1126 of ( [ 2by2-finish ] ) to @xmath1127 of the complex ( [ 2by2-start ] ) . since our map takes @xmath1128 to @xmath1129 when extending it to the remaining part of the complex we will send @xmath1130 to @xmath1131 for any @xmath1130 that belongs to @xmath1059 on the right side of the diagram ( [ 2by2-finish ] ) .
this is to insure that our map commutes with differentials , i.e. , it is a map of complexes .
case @xmath1082 let @xmath885 be of type @xmath821 for @xmath1082 the complex @xmath955 is the folding of @xmath1132 the situation is very similar to the case @xmath1097 the complex @xmath1076 is isomorphic to the direct sum of acyclic complexes and of the complex which is the folding of @xmath1133 where @xmath1134 the complex @xmath1069 which is the direct sum of @xmath955 and ( [ letsfold ] ) inside @xmath1073 consists of the central part , which is the folding of @xmath1135 and of two long tails of @xmath1107 s .
the map @xmath1108 is given by the formula ( [ psi-2 ] ) .
the module @xmath1110 in the center of the top row of ( [ central - part ] ) generates an acyclic complex inside @xmath1112 the quotient of @xmath1071 by this acyclic subcomplex is isomorphic to @xmath1081 ( things work here in the same way as in the case @xmath1136 treated earlier ) .
* type @xmath1054 this case is very similar to @xmath1137 write down the complex @xmath1138 compute @xmath1139 throw away long tails of acyclic subcomplexes in @xmath1139 we ll be left with ( [ asubcomplex ] ) ( case @xmath1140 ) or ( [ letsfold ] ) ( case @xmath1141 ) .
form the direct sum @xmath1071 of @xmath955 and what s left of @xmath1142 complex @xmath1071 is a subcomplex of @xmath1143 quotient out @xmath1071 by an acyclic subcomplex in the same way as in case @xmath1137 the result is isomorphic to @xmath1091 this completes our case - by - case analysis . for each @xmath200-string @xmath885 of @xmath669
we constructed a homotopy equivalence @xmath1144 which extends naturally to @xmath1072 putting all these equivalences together we obtain a homotopy equivalence @xmath1145 the proof of proposition [ curve - curve ] is complete .
proposition [ curve - curve ] implies ( taking @xmath1146 ) [ main - corollary ] for a braid @xmath963 objects @xmath1147 and
@xmath1148 of the category @xmath952 are isomorphic .
the main result of this section : [ th : dimequals ] for @xmath1149 and @xmath1150 the abelian group @xmath1151\ { -s_2\})\ ] ] is free .
the poincar polynomial @xmath1152\ { -s_2\ } ) ) q_1^{s_1 } q_2^{s_2}\ ] ] is equal to the bigraded intersection number @xmath1153 the braid group acts in the category @xmath393 in particular , @xmath1154 the bigraded intersection number is also preserved by the braid group action : @xmath1155 it suffices , therefore , to prove the proposition in the case @xmath1156 moreover , corollary [ main - corollary ] tells us that we can substitute @xmath1157 for @xmath1158 in this proposition .
[ contributions ] for a bigraded admissible curve @xmath669 there is a natural isomorphism @xmath1159\ { -s_2\ } ) \cong { { \mathop{\bigoplus}\limits_{{\tilde{g}}\in \mathrm{st}({\tilde{c}},k ) } } } \mathrm{hom}_{{{\mathcal{c}}_m}}(p_k ,
l({\tilde{g}})[s_1]\ { -s_2\})\ ] ] for all @xmath1160 and @xmath1161 in other words , homomorphisms from @xmath1039 to the complex associated to an admissible curve come from homomorphisms of @xmath1039 to complexes associated to @xmath200-strings of the curve .
_ proof of the lemma . _
the complex @xmath1162 is obtained from @xmath902 by throwing away all modules @xmath212 for @xmath1163 and by changing differentials @xmath1164 to zero whenever @xmath877 and @xmath806 belong to boundaries of two different @xmath200-strings of @xmath871 the lemma follows since @xmath1165\ { s_2\})=0\ ] ] for all @xmath1160 and all @xmath214 such that @xmath1166 and since maps @xmath1167 induced by @xmath1168 as above are zero maps.@xmath220 we know that @xmath1169 is obtained by summing up contributions from all @xmath200-strings of @xmath669 ( see lemma [ th : boring ] ) .
similarly , lemma [ contributions ] tells us that the space of homomorphisms from @xmath1039 to a ( possibly shifted ) @xmath902 is the direct sum of contributions corresponding to @xmath200-strings of @xmath871 therefore , it suffices to prove [ free - abelian ] for any bigraded @xmath200-string @xmath885 the abelian group @xmath1170\ { -s_2\})\ ] ] is free .
the poincar polynomial @xmath1171\ { -s_2\ } ) ) q_1^{s_1 } q_2^{s_2}\ ] ] is equal to the bigraded intersection number @xmath1172 _ proof of the lemma .
_ let us examine how shifting a bigraded @xmath200-string by @xmath781 changes its poincar polynomial .
if @xmath1173 then @xmath1174\ { r_2\}$ ] and @xmath1175 this shift matches the corresponding shift in the bigraded intersection number : @xmath1176 therefore , it suffices to prove the lemma in the case when the bigraded @xmath200-string @xmath885 has its parameters @xmath781 ( see figures [ fig : infinite - typesa][fig : infinite - typesc ] ) set to @xmath205 we start by treating the case @xmath1177 figure [ fig : infinite - typesa ] depicts 10 possible types of bigraded @xmath200-strings , and we have already reduced to the @xmath1052 case .
notice that types @xmath1178 and @xmath1092 have an extra integral parameter @xmath1179 denote by @xmath1180 one of the above @xmath1181 types .
the @xmath200-string @xmath1182 is given by twisting @xmath1183 by @xmath1184 since @xmath1185 ( the third equality uses lemma [ th : self - shift ] ) and , at the same time , @xmath1186\ { -s_2\ } ) ) q_1^{s_1 } q_2^{s_2 } = \\
{ { \mathop{\sum}\limits_{s_1,s_2 } } } \mathrm{rk}(\mathrm{hom}_{{{\mathcal{c}}_m } } ( p_k , ( { { \mathcal{r}}}_k)^ul(y_0)[s_1]\ { -s_2\ } ) ) q_1^{s_1 } q_2^{s_2 } = \\ { { \mathop{\sum}\limits_{s_1,s_2 } } } \mathrm{rk}(\mathrm{hom}_{{{\mathcal{c}}_m } } ( ( { { \mathcal{r}}}_k)^{-u}p_k , l(y_0)[s_1]\ { -s_2\ } ) ) q_1^{s_1 } q_2^{s_2 } = \\ { { \mathop{\sum}\limits_{s_1,s_2 } } } \mathrm{rk}(\mathrm{hom}_{{{\mathcal{c}}_m } } ( p_k[-u]\ { -u \ } , l(y_0)[s_1]\ { -s_2\ } ) ) q_1^{s_1 } q_2^{s_2 } = \\ { { \mathop{\sum}\limits_{s_1,s_2 } } } \mathrm{rk}(\mathrm{hom}_{{{\mathcal{c}}_m } } ( p_k , l(y_0)[s_1+u]\ { u - s_2\ } ) ) q_1^{s_1 } q_2^{s_2 } = \\ ( q_1^{-1}q_2)^u p(y_0 ) , \end{array}\ ] ] ( the second equality follows from theorem [ main - theorem ] ) it suffices to treat the case @xmath1120 [ more - tables ] for @xmath837 the poincar polynomials of bigraded @xmath200-strings with parameters @xmath1052 and ( for types @xmath1187 ) with @xmath1188 are given by the following table : @xmath1189 the poincar polynomials of @xmath235-strings with @xmath1052 are @xmath895 _ proof of the lemma . _ direct computation . for @xmath1190 and a bigraded @xmath200-string @xmath885 as above
write down the complex @xmath955 according to the prescription in section [ complex - to - a - curve ]
. then compute the hom complex @xmath1191 and the poincar polynomial @xmath1192 to simplify the computation we can look at all homomorphisms from @xmath1039 to @xmath1138 not just the ones that preserve the grading , and later sort them out into graded pieces .
example : @xmath885 has type @xmath1193 the complex @xmath955 is ( see also the end of section [ complex - to - a - curve ] ) @xmath1194 the complex @xmath1191 is quasi - isomorphic to @xmath1195 and the poincar polynomial @xmath1196 the remaining nine cases are equally easy to compute , details are left to the reader .
we note that for @xmath885 of the type @xmath1033 and @xmath829 the complex @xmath1191 is acyclic and the poincar polynomial is @xmath205 cases @xmath1197 and @xmath1198 can be treated in the same fashion .
for @xmath1199 the four types of @xmath592-strings ( see figure [ fig : infinite - typesb ] ) naturally correspond to the four out of ten types of @xmath200-strings with @xmath1200 and the computation for the @xmath1201 case extends word by word to @xmath1202 if @xmath1203 there are @xmath1181 cases to consider .
a @xmath235-string has either one or two crossings , and the poincar polynomial is easy to compute .
the answer is written in the second table of the lemma .
@xmath220 the tables in lemmas [ th : boring ] and [ more - tables ] are identical .
lemma [ free - abelian ] and proposition [ th : dimequals ] follow .
@xmath220 proposition [ th : dimequals ] , specialized to @xmath1204 implies theorem [ th : gin ] of the introduction .
proposition [ th : dimequals ] , specialized to @xmath1205 and lemma [ th : detect - identity ] imply that objects @xmath1158 and @xmath212 are isomorphic if and only if @xmath381 is the trivial braid ( a similar argument was used to prove proposition [ th : birman - hilden ] ) .
therefore , the braid group acts faithfully in the category @xmath952 ( that proves corollary [ th : faithful ] ) .
the definition of floer cohomology used here is essentially the original one @xcite ; far more general versions have been developed in the meantime , but we do not need them .
in fact , we will even impose additional restrictions whenever this simplifies the exposition .
the only exception is that we allow lagrangian submanifolds with boundary .
after the expository part , a result is proved which computes floer cohomology in certain very special situations .
this is based on a simple @xmath168-symmetry argument , and will be the main technical tool later on . to conclude , we discuss briefly the question of grading .
a symplectic manifold with contact type boundary is a compact manifold with boundary @xmath26 , with a symplectic form @xmath1206 and a contact one - form @xmath1207 , subject to two conditions .
one is that @xmath1208 , and the other is that the reeb vector field @xmath267 on @xmath149 should satisfy @xmath1209 for any normal vector field @xmath48 pointing outwards . a lagrangian submanifold with legendrian boundary in @xmath145 is a submanifold @xmath44 which intersects @xmath149 transversally , such that @xmath1210 and @xmath1211 ( note that @xmath1212 is allowed ) . for brevity , we call these objects simply _ lagrangian submanifolds_. [ th : normal - field ] let @xmath44 be a lagrangian submanifold
. there is a unique @xmath1213 which satisfies @xmath1214 for any @xmath1215 .
the proof is straightforward , and we omit it . by definition ,
a lagrangian isotopy is a smooth family @xmath1216 of lagrangian submanifolds .
infinitesimally , such an isotopy is described at each time @xmath528 by a section @xmath1217 of the normal bundle to @xmath1218 , or dually by a one - form @xmath1219 on @xmath1218 .
@xmath1219 is always closed .
moreover , if @xmath1220 is the vector field from lemma [ th : normal - field ] for @xmath1221 then @xmath1222 it follows that the pair @xmath1223 defines a class in @xmath1224 .
the lagrangian isotopy is called _ exact _ if this class is zero for all @xmath528 .
this means that there is a @xmath1225 with @xmath1226 and @xmath1227 .
a special class of lagrangian isotopies are those where @xmath1228 remains constant for all @xmath528 , which we call _ isotopies rel @xmath149_. another important class consists of those isotopies where @xmath1228 moves along the reeb flow with positive speed . by this
we mean that there is a function @xmath1229 , { \mathbb{r}}^{>0})$ ] such that @xmath1230 when projected to the normal bundle of @xmath1231 is equal to @xmath1232 using one can see that this is the case iff @xmath1233 is a positive constant function for each @xmath1234 another equivalent condition : if one takes an embedding @xmath1235 \longrightarrow \partial m$ ] such that the image of @xmath1236 is @xmath1228 , then the pullback of @xmath138 under it is @xmath1237 for some positive function @xmath1238 .
we call isotopies of this kind _ positive_. there are always many positive isotopies , even exact ones , starting at a given lagrangian submanifold @xmath999 . for instance , one can carry @xmath999 along the flow of some hamiltonian function @xmath1239 with @xmath1240 and @xmath1241 at all points @xmath1242 .
let @xmath145 be a symplectic manifold with contact type boundary .
one can always extend @xmath138 to a one - form @xmath165 on some neighbourhood @xmath1243 of @xmath149 , such that @xmath1244 holds .
the vector field @xmath414 dual to @xmath165 , @xmath1245 , is liouville and points outwards along @xmath149 .
the embedding @xmath1246 \times \partial m \longrightarrow m$ ] , for some @xmath1247 , defined by the flow of @xmath414 satisfies @xmath1248 and hence @xmath1249 , where @xmath1250 is the variable in @xmath1251 $ ] .
fix some @xmath165 and the corresponding @xmath1252 .
a lagrangian submanifold @xmath44 is called _ @xmath1252-compatible _ if @xmath1253 \times \partial m ) = [ -r_1;0 ] \times \partial l$ ] for some @xmath1254 .
equivalently , @xmath1255 should vanish near @xmath1256 .
[ th : compatible ] [ item : compatible - one ] any lagrangian submanifold can be deformed , by an exact isotopy rel @xmath149 , to a @xmath1252-compatible one .
[ item : compatible - two ] let @xmath1216 be a lagrangian isotopy , and assume that @xmath1257 are compatible with @xmath1252 .
then there is another isotopy @xmath1258 with the same endpoints , and with @xmath1259 for all @xmath528 , such that all @xmath1260 are compatible with @xmath1252 .
if @xmath1261 is exact then @xmath1258 may be chosen to have the same property .
[ item : compatible - one ] let @xmath44 be a lagrangian submanifold . choose a @xmath1254 such that @xmath1256 is a deformation retract of @xmath1262 \times \partial m)$ ] .
@xmath1263 is a closed one - form which vanishes on @xmath1264 ; hence it can be written as the differential of a function on @xmath496 which vanishes on @xmath1265 extend this to a function @xmath1266 with @xmath1267 , and consider the family of one - forms @xmath1268 , @xmath1269 .
they satisfy @xmath1270 and @xmath1271 , and hence define a family of embeddings @xmath1272 \times \partial m \longrightarrow m$ ] for some @xmath1273 .
note that @xmath1274 while @xmath1275 vanishes on a neighbourhood of @xmath1256 , namely on @xmath496 .
let @xmath1276 be a neighbourhood of @xmath149 which is contained in the image of @xmath1277 for all @xmath528 ; we can assume that @xmath1278 is a deformation retract .
@xmath1279 is a symplectic vector field on @xmath1276 which vanishes on @xmath149 .
the corresponding one - form @xmath1280 is zero on @xmath149 , and hence it can be written as the boundary of a function @xmath1281 with @xmath1282 .
after possibly making @xmath1276 smaller one finds that for each @xmath528 , @xmath1217 can be extended to a hamiltonian vector field @xmath1283 on the whole of @xmath26 .
let @xmath1284 be the flow of @xmath1285 seen as a time - dependent vector field . by definition @xmath1286 on some neighbourhood of the boundary
, and , therefore , @xmath1287 this shows that @xmath1288 is equal to @xmath1275 near @xmath1256 , so that @xmath1289 is @xmath1252-compatible .
one sees easily that the isotopy @xmath1290 is exact , which finishes the argument .
the proof of [ item : compatible - two ] is just a parametrized version of [ item : compatible - one ] .
assume now that the relative symplectic class @xmath1291 \in h^2(m,\partial m;{\mathbb{r}})$ ] is zero .
then there is a one - form @xmath165 on @xmath26 with @xmath1292 and @xmath1293 .
fix such a @xmath165 ; the corresponding embedding @xmath1252 is defined on all of @xmath1294 .
a lagrangian submanifold @xmath999 is called _ @xmath165-exact _
if @xmath1295 \in h^1(l,\partial l;{\mathbb{r}})$ ] is zero .
the next lemma describes the relationship between the absolute notion of a @xmath165-exact submanifold and the relative notion of exact isotopy .
the lemma after that concerns the existence of @xmath165-exact submanifolds in a given lagrangian isotopy class .
we omit the proofs .
[ th : exact - isotopies ] let @xmath1216 be a lagrangian isotopy such that @xmath148 is @xmath165-exact . then the isotopy is exact @xmath1296 all the @xmath1218 are @xmath165-exact . [
th : exist - exact ] let @xmath44 be a lagrangian submanifold such that @xmath1297 surjects onto @xmath1298 .
then there is a lagrangian isotopy @xmath1261 rel @xmath149 with @xmath1299 and such that @xmath1300 is @xmath165-exact .
[ item : deform - to - exact - isotopy ] let @xmath1301 be two @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds which are isotopic rel @xmath149 .
assume that @xmath1297 surjects onto @xmath1302 .
then there is an exact isotopy rel @xmath149 which connects @xmath148 and @xmath1300 .
there is a similar notion for symplectic automorphisms .
let @xmath1303 be the group of symplectic automorphisms @xmath1304 which are the identity in some neighbourhood ( depending on @xmath30 ) of @xmath1305 . by definition ,
a hamiltonian isotopy in this group is one generated by a time - dependent hamiltonian function which vanishes near @xmath149 .
call @xmath1306 _ @xmath165-exact _
if @xmath1307 \in h^1(m,\partial m;{\mathbb{r}})$ ] is zero .
the analogue of lemma [ th : exact - isotopies ] is this : let @xmath1308 be an isotopy in @xmath1309 with @xmath1310 @xmath165-exact . then @xmath1308 is a hamiltonian isotopy iff all the @xmath1284 are @xmath165-exact . as for lemma [
th : exist - exact ] , the analogous statement is actually simpler : the subgroup of @xmath165-exact automorphisms is always a deformation retract of @xmath1309 . finally , note that @xmath165-exact automorphisms preserve the class of @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds .
let @xmath145 be a symplectic manifold with contact type boundary , such that @xmath1291 \in h^2(m,\partial m;{\mathbb{r}})$ ] is zero .
fix a @xmath1311 with @xmath1292 , @xmath1293 .
floer cohomology associates a finite - dimensional vector space over @xmath168 , denoted by @xmath23 , to any pair @xmath1312 of @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds whose boundaries are either the same or else disjoint .
we now give a brief account of its definition , concentrating on the issues which arise in connection with the boundary @xmath149 . for expositions emphasizing other aspects
see e.g. @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
we begin with a digression concerning almost complex structures .
let @xmath1313 be the symplectic vector bundle @xmath1314 .
given a compatible almost complex structure @xmath1315 on @xmath1316 , one can define an almost complex structure @xmath1317 on @xmath1318 , compatible with @xmath1319 , by @xmath1320 for @xmath1321 and @xmath1322 .
the almost complex structures @xmath1317 appeared first in @xcite .
the next lemma describes their main property ; it is taken from ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 3.9.2 ) with some modifications .
[ th : convexity ] let @xmath1323 be an open subset of @xmath1324 $ ] , and @xmath1325 a smooth family of compatible almost complex structures on @xmath1316 parametrized by @xmath1326 .
let @xmath1327 be the corresponding family of almost complex structures on @xmath1328 .
let @xmath1329 be two legendrian submanifolds , and @xmath1330 a smooth map which satisfies @xmath1331 , such that @xmath1332 for all @xmath1333
. then @xmath1334 has no local maxima .
let @xmath1335 be the projections from @xmath1318 to the two factors .
for any @xmath1326 one has @xmath1336 .
hence @xmath1337 , and similarly @xmath1338 .
therefore @xmath1339 . by assumption @xmath1340
at each point @xmath1333 , and hence @xmath1341 .
this shows that @xmath1334 is subharmonic and satisfies von neumann boundary conditions on @xmath1342 .
the maximum principle implies that such a function can not have local maxima .
let @xmath1343 be the embedding associated to @xmath165 , as in the previous section .
we define @xmath1344 to be the space of all smooth families @xmath1345 of @xmath137-compatible almost complex structures on @xmath26 which have the following property : there is an @xmath1247 and a family @xmath1346 of compatible almost complex structures on @xmath1316 such that for each @xmath528 , @xmath1347 \times \partial m$ ] agrees with @xmath1348 .
now take two @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds @xmath1301 with @xmath1349 .
the first step in defining @xmath23 is to deform them in a suitable way .
[ th : perturb ] there are lagrangian submanifolds @xmath1350 such that @xmath1351 and @xmath1352 are joined by an exact isotopy rel @xmath149 , for @xmath1353 , and with the following properties : each @xmath1352 is @xmath1252-compatible , and the intersection @xmath1354 is transverse .
this follows from lemma [ th : compatible][item : compatible - one ] and a well - known transversality argument .
note that @xmath1355 are again @xmath165-exact , because of lemma [ th : exact - isotopies ] .
for @xmath1356 , let @xmath1357 be the set of smooth maps @xmath1358 \longrightarrow m$ ] satisfying floer s equation @xmath1359 and whose energy @xmath1360 is finite .
we remind the reader that can be seen as the negative gradient flow equation of the action functional @xmath855 on the path space @xmath1361 , m ) { \ ; | \;}\gamma(j ) \in l_j',\ ; j = 0,1\}$ ] . to define @xmath855
one needs to choose functions @xmath1362 with @xmath1363 ( such functions exist by the assumption of @xmath165-exactness ) ; then @xmath1364 } \gamma^*\theta + h_1(\gamma(1 ) ) - h_0(\gamma(0))$ ] .
[ th : bounded ] for any @xmath1365 , there is a compact subset of @xmath1366 which contains the image of all @xmath1367 .
this is mainly a consequence of lemma [ th : convexity ] and of the definition of @xmath1344 .
the other elements which enter the proof are : the convergence of each @xmath1367 towards limits @xmath1368 in @xmath1369 ; the @xmath1252-compatibility of @xmath1355 ; and the fact that @xmath1370 .
we leave the details to the reader .
the importance of lemma [ th : bounded ] is that it allows one to ignore the boundary of @xmath26 in all arguments concerning solutions of .
one can associate to any @xmath1367 a fredholm operator @xmath1371 from @xmath1372 to @xmath1373 ( @xmath1374 is some fixed real number ) which describes the linearization of near @xmath833 .
let @xmath1375 be the subset of those @xmath833 with limits @xmath1376 and such that @xmath1377 has index @xmath1378 .
there is a natural action of @xmath1379 on each of these sets , by translation in the @xmath1380-variable .
call @xmath1367 regular if @xmath1377 is onto .
if this is true for all @xmath1367 then @xmath1381 itself is called regular .
[ th : fhs ] the regular @xmath1381 form a @xmath1382-dense subset @xmath1383 .
[ th : floer ] for @xmath1384 , the quotients @xmath1385 are finite sets . moreover , if we define @xmath1386 to be the number of points mod @xmath295 in @xmath1385 , then @xmath1387 for each @xmath1388 .
let @xmath1389 be the @xmath168-vector space freely generated by the points of @xmath1369 , and @xmath1390 the endomorphism of this space which sends the basis element @xmath1391 to @xmath1392 .
theorem [ th : floer ] implies that @xmath1393 , and one sets @xmath1394 .
finally , @xmath23 is defined as @xmath1395 for any choice of @xmath1355 as in lemma [ th : perturb ] and any @xmath1384 .
one can show that this is independent of the choices up to canonical isomorphism .
the proof uses the continuation maps introduced in ( * ? ? ?
* section 6 ) .
we will not explain the details , but it seems appropriate to mention two simple facts which are used in setting up the argument : firstly , an exact lagrangian isotopy rel @xmath149 which consists only of @xmath1252-compatible submanifolds can be embedded into a hamiltonian isotopy in @xmath1309 .
secondly , there is an analogue of lemma [ th : bounded ] for solutions of the continuation equation , which is again derived from lemma [ th : convexity ] .
as well as proving its well - definedness , the continuation argument also establishes the basic isotopy invariance property of floer cohomology : [ th : isotopy - invariance ] @xmath23 is invariant ( up to isomorphism ) under exact isotopies of @xmath148 or @xmath1300 rel @xmath149 .
we will now extend the definition of floer cohomology to pairs of lagrangian submanifolds whose boundaries coincide .
the basic idea is the same as in the case of geometric intersection numbers .
let @xmath1312 be two @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds with @xmath1396 , and let @xmath1397 be a submanifold obtained from @xmath148 by a sufficiently small lagrangian isotopy which is exact and positive .
then @xmath1398 , and one sets @xmath1399 .
the proof that this is independent of the choice of @xmath1397 requires a generalization of proposition [ th : isotopy - invariance ] : [ th : moving - boundary ] let @xmath1400 be an isotopy of @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds , and @xmath1300 a @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifold such that @xmath1401 for all @xmath1380 .
then @xmath1402 is independent of @xmath1380 up to isomorphism .
it is sufficient to show that the dimension of @xmath1402 is locally constant in @xmath1380 near some fixed @xmath1403 $ ] .
let @xmath1404 be a lagrangian submanifold which is @xmath1252-compatible and isotopic to @xmath1300 by an exact isotopy rel @xmath149 .
let @xmath1405 be an isotopy of lagrangian submanifolds , such that each @xmath1406 is @xmath1252-compatible and isotopic to @xmath1407 by an exact isotopy rel @xmath149 .
we may assume that @xmath1408 intersects @xmath1404 transversally .
take a @xmath1409 .
for all @xmath1380 sufficiently close to @xmath1410 , the intersection @xmath1411 remains transverse , and @xmath1381 lies still in @xmath1412 . hence by definition of floer cohomology @xmath1413 for all @xmath1380 close to @xmath1410 . by considering the corresponding parametrized moduli spaces one sees that the complex @xmath1414 is independent of @xmath1380 ( near @xmath1415 up to isomorphism ; compare ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 3.4 ) .
the same argument can be used to extend proposition [ th : isotopy - invariance ] to pairs @xmath1312 with @xmath1416 .
it is difficult to see whether the isomorphisms obtained in this way are canonical or not .
this is an inherent weakness of our approach ; there are alternatives which do not appear to have this problem @xcite . in any case , the question is irrelevant for the purposes of the present paper .
a theorem of floer @xcite says that @xmath1417 for any @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifold @xmath999 ( floer stated the theorem for @xmath1212 only , but his proof extends to the general case ) . there is no general way of computing @xmath23 when @xmath1418 , but there are a number of ad hoc arguments which work in special situations .
one such argument will be the subject of the next two sections .
let @xmath145 and @xmath165 be as before .
in addition we now assume that @xmath26 carries an involution @xmath1419 which preserves @xmath137 , @xmath165 , and @xmath138 . the fixed point set
@xmath1420 is again a symplectic manifold with contact type boundary .
moreover , if @xmath44 is a lagrangian submanifold with @xmath1421 , its fixed part @xmath1422 is a lagrangian submanifold of @xmath1420 .
we denote by @xmath1423 the subspace of those @xmath1345 such that @xmath1424 for all @xmath528 .
let @xmath1355 be a pair of @xmath165-exact and @xmath1252-compatible lagrangian submanifolds of @xmath26 , which intersect transversally and satisfy @xmath1425 .
assume that @xmath1426 for @xmath1353 .
if one wants to use this symmetry property to compute floer cohomology , the following question arises : can one find a @xmath1427 which is regular ?
the answer is no in general , because of a simple phenomenon which we will now describe .
take a @xmath1427 , and let @xmath1367 be a map whose image lies in @xmath1420 .
then the spaces @xmath1428 and @xmath1429 carry natural @xmath168-actions , and @xmath1377 is an equivariant operator .
assume that the invariant part @xmath1430 is surjective , and that @xmath1431 . then @xmath1377 can obviously not be onto .
this situation is stable under perturbation , which means that for any @xmath1432 sufficiently close to @xmath1381 one can find a @xmath1433 with the same property as @xmath833 .
hence @xmath1434 is not dense in @xmath1435 .
this is a general problem in equivariant transversality theory , and it is not difficult to construct concrete examples . by taking the reasoning a little further , one can find cases where @xmath1436 .
the aim of this section is to show that the maps @xmath1367 with @xmath1437 are indeed the only obstruction ; in other words , equivariant transversality can be achieved everywhere except at these solutions .
[ th : regular ] let @xmath1367 , for some @xmath1427 , be a map which is not constant and such that @xmath1438 .
let @xmath1439 be the limits of @xmath833 .
then the subset @xmath1440 of those @xmath506 which satisfy @xmath1441 is open and dense .
we will use the methods developed in @xcite . to begin with , take a more general situation : let @xmath26 be an arbitrary manifold and @xmath1442 a smooth family of almost complex structures on it .
we consider smooth maps @xmath1443 , where @xmath1323 is some connected open subset of @xmath1444 , satisfying @xmath1445 some basic properties of this equation are : [ item : critical ] if @xmath1130 is a non - constant solution of then @xmath1446 is a discrete subset of @xmath1323 .
[ item : coincidence ] let @xmath1447 be two solutions of defined on the same set @xmath1323 , such that @xmath1448 . then @xmath1449 is a discrete subset . [
item : preimage ] let @xmath1130 be a non - constant solution of . for each @xmath1450 , @xmath1451 is a discrete subset .
[ item : shifted ] let @xmath1452 and @xmath1453 be two solutions of such that @xmath1454 is an embedding .
assume that for any @xmath1455 there is an @xmath1456 with @xmath1457 and @xmath1458 .
then there is a @xmath1459 such that for all @xmath1455 we have @xmath1460 and @xmath1461 .
[ item : better - coincidence ] let @xmath1462 be two non - constant solutions of .
assume that @xmath1454 is not a translate of @xmath1463 in @xmath1380-direction .
then for any @xmath1464 the subset @xmath1465 \times \{t\})\}$ ] is open and dense in @xmath1444 .
[ item : critical ] is ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 2.3(ii ) ) .
[ item : coincidence ] is a form of the unique continuation theorem ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 3.1 ) , and [ item : preimage ] follows from it by letting @xmath1466 be a constant map . [
item : shifted ] is a variant of ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 4.2 ) , and is proved as follows .
@xmath1467 is a holomorphic map of the form @xmath1468 . by looking at the derivative of @xmath1238 one
sees that it must be a translation in @xmath1380-direction .
the proof of the final property [ item : better - coincidence ] is similar to that of ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.3 ) ; however , the differences are sufficiently important to deserve a detailed discussion .
it is clear that @xmath1469 is open for any @xmath1464 .
now assume that @xmath1470 is a point which has a neighbourhood disjoint from @xmath1469 .
after possibly moving @xmath1471 slightly , one can assume that @xmath1472 .
this can be achieved because @xmath1473 is a countable set by [ item : critical ] , and hence @xmath1474 is countable by [ item : preimage ] . again because of [ item : preimage ] , there are only finitely many @xmath1475 $ ] such that @xmath1476 . by choice of @xmath1471
, we have @xmath1477 for all these @xmath1478 .
choose an @xmath1479 such that the restriction of @xmath1454 to the open disc @xmath1480 of radius @xmath1481 around @xmath1482 is an embedding for any @xmath214 .
* claim a : * _ there is an @xmath1483 with the following property : for each @xmath1484 there is an @xmath1485 with @xmath1486 and @xmath1487 . _ to prove this , take a sequence of points @xmath1488 with limit @xmath1471 . for sufficiently large @xmath73
we have @xmath1489 .
hence there are @xmath1490 $ ] , @xmath1491 , such that @xmath1492 .
if the claim is false , one can choose the @xmath1493 and @xmath1494 in such a way that @xmath1495 .
then , after passing to a subsequence , one obtains a limit @xmath1496 $ ] with @xmath1497 and @xmath1498 , which is a contradiction .
* claim b : * _ there is a nonempty connected open subset @xmath1499 and a @xmath1500 with the following property : for any @xmath1501 there is an @xmath1502 with @xmath1486 and @xmath1503 . _
let @xmath1504 be the closed subset of those @xmath506 such that @xmath1505 for some @xmath1506 .
claim a says that @xmath1507 ; hence at least one of the @xmath1508 must have nonempty interior . define @xmath1509 to be some small open disc inside that @xmath1508 ; this proves claim b. now consider the restrictions @xmath1510 and @xmath1511 , where @xmath1512 . by definition @xmath1511
is an embedding ; applying [ item : shifted ] shows that @xmath1510 is a translate of @xmath1511 in @xmath1380-direction . because of unique continuation [ item : coincidence ] it follows that @xmath1463 must be a translate of @xmath1454 , which completes the proof of [ item : better - coincidence ] .
after these preliminary considerations , we can now turn to the actual proof of lemma [ th : regular ] .
set @xmath1513 .
@xmath1130 can not be a translate of @xmath833 in @xmath1380-direction . to see this ,
assume that on the contrary @xmath1514 for some @xmath1515 .
the case @xmath1516 is excluded by the assumptions , since it would imply that @xmath1517 . if @xmath1518 then @xmath1519 which , because of the finiteness of the energy , means that @xmath833 is constant ; this is again excluded by the assumptions .
clearly @xmath1520 where @xmath1521 @xmath1522 is the set of regular points of @xmath833 as defined in @xcite , and it is open and dense by a slight variation of ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.3 ) ; see also @xcite .
@xmath1523 is open and dense by [ item : preimage ] above .
@xmath1524 is the intersection of countably many sets @xmath1525 , each of which is open and dense by [ item : better - coincidence ] .
baire s theorem now shows that @xmath1526 is dense . as for its openness
, it can be proved by an elementary argument , as in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.3 ) .
[ th : transversality ] there is a @xmath1427 such that every @xmath1367 whose image is not contained in @xmath1420 is regular . in fact , the subspace of such @xmath1381 is @xmath1382-dense in @xmath1435 .
it is convenient to recall first the proof of the basic transversality result in floer theory , proposition [ th : fhs ] .
let @xmath1527 be the tangent space of @xmath1344 at some point @xmath1381 .
this space consists of smooth families @xmath1528 of sections @xmath1529 satisfying some additional properties , which we will not write down here . for @xmath1365 and @xmath1367
one defines an operator @xmath1530 the main point in the proof of proposition [ th : fhs ] is to show that @xmath1531 is always onto .
assume that the contrary holds : then , because the image is closed , there is a nonzero @xmath1532 , with @xmath1533 , which satisfies a linear @xmath1534-type equation , hence is smooth on @xmath1444 , and such that @xmath1535 } { \omega}(y_t(u ) \partial u/\partial t , j_t(u ) z ) \ ; ds\ , dt = 0 \quad \text{for all } { \mathbf{y}}\in { \mathcal{t}}_{\mathbf{j}}.\ ] ] let @xmath1536 be the limits of @xmath833 . excluding the case of constant maps @xmath833 , for which @xmath1377 is already onto , one can find an @xmath1537 with @xmath1538 , @xmath1539 , and @xmath1540 . in order to avoid problems with the behaviour of @xmath1541 near the boundary ,
it is useful to require that @xmath1542 lies outside a fixed small neighbourhood of @xmath149 . then , assuming that @xmath1543 , one can construct a @xmath1544 which is concentrated on a small neighbourhood of @xmath1542 and which contradicts .
since the set of points @xmath506 with these properties is open , it follows that @xmath414 vanishes on some open subset . by the unique continuation for solutions of linear @xmath1534-equations , @xmath1545 , which is a contradiction .
the proof of proposition [ th : transversality ] differs from this in that one considers only equivariant @xmath1381 .
this means that the domain of @xmath1531 must be restricted to those @xmath1541 which are equivariant .
one considers a supposed @xmath414 as before , and takes a point @xmath1546 as in lemma [ th : regular ] .
the same local construction as before yields a non - equivariant @xmath1544 which is concentrated near @xmath1542 .
one then makes this equivariant by taking @xmath1547 ; the properties of @xmath1526 ensure that this averaged element of the tangent space still leads to a contradiction with .
the details are straightforward , and we leave them to the reader . the notations @xmath145 , @xmath165 , @xmath1252 and @xmath1419 are as in the previous section .
we begin with the most straightforward application of equivariant transversality .
[ th : first - symmetry ] let @xmath1301 be two @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds with @xmath1548 and @xmath1549 .
assume that the following properties hold : [ item : first - intersection ] the intersection @xmath1550 is transverse , and each intersection point lies in @xmath1420 ; [ item : first - no - invariants ] there is no continuous map @xmath501 ^ 2 \longrightarrow m^\iota$ ] with the following properties : @xmath1551 , @xmath1552 for all @xmath528 , where @xmath1553 are points of @xmath1550 , and @xmath1554 , @xmath1555 for all @xmath1380
. then @xmath1556 .
an inspection of the proof of lemma [ th : compatible][item : compatible - one ] shows that one can find @xmath1252-compatible lagrangian submanifolds @xmath1557 , @xmath1353 , which are isotopic to @xmath1351 by an exact _ and @xmath1419-equivariant _ lagrangian isotopy rel @xmath1305 .
moreover , this can be done in such a way that @xmath1557 is equal to @xmath1351 outside a small neighbourhood of @xmath149 , and such that @xmath1558 .
then the conditions [ item : first - intersection ] and [ item : first - no - invariants ] continue to hold with @xmath1312 replaced by @xmath1559 .
choose a @xmath1427 which has the property stated in proposition [ th : transversality ] .
we will show that @xmath1384 .
assume that on the contrary there is a @xmath1367 which is not regular .
note that @xmath833 can not be constant , since the constant maps are regular for any choice of @xmath1381 . by proposition [ th : transversality ] @xmath1437
. then condition [ item : first - no - invariants ] says that the two endpoints @xmath1560 must necessarily agree . because of the gradient flow interpretation of floer s equation ( recall that the action functional is not multivalued in the situation which we are considering ) , @xmath833 must be constant , which is a contradiction .
this shows that @xmath1381 is indeed regular .
composition with @xmath1419 defines an involution on @xmath1357 .
it is not difficult to see that the index of @xmath1377 and @xmath1561 are the same ; indeed , there are obvious isomorphisms between the kernels resp .
cokernels of these two operators .
moreover , @xmath833 and @xmath1562 have the same endpoints because @xmath1563 .
hence the involution preserves each subset @xmath1375 .
consider the induced involution @xmath1564 on the quotients @xmath1385
. a fixed point of @xmath1564 would be a map @xmath1367 such that @xmath1565 for some @xmath1459 . by the same argument as in the proof of lemma [ th : regular ]
, the only maps with this property are the constant ones , which do not lie in @xmath1566 since the associated operators have index zero .
hence @xmath1564 is free for all @xmath1388 . by definition ,
@xmath23 is the homology of @xmath1567 .
since each set @xmath1385 admits a free involution , @xmath1568 and hence @xmath1569 are zero , so that @xmath1570 . [
th : symmetry ] let @xmath1301 be two @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds with @xmath1548 and @xmath1549 .
assume that the following properties hold : [ item : clean ] the intersection @xmath1571 is clean , and there is a @xmath1419-invariant morse function @xmath153 on @xmath48 whose critical points are precisely the points of @xmath1572 ; [ item : no - invariants ] same as [ item : first - no - invariants ] above
. then @xmath1573 .
clean intersection means that @xmath48 is a smooth manifold and @xmath1574 .
we will now describe a local model for clean intersections , due to weinstein ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.3 ) .
there are a neighbourhood @xmath1575 of @xmath48 , a function @xmath1576 with @xmath1577 and which is nondegenerate in the sense of bott , a neighbourhood @xmath1578 of the zero - section , and a symplectic embedding @xmath1579 with @xmath1580 and @xmath1581 . here
@xmath1582 carries the standard symplectic structure , @xmath1276 is considered to be embedded in @xmath828 as the zero - section , and @xmath1583 is the graph of @xmath1584 .
weinstein s construction can easily be adapted to take into account the presence of a finite symmetry group . in our situation
this means that one can take @xmath1585 to be invariant under @xmath1586 , @xmath828 to be invariant under the induced action of @xmath168 on @xmath1582 , and @xmath1238 to be an equivariant embedding .
let @xmath153 be a function as in [ item : clean ] .
one can find a @xmath1419-invariant function @xmath1587 such that @xmath1588 .
an elementary argument shows that for all sufficiently small @xmath535 , @xmath1589 is a morse function whose critical point set is @xmath1590 .
define a lagrangian submanifold @xmath1591 by setting @xmath1592 and @xmath1593 for some small @xmath535 .
@xmath1594 is obviously @xmath1419-invariant , and can be deformed back to @xmath1300 by an exact lagrangian isotopy rel @xmath149 .
moreover , @xmath1595 consists of the critical points of @xmath1596 , hence is equal to @xmath1597 .
the @xmath1419-invariant parts of @xmath1257 are lagrangian submanifolds of @xmath1420 which intersect cleanly in @xmath1597 . by assumption [ item : clean ] @xmath1597 is a finite set , so that @xmath1598 and @xmath1599 actually intersect transversally . since @xmath1600 is a @xmath1601-small perturbation of @xmath1602 , there is a homeomorphism of @xmath1420 which sends @xmath1598 to itself and carries @xmath1599 to @xmath1600 . as a consequence of this , [ item : no - invariants ] continues to hold with @xmath1312 replaced by @xmath1603 .
we have now proved that the pair @xmath1604 satisfies all the assumptions of lemma [ th : first - symmetry ] . using that lemma and proposition [ th : isotopy - invariance ] one obtains @xmath1605 it remains to explain why @xmath1606 is equal to the dimension of @xmath1607 .
this is in fact a consequence of the finite - dimensional ( morse theory ) analogue of lemma [ th : first - symmetry ] .
consider the gradient flow of @xmath153 with respect to some @xmath168-invariant metric on @xmath48 . since @xmath1597 is a finite set , there are no @xmath168-invariant gradient flow lines
. therefore one can perturb the metric equivariantly so that the moduli spaces of gradient flow lines become regular .
then @xmath1419 induces a free @xmath168-action on these moduli spaces , which implies that the differential in the morse cohomology complex ( with coefficients in @xmath168 ) for @xmath153 is zero .
hence @xmath1608 .
the basic idea in this section is due to kontsevich @xcite ; for a detailed exposition see @xcite .
let @xmath1609 be as in section [ subsec : floer ] , with @xmath1610 ; in addition assume that @xmath1611 is zero .
let @xmath1612 be the natural fibre bundle whose fibres @xmath1613 are the lagrangian grassmannians ( the manifolds of all linear lagrangian subspaces ) of @xmath1614 . recall that @xmath1615 and that @xmath1616 has a canonical generator , the maslov class @xmath1617 .
because of our assumption on the first chern class , there is a cohomology class on @xmath1618 which restricts to @xmath1617 for any @xmath877 . correspondingly there is an infinite cyclic covering @xmath1619 such that each restriction @xmath1620 is the universal covering .
fix one such covering ( there may be many non - isomorphic ones in general , so that there is some nontrivial choice to be made here ) and denote the @xmath107-action on it by @xmath1621 . for any lagrangian submanifold @xmath999 in @xmath145
there is a canonical section @xmath1622 given by @xmath1623 .
a _ grading of @xmath999 _ is a lift @xmath1624 of @xmath1625 to @xmath1626 .
clearly , a grading exists iff @xmath1627 is a trivial covering of @xmath999 , so that the obstruction lies in @xmath1628 .
pairs @xmath1629 are called _ graded lagrangian submanifolds _ ; we will usually write @xmath1624 instead of @xmath1629 . @xmath1621 defines a @xmath107-action on the set of graded lagrangian submanifolds .
there is also a notion of isotopy , whose definition is obvious . an equivalent formulation of the theory goes as follows .
let @xmath1630 be an @xmath137-compatible almost complex structure on @xmath26 . by assumption
the bicanonical bundle @xmath1631 is trivial ; any nowhere zero section @xmath1632 of it determines a map @xmath1633 defined by @xmath1634 for any family of @xmath128 orthonormal vectors @xmath1635 spanning a lagrangian subspace .
the pullback of the universal cover @xmath1636 , @xmath1637 by @xmath1638 is a covering @xmath1626 of the kind considered above , and one can show that all such coverings ( up to isomorphism ) can be obtained in this way . from this point of view , a grading of a lagrangian submanifold @xmath999 is just a map @xmath1639 which is a lift of @xmath1640 , @xmath1641 ; and the @xmath107-action on the set of gradings is by adding constant functions .
suppose that @xmath26 is the intersection of a complex hypersurface @xmath1642 with some ball in @xmath133 , and that @xmath137 is the restriction of the standard symplectic form
. in this case one can take @xmath1630 to be the standard complex structure , and @xmath1632 to be the square of the complex @xmath128-form @xmath1643 . then , if @xmath1644 is an orthonormal basis of @xmath1645 , one has @xmath1646 let @xmath1647 and @xmath1648 be a pair of graded lagrangian submanifolds . to any point @xmath1649 one can associate an absolute maslov index @xmath1650 . to define it ,
take a path @xmath1651 \longrightarrow \widetilde{{\mathcal{l}}}_x$ ] with endpoints @xmath1652 , @xmath1353 .
the projection of @xmath1653 to @xmath1618 is a path @xmath1654 \longrightarrow { \mathcal{l}}_x$ ] with @xmath1655 .
let @xmath1656 \longrightarrow { \mathcal{l}}_x$ ] be the constant path @xmath1657 , and set @xmath1658 here @xmath1659 is the ` maslov index for paths ' defined in @xcite .
the absolute maslov index is well - defined , essentially because @xmath1660 is unique up to homotopy rel endpoints .
it depends on the gradings through the formula @xmath1661 for later use , we record a situation in which the index is particularly easy to compute . for any @xmath1662
$ ] one can define a quadratic form @xmath1663 on @xmath1664 by setting @xmath1665 , where @xmath1666 is a smooth path in @xmath1614 ( defined for @xmath297 near @xmath528 ) with @xmath1667 , @xmath1668 for all @xmath297 .
in particular , taking @xmath1669 yields a quadratic form @xmath1670 defined on @xmath1671 .
[ th : compute - index ] assume that @xmath1672 is the same for all @xmath1673 , and that the quadratic form @xmath1670 is nonpositive with nullspace precisely equal to @xmath1674
. then @xmath1675 .
we omit the proof , which is an immediate consequence of the basic properties of the maslov index for paths .
now let @xmath1257 be two @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds with @xmath1548 , and @xmath1676 gradings of them . to define @xmath23 one has to deform the given @xmath1351 to @xmath1252-compatible lagrangian submanifolds @xmath1557 as in lemma [ th : perturb ] .
the @xmath1557 inherit preferred gradings @xmath1677 from those of @xmath1351 ( this is done by lifting the isotopy from @xmath1351 to @xmath1557 to an isotopy of graded lagrangian submanifolds ) .
introduce a @xmath107-grading on @xmath1389 by setting @xmath1678 then @xmath1390 , for any @xmath1384 , has degree one , so that one gets a @xmath107-grading on @xmath1679 .
one can show that the continuation isomorphisms between these groups for various choices of @xmath1355 and @xmath1381 have degree zero .
hence there is a well - defined graded floer cohomology group @xmath1680 , which satisfies @xmath1681 in view of the definition of floer cohomology , the whole discussion carries over to pairs of lagrangian submanifolds with @xmath1416 .
we will now explain the relation between this formalism and the traditional _ relative grading _ on floer cohomology , which we have used in the statement of corollary [ th : comparison ] .
the relative grading is defined under the assumption that a certain class @xmath1682 vanishes ; then @xmath23 splits as a direct sum of groups corresponding to the different connected components of @xmath1683 , and for each of these summands there is a @xmath107-grading which is unique up to a constant shift ; see e.g. @xcite , @xcite .
if the manifolds @xmath1257 admit gradings , for some covering @xmath1626 , then @xmath1684 must necessarily be zero , and the absolute grading @xmath1680 with respect to any @xmath1676 is also one of the possible choices of relative grading .
the converse statement is false : there are more choices of relative gradings than those which occur as @xmath1680 .
[ th : graded - symmetry ] let @xmath1301 be two lagrangian submanifolds as in proposition [ th : symmetry ] , and assume that they have gradings @xmath1676 with respect to some covering @xmath1626 .
then there is a graded isomorphism @xmath1685 here @xmath1686 are the connected components of @xmath1571 ; and @xmath1687 is the index @xmath1688 at some point @xmath1689 ( this is independent of the choice of @xmath877 because the intersection @xmath1550 is clean ) .
the proof is essentially the same as that of proposition [ th : symmetry ] .
there is just one additional computation , which describes the change in the maslov index when @xmath1257 are perturbed to make the intersection transverse .
since this is a well - known issue , which has been addressed e.g. in @xcite , we will not discuss it here .
we will first define the general notion of symplectic monodromy map for deformations of isolated hypersurface singularities .
after that we consider the milnor fibres of the singularities of type @xmath129 in more detail . concretely ,
following a suggestion of donaldson , we will set up a map @xmath1690 here `` curve '' is taken in the sense of section [ subsec : curves ] .
at least for those curves which meet at least one marked point , the floer cohomology of the associated lagrangian submanifolds is well - defined and recovers the geometric intersection number of the curves .
this quickly leads to a proof of our main symplectic results , theorem [ th : gin - two ] and corollary [ th : faithful - two ] .
we will also carry out a refined version of the same argument , which involves floer cohomology as a graded group .
a comparison between this and the results of section [ subsec : bigrdim ] yields corollary [ th : comparison ] . [ item : f1 ] a proper smooth fibration @xmath1693 whose fibres @xmath1694 are manifolds with boundary .
if @xmath1009 also has a boundary , @xmath432 is a manifold with corners ; in that case we adopt the convention that @xmath1695 refers just to the boundary in fibre direction , which is the union of the boundaries @xmath1696 of the fibres ; [ item : f2 ] the structure of a symplectic manifold with contact type boundary on each fibre .
more precisely , we want differential forms @xmath1697 and @xmath1698 , depending smoothly on @xmath1699 and satisfying the obvious conditions .
we also require that @xmath1700 \in h^2(e_w,\partial e_w;{\mathbb{r}})$ ] is zero for all @xmath1666 ; [ item : f4 ] a trivialization of @xmath1704 , compatible with all the given structure .
this is a fibrewise diffeomorphism @xmath1705 such that @xmath1706 and @xmath1707 for each @xmath1708 , and which agrees with @xmath297 on @xmath1709 .
two symplectic fibrations over @xmath1692 are _ cobordant _ if they can be joined by a symplectic fibration over @xmath1710 , \widehat{w } \times [ 0;1])$ ] .
a symplectic fibration is called _ strict _ if @xmath1711 for all @xmath1666 ( for a general symplectic fibration , this holds only as an equality of contact structures ) .
what we have defined is actually a family of symplectic manifolds with contact type boundary , equipped with certain additional data .
still , we prefer to use the name symplectic fibration for the sake of brevity ; for the same reason we usually write @xmath432 rather than @xmath1712 .
[ ex : interval ] let @xmath30 be a map in @xmath1309 . consider the projection @xmath1713 \longrightarrow [ 0;1]$ ] . define @xmath1714 to be the identity , and @xmath1715 to be @xmath1716 .
this , with the remaining data chosen in the obvious way , defines a strict symplectic fibration over @xmath1717,\{0;1\})$ ] , which we denote by @xmath1718 .
the nontrivial issue here is that different fibres of a symplectic fibration may not be symplectically isomorphic ; not even their volumes need to be the same .
we will therefore define @xmath1720 first for strict symplectic fibrations , where the problem does not occur , and then extend the definition using cobordisms .
an alternative approach is outlined in remark [ th : alternative ] below .
take a symplectic fibration @xmath432 over @xmath1692 , and let @xmath1726 be the function defined by @xmath1727 ; by assumption , it vanishes on @xmath1728 .
choose @xmath1311 with @xmath1729 , @xmath1293 , and let @xmath1730 be the embedding determined by the corresponding liouville vector field .
similarly choose a smooth family @xmath1731 , @xmath1699 , with @xmath1732 and @xmath1733 for all @xmath1666 , and such that @xmath1734 whenever @xmath1708 .
this determines an embedding of @xmath1735 into @xmath432 which fibers over @xmath1009 . by combining this with @xmath297 ,
one obtains an embedding @xmath1736 which satisfies @xmath1737 , and such that @xmath1738 for @xmath1708 .
more precisely , we will show that for any point of @xmath1009 there is a neighbourhood @xmath1276 and a local trivialization @xmath1740 which agrees with @xmath1739 on @xmath1741 , such that @xmath1742 for all @xmath1743 in a neighbourhood of @xmath1744 .
the transition maps between two local trivializations with this property obviously take values in @xmath1309 , providing the desired structure .
this is not difficult .
one takes a one - form @xmath1632 on @xmath432 with @xmath1753 , such that @xmath1754 is equal to the pullback of @xmath1755 near @xmath1750 , and with @xmath1756 the pullback of @xmath165 to @xmath1757 .
such a one - form exists because the fibration is strict .
then @xmath1758 satisfies the conditions above .
define , for any @xmath1759 , a subspace @xmath1760 .
the subbundle @xmath1761 formed by the @xmath1762 is complementary to @xmath1763 by [ item : o1 ] and is tangent to @xmath1695 by [ item : o3 ] ; hence it defines a connection on @xmath1693
. the parallel transport maps of this connection are symplectic by [ item : o2 ] ( the reader can find a more extensive discussion of symplectic connections in ( * ? ? ? * chapter 6 ) ) .
moreover , with respect to the map @xmath1764 , they are trivial near @xmath1695 by [ item : o3 ] . using those maps ,
one easily obtains the desired local trivializations .
take a symplectic fibration @xmath432 , and define @xmath1238 and @xmath1764 as before .
let @xmath1765 be given by @xmath1766 .
choose some @xmath1479 and a function @xmath1767 , such that the restriction @xmath1768 has the following properties for each @xmath1699 : @xmath1769 for @xmath1770 , @xmath1771 for @xmath1772 , and @xmath1773 for @xmath1774 .
for @xmath1775 $ ] define @xmath1776 by setting @xmath1777 outside @xmath1778 \times \partial m)$ ] and @xmath1779 @xmath1780 is a symplectic form on @xmath1781 .
in fact , the top exterior power of the two - form on the r.h.s of is @xmath1782 , and this is everywhere nonzero by assumption on @xmath1783 .
define @xmath1784 by @xmath1785 . in the same way one can construct one - forms @xmath1786 on @xmath1781 with @xmath1787 and @xmath1788 , which shows that the relative cohomology class @xmath1789 $ ] is zero .
@xmath1790 is a symplectic manifold with contact type boundary for all @xmath1791 $ ] . for
@xmath1792 these are the original fibres @xmath1793 ; the same holds for arbitrary @xmath1380 when @xmath1708 , since then @xmath1794 .
note also that for @xmath1795 , @xmath1796 . finally , by putting these forms onto @xmath1797 \rightarrow w \times [ 0;1]$ ] and taking @xmath1798 to be induced from @xmath1799 in the obvious way , one obtains a cobordism between @xmath432 and the strict symplectic fibration @xmath1800 . for a strict symplectic fibration @xmath432
one defines @xmath1720 in terms of the fibre bundle structure from lemma [ th : fibre - bundle ] . to show that this is independent of all choices , it is sufficient to observe that any two fibre bundle structures on @xmath432 obtained from different choices of @xmath1801 can be joined by a fibre bundle structure on @xmath1802 $ ] . as mentioned earlier ,
the definition is then extended to general symplectic fibrations by using lemma [ th : strict ] .
there is again a uniqueness part of the proof , which consists in showing that two strict symplectic fibrations which are cobordant are also cobordant by a strict cobordism ; this is a relative version of lemma [ th : strict ] .
the properties [ item : naturality][item : interval ] follow immediately from the definition ; and the fact that they characterize @xmath1720 is obvious .
our construction implies that @xmath1720 is multiplicative in the following sense : if @xmath1803 are two paths @xmath1717,\{0;1\ } ) \longrightarrow ( w,\widehat{w})$ ] with @xmath1804 , then @xmath1805 ) = \rho_s^e([\beta_1 ] ) \rho_s^e([\beta_0])$ ] . in the special case where @xmath1806 is a single point ,
one obtains a group homomorphism @xmath1807 ( because of the way in which we write the composition of paths , our fundamental groups are the opposites of the usual ones ) . as a final observation , note that @xmath1720 depends only on the homotopy class ( rel @xmath1808 ) of the contact trivialization @xmath297 ; the reason is that changing @xmath297 within such a class gives a fibration which is cobordant to the original one .
[ th : alternative ] an alternative way of proving proposition [ th : monodromy ] is to attach an infinite cone to @xmath26 , forming a noncompact symplectic manifold @xmath1809 . because @xmath1291 = 0 $ ] , the inclusion @xmath1810 is a weak homotopy equivalence .
given a symplectic fibration @xmath432 , one similarly attaches an infinite cone to each fibre .
the resulting family of non - compact symplectic manifolds admits a natural structure of a fibre bundle with the group @xmath1811 as structure group , and this defines a map @xmath1812 [ th : relative - monodromy - one ] let @xmath432 be a symplectic fibration over @xmath1813,\{0;1\})$ ] .
let @xmath1814 be a compact submanifold which intersects each fibre @xmath1781 transversally , such that @xmath1815 is a closed lagrangian submanifold for all @xmath1666 .
define lagrangian submanifolds @xmath1301 by @xmath1816 .
let @xmath1306 be a map which represents @xmath1817)$ ] , where @xmath1723}$ ] .
then @xmath1300 is lagrangian isotopic to @xmath1818 .
the result is obvious when @xmath432 is strict ; as remarked after lemma [ th : fibre - bundle ] , we may then assume that @xmath1721 is as in example [ ex : interval ] , and the submanifolds @xmath1819 will form a lagrangian isotopy between @xmath148 and @xmath1820 .
now consider the general case ; for this we adopt the notation from the proof of lemma [ th : strict ] .
the vector fields dual to the one - forms @xmath1821 define a semiflow @xmath1822 on @xmath432 , whose restriction to each fibre is liouville ( rescales the symplectic form exponentially ) . define @xmath1823 \subset \widetilde{e},\ ] ] where @xmath1824 is a number smaller than @xmath1825 for all @xmath1699 .
the restriction @xmath1826 is a closed lagrangian submanifold in @xmath1827 for all @xmath1828 $ ] . by restricting to the subset @xmath1829 , on which @xmath1830 becomes strict , and
using the observation made above concerning the strict case together with the cobordism invariance of @xmath1720 , one finds that @xmath1831 is lagrangian isotopic to @xmath1832 .
moreover , the flow @xmath1833 provides symplectic isotopies between @xmath1834 and @xmath1835 for @xmath1836 .
[ th : relative - monodromy - two ] let @xmath432 be a symplectic fibration over @xmath1813,\{0;1\})$ ] .
let @xmath1837 be a compact submanifold with which intersects each fibre @xmath1781 transversally , and such that @xmath1815 is a lagrangian submanifold with nonempty boundary for all @xmath1666 .
assume that the path in the space of all legendrian submanifolds of @xmath1838 defined by @xmath1839 is closed and contractible .
then , for @xmath1257 and @xmath30 as in the previous lemma , @xmath1300 is isotopic to @xmath1818 by a lagrangian isotopy rel @xmath149 . to begin with , some notation : @xmath1840 , @xmath1841 , @xmath1842
denote the open ball , the closed ball , and the sphere of radius @xmath1843 around the origin in @xmath1844 ; @xmath1845 and @xmath1846 are the standard forms .
let @xmath1847 $ ] be a polynomial with @xmath1848 and @xmath1849 , such that @xmath1850 is an isolated critical point .
a theorem of milnor says that @xmath1851 intersects @xmath1852 transversally for all sufficiently small @xmath1479 .
fix an @xmath1481 in that range .
assume that we are given a family @xmath1853 of polynomials of the form @xmath1854 , where @xmath1855 .
the intersection of @xmath1856 with @xmath1852 remains transverse for all sufficiently small @xmath1666 .
fix a @xmath1857 such that this is the case for all @xmath1858 .
this is an immediate consequence of gray s theorem , because @xmath1861 is contractible .
let @xmath1862 be the subset of those @xmath1666 such that @xmath1863 contains no singular point of @xmath1864 .
it is open and connected , because its complement is a complex hypersurface . for each @xmath1699 equip @xmath1865 with the forms @xmath1866 and @xmath1867 , and set @xmath1868
then each @xmath1793 is a symplectic manifold with contact boundary , and the relative symplectic class @xmath1700 $ ] is zero because of the existence of @xmath1821 .
consider the smooth fibration @xmath1869 whose fibres are the manifolds @xmath1781 .
choose some base point @xmath1870 and set @xmath1871 .
by restriction , any trivialization as in lemma [ th : gray ] defines a contact trivialization @xmath1872 .
take @xmath1873 to be the identity map .
what we have defined is a symplectic fibration @xmath432 over @xmath1874 . by proposition [ th : monodromy ]
one can associate to it a homomorphism @xmath1875 in the usual terminology , @xmath432 is the milnor fibration of the deformation @xmath1876 of the singularity @xmath1877 , and the manifolds @xmath1781 are the milnor fibres .
we call @xmath158 the symplectic monodromy map associated to the deformation .
we need to discuss briefly how @xmath158 depends on the various parameters involved .
@xmath297 is unique up to homotopy , so that @xmath158 is independent of it .
changing @xmath298 affects the space @xmath1009 , but the fundamental group remains the same for all sufficiently small @xmath298 , and we will assume from now on that @xmath298 has been chosen in that range . the dependence on the base point @xmath1878 is a slightly more complicated issue .
different fibres of the milnor fibration are not necessarily symplectically isomorphic , but they become isomorphic after attaching an infinite cone , as in remark [ th : alternative ] .
this means that , given a path in @xmath1009 from @xmath1879 to @xmath1880 , one can identify @xmath1881 and this fits into a commutative diagram with the corresponding isomorphism @xmath1882 and with the symplectic monodromy maps at these base points . for a similar reason , making @xmath1481 smaller changes
@xmath26 but does not affect @xmath159 or @xmath158 .
finally ( but we will not need this ) one can choose @xmath1883 to be a miniversal deformation of @xmath16 , and then the resulting symplectic monodromy map is really an invariant of the singularity .
apart from the present paper , symplectic monodromy has been studied only for the one - parameter deformations @xmath1884 . in that case @xmath1885 , so that it is sufficient to consider the class @xmath1886 = \rho_s(1 ) \in \pi_0({\mathrm{symp}}(m,\partial m,{\omega}))$ ] .
when @xmath16 is the ordinary singularity @xmath1887 , @xmath26 is isomorphic to a neighbourhood of the zero - section in @xmath1888 , and @xmath30 can be chosen to be the generalized dehn twist along the zero - section in the sense of @xcite , @xcite ; those papers show that @xmath1886 $ ] has infinite order in all dimensions @xmath1889 .
we should say that the relevance of symplectic geometry in this example was first pointed out by arnold @xcite .
more generally , in @xcite it is proved that @xmath1886 $ ] has infinite order for all weighted homogeneous singularities such that the sum of the weights is @xmath1890 ( the definition of symplectic monodromy in @xcite differs slightly from that here , but it can be shown that the outcome is the same ) . the general question , _ does @xmath1886 $ ] have infinite order for all nontrivial isolated hypersurface singularities ?
_ , is open .
we continue to use the notation introduced in the previous section .
the @xmath128-dimensional singularity of type @xmath129 , for @xmath130 , is given by @xmath1891 .
we consider the @xmath3-parameter deformation @xmath1892 , where @xmath1893 $ ] ( this is slightly larger than the usual miniversal deformation , but that makes no difference as far as the monodromy map is concerned ) . since @xmath16 is weighted homogeneous , one can take @xmath1894 .
in contrast , we will make use of the right to choose @xmath298 small
. for @xmath1895 set @xmath1896 .
[ item : positivity ] let @xmath712 \longrightarrow \partial d_w$ ] be an embedded path which moves in positive sense with respect to the obvious orientation .
then @xmath1900 for all @xmath1662 $ ] , where @xmath1901 is the argument function . for @xmath1904 ,
@xmath1905 , and @xmath1906 is a circle centered at the origin , so the conditions are certainly satisfied . perturbing @xmath1666 slightly will change @xmath1907 and @xmath1908 only by a small amount in any @xmath1909-topology , and this implies the first two parts .
the proof of [ item : delta - w ] is even simpler .
we will now study the symplectic geometry of the milnor fibres @xmath1911 equipped with the forms @xmath1912 .
consider the projection @xmath1913 , @xmath1914 , whose fibres are the affine quadrics @xmath1915 .
@xmath1916 is smooth for all @xmath1917 , and actually symplectically isomorphic to @xmath1918 .
if one chooses a symplectic isomorphism which respects the obvious @xmath1919-actions , the zero - section @xmath1920 corresponds to @xmath1921 , which is the subset of those @xmath1922 such that @xmath1923 , @xmath1924 , and @xmath1925 for @xmath1926 . for @xmath1927
, @xmath1916 is homeomorphic to @xmath1918 with the zero - section collapsed to a point , that point being precisely @xmath1928 .
moreover , by definition of @xmath1929 , @xmath1930 for @xmath1699 and @xmath143 a curve in @xmath1931 as defined in section [ subsec : curves ] , set @xmath1932 [ item : donaldson - one ] assume first that @xmath143 can be parametrized by a smooth embedding @xmath483 \longrightarrow d_w$ ] with @xmath1935 and @xmath1936 . because @xmath1937 is a simple zero of @xmath1907
, one can write @xmath1938 for some @xmath1939,{\mathbb{c}}^*)$ ] . choose a smooth square root @xmath1940 , and define a map from the unit ball @xmath1941 to @xmath1781 by @xmath1942 this is a smooth embedding with image @xmath1933 .
since @xmath1764 meets @xmath1908 transversally , the embedding intersects @xmath1696 transversally .
moreover , the pullback of @xmath1821 under is of the form @xmath1943 for some @xmath1944,{\mathbb{r}})$ ] .
this implies that @xmath1945 and @xmath1946 , which means that @xmath1933 is indeed a lagrangian submanifold . in the other case ,
when @xmath143 joins two points of @xmath1902 , @xmath1933 is a lagrangian submanifold diffeomorphic to the @xmath128-sphere ; this is proved in the same way as before , only that now one splits @xmath143 into two parts , and covers @xmath1933 by two smooth charts .
the @xmath1821-exactness of @xmath1933 is obvious for all @xmath1947 , since then @xmath1948 for @xmath152 what one has to prove is that @xmath1949 for some orientation of @xmath1933 . now
the involution @xmath1950 preserves @xmath1821 and reverses the orientation of @xmath1933 , as one can see by looking at the tangent space at any point @xmath1951 , @xmath1952 ; this implies the desired result .
part [ item : donaldson - two ] of the lemma follows from [ item : donaldson - one ] together with lemma [ th : exact - isotopies ] .
[ th : positive - isotopies ] let @xmath143 be a curve in @xmath1931 which joins a point of @xmath1902 with a point of @xmath1908 . take a vector field on @xmath1908 which is nonvanishing and positively oriented . extend it to a vector field @xmath414 on @xmath1929 which vanishes near @xmath1902 , and let @xmath533 be the flow of @xmath414 .
then the lagrangian isotopy @xmath1953 , @xmath1954 , is exact and also positive in the sense of section [ subsec : symplectic ] .
the exactness follows again from lemma [ th : exact - isotopies ] .
define a smooth path @xmath712 \longrightarrow \partial d_w$ ] by requiring that @xmath1955 be the unique point of @xmath1956 .
choose some square root of @xmath1957 , and consider @xmath1958 \longrightarrow \partial e_w , \quad ( y , t ) \longmapsto ( \sqrt{-h_w(\beta(t))}y,\beta(t)).\ ] ] this maps @xmath1959 to @xmath1960 .
a computation shows that the pullback of @xmath1961 under is @xmath1237 , where @xmath1962 is a positive function by [ item : positivity ] in lemma [ th : convex ] .
this is one of the definitions of a positive isotopy .
the intersections of the submanifolds @xmath1933 are governed by those of the underlying curves .
in fact @xmath1963 consists of an @xmath1964-sphere for any point of @xmath1965 together with an isolated point for each point of @xmath1966 .
the next lemma translates this elementary fact into a statement about floer cohomology .
we consider first the case when @xmath1969 and @xmath1970 .
@xmath518 depends only on the isotopy classes of @xmath486 ; the same is true of @xmath1967 , by lemma [ th : donaldson][item : donaldson - two ] and proposition [ th : isotopy - invariance ] .
hence we may assume that @xmath486 have minimal intersection .
a straightforward computation of the tangent spaces shows that @xmath1971 have clean intersection .
moreover , since @xmath1969 , @xmath1972 . consider the involution @xmath1973 on @xmath1781 , which preserves @xmath1974 and @xmath1821 .
each connected component @xmath1928 of @xmath1975 carries a @xmath1419-invariant morse function @xmath1976 whose critical point set is @xmath1977 .
namely , for @xmath1927 one takes @xmath1976 to be constant , and otherwise @xmath1978 for some choice of square root .
hence @xmath1971 satisfy condition [ item : clean ] in proposition [ th : symmetry ] .
the fixed point set @xmath1420 is precisely the double branched cover of @xmath1929 from section [ subsec : branched - cover ] , and @xmath1979 is the preimage of @xmath1980 under the covering projection .
lemma [ th : lifting - curves ] shows that @xmath1981 and @xmath1982 have minimal intersection as curves in @xmath1420 .
hence , using lemma [ th : no - maps ] , it follows that @xmath1971 also satisfy condition [ item : no - invariants ] in proposition [ th : symmetry ] . applying that proposition shows that @xmath1983 .
next , consider the case when @xmath1969 and @xmath513 .
this means that @xmath510 must be a path joining two points of @xmath1902 ; hence @xmath1984 . on the other hand ,
since @xmath1985 and @xmath1986 are isotopic by an exact lagrangian isotopy , one has @xmath1987 by floer s theorem @xcite .
the final case is @xmath1988 .
then @xmath486 have each one point on the boundary @xmath1908 , which is the same for both , so that @xmath1989 . to compute @xmath1967
one has to perturb @xmath1985 by an exact and positive lagrangian isotopy .
one can take the isotopy to be @xmath1990 for some flow @xmath533 on @xmath1929 as in lemma [ th : positive - isotopies ] . by definition ,
@xmath1991 for small @xmath535 .
this reduces the floer cohomology computation to the case which we have already proved .
one can embed @xmath1009 as an open subset into @xmath539 by sending @xmath1996 .
the image of this embedding contains all configurations of points which lie close to the origin , and it is mapped into itself by the maps which shrink configurations by some factor @xmath1997 . from this one can easily see that the embedding is a weak homotopy equivalence . by combining this with the observation made in section [ subsec : disc ] one obtains canonical isomorphisms @xmath1998 where @xmath102 .
[ th : curves - and - monodromy ] let @xmath106 and @xmath1306 be related in the following way : @xmath546 \in \pi_0({\mathcal{g}})$ ] corresponds to a class in @xmath1999 whose image under @xmath158 is @xmath1886 \in \pi_0({\mathrm{symp}}(m,\partial m,{\omega}))$ ] .
then , for any curve @xmath143 in @xmath116 which meets @xmath97 , @xmath2000 and @xmath2001 are isotopic by a lagrangian isotopy rel @xmath149 .
consider first the case when @xmath2002 .
since the result depends only on the isotopy class of @xmath143 , we may assume that @xmath2003 .
similarly , the result depends only on the isotopy class of @xmath103 , and we may assume that @xmath103 is the identity outside @xmath2004 . take a smooth path @xmath2005,\{0;1\ } ) \longrightarrow ( w,\hat{w})$ ] whose class in @xmath1999 corresponds to @xmath546 \in \pi_0({\mathcal{g}})$ ] under the canonical isomorphism .
this means that there is an isotopy @xmath526 in @xmath2006 with @xmath529 , @xmath2007 , and @xmath2008 for all @xmath528 .
we may assume that each @xmath2009 is equal to the identity outside @xmath2010 .
then @xmath2011 is a curve in @xmath2012 for all @xmath1662 $ ] .
moreover , the lagrangian submanifolds @xmath2013 depend smoothly on @xmath528 ; by this we mean that they form a submanifold @xmath2014 of the pullback @xmath2015 $ ] , as in lemma [ th : relative - monodromy - one ]
. by using that lemma and the naturality of the maps @xmath1720 under pullbacks , it follows that @xmath2000 is lagrangian isotopic to @xmath2001 .
the case when @xmath2016 is not very different .
we may assume that the intersection @xmath2017 consists of a straight radial piece @xmath2018 , for some @xmath2019 .
we take a smooth path @xmath2020 and an isotopy @xmath533 as in the previous case .
then @xmath2021 is a curve in @xmath2022 for all @xmath1269 .
the rest is as before except that in order to apply lemma [ th : relative - monodromy - two ] , one has to show that the path of legendrian submanifolds of @xmath2023 given by @xmath2024 is closed and contractible ( in the space of legendrian submanifolds ) .
the closedness is obvious because @xmath2000 and @xmath144 have the same boundary . in order to prove contractibility ,
observe that for any @xmath1860 , one can define a legendrian submanifold @xmath2025 in @xmath2026 by @xmath2027 by using a relative version of lemma [ th : gray ] , one sees that the trivialization @xmath297 can be chosen in such a way that @xmath2028 is the same for all @xmath1699 .
now our path of legendrian submanifolds consists of @xmath2029 , so that its contractibility is obvious for that specific choice of @xmath297 .
since any two @xmath297 are homotopic , it follows that contractibility holds for an arbitrary choice .
[ th : refinement ] assume that the symplectic automorphism @xmath30 in lemma [ th : curves - and - monodromy ] has been chosen @xmath165-exact .
then the isotopy between @xmath2000 and @xmath2001 in lemma [ th : curves - and - monodromy ] can be made exact .
for @xmath2030 there is nothing to prove : first of all , @xmath1297 is zero , so that any choice of @xmath30 is @xmath165-exact ; and secondly , @xmath2031 , so that any lagrangian isotopy between such submanifolds is exact .
therefore we now assume that @xmath152 . since @xmath30 is @xmath165-exact , both @xmath2001 and @xmath2000 are @xmath165-exact lagrangian submanifolds . with one exception ,
it is true that @xmath144 represents a nontrivial class in @xmath2032 , so that the restriction map @xmath2033 is onto ; then one can apply lemma [ th : exist - exact][item : deform - to - exact - isotopy ] to prove the desired result .
the one exception is when @xmath2034 and @xmath143 is the unique ( up to isotopy ) curve joining the two points of @xmath97 . in this particular case
the milnor fibre @xmath2035 is isomorphic to a cylinder @xmath2036 \times s^1 , ds \wedge dt)$ ] , and @xmath144 is a simple closed curve which divides @xmath26 into two pieces of equal area ; to verify this last fact , it is sufficient to note that the involution @xmath1419 exchanges the two pieces
. clearly @xmath2001 also divides @xmath26 into two pieces of equal area ; and this is sufficient to prove that @xmath2001 is isotopic to @xmath144 by an exact isotopy . on the other hand , @xmath2037 for any @xmath106 , so that @xmath144 is exact isotopic to @xmath2000 by lemma [ th : donaldson][item : donaldson - two ] .
now choose a set of basic curves @xmath115 in @xmath116 , and let @xmath2038 be the corresponding lagrangian submanifolds of @xmath145 ; from the discussion above , it follows that these do indeed satisfy . as explained in section [ subsec : disc ] , the choice of @xmath115 allows one to identify each of the canonically isomorphic groups with @xmath4 .
in particular , the symplectic monodromy can now be thought of as a map @xmath2039 . from the various isomorphisms which we have introduced
, it follows that @xmath2040 and @xmath2041 are related as in lemmas [ th : curves - and - monodromy ] and [ th : refinement ] . using those two results together with lemma [ th : floer - cohomology ]
, one finds that @xmath2042 .
let @xmath112 be an element whose image under the monodromy map is the trivial class in @xmath159
. then one can take @xmath2043 in theorem [ th : gin - two ] , so that @xmath2044 for all @xmath181 .
the same holds for @xmath2045 , since @xmath2046 is again trivial . in view of lemma
[ th : detect - identity ] , it follows that @xmath381 must be the trivial element .
[ [ bigraded - curves - and - graded - lagrangian - submanifoldssubsecboth - gradings ] ] bigraded curves and graded lagrangian submanifolds[subsec : both - gradings ] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ we use the notation @xmath116 , @xmath153 , @xmath144 , and @xmath1609 as in the previous section . as explained in section [ subsec : bigraded - curves ] , the polynomial @xmath153 can be used to define a map @xmath2047 which classifies the covering @xmath658 of @xmath646 , and one can express the notion of bigraded curves in terms of this map . on the other hand , @xmath26 is the intersection of a complex hypersurface @xmath2048 with the unit ball @xmath2049 . as explained in section [ subsec : grading ] ,
the polynomial @xmath2050 which defines @xmath2048 determines a map @xmath2051 ; and one can use this map to define a covering @xmath1626 and the corresponding notion of graded lagrangian submanifold of @xmath26 .
gradings - and - bigradings ] let @xmath143 be a curve in @xmath116 which meets @xmath97 .
any bigrading @xmath669 of @xmath143 determines in a canonical way a grading @xmath2052 of @xmath144 .
moreover , if @xmath2052 is the grading associated to @xmath669 , the grading associated to @xmath2053 is @xmath2054 .
let @xmath2055 be an embedding which parametrizes an open subset of @xmath143 , and @xmath1450 a point of @xmath2056 . a straightforward computation ,
starting from , shows that @xmath2057 now assume that we have a bigrading of @xmath143 , which is a map @xmath2058 with specific properties .
define @xmath2059 by @xmath2060 for a point @xmath877 as before .
a comparison of with and shows that @xmath2052 is a grading of @xmath999 , defined everywhere except at finitely many points .
it remains to prove that @xmath2052 can be extended continuously over those missing points . if @xmath2061 , this is true for general reasons .
namely , whenever has a infinite cyclic covering of an @xmath128-dimensional manifold ( which in our case is @xmath1627 ) and a continuous section of it defined outside a finite subset , the values at the missing points can always be filled in continuously . in the remaining case @xmath152 , any one of the missing points divides @xmath144 locally into two components , and one has to check that the limits of @xmath2052 from both directions ( which certainly exist ) are the same . but this follows from the fact that @xmath2052 is invariant under the involution @xmath1419 .
[ th : two - indices ] let @xmath486 be two curves in @xmath116 which meet @xmath97 and which intersect transversally .
let @xmath740 be two bigradings , and @xmath2062 be the local index at a point @xmath2063 .
let @xmath2064 be the corresponding gradings of @xmath2065 .
then the absolute maslov index at any point @xmath2066 is @xmath2067 in view of the last part of lemma [ th : gradings - and - bigradings ] it is sufficient to prove this for @xmath2068 .
take an isotopy @xmath526 in @xmath2069 with @xmath2070 for all @xmath528 , @xmath529 , and @xmath2071 in some neighbourhood of @xmath99 .
we also assume that @xmath2072 rotates clockwise with positive speed during the isotopy , and that the total angle by which is moves is less than @xmath735 ( see figure [ fig : turning ] ) .
let @xmath2073 be the famiy of graded lagrangian submanifolds corresponding to the bigraded curves @xmath2074 . by definition of the local index ,
@xmath2075 is equal to @xmath743 near @xmath99 .
hence @xmath2073 agrees with @xmath2076 near @xmath2077 .
it follows that for any @xmath2078 one can use the paths @xmath2079 \longrightarrow { \mathcal{l}}_x$ ] , @xmath2080 , @xmath2081 , to compute the absolute maslov index .
now , it is not difficult to see that these two paths satisfy the conditions of lemma [ th : compute - index ] , so that the absolute maslov index is in fact zero .
[ th : graded - floer - cohomology ] let @xmath723 and @xmath724 be two bigraded curves in @xmath116 , such that both @xmath510 and @xmath519 intersect @xmath97 .
let @xmath2082 be the corresponding graded lagrangian submanifolds of @xmath145 .
then the poincar polynomial of the graded floer cohomology is obtained by setting @xmath2083 , @xmath2084 in the bigraded intersection number : @xmath2085 this is essentially the same argument as for lemma [ th : floer - cohomology ] . consider the case when @xmath630 and @xmath617 .
we may assume that @xmath486 have minimal intersection .
using proposition [ th : graded - symmetry ] , and lemma [ th : two - indices ] to compute the relevant absolute maslov indices , one finds that the following holds : a point @xmath2063 with local index @xmath2086 contributes @xmath2087 to the poincar polynomial of the floer cohomology .
the factor @xmath2088 in the first case comes from the ordinary cohomology of the @xmath1964-sphere @xmath2077 .
it is now straightforward to compare this with the definition of the bigraded intersection number @xmath756 .
one can forget about graded lagrangian submanifolds and consider lemma [ th : graded - floer - cohomology ] as a statement about the relative grading on @xmath2090 . using this , and arguing as in the proof of theorem [ th : gin - two ]
, one sees that ( for some choice of relative grading on the left hand side ) @xmath2091 the proof is completed by comparing this with proposition [ th : dimequals ] .
v. i. arnold , _ some remarks on symplectic monodromy of milnor fibrations _ , the floer memorial volume ( h. hofer , c. taubes , a. weinstein , and e. zehnder , eds . ) , progress in mathematics , vol . 133 , birkhuser , 1995 , pp .
99104 .
j. bernstein , i. frenkel , and m. khovanov , _ a categorification of the temperley - lieb algebra and schur quotients of @xmath2093 via projective and zuckerman functors _ , selecta math . , new ser . 5 , ( 1999 ) , 199241 ; math.qa/0002087 . | we consider the derived categories of modules over a certain family @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) of graded rings , and floer cohomology of lagrangian intersections in the symplectic manifolds which are the milnor fibres of simple singularities of type @xmath2 we show that each of these two rather different objects encodes the topology of curves on an @xmath3-punctured disc .
we prove that the braid group @xmath4 acts faithfully on the derived category of @xmath0-modules , and that it injects into the symplectic mapping class group of the milnor fibers .
the philosophy behind our results is as follows .
using floer cohomology , one should be able to associate to the milnor fibre a triangulated category ( its construction has not been carried out in detail yet ) .
this triangulated category should contain a full subcategory which is equivalent , up to a slight difference in the grading , to the derived category of @xmath0-modules .
the full embedding would connect the two occurrences of the braid group , thus explaining the similarity between them . |
here we show that if one uses an isotropic exchange interaction instead of the anisotropic interactions in the teleportation protocol one can also perform adiabatic teleportation . in this case
the initial hamiltonian is @xmath90\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the final hamiltonian is @xmath91\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have expressed these hamiltonians in terms of the encoded operations given in eq . 1 of the main text .
these equations show that now instead of two decoupled encoded qubits , the encoded qubits are coupled .
however notice that the initial ground state is the @xmath92 eigenstate of @xmath23 and @xmath24 and the final ground state is the @xmath92 eigenstate of the @xmath27 and @xmath28 , just as in anisotropic exchange protocol , but with the signs flipped .
further there are no level crossing in a linear ramping between these two hamiltonians , and the gap is a constant @xmath93 occurring at the midpoint of this evolution .
thus the adiabatic teleportation protocol caries through for the isotropic exchange .
notice , importantly , that the coupling however must be antiferromagnetic .
here we provide more details on how to implement the hamiltonian in eq . 4 in the main text using the perturbation theory gadgets of bartlett and rudolph @xcite .
in these gadgets , one replaces one of the qubits in a three - qubit interaction by an _ encoded _
qubit across two qubits .
since we need two three - qubit interactions , this means that we require two extra qubits in this construction .
we label our logical qubits @xmath94 and @xmath95 ( for left and right ) , and encode each into four physical qubits labeled 1 4 . and @xmath95 , each encoded in three physical qubits @xmath96 , where the ancillas facilitate the teleportation as discussed in the main text .
blue bars represent @xmath97 couplings , while green triangles represent interactions of the form @xmath98 ( and similarly with @xmath99 ) as in eq .
( [ e : ideal ] ) .
] let s recall eq .
4 , relabeled here as in fig .
[ f : ideal ] .
the ideal initial hamiltonian is @xmath100 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath101 $ ] just means to add the terms which exchange the qubits @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
now let s add the ancilla qubits and move to the encoded subspace .
the encoded subspaces we are working in are the subspaces spanned by @xmath102 and @xmath103 on qubits @xmath104 and @xmath83 .
we can force the joint state of qubits 3 and 4 to lie in this subspace by adding a strong @xmath105 coupling term to the ideal hamiltonian .
thus , eq . ( [ e : ideal ] ) can be realized using encoded operators as the following target hamiltonian @xmath106 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] here the encoded operators ( with bars on top ) are @xmath107 for both the left and right qubits and we are assuming that the coupling strengths satisfy @xmath108 .
we are free to choose either @xmath109 or @xmath110 for the encoded @xmath111 operation because these operators act equivalently up to multiplication by the stabilizer of the encoded subspace . writing this out in terms of the pauli operators on the physical qubits , we find ( for one such choice of encoded @xmath5 ) @xmath112 .\end{aligned}\
] ] following bartlett and rudolph , we use the following initial hamiltonian .
it is a two - body gadget hamiltonian that simulates the low energy behavior of the above target hamiltonian , and is given by @xmath113 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath9 term in this hamiltonian by itself would force the ground state of qubits @xmath104 and @xmath83 to be in the subspace spanned by @xmath102 and @xmath103 as discussed above .
the @xmath71 term is now a two - qubit interaction which simulates the four - body term in the target hamiltonian .
our desired final hamiltonian is given by @xmath114 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice , importantly , that we leave on the interaction which forces qubits @xmath104 and @xmath83 into the encoded subspace during the entire evolution . as usual , our total evolution is given in terms of the scaled time @xmath19 by @xmath115 this evolution is depicted in fig .
[ f : gadget ] .
we must show that the above adiabatic evolution has high fidelity with the ideal evolution and that the gap is not too small .
the fidelity is governed by the overlap of the ground state of @xmath10 with the ground state of the ideal ( encoded ) hamiltonian @xmath116 . .
the simulation gadget uses one additional ancilla qubit ( labeled @xmath83 ) per logical qubit .
qubits @xmath104 and @xmath83 are bound by strong @xmath117 couplings for the duration of the evolution , as shown by the broad green bars .
blue bars represent two - body interactions @xmath118 , while the red horizontal bar represents a @xmath119 coupling .
when the coupling strengths are chosen so that @xmath120 , this adiabatic evolution simulates the ideal evolution of eq .
( [ e : ideal ] ) and fig .
[ f : ideal ] .
the fidelity of the simulation is @xmath121 and the energy gap governing the adiabatic condition is given by @xmath122 . ] in order to analyze this gadget it is useful to perform a change of basis .
in particular if one undoes the controlled - phase gate between the ancilla qubits @xmath123 and @xmath124 , then above hamiltonian becomes a sum of terms acting separately on @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
since this is a unitary conjugation it does nt change the gap , and we can also find the ground state in this basis and transform back . since the hamiltonian is now decoupled across @xmath94 and @xmath95 , we drop these subscripts now and write the transformed initial hamiltonian as @xmath125 note that the final hamiltonian is unaffected by this transformation , and so we need merely to drop the @xmath94 and @xmath95 superscripts to obtain @xmath126 let s first find the ground state of the initial hamiltonian so we can check the fidelity .
we can further simplify things by applying a controlled - not gate from qubit 3 to qubit 2 resulting in @xmath127 in this basis , qubits 1 and 2 completely decouple , and the fidelity depends only on the overlap of this ground state with the bell state @xmath128 on qubits 3 and 4 .
we can exactly diagonalize by first transforming to the bell basis .
let s define @xmath129 to be our small expansion parameter .
then the ground state of eq .
( [ e : twoprimes ] ) on qubits 3 and 4 is given by @xmath130 where the coefficient @xmath131 is @xmath132 expanding in powers of @xmath129 , the fidelity is @xmath133 which is corrected at second order in @xmath134
. now let s compute the gap to see what price we must pay to achieve high fidelity .
in the basis where we have applied a controlled - not from qubit 3 to qubit 2 , the final hamiltonian is @xmath135 note that @xmath136 and @xmath137 commute with both the initial and final hamiltonian , corresponding to the encoded quantum information .
suppose we work in a basis where this information is in the @xmath22 eigenstate of @xmath136 .
then the final hamiltonian simplifies to @xmath138 here we see that qubits @xmath88 and @xmath84 are decoupled from those of @xmath104 and @xmath83 .
if one linearly sweeps between these initial and final hamiltonians , one will obtain a minimal gap for each of these evolutions .
the smaller of these gaps comes from qubits @xmath104 and @xmath83 .
explicitly , the evolution to consider is @xmath139 -s [ \lambda z_3 + \omega ( z_3 z_4)].\ ] ] the gap between the lowest two eigenvalues of this evolution is @xmath140 where @xmath141 using the fact that @xmath142 for @xmath143 we can bound this as @xmath144 we can upper bound the lower equation by @xmath145 , and we can use @xmath146 for @xmath147 to express the gap as @xmath148 this obtains its max at @xmath149 for @xmath150 this yields a bound on the gap of @xmath151 thus we have shown that the initial fidelity with the proper ground state is high @xmath152 , and also that the energy scale which sets the adiabatic condition is set by the perturbative energy scale , @xmath153 . for fault - tolerance we require a fixed accuracy and our results imply that the gadget construction can achieve this , albeit at the cost of the energy gap shrinking and thus a slower adiabatic gate time . | the difficulty in producing precisely timed and controlled quantum gates is a significant source of error in many physical implementations of quantum computers . here
we introduce a simple universal primitive , adiabatic gate teleportation , which is robust to timing errors and many control errors and maintains a constant energy gap throughout the computation above a degenerate ground state space .
notably this construction allows for geometric robustness based upon the control of two independent qubit interactions .
further , our piecewise adiabatic evolution easily relates to the quantum circuit model , enabling the use of standard methods from fault - tolerance theory for establishing thresholds . building a quantum computer
is a daunting task , so much so that it is not even clear which of a plethora of architectures is the most physically viable .
in addition to the standard pulsed implementation of the circuit model of quantum computation ( qc ) , other possible architectures include measurement - based qc @xcite , universal adiabatic qc @xcite , and holonomic qc @xcite .
of these , adiabatic qc has recently drawn considerable attention , in part because of its deep connection to computational complexity problems @xcite , but also due to the advantages this model possesses with respect to decoherence and control @xcite .
similarly holonomic qc has attracted interest because of the geometric robustness of control in this scheme . motivated by some of the benefits of adiabatic and holonomic qc , we introduce a new model of qc which is a hybrid between the adiabatic , circuit , and holonomic models .
this model uses nothing but adiabatic quantum evolution , but instead of using a single interpolation between an initial and final hamiltonian , we use piecewise adiabatic evolutions whose individual parts implement a step in a quantum circuit .
we achieve this by introducing a new primitive : adiabatic gate teleportation ( agt ) .
our route to agt proceeds by merging two quantum computing protocols : teleportation and adiabatic qc .
quantum teleportation is the process of transferring the state of a qubit between two distant parties via the use of an initial shared entangled state and two bits of classical communication @xcite .
notably , while teleportation consumes a bell pair @xmath0 shared between the parties , it can end with a bell pair localized to the sender . in adiabatic qc @xcite one
adiabatically turns off one hamiltonian while turning on another hamiltonian , dragging the system from the ground state of the initial hamiltonian to that of the final hamiltonian .
the initial hamiltonian is chosen such that preparing the system in its ground state can be done efficiently , and the final hamiltonian is chosen so that its ground state is the solution to a computational problem .
motivated by teleportation and adiabatic quantum algorithms , we will attempt to adiabatically mimic teleportation .
this will lead us to an adiabatic protocol for swapping with a simple control scheme that we call adiabatic teleportation .
the main theme of this paper is to use variants on this adiabatic teleportation scheme and the analogy with gate teleportation @xcite to build a universal quantum computer from piecewise adiabatic evolutions .
constant - gap piecewise adiabatic evolution has previously been considered in the context of state preparation @xcite and in the context of producing geometric quantum gates from noncyclic adiabatic evolution @xcite .
our model is distinguished from these results by achieving universality and geometric robustness with separately controlled interactions , and by its explicit connection to gate teleportation . _ adiabatic teleportation _
our setup uses three qubits .
the first qubit is the qubit whose state we wish to transport ( swap ) to the third qubit .
the second qubit is merely a mediator , which ( we will see ) is necessary . at the beginning of the computation
we construct a system whose ground state has a single bell pair @xmath1 on the second and third qubit .
we then adiabatically drag the system to a new hamiltonian whose ground state has a bell pair on the first and second qubit ( again @xmath1 . ) throughout the evolution the lowest energy level , which is two - fold degnerate , remains degenerate .
if we encode a single qubit of information into this degeneracy , then after this adiabatic evolution the information in this first qubit will now reside in the third qubit .
we choose the initial hamiltonian for our three qubits to be @xmath2 and the final hamiltonian to be @xmath3 where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are single qubit pauli matrices , @xmath6 represents the operator @xmath7 acting on the @xmath8th qubit , and the identity acting on all other qubits and @xmath9 sets the energy scale .
the ground state of @xmath10 is two - fold degenerate : we can choose a basis for this space as @xmath11 and @xmath12 .
similarly , the ground state of @xmath13 is spanned by @xmath14 and @xmath15 . in other words , initially we can store a qubit of information in the first qubit and in the final system we can store it in the third qubit and both configurations are ground states of their respective hamiltonians .
now suppose we adiabatically drag the system between @xmath10 and @xmath13 .
for example , we may linearly turn off @xmath10 and turn on @xmath13 so that @xmath16 from time @xmath17 to @xmath18 and @xmath19 is a dimensionless scaled time with scale @xmath20 .
( other interpolation schemes are certainly possible , and indeed this is one of the benefits of using an adiabatic evolution . )
the above evolution moves the information stored in the first qubit to the third qubit , as we now show .
let s first define logical qubit operators @xmath21 initially we are in the @xmath22 eigenstate of @xmath23 and @xmath24 .
writing @xmath25 in this basis we find @xmath26 since this hamiltonian does not include the first logical qubit , it is untouched by the evolution .
this hamiltonian is nothing more than the time dependent sweeping of @xmath23 to @xmath27 and @xmath24 to @xmath28 .
evidently this means that if we perform the above evolution slow enough , then , since we start in the @xmath22 eigenstates of @xmath23 and @xmath24 , at the end of the evolution we will be in the @xmath22 eigenstates of @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
a minimum energy gap of @xmath29 occurs when @xmath30 .
can we figure out what happens to the first qubit under the above evolution ?
we can express the first qubit pauli operators in terms of the above logical qubits : @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
since we start off in the @xmath22 eigenspace of @xmath24 and @xmath23 , we see that the logical information is really encoded into the first logical qubit . as we have argued above , this qubit is untouched by the evolution .
thus when @xmath18 we must have the same logical information in the first qubit , but now be in the @xmath22 eigenvalue subspace of @xmath27 and @xmath28 . now notice that @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
thus we see that actually the information from the first qubit has been dragged to the information on the last qubit .
because the gap of the above adiabatic quantum evolution is constant , if we evolve the system sufficiently slowly and in a smooth enough manner , then the adiabatic theorem guarantees that we can achieve the above process with a high fidelity .
there are numerous adiabatic theorems that can be proven ( see for example @xcite ) which provide guarantees that by making @xmath20 sufficiently large we can increase the probability that the adiabatic evolution will act successfully ( meaning the probability that the system is excited out of the desired subspace is smaller than some constant ) .
choosing @xmath35 is sufficient to guarantee a constant error probability below the threshold for fault - tolerant qc @xcite .
_ three qubits are necessary _
we have shown that it is possible to swap quantum information between two qubits via a simple adiabatic interpolation between two fixed hamiltonians on three qubits .
is it possible to achieve a similar result without the ancilla qubit ? if we wish to simply interpolate between two two - qubit hamiltonians , then no .
this does not imply that it is impossible to adiabatically swap two qubits , only that a construction which behaves like the adiabatic quantum algorithm is not possible .
we will also see how this null result implies significant benefits over other adiabatic schemes such as holonomic qc .
suppose we have two qubits which we wish to swap by adiabatically ramping between an initial hamiltonian @xmath36 and a final hamiltonian @xmath37 .
the initial and final hamiltonians are required to be degenerate such that we can store a single qubit of information in these systems .
further the initial ( final ) hamiltonian must allow for this degeneracy to reside only in the first ( second ) qubit .
without loss of generality , we can pick a basis for the first and second qubit so that @xmath36 and @xmath37 are @xmath38 respectively .
now assume that we turn off @xmath36 while turning on @xmath37 .
this leads to the hamiltonian @xmath39 , where @xmath40 ( @xmath41 ) is a slowly decreasing ( increasing ) function with @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( @xmath44 and @xmath45 ) .
notice , however , that @xmath25 is always diagonal in the basis we picked , and therefore the system can not transform amplitude between these states as required for a swap .
it is crucial here that we assume a simple ramping on and off of the hamiltonians .
more complicated control schemes lead to holonomic qc which differs significantly from our approach
. _ adiabatic gate teleportation _
we have shown how to swap a qubit from the first qubit to the third qubit using adiabatic evolution and now we will show how this can be used to achieve universal qc .
first we will show how in the process of swapping we can also apply a single qubit gate by a simple modification of our initial hamiltonian .
we label this protocol adiabatic gate teleportation ( agt ) in analogy with how gates can be teleported in the quantum circuit model @xcite .
suppose , in analogy with the teleportation of quantum gates , that we apply a unitary rotation on the third qubit on the initial hamiltonian @xmath10 : i.e. consider the initial hamiltonian @xmath46 .
such an operation does not change the final hamiltonian , but does change the initial hamiltonian .
we can then carry the above analysis forward as before , but now in this changed basis . at the end of the evolution we end up with
the logical qubit dragged to the third physical qubit in a rotated basis .
the gap remains @xmath47 since the spectrum is unchanged by a unitary conjugation .
thus it is possible , using this construction , to perform any single - qubit unitary during the adiabatic teleportation .
notice that the rotated @xmath10 will still consist of two - qubit interactions .
for example , if we wish to perform a hadmard gate , we can use the same final hamiltonian , @xmath48 , but chang the initial hamiltonian to @xmath49 .
it is possible to make different assumptions about how the new , rotated @xmath50 hamiltonian arises physically .
we can just assume , for example , that a set of @xmath10 are available in order to perform the desired quantum gates .
a different assumption is that we start with only hamiltonians of the form @xmath51 between qubits @xmath52 and @xmath53 , but allows for one to adiabatically drag this hamiltonian to other `` gate teleporting '' hamiltonians . in this model
we must ensure that the total system remains in the ground space for the entire evolution , so we must also adiabatically transition from our canonical initial hamiltonian @xmath54 to a new hamiltonian @xmath55 which leaves the @xmath52 qubit untouched but prepares @xmath56 on the @xmath53 qubit for agt .
we call this adiabatic gate preparation ( agp ) . in general ,
such an evolution is nt directly possible for an arbitrary choice of @xmath57 .
( for example , consider @xmath58 . )
we can circumvent this by using a universal gate set for a single qubit where every member of the gate set yields an @xmath59 with a gap .
for instance , we can choose the unitaries @xmath60 which have the requisite properties .
the @xmath61 matrix is , up to a phase , a square root of the hadamard matrix , i.e. @xmath62 , while @xmath63 satisfies @xmath64 .
the minimum agp gaps are @xmath65 and @xmath66 , respectively , at @xmath30 .
together , @xmath61 and @xmath63 generate @xmath67 and hence are universal for single - qubit operations ( see pg .
196 of @xcite ) .
next consider how to achieve two - qubit gates during the swapping of two qubits . to do this
we follow as above , but instead of applying a single - qubit gate , we apply a two - qubit gate on the final two output qubits . for example , suppose that we wish to apply a controlled - phase between two logical qubits
. then we start with @xmath68 and end with the hamiltonian @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the controlled - phase between the the third and sixth physical qubit .
notice that the gap in this system is again the same constant @xmath65 , but now we require three - qubit interactions .
we can bypass the inconvenient three - qubit interactions by using perturbation theory gadgets @xcite , i.e. two - body hamiltonians whose low energy dynamics mimic three - qubit interactions .
the price is a reduction in the energy gap by a constant . in the appendix at the end of this paper we provide a detailed analysis of one such construction .
the crux of this analysis shows that we can use two ancilla qubits and interactions of strength @xmath9 and @xmath71 to produce an adiabatic evolution with energy gap @xmath72 with a gate fidelity of @xmath73 . , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 we can perform universal quantum computation .
here we diagram how this works for a single - qubit computation ( circuit below , the hamiltonians at different times diagramed from top to bottom . )
each circle represents a qubit , and a bar represents a two - qubit hamiltonian in our scheme , rotated by a labeled unitary @xmath76 . notice how in each step to the next hamiltonian , the qubit is swapped over two qubits ( the arrows ) and a gate is applied to this qubit .
thus the gates to be applied are encoded spatially across the the three hamiltonians .
the @xmath77th gate thus depends on the the hamiltonian @xmath78 with the gate being applied changing the interaction between qubits @xmath79 and @xmath80 in this hamiltonian .
generalizing to more than one qubit this proves that universal holonomic quantum computation can be done by interpolation between only three hamiltonians . ]
putting this all together we have shown how to use agt to perform one- and two - qubit gates by teleporting quantum information adiabatically between qubits .
given the ability to prepare fiducial initial single - qubit states and the ability to measure the qubits which contain the state of the final system , we then obtain a model equivalent in power to the standard circuit model of qc . _ relationship to holonomic qc _ in holonomic quantum computing ( hqc ) one uses a cyclic adiabatic evolution of a hamiltonian around a loop in parameter space to produce a quantum gate .
almost all hqc is cast within the context of cyclic evolutions , with the exception of kult _ et al .
_ @xcite who pointed out that noncyclic geometric gates are also possible .
agt is a example of a noncyclic geometric gate : so long as the evolution is adiabatic and we remain within the control manifold defined by the two interactions we are turning on and off , the desired gate is enacted independent of the actual time dependence of the path taken .
our construction is distinguished in two ways .
first , we achieve robustness by turning on and off interactions between two different subsystems ( as opposed to controlling interactions within the same system ) , and we expect that the separation of control needed to make geometric evolution robust will be much easier to achieve in this setting .
second , our explicit connection to gate teleportation leads directly to universal qc and enables methods from fault - tolerance theory .
_ possible architectures _
there are many different schemes for using the above agt primitives to build a universal quantum computer . using minimal resources ,
we can build a circuit on @xmath81 qubits using only @xmath82 qubits ( @xmath83 qubits for the two extra gates and @xmath84 for the ancillas in the perturbation gadgets ) assuming that we can move the qubits involved in the hamiltonians around at will .
more realistic and interesting architectures disallow such movement , but allow the parallel circuit elements required for fault - tolerant qc .
one very compelling architecture builds a circuit on @xmath81 qubits using @xmath85 qubits ( plus @xmath81 ancilla gadget qubits ) in a quasi - one - dimensional architecture .
the idea here is simply that one can perform alternating steps in a quantum circuit by gate teleportation from the first @xmath81 qubits to the third @xmath81 qubits and then back to the first @xmath81 qubits .
another possible architecture builds a quantum circuit of length @xmath86 on @xmath81 qubits onto teleportation across @xmath87 qubits by simply imprinting the quantum circuit being implemented spatially ( in a manner similar to what occurs in one - way quantum computing @xcite . )
thus we can perform universal qc by interpolating between just three different fixed hamiltonians ( see fig .
[ fig ] . ) _ fault tolerance _ a full analysis of fault - tolerance in the piecewise adiabatic scheme is beyond the scope of this letter , but here we argue that our system should show similar behavior to fault - tolerance in the standard quantum circuit model .
the reason for this is simply that agt , while using adiabatic evolution , essentially has the behavior of producing a gate on some ( teleported ) quantum information .
thus we could use the standard techniques for proving a threshold on this model .
that said , however , in practice this model may perform significantly better than the standard circuit model .
the reason is that the system is always performing adiabatic evolution with a constant energy gap ( unlike many other models which yield energy gaps which scale inversely as a polynomial in the number of qubits . )
thus we obtain two of the benefits of adibatic qc , ( 1 ) the system is separated by a constant energy barrier from , and thus at low temperature is robust to , excitation out of the ground state ( a form of leakage error ) and ( 2 ) considerable robustness exists with respect to varying the tunings which change the hamiltonian adiabatically .
_ comparison to other schemes _ using piecewise adiabatic quantum gate teleportations to build a quantum computer shares similarities with many other schemes , but differs in many respects as well .
like universal adiabatic qc , the scheme uses a smooth one way interpolation between an initial and final hamiltonian , but we use multiple such interpolations .
like holonomic qc , we rely on degenerate levels of a hamiltonian , but here our adiabatic evolution is not cyclic . along these lines ,
our scheme is related to a recent method to make holonomic qc fault - tolerant @xcite by using interpolations between encoded pauli operators .
in contrast to our proposal , these are done in a cyclic fashion and with three - qubit interactions .
further we achieve a gate by controlling interactions between separate subsystems , thus insuring that the geometric robustness depends only on the degree to which these independent controls can be manipulated .
finally the scheme is similar in spirit to recent proposals to use spin chains with adiabatic time - dependent interactions to transmit quantum information @xcite , where interpolation between two spin-@xmath88 hamiltonians was used to transmit quantum information down the chain with an energy gap that scaled ( at least numerically ) as @xmath89 where @xmath86 is the length of the chain .
by contrast , our scheme maintains a constant energy gap for the entire computation .
while both schemes require similar transmission times , the former @xcite has a small energy gap , which will be a problem when using this scheme at finite temperature .
furthermore , by explicitly connecting our scheme to gate teleportation , we achieved a universal qc .
_ discussion _ we have shown how to build a universal quantum computer using a series of piecewise adiabatic quantum evolutions related to teleportation .
this opens up a novel architecture for building a quantum computer based entirely on adiabatic quantum evolutions between two - qubit interactions and it considerably simplifies the control requirements for building a quantum computer . after completing this paper
we became aware of concurrent work done independently by oreshkov @xcite showing a similar result using cyclic two - qubit interpolations .
we thank d. gottesman for discussions .
db was supported by nsf grants 0803478 and 0829937 and darpa quest grant fa-9550 - 09 - 1 - 0044 .
stf was supported by the perimeter institute for theoretical physics .
research at perimeter is supported by the government of canada through industry canada and by the province of ontario through the ministry of research & innovation .
17 r. raussendorf and h. j. briegel , phys .
rev .
lett .
* 86 * , 5188 ( 2001 ) .
d. aharonov _ et al .
_ , in _ 45th annual ieee symposium on foundations of computer science _
( 2004 ) , pp .
4251 .
p. zanardi and m. rasetti , phys .
lett .
a * 264 * , 94 ( 1999 ) .
a. m. childs , e. farhi , and j. preskill , phys .
rev .
a * 65 * , 012322 ( 2001 ) . c. h. bennett _ et al .
_ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 70 * , 1895 ( 1993 ) .
e. farhi _ et al .
_ , _ quantum computation by adiabatic evolution _
( 2000 ) , .
d. gottesman and i. l. chuang , nature * 402 * , 390 ( 1999 ) .
g. schaller , phys .
rev .
a * 78 * , 032328 ( 2008 ) .
d. kult , j. berg , and e. sjqvist , phys .
rev .
a * 74 * , 022106 ( 2006 ) .
s. jansen , m. b. ruskai , and r. seiler , j. math .
phys . *
48 * , 102111 ( 2007 ) .
g. schaller , s. mostame , and r. schutzhold , phys .
rev .
a * 73 * , 062307(2006 ) .
m. a. nielsen and i. l. chuang , _ quantum computation and quantum information _
( cambridge university press , cambridge , 2000 ) j. kempe , a. kitaev , and o. regev , siam j. comput . *
35 * , 1070 ( 2006 ) .
r. oliveira and b. terhal , quant .
inf . comp .
* 8 * , 0900 ( 2008 ) .
s. d. bartlett and t. rudolph , phys .
rev .
a * 74 * , 040302(r ) ( 2006 ) .
o. oreshkov , t. a. brun , and d. a. lidar , phys .
rev .
lett . * 102 * , 070502 ( 2009 ) .
k. eckert , o. romero - isart , and a. sanpera , new j. phys .
* 9 * , 155 ( 2007 ) .
o. oreshkov , _ holonomic quantum computation in subsystems _ ( 2009 ) , .
s. d. bartlett and t. rudolph , phys .
rev .
a * 74 * , 040302 ( 2006 ) . |
decays of a bound state of a quark and its anti - quark , quarkonium , provide an excellent laboratory for studying qcd .
particularly , heavy quarkonia such as charmonium states are less relativistic , thus play a special role in probing strong interactions .
cleo recently has accumulated data taken at the @xmath5 resonance , providing a total of 27 m @xmath5 decays . with the combination of this large statistical sample and the excellent cleo detector , we will explore an unprecedented world of charmonia .
while many analyses are currently being carried out , in this note we present recent results on multi - body @xmath0 decays which employed the pre - existing 3 m @xmath5 sample .
we also present recent studies on decays of one of the exotic states , y(4260 ) , as well as precision measurement on @xmath2 that has an implication on properties of x(3872 ) . finally , based on the full sample of @xmath5 data
, we have results on properties of one of the light mesons , @xmath6 .
@xmath7 states , which have one unit of orbital angular momentum and total spin of j=0 , 1 , or 2 , can not be produced directly from @xmath8 collisions .
they can be reached from @xmath5 through radiative ( electric dipole ) transitions .
since @xmath9 , and @xmath10 for j=0 , 1 , and 2 respectively @xcite , 27 m @xmath5 decays of the new data provides @xmath112 m decays of each spin state of @xmath0 which should give us a greater understanding of the decay mechanisms of the @xmath0 mesons . in this section , we present recent results of studies of @xmath0
decays based on 3 m @xmath5 decays which should serve as the foundation for the future precision measurements by employing the full data sample of 27 m of @xmath5 decays .
we present results on @xmath0 decay into combinations of @xmath6 and @xmath12 mesons .
figure [ fig : etaetamass ] shows invariant masses of combinations of @xmath6 and @xmath12 .
no @xmath13 is seen as expected from conservation of spin - parity .
( a ) , @xmath14 ( b ) , and @xmath15 ( c),width=302 ] we measured @xmath16 to be @xmath17 @xcite where the first uncertainty is statistical , the second is systematic , and the third is systematic due to the uncertainty in @xmath18 .
this is slightly higher , but consistent with , the two previously published measurements .
the bes collaboration measured this branching ratio to be @xmath19 @xcite and the e-835 collaboration @xcite had @xmath20 .
we also measured @xmath21 to be @xmath22 for the first time .
we set upper limits for @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 , and @xmath26 at @xmath27 confidence level .
our result can be compared to predictions based on the model of qiang zhao @xcite .
he translates these decay rates into a qcd parameter , @xmath28 , which is the ratio of doubly- to singly - ozi suppressed decay diagrams . in his model , our results indicate that the singly - ozi suppressed diagram dominates in these decays .
we have also looked at three - body decays of @xmath0 states ( one neutral and 2 charged hadrons ) @xcite .
they are @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35 , and @xmath36 . measured branching fractions
are summarized in table [ tab:3btab ] .
again , our results are consistent with the results from bes collaboration @xcite , with better precision . in three of the above modes we looked for , @xmath29 , @xmath33 , and @xmath35 ,
we observed significant signals of @xmath13 decays which are shown in figure [ fig : threebody ] .
[ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : etabr ] further more , we also measured the mass of @xmath6 meson @xcite .
this was motivated by two recent precision measurements that were inconsistent with each other . in 2002 ,
the na48 collaboration reported @xmath37 mev @xcite , while in 2005 , gem collaboration reported @xmath38 mev @xcite which was 8 standard deviations below na48 s result .
we used the same @xmath6 sample described previously in this section but used only 4 decay modes , @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 while , again , constraining masses of @xmath43 and @xmath5 .
our result , the average of the 4 @xmath6 decay modes , is @xmath44 mev which has comparable precision to both na48 and gem results , but is consistent with the former and 6.5 standard deviations larger than the later .
we note that the kloe collaboration also recently measured mass of the @xmath6 meson to be @xmath45 mev which was presented at the 2007 lepton - photon conference @xcite .
i have presented confirmation of babar s observation of y(4260 ) in di - pion transition to @xmath43 along with a new observation through neutral di - pion transition .
our precision measurement on @xmath2 calls for more precise measurement on @xmath46 . with 3 m @xmath5 sample
, we have results on two- , three- , and four - body decays of @xmath0 states in which many sub - structures were seen in three- and four - body modes .
dalitz plot analyses were done for the case of 3-body decays .
more detailed analyses can be done with the full 27 m @xmath5 sample . using the 27 m sample , we performed precision measurements on @xmath4 and @xmath3 .
99 w. m. yao _
[ particle data group ] , j. phys .
g * 33 * , 1 ( 2006 ) .
g. s. adams _ et al .
_ ( cleo collaboration ) , phys . rev .
d * 75 * , 071101(r ) ( 2007 ) .
( bes collaboration ) , phys .
d * 67 * , 032004 ( 2003 ) .
m. andreotti _
( e-835 collaboration ) , phys .
d * 72 * , 112002 ( 2005 ) .
q. zhao , phys .
d * 72 * , 074001 ( 2005 ) .
( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
d * 75 * , 032002 ( 2007 ) .
m. ablikim _
( bes collaboration ) , phys .
d * 74 * , 072001 ( 2006 ) .
b. aubert _
( _ babar _ collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 142001 ( 2005 ) . q.
he _ et al . _
( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
d * 74 * , 091104 ( 2006 ) .
t. e. coan _
( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 162003 ( 2006 ) .
x. liu , x .- q .
zeng , and x .- q .
li , phys .
d * 72 * , 054023 ( 2005 ) .
qiao , he - ph/0510228 ( 2005 ) .
s. k. choi _
et al . _ ( belle collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 91 * , 262001 ( 2003 ) .
d. acosta _ et al .
_ ( cdf ii collaboration ) , phys . rev
. lett . * 93 * , 072001 ( 2004 ) . v.
m. abazov _
( d@xmath47 collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 162002 ( 2004 ) .
b. aubert _
( _ babar _ collaboration ) , phys .
d * 71 * , 071103 ( 2005 ) .
e. s. sanson , phys . lett . *
b588 * , 189 ( 2004 ) ; n. a. trnqvist , phys . lett . * b599 * , 209 ( 2004 ) ; m. b. voloshin , phys . lett . * b579 * , 316 ( 2004 ) . c. cawlfield _ et al . _
( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 092002 ( 2007 ) .
a. pevsner _
et al . _ ,
* 7 * , 421 ( 1961 ) .
( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
. lett . * 99 * , 122001 ( 2007 ) .
m. ablikim _
( bes collaboration ) , phys .
d * 73 * , 052008 ( 2006 ) ; d. alde _ et al .
_ , z. phys .
* c25 * , 225 ( 1984 ) ; yad . fiz . * 40 * , 1447 ( 1984 ) ; r. r. akhmetshin _ et al . _
( cmd-2 collaboration ) , phys .
b509 * , 217 ( 2001 ) ; j. j. thaler _ et al .
d * 7 * , 2569 ( 1973 ) .
d. h. miller _
( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 99 * , 122002 ( 2007 ) .
( na48 collaboration ) , phys .
b533 * , 196 ( 2002 ) .
m. abdel - bary _ et al . _
( gem collaboration ) , phys .
b619 * , 281 ( 2005 ) .
f. ambrosino _
( kloe collaboration ) , arxiv:0707.4616 ( contributed paper to lepton photon 2007 ) . | recent results on charmonium decays are reviewed which includes two- , three- and four - body decays of @xmath0 states , observations of y(4260 ) through @xmath1 transitions , precise measurements of @xmath2 , @xmath3 as well as @xmath4 . |
the geodesics in a kerr metric are considered in the classical books on general relativity [ 13 ] .
some recent papers are devoted to more detailed study of geodesics on kerr s black hole with the aim to elucidate the mechanism of jet formation [ 4 ] , and to analyze the possibility of particle acceleration to arbitrary high energy [ 5 ] .
the complete sets of analytic solutions of the geodesic equation in axially symmetric space - time are given in [ 6 ] .
however , the description of particle motion by geodesics is restricted to a spinless particle . the motion of a spinning test particle is described by the mathisson - papapetrou - dixon equations [ 79 ] : @xmath2 @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the particle s 4-velocity , @xmath5 is the tensor of spin , @xmath6 and @xmath7 are , respectively , the mass and the covariant derivative with respect to the particle s proper time @xmath8 ; @xmath9 is the riemann curvature tensor ( units @xmath10 are used ) .
it is necessary to add a supplementary condition to eqs .
( 1 ) , ( 2 ) in order to choose an appropriate trajectory of the particle s center of mass . most often the conditions @xmath11 and @xmath12 are used , where @xmath13 is the 4-momentum . in practice
, the condition for a spinning test particle @xmath14 must be taken into account [ 10 ] , where @xmath15 is the absolute value of spin , @xmath16 is the coordinate distance of the particle from the massive body .
after [ 79 ] , eqs .
( 1 ) , ( 2 ) were obtained in many papers by different approaches [ 11 ] . also , this subject is of importance in some recent publications [ 12 ] . in general , the solutions of eqs .
( 1 ) , ( 2 ) under conditions ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) are different .
however , in the post - newtonian approximation these solutions coincide with high accuracy [ 13 ] , just as in the case if the spin effects can be described by a convergent in spin series , as some corrections to the corresponding geodesic expressions [ 14 ] .
therefore , instead of rigorous mpd eqs .
( 1 ) their linear spin approximation @xmath17 is often considered . in this approximation condition
( 4 ) coincides with ( 3 ) .
the effect of spin on the particle s motion in kerr s field has been studied since the 1970s [ 10,15,16 ] . in the past 1012 years
this subject gives rise to renewed interest [ 1722 ] , particularly in the context of investigations of the possible chaotic motions [ 17,19 ] .
also , these references provide a good introduction concerning the mpd equations .
the purpose of this paper is to investigate more carefully the world lines and trajectories of a spinning particle moving relative to a kerr source with the velocity close to the velocity of light .
we focus on the circular and close to circular orbits , because just on these orbits one can expect the significant effects of the spin - gravity interaction [ 10,2325 ] .
indeed , these orbits are of interest in the context of investigations of the nongeodesic synchrotron electromagnetic radiation of highly relativistic protons and electrons near black holes . besides , it is known that the highly relativistic circular orbits of a spinless particle are of importance in the classification of all possible geodesic orbits in a kerr spacetime .
naturally , the circular highly relativistic orbits of a spinning particle are of importance in the classification of all possible significantly nongeodesic orbits in this spacetime as well .
also , these orbits are exclusive in the sense that they are described by the strict analytical solutions of the mpd equations . the main features of the spin - gravity interaction that are revealed on the circular and close to circular orbits will be a good reference to further investigations of most general motions of a spinning particle in a kerr spacetime . we stress that mpd equations are the classical limit of the general relativistic dirac equation [ 26 ] , new results in this context are presented in [ 27 ] . therefore , highly relativistic solutions of the mpd equations stimulate the corresponding investigations of the fermion s interaction with the strong gravitational field .
the paper is organized as follows .
sec . 2 deals with the relationships following from the mpd equations for the highly relativistic equatorial circular orbits of a spinning particle in kerr s field , in the boyer - lindquist coordinates .
the linear spin mpd equations for any motions of a spinning particle are considered in sec .
the results of computer integration of these equations for some significantly nongeodesic motions are presented in sec .
4 . we conclude in sec .
5 . following [ 3 ]
, in this paper @xmath0 notes the radial coordinate of the photon circular orbits in the case of the counter - rotation .
in practical calculations it is convenient to represent the mpd equations through the spin 3-vector @xmath18 , instead of the 4-tensor @xmath5 , where by definition @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the determinant of @xmath21 , @xmath22 is the levi - civita symbol ( here and in the following , latin indices run 1 , 2 , 3 , and greek indices 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , unless otherwise specified ) .
( 2 ) can be written as [ 23 ] @xmath23 } - u^\pi u_\rho \gamma^\rho_{\pi[4 } u_{i]})s_k u^k\ ] ] @xmath24 } u^\pi = 0,\ ] ] where a dot denotes differentiation with respect to the proper time @xmath8 , and square brackets denote antisymmetrization of indices ; @xmath25 are the christoffel symbols .
( 7 ) in terms of @xmath18 is @xmath26 @xmath27 in many papers the 4-vector of spin @xmath28 is considered , where @xmath29 the following relationship holds : @xmath30 let us consider eqs .
( 9 ) , ( 10 ) for the kerr metric using the boyer - lindquist coordinates @xmath31 then the nonzero components of @xmath21 are @xmath32 @xmath33 @xmath34 where @xmath35 [ in the following we shall put @xmath36 , without any loss in generality ; the metric signature is + . ]
it is easy to check that three equations from ( 9 ) have a partial solution with @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 and the relationship for the nonzero component of the spin 3-vector @xmath40 is @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the constant of integration .
the physical meaning of this constant is the same as in the general integral of the mpd equations [ 15 ] @xmath43 we stress that relationship ( 12 ) is valid for any equatorial motions ( @xmath37 ) , with the spin orthogonal to the motion plane ( @xmath44 ) .
the possible equatorial orbits of a spinning particle are described by eq .
first , we shall consider the case of the circular orbits with @xmath45 investigating the conditions of existence of the equatorial circular orbits for a spinning particle in kerr s field we use eqs .
( 10 ) , ( 12 ) , and @xmath46 .
it is known that from the geodesic equations in this field , the algebraic relationship that follows determines the dependence of the velocity of a spinless particle on the radial coordinate @xmath16 of the equatorial circular orbit .
similarly , from the first equation of set ( 10 ) using eq . ( 14 ) we obtain the relationship for the equatorial circular orbits of a spinning particle in kerr s field as follows : @xmath47 @xmath48=0.\ ] ] [ by eq .
( 14 ) other equations of set ( 10 ) are automatically satisfied . ]
taking into account eq .
( 12 ) and the explicit expressions for @xmath49 and @xmath9 ( see , e.g. , [ 18 ] ) from eq .
( 15 ) we obtain @xmath50 @xmath51=0.\ ] ] the 4-velocity component @xmath52 can be expressed through @xmath53 from the condition @xmath46 as follows : @xmath54 ( just the sign `` + '' at the radical in eq .
( 17 ) ensures the positive value of @xmath52 ) . inserting expression ( 17 ) into eq .
( 16 ) and eliminating the radical by raising to the second power we get @xmath55 + 12\varepsilon mar^4\delta-9\varepsilon^2m^2r^4\delta)\ ] ] @xmath56 @xmath57 where , as in eq .
( 6 ) , @xmath58 . without any loss in generality we put @xmath59 , then by eq .
( 12 ) @xmath60 .
so , the particle s angular velocity @xmath61 on the circular orbit with the radial coordinate @xmath16 must satisfy eq . (
let us show that eq .
( 18 ) provides known solutions . in the partial case of a spinless particle ( @xmath62 ) from eq . ( 18 ) we have @xmath63}.\ ] ] it follows from eq .
( 19 ) that the velocity of such a particle on the circular orbit is highly relativistic if the expression @xmath64 is close to @xmath65 .
this fact is known from the analysis of the geodesic orbits in a kerr field , as well as that just the roots of the equation @xmath66 determine the values of @xmath16 for the photon orbits . if @xmath67 and the absolute value of the expression @xmath68 $ ] in the factor of @xmath69 in eq . ( 18 ) is much greater than @xmath70 , then it is easy to verify that the corresponding roots of eq .
( 18 ) describe the circular orbits with the angular velocity which is close to the angular velocity of the corresponding geodesic orbits due to @xmath71 .
more exactly , in this case we have @xmath72 that is not described in the literature .
namely , it is not difficult to calculate that for @xmath67 eqs .
( 16 ) , ( 18 ) have the solutions which describe the highly relativistic circular orbits with the values of @xmath16 that is equal or close to @xmath0 , i.e. , to the radial coordinate of the counter - rotation photon circular orbits . for example , in the case of the maximum kerr field ( @xmath73 ) the orbits with @xmath74 , where @xmath75 , are highly relativistic , both for positive and negative @xmath76 . if @xmath77 , according to eqs . ( 16 ) , ( 18 ) the values of @xmath53 on these orbits are determined by the expression @xmath78 [ the choice of the sign in eq .
( 21 ) , @xmath79 , is dictated by the necessity to satisfy both eq . ( 18 ) and ( 16 ) ; eq .
( 18 ) , as compared to ( 16 ) , has additional roots because of the operation of raising to the second power . ]
similarly as in the case of eq .
( 20 ) , it is easy to check that if @xmath80 it follows from eqs .
( 16 ) , ( 18 ) the expression for @xmath53 which in the main term coincides with the known analytic solution for the corresponding geodesic circular orbit .
it follows from eqs .
( 16 ) , ( 18 ) at @xmath1 for any @xmath81 that @xmath82 it is known from the geodesic equations that the values of @xmath0 increase monotonically from @xmath83 at @xmath84 to @xmath85 at @xmath73 .
thus , according to eq .
( 22 ) the expression for the angular velocity @xmath61 in the main term is proportional to @xmath86 , whereas the angular velocity in eq .
( 20 ) at @xmath87 , @xmath88 is proportional to @xmath89 .
further details appear below in this sec . using eq .
( 22 ) we can estimate the value of the lorentz @xmath90-factor , corresponding to the 4-velocity component @xmath53 , for different @xmath91 .
more exactly , we shall calculate the lorentz @xmath90-factor from the point of view of an observer which is at rest relative to a kerr mass . according to the general expression for the 3-velocity components
@xmath92 we write [ 1 ] @xmath93 and for the second power of the velocity absolute value @xmath94 we have @xmath95 where @xmath96 is the 3-space metric tensor . the relationship between @xmath96 and @xmath21
is as follows : @xmath97 for the circular motions we have @xmath98 , and according to eq .
( 23 ) @xmath99 by eqs .
( 24)-(26 ) and the condition @xmath46 , for the @xmath90-factor we write @xmath100 inserting the value @xmath53 from eq .
( 22 ) into eq .
( 27 ) we find in the corresponding spin approximation @xmath101 it follows from eq .
( 28 ) that @xmath102 , i.e. , the under consideration circular motions are highly relativistic . fig .
1 shows the dependence @xmath103 on @xmath104 , where @xmath105 is the @xmath90-factor for @xmath106 , that is , at @xmath84 .
ratio @xmath90-factor at different @xmath91 , from @xmath107 , to @xmath90-factor at @xmath84 vs. radial coordinate.,width=264 ] it is known that the important characteristic of the particle s motion in the kerr spacetime are its energy and angular momentum .
let us estimate the conserved values of the energy @xmath108 and angular momentum @xmath109 of a spinning particle on the above considered highly relativistic circular orbits with eqs .
( 21 ) , ( 22 ) .
the expressions for these quantities are [ 16,28 ] @xmath110 @xmath111 by eqs .
( 21 ) , ( 29 ) for @xmath74 , @xmath77 we obtain @xmath112 the energy of a spinless particle on the geodesic circular orbit with @xmath74 , @xmath113 for @xmath73 is equal to @xmath114 it follows from eqs . ( 31 ) , ( 32 ) that @xmath115 at the same time according to ( 31 ) , ( 32 ) for @xmath116 we have @xmath117 that is , the values of energy of the spinning and spinless particles on the highly relativistic circular orbits with the same @xmath74 in the maximal kerr field can differ significantly .
it is easy to show that similar situation takes place for all values @xmath81 with @xmath87 .
in addition , one can estimate for these circular orbits that according to eq .
( 30 ) @xmath118 . as a result , the relationships @xmath119 and @xmath118 following from eqs .
( 29 ) , ( 30 ) show clearly that the corresponding solutions of the mpd equations can not be obtained in the framework of the analytic perturbation approach to the dynamics of a classical spinning particle developed in [ 2022 ] .
we stress that in this sec .
above we have considered the new highly relativistic circular solutions of the approximate mpd eqs .
( 2 ) , ( 7 ) .
let us show that these solutions satisfy the rigorous mpd eqs .
( 1 ) , ( 2 ) . indeed
, it follows from eqs .
( 1 ) that their terms , which were neglected in eqs . ( 7 ) , in the case of the circular equatorial motions are presented in the first eq . of set ( 1 ) only . in metric
( 11 ) these terms can be written as @xmath120 where @xmath121 @xmath122 @xmath123,\ ] ] @xmath124 @xmath125 first , we point out that according to eq .
( 36 ) in the case of a schwarzschild s field for the circular orbit with @xmath126 the all coefficients @xmath127 are equal to 0 .
therefore , in this case expression ( 35 ) is equal to 0 identically , independently on the explicit expressions for @xmath53 , @xmath52 .
it means that the highly relativistic circular orbit of a spinning particle with @xmath126 in a schwarzschild s field is a common strict solution both of the approximate mpd equations ( 2 ) , ( 7 ) and the rigorous mpd equations ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) .
second , it is not difficult to check that applying eqs .
( 17 ) , ( 22 ) to expression ( 35 ) at @xmath128 yields @xmath65 in the main terms , i.e. , within the accuracy of order @xmath129 .
thus , in this sec .
we dealt with new partial solutions of the mpd equations in a kerr spacetime with eqs .
( 12 ) , ( 14 ) , ( 22 ) .
all highly relativistic orbits of a spinning particle described by these solutions are circular and located in the space region with @xmath87 , @xmath75 .
to study highly relativistic orbits beyond this region it is necessary to carry out the corresponding computer calculations .
it is an aim of secs . 3 and 4 .
now the point of interesting is the noncircular highly relativistic motions of a spinning particle that starts near @xmath0 in a kerr field . in particular
, we shall consider the effect of the 3-vector @xmath18 inclination to the equatorial plane @xmath37 on the particle s trajectory . in this case
( 9 ) can not be integrated separately from eqs .
( 7 ) . for computer integration
, it is necessary to write the explicit form of eqs .
( 7 ) , ( 9 ) in metric ( 11 ) .
it is convenient to use the dimensionless quantities @xmath130 , where by definition @xmath131 @xmath132 @xmath133 and @xmath134 ( in contrast to @xmath129 from ( 6 ) , that depends on @xmath16 , here @xmath135 is defined to be @xmath136 ) .
then it follows from eqs .
( 7 ) , ( 9 ) the set of 11 first - order differential equations @xmath137 @xmath138 @xmath139 where a dot denotes differentiation with respect to @xmath140 , and @xmath141 ( @xmath142 ) are some functions which depend on @xmath143 . because the expressions for @xmath144 in general case of any @xmath91 are too lengthy , here we write @xmath144 for the much simpler case @xmath84 : @xmath145 @xmath146 @xmath147 @xmath148 @xmath149 @xmath150 @xmath151 @xmath152 @xmath153 @xmath154+\frac{y_9}{y_8}a_4,\ ] ] @xmath155 @xmath156 @xmath157 @xmath158,\ ] ] @xmath159 @xmath160 @xmath161 @xmath162 @xmath163+\frac{y_{11}}{y_8}a_4,\ ] ] where @xmath164 according to eqs .
( 13 ) , ( 38 ) the expression for @xmath165 can be written as @xmath166 @xmath167 @xmath168 eqs .
( 39)(41 ) are aimed at computer integration .
we present here the results of computer integration of eqs . ( 39 ) with ( 40 ) , ( 41 ) . all plots below
are restricted to the domains of validity of the linear spin approximation .
that is , in these domains the neglected terms of the rigorous mpd equations are much less than the linear spin terms .
we monitor errors of computing using the conserved quantities : the absolute value of spin , the energy and angular momentum ( see eqs .
( 13 ) , ( 29 ) , ( 30 ) ) .
29 correspond to the case of schwarzschild s field .
all plots start with the same initial values of the coordinates @xmath169 , namely , at @xmath170 and @xmath65 correspondingly .
we do not vary the initial values of the 4-velocity components @xmath171 and @xmath53 as well .
more exactly , we put @xmath172 and @xmath173 where expression ( 42 ) is the solution of eq . ( 18 ) at @xmath84 , rigorous in @xmath135 .
that is , the initial values of @xmath171 and @xmath53 are the same as for the equatorial circular orbit with @xmath126 ( it is easy to check that expression ( 42 ) coincides with ( 22 ) in the corresponding spin approximation ) .
however , we vary the initial inclination angle of the spin 3-vector to the plane @xmath174 , without change of the absolute value of spin ( figs .
26 ) , and add the small perturbation by the radial velocity ( figs .
79 ) . without any loss in generality we put @xmath175 . for comparison
, we present the corresponding solutions of the geodesic equations that start with the same initial values of the coordinates and velocity as the solutions of the equations for a spinning particle . in all cases as a typical value we put @xmath176 . figs .
29 let us compare the world lines and trajectories of the spinning and spinless particles in schwarzschild s field .
2 , 6 , 7 , 9 exhibit the significant repulsive effects of the spin - gravity interaction on the spinning particle . due to the repulsive action the spinning particle falls on the horizon surface during longer time as compared to the spinless particle ( fig .
2 ) . moreover , according to figs . 6 , 9
the considerable space separation takes place within a short time , i.e. , within the time of the spinless particle s fall on the horizon .
the point of interest is the phenomenon when a spinning particle orbits below the equatorial plane for some revolutions , figs . 3 , 8 ( we recall that according to the geodesic equations similar situation is impossible for a spinless particle ) .
it is easy to calculate that for @xmath177 a spinning particle can orbit above the equatorial plane .
we stress that all graphs in figs .
29 are interrupted beyond the domain of validity of the linear spin approximation . by figs .
3 , 4 , within the time of this approximation validity , the period of the @xmath178-oscillation coincides with the period of the particle s revolution by @xmath179 .
whereas on this interval the value of the spin component @xmath180 is @xmath136 ( fig .
5 ) , just as the components @xmath181 and @xmath182 ( the corresponding graphs are not presented here ) .
we point out that this situation differs from the corresponding case of the circular motions of a spinning particle that are not highly relativistic .
indeed , then the nonzero radial spin component is not @xmath136 but oscillates with the period of the particle s revolution by @xmath179 .
besides , in the last case the mean level of @xmath178 coincides with @xmath183 , whereas in figs . 3 , 8 the mean values of @xmath178 are above @xmath183 .
according to figs . 3 , 8 the amplitude of the @xmath178-oscillation increases with the inclination angle .
however , @xmath184 is small even for the inclination angle that is equal to @xmath183 . in the context of figs . 3 , 8 we point out an interesting analytical result following from eqs .
( 39)(41 ) .
namely , it is not difficult to check that these equations are satisfied if @xmath185 @xmath186 @xmath187 @xmath188 @xmath189 where @xmath190 and @xmath191 are some small constant values such that @xmath192 , @xmath193 . according to eq .
( 41 ) the relationship between @xmath190 , @xmath191 and @xmath129 from eq .
( 6 ) is as follows : @xmath194 by notation ( 37 ) we conclude that the partial solution of eqs .
( 39)(40 ) , that is presented in eq .
( 43 ) , describes the highly relativistic nonequatorial circular motion with @xmath195 .
that is , eq .
( 43 ) shows the possibility of the spinning particle solution that orbit permanently above or below the equatorial plane , however , with the small value @xmath196 only .
one can verify that due to the small values @xmath190
, @xmath191 solution ( 43 ) is an approximate solution of the rigorous mpd equations . just as in the case of schwarzschild s field ,
the set of eqs .
( 39 ) with the corresponding expressions for @xmath144 can be integrated numerically in kerr s field .
10 , as an analogy of fig .
2 , shows the plots of @xmath197 for some values of the inclination angle at @xmath73 .
11 shows the dependence of the amplitude and period of the @xmath178-oscillation on the kerr parameter @xmath91 .
the main features of figs .
49 are peculiar to the corresponding plots for kerr s field , that are not presented here for brevity . according to figs . 2 , 6 , 10 when the inclination angle is equal to @xmath183 , i.e. , when spin lies in the equatorial plane , so that spin - gravity coupling is equal to @xmath65 , the corresponding plots coincide with the geodesics .
it is an evidence of the correct transition from solutions of the mpd equations to geodesics . fig .
12 illustrates some typical cases of the equatorial motions of a particle with fixed initial values of its coordinates and velocity but with different absolute value of spin ( the inclination angle is equal to @xmath198 ) in kerr s field at @xmath73 .
all curves start from @xmath199 with zero radial velocity and the tangential velocity which at @xmath176 is needed for the circular motion with @xmath199 .
this circular motion is shown by the horizontal line , whereas other curves represent the noncircular motions at @xmath200 with the same particle s initial values of coordinates and velocity . according to fig .
12 the circular orbit of a spinning particle with @xmath199 monotonically trend to the corresponding noncircular geodesic orbit if @xmath135 trend to 0 , i.e. , the limiting transition @xmath201 is correct .
radial coordinate vs. proper time for the inclination angle @xmath198 ( horizontal line @xmath126 ) , @xmath202 ( dash and dot line ) , @xmath203 ( dash line ) , and @xmath183 ( solid line ) at @xmath84 , @xmath176 .
the dot line corresponds to the geodesic motion with the same initial values of the coordinates and velocity.,width=264 ] graphs of the angle @xmath178 vs. proper time for the inclination angle @xmath198 ( horizontal line @xmath204 , @xmath202 ( solid line ) , @xmath203 ( dash line ) , and @xmath183 ( dash and dot line ) at @xmath84 , @xmath176.,width=249 ] graphs of the angle @xmath179 vs. proper time at @xmath84 , @xmath176 for different values of the inclination angle practically coincide with the corresponding geodesic plot .
the same feature takes place for the corresponding graphs t vs. s that are not presented here for brevity.,width=283 ] graphs of @xmath180 vs. proper time for the inclination angle @xmath202 ( dash line ) , @xmath203 ( dash and dot line ) , and @xmath183 ( solid line ) at @xmath84 , @xmath176.,width=283 ] trajectories of the spinning particle in the polar coordinates for the inclination angle @xmath198 ( circle @xmath126 ) , @xmath202 ( dash line ) , @xmath203 ( dash and dot line ) , and @xmath183 ( solid line ) at @xmath84 , @xmath176 .
the dot line corresponds to the geodesic motion with the same initial values of the coordinates and velocity .
the circle @xmath205 corresponds to the horizon line.,width=226 ] radial coordinate vs. proper time for the inclination angle @xmath198 ( dash and dot line ) , @xmath202 ( dash line ) , and @xmath203 ( solid line ) at @xmath84 , @xmath176 , and the nonzero radial velocity @xmath206 .
the dot line corresponds to the geodesic motion with the same initial values of the coordinates and velocity.,width=264 ] graphs of the angle @xmath178 vs. proper time for the inclination angle @xmath198 ( horizontal line ) , @xmath202 ( dash line ) and @xmath203 ( solid line ) , at @xmath84 , @xmath176 , and @xmath206.,width=264 ] trajectories of the spinning particle in the polar coordinates for the inclination angle @xmath198 ( dash and dot line ) , @xmath202 ( dash line ) , and @xmath203 ( solid line ) at @xmath84 , @xmath176 , and @xmath207 .
the dot line corresponds to the geodesic motion with the same initial values of the coordinates and velocity.,width=226 ] radial coordinate vs. proper time for the inclination angle @xmath198 ( horizontal line @xmath199 ) , @xmath202 ( dash and dot line ) , @xmath203 ( dash line ) , and @xmath183 ( solid line ) at @xmath73 , @xmath176 .
the dot line corresponds to the geodesic motion with the same initial values of the coordinates and velocity .
, width=264 ] graphs of the angle @xmath178 vs. proper time for the inclination angle @xmath202 at @xmath84 ( dash line ) , @xmath208 ( dash and dot line ) , @xmath73 ( solid line ) ; @xmath176.,width=264 ] radial coordinate vs. proper time for the equatorial motions in kerr s field at @xmath73 with different absolute value of spin and the same ( common ) initial values of the coordinates and velocity . the circular orbit with @xmath199 at @xmath176
is shown by the long dash line .
the solid , dash and dot , and dash lines describe the cases when @xmath135 is equal to @xmath209 , @xmath210 , and @xmath211 correspondingly .
the dot line represents the geodesic motion with the same initial values of the coordinates and velocity.,width=226 ] finally , we remark on a simple conclusion following from the nongeodesic curves of a spinning particle presented , in part , in figs .
212 . let us consider any point on the trajectory of a spinning particle corresponding to its proper time @xmath212 ( we recall that all curves in figs .
212 begin at @xmath213 ) .
then the geodesic curve can be calculated which starts just at this point with the velocity that is equal to the velocity of the spinning particle at the same point . also , it is not difficult to estimate the deviation of the pointed out nongeodesic curve from this geodesic . in principle , it means that in our comparison of the corresponding geodesic and nongeodesic curves we are not restricted to the trajectories of a spinning particle which start in the small neighborhood of the value @xmath1 only ( naturally , here we are restricted to the domain of validity of the linear spin approximation )
. this conclusion may be useful for the generalization of the results obtained in this sec .
on other motions of a spinning particle .
in this paper , using the linear spin approximation of the mpd equations , we have studied the significantly nongeodesic highly relativistic motions of a spinning particles starting near @xmath1 in kerr s field .
some of these motions , namely circular , are described by the analytical relationships following directly from mpd equations in the boyer - lindquist coordinates .
others , noncircular and nonequatorial , are calculated numerically . for realization of these motions
the spinning particle must possess the obital velocity corresponding to the relativistic lorentz @xmath90-factor of order @xmath86 .
all considered cases of the spinning particle motion are within the framework of validity of the test - particle approximation when @xmath214 .
the situation with a macroscopic test particle moving relative to a massive body with @xmath215 is not realistic .
however , the highly relativistic values of the lorentz @xmath90-factor are usual in astrophysics for the elementary particles . for example , if @xmath216 is equal to three of the sun s mass ( as for a black hole ) , then @xmath135 for an electron is of order @xmath217 and from eq . ( 28 ) we have the @xmath90-factor of order @xmath218 .
similarly , for a neutrino with the mass @xmath219 we have @xmath220 . we can expect the effects of the significant space separation of some highly relativistic particles with different orientation of spin .
indeed , the effects considered in this paper exhibit the strong repulsive action of the spin - gravity interaction . for another correlation of signs of the spin and the particle s orbital velocity
this interactions acts as an attractive force . in general ,
the last case is beyond the validity of the linear spin approximation .
the nonlinear spin effects will be investigated in another paper . also , we plan to show that according to the mpd equations significantly nongeodesic orbits of a highly relativistic spinning particle , with the @xmath90-factor of order @xmath86 , exist for the much wider space region of the initial values of the particle s coordinates in a kerr spacetime than the orbits considered above . however , the corresponding calculations are very complicated because this result follows from the rigorous mpd equations ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) only , and is not common for the approximate equations ( 2 ) , ( 7 ) .
l. d. landau and e. m. lifshitz , _ the classical theory of fields _ ( addison - wesley , reading , massachusetts , 1971 ) . c. w. misner , k. s. thorne , and j. a. wheeler , _ gravitation _ ( freeman , san francisko , 1973 ) .
s. chandrasekhar , _ the mathematical theory of black holes _ ( oxford university press , oxford , 1983 ) .
j. gariel , m. a. h. maccallum , g. marcilhacy , and n. o. santos , astron . and astrophys .
* 515 * , a15 ( 2010 ) .
m. banados , j. silk , and s. m. west , phys .
103 * , 111102 ( 2009 ) ; e. berti , v. cardoso , l. gualtieri , f. pretorios , and u. sperhake , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 239001 ( 2009 ) ; t. jacobson and t. sotiriou , phys .
* 104 * , 021101 ( 2010 ) .
e. hackmann , v. kagramanova , j. kunz , and c. lmmerzahl , europhys .
lett . * 88 * , 30008 ( 2009 ) .
m. mathisson , acta phys . polon .
* 6 * , 163 ( 1937 ) .
a. papapetrou , proc .
a * 209 * , 248 ( 1951 ) .
w. g. dixon , proc .
a * 314 * , 499 ( 1970 ) ; gen .
gravitation * 4 * , 199 ( 1973 ) ; philos .
a * 277 * , 59 ( 1974 ) ; acta phys .
. suppl . * 1 * , 27 ( 2008 ) .
r. wald , phys .
d * 6 * , 406 ( 1972 ) .
w. tulczyjew , acta phys . pol .
* 18 * , 393 ( 1959 ) ; a. taub , j. math . phys . * 5 * , 112 ( 1964 ) ; p. bartrum , proc .
r. soc . a * 284 * , 204 ( 1965 ) ; h. p. knzl , j. math
* 13 * , 739 ( 1972 ) ; m. omote , progr . theor
49 * 1559 ( 1973 ) ; s. hojman , phys .
d * 18 * , 2741 ( 1978 ) ; a. balachandran , g. marmo , b. skagerstam , and a. stern , phys .
b * 89 * 199 ( 1980 ) .
j. natario , commun .
* 281 * , 387 ( 2008 ) ; e. barausse , e. racine , and a. buonanno , phys .
d * 80 * , 104025 ( 2009 ) ; j. steinhoff and g. schfer , europhys
. lett . * 87 * , 50004 ( 2009 ) . b. m. barker and r. f. oconnell , gen .
* 4 * , 193 ( 1973 ) .
a. n. aleksandrov , kinem .
* 7 * , 13 ( 1991 ) .
b. mashhoon , j. math .
* 12 * , 1075 ( 1971 ) .
k. p. tod , f. de felice , and m. calvani , nuovo cim .
b * 34 * , 365 ( 1976 ) .
s. suzuki and k. maeda , phys .
d * 58 * , 023005 ( 1998 ) .
o. semerak , mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . * 308 * , 863 ( 1999 ) .
m. hartl , phys .
d * 67 * , 024005 ( 2003 ) ; phys .
d * 67 * , 104023 ( 2003 ) .
c. chicone , b. mashhoon , and b. punsly , phys .
a * 343 * , 1 ( 2005 ) .
b. mashhoon and d. singh , phys .
d * 74 * , 124006 ( 2006 ) .
d. singh , phys .
d * 78 * , 104028 ( 2008 ) .
r. plyatsko , phys .
d. * 58 * , 084031 ( 1998 ) .
r. plyatsko and o. bilaniuk , class .
quantum grav . * 18 * , 5187 ( 2001 ) .
r. plyatsko , class .
quantum grav .
* 22 * , 1545 ( 2005 ) .
s. wong , int .
. phys . * 5 * , 221 ( 1972 ) ; l. kannenberg , ann .
( n.y . ) * 103 * , 64 ( 1977 ) ; r. catenacci and m. martellini , lett .
nuovo cimento * 20 * , 282 ( 1977 ) ; j. audretsch , j. phys .
a * 14 * , 411 ( 1981 ) ; a. gorbatsievich , acta phys .
b * 17 * , 111 ( 1986 ) ; a. barut and m. pavsic , class .
quantum grav .
* 4 * , 41 ( 1987 ) .
f. cianfrani and g. montani , europhys . lett . * 84 * , 30008 ( 2008 ) ; int . j. mod .
a * 23 * , 1274 ( 2008 ) ; yu .
obukhov , a. silenko , and o. teryaev , phys .
d * 80 * , 064044 ( 2009 ) .
r. micoulaut , z. phys .
* 206 * , 394 ( 1967 ) . | using the mathisson - papapetrou - dixon ( mpd ) equations , we investigate the trajectories of a spinning particle starting near @xmath0 in a kerr field and moving with the velocity close to the velocity of light ( @xmath0 is the boyer - lindquist radial coordinate of the counter - rotation circular photon orbits ) .
first , as a partial case of these trajectories , we consider the equatorial circular orbit with @xmath1 .
this orbit is described by the solution that is common for the rigorous mpd equations and their linear spin approximation .
then different cases of the nonequatorial motions are computed and illustrated by the typical figures .
all these orbits exhibit the effects of the significant gravitational repulsion that are caused by the spin - gravity interaction .
possible applications in astrophysics are discussed . |
the state of the intergalactic medium ( igm ) at redshift @xmath17 remains under considerable debate .
significant transmitted flux in the ly@xmath3 forest at @xmath18 means that the igm must have been highly ionized by at least @xmath19 gyr after the big bang @xcite .
each of the four known qsos at @xmath20 show gunn - peterson troughs @xcite over at least a narrow redshift interval @xcite . this complete lack of transmitted flux has been interpreted as an indication that the tail end of cosmic reionization may extend to @xmath21 .
however , @xcite found the evolution of transmitted flux over @xmath22 to be consistent with a smoothly decreasing ionization rate and not indicative of a sudden jump in the ly@xmath3 optical depth at @xmath23 .
significant variations in the fraction of transmitted flux are common among sightlines at the same redshift @xcite . while the spectrum of sdss j1030 + 0524 ( @xmath6 ) shows complete absorption in ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 over a redshift interval @xmath24 @xcite , transmitted flux appears over the same redshifts in the ly@xmath3 , ly@xmath5 , and ly@xmath25 forests of sdss j1148 + 5251 ( @xmath4 ) @xcite .
either the igm is highly ionized everywhere at @xmath26 and long stretches of complete absorption are the result of line blending , or the neutral fraction of the igm is patchy on large scales .
a patchy igm could result from the clumpiness of the igm and the clustering of ionizing sources @xcite .
studies of h i transmitted flux are ultimately hampered by the large optical depths expected for even a small neutral fraction .
the presence of a gunn - peterson trough can at best constrain the volume- and mass - weighted h i neutral fractions to @xmath27 and @xmath28 , respectively @xcite .
alternative measurements are required to probe larger neutral fractions .
the non - evolution in the luminosity function of ly@xmath3-emitting galaxies provides an independent indication that the igm at @xmath29 is highly ionized ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , although ly@xmath3photons may escape as a result of galactic winds @xcite or from locally ionized bubbles created by clustered sources @xcite . in the future , observations of redshifted 21 cm emission / absorption should trace the growth and evolution of ionized regions at @xmath30 , placing strong constraints on reionization scenarios ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
a high neutral fraction must also have a measurable effect on metal absorption lines @xcite .
overdense regions of the igm should be the first to become enriched , due to the presence of star - forming sources , yet the last to remain ionized , due to the short recombination times @xcite .
low - ionization metal species should therefore produce numerous absorption features in the spectra of background objects prior to reionization .
a particularly good candidate is o i , which has an ionization potential nearly identical to that of h i and a transition at 1302 that can be observed redward of the ly@xmath3 forest .
oxygen and hydrogen will lock in charge - exchange equilibrium @xcite , which ensures that their neutral fractions will remain nearly equal , @xmath31 despite the increased photo - ionization cross section of o i at higher energies , this relationship is expected to hold over a wide range in @xmath32 ( oh et al .
2005 , in prep ) . in this work ,
we present a search for o i in the spectra of nine @xmath33 qsos .
this is the first time a set of @xmath34 spectra has been taken at high resolution ( r = 45,000 ) .
our sample includes three objects at @xmath13 , where we might expect to see an `` o i forest '' @xcite . in
2 we describe the observations and data reduction .
the results of the o i search are detailed in 3 . in
4 we demonstrate a significant overabundance of o i systems towards the highest - redshift object , sdss j1148 + 5251 ( @xmath4 ) , and compare the overabundance to the number density of lower - redshift o i systems and other absorbers with high h i column densities . measurements of the relative metal abundances for all the detected systems are described in 5 . in 6
we discuss the significance of these excess systems for the enrichment and ionization state of the igm at @xmath23 .
our results are summarized in 7 . throughout this paper
we assume @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 , and @xmath38 km s@xmath39 mpc@xmath39 .
observations using the keck hires spectrograph @xcite were made between 2003 february and 2005 june , with the bulk of the data acquired during 2005 january and february .
our qso sample and the observations are summarized in table 1 . all except the 2003 february data were taken with the upgraded hires detector .
we used an 086 slit , which gives a velocity resolution fwhm of @xmath40 km s@xmath39 .
the continuum luminosities in our sample approach the practical detection limit of hires .
in addition , the spectral regions of interest for this work lie in the far red , where skyline contamination and atmospheric absorption are major concerns . to address these difficulties ,
the data were reduced using a custom set of idl routines written by one of us ( gdb ) .
this package uses optimal sky subtraction @xcite to achieve poisson - limited residuals in the two - dimensional sky - subtracted frame .
one - dimensional spectra were extracted using optimal extraction @xcite .
blueward of the ly@xmath3 emission line , the continuum for these objects is highly obscured due to strong absorption from the ly@xmath3 forest .
furthermore , single exposures were typically too faint to fit reliable continua even in unabsorbed regions .
individual orders were therefore combined by first flux calibrating each order using the response function derived from a standard star .
the combined spectra were continuum - fit by hand using a cubic spline .
standards stars were also to correct for telluric absorption . estimated residuals from continuum fitting ( redward of ly@xmath3 ) and atmospheric correction are typically within the flux uncertainties .
at @xmath41 it becomes increasingly difficult to identify individual ly@xmath3 lines due to the large opacity in the ly@xmath3 forest .
therefore , candidate o i lines must be confirmed using other ions at the same redshift .
si ii @xmath42 and c ii @xmath43 are the most useful for this purpose since their rest wavelengths place them redward of the ly@xmath3 forest , at least over a limited range in redshift .
these transitions are also expected to be relatively strong over a range in ionization conditions . at lower redshifts where
si ii @xmath42 has entered the forest , we are still sensitive to si ii @xmath44 , although it is weaker than si ii @xmath42 by a factor of 7 .
we searched for o i in each sightline over the redshift range between the quasar redshift @xmath45 and the redshift @xmath46 , where o i enters the ly@xmath3 forest . to identify a system , we required absorption at the same redshift in o i and either si ii @xmath42 or c ii @xmath47 , and that the line profiles for at least two of the ions be comparable . in practice ,
si ii @xmath42 proved to be the best indicator over the lower - redshift end of each sightline , since the signal - to - noise ( @xmath48 ) ratio was typically better over that region of the spectrum . at redshifts where si ii @xmath42 was lost in the forest we relied solely upon c ii for confirmation . by chance , the two o i systems we identified using only c ii were also strong enough to be detected in si ii @xmath44 .
we identified six o i systems in total along our nine lines of sight .
their properties are summarized in table 2 .
four of the six systems appear towards sdss j1148 + 5251 , and we examine this potential overabundance in detail in 4 .
voigt profiles were fitted using the vpfit package written , by r. carswell .
due to line blending and the modest @xmath48 ratio over some regions of the data , it was often necessary to tie the redshift and/or doppler parameter of one ion to those of another whose profile was more clearly defined in order to obtain a satisfactory fit . in practice ,
the resulting total column densities are very similar to those obtained when all parameters are allowed to vary freely , as would be expected for systems still on the linear part of the curve of growth .
comments on individual systems are given below .
this system shows a central complex in o i , si ii , and c ii that is best fit using three components with a total velocity span of @xmath51 km s@xmath39 .
we measure the redshifts and @xmath52-parameters of the bluest two central components from si ii .
the redshift and @xmath52-parameter for the reddest central component are measured from o i , which is least affected by additional lines towards the red .
leaving all parameters untied produces a two - component fit for c ii , which is likely due to low @xmath48 .
however , the total column densities remain virtually unchanged . a single component at @xmath53 km s@xmath39 appears in si iiand c ii but not in o i. since o
i is more easily ionized than either si ii or c ii ( @xmath54 ev , @xmath55 ev , @xmath56 ev ) this component probably arises from gas that is more highly ionized than the gas producing the o i absorption .
three additional components appear redward of the central o i complex .
these are visible in si ii , c ii , and si iv and presumably correspond to gas in a still higher ionization state .
we use si ii to constrain the redshift and @xmath52-parameters for all the non - o i components , although fitting without tying any parameters produces very similar results .
this system shows multiple components with a total velocity span of @xmath58 km s@xmath39 .
the si ii is strong enough that the 1304 transition is clearly visible .
some additional absorption occurs along the blue edge of the o i complex .
however , since no corresponding absorption appears in c ii this features is unlikely to be genuine o i. we use c ii to fix the redshifts and @xmath52-parameters of the bluest two components and the reddest component for all ions .
the @xmath59 and @xmath52 values for the remaining components are tied to o i. the weakest c ii component was automatically dropped by the fitting program .
however , this should not have a significant impact on the summed c ii column density .
no si iv was detected down to @xmath60 .
a strong line appears at a velocity separation @xmath61 km s@xmath39 from the o i complex .
weak absorption appears at the same velocity in si ii @xmath44 .
however , the corresponding c ii region is completely covered by mg i @xmath62 from a strong mg ii system at @xmath63 . therefore , while these features are plausibly associated with the o i complex , their identity can not presently be confirmed .
we do not include these lines when computing the relative abundances , although their o i / si ii ratio is consistent with those measured for the other o i systems .
this system shows multiple components with a velocity span of @xmath65 km s@xmath39 .
the si ii @xmath42 transition falls in the ly@xmath3 forest .
however , si ii @xmath44 is clearly visible .
the c ii occurs among moderate - strength telluric absorption . in correcting for the atmosphere we recovered a c ii velocity profile very similar to that of o i and si ii .
some additional absorption around the c ii are probably telluric lines that were not completely removed .
we achieved the best fit for o i using four components while allowing the continuum level to vary slightly . using fewer components resulted in virtually the same total @xmath66 , which is to be expected if the lines lie along the linear part of the curve of growth .
we used the @xmath59 and @xmath52 values for these four o i lines to determine the corresponding column densities for si ii and c ii . leaving all parameters untied resulted in small changes in the @xmath52-parameters and in the preferred number of lines used by vpfit ( 3 for si ii instead of 4 ) , but negligible changes in the total column density for each ion .
we detect no si iv down to @xmath67 .
this system does show c iv absorption in the low - resolution nirspec spectrum taken by @xcite .
however , the kinematic structure can not be determined from their data , and it is therefore unknown whether the c iv absorption arises from the same gas that produces the lower - ionization lines .
the si ii @xmath42 line for this system falls in the ly@xmath3forest . however , si ii @xmath44 is strong enough to be visible .
we tie the redshifts and @xmath52-parameters for si ii and c ii at @xmath69 to those for o i , which has the cleanest profile . leaving all parameters untied produces changes in the @xmath52-parameters that are within the errors and negligible changes in the column densities .
possible additional c ii lines appear at @xmath70 , -29 , and 26 km s@xmath39 from the strong component .
these do not appear in o i and would probably be too weak to appear in si ii @xmath44 .
we do not include them when computing the relative abundances for this system .
no si iv was detected down to @xmath71 .
the si ii @xmath42 and c ii lines for this system occur in transparent gaps within regions of mild telluric absorption . in some of our exposures ,
the o i line falls on the blue wing of a strong telluric feature .
however , the o i can be clearly seen in the uncorrected 2005 january data , where the heliocentric velocity shifted the observed qso spectrum further to the blue .
we tie the redshifts and @xmath52-values for o i and c ii to those of si ii , for which the line profile is the cleanest . leaving all parameters
untied produces negligible changes in the column densities .
we use a single component for the primary fit to this system .
the c ii falls on a sky emission line and hence the line profile is rather noisy .
we therefore tied the redshift and @xmath52-parameter for c ii to those of si ii , while @xmath59 and @xmath52 for o i were allowed to vary freely .
the fitted @xmath59 and @xmath52 values for o i agree with those for si ii within the fit errors . tying @xmath59 and @xmath52 for o i to those of si ii produced no significant change in @xmath66 .
both si ii @xmath42 and o i are well fit by a single line , while the blue edge of the c ii shows a possible additional component .
we fit this component separately but do include it when computing relative abundances .
despite the relatively small total number of detected o i systems , a noticable overabundance appears towards sdss j1148 + 5251 .
it should be noted that this object has one of the brightest continuum magnitudes among qsos at @xmath41 @xcite .
we also spent considerable integration time on this object .
therefore , the data are among the best in our sample . in this section
we address the null hypothesis that the apparent imbalance in the distribution of o i systems results from a combination of incompleteness and small number statistics . for each sightline we used an automated scheme to determine the absorption pathlength interval @xmath74 over which we are sensitive to systems above a given o i column density . for a non - evolving population of sources expanding with the hubble flow , we expect to intersect the same number of sources per unit @xmath75 at all redshifts , where @xmath75 is defined for @xmath35 as @xmath76 at the redshift of each pixel where we are potentially sensitive to o i , we inserted artificial single - component systems containing o i , si ii , and c ii with relative abundances set to the mean measured values ( see 5 ) and a turbulent doppler width of @xmath77 km s@xmath39
. the minimum @xmath66 at which the system could be detected by the automated program was then determined .
a detection required that there be significant ( @xmath78 ) absorption at the expected wavelengths of o i and at least one of the other two ions .
the redshifts of at least two of the three fitted profiles must also agree within a tolerance of @xmath79 , and the line widths must agree to within a factor of two . in the case where the fitted profiles agree for only two of the ions , the spectrum at the wavelength of the third ion must be consistent with the expected level of absorption .
this allows for one of the ions to be blended with another line or lost in ly@xmath3 forest .
lines that fell in the fraunhofer a band were not considered .
this method detected all of the known o i systems and produced only one false detection in the real data , which was easily dismissed by visual inspection .
we note that this method focuses on our ability to detect systems similar to those observed towards sdss j1148 + 5251 .
multiple - component systems such as the two at lower redshift are in general easy to identify , even in noisy regions of the spectrum . the results of the sensitivity measurements are shown in figure 9 .
the solid lines show the @xmath74 over which we are sensitive to systems with @xmath80 .
the o i column densities for the four systems seen towards sdss j1148 + 5251 are marked with circles .
the dashed line shows the mean @xmath74 as a function of @xmath81 for all nine sightlines .
while it is clear that the path length over which we are sensitive to low - column density systems is considerably smaller for some sightlines than for sdss j1148 + 5251 , there does exist significant coverage across the total sample even at the @xmath66 of the weakest system in our sample .
completeness effects will depend on the intrinsic distribution of line strengths , in that weaker systems will more easily be lost in low-@xmath48 sightlines .
it is useful to define an effective absorption pathlength interval @xmath82 such that , for a sightline with a total pathlength @xmath83 and sensitivity @xmath84 , we would expect to detect the same number @xmath85 of systems with @xmath86 over @xmath82 if we had perfect sensitivity . for a column - density distribution @xmath87 , this gives @xmath88 where @xmath84 is the fraction of the total pathlength over which we are sensitive to systems with column density @xmath89 .
the sensitivity function can be determined directly from figure 9 .
we assume a conventional power - law distribution in o i column densities @xmath90 .
hence , @xmath91 taking into account our measured sensitivity , the maximum likelihood estimator for @xmath3 for all six o i systems is @xmath92 .
a k - s test allows @xmath93 at the 95% confidence level . in figure 10 we plot
@xmath82 as a function of @xmath3 taking @xmath94 @xmath95 as the cutoff value .
the solid line shows @xmath82 for sdss j1148 + 5251 , while the dashed line shows @xmath82 for the remaining eight sightlines , divided by 5.7 to match sdss j1148 + 5251 at @xmath96 .
it is easy to see that the ratio @xmath97 does not change significantly with @xmath3 ( @xmath98 over @xmath99 ) .
this is purely a coincidence , most likely related to the fact that the overall high quality of the sdss j1148 + 5251 data is balanced by the placement of the o i systems in a difficult region of the spectrum .
however , it means that the relative numbers of expected o i detections for sdss j1148 + 5251 and the remaining eight sightlines should be nearly invariant over a wide range in plausible column density distributions .
we can now evaluate the likelihood that the imbalance of o idetection results from small number sampling .
for a poisson distribution , the likelihood of detecting @xmath85 systems when the expected number of detections is @xmath100 is given by @xmath101 if we assume that the expected number of detections towards sdss j1148 + 5251 is @xmath102 , then the probability of detecting at least 4 systems is @xmath103 similarly , if we take the number of systems observed towards sdss j1148 + 5251 as a representative sample and compute the expected number of systems towards the remaining eight sightlines to be @xmath104 , then the likelihood of detecting at most two systems is @xmath105 the probability of simultaneously detecting at least 4 systems towards sdss j1148 + 5251 while detecting at most two systems along the remaining eight sightlines , @xmath106 \ , \left [ \sum_{\mathcal{n } = 0}^{2}{p(\mathcal{n},{\frac{\partial\mathcal{n}}{\partial x}}\,\delta x^{\rm eff}_{\rm other } ) } \right ] \ , , \ ] ] has a maximum of @xmath107 at @xmath108 , taking @xmath109 .
thus , assuming that the o i systems are randomly distributed , we can rule out with a high degree of confidence the possibility that the excess number of detected systems towards sdss j1148 + 5251 is the result of a statistical fluctuation .
our sample of nine @xmath110 sightlines is sufficient to demonstrate that the apparent excess of o i systems towards sdss 1148 + 5251 is highly unlikely to arise from a random spatial distribution of absorbers .
however , the distribution may be significantly non - random due to large - scale clustering .
for example , if the line - of - sight towards sdss 1148 + 5251 passes through an overdense region of the igm then we might expect to intersect more than the typical number of absorbers . to address this possibility , we have searched for o i in the spectra of an additional 30 qsos with @xmath111 .
the sample was taken entirely with hires for a variety of studies .
due to the lower qso redshifts , the data are of significantly higher quality than the @xmath110 sample .
all sightlines are complete down to @xmath112 ( apart from rare wavelength coverage gaps ) with the majority complete down to @xmath113 . a detailed study of the properties of lower - redshift o i absorbers will be presented elsewhere .
here we note that 11 systems with @xmath1 were identified along all 30 sightlines in the redshift intervals where o i would occur redward of the ly@xmath3 forest .
this is comparable to but slightly larger than the incidence rate among the eight lowest - redshift sightlines in our @xmath110 sample .
the number density is even somewhat higher among the @xmath114 sample since the absorption pathlength intervals are shorter ( cf .
[ eq : dx ] ) .
however , many of the @xmath114 spectra were taken in order to study known damped ly@xmath3 systems ( dlas ; @xmath115 ) , which commonly exhibit o i ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
we would therefore expect these sightlines to contain more than the typical number of o i systems .
the important point is that no sightline contained more than a single system .
if the excess towards sdss j1148 + 5251 is due to the chance alignment with an overdense region of the igm , then such a coincidence must occur in fewer than @xmath116 of all sightlines .
we can compare the observed number of o i systems in our @xmath117 sample with the expected number of dlas by extrapolating from lower - redshift dla surveys .
@xcite find a line number density @xmath118 .
this is consistent at high-@xmath59 with the larger survey done by @xcite and with the number density evolution @xcite obtained by combining dla samples over @xmath119 . from this @xmath120
we would expect a total of @xmath121 dlas total along all nine lines - of - sight in the redshift intervals where are sensitive to o i. this is consistent with the two o i systems seen along the eight lower - redshift sightlines .
however , we would expect to see only @xmath122 dlas towards sdss j1148 + 5251 , which is inconsistent with the four we observe .
the disparity eases for sdss j1148 + 5251 if we include all lyman limit systems ( llss ; @xmath123 ) .
the line number density of llss at @xmath124 found by @xcite , @xmath125 , predicts @xmath126 llss towards sdss j1148 + 5251 in the interval where we can observe o i. however , there should also be @xmath127 llss along the remaining eight lines - of - sight . if the excess o i absorbers are associated with the progenitors of lower - redshift llss then they must evolve strongly in o i at @xmath128 .
absorption systems at @xmath41 provide an opportunity to study metal enrichment when the age of the universe was @xmath129 gyr .
the opacity of the ly@xmath3 forest at these redshifts prevents us from measuring reliable h i column densities .
however , we are still able to constrain relative abundances . in table 3
we summarize the voigt profile fitting results .
total column densities for each system include only components with confirmed o i. relative abundances were calculated using the solar values of @xcite and assuming zero ionization corrections .
these are plotted in figure 11 .
the error - weighted mean values for all six systems are @xmath130 \rangle = -0.04 \pm 0.06 $ ] , @xmath131 \rangle = -0.31 \pm 0.09 $ ] , and @xmath132 \rangle = -0.34 \pm 0.07 $ ] ( 2@xmath133 errors ) .
the uncorrected abundances are broadly consistent with the expected yields from type ii supernovae of low - metallicity progenitors @xcite .
low- and intermediate - mass stars should not contribute significantly to the enrichment of these systems since these stars will not have had time to evolve by @xmath23 ( although see * ? ? ?
we can use the o / si ratio to constrain the enrichment from zero - metallicity very massive stars ( vmss , @xmath134 ) .
vmss exploding as pair instability supernovae are expected to yield @xmath126 times as much silicon compared to type ii sne for the same amount of oxygen @xcite .
we can estimate the fraction @xmath135 of silicon contributed by vmss to these systems using the simple mixing scheme of @xcite , @xmath136 adopting @xmath137_{\rm vms } } = -0.61 $ ] from @xcite , and @xmath138_{\rm sn\,ii } } = 0.00 $ ] from @xcite , the mean uncorrected o / si gives @xmath139 .
however , this value of o / si should be considered a lower limit .
the ionization potential of o i is smaller than that of si ii ( @xmath140 ev , @xmath141 ev ) .
therefore , applying an ionization correction would increase o / si . taking @xmath130
-0.10 $ ] gives @xmath142 .
the mean c / si ratio is consistent with zero silicon contribution from vmss , although c / si may decrease if ionization corrections are applied ( @xmath56 ev @xmath143 ) .
dust corrections would also decrease c / si since silicon is more readily depleted onto grains @xcite .
our upper limit of @xmath144 \rangle < -0.27~(2\sigma)$ ] therefore does not provide an additional constraint on @xmath135 .
however , the limit set by o / si may still imply that vmss provided a smaller fraction of the metals in these o i systems than in the general igm . @xcite
have argued that vmss at @xmath145 must have contributed @xmath146 of the silicon in the igm in order to produce @xmath147_{\rm igm } } \sim 0.7 $ ] at @xmath148 @xcite .
however , the si / c ratio in the igm derived from high - ionization lines depends sensitively on the choice of ionizing backgrounds .
the high level of absorption blueward of the ly@xmath3 emission line at @xmath149 prevents us from reliably fitting voigt profiles to h i. however , transmission peaks in the ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 forests near the o i redshifts allow us to set upper limits on the h i column density for two of our systems .
fits to these systems with the strongest allowable damping wings are shown in figures 7 and 8 , and the corresponding limits are listed in table 3 . the limits take into account uncertainties in the continuum level , which was set to a power - law @xmath150 with spectral index @xmath151 , normalized at a rest wavelength of 1280 .
the continuum uncertainty will include the error in the amplitude of the power law at the wavelength of the damped system .
taking @xmath152 to incorporate 95% of the scatter in qso spectral indices @xcite , this error is @xmath153 for the system at @xmath50 , for which the limit on @xmath154 was set using ly@xmath3 transmission , and @xmath155 for the system at @xmath156 , for which the limit was set using ly@xmath5 .
larger uncertainties in the continuum may result from errors in the relative flux calibration and the departure from a power law .
we conservatively estimate both of these to be @xmath157 , which translates to an uncertainty in the column density @xmath158 .
the upper limits on @xmath159 listed in table 3 are our `` best fit '' values plus this uncertainty .
the corresponding limits on the absolute abundances are @xmath160 > -2.4 $ ] ( @xmath50 ) and @xmath161 > -4.1 $ ] ( @xmath64 ) .
the comoving mass density for each ion is given by @xmath162 where @xmath163 is the mass of the ion , @xmath164 is the cosmological closure density , and @xmath83 is the total pathlength interval over which we are sensitive to o i. in table 4 we list @xmath165 for o i , si ii , and c ii summing over all @xmath110 sightlines , over the three sightlines with @xmath13 only , and over the sightline towards sdss j1148 + 5251 only .
the mass densities include all confirmed absorption components , including those without detected o i. however , we have made no attempt to correct for incompleteness .
the densities of low - ionization metal species along our @xmath13 sightlines are comparable to the densities of the corresponding high - ionization species at lower - redshift . @xcite measured @xmath166 and @xmath167 over @xmath168 , with a drop in @xmath169 by at least a factor of two at @xmath41 . a decrease in high - ionization metals and
a correlated rise in their low - ionization counterparts with redshift might signal a change in the ionization state of the @xmath41 igm .
however , coverage of c iv does not currently extend to @xmath23 , and our o i sample is probably too small to make a meaningful comparison .
although we observe an overabundance of o i at @xmath30 along one of our highest - redshift sightlines , it is not clear that these four systems constitute a `` forest '' which would signal a predominantly neutral igm . in the reionization phase
prior to the overlap of ionized bubbles , @xcite predicts tens to hundreds of o i lines with @xmath170 , although the number may be lower if the enriched regions have very low metallicity ( @xmath171 ) , or if the volume filling factor of metals is small ( @xmath172 ) .
the number of o i systems we detect is more consistent with his predictions for the post - overlap phase , although the expected number of lines depends on the ionizing efficiency of the metal - producing galaxies .
the @xcite model also predicts lines with @xmath173 , which we do not observe .
the significance of the excess o i towards sdss j1148 + 5251 is complicated by the presence of ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 transmission along that sightline .
the o i systems occur interspersed in redshift with the ly@xmath5 peaks , with the velocity separation from the nearest peak ranging from @xmath174 to @xmath175 km s@xmath39 ( @xmath176 to @xmath177 comoving mpc ) .
the o i absorbers also do not appear to be clustered .
along a total redshift interval @xmath178 ( @xmath179 comoving mpc ) where we are sensitive to o i , the detected systems are separated by @xmath180 to @xmath181 ( @xmath182 to @xmath183 comoving mpc ) .
if any significantly neutral regions are present along this sightline , then they occur within or near regions that are highly ionized .
in contrast , we find no o i towards sdss j1030 + 0524 , despite the fact that its spectrum shows complete absorption in ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 over @xmath7 .
the sdss j1030 + 0524 sightline may pass through a region of the igm that is still largely neutral and not yet enriched .
alternatively , there may be no o i because the sightline is highly ionized . in that case
, a large - scale density enhancement could still produce the high ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 optical depth @xcite .
the overabundance of o i together with the transmission in ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 indicates that the sdss j1148 + 5251 sightline has experienced both significant enrichment _ and _ ionization .
one explanation is that we are looking along a filament .
the total comoving distance between o i systems towards sdss j1148 + 5251 is @xmath184 mpc , which is smaller than the largest known filamentary structures at low redshift ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
if the line - of - sight towards sdss 1148 + 5251 runs along a filament at @xmath23 then we might expect to intersect more than the average number of absorbers .
galaxies along such a structure might produce enough ionizing radiation to create the transmission gaps observed in the ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 forests while still allowing pockets of neutral material to persist if the ionizing background is sufficiently low .
if we assume that every @xmath23 galaxy is surrounded by an enriched halo , then we can calculate the typical halo radius @xmath185^{1/2}\\ \nonumber & \sim & 35~{\rm proper~kpc } \
, \left(\frac{\mathcal n}{4}\right)^{1/2 } \left(\frac{1+z}{7.2}\right)^{-1 } \left(\frac{\left<\phi_{\rm gal}\right > } { 0.01\,{\rm mpc^{-3}}}\right)^{-1/2 } \\ & & \times \left(\frac{\delta_{\rm gal}}{10}\right)^{-1/2 } \left(\frac{\delta d}{200\,{\rm mpc}}\right)^{-1/2 } \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath186 is the total comoving distance over which we are sensitive to o i. we have used the mean comoving number of galaxies @xmath187 at @xmath23 measured down to the limit of the hubble ultra deep field ( udf ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and assumed an overdensity of galaxies @xmath188 along this sightline .
the absorption could be due to filled halos , shells , or other structures surrounding the galaxies .
note that by inverting eq .
[ eq : rhalo ] we can rule out the possibility that these o i systems arise from the central star - forming regions of galaxies similar those observed in the udf .
the small size @xmath189 kpc of galaxies at @xmath23 @xcite would require either a local galaxy overdensity @xmath190 or a large number of faint galaxies to produce the observed absorption systems .
at present we can place relatively few physical constraints on these absorbers .
assuming charge - exchange equilibrium ( eq . [ eq : equilib ] ) , we can estimate the h i column densities as a function of metallicity , @xmath191}\,.\ ] ] for solar metallicities , even the weakest o i system in our sample must be nearly optically thick .
metal - poor absorbers with [ o / h ] @xmath192 would require column densities @xmath193 , which is consistent with the indication from the relative metal abundances that these absorbers are largely neutral . finally , the excess o i absorbers are distinguished by their small velocity dispersions .
three out of the four systems towards sdss j1148 + 5251 have single components with doppler widths @xmath194 km s@xmath39 .
we may be seeing only the low - ionization component of a kinematically more complex structure such as a galactic outflow ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
however , if there are additional high - ionization components that would appear in c iv and si iv then we might expect to see components in c ii and possibly si ii without o i. this is the case in the @xmath50 system towards sdss j0231 - 0728 .
the @xmath68 and @xmath195 systems towards sdss j1148 + 5251 show potential c ii lines that do not appear in o i , but these are relatively weak , and in the @xmath68 system there is no apparent strong si iv . among the 11 o i absorbers in the @xmath196 sample , only three have a single o i component with a velocity width comparable to the three narrowest systems towards sdss j1148 + 5251 .
the fact that the excess o i systems appear kinematically quiescent further suggests that they are a distinct class of absorbers .
we have conducted a search for o i in the high - resolution spectra of 9 qsos at @xmath197 . in total , we detect six systems in the redshift intervals where o i @xmath2 falls redward of the ly@xmath3 forest .
four of these lie towards sdss j1148 + 5251 ( @xmath4 ) .
this imbalance is not easily explained by small number statics or by varying sensitivity among the data .
a search at lower redshift revealed no more than than one o isystem per sightline in a high - quality sample of 30 qsos with @xmath198 .
the number of excess systems is significantly larger than the expected number of damped ly@xmath3 systems at @xmath23 , but similar to the predicted number of lyman limit systems .
the six systems have mean relative abundances @xmath199 \rangle = -0.04 \pm 0.06 $ ] , @xmath131 \rangle = -0.31 \pm 0.09 $ ] , and @xmath132 \rangle = -0.34 \pm 0.07 $ ] ( @xmath11 errors ) , assuming no ionization corrections .
these abundances are consistent with enrichment dominated by type ii supernovae .
the lower limit on the oxygen to silicon ratio @xmath200 \rangle > -0.10 $ ] is insensitive to ionization corrections and limits the contribution of silicon from vmss to @xmath201 in these systems .
the upper limits on the ratio of carbon to oxygen @xmath202 } \le -0.13 $ ] , and carbon to silicon @xmath203 } \le -0.20 $ ] are also insensitive to ionization . integrating over only the confirmed absorption lines , the mean ionic comoving mass densities along the three @xmath13 sightlines are @xmath204 , @xmath205 , and @xmath206 .
the excess o i systems towards sdss j1148 + 5251 occur in redshift among ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 transmission features , which indicates that the igm along this sightline has experienced both enrichment _ and _ significant ionization .
the sightline may pass along a filament , where galaxies are producing enough ionizing photons create the transmission gaps while still allowing a few neutral absorbers to persist .
in contrast , no o i was observed towards sdss j1030 + 0524 , whose spectrum shows complete gunn - peterson absorption .
the sdss j1030 + 0524 sightline may pass through an underdense region containing very few sources that would either enrich or ionize the igm .
alternatively , the sightline may be highly ionized , with a large - scale density enhancement producing strong line - blending in the ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 forests .
future deep imaging of these fields and near - infrared spectroscopy covering high - ionization metal lines will allow us to distinguish between these scenarios and clarify the nature of the excess o i absorbers .
the authors would like to thank the anonymous referee for helpful comments , peng oh for sharing his recent results on charge - exchange equilibrium ahead of publication , and bob carswell for vpfit .
wlws gratefully acknowledge support from the nsf through grants ast 99 - 00733 and ast 02 - 06067 .
mr has been supported by the nsf under grant ast 00 - 98492 .
ras has been supported by the mit pappalardo fellowship program .
finally , we thank the hawaiian people for the opportunity to conduct observations from mauna kea . without their hospitality
this work would not have been possible . in particular
, we would like to thank lono , who granted us clear skies during the overcast months of 2005 january and february .
aguirre , a. , schaye , j. , kim , t .- s . , theuns , t. , rauch , m. , & sargent , w. l. w. 2004 , , 602 , 38 barth , a. j. , martini , p. , nelson , c. h. , & ho , l. c. 2003 , , 594 , l95 becker , r. h. , et al .
2001 , , 122 , 2850 bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. , blakeslee , j. p. , & frankx , m. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/05090641 ) carilli , c. l. , gnedin , n. , furlanetto , s. , & owen , f. 2004 , new astronomy review , 48 , 1053 chieffi , a. , & limongi , m. 2004 , , 608 , 405 djorgovski , s. g. , castro , s. , stern , d. , & mahabal , a. a. 2001 , , 560 , l5 fan , x. , et al . 2001 , , 122 , 2833 fan , x. , narayanan , v. k. , strauss , m. a. , white , r. l. , becker , r. h. , pentericci , l. , & rix , h .- w .
2002 , , 123 , 1247 fan , x. , et al .
2003 , , 125 , 1649 fan , x. , et al .
2004 , , 128 , 515 furlanetto , s. r. , & loeb , a. 2003 , , 588 , 18 furlanetto , s. r. , hernquist , l. , & zaldarriaga , m. 2004 , mnras , 354 , 695 furlanetto , s. r. , zaldarriaga , m. , & hernquist , l. 2004 , , 613 , 16 furlanetto , s. r. , & oh , s. p. 2005 , mnras , submitted ( astro - ph/0505065 ) gott , j. r. i. , juri , m. , schlegel , d. , hoyle , f. , vogeley , m. , tegmark , m. , bahcall , n. , & brinkmann , j. 2005 , , 624 , 463 grevesse , n. , & sauval , a. j. 1998 , space science reviews , 85 , 161 gunn , j. e. , & peterson , b. a. 1965 , , 142 , 1633 heger , a. , & woosley , s. e. 2002 , , 567 , 532 horne , k. 1986 , , 98 , 609 kassim , n. e. , lazio , t. j. w. , ray , p. s. , crane , p. c. , hicks , b. c. , stewart , k. p. , cohen , a. s. , & lane , w. m. 2004 , p&ss , 52 , 1343 kelson , d. d. 2003 , , 115 , 688 malhotra , s. , & rhoads , j. e. 2004 , apjl , 617 , l5 oh , s. p. 2002
, , 336 , 1021 oh , s. p. , & furlanetto , s. r. 2005 , , 620 , l9 osterbrock , d. e. 1989 , astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei ( sausalito , ca : university science books ) pentericci , l. , et al . 2002 , , 123 , 2151 proux , c. , mcmahon , r. g. , storrie - lombardi , l. j. , & irwin , m. j. 2003 , , 346 , 1103 pettini , m. , shapley , a. e. , steidel , c. c. , cuby , j .- g . , dickinson , m. , moorwood , a. f. m. , adelberger , k. l. , & giavalisco , m. 2001 , , 554 , 981 press , w. h. , & schechter , p. 1974
, , 187 , 425 prochaska , j. x. , et al .
2001 , , 137 , 21 prochaska , j. x. , gawiser , e. , wolfe , a. m. , cooke , j. , & gelino , d. 2003 , , 147 , 227 prochaska , j. x. , herbert - forte , s. , & wolfe , a. m. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0508361 ) qian , y .- z .
, & wasserburg , g. j. 2005 , , 623 , 17 qian , y .- z . , & wasserburg , g. j. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0509151 ) rao , s. m. , turnshek , d. a. , & nestor , b. d. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0509469 ) richards , g. t. , et al .
2001 , , 121 , 2308 santos , m. r. 2004 , mnras , 349 , 1137 savage , b. d. , & sembach , k. r. 1996 , , 34 , 279 schaerer , d. 2002 , , 382 , 28 schaye , j. , aguirre , a. , kim , t .- s . ,
theuns , t. , rauch , m. , & sargent , w. l. w. 2003 , , 596 , 768 sheth , r. k. , & tormen , g. 2002 , , 329 , 61 simcoe , r. a. , sargent , w. l. w. , & rauch , m. 2004 , , 606 , 92 simcoe , r. a. , sargent , l. w. l. , rauch , m. , & becker , g. d. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0508116 ) songaila , a. 2004 , , 127 , 2598 songaila , a. 2005 , , 130 , 1996 stern , d. , yost , s. a. , eckart , m. e. , harrison , f. a. , helfand , d. j. , djorgovski , s. g. , malhotra , s. , & rhoads , j. e. 2005 , apj , 619 , 12 storrie - lombardi , l. j. , & wolfe , a. m. 2000 , , 543 , 552 tozzi , p. , madau , p. , meiksin , a. , & rees , m. j. 2000 , apj , 528 , 597 umeda , h. , & nomoto , k. 2002 , , 565 , 385 vogt , s. s. , et al .
1994 , , 2198 , 362 white , r. l. , becker , r. h. , fan , x. , & strauss , m. a. 2003 , , 126 , 1 white , r. l. , becker , r. h. , fan , x. , & strauss , m. a. 2005 , , 129 , 2102 woosley , s. e. , & weaver , t. a. 1995 , , 101 , 181 wyithe , s. , & loeb , a. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0508604 ) yan , h. , & windhorst , r. a. 2004 , , 612 , l93 lccc sdss j2225@xmath490014 & 4.87 & 2004 jun & 6.7 + sdss j1204@xmath490021 & 5.09 & 2005 jan - feb & 6.7 + sdss j0915@xmath2074244 & 5.20 & 2005 jan - feb & 10.8 + sdss j0231@xmath490728 & 5.42 & 2005 jan - feb & 10.0 + sdss j0836@xmath2070054 & 5.80 & 2003 feb - 2005 jan & 21.7 + sdss j0002@xmath2072550 & 5.82 & 2005 jan - jun & 4.2 + sdss j1623@xmath2073112 & 6.22 & 2005 jun & 12.5 + sdss j1030@xmath2070524 & 6.30 & 2005 feb & 12.0 + sdss j1148@xmath2075251 & 6.42 & 2003 feb - 2005 feb & 22.0 + llll si ii & @xmath208 & @xmath209 & @xmath210 + c ii & @xmath211 & @xmath212 & @xmath213 + si ii & @xmath214 & @xmath215 & @xmath216 + si ii & @xmath217 & @xmath218 & @xmath219 + si ii & @xmath220 & @xmath221 & @xmath222 + o i & @xmath223 & @xmath224 & @xmath225 + o i & @xmath226 & @xmath227 & @xmath228 + o i & @xmath229 & @xmath230 & @xmath231 + c ii & @xmath223 & @xmath224 & @xmath232 + c ii & @xmath226 & @xmath227 & @xmath233 + c ii & @xmath220 & @xmath221 & @xmath234 + si ii & @xmath235 & @xmath236 & @xmath237 + si ii & @xmath238 & @xmath239 & @xmath240 + si ii & @xmath241 & @xmath242 & @xmath243 + c ii & @xmath244 & @xmath245 & @xmath246 + c ii & @xmath247 & @xmath248 & @xmath249 + c ii & @xmath250 & @xmath251 & @xmath252 + si iv & @xmath244 & @xmath245 & @xmath253 + si iv & @xmath247 & @xmath248 & @xmath254 + si iv & @xmath250 & @xmath255 & @xmath256 + o i & @xmath257 & @xmath258 & @xmath259 + o i & @xmath260 & @xmath261 & @xmath262 + si ii & @xmath263 & @xmath264 & @xmath265 + si ii & @xmath266 & @xmath267 & @xmath268 + si ii & @xmath269 & @xmath270 & @xmath271 + si ii & @xmath272 & @xmath273 & @xmath274 + si ii & @xmath275 & @xmath276 & @xmath277 + si ii & @xmath278 & @xmath279 & @xmath280 + si ii & @xmath281 & @xmath282 & @xmath283 + si ii & @xmath284 & @xmath285 & @xmath286 + si ii & @xmath287 & @xmath288 & @xmath289 + o i & @xmath269 & @xmath270 & @xmath290 + o i & @xmath272 & @xmath273 & @xmath291 + o i & @xmath292 & @xmath293 & @xmath294 + o i & @xmath295 & @xmath296 & @xmath297 + o i & @xmath298 & @xmath299 & @xmath300 + o i & @xmath301 & @xmath302 & @xmath303 + o i & @xmath287 & @xmath288 & @xmath304 + c ii & @xmath305 & @xmath306 & @xmath307 + c ii & @xmath308 & @xmath309 & @xmath310 + c ii & @xmath275 & @xmath276 & @xmath311 + c ii & @xmath278 & @xmath279 & @xmath312 + c ii & @xmath281 & @xmath282 & @xmath313 + c ii & @xmath314 & @xmath315 & @xmath316 + si ii & @xmath317 & @xmath318 & @xmath319 + si ii & @xmath320 & @xmath321 & @xmath322 + si ii & @xmath323 & @xmath324 & @xmath325 + si ii & @xmath326 & @xmath327 & @xmath328 + o i & @xmath329 & @xmath330 & @xmath331 + o i & @xmath332 & @xmath333 & @xmath334 + o i & @xmath335 & @xmath336 & @xmath337 + o i & @xmath338 & @xmath339 & @xmath340 + c ii & @xmath317 & @xmath318 & @xmath341 + c ii & @xmath320 & @xmath321 & @xmath342 + c ii & @xmath323 & @xmath324 & @xmath343 + c ii & @xmath326 & @xmath327 & @xmath344 + c ii & @xmath345 & @xmath346 & @xmath347 + c ii & @xmath348 & @xmath349 & @xmath350 + si ii & @xmath351 & @xmath352 & @xmath353 + o i & @xmath354 & @xmath355 & @xmath356 + c ii & @xmath351 & @xmath352 & @xmath357 + c ii & @xmath358 & @xmath359 & @xmath360 + si ii & @xmath361 & @xmath362 & @xmath363 + o i & @xmath364 & @xmath365 & @xmath366 + c ii & @xmath364 & @xmath365 & @xmath367 + c ii & @xmath368 & @xmath369 & @xmath370 + si ii & @xmath371 & @xmath372 & @xmath373 + o i & @xmath374 & @xmath375 & @xmath376 + c ii & @xmath377 & @xmath378 & @xmath379 + lcccccccc sdss j1148@xmath2075251 & 6.2555 & @xmath380 & @xmath381 & @xmath382 & @xmath383 & @xmath384 & @xmath385 & + sdss j1148@xmath2075251 & 6.1968 & @xmath386 & @xmath387 & @xmath388 & @xmath389 & @xmath390 & @xmath391 & + sdss j1148@xmath2075251 & 6.1293 & @xmath392 & @xmath393 & @xmath394 & @xmath395 & @xmath396 & @xmath397 & + sdss j1148@xmath2075251 & 6.0097 & @xmath398 & @xmath399 & @xmath400 & @xmath401 & @xmath402 & @xmath403 & @xmath404 + sdss j1623@xmath2073112 & 5.8408 & @xmath405 & @xmath406 & @xmath407 & @xmath408 & @xmath409 & @xmath410 & + sdss j0231@xmath490728 & 5.3364 & @xmath411 & @xmath412 & @xmath413 & @xmath414 & @xmath415 & @xmath416 & @xmath417 + | we present a search for o i in the spectra of nine @xmath0 qsos taken with keck / hires .
we detect six systems with @xmath1 in the redshift intervals where o i @xmath2 falls redward of the ly@xmath3 forest .
four of these lie towards sdss j1148 + 5251 ( @xmath4 ) .
this imbalance is unlikely to arise from variations in sensitivity among our data or from a statistical fluctuation .
the excess o i occurs over a redshift interval that also contains transmission in ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 .
therefore , if these o i systems represent pockets of neutral gas , then they must occur within or near regions of the igm that are highly ionized .
in contrast , no o i is detected towards sdss j1030 + 0524 ( @xmath6 ) , whose spectrum shows complete absorption in ly@xmath3 and ly@xmath5 over @xmath7 . assuming no ionization corrections
, we measure mean abundance ratios @xmath8 \rangle = -0.04 \pm 0.06 $ ] , @xmath9 \rangle = -0.31 \pm 0.09 $ ] , and @xmath10 \rangle = -0.34 \pm 0.07 $ ] ( @xmath11 ) , which are consistent with enrichment dominated by type ii supernovae .
the o / si ratio limits the fraction of silicon in these systems contributed by metal - free very massive stars to @xmath12 , a result which is insensitive to ionization corrections .
the ionic comoving mass densities along the @xmath13 sightlines , including only the detected systems , are @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 . |
nature has provided us with a variety of neutrino sources , from the not yet observed 1.9 k cosmological background to the icecube pev neutrinos @xcite , whose origin is still mysterious .
neutrinos are intriguing weakly interacting particles .
after 1998 many unknown properties have been determined thanks to the discovery of neutrino oscillations , first proposed in @xcite and observed by the super - kamiokande experiment using atmospheric neutrinos @xcite .
this discovery is fundamental for particle physics , for astrophysics and for cosmology .
neutrino oscillations is an interference phenomenon among the @xmath0 mass eigenstates , that occurs if neutrinos are massive and if the mass ( propagation basis ) and the flavor ( interaction basis ) do not coincide .
the maki - nakagawa - sakata - pontecorvo matrix relates these two basis @xcite . within three active flavors ,
such a matrix depends on three mixing angles , one dirac and two majorana cp violating phases . in the last two decades solar , reactor and accelerator experiments
have precisely determined most of the oscillation parameters , including the so - called atmospheric @xmath1ev@xmath2 , and solar @xmath3ev@xmath2 mass - squared differences @xcite .
moreover the sign of @xmath4 has been measured since @xmath5b neutrinos undergo the mikheev - smirnov - wolfenstein ( msw ) effect @xcite in the sun @xcite .
the sign of @xmath6 is still unknown , either @xmath7 and the lightest mass eigenstate is @xmath8 ( normal ordering or `` hierarchy '' ) , or @xmath9 it is @xmath10 ( inverted ordering ) .
most of neutrino oscillation experiments can be interpreted within the framework of three active neutrinos .
however a few measurements present anomalies that require further clarification .
sterile neutrinos that do not couple to the gauge bosons but mix with the other active species could be the origin of the anomalies .
upcoming experiments such as stereo or cesox will cover most of the mixing parameters identified in particular by the `` reactor anomaly '' @xcite . among the fundamental properties yet to be determined are the mechanism for the neutrino mass , the absolute mass value and ordering , the neutrino nature ( dirac versus majorana ) , the existence of cp violation in the lepton sector and of sterile neutrinos .
the combined analysis of available experimental results shows a preference for normal ordering and for a non - zero cp violating phase , currently favouring @xmath11 , although statistical significance is still low @xcite . in the coming decade(s ) experiments will aim at determining the mass ordering , the dirac cp violating phase , the neutrino absolute mass and hopefully nature as well .
moreover super - kamiokande with gadolinium should have the sensitivity to discover the relic supernova neutrino background @xcite .
electron neutrinos are constantly produced in our sun and in low mass main sequence stars through the proton - proton ( pp ) nuclear reaction chain that produces 99 @xmath12 of their energy by burning hydrogen into helium-4 @xcite .
the corresponding solar neutrino flux receives contributions from both fusion reactions and beta - decays of @xmath13be and @xmath5b ( figure 1 ) .
first measured by r. davis pioneering experiment @xcite , such flux was found to be nearly a factor of three below predictions @xcite . over the decades solar neutrino experiments have precisely measured electron neutrinos from the different pp branches , usually referred to as the pp , pep , @xmath13be and @xmath5b and hep neutrinos .
the measurement of a reduced solar neutrino flux , compared to standard solar model predictions ( the so - called the `` solar neutrino deficit problem '' ) , has been confirmed by experiments mainly sensitive to electron neutrinos , but with some sensitivity to the other flavors . the advocated solutions included unknown neutrino properties ( e.g. flavor oscillations , a neutrino magnetic moment coupling to the solar magnetic fields , neutrino decay , the msw effect ) and questioned the standard solar model . in particular , the msw effect is due to the neutrino interaction with matter while they traverse a medium .
o and @xmath14n neutrinos have not been observed yet @xcite.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] the solar puzzle is definitely solved by the discovery of the neutrino oscillation phenomenon @xcite and the results obtained by the sno and kamland experiments ( see @xcite for a review on solar neutrino physics ) . in fact , using elastic scattering , charged- and neutral- current neutrino interactions on heavy water , the sno experiment has showed that the measurement of the total @xmath5b solar neutrino flux is consistent with the predictions of the standard solar model : solar electron neutrinos convert into the other active flavors .
in particular , the muon and tau neutrino components of the solar flux has been measured at 5 @xmath15 @xcite .
moreover the reactor experiment kamland has definitely identified the large mixing angle ( lma ) solution , by observing reactor electron anti - neutrino disappearance at an average distance of 200 km @xcite .
the ensemble of these observations shows that low energy solar neutrinos are suppressed by averaged vacuum oscillations while neutrinos having more than 2 mev energy are suppressed because of the msw effect ( figure 2 ) .
theoretically one expects @xmath16 ( with @xmath17 ) for ( @xmath18 mev ) solar neutrinos ; for high energy portion of the @xmath5b spectrum , the matter - dominated survival probability is @xmath19 ( see @xcite ) .
the precise determination of the transition between the vacuum averaged and the lma solution brings valuable information since deviations from the simplest vacuum - lma transition could point to new physics , such as non - standard neutrino interactions @xcite .
be , @xmath5b neutrinos from the borexino experiment .
the results are compared to averaged vacuum oscillation prediction ( @xmath20 mev ) and the msw prediction ( @xmath21 mev ) , taking into account present uncertainties on mixing angles .
figure from @xcite .
, scaledwidth=70.0% ] the borexino experiment has precisely measured the low energy part of the solar neutrino flux , namely the pep @xcite , @xmath13be @xcite . moreover , by achieving challenging reduced backgrounds , the collaboration has reported the first direct measurement of pp neutrino , the keystone of the fusion process in the sun .
the measured flux is consistent with the standard solar model predictions @xcite .
the ensemble of solar observations has established that the sun produces @xmath22 ergs / s via the pp chain .
moreover the occurrence of the msw effect for the high energy solar neutrinos shows that these particles change flavor in vacuum in a very different way than in matter .
in fact , in the central high density regions of the star the flavor coincide with the matter eigenstates . during their propagation towards the edge of the sun , they encounter a resonance ( if the msw resonance condition is fulfilled ) and evolve adiabatically through it depending on the neutrino energies , squared - mass difference value and the gradient of the matter density .
adiabaticity implies that the matter eigenstates mixing is suppressed at the resonance . in the latter case electron neutrinos can efficiently convert into muon and tau neutrinos .
the msw phenomenon is analogous to the two - level system in quantum mechanics .
it occurs in numerous contexts , including the early universe ( at the epoch of the primordial elements formation ) , massive stars like core - collapse supernovae , accretion disks aroung black holes and the earth .
future measurements will aim at observing solar neutrinos produced in the carbon - nitrogen - oxygen ( cno ) cycle which is thought to be the main mechanism for energy production in massive main sequence stars @xcite .
borexino experiment has provided the strongest constraint on the cno cycle which represents 1 @xmath12 of energy production in the sun , consistent with standard solar model predictions @xcite .
the achievement of increased purity both by borexino and sno+ could allow to reach the sensivity for this challenging measurement
. beyond furnishing confirmation of stellar evolutionary models , the observation of cno neutrinos could help solving the so - called solar `` opacity '' problem .
standard solar models predict solar neutrino fluxes , from the pp cycle , in agreement with observations .
however the gs98-sfii and agss09-sfii models differ for their treatment of the metal element contributions ( elements heavier than he ) .
the first model uses older abundances for volatile elements that are obtained by an absorption line analysis in which the photosphere is treated as one - dimensional that yields a metallicity of @xmath23 ( @xmath24 and @xmath25 being the metal and hydrogen abundances respectively ) with solar fusion ii cross sections ( gs98-sfii ) .
the second model takes abundances from a three - dimensional photospheric model @xmath26 ( agss09-sfii ) .
the latter produces a cooler core by @xmath27 and lower fluxes of temperature sensitive neutrinos such as @xmath5b ones . a comparison of the solar parameters used in the two models and corresponding predictions on the neutrino fluxes
are given in tables 1 and 2 of ref.@xcite .
the `` solar opacity problem '' is the inconsistency between agss09 that uses the best description of the solar photosphere , while gs98 has the best agreement with helioseimic data that are sensitive to the interior composition .
since there is approximately 30 @xmath12 difference between c and n abundances in the two models , a measurement of cno neutrinos with @xmath28 precision , which could be achieved in the future , will allow to determine the solar opacity .
core - collapse supernovae ( sne ) are stars with mass @xmath29 ( @xmath30 being the sun s mass ) whose core undergoes gravitational collapse at the end of their life .
these include types ii and ib / c depending on their spectral properties .
they are of type ii if they exhibit h lines in their spectra and of type i if they do nt because the star has lost the h envelope .
sne iib have a thin h envelope ; type ii - p and ii - l present a plateau or a linear decay of the light curves after the peak .
the sne ib shows he and si lines , while sne ic shows none of these indicating that before collapse the star has lost both the h envelope and he shells .
the supernova can still appear as bright if the h envelope is present , otherwise it can be invisible ( type ib / c ) @xcite . in 1960
hoyle and fowler proposed that stellar death of snii and i / b happens because of the implosion of the core @xcite .
the same year colgate and johnson suggested that a bounce of the neutron star forming launches a shock that ejects the matter to make it unbound @xcite ( the `` prompt model '' ) .
it was realised by colgate and white @xcite that a gravitational binding energy of the order of @xmath31 erg associated with the collapse of the star core to a neutron star ( ns ) would be released as neutrinos that would deposit energy to trigger the explosion .
arnett @xcite and wilson @xcite critized the model because it would not give enough energy .
wilson revisited the model and developed it further : the ejection of the mantle would be preceded by an accreting phase in the so - called `` delayed neutrino - heating mechanism '' @xcite . the fate of a massive star is mainly determined by the initial mass and composition and the history of its mass loss .
their explosion produces either neutron stars or black holes directly or by fallback .
their initial masses range from 9 to 300 solar masses ( @xmath30 ) .
stars having 6 - 8 @xmath30 develop an o - ne - mg core while those with @xmath32 @xmath30 possess an iron core before collapse .
hypernovae are asymmetric stellar explosions with high ejecta velocities , they are very bright , producing a large amount of nickel . they are often associated with long - duration gamma - ray - bursts .
collapsars are all massive stars whose core collapse to a black hole and that have sufficient angular momentum to form a disk ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
[ fig:2 ] on 23 february 1987 sk -@xmath33 exploded producing sn1987a , the first naked - eye supernova since kepler s one in 1604 .
it was located in the large magellanic cloud , a satellite galaxy of the milky way .
the determined distance is 50 kpc from the earth based on the expanding photosphere method from different groups which agree within 10 @xmath12 ( see table i of @xcite ) .
this method to establish extragalactic distances allows to cover a wide range , from 50 kpc to 200 mpc . from the observed light - curve and simulations
it appears that the core mass of sn1987a progenitor was around 6 @xmath30 and total mass @xmath34 18 @xmath30 and the progenitor radius about @xmath35 cm @xcite .
sn1987a is unique because it was observed in all wavelengths from gamma rays to radio , and for the first time , neutrinos were observed from the collapse of the stellar core .
the neutrinos was first discovered by kamiokande ii @xcite , then by imb @xcite and baksan @xcite .
the number of detected electron anti - neutrinos events were 16 in kamiokande ii , 8 in imb and 5 in baksan .
time , energy , sn - angle and background rate for all the events is given in table i of the recent review @xcite .
several hours before 5 events were seen in lsd detector that could be due to a speculative emission phase preceding the ones seen in the other detectors @xcite .
such events are often discarded in the analysis of sn1987a data since their are object of debate .
the earliest observations of optical brightening were recorded 3 hours after neutrino s arrival .
an enthusiastic description of sn1987a discovery is reported in @xcite .
three puzzling features concerning sn1987a has set constraints on stellar evolutionary models and supernova simulations .
the progenitor was a blue supergiant rather than a red supergiant while type ii supernovae were thought to be produced by red supergiants .
large - mixing processes had transported radioactive nuclei from the deep core far into the h envelope of the progenitor and in the pre supernova ejecta , producing anomalous chemical abundances .
the presence of three ring - like geometry of the circumstellar nebula around the supernova ( figure [ fig : sn1987 ] ) was implying a highly non - spherical structure of the progenitor envelope and its winds @xcite .
various explanations have been suggested for the presence of these rings , the inner one being dated 20000 years before the explosion .
they might have originated by a binary merger event of that epoch @xcite showing that rotation might have played a significant role in the dying star .
however the prolate deformation of the supernova ejecta at the center of the ring system might have a very different origin ( figure [ fig : sn1987 ] ) .
in fact , the presence of large - mixing and the asymmetric ejecta indicates breaking of spherical symmetry due to hydrodynamical instabilities such as the bipolar standing accretion shock instability ( sasi ) @xcite .
sn1987a remnant is likely not a black hole since the progenitor was light enough to be stabilised by nuclear equation - of - states consistent with measured neutron star masses @xcite .
there is currently no sign as well of a bright pulsar as the one born from the supernova explosion in the crab nebula in 1054 .
sn1987a neutrino observations have been used to derive constraints on fundamental physics and the properties of neutrinos , axions , majorons , light supersymmetric particles and on unparticles .
these are derived by the absence of non - standard signatures , by using the intrinsic neutrino signal dispersion or by the cooling time of the newborn neutron star .
many such limits have been superseded by direct measurements with controlled sources on earth , while other remain valuable constraints .
for example , from the three hours delay in the transit time of neutrinos and photons a tight limit can be on the difference between the speed of neutrinos @xmath36 and light @xmath37 is obtained , i.e. @xmath38 @xcite . sn1987a neutrinos have also confirmed the basic features of core - collapse supernova predictions concerning the neutrino fluence ( time - integrated flux ) and spectra . from a comparative analysis of the observed neutrino events one gets as a best fit point @xmath39 erg and @xmath40 mev for the total gravitational energy radiated in electron anti - neutrinos and their temperature respectively @xcite .
accoding to expectations , 99 @xmath12 of the supernova gravitational binding energy should be converted in @xmath41 neutrinos ( and anti - neutrinos ) in the several tens of mev energy range .
such neutrinos are produced by pair annihilation , electron capture and neutron bremstrahlung @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 .
if one considers that energy equipartition among the neutrino flavors is rather well satisfied , one gets about @xmath47 ergs and the emission time is also found to be of @xmath48 s. considering that the neutrino spectra are to a fairly good approximation thermal , one gets for the average electron anti - neutrino energy @xmath49 giving 12 mev at the best fit point .
this appears currently more compatible with supernova simulations based on realistic neutrino transport , although it has appeared much lower than the expected value of @xmath48 mev claimed for a long time .
supernova neutrinos are tightly connected with two major questions in astrophysics , namely what is the mechanism that makes massive stars explode and what is ( are ) the site(s ) where the heavy elements are formed through the so - called rapid neutron capture process ( or @xmath50-process ) .
neutrinos would contribute in neutrino - driven winds in core - collapse supernovae , accretion - disks around black holes and neutron - star mergers .
in fact , the interaction of electron neutrinos and anti - neutrinos with neutrons and protons in such environments determines the neutron - to - proton ratio , a key parameter of the r - process .
obviously astrophysical conditions and the properties of exotic nuclei ( like masses , @xmath51-decay half - lives or fission ) are crucial in determining the abundances .
several studies have shown that neutrinos impact the neutron richness of a given astrophysical environment . finally assessing their influence
still requires extensive simulations ( see the reviews in the focus issue @xcite ) .
various mechanisms for the sn blast are investigated , including a thermonuclear , a bounce - shock , a neutrino - heating , a magnetohydrodynamic , an acoustic and a phase - transition mechanisms ( see @xcite ) .
since the kinetic energy in sn events goes from @xmath52 erg for sne up to several @xmath53 erg for hypernovae , the explosion driving mechanism have to comply , among others , with providing such energies .
the neutrino - heating mechanism with non - radial hydrodynamical instabilities ( convective overturn with sasi ) appear to be a good candidate to drive iron - core collapse supernova explosions ; while the more energetic hypernovae events could be driven by the magnetohydrodynamical mechanism .
note that a new neutrino - hydrodynamical instability termed lesa ( lepton - number emission self - sustained asymmetry ) has been identified @xcite .
simulations of the lighter o - ne - mg core - collapse supernovae do explode , while this is not yet the case for iron - core collapse ones .
successful explosions for two - dimensional simulations with realistic neutrino transport have been obtained for several progenitors ; while the first three - dimensional explosion are being obtained @xcite .
neutrino propagation in cosmological or astrophysical environments is often described using effective ( iso)spins , neutrino amplitudes , the density matrix approach , the path - integral formalism or many - body green s functions ( see @xcite and @xcite for a review ) .
note that the spin formalism gives a geometrical representation of neutrino evolution in flavor space . here
we briefly describe how to derive neutrino evolution equations useful for astrophysical applications based on the mean - field approximation . to this aim
we use the density matrix formalism and follow the derivation in ref.@xcite . in the mass basis , at each time the spatial fourier decomposition of a dirac neutrino field reads @xmath54 with @xmath55 where we note @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
the dirac spinors corresponding to mass eigenstates @xmath58 are normalized as ( no sum over @xmath58 ) @xmath59 the standard particle and antiparticle annihilation operators ( in the heisenberg picture ) for neutrinos of mass @xmath60 , momentum @xmath61 and helicity @xmath62 satisfy the canonical equal - time anticommutation relations .
@xmath63 @xmath64 and similarly for the anti - particle operators . in the flavor basis ,
the field operator is obtained as @xmath65 with @xmath66 the maki - nakagawa - sakata - pontecorvo unitary matrix @xcite .
note that the indices can refer to active as well as to sterile neutrinos . in the framework of three active neutrinos the
three mixing angles of @xmath66 are now determined .
two are almost maximal , while the third one is small @xcite .
the dirac and majorana cp violating phases are still unknown @xcite .
the flavor evolution of a neutrino , or of an antineutrino , in a background can be determined using one - body density matrices , namely expectation values of bilinear products of creation and annihilation operators @xmath67 @xmath68 where the brackets denote quantum and statistical average over the medium through which neutrino are propagating . for particles without mixings ,
only diagonal elements are necessary and relations ( [ e : rho]-[e : arho ] ) correspond to the expectation values of the number operators . if particles have mixings as is the case for neutrinos , the off - diagonal contributions ( @xmath69 ) of @xmath70 and @xmath71 account for the coherence among the mass eigenstates .
the mean - field equations employed so far to investigate flavor evolution in astrophysical environments evolve the particle and anti - particle correlators @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
however , the most general mean - field description includes further correlators .
first , densities with `` wrong '' helicity states , such as @xmath72 are present .
these have already been shown to impact neutrino evolution in presence of magnetic fields @xcite .
they also give non - zero contributions if non - zero mass corrections are included @xcite .
moreover two - point correlators called abnormal or pairing densities @xcite @xmath73 and the hermitian conjugate also exist .
equations of motion including them have first been derived in ref.@xcite .
if neutrinos are majorana particles , correlators similar to ( [ e : kappa ] ) can be defined , as done in ref . @xcite , such as @xmath74 or @xmath75 that violate total lepton number .
the most general mean - field evolution equations for dirac or majorana neutrinos evolving in an inhomogeneous medium is derived in ref.@xcite .
the effective most general mean - field hamiltonian takes the general bilinear form ( @xmath76 ) @xmath77 where @xmath78 denotes the @xmath58-th component of the neutrino field in the mass basis eq.([e : field ] ) .
the explicit expression of the kernel @xmath79 depends on the kind of interaction considered ( charged- or neutral - current interactions , non - standard interactions , effective coupling to magnetic fields , etc ... ) . it does not need to be specified to obtain the general structure of the equations , but for practical applications .
equations of motion for the neutrino density matrix eqs.([e : rho]-[e : arho ] ) can be obtained from the ehrenfest theorem : @xmath80 \rangle\ ] ] and similarly for the other correlators .
spinor products can be introduced @xmath81 @xmath82 @xmath83 @xmath84 where the fourier transform of the mean - field in eqs.([e : g1]-[e : g4 ] ) is defined as @xmath85 important progress has been achieved in our understanding of how neutrinos change their flavor in massive stars , a case which is much more complex than the one of our sun . the msw effect in supernovae is well established .
since the star is very dense the msw resonance condition can be fulfilled three times for typical supernova density profiles @xcite . at high density
the @xmath101 resonance depending on @xmath102 takes place but does not produce any spectral modification . at lower densities two further resonances can occur that depend on @xmath103 and @xmath104 , usually termed as the high resonance and the low resonances .
the sign of the neutrino mass - squared differences determines if neutrinos or anti - neutrinos undergo a resonant conversion .
the sign of @xmath105 produces a low resonance in the neutrino sector .
the one of @xmath106 keeps unknown ( the hierarchy problem ) .
the adiabaticity of the evolution at the resonances depends also on the neutrino energy and on the gradient of the matter density which is fulfilled for typical power laws that accord with simulations @xcite .
recent calculations have shown the emergence of new phenomena due to the neutrino - neutrino interaction , the presence of shock waves and of turbulence ( see @xcite for a review ) .
steep changes of the stellar density profile due to shock waves induce multiple msw resonances and interference phenomena among the matter eigenstates . as a consequence
the neutrino evolution can become completely non - adiabatic when the shock passes through the msw region .
as for the neutrino self - interaction it can produce collective stable and unstable modes of the ( anti-)neutrino gas and a swapping of the neutrino fluxes with spectral changes .
various models have been studied to investigate the impact of the self - interactions on the neutrino spectra and the occurrence of collective instabilities that trigger flavour modifications in the star .
the first model , so called `` bulb '' model , was assuming that the spherical and azymuthal symmetries for neutrino propagation from the neutrino sphere , homogeneity and stationarity . within this model three flavor conversion regimes are present and well understood ( the synchronisation , the bipolar oscillations and the spectral split ) .
for example the spectral split phenomenon is an msw - effect in a comoving frame @xcite , or analogous to a magnetic - resonance phenomenon @xcite ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
the interplay between matter and neutrino self - interaction effects needs to be accurately considered .
in fact matter can decohere the collective neutrino modes since neutrinos with different emission angles ( in the so - called `` multiangle simulations '' ) at the neutrinosphere have different flavor histories @xcite .
it appears as for now that simulations based on realistic density profiles from supernova one - dimensional simulations suppress neutrino self - interaction effects .
however this is no longer true if non - stationarity and inhomogeneity is considered : small scale seed perturbations can create large scale instabilities @xcite .
one should keep in mind that the solution of the full dynamical problem should involve the seven dimensions @xmath107 . to make the problem
numerically computable the models involve various approximations .
these are usually non - stationarity , homogeneity , the spherical and/or azymuthal symmetries .
however , it has been shown that even if initial conditions have some symmetry , the solutions of the evolution equations does not necessarily retain it @xcite . to avoid the demanding solution of the equations , often the instabilities are determined by employing a linearised stability analysis @xcite ( see e.g. @xcite ) . such analysis
are useful to identify the location of the instability , while they do not inform of the spectral modifications .
the neutrino spectral swapping turned out to be significant in the context of the `` bulb '' model while they could well reveal minor modifications in simulations including non - stationarity , inhomogeneities and a realistic description of the neutrino sphere ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
for the latter , ref.@xcite has in fact shown that fast conversions can occur very close to the neutrino sphere , even if mixings are not taken into account .
many general features are established , but important questions remain in particular on the conditions for the occurrence of flavor modifications and its impact on the neutrino spectra .
another open question is the role of corrections beyond the usual mean - field in the transition region .
this is between the dense region within the neutrinosphere which is boltzmann treated , to the diluted one outside the neutrinosphere where collective flavor conversion occurs .
so far , this transition has been treated as a sharp boundary where the neutrino fluxes and spectra obtained in supernova simulations is used as initial conditions in flavour studies .
extended descriptions describing neutrino evolution in a dense medium have recently been derived using a coherent - state path integral @xcite , the born - bogoliubov - green - kirkwood - yvon hierarchy @xcite , or the two - particle - irreducible effective action formalism @xcite ( see also @xcite ) . besides collisions ,
two kinds of corrections in an extended mean - field description are identified : spin or helicity coherence @xcite and neutrino - antineutrino pairing correlations @xcite .
such corrections are expected to be tiny , but the non - linearity of the equations could introduce significant changes of neutrino evolution in particular in the transition region .
numerical calculations are needed to investigate the role of spin coherence or neutrino - antineutrino pairing correlations or of collisions .
a first calculation in a simplified model shows that helicity coherence might have an impact @xcite .
neutrino flavor conversion also occurs in accretion disks around black holes @xcite and binary compact objects such as black hole - neutrons star and neutron star - neutron star mergers @xcite . in particular ,
flavour modification can be triggered by a cancellation of the neutrino matter and self - interaction contributions in these scenarios .
this produces a resonant phenomenon called the neutrino - matter resonance @xcite .
another interesting theoretical development is the establishment of connections between neutrino flavor conversion in massive stars and the dynamics , or behaviour , of many - body systems in other domains . using algebraic methods
, ref.@xcite has shown that the neutrino - neutrino interaction hamiltonian can be rewritten as a ( reduced ) bardeen - cooper - schrieffer ( bcs ) hamiltonian for superconductivty @xcite .
as mentioned above , ref.@xcite has included neutrino - antineutrino correlations of the pairing type which are formally analogous to the bcs correlations .
the linearisation of the corresponding neutrino evolution equations has highlighted the formal link between stable and unstable collective neutrino modes and those in atomic nuclei and metallic clusters @xcite .
the observation of the neutrino luminosity curve from a future ( extra)galactic explosion would closely follow the different phases of the explosion furnishing a crucial test of supernova simulation predictions , and information on the star and unknown neutrino properties . in particular , the occurrence of the msw effect in the outer layer of the star and collective effects depends on the value of the third neutrino mixing angle and the neutrino mass ordering .
the precise measurement of the last mixing angle @xcite reduces the number of unknowns .
still , the neutrino signal from a future supernova explosion could tell us about the mass ordering , either from the early time signal in icecube @xcite , or by measuring the positron time and energy signal , in cherenkov or scintillator detectors , associated with the passage of the shock wave in the msw region @xcite .
several other properties can impact the neutrino fluxes such as the neutrino magnetic moment @xcite , non - standard interactions , sterile neutrinos .
cp violation effects from the dirac phase exist but appear to be small @xcite .
in spite of the range of predictions , the combination of future observations from detection channels with different flavor sensitivities , energy threshold and time measurements can pin down degenerate solutions and bring key information to this domain ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
the supernova early warning system ( snews ) and numerous other neutrino detectors around the world can serve as supernova neutrino observatories if a supernova blows up in the milky way , or outside our galaxy .
large scale detectors based on different technologies @xcite including liquid argon , water cherenkov and scintillator are being considered .
upcoming observatories are the large scale scintillator detector juno @xcite and hopefully the water cherenkov hyper - kamiokande @xcite .
these have the potential to detect neutrinos from a galactic and an extragalactic explosion as well as to discover the diffuse supernova neutrino background produced from supernova explosions up to cosmological redshift of 2 .
the latter could be observed by egads , i.e. the super - kamiokande detector with the addition of gadolinium @xcite ( for a review see @xcite ) .
the main mission of high - energy neutrino telescopes is to search for galactic and extra - galactic sources of high - energy neutrinos to elucidate the source of cosmic rays and the astrophysical mechanisms that produce them .
these telescopes also investigate neutrino oscillations , dark matter and supernova neutrinos ( for icecube ) .
the 37 events collected in icecube , with deposited energies ranging from 30 to 2 pev , is consistent with the discovery of high energy astrophysical neutrinos at 5.7 @xmath108 @xcite .
the 2 pev event is the highest - energy neutrino ever observed .
high - energy neutrino telescopes are currently also providing data on neutrino oscillations measuring atmospheric neutrinos , commonly a background for astrophysical neutrino searches . using low energy samples , both antares
@xcite and icecube / deepcore @xcite have measured the parameters @xmath109 and @xmath110 in good agreement with existing data .
orca @xcite and pingu @xcite , icecube extension in the 10 gev energy range , could measure the mass hierarchy by exploiting the occurrence of the matter effect from neutrinos , both from the msw and the parametric resonance occurring in the earth @xcite .
neutrino telescopes are also sensitive to other fundamental properties such as lorentz and cpt violation @xcite , or sterile neutrinos .
9 m. g. aartsen _ et al . _ , _ observation of high - energy astrophysical neutrinos in three years of icecube data , phys .
* 113 * ( 2014 ) 101101 [ arxiv:1405.5303 ] .
b. pontecorvo , _ mesonium and anti - mesonium , sov .
jetp _ * 6 * ( 1957 ) 429 [ _ zh .
fiz . _ * 33 * ( 1957 ) 549 ] .
y. fukuda _ et al .
_ , _ evidence for oscillation of atmospheric neutrinos , phys .
* 81 * ( 1998 ) 1562 [ hep - ex/9807003 ] .
z. maki , m. nakagawa , and s. sakata , _ remarks on the unified model of elementary particles , prog .
_ * 28 * ( 1962 ) 870 .
k. a. olive _ et al . _
[ particle data group collaboration ] , _ `` review of particle physics , '' chin .
c _ * 38 * ( 2014 ) 090001 .
l. wolfenstein , _ neutrino oscillations in matter , phys .
d _ * 17 * ( 1978 ) 2369 .
s. p. mikheev and a. y. smirnov , _ resonance amplification of oscillations in matter and spectroscopy of solar neutrinos , sov .
j. nucl .
* 42 * ( 1985 ) 913 [ yad .
fiz . * 42 * , 1441 ( 1985 ) ] .
k. eguchi et al . , _ `` first results from kamland : evidence for reactor anti - neutrino disappearance , '' phys
. rev .
lett . _ * * 90 * * , 021802 ( 2003 ) .
w. c. haxton , r. g. hamish robertson and a. m. serenelli , _ solar neutrinos : status and prospects , ann .
astrophys . _ * 51 * ( 2013 ) 21 [ arxiv:1208.5723 ] .
g. mention et al . , _
`` the reactor antineutrino anomaly , '' phys .
d _ * 83 * , 073006 ( 2011 ) .
r. davis , jr .
, d. s. harmer and k. c. hoffman , _ search for neutrinos from the sun , phys .
lett . _ * 20 * ( 1968 ) 1205
. j. n. bahcall , n. a. bahcall and g. shaviv , _ present status of the theoretical predictions for the cl-36 solar neutrino experiment , phys .
_ * 20 * ( 1968 ) 1209 .
a. friedland , c. lunardini and c. pena - garay , _ solar neutrinos as probes of neutrino matter interactions , phys . lett .
b _ * 594 * ( 2004 ) 347 [ hep - ph/0402266 ] .
g. bellini _ et al .
_ , _ first evidence of pep solar neutrinos by direct detection in borexino , phys .
* 108 * ( 2012 ) 051302 [ arxiv:1110.3230 ] . c. arpesella
_ , _ direct measurement of the be-7 solar neutrino flux with 192 days of borexino data , phys .
lett . _ * 101 * ( 2008 ) 091302 [ arxiv:0805.3843 ] .
g. bellini _ et al .
_ , _ neutrinos from the primary proton - proton fusion process in the sun , nature _ * 512 * , no . 7515 ( 2014 )
383 .
b. p. schmidt , r. p. kirshnerm and r. g. eastman , _ `` expanding photospheres of type ii supernovae and the extragalactic distance scale .
, '' astrophys .
j. _ * 395 * , 366 ( 1992 ) [ astro - ph/9204004 ] .
p. podsiadlowski , _ `` the progenitor of sn1987a '' , astronomical society of the pacific _ * 104 * , 717 ( 1992 ) . k. hirata _ et al . _ [ kamiokande - ii collaboration ] , _ `` observation of a neutrino burst from the supernova sn 1987a , '' phys . rev .
lett . _ * 58 * , 1490 ( 1987 ) .
r. m. bionta , g. blewitt , c. b. bratton , d. casper , a. ciocio , r. claus , b. cortez and m. crouch _ et al .
_ , _ `` observation of a neutrino burst in coincidence with supernova sn 1987a in the large magellanic cloud , '' phys . rev
. lett . _ * 58 * , 1494 ( 1987 ) . e. n. alekseev , l. n. alekseeva , i. v. krivosheina and v. i. volchenko ,
_ `` detection of the neutrino signal from sn1987a in the lmc using the inr baksan underground scintillation telescope , '' phys .
b _ * 205 * , 209 ( 1988 ) .
m. aglietta , g. badino , g. bologna , c. castagnoli , a. castellina , w. fulgione , p. galeotti and o. saavedra _ et al .
_ , _ `` on the event observed in the mont blanc underground neutrino observatory during the occurrence of supernova 1987a , '' europhys .
_ * 3 * , 1315 ( 1987 ) .
a. suzuki , _ the 20th anniversary of sn1987a , j. phys .
* 120 * ( 2008 ) 072001 .
p. podsiadlowski , t. s. morris and n. ivanova , _ the progenitor of sn 1987a , " aip conf .
proc . _ * 937 * , 125 ( 2007 ) .
janka , a. marek and f .- s .
kitaura , _
`` neutrino - driven explosions twenty years after sn1987a , '' aip conf .
proc . _ * 937 * , 144 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0706.3056 ] .
k. sato and h. suzuki , _
`` total energy of neutrino burst from the supernova sn1987a and the mass of neutron star just born , '' phys . lett .
b _ * 196 * , 267 ( 1987 ) .
m. j. longo , _ tests of relativity from sn1987a , phys
. rev .
d _ * 36 * ( 1987 ) 3276 .
i. tamborra _ et al .
_ , _ self - sustained asymmetry of lepton - number emission : a new phenomenon during the supernova shock - accretion phase in three dimensions , astrophys .
j. _ * 792 * ( 2014 ) 96 [ arxiv:1402.5418 ] .
janka , t. melson and a. summa , _
`` physics of core - collapse supernovae in three dimensions : a sneak preview , '' _ arxiv:1602.05576 .
j. serreau and c. volpe , _ `` neutrino - antineutrino correlations in dense anisotropic media , '' phys . rev .
d _ * 90 * , no .
12 , 125040 ( 2014 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.90.125040 [ arxiv:1409.3591 ] .
a. e. lobanov and a. i. studenikin , _
`` neutrino oscillations in moving and polarized matter under the influence of electromagnetic fields , '' phys .
b _ * 515 * , 94 ( 2001 ) doi:10.1016/s0370 - 2693(01)00858 - 9 [ hep - ph/0106101 ] .
a. banerjee , a. dighe and g. raffelt , _
`` linearized flavor - stability analysis of dense neutrino streams , '' phys .
d _ * 84 * , 053013 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1107.2308 ] .
d. vnnen and c. volpe , _ `` linearizing neutrino evolution equations including neutrino - antineutrino pairing correlations , '' phys . rev . d _ * 88 * , 065003 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1306.6372 [ hep - ph ] ] .
s. chakraborty , r. s. hansen , i. izaguirre and g. raffelt , _
`` self - induced flavor conversion of supernova neutrinos on small scales , '' jcap _ * 1601 * , no . 01 , 028 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1507.07569 ] .
h. duan , g. m. fuller and y. z. qian , _ collective neutrino oscillations , ann .
nucl . part .
* 60 * ( 2010 ) 569 [ arxiv:1001.2799 ] .
h. duan and j. p. kneller , _ neutrino flavor transformation in supernovae , j. phys .
g _ * 36 * ( 2009 ) 113201 [ arxiv:0904.0974 ] .
g. g. raffelt and a. y. smirnov , _ adiabaticity and spectral splits in collective neutrino transformations , phys .
d _ * 76 * ( 2007 ) 125008 [ arxiv:0709.4641 ] .
s. galais and c. volpe , _ the neutrino spectral split in core - collapse supernovae : a magnetic resonance phenomenon , phys .
d _ * 84 * ( 2011 ) 085005 [ arxiv:1103.5302 ] .
a. esteban - pretel , a. mirizzi , s. pastor , r. tomas , g. g. raffelt , p.
d. serpico and g. sigl , _
`` role of dense matter in collective supernova neutrino transformations , '' phys .
d _ * 78 * , 085012 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0807.0659 ] .
f. capozzi , b. dasgupta and a. mirizzi , _ `` self - induced temporal instability from a neutrino antenna , '' jcap _ * 1604 * , no . 04 , 043 ( 2016 ) doi:10.1088/1475 - 7516/2016/04/043 [ arxiv:1603.03288 ] .
g. raffelt , s. sarikas and d. de sousa seixas , _ `` axial symmetry breaking in self - induced flavor conversionof supernova neutrino fluxes , '' phys .
_ * 111 * , no .
9 , 091101 ( 2013 ) erratum : [ phys .
lett . * 113 * , no .
23 , 239903 ( 2014 ) ] [ arxiv:1305.7140 ] .
a. malkus , j. p. kneller , g. c. mclaughlin and r. surman , _ `` neutrino oscillations above black hole accretion disks : disks with electron - flavor emission , '' phys
. rev .
d _ * 86 * , 085015 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1207.6648 .
y. l. zhu , a. perego and g. c. mclaughlin ,
_ `` matter neutrino resonance transitions above a neutron star merger remnant , '' _
m. frensel , m. r. wu , c. volpe and a. perego , _ `` neutrino flavor evolution in binary neutron star merger remnants , '' _ arxiv:1607.05938 .
y. abe _ et al .
_ , _ indication for the disappearance of reactor electron antineutrinos in the double chooz experiment , phys . rev
. lett . _
* 108 * ( 2012 ) 131801 [ arxiv:1112.6353 ] .
f. p. an _ et al .
_ , _ observation of electron - antineutrino disappearance at daya bay , phys . rev
. lett . _
* 108 * ( 2012 ) 171803 [ arxiv:1203.1669 ] .
j. k. ahn _
_ , _ observation of reactor electron antineutrino disappearance in the reno experiment , phys .
* 108 * ( 2012 ) 191802 [ arxiv:1204.0626 ] .
a. b. balantekin , j. gava and c. volpe , _ possible cp - violation effects in core - collapse supernovae , phys .
b _ * 662 * , 396 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0710.3112 ] .
j. gava and c. volpe , _ collective neutrinos oscillation in matter and cp - violation , phys .
d _ * 78 * , 083007 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0807.3418 ] . j. p. kneller and g. c. mclaughlin , _ three flavor neutrino oscillations in matter : flavor diagonal potentials , the adiabatic basis and the cp phase , phys .
d _ * 80 * , 053002 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.3823 ] .
y. pehlivan , a. b. balantekin and t. kajino , _ neutrino magnetic moment , cp violation and flavor oscillations in matter , phys .
d _ * 90 * , 065011 ( 214 ) [ arxiv:1406.5489 ] .
d. vnnen and c. volpe , _ the neutrino signal at halo : learning about the primary supernova neutrino fluxes and neutrino properties , jcap _ * 1110 * ( 2011 ) 019 [ arxiv:1105.6225 ] .
k. scholberg , _ supernova neutrino detection , ann .
nucl . part .
* 62 * ( 2012 ) 81 [ arxiv:1205.6003 ] .
f. an _ et al . _ [ juno collaboration ] , _ `` neutrino physics with juno , '' j. phys .
g _ * 43 * , 030401 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1507.05613 [ physics.ins-det ] ] . | we summarize the progress in neutrino astrophysics and emphasize open issues in our understanding of neutrino flavor conversion in media .
we discuss solar neutrinos , core - collapse supernova neutrinos and conclude with ultra - high energy neutrinos . |
social media has evolved from friendship based networks to become a major source for the consumption of news ( nist , 2008 ) . on social media
, news is decentralised as it provides everyone the means to efficiently report and spread information .
in contrast to traditional news wire , information on social media is spread without intensive investigation , fact and background checking .
the combination of ease and fast pace of sharing information provides a fertile breeding ground for rumours , false- and disinformation .
social media users tend to share controversial information in - order to verify it , while asking about for the opinions of their followers ( zhao et .
al , 2015 ) .
this further amplifies the pace of a rumour s spread and reach .
rumours and deliberate disinformation have already caused panic and influenced public opinion .
+ the cases in germany and austria in 2016 , show how misleading and false information about crimes committed by refugees negatively influenced the opinion of citizens .
+ detecting these rumours allows debunking them to prevent them from further spreading and causing harm .
the further a rumour has spread , the more likely it is to be debunked by users or traditional media ( liu et .
al , 2015 ) . however , by then rumours might have already caused harm .
this highlights the importance and necessity of recognizing rumours as early as possible - preferably instantaneously .
+ rumour detection on social media is challenging due to the short texts , creative lexical variations and high volume of the streams .
the task becomes even harder if we attempt to perform rumour detection on - the - fly , without looking into the future .
we provide an effective and highly scalable approach to detect rumours instantly after they were posted with zero delay .
we introduce a new features category called novelty based features .
novelty based features compensate the absence of repeated information by consulting additional data sources - news wire articles .
we hypothesize that information not confirmed by official news is an indication of rumours .
additionally we introduce pseudo feedback for classification . in a nutshell , documents that are similar to previously detected rumours are considered to be more likely to also be a rumour .
the proposed features can be computed in constant time and space allowing us to process high - volume streams in real - time ( muthukrishnan , 2005 ) .
our experiments reveal that novelty based features and pseudo feedback significantly increases detection performance for early rumour detection .
+ the contributions of this paper include : + * novelty based features * + we introduced a new category of features for instant rumour detection that harnesses trusted resources .
unconfirmed ( novel ) information with respect to trusted resources is considered as an indication of rumours .
+ * pseudo feedback for detection / classification * + pseudo feedback increases detection accuracy by harnessing repeated signals , without the need of retrospective operation . before rumour detection
, scientists already studied the related problem of information credibility evaluation ( castillo et .
; richardson et .
al , 2003 ) .
recently , automated rumour detection on social media evolved into a popular research field which also relies on assessing the credibility of messages and their sources .
the most successful methods proposed focus on classification harnessing lexical , user - centric , propagation - based ( wu et .
al , 2015 ) and cluster - based ( cai et .
al , 2014 ; liu et . al , 2015 ; zhao et . al , 2015 ) features .
+ many of these context based features originate from a study by castillo et .
al ( 2011 ) , which pioneered in engineering features for credibility assessment on twitter ( liu et .
al , 2015 ) .
they observed a significant correlation between the trustworthiness of a tweet with context - based characteristics including hashtags , punctuation characters and sentiment polarity .
when assessing the credibility of a tweet , they also assessed the source of its information by constructing features based on provided urls as well as user based features like the activeness of the user and social graph based features like the frequency of re - tweets .
a comprehensive study by castillo et .
al ( 2011 ) of information credibility assessment widely influenced recent research on rumour detection , whose main focuses lies upon improving detection quality .
+ while studying the trustworthiness of tweets during crises , mendoza et .
al ( 2010 ) found that the topology of a distrustful tweet s propagation pattern differs from those of news and normal tweets .
these findings along with the fact that rumours tend to more likely be questioned by responses than news paved the way for future research examining propagation graphs and clustering methods ( cai et .
al , 2014 ; zhao et .
al , 2015 ) .
the majority of current research focuses on improving the accuracy of classifiers through new features based on clustering ( cai et .
al , 2014 ; zhao et .
al , 2015 ) , sentiment analysis ( qazvinian et . al , 2011 ; wu et .
al , 2015 ) as well as propagation graphs ( kwon , et .
al , 2013 ; wang et .
al , 2015 ) .
+ recent research mainly focuses on further improving the quality of rumour detection while neglecting the increasing delay between the publication and detection of a rumour .
the motivation for rumour detection lies in debunking them to prevent them from spreading and causing harm .
unfortunately , state - of - the - art systems operate in a retrospective manner , meaning they detect rumours long after they have spread .
the most accurate systems rely on features based on propagation graphs and clustering techniques .
these features can only detect rumours after the rumours have spread and already caused harm .
+ therefore , researchers like liu et .
al ( 2015 ) , wu et .
al ( 2015 ) , zhao et .
al ( 2015 ) and zhou et . al ( 2015 ) focus on early rumour - detection while allowing a delay up to 24 hours .
their focus on latency aware rumour detection makes their approaches conceptually related to ours .
al ( 1015 ) found clustering tweets containing enquiry patterns as an indication of rumours .
also clustering tweets by keywords and subsequently judging rumours using an ensemble model that combine user , propagation and content - based features proved to be effective ( zhou et .
al , 2015 ) .
although the computation of their features is efficient , the need for repeated mentions in the form of response by other users results in increased latency between publication and detection .
the approach with the lowest latency banks on the wisdom of the crowd ( liu et .
al , 2015 ) .
in addition to traditional context and user based features they also rely on clustering micro - blogs by their topicality to identify conflicting claims , which indicate increased likelihood of rumours .
although they claim to operate in real - time , they require a cluster of at least 5 messages to detect a rumour .
+ + in contrast , we introduce new features to detect rumours as early as possible - preferably instantly , allowing them to be debunked before they spread and cause harm .
rumour detection is a challenging task , as it requires determining the truth of information ( zhao et .
al , 2015 ) . the cambridge dictionary , defines a rumour as information of doubtful or unconfirmed truth .
we rely on classification using an svm , which is the state - of - the - art approach for novelty detection .
numerous features have been proposed for rumour detection on social media , many of which originate from an original study on information credibility by castillo et .
al ( 2011 ) .
unfortunately , the currently most successful features rely on information based on graph propagation and clustering , which can only be computed retrospectively .
this renders them close to useless when detecting rumours early on .
we introduce two new classes of features , one based on novelty , the other on pseudo feedback . both feature categories improve detection accuracy early on , when information is limited .
we frame the real - time rumour detection task as a classification problem that assesses a document s likelihood of becoming a future rumour at the time of its publication .
consequently , prediction takes place in real - time with a single pass over the data .
+ + more formally , we denote by @xmath0 the document that arrives from stream @xmath1 at time @xmath2 . upon arrival of document @xmath0 we compute its corresponding feature vector @xmath3 . given @xmath3 and the previously obtained weigh vector @xmath4 we compute the rumour score @xmath5 .
the rumour prediction is based on a fixed thresholding strategy with respect to @xmath6 .
we predict that message @xmath0 is likely to become a rumour if its rumour score exceeds the detection threshold @xmath7 .
the optimal parameter setting for weight vector @xmath4 and detection threshold @xmath6 are learned on a test to maximise prediction accuracy . to increase instantaneous detection performance , we compensate for the absence of future information by consulting additional data sources . in particular
, we make use of news wire articles , which are considered to be of high credibility .
this is reasonable as according to petrovic et .
al ( 2013 ) , in the majority of cases , news wires lead social media for reporting news .
when a message arrives from a social media stream , we build features based on its novelty with respect to the confirmed information in the trusted sources . in a nutshell ,
the presence of information unconfirmed by the official media is construed as an indication of being a rumour .
note that this closely resembles the definition of what a rumour is .
high volume streams demand highly efficient feature computation .
this applies in particular to novelty based features since they can be computationally expensive .
we explore two approaches to novelty computation : one based on vector proximity , the other on kterm hashing .
+ computing novelty based on traditional vector proximity alone does not yield adequate performance due to the length discrepancy between news wire articles and social media messages . to make vector proximity applicable
, we slide a term - level based window , whose length resembles the average social media message length , through each of the news articles .
this results in sub - documents whose length resembles those of social media messages .
novelty is computed using term weighted tf - idf dot products between the social media message and all news sub - documents .
the inverse of the minimum similarity to the nearest neighbour equates to the degree of novelty .
+ the second approach to compute novelty relies on kterm hashing ( wurzer et .
al , 2015 ) , a recent advance in novelty detection that improved the efficiency by an order of magnitude without sacrificing effectiveness .
kterm hashing computes novelty non - comparatively . instead of measuring similarity between documents , a single representation of previously seen information is constructed . for each document , all possible kterms are formed and hashed onto a bloom filter .
novelty is computed by the fraction of unseen kterms .
kterm hashing has the interesting characteristic of forming a collective memory , able to span all trusted resources .
we exhaustively form kterm for all news articles and store their corresponding hash positions in a bloom filter .
this filter then captures the combined information of all trusted resources .
a single representation allows computing novelty with a single step , instead of comparing each social media message individually with all trusted resources .
+ + when kterm hashing was introduced by wurzer et .
al ( 2015 ) for novelty detection on english tweets , they weighted all kterm uniformly .
we found that treating all kterms as equally important , does not unlock the full potential of kterm hashing .
therefore , we additionally extract the top 10 keywords ranked by @xmath8 and build a separate set of kterms solely based on them .
this allows us to compute a dedicated weight for kterms based on these top 10 keywords .
the distinction in weights between kterms based on all versus keyword yields superior rumour detection quality , as described in section [ section_featureanalysis ] .
this leaves us with a total of 6 novelty based features for kterm hashing - kterms of length 1 to 3 for all words and keywords .
+ + apart from novelty based features , we also apply a range of 51 context based features .
the full list of features can be found in table [ tab : allfeatures ] .
the focus lies on features that can be computed instantly based only on the text of a message to keep the latency of our approach to a minimum .
most of these 51 features overlap with previous studies ( castillo et .
al , 2011 ; liu et .
al , 2015 ; qazvinian et .
al , 2011 ; yang et .
al , 2012 ; zhao et .
al , 2015 ) .
this includes features based on the presence or number of urls , hash - tags and user - names , pos tags , punctuation characters as well as 8 different categories of sentiment and emotions .
+ + on the arrival of a new message from a stream , all its features are computed and linearly combined using weights obtained from an svm classifier , yielding the rumour score
. we then judge rumours based on an optimal threshold strategy for the rumour score .
in addition to novelty based features we introduce another category of features - dubbed pseudo - feedback ( pf ) feature - to boost detection performance . the feature is conceptually related to pseudo relevance feedback found in retrieval and ranking tasks in ir .
the concept builds upon the idea that documents , which reveal similar characteristics as previously detected rumours are also likely to be a rumour . during detection , feedback about which of the previous documents describes a rumour is not available .
therefore , we rely on pseudo feedback and consider all documents whose rumour score exceeds a threshold as true rumours
. + the pf feature describes the maximum similarity between a new document and those documents previously considered as rumour .
similarities are measured by vector proximity in term space .
conceptually , pf passes on evidence to repeated signals by increasing the rumour score of future documents if they are similar to a recently detected rumour .
note that this allows harnessing information from repeated signals without the need of operating retrospectively . + + * training pseudo feedback features * + the trainings routine differs from the standard procedure , because the computation of the pf feature requires two training rounds as we require a model of all other features to identify pseudo rumours .
in a first training round a svm is used to compute weights for all features in the trainings set , except the pf features .
this provides a model for all but the pf features .
then the trainings set is processed to computing rumour scores based on the model obtained from our initial trainings round .
this time , we additionally compute the pf feature value by measuring the minimum distance in term space between the current document vector and those previous documents , whose rumour score exceeds a previously defined threshold .
since we operate on a stream , the number of documents previously considered as rumours grows without bound . to keep operation constant in time and space ,
we only compare against the k most recent documents considered to be rumours .
once we obtained the value for the pf feature , we compute its weight using the svm .
the combination of the weight for the pf feature with the weights for all other features , obtained in the initial trainings round , resembles the final model . [ cols="^,<",options="header " , ] previous approaches to rumour detection rely on repeated signals to form propagation graphs or clustering methods . beside causing a detection delay these methods
are also blind to less popular rumours that do nt go viral .
in contrast , novelty based feature require only a single message enabling them to detect even the smallest rumours .
examples for such small rumours are shown in table [ tab_rumourlist ] . to demonstrate the high efficiency of computing novelty and pseudo feedback features
, we implement a rumour detection system and measure its throughput when applied to 100k weibos .
we implement our system in c and run it using a single core on a 2.2ghz intel core i7 - 4702hq .
we measure the throughput on an idle machine and average the observed performance over 5 runs .
figure [ fig : throughput ] presents performance when processing more and more weibos .
the average throughput of our system is around 7,000 weibos per second , which clearly exceeds the average volume of the full twitter ( 5,700 tweets / sec . ) and sina weibo ( 1,200 weibos / sec . )
since the number of news articles is relatively small , we find no difference in terms of efficiency between computing novelty features based on kterm hashing and vector similarity .
figure [ fig : throughput ] also illustrates that our proposed features can be computed in constant time with respect to the number of messages processed .
this is crucial to keep operation in a true streaming environment feasible .
approaches , whose runtime depend on the number of documents processed become progressively slower , which is inapplicable when operating on data streams .
our experiments show that the proposed features perform effectively and their efficiency allows them to detect rumours instantly after their publication .
we introduced two new categories of features which significantly improve instantaneous rumour detection performance .
novelty based features consider the increased presence of unconfirmed information within a message with respect to trusted sources as an indication of being a rumour .
pseudo feedback features consider messages that are similar to previously detected rumours as more likely to also be a rumour .
pseudo feedback and its variant , recursive pseudo feedback , allow harnessing repeated signals without the need of operating retrospectively .
our evaluation showed that novelty and pseudo feedback based features perform significantly more effective than other real - time and early detection baselines , when detecting rumours instantly after their publication .
this advantage vanishes when allowing an increased detection delay .
we also showed that the proposed features can be computed efficiently enough to operate on the average twitter and sina weibo stream while keeping time and space requirements constant .
+ + + + + plainnat.bst james allan , victor lavrenko and hubert jin .
first story detection in tdt is hard . in proceedings of the ninth international conference on information and knowledge management .
acm , 2000 james allan .
topic detection and tracking : event - based information organization .
kluwer academic publishers , norwell , 2002 g. cai , h. wu , r. lv , rumours detection in chinese via crowd responses , asonam 2014 , beijing , china , 2014 castillo c , mendoza m , poblete b. information credibility on twitter[c ] , the 20th international conference on world wide web , hyderabad , india , 2011 s. kwon , m. cha , k. jung , w. chen and y. wang , `` prominent features of rumor propagation in online social media '' , data mining ( icdm ) , ieee , 2013 x. liu , a. nourbakhsh , q. li , r. fang , and s. shah , real - time rumor debunking on twitter , in proceedings of the 24th acm international conference on information and knowledge management .
acm , 2015 m. mendoza , poblete b , castillo c , twitter under crisis : can we trust what we rt ?
, the 1st workshop on social media analytics , soma , 2010 s. muthukrishnan .
data streams : algorithms and applications .
now publishers inc , 2005 s. petrovic , m. osborne , r. mccreadie , c. macdonald , i. ounis , and l. shrimpton .
can twitter replace newswire for breaking news ? in proc .
of icwsm , 2013 v. qazvinian , e. rosengren , d. r. radev , q. mei , rumour has it : identifying misinformation in microblogs , emnlp , july 27 - 31 , 2011 , edinburgh , uk , 2011 richardson m , agrawal r , domingos p , trust management for the semantic web ; lecture notes in computer science , 2003 : 351 - 368 .
fensel d , sycara k , mylopoulos j , the semantic web - iswc 2003 , heidelberg : springer berlinheidelberg , 2003 s. sun , h. liu , j. he , x , du , detecting event rumours on sina weibo automatically , apweb 2013 tdt by nist - 1998 - 2004 . http://www.itl.nist.gov/iad/mig/tests/tdt/resources.html ( last update : 2008 ) k. wu , s. yang , k. zhu , false rumours detection on sina weibo by propagation structures , in the proceedings of icde , 2015 shihan wang , takao terano , detecting rumour patterns in streaming social media , guimi , ieee , 2015 dominik wurzer , victor lavrenko , miles osborne .
tracking unbounded topic streams . in the proceedings of the 53rd annual meeting of the association for computational linguistics , acl , 2015 dominik wurzer , victor lavrenko , miles osborne .
twitter - scale new event detection via k - term hashing . in the proceedings of the conference on empirical methods in natural language processing , emnlp , 2015 fan yang , xiaohui yu , yang liu , min yang ( 2012 ) automatic detection of rumor on sina weibo .
august 12 , 2012 z. zhao , p. resnick , and q. mei enquiring minds : early detection of rumors in social media from enquiry posts . in the proceedings of www , 2015 x. zhou , j. cao , z. jin , x. fei , y. su , j. zhang , d. chu , and x cao .
realtime news certification system on sina weibo . | rumour detection is hard because the most accurate systems operate retrospectively , only recognising rumours once they have collected repeated signals .
by then the rumours might have already spread and caused harm .
we introduce a new category of features based on novelty , tailored to detect rumours early on . to compensate for the absence of repeated signals , we make use of news wire as an additional data source . unconfirmed ( novel ) information with respect to the news articles is considered as an indication of rumours .
additionally we introduce pseudo feedback , which assumes that documents that are similar to previous rumours , are more likely to also be a rumour . comparison with other real - time approaches shows that novelty based features in conjunction with pseudo feedback perform significantly better , when detecting rumours instantly after their publication . |
recent development in the cooling and trapping technique of atoms and the following success in achieving the bose - einstein condensation of alkali atoms@xcite have now opened up a new era in the progress in quantum physics .
while the condensed system serves as a testing ground for a research in fundamental problems of quantum mechanics , it also offers a new example of finite quantum many - body systems such as hadrons , nuclei and microclusters .
an important characteristic of the trapped alkali atoms is that it is a dilute system of weakly interacting particles and an ideal place to test genuine properties of condensed systems predicted by theories .
along with a further progress in the study of bose - einstein condensed systems , a similar technique is being extended to create a degenerate gas of fermionic atoms , where a number of theoretical studies have been made@xcite .
to realize such a degenerate fermionic system that requires a still lower temperature than bose systems , the technique of sympathetic cooling has been investigated@xcite : the cooling mechanism through the collisions with coexisting cold bose particles in a polarized boson - fermion mixture , where the fermion - fermion interaction is less effective .
the mixture of bose and fermi particles is itself an interesting system for a study : the hydrogen - deuterium system has been studied already at the early stage of these investigations@xcite .
recently , theoretical studies have been made for the trapped boson - fermion system of alkali atoms and proposed many interesting properties : the exotic density configurations through the repulsive or attractive boson - fermion interactions @xcite , the decaying processes after the removal of the confining trap @xcite , and the metastability of the @xmath1li-@xmath2li mixture @xcite . in this paper , we study static properties of a mixed bose - fermi system of trapped potassium atoms , where one fermionic ( @xmath3k ) and two bosonic isotopes ( @xmath4k and @xmath5k ) are known as candidates for a realization of such a degenerate quantum system .
trapping of the fermionic isotope @xmath3k has already been reported@xcite .
these isotopes are also of an interest since the boson - fermion interaction may be repulsive or attractive depending on their choice@xcite .
below we first describe a set of equations for the mixed system at @xmath6 , where the bosonic part is given by a gross - pitaevskii ( gp ) equation and including boson - fermion interaction , and the fermionic part is by the thomas - fermi ( tf ) equation .
the use of the gp equation allows one to study a system with a net attractive potential for bosons where the thomas - fermi - type ( tf ) approximation is not applicable .
the applicability of these equations for the trapped potassium system was discussed in @xcite . in sec .
iii , we discuss qualitative properties of solutions from the gp and tf equations analytically ; especially , their dependence on the boson / fermion number is estimated . in ref .
@xcite , general features of solution including a deformed system is discussed in the repulsive boson - fermion interaction . on the other hand , to study more realistic system , we concentrate on the specific systems of potassium isotopes , i.e.,@xmath4k-@xmath3k system and @xmath5k-@xmath3k system using empirically derived atomic interactions .
we also consider the effect of changing parameters of the trapped potential .
finally , we mention the possibility of trapping fermions only through the attractive interactions by the trapped bose particles .
we consider a spin - polarized system of bosons and fermions at @xmath6 described by a hamiltonian @xmath7 : @xmath8 where @xmath9 and @xmath10 respectively denote boson and fermion field operators with masses @xmath11 and @xmath12 . because of diluteness
, the particle interactions have been approximated by the @xmath13-wave - dominated contact potential @xmath14 .
the strengths of the coupling constants @xmath15 ( boson - boson ) and @xmath16 ( boson - fermion ) are given by @xmath17 where @xmath18 and @xmath19 are the @xmath13-wave scattering lengths for the boson - boson and boson - fermion scatterings and @xmath20 is a reduced mass .
the fermion - fermion interaction has been neglected because of diluteness and particle polarization .
the chemical potentials @xmath21 and @xmath22 in ( [ eqha ] ) and ( [ eqhb ] ) are determined from the condensed boson / fermion numbers @xmath23 and @xmath24 through the ground state expectation values : @xmath25 in the mean - field approximation at @xmath6 , the bosons occupy the lowest single - particle state @xmath26 , and the energy of the system is just given by a replacement of field operator @xmath9 in the hamiltonian with its expectation value : @xmath27 that describes the order parameter of the bose - einstein condensate .
( we here neglect quantities of the order @xmath28 . ) in this approximation , the boson density @xmath29 is given by @xmath30 . in the same approximation ,
the fermion wave function is given by a slater determinant ; the single - particle states are determined , e.g. , by the hartree - fock self - consistent equation . in the present approximation of neglecting fermion - fermion interactions
, we only have to solve for the single particle states under the effective potential for fermions : the trapping potential and the boson - fermion interaction . in the actual calculation
, we however adopt a semiclassical ( tf ) description for fermion density , which is known to provide a good approximation as far as the number of atoms is sufficiently large@xcite .
we thus obtain a set of equations for @xmath31 and @xmath32 @xcite : @xmath33 \phi(\vec{r } ) = \mu_b \phi(\vec{r } ) , \label{gpeq}\\ % & & \frac{\hbar^2}{2 m_f } [ 6 \pi^2 n_f(\vec{r})]^{2/3 } + \frac{1}{2 } m_f \omega_f^2 r^2 + h\ , n_b(\vec{r } ) = \mu_f , \label{fermieq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the boson and fermion densities are defined by @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
before the study of numerical results for ( [ gpeq ] ) and ( [ fermieq ] ) , we discuss about their solutions qualitatively .
\i ) _ radius of the boson / fermion distribution _
if we neglect the boson - fermion interaction , we would obtain a much broader distribution for fermions as compared with that for bosons because of the exclusion principle . to see this
, we consider a free boson / fermion system trapped in a harmonic oscillator potential .
the mean square radius of each system is obtained from the virial theorem : @xmath36 where the harmonic - oscillator lengths @xmath37 are @xmath38 and @xmath39 are the total boson / fermion numbers .
the @xmath40 in ( [ eqd ] ) is the number of fermions in the last occupied shell that is obtained as a solution of @xmath41 .
the ratio of the root - mean - square ( rms ) radii @xmath42 thus increases as the power @xmath43 when @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
in fact , for a repulsive boson - boson interaction , the boson distribution become broader than that for a free system just discussed , but this effect does not change the qualitative structure as shown in sec .
v. on the other hand , the strong boson - fermion interaction may give qualitative changes of the density profiles such as the phase separation and the fermion collapse as shown in @xcite .
we also discussed about them from different points of view in iii ) in this section .
ii)_scaled gp and tf equations and changes of the density distribution for the different @xmath39 _ for qualitative estimations of the density distribution
, we should use the scaled dimensionless variables @xcite : @xmath46 where @xmath39 , @xmath37 are the total boson / fermion numbers and the harmonic - oscillator lengths defined in eqs .
( [ eqh ] ) and ( [ eqc ] ) . using these scaled variables , the gp and tf equations in eqs .
( [ gpeq ] ) and ( [ fermieq ] ) become @xmath47 \tilde{\varphi_b}(\vec{x } ) = \tilde{\mu}_b \tilde{\varphi_b}(\vec{x } ) \label{scgpeq}\\ % & & \frac{1}{r_m } [ 6 \pi^2 n_{f } \rho_f(\vec{x})]^{\frac{2}{3 } } + r_m r_\omega^2 x^2 + \tilde{h}\ , n_b\ , \rho_b(\vec{x } ) = \tilde{\mu}_f , \label{scfermieq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath48 and @xmath49 . the scaled coupling constants @xmath50 and @xmath51 in eqs .
( [ scgpeq ] ) and ( [ scfermieq ] ) are defined by @xmath52 where eq .
( [ eqe ] ) has been used to obtain the @xmath53-representations , and the last factor comes from @xmath54 . from eqs .
( [ scgpeq ] ) and ( [ scfermieq ] ) , we should notice that the scaled equations include six independent parameters , ( @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath24 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 ) ; for two systems where these parameters take the same values , their physical properties become similar under the scaling relations ( [ eqb ] ) . here , based on eqs .
( [ scgpeq ] ) and ( [ scfermieq ] ) , we discuss about changes of the density distribution by the scaled parameters . in this subsection
, we assume @xmath60 and the large particle numbers @xmath61 ; for the effect of @xmath62 , the discussion will be given in sec .
v. let us consider the fermion tf equation ( [ scfermieq ] ) , first .
for the chemical potential @xmath63 , we use the result in the system without boson - fermion interaction : @xmath64 . it should be a good approximation when @xmath65 . using it in eq .
( [ scgpeq ] ) , we obtain @xmath66 at the central region ( @xmath67 ) . on the other hand ,
the boson equation ( [ scgpeq ] ) gives @xmath68 under the tf approximation valid in @xmath69 .
using these estimates , we can obtain the ratio @xmath0 of the boson - boson / boson - fermion interaction effects in the gp equation ( [ scgpeq ] ) : @xmath70 the small @xmath0 ( @xmath71 ) indicates the small contribution from the boson - fermion interaction for the boson part , and we obtain @xmath72 .
however , when @xmath73 , the boson - fermion interaction is not negligible , and the boson density profile can be quite different from that in non - interacting case ( @xmath74 ) . in @xmath4k-@xmath3k system discussed in sec .
v , the scaled parameters are @xmath75 in @xmath76 , @xmath55 and @xmath56 are in the same order , but @xmath24 is a factor of 2 larger than @xmath56 ,
so eq . ( [ eqi ] ) gives @xmath77 .
it explains the rather small change of the boson density profile @xmath72 in @xmath4k-@xmath3k system , as shown in the numerical results in sec .
v. it is very interesting to apply the above estimation for the results by @xcite and compare them with the results in this paper .
one of the parameter set with which the boson density profiles changed drastically is @xmath78 where @xmath79 has been taken and the qualitative changes of the boson density profile have been seen @xmath80 @xcite .
it should be noticed that the parameters in ( [ eqf ] ) are in the same order when @xmath81 , and it means @xmath82 in that case .
for this reason , the boson density profile changed drastically from that of @xmath83 with these parameters . to check the relation between the boson profile change and the ratio @xmath0 in eq .
( [ eqi ] ) a little more , we solved eqs .
( [ scgpeq ] ) and ( [ scfermieq ] ) numerically for a ) @xmath84 and b ) @xmath85 with other parameters fixed as in ( [ eqf ] ) , and , for @xmath86 , two values were taken @xmath87 .
the resultant boson densities are shown in fig . 1
: @xmath88 has very different profile from @xmath89 in case a ) , but the very small change is found between them in case b ) .
those results shows the clear relation between @xmath0 and the boson density profile . in summary ,
the parameter regions exist where the boson density profile changes very large or not , and these regions are discriminated by the value of @xmath0 .
we should comment that the results in this paper are complementary with those with ( [ eqf ] ) in @xcite in the scale of the ratio @xmath0 .
\iii ) _ boson - fermion interaction effects for the fermion distribution function _
we next consider the effect of the boson - fermion interaction on the fermion distribution , especially the phase separation phenomena in the strongly repulsive boson - fermion interaction case , which has been proposed in @xcite . here
we assume the tf approximation for bosons ( neglecting the kinetic term in eq.([fermieq ] ) ) .
as discussed in the literature @xcite , the effective potential for fermions receives an additional repulsive or attractive contribution from bosons within the range @xmath90 depending on the sign of the interaction . for a strongly repulsive boson - fermion interaction ( @xmath91 ) , the fermion will be squeezed out from the center , so that the two kind of particles tend to make a separate phase @xcite . here
we give analytical estimation for this interesting phenomena .
as shown in @xcite , in the phase - separated system , the fermion are almost completely pushed away outside the boson distribution , so that the critical ratio @xmath92 for the phase separation can be estimated from the vanishing fermion density at the center @xmath93 . neglecting the boson - fermion interaction in the boson tf equation , we obtain @xmath94 where @xmath95 . in fig . 2 ,
the function @xmath96 in ( [ eqa ] ) is plotted when @xmath97 with the parameters used in @xcite : ( @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 , @xmath102 , @xmath103 ) = ( @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath105 , @xmath107 , @xmath107 ) @xcite . from the crossing point of @xmath108 and @xmath97 (
dashed line ) in fig . 2 ,
the critical point can be read off : @xmath109 , which is almost consistent with the result given in @xcite ( @xmath110 ) . for an attractive interaction ( @xmath111 ) , fermions tend to concentrate and increase the overlap with bosons .
thus we may expect a coherence of the two kinds of particles to occur in this case . for large attraction , another interesting phenomena ,
fermion collapse in mixture has been proposed @xcite .
in the numerical calculation , we solved the set of equations ( [ gpeq ] ) and ( [ fermieq ] ) by reducing them into the following equation for the order parameter : @xmath112 f(t)=0 , \label{numeric}\ ] ] where @xmath113 and the scaled parameters @xmath114 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath115 have been defined in ( [ eqb ] ) . the function @xmath116 is related to the order parameter by @xmath117 .
the boundary conditions for @xmath118 are given by the value at @xmath119 and by the asymptotic condition @xmath120 .
we first give initial values for @xmath121 and @xmath22 and solved the equation ( [ numeric ] ) numerically by means of the relaxation method .
finally , the fermion density @xmath122 is obtained from eq.([fermieq ] ) .
the details of the calculation will be given elsewhere@xcite .
we consider the potassium atoms where there exist two bosonic ( @xmath4k , @xmath5k ) and one fermionic ( @xmath3k ) isotopes .
the precise values of the interatomic interaction are not known , but the recent estimate from molecular scattering@xcite suggest a repulsive interaction between @xmath4k and @xmath3k , and an attractive one between @xmath5k and @xmath3k , although the values still have rather large ambiguities .
we take up the following values for the @xmath13-wave scattering lengths @xcite : @xmath123 , @xmath124 , @xmath125 , @xmath126 .
we take the atomic masses to be the same for all the isotopes : @xmath127 .
the angular frequency @xmath128 of the bosonic external potential is fixed at @xmath129 , while @xmath130 is allowed to vary . in this case , it is corresponding to @xmath131 , @xmath132 for @xmath4k-@xmath3k system and @xmath133 , @xmath134 for @xmath5k-@xmath3k system .
first , we consider the @xmath4k-@xmath3k system where the boson - fermion interaction is repulsive . in this case , because of @xmath135 , phase separation do not occur .
3 shows the density - distribution functions of bosons ( a ) and fermions ( b ) for @xmath136 , @xmath137 and @xmath138 .
the dashed line shows the result for @xmath139 ( @xmath83 ) as compared with the solid line for @xmath140 ( @xmath141 ) . as seen from the figure , the fermions have a much broader distribution than bosons even for a much less number of particles . that has been discussed in sec .
iii - i ) .
the boson - fermion interaction is seen to squeeze out the fermions leading to a fermion - density depletion at the center , while its effect on the boson distribution is negligible .
this also can be seen in table i where some observables are listed for the two cases @xmath142=(1000,1000 ) and ( 10000,1000 ) with / without the boson - fermion interaction .
the robust structure of the boson distribution just mentioned is reflected in the almost constant values of the rms radius and other observables for the bosonic part of the mixed condensate against the switching on / off of the boson - fermion interaction . to understand this robustness , we apply the estimation in sec .
iii - ii ) : the ( 1000,1000 ) system just corresponds to the parameters of eq .
( [ eqj ] ) , so the @xmath0 in ( [ eqi ] ) becomes @xmath77 . for ( 10000,1000 )
case , the scaled parameters are ( @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 ) = ( @xmath143 , @xmath144 , @xmath145 , @xmath146 ) , and the ratio @xmath147 in eq .
( [ eqi ] ) gives additional factor @xmath148 , so we obtain @xmath149 .
it shows that ( 10000,1000 ) system is more robust than ( 1000,1000 ) case . it is supported in ref .
@xcite that the tf approximation yields qualitative correct result . using the method in @xcite , we can also verify that the correction for the tf approximation is small for 1000 fermion case .
we next turn to the @xmath5k-@xmath3k system where the boson - fermion interaction is attractive .
because of the large value of the strength , one may expect a sizable effect of the boson - fermion interaction for this system .
moreover , the strong boson - boson interaction makes a stronger overlap of bosons and fermions and thus the attractive interaction are more efficient .
so the system might be expected to be unstable against collapse . if the effect of the boson - fermion interaction is too strong
. actually , @xmath142=(1000,1000 ) and ( 10000,1000 ) , we obtained a distribution as given in fig . 4 and table ii .
the effect of the attraction on the fermions is larger than the @xmath4k-@xmath3k system , although it is not strong enough to cause an appreciable change in the boson distribution .
the stability condition for the fermion collapse can be derived from the scaling law in refs .
@xcite : @xmath150 in the present case , we obtain @xmath151 and @xmath152 , so that the stability condition ( [ eqm ] ) is well satisfied , and we have found the parameters of @xmath5k-@xmath3k system is in ( quasi ) stable region . is the bosonic distribution always robust against a mixture of fermions ? aside from the possibility of changing the interaction strength via feshbach resonances@xcite , we have a possibility of enhancing the boson - fermion interaction effect using the different confining potential for bosons and fermions separately ( i.e. @xmath153 ) . fig . 5 shows the boson / fermion distribution for ( a ) @xmath4k-@xmath3k ( @xmath154 ) and ( b ) @xmath5k-@xmath3k ( @xmath155 ) : @xmath156 , @xmath157 . for a large value of the ratio @xmath158 , the fermions are trapped in a strong confining potential and thus have a large overlap with bosons ; the boson distribution ( solid lines ) is sensitive to the value of @xmath59 even though the bosonic parameters are fixed .
this may be traced back to a rather large fraction of the boson - fermion interaction energy in the total boson energies : for the @xmath5k-@xmath3k system at @xmath159 , for instance , the ratio of the boson - fermion interaction energy to the total boson energy becomes @xmath160 @xcite , while it is less than 1 per cent to the total fermion energy .
the change of the boson - density distribution can be estimated from the ratio @xmath0 in ( [ eqi ] ) . when @xmath62 , it becomes @xmath161 so that the boson - density distribution become more sensitive for large values of @xmath59 .
the effect of the boson - fermion interaction on fermions may show up in the opposite extreme , i.e. , for vanishing @xmath59 . in this case
, the fermions can keep themselves from escape only through the attractive boson - fermion interaction .
this possibility can be estimated from the chemical potential : when fermions are trapped by bosons , the @xmath22 should take the negative value . taking the tf approximation for the bosonic part ( @xmath162 , @xmath163 ) and setting @xmath164 for the fermionic part
, we obtain the total fermion number represented by @xmath22 : @xmath165 when @xmath166 in ( [ eqk ] ) , we obtain the maximum number for the boson - trapped fermions : @xmath167 where we used the parameters of @xmath5k-@xmath3k system to obtain the last term . from eq .
( [ eql ] ) , estimations can be obtained for the boson - trapped fermion number : for @xmath136 , only 18 fermions are bound , while for @xmath168 more than 4000 fermions will be trapped within the bose condensate .
this qualitative estimate is verified also in the numerical calculation for @xmath136 , although one should actually take the shell effect into account for such a small number of fermions@xcite .
in the present paper , we studied static properties of a mixed system of bosons ( @xmath4k or @xmath5k ) and fermions ( @xmath3k ) in the trapping potential at temperature zero .
we solved a coupled gp and tf equations for a different combination of boson and fermion particle numbers and also for a repulsive or an attractive interaction of bosons and fermions depending on the combination of potassium isotopes .
the analytical estimations have been done generally for the rms radii of the boson / fermion distribution , the parameter - dependence of their profile and the phase separation , and we have found the feasible conditions for them .
these analytical estimations have been applied to the numerical results for the potassium system and also compared with the discussion done in @xcite : consequently , the consistency was checked for these estimations . for similar particle numbers and external potential parameters , the fermions have a much more extended distribution and larger energies than bosons because of the exclusion principle .
we studied the effect of the boson - fermion interaction on the density distribution of both kinds of particles . for a repulsive interaction ,
the fermions tend to be pushed out , but the effect is not very large for the parameters of @xmath5k-@xmath3k system adopted in the present paper . in the case of the attractive interaction ,
a coherence of @xmath5k and @xmath3k occurs and is strongly enhanced if the trapping potential is adjusted so as to make them overlap .
it was shown also that the fermions could be kept trapped without external potential due only to an attractive interaction with trapped bose particles .
one may as well consider the opposite case where the bosons are trapped only via an attractive interaction with surrounding trapped fermi particles .
this will be discussed in a future publication@xcite .
m. h. anderson et al . , science * 269 * , 198 ( 1995 ) ; k. b. davis et al . , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 3969 ( 1995 ) ; c. c. bradley et al .
lett . * 75 * , 1687 ( 1995 ) .
k. burnett , contemp . phys . * 37 * , 1 ( 1996 ) ; m. lewenstein and l. you , adv . atom .
phys . , * 36 * , 221 ( 1996 ) ; a. s. parkins and h. d. f. walls , phys .
reports * 303 * , 1 ( 1998 ) .
f. dalfovo , s. giorgini , l. p. pitaevskii and s. stringari rev .
phys.*71 * , 463 ( 1999 ) .
j. schneider and h. wallis , phys .
rev.*a57 * , 1253 ( 1997 ) ; d. a. butts and d. s. rokhsar , phys .
rev.*a55 * , 4346 ( 1997 ) ; g. m. bruun and k. burnett , phys . rev . *
a58 * , 2427 ( 1998 ) . c. j. myatt et al .
lett . * 78 * , 586(1997 ) ; d. s. hall et al .
* 81 * , 1539 ( 1998 ) ; w. geist , l. you and t. a. b. kennedy , phys . rev .
* a59 * , 1500 ( 1999 ) . i. f. silvera ; physica * 109 & 110 * , 1499 ( 1982 ) ; j. oliva ; phys . rev . * b38 * , 8811 ( 1988 ) .
k. mlmer , phys .
. lett . * 80 * , 3419 ( 1998 ) .
n. nygaard and k. mlmer , phys . rev .
* a59 * , 2974 ( 1999 ) . m. amoruso et al , eur .
j. * d4 * , 261 ( 1998 ) ; l. vichi , et al . , j. phys . * b31 * , l899 ( 1998 ) .
m. amoruso , c. minniti and m. p. tosi , to be published in eur . phys . j. * d*. r. s. williamson iii and t. walker , j. opt .
. am . * b12 * , 1394 ( 1995 ) ; f. s. cataliotti , et al . ,
phys . rev . * a57 * , 1136 ( 1998 ) .
h. m. j. m. boesten , et al .
, phys . rev .
* a54 * , r3726 ( 1996 ) .
r. cot et al .
* a57 * , r4118 ( 1998 ) . in @xcite , @xmath169 was used , where the phase separation was found in @xmath170 .
t. miyakawa et al . , in preparation .
p. ring and p. shuck , _ the nuclear many - body problem _
( springer - verlag , 1980 ) .
e. tiesinga et al . , phys .
rev.*a46 * , r1167 ( 1992 ) ; ibid.*a47 * , 4114(1993 ) . the kinetic ( @xmath171 ) , external potential ( @xmath172 ) , boson - boson ( @xmath173 ) and boson - fermion ( @xmath174 ) interaction energies per particle are @xmath175 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 , and @xmath178 , respectively , in th unit of @xmath179 . .
results for the @xmath4k-@xmath3k system with ( @xmath180 ) and without ( @xmath139 ) the boson - fermion interaction for @xmath156 and @xmath181 .
contributions to the equilibrium energy ( measured in the unit of @xmath182 ) per particle , the central density @xmath183 ( @xmath184 ) and the rms radii are given for each of the constituent isotopes .
other parameters are fixed as @xmath185 , @xmath186 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] | static properties of a bose - fermi mixture of trapped potassium atoms are studied in terms of coupled gross - pitaevskii and thomas - fermi equations for both repulsive and attractive bose - fermi interatomic potentials .
qualitative estimates are given for solutions of the coupled equations , and the parameter regions are obtained analytically for the boson - density profile change and for the boson / fermion phase separation .
especially , the parameter ratio @xmath0 is found that discriminates the region of the large boson - profile change .
these estimates are applied for numerical results for the potassium atoms and checked their consistency .
it is suggested that a small fraction of fermions could be trapped without an external potential for the system with an attractive boson - fermion interaction .
= -5 mm |
the analysis and interpretation of ongoing and future neutrino oscillation experiments strongly rely on the nuclear modeling for describing the interaction of neutrinos and anti - neutrinos with the detector .
moreover , neutrino - nucleus scattering has recently become a matter of debate in connection with the possibility of extracting information on the nucleon axial mass .
specifically , the data on muon neutrino charged - current quasielastic ( ccqe ) cross sections obtained by the miniboone collaboration @xcite are substantially underestimated by the relativistic fermi gas ( rfg ) prediction .
this has been ascribed either to effects in the elementary neutrino - nucleon interaction , or to nuclear effects .
the most poorly known ingredient of the single nucleon cross section is the cutoff parameter @xmath0 employed in the dipole prescription for the axial form factor of the nucleon , which can be extracted from @xmath1 and @xmath2 scattering off hydrogen and deuterium and from charged pion electroproduction .
if @xmath0 is kept as a free parameter in the rfg calculation , a best fit of the miniboone data yields a value of the order of 1.35 gev / c@xmath3 , much larger than the average value @xmath4 gev / c@xmath3 extracted from the ( anti)neutrino world data @xcite .
this should be taken more as an indication of incompleteness of the theoretical description of the data based upon the rfg , rather than as a true indication for a larger axial mass .
indeed it is well - known from comparisons with electron scattering data that the rfg model is too crude to account for the nuclear dynamics .
hence it is crucial to explore more sophisticated nuclear models before drawing conclusions on the value of @xmath0 .
several calculations have been recently performed and applied to neutrino reactions .
these include , besides the approach that will be presented here , models based on nuclear spectral functions @xcite , relativistic independent particle models @xcite , relativistic green function approaches @xcite , models including nn correlations @xcite , coupled - channel transport models @xcite , rpa calculations @xcite and models including multinucleon knock - out @xcite .
the difference between the predictions of the above models can be large due to the different treatment of both initial and final state interactions . as a general trend ,
the models based on impulse approximation , where the neutrino is supposed to scatter off a single nucleon inside the nucleus , tend to underestimate the miniboone data , while a sizable increase of the cross section is obtained when two - particle - two - hole ( 2p-2h ) mechanisms are included in the calculations .
furthermore , a recent calculation performed within the relativistic green function ( rgf ) framework has shown that at this kinematics the results strongly depend on the phenomenological optical potential used to describe the final state interaction between the ejected nucleon and the residual nucleus @xcite . with an appropriate choice of the optical potential
the rgf model can reproduce the miniboone data without the need of modifying the axial mass ( see giusti s contribution to this volume @xcite ) .
the kinematics of the miniboone experiment , where the neutrino flux spans a wide range of energies reaching values as high as 3 gev , demands relativity as an essential ingredient .
this is illustrated in fig . 1 , where the relativistic and non - relativistic fermi gas results for the ccqe double differential cross section of 1 gev muon neutrinos on @xmath5 are shown as a function of the outgoing muon momentum and for two values of the muon scattering angle
. the relativistic effects , which affect both the kinematics and the dynamics of the problem , have been shown to be relevant even at moderate momentum and energy transfers @xcite .
@xmath6ccqe double differential cross sections on @xmath5 displayed versus the outgoing muon momentum for non - relativistic ( nrfg ) and relativistic ( rfg ) fermi gas.,title="fig : " ] @xmath6ccqe double differential cross sections on @xmath5 displayed versus the outgoing muon momentum for non - relativistic ( nrfg ) and relativistic ( rfg ) fermi gas.,title="fig : " ] hence in our approach we try to retain as much as possible the relativistic aspects of the problems .
in spite of its simplicity , the rfg has the merit of incorporating an exact relativistic treatment , fulfilling the fundamental properties of lorentz covariance and gauge invariance .
however , it badly fails to reproduce the electron scattering data , in particular when it is compared with the rosenbluth - separated longitudinal and transverse responses .
comparison with electron scattering data must be a guiding principle in selecting reliable models for neutrino reactions .
a strong constraint in this connection is represented by the `` superscaling '' analysis of the world inclusive @xmath7 data : in refs .
@xcite it has been proved that , for sufficiently large momentum transfers , the reduced cross section ( namely the double differential cross section divided by the appropriate single nucleon factors ) , when represented versus the scaling variable @xmath8 @xcite , is largely independent of the momentum transfer ( first - kind scaling ) and of the nuclear target ( second - kind scaling ) . the simultaneous occurrence of the two kinds of scaling is called susperscaling . moreover , from the experimental longitudinal response a phenomenological quasielastic scaling function has been extracted that shows a clear asymmetry with respect to the quasielastic peak ( qep ) with a long tail extended to positive values of the scaling variable , i.e. , larger energy transfers . on the contrary the rfg model , as well as
most models based on impulse approximation , give a symmetric superscaling function with a maximum value 20 - 30% higher than the data @xcite . in this contribution , after recalling the basic formalism for ccqe reactions and their connection with electron scattering , we shall illustrate two models which provide good agreement with the above properties of electron scattering data : one of them , the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) model , comes from microscopic many - body theory , the other , the superscaling approximation ( susa ) model , is extracted from @xmath7 phenomenology .
we shall then include the contribution of 2p-2h excitations in the susa model and finally compare our results with the miniboone double differential , single differential and total cross sections .
most of the results which will be presented are contained in refs .
@xcite and @xcite .
charged current quasielastic muonic neutrino scattering @xmath9 off nuclei is very closely related to quasielastic inclusive electron scattering @xmath7 .
however two major differences occur between the two processes : 1 . in the former case
the probe interacts with the nucleus via the weak force , in the latter the interaction is ( dominantly ) electromagnetic .
while the weak vector current is related to the electromagnetic one via the cvc theorem , the axial current gives rise to a more complex structure of the cross sections , with new response functions which can not be related to the electromagnetic ones . as a consequence , while in electron scattering the double - differential cross section can be expressed in terms of two response functions , longitudinal and transverse with respect to three - momentum carried by the virtual photon , for the ccqe process it can be written according to a rosenbluth - like decomposition as @xcite @xmath10_{e_\nu } = \sigma_0 \left [ { \hat v}_{l } r_l + { \hat v}_t r_t + { \hat v}_{t^\prime } r_{t^\prime } \right ] , \label{eq : d2s}\ ] ] where @xmath11 and @xmath12 are the muon kinetic energy and scattering angle , @xmath13 is the incident neutrino energy , @xmath14 is the elementary cross section , @xmath15 are kinematic factors and @xmath16 are the nuclear response functions , the indices @xmath17 referring to longitudinal , transverse , transverse - axial , components of the nuclear current , respectively . the expression ( [ eq : d2s ] )
is formally analogous to the inclusive electron scattering case , but : _ i ) _ the `` longitudinal '' response @xmath18 takes contributions from the charge ( 0 ) and longitudinal ( 3 ) components of the nuclear weak current , which , at variance with the electromagnetic case , are not related to each other by current conservation , _ ii ) _ @xmath18 and @xmath19 have both `` vv '' and `` aa '' components ( stemming from the product of two vector or axial currents , respectively ) , _ iii ) _ a new response , @xmath20 , arises from the interference between the axial and vector parts of the weak nuclear current .
+ in fig .
2 we show the separate contributions of the three responses in ( [ eq : d2s ] ) , evaluated in the rfg model for the @xmath5 target nucleus , for two different values of the scattering angle .
it can be seen that in the forward direction the transverse response dominates over the longitudinal and transverse - axial ones , whereas at higher angles the @xmath21-component becomes negligible and the @xmath22 and @xmath23 responses are almost equal .
this cancellation has important consequences on antineutrino - nucleus scattering , where the response @xmath20 has opposite sign .
+ separate contributions of the rfg longitudinal @xmath24 , transverse @xmath25 and axial - vector interference @xmath26 responses to the double differential @xmath6ccqe cross sections displayed versus the muon kinetic energy at two different angles .
the neutrino energy is averaged over the miniboone flux and the axial mass parameter has the standard value .
, title="fig : " ] separate contributions of the rfg longitudinal @xmath24 , transverse @xmath25 and axial - vector interference @xmath26 responses to the double differential @xmath6ccqe cross sections displayed versus the muon kinetic energy at two different angles .
the neutrino energy is averaged over the miniboone flux and the axial mass parameter has the standard value .
, title="fig : " ] 2 . in @xmath7 experiments
the energy of the electron is well - known , and therefore the detection of the outgoing electron univoquely determines the energy and momentum transferred to the nucleus . in neutrino experiments
the neutrino energy is not known , but distributed over a range of values ( for miniboone from 0 to 3 gev with an average value of about 0.8 gev ) .
the cross section must then be evaluated as an average over the experimental flux @xmath27 @xmath28_{e_\nu } \phi(e_\nu ) de_\nu \ , \label{eq : fluxint}\ ] ] which may require to account for effects not included in models devised for quasi - free scattering .
this is , for instance , the situation at the most forward scattering angles , where a significant contribution in the cross section comes from very low - lying excitations in nuclei @xcite , as illustrated in fig . 3 : here
the double differential cross section is evaluated in the susa model ( see later ) at the miniboone kinematics and the lowest angular bin and compared with the result obtained by excluding the energy transfers lower than 50 mev from the flux - integral ( [ eq : fluxint ] ) .
+ ( color online ) solid lines ( red online ) : flux - integrated @xmath6ccqe cross sections on @xmath5 calculated in the susa model for a specific bin of scattering angle . dashed lines ( green online ) : a lower cut @xmath29 mev is set in the integral over the neutrino flux . ]
+ it appears that at these angles 30 - 40% of the cross section corresponds to very low energy transfers , where collective effects dominate .
moreover , processes involving meson exchange currents ( mec ) , which can excite both one - particle - one - hole ( 1p1h ) and two - particle - two - hole ( 2p-2h ) states via the exchange of a virtual meson , should also be taken into account , since they lead to final states where no pions are present , classified as `` quasielastic '' in the miniboone experiment .
in this section we briefly outline the main ingredients of the rmf and susa model and we illustrate our calculation of the contribution of 2p-2h meson exchange currents . in the rmf model a fully relativistic description of both the kinematics and the dynamics of the process is incorporated .
details on the rmf model applied to inclusive qe electron and ccqe neutrino reactions can be found in refs .
@xcite . here
we simply recall that the weak response functions are given by taking the appropriate components of the weak hadronic tensor , constructed from the single - nucleon current matrix elements @xmath30 where @xmath31 and @xmath32 are relativistic bound - state and scattering wave functions , respectively , and @xmath33 is the relativistic one - body current operator modeling the coupling between the virtual @xmath34-boson and a nucleon .
the bound nucleon states are described as self - consistent dirac - hartree solutions , derived by using a lagrangian containing @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 mesons @xcite .
the outgoing nucleon wave function is computed by using the same relativistic mean field ( scalar and vector energy - independent potentials ) employed in the initial state and incorporates the final state interactions ( fsi ) between the ejected proton and the residual nucleus .
the rmf model successfully reproduces the scaling behaviour of inclusive qe @xmath7 processes and , more importantly , it gives rise to a superscaling function with a significant asymmetry , namely , in complete accord with data @xcite .
this is a peculiar property associated to the consistent treatment of initial and final state interactions .
it has been shown in refs .
@xcite that other versions of the rmf model , which deal with the fsi through a real relativistic optical potential , are not capable of reproducing the asymmetry of the scaling function .
moreover , contrary to most other models based on impulse approximation , where scaling of the zeroth kind - namely the equality of the longitudinal and transverse scaling functions - occurs , the rmf model provides @xmath21 and @xmath23 scaling functions which differ by typically @xmath38 , the t one being larger .
this agrees with the analysis @xcite of the existing @xmath39 separated data , which has shown that , after removing inelastic contributions and two - particle - emission effects , the purely nucleonic transverse scaling function is significantly larger than the longitudinal one .
the susa model is based on the phenomenological superscaling function extracted from the world data on quasielastic electron scattering @xcite .
the model has been extended to the @xmath40-resonance region in ref .
@xcite and to neutral current scattering in ref .
@xcite , but here we restrict our attention to the quasielastic charged current case . assuming the scaling function @xmath41 extracted from @xmath7 data to be universal , i.e. , valid for electromagnetic and weak interactions , in @xcite ccqe neutrino - nucleus cross sections have been evaluated by multiplying @xmath41 by the corresponding elementary weak cross section .
thus in the susa approach all the nuclear responses in ( [ eq : d2s ] ) are expressed as follows @xmath42 where @xmath43 are the elementary lepton - nucleon responses , @xmath44 and @xmath45 are the fermi energy and momentum , @xmath46 is the number of nucleons ( neutrons in the @xmath6ccqe case ) and @xmath47 in the universal superscaling function , depending only on the scaling variable @xmath8 @xcite .
the susa approach provides nuclear - model - independent neutrino - nucleus cross sections and reproduces the longitudinal electron data by construction . however , its reliability rests on some basic assumptions .
first , it assumes that the scaling function - extracted from _
@xmath7 data - is appropriate for all of the weak responses involved in neutrino scattering ( charge - charge , charge - longitudinal , longitudinal - longitudinal , transverse and axial ) , and is independent of the vector or axial nature of the nuclear current entering the hadronic tensor . in particular
it assumes the equality of the longitudinal and transverse scaling functions ( scaling of the zeroth kind ) , which , as mentioned before , has been shown to be violated both by experiment and by some microscopic models , for example relativistic mean field theory .
second , the charged - current neutrino responses are purely isovector , whereas the electromagnetic ones contain both isoscalar and isovector components and the former involve axial - vector as well as vector responses .
one then has to invoke a further kind of scaling , namely the independence of the scaling function of the choice of isospin channel so - called scaling of the third kind .
finally , the susa approach neglects violations of scaling of first and second kinds .
these are known to be important at energies above the qe peak and to reside mainly in the transverse channel , being associated to effects which go beyond the impulse approximation : inelastic scattering , meson - exchange currents and the associated correlations needed to conserve the vector current .
the inclusion of these contributions in the susa model is discussed in the next paragraph .
meson exchange currents are two - body currents carried by a virtual meson which is exchanged between two nucleons in the nucleus .
they are represented by the diagrams in fig .
[ fig : mec ] , where the external lines correspond to the virtual boson ( @xmath48 or @xmath34 ) and the dashed lines to the exchanged meson : in our approach we only consider the pion , which is believed to give the dominant contribution in the quasielastic regime .
the thick lines in diagrams ( d)-(g ) represent the propagation of a @xmath40-resonance .
the explicit relativistic expressions for the current matrix elements can be found , e.g. , in ref .
@xcite . two - body meson - exchange currents .
( a ) and ( b ) : `` contact '' , or `` seagull '' diagram ; ( c ) : `` pion - in - flight '' diagram ; ( d)-(g ) : `` @xmath40-mec '' diagram . ]
being two - body currents , the mec can excite both one - particle one - hole ( 1p-1h ) and two - particle two - hole ( 2p-2h ) states . in the 1p-1h sector
, mec studies of electromagnetic @xmath49 process have been performed for low - to - intermediate momentum transfers ( see , _ e.g. _ , @xcite ) , showing a small reduction of the total response at the quasielastic peak , mainly due to diagrams involving the electroexcitation of the @xmath40 resonance .
however in a perturbative scheme where all the diagrams containing one and only one pionic line are retained , the mec are not the only diagrams arising , but pionic correlation contributions , where the virtual boson is attached to one of the two interacting nucleons , should also be considered .
these are represented by the same diagrams as in fig .
[ fig : mec](d)-(g ) , where now the thick lines are nucleon propagators . only when all the diagrams are taken into account gauge invariance
is fulfilled and the full two - body current is conserved .
correlation diagrams have been shown to roughly compensate the pure mec contribution @xcite , so that in first approximation we can neglect the 1p-1h sector and restrict our attention to 2p-2h final states .
the contribution to the inclusive electron scattering cross section arising from two - nucleon emission via meson exchange current interactions was first calculated in the fermi gas model in refs .
@xcite , where sizable effects were found at large energy transfers . in these references a non - relativistic reduction of the currents was performed , while fully relativistic calculations have been developed more recently in refs .
it has been found that the mec give a significant positive contribution which leads to a partial filling of the `` dip '' between the quasielastic peak and the analogous peak associated with the excitation of the @xmath40 resonance .
moreover , the mec have been shown to break scaling of both first and second kinds @xcite .
here we use the fully relativistic model of @xcite , where all the mec many - body diagrams containing two pionic lines that contribute to the electromagnetic 2p-2h transverse response were taken into account .
similar results for the 2p-2h mec were obtained in ref .
@xcite , where the correlation diagrams were also included . in order to apply the model to neutrino scattering
, we observe that in lowest order the 2p2h sector is not directly reachable for the axial - vector matrix elements .
hence the mec affect only the transverse polar vector response , @xmath50 .
note that , at variance with the 1p-1h sector , where the contribution of the mec diagrams originates from the interference between 1-body and 2-body amplitudes and has therefore no definite sign ( in fact it turns out to be negative due to the dominance of the diagrams involving the @xmath40 ) , the 2p-2h contribution of mec to the nuclear responses is the square of an amplitude , hence it is positive by definition .
therefore the net effect of 2p-2h mec to neutrino scattering is to increase the transverse vector response function , as will be illustrated in the next section .
in this section we present the predictions of the above models and their comparison with the miniboone data .
more results can be found in refs .
@xcite and @xcite . in figs .
[ fig : cos ] and [ fig : tmu ] the flux - integrated double - differential cross section per target nucleon for the @xmath6ccqe process on @xmath51c is evaluated for the three nuclear models above described : the rmf model and the susa approach with and without the contribution of 2p-2h mec . in fig .
[ fig : cos ] the cross sections are displayed versus the muon kinetic energy @xmath11 at fixed scattering energy @xmath12 , in fig .
[ fig : tmu ] they are displayed versus @xmath52 at fixed @xmath11 .
it appears that the susa predictions systematically underestimate the experimental cross section , the discrepancy being larger at high scattering angle and low muon kinetic energy .
the inclusion of 2p-2h mec tends to improve the agreement with the data at low angles , but it is not sufficient to account for the discrepancy at higher angles .
the rmf calculation , which , as already mentioned , incorporates violations of scaling of the zeroth kind with a substantial enhancement of the vector transverse response , yields cross sections which are in general larger than the susa ones . in particular , in the region close to the peak in the cross section , the rmf result becomes larger than the one obtained with susa+mec .
furthermore , the rmf does better than susa in fitting the shape of the experimental curves versus both the scattering angle and the muon energy : this is partly due to the fact that the rmf is better describing the low - energy excitation region whereas the susa model has no predictive power at very low angles , where the cross section is dominated by low excitation energies and the superscaling ideas are not supposed to apply . concerning the susa+mec results , a possible explanation of the theory / data disagreement is the fact that , as already mentioned , a fully consistent treatment of two - body currents should take into account not only the genuine mec contributions , but also the correlation diagrams that are necessary in order to preserve the gauge invariance of the theory
this , however , is not an easy task because in an infinite system like the rfg the correlation diagrams give rise to divergences which need to be regularized @xcite .
the divergences arise from a double pole in some of the diagrams , associated to the presence of on - shell nucleon propagators .
different prescriptions have been used in the literature in order to overcome this problem @xcite , leading to a substantial model - dependence of the results . in particular in ref .
@xcite the divergence has been cured by introducing a parameter @xmath53 which accounts for the finite size of the nucleus ( and therefore the finite time of propagation of a nucleon inside the nucleus ) and the @xmath53-dependence of the contribution of correlation diagrams has been explored .
the study has shown that for reasonable values of the parameter the correlations add to the pure mec in the high - energy tail and are roughly of the same order of magnitude , but now contributing to both the longitudinal and the transverse channels .
the inclusion of these terms in neutrino reactions is in progress @xcite and is expected to give a further enhancement of the cross sections .
flux - integrated double - differential cross section per target nucleon for the @xmath6 ccqe process on @xmath51c evaluated in the rmf ( red ) model and in the susa approach with ( blue line ) and without ( green line ) the contribution of mec and displayed versus the muon kinetic energy @xmath11 for three specific bins of the scattering angle .
the data are from miniboone @xcite . ]
flux - integrated double - differential cross section per target nucleon for the @xmath6 ccqe process on @xmath51c evaluated in the rmf ( red ) model and in the susa approach with ( blue line ) and without ( green line ) the contribution of mec and displayed versus the muon kinetic energy @xmath11 for three specific bins of the scattering angle .
the data are from miniboone @xcite . ]
flux - integrated double - differential cross section per target nucleon for the @xmath6 ccqe process on @xmath51c evaluated in the rmf ( red ) model and in the susa approach with ( blue line ) and without ( green line ) the contribution of mec and displayed versus the muon kinetic energy @xmath11 for three specific bins of the scattering angle .
the data are from miniboone @xcite . ]
flux - integrated double - differential cross section per target nucleon for the @xmath6 ccqe process on @xmath51c evaluated in the rmf ( red ) model and in the susa approach with ( blue line ) and without ( green line ) the contribution of mec and displayed versus the muon scattering angle for three bins of the muon kinetic energy @xmath11 .
the data are from miniboone @xcite . ]
flux - integrated double - differential cross section per target nucleon for the @xmath6 ccqe process on @xmath51c evaluated in the rmf ( red ) model and in the susa approach with ( blue line ) and without ( green line ) the contribution of mec and displayed versus the muon scattering angle for three bins of the muon kinetic energy @xmath11 .
the data are from miniboone @xcite . ]
flux - integrated double - differential cross section per target nucleon for the @xmath6 ccqe process on @xmath51c evaluated in the rmf ( red ) model and in the susa approach with ( blue line ) and without ( green line ) the contribution of mec and displayed versus the muon scattering angle for three bins of the muon kinetic energy @xmath11 .
the data are from miniboone @xcite . ] the single differential cross sections with respect to the muon kinetic energy and scattering angle , respectively , are presented in figs .
[ fig : csvst ] and [ fig : csvscos ] , where the relativistic fermi gas result is also shown for comparison : again it appears that the rmf gives slightly higher cross sections than susa , due to the @xmath39 unbalance , but both models still underestimate the data for most kinematics .
the inclusion of 2p-2h excitations leads to a good agreement with the data at high @xmath11 , but strength is still missing at the lower muon kinetic energies ( namely higher energy transfers ) and higher angles .
( color online ) flux - averaged @xmath6ccqe cross section on @xmath5 integrated over the muon kinetic energy and displayed versus the scattering angle .
the data are from miniboone @xcite . ]
( color online ) flux - averaged @xmath6ccqe cross section on @xmath5 integrated over the muon kinetic energy and displayed versus the scattering angle .
the data are from miniboone @xcite . ] finally , in fig .
[ fig : csvsenu ] the total ( namely integrated over over all muon scattering angles and energies ) ccqe cross section per neutron is displayed versus the neutrino energy and compared with the experimental flux - unfolded data . besides the models above discussed ,
we show for comparison also the results of the relativistic mean field model when the final state interactions are ignored ( denoted as rpwia - relativistic plane wave impulse approximation ) or described through a real optical potential ( denoted as rrop ) .
note that the discrepancies between the various models , observed in figs .
[ fig : cos ] and [ fig : tmu ] , tend to be washed out by the integration , yielding very similar results for the models that include fsi ( susa , rmf and rrop ) , all of them giving a lower total cross section than the models without fsi ( rfg and rpwia ) . on the other hand
the susa+mec curve , while being closer to the data at high neutrino energies , has a somewhat different shape with respect to the other models , in qualitative agreement with the relativistic calculation of @xcite .
it should be noted , however , that the result is affected by an uncertainty of about 5% associated with the treatment of the 2p-2h contribution at low momentum transfers and that pionic correlations are not included .
( color online ) total ccqe cross section per neutron versus the neutrino energy .
the curves corresponding to different nuclear models are compared with the flux unfolded miniboone data @xcite . ]
two different relativistic models , one ( susa ) phenomenological and the other ( rmf ) microscopic , have been applied to the study of charged - current quasielastic neutrino scattering and the impact of 2p-2h meson exchange currents on the cross sections has been investigated .
the results can be summarized as follows : 1 .
both the susa and the rmf models , in contrast with the relativistic fermi gas , are fitting with good accuracy the longitudinal quasielastic electron scattering response at intermediate to high energy and momentum transfer .
+ the susa and rmf models give very similar results for the integrated neutrino cross section and both substantially under - predict the miniboone experimental data
. however the comparison with the double differential experimental cross section reveals some differences between the two models , which are washed out by the integration .
indeed the rmf , although being lower than the data , reproduces better the slopes of the cross section versus the muon energy and scattering angle .
this is essentially due to the enhancement of the transverse response , which arises from the self - consistent mean field approach of rmf ( in particular from the consistent treatment of initial and final state interactions ) and is absent in the superscaling approach .
2 . in relativistic or semi - relativistic models
final state interactions have been shown to play an essential role for reproducing the shape and size of the electromagnetic response @xcite and can not be neglected , in our scheme , in the study of neutrino interactions .
the effect of final state interactions in the susa and rmf models is to lower the cross section , giving a discrepancy with the data larger than the rfg .
3 . in the transverse channel
, the analysis of @xmath7 data points to the importance of meson - exchange currents which , through the excitation of two - particle - two - hole states , are partially responsible of filling the `` dip '' region between the qe and @xmath40 peaks .
the 2p-2h mec can be even more relevant in the ccqe process , where `` quasielastic '' implies simply that no pions are present in the final state but , due to the large energy region spanned by the neutrino flux , processes involving the exchange of virtual pions can give a sizable contribution .
in fact the inclusion of 2p-2h mec contributions yields larger cross sections and accordingly better agreement with the data , although the theoretical curves still lie below the data at high angles and low muon energy .
it should be stressed , however , that the present calculation , though exact and fully relativistic , is incomplete . in order to preserve gauge invariance the full two - body current , including not only the mec but also the corresponding correlation diagrams , must be included .
these have recently been shown to yield a sizable contribution at high energies in @xmath7 scattering @xcite and are likely to improve the agreement of our models with the miniboone data .
4 . in all our calculations
the standard value @xmath541.03 gev / c@xmath3 has been used .
it has been suggested that a larger value of the axial mass ( 1.35 gev / c@xmath3 ) would eliminate the disagreement with the data .
however the fit was done using a rfg analysis , and more sophisticated nuclear models must be explored before drawing conclusions on the actual value of the axial mass .
for instance in ref . @xcite it is shown that the miniboone data can as well be fitted by effectively incorporating some nuclear effects in the magnetic form factor of the bound nucleon , without changing the axial mass . +
although our scope here is not to extract a value for the axial mass of the nucleon , but rather to understand which nuclear effects are effectively accounted for by a large axial cutoff parameter , let us mention that a best fit of the rmf and susa results to the miniboone experimental cross section gives an effective axial mass @xmath55 1.5 gev / c@xmath3 and values in the range @xmath56 gev / c@xmath3 yield results compatible with the miniboone data within the experimental errors .
a similar analysis in the model including the 2p-2h contribution will be possible only when the above mentioned correlation diagrams will be consistently evaluated @xcite .
i would like to thank j.e .
amaro , j.a .
caballero , t.w .
donnelly , j.m .
udias and c.w .
williamson for the fruitful collaboration which lead to the results reported in this contribution .
9 a. a. aguilar - arevalo _ et al . _ [ miniboone collaboration ] , phys .
d * 81 * , 092005 ( 2010 ) .
v. bernard , l. elouadrhiri and u. g. meissner , j. phys .
g * 28 * , r1 ( 2002 ) .
m. b. barbaro , a. de pace , t. w. donnelly , a. molinari and m. j. musolf , phys .
c * 54 * , 1954 ( 1996 ) .
o. benhar , n. farina , h. nakamura , m. sakuda and r. seki , phys .
d * 72 * , 053005 ( 2005 ) .
o. benhar and d. meloni , nucl .
a * 789 * , 379 ( 2007 ) .
o. benhar and d. meloni , phys .
d * 80 * , 073003 ( 2009 ) .
a. m. ankowski , o. benhar and n. farina , phys . rev .
d * 82 * , 013002 ( 2010 ) .
o. benhar , p. coletti and d. meloni , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 132301 ( 2010 ) . c. juszczak , j. t. sobczyk and j. zmuda , phys .
c * 82 * , 045502 ( 2010 ) .
a. m. ankowski and o. benhar , phys . rev .
c * 83 * , 054616 ( 2011 ) .
w. m. alberico _ et al .
_ , nucl .
a * 623 * , 471 ( 1997 ) .
w. m. alberico _ et al .
_ , phys .
b * 438 * , 9 ( 1998 ) .
w. m. alberico _ et al .
_ , nucl .
a * 651 * , 277 ( 1999 ) .
a. meucci , c. giusti and f. d. pacati , nucl .
a * 739 * , 277 ( 2004 ) .
a. meucci , c. giusti and f. d. pacati , nucl .
a * 744 * , 307 ( 2004 ) .
a. meucci , c. giusti and f. d. pacati , nucl .
a * 773 * , 250 ( 2006 ) .
a. meucci , j. a. caballero , c. giusti and j. m. udias , phys .
c * 83 * , 064614 ( 2011 ) .
a. meucci , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , c. giusti and j. m. udias , arxiv:1107.5145 [ nucl - th ] .
a. n. antonov _ et al .
_ , phys .
c * 74 * , 054603 ( 2006 ) .
a. n. antonov , m. v. ivanov , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , e. moya de guerra and m. k. gaidarov , phys .
c * 75 * , 064617 ( 2007 ) .
m. v. ivanov , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , a. n. antonov , e. moya de guerra and m. k. gaidarov , phys .
c * 77 * , 034612 ( 2008 ) .
t. leitner , l. alvarez - ruso and u. mosel , phys .
c * 73 * , 065502 ( 2006 ) .
t. leitner , l. alvarez - ruso and u. mosel , phys .
c * 74 * , 065502 ( 2006 ) .
o. buss , t. leitner , u. mosel and l. alvarez - ruso , phys .
c * 76 * , 035502 ( 2007 ) .
t. leitner and u. mosel , phys .
c * 81 * , 064614 ( 2010 ) .
j. nieves , j. e. amaro and m. valverde , phys .
c * 70 * , 055503 ( 2004 ) [ erratum - ibid .
c * 72 * , 019902 ( 2005 ) ] .
j. nieves , m. valverde and m. j. vicente vacas , phys .
c * 73 * , 025504 ( 2006 ) .
m. valverde , j. e. amaro and j. nieves , phys .
b * 638 * , 325 ( 2006 ) .
m. martini , m. ericson , g. chanfray and j. marteau , phys .
c * 80 * , 065501 ( 2009 ) .
m. martini , m. ericson , g. chanfray and j. marteau , phys .
c * 81 * , 045502 ( 2010 ) .
j. nieves , i. ruiz simo and m. j. vicente vacas , phys .
c * 83 * , 045501 ( 2011 ) .
j. nieves , i. r. simo and m. j. v. vacas , arxiv:1106.5374 [ hep - ph ] . c. giusti and a. meucci , arxiv:1107.5425 [ nucl - th ] .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly and a. molinari , nucl .
a * 643 * , 349 ( 1998 ) .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly and a. molinari , phys .
* 368 * , 317 ( 2002 ) .
d. b. day , j. s. mccarthy , t. w. donnelly and i. sick , ann .
nucl . part .
sci . * 40 * , 357 ( 1990 ) .
j. jourdan , nucl .
a * 603 * ( 1996 ) 117 .
t. w. donnelly and i. sick , phys . rev .
* 82 * , 3212 ( 1999 ) .
t. w. donnelly and i. sick , phys .
c * 60 * , 065502 ( 1999 ) . c. maieron , t. w. donnelly and i. sick , phys .
c * 65 * ( 2002 ) 025502 .
w. m. alberico , a. molinari , t. w. donnelly , e. l. kronenberg and j. w. van orden , phys .
c * 38 * , 1801 ( 1988 ) .
m. b. barbaro , j. e. amaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly , proceedings of the xxv international worshop on nuclear theory , rila , 2005 , `` nuclear theory 25 '' , ed .
s. dimitrova , heron press , sofia , 2006 ; [ arxiv : nucl - th/0609057 ] .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly and c. f. williamson , phys .
b * 696 * , 151 ( 2011 ) .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly and j. m. udias , phys .
d * 84 * , 033004 ( 2011 ) .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly , a. molinari and i. sick , phys .
c * 71 * ( 2005 ) 015501
. j. a. caballero , phys .
c * 74 * , 015502 ( 2006 ) . j. a. caballero , j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , t. w. donnelly and j. m. udias , phys .
b * 653 * , 366 ( 2007 ) .
j. a. caballero , j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , t. w. donnelly , c. maieron and j. m. udias , phys .
* 95 * , 252502 ( 2005 ) .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero and t. w. donnelly , phys .
* 98 * ( 2007 ) 242501 . c. maieron , m. c. martinez , j. a. caballero and j. m. udias , phys .
c * 68 * , 048501 ( 2003 ) . j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly and j. m. udias , phys .
c * 75 * , 034613 ( 2007 ) . c. j. horowitz , b. d. serot , nucl .
phys . a * 368 * , 503 ( 1981 ) ; phys .
b * 86 * , 146 ( 1979 ) .
b. d. serot , j. d. walecka , adv .
j. w. negele , e. w. vogt .
plenum press , new york ( 1986 ) .
m. m. sharma , m. a. nagarajan and p. ring , phys .
b * 312 * , 377 ( 1993 ) .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero and t. w. donnelly , phys .
c * 73 * , 035503 ( 2006 ) .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly and c. maieron , phys . rev .
c * 71 * , 065501 ( 2005 ) .
j. e. amaro , c. maieron , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero and t. w. donnelly , phys .
c * 82 * , 044601 ( 2010 ) .
w. m. alberico , t. w. donnelly and a. molinari , nucl .
a * 512 * , 541 ( 1990 ) .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly and a. molinari , nucl .
a * 723 * , 181 ( 2003 ) .
j. e. amaro , m. b. barbaro , j. a. caballero , t. w. donnelly , c. maieron and j. m. udias , phys .
c * 81 * ( 2010 ) 014606 .
t. w. donnelly , j. w. van orden , t. .
j. de forest and w. c. hermans , phys .
b * 76 * , 393 ( 1978 ) .
j. w. van orden and t. w. donnelly , annals phys .
* 131 * ( 1981 ) 451 .
m. j. dekker , p. j. brussaard and j. a. tjon , phys .
c * 49 * , 2650 ( 1994 ) .
a. de pace , m. nardi , w. m. alberico , t. w. donnelly and a. molinari , nucl .
a * 726 * , 303 ( 2003 ) .
a. de pace , m. nardi , w. m. alberico , t. w. donnelly and a. molinari , nucl .
a * 741 * , 249 ( 2004 ) .
w. m. alberico , m. ericson and a. molinari , annals phys .
* 154 * , 356 ( 1984 ) .
w. m. alberico , a. de pace , a. drago and a. molinari , riv .
nuovo cim .
* 14n5 * , 1 ( 1991 ) .
a. gil , j. nieves and e. oset , nucl .
a * 627 * , 543 ( 1997 ) .
j. e. amaro et al .
, work in progress .
a. bodek , h. budd , e. christy , arxiv:1106.0340 [ hep - ph ] . | after a short review of the recent developments in studies of neutrino - nucleus interactions , the predictions for double - differential and integrated charged current - induced quasielastic cross sections are presented within two different relativistic approaches : one is the so - called susa method , based on the superscaling behavior exhibited by electron scattering data ; the other is a microscopic model based on relativistic mean field theory , and incorporating final - state interactions .
the role played by the meson - exchange currents in the two - particle two - hole sector is explored and the results are compared with the recent miniboone data . |
the merger of two neutron stars , two black holes or a black hole and a neutron star are among the most important sources of gravitational waves ( gw ) , due to the huge energy released in the process .
in particular , the coalescence of double neutron stars ( dns ) may radiate about 10@xmath6 erg in the last seconds of their inspiral trajectory , at frequencies up to 1.4 - 1.6 khz , range covered by most of the ground - based laser interferometers like virgo @xcite , ligo @xcite , geo @xcite or tama @xcite . besides the amount of energy involved in these events , the rate at which they occur in the local universe is another parameter characterizing if these mergings are or not potential interesting sources of gw . in spite of the large amount of work performed in the past years , uncertainties persist in estimates of the dns coalescence rate . in a previous investigation
, we have revisited this question @xcite , taking into account the galactic star formation history derived directly from observations and including the contribution of elliptical galaxies when estimating the mean merging rate in the local universe .
based on these results , we have predicted a detection rate of one event every 125 and 148 years by initial ligo and virgo respectively and up to 6 detections per year in their advanced configurations . besides the emission produced by the coalescence of the nearest dns , the superposition of a large number of unresolved sources at high redshifts will produce a stochastic background of gw . in the past years
, different astrophysical processes susceptible to generate a stochastic background have been investigated . on the one hand , distorted black holes @xcite , bar mode emission from young neutron stars @xcite are examples of sources able to generate a shot noise ( time interval between events large in comparison with duration of a single event ) , while supernovas or hypernovas @xcite are expected to produce an intermediate popcorn " noise . on the other hand ,
the contribution of tri - axial rotating neutron stars @xcite , including magnetars @xcite , constitutes a truly continuous background .
populations of compact binaries as , for instance , the cataclismic variables are responsible for the existence of a galactic background of gw in the mhz domain , which could represent an important source of confusion noise for space detectors as lisa @xcite .
these investigations have been extended recently to the extra - galactic contribution .
@xcite , @xcite and @xcite considered cosmological populations of double and mixed systems involving black holes , neutron stars and white dwarfs , while close binaries originated from low and intermediate mass stars were discussed by @xcite . in this work ,
using the dns merging rate estimated in our precedent study , we have estimated the gravitational wave background spectrum produced by these coalescences .
numerical simulations based on monte carlo methods were performed in order to determine the critical redshift @xmath7 beyond which the duty cycle condition required to have a continuous background ( @xmath8 ) is satisfied . unlike previous studies which focus their attention on the early low frequency inspiral phase covered by lisa @xcite
, here we are mainly interested in the few thousand seconds before the last stable orbit is reached , when more than 96% of the gravitational wave energy is released .
the signal frequency is in the range 10 - 1500 hz , covered by ground based interferometers .
the paper is organized as follows . in 2 , the simulations are described ; in 3 the contribution of dns coalescences to the stochastic background is calculated ; in 4 the detection possibility with laser beam interferometers is discussed and , finally , in 5 the main conclusions are summarized .
in order to simulate by monte carlo methods the occurrence of merging events , we have adopted the following procedure . the first step was to estimate the probability for a given pair of massive stars , supposed to be the progenitors of dns , be formed at a given redshift .
this probability distribution is essentially given by the cosmic star formation rate @xcite , normalized in the redshift interval @xmath9 , e.g. , @xmath10 the normalization factor in the denominator is essentially the rate at which massive binaries are formed in the considered redshift interval , e.g. , @xmath11 which depends on the adopted cosmic star formation rate , as we shall see later .
the formation rate of massive binaries per redshift interval is @xmath12 in the equation above , @xmath13 is the cosmic star formation rate ( sfr ) expressed in m@xmath14 mpc@xmath15yr@xmath16 and @xmath17 is the mass fraction converted into dns progenitors .
hereafter , rates per comoving volume will always be indicated by the superscript * , while rates with indexes z@xmath18 " or
z@xmath19 " refer to differential rates per redshift interval , including all cosmological factors . the ( 1+z ) term in the denominator of eq .
[ eq - frate ] corrects the star formation rate by time dilatation due to the cosmic expansion . in the present work
we assume that the parameter @xmath20 does not change significantly with the redshift and thus it will be considered as a constant .
in fact , this term is the product of three other parameters , namely , @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the fraction of binaries which remains bounded after the second supernova event , @xmath23 is the fraction of massive binaries formed among all stars and @xmath24 is the mass fraction of neutron star progenitors .
according to the results by @xcite,@xcite , @xmath22 = 0.024 and @xmath23 = 0.136 , values which will be adopted in our calculations . assuming that progenitors with initial masses above 40 m@xmath14 will produce black holes and considering an initial mass function ( imf ) of the form @xmath25 , with @xmath26 = 2.35 ( salpeter s law ) , normalized within the mass interval 0.1 - 80 m@xmath14 such as @xmath27 = 1 , it results finally @xmath28 and @xmath29 m@xmath30 .
the evaluation of the parameters @xmath22 and @xmath23 depends on different assumptions , which explain why estimates of the coalescence rate of dns found in the literature may vary by one or even two orders of magnitude .
the evolutionary scenario of massive binaries considered in our calculations ( see @xcite for details ) is similar to that developed by @xcite , in which none of the stars ever had the chance of being recycled by accretion .
besides the evolutionary path , the resulting fraction @xmath22 of bound ns - ns binaries depends on the adopted velocity distribution of the natal kick .
the imparted kick may unbind binaries which otherwise might have remained bound or , less probably , conserve bound systems which without the kick would have been disrupted .
the adopted value for @xmath22 corresponds to a 1-d velocity dispersion of about 80 km / s .
this value is smaller than those usually assumed for single pulsars , but consistent with recent analyses of the spin period - eccentricity relation for ns - ns binaries @xcite .
had we adopted a higher velocity dispersion in our simulations ( 230 km / s instead of 80 km / s ) , the resulting fraction of bound systems is reduced by one order of magnitude , e.g. , @xmath22 = 0.0029 . if , on the one hand the fraction of bound ns - ns systems after the second supernova event depends on the previous evolutionary history of the progenitors and on the kick velocity distribution , on the other hand estimates of the fraction @xmath23 of massive binaries formed among all stars depends on the ratio between single and double ns systems in the galaxy and on the value of @xmath22 itself @xcite .
we have estimated relative uncertainties of about @xmath31 and @xmath32 , leading to a relative uncertainty in the parameter @xmath20 of about @xmath33 .
however , we emphasize that these are only formal uncertainties resulting from our simulations , which depend on the adopted evolutionary scenario for the progenitors . a comparison with other estimates can be found in @xcite .
the element of comoving volume is given by @xmath34 with @xmath35^{1/2}\ ] ] where @xmath36 and @xmath37 are respectively the present values of the density parameters due to matter ( baryonic and non - baryonic ) and vacuum , corresponding to a non - zero cosmological constant .
a flat " cosmological model ( @xmath38 ) was assumed . in our calculations
, we have taken @xmath36 = 0.30 and @xmath37 = 0.70 , corresponding to the so - called concordance " model derived from observations of distant type ia supernovae @xcite and the power spectra of the cosmic microwave background fluctuations @xcite .
the hubble parameter h@xmath39 was taken to be @xmath40 .
@xcite provide three models for the cosmic sfr history up to redshifts @xmath41 .
differences among these models are mainly due to various corrections applied , in particular those due to extinction by the cosmic dust . in our computations ,
we have considered the second model , labelled sfr2 @xcite but numerical results using sfr1 @xcite will be also given for comparison .
both rates increase rapidly between @xmath42 and peak at @xmath43 , but sfr1 decreases gently after @xmath44 while sfr2 remains more or less constant ( figure [ fig - sfr ] ) .
the next step consists to estimate the redshift @xmath45 at which the progenitors have already evolved and the system is now constituted by two neutron stars .
this moment fixes also the beginning of the inspiral phase .
if @xmath46 ( @xmath47 yr ) is the mean lifetime of the progenitors ( average weighted by the imf in the interval 9 - 40 m@xmath14 ) then @xmath48 once the beginning of the inspiral phase is established , the redshift at which the coalescence occurs is estimated by the following procedure .
the duration of the inspiral phase depends on the orbital parameters just after the second supernova and on the neutron star masses .
the probability for a given dns system to coalesce in a timescale @xmath49 was initially derived by @xcite , confirmed by subsequent simulations @xcite and is given by @xmath50 simulations indicate a minimum coalescence timescale @xmath51 yr but a considerable number of systems have a coalescence timescale higher than the hubble time .
the normalized probability in the range @xmath52 yr up to 20 gyr implies @xmath53 .
therefore , the redshift @xmath54 at which the coalescence occurs after a timescale @xmath49 is derived from the equation @xmath55 which was solved in our code by an iterative method .
the resulting distribution of the number of coalescences as a function of @xmath54 is shown in figure [ fig - dist_coalescence ] for both star formation rates sfr1 and sfr2 , while the corresponding coalescence rate per redshift interval , @xmath56 , is shown in figure [ fig - sfr ] . in the same figure , for comparison
, we have plotted the formation rate @xmath57 ( eq .
[ eq - frate ] ) .
notice that the maximum of @xmath56 is shifted towards lower redshifts with respect to the maximum of @xmath57 , reflecting the time delay between the formation of the progenitors and the coalescence event .
the coalescence rate @xmath56 , does not fall to zero at @xmath58 because a non negligible fraction of coalescences ( @xmath59 for sfr2 and @xmath60 for sfr1 ) occurs later than @xmath58 .
the nature of the background is determined by the duty cycle defined as the ratio of the typical duration of a single burst @xmath61 to the average time interval between successive events , e.g. , @xmath62 the critical redshift @xmath7 at which the background becomes continuous is fixed by the condition @xmath63 .
since we are interested in the last instants of the inspiral , when the signal is within the frequency band of ground based interferometers , we took @xmath64 s , duration which includes about @xmath65 of the total energy released ( see table [ tbl - duration ] ) . from our numerical experiments and imposing d = 1 , one obtains @xmath66 when the sfr2 is used and @xmath67 for the sfr1 .
about 96% ( 94% in the case of sfr1 ) of coalescences occur above such a redshift , contributing to the production of a continuous background .
sources in the redshift interval @xmath68 ( sfr2 ) or @xmath69 ( sfr1 ) correspond to a duty cycle d = 0.1 and they are responsible for a cosmic popcorn " noise .
the gravitational fluence ( given here in erg @xmath70hz@xmath16 ) in the observer frame produced by a given dns coalescence is : @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the distance luminosity , @xmath73 is the proper distance , which depends on the adopted cosmology , @xmath74 is the gravitational spectral energy and @xmath75 the frequency in the source frame . in the quadrupolar approximation and for a binary system with masses @xmath76 and @xmath77 in a circular orbit : @xmath78 where the fact that the gravitational wave frequency is twice the orbital frequency was taken into account . then @xmath79 assuming @xmath80 one obtains @xmath81 erg hz@xmath82 .
the spectral properties of the stochastic background are characterized by the dimensionless parameter @xcite : @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the wave frequency in the observer frame , @xmath85 is the critical mass density needed to close the universe , related to the hubble parameter @xmath86 by , @xmath87 @xmath88 is the gravitational wave flux ( given here in erg @xmath70hz@xmath16s@xmath16 ) at the observer frequency @xmath89 , integrated over all sources at redshifts @xmath90 , namely @xmath91 instead of solving analytically the equation above by introducing , for instance , an adequate fit of the cosmic coalescence rate , we have calculated the integrated gravitational flux by summing individual fluences ( eq . [ eq - fluence ] ) , scaled by the ratio between the expected number of events per unit of time and the number of simulated coalescences or , in other words , the ratio between the total formation rate of progenitors ( eq . [ eq - nevents ] ) and the number of simulated massive binaries , e.g. , @xmath92 the number of runs ( or @xmath93 ) in our simulations was equal to @xmath94 , representing an uncertainty of @xmath95 0.1% in the density parameter @xmath4 . using the sfr2 ,
the derived formation rate of progenitors is @xmath96 , whereas for the sfr1 one obtains @xmath97 . for each run
, the probability distribution @xmath98 defines , via monte carlo , the redshift at which the massive binary is formed .
the beginning of the inspiral phase at @xmath45 is fixed by eq .
[ eq - zb ] .
then , in next step , the probability distribution of the coalescence timescale and eq . [ eq - h0_tau ]
define the redshift @xmath54 at which the merging occurs .
the fluence produced by this event is calculated by eq .
[ eq - fluence ] , stored in different frequency bins in the observer frame and added according to the equation above . figure [ fig - omega ] shows the density parameter @xmath4 as a function of the observed frequency derived from our simulations .
the density parameter @xmath4 increases as @xmath99 at low frequencies , reaches a maximum amplitude of about @xmath100 around 670 hz in the case of sfr2 and a maximum of @xmath101 ) around 630 hz , in the case of sfr1 .
a high frequency cut - off at @xmath102 hz ( @xmath103 hz for sfr1 ) is observed , corresponding approximately to the frequency of the last stable orbit at the critical redshift @xmath104 ( @xmath105 for sfr1 ) .
calculations performed by @xcite , in spite of the similar local merging rates , indicate that the maximum occurs at lower frequencies ( @xmath106 100 hz ) with an amplitude ( scaled to the hubble parameter adopted in this work ) lower by a factor of seven . however , as those authors have stressed , their calculations are expected to be accurate in the frequency range 10 @xmath107hz up to 1 hz , since they have set the value of the maximum frequency @xmath108 to about that expected at a separation of three times the last stable orbit " ( lso ) , e.g. , @xmath109 .
thus , a direct comparison with our results is probably meaningless . a more conservative estimate can be obtained if one adopts a higher duty cycle value , namely , @xmath110 , corresponding to sources located beyond @xmath111 ( @xmath112 for sfr1 ) .
our results are plotted in fig .
[ fig - omega ] , which includes , for comparison , the popcorn " noise contribution arising from sources between @xmath113 ( @xmath69 for sfr1 ) , corresponding to the intermediate zone between a shot noise ( @xmath114 ) and a continuous background ( @xmath115 ) . when increasing the critical redshift ( or removing the nearest sources ) , the amplitude of @xmath4 decreases and the spectrum is shifted toward lower frequencies .
the amplitude of the popcorn " background is about one order of magnitude higher than the continuous background , with a maximum of about @xmath116 ( @xmath117 for sfr1 ) around a frequency of @xmath118 khz . since some authors use , instead of @xmath4 , the gravitational strain @xmath119 defined by @xcite as @xmath120 we show this quantity in figure [ fig - sh ] .
because the background obeys a gaussian statistic and can be confounded with the instrumental noise background of a single detector , the optimal detection strategy is to cross - correlate the output of two ( or more ) detectors , assumed to have independent spectral noises .
the cross correlation product is given by @xcite : @xmath121 where @xmath122 is a filter that maximizes the signal to noise ratio ( @xmath123 ) . in the above equations , @xmath124 and @xmath125 are the power spectral noise densities of the two detectors and
@xmath126 is the non - normalized overlap reduction function , characterizing the loss of sensitivity due to the separation and the relative orientation of the detectors .
the optimized @xmath127 ratio for an integration time @xmath128 is given by @xcite : @xmath129 in the literature , the sensitivity of detector pairs is usually given in terms of the minimum detectable amplitude for a flat spectrum ( @xmath4 equal to constant ) @xcite , e.g. , @xmath130 the expected minimum detectable amplitude for the main pair of detectors in the world , after one year integration , are given in table [ tbl - sensitivity ] , for a detection rate @xmath131 and a false alarm rate @xmath132 .
the power spectral densities expressions used for the present calculation can be found in @xcite .
@xmath133 is of the order of @xmath134 for the first generation of interferometers combined as ligo / ligo and ligo / virgo .
their advanced counterparts will permit an increase of two or even three orders of magnitude in sensitivity ( @xmath135 ) .
the pair formed by the co - located and co - aligned ligo hanford detectors , for which the overlap reduction function is equal to one , is potentially one order of magnitude more sensitive than the hanford / livingston pair , provided that instrumental and environmental noises could be removed .
however , because the spectrum of dns coalescences _ is not flat _ and the maximum occurs out of the optimal frequency band of ground based interferometers , which is typically around @xmath136 hz , as shown in figure [ fig - snr ] , the s / n ratio is slightly reduced . considering the co - located and co - aligned ligo interferometer pair , we find a signal - to - noise ratio of @xmath137 ( @xmath138 ) for the initial ( advanced ) configuration . unless the coalescence rate be substantially higher than the present expectations ,
our results indicate that their contribution to the gravitational background is out of reach of the first and the second generation of interferometers . on the other hand
, the sensitivity of the future third generation of detectors , presently in discussion , could be high enough to gain one order of magnitude in the expected s / n ratio .
examples are the large scale cryogenic gravitational wave telescope ( lcgt ) , sponsored by the university of tokyo and the european antenna ego ( sathyaprakash , private communication ) .
ego will incorporate signal recycling , diffractive optics on silicon mirrors , cryo - techniques and kw - class lasers , among other technological improvements . a possible sensitivity for this detector
is shown in figure [ fig - sh ] , compared to the expected sensitivity of advanced ligo . around 650 hz ,
the planned strain noise @xmath139 is about @xmath140 hz@xmath141 for the advanced ligo configuration while at this frequency , the planned strain noise for ego is @xmath142 hz@xmath141 , which represents a gain by a factor of @xmath143 . considering two interferometers located at the same place
, we find a signal - to - noise ratio @xmath144 .
on the other hand , the popcorn noise contribution could be detected by new data analysis techniques currently under investigation , such as the search for anisotropies @xcite that can be used to create a map of the gw background @xcite , the maximum likelihood statistic @xcite , or methods based on the probability event horizon " concept @xcite , which describes the evolution , as a function of the observation time , of the cumulated signal throughout the universe .
the peh of the gw signal evolves fastly from contributions of high redshift populations , forming a real continuous stochastic background , to low redshift and less probable sources that can be resolved individually , while the peh of the instrumental noise is expected to evolve much slower .
consequently , the gw signature could be distinguished from the instrumental noise background .
in this work , we have performed numerical simulations using monte carlo techniques to estimate the occurrence of double neutron star coalescences and the gravitational stochastic background produced these events .
since the coalescence timescale obeys a well defined probability distribution ( @xmath145 ) , derived from simulations of the evolution of massive binaries @xcite , the cosmic coalescence rate does not follow the cosmic star formation rate and presents necessarily a time - lag . in the case where the sources are supernovae or black holes ,
the gravitational burst is produced in a quite short timescale after the the formation of the progenitors .
therefore , the time - lag is negligible and the comoving volume where the progenitors are formed is practically the same as that where the gravitational wave emission occurs , introducing a considerable simplification in the calculations .
this is not the case when ns - ns coalescences are considered , since timescales comparable or even higher than the hubble timescale have non negligible probabilities .
the maximum probability to form a massive binary occurs at @xmath146 , depending slightly on the adopted cosmic star formation rate , whereas the maximum probability to occur a coalescence is around @xmath147 .
we have found that a truly continuous background is formed only when sources located beyond @xmath148 ( @xmath149 for the sfr1 case ) , including 96% ( 94% for sfr1 ) of all events and the critical redshift corresponds to the condition @xmath8 .
sources in the redshift interval @xmath113 ( @xmath69 for sfr1 ) produce a popcorn " noise .
our computations indicate that the density parameter @xmath4 has a maximum around 670 hz ( 630 hz for sfr1 ) , attaining an amplitude of about of @xmath100 ( @xmath150 for sfr1 ) .
the low frequency cutoff around 1.2 khz corresponds essentially to the gravitational redshifted wave frequency associated to last stable orbit of sources located near the maximum of the coalescence rate .
the computed signal is below the sensitivity of the first and the second generation of detectors .
however , using the planned sensitivity of third generation interferometers , we found that after one year of integration , the cross - correlation of two ego like coincident antennas , gives an the optimized signal - to - noise of @xmath151 .
the popcorn " contribution is one order of magnitude higher with a maximum of @xmath152 ( @xmath117 for sfr1 ) at @xmath153 khz .
this signal , which is characterized by the spatial and temporal evolution of the events as well as by its signature , can be distinguished from the instrumental noise background and adequate data analysis strategies for its detection are currently under investigation @xcite . | in this work , numerical simulations were used to investigate the gravitational stochastic background produced by coalescences occurring up to @xmath0 of double neutron star systems .
the cosmic coalescence rate was derived from monte carlo methods using the probability distributions for forming a massive binary and to occur a coalescence in a given redshift .
a truly continuous background is produced by events located only beyond the critical redshift @xmath1 .
events occurring in the redshift interval @xmath2 give origin to a popcorn " noise , while those arising closer than @xmath3 produce a shot noise .
the gravitational density parameter @xmath4 for the continuous background reaches a maximum around 670 hz with an amplitude of @xmath5 , while the popcorn " noise has an amplitude about one order of magnitude higher and the maximum occurs around a frequency of 1.2 khz .
the signal is below the sensitivity of the first generation of detectors but could be detectable by the future generation of ground based interferometers . correlating two coincident advanced - ligo detectors or two ego interferometers , the expected s / n ratio are respectively 0.5 and 10 . |
the idea of quantum pumping , i.e. of producing a dc current at zero bias voltage by time periodic modulation of two system parameters , dates back to the work of thouless @xcite .
if the parameters change slowly as compared to all internal time scales of the system , the pumping is _ adiabatic _ , and the average charge per period does not depend on the detailed time dependence of the parameters .
using the concept of emissivity proposed by bttiker et al.@xcite , brouwer@xcite related the charge pumped in a period to the derivatives of the instantaneous scattering matrix of the conductor with respect to the time - varying parameters . since then , a general framework to compute the pumped charge through a conductor has been developed for noninteracting electrons@xcite .
the interest in the pumping phenomenon has shifted then to the experimental@xcite investigations of confined nanostructures , as quantum dots , where the realization of the periodic time - dependent potential can be achieved by modulating gate voltages applied to the structure@xcite . in case of interacting electrons the computation of the pumped charge
becomes rather involved and few works have addressed this issue for different systems@xcite and in specific regimes . as for the case of interacting quantum dots ,
the pumped charge in a period was calculated by aono@xcite by exploiting the zero - temperature mapping of the kondo problem .
a very general formalism was developed in ref .
[ ] where an adiabatic expansion of the self - energy based on the average - time approximation was used to calculate the dot green s function while a linear response scheme was employed in ref .
more recently , another interesting study@xcite was performed aiming at generalizing brouwer s formula for interacting systems to include inelastic scattering events . in this work we present a general expression for the adiabatic pumping current in the interacting quantum dot in terms of instantaneous properties of the system at equilibrium , generalizing the scattering approach for noninteracting particles and
discuss the limit of its validity . to get a pumped current
the two model parameters which are varied in time are the tunneling rates between the noninteracting leads and the quantum dot .
in particular , we let them vary both in modulus and phase through the adiabatic and periodic modulation of two external parameters ( e.g. gate voltages or magnetic fields ) and show that a rectification - like term arises in the current due to the time - dependent tunneling phase .
the plan of the paper is the following . in sec.[sec : model ] we introduce the model and relevant parameters .
we develop the scattering matrix approach together with the green s function formalism to derive the formula of the pumped current through an interacting multilevel quantum dot in the adiabatic regime at very low - temperatures . in sec.[sec : single - level ] we specialize on a single - level quantum dot and give the explicit expression of the pumped current .
conclusions are given in sec.[sec : conclusions ] .
we consider a multi - level quantum dot ( qd ) coupled to two noninteracting leads , with the external leads being in thermal equilibrium .
the hamiltonian of the system is given by : @xmath1 where @xmath2 , with @xmath3 the creation ( annihilation ) operator of an electron with spin @xmath4 in the lead @xmath5 and dispersion @xmath6 .
the qd is described by the hamiltonian @xmath7 , where @xmath8 with @xmath9 the creation ( annihilation ) operator of the electron with spin @xmath10 and @xmath11 the dot @xmath12-th energy level .
the on - site energy @xmath13 describes the coulomb interaction .
the tunneling hamiltonian is given by @xmath14 , with time - dependent tunnel matrix elements @xmath15 .
for simplicity we assume that @xmath16 are spin independent , i.e. @xmath17 and that both the modulus and the phase of @xmath18 vary in time with frequency @xmath19 , i.e. @xmath20 .
their explicit time dependence is determined by two external parameters ( e.g. two gate voltages applied at the barriers of the dot or a gate voltage and a magnetic field ) which are varied adiabatically and periodically in time or by the presence of parasitic bias voltages .
two specific examples will be considered below . in particular
, we will specialize on the case in which the tunneling phase can vary harmonically or linearly in time .
the instantaneous strength of the coupling to the leads is instead characterized by the parameters @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the density of states in the leads at the fermi level . by varying in time
@xmath23 and @xmath24 and keeping them out of phase , the charge @xmath25 pumped in a period @xmath26 is related to the time dependent current @xmath27 flowing through the left barrier , i.e. @xmath28 . while the exact formula for the current depends on time - dependent green s function out of equilibrium , in the following we consider the adiabatic limit where the current depends only on the instantaneous equilibrium properties of the dot , i.e. on the retarded dot green s function ( gf ) .
this situation is realized in the two following cases .
first , let us consider that only the modulus of the tunneling matrix elements is varied in time , i.e. @xmath29 . under the adiabatic condition , the tunneling rate varies slowly in time , and the quantum dot can be considered time by time in equilibrium with the external leads . the effect of quantum pumping is well described by an adiabatic expansion of the self - energy based on the average - time approximation as described in ref . [ ] and using the equilibrium relations to write the pumped current in terms of the retarded gf only .
let us consider now the situation in which the modulus of the tunneling terms is fixed while their phases are modulated in time , i.e. @xmath30 .
this situation is equivalent ( by a gauge transformation ) to having a system biased with an ac external signal .
in particular , the ac voltage applied to the leads is proportional to the time derivative of the tunneling phase @xmath31@xcite .
since the tunneling terms are assumed to vary in time with frequency @xmath19 , the ac signal forcing the quantum dot is proportional to the pumping frequency @xmath19 and thus can be considered as a small perturbation under the adiabatic condition .
in particular , if one consider the case in which the tunneling phases vary linearly in time , @xmath32 , this situation corresponds to an interacting quantum dot biased by a dc voltage @xmath33 . following the work by meir and wingreen@xcite , the current @xmath34 flowing through the interacting multilevel dot biased by a dc voltage @xmath33 can be written as : @xmath35tr\{g^a\gamma^r g^r \gamma^l\mathcal{r}\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath36 are the fermi functions , @xmath37 are the dot - leads coupling strengths and @xmath38 is the ratio between the fully interacting self - energy and the noninteracting one , responsible for the deviation from the landauer - bttiker formula ( see ref .
[ ] , eq.(10 ) ) . in the zero - temperature limit and for a weak bias
, @xmath39 at the fermi level and thus eq . ( [ eq : curr - out - eq ] ) can written as @xmath40 , which corresponds to the usual linear response form , even though the green s function are interacting ones .
this argument is extensively discussed in refs .
[ ] ( see eq.s ( 37 ) and ( 38 ) ) and [ ] .
thus in general we expect that , when both the modulus and the phase of the pumping parameters are varied in time , apart the usual dc pumping current a new term arises ( that we call of _ rectification _ ) which is proportional to the time derivative of the tunneling phase : @xmath41 .
since , as explained above , in adiabatic regime the current is determined by the instantaneous properties of the dot ( retarded green s function ) and since in the zero temperature limit the usual linear response formula can be adopted for the calculation of the current , the pumping and rectification currents through the interacting quantum dot can be calculated by the scattering matrix approach as well .
in fact , as well known , the retarded green s function is related to scattering matrix by the fisher - lee relation .
we thus employ the scattering matrix formalism developed in ref .
[ ] where the charge current originated by an adiabatic pump is related to an expansion of the quantity @xmath42s^{\dag}(e,\tau)\}_{\alpha\alpha}$ ] with respect to the time derivative operator @xmath43 ( here @xmath44 is the scattering matrix and @xmath45 is the fermi function ) .
the first order of this expansion reproduces the famous brouwer s formula@xcite .
let us only stress that the scattering matrix formalism is well defined , not only in the noninteracting case , but also for the interacting problem ( e.g. see ref .
the expression of the pumped current @xmath46 in terms of the time - dependent scattering matrix@xcite is : @xmath47 where @xmath45 is the fermi function and @xmath44 is the instantaneous @xmath48-matrix of the qd .
it is given by the wigner transform @xmath49 , where @xmath50 here @xmath51 is the full retarded qd green s function , @xmath52 and @xmath53_{mn}=2\pi i\rho v^{\ast}_{\alpha , m}(t)v_{\beta , n}(t')$ ] . in the limit of the pumping frequency @xmath54 , i.e. under the adiabatic condition , the scattering matrix @xmath44 is expressed by the instantaneous green s function of the dot as@xcite : @xmath55 when substituting ( [ eq : inst ] ) into ( [ eq : curr ] ) to compute the current we need the time - derivative of the qd green s function which satisfies the relation : @xmath56 where the dot symbol indicates a time - derivative and the matrix notation for the dot green s function has been used .
the final expression obtained for the @xmath46 for a multi - level quantum dot is@xcite : @xmath57,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath58 this expression has been obtained by considering explicitly the time dependence of the modulus and phase of the tunnel matrix elements , and consequently of the leads - dot coupling function @xmath59 .
the symbol @xmath60 stands for the l , r lead in correspondence of @xmath61=r , l .
the total dc current through the lead @xmath61 is given by : @xmath62.\ ] ] the expression ( [ eq : main ] ) represents our main result .
it is valid for a multi - level qd and for any interaction strength in the zero temperature limit under the adiabatic condition . the first term in eq.([eq : main ] ) represents the pumping current , while the second one , proportional to the time - derivative of the tunneling rate phase , is the effective rectification term we have discussed above .
it can also be written as @xmath63 , where @xmath64 is the conductance of the structure , while @xmath65 . the last term in ( [ eq : main ] )
contains information on the time derivative of the retarded self - energy and is zero for a single - level quantum dot within the wide band limit .
up to now we have developed a theory of the pumped current valid in the case of a multi - level qd .
we now specialize eq .
( [ eq : main ] ) to the case of a single level qd . eliminating the trace in ( [ eq : main ] ) and considering the remaining quantities as c - numbers , the expression for
the current simplifies to : @xmath66.\end{aligned}\ ] ] when the time - derivative of the tunneling phase is neglected the above formula is equivalent to the pumped current calculated by the self - energy adiabatic expansion@xcite . in the following
we consider the case of a single level qd both in the strongly interacting and non - interacting case and describe the behavior of the charge @xmath67 ( in unit of the electron charge @xmath68 ) pumped per cycle in the zero - temperature limit .
the fermi energy @xmath69 is set to zero as reference energy level , while the static linewidth @xmath70 is assumed as energy unit ( typical value for @xmath71 is @xmath72 ) .
+ in the noninteracting case , i.e. when the qd green s function becomes a scalar , the expression for the instantaneous pumping current is explicitly given by : @xmath73.\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath74 , the charge pumped is zero when the level is resonant ( @xmath75 ) . in the case of a strongly interacting quantum dot ,
i.e. in the infinite-@xmath13 limit , we take the expression of the qd green s function as in ref .
the current is : @xmath76,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the occupation number @xmath77 on the dot has to be determined self - consistently by the relation @xmath78 , where @xmath79 is the qd lesser green s function .
+ in order to show the effects of the time - dependent tunneling phase we report below the numerical results of the charge @xmath67 pumped per cycle .
the pumping cycle is determined by the periodic time variation of the leads - dot coupling strength , where @xmath80 , while for the tunneling phase two cases can be considered .
either it varies harmonically @xmath81 with the same frequency of the two external gate voltages ( this case is shown in fig.[fig : fig1 ] ) or it varies linearly in time @xmath82 , e.g. when a parasitic gate voltage is present , ( this case is shown in fig.[fig : fig2 ] ) .
the quantity @xmath83 is the pumping phase that we take different from zero between l and r lead .
+ in fig.[fig : fig1 ] we plot @xmath67 as a function of the energy level @xmath84 by fixing the other parameters as : @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 .
in particular , in the upper panel , the charge induced by the pumping ( triangle ) and the charge due to the rectification term ( box ) is shown for a non - interacting dot ( @xmath92 ) . the total charge ( empty circle )
is significantly modified by the presence of the rectification term which is a non - vanishing quantity at the fermi energy ( @xmath75 ) .
the lower panel in fig.[fig : fig1 ] shows the behavior of the rectification current as a function of @xmath84 in the strongly interacting limit ( @xmath93 ) and by choosing the remaining parameters as in the upper panel .
while the general aspect of the total charge ( empty circle ) is only marginally modified by the strong correlations in the specified region of parameters , the rectified charge ( box ) shows a pronounced asymmetric behavior with respect to the level of the dot . pumped per pumping cycle as a function of the dot level @xmath84 .
the pumping ( triangle ) and the rectification ( box ) contribution to the total charge ( empty circle ) are shown for the non interacting case ( @xmath92 ) in the upper panel and for strongly interacting dot ( @xmath94 ) in the lower panel .
both figures are computed for the following choice of parameters : @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 .
the pumping cycle is determined by : @xmath80 , @xmath81 , with @xmath95 and @xmath96 , @xmath97,title="fig : " ] + pumped per pumping cycle as a function of the dot level @xmath84 .
the pumping ( triangle ) and the rectification ( box ) contribution to the total charge ( empty circle ) are shown for the non interacting case ( @xmath92 ) in the upper panel and for strongly interacting dot ( @xmath94 ) in the lower panel .
both figures are computed for the following choice of parameters : @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 .
the pumping cycle is determined by : @xmath80 , @xmath81 , with @xmath95 and @xmath96 , @xmath97,title="fig : " ] + in fig.[fig : fig2 ] we focus on the case of time - linear variation of the phase @xmath98 , and take the parameters as in fig.[fig : fig1 ] . in the upper panel ,
the pumped charge @xmath67 is plotted as a function of the dot level @xmath84 in the non - interacting case ( @xmath92 ) .
contrary to the previous case , the rectification contribution ( box ) is dominant over the one induced by the pumping mechanism ( triangle ) and thus the total charge ( empty circle ) is mainly affected by a resonant - like behavior . in the lower panel , the results for @xmath94 are shown . apart from a renormalization of the linewidth of the resonance induced by the factor @xmath99 in the numerator of eq .
( [ eq : single - level - interact ] ) , a behavior similar to the one of the non - interacting system is found . a slave boson treatment with the inclusion of a renormalization of the dot energy level ,
could in principle modify this picture .
let us note that when the tunneling phase varies harmonically both the pumping current and the rectification current follow the same @xmath100 behavior w.r.t .
the pumping phase @xmath0 . pumped per pumping cycle as a function of the dot level @xmath84 in the non interacting case ( upper panel ) and strongly interacting
case ( lower panel ) .
the pumping ( triangle ) and the rectification ( box ) contribution to the total charge ( empty circle ) are shown in the zero temperature - limit by setting the remaining parameters as follows : @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 . differently from fig.[fig : fig1 ] , the pumping cycle is determined by : @xmath80 , @xmath82 , with @xmath95 and @xmath96 , @xmath97.,title="fig : " ] + pumped per pumping cycle as a function of the dot level @xmath84 in the non interacting case ( upper panel ) and strongly interacting case ( lower panel ) .
the pumping ( triangle ) and the rectification ( box ) contribution to the total charge ( empty circle ) are shown in the zero temperature - limit by setting the remaining parameters as follows : @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 . differently from fig.[fig : fig1 ] , the pumping cycle is determined by : @xmath80 , @xmath82 , with @xmath95 and @xmath96 , @xmath97.,title="fig : " ] + in fig.[fig : fig3 ] we show the behavior of the charge induced by the pumping term ( upper panel ) and by the rectification ( lower panel ) with respect to the pumping phase @xmath0 and by fixing the dot level to @xmath101 and the remaining parameters as done in fig.[fig : fig2 ] .
the full line in both panels represents the result for the @xmath92 case , while the full circles ( @xmath102 ) represent the curves computed for the infinite-@xmath13 case .
let us note that while the pumping term follows the conventional @xmath100-behavior as in brouwer theory , the rectification contribution takes the form @xmath103 $ ] , where the coefficients @xmath104 and @xmath105 for the @xmath92 case are explicitly given by : @xmath106}{32[\xi+(\gamma_0/2)^2]^3},\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath107 .
the different symmetry of the pumping and rectification current has already been reported in experimental works in quantum dots@xcite and some theoretical explanations have been proposed@xcite . furthermore , the analysis of the coefficient @xmath105 shows that the charge transferred by the rectification effect can be significantly increased by coupling the dot region to the leads in an asymmetric way ( @xmath108 ) , e.g. by using tunnel barriers with very different transparencies .
the above results remain almost unchanged in the strongly interacting case ( @xmath109 ) .
+ is reported for @xmath101 and taking the remaining parameters as in fig.[fig : fig2 ] .
notice that the pumping term is proportional to @xmath100 , while the rectification one is proportional to @xmath110 .
both in the upper and lower panel , the full line represents the non interacting result , while the interacting case is indicated by full circles ( @xmath102).,title="fig : " ] + is reported for @xmath101 and taking the remaining parameters as in fig.[fig : fig2 ] .
notice that the pumping term is proportional to @xmath100 , while the rectification one is proportional to @xmath110 .
both in the upper and lower panel , the full line represents the non interacting result , while the interacting case is indicated by full circles ( @xmath102).,title="fig : " ] + in the limiting case in which the phase difference between the tunneling barriers is kept zero , i.e. @xmath111 , the pumping term is exactly zero and the rectification contribution acts as a quantum ratchet@xcite .
within the green s function and scattering matrix approach we have analyzed the quantum pumping current through an interacting quantum dot when both the modulus and the phase of the model time - dependent parameters , in our case the leads - dot tunneling rate , is adiabatically varied . in this way it has been possible to derive an expression for the pumped current containing an effective rectification term due to the time - dependent phase .
such contribution can be written in a landauer - buttiker - like form , even though for the interacting system , when the zero temperature limit and the adiabatic conditions are met .
the numerical analysis also show that when the tunneling phase varies linearly in time the rectification term is even with respect to the pumping phase @xmath0 , i.e. of the form @xmath112 , in contrast to the usual pumping term which is odd .
the mentioned contribution could be related to the experimentally observed rectification effects in quantum dots @xcite .
+ in particular , we have been considering an open system , but concerning closed systems ( e.g. annular devices with a quantum dot ) , the tunneling phase contribution to the pumped charge could find a natural interpretation in a complex phase of geometric nature@xcite .
this phase would be a berry phase @xcite .
thus the detection of a rectification current in addition to the pumping one could be an indirect probe of a berry phase .
+ the proposed analysis could be easily generalized up to the second order in the pumping frequency @xmath19 allowing to describe features involved in the moderate non - adiabatic limit .
we thank dr .
adele naddeo for useful suggestions .
we regret to acknowledge the passing away of prof .
maria marinaro with whom we have shared enlightening discussions during the completion of this work .
99 d. thouless , phys .
b * 27 * , 6083 ( 1983 ) .
b. altshuler and l. glazman , science * 283 * , 1864 ( 1999 ) .
m. bttiker , h. thomas , and a. prtre , z. phys .
b * 94 * , 133 ( 1994 ) .
p. w. brouwer , phys .
b * 58 * , 10135 ( 1998 ) .
f. zhou , b. spivak , and b. altshuler , phys .
82 * , 608 ( 1999 ) ; yu .
makhlin and a. d. mirlin , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 276803 ( 2001 ) ; o. entin - wohlman , a. aharony , and y. levinson , phys .
b * 65 * , 195411 ( 2002 ) ; m. moskalets and m. bttiker , phys .
b * 66 * , 035306 ( 2002 ) ; _ ibid._*66 * , 205320 ( 2002 ) .
m. switkes , c. m. marcus , k. campman , and a. c. gossard , science * 283 * , 1905 ( 1999 ) ; s. k. watson , r. m. potok , c. m. marcus , and v. umansky , phys .
lett . * 91 * , 258301 ( 2003 ) .
h. pothier , p. lafarge , c. urbina , d. esteve , and m. h. devoret , europhys . lett .
* 17 * , 249 ( 1992 ) ; i. l. aleiner and a.v .
andreev , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 1286 ( 1998 ) ; r. citro , n. andrei , and q. niu , phys .
b * 68 * , 165312 ( 2003 ) ; p.w . brouwer , a. lamacraft , and k. flensberg , phys . rev .
b * 72 * , 075316 ( 2005 ) .
t. aono , phys .
93 * , 116601 ( 2004 ) .
j. splettstoesser , m. governale , j. knig , and r. fazio , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 246803 ( 2005 ) .
yigal meir and ned s. wingreen , phys .
lett . * 68 * , 2512 ( 1992 ) ; see the discussion of pag .
2514 , first column , after eq.(9 ) . b. wang and j. wang , phys .
b * 66 * , 201305(r ) ( 2002 ) .
d. langreth , phys . rev . *
150 * , 516 ( 1966 ) .
f. m. souza , j. c. egues , and a. p. jauho , phys .
b * 75 * , 165303 ( 2007 ) ; see appendix . e. sela and y. oreg , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 166802 ( 2006 ) .
d. fioretto and a. silva , phys .
100 * , 236803 ( 2008 ) ; see also ` arxiv:0707.3338 ` . in formula ( [ eq : inst ] ) the sum on the discretized dot levels has been explicitly written . in deriving the expression for the instantaneous current we have been using the relation @xmath113 for the istantaneous green s function @xmath114 of the qd , while we defined @xmath115 .
p. w. brouwer , phys .
b * 63 * , 121303 ( 2001 ) . when an external d.c . or a.c .
bias voltage is applied to the system , a gauge transformation can be perfomed to eliminate the bias and the tunneling term acquires a time - dependent phase proportional to the bias . in our case
the time - dependent phase of the tunneling comes from the representation of a complex quantity .
a. l. kuzemsky , int . j. mod
b * 10 * , no .
15 , 1895 - 1912 ( 1996 ) .
s. k. watson , r. m. potok , c. m. marcus , and v. umansky , phys .
91 * , 258301 ( 2003 ) .
f. romeo , r. citro and m. marinaro , phys .
b * 78 * , 245309 ( 2008 ) and references therein .
antti - pekka jauho , ned s. wingreen and yigal meir , phys .
b * 50 * , 5528 ( 1994 ) .
huan - qiang zhou , urban lundin and sam young cho , j. phys . :
matter * 17 * , 1059 ( 2005 ) .
r. s. whitney , y. makhlin , a. shnirman and y. gefen , phys .
lett . * 94 * , 070407 ( 2005 ) . h. linke _
science * 286 * , 2314 ( 1999 ) ; see also liliana arrachea , phys .
b * 72 * , 121306(r ) ( 2005 ) and phys . rev .
b * 72 * , 249904(e ) ( 2005 ) . | we derive a formula describing the adiabatically pumped charge through an interacting quantum dot within the scattering matrix and green s function approach .
we show that when the tunneling rates between the leads and the dot are varied adiabatically in time , both in modulus and phase , the current induced in the dot consists of two terms , the pumping current and a rectification - like term .
the last contribution arises from the time - derivative of the tunneling phase and can have even or odd parity with respect to the pumping phase @xmath0 .
the rectification - like term is also discussed in relation to some recent experiments in quantum - dots . |