article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
in a note to the second edition of his book on statistical thermodynamics @xcite , schrdinger suggests that thermodynamical functions can not be based on the gratuitous allegation that quantum - mechanical levels ( typically the orthogonal eigenstates of the hamiltonian operator ) are the only allowed states in statistical thermodynamics . in khinchin s classical book on the mathematical foundations of quantum statistics ( sec .
2 of chap iii of @xcite ) an approach to microcanonical averages is proposed in line with schrdinger s suggestion .
landau and lifshitz @xcite also consider unrealistic the possibility of preparing isolated macroscopic physical systems in a precise energy eigenstate , since energy levels are too close to each other to select just one . from these points of view
, it seems then natural to consider the description of quantum statistical systems in terms of probability densities defined on the space of physical states .
this description offers the possibility of considering the weight of a given state in an analogous manner to what it is done when describing classical statistical systems .
the approach also offers many advantages in the description of hybrid quantum - classical systems , as it can be seen in @xcite .
nonetheless , it is important to keep in mind that these distributions are ambiguous from the physical point of view .
indeed , it is well known since von neumann @xcite that the physical properties of a quantum system are encoded univocally in its density matrix @xmath0 , but there are many different equivalent expressions for @xmath1 as a sum of pure states ( projectors ) . therefore
, we may define entirely different distributions on the space of states , which nevertheless are equivalent because they lead to the same density matrix . in refs .
@xcite brody et al .
, propose their quantum microcanonical postulate which asserts that every quantum state possessing the same energy expectation value must be realized with the same probability .
brody and coworkers also introduce an alternative quantum canonical distribution and studied some of its properties . the distribution is defined as a density on the space of pure quantum states that assigns to each state the boltzmann weight associated with the expectation value of the hamiltonian .
these ideas have been adopted with different degrees of intensity by several authors in the last years using even different distributions ( see refs .
@xcite for some examples ) . in this work
we focus on the particular state - space distribution introduced in refs .
@xcite and , following jona - lasinio and presilla , we refer to it as the schrdinger - gibbs ( sg ) distribution .
a crucial result of this construction is that , as suggested by fig . 2 of ref .
@xcite , the third law of thermodynamics may not be satisfied .
therefore it is desirable to know why this happens and whether some other essential properties of the equilibrium thermodynamics , such as the definition of consistent extensive magnitudes , are maintained when using the sg distribution . in this work
we prove that , when considered on composite noninteracting quantum systems , this distribution defines partition functions that do not factorize as products of partition functions of the subsystems , even in the thermodynamical regime .
this implies that it is not possible to define extensive thermodynamical magnitudes such as the free energy , the internal energy or the thermodynamic entropy by using these models .
therefore , although schrdinger s suggestion might seem reasonable a priori and it could have interesting dynamical features ( as can be learned from some of the references above ) , it can not be used to construct an appropriate quantum thermodynamics ; at least not if the suggestion is materialized in the form of the sg distribution used as an equilibrium distribution .
the structure of the paper is as follows . in section [ sec : two - canon - ensembl ] we review the traditional canonical distribution as well as the sg distribution , and we discuss the different alternative forms to present them .
section [ sec : quant - prop - boltzm ] studies the quantum properties associated with the density matrix that encodes the properties of the sg distribution , in particular that it commutes with the hamiltonian .
section [ sec : therm - prop - boltzm ] and section [ sec : orig - non - extens ] contain the main result of the paper : we prove that the partition function of the new quantum ensemble does not factorize in the case of composite noninteracting systems . in section [ sec : additivity - entropy ] we present a simple model to exemplify our analysis , and discuss it from several points of view .
namely , we evaluate the partition function , the possible definitions of thermodynamic extensive magnitudes , and an alternative description in terms of density matrices . in both approaches
we identify the lack of factorizability and one of its causes : basically , that the density matrix associated with the sg distribution represents an entangled state . in section [ sec : conclusions ] , we briefly summarize the content of the paper and consider the potential impact of our analysis on the study of the equilibrium and non - equilibrium statistics of hybrid quantum - classical systems .
consider a physical system on a hilbert space @xmath2 of dimension @xmath3 .
we define the dynamics by a hamiltonian @xmath4 . in this context , the traditional quantum canonical ensemble ( qce , see standard textbooks such as ref .
@xcite for details ) is the ensemble defined by the density matrix @xmath5 where the partition function @xmath6 is defined as @xmath7 one may alternatively arrive at ensemble definitions by establishing first a probability distribution @xmath8 on the hilbert space @xmath2 with respect to the canonical volume element @xmath9 , or equivalently , a probability distribution @xmath10 on the projective space @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the orthogonal projector onto the one - dimensional subspace generated by state @xmath13 .
these distributions can then be used to define the ensembles , i.e. , to construct the density matrices : given any probability distribution @xmath14 defined on the state space , the corresponding density matrix is given by : @xmath15 where @xmath16 represents a ( dynamically ) invariant measure on @xmath11 .
different distributions @xmath14 and @xmath17 may lead to the same density matrix , and must then be considered equivalent .
this is just reflecting the well known ambiguity in the definition of a density matrix : given a density matrix @xmath0 , there are infinitely many ways of writing it as a convex combination of rank - one projectors
. one may now prove that the average value of an arbitrary quantum observable @xmath18 , can be calculated as ( see @xcite ) @xmath19 where @xmath20 .
however the result is exactly the same if we compute @xmath21 where @xmath0 is eq .
( [ equation3 ] )
. one can construct one of such probability distributions to obtain the quantum canonical ensemble @xmath22 .
let us begin with a distribution defined on the hilbert space as : @xmath23 with the partition function @xmath24 where @xmath25 represent the energy eigenvectors of the hamiltonian @xmath4 and @xmath26 the corresponding eigenvalues .
of course , as we mentioned above , this representation is not unique .
if we prefer to consider the distribution as defined on the projective space @xmath11 , we have @xmath27 where now the partition function is written as : @xmath28 where @xmath16 represents an invariant measure on @xmath11 .
notice that these are just the expressions for the spectral decomposition of the density matrix ( [ eq:36 ] ) written as a probability distribution on @xmath29 or @xmath11 .
these distributions select , out of all states of @xmath2 ( equivalently of @xmath11 ) , only those that are eigenstates of the hamiltonian , and assigns to them the corresponding boltzmann probability .
this may lead one to think that the canonical ensemble contains some kind of preference for those states , but this is not true . invoking the above - mentioned non - uniqueness , one may use a different distribution @xmath14 to construct the canonical ensemble @xmath22 , without using delta functions centered at the hamiltonian eigenstates .
it could be a continuous distribution over the entire space , or even one distribution that assigns zero probability to those eigenstates .
brody and coauthors ( see refs .
@xcite ) and jona - lasinio and presilla ( see refs .
@xcite ) introduced another distribution , following the seminal idea by schrdinger @xcite . the main point is to consider , instead of only one state for each eigenvalue of the hamiltonian , all physical states of @xmath2 ( or @xmath11 ) leading to the same expectation value for @xmath4 , and assign to all of them the boltzmann probability with respect to that expectation value , i.e. , @xmath30 .
as we said , we will call this distribution the schrdinger - gibbs distribution and represent it as @xmath31 .
notice that , by construction , @xmath31 can be thought as a direct generalization to the quantum realm of the classical canonical distribution .
however , as we are going to see , its properties are different from the classical case because of the quantum nature of the states it is defined on
. the sg distribution on the hilbert space can thus be written as : @xmath32 where now the partition function reads @xmath33 where we denote by @xmath34 the sphere of vectors in @xmath2 of norm equal to one .
this last distribution is equivalent to a distribution @xmath31 defined on the projective space @xmath11 modulo a constant factor that does not affect the resulting ensemble ( if interested see appendix [ sec : integr - proj - space ] to understand the origin of the constant factor ) .
if we define the expectation value of the operator @xmath4 on projector @xmath35 as @xmath36 the distribution can be written as : @xmath37 with partition function @xmath38 if we evaluate the density matrix associated with the distribution ( [ eq:45 ] ) ( and use the result proved in appendix [ sec : integr - proj - space ] to evaluate the integrals on the sphere @xmath34 of vectors of @xmath2 with norm equal to one ) we obtain : @xmath39 regarding the measure @xmath16 a few comments are in order .
it is well known ( see @xcite and references therein ) that finite dimensional quantum systems defined on @xmath40 admit a hamiltonian structure associated with the canonical khler structure of the manifold .
the schrdinger equation corresponds then to the flow of a hamiltonian vector field associated with the canonical symplectic form .
therefore , the liouville theorem ensures that the corresponding symplectic volume is preserved by the dynamics , as it happens in classical mechanics . as the sphere of vectors with norm one
is also preserved by the dynamics , the natural choice for @xmath16 on @xmath34 is the restriction of the symplectic volume of @xmath40 .
regarding the projective space @xmath11 , again there exists a canonical khler structure on it , also preserved by the dynamics .
therefore we can also consider the corresponding symplectic volume , which will also be invariant .
now , what the physical origin of the differences between eq .
( [ eq:36 ] ) and eq .
( [ eq:49 ] ) is .
if one approaches the canonical ensemble from the microcanonical one the origin is clear .
indeed , while the microcanonical in refs .
@xcite is based on the postulate that every state possessing the same energy expectation value must be democratically realized ( which implements schrdinger s suggestion ) , in the traditional microcanonical ensemble , orthogonal states must be the only ones to be included in the sample space of the statistical thermodynamics .
the arguments for using only orthogonal states are based on the standard theory of probability ( see for instance secs 4.5 and 4.6 of ref .
@xcite and ref @xcite ) , and on the relationship between information theory and thermodynamics @xcite .
let us now study the properties of the density matrix ( [ eq:49 ] ) in more detail .
first of all , for technical reasons that will become clear later , we want to prove that the sg density matrix commutes with the hamiltonian and hence both operators can be diagonalized in a common eigenbasis .
notice that if we consider @xmath41 as a stationary distribution corresponding to an equilibrium situation and the hamiltonian does not depend on time , the result is trivial : @xmath42\quad \longrightarrow \quad \frac{\partial \hat \rho^{sg}(t)}{\partial t}=0 \rightarrow [ \hat h , \hat \rho^{sg}(t)]=0.\ ] ] however _ a priori _ there is no reason to consider @xmath43 to be stationary . in the following , we will prove that it is indeed time - independent .
the simplest way to do this is to consider a unitary evolution for @xmath44 of the form @xmath45 where , as we assume that the hamiltonian does not depend on time , @xmath46 under the same evolution , the volume element @xmath16 on @xmath34 and the expectation value of the energy @xmath47 are , because of unitarity , constant in `` time '' .
thus , for any @xmath48 , we can write @xmath49 and thus , as the volume element is also preserved , we find @xmath50 consider now the expression of the density matrix @xmath41 defined in eq .
( [ eq:49 ] ) which we denote as @xmath51 .
let us consider how the unitary evolution transforms this density matrix after an arbitrary but fixed value of time @xmath52 , i.e. , @xmath53 here @xmath54 defines a transformation on the set of states as @xmath55 which obviously preserves the sphere @xmath34 since @xmath56 and thus we can re - write eq .
( [ eq:55 ] ) as @xmath57 we know that the measure is invariant , i.e. , @xmath58 and therefore , as the sphere @xmath34 is invariant and the integral runs over all normalized states , we can write @xmath59 which is the same as eq . ( [ eq:49 ] ) .
hence , we have proved that @xmath60 as the value of @xmath52 was generic , we conclude that the density matrix is independent of @xmath48 and hence commutes with the hamiltonian : @xmath61=0.\ ] ] on a different matter , in order to compute the integral in eq .
( [ eq:49 ] ) , we can use the tools of complex analysis , as presented in appendix [ sec : partition - function ] .
the result for the partition function is obtained in eqs .
( [ eq:76]-[eq:80 ] ) . assuming that there exist @xmath62 different eigenvalues of the hamiltonian @xmath4 with degeneracies @xmath63 , the partition function is written as : @xmath64 where @xmath65 and @xmath66 represents the multinomial coefficient @xmath67 notice that the traditional distribution ( [ eq:41 ] ) associated with the qce corresponds to the case where @xmath68 where @xmath69 stands for the degeneracy of the energy level @xmath70 . from the above expressions ,
we can obtain the spectral decomposition of the density matrix @xmath41 defined by eq .
( [ eq:49 ] ) .
indeed , we know that @xmath41 is diagonal in the energy - eigenbasis , and thus it can be written as @xmath71 where the eigenvalue @xmath72 corresponding to the eigenvector @xmath73 is equal to : @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
each @xmath72 is thus obtained as a suitable derivative of the partition function @xmath76 , as in the case of the canonical distribution : @xmath77 therefore , we just proved that the probability distribution ( [ eq:43 ] ) can be written as @xmath78 which is formally analogous to the distribution ( [ eq:41 ] ) , but with very different content because of the second term in the sum .
if we write it as a density matrix we have : @xmath79 notice that the second term is such that @xmath80 and then @xmath81
. only if the functions @xmath82 were independent from the energy eigenvalues and equal to the degeneracies @xmath69 , would @xmath41 coincide with the usual canonical distribution @xmath83 in eq .
( [ eq:36 ] ) .
thus , given any @xmath84 , the average value of any quantum observable @xmath18 will be in general different in the ensembles and , in general , the properties of the ensembles will not coincide .
we will return to this point in section [ sec : additivity - entropy ] .
a similar computation for some particular cases can be found in @xcite .
indeed , the authors analyze the completely non - degenerate case of a general system , and the strong coupling limit of a spin - spin interaction hamiltonian .
nonetheless , the authors of @xcite do not study the implications of their results at the thermodynamic level , as we will in the next section .
we have just seen how , even if @xmath31 is analogous to the canonical distribution of a classical ( continuous ) system , the quantum nature of the system it describes makes it equivalent to a quantum ensemble described by a density matrix @xmath41 that is different from the traditional canonical one .
we want to check now if , despite these differences , we can still define an appropriate thermodynamics associated with the sg distribution . in order to define a system in thermodynamical equilibrium ,
we must obtain the corresponding thermodynamic magnitudes , both extensive and intensive ones , from the statistical - mechanics objects .
thus , for a system described by a partition function @xmath6 , the helmholtz free energy @xmath14 ( which is the natural free energy in the canonical ensemble ) corresponds to @xmath85 the thermodynamic ( also called sometimes `` internal '' ) energy @xmath86 corresponds to the average value of the energy , which can be obtained through @xmath87 and the thermodynamic entropy @xmath88 is written as @xmath89 if the partition function @xmath6 is factorizable , the functions @xmath90 and @xmath88 are extensive magnitudes . then
, the extensiveness of the functions @xmath14 , @xmath86 or @xmath88 in the present case , is equivalent to the factorizability property of the partition function @xmath76 .
that is , if we consider a system defined as the composition of non - interacting subsystems , the partition function of the complete system must be written as the product of the partition function restricted to the subsystems in order to yield extensive thermodynamic functions .
notice that , so far , @xmath84 represents just a parameter that is used to define the partition function and ultimately may not have any physical meaning ( for example , if the resulting thermodynamics is found to be inappropriate ) .
consider then that the total hilbert space @xmath2 is equal to the tensor product of the hilbert spaces describing the corresponding subsystems , i.e. , @xmath91 with dimensions @xmath92 ( for simplicity we assume the case of finite - dimensional quantum systems ) .
the dimension of @xmath2 is thus given by @xmath93 .
since we assume that there is no interaction among the subsystems , the total hamiltonian is written as the sum @xmath94 as all @xmath95 commute , the tensor product of the eigenbases of the @xmath96 is an eigenbasis of the total hamiltonian @xmath97 .
we thus have that each element of the total - energy eigenbasis @xmath98 of the subsystems ( with corresponding eigenvalues @xmath99 ) : @xmath100 with no loss of generality , we will assume that @xmath101 it is well known that the partition function of the canonical distribution @xmath83 in eq . ( [ eq:36 ] ) factorizes as a product of the partition function of the subsystems ( see @xcite , sec .
if we compute the partition function @xmath76 in this basis , we obtain as a result eq .
( [ eq:76b ] ) .
if we did the same computation restricted to the subsystem @xmath102 , we would obtain similar expressions for the partition functions @xmath103 , with the eigenvalues @xmath70 replaced by the eigenvalues @xmath104 . in order to check whether or not @xmath76 factorizes , let us consider the limit @xmath105 , where we can write that @xmath106 analogously , @xmath107 factorizability of the partition function would require that @xmath108 which implies : @xmath109 however we can immediately check that @xmath110 indeed , in the non - degenerate groundstate case , eq .
( [ eq:80b ] ) becomes for @xmath111 and @xmath112 , respectively @xmath113 and thus it is simple to prove that @xmath114 the last inequality can be easily understood by thinking that , on the right hand side , there are only energy differences corresponding to a change in one subsystem , while , on the left hand side , all possible energy differences are considered .
this being so in the limit @xmath105 is sufficient to prove that the partition function @xmath76 is not the product of the partition functions of the subsystems , and therefore that we can not define extensive magnitudes from @xmath76 .
besides , this property does not depend on the number of subsystems , and therefore it is still valid in a thermodynamic limit where @xmath115 ; i.e. , we can claim that @xmath116 we thus conclude that the thermodynamic functions defined by eqs .
( [ eq:86 ] ) , ( [ eq:87 ] ) or ( [ eq:88 ] ) can not represent extensive magnitudes .
in principle we may study the same problem from the point of view of the density matrix @xmath41 , but doing so in full generality becomes quite difficult from the computational point of view .
we will tackle this analysis in sec .
[ sec : additivity - entropy ] for the case of a specific quantum system resulting from the composition of two - level systems , and we will recover the same results obtained here but in a much simpler way .
let us consider the simplest case of a composite system by assuming that we have @xmath117 in eqs .
( [ eq:89 ] ) and ( [ eq:90 ] ) . we know from eq .
( [ eq:50 ] ) that @xmath118 now , we want to understand the origin of this difference from a physical point of view . the partition functions for the individual subsystems and for the composite system will read ,
respectively : @xmath119 @xmath120 and @xmath121 where @xmath122 and @xmath123 represent the @xmath124-dimensional , @xmath125dimensional and @xmath126-dimensional spheres . we can write the product of two integrals like that of eq .
( [ eq:98 ] ) as @xmath127 in a basis like the one in ( [ eq:91 ] ) , constituted by separable vectors , we have @xmath128 the separability of the vectors allows us to write @xmath129 thus the resulting exponent is the expectation value of the hamiltonian @xmath130 , evaluated at the separable points of @xmath131 .
notice that in the sum above , @xmath132 runs from 1 to @xmath133 and @xmath134 from 1 to @xmath135 , in such a way that the coordinate expression of a separable state @xmath13 reads @xmath136 putting everything together , we have just proved that : @xmath137 equation ( [ eq:15 ] ) sums the same function as ( [ eq:98c ] ) , but only over the separable states of @xmath138 ; while ( [ eq:98c ] ) integrates over all states , both separable and entangled .
this explains eq .
( [ eq:16 ] ) from the physical point of view .
if we compare this situation with the traditional canonical distribution described by eq .
( [ eq:41 ] ) , we see that the delta functions would restrict the corresponding integrals to the eigenvectors of the hamiltonian @xmath4 , which , in the case of non - interacting subsystems , correspond always to separable states . in addition , the statistical weight assigned to each of these eigenstates depends only on the eigenspace . in contrast , if we think about the sg distribution in terms of the corresponding density matrix ( i.e. , using expression ( [ eq:85 ] ) ) , we would be considering , apparently , only separable states ( the hamiltonian eigenstates participating of the spectral decomposition ) , but now the statistical weights associated with them do not factorize . therefore the density matrix ( [ eq:85 ] ) is not separable .
we will illustrate this in a simple example in next section .
in this section we will present numerical examples of the properties discussed in the previous section .
we will analyze the two different distributions ( ( [ eq:41 ] ) and ( [ eq:44 ] ) ) for a system of @xmath139 noninteracting two - level particles whose dynamics is described by a hamiltonian of the form @xmath140 where @xmath141 stands for the identity operator in two dimensions and the one - particle hamiltonian @xmath142 can be written in the corresponding eigenbasis as @xmath143 where @xmath144 represents the energy - gap .
let us now consider a basis for @xmath2 defined as the tensor product of the energy eigenbases of every two - level subsystem .
thus , if we write @xmath145 for short , we have the set of vectors of the form @xmath146 we also fix an ordering for the basis : @xmath147 in this basis , it is a simple task to verify that the eigenvalues @xmath148 of the total hamiltonian @xmath97 and the corresponding degeneracies @xmath69 are given by @xmath149 our goal now is to obtain the expressions for the schrdinger - gibbs distribution corresponding to this hamiltonian .
we saw that the ensemble is defined by the partition function in ( [ eq:44 ] ) .
thus , our goal is to write @xmath150 for the particular case of the hamiltonian in eq .
( [ eq:6 ] ) .
previously , from the analysis in appendix [ sec : partition - function ] , the expression for @xmath76 was written as in eq .
( [ eq:76b ] ) , where now @xmath145 and the spectrum is given by eq .
( [ eq:30 ] ) .
the simplest cases can be easily written .
indeed , we can consider the case @xmath151 ( i.e. , @xmath152 ) and write eq . ( [ eq:76b ] ) as @xmath153 analogously , the next case is @xmath154 ( or , equivalently , @xmath155 ) : @xmath156 we can immediately check that , as we proved in general , the partition function does not factorize , i.e. , @xmath157 we can also compute the corresponding entropy functions @xmath88 using eq .
( [ eq:88 ] ) .
we obtain : @xmath158 and @xmath159 again , it is simple to verify that these functions are not additive , i.e. , that @xmath160 therefore , we must conclude that @xmath88 can not model an extensive magnitude , and hence it can not represent the thermodynamic entropy of a physical system . besides this non - extensiveness , @xmath88 does not satisfy other properties that are required for the thermodynamic entropy , such as positiveness and that it must tend to zero in the limit where @xmath161 tends to zero .
of course , in this case , @xmath162 must be considered just a parameter and in no way can it be identified with a physical temperature . notice
that this behavior does not follow from the non - extensiveness of the ensemble , since it is present in the @xmath151 case where non - extensiveness is meaningless . as we mentioned in the previous section ,
the ensemble encoded in eq ( [ eq:85 ] ) is completely different from the canonical ensemble ( [ eq:36 ] ) and therefore its properties will , in general , be different . thus it is natural that @xmath163 defines extensive thermodynamical functions while @xmath43 does not and it is also natural that the behavior in the limit @xmath164 of the corresponding entropies differ .
regarding the nonextensiveness of @xmath43 , we proved in section [ sec : orig - non - extens ] that it is related to the integration over entangled states in the definition of the ensemble ( eq . [ eq:46 ] ) .
we do not have a similar proof to explain the behavior of the entropy in the @xmath164 limit , but it is evident that entanglement is not the only reason .
if we also compute the case @xmath165 ( see ) , we can represent the corresponding entropies together with the previous ones and confirm that , again , their zero-@xmath162 limit is different from zero and the functions are negative in a measurable part of their domains ( see fig .
[ fig5 ] ) .
( dotted line ) , @xmath166 ( thin line ) , @xmath167 ( thick line ) versus t for @xmath168 and @xmath169 for the sg ensemble .
we can easily verify the non - additivity property of the function @xmath88 and the violation of the third law , since the entropy does not go to zero in the limit @xmath164,width=566 ] if we consider the analogous quantity for the canonical ensemble ( @xmath163 defined in eq .
( [ eq:36 ] ) ) in the same system , we find a very different behavior .
indeed , we can immediately obtain that @xmath170 we can plot the first three cases for the same parameter values as before , and obtain an equally spaced set of functions , as we can see in figure [ fig : canonical ] . of the canonical ensemble vs. @xmath162 with @xmath151 ( dotted line ) , @xmath154 ( thin line ) , @xmath165 ( thick line ) and for @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
we see how additivity is clearly preserved and that the limit @xmath164 is equal to zero .
, width=566 ] we can also consider other magnitudes such as the specific heat @xmath171 ( computed as @xmath172 ) , which we plot in fig . [ fig : cv ] . for @xmath173
, we recover the dependence obtained by brody and coworkers in the simplest @xmath151 case @xcite , but we can also see ( thanks to the more general calculations in this work ) how @xmath173 scales with the number of subsystems @xmath139 . with @xmath151 ( dotted line ) , @xmath154 ( thin line ) , @xmath165 ( thick line ) and for @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
we can see that the limit when @xmath164 increases with @xmath139 , while for a consistent thermodynamic description it must go to zero.,width=566 ] finally , notice that @xmath173 increases with @xmath139 in the limit @xmath164 , while for a consistent thermodynamic description it must go to zero .
this is a property that is preserved in the usual canonical ensemble .
therefore , its violation can not be considered a consequence of the quantum nature of the system but an essential property of the sg ensemble that can not be disregarded .
apart from the description in terms of probability distributions , we can also describe the systems in the previous sections by their corresponding density matrices , using eq .
( [ eq:85 ] ) . for the simple cases @xmath151 and @xmath154 we obtain : @xmath174 and @xmath175 where @xmath176 and @xmath177 represent the energy eigenstates for @xmath151 , and @xmath178 and @xmath179 are the eigenstates associated with the @xmath154 case .
the vectors @xmath180 and @xmath181 span the two - dimensional eigenspace with energy equal to @xmath182 in the last @xmath154 case .
it is now easy to verify that @xmath183 it suffices to check that the coefficients of the projectors onto the ground state ( @xmath184 ) do not coincide .
this relation translates eq .
( [ eq:63 ] ) into the language of density matrices . indeed , since the hamiltonian does not introduce a coupling among the different subsystems , the tensor product of equilibrium density states representing single subsystems ( such as eq .
( [ eq:17 ] ) ) , should define equilibrium density states of the composite system .
this is a property that holds for the usual canonical ensemble in eq .
( [ eq:36 ] ) , but fails for the sg distribution , as we have just shown .
the sg distribution can also be studied from the point of view of von neumann s entropy @xmath185 we know that this quantity is always positive and well defined for any density matrix we evaluate it on .
we can also plot ( see fig . [
fig : vn3 ] ) the von neumann entropies for @xmath151 , @xmath154 and @xmath165 and verify that they are not equally spaced as in the canonical distribution ( figure [ fig : canonical ] ) , where the thermodynamic and the von neumann entropy functions coincide .
( dotted line ) , @xmath154 ( thin line ) and @xmath165 ( thick line ) , vs. @xmath162 , with @xmath186 and @xmath169 .
we can notice that the three levels are not equally spaced , width=566 ] thus , as a consequence of the non - factorizability of the partition function , the von neumann entropy is not additive , even if the subsystems are non - interacting .
obviously , by comparing figure [ fig : vn3 ] and figure [ fig5 ] we can easily verify that , in the sg case , von neumann entropy is not the same function as @xmath88 while in the canonical distribution both entropies coincide .
we can explain this non - additivity of von neumann s entropy in a simple manner if we appeal to the notion of entanglement .
if we compute the partial trace of the density matrix in eq .
( [ eq:19 ] ) , we obtain a density matrix @xmath187 , which we can write as @xmath188 analogously , we can define ( and compute ) @xmath189 however we can immediately verify that @xmath190 this is just reflecting upon the fact that sg density matrices , @xmath191 , represent entangled states , as we advanced in sec .
[ sec : orig - non - extens ] .
indeed , being defined from partition functions @xmath76 which are not factorizable , the description in terms of density matrices @xmath41 must also encode this property , and it does so in the standard way .
we also know that , while separable states have additive von neumann entropy ( see appendix [ sec : addit - von - neum ] for a simple proof ) , the von neumann entropy of entangled states is never additive ( the difference between the entropy of the composite system with respect to the sum of the entropies of the subsystems is what is called the _ quantum mutual information _ in quantum information theory ) .
in this paper we have proved that the schrdinger - gibbs density distribution , defined as the exponential of ( minus @xmath84 times ) the expected value of the hamiltonian operator on the corresponding ray , can not be used to construct a consistent quantum thermodynamics .
it has severe problems at the thermodynamical level ( the third law of thermodynamics is not satisfied , see for instance figure [ fig : cv ] ) , and we have devoted some time to show that , in particular , the thermodynamic functions defined by it are non - extensive .
notice that the definition of the ensemble ( eq .
( [ eq:46 ] ) ) makes perfect sense for finite dimensional quantum systems , where the integral over the projective space is well defined .
the framework we used in appendix [ sec : partition - function ] to perform the integrals for the partition function and to determine from there the expression of @xmath43 ( eq .
( [ eq:85 ] ) ) depends also on the finiteness of the corresponding hilbert space .
a natural question arises : can we extend our conclusions to general quantum systems , defined on infinite dimensional spaces ?
the answer is not simple since the definition itself becomes quite subtle in infinite dimensions , because the rigorous mathematical definition of a functional integral over an infinite dimensional projective space is not an easy task .
however let us assume that the definition of the functional integral is done and let us focus on the generalization of the results .
there are two important points to discuss : the procedure we used in appendix [ sec : partition - function ] and the results we obtain .
obviously the procedure makes sense only if the definition of the integral is done via a limit process over finite dimensional approximations . in this case
we could define an analog of our integrals ( eq .
( [ eq:32]- ( [ eq:76 ] ) ) for each finite dimensional approximation without any change . regarding the results
, the limit process would be straightforward as long as the spectrum of the hamiltonian operator is purely discrete , i.e. , if its essential spectrum is empty ( see @xcite ) . in that case , the dimension of all the eigenspaces is finite and there are no accumulation points in the spectrum . in a situation like this ,
( [ eq:76b ] ) and e. ( [ eq:85 ] ) make sense even in infinite dimensions .
we conclude thus that the sg ensemble does not make sense as an equilibrium distribution because the thermodynamics associated with it fails to satisfy very basic properties such as additivity or the third law . on the other hand ,
the use of density distributions is a natural option when studying hybrid quantum - classical models such as ehrenfest models in nonadiabatic molecular dynamics ( see @xcite and @xcite).we leave for future work the study of the consequences of the analysis in this paper for the equilibrium and non - equilibrium statistics of hybrid quantum - classical systems ( see @xcite for a recent approach to nonequilibrium and irreversibility ) , where the nonlinear effects on the dynamics produced by the classical subsystem may alter significantly the results we have presented here .
we will include , for completeness , a classical proof of the additivity of von neumann s entropy ( see , for instance , @xcite ) .
let @xmath192 be a composite system with hilbert space @xmath193 , of dimension @xmath194 .
we want to prove that the von neumann entropy is additive on product states @xmath195 , i.e. , @xmath196 where @xmath197 .
additivity comes from the fact that the spectrum of @xmath198 consists of the products of the eigenvalues of @xmath199 and @xmath200 : @xmath201 where we denote as @xmath202 and @xmath203 and @xmath204 respectively , and as @xmath205 and @xmath206 the corresponding eigenvalues .
if we compute von neumann s entropy in the eigenbasis of @xmath207 we obtain @xmath208 where the fact that @xmath209 has been used .
as the trace does not depend on the basis , the result is proved .
for the sake of completeness , we prove in this appendix the following result : consider a function @xmath210 defined on the sphere @xmath211 , which is constant along the fibers of the fibration @xmath212 i.e. , which can be obtained as the pullback @xmath213 of a function @xmath210 on the projective space , or , from the physical point of view , which represents a true physical quantity , as it does not depend on the global phase of the state . notice that eq .
( [ eq:1 ] ) corresponds to the restriction of the canonical fibration @xmath214 to the states of norm equal to one .
then , we have that @xmath215 where @xmath216 and @xmath217 represent the corresponding volume forms .
let us recall that both the sphere and the projective space are nontrivial differentiable manifolds and therefore that integrals on them are obtained by patching together the integrals on the charts of their atlases .
thus , given an open covering @xmath218 for the manifold @xmath219 , we consider a subordinated partition of unity @xmath220 , i.e. , a collection of functions @xmath221 that satisfy that for any point @xmath222 , the sum of the functions corresponding to the open sets to which the point belong , is equal to one : @xmath223 with these , we define the integral on the manifold @xmath219 as @xmath224 where @xmath14 represents a function on @xmath219 , @xmath16 represents the corresponding volume element , and @xmath225 and @xmath226 represent the restrictions of the volume element and the function , respectively , to the open set @xmath227 .
we can now use the bundle structure @xmath228 to define a covering for @xmath229 as a product : @xmath230 where @xmath231 represent open sets of a covering for @xmath232 and @xmath233 represent open sets of a covering of the projective space .
such a covering always exists because of the bundle structure .
then , consider a partition of unity @xmath220 for @xmath234 associated with the covering defined by the open sets @xmath235 .
we can extend this family to define a covering for @xmath229 by considering a partition of the unity @xmath236 associated with the covering @xmath237 for the group @xmath238 , and defining @xmath239 it is trivial to verify that @xmath240 defines a partition of the unity related to the covering @xmath241 .
next , we can define the integral on the sphere as : @xmath242 and , as the integrand is constant on the fibers , we can split the integral in the following way : @xmath243 by definition the integral on @xmath244 is equal to @xmath245 and thus we proved that eq .
( [ eq:2 ] ) holds .
our goal in this appendix is to compute the partition function @xmath246 where we recall that the relation of the integral on the unit sphere and the integral on the projective space ( which is the physically meaningful one ) is explained in appendix [ sec : integr - proj - space ] .
consider this distribution written as in eq .
( [ eq:46 ] ) and implement the constraint by a complex integral in the form @xmath247 where @xmath248 is the canonical volume element in @xmath40 .
now , the gaussian integrals factorize and can be computed straightforwardly : @xmath249 if we also take into account the degeneracies of the eigenvalues we have : @xmath250 where @xmath69 represents the degeneracy of eigenvalue @xmath70 and the product runs only over different eigenvalues ( we assume that there are @xmath62 of them ) .
the last integral ( over @xmath251 ) must be evaluated on the complex plane , where the integration runs over the real axis . to this end , let us first make a change of coordinates @xmath252 that produces : @xmath253 where now @xmath254 is the imaginary axis . from the cauchy theorem , we know that the integral is equal to the sum of the corresponding residues at the poles of the integrand , which in this case lie on @xmath256 their order corresponding to the degeneracy of the corresponding eigenvalue .
we have thus that : @xmath257 we would like to thank professor mario flora for several enlightening discussions that guided us in the right direction .
we would also like to thank an anonymous referee for a very careful reading of the manuscript , which has improved it in a very significant manner .
this work was supported by diputacin general de aragn ( spain ) grants no .
e24/1 , no .
e24/2 , and no .
e24/3 ; banco de santander and universidad de zaragoza grant no .
uz2012-cie-06 ; and ministerio de economia y competitividad ( spain ) grants no .
fis2013 - 46159-c3 - 2-p and no .
fpa2012 - 35453 .
43ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _
_ ( , ) http://books.google.es/books?id=5a58_f-16vqc[__ ] , dover books on mathematics series ( , ) @noop `` , '' ( ) link:\doibase 10.1088/1751 - 8113/44/39/395004 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.4737861 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1063/1.532661 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0305 - 4470/38/38/l01 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1742 - 6596/67/1/012025 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1088/1742 - 5468/2006/06/p06015 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s10955 - 006 - 9210-z [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3455998 [ * * , ( ) ] http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jp9039989 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.80.051130 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0031 - 8949/2012/t151/014078 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.050401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s00220 - 011 - 1205 - 1 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/15/11/115008 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physleta.2013.05.041 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.laa.2012.10.043 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , , ) http://books.google.es/books?id=8rlvaaaamaaj[__ ] ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) http://books.google.es/books?id=bzughg0xiiwc[__ ] ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.82.2835 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) _ _ , @noop , ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1063/1.4820010 [ , ( ) ] http://books.google.es/books?id=-s4dey7o-a0c[__ ] ( , ) http://books.google.es/books?id=rmgqmyfbcl8c[__ ] , fundamental theories of physics ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.81.1 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.106.070401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.188901 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.188902 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physleta.2010.03.060 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.50.221 [ * * , ( ) ] | schrodinger suggested that thermodynamical functions can not be based on the gratuitous allegation that quantum - mechanical levels ( typically the orthogonal eigenstates of the hamiltonian operator ) are the only allowed states for a quantum system [ e. schrodinger , statistical thermodynamics ( courier dover , mineola , 1967 ) ] .
different authors have interpreted this statement by introducing density distributions on the space of quantum pure states with weights obtained as functions of the expectation value of the hamiltonian of the system . in this work we focus on one of the best known of these distributions , and we prove that , when considered in composite quantum systems , it defines partition functions that do not factorize as products of partition functions of the noninteracting subsystems , even in the thermodynamical regime .
this implies that it is not possible to define extensive thermodynamical magnitudes such as the free energy , the internal energy or the thermodynamic entropy by using these models .
therefore , we conclude that this distribution inspired by schrdinger s idea can not be used to construct an appropriate quantum equilibrium thermodynamics . |
thanks to the super - kamiokande @xcite and sno @xcite experiments , both solar and atmospheric neutrino oscillations are convincingly established .
it turns out that neutrinos _
do _ have masses and lepton flavors are really mixed , just as expected in some grand unified theories .
two neutrino mass - squared differences and three lepton mixing angles have been measured or constrained by current neutrino oscillation data @xcite .
a more precise determination of these parameters has to rely on the new generation of accelerator neutrino experiments with very long baselines @xcite , in which leptonic cp violation may also be observed .
the terrestrial matter effects in all long - baseline neutrino experiments must be taken into account , since they can unavoidably modify the genuine behaviors of neutrino oscillations in vacuum . to formulate the probabilities of neutrino oscillations in matter in the same form as those in vacuum
, one may define the _ effective _ neutrino masses @xmath0 and the _ effective _ lepton flavor mixing matrix @xmath1 in which the terrestrial matter effects are already included . in this common approach , it is necessary to find out the relationship between the fundamental quantities of neutrino mixing in vacuum ( @xmath2 and @xmath3 ) and their effective counterparts in matter ( @xmath0 and @xmath1 ) . the exact formulas of @xmath0 and @xmath1 as functions of @xmath2 and @xmath3 have been achieved by a number of authors @xcite , and the similar expressions of @xmath2 and @xmath3 in terms of @xmath0 and @xmath1 have been derived in ref .
the latter case is equivalently interesting in phenomenology , because our physical purpose is to determine the fundamental parameters of lepton flavor mixing from the effective ones , whose values can directly be measured from a variety of long - baseline neutrino oscillation experiments .
this paper aims to reconstruct the genuine neutrino mixing matrix @xmath3 and its unitarity triangles from possible long - baseline neutrino oscillations with terrestrial matter effects .
our work is remarkably different from the existing ones @xcite in the following aspects : * we derive a new set of sum rules between @xmath4 and @xmath5 .
it may perfectly complement the sum rules obtained in ref .
we show that similar results can be achieved in the four - neutrino mixing scheme . *
our sum rules allow us to calculate the moduli of @xmath6 ( for @xmath7 and @xmath8 ) in terms of those of @xmath9 .
this approach , which results in some much simpler relations between @xmath10 and @xmath11 , proves to be more useful than that proposed in our previous work @xcite .
the sides of three unitarity triangles can also be derived in a similar way .
* we express the neutrino oscillation probabilities in terms of @xmath11 and the matter - corrected jarlskog parameter @xmath12 @xcite .
the fundamental lepton flavor mixing matrix @xmath3 and its unitarity triangles can then be reconstructed from possible long - baseline neutrino oscillations straightforwardly and parametrization - independently .
the only assumption to be made is a constant earth density profile .
such an assumption is rather reasonable and close to reality for most of the presently - proposed terrestrial long - baseline neutrino oscillation experiments @xcite , in which the neutrino beam is not expected to go through the earth s core .
the remaining parts of this paper are organized as follows . in section
ii , we figure out a new set of sum rules between @xmath13 and @xmath5 and discuss its extension in the four - neutrino mixing scheme .
section iii is devoted to the calculation of @xmath10 in terms of @xmath14 .
we also show how to derive the sides of three unitarity triangles in a similar approach . in section
iv , the neutrino oscillation probabilities are presented in terms of @xmath11 and @xmath12 .
we illustrate the dependence of different oscillation terms on the neutrino beam energy and the baseline length .
section v is devoted to a brief summary of our main results .
in the basis where the flavor eigenstates of charged leptons are identified with their mass eigenstates , the lepton flavor mixing matrix @xmath3 is defined to link the neutrino mass eigenstates ( @xmath15 ) to the neutrino flavor eigenstates ( @xmath16 ) : @xmath17 a similar definition can be made for @xmath1 , the effective counterpart of @xmath3 in matter .
the strength of cp violation in normal neutrino oscillations is measured by a rephasing - invariant quantity @xmath18 ( in vacuum ) or @xmath12 ( in matter ) , the so - called jarlskog parameter @xcite : @xmath19 where the greek subscripts @xmath20 and the latin subscripts @xmath21 run over @xmath22 and @xmath23 , respectively .
the effective hamiltonian responsible for the propagation of neutrinos in vacuum or in matter can be written as @xmath24 where @xmath25 and @xmath26 , @xmath27 is the neutrino beam energy , @xmath28 and @xmath29 denote the corresponding genuine and matter - corrected neutrino mass matrices in the chosen flavor basis , @xmath2 and @xmath0 ( for @xmath30 ) stand respectively for the neutrino masses in vacuum and those in matter .
the deviation of @xmath31 from @xmath32 results non - trivially from the charged - current contribution to the @xmath33 forward scattering @xcite , when neutrinos travel through a normal material medium like the earth : @xmath34 where @xmath35 with @xmath36 being the background density of electrons .
subsequently we assume a constant earth density profile ( i.e. , @xmath36 = constant ) , which is a very good approximation for most of the long - baseline neutrino experiments proposed at present .
( 3 ) implies that @xmath37 and @xmath38 hold , in which @xmath39 , etc . to be explicit ,
we obtain @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 run over @xmath43 , @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
the simplest connection between @xmath46 and @xmath47 is their linear relation with @xmath48 ; i.e. , @xmath49 as indicated by eqs .
( 3 ) and ( 4 ) . with the help of eqs . ( 5 ) and ( 6 ) , one may easily find @xmath50 where @xmath51 . in the @xmath52 case , eq .
( 7 ) reproduces the sum rules obtained in ref .
a new set of sum rules can be achieved , if the square relation @xmath53 is taken into account .
resolving eq .
( 8) by use of eqs .
( 4 ) and ( 5 ) , we arrive at @xmath54 v_{\alpha i}v^*_{\beta i } \right \ } + a^2 \delta_{\alpha e}\delta_{e \beta } \ ; .
% ( 9)\ ] ] eqs .
( 7 ) and ( 9 ) , together with the unitarity conditions @xmath55 constitute a full set of linear equations of @xmath56 or @xmath57 for @xmath58 and 3 .
we shall make use of these equations to derive the concrete expressions of @xmath59 in terms of @xmath2 , @xmath0 and @xmath60 in the next section .
it is worth remarking that the sum rules in eq .
( 9 ) are completely different from those presented in refs .
@xcite , where the relationship between @xmath61 and @xmath62 has been used .
our new result can appreciably simplify the calculations of @xmath10 in terms of @xmath11 ( or vice versa ) , as one may see later .
( 7 ) and ( 9 ) may be generalized to include the mixing between one sterile neutrino ( @xmath63 ) and three active neutrinos ( @xmath64 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 ) . in this case
, @xmath3 is redefined to link the neutrino mass eigenstates @xmath67 to the neutrino flavor eigenstates @xmath68 : @xmath69 and @xmath1 can be redefined in the same manner .
the matrices @xmath70 , @xmath71 and @xmath72 in eqs . ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) are now rewritten as @xmath73 in which @xmath74 denotes the sterile neutrino s mass , and @xmath75 with @xmath76 being the background density of neutrons @xcite .
different from @xmath77 , @xmath78 measures the universal neutral - current interactions of @xmath64 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 with terrestrial matter .
both @xmath77 and @xmath78 are assumed to be constant throughout this work
. then two sets of sum rules can respectively be derived from the linear and square relations given in eqs .
( 6 ) and ( 8) : @xmath79 v_{\alpha i}v^*_{\beta i } \right \ } \nonumber \\ & & + { a'}^2 \delta_{\alpha s}\delta_{s \beta } + a^2 \delta_{\alpha e}\delta_{e \beta } \ ; .
% ( 13)\end{aligned}\ ] ] of course , one may also make use of the relation between @xmath80 and @xmath81 to derive another set of sum rules between @xmath4 and @xmath5 , although the relevant calculations are somehow lengthy .
it is then possible to establish a full set of linear equations of @xmath57 or @xmath59 for @xmath82 and 3 in the four - neutrino mixing scheme , from which both the moduli of @xmath6 and the sides of six unitarity quadrangles of @xmath3 @xcite can be derived in terms of @xmath77 , @xmath78 and the neutrino mass and mixing parameters in matter .
such an idea and its phenomenological consequences will be elaborated elsewhere .
now let us calculate the moduli of @xmath6 by using eqs .
( 7 ) , ( 9 ) and ( 10 ) in the conventional three - neutrino mixing scheme , assuming that @xmath11 can directly be determined from possible long - baseline neutrino oscillation experiments .
those three equations are rewritten , in the @xmath83 case , as follows : @xmath84 where @xmath85 with the help of the relationship @xcite @xmath86 we solve eq .
( 14 ) and obtain the following exact results : @xmath87 and @xmath88 and @xmath89 in which the neutrino mass - squared differences @xmath90 and @xmath91 are defined .
one can see that these results are more instructive and much simpler than those obtained in ref .
@xcite , because we have introduced a new set of sum rules in eq .
next we calculate @xmath59 in terms of @xmath57 ( for @xmath92 ) .
the former can form three unitarity triangles in the complex plane , which were originally named as @xmath93 with @xmath94 , @xmath95 with @xmath96 , and @xmath97 with @xmath98 in ref .
their effective counterparts in matter are then referred to as @xmath99 , @xmath100 and @xmath101 . taking account of eqs .
( 7 ) , ( 9 ) and ( 10 ) , one may easily write down a full set of equations of @xmath59 with @xmath52 : @xmath102 where @xmath103 & m_2 ^ 2 \left [ m_2 ^ 2 + a \left ( \delta_{\alpha e } + \delta_{e \beta } \right ) \right ] & m_3 ^ 2 \left [ m_3 ^ 2 + a \left ( \delta_{\alpha e } + \delta_{e \beta } \right ) \right ] \cr } \right ) \ ; , \nonumber \\ \tilde{o}_2 & = & \left ( \matrix { 1 & 1 & 1 \cr \tilde{m}_1 ^ 2 & \tilde{m}_2 ^ 2 & \tilde{m}_3 ^ 2 \cr \tilde{m}_1 ^ 4 & \tilde{m}_2 ^ 4 & \tilde{m}_3 ^ 4 \cr } \right ) \ ;
. % ( 21)\end{aligned}\ ] ] we solve eq .
( 20 ) and arrive at @xmath104 for @xmath93 ; and @xmath105 for @xmath95 ; and @xmath106 for @xmath97 , where @xmath107 denote the neutrino mass - squared differences in vacuum .
these results are exactly the same as those obtained in ref .
@xcite , although a different approach has been followed .
( 22 ) , ( 23 ) or ( 24 ) allows us to establish a direct relation between @xmath18 and @xmath12 defined in eq .
a straightforward calculation yields @xmath108 , which has been derived in refs .
@xcite in a different way . for the sake of completeness ,
let us list the expressions of two independent @xmath109 in terms of their effective counterparts in matter .
@xmath110 \ ; , \nonumber \\ { \delta}_{32 } & = & \displaystyle \frac{1}{3 } \sqrt{\tilde{x}^2 - 3\tilde{y } } \left [ 3 \tilde{z } - \sqrt{3 \left ( 1 - \tilde{z}^2 \right ) } \right ] \ ; , % ( 25)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xcite @xmath111 \ ; .
% ( 26)\end{aligned}\ ] ] three independent @xmath112 can be expressed as @xmath113 \ ; , \nonumber \\ \widehat{\delta}_{22 } & = & \displaystyle \frac{1}{3 } \tilde{x } - \frac{1}{3 } \sqrt{\tilde{x}^2 - 3\tilde{y } } \left [ \tilde{z } - \sqrt{3 \left ( 1 - \tilde{z}^2 \right ) } \right ] - \widetilde\delta_{21 } \ ; , \nonumber \\ \widehat{\delta}_{33 } & = & \displaystyle \frac{1}{3 } \tilde{x } + \frac{2}{3 } \tilde{z } \sqrt{\tilde{x}^2 - 3\tilde{y } } ~ - \widetilde\delta_{31 } \ ; .
% ( 27)\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath114 holds .
thus both @xmath109 and @xmath112 are fully calculable , once @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath77 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 ( or @xmath119 ) are specified .
note that the afore - obtained results are only valid for neutrinos propagating in vacuum and interacting with matter . as for antineutrinos
, the corresponding results can simply be obtained through the replacements @xmath120 and @xmath121 ( and @xmath122 for the four - neutrino mixing scheme ) .
the matter - corrected moduli @xmath11 and the effective jarlskog parameter @xmath12 can , at least in principle , be determined from a variety of long - baseline neutrino oscillation experiments . to be concrete ,
the survival probability of a neutrino @xmath123 and its conversion probability into another neutrino @xmath124 are given by @xcite @xmath125 - 8\tilde{j } \prod \limits_{i <
j } \left(\sin \tilde{f}_{ji } \right ) \ , % ( 28)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath126 run over @xmath127 , @xmath128 or @xmath129 , @xmath130 with @xmath131 being the baseline length ( in unit of km ) and @xmath27 being the neutrino beam energy ( in unit of gev ) , and @xmath12 has been defined in eq .
the @xmath132 term in @xmath133 can be expressed as @xmath134 with @xmath52 and @xmath135
. then we rewrite eq .
( 28 ) as follows : @xmath136 where @xmath137 some comments on eqs .
( 30 ) and ( 31 ) are in order . * three oscillation terms in @xmath138
are associated with @xmath139 ( with @xmath140 ) .
taking @xmath141 and @xmath142 for example , we obtain an effective unitarity triangle whose three sides are @xmath143 , @xmath144 and @xmath145 in the complex plane
. this triangle was originally named as @xmath146 in ref .
@xcite . triangles @xmath147
( for @xmath148 and @xmath149 ) and @xmath150 ( for @xmath141 and @xmath149 ) can similarly be defined .
their genuine counterparts in vacuum are referred to as @xmath151 for @xmath58 and 3 . if the sides of @xmath152 can all be determined from @xmath153 in some _ disappearance _ neutrino oscillation experiments , it is then possible to calculate individual @xmath11 and to extract @xmath10 by using eqs .
( 17 ) , ( 18 ) and ( 19 ) . *
three sides of triangle @xmath99 , @xmath100 or @xmath101 are associated with three oscillation terms @xmath154 ( for @xmath155 ) of the _ appearance _ neutrino oscillation probability @xmath156 , while the effective cp - violating parameter @xmath12 is relevant to the oscillation term @xmath157 .
to illustrate , we plot the dependence of @xmath154 and @xmath157 on the neutrino ( or antineutrino ) beam energy @xmath27 in fig .
1 , where two typical neutrino baselines @xmath158 @xcite and @xmath159 @xcite have been taken .
the input parameters include @xmath160 , @xmath161 , @xmath162 , @xmath163 , @xmath164 and @xmath165 in the standard parametrization of @xmath3 @xcite .
in addition , the terrestrial matter effects can approximately be described by @xmath166 $ ] @xcite . fig .
1 shows that @xmath154 may have quite different behaviors , if the baseline length is sufficiently large ( e.g. , @xmath167 km or larger ) .
hence the proper changes of @xmath27 and ( or ) @xmath131 would allow us to determine the coefficients of @xmath154 , i.e. , @xmath168 .
the parameter @xmath12 can also be extracted from a suitable long - baseline neutrino oscillation experiment , because the dependence of @xmath157 on @xmath27 and @xmath131 is essentially different from that of @xmath154 .
provided all or most of such measurements are realistically done , the moduli of @xmath6 and leptonic unitarity triangles @xmath93 , @xmath95 and @xmath97 may finally be reconstructed .
* it is clear that both types of neutrino oscillation experiments ( i.e. , appearance and disappearance ) are needed , in order to get more information on lepton flavor mixing and cp violation .
they are actually complementary to each other in determining the moduli of nine matrix elements of @xmath3 and its unitarity triangles . in practice
, the full reconstruction of @xmath3 from @xmath1 requires highly precise and challenging measurements .
a detailed analysis of the unitarity triangle reconstruction can be found from ref .
@xcite , in which the issues of experimental feasibility and difficulties have more or less been addressed .
let us remark that the strategy of this paper is to establish the model - independent relations between @xmath3 and @xmath1 , both their moduli and their unitarity triangles .
hence we have concentrated on the generic formalism instead of the specific scenarios or numerical analyses .
our exact analytical results are expected to be a very useful addition to the phenomenology of lepton flavor mixing and neutrino oscillations .
we have derived a new set of sum rules between @xmath4 and @xmath5 for both three- and four - neutrino mixing schemes . with the help of our sum rules
, we have calculated the moduli of @xmath6 in terms of those of @xmath9 .
the sides of leptonic unitarity triangles @xmath93 , @xmath95 and @xmath97 can also be figured out in a similar way .
we find that it is useful to express the neutrino oscillation probabilities in terms of @xmath11 and the matter - corrected jarlskog parameter @xmath12 .
the fundamental lepton flavor mixing matrix @xmath3 and its six unitarity triangles can then be reconstructed , at least in principle , from a variety of long - baseline neutrino oscillations in a straightforward and parametrization - independent way .
our analytically exact results will be applicable for the study of terrestrial long - baseline neutrino oscillations , from which much better understanding of the neutrino mass spectrum , lepton flavor mixing and cp violation can be achieved .
one of us ( z.z.x . ) is grateful to cssm at the university of adelaide , where this paper was written , for warm hospitality .
our work was supported in part by the national nature science foundation of china .
fisher , b. kayser , and k.s .
mcfarland , ann .
nucl . part .
sci . * 49 * , 481 ( 1999 ) ; b. autin _
et al . _ , cern 99 - 02 ( 1999 ) ; d. ayres _ et al . _ , physics/9911009 ; c. albright _ et al .
_ , hep - ex/0008064 ; and references therein . | we derive a new set of sum rules between the neutrino mass and mixing parameters in vacuum and their effective counterparts in matter .
the moduli of nine genuine lepton mixing matrix elements can then be calculated in terms of the matter - corrected ones , and the latter can directly be determined from a variety of long - baseline neutrino oscillations .
we show that it is possible to reconstruct the leptonic unitarity triangles and cp violation in a similar parametrization - independent way . |
i thank a. b. balantekin , v. barger , d. marfatia and s. pakvasa for collaboration and a. b. mcdonald for useful conversations .
this work was supported in part by the nsf grant no .
phy-0244384 and the wisconsin alumni research foundation . 0 s. n. ahmed _ et al .
_ [ sno collaboration ] , phys . rev .
lett . * 92 * , 181301 ( 2004 ) .
m. b. smy _ et al . _
[ super - kamiokande collaboration ] , phys .
d * 69 * , 011104 ( 2004 ) .
y. ashie _ et al . _
[ super - kamiokande collaboration ] , phys .
lett . *
93 * , 101801 ( 2004 ) .
m. apollonio _ et al . _
[ chooz collaboration ] , phys .
b * 466 * , 415 ( 1999 ) ; f. boehm _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 64 * , 112001 ( 2001 ) ; t. araki _ et al .
_ [ kamland collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - ex/0406035 .
m. h. ahn _
[ k2k collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 90 * , 041801 ( 2003 ) .
a. b. balantekin and h. yuksel , j. phys .
g * 29 * , 665 ( 2003 ) a. b. balantekin and h. yuksel , phys .
d * 68 * , 113002 ( 2003 ) .
g. l. fogli , e. lisi , a. marrone and a. palazzo , phys .
b * 583 * , 149 ( 2004 ) .
j. n. bahcall _ et al .
_ , phys . rev .
c * 66 * , 035802 ( 2002 ) .
a. b. mcdonald , private communication .
a. b. balantekin , v. barger _
et al . _ , arxiv : hep - ph/0405019 . | emergence of neutrino physics is fueled by the recent growth in quality and quantity of experimental data , yet , there are still open questions . how much can the determination of mixing parameters be improved ?
can we improve bounds on @xmath0 before experiments designed specifically for this parameter start ? how well can we determine or limit sterile fraction of neutrino flux from sun and sterile mixing angle ?
we examine the impact of outcome from new measurements in the context of providing answers to these questions .
[ [ section ] ] it is well established that , solar neutrinos primarily change into another active flavor@xcite .
experimental evidences from solar@xcite , atmospheric@xcite , reactor@xcite and long - baseline@xcite experiments can be accommodated into the framework of neutrino mass , oscillations , and neutrino mixing . in this formalism
, it is known that solar mixing angle , @xmath1 , is large@xcite , but not maximal , and atmospheric mixing angle , @xmath2 , is large , even maximal .
matter effects probably plays a role in this transformation@xcite .
the size of the third mixing angle , @xmath0 , is currently best limited by combined chooz reactor experiment and sk atmospheric data . in fig .
[ fig:1 ] , we present bounds on @xmath0 under certain considerations .
the horizontal shaded regions are 90% c. l. and 99% c. l. bounds on @xmath3 from superk atmospheric data .
the thick ( thin ) dashed curve is the 90% c. l. ( 3@xmath4 ) chooz bound . the 99% c. l. region on @xmath3 extends as low as @xmath5ev@xmath6 .
at the lower end of this region , @xmath0 is poorly constrained by chooz .
the solid curves in fig .
[ fig:1 ] are bounds from from chooz , kamland and solar data at 90% c. l. and 3@xmath4 .
our analysis shows that , the upper bound on @xmath0 from kamland and solar neutrino data gets stronger ( especially in the region with small @xmath7 where chooz reactor bound is relatively weak ) , and even dominates as this data gets refined . in order to examine the possible impact of new nc and cc measurements from ncd phase of sno experiment , we add two new hypothetical measurements with 1-@xmath4 uncertainties of 5.5% and 6.4% , and vary the corresponding central values by 1-@xmath4 around their salt - phase determinations .
the shaded curved bands , showing how 90% c. l. and 3@xmath4 bounds vary upon addition of these hypothetical data , suggest that the impact could be further improvement of the bounds on @xmath0 . vs. @xmath8 from analyses , all solar and kamland data ( solid line ) and just sno and kamland data ( dashed line ) .
the horizontal dotted lines are at the @xmath9 indicating n-@xmath4 confidence levels .
@xmath10b flux is free.,scaledwidth=90.0%,height=188 ] vs. @xmath8 from analyses , all solar and kamland data ( solid line ) and just sno and kamland data ( dashed line ) .
the horizontal dotted lines are at the @xmath9 indicating n-@xmath4 confidence levels . @xmath10b flux is free.,scaledwidth=100.0%,height=188 ] in simple 4-neutrino mixing scenarios , electron neutrinos change into some linear combination of active ( non - electron ) and sterile neutrinos , @xmath11 this is based on the assumption that the electron flavor is distributed among two eigenstates only .
the sterile admixture is described by sterile mixing angle , @xmath12 .
the fraction of oscillating neutrinos changing into active ( sterile ) flavor is given by @xmath13 ( @xmath14 ) .
the average survival probability of electron neutrinos , @xmath15 , for sno experiment can be calculated as , @xmath16 where @xmath17 is @xmath18 spectrum and @xmath19 is cc cross section .
the energy dependent survival probability , @xmath20 , is a function of both neutrino energy , @xmath21 , and mixing parameters , @xmath22 and @xmath1 , which can be taken from kamland experiment .
matter effects has little effect on calculation of @xmath15 in the model we applied here ( especially when sterile fraction is small ) .
sno experiment measures cc , @xmath23 , and nc , @xmath24 where @xmath25 is active fraction of the total flux and @xmath26 is solar @xmath27 neutrino flux .
it is estimated that @xmath15 can be known up to 7% uncertainty@xcite , while @xmath28 and @xmath29 can be measured with 5.5% , 6.4% uncertainties in ncd phase of sno@xcite .
the fraction of oscillating neutrinos changing into active flavor can be cast into the form , @xmath30 we examine the fractional error , @xmath31 , which requires access to the value of @xmath18 flux . adapting ssm value , which has over 20% uncertainty , yields almost 30% fractional uncertainty on @xmath8 .
an alternative way is extracting , @xmath18 flux from sno cc measurement , through the relation @xmath32 .
we see that fractional uncertainty on @xmath8 can be reduced below 20% by this substitution@xcite .
this result is independent of solar model uncertainties .
another method to determine the uncertainty on @xmath8 is to perform a statistical analysis based on the oscillation formulae , where @xmath33 is a fit parameter .
we present results of such global analyses in fig .
[ fig:2 ] projected on @xmath8 and marginalized over all other mixing parameters . the results consistent with non existence of sterile component in solar neutrino flux .
the 1-@xmath4 bound for the analysis , in which solar and kamland data is considered ( the solid line in fig . [ fig:2 ] ) , yields about 10% uncertainty on @xmath33 . when only sno and kamland data is considered ( the dashed line in fig .
[ fig:2 ] ) , the uncertainty on @xmath8 increases to about 20% ( which is comparable to the bound we obtained in simpler approach we utilized earlier , using @xmath15 determination from kamland and nc , cc measurements from sno ) . to conclude , oscillation of solar neutrinos into pure sterile flavor is not allowed but the possibility of a small sterile component in solar flux can not be eliminated within the current precision of model dependencies . in the long run , solar model model
independent measurements , like nc determination by sno experiment , are the preferred way for studying the sterile neutrino fraction and/or sterile mixing angle in both simple approaches ( like the one we presented ) and full statistical analysis based on the oscillation formulae . |
curved spacetimes for which the ricci scalar @xmath0 is identically zero have been known in general relativity ( gr ) since the discovery of the schwarzschild solution . while , in gr , the schwarzschild is a vacuum spacetime for which both @xmath0 and @xmath1 are zero , the reissner - nordstrom geometry has @xmath2 but @xmath3 , thereby implying the presence of traceless matter .
it has been further shown in @xcite that a generalisation of schwarzschild spacetime with @xmath4 everywhere finite and non - zero and @xmath2 can be obtained .
more recently @xcite , this @xmath2 wormhole spacetime has been found to be a solution in a scalar - tensor theory of gravity which is also the low energy , effective , on - brane gravity theory for the warped two - brane randall - sundrum model .
the @xmath2 spacetime in @xcite when viewed as a solution in gr , requires matter that violates the weak energy condition ( wec ) .
however , as shown in @xcite , in the context of the scalar - tensor theory , the required matter does not violate the wec and the scalar field ( radion ) is also finite and non - zero everywhere . in our work here ,
we further generalise the spacetime studied in @xcite .
in particular , newer @xmath2 spacetimes with @xmath4 everywhere non - zero are constructed and shown to be solutions in scalar - tensor gravity .
a sub - class of such spacetimes are lorentzian wormholes with the required matter satisfying the wec . in our analysis here , we begin with a general static , spherisymmetric line element for which the @xmath2 constraint is written as a differential equation for @xmath5 .
obviously , this differential equation contains @xmath6 ( or , @xmath7 where @xmath8 ) and its derivatives in its coefficients .
it can therefore be solved once we provide our choice for @xmath7 .
assuming @xmath7 as one should for a lorentzian wormhole , we find that for some specific choices ( eg . the schwarzschild wormhole and the ellis
bronnikov wormhole @xcite ) the differential equation for @xmath9 can indeed be solved .
we obtain a wide class of geometries in this manner .
thereafter , we show how these geometries fare in terms of the wec violation issue .
as mentioned above , in gr we require wec violation for the matter that threads non - singular wormhole spacetimes .
however , it has been shown recently that , within gr , a wormhole ( which is topologically different from the morris - thorne class ) can be supported by a negative cosmological constant ( which is not quite exotic , wec violating matter ) @xcite .
further , it is known that certain wormhole solutions which have been constructed in various modified theories of gravity such as brans - dicke theory ( scalar - tensor gravity with constant coupling @xmath10 ) @xcite , @xmath11-gravity @xcite , gauss - bonnet gravity @xcite , third - order lovelock gravity @xcite , eddington - inspired born - infeld gravity @xcite , mimetic gravity @xcite , dgp gravity @xcite , do not require wec violating matter . in our work here ,
we consider scalar - tensor gravity with a non - constant coupling @xmath12 and in the presence of matter stress - energy . through our specific solutions ,
we show that there may not be wec violation for the matter required to support a lorentzian wormhole .
it must be noted though that the timelike convergence condition is still violated , as it must be , for wormholes .
the essential point is that the relation between the convergence condition and the energy condition is not as it is in gr , because of which there is extra freedom to avoid any violation in a modified theory of gravity ( here , scalar - tensor gravity ) @xcite .
our paper is organised as follows . in section [ sec : stg ] , we briefly recall scalar - tensor gravity both as an independent theory and in the context of braneworld gravity .
we provide the details of our construction of @xmath2 spacetimes in section [ sec : solution ] .
section [ sec : wec ] and [ sec : m0 ] deal with the status of the wec . in section
[ sec : redshift ] , we study gravitational redshift in the wormhole spacetimes . the existence of stable and unstable circular orbits and the issue of traversability are addressed in section [ sec : traversability ] .
finally , we conclude in section [ sec : conclusion ] .
scalar - tensor theories are well - studied from various angles and perspectives .
the first such theory was , of course , the jordan - brans - dicke theory @xcite .
a scalar field @xmath13 and an extra parameter @xmath10 characterises such theories .
though originally considered a constant , a modified version incorporates a @xmath13-dependent @xmath10 @xcite . in general , the einstein field equations for such theories are given as : @xmath14 where the @xmath15 is the matter energy - momentum tensor and the metric @xmath16 is written in the jordan frame where the action is not in the standard canonical ( einstein - hilbert ) form .
viewed as an independent competitor of gr , a scalar tensor theory could be specified by providing a form for @xmath12 .
note that @xmath13 must satisfy the equation , @xmath17 various aspects of scalar - tensor theories have been extensively studied and we will not review them here . see @xcite and references therein for detailed reviews
. taking the trace of ( [ eq : field_equation1 ] ) and using ( [ eq : scalar_equation ] ) , one obtains @xmath18 note that traceless matter implies @xmath2 in gr .
but , in scalar - tensor gravity , traceless matter does not imply @xmath2 in general .
but , for the specific form of @xmath12 given by @xmath19 @xmath20 and hence , traceless matter implies @xmath2 . here , @xmath21 is an integration constant . as we shall see
, the case @xmath22 arises in the low energy , effective on - brane quasi - scalar - tensor gravity theory developed by kanno and soda @xcite in the context of the randall - sundrum two - brane model .
it is well - known that scalar - tensor theories arise as effective theories of gravity in diverse contexts .
for example , the low - energy effective gravity theory which emerges out of superstring theory contains a scalar known as the dilaton and the theory is a @xmath23 brans - dicke theory @xcite . in the braneworld scenario ,
our four dimensional visible universe is considered as a lower dimensional hypersurface called a brane , which is embedded in a higher dimensional bulk . in the low energy limit , the field equation governing bulk gravity , leads to effective field equations for gravity on the brane .
the presence of the extra dimensional bulk leaves its imprint by modifying the einstein field equations on the brane .
the most popular among the on - brane effective einstein equations was obtained by shiromizu - maeda - sasaki @xcite in the context of a single - brane model and contains a non - local term ( bulk - weyl dependent @xmath24 ) .
the on - brane effective einstein equations obtained by kanno and soda @xcite in the context of the two - brane randall sundrum model , however , does not contain any non - local contribution .
earlier , the non - local @xmath25 was used to obtain @xmath2 spacetime solutions @xcite ( mostly wormhole solutions ) in the single - brane effective theory of shiromizu - maeda - sasaki . in the effective on - brane theory of kanno and soda
, we have an effective energy momentum tensor ( other than the matter on the branes ) constructed from the scalar radion field ( which measures the inter - brane distance ) and its derivatives .
the radion field plays a crucial role in obtaining both static , spherically symmetric spacetimes and cosmological solutions @xcite .
it has been shown that the presence of the radion field can correctly reproduce the observed virial mass of galaxy clusters and observed galaxy rotation curves .
thus , the radion field can act as a possible dark matter candidate @xcite .
let us now briefly review the low energy effective on - brane quasi - scalar - tensor theory developed by kanno and soda @xcite .
the action is given as , @xmath26 where @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the five dimensional gravitational coupling constant , the five dimensional curvature scalar and the induced metric on the branes , respectively . @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the brane - tensions . the positive tension brane a ( planck brane ) and the negative tension brane b ( visible brane ) are respectively placed at fixed bulk locations ( @xmath32 and @xmath33 ) .
the bulk line element is , @xmath34 where the bulk curvature radius is @xmath35 . assuming the brane curvature radius @xmath36 as large compared to the bulk curvature radius @xmath35 , i.e. , @xmath37 , kanno and soda used a low energy expansion scheme ( the gradient expansion method ) wherein the bulk metric and the extrinsic curvature are expanded in powers of @xmath38 .
they obtained the effective field equations , @xmath39 on the visible brane .
here , @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 are respectively the radion field , the matter on the planck brane , the matter on the visible brane and the metric tensor on the visible brane .
the proper distance @xmath44 between the branes is defined as @xmath45 the radion field @xmath13 satisfies the following equation of motion on the visible brane : @xmath46 where both the traces @xmath47 and @xmath48 are taken with respect to the metric tensor @xmath43 and the coupling function is given by @xmath49 using the radion equation of motion in the trace of the field equation ( [ eq : field_equation ] ) , we obtain @xmath50 , where @xmath0 is the curvature scalar on the visible brane . note
that this is the @xmath22 case discussed earlier .
therefore , traceless matter implies @xmath2 in this theory . using the transformation @xmath51
, we can express the radion equation of motion in the form @xmath52 in the subsequent sections , we obtain our new solutions .
it is important to note that the solutions could either be viewed as solutions in a scalar - tensor theory which has no link with extra dimensions or as solutions in the context of braneworld gravity . in obtaining the solutions , we take the planck brane to be devoid of matter , i.e. , @xmath53 .
further , henceforth , we refer to this on - brane scalar - tensor gravity as kanno - soda theory of gravity because of the specific form of the coupling function @xmath12 given in ( [ eq : coupling2 ] ) .
we begin with the static , spherically symmetric line element given as @xmath54 where @xmath9 and @xmath7 are unknown functions to be determined .
we are interested in vanishing curvature scalar ( @xmath2 ) solutions .
the @xmath2 constraint yields the following second order differential equation for @xmath9 : @xmath55 the above equation can also be re - written as a first order differential equation for @xmath7 .
attempts have been made to find out @xmath2 spacetime solutions in the past @xcite . in most of these articles ,
the authors have ( a ) considered known forms of @xmath9 and obtained solutions by solving the first order differential equation for @xmath7 or ( b ) used some known @xmath2 solutions present in the literature and analysed them in the context of an effective theory of gravity . in our work , we take a different route .
we specify the form of @xmath7 and solve the second order differential equation for @xmath9 .
this way we hope to obtain a more general solution different from those obtained earlier .
another advantage of specifying the form of the shape function @xmath7 is that we can choose to have wormhole solutions with a desired spatial shape .
one can take different forms of @xmath7 . in our work here , we take @xmath56 . putting @xmath57 in the @xmath2 equation , we obtain @xmath58 after some manipulations , the above equation can be re - written in the form @xmath59=0 \nonumber\ ] ] which can be integrated to obtain @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 are integration constants .
therefore , the line element becomes @xmath63 ^ 2dt^2 \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{dr^2}{1-\frac{2m}{r}-\frac{\beta}{r^2}}+r^2d\omega^2 \label{eq : general_metric}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is useful to note that , when @xmath64 or @xmath65 , the @xmath66 is of the general form , @xmath67 .
however , when @xmath68 , @xmath69 are both non - zero , this generic form does not hold and we have @xmath70 .
however , it is important to note that , in all cases , the red - shift function is finite and non - zero everywhere .
we now look at special cases of our general solution .
some of these special cases reproduce the @xmath2 spacetimes obtained earlier by other authors . for @xmath65 , @xmath71 and @xmath72
, the spacetime takes the form @xmath73
^ 2dt^2+\frac{dr^2}{1-\frac{2m}{r}}+r^2d\omega^2\ ] ] this spatially schwarzschild spacetime has been obtained in @xcite .
this spacetime represents either a wormhole or a naked singularity for @xmath74 . for @xmath75 and @xmath76
, the spatially schwarzschild solution reduces to the schwarzschild spacetime . taking @xmath77 and @xmath78 in this solution
, we obtain the spatial schwarzschild wormhole obtained in @xcite . for @xmath79 , @xmath80 , @xmath81 and @xmath82 ,
the general metric takes the form @xmath83 where @xmath84 .
this metric has been obtained in @xcite .
this metric reduces to the extreme reissner - nordstr@xmath85 m form for @xmath86 , i.e. , @xmath87 .
the above metric fails to produce spatial ellis geometry because @xmath88 implies @xmath89 .
however , we can obtain spatial ellis geometry from our general solution by taking @xmath64 and @xmath90 .
the line element becomes @xmath91 this new metric has not been obtained before .
note that , due to the presence of the @xmath92 factor in @xmath66 , the above metric is different from the spatial ellis geometry obtained in @xcite for vanishing torsion scalar in the context of modified teleparallel gravity . for @xmath93 , the general
metric reduces to spatial reissner - nordstr@xmath85 m metric .
the spatial reissner - nordstr@xmath85 m metric further reduces to the reissner - nordstr@xmath85 m metric for @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
our focus is on the general metric ( [ eq : general_metric ] ) .
depending on the signs and values of @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath61 and @xmath62 , the general spacetime may represent a black hole , a wormhole or a naked singularity .
the nature of the solution depends on the presence of the zeroes of @xmath9 and @xmath96 .
we will focus on solutions for which @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
the solution for such choices does represent a lorentzian wormhole . for later use ,
let us now write down the solution in isotropic coordinates .
the transformation from the schwarzschild radial coordinate @xmath100 to the isotropic coordinate @xmath0 is given as @xmath101 using the transformation between @xmath100 and @xmath0 we obtain , in isotropic coordinates , the line element , @xmath102 where @xmath103 @xmath104 and @xmath105 the constants @xmath106 and @xmath107 are given as @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
it is easy to show that @xmath110 and @xmath111 are related to @xmath106 and @xmath107 as follows : @xmath112 it can be shown that , for a spacetime without a horizon @xmath113 is necessary .
we will use the isotropic coordinate form of the line element while discussing the weak energy condition . defining @xmath114
one can solve the radion field equation as shown in @xcite .
obviously one ends up introducing a new constant which we denote as @xmath115 .
we have @xmath116 where we have omitted an overall additive constant .
it is easy to see that @xmath117 is never zero as along as @xmath118 .
note that the domain of @xmath119 is from @xmath120 to @xmath121 , where @xmath122 corresponds to the wormhole throat .
we will now turn towards analysing the weak energy condition inequalities and demonstrate that it can indeed be satisfied for the wormhole we have constructed .
the weak energy condition comprises the inequalities @xmath123 for a diagonal energy momentum tensor with energy density @xmath124 , radial pressure @xmath125 and tangential pressures @xmath126 defined in the static observer s frame .
physically , the wec means that the matter energy density is always non - negative in any frame of reference . for our case here , we have , for the l.h.s . of the wec inequalities , @xmath127\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath128\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath129\ ] ] where the last equation follows from the traceless requirement on the matter energy momentum tensor . for arbitrary values of the parameters it is not possible to satisfy these inequalities .
however , one can isolate the negativity by looking at the requirements that emerge near @xmath130 . in the limit @xmath131
, we have @xmath132x^4+\mathcal{o}(x^5)\ ] ] @xmath133x^3+\mathcal{o}(x^4)\ ] ] @xmath134 where @xmath135 .
note that , at the leading order , ( i.e. , terms which are @xmath136 ) , @xmath137 and @xmath138 are opposite in sign .
this violates the wec in the limit @xmath131 .
therefore , we must set the coefficient of @xmath139 in @xmath137 to zero .
this yields the following expression for @xmath115 .
@xmath140 which reduces to the expression quoted in @xcite for @xmath141 and @xmath142 . with
the above condition satisfied , it can be shown that in @xmath137 , @xmath143 term vanishes as well and @xmath144 term is always positive for any positive @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
therefore , it is clear from the traceless condition that , at the @xmath143 , positivity of @xmath124 implies positivity of @xmath138 .
note that , at this point , @xmath106 and @xmath107 can be chosen so that @xmath124 and @xmath145 are positive .
however , we choose those values of @xmath106 and @xmath107 for which the coefficient of the @xmath143 term in @xmath124 vanishes .
this gives us the following requirement on @xmath145 .
@xmath146 equating the above two expressions for @xmath145 , one arrives at a relation between @xmath106 and @xmath107 which must be obeyed .
@xmath147 \log\frac{q_1}{q_2 } = q_1 ^ 2-q_2 ^ 2 \label{eq : q1q2}\ ] ] thus , once we are able to choose a @xmath106 and a @xmath107 which satisfies the above relation , we can use their values to find @xmath115 .
the set of values for @xmath106 , @xmath107 and @xmath115 can therefore be used to write down the line element and the scalar field profile for a lorentzian wormhole in scalar - tensor gravity which will satisfy all the wec inequalities .
the central issue at this point is whether we can obtain an analytical handle on the relation between @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
to get rid of the logarithm , we can assume @xmath148 .
this will eventually lead us to a quartic equation in @xmath107 for which we can obtain the positive , real valued roots in terms of @xmath149 .
choosing @xmath149 one can then obtain @xmath106 , @xmath107 and then @xmath115 .
we will now illustrate the above statements with examples and also demonstrate our claim that the wec is indeed satisfied for the wormholes we have constructed .
putting @xmath148 in ( [ eq : q1q2 ] ) , we obtain @xmath150 where , @xmath151 @xmath152 therefore , we fix @xmath106 and @xmath107 and hence @xmath111 , @xmath110 and @xmath115 by choosing a particular value of @xmath149 . it can be shown that @xmath153 for the whole range @xmath154 .
therefore , the definitions of @xmath106 and @xmath107 indicate that both are positive .
figure [ fig : q ] shows the parametric plot for @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
figure [ fig : gamma ] shows the dependence of @xmath115 on @xmath106
. figures [ fig : ec1]-[fig : ec3 ] show the l.h.s of the wec inequalities for three sets of parameter values .
it is to be noted that wec inequalities are satisfied . as a function of @xmath106 . ] as a function of @xmath106 . ]
( blue dashed curve ) , @xmath155 ( red dotted curve ) and @xmath156 ( black dot - dashed curve ) as a function of @xmath119 for @xmath157 which corresponds to @xmath158 , @xmath159 , @xmath160 , @xmath161 and @xmath162 . ] ( blue dashed curve ) , @xmath155 ( red dotted curve ) and @xmath156 ( black dot - dashed curve ) as a function of @xmath119 for @xmath163 which corresponds to @xmath164 , @xmath165 , @xmath166 , @xmath167 and @xmath168 . ] ( blue dashed curve ) , @xmath155 ( red dotted curve ) and @xmath156 ( black dot - dashed curve ) as a function of @xmath119 for @xmath169 which corresponds to @xmath170 , @xmath171 , @xmath172 , @xmath173 and @xmath174 . ]
let us now take the limit @xmath175
. in this limit @xmath176 and @xmath110 diverges .
but , the product @xmath177 is finite . in terms of @xmath178
, we have @xmath179 therefore , @xmath106 and @xmath107 have opposite signs . in this limit , the factor @xmath180 in the energy density and pressures must be replaced by @xmath181 .
it can be shown that @xmath182 does not have zeroes in the range @xmath183 for @xmath184 , thereby representing a wormhole .
but , for @xmath185 , it does have a zero and represents a naked singularity . let us first consider the case @xmath184 .
like the @xmath186 case , here also , one must consider the expression ( [ eq : gamma1 ] ) . with this
, it can be shown that , in the limit @xmath131 , the coefficient of the @xmath143 term in @xmath124 can not be set to zero since it is negative for all @xmath184 , thereby violating the wec .
it also implies that the expression in ( [ eq : gamma2 ] ) is not valid .
however , we can make use of the freedom to add an additive constant to @xmath187 and make this coefficient positive .
if we do so , then we find that @xmath188 in ( [ eq : gamma1 ] ) , i.e. , @xmath115 is imaginary . on the other hand , it can be shown that if we force @xmath145 to be positive , then either @xmath124 or @xmath137 or both become negative in the limit @xmath131 .
therefore , the wormholes without the mass term ` @xmath68 ' violate the wec .
figure [ fig : ec4 ] shows the wec violation for @xmath64 .
we have carried out a similar analysis for the naked singularity case @xmath189 where we found that the wec can be satisfied in the limit @xmath131 , but the radion field @xmath187 vanishes at a point between the singularity and spatial infinity .
this gives an invalid solution .
therefore , wec can not be satisfied for the naked singularity .
( blue dashed curve ) , @xmath155 ( red dotted curve ) and @xmath156 ( black dot - dashed curve ) as a function of @xmath119 for @xmath190 . ]
let us now look at the gravitational redshift of a light signal propagating in the @xmath2 wormhole spacetimes discussed above .
note that by virtue of having a @xmath191 which is everywhere finite and non - zero , the gravitational redshift is always finite . by definition ,
wormhole spacetimes are horizon - free .
assume that a light signal is emitted at a frequency @xmath192 from the wormhole throat ( @xmath122 ) and it travels to spatial infinity ( @xmath130 ) where a static observer receives it at a frequency @xmath193 .
therefore , the fractional change in frequency due to the gravitational redshift is given by the standard formula .
@xmath194 we choose values of @xmath106 and @xmath107 which satisfy eqn .
( [ eq : q1q2 ] ) and hence , the wec .
figure [ fig : redshift ] shows the fractional change in frequency as a function of @xmath106 .
it is worth noting that the light signal may have a negative gravitational redshift , i.e. , a gravitational blueshift ( @xmath195 ) for certain values of @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
for the three sets of @xmath106 and @xmath107 given in figs .
[ fig : ec1]-[fig : ec3 ] , @xmath196 are respectively @xmath197 , @xmath198 and @xmath199 . for @xmath200 and @xmath201 , @xmath196 vanishes .
therefore , the wormholes can exhibit both redshift and blueshift .
it can be shown that , for those @xmath106 and @xmath107 satisfying the wec , the maximum redshift is @xmath202 .
this redshift does not exceed @xmath203 for such values of @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
however , we can have more than @xmath203 redshift if we choose @xmath106 and @xmath107 arbitrarily , which obviously violates the wec .
thus , in a certain sense , as mentioned above , the wec does restrict the gravitational redshift to an amount below @xmath203 .
it is possible to use this result ( along with other signatures ) to identify whether the cause of an observed gravitational frequency shift is indeed due to a wormhole . with @xmath107 and @xmath106 satisfying eqn .
the geodesic equations for a test particle moving in the equatorial ( @xmath204 ) plane of the spacetime [ eq : general_metric ] reduce to the following first integrals : @xmath205 where the energy @xmath206 and the angular momentum @xmath36 are constants of motion .
an overdot represents differentiation with respect to the parameter @xmath207 ( affine for timelike and arbitrary for null geodesics ) .
the effective potential @xmath208 is given by @xmath209 where the normalisation constant @xmath210 is @xmath211 for timelike geodesics and is @xmath120 for null geodesics .
we now look for circular orbits which correspond to @xmath212 ( i.e. @xmath213 ) and @xmath214 ( i.e. extrema of the effective potential ) .
minima ( @xmath215 ) and maxima ( @xmath216 ) of the effective potential correspond to the stable and unstable circular orbits , respectively . for the line element in ( [ eq : general_metric ] )
, the effective potential can be written as @xmath217f^2(z)\ ] ] where @xmath218 @xmath219 and @xmath220 , @xmath221 being the throat radius . here , we have normalised @xmath9 by dividing it by @xmath222 such that @xmath223 as @xmath224 . the effective potential is plotted in figs .
[ fig : potential1 ] and [ fig : potential2 ] for the parameter values satisfying the wec . by choosing @xmath149
, we find @xmath107 from ( [ eq : q2 ] ) , @xmath106 from @xmath148 and hence @xmath111 and @xmath110 from ( [ eq : mu_eta ] ) .
it should be noted that both stable and unstable circular orbits exist for the timelike case .
however , for the null case , no stable circular orbit exists for the parameter values satisfying the wec .
but , stable circular orbits exist if we choose the parameter values arbitrarily which , of course , violates the wec . to check this
, we first note that the extremum @xmath225 of the potential are given by @xmath226 using eqs .
( [ eq : ricci_flat ] ) and ( [ eq : extremum ] ) , it can be shown that @xmath227 therefore , minima ( @xmath228 ) exist if @xmath225 are real and @xmath229 .
note that we must have @xmath230 .
this is possible when @xmath231 .
figure [ fig : potential3 ] shows the plots for the potential for parameter values chosen arbitrarily .
we have checked that the wec is violated for these parameter values .
therefore , stable null circular orbits exist if the wec is violated . .
red dots represent unstable circular orbits . here , we have taken @xmath232 . ] .
the green and red dots represent respectively the stable and unstable circular orbits . here , we have taken @xmath233 and @xmath232 . ]
it should be noted that , for the parameter values used in fig .
[ fig : potential3 ] , @xmath106 and @xmath107 become complex conjugates of each other because the square root terms in the expressions of @xmath106 and @xmath107 become imaginary .
but , the metric function @xmath182 still remains real since @xmath234 and @xmath235 are real .
it can also be shown that @xmath236 is real . to verify this ,
let @xmath237 where @xmath238 and @xmath239 are real .
therefore , @xmath240 .
writing @xmath241 and @xmath242 where @xmath243 , we obtain @xmath244=\frac{2\gamma\theta(x)}{b}\ ] ] which is real .
traversability of a wormhole demands that the tidal force felt by a human traveller moving radially , must be within tolerable limits . in an orthonormal basis
@xmath245 attached to the traveller frame , the tidal acceleration between two parts of his / her body , separated by the deviation vector @xmath246 is given by @xcite @xmath247 where @xmath248 is the riemann tensor . at the throat , the components of the tidal acceleration are given by @xmath249 @xmath250 where @xmath251 and @xmath252 is the the radial velocity of the traveler as measured by a static observer .
@xmath253 denotes the radial velocity at the throat . for the wormhole solutions
, we must have @xmath254 .
note that , the radial component of the tidal acceleration vanishes for @xmath65 .
therefore , it can be made arbitrarily small by choosing an appropriate value of @xmath69 .
we now restrict the radial component below one earth gravity , i.e. , @xmath255 .
thus , for a traveller of typical size @xmath256 @xmath257 meters , we obtain @xmath258 @xmath259 where we have used the expressions @xmath260 and @xmath261 .
note that @xmath68 and @xmath69 are related through @xmath111 . for a given metric parameter @xmath111 , the constraint on @xmath68 ( and hence on @xmath69 )
puts a constraint on the throat radius .
the constraint on @xmath221 is given by @xmath262 for @xmath263 which corresponds to fig .
[ fig : ec2 ] , we obtain @xmath264 , where @xmath265 km is the earth radius .
however , we can reduce the lower limit on @xmath221 if we choose @xmath111 to be close to @xmath121 . if the wormhole is to be traversable , not only the tidal acceleration but also the magnitude of acceleration felt by the traveller as he or she travels through it , must be within tolerable limits .
in the orthonormal basis of the traveler frame , the magnitude of the acceleration is given by @xcite @xmath266 let us now consider both @xmath267 and @xmath268 to be finite at the throat .
therefore , at the throat @xmath221 , we have @xmath269 for the wormhole solutions , we must have @xmath113 . therefore , for a given @xmath221 and @xmath68 which restrict the tidal acceleration below one earth gravity
, the magnitude of the acceleration can be made arbitrarily small by taking @xmath110 to be very close to zero which , of course , satisfies the wec ( fig .
[ fig : ec2 ] ) .
in this work , we have obtained a class of static , spherically symmetric @xmath2 spacetimes which generalise certain known @xmath2 line elements .
we have shown that our spacetimes can arise in a scalar - tensor theory of gravity , an example of which is the low energy , effective on - brane gravity theory developed by kanno and soda @xcite in the context of the randall - sundrum two - brane model .
some special cases of the general solution reproduce the @xmath2 spacetimes obtained earlier by other authors in the context of gr and in the on - brane effective gravity theory due to shiromizu - maeda - sasaki @xcite for a single - brane scenario .
a sub - class of the general spacetimes found by us represents @xmath2 lorentzian wormholes .
we have studied the wec for the matter that supports such wormholes and have shown that they can satisfy wec .
this is in contrast to gr , where such wormholes must violate wec .
we have also shown that the mass term in the metric functions is necessary to satisfy the wec for these wormholes .
note that most of the wormhole solutions obtained in @xcite are in vacuum - brans - dicke theory .
however , the solutions we have obtained include both matter and a non - constant , i.e. , a @xmath13-dependent coupling @xmath12 . as a additional curiosity
, we also looked at the wec for the naked singularity with the parameter @xmath64 , and have found that it is violated .
apart from constructing solutions and checking the wec , we have calculated the gravitational redshift of a light signal traveling in such wormholes and have found that the wec restricts the amount of redshift to be below @xmath203 .
furthermore , we obtained the effective potentials for particle motion and investigated the possibility of circular orbits in these wormhole spacetimes .
it has been shown that both stable and unstable circular orbits exist for the timelike case .
for the null case , only unstable circular orbits are possible if the wec is satisfied .
but , stable null circular orbits exist if the wec is violated . finally , we analysed traversability in such wormholes and found that they are traversable for values of the metric parameters satisfying the wec .
therefore , we now have wormholes which satisfy the wec and are traversable .
in addition , they may also be viewed as on - brane spacetimes if one considers the existence of warped extra dimensions of the randall - sundrum variety , in a two - brane context .
in such a context the scalar field ( radion ) is related to the inter - brane distance and we have seen that this can always be kept finite and non - zero everywhere .
recently , it has been argued that the universal ringdown waveforms from a binary coalescence indicate the presence of light rings , rather than of horizons @xcite .
therefore , an object ( e.g. a traversable wormhole ) with a light ring will display a similar initial ringdown stage ( waveform ) , even when its quasinormal mode spectrum is completely different from that of a black hole .
however , their late time ringdown stages are different @xcite . it has further been shown that , if one does not use the thin - shell wormhole ( the one used in @xcite ) obtained by special matching near the schwarzschild radius but prefers a wormhole configuration constructed without thin - shells instead , a wormhole may ring like a black hole or differently at all times , depending on the values of the wormhole and black hole parameters @xcite .
this leads to the hope that the lorentzian wormholes we have obtained here , may be relevant in such studies and may have an observational consequence in astrophysics , in future .
further , it is to be noted that the @xmath2 spacetime solution we have obtained can be used in the context of any other theory of gravity ( different from the one considered here ) to study the relation between the energy conditions and wormholes . we have noted that a sub - class of our @xmath2 spacetimes represents naked singularities .
therefore , as a observational test , it will be interesting to study gravitational lensing in the spacetimes we have obtained here and to see whether we can find ways to distinguish between wormholes and naked singularities @xcite through observations .
r. s. acknowledges the council of scientific and industrial research , india , for providing support through a fellowship .
99 n. dadhich , s. kar , s. mukherjee , and m. visser , _
@xmath2 spacetimes and self - dual lorentzian wormholes _ , phys .
d * 65 * , 064004 ( 2002 ) .
s. kar , s. lahiri , and s. sengupta , _ can extra dimensional effects allow wormholes without exotic matter ? _ , phys . lett .
b * 750 * , 319 ( 2015 ) .
h. g. ellis , _ ether flow through a drainhole : a particle model in general relativity _ , j. math .
* 14 * , 104 ( 1973 ) ; errata : j. math
. phys . * 15 * , 520 ( 1974 ) .
k. a. bronnikov , _ scalar - tensor theory and scalar charge _ , acta phys .
b * 4 * , 251 ( 1973 ) .
e. ayon - beato , f. canfora , and j. zanelli , _ analytic self - gravitating skyrmions , cosmological bounces and wormholes _ , phys . lett .
b * 752 * , 201 ( 2016 ) . c. h. brans , _
mach s principle and a relativistic theory of gravitation .
ii _ , phys
. rev . * 125 * , 2194 ( 1962 ) ; a. g. agnese and m. lacamera , _ wormholes in the brans - dicke theory of gravitation _ , phys .
d * 51 * , 2011 ( 1995 ) ; k. k. nandi , a. islam , and j. evans , _ brans wormholes _ , phys .
d * 55 * , 2497 ( 1997 ) ; k. k. nandi , b. bhattacharjee , s. m. k. alam and j. evans , _ brans - dicke wormholes in the jordan and einstein frames _ , phys .
d * 57 * , 823 ( 1998 ) ; e. f. eiroa , m. g. richarte , and c. simeone , _ thin - shell wormholes in brans
dicke gravity _ ,
lett . a * 373 * , 1 ( 2008 ) ; e. f. eiroa , m. g. richarte , and c. simeone , _ erratum to thin - shell wormholes in brans dicke gravity " [ phys .
a 373 , 1 ( 2008 ) ] _ , phys .
a * 373 * , 2399 ( 2009 ) ; a. bhattacharya , i. nigmatzyanov , r. izmailov and k. k. nandi , _ brans - dicke wormhole revisited _ , classical quantum gravity * 26 * 235017 ( 2009 ) ; f. s. n. lobo and m. a. oliveira , _ general class of vacuum brans - dicke wormholes _ , phys .
d * 81 * , 067501 ( 2010 ) ; s. v. sushkov and s. m. kozyrev , _ composite vacuum brans - dicke wormholes _ , phys .
d * 84 * , 124026 ( 2011 ) ; x. yue and s. gao , _ stability of brans - dicke thin - shell wormholes _ , phys .
a * 375 * , 2193 ( 2011 ) ; f. s. n. lobo and m. a. oliveira , _ wormhole geometries in @xmath11 modified theories of gravity _ , phys .
d * 80 * , 104012 ( 2009 ) ; t. harko , f. s. n. lobo , m. k. mak , and s. v. sushkov , _ modified - gravity wormholes without exotic matter _ , phys .
d * 87 * , 067504 ( 2013 ) ; b. bhawal and s. kar , _ lorentzian wormholes in einstein - gauss - bonnet theory _ , phys .
d * 46 * , 2464 ( 1992 ) ; m. g. richarte and c. simeone , _ thin - shell wormholes supported by ordinary matter in einstein - gauss - bonnet gravity _ ,
d * 76 * , 087502 ( 2007 ) ; m. g. richarte and c. simeone , _ erratum : thin - shell wormholes supported by ordinary matter in einstein - gauss - bonnet gravity [ phys .
d 76 , 087502 ( 2007 ) ] _ , phys . rev .
d * 77 * , 089903(e ) ( 2008 ) ; h. maeda and m. nozawa , _ static and symmetric wormholes respecting energy conditions in einstein - gauss - bonnet gravity _ ,
d * 78 * , 024005 ( 2008 ) ; j. ponce de leon ,
_ static wormholes on the brane inspired by kaluza - klein gravity _
, j. cosmol .
* 11 * ( 2009 ) 013 ; m. h. dehghani and s. h. hendi , _ wormhole solutions in gauss - bonnet - born - infeld gravity _ , gen .
. gravit . * 41 * , 1853 ( 2009 ) ; p. kanti , b. kleihaus , j. kunz , _ wormholes in dilatonic einstein - gauss - bonnet theory _
, phys .rev
. lett . * 107 * , 271101 ( 2011 ) ; p. kanti , b. kleihaus , j. kunz , _
stable lorentzian wormholes in dilatonic einstein - gauss - bonnet theory _ , phys .
d * 85 * , 044007 ( 2012 ) ; m. r. mehdizadeh , m. k. zangeneh and f. s. n. lobo , _ einstein - gauss - bonnet traversable wormholes satisfying the weak energy condition _ , phys
d * 91 * , 084004 ( 2015 ) ; t. kokubu , h. maeda , and t. harada , _ does the gauss - bonnet term stabilize wormholes ? _ , classical quantum gravity * 32 * 235021 ( 2015 ) .
m. k. zangeneh , f. s. n. lobo , and m. h. dehghani , _ traversable wormholes satisfying the weak energy condition in third - order lovelock gravity _
, phys . rev .
d * 92 * , 124049 ( 2015 ) ; m. r. mehdizadeh and f. s. n. lobo , _ novel third - order lovelock wormhole solutions _ , phys .
d * 93 * , 124014 ( 2016 ) .
r. shaikh , _ lorentzian wormholes in eddington - inspired born - infeld gravity _
d * 92 * , 024015 ( 2015 ) .
r. myrzakulov , l. sebastiani , s. vagnozzi , and s. zerbini , _
static spherically symmetric solutions in mimetic gravity : rotation curves @xmath270 wormholes _ , classical quantum gravity * 33 * , 125005 ( 2016 ) . m. g. richarte , _ wormholes and solitonic shells in five - dimensional dgp theory _ , phys .
d * 82 * , 044021 ( 2010 ) ; m. g. richarte , _ cylindrical wormholes in dgp gravity _ , phys .
d * 87 * , 067503 ( 2013 ) ; y. tomikawa , t. shiromizu , and k. izumi , _
wormhole on dgp brane _ ,
d * 90 * , 126001 ( 2014 ) . c. brans and r. h. dicke , _
mach s principle and a relativistic theory of gravitation _ ,
phys . rev . *
124 * , 925 ( 1961 ) . p. g. bergmann , _
comments on the scalar - tensor theory _ ,
phys.*1 * , 25 ( 1968 ) .
y. fujii , k. maeda , _ the scalar - tensor theory of gravitation _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 2003 ) ; v. faraoni , _ cosmology in scalar - tensor gravity _
( springer , new york , 2004 ) ; t. p. sotiriou , _ gravity and scalar fields _ , lect .
notes phys .
* 892 * , 3 ( 2015 ) ; t. p. sotiriou , _ black holes and scalar fields _ , classical quantum gravity * 32 * , 214002 ( 2015 ) .
s. kanno and j. soda , _ radion and holographic brane gravity _ , phys.rev .
d * 66 * , 083506 ( 2002 ) .
g. t. horowitz , _ the dark side of string theory : black holes and black strings _ , arxiv : hep - th/9210119 . t. shiromizu , k. maeda and m. sasaki , _ the einstein equations on the 3-brane world _ , phys .
d * 62 * , 024012 ( 2000 ) .
r. casadio , a. fabbri , and l. mazzacurati , _ new black holes in the brane world ? _ , phys .
d * 65 * , 084040 ( 2001 ) .
k. a. bronnikov and s .- w .
possible wormholes in a brane world _ , phys .
d * 67 * , 064027 ( 2003 ) .
k. a. bronnikov , v. n. melnikov and heinz dehnen , _ general class of brane - world black holes _
d * 68 * , 024025 ( 2003 ) .
f. parsaei and n. riazi , _ new wormhole solutions on the brane _ , phys .
d * 91 * , 024015 ( 2015 ) .
s. kar , s. lahiri , and s. sengupta , _ a note on spherically symmetric , static spacetimes in kanno - soda on - brane gravity _ ,
gravit . * 47 * , 70 ( 2015 ) .
s. kar , s. lahiri , and s. sengupta , _ radion stability and induced , on - brane geometries in an effective scalar - tensor theory of gravity _ , phys .
d * 88 * , 123509 ( 2013 ) .
s. chakraborty and s. sengupta , _ radion as a possible dark matter candidate _ ,
s. kar and d. sahdev , _ restricted class of traversable wormholes with traceless matter _ , phys .
d * 52 * , 2030 ( 1995 ) .
n. dadhich , _ spherically symmetric empty space and its dual in general relativity _
sci . * 78 * , 1118 ( 2000 ) ( arxiv : gr - qc/0003018 ) . c. g. b@xmath85hmer , t. harko , and f. s. n. lobo , _ wormhole geometries in modified teleparallel gravity and the energy conditions _
d * 85 * , 044033 ( 2012 ) . m. s. morris and k. s. thorne , _ wormholes in spacetime and their use for interstellar travel : a tool for teaching general relativity _
* 56 * , 395 ( 1988 ) . v. cardoso , e. franzin , and p. pani ,
_ is the gravitational - wave ringdown a probe of the event horizon ? _ , phys .
* 116 * , 171101 ( 2016 ) .
r. a. konoplya and c. molina , _ ringing wormholes _ , phys .
d * 71 * , 124009 ( 2005 ) .
r. a. konoplya and a. zhidenko , _ wormholes versus black holes : quasinormal ringing at early and late times _ , arxiv:1606.00517 .
r. shaikh and s. kar , in preparation . | we obtain a large class of lorentzian wormhole spacetimes in scalar - tensor gravity , for which the matter stress energy does satisfy the weak energy condition .
our constructions have zero ricci scalar and an everywhere finite , non - zero scalar field profile . interpreting the scalar - tensor gravity as an effective on - brane theory resulting from a two - brane randall sundrum model of warped extra dimensions , it is possible to link wormhole existence with that of extra dimensions .
we study the geometry , matter content , gravitational red - shift and circular orbits in such wormholes and argue that our examples are perhaps among those which may have some observational relevance in astrophysics in future .
we also study traversability and find that our wormholes are indeed traversable for values of the metric parameters satisfying the weak energy condition . |
the structure of the density and velocity fields in the interstellar medium ( ism ) has been studied using a variety of tracers , from spectral lines in emission and absorption to pulsar scintillation and faraday rotation .
a particularly convenient tracer is the 21-cm line of hi because it is very widespread and easily detectable from both dense and diffuse clouds and from the `` intercloud '' or warm neutral medium .
two sorts of structure are traced with this line : deterministic and stochastic .
the former are coherent features in the density and/or velocity fields that can be interpreted dynamically as evolving physical structures , like shells , bubbles , chimneys , clouds , or streams .
the latter are apparently random variations in the density of the gas as a function of position and velocity , that can best be characterized statistically .
the two classes of structure are related .
for example , as the shells blown by stellar winds and supernova remnants expand , they ultimately lose their separate identity and blend into the background of apparently random density fluctuations .
this paper is a study of the structure of the neutral atomic medium in an area of the fourth quadrant of the galactic plane mapped in the 21-cm line as part of the southern galactic plane survey ( sgps ) .
preceeding papers in this series ( mcclure - griffiths et al .
2000 , 2001 , hereafter paper 1 and paper 2 ) presented some apparently deterministic hi structures ( shells and chimneys ) from the survey ; this paper deals with the random fluctuations .
a favorite statistical characterization of the properties of a random density or velocity distribution is the structure function ( kaplan 1966 , rickett 1976 ) . for the ionized medium
this can be measured over a huge range of scales using the propagation of pulsar signals .
this analysis leads to `` the big power law in the sky '' ( spangler 2001 ) , a power law that corresponds to a kolmogorov cascade of interstellar turbulence ( cordes and rickett 1998 and references therein ) .
a different function for describing the structure , which is particularly easy to apply to aperture synthesis observations of the brightness of a spectral line , is the spatial power spectrum .
this is the fourier transform of the structure function or the magnitude squared of the fourier transform of the brightness distribution ( see goldman 2000 , and references therein ) .
early studies of the spatial power spectrum ( hereafter sps ) of galactic hi ( crovisier and dickey 1983 ; kalberla and stenholm 1983 ) revealed , quite unexpectedly , that it has a smooth , power law form with logarithmic slope [email protected] .
this result remained unexplained for many years , even after it was demonstrated by green ( 1993 ) that the power law shows almost exactly the same slope in another direction in the outer galaxy .
more recently stanimirovi et al .
( 1999 ) have shown that even in the small magellanic cloud the same power law slope is obtained .
the lmc shows similar behavior ( elmegreen et al . 2001 ) , as do galactic molecular clouds ( zielinsky and sttzki 1999 , dickman et al .
1990 , gautier et al . 1992 ) . in recent years , the relationship between this power law and the kolmogorov energy cascade is becoming more clear ( lazarian and pogosyan 2000 , and references therein , goldman 2000 ) .
more profoundly , the structure of the ism as measured either by the structure function or by the sps can be interpreted as a manifestation of the fractal geometry of the medium ( elmegreen et al .
2001 , stanimirovi et al . 1999 , westpfahl et al . 1999 , sttzki et al .
1998 ) .
in this paper we concentrate on testing a simple prediction of the mathematical theory of turbulence pointed out by lazarian and pogosyan ( 2000 ) .
the theory states that the slope of the power law of the observed ( two dimensional ) sps should steepen when the region sampled changes from thin to thick along the line of sight .
`` thick '' and `` thin '' here depend on whether the line of sight thickness of the gas sampled by a given velocity bandwidth is more or less than the thermal width of the line divided by the velocity gradient along the line of sight due to differential galactic rotation . in the inner galaxy ,
the steep velocity gradient allows us to make the transition from thin to thick slices by averaging over progressively broader velocity widths .
the result we find is in good agreement with the prediction .
this gives strong support to the kolmogorov paradigm as an explanation for the power law , and it indirectly supports the interpretation of elmegreen et al .
( 2001 ) that the hi disk in the lmc is thin .
a similar result is found for the lmc by padoan et al .
( 2001 ) using the related spectral correlation function technique .
the observed steepening of the power law slope of the sps with broader velocity averaging is so clear that we attempt a more profound analysis .
interstellar turbulence includes both velocity fluctuations ( small scale structure in the velocity field of the gas ) and density fluctuations , each with their own structure functions .
choosing one of the cases considered by lazarian and pogosyan ( 2001 ) , we attempt to determine the power law spectral indices of the spatial power spectra of both quantities .
the results suggest that the different thermal regimes ( warm and cool hi ) are in fundamentally different regimes of turbulence .
the sgps is a combination of two surveys of the 21-cm line and continuum emission and absorption from the southern galactic plane ( @xmath3 , i.e. @xmath4 at @xmath5 ) .
the australia telescope compact array ( atca ) interferometer of the australia telescope national facility is used in its mosaicing mode to make aperture synthesis images , that are combined with single dish images using the parkes telescope multibeam receiver ( paper 1 , dickey et al .
the latitude coverage is @xmath6 for the interferometer with extension to @xmath7 with the single dish only ( resolution @xmath8 ) .
the resulting spectral line cubes have uniform sensitivity to all angular scales down to @xmath9 .
the combination is done using the miriad task immerge , that provides the opportunity for careful gain balance between the single dish and interferometer images , using their respective amplitudes in the overlapping portion of the @xmath10 plane .
we used the continuum images ( line free ) to set this relative gain factor , the line data are thus not used to scale itself at any stage .
overall flux calibration is tied to the primary southern calibration source , pks b1934 - 638 , that is assumed to have flux density of 14.95 jy at 1380 mhz .
the best studied portion of the sgps so far is our test region , which covers @xmath11 and @xmath12 .
observations of this area were done before the main survey , to evaluate the data quality and reduction strategy .
our basic spectral line cube of this region has spectral channel spacing 0.824 km s@xmath13 , pixel size 40 , and clean beam size ( fwhm ) 118@xmath14 125 .
this gives gain g = 41.2 k / jy , where g is defined by @xmath15 where @xmath16 is boltzmann s constant , @xmath17 the wavelength , and @xmath18 is the solid angle of the synthesized beam , that is 1.3x10@xmath19 degrees@xmath20 or 10.3 pixels in the map plane .
the rms noise is 1.7 k in the spectral line channels , and the dynamic range is about 250:1 in the continuum .
the area was covered as a mosaic of 190 pointings with the interferometer , of which each one was observed 40 times with `` snapshots '' of 30 s integration time each .
the mosaic was processed with the miriad program mosmem ( sault et al .
1996 ) , that deconvolves the effects of missing @xmath10 spacings , and partially recovers the short spacing information that the interferometer misses . * for figure 1 see the jpeg image associated with this paper . * figure 1 shows the hi emission after continuum subtraction .
the upper portion shows the velocity integral of the emission spectra in each pixel ( zero moment map ) , and the lower portion shows the emission brightness vs. longitude and velocity along a line near latitude 0for which there are no bright continuum sources .
individual channel maps of the 21-cm emission of this region are shown in paper 2 .
the large scale galactic structures that cross this longitude range are the norma arm , the scutum - crux arm , and the sagittarius - carina arm . following the discussion of paper 2 ( figure 4 )
, the norma arm is near the tangent point , at galactocentric radius about 4.5 kpc and radial velocity -100 dropping to -60 km s@xmath13 ( lsr ) .
we see this arm tangent to the line of sight , stretching from about 6 to 11 kpc distance .
the scutum - crux arm is at about 3.5 kpc distance , with radial velocity -50 to -60 km s@xmath13 .
the sagittarius - carina arm blends with the local gas at about -10 to -20 km s@xmath13 .
the solar circle on the far side is at about 15 kpc distance . at that distance
the z - height of the top of our field ( @xmath21 ) is about 800 pc , so the scale height of the hi layer ( nominally 150 pc ) comes up only to about 06 . at the scutum - crux arm
distance the top of our field is only at 180 pc , so at -50 km s@xmath13 we see a decrease in hi brightness with b by about a factor of two to three over our latitude range .
this large scale structure of the inner galaxy is not strikingly apparent on the longitude - velocity diagram of figure 1 for three reasons .
the first is that , unlike co and other tracers of gas in high density environments , the hi 21-cm emission coefficient depends only on the density and not on the temperature .
atomic hydrogen is quite widespread , with a filling factor of 25% or more in the inner galaxy , so the inter - arm regions are not empty of hi .
but in the high density environment of the spiral arms , most of the hi is converted to h@xmath22 , so the 21-cm emissivity no longer traces the total density of hydrogen ( allen 2001 ) .
large scale galactic structure typically causes only moderate variations in the hi emissivity , that are reflected in variations of a factor of two or three in the spectrum of brightness temperature vs. velocity .
the second problem is that large scale departures from circular rotation can cause as much structure in the emission spectra as density variations ( burton 1971 ) .
thus the details of the @xmath23-v diagram depend as much on the velocity structure of the spiral pattern as they do on the local emissivity variations . finally , the third complicating factor is self - absorption in the 21-cm line .
the optical depth of the hi is on the order of one over roughly 30% of the inner galaxy velocity range ( here negative velocities ) .
a full analysis of this effect is beyond the scope of this paper , we will present a more extensive discussion of hi absorption and hi self - absorption in a forthcoming paper .
to study the sps of the emission , we want to look where there is emission only , to avoid confusion between emission and absorption .
we concentrate on two sample regions where there are no bright continuum sources , each 128 pixels square ( 85.3@xmath24 85.3 ) ; region 1 extends from ( l , b)=(32732,+182 ) to ( 32874,+323 ) , region 2 extends from ( 32929,-001 ) to ( 33070,+140 ) .
the first is at a latitude high enough that even the diffuse continuum is faint , the latter is near b=0 , so it has the longest lines of sight across the outer galaxy .
these areas are indicated on figure 2 , that shows the continuum emission from the test region . the extended sources are mostly identified as hii regions or supernova remnants , as discussed in paper 2 .
here we avoid them and their effects on the ism .
figure 2 shows representative spectra ( taken from the center of each area ) , with at the bottom of each an indication of the radial velocity vs. distance @xmath25 along the line of sight predicted by cylindrical rotation with the rotation curve of fich et al .
the * slope * of this curve is the velocity gradient , a critical quantity for determining the line of sight depth of a given velocity interval , and thus the expected profile shape ( burton 1989 ) . along
most of the line of sight in the inner galaxy the velocity gradient has value @xmath26 , except near the subcentral point where it necessarily goes through zero . for each region , we apodize by multiplying each plane of the cube by a window function that is unity everywhere except near the edges of the region where it drops smoothly to zero with a gaussian profile ( stanimirovi 1999 ) .
this reduces the `` edge effects '' in the transform plane caused by discontinuities at the edge of the image when it is replicated in both dimensions ( e.g. brault and white 1971 ) .
then we fourier transform , and compute the * magnitude squared * of the fourier components .
the transforms were done using the miriad task fft , that does the normalization by @xmath27 in the inverse transform , so values on the transform plane are typically a factor of @xmath28 higher than on the sky plane .
there are still `` diffraction spikes '' through the center of the transform image ( pixel 65,65 is the center or `` zero spacing '' in the uv plane ) due to the narrow width of the edge taper in the apodizing function , so we blank row 65 and column 65 .
then we segment the uv plane into annuli with radii increasing logarithmically , and for each annulus we compute the mean and rms of the values of the transform magnitude squared for all pixels whose centers lie in the annulus .
the results are shown in figures 3 through 6 .
figure 3 shows the spatial power spectra of the hi emission in region 1 .
each set of points connected by line segments corresponds to a single velocity channel ( 0.824 km s@xmath13 ) .
we plot only every 24th channel , so the lines on figure 3 correspond to velocity channels spaced by 20 km s@xmath13 from -140 to + 100 km s@xmath13 .
these include several baseline channels on each side of the emission , five channels that sample primarily the inner galaxy ( at negative velocities ) , and four that sample the outer galaxy ( positive velocities ) , indicated by different symbols on figure 3 .
figure 3 has different units on its different axes .
the bottom axis is the spatial frequency , that has units of inverse angle ( here degrees@xmath13 ) .
this shows the radius on the uv plane of the middle of each annular bin .
corresponding to a given spatial frequency ( number of cycles per degree ) is a baseline length of the interferometer ; these lengths are shown on the top scale .
the original image has units of brightness temperature ( k ) , so its transform has units of brightness temperature per pixel area , or k degree@xmath29 .
since the images are 128 x 128 pixels at 40 , the pixel size on the conjugate ( @xmath10 ) plane is 0.703 degrees@xmath13 and the pixel area is 0.494 degrees@xmath30 .
finally we scale the magnitude squared of the transform components by the pixel size squared , i.e. by dividing by ( 0.703 deg@xmath13)@xmath31 to get units of k@xmath32 degree@xmath33 .
these units are indicated on the left hand scale of figure 3 .
we can alternatively convert the original image to units of jy per beam by dividing by 41 k / jy ( the gain of the synthesized beam , g , defined above ) .
dividing the image in units of jy per beam by the beam area in pixels gives units of jy per pixel .
then the units on the transform plane are simply jy . the corresponding squared magnitudes have units jy@xmath32 , as indicated on the right hand scale of figure 3 . on figures 3 and 4
the baseline channels show flat spectra , consistent with radiometer noise that is spatially `` white '' , up to the inverse of the synthesized beam size ( @xmath34fwhm ) .
the prediction for a gaussian with fwhm = @xmath35 and amplitude equal to the square of the two sigma noise level is indicated on figures 3 and 4 .
channels for which the region is filled with emission show the familiar power law sps , with spectral index very close to -3 out to the resolution limit .
figure 4 uses only the atca data for region 2 , while figure 3 uses the combined parkes plus atca images for region 1 .
the interferometer data alone show a cutoff at large angular sizes ( the last column of points on the left side of figure 4 ) that can only be measured with the single dish telescope .
the smoothness of the spatial power spectra down to this smallest spatial frequency in figure 3 demonstrates the quality of the calibration between the interferometer and single dish data . a few channels on figures 3 and 4 show power law slopes flatter than -3 , for example v=+80 km s@xmath13 in region 1 shows slope of -1.5 .
investigation of the images shows that the emission at this velocity is concentrated in a very small clump that is presumably at great distance in the outer galaxy ( its nominal kinematic distance is @xmath36 kpc ) .
since this emission covers an area much smaller than the area of region 1 , the spatial power spectrum is dominated by the * boundaries * of the cloud , rather than its internal structure .
this inevitably flattens the slope of the spectrum , since the lower spatial frequencies can not be as strong for a small cloud as for emission that fills the region . in the limit of a very small cloud , barely resolved by the synthesized beam
, the sps would be flat , similar to the noise in the baseline channels on figures 3 and 4 .
the different slope in this case is not evidence for different statistics of the * internal structure * of the hi cloud , that could only be measured in this way over much smaller areas entirely within the cloud s boundaries .
figure 5 shows velocity spectra of the amplitude squared of the fourier components .
each panel shows the average over one of the annuli on the @xmath10 plane , starting with radius 1.2 degree@xmath13 and going to 37 degree@xmath13 in steps of 0.15 in the log@xmath37 of the radius ( i.e. factors of @xmath38 in spatial frequency , as on figures 3 and 4 ) .
the lowest spatial frequencies show broad , very smooth spectra , whose most significant feature is a bump at high positive velocities ( @xmath39 km s@xmath13 ) on figure 3 .
this corresponds to the small cloud mentioned above . at higher spatial frequencies
the spectra show more structure in velocity , but they are still smoother than any single - pixel emission spectrum from the region . the results presented in figs . 3 and 4 show that the hi spatial power spectrum for both regions 1 and 2 can be fitted with a power law , over a range of angular scales from 3 arcmin to 1 degree ( corresponding to length scales of 6 to 130 pc at the tangent point distance of 7.4 kpc ) . as region 1
is located at @xmath40 degrees ( @xmath41 pc at the tangent point ) and does not contain significant continuum emission , the effects of absorption and hi self - absorption are not severe , and the 21-cm line intensity is generally directly proportional to the hi column density .
we can therefore test predictions of the turbulence theory described in lazarian & pogosyan ( 2000 , hereafter lp ) on this region .
this theory provides a way to relate the observed 2-d sps of the hi brightness to the underlying 3-d statistics of both the density and the velocity distributions . the simplest theoretical situation is the case of density fluctuations alone , with no small scale structure in the velocity field . in this case
, a narrow section through the medium should show a sps slope that differs from that of a deep sample . in the asymptotic limit of thin and thick slices described by lp ( section 3 ) , and assuming steep spectra ( slope @xmath42 less than -1 ) the difference in slope is just one unit , i.e. @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the observed sps and @xmath16 is the spatial frequency .
we can use velocity smoothing to effectively change the width of the slice , since the velocity gradient translates velocity width to line of sight depth as described above .
to search for a change of slope , we average the line data over broad velocity widths in the cube for region 1 , and then recompute the sps following the same method described above .
the results are shown on figures 6 - 8 .
figure 6 is similar to figures 3 and 4 , but with the spectral line data averaged over 24 channels before the fourier transform ( bandwidth 20 km s@xmath13 ) .
based on the velocity gradient of 20 km s@xmath13 kpc@xmath13 , averaging over this velocity width increases the line of sight depth of the samples from @xmath450.4 to 1 kpc .
the sps does indeed steepen , as predicted , from @xmath45 -3.1 to @xmath45 -4.0 in the logarithmic slope .
this range includes the prediction of the simple kolmogorov theory , @xmath46 .
we study this transition from thin to thick sections through the gas , by averaging over progressively broader bandwidths from a single 0.8 km s@xmath13 velocity channel , to three ( 2.5 km s@xmath13 ) , six ( 4.9 km s@xmath13 ) and so on up to the 24 channel averages shown on figure 6 .
we then fit straight lines to the spatial power spectra over the interval from 2 to 8 deg@xmath13 for each new velocity average .
results are shown on figure 7 for representative velocity channels spaced by 30 km s@xmath13 . here
we include three channels from the inner galaxy ( at -20 , -50 , and -80 km s@xmath13 ) , two from the outer galaxy ( + 40 and + 80 km s@xmath13 ) , and one baseline channel that is mostly noise ( -140 km s@xmath13 ) .
they all show some steepening , although the baseline channel fluctuates between slope 0 and slope -1.5 . at velocity
+ 70 the slope steepens from -0.5 to -2 , but this is probably simply due to the small covering factor of this very distant gas , so that the broader velocity averaging includes many separate , unrelated structures in such a way as to increase the covering factor of the hi .
the inner galaxy channels are the most consistent and they best match the prediction of the turbulence model .
each one steepens smoothly ( from slope -2.5 to -3.6 at -50 km s@xmath13 , from -3.3 to -4.1 at -20 km s@xmath13 , and -3.1 to -3.6 at -80 km s@xmath13 ) .
the last , -80
km s@xmath13 , seems to flatten at the broadest bandwidths , that may be due to the velocity gradient s sharp drop to zero at the terminal velocity ( @xmath45 -100 km s@xmath13 at this longitude ) .
averaging more than about 20 km s@xmath13 does not significantly steepen the slope .
this is shown on the upper panel of figure 8 , that plots * all * data for the inner galaxy for a broad range of averaging widths ( to 55 km s@xmath13 ) . to make figure 8 we compute the slope for every modified velocity channel , and
then find the mean and standard deviation of the slopes .
the error bars indicate @xmath47 around the mean of the slopes , for the sample ( size @xmath48 ) of all modified velocity channels with centers in the range -15 km
s@xmath13 to -80 km s@xmath13 . including the turbulence - induced fluctuations of the * velocity field * of the gas as well as density fluctuations changes the meaning of the slope . following lp ( section 4.2 ) we find that the power law slope of the sps for the thin and thick slices becomes @xmath49 in the thick case and @xmath50 in the thin case , where @xmath51 is the power law index of the velocity structure function .
the kolmogorov case has @xmath52 , that would give -2.67 and -3.33 respectively for the slopes in the thin and thick cases .
if we try to force the data from region 1 to match the prediction for the velocity dominated regime , we find a steeper velocity spectral index ( @xmath53 ) but * not centered on -3*. this suggests that the velocity term is not strong enough to dominate the density term in the calculation of the sps slope for region 1 , so there we can measure @xmath42 but not @xmath51 .
region 2 , at much lower latitudes , shows very different behavior .
the center of the region is at @xmath54 , that translates to @xmath55 pc at the tangent point .
this is less than the scale height of * cool * hi ( roughly 120 pc ) , so the line of sight is rich in cool gas , as shown by the many deep absorption lines toward continuum sources in this area .
this effects the lp analysis of the sps in two ways .
first , self - absorption in the hi causes the brightness temperature to saturate , so that it no longer traces the column density of the gas .
second , the intrinsic linewidth of the emission changes from about 16 km s@xmath13 to about 1.6 km s@xmath13 , since the thermal velocity decreases with the temperature , that is about 6000 k in the warm hi but typically 60 k or less in the cool gas . the thermal linewidth is given by @xmath56 where @xmath57 .
this could have a dramatic effect on the sps , as discussed by lp ( section 4.3 ) , in that a given velocity width may be effectively thick for warm gas , but thin for cool gas .
lp predict that changing the velocity resolution will change the sps slope only so long as the velocity resolution is less than the thermal velocity width .
the lower panel of figure 8 shows that the steepening of the sps slope in region 2 stops at velocity width of about 6 km s@xmath13 .
this is rather broad for the * thermal * width of the cool phase gas , however 6 km s@xmath13 matches quite well the random velocity of the cool hi clouds ( belfort and crovisier 1984 ) .
thus the implication of figure 8 is that at low @xmath58 , where the cool phase of the hi dominates , the turbulent * velocity * field dominates the emission fluctuations , whereas at higher @xmath58 , where there is little cool hi relative to warm , the * density * fluctuations dominate .
the numbers indicated for region 2 on figure 8 are significantly lower than for region 1 ; the power law index varies from about -2.65 to about -3.1 .
the much smaller increase in slope with increasing velocity width in this case suggests that we are now in the regime dominated by velocity fluctuations , rather than density fluctuations as in region 1 .
the narrow band slope of -2.65 is in good agreement with the kolmogorov prediction for the velocity dominated regime ( -2.67 ) , but the steeper slope of -3.1 for the broader velocity slices does not match the kolmogorov prediction of -3.33 , based on @xmath52 .
taken at face value , our slope change suggests that @xmath59 , that is a much shallower slope than in the kolmogorov case , implying more energy on small scales than in the classical theory .
these numbers are remarkably similar to the power - law index of -2.8 found for * molecular clouds * , using the optically thick lines of @xmath60co and @xmath61co as tracers ( sttzki et al .
1998 ; bensch et al .
this points out that optically thick gas may show a significantly different sps slope from the optically thin case .
further modifications of the lp theory are needed in order to relate the 2-d and 3-d properties of gas in the optically thick regime .
recent measurements of the sps of the hi in the smc ( stanimirovic & lazarian 2001 , in preparation ) suggest that in that environment the velocity fluctuations dominate the density fluctuations even for the warm medium .
the sps in the smc shows a gradual steepening of the power - law slope , from @xmath62 to @xmath63 , with velocity averaging width .
this is quite close to what would be expected for kolmogorov turbulence ( @xmath52 ) , for an optically thin tracer for which velocity fluctuations dominate .
comparison with the spectra obtained for region 1 suggests that while the smc has more power on smaller scales , the energy cascades faster in the milky way than in the smc .
this is the first study of the galactic hi spatial power spectrum to make use of the technique of large - scale mosaicing that was pioneered by staveley - smith et al .
( 1995 ) in their mapping of the smc .
this technique allows analysis of many interferometer primary beam areas together , at the full resolution of the maximum interferometer baseline .
combining the single dish and interferometer data gives us an effective range of spatial frequencies of more than a factor of 30 .
in addition , the mosaicing technique removes most of the effect of the attenuation due to the primary beam of the interferometer , that was a complication in earlier single - field interferometer studies of the hi in the milky way .
one motivation for this analysis was to confirm the data quality of the sgps , and particularly the relative calibration of the brightness on large and small angular scales .
the smoothness of the power laws at low spatial frequencies on figure 3 demonstrates that the sgps images do not suffer from systematic bias between the single dish and interferometer data , or from missing baselines on the @xmath10 plane .
the results for the sps slopes agree with the general prediction of turbulence theory that the slope should steepen when we make the transition from thin to thick slices ( lp equation 28 ) . looking in more detail at the change of slope vs. velocity averaging in section 3.1 above
, we find that the data for region 1 suggest that in the warm phase hi the sps is dominated by * density * fluctuations , that match the kolmogorov prediction quite well ( @xmath64 is observed , vs. the predicted @xmath65 ) . apparently velocity fluctuations have little effect in this regime .
however at lower latitudes in region 2 we find that velocity fluctuations dominate , with the very shallow spectral index of @xmath66
. this interpretation may require further theoretical analysis taking account of the optical depth of the cool gas .
the larger significance of the change of slope with velocity width is that it provides support to the overall interpretation that the small scale structure of the ism is governed by a turbulence cascade .
this has long been the paradigm for interpretation of the structure function of the * ionized * gas , but it has only recently been extended to cover the structure of the neutral medium as well .
there is some evidence that extending the sps down to the very small angular scales sampled by vlbi observations of 21-cm absorption variations ( faison et al .
1998 ) shows that even this `` tiny scale structure '' ( heiles 1996 ) is consistent with the same cascade ( deshpande 2000 ) . as a disclaimer we must point out that the results presented here , are derived only from small areas that may not be representative of the milky way disk as a whole
it is very likely that different regions of the galaxy have very different characteristics that may be reflected in differences in the statistics of their small scale density and velocity fields .
the differences between the two regions studied here may not nearly span the range of possibilities for the real ism .
only a comprehensive study of the data from the entire sgps area will show how diverse the hi spatial power spectrum may be . on the theoretical side ,
questions remain about how the energy of the turbulence cascades from large to small scales , whether some is lost by dissipation at intermediate scales since the medium almost certainly is compressible , and how the irregularities in the density and velocity fields are coupled .
these fundamental questions are beyond the scope of this study , but we can hardly begin to understand interstellar turbulence until we can answer them .
observationally , the results presented here for the spatial fluctuations of the 21-cm * emission * are critical for the measurement and interpretation of the 21-cm * absorption * in the sgps .
this will be the topic of a forthcoming paper .
we are very grateful to the atnf staff for their assistance and encouragement at all stages of this project , and in particular to robin wark and john reynolds for their support .
we are grateful to avinash deshpande , david green , itzhak goldman and the anonymous referee for suggestions and comments on the manuscript .
b.m.g . acknowledges the support of nasa through hubble fellowship grant hst - hf-01107.01-a awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, for nasa under contract nas 526555 . n.m .
g . is supported by nasa graduate student researchers program gsrp ) fellowship ngt 5 - 50250 .
this research was supported in part by nsf grant ast 97 - 32695 to the university of minnesota .
allen , r.j .
2001 , in * gas and galaxy evolution * asp conference series , eds . j.e .
hibbard , m.p .
rupen , and j.h .
van gorkom , ( san francisco , asp ) in press .
belfort , p. and crovisier , j. 1984 , 136 , 368 .
bensch , f. , sttzki , j. , and heithausen , a. , 2001 , 366 , 636 .
burton , w.b .
, 1971 , 10 , 76 .
burton , w.b .
, 1988 , in * galactic and extragalactic radio astronomy * , 2nd ed .
verschuur and k. kellerman , ( new york : springer - verlag ) p. 295 .
brault , j.w . and white , o.r . , 1971 13 , 169 .
cordes , j.m , and rickett , b.j .
1998 507 , 846 .
crovisier , j. , and dickey , j.m . , 1983 , 122 , 282 .
deshpande , a.a . , 2000 ,
mnras , 317 , 199 .
deshpande , a.a . ,
dwarakanath , k.s . , and goss , w.m . , 2000 543 , 227 .
dickey , j.m .
, mcclure - griffiths , n. , gaensler , b. , green , a. , haynes , r. , wieringa , m. 1999 , in * new perspectives on the interstellar medium * , asp conference series 168 , eds .
taylor , t.l .
landecker , and g. joncas ( san francisco , asp ) p. 27 .
dickman , r.l . ,
margulis , m. , horvath , m.a .
1990 , 365 , 586 .
elmegreen , b.g . , kim , s. , and staveley - smith , l. 2001 , 548 , 749 .
faison , m.d . ,
goss , w.m . ,
diamond , p.j . ,
taylor , g.b . , 1998 , 116 , 2916 .
fich , m. , blitz , l. , and stark , a.a . , 1989 , 342 , 272 .
gautier , t.n .
, boulanger , f. , perault , m. , and puget , j.l . , 1992 , 103 , 1313 .
goldman , i. 2000 541 , 701 .
green , d.a .
, 1993 , 262 , 327 .
heiles , c. , 1997 , 481 , 193 .
kalberla , p.m.w . , and stenholm , l.g .
, 1983 , mitteil .
gesellschaft , 60 , 397 .
kaplan , s.a .
, 1966 , * interstellar gas dynamics * ( oxford : pergamon press ) p.123 ff .
lazarian , a. and pogosyan , d. 2000 537 , 720 .
mcclure - griffiths , n.m . , dickey , j.m .
, gaensler , b.m . , green , a.j . ,
haynes , r.f . , wieringa , m.h . , 2000 , 119 , 2828 .
mcclure - griffiths , n.m . , green , a.j . , dickey , j.m .
, gaensler , b.m . , haynes , r.f . ,
wieringa , m.h . , 2001 , in press .
padoan , p. , kim , s. , goodman , a. , staveley - smith , l. , 2001 , ap .
j. in press ( astro - ph 11122p ) .
rickett , b.j .
1977 , 15 , 479 .
sault , r.j .
, staveley - smith , l. , and brouw , w.n . ,
1996 , supplements , 120 , 375 .
spangler , s.r .
2001 , space science reviews , in press .
stanimirovi , s. , staveley - smith , l. , dickey , j.m . , sault , r.j . , and snowden , s.l . , 1999 , 302 , 417 .
stanimirovi , s. 1999 , ph.d .
thesis , university of western sydney nepean , p. 157 .
staveley - smith , l. , sault , r.j . , mcconnell , d. , kesteven , m.j . ,
hatzidimitriou , d. , freeman , k.c . , and dopita , m.a . , 1995 ,
pasa 12,13 .
sttzki , j. , bensch , f. , heithausen , a. , ossenkopf , v. , and zielinsky , m. , 1998 336 , 697 .
westpfahl , d.j . ,
coleman , p.h . , alexander , j. , and tongue , t. 1999 118 , 323 .
zielinsky , m. and sttzki , j. , 1999 347 , 630 . | using data from the southern galactic plane survey we have measured the spatial power spectrum of the interstellar neutral atomic hydrogen in the fourth galactic quadrant .
this function shows the same power law behavior that has been found for hi in the second quadrant of the milky way and in the magellanic clouds , with the same slope .
when we average over velocity intervals broader than the typical small - scale velocity dispersion , we find that the slope steepens , from @xmath0 to @xmath1 for the warm gas , as predicted by theories of interstellar turbulence if the column density fluctuations are dominated by variations in the gas density on small spatial scales .
the cool gas shows a different increase of slope , that suggests that it is in the regime of turbulence dominated by fluctuations in the velocity field .
overall , these results confirm that the small scale structure and motions in the neutral atomic medium are well described by a turbulent cascade of kinetic energy . |
the baryon asymmetry of the universe ( bau ) is one of the intriguing puzzles in our understanding of the universe . in order to generate the bau ,
three conditions , which have been pointed out by sakharov @xcite , need to be satisfied in the early universe : baryon number ( @xmath3 ) violation , @xmath4/@xmath1 violation and departure from equilibrium .
the @xmath3-violation is actually replaced by @xmath5-violation since the @xmath5-conserving and @xmath6-violating sphaleron process can easily transfer @xmath3 number into @xmath7 number and _ vice versa _ before the electroweak phase transition @xcite .
while several ideas have been proposed to produce bau by using @xmath3-violating interactions , leptogenesis provides a different mechanism for generating bau by using @xmath7-violating interactions @xcite .
in such a case , instead of a baryon asymmetry , a lepton asymmetry is generated in the early universe via @xmath7-violating interactions .
once the net lepton number is generated , it is transferred into the baryon number via the sphaleron process .
such scenarios are naturally realized in seesaw models for neutrino mass generation .
the @xmath7-violating and @xmath4/@xmath1-violating interactions are introduced for majorana mass terms and their yukawa couplings of right - handed neutrinos ( rhns ) .
one of the most beautiful scenarios is the thermal leptogenesis that produces lepton asymmetry from thermally produced rhns . the thermal plasma after reheating produces a number of rhns . when the produced rhns are out of equilibrium , they decay asymmetrically into leptons vs. anti - leptons and thus generate net lepton number .
it has been known that in this case , a large reheating temperature @xmath8 gev is required to obtain enough baryon - number - to - entropy ratio @xmath9 @xcite .
if supersymmetry ( susy ) exists , however , one must take care of gravitino production for such a high reheating temperature @xcite .
the affleck - dine ( ad ) mechanism @xcite is an attractive baryogenesis scenario in susy models that does not necessarily require high reheating temperature and hence the tension with gravitino production is circumvented.gev . ] in susy models , it is quite generic to have many flat directions , so the baryon asymmetry can be efficiently generated along such flat directions .
in particular , if one considers the @xmath0 flat direction , whose non - renormalizable potential is generated by integrating out rhns , sufficient lepton asymmetry can be produced at relatively small reheat temperature . in this case , however , one difficulty arises . for the desired baryon asymmetry
, the @xmath0 direction must be very flat during lepton number generation , which results in a hierarchically light neutrino @xcite .
while this is not excluded since currently there is no lower bound on the lightest neutrino mass , such a hierarchical structure of neutrino masses may not be natural from the viewpoint of model building .
one reason for a hierarchically small neutrino mass in the ad mechanism stems from the fact that the rhn mass scale is responsible for both leptogenesis and neutrino mass generation .
thus the flatness of the @xmath0 direction is directly related to the lightness of neutrino .
one way to relax this constraint is to make the rhn mass dynamical .
if the rhn mass scale is very large during lepton number generation but become small during the current universe , the lightest neutrino can have a rather large mass .
as pointed out in @xcite , such a dynamical rhn mass can be realized in a peccei - quinn ( pq ) symmetric model to solve the strong cp problem @xcite .
if the rhns are charged under pq symmetry , their masses are generated by the pq symmetry breaking @xcite .
thus , the rhn mass is time - dependent and it is determined by the dynamics of the pq field . during inflation ,
the hubble - induced susy breaking potential holds the pq field at the planck scale , and thus pq symmetry is broken at the planck scale .
after inflation and lepton number generation , the hubble - induced susy breaking effect becomes as small as ordinary susy breaking contributions , so the pq field starts to oscillate and settles down at the current value of the pq breaking scale .
the rhns also have planck scale masses from the inflation era to the lepton number generation era , and become lighter afterwards .
therefore , it is possible to simultaneously accommodate very efficient ad leptogenesis when the pq scale is around planck scale and rather larger neutrino mass in the current universe . in this work ,
we revisit the scenario of ad leptogenesis with a varying pq scale , and provide its concrete realization in the dine - fischler - srednicki - zhitnitsky ( dfsz ) type model @xcite . in this model ,
the pq breaking scalar fields provide a solution to the strong cp problem , generate rhn masses and the superpotential @xmath2-term for the higgsino sector .
in addition , the superpotential term responsible for the @xmath2-term plays an important role to maintain the generated lepton asymmetry during pq field oscillation . the isocurvature contribution from axion dark matter
is naturally suppressed by the large pq scale during inflation . in this case , one additional crucial feature resides in the pq field decay . as stated above ,
once the hubble - induced susy breaking effect becomes comparable to the ordinary susy breaking terms , the pq breaking field , which is called saxion , starts to oscillate with respect to the current pq scale .
the saxion dominates the universe right after the reheating process , so its decay produces large amount of entropy .
hence the final baryon asymmetry is sensitive to the saxion decay , which depends on how the pq sector couples to the standard model particles . in the dfsz case ,
the saxion decay is dependent on the @xmath2-term .
therefore the resulting baryon asymmetry after saxion decay is linked to electroweak fine - tuning , which is determined by the @xmath2-term . in sec .
[ sec : ad ] , we analyze ad leptogenesis along the @xmath0 flat direction with a dynamical pq breaking scale and then estimate the baryon asymmetry taking account of the dilution from saxion decay . in sec .
[ sec : pq_dyn ] , we investigate the dynamics of pq breaking scalar fields and then examine conservation of lepton asymmetry during the saxion oscillation . in sec .
[ sec : susy_scale ] we present the main results in the form of contours of required @xmath10 values in the @xmath2 vs. @xmath11 plane , which show a relation between the baryon asymmetry and the electroweak fine - tuning . in sec .
[ sec : pq ] , we discuss some cosmological implications of the pq sector : the axion isocurvature perturbation and axino production .
we conclude in sec .
[ sec : conc ] .
in this section , we show how dynamical pq symmetry breaking accommodates enough baryon asymmetry and a relatively large neutrino mass .
we consider the neutrino sector for ad leptogenesis and the pq breaking sector , which are described by the following superpotential , @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the rhn , @xmath7 is the lepton doublet , @xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) is the up - type ( down - type ) higgs doublet , @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the pq fields , @xmath18 is a singlet scalar , @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 represent numerical coefficients , @xmath22 denotes the ( present ) pq breaking scale and @xmath23 the reduced planck scale .
the pq charges and lepton numbers of these fields are given in table [ table : pqcharge ] .
.u(1 ) charges of the fields . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] when @xmath16 obtains a large field value , the rhn becomes massive and can be integrated out to obtain the effective superpotential : @xmath24 the neutrino mass is generated by the see - saw mechanism at low energy @xmath25 : @xmath26 where @xmath27 gev and @xmath28 here and in the following , we assume that the lepton asymmetry is generated along the flattest @xmath0 direction , which corresponds to the smallest neutrino mass @xmath29 . as will become clear , @xmath16 is different from its low - energy vacuum expectation value ( vev ) @xmath22 in the early universe . at the present universe . ] in particular , @xmath16 is shown to be fixed at @xmath30 until the saxion begins to oscillate ( see sec .
[ sec : pq_dyn ] )
. thus one can also define an effective scale in the early universe as @xmath31 in a different way , @xmath32 is expressed by @xmath33 thus @xmath32 is much larger than @xmath34 , which modifies the ordinary relation between low - energy neutrino mass and the efficiency of ad leptogenesis @xcite . in what follows
, we consider the dynamics of the ad field @xmath35 , which parameterizes the @xmath0 @xmath36-flat direction as @xmath37 the scalar potential of the ad field in the model of eq .
[ eq : lagpq ] reads @xmath38 , \\ & v_h = -c_h h^2|\phi|^2 + \left [ a_h h \frac{y_{\nu}^2}{8\lambda}\frac{\phi^4}{x}+{\rm h.c.}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath39 denotes the contribution from the soft susy breaking and @xmath40 the hubble - induced terms . here
@xmath41 and @xmath42 are of the soft mass scale ( @xmath43 few tev ) , @xmath44 is the hubble parameter , @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 are @xmath48 coefficients . term . in this paper
we simply assume that there is a hubble - induced @xmath49 term . ] for the moment , we assume that the pq field @xmath16 is fixed at @xmath50 until the ad field begins to oscillate . we examine the dynamics including the pq field in sec .
[ sec : pq_dyn ] . from the hubble induced mass and @xmath51 , the ad field is stabilized at @xmath52 for @xmath53 . writing @xmath54
one finds @xmath55 where @xmath56 . the mass along the phase direction is then given by @xmath57 where we have used the fact that @xmath58 .
the mass along the phase direction is of order @xmath44 , so the phase condensate rapidly rolls down to its minimum .
since the phase minimum of this hubble - induced @xmath49 term differs from the soft susy breaking - induced @xmath49 term , the ad field obtains angular momentum in the complex plane , generating the lepton number .
note that we have one more phase direction orthogonal to the above massive direction .
this does not appear in the potential , so is a massless mode corresponding to the axion of the spontaneously broken pq symmetry . in the limit of @xmath58 ,
the massive mode is mostly @xmath59-like and the massless mode is mostly @xmath60-like .
now let us evaluate the lepton number generated through the ad mechanism .
the massive phase mode automatically cancels the imaginary part of the hubble induced @xmath49-term potential , so it does not significantly contribute to lepton number generation .
thus , as in ordinary ad leptogenesis , lepton number is determined by the ordinary @xmath49-term which depends on the hidden sector susy breaking ( _ i.e. _ , gravitino mass in gravity mediation ) .
the lepton number obeys the equation , term in the superpotential after integrating out @xmath13 , the pq number is exactly conserved ( except for the small instanton effect ) . ]
@xmath61 the baryon number to entropy ratio is obtained as @xcite @xmath62 where @xmath63 represents an effective cp violating phase , and @xmath64 is the hubble parameter when the @xmath35 field starts to oscillate .
taking account of thermal effects on the ad potential @xcite , the latter is determined by @xmath65 , \label{eq : hosc}\ ] ] where @xmath66.\ ] ] here , the @xmath67 are coupling constants of @xmath35 with particles in thermal background , @xmath68 and @xmath69 are real positive constants of order unity , and @xmath70 is the reheating temperature after inflation . from eq .
( [ eq : hosc ] ) , @xmath64 is nearly @xmath71 when the temperature is small . in the case of a large reheat temperature
, the @xmath35 oscillation can commence earlier due to thermal effects which result in the second and third terms inside the bracket of eq .
( [ eq : hosc ] ) .
the detailed physical aspects are explained in ref .
@xcite and references therein .
if @xmath72 tev and @xmath73 gev , such early oscillation occurs for @xmath74 gev . for an illustration , we show a formula for a case where the early oscillation does not occur . in such a case ,
@xmath75 , so the baryon - number - to - entropy ratio becomes @xmath76 where we also assume @xmath77 . in this scenario , however , saxion will dominate the universe , and its decay produces entropy dilution . in order to obtain the final baryon asymmetry after saxion decay , the entropy dilution must be taken into account .
we will consider the entropy production in the following subsection . before closing this subsection ,
let us comment on the possible lepton number violation during the saxion oscillation .
since the field value of @xmath16 can become small during its oscillation , the effect of the lepton number violation , induced by the effective superpotential or the corresponding @xmath49-term , may become large . here , as shown in sec .
[ sec : pq_dyn ] , the @xmath2-term interaction in eq . , @xmath78 plays an important role .
assuming @xmath79 , the lepton number violation during the saxion oscillation is small enough to maintain the generated lepton asymmetry by the ad mechanism .
as we shall see in the next subsection , the @xmath2-term interaction also plays a key role to determine the saxion decay , and hence the final baryon asymmetry .
we have discussed how the dynamical pq breaking scale can enhance the baryon asymmetry .
for the final result , one crucial point to consider is the entropy production from saxion decay . in the dfsz model ,
saxion interactions with the standard model particles and their superpartners are realized in the @xmath2-term interaction .
once @xmath16 and @xmath17 settle down to the current value of the pq symmetry breaking scale , @xmath80 , this superpotential generates the @xmath2-term , @xmath81 and also interactions between the axion superfield and the higgs supermultiplets . through this interaction ,
the saxion dominantly decays into higgsino states if they are kinematically allowed .
its decay rate is approximately given by @xcite , we use the saxion decay rates including phase space and mixings in @xcite . ]
@xmath82 note that we have used here @xmath83 under assumption of @xmath84 in the present universe , so quantities related to axion dark matter is determined by @xmath85 ( @xmath86 : domain wall number ) as the usual normalization .
the decay temperature is @xmath87 if saxion decays into higgsino states are disallowed , it dominantly decays into the light higgs and gauge bosons .
the decay rate in such a case is given by @xmath88 and the decay temperature becomes @xmath89 from the above decay temperature for each case , one finds the entropy dilution factor @xmath90 .
\label{eq : dilut}\ ] ] here we have included the case where @xmath70 is small so that the saxion decays before the reheating process is over . the final baryon asymmetry is determined by the amount of asymmetry when the ad mechanism completes , eq .
( [ eq : bary - to - ent_wo_dilut ] ) and by the dilution factor , eq . ( [ eq : dilut ] ) : @xmath91 for the case where saxion dominantly decays into higgsinos , @xmath92 or for the case where saxion dominantly decays into light higgs and gauge bosons , @xmath93 from this it is easily seen that the observed baryon - number - to - entropy - ratio can be obtained for relatively large neutrino mass @xmath94 ev if the pq breaking scale is near the planck scale in the beginning and settles to @xmath95 gev at the present universe .
we will see numerical results for some example parameter regions in sec .
[ sec : susy_scale ] .
in this section , we discuss the dynamics of the pq breaking fields in order to investigate the realization of the planck scale pq breaking in the early stage and lepton number conservation at the late stage .
let us first examine the scalar potential of @xmath16 and @xmath17 for large @xmath44 to check if the pq scale is @xmath96 .
we have to consider the supergravity potential which is given by @xmath97 where @xmath98 .
we assume that the effect of the ad field @xmath35 is negligible .
the khler potential and superpotential are given by @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the inflaton field .
note that only @xmath16 has non - minimal coupling with the inflaton in @xmath101 .
if @xmath102 , one can obtain a negative hubble - induced mass term for @xmath16 and thus @xmath16 develops a large vev .
let us see the scalar potential in detail . in this discussion , @xmath18 obtains a mass of @xmath103 and @xmath104 ( @xmath105 ) , so its vev is zero up to of the order of the gravitino mass : @xmath106 .
thus we can safely neglect the dynamics of @xmath18 . if @xmath107 during inflation , the inflaton energy is dominantly determined by the @xmath108-term potential , _
i.e. _ @xmath109 , @xmath110 and @xmath111 .
one can simplify the inflaton potential : @xmath112 . in these circumstances ,
the scalar potential of @xmath16 and @xmath17 is given by @xmath113 let us define @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
the extremum condition is obtained as @xmath116\nonumber\\ & & \times e^{(x^2+y^2)/m_p^2},\label{eq : dvdx}\\ 0=\frac{\partial v}{\partial y}&= & \eta^2(xy - f^2)\left(\frac{y}{m_p^2}(xy - f^2)+2x\right)e^{(x^2+y^2)/m_p^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the second equation , we find that @xmath117 since the second solution leads to a trivial solution @xmath118 we select the first solution . from eq .
( [ eq : dvdx ] ) , we obtain the solution for @xmath119 , @xmath120 for @xmath102 , @xmath119 develops an @xmath96 vev as long as @xmath121 .
it is also evident that @xmath16 obtains a ( negative ) mass squared of the order of @xmath122 during the inflaton domination .
as argued in the previous subsection , @xmath16 stays at @xmath123 until the hubble parameter drops down to @xmath124 .
after that , the saxion begins a coherent oscillation around the minimum @xmath125 with an initial amplitude of @xmath126 . since the scalar field orthogonal to the @xmath108-flat direction ( saxion ) has a mass of @xmath127 , which is much higher than the soft mass scale , we can safely set @xmath128 to integrate out either @xmath16 or @xmath17
. then the scalar potential along the @xmath108-flat direction @xmath129 and the ad field @xmath35 reads @xmath130 where @xmath131 and @xmath132 are the soft susy breaking mass of @xmath16 and @xmath17 , respectively .
the last term comes from @xmath133 ( [ eq : mu ] ) .
the third and fourth terms act as the effective potential for @xmath16 and they prevent @xmath16 from being very small during the oscillation .
let us denote by @xmath134 the maximum value of @xmath16 during each @xmath16 oscillation , which adiabatically becomes smaller due to the hubble expansion @xmath135 .
then we can define @xmath136 , the minimum value of @xmath16 during each oscillation . for a large ad field value @xmath35 ,
the last term is important to determine @xmath136 .
thus we can evaluate @xmath136 as @xmath137 .
\label{eq : xmin}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath138 and @xmath139 just after the saxion oscillation , @xmath136 is generically much larger than the soft mass scale , meaning that the rhn masses can not be as small as the soft mass during saxion oscillation and hence the procedure to integrate out the rhn to obtain the effective potential of the ad field is justified .
now let us consider the lepton number violation after the @xmath16 begins to oscillate .
the lepton number follows : @xmath140 as discussed above , @xmath16 oscillates between @xmath134 and @xmath136 in a time scale @xmath141 where @xmath136 is given by eq . .
the most dangerous @xmath7 violation may happen around @xmath142 at which the @xmath7-violating operator becomes large .
the time interval @xmath143 during which @xmath144 is estimated from the equation of motion @xmath145 during this time interval , the @xmath7 number changes as @xmath146 using @xmath147 , we obtain @xmath148 since @xmath149 in the numerator decreases faster than @xmath134 in the denominator , this takes a maximum value just after the @xmath16 begins to oscillate @xmath150 .
@xmath151 this must be smaller than 1 to ensure the conservation of lepton number .
if thermal effects are neglected and @xmath152 , we have @xmath153 and it becomes @xmath154 thus , the lepton number violation during the saxion oscillation can be neglected as far as @xmath152 is satisfied .
we have discussed how pq symmetry breaking accommodates the baryon asymmetry with a sizable neutrino mass when the pq scale varies during and after inflation . in this scenario ,
the entropy dilution from saxion decay indeed plays a substantial role for determining the final value of the baryon asymmetry .
the saxion decay rate depends on its mass and the @xmath2-term as shown in eqs .
( [ eq : saxdec1 ] ) and ( [ eq : saxdec2 ] ) . in many cases ,
the saxion mass and @xmath2-term are related to the soft susy breaking scale . in particular , @xmath2-term is a measure of fine - tuning of the electroweak symmetry breaking .
therefore , it leads us to discuss the soft susy scale and fine - tuning from the measured baryon asymmetry . since the saxion is linked to the axion which is the nambu - goldstone boson of broken pq symmetry , it is massless in the supersymmetric limit . when susy is broken , however , the saxion ( and also the axino ) acquires a mass .
the saxion mass is typically of the gravitino mass order although it can be either larger or smaller than the gravitino mass in some models @xcite . on the other hand , as shown in the sec .
[ sec : pq_dyn]b , the saxion mass ( _ i.e. _ @xmath131 ) is required to be smaller than the ad field mass in order to not spoil lepton number generation . in this regard , we consider a rather small saxion mass compared to the ad field mass , _
i.e. _ @xmath155 .
in contrast to the saxion mass , the @xmath2-term is a supersymmetric parameter , so its origin can be different from the susy breaking . in models with pq symmetry breaking ,
the @xmath2-term can be generated from pq symmetry breaking through non - renormalizable interactions @xcite .- term generated by pq symmetry breaking is related to the soft susy scale . in this work , however , we are agnostic as to the origin of the pq scale @xmath22 in eq .
( [ eq : lagpq ] ) . ] in sec .
[ sec : sax_dec ] , we have discussed the @xmath2-term generation via an interaction suppressed by the planck scale as shown in eq .
( [ eq : mu ] ) .
in such a case , the @xmath2-term is typically @xmath156 .
however , the suppression scale for this interaction can be different from the planck scale ( _ e.g. _ the grand unification scale ) , while the coupling constant ( @xmath21 ) for this interaction can be smaller than unity . for this reason , we will consider @xmath2 as an independent parameter of the model in the following discussions . in order to achieve successful electroweak symmetry breaking ,
the soft susy breaking scale and @xmath2-term must coincide with each other since they need to satisfy the relation , @xmath157 where @xmath158 is the soft mass term for the up - type higgs at the weak scale . for a natural model , these three quantities above need to be comparable to one another so that no dramatic cancellation takes place .
if @xmath158 and @xmath2 are much larger than @xmath159 , on the other hand , fine - tuning arises .
although it is hard to quantify the level of fine - tuning without specifying the whole susy spectrum , we can roughly see how much fine - tuning is required from the size of @xmath2-term ( or equivalently @xmath158 ) @xcite : @xmath160 the baryon asymmetry depends on the soft susy breaking scale when the ad mechanism works as described in eq .
( [ eq : bary - to - ent_wo_dilut ] ) .
it is also dependent on the saxion decay rate which is determined by the saxion mass ( soft susy scale ) , the @xmath2-term and the pq breaking scale as shown in eqs .
( [ eq : bau_large ] ) and ( [ eq : bau_small ] ) . therefore , by requiring @xmath161 , we can obtain _ the relation between the lightest neutrino mass and @xmath2-term_. [ ev ] on the @xmath162 plane to reproduce the observed baryon asymmetry .
in the left ( right ) panel we have taken @xmath163 @xmath164 while @xmath165 ( @xmath166 ) .
the light ( dark ) red shaded region corresponds to @xmath167gev ( 1gev ) and the grey shaded region is excluded by the kamland - zen experiment .
the light - gray shaded region is constrained by planck+bao @xcite .
the light - purple shaded region indicates bound from sn1987a @xcite .
the blue shaded region corresponds to @xmath168 .
, title="fig:",width=302][ev ] on the @xmath162 plane to reproduce the observed baryon asymmetry .
in the left ( right ) panel we have taken @xmath163 @xmath164 while @xmath165 ( @xmath166 ) .
the light ( dark ) red shaded region corresponds to @xmath167gev ( 1gev ) and the grey shaded region is excluded by the kamland - zen experiment .
the light - gray shaded region is constrained by planck+bao @xcite .
the light - purple shaded region indicates bound from sn1987a @xcite .
the blue shaded region corresponds to @xmath168 .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] shows illustrative contours of neutrino masses which produce the desired baryon asymmetry , @xmath169 for given values of @xmath11 and @xmath2 . in the left panel ,
we take @xmath170 for which saxion decays into higgsino states are allowed while in the right panel , we take @xmath171 for which saxion can decay only into sm particles . in order to maintain the generated lepton asymmetry , @xmath165 and @xmath166
are taken respectively for each case .
the gray shaded region shows parameter space where the lightest neutrino mass is larger than the kamland - zen bound @xcite .
we also show a bound from planck+bao constraint on the sum of neutrino masses , @xmath172 ev @xcite .
the light - purple shaded region shows the bound from sn1987a @xcite . the ( light-)red shaded region shows parameter space where the saxion decay temperature is smaller than 1 gev ( 10 gev ) .
the blue shade indicates the region for which @xmath173 .
we consider fixed @xmath174 gev since larger @xmath70 does not change or does suppress @xmath175 ( see eq .
( [ eq : nbs_final ] ) ) . in the case where @xmath175 is suppressed
, it requires a smaller neutrino mass that is less attractive . from the figure
, it is clearly shown that neutrino mass is large for large @xmath2 and small @xmath11 while it becomes smaller for small @xmath2 and large @xmath11 .
this feature stems from the saxion decay temperature .
the saxion decay temperature is enhanced by the @xmath2-term while suppressed by @xmath11 .
it is also of great importance that small @xmath11 is good for obtaining a flatter direction during lepton number generation as shown in eq .
( [ eq : m _ * ] ) . for @xmath176 tev and @xmath177 gev
, our model predicts a rather large neutrino mass so that it is constrained by recent neutrinoless double beta decay ( @xmath178 ) experiment . for this constraint ,
we take a conservative bound from kamland - zen , @xmath179 ev @xcite . from the lower - right corner ( @xmath180 gev , @xmath181 gev ) to the upper - left corner ( @xmath182 gev , @xmath183 gev ) , the resulting neutrino mass scans over @xmath184 ev . for large @xmath185 gev , in order to obtain a natural value of the lightest neutrino mass , @xmath186 ev in cases of both @xmath170 and @xmath171 , the @xmath2-term is required to be tens of tev . in such cases , the fine - tuning in the electroweak symmetry breaking is of permyriad ( @xmath187 ) order . for a smaller pq scale , @xmath181 gev , @xmath2 can be a few hundred gev to achieve @xmath188 ev , so the model is much less fine - tuned . if we constrain the @xmath2-term to make fine - tuning better than a percent level , _
@xmath189 gev@xmath190 gev , @xmath191 ev@xmath192 ev can be achieved for @xmath193 gev@xmath194 gev .
this region is well - matched with the parameter space where @xmath2 can be determined by the planck suppressed interaction , eq .
( [ eq : mu ] ) .
moreover , it is good for the _ mixed axion - higgsino dark matter scenario _ @xcite . before closing this section ,
it is worth noting that the saxion decay temperature can be smaller than @xmath195 gev for small @xmath2 and large @xmath11 as indicated by red shaded regions in fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] .
the region with @xmath196 gev may cause the saxion to decay after freeze - out of weakly interacting massive particle ( wimp ) dark matter and thus such late decay affects the wimp dark matter density due to entropy production and/or non - thermal dark matter production , although it is not possible to make a concrete analysis without a specific susy spectrum .
moreover , for the region with @xmath197 gev , the saxion decays after coherent oscillation of axion commences , so it affects the axion dark matter density , too .
in this section we discuss some cosmological implications related to the pq sector : axion isocurvature perturbation and axino production .
there is a ( nearly ) massless goldstone boson from the spontaneous breakdown of the u(1)@xmath198 symmetry , the axion , which can also be interpreted as a massless majoron in our model @xcite .
such a massless boson potentially causes several cosmological problems @xcite . in our setup , the pq symmetry is already broken during inflation and is not restored thereafter .
thus there is no axionic domain wall problem .
the pq scalar @xmath16 obtains a large vev of @xmath126 in our setup , hence the pq scale during inflation is much higher than that in the present universe .
it significantly suppresses the axion isocurvature perturbation @xcite .
since the massless axion mode almost consists of the phase component of @xmath16 for @xmath199 , the effective pq scale during inflation is simply given by @xmath200 . or @xmath15 has a larger field value than @xmath16 , the effective pq scale is given by @xmath201 or @xmath202 @xcite .
this is not the case in our model . ]
the magnitude of cdm isocurvature perturbation is then given by @xmath203 where @xmath204 denotes the hubble scale during inflation , @xmath205 denotes the initial misalignment angle of the axion and @xmath206 denotes the fraction of present axion energy density in the matter energy density : @xmath207 .
the final axion density is given by @xcite @xmath208 here we have assumed that there is no dilution of the axion density due to the saxion decay .
the planck constraint on the uncorrelated isocurvature perturbation @xcite reads @xmath209 this constraint is easily satisfied for most inflation models since @xmath210 in our scenario .
the axino is the fermionic superpartner of the axion , consisting of the fermionic components of @xmath16 and @xmath17 with a small mixture of higgsino .
it obtains a mass of @xmath211 .
it has a relatively long lifetime if it is not the lightest susy particle ( lsp ) @xcite .
its decay width is approximately given by @xmath212 which is comparable to the saxion .
thus the axino can have significant impacts on cosmology .
the dominant axino production process is the thermal one .. ] the axino thermal production in the dfsz model comes from the combination of higgsino decay / inverse decay , scatterings of higgs and weak gauge bosons and also top / stop scatterings @xcite .
there it was found that the production is dominated at @xmath213 in general and the abundance is independent of the reheating temperature @xmath70 as long as @xmath214 . in our case ,
the saxion decay temperature @xmath215 can be lower than @xmath42 and hence there is a dilution of the preexisting axino abundance .
first , let us consider the case @xmath216 .
one of the main contributions may be the heavy higgs decay into the higgsino plus axino with the partial decay rate @xmath217 where the heavy higgs mass is assumed to be @xmath218 .
the axino abundance is then estimated as @xmath219 in the opposite case @xmath220 , we must take the dilution factor into account . noting that @xmath221 during saxion domination , the resultant axino abundance is given by @xmath222 due to the dilution
, the axino abundance can be suppressed .
when the axino decays into lsp ( _ e.g. _ neutralinos ) , the lsp density is determined by its re - annihilation rate @xcite , @xmath223 where @xmath224 is the axino decay temperature .
thus the dark matter density from axino decay highly depends on details of the axino decay as well as upon its annihilation rate at @xmath224 .
in this paper we have reconsidered the ad leptogenesis in a scenario where the rhn mass is dynamical .
if the rhn mass is generated by the pq field , it naturally takes hierarchically different values between the early universe and the present epoch .
in particular , the pq scalar can be stabilized at the planck scale in the early universe until the lepton asymmetry is generated , which makes leptogenesis much more efficient than in the ordinary scenario .
the predicted lightest neutrino mass to reproduce the observed baryon asymmetry can be close to the neutrino mass differences known from the neutrino oscillation data .
it significantly relaxes the problem of the ordinary ad leptogenesis scenario in which the lightest neutrino mass should be hierarchically smaller than the other two neutrinos . in order to realize this scenario ,
we have considered the dfsz model which provide a solution to the strong @xmath1 problem and generates the @xmath2-term and the rhn mass .
since the final baryon asymmetry depends on the saxion decay , it is related to the @xmath2-term and to the electroweak fine - tuning . as a result ,
a comparatively large mass of the lightest neutrino , @xmath225 ev , is predicted for @xmath193 gev@xmath194 gev and @xmath189 gev@xmath190 gev . in this model , therefore , it is possible to accommodate successful ad leptogenesis with a natural neutrino mass and natural electroweak symmetry breaking .
in addition , due to the very large pq scale during inflation , the axion isocurvature perturbation is suppressed .
this work is supported by ibs under the project code , ibs - r018-d1 [ kjb ] and the grant - in - aid for scientific research on scientific research a ( no.26247038 [ kh ] , no.26247042 [ kn ] , no.16h02189 [ kh ] ) , young scientists b ( no.26800121 [ kn ] , no.26800123 [ kh ] ) and innovative areas ( no.26104001 [ kh ] , no.26104009 [ kh and kn ] , no.15h05888 [ kn ] ) , and by world premier international research center initiative ( wpi initiative ) , mext , japan .
the work of hb is supported in part by the us department of energy , office of high energy physics .
a. d. sakharov , pisma zh .
* 5 * , 32 ( 1967 ) [ jetp lett . * 5 * , 24 ( 1967 ) ] [ sov .
usp . * 34 * , 392 ( 1991 ) ] [ usp .
nauk * 161 * , 61 ( 1991 ) ] .
doi:10.1070/pu1991v034n05abeh002497 v. a. kuzmin , v. a. rubakov and m. e. shaposhnikov , phys . lett .
b * 155 * , 36 ( 1985 ) .
doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(85)91028 - 7 m. fukugita and t. yanagida , phys . lett .
b * 174 * , 45 ( 1986 ) .
doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(86)91126 - 3 w. buchmuller , r. d. peccei and t. yanagida , ann . rev .
nucl . part .
sci . * 55 * , 311 ( 2005 ) doi:10.1146/annurev.nucl.55.090704.151558 [ hep - ph/0502169 ] .
m. kawasaki , k. kohri , t. moroi and a. yotsuyanagi , phys .
d * 78 * ( 2008 ) 065011 doi:10.1103/physrevd.78.065011 [ arxiv:0804.3745 [ hep - ph ] ] .
i. affleck and m. dine , nucl .
b * 249 * , 361 ( 1985 ) .
doi:10.1016/0550 - 3213(85)90021 - 5 m. dine , l. randall and s. d. thomas , nucl .
b * 458 * , 291 ( 1996 ) doi:10.1016/0550 - 3213(95)00538 - 2 [ hep - ph/9507453 ] .
g. lazarides and q. shafi , phys
. lett .
b * 258 * , 305 ( 1991 ) .
doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(91)91090-i t. asaka , k. hamaguchi , m. kawasaki and t. yanagida , phys .
b * 464 * , 12 ( 1999 ) doi:10.1016/s0370 - 2693(99)01020 - 5 [ hep - ph/9906366 ] ; phys .
d * 61 * , 083512 ( 2000 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.61.083512 [ hep - ph/9907559 ] .
k. hamaguchi , h. murayama and t. yanagida , phys .
d * 65 * , 043512 ( 2002 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.65.043512 [ hep - ph/0109030 ] .
t. asaka , m. fujii , k. hamaguchi and t. yanagida , phys .
d * 62 * , 123514 ( 2000 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.62.123514 [ hep - ph/0008041 ] . m. fujii , k. hamaguchi and t. yanagida , phys . rev .
d * 63 * , 123513 ( 2001 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.63.123513 [ hep - ph/0102187 ] .
r. d. peccei and h. r. quinn , phys .
lett . * 38 * , 1440 ( 1977 ) .
doi:10.1103/physrevlett.38.1440 p. langacker , r. d. peccei and t. yanagida , mod .
lett . a * 1 * , 541 ( 1986 ) .
doi:10.1142/s0217732386000683 m. dine , w. fischler and m. srednicki , phys .
b * 104 * , 199 ( 1981 ) ; a. r. zhitnitsky , sov .
. phys . * 31 * , 260 ( 1980 ) [ yad .
fiz . * 31 * , 497 ( 1980 ) ] .
s. kasuya , m. kawasaki and f. takahashi , jcap * 0810 * , 017 ( 2008 ) doi:10.1088/1475 - 7516/2008/10/017 [ arxiv:0805.4245 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. allahverdi , b. a. campbell and j. r. ellis , nucl .
b * 579 * , 355 ( 2000 ) doi:10.1016/s0550 - 3213(00)00124 - 3 [ hep - ph/0001122 ] .
a. anisimov and m. dine , nucl .
b * 619 * , 729 ( 2001 ) doi:10.1016/s0550 - 3213(01)00550 - 8 [ hep - ph/0008058 ] .
k. hamaguchi , hep - ph/0212305 .
t. goto and m. yamaguchi , phys .
b * 276 * , 103 ( 1992 ) .
doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(92)90547-h e. j. chun , j. e. kim and h. p. nilles , phys .
b * 287 * , 123 ( 1992 ) doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(92)91886-e [ hep - ph/9205229 ] .
e. j. chun and a. lukas , phys .
b * 357 * , 43 ( 1995 ) doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(95)00881-k [ hep - ph/9503233 ] .
k. j. bae , h. baer , e. j. chun and c. s. shin , phys .
d * 91 * , no . 7 , 075011 ( 2015 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.91.075011 [ arxiv:1410.3857 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. e. kim and h. p. nilles , phys .
* 138b * , 150 ( 1984 ) .
doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(84)91890 - 2 h. murayama , h. suzuki and t. yanagida , phys . lett .
b * 291 * , 418 ( 1992 ) .
doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(92)91397-r t. gherghetta and g. l. kane , phys .
b * 354 * , 300 ( 1995 ) doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(95)00620-z [ hep - ph/9504420 ] .
k. choi , e. j. chun and j. e. kim , phys .
b * 403 * , 209 ( 1997 ) doi:10.1016/s0370 - 2693(97)00465 - 6 [ hep - ph/9608222 ] .
n. abe , t. moroi and m. yamaguchi , jhep * 0201 * , 010 ( 2002 ) doi:10.1088/1126 - 6708/2002/01/010 [ hep - ph/0111155 ] . k. nakayama and n. yokozaki , jhep * 1211 * , 158 ( 2012 ) doi:10.1007/jhep11(2012)158 [ arxiv:1204.5420 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. j. bae , h. baer and h. serce , phys .
d * 91 * , no . 1
, 015003 ( 2015 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.91.015003 [ arxiv:1410.7500 [ hep - ph ] ] . h. baer , v. barger , p. huang , a. mustafayev and x. tata , phys .
lett . * 109 * , 161802 ( 2012 ) doi:10.1103/physrevlett.109.161802 [ arxiv:1207.3343 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. gando _ et al .
_ [ kamland - zen collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 117 * , no . 8 , 082503 ( 2016 ) addendum : [ phys . rev .
lett . * 117 * , no .
10 , 109903 ( 2016 ) ] doi:10.1103/physrevlett.117.109903 , 10.1103/physrevlett.117.082503 [ arxiv:1605.02889 [ hep - ex ] ] .
p. a. r. ade _ et al .
_ [ planck collaboration ] , astron .
astrophys .
* 594 * , a13 ( 2016 ) doi:10.1051/0004 - 6361/201525830 [ arxiv:1502.01589 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
we take the limit from a recent review , j. e. kim and g. carosi , rev .
phys . * 82 * , 557 ( 2010 ) doi:10.1103/revmodphys.82.557 [ arxiv:0807.3125 [ hep - ph ] ] . k. j. bae , h. baer and e. j. chun , jcap * 1312 * , 028 ( 2013 ) doi:10.1088/1475 - 7516/2013/12/028 [ arxiv:1309.5365 [ hep - ph ] ] . k. j. bae , h. baer , a. lessa and h. serce , jcap * 1410 * , no .
10 , 082 ( 2014 ) doi:10.1088/1475 - 7516/2014/10/082 [ arxiv:1406.4138 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. kawasaki and k. nakayama , ann .
nucl . part .
sci . * 63 * , 69 ( 2013 ) doi:10.1146/annurev - nucl-102212 - 170536 [ arxiv:1301.1123 [ hep - ph ] ] .
s. kasuya , m. kawasaki and t. yanagida , phys .
b * 409 * , 94 ( 1997 ) doi:10.1016/s0370 - 2693(97)00809 - 5 [ hep - ph/9608405 ] .
a. d. linde and d. h. lyth , phys .
b * 246 * , 353 ( 1990 ) .
doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(90)90613-b a. d. linde , phys . lett .
b * 259 * , 38 ( 1991 ) .
doi:10.1016/0370 - 2693(91)90130-i m. kawasaki , n. sugiyama and t. yanagida , phys .
d * 54 * , 2442 ( 1996 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.54.2442 [ hep - ph/9512368 ] . m. kawasaki and k. nakayama , phys .
d * 77 * , 123524 ( 2008 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.77.123524 [ arxiv:0802.2487 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. choi , e. j. chun , s. h. i m and k. s. jeong , phys .
b * 750 * , 26 ( 2015 ) doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2015.08.041 [ arxiv:1505.00306 [ hep - ph ] ] . k. nakayama and m. takimoto , phys .
b * 748 * , 108 ( 2015 ) doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2015.07.001 [ arxiv:1505.02119 [ hep - ph ] ] .
l. f. abbott and p. sikivie , phys .
lett . * 120b * ( 1983 ) 133 ; j. preskill , m. b. wise and f. wilczek , phys .
* 120b * ( 1983 ) 127 ; m. dine and w. fischler , phys .
lett . * 120b * ( 1983 ) 137 ; m. s. turner , phys . rev .
d * 33 * ( 1986 ) 889 ; k. j. bae , j. h. huh and j. e. kim , jcap * 0809 * ( 2008 ) 005 ; l. visinelli and p. gondolo , phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 035024 .
p. a. r. ade _ et al .
_ [ planck collaboration ] , doi:10.1051/0004 - 6361/201525898 arxiv:1502.02114 [ astro-ph.co ] .
e. j. chun , phys .
d * 84 * , 043509 ( 2011 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.84.043509 [ arxiv:1104.2219 [ hep - ph ] ]
. k. j. bae , k. choi and s. h. i m , jhep * 1108 * , 065 ( 2011 ) doi:10.1007/jhep08(2011)065 [ arxiv:1106.2452 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. j. bae , e. j. chun and s. h. i m , jcap * 1203 * , 013 ( 2012 ) doi:10.1088/1475 - 7516/2012/03/013 [ arxiv:1111.5962 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. y. choi , j. e. kim , h. m. lee and o. seto , phys .
d * 77 * , 123501 ( 2008 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.77.123501 [ arxiv:0801.0491 [ hep - ph ] ] .
f. t. avignone , iii , s. r. elliott and j. engel , rev .
* 80 * , 481 ( 2008 ) doi:10.1103/revmodphys.80.481 [ arxiv:0708.1033 [ nucl - ex ] ] .
t. yanagida , conf .
c * 7902131 * , 95 ( 1979 ) ; m. gell - mann , p. ramond and r. slansky , conf .
c * 790927 * , 315 ( 1979 ) [ arxiv:1306.4669 [ hep - th ] ] ; p. minkowski , phys .
b * 67 * , 421 ( 1977 ) .
z. maki , m. nakagawa and s. sakata , prog .
theor . phys .
* 28 * , 870 ( 1962 ) .
f. capozzi , g. l. fogli , e. lisi , a. marrone , d. montanino and a. palazzo , phys .
d * 89 * , 093018 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1312.2878 [ hep - ph ] ] . | the affleck - dine leptogenesis scenario along the @xmath0 flat direction is reconsidered .
it is known that successful affleck - dine leptogenesis requires that the lightest neutrino mass is extremely small .
this situation can be significantly relaxed if the neutrino mass in the early universe is different from the present one .
we consider a supersymmetric dine - fischler - srednicki - zhitnitsky ( dfsz ) type model , which provides a solution to the strong @xmath1 problem and generates a susy @xmath2-term and right - handed neutrino masses .
if the pq scale during lepton number generation is much larger than the present value , leptogenesis is very efficient so that enough baryon number can be generated without introducing a hierarchically small neutrino mass .
the final baryon asymmetry is related to the @xmath2-term , and hence linked to the level of electroweak fine tuning .
we also show the pq breaking scalar dynamics that keeps a large pq breaking scale during inflation and lepton number generation .
the @xmath2-term generating superpotential plays an important role for preserving the lepton asymmetry during saxion oscillation . in this scenario ,
the axion isocurvature perturbation is naturally suppressed .
ctpu-16 - 44 ut-16 - 37 ipmu-16 - 0190 |
strongly correlated electron systems exhibit the highest attained superconducting transition temperatures currently known , and a rich variety of complex electronic phases@xcite .
many compounds among this family of mott insulators , such as the cuprates , are quasi - two - dimensional layered materials .
this renders them ideal candidates for bilayer exciton condensation , which is the topic of this publication .
the effort to achieve the condensation of excitons has a long history starting just after the discovery of bcs theory@xcite .
an exciton is the bound state of an electron and a hole and as such it can bose condense . the obvious advantage of considering excitons above cooper pairs is the strong coulomb attraction between the electron and the hole ; allowing in principle for a much higher critical temperature . to reduce the exciton lifetime problems caused by electron - hole recombination
, it has been suggested to spatially separate the electrons and holes in their own subsequent layers@xcite .
this indeed has resulted in the experimental realization of exciton condensates , first in the so - called quantum hall bilayers@xcite and more recently without an externally applied magnetic field in electrically gated , optically pumped semiconductor quantum wells@xcite .
the successes of exciton condensation in semiconductor 2deg bilayer systems have led to many proposals for exciton condensation in alternative bilayer materials , such as gated topological insulators@xcite or double layer graphene@xcite .
however , these proposals are limited to the bcs paradigm of weak coupling . on the other hand ,
mott insulators provide a completely different route to exciton condensation@xcite .
naively one would expect that the localization of the electrons and holes leads to a higher critical temperature , since @xmath2 is determined by the competition between the electronic kinetic energy and the electron - hole attraction .
but the physics of exciton condensation in mott insulators is in fact much richer . instead of the picture that the electron - hole pair lives in a conduction and valence band ,
an exciton now consists of a double occupied and vacant site bound together on an interlayer rung , see figure [ lattice ] . to estimate the binding energy , consider the in - plane charge - transfer excitons which are known to have a binding energy of the order of 1 - 2 ev@xcite .
due to the small interlayer distances of order 1 nm we expect that a similar energy scale will set the binding of the interlayer exciton . as such , excitons in a mott bilayer are most likely in the strongly coupled regime .
side view of a strongly correlated electron bilayer with an exciton present .
the red arrows denote the spin of the localized electrons , and the exciton is a bound state of a double occupied and an empty site . ]
furthermore , a single doublon - holon pair inserted into a mott insulator leads to dynamical frustration effects@xcite , even stronger than seen for a single hole in the @xmath0 model@xcite .
the study of excitons in strongly correlated materials thus catches the complexity of doped mott insulators . as we discussed elsewhere
@xcite the bosonic nature of the excitons actually falls short to completely eliminate all `` fermion - like '' signs : there are still left - over signs of the phase - string type@xcite .
however , it is easy to demonstrate that collinear spin order is a sufficient condition for these signs to cancel out , leaving a truly bosonic dynamics controlling the ground state and long wavelength physics .
the problem thereby reduces to that of hard - core bosons ( the excitons ) in a sign - free spin background .
this is very similar to the `` spin - orbital '' physics described by kugel - khomskii type models@xcite , which can be viewed after all as describing d - d excitons interacting with spins .
also the lattice implementations@xcite of the so(5 ) model@xcite for ( cuprate ) superconductivity are in this family .
such bosonic problems can be handled with standard ( semi - classical ) mean field theory , and therefore the regime of finite exciton density can be addressed in an a - priori controlled manner . in most bilayer exciton set - ups , such as the quantum hall bilayers or the pumped systems , there is no controllable equilibrium exciton density . in these cases
one can hardly speak of the exciton density as a conserved quantity , and exciton condensation in the sense of spontaneously broken @xmath3 symmetry is impossible@xcite .
however , in mott insulators the dopant density per layer could be fixed by , for example , chemical doping .
the effective exciton chemical potential is then by definition large compared to the recombination rate .
effectively , the excitons are at finite density in equilibrium and hence spontaneous @xmath3 symmetry breaking is possible in the mott insulating bilayer . besides the exciton superfluid phase one anticipates a plethora of competing orders , as is customary in strongly correlated materials . at zero exciton density
the bilayer heisenberg system exhibits already interesting magnetism , in the form of the antiferromagnet for small rung coupling turning via an @xmath4-qnls quantum phase transition into an `` incompressible quantum spin liquid '' for larger rung couplings that can be viewed as a continuation of pair singlets ( `` valence bonds '' ) stacked on the rungs @xcite .
the natural competitor of the exciton superfluid at finite density is the exciton crystal and one anticipates that due to the strong lattice potential this will tend to lock in at commensurate densities forming exciton `` mott insulators '' .
we will wire this in by taking also the exciton - exciton dipolar interaction into account that surely promotes such orderings . in principle
there is the interesting possibility that all these orders may coexist microscopically forming an `` antiferromagnetic supersolid '' @xcite . in this bosonic
setting we can address it in a quite controlled manner , but we find that at least for the strongly coupled `` small '' excitons assumed here this does not happen .
the reason is interesting .
we already alluded to the dynamical `` frustration '' associated with the exciton delocalizing in the anti - ferromagnetic spin background , which is qualitatively of the same kind as for the standard `` electron '' t - j model . at finite densities
this turns into a tendency to just phase separate on a macroscopic scale , involving antiferromagnets , exciton crystalline states and high density diamagnetic exciton superfluids , respectively .
even though the exciton dipolar repulsion is long - ranged , there is no possibility of frustrated phase separation as suggested for the electronic order in cuprates@xcite because the @xmath5 interaction falls off too quickly .
however , if one correctly incorporates the full exciton dipolar interaction , a variety of different exciton ordered phase may arise@xcite . here
we restrict ourselves to nearest neighbor repulsion only , which allows for the formation of a checkerboard ordered exciton crystalline state .
it is disappointing that apparently in this system only conventional ground states occur .
however , this is actually to a degree deceptive .
the hamiltonian describing the physics at the lattice scale describes a physics where the exciton- and spin motions are `` entangled '' : the way in which these subsystems communicate gets beyond the notion of just being strongly coupled , since the motions of the exciton motions and the spin dynamics can not be separated . by coarse graining
this all the way to the static order parameters ( the mean fields ) an effective decoupling eventually results as demonstrated by the pure ground states .
however , upon going `` off - shell '' this spin - exciton entanglement becomes directly manifest in the form of unexpected and rather counterintuitive effects on the excitation spectrum .
a simple example is the zero exciton density antiferromagnet . from the rather controlled linear spin wave self - consistent born approximation ( lsw - scba ) treatment of the one exciton problem
@xcite we already know that the resulting exciton spectrum can be completely different from that in a simple semiconductor .
we compute here the linearized excitations around the pure antiferromagnet , recovering the lsw - scba result in the `` adiabatic limit '' where the exciton hopping is small compared to the exchange energy of the spin system , which leads to a strong enhancement of the exciton mass . in the opposite limit of fast excitons , the energy scale is recovered but the `` ising - confinement '' ladder spectrum revealed by the lsw - scba treatment is absent .
the reason is clear : in the language of this paper , the couplings between the exciton- and spin - wave modes become very big and these need to be re - summed in order to arrive at an accurate description of the exciton propagator , while our mean - field treatment corresponds with a complete neglect of these exciton - spin interactions .
the real novelty in this regard is revealed in the high density exciton superfluid phase .
the spin system forms here a ground state that is a product state of pair - singlets living on the rungs . besides the superfluid phase modes one expects in addition also the usual massive spin - triplet excitations associated with the ( incompressible ) singlet vacuum .
the surprise is that these are characterized by a dispersion which is in part determined by the _ superfluid density of the exciton condensate _ , as we already announced elsewhere@xcite for which we present here the details .
counterintuitively , by measuring the spin fluctuations one can in principle determine whether the excitons are condensed in a superfluid .
let us complete this introduction by specifying the point of departure : the hamiltonian describing strongly bound excitons propagating through a bilayer heisenberg spin 1/2 system .
this model is derived and discussed at length in our earlier papers @xcite and here we just summarize the outcome . due to the strong electron - electron interactions the electronic degrees of freedom
are , at electronic half - filling , reduced to spin operators @xmath6 governed by the bilayer heisenberg model@xcite @xmath7 the subscript denotes spin operators on site @xmath8 in layer @xmath9 .
the heisenberg @xmath10 is antiferromagnetic with @xmath11 and @xmath12 .
the interlayer exciton can hop around , thereby interchanging places with the spin background . in the strong - coupling limit of exciton
binding energies the exciton hopping process is described by the hamiltonian @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the exciton state on an interlayer rung , and @xmath15 represent the rung spin states .
whenever an exciton hops , it effectively exchanges the spin configuration on its neighboring site .
this exciton @xmath0 model was derived earlier in refs .
@xcite , where the optical absorption was computed in the limit of vanishing exciton density @xmath16 . in order to study the system with a finite density of excitons , we need to enrich the current @xmath0 model with two extra terms : a chemical potential and an exciton - exciton interaction . the chemical potential is straightforwardly @xmath17 the exciton - exciton interaction requires more thought .
the bare interaction between two interlayer excitons results from their electric dipole moment . since
all interlayer exciton dipole moments are pointing in the same direction the full exciton - exciton interaction is described by a repulsive @xmath5 interaction .
hence the interaction strength decays sufficiently fast to avoid the coulomb catastrophe responsible for frustrated phase separation@xcite .
we consider it reasonable to only include the nearest - neighbor repulsion , @xmath18 here @xmath19 is the energy scale associated with nearest neighbor exciton repulsion .
this number can get quite high : given a typical interlayer distance@xcite of @xmath20 and an intersite distance of @xmath21 the bare dipole interaction energy is 14 ev . in reality
, we expect this energy to be lower due to quantum corrections and screening effects .
however , the exciton - exciton interaction scale remains on the order of electronvolts and thus larger than the estimated heisenberg @xmath22 and hopping @xmath23 .
let us finally consider the effects of interlayer hopping of electrons , which leads to the annihilation of excitons , @xmath24 this term explicitly breaks the @xmath3 symmetry associated with the conservation of excitons . while this term is almost certainly present in any realistic system
, it is a matter of numbers whether it is relevant . in the present case of cuprates , where each layer can be doped by means of chemical substitution
, we expect the chemical potential @xmath25 to be significantly larger than the interlayer tunneling @xmath26 .
consequently , the interlayer hopping is barely relevant . throughout this publication
we will discuss the effects that the inclusion of a small @xmath26 will have .
the full model hamiltonian describing a finite density of excitons in a strongly correlated bilayer is thus @xmath27 let us now summarize the layout of our paper .
most of the physics of hard - core excitons on a lattice can be captured using an effective @xmath1 model , which is studied in section [ secxxz ] .
the ground state phase diagram of the full exciton @xmath0 model is derived in section [ secmft ] , using both numerical simulations and analytical mean field theory .
the excitations and the corresponding susceptibilities are discussed in section [ seceex ] .
we conclude this paper with a discussion on possible further lines of theoretical and experimental research in section [ secconc ] .
the hamiltonian , equation ( [ fullh ] ) , has five model parameters : @xmath22 , @xmath28 , @xmath23 , @xmath19 and @xmath25 .
however , most properties of the excitons can be understood by considering the problem of hard - core bosons on a lattice . in this section
we will argue that the exciton degrees of freedom can be described by an effective @xmath1 model .
based on some reflections on the mathematical symmetries of the full exciton @xmath0 model , we will describe the properties of this effective @xmath1 model in subsection [ subsecxxz1 ] .
we will conclude this section with an outline of the method used to obtain the excitation spectrum of the model . before characterizing different phases of the model we need to assess the algebraic structure of the exciton @xmath0 model .
the set of all operators that act on the local hilbert space form the _ dynamical algebra _ , whereas the symmetries of the system are grouped together in the _ symmetry algebra_. to derive the dynamical algebra , it is instructive to start with the bilayer heisenberg model which has , on each interlayer rung , a @xmath29 dynamical algebra@xcite .
upon inclusion of the exciton hopping term we need more operators , since now the local hilbert space on an interlayer rung is five - dimensional ( four spin states and the exciton ) . consider the spin - to - exciton operator @xmath30 and its conjugate @xmath31 .
their commutator reads @xmath32 = |e \rangle \langle e | - | s\ ; m \rangle \langle s \ ; m
| \equiv 2 e^z_{sm}\ ] ] where we have introduced the operator @xmath33 to complete a @xmath34 algebraic structure .
we could set up such a construction for each of the four spin states @xmath15 . under these definitions
the exciton hopping term , equation ( [ excitonhop ] ) , can be rewritten in terms of an @xmath35-model for each spin state , @xmath36 where the sum over @xmath37 runs over the singlet and the three triplets .
note that the exciton chemical potential , equation ( [ hmu ] ) , acts as an externally applied magnetic field to this @xmath35-model , and that the exciton - exciton repulsion , equation ( [ hv ] ) , can be rewritten as an antiferromagnetic ising term in the @xmath33 operators .
the dynamical algebra therefore contains four @xmath34 algebras in addition to the @xmath38 from the bilayer heisenberg part .
the closure of such an algebra is necessarily @xmath39 , which is the largest algebra possible acting on the five - dimensional hilbert space .
hence we need a full @xmath39 dynamical algebra to describe the exciton @xmath0 model at finite density .
the operators that compose this algebra are enumerated in appendix [ appendixa ] . from the @xmath35-representation of the hopping term
one can already deduce that we have four distinct @xmath3 symmetries associated with spin - exciton exchange .
the bilayer heisenberg model contains two separate @xmath34 symmetries , associated with in - phase and out - phase interlayer magnetic order .
therefore the full symmetry algebra of the model is @xmath40 ^ 2 \times [ u(1)]^4 $ ] .
breaking of the @xmath34 symmetry amounts to magnetic ordering , which is most likely antiferromagnetic ( and therefore also amounts to a breaking of the lattice symmetry ) .
each of the @xmath3 algebras can be broken leading to exciton condensation .
note that next to possible broken continuous symmetries , there also might exist phases with broken translation symmetry .
the checkerboard phase , already anticipated in the introduction , is an example of a phase where the lattice symmetry is broken into two sublattices . when discussing the dynamical algebra of the exciton @xmath0 model we found that the exciton hopping terms are similar to an @xmath35-model .
the main reason is that the excitons are , in fact , hard - core bosons and thus allow for a mapping onto pseudospin degrees of freedom . viewed as such , the exciton - exciton interaction equation ( [ hv ] ) is similar to an antiferromagnetic ising term and the exciton chemical potential equation ( [ hmu ] ) amounts to an external magnetic field in the @xmath41-direction .
together they form an @xmath1-model in the presence of an external field , which has been investigated in quite some detail elsewhere@xcite as well as in the context of exciton dynamics in cold atom gases@xcite . in order to understand the basic competition between the checkerboard phase and the superfluid phase of the excitons , it is worthwhile to neglect the magnetic degrees of freedom and study first this effective @xmath1-model for the excitons only .
the transition between the checkerboard and superfluid phases is known as the ` spin flop'-transition@xcite . keeping the identification of the exciton degrees of freedom as @xmath1 pseudospin degrees of freedom in mind ,
let us review the basics of the @xmath1 hamiltonian @xmath42 where @xmath43 creates a hard - core bosonic particle @xmath44 out of the vacuum @xmath45 .
this model has a built - in competition between @xmath46 , which favors a superfluid state , and @xmath47 , which favors a crystalline state where all particles are on one sublattice and the other sublattice is empty .
the external field or chemical potential @xmath25 tunes the total particle density .
the ground state can now be found using mean field theory .
it is known that for pseudospin @xmath48 models in @xmath49d the quantum fluctuations are not strong enough to defeat classical order and therefore we can rely on mean field theory , as supported by exact diagonalization studies@xcite . to find
the ground state we introduce a variational wavefunction describing a condensate of excitons , @xmath50 the mean - field approximation amounts to choosing @xmath51 constant and @xmath52 only differing between the two sublattices .
we find the following mean - field energy @xmath53 let s rewrite this in terms of @xmath54 and @xmath55 , @xmath56 when @xmath57 the ground state is fully polarized in the @xmath41-direction .
this means either zero particle density for negative @xmath25 , or a @xmath58 for the positive @xmath25 case .
starting from the empty side , increasing @xmath25 introduces a smooth distribution of particles .
this phase amounts to the superfluid phase of the excitons .
the particle density on the two sublattices is equal and the total density is given by @xmath59 at the critical value of the chemical potential @xmath60 a first order transition occurs towards the checkerboard phase : the spin flop transition . in the resulting phase , which goes under various names such as the antiferromagnetic model . to avoid confusion , from now on we will use the term antiferromagnetism only when referring to the spin degrees of freedom in the full exciton @xmath0 model . ] , solid , checkerboard or wigner crystalline phase
, the sublattice symmetry is broken .
the resulting ground state phase diagram is shown in figure [ figxxz]a , where we also show the dependence of the particle density on @xmath25 .
* a. * the ground state phase diagram of the @xmath1 model , equation ( [ xxzmodel ] ) .
the graph shows the mean field particle density @xmath61 as a function of @xmath25 , with model parameters @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
one clearly distinguishes the fully polarized phases for large @xmath25 , the superfluid phase with a linear @xmath61 vs @xmath25 dependence and the crystalline checkerboard phase with @xmath64 . in between the checkerboard and the superfluid phase a non -
trivial first order transition exists , with a variety of coexistence ground states with the same ground state energy .
the insets show how the @xmath65-vectors look like in the different phases . *
b. * finite temperature phase diagram of the @xmath1 model with the same parameters .
the background coloring corresponds to a semiclassical monte carlo computation of @xmath61 , the solid lines are analytical mean field results for the phase boundaries .
we indeed see the checkerboard phase and the superfluid phase , as well as a high - temperature non - ordered ` normal ' phase . ] at finite temperatures in @xmath49d there can be algebraic long - range order . at some critical temperature
a kosterlitz - thouless phase transition@xcite will destroy this long - range order .
the topology of the phase diagram however can be obtained using the finite temperature mean field theory for which we need to minimize the mean field thermodynamic potential@xcite @xmath66 \nonumber \\ & & - \frac{\mu}{2 } \tanh \left ( \frac{\beta m}{2 } \right ) \cos \delta \theta \cos \overline{\theta}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] expectation values are @xmath67 and the parameter @xmath68 needs to be determined self - consistently .
the resulting phase diagram is shown in figure [ figxxz]b , which is of the form discussed by fisher and nelson@xcite .
the first order quantum phase transition at @xmath69 turns out to be non - trivial , a point which is usually overlooked in the literature .
a trivial first order transition occurs when there are two distinct phases with exactly the same energy . in the case
presented here , there is a infinite set of mean field order parameters all yielding different phases yet still having the same energy .
a simple analytic calculation shows that the energy of the ground state at the critical point is @xmath70 .
now rewrite the mean field parameters @xmath71 and @xmath72 into a sum and difference parameter @xmath73 for each value of @xmath74 with @xmath75 we can find a value of @xmath76 such that the mean field energy is exactly @xmath77 .
this has interesting consequences .
if one can control the density instead of the chemical potential around a first order transition , in general phase separation would occur between the two competing phases . from the mean field considerations above it
is unclear what would happen in a system described by the @xmath1 hamiltonian , equation ( [ xxzmodel ] ) .
all phases would be equally stable , at least on the mean field level , and every phase may occur in regions of any size .
such a highly degenerate state may be very sensible to small perturbations .
we consider it an interesting open problem to study the dynamics of such a highly degenerate system , and whether this degeneracy may survive the inclusion of quantum corrections . in the introduction we mentioned the existence of interlayer hopping , equation ( [ interlayerhopping ] ) .
qualitatively the @xmath26 is irrelevant , which can be seen in the @xmath1 pseudospin language where it takes the form of a tilt of the magnetic field in the @xmath78-direction , @xmath79 as a result the phase diagram is shifted but not qualitatively changed .
the effect of the @xmath26 on the excitation spectrum is briefly discussed in section [ sfphasesection ] . of direct experimental relevance
are the elementary excitations of a phase .
the dispersion of these excitations can be computed using the ` equations of motion'-method based on the work of zubarev@xcite .
we present the formalities of this method in appendix [ appendixc ] . in this subsection
we briefly show the essence of this technique , applied to the @xmath1 model .
later , in section [ seceex ] , we will compute the excitations for the full exciton @xmath0 model .
the key ingredients of this zubarev - approach are the heisenberg equations of motion , @xmath80 where @xmath81 runs over all nearest neighbors .
these equations can not be solved exactly , and one relies on the approximation controlled by the mean field vacua .
that is , we neglect fluctuations of the order parameters , so that products of operators on different sites are replaced by@xcite @xmath82 where @xmath83 denotes the mean field expectation value . by such a decoupling
the heisenberg equations of motion become a coupled set of linear equations which can be solved easily . in the homogeneous phase
we thus obtain , after fourier transforming , @xmath84 we find an analytical expression for the excitations in the superfluid phase , @xmath85 where @xmath86 . for small momenta
this excitation has a linear dispersion , conform to the goldstone theorem requiring a massless excitation as a result of the spontaneously broken @xmath3 symmetry .
exactly at @xmath87 the dispersion reduces to @xmath88 , hence the gap at @xmath89 closes thus signaling a transition towards the checkerboard phase . at the critical point and in the checkerboard phase , we need to take into account the fact that expectation values of operators differ on the two sublattices .
the heisenberg equations of motion now reduce to six ( instead of three ) linear equations , which can be straightforwardly solved .
for now we postpone the discussion on the dispersion of elementary excitations to section [ seceex ] , where the full exciton @xmath0 model will be considered using the technique discussed here .
in the previous section we have seen that the effective @xmath1 model predicts the existence of both an exciton superfluid phase and a checkerboard phase , separated by a first order transition .
now we derive the ground state phase diagram for the full exciton @xmath0 model given by equation ( [ fullh ] ) .
we will proceed along the same lines as in the previous section , starting with a variational wavefunction .
numerical simulation of this wavefunction creates an unbiased view on the possible inhomogeneous and homogeneous ground state phases .
this serves as a basis to further analyze the phase diagram with analytical methods .
the analytical mean field theory also allows us to characterize the three homogeneous phases : the antiferromagnet , the superfluid and the checkerboard crystal . finally , combining the numerical and analytical mean field results we obtain the ground state phase diagram , see figure [ finalphasediagramfig ] .
recall that the local hilbert space consists of four spin states @xmath15 and the exciton state @xmath14 .
we therefore propose a variational wavefunction consisting of a product state of a superposition of all five states on each rung .
for the spin states we take the @xmath38 coherent state@xcite @xmath90 which needs to be superposed with the exciton state , @xmath91 to obtain the total variational ( product state ) wavefunction @xmath92 this full wavefunction acts as ansatz for the numerical simulations . note that the homogeneous phases can be described by this wavefunction with the parameters @xmath93 and @xmath76 only depending on the sublattice .
given this wavefunction , the expectation value of a product of operators on different sites decouples , @xmath94 .
the only nonzero expectation values of spin operators are for @xmath95 and it equals @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the unit vector described by the angles @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
this variational wavefunction therefore assumes interlayer nel order of magnitude @xmath100 , which enables us to correctly interpolate between the perfect nel order at @xmath101 and the singlet phase @xmath102 present in the bilayer heisenberg model .
the exciton density at a rung @xmath8 is trivially given by @xmath103 .
given the variational wavefunction , we can use simulated annealing to develop an unbiased view on the possible mean field ground state phases .
therefore we start out with a lattice with on each lattice site the variables @xmath52 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath51 and @xmath103 and with periodic boundary conditions .
the energy of a configuration is @xmath106 we performed standard metropolis monte carlo updates of the lattice with fixed total exciton density .
the fixed total exciton density is imposed as follows : if during an update the exciton density @xmath103 is changed , the exciton density on one of the neighboring sites is corrected such that the total exciton density remains constant .
the main results of the simulation are shown in figure [ mcresults ] , for various values of the hopping parameter @xmath23 and exciton density @xmath76 .
we performed the computations on a @xmath107 lattice .
notice that even though true long - range order does not exist in two dimensions , the correlation length of possible ordered phases is larger than the size of our simulated lattice .
the other parameters are fixed at @xmath108 mev , @xmath109 and @xmath110 ev . the heisenberg couplings @xmath108 mev and @xmath109 are obtained from measurements of undoped ybco - samples@xcite , which we consider to be qualitatively indicative of all strongly correlated electron bilayers .
the dipolar coupling is estimated at 2 ev , following our discussion in the introduction .
for each value of @xmath76 and @xmath23 we started at a high temperature @xmath111 ev , to slowly reduce the temperature to @xmath112 ev while performing a full update of the whole lattice 10 million times .
we expect that by such a slow annealing process we obtain the true ground state of equation ( [ scenergy ] ) , devoid of topological defects .
once we arrive at the low temperature state , we performed measurements employing 200.000 full updates of the system .
results from the semi - classical monte carlo simulations . here shown are color plots , with on the horizontal axes the exciton density @xmath76 and on the vertical axes the hopping parameter @xmath23 ( in ev ) .
other parameters are fixed at @xmath108 mev , @xmath109 and @xmath110 ev .
the five measurements shown here are the nel order parameter , equation ( [ firstmcformula ] ) , the checkerboard order parameter , equation ( [ cbmcformula ] ) , the superfluid density , equation ( [ sfdensityformula ] ) , the phase coherence , equation ( [ phasemcf ] ) , and the ratio signaling phase separation according to equation ( [ lastmcformula ] ) , 0 means complete phase separation , 1 means no phase separation .
notice that the prominent line at @xmath113 signals the checkerboard phase . ]
we measured six different order parameter averages : * the nel order parameter defined by @xmath114 where we first sum over all spin vectors and then take the norm . * the checkerboard order , defined as the difference in exciton density between the sublattices divided by the maximal difference possible .
the maximal difference possible equals @xmath115 , so @xmath116 * the superfluid density is given by the expectation value of the exciton operator .
here we do not make a distinction between singlet exciton condensation or triplet exciton condensation .
therefore @xmath117 * now the superfluid density is not the only measure of the condensate , we can also probe the rigidity of the phase @xmath118
. therefore we sum up all the phase factors on all sites , @xmath119 if the phase is disordered , this sum tends to zero .
on the other hand , complete phase coherence in the condensate phase implies that this quantity equals unity .
* finally , we considered a measure of phase separation between the checkerboard phase and the superfluid phase .
if the exciton condensate and the checkerboard phase are truly coexisting , then the maximal superfluid density attainable would be @xmath120 where @xmath121 . if there is phase separation however , the actual superfluid density is less than this maximal density
. therefore we also measured the ratio @xmath122 to quantify the extent of phase separation .
when this ratio is less than @xmath123 this indicates phase separation .
typical configurations for the exciton density per site , obtained in the monte carlo simulation on a @xmath124 square lattice .
the color scale indicates the exciton density .
all five figures have model parameters @xmath108 mev , @xmath109 and @xmath110 ev .
* a : * separation between the antiferromagnetic phase ( without excitons , hence shown black ) and the exciton condensate with smooth exciton density ( @xmath125 , @xmath126 ev ) . * b : * separation between checkerboard - like localized excitons and an antiferromagnetic background ( @xmath127 , @xmath128 ev ) .
* c : * separation between the checkerboard phase and a low density exciton condensate ( @xmath129 , @xmath126 ev ) .
* d : * separation between the checkerboard phase and a high density exciton condensate ( @xmath130 , @xmath131 ev ) .
* e : * the region where antiferromagnetic order , checkerboard order and the exciton condensate are all present ( @xmath132 , @xmath133 ) . ]
the results for a full scan for the range @xmath134 and @xmath135 ev are shown in figure [ mcresults ] . in figures
[ mcdensityplots ] and [ phasesepfig ] we have displayed typical exciton density configurations for various points in the phase diagram . in combination
these results suggest that there are three homogeneous phases present in the system : the antiferromagnet at low exciton densities , the exciton superfluid at high exciton hopping energies and the checkerboard crystal at half - filling of excitons .
however , for most parts of the phase diagram the competition between the three phases appears to result in phase separation .
let us investigate the phase separation in somewhat more detail . in our earlier work we found that the motion of an exciton in an antiferromagnetic background leads to dynamical frustration@xcite . in other words : excitons do not want to coexist with antiferromagnetism .
the introduction of a finite density of excitons will therefore induce phase separation . for large @xmath23
, we find macroscopic phase separation between the antiferromagnet and the exciton superfluid , see figure [ mcdensityplots]a . at low exciton kinetic energy
the excitons will crystallize in a checkerboard pattern as can be seen in figure [ mcdensityplots]b .
close to half - filling the role of the dipole repulsion @xmath19 becomes increasingly relevant .
the first order ` spin flop ' transition we discussed in section [ subsecxxz1 ] implies that there will be phase separation between the superfluid and the checkerboard order .
figures [ mcdensityplots]c and d show this phase separation . finally there is a regime where the condensate , the checkerboard order and the nel order are all present .
however , given the dynamical frustration on the one hand and the spin - flop transition on the other hand , we again predict phase separation .
a typical exciton configuration in this parameter regime is shown in figure [ mcdensityplots]e . different exciton configurations with their respective energies on a @xmath136 lattice , to show whether there is macroscopic phase separation .
the model parameters are @xmath137 ev , @xmath108 mev , @xmath109 , @xmath110 ev and @xmath138 .
yellow indicates the presence of excitons , and in the black regions there is antiferromagnetic order .
* a : * the lowest energy state is the one with complete macroscopic phase separation .
* b : * more complicated phase separation , such as the halter form depicted here , are higher in energy .
* c : * starting at high temperatures with the configuration a , we slowly lowered the temperature .
the resulting configuration shown here is a local minimum . *
d : * using the same slow annealing as for c starting from configuration b. the local energy minimum obtained this way is lower in energy than the configuration c. we conclude that even though macroscopic phase separation has the lowest energy , there are many local energy minima without macroscopic phase separation . ] these simulated annealing results suggest that phase separation dominates the physics of this exciton system . to check whether the numerics are reliable we inspected directly the energies of the various homogeneous mean field solutions , using the maxwell construction for phase separated states .
the constructed phase separated configurations and their energies are shown in figure [ phasesepfig ] .
the lowest energy configuration ( [ phasesepfig]a ) has macroscopic phase separation between the checkerboard and the antiferromagnetic phase .
intermediate states with one blob of excitons ( [ phasesepfig]c ) are slightly higher in energy than states with two blobs of excitons ( [ phasesepfig]d ) .
however , even though macroscopic phase separation has the lowest energy , configurations with more blobs have more entropy .
consequently for any nonzero temperatures complete macroscopic phase separation is not the most favorable solution .
this is indeed seen in the numerical simulations : annealing leads to high - entropy states such as figure [ phasesepfig]d rather than to the lowest energy configuration .
we thus conclude that the dominant phases are the antiferromagnet , the superfluid and the checkerboard . the competition between these three phases leads to phase separation in most parts of the phase diagram .
the unbiased monte carlo simulations show the direction in which further analytical research should be directed : we will use mean field theory to characterize the three homogeneous phases .
given the fact that we are dealing with a hard - core boson problem , we know that mean field theory is qualitatively correct .
a remaining issue is whether one can tune the exciton chemical potential rather than the exciton density in realistic experiments .
since we are prescient about the many first - order phase transitions in this system , we will perform the analysis with a fixed exciton density ( the canonical ensemble ) . using the maxwell construction and the explicit @xmath25 vs. @xmath76 relations
, we can transform back to the grand - canonical ensemble .
the numerical simulations suggest that the only solutions breaking translational symmetry invoke two sublattices , @xmath139 and so forth for @xmath140 , @xmath98 , @xmath118 and @xmath99 .
this broken translational symmetry allows for the antiferromagnetic and exciton checkerboard order .
evaluation of the energy @xmath141 of the variational wavefunction , equation ( [ variationalwavefunction ] ) , directly suggests that we can set @xmath142 on all sites .
we restrict the spin vectors to be pointing in the @xmath143 direction only . since we anticipate magnetic ordering we have the freedom to choose the direction of the ordering .
similar arguments hold for the choice @xmath144 ; when breaking the @xmath3 symmetry associated with exciton condensation we are free to choose the phase direction .
] we are left with four parameters @xmath145 and @xmath146 , and as it turns out it will be more instructive to rewrite these in terms of sum and difference variables , @xmath147 the mean field energy per site is now given by @xmath148 \nonumber \\ & & - \frac{1}{4 } zt \sqrt{((1 - \overline{\rho})^2 - \delta_\rho^2)(\overline{\rho}^2 - \delta_\rho^2 ) } \cos \delta_\chi \nonumber \\ & & - \mu \overline{\rho } + \frac{1}{2 } z v ( \overline{\rho}^2 - \delta_\rho^2 ) \label{meanfielde}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which has to be minimized for a fixed average exciton density @xmath149 with the constraint @xmath150 .
the resulting mean field phase diagram for typical values of @xmath151 and @xmath19 , and for various @xmath152 , is shown in figure [ canonicaldiagram ] . the canonical mean - field phase diagram for typical values of @xmath108 mev , @xmath109 and @xmath110 ev whilst varying @xmath23 and the exciton density @xmath76 . in the absence of exciton , at @xmath153 , we have the pure antiferromagnetic nel phase ( af ) .
exactly at half - filling of excitons ( @xmath154 ) and small hoping energy @xmath155 we find the checkerboard phase ( cb ) where one sublattice is filled with excitons and the other sublattice is filled with singlets . for large values of @xmath23
we find the singlet exciton condensate ( ec ) , given by the wavefunction @xmath156 .
the coexistence of antiferromagnetism and superfluidity for small @xmath76 and @xmath23 is an artifact of the mean field theory .
conform the monte carlo results of figure [ mcresults ] , for most parts of the phase diagram phase separation ( ps ) is found . ]
as long as the exciton density is set to zero , the mean field ground state is given by the ground state of the bilayer heisenberg model , @xmath157 the nel order is given by @xmath158 and the energy of the antiferromagnetic state is @xmath159 the introduction of excitons in an antiferromagnetic background leads to dynamical frustration effects which disfavors the coexistence of excitons and antiferromagnetic order@xcite .
in fact , the numerical simulations already ruled out coexistence of superfluidity and antiferromagnetism . for large exciton hopping energy @xmath23
it becomes more favorable to mix delocalized excitons into the ground state . due to the bosonic nature of the problem this automatically leads to exciton condensation .
the delocalized excitons completely destroy the antiferromagnetic order and the exciton condensate is described by a superposition of excitons and a singlet background , @xmath160 here we wish to emphasize the ubiquitous coupling to light of the superfluid .
the dipole matrix element allows only spin zero transitions , and since the exciton itself is @xmath161 the dipole matrix element is directly related to the superfluid density , @xmath162 the dipole matrix element thus acts as the order parameter associated with the superfluid phase . in most bilayer
exciton condensates , such as the one in the quantum hall regime@xcite , this order parameter is also nonzero in the normal phase because of interlayer tunneling of electrons .
one can therefore not speak strictly about spontaneous breaking of @xmath3 symmetry in such systems ; there is already explicit symmetry breaking due to the interlayer tunneling . in strongly correlated electron systems
the finite @xmath26 is small compared to the chemical potential @xmath25 . as discussed in the introduction ,
the mott insulating bilayers now effectively allow for spontaneous @xmath3 symmetry breaking , and the above dipole matrix element acts as a true order parameter .
note that the irrelevance of interlayer hopping @xmath26 implies that this order parameter is , unfortunately , not reflected in photon emission or interlayer tunneling measurements .
the exciton condensate is a standard two - dimensional bose condensate . the @xmath3 symmetry present in the @xmath35-type exciton hopping terms is spontaneously broken and we expect a linearly dispersing goldstone mode in the excitation spectrum , reflecting the rigidity of the condensate .
we will get back to the full excitation spectrum in section [ seceex ] .
the energy of the singlet exciton condensate is @xmath163 and the exciton density is given by @xmath164 whenever the exciton hopping is small , the introduction of excitons into the system leads to the ` spin flop ' transition towards the checkerboard crystalline phase .
as shown in the context of the @xmath1 model , this phase implies that one sublattice is completely filled with excitons and the other sublattice is completely empty . on the empty sublattice
, any nonzero @xmath28 will guarantee that the singlet spin state has the lowest energy .
hence the average exciton density is here @xmath165 and the energy of the checkerboard phase is given by @xmath166 it is interesting to note that the checkerboard phase is in fact similar to a bose mott insulator : with the new doubled unit cell we have one exciton per unit cell .
the nearest neighbor dipole repulsion now acts as the ` on - site ' energy preventing extra excitons per unit cell . within the analytical mean field theory set by equation ( [ meanfielde ] )
there exists a small region where antiferromagnetism and the exciton condensate coexist .
there the energy of the homogenous coexistence phase is lower than the energy of macroscopic phase separation of the antiferromagnet and the condensate , as obtained using the maxwell construction .
however , within numerical simulations we found no evidence of coexistence .
instead , we found microscopic phase separation , which hints at a possible complex inhomogeneous phase .
we therefore conclude that the homogeneous mean field theory discussed here is insufficient to find the true ground state . finally , when the exciton density is unity we have a system composed of excitons only . in the parlance of hard - core bosons
this amounts to a exciton mott insulator .
this rather featureless phase is adiabatically connected to a standard electronic band insulator : the system is now composed of two layers where each layer has an even number of electrons per unit cell .
the energy of the exciton mott insulator is , trivially @xmath167 in this mean field theory most of the phase transitions are first order , with the exciton density varying discontinuously along the transition .
the critical values of @xmath25 or @xmath168 for the first order transitions are @xmath169 the transitions towards the coexistence region from the antiferromagnet or the condensate are second order .
additionally , the transition from the condensate to the exciton mott insulator is second order .
the critical values of @xmath168 or @xmath25 at these second order transitions are @xmath170 the subscripts indicate the phases : antiferromagnetic phase ( af ) , coexistence phase ( co ) , exciton condensate ( ec ) , exciton mott insulator ( ei ) , checkerboard phase ( cb ) . for any nonzero
@xmath171 the first order transitions from the antiferromagnetic or coexistence phase towards the checkerboard phase are ` standard ' in the sense that at the critical value of @xmath25 there are only two mean field states with equal energy .
this is also true for the transitions from the antiferromagnet to the exciton condensate except at a single point . at the tricritical point @xmath172 separating the coexistence phase , the antiferromagnetic phase and the exciton condensate
, we can set the parameters @xmath173 , @xmath174 and @xmath175 given by the value in the coexistence phase .
now the energy becomes independent of the exciton density @xmath149 .
similarly , at the critical value of @xmath176 describing the transition between the checkerboard phase to the singlet exciton condensate , we can choose the mean field parameters @xmath173 , @xmath177 and @xmath178 with these parameters , the energy becomes independent of @xmath76 .
this implies that the mean field theory predicts highly degenerate states at the critical values of @xmath25 , similar to the one we found in the @xmath1 model .
the phase separation that thus occurs can be between an infinite set of possible ground states that have all a different exciton density .
coincidentally , the numerical simulations indicate that around the two ` degenerate ' critical points indeed all the three phases are present .
while the macroscopic phase separated state might have the lowest energy , figure [ phasesepfig ] suggests that more complicated patterns of phase separation are likely to occur .
the degeneracy of the critical points on the level of mean fields theory might be responsible for richer physics in these special regions of the phase diagram . the canonical ground state phase diagram of the exciton @xmath0 model , which is a combination of the semi - classical monte carlo result and the mean field computations . in the background
we have put the mean field phase diagram of figure [ canonicaldiagram ] , whilst the lines show the phase diagram as obtained from the monte carlo simulations .
the dotted area represents phase separation between the condensate , antiferromagnetic and checkerboard order .
furthermore : ec means exciton condensate , cb means checkerboard phase , af means antiferromagnetism and ps stands for phase separation . ]
finite temperature graph of the phase coherence in the exciton condensate region of the phase diagram . here
@xmath179 ev and @xmath180 and the other parameters are the same as in a. a clear transition is observed at around 0.06 ev , which amounts to a transition temperature of about 700 kelvin . ] combining the simulated annealing results of figure [ mcresults ] with the analytical mean field results of figure [ canonicaldiagram ] we arrive at the definitive mean field phase diagram of the exciton @xmath0 model in figure [ finalphasediagramfig ] .
there are three main phases : the antiferromagnet at zero exciton density , the checkerboard crystal at exciton density @xmath154 and the superfluid at high hopping energy @xmath23 . for most parts of the phase diagram ,
phase separation between these three phases occurs in any possible combination .
the competition between these three phases leads generally to macroscopic phase separation .
finally , within the limitations of the semi - classical monte carlo approach we deduce an estimate of the transition temperature towards the superfluid state . given a typical point in the phase diagram where the exciton condensate exists , at @xmath179 ev and @xmath181 , we find a kosterlitz - thouless transition temperature of approximately 700 kelvin , see figure [ mcresults]c .
this number should be taken not too seriously , as the exciton @xmath0 model might not be applicable at such high temperatures given possible exciton dissociation .
additionally , at high temperatures the electron - phonon coupling becomes increasingly important , which we neglect in our exciton @xmath0 model .
nonetheless , our estimate suggests that exciton superfluidity may extend to quite high finite temperatures .
each phase of the excitons in the strongly correlated bilayer has distinct collective modes , that are in principle measurable by experiment . in order to obtain the dispersions of the collective modes we employ the technique of the heisenberg equations of motion , introduced in the context of the @xmath1 model in section [ xxzexc ] and
further formalized in appendix [ appendixc ] . in the case of the exciton @xmath0 model
the set of equations is larger and analytical solutions can in general not be obtained . whenever this is the case we compute the dispersions numerically .
quantities of direct experimental relevance are the dynamical susceptibilities .
we are for instance interested in the absorptive part of the dynamical magnetic susceptibility , defined by @xmath182 here @xmath183 is the ground state of the system and @xmath184 are the excited states with energy @xmath185 .
it appears unlikely that bilayer exciton systems can be manufactured in bulk form which is required for neutron scattering , while there is a real potential to grow these using thin layer techniques .
therefore the detection of the dynamical spin susceptibility forms a realistic challenge for resonant inelastic x - ray scattering ( rixs)@xcite measurements with its claimed sensitivity for interface physics@xcite .
furthermore we are interested in the charge dynamical susceptibility @xmath186 which is directly related to the polarization propagator .
we use the operator @xmath187 because this amounts to the interlayer dipole matrix element .
therefore , this charge dynamical susceptibility expresses the excitonic excitations . it can be observed by optical absorption experiments@xcite at @xmath188 .
finite wavelength measurements may be obtained using the aforementioned rixs@xcite technique , or using electron energy loss spectroscopy ( eels)@xcite . the method we use to compute the susceptibilities , based on the heisenberg equations of motion method , is also described in appendix [ appendixc ] .
the three dominant phases we encountered in our mean field analysis will have distinct magnetic and optical responses .
let us briefly summarize our main findings with respect to the collective excitations .
the results for the antiferromagnetic phase are shown in figures [ afspinwaves ] to [ afantiadiabatic ] .
this limit of vanishing exciton density has been studied with in far greater rigor than our current zubarev method is capable of@xcite .
we can therefore compare the results of the zubarev method with a full resummation of spin - exciton interactions using the self - consistent born approximation ( lsw - scba ) .
it turns out that for small exciton kinetic hopping @xmath23 the non - interacting equations - of - motion method yields reliable results . for large @xmath23
one needs the full scba code to correctly reproduce the dynamical frustration effects of excitons in the antiferromagnetic background .
the collective modes of the exciton condensate are shown in figures [ ec - exciton ] and [ ec - spin ] . due to the absence of dynamical frustration and the presence of a spin - gap
we expect that these results survive in a fully interacting computation .
in fact , here the modes of the simple hard - core boson system discussed in section [ secxxz ] can be used as a template . just as for the phase diagram , the qualitative features of @xmath1 model are still of relevance for the more complicated @xmath0 model .
nonetheless , in this condensate phase the interplay between excitonic and magnetic degrees of freedom gives rise to a rather counterintuitive effect .
we find that the _ exciton superfluid density _ can be detected directly in a measurement of the _ magnetic excitations _ , as we already announced elsewhere@xcite .
in contrast , in the checkerboard crystalline phase the spin and exciton degrees of freedom are once again decoupled . in the remainder of this section
we will elaborate further on these results for each phase separately . throughout the following discussion ,
the model parameters are @xmath108 mev , @xmath109 , @xmath189 ev and a varying @xmath23 and @xmath76 . in order to visualize the susceptibilities we have convoluted @xmath190 with a lorentzian of width @xmath191 ev .
the color scale of the susceptibility plots is in arbitrary units .
the spin wave dispersions ( * a. * ) and the dynamical magnetic susceptibility ( * b. * ) in the antiferromagnetic phase .
in this phase , the spin wave dispersions are not influenced by exciton dynamics . as is known from previous studies ,
there are two transversal spin waves and two longitudinal spin waves@xcite .
the transversal spin waves are gapless around either @xmath192 ( solid red line ) or the @xmath193 point ( dotted blue line ) .
the longitudinal spin waves , which are associated with interlayer fluctuations ( solid green line ) , are nearly flat and have a gap of order @xmath194 .
the dynamic magnetic susceptibility ( * b. * ) only shows one transversal spin wave .
these results and all subsequent figures are obtained using @xmath195 mev and @xmath109 , as is expected for the undoped bilayer cuprate ybco @xcite . ] the exciton modes in the antiferromagnetic phase in the adiabatic regime @xmath196 .
here we have chosen @xmath197 ev , @xmath195 mev and @xmath198 . within the equations of motion picture
there are four exciton modes ( * a. * ) , which come in pairs of two with a small interlayer splitting . due to the antiferromagnetic order
the exciton bands are renormalized with respect to a free hard - core boson ( * b. * ) .
the susceptibility corresponding to the free exciton motion ( * c. * ) is verified by the fully interacting lsw - scba results ( * d. * ) .
this is to be expected : in the adiabatic regime spins react much faster than the exciton motion and the exciton still moves freely dressed by a spin polaron , reducing its bandwidth to order @xmath199 . ]
the exciton modes in the antiferromagnetic phase in the antiadiabatic regime @xmath200 .
here we have chosen @xmath201 ev , @xmath195 mev and @xmath198 .. just like in figure [ afadiabatic ] we find four exciton bands ( * a. * ) , renormalized with respect to the free hard - core boson results ( * b. * ) . however , upon inclusion of the interaction the free susceptibility ( * c. * ) gets extremely renormalized ( * d. * ) .
the large exciton kinetic energy together with the relatively spin dynamics create an effective potential for the exciton : the exciton becomes localized and the confinement generates a ladder spectrum . note that thus in the antiadiabatic regime the free results ( * a. * , * c. * ) can not be trusted .
] in the limit of zero exciton density we recover the well - known bilayer heisenberg physics@xcite . as discussed in section [ ssgrandcanonical ] , the spins tend to order antiferromagnetically .
the excitations spectrum thus contains a goldstone spin wave with linear dispersion around @xmath192 and a similar mode centered around @xmath202 .
in addition , the bilayer nature is reflected in the presence of two longitudinal spin waves with a gap of order @xmath194 and a narrow bandwidth of order @xmath28 .
the excitation spectrum and the corresponding magnetic dynamical susceptibility is shown in figure [ afspinwaves ] .
since the spin modes of the bilayer antiferromagnet are independent of any exciton degrees of freedom , we will not discuss these any further .
the dynamics of an isolated exciton in an antiferromagnetic background has been studied extensively by means of a linear spin - wave self - consistent born approximation technique ( lsw - scba)@xcite .
the non - interacting equations of motion method used in this paper , amounts to the complete neglect of exciton - spin interactions , while these are on the foreground of the ( resummed ) lsw - scba computation .
however , the mere existence of lsw - scba results allows us to compare it with our current non - interacting calculations .
let us therefore first go through the lsw - scba results .
there we need to distinguish between two limits : the adiabatic limit with @xmath196 shown in figure [ afadiabatic ] , and the anti - adiabatic limit where @xmath200 shown in figure [ afantiadiabatic ] .
consider a single exciton in an antiferromagnetic background . now
if this exciton hops to a neighboring site , it will leave behind two spins that are ferromagnetically aligned with their neighbors .
this process is called dynamical frustration and limits severely the motion of an exciton . in the adiabatic limit ( @xmath196 )
this causes the exciton bandwidth to be drastically reduced to an order @xmath199 .
in addition , the magnetic background acts as a confining potential leading to small but detectable ladder states at higher energies . at the other hand , in the anti - adiabatic regime
@xmath200 exciton hopping will destroy the antiferromagnetic order as it will be surrounded by a cloud of frustrated spins .
the quasiparticle picture completely breaks down and the spectral weight of the exciton is redistributed to a wide incoherent spectral bump . the ladder spectrum arising from the effective confinement will still be visible , though smeared out .
the equations - of - motion method however ignores the effects of spin - exciton interactions such as dynamical frustration .
it treats the excitons as well - defined quasiparticles .
as such we can already guess beforehand that the non - interacting results will be reliable in the adiabatic regime . indeed , in the equations - of - motion method we find four exciton modes corresponding to either the singlet @xmath203 or @xmath204 triplet exciton @xmath205 operator , just as in the lsw - scba .
when @xmath206 we can write out an analytical expression for the non - interacting dispersions , @xmath207 where each branch is twofold degenerate .
this degeneracy is lifted when @xmath208 , leading to a splitting of order @xmath171 which is largest around @xmath192 and @xmath193 . in the limit of @xmath196
the dispersions , equation ( [ excdispersion ] ) , indeed result in an effective exciton bandwidth of order @xmath199 , conform the fully interacting theory as can be seen in figure [ afadiabatic ] . the natural question
then arises : how is it possible that in the present non - interacting theory the exciton bandwidth depends on the spin parameter @xmath22 ? for sure , the effective exciton model introduced in section [ secxxz ] has no such renormalization as is shown in figure [ afadiabatic ] .
there the exciton bandwidth fully depends on @xmath209 . however , it is important to realize that the exciton operators @xmath210 do not commute with the antiferromagnetic order parameter operator @xmath211 . as a result the mean field energy of exciting an exciton is shifted either up or down ( depending on the sublattice ) yielding a gap between the two exciton branches of @xmath212 .
now for small @xmath23 , propagation of the exciton requires that one has to pay the energy shift @xmath194 to move through both sublattices . as a result
the effective hopping is reduced by a factor @xmath168 .
therefore the exciton bandwidth renormalization , seen in the full lsw - scba , is already present at the mean field level .
for large @xmath168 however we will pay a price for the convenience of the non - interacting equations of motion method . at
the mean field level one still expects the dispersions to be described by equation ( [ excdispersion ] ) .
however , upon inclusion of the interaction corrections this picture breaks down completely .
the bandwidth of the non - interacting exciton is of order @xmath209 , whereas in the interacting theory an incoherent ladder spectrum of the same width arises .
thus for large @xmath168 the non - interacting results can not be trusted .
however , this only applies to the antiferromagnetic phase due to the presence of dynamical frustration . in general
, it appears that the non - interacting results are qualitatively correct in the absence of gapless modes that need to be excited in order for an exciton to move .
this condition is naturally met for the other two phases .
we therefore expect that exciton - spin interactions only lead to qualitative changes in the antiferromagnetic phase .
by simple selection rules one can already conclude that the singlet exciton mode couples to light . as a consequence
this is the mode that is visible in the charge dynamical susceptibility , which is related to the polarization propagator .
the exciton excitations are shown in figures [ afadiabatic]d ( for @xmath213 ) and [ afantiadiabatic]d ( for @xmath214 ) .
finally , note that at the transition from the antiferromagnetic phase to the checkerboard phase the gap in the exciton spectrum vanishes at @xmath202 .
dispersions and susceptibilities of the goldstone mode associated with the exciton condensate .
we have set @xmath215 ev , @xmath195 mev and @xmath198 , and the exciton density is either @xmath216 ( left column ) or @xmath217 ( right column ) . * a , b. * in the simple hard - core boson model
the condensate phase clearly show the superfluid phase mode , linear at small momenta . * c , d .
* in the full @xmath0 model the goldstone mode has a similar dispersion as in the @xmath1 model .
the speed of the mode scales with the superfluid density . at higher densities
the mode softens around @xmath202 , and when this gap closes a first order transition to the checkerboard phase sets in .
* e , f . * the absorptive part of the charge susceptibility , which can be measured with for example eels or rixs . ] dispersions and magnetic susceptibilities of the exciton condensate .
we have set @xmath215 ev , @xmath195 mev and @xmath198 , and the exciton density is either @xmath216 ( left column ) or @xmath217 ( right column ) .
* as the exciton condensate is spin singlet , we assume that the excitation spectrum is governed by propagating triplet modes .
these modes have a gap of order @xmath28 and a bandwidth of order @xmath194 .
* c , d . * in contrast to the simple heisenberg results , the actual triplet modes have enhanced kinetics@xcite .
the modes are split in a spin - dominated branch with small gap and large bandwidth proportional to the superfluid density ( * e , f . * ) ; and an exciton - dominated branch with a large gap and a small bandwidth ( * g , h . * ) . ]
the mode spectrum of superfluid phase , as shown in figures [ ec - exciton ] and [ ec - spin ] , is characterized by a linearly dispersing goldstone mode associated with the broken @xmath3 symmetry .
this superfluid phase mode has vanishing energy at the @xmath192 point , where we find the inescapable linear dispersion relation @xmath218 the speed of the superfluid phase mode is the same as for the @xmath1 model in equation ( [ xxzsuperfluidspeed ] ) up to a rescaling of the @xmath23 and @xmath19 parameters .
indeed , this speed is proportional to the superfluid density @xmath219 .
this mode can be seen in the charge susceptibility , figures [ ec - exciton]e and f. the goldstone mode has a gap at @xmath202 which decreases monotonically with increasing exciton density . precisely at the first order transition towards the checkerboard phase
this gap closes .
this mode softening at @xmath202 is reminiscent of the roton in superfluid helium : the wavelength of the roton is the same as the lattice constant of solid helium .
next to the goldstone mode there are two triplet excitations , shown in figure [ ec - spin ] , each one three - fold degenerate .
the degeneracy obviously arises from the standard triplet degeneracy @xmath220 .
the two branches however distinguish between _ exciton - dominated _ modes and _ spin - dominated _ modes , let us discuss them separately .
the spin - dominated modes have a gap of order @xmath221 , which is similar to the triplet gap in the bilayer heisenberg model for large @xmath171 . however , the bandwidth of these excitations scales with @xmath23 rather than with @xmath22 , as would be customary in a system without exciton condensation ( see figures [ ec - spin]a and b ) .
we discussed this in great detail in recent work@xcite , so let us briefly review these results . in the absence of a excitons the motion of triplets is governed by the heisenberg superexchange yielding a bandwidth of order @xmath22 .
now introduce fock operators @xmath222 and @xmath223 , so that the exciton - triplet exchange equation ( [ excitonhop ] ) reads @xmath224 this is an interaction term , thus seemingly irrelevant to the bandwidth of the triplet .
however , when the exciton condensation sets in the operator @xmath225 obtains an expectation value , in fact @xmath226 where @xmath227 is the condensate density .
therefore the higher order exchange term yields a quadratic triplet hopping term @xmath228 and the bandwidth of the triplet excitations becomes of order @xmath229 .
now remember that the exciton hopping energy @xmath23 resulted , in second order perturbation theory , from the ratio @xmath230 where @xmath231 is the electron hopping energy and @xmath232 is the nearest neighbor coulomb repulsion@xcite .
the heisenberg coupling however was given by @xmath233 where @xmath234 is the onsite coulomb repulsion . since for obvious reasons
@xmath235 , we find that the triplet bandwidth is enhanced whenever exciton condensation sets is .
this enhancement is clearly visible in the spin susceptibility @xmath236 , which allows for an experimental probe of the exciton superfluid density .
the other branch of triplet excitations is dominated by triplet excitons , and is therefore barely visible in the spin susceptibility and not visible in the exciton susceptibility ( which only shows singlet excitons ) . that it is indeed dominated by triplet excitons
can be inferred from computing the matrix elements of the operator @xmath237 , which are shown in figures [ ec - spin]g and h. furthermore , the gap @xmath238 is a function of exciton model parameters only .
the bandwidth of this mode is of order @xmath239 , relatively independent of the exciton density . as a result , for large superfluid densities the exciton - dominated modes cross the spin - dominated triplet modes .
one can directly see this in the excitation spectrum for @xmath217 as shown in figure [ ec - spin]d .
we can compare the triplet spectrum to the mode spectrum of the singlet phase of the bilayer heisenberg model .
when @xmath240 the ground state consists of only rung singlets .
the excitation towards a triplet state , shown in figures [ ec - spin]a and b , has a gap @xmath241 and a bandwidth of order @xmath194 , which is considerably smaller than the @xmath239 bandwidth in the condensate .
however , because the topology of the triplet mode is the same we expect that the effect of the spin - exciton interactions is the same in the bilayer heisenberg model as for the superfluid . since earlier lsw - scba showed no changes in the spectrum due to interactions , we infer that the non - interacting results for the superfluid are reliable . to conclude our discussion of the excitations of the superfluid phase let us consider the influence of the interlayer tunneling .
in the context of the @xmath1 model we noticed that interlayer tunneling has no qualitative influence on the phase diagram itself . however , the presence of a weak interlayer tunneling may act as potential pinningthe phase@xcite opening a gap in the superfluid phase mode spectrum of order @xmath242 .
persistent currents can still exist , but one needs to overcome this gap in order to get the exciton supercurrent flowing . the excitation spectrum of the checkerboard phase .
* a. * in the simple hard - core boson model there are two exciton modes associated with the doublon and the holon excitation . *
b. * the spin modes are decoupled from the exciton modes in the full @xmath0 model .
there is only one possible spin excitation : changing the singlet groundstate into a non - propagating triplet .
* c. * the exciton modes , on the other hand , can still propagate .
the excitation of removing an exciton can propagate through the checkerboard . *
d. * the propagating mode that changes an exciton into a singlet is detectable by optical means and thus shows up in the charge susceptibility . ]
the third homogeneous phase of the exciton @xmath0 model is the checkerboard phase . in this phase the unit cell
is effectively doubled with one exciton per unit cell .
this state is analogous to a bose mott insulator .
the trivial excitations are then the doublon and the holon : create two bosons per unit cell which costs an energy @xmath243 or to remove the boson .
the latter will generate a propagating exciton mode , with dispersion @xmath244 there are two such propagating modes : one associated with the singlet exciton and one with the triplet exciton . precisely at the transition towards the superfluid phase , one of these exciton waves
becomes gapless .
note that the arguments that lead to the bandwidth renormalization in the antiferromagnetic phase also apply here , leading to an exciton bandwidth of order @xmath245 .
the dispersions and the corresponding charge dynamical susceptibility can be seen in figure [ dispersionfigcb ] . in the spin sector
one can excite a localized spin triplet on the empty sublattice .
the triplet gap is set by the interlayer energy @xmath28 , and the dispersion is flat because this triplet can not propagate , as can be seen in figure [ dispersionfigcb]b .
we have studied the possibility of exciton condensation in strongly correlated electron bilayers .
starting from the description of the mott state , with localized electrons , an exciton is defined as an interlayer bound state of a double occupied and vacant site . in the strong coupling limit , as of relevance to laboratory systems based on mott insulators , the physics of such a system is described by the exciton @xmath0 model , equation ( [ fullh ] ) .
we constructed the ground state phase diagram ( figure [ finalphasediagramfig ] ) , based on both numerical simulations and analytical mean field theory .
three distinct phases are dominant : the antiferromagnetic phase , the checkerboard phase and the exciton condensate . for most parts of the phase diagram
however , macroscopic phase separation will occur between these three phases .
measurements of the spin and charge susceptibilities may discern in which one of the three main phases a specific system is in . the antiferromagnetic phase is characterized by a spin wave centered at @xmath202 , whilst in the exciton condensate the triplet bandwidth acts as a probe for the superfluid density ( see figure [ ec - spin ] and ref .
@xcite ) . in the checkerboard phase the spin degrees of freedom
are reflected only in a localized triplet excitation at low energy .
the charge dynamic susceptibility shows distinct qualitative behavior depending on the phase . in the antiferromagnet
the spin - exciton interactions play an important role @xcite .
the superfluid phase is characterized by the visibility of the condensate goldstone mode , whereas the checkerboard phase has propagating exciton waves with bandwidth @xmath246 .
note however that since we expect phase separation to occur for most model parameters , realistic samples will likely display features from all phases in its susceptibilities .
our theoretical work presented here is largely based on the assumption of strong coupling . in this limit ,
the excitons behave as local hard - core bosons .
if the exciton binding energy is less dominant , the exciton will extend over more lattice sites and thus probably enable coexistence phases .
on the other hand we expect that spin - exciton interactions destabilize the coexistence phases , since these interactions generally lead to frustration effects .
one could also wonder what happens if one includes longer - ranged interactions for the excitons , with the possibility of exciton stripes and incommensurate charge ordered phases@xcite .
next , we are dealing with first order phase transitions where small changes may have severe consequences . combining all these effects may lead to significant changes in the phase diagram , most notably in the regime where we predict phase separation . within the context of the strongly coupled exciton @xmath0 model
, a weaker exciton binding energy can be incorporated via interaction and hopping terms for the next nearest neighbors , next next nearest neighbors , etcetera .
this might lead to complex ordered phases such as stripes@xcite .
such phases are found in many strongly correlated electron systems@xcite , and studying these in the context of the simple bosonic exciton @xmath0 model might shed new light on the more troublesome fermionic @xmath0 model .
in addition to stripy behavior other non - trivial exciton density profiles may occur when one considers a density imbalance between the electrons and holes .
semiconductor imbalanced systems are predicted to exhibit fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov density modulated phases@xcite .
it is worthwhile to investigate whether such phase can exist in strongly correlated electron systems .
next to an improvement of the phase diagram , we can also improve the susceptibilities by including the effect of exciton - spin interactions .
similar to our earlier work @xcite on the interaction between excitons and spins in the limit of a single exciton , one could perform a diagrammatic expansion of these interactions .
we expect that , apart from our earlier results in the antiferromagnetic phase , inclusion of spin - exciton interactions will not qualitatively alter the excitation spectra .
experimentally , the close coupling of p- and n - doped mott insulators is still relatively ill explored .
however , important advances in complex oxide thin film growth , by techniques such as molecular beam epitaxy ( mbe ) and pulsed laser deposition ( pld ) equipped with in situ monitoring tools such as reflective high energy electron diffraction ( rheed ) are making it possible now to grow multilayers of perovskite oxides - of which many are mott insulators - with unit cell precision . a complicating factor in fabricating multilayers of p- and n - doped perovskites , like the cuprate family from which also the high - tc superconductors are derived ,
are the oftentimes conflicting ( de)-oxygenation requirements .
optimized deposition and post - anneal procedures have made it possible however to make thin film contacts between n- and p - doped superconducting cuprates @xcite , which is now further being explored in our labs to create and study the parallel n - p combinations resembling the theoretical model .
an interesting additional system that can be included in this endeavor is the 2-dimensional electron gas that is formed at the interfaces between selected oxide band - insulators such as srtio@xmath247 and laalo@xmath247 . in this respect
it is noteworthy that in specific configurations , in particular a 1 unit cell srtio@xmath247 layer on top of a 2 unit cell laalo@xmath247 layer grown on tio@xmath248-terminated srtio@xmath249 , a system of a closely coupled 2-dimensional electron gas and a 2-dimensional hole gas has been realized @xcite .
finally we note that some cuprate high - tc materials appear to have an intrinsic stacking of electron - doped and hole - doped cuo@xmath248 layers , such as ba@xmath248ca@xmath247cu@xmath250o@xmath251f@xmath248 @xcite , where one could look for excitonic effects .
this research was supported by the dutch nwo foundation through a vici grant .
the authors thank sergei mukhin and kai wu for helpful discussions .
in this appendix we will define the operators that compose the @xmath39 dynamical lie algebra , as described in the beginning of section [ algebrasec ] . from the bilayer heisenberg we already have the @xmath38 spin subalgebra @xmath252 where we use the obvious short - handed notation for the singlet and triplet kets and bras .
the commutation relation between these operators read @xmath253 & = & i \epsilon^{abc } s^c \\
\left [ s^a , \widetilde{s}^b \right ] & = & \left [ \widetilde{s}^a , s^b \right ] = i \epsilon^{abc } \widetilde{s}^c \\
\left [ \widetilde{s}^a , \widetilde{s}^b \right ] & = & i \epsilon^{abc } s^c.\end{aligned}\ ] ] there are 12 exciton operators in the @xmath35-like part of the hamiltonian , which we denote by @xmath254 where @xmath255 and @xmath256 , with commutation relations @xmath257 & = & 2e^z_{sm } \\ \left [ e^z_{sm},e^+_{sm } \right ] & = & e^+_{sm}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we consider commutators between @xmath258-operators with different @xmath37 then we obtain operators that are fully spin - dependent .
we find that the only nonzero commutators between @xmath259 operators with @xmath260 , @xmath261 & = & | s \ ; m \rangle \langle s ' \ ; m ' | \\ \left [ e^z_{sm},e^+_{s'm ' } \right ] & = & \frac{1}{2 } e^+_{s'm'}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we need some more operators to close the spin @xmath262 subalgebra , therefore define @xmath263 operators by ( note that @xmath264 ) , @xmath265 to complete the spin @xmath262 subalgebra we define @xmath266 and the corresponding @xmath267 .
finally , notice that we have one operator too much in our listing , since there are only 24 operators in @xmath39 .
thus there exists a linear dependency relation between some operators , which is @xmath268 so when constructing the heisenberg equations of motion , we will exclude one of these three from our formalism .
the most logical step is to throw out the combination @xmath269 and leave the sum @xmath270 the 24 operators of our dynamical @xmath39 algebra are the three @xmath271- , three @xmath272- , two @xmath273- , three @xmath274- , two @xmath193- and eleven @xmath258-operators .
in this appendix we elaborate a bit further on the heisenberg equations of motion method , as introduced in paragraph [ xxzexc ] .
the aim of this method is to find the spectrum of excitations , building on the foundations given by the mean field approximation .
given a full set of local operators @xmath275 , we can construct the heisenberg equations of motion @xmath276\ ] ] which is in general impossible to solve .
we employ the notation that @xmath8 indicates the lattice site , and @xmath277 is the index denoting the type of operator .
the right hand side of this equation contains products of operators at different lattice sites .
such products can be decoupled within the mean field approximation as @xcite @xmath278 where @xmath8 and @xmath279 are different lattice sites . upon fourier transforming lattice position into momentum and time into energy , we thus obtain a set of linear equations for the operators , @xmath280 the spectrum of excitations is simply found by solving this eigenvalue equation for the matrix @xmath281 . in order to find
the matrix elements @xmath282 that enter in susceptibilities we need will introduce the following scheme .
assume that the hamiltonian is of the form @xmath283 where the sum over @xmath284 runs over momenta , and @xmath285 indicates the different excited states . now @xmath286 is a creation operator , and irrespective of whether we are dealing with fermions or bosons we have the following equations of motion @xmath287 that is : every eigenvector of @xmath288 corresponding to a negative eigenvalue can be identified as a creation operator for one of the elementary excitations .
however , the eigenvalue equation itself is not enough because it does not yield the proper normalization of @xmath289 .
since we have the eigenvector solution @xmath290 we can write out the ( anti)commutation relation for @xmath286 in terms of the ( anti)commutation relations for the @xmath291 . upon requiring that on the mean field level the operators @xmath286 obey canonical commutation relations , that is for bosons @xmath292 \rangle = \delta_{nn'},\ ] ] we obtain a proper normalization for the new creation operators .
we can invert the normalized matrix @xmath293 to express @xmath291 in terms of the creation operators @xmath286 . finally , using @xmath294
we can compute the wanted matrix element for @xmath291 . as an example of this technique we can compute the matrix element @xmath295 for the antiferromagnetic heisenberg model on a square lattice .
the mean field ground state is the nel state , which leads to the following equations of motion , @xmath296 where the subscript @xmath297 and @xmath298 denote the two different sublattices , and @xmath299 .
we quite easily infer that the eigenvalues are @xmath300 and thus we have one eigenvector corresponding to a creation operator , and one to an annihilation operator .
if we define @xmath301 then the commutation relations tell us that the eigenvector matrix @xmath302 must satisfy @xmath303 \rangle = - 2 u_{11}^2
\langle s^z_{a } \rangle - 2 u_{12}^2 \langle s^z_{b } \rangle = - u_{11}^2 + u_{12}^2.\ ] ] the initial @xmath304 operator , which enters in the spin susceptibility , can be expressed in terms of the eigenvector matrix as @xmath305 some straightforward algebra now yields @xmath306 which is the same susceptibility one can obtain by using the holstein - primakoff linear spin wave approximation .
the approximation scheme we introduced here can therefore be viewed as a generalization of the linear spin wave approximation . | we studied the possibility of exciton condensation in mott insulating bilayers . in these strongly correlated systems
an exciton is the bound state of a double occupied and empty site . in the strong coupling limit
the exciton acts as a hard - core boson .
its physics are captured by the exciton @xmath0 model , containing an effective @xmath1 model describing the exciton dynamics only . using numerical simulations and analytical mean field theory we constructed the ground state phase diagram .
three homogeneous phases can be distinguished : the antiferromagnet , the exciton checkerboard crystal and the exciton superfluid . for most model parameters ,
however , we predict macroscopic phase separation between these phases .
the exciton superfluid exists only for large exciton hopping energy .
additionally we studied the collective modes and susceptibilities of the three phases . in the superfluid phase
we find the striking feature that the bandwidth of the spin - triplet excitations , potentially detectable by resonant inelastic x - ray scattering ( rixs ) , is proportional to the superfluid density .
the superfluid phase mode is visible in the charge susceptibility , measurable by rixs or electron energy loss spectroscopy ( eels ) . |
consider a mc with mass @xmath5 at a distance @xmath6 , located in a region in the galaxy where the cr ( protons ) intensity is @xmath7 . for illustrative purpose , we set here @xmath8 .
we further assume that the high energy crs ( the ones with energy above the threshold for @xmath9-production ) can freely penetrate the cloud@xcite . under these assumptions the expected gamma ray flux from the mc due to proton - proton interactions
is given by : @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the interaction cross section , @xmath12 is the proton mass , and @xmath13 depends on @xmath14 and is tabulated in ref . .
equation [ flux ] is valid at high energies only ( @xmath15 ) , while at lower energies the spectrum ( in log - log scale ) is symmetric with respect to the energy @xmath16 .
assume now that the cr intensity in the region under exam differs by a factor @xmath17 from the one measured at the earth ( which is:@xcite @xmath18 ) , so that equation [ flux ] can be rewritten as : @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the mass of the mc in units of @xmath21 , @xmath22 is the distance in kpc , and @xmath23 takes into account the fact that on average crs with energy @xmath0 produce gamma rays with energy @xmath24 .
moreover , a multiplicative factor of 1.5 has been applied to account for the contribution to the emission from nuclei heavier than h both in crs and in the mc gas .
if gamma rays are detected from a mc , and its mass and distance are known from its co emission@xcite , then equation [ barometer ] allows one to measure both the spectrum and intensity of crs at the mc s location , and thus the quantity @xmath25 .
it follows that mcs can be effectively used as probes of the energy density of crs at different locations in the galaxy , and for this reason have been sometimes referred to as _
cr barometers_. @xcite since observations in the gev range of the galaxy suggest that , on large spatial scales , cr variations are not very large , @xcite @xmath25 is normally interpreted as the excess above the galactic cr background . some examples of how to use this fact to estimate the cr diffusion coefficient are given in the following sections .
the h.e.s.s . collaboration reported on the detection of diffuse gamma ray emission from the galactic centre ( gc ) ridge .
@xcite remarkably , the emission correlates spatially with a complex of giant mcs , suggesting that the emission itself is likely to be originated by cr hadronic interactions in the dense ambient gas .
the tev gamma ray spectrum extracted from the region of galactic coordinates @xmath26 , @xmath27 can be fitted by a power law with index @xmath28 and normalization @xmath29 . at the distance of the gc ( @xmath30 )
the emitting region has a size of @xmath31 , and encloses a total gas mass of @xmath32 .
@xcite by assuming that all the observed gamma ray emission has an hadronic origin , we can use equation [ barometer ] to show that , close to the gc , the cr intensity at 10 tev is enhanced with respect to the local one by a factor of @xmath33 , and grows at higher energies due to the hardness of the measured emission .
moreover , the total energy in form of crs needed to explain the emission is @xmath34 , if the observed spectrum is extrapolated from 1 gev to 1 pev .
thus , a single snr with explosion energy @xmath35 and acceleration efficiency @xmath36 might explain the whole cr excess in the region .
@xcite one possible cr accelerator is the snr sgr a east , located close to the gc and with an estimated ( but uncertain ) age of @xmath37 .
if the crs responsible for the observed emission are assumed to be released during the earliest phase of the snr evolution , then it is possible to estimate the diffusion coefficient by requiring them to fill the emitting region of size @xmath38 in a time @xmath39 .
this gives @xmath40 , which , taking into account the large uncertainties in the assumptions made , is in rough agreement with ( maybe somewhat smaller than @xcite ) the value of the diffusion coefficient of @xmath41 tev crs in the galactic disk .
the presence of a massive mc at @xmath42 ( @xmath43 ) which does not show prominent gamma ray emission suggests that crs accelerated at the gc have not diffused yet up to that distance , and this justifies our assumption for @xmath44 .
@xcite this estimate of the diffusion coefficient has to be regarded as a very rough one , due to the presence of many uncertainties in its derivation .
for example , another source ( e.g. the black hole sgr a@xmath45 @xcite ) , or many sources ( e.g. an ensemble of snrs @xcite ) might be the accelerators of the crs responsible for the tev emission . moreover , proton energy losses ( ignored here ) might affect the estimate of the diffusion coefficient by a factor of @xmath46 .
@xcite better constraints on the diffusion coefficient and on the nature of the source(s ) of the accelerated particles could be obtained if the spatial variation of the spectrum of the gamma ray emission was known .
measuring such variation , though challenging for currently operating instruments , is within the capabilities of future ones like the cherenkov telescope array .
it seems thus appropriate to discuss the future perspectives in this direction . according to the scenario summarized above , the snr sgr a east , located close to the gc , released about @xmath47 in form of crs about 10 kyr ago . since high energy crs
are believed to be accelerated by young snrs ( aged up to few thousands years ) , we are allowed to consider this as an impulsive injection event .
if crs are injected with a power law spectrum @xmath48 , their time dependent spatial distribution around the source is : @xcite @xmath49 where @xmath50(@xmath51 ) is the maximum ( minimum ) cr energy , @xmath52 is a diffusion length and @xmath53 the diffusion coefficient .
the cr intensity is the sum of equation [ atoyan ] and the galactic cr background .
( solid ) and @xmath54 ( dashed ) .
horizontal lines represent the observed slope ( measured value @xmath55 error ) .
dotted vertical lines delimit the emitting region .
arrows refer to the positions of the peaks in the gas distribution.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the expected excess over the background for crs with energy 3 tev is shown in figure [ fig : excess ] ( top panel ) as a function of galactic longitude .
these are the crs that produce most of the emission detected above @xmath56 in the region @xmath26 ( marked by dotted vertical lines in figure [ fig : excess ] ) .
the slope of the gamma ray emissivity at 300 gev and for a diffusion coefficient @xmath57 with @xmath58 is plotted as a solid line in the bottom panel , where it is compared with the measured one , represented by the horizontal dotted lines ( measured slope @xmath55 statistical error ) .
the arrows represent the ( projected ) position of the four prominent peaks in the gas density distribution .
if the total gas mass is concentrated at these locations and if projection effects in the gas distribution do not play an important role , the spectral slope of the emissivity should roughly represent the observed slope also .
the results in figure [ fig : excess ] can be interpreted as follows . within roughly one diffusion length
, the gamma ray spectrum hardens with the distance from the source .
this is because higher energy crs occupy a larger volume of space around the source , and thus the low energy emission is progressively suppressed at larger and larger distances . on the other hand , at distances
much larger than one diffusion length , the cr excess vanishes and the steep spectrum characteristic of the cr background is recovered .
though these calculations are far too crude , they might still serve to estimate the order of magnitude of the expected spectral variations within the emitting region . from figure
[ fig : excess ] one sees that variations of the order of @xmath59 are expected for a diffusion coefficient with slope @xmath58 .
a stronger dependency on energy would produce more pronounced variations , as illustrated by the dashed line which refers to @xmath60 .
values of @xmath61 significantly larger than 0.3 would require a harder injection spectrum of crs in order to preserve the observed slope in gamma rays .
such variations in the slope of the emission , if detected , would support the scenario of a localized injection of crs close to the gc and provide better constraints on the diffusion coefficient .
complementary studies of the three dimensional distribution of the gas in the region are also needed in order to control projection effects .
w28 is a snr in its radiative phase of evolution , located at a distance of @xmath62 , in a region rich of dense molecular gas .
gamma ray emission has been detected from the surroundings of w28 both at tev @xcite and gev energies @xcite , by hess , fermi , and agile , respectively .
the tev emission correlates quite well with the position of three massive ( @xmath63 ) mcs , one of which is interacting with the north - eastern part of the shell ( and corresponds to the tev source hess j1801 - 233 ) , and the other two being located to the south of the snr ( tev sources hess j1800 - 240 a and b ) .
let us assume that this gamma ray emission is the result of hadronic interactions of crs that have been accelerated at the snr and then escaped in the surrounding medium.@xcite in this scenario , the distribution of runaway crs around the snr is still given by equation [ atoyan ] .
a diffusion coefficient @xmath64 is assumed , where @xmath65 represents possible deviations with respect to the average diffusion coefficient in the galaxy .
equation [ atoyan ] tells us that , up to a distance equal to the diffusion radius @xmath66 , the spatial distribution of crs around the source is roughly constant , and given by @xmath67 . on the other hand ,
the observed gamma ray flux from each one of the mcs is : @xmath68 . by using the definitions of @xmath69 and @xmath66 we can finally write the approximate equation , valid within a distance @xmath66 from the snr : @xmath70 estimates
can be obtained from observations for all the physical quantities in equation [ eq : w28 ] except for the cr acceleration efficiency @xmath71 and the diffusion coefficient @xmath72 . by fitting the tev data we can thus attempt to constrain a combination of these two parameters ( namely @xmath73 ) . given all the uncertainties above
, our results have to be interpreted as a proof of concept of the fact that gamma ray observations can serve as tools to estimate the diffusion coefficient .
more detections of snr / mc associations are needed in order to check whether the scenario described here applies to a whole class of objects and not only to a test - case as w28 .
future observations from the cherenkov telescope array will most likely solve this issue .
figure [ fig : w28 ] shows a simultaneous fit to the hess data for the three massive mcs in the w28 region , obtained by setting @xmath74 .
this implies that the normalized diffusion coefficient @xmath65 has to be much smaller than 1 for any reasonable value of @xmath75 .
for example , an acceleration efficiency @xmath76 corresponds to @xmath77 , which in turn gives a diffusion distance for tev particles of @xmath78 .
this means that the results in figure [ fig : w28 ] are valid if the physical ( not projected ) distances between the mcs and the snrs do not significantly exceed @xmath66 .
small values of the diffusion coefficient have been also proposed in ref . .
note that , since we are considering gamma rays in a quite narrow energy band around @xmath79 tev , we are actually constraining the diffusion coefficient of crs with energy @xmath80 tev . with some caveats
@xcite , observations in the gev range might be used to constrain the diffusion coefficient down to gev particle energies .
the snr ic443 has an estimated age of @xmath81 , explosion energy of @xmath82 , and distance @xmath83.@xcite it has been detected at both gev @xcite and tev @xcite energies .
a power law fit to the tev emission is : @xmath84 .
observations of the co line indicate that about @xmath85 of molecular gas are present in the region .
@xcite though the gev emission might be explained as the emission from shocked clouds,@xcite this scenario can not account for the very high energy crs that originate the tev photons .
if these photons are produced by runaway crs we can attempt to estimate the diffusion coefficient , as done for w28 .
if the tev radiation is produced in a mc of mass @xmath86 , then from equation [ barometer ] we can infer an excess in the intensty of multi - tev crs of the order of @xmath87 . if these particles had time to diffuse up to a distance @xmath66 , their total ( integrated over volume ) energy is @xmath88 ( see equation [ atoyan ] ) .
this number has to be multiplied by @xmath89 to account for the extension of the spectrum of crs injected by the snr and then equated to @xmath90 .
this gives ( very roughly ) a diffusion coefficient for multi - tev crs of @xmath91 .
this is , again , much smaller than the average diffusion coefficient in the galaxy , @xcite and corresponds to @xmath92 .
other snr / mc associations detected in tev gamma rays that would deserve attention include ctb 37a , hess j1745 - 303 , and w51 .
@xcite the approach described here might now be extended to the gev range , where several snr / mc associations are being detected by fermi.@xcite the cygnus region , rich of dense gas and detected at multi - tev energies , also promises to be an ideal region of the sky for this kind of studies .
mcs , when detected in gamma rays , can serve as probes of the cr intensity throughout the galaxy .
if they are located close to cr sources , the intensity of the gamma ray emission might impose constraints on the local diffusion coefficient . in at least one case ( snr w28 )
, preliminary evidence has been reported for a significant suppression of the diffusion coefficient with respect to the average galactic one .
this suppression might be the result of an enhancement in the magnetic turbulence due to the streaming of crs away from the source .
observations with future facilities such as the cherenkov telescope array will conclusively test the feasibility and reliability of the approach to constrain cr diffusion that has been presented here .
100 a.m. hillas , _ j. phys .
phys . _ * 31 * , 95 ( 2005 ) a.r .
bell , _ mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . _ * 182 * , 147 ( 1978 ) f. aharonian , et al . , _ rep .
phys . _ * 71 * , 096901 ( 2008 ) l.oc .
drury , et al .
, _ astron .
_ * 287 * , 959 ( 1994 ) d. c. ellison , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 712 * , 287 ( 2010 ) v.s .
berezinskii , et al .
1990 , _ astrophysics of cosmic rays _
( amsterdam : north - holland ) r. kulsrud , w.p .
pearce , _ astrophys .
j. _ * 156 * , 445 ( 1969 ) a.j .
farmer , p. goldreich , _ astrophys .
j. _ * 604 * , 671 ( 2004 ) v.s .
ptuskin , et al . ,
space res . _
* 42 * , 486 ( 2008 ) t. montmerle , _ astrophys . j. _ * 231 * , 95 ( 1979 ) m. cass , j.a .
paul , _ astrophys .
j. _ * 237 * , 236 ( 1980 ) f.a .
aharonian , a. atoyan , _ astron .
astrophys . _ * 309 * , 917 ( 1996 ) s. gabici , f.a .
aharonian , _ astrophys . j. _ * 665 * , l131 ( 2007 ) s. gabici , et al . ,
_ mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . _ * 396 * , 1629 ( 2009 ) for a discussion on cr exclusion from mcs see : j. skilling , a.w .
strong , _ astron .
_ * 53 * , 253 ( 1976 ) ; s. gabici , et al . ,
_ astrophys .
space sci .
_ * 309 * , 365 ( 2007 ) ; r.j .
protheroe , et al . ,
_ mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . _ * 390 * , 683 ( 2008 ) k. nakamura et al .
( particle data group ) , _ j. phys .
g _ * 37 * , 075021 ( 2010 ) t.m .
dame , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 547 * , 792 ( 2001 ) m.r .
issa , a.w .
wolfendale , _ nature _ * 292 * , 430 ( 1981 ) f.a .
aharonian , _ astrphys .
space sci . _
* 180 * , 305 ( 1991 ) s. casanova , et al . , _ pub .
japan _ * 62 * , 769 ( 2010 ) a.w .
strong , et al . , _ astron .
astrophys . _ * 207 * , 1 ( 1988 ) s.d .
hunter , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 481 * , 205 ( 1997 ) a.a .
abdo , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 710 * , 133 ( 2010 ) f.a .
aharonian , et al .
, _ nature _ * 439 * , 695 ( 2006 ) d.r .
ballantyne , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 657 * , l13 ( 2007 ) a.d .
erlykin , a. wolfendale , _ j. phys .
g : nucl . part .
phys . _ * 34 * , 1813 ( 2007 ) s. dimitrakoudis , et al .
, _ astropart .
phys . _ * 31 * , 13 ( 2009 ) m. tsuboi , et al .
, _ astrophys .
_ * 120 * , 1 ( 1999 ) ; m.j .
reid , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 705 * , 1548 ( 2009 ) ; g. ponti , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 714 * , 732 ( 2010 ) f.a .
aharonian , et al .
, _ astron .
astrophys . _ * 481 * , 401 ( 2008 ) a.a .
abdo , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 718 * , 348 ( 2010 ) a. giuliani , et al .
, _ astron .
astrophys . _ * 516 * , l11 ( 2010 ) s. gabici , et al . , to appear in the proc .
of sf2a-2010
arxiv:1009.5291 y. fujita , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 707 * , l179 ( 2009 ) h. li , y. chen , _ mon.not .
r. astron .
_ , in press - arxiv:1009.0894 y. ohira , et al . , _ mon . not .
r. astron .
_ , in press - arxiv:1007.4869 d.f .
torres , et al .
, _ mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . _ * 387 * , l59 ( 2008 ) a.a .
abdo , et al .
, _ astrophys . j. _ * 712 * , 459 ( 2010 ) j. albert , et al . , _ astrophys
. j. _ * 664 * , l87 ( 2007 ) y. uchiyama , et al .
, arxiv:1008.1840 f.a .
aharonian , et al .
, _ astron .
astrophys . _ * 483 * , 509 ( 2008 ) ; _ ibid .
_ , * 490 * , 685 ( 2008 ) ; a. fiasson , et al .
2009 , proc .
xliv rencontres de moriond , p. 81
d. castro , p. slane , _ astrophys .
j. _ * 717 * , 372 ( 2010 ) a.a .
abdo , et al .
, _ astrophys .
j. _ * 688 * , 1078 ( 2008 ) | observations of molecular clouds in the gamma ray domain provide us with a tool to study the distribution of cosmic rays in the galaxy .
this is because cosmic rays can penetrate molecular clouds , undergo hadronic interactions in the dense gas , and produce neutral pions that in turn decay into gamma rays .
the detection of this radiation allows us to estimate the spectrum and intensity of cosmic rays at the cloud s position .
remarkably , this fact can be used to constrain the cosmic ray diffusion coefficient at specific locations in the galaxy .
galactic cosmic rays ( crs ) are believed to be accelerated by supernova remnants ( snrs).@xcite the main ( but not conclusive ) arguments supporting this idea are the fact that snrs can provide the total power required to maintain the galactic cr population , and the belief that an efficient acceleration mechanism , diffusive shock acceleration @xcite , operates in these objects .
the detection of some snrs in tev gamma rays @xcite , expected if they indeed are the sources of crs @xcite , also supports this scenario , though the emission might have a leptonic origin and not be related to the acceleration of crs .
@xcite besides the total cr power of the galaxy , a theory of cr origin must also explain the spectrum , isotropy , and chemical composition of crs.@xcite this requires a thorough knowledge not only of the nature of cr sources , but also of the way in which crs propagate in the galaxy .
this is because the observed properties of crs results from the equilibrium between the injection rate of crs from sources and their diffusive escape from the galaxy
. measurements of the amount of spallation suffered by crs allow us to infer the average residence time of a cr of energy @xmath0 in the galaxy as @xmath1 , with @xmath2 .
if @xmath3 is the length a cr has to move away from its source before escaping the galaxy ( i.e. the galaxy s thickness ) , then the diffusion coefficient reads : @xmath4 .
however , this has to be intended as the average diffusion coefficient in the galaxy , and local variations ( both in time and space ) might exist .
in particular , the diffusion coefficient might be suppressed close to cr sources .
this is because crs can excite magnetic turbulence while streaming away from their acceleration site .
this would enhance the scattering rate of cr themselves and thus reduce the diffusion coefficient @xcite .
the problem of estimating , on theoretical grounds , the diffusion coefficient around cr sources is far from being solved , mainly because of its intrinsic non - linearity and because various mechanisms might damp the cr generated waves and thus affect the way in which crs diffuse @xcite . in principle , gamma ray observations can provide us with constraints on the diffusion coefficient close to cr sources .
once escaped from their sources , crs undergo hadronic interactions with the surrounding gas and produce gamma rays .
the characteristics of such radiation ( in particular its spectrum and intensity as a function of the time elapsed since crs escaped the source ) depend on the value of the diffusion coefficient that can thus be constrained , if a reliable model for cr acceleration at the source is available .
the presence of massive molecular clouds ( mcs ) close to the source would enhance the gamma ray emission , making its detection more probable .
studying such radiation is of great importance not only in order to reach a better understanding of how crs diffuse , but also because its detection can provide an indirect way to identify the sources of galactic crs @xcite . |
the meticulous analysis of the cmb ( cosmic microwave background ) temperature power spectrum done by the planck mission team has casted both light and shadow on the status of the @xmath0cdm ( cosmological constant @xmath0 + cold dark matter ) cosmology . while at high multipoles ( @xmath1 the @xmath0cdm cosmology is found perfect in matching the observational data , at low multipoles ( @xmath2 ) its poor - fits has been confirmed not as numerical flukes but likely to be real @xcite .
given that the low - multipole behavior of the cmb temperature spectrum reflects the most primordial feature of the universe , the planck result along with the infamous long - standing problem associated with @xmath0 may imply the incompleteness of the @xmath0cdm cosmology , encouraging the cosmologists to search more strenuously than ever for physical alternatives .
the coupled dark energy ( cde ) models where dark energy is not the inert @xmath0 but a dynamic scalar field coupled to nonbaryonic dark matter particles @xcite have recently attained probing attention because of their capacity for accommodating several observational mysteries that the @xmath0cdm cosmology could not resolve . for instance , according to @xcite , the high-@xmath3 massive clusters regarded as extremely rare events in the @xmath0cdm universe ( e.g. , see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) are more probable to detect in the cde models .
@xcite demonstrated that the cde models can explain the observed higher degree of the misalignment between the spatial distributions of cluster galaxies and dark matter than naturally expected in the @xmath0cdm cosmology @xcite . in the work of @xcite ,
the morphological properties of the observed bullet cluster @xcite that had been found to be in a serious tension with the prediction of the @xmath0cdm cosmology @xcite were much less anomalous in cde models .
very recently , @xcite claimed that the dispute on the value of the hubble constant between the planck experiment and the hst ( hubble space telescope ) project can be ended if cde is assumed to exist .
this capacity of the cde models to alleviate the tensions posed by the observational anomalies is mainly owing to the presence of an additional long - range fifth force induced by the dark sector coupling ( the interaction between dark energy and nonbaryonic dark matter ) .
see @xcite for a comprehensive review of the cde models .
since the tight constraints put on the strength of dark sector coupling by the recent observations have sustained as viable only those cde models which are very hard to distinguish from the @xmath0cdm cosmology ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , it is necessary to develop as a powerful indicator of cde as possible for the detection of the effect of cde on the evolution of the universe .
the spatial clustering of galaxy clusters that generates collectively the cosmic web phenomenon @xcite has been regarded as one of the most powerful indicators of dynamic dark energy . as
the dark sector coupling would affect not only the strength of the large - scale clustering but also its degree of anisotropy , the cosmic web must take on different pattern in the presence of cde . the anisotropic clustering of clusters is well manifested by the elongated filamentary shapes of the rich superclusters which correspond to the densest section of the cosmic web . in the literatures which studied the superclusters and their morphological properties , the shapes of the superclusters were measured by various different algorithms such as percolation , ellipsoid - fitting , friends - of - friends , minkowski functional and etc .
( e.g. , * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the general consensus of those previous works was that no matter what algorithm was used , the richer superclusters appear to have more filamentary shapes .
recently , @xcite noted that the shape of a richest supercluster located in the highly overdense region is best described as a `` multi - branch '' filament consisting of the main stem and several branches . assuming that the degree of the straightness of the supercluster main stems would depend strongly on the dynamics of dark energy , we speculate that in cde models the main stems of rich superclusters would be less straight , having shorter spatial extents compared with the @xmath0cdm case , due to the effect of the fifth force . to quantitatively inspect this speculation , we utilize the data from the high - resolution n - body simulations ran for various cde models as well as for the @xmath0cdm model .
the upcoming chapters are organized as follows : in section 2 , we briefly review the cde scenarios and describe how the spatial extents of the superclusters found in the n - body data are determined . in section 3 , we show how the degree of the supercluster straightness depends on the strength of dark sector coupling and how the difference in the supercluster straightness between the cde and the @xmath0cdm cases changes with redshifts . in section 5 ,
we summarize the key results and draw a final conclusion .
the codecs stands for the coupled dark energy cosmological simulations performed by @xcite for several different cde models as well as for the standard @xmath0cdm model with @xmath4 cdm particles and the same number of baryon particles in a periodic box of linear size @xmath5gpc .
the codecs has the mass - resolution of @xmath6 and @xmath7 where @xmath8 and @xmath9 represent the mass of each cdm and baryon particle at the present epoch , respectively .
as conventionally done , a bound dark halo was identified in the codecs suite as a friends - of - friends ( fof ) group in which the component particles are all within the linking length of @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the mean particle separation @xcite . in the codecs project
the initial conditions of all models were set to be consistent with the wmap7 values @xcite . for the cde models the normalization amplitude of the density power spectrum , @xmath12 , has the same value as the @xmath0cdm case at the moment of the last - scattering , while the other key parameters have the wmap7 values at @xmath13 . for a full description of the codecs ,
see @xcite . among several target cde models of the codecs ,
the following four models are considered for our analysis : exp002 , exp003 , exp008e3 and sugra003 . in the first two models ( exp002 and exp003 ) where the dynamics of a scalar field cde , @xmath14 , is governed by an exponential potential of @xmath15 with @xmath16 @xcite , the coupling parameter @xmath17 that quantifies the strength of the dark sector coupling has a positive constant value of @xmath18 and @xmath19 , respectively . in the third model ( exp008e3 ) where the cde potential has the same exponential shape , the coupling strength is no longer a constant but depends exponentially on @xmath14 as @xmath20 . in the fourth model ( sugra003 )
where the cde evolves according to the supergravity potential of @xmath21 @xcite , @xmath17 has a negative constant value of @xmath22 @xcite .
the amplitudes of the linear density power spectrum at @xmath13 have the values of @xmath23 and @xmath24 at @xmath13 for the exp002 , exp003 , exp008e3 and sugra003 models , respectively . for comparison
, we also consider the @xmath0cdm model included in the codecs project for which @xmath25 . for a detailed explanation of the cde models considered in the codecs ,
see @xcite . from the dark halo catalogs from the codecs at @xmath13 , we first select only those cluster halos whose masses @xmath26
satisfy the condition of @xmath27 for each model .
following the conventional scheme ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , we identify the superclusters as the fof groups of the closely located clusters among the selected ones within the linking length , @xmath28 , equal to one third of the mean separation of the selected clusters , @xmath29 , as @xmath30 .
figure [ fig : mf ] plots the number densities of the selected clusters and the identified superclusters per unit volume for five cosmological models at @xmath13 in the top and bottom panels , respectively .
as can be seen , the selected clusters of each model exhibit a different mass spectrum .
this result indicates that the selected clusters of each model has a different mean separation @xmath29 , which has been in fact properly taken into account when the superclusters are identified as fof groups of the linked clusters within the distance of @xmath28 .
note that the massive clusters and superclusters are most abundant in the exp003 model , while the sugra003 model displays almost the same mass distributions as the @xmath0cdm case . choosing only those rich superclusters which have three or more member clusters
, we apply the minimal spanning tree ( mst ) technique to dig out their filamentary patterns for each cosmological model .
it was @xcite who for the first time used the mst algorithm to study systematically the local galaxy distribution .
afterwards , the mst algorithm has been refined and modified by several authors to investigate the geometrical properties of the large scale structure with it ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
it may be worth explaining here why we choose the mst algorithm for our analysis rather than more recently developed algorithms such as the skeleton @xcite , the multiscale morphology filter @xcite , the nexus @xcite , and so forth , all of which are believed to be more accurate and efficient in tracing the cosmic web .
the number one reason is that the application of those more recent and more elaborate algorithms require us to know the underlying dark matter distribution ( or density / velocity fields ) unlike the mst algorithm for which only the halo distributions are necessary . given that the dark matter distribution from the codecs is not publicly available , we had to find an algorithm based only on the halo distributions .
of course , it is still possible in principle to reconstruct the density / velocity fields from the codecs halo catalogs and then to apply those more improved algorithms to the reconstructed density / velocity fields .
but , our ultimate goal is not to model as accurately as possible the supercluster shapes but to see if and how the supercluster straightness depends on the background cosmology .
thus , we belive that the reconstruction of the density fields of all five models is beyond the scope of this paper . in fact , the mst which treats each member cluster as a point ( node ) without weighing it by its mass must be the most optimal ( and the most practical ) algorithm to achieve our goal since we would like to separate the cosmology dependence of the supercluster straightness from that of the supercluster mass which is anyway hard to estimate accurately in real observation .
after constructing the mst of each supercluster , we extract its main stem by pruning off its minor branches , under the assumption that the main stem of a supercluster mst corresponds to its most prominent filamentary part .
since we confine the mst reconstruction procedure to the member cluster distribution inside each supercluster , we only prune a supercluster mst without separating it into smaller filamentary parts ( c.f .
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
figure [ fig : prune ] illustrates in the two - dimensional projected space how the main stem of a supercluster mst is determined through pruning process at @xmath13 for the @xmath0cdm model , displaying how the minor branches are repeatedly cleared off from the main stem of a supercluster mst . as @xcite called the main stem of a mst out of the galaxy distribution as the `` backbone of the large - scale structure '' , hereafter we also call the main stem of a supercluster _ the supercluster spine_. figure [ fig : pnode ] plots the number distribution of the member clusters of those rich supercluster spines consisting of three or more nodes for the five models at @xmath13 .
as can be seen , the distributions of the node numbers ( @xmath31 of the supercluster spines for the five models are very similar to one another except for the numerical fluctuations in the large-@xmath32 section , even though each model has a different mass distribution ( see figure [ fig : mf ] ) .
an acute reader might concern about a possibility that in case of a more or less spherically shaped supercluster the pruning process would remove its most massive member from the main stem .
we have investigated how probable this case is for each model and found that the fraction of all supercluster msts occupied by those cases is less @xmath33 for every model , having very negligible effect on the final result .
table [ tab : mmass ] lists the numbers of those rich superclusters whose spines consist of three or more nodes and the percentage of the supercluster spines from which the most massive member clusters are pruned away at @xmath13 for the five models .
figure [ fig : spinesm ] plots the mean specific mass , @xmath34 , of the rich supercluster spines vs. the cosmological model .
as can be seen , the mean specific mass is the highest for the exp003 case , indicating that the superclusters tend to have higher masses when the amplitude of the density power spectrum , @xmath12 , has a higher value .
using only those rich superclusters whose spines consist of three or more nodes , we determine their sizes , @xmath35 . although a detailed explanation about how to measure the size of a pruned mst is provided in @xcite ( see also , * ? ? ?
* ) , we also briefly describe here the procedure to estimate the size of each supercluster spine to make this paper self - contained .
let the comoving cartesian coordinates of all nodes belonging to a supercluster spine be in range of @xmath36 , respectively .
the size , @xmath35 , of a supercluster spine is now estimated as @xmath37^{1/2}$ ] , which quantifies effectively how extended the supercluster spine is in the three dimensional space .
figure [ fig : size_mst ] illustrates how the size @xmath35 of a supercluster spine is measured at @xmath13 for the @xmath0cdm case in the two - dimensional projected space .
obviously the size of a supercluster spine increases with the number of nodes . when the number of nodes @xmath32 is fixed , however , the more straight superclusters should have larger sizes . to quantify its degree of the straightness of a supercluster spine
, we define the specific size @xmath38 as the size per node , @xmath39 .
figure [ fig : straight ] shows the projected images of three randomly chosen supercluster spines with three different specific sizes at @xmath13 for the @xmath0cdm case .
as can be seen , those supercluster spines with larger specific sizes look more straight , demonstrating that the specific size of a supercluster spine is an effective indicator of its straightness .
now , we estimate the mean value of @xmath38 averaged over those superclusters whose spines have @xmath40 for each cosmological model .
figure [ fig : mssize ] plots the mean specific sizes , @xmath41 , versus the five cosmological models at @xmath13 .
the errors @xmath42 are calculated as the one standard deviation in the measurement of the mean value @xmath43^{1/2}$ ] . as can be seen , in the cde models the supercluster spines tend to have smaller specific sizes .
in other words , the superclusters in models with cde are less straight .
the @xmath0cdm case exhibits the highest value of @xmath38 while the lowest value is found for the sugra003 case .
as can be seen , the difference in @xmath38 between the @xmath0cdm and the sugra003 cases is the most significant .
there is a clear trend that the mean value of @xmath38 decreases with increasing coupling strength for the cases that cde has a constant constant coupling ( exp002 and exp003 ) while the exp008e3 case does not show a significant difference in @xmath38 from the @xmath0cdm case .
it is important to note that the cosmology dependence of @xmath41 is obviously different from that of @xmath44 by comparing the result shown in figure [ fig : spinesm ] with that in figure [ fig : mssize ] .
the mean specific mass of the supercluster spines in the sugra003 model turns out to be very similar to the @xmath0cdm case , while the two models show significant difference in the mean specific size of the supercluster spines .
this result implies that the difference in the supercluster mass existent among the models should not be the cause of the detected overall trend between the cde models and the mean specific sizes of the supercluster spines .
the result shown in figure [ fig : mssize ] reveals that the dark sector coupling plays a role in diminishing the degree of the straightness of the superclusters .
our interpretation is as follows : the accelerating expansion of the universe caused by the anti - gravitational action of dark energy sharpens the cosmic web while the gravitational clustering of clusters tends to blunt it since the former ( latter ) increases the relative dominance of the anisotropic ( isotropic ) stress on the supercluster scales .
the competition between the two driving forces determines the degree of the straightness of the superclusters which reflects how sharp the cosmic web is in the universe . in the cde models ,
the additional attractive fifth force with long range helps gravity blunt the cosmic web on the large scale , reducing the specific sizes of the supercluster spines , which is why the stronger dark sector coupling makes the supercluster spines less straight .
the lowest value of @xmath41 found for the sugra003 case may be also interpreted as follows .
the degree of the supercluster straightness is also affected by the peculiar velocity perturbation .
the large peculiar velocity perturbation tends to sharpen the cosmic web .
a good analogy can be found in a warm dark matter ( wdm ) model where the peculiar velocity perturbation of dm particles is much larger than for the cdm case .
@xcite clearly demonstrated by using a high - resolution hydrodynamic simulation that a wdm model produces a sharper cosmic web due to its larger velocity perturbation . given this analogy
, one can expect that in the cde models with smaller velocity perturbation the superclusters must become less straight . as shown in @xcite and @xcite ,
the velocity perturbation of the sugra003 model is as large as that of the exp003 case before @xmath45 but suddenly changes its tendency , dropping rapidly below that of the @xmath0cdm model at lower redshifts ( see figure 7 in * ? ? ?
therefore , at present epoch the velocity perturbation in the sugra003 model is even smaller than that of the @xmath0cdm case , which leads to blunt the cosmic web and to diminish the degree of the straightness of the supercluster spines .
as for the exp002 and exp003 model with constant coupling , the interplay between the dark sector coupling and the larger velocity perturbation determines the decrement in the degree of the supercluster straightness : the presence of the dark sector coupling tends to undermine the degree of the supercluster straightness while the large velocity perturbation relative to the @xmath0cdm case plays a role in straightening the superclusters . our result shown in figure
[ fig : mssize ] indicates that the former effect should be more dominant . to investigate how the supercluster straightness evolves for each model
, we repeat the whole process at three higher redshifts : @xmath46 .
figure [ fig : mssize_z ] plots the mean specific sizes of the supercluster spines as a function of @xmath3 for five different models .
as can be seen , for all of the five cosmological models , the specific sizes of the supercluster spines increase with redshifts .
it can be well understood by the fact that at higher redshifts the superclusters obtained as fof groups from the mass - limited cluster sample ( with the same mass threshold of @xmath47 ) correspond to more linear regimes where the clustering of clusters is not so strong .
as can be also seen in figure [ fig : mssize_z ] , at all redshifts , the @xmath0cdm case is found to have the largest mean specific sizes of the supercluster spines .
the strongest evolution in @xmath41 is found for the sugra003 case , while the exp003 shows the weakest evolution .
it is also interesting to see that at higher redshifts the exp008e3 case differs significantly in @xmath41 from the @xmath0cdm case . as shown in @xcite , the velocity perturbation in the exp008e3 model increases exponentially relative to the @xmath0cdm case at lower redshifts .
therefore , the significant difference in @xmath41 between the exp008e3 and the @xmath0cdm case at high redshifts must be due to the smaller velocity perturbation of the exp008e3 at higher redshifts than at the present epoch , which is consistent with our interpretation that the larger ( smaller ) velocity perturbation functions for ( against ) sharpening the cosmic web . the result shown in [ fig : mssize_z ] also shows that at higher redshifts the differences in @xmath41 between the cde and the @xmath0cdm cases become more significant . as mentioned in the above , the high-@xmath3 superclusters are more linear objects and thus they are more vulnerable to the long - range fifth force in cde models
. the crucial implication of this result is that the redshift evolution of @xmath41 must be a powerful complimentary probe of cde .
although the dependence of the `` filamentarity '' of the rich superclusters on the initial conditions of the universe was already noted by several authors , ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the supercluster shape distribution was not seriously considered as an efficient cosmological probe mainly because the rich filament - like superclusters were regarded too rare to provide good - number statistics .
however , the recently available large datasets from the full sky galaxy surveys and the high - resolution simulations have allowed us to explore systematically what a new window the noticeable filamentary shapes of the rich supercluster can open on the early universe . in this paper
we have investigated how the presence of the dark sector coupling in cde models changes the intrinsic clustering pattern of the clusters in the supercluster environments by utilizing the group catalogs from the codecs . to single out the effect of the dark sector coupling on the clustering of supercluster clusters from the nonlinear growth of the large - scale density field , instead of dealing with the overall filamentary shapes of the superclusters , we focus only on the straightness of the main stems ( i.e. , spines ) of the minimal spanning trees constructed out of the supercluster clusters .
the degree of the straightness of a supercluster has been quantified by the specific size of its spine ( spatial extent of the spine per member cluster ) .
it has been finally shown that the stronger dark sector coupling makes the superclusters less straight and that in the presence of cde governed by the supergravity potential @xcite the superclusters are least straight . the difference in the mean specific size of the supercluster spines between the @xmath0cdm and the viable cde models has been found to become more significant at higher redshifts .
our results have been physically explained as follows .
the attractive fifth force in the cde models helps the large - scale gravitational clustering blunt the cosmic web while the anti - gravitational action of dark energy sharpens it .
since the supercluster straightness depends on how sharp the cosmic web is , the cde models have less straight superclusters than the @xmath0cdm case .
the degree of the supercluster straightness also depends on the peculiar velocity perturbation of clusters .
the large peculiar velocity perturbation of clusters functions against blunting the cosmic web , contributing to the degree of the supercluster straightness . at higher redshifts ,
the superclusters for both of the cde and the @xmath0cdm models are more straight since they correspond to more linear regimes where the isotropic stress is less dominant .
the sharp increase of the supercluster straightness with redshifts found in the supergravity model is closely related to the bouncing behavior of dark energy equation of state in the supergravity model @xcite .
finally , we conclude that the redshift evolution of the supercluster straightness should in principle become a complimentary new test of cde . for a practical test of cde with the evolution of the supercluster straightness
, however , it will be necessary to deal with the superclusters identified not in real space but in redshift space .
if the host superclusters are elongated along the line - of - sight directions , the cluster bulk motions along the supercluster major axes would cause significant uncertainty on the measurements of the supercluster sizes .
furthermore , the effect of the redshift distortion caused by the cluster bulk motion on the supercluster straightness is likely related to the strength of dark sector coupling since in the cde models the cluster bulk motions must be more active ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
. it will be definitely important to account for the redshift distortion effect on the supercluster straightness and to examine how strongly the effect depends on the strength of dark sector coupling .
the other thing that it will be worth exploring is the robustness of our result against the algorithm to identify the filamentary structures in the cosmic web . in the current work
, the mst algorithm has been exclusively utilized to determine the most prominent filamentary part of the richest section of the cosmic web .
but , as mentioned in section 2 , there exist several more recently developed algorithms which are expected to trace more rigorously the linear patterns of the cosmic web on the scales beyond the superclusters @xcite .
if a consistent result be drawn even with a different algorithm , it would confirm strongly the usefulness of the supercluster straightness as a probe of coupled dark energy .
our future work is in this direction .
we thank an anonymous referee for his / her help comments which helped us improve the original manuscript .
this research was supported by basic science research program through the national research foundation of korea(nrf ) funded by the ministry of education ( no .
2013004372 ) and partially by the research grant from the national research foundation of korea to the center for galaxy evolution research ( no .
2010 - 0027910 ) .
akahori , t. , & yoshikawa , k. 2012 , , 64 , 12 amendola , l. 2000 , , 62 , 043511 amendola , l. 2004 , , 69 , 103524 amendola , l. & tsujikawa , s. 2010 , dark energy ( cambridge university press : cambridge ) aragn - calvo , m. a. , van de weygaert , r. , & jones , b. j. t. 2010 , , 408 , 2163 baldi , m. , & viel , m. 2010 , , 409 , l89 baldi , m. , pettorino , v. , robbers , g. , & springel , v. 2010 , , 403 , 1684 baldi , m. , & pettorino , v. 2011 , , 412 , l1 baldi , m. , lee , j. , & macci , a. v. 2011 , , 732 , 112 baldi , m. 2011a , , 411 , 1077 baldi , m. 2011b , , 414 , 116 baldi , m. 2012 , , 420 , 430 baldi , m. 2012 , , 422 , 1028 barrow , j. d. , bhavsar , s. p. , & sonoda , d. h. 1985 , , 216 , 17 basilakos , s. , plionis , m. , & rowan - robinson , m. 2001 , , 323 , 47 basilakos , s. 2003 , , 344 , 602 basilakos , s. , plionis , m. , yepes , g. , gottlber , s. , & turchaninov , v. 2006 , , 365 , 539 bean , r. , flanagan , . . ,
laszlo , i. , & trodden , m. 2008 , , 78 , 123514 benson , a. j. 2005 , , 358 , 551 bond , j. r. , kofman , l. , & pogosyan , d. 1996 , , 380 , 603 brax , p. h. , & martin , j. 1999 , physics letters b , 468 , 40 cautun , m. , van de weygaert , r. , & jones , b. j. t. 2013 , , 429 , 1286 clowe , d. , gonzalez , a. , & markevitch , m. 2004 , , 604 , 596 clowe , d. , brada , m. , gonzalez , a. h. , markevitch , m. , randall , s. w. , jones , c. , & zaritsky , d. 2006 , , 648 , l109 colberg , j. m. 2007 , , 375 , 337 davis , m. , efstathiou , g. , frenk , c. s. , & white , s. d. m. 1985 , , 292 , 371 dekel , a. , west , m. j. , & aarseth , s. j. 1984 , , 279 , 1 doroshkevich , a. g. , tucker , d. l. , fong , r. , turchaninov , v. , & lin , h. 2001 , , 322 , 369 einasto , m. , saar , e. , liivamgi , l. j. , et al .
2007 , , 476 , 697 einasto , m. , liivamgi , l. j. , tago , e. , et al . 2011 , , 532 , a5 farrar , g. r. , & rosen , r. a. 2007 , physical review letters , 98 , 171302 gao , l. , & theuns , t. 2007 , science , 317 , 1527 jaaniste , j. , tago , e. , einasto , m. , et al .
1998 , , 336 , 35 jee , m. j. , dawson , k. s. , hoekstra , h. , et al .
2011 , , 737 , 59 ho , s. , bahcall , n. , & bode , p. 2006
, , 647 , 8 kasun , s. f. , & evrard , a. e. 2005 , , 629 , 781 kolokotronis , v. , basilakos , s. , & plionis , m. 2002 , , 331 , 1020 komatsu , e. , et al .
2011 , , 192 , 18 krzewina , l. g. , & saslaw , w. c. 1996 , , 278 , 869 lee , j. 2006 , , 643 , 724 lee , j. , & park , d. 2006 , , 652 , 1 lee , j. , & park , d. 2009 , , 696 , l10 lee , j. , hahn , o. , & porciani , c. 2009 , , 705 , 1469 lee , j. , & komatsu , e. 2010 , , 718 , 60 lee , j. 2010 , arxiv:1008.4620 lee , j. , & baldi , m. 2012 , , 747 , 45 lee , j. 2012 , , 751 , 153 lim , s. , & lee , j. 2012 , arxiv:1201.1382 lucchin , f. , & matarrese , s. 1985 , , 32 , 1316 macci , a. v. , quercellini , c. , mainini , r. , amendola , l. , & bonometto , s. a. 2004 , , 69 , 123516 mainini , r. , & bonometto , s. 2006 , , 74 , 043504 mangano , g. , miele , g. , & pettorino , v. 2003 , modern physics letters a , 18 , 831 markevitch , m. , gonzalez , a. h. , david , l. , vikhlinin , a. , murray , s. , forman , w. , jones , c. , & tucker , w. 2002 , , 567 , l27 markevitch , m. , gonzalez , a. h. , clowe , d. , vikhlinin , a. , forman , w. , jones , c. , murray , s. , & tucker , w. 2004 , , 606 , 819 markevitch , m. , govoni , f. , brunetti , g. , & jerius , d. 2005 , , 627 , 733 mastropietro , c. , & burkert , a. 2008 , , 389 , 967 oguri , m. , takahashi , k. , ichiki , k. , & ohno , h. 2004 , arxiv : astro - ph/0410145 oguri , m. , takada , m. , okabe , n. , & smith , g. p. 2010
, , 405 , 2215 park , d. , & lee , j. 2007 , physical review letters , 98 , 081301 park , d. , & lee , j. 2009 , , 397 , 2163 pettorino , v. , & baccigalupi , c. 2008 , , 77 , 103003 plionis , m. , valdarnini , r. , & jing , y .- p . 1992 , , 398 , 12 planck collaboration , ade , p. a. r. , aghanim , n. , et al .
2013 , arxiv:1303.5076 planck collaboration , ade , p. a. r. , aghanim , n. , et al .
2013 , arxiv:1303.5075 ratra , b. , & peebles , p. j. e. 1988 , , 37 , 3406 salvatelli , v. , & marchini , a. 2013 , arxiv:1304.7119 sousbie , t. , pichon , c. , colombi , s. , novikov , d. , & pogosyan , d. 2008 , , 383 , 1655 springel , v. , & farrar , g. r. 2007 , , 380 , 911 thompson , r. , & nagamine , k. 2012 , , 419 , 3560 wen , z. l. , han , j. l. , & liu , f. s. 2010 , , 407 , 533 west , m. j. 1989 , , 347 , 610 wetterich , c. 1988 , nuclear physics b , 302 , 668 wetterich , c. 1995 , , 301 , 321 wintergerst , n. , & pettorino , v. 2010 , , 82 , 103516 wray , j. j. , bahcall , n. a. , bode , p. , boettiger , c. , & hopkins , p. f. 2006 , , 652 , 907 | the galaxy clusters exhibit noticeably anisotropic pattern in their clustering , which is vividly manifested by the presence of rich filament - like superclusters .
the more anisotropic the clustering of galaxy clusters is , the more straight the rich filament - like superclusters become . given that the degree of the anisotropy in the largest - scale clustering depends sensitively on the nature of dark energy , the supercluster straightness may play a complimentary role in testing dynamic dark energy models . here
we focus on the coupled dark energy ( cde ) models which assume the existence of dark sector coupling between scalar field dark energy and nonbaryonic dark matter . determining the spines of the superclusters identified in the publicly available group catalogs from the codecs ( coupled dark energy cosmological simulations ) for four different cde models as well as for the @xmath0cdm model , we quantify the straightness of each supercluster as the spatial extent of its spine per member cluster where a supercluster spine represents the main stem of the minimal spanning tree constructed out of the member clusters .
it is shown that the dark sector coupling plays a role in making the supercluster less straight relative to the @xmath0cdm case and that in a cde model with supergravity potential the superclusters are least straight .
we also find that the difference in the degree of the supercluster straightness between the cde and the @xmath0cdm cases increases with redshifts .
a physical interpretation of our result as well as its cosmological implication are discussed . |
the search for supersymmetry ( susy ) @xcite plays an important rle in the experimental program at the colliders lep2 and tevatron
. it will be even more important at future colliders , e.g. an upgraded tevatron , lhc , an @xmath6 linear collider or a @xmath7 collider . therefore many phenomenological studies have been carried out in recent years ( see e.g. @xcite and references therein ) . within the supersymmetric extensions of the standard model ( sm ) the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm )
@xcite is the most investigated one .
the mssm implies that every sm fermion has two spin 0 partners called sfermions @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
in general sfermions decay according to @xmath10 where @xmath11 and @xmath12 denote neutralinos and charginos , respectively . here
we assume that the lightest neutralino is the lightest supersymmetric particle ( lsp ) .
owing to large yukawa couplings the sfermions of the third generation have a quite different phenomenology compared to those of the first two generations ( see e.g. @xcite and references therein ) .
the large yukawa couplings imply a large mixing between @xmath8 and @xmath9 and large couplings to the higgsino components of neutralinos and charginos .
this is in particular the case for the lighter top squark @xmath5 because of the large top quark mass @xcite .
the large top quark mass also implies the existence of scenarios where all two - body decay modes of @xmath5 ( e.g. @xmath13 ) are kinematically forbidden at tree - level . in these scenarios
higher order decays of @xmath5 become relevant : @xcite : @xmath14 where @xmath15 denotes @xmath16 .
in @xcite it has been shown that decays into sleptons are dominating over the decays into @xmath17 if they are kinematically allowed .
however , they have used the approximation : @xmath18 , @xmath19 ( @xmath20 ) , @xmath21 .
in @xcite it has been shown that for small @xmath22 the decay @xmath0 in general dominates over @xmath23 whereas for large @xmath22 their branching ratios can be of comparable size . in this paper
we present the complete formulas for the three - body decays which are so far missing in the literature .
we also perform a numerical analysis for the mass range of an upgraded tevatron , the lhc , and a future lepton collider including the possibility that all of the above decay channels are simultaneously open .
in particular it turns out that the inclusion of the bottom and tau yukawa couplings @xmath24 and @xmath25 is important .
this paper is organized as follows : in sect .
ii we fix our notation and give the analytical expressions for the decay amplitudes together with the relevant parts of the mssm lagrangian . in sect .
iii we present our numerical results for the branching ratios of the three - body decays in scenarios accessible either at the tevatron run ii , lhc , or a future lepton collider .
our conclusions are drawn in sect .
the analytical formulas for the squared amplitudes are listed in appendix [ appa ] , and appendix [ appb ] gives the various couplings .
in this section we fix our notation and we give the lagrangian relevant for the calculation of the decay widths .
moreover , we present the analytical formulas for the matrix elements and generic formulas for the decay widths .
the complete formulas for the latter are rather lengthy and are listed in appendix [ appa ] .
the parameters relevant for the following discussion are @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath22 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , and @xmath34 .
@xmath35 and @xmath27 are the @xmath36 and @xmath37 gaugino masses , for which we assume the gut relation @xmath38 .
@xmath29 is the parameter of the higgs superpotential , @xmath28 the mass of the pseudoscalar higgs boson , and @xmath39 where @xmath40 denotes the vacuum expectation value of the higgs doublet @xmath41 .
@xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 are soft susy breaking masses for the squarks , @xmath33 and @xmath34 are trilinear higgs squark couplings , and
@xmath42 is the generation index .
the mass matrix for sfermions in the @xmath43 basis has the following form @xcite : @xmath44 with @xmath45 and @xmath46 where @xmath47 is a generation index ( @xmath48 ) which will be suppressed in the following .
the mass eigenstates @xmath49 and @xmath50 are related to @xmath51 and @xmath52 by : @xmath53 with the eigenvalues @xmath54 the mixing angle @xmath55 is given by @xmath56 the sneutrino mass is given by : @xmath57 the part of the lagrangian , which is needed for the calculation of the three - body decay widths , is given by : @xmath58 where @xmath59 .
the various couplings are given in appendix [ appb ] .
the formula for the decay width @xmath60 has already been given in @xcite .
therefore , we give only the corresponding matrix element @xmath61 : @xmath62 v ( p_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } ) \epsilon_{\mu } ( p_w ) \nonumber \\ & & + \ , g^2 \sum^2_{j=1 } \bar u(p_b ) \left [ l^{\tilde t}_{1j } p_r + k^{\tilde t}_{1j } p_l \right ] \frac { \not \ !
p_{{\tilde \chi}^+_j } - m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } } { p_{{\tilde \chi}^+_j}^2 - m^2_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } - i m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } \gamma_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{20 mm } * \left [ o^l_{1j } { } ' p_l + o^r_{1j } { } ' p_r \right ] \gamma^{\mu } v(p_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } ) \epsilon_{\mu } ( p_w ) \nonumber \\ & & - \frac{g^2}{\sqrt2 } \bar u ( p_b ) \gamma^{\mu } p_l
\frac { \not \ ! p_t + m_t } { p_{t}^2 -m_{t}^2 - i m_t \gamma_{t } } \left [ b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } p_l + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } p_r \right ] v ( p_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } ) \epsilon_{\mu } ( p_w ) \label{eq : tfistbwchi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in @xcite also the formula for @xmath63 @xcite has been rewritten in the notation used here . in fig .
[ stbhgchi ] we show the feynman diagrams for the decay @xmath64 .
the matrix element @xmath65 for this decay is given by : @xmath66 v ( p_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } ) } { p_{{\tilde b}_j}^2 - m^2_{{\tilde b}_j } - i m_{{\tilde b}_j } \gamma_{\tilde{b}_j } } \nonumber \\ & & - \ , g^2 \sum^2_{j=1 } \frac { \bar u(p_b ) \left [ l^{\tilde t}_{1j } p_r + k^{\tilde t}_{1j } p_l \right ] [ \not \ ! p_{{\tilde \chi}^+_j } - m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } ] \left [ q^l_{1j } { } ' p_l + q^r_{1j } { } ' p_r \right ] v(p_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } ) } { p_{{\tilde \chi}^+_j}^2 - m^2_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } - i m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } \gamma_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } } \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{g^2 } { \sqrt2 m_w } \frac { \bar u ( p_b ) \left [ m_b \tan \beta p_l + m_t \cot \beta p_r \right ] [ \not \ ! p_t + m_t ] \left [ b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } p_l + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } p_r \right ] v ( p_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } ) } { p_{t}^2
-m_{t}^2 - i m_t \gamma_{t } } \nonumber \\ \label{eq : tfistbhchi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the decay width is given by @xmath67 with @xmath68 given in appendix [ appa ] .
alternatively @xmath5 can decay into sleptons : @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , and @xmath72 .
these decays are mediated through virtual charginos .
the feynman graphs are similar to the second one in fig .
[ stbhgchi ] , where one has to replace the higgs boson by a slepton and the neutralino by the corresponding lepton . note , that the decays into @xmath73 and @xmath74 are negligible because their couplings to the charginos are proportional to @xmath75 and @xmath76 , respectively .
in the case of decays into sneutrinos and leptons the matrix elements @xmath77 have the generic form : @xmath78 \left [ \not \ ! p_{{\tilde \chi}^+_j } - m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } \right ] \left [ l^{\tilde \nu_l}_{j } p_r + k^{\tilde \nu_l}_{j } p_l \right ] v(p_l ) } { p_{{\tilde \chi}^+_j}^2 - m^2_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } - i m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } \gamma_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } } , \label{eq : tfistbsneut}\end{aligned}\ ] ] whereas for the decays into sleptons and neutrinos we get : @xmath79 \left [ \not \ ! p_{{\tilde \chi}^+_j } - m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } \right ] \left [ l^{\tilde l}_{kj } p_l \right ] v(p_{\nu_l } ) } { p_{{\tilde \chi}^+_j}^2 - m^2_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } - i m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } \gamma_{\tilde{\chi}^+_j } } \ , .
\label{eq : tfistbslept}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in both cases the decay width is given by @xmath80 the explicit expressions for @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 are given in appendix [ appa ] .
in this section we present our numerical results for the branching ratios of the higher order decays of @xmath5 . here
we consider scenarios where all two - body decays at tree - level are kinematically forbidden .
we have fixed the parameters as in @xcite to avoid colour breaking minimas : we have used @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath22 , and @xmath29 as input parameters in the top squark sector . for the sbottom ( stau ) sector
we have fixed @xmath86 and @xmath87 ( @xmath88 , and @xmath89 ) as input parameters . for simplicity , we assume that the soft susy breaking parameters are equal for all generations .
note , that due to @xmath37 invariance @xmath90 appears in both up- and down - type squark mass matrices . in the sbottom ( stau )
sector the physical quantities @xmath91 , @xmath92 , and @xmath93 ( @xmath94 , @xmath95 , and @xmath96 ) obviously change with @xmath29 and @xmath22 . in fig .
[ brst3cosa](a ) and ( b ) we show the branching ratios of @xmath5 as a function of @xmath85 .
we have restricted the @xmath85 range such that @xmath97 tev to avoid color / charge breaking minima .
the parameters and physical quantities are given in tab .
[ tabbrst3cosa ] .
the slepton parameters have been chosen such that the sum of the masses of the final state particles are @xmath98 gev . in fig .
[ brst3cosa](a ) we show @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 ) + @xmath102 , and @xmath103 + @xmath104 + @xmath105 . here
we have not included the possibility of the decay @xmath106 because with this parameter set there exists no value of @xmath28 which simultaneously allows this decay and fulfills the condition @xmath107 gev @xcite ( we have used the mssm formula for the calculation of @xmath108 including 1-loop corrections as given in @xcite ) .
however , we will discuss this decay later on .
we have summed up those branching ratios for the decays into sleptons that give the same final state , for example : @xmath109 note , that in the above cases the assumption @xmath110 implies @xmath111 .
therefore , the sleptons can only decay into the corresponding lepton plus @xmath112 except for a small parameter region where the decay into @xmath113 is possible .
however , this decay is negligible due to kinematics in that region .
the branching ratios for decays into @xmath114 or @xmath115 are practically the same as those into @xmath116 or @xmath117 . for this set of parameters
@xmath100 is @xmath118 independent of @xmath85 and therefore negligible . near @xmath119 @xmath99
is almost @xmath120 because the @xmath5-@xmath121-@xmath122 coupling @xmath123 vanishes .
we have found that the decay @xmath124 is dominated by the @xmath125-quark exchange . in many cases
the interference term between @xmath125 and @xmath126 is more important than the @xmath126 exchange .
moreover , we have found that the contribution from sbottom exchange is in general negligible . in fig .
[ brst3cosa](b ) the branching ratios for the various decays into sleptons are shown . for small @xmath22 sleptons couple mainly to the gaugino components of @xmath121 .
this leads to @xmath127 because @xmath128 .
the decays into sneutrinos are preferred by kinematics while the decay into @xmath129 is suppressed by the same reason ( table [ tabbrst3cosa ] ) .
moreover , the matrix elements eqs .
( [ eq : tfistbsneut ] ) and ( [ eq : tfistbslept ] ) for the decays into charged and neutral sleptons have a different structure in the limit @xmath130 : @xmath131 this leads to different decay widths even in the limit of equal slepton masses . in figs .
[ brst3tana](a ) and ( b ) we show the branching ratios as a function of @xmath22 for @xmath132 and the other parameters as above . for small @xmath22
the decay into @xmath124 is the most important one .
the branching ratios for the decays into sleptons decrease with increasing @xmath22 except for the decay into @xmath133 .
this results from : ( i ) for increasing @xmath22 the gaugino component of @xmath121 decreases while its mass increases , ( ii ) the masses of the sleptons increase with increasing @xmath22 , except @xmath94 which decreases , and ( iii ) the @xmath134 yukawa coupling increases .
these facts lead to the dominance of @xmath135 for large @xmath22 as can be seen in fig .
[ brst3tana](b ) .
in addition , the decay into @xmath136 gains some importance for large @xmath22 because its width is proportional to the bottom yukawa coupling in the approximation of @xcite .
the assumption that no two - body decays be allowed at tree level implies that @xmath137 .
therefore , one expects an increase of @xmath99 if @xmath84 increases , because the decay into @xmath138 is dominated by the @xmath125 exchange whereas for the decays into sleptons @xmath121 exchange dominates .
this is demonstrated in figs .
[ brst3cospmu](a ) and ( b ) where we have fixed @xmath139 gev . here
also the decay into @xmath140 is possible .
however , this channel is in general suppressed by kinematics .
we have not found any case with @xmath141 gev while @xmath142 gev @xcite .
these general features still hold if @xmath22 increases as can be seen in figs .
[ brst3tanb](a ) and ( b ) .
here we have fixed @xmath143 . in accordance with the discussion above , the decay into @xmath135 gains importance with increasing @xmath22 .
note , that for large @xmath22 @xmath144 decreases since @xmath108 increases due to radiative corrections . however , there are scenarios where the decay @xmath106 becomes important .
this can be seen in fig .
[ brst3md ] where the branching ratios are shown as a function of @xmath145 for @xmath146 gev , @xmath147 , and the other parameters as in tab .
[ tabbrst3cospmu ] . at the lower end of the @xmath145 range we get @xmath148 gev .
moreover , @xmath91 is approximately @xmath149 leading to an enhancement of this width .
we have found that contrary to the case @xmath124 for the decays @xmath106 sbottom exchange can be important .
this is a consequence of the different spin structure of the corresponding matrix elements ( eqs .
( [ eq : tfistbwchi ] ) and ( [ eq : tfistbhchi ] ) ) and because of the large bottom yukawa coupling .
the decrease in @xmath144 for @xmath150 gev is mainly due to the fact that @xmath108 grows with increasing @xmath145 .
finally , we want to discuss a scenario which is within the reach of an upgraded tevatron . here
we refer to the examples of @xcite . in general
the decays into sleptons clearly dominate when they are kinematically allowed ( except the case when the couplings of the top squark to the lighter chargino nearly vanishes ) . in the case @xmath151
gev , @xmath152 , @xmath153 gev , @xmath154 gev , @xmath155 gev , @xmath156 gev and @xmath157 ( scenario b of table i in @xcite ) we obtain : @xmath158 , @xmath159 , @xmath160 , @xmath161 , and @xmath162 .
the order of magnitude is independent of @xmath29 and @xmath85 because the lighter chargino is mainly gaugino - like in the parameter space where the decay @xmath124 is possible ( see fig .
2b of @xcite ) .
for increasing @xmath22 we have found a similar behaviour as in figs .
[ brst3tana ] and [ brst3tanb ] : dominance of the decay @xmath163 , an increase of @xmath164 and a decrease of all other decay channels .
we have calculated the three - body decays @xmath106 , @xmath165 , and @xmath166 ( @xmath20 ) including all terms proportional to @xmath167 , @xmath168 , and all yukawa couplings .
we have compared these decays with @xmath164 @xcite and @xmath124 @xcite .
these decays are competitive in that part of the parameter space accessible at an upgraded tevatron , the lhc or a future lepton collider where the tree level two - body decays @xmath169 and @xmath170 are kinematically forbidden .
we have found that for @xmath171 gev the decays into sleptons dominate due to kinematics . in the range
200 gev @xmath172 gev all the decays mentioned above compete with each other .
the branching ratios depend crucially on the coupling of @xmath5 to @xmath121 , implying that one can get information on the mixing angle of the top squarks , once the chargino properties are known . for heavier top
squark masses the decay into @xmath138 , mainly proceeding via a virtual @xmath125 quark , is in general the most important one .
in addition , we have found that for small @xmath22 the decays into sneutrinos are more important than the decays into charged sleptons .
this is a result of the different spin structures of the corresponding matrix elements . for large @xmath22
the decay into the lighter stau becomes important due to the large tau yukawa coupling ( implying also a smaller stau mass ) .
the decay into @xmath140 is kinematically suppressed because the existing mass bounds on the neutral higgs bosons also imply a lower bound on @xmath108 . however , in scenarios where radiative corrections decrease @xmath108 and where at the same time @xmath173 we have found branching ratios of the order of 30% .
the large variety of possible three - body decay modes implies the chance to determine the properties of @xmath5 also when higher order decays are dominant .
clearly , a detailed monte carlo study will be necessary to see how the different channels can be separated .
i thank a. bartl , h. eberl , t. gajdosik , s. kraml , and w. majerotto for many helpful discussions and the inspiring atmosphere .
i am grateful to j.w.f .
valle for the kind hospitality and the pleasant atmosphere at the departamento de fsica terico .
this work was supported by the `` fonds zur frderung der wissenschaftlichen forschung '' of austria , project no .
p10843-phy , and by the eec under the tmr contract erbfmrx - ct96 - 0090 .
in the subsequent sections the formulas for the decay widths are listed which have been omitted in sec . [ sec : threebody ] .
the decay width is given by @xmath175 with @xmath176 \nonumber \\ & & + ( a_{31 } + a_{32 } s ) j^0_{tt}(m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } + m^2_{h^+ } + m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } - m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^+_1 } - s , \gamma_{{\tilde \chi}^+_1 } m_{{\tilde \chi}^+_1 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{33 mm } , m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } + m^2_{h^+ } + m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } - m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^+_2 } - s , \gamma_{{\tilde \chi}^+_2 } m_{{\tilde \chi}^+_2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & + ( a_{33 } + a_{34 } s ) j^1_{tt}(m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } + m^2_{h^+ } + m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } - m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^+_1 } - s , \gamma_{{\tilde \chi}^+_1 } m_{{\tilde \chi}^+_1 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{33 mm } , m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } + m^2_{h^+ } + m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } - m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^+_2 } - s , \gamma_{{\tilde \chi}^+_2 } m_{{\tilde \chi}^+_2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & + \ , a_{34 } \
, j^2_{tt}(m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } + m^2_{h^+ } + m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } - m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^+_1 } - s , \gamma_{{\tilde \chi}^+_1 } m_{{\tilde \chi}^+_1 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{17 mm } , m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } + m^2_{h^+ } + m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } - m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^+_2 } - s , \gamma_{{\tilde \chi}^+_2 } m_{{\tilde \chi}^+_2 } ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath177 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath178 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath179 @xmath180 \ , , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath181 \right\ } \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the integrals @xmath182 are : @xmath183 with @xmath184 .
their integration range is given by @xmath185 where @xmath186 and @xmath187 are the usual mandelstam variables .
note , that @xmath188 appears in the entries of the integrals @xmath189 and @xmath190 because the chargino is exchanged in the @xmath191-channel in our convention .
the coefficients are given by : @xmath192 \nonumber \\ & & - \left ( ( k^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^l_{11}{}')^2 + ( l^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^r_{11}{}')^2 \right ) m^2_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \left(m^2_b+m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \ , , \\
% a_{12 } & = & 4 \ , k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' m_b m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } + \left ( ( k^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^r_{11}{}')^2 + ( l^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^l_{11}{}')^2 \right ) \left ( m^2_b+m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } \left ( ( q^l_{11}{}')^2 + ( q^r_{11}{}')^2 \right ) m_b m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } + 2 \ , q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' \left ( ( k^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 + ( l^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 \right ) m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \nonumber \\ & & + \left ( ( k^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^l_{11}{}')^2 + ( l^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^r_{11}{}')^2 \right ) m^2_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \ , , \\ % a_{13 } & = & 4 \ , k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' m_b m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } + 2 \ , q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' \left ( ( k^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 + ( l^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 \right ) m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \nonumber \\ & & + \left ( ( k^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^r_{11}{}')^2 + ( l^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^l_{11}{}')^2 \right ) \left(2 \ , m^2_b+2 \ , m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } + m^2_{h^+}+m^2_{{\tilde t}_1}\right ) \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } \left ( ( q^l_{11}{}')^2 + ( q^r_{11}{}')^2 \right ) m_b m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \ , , \\ % a_{14 } & = & - ( k^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^r_{11}{}')^2 - ( l^{\tilde t}_{11})^2 ( q^l_{11}{}')^2 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath193 \nonumber \\ & & - 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{12 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_b m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \left(m^2_b+m^2_{{\tilde t}_1}+2 \ , m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \nonumber \\ & & - 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{12 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_b m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_2 } \left(m^2_b+m^2_{{\tilde t}_1}+2 \ , m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \nonumber \\ & & - 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + l^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_2 } \left(m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } + m^2_b \right ) \ , , \\ % a_{32 } & = & 2 \left(l^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{12 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \nonumber \\ & & + 4 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{12 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{12 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_b m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{12 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' + l^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_2 } \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , \left(l^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) \left ( m^2_b+m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{12 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_b m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{12 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_b m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_2 } \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + l^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_2 } \ , , \\ % a_{33 } & = & 2 \left(l^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{12 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \nonumber \\ & & + 4 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{12 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{12 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_b m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{12 } { } ' q^r_{11 } { } ' + l^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_2 } \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , \left(l^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) \left(2 \ , m^2_b+2 \ , m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } + m^2_{h^+}+m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } \right ) \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{12 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_b m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \ , \left(k^{\tilde t}_{12 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) m_b m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_2 } \ , , \\ % a_{34 } & = & - 2 \ , \left(l^{\tilde t}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^l_{11 } { } ' q^l_{12 } { } ' + k^{\tilde t}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{12 } q^r_{11 } { } ' q^r_{12}{}'\right ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath194 \nonumber \\ & & + b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m_t \left [ \left ( m^2_{h^+ } m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } - m^2_b m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \cot \beta - m^2_b \left ( m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } + 2 \ , m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \tan \beta \right ] \nonumber \\ & & + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{2 mm } * \left [ m^2_b \left ( m^2_{h^+}+m^2_{{\tilde t}_1}-m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } -m^2_b \right ) \tan \beta - m^2_t \left ( 2 \ , m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } + m^2_{h^+ } \right ) \cot \beta \right ] \nonumber \\ & & + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } m_b m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \left [ \left(m^2_{h^+}-m^2_b \right ) \tan
\beta - 2 \ , m^2_t \cot \beta \right ] \nonumber \\ & & + b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_b m_t \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{2 mm } * \left [ \left(m^2_{{\tilde t}_1}+m^2_{h^+}-m^2_b -m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \cot \beta - \left ( m^2_{h^+}+2 \ , m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \tan \beta \right ] \nonumber \\ & & + b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_t m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \left [ \left(m^2_{h^+}-m^2_b \right ) \cot
\beta - 2 \ , m^2_b \tan \beta \right ] \nonumber \\ & & - a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_b \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{2 mm } * \left [ \left(m^2_b m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } - m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } m^2_{h^+ } \right ) \tan \beta + m^2_t \left ( m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde t}_1}+2 \ , m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 }
\right ) \cot \beta \right ] \nonumber \\ & & - a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \left [ m^2_b \left(m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1}-m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } \right ) \tan \beta + m^2_t \left(m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \cot \beta \right ] \bigg\ } \ , , \\ % b_{12 } & = & \frac{\sqrt2 \,}{m_w } \bigg\ { b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } m_b m_t \tan \beta + b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m^2_b m_t \tan \beta \nonumber \\ & & + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m^2_t m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \cot \beta + b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_b m_t \tan \beta \nonumber \\ & & + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } m^2_t \cot
\beta + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_b m^2_t \cot \beta \bigg\ } \ , , \\
% b_{13 } & = & - \frac{\sqrt2 \,}{m_w } \bigg\ { b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } m_b m_t \cot \beta - a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m^2_t m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \cot \beta \nonumber \\ & & + b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m_t \left [ \left ( m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } + m^2_{h^+}+m^2_{{\tilde t}_1}+m^2_b \right ) \cot
\beta - m^2_b \tan \beta \right ] \nonumber \\ & & + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } m_b m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \tan \beta - b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } m_b m_t \tan \beta \nonumber \\ & & + b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } m_t m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \cot \beta + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m^2_b m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \tan \beta \nonumber \\ & & + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_b \left [ \left(m^2_b + m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } + m^2_{h^+ } + m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } \right ) \tan \beta - m^2_t \cot \beta \right ] \bigg\ } \ , , \\ % b_{14 } & = & \frac{\sqrt2 \,}{m_w } \left ( b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' m_t \cot \beta + a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' m_b \tan \beta \right ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath195 \ , , \\ % c_{112 } & = & - 2 \ , c^h_{{\tilde t}_1 { \tilde b}_1 } \bigg [ \left(b^{\tilde b}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' + a^{\tilde b}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' \right ) m_b + \left(a^{\tilde b}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' + b^{\tilde b}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' \right ) m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{16 mm } + \left(b^{\tilde b}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' + a^{\tilde b}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' \right ) m_{\tilde{\chi}^+_1 } \bigg ] \ , , \\
% c_{113 } & = & -2 \ , c^h_{{\tilde t}_1 { \tilde b}_1 } \bigg [ \left(b^{\tilde b}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' + a^{\tilde b}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' \right ) m_b + \left(a^{\tilde b}_{11 } l^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^l_{11 } { } ' + b^{\tilde b}_{11 } k^{\tilde t}_{11 } q^r_{11 } { } ' \right ) m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \bigg ] \ , , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath196 \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{5 mm } + 2 \ , \left ( ( a^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 + ( b^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 \right ) m^2_b m^2_t \left ( m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } - m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \bigg ] \ , , \\
% d_2 & = & \frac{m^2_t}{2 \ , m^2_w } \left ( ( a^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 m^2_t \cot^2 \beta + ( b^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 m^2_b \tan^2 \beta \right ) \ , , \\ % d_{3 } & = & \frac{-1}{2 m^2_w } \bigg [ 2 \left ( ( a^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 + ( b^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 \right ) m^2_b m^2_t + 2 a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } m_t m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \left ( m^2_b \left ( 2 + \tan^2 \beta \right ) + m^2_t \cot^2 \beta \right ) \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{12 mm } - \left ( ( a^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 m^2_b \tan^2 \beta + ( b^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 m^2_t \cot^2 \beta \right ) \left(m^2_{h^+}+m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } \right ) \bigg ] \ , , \\ % d_{4 } & = & - \frac{(a^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 m^2_b \tan^2 \beta + ( b^{\tilde{t}}_{11})^2 m^2_t \cot^2 \beta } { 2 \ , m^2_w } \
, , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath197 \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{21 mm } + b^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } m_b m_t \left [ \left ( m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } - m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \cot \beta - \left(m^2_b+m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \tan \beta \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{21 mm } - a^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } \left [ m^2_t \left ( m^2_b+m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \right ) \cot \beta + m^2_b \left(m^2_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } -m^2_{{\tilde t}_1 } \right ) \tan \beta \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{21 mm } - b^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } m_b m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \left [ 2 \ , m^2_t \cot \beta + \left ( m^2_b - m^2_{h^+ } \right ) \tan \beta \right ] \bigg\ } \ , , \\
% e_{12 } & = & - \frac { \sqrt2 \ , c^h_{{\tilde t}_1 { \tilde b}_1}}{m_w } \left ( a^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } m^2_t \cot \beta + b^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } m_b m_t \tan \beta \right ) \ , , \\
% e_{13 } & = & \frac { \sqrt2 \ , c^h_{{\tilde t}_1 { \tilde b}_1}}{m_w } \bigg ( a^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } m_t m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \cot \beta + b^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } b^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } m_b m_t \cot \beta \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{17 mm } + \ , a^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } m^2_b \tan \beta + b^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } a^{\tilde{t}}_{11 } m_b m_{{\tilde \chi}^0_1 } \tan \beta \bigg ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath198 \ , , \\ % f_{12 } & = & ( c^h_{{\tilde t}_1 { \tilde b}_1})^2 \left((a^{\tilde{b}}_{11})^2+(b^{\tilde{b}}_{11})^2 \right ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath199 \ , , \nonumber \\ \\ % f_{32 } & = & 2 \ , c^h_{{\tilde t}_1 { \tilde b}_1 } c^h_{{\tilde t}_1 { \tilde b}_2 } \left ( a^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } a^{\tilde{b}}_{12 } + b^{\tilde{b}}_{11 } b^{\tilde{b}}_{12 } \right ) \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] one gets the remaining coefficients by replacements : + ( 135,175 ) ( 43,153)@xmath200 ( 106,144)@xmath201 ( 65,161)@xmath202 ( 76,153)@xmath203 ( 106,155)@xmath122 ( 43,93)@xmath200 ( 108,98)@xmath202 ( 107,83)@xmath201 ( 75,94)@xmath204 ( 68,101)@xmath122 ( 43,33)@xmath200 ( 65,42)@xmath201 ( 108,37)@xmath202 ( 77,32)@xmath125 ( 108,20)@xmath122 ( 30,10 ) | we discuss the three - body decays @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) of the lighter top squark @xmath5 within the minimal supersymmetric standard model .
we give the complete analytical formulas for the decay widths and present a numerical study in view of an upgraded tevatron , the cern lhc , and a future lepton collider demonstrating the importance of these decay modes . |
there are many physical systems where the @xmath0 mkdv equation @xcite appears , e.g. phonons in anharmonic lattices @xcite , ion acoustic solitons @xcite and van alfvn waves in collisionless plasma @xcite , schottky barrier transmission lines @xcite as well as in the models of traffic congestion @xcite .
a subclass of hyperbolic surfaces @xcite , slag - metallic bath interfaces @xcite , curve motion @xcite , meandering ocean jets @xcite and other models in fluid mechanics @xcite are also related to the mkdv equation .
furthermore , it has been shown that the dynamics of thin elastic rods can also be reduced to the mkdv equation @xcite .
this equation is also of special interest due to its integrability in the context of nonlinear soliton bearing systems @xcite . from a physical perspective
it is therefore important to examine novel classes of solutions of such partial differential equations and their potential relevance in this diverse class of applications .
a particularly interesting type of solution is the so called breather lattice solution .
breathers are spatially localized and temporally periodic solutions which are of significant relevance to localization type phenomena in optics , condensed matter physics and biophysics . for a representative set of reviews of the continuously increasing volume of work in this area , see e.g. @xcite .
as can be seen in these investigations , typically analytical expressions for breather type solutions are unavailable and such solutions have to be traced by means of numerical methods .
however , in some cases and particularly for integrable models , such solutions may exist in closed form .
one such example is the breather lattice solution of the sine - gordon equation which was presented in explicit analytic form in @xcite .
such a solution , albeit unstable , is very important because it can be stabilized in more realistic contexts of driving and damping .
in addition , it is useful in extracting the asymptotic breather - breather ( exponential ) interaction by means of energy methods as demonstrated in @xcite . it is naturally worthwhile to enquire whether similar extended pattern solutions are available in closed form in other models .
of particular interest are models of the mkdv ( and kdv ) variety not only due to an abundance of the corresponding applications but also due to the fundamental differences of such integrable models with nonlinear klein - gordon equations , such as sine - gordon .
the latter have lorentz invariance that permits the breathers to be either standing or travelling . in the former case
such invariances are absent and breathers can only be sustained in a travelling wave form .
furthermore , the dissipation type effects are introduced by very different operators in the two cases .
thus , for reasons of physical applicability and mathematical tractability , it is very important to identify similar solutions of the breather lattice type in models of the kdv family such as the mkdv and examine their stability .
this is the main objective of the present work .
our presentation is structured as follows . in sec .
ii we present the explicit mkdv breather lattice solution in terms of elliptic functions , retrieve the well known single breather limit and analyze the algebraic and physical conditions for the existence of such a solution . in sec .
iii we numerically study the stability of the unperturbed mkdv breather lattice and display its instability . in sec .
iv , we demonstrate that such a solution can be stabilized by viscous effects when combined with appropriate driving to sustain the breathers and finally in sec .
v we summarize our findings and present our conclusions .
the modified korteweg - de vries equation for a field @xmath1 @xmath2 can be transformed into @xmath3 where @xmath4 the single breather solution of mkdv is known to be @xcite @xmath5 with @xmath6 and @xmath7 , @xmath8 are arbitrary constants .
let us now try to obtain the breather lattice solution of the mkdv equation . to that end , we start with the ansatz @xmath9 with @xmath10 where @xmath11 and @xmath12 are jacobi elliptic functions with modulus @xmath13 and @xmath14 , respectively .
this ansatz is inspired by the derivative relationship between a single breather solution of the sine - gordon equation and that of mkdv [ eq .
( 4 ) ] as well as by the functional similarity of the sine - gordon breather lattice solution @xcite . substituting the ansatz ( 7 ) in eq . ( 2 ) and upon lengthy algebraic manipulations , we find that eq .
( 7 ) is indeed the mkdv breather lattice solution , provided that @xmath15 @xmath16~ , ~~d = c[3a^2(1+k)-(2-m)c^2]~. \eqno(9)\ ] ] as expected , in the limit @xmath17 , the breather lattice solution ( 7 ) reduces to the single breather solution ( 4 ) and the relations between @xmath18 and @xmath19 as well as between @xmath20 and @xmath21 reduce to the ones given by eq .
( 5 ) . on physical grounds ( i.e. , to have solutions with a definite spatial periodicity )
, it is natural to demand that the periods of the @xmath11 and @xmath12 functions must be spatially commensurate , i.e. , in addition to conditions ( 8) and ( 9 ) , we must also demand that @xcite @xmath22 where k(k ) is the complete elliptic integral of the first kind .
note , however , that since the mkdv breather is always moving , it need not have temporal commensurability . combining conditions ( 8) and ( 10 ) yields @xmath23 implying thereby that @xmath14 and @xmath13 are not independent .
for example , note that as expected with @xmath24 , @xmath25 the breather lattice solution reduces to the single breather solution ( 4 ) .
however , as @xmath26 , @xmath27 and then it is easily shown that an exact ( nonlinear ) travelling wave solution is given by @xmath28+a_0,k)~. \eqno(12)\ ] ] summarizing , since there are four relations among the six parameters @xmath29 , we have obtained a two - parameter family of breather lattice solutions . a plot of the ( exact ) breather lattice of eq .
( 6 ) for @xmath30 , @xmath31 is given in the top left panel of fig .
[ afig1 ] .
based on the breather lattice simulations for the sine - gordon case @xcite it may be natural to expect that the mkdv breather lattice configuration is also unstable . in the numerical simulation of the mkdv problem , we have found that the direct center - difference discretization does a poor job in adequately following the mkdv equation ( and in conserving the corresponding integrals of motion ) .
while one can also use the integrable scheme of ablowitz - ladik ( see e.g. , @xcite and references therein ) , we have followed a different path here in spatially discretizing the partial differential equation and following the integrable discretization scheme of @xcite for kdv and adapting it to the case of the mkdv . in particular , the spatially discrete version of our equation
reads ( with lattice spacing @xmath32 ) : @xmath33 .
\eqno(13)\ ] ] the time integration has been performed by means of a 4th order runge - kutta scheme .
we used periodic boundary conditions and the initial condition contained an exact breather lattice configuration , matching the periodicity of the finite domain .
hence , the only perturbation to the exact solution came from the numerical discretization of the problem .
it should also be noted that in the results mentioned below , the accuracy of the numerical method was monitored by probing the conservation of two quantities , @xmath34 and @xmath35 , which emulate the discrete analogs of the mass and the momentum , respectively . typically the former is conserved ( at worst ) to 1 part in @xmath36 , while the latter to 1 part in @xmath37 .
we found that , as can be seen in the top right panel of fig .
[ afig1 ] , the numerical discretization perturbation grows and eventually destroys the breather lattice configuration in all the cases considered .
various snapshots of the solution @xmath1 are depicted in the bottom panel of fig .
[ afig1 ] . to further understand the instability , we performed runs for different values of the two relevant parameters of the solution , namely @xmath18 and @xmath14 .
three typical cases are shown in fig .
[ afig2 ] .
the particular numerical experiments are chosen to illustrate the characteristic dependences of the instability .
we expect from the experience of other nonlinear wave equations with interacting breather structure ( see e.g. , @xcite for sine - gordon and @xcite for nonlinear schrdinger type models ) that the instability is caused by the interaction between the breathers , which is exponential in their separation . from eq .
( 10 ) , the separation between the breathers is given by @xmath38 .
the top panels of fig . [ afig2 ] correspond to two cases with different @xmath18 and @xmath14 but with the same @xmath39 .
clearly the instability develops at very similar times and verifies the dependence of the growth rate on the inter - breather separation @xmath40 .
the bottom panel shows a case with @xmath41 .
notice that these typical results have been verified by additional numerical experiments .
furthermore , the ratio of the breather separations in the cases of the top right panel of fig . [ afig1 ] , top panels of fig . [ afig2 ] and the bottom panel of fig .
[ afig2 ] is 1:2:4 while the corresponding ( approximate ) instability onset times have a ratio of 2.5:16:150 , clearly hinting an exponential dependence of the instability onset on @xmath42 .
while the results of the previous section indicate that very long - lived breather lattice configurations can be achieved by appropriate parameter selection , it is natural to enquire whether by mechanisms of ac driving and damping it is possible to fully stabilize such configurations . we have thus examined the following driven - damped mkdv equation @xmath43 where the `` viscosity '' coefficient was fixed to @xmath44 while @xmath45 was varied .
notice that the periodicity of the driver was chosen to match one of the unperturbed breather lattice configurations . for small values of @xmath45 ,
the viscosity damps the breather amplitude .
however , for sufficiently large driving amplitudes ( such as the one used in fig .
[ afig3 ] ) the driver can lead to the stabilization of an asymmetric lattice configuration .
we also note that the ac drive was motivated by earlier studies , e.g. @xcite ( and the references therein ) .
in addition , we point out that lattice configurations propagating in the opposite direction can be stabilized if the velocity of the driver is reversed ( results not shown here ) .
we note that the value of the viscosity coefficient @xmath44 and the amplitude of the driver @xmath46 used in fig . 3 to stabilize the breather lattice are relatively large .
in this sense the stabilized ( numerical ) breather lattice in fig .
3 is different from the exact solution of the mkdv equation given in eqs .
( 6 ) and ( 7 ) .
thus the physical origin of the stabilized solution may be different from the original solution of the mkdv equation .
we should also remark that variation of the value of @xmath47 will not significantly modify the results .
i.e. , even for much smaller values of @xmath47 the multi - breather configuration is destroyed at a finite time and the resulting profile does not closely resemble the initial condition .
however , the relaxation time to the final state depends considerably on the exact value of the viscosity coefficient and is longer for smaller @xmath47 .
inspired by the exact breather lattice solution of the sine - gordon equation @xcite we used an ansatz to find a corresponding solution of the modified korteweg - de vries equation .
we determined the conditions under which the ansatz becomes an exact solution of mkdv and showed how it degenerates to the single mkdv breather solution in the appropriate limit .
we then used this exact expression to derive additional lattices of nonlinear travelling waves .
the mkdv breather lattice is a genuinely propagating solution in constrast to the sine - gordon solution which can be static .
our numerical experiments ( by means of a novel numerical scheme ) indicated that the mkdv breather lattice solution is unstable ; however , it can be stabilized by inclusion of damping and ac driving .
the results presented here may be relevant to numerous physical phenomena such as jamming in traffic flow @xcite , fluid dynamics @xcite and collisionless plasmas @xcite .
s. aubry , physica * 103d * , 201 ( 1997 ) ; s. flach and c.r .
willis , phys .
* 295 * , 181 ( 1998 ) ; physica * 119d * , ( 1999 ) , special volume edited by s. flach and r.s .
mackay ; p.g .
kevrekidis , k. .
rasmussen and a.r .
bishop , int .
b * 15 * , 2833 ( 2001 ) ; focus issue edited by yu .
s. kivshar and s. flach , chaos * 13 * , 586 - 799 ( 2003 ) .
we have also examined `` weakly commensurate '' cases where @xmath48 with similar results . here
@xmath49 and @xmath50 denote relative primes . for incommensurate cases ,
the boundary periodicity can not be imposed and typically we found that this creates an immediate instability - inducing perturbation to the configuration . | we obtain an exact solution for the breather lattice solution of the modified korteweg - de vries ( mkdv ) equation .
numerical simulation of the breather lattice demonstrates its instability due to the breather - breather interaction .
however , such multi - breather structures can be stabilized through the concurrent application of ac driving and viscous damping terms . * breather lattice and its stabilization for the modified korteweg - de vries equation * |
cryptography is one of the most promising applications of quantum science @xcite . with the recent demonstrations of high - dimensional two - photon entanglement using time bins
@xcite and oam @xcite , large - alphabet entanglement - based quantum key distribution ( qkd ) systems become closer to their real - world implementations and applications .
the traditional approach to large - alphabet qkd based on bell s theorem involves verifying the security of the generated key using a test of a bell inequality .
this is a straighforward generalization of the original protocol introduced by ekert in 1991 ( e91 ) @xcite and e91-based protocols have been demonstrated for qubits using @xcite and using time - energy entanglement @xcite .
a bell - type test of energy - time entangled qutrits has also been realised @xcite . reported experiments using oam qutrits @xcite have implemented a randomized selection of dichotomous measurements instead of full projective measurements in a 3-dimensional state space .
although projective measurement for detection of high - dimensional oam states of light with up to 11 different outcomes is now within reach @xcite , it still remains an experimental challenge to perform in arbitrary qudit bases . in the case of high - dimensional time - bin states
, such unitary operations would require multi - path interferometric setups which become cumbersome to implement for a high number of dimensions .
@xcite , the applicability of this scheme is specific to this kind of entanglement and the security verification is highly device dependent as it places stringent conditions on timing resolutions of the detectors , which limits .
security verification of quantum key distribution schemes is a complicated problem in general .
security proofs have been provided for bell - test - based qkd against the so - called collective attacks @xcite as well as the most general coherent attacks in the standard security scenarios @xcite . however , proofs of device - independent security against these sophisticated attacks are not yet available in the case of entangled qudits requiring bell tests generalised to high - dimensions @xcite . here
, we propose an approach to large - alphabet entanglement - based qkd which circumvents these problems by avoiding the need to perform high - dimensional unitary rotations required for measurements in different mutually unbiased bases , resulting in a much simplified measurement setup .
the scheme presented here also benefits from security proofs for qkd based on entangled qubits against collective attacks .
is in principle applicable to any system in which it is possible to create bipartite two - dimensional entanglement in one degree of freedom and high - dimensional correlations in another .
although we will use an example with photon polarization and oam to illustrate the protocol , the principle can be applied to other systems using other degrees of freedom to encode secret keys . .
the development of oam sorters genuine large - alphabet key generation using up to 11-dimensional oam entanglement .
this will also allow for a higher data rate per photon pair , as the detection of the photonic qudits would not need to be implemented as ( probabilistic ) dichotomous measurements as has been the case in previous experiments @xcite .
it is also straightforward to implement projective measurements in computational ( unrotated ) time - bin bases . in what follows
, we will first describe the existing generalizations of the e91 protocol .
we will then describe the source state , measurement setup , and security considerations for our proposed scheme .
finally , we will conclude with a few remarks on the realizability of the proposed experimental implementations .
to establish our scheme , let us first review the entanglement - based large - alphabet qkd . assume a source producing photon pairs in the state @xmath0 , where @xmath1 denotes tensor product . in terms of oam eigenstates
@xmath2 for example , this may be written as the maximally entangled state @xmath3 for all @xmath4 when @xmath5 is odd , and @xmath6 , when @xmath5 is even . in a bell inequality test experiment ,
each of the communicating parties ` alice ' ( a ) and ` bob ' ( b ) have a photon oam detector with and two settings / measurements : @xmath7 and @xmath8 respectively , which maximize bell inequality violation .
alice and bob independently choose their settings at random and also note their detection results independently .
after sufficiently many measurement runs , alice and bob to determine the security of this key , the correlation in the rest of the data will be checked for eavesdropping through a bell inequality test , for example using bell inequalities generalised to @xmath5-outcomes per measurement proposed by collins _
et al . _
@xcite , equivalent to the chsh - bell inequality @xcite @xmath9 .
only cases in which the combination of measurement settings involve @xmath10 and @xmath11 are used for this test , while the remaining results are discarded .
after basis reconciliation , bob announces his data for the bell inequality check , and alice computes the value of the bell parameter @xmath12 .
if @xmath13 , then the key is secure and the eavesdropper , eve , will not have gained any useful information on the key .
the secret key can then be used in any cryptographic communication between alice and bob .
implementing the above requires full projective measurements in the oam state basis @xmath14 in a @xmath5-dimensional subspace , corresponding to @xmath15 .
this be realized , e.g. for up to @xmath16 using oam mode sorters as mentioned above .
however , full projective measurements whose operators have eigenstates which are oam superpositions are also required .
it is nontrivial to realize such measurements because it requires a unitary operation within the high - dimensional oam subspace being considered before the oam detection .
the implementations of such operations are difficult to derive in general , and have not realized experimentally .
we propose a state which replaces the need for measurements in high - dimensional rotated bases with the simplicity of a two - dimensional chsh bell test for the verification of the security of generated key . to appreciate how our source state relates to hybrid entangled states , consider the state expressed in terms of the composite oam and polarisation states @xmath17 ( where @xmath4 denotes the oam , @xmath18 ; and @xmath19 denotes the prolarization @xmath20 ) as @xmath21 for even @xmath5 .
note that this state combines orbital angular momentum entanglement and polarization entanglement in a way similar but quite different from the cases of the so - called hyper - entangled @xcite , hypoentangled or entangled entangled @xcite states . in hyper - entanglement , a measurement of oam will not destroy polarization entanglement and vice versa . in hypoentanglement , measuring either polarization or oam destroys entanglement in the other degree of freedom . here measuring oam completely destroys polarization entanglement , but the converse is not true .
we note that the division of the subspaces ( e.g. into odd and even oam parities in this example ) can also be done in other ways , depending on the specific realization and experimental convenience
. state can be rewritten , as @xmath22 is an entangled state within the @xmath23th oam subspace .
although this state is ( hypo)entangled in both polarization and oam , only the classical correlation in oam is strictly necessary for our scheme .
+ + * source state : * our source state is of the form @xmath24 is an entangled state in polarisation within an oam subspace specified by @xmath23 .
the source state could be obtained either by post - selection or deterministically ( denoted by superscripts p and d respectively ) as outlined below .
suppose we define @xmath25 note that this state is a combination of @xmath5 photon pairs , with each pair hypoentangled in both polarisation and oam in unique oam subspaces . a source state for our scheme [ of the form eq .
] could be obtained by post - selection from latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } \label{eq : mstatemulti3 } which is a product state of @xmath5 pairs of oam - entangled photons where @xmath27 is the two - photon state expressed in eq . . a proposed scheme to obtain @xmath28 from common spontaneous parametric down conversion ( spdc )
sources is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : setup1](a ) .
this involves generating oam entanglement by type - i collinear parametric downconversion with a defined polarization , say horizontal ( @xmath29 ) .
the co - propagating photon pairs entangled in oam are passed through an oam parity ( even / odd ) sorter @xcite .
a half - wave plate is then inserted after one of the output arms which rotates @xmath29 to vertical polarization @xmath30 , coupling oam parity to polarization .
the state represented in eq .
could then be generated by choosing parameters of the spdc source to create more than one entangled photon pair simultaneously .
it is well known that a desired probability of multiple pair generation per pump pulse can be achieved according to the theoretical @xmath5-pair creation probability @xcite @xmath31 where @xmath32 is a real - valued coupling coefficient which is proportional to the product of the pump amplitude and the coupling constant between the electromagnetic field and the nonlinear crystal .
the source state for our scheme can then be obtained by final postselection on state represented by eq .
. this can be done by registering only the values of @xmath23 for which both alice and bob have a detection per oam subspace in one run . to achieve this , it suffices to use detectors which distinguish between zero , one , and more than one photon .
such detectors have been experimentally demonstrated @xcite .
also , actual photon - number - resolving detectors have been realised ( e.g. , see @xcite ) with increased detection efficiencies @xcite . a more suitable approach , however , is to prepare the source state in a deterministic way by , e.g. , using an array of @xmath5 polarization - entangled - photon sources ( eps ) generating exactly one photon pair at a time .
existing semiconductor quantum dot ( qd ) systems provide a suitable platform for single photon generation @xcite , as well as generation of entangled photon pairs on demand with high efficiency @xcite .
rapid experimental progress is also being made towards implementing arrays consisting of several qd high - fidelity - entangled - photon - pair emitters on the same chip @xcite . here
, we propose a setup utilising @xmath5 eps ( see fig . [
fig : setup2 ] ) .
oam of @xmath33 , for example , is then individually imprinted on photons emitted by the @xmath34 source to yield state resulting in basis states that are assigned as shown below .
the photons in an entangled pair are usually generated using the biexciton - exciton - vacuum cascade , and are separable based on their wavelength .
individual photons from different pairs may then be combined into one beam using an oam combiner ( i.e. , a coherent oam sorter operated in reverse ) to obtain the source state @xmath35 [ eq . ] . for this case ,
the entangled state @xmath36 within the @xmath23th subspace defined as @xmath37 we note that the source state[eq .
[ eq : mstatemulti2 ] ] is essentially the same for both the probabilistic and deterministic preparations except for a change in the basis state assignment of the oam measurement .
this basis selection is simply for the convenience of experimental implementation specific to each method of state preparation .
, our scheme using the state also involves three measurement settings randomly and independently chosen by alice and bob .
however , the settings @xmath10 and @xmath11 are now polarization measurements for maximal chsh - bell inequality violation .
these measurement settings each have two outcomes `` + '' and `` - '' . for key generation ,
@xmath38 and @xmath39 , ( @xmath40 and @xmath41 ) are the same as described above .
an important aspect of our scheme is to perform both key generation and bell tests _ individually _ in each @xmath23th subspace ( or channel ) , and _ simultaneously _ for all @xmath42 , using the same bell - test setup . to achieve the simultaneous measurements for the case of the non - deterministic state preparation outlined in section [ sec : nondet ] above , alice bob need to first perform local operations which make
the respective oam states degenerate for orthogonal polarisations of alice s and bob s photons within each @xmath23th subspace , i.e. , to disentangle the polarisation and oam degrees of freedom .
this can be achieved if , e.g. , alice ( bob ) subtracts ( adds)@xmath43 of oam for the vertically polarised photons [ using the combination of pbs1 , slm1 and pbs2 in fig .
[ fig : setup1 ] ( b ) ] .
this operation by alice and bob can be described by the transformations @xmath44 and @xmath45 where @xmath46 note that this only causes a transformation of the basis states defined in eq .
as follows , @xmath47 a combination of a hwp and a pbs can now carry out the bell - test polarisation measurements ( @xmath10 or @xmath11 ) for each value of @xmath23 .
@xmath48 where the correlation coefficients of the measurement @xmath49 performed by alice and @xmath50 by bob are defined as @xmath51 @xmath52 and @xmath53 are probabilities for equal and unequal outcomes respectively , determined experimentally using the coincidence each @xmath23th subspace .
the detector settings for the chsh bell inequality violation could be specified as measurements in the bases @xmath54 , where if we set @xmath55 as values of @xmath56 for @xmath57 and @xmath58 respectively , then we will and get the maximal violation of @xmath59 for each @xmath23th subspace of state .
when the state is prepared deterministically as described in section [ sec : detprepst1 ] , operators @xmath60 and @xmath61 [ eqs . and ] are not necessary for the measurements . as in the non - deterministic case ,
the bell test is carried out using a combination of a hwp and pbs [ see fig . [
fig : setup2 ] ( b ) ] , but photon number resolution and final postselection are not required . due to the difference in basis assignment in this case , we redefine the detector settings for the chsh bell inequality violation as measurements in the bases @xmath62 , where latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } \label{eq : basezdet } the optimum settings ( specified by @xmath56 ) for the hwp are the same as in eq .
above , and the resulting bell operator for this case [ see eq . ]
is @xmath64 the state represented by eq .
is also maximally entangled within the @xmath23th subspace for this case , and it gives a maximal violation of the chsh inequality based on operator when the key has not been eavesdropped .
any eavesdropping of the key is essentially a measurement strategy that will destroy polarisation entanglement which is used to establish the key .
this in turn degrades the chsh bell inequality violation @xcite .
a _ collective attack _ is one in which the eavesdropper ( eve ) applies the same operation on each of alice s and bob s particles , other limitations . in particular
, she is allowed to have access to a string of qubits from alice / bob at one time , .
our scheme is essentially a multiplexing of multiple polarisation - entangled qubit pairs by means of a higher - dimensional degree of freedom , followed by independently testing the chsh bell inequality simultaneously
eve s access to one or more source states in our scheme is equivalent to her access to a string of qubits on which she can perform joint ( coherent ) measurements .
therefore , the security of our scheme is completely guaranteed by the security of the individual qubit - based schemes against collective attacks @xcite .
this , in turn , implies security against the most general , so - called coherent attacks @xcite .
these results apply fully to our large - alphabet protocol since it is equivalent to simultaneous but independent 2-qubit secure protocols .
the bit rate generated securely against collective attacks as a function of bell parameters @xmath65 @xcite @xmath66 where @xmath67 is the binary entropy and @xmath68 is the quantum bit error rate for channel @xmath23 . as shown in fig .
[ fig : securerate1nd ] , the larger the measured bell violation , the higher the secure key rate per run . a @xmath5-fold enhancement over the traditional 2-qubit schemes as a large - alphabet scheme , but uses a much simplified bell - test measurement setup compared to traditional large - alphabet .
as a function of the bell parameter @xmath12 and the quantum bit - error rate ( qber ) @xmath69 , in a single run , for our scheme with a qubit - based e91-type protocol @xcite .
we assume that the quantum bit error rate @xmath69 and bell parameter for each channel is the same , i.e. , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 respectively for all @xmath23 .
our scheme shows a @xmath5-fold enhancement in secure key rate.,scaledwidth=40.0% ]
it results in a greatly simplified security verification and key generation setup which does not get more complicated with increasing @xmath5 , except for an increase in the number of output ports of the oam sorting device .
it thereby provides a route to boosting the secure key rates in entanglement - based qkd without the usual increased complexity of bell tests in high dimensions .
it also benefits from the relative tolerance two - dimensional bell tests to measurement error .
although it is known that the amount of violation for an actual @xmath72-dimensional bell test increases with @xmath72 , these increments are marginal even in the ideal case , and level off as @xmath72 increases @xcite the high sensitivity of the complicated measurement setup to errors will usually overwhelm these increments even for modest values of @xmath72 , resulting in smaller violations than in the qubit case .
another advantage of our scheme where an spdc source is used is that non - maximal high - dimensional entanglement will not generally degrade the the verification of security .
for example , . whereas , if generalised oam - based bell tests are used without procrustrean filtering , then a small spiral bandwidth might cause a failure of the bell test for an entangled state @xcite . in summary , this paper has described a practical scheme in which a single chsh - bell test setup combined with a full projective measurement is sufficient for security verification even for a large - alphabet scheme capable of arbitrarily large key rates per run .
the scheme is simpler to implement than existing generalizations of e91 protocol to high - dimensions because it circumvents measurements in mutually unbiased bases in high dimensions , while maintaining capacity for large key - rate and security against collective attacks .
a second significant advantage is that non - maximal high - dimensional entanglement will not necessarily degrade of security .
we point out that the scheme is realisable using current technology by mentioning two examples for generating applicable source states , namely , spontaneous parametric downconversion and , more suitably , source of single pairs of entangled photons , such as semiconductor quantum dots . from the point of view of real - world applications of high - dimensional qkd , judicious selection of basis states
@xcite will increase resilience against decoherence induced by atmospheric turbulence in a free space .
although this can be applied within the framework of this scheme , implementations with time bins @xcite or path appear promising for long distance applications . the complexity of security verification in large - alphabet entanglement - based qkd makes it apparent that the simplified scheme presented here will likely enable otherwise infeasible secure key rates in qkd , enabling more practical implementations of entanglement - based technologies .
47ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.67.661 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/09500340500283821 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.73.031801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys1996 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.79.052101 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.67.012310 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.78.020301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.84.4737 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.93.010503 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1367-2630/8/i=5/a=075 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.153601 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/2040-8986/13/i=6/a=064006 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.060503 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.78.2256 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.230501 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.88.257901 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.95.080501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.88.040404 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.23.880 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.95.260501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.97.020501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.61.042304 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ao.33.001844 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.123482 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.130501 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature04446 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphoton.2013.377 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphoton.2013.128 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.51.r1727 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.68.3259 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.65.052325 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.79.4034 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.49.1804 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1142/s021974991100843x [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.68.050301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/oe.19.006671 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/oe.20.013195 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.93.180502 [ * * , ( ) ] | we propose a practical quantum cryptographic scheme which combines high information capacity , such as provided by , with the simplicity of a two - dimensional clauser - horne - shimony - holt ( chsh ) bell test for security verification . by applying a state combining entanglement in a two - dimensional degree of freedom , such as photon polarization , with in another degree of freedom , such as photon orbital angular momentum ( oam ) or path
, the scheme provides a considerably simplified route towards security verification in quantum key distribution ( qkd ) aimed at . |
the laser interferometer gravitational wave observatory ( ligo ) is a network of interferometric detectors aiming to make direct observations of gravitational waves .
construction of the ligo detectors is essentially complete , and much progress has been made in commissioning them to ( a ) bring the three interferometers to their final optical configuration , ( b ) reduce the interferometers noise floors and improve the stationarity of the noise , and ( c ) pave the way toward long - term science observations .
interleaved with commissioning , four `` science runs '' have been carried out to collect data under stable operating conditions for astrophysical gravitational wave searches , albeit at reduced sensitivity and observation time relative to the ligo design goals .
the first science run , called s1 , took place in the summer of 2002 over a period of 17 days .
s1 represented a major milestone as the longest and most sensitive operation of broad - band interferometers _ in coincidence _ up to that time . using the s1 data from the ligo and geo600 interferometers @xcite , astrophysical searches for four general categories of gravitational wave source types binary inspiral @xcite , burst - like @xcite , stochastic @xcite and continuous wave @xcite were pursued by the ligo scientific collaboration ( lsc ) .
these searches established general methodologies to be followed and improved upon for the analysis of data from future runs . in 2003 two
additional science runs of the ligo instruments collected data of improved sensitivity with respect to s1 , but still less sensitive than the instruments design goal .
the second science run ( s2 ) collected data in early 2003 and the third science run ( s3 ) at the end of the same year .
several searches have been completed or are underway using data from the s2 and s3 runs @xcite .
a fourth science run , s4 , took place at the beginning of 2005 . in this paper
we report the results of a search for gravitational wave bursts using the ligo s2 data .
the astrophysical motivation for burst events is strong ; it embraces catastrophic phenomena in the universe with or without clear signatures in the electromagnetic spectrum like supernova explosions @xcite , the merging of compact binary stars as they form a single black hole @xcite and the astrophysical engines that power the gamma ray bursts @xcite .
perturbed or accreting black holes , neutron star oscillation modes and instabilities as well as cosmic string cusps and kinks @xcite are also potential burst sources .
the expected rate , strength and waveform morphology for such events is not generally known .
for this reason , our assumptions for the expected signals are minimal .
the experimental signatures on which this search focused can be described as burst signals of short duration ( @xmath3 1 second ) and with enough signal strength in the ligo sensitive band ( 1001100 hz ) to be detected in coincidence in all three ligo instruments .
the triple coincidence requirement is used to reduce the false alarm rate ( background ) to much less than one event over the course of the run , so that even a single event candidate would have high statistical significance .
the general methodology in pursuing this search follows the one we presented in the analysis of the s1 data @xcite with some significant improvements . in the s1 analysis
the ringing of the pre - filters limited our ability to perform tight time - coincidence between the triggers coming from the three ligo instruments .
this is addressed by the use of a new search method that does not require strong pre - filtering .
this new method also provides an improved event parameter estimation , including timing resolution .
finally , a waveform consistency test is introduced for events that pass the time and frequency coincidence requirements in the three ligo detectors .
this search examines 9.98 days of live time and yields one candidate event in coincidence among the three ligo detectors during s2 .
subsequent examination of this event reveals an acoustic origin for the signal in the two hanford detectors , easily eliminated using a `` veto '' based on acoustic power in a microphone . taking this into account , we set an upper limit on the rate of burst events detectable by our detectors at the level of 0.26 per day at an estimated 90% confidence level
. we have used _ ad hoc _ waveforms ( sine - gaussians and gaussians ) to establish the sensitivity of the s2 search pipeline and to interpret our upper limit as an excluded region in the space of signal rate versus strength . the burst search sensitivity in terms of the _ root - sum - square _ ( rss ) strain amplitude incident on earth lies in the range @xmath2 . both the upper limit
( rate ) and its applicability to signal strengths ( sensitivity ) reflect significant improvements with respect to our s1 result @xcite .
in addition , we evaluate the sensitivity of the search to astrophysically motivated waveforms derived from models of stellar core collapse @xcite and from the merger of binary black holes @xcite . in the following sections we describe the ligo instruments and the s2 run in more detail ( section [ sec : ligos2run ] ) as well as an overview of the search pipeline ( section [ sec : pipeline ] ) . the procedure for selecting the data that we analyze
is described in section [ sec : dataselect ] .
we then present the search algorithm and the waveform consistency test used in the event selection ( section [ sec : etg_methods ] ) and discuss the role of vetoes in this search ( section [ sec : vetoes ] ) .
section [ sec : evana ] describes the final event analysis and the assignment of an upper limit on the rate of detectable bursts .
the efficiency of the search for various target waveforms is presented in section [ sec : efficiency ] .
our final results and discussion are presented in sections [ sec : results ] and [ sec : summaries ] .
ligo comprises three interferometers at two sites : an interferometer with 4 km long arms at the ligo livingston observatory in louisiana ( denoted l1 ) and interferometers with 4 km and 2 km long arms in a common vacuum system at the ligo hanford observatory in washington ( denoted h1 and h2 ) .
all are michelson interferometers with power recycling and resonant cavities in the two arms to increase the storage time ( and consequently the phase shift ) for the light returning to the beam splitter due to motions of the end mirrors @xcite .
the mirrors are suspended as pendulums from vibration - isolated platforms to protect them from external noise sources .
a detailed description of the ligo detectors as they were configured for the s1 run may be found in ref .
@xcite .
the ligo interferometers @xcite are still undergoing commissioning and have not yet reached their final operating configuration and sensitivity . between s1 and s2 a number of changes were made which resulted in improved sensitivity as well as overall instrument stability and stationarity .
the most important of these are summarized below .
the mirrors analog suspension controller electronics on the h2 and l1 interferometers were replaced with digital controllers of the type installed on h1 before the s1 run .
the addition of a separate dc bias supply for alignment relieved the range requirement of the suspensions coil drivers .
this , combined with flexibility of a digital system capable of coordinated switching of analog and digital filters , enabled the new coil drivers to operate with much lower electronics output noise . in particular , the system had two separate modes of operation : acquisition mode with larger range and noise , and run mode with reduced range and noise . a matched pair of filters was used to minimize noise in the coil current due to the discrete steps in the digital to analog converter ( dac ) at the output of the digital suspension controller : a digital filter before the dac boosted the high - frequency component relative to the low - frequency component , and an analog filter after the dac restored their relative amplitudes .
better filtering , better diagonalization of the drive to the coils to eliminate length - to - angle couplings and more flexible control / sequencing features also contributed to an overall performance improvement . the noise from the optical lever servos that damp the angular excitations of the interferometer optics was reduced . the mechanical support elements for the optical transmitter and receiver
were stiffened to reduce low frequency vibrational excitations .
input noise to the servo due to the discrete steps in the analog to digital converter ( adc ) was reduced by a filter pair surrounding the adc : an analog filter to whiten the data going into the adc and a digital filter to restore it to its full dynamic range .
further progress was made on commissioning the wavefront sensing ( wfs ) system for alignment control of the h1 interferometer .
this system uses the main laser beam to sense the proper alignment for the suspended optics . during s1 , all interferometers had two degrees of freedom for the main interferometer ( plus four degrees of freedom for the mode cleaner ) controlled by their wfs .
for s2 , the h1 interferometer had 8 out of 16 alignment degrees of freedom for the main interferometer under wfs control .
as a result , it maintained a much more uniform operating point over the run than the other two interferometers , which continued to have only two degrees of freedom under wfs control .
the high frequency sensitivity was increased by operating the interferometers with higher effective power .
two main factors enabled this power increase .
improved alignment techniques and better alignment stability ( due to the optical lever and wavefront sensor improvements described above ) reduced the amount of spurious light at the anti - symmetric port , which would have saturated the photodiode if the laser power had been increased in s1 .
also , a new servo system to cancel the out - of - phase ( non - signal ) photocurrent in the anti - symmetric photodiode was added .
this amplitude of the out - of - phase photocurrent is nominally zero for a perfectly aligned and matched interferometer , but various imperfections in the interferometer can lead to large low frequency signals .
the new servo prevents these signals from causing saturations in the photodiode and its rf preamplifier . during s2 , the interferometers operated with about @xmath4 w incident on the mode cleaner and about @xmath5 w incident on the beam splitter .
these changes led to a significant improvement in detector sensitivity .
figure [ fig : s2sens ] shows typical spectra achieved by the ligo interferometers during the s2 run compared with ligo s s1 and design sensitivity .
the differences among the three ligo s2 spectra reflect differences in the operating parameters and hardware implementations of the three instruments , which were in various stages of reaching the final design configuration .
the data analyzed in this paper were taken during ligo s second science run ( s2 ) , which spanned 59 days from february 14 to april 14 , 2003 . during this time
, operators and scientific monitors worked to maintain continuous low noise operation of the ligo instruments .
the duty cycles for the individual interferometers , defined as the fraction of the total run time when the interferometer was locked ( , all interferometer control servos operating in their linear regime ) and in its low noise configuration , were approximately 74% for h1 , 58% for h2 and 37% for l1 ; the triple coincidence duty cycle ( , the time during which all three interferometers were simultaneously in lock and in low - noise configuration ) was 22% . the longest continuous locked stretch for any interferometer during s2 was 66.2 hours for h1 .
the main sources of lost time were high microseismic motion at both sites due to storms , and anthropogenic noise in the vicinity of the livingston observatory . improved monitoring and automated alarms instituted after s1 gave the operators and scientific monitors better warnings of out - of - nominal operating conditions for the interferometers . as a result ,
the fraction of time lost to high noise or to missing calibration lines ( both major sources of unanalyzable data during the s1 run ) was greatly reduced .
thus , even though the s2 run was less than a factor of four longer than the s1 run and the duty cycle for triple interferometer coincidence was in fact marginally lower ( 23.4% for s1 vs. 22.0% for s2 ) , the total amount of _ analyzable _ triple coincidence data was 305 hours compared to 34 hours for s1 .
the signature of a gravitational wave is a differential change in the lengths of the two interferometer arms relative to the nominal lengths established by the control system , @xmath6/l$ ] , where @xmath7 is the average length of the @xmath8 and @xmath9 arms . as in s1 ,
this time series was derived from the error signal of the feedback loop used to differentially control the lengths of the interferometer arms in order to keep the optical cavities on resonance . to calibrate the error signal ,
the effect of the feedback loop gain was measured and divided out .
although more stable than during s1 , the response functions varied over the course of the s2 run due to drifts in the alignment of the optical elements .
these were tracked by injecting fixed - amplitude sinusoidal signals ( calibration lines ) into the differential arm control loop , and monitoring the amplitudes of these signals at the measurement ( error ) point @xcite .
the s2 run also involved coincident running with the tama interferometer @xcite .
tama achieved a duty cycle of 81% and had a sensitivity comparable to ligo s above @xmath10 khz , but had poorer sensitivity at lower frequencies where the ligo detectors had their best sensitivity .
in addition , the location and orientation of the tama detector differs substantially from the ligo detectors , which further reduced the chance of a coincident detection at low frequencies .
for these reasons , the joint analysis of ligo and tama data focused on gravitational wave frequencies from 7002000 hz and will be described in a separate paper @xcite . in this paper
, we report the result of a ligo - only search for signals in the range 1001100 hz . the overlap between these two searches ( 7001100 hz ) serves to ensure that possible sources with frequency content spanning the two searches will not be missed .
the geo600 interferometer @xcite , which collected data simultaneously with ligo during the s1 run , was undergoing commissioning at the time of the s2 run .
the overall burst search pipeline used in the s2 analysis follows the one we introduced in our s1 search @xcite .
first , data selection criteria are applied in order to define periods when the instruments are well behaved and the recorded data can be used for science searches ( section [ sec : dataselect ] ) . a wavelet - based algorithm called waveburst @xcite ( section [ sec : etg_methods ] ) is then used to identify candidate burst events . rather than operating on the data from a single interferometer , waveburst analyzes simultaneously the time series coming from a pair of interferometers and incorporates strength thresholding as well as time and frequency coincidence to identify transients with consistent features in the two data streams . to reduce the false alarm rate
, we further require that candidate gravitational wave events occur effectively simultaneously in all three ligo detectors ( section [ ss : triplecoinc ] ) .
besides requiring compatible waveburst event parameters , this involves a waveform consistency test , the @xmath11-statistic @xcite ( section [ sec : rstat ] ) , which is based on forming the normalized linear correlation of the raw time series coming from the ligo instruments .
this test takes advantage of the fact that the arms of the interferometers at the two ligo sites are nearly co - aligned , and therefore a gravitational wave generally will produce correlated time series .
the use of waveburst and the @xmath11-statistic are the major changes in the s2 pipeline with respect to the pipeline used for s1 @xcite .
when candidate burst events are identified , they can be checked against veto conditions based on the many auxiliary read - back channels of the servo control systems and physical environment monitoring channels that are recorded in the ligo data stream ( section [ sec : vetoes ] ) .
the background in this search is measured by artificially shifting in time the raw time series of one of the ligo instruments , l1 , and repeating the analysis as for the un - shifted data .
the time - shifted case will often be referred to as `` time - lag '' data and the unshifted case as `` zero - lag '' data .
we will describe the background estimation in more detail in section [ sec : evana ] .
we have relied on hardware and software signal `` injections '' in order to establish the efficiency of the pipeline . simulated signals with various morphologies @xcite were added to the digitized raw data time series at the beginning of our analysis pipeline and were used to establish the fraction of detected events as a function of their strength ( section [ sec : efficiency ] ) .
the same analysis pipeline was used to analyze raw ( zero - lag ) , time - lag , and injection data samples .
we maintain a detailed list with a number of checks to perform for any zero - lag event(s ) surviving the analysis pipeline to evaluate whether they could plausibly be gravitational wave bursts .
this `` detection check - list '' is updated as we learn more about the instruments and refine our methodology .
a major aspect is the examination of environmental and auxiliary interferometric channels in order to identify terrestrial disturbances that might produce a candidate event through some coupling mechanism .
any remaining events are compared with the background and the experiment s live time in order to establish a detection or an upper limit on the rate of burst events .
the selection of data to be analyzed was a key first step in this search .
we expect a gravitational wave to appear in all three ligo instruments , although in some cases it may be at or below the level of the noise . for this search ,
we _ require _ a signal above the noise baseline in all three instruments in order to suppress the rate of noise fluctuations that may fake astrophysical burst events . in the case of a genuine astrophysical event
this requirement will not only increase our detection confidence but it will also allow us to extract in the best possible way the signal and source parameters . therefore , for this search we have confined ourselves to periods of time when all three ligo interferometers were simultaneously locked in low noise mode with nominal operating parameters ( nominal servo loop gains , nominal filter settings , etc . ) , marked by a manually set bit ( `` science mode '' ) in the data stream .
this produced a total of 318 hours of potential data for analysis .
this total was reduced by the following data selection cuts : * a minimum duration of 300 seconds was required for a triple coincidence segment to be analyzed for this search .
this cut eliminated @xmath12% of the initial data set . * post - run re - examination of the interferometer configuration and status channels included in the data stream identified a small amount of time when the interferometer configuration deviated from nominal .
in addition we identified short periods of time when the timing system for the data acquisition had lost synchronization .
these cuts reduced the data set by @xmath13% . *
it was discovered that large low frequency excitations of the interferometer could cause the photodiode at the anti - symmetric port to saturate .
this caused bursts of excess noise due to nonlinear up - conversion .
these periods of time were identified and eliminated , reducing the data set by 0.3% .
* there were occasional periods of time when the calibration lines either were absent or were significantly weaker than normal .
eliminating these periods reduced the data set by approximately 2% .
* the h1 interferometer had a known problem with a marginally stable servo loop , which occasionally led to higher than normal noise in the error signal for the differential arm length ( the channel used in this search for gravitational waves ) .
a data cut was imposed to eliminate periods of time when the rms noise in the 200400 hz band of this channel exceeded a threshold value for 5 consecutive minutes .
the requirement for 5 consecutive minutes was imposed to prevent a short burst of gravitational waves ( the object of this search ) from triggering this cut .
this cut reduced the data set by 0.4% .
these data quality cuts eliminated a total of 13 hours from the original 318 hours of triple coincidence data , leaving a `` live - time '' of 305 hours .
the fraction of data surviving these quality cuts ( 96% ) is a significant improvement over the experience in s1 when only 37% of the data passed all the quality cuts . the trigger generation software used in this search ( to be described in the next section ) processed data in fixed 2-minute time intervals , requiring good data quality for the entire interval .
this constraint , along with other constraints imposed by other trigger generation methods which were initially used to define a common data set , led to a net loss of 41 hours , leaving 264 hours of triple coincidence data actually searched .
the search for bursts in the ligo s2 data used roughly 10% of the triple coincidence data set in order to tune the pipeline ( as described below ) and establish event selection criteria .
this data set was chosen uniformly across the acquisition time and constituted the so - called `` playground '' for the search .
the rate bound calculated in sec .
[ sec : evana ] reflects only the remaining @xmath1490% of the data , in order to avoid bias from the tuning procedures .
an accurate knowledge of gravitational wave burst waveforms would allow the use of _ matched filtering _
@xcite along the lines of the search for binary inspirals @xcite . however , many different astrophysical systems may give rise to gravitational wave bursts , and the physics of these systems is often very complicated .
even when numerical relativistic calculations have been carried out , as in the case of core collapse supernovae , they generally yield roughly representative waveforms rather than exact predictions .
therefore , our present searches for gravitational wave bursts use general algorithms which are sensitive to a wide range of potential signals .
the first ligo burst search @xcite used two event trigger generator ( etg ) algorithms : a time - domain method designed to detect a large `` slope '' ( time derivative ) in the data stream after suitable filtering @xcite , and a method called tfclusters @xcite which is based on identifying clusters of excess power in time - frequency spectrograms .
several other burst - search methods have been developed by members of the ligo scientific collaboration .
for this paper , we have chosen to focus on a single etg called waveburst which identifies clusters of excess power once the signal is decomposed in the wavelet domain , as described below .
other methods which were applied to the s2 data include tfclusters ; the excess power statistic of anderson _ et al . _
@xcite ; and the `` block - normal '' time - domain algorithm @xcite . in preliminary studies using s2 playground data , these other methods had sensitivities comparable to waveburst for the target waveforms described in section [ sec : efficiency ] , but their implementations were less mature at the time of this analysis . an integral part of our s2 search and the final event trigger selection is to perform a consistency test among the data streams recorded by the different interferometers at each trigger time identified by the etg .
this is done using the @xmath11-statistic @xcite , a time - domain cross - correlation method sensitive to the coherent part of the candidate signals , described in subsection c below .
waveburst is an etg that searches for gravitational wave bursts in the wavelet time - frequency domain .
it is described in greater detail in @xcite .
the method uses wavelet transformations in order to obtain the time - frequency representation of the data .
bursts are identified by searching for regions in the wavelet time - frequency domain with an excess of power , coincident between two or more interferometers , that is inconsistent with stationary detector noise .
waveburst processes gravitational wave data from two interferometers at a time . as shown in fig .
[ fig : pipeline ] the analysis is performed over three ligo detectors resulting in the production of triggers for three detector pairs .
the three sets of triggers are then compared in a `` triple coincidence '' step which checks for consistent trigger times and frequency components , as will be described in section [ ss : triplecoinc ] . for each detector pair
, the waveburst etg performs the following steps : ( a ) wavelet transformation applied to the gravitational wave channel from each detector , ( b ) selection of wavelet amplitudes exceeding a threshold , ( c ) identification of common wavelet components in the two channels , ( d ) clustering of nearby wavelet components , and ( e ) selection of burst triggers . during steps ( a ) , ( b ) and ( d ) the data processing is independent for each channel . during steps ( c ) and ( e ) data from both channels are used .
the input data to the waveburst etg are time series from the gravitational wave channel with duration of @xmath15 seconds and sampling rate of @xmath16 hz .
before the wavelet transformation is applied the data are downsampled by a factor of two . using an orthogonal wavelet transformation ( based on a symlet wavelet with filter length of 60 ) the time series
are converted into wavelet series @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the time index and @xmath19 is the wavelet layer index .
each wavelet layer can be associated with a certain frequency band of the initial time series .
the time - frequency resolution of the waveburst scalograms is the same for all the wavelet layers ( @xmath20 sec @xmath21 hz ) .
therefore , the wavelet series @xmath17 can be displayed as a time - frequency scalogram consisting of 64 wavelet layers with @xmath22 pixels ( data samples ) each .
this tiling is different from the one in the conventional dyadic wavelet decomposition where the time resolution adjusts to the scale ( frequency ) @xcite .
the constant time - frequency resolution makes the waveburst scalograms similar to spectrograms produced with windowed fourier transformations . for each layer we first select a fixed fraction @xmath23 of pixels with the largest absolute amplitudes .
these are called _
black pixels_. the number of selected black pixels is @xmath24 .
all other wavelet pixels are called _
white pixels_. then we calculate rank statistics for the black pixels within each layer .
the rank @xmath25 is an integer number from 1 to @xmath24 , with the rank 1 assigned to the pixel with the largest absolute amplitude in the layer .
given the rank of wavelet amplitudes @xmath25 , the following non - parametric pixel statistic is computed @xmath26 for white pixels the value of @xmath27 is set to zero . the statistic @xmath27 can be interpreted as the pixel s _
logarithmic significance_. assuming gaussian detector noise , the logarithmic significance can be also calculated as @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the absolute value of the pixel amplitude in units of the noise standard deviation . in practice ,
the ligo detector noise is not gaussian and its probability distribution function is not determined _ a priori_. therefore , we use the non - parametric statistic @xmath27 , which is a more robust measure of the pixel significance than @xmath30 . using the inverse function of @xmath31 with @xmath27 as an argument
, we introduce the _ non - parametric amplitude _ @xmath32 and the _ excess power ratio _
@xmath33 which characterizes the pixel excess power above the average detector noise .
after the black pixels are selected , we require their time - coincidence in the two channels . given a black pixel of significance @xmath27 in the first channel , this is accepted if the significance of neighboring ( in time ) pixels in the second channel ( @xmath34 ) satisfies @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the _ coincidence threshold_. otherwise , the pixel is rejected .
this procedure is repeated for all the black pixels in the first channel .
the same coincidence algorithm is applied to pixels in the second channel . as a result
, a considerable number of black pixels in both channels produced by fluctuations of the detector noise are rejected . at the same time
, black pixels produced by gravitational wave bursts have a high acceptance probability because of the coherent excess of power in two detectors .
after the coincidence procedure is applied to both channels a clustering algorithm is applied jointly to the two channel pixel maps . as a first step ,
we merge ( or ) the black pixels from both channels into one time - frequency plane . for each black pixel
we define neighbors ( either black or white ) , which share a side or a vertex with the black pixel .
the white neighbors are called _ halo _ pixels .
we define a cluster as a group of black and halo pixels which are connected either by a side or a vertex .
after the cluster reconstruction , we go back to the original time - frequency planes and calculate the cluster parameters separately for each channel . therefore , there are always two clusters , one per channel , which form a waveburst trigger .
the cluster parameters are calculated using black pixels only .
for example , the cluster size @xmath37 is defined as the number of black pixels .
other parameters which characterize the cluster strength are the cluster excess power ratio @xmath38 and the cluster _ logarithmic likelihood _ @xmath39 . given a cluster @xmath40 ,
these are estimated by summing over the black pixels in the cluster : @xmath41 given the times @xmath42 of individual pixels , the cluster center time is calculated as @xmath43 as configured for this analysis , waveburst initially generated triggers with frequency content between 64 hz and 4096 hz . as we will see below , the cluster size , likelihood , and excess power ratio can be used for the further selection of triggers , while the cluster time and frequency span are used in a coincidence requirement . the frequency band of interest for this analysis , 1001100 hz , is selected during the later stages of the analysis .
there are two main waveburst tunable input parameters : the black pixel fraction @xmath23 which is applied to each frequency layer , and the coincidence threshold @xmath36 .
the purpose of these parameters is to control the average black pixel occupancy @xmath44 , the fraction of black pixels over the entire time - frequency scalogram . to ensure robust cluster reconstruction
, the occupancy should not be greater than @xmath45% .
for white gaussian detector noise the functional form of @xmath44 can be calculated analytically .
this can be used to set a constraint on @xmath23 and @xmath36 for a given target @xmath44 .
if @xmath23 is set too small ( less then a few percent ) , noise outliers due to instrumental glitches may monopolize the limited number of available black pixels and thus allow gravitational wave signals to remain hidden . to avoid this domination of instrumental glitches
, we run the analysis with @xmath23 equal to 10% .
this value of @xmath23 together with the occupancy target @xmath44 of 0.7% defines the coincidence threshold @xmath36 at 1.5 .
all the tuning of the waveburst method was performed on the s2 playground data set ( section [ sec : dataselect ] ) .
for the selected values of @xmath23 and @xmath36 , the average trigger rate per ligo instrument pair was approximately @xmath46 hz , about twice the false alarm rate expected for white gaussian detector noise .
the trigger rate was further reduced by imposing cuts on the excess power ratio @xmath38 . for clusters of size
@xmath37 greater than @xmath45 we required @xmath38 to be greater than @xmath47 while for single pixel clusters ( @xmath48 ) we used a more restrictive cut of @xmath38 greater than @xmath49 .
this selection on the event parameters further reduced the counting rates per ligo instrument pair to @xmath50 hz .
the times and reconstructed parameters of waveburst events passing these criteria were written onto disk .
this allowed the further processing and selection of these events without the need to re - analyze the full data stream , a process which is generally time and cpu intensive .
further selection of waveburst events proceeds by identifying triple coincidences .
the output of the waveburst etg is a set of coincident triggers for a selected interferometer pair @xmath51 .
each waveburst trigger consists of two clusters , one in @xmath52 and one in @xmath53 .
for the three ligo interferometers there are three possible pairs : ( l1,h1 ) , ( h1,h2 ) and ( h2,l1 ) . in order to establish triple coincidence events ,
we require a time - frequency coincidence of the waveburst triggers generated for these three pairs .
to evaluate the time coincidence we first construct @xmath54 , , the average central time of the @xmath52 and @xmath53 clusters for the trigger .
three such combined central times are thus constructed : @xmath55 , @xmath56 , and @xmath57 .
we then require that all possible differences of these combined central times fall within a time window @xmath58 ms .
this window is large enough to accommodate the maximum difference in gravitational wave arrival times at the two detector sites ( @xmath59 ms ) and the intrinsic time resolution of the waveburst algorithm which has an rms on the order of @xmath60 ms as discussed in section [ sec : efficiency ] .
we apply a loose requirement on the frequency consistency of the waveburst triggers .
first , we calculate the minimum ( @xmath61 ) and maximum ( @xmath62 ) frequency for each interferometer pair @xmath63 @xmath64 where @xmath65 and @xmath66 are the low and high frequency boundaries of the @xmath52 and @xmath53 clusters .
then , the trigger frequency bands are calculated as @xmath67 for all pairs . for the frequency coincidence ,
the bands of all three waveburst triggers are required to overlap .
an average frequency is then calculated from the clusters , weighted by signal - to - noise ratio , and the coincident event candidate is kept for this analysis if this average frequency is above 64 hz and below 1100 hz .
the final step in the coincidence analysis of the waveburst events involves the construction of a single measure of their combined significance . as we described already , triple coincidence events consist of three waveburst triggers involving a total of six clusters .
each cluster has its parameters calculated on a per - interferometer basis .
assuming white detector noise , the variable @xmath39 for a cluster of size @xmath37 follows a gamma probability distribution .
this motivates the use of the following measure of the _ cluster significance _ : @xmath68 which is derived from the logarithmic likelihood @xmath39 of a cluster @xmath40 and from the number @xmath37 of black pixels in that cluster @xcite .
given the significance of the six clusters , we compute the _ combined significance _ of the triple coincidence event as @xmath69 where @xmath70 ( @xmath71 ) is the significance of the @xmath52 ( @xmath53 ) cluster for the @xmath63 interferometer pair . in order to evaluate the rate of accidental coincidences , we have repeated the above analysis on the data after introducing an unphysical time shift ( `` lag '' ) in the livingston data stream relative to the hanford data streams .
the hanford data streams are not shifted relative to one another , so any noise correlations from the local environment are preserved .
figure [ fig : signif ] shows the distribution of cluster significance ( equation [ eq : clustersig ] ) from the three individual detectors , and the combined significance ( equation [ eq : combsig ] ) , over the entire s2 data set , for both zero - lag and time - lag coincidences . using 46 such time - lag instances of the s2 playground data we have set the threshold on @xmath72 for this search in order to yield a targeted false alarm rate of @xmath73hz . without significantly compromising the pipeline sensitivity ,
this threshold was selected to be @xmath74 . in the 641100 hz frequency band ,
the resulting false alarm rate in the s2 playground analysis was approximately @xmath75hz .
the coincident events selected by waveburst in this way are then checked for their waveform consistency using the @xmath11-statistic . the @xmath11-statistic test @xcite is applied as the final step of searching for gravitational wave event candidates
. this test re - analyzes the raw ( unprocessed ) interferometer data around the times of coincident events identified by the waveburst etg .
the fundamental building block in performing this waveform consistency test is the @xmath11-statistic , or the normalized linear correlation coefficient of two sequences , @xmath76 and @xmath77 ( in this case , the two gravitational wave signal time series ) : @xmath78 where @xmath79 and @xmath80 are their respective mean values .
this quantity assumes values between @xmath81 for fully anti - correlated sequences and @xmath82 for fully correlated sequences . for uncorrelated white noise
, we expect the @xmath11-statistic values obtained for arbitrary sets of points of length @xmath83 to follow a normal distribution with zero mean and @xmath84 . any coherent component in the two sequences will cause @xmath11 to deviate from the above normal distribution . as a normalized quantity ,
the @xmath11-statistic does not attempt to measure the consistency between the relative amplitudes of the two sequences .
consequently , it offers the advantage of being robust against fluctuations of detector amplitude response and noise floor .
a similar method based on this type of time - domain cross - correlation has been implemented in a ligo search for gravitational waves associated with a grb @xcite and elsewhere @xcite . as will be described below
, the final output of the @xmath11-statistic test is a combined confidence statistic which is constructed from @xmath11-statistic values calculated for all three pairs of interferometers . for each pair , we use only the absolute value of the statistic , @xmath85 , rather than the signed value .
this is because an astrophysical signal can produce either a correlation or an anticorrelation in the interferometers at the two ligo sites , depending on its sky position and polarization .
in fact , the @xmath11-statistic analysis was done using whitened ( see below ) but otherwise uncalibrated data , with an arbitrary sign convention .
a signed correlation test using calibrated data would be appropriate for the h1-h2 pair , but all three pairs were treated equivalently in the present analysis . the number of points @xmath83 considered in calculating the statistic in eq .
( [ eqn : rstat ] ) , or equivalently the _ integration time _
@xmath86 , is the most important parameter in the construction of the @xmath11-statistic .
its optimal value depends in general on the duration of the signal being considered for detection . if @xmath86 is too long , the candidate signal is `` washed out '' by the noise when computing @xmath11 . on the other hand ,
if it is too short , then only part of the coherent signal is included in the integration .
simulation studies have shown that most of the short - lived signals of interest to the ligo burst search can be identified successfully using a set of three discrete integration times with lengths of 20 , 50 and 100 ms . within its ligo implementation , the @xmath11-statistic analysis first performs data `` conditioning '' to restrict the frequency content of the data to ligo s most sensitive band and to suppress any coherent lines and instrumental artifacts .
each data stream is first band - pass filtered with an 8th - order butterworth filter with corner frequencies of 100 hz and 1572 hz , then down - sampled to a 4096 hz sampling rate .
the upper frequency of 1572 hz was chosen in order to have 20 db suppression at 2048 hz and thus avoid aliasing . the lower frequency of 100 hz
was chosen to suppress the contribution of seismic noise ; it also defines the lower edge of the frequency band for this gravitational wave burst search , since it is above the lower frequency limit of 64 hz for waveburst triggers .
the band - passed data are then whitened with a linear predictor error filter with a 10 hz resolution trained on a 10 second period before the event start time .
the filter removes predictable content , including lines that were stationary over a 10 second time scale .
it also has the effect of suppressing frequency bands with large stationary noise , thus emphasizing transients @xcite .
the next step in the @xmath11-statistic analysis involves the construction of all the possible @xmath11 coefficients given the number of interferometer pairs involved in the trigger , their possible relative time - delays due to their geographic separation , and the various integration times being considered .
relative time delays up to @xmath87 ms are considered for each detector pair , corresponding to the light travel time between the hanford and livingston sites .
future analyses will restrict the time delay to a much smaller value when correlating data from the two hanford interferometers , to allow only for time calibration uncertainties .
furthermore , in the case of waveburst triggers with reported durations greater than the integration time @xmath86 , multiple integration _
windows _ of that length are considered , offset from the reported start time of the trigger by multiples of @xmath88 . for a given integration window indexed by @xmath89 ( containing @xmath90 data samples ) , ordered pair of instruments indexed by @xmath91 @xmath92 , and relative time delay indexed by @xmath37 , the @xmath11-statistic value @xmath93 is calculated . for each @xmath94 combination ,
the _ distribution _ of @xmath93 for all values of @xmath37 is compared to the null hypothesis expectation of a normal distribution with zero mean and @xmath95 using the kolmogorov - smirnov test .
if these are statistically consistent at the 95% level , then the algorithm assigns no significance to any apparent correlation in this detector pair .
otherwise , a one - sided significance and its associated logarithmic confidence are calculated from the _ maximum _ value of @xmath93 for any time delay , compared to what would be expected if there were no correlation .
confidence values for all ordered detector pairs are then averaged to define the combined correlation confidence for a given integration window .
the final result of the @xmath11-statistic test , @xmath96 , is the maximum of the combined correlation confidence over all of the integration windows being considered .
events with a value of @xmath96 above a given threshold are finally selected . the @xmath11-statistic implementation , filter parameters , and set of integration times were chosen based on their performance for various simulated signals .
the single remaining parameter , the threshold on @xmath96 , was tuned primarily in order to ensure that much less than one background event was expected in the whole s2 run , corresponding to a rate of o@xmath97hz . since the rate of waveburst triggers was approximately @xmath75hz , as mentioned in section [ ss : triplecoinc ] , a rejection factor of around 150 was required .
table [ t : reject ] shows the rejection efficiency of the @xmath11-statistic test for two thresholds on @xmath96 when the test is applied to white gaussian noise ( 200 ms segments ) , to real s2 interferometer noise at randomly selected times ( 200 ms segments ) , and to the data at the times of time - lag ( , background ) waveburst triggers in the s2 playground . in the first two cases ,
200 ms of data was processed by the @xmath11-statistic algorithm , whereas in the latter case , the amount of data processed was determined by the trigger duration reported by waveburst .
the table shows that random detector noise rarely produced a @xmath96 value above @xmath98 , but the rejection factor for waveburst triggers was not high enough .
a @xmath96 threshold of @xmath99 was ultimately chosen for this analysis , yielding an estimated rejection factor of @xmath100 for waveburst triggers .
[ htb ] .percentage of s2 background events rejected by the @xmath11-statistic for two different thresholds on @xmath96 . [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ]
the waveburst algorithm estimates the signal strength from the measured excess power in the cluster pixels , expressed as @xmath101 as in equation [ eq : hrss ] but with the integrand being the antenna - pattern - corrected @xmath102 given by equation [ eq : hdet ] rather than the intrinsic @xmath103 of the gravitational wave .
figure [ fig : sg_hrss ] shows that this quantity is slightly overestimated on average , particularly for weak signals .
several factors contribute to mis - estimation of the signal strength .
waveburst limits the signal @xmath101 integration to within the detected time - frequency volume of an event and not over the entire theoretical support of a signal .
errors in the determination of the signal s time - frequency volume due to thresholding may lead to systematic uncertainties in the determination of its strength .
the @xmath101 shown in fig . [ fig : sg_hrss ] also reflects the folding of the measurements from all three ligo instruments and thus it is affected by calibration errors and noise fluctuations in any instrument .
our simulation analysis has shown that the detected signal s @xmath101 is the quantity most sensitive to detector noise and its variability ; for this reason , it is not used in any step of the analysis either as part of the coincidence analysis or for the final event selection . ] during the s2 data taking , as well as shortly before and after it , several run intervals were designated for hardware signal injections .
these injections were intended to address any instrumental issues , including calibrations , and provide a robust end - to - end test of ligo s data analysis pipelines .
they also provided an important tool for establishing the `` safety '' of the veto analysis , , the absence of any couplings between a real gravitational wave burst and the auxiliary channels we considered as potential vetoes ( section [ sec : vetoes ] ) . an arbitrary function generator connected to the mirror position actuators provided the capability of exciting the mirrors according to a simulated gravitational wave pattern .
the waveforms injected through this hardware calibration included several of the ones described in the target waveform section above .
the signals were injected into all three ligo instruments at identical times , without attempting to mock up the relative time delays and amplitudes that would be produced by a source at a particular position in the sky .
thus the coincidence analysis , using the end - to - end pipeline invoked in the analysis of the real data alone as well as with software injections , was not fully appropriate for the hardware injections . we have restricted ourselves to examining the performance of the ligo instruments and of the waveburst etg in detecting these events and reconstructing their signal parameters using each individual detector . both the time and frequency reconstruction by the waveburst algorithm on these hardware - injected signals is consistent with our software injections and within our expectations .
the largest source of systematic error in the efficiency of this search is uncertainty in the absolute calibration of the detectors .
several contributions to this uncertainty have been considered @xcite .
systematic uncertainties are less than 12% for l1 , 5% for h1 , and 6% for h2 over the frequency band used in this analysis .
the calibration at any given point in time is subject to an additional uncertainty from detector noise affecting the measurement of the amplitude of the calibration lines .
these random errors were especially large near the beginning of the run , when the h1 and l1 calibration lines were rather weak .
however , the efficiency of the search , averaged over the run , is insensitive to these random errors .
the overall systematic uncertainty on the triple - coincidence efficiency is a combination of the individual systematic uncertainties which depends on the relative sensitivities of the detectors , with the least sensitive detector having the greatest influence . as shown in fig .
[ fig : s2sens ] , h2 was the least sensitive detector at low frequencies while h1 was the least sensitive at high frequencies . the net uncertainty in the efficiency is estimated to be less than 8% at all frequencies .
no significant systematic error is attributed to the procedure we followed in order to perform the efficiency measurement .
the various signal morphologies were superimposed over the entire s2 data sample and its full range of detector behavior . the statistical error attributed to the finite number of simulations used for the efficiency measurement
is reflected in the goodness of the sigmoid - like fits and is estimated to be less than 5% .
the efficiency measurement was performed in multiple slightly - varying ways all of which yielded results within one standard deviation .
these variations included different sampling of the s2 data set , different versions of the calibration constants , and different number and placement of the signal injections . combining all uncertainties
, we estimate our efficiency to any given signal morphology to be accurate at the 10% level or better .
as we have seen in section [ sec : evana ] , using the zero - lag and background rate measurements we set an upper bound on the rate of gravitational wave bursts at the instruments at the level of @xmath104 events per day at the 90% confidence level .
we will now use the measurement of the efficiency of the search as described in the previous section in order to associate the above rate bound with the strength of the gravitational wave burst events .
this is the rate versus strength interpretation that we introduced in our previous search for bursts in ligo using the s1 data @xcite . the rate bound of our search as a function of signal strength @xmath101 is given by @xmath105 where the numerator @xmath36 is the upper bound on the rate of detectable signal events at a given confidence level ( sec .
[ ss : ratelimit ] ) and the denominator is the fractional efficiency for signals of strength @xmath101 ( at the earth ) . this rate versus strength interpretation makes the same assumptions on the signal morphology and origin as the ones that enter in the determination of the efficiency . in fig .
[ fig : gsg_exclude ] we show the rate versus strength upper limit for the sine - gaussian and gaussian waveform families . for a given signal strength @xmath101 these plots give the upper limit at the 90% confidence level on the rate of burst events at the instruments with strength equal to or greater than @xmath101 . in that sense ,
the part of the plot above and to the right of these curves defines the region of signal strength - rate excluded by this search at 90% confidence level .
as one would expect , for strong enough signals the efficiency of the search is 1 for all the signal morphologies : this part of the plot remains flat at a level that is set primarily by the observation time of this search . for weaker signals
the efficiency decreases and the strength - rate plot curves up . eventually , as the efficiency vanishes the rate limit reaches infinity asymptotically .
these curves for the various waveforms are not identical , as the detailed trailing off of the efficiency is dependent on the waveform .
the exclusion rate - strength plots obtained from the s2 analysis represent a significant improvement with respect to the s1 result @xcite . as already noted in section [ sec : evana ] , the horizontal part of the plot determined by the observation time is improved by a factor of 6 while the sensitivity - limited curved part of it reflects an improvement in the efficiency of a factor of 17 or better , depending on the waveform morphology .
exclusion plots at the 90% confidence level derived from the ligo burst search using the s2 data .
the top plot corresponds to burst events modeled by sine - gaussians of q=8.9 and frequencies ranging from 100 hz to 849 hz , while the bottom plot corresponds to ones events modeled by gaussians of the @xmath86 s shown . for comparison ,
the corresponding curves resulting from the s1 analysis are superimposed .
, title="fig : " ] exclusion plots at the 90% confidence level derived from the ligo burst search using the s2 data .
the top plot corresponds to burst events modeled by sine - gaussians of q=8.9 and frequencies ranging from 100 hz to 849 hz , while the bottom plot corresponds to ones events modeled by gaussians of the @xmath86 s shown . for comparison ,
the corresponding curves resulting from the s1 analysis are superimposed .
, title="fig : " ] as mentioned in the introduction , potential sources of gravitational wave bursts targeted in this search include core collapse supernovae , merging compact binaries ( neutron stars and/or black holes ) and gamma ray bursts . in recent years
there has been much effort devoted to predicting gravitational wave burst waveforms from astrophysical sources , generally relying on detailed numerical and approximation methods .
our search is designed to be sensitive to a broad range of short - duration bursts , so we wish to evaluate how it performs for plausible astrophysical signals suggested by certain models . as part of our signal simulation analysis for this search ,
we focus in particular on the case of the core collapse of rapidly spinning massive stars @xcite , and of binary black hole mergers @xcite .
the core collapse simulations employ detailed hydrodynamical models in two dimensions , enforcing axisymmetry of the rotating star throughout its evolution .
the core collapse is initiated artificially ( , through a change in the adiabatic index of the core material @xcite ) .
an accelerating quadrupole moment is calculated in 2d from the distribution and flow of matter during the collapse , from which the gravitational wave signal is derived .
the rapid spinning of the progenitor star may produce multiple bounces of the dense core , which is reflected in the waveform of the emitted waves .
simple models of the differential rotation of material in the star also lead to significant differences in the resulting waveforms .
relativistic effects @xcite , if included , serve to effectively `` stiffen '' the core , shifting the waves to higher frequencies and shorter durations .
the simulation is followed through the core collapse phase when most of the gravitational wave signal is produced ; it need not be continued through to the explosion of the outer layers ( and indeed , these simulations may not produce such explosions ) . the simulations attempt to sample the space of important parameters ( progenitor star angular momentum , differential angular momentum versus radius , density versus radius , adiabatic index of the core , ) , resulting in collections of waveforms with widely varying morphologies ; but of course the actual distributions of such parameters are poorly known . in ref .
@xcite the authors employ updated progenitor models and nuclear equation of state . for the studies described here , we make use of 78 waveforms supplied in ref .
@xcite , 26 from ref .
@xcite , and 72 from ref .
we emphasize that we are studying these waveforms only as a guide for evaluating our search algorithm ; we do not rely on accurately modelling a realistic population of progenitor stars .
the binary black hole merger waveforms are taken from the lazarus project @xcite , which combines numerical simulation of the vacuum einstein equations for the most significantly nonlinear part of the interaction with close - limit perturbation theory for the late - time dynamics .
the authors in @xcite generate waveforms from simulations of equal mass binary black holes with no intrinsic spin starting from near the innermost stable circular orbit following a binary black hole inspiral .
it should be kept in mind that these waveforms include the ringdown phase of the binary system and would naturally occur after an inspiral waveform , which is searched for using matched filtering techniques @xcite . in all of these models ,
the simulations and calculations predict gravitational wave bursts with time durations ranging from a fraction of a millisecond to tens or hundreds of milliseconds and with a significant fraction of their power in ligo s most sensitive frequency band ( 1001100 hz ) .
this observation motivates the choice of parameters for the sine - gaussian and gaussian waveforms used to optimize and evaluate the efficiency for our search pipeline , as discussed in section [ sec : efficiency ] . after tuning our pipeline algorithms using these _ ad hoc _ waveforms , we evaluate the efficiency for our search to detect the waveforms predicted from the astrophysical simulations .
the amplitudes of these waveforms are predicted by the simulations , so that in addition to evaluating the efficiency as a function of @xmath101 ( at the earth ) , we can also present them as a function of distance to the source ( for a particular source inclination ) .
we have evaluated the efficiency versus actual distance , averaged over source directions and polarizations , assuming an isotropic distribution in source direction .
this assumption becomes invalid for supernova progenitors in the galactic disk , when the ligo detectors become sensitive to supernovae at distances greater than the disk thickness ( on the order of 150 pc ) .
it is also invalid for extra - galactic binary black hole mergers , since the distribution of nearby galaxies is far from isotropic at the 1 mpc scale .
this evaluation of the efficiency as a function of distance is only to `` set the scale '' for the current and future astrophysical searches . for the case of core collapse supernovae we considered the collections of waveforms from the three studies discussed above @xcite .
there are 176 such supernovae waveforms .
they are generally broad - band in frequency ; for 115 of them their central frequency is within the sensitive band of this search ( 1001100 hz ) and for them we established strength and distance sensitivities .
sources were uniformly distributed over the whole sky with random polarization and fixed , optimal inclination . for detecting these waveforms , @xmath101 amplitudes of a few times @xmath106 corresponding to source distances of the order of 100 pc were required .
such close - by supernovae are , of course , quite rare . in fig .
[ fig : sn2 ] we show the expected @xmath101 ( at the detectors ) and the central frequency for each of the 176 supernovae waveforms assuming they originate from a core collapse supernovae that is optimally oriented and polarized and is located at 100 pc from the detectors . superimposed , we show the sensitivity of the ligo instruments during s2 . at the detectors versus central frequency for the 176 supernovae waveforms from the three models described in references @xcite : the hydrodynamical model of ref .
@xcite , labeled `` zm '' , the relativistic effects considered in ref
. @xcite and labeled `` dfm '' , and finally the hydrodynamical model employing realistic nuclear equation of state of ref .
@xcite , labeled `` oblw '' . in all cases , the supernova events are positioned in optimal orientation and polarization at 100 pc from the detectors .
the strain sensitivity of the l1 detector during the s2 run is shown for comparison .
[ fig : sn2 ] ] for the case of binary black hole mergers , we have considered systems of black hole mass in the range of 10 - 90 @xmath107 .
the characteristic frequency of the resulting waveform is inversely proportional to the mass of the system and thus five different masses of 10 , 30 , 50 , 70 and 90 @xmath107 were chosen in order to span the nominal frequency band of this search , , the 1001100 hz band .
moreover , the waveforms of these systems @xcite come with two polarizations and they thus offered a check of the robustness of the waveform consistency test , the @xmath11-statistic , against complex morphologies . the efficiency is calculated over the whole sky considering the two polarization waveforms and a fixed inclination angle .
the best performing mass system corresponds to 50 @xmath107 : the characteristic frequency of this system corresponds to the best operating point of the ligo instruments , , close to 250 hz . on the contrary , the two worst performing mass systems reflect frequencies at the two ends of the ligo instrument s sensitivities relevant to this search , , 100 hz and 1100 hz . as with the supernova waveforms ,
the black - hole simulations provide us with order - of - magnitude estimates of the distance to which our detectors were sensitive to such astrophysical systems during the s2 run . for the lazarus black - hole mergers our @xmath101 amplitudes of a few times
@xmath106 correspond to distances of order 1 mpc .
all four waveform families we have considered for our simulations , either _
ad hoc _ or astrophysically motivated , have frequency content that ranges over the entire band of our search . within each of these families ,
signal strengths in order to reach fixed efficiency ( , 50% ) range over approximately an order of magnitude ; this is primarily a manifestation of the different frequency content of each waveform and the fact that the ligo detectors frequency response is not flat ( and varies by an order of magnitude or more over the 1001100 hz band , as shown in fig .
[ fig : s2sens ] ) .
we are in the process of augmenting the waveform library to be considered in future ligo burst searches .
this will give us further opportunities to test the robustness of our methods and the use of @xmath101 as a measure of the signal strength relevant to burst detection in ligo .
we have presented a search for gravitational wave bursts using the data the three ligo detectors collected during their second science run .
transients with sufficient energy in ligo s most sensitive band during the s2 run , 1001100 hz , were searched for . a search for gravitational wave bursts with frequency content above the 1100 hz range
is being pursued in coincidence with the tama @xcite detector and will be described in a separate publication @xcite .
our analysis yielded a single candidate event which was subsequently determined to be terrestrial in origin and was vetoed retroactively .
incorporating this into a frequentist statistical approach , we set an upper limit on the rate of strong gravitational wave bursts of @xmath104 events per day at the 90% confidence level .
this rate limit is a factor of 6 below our previously published value @xcite , due primarily to the longer duration of the s2 run and to better data quality .
the efficiency of this search was measured using various waveform morphologies .
besides the families of _ ad hoc _ waveforms we introduced in our previous search , we also measured the efficiency of our search to astrophysically motivated waveforms resulting from numerical simulations of the core collapse supernovae and binary black hole mergers . for most of the waveforms
considered , the values of @xmath101 at 50% efficiency lie in the @xmath108 range .
the sensitivity attained by this search represents an improvement with respect to s1 by a factor of 17 or more for waveforms studied in both searches .
this difference is frequency dependent and mainly reflects the instruments noise floor improvement by a factor of @xmath1410 .
the rest is attributed to improvements of the search algorithm and the use of the waveform consistency test ( @xmath11-statistic ) , allowing a lower effective threshold on signal amplitude .
the interpreted results of this search include the rate versus strength exclusion curves on a per waveform morphology basis .
the improvements on the rate and signal strength sensitivity are both reflected in significantly more stringent regions now allowed in these rate versus strength plots . in our s1 paper
, we made a comparison with results from searches with broad - band interferometric detectors described in @xcite .
the upper limit set by these detectors is at the level of 0.94 events per day and with a signal strength sensitivity of @xmath109 , both of which are now surpassed by our s2 search . in our s1 paper we also compared with the results of the igec search for gravitational wave bursts @xcite .
ligo s broad band response allowed us to set better limits on bursts whose power was mainly at frequencies away from the bars resonances . at or near the bars resonant frequencies ,
however , the igec search benefited from a much longer observing time and somewhat better sensitivity at those frequencies , and thus was able to set rate limits far below what we were able to do in ligo . with improved sensitivity in s2 ,
it is interesting to again compare ligo s performance at a frequency near the bars resonance . in order to perform this comparison in
our published s1 work @xcite we chose the sine - gaussian simulations at 849 hz frequency and with q=8.9 .
although this waveform morphology has significant signal power in the narrow frequency band ( 895930 hz ) of sensitivity for most of the igec detectors , it actually fails to maintain an approximately flat fourier spectrum over the broader range ( 694930 hz ) needed in order to encompass all of them .
for this reason , in order to perform the same comparison in s2 we have used the gaussian of @xmath86=0.1 ms signal morphology which was the closest waveform with a flat spectrum in the 694930 hz range that we included in our s2 simulations .
the igec analysis @xcite set an upper limit of @xmath110 events / day at the 95% confidence level on the rate of gravitational wave bursts .
the limit was derived assuming optimal source direction and polarization and was also given as a function of the burst fourier amplitude in a rate versus strength exclusion curve similar to ligo s .
using ligo s s2 gaussian of @xmath86=0.1 ms simulations , the waveburst etg efficiency for sources with random linear polarizations is 50% at a strength of @xmath111 ( see table [ tbl : adhoc ] ) .
for the same sources all with _ optimal _ polarizations , the 50% efficiency point improves by roughly a factor of 3 , to @xmath112 .
thus the optimally oriented rate versus strength curve looks similar to fig .
[ fig : gsg_exclude ] , but shifted to the left . substituting the 95% confidence level ( cl ) event limit of @xmath113 for the 90% cl event limit of @xmath104 shifts the curve up .
lastly , the igec excluded region from fig . 13 of @xcite can be translated from bars natural units ( hz@xmath114 ) to units of @xmath101 ( ) .
given the fourier transform h(f ) for a gaussian waveform h(t ) , @xmath115 @xmath116 we convert the igec values of spectral amplitude h(f ) into @xmath101 for a gaussian of @xmath86=0.1 ms signal morphology ( the conversion is a function of the assumed frequency of the igec result and may vary by a few percent over the 694930 hz range . ) the resulting comparison can be seen in fig . [
fig : ligovsigec ] .
exclusion curves at the 95% confidence level for optimally oriented gaussians of @xmath86=0.1 ms .
the solid curve displays the 95% confidence level measurement obtained by ligo with this search .
the igec exclusion region is shown shaded and it is adapted from fig . 13 of @xcite .
if the comparison were performed using q=8.9 , 849 hz sine - gaussians , the ligo and igec curves would move to smaller amplitudes by factors of 1.1 and @xmath143 , respectively . ] with ligo and s2 we are able to stretch the excluded region substantially to the left ( , to weaker signals ) of the boundary of the excluded region in the rate versus strength curve of fig .
13 in @xcite .
however , although s2 s increased observing time allows a lower rate limit than could be set in s1 , it is still the case that the igec longer duration search allows substantially better rate limits to be set , for signals strong enough for its detectors to have seen them .
furthermore , we are interested in a comparison with the results reported from the analysis of the explorer and nautilus 2001 data . in their 2002 paper @xcite the rome group that analyzes the data of and operates these two resonant mass detectors reported a slight excess of events seen in sidereal hours between 3 and 5 . the events seen in concidence by the two detectors are of an average temperature of approximately 120mk which according to the authors corresponds to an optimally oriented gravitational wave burst fourier amplitude of @xmath117hz@xmath114 ( equation 4 from ref .
the rate of such events is of order 200 events / year ( or 0.55 events / day ) @xcite . given the amplitude of the observed events by the resonant mass detectors , the corresponding @xmath101 of the hypothetical events in our ligo instruments will generally depend on the signal morphology . as with our aforementioned igec analysis , we considered the case of a gaussian of @xmath86=0.1 ms , for which the fourier amplitude of the observed events at the detectors average resonance frequency implies an @xmath101 of @xmath118 . keeping in mind that the suggested @xmath101 values refer to optimal orientation
, we can see from fig .
[ fig : ligovsigec ] that for this event strength the ligo s2 search set an upper bound to their flux at roughly @xmath119 events per day at the 95% cl .
it should be noted , though , that depending on the assumptions of signal waveform ( for example a single cycle of a 914 hz sinusoid or a narrow - band sine - gaussian signal centered on the same frequency ) or considering the range of event strengths recorded by explorer and nautilus ( rather than their average value only ) the corresponding @xmath101 at the ligo detectors may come nearer to the threshold of our sensitivity and thus make our rate limits poorer .
the signal strength and rate of the 2001 rome results come with enough uncertainties that given the ligo s2 sensitivity and exposure we can not make a definitive comparison .
the significant improvements in sensitivity and longer observation times that we expect in new ligo searches in the near future will enable us to move in this direction .
the search for gravitational wave bursts in ligo s s2 run has seen significant improvements introduced in the search methodology and interpretation with respect to s1 .
this included the introduction of the waveform consistency cut and the use of astrophysically motivated waveforms as part of the search interpretation .
additional improvements are currently under way .
we expect them to bring stronger suppression of the background via the use of a burst amplitude consistency test between the ligo detectors as well as new ways of performing our event analysis within the context of a distributional analysis of their strength .
moreover , we plan to make use of data taking periods corresponding to the double coincidence of the instruments that are not part of the triple coincidence dataset .
we will continue investigating the optimization of search algorithms for specific types of waveforms and adding stronger astrophysical context in our search by invoking source population models or targeting plausible point sources . among the lessons learned in the s2 search
has been the importance of the follow - up investigations dictated by coincident triggers revealed by the pipeline .
as expected , with the detector performance nearing design sensitivity , potential couplings from the environment and the instrument itself will become apparent and will need to be identified and vetoed out .
our on - going work for vetoes will become more prominent together with the need to define rigorous criteria and procedures for following up on such events .
ligo s subsequent runs have already collected data of comparable duration and improved sensitivity with respect to s2 and they will present the next milestone of the search for bursts where a good number of these improvements will be exercised .
the authors gratefully acknowledge the support of the united states national science foundation for the construction and operation of the ligo laboratory and the particle physics and astronomy research council of the united kingdom , the max - planck - society and the state of niedersachsen / germany for support of the construction and operation of the geo600 detector .
the authors also gratefully acknowledge the support of the research by these agencies and by the australian research council , the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada , the council of scientific and industrial research of india , the department of science and technology of india , the spanish ministerio de educacion y ciencia , the john simon guggenheim foundation , the leverhulme trust , the david and lucile packard foundation , the research corporation , and the alfred p. sloan foundation . | we perform a search for gravitational wave bursts using data from the second science run of the ligo detectors , using a method based on a wavelet time - frequency decomposition .
this search is sensitive to bursts of duration much less than a second and with frequency content in the 1001100 hz range .
it features significant improvements in the instrument sensitivity and in the analysis pipeline with respect to the burst search previously reported by ligo .
improvements in the search method allow exploring weaker signals , relative to the detector noise floor , while maintaining a low false alarm rate , @xmath0 @xmath1hz .
the sensitivity in terms of the _ root - sum - square _
( rss ) strain amplitude lies in the range of @xmath2 .
no gravitational wave signals were detected in 9.98 days of analyzed data .
we interpret the search result in terms of a frequentist upper limit on the rate of detectable gravitational wave bursts at the level of 0.26 events per day at 90% confidence level .
we combine this limit with measurements of the detection efficiency for given waveform morphologies in order to yield rate versus strength exclusion curves as well as to establish order - of - magnitude distance sensitivity to certain modeled astrophysical sources . both the rate upper limit and its applicability to signal strengths improve our previously reported limits and reflect the most sensitive broad - band search for untriggered and unmodeled gravitational wave bursts to date . |
pairing of electrons by exchange of spin fluctuations is a popular paradigm proposed for unconventional superconductivity including fe - based superconductors , cuprates , and heavy fermion systems .
since many of these systems exhibit an ordered magnetic phase coexisting with , or in close proximity to , the superconducting phase , a small number of studies have addressed the subsidiary problem of pairing of quasi - particles in the symmetry broken spin - density - wave ( sdw ) phase . while this problem has a long history , recent experimental and theoretical developments have led a number of authors to revisit it.@xcite for the simplest case of a doped one - band hubbard model with standard commensurate @xmath4 ordering , the existence of pairing and its consequences for the symmetry of the superconducting order parameter was initially investigated in a seminal paper by schrieffer _
et al . _ , @xcite where the effective pairing interaction was obtained within the random phase approximation ( rpa ) arising from longitudinal spin fluctuations in the magnetically ordered phase .
these authors neglected the contribution to pairing from the transverse spin fluctuations corresponding to the goldstone mode of the spin symmetry broken state , arguing that while such modes lead to a divergent contribution to the spin susceptibility at the ordering vector @xmath5 , the coherence factors of the sdw phase screen the bare electron - electron interaction vertex , which therefore vanishes at @xmath5 .
soon after , frenkel and hanke @xcite showed that the transverse fluctuations do contribute to the pairing interaction in the same order as the longitudinal fluctuations ; the divergence of the transverse spin susceptibility is eliminated by the coherence factors , but a residual constant interaction remains . for electron - doped cuprates , the one - band hubbard model seems to provide a reasonable minimal model since the doped electrons reside primarily on the copper sites .
furthermore , calculations of band parameters for the electron - doped cuprates point to the fact that the coulomb interaction is smaller than the bandwidth , @xcite in contrast to their hole - doped counterparts . in consequence ,
the mean field treatment of the sdw order works quite well for the normal state properties of the electron - doped systems .
in particular , arpes reports show a fermi surface evolution upon increased electron doping which agrees well with the band reconstruction of the one - band hubbard model due to commensurate @xmath4 order . upon electron doping ,
the fermi surface consists of electron pockets around @xmath6 , @xmath7 .
close to critical electron doping , the emergence of hole pockets at ( or close to ) the fermi level around @xmath8 , @xmath9 may occur .
@xcite theoretically , the study of spin - fluctuation pairing for the electron - doped cuprates has been addressed mostly in the paramagnetic phase , @xcite where the mechanism was found to give rise to a gap with @xmath0 symmetry with strong non - monotonic features as a function of momentum as a result of fermi surface intersections with the magnetic zone boundary , the so - called hot spots . at these positions
the pairing becomes particularly pronounced .
this behavior was found to agree qualitatively with arpes @xcite and raman @xcite observations . in ref . the possibility for a cross - over to @xmath10 symmetry
was found at large dopings . in a later work , krotkov and chubukov
@xcite studied the spin - mediated pairing gap close to the quantum critical point of antiferromagnetic ( af ) order and found an anisotropic @xmath0 gap symmetry , but the anisotropic behavior was not related to the hot spots , as opposed to previous work .
a few studies also addressed the coexistence of superconductivity and long - range af order but treated the pairing phenomenologically , and also found a @xmath0-wave solution .
@xcite for hole - doped cuprates , stronger interactions imply that application of a weak - coupling approach to pairing is somewhat less justified .
in addition , calculations of the spin wave spectrum suggest that the commensurate @xmath4 order in this case is not the ground state solution , @xcite complicating the theoretical modelling .
spin - fluctuation - mediated pairing has , however , been extensively applied to study also hole - doped cuprates within the one - band hubbard model .
first , for the paramagnetic phase scalapino _
et al . _
@xcite generalised the approach of berk and schrieffer @xcite and found a dominant @xmath0-wave pairing instability .
later , the study was extended by various methods and numerical approaches @xcite including discussions of the possibility of other superconducting pairing symmetries arising from spin fluctuations . from a strong coupling approach ,
as derived from the @xmath11 model , analysis of the effective pairing at low hole doping @xcite suggests a @xmath3-wave superconducting ground state in any coexistence phase .
this is consistent with rigorous perturbative weak - coupling calculations in the presence of weak density - wave order @xcite as well as a study of hole - doped cuprates in the coexistence phase .
@xcite in addition , a recent study of spin - fluctuation mediated superconductivity in the sdw ordered metal attacked the problem by analytical rpa calculations in the large magnetization ( small pocket ) limit @xcite and found that interactions were dominated by longitudinal fluctuations on the electron - doped side , supporting a nodeless @xmath0 gap , whereas on the hole - doped side both longitudinal and transverse fluctuations support a nodal @xmath0 gap .
recently , lu _ et al . _ @xcite studied the case of underdoped cuprates in a @xmath11 like model and came to a rather different conclusion . in this paper , the coexistence of commensurate af and superconductivity was investigated in a phenomenological model where the pairing interaction arises based on nearest - neighbor magnetic exchange neglecting the double occupancy constraint . in the coexistence phase , this study found the leading superconducting instability to be triplet @xmath1-wave in the case of hole doping , providing a potential explanation for recent photoemission measurements indicating a nodal gap " , a state with a full gap near the usual positions of the @xmath0 gap nodes whose existence is well - established at higher dopings.@xcite it is worth noting , however , that in the original strong - coupling study of unconventional superconductivity driven by the spin waves , studied within the @xmath11 model , the @xmath0-wave symmetry of the superconducting gap was found to be the only stable solution .
@xcite we also note that there exist other potential explanations of the existence of the nodeless gap in the literature .
@xcite this controversy suggests the need for a better understanding of the phase diagram of the single - band hubbard model within a single , reliable approximation scheme which can encompass paramagnetic , superconducting and coexistence phases , and which is capable of identifying the strength of pairing by both longitudinal and transverse spin fluctuations and charge fluctuations , and their relative importance for pairing across a large doping range , for different electronic structures , and for both weak and strong magnetism .
therefore , we extend the work of ref . by a more complete , fully numerical solution of the problem to both confirm the analytical calculations and extend them to the larger phase diagram .
we address the question of how the pairing interactions and resulting gap symmetry in the one - band hubbard model , treated within the full spin - fluctuation approach with self - consistently determined sdw order , evolve as a function of doping throughout the phase diagram , including the coexistence dome of sdw order and superconductivity .
we show that the @xmath0 solution is in fact the leading superconducting instability for all electron doping levels . in the hole - doped case ,
we limit ourselves to small hole doping only and force the @xmath4 order to be stable by a suppression of additional intrapocket nesting contributions to the transverse spin susceptibility .
this approach also yields a coexistence phase with @xmath0 order .
thus , the weak - coupling approach where pairing is mediated by spin fluctuations gives qualitatively different results than the `` strong - coupling '' approach of ref . in the case of hole doping .
we find that the sub - leading instability is a singlet @xmath2-wave solution , which shares common nodes with the @xmath0 solution along the zone diagonals , and has additional nodes along the momentum axes . in the hole - doped case where
the fermi pockets are located far away from the zone axis , @xmath2 and @xmath0 become nearly degenerate .
however , since the two solutions share common nodes , there is no gain in condensation energy by e.g. a time - reversal - symmetry broken solution of the form @xmath12 , and the solution of the full gap equation in fact favors @xmath0 over @xmath2 .
we find further that extended @xmath13-wave is always suppressed in the coexistence phase , in agreement with the findings in ref . for small doping levels , and on the electron - doped side we do not encounter a leading triplet gap at any moderate doping away from half - filling .
the spin - fluctuation - pairing mechanism becomes strongly suppressed above the critical doping for which long - range magnetic order vanishes , since the nesting conditions are rapidly weakening as the fermi surface segments of the paramagnetic phase move apart .
in a recent study of the iron - based superconductors by hinojosa _ et al . _
@xcite it was pointed out that additional interband gaps may develop in the coexistence phase due to pairing of two fermions residing on different bands .
such pairs are naively expected to be negligible because they involve fermionic states far from the fermi energy and do not alone manifest a cooper instability . in this regard ,
these interband pairs can be considered as `` anomalous '' .
however , they are non - zero in the sdw state due to a combined effect of the sdw gap and coupling to the intraband gaps ( dubbed in the following as normal gaps ) . in the iron - based system , this effect is predicted to create a different superconducting phase which explicitly breaks time - reversal symmetry by development of chiral gaps .
we find from a self - consistent treatment of the coupled gap equations that the one - band hubbard model also supports substantial anomalous interband pairings .
the structural factor of the anomalous gaps is @xmath0 as for the intraband gaps , but the phase structure of the intraband and interband gaps can be different . however ,
unlike the case of iron - based system , @xcite the chiral solution @xmath14 does not appear to be favored in our numerical calculations .
the model is the one - band hubbard hamiltonian @xmath15 where @xmath16 creates an electron on site @xmath17 with spin @xmath18 .
the interaction term @xmath19 denotes the energy cost associated with having two electrons on the same site . in reciprocal space
the hamiltonian reads @xmath20 with @xmath21 - 4t'\cos(k_x)\cos(k_y)-\mu.\ ] ] the parameter @xmath22 is the energy gain corresponding to hopping between neighboring sites , and @xmath23 denotes the energy gain by hopping to next - nearest neighbor sites .
the doping level of the system is controlled by changing the chemical potential @xmath24 .
the interaction between two electrons is first treated in the hartree - fock approximation giving rise to af ordering of the spins .
we therefore consider the mean field hamiltonian @xmath25 where @xmath26 $ ] is the af order parameter , and @xmath27 refers to summation over the reduced brillouin zone only .
diagonalization of the mean field hamiltonian leads to the energy spectrum @xmath28 the magnetic gap equation is solved self - consistently given the hopping integrals @xmath29 , @xmath30 , the coulomb repulsion @xmath19 and the doping .
a gapless goldstone mode at @xmath31 in the transverse spin channel is obtained automatically , since the magnetic gap equation is equivalent to the condition @xmath32 .
@xcite higher order interactions in @xmath19 generate superconductivity on top of the af order through longitudinal and transverse spin fluctuations , following the original proposals of refs . .
since @xmath19 scatters the bare electrons , the diagrammatics are performed in terms of the bare electron green s functions , but the cooper pairing takes place between the quasi - particles of the af state .
the quasi - particle operators are related to the bare electron operators by the transformation : @xmath33.\end{aligned}\ ] ] transverse and longitudinal spin fluctuations give rise to fundamentally different interactions .
inspection of the interaction vertex formulated in real space @xcite shows that the charge and longitudinal interaction vertices give rise to no spin flips , whereas the transverse interaction does . in the latter channel
, we have the gapless goldstone mode of the af phase which gives rise to a divergent interaction potential between the bare electrons . however , when we consider pairing between the quasi - particles of the af state , this divergence is removed by the coherence factors as noted in earlier works .
@xcite in the case of pairing between opposite spin electrons , spin flip processes are possible and the effective interaction is mediated both by longitudinal and transverse spin fluctuations . if pairing occurs between same spin electrons , only longitudinal spin fluctuations contribute and the pairing potential does not include the bare coulomb repulsion @xmath19 since this acts only between opposite spin electrons .
the interaction hamiltonian is formulated in terms of the sdw quasi - particles , and in line with earlier work @xcite we show the interactions in the longitudinal and transverse channel individually , with the transverse part of the interaction stated as a spin flip vertex explicitly , @xmath34 with @xmath35l^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')-[2u - v_c({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})]m^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' ) + v_z({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}')l^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')-v_z({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})m^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' ) \nonumber , \\ & & \label{eq : gammaz}\\ \gamma^{+-}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}'}&=&v_{+-}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}')n^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')-v_{+-}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})p^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')\label{eq : gammapm } , \\ & & \nonumber \\
\gamma^{\rm ss}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}'}&=&-v_{c}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}')l^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')-v_{c}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})m^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')-v_{z}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}')l^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')-v_{z}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})m^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}').\label{eq : gammass}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the main ingredients in the pairing interactions are the spin and charge susceptibilities within the rpa approximation @xmath36 @xmath37 @xmath38 where the spin susceptibilities are defined by @xmath39 and @xmath40 . as seen from eqs .
( [ eq : gammaz])-([eq : gammass ] ) the bare interaction vertices are modified by coherence factors of the sdw phase given by @xmath41 with @xmath42 and @xmath43 .
the interaction hamiltonians stated in eqs .
( [ eq : hc])-([eq : hss ] ) are restricted to cooper pairing between quasi - particles residing in the same band , i.e. @xmath44 and @xmath45 . in section [ sec : anomalouspairing ] we introduce an extended model which includes cooper pairing between fermions residing on different pockets , i.e. mean fields of the form @xmath46 .
for now we restrict ourselves to normal intraband cooper pairs and include pair scattering interactions within each band as well as between the bands .
the expression for the interband couplings between pairs of @xmath47 with @xmath48 residing on the @xmath49 band and @xmath50 on the @xmath51 band , which are dubbed @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 are obtained by interchanging the coherence factors @xmath55 and @xmath56 in the eqs .
( [ eq : gammaz])-([eq : gammass ] ) in agreement with refs . .
the presence of magnetic order breaks spin - rotational symmetry , but inversion symmetry is preserved .
this allows us to express the superconducting gap in an even and odd parity form which corresponds to a quasi - spin singlet and a quasi - spin triplet gap , respectively .
we label the gaps by the superscript `` s '' for even parity ( singlet ) and superscript `` t '' for the odd parity ( triplet ) gap , i.e. @xmath57 . as we show later when discussing the interband ( anomalous ) pairing terms , it is more useful to classify the superconducting gaps in the sdw background by parity rather than by spin quantum numbers . in this regard calling cooper pairing spin singlet or spin triplet in the sdw background actually refers to the even or odd parity of the wave function , respectively . in the derivation of the superconducting gap equations
the splitting of these two channels leads to the symmetrization / antisymmetrization of the pairing potential in the quasi - spin singlet / triplet gap equation @xmath58\nonumber,\\ \label{eq : scgapequation}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and similarly for @xmath59 by interchanging @xmath60 . in the case of opposite spin interaction
the effective pairing interactions for the singlet and triplet channel are given by @xmath61 for the intraband contributions and equivalent expressions for the interband , @xmath62 , contributions .
similarly , for same spin electron interactions , the singlet and triplet potential is obtained directly by a symmetrization / antisymmetrization of the potential stated in eq .
( [ eq : gammass ] ) .
the strength of the pairings is calculated by evaluating the real part of the rpa susceptibilities at zero energy .
note that due to broken spin rotation symmetry there is a difference between @xmath63 and @xmath64 .
the pairing vertex @xmath65 diverges at @xmath66 due to the goldstone mode in the transverse channel .
this divergence is removed , however , by the coherence factor @xmath67 of the sdw phase , as discussed above . in the paramagnetic phase where @xmath68 , pairing takes place between the bare electrons and the gap equation then reduces to @xmath69\frac{\delta^{\rm ( s / t)}_{{{\bf k}}'}}{e^{\rm ( s / t)}_{{{\bf k}}'}}\tanh\big(\frac{e^{\rm ( s / t)}_{{{\bf k}}'}}{2k_bt}\big),\nonumber\\ \label{eq : scgapequationns}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath70
. the effective pairings are given by @xmath71\pm v_{+-}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}').\nonumber\\ \label{eq : pmpot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the sdw phase , the effective pairings contain umklapp terms , which are the terms in eqs .
( [ eq : gammaz])-([eq : gammass ] ) containing the argument @xmath72 . due to these terms
, there are attractive pair scatterings @xmath47 on the reconstructed fermi surface .
this contrasts with the situation in the paramagnetic phase , where the spin - fluctuation part of singlet potential is always purely repulsive for all pairs of @xmath47 , as seen from eq .
( [ eq : pmpot ] ) .
however , despite the presence of a partially attractive potential , a conventional @xmath13-wave superconducting gap is not possible .
this is due to a symmetry constraint on the pairing potentials , which must obey @xmath73 , a property that is fulfilled for both the longitudinal and transverse pairing interactions .
this symmetry also carries over to the superconducting gap , which must satisfy @xmath74 for the two dimensional square lattice , the gap solutions can be classified according to the five irreducible representations of the @xmath75 group that are even under reflection through the horizontal plane , i.e. extended @xmath13-wave ( @xmath76 ) , @xmath0 , @xmath10 , @xmath2 and the triplet solution , @xmath77 , which is doubly degenerate .
first we consider whether these solutions all comply with the additional symmetry constraint , eq .
( [ eq : dsym ] ) present in the sdw phase .
this disqualifies the @xmath10 solution and as a result we consider the leading gap symmetries from among the set @xmath78\sin(k_x)\sin(k_y ) , \label{eq : gxy}\\ e_{u } : & ~ & p_{x}=\sin(k_x ) , \quad p_{y}=\sin(k_y ) \label{eq : p}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we emphasize that these basis functions are only the lowest order functions corresponding to the given irreducible representations . in the construction of higher order solutions in the sdw phase
, it is important to note that an odd number of the above basis functions must be multiplied in order for the resulting higher order gap function to comply with eq .
( [ eq : dsym ] ) . further allowed higher order solutions can also be achieved by a multiplication of the @xmath10 basis function [ @xmath79 with any @xmath80 , @xmath81 or @xmath82 basis functions .
a relevant triplet solution is constructed by a multiplication of the triplet @xmath1-wave with the lowest order a@xmath83 and b@xmath83 basis functions , @xmath84[\cos(k_x)+\cos(k_y)]\sin(k_x ) , \label{eq : extf } \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] which for tetragonal symmetry belongs to the same @xmath85 symmetry representation as the original @xmath1-wave solution .
therefore , we dub this state @xmath86-wave .
note that in the literature on sr@xmath87ruo@xmath88 this function is sometimes called @xmath89-wave .
@xcite we find that this is the leading solution among the triplet solutions for any doping .
however , as we shall see below , it does not dominate over the singlet solutions . and ( b ) small electron doping @xmath90 for @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
] the consequences of a @xmath0 solution are manifested very differently depending on the fermi surface geometry . in the presence of only electron pockets , as in fig .
[ fig : fermisurf](b ) , it is nodeless at the fermi surface , as opposed to the other solutions , which all display nodes . if both electron and hole pockets are present at the fermi surface as in fig .
[ fig : solutionslge](e ) , the @xmath0 solution has nodes only at the hole pockets , whereas the extended @xmath13-wave as well as the @xmath2-wave solutions exhibit nodes at both types of pockets .
navely , we might expect the preferred solution to have the minimum number of nodes at the fermi surface . in this respect ,
the @xmath0 solution clearly wins , but ultimately the leading solution relies on a detailed investigation of the structure of the pairing interaction in the sdw phase and the solution to the full gap equation . finally , when only hole pockets are present at the fermi surface as shown in fig .
[ fig : fermisurf](a ) , the @xmath93 solution becomes nodeless , whereas none of the singlet gap symmetries will provide nodeless superconductivity .
as we show below , the @xmath93 solution is supported from the structure of the longitudinal fluctuations , but becomes overall less favorable compared to @xmath0 due to an effective repulsion arising from the transverse spin fluctuations . in order to determine the leading and sub - leading instabilities , we linearize the full gap equation stated in eq .
( [ eq : scgapequation ] ) to obtain the eigenvalue problem @xmath94 the eigenvector of this equation @xmath95.\end{aligned}\ ] ] is a function of momentum @xmath48 .
the momentum is located either on the electron pocket around @xmath6 , which we denote by @xmath49 , or on the two hole pockets , denoted by @xmath96 , around @xmath8/@xmath9 , respectively , see fig . [
fig : fermisurf ] .
we solve the eigenvalue problem eq .
( [ eq : lge ] ) for @xmath48 and @xmath50 on these three closed pockets , which is equivalent to solving it in the whole magnetic brillouin zone .
all intraband and interband interactions are included in @xmath97 : @xmath98 . \nonumber\ ] ] here , @xmath99 denotes the length of the fermi surface line segment represented by the point @xmath50 and @xmath100 is the fermi velocity at @xmath50 .
the intraband ( @xmath101 ) and interband ( @xmath102 ) pairings must be expressed in the singlet and triplet symmetrized versions in accordance with eqs .
( [ eq : sympots])-([eq : sympott ] ) .
the largest eigenvalue , @xmath103 , gives the leading instability since it corresponds to the largest superconducting critical temperature and the symmetry of the gap is given by the corresponding eigenvector .
the linearized gap equation does not allow for a determination of complex gap solutions , which are time - reversal - symmetry - broken ( trsb ) solutions , since higher order interactions in @xmath104 are removed in the linearization process .
therefore , we have additionally solved the full nonlinear gap equation as given in eq .
( [ eq : scgapequation ] ) .
this allows us to compare the real solutions and trsb solutions energetically .
the latter type of solutions arise naturally in situations where the pairing potential allows for two degenerate eigenfunctions of @xmath97 .
therefore , they are likely to appear in the triplet channel , where all solutions to the linearized gap equation are two - fold degenerate
. since the linearized equation in fact also exhibits accidentally degenerate solutions in the singlet channel upon hole doping , this opens the possibility of trsb states in this case .
the prospect of observation of transitions to trsb states as a function of doping or other control parameters , potentially the first observation of this kind , has recently been the subject of considerable attention in fe - based superconductors .
@xcite so far , we have restricted the discussion to cooper pairing between quasi - particles residing on the same band , which are cooper pairs of the form @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
now we introduce an extension of the model to also include anomalous pairings between fermions belonging to different pockets , i.e. @xmath46 .
the complete interaction hamiltonian includes pair scattering processes between normal and anomalous gaps , as well as scatterings between anomalous gaps .
anomalous pairs of the form @xmath46 involve fermions far from the fermi level , since the two bands are gapped by @xmath105 .
nevertheless , the anomalous gaps become sizeable due to the coupling to the normal intraband pairs and exist only in the sdw phase since the coupling between normal and anomalous gaps are proportional to @xmath106 .
a detailed analysis of the interaction hamiltonian reveals that _ even _ parity intraband gaps , i.e. @xmath107 couple to _ even _ parity anomalous interband gaps . in the iron - pnictide study of ref .
the reported anomalous gap was dubbed quasi - spin triplet and coupled to an even parity singlet intraband gap .
however , in that case the triplet gap is actually of even parity , which is allowed due to the band index . as a matter of fact , in the sdw background
it is more useful to classify the superconducting gaps by parity rather than by spin quantum numbers , as spin - rotational symmetry is explicitly broken .
thus , in our case as well as in ref .
one has an even - parity normal intraband gap coupling to even - parity anomalous pairing contributions . as we shall see below
, calculations of the normal intraband gaps reveal an even - parity @xmath0-wave solution . because of this , and also as a result of the structure of the interaction hamiltonian , we restrict ourselves to the even - parity channel which we label by a quasi - spin singlet index , @xmath13 . in the even - parity channel
, the mean - field interaction hamiltonian takes the form @xmath108 \nonumber\\ & & \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{.8cm}+\delta_{\alpha\beta{\uparrow}{\downarrow}}^s({{\bf k}})\alpha_{-{{\bf k}}{\downarrow}}\beta_{{{\bf k}}{\uparrow } } -\delta_{\alpha\beta{\downarrow}{\uparrow}}^s({{\bf k}})\beta_{-{{\bf k}}{\downarrow}}\alpha_{{{\bf k}}{\uparrow } } + h.c .
\big],\nonumber\\ \label{eq : hmffull}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the mean fields @xmath109 + i\sigma_{\gamma\delta}^y\gamma^{\alpha\beta , s}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' } \langle \alpha_{{{\bf k } } ' \delta } ^\dagger \beta_{-{{\bf k } } ' \gamma}^\dagger + \beta_{{{\bf k } } ' \delta } ^\dagger \alpha_{-{{\bf k } } ' \gamma}^\dagger \rangle , \label{eq : daa}\\ & & \nonumber\\ \delta_{\beta\beta}^s({{\bf k}})&=&-\frac{1}{8n}\sideset{}{'}\sum_{{{\bf k } } ' } i\sigma_{\gamma\delta}^y[\gamma^{\rm s}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}'}\langle \beta_{{{\bf k } } ' \gamma}^\dagger \beta_{-{{\bf k } } ' \delta}^\dagger \rangle + \tilde\gamma^{\rm s}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf
k}}'}\langle \alpha_{{{\bf k } } ' \gamma } ^\dagger \alpha_{-{{\bf k } } ' \delta } ^\dagger \rangle ] - i\sigma_{\gamma\delta}^y \gamma^{\alpha \beta , s}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' } \langle \alpha_{{{\bf k } } ' \delta } ^\dagger \beta_{-{{\bf k } } ' \gamma}^\dagger + \beta_{{{\bf k } } ' \delta } ^\dagger \alpha_{-{{\bf k } } ' \gamma}^\dagger \rangle , \label{eq : dbb}\\ & & \nonumber
\\ \delta_{\alpha\beta}^s({{\bf k}})&=&-\frac{1}{8n}\sideset{}{'}\sum_{{{\bf k } } ' } i\sigma_{\gamma\delta}^y \gamma^{\alpha \beta , s}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}'}\langle \alpha_{{{\bf k } } ' \gamma } ^\dagger \alpha_{-{{\bf k } } ' \delta } ^\dagger - \beta_{{{\bf k } } ' \gamma } ^\dagger \beta_{-{{\bf k } } ' \delta } ^\dagger \rangle , \label{eq : gapano } \\ \delta_{\alpha\beta { \uparrow}{\downarrow}}^s({{\bf k}})&=&-\frac{1}{4n}\sideset{}{'}\sum_{{{\bf k } } ' } \gamma^{\alpha\beta\alpha\beta,1,s}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' } \langle \alpha_{{{\bf k } } ' { \uparrow}}^\dagger \beta_{-{{\bf k } } ' { \downarrow}}^\dagger \rangle + \gamma^{\alpha\beta\alpha\beta,2,s}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' } \langle \beta_{{{\bf k } } ' { \uparrow}}^\dagger \alpha_{-{{\bf k } } ' { \downarrow}}^\dagger \rangle , \\
\delta_{\alpha\beta { \downarrow}{\uparrow}}^s({{\bf k}})&=&-\frac{1}{4n}\sideset{}{'}\sum_{{{\bf k } } ' } \gamma^{\alpha\beta\alpha\beta,1,s}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' } \langle \alpha_{{{\bf k } } ' { \downarrow}}^\dagger \beta_{-{{\bf k } } ' { \uparrow}}^\dagger \rangle + \gamma^{\alpha\beta\alpha\beta,2,s}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' } \langle \beta_{{{\bf k } } ' { \downarrow}}^\dagger \alpha_{-{{\bf k } } ' { \uparrow}}^\dagger \rangle .
\label{eq : gapanodownup}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in these gap equations we have introduced three new spin - fluctuation - mediated pairing interactions @xmath110 - [ 2v_{+-}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}')\mu({{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' ) + 2v_{+-}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})\nu({{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' ) ] , \nonumber \\ & & \label{eq : pairingaaab } \\
\gamma^{\alpha\beta\alpha\beta,1}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}'}&= & -[v_{lo}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}')p^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')+v_{lo}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})n^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')+2v_{+-}({{\bf k}}+{{\bf k}}')n^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')+2v_{+-}({{\bf k}}+{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})p^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')],\nonumber \\ & & \\
\gamma^{\alpha\beta\alpha\beta,2}_{{{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}'}&= & v_{lo}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}')l^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')+v_{lo}({{\bf k}}-{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})m^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' ) + 2v_{+-}({{\bf k}}+{{\bf k}}')m^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')+2v_{+-}({{\bf k}}+{{\bf k}}'+{{\bf q}})l^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')],\nonumber\\ \label{eq : gammaabab2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath111 , and @xmath112 in eq .
( [ eq : pairingaaab ] ) refers to the quasi - spin singlet and triplet , respectively . in eqs .
( [ eq : daa])-([eq : gapanodownup ] ) the superscript @xmath13 refers to the symmetrized potentials , e.g. @xmath113 .
this ensures that all mean fields are of even parity .
we have introduced two new coherence factors , which are proportional to the magnetic order parameter @xmath106 @xmath114 note that the coupling between the normal intraband gaps and the anomalous pairings occurs due to the pairing stated in eq .
( [ eq : pairingaaab ] ) which is proportional to the sdw order parameter .
, in the sdw phase as a function of doping , for the parameters @xmath92 and @xmath91 . ]
in the next sections , we discuss the results of spin - fluctuation - mediated pairing in the sdw phase .
first , we restrict the model to normal intraband cooper pairs only . in section [ sec : pairingstrength ] we study how the effective interactions mediated by transverse and longitudinal spin fluctuations evolve as a function of doping .
thereafter , we turn to the implications for the evolution of different gap symmetry solutions in section [ sec : lgeresults ] .
we focus on electron doping , since this is the most relevant regime for a coexistence phase of commensurate af order and superconductivity . in the case of hole doping ,
we restrict the investigation to small hole doping levels below 10 % .
lastly , we provide a discussion of the extended model , where anomalous pairings are included , in section [ sec : anomalouspairingresults ] .
first we focus on the strength and structure of the pairing potentials between opposite spin electrons arising from longitudinal and transverse spin fluctuations for hole and electron doping . in fig .
[ fig : potphasediagram ] we plot the value of the pair scattering @xmath115 for which the pairing strength is maximal for any pair of momenta @xmath47 on the fermi surface . in the low doping limit
, we observe that the interaction through transverse fluctuations is much stronger for hole doping than for electron doping .
for interactions in the longitudinal channel , the situation is opposite , since in this case the pairings are strongest for small electron doping compared to small hole doping . generally , for the hole - doped system , transverse fluctuations are quantitatively stronger than the longitudinal fluctuations . for electron dopings ,
the longitudinal fluctuations dominate close to half filling , whereas both types of pairings contribute more equally at larger doping levels .
in fact , the strength of the pairing interactions in both channels builds up towards the critical electron doping where the af order disappears .
this navely suggests an increase in superconductivity close to critical electron doping .
however , a closer inspection of the @xmath47 dependence of the pairing reveals that it develops a sign change for a part of the intrapocket potential and becomes strongly repulsive for nearby points at the fermi surface .
this leads to an overall gap suppression despite the increased interaction strength . .
the black cross denotes the position of @xmath50 and the value of @xmath115 is shown as a function of @xmath48 around the hole pocket .
negative potential contributions correspond to effective attraction .
the zone diagonal is indicated by a dashed line .
the filling is @xmath116 and @xmath117 , @xmath92 .
note the different color scale for pairing potentials in the longitudinal and transverse channels . ] .
the black cross denotes the position of @xmath50 and the value of @xmath115 is shown as a function of @xmath48 around the electron pocket .
the filling is @xmath90 and @xmath117 , @xmath92 .
note the different color scale for singlet and triplet pairing potentials . ] in general , knowledge of the @xmath47 structure of the pairing potential is crucial in order to decide what kind of superconducting instabilities are favored in the af phase . to address this question , in figs .
[ fig : potbeta ] and [ fig : potalpha ] we map out both the singlet and triplet pair scattering potentials due to longitudinal and transverse spin fluctuations for hole- and electron doping , respectively . in the case of small hole doping ( fig .
[ fig : potbeta ] ) , the singlet pairing interactions from longitudinal and transverse spin fluctuations are similar in structure ; there is an effective attractive ( negative ) interaction for @xmath48 and @xmath50 on the same side of the zone diagonal , whereas the interaction becomes repulsive ( positive ) when @xmath48 and @xmath50 are on opposite sides of the zone diagonal , as deduced from fig .
[ fig : potbeta](a - b ) .
this structure supports @xmath3-wave as well as @xmath2-wave states . in this case , the pairing interaction due to transverse spin fluctuations is much stronger than the pairing arising from longitudinal spin fluctuations , as was also deduced from fig .
[ fig : potphasediagram ] , and expected from refs . , and .
in the triplet channel , the effective interaction arising from the two different types of spin fluctuations has very different character .
the longitudinal fluctuations in fact give rise to a locally attractive pairing on the entire pocket , as shown in fig .
[ fig : potbeta](c ) .
this type of pairing supports a nodeless gap of @xmath1-wave character , i.e. @xmath118 .
however , due to the strong intrapocket repulsive interaction mediated by transverse spin fluctuations shown in fig .
[ fig : potbeta](d ) , the total pairing interaction does not allow for a @xmath1-wave solution .
@xcite therefore the triplet solution becomes higher order and will display nodes at the fermi level . ) ,
( c , d ) only electron pockets ( 5 % electron doping and @xmath91 ) or ( e , f ) both types of pockets ( 5% electron doping and @xmath119 ) .
the last situation is obtained very close to the af quantum critical point , i.e. for @xmath120 .
the leading solutions are shown in the first column and the sub - leading solutions are shown in the second column .
in all three cases the leading solution is @xmath0 , and the sub - leading solution is @xmath2-wave .
the latter differs from @xmath13-wave by being odd under @xmath121 and @xmath122 .
note that in the case of hole doping the two solutions @xmath0 and @xmath2 are nearly degenerate with @xmath123 and @xmath124 . in the case of small and intermediate electron doping ,
the @xmath0 solution becomes strongly dominant . upon
increased electron doping approaching the quantum critical point , the @xmath2-wave solution becomes increasingly important , although always subdominant . ] for electron doping , the pairing interaction in the singlet channel is locally attractive for @xmath48 and @xmath50 residing on the same electron pocket , as shown in fig .
[ fig : potalpha](a - b ) .
attractive pairing occurs due to both longitudinal and transverse spin fluctuations .
as opposed to the hole - doped case , it is the longitudinal fluctuations that mediate the strongest effective pairing . in this regime
, it is clearly the @xmath0 solution which will be favored due to the symmetry @xmath125 . upon increasing the electron doping the purely attractive intrapocket interaction
is replaced by partly repulsive regions and this will diminish the resulting superconducting gap value . in the triplet channel
the pairings from both types of fluctuations will be quite weak , see fig .
[ fig : potalpha](c - d ) . as in the case of hole doping ,
the longitudinal fluctuations support a @xmath1-wave gap since it is attractive for @xmath48 and @xmath50 located at the same side of the fermi pocket and repulsive for @xmath48 and @xmath50 on opposite sides , as shown in fig .
[ fig : potalpha](c ) .
the transverse fluctuations display the reverse structure as evident from in fig .
[ fig : potalpha](d ) , which is the reason why the @xmath1-wave solution becomes suppressed also on the electron - doped side . keeping in mind the structure of the pairing interactions described above
, we now turn to the solutions to the linearized gap equation eq .
( [ eq : lge ] ) in order to determine the subleading solutions and the doping evolution of the three leading solutions .
we consider three qualitatively different types of fermi surfaces .
first , we study a fermi surface consisting of hole pockets at @xmath126 which occurs on the hole - doped side , see fig .
[ fig : solutionslge](a ) .
second , we turn to electron pockets at @xmath127 and @xmath128 which occur for small and intermediate electron doping levels , see fig . [
fig : solutionslge](c ) , and third , we study the occurrence of both electron and hole pockets very close to critical doping as in fig .
[ fig : solutionslge](e ) , i.e. the doping level for which af order disappears .
as discussed above , the presence of hole pockets destabilizes the commensurate af by additional intrapocket contributions to the bare spin susceptibilities . in this case
, we force stability of the commensurate af order by turning off the intrapocket contributions by hand , which is justified from the work by chubukov and frenkel@xcite showing that vacuum renormalization leads to a stability of the commensurate af order at small hole dopings . by inspection of the intrapocket potential structure on the hole pocket shown in fig .
[ fig : potbeta](a , b ) , we expect either of the two solutions @xmath0 or @xmath2 for the weakly hole - doped system .
from the intrapocket potential structure it is not possible to qualitatively distinguish between these two solutions .
the only other way that the system might choose one solution over the other would be from the structure of the pairing potential for @xmath48 on one hole pocket and @xmath50 on the neighboring pocket .
however , from the numerical potential evaluation it turns out that the interpocket pairing contribution is an order of magnitude smaller than the intrapocket pairing and its symmetry does not favor one of the solutions over the other .
this is the reason we obtain two nearly degenerate singlet solutions , namely @xmath0 and the @xmath2 solutions , in fig .
[ fig : solutionslge](a , b ) .
turning to the case of 5 % electron doping shown in fig .
[ fig : solutionslge](c , d ) , we see that the @xmath0 solution is clearly favored over the sub - leading solution @xmath2 , which becomes strongly suppressed .
this is a direct consequence of the intrapocket attraction between @xmath48 and @xmath50 residing on the same electron pocket . upon increasing doping ,
the electron pockets grow in size , but throughout the sdw region , the @xmath0 solution continues to be the leading solution although the sub - leading @xmath2-wave gets closer . also close to the crossover to the paramagnetic phase , where both electron and hole pockets are present at the fermi surface , the leading solution remains @xmath0 as shown in fig . [
fig : solutionslge](e , f ) . ) , are shown .
the @xmath0 solution ( red line ) dominates at all fillings .
the next - nearest neighbor hopping is @xmath92 and the bare coulomb interaction is @xmath91 . ]
the complete doping evolution of the three leading superconducting order parameters , @xmath0 , @xmath2 , and @xmath129-wave , is shown in the phase diagram in fig .
[ fig : phasediagramu3nt0p35 ] . on the hole - doped side ,
we limit the study to the underdoped region . very close to half filling we observe a near - degeneracy of the @xmath0 and @xmath2-wave solutions .
the existence of two degenerate solutions in principle allows for their mixture as a trsb solution , or for orthorhombic distortions as a direct mixture . at the mean field level
, the preference of a low temperature trsb solution might be expected when it is possible to remove gap nodes at the fermi surface , since removal of gaps from @xmath130 leads to a gain in the condensation energy . in the present case of the degenerate solutions @xmath0 and @xmath2 , however , we note that these share the same nodes along the zone diagonal . thus , there will be no apparent gain of energy by constructing a trsb solution of the form @xmath131 .
in fact , solving the full gap equation as stated in eq .
( [ eq : scgapequation ] ) reveals that the @xmath0 solution is energetically favored . upon larger hole doping ,
the near - degeneracy of the @xmath0 and @xmath2-wave solutions is split and the @xmath0 solution becomes clearly dominant in this regime . in the case of electron doping
, the @xmath3-wave solution is strongest very close to half filling even though this is not where the longitudinal and transverse pairing potentials achieve their maximum strengths , see fig .
[ fig : potphasediagram ] .
the reason is that in the limit where electron pockets are small , the structure of the intrapocket pairing potentials is purely attractive , as shown in fig . [
fig : potalpha](a , b ) , and this strongly supports a @xmath3-wave solution .
we note that this feature of a well - developed gap in the limit of small electron dopings is an inherent result of the weak - coupling approach to the coexistence phase . at critical electron doping for which @xmath132 , the fermi arcs just touch the magnetic zone boundary and as a consequence , nesting by @xmath133 on the paramagnetic side is rapidly weakened upon increased electron doping .
the ordering of the leading solutions remains the same as in the sdw phase , with the @xmath129 solution , which in the paramagnetic phase takes the simpler form @xmath134\sin(k_x)$ ] , the least favorable .
the paramagnetic fermi surface , which is a hole pocket centered at @xmath4 is roughly circular thereby preventing nesting not only at @xmath133 , but at any @xmath135-vector . as a result
spin - fluctuation - mediated superconductivity rapidly dies off .
the evolution of the @xmath0 solution was previously discussed in ref . , where the possibility of a different pairing mechanism close to the crossover between sdw and paramagnetism was speculated . in ref .
the pairing was treated at a phenomenological level and here we note that also the full treatment of the spin - mediated pairing gives rise to a rapid decrease in the superconductivity upon entering the paramagnetic region . finally , we show estimations for the critical temperatures of the commensurate af order , @xmath136 , as well as the superconducting ordering temperature , @xmath137 in fig .
[ fig : tempphasediagramu3nt0p35 ] .
the @xmath137 is estimated from the eigenvalue @xmath103 obtained for the leading @xmath3-wave solution as a function of doping .
whereas @xmath137 drops off upon increasing electron doping it shows the opposite evolution as a function of hole doping . at @xmath138
the superconducting instability is absent due to a full gapping of the fermi surface by the magnetic order .
similar behavior was found by variational cluster perturbation theory in the work by snchal and coworkers .
@xcite , with the energy cut off set to @xmath139 and @xmath140 mev .
the superconducting instability is @xmath0 at all fillings .
the sdw region which is determined from the mean field gap equation is shown by the green area .
the next - nearest neighbor hopping is @xmath92 and the bare coulomb interaction is @xmath91 .
note that within the weak - coupling approach the sdw ground state is always metallic away from @xmath138 and therefore , does not cover the mott insulating behavior of in the underdoped region of hole - doped cuprates . ] as discussed in the introduction , the results on the hole - doped side contradicts the recent findings of ref . , where a @xmath1-wave solution appears as the leading instability .
in fact , the cooper - pairing in ref .
is mediated by an exchange interaction which involves only nearest neighbor sites , while in our approach the interaction potential in the cooper channel invokes effectively also sites which are farther apart .
the similarity of the treatment of the coexistence phase in ref .
and our approach allows for a direct comparison of the interaction hamiltonians . in the simplified case of only hole pockets at the fermi surface
, the interaction hamiltonian reads generally @xmath141 in the _ t - j_-like model without double occupancy constraint employed in ref . , the effective interaction entering eq .
takes the form @xmath142 \nonumber \\ & & -j({{\bf k}}+{{\bf k}}')[n^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k}}')+p^2({{\bf k}},{{\bf k } } ' ) ] , \nonumber \\ \label{eq : lugamma}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath143 $ ] and @xmath144 .
by contrast , in the hubbard model the effective interaction entering eq .
is given by @xmath145 with the longitudinal and transverse effective interactions stated in eqs .
( [ eq : gammaz ] ) and ( [ eq : gammapm ] ) . the lower sign of eq .
( [ eq : betahub ] ) belongs to the triplet channel and this is the source of an effective intrapocket repulsion on the hole - doped side as shown in fig .
[ fig : potbeta](d ) . on the contrary , the effective interaction as stated in eq .
( [ eq : lugamma ] ) gives rise to a purely attractive triplet potential for @xmath48 and @xmath50 residing on the same hole pocket , and therefore the @xmath1-wave solution would indeed appear to be the dominating instability .
note , however , that the model of ref . can not be considered strictly as a strong - coupling limit of the single band hubbard model as it does not include a constraint for no double occupancies of the fermions explicitly .
this could play an important role .
for example , as mentioned in the introduction , the original strong - coupling study of unconventional superconductivity driven by the spin waves , studied within the _ t - j _ model with the constraint of no double occupancies , does find the d@xmath146-wave symmetry of the superconducting gap to be the only stable solution .
@xcite we introduced the possibility of additional pairing gaps in the coexistence phase in sec .
[ sec : anomalouspairing ] .
such anomalous pairings were neglected in the previous discussion , see figs .
[ fig : potphasediagram]-[fig : tempphasediagramu3nt0p35 ] , where we demonstrated that the dominating symmetry of the normal intraband pairing gaps is @xmath0 at all doping values .
now we address the question of whether the inclusion of anomalous interband gaps introduces essential modifications to this result .
the anomalous gaps develop under the constraint that they must have the same parity as the normal intraband gaps . in the current case
, this means that anomalous pairing gaps must necessarily be of even parity . )
-([eq : gapanodownup ] ) for the electron - doped system with @xmath51-bands outside the energy cut off .
the superconducting gap symmetry is @xmath0 for both normal and anomalous gaps .
the next - nearest neighbor hopping is @xmath92 and the bare coulomb interaction is @xmath91 .
the energy cut off set to @xmath147 .
we show the absolute value of the gap averaged over @xmath48-states within the energy range @xmath148 , e.g. @xmath149 . within this energy range
no normal superconducting gap develops on the @xmath51-band , i.e. @xmath150 . the dashed blue line shows @xmath151 in the case where all anomalous gaps are excluded . ]
we solve the system of five coupled gap equations as stated in eqs .
( [ eq : daa])-([eq : gapanodownup ] ) numerically to obtain the fully self - consistent solutions in the coexistence phase . since we have not included any energy dependence of the effective pairing vertices , we restrict the momentum sums of eqs .
( [ eq : daa])-([eq : gapanodownup ] ) to states in the vicinity of the fermi surface . the effective potential for pair scattering between anomalous gaps , @xmath152 stated in eq .
( [ eq : gammaabab2 ] ) , formally includes a divergent contribution for @xmath153 . to avoid such contributions we cut off all pairings @xmath152 to a maximum value of @xmath154 . by this procedure , we find that also the anomalous gaps acquire a @xmath0 structure . in fig .
[ fig : electronselfconsistent ] we present the normal and anomalous mean field gaps given in eqs .
( [ eq : daa])-([eq : gapanodownup ] ) in the case of an electron - doped system in the regime of well - developed sdw order .
we show the gap value averaged over @xmath48-states close to the fermi surface , e.g. @xmath149 , where @xmath155 is the number of @xmath48-states with @xmath156 and @xmath157 is the cut off energy . upon approaching half filling where @xmath158 for this band , the self - consistent solutions gradually decrease .
this differs from the results obtained for the linearized gap equation in fig .
[ fig : phasediagramu3nt0p35 ] where the decrease is very abrupt . the gradual decrease in fig .
[ fig : electronselfconsistent ] follows the decrease in the number of states within the energy range around the fermi surface towards half filling . and @xmath159 and ( b ) the anomalous gap , @xmath160 . all gaps have @xmath0 structure .
whereas the normal gaps show the same overall phase on electron and hole pockets , the anomalous gaps display an internal @xmath161-shift between the electron and hole pockets . ] from the results presented in fig .
[ fig : electronselfconsistent ] , it is evident that the mean field @xmath162 is the most important contributor to anomalous pairing whereas @xmath163 and @xmath164 are negligible .
this illustrates the point that it is the linear coupling to the normal gaps via the pairing interaction @xmath165 of eq .
( [ eq : pairingaaab ] ) which generates the anomalous pairings . without this coupling term also the subdominant mean fields @xmath163 and
@xmath164 would vanish .
furthermore , the inclusion of anomalous pairings slightly enhances the size of the intraband gap .
this is seen from fig .
[ fig : electronselfconsistent ] by compairing @xmath151 as deduced from the self - consistent determination of all five gaps shown by blue circles with a full line with the self - consistent calculation of the normal intraband gaps alone , which is shown by the blue dashed line . in the latter case
the gap magnitudes are slightly smaller .
if hole pockets are included within the energy cut off , i.e. @xmath166 , the self - consistent calculation finds a @xmath161-shift of the anomalous superconducting phase at the hole pockets compared to the electron pockets , see fig .
[ fig : phase ] ( b ) .
this is a robust feature arising from the momentum structure of the normal - anomalous pair scattering potential and as a result of the internal sign between @xmath49- and @xmath51-operators in eq .
( [ eq : gapano ] ) .
we have tested numerically that this result is insensitive to the relative ratio of normal and anomalous pairing potentials .
lastly , we mention that the self - consistent gap solutions are all real - valued . therefore unlike the iron - based case studied in ref . , we do not find a trsb superconductor in the coexistence phase . in conclusion
, the incorporation of anomalous pairings in the effective interaction hamiltonian gives only small quantitative changes to the intraband gap results presented in the previous sections .
this study represents a very detailed investigation of spin - fluctuation - mediated superconductivity in a system with well - developed itinerant antiferromagnetic order and includes a calculation of the complete coexistence phase diagram of the hubbard model .
the spin fluctuations bear important fingerprints of the spin order with the transverse spin fluctuations corresponding to the goldstone mode of the spin - symmetry - broken state .
we find that longitudinal and transverse spin fluctuations are equally important for the development of an effective pairing glue between the fermionic quasi - particles of the spin - density - ordered metal .
both types of spin fluctuations act in concert in the even parity quasi - spin singlet channel and this gives rise to a robust gap solution of @xmath0 structure at all doping levels within the coexistence doping region .
the situation is quite different in the case of odd parity quasi - spin triplet superconductivity . here
longitudinal spin fluctuations promote a nodeless @xmath1-wave solution in the hole - doped system due to an effective intrapocket attraction .
however , a strong intrapocket repulsive contribution from transverse fluctuations destroys this effective attraction and destabilizes the @xmath1-wave solution .
thus , the coexistence phase treated within the hubbard model does not support a nodeless gap on the hole doped side , in contrast to a recent study of the coexistence phase within the @xmath11 model without double occupancy constraint .
@xcite a modified version of the hubbard model in which the relative contribution from the transverse fluctuations is suppressed , could also stabilize a nodeless @xmath1-wave state .
finally , we have investigated the additional interband pairing amplitudes that appear in the sdw phase as a consequence of the linear coupling to the normal intraband gaps .
such anomalous pairing gaps are required to have the same parity under inversion as the normal intraband gaps .
specifically , the anomalous pairing amplitudes also manifest a @xmath0 structure and the gap magnitude is similar to the normal pairing gaps .
we thank a.v .
chubukov , a. kreisel , and s. mukherjee for useful discussions , and w. rowe for her contributions to the early stages of this project .
a. t. r. and b. m. a acknowledge support from a lundbeckfond fellowship ( grant a9318 ) .
j. h. acknowledges support from nsf - dmr-1005625 .
the work of i. e. was supported by the focus program 1458 eisen - pniktide of the dfg , and by the german academic exchange service ( ppp usa no .
57051534 ) .
i. e. acknowledges the financial support of the ministry of education and science of the russian federation in the framework of increase competitiveness program of nust misis ( no . 2 - 2014 - 015 ) y. peng , j. meng , d. mou , j. he , l. zhao , y. wu , g. liu , x. dong , s. he , j. zhang , x. wang , q. peng , z. wang , s. zhang , f. yang , c. chen , z. xu , t. k. lee , and x. j. zhou , nat
. comms . * 4 * , 2459 ( 2013 ) .
m. yu . kuchiev and o.p .
sushkov , physica c * 218 * , 197 ( 1993 ) ; v.v .
flambaum , m.yu .
kuchiev , and o.p .
sushkov , physica c * 227 * , 267 ( 1994 ) ; v. i. belinicher , a. l. chernyshev , a. v. dotsenko , and o. p. sushkov , phys .
b * 51 * , 6076 ( 1995 ) . | we study the phase diagram of the hubbard model in the weak - coupling limit for coexisting spin - density - wave order and spin - fluctuation - mediated superconductivity .
both longitudinal and transverse spin fluctuations contribute significantly to the effective interaction potential , which creates cooper pairs of the quasi - particles of the antiferromagnetic metallic state .
we find a dominant @xmath0-wave solution in both electron- and hole - doped cases . in the quasi - spin triplet channel ,
the longitudinal fluctuations give rise to an effective attraction supporting a @xmath1-wave gap , but are overcome by repulsive contributions from the transverse fluctuations which disfavor @xmath1-wave pairing compared to @xmath0 .
the sub - leading pair instability is found to be in the @xmath2-wave channel , but complex admixtures of @xmath3 and @xmath2 are not energetically favored since their nodal structures coincide .
inclusion of interband pairing , in which each fermion in the cooper pair belongs to a different spin - density - wave band , is considered for a range of electron dopings in the regime of well - developed magnetic order .
we demonstrate that these interband pairing gaps , which are non - zero in the magnetic state , must have the same parity under inversion as the normal intraband gaps .
the self - consistent solution to the full system of five coupled gap equations give intraband and interband pairing gaps of @xmath0 structure and similar gap magnitude . in conclusion
, the @xmath0 gap dominates for both hole and electron doping inside the spin - density - wave phase . |
as we know the defect structures exist in different branches of physics , such as domain wall , kinks , vertices , monopoles , condensed matter and string theory . in higher space - times dimensions
the defect structures are generated by real scalar fields such that the single real scalar field produce just single defect as kink - like and the double sin - gordon model may create two different defects . on the other hand , models containing two or more real scalar fields can give rise to at least two other classes of systems that produce defect that engender internal structure and those that support junctions of defects . also two and three scalar fields describe the regular hexagonal network , higgs model [ 1 - 5 ] and bent brane in five dimensions [ 6 ] . in other hand for field theories involving two and three real scalar fields ,
the mathematical problem concerning the integrability of equations of motion is much harder , as one deals with a system of two coupled second order nonlinear ordinary differential equations .
also the configuration space shows a distribution of minima that allows for a number of topological sectors .
one way of simplifying the problem is to consider potentials belonging to large class corresponding to bosonic sector of supersymmetric theories .
such systems can be studied by super - potential .
this super - potential lead us to consider all second order equations in terms of first order .
all bogomolnyi - prasad - sommerfield ( bps ) configuration can be described by this first order equation . for models with three interacting components , the solutions on each topological sector
determine orbits in the configuration space , which can be expressed as a constraint equation @xmath2 the equations arising for three fields in deformation procedure more complicated then two and single field , so three deformation functions are required .
it is difficult to solve this deformation equation , then we restrict the orbit in field space . therefore , by deforming the first order equations for a three coupled field system we need to impose the orbit constraint .
as we know the deformation method for the single and two coupled scalar fields are discussed by bazeia and et al .
but we are going to consider three coupled scalar fields in ( 1,1 ) dimensions in flat space - time , where metric is @xmath3 [ 1 - 4 ] .
the first - order differential equation and the static solutions such as topological solutions for stable states has been discussed by refs . [
7,8 ] . + in present paper
, we use deformation procedure to obtain defect solutions .
this deformation plays an important role to investigate the energy of systems .
for example in cosmological model , the energy density , pressure and equation of states can be controlled by the deformation method on the fields .
+ the above pretext give us motivation to discuss the deformation procedure .
so the outline of the paper follows . in the next section three coupled scalar fields with an example
is discussed and the analysis of the solution without deformation is shown .
the deformation procedure for the three coupled scalar field with diagram is discussed in sec.3 .
also we compare two diagrams and show that the variations of the fields with respect to coordinates are changed by scale .
lagrangian systems described by coupled scalar fields are gaining renewed attention . in the case of real fields ,
in particular , the work presented in [ 4 ] has introduced a specific class of systems of two coupled real scalar fields .
+ let us to start with the lagrangian density with three coupled system , @xmath4 where @xmath5 is in general a non - linear function of the three fields @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath8 here we are using natural units , and so @xmath9 and the metric is such that @xmath10 and @xmath11 + by using euler - lagrange equations , one can obtain the equations of motion as follows ; @xmath12 in order to obtain solution for the equation ( 2 ) , we define super - potential function @xmath13 such that one may write the potential in terms of super potential , @xmath14 where @xmath13 is a smooth function and we have , @xmath15 the energy spectrum associated with these configurations could be written as [ 9 - 10 ] , @xmath16,\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can rewrite it also as following , @xmath17 ^ 2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here also we set the bps energy , @xmath18 this procedure shows that the energy is minimized to , @xmath19 as we have already learned from [ 4 ] , we impose conditions , @xmath20 in this case we see that the energy gets to its lower bound @xmath21 , and the above first - order equation ( 9 ) solve the corresponding equations of motion ( 2 ) .
now we consider special example of three coupled scalar fields which describes the regular hexagonal network .
let us consider the system defined by the following super - potential , @xmath22 in this case the first - order equations become , @xmath23 as we know the exact solution for the above equations is not clear , so we shall use the following elliptical orbit procedure [ 6,9,11 ] , @xmath24 finally three - field static solution for the system ( 11 ) is , @xmath25 so we have a three- field model and its general orbit equation depending on two parameters @xmath26 and @xmath27 ( the arbitrary phase ) .
+ we recall that there are several orbits for solving the equation ( 11 ) .
but here we shall consider the condition @xmath28 and the orbit equation ( 12 ) .
+ by putting equation ( 13 ) in ( 10 ) and ( 3 ) the corresponding super - potential and potential in terms of @xmath29 are given by , @xmath30,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath31.\end{aligned}\ ] ]
we are going to apply deformation procedure for three couple scalar fields . as we know
the deformation method for two and single field were discussed in ref.s . [ 9 , 12 , 13 ] .
+ first we transform three initial scalar fields @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 into the form of scalar fields @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 respectively . + in order to deform three scalar fields we introduce the following deformed function ; @xmath38 where non - deformed function @xmath39 and deformed function @xmath40 are differentiable and invertible .
we can write the inverse function as @xmath41 for @xmath42 . for simplicity the deformed functions are just function of single field .
the essential condition for the deformation functions are given by [ 12 ] , @xmath43_{orbit}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is just the orbit - based deformation procedure .
also , we note that in ref .
[ 12 ] they applied this procedure in two fields system and we will apply for three fields system where @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 . this equation shows that the variation of non - deformed functions are equivalent to the deformed functions .
finally the deformed super - potential @xmath47 from eqs .
( 4 ) and ( 9 ) will be as ; @xmath48 with the help of essential condition and eq .
( 3 ) we have , @xmath49 where @xmath50 deformed potential in terms of deformed super - potential is , @xmath51 the energy of deformed defects can be written by following expression , @xmath52 where @xmath53 is deformed bps energy .
+ + now we apply deformation method for super - potential ( 10 ) . to start
, we shall introduce the deformed function @xmath54 , @xmath55 and from eq .
( 9 ) @xmath54 is given by , @xmath56 by using the following expression @xmath57 the orbit equation ( 12 ) will be as , @xmath58 in order to obtain the deformation fields @xmath59 and @xmath60 , we use eqs .
( 16 ) and ( 17 ) , so we shall have ; @xmath61 here we use equations ( 23 ) , ( 24 ) and ( 13 ) the corresponding deformed fields @xmath59 and @xmath60 are respectively ; @xmath62 @xmath63 the deformation functions also will be the following ; @xmath64 @xmath65 the deformed super - potential and deformed potential from equations ( 18 ) and ( 19 ) are given by ; @xmath66 and @xmath67}{(1+tanh^2(2rx))^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally we can say the topological solutions of non - deformed and deformed equations are compared together by drawing their graphs see figs .
( 1 ) and ( 2 ) .
( 1 ) shows that the plots of non - deformed fields @xmath6 and deformed @xmath54 which are drawn as kink .
plots of non - deformed fields @xmath7 and @xmath68 and deformed fields @xmath59 and @xmath60 are lumps .
we see that the graphs of three fields for non - deformed and deformed are same . in that case
they are just changed by scale .
( 2 ) shows plots of non - deformed and deformed super - potentials .
similarly , we see that the variation of two cases are the same , though by scale are different .
in this paper , we first have introduced three coupled scalar fields @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 [ 11 ] and obtained topological solutions by orbit method .
next we have deformed the initial fields as @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 also the topological solutions for deformed field are obtained by the orbit method . the solution of deformed and non - deformed three coupled scalar fields lead us to compare these two cases .
so , we have shown that the variation of fields for two cases with respect to coordinates in figs.(1 ) and ( 2 ) are same and different just by scale . consequently , different orbit may be lead to different full deformed models and solutions . as we know the deformed fields similar to non - deformed fields are the form of kink and lump solutions , so we have to choose a deformation function such as eq .
. therefore we could consider eq .
( 22 ) in different forms , it may be interesting for the future work . r. rajaraman and e. weinberg , phys . rev .
d * 11 * ( 1975 ) 2950 .
r. rajaraman , phys .
lett . * 42*(1979 ) 200 . g. w. gibbons and p. k. townsend , phys .
* 83 * ( 1999 ) 1725 .
d. bazeia , m. j. dos santos , and r. f. ribeiro , phys .
lett . a * 208 * ( 1995 ) 84 .
z. surujon , phys .
d * 73 * ( 2006 ) 016008 .
j. sadeghi and a. mohammadi , eur .
phys . j. c * 49 * ( 2007 ) 859 - 864 e. b. bogomolnyi , sov .
j. nucl.phys .
* 24 * , 449 ( 1976 ) .
m. k. prasad and c. m. sommerfield , phys .
* 35 * ( 1975 ) 760 .
r. rajaraman .
solitons and instantons ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1982 ) .
d. bazeia , l. losano and j. m. c. malbouisson , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 101701 ( r ) .
d. bazeia , l. losono , c. wotzasek , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 105025 . v. i. afonso , d. bazeia , m. a. gonzalez leon , l. losano and j. mateos guilarte , phys .
d ( 2007 ) * 76 * 025010 .
a. de souza dutra , [ arxiv : hep - th/07053237 ] . j. sadeghi and a. mohammadi , mod .
lett . a * 22 * , 18 ( 2007 ) 1349 - 1358 . | in this work , we present a deformed solutions starting from systems of three coupled scalar fields with super - potential @xmath0 by orbit method . first , we deform the corresponding super - potential and obtain defect solutions .
it is shown that how to construct new models altogether with its defect solutions in terms of the non - deformed model .
therefore , we draw the graph of super - potential and different fields in terms of @xmath1 so we observe that the graphs for deformed and non - deformed cases are changed by the scale . + * keywords:*three scalar fields ; deformation method ; orbit solution + + * pacs number : * 11.10.-z , 11.10.lm , 11.27.+d . |
as finite sized rigid particles are brought together by increasing their density or by compression , they undergo sharp transitions into globally rigid structures , a phenomenon known as jamming @xcite .
such systems do not in general form periodic spatial patterns associated with crystalline solids , instead they display rigidity in an amorphous fashion .
the physical properties of such amorphous solids are intimately linked with the underlying disorder in their packing . the packing of particles into mechanically rigid structures has been of interest in diverse fields including physics , biology and geology and has wide - ranging industrial applications .
several characteristics of rigid particle packings have been studied experimentally and also via numerical simulations @xcite .
many theoretical studies have focussed on frictionless particles with hard core interactions , and much of our rigorous understanding stems from the study of such systems @xcite .
particles with isotropic shapes such as spheres and disks are particularly appealing in terms of their mathematical tractability , and have a long history of study in their own right @xcite .
they have frequently been used as idealized models to study more general problems of granular materials , glassy systems and even information theory @xcite .
although hard cores serve as a good first approximation to real particles , the incorporation of distance dependent interactions represents a non - trivial generalization which continues to be a subject of active research . a natural way to introduce such interactions
is by considering particles with soft cores , with an energy dependent on the amount of overlap between particles .
soft particle packings , which yield hard particle systems in the limit of zero overlap , have also been the subject of considerable interest @xcite .
recently such packings of soft frictionless particles have also been realized experimentally @xcite .
the jamming of soft frictionless disks in two dimensions has been investigated in great detail over the last decade @xcite .
as soft disks are gradually compressed , they undergo a transition to a _ marginally jammed state _ at a well - defined protocol - dependent density .
this marginal state , although at zero pressure and zero energy , nevertheless displays peculiar spatial characteristics , such as local randomness and long range hyperuniformity @xcite .
the reproducibility of several properties of marginal states , such as zero energy packing fractions and contact numbers , despite their seemingly random internal structures have led to a renewed interest in their structural properties .
several entropic arguments have been proposed to explain these characteristics of soft disks close to the jamming transition including that the marginal state is _ maximally random _
@xcite , or that the majority of states belong to basins that jam at the same density @xcite .
bulk properties of jammed soft disks have been extensively investigated and several _ average _ properties of marginally jammed disks have been well corroborated .
the average number of contacts per particle in the marginally jammed state of sphere packings is well known : @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the dimensionality of the embedding space .
this condition is also referred to as _
isostaticity_. for disks that we consider in this paper @xmath9 .
the distributions of the contact lengths , contact angles and two point correlations have also been studied in detail @xcite . however despite considerable effort , several questions about jamming transitions of even simple frictionless soft disks remain unanswered @xcite . in particular ,
the local microstructures in packings close to the transition remain relatively less understood .
similarly , the spatial randomness of the network and the nature of the underlying disorder is an aspect that has not received much attention .
although there is a well defined transition in the bulk properties of the system with continuously measurable quantities such as packing fraction , there are discontinuous jumps in several structural variables that are ill - defined on one side of the transition .
these include network properties such as connectivities of particles , shear and pressure .
it is not a - priori obvious that the two sides of the transition can be described with a single theory , and indeed by the same microscopic variables . in this context
it becomes important to identify the relevant microscopic variables with which to describe the behaviour of the system near the transition .
in this paper we study the spatial structures that arise near the well - studied jamming transition of frictionless soft disks .
we focus specifically on jammed configurations near the unjamming transition point , i.e. we approach the transition from mechanically stable packings with decreasing energies
. the main results of this paper can be summarized as follows .
we introduce a representation that assigns convex polygonal areas to the disks and _ also _ to the voids ( see fig .
[ explanatory_figures ] ) .
we also assign a measure to this polygonal construction using a delaunay triangulation of the underlying network .
this allows us to study the structural properties of both voids and disks and accurately measure their statistics .
although the underlying degrees of freedom have complicated joint probability distributions arising from constraint satisfaction , we find that they display self averaging behaviour , such that system averages are equivalent to ensemble averages .
this allows us to measure reproducible distribution functions of these individual quantities .
we find that the total area occupied by the grain polygons serves as a reliable real space parameter that displays non - trivial scaling as the transition is approached .
we perform large scale simulations to measure scaling exponents associated with this area as the transition is approached .
we then distribute this total area into microscopic variables by assigning well - defined areas to each contact and find this works well as a local field .
finally we use this construction to study the nature of the disorder that arises in such packings .
our study relies on the special convexity properties that appear in frictionless force balanced systems ( see section [ convexity_section ] ) .
this highlights the difference between the contact networks that emerge in frictional and frictionless systems .
we are not aware of any other real space representation where such a difference is manifest .
the paper is organised as follows . in section [ generating_jammed_section ]
we describe the potential energy function and define the jammed configurations we focus on in our study . in section [ polygonal_representation_section ]
we introduce two representations of the disk packing referred to as the polygonal " and triangulation " graphs .
this allow us to accurately characterise the spatial properties of jammed disk packings .
in section [ network_properties_section ] we characterise the total number of voids , contacts and triangulation vectors that arise in such packings .
we derive conservation laws for the triangulation graph that allows us to assign the triangulation vectors uniquely to the local polygonal objects .
we use these network properties to characterise the spatial degrees of freedom of the system and use these geometrical degrees of freedom to construct an isostaticity condition . in section [ distribution_functions_section ]
we perform large scale simulations to measure statistics of these contact networks , focussing on the lengths of contact vectors , their relative angles and the local areas of the polygons . in section [ grain_area_section ]
we provide evidence that the total grain area can be used as a reliable parameter with which to describe the unjamming transition . in section [ measures_of_order_section ]
we use the distribution functions of the local areas to study the underlying geometrical randomness in the packings .
we find that a finite fraction of order persists as the transition is approached .
we also find that the excess order in the system displays non - trivial scaling as the transition is approached .
finally , in section [ correlation_section ] we measure particle and contact correlations that we use to estimate the length scales over which the jammed packings display disorder .
although we focus specifically on frictionless disks , our methods can be readily applied to frictional systems and other convex particles as well . in this paper
, we refer to the particles interchangeably as disks or grains " .
we use capitalized letters to represent global quantities and lower case letters to represent local properties .
we begin by defining an energy function for a given configuration of disks .
a configuration is fully specified by the set of positions of the centres of grains @xmath10 and their associated radii @xmath11 .
the total energy of the system is given by a sum of two body interactions @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the distance between the disks @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
this interaction potential is modelled as a one - sided linear spring repulsion potential of the form @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the heaviside function and @xmath18 is the sum of the undistorted radii of disks @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
the total number of grains is referred to by @xmath19 . when quoting @xmath19 from simulation data , we follow the convention that all grains used in the simulation are counted , regardless of whether they are a part of the contact network in the final jammed state . in computing all other system quantities
, @xmath19 refers only to the grains that are part of the rigid structure , i.e. @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the number of rattlers " , particles that are not in contact with any of the others ( see fig .
[ system_figure ] ) . the total energy per grain of the system
is then given by @xmath22 where the sum is taken over all pairs @xmath23 , with @xmath24 .
the potential energy function therefore acts as a tuning parameter that defines a distance to the unjamming transition located at precisely @xmath25 . in this paper
we approach the transition from finite positive energies @xmath26 .
a configuration is defined as jammed if and only if @xmath27 _ and _ @xmath28 eq .
( [ force_balance_equation ] ) is simply a statement of _ force balance _ for every grain @xmath14 .
two disks are in contact if @xmath29 .
we refer to the collection of distance vectors @xmath30 between grains in contact as the contact network " .
the force balance condition ensures that configurations with finite energies possess a system spanning contact network . in this paper
we only consider configurations that are jammed .
we consider systems with periodic boundary conditions in both directions .
this boundary condition makes the embedding plane a genus @xmath31 torus with an euler characteristic @xmath32 .
we will use this property in section [ network_properties_section ] . with associated radii @xmath11 .
the positions of the contact points are represented by the set of vectors @xmath33 where @xmath34 , the total number of contacts .
the contact vectors belonging to every grain @xmath14 are represented by @xmath35 where @xmath36 , the connectivity of the grain .
the edges associated with every grain @xmath14 are represented by @xmath37 with @xmath38 . the edges within each grain circulate in an anti - clockwise direction .
the triangle formed by the points @xmath39 ( shaded area ) is labelled by the unique edge @xmath40 and is referred to as an edge triangle " with an associated area @xmath41 . *
( right ) * the jammed configuration of fig .
[ explanatory_figures ] along with the associated polygonal construction and delaunay triangulation .
the vectors coinciding with real contacts are depicted in black and the fictitious contacts " are shown in red.,title="fig : " ] with associated radii @xmath11 .
the positions of the contact points are represented by the set of vectors @xmath33 where @xmath34 , the total number of contacts .
the contact vectors belonging to every grain @xmath14 are represented by @xmath35 where @xmath36 , the connectivity of the grain .
the edges associated with every grain @xmath14 are represented by @xmath37 with @xmath38 .
the edges within each grain circulate in an anti - clockwise direction .
the triangle formed by the points @xmath39 ( shaded area ) is labelled by the unique edge @xmath40 and is referred to as an edge triangle " with an associated area @xmath41 . *
( right ) * the jammed configuration of fig .
[ explanatory_figures ] along with the associated polygonal construction and delaunay triangulation .
the vectors coinciding with real contacts are depicted in black and the fictitious contacts " are shown in red.,title="fig : " ]
we next introduce two representations of the disk packing generated using the network of contacts that form between the disks .
we generate a polygonal graph " by partitioning the two dimensional space into polygonal tilings of grains and voids , and a triangulation graph " by a delaunay triangulation of locally convex sections of the contact network .
recently voronoi tesselations have proved fruitful in understanding the local spatial structures of packings @xcite .
our procedure differs from the voronoi tesselation in that it is able to assign well defined sections of space to grains as well as to voids .
the packing of disks in the two dimensional plane can naturally be considered as a decomposition of space into regions that lie within the circular areas associated with the disks and regions that lie outside .
we refer to these exterior regions as voids " . in jammed packings ,
these voids are completely enclosed by the areas of grains surrounding them , and in general have a complicated , non - convex shape ( see fig . [ explanatory_figures ] ) .
the total number of such voids is referred to by @xmath42 . in order to characterize these voids we can use the positions of the surrounding grains to build circuits around them .
this is done by constructing a circuit of distance vectors with vertices at the centres of the grains surrounding each void @xmath43 as @xmath44 ( see fig . [ explanatory_figures ] ) .
these circuits are also referred to as _ minimum cycles _ of the contact network since they represent the shortest possible loops in this network .
each minimum cycle is uniquely associated with a void , and completely encloses the non - circular shaped space formed between the disks .
using the positions and radii of the grains in a given configuration we can next construct the contacts between the grains . although the contacts occur as finite regions of overlap between grains , we assign them to unique points in space .
the positions of the contact points are represented by the set of contact positions @xmath33 .
we use the convention @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the contact between grains @xmath14 and @xmath15 . here
@xmath47 where @xmath48 is the total number of contacts in the system . in this convention
every contact is counted twice , once for each grain . the convention in eq .
( [ contact_positions_equation ] ) also ensures that configurations that are related by a simple expansion or contraction of all disks have the same contact network .
using the positions of contacts belonging to every grain , we can assign contact vectors " to each grain as @xmath49 where @xmath14 refers to the grain index and @xmath46 refers to the contact number associated with the grain , @xmath36 .
the number of contacts @xmath50 is also referred to as the connectivity " of the grain .
every contact vector has two degrees of freedom which can be parametrized by its length @xmath51 and its angle in relation to the @xmath52-axis @xmath53 .
the system can then be parametrized in terms of the contact vectors , although this is an overcounting of the degrees of freedom .
the contact vectors must satisfy constraints in order for them to be a valid packing .
we discuss these constraints in detail in section [ coordination_section ] .
the normality of forces in the system of frictionless disks leads to special convexity properties of the contact network .
the force balance condition on each grain disallows any configuration in which contacts lie on _ only _ one semi - circle of a disk , since this would generate a net force along the direction normal to this semi - circle .
we refer to this statement as the semi - circle condition " .
this then ensures that the relative angles between the contact vectors obeys @xmath54 where @xmath55 is taken cyclically within each grain . using this property
, we can deduce that each minimum cycle surrounding a void forms a convex polygon .
therefore the contact network partitions space into _ locally convex _ regions , with each of these regions being uniquely associated to a void .
the partitioning of space into locally convex regions greatly simplifies the characterization of the underlying structure of the packing and allows us to construct convex tilings associated uniquely with grains and also with the voids .
it is important to note that there is no such semi - circle condition for frictional systems .
the network construction therefore highlights a crucial difference between frictionless and frictional systems . using the contact vectors
, we can next build a collection of edges @xmath37 defined as @xmath56 where the edges connect pairs of contacts @xmath55 belonging to the grain @xmath14 in a cyclic manner based on their angles ( see fig . [ system_figure ] ) . here
@xmath57 is the edge number associated with the grain , @xmath58 .
we use the convention that the edges circulate in an anti - clockwise manner within each grain .
every contact belonging to a grain therefore has a unique edge associated with it , namely the outgoing edge vector at each contact .
the edges associated with the grains naturally form a @xmath50-sided polygon .
we refer to these embedded polygons as grain polygons " .
since we are dealing with convex disks , the associated polygons are also convex and hence have an associated convex area @xmath59 .
the total area covered by the grain polygons is denoted by @xmath60 .
we then have @xmath61 where the edge @xmath57 connects the contacts @xmath55 .
we refer to the individual areas @xmath41 as edge triangles " , since they are triangular in shape and are uniquely associated with an edge @xmath57 ( see fig . [ system_figure ] ) .
we measure the statistical properties of these edge triangles in section [ measures_of_order_section ] .
next , we can also use the contact vectors to construct void polygons " .
these are created using the edges surrounding each void in the same manner as the grain polygons and have an associated area @xmath62 . for fricitionless packings of disks ,
the convexity of the circumscribing minimum cycle enclosing every void also ensures the convexity of the void polygon .
the edges associated with the void polygons circulate in the clockwise direction .
once again we can define a void connectivity @xmath63 as the total number of edges associated with the void .
an important property of the void polygons is that they circumscribe the voids between the disks , which has a non - convex shape , with a convex polygon . for marginally jammed disks ,
the void polygon is precisely the _ convex hull _ of the non - circular area of the void .
this makes the characterization of the shape and size of individual voids easier .
we note that our void construction is similar to the circulating currents of ball and blumenfeld @xcite , however their assignment of grain areas is different .
our construction is aimed at introducing a grain area parameter that serves as a substitute for the packing fraction , which can then be used to test scaling properties of the system .
we refer to the graph @xmath64 with vertices at the position of contacts and edges formed by the edge vectors as the polygonal graph " . in order to assign a measure to our network
, we use the positions of the grains to construct a triangulation of the two dimensional space .
as we have seen , for frictionless disk packings , the contact network naturally breaks up the space into convex minimum cycles enclosing the voids .
we can then individually triangulate each cycle with the distance vectors @xmath65 that form the convex hull of each cycle , and extra vectors @xmath66 traversing through the minimum cycles .
we refer to these extra triangulation vectors as fictitious contacts " since they mostly represent disks that are almost in contact .
it should be noted that the fictitious contacts are infact distance vectors in our convention .
the statistics of these fictitious contacts are of interest to us since they provide significant information about how the contact network is embedded in space .
the union of the individual triangulations then yields a global triangulation @xmath67 with vertices at the position of grains and edges formed by the grain distances and fictitious contacts .
we refer to @xmath68 as the triangulation graph " .
the natural triangulation to use within each minimum cycle is the delaunay triangulation @xcite , which maximizes the minimum angle among all possible triangulations .
this forms the least scalene triangulation possible and is convenient for developing discrete calculus frameworks for microscopic properties of granular systems @xcite .
since the union of delaunay triangles yields the convex hull @xcite , this ensures that the distance vectors are a subgraph of the triangulation of each minimum cycle .
therefore the contact network forms a subgraph of the triangulation graph .
this construction is unique since each minimum cycle contains points that are not collinear , ensuring the uniqueness of the individual triangulations .
it is important to note that the union of the individual delaunay triangulations does not necessarily yield the global delaunay triangulation obtained by simply triangulating the vertices of grain positions . for monodisperse disks
, this union does indeed yield the global delaunay triangulation . to show this
it is sufficient to prove that two disks in contact are connected by a global delaunay edge .
this can be proved by recognizing that the delaunay triangulation is simply the adjacency graph of the voronoi tesselation , i.e. if two points share an edge in a voronoi tesselation , they will be connected by a delaunay edge . the voronoi area associated with each vertex @xmath69
is defined as all points @xmath70 such that @xmath71 . for non - overlapping disks ,
the associated circular areas therefore lie within their voronoi areas . at each overlap
the voronoi area of two disks in contact are modified by the amount of overlap , and therefore are adjacent in the voronoi tesselation , leading to them being connected by a delaunay edge .
this property therefore breaks down if one considers highly stressed states with more than two disks in overlap .
it is easy to show that for bidispersed systems with particle radii @xmath72 and @xmath73 with @xmath74 , as @xmath1 the global delaunay triangulation coincides with the union of delaunay triangulations of minimum cycles .
this is true for the bidispersed case with diameter ratio @xmath75 that we simulate . in the case of highly polydisperse systems
the global delaunay triangulation is no longer the best choice , however our construction using the union of minimum cycles still holds . to deal with such cases
several generalizations of voronoi tesselations have been proposed in the literature , the best studied of which is the radical voronoi tesselation @xcite . using this construction , the argument for the monodispersed case
can easily be generalized to systems with varying sizes of disks .
the polygonal graph and the triangulation graph are both representations of the same underlying system .
however , they have different properties .
we list some of the properties for each graph below . *
the grain polygons and void polygons form a _ bipartite graph _ , i.e. voids are connected to only grains through their edges , and vice versa .
this can also be stated alternatively as the _ adjacency graph _ of grains and voids forms a bipartite network . for the hexagonal close packed structure
this adjacency graph is simply the dice lattice . *
the network is _ space filling _ ,
i.e. + @xmath76 + where @xmath77 and @xmath78 are the total areas associated with the grain polygons @xmath79 and the void polygons @xmath80 respectively .
this property differs crucially from other measures of packing fraction used in the literature , that include the excess volumes of overlaps between disks . *
every node has exactly four neighbours ( @xmath81 ) .
every contact has two incoming edges and two outgoing edges since each contact belongs to two grains . *
the network is _ planar _
, i.e. none of the edges formed by the contact vectors cross each other .
this property allows us to use euler s theorem to understand the properties of the graph . *
the contact network forms a subgraph of the triangulation graph .
this is true by construction ( see section [ delaunay_fictitious_section ] ) . *
the network is _ planar _ ,
i.e. none of the network vectors cross each other .
this property follows directly from the fact that we only consider two - disk overlaps as valid and the properties of the delaunay triangulation @xcite . *
_ triangulation property : _ every triangulation has the following general property @xcite : let @xmath82 be a set of @xmath83 points in the plane , not all collinear , and let @xmath84 denote the number of points in @xmath82 that lie on the boundary of the convex hull of @xmath82 .
then any triangulation of @xmath82 has : @xmath85 triangles and @xmath86 edges .
we will use these properties to construct conservation laws in section [ conservation_section ] .
.properties of the polygonal and triangulation graphs . @xmath87 and
@xmath88 refer to the number of vertices , edges and faces respectively .
the planarity of these graphs ensures that they obey the euler identity : @xmath89 , where @xmath90 refers to the euler characteristic of the embedding plane . for the toroidal boundary conditions that we consider , @xmath32 . the euler identity for the triangulation graph
can be used to compute the total number of fictitious contacts in the system using the triangulation condition @xmath91 . [
cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] we next use the total grain area to study critical exponents of the unjamming transition .
we test the scaling behaviour of the total grain area with two parameters that acquire well defined values at the unjamming transition , namely the energy per grain @xmath1 and the excess coordination @xmath92 .
the unjamming transition is located precisely at @xmath25 , and at @xmath93 .
the value of @xmath94 was derived in eq .
( [ z_iso_equation ] ) .
we can therefore use the deviations from these two values to test the scaling of the total area @xmath60 .
since the polygonal measure is only sensitive to structural changes in the configurations ( a simple expansion or contraction of all disks is given the same weight ) , it is interesting to see whether we can measure exponents that provide information about the geometric structure of the packings .
we find that this is indeed the case , and that critical exponents measured from grain areas differ from those measured using standard packing fractions .
as the unjamming transition is approached from above @xmath26 , fewer disks are in contact , leading to a decrease in the total grain area .
we plot the distributions of the area for different energies for @xmath95 disks in fig .
[ area_figure ] . for higher densities , for example with @xmath96 ,
we find @xmath97 for @xmath98 , @xmath99 for @xmath100 and @xmath101 for @xmath102 .
it is then interesting to ask at what covered fraction of total area the transition occurs . in order to estimate this quantity ,
as is standard in the study of phase transitions , we use finite - size extrapolation .
we first estimate the transition point for a given system size ( number of disks ) as @xmath1 , and then extrapolate to @xmath103 .
we can estimate these critical points using both @xmath104 and @xmath105 .
the locations of these points for different system sizes is summarized in table [ finite_size_scaling_table ] .
we find that the finite size effects scale as @xmath106 with the system size .
using these values , and accounting for statistical sampling error , we find @xmath107 @xmath108 therefore defines a new real - space parameter for the unjamming transition .
we note that the polygonal construction produces @xmath109 for the hexagonal ordered structure , with the value @xmath110 significantly different from this number as compared to the closeness of the values in the packing fraction measure . with total energy per particle @xmath104 .
we find that the excess grain area scales as a power of the total energy in the system with exponent @xmath111 . *
( right ) * scaling of @xmath112 with excess coordination in the system @xmath105 .
we find that the excess grain area scales as a power of @xmath105 with exponent @xmath113.,title="fig : " ] with total energy per particle @xmath104 .
we find that the excess grain area scales as a power of the total energy in the system with exponent @xmath111 . *
( right ) * scaling of @xmath112 with excess coordination in the system @xmath105 .
we find that the excess grain area scales as a power of @xmath105 with exponent @xmath113.,title="fig : " ] we next use the deviation of the total grain area from its value at the unjamming point @xmath114 to test the scaling behaviour with our two control parameters @xmath104 and @xmath105 .
we define two scaling exponents @xmath115 and @xmath116 that quantify this behaviour @xmath117 in fig .
[ scaling_with_eg_figure ] we plot the scaling of @xmath112 with total energy per particle @xmath104 .
we find that the excess grain area scales as a power of the total energy in the system with exponent @xmath111 .
the estimates of @xmath115 from finite size extrapolation are summarized in table [ finite_size_scaling_table ] .
this value of @xmath115 is in contrast with the known scaling of the packing fraction which displays an exponent @xmath118 @xcite .
this is a surprising feature of the polygonal measure , in that even though it measures the occupied area similar to the packing fraction , it has different scaling properties close to the transition .
we next test the scaling of the total grain area with excess coordination near the transition . in fig .
[ scaling_with_eg_figure ] we plot the scaling of @xmath112 with @xmath105 .
we find that the excess grain area scales as a power of @xmath105 with exponent @xmath119 .
once again this is in contrast with the scaling of packing fractions which displays an exponent @xmath120 @xcite .
estimates of @xmath116 from finite size extrapolation are summarized in table [ finite_size_scaling_table ] .
the linear scaling of @xmath112 with @xmath105 suggests an assignment of individual areas to the contacts which can serve as a microscopic order parameter .
we find that the edge triangles defined in section [ polygonal_representation_section ] serve as precisely such variables .
we measure the statistics of these edge triangles and other geometrical characteristics of the underlying packings in section [ measures_of_order_section ] .
in this section we characterize the types of polygonal tilings that emerge in the packing of disks near the marginally jammed state .
the area statistics of the individual grain polygons and the void polygons provide useful insight into the structural randomness present at the microscopic scale .
one quantity that can be used to measure local disorder is the shape of the grain polygons formed by the jammed packings . in order to characterize the shape of these grain polygons
, we measure the areas of their constituent edge triangles introduced in section [ polygonal_representation_section ] . at exactly @xmath25 ,
the distribution of areas of edge triangles is directly related to the distribution of contact angles . at finite energies these differ as the edge triangles also includes the effect of overlaps between grains .
the areas of the individual triangles can vary between @xmath121 and @xmath122 where @xmath123 is the radius of the grain to which they belong ( see fig . [ system_figure ] ) .
we note that @xmath124 can vary between different configurations chosen with the same energy @xmath104 . in order to account for the different sizes between configurations , we measure the following normalized area @xmath125
. this can take values between @xmath121 and @xmath126 .
the minimum value is not attained in ordinary packings at low compressions , however we can obtain good statistics of these triangular areas close to the maximum , corresponding to disks with contact angles close to @xmath127 .
we plot the distribution of edge triangle areas @xmath128 for a system with @xmath129 disks at different energies in fig .
[ grain_void_figure ] .
we find that this distribution displays self averaging behaviour and reaches a limiting form as the system size is increased .
this is significant since it is then possible to distribute the total grain area @xmath60 into the local " areas of edge triangles .
the edge triangles therefore serve as reliable local jamming parameters that can be used to construct microscopic theories .
these peaks occur at @xmath130 and @xmath131 ( see fig . [ grain_void_figure ] ) .
these structures also cause peaks to appear in the areas of void polygons ( blue triangles ) . for the diameter ratio @xmath75 these peaks
occur at @xmath132 , and @xmath133 ( see fig . [ grain_void_figure ] ) .
the fraction of the system in these ordered structures gives us a measure of order in the system @xmath134 . ]
we next focus on the well - defined peaks in the distribution of edge triangle areas .
we find that these peaks become sharper as the transition is approached .
these peaks can be identified as arising from ordered structures formed by three , four and higher numbers of disks in contact .
the first five peaks in the distribution of @xmath135 can be identified as arising from three disks in contact .
these arise from combinations of type-@xmath136 and type-@xmath137 disks , namely @xmath138 , @xmath139 , @xmath140 , @xmath141 and @xmath142 , where the brackets represent disks in contact with the unbracketed disk , to which the edge belongs . at the marginally jammed state
( with zero overlap ) , the distances between the disks in contact can take only unique values ( see fig .
[ three_disks_figure ] ) leading to unique values of the angles and consequently the areas which can be computed exactly . for the ratio of diameters
@xmath75 these are @xmath143 and @xmath144 .
we can quantify the amount of order present in the packing by measuring the area under these ordered peaks .
we study this in detail in section [ mrj_section ] .
the disordered parts of the edge triangle areas , namely the areas not under any ordered peaks , exhibit characteristics similar to those of the contact angles ( see fig . [ prob_angle_figure ] ) .
this can be understood from the fact that the areas of the edge triangles are built from the underlying contact vectors and contact angles and that at low energies the contact vectors take well defined values . for @xmath129 at different energies .
@xmath145 corresponds to disks with relative contact angles close to @xmath146 .
we find well defined ordered peaks that can be used to estimate the amount of order in the system .
the five largest peaks arise from ordered structures formed by three disks in contact ( see fig .
[ three_disks_figure ] ) .
these ordered peaks get sharper as @xmath1 . *
( right ) * distribution of areas of void polygons @xmath147 , where @xmath72 is the radius of grains of type-@xmath136 in the given configuration .
the plot shows @xmath148 for configurations of bidispersed grains with @xmath129 at different energies .
we find four well - defined ordered peaks that correspond to three - disk ordered structures ( see fig .
[ three_disks_figure ] ) .
the area under these ordered peaks can be used to estimate the fraction of order present in the system @xmath149 as @xmath1.,title="fig : " ] for @xmath129 at different energies .
@xmath145 corresponds to disks with relative contact angles close to @xmath146 .
we find well defined ordered peaks that can be used to estimate the amount of order in the system .
the five largest peaks arise from ordered structures formed by three disks in contact ( see fig .
[ three_disks_figure ] ) .
these ordered peaks get sharper as @xmath1 .
* ( right ) * distribution of areas of void polygons @xmath147 , where @xmath72 is the radius of grains of type-@xmath136 in the given configuration .
the plot shows @xmath148 for configurations of bidispersed grains with @xmath129 at different energies .
we find four well - defined ordered peaks that correspond to three - disk ordered structures ( see fig .
[ three_disks_figure ] ) .
the area under these ordered peaks can be used to estimate the fraction of order present in the system @xmath149 as @xmath1.,title="fig : " ] another quantity that can be used to measure disorder at the microscopic scale are the voids that are formed in jammed packings . in order to characterise the spatial structure of these voids
, we measure the distribution of the areas of individual void polygons ( @xmath62 ) . in this respect ,
our polygonal construction has an advantage over previous measures of spatial anisotropy , since we can identify well defined sections of space that belong to voids alone . in order to account for the different sizes of the grains and changes in grain diameters for different configurations , we measure the following normalized void areas @xmath147 , where @xmath72 is the radius of grains of type-@xmath136 ( the larger of the two ) in a given configuration .
we find that even though @xmath124 varies for different configurations and also for different energies , the distribution of @xmath150 is reproducible and also displays self averaging properties . in fig .
[ grain_void_figure ] we plot the distribution of these normalized void polygon areas @xmath148 for a system of @xmath129 grains at three different energies @xmath151 and @xmath152 approaching the marginally jammed state . as with the distribution of edge triangles
, we find well defined ordered peaks that persist even as we approach the marginally jammed state .
the first four peaks in this distribution can be identified as arising from triangular voids ( @xmath153 ) that arise from three - disk ordered structures .
these four peaks arise from the four possible combination of type-@xmath136 and type-@xmath137 disks in the bidispersed system , namely @xmath154 , @xmath155 , @xmath156 , and @xmath157 . at the marginally jammed state with zero overlaps
, the distances between the disks in contact can take only unique values ( see fig .
[ three_disks_figure ] ) leading to a unique values of the areas of these three sided void polygons .
we can compute the positions of these peaks exactly .
for the ratio of diameters @xmath75 these are @xmath158 , and @xmath159 . in states with larger energies ,
the finite overlaps between disks causes a broadening of these peaks .
although the value at which the peaks occur are easily understood , the question of how many of the voids in the system contribute to them is non - trivial . in this context , an interesting quantity to measure is the area under these four ordered peaks , we measure this in section [ mrj_section ] .
the disordered parts of the void polygon areas exhibits interesting modulations , which can be attributed to ordered structures formed by four or more disks in contact .
the marginally jammed states of soft disks have exactly zero overlap and can therefore be mapped on to systems with infinitely hard interactions .
such packings of frictionless hard disks have been the subject of continued interest and have a rich history @xcite .
hard disk packings generated from random protocols have recently been argued to be _ maximally random _
@xcite , i.e. they present the least amount of order amongst all possible states available to the system .
a natural question to ask is then : how random are the states of frictionless soft disk packings as the unjamming transition is approached .
inversely we can study the amount of order present in these soft disk packings close to the marginally jammed state in order to understand the nature of such maximally random states .
a natural measure of disorder is the _ absence _ of the ordered structures formed by three disks in contact identified in sections [ edge_triangles_section ] and [ void_areas_section ] . in section [ connectivity_section ]
we derived local conservation laws for the number of fictitious contacts , assigning them uniquely to the voids with @xmath160 .
we can then define a measure of disorder as simply the total number of fictitious contacts in the system , or alternatively as a density measure @xmath161 where the disorder density @xmath162 is assigned to every void .
the normalization ensures that @xmath163 as @xmath103 ( see eqs .
( [ void_bound ] ) and ( [ fictitious_bound ] ) ) .
numerically , this can be easily computed for a given packing using relations derived in section [ coordination_section ] .
as we have shown , the number of fictitious contacts attains its maximum value at isostaticity . therefore in this measure isostatic packings naturally have the largest amount of disorder @xmath164 . since we have also argued that marginally jammed packings that do not possess special conservation laws are isostatic , randomly created marginally jammed states are therefore the most disordered .
similarly the hexagonally close packed structure has the least amount of disorder @xmath165 . with total energy per particle @xmath104 .
we find that the excess order scales as a power of the total energy in the system with exponent @xmath166 . *
( right ) * scaling of the excess order @xmath167 with the excess coordination @xmath105 .
we find that the excess order scales as a power of @xmath105 in the system with exponent @xmath168.,title="fig : " ] with total energy per particle @xmath104 .
we find that the excess order scales as a power of the total energy in the system with exponent @xmath166 . *
( right ) * scaling of the excess order @xmath167 with the excess coordination @xmath105 .
we find that the excess order scales as a power of @xmath105 in the system with exponent @xmath168.,title="fig : " ] another closely related measure of _ order _ is the fraction of the system under the ordered peaks in the microscopic distribution functions measured in sections [ edge_triangles_section ] and [ void_areas_section ] . in the simplest construction
we only account for the ordered structures formed by three disks in contact in the system .
this can be estimated from the amount of area under the five ordered peaks in the distribution of edge triangle areas or alternatively the four ordered peaks in the distribution of the void areas .
this measure can be recognized as simply the total number of voids with a coordination @xmath153 .
we can therefore define a measure of order as @xmath169 where @xmath170 is the number of voids with connectivity @xmath171 in a packing with @xmath42 voids and @xmath172 is the distribution of void connectivities studied in section [ connectivity_section ] .
as the peaks sharpen , @xmath173 decreases , but remains finite even in the @xmath1 limit .
for example for configurations prepared with @xmath96 disks , at @xmath98 we find @xmath174 , at @xmath100 we find @xmath175 , and at @xmath102 we find @xmath176 .
using finite size scaling as in section [ grain_area_section ] , we find that @xmath177 we obtain a similar estimate from the limit @xmath178 . once again , as for the excess grain area , we can study the behaviour of the excess order @xmath179 as the energy of the system and the coordination number is increased .
the scaling of the excess order with energy and @xmath105 are shown in fig .
[ psi_with_eg_figure ] .
we find that @xmath167 displays non - trivial scaling with energy and also with the excess coordination .
@xmath180 intriguingly these are the same exponents as those for the scaling of the excess grain area
. it would be very interesting to understand the origin of these scaling exponents in such disordered packings of soft disks .
although several probability distributions of local properties are reproducible and self averaging , this does not imply a completely uncorrelated behaviour on the microscopic level .
several constraints such as force balance and the tilings constraints for polygons can cause local structures to emerge in correlated patterns .
hence it is important to assess the length scale over which these correlations persist in the real space networks , and specifically for the quantities that we have measured . in this section
we compute network - based correlation functions that we use to assess the length scale up to which _ short range order _ persists in this system .
we use these correlation functions to estimate the system sizes needed for self averaging behaviour to become valid . in order to test the correlations in the system
we measure the radial distribution function @xmath181 defined as the probability that the centre of a disk @xmath15 is within the annulus @xmath182 and @xmath183 centered around @xmath14 , normalized by @xmath184 . here
we normalize the distances by the size of the grain from which it is measured @xmath185 , where @xmath186 is the distance computed in the real space packing @xmath187 .
this is equivalent to computing a two point radial correlation function .
we find peaks at well - defined distances which we can attribute to the short - range order present in the underlying packings .
we have tested that the scaling near the ordered peaks follows the @xmath188 behaviour observed in previous studies @xcite . for contacts , with @xmath189 and @xmath190 . here
@xmath14 refers to the grain to which the central contact belongs .
this has been computed for a packing with @xmath191 at different energies .
we find well defined density modulations that are detectable up to @xmath192 grain diameters that has only a weak dependence on energy . *
( right ) * distribution of the length of fictitious contacts @xmath193 , where @xmath194 and @xmath65 is the length of the triangulation vector connecting grains @xmath14 and @xmath15 with radii @xmath123 and @xmath195 respectively .
the plotted distribution is at the lowest measured energy @xmath102 .
we find a clear @xmath196 behaviour as @xmath197 .
the drop off at @xmath198 grain diameters sets the length scale for the linear dimension of the voids , independent of the system size.,title="fig : " ] for contacts , with @xmath189 and @xmath190 . here
@xmath14 refers to the grain to which the central contact belongs .
this has been computed for a packing with @xmath191 at different energies .
we find well defined density modulations that are detectable up to @xmath192 grain diameters that has only a weak dependence on energy . *
( right ) * distribution of the length of fictitious contacts @xmath193 , where @xmath194 and @xmath65 is the length of the triangulation vector connecting grains @xmath14 and @xmath15 with radii @xmath123 and @xmath195 respectively .
the plotted distribution is at the lowest measured energy @xmath102 .
we find a clear @xmath196 behaviour as @xmath197 .
the drop off at @xmath198 grain diameters sets the length scale for the linear dimension of the voids , independent of the system size.,title="fig : " ] similarly we can define @xmath199 as the probability that a contact @xmath200 is within the annulus @xmath182 and @xmath183 centered around the contact @xmath46 , normalized by @xmath184 .
once again we normalize the distances by the size of the grain to which the central contact belongs @xmath201 , where @xmath202 is the distance computed in the real space packing @xmath190 .
we use this distribution function to study the fluctuations in the number of _ contacts _ within a given radius of another contact .
this is in effect a two point contact correlation function . in fig .
[ correlations_figure ] we plot @xmath199 for a packing of @xmath203 disks at varying energies . we notice that this radial contact distribution function exhibits periodic modulations that persist for @xmath192 grain diameters .
this length scale is set by the underlying geometrical randomness and therefore has only a very weak dependence on the energy of the system .
this can be explained from the fact that contacts are located on the vertices of tilings of void and grain polygons .
since the distribution functions of the areas of these polygons exhibit ordered peaks , this also implies ordered peaks in the the linear size of these polygons .
next , since the distances between contacts can be formed by traversing linearly through these polygons , this leads to ordered peaks in the contact correlations .
since these distances are drawn randomly from the underlying distribution functions , these correlations will be randomized after a persistence length " , @xmath204 grain diameters in this case .
this length scale sets a scale for the system sizes above which we can expect self averaging behaviour to become valid . since we keep the box length fixed , the linear size ( number particles traversed along a linear axis ) of the system grows as @xmath205 .
this suggests that the effect of these correlations can be neglected beyond systems with @xmath206 .
this agrees with our finite size studies of the scaling behaviour near the unjamming transition . finally , to understand the spatial correlations in the _ triangulation network _
, we measure the distribution of the lengths of fictitious contacts formed in the delaunay triangulation graph .
this gives us valuable information about the spatial separation of the disks that are almost in contact .
the delaunay triangulation is a geometric spanner , i.e. the length @xmath182 of the shortest path along delaunay edges is known to be @xmath207 \le \frac{4\pi}{3\sqrt{3}}$ ] , where @xmath208 is the euclidean distance between vertices @xcite .
this allows us to understand the long distance correlations in the system based simply on the distributions of the lengths of vectors in the triangulation .
as we have shown , the number of fictitious contacts increases and attains its maximum value as the transition is approached .
this points to the fact that the fictitious contacts play a crucial role in determining the stability of the jammed networks close to the unjamming transition .
another important property of the fictitious contacts is that they traverse the void polygons , as shown in section [ conservation_section ] .
therefore the lengths of these vectors can be used to estimate the linear dimension of the voids .
this is important in measuring quantities such as porosity , that has been of interest in the literature @xcite . in order to understand the behaviour of the fictitious contacts near the transition , we measure the distribution function @xmath209 defined as the probability that two grains are separated by a delaunay edge of length @xmath182
. we account for the different sizes of the disks by normalizing the length of the triangulation vectors as @xmath194 where @xmath65 is the length of the triangulation vector between grains @xmath14 and @xmath15 and @xmath123 and @xmath195 are the radii of the disks connected by the vector .
distances of @xmath210 correspond to fictitious contacts and @xmath211 correspond to real contacts .
since we have already studied the distribution of lengths of contact vectors in section [ contact_vectors_section ] , we focus on the @xmath210 part of this distribution .
this differs from the standard pair correlation function @xcite since this distribution function only measures nearest - neighbour distances on the delaunay network . in fig .
[ correlations_figure ] we plot the distribution @xmath193 for two system sizes with @xmath102 , i.e. marginally jammed .
we find a clear @xmath196 behaviour as @xmath197 , in agreement with previous studies of the pair correlation functions @xcite . in this case
as well , we find sharp peaks that we can identify as arising from the ordered structures formed by _ four _ disks in contact .
finally , we note that the sharp drop - off in the distribution at @xmath198 grain diameters sets the length scale for the linear size of the voids , independent of the system size .
in conclusion , we have introduced a network based framework for analysing spatial characteristics of jammed packings .
the polygonal construction differs from the well - known voronoi measure of local volumes since it allows us to probe the internal structure of both grains _ and _ voids in jammed packings .
we have found that the grain area serves as a reliable parameter with which to describe the unjamming transition .
we found evidence for a well defined transition at an area fraction @xmath212 .
the construction of polygonal tilings allowed us to precisely study the scaling behaviour near the unjamming transition .
we measured the scaling properties of this area and found that it displays non - trivial scaling with both the energy and excess coordination as the transition is approached .
we found new structural critical exponents @xmath111 and @xmath113 that describe this scaling behaviour near the transition .
we expect the critical exponent @xmath115 to display non - universal behaviour for different potentials while the microscopic assignment of areas to the contacts makes the exponent @xmath116 universal .
our measured distribution functions revealed signatures of a finite order even in the marginally jammed state .
we estimated this fraction of order using the amount of ordered structures formed by three disks in contact in the marginal state as @xmath213 .
we also found that the excess order in the system displays non - trivial scaling near the transition , attaining a minimum value in the marginal state .
another interesting aspect of our analysis is the observed deviation of these exponents from simple fractions , similar to those observed in recent experiments @xcite .
it would be very interesting to understand the origin of these non - trivial exponents in such systems .
a natural extension to this study would be to analyse the quantities studied in this paper at different values of polydispersity .
since packing fractions seem to display some degree of robustness to polydispersity near the transition , it would be interesting to test the sensitivity of the polygonal measure in this regard .
it would also be interesting to extend our analysis to convex particles with non - circular shapes , which our construction can straightforwardly be extended to .
our network construction is able to clearly distinguish between frictionless and frictional systems .
an interesting aspect for further investigation would then be to study the effect of friction on the statistics of these jammed networks .
many of our constructions can be generalized to higher dimensional systems which would be an intriguing avenue of further research .
finally , it would be very interesting to use the underlying distribution functions studied in this paper to construct microscopic theories that describe the scaling properties of such systems near the unjamming transition .
we thank c. s. ohern , t. bertrand and q. wu for providing configurations that were used in the initial analysis of this work . we acknowledge helpful discussions with d. dhar .
k. r. acknowledges helpful discussions with a. narayanan . this work has been supported by nsf - dmr 1409093 and the w. m. keck foundation .
p. g. de gennes , rev .
phys . * 71 * , s374 ( 1999 ) .
l. p. kadanoff , rev .
phys . * 71 * , 435 ( 1999 ) .
m. e. cates , j. p. wittmer , j .-
bouchaud and p. claudin , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 1841 ( 1998 ) . j .-
bouchaud , _ granular media : some ideas from statistical physics _ , proceedings of les houches summer school , ( edp sciences , les ulis , 2002 ) . a. j. liu and s. r. nagel , nature * 396 * , 21 ( 1998 ) .
g. d. scott and d. m. kilgour , br . j. appl . phys .
* 2 * , 863 ( 1969 ) .
h. m. jaeger and s. r. nagel , science * 255 * , 1523 ( 1992 ) .
f. radjai , m. jean , j. j. moreau , and s. roux , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 274 ( 1996 ) .
h. m. jaeger , s. r. nagel , and r. p. behringer , rev .
phys . * 68 * , 1259 ( 1996 ) . c. f. moukarzel , phys .
* 81 * , 1634 ( 1998 ) .
e. r. nowak , j. b. knight , e. ben - naim , h. m. jaeger , and s. r. nagel , phys .
e * 57 * , 1971 ( 1998 ) .
d. howell , r. p. behringer and c. veje , phys .
82 * , 5241 ( 1999 ) .
a. v. tkachenko and t. a. witten , phys .
e * 60 * , 687 ( 1999 ) .
h. a. makse , n. gland , d. l. johnson and l. m. schwartz , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 5070 ( 1999 ) .
e. i. corwin , h. m. jaeger , and s. r. nagel , nature ( london ) * 435 * , 1075 ( 2005 ) .
t. s. majmudar , m. sperl , s. luding , and r. p. behringer , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 058001 ( 2007 ) .
p. olsson and s. teitel , phys .
lett . * 99 * , 178001 ( 2007 ) .
d. bi , j. zhang , b. chakraborty , and r. p. behringer , nature * 480 * , 355 ( 2011 ) .
j. p. hansen and i. r. mcdonald , _ theory of simple liquids _
( academic press , 2006 ) .
b. mccoy , _ advanced statistical mechanics _ ( international series of monographs on physics ) ( oxford university press ) ( 2010 ) .
s. torquato , t. m. truskett and p. g. debenedetti , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 2064 ( 2000 ) .
s. torquato and f. h. stillinger , phys .
e * 68 * , 041113 ( 2003 ) . s. torquato and f. stillinger , rev .
* 82 * , 2633 ( 2010 ) .
g. parisi and f. zamponi , rev .
phys . * 82 * , 789 ( 2010 ) .
t. aste and d. weaire , _ the pursuit of perfect packing _ , taylor and francis , new york ( 2008 ) .
j. d. bernal , nature * 183 * , 141 ( 1959 ) .
d. bideau , a. gervois , l. oger , and j. p. troadec , j. physique * 47 * , 1697 ( 1986 ) .
t. aste , phys .
e * 53 * , 2571 ( 1996 ) .
a. donev , s. torquato , and f. h. stillinger , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 090604 ( 2005 ) .
a. donev , s. torquato , and f. h. stillinger , phys .
e * 71 * , 011105 ( 2005 ) .
j. tian , y. xu , y. jiao , and s. torquato , nature scientific reports * 5 * , 16722 ( 2015 ) .
d. j. durian phys .
75 * , 4780 ( 1997 ) .
d. j. durian , phys .
e * 55 * , 1739 ( 1997 ) .
m. van hecke , j. phys . :
matter * 22 * , 033101 ( 2010 ) .
b. tighe , phys .
. lett . * 109 * , 168303 ( 2012 ) .
f. bolton and d. weaire , phys .
lett . * 65 * , 3449 ( 1990 ) .
j. bruji , s. f. edwards , i. hopkinson , and h. a. makse , physica a * 327 * , 201 ( 2003 ) .
j. zhou , s. long , q. wang , and a. d. dinsmore , science * 312 * , 1631 ( 2006 ) .
x. hong , m. kohne , e. r. weeks , arxiv:1512.02500 ( 2015 ) .
c. s. o13hern , s. a. langer , a. j. liu , and s. r. nagel , phys .
lett . * 88 * , 075507 ( 2002 ) .
l. e. silbert , g. s. grest , and j. w. landry , phys .
e * 66 * , 061303 ( 2002 ) . c. s. o13hern , l. e. silbert , a. j. liu , and s. r. nagel , phys .
e * 68 * , 011306 ( 2003 ) .
m. wyart , s. r. nagel , and t. a. witten , europhys . lett . * 72 * , 486 ( 2005 ) . l. e. silbert , a. j. liu and s. r. nagel , phys .
e * 73 * , 041304 ( 2006 ) .
s. henkes , b. chakraborty and c. s. o13hern , phys .
lett . * 99 * , 038002 ( 2007 ) .
s. henkes and b. chakraborty , phys .
e * 79 * , 061301 ( 2009 ) .
w. g. ellenbroek , m. van hecke , and w. van saarloos , phys .
e * 80 * , 061307 ( 2009 ) .
m. wyart , phys .
. lett . * 109 * , 125502 ( 2012 ) .
l. berthier , p. chaudhuri , c. coulais , o. dauchot and p. sollich , phys .
lett . * 106 * , 120601 ( 2011 ) .
s. atkinson , f. h. stillinger , s. torquato , proc .
111 * , 18436 - 18441 ( 2014 ) .
r. dreyfus , y. xu , t. still , l. a. hough , a. g. yodh , and s. torquato , phys . rev .
e * 91 * , 012302 ( 2015 ) .
p. k. morse and e. i. corwin , phys .
lett . * 112 * , 115701 ( 2014 ) .
r. c. ball and r. blumenfeld , phys .
rev . lett . * 88 * , 115505 ( 2002 ) . m. de berg , o. cheong , m. van kreveld and m. overmars , _ computational geometry : algorithms and applications _ ( springer - verlag , new york , ed . 3 , 2008 ) .
m. satake , mechanics of materials * 16 * , 65 ( 1993 )
. r. blumenfeld , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 108301 , ( 2004 ) .
e. degiuli and j. mcelwaine , phys .
e * 84 * , 041310 ( 2011 ) .
e. degiuli , _ continuum limits of granular systems _ , ph.d .
thesis , university of british columbia ( 2013 ) .
e. degiuli and c. schoof , europhys
* 105 * , 28001 ( 2014 ) .
b. j. gellatly and j. l. finney , j. non - cryst .
solids 50 , 313 ( 1981 ) .
w. g. ellenbroek , v. f. hagh , a. kumar , m. f. thorpe and m. van hecke , phys .
* 114 * , 135501 ( 2015 ) .
j. c. phillips , journal of non - crystalline solids * 34 * , 153 ( 1979 ) .
m. f. thorpe , journal of non - crystalline solids * 57 * , 355 ( 1983 ) .
o. gendelman , y. g. pollack , i. procaccia , s. sengupta , and j. zylberg , phys .
116 * , 078001 ( 2016 ) .
s. f. edwards and r. b. s. oakeshott , physica a * 157 * , 1080 ( 1989 ) .
d. frenkel , d. asenjo , and f. paillusson , mol .
111 * , 3641 ( 2013 ) .
r. blumenfeld , s. amitai , j. f. jordan and r. hihinashvili , phys .
* 116 * , 148001 ( 2016 ) . g. y. onoda and e. g. liniger , phys .
* 64 * , 2727 ( 1990 ) .
t. bertrand , r. p. behringer , b. chakraborty , c. s. ohern and m. d. shattuck , phys .
e * 93 * , 012901 ( 2016 ) .
m. keil and c. gutwin , discrete comput .
* 7 * , 13 - 28 ( 1992 ) .
s. sastry , d. s. corti , p. g. debenedetti and f. h. stillinger , phys .
e * 56 * , 5524 ( 1997 ) .
p. guan , s. lu , m. j. b. spector , p. k. valavala and m. l. falk , phys .
* 110 * , 185502 ( 2013 ) .
j. lin , i. jorjadze , l .- l .
pontani , m. wyart and j. brujic , arxiv:1608.02475 ( 2016 ) . | we analyse properties of contact networks formed in packings of soft frictionless disks near the unjamming transition .
we construct polygonal tilings and triangulations of the contact network that partitions space into convex regions which are either covered or uncovered .
this allows us to characterize the _ local _ spatial structure of the packing near the transition using well - defined geometric objects .
we construct bounds on the number of polygons and triangulation vectors that appear in such packings .
we study these networks using simulations of bidispersed disks interacting via a one - sided linear spring potential . we find that several underlying geometric distributions are reproducible and display self averaging properties .
we find that the total covered area is a reliable real space parameter that can serve as a substitute for the packing fraction .
we find that the unjamming transition occurs at a fraction of covered area @xmath0 .
we determine scaling exponents of the excess covered area as the energy of the system approaches zero @xmath1 , and the coordination number @xmath2 approaches its isostatic value @xmath3 .
we find @xmath4 and @xmath5 , representing new structural critical exponents .
we use the distribution functions of local areas to study the underlying geometric disorder in the packings .
we find that a finite fraction of order @xmath6 persists as the transition is approached .
= -.7 cm @=11
@=12 [ [ section ] ] starttoctoc |
as known , a charged particle emits electromagnetic radiation at its acceleration independently on the origin of this acceleration @xcite .
this phenomenon well studied both theoretically and experimentally , moreover , for more then 50 years it has been used within various branches of the science , from the basic research ( acceleration physics , particle physics , etc . )
to many applications as a source of radiation ( synchrotron and undulator radiations , free electron lasers , applications in material sciences , chemistry , biology , medicine , etc . ) . however , a charged particle can emit electromagnetic radiation even without its acceleration , in presence of various media , for instance .
the pioneering works on this radiation brings us to the discovery by p. cherenkov and s. vavilov , presently known as cherenkov ( or cherenkov - vavilov ) radiation , the origin of which was first suggested within the phenomenology developed by their colleagues i. tamm and i. frank @xcite .
this radiation is emitted when a charged particle crosses the media with the velocity exceeding the speed of light in media .
later on , developing the proposed theory for charged particles propagation in solids , i. tamm and v. ginzburg predicted another kind of electromagnetic radiation that was called transition radiation @xcite .
the latter is emitted when the particle crosses the media interfaces characterized by different dielectric constants , thereby , creating polarization currents that , in turn , explains the origin of radiation .
obviously , in this case , to suppose that power ( intensity ) independently , the possibility of electromagnetic radiation emission at propagation of charged particle bunches near the solid ends that can be also characterized by induced polarization in media . and one of these types of radiation is known as diffraction radiation ( dr ) , and can be registered at propagation of a charged projectile of constant velocity near the sharp solid end @xcite .
special interest represent so - called optical diffraction radiation interference ( odri ) , the features of which was previously discussed in @xcite .
indeed the sensitivity of this technique based on the interference is higher .
as seen , dr , by its nature , is a kind of transition radiation but with some essential features . of course , and it is the name , this phenomenon appears when a charged particle moves near optical heterogeneity , hence , it requests taking into account the diffraction effects on the media end .
the theory of diffraction radiation was in details considered by many authors ( see , for instance @xcite and refs . in ) , and presently , we can apply it for various schemes either to predict or to analyze the results of both planned and performed experiments . in this work we present the results of theoretical analysis for various possible schemes to be experimentally realized .
the studies were done to reveal fine features of dr in both near and far zones of radiation for one - slit as well as two - slit systems .
the latter induced us to use the wave approximation at the radiation distribution , spatial and angular , and radiation intensity simulations .
below , following the description presented in @xcite , we briefly introduce to the basics of diffraction radiation by relativistic electrons on a planar slit . as known dr
is observed when charged particle moves near the solid media end .
let consider the case of a perfectly conductive media , i.e. an infinite thin screen , the geometry of which is shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] . following the method described in @xcite we can define the components of current and charge density induced by passing particle in such geometry by the following expressions ( here @xmath0 ) @xmath1 @xmath2 where the parameters @xmath3}{\omega(\alpha_0\cos\varphi_0 + i\sin\varphi_0)}\exp{(-\ae)}\,\ , , \ ] ] @xmath4 @xmath5 correspond to the particle field , the relativistic angular parameter and attenuation parameter respectively .
the z - component of current @xmath6 we can reduce from the continuity equation @xmath7 , where @xmath8 , @xmath9 is the velocity , @xmath10 is the lorentz factor , @xmath11 is the impact parameter and @xmath12 is the charge of electron . the fourier components of the field we can be reduced directly from the maxwell s equations @xcite . for simplicity , the coordinate system associated with the wave vector @xmath13 is selected : @xmath14}{\sin\psi}=\{-\sin\phi , \cos\phi , 0\}\,\ , , \ ] ] @xmath15=\{\cos\phi\cos\psi,\sin\phi\cos\psi,-\sin\psi\}\,\ , , \
] ] @xmath16 the coordinate system is connected to the basic through the appropriate angles . in this coordinate system one of the components of the field is always equal to zero , and the component along @xmath17 could be neglected due to the reason described below .
then the component @xmath18 for the velocity of a particle perpendicular to the screen can be presented as @xmath19 below we can use these relations substituting the variables by @xmath20 and @xmath21 that , as seen from the draw of fig .
[ fig1 ] , allows us to pass our considerations to the angles of radiation with respect to the particle velocity direction ( see fig .
[ fig2 ] ) .
as known , the radiation of relativistic particles is mostly concentrated within the cone @xmath22 ( where @xmath10 is the lorentz - factor ) .
taking this fact into account , after some transformations and neglecting terms of the order of @xmath23 , the previous expression can be rewritten for dr from one half - plane in more simple form @xmath24}{\sqrt{\gamma^{-2}+\theta_x^2}-i\theta_y } \,\
, , \label{e2 - 2}\ ] ] where @xmath11 is the impact parameter , and @xmath25 is the wavelength of observed radiation . using the slit instead of a screen we have to take into account the interference of dr from two half screens ( planes ) , which together act as a unique slit .
thus , total field from the slit can be defined in the form @xmath26 in which the coefficients `` @xmath27 '' and `` @xmath28 '' correspond , respectively , to the upper and lower half - planes . the expression for radiation from upper half - plane we can get from the expression for lower half - plane by the complex conjugation combined with simultaneous substitution @xmath29 . within the approximation of small angles in relativistic case it is possible to define that @xmath30 then , using eqs .
( [ e2 - 2 ] ) and ( [ varphi_ul ] ) the total field of dr from a slit in the forward direction can be written as follows @xmath31}{\sqrt{\gamma^{-2}+\theta_x^2}-i\theta_y}+\frac{\exp{[-\frac{2\pi h_l}{\lambda}(\sqrt{\gamma^{-2}+\theta_{x}^{2}}}+i\theta_y)]}{\sqrt{\gamma^{-2}+\theta_x^2}+i\theta_y}\right ) \label{e2}\ ] ]
for many problems in high energy physics , especially at accelerators when the beams of particles move inside various cavities such as the beam - pipes , solenoids , magnets , etc . , it is important to know the position of a particle in a space inside these guides
. these features can be evaluated studying dr dependence on the position between the beam and the slit .
let us analyze the dr intensity versus the angle of emission at various positions of a particle with respect to the center of a slit .
fist of all , below we simplify the task in order to determine some parameters .
assuming that both radiation wave vector and vector of electron velocity are situated in one plane , we get @xmath32 .
moreover , the component @xmath33 linearly depends on @xmath34 , hence we can take @xmath35 . and
that is the reason why we could omit this component from our consideration . that , in experiment can be realized by means of the polarizer
thus , in this approximation eq.([e2 ] ) is reduced to @xmath36}}{\gamma^{-1}-i\theta_y}+\frac{\exp{[-\frac{2\pi h_l}{\lambda}(\gamma^{-1}+i\theta_y)]}}{\gamma^{-1}+i\theta_y}\right)\ ] ] to perform concrete analysis of dr angular distribution we have used the parameters of the desy test facility , i.e. the bunch and radiation parameters are , respectively , @xmath37 nm , and the width of a slit is 1 mm . the simulations were performed for various electron positions in the space between two half - planes . in fig .
[ fig3 ] we have presented the angular evolution of dr in dependence on the position of a projectile with respect to both half - planes of a slit . the distance of a particle to the plane has been marked above each plot , the first value is the distance to the upper edge , while the second number - to lower edge . as we can see
the distance between the spikes varies at the change of electron position .
this dependence is shown in fig .
[ fig4 ] .
+ + it should be noted that such dependence leaves one uncertainty .
we obtain the equal angles between the spikes for two symmetric positions relative to the center of a slit .
however , this problem can be resolved if to move the slit detecting simultaneously the change of the angular distance between the spikes .
for example , if up - moving the slit we observe the decrease of the angular distance between the spikes , then the projectile is positioned in the upper part of a slit , and vice versa .
obviously , the sensitivity of this method is much higher near one of the edges .
in previous section we have considered the point like beam ( which corresponds to single projectile ) to simplify our task . however , in reality the task is more complex . in order to be closer to the reality we have to take into account a few more parameters . in next sections
we consider the size of a beam , its divergence , and , moreover , for the case of two slit system the slits uncoplanarity will be introduced .
let us start our analysis from the size of a beam .
typically , the beam profile is characterized by the gaussian distribution in perpendicular cross - section .
if @xmath38 is the distance from the arbitrary point of a beam to the center of a slit , we can determine the beam spatial distribution as a function @xmath39 .
successfully , total radiation from the beam can be presented as @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 is the limits describing the beam size . for the gaussian profile of a beam
we can define a new parameter , a spatial dispersion , which determines the integration limits @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
indeed these parameters are equal to the dispersion @xmath43 @xcite . performing some calculations
we can reduce the size of a beam with respect to the spikes position in dr angular distribution .
+ + for our calculations the desy parameters were used . in particular , the beam size was about 80 @xmath44 m . in fig.[fig5 ] on top of plots
the first two values , as in previous case , show the distances from both upper and lower half planes , and for the each plot is shown corresponding beam size . as seen from the plots in fig .
[ fig5 ] the beam size influences on the distribution of dr but without any spikes shift .
now , knowing that the beam size has no influence on the position of spikes , we can introduce the divergence of a beam in our calculations . according to @xcite in order to calculate the distribution of dr from a divergent beam we have to take the convolution of the intensity function with the function of angular distribution taken in gaussian approximation .
then , we obtain @xmath45 or @xmath46f(\delta_\phi)d\delta_\phi\,\ , , \ ] ] where @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the limits describing the effective divergence of a beam , and @xmath49 is the deviation angle with respect to the normal of a screen .
+ + in fig .
[ fig6 ] ( right column ) you can see the influence of beam divergence on the dr distribution .
first two values show the distance from beam line to upper and lower half - plane respectively , third value show the beam size , and each curve corresponds to the average beam divergence ( in our case the fwhm , i.e. the full width at half maximum ) .
the left column shows the distributions for different beam sizes but with the same divergence angle .
as we can see the influence of angular divergence is much stronger than that of the beam size .
however , this depends on the parameters used .
as seen from this chapter , the divergence as well as the size of a beam have no influence on the position of spikes in the dr angular distribution .
unfortunately , these parameters might lead to disappearing all spikes on the graphs , if they are comparable with the slits values .
this feature is very sharp in fig .
[ fig6 ] , the right column .
in order to have more sensitive system based on dr technique let us introduce a second slit ( fig.[fig7 ] ) .
for two slit configuration one of the most important parameter is the shift between the upper and lower half - planes , because even small shift between half - planes can lead to dramatic changes in dr distribution , as shown in @xcite .
moreover , the shift between the centers of slits should be taken into account .
first of all , let us define the angular dependence between two spikes versus position of a bunch . for simplicity
, we have chosen the slits to be collinear . to calculate dr from the system of two slits we have used the approximation as described in @xcite in fig .
[ fig8 ] we have represented several distributions corresponding to different locations of the beam .
as we can see , for a two - slit configuration , the distance between spikes does not vary at the change of electron position that makes the system of two slits not applicable for determination of electron bunch position .
in previous sections for all calculations a far - field approximation was used . however , in experiment with two - slit setup the second slit is situated in 2 cm from the first one .
hence , in order to know the changes in final dr distribution due to the presence of a second slit we need to know dr distribution from the first slit at the position of second one .
these calculations have to be done within the near - field approximation , which we have used as for transition radiation ( tr ) @xcite : @xmath50}}{\sqrt{d^2+(h_x - x)^2+(h_y - y)^2}}\ , , \label{e - tr}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath51 here @xmath52 is the mcdonald function , @xmath41 and @xmath47 are the sizes of a plate , @xmath53 and @xmath54 are the initial shifts with respect to the center of a plate , and @xmath48 is the distance between the tr source and the plane of radiation detection ( fig.[fig9 ] ) . in order to calculate dr
, we have to exclude from the integral expression for tr the part corresponding to the slit .
indeed , it means that we can consider dr as tr from two half - planes without the coefficient before the integral ( [ e - tr ] ) @xmath55}}{\sqrt{d^2+(h_x - x)^2+(h_y - y)^2 } } dh_x + \\ \\
+ \int_{-a}^{\frac{-w_{sl}}{2}-h_{0y } } \ !
dh_y \int_{-c}^{c}e_{y}^i(h_x , h_y ) \frac{\exp{[ik\sqrt{d^2+(h_x - x)^2+(h_y - y)^2}]}}{\sqrt{d^2+(h_x - x)^2+(h_y - y)^2 } } dh_x,\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath56 is the width of a slit .
now let us analyze and successfully compare the results of calculations for both far- and near - field approximations .
+ in fig . [ fig10 ] a ) and b ) we have presented the angular distributions for both far- and near - field calculations when electron passes through the center of a slit with the width of 1 mm . as seen , the distributions are characterized by visible differences , while the positions of maxima remains unchanged .
we deal with the opposite situation when the bunch is shifted with respect to the center of a slit .
namely , the dr angular distributions simulated for far - field approximation are different from those for near - field one .
this situation is shown in fig .
[ fig10 ] c ) and d ) ( here , the impact parameter for upper half plane is 0.7 mm , and for lower half plane - 0.3 mm ) .
this feature becomes easy to understand if we consider dr from one half - plane . in fig .
[ fig11 ] for both pictures the blues line represent the distributions from the upper half - plane , the red line - from lower half - plane , and the dashed line - the sum of these distributions . from the distributions the intensity maxima in far - field approximation are revealed in forward direction ( at zero angle ) , while for near - field distributions the maxima are shifted from `` zero '' in opposite directions to each other . in fig .
[ fig12 ] we can see that the position of maximum for dr angular distribution , simulated in near - field limit , tends to zero at moving the detection plane far away from the slit that corresponds to the far - field approximation at long distances . as seen , the dr intensity at such long distances are extremely low that is , obviously , expected result ( it is shown by normalized black curve ) .
moreover , from these calculations we can conclude that the pronounced maximum of dr in near - field case becomes less sharp by its intensity for a distant observation plane .
it should be underlined that in experiments the angular distributions are measured by mean of a lens that allows direct ( distance independent ) angular scan for dr distributions .
this feature is taken into account for further simulations .
let us apply near - field calculations to two - slit system .
typically , we measure the interference between forward dr ( fdr ) from the first slit and backward dr ( bdr ) from the second slit ( fig.[fig7 ] ) . at reflection of fdr from the second slit some portion of radiation passes through the hole ; evidently , this portion does not contribute to bdr . in order to calculate this part we have to use the near - field calculations .
spatial distribution of fdr at the distance of 2 cm for 1 mm slit can be simulated by the expression ( [ near - field ] ) . at such small distances total dr , which is generated by two half planes , does not still overlap .
thus , at the second slit position we can resolve two independent maxima .
indeed , the emission distributions overlap in the hole space of a slit that results in its loosing for further evaluation .
however , this portion of radiation is rather small ( the second slit of only 0.5 mm ) , and successfully , we can see that it does not change essentially the final distribution . in order to understand how dr distribution depends on the shift between the centers of two slits several angular distributions for various shifts were compared ( fig .
[ fig14 ] ) .
first distribution ( a ) corresponds to the beam passing through the center of first slit without the slits shift .
dashed line is dr from the second slit in absence of the first one . in presence of
the first slit the central maxima get lower and , vice versa , the second ( side ) maxima become higher . following the desy experiments ,
the second slit is fixed to have a beam passed through its center , while the position of the first slit has been changed . in fig .
[ fig14 ] b ) we have shown the case when the edges of the upper half - planes of both first and second slits are on the same level .
for such configuration we lose part of radiation from upper half - plane that corresponds to negative angles . as a consequence , the relative influence of
the first slit on positive part of dr will be stronger . in fig .
[ fig14 ] b ) we observe the positive spike less intense than negative one ( with respect to zero position ) , and , vice versa , for the second maxima . as above mentioned , for the collinear slits , additional slit makes central maxima less , while for the side maxima we have got the intensity increase .
+ a ) + b ) + c ) now let us decrease the impact parameter for upper half plane of the first slit with respect to that for the second slit ( fig .
[ fig14 ] c ) . for this geometry
we can neglect the radiation from lower half - plane of the first slit due to relatively distant beam pass .
radiation in negative angles ( especially for big angles ) is completely lost and , hence , its influence becomes disappearing . but some part of radiation for positive angles even more intensive than the radiation from the second slit , is reflected ( fig .
[ fig14 ] c ) . comparing these results
we can conclude that the influence of the slits shift is mostly significant when beam passes very close to one of the half - planes .
in order to compare with experimental data it is necessary to introduce parameters of both beam and slit . for far - field calculations
we have already introduced the size of a beam as all as its divergence . for near - field case ,
the calculations were performed paying attention to coherent features of a beam . indeed in our calculations
we deal with the field parameters instead of their intensities in the case of far - field limit , i.e. the coherent field can be written as follows @xmath57 here @xmath47 and @xmath48 defines the beam divergence cone .
preliminary calculations have shown that the size of a beam has very small influence on final distributions .
the latter allows us to limit the analysis taking into account the beam divergence .
however , we have additionally to introduce the shift between two half - planes of the slit . this can be done by adding the phase shift between uppers and lowers half - planes of both slits @xcite . moreover , in our calculations we have to introduce the angle of incident it is well known how to calculate dr for the geometry when the beam crosses the slit normal to the slit plane . to evaluate dr for the case of non perpendicular incidence we can reduce the problem to known one .
namely , for each point of the slit we can apply imaginary slit perpendicular to the incident beam ( fig .
[ fig15 ] ) .
that allows calculation of radiation within known code .
however , within this approach it becomes necessary to change impact parameter for each point of the slit : @xmath58 , as well as to take into account the phase shift between the points of a slit ( we assume that projectile emits at shortest impact parameter ) .
the experimental dr distributions are presented in fig .
[ fig16 ] . in experiments two - slit system
was used with the distance between the silts of 2 cm ; the slits width were 1 mm for the first slit , and 0.5 mm for the second .
the electron beam passes through the center of second slit , while the first slit is moveable .
the accuracy in half - planes coplanarity was within about 10 nm .
the beam divergence was measured about 10 @xmath44rad .
fig.[fig16 ] a ) shows dr when the beam passes the centers of both slits , while in the figure b ) the first slit is shifted by 25 @xmath44 m . on both graphs the dashed line corresponds to theoretical dependences , while the solid line - to experiment ones .
as seen , theoretical distributions are in a good agreement with experimental data keeping the maximal error within 5% . for calculations
we have defined next parameters ( close to those of the experiment ) : the shift between slit half - planes of 60 nm , the divergence of 40 @xmath44rad .
our calculations have shown better coincidence with experiment at the second slit width of 0.57 mm instead of 0.5 mm used .
in this work we have presented the results on dr in near - flied limit , and its difference from the one of far - filed approach . having calculated spatial distribution of dr in near - filed zone
, we have studied the influence of slits incoplanarity on the final distribution .
the results obtained have shown that at definite system configurations the relative shift of the slit centers can strongly affect the resulting dr angular distribution .
the simulations were first done for the case of coherent beam .
all described models were used to compare with experimental data , and have shown a good coincidence . calculated beam parameters , such as its divergence , were well comparable with beam parameters obtained by the use of alternative methods ( quadruple scanning ) . moreover , in this work we have proposed a new method to define the position of electron beam with respect to the slit taking into account the positions of two central maxima in dr angular distributions .
the authors are grateful to m. ferrario , m. castellano , a. cianchi and e. chiadroni for fruitful discussions and experimental data provided .
special thanks from v. sh . addressed to o. bogdanov , a. babaev and e. frolov for their help in numerical calculations . 99 l.d .
landau , and e.m .
lifshitz , course of theoretical physics , vol .
2 , pergamon press ( 1962 ) . l.d .
landau , and e.m .
lifshitz , course of theoretical physics , vol . 8 , pergamon press ( 1962 ) .
ginzburg , and v.n .
tsytovich , transition radiation and transition scatering , adam hilger , bristol and new york ( 1990 ) .
kazantsev , and g.i .
surdutovich , sov .
dokl . 7 , 990 ( 1963 ) .
potylitsyn , m.i .
ryazanov , m.n .
strikhanov , and a.a .
tishchenko , diffraction radiation from relativistic particles .
stmp 239 ( springer , berlin heidelberg 2010 ) . r.b .
fiorito , and d.w .
rule , nucl .
. meth . in phys
b 173 ( 2001 ) 67 - 82 .
n. potylitsina - kube , and x. artru , nucl
. instr . meth . in phys .
b 201 ( 2003 ) 172 - 183 .
m. castellano , e. chiadroni , and a. cianchi , nucl .
instr . and meth .
a 614 ( 2010 ) 163 - 168 .
a. cianchi , m. castellano , l. catani , e. chiadroni , k. honkavaara , and g. kube , phys .
- accelerators and beams 14 , 102803 ( 2011 ) .
p. karataev , and s. akari .
- accelerators and beams 11 , 032804 ( 2008 ) d.v .
karlovets , and a.p .
potylitsyn , physics letters a 373 ( 2009 ) 1988 - 1996 . | new research in acceleration physics leads to growing up the power of charged particles bunches .
existed methods based on interaction of detection devices with bunches do not satisfy our need , because of the fact that new high intensity bunches can damage this devices .
moreover , these methods do not allow analyzing the bunches in real time .
recently new technique based on odri ( optical diffraction radiation interference ) by a bunch at its propagation through the slit was proposed . in this work
the results of theoretical simulations on diffraction radiation , in particular odri , by electrons for various slit systems as well as the comparison with the desy experimental data are presented .
pacs : 41.60.-m , 29.27.-a , 41.75.ht , 07.77.ka |
the study of the extended emission in the narrow - line region ( nlr ) around nearby active galactic nuclei ( agn ) allows the investigation of both the agn feeding via gas inflows ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and feedback via the interaction of the agn radiation and mass outflow with the circumnuclear gas , affecting its kinematics and excitation ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
most studies on the feeding and feedback mechanisms of active galactic nuclei ( agn ) presently available in the literature are based on optical observations , which are affected by dust obscuration , a problem that can be softened by the use of infrared observations .
another advantage of infrared spectral region is that , besides observing ionized gas emission , we can also observe emission from molecular gas ( h@xmath10 ) .
our group , _ agnifs _
( for agn integral field spectroscopy ) , has been developing a project to map both the feeding and feedback in nearby agn using near - infrared integral field spectroscopic observations mostly with the instrument nifs at the gemini north telescope .
the main findings of our group so far have been that the molecular gas traced by k - band @xmath16 emission , and the ionized gas traced by hi recombination lines and [ feii ] emission , present distinct flux distributions and kinematics .
usually the @xmath16 emitting gas is restricted to the plane of the galaxy , while the ionized gas extends also to high latitudes and is associated with the radio emission , when present @xcite .
the @xmath16 kinematics is usually dominated by rotation , including in some cases , streaming motions towards the nucleus , while the kinematics of the ionized gas , and in particular of the [ feii ] emitting gas , shows also , in many cases , a strong outflowing component associated with radio jets from the agn .
similar results have been found using the spectrograph for integral field observations in the near infrared ( sinfoni ) at the very large telescope ( vlt ) .
@xcite found molecular gas inflows towards the nucleus of ngc1097 and @xcite mapped similar h@xmath10 inflows feeding and obscuring the active nucleus of ngc1068 , while @xcite mapped outflows in ionized gas around 7 active galatic nuclei . in this work
, we present the gaseous distribution and kinematics of the inner 450pc radius of the narrow - line seyfert 1 galaxy mrk766 ( ngc4253 ) a barred spiral galaxy ( sba ) , located at a distance of 60.6mpc , for which 1@xmath17 corresponds to 294pc at the galaxy .
the hst images of this galaxy show some irregular dust filaments around the nucleus @xcite .
@xcite show that the radio source appears to be extended to south - east in pa @xmath2 150@xmath18 ( on a scale of @xmath2 1@xmath19 ) .
the optical emission is extended beyond the radio structure @xcite .
the nir spectrum is well described by @xcite , showing a large number of permited lines of hi , hei , heii and feii , and by forbidden lines of [ sii ] , [ siii ] and [ feii ] .
high ionization lines like [ siix ] , [ six ] , [ six ] and [ mgviii ] are also observed .
the x - rays observations of this galaxy show that it is a strong variable source , with evidences of the amplitude being larger at @xmath2 2kev .
the mass of the supermassive black hole has been accurately measured via reverberation mapping by @xcite , resulting in a mass of 1.76@xmath2010@xmath21m@xmath13 .
there is no co observations for this galaxy in the literature .
mrk766 was selected for this study because : ( i ) it presents strong near - ir emission lines ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , allowing the mapping of the gaseous distribution and kinematics ; and ( ii ) it has radio emission , allowing the investigation of the role of the radio jet @xcite in the gas excitation and kinematics .
this paper is organized as follows : in sec .
2 we describe the observations and data reduction procedures .
the results are presented in sec . 3 and discussed in sec . 4 .
we present our conclusions in sec .
the observations of mrk766 were obtained using the gemini near infrared integral field spectrograph ( nifs - @xcite ) operating with the gemini north adaptive optics system altair in june 2010 under the programme gn-2010a - q-42 , following the standard sky - object - object - sky dither sequence .
observations were obtained in the j - band using the @xmath22 grating and @xmath23 filter , and in the @xmath24-band using the @xmath25 grating and @xmath26 filter . on - source and
sky position observations were both obtained with individual exposure times of 550s .
two sets of observations with six on - source individual exposures were obtained : the first , in the j - band , was centred at 1.25@xmath5 m and covered the spectral range 1.14@xmath5 m to 1.36@xmath5 m , and the second , in the @xmath24-band , was centred at 2.3@xmath5 m and covered the spectral range 2.10@xmath5 m to 2.53@xmath5 m .
the data reduction procedure included trimming of the images , flat - fielding , sky subtraction , wavelength and spatial distortion calibrations .
we also removed the telluric bands and flux calibrated the frames by interpolating a black body function to the spectrum of the telluric standard star .
these procedures were executed using tasks contained in the nifs software package which is part of gemini iraf package , as well as generic iraf tasks . in order to check our flux calibration , we extracted a nuclear spectrum with the same aperture of a previous spectrum of the galaxy by @xcite .
the two spectra are very similar to each other ( considering the difference in spectral resolution ) , with the largest difference in flux being about 5% at 2.2@xmath5 m .
the final ifu data cube for each band contains @xmath274200 spectra , with each spectrum corresponding to an angular coverage of 005@xmath28005 , which translates into @xmath215@xmath2815pc@xmath29 at the galaxy and covering the inner 3@xmath283(@xmath2 900@xmath28900pc@xmath29 ) of the galaxy .
the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of the arc lamp lines in the j - band is 1.65 , corresponding in velocity space to 40kms@xmath1 , while in the @xmath24-band the fwhm of the arc lamp lines is 3.45 , corresponding to 45kms@xmath1 .
the angular resolution obtained from the fwhm of the spatial profile of the flux distribution of the broad component of the pa@xmath11 and br@xmath9 lines and is 021@xmath30003 for the j - band and 019@xmath30003 for the @xmath24-band , corresponding to 60pc and 55pc at the galaxy , respectively .
in the top - left panel of fig.[galaxia ] we present an optical image of mrk766 obtained with the lick observatory nickel telescope @xcite . in the top - right panel
we present an optical image of mrk766 obtained with the hubble space telescope ( hst ) wide field planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2 ) through the filter f606w @xcite . in the bottom panels we present , to the left , a zoom of the hst image within the field - of - view ( fov ) covered by the nifs observations and to the right an image obtained from the nifs data cube within a continuum window centred at @xmath31 m . in fig.[teste ] we present two ifu spectra integrated within a 025@xmath28025 aperture : one at the nucleus and the other at 05 east of it ( position a ) , chosen randomly with the purpose of just presenting a characteristic extranuclear spectrum .
the nucleus was defined to be the location of the peak flux in the continuum .
we list in table 1 the emission line fluxes we could measure from these two spectra , which comprise 20 emission lines from the species [ pii ] , [ feii ] , heii , hi , @xmath32 , [ six ] and [ caviii ] .
they were measured with the _ splot _ task in iraf and the uncertainties were estimated as the standard deviation of the average of 6 measurements . in order to map the flux distributions as well as the centroid velocity and velocity dispersion fields , we used the profit routine @xcite to fit the profiles of [ pii]@xmath33 m , [ six]@xmath3 m , [ feii]@xmath6 m , pa@xmath34 m , @xmath35 m and br@xmath36 m emission lines at each pixel over the whole fov .
these emission lines were chosen because they have the highest signal - to - noise ( s / n ) ratios among their species ( coronal , ionized and molecular gas ) .
the flux values ( as well as those of the central wavelength and width of the profile , see next sections ) were obtained by the fit of the profiles using both gaussian and gauss - hermite ( gh ) series .
we found out that the latter gave better fits to most lines , except for the [ six ] line , for which the gh fits introduced extra wings in some regions where the line was weak .
we decided then to adopt the paramenters of the fit obtained from the gh for all lines except for [ s ix ] , for which we adopted the fit with gaussians . in the case of pa@xmath11 and br@xmath9
we have fitted also a broad component to the line .
this was done via a modification of the profit routine to fit the broad component and subtract its contribution from the profiles in order to generate a datacube only with the narrow component .
the steps in this procedure were : i ) fit only one gaussian to the broad component ; ii ) subtract it from the spectra where it is present , and iii ) fit the narrow component . in fig.[flux - distributions ]
we present the resulting flux distribution maps , where we have masked out the bad fits by using the chi - square map , which is an output from the profit routine .
all maps have their peak fluxes at the same position , which also coincides with that of the peak of the continuum : the nucleus .
the [ pii ] and [ six ] flux distributions are the most compact , reaching about 05 from the nucleus in all directions in the case of the former , and being more extended to the south - west in the case of the latter .
another coronal line ( not shown in the figure ) , [ caviii]@xmath37 m , also shows a similarly compact flux distribution , indicating that the coronal line region is compact but resolved , extending up to 150 pc from the nucleus , what is a typical radius for this region ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the highest levels of the [ pii ] flux distribution are more elongated towards the south - east .
this elongation is also observed in the [ feii ] emission , which reaches 08 ( 240 pc ) from the nucleus in that direction .
the pa@xmath11 flux distribution is the most extended in all directions , reaching up to 1@xmath17 from the nucleus .
the br@xmath9 flux distribution is very similar to that of pa@xmath11 , although noisier due to its lower flux .
the h@xmath10 flux distribution is somewhat distinct , being elongated from north - east to south - west , thus approximately perpendicular to the elongation of the [ feii ] flux distribution , reaching 15 ( 440 pc ) from the nucleus towards the south - west . .
[ flux - distributions ] in fig .
[ razoes ] , we present line - ratio maps obtained from the flux maps , where regions with bad fits were masked out .
the average uncertainties in the line - ratio values are @xmath2 10% . in the left panel
we present the [ feii]@xmath38m/@xmath7 ratio map , which can be used to investigate the excitation mechanism of [ feii ] ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the values of [ feii]/pa@xmath11 for mrk766 range from 0.2 ( most locations ) to 1.0 with the highest values between 0.6 and 1 being observed between 02 and 06 to the south - east of the nucleus
. another line ratio that can be used to investigate the [ feii ] excitation mechanism is [ feii]@xmath39m/[pii]@xmath40 m .
values larger than 2 indicate that shocks have passed through the gas destroying the dust grains , releasing the fe and enhancing its abundance and emission ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we present this ratio map in the central panel of fig .
[ razoes ] .
the lowest values ( @xmath412 ) , are observed to the north and north - west of the nucleus while the highest values of @xmath2 7.0 are observed in a narrow strip at @xmath206 to the south - east of the nucleus , approximately at the border of the region with the highest values of [ feii]/pa@xmath11 . in the right panel of fig .
[ razoes ] we present the @xmath35m / br@xmath9 ratio map , which is useful to investigate the excitation of the @xmath32 emission line ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in mrk766 ,
the values of this ratio range from 0.2 to 2.0 .
the lowest values are observed at the nucleus and in most regions to the south and south - east , except for the region between 02 and 06 to the south - east where the values increase to @xmath20.8 ( where both [ feii]/pa@xmath11 and [ feii]/[pii ] show larger values ) .
such increased values are also observed to the north where they reach @xmath2 1.25 . at approximately 1 arcsec to the south - west ,
the values reach up to @xmath22 , although the fit of the lines is not so good and the uncertainty is high there . [
cols="<,<,^,^",options="header " , ] the profit routine ( riffel 2010 ) that we have used to obtain the flux of the emission lines , provide also the centroid velocity ( v ) , velocity dispersion ( @xmath42 ) and higher order gauss - hermite moments ( @xmath43 and @xmath44 ) , which have been used to map the gas kinematics . in fig .
[ velocity ] we present the centroid velocity fields after subtraction of the heliocentric systemic velocity of 3853@xmath3017 km s@xmath1 , which was obtained through a model fitted to the pa@xmath11 velocity field , as discussed in sec .
the uncertainties in the velocity maps range from 5 to 20 km s@xmath1 depending on the s / n ratio of the spectra ( which decrease from the center towards the border of the mapped region ) .
the white regions in the figures represent locations where the s / n was not high enough to allow the fitting of the line profiles .
all velocity fields show blueshifts to the east ( left in the figures ) and redshifts to the west , with the line of nodes oriented at a position angle of approximately @xmath45 ( see sec .
4.3 ) , with the isovelocity lines showing an approximate `` spider diagram '' characteristic of rotation .
6 shows the velocity dispersion maps corresponding to the centroid velocity maps of fig .
[ velocity ] . as in the case of the centroid velocities , the uncertainties in the velocity dispersion maps range from 5 to 20 km s@xmath1 depending on the s / n ratio of the spectra .
the white regions in the figures represent locations where the s / n was not high enough to allow the fitting of the line profiles .
the [ feii ] @xmath42 map shows the highest values of up to 150 kms@xmath1 to the south - east of the nucleus and lowest values , down to 75 kms@xmath1 , to the north - west .
the [ pii ] @xmath42 map has medium values with soft deviations .
the pa@xmath11 @xmath42 map shows high values at the nucleus and also 0@xmath194 to the south and 0@xmath196 to the north and lower values to the east , south and west of this central region .
the higher values at the nuclear region may be due to residual contamination from the broad component of the line .
the @xmath16 emitting gas presents the lowest @xmath42 values , which are smaller than 70 kms@xmath1 at most locations .
we do not show the @xmath43 and @xmath44 maps because their values are low and do not present any systematic behavior .
channel maps along the emission line profiles are shown in figs . 7 , 8 , 9 and 10 for the [ six ] , [ feii ] , pa@xmath11 and @xmath16 emission lines , respectively .
each panel presents the flux distribution in logarithmic units integrated in velocity bins centred at the velocity shown in the top - left corner of each panel ( relative to the systemic velocity of the galaxy ) .
the central cross marks the position of the nucleus .
we do not show channel maps for [ pii ] and br@xmath9 because the [ pii ] maps are similar to those of [ feii ] and those for br@xmath9 are similar to those of pa@xmath11 but noisier . in fig .
7 , the channel maps along the [ six ] emission line profile show the flux distributions integrated within velocity bins of 25 kms@xmath1 ( corresponding to one spectral pixel ) . at the highest velocities
the emission is extended 05 to the south / south - west , and at the lowest velocities , the [ six ] is concentrated in the nucleus . in fig .
8 , the channel maps along the [ feii ] emission - line profile show the flux distributions integrated within velocity bins of 105 kms@xmath1 ( corresponding to three spectral pixels ) for the highest velocities and 50kms@xmath1 for the central panels ( corresponding to two spectral pixels ) .
all [ feii ] channel maps present flux distributions which are elongated towards the south - east , up to@xmath209 ( 270pc ) from the nucleus . both the highest blueshifts and highest redshifts , which reach @xmath46kms@xmath1 ,
are also observed to the south - east of the nucleus . fig .
9 shows the channel maps for the pa@xmath11 emitting gas for the same velocity bins as for [ feii ] .
the highest blueshifts and redshifts are observed mostly at the nucleus , but are probably due to residuals of a broad component to the line which was fitted and subtracted .
the flux distributions are more extended and more symmetrically distributed around the nucleus than those of the [ feii ] channel maps .
10 shows the channel maps for the @xmath16 emitting gas , for velocity bins of 30kms@xmath1 .
the highest blueshifts and redshifts , reaching @xmath2130kms@xmath1 , are observed to the north - east and south - west of the nucleus respectively , following the line of nodes of the galaxy , as seen in fig .
[ velocity ] . for zero and positive velocities
there is a structure extending from the nucleus to the south - west .
in order to further map the excitation of the circum - nuclear line - emitting region we constructed a spectral diagnostic diagram with the ratios [ feii]@xmath6m@xmath47 vs. @xmath35m / br@xmath9 @xcite , shown in fig[diagnostico ] .
typical values for the nuclei of seyfert galaxies range between 0.6 and 2.0 for both ratios @xcite , while for starbursts the values are smaller than 0.6 and for liners the values are larger than 2 , as shown in the top panel of fig.[diagnostico ] . in this figure ,
black filled circles represent seyfert ratios , blue open circles , starbursts ratios and red crosses represent ratios of low - ionization nuclear emission - line regions ( liners ) .
most ratios present starburst and seyfert values , with a few liner values .
the locations from where the distinct line ratios originate are shown in the bottom panel of fig.[diagnostico ] .
seyfert ratios are found at the nucleus , in most regions to the north and between 02 and 06 to the south - east . in a few locations to the north of the nucleus , between the nucleus and the region of enhanced ratios ( at 0206 ) and beyond this region ,
starburst ratios are found .
liner ratios are only found at the south - west border of the mapped region .
@xmath41.25@xmath5m / pa@xmath11 versus h@[email protected]@xmath5m / br@xmath9 line - ratio diagnostic diagram .
the dashed lines delimit regions with ratios typical of starbursts ( blue open circles ) , seyferts ( black filled circles ) and liners ( red crosses ) .
bottom panel : spatial position of each point from the diagnostic diagram . ]
the excitation of warm h@xmath10 has been the subject of many previous studies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . summarizing
, these studies have shown that the @xmath16 emission lines can be excited by two mechanisms : ( i ) fluorescent excitation through absorption of soft - uv photons ( 912 - 1108 ) in the lyman and werner bands @xcite and ( ii ) collisional excitation due to heating of the gas by shocks , in the interaction of a radio jet with the interstellar medium @xcite or heating by x - rays from the central agn @xcite .
the second mechanism is usually referred to as thermal process since it involves the local heating of the emitting gas , while the first is usually called a non - thermal process .
previous studies have verified that non - thermal processes are not important for most galaxies studied so far ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in the case of mrk766 , the h@xmath10/br@xmath9 ratio ( fig . [ razoes ] ) is larger than 0.6 to the north - east of the nucleus and in the arc - shaped region between @xmath48 and @xmath49 to the south - east supporting seyfert excitation there
. the origin of the h@xmath10 excitation could be fluorescence or thermal excitation .
one possible evidence for fluorescence ( a non - thermal process ) is a ratio between the h@xmath10 lines 2.24@xmath5m/2.12@xmath5 m higher than 0.6 @xcite .
we could measure this ratio at position a , where the value is @xmath270.2 , favoring thermal excitation . at a number of other positions , the 2.24@xmath5 m line is fainter , but wherever it could be measured , the line ratio is smaller than 0.2 .
this line ratio thus seem to favor thermal excitation due to heating by x - rays or shocks from a radio jet ( which seems to be present to the se ) in the region with seyfert excitation " , although there is no clear signature of shocks such as an increase in velocity dispersion as observed in the [ feii ] emission . in the remaining regions , the h@xmath10/br@xmath9 ratio is smaller than 0.6 , supporting starburst excitation via heating from shocks in sne winds and/or by uv radiation from young stars .
the presence of starbursts in the nuclear region is in agreement with the results of @xcite , who reported the observation of the pah 3.3@xmath5 m feature in the infrared spectrum of mrk766 within the inner 150 pc , suggesting the presence of recent star formation there .
the mixed seyfert and starburst excitation is also seen in the diagnostic diagram of fig .
[ diagnostico ] . using the [ feii]@xmath6m@xmath47 and [ feii]@xmath6m@xmath50[pii]@xmath40 m line - ratio maps shown in fig.[razoes ]
, we can investigate the excitation mechanism of [ feii ] .
the first ratio [ feii]@xmath6m@xmath47 is controlled by the ratio between the volumes of partially to fully ionized gas regions , as the [ feii ] emission is excited in partially ionized gas regions . in agns , such regions can be created by x - ray ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) and/or shock ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) heating of the gas . for starburst galaxies , [ feii]/@xmath51 and for supernovae for which shocks are the main excitation mechanism ,
this ratio is larger than 2 @xcite .
the values of [ feii]/@xmath7 range from @xmath20.2 to the north - west to @xmath21.0 in the arc - shaped region between 02 and 06 to the south - east of the nucleus .
@xcite have obtained a 3.6 cm radio image of mrk766 and found an extended emission to the se , at the location of the arc - shaped region where there is an enhancement of the [ feii]/pa@xmath11 ratio .
the variation of this line ratio , and its correlation with the radio structure suggest that excitation by shocks from the radio jet is indeed important at this location . on the other hand , we can not rule out the possible contribution from supernovae as well .
the above conclusion is also supported by the [ feii]@xmath6m/[pii]@xmath33 m line - ratio map ( central panel of fig.[razoes ] ) .
these two lines have similar ionization temperatures , and their parent ions have similar ionization potentials and relative recombination coefficients . values larger than 2 indicate that the shocks have passed through the gas destroying the dust grains , releasing the fe and enhancing its abundance and thus emission @xcite . for supernovae remnants , where shocks are the dominant excitation mechanism , [ feii]/[pii ] is typically higher than 20 @xcite . for mrk766 , to the south - east of the nucleus , where there is the radio structure , [ feii]/[pii ]
values reach @xmath210 ( fig.[razoes ] ) , suggesting that shocks are indeed important in agreement with the highest values obtained for the [ feii]/@xmath7 at the same locations . in other regions ,
typical values are [ feii]/[pii]@xmath41 2 , indicating almost no contribution from shocks .
finally , the diagnostic diagram of fig.[diagnostico ] confirms seyfert excitation in the nucleus and in the south - east arc and regions surrounding the nucleus and non - seyfert values in the other regions .
and the low [ feii]/[pii ] ratios in these other regions suggest also that sne winds should not be important , favoring ionization by young stars instead . the mass of ionized gas in the inner 900@xmath28900pc@xmath29 of the galaxy can be estimated using ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) : @xmath52 , \ ] ] where @xmath53 is the integrated flux for the @xmath54 emission line and @xmath55 is the distance to mrk766 .
we have assumed an electron temperature @xmath56 and electron density @xmath57@xmath58 @xcite .
the mass of warm molecular gas can be obtained using @xcite : @xmath59,\ ] ] where @xmath60 is the integrated flux for the @xmath61 m emission line and we have used the vibrational temperature @xmath62 @xcite .
we used the br@xmath9/pa@xmath11 line ratio in order to estimate the effect of the reddening in the observed fluxes for these lines .
we constructed a reddening map using the pa@xmath11/br@xmath9 line ratio .
the resulting map is very noisy with an additional uncertainty relative to other line ratios because the lines are in different spectral bands ( k and j ) .
the e(b - v ) values are also mostly very small .
thus , instead of using this map to correct the whole br@xmath9 flux distribution for reddening as we would introduce too much noise we have estimated an average value for @xmath63 using the the integrated fluxes for br@xmath9 and pa@xmath11 emission lines over the whole field of view , following @xcite and adopting the extinction law of @xcite . adopting this @xmath64 value , the fluxes for the emission lines in the k band increase by about 10% .
the effect of the reddening is negligible for the line ratios of fig .
[ razoes ] , since the lines are from the same band and the reddening has no effect on the discussion of the gas excitation presented above . on the other hand ,
its effect is not negligible for the estimate of the ionized and molecular gas masses , which have thus been corrected .
integrating over the whole ifu field , we obtain the following reddening - corrected values : @xmath65
6.82@xmath66 erg@xmath67@xmath68 and @xmath697.3@xmath70erg@xmath67@xmath68 .
the resulting masses are @xmath71 7.6@xmath72 and @xmath73 1.32@xmath74 @xmath75 .
the above values are similar to those we have obtained in previous studies , which are in the range @xmath76 m@xmath77 [email protected]@xmath79 m@xmath80 and 66m@xmath77 m@xmath813300 m@xmath80 , respectively . the mass of molecular gas is thus 10@xmath82 times smaller than that of the ionized gas but , as discussed in @xcite , this h@xmath10 mass represents only that of warm gas emitting in the near - ir .
the total mass of molecular gas is dominated by the cold gas , and the usual proxy to estimate the cold h@xmath10 mass has been the co emission .
a number of studies have derived the ratio between the cold and warm h@xmath10 gas masses by comparing the masses obtained using the co and near - ir emission . @xcite
obtained ratios in the range 10@xmath8310@xmath84 ; using a larger sample of 16 luminous and ultraluminous infrared galaxies , @xcite derived a ratio m@xmath85/m@xmath86 = 1 - 5@xmath87 .
more recently , @xcite compiled from the literature values of mcold derived from co observations and [email protected]@xmath5 m luminosities for a larger number of galaxies , covering a wider range of luminosities , morphological and nuclear activity types . from that
, an estimate of the cold h2 gas mass can be obtained from @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the luminosity of the [email protected]@xmath5 m line .
the resulting mass value is m@xmath90 @xmath2 9.8@xmath2810@xmath91 .
all the velocity fields shown in fig . [ velocity ] suggest rotation in the inner 450pc of mrk766 . in order to obtain the systemic velocity , orientation of the line of nodes and an estimate for the enclosed mass
, we fitted a model of circular orbits in a plane to the @xmath7 and h@xmath92 m velocity fields .
the expression for the circular velocity is given by @xcite : @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the projected distance from the nucleus in the plane of the sky , @xmath95 is the corresponding position angle , @xmath96 is the mass inside @xmath94 , @xmath97 is the newtow s gravitational constant , @xmath98 is the systemic velocity , @xmath99 is the inclination of the disc ( @xmath100 for a face - on disc ) , @xmath101 is the position angle of the line of nodes and @xmath102 is a scale length projected in the plane of the sky . the location of the kinematical center was not allowed to vary , being fixed to the position of the peak of the continuum .
the equation above contains five free parameters , which can be determined by fitting the model to the observations .
this was done using the levenberg - marquardt least - squares fitting algorithm , in which initial guesses are given for the free parameters .
the best fit model for pa@xmath11 is shown in fig.[residuals1 ] ( top - left panel ) and the best fit model for h@xmath92 m in fig.[residuals2 ] . in both figures
we show the residual maps ( observed velocity field - model ) for [ feii ] ( bottom - left panel ) , @xmath16 ( bottom - right panel ) and @xmath7 ( top - right panel ) .
the parameters derived from the fit of the pa@xmath11 are : the systemic velocity corrected to the heliocentric reference frame @xmath103kms@xmath1 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 pc .
we can compare the near - ir line - emitting gas kinematics with results obtained in the optical at larger scales .
@xcite present long - slit spectroscopy of mrk 766 at kpc scales with the slit oriented along pa@xmath108 .
they found that the kinematic of the high - excitation gas ( traced by the [ oiii]@xmath109 emission ) is more perturbed than that of the low - ionization gas ( traced by h@xmath110 and h@xmath11 ) , showing radial motions consistent with gas outflows from the nucleus .
the low - ionization gas seems to be dominated by rotation in the plane of the galaxy with a velocity amplitude of @xmath27130 kms@xmath1 . at distances smaller than 15 from the nucleus , the velocity amplitude is @xmath11150kms@xmath1 , which is somewhat smaller than the amplitude that we have derived .
this is expected , since the slit used by @xcite was not oriented along the major axis of the galaxy .
@xcite quote a photometric major axis orientation of 105@xmath112 , based on an large scale continuum image at @xmath45960 .
the pa of the line of nodes @xmath101 that we have found is 25@xmath112 smaller than this value . on the other hand ,
our @xmath101 is in reasonable agreement with the value listed at the hyperleda ( @xmath113 * ? ? ?
[ galaxia ] shows that mrk766 presents a bar with size of 4.5 kpc .
the orientation of the bar is similar to that of the photometric major axis considered by @xcite . as the bar is broad an luminous and the outer parts of the galaxy are faint , we believe they have mistakenly concluded that the direction of the bar was that of the major axis .
the systemic velocity and @xmath99 are in reasonable agreement with the values listed at the hyperleda @xcite and ned databases ( @xmath114kms@xmath1 and @xmath115 and @xmath96 and @xmath102 are similar to values found for other seyfert galaxies using the same model ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . for the h@xmath92
m fit we found a much more compact velocity field than that of pa@xmath11 , with a scale lenght @xmath116 pc .
the other parameters were practically the same .
this signature of a more compact rotating disk in h@xmath10 than in pa@xmath11 , is similar to that we have found for mrk1066 @xcite , indicating that h@xmath10 presents a `` colder '' and more ordered kinematics .
an exception is the region to the south - west , which seems to show a detached kinematics .
this region is probably a molecular cloud that is not in the galaxy disc .
the residuals shown in fig.[residuals1 ] show blueshifts in the borders of the measured field in pa@xmath11 to the north north - east of the nucleus which we attribute to poor fits of the lines in this region .
more significant are the redshift residuals to the south - south - east , a region where the largest residuals in the [ feii ] velocity field are also observed .
there is where the enhanced [ feii ] velocity dispersion and the radio structure are also located .
in addition , in this same region , the [ feii ] flux distributions in the channel maps of fig . 8 show both blueshifts and redshifts , with velocities of up to 250 kms1 .
we interpret these results as being due to emission of gas in a one - sided outflow oriented along the position angle @xmath2 135@xmath18 .
the observation of both blueshifts and redshifts in the channel maps supports that its axis lies approximately in the plane of the sky .
the main residuals in the h@xmath10 velocity field that are not in the borders of the field ( where the line fits are poorer ) are the redshifts observed to the north northwest . as this is the near side of the galaxy , we speculate that these residuals could be due to inflows in the plane of the galaxy .
these residuals are seen along the direction of the bar at pa@xmath117 .
we speculate that they may be associated to inflows along the bar , as predicted by theoretical models ( e.g * ? ? ?
* ) and as measured in a few cases ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . in previous studies ,
we have found inflows along nuclear dusty spirals @xcite .
indeed , numerical simulations by @xcite have shown that if a central smbh is present , shocks can extend all the way to the vicinity of the smbh and generate gas inflows consistent with the accretion rates inferred in local agn .
similar residuals are also seen in the pa@xmath11 and [ feii ] residual maps : redshifts to north
northwest , also suggesting inflows .
we rule out the possibility of these redshifts being due to a counterpart of the south - east outflow once it is observed in redshift over the far side of the galaxy .
a possible counterpart should be in blueshift and behind the near side of the galaxy plane .
we do not see such a component ; one possibility is that it is hidden by the galaxy plane .
the residuals shown in fig.[residuals2 ] , after the subtraction of the circular velocity model fitted to the h@xmath10 velocity field shows similar residuals to the south south - east for pa@xmath11 and [ feii ] , but show additional residuals in the northern part of the field . in the case of the h@xmath10 residuals , redshifts are observed also in the region to the south - west , that we have interpreted as due to a detached cloud , that is probably not in the galaxy plane . with the goal of quantifying the feedback from the agn in mrk766 , we estimate the ionized - gas mass outflow rate through a circular cross section with radius @xmath118pc located at a distance of @xmath119 from the nucleus to the south - east .
this geometry corresponds to a conical outflow with an opening angle of @xmath2 64@xmath112 , estimated from fig.[sliceferro ] .
the mass outflow rate can be obtained using : @xmath120 and the filling factor ( @xmath121 ) can be obtained from @xmath122 where @xmath123 is the proton mass , @xmath124 the electron density , @xmath125 is velocity of the outflowing gas and @xmath126 and @xmath127 are the luminosity and the emission coefficient of pa@xmath11 @xcite .
we have assumed that @xmath128@xmath58 , @xmath1291.43@xmath130 erg s@xmath1 , @xmath131 erg @xmath132s@xmath1 and @xmath133kms@xmath134kms@xmath1 where @xmath135 is the angle between the wall of the cone ( from where we observe the line - of - sight velocity component of 147kms@xmath1 ) and the plane of sky .
the latter velocity value was obtained directly from the channel maps considering that the structure seen to south - east is due to the emission of the walls of the cone . as described above , the axis of the cone seems to lie close to the plane of the sky . from the estimated aperture of the cone ,
we adopt a maximum angle between the cone and the plane of the sky of @xmath136 . under these assumptions
we obtain @xmath137 and then @xmath138 yr@xmath1 .
the value found here for @xmath139 is in good agreement with those found in @xcite , which range from 0.1 to 10@xmath140 yr@xmath1 , it is of the same order of that obtained by @xcite , of 8@xmath141 yr@xmath1 , and is also within the range of the values found by @xcite , which range from 2.5 to 120 @xmath141 yr@xmath1 .
following @xcite , we can use the above mass outflow rate to estimate the kinetic power of the outflow using : @xmath142 where @xmath143 is the velocity of the outflowing gas and @xmath42 is its velocity dispersion . using @xmath144kms@xmath1 ( from fig.[disper ] ) and @xmath145kms@xmath1 we obtain @xmath146ergs@xmath1 which is in good agreement with the values obtained for seyfert galaxies and compact radio sources @xcite .
this value is also similar to that obtained for mrk1157 @xcite , of @xmath147ergs@xmath1 , it is within the range of those found by @xcite , between 0.6 to 50@xmath148ergs@xmath1 . in order to compare the above value of @xmath149 with the bolometric luminosity , we estimate the latter as 10 times the x - ray luminosity , of 3.5@xmath148 erg s@xmath1 @xcite , resulting in @xmath150 0.08 l@xmath151 . finally , we can calculate the mass acretion rate to feed the active nucleus from@xcite @xmath152 where , @xmath153 is the nuclear bolometric luminosity , @xmath154 is the efficiency of conversion of the rest mass energy of the accreted material into radiation and @xmath155 is the light speed .
the bolometric luminosity was already estimated as 3.5@xmath156 erg s@xmath1 .
assuming @xmath1570.1 which is a typical value for a geometrially thin , optically thick accretion disc @xcite , we obtain an accretion rate of @xmath1581.4@xmath2810@xmath159 m@xmath13yr@xmath1 , which is about three orders of magnitude smaller than the mass outflow rate , a ratio compared with those found in our previous studies .
we have mapped the gas flux distribution , excitation and kinematics from the inner @xmath2450pc radius of the seyfert1 galaxy mrk766 using near - ir j - and k - band integral - field spectroscopy at a spatial resolution of @xmath260pc ( 020 ) .
the main conclusions of this work are : * the emission - line flux distributions of molecular hydrogen h@xmath10 and low - ionization gas are extended to at least @xmath2300pc from the nucleus ; * the h@xmath10 line emission is most extended along pa=70@xmath112 , which is close to the position angle of the line of nodes of the gas kinematics ; * the [ feii ] emission is most extended approximately along the perpendicular direction to the line of nodes of the gas kinematics ; * the coronal line [ six ] emission is resolved and extends up to @xmath2150pc from the nucleus ; * the emission - line ratios [ feii]/@xmath7 and @xmath32/br@xmath9 show a mixture of starburst and seyfert type excitation ; the seyfert values dominates at the nucleus , to the north - west and in an arc - shaped region between 02 and 06 to the south - east where a radio jet has been observed , while starburst values are present at the nucleus and other regions ; * the enhancement of the [ feii]/[pii ] line ratio at the location of the radio jet , as well as the corresponding increase in the [ fe ii ] flux and velocity dispersion support a contribution from shocks to the gas excitation in the arc - shaped region to the south - east ; in the remaining regions , the favoured excitation mechanism is uv radiation from young stars ; * the @xmath16 gas kinematics is dominated by rotation in a compact disc with a velocity amplitude of 140 km s@xmath1 and low velocity dispersion ( 40 - 60 km s@xmath1 , consistent with orbital motion in the plane of the galaxy ) ; * the kinematics of the ionized gas is also dominated by rotation , but channel maps in [ fe ii ] show in addition an outflowing component to the south - east , with an axis lying close to the plane of the sky reaching velocities of @xmath27 300 km s@xmath1 , probably associated with the radio jet . * the mass outflow rate in ionized gas is estimated to be @xmath2 10.7 m@xmath80 yr@xmath1 and the power of the outflow estimated to be @xmath160 ; * the mass of ionized gas is @xmath161 while the mass of the hot molecular gas is @xmath162 and the estimated cold molecular gas mass is m@xmath90 @xmath2 9.8@xmath2810@xmath91 .
+ the distinct flux distributions and kinematics of the h@xmath10 and [ feii ] emitting gas , with the first more restricted to the plane of the galaxy and in compact rotation and the second related with the radio jet and in outflow are common characteristics of 8 seyfert galaxies ( eso428-g14 , ngc4051 , ngc7582 , ngc4151 , mrk1066 , mrk1157 , mrk79 and mrk766 ) we have studied so far using similar integral - field observations and 2 others ( circinus and ngc2110 ) using long - slit observations .
these results again suggest as those found in previous studies that the h@xmath10 emission is tracer of the agn feeding , while the [ feii ] is a tracer of its feedback .
this work is based on observations obtained at the gemini observatory , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under a cooperative agreement with the nsf on behalf of the gemini partnership : the national science foundation ( united states ) , the science and technology facilities council ( united kingdom ) , the national research council ( canada ) , conicyt ( chile ) , the australian research council ( australia ) , ministrio da cincia e tecnologia ( brazil ) and south - east cyt ( argentina ) .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
we acknowledge the usage of the hyperleda database ( http://leda.univ-lyon1.fr ) . this work has been partially supported by the brazilian institutions cnpq , capes and fapergs .
barbosa f. k. b. , storchi - bergmann t. , cid fernandes r. , winge c. , schmitt h. , 2006 , mnras , 371 , 170 .
bentz m. c. , walsh j. l. , barth a. j. , baliber n. , bennert v. n. , canalizo g. , filippenko a. v. , ganeshalingam m. , gates e. l. , greene j. e. , hidas m. g. , hiner k. d. , lee n. , li w. , malkan m. a. , minezaki t. , sakata y. , serduke f. j. d. , silverman j. m. , steele t. n. , stern d. , street r. a. , thornton c. e. , treu t. , wang x. , woo j. h. , yoshii y. , 2009 , apj , 705 , 199b .
black j. h. , van dishoeck e. f. , 1987 , apj , 322 , 412 .
boller , t. , keil , r. , trmper , j. , obrien , p. t. , reeves , j. & page , m. 2001 , a&a , 365 , 146 .
cardelli , j. a. , clayton , g. c. & mathis , j. s. , 1989 , apj , 345 , 245 .
crenshaw , d. m. , & kraemer , s. b. 2007 , apj , 659,250 .
crenshaw , d. m. , kraemer , s. b. , schmitt h. r. , kaastra , j. s. , arav , n. , gabel , j. r. & korista , k. t. 2009 , apj , 698 , 281 .
crenshaw , d. m. , kraemer , s. b. , schmitt , h. r. , jaff , y. l. , deo , r. p. , collins , n. r. & fischer , t. c. 2010a , apj , 139 , 871 .
crenshaw , d. m. , schmitt , h. r. , kraemer , s. b. , mushotsky , r. f. & dunn , j. p. 2010b
, apj , 708 , 419 .
dale d. a. , sheth k. , helou g. , regan m. w. , httemeister s. , 2005 , aj , 129 , 2197d .
davies r. i. i. , sternberg a. , lehnert m. d. , tacconi - garman l. e. , 2005 , apj , 633 , 105 davies r. i. , maciejewski w. , hicks e. k. s. , tacconi l. j. , genzel r. , engel h. , apj , 702 , 114d .
dors o. l. jr . ,
riffel , r. a. , cardaci m. v. , hgele g. f. , krabbe a. c. , prez - montero , e.,rodrigues , i. , 2012 , mnras , 252 , 260 .
fathi k. , storchi - bergmann t. , riffel r. a. , winge c. , axon d. j. , robinson a. , capetti a. , marconi a. , 2006 , apj , 641 , l25 ferruit , p. , wilson , a. s. , & mulchaey , j. 2000 , apjs , 128 , 139 .
fischer , t. c. , crenshaw , d.m . ,
kraemer , s. b. , schmitt , h. r. & trippe , m. l. 2010 , aj , 140 , 577 .
fischer , t. c. , crenshaw , d.m . ,
kraemer , s. b. , schmitt , h. r. , mushotsky , r. f. & ward , m. j. 1993 , apj , 727 , 71 .
frank j. , king a. r. , raine d. j. , 2002 , accretion power in astrophysics , 3rd edn .
cambridge univ . press , cambridge .
forbes d. a. , ward m. j. , 1993 , apj , 416 , 150 .
gonzlez delgado r. m. , & prez e. , 1996 , mnras , 278 , 737 .
guillard p. , boulanger f. , cluver m. e. , appleton p. n. , pineau des forts g. , ogle p. , 2010 ,
a&a , 518 , 59 .
holt j. , tadhunter c. , morganti r. , bellamy m. , gonzlez delgado r. m.,tzioumis a. , inskip k. j. , 2006 , mnras , 370 , 1633 .
hollenbach d. , mckee c. f. , 1989 , apj , 342 , 306 .
hunt l. k. , malkan m. a. , rush b. , bicay m. d. , nelson b. o. , stanga r. m. , webb w. , 1999 , apjs , 125 , 349 .
kukula m. j. , pedlar a.,baum s. a. , odea c. p. , 1995 ,
mnras , 276 , 1262 .
larkin j. e. , armus l. , knop r. a. , soifer b. t. , matthews k. , 1998 , apjs , 114 , 59 .
malkan m. a. , gorjian v. , tam r. , 1998 , apjs , 117 , 25 .
maloney p. r. , hollenbach d. j. , tielens a. g. g. m. , 1996 , apj , 466 , 561 .
mazzalay x. , rodrguez - ardila a. , komossa s. , 2010 , mnras , 405 , 1315 .
mazzalay x. et al . , 2013 ,
mnras , 428 , 2389 .
mcgregor p. j. et al . , 2003,proc .
spie , 4841 , 1581 .
morganti r. , tadhunter c. n. , oosterloo t. a. , 2005 , a&a , l9 , l13 .
mller - snchez f. , davies r. i. , eisenhauer f. , tacconi l. j. , genzel r. , sternberg a. , 2006 , a&a , 454 , 492 .
mller - snchez f. , prieto m. a. , hicks e. k. s. , vives - arias h. , davies r. i. , malkan m. , tacconi l. j. , genzel r. , 2011 , apj . , 739 , 69 .
mller snchez f. , davies r. i. , genzel r. , tacconi l. j. , eisenhauer f. , hicks e. k. s. , friedrich s. , sternberg a. , 2009 , apj , 691 , 749 .
mundell c. g. , shone d. l. , 1999 , mnras , 304 , 475 .
oliva e. et al . , 2001 , a&a , 369 , l5 .
riffel r. , rodrguez - ardila a. , pastoriza m. g. , 2006b , a&a , 457 , 61 .
riffel r. , rodrguez - ardila a. , aleman i. , brotherton m. s. , pastoriza m. g. , bonatto c. j. & dors o. l. 2013a , mnras , 430 , 2017 .
riffel r. a. , 2010 , ap&ss , 327 , 239 .
riffel r. a. , sorchi - bergmann t. , winge c. , barbosa f. k. b. , 2006a , mnras , 373 , 2 .
riffel r. a. , storchi - bergmann t. , winge c. , mcgregor p. j. , beck t. , schmitt h. , 2008 , mnras , 385 , 1129 .
riffel r. a. , storchi - bergmann t. , dors o. l. , winge c. , 2009 , mnras , 393 , 783 .
riffel r. a. , storchi - bergmann t. , 2010 , mnras , 411 , 469 . riffel r. a. , storchi - bergmann t. , nagar n. m. , 2010 , mnras , 404 , 166 .
riffel r. , riffel r. a. , ferrari f. , storchi - bergmann t. , 2011 , mnras , 416 , 493 .
riffel r. a. et al . , 2013b , mnras , 429 , 2587 .
riffel r. a. , storchi - bergmann t. , winge , c. 2013 , mnras , 430 , 2249 .
rodrguez - ardila a. , pastoriza m. g. , viegas s. , sigut t. a. a. , pradhan a. k. , 2004 , a&a , 425 , 457 .
rodrguez - ardila a. , contini m. , viegas s. m. , 2005 , mnras , 357 , 220 .
rodrguez - ardila a. , prieto m. a. , viegas s. , gruenwald r. , 2006 , apj , 653 , 1098 .
rodruez - ardila a. , riffel r. , pastoriza m. g. , 2005 , mnras , 364 , 1041 .
riffel r. , rodrguez - ardila a. , pastoriza m. g. , 2006b , a&a , 457 , 61 .
scoville , n. z. , hall , d. n. b. , kleinmann , s. g. , & ridgway , s. t. 1982 , 253 , 136 .. schmitt h. r. , kinney a. l. , 1996 , apj , 463 , 498 .
schnorr mller , a. , storchi - bergmann , t. , riffel , r. a. , ferrari , f. , steiner , j. e. , axon , d. j. , robinson , a. 2011 , mnras , 413 , 149 simpson c. , forbes d. a. , baker a. c. , ward m. j. , 1996 , mnras , 283 , 777 .
storchi - bergmann t. , winge c. , ward m. , wilson a. s. , 1999 , mnras , 304 , 35 . storchi - bergmann t. , dors o. , jr , riffel r. a. , fathi k. , axon d. j. , robinson a. , 2007 , apj , 670 , 25 .
storchi - bergmann t. , mcgregor p. , riffel r. , rogemar a. , simes lopes r. , beck t. , dopita m. , 2009 , mnras , 394 , 1148 .
storchi - bergmann t. , simes lopes r. , mcgregor p. riffel , rogemar a. , beck t. , martini p. , 2010
, mnras , 402 , 819 .
veilleux s. , cecil g. , bland - hawthorn j. , 2005 , ara&a , 43 , 769 .
veilleux s. a. , goodrich r. w. , hill g. j. , 1997 , apj , 477 , 631 .
wilson a. s. , braatz j. a. , heckman t. m. , krolic j. h. , miley g. k. , 1993 , apj , 419 , l61 . | we have mapped the emission - line flux distributions and ratios as well as the gaseous kinematics of the inner 450 pc radius of the seyfert 1 galaxy mrk766 using integral field near - ir j- and k@xmath0-band spectra obtained with the gemini nifs at a spatial resolution of 60 pc and velocity resolution of 40 kms@xmath1 .
emission - line flux distributions in ionized and molecular gas extend up to @xmath2 300 pc from the nucleus .
coronal [ six]@xmath3 m line emission is resolved , being extended up to 150 pc from the nucleus . at the highest flux levels ,
the [ feii]@xmath41.257@xmath5 m line emission is most extended to the south - east , where a radio jet has been observed.the emission - line ratios [ feii]@xmath6m/@xmath7 and @xmath8m / br@xmath9 show a mixture of starburst and seyfert excitation ; the seyfert excitation dominates at the nucleus , to the north - west and in an arc - shaped region between 02 and 06 to the south - east at the location of the radio jet . a contribution from shocks at this location
is supported by enhanced [ feii]/[pii ] line ratios and increased [ feii ] velocity dispersion .
the gas velocity field is dominated by rotation that is more compact for h@xmath10 than for pa@xmath11 , indicating that the molecular gas has a colder kinematics and is located in the galaxy plane .
there is about 10@xmath12 m@xmath13 of hot h@xmath10 , implying @xmath2 10@xmath14 m@xmath13 of cold molecular gas . at the location of the radio jet
, we observe an increase in the [ feii ] velocity dispersion ( 150 km s@xmath1 ) , as well as both blueshift and redshifts in the channel maps , supporting the presence of an outflow there .
the ionized gas mass outflow rate is estimated to be @xmath2 10 m@xmath13 yr@xmath1 , and the power of the outflow @xmath2 0.08 l@xmath15 .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : individual ( mrk766 ) galaxies : active galaxies : seyfert galaxies : nuclei galaxies : kinematics and dynamics |
understanding coherent atom - light interactions in multi - level atomic media continues to be the focus of much attention , with an increasing variety of applications .
phenomena such as electromagnetically induced transparency ( eit ) @xcite , coherent population trapping ( cpt ) @xcite , and four - wave mixing ( fwm ) have been instrumental in the development of atomic clocks @xcite , magnetometers @xcite , sub- and super - luminal propagation of light @xcite , quantum memories @xcite , photonic phase gates @xcite , single - photon sources @xcite , and squeezed states of light @xcite .
quantitative modeling for thermal ensembles remains difficult due to the complex atomic energy - level structure .
in contrast , there has been much recent progress in quantitative modeling of linear systems both in terms of fundamental physics and applications @xcite . a recent experiment @xcite demonstrated that applying a large magnetic field can greatly simplify spectroscopic measurements , allowing the isolation of pure two - level systems even in hot atomic vapors where the doppler broadening is significantly larger than the natural linewidth . here
we show this can be extended to two - photon excitation which , in a similar way , isolates pure three - level systems and thereby allows accurate modeling of eit spectra . as a demonstration we use this method to make the first direct measurement of the @xmath0 matrix element in @xmath1rb .
( a ) schematic of the experimental apparatus .
pbs - polarizing beam splitter ; @xmath3 - quarter waveplate ; l - lens with 200 mm focal length ; exp .
cell - 2 mm rubidium vapor cell ; pd - high gain photodetector .
( b ) axial magnetic field profile ( red ) of the permanent ring - magnets ( grey blocks ) .
the maximum field strength is 0.6 t and the maximum variation over the region occupied by the vapor cell ( shown in blue ) is less than 1 mt . ] matrix elements for the alkali - metal atom @xmath4-lines are known to a very high precision by measuring fluorescence decay lifetimes @xcite .
extending this technique to transitions between excited states is generally very difficult owing to the many possible decay channels . in most cases
these matrix elements can be inferred by combining experimentally measured lifetimes with theoretically predicted branching ratios . however , in the case of @xmath4 states , properties such as lifetimes and branching ratios are more difficult to calculate accurately @xcite .
direct experimental measurements of these matrix elements are therefore needed to support theoretical models . in this article
we study eit in the hyperfine paschen - back ( hpb ) regime , allowing us to isolate a pure three - level system in a hot atomic vapor of @xmath1rb .
previous work on eit in large magnetic fields focused on @xmath5-eit @xcite and cpt @xcite and did not include quantitative analysis of the spectra .
we extend this work by investigating a ladder system , which is of interest in for example , rydberg eit @xcite and diamond four - wave mixing @xcite . following the method of @xcite we conduct quantitative analysis of the eit spectra to determine rabi frequencies and extract the dipole matrix element .
we find excellent agreement with an analytic three - level model for the spectra @xcite giving confidence in the reported matrix element .
a schematic diagram of the experimental apparatus is shown in fig . [
fig : setup ] .
we use a 2 mm long vapor cell , containing isotopically enriched @xmath1rb ( @xmath62% @xmath7rb ) , which is heated to 70 @xmath8c to provide suitable optical depth on resonance .
the cell also contains a buffer gas which leads to a lorentzian line broadening of @xmath97 mhz on the 5s@xmath105p transitions and @xmath920 mhz on the 5p@xmath105d transitions @xcite . to generate the strong magnetic field needed to study the hpb regime we use a pair of permanent magnets separated by 15 mm . a cross sectional view is shown in fig .
[ fig : setup](b ) along with the axial magnetic field profile .
the field strength at the center of the magnets is 0.6 t and has a variation of less than 1 mt over the length of the vapor cell ( blue line in fig .
[ fig : setup ] ) .
we measure the transmission of a weak @xcite ( 20 nw ) probe laser at 780 nm as its frequency is scanned @xmath925 ghz around the rubidium @xmath11 ( @xmath12 ) transition . a second ecdl at 776 nm provides a strong control field resonant with the @xmath13 transition which counter - propagates with the first .
the beams are focused through the cell to @xmath14 radii of @xmath15 m for the probe beam and @xmath16 m for the control beam .
the beam waists are chosen as a compromise between maximizing beam intensity , minimizing beam diffraction across the cell and ensuring that the probed atoms observe a uniform control - beam electric field profile .
the polarizations are set using @xmath3 waveplates such that they drive @xmath17 ( @xmath18 ) transitions .
the temperature and magnetic field strength are verified by quantitatively fitting the probe transmission spectra with the control beam blocked @xcite .
an example transmission spectrum is shown in fig . [
fig : brdiagram](a ) .
the spectroscopic features can be mapped on to individual @xmath19 transitions , as we show in fig .
[ fig : brdiagram](b ) . to understand the probe transmission spectrum we first consider the effect of the strong magnetic field on the energy levels of the atoms .
the magnetic field splits the energy levels according to their magnetic spin - orbit quantum numbers ( @xmath20 ) , with the change in energy @xmath21
@xcite , where @xmath22 is the bohr magneton and @xmath23 is the ( axial ) magnetic field strength . for @xmath1rb ( @xmath24 ) in a 0.6 t magnetic field
the zeeman shift is much larger than the hyperfine interaction energy .
this leads to a decoupling of the spin - orbit and nuclear spin angular momenta which defines the hyperfine paschen - back regime @xcite . in the @xmath25 ground state
the hyperfine structure is split into two groups of states with magnetic spin - orbit quantum numbers @xmath26 , each of which contain @xmath27 states with @xmath28 that are split by the hyperfine interaction energy . in the excited states @xmath29 ,
the spin - orbit angular momentum , is larger so that both the number of states and the splitting of the stretched states increase .
the hyperfine interaction energy is largest in the ground state where it is also larger than the doppler width .
coupled with the transition selection rule @xmath30 this means that the probe field can address a single @xmath31 component of the @xmath25 to @xmath32 transition . at 0.6 t
the interaction of the ground state with the field is not large enough to completely decouple the spin - orbit and nuclear spin angular momenta . on the right hand side of fig .
[ fig : brdiagram ] we write the @xmath25 eigenstates in the uncoupled basis , @xmath33 , which show clearly ( in blue ) the small fraction of residual hyperfine mixing .
this small mixed fraction gives rise to the three weak transitions labeled 9 - 11 on fig .
[ fig : brdiagram](b ) . these weak transitions and the dependence of their line strengths on magnetic field
have been investigated in detail in @xcite . in our experiment
the control field is resonant with the @xmath34 transition .
this leads to doppler - free eit resonances on each of the lines labeled 1 - 4 and 9 - 11 as well as some narrow off - resonant two - photon absorption lines associated with probe absorption resonances labeled 5 - 8 . for clarity one of these two - photon absorption resonances
is indicated by an additional arrow labeled 8a .
crucially , all these two - photon resonances involve only 3 atomic states ; this is in contrast to the zero - field case when it is typically necessary to include large numbers of degenerate states to correctly model the response of the medium @xcite .
we now focus on a single absorption line and show , in fig .
[ fig : single - fit ] , that we are able to accurately predict the observed eit line shapes with a simple three - level model .
the electric susceptibility of a medium containing three level ladder - type atoms ( with axial velocity component @xmath35 ) exposed to a strong control field and a weak probe field is given by the formula @xcite , @xmath36 where @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 is the dipole matrix element of the probe transition , @xmath40 is the vacuum permittivity , @xmath41 are the decay rates of the coherence on the probe and control transitions , @xmath42 are the probe and control detunings , @xmath43 are the probe and control wavenumbers , @xmath44 is the control transition rabi frequency and @xmath45 is the number density of @xmath1rb atoms . the absorption coefficient is then given by the integral of the imaginary component of the susceptibility over the maxwell - boltzmann distribution of atomic velocities @xmath46 , where @xmath47 is the most probable speed , @xmath48 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath49 is the vapor temperature , and @xmath50 is the atomic mass .
the transmission of the weak probe field for a medium of length @xmath51 is given by @xmath52n(v)~dv\right).\ ] ] figure [ fig : single - fit ] shows experimental transmission spectra as well as a least - squares fit to the above model .
experimental transmission spectrum ( blue ) showing a purely three - level eit resonance in a hot @xmath1rb vapor .
the red line is a least - squares fit to the data using a three - level eit model .
the fit results in a measurement of the control - beam rabi frequency @xmath53 mhz where the uncertainty is from the statistical error of the fit .
the residual ( r ) shows the excellent agreement between the model and data , with the small amount of structure near line center being explained by electromagnetically induced absorption ( see main text ) . ]
it is clear that the model is in excellent agreement with the data .
however , there is some small but noticeable structure near to line center which is consistent with a small amount of electromagnetically induced absorption @xcite caused by the back - reflected control light in the cell ( see appendix [ eia ] ) .
we point out that such good agreement is not obtained for the case of zero magnetic field where multiple overlapping resonances lead to a more complex line shape , the modeling of which is non - trivial .
figure [ fig : detuning ] shows experimental spectra and fits for three different control detunings , @xmath54 mhz .
the transition from resonant eit to off - resonant two - photon absorption is clearly displayed across this range providing an excellent test for the model .
the fits are to the three level eit model [ eq . ( [ equation : eit ] ) ] and all fit parameters , except for control detuning , are constrained to be equal for all data sets .
the resulting fits are all excellent as shown by the structureless residuals @xcite .
experimental transmission spectra ( blue ) and numerical fits ( red ) for three control - beam detunings .
the fit parameters except for control detuning are constrained to be equal in all three data sets .
the extracted control - beam detunings are @xmath55 mhz .
the residuals ( r ) show the excellent agreement between the model and data . ]
based on the excellent agreement between experiment and theory , we now extract the control rabi frequency from the numerical fitting , for a range of control - beam powers and detunings , allowing us to measure the dipole matrix element @xmath56 . at each power rabi frequencies
are extracted for 15 control - beam detunings ( between @xmath57 and @xmath58 mhz ) and are averaged to give the data points shown in fig .
[ fig : rabi ] ; the error bars shown are the standard error on the mean . extracted values of the control rabi frequency ( @xmath59 ) for increasing control - beam power ( @xmath60 ) .
the red line is a least - squares fit to the function @xmath61 , with @xmath62 mhz@xmath63 .
the residuals ( r ) are shown below and the fit has a reduced chi - squared of 0.5 .
the inset shows the data on a logarithmic scale . ]
since the rabi frequency is proportional to the local electric field amplitude , we expect to observe a square root dependence on control - beam power . in fig .
[ fig : rabi ] the red line is the result of a least - squares fit to the experimental data using the function @xmath61 , from which it is determined @xmath62 mhz@xmath63 .
the agreement between model and experimental data is excellent , with structureless residuals and reduced chi squared @xmath64 @xcite . in the following section we provide details of how @xmath65 is converted into the dipole matrix element . to calculate the dipole moment
we must determine the control - beam electric field in the vicinity of the atoms .
since the control - beam intensity changes significantly over the extent of the probe beam , we use a weighted average of the control - beam electric field profile ( @xmath66 ) weighted by the probe - beam intensity profile ( @xmath67 ) , i.e. @xmath68 we then determine the dipole moment of the driven transition ( between ground and excited states @xmath69 and @xmath70 ) through the equation : @xmath71 where the + 1 refers to the fact that the transition is a @xmath17 transition in which the final magnetic spin - orbit angular momentum @xmath72 . in a magnetic field of 0.60 t the states resonantly coupled by the control field
can be decomposed in the @xmath73 basis as @xmath74 therefore , @xmath75 we now calculate the reduced matrix element using @xcite @xmath76 which is in excellent agreement with the theoretically calculated value of @xmath77 @xcite .
further , we may determine the fully reduced dipole matrix element using @xcite @xmath78 .[tab : errors ] error budget of the @xmath56 dipole moment measurement .
the second column shows the corrections we have made to account for the measured polarization impurity of the control field and for the measured reflectivity of the vapor cell windows . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] in all cases the uncertainties are estimated by numerically modeling the modified line shapes and then performing a least - squares fit to the three - level eit model @xcite .
the following subsections provide details of these systematic changes to the eit line shape .
the three - level eit line shape @xcite implicitly assumes that every atom within the probe field experiences the same control - beam electric field . in practice
this can be achieved by using specially engineered diffractive optics @xcite to create top - hat shaped beams of light . for simplicity
we take the alternate approach of expanding the control beam to approximately double the size of the probe beam .
this approach leads to a lower peak rabi frequency but has the advantage that the beam profile does not change significantly on propagation through the medium .
we estimate that making the assumption of constant control - beam intensity for our beams leads to a 0.4% overestimate of the matrix element .
the vapor cell windows are uncoated and have a reflectivity of approximately 4% at each surface .
the reflected light from the control beam overlaps with the interaction region and leads to weak electromagnetically induced absorption ( eia ) resonances .
this effect has been investigated in detail @xcite and its modifying effect on the eit line shape is well understood .
figure [ fig : eia ] shows the expected eia line shape assuming a 4% back reflection overlapping with 15% of the interaction region ( the cell is tilted to minimize this overlap ) . predicted electromagnetically induced absorption ( eia ) line shape for a 4% back reflection of the control beam overlapping with 15% of the interaction region .
the dashed line shows the fit to this line shape using a three - level eit line shape and the residual ( r ) shows the same structure as is found in the experimental data . ]
the three - level eit formula [ eq .
( [ equation : eit ] ) ] is fitted to the modified line shape and the residual shows the same structure that is found in the experimental data . although the effect on the line shape is quite noticeable , the effect on the extracted rabi frequency is small ( typically @xmath79% change ) and the impact on the measurement of the matrix element is even smaller due to the large range of control - beam powers used .
if the vapor cell is not positioned exactly at the center of the magnetic field profile there will be a significant magnetic field gradient across the cell leading to an effective broadening of the lines . the effect on the line shape
can be quite large so care is taken to ensure the cell is positioned correctly .
the uncertainty in the positioning of the cell is @xmath80 mm which leads to a 0.1% overestimate of the matrix element . in our experiment
the probe - beam rabi frequency is 0.5 mhz which is significantly smaller than the linewidth of 6 mhz . as such there is very little power broadening of the spectral lines and the weak probe assumption @xcite is very good .
we estimate that this approximation leads to a 0.08% underestimate of the matrix element .
the experimental spectra are frequency calibrated using an optical cavity with a free spectral range of 375 mhz and an atomic reference based on hyperfine pumping spectroscopy @xcite .
the uncertainty in the calibration is approximately 0.1% which directly correlates with the uncertainty in the dipole matrix element .
the presence of other nearby absorptive resonances can modify the eit line shape .
specifically , the absorption in the wings of the line is increased relative to the line - center value .
since the nearest absorptive resonances are @xmath81 ghz away , this effect is small and leads to a 0.2% underestimate of the matrix element .
39ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1063/1.881806 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.77.633 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.3.000218 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.94.050801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.94.173002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.82.033807 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/17561 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.173601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.84.4232 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.71.023803 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.033601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.123602 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.100.233601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 4075/45/21/215005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.37.003405 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 4075/47/7/075005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.40.002000 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.cpc.2014.11.023 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 4075/41/15/155004 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0031 - 8949/1996/t65/007 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.93.022503 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.69.022509 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1134/s0021364012170134 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/josab.14.002221 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.113003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.85.063821 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.79.033814 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/13/9/093012 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.51.576 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.82.045806 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1119/1.3013197 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ , ed .
( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1088/1612 - 2011/11/5/055701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 4075/34/22/107 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.40.004289 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) http://arxiv.org/abs/1510.07708 [ `` , '' ] link:\doibase 10.1119/1.1652039 [ * * , ( ) ] | applying large magnetic fields to gain access to the hyperfine paschen - back regime can isolate three - level systems in a hot alkali metal vapors , thereby simplifying usually complex atom - light interactions .
we use this method to make the first direct measurement of the @xmath0 matrix element in @xmath1rb . an analytic model with only three levels
accurately models the experimental electromagnetically induced transparency spectra and extracted rabi frequencies are used to determine the dipole matrix element .
we measure @xmath2 which is in excellent agreement with the theoretical calculations of safronova , williams , and clark [ phys .
rev .
a * 69 * , 022509 ( 2004 ) ] . |
since its proposal , the random boolean network model [ 1 ] has successfully described in a qualitative way several important aspects of gene regulation and cell differentiation processes ( for references see [ 2 ] ) .
the model is constructed by assigning to each of the genes its regulatory inputs from among the large number of genes present in the network .
the model consists of @xmath0 binary variables , corresponding to the two states of gene expression ( off and on ) . in this binary setting , each gene is assigned a logical function on its inputs showing its next activity . while clearly an idealization , much has been learned from this class of large boolean networks , and major features generalize to a class of piecewise linear differential equations [ 3 - 4 ] and a family of polynomial maps [ 5 ] .
the research on complex boolean networks , shows that networks behave in three regimes : ordered , critical and chaotic [ 6 ] .
it is a very attractive hypothesis that cell types have evolved by natural selection to lie in the ordered regime , close to the critical phase transition , where the most complex coordinated behaviors can occur [ 7 - 8 ] . in this deterministic setting , it is almost an inevitable hypothesis that the distinct cell types of an organism correspond to the distinct attractors of the network .
this hypothesis needs to be confirmed by experimental tests .
cell differentiation consists in response to a perturbation or signal that places the network in a different basin of attraction from which it flows to a new attractor .
obviously , real genetic networks are not boolean nets . in real nets
, one has to take into account the molecular dynamics by using stochastic differential equation models .
the resulted equations can be solved using monte - carlo methods . here
the favored approach is the gillespie algorithm [ 9 ] , which can be used to model discrete molecular events of transcription , translation and gene control in complex reaction networks .
boolean networks already impose some formidable computational problems .
introducing stochastic models render even smaller networks computationally intractable because the number of reactions one has to consider grows exponentially fast with the number of genes in the network . here , we propose a simplified mean - field model of the genetic regulatory network , where the main idea is to replace all regulatory interactions to any one gene with an average or effective interaction , which takes into account the repression and activation mechanisms .
our model attempts to bridge the gap between random boolean networks and more realistic stochastic modeling of regulatory networks . in this model ,
the regulatory interactions are described by differential equations corresponding to the chemical reactions considered in the genetic network .
the same set of chemical reactions can , for example , be used in a stochastic simulation of the network . from this point of view
, the proposed model gives a mean - field description of the more accurate stochastic approach . in the mean - field deterministic description ,
the gene - expression state at a given time and the regulatory interactions among them unambiguously determine the gene - expression state at the next time . in a stochastic system ,
on the other hand , a given gene - expression state can generate more than one successive gene - expression states , and therefore , different cells of the same population may follow a different gene - expression path . as a result of these considerations ,
the stochastic model describe the kinetics of gene regulation more accurately than a deterministic model .
however , a deterministic mean - field model can be transformed in a stochastic model by incorporating noise .
this approach results in a stochastic differential equation or langevin equation .
it is well known that the langevin equation is asymptotically equivalent ( under certain conditions ) to the chemical master equation [ 10 ] .
therefore , the proposed mean - field model is still relevant for the description of gene regulation and cell differentiation processes . we show that depending on the set of regulatory parameters , the model exhibits differing behaviors corresponding to ordered and chaotic dynamics .
this result gives quantitative support to the earlier qualitative results obtained for random boolean networks .
also , we show that the system acquires stability by increasing the number of interactions .
this conclusion provides a possible explanation of how diversity and stability are created in a biological system , giving rise to a great variety of stable living organisms .
for the beginning , let us analyze the gene expression process [ 11 - 14 ] . in a genetic regulatory network , genes can be turned on or off by the binding of proteins to regulatory sites on the dna [ 1 ] .
the proteins are known as transcription factors , while the dna binding sites are known as promoters .
transcription factors can regulate the production of other transcription factors , or they can regulate their own production .
the simplest model of gene expression involves only two steps in which the genetic information is first transcribed into messenger rna ( @xmath1 ) and then translated into proteins ( @xmath2 ) by ribosomes ( @xmath3 ) .
the transcription process can be described by a sequence of reactions , in which the rna polymerase ( @xmath4 ) binds to the gene promoter ( @xmath5 ) leading to transcription of a complete @xmath6 molecule : @xmath7 here , @xmath8 corresponds to the complex formed in the intermediate reaction @xmath9 , with constant rate @xmath10 .
since the waiting times are independent statistical quantities , the waiting time for the whole sequence of intermediate complex formation is the sum of the waiting times for the individual steps .
also , we should note that the central limit theorem [ 10 ] indicates that the lumped reaction of the open complex formation will tend to have a gaussian distribution of waiting times , converging to a @xmath11 function for a very large number of intermediate steps .
thus , in terms of reaction rates ( which have units of inverse time ) we have @xmath12 . from the above considerations
, it follows that the whole sequence of reactions can be approximated by the following reaction : @xmath13 where @xmath14 let us now analyze the translation process , in which the information initially transcribed into @xmath1 is now translated into proteins @xmath2 . to describe this we consider the following additional reactions : @xmath15
@xmath16 the first reaction idealizes the multistep translation process , under the further idealization that a ribosome ( @xmath3 ) binds the @xmath1 and a protein @xmath2 is produced .
the second reaction captures the degradation of @xmath1 .
the model described here is intentionally as simple as possible .
we believe that such an approach is as important as detailed biological modeling in elucidating the basic physics behind genetic regulatory networks .
the main idea of the model is to replace all regulatory interactions to any one gene with an average or effective interaction which takes into account the repression and activation mechanisms .
let us now consider a system formed from @xmath0 genes . in this system protein
multimers ( which are the transcription factors ) are responsible for gene regulation ( activation and repression ) and are allowed to bind to the promoter site . here ,
an important problem is to specify which reactions are allowed to take place in the system .
we consider that the basic level of expression ( transcrition and translation ) , the @xmath1 and protein degradation reactions always exist , and they represent the minimum set of reactions describing the system .
the existence of the other ( activation , repression and multimerization ) reactions is specified by an associated set of binary coefficients ( switches ) @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 .
if the value of such a coefficient is @xmath22 then the reaction exists , if the coefficient is @xmath23 then the reaction does not exist .
the possible chemical reactions up to the dimer interaction case are @xmath24 : - transcription : @xmath25 - @xmath1 degradation @xmath26 - translation : @xmath27 - protein degradation : @xmath28 - protein dimerization : @xmath29 where the coefficients @xmath30 are the selection switches . here , a protein dimer is formed by combining two protein monomers
. - repression : @xmath31 @xmath32 where the selection is done by setting @xmath33 , @xmath34 . in the first reaction ,
a protein monomer binds to the promoter and the effect is an inhibition of the basic level of transcription reaction , which actually leads to a gene repression .
the existence of the second repression reaction is conditioned by the dimerization reaction between proteins . therefore , the real regulatory coefficient for this reaction is @xmath35
. - activation : @xmath36 @xmath37 in order to have an activation , a protein monomer or a dimer must first bind to the promoter and form another complex .
therefore , the existence of an activation reaction is conditioned by the coefficients @xmath33 , @xmath38 and @xmath39
. thus , the activation reactions are in fact regulated by @xmath40 , @xmath41 , where @xmath42 , @xmath43
. we should note that the number of possible reactions is very high .
this number depends on the considered length of possible multimers formed by the transcription factors .
here we have considered only the reactions up to a possible dimer interaction .
however , we will show that these reactions are enough for the purpose of illustrating the interaction mechanism in a more general model , corresponding to higher order multimer interactions .
in a steady state the repression and dimerization reactions are in equilibrium and we have : @xmath44[m_{i } ] & = & \widetilde{k}_{i}^{n}[p_{n}m_{i } ] , \\ k_{ij}^{n}[p_{n}][m_{i}m_{j } ] & = & \widetilde{k}_{ij}^{n}[p_{n}m_{i}m_{j } ] , \nonumber \\ k_{ij}[m_{i}][m_{j } ] & = & \widetilde{k}_{ij}[m_{i}m_{j } ] .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here by @xmath45 $ ] we understand the concentration of @xmath46 .
one can see that each promoter @xmath47 can be in different states corresponding to the transcription factor complex which binds to it : @xmath48 from the above equations one can see that the probabilities associated to these states are in the ratio : @xmath49}{[p_{n } ] } & = & \frac{k_{i}^{n}}{\widetilde{k}_{i}^{n } } [ m_{i}]=a_{i}^{n}x_{i } , \\
\frac{\lbrack p_{n}m_{i}m_{j}]}{[p_{n } ] } & = & \frac{k_{ij}^{n}}{\widetilde{k } _ { ij}^{n}}[m_{i}m_{j}]=\frac{k_{ij}^{n}}{\widetilde{k}_{ij}^{n}}\frac{k_{ij } } { \widetilde{k}_{ij}}x_{i}x_{j } \nonumber \\ & = & ( b_{ij}^{n}+b_{ij}^{n})x_{i}x_{j}=2b_{ij}^{n}x_{i}x_{j}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath50 are the reduced concentrations variables for the transcription factors .
the probability that the promoter @xmath47 is in a free state is given by : @xmath51 where the denominator is the sum over all possible states of the promoter including the free state and the binding states .
consequently , the probabilities that the promoter is in a binding state @xmath52 or @xmath53 are : @xmath54 @xmath55 obviously , from the above equations we have : @xmath56 in a steady state , the rate of @xmath57 transcription should be equal to the rate of @xmath57 degradation and therefore we can write the following mean - field equation : @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the reduced concentration of @xmath57 . here , we have covered all the system construction possibilities by using the binary coefficients @xmath39 , @xmath33 , @xmath42 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 .
thus , the transcription of gene @xmath62 , can be approximated using the following nonlinear differential equation : @xmath63 where @xmath64 , @xmath65 .
also , @xmath66 is a parameter corresponding to the promoter strength ( the ratio between the transcription and the degradation rates ) . also , in a steady state , the rate of translation should be equal to the rate of protein degradation .
therefore , for the gene @xmath62 , we can write the second equation : @xmath67=\widetilde{k}_{ii}^{n}[m_{n}],\ ] ] and consequently the second differential equation : @xmath68 where @xmath69 is a coefficient measuring the delay induced by the translation process .
let us give some simple examples to the above equations .
first , let us consider the case of two genes , where all the monomer interactions are excluded and the interaction is mediated only by dimers ( @xmath70 ) .
we consider that the interaction at the dimer level is performed only by homo - dimers ( @xmath71 . also , the interaction is due only to the repression mechanism ( @xmath72 ) , and the repression is performed only by the other gene s homo - dimers ( @xmath73 ) . with these approximations
we obtain the well known toggle switch model [ 15 ] : @xmath74 now , let us consider the case in which three genes are repressing each other at a dimer level in a circular way : @xmath75 this means that : @xmath76 ; @xmath77 ( @xmath78 ) ; @xmath72 ; @xmath79 ( @xmath78 and @xmath80 ) . with these assumptions we obtain the well known equations of the repressilator [ 16 ] : @xmath81 the analysis of the repressilator model has shown that in order to obtain sustained oscillations we need strong promoters , which is equivalent to a high rate of expression or a low rate of degradation [ 16 ] . from the above considerations we observe that the multimer interactions can be represented using a tensorial expansion .
the coefficients describing the interaction can be condensed in tensors of different ranks , corresponding to the length of considered multimers .
thus , in general for a network with @xmath0 genes we can write the following set of equations @xmath82 : @xmath83 one can see that the numerator of the above fraction contains all the activation interactions , while the denominator contains all the repression interactions .
therefore , this intrinsic ratio , between activation and repression , defines the dynamics of the gene network .
in order to simplify further our description we consider that the transcription and translation processes can be condensed in only one reaction : @xmath84 this means that we are neglecting the delay effects introduced by the translation process , which is equivalent to consider @xmath85 .
therefore the dynamics of the system will be described only by the following simplified equations : @xmath86 let us consider the mean - field equations up to the dimer level .
obviously , these equations contain an extremely large number of unknown parameters .
for example , very few rate constants for the constituent reactions have been measured in cells and one is often ignorant of absolute concentrations of the participating molecular species . meanwhile , the ensemble approach [ 17 ] , which consists in sampling random networks from an ensemble of networks built according to the constraints we know that characterize real genomic systems and then analyzing the typical , or generic , properties of ensemble members , remains one useful approach to making use of the information we are gathering on real systems to understand their large scale dynamical and network connectivity implications .
we would like to emphasize that the mean - field model described here has the advantage that all the parameters correspond only to ratios of reaction constant rates , and therefore it does not require the knowledge of absolute values of these constant rates .
this characteristic of the model gives us the chance to simplify even more the sampling of the parameters .
thus , in the spirit of the ensemble approach let us consider that the coefficients @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath92 are drawn from a gaussian distribution as following : @xmath93 here , @xmath94 is a random variable governed by a gaussian distribution with zero mean and variance equal to one , and @xmath95 . by using this sampling procedure ,
we assume implicitly that the ratios of reaction constant rates are normally distributed around some average values @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 .
also , high values of the parameters controlling the variance ( @xmath101 ) are useful in creating a large spectrum of values around the average values .
for example , because @xmath64 are generated from a gaussian distribution centered at @xmath98 it follows that : @xmath102 or @xmath103 .
this means that for @xmath104 the rate of activation reactions can be higher or lower than the rate corresponding to the basic level of expression . in our simulations
we have used the following parameters : @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 . also , the initial conditions @xmath108 are drawn from an uniform distribution between @xmath23 and @xmath109 .
obviously , one can try a different scenario in which for example all these parameters are drawn from an uniform distribution .
let us now consider the extreme case when all the dimers formed by the transcription factors are missing from the system : @xmath110 because the number of parameters in the system is still very large one can imagine a huge number of numerical experiments .
below we describe a couple of such possible numerical experiments . in the first experiment , the coefficients regulating the monomer interactions
@xmath111 are generated randomly such that : @xmath112 the numerical results have shown that for any values of @xmath113 and @xmath114 the system converges only to steady states . in the second experiment , the values of the coefficients regulating the monomer interactions
@xmath111 are generated such that the sums : @xmath115 follow a power law distribution : @xmath116 where @xmath117 is the riemann zeta function .
recent analysis indicates that a power law distribution of interactions seems to fit better the data observed experimentally for several organisms [ 18 - 20 ] .
such a distribution can be obtained from an uniform distribution using the inverse transformation method : @xmath118^ { \frac{1}{1-\omega } } .\ ] ] here , @xmath119 is an uniform distributed random number on the interval @xmath120 $ ] .
the exponent of the power law distribution is @xmath121 ( where @xmath122 is the pareto distribution shape parameter ) .
the above equation returns a value @xmath123 $ ] , distributed accordingly to a power law with the exponent @xmath124 . in our simulation we have set @xmath125 , @xmath126 and the variable parameter is @xmath124 . the rest of the parameters and the initial states are set as before .
the numerical results have shown that for any values @xmath127 the system converges to steady states .
these numerical results suggest that protein multimerization might be a necessary condition to generate more complex dynamics in the system . by increasing the number of dimers formed by the transcription factors : @xmath128
one can easily see how the complex behavior emerges in the system . depending on the values of the other regulatory parameters , the model exhibits complex oscillatory and chaotic dynamics .
let us now consider the other extreme case when all the dimers formed by the transcription factors are present in the system : @xmath129 the coefficients @xmath111 , @xmath130 , regulating the monomer interactions , are generated randomly as before , with the probabilities @xmath113 and @xmath114 .
the other coefficients are determined as following : @xmath131 the rest of the coefficients and the initial conditions are set as before in the numerical experiment for @xmath132 .
the numerical results , have shown that for any values of @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath133 , @xmath134 the system mostly converges to steady states similar to those obtained for @xmath132 , however oscillatory solutions have also been observed . in the next numerical experiment
we consider that the values of the coefficients regulating the monomer and dimer interactions are generated such that the sums : @xmath135 follows a power law distribution . for @xmath136 and @xmath137
we set @xmath126 , while for @xmath138 and @xmath139 we have @xmath140 .
the rest of the coefficients and the initial conditions are set as before . for small values of @xmath141
the system converges mostly to steady states .
an example of steady state obtained for @xmath142 and @xmath143 is given in fig .
for average values @xmath144 the density of steady states in the solution space decreases , making room for oscillatory solutions . in fig .
1(b ) we give an example of oscillatory solution obtained for @xmath145 . for larger values
@xmath146 one can easily obtain chaotic solutions . in fig .
1(c ) we give an example of chaotic solution obtained for @xmath147 .
the dynamic behavior of solutions was characterized by performing fourier analysis on long trajectories .
the fourier power spectrum is discrete for an oscillatory solution , while in the case of a chaotic solution it shows continuous intervals of frequencies . in fig .
2 we give the typical fourier power spectrum obtained for a single @xmath148 trajectory : ( a ) oscillations ; ( b ) chaos .
the above result suggests that for power law distributed interactions ( up to the dimer level ) , there is a transition between order and chaos when the power law exponent @xmath124 increases . in order to characterize this transition one can try to calculate the largest lyapunov exponent for the dynamical system [ 21 ] . a positive value of the largest lyapunov exponent indicates the chaotic behavior of the system , while a negative value indicates a regular dynamics .
we have performed several calculations for networks with a modest size ( @xmath149 ) just to confirm the chaotic behavior of the solutions .
unfortunately , the computation of the lyapunov exponent is quite intensive and it quickly becomes prohibitive for networks with a very large number of genes , sampled from a huge ensemble of networks ( as described above ) .
therefore , in order to analyze this transition we consider a simplified approach , which focuses on steady state solutions , by calculating the average fluctuations : @xmath150 here , @xmath151 is the length of the trajectory ( the number of time steps , after the transient is eliminated ) and @xmath152 is the time average of @xmath148 . the global quantity @xmath153 measures the fluctuations around the average values @xmath154 .
obviously , @xmath155 can not distinguish between chaotic and oscillatory trajectories , however it provides a simple and efficient discrimination between ordinary steady state solutions ( fig .
1(a ) ) and the oscillatory and chaotic solutions ( fig .
1(b ) , ( c ) ) . for ordinary steady state solutions
@xmath156 , while for oscillatory and chaotic solutions @xmath157 . in fig .
we give the results obtained for @xmath158 by averaging over 100 solutions for @xmath159 $ ] .
the parameter @xmath153 measures the transition between a phase with high density of ordinary steady state solutions and a phase with low density of steady state solutions .
one can see that the transition occurs around @xmath160 .
also , one can see that @xmath161 does not seems to depend on the number of genes in the network @xmath162 , @xmath163 , @xmath164 , @xmath165 , @xmath166 .
therefore , the average number of interactions per gene at the critical point in a large network ( @xmath167 ) can be easily estimated as : @xmath168 obviously , by increasing @xmath124 the number of interactions per gene decreases . for large values of @xmath124
the number of interactions approaches @xmath169 .
these results suggest that the network is more stable for low values of @xmath124 , i.e. when the number of interactions per gene is higher than @xmath170 , and it looses stability when @xmath124 increases , i.e. when the number of interactions is low .
we have observed this phenomenon for various values of the system parameters , which suggests that it is an important characteristic of the system .
for @xmath172 the numerical simulation becomes difficult because of the higher order combinatorial explosion in the definition of tensor coefficients .
the number of coefficients for a tensor with rank @xmath2 grows exponentially fast as @xmath173 , where @xmath0 is the number of genes in the network .
therefore , further simplifications are required . here
, we consider a simplified system of @xmath0 genes which has a high level of complexity , comparable with the general mean - field system of equations .
this simplified system has the advantage that it can make the simulations possible even for very large values of @xmath2 and @xmath0 .
we make a further simplification by assuming that @xmath174 this means that the interaction strength at a given multimer level depends slightly on the corresponding tensor rank . with these assumptions
we obtain the following set of equations ( @xmath175 ) : @xmath176 now let us assume that all the higher order multimer interactions ( corresponding to a tensor rank @xmath177 ) are generated from the first order monomer interactions in the following recursive way : -repression : @xmath178 -activation : @xmath179 for example , the dimer interaction terms are given by : -repression : @xmath180 -activation : @xmath181 thus , we obtain the following simplified system of differential equations @xmath182 : @xmath183 \left ( \frac{a_{n}\sum\limits_{i}\beta _ { i}^{n}x_{i}-1}{c_{n}a_{n}\sum \limits_{i}\gamma _ { i}^{n}\beta _ { i}^{n}x_{i}-1}\right ) -x_{n}.\ ] ] the advantage of this model consists in the fact that at each iteration step , in the algorithm used to solve the system of differential equations , one has to calculate only the first rank interaction tensors , @xmath184 and @xmath185 , even though the expansion is considered up to the maximum rank @xmath2 .
we have performed a numerical experiment in which all the parameters and the initial states are set as before for @xmath186 .
also , the coefficients regulating the monomer interactions @xmath187 , @xmath130 are generated using the probabilities @xmath113 , @xmath114 , as in the first numerical experiment , performed for @xmath132 .
thus , the variable parameters are @xmath113 , @xmath114 and the maximum rank @xmath2 of tensorial expansion ( which corresponds to the maximum length of multimers mediating the interaction among genes ) .
depending on the values of all these parameters , the system exhibits different types of behavior .
however , the most important parameter seems to be @xmath2 . for low values @xmath188
the density of steady states in the solution space is very high and therefore the system converges most of the time to a steady state ( fig .
4 ( a ) ) . by increasing @xmath2 to @xmath189 the density of steady states decreases and
the typical behavior becomes oscillatory ( fig . 4 ( b ) ) .
for larger values of @xmath190 , the dynamics becomes more complex , exhibiting chaotic behavior ( fig .
4 ( c ) ) . the numerical results for
this experiment show that there is a smooth transition between order and chaos as the parameter @xmath2 increases .
this is a consequence of the fact that by increasing @xmath2 one actually increases the cooperativity among the transcription factors and implicitly the nonlinearity of the system .
we have discussed a mean - field model of genetic regulatory networks , in which the regulatory interactions are described by differential equations corresponding to the chemical equations considered in the network .
we have shown that , depending on the set of regulatory parameters , the model exhibits differing behaviors corresponding to ordered and chaotic dynamics .
this result gives some quantitative support to the earlier qualitative results obtained for random boolean networks [ 2 - 6 ] .
however , contrary to boolean networks , by increasing the number of interactions per gene , our model acquires stability .
this is an important issue which we would like to address here and in the future .
we believe that the stability of the system occurs from the intrinsic construction of the activation / repression ratio .
this ratio corresponds to an average interaction , which takes into account all the repression and activation mechanisms acting on any one gene in the network .
also , according to the central limit theorem , the variance of the sums , defining the numerator and denominator of this ratio , decreases by considering more terms ( interactions ) .
these mechanisms create stability in the system by producing a contraction which keeps the solution bounded .
so , by increasing the number of interactions , the system becomes more stable . for specific sets of parameters
the solution is not only bounded but it also corresponds to ordered dynamics ( steady states or oscillations ) . by changing the set of parameters ,
this contraction becomes loose enough that the solution becomes chaotic . in this case
the system becomes ergodic and it is able to explore large regions in the solution space .
an important role in generating oscillatory and chaotic dynamics is played by the length of transcription factor multimers mediating the interaction among genes .
our analysis has shown that protein multimerization is a necessary condition for the discussed mean - field model to generate oscillatory and chaotic dynamics . in summary , we have introduced and provided an initial analysis of a mean - field model for a class of reasonably realistic chemical equations modeling genetic regulatory networks . we presume a critical phase transition occurs as the system goes from order to chaos .
this is important because recent evidence tentatively suggests that yeast cells are critical [ 23 ] .
indeed , it has been a long standing hypothesis that cells are critical or slightly subcritical to withstand noise [ 24 ] .
thus , our results give preliminary support to this hypothesis .
it remains for future work to explore in more detail how networks with diverse topologies but similar kinetics behave .
if it proves true that biological cells are critical or near critical , our model should be of use in exploring the combinations of network topologies , motifs and kinetic rules that can correspond to such critical behavior .
this research was supported by icore under grant no . rt732223 .
m. aldana , s. coopersmith , l. p. kadanoff , _ perspectives and problems in nonlinear science .
springer applied mathematical sciences series .
_ ehud kaplan , jerrold e. marsden , and katepalli r. sreenivasan eds . ,
23 - 89 ( 2003 ) .
example of typical solutions obtained for m=2 : ( a ) steady state ;
( b ) oscillations ; ( c ) chaos . here , @xmath148 is the reduced concentration of protein monomer ( transcription factor ) @xmath62 as a function of time @xmath191 .
the total number of genes in the network is @xmath143.,width=453 ] example of typical solutions obtained for @xmath172 : ( a ) steady states ; ( b ) oscillations ; ( c ) chaos . here , @xmath148 is the reduced concentration of protein monomer ( transcription factor ) @xmath62 as a function of time @xmath191 .
the total number of genes in the network is @xmath143 .
the parameter @xmath2 is the maximum length of multimers mediating the interaction among genes.,width=453 ] | in this paper , we propose a mean - field model which attempts to bridge the gap between random boolean networks and more realistic stochastic modeling of genetic regulatory networks .
the main idea of the model is to replace all regulatory interactions to any one gene with an average or effective interaction , which takes into account the repression and activation mechanisms .
we find that depending on the set of regulatory parameters , the model exhibits rich nonlinear dynamics .
the model also provides quantitative support to the earlier qualitative results obtained for random boolean networks . *
pacs : * 05.45.-a ; 87.16.yc institute for biocomplexity and informatics university of calgary 2500 university drive nw , calgary alberta , t2n 1n4 , canada |
the fu orionis systems are a small but remarkable class of variable young stellar objects ( ysos ) which undergo outbursts in optical light of 5 magnitudes or more @xcite , with a f - g supergiant optical spectra and k - m supergiant near - infrared ( near - ir ) spectra dominated by deep co overtone absorption .
fu orionis objects ( fuors ) have been modelled as a high mass accretion disk around pre - main - sequence stars ( hartmann @xmath7 kenyon 1985 , 1987a , 1987b ) to explain the infrared color excesses and the variations of both the spectral type and rotational line width with wavelength ( hartmann @xmath7 kenyon 1996 ; paper i ) .
@xcite argued that at least some fu orionis outbursts must be repetitive , and @xcite suggested that this could be explained by infall from an envelope to the disk , replenishing the disk mass for further outbursts . the infall picture is also suggested by the presence of scattered light envelopes around fuors , suggesting that they are objects in early stages of star formation @xcite . in the evolution sequence
, fuors may play significant role in transfering a large amount of mass ( @xmath810@xmath9 ) to the central star , which is even higher than the mass accumulated in the t tauri phase @xcite .
however , not all fuors show the large mid - infrared ( mid - ir ) excesses that clearly demand dense infalling envelopes .
in particular , @xcite suggested that fu ori itself had only a depleted or low - density envelope .
@xcite suggested that a pure flared disk model could explain fu ori while an infalling envelope was needed for v1057 cyg , but @xcite proposed that both fu ori and v1057 cyg required flattened envelopes .
finally , taking advantage of irs spectra obtained with the spitzer space telescope , @xcite concluded that the seds of v1057 and v1515 cyg required envelopes and derived crude models for these objects , while fu ori and bbw 76 might be explained with flared disks only .
some recent studies about the silicate features also show fuors can be classified as two categories and some objects are evolved ( fu ori and bbw 76 ) with only disks left @xcite .
the irs spectra provide us with the opportunity to perform a much more detailed sed analysis for fuors . in paper
i , we developed detailed accretion disk models to study the inner disk of fu ori and we derived an inner disk size @xmath0 1 au . in this paper , we re - examine the interpretation of mid - ir excesses , taking advantage of the irs spectra , with more detailed radiative transfer models , to resolve the disk / envelope problem .
we will describe the observational data in 2 . in 3 , the method to calculate the temperature structure of the irradiated surface and the resulting spectrum is described .
model results for three fu orionis objects ( fu ori , bbw 76 , and v1515 cyg ) are presented in 5 .
finally , in 6 we discuss some implications of our results .
because fu orionis objects are significantly variable , it is crucial to minimize differences in the times of observations at differing wavelengths .
we build on the database assembled in paper i for fu ori . for other fu orionis objects
, we also collected optical photometry from @xcite .
these data were obtained in 2004 at the maidanak observatory and all the data collected in this year for the same band were averaged considering fuors are variable objects .
near - ir fluxes are from 2mass point - source catalog ( psc ) .
v1057 cyg was observed in june , 2000 ; v1515 cyg was observed in november , 1998 ; bbw 76 was observed in february 1999 . as mentioned in @xcite , because fu orionis objects are fading slowly , the extrapolation from the 2mass epoch ( @xmath01998 ) to the irs epoch ( @xmath02004 ) is not important ; thus , we adopted the 2mass jhk photometry without any correction .
mid - infrared fluxes are derived from the _ spitzer _ irs spectra observed in 2004 @xcite . the spectral energy distributions ( seds ) need to be corrected for extinction to assess the brightness of the mid - ir excess relative to the central hot disk , which will determine whether or not a flared disk can explain the observations . to get the right extinction correction , we de - reddened the optical and near - ir photometry by a variety of extinction parameters ( a@xmath10 ) .
then we compared these de - reddened observations with the steady disk spectra calculated with our disk model ( paper i ) , in which disk temperatures peak around 6000 k. through this comparison , the extinction parameter which gave the best fit to the model spectrum was chosen for that object . because the disk radial temperature distribution may deviate from the steady disk and boundary layer emission may be present , we estimate the uncertainty of our extinction values as @xmath11 0.5 .
we use both the near - ir and mid - ir interferometry to test our modelling of fu ori .
the near - ir interferometric data are from @xcite , who obtained 287 long - baseline interferometric observations in the h and k bands from 1998 to 2003 , with resolution of au scales at the distance of fu ori . the @xmath12-plane coverage is shown in fig .
1 in their paper and the averaged square visibilities are provided in table 3 of their paper .
the mid - ir interferometric data are from @xcite , who carried measurements from 8 @xmath2 m to 13 @xmath2 m at three baselines ( 44.56 m , 86.25 m , and 56.74 m ) between october 31 and november 4 2004 with the mid - infrared interferometric instrument ( midi ) at eso s very large telescope interferometer ( vlti ) on paranal , chile .
the visibilities are provided in table 5 of their paper .
we follow the method of @xcite to calculate the temperature structure of the outer flaring surface irradiated by the inner hot high @xmath13 disk . in this treatment
we have not considered the outer disk self - heating , which is not important for a moderate flaring disk , but has a non - negligible effect on a highly flared envelope , as discussed further in 5.2 .
we have assumed the flaring surface is very optically thick whether it is the disk surface or the outflow cavity driven into an opaque envelope .
milne s reflection effect is included and lte is assumed .
milne s reflection effect tells us that , without additional heating sources , the incident radiation alters the temperature structure of the low - optical depth layers such that all the energy incident on those layers is radiated back or , in other words , the net fluxes of those layers are zero . in the case of lte , when the source function is determined by local conditions , the transfer equation is a linear equation and solutions can be superposed .
specifically , if @xmath14 is the temperature structure of the standard viscous heating disk with zero incident radiation but net viscous flux @xmath15\ ] ] and @xmath16 is a temperature structure with a given incident radiation but zero net flux , then the temperature structure of the disk with both of a net flux @xmath17 and a given incident radiation is @xmath18 .
we can solve @xmath19 by assuming the incident radiation from the central star / high @xmath13 disk covers a well separated frequency range from the disk emergent radiation ; details can be found in @xcite .
if the incident radiation consists of a parallel beam carrying energy @xmath20(ergs @xmath21 ) , incident at an angle cos@xmath22 to the normal of the disk surface , a fraction @xmath23 of the energy in the beam will be scattered and a fraction @xmath24 of the incident beam will be truly absorbed and remitted .
the temperature structure corresponding to an atmosphere that has @xmath17 net flux and incident radiation of flux @xmath25 is @xmath26 \label{eq : t}\ ] ] where @xmath27 @xmath28 @xmath29 and @xmath30 @xmath31(1-\beta^{2}\mu_{0}^{2})}\ ] ] where @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
@xmath35 and @xmath36 are the optical depths at the stellar and disk frequency . for a viscous heating disk , @xmath37,\ ] ] while for an envelope without viscous heating , @xmath38 .
we assume a two part model : an inner steady accretion disk of high mass accretion rate @xmath13 with outer radius @xmath39 , which is optically thick but geometrically thin and flat with height @xmath40 ; and an outer optically thick region , @xmath41 , which is heated by absorption of the light from the inner disk .
the geometrical details are described in the appendix a and fig .
[ fig:1 ] .
the values of the quantities @xmath42 and @xmath20 characterizing the incoming radiation to every outer annulus are calculated by integrating the mean intensity arriving from every part of the inner disk .
these quantities depend on both of the inner disk physical condition ( eg . the peak temperature , disk size ) and the geometry of the outer disk surface ( appendix a ) .
we used the same parametrization to describe the flared surface geometry of the disk outside @xmath39 as @xcite .
the scale height of a vertically isothermal disk is @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the sound speed at the disk midplane and @xmath45 is the angular velocity . for typical disk temperature distributions , @xmath46 , where 3/4 @xmath47 n @xmath47 1/2 .
thus , for a keplerian disk , @xmath48 , where 9/8 @xmath49 5/4 . for a very optically thick disk , the absorption height @xmath50 where most of the inner disk radiation is absorbed is a nearly constant multiple of @xmath51 @xcite ; thus we parameterize @xmath50 as @xmath52 where @xmath40 is the disk height of the inner high @xmath13 disk and @xmath39 is the outer radius of the inner high @xmath13 disk , which is also the inner boundary of the flared outer surface ( fig .
[ fig:1 ] ) .
thus , for fu ori , @xmath530.5 - 1 au .
we adopt this form to model all objects .
when it turns out that @xmath54 , or @xmath55 , we conclude that the absorbing surface we are describing is not that of a flared disk but rather represents the edge of a cavity in a dusty opaque envelope .
our outer disk ( or envelope ) structure joins abruptly to the inner flat thin disk . in reality
we expect a smoother joining between inner and outer regions , but this depends upon the precise geometry of the inner disk ( height , flaring ) which in turn depends upon the detailed viscosity , etc .
thus , the details of our model near @xmath39 ( and the precise values of @xmath39 and @xmath40 ) are uncertain , while the structure at @xmath56 is more robustly modeled .
the gas opacity used in this model is the same as we used in paper i. we improve our dust opacity by using the prescription in @xcite . for each dust component ,
the grain size distribution is given by a power law of the grain radius , @xmath57 , between a minimum and maximum radius .
we choose @xmath58=0.005 @xmath2 m , @xmath59=1 @xmath2 m , and @xmath60=3.5 .
the detailed ingredients of the dust are shown in table 1 . with this monochromatic dust opacity and gas opacity from paper i
, we calculate the @xmath24 and @xmath61 parameters of eq .
( [ eq : t ] ) . for @xmath24 , we weight the monochromatic @xmath62 by the planck function at the stellar temperature .
for @xmath61 , we calculate the rosseland mean opacity weighted by the planck function at the stellar temperature and the disk temperature separately , and then divide them .
we also use the same opacity to calculate the emergent spectra and disk images .
although the dust ingredients may vary for different objects , we use the ingredients in table [ tab1 ] for all , considering that larger uncertainties caused by the invalidity of the plane parallel assumption , as discussed below . given @xmath24 , @xmath61 , @xmath42 and e@xmath63 , we can calculate the temperature structure of every outer irradiated annulus using eq .
( [ eq : t ] ) .
the emergent intensity of any annulus at any outgoing direction then can be derived by solving the radiative transfer equation .
our calculation of the emergent spectrum does not include scattering .
scattering is unlikely to be important in the mid - infrared but may have an effect in the near - infrared ; we will consider a detailed scattering treatment in a future paper . when the intensity of every annulus , every outgoing direction and every wavelength is derived , the total flux and the image of the flared surface for any inclination angle can be derived , for given flared surface geometry .
the total flux can be compared with the irs spectra while the image can be used to do interferometric tests .
the details are shown in appendix b.
[ fig : fuorispe ] shows the final model spectra for fu ori compared with the observed sed .
the parameters are in table 2 .
the inner disk model is that of paper i , which shows absorption features because it is internally heated by viscous dissipation .
the outer flared disk exhibits 10 and 18 @xmath2 m silicate emission features due to the strong irradiation by the inner high @xmath13 disk , which produces a temperature inversion at its surface .
the model does not fit the 18 @xmath2 m feature very well , suggesting that either the size distribution we are using for the dust may vary with radius or the temperature structure of the outer region is not accurate . the adopted surface has the parameters @xmath64 au , where @xmath39=0.58 au ( see fig .
[ fig : fuorisurf ] ) . to investigate whether this surface is plausibly that of a flared disk , we computed the approximate local vertical scale height @xmath65 , assuming that the central mass is 0.3 m@xmath5 ( paper i ) and the temperature at the mid - plane is equal to the temperature at @xmath36=10 ( i.e. , the disk interior temperature distribution is roughly isothermal . ) .
the results indicate that our adopted surface lies roughly 3 scale heights above the midplane ( fig .
[ fig : fuorisurf ] ) , comparable to the dusty disk scale heights estimated for typical t tauri stars @xcite .
thus , a physically - plausible flared disk can reproduce the mid - ir flux of fu ori .
the temperature at @xmath66 is shown in fig .
[ fig : surftemp ] . because the disk is isothermal when @xmath67@xmath68 , the midplane temperature is almost the same as fig .
[ fig : surftemp ] . in paper
i , without considering the flux from the flared outer surface , we derived an inner high @xmath13 disk size of @xmath0 1 au , constrained by the mid - ir irs spectrum .
the flared outer disk contributes some emission shortward of 10 @xmath2 m , necessitating a reduction of the outer radius of the inner outbursting disk from 1 au to @xmath0 0.58 au .
this reduction of the outer radius does not significantly affect the conclusions of paper i ; in particular , the model of bell & lin ( 1994 ) still can not reproduce the observations .
we next compare model results with near - ir and mid - ir interferometry .
the images at the h and k bands are calculated by assuming the above flared surface geometry and all the parameters flow strictly from the sed fitting . to compensate for the lack of scattering in our models , we add an extra component of emission corresponding to an `` effective albedo '' of about 30% in h and k ;
compared with the case without scattering , the scattering model decreases the square visibilities by only 5% .
we adopt the 55 degree inclination angle estimated by @xcite .
we further adopt a -30 degree position angle for the disk , which is roughly perpendicular to the axis of large - scale reflection nebulosity seen in optical imaging @xcite , although due to the large error bars in the observed visibilities , the choice of the position angle has little effect . with the image as shown in fig .
[ fig : image ] , the resulting model visibilities are compared with the observations in fig . [
fig : hkvis ] . within the relatively large observational errors ,
our fu ori model is consistent with the near - ir interferometry . considering 90% of the flux at h and k bands
is from the inner disk , the near - ir interferometry only tests the inner disk modeling and longer wavelength data are needed to test the outer disk modeling . we compute the mid - infrared visibilities , and compare with the vlti - midi data from @xcite ; the comparison is shown in fig .
[ fig : midi ] . while the model predictions are in reasonable agreement with the observations at the shortest wavelengths , the predicted visibilities are considerably lower than the observations at long wavelengths .
although self - heating is not important in sed fitting because only 17@xmath9 of the inner disk radiation intercepted by the outer disk within 10 au by eq . 7 in @xcite , self - heating may change the visibility a little bit . however , it is not apparent to tell whether the visibility will increase or decrease , because the inclusion of the self - heating will decrease the flaring slightly , and thus decrease the amount of light intercepted from the inner disk , to keep the same sed .
the comparison with the mid - infrared observation might be improved if the disk has a higher inclination angle than estimated by malbet et al . with a bigger inclination angle ,
the disk would be less resolved ( higher visibility ) for the 44.56 m baseline which lies on the short axes of the disk image .
the visibilities for other two baselines would also increase , though not as much as for the 44.56 m baseline .
however , a bigger inclination angle may also increase the visibilities at shorter wavelengths which may contradict with the observed visibilities around 8 @xmath2 m .
unfortunately we can not test this by our model because the light from the inner disk has to travel through the outer disk to reach us at higher inclination angle and this needs a more complicated radiative transfer treatment than adopted in this paper .
another possibility is that there might be an abrupt change in the disk absorption height at the radius around @xmath39 where dust condenses , due to the much larger opacity of dust than gas ; this might produce a radially - sharp mid - infrared emission feature in the disk where the dust begins to form at t@xmath01500 k , by intercepting more irradiated flux from the inner disk .
finally , there might simply be narrower structures than we can model , such as non - axisymmetric spiral arms due to gravitational instability in the outer disk ( paper i ) .
overall , the spectrum fitting and the near - infrared interferometry support our flared disk model .
better uv plane coverage in mid - infrared interferometry would help to improve our understanding of the outer disk structure .
we fit the sed of bbw 76 following the same procedure as used for fu ori ( fig .
[ fig : bbwspe ] ) .
given the similarity of the large scale nebulosity to that of fu ori , we adopt a similar inclination angle of 50 degrees . because bbw 76 has the same rotational velocity broadening as fu ori ( reipurth et al . 2002 )
, we choose the same central star mass 0.3 m@xmath5 .
the parameters of the best fit model are displayed in table 2 .
the flared surface ( solid curve in fig .
[ fig : fuorisurf ] ) also lies close to 3 scale heights , and is therefore consistent with a flared disk structure . with the same relative strength of the irs spectrum with respect to the optical flux and the same irs spectrum shape as fu ori
, we derived a similar outer radius of the inner high @xmath13 disk @xmath00.6 au .
however , the outer disk extends further than in fu ori , to @xmath0 200 au , due to the slightly higher 18 @xmath2 m excess of bbw 76 .
the nebulosity seen on large scales suggests that we view v1515 cyg nearly pole - on , looking right down an outflow cavity ( goodrich 1987 ) .
for simplicity we assume an inclination angle of 0 ; small departures from this will have little effect on our modelling .
because of the low inclination , it is difficult to constrain the central star mass very well ( kenyon , hartmann , & hewett 1988 ) .
we therefore assume the central star is like fu ori with a mass of 0.3 m@xmath5 .
in contrast to fu ori and bbw 76 , the absorption height of the surface required to fit the sed of v1515 cyg is highly flared ( fig .
[ fig : v1515spe ] ) .
this surface lies at about 6 scale heights ( fig .
[ fig : fuorisurf ] ) with the assumption that the central star mass is 0.3 m@xmath5 ; this value is higher than a physically plausible height for a disk . instead , the large dust surface height and relatively small opening angle ( h / r @xmath69 1 ) strongly suggest that this surface defines an outflow - driven cavity in an infalling envelope , as suggested by kenyon & hartmann ( 1991 ) and green et al .
( 2006 ) .
though this surface may extend to a very large radius , most of the irs mid - ir flux comes from small radii , eg .
80 @xmath9 of 10 @xmath2 m flux and 50 @xmath9 of 20 @xmath2 m flux come within 10 au .
this can be roughly estimated from fig .
[ fig : surftemp ] . by wien s law
, 100 k blackbody has its peak flux at 20 @xmath2 m and from fig .
[ fig : surftemp ] 100 k corresponds to 10 au .
our assumed dust properties fit the silicate emission features of fu ori very well , but in v1515 cyg the model continuum is a bit too steeply declining longward of 30 @xmath2 m ; in addition , the model predicts slightly stronger silicate features than observed ( fig . [
fig : v1515spe ] ) . these discrepancies might be reduced if we had adopted larger dust grain sizes which can make the silicate features wider and shallower . however , it could also be that our assumption of plane - parallel geometry is not correct for the outer envelope . as fig .
[ fig : surftemp ] shows , although the fluxes at @xmath70 ( characteristic of a black body temperature @xmath71 300 k ) are mainly from the surface within 10 au , the long wavelength fluxes may come from a much larger radius from 10 au to 100 au . because infalling envelopes are much less optically thick than disks at these radii , long wavelength photons may travel further into the envelope , invalidating the plane - parallel assumption .
the inner disks of the fuors are internally - heated accretion disks , which produce absorption features .
however , the silicate emission features must arise in a dusty region that is externally heated to produce a temperature inversion in the surface of optically - thick dusty disks and envelopes . in the cases of fu ori and bbw 76
, we find that the irs sed can be explained with physically plausible flared disks . for the flared disks of fu ori and bbw 76 we derived @xmath72 which is larger than the value of 0.2 crudely estimated by @xcite for fu ori .
the main reason for the discrepancy is that we adopt a smaller @xmath73 than @xcite , which makes the inner disk fainter and thus requires a more flared outer disk to absorb and reemit the same luminosity ( the long - wavelength spectrum is relatively unaffected at these low values of extinctions ) . if anything our extinction estimate is likely to be low , which means that we may have overestimated the required flaring , and thus makes it even more plausible that the long - wavelength emission comes from the outer disks .
we note that , in estimating the number of scale heights for the disk , we have assumed that the disk has been able to relax to vertical hydrostatic equilibrium after the outburst . before the outburst
, we expect the outer disk to be cooler and thus thinner .
after the outburst , the outer disk is heated by the inner hot disk and gets puffed up .
the time scale for the disk to adjust its vertical hydrostatic equilibrium to the extra irradiation is @xmath74 , where @xmath51 is the disk scale height and @xmath44 is the sound speed . since @xmath75 , @xmath76 or @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the orbital period .
thus , @xmath79 as the outburst of fu ori has been proceeding for over 70 years now , our assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium is good for the inner parts of the flared disk , but may be less appropriate for the outer disk ; beyond 50 au for an assumed 0.3 m@xmath5 central star ( paper i ) , the hydrostatic equilibrium time starts to become longer ( 100 yrs ) than the length of the current outburst . while it is not necessary to include disk accretion energy in the outer disk to fit the spectrum reasonably well , this does not mean that the disk is not accreting ; the local viscous energy release is simply much less than the irradiation heating .
we find that outer disk accretion rates greater than @xmath80 of the inner disk accretion rate yield silicate features shallower than observed in the irs spectra .
thus , the data suggest that the outer disk accretion rates in bbw 76 and fu ori are significantly smaller than the inner disk accretion rates .
this is consistent with models in which material piles up and then accretes in bursts ( e.g. , kenyon @xmath7 hartmann 1991 ; armitage et al .
2001 ) .
the irs sed of v1515 cyg can not be explained with a reasonably flared disk .
a much more plausible explanation is that we are observing emission from the surface of a cavity in a dusty , infalling envelope .
@xcite also inferred an envelope around v1515 cyg , and estimated a maximum solid angle of the outer envelope of @xmath81 based on 14% of the inner disk radiation being intercepted and reradiated by the envelope .
however , their estimate was a lower limit because they did not include emission at longer wavelengths than observed by the irs
. in our radiative transfer model , 80@xmath9 of the 10 @xmath2 m flux and 50% of the 20 @xmath2 m flux arises from within 10 au . at this radius
the height of the envelope surface is about 10 au ( fig .
[ fig : fuorisurf ] ) , so that the fraction of solid angle covered at this point is about 70% .
this is roughly twice the solid angle estimated by @xmath81 from green et al . , but the assumed geometries are different . our cavity structure ( fig .
[ fig : fuorispe ] ) is much more consistent with typical outflow cavity structures @xcite and our radiative transfer methods are more robust .
we estimate that self - heating of the outer flared disks , which we ignore , is a relatively small effect because the outer disk only intercepts a small fraction of the inner disk flux .
this is not true of the envelope for v1515 cyg , and so our results for this object can only be suggestive rather than conclusive .
our main point is that a flared disk model can not reproduce the observations of v1515 cyg and v1057 cyg .
we are currently exploring models o these two objects with two - dimensional radiative transfer and will report results in a future paper .
we have also begun to investigate v1057 cyg .
our preliminary model is very similar to that of v1515 cyg , with a highly flared envelope .
however , when the object is not pole - on or a flat disk our method is questionable ( i.e. , maybe we are looking along the edge of the envelope , or even through some of the envelope ) , thus we will revisit v1057 cyg using a more detailed radiative transfer method in a subsequent paper .
the near - ir keck interferometer @xcite also found a difference between the near - ir sizes for v1515 cyg and v1057 cyg compared with fu ori .
the low near - ir visibilities suggest v1515 cyg and v1057 cyg are more resolved than fu ori , which suggests dense envelops may be present for these objects .
this is an additional support for the envelope model , but in future the detailed modeling is needed to fit these interferometry data .
as both fu ori and bbw 76 have large - scale reflection nebulosities , it suggests that they have remnant infalling envelopes , if sufficiently optically thin .
we can estimate an upper limit to the amount of possible envelope material in fu ori and bbw 76 from a limit on the visual extinction .
we use the rotating collapse model of terebey , shu , & cassen ( 1984 ) .
when @xmath82 , where @xmath83 is the centrifugal radius , @xmath84 when @xmath85 , @xmath86 integrating the above equations from 0 to @xmath87 and then multiplying by the visual dust opacity @xmath88 at the v band , @xmath89 with @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath88=100 @xmath92/gr , and @xmath932 constrained by a@xmath10@xmath02 , we find @xmath94 if @xmath83=200 au , we thus estimate an upper limit of @xmath95yr@xmath6 , which is considerably smaller than typical class i infall rates of @xmath96yr@xmath6 .
@xcite also suggested that fu ori has a highly depleted dusty envelope , with a density depletion factor 0.01 with respect to the density derived by their standard infall envelope model .
though they did nt give the mass infall rate for the depleted envelope models , we can estimate their mass infall rate is @xmath010@xmath4m@xmath5/yr by multiplying the depletion factor 0.01 by their standard mass infall rate 10@xmath97m@xmath5/yr . because they did nt consider the flared outer disk which is the main contributor at irs range
, this infall rate is an upper limit .
submillimeter observations barely resolve fu ori and bbw 76 @xcite , which also implies highly evolved or absent envelopes .
the 18 @xmath2 m features in the seds are not well fit , indicating that we may need to use a different grain opacity or a more detailed radiative transfer method .
however , we can still study the dust properties from the 10 @xmath2 m silicate emission features .
the dust , with a power - law distribution of the grain radius and a maximum radius 1 @xmath2 m , is larger than the typical interstellar medium dust with a maximum grain radius 0.25 @xmath2 m @xcite .
although this dust composition differs from the one used by @xcite , where they use a mixture of grains with three different sizes ( 0.1,1.5 and 6 @xmath2 m ) , it also suggests that grain growth has taken place in the disk .
our results confirm @xcite that a significantly higher fraction of @xmath01@xmath2 m grains is required .
bbw 76 is similar to fu ori while v1515 cyg seems to require grains growing to even larger sizes . in paper
i , we suggested that dust might be depleted in the inner disk , based on the observed water vapor absorption features at @xmath98 m .
however , if we deplete the dust in the outer disk of fu ori and bbw 76 , we predict a strong water vapor emission at 8 @xmath2 m , which is not observed .
thus , there may not be significant depletion in the outer disk , which may be reasonable given the youth of the system and the likelihood that grain growth / settling timescales are longer at larger radii @xcite .
however , this is not a firm conclusion , as the abundance of water vapor is poorly understood and the region of the disk where most of the 8 @xmath99 flux comes from is at the region where we join the inner and outer disk solutions , and thus is uncertain .
the ( meager ) event statistics suggest that there must be repeated fu orionis outbursts in at least some young stars ( herbig 1977 ; hartmann & kenyon 1996 ) .
kenyon & hartmann ( 1991 ) proposed that continued infall was needed to replenish the material accreted onto the central star during an outburst .
while we are unable to determine the infall rate for v1515 cyg from our particular modelling , previous estimates suggest that sufficient matter may be falling in to make repeat outbursts possible in v1515 cyg and in v1057 cyg ( kenyon & hartmann 1991 ; green et al .
2006 ) .
in contrast , we have shown that fu ori and bbw 76 have little or no infall from remnant envelopes .
the low upper limits of infall in these objects suggest that continuing infall may not be important in continuing outbursts ; any subsequent outbursts may have to rely on material already present in these disks .
thus , we suggest that fu ori and bbw 76 are nearing the end of their outburst lives , while v1515 cyg and v1057 cyg have a much higher probability of continuing their activity . the significant difference between fu ori and bbw 76 on the one hand , and v1515 cyg and v1057 cyg on the other , is also supported by submillimeter observations .
fu ori and bbw 76 are very faint and hardly resolved at submilimeter wavelengths @xcite , suggesting that they have more depleted envelopes than other fu orionis objects .
overall , the variety of the fu orionis envelopes suggests that fu orionis phenomenon is observed at different stages of the protostars and every yso may experience several fu orionis outbursts from the early to the late stages of protostellar infall . in this
regard , young stellar objects ( yso ) have been classified as two categories based on their spectral index @xmath100 log(@xmath101 log @xmath102 in the near - infrared and mid - infrared @xcite .
@xmath103 represents the protostars embedded in infalling envelopes ( class i ) and @xmath104 represents the t tauri stars without envelopes ( class ii ) .
this classification helps us to understand the evolutionary sequence of yso , from protostars to pre - main - sequence stars . as we discussed above , fu
orions objects are in a stage between class i and class ii .
thus , it is also helpful to classify fu orions objects in two categories @xcite .
however because of the strong near - ir flux produced by the high @xmath13 disk , @xmath105 is always positive in the near - ir and mid - ir ( 1 - 10 @xmath2 m ) range .
thus , based on the spectra and envelope structures of fu ori , bbw 76 and v1057 cyg , we suggest a criterion to classify fu orionis objects by using mid - ir spectral index @xmath100 log(@xmath106 log @xmath102 from 14 to 40 @xmath2 m , where most of the flux is contributed by the outer region beyond the inner disk . if @xmath105 is negative or close to zero , this fu orionis object has a circumstellar envelope which produces a flat mid - ir spectrum ( eg : v1057 cyg and v1515 cyg ) .
if @xmath105 is positive it may have a remnant envelope far away and the mid - ir flux is contributed by a flared outer disk ( eg : fu ori and bbw 76 ) .
this classification method is different from the method used by @xcite where they used the 10 @xmath2 m silicate feature to classify fu orionis objects .
they suggest that the objects with absorption features are in category i , embedded in circumstellar envelopes , while the objects with emission features are in category ii , which are more evolved and show properties of class ii sources . however , as discussed above , some fu orionis objects embedded in envelopes have cavities ( eg .
v1057 cyg and v1515 cyg ) with moderate opening angles .
thus , if we view these objects pole on , we will still detect the emission features and would classify them as category i by the emission silicate feature method .
another benefit of using a mid - ir index is that the strength of 10 @xmath2 m silicate features are dependent on the inclination angle .
in contrast , for continuum emission at 14 - 40 @xmath2 m is not affected significantly by the inclination and envelope extinction , since the opacity at 14 @xmath2 m is close to the opacity at 30 @xmath2 m , and 5 times smaller than the opacity at 9 @xmath2 m for a@xmath107=1 @xmath2 m olivine grains . even for a highly embedded fu orionis objects , a@xmath10=10 ( a@xmath108=0.7 ) , a@xmath109 is only @xmath0 0.15 , in which case an extinction correction is not necessary . with the mid - ir index method
, we get the same classification for the objects listed in @xcite except that v1057 cyg , v1515 cyg , and v 1647 ori are identified in category i. in this paper , we suggest that v1057 cyg , v1515 cyg have normal envelopes , thus they are indeed in category i. v1647 ori object is a special fuor with both large extinctions , a@xmath11011 and silicate emission features .
@xcite suggests there maybe a foreground cloud between this object and us , which makes it hard to classify and it needs detailed modelling .
with the latest irs spectra and a detailed radiative transfer model including irradiation , we revisited the envelope / flared disk problem of fuors .
we confirmed the results of @xcite that fu ori and bbw 76 have flared outer disks while v1515 cyg has a circumstellar envelope .
however , instead of a flattened envelope and a large opening angle @xcite , we derived a more reasonable cavity structure . for fu ori
, near - infrared interferometry also supports our model , while mid - infrared interferometry does not fit perfectly and needs further modelling . including the contribution from the outer flared disk , we gave a tighter constraint on the outer radius of the inner disk @xmath00.5 au , which is essential to test outburst theories ( paper i ) .
we also suggest using a spectral index @xmath105 from 14 @xmath2 m to 40 @xmath2 m to classify fuors into early ( category i ) and late ( category ii ) , which is less sensitive to the viewing angle .
the variety of fu orionis envelopes suggests that fu orionis phenomenon is observed at different stages of the protostars , and every yso may experience several fu orionis outbursts from very early to late stages of the infalling envelope .
this research was supported in part by the university of michigan .
in addition , this work was based in part on observations made with the spitzer space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under a contract with nasa .
we gratefully acknowledges john d. monnier who drew our attention to the interferometry and gave us many helpful advices .
the inner disk and outer flared surface are shown in figure 1 . for point a , located at distance @xmath111 from the center , the quantities @xmath42 and @xmath20 are derived as follows .
we define several vectors as shown in the figure 1 ; the normal vector to the flaring surface at a is : @xmath112 the vector from the shaded area at r@xmath113 in the inner disk to point a at the flaring outer disk is : @xmath114 where @xmath115 the solid angle @xmath116 extended by s with respect to point a is ( s is the area of the tiny shaded region at r@xmath113 in figure 1 . ) @xmath117 where @xmath118 thus @xmath119 , the amount of energy irradiated from the inner disk annulus r@xmath113 to unit area normal to @xmath120 at point a , is @xmath121 integrated over all the area of annulus i. thus , @xmath122 because of limb darkening , @xmath123 from the inner disk annulus i equals to @xmath124 , where @xmath125 is the intensity at radius r@xmath113 towards z direction ( direction perpendicular to the inner disk surface ) and @xmath2 is the cosine of the angle between @xmath120 and z direction ; thus we use @xmath126 to approximate @xmath2 .
then , @xmath127 , the amount of energy irradiated from the inner disk annulus r@xmath113 to unit area at the flaring surface point a ( notice it is different from the above unit area normal to @xmath120 at point a ) , is @xmath128 finally , we add the contributions of all the inner annuli together to get the flux @xmath20 , @xmath129 and the equivalent @xmath42 ( cosine of the equivalent incident angle @xmath130 ) : @xmath131
to derive the total flux and the image detected by the observer on earth , the flared surface needs to be projected onto the plane of sky . for a tiny patch of the flared surface @xmath132 , with area vector @xmath133 normal to the surface , the projection area to the plane which is normal to our line of sight
is @xmath134 , where @xmath135 is the unit vector pointing to the observer along our line of sight .
the angle between @xmath135 and @xmath133 is @xmath136=cos@xmath6(@xmath137/@xmath138 ) .
the flux we observed from @xmath132 can be derived by multiplying the intensity at direction @xmath136 , @xmath139 , and the solid angle extended by @xmath132 towards us , @xmath140 , @xmath141 is the distance between the object and the observer .
the addition over all the surface , @xmath142 , is the total flux .
the image of the flared surface could also be derived in this way .
cll ingredient & @xmath143 & t@xmath144 ( k ) + mg@xmath145fe@xmath146sio@xmath147 ( olivine ) & 0.0017 & 1460 + mg@xmath145fe@xmath148sio@xmath149 ( pyroxene ) & 0.0017 & 1460 + graphite & 0.0041 & 734 + water ice & 0.0056 & 146 + cccccccccc object & a@xmath10 & inclination & @xmath150 & @xmath151 & @xmath152 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 & @xmath153 & @xmath154 + & & angle & 10@xmath97m@xmath155yr@xmath6 & r@xmath5 & l@xmath5&au&r@xmath5 & & au + fu ori & 1.5 & 55 & 7.4 & 5 & 232 & 0.58 & 41.5 & 1.125 & 70 : + bbw 76 & 2.2 & 50 & 8.1 & 4.6 & 277 & 0.64 & 49.22 & 1.125 & 200 : + v1515 cyg & 3.2 & 0 & 1.3 & 2.8 & 73 & 0.25 & 16.8 & 1.3 & 10@xmath156 : + | the mid- to far - infrared emission of the outbursting fu orionis objects has been attributed either to a flared outer disk or to an infalling envelope .
we revisit this issue using detailed radiative transfer calculations to model the recent , high signal - to - noise data from the irs instrument on the _ spitzer space telescope_. in the case of fu ori , we find that a physically - plausible flared disk irradiated by the central accretion disk matches the observations . building on our previous work
, our accretion disk model with outer disk irradiation by the inner disk reproduces the spectral energy distribution between @xmath0 4000 to @xmath1 @xmath2 m .
our model is consistent with near - infrared interferometry but there are some inconsistencies with mid - infared interferometric results . including the outer disk allows us to refine our estimate of the outer radius of the outbursting , high mass accretion rate disk in fu ori as @xmath0 0.5 au , which is a crucial parameter in assessing theories of the fu orionis phenomenon .
we are able to place an upper limit on the mass infall rate of any remnant envelope infall rate to @xmath310@xmath4 m@xmath5yr@xmath6 assuming a centrifugal radius of 200 au .
the fuor bbw 76 is also well modelled by a 0.6 au inner disk and a flared outer disk .
however , v1515 cyg requires an envelope with an outflow cavity to adequately reproduce the irs spectrum .
in contrast with the suggestion by green et al . , we do not require a flattened envelope to match the observations ; the inferred cavity shape is qualitatively consistent with typical protostellar envelopes .
this variety of dusty structures suggests that the fu orionis phase can be present at either early or late stages of protostellar evolution . |
parametric down conversion is a process that is used to produce light possessing strong quantum features .
photon pairs generated by this process show entanglement with respect to different physical attributes such as time of arrival @xcite and states of polarization @xcite .
they are increasingly being utilized for very basic experiments to test the foundation of quantum mechanics and to do quantum information processing @xcite .
it is also recognized that entangled photon pairs could be useful in many practical applications in precision metrology involving e.g. interferometry @xcite , imaging @xcite , lithography @xcite and spectroscopy @xcite .
there is a proposal @xcite to use electromagnetic fields in @xmath0 states to improve the sensitivity of measurements by a factor of @xmath1 .
some implementations of this proposal exist @xcite . in particular
, the use of photon pairs in interferometers allows phases to be measured to the precision in the heisenberg limit where uncertainty scales as @xmath2 @xcite as compared to the shot noise limit where it scales as @xmath3 .
this means that for large number of particles , a dramatic improvement in measurement resolution should be possible . in this paper
we present an analysis of how parametric down converted photons could be very useful in getting better spectroscopic information about the medium .
we demonstrate how the improvement in magneto - optical rotation ( mor ) of light could be realized by employing two different schemes with collinear and non - collinear down conversion geometry in compared to use of coherent light .
we calculate the resolution that can be achieved in the mor s both by use of coherent light and down converted light .
we discuss that the heisenberg limit @xcite could be reached in magnetometry by the use down converted light .
consider a single mode coherent light travelling in the z - direction and a linear isotropic medium made anisotropic by the application of the magnetic field @xmath4 in the z - direction .
the incident field can be written in the form @xmath5 the medium is described by the frequency and magnetic field dependent susceptibilities @xmath6 .
that means horizontally and vertically polarized components of the incident light will rotate on travelling the medium of length @xmath7 and the field at the exit can be written as @xmath8 the rotation of the horizontal and vertical components can be expressed by the relations @xmath9 where @xmath10 the corresponding quantum mechanical description can be obtained by replacing the classical amplitudes @xmath11 and @xmath12 by the annihilation operators @xmath13 and @xmath14 respectively . for measurements with coherent sources one can look at the intensities of the @xmath15 and @xmath16 components of the output when the input is @xmath15 polarized with coherent state amplitude @xmath17 ( see fig .
[ setup](a ) .
then the measured quantities will be @xmath18 one can estimate the minimum detectable rotation angle @xmath19 by looking at the fluctuations @xmath20 in the photon number difference between horizontal and vertical photons , where the number difference operator is given as @xmath21 .
this expression is calculated to be @xmath22 and since the fluctuation noise is 1 we obtain @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the mean number of input photons which is equal to @xmath25 .
we now discuss how the results ( [ coherent1 ] ) and ( [ coherent2 ] ) are modified if we work with down - converted photons .
we first consider the collinear case shown in fig .
[ setup](b ) .
the state produced in collinear pdc can be written by @xmath26 and the phase @xmath27 are related to the pump amplitude of the nonlinear crystal that is used in the down conversion process and the coupling constant between the electromagnetic field and the crystal .
note that the state @xmath28 is a superposition of @xmath29 photon pairs of horizontally and vertically polarized modes . inside the medium , these modes rotate with the same rotation matrix @xmath30 given in eq .
( [ rotation ] ) : @xmath31 one can measure the intensity of each mode : @xmath32 and the two - photon coincidence count is : @xmath33 note the difference between eqs . ( [ coherent1 ] ) and ( [ co - pdc ] ) . with
collinearly down - converted photons we measure a rotation angle that is twice as large compared with the angle for a coherent input . for @xmath34
we obtain the same result as given in @xcite .
the fringe pattern and the visibility is given in figs .
[ collinear - twophoton ] and [ visibility ] .
one can calculate the minimum detectable rotation angle again by looking at the fluctuations in the photon number difference @xmath35 .
this is given by @xmath36 for large @xmath24 where @xmath37 .
making @xmath38 @xcite we get @xmath39 .
note that the sensitivity of this quantity is also improved by a factor of @xmath3 .
next , we discuss the non - collinear pdc case . we have found an arrangement shown in fig .
[ setup](c ) which is especially attractive for improving sensitivity .
the entangled photons are coming in two different spatial modes , @xmath40 and @xmath41 . while one mode ( say @xmath40 ) is going parallel to @xmath4 inside the medium , the other is going anti - parallel to it . at the exit we separate the @xmath42 and @xmath43 modes by polarizing beam splitters .
the state of the input photons can be written in the form @xcite @xmath44 where @xmath45 represents @xmath46 vertically polarized photons in mode @xmath40 . inside the medium , @xmath47 and @xmath48 polarization components of the modes @xmath40 and @xmath41 gain phases @xmath49 and @xmath50 respectively .
thus we can write an effective hamiltonian for the evolution of the state @xmath51 inside the medium as follows : @xmath52 where @xmath53 [ 0.50](a ) the normalized four - photon probability defined in eq .
( [ 4photon1 ] ) , and ( b ) its envelope _ wrt _ the interaction parameter @xmath54 in the non - collinear geometry.,title="fig : " ] [ 0.50](a ) the normalized four - photon probability defined in eq .
( [ 4photon2 ] ) , and ( b ) its envelope _ wrt _ the interaction parameter @xmath54 at the exit ports of pbs in the collinear geometry.,title="fig : " ] the minus sign in front of the @xmath55 modes comes from the fact that they are travelling anti - parallel to the @xmath56 field inside the medium
. then one can calculate the probability of detecting four photons in each mode as : @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the duration for the state to evolve inside the medium .
note that this four - photon probability has the rotation angle that is four - times as large compared with the angle for a coherent input .
the fringe pattern with respect to @xmath59 and the probability distribution with respect to @xmath54 are shown in fig .
[ noncollinear-4photon ] ( a ) and ( b ) .
next we also examine the four - photon probability in the collinear case .
the probability of finding two @xmath42-photons and two @xmath43-photons at the exit ports of the polarizing beam splitter is given by : @xmath60 ^ 2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we take @xmath61 because of the collinear geometry .
the normalized plot of this quantity with respect to the magneto - optical rotation angle @xmath59 and the envelope of the probability with respect to @xmath54 are shown in fig .
[ collinear-4photon_a ] ( a ) and ( b ) . on the other hand one can also calculate the coincidence counts of four photons two - by - two at each detector as given by glauber s higher order correlation functions : @xmath62 the plot of this quantity for different values of the interaction parameter @xmath54 and the visibility
are shown in figs .
[ collinear-4photon ] and [ visibility ] .
note the distinction between eqs .
( [ 4photon2 ] ) and ( [ 4photon in detector ] ) which is a reflection of what the detector is set to measure as we explain now .
the former is the probability of the state @xmath63 to be projected onto the particular four - photon subspace @xmath64 i.e. @xmath65 $ ] where @xmath66 and @xmath67 is the unitary operator that represents the evolution of the state by the hamiltonian @xmath68 in the collinear geometry . on the other hand , coincidence counting of four - photons at the detectors @xmath69 and @xmath70 ( see fig .
[ setup](b ) ) is represented by the expectation value @xmath71 $ ] .
note here that the operator @xmath72 has the spectral decomposition @xmath73 and obviously it contains the projectors of all @xmath74-photon subspaces with nonzero coefficients @xmath75 .
therefore four - photon counting process at detectors includes not only @xmath64 but all other states @xmath76 in @xmath63 .
here the state @xmath76 represents @xmath29 and @xmath46 photons in the @xmath77 and @xmath78 modes respectively .
we showed that the use of non - collinear type - ii pdc light in mor s increases the sensitivity by a factor of four in comparison to coherent light .
we also give an argument that minimum rotation uncertainty scales to heisenberg limit by the use of down converted photons .
it should be noted that heisenberg limit should be understood as an approximate limit at a large mean photon number , that is , the rotation uncertainty approaches the order of @xmath79 for large @xmath80 @xcite .
the regime with an interaction parameter value of @xmath81 has already been reached in the experiment @xcite giving entanglement of @xmath82 photons and an evidence also was given for entanglement up to 100 photons .
in this appendix we show the details of the calculation leading to the result given in eq .
( [ 4photon1 ] ) . one can obtain the result first by solving the schrdinger equation for the state @xmath83 in the four - photon subspace of the electromagnetic field and having the inner product with the state @xmath84 . since the parts of the hamiltonian having @xmath40 and @xmath41 modes commute
, we can solve the schrdinger equation for the states @xmath85 and @xmath86 separately .
let us start with a general time - dependent state in the @xmath77 and @xmath78 modes which contain two photons totally ; @xmath87 with the initial condition @xmath88 .
solving the schrdinger equation by using the effective hamiltonian @xmath89 gives us the result @xmath90\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
for a medium of length @xmath7 , the angle @xmath93 corresponds to the mor angle @xmath59 which is given in eq .
( [ mor ] ) .
the solution for the state @xmath86 can be obtained just by replacing @xmath59 by @xmath94 because the direction of propagation of the @xmath41 modes are opposite to that of @xmath40 modes inside the medium .
this is the reason that the part of the effective hamiltonian for the @xmath55 modes takes minus sign in eq .
( [ medium ] ) .
consequently we can write the solution of the schrdinger equation for the state @xmath83 as : | recent theoretical and experimental papers have shown how one can achieve heisenberg limited measurements by using entangled photons . here
we show how the photons in non - collinear down conversion process can be used for improving the sensitivity of magneto - optical rotation by a factor of four which takes us towards the heisenberg limit .
our results apply to sources with arbitrary pumping .
we also present several generalizations of earlier results for the collinear geometry .
the sensitivity depends on whether the two - photon or four - photon coincidence detection is used . |
slotted aloha and its many variants are popular random access mechanisms used in various networks , e.g. , cellular or satellite networks .
the current rise of machine - to - machine ( m2 m ) communications , with substantially increased number of terminals and different traffic patterns with respect to human - centric communications , requires efficient random access mechanisms and their redesign and enhancements are one of the main interests of m2 m research community . an important research track in this direction is use of successive interference cancellation ( sic ) in slotted aloha - based protocols @xcite .
particularly , the work presented in @xcite identified the analogies between sic in framed slotted aloha and the iterative belief - propagation ( bp ) decoding of fixed - rate erasure - correcting codes , enabling the application of erasure - coding theory and tools .
the asymptotic analysis in terms of symbol erasure probability of erasure - correcting codes is standardly performed using and - or tree evaluation technique , first presented in @xcite , and applied in its original form for the slotted aloha case in @xcite . however , both in @xcite , the underlying assumption is that the contending terminals are able to perform perfect power control , and thus experience the uniform probability of packet loss .
these results are not readily transferable to the case when link quality and packet loss vary across terminals . in this paper
we derive the generalization of the and - or tree evaluation when the contending terminals experience different packet - loss probabilities .
this assumption introduces fundamental differences with respect to the standard and - or tree evaluation used in erasure coding , where all input symbols contained ( i.e. , encoded ) in a given output symbol have the same potential to contribute to the decoding process and there is no concept of varying quality across input symbols .
in contrast , in a random access setting , the probability that a packet is successfully decoded depends on the channel conditions of the user sending the packet , irrespective if there was a single user sending in the slot , or there were multiple users sending , but the packets of other users were removed with sic .
the presented analysis can be applied to any slotted aloha - based method in which the user access strategy depends on the channel conditions .
we instantiate it for the case of _ frameless _ aloha @xcite , providing insights on the relations between user access strategy , channel conditions , throughput and probability of successful resolution of user transmission , which hold in general for any coded slotted aloha access method .
an extension of the and - or tree evaluation for the case of unequal error protection ( uep ) rateless codes was assessed in @xcite , where input symbols are divided into classes with different selection probabilities when encoding the output symbol .
this was further generalized for the case of expanding - window lt codes @xcite .
another extension was made for the case of distributed lt codes @xcite , where the encoding is performed independently by sources that can access only subsets ( i.e. , classes ) of input symbols , and the outputs of the sources are combined by a relay .
this was developed further in @xcite , where the relay , according to some probability distribution , choose either to forward or combine outputs of the sources that perform distributed encoding .
finally , a generalization of and - or tree evaluation where input and output symbols are divided into classes and selection probability of input symbols depend both on the output and input symbol class , was presented in @xcite . the presented work is closely related to @xcite , as we also consider the case in which there are classes of users ( i.e. , input symbols ) , and slots ( i.e. , output symbols ) .
we assume that the division of the users into classes depends on the experienced channel conditions , which determines the user access strategy .
our main contribution is the incorporation of the effects of unequal channel conditions into analysis ; to the best of our knowledge , this has not been addressed in the previous work , as it is inherent to the random access framework .
we assume that there are @xmath0 contending users , divided into @xmath1 classes @xmath2 , @xmath3 , according to their probability of packet loss ; the term _ packet loss _ denotes the event when a user transmits interference - free and its packet is lost due to noise - induced errors .
thus , the probability of packet loss depends only on the transmission power and channel conditions .
the packet loss probability for class @xmath2 is @xmath4 and a fraction of @xmath5 users belongs to @xmath2 , @xmath6 .
the length of the contention period is @xmath7 slots , where @xmath7 , in general , does not have to be a priori fixed value .
the slots are divided into @xmath8 classes @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and fraction of @xmath11 slots belongs to class @xmath9 , @xmath12 .
finally , the expected fraction of transmissions of class @xmath2 users taking place in class @xmath9 slots is given by @xmath13 ; without loss of generality , we assume that : @xmath14 where @xmath15 are suitably chosen constants .
the above framework is depicted in fig .
[ fig : f - graph ] , showing connections among users and slots at class levels .
we note that this framework is applicable both to framed aloha , where the users select transmission slot in a frame , and to slotted aloha , where the users decide whether to transmit or not on an individual slot basis .
every user transmission consists of a replica of the same packet and a pointer to all other replicas .
the resolution of user transmissions is executed in the same way as iterative bp erasure - decoding .
first , slots containing a single packet ( i.e. , degree one slots ) are identified and corresponding transmissions resolved . in the next step , using pointers contained in the resolved packets , the slots containing the packet replicas are identified and these replicas are removed , potentially resulting with new degree one slots and instigating new iterations of the algorithm .
we assume a perfect interference cancellation , i.e. , once a user packet is resolved , all its replicas are perfectly removed .
this implies that whether a slot is useful or not when its degree is reduced to one , eventually depends on the packet - loss probability of the remaining packet .
first , we briefly introduce the notation and terminology , following the standard introduced in @xcite . for the general introduction on the and - or tree evaluation
, we refer the interested reader to @xcite .
denote a generic user from class @xmath2 by @xmath16 and a generic slot from @xmath9 by @xmath17 .
by @xmath18 denote the probability that user @xmath19 is connected to @xmath20 slots from class @xmath9 , i.e. , the probability that the degree of @xmath19 with respect to class @xmath9 is @xmath20 .
the node - oriented degree distribution of @xmath19 with respect to @xmath9 is @xmath21 , and the edge - oriented degree distribution of @xmath16 with respect to @xmath9 is @xmath22 .
similarly , by @xmath23 denote the probability that the slot @xmath17 is connected to @xmath20 users from class @xmath2 , i.e. , the probability that the degree of @xmath17 with respect to @xmath2 is @xmath20 .
the node - oriented degree distribution of @xmath17 with respect to @xmath2 is @xmath24 , and the edge - oriented degree distribution of @xmath17 with respect to @xmath2 is @xmath25 .
denote the probability that the transmission of user @xmath16 is not resolved during the @xmath26-th iteration of the and - or tree evaluation by @xmath27 ; by default we assume @xmath28 .
the evaluation of @xmath27 through iterations is given by the following theorem .
[ theorem ] @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the expected degree of @xmath17 and @xmath31 .
assume that the degree of @xmath16 with respect to @xmath9 is @xmath32 , for @xmath33 .
using the standard `` or '' argument , it is easy to show that : @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the probability that a slot @xmath17 sends a not - resolved ( i.e. , erasure ) message in the previous iteration . averaging over @xmath32 , @xmath33 , yields : @xmath36 where , with slight notation abuse
, @xmath37 also denotes the average .
now , assume that the degree of @xmath38 with respect to @xmath39 is @xmath40 , for @xmath41 .
the probability that a slot sends a not - resolved message , assuming that the last user that remains unresolved after sic execution belongs to class @xmath42 , is : @xmath43 where the product term stems from the standard `` and '' argument .
averaging over @xmath40 , @xmath41 , yields : @xmath44 where @xmath45 is used to denote the average , as well .
finally , averaging over all user classes with respect to the last unresolved user , becomes : @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the expected fraction of edges incident to @xmath48 that are also incident to @xmath17 . substituting in completes the proof .
the probability of resolving transmission of @xmath16 is simply @xmath49 .
the expected fraction of resolved users and the expected throughput , which are among key performance indicators of random access schemes , are : @xmath50 where @xmath51 .
going back to the system model , as depicted in fig .
[ fig : f - graph ] , it could be shown that @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
furthermore , we draw attention to another important fact , which generally holds for any slotted aloha - based scheme . as users perform access independently and uncoordinatedly , slot degrees can not be controlled directly , in contrast to the typical erasure - coding scenarios .
it is straightforward to show that the probability that the degree of @xmath17 with respect to @xmath2 is @xmath20 equals : @xmath55 and the corresponding node - oriented and edge - oriented degree distributions are : @xmath56 finally , we note that this generalization of the and - or tree evaluation is similar in flavor to the version of and - or tree lemma presented in @xcite , where the `` and '' nodes can be short - circuited to evaluate to zero with a predefined probability , irrespective to the values of input messages .
however , a crucial difference in the case assessed here is that the evaluation of `` and '' nodes to zero depends both on the packet - loss probability _ and _ user access strategy through @xmath57 , see , posing a different optimization problem .
in this section we exemplify theorem [ theorem ] for the case of frameless aloha @xcite .
the key feature of frameless aloha is that users randomly and independently decide to transmit on a slot basis , using predefined slot access probability .
the slot access probability @xmath58 depends both on the user class @xmath2 and slot class @xmath9 , and is set to be equal to : @xmath59 i.e. , @xmath58 is equal to the expected fraction of transmissions of class @xmath2 users taking place in class @xmath9 slots , see section [ sec : model ] and eq . .
the length of the contention period @xmath7 is not a priori set , and it lasts until a predefined criterion is satisfied ; the termination criterion could be related to maximization / optimization of the fraction of resolved users and/or throughput .
we note that the proposed access method was inspired by the encoding of rateless codes @xcite .
however , in contrast to the standard rateless coding , neither input _ nor _ output distributions can be directly controlled in the random access framework .
it is straightforward to show that in this case the probability that the degree of user @xmath19 with respect to class @xmath9 is @xmath20 , is : @xmath60 further , it could be shown that the node - oriented and edge - oriented degree distributions of @xmath19 with respect to @xmath9 are : @xmath61 the substitution of and into instantiates the theorem for the proposed random access method .
0.95 0.95 0.95 we apply the derived asymptotic analysis to the example consisting of the following scenarios : ( 1 ) single user class and packet - loss probability @xmath62 , ( 2 ) single user class and @xmath63 , and ( 3 ) two user classes , equal fractions of user belonging to each class , i.e. , @xmath64 and @xmath65 , and @xmath66 and @xmath67 . in all cases we assume a single slot class ; therefore , for scenarios ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and for scenario ( 3 ) @xmath70 ( henceforth , we omit the subscripts corresponding to the user and slot classes when they are not required ) . our aim is to find parameters @xmath71 that asymptotically maximize the expected throughput .
[ fig : example ] depicts maximal expected throughput @xmath72 and corresponding maximal probability of resolution @xmath73 and optimal expected slot degree @xmath74 , as functions of the ratio of the number of slots vs number of users @xmath75 . in other words ,
[ fig : beta ] shows what is the optimal @xmath74 that yields maximal @xmath73 and @xmath72 in figs .
[ fig : pr ] and [ fig : t ] , for each value of @xmath75 .
comparison of the results for scenarios ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) reveals that , asymptotically , the overall maximal expected throughputs are @xmath76 and @xmath77 , respectively ; the corresponding lengths of the contention period are @xmath78 and @xmath79 slots , while @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
these results are in line with a general reasoning that @xmath82 , while @xmath73 and @xmath74 should be the same .
further , the results corresponding to scenario ( 3 ) show that @xmath83 , which is obtained for @xmath84 , @xmath85 and @xmath86 . in other words , with respect to throughput maximization ,
the best strategy is to allow contention only among users with lower packet - loss probabilities ( i.e. , better channel conditions ) and to silence the rest ; this conclusion is also in line with expectations . following this insight
, it could be shown that @xmath87 and that @xmath88 . on the other hand ,
if one aims to attain the overall high probability of user resolution @xmath89 , which includes users belonging to the second class as well , this comes at the expense of lower expected throughput .
as @xmath89 increases and reaches @xmath90 , @xmath91 increases , but always remains lower than @xmath92 .
at the same time , @xmath93 tends to @xmath94 , as now the average packet - loss probability of scenario ( 3 ) tends to packet - loss probability of scenario ( 2 ) .
the presented analysis could be generally applied for the case when there is no power control , and its results used for a broader category of optimization problems , apart from the demonstrated throughput maximization . for instance , one could further subdivide the users into classes with respect to the importance of their messages , and , following the presented methodology , derive and analyze the performance of the user access strategy . finally , we note that further generalizations of the and - or tree evaluation could include the impacts of imperfect sic and capture effect , as outlined in @xcite .
the research presented in this paper was partly supported by the danish council for independent research ( det frie forskningsrd ) within the sapere aude research leader program , grant no .
11 - 105159 `` dependable wireless bits for machine - to - machine ( m2 m ) communications '' and performed partly in the framework of the fp7 project ict-317669 metis , which is partly funded by the european union .
the authors would like to acknowledge the contributions of their colleagues in metis , although the views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the project .
e. cassini , r. d. gaudenzi , and o. del rio herrero , `` contention resolution diversity slotted aloha ( crdsa ) : an enhanced random access scheme for satellite access packet networks , '' _ ieee trans .
wireless commun .
_ , vol . 6 , no . 4 , pp . 14081419 , apr
. 2007 .
d. sejdinovic , d. vukobratovic , a. doufexi , v. senk , and r. j. piechocki , `` expanding window fountain codes for unequal error protection , '' _ ieee trans .
_ , vol .
57 , no . 9 , pp . 15281540 ,
september 2009 . | the recent research has established an analogy between successive interference cancellation in slotted aloha framework and iterative belief - propagation erasure - decoding , which has opened the possibility to enhance random access protocols by utilizing theory and tools of erasure - correcting codes . in this paper
we present a generalization of the and - or tree evaluation , adapted for the asymptotic analysis of the slotted aloha - based random - access protocols , for the case when the contending users experience different channel conditions , resulting in packet loss probability that varies across users .
we apply the analysis to the example of frameless aloha , where users contend on a slot basis .
we present results regarding the optimal access probabilities and contention period lengths , such that the throughput and probability of user resolution are maximized . |
frustration in the antiferromagnetic ( afm ) ordering of fcc and spinel lattices was recognized long ago by anderson in his analysis of the highly degenerate magnetic ground state of these structures.@xcite this so - called @xmath26 frustration can prevent the system from undergoing spin - glass ( sg ) or afm ordering down to temperatures much lower than the curie - weiss temperature , @xmath27,@xmath28 .
it has also been shown , theoretically @xcite and experimentally , @xcite that the ground state degeneracy can be removed by atomic disorder leading to a sg type of ordering .
the afm @xmath5 spinel zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 structure , in which the octahedral cr sites form corner - sharing tetrahedra , @xcite as well as the pyrochlore @xcite@xmath29@xcite and kagom@xcite structures , are excellent systems to study the _ geometric _ frustration phenomenon .
zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 has a very high curie - weiss temperature , @xmath30 k , and a first order afm transition at @xmath31 @xmath32 k @xcite accompanied by a slight tetragonal crystal distortion ( @xmath33 ) .
@xcite besides , recent interesting low-@xmath0 neutron diffraction experiments showed , in the ordered phase ( @xmath24 ) , the existence of a near dispersionless excitation at @xmath23 mev , and for @xmath34 , a continuous magnetic gapless density of states.@xcite in this work we report on the @xmath0-dependence ( @xmath1 - @xmath2 k ) of the electron paramagnetic resonance ( epr ) , magnetic susceptibility , @xmath3 , and specific heat , @xmath4 , in a single crystal of the @xmath5 spinel zncr@xmath35o@xmath7 of cubic structure ( @xmath36 , o@xmath37 ) and in the cd doped polycrystalline zn@xmath8cd@xmath9cr@xmath6o@xmath7 ( @xmath10 ) compounds .
a polycrystalline isomorphous compound of znga@xmath6o@xmath7 was also used as a reference compound for the specific heat measurements .
single crystals of zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 of typical size of @xmath382x2x2 mm@xmath39 were obtained by the method of solid state reaction between stoichiometric amounts of cr@xmath6o@xmath40 and zno in air.@xcite the crystals show natural growing ( 001 ) , ( 111 ) , and ( 011 ) faces that were checked by the usual laue method .
polycrystalline cd doped zn@xmath8cd@xmath9cr@xmath6o@xmath7 ( @xmath41 ) and znga@xmath6o@xmath7 samples were prepared by the same method .
the epr experiments were carried out in a conventional elexsys bruker x - band epr spectrometers using a te@xmath42 room temperature cavity .
the sample temperature was varied by a temperature controller using helium and nitrogen gas flux systems .
this set up assures one that the spectrometer sensitivity remains about the same over a wide range of @xmath0 .
magnetization measurements have been taken in a quantum design @xmath43 squid mpms-5 t magnetometer .
the specific heat was measured using the heat pulse method in a quantum design calorimeter using the qd - ppms-9 t measurement system .
for the zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 single crystal , as the temperature is lowered from room-@xmath0 , the epr line broadens and its intensity goes through a maximum at about @xmath16 k with no measurable resonance shift .
figure 1 shows the @xmath0-evolution of the epr spectra between @xmath44 k and @xmath45 k. for @xmath46 k the resonance distorts and small resonances modes emerge at low-@xmath0 .
these modes do not depend on whether the epr spectra are taken under field cooling ( fc ) or zero field cooling ( zfc ) conditions .
but , they depend on the size and shape of the sample and show a slight orientation dependence ( see inset ) . for @xmath47
k the epr spectra show a single isotropic resonance . for the cd doped samples the resonance also broadens , but the intensity increases down to @xmath48 k ( see below ) where , again , the resonance distorts and small resonance modes are seen
. these modes also show the same spectra under fc and zfc conditions .
figure 2 shows the @xmath0-dependence of the linewidth , @xmath49 , and @xmath15-value between @xmath50 k and @xmath2 k for the crystal of figure 1 .
the linewidth broadens at low-@xmath0 , the @xmath15-value is @xmath0-independent and its value , @xmath15 @xmath51 @xmath52 , corresponds to that of cr@xmath18 ( @xmath53 , s @xmath19 ) ions @xmath15-value in a cubic site .
@xcite@xmath54@xcite both , the @xmath15-value and linewidth are isotropic for @xmath55 @xmath56 k. for the cd doped samples similar resonance line broadening and @xmath15-values are obtained ( not shown ) .
figure 3 presents the @xmath43 magnetic susceptibility , @xmath3 , corrected by the host diamagnetism in the range between @xmath1 k and @xmath2 k for the same crystal of figure 1 .
fc and zfc measurements at @xmath57 @xmath58 koe and @xmath59 koe gave no difference for the susceptibility data . at low field @xmath3
shows the typical 3d afm ordering with @xmath60 @xmath61 @xmath45 k ) .
the inset shows the sharp drop of the susceptibility at @xmath0 @xmath62 k. this temperature defines the nel temperature , @xmath63 , for the 3d long range afm ordering in zncr@xmath64o@xmath65 .
the inset shows that , for @xmath66 , the susceptibility is field dependent , @xmath67 .
this has been attributed to domain wall movement in the afm ordered state .
@xcite figure 4 compares the magnetic susceptibility of the zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 single crystal of figure 3 with those of the polycrystalline zn@xmath8cd@xmath68cr@xmath6o@xmath7 ( @xmath10 ) samples . for @xmath55 @xmath69
k the data for the three compounds can be fitted to the usual curie - weiss law .
the linear fit yields to an effective number of bohr magnetons @xmath70 @xmath71 @xmath72 , as expected for cr@xmath18 ( @xmath15 @xmath73 , s @xmath19 ) , and a curie - weiss temperature , @xmath74 @xmath75 k for zncr@xmath6o@xmath76 . in a molecular field approximation @xmath74 @xmath51 s(s+1 ) @xmath77 . for s
@xmath19 , @xmath78 @xmath79 ( nearest - neighbors ) , and @xmath74 @xmath80 k we obtain @xmath81 @xmath82 k. the curie - weiss parameters for the zn@xmath8cd@xmath9cr@xmath6o@xmath7 ( @xmath10 ) samples are given in table i. for @xmath83 @xmath69 k figure 4 shows , however , that there is a significant difference between the pure and cd doped compounds .
low ( high ) field zfc - fc measurements show , in the cd doped samples , the typical sg irreversibility ( reversibility ) for @xmath84 k ( see inset of figure 4 ) .
these results and the large values found for @xmath85 @xmath86 ( see table i ) , clearly indicate that the cd doped samples develop a highly frustrated sg - type behavior with @xmath87 k. figure 5 presents the @xmath0-dependence of the resonance intensity , @xmath88 , for the zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 single crystal and the polycrystalline zn@xmath8cd@xmath68cr@xmath6o@xmath7 ( @xmath10 ) samples . using an epr standard
, we found that the intensity of the resonance at room-@xmath0 , @xmath89 k ) , corresponds to the total amount of cr@xmath18 ions present in the samples .
similar to the susceptibility data shown in figure 4 , here also we observe two @xmath0-regimes , above and below @xmath90 @xmath69 k. for @xmath83 @xmath69 k @xmath88 shows significant difference between the pure and cd doped compounds . for the cd doped samples we found that @xmath88 and @xmath3 correlate well above @xmath87 k ( not shown ) ; however , for the pure sample this correlation is only observed for @xmath55 @xmath69 k ( see inset in figure 5 ) .
figure 6 presents the @xmath0-dependence of the specific heat , @xmath4 , for the zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 single crystal , the polycrystalline zn@xmath8cd@xmath9cr@xmath6o@xmath7 ( @xmath10 ) samples , and the reference compound znga@xmath91o@xmath7 .
the inset show the strong effect that the cd impurities have on the afm transition of the pure compound zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 .
the large reduction in the peak of the @xmath4 confirms the assignment of sg character for the transition observed at @xmath92 k in the susceptibility data for the cd doped samples .
the transition temperatures , @xmath93 and @xmath94 , are in fairly good agreement with those extracted from the susceptibility data ( see inset in figure 4 ) .
fields up to @xmath95 t , within the data resolution , did not affect @xmath4 and the afm and sg transitions temperatures .
the above epr and magnetic susceptibility results show that the cubic @xmath96 spinel zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 and zn@xmath8cd@xmath9cr@xmath6o@xmath7 ( @xmath41 ) compounds present interesting magnetic behavior between @xmath1 k and @xmath2 k. a high-@xmath0 paramagnetic phase ( htpp ) , @xmath55 @xmath69 k for zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 and @xmath55 @xmath32 k for the cd doped samples , and a low-@xmath0 ordered phase ( ltop ) , @xmath83 @xmath32 k , afm for the pure and sg for the doped compounds . for zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 , a transition between these two regimes is observed in the interval between @xmath32 k and @xmath69 k. our high-@xmath0 epr results are in general agreement with those already reported for polycrystalline samples .
@xcite@xmath29@xcite however , the low-@xmath0 epr data for our zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 single crystal are quite different from those reported in ref . 12 . as the temperature decreases in the htpp , the cr@xmath97 magnetic moments experience short range afm correlations .
the evidence for it is that , for @xmath55 @xmath98 , the epr resonance shows no @xmath15-shift and a @xmath0-dependence of the line broadening expected for a short range magnetic interaction in afm materials above the nel temperature @xmath94 : @xcite @xmath99^{x } } \label{1}\ ] ] the solid line in fig .
2 shows the fitting of the data to eq .
the fitting parameters are : @xmath100 , @xmath94 @xmath62 k , @xmath101 @xmath102 oe , and @xmath103 @xmath104 oe k@xmath105 .
we should mention that , for @xmath106 , recent neutron diffraction measurements found a continuous gapless spectrum that was attributed to quantum critical fluctuations of small short range afm correlated domains.@xcite in the htpp of zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 , and for @xmath55 @xmath69 k , @xmath3 and @xmath88 follow the same @xmath0-dependence ( see inset in fig .
5 ) , indicating that all the cr@xmath97 ions that contribute to @xmath3 also participate in @xmath88 .
however , for @xmath83 @xmath69 k , @xmath3 deviates from @xmath88 , and they show maximums at @xmath90 @xmath107 k and @xmath90 @xmath69 k , respectively ( see inset in fig .
the maximum in @xmath3 is caused by afm correlations and indicates the onset of long range afm ordering .
instead , the maximum in @xmath88 can be interpreted as transitions within thermally populated exited states .
the observation of epr resonances in exited state levels of nearest - neighbor cr@xmath18 spin - coupled pairs diluted in the spinel znga@xmath6o@xmath7 has been reported by henning et .
@xcite these authors were able to determine , from the observed @xmath88 , the energy separation between the first exited triplet state ( s @xmath108 ) and the ground singlet state ( s @xmath109 ) to be @xmath110 @xmath111 k. also , from the optical spectra of the cr@xmath18 spin - coupled pairs in znga@xmath6o@xmath7 a value of @xmath112 @xmath111 k was measured for @xmath113 .
@xcite within the same scenario and taking into account the thermal population of all the exited states for the cr@xmath18 spin - coupled pairs ( @xmath114 - @xmath115 ; 3 , 2 , 1 , and 0 ; @xmath116 @xmath19 ) , the expected @xmath0-dependence of the total epr intensity , @xmath88 , in the three exited states levels at energies @xmath117 @xmath118 , and @xmath119 above the singlet ground state is given by:@xcite @xmath120 /z\ ] ] where @xmath121 is the partition function , the coefficients @xmath122 , @xmath123 , and @xmath124 are adjustable parameters proportional to the transition probability within each excited multiplet .
the solid line in the inset of the figure 4 shows the @xmath0-dependence given by eq . 2 for @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 and @xmath128 @xmath129 k. the value found for @xmath113 is larger than the one ( @xmath112 @xmath111 k ) found for isolated cr@xmath18 spin - coupled pairs in znga@xmath6o@xmath7.@xcite this difference is probably due to the different lattice parameters of zncr@xmath35o@xmath7 ( @xmath130 @xmath131 ) in znga@xmath6o@xmath7 ( @xmath130 @xmath132 ) .
@xcite nevertheless , the value is in good agreement with that extracted from the curie - weiss temperature , @xmath74 , ( see above ) .
as we pointed out elsewhere @xcite , one can also attribute the difference between the temperature dependence of the susceptibility and the epr intensity to the presence of non resonant low frequency modes that contribute spectral weight to the kramers kronig integral for the static susceptibility , @xmath133 but do not participate in the epr absorption .
it is likely that such modes are seen in inelastic neutron scattering above @xmath63@xcite .
the fact that the susceptibility and the epr intensity have a common temperature variation in the cd
doped samples suggests that the non resonant , low frequency modes , if present , are not making a significant contribution to the susceptibility integral .
figure 7 shows the @xmath134 plots obtained from the data of figure 6 for each studied sample . the contribution from the magnetic component
is obtained from the difference with the data for the non magnetic reference compound znga@xmath6o@xmath7 .
the entropy , @xmath135 , is obtained integrating these differences and gives approximately the multiplicity of the involved levels , @xmath112 @xmath136 . within the same scenario of cr@xmath18 spin - coupled pairs , the schottky anomaly for the spin - coupled pairs
is given by : @xmath137\ ] ] figure 8 shows the fitting of the data to eq .
the obtained value for @xmath138 @xmath139 k suggests the scheme of levels shown in figure 8 .
the value found for @xmath113 is consistent with those values obtained independently from the curie - weiss temperature , @xmath74 , and epr intensity measurements in the htpp ( see above ) . in the ltop
our epr experiments show the appearance of small resonance modes ( see figure 1 for @xmath83 @xmath140 k ) .
we believe that their sample size and shape dependence and angular variation are , probably , more related to demagnetizing effects rather than to the tetragonal crystal distortion observed at @xmath48 k.@xcite besides , for @xmath24 the magnetic susceptibility increases at higher fields ( see inset of figure 3 ) and also , a small increase is oberved for @xmath83 @xmath141 k ( see figure 3 ) .
these behaviors are similar to those observed in magnetization measurements of polycrystalline samples of zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 and they have been attributed to the presence of afm domains in the ltop.@xcite thus , we associate our resonance modes with afm domains that might be present in these materials as a consequence of their highly frustrated 3d long range afm magnetic structure .
in conclusion , our epr and @xmath3 results in the @xmath5 spinel zncr@xmath35o@xmath7 show , between @xmath32 k and @xmath69 k , a transition from a long to a short range regime of afm correlations ( ltop - htpp ) . from the @xmath0-dependence of the epr intensity in the htpp an exchange parameter of @xmath81 @xmath142 k between the cr@xmath18 ( s @xmath19 ) spin - coupled pairs was extracted .
this value is close to the one obtained independently from the curie - weiss temperature , @xmath74 , and from the schottky anomaly observed in the specific heat .
thus , the magnetic properties of these strongly frustrated systems in the htpp can be described within a scenario involving just spin - coupling pairs of cr@xmath18 ( s @xmath19 ) . the sharp drop in @xmath3 at @xmath90 @xmath32
k , the peak in @xmath4 also at @xmath90 @xmath32 k , and the ordering temperature extracted from the broadening of the epr linewidth ( @xmath31 @xmath32 k ) confirmed the afm ordering at @xmath90 @xmath32 k in zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 .
the resonance modes observed in the ltop and the field dependent susceptibility , @xmath67 , indicates the presence of afm domains in this material .
finally , we found that the disorder caused by the cd impurities in zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 drives the system from an afm to a sg type of highly frustrated magnetic ordering .
although a model based on isolated pairs can account for many of the magnetic properties of zncr@xmath64o@xmath65 , it does not include the interaction of the pairs with the surrounding ions .
a widely used pair model that does include the effects of the interaction with neighboring spins is the constant coupling approximation @xcite .
however , this model does not exploit the unique tetrahedral character of the cr sublattice in zncr@xmath64o@xmath65 .
in particular , it predicts the same susceptibility for zncr@xmath64o@xmath65 as found in an unfrustrated simple cubic antiferromagnet , which has the same number of nearest neighbor interactions ( 6 ) and exhibits a conventional afm transition . this contradiction has led two of us ( ajga and dlh ) to develop a quantum tetrahedral mean field model @xcite . in this model , the energy levels of a four spin tetrahedral cluster
are calculated exactly and the interaction with the neighboring ions is treated in the mean field approximation .
good agreement with the susceptibility and the magnetic specific heat are obtained with nearest neighbor interaction , @xmath143
k , and next neighbor interaction , @xmath144 k@xcite .
this work was supported by fapesp grants no 95/4721 - 4 , 96/4625 - 8 , 97/03065 - 1 , and 97/11563 - 1 so paulo - sp - brazil , and nsf - dmr no 9705155 , and nsf - int no 9602928 .
ajga wants to thank the spanish mec for financial support under the subprograma general de formacin de personal investigador en el extranjero .
f. hartmann - boutron , a. gerard , p. imbert , r. kleibergerard , and f. varret , comptes rendus de l academie des sciences paris , serie ii fascicule b * 268 * , 906 ( 1969 ) ; s .- h .
lee , c. broholm , t.h .
kim , w. rotcliff , s .- w .
cheong , and q. huang , unpublished ; h. martinho , n.o .
moreno , j.a .
sanjuro , c. rettori , a.j .
adeva , d.l .
huber , s.b .
oseroff , w. ratcliff , ii , s .- w .
cheong , p.g .
pagliuso , j.l .
sarrao , and g.b .
martins , paper dh-08 , 8th joint mmm - intermag conference , san antonio , jan . | the @xmath0-dependence ( @xmath1- @xmath2 k ) of the electron paramagnetic resonance ( epr ) , magnetic susceptibility , @xmath3 , and specific heat , @xmath4 , of the @xmath5 antiferromagnetic ( afm ) spinel zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 and the spin - glass ( sg ) zn@xmath8cd@xmath9cr@xmath6o@xmath7 ( @xmath10 ) is reported .
these systems behave as a strongly frustrated afm and sg with @xmath11 @xmath12 k and @xmath13 k @xmath14 k. at high-@xmath0 the epr intensity follows the @xmath3 and the @xmath15-value is @xmath0-independent .
the linewidth broadens as the temperature is lowered , suggesting the existence of short range afm correlations in the paramagnetic phase . for zncr@xmath6o@xmath7 the epr intensity and @xmath3 decreases below @xmath16 k and @xmath17 k , respectively .
these results are discussed in terms of nearest - neighbor cr@xmath18 ( s @xmath19 ) spin - coupled pairs with an exchange coupling of @xmath20 @xmath17 k. the appearance of small resonance modes for @xmath21 k , the observation of a sharp drop in @xmath3 and a strong peak in @xmath4 at @xmath22 k confirms , as previously reported , the existence of long range afm correlations in the low-@xmath0 phase .
a comparison with recent neutron diffraction experiments that found a near dispersionless excitation at @xmath23 mev for @xmath24 and a continuous gapless spectrum for @xmath25 , is also given . |
the fast winds from massive stars and their subsequent supernovae ( sne ) ejecta dominate the mass and energy input to the interstellar medium ( ism ; e.g. , abbott 1982 ) and so may regulate star formation and galaxy evolution .
most massive stars form in ob associations , and the concentrated energy input from massive stars in ob associations sweeps up the ambient ism to form expanding shells called superbubbles ( e.g. , mccray & snow 1979 ) .
the physical structure of a superbubble is very similar to that of a bubble blown by the stellar wind of an isolated massive star @xcite .
however , theories of such bubbles are still very uncertain and have not had much serious appraisal with observations of high quality .
studies of galactic superbubbles are difficult because of their large angular sizes and the confusion of objects in the line of sight .
the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) , in contrast , provides an excellent laboratory to study superbubbles since it is nearby ( at a distance of @xmath20 kpc , as adopted here , @xmath21 pc ; eastman & kirshner 1989 ) and almost face - on ( inclined by @xmath22 to the line of sight ; van der marel & cioni 2001 ) .
it also has little foreground ( @xmath23 ; xu et al . 1992 ) or internal extinction ( @xmath24 in the range from @xmath25 to @xmath26 ; bessel 1991 ) .
the superbubble 30 dor c (= dem l 263 ; davies , elliott , & meaburn 1976 ) is southwest of the main 30 doradus complex in the lmc , and is coincident with the large ob association lh 90 (= ngc 2044 ; lucke & hodge 1970 ) .
this ob association consists of a number of stellar clusters and is particularly rich in wolf - rayet ( w - r ) stars @xcite .
the most massive stars appear to have ages in the range from @xmath27 to @xmath28 myr ( testor , schild , & lortet 1993 ) . in x - ray imaging observations ,
30 dor c appears almost as a complete shell with a diameter of @xmath29 ( wang & helfand 1991 ; dennerl et al .
2001 ; dunne , points , & chu 2001 ) .
the x - ray shell is confined within the h@xmath17-emitting filaments ( see fig .
1__l _ _ of dunne et al . 2001 ) , as expected from the evaporation of cool gas into the hot interior of a superbubble .
there is also an indication for a substantial nonthermal contribution in addition to an assumed one - temperature thermal component , particularly in the western part of shell @xcite .
the radio emission from 30 dor c may be due to a combination of synchrotron - emitting relativistic electrons produced by shocks within the superbubble and thermal emission from the h@xmath17-emitting shell @xcite . in this paper , we report on a spatially resolved spectroscopic analysis with _ xmm - newton _ of the diffuse x - ray emission emanating from 30 dor c. we specifically use the wind - blown bubble model of weaver et al .
( 1977 ; see also mac low & mccray 1988 ) to infer the temperature and density structure of the x - ray emitting gas , which in turn are used to estimate both the density of the ambient medium and the rate at which energy is injected into the ism by the stellar winds .
the region surrounding 30 dor c is known to be rich in x - ray sources and was chosen as the first light image for _ xmm - newton _ @xcite .
however , data acquired this early in the mission are in a format which can not be processed by the science survey center using the standard software and so are not included in the _ xmm - newton _ archive at the time of writing .
the data reported here were instead acquired during @xmath30 and @xmath31 ks observations of sn 1987a and psr j0537 - 6909 with _ xmm - newton _ on 2000 november 25 - 26 ( observation i d 0104660301 ;
pi : watson ) and 2001 november 19 - 20 ( observation i d 0113020201 ; pi : aschenbach ) , respectively .
these observations had a low background count rate and were pointed @xmath32 ( 0104660301 ) and @xmath33 ( 0113020201 ) offset from the center of the 30 dor c. while there are other observations that covered 30 dor c in the _ xmm - newton _ archive , these observations are either severely contaminated by background flares ( observational i d 0083250101 ) or had a very short good exposure time ( e.g. , @xmath34 ks for observation 0104660101 ; pi : watson ) .
the epic mos cameras @xcite were operated in the full - frame mode with the medium filter inserted . over the time interval between the two observations ,
the energy resolution of mos ccds had worsened , from @xmath35 ev to @xmath36 ev ( fwhm ) at @xmath37 kev , due to radiation damage .
these values are actually worse than the initial post - launch value of @xmath38 ev .
the on - axis telescope point spread function is @xmath39 ( fwhm ) at 1.5 kev and the field - of - view is roughly circular with a diameter of @xmath40 .
unfortunately , the epic pn exposure of the first observation was taken with the calibration lamps switched on , so rendering the data useless for scientific analysis , and the pn was operated in the timing mode during the second observation , so providing no imaging data . the data reduction and analysis were done using the xmm - newton science analysis software ( sas ) version 5.4.1 ( released on 2003 january 16 ) .
the mos data were reprocessed into calibrated event list files using the sas program _
emchain_. the procedure of @xcite was used to filter each event list for periods of high background .
we created lightcurves in the 1015 kev energy range , where no source counts are expected due to the very low effective area of the x - ray telescope , and using only single pixel events and flag values as defined by # xmmea_em .
periods when the count rate in these lightcurves exceeded @xmath41 counts s@xmath8 were excluded from the event files .
the event lists were then filtered further , keeping only single , double , triple , and quadruple pixel events in the @xmath42@xmath43 kev energy range . for the first observation , the total good exposure time was @xmath44 ks , and for the second observation , the mos1 and mos2 ccds had total good exposure times of @xmath45 ks and @xmath46 ks , respectively .
we also checked for soft proton flares in the @xmath47@xmath48 kev band , but found none .
the interstellar extinction ( @xmath24 ) towards the western part of 30 dor c is known to be higher by at least @xmath49 than that towards the eastern part ( testor et al .
1993 ; see also dunne et al .
2001 and fig . 5 of dennerl et al .
we therefore extracted spectra from two sectors of an ellipse centered on 30 dor c with major - axis diameter of @xmath50 ( @xmath51 pc ) and major - to - minor axis ratio of @xmath52 .
the regions are marked in figure [ fig1 ] , which is an image of the central region of the 30 dor c field ( see [ sec - morphology ] for a description of x - ray sources in this image ) .
the shape and size of the extraction regions were chosen to include as much of the diffuse emission from the superbubble as possible , while minimizing the contribution from the background .
the background was estimated from source free regions near the superbubble ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ) .
there are spatial variations in the detector background rate , which can be estimated from a comparison of blank - field spectra in the source and source free regions of the 30 dor c observations . for this comparison ,
we have used blank - field observations with a total exposure of @xmath53 ks and @xmath54 ks for the mos1 and mos2 detectors , respectively @xcite .
these data , taken with the same instrument mode and filter combination as the 30 dor c observations , had point sources of emission excised , and were reprojected on the sky to match the positions of the 30 dor c observations .
we find that for the first observation , the mos1 blank - field spectra in the source free region and in the eastern part of 30 dor c are statistically consistent ( within @xmath55 deviation ) with each other in the @xmath56@xmath11 kev band , with @xmath57 ( 497 dof ) . however , for the same observation , a comparison of the mos2 blank - field spectra in the source free region and in the eastern part of 30 dor c revealed significant differences in the background count rate near the energy of the si k@xmath17 ( @xmath58 kev ) fluorescence line .
we therefore compared the mos2 blank - field spectra in the @xmath56@xmath59 and @xmath60@xmath11 kev band , and find that the spectra are consistent with each other , with @xmath61 ( 466 dof ) .
there are also , for the first observation , and near the energies of the al k@xmath17 ( 1.5 kev ) and the si k@xmath17 fluorescence lines , significant differences in the background count rate between the blank - field spectra in the source free region and the blank - field spectra in the western part of 30 dor c. in the @xmath56@xmath62 and @xmath60@xmath11 kev band , however , the blank - field spectra in the source free region are statistically consistent with the blank - field spectra in the western part of 30 dor c , with @xmath63 ( 449 dof ) and @xmath64 ( 430 dof ) for the mos1 and mos2 detectors , respectively
. similarly , for the second observation , and near the energy of the si k@xmath17 fluorescence line , we find that there are significant differences in the background count rate near between the blank - field spectra in the source free region and the blank - field spectra in the eastern part of 30 dor c. in the @xmath56@xmath59 and @xmath60@xmath11 kev band , however , the blank - field spectra are consistent with each other , with @xmath65 ( 464 dof ) and @xmath66 ( 476 dof ) for the mos1 and mos2 detectors , respectively .
there are also , for the same observation , and near the energies of the al k@xmath17 and si k@xmath17 fluorescence lines , significant differences in the background count rate between the blank - field spectra in the source free region and the blank - field spectra in the western part of 30 dor c. we therefore compared the blank - field spectra in the @xmath56@xmath62 and @xmath60@xmath11 kev band , and find that the mos1 and mos2 blank - field spectra in the source free region should be scaled by @xmath67 and @xmath68 , respectively , in order to match the blank - field spectra in the western part of 30 dor c. the rescaled spectra are statistically consistent with the blank - field spectra in the western part of 30 dor c , with @xmath69 ( 478 dof ) and @xmath70 ( 468 dof ) for the mos1 and mos2 detectors , respectively .
we therefore excluded data in the @xmath59@xmath60 kev band from the mos2 spectra of the diffuse emission in the eastern part of 30 dor c and data in the @xmath62@xmath60 kev band from the spectra of the diffuse emission in the western part of 30 dor c. for the second observation , we also excluded data in the @xmath59@xmath60 from the mos1 spectrum of the diffuse emission in the eastern part of 30 dor c. we created spectral redistribution matrices and ancilliary response files for the source spectra using the sas programs _ rmfgen _ and _ arfgen _ , respectively .
the ancilliary response file appropriate for each source spectrum was created weighting the position - dependent quantum efficiency and effective area by the number of @xmath56@xmath11 kev blank - field background subtracted counts in the corresponding region .
prior to performing the spectral analysis with xspec version 11.2.0au @xcite , we rebinned the data so that the background subtracted signal - to - noise ratio in each bin is greater than @xmath71 . when performing the spectral analysis , we excluded data with energies greater than @xmath11 kev , since the background dominates the total emission from 30 dor c at energies greater than this .
we also excluded data with energies less than @xmath56 kev , because of the uncertainties in the calibration of the instruments .
figure 1 shows the _ xmm - newton _ image of the @xmath72 ( @xmath73 ) region centered on 30 dor c in the @xmath56@xmath48 kev band . in this image ,
30 dor c is a roughly elliptical feature with major axis @xmath74 ( @xmath75 pc ) .
this feature appears to be the observational manifestation of a bubble blown in the ism by the winds from massive stars in the bubble s interior @xcite .
other sources of x - ray emission in figure [ fig1 ] include sn 1987a , which is located @xmath76 southwest of the bubble center and close to a region of diffuse x - ray emission associated with the honeycomb nebula @xcite .
there is also a compact x - ray source , j0536.9 - 6913 , to the east of 30 dor c , which has a radio counterpart and is probably a background agn @xcite .
the bright source at the left of the image is the crab - like supernova remnant n157b @xcite . in figure
[ fig2 ] , we compare an h@xmath17 emission - line image from university of michigan / ctio magellanic cloud emission - line survey ( mcels ; smith et al .
1998 ) to an adaptively smoothed image of the inner @xmath77 region of the 30 dor c field in the @xmath56@xmath48 kev band .
the edge - brightened x - ray emission is presumably due to an increase in gas density around the edge of the bubble , and is spatially enclosed by the h@xmath17-emitting filaments .
it is conceivable that the increase in gas density is due to the evaporation of cool ( @xmath78 k ) gas into the hot interior from the surrounding h@xmath17-emitting shell @xcite .
we also show adaptively smoothed images of the central @xmath79 region of the 30 dor c field in the soft ( @xmath56@xmath80 kev ) , medium ( @xmath80@xmath47 kev ) , and hard ( @xmath47@xmath48 kev ) bands ( fig .
[ fig3 ] ) . in these images
, there is evidence for spectral variations in the x - ray emission across the face of the bubble . while the western part of the bubble is easily seen in the medium and hard band images , it is almost invisible in the soft band image , clearly due to the x - ray absorption by foreground cool gas ( see also dennerl et al .
2001 and dunne et al .
there is a region of localized co emission projected onto the western part of 30 dor c @xcite . assuming a @xmath81co(1 - 0 ) intensity of @xmath82 k km s@xmath8 for the cloud ( see table 3 of johansson et al . 1998 ) and a co to @xmath83 conversion factor of @xmath84 for the lmc @xcite , we estimate an @xmath83 column density of @xmath85 towards the western part of 30 dor c. this absorption column density is sufficient to absorb the soft x - ray emission from the western part of bubble .
intriguingly , in the hard band image , the western part of the bubble appears much brighter than the eastern part , and is presumably more luminous .
finally , we note that j0536.9 - 6913 is almost invisible in the soft band image , due to either absorption by gas in the lmc or absorption intrinsic to the source .
this source also went undetected in the pspc observations reported by @xcite , which would require either an increase in the absorption column density towards the source or a decrease in the intensity of the source . in earlier studies of 30 dor c with _
einstein _ and _ rosat _ , the x - ray luminosity expected from the stellar wind - blown bubble model of @xcite was often compared with that derived from spectral fits to the data using a single temperature thermal plasma model ( e.g. , dunne et al .
the main disadvantage of this approach is that the data are not directly compared to the model and so any test of the model will depend on the measurements used to derive the expected x - ray luminosity of the bubble ( e.g. , the number density and expansion velocity of the h ii region ) .
also , the wide range of gas temperatures inside the bubble gives rise to soft x - ray emission in excess of that expected from a single temperature plasma model and emission lines from a wider range of ionization states than those expected from a single temperature thermal plasma model , which will naturally result in an underestimate of the heavy element abundances .
the shortfall in the soft x - ray emission below @xmath86 kev from the single temperature thermal plasma model can also lead to an underestimate of the absorption column density , and hence the soft x - ray luminosity . in a more sophisticated analysis of 30 dor c with the _ einstein _ data ,
@xcite compared the ipc spectrum with that expected from integrating the model over the bubble interior and folding the result through the ipc response . however , with the limited quality of the ipc data , they were unable to constrain tightly the basic spectral parameters such as temperature and absorption column density , let alone to test other interesting parameters such as the efficiency of thermal conduction and metal abundance of the x - ray emitting gas . in a more recent analysis of the _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ data , @xcite discovered nonthermal x - ray emission from 30 dor c , although the discovery was made using a single temperature , non - equilibrium , ionized plasma model to describe the thermal emission from the bubble .
here we have compared the x - ray spectra of 30 dor c directly with the stellar wind - blown bubble model of weaver et al .
( 1977 ; see also mac low & mccray 1988 ) by implementing it into the spectral analysis package xspec .
the x - ray emission in their model arises primarily from a region of thermally evaporated material ( see fig . 3 of weaver et al .
the temperature and density of the hot gas as a function of radius @xmath87 within this region can be approximated as @xmath88 and @xmath89 , respectively , where @xmath90 and @xmath91 are the corresponding central values , and @xmath92 is the outer radius of the bubble .
the x - ray flux , @xmath93 , expected from the bubble is @xmath94 \ ,
n(r)^{2 } \ , 4\pi r^{2 } dr \label{eqn - dem}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath95 is the mean emissivity of the hot gas in the x - rays and @xmath96 is the distance to the source .
we have calculated the x - ray spectrum with a multi - temperature , variable heavy element abundance mekal ( mewe , kaastra , & liedahl 1995 ) model , as implemented in xspec , using @xmath97 \ , { \rm d}t / t_{\rm c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the differential emission measure @xmath98 , which is a function of temperature .
$ ] is the normalization of the spectrum in xspec . in this form
, the model spectrum can be applied approximately to a slightly aspherical bubble of an equivalent volume @xmath100 .
the mos1 and mos2 spectra of the diffuse emission in the eastern and western parts of 30 dor c ( a total of 8 spectra ) were simultaneously fitted to the above wind - blown bubble model and a foreground absorption of a column density of @xmath101 .
the absorption cross - sections and atomic abundances were taken from @xcite and @xcite , respectively .
while the foreground absorption was allowed to be different between the eastern and western parts of 30 dor c , we constrained the bubble model to have the same temperature , metal abundance , and intensity in the eastern and western parts of 30 dor c. this model , which has 5 free parameters , gives a poor , simultaneous fit to the mos1 and mos2 data with @xmath102 ( 349 dof ) .
we also did not obtain a significant improvement in the fit when we allowed the normalization of the bubble model to be different between the mos1 and mos2 datasets .
an inspection of the spectra indicates that much of the deviation from the best - fit bubble model is due to an excess of hard x - rays in the spectra of the diffuse emission , particularly in the western part of 30 dor c. such an hard x - ray excess can naturally be explained as nonthermal x - ray emission , which can typically be described by a power - law .
we therefore added a power - law component of photon index @xmath103 to our model fits .
the normalization of the power - law continuum was allowed to vary between the eastern and western parts of 30 dor c , to account for the spatial variation in the hard x - ray emission ( fig [ fig3 ] ) . in our initial modeling of the data ,
the metal abundance was poorly constrained , with a lower limit of @xmath104 solar and an upper limit of several times solar .
we therefore fixed the metal abundance at the known mean value of @xmath105 solar for the ism in the lmc @xcite .
in comparison to the bubble model , this model ( model b+p ) gives a much improved , although still statistically unacceptable , simultaneous fit to the mos1 and mos2 data with @xmath106 ( @xmath107 dof ; table [ tbl-1 ] , column 2 ) .
the absorbed @xmath105@xmath11 kev flux in the western and eastern parts of 30 dor c are @xmath108 and @xmath109 erg s@xmath8 @xmath2 , respectively .
these fluxes are slightly larger than the fluxes reported in @xcite for their regions 14 , due to the differences in the sizes of the regions used for extracting spectra between the present work and @xcite .
we note that a marginal ( at greater than @xmath110% confidence a @xmath111 result ) improvement in the fit is obtained when we allowed the normalization of the bubble model to be different between the eastern and western parts of 30 dor c. the spectra of the diffuse x - ray emission in wind - blown bubbles have often been fitted to single temperature plasma models in collisional ionization equilibrium ( e.g. , dunne et al .
2001 ) , although with little physical justification . in order to compare with these earlier observations and analyses ,
we have replaced the bubble model with a single temperature mekal model .
we have also fixed the metal abundance of the mekal at @xmath105 solar , since it is poorly constrained by the data .
this model ( model m+p ) gives a similar quality fit to the data as the b+p model , with @xmath112 ( @xmath107 dof ; table [ tbl-1 ] , column 3 ) .
the best - fit equivalent hydrogen column densities and normalizations of the power - law continua are comparable to the values obtained from the fitting the data to the b+p model , and the best - fit temperature of the mekal is consistent with the value reported in @xcite for the thermal emission in their region 1 .
we have also considered the possibility that the hard x - ray excess in 30 dor c is attributable to a second thermal component that might be caused by a recent supernova explosion , for example .
we replaced the power - law component in the above m+p model with a second mekal model , with the metal abundances of the two mekals fixed at the same value of @xmath105 solar and the normalization of the high - temperature mekal allowed to vary between the eastern and western parts of 30 dor c. we find that this model provides a much worse fit to the data than do either the b+p or m+p models , with @xmath113 ( @xmath107 dof ) .
this is due to the data at high energies being much too flat compared to the model .
although a significant ( at greater than @xmath114% confidence ) improvement in the fit is obtained when we allowed the metal abundances of the two mekals to vary together , this model , with one extra free parameter , still provides a worse fit to the data than do either the b+p or m+p models , with @xmath115 ( @xmath116 dof ) .
moreover , the metal abundance of @xmath117 solar is uncomfortably small for the ism in the lmc .
more sophisticated models , such as the non - equilibrium , ionized ( nei ) plasma codes as implemented in xspec ( see e.g. , borkowski , lyerly , & reynolds 2001 for a detailed critique of these models ) , also gave poorer fits to the data than do either the b+p or m+p models .
we therefore conclude that the hard x - ray excess in 30 dor c is best described by a nonthermal emission component .
because 30 dor c is a massive star forming region with possible recent core - collapse supernovae occurring inside the bubble , we have further examined the data for an over - abundance of the @xmath17-process elements compared to fe - like elements .
we did this by dividing the elements into two groups : the @xmath17-process elements o , ne , mg , si , s , ar , and ca ; and the remaining fe - like elements c , n , na , al , fe , and ni . elements in each group were constrained to have the same abundance relative to solar .
the abundances of he and the fe - like elements were fixed at the solar and @xmath105 solar values , respectively , which are appropriate for the ism in the lmc @xcite .
this model ( model vb+p ) further improves the fit to the mos1 and mos2 data with @xmath118 ( @xmath116 dof ; table [ tbl-1 ] , column 3 ) .
for clarity , we show the co - added mos spectra from the eastern and western parts of the bubble , together with the residuals to this model fit ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ) .
there are some large residuals around the energies of the al k@xmath17 fluorescence line that arises from the detector housing and the au m - edge that arises from x - ray absorption in the telescope mirror surface . with the possible exception of si ,
the @xmath17-process elemental abundance of @xmath119 solar ( errors here and elsewhere in this paper are 90% confidence for one interesting parameter , @xmath120 ) is higher than that of the ism in the lmc @xcite .
there is no improvement ( at greater than 90% confidence ) in the fit when we allow the abundance of the fe - like elements to vary .
although the model spectrum can still be rejected statistically at @xmath121% confidence , we consider the fit to be reasonably good .
the model is certainly still an over - simplification .
for example , we have assumed that the normalization of the soft bubble component is the same for both the eastern and western parts of 30 dor c. this assumption is problematic , however , since the power - law components of the two parts are very different .
because of the heavy absorption , the data below @xmath80 kev does not allow us to independently constrain the bubble component in the western part of 30 dor c. dividing the data into the two parts ( east and west ) is an oversimplification ; in general , the transition from east to west must be gradual and so the parameters inferred from our model should be considered as averaged values within the divided regions .
we have also not included any systematic error in the data due to uncertainties in the calibration , background subtraction , and modeling , which are difficult to quantify at present .
we therefore decided not to add more complications ( such as varying abundances of individual elements ) into the model .
the morphology of the diffuse x - ray emission in 30 dor c is consistent with that expected from the evaporation of cool gas into the hot interior of a bubble created in the ism by the winds of massive stars .
the close confinement of the limb - brightened x - ray emission by the outer h@xmath17-emitting shell indicates that the bubble is roughly spherical . otherwise , the bubble has to be elongated almost exactly along the line of sight .
we have therefore interpreted the x - ray emission in terms of the stellar wind - blown bubble model of @xcite .
assuming that the above wind - blown bubble model provides a reasonable characterization of 30 dor c , the physical properties of the enclosed hot gas can be inferred from the spectral parameters obtained above .
we have adopted a notation similar to @xcite , where @xmath122 is the age of the superbubble in myrs , @xmath123 is the ambient density of the ism in @xmath6 , @xmath124 is the equivalent mechanical power injected into the superbubble in units of @xmath125 erg s@xmath8 , and @xmath126 is the ratio of the coefficient of thermal conduction to the classical spitzer value ( @xmath127 erg s@xmath8 k@xmath8 cm@xmath8 ) .
the respective central temperature and density of the hot gas are @xmath129 and @xmath130 , assuming a superbubble radius @xmath131 ( shull & saken 1995 ; see also mac low & mccray 1988 ) .
we can rearrange the above equations for @xmath90 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 to give @xmath132 @xmath133 and @xmath134 the parameters on the right side of equations ( [ eqn - n0])([eqn - kappa0 ] ) can be inferred from either the spectral fits with the bubble model ( @xmath91 and @xmath90 ) or other independent measurements ( @xmath92 and @xmath135 ) .
the central temperature and normalization of the best - fit bubble model ( model vb+p ) are @xmath136 and @xmath137 , respectively .
this value of @xmath138 gives a central density of @xmath139 and a mean emission measure of @xmath140 @xmath141 pc , assuming the bubble to be a prolate spheroid of dimension @xmath142 . adopting a mean radius of @xmath143 for the bubble , which is the radius of the sphere that has the same volume as the prolate spheroidal bubble , gives an ambient density of @xmath144 , a mechanical luminosity of @xmath145 , and a coefficient of thermal conduction of @xmath146 of the spitzer value .
the mass of gas that has been swept up is then @xmath147 , where @xmath148 is the mass per particle , @xmath149 is the mass of a hydrogen atom , and @xmath150 is the mass of the sun .
following @xcite , we also estimate the mass of x - ray emitting gas at temperatures @xmath151 k as @xmath152 .
finally , the thermal and kinetic energy of the superbubble are @xmath153 and @xmath154 respectively , and the thermal pressure of the hot gas is @xmath155 . from the total energy , we infer that one or two core - collapse supernovae could have occurred within the superbubble , since each supernova supplies roughly @xmath156 erg ( e.g. , woosley & weaver 1986 ) .
w - r stars are the most probable core - collapse supernovae progenitors in lh 90 , and we may expect these stars to have a mass distribution similar to that of the w - r stars in the galaxy , i.e. , masses in the range from @xmath157 to @xmath158 ( e.g. , cherepashchuk 1991 ) .
stars with masses in the range from @xmath159 to @xmath158 are expected to undergo nuclear fusion of the @xmath17-elements and yield between @xmath160 and @xmath161 of oxygen @xcite . from the best - fit @xmath17-process elemental abundance of @xmath59 solar , we infer an oxygen / hydrogen mass ratio of @xmath162 for the x - ray emitting gas in the bubble .
the ism in the lmc has an @xmath17-process elemental abundance of @xmath19 solar or an oxygen / hydrogen mass ratio of @xmath163 .
thus , the bubble must have been enriched by @xmath164 of oxygen , assuming that @xmath165 percent of the mass of the x - ray emitting gas is hydrogen .
at least 23 high ( @xmath166 ) mass , core - collapse supernovae are needed to explain the oxygen abundance in the bubble , and the total energy supplied exceeds the value inferred from the spectral fits .
to make our results a bit more quantitative , we need to know the age of the bubble , which is still uncertain .
following @xcite , we use the observed expansion velocity of @xmath167 km s@xmath8 @xcite , where @xmath168 in units of pc , to derive a bubble age of @xmath169 years .
this value of @xmath170 is probably a lower limit to the true age of the bubble since the expansion is only detected in parts of the bubble ( y .- h .
chu 2004 , private communication ) .
the energy input from the ob association also tends to increase with time @xcite .
the ages of the most massive stars in the ob association give an age of @xmath27@xmath71 myr @xcite , although there are subclusters that are older ( up to @xmath171 myr ) .
this kind of progressive star formation is also seen in the central ob association of the nearby 30 dor nebula , typically with increasing strength ;
i.e. , the most massive stars are formed later ( e.g. , selman et al .
therefore , we adopt a mean age of the ob association as @xmath172 myrs .
the inferred ambient density of @xmath173 is reasonable for the expected high density ism near 30 dor c. the mean emission measure of the h@xmath17-emitting shell is @xmath174 @xmath141 pc @xcite . adopting a minimum path length of @xmath175 through the h@xmath17 emission region , which is twice as large as the width of the optical line - emitting filaments in figure [ fig2 ]
( see also fig .
1__l _ _ of dunne et al .
2001 ) , gives an upper limit to the mean electron density of @xmath176 for the ionized shell , where @xmath177 is the filling factor of the h@xmath17-emitting gas .
the thermal pressure of the ionized shell is approximately @xmath178 , where @xmath179 k and @xmath180 is the boltzmann constant .
this value is within a factor of three of the thermal pressure derived from the x - ray data for filling factors in the range @xmath10@xmath80 .
the mechanical luminosity required to power the bubble is @xmath181 .
there are @xmath182 spectroscopically indentified o - type stars and @xmath183 confirmed w - r stars in lh 90 @xcite . while the mass loss rates of w - r stars can be an order of magnitude higher than those of o - type stars ( e.g. , nugis & lamers 2000 ) , the lifetime of these stars are fractions of a million years , i.e. , much shorter than the probable age of the bubble , and so their energy input to the bubble is negligible compared with that from the o - type stars . adopting a mean mass loss rate of @xmath184 ( de jager , nieuwenhuijzen , & van der hucht 1988 ) and terminal velocities in the range from @xmath185 to @xmath186 ( prinja , barlow , & howarth 1990 ) , which are typical values for the o - type stars in lh 90 , we calculate an integrated wind luminosity of @xmath187@xmath188 .
therefore , the o - type stars in the stellar clusters of lh 90 could easily supply the mechanical luminosity required to power the bubble , without the contributions from a few supernovae .
if the bubble is much older than @xmath71 myr , then the mechanical energy input to the bubble from the o - type stars could greatly exceed the value of @xmath189 inferred from the spectral fits .
the best - fit bubble parameters give an estimate of the total energy input of @xmath190 .
this energy input is inferred from the density and temperature structure of the bubble , and not from its mechanical luminosity and age .
there is clearly discrepancy between the expected mechanical energy input from the ob association and that inferred from the bubble model .
this apparent oversupply of mechanical energy is a common problem in the existing studies of several other structures around ob associations ( e.g. , oey 1996 ; naz et al .
2001 ; cooper et al .
in all these studies , including the present one , a potentially very important energy mechanism dust grain cooling is not considered .
one expects dust grains to be mixed with the x - ray - emitting gas due to the thermal evaporation and supernova ejecta . with a normal interstellar dust grain population , the cooling rate of dust grains heated by collisions with hot electrons can be substantially greater than the radiative cooling of the hot gas itself ( e.g. , dwek & arendt 1992 and references therein ) .
of course , dust grains subject to the sputtering .
their survival timescale depend on both the grain sizes and the ambient hot gas density . with the large uncertainties in these parameters , we find that it is conceivable for dust grains to be the major coolant of a superbubble .
we find a coefficient of thermal conduction of @xmath191 of the classical spitzer value .
thermal conduction can be reduced by the presence of magnetic fields ( e.g. , chandran & cowley 1998 ) : the thermal conductivity can approach @xmath192% of the spitzer value due to the chaotic transverse wandering of the magnetic field lines , although this value could be uncertain by a factor of two @xcite . the theoretical value of @xmath126 is consistent with our measurement , given the uncertainties in the bubble age .
thermal conduction is unlikely to be saturated ( e.g. , cowie & mckee 1977 ) , since the mean free path of a charge particle is much smaller than the radius of the bubble .
as expected , the best - fit equivalent hydrogen column densities toward the eastern and western parts of 30 dor c are significantly higher than the equivalent galactic h i column density toward 30 dor c of @xmath193 @xmath2 @xcite .
we therefore use the optical extinction of stars in the ob association to independently estimate the total ( atomic plus molecular ) column density toward 30 dor c. the mean interstellar extinction for the association as a whole is @xmath194 and reaches a maximum of @xmath195 in the western part @xcite . adopting a value of @xmath196 for the galactic foreground extinction toward 30 dor c @xcite and assuming gas - to - dust ratios of @xmath197 ( bohlin , savage , & drake 1978 ) and @xmath198 @xcite for the galaxy and lmc respectively , we estimate a mean column density of @xmath199 toward the ob association and a maximum column density of @xmath200 toward the western part . while these values appear to be larger than our measurements , we had assumed solar abundances for the atomic absorption cross - sections in the spectral fits .
almost all of the absorption cross - section at @xmath201 kev is provided by metals and so , for a metal abundance of @xmath105 solar , the measured x - ray absorption column densities towards the eastern and western parts of the bubble are @xmath202 @xmath2 and @xmath203 @xmath2 , respectively .
these x - ray absorption column densities are consistent with the absorption column densities estimated from the optical extinction of stars in the ob association .
the difference in the measured x - ray absorption column densities of @xmath204 @xmath2 is consistent with the h@xmath205 column density inferred from the co emission projected onto the western part of 30 dor c ( see [ sec - morphology ] ) .
for energy - conserving shocks , the h@xmath17 expansion velocity of @xmath206 km s@xmath8 @xcite corresponds to a shock velocity of @xmath207 km s@xmath8 ( e.g. , chu et al .
1995b ) , and gas passing through the shock would only be heated to temperatures of @xmath208 k ( e.g. , hollenbach & mckee 1979 ) , which is well below the temperature of the x - ray emitting gas . the observed [ s ii]/h@xmath17 flux ratio of @xmath56 @xcite is also below that expected from shocked gas ( e.g. , long et al . 1990 ) and , contrary to the observations , the bulk of the nonthermal x - ray emission is expected to originate in the eastern part of 30 dor c since the non - thermal radio emission is much stronger on the eastern side of the bubble than on the western side .
thus , we conclude that any recent supernova explosion must have occured deep inside the bubble , producing little or no observable nonthermal x - ray synchrotron radiation .
@xcite explained the the apparently nonthermal component in the x - ray spectrum of 30 dor c as synchrotron radiation from relativistic electrons .
if this is true , the required electron energies should be a few hundred tev for a typical interstellar magnetic field of order @xmath209 g. although low ( up to a few tens of km s@xmath8 ) velocity shoulders are visible on the h@xmath17 emission lines from various parts of the bubble ( y .- h .
chu 2004 , private communication ) , there is a complete lack of emission with velocities greater than @xmath75 km s@xmath8 from the recessional velocity of the lmc and so the shock velocities are certainly too low to produce such energetic particles . the most obvious site for an effective particle acceleration should be the reverse shock , which separates the free - streaming stellar wind from the region of thermally evaporated material ( @xmath210 in fig . 1 of weaver et al . 1977 ) .
for a mean mass loss rate of @xmath211 , a terminal velocity of @xmath212 , an ambient density of @xmath213 @xmath6 , and a bubble age of @xmath71 myrs , the inner shock radius is roughly @xmath183 pc @xcite .
the time scales for the relativistic electrons to diffuse from the reverse shock to the edge of the bubble would have to be shorter than their synchrotron half - lives , which are of order @xmath214 ( e.g. , lang 1974 , pp .
31 - 32 ) .
the relativistic electrons would therefore have to travel in the bubble at velocities that are an order of magnitude faster than the sound velocity of @xmath215@xmath216 km s@xmath8 and two orders of magnitude faster than the alfvn velocity of @xmath217 km s@xmath8 , which is untenable ( e.g. , jaffe 1977 ) .
it is possible that the electrons could be accelerated by turbulent motions in the bubble itself .
the turbulent velocities would be of order or greater than the alfvn velocity , since otherwise the magnetic field would damp the turbulent motions ( e.g. , jaffe 1977 ) , and so the turbulent kinetic energy involved would be a few @xmath218 erg . the electrons must be accelerated on time scales that are shorter than their radiative lifetimes and so the power dissipated in this process is of order @xmath219 erg s@xmath8 .
while this value is comparable to the mechanical wind luminosity of the early - type stars , the `` second - order '' acceleration by turbulence is probably too inefficient .
the inverse compton ( ic ) scattering of cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) and other ambient photons ( e.g. , infrared photons from reprocessed starlight ) by relativistic electrons will also generate nonthermal x - ray emission .
the upscattering of such photons to @xmath220 kev requires electrons with energies in the range from @xmath221 to @xmath201 gev .
these electrons radiate synchrotron emission at frequencies of mhz to tens of mhz in magnetic fields of order @xmath222 . for cmb photons , the ratio of inverse compton - scattered x - ray flux to radio synchrotron flux is @xmath223 ( e.g. , blumenthal & gould 1970 ) , where @xmath224 and @xmath225 are the flux densities at frequencies @xmath226 and @xmath227 , respectively . the functions @xmath228 and @xmath229 are given in @xcite for a power - law distribution of electron energies with index @xmath230 .
the radio synchrotron spectrum should have the same spectral index as the ic emission and so we have assumed a spectral index of @xmath231 for the radio synchrotron spectrum .
the ratio of @xmath228 to @xmath229 is @xmath232 for this value of @xmath17 .
we have also assumed that the magnetic field strength is @xmath222 and that the electron distribution is an unbroken power - law extending from lorentz factors of few times @xmath216 , which will upscatter cmb photons to x - ray wavelengths , to lorentz factors of order @xmath233 , which will produce @xmath234 mhz radio emission via synchrotron radiation .
this last assumption may not be correct , however , since the nonthermal x - ray emission is stongest in the western part of the bubble where there is no evidence for nonthermal radio emission @xcite .
nonetheless , the total ( thermal plus synchrotron ) emission at @xmath234 mhz is @xmath235 jy @xcite and so the expected 1 kev to @xmath234 mhz flux density ratio of @xmath236 gives an upper limit to the ic emission at 1 kev of @xmath237 photons @xmath2 s@xmath8 kev@xmath8 .
although this value is consistent with the flux densities of the power - law emissions from the eastern and western parts of 30 dor c , the ic emission is probably much fainter than this , since the flat ( @xmath238 ) radio spectrum is an indication that the radio emission is mostly thermal @xcite .
the upscattering of infrared photons to x - ray energies requires electrons with lorentz factors of a few hundred . for a power - law distribution of electron energies with index @xmath239
, we would expect the number of electrons capable of upscattering infrared photons to x - ray energies to be @xmath215 times the number of electrons capable of upscattering cmb photons to x - ray energies .
the @xmath240@xmath241 m luminosity of 30 dor c can be estimated from @xmath242 ( _ cataloged galaxies and quasars observed in the iras survey _ , appendix b ) , where @xmath243 and @xmath244 are the _ iras _ flux densities in jy at @xmath245 m and @xmath246 m , respectively , and @xmath96 is the distance to the source in cm . the extended infrared emission measured by _ iras _ is roughly @xmath43 and @xmath247 jy at @xmath248 and @xmath249 m , respectively @xcite , and so we estimate a @xmath240@xmath250 m luminosity of the order of a few @xmath125 erg s@xmath8 .
thus , the mean infrared energy density of the bubble is of the order @xmath251 erg @xmath6 and could be higher if the infrared emission is concentrated in the outer shell . if we adopt a mean photon energy of @xmath252 ev for the infrared emission , then the total infrared photon number density is @xmath253 @xmath6 .
the cmb photons have , in contrast , a mean photon energy of @xmath254 ev and a total photon number density of @xmath255 @xmath6 ( e.g. , gaiser , protheroe , & stanev 1998 ) . from equation ( 6 ) of @xcite and assuming that the electron energies are distributed as a power - law of index @xmath239 , we find that the ic emission at a fixed photon energy scales roughly as @xmath256 , where @xmath257 is the photon number density of the radiation under consideration
. so we would expect the x - ray emission from ic - scattered infrared photons to be @xmath258 percent higher than that from the upscattering of the cmb photons .
however , the optical radiation from stars should have an energy density greater than that of the infrared emission and could be ic - scattered to x - ray energies by electrons with lorentz factors of @xmath259 . if we assume that the mean energy of the optical photons is @xmath260 ev , then the total photon number density of the optical radiation should be @xmath261 @xmath6 and the x - ray emission from ic - scattered optical photons should be an order of magnitude higher than that from the upscattered infrared and cmb photons .
unless the particle energy distribution is far from the power law ( e.g. , a maxwellian distribution ) and/or the particle population is greatly enhanced at the shell , the nonthermal x - ray emission should then be concentrated in the central region of 30 dor c , where the optical emission is greatest .
this is inconsistent with the observed limb - brightened hard x - ray emission ( fig . [ fig3 ] ) . a strong shock ,
as expected inside the bubble , will also produce electron spectra with indexes of @xmath262 ( e.g. , blandford & eichler 1987 ) , which is totally at odds with the spectral index of the nonthermal x - ray emission . on the other hand ,
if the relativistic particles represent the thermalized wind material from young pulsars during the lifetime of the bubble , then the particle energies could be distributed as a maxwellian of peak energy @xmath263@xmath216 @xcite .
therefore , we can not rule out the possibility that the bulk of the nonthermal x - ray emission from the bubble is due to ic radiation .
nonthermal particles generate bremsstrahlung in regions where the energy losses due to ionization and coulomb collisions are significant .
the energy flux of the bremsstrahlung radiation is @xmath264 times the total energy input to the particles ( e.g. , dogiel et al .
2002 ) , i.e. , a large amount of energy is required to maintain the particles against coulomb / ionization losses to the emitting region .
the best - fit bubble model ( model vb+p ) has power - law components with unabsorbed @xmath10@xmath11 kev luminosities of @xmath265 and @xmath266 erg s@xmath8 in the eastern and western parts of the bubble , respectively .
the required energy input is therefore @xmath267@xmath268 erg s@xmath8 .
although the necessary energy input can be less than this for a quasi - thermal distribution of electrons formed in regions of in situ acceleration @xcite , it is still orders of magnitude greater than the integrated wind luminosity of @xmath201-@xmath269 erg s@xmath8 from the o - type stars in lh 90 . a recent ( within the last a few @xmath270 years ; chu & maclow 1990 ) supernova explosion could provide the energy input to the bubble , but this would mean that we are seeing the event by chance .
the 26 o - type stars in lh 90 have masses in the range from @xmath271 to @xmath272 ( e.g. , walborn et al .
1995 , 1999 ) .
if we assume a spitzer initial mass function for the stars in lh 90 , then we would expect @xmath159 o - type stars with masses in the range from @xmath273 to @xmath274 .
although some of these stars would undoubtedly have evolved into w - r stars , the remainder would have exploded as supernovae ( stars with masses greater than @xmath275 do not explode as supernovae , but instead collapse into a black - hole ) .
thus , there must have been at least @xmath157@xmath276 supernovae in 30 dor c , and so the probability of seeing a supernova within the last @xmath233 years is approximately @xmath80 percent , assuming that the age of the bubble is @xmath71 myr .
in summary , the nature of the apparent nonthermal hard x - ray component is still uncertain .
the expansion of the bubble is much too slow in order to produce the energetic particles necessary for nonthermal x - ray synchrotron emission .
although such energetic particles can be produced at the inner reverse shock , they can not cross the bubble within their synchrotron half - lives .
nonthermal bremsstrahlung is an inefficient process , requiring at least three orders of magnitude more energy than can be supplied by the o - type stars in lh 90 .
a recent supernova could supply the necessary energy , but this would mean that we are seeing the event by chance ( a probability of @xmath277 percent ) . the ic scattering of cmb and infrared photons can not account for all of the nonthermal x - ray emission unless the radio flux is purely synchrotron radiation , which seems unlikely .
while the x - ray emission from ic - scattered optical photons should be much higher than that from ic - scattered cmb and infrared photons , it should be concentrated in the central region of 30 dor c , where the optical photon density is greatest , in sharp contrast to the data .
the nonthermal x - ray emission could instead be due to the ic scattering of cmb and infrared photons by relativistic particles originating in young pulsar wind material with energies peaking between @xmath263@xmath216 .
high spatial resolution x - ray imaging , which can be afforded by an on - axis _
chandra _ observation , will be particularly useful to further the understanding of the component
. such an observation will allow for an accurate determination of the size and geometry of the x - ray - emitting region and for a detailed comparison with images in other wavelength bands .
a substantial fraction of the expected energy input from stellar winds and supernovae may be radiated in the infrared by dust grains entrained in the hot gas .
we thank r. chris smith for providing his optical image of 30 dor c in computer - readable format , glenn allen for discussions on the nonthermal emission , and the referee for insightful comments on an earlier draft of the paper .
this research is supported by the nasa ltsa grant nag5 - 8935 .
abbott , d. c. 1982 , , 263 , 723 anders , e. , & grevesse , n. 1989 , geochimica et cosmochimica acta , 53 , 197 arnaud , k. a. 1996 , in asp conf .
proc . 101 , astronomical data analysis software and systems v , ed .
g. jacoby & j. barnes ( san francisco : asp ) , 17 arons , j. & tavani , m. 1994 , , 90 , 797 atoyan 1999 , , 346 , l49 bamba , a. , ueno , m. , koyama , k. , & itoh , m. 2003 , in the proceedings of the 8th iau asian - pacific regional meeting , volume ii , ed .
, s. ikeuchi , j. hearnshaw , and t. hanawa ( san francisco : asp ) , 129 bamba , a. , ueno , m. , nakajima , h. , & koyama , k. 2004 , , 602 , 257 bessel , m. s. 1991 , , 242 , l17 blandford , r. d. , & eichler , d. 1987 , phys .
, 154 , 1 blumenthal , g. r. , & gould , r. j. 1970 , rev .
phys . , 42 , 237 bohlin , r. c. , savage , b. d. , & drake , j. f. 1978 , , 224 , 132 borkowski , k. j. , lyerly , w. j. , & reynolds , s. p. 2001
, , 548 , 820 cass , m. , & paul , j. a. 1980 , , 237 , 236 chandran , b. d. g. , & cowley , s. c. 1998 , phys .
lett . , 80 , 3077 cherepashchuk a. m. , 1991 , in proc .
143 , wolf - rayet stars and interrelations with other massive stars in galaxies , ed .
k. a. van der hucht , b. hidayat ( dordrecht : kluwer ) , 187 chu , y .- h . , &
mac low , m .-
1990 , , 365 , 510 chu , y .- h . , chang , h .- w . , su , y .-
, & mac low , m .-
1995a , , 450 , 157 chu , y .- h . ,
dickel , j. r. , staveley - smith , l. , osterberg , j. , & smith , r. c. 1995b , , 109 , 1729 cooper , r. l. , guerrero , m. a. , chu , y .- h . , chen , c .- h .
r. , & dunne , b. d. 2003 , , submitted cowie , l. l. , & mckee , c. f. 1977 , , 211 , 135 davies , r. d. , elliott , k. h. , & meaburn , j. 1976 , mmras , 81 , 89 de jager , c. , nieuwenhuijzen , h. , & van der hucht , k. a. 1988 , , 72 , 259 dennerl , k. , et al .
2001 , , 365 , l202 dickey , j. m. , & lockman , f. j. 1990 , , 28 , 215 dogiel , v. a. , inoue , h. , masai , k. , schnfelder , v. , & strong , a. w. 2002 , , 581 , 1061 dunne , b. c. , points , s. d. , & chu , y .- h . 2001 , , 136 , 119 dwek , e. & arendt , r.g .
, 1992 , , 30 , 11 eastman , r. g. , & kirshner , r. p. 1989
, , 347 , 771 fitzpatrick , e. l. 1985 , , 299 , 219 gaisser , t. k. , protheroe , r. j. , & stanev , t. 1998 , , 492 , 219 ghavamian , p. , winkler , f. p. , raymond , j. c. , & long , k. s. 2002 , , 572 , 888 haberl , f. , dennerl , k. , filipovi , m. d. , aschenbach , b. , pietsch , w. , & trmper , j. 2001 , , 365 , l208 hollenbach , d. , & mckee , c. f. 1979 , , 41 , 555 israel , f. p. 1997
, , 328 , 471 jaffe , w. j. 1977 , , 212 , 1 jansen , f. , et al .
2001 , , 365 , l1 johansson , l. e. b. , et al .
1998 , , 331 , 857 lang , k. r. 1974 , astrophysical formulae ( new york : springer ) laspias , v. n. , & meaburn , j. 1991 , , 249 , 1p long , k. s. , blair , w. p. , kirshner , r. p. , & winkler , p. f. 1990 , , 72 , 61 lortet , m. c. , & testor , g. 1984 , , 139 , 330 lucke , p. b. , & hodge , p. w. 1970 , , 75 , 171 mathewson , d. s. , ford , v. l. , tuohy , i. r. , mills , b. y. , turtle , a. j. , & helfand , d. j. 1985 , , 58 , 197 mac low , m .- m . , & mccray , r. 1988 , , 324 , 776 mccray , r. , & snow , t. p. , jr .
1979 , , 17 , 213 meaburn , j. , wang , l. , palmer , j. , & lopez , j. a. 1993 , , 263 , l6 mewe , r. , kaastra , j. s. , & liedahl , d. a. 1995 , legacy , 6 , 16 morrison , r. , & mccammon , d. 1983 , , 270 , 119 narayan , r. , & medvedev , m. v. 2001 , , 562 , l129 naz ' e , y. , chu , y .- h . , points , s. d. , danforth , c. w. , rosado , m. , chen , c .- h .
r. 2001 , , 122 , 921 nugis , t. , & lamers , h. j. g. l. m. 2000 , , 360 , 227 oey , m. s. 1996 , , 467 , 666 prinja , r. k. , barlow , m. j. , & howarth , i. d. 1990 , , 361 , 607 read , a. m. , & ponman , t. j. 2003 , , 409 , 395 russell , s. c. , & dopita , m. a. 1992 , , 384 , 508 selman , f. , melnick , j. , bosch , g. , & terlevich , r. 1999 , , 347 , 532 shull , j. m. , & saken , j. m. 1995 , , 444 , 663 smith , r. c. , and the mcels team 1998 , publ . astron .
aust . , 15 , 163 testor , g. , schild , h. , & lortet , m. c. 1993 , , 280 , 426 thielemann , f .- k . ,
nomoto , k. , & hashimoto , m. 1996 , , 460 , 408 turner , m. j. l. , et al .
2001 , , 365 , l27 van der marel , r. p. , & cioni , m .-
l. 2001 , , 122 , 1807 wang , q. , & helfand , d. j. 1991 , , 373 , 497 wang , q. d. , & gotthelf , e. v. 1998 , , 494 , 623 walborn , n. r. , mackenty , j. w. , saha , a. , white , r. l. , & parker , j. w. 1995 , , 439 , l47 walborn , n. r. , drissen , l. , parker , j. w. , saha , a. , mackenty , j. w. , & white , r. l. 1999 , , 118 , 1684 weaver , r. , mccray , r. , castor , j. , shapiro , p. , & moore , r. 1977 , , 218 , 377 woosley , s. e. , & weaver , t. a. 1986 , , 24 , 205 woosley , s. e. , & weaver , t. a. 1995 , , 101 , 181 xu , c. , klein , u. , meinert , d. , wielebinski , r. , & haynes , r. f. 1992 , , 257 , 47 @xmath278 & ( @xmath279 @xmath2 ) & @xmath280 & @xmath281 & @xmath282 + @xmath283 & ( @xmath279 @xmath2 ) & @xmath284 & @xmath285 & @xmath286 + @xmath287 & ( kev ) & @xmath288 & @xmath289 & @xmath290 + @xmath291 & ( @xmath292 ) & @xmath293 & @xmath293 & @xmath293 + @xmath294 & ( @xmath292 ) & @xmath295 & @xmath293 & @xmath296 + @xmath297 & ( @xmath298 ) & @xmath299 & @xmath300 & @xmath301 + @xmath103 & & @xmath302 & @xmath303 & @xmath304 + @xmath305 & ( @xmath306 photons @xmath2 s@xmath8 kev@xmath8 ) & @xmath307 & @xmath308 & @xmath309 + @xmath310 & ( @xmath306 photons @xmath2 s@xmath8 kev@xmath8 ) & @xmath311 & @xmath312 & @xmath313 + @xmath314 ( dof ) & & @xmath315 & @xmath316 & @xmath317 + prob . & & @xmath318 & @xmath319 & @xmath320 + @xmath321model : b @xmath322 wind - blown bubble ( model valid for gas temperatures in the range from 8 ev to 80 kev ) ; vb @xmath322 wind - blown bubble with variable abundances ( model valid for gas temperatures in the range from 8 ev to 80 kev ) ; m @xmath322 mekal ( model valid for gas temperatures in the range from 8 ev to 80 kev ) ; p @xmath322 power - law .
+ @xmath323measured column density towards the eastern part of the bubble .
+ @xmath324measured column density towards the western part of the bubble .
+ @xmath325the gas temperature at the center of the bubble .
+ @xmath326c , n , na , al , fe , and ni abundance relative to solar of the bubble .
+ @xmath327fixed at the known value of @xmath247% solar for the ism in the lmc .
+ @xmath328o , ne , mg , si , s , ar , and ca abundance relative to solar of the bubble .
+ @xmath329the normalization of the bubble model .
the units are cgs .
+ @xmath330photon spectral index .
+ @xmath331normalization for the power - law model in the eastern part of the bubble .
+ @xmath332normalization for the power - law model in the western part of the bubble .
+ @xmath333probability that the model describes the data and that @xmath314 exceeds the observed value by chance . | we present an analysis of _ xmm - newton _ observations of the superbubble 30 dor c and compare the results with the predictions from the standard wind - blown bubble model .
we find that the observed x - ray spectra can not be fitted satisfactorily with the model alone and that there is evidence for nonthermal x - ray emission , which is particularly important at @xmath0 kev .
the combination of the bubble model and a power - law gives a reasonable fit to the observed spectra .
the thermal pressure and central temperature of the bubble are @xmath1 dyne @xmath2 and @xmath3 k , respectively , and we infer that , for a bubble age of @xmath4 years , the ambient density is @xmath5 @xmath6 , the mechanical luminosity is @xmath7 erg s@xmath8 , and the coefficient of thermal conductivity is @xmath9 of the spitzer value . the total unabsorbed @xmath10@xmath11 kev luminosities of the eastern and western parts of the bubble are @xmath12 erg s@xmath8 and @xmath13 erg s@xmath8 , respectively .
the unabsorbed @xmath10@xmath11 kev luminosity of the bubble model is @xmath14 erg s@xmath8 and so the power - law component contributes between @xmath15 and @xmath16 to the total unabsorbed luminosity in this energy band .
the nature of the hard nonthermal emission is not clear , although recent supernovae in the bubble may be responsible .
we expect that about one or two core - collapse supernovae could have occured and are required to explain the enrichment of the hot gas , as evidenced by the overabundance of @xmath17-elements by a factor of @xmath18 , compared to the mean value of @xmath19 solar for the interstellar medium in the large magellanic cloud . as in previous studies of various superbubbles ,
the amount of energy currently present in 30 dor c is significantly less than the expected energy input from the enclosed massive stars over their lifetime .
we speculate that a substantial fraction of the input energy may be radiated in far - infrared by dust grains , which are mixed with the hot gas because of the thermal conduction and/or dynamic mixing . |
the first generation of large - scale laser - interferometric gravitational wave detectors @xcite is now in operation and collects data of impressive sensitivity and bandwidth .
the optical configurations of these kilometer long gravitational wave observatories are based on a michelson interferometer
. moreover , the standard configuration , implemented in the three ligo interferometers as well as in virgo and tama300 , employs cavities in the arms of the interferometer and power - recycling to increase the storage time of the light inside the interferometer . in order to get an optimal power increase inside the arm cavities ,
these are kept to be resonant for the carrier light .
however , as we show in this article , detuning these arm cavities by a few hundred hz has the advantage of a larger signal gain in a certain frequency band and might therefore be favorable .
in section [ sec : principle ] we give a brief and intuitive description of the principle of an optical configuration employing detuned arm cavities . using a idealized interferometer as an example we show in section [ sec : simulation ]
that with detuned arm cavities the shot noise limited sensitivity can , in a certain frequency range , be increased using the same optical power circulating in the arm cavities as in the case of tuned arm cavities . in section [ sec : rse ] we compare the interferometer response with detuned arm cavities to a configuration using in addition the advanced technology of resonant sideband extraction ( rse ) .
the potential benefit of using detuned arm cavities for ligo is evaluated by simulations described in section [ sec : real_ligo ] .
finally we give a summary and an outlook in section [ sec : summary ] .
figure [ layouts ] a ) shows a simplified schematic of the initial ligo optical layout .
the red and the dark blue lines indicate in which part of the interferometer carrier light ( red ) and gravitational wave signal sidebands ( dark blue ) are present .
the carrier light enters the interferometer through the power recycling mirror ( prm ) and is split by the beam splitter ( bs ) in equal shares into the x and y arm . the arms consist of an arm cavity each , formed by two mirrors separated by 4 km ( itx and etx , ity and ety ) .
these arm cavities are chosen to be resonant for the carrier light resulting in a larger power enhancement inside .
the small michelson interferometer formed by bs , ity and itx is kept on a dark fringe , thus no carrier light is leaving the interferometer towards the output port , but all light is going back to the input port so that it becomes further resonantly enhanced by prm .
the presence of a gravitational wave produces phase modulation sidebands around the carrier light . because the signal sidebands in the two perpendicular arms have opposite phase they can interfere constructively at the bs to leave the interferometer at the output port . with the arm cavities being set on resonance for the carrier light , the signal sidebands of interest ( @xmath0hz ) experience less enhancement than the carrier light .
a new concept that turns this principle around is to use detuned arm cavities as shown in figure [ layouts ] c ) .
in contrast to the conventional initial ligo scheme the length of the arm cavities was chosen to be resonant for a specific single - sided signal sideband frequency , i.e. the cavities are detuned from the carrier frequency .
this detuning can easiest be realized by shifting ety and etx in common mode either to shorten or to lengthen the arm cavities , corresponding to making them resonant for the upper and the lower signal sideband , respectively .
the operating points of the other main mirrors ( itx , ity , and bs ) do not need to be changed
. the obvious drawback of this scheme , in the following referred to as _ detuned arm cavities _ , is the lower optical power inside the arms , compared to arm cavities resonant for the carrier light .
however , the achievable circulating power in current detectors is not limited by the available laser power nor the finesse of the arm cavities .
instead technical problems , like , for example , thermal lensing or parametric instabilities , become limiting factors when the circulating light power is increased @xcite
. therefore we belief it useful to compare the concept of detuned arm cavities to resonant arm cavities with identical stored optical power .
in order to evaluate the benefit from detuning the arm cavities and resonantly enhancing the gravitational wave signal sideband we performed numerical simulations of the shot noise limited sensitivity using the finesse software @xcite . as an example we have chosen an idealized and simplified michelson interferometer with power - recycling employing tuned and detuned arm cavities of 4 km length . to simplify the simulation of shot noise ,
a dc - readout scheme was used .
table [ ligo_tab ] gives a summary of the simulation : with an input power of 4w a circulating light power of 10kw is achieved in each arm cavity .
the corresponding shot noise limited displacement sensitivity of such a configuration with arm cavities resonant for the carrier light is shown in figure [ initial ] ( green solid trace ) .
.simulation of an ideal michelson interferometer with dc - readout .
[ ligo_tab ] [ cols="<,^",options="header " , ]
we have introduced a new concept that uses detuned arm cavities combined with a moderately increased power - recycling gain to increase the shot noise limited sensitivity of initial ligo for frequencies between 125 and 400hz , without increasing the light power inside the arm cavities .
this concept is found to give a sensitivity similar to that of a conventional rse configuration with a srm of moderate reflectivity .
the implementation of detuned arm cavities might require less new hardware than rse .
this is a considerable advantage , however , further investigations and simulations should be performed to evaluate the performance of the proposed scheme with respect to noise couplings .
we have chosen to validate the concept using the initial ligo configuration because the real parameters and performance of the running interferometers are well known . nevertheless , the same concept is applicable to these interferometers after the next upgrade : enhanced ligo .
further investigations are required , however , to understand the technical limits to the circulating power in the arm cavities and the small michelson in a realistic enhanced ligo scenario . | we introduce a concept that uses detuned arm cavities to increase the shot noise limited sensitivity of ligo without increasing the light power inside the arm cavities .
numerical simulations show an increased sensitivity between 125 and 400hz , with a maximal improvement of about 80% around 225hz , while the sensitivity above 400hz is decreased . furthermore our concept is found to give a sensitivity similar to that of a conventional rse configuration with a signal - recycling mirror of moderate reflectivity . in the near future detuned arm cavities
might be a beneficial alternative to rse , due the potentially less hardware intensive implementation of the proposed concept . |
it is well known that for bodies separated by @xmath2 the radiative heat transfer between them is described by the stefan- bolzman law : @xmath3 where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the temperatures of solid @xmath6 and @xmath7 , respectively . in this limiting case the heat transfer is connected with traveling electromagnetic waves radiated by the bodies , and does not depend on the separation @xmath1 .
for @xmath8 the heat transfer increases by many order of magnitude , which can be explained by the existence of evanescent electromagnetic field that decay exponentially into the vacuum . at present time
there is an increasing number of investigations of heat transfer due to evanescent waves in connection with scanning tunneling microscopy and scanning thermal microscopy ( stm ) under ultrahigh vacuum conditions @xcite .
stm can be used for local heating of the surface , resulting in local desorption or decomposition of molecular species , and this offer further possibilities for the stm to control local chemistry on a surface .
a general formalism for evaluating the heat transfer between macroscopic bodies was proposed some years ago by polder and van hove @xcite .
their theory is based on the general theory of the fluctuating electromagnetic field developed by rytov @xcite and applied by lifshitz @xcite for studying the conservative part , and by volokitin and persson @xcite for studying dissipative part of the van der waals interaction . in the present paper we significantly simplify the formalism of polder and van hove .
we reduce the problem to the finding of the electromagnetic field created by a point dipole outside the bodies .
the formalism of polder and van hove requires the determination of electromagnetic field for all space and for all position of a point dipole , and requires the integration of the product of the component of the electric and magnetic field over the volumes of two bodies .
our formalism requires only the evaluation of a surface integral over one of the bodies and is simplified further in the non - retarded limit ( small distances between bodies ) , where the calculation of the heat transfer is reduced to the problem of finding the electrostatic potential due to a point charge .
we apply the formalism to the calculation of the heat transfer between : ( a ) two semi - infinite bodies , ( b ) a semi - infinite body and a spherical particle , and ( c ) two spherical particles .
problem ( a ) was considered by polder and van hove , but our derivation is much simpler . the problem ( b ) was recently studied by pendry @xcite .
however he only considered large separation and neglected retardation effects .
however for large separations retardation effects becomes very important .
following polder and van hove @xcite , to calculate the fluctuating electromagnetic field we use the general theory of rytov ( see ref .
this method is based on the introduction of a fluctuating current density in the maxwell equations ( just as , for example , the introduction a `` random '' force in the theory of brownian motion of a particle ) . for a monochromatic field ( time factor @xmath9 ) in a dielectric , nonmagnetic medium ,
these equations are : @xmath10 where , following to rytov , we have introduced a fluctuating current density @xmath11 associated with thermal and quantum fluctuations .
@xmath12 , @xmath13 and@xmath14 @xmath15 are the electric and the electric displacement field , the magnetic and the magnetic induction fields , respectively . for nonmagnetic medium @xmath16 and @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the dielectric constant of the surrounded media . accordingly to rytov the average value of the product of components of @xmath11 for local optic case is given by formula @xmath19 and for nonlocal local optic @xmath20 where @xmath21 is a non - local dielectric constant . for simplicity ,
in the derivation we will assume local optics .
however , the same derivation is valid also for the non - local optics case , and the final results is the same in the sense that in both cases the problem of the heat transfer between two bodies is reduced to the problem of finding the electromagnetic field outside the bodies . compared to polder and van hove , our treatment includes non - local effects , such as the anomalous skin effect . in order to calculate the radiative energy transfer between the bodies we need the ensemble average of the poyting vector @xmath22 at suitable point @xmath23 . from the maxwell equations it follows that the electric field , produced by random current density @xmath24 , is given by @xmath25 where function @xmath26 obeys the equations @xmath27d_{kj}(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime},\omega ) = ( 4\pi\omega\mathrm{i } /c^2)\delta_{ij}\delta(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}^{\prime } ) \label{six}\ ] ] @xmath28d_{ik}(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime},\omega ) = ( 4\pi\omega\mathrm{i } /c^2)\delta_{ij}\delta(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}^{\prime } ) \label{seven}\ ] ] the functions @xmath26 have the following symmetry properties @xcite @xmath29 the poyting vector can be expressed trough the average products of the components of electric field . using equations ( [ six],[seven ] ) we get @xmath30 d_{jk}^{*}(\mathbf{r}^{\prime } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime \prime } ) \nonumber \\ - \left [ \left ( \nabla_k^{\prime \prime } \nabla_l^{\prime\prime}-\delta_{lk }
\nabla^{\prime\prime 2 } \right ) d_{jl}^ * ( \mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime}})+\frac{4 \pi \omega \mathrm{i}}{c^2}\delta_{jk } \delta ( \mathbf{r } -\mathbf{r}^{\prime \prime } \right ] d_{ik}(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime \prime})\bigg \ } \nonumber \\ = \frac{c^2}{2\mathrm{i } } \int \mathrm{d}\mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime}}a(\mathrm{r}^{{\prime}{\prime}})\nabla^{{\prime}{\prime } } _
{ d_{jk}^{*}(\mathbf{r}^{{\prime}},\mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime } } ) \left ( \nabla_k^{{\prime}{\prime } } d_{il}(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime}})-\nabla_l^{{\prime}{\prime } } d_{ik}(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime } } ) \right ) \nonumber \\ -{}d_{ik}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime } } ) \left ( \nabla_k^{{\prime}{\prime } } d_{jl}^{*}(\mathbf{r } ^{{\prime } } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime}})-\nabla_l^{{\prime}{\prime } } d_{jk}^{*}(\mathbf{r}^{{\prime } } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime } } ) \right ) \bigg \ } -4\omega \pi a(t_2 ) \mathrm{re}d_{ij}(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime } } ) \nonumber \\ = \frac{(a(t_1)-a(t_2))c^2}{2\mathrm{i } } \int \mathrm{d } s_{1l}^{{\prime}{\prime } } \bigg\ { d_{ik}(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime } } ) \left ( \nabla_l^{{\prime}{\prime } } d_{jk}^{*}(\mathbf{r}^{{\prime } } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime } } ) - \nabla_k^{{\prime}{\prime } } d_{jl}^{*}(\mathbf{r}^{{\prime } } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime } } ) \right ) \nonumber \\ - { } d_{jk}^{*}(\mathbf{r}^{{\prime } } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime } } ) \left ( \nabla_l^{{\prime}{\prime } } d_{ik } ( \mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime}{\prime}})- \nabla_k^{{\prime}{\prime } } d_{ji}(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime \prime } ) \right ) \bigg\ } -{}4\pi \omega a(t_2 ) \mathrm{re}d_{ij } ( \mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{{\prime } } ) , \label{nine}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we transformed the volume integral over bodies @xmath6 and @xmath7 to a surface integral over body @xmath6 .
assume that the two points @xmath23 and @xmath31 lie outside the bodies .
using that for @xmath32 @xmath33 and performing surface integral in ( [ nine ] ) gives @xmath34 @xmath35 using the maxwell equation ( [ zero ] ) we can write the poyting vector as @xmath36 in the non - retarded limit the formalism can be simplified . in this case the electric field can be written as the gradient of an electrostatic potential , @xmath37 .
thus the total poyting vector becomes @xmath38 \right\rangle_{\omega } + c.c .
\\ = \frac { c}{8 \pi } \int \mathrm{d } \mathbf{s } \cdot \left\ { \left\langle - \left [ \mathbf{\nabla } \phi \times \mathbf{b}^ { * } \right ] \right\rangle_{\omega } + c.c . \right\ } \\
= \frac c{8 \pi } \int \mathrm{d } \mathbf{s } \cdot \left\ { \left\langle \left [ \phi\mathbf{\nabla } \times \mathbf{b}^ { * } \right ] \right\rangle_{\omega } + c.c . \right\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath39 in the same approximation we can write @xmath40 where the function @xmath41 obeys the poisson s equation @xmath42 using the identities @xmath43 - \nonumber \\ - d(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime \prime } ) \left ( \nabla_l^{\prime \prime } \nabla_k^{\prime \prime } d_{jk}^ { * } ( \mathbf{r}^{\prime } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime \prime } ) - \nabla_k^{\prime \prime 2 } d_{jl}^ { * } ( \mathbf{r}^{\prime } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime \prime})\right ) \bigg\ } \nonumber \\ = - \frac{\mathrm{i}}{\omega}\nabla_i \nabla_k^{\prime \prime } \left [ d(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^ { \prime \prime } ) \left ( \nabla_l^{\prime \prime } d_{jk}^ { * } ( \mathbf{r}^{\prime } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime \prime } ) - \nabla_k^{\prime \prime } d_{jl}^ { * } ( \mathbf{r}^{\prime } , \mathbf{r}^{\prime \prime})\right ) \right ] \nonumber \\ - \frac 1{c^2}\nabla_i \nabla_j^{\prime } d(\mathbf{r } , \mathbf{r}^ { \prime \prime})\nabla_l^{\prime \prime}d^{*}(\mathbf{r}^{\prime } , \mathbf{r}^ { \prime \prime } ) , \label{thirteen}\end{aligned}\ ] ] formula ( [ nine ] ) gives @xmath44
in this section we apply the general formalism , developed in the previous section , to the problem of the heat transfer between two flat surfaces .
this problem was considered some years ago by polder and van hove @xcite , and the non - retarded limit was recently studied by pendry @xcite .
the present derivation is more compact and demonstrate the elegance of our general approach .
we suppose that the half - space @xmath45 is filled by a medium ( temperature @xmath4 ) with reflection factors @xmath46 and @xmath47 for @xmath48- and @xmath49- polarized electromagnetic fields , respectively , and the half - space @xmath50 is filled by a medium ( temperature @xmath5 ) with reflection factors @xmath51 and @xmath52 , and the region between the solids , @xmath53 , is assumed to be vacuum .
let @xmath54 be the component of wave vector @xmath55 parallel to the surfaces and @xmath56 since the problem is translationaly invariant in the @xmath57 plane , the green s function @xmath58 can be represented by the fourier integral : @xmath59 taking the @xmath60- axis along the vector @xmath54 , equations ( [ six ] ) and ( [ seven ] ) become @xmath61 since the equations for @xmath62 and @xmath63 are homogeneous , these components of the green function must vanish . thus solving the system of equations ( [ fifteen ] ) - ( [ nineteen ] )
is equivalent to solving altogether two equations : equation ( [ fifteen ] ) for @xmath64 , and the equation for @xmath65 which follows from equations ( [ sixteen ] ) and ( [ seventeen ] ) : @xmath66 @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 for @xmath70 can be obtained as @xmath71 in the vacuum gap , @xmath53 , the solution of ( [ fifteen ] ) has the form @xmath72 at the boundaries @xmath73 and @xmath74 , the amplitude of the reflected wave is equal to the amplitude of the incident wave times to corresponding reflection factor .
the green s function @xmath64 is associated with the @xmath48-wave , which satisfies the boundary conditions @xmath75 using ( [ twentyone])-([sixtyone ] ) @xmath76 equation ( [ twenty ] ) for @xmath65 is similar to equation ( [ fifteen ] ) for @xmath64 , and taking into account that @xmath65 is associated with @xmath49- wave it can be obtained directly from ( [ twentytwo ] ) by replacing @xmath77 : @xmath78 \label{twentyeight}\ ] ] we note that in our approach the calculation of the reflection factors for @xmath48- and @xmath49- waves is considered as separated problem , which , if necessary , can be solved by taking into account non - local effects . for the local optic case
the reflection factors are determined by the well known fresnel formulas @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the complex dielectric constant for body @xmath81 , @xmath82 for homogeneous ( in @xmath83-plane ) bodies the second term in ( [ eleven ] ) for @xmath84- component for poyting vector can be written in the form @xmath85 the last quantity in this expression is purely real , and does not give any contribution to @xmath84 - component of the poyting vector .
thus , from equations ( [ ten ] ) and ( [ eleven ] ) we obtain @xmath86}{16\pi \omega } \int \frac{\mathrm{d}^2\mathbf{q}}{(2\pi)^2}\bigg\ { \bigg(d_{yy}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial z \partial z^{\prime}}d^{*}_{yy}(z , z^{\prime } ) - \nonumber \\ \frac{\partial}{\partial z}d_{yy } \frac{\partial}{\partial z^{\prime}}d_{yy}(z , z^{\prime})\bigg ) + \left(\frac{\omega } { pc}\right)^4\left ( \left [ y \rightarrow x \right ] \right ) + c.c .
\bigg\}_{z\rightarrow z^{\prime}+0 } \label{twentyseven}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using ( [ twentytwo ] ) and ( [ twentyeight ] ) in ( [ twentyseven ] ) we finally obtain @xmath87 \nonumber \\ & & + \frac \hbar { 2\pi ^3}\int_0^\infty \mathrm{d}\omega \omega\int_{q>\omega /c}% \mathrm{d}^2q\mathrm{e}^{-2\mid p\mid d } \nonumber \\ & & \times \frac{\mathrm{im}r_{1p}(\omega ) \mathrm{im}% r_{2p}(\omega ) } { \mid 1-\mathrm{e}^{-2\mid p\mid d}r_{1p}(\omega ) r_{2p}(\omega)\mid ^2}(n_{1}(\omega)-n_{2}(\omega ) ) \nonumber \label{fourtyfour } \\ & & \left .
+ \left [ p\rightarrow s\right ] \label{seventyone } \right.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath88 is the bose - einstein factor of solid * 1 * and similar for @xmath89 .
1a shows the heat transfer between two semi - infinite silver bodies separated by the distance @xmath1 and at the temperatures @xmath90 and @xmath91 , respectively .
the @xmath48- and @xmath49-wave contributions are shown separately , and the @xmath49-wave contribution has been calculated using non - local optics ( the dashed line shows the result using local optics ) .
it is remarkable how important the @xmath48-contribution is even for short distances .
the detailed distance dependence of @xmath92 has been studied by polder and van hove within the local optics approximation , and will not be repeated here .
the nonlocal optics contribution to @xmath93 , which is important only for @xmath94 ( where @xmath95 is the electron mean free path in the bulk ) , is easy to calculate for free electron like metals .
the non - local surface contribution to @xmath96 is given by @xcite @xmath97 where @xmath98 depends on the electron density parameter @xmath99 but typically @xmath100 .
using this expression for @xmath96 in ( [ seventyone ] ) gives the ( surface ) contribution : @xmath101 note from fig .
1a that the local optics contribution to @xmath102 depends nearly linearly on @xmath103 in the studied distance interval , and that this contribution is much smaller than the @xmath48-wave contribution .
both these observations differ from ref .
@xcite , where it is stated that the @xmath48 contribution can be neglected for small distances and that the @xmath49-wave contribution ( within local optics ) is proportional to @xmath104 for small distances .
however , for very high - resistivity materials , the @xmath49-wave contribution becomes much more important , and a crossover to a @xmath104-dependence of @xmath102 is observed at short separations @xmath1 . this is illustrated in fig .
1b and 1c , which have been calculated with the same parameters as in fig .
1a , except that the electron mean free path has been reduced from @xmath105 ( the electron mean free path for silver at room temperature ) to @xmath106 ( roughly the electron mean free path in lead at room temperature ) ( fig .
1b ) and @xmath107 ( of order the lattice constant , representing the minimal possible mean free path ) ( fig .
note that when @xmath95 decreases , the @xmath49 contribution to the heat transfer increases while the @xmath48 contribution decreases .
since the mean free path can not be much smaller than the lattice constant , the result in fig .
1c represent the largest possible @xmath49-wave contribution for normal metals
. however , the @xmath49-wave contribution may be even larger for other materials , e.g. , semimetals , with lower carrier concentration than in normal metals .
this fact has already been pointed out by pendry : the p - wave contribution for short distances is expected to be maximal when the function @xmath108^{-1}\ ] ] is maximal with respect to variations in @xmath109 .
this gives : @xmath110 where we have used that typical frequencies @xmath111 . since the dc resistivity @xmath112 we get ( at room temperature ) @xmath113 . to illustrate this case , fig .
2 shows the thermal flux as a function of the separation @xmath1 between the surfaces when @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
one body is at zero temperature and the other at @xmath116 .
3 shows the thermal flux as a function of the resistivity of the solids .
again we assume that one body is at zero temperature and the other at @xmath116 .
the solid surfaces are separated by @xmath117 and @xmath118 . the heat flux for other separations
can be obtained using scaling @xmath119 which holds for high - resistivity materials .
finally , we note that thin high - resistivity coatings can drastically increase the heat transfer between two solids .
this is illustrated in fig .
4 shows the heat flux when thin films ( @xmath120 ) of high resistivity material @xmath121 , are deposited on silver .
one body is at zero temperature and the other at @xmath116 .
( a ) and ( b ) shows the @xmath49 and @xmath48-contributions , respectively .
also shown are the heat flux when the two bodies are made from silver , and from the high resistivity material .
it is interesting to note that while the @xmath49-contribution to the heat flux for the coated surfaces is strongly influenced by the coating , the @xmath48-contribution is nearly unaffected .
it was pointed by pendry @xcite the local heating of a surface by stm tip can be used for local modification of a surface if the heat transfer is sufficiently great . to investigate the power of a hot tip to heat a surface pendry modeled the tip as a hot sphere of the same radius @xmath122 as the tip .
this is a common approximation when calculating tunneling current and the same arguments justify its use for calculating heat tunneling .
pendry considered the case @xmath123 and the electrostatic limit .
however at large distances retardation effects can be important .
in fact , it will be shown below that the heat transfer between a sphere and surface in the asymptotic limit ( large separation ) can be obtained directly from formula ( [ seventyone ] ) .
consider distances @xmath124 ( at @xmath125 we have @xmath126 @xmath127 ) . in this case
we can neglect by the first integral in ( [ fourtyfour ] ) , put @xmath128 , and extend the integral to the whole @xmath129 - plane . using these approximations , the second integral in ( [ seventyone ] )
can be written as @xmath130\right\}. \label{fourtyeight}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , assume that the medium @xmath131 is sufficiently rarefied and consist of particles with the radius @xmath132 , and the polarizability @xmath133 .
then @xmath134 , where @xmath135 is the number of particles per unit volume .
thus , when @xmath136 it is enough to include only the first- non - vanishing terms in the expansion of the integrand of eq.([fourtyeight ] ) in powers of @xmath137 . the heat transfer between one particle and a surface can be obtained as the ratio between the change of heat transfer after displacement of body @xmath131 by small distance @xmath138 , and the number of particle in a slab with thickness @xmath138 : @xmath139 to treat this expression we assume that @xmath140 holds for all relevant frequencies . in the limit @xmath141 , where @xmath142 is taken at the characteristic frequency @xmath143 , the reflection factor of @xmath49-wave becomes @xmath144 the polarizability of the sphere is determined by @xmath145 we describe the sphere the same dielectric function as the substrate : @xmath146 where @xmath147 is the drude relaxation time and @xmath148 the plasma frequency . in this case
the @xmath49-wave contribution becomes @xmath149 this result is in an agreement with calculations of pendry @xcite . to evaluate the @xmath48-wave contribution in the limit @xmath141
, we use the integral @xmath150 where @xmath151 .
thus , @xmath152 from the comparison ( [ fifty ] ) and ( [ fiftyone ] ) the @xmath48-wave contribution exceeds the @xmath49-wave contribution for @xmath153 ; for typical metals at room temperature , @xmath154 and @xmath155 so that @xmath156 .
for @xmath157 we obtain @xmath158 for @xmath159 we obtain the @xmath48-wave contribution @xmath160 assume now that the spherical particle is so close to the surface that we can neglect retardation effects . in this case the problem is reduced to finding of electrostatic potential created by point charge , located in vacuum .
using image theorem @xcite the electrostatic potential can be written in the form @xmath161 where we have choosen the origin of the coordinate system at the center @xmath162 of the spherical particle , and taken the polar axis along the line connecting @xmath162 with the center of image " sphere @xmath163 , and assumed that the points @xmath23 and @xmath31 have the polar coordinates @xmath164 and @xmath165 with respect @xmath162 ; @xmath166 is the image " of @xmath31 ; @xmath167 where @xmath168 is the vector connecting the centers @xmath162 and @xmath163 .
@xmath169 and @xmath170 is the associated legendre function ( see fig.5 ) . at any interior point of the sphere
the resultant potential is @xmath171 we expand the potential ( [ none ] ) in the spherical harmonics around the center @xmath162 using the formulas @xcite @xmath172 where @xmath173 for @xmath174 . using ( [ ntwo])-([nthree ] ) we can rewrite ( [ none ] ) in the form @xmath175 across the surface of the sphere the green function @xmath41 ( as the function of @xmath23 ) , and its normal derivatives must be continuous .
these boundary conditions lead to the equation @xmath176 outside the sphere the function @xmath177 satisfies to laplace s equation and can be expanded as @xmath178 using ( [ nfive ] ) in ( [ nfour ] ) and taking into account that equation ( [ nfour ] ) must be satisfied at arbitrary @xmath179 we obtain equations for coefficients @xmath180 and @xmath181 @xmath182 if we make the replacement @xmath183 then from ( [ nsix ] ) and ( [ nseven ] ) we obtain @xmath184 let us introduce the dimensionless coefficients @xmath185 @xmath186 where @xmath187 @xmath188 .
the coefficients @xmath185 obey the equation @xmath189 the solution of ( [ bone ] ) can be found by iterations and has the form @xmath190 using ( [ nsix ] ) and ( [ nseven ] ) formula ( [ nnone ] ) can be significantly simplified @xmath191 using ( [ nntwo ] ) in ( [ aone ] ) we obtain @xmath192 using ( [ atwo ] ) in ( [ twelve ] ) for the heat transfer between a sphere and a flat surface we obtain @xmath193 the above formalism gives , in principle , an exact solution of the problem in the non - retarded limit .
however , for @xmath194 extensive numerical calculation are necessary , because in this case the series converge slowly .
the numerical results will be presented elsewhere . in the present publication we only present an approximate solution of the problem .
using image theorem for @xmath195 and for the points @xmath23 and @xmath31 close to the surface of the sphere , in the first approximation in the expansion of the electrostatic potential in the sum of the potentials created by the image charges we can write the potential in the form @xmath196 where @xmath197 @xmath198 and @xmath199 . the value of the surface integral ( [ aone ] ) does not change if we assume that the potential has the form ( [ eone ] ) in all space outside a sphere . thus using the green s theorem
we can convert the surface integral to a volume integral over all space outside a sphere .
this volume integral can be easily calculated using the fact that outside a sphere the potential @xmath41 obeys the poisson s equation with the point charges located at @xmath200 , and @xmath201 . performing the calculation
gives : @xmath202 using ( [ cone ] ) in ( [ twelve ] ) for the heat transfer between a sphere and a flat surface we obtain @xmath203 ^ 2 } \approx \frac{\pi } { 30}\frac{r}{d}\sigma_1^{-1}\sigma_2^{-1}\hbar^{-3}k_b^4 ( t_1 ^ 4-t_2 ^ 4 ) , \label{ctwo}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath204 .
if we assume that in an accordance with ( [ fifty ] ) every the elementary volume of the sphere gives the contribution to the heat transfer @xmath205 then after integration of ( [ cthree ] ) over the volume of the sphere we obtain the result of the same order magnitude as ( [ ctwo ] ) . because for @xmath206 in the accordance with ( [ fiftyone ] ) the @xmath48-contribution of small particle does not depend on
the separation @xmath1 formula ( [ fiftyone ] ) is valid also for small separation @xmath1 . from the comparison ( [ ctwo ] ) and ( [ fiftyone ] )
we get that for the sphere close to the surface @xmath48-contribution dominates for @xmath207 for `` normal '' metal at room temperature @xmath208 .
let us now consider the heat transfer between an stm tip , which we again model by a spherical particle with radius @xmath209 and the polarizability @xmath210 , and a spherical particle with radius @xmath211 and the polarizability @xmath212 located on a surface .
we consider the case of large separation @xmath213 , and neglect by influence of the substrate on the heat transfer . at large distances the thermal electromagnetic field radiated by particle @xmath6
can be considered as the radiative electromagnetic field of a fluctuating point dipole @xmath214 with ensemble average @xmath215 the electric field of this point dipole is given by @xmath216\left(\frac 1{r^3}- \frac{\mathrm{i}k}{r^2}\right)e^{\mathrm{i}kr}-k^2[\mathbf{n}(\mathbf{n\cdot p}^f)-\mathbf{p}^f ] \frac{e^{\mathrm{i}kr}}{r } , \label{fiftytwo}\ ] ] where @xmath217 and where @xmath218 is a unit vector along the axis connecting the two particle .
the rate at which a particle @xmath219 does work on a particle @xmath220 is determined by @xmath221 after absorption in the particle @xmath7 this work is converted into heat . in the same manner
we can calculate the rate of cooling of particle @xmath7 using the same formula by reciprocity .
thus the total heat transfer between the particles will determined by @xmath222 \mathrm{im}\alpha_1(\omega)\mathrm{im}\alpha_2(\omega ) \nonumber \\
\times\left(\frac 6{d^6}+\frac{2k^2}{d^4}+\frac{2k^4}{d^2}\right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] using for the polarizabilities of particles expression ( [ sixty ] ) we obtain @xmath223,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath224 .
the heat transfer studied above is closely related to the frictional stress between bodies in relative motion , separated by a vacuum gap . in the last years
this `` vacuum '' friction has attracted a great attention in the connection with the development of the scanning probe technique @xcite . in @xcite
we show that the frictional stress between the bodies having flat parallel surfaces separated by a distance @xmath1 and moving with velocity @xmath225 relative to each other is determined by formula which is very similar to ( [ seventyone ] ) : @xmath226\left(- \frac { \partial n(\omega ) } { \partial \omega}\right ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac { \hbar v}{4\pi ^3}\int_0^\infty \mathrm{d}\omega \int_{q>\omega /c}% \mathrm{d}^2q q^2\mathrm{e}^{-2\mid p\mid d } \nonumber \\ & & \times \frac{\mathrm{im}r_{1p}(\omega ) \mathrm{im}% r_{2p}(\omega ) } { \mid 1-\mathrm{e}^{-2\mid p\mid d}r_{1p}(\omega ) r_{2p}(\omega)\mid ^2}\left(- \frac { \partial n(\omega ) } { \partial \omega}\right ) \nonumber \\ & & \left .
+ \left [ p\rightarrow s\right ] \label{cfive } \right.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the distances @xmath227 this formula is reduced to : @xmath228\right\ } , \label{csix}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is very similar to the corresponding heat - transfer formula ( [ fourtyeight ] ) . for @xmath229 , where @xmath230 is taken at the characteristic frequency @xmath143 , the @xmath49- wave contribution is given by @xcite @xmath231 and for @xmath232 : @xmath233 for @xmath229 , the @xmath48-wave contribution @xmath234 becomes independent of @xmath1 : @xmath235 for @xmath236 we have : @xmath237 from the comparison ( [ cseven ] ) and ( [ done ] ) we find that @xmath238 for @xmath239 .
for typical metal at room temperature this corresponds to @xmath240 .
this is in drastic constant to the ( conservative ) van der waals interaction , where the retardation effects become important only for @xmath241 @xcite .
finally we carry out the transition to frictional stress between a particle with the radius @xmath132 and semi - infinite body in ( [ csix ] ) . to do this
, we assume as in sec.4 that the body @xmath242 is sufficiently rarefied , i.e. , that the difference @xmath243 is small . keeping only the first non - vanishing terms in the expansion of the integrand of ( [ csix ] ) in powers of these difference
, we get formula similar to ( [ fourtynine ] ) : @xmath244 in the limit @xmath141 the reflection factor of @xmath49-wave is determined by ( [ dthree ] ) and in ( [ dtwo ] ) the @xmath49-wave contribution is reduced to the formula , which was obtained by tomassone and widom @xcite . for the spherical particle in this limit
we get @xmath245 and for @xmath246 we get @xmath247 for @xmath141 , @xmath234 is independent of @xmath1 : @xmath248 and for @xmath246 we get : @xmath249 from the comparison ( [ fone ] ) and ( [ fthree ] ) we get that @xmath250 for @xmath251 . for normal metal at room temperature @xmath252 . for @xmath246 @xmath253 .
to estimate @xmath254 for @xmath255 we use the same approach as in sec .
we define the frictional stress between the elementary volume @xmath256 and the semi - infinite body as @xmath257 , where @xmath254 is given by an expression for a spherical particle for @xmath132 .
after integration over the volume of the sphere for @xmath258 we get : @xmath259 because in this limit @xmath234 does not depend on @xmath1 , it is still determined by ( [ ffour ] ) . from ( [ ffour ] ) and ( [ ffive ] ) we get that @xmath250 for @xmath260 for `` normal '' metal at room temperature and @xmath261 , @xmath208 .
recently , dorofeev _
et.al_. @xcite have observed brownian motion of a small metal particle connected by a spring to a holder , and located in ultrahigh vacuum in the vicinity of a gold surface .
it was observed that the particle performed a stochastic oscillatory motion increased as the particle approach the gold surface .
it was suggested that this increased damping is due to the coupling to the fluctuating electromagnetic field . from ( [ fthree ] ) and ( [ ffive ] ) we can estimate the damping constant @xmath262 . for @xmath263 , and for `` normal '' metal at room temperature
we get @xmath264 and @xmath265 .
however in the experiment @xcite @xmath266 .
thus the contribution of a fluctuating electromagnetic field to the damping constant can not explain the observed experimental date .
this result is in an agreement with our earlier conclusion @xcite .
the fluctuating electromagnetic field is an origin of the frictional drag , observed between parallel two - dimensional electron systems @xcite . in the frictional drag experiments a current
is drawn in the first layer , while the second layer is an open circuit .
thus no dc - current can flow in the second layer , but an induced electric field occur that opposes the `` drag force '' from the first layer .
recently we used the theory of a fluctuating electromagnetic field to calculate frictional drag force between two - dimensional electron systems @xcite . for frictional drag stress we found formula , which is very similar to ( [ cfive ] ) .
we found that for modulation - doped semiconductor quantum wells retardation effects are not important under typical experimental conditions , supporting earlier calculations where retardation effects always have been neglected @xcite .
a striking new result we found is that for systems with high 2d - electron density , e.g. , thin metallic films , retardation effects becomes crucial and in fact dominate the frictional shear stress @xmath254 .
we have developed a general formalism for the calculation of the radiative heat transfer between two bodies of arbitrary shape and properties .
the formalism has been applied to three different cases , namely the heat transfer between ( a ) two flat surfaces , ( b ) a spherical particle and a flat surface , and ( c ) between two spherical particles . for two flat solid surfaces
we have presented numerical results for several cases of practical importance , namely for two `` normal '' ( high conductivity ) metals ( silver ) , two ( high resistivity ) semi - metals and two silver metals coated by thin layers ( @xmath267 ) of high resistivity material . for high - resistivity metals the @xmath49-wave contribution dominates , but for `` normal '' ( high conductivity ) metals we found the remarkable result that the @xmath48-wave contribution dominates even for short separation between the solids .
we have pointed out the close relation ship between the radiative heat transfer between two solids and the vacuum friction [ .. ] which occur when one of the solids slide relative to the other solid .
the formalism developed in this paper may can be generalized to treat the vacuum friction between bodies with curved surfaces .
1 ( a ) the heat transfer flux between two semi - infinite silver bodies , one at temperature @xmath268 and another at @xmath269 .
( b ) the same as ( a ) except that we have reduced the drude electron relaxation time @xmath270 for solid 1 from a value corresponding to a mean free path @xmath271 to @xmath106 .
( c ) the same as ( a ) except that we have reduced @xmath95 to @xmath272 .
3 the thermal flux as a function of the resistivity of the solids .
the solid surfaces are separated by @xmath117 and @xmath118 .
the heat flux for other separations can be obtained using scaling @xmath119 which holds for high - resistivity materials .
4 . the heat flux between two semi - infinite silver bodies coated with @xmath274 high resistivity ( @xmath275 ) material . also shown is the heat flux between two silver bodies , and two high - resistivity bodies .
one body is at zero temperature and the other at @xmath116 .
( a ) and ( b ) shows the @xmath49 and @xmath48-contributions , respectively .
m.s.tomassone and a.widom , phys.rev .
b * 56 * , 4938 , ( 1997 ) t.j.gramila , j.p.eisenstein , a.h.macdonald , l.n.pfeiffer , and k.w.west , phys.rev . * 66 * , 1216 ( 1991 ) ; surface.sci . , * 263 * , 446 , ( 1992 ) ; phys.rev .
b * 47*,12 957 , ( 1993 ) ; physica b * 197 * , 442 , ( 1994 ) . | we simplify the formalism of polder and van hove [ phys.rev.b * 4 * , 3303(1971 ) ] , which was developed to calculate the heat transfer between macroscopic and nanoscale bodies of arbitrary shape , dispersive and adsorptive dielectric properties . in the non - retarded limit , at small distances between the bodies ,
the problem is reduced to the solution of an electrostatic problem .
we apply the formalism to the study of the heat transfer between : ( a ) two parallel semi - infinite bodies , ( b ) a semi - infinite body and a spherical body , and ( c ) that two spherical bodies .
we consider the dependence of the heat transfer on the temperature @xmath0 , the shape and the separation @xmath1 .
we determine when retardation effects become important . |
the van emde boas data structure ( veb ) @xcite represents an ordered multiset of integers .
the data structure supports query operations for the current minimum and maximum element , the predecessor and successor of a given element , and the element closest to a given number , as well as the operations of insertion and deletion .
each operation requires @xmath5 time , where the elements are taken from a universe @xmath6 .
we give variants of the veb data structure that are faster than the original veb , but only guarantee approximately correct answers .
the notion of approximation is the following : the operations are guaranteed to be consistent with the behavior of the corresponding exact data structure that operates on the elements after they are mapped by a fixed function @xmath7 . for the multiplicatively approximate variant , the function @xmath7 preserves the order of any two elements differing by at least a factor of some @xmath8 . for the additively approximate variant , the function @xmath7 preserves the order of any two elements differing additively by at least some @xmath9 .
let the elements be taken from a universe @xmath10 $ ] . on an arithmetic ram with @xmath11-bit words , the times required per operation in our approximate data structures are as follows : @xmath12 [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] @xmath12 the space requirements of our data structures are @xmath13 and @xmath14 , respectively .
the space can be reduced to close to linear in the number of elements by using dynamic hashing .
specifically , the space needed is @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the set of elements , @xmath7 is the fixed function mapping the elements of @xmath16 ( hence , @xmath17 is the number of distinct elements under the mapping ) , and @xmath18 is the time required per operation .
the overhead incurred by using dynamic hashing is constant per memory access with high probability @xcite .
thus , if the data structures are implemented to use nearly linear space , the times given per operation hold only with high probability . [
sec : description ] the approach is simple to explain , and we illustrate it for the multiplicative variant with @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
let @xmath21 ( the index of @xmath22 s most significant bit ) .
the mapping preserves the order of any two elements differing by more than a factor of two and effectively reduces the universe size to @xmath23 . on an arithmetic ram with @xmath11-size words ,
a bit - vector for the mapped elements fits in a single word , so that successor and predecessor queries can be computed with a few bitwise and arithmetic operations .
the only additional structures are a linked list of the elements and a dictionary mapping bit indices to list elements .
in general , each of the approximate problems with universe size @xmath24 reduces to the exact problem with a smaller universe size @xmath25 : for the case of multiplicative approximation we have size @xmath26 and for the case of additive approximation @xmath27 each reduction is effectively reversible , yielding an equivalence between each approximate problem and the exact problem with a smaller universe .
the equivalence holds generally for any numeric data type whose semantics depend only on the ordering of the elements .
the equivalence has an alternate interpretation : each approximate problem is equivalent to the exact problem on a machine with larger words .
thus , it precludes faster approximate variants that do nt take advantage of fast operations on words . for universe sizes bigger than the number of bits in a word
, we apply the recursive divide - and - conquer approach from the original veb data structure .
each operation on a universe of size @xmath25 reduces to a single operation on a universe of size @xmath28 plus a few constant time operations . when the universe size is @xmath11 , only a small constant number of arithmetic and bitwise operations are required .
this gives a running time of @xmath29 , where @xmath25 is the effective universe size after applying the universe reduction from the approximate to the exact problem . in the next section
we motivate our development of approximate veb data structures by demonstrating how they can be used in three well - known algorithms : prim s algorithm for minimum spanning trees , dijkstra s shortest paths algorithm , and an on - line version of the graham scan for finding convex hulls .
related work is discussed in section [ sec : related ] .
our model of computation is defined in section [ sec : model ] . in section [ sec : veb ] , we show how to construct our approximate veb data structures and we analyze their characteristics .
we make concluding remarks in section [ sec : conclusions ] .
we consider three prototypical applications : to minimum spanning trees , to single - source shortest paths , and to semi - dynamic on - line convex hulls .
our approximate minimum spanning tree algorithm runs in linear time and is arguably simpler and more practical than the two known linear - time mst algorithms .
our approximate single - source shortest paths algorithm is faster than any known algorithm on sparse graphs .
our on - line convex hull algorithm is also the fastest known in its class ; previously known techniques require preprocessing and thus are not suitable for on - line or dynamic problems .
the first two applications are obtained by substituting our data structures into standard , well - known algorithms .
the third is obtained by a straightforward adaptation of an existing algorithm to the on - line case .
these examples are considered mainly as prototypical applications . in general , approximate data structures can be used in place of any exact counterpart .
our results below assume a ram with a logarithmic word size as our model of computation , described in more detail in section [ sec : model ] .
the proofs are simple and are given in the full paper . for the minimum spanning tree problem ,
we show the following result about the performance of prim s algorithm @xcite when our approximate veb data structure is used to implement the priority queue : [ thm : prim ] given a graph with edge weights in @xmath30 , prim s algorithm , when implemented with our approximate veb with multiplicative error @xmath31 , finds a @xmath31-approximate minimum spanning tree in an @xmath3-node , @xmath32-edge graph in @xmath33 time .
for @xmath34 , theorem [ thm : prim ] gives a linear - time algorithm .
this algorithm is arguably simpler and more practical than the two known linear - time mst algorithms .
this application is a prototypical example for which the use of an approximate data structure is equivalent to slightly perturbing the input .
approximate data structures can be `` plugged in '' to such algorithms without modifying the algorithm . for the single - source shortest paths problem ,
we get the following result by using an approximate veb data structure as a priority queue in dijkstra s algorithm ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ?
* thm 7.6 ) ) : [ thm : shortestpaths ] given a graph with edge weights in @xmath6 and any @xmath35 , dijkstra s algorithm , when implemented with our approximate veb with multiplicative error @xmath36 , computes single - source shortest path distances within a factor of @xmath31 in @xmath37 time .
if @xmath38 , the algorithm runs in @xmath39 time faster than any known algorithm on sparse graphs and is simpler than theoretically competitive algorithms .
this is a prototypical example of an algorithm for which the error increases by the multiplicative factor at each step .
if such an algorithm runs in polynomial time , then @xmath1 time per veb operation can be obtained with insignificant net error .
again , this speed - up can be obtained with no adaptation of the original algorithm .
* analysis . *
the proof of theorem [ thm : shortestpaths ] follows the proof of the exact shortest paths algorithm ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ?
* thm 7.6 ) ) .
the crux of the proof is an inductive claim , saying that any vertex @xmath40 that becomes labeled during or after the scanning of a vertex @xmath41 also satisfies @xmath42 , where @xmath43 is a so - called tentative distance from the source to @xmath40 .
when using a @xmath31-approximate veb data structure to implement the priority queue , the inductive claim is replaced by @xmath44 where vertex @xmath41 is the @xmath22th vertex to be scanned .
thus , the accumulated multiplicative error is bounded by @xmath45 we leave the details to the full paper , and only note that it is not difficult to devise an example where the error is actually accumulated exponentially at each iteration .
finally , we consider the semi - dynamic on - line convex hull problem . in this problem ,
a set of planar points is processed in sequence .
after each point is processed , the convex hull of the points given so far must be computed .
queries of the form `` is @xmath46 in the current hull ? '' can also be given at any time .
for the approximate version , the hull computed and the answers given must be consistent with a @xmath47-approximate hull , which is contained within the true convex hull such that the distance of any point on the true hull to the approximate hull is @xmath48 times the diameter .
we show the following result about the graham scan algorithm @xcite when run using our approximate veb data structure : [ on - line ch ] the on - line @xmath47-approximate convex hull can be computed by a graham scan in constant amortized time per update if @xmath49 for any fixed @xmath50 , and in @xmath1 amortized time per update if @xmath51 .
this represents the first constant - amortized - time - per - query approximation algorithm for the on - line problem .
this example demonstrates the usefulness of approximate data structures for dynamic / on - line problems .
related approximate sorting techniques require preprocessing , which precludes their use for on - line problems .
* analysis .
* graham s scan algorithm is based on scanning the points according to an order determined by their polar representation , relative to a point that is in the convex hull , and maintaining the convex hull via local corrections .
we adapt graham s scan to obtain our on - line algorithm , as sketched below . as an invariant
, we have a set of points that are in the intermediate convex hull , stored in an approximate veb according to their angular coordinates .
the universe is @xmath52 $ ] with a @xmath9 additive error , which can be interpreted as the perturbation error of points in their angular coordinate , without changing their values in the distance coordinates .
this results in point displacements of at most @xmath47 times the diameter of the convex hull .
given a new point , its successor and predecessor in the veb are found , and the operations required to check the convex hull and , if necessary , to correct it are carried on , as in graham s algorithm @xcite .
these operations may include the insertion of the new point into the veb ( if the point is on the convex hull ) and the possible deletion of other points .
since each point can only be deleted once from the convex hull , the amortized number of veb operations per point is constant .
our work was inspired by and improves upon data structures developed for use in dynamic random variate generation by matias , vitter , and ni @xcite .
approximation techniques such as rounding and bucketing have been widely used in algorithm design .
this is the first work we know of that gives a general - purpose approximate data structure . *
finite precision arithmetic .
* the sensitivity of algorithms to approximate data structures is related in spirit to the challenging problems that arise from various types of error in numeric computations .
such errors has been studied , for example , in the context of computational geometry @xcite .
we discuss this further in section [ sec : conclusions ] .
* approximate sorting .
* bern , karloff , raghavan , and schieber @xcite introduced _
approximate sorting _ and applied it to several geometric problems .
their results include an @xmath53-time algorithm that finds a @xmath31-approximate euclidean minimum spanning tree .
they also gave an @xmath54-time algorithm that finds a @xmath47-approximate convex hull for any @xmath55 1/polynomial . in a loose sense ,
approximate veb data structures generalize approximate sorting .
the advantages of an approximate veb are the following .
an approximate veb bounds the error for each element individually .
thus , an approximate veb is applicable for problems such as the general minimum spanning tree problem , for which the answer depends on only a subset of the elements .
the approximate sort of bern _ et al .
_ bounds the _ net _ error , which is not sufficient for such problems .
more importantly , a veb is dynamic , so is applicable to dynamic problems such as on - line convex hull and in algorithms such as dijkstra s algorithm in which the elements to be ordered are not known in advance .
sorting requires precomputation , so is not applicable to such problems .
* convex hull algorithms .
* there are several relevant works for the on - line convex hull problem .
shamos ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) gave an on - line algorithm for ( exact ) convex hull that takes @xmath56 amortized time per update step .
preparata @xcite gave a _
real - time _ on - line ( exact ) convex hull algorithm with @xmath56-time worst - case time per update step .
bentley , faust , and preparata @xcite give an @xmath57-time algorithm that finds a @xmath47-approximate convex hull .
their result was superseded by the result of bern _
et al . _
mentioned above .
janardan @xcite gave an algorithm maintaining a fully dynamic @xmath58-approximate convex hull ( allowing deletion of points ) in @xmath59 time per request .
our on - line approximation algorithm is based on graham s scan algorithm @xcite and can be viewed as a combination of the algorithms by shamos and by bentley _
et al . _ , with the replacement of an exact veb data structure by an approximate variant . *
computation with large words . *
kirkpatrick and reich @xcite considered exact sorting with large words , giving upper and lower bounds .
their interest was theoretical , but lemma [ equivlemma ] , which in some sense says that maintaining an approximate veb data structure is equivalent to maintaining an exact counterpart using larger words , suggests that lower bounds on computations with large words are relevant to _ approximate _ sorting and data structures . * exploiting the power of ram .
* fredman and willard have considered a number of data structures taking advantage of arithmetic and bitwise operations on words of size @xmath60 . in
@xcite , they presented the _ fusion tree _ data structure . briefly , fusion trees implement the veb data type in time @xmath61 .
they also presented an _
atomic heap _ data structure @xcite based on their fusion tree and used it to obtain a linear - time minimum spanning tree algorithm and an @xmath62-time single - source shortest paths algorithm .
willard @xcite also considered similar applications to related geometric and searching problems .
generally , these works assume a machine model similar to ours and demonstrate remarkable theoretical consequences of the model . on the other hand , they are more complicated and involve larger constants .
subsequent to our work klein and tarjan recently announced a randomized minimum spanning tree algorithm that requires only expected linear time @xcite .
arguably , our algorithm is simpler and more practical .
the model of computation assumed in this paper is a modernized version of the _ random access machine _ ( ram ) .
many ram models of a similar nature have been defined in the literature , dating back to the early 1960s @xcite .
our ram model is a realistic variant of the logarithmic - cost ram @xcite : the model assumes constant - time exact binary integer arithmetic ( @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 ) , bitwise operations ( @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 ) , and addressing operations on words of size @xmath11 .
put another way , the word size of the ram is @xmath11 .
we assume that numbers are of the form @xmath71 , where @xmath22 and @xmath72 are integers with @xmath73 , and that the numbers are represented with two words , the first holding @xmath22 and the second holding @xmath72 .
for simplicity of exposition , we use the `` most - significant - bit '' function @xmath74 ; it can be implemented in small constant time via the previously mentioned operations and has lower circuit complexity than , e.g. , division .
this section gives the details of our approximate veb data structure .
first we give the relevant semantics and notations .
the operations supported are : + + @xmath75 , + @xmath76 , + @xmath77 , + @xmath78 , + @xmath79 , + @xmath80 , + @xmath81 , + @xmath82 , and + @xmath83 .
+ + the @xmath84 operation and the query operations return the _ name _ @xmath85 of the element in question .
the name is just a pointer into the data structure allowing constant - time access to the element .
subsequent operations on the element are passed this pointer so they can access the element in constant time .
@xmath84 takes an additional parameter @xmath86 , an arbitrary auxiliary data item .
@xmath87 , where @xmath46 is a real number ( but not necessarily an element ) , returns the name of the largest element less than or equal to @xmath46 . for the approximate variants , the query operations are approximate in that the element returned by the query is within a @xmath88 relative factor or a @xmath9 absolute amount of the correct value .
operations @xmath89 and @xmath90 , given an element s name @xmath85 , return the element and its data item , respectively .
the universe ( specified by @xmath24 ) and , for the approximate variants , the error of approximation ( @xmath91 or @xmath9 ) are specified when the data structure is instantiated .
the lemma below assumes a logarithmic word - size ram .
the notion of equivalence between data structures is that , given one of the data structures , the other can be simulated with constant - time overhead per operation .
[ equivlemma ] the problem of representing a multiplicatively @xmath31-approximate veb on universe @xmath10 $ ] is equivalent to the problem of representing an exact veb on universe @xmath92 .
the problem of representing an additively @xmath9-approximate veb on universe @xmath93 $ ] is equivalent to the problem of representing an exact veb on universe @xmath94 .
assume we have a data structure for the exact data type on the specified universe . to simulate the multiplicatively approximate data structure ,
the natural mapping to apply to the elements ( as discussed previously ) is @xmath95 .
instead , we map @xmath46 to approximately @xmath96 and we use a mapping that is faster to compute : let @xmath97 , let @xmath98 , and let @xmath99 .
we use the mapping @xmath7 that maps @xmath46 to @xmath100 if @xmath101 , then to right - shift by @xmath102 means to left - shift by @xmath103 .
note that in this case the fractional part of @xmath46 is shifted in .
this mapping effectively maps @xmath46 to the lexicographically ordered pair @xmath104 , where @xmath105 represents the bits with indices @xmath106 though @xmath107 in @xmath46 .
the first part of the tuple distinguishes between any two @xmath46 values that differ in their most significant bit .
if two @xmath46 values have @xmath108 , then it suffices to distinguish them if they differ additively by @xmath109 .
the second part of the tuple suffices for this .
note that @xmath110 and @xmath111 .
this shows one direction of the first part .
the other direction of the first part is easily shown by essentially inverting the above mapping , so that distinct elements map to elements that differ by at least a factor of @xmath8 .
finally , the second part follows by taking the mapping @xmath112 and its inverse .
lemma [ equivlemma ] reduces the approximate problems to the exact problem with smaller universe size .
this section gives an appropriate solution to the exact problem .
if an approximate variant is to be implemented , we assume the elements have already been mapped by the constant - time function @xmath7 in lemma [ equivlemma ] . the model of computation is a ram with @xmath11-bit words .
a _ dictionary _ data structure supports update operations @xmath113 and @xmath114 and query operation @xmath115 ( returning the value , if any , associated with the key ) .
it is well known how to implement a dictionary by hashing in space proportional to the number of elements in the dictionary or in an array of size proportional to the key space . in either case ,
all dictionary operations require only constant time . in the former case ,
the time is constant with high probability @xcite ; in the latter case , a well - known trick is required to instantiate the dictionary in constant time .
each instance of our data structure will have a doubly - linked list of element / datum pairs .
the list is ordered by the ordering induced by the elements .
the name of each element is a pointer to its record in this list .
if the set to be stored is a multiset , as will generally be the case in simulating an approximate variant , then the elements will be replaced by buckets , which are doubly - linked lists holding the multiple occurrences of an element .
each occurrence holds a pointer to its bucket . in this case
the name of each element is a pointer to its record within its bucket .
each instance will also have a dictionary mapping each element in the set to its name .
if the set is a multiset , it will map each element to its bucket .
in general , the universe , determined when the data structure is instantiated , is of the form @xmath116 .
each instance records the appropriate @xmath117 and @xmath24 values and subtracts @xmath117 from each element , so that the effective universe is @xmath118 .
the ordered list and the dictionary suffice to support constant - time , , , and operations .
the other operations use the list and dictionary as follows .
@xmath119 finds the predecessor - to - be of @xmath22 by calling @xmath120 , inserts @xmath22 into the list after the predecessor , and updates the dictionary .
if @xmath16 is a multiset , @xmath22 is inserted instead into its bucket and the dictionary is updated only if the bucket did nt previously exist .
@xmath76 deletes the element from the list ( or from its bucket ) and updates the dictionary appropriately .
how @xmath121 works depends on the size of the universe .
the remainder of this section describes @xmath121 queries and how @xmath84 and @xmath122 maintain the additional structure needed to support @xmath121 queries . for a universe of size @xmath11 ,
the additional structure required is a single @xmath11-bit word @xmath40 .
as described in section [ sec : description ] , the word represents a bit vector ; the @xmath22th bit is 1 iff the dictionary contains an element @xmath22 .
@xmath84 sets this bit ; @xmath122 unsets it if no occurrences of @xmath22 remain in the set . setting or unsetting bits
can be done with a few constant time operations .
the @xmath120 operation is implemented as follows
. if the list is empty or @xmath22 is less than the minimum element , return * nil*. otherwise , let @xmath123 i.e. , let @xmath72 be the index of the most significant 1-bit in @xmath40 that is at most as significant as the @xmath22th bit . return @xmath72 s name from the dictionary .
* analysis .
* on universes of size @xmath11 , all operations require only a few constant - time operations . if hashing is used to implement the dictionary , the total space ( number of words ) required at any time is proportional to the number of elements currently in the set .
the fully recursive data structure is a straightforward modification of the original van emde boas data structure . for those not familiar with the original data structure , we first give an intermediate data structure that is conceptually simpler as a stepping stone .
the additional data structures to support @xmath120 for a universe @xmath124 are as follows .
divide the problem into @xmath125 subproblems : if the current set of elements is @xmath16 , let @xmath126 denote the set @xmath127 .
inductively maintain a veb data structure for each non - empty set @xmath126 .
note that the universe size for each @xmath126 is @xmath128 .
each @xmath126 can be a multiset only if @xmath16 is .
let @xmath129 denote the set @xmath130 .
inductively maintain a veb data structure for the set @xmath129 .
the datum for each element @xmath131 is the data structure for @xmath126 .
note that the universe size for @xmath129 is @xmath11 .
note also that @xmath129 need not support multi - elements .
implement @xmath120 as follows .
if @xmath22 is in the dictionary , return @xmath22 s name . otherwise , determine @xmath131 such that @xmath22 would be in @xmath126 if @xmath22 were in @xmath16 .
recursively search in @xmath129 for the largest element @xmath132 less than or equal to @xmath131 .
if @xmath133 or @xmath22 is less than the minimum element of @xmath126 , return the maximum element of @xmath134 .
otherwise , recursively search for the largest element less than or equal to @xmath22 in @xmath126 and return it .
@xmath84 and @xmath122 maintain the additional data structures as follows .
@xmath119 inserts @xmath22 recursively into the appropriate @xmath126 .
if @xmath126 was previously empty , it creates the data structure for @xmath126 and recursively inserts @xmath131 into @xmath129 .
@xmath76 recursively deletes the element from the appropriate @xmath126 .
if @xmath126 becomes empty , it deletes @xmath131 from @xmath129 . * analysis . *
because the universe of the set @xmath129 is of size @xmath11 , all operations maintaining @xmath129 take constant time .
thus , each @xmath121 , @xmath84 , and @xmath122 for a set with universe of size @xmath135 requires a few constant - time operations and possibly one recursive call on a universe of size @xmath128 .
thus , each such operation requires @xmath136 time . to analyze the space requirement , note that the size of the data structure depends only on the elements in the current set .
assuming hashing is used to implement the dictionaries , the space required is proportional to the number of elements in the current set plus the space that would have been required if the _
distinct _ elements of the current set had simply been inserted into the data structure . the latter space would be at worst proportional to the time taken for the insertions .
thus , the total space required is proportional to the number of elements plus @xmath137 times the number of distinct elements .
we exponentially decrease the above time by balancing the subdivision of the problem exactly as is done in the original van emde boas data structure .
the first modification is to balance the universe sizes of the set @xmath129 and the sets @xmath138 .
assume the universe size is @xmath139 .
note that @xmath140 .
define @xmath141 and define @xmath142 .
note that the universe size of each @xmath126 _ and _ of @xmath129 is @xmath143 . with this modification , @xmath121 , @xmath84 , and @xmath122 are still well defined .
inspection of @xmath121 shows that if @xmath121 finds @xmath131 in @xmath129 , it does so in constant time , and otherwise it does not search recursively in @xmath126 .
thus , only one non - constant - time recursion is required , into a universe of size @xmath143 .
thus , @xmath121 requires @xmath144 time .
@xmath84 and @xmath122 , however , do not quite have this nice property . in the event that @xmath126 was previously empty
, @xmath84 descends recursively into both @xmath126 and @xmath129 .
similarly , when @xmath126 becomes empty , @xmath122 descends recursively into both @xmath126 and @xmath129 .
the following modification to the data structure fixes this problem , just as in the original van emde boas data structure .
note that @xmath84 only updates @xmath129 when an element is inserted into an empty @xmath126 .
similarly , @xmath122 only updates @xmath129 when the last element is deleted from the set @xmath126 .
modify the data structure ( and all recursive data structures ) so that the recursive data structures exist only when @xmath145 . when @xmath146 , the single element is simply held in the list .
thus , insertion into an empty set and deletion from a set of one element require only constant time .
this insures that if @xmath84 or @xmath122 spends more than constant time in @xmath129 , it will require only constant time in @xmath126 .
this modification requires that when @xmath16 has one element and a new element is inserted , instantiates the recursive data structures and inserts both elements appropriately .
the first element inserted will bring both @xmath129 and some @xmath126 to size one ; this requires constant time . if the second element is inserted into the same set @xmath126 as the first element , @xmath129 is unchanged .
otherwise , the insertion into its newly created set @xmath134 requires only constant time . in either case ,
only one non - constant - time recursion is required .
similarly , when @xmath16 has two elements and one of them is deleted , after the appropriate recursive deletions , destroys the recursive data structures and leaves the data structure holding just the single remaining element .
if the two elements were in the same set @xmath126 , then @xmath129 was already of size one , so only the deletion from @xmath126 requires more than constant time .
otherwise , each set @xmath126 and @xmath134 was already of size one , so only the deletion of the second element from @xmath129 took more than constant time . * analysis . * with the two modifications , each @xmath121 , @xmath84 , and @xmath122 for a universe of size @xmath147 requires at most one non - constant - time recursive call , on a set with universe size @xmath143 .
thus , the time required for each operation is @xmath148 . as for the intermediate data structure ,
the total space is at worst proportional to the number of elements , plus the time per operation ( now @xmath149 ) times the number of distinct elements .
the approximate data structures described in this paper are simple and efficient .
no large constants are hidden in the asymptotic notations in fact , a `` back of the envelope '' calculation indicates significant speed - up in comparison to the standard van emde boas data structure .
the degree of speed - up in practice will depend upon the machines on which they are implemented .
machines on which binary arithmetic and bitwise operations on words are nearly as fast as , say , comparison between two words will obtain the most speed - up .
practically , our results encourage the development of machines which support fast binary arithmetic and bitwise operations on large words .
theoretically , our results suggest the need for a model of computation that more accurately measures the cost of operations that are considered to require constant time in traditional models .
the applicability of approximate data structures to specific algorithms depends on the robustness of such algorithms to inaccurate intermediate computations . in this sense
, the use of approximate data structures has an effect similar to computational errors that arise from the use of finite precision arithmetic . in recent years
there has been an increasing interest in studying the effect of such errors on algorithms .
of particular interest were algorithms in computational geometry .
frameworks such as the `` epsilon geometry '' of guibas , salesin and stolfi @xcite may be therefore relevant in our context .
the `` robust algorithms '' described by fortune and milenkovic @xcite are natural candidates for approximate data structures .
expanding the range of applications of approximate data structures is a fruitful area for further research .
other possible candidates include algorithms in computational geometry that use the well - known sweeping technique , provided that they are appropriately robust . for instance , in the sweeping algorithm for the line arrangement problem with approximate arithmetic , presented by fortune and milenkovic @xcite , the priority queue can be replaced by an approximate priority queue with minor adjustments , to obtain an output with similar accuracy .
if the sweeping algorithm of chew and fortune @xcite can be shown to be appropriately robust then the use of the van emde boas priority queue there can be replaced by an approximate variant ; an improved running time may imply better performance for algorithms described in @xcite .
m. dietzfelbinger and f. meyer auf der heide . a new universal class of hash functions and dynamic hashing in real time , in _ proc .
of 17th international colloquium on automata languages and programming _ , springer lncs 443 : 619 , 1990 .
m. l. fredman and d. e. willard .
trans - dichotomous algorithms for minimum spanning trees and shortest paths . in _ proc . of the 31st ieee annual symp . on foundation of computer science _ , pages 719725 , 1990
l. i. guibas , d. salesin , and j. stolfi .
epsilon geometry : building robust algorithms from imprecise computations . in _ proc . of the 5th annual symposium on computational geometry _ ,
pages 208217 , 1989 .
r. janardan . on maintaining the width and diameter of a planar point - set online .
in _ proc .
2nd international symposium on algorithms _ , volume 557 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 137149 .
springer - verlag , 1991 . to appear in international journal of computational geometry & applications .
v. milenkovic .
double precision geometry : a general technique for calculating line and segment intersections using rounded arithmetic . in _ proc . of the 30th ieee annual symp . on foundation of computer science _ , 1989 | in this paper we introduce the notion of _ approximate data structures _ , in which a small amount of error is tolerated in the output .
approximate data structures trade error of approximation for faster operation , leading to theoretical and practical speedups for a wide variety of algorithms .
we give approximate variants of the van emde boas data structure , which support the same dynamic operations as the standard van emde boas data structure @xcite , except that answers to queries are approximate .
the variants support all operations in constant time provided the error of approximation is @xmath0 , and in @xmath1 time provided the error is @xmath2 , for @xmath3 elements in the data structure .
we consider the tolerance of prototypical algorithms to approximate data structures .
we study in particular prim s minimum spanning tree algorithm , dijkstra s single - source shortest paths algorithm , and an on - line variant of graham s convex hull algorithm .
to obtain output which approximates the desired output with the error of approximation tending to zero , prim s algorithm requires only linear time , dijkstra s algorithm requires @xmath4 time , and the on - line variant of graham s algorithm requires constant amortized time per operation . |
thermodynamic phase transitions are examples of emergent phenomena in many degrees of freedom systems , described in the framework of statistical mechanics .
the standard statistical ensembles measures relate macroscopic ( thermodynamic ) observables with microscopic degrees of freedom .
the interactions among the microscopic degrees of freedom - which can be either continuous or discrete ( as in the case of spin models , vertex models , and so on ) - are often described by a hamiltonian function ( or a hamiltonian operator in a quantum context ) @xcite .
but what about discrete systems , i.e. networks , undergoing a phase transition for which a microscopic hamiltonian does not exist ? a paradigmatic example
is represented by a random graphs model @xmath0 devised by choosing with uniform probability a graph from the set of all graphs having @xmath1 vertices and @xmath2 edges @xcite .
we can think of a process evolving by adding the edges one at a time .
when @xmath3 has the same order of magnitude of @xmath4 , the evolution from @xmath5 to @xmath6 yields , according to erds - rnyi theorem @xcite , a _ phase transition _ , revealing itself in a rapid growth with @xmath3 of the size of the largest component ( number of vertices fully connected by edges ) . specifically , the structure of graphs when the expected degree of each of its vertices is close to @xmath7 , i.e. @xmath8 , shows a jump : the order of magnitude of the size of the largest component of graphs rapidly grows , asymptotically almost surely , from @xmath9 to @xmath4 , if @xmath3 has the same order of magnitude of @xmath4 . in fact , if @xmath10 , as the process evolves , the components of a graph [ the largest of them being a.a.s . of size @xmath11
merge mainly by attaching small trees ; thus they grow slowly and quite smoothly .
nonetheless , at the same point of the process , the largest components become so large that it is likely for a new edge to connect two of them .
thus , fairly quickly , all the largest components of a graph merge into one giant component , much larger than any of the remaining ones @xcite .
it is worth noticing that this process represents the mean - field case of percolation @xcite .
regarding @xmath0 as a statistical ensemble it is quite natural to employ tools from statistical mechanics , above all entropy , to analyze it . in ref .
@xcite the gibbs entropy of such random graphs was defined as @xmath12 there , the configuration space was given by @xmath13 graphs with labelled nodes . due to their equiprobability
, they have the same weight , chosen to be @xmath14 in order to account for all the labelling permutations of the nodes .
later , the perspective was to modify the erds - rnyi ensemble by introducing a functional weight which explicitly depends on the graph s topology . in this way
one can eventually characterize other classes of random graphs , like scale free or fixed degree sequence , as well . a research line that has been pursued in the last decade
@xcite , also putting forward variants of the entropy measure @xcite .
however , we may notice that the entropy as a function of the ratio @xmath15 is unable itself to detect the phase transition occurring in the erds - rnyi ensemble . in the present work ,
focussing on the erds - rnyi ensemble , we propose a general method to associate a continuous mathematical object ( a riemannian manifold ) to a generic discrete system , graph or network , thus allowing the definition of a _ geometric entropy _ which is able to detect a phase transition .
actually , we endow each network with a statistical riemannian manifold . this can be obtained basically via two steps ; first by understanding a network as an undirected graph without loops on the nodes , and account for links ( weighted edges ) between nodes expressed by the adjacency matrix @xmath16 .
second , considering random variables as sitting on the vertices of a network , methods of information geometry @xcite can be employed to lift the network to a statistical riemannian manifold . in this way , we associate a configuration space to each network .
such a space consists of a subset of the linear vector space @xmath17 given by the parameters which characterize the joint probability distribution of the random variables sitting on the nodes of the network .
furthermore , this configuration space is endowed with a riemannian metric which is inspired by the well - known fisher - rao metric @xcite .
then , in analogy with classical statistical mechanics , we define a geometric entropy as the logarithm of the volume of this manifold . applied to erds - rnyi random graphs it proves very effective ( as a function of the ratio @xmath15 ) in detecting the appearance of the so called ` giant component ' as well as any smooth function of order parameters within the framework of statistical mechanics @xcite .
let us start considering a set of @xmath4 real - valued random variables @xmath18 characterized by the following multivariate gaussian probability distribution @xmath19 , \label{pxt}\ ] ] where @xmath20 with @xmath21 denoting the transposition and we have also assumed , without loss of generality , that all the mean values are zero .
furthermore , @xmath22 are the real valued parameters characterizing the above probability distribution function , i.e. the entries of the covariance matrix @xmath23 .
hence @xmath24 .
next we consider a family @xmath25 of such probability distributions @xmath26 where @xmath27 and the mapping @xmath28 is injective .
defined in such a way @xmath25 is an @xmath29-dimensional statistical model on @xmath30 .
the open set @xmath31 is defined as follows @xmath32 and we call it the parameter space of the @xmath29-dimensional statistical model @xmath25 . assuming parametrizations which are @xmath33 we can turn @xmath25 into a @xmath33 differentiable manifold @xcite .
then , given a point @xmath34 , the fisher information matrix of @xmath25 in @xmath34 is the @xmath35 matrix @xmath36 $ ] , where the @xmath37 entry is defined by @xmath38 with @xmath39 standing for @xmath40 .
the matrix @xmath41 is symmetric , positive semidefinite and endows the parameter space @xmath31 with a riemannian metric @xcite .
we highlight that the integral of eq .
with is a gaussian one and amounts to @xmath42f_{\mu\nu } |_{x=0 } , \label{gint}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the exponential stands for a power series expansion over its argument ( the differential operator ) and @xmath43\ \partial_\nu \log[p(x;\theta)].\ ] ] the derivative of the logarithm has the following expression @xmath44=-\frac 1 2\bigg[\frac{\partial_\mu(\det c)}{\det c } + \sum_{\alpha,\beta=1}^n \partial_\mu(c_{\alpha\beta}^{-1})x_\alpha x_\beta\bigg],\ ] ] where @xmath45 denotes the @xmath46 entry of the inverse of the covariance matrix @xmath23 in . the latter equation together with eq .
show the computational complexity of the eq . .
indeed , the well - known formulas @xmath47 require the calculation of @xmath48 derivatives with respect to the variables @xmath49 of eq . in order to work out the derivative of the logarithm in .
finally , to obtain the function @xmath50 in , we have to evaluate @xmath51 derivatives .
this quickly becomes an unfeasible task with growing @xmath4 , even numerically . in order to overcome the difficulty of explicitly computing the components of the fisher - rao metric
, we proceed by defining a new ( pseudo)-riemannian metric on the parameter space @xmath31 which account as well for the network structure given by the adjacency matrix @xmath16 . to this end
we consider first a trivial network with null adjacency matrix and interpret @xmath4 independent gaussian random variables @xmath52 as sitting on its vertices . in this particular case
, the joint probability distribution is given with a diagonal covariance matrix with entries given by @xmath53 .
let us denote this matrix as @xmath54 .
so , making use of eqs . and , the statistical riemannian manifold @xmath55 , with @xcite @xmath56 is associated to the _ bare _ network .
given the matrix @xmath57 $ ] , from it is evident that @xmath58 , where @xmath59 is the @xmath60 entry of the inverse matrix of @xmath54 given by @xmath61 , for all @xmath62 .
inspired by this functional form of @xmath63 , we propose to associate a ( pseudo)-riemannian manifold to any network @xmath64 with non vanishing adjacency matrix @xmath16 . to this aim , we consider the map @xmath65 defined by @xmath66 with @xmath67 denoting the set of the symmetric @xmath68 matrices over @xmath69 with vanishing diagonal elements that can represent any simple undirected graph .
then , we deform the manifold @xmath70 in via @xmath71 .
hence the manifold associated to a network @xmath64 with adjacency matrix @xmath16 is @xmath72 with @xmath73 and @xmath74 with components @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the @xmath77 entry of the inverse of the matrix @xmath78 . in this way , we associated a differentiable system ( riemannian manifold ) to a discrete system ( network ) through the description of network by a set of probability distribution functions .
some other ways to describe a network with probabilistic methods are also employed in literature . among them
it is worth mentioning the random walk method @xcite . here
the green function , meaning the transition amplitude from one vertex to another by accounting for all possible paths , gives rise to a metric @xcite , thus allowing as well for a geometric approach .
however the main difference is that in such a case one deals with a stationary transition probability originating from the adjacency matrix @xcite , in our case beside adjacency matrix also the variances of a gaussian distribution of random variables sitting on nodes of the network play a role ( namely a family of gaussian distributions ) .
we now define a geometric entropy of a network @xmath64 with adjacency matrix @xmath16 and associated manifold @xmath72 as @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the volume of @xmath81 evaluated from the element @xmath82 notice , however , that in such a way @xmath80 is ill - defined .
thus we regularize it as follows @xmath83 where @xmath84 is any suitable `` infrared '' and `` ultraviolet '' regularizing function ; @xmath78 and @xmath85 are given in and , respectively .
the need for regularization is twofold : the set @xmath86 in eq .
is not compact because the variables @xmath87 are unbounded from above ; furthermore , from eq .
, @xmath88 diverges since @xmath89 approaches zero for some @xmath87 .
a possible choice of @xmath90 has recently been defined @xcite , @xmath91,\ ] ] where @xmath23 is the covariance matrix in when off - diagonal entries are @xmath7 or @xmath92 . in the present work
we would extent such a regularizing function to a more general kind of networks , taking also into account the weights of links between vertices . however , the functional type should be still like in
. the definition is inspired by the microcanonical definition of entropy @xmath93 in statistical mechanics , that is @xmath94 , where @xmath95 is the phase space volume bounded by the hypersurface of constant energy @xmath96 .
after integration on the momenta one finds @xmath97^{n/2}\;dq^1\wedge\ldots\wedge dq^n $ ] , where @xmath98 is a constant stemming from the integration on the momenta , @xmath99 is the configuration space subset bounded by the equipotential level set @xmath100 , and @xmath101 are the configurational coordinates .
now , the term @xmath102^{n/2}$ ] is just @xmath103 , with @xmath104 the jacobi kinetic energy metric whose associated geodesic flow coincides with the underlying hamiltonian flow @xcite . in the end
the microcanonical entropy is @xmath105 , that is proportional to the logarithm of the volume of the riemannian manifold associated with the underlying dynamics . as already stated at the beginning of this paper , in order to assess the interest of the proposed geometric entropy in eq .
we check it against a system undergoing the classical erds - rnyi phase transition in random graphs @xcite .
we numerically compute @xmath106 , the geometric entropy in eq . vs @xmath3 for a fixed @xmath4 in order to investigate its sensitivity to the appearance of the giant component during the evolution of the random graph model @xmath0 . to this aim
, we consider four different numbers of vertices : @xmath107 .
the choice of @xmath4 determines the dimension of the associated manifold @xmath108 .
then , for a given @xmath4 , we choose the number of links @xmath3 , with @xmath109 .
next , for a given pair @xmath110 we generate at random a set of @xmath3 entries @xmath111 , with @xmath112 , of the non - vanishing adjacency matrix elements @xmath113 . hence , since the covariance matrix @xmath23 is functionally assigned , we get @xmath114 of eq . and finally the metric @xmath115 of eq .. now , having determined @xmath116 , we can compute the volume @xmath80 in eq . and the entropy @xmath117 of eq .. in numerical computations
the volume regularization is performed in two steps , the first one is by restricting the manifold support @xmath118 to an hypercube . inside @xmath119 we generate a markov chain , to perform a monte carlo estimate of the average @xmath120 the number of random configurations considered varies between @xmath121 and @xmath122 ; the second step of the regularization procedure of the volume is obtained by excluding those points where the value of @xmath123 exceeds @xmath124 ( the numerical overflow limit of the computers used ) . for any given pair @xmath110 this computational scheme is repeated @xmath125 times , each time considering a different randomly generated realisation of the adjacency matrix @xmath16 .
thus the final values of the entropy @xmath117 are obtained as averages on these @xmath125 different manifolds @xmath108 . in the figures [ bifurcation ] and [ linkweight ] we report the monte carlo numerical estimates of @xmath126 repeated for different values of @xmath3 ; here @xmath127 stands for the above mentioned average over the different realisations of the adjacency matrix @xmath16 , and @xmath63 is the metric corresponding to the null adjacency matrix . for all the four cases reported in figure [ bifurcation ] we have equal weights @xmath128 for all the @xmath3 non - vanishing links . of @xmath129 ( magenta points ) , @xmath130 ( black points ) , @xmath131 ( red points ) and @xmath132 ( blue points ) networks as a function of the number @xmath3 of randomly chosen links of weights equal to @xmath133 . the black solid line is a guide to the eye coming from a linear fitting of a linear - logarithmic presentation of the data.,width=302,height=226 ] of @xmath130 networks as a function of the number @xmath3 of randomly chosen links of weights equal to @xmath134 ( green points ) , @xmath133 ( red points ) and @xmath135 ( black points).,width=302,height=226 ] the reason for displaying @xmath136 of eq . instead of @xmath117 in and _
@xmath15 instead of @xmath3 is that one obtains what in the context of statistical mechanics is called a _ collapse plot _ of the results obtained at different @xmath4-values .
the corresponding points crowd on a common pattern for large @xmath3 whereas for @xmath15 ranging from @xmath92 to approximately @xmath7 the patterns obtained show a phenomenon which is familiar in the context of numerical investigations of second order phase transitions : as in the case of finite - size effects observed for the order parameter , what asymptotically would be a sharp bifurcation is rounded at finite @xmath4 @xcite ; however , the larger @xmath4 the more pronouced the ` knee ' of @xmath137 in the range @xmath138 .
this is clearly in excellent agreement with an @xmath4-asymptotic bifurcation at @xmath139 ( marked by the solid line ) where the erds - rnyi phase transition takes place . in figure [ linkweight ]
we report the outcomes for @xmath140 having set all the non - vanishing entries @xmath113 of the adjacency matrix again equal to a constant value @xmath141 . for @xmath134 a considerable softening of the shape of @xmath142
is observed ; this is of course an expected result since for @xmath143 the transition must disappear . for @xmath133 and @xmath135 the shapes of @xmath142
look almost the same , the only interesting difference being a slightly more pronounced ` knee ' in the @xmath135 case , which , going in the opposite direction , is coherent with the previous ones .
another interesting property of this entropy consists in its versatility , that is , it can be easily adapted to more refined descriptions of networks / graphs .
for example , we can consider a refined modeling of graphs where the entries of the @xmath68 adjacency matrix @xmath16 are given by terms of the form @xmath144 . here
the @xmath145s ( @xmath146 ) are the weights of the links between the nodes of the network described by @xmath16 .
furthermore , the @xmath87s ( @xmath147 ) are local coordinates on the manifold @xmath81 of eqs . and , representing the variances of the random variables on the nodes of the network .
networks as a function of the number @xmath3 of randomly chosen non - vanishing adjacency matrix elements @xmath113 of the form @xmath144 with @xmath148 . ]
this kind of model has an interesting property : the closer a given variable @xmath87 to zero , the weaker the weights of all the links associated to the @xmath149-th node .
in such a way , this second model , allows one to describe a more general class of networks .
in fact , consider for example the flow of some quantity across a network , the vanishing of the flow on a given node @xmath149 implies that all the other nodes connected to it become effectively independent of it . in view of this argument
, we consider the entropy @xmath150 in eq . against the more general model
just described above . in figure [ linkthetaithetaj ] it
is shown @xmath136 versus @xmath15 where @xmath151 is the dimension of the manifold associated to the network , and @xmath152 is the number of non - vanishing @xmath145 ( all of them are chosen equal to @xmath7 ) , for @xmath153 and @xmath112 .
also in this case our entropy detects the phase - transition predicted by the erds - rnyi theorem occuring at @xmath154 .
the pattern of @xmath142 reported in figure [ linkthetaithetaj ] shows a more pronounced `` knee '' at the asymptotic transition value @xmath154 with respect to what is found for the same @xmath4 value and is reported in figures [ bifurcation ] and [ linkweight ] .
summarizing , the present work puts forward a novel entropic functional useful to characterize probabilistic graph models .
it is inspired to statistical mechanics , however , instead of being modeled on the boltzmann entropy it is rather modeled on the microcanonical ensemble definition of entropy . the phase space volume being replaced by the volume of a ` state manifold ' ( that is a riemannian manifold whose points correspond to all the possible states of a given network ) .
the state manifold is defined through a suitable metric which is borrowed from an information geometry framework .
the result is a constructive way of associating a differentiable and handy mathematical object to any simple undirected and weighted graph or network .
notice that a similar way of associating a probability distribution to a network , is that of probabilistic graphs models @xcite . here
the choice of gaussian probability distributions is motivated by the fact that gaussian networks are extensively used in many applications ranging from neural networks , to wireless communication , from proteins to electronic circuits , and so on .
the most relevant property of the proposed entropic - geometric measure is its ability to detect the phase transition which is rigorously predicted by the erds - rnyi theorem for random graphs : a paradigmatic example of an analytically known emergent phenomenon occurring in a network .
this effect shows up very clearly , in fact , the geometric entropy proposed here displays both the pattern ( as a function of a control parameter ) and the finite - size - dependence which are typically displayed by the order parameter of a second - order phase transition in physics . as natural ,
though non - trivial , extension our entropic - geometric measure could be applied to pseudo - random graphs and dense graphs where the emergence of the giant component has been recently proved @xcite .
finally , the differential - geometric framework proposed opens some fascinating perspectives of application to the study of complex networks @xcite . as matter of fact
the introduced geometric entropic measure could account for both the structural complexity of a given network and for its statistical complexity , that is , for the complexity of the probability distributions of the entities constituting the network .
we acknowledge the financial support of the european commission by the fet - open grant agreement topdrim , number fp7-ict-318121 . | we propose a method to associate a differentiable riemannian manifold to a generic many degrees of freedom discrete system which is not described by a hamiltonian function .
then , in analogy with classical statistical mechanics , we introduce an entropy as the logarithm of the volume of the manifold .
the geometric entropy so defined is able to detect a paradigmatic phase transition occurring in random graphs theory : the appearance of the ` giant component ' according to the erds - rnyi theorem .
* keywords : * probability theory , riemannian geometry , complex systems |
heavy flavor is one of the important probes for the hot dense nuclear matter created in relativistic heavy - ion collisions @xcite . unlike the light flavors , heavy flavor was expected to be much less thermalized in the matter due to the relatively smaller cross section .
however , it was found that @xmath5 of heavy flavor is much suppressed in the intermediate and high transverse momentum region and that its @xmath2 is not small @xcite .
this implies that charm quarks , which comprise the majority of heavy flavors produced in heavy - ion collisions , are considerably thermalized . on the other hand ,
charm quarks never reach chemical equilibrium due to too small cross section for the annihilation or the creation of the @xmath0 pair .
in fact , the measured number of @xmath0 pairs in au+au collision at rhic is almost proportional to the number of binary collisions @xcite .
hydrodynamics , which is based on conservation of the energy - momentum and various kind of charges , was found to be successful in reproducing the @xmath6 spectrum and the elliptic flow of bulk particles in relativistic heavy - ion collisions @xcite .
additionally , from the fact that the number of charm pairs is almost conserved in the fireball @xcite , one can introduce the charge of charm pairs .
this charge is different from the charge of charm flavor , which is zero throughout the space - time of the collision as the the same number of anticharm quarks cancels the charm charge .
once the charge is introduced , its transport can be described in hydrodynamics assuming that the charm quark interact strongly with the matter .
the flow velocity of heavy flavor is a key ingredient in the @xmath2 of open charms as well as that of the charmonia . in most cases ,
the flow velocity is assumed same as that of the bulk particles or is just parameterized according to a given assumption @xcite . in this study
, we attempt to calculate the flow velocity of charm quarks in hydrodynamics and use it to obtain the @xmath2 of the open as well as hidden charm . the paper is organized as follows : in sec .
[ hydro ] , our 2 + 1 hydrodynamics simulation is presented and tested by comparing the calculated @xmath2 of light hadrons with the experimental data at rhic .
we introduce the charge of charm pairs into the hydrodynamics in sec .
[ applications ] , and use it to calculate the radial and elliptic flows of charm . in sec .
[ jpsi ] , the elliptic flow of regenerated @xmath4 is obtained with the charm flow .
the summary is given in sec .
[ discussion ] and the details on the semileptonic decay of open charm in the appendix .
for our 2 + 1 hydrodynamics , we use the @xmath7 coordinate system defined as follows , @xmath8 after relativistic heavy - ion collision , hot dense nuclear matter is produced between the two receding nuclei .
the matter is assumed to be thermalized at @xmath9 0.6 fm / c @xcite . the local entropy density at initial time is parameterized by @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the number density of participants ( binary collisions ) in the glauber model , defined by @xmath12 ; the parameters @xmath13 and @xmath14 are , respectively , taken as 25.5 and 0.11 to reproduce the multiplicity of charged particles at rhic @xcite .
after the initial thermalization , the hot dense nuclear matter is assumed to expand according to the hydrodynamics .
the equations of energy - momentum conservation in 2 + 1 hydrodynamics are given as @xcite @xmath15 where @xmath16 with @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 being respectively the four - velocity of flow , energy density and pressure of the matter .
for the equations of state of qgp and hadron gas , the quasiparticle model based on lattice data and the resonance gas model are adopted respectively @xcite .
whence , a first - order phase transition is assumed and the critical temperature @xmath20 is 170 mev .
[ sound ] shows the speed of sound squared , @xmath21 , as a function of energy density .
@xmath22 approaches 1/3 at high energy density , which is the value for a free gas , and is zero in the mixed phase where pressure is constant in the first - order phase transition . the equations in eq .
( [ conservations ] ) are solved numerically by using hlle algorithm ( godunov - type algorithm ) @xcite .
the simulation is monitored by entropy conservation condition @xcite , @xmath23 where @xmath24 is entropy density and @xmath25 .
it is found that the entropy in our simulation is conserved within @xmath26 4% error .
plane , where @xmath27 is perpendicular to both the beam direction and the direction of impact parameter , and ( b ) @xmath28 at @xmath29 9 fm in au+au collision at rhic.,width=321 ] plane , where @xmath27 is perpendicular to both the beam direction and the direction of impact parameter , and ( b ) @xmath28 at @xmath29 9 fm in au+au collision at rhic.,width=321 ] fig .
[ hypersurface ] ( a ) shows isothermal lines at the impact parameter @xmath29 9 fm . the temperature for kinetic freeze - out is assumed to be at 125 mev .
the lifetimes of the qgp , the mixed and the hg phases are respectively 4.6 , 5.4 and 10.1 fm / c .
the differential yield of particles of type @xmath30 in cooper - frye freeze - out formula is @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the azimuthal angle of momentum @xmath19 ; @xmath33 is the hypersurface at freeze - out temperature ; @xmath34 is the phase - space distribution of particles . @xmath35 and @xmath36 in @xmath7 coordinate system are , respectively , @xmath37 where @xmath28 is the invariant time @xmath38 at freeze - out temperature on the @xmath39 plane , such as shown in fig .
[ hypersurface ] ( b ) . substituting eq .
( [ dsig ] ) into eq .
( [ dn1 ] ) @xcite , @xmath40 , \label{dn2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath41 is degeneracy factor .
the sign behind summation is positive for boson and negative for fermion , @xmath42 is modified bessel function , and @xmath43 . if @xmath44 does not depend on the transverse position @xmath39 , eq .
( [ dn2 ] ) is equivalent to the blast wave model .
two comments are to be made in regard to eq .
( [ dn2 ] ) .
first , if temperature at @xmath45 is higher than @xmath46 with infinitesimal positive @xmath47 , the square bracket in eq .
( [ dn2 ] ) should be multiplied by an additional negative sign , because the direction of @xmath36 is defined as from the higher to lower temperature .
second , if the square bracket is negative , it is abandoned .
negative @xmath48 means particle moves into the fireball @xcite .
the @xmath2 of light hadrons from our hydrodynamics are compared with experimental data in fig .
[ v2-fig ] . here , @xmath2 of particle @xmath30 is defined as the following : @xmath49 the experimental data include the decay of particles like @xmath50 , but ours do not . as in other hydrodynamics simulations , @xmath2 is reproduced well at low @xmath6 including the ordering of @xmath2 according to the particle masses . of @xmath51 , @xmath52 and proton at @xmath29 9 fm in hydrodynamics and the experimental data in 20@xmath160 % central collision of au+au at rhic @xcite.,width=9 ]
the charge conservation in 2 + 1 hydrodynamics is expressed as @xmath53 where @xmath54 can be any kind of charge density that is conserved .
the number of @xmath55 pairs produced in relativistic heavy - ion collisions , which is proportional to the number of binary collisions , is assumed to be conserved during the fireball expansion .
the justification for this assumption is the small cross sections for the creation or the annihilation of the pair and the overall small number densities for these heavy particles @xcite .
therefore , we can define the charge of @xmath55 pair .
this charge is different from the charge of charm flavor , because the charm net charge is always canceled by the same number of the anticharm quarks .
now , assuming ( anti)charm quarks interact with nuclear matter as strongly as light quarks , charm quarks follow the bulk flow and eq .
( [ charge ] ) can be used for the transport of @xmath0 pairs in the nuclear matter .
we further assume that charm has thermal distribution in each fluid cell , though it may fail in high-@xmath6 region .
more realistic description is possible by solving the langevin equation @xcite .
the initial charge density of @xmath0 is given by glauber model as following @xcite : @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the cross section for @xmath0 production in p+p collision ; a and b are mass numbers of nucleus a and b respectively ; @xmath58 and @xmath59 are the transverse spatial vector and the impact parameter vector respectively ; @xmath60 is the wood - saxon distribution function of a nucleon in nucleus a(b ) .
the transport of heavy flavor is obtained by solving eq .
( [ conservations ] ) and ( [ charge ] ) with the initial condition of eq .
( [ initial ] ) .
9 fm in au+au collision.,width=321 ] fig .
[ velocity ] shows the mean radial distances from the center of fireball and the mean radial flow velocities of the bulk matter and of the heavy flavor at @xmath29 9 fm in au+au collision . for the bulk matter , the radial distance and the radial flow velocity
are weighted by entropy density , and for heavy flavor , by the charge density of heavy flavor , both in the fireball frame . as a result ,
the mean radial distance of heavy flavor is smaller than that of the bulk matter by 10@xmath115 % .
and the radial flow velocity is also smaller by similar percentages .
the reason is as following : the number of @xmath0 pairs is proportional to the number of binary collisions while the multiplicity of bulk particles mainly to the number of participants , as seen in eq .
( [ entropy ] ) and ( [ initial ] ) .
the number of binary collisions is more concentrated in the central region of fireball than that of the participants .
so the mean radial distance of heavy flavor from the center is smaller than that of bulk matter .
on the other hand , the flow velocity is inversely proportional to the distance from the center , because pressure gradient is high at the border of fireball .
therefore , @xmath0 pair is less accelerated than bulk particle in hydrodynamics .
the @xmath2 of open charms is the same as eq .
( [ v2 ] ) except that the differential yield is multiplied by the local charm fugacity , @xmath61 , which is proportional to the charge density of @xmath0 in local frame ,
@xmath62 : @xmath63 experimentally the elliptic flow of heavy flavor is measured through the electrons produced from the semileptonic decay of heavy flavor . to reproduce the experimental data ,
d mesons are generated according to eq .
( [ dn2 ] ) with the local charm fugacity being multiplied .
it is assumed that open charms freeze out at @xmath20 .
and then 61.4 % and 38.6 % of them decay into @xmath64 and @xmath65 respectively , assuming that the branching ratio of semileptonic decay is 100 % .
the energy spectra of single electrons in both decay channels are presented in appendix . of heavy - flavor electrons at @xmath29 5.1 fm in hydrodynamics and the experimental data in minimum bias @xcite.,width=321 ] fig .
[ v2e ] compares the @xmath2 of heavy - flavor electrons at @xmath29 5.1 fm in hydrodynamics and the experimental data in minimum bias @xcite .
the impact parameter corresponds to the mid - centrality weighted by the number of @xmath0 pairs @xcite .
it is seen that the @xmath2 in hydrodynamics reproduces the experimental data up to around @xmath3 1.5 gev .
this result implies that the heavy flavor in heavy - ion collision at rhic is considerably thermalized at low transverse momentum .
the @xmath2 of @xmath4 in relativistic heavy - ion collisions is a very interesting quantity revealing how much fraction of @xmath4 is produced through regeneration @xcite . ignoring the @xmath2 of primordial @xmath4 which seems much smaller than that of regenerated @xmath4 , the @xmath2 of total @xmath4 can be approximated to be the @xmath2 of regenerated @xmath4 multiplied by its fraction among the total observed yield of @xmath4 .
the fraction gives valuable information on the thermal properties of @xmath4 as well as of the hot nuclear matter created in relativistic heavy - ion collision .
because the @xmath4 is composed of charm and anticharm quark , the differential yield of regenerated @xmath4 in @xmath2 is multiplied by the local charm fugacity squared : @xmath66 in fig .
[ v2jpsi ] , the solid line is the @xmath2 of regenerated @xmath4 at @xmath29 9 fm , which corresponds to 20@xmath160 % central collision .
in contrast to our previous study @xcite , where only radial component of flow was considered , negative @xmath2 is not observed at low @xmath6 . the freeze - out temperature for @xmath4 is assumed to be @xmath20 as in the open charm case .
the figure shows that we reproduce the first data point at @xmath67 1.0 gev , but overestimate the data at three higher @xmath6 .
this result could be explained if the measured @xmath4 at these higher @xmath6 are mostly primordial ones , which has no elliptic flow . in the two - component model ,
the fraction of regenerated @xmath4 is only 20 % at @xmath29 9 fm @xcite
. the dashed line is @xmath2 assuming 20 % of @xmath4 are regenerated ones and the rest primordial ones .
it seems from the figure that the fraction of regenerated @xmath4 is larger than 20 % at @xmath67 1.0 gev , but smaller than 20 % at three higher @xmath6 . of regenerated @xmath4 at @xmath29 9 fm in hydrodynamics ( solid line ) and 20 % of them (
dashed line ) .
the experimental data are taken from @xcite.,width=9 ]
the flow of heavy flavor in heavy - ion collision is studied in 2 + 1 hydrodynamics by introducing the charge of the @xmath0 pair . for this , we assume that the number of heavy flavor does not change in fireball but that the heavy flavor interacts with the nuclear matter created in relativistic heavy - ion collision as strongly as the light flavors . it is found that the mean radial distance from the center of fireball and the mean radial flow velocity of heavy flavor are less than those of bulk particles by 10@xmath115 % .
this is so because the creation of heavy flavor is more concentrated in the central region than that of bulk particles .
the elliptic flow of heavy - flavor electrons is calculated in monte carlo method and compared with experimental data at rhic .
if heavy flavor particle does not interact with the nuclear matter , it has no elliptic flow ( @xmath68 0 ) .
if the interaction is strong enough , heavy flavor particle has the maximum elliptic flow which is given by hydrodynamics .
it is found that our model reproduces experimental data up to around @xmath3 1.5 gev .
it implies that the heavy flavors are considerably thermalized at low transverse momentum .
finally , the @xmath2 of regenerated @xmath4 is calculated with the same flow of charm . by comparing with experimental data
, it is found that the fraction of regenerated @xmath4 depends on transverse momentum and the the fraction is not small at low @xmath6 .
this work was supported was supported by the korean ministry of education through the bk21 program and krf-2006-c00011 .
in this study , two main semileptonic decay channels of d meson are considered : @xmath69 and @xmath70 with the average branching ratios being 6.09 % and 3.84 % respectively . in the limit of massless electron , the differential partial widths are @xmath71 where @xmath72 in eq .
( [ width1])@xmath1([width2 ] ) , @xmath73 and @xmath74 are , respectively , the four momentum squared and the magnitude of three momentum of w boson in the d meson rest frame .
@xmath75 is the angle between the three momentum of lepton and that of w boson in the w rest frame . @xmath76 ,
@xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath79 are form factors and are parameterized as the followings : where the upper limit of the integration @xmath95 is given from the condition that @xmath96 .
the available range of @xmath93 is taken to be from 0 to @xmath97 .
the phase space is the same for @xmath70 after @xmath98 is replaced by @xmath99 . | the flow of charm is calculated in 2 + 1 ideal hydrodynamics by introducing the charge of @xmath0 pair assuming that the number of @xmath0 pairs is conserved in relativistic heavy - ion collisions .
it is found that the mean radial flow velocity of charm quarks is smaller than that of bulk matter by 10@xmath115 % and the measured @xmath2 of heavy - flavor electrons is reproduced up to @xmath3 1.5 gev / c in au+au collision at rhic .
the same flow is applied to regenerated @xmath4 and its @xmath2 is discussed . |
sco x-2 is one of the persistently bright neutron star low - mass x - ray binaries known as z sources .
z sources are so - named because , over time , they trace out a ` z ' shaped track in an x - ray colour - colour ( cd ) and hardness - intensity ( hid ) diagram . the top of the ` z ' is called the horizontal branch ( hb ) , the diagonal is the normal branch ( nb ) , and the bottom is the flaring branch ( fb ) ( hasinger & van der klis @xcite ) . inferred mass - accretion rate increases from the hb , through the nb , to the fb .
the mass - accretion rate is thought to reach the eddington limit at the bottom of the nb , and is super - eddington in the fb .
the five other traditional z sources are : sco x-1 , gx 17 + 2 , cyg x-2 , gx 340 + 0 and gx 5@xmath11 .
a related class of objects are the atoll sources ; they exhibit a curved track in a colour - colour diagram ( hasinger & van der klis @xcite ) . through the study of the x - ray fast - time variability of low - mass x - ray binaries ,
we are able to investigate mass - accretion processes ; in particular , the fast - time variability is a signature of the flow of matter near the compact object ( see review van der klis @xcite ) . the typical power spectral properties of z and atoll sources
are correlated with position in the cd ( hasinger & van der klis @xcite ; also van der klis @xcite ) . on the hb ,
z sources typically exhibit six variability components that are phenomenologically related ( e.g. , homan et al . @xcite and references therein ) : a band - limited noise component with cut - off frequency in the range 210 hz , called low frequency noise ( lfn ) ; a quasi - periodic oscillation ( qpo ) in the range 1560 hz , known as the horizontal branch oscillation ( hbo ) ; a broad sub - hbo peak located between the lfn and hbo , and which has been identified as a sub - harmonic of the hbo ; a second harmonic to the hbo ; and a pair of qpos in the range 2001130 hz , called khz qpos . on the nb and lower part of the fb
there is a qpo in the range 620 hz ( e.g. , van der klis @xcite ; dieters & van der klis @xcite ; homan et al .
@xcite ) . on the nb ,
it is known as a normal branch oscillation ( nbo ) , and its frequency is roughly constant near 6 hz . with movement through the nb / fb vertex the mean frequency and full - width - at - half - maximum ( fwhm ) of the qpo rise rapidly .
it is then known as a flaring branch oscillation ( fbo ) , and becomes indistinguishable from the underlying continuum at about 1020 per cent of the way up that branch .
some of the features seen in the hb are also sometimes seen on the nb and fb . in sco x-1 ,
van der klis et al .
( @xcite ) found that the nbo appeared to ` peak - up ' out of the lfn . in gx 17 + 2 ,
homan et al .
( @xcite ) found that the nbo and lfn existed simultaneously , and were separate features .
they also observed a peaked noise feature in the fb , in addition to an fbo , which they identified as lfn . a power - law noise component , called very low frequency noise ( vlfn ) , exists throughout the z track , and is stronger at higher mass - accretion rates and at higher energies ( e.g. , van der klis @xcite ) .
van der klis ( @xcite ) suggested that it is produced by the variations in intensity that are associated with movement along the z track .
dieters & van der klis ( @xcite ) constructed power spectra of rank number ( see section [ sect : cohidaps ] ) , in the frequency range 3@[email protected] hz , and also of intensity , in the range [email protected] hz .
they found that the power - law indices from the rank number power spectra were consistent with those from the intensity power specta , although we note that the uncertainties on the rank number power - law indices were quite large .
if vlfn is due to movement along the z track , then the speed of that movement should be correlated with the vlfn strength .
dieters & van der klis ( @xcite ) found this to be the case in sco x-1 , homan et al .
( @xcite ) found that the correlation exists in some parts of the z track of gx 17 + 2 , and wijnands et al .
( @xcite ) found that the vlfn strength in cyg x-2 did not vary monotonically with speed .
finally , a noise component with a cut - off frequency in the range 30100 hz , called high frequency noise ( hfn ) , has also been observed ( e.g. , van der klis @xcite ) . at their lowest inferred mass - accretion rates
atoll sources exhibit : a band - limited noise component , modelled using a broken power - law with a break frequency in the range 0.132 hz , called ( rather confusingly ) high frequency noise ; low frequency qpos or broad peaks in the range 167 hz ; and khz qpos . except for the khz qpos , these features are very similar to those seen in black hole candidates ( bhcs ) ( e.g. , wijnands & van der klis @xcite and references therein ) . in atoll
souces vlfn dominates at higher mass - accretion rates .
a correlation was found in z sources and atoll sources between the frequencies of the khz qpos , and the hbo or 167 hz qpo ; the same correlation was found between features in the power spectra of bhcs ( psaltis , belloni & van der klis @xcite ; also psaltis et al .
@xcite ) . wijnands & van der klis ( @xcite ) discovered another correlation in atoll sources and bhcs , between the break frequency of the band - limited noise ( the hfn in atoll sources ) , and the centroid frequency of a qpo or bump in the range 0.267 hz ( the 167 hz qpo in atoll sources ) . the same correlation was found to exist in z sources between the lfn and sub - hbo peak , and also between the sub - hbo and hbo ( wijnands & van der klis @xcite ; also homan et al .
van der klis ( @xcite , b ) , belloni , psaltis & van der klis ( @xcite ) , and sunyaev & revnivtsev ( @xcite ) have also made comparisons between the power spectra of bhcs and neutron star lmxbs . there is currently much effort being put into developing models that can explain these correlations . the discovery that the power spectral components in black hole candidates follow the same correlations seen in z sources and atoll sources gives support to those models which do not depend on the presence or otherwise of a solid surface or magnetic field ( e.g. , van der klis @xcite ) . except for the fact that sco x-2 has never been observed in the hb , its hardness - intensity diagram looks nearly identical to that of sco x-1 ( e.g. , schulz , hasinger & trmper @xcite ) .
therefore , one might expect the fast - time variability of sco x-2 to be similar to that seen in sco x-1 .
ponman , cooke & stella ( @xcite ) analysed _ exosat _ data and found broad peaked noise in the fb , with a centroid frequency , fwhm and fractional rms amplitude of roughly 5 hz , 10 hz and 3 per cent , respectively .
kuulkers & van der klis ( @xcite ) analysed a small _ rxte _ dataset and found that the peaked noise became narrower and moved to lower frequencies with movement from the nb into the fb .
oneill et al .
( @xcite ) analysed _ ginga _ data , and found peaked noise with a centroid frequency and fwhm in the range 47 hz and 612 hz , respectively .
they found that it was strongest at about 10 per cent of the way up fb , and was present until halfway up the branch .
they referred to the feature as flaring branch noise ( fbn ) , and concluded that : fbn is not the same as atoll source high frequency noise ; it is difficult to explain it with the model for typical normal / flaring branch oscillations ( fortner , lamb & miller @xcite ) ; and it resembles the peaked noise seen in the fb of cyg x-2 at low overall intensities .
oneill et al . (
@xcite ) also found very low frequency noise that became stronger with movement up the fb , as seen in other z sources .
zhang , strohmayer & swank ( @xcite ) observed sco x-2 with _ rxte _ in 1998 january . during those observations sco x-2 traced out the most extensive z track ever seen from that object ; most importantly , it was found higher up in the nb than ever before .
a pair of kilohertz quasi - periodic oscillations were detected at 712 hz and 978 hz , respectively , in the uppermost part of the observed nb .
agrawal & bhattacharyya ( @xcite ) analysed @xmath040 ks of _ rxte _ data obtained in 1998 september and october and also found an extended nb .
they detected peaked noise similar to that found in previous observations , though its fractional rms amplitude did not vary smoothly , and the feature was detected as high as 80 per cent of the way up the fb .
they found that the properties of the peaked noise were similar throughout the z track , and thus concluded that the peaked noise seen in the nb was the same as that seen in the fb .
a qpo , with a centroid frequency of 3.8 hz , was detected ( 90 per cent confidence level ) in the fb during a dip in the intensity that occurred after a flare . during the september and october observations
the behaviour of the vlfn was very different to that seen previously : it was , on average , stronger in the nb than in the fb , and did not exhibit an increase in strength with movement up the fb .
on the basis of phenomenology , the peaked noise observed in the nb and fb of sco x-2 is unlikely to be an n / fbo ( e.g. , agrawal & bhattacharyya @xcite and references therein ) .
first , the peaked noise seen in the nb of sco x-2 is much broader than an nbo .
second , as sco x-2 moves from the nb , through the nb / fb vertex , and then up the fb , the centroid frequency and fwhm of the peaked noise decrease , and then stay roughly constant .
this is in contrast to an n / fbo , of which , with the same movement along the track , the centroid frequency and fwhm increase rapidly .
third , the peaked noise in sco x-2 has been seen as far as 80 per cent of the way up the fb , while fbos are only present in the lowest 1020 per cent of that branch .
zhang et al . ( @xcite ) did not analyse the low frequency fast - time variability in detail .
we , therefore , decided to reanalyse those data .
our primary objectives were : to look for the lfn and hbo that are expected to accompany khz qpos ; to better understand the phenomenology of fbn ; to study the properties of the khz qpos as a function of both position on the z track and photon energy ; and , to further investigate vlfn .
a preliminary account of this work has been given by oneill et al .
( @xcite ) .
the _ rossi x - ray timing explorer _ ( _ rxte _ ; bradt , rothschild & swank @xcite ) proportional counter array ( pca ) observed sco x-2 between 1 and 29 january 1998 .
the @xmath0156 ks of data were recorded simultaneously in six different modes .
the ` standard 2 ' mode data had a time resolution of 16 s , and sco x-2 was visible in the energy range 2.040 kev .
three ` single bit ' modes and one ` event mode ' were used , with a time resolution of 122 @xmath5s .
the effective energy boundaries of the single bit and event mode data were 2.05.16.58.7 kev and 8.740 kev , respectively .
we only used data in which all five proportional counter units were operating .
a hardness - intensity diagram was constructed from the standard 2 data using 16 s averages , and is shown in fig .
[ fig : b_rk ] .
the counting rates were corrected for detector deadtime and background . in the hid ,
the hardness is defined as the counting rate ratio between the energy ranges 8.719.7 kev and 6.28.7 kev , and the intensity is the counting rate in the range 2.019.7 kev .
[ fig : b_rk ] shows the most complete z track ever observed from sco x-2 ( see also zhang et al .
the counting rate at the top of the fb is a factor of 2.6 greater than the intensity at the nb / fb vertex . in comparison ,
the factor was : 2.2 in _ ginga
_ data ( 1.116.7 kev , 64 s averages ; oneill et al .
@xcite ) ; @xmath02.1 in the _ exosat _ data ( 110 kev , 64 s averages ; ponman et al .
@xcite ) ; and @xmath02 in the 1998 september and october _ rxte _ data ( 216 kev , 256 s averages ; agrawal & bhattacharyya @xcite ) .
we note that using lower energy bands and longer averages reduces the observed maximum intensity of the fb .
light curves were extracted from the single bit and event mode data , with a time resolution of 244 @xmath5s .
we summed the energy resolved data to produce light curves with various energy ranges .
we calculated power spectra from 16 s intervals in each light curve ; each interval corresponded exactly to one point in the hid . to investigate the 0.0625300 hz frequency range we used a logarithmic frequency rebinning scheme , while we used linear rebinning to investigate the kilohertz region .
a spline was fitted through the hid , and rank numbers were calculated for each point .
rank number is a one dimensional measure of position in the z track ; it was introduced by hasinger et al .
( @xcite ) , and is symbolised as s@xmath6 ( hertz et al . @xcite ; see also dieters & van der klis @xcite ) . it is a measure of the inferred mass - accretion rate .
we defined the nb / fb vertex as s@xmath6=2 , and the top of the fb as s@xmath6=3 .
average power spectra were then constructed on the basis of rank number , and were normalised to give fractional rms amplitude squared per hz . the error given for each mean
s@xmath6 is the standard deviation of the rank numbers used in the average . to investigate the low frequency fast - time variability
, we fitted the resultant power spectra in the range 0.0625300 hz using : a power - law to represent very low frequency noise , lorentzians as required to represent peaked noise , and a constant to represent the deadtime - affected white - noise level .
we investigated the kilohertz quasi - periodic oscillations by fitting the resultant power spectra in the range 5001200 hz , using two lorentzians and a constant .
the vlfn fractional rms amplitude was measured by extrapolating the best - fitting power - law and integrating over the range 0.011 hz .
the addition of a lorentzian component to a model was deemed necessary only when the probability of exceeding the @xmath7 of the best - fitting model was @xmath80.001 , and an f - test for the inclusion of the extra lorentzian was significant at or above the 3@xmath9 level .
we fixed the centroid frequency and/or the fwhm of a lorentzian component either when they could not be constrained , or when a fractional rms amplitude upper limit was being measured .
uncertainties in the best - fitting parameters were measured using @xmath10 , and upper limits were measured using @xmath11 ( 95 per cent confidence level ) .
we corrected the best - fitting fractional rms amplitudes for differential deadtime and channel cross - talk as appropriate ( see appendix a ) .
finally , we corrected the fractional rms amplitudes for the background counting rate ( e.g. , van der klis @xcite ) . in the low frequency power spectra , the reduction of the rms due to the binning of data was negligible ; the binning correction factor applied to the rms of the khz qpos was 1.1 ( van der klis @xcite ) . to further investigate the vlfn
, we constructed a hid from the single bit and event mode data using 32 s averages .
we defined the hardness as the counting rate ratio between the energy ranges 8.740 kev and 6.58.7 kev , and the intensity as the counting rate in the range 2.040 kev .
we calculated complex fourier spectra from both the hardness light curve and the deadtime corrected intensity light curve , using 1 s time resolution and 32 s intervals .
each interval , along with its associated fourier spectrum , corresponded exactly to one point in the hid .
we used 1 s time resolution so we could directly investigate the fast - time variability in the time - domain .
the fourier spectra had a frequency range of 0.031250.5 hz . for each 32 s interval we calculated complex cross spectra between the hardness and intensity .
we multiplied the complex fourier amplitudes of the intensity , by the complex conjugate of the complex fourier amplitudes of the hardness ( e.g. , van der klis et al .
@xcite ) . at each frequency in the resultant cross spectrum
there is a corresponding cross vector @xmath12 , with a real and imaginary component .
the phase of the cross vector is the phase difference between the variations in hardness and the variations in intensity ; a negative phase means that hardness lags intensity .
a phase of 0@xmath13 means hardness and intensity are positively correlated , and a phase of 180@xmath13 means they are anti - correlated .
we then constructed average complex cross spectra . at each frequency
, we averaged together the real and imaginary components from all cross spectra whose corresponding point in the hid was within a specified range of hardness and intensity .
the mean amplitude and phase at each frequency was calculated from the mean real and imaginary components .
the uncertainties in the mean real and imaginary components are the observed standard deviation in the mean of those components , and we determined the uncertainties in amplitude and phase by using error propagation .
the phases at the nyquist frequency are always either 0@xmath13 or 180@xmath13 so they have no error bars .
if , at a particular frequency , the hardness and intensity are uncorrelated , then the phases of the _ individual _ cross vectors corresponding to that frequency will be uniformly distributed between @xmath14 and @xmath15 . in this situation , the real and imaginary components of the corresponding vector @xmath16 in the _ average _ cross spectrum will have gaussian distributions with a mean of zero .
the real component of @xmath16 has a variance , @xmath17 , that is equal to the variance of the imaginary component , @xmath18 .
these may be calculated by using the expression @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the observed standard deviation and mean , respectively , of the amplitudes of the set of cross vectors that were averaged together , and @xmath22 is the number of vectors comprising that average .
therefore , in the absence of a correlation between intensity and hardness , the squared amplitude @xmath23 of the average cross vector is distributed such that the probability of observing a @xmath23 greater than a certain threshold level @xmath24 is given by ( dieters et al .
@xcite ; dieters , private communication ) @xmath25 where @xmath26 given an observed squared amplitude @xmath24 , the significance of the detection of a correlation , expressed as a percentage , is given by @xmath27 the cross vector at the nyquist frequency has only a real component , so it must be treated separately . the value @xmath28 is distributed as @xmath29 with 1 degree of freedom , where @xmath30 . for a comparison with the analytical significance levels
, we also used a monte carlo simulation to determine the significance of the observed correlations .
we randomised the phase difference between the hardness and intensity at each frequency , in each _ individual _ complex cross spectra , while maintaining the observed amplitudes .
we then used those ` random - phase ' cross spectra to construct an average cross spectrum .
we repeated this procedure 10000 times and obtained , at each frequency , the distribution of mean amplitudes that would be present if our data were actually uncorrelated . with this method ,
the significance of a correlation is equal to the percentage of random - phase amplitudes that are less than the observed amplitude .
we deemed the hardness and intensity to be correlated , at a particular frequency , if the significance obtained from the analytical method was at least 90 per cent .
the phases of those cross vectors with a significant correlation are presented in table [ tab : phases ] , along with the significance we obtained from each method .
the results obtained from the monte carlo method were , on average , within 0.3 per cent significance of those found from the analytical method ( see table [ tab : phases ] ) .
we repeated the entire procedure twice .
first , using a time resolution of 8 s with 256 s intervals , corresponding to the frequency range 0.003906250.0625 hz , which allowed us to investigate the frequency range in which the power - law component dominates .
second , using a time resolution of 0.125 s with 4 s intervals , corresponding to the frequency range 0.254.00 hz , which allowed us to investigate the influence of low frequency noise and flaring branch noise on our cross spectra .
in fig . [ fig : f_55_s ] we present representative 0.0625300 hz power spectra from the nb ( fig . [
fig : f_55_s ] top ; s@xmath6 range 1.531.85 ) and fb ( fig .
[ fig : f_55_s ] bottom ; s@xmath6 range 2.033.0 ) , and the various components we identified .
we detected three features : very low frequency noise ; low frequency noise / flaring branch noise ; and a high frequency peaked noise component .
we subdivided our data further and constructed thirteen average power spectra covering the entire z track .
the best - fitting values from the thirteen average power spectra , in the range 0.0625300 hz , are presented in table [ tab : powfits2 ] . in table
[ tab : powfits2 ] we also present the @xmath31 of each lorentzian component .
this can be calculated for both a lorentzian and cut - off power - law , and it facilitates a comparison between the two forms .
the @xmath31 is the frequency at which there is a maximum in a power - density - times - frequency plot , and it is a useful measure of the characteristic frequency of a power spectral feature ( e.g. , belloni et al .
@xcite ) .
the kilohertz quasi - periodic oscillations were only detected at s@xmath6=1.66 . in table [ tab : khzfits ] we present the best - fitting values of the khz qpos in the nb .
we investigated the energy dependence of the khz qpos by fitting energy resolved power spectra corresponding to s@xmath6=1.66 .
we fixed the centroid frequencies and fwhm at the values found from the 2.040 kev power spectrum . in the energy resolved spectra , we only detected khz qpos in the 5.140 kev range , with fractional rms amplitudes of [email protected] per cent and [email protected] per cent for the lower and upper peaks , respectively . in the energy range 2.08.7 kev , the upper limits of the rms for the lower and upper peaks were 2.1 per cent and 1.8 per cent , respectively . therefore , the khz qpos in sco x-2 are hard , like those seen in other objects ( e.g. , van der klis @xcite and references therein ) .
zhang et al .
( @xcite ) fitted the khz qpos using gaussians ; we also fitted our qpos using gaussians and found best - fitting values consistent with their results .
the @xmath7/degrees of freedom ( dof ) was 0.97/51 for the gaussian model , compared with 0.93/51 for the lorentzian model . to investigate the energy dependence of the 0.0625300
hz power spectral features we used energy resolved power spectra corresponding to the average spectra shown in fig .
[ fig : f_55_s ] .
we fixed the centroid frequencies and fwhm at the values found from the 2.040 kev spectra .
the results are shown in table [ tab : enefits ] . in the next three subsections
we describe in more detail the properties of the lfn / fbn peak , the high frequency peak , and the vlfn . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] + @xmath33256 s intervals .
+ @xmath3432 s intervals .
+ @xmath354 s intervals .
using zhang et al.s ( @xcite ) _ rxte _ data , we have carried out the most comprehensive investigation of the x - ray fast - time variability of sco x-2 thus far , as a function of position on the z track .
our primary discoveries are : the properties of the low frequency noise / flaring branch noise peak , and the very low frequency noise , exhibit abrupt changes with movement from the nb into the fb ; there is a peaked noise feature with a centroid frequency in the range 1154 hz , which , in the nb , may contain either one or two components ; and , very low frequency noise is not entirely due to motion along the z track .
the peak we observed in the nb and fb , with a centroid frequency in the range 3.37.6 hz , is not an n / fbo : nbos are much narrower than the peak we observed ; the centroid frequency of an fbo increases rapidly with movement up the fb , in contrast to our peak ; and fbos are only present in the lowest 1020 per cent of the fb , while the feature in sco x-2 is present until about halfway up the branch ( see also section [ sec : sx ] ) . given the presence of khz qpos in the upper nb , and the fact that the peak has a @xmath31 in the range 7.59.1 hz , which is consistent with the lfn found in other z sources ( e.g. , gx 17 + 2 , homan et al .
@xcite ; sco x-1 , dieters & van der klis @xcite ) , we argue that we have detected lfn in the nb . in the fb ,
the peak is similar to the fbn found earlier in sco x-2 ( e.g. , agrawal & bhattacharyya @xcite and references therein ) , and we identify it as such .
lfn is a hard phenomenon ( e.g. , van der klis @xcite ) .
for example , jonker et al .
( @xcite ) found that the fractional rms amplitude of the lfn in gx 340 + 0 was more than a factor of three greater in the 1360 kev band than it was in the 25 kev band .
in contrast , the lfn we observed is strongest in the 6.58.7 kev band .
this difference suggests that maybe we have _ not _ observed lfn , since different production mechanisms give rise to different energy dependences ( e.g. , compare hbos with nbos , van der klis @xcite and references therein ) .
however , the fractional rms amplitude spectrum of nbos , for example , is known to differ between objects ( e.g. , van der klis @xcite and references therein ; dieters & van der klis @xcite ; dieters et al .
@xcite ) and lfn may behave similarly different per source .
this suggestion can be confirmed through a sensitive investigation of the s@xmath6 dependence of the lfn that we detected , and by making a comparison with other z sources . in previous observations of sco
x-2 the properties of the peaked noise in the nb was found to be similar to that seen in the fb , suggesting that it was the same feature in both branches ( agrawal & bhattacharyya @xcite ) .
we argue , for two reasons , that fbn is different to lfn : the properties of the lfn / fbn peak , as seen in fig . [
fig : fbn_val ] , exhibit abrupt changes at the nb / fb vertex ; and the energy dependence of the peak differs between nb and fb . we note that according to the ` unified model ' ( psaltis , lamb & miller @xcite ) , the inferred mass - accretion rates are expected to be sub - eddington in the nb , and super - eddington in the fb , suggesting that the mechanism producing the variability in the nb may be different to that in the fb .
however , the properties of the n / fbo , for example , also differ between nb and fb , with the changes occurring near the vertex ( e.g. , dieters & van der klis @xcite ) , and the nbo and fbo are still thought to be related .
likewise , there remains the possibility that lfn evolves into fbn .
our observations of fbn support the conclusions reached by oneill et al .
( @xcite ) , which were detailed in section [ sec : sx ] .
in particular , we note again the similarity between fbn and the broad peak seen in the fb of cyg x-2 at low overall intensities ( kuulkers , wijnands & van der klis @xcite ; see also oneill et al .
@xcite ; agrawal & bhattacharyya @xcite ) . the feature in cyg x-2 was fitted with a cut - off power - law , with a @xmath31 of 10@xmath323 hz .
this is consistent with the fbn we observed .
the peak in cyg x-2 was not observed in the nb , with a fractional rms amplitude upper limit of 1.0 per cent , compared with the fb rms of [email protected] per cent .
an investigation of the s@xmath6 dependence of the cyg x-2 peak will reveal whether or not it is the same phenomenon as fbn . furthermore , a stringent upper limit on the rms of the peak in the nb would support our suggestion that fbn is not the same as lfn .
we now compare the lfn and fbn we observed in sco x-2 , with the lfn observed in the nb and fb of gx 17 + 2 ( homan et al .
the @xmath31 of the lfn in the nb of sco x-2 is generally a few hertz lower than that seen in the nb of gx 17 + 2 , and it is consistent with the @xmath31 observed in the hb . there is no abrupt decrease in the centroid frequency and increase in the fractional rms amplitude of the lfn in gx 17 + 2 , with movement from the nb into the fb , suggesting that it may not be the same as sco x-2 lfn / fbn .
however , homan et al .
( @xcite ) stated that their best - fitting values of lfn in the lower nb and lower fb were probably influenced by the n / fbo that was present , so the true lfn phenomenology may have been masked .
the overall behaviour of @xmath31 in the fb is similar in both objects , and the decrease in the fractional rms amplitude of the lfn in gx 17 + 2 , with movement up the fb , is remarkably similar to fbn .
in contrast to the fbn we observed , the lfn in gx 17 + 2 was detected as high as about 85 per cent of the way up the fb .
but , we note again that agrawal & bhattacharyya ( @xcite ) reported the detection of peaked noise in the fb of sco x-2 at about 80 per cent of the way up the fb .
in addition to gx 17 + 2 , a close examination of the lfn in sco x-1 is also desirable .
sco x-1 has been observed by _
rxte _ , with 260 kev counting rates of @xmath010@xmath36 counts s@xmath37 , and these data are currently available in the archive ( e.g. , yu , van der klis & jonker @xcite ) . of course , more data on sco x-2 are also required before sufficiently detailed comparisons can be made . in the nb , we detected a high frequency peaked noise feature , with a centroid frequency in the range 1122 hz .
this feature contains power at frequencies where we would expect to find high frequency noise , a horizontal branch oscillation , and/or a sub - horizontal branch oscillation ( see section [ sec : zaasfv ] ) .
we showed that the nb power spectrum could be fitted satisfactorily with a two - lorentzian model , using one lorentzian for the low frequency noise , and one for the high frequency peak ( see section [ sec : hfp ] ) .
however , at s@xmath6=1.66 , there is an excess of power in the frequency range where we would expect to find an hbo ( see fig .
[ fig : f_09_s_2lore ] ) .
the addition of a third lorentzian component significantly improved the fit .
therefore , we shall consider both two- and three - lorentzian models for fitting the nb data .
the high frequency peak , if considered as a single lorentzian , resembles z source hfn .
the @xmath31 we found is consistent with that seen in other z sources ( e.g. , hasinger & van der klis @xcite ) , and it was stronger at higher energies , which is typical of hfn ( e.g. , dieters & van der klis @xcite ) .
however , there is some doubt as to the origin of hfn : it may be an instrumental effect from _ exosat _ ( berger & van der klis @xcite ) .
homan et al .
( @xcite ) did not detect hfn in a large _ rxte _ dataset on gx 17 + 2 , in contrast to previous observations made by _ exosat_. they suggested that in the hb in the _ exosat _ observations , where the hfn was too strong to be an instrumental effect , the feature being fitted in power spectra may have actually been the sub - hbo peak .
is then the high frequency peak , taken as a single lorentzian , a sub - hbo peak ? at the top of the observed nb , the lfn we detected had a @xmath31 of [email protected] hz . the centroid frequency , fwhm and @xmath31 of the high frequency peak were 22@xmath3211 hz , 70@xmath3211 hz and 41@xmath327 hz , respectively . in comparison , when the lfn in gx 17 + 2 had a @xmath31 of @xmath07.5 hz , its sub - hbo peak had a centroid frequency , fwhm , and @xmath31 of [email protected] hz , 21@xmath327 hz and 27@xmath322 hz , respectively ( homan et al .
the high frequency peak in sco x-2 is at the expected centroid frequency of a sub - hbo , but there are some marked differences : we would expect to clearly detect an hbo when a sub - hbo peak is present ; the high frequency peak is much broader than a typical sub - hbo , which results in a much higher @xmath31 ; and , with movement down the nb , the @xmath31 of the high frequency peak in sco x-2 _ decreased _ to 21@xmath323 , while in gx 17 + 2 the @xmath31 of the sub - hbo peak _ increased _ to a maximum of @xmath050 hz .
therefore , we conclude that the high frequency peak , if considered as a single lorentzian , can not be identified as a typical manifestation of a sub - hbo .
we now consider the possibility that the high frequency peak consists of two lorentzian features . at s@xmath6=1.66 , the peak
could be fitted using two lorentzians , representing a possible sub - hbo and hbo . in the same part of the nb ,
the lower khz qpo is at 715@xmath3212 hz .
we find that , according to the correlation found by wijnands & van der klis ( @xcite ) , and in comparison to gx 17 + 2 ( homan et al .
@xcite ) , the frequencies of the lfn and possible sub - hbo peak we observed in sco x-2 are consistent with expectations , assuming the presence of an hbo at 48 hz . according to the correlation found by psaltis et al .
( @xcite ) , when the lower khz qpo is at 715 hz the hbo is inferred to have a centroid frequency of about 60 hz .
this is somewhat higher than the 48 hz centroid frequency of our possible hbo .
an hbo centroid frequency of 48 hz corresponds to a lower khz qpo frequency of about 600 hz ( psaltis et al .
@xcite ; homan et al .
the hbo is sco x-1 has only been detected with centroid frequencies in the range @xmath04050 hz , and sco x-1 also lies off the psaltis et al .
( @xcite ) correlation ; for example , its hbo was found at @xmath045 hz , even when the lower khz qpos was at @xmath0875 hz ( van der klis et al .
therefore , we speculate that sco x-2 is similar to sco x-1 in this regard , and predict that future observations may reveal an hbo in the same frequency range as seen in sco x-1 . there remains a problem , however , with the interpretation of our @xmath31@xmath020 hz feature as being a z source sub - hbo .
if we assume we have detected an hbo and sub - hbo in the nb power spectra at s@xmath6=1.66 and 1.79 , then , as sco x-2 moves down the nb , the sub - hbo peak should disappear before the hbo does .
this effect is clearly seen in gx 17 + 2 , in which the sub - hbo peak becomes undetectable in the middle part of the nb while the hbo is present all the way down to the fb ( homan et al .
@xcite ) . in contrast , we find that our possible hbo component disappears by s@xmath6=1.91 , while the possible sub - hbo component remains strong .
furthermore , the @xmath31 and centroid frequency of the possible sub - hbo at s@xmath6=1.79 and 1.91 , are significantly lower than the maximum values observed in the nb in gx 17 + 2 ( homan et al .
@xcite ) . however , we note that the uncertainties on our measurements do allow for an increase in the possible sub - hbo centroid frequency and @xmath31 . therefore , although problematic , we can not rule out the possibility that we have observed a manifestation of a sub - hbo slightly different to that seen in gx 17 + 2 . in summary ,
if three lorentzians _ are _ required to fit the power spectrum from the upper nb , we conclude that : the frequency of the lower khz qpo , relative to the centroid frequency of the hbo , is similar to that seen in sco x-1 ( van der klis et al .
@xcite ) ; and the feature with @xmath31@xmath020 hz may be a sub - hbo peak , though it must be a different manifestation to that seen in gx 17 + 2 . since flaring branch noise is present at super - eddington inferred mass - accretion rates , where the accreting material and outgoing radiation must be separated ( e.g. , lamb @xcite ) , an adaptation of the photon bubble model ( klein et al .
@xcite ) may prove useful in explaining it .
the photon bubble model was originally applied to x - ray pulsars , in which locally super - eddington accretion takes place onto the polar caps of a strongly magnetised neutron star ( klein et al .
photon bubbles are formed in the settling mound below the accretion shock .
the bubbles coalesce to form larger bubbles , and then rise up and lose their photons through diffusion into the accretion shock .
the result is quasi - periodic variability in the x - ray intensity , the frequency of which is primarily dependent upon the time it takes for the bubbles to coalesce .
modelling showed that qpos could be produced at frequencies from as low as 20 hz to as high as 12000 hz , along with a simultaneous power - law component ( klein et al .
@xcite ; klein et al .
it would be interesting to see whether or not a similar process , operating in either a radial inflow or in the accretion funnel onto the neutron star magnetic poles , could give rise to fbn . in the magnetospheric beat frequency model for horizontal branch oscillations ( e.g. , alpar & shaham @xcite ; lamb et al .
@xcite ; shibazaki & lamb @xcite ) , the hbo is predicted to be accompanied by a noise component at lower frequencies , with both features expected to be hard . in the power spectra of z sources
it is possible to identify either the lfn or the sub - hbo peak as the noise component ( e.g. , wijnands & van der klis @xcite ) .
the lfn that we observed in the nb was strongest at intermediate energies , suggesting that , in the context of the magnetospheric beat frequency model , either lfn is not related to the hbo , or the feature we observed is not classical lfn .
we have argued in section [ sect : lfnafbn ] that we _ have _ observed z source lfn .
if we are correct , then the sub - hbo peak , rather than lfn , might be identified as the noise component that is expected to accompany the hbo . in the relativistic precession model , the upper and lower khz qpos , and the hbo ,
are all produced by the same blob orbiting in the accretion disc ( stella & vietri @xcite ; stella & vietri @xcite ; stella , vietri & morsink @xcite ) .
the model makes clear predictions of the correlations between those frequencies .
unfortunately , since we did not definitely detect an hbo , and the khz qpos were only detected in one part of the z track , we can not test those predictions . and
, our hbo upper limits are too high to draw any meaningful conclusion about its presence or otherwise , since weaker hbos have been observed ( e.g. , in sco x-1 ; van der klis et al .
if we assume that we _ have _ detected an hbo at 48 hz , with khz qpos at 715 hz and 985 hz , then the mass and spin frequency of the neutron star can be inferred from the model .
judging from fig . 1 in stella & vietri ( @xcite ) , the inferred mass is @xmath02 m@xmath38 ;
the other z sources have inferred masses in the range @xmath01.82.2 m@xmath38 ( stella & vietri @xcite ) .
the mass of the neutron star in cyg x-2 has been dynamically established as [email protected] m@xmath38 , which is consistent with the inferred masses ( orosz & kuulkers @xcite ) .
judging from fig .
1(b ) in stella et al .
( @xcite ) , the inferred spin frequency , for neutron star equation of state au and an assumed mass of 1.95 m@xmath38 , is @xmath0600 hz ; the other z sources have an inferred spin frequency in the range @xmath0600900 hz ( stella et al .
@xcite ) . in the so - called transition layer model ( e.g. , titarchuk ,
osherovich & kuznetsov @xcite ) , z source lfn is the same phenomenon as atoll source hfn , and the sub - hbo peak is the same phenomenon as atoll source 167 hz qpos .
both of these phenomena are due to oscillations in the transition layer between the disc and the neutron star .
the hbo , the hbo second harmonic , and the upper khz qpo , are frequencies at which a blob oscillates , having been thrown out of the transition layer into the magnetosphere . the lower khz qpo is the orbital frequency at the inner edge of the disc .
recently , wu ( @xcite ) found good agreement between the predictions of the model and observations of z sources and atoll sources .
it is unclear how the fractional rms amplitude of lfn is predicted to vary with energy because the actual mechanism that produces that variability has not been specified ( titarchuk & osherovich @xcite ) .
naturally any such mechanism that is proposed must account for the energy dependence we observed in sco x-2 .
if the transition layer model is correct , we can measure the angle @xmath39 between the plane of the accretion disc and the equator of the magnetosphere ( e.g. , titarchuk et al .
if we assume an hbo frequency of 48 hz , and use our observed khz qpo frequencies , then we infer @xmath39=56@xmath3203 , which is within the 5464 range found from the other z sources ( wu @xcite ) .
the sub - hbo seen in z sources may be interpreted as the fundamental qpo frequency , with the hbo and its second harmonic being interpreted as the second and fourth harmonics of the sub - hbo ( jonker et al .
jonker et al .
( @xcite ) ( also jonker @xcite ) found a broad feature in gx 5@xmath11 at 1.5 times the hbo frequency , making it the third harmonic of the sub - hbo .
they suggested that a warped disc with a two - fold symmetry can provide a mechanism which produces odd harmonics that are broader than the even harmonics , and that this mechanism could be used as part of the relativistic precession model .
the fwhm of the possible sub - hbo and hbo we observed at s@xmath6=1.66 were 29@xmath3210 hz and 26@xmath328 hz , respectively .
the uncertainties here are too large to test the warped disc model . if vlfn is due to changes in intensity that are associated with the movement of a source along its z track , then a model for vlfn will provide at least part of the mechanism that gives rise to the z track .
for example , in the unified model ( e.g. , psaltis et al .
@xcite ) the movement along the z track is driven by changes in the mass - accretion rate which alter the physical conditions in the region of the neutron star and inner accretion disc .
the mass - accretion rate changes from sub- to super - eddington with movement from the nb into the fb . in this particular context , a model for vlfn will provide the mechanism that produces those changes in the accretion rate .
recently , van der klis ( @xcite ) suggested that position along the z track may not be related to the actual mass - accretion rate .
rather , he proposed that rank number is related to the ratio @xmath40 between the instantaneous accretion rate through the disc , and the long - term average of that rate . in this model ,
movement to a higher s@xmath6 requires either : an increase in the accretion rate ; or for the accretion rate to remain constant immediately following a decrease .
conversely , movement to a lower s@xmath6 occurs either : when the accretion rate decreases ; or when it remains constant immediately following an increase . again
, if vlfn is due to movement along the track , then the details of this model must be such that @xmath40 exhibits a power - law variability .
furthermore , the abrupt changes we observed in the properties of the vlfn with movement through the nb / fb vertex suggests that any model for vlfn should also provide information about the physical basis of that transition .
we observed an increase in the fractional rms amplitude of the vlfn with increasing s@xmath6 , and it was stronger at higher energies .
the same behaviour was seen in the _ ginga _ observations of sco x-2 ( oneill et al .
@xcite ) , and also in sco x-1 ( dieters & van der klis @xcite ) . however , our results are very different to those from the 1998 september and october _ rxte _ data on sco x-2 , in which the vlfn behaved somewhat erratically , and was , on average , stronger in the nb than in the fb ( agrawal & bhattacharyya @xcite ) .
homan et al .
( @xcite ) found that , in gx 17 + 2 , the rms of the vlfn did not increase smoothly with movement up the fb ; as the object moved away from the nb / fb vertex , the rms decreased at first , reaching a local minimum at about one - quarter of the way up the fb , and then increased smoothly with increasing s@xmath6 .
however , the vlfn in gx 17 + 2 was still , on average , stronger in the fb than in the nb .
the reason for the differences between our results and those from the 1998 september and october data is unclear .
agrawal & bhattacharyya ( @xcite ) used 8 s intervals when calculating their power spectra , which meant their lowest frequency was 0.125 hz , compared to 0.0625 hz in our spectra ; this may have produced some differences between the two sets of results due to interference , during the fitting process , from the peaked noise .
the power - law index of the vlfn we observed decreased with movement down the nb , abruptly increased at the nb / fb vertex , and then remained roughly constant with movement up the fb , decreasing slightly in the upper part of the fb ; in the fb , the mean value of the index was [email protected] .
in contrast to this , the index of the vlfn found in the 1998 september and october _ rxte _ data exhibited no dependence on s@xmath6 ; in the fb the index had a mean value of [email protected] ( agrawal & bhattacharyya @xcite ) . in sco x-1 , the power - law index _ increased _ with movement down the nb , from 1.2 to 1.7 , although , similar to our results , was constant in the fb , with a mean of [email protected] ( dieters & van der klis @xcite ) .
in gx 17 + 2 , the index gradually increased with movement down the nb and reached a maximum at about 10 per cent of the way up the fb ; it then decreased gradually with further movement up the fb ( homan et al .
@xcite ) . of note
, however , is that the power - law index in gx 17 + 2 reached a local maximum of @xmath01.6 , at roughly three - quarters of the way down the nb , and it then subsequently decreased to reach a local minimum , of @xmath00.8 , near the nb / fb vertex ( see fig . 11 in homan et al .
a similar effect has also been seen in gx 5@xmath11 ( jonker et al .
@xcite ) , and we may have observed the same thing in sco x-2 , albeit with a much broader local minimum . as discussed in the previous section ,
understanding vlfn is important in understanding the overall behaviour of z sources .
therefore , the presence of vastly different vlfn phenomenologies in sco x-2 , during different observations , is an important result that needs to be clarified .
wijnands et al .
( @xcite ) found that , in cyg x-2 , the properties of the vlfn varied as the overall intensity level changed ; variations in other components of the fast - time variability , and in the x - ray spectral properties , also accompanied those changes .
the differences in the vlfn phenomenology in sco x-2 may be related to the same effect .
dieters & van der klis ( @xcite ) identified vlfn in sco x-1 with movement along the z track , while homan et al .
( @xcite ) found that , in gx 17 + 2 , the speed of movement through the z track was not correlated with vlfn strength in all parts of the track .
wijnands et al .
( @xcite ) similarly investigated the vlfn in cyg x-2 at different overall intensities .
they found that the speed of movement through the track was highest at the highest overall intensity level , while the vlfn was strongest at the intermediate level ; they , therefore , concluded that the vlfn in the nb could not solely be due to movement along the z track .
we detected vlfn in the vertical part of the nb .
therefore , if vlfn is produced solely by intensity changes that are associated with movement along the track , then , within each interval , there must significant movement along the track to regions above and below the vertical part of the nb , such that there are variations in intensity .
the absence of an arc - like distribution of the 1 s time resolution points suggests there is no such movement .
the 1 s time - domain data points have very large uncertainties in hardness , so we used cross spectral analysis to investigate the relationship between intensity and hardness . in the fb and upper nb the variations in the intensity and hardness
are consistent with being in phase with each other .
this is consistent with the variations in intensity being due only to movement along the z track , though it does not rule out a cross - track component . in the lower nb
, we found that at @xmath410.004 hz the variations in intensity were negatively correlated with the variations in hardness , which is consistent with those variations also being due to movement up and down that part of the nb .
however , at higher frequencies , we found that the intensity was positively correlated with hardness , indicating that , at those frequencies , the variations in intensity must be associated with movement that is not directly along the z track . and
, the negative correlation at @xmath410.004 hz suggests that that cross - track component of motion is more prominent at higher frequencies .
we caution , however , that these conclusions must remain tentative due to the low significance , and large uncertainties , of our phase measurements .
a model has been proposed to explain power - law variability in black hole candidates ( e.g. , mineshige , takeuchi & nishimora @xcite ) .
their model can produce power - law fluctuations in the mass - accretion rate from the inner accrection disc , even when the rate of mass - injection into the inner part of the disc is random .
the predicted x - ray power spectrum exhibits a power - law index of about 1.6 , with a flattening at low frequencies .
this model can possibly be applied to the unified model , thereby providing the mechanism to produce changes in the accretion rate . whether or not it can produce a large enough range in mass - accretion rate ( 0.71.02 times the eddington limit ; psaltis et al .
@xcite ) and a low enough break frequency ( sco x-1 is predicted to have a turnover time - scale of several days ; dieters & van der klis @xcite ) needs to be tested . an alternative , yet similar , model for vlfn is the ` dripping handrail ' model ( e.g. , young & scargle @xcite ) , in which the amount of matter present at the inner edge of the accretion disc varies both quasi- and aperiodically . if luminosity is considered to be proportional to the mass at the inner edge of the disc , then both a power - law variability and a qpo are produced .
the frequency of the qpo is proportional to accretion rate , so it can not be identified as flaring branch noise ( see also dieters & van der klis @xcite ) .
if the rate at which matter _ leaves _ the disc is considered , then the power - law component disappears ( steiman - cameron et al .
this model can not , therefore , produce a power - law variability in mass - accretion rate , and so it can not be applied to the unified model .
time dependent nuclear burning on the surface of the neutron star has also been proposed to produce vlfn , with the power - law index expected to increase with increasing mass - accretion rate ( bildsten @xcite ) .
dieters & van der klis ( @xcite ) noted that : the predicted variability has a characteristic time - scale , in contrast to the observed vlfn in sco x-1 , which is a power - law over time - scales ranging from 10 s to about 14 h ; and the energy available from nuclear burning is not sufficient to produce the observed fractional rms amplitude .
therefore , it is difficult for nuclear burning alone to account for vlfn .
our results provide further evidence that the variations in intensity comprising the very low frequency noise are associated with movement that is not directly along the z track .
a possible scenario is that changes in mass - accretion rate , or @xmath40 , produce motion in which there is a component both along , and across , the track , and that the cross - track component is more prominent at higher frequencies .
alternatively , changes in mass - accretion rate or @xmath40 might only produce movement along the track , with nuclear burning providing a cross - track component .
except for the transition from the nb into the fb , we observed a general decrease in power - law index with increasing inferred mass - accretion rate .
in contrast , the nuclear burning model predicts an increase in index with increasing mass - accretion rate .
therefore , if nuclear burning is found to be contributing significantly to vlfn , the ` @xmath40 model ' for the z - track is preferred , since it does not specify a particular mass - accretion rate for each part of the track . as pointed out by dieters & van der klis ( @xcite )
, the two types of variations would need to combine and produce the observed vlfn power - law .
we have carried out the most comprehensive study to date , of the x - ray fast - time variability of sco x-2 as a function of position on the z track .
we found low frequency noise in the nb , and typical sco x-2 flaring branch noise in the fb , with centroid frequencies in the range 3.35.8 hz and 5.47.6 hz , respectively .
the lfn was strongest at intermediate photon energies , while fbn was hard .
the various models seeking to provide an explanantion for lfn in z sources must account for the energy dependence we observed .
with regard to fbn , we confirm the conclusions reached by oneill et al .
( @xcite ) , and again note the similarity between fbn and the peaked noise seen the fb of cyg x-2 at low overall intensities ( kuulkers et al .
we suggest that an adaptation of the photon bubble model may possibly provide an explanation for fbn ( klein et al .
@xcite ) . we found a new peaked noise feature in the nb and fb , with a centroid frequency in the range 1154 hz .
this high frequency peak was stronger at higher energies .
it could be fitted satisfactorily with a single lorentzian , but , in the nb , it could also be fitted with two lorentzian components , representing a possible hbo and sub - hbo peak .
we found very low frequency noise throughout the z track .
it exhibited abrupt changes in the power - law index and fractional rms amplitude with movement from the nb into the fb .
we calculated complex cross spectra between intensity and hardness , and discovered that vlfn is not entirely due to movement along the z track . we speculate that vlfn may be due to : variations in mass - accretion rate or @xmath40 that produce motion in the hid with a component both parallel , and perpendicular , to the track ; or a combination of nuclear burning on the neutron star , and variations in accretion or @xmath40 .
this research has made use of data obtained from the high energy astrophysics science archive research center , nasa / goddard space flight center .
the authors thank alan smale for assistance in obtaining the data .
pmo has in part been supported by the australian postgraduate award scheme .
this work was supported in part by the netherlands organization for scientific research ( nwo ) . 99 agrawal v. k. ,
bhattacharyya s. , 2001 , a&a , submitted [ astro - ph/0112545 ] alpar m. a. , shaham j. , 1985 , nat , 316 , 239 belloni t. , psaltis d. , van der klis m. , 2002 , apj , submitted [ astro - ph/0202213 ] berger m. , van der klis m. , 1994 , a&a , 292 , 175 bildsten l. , 1995 , apj , 438 , 852 bradt h. v. , rothschild r. e. , swank j. h. , 1993 , a&as , 97 , 355 dieters s. w. , van der klis m. , 2000 , mnras , 311 , 201 dieters s. w. , vaughan b. a. , kuulkers e. , lamb f. k. , van der klis m. , 2000 , a&a , 353 , 203 fortner b. , lamb f. k. , miller g. s. , 1989 , nat , 342 , 775 hasinger g. , van der klis m. , 1989 , a&a , 225 , 79 hasinger g. , van der klis m. , ebisawa k. , dotani t. , mitsuda k. , 1990 , a&a , 235 , 131 hertz p. , vaughan b. , wood k.s . , norris j.p . , mitsuda k. , michelson p.f . , dotani t. , 1992 , apj , 396 , 201 homan j. , van der klis m. , jonker p. , wijnands r. , kuulkers e. , m@xmath42ndez m. , lewin w. h. g. , 2002 , apj , 568 , 878 jonker p. g. , 2001 , phd thesis , univ . of amsterdam jonker p. g. , van der klis m. , wijnands r. , homan j. , van paradijs j. , m@xmath42ndez m. , ford e. c. , kuulkers e. , lamb f k. , 2000 , apj , 537 , 374 jonker p. g. , van der klis m. , homan j. , m@xmath42ndez m. , lewin w. , wijnands r. , zhang w. , 2002 , mnras , submitted [ astro - ph/0202420 ] klein r. i. , arons j. , jernigan g. , hsu j. j .- l .
, 1996a , apj , 457 , l85 klein r. i. , jernigan j. g. , arons j. , morgan , e. h. , zhang , w. , 1996b , apj , 469 , l119 kuulkers e. , van der klis m. , 1998 , a&a , 332 , 845 kuulkers e. , wijnands r. , van der klis m. , 1999 , mnras , 308 , 485 lamb f. k. , 1991 , in ventura j. , pines d. , eds . , neutron stars : theory and observations .
kluwer academic publishers , dordrecht p. 445 . lamb f. k. , shibazaki n. , alpar m. a. , shaham j. , 1985 , nat , 317 , 681 lewin w. h. g. , lubin l. m. , tan j. , van der klis m. , paradijs j. , penninx w. , dotani t. , mitsuda k. , 1992 , mnras , 256 , 545 mineshige s. , takeuchi m. , nishimori h. , 1994 , apj , 435 , l125
oneill p. m. , kuulkers e. , sood r. k. , dotani t. , 2001a , a&a , 370 , 479 oneill p. m. , kuulkers e. , sood r. k. , van der klis m. , 2001b , in inoue h. , kunieda h. , eds
. , new century of x - ray astronomy , astronomical society of the pacific conf .
. astronomical society of the pacific , san francisco , p. 396 .
orosz j. a. , kuulkers e. , 1999 , mnras , 305 , 132 ponman t. j. , cooke b. a. , stella l. , 1988 , mnras , 231 , 999 psaltis d. , lamb f. k. , miller g. s. , 1995 , apj , 454 , l137 psaltis d. , belloni t. , van der klis m. , 1999a , apj , 520 , 262 psaltis d. , et al .
, 1999b , apj , 520 , 763 schulz n.s . , hasinger g. , trmper j. , 1989 , a&a , 225 , 48 shibazaki n. , lamb f. k. , 1987 , apj , 318 , 767 steiman - cameron t. y. , young k. , scargle j. d. , crutchfield j. p. , imamura j. n. , wolff m. t. , wood k. s. , 1994 , apj , 435 , 775 stella l. vietri m. , 1998 , apj , 492 , l59 stella l. vietri m. , 1999 , phys .
, 82 , 17 stella l. vietri m. , morsink s. m. , 1999 , apj , 524 , l63 sunyaev r. , revnivtsev m. , 2000 , a&a , 358 617 titarchuk l. , osherovich v. , 1999 , apj , 518 , l95 titarchuk l. , osherovich v. , kuznetsov s. , 1999 , apj , 525 , l129 van der klis m. , 1989 , in gelman h. , van den heuvel , e. p. j. , eds . , timing neutron stars .
kluwer academic publishers , dordrecht , p. 27 . van der klis m. , 1991 , in ventura j. , pines d. , eds . , neutron stars :
theory and observation .
kluwer academic publishers , dordrecht , nato asi series c 344 , p. 319 . van der klis m. , 1994a , a&a , 283 , 469 van der klis m. , 1994b , apjs , 92 , 511 van der klis m. , 1995a , in lewin w. h. g. , van paradijs j. , van der heuvel e. p. j. , eds .
, x - ray binaries .
cambridge univ . press , cambridge ,
p. 252 .
van der klis m. , 1995b , in alpar m. a. , et al .
, eds . , the lives of neutron stars .
kluwer academic publishers , dordrecht , p. 301 .
van der klis m. , 2000 , ara&a , 38 , 717 van der klis m. , 2001 , apj , 561 , 943 van der klis m. , hasinger g. , stella l. , langmeier a. , van paradijs j. , lewin w. h. g. , 1987 , apj , 319 , l13 van der klis m. , wijnands r. a. d. , horne k. , chen w. , 1997 , apj , 481 , l97 wijnands r. , van der klis m. , 1999 , apj , 514 , 939 wijnands r. , van der klis m. , kuulkers e. , asai k. , hasinger g. , 1997 , a&a , 323 , 399 wu x. , 2001 , apj , 552 , 227 young k. , scargle j. d. , 1996 , apj , 468 , 617 yu w. , van der klis m. , jonker p. g. , 2001 , apj , 559 , l29 zhang w. , strohmayer t. e. , swank j. h. , 1998 , apj , 500 , l167
in the case of _ rxte _ , the observed counting rate _ per detector _
@xmath5 , and incident counting rate @xmath43 , can be divided into four components:`good xenon ' counting rate @xmath44 ; the ` remaining count ' @xmath45 ; the counting rate from the propane layer @xmath46 ; and the ` very large event ' counting rate @xmath47 .
the counting rate of good xenon events is the x - ray counting rate from the source and background .
the remaining count is the counting rate of events that are detected simultaneously at more than one anode .
these coincident events are primarily due to particles , and , in bright sources , may also due to ` genuine ' photons . in each detector
, there is a propane layer in front of the xenon layers which is used primarily for anti - coincidence , and may also be used to detect source photons in the range 13 kev ( bradt et al .
@xcite ) . the very large event counting rate is from events that are above the upper discriminator ; these events are mainly due to particles .
the actual fractional rms amplitude @xmath57 of variations in @xmath58 may be related to the observed fractional rms amplitude @xmath59 of variations in @xmath44 by the following expression ( van der klis @xcite ) to determine @xmath62 , we need to evaluate @xmath63 .
therefore , we also need to determine how @xmath64 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 , depend on @xmath58 . in figs .
[ fig : remainingcnt ] , [ fig : vpcnt ] , and [ fig : vlecnt ] , we present plots of @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 , respectively , versus @xmath58 .
the data presented are from standard 1 mode using 16 s averages . in fig .
[ fig : remainingcnt ] , in the region @xmath673000 counts s@xmath37 detector@xmath37 , there is a roughly linear relationship between the good xenon counting rate and remaining count . in the region @xmath683000
counts s@xmath37 detector@xmath37 , the lower envelope of the plot also follows the linear relationship observed above 3000 counts s@xmath37 detector@xmath37 , suggesting that the relationship holds for all @xmath58 .
the best - fitting linear coefficient , as fitted in the @xmath58 range 30004600 counts s@xmath37 detector@xmath37 , was 0.085 .
the large scatter of points lying above the linear relationship , in the region @xmath683000 counts s@xmath37 detector@xmath37 , can be attributed to events from particles .
this interpretation is supported by the presence of a similar scattering of points in fig [ fig : vlecnt ] . in fig .
[ fig : vpcnt ] , there is a quadratic relationship between @xmath65 and @xmath58 .
the best - fitting quadratic and linear coefficients were @xmath11.165e-5 and 0.175 , respectively . in fig .
[ fig : vlecnt ] , there is no clear correlation between @xmath66 and @xmath58 .
@xmath71 } { \left ( 1 + \tau_{\mathrm{xe}}\lambda_{\mathrm{xe } } + \tau_{\mathrm{r}}\lambda_{\mathrm{r } } + \tau_{\mathrm{p}}\lambda_{\mathrm{p } } + \tau_{\mathrm{v}}\lambda_{\mathrm{v } } \right)^{2 } } \\ \frac{d f}{d \lambda_{\mathrm{xe } } } & = - \tau_{\mathrm{xe}}[1.26 - ( 2.33\mathrm{e-}5)\lambda_{\mathrm{xe } } ] { f^{2}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] | sco x-2 ( gx 349 + 2 ) is a low - mass x - ray binary and z source .
we have analysed @xmath0156 ks of _ rossi x - ray timing explorer _ data , obtained in 1998 january , on this source .
we investigated the fast - time variability as a function of position on the z track . during these observations ,
sco x-2 traced out the most extensive z track ever reported from this object , making this the most comprehensive study thus far .
we found the broad peaked flaring branch noise that is typical of sco x-2 , with a centroid frequency in the range 3.35.8 hz .
we also discovered low frequency noise , and a new peaked noise feature , with centroid frequencies in the range 5.47.6 hz and 1154 hz , respectively .
we discuss the phenomenology of these features , their relationship with the power spectral components found in other low - mass x - ray binaries , and the implications for current models .
in particular , the low frequency noise we observed was strongest at intermediate energies , in contrast to the low frequency noise seen in other z sources .
we also detected very low frequency noise , and have calculated complex cross spectra between intensity and hardness .
we found that the very low frequency noise is not entirely due to motion along the z track .
[ firstpage ] accretion , accretion disks stars : binaries : close stars : individual : sco x-2 ; gx 349 + 2 stars : neutron x - rays : stars |
manganese pnictides of the hexagonal nias structure type ( _ e.g. _ mnas , mn@xmath1sb , mnbi ; figure [ fig : structure ] ) display a wealth of functional magnetic properties .
the class of materials includes potential candidates for rare earth - free permanent magnets,@xcite magneto - optical data storage,@xcite and magnetic refrigeration.@xcite manganese antimonide is known to only exist as a manganese - rich phase , mn@xmath1sb.@xcite the wide compositional region shown on the equilibrium phase diagram extends from @xmath7,@xcite with excess mn occupying the interstitial site ( figure [ fig : structure]b ) in trigonal bipyramidal coordination by sb .
increasing amounts of interstitial mn ( mn@xmath0 ) lengthen the @xmath8 and shorten the @xmath9 lattice parameters , which accompanies reductions of the saturation magnetization , spin - reorientation temperature ( @xmath10),@xcite and the curie temperature ( @xmath11).@xcite magnetic ordering of the primary mn sites occurs parallel to @xmath9 at high temperature , but it changes to the @xmath12 plane below @xmath10.@xcite although the bulk magnetic properties are well known , the microscopic nature of the magnetism associated with mn@xmath0 has been equivocal .
a straightforward explanation of the reduced magnetization in more mn - rich samples is that mn@xmath0 is aligned antiparallel to the ferromagnetic mn@xmath13 atoms , that is , mn@xmath1sb is ferrimagnetic .
( here we use krger vink notation to differentiate interstitial mn@xmath0 and nominal mn@xmath13 atoms . )
nonpolarized neutron diffraction studies are consistent with this expectation.@xcite however , polarized neutron scattering analyses have suggested that mn@xmath0 has no moment .
@xcite the reduction of magnetization is then explained on the basis of greater orbital overlap between mn atoms upon reduction of the @xmath9 lattice constant , and to a local perturbation of the mn moment when in proximity to mn@xmath0.@xcite , with mn on 2@xmath8 at ( 0,0,0 ) and bi on 2@xmath9 at ( @xmath14 ) ] , and inelastic neutron scattering data collected at 4k from a single crystal of mnbi .
( b ) structure of mn@xmath1sb highlighting the fractionally occupied , trigonal bipyramidal coordination environment of interstitial mn [ mn@xmath0 , on 2@xmath15 site at ( @xmath16 ) ] .
note that mn@xmath0 is also in trigonal prismatic coordination with respect to the primary ( fully occupied ) mn@xmath13 site .
inelastic neutron scattering data collected at 10k on a single crystal of mn@xmath17sb shows a pronounced diffuse component that is not observed for mnbi .
inelastic scattering figures adapted from taylor _ et al .
_ , reference .,width=316 ] the question of whether mn@xmath0 carries a moment was recently re - addressed by taylor _
_ via a combination of nonpolarized elastic and inelastic neutron scattering on an mn@xmath17sb single crystal.@xcite a critical feature of the modeling strategies adopted in previous _
polarized _ neutron studies was the use of a highly aspherical magnetic form factor for mn.@xcite in the recent work of taylor and co - workers it was shown that such a model provides an inferior description of the magnetic reflections particularly at low @xmath18 where magnetic scattering is strongest relative to a model employing a spherical magnetic form factor and antiferromagnetic coupling between mn@xmath0 and mn@xmath13.@xcite density functional calculations enlisting small supercells further supported mn@xmath1sb as a ferrimagnet .
additionally , a pronounced and gapless diffuse magnetic component was observed across all temperature regimes in the inelastic spectrum ( figure [ fig : structure]b ) , centered at ( 001 ) .
similar or related features have also been noted by other groups.@xcite the location of the diffuse component is intriguing because the ( 001 ) reflection should be systematically absent from the structure factor ; there is no diffuse scattering observed for stoichiometric ( interstitial - free ) mnbi ( figure [ fig : structure]a ) .
two plausible explanations were suggested : the diffuse scattering could arise from ( @xmath19 ) correlated structural or magnetic disorder , or ( @xmath20 ) modification of the neighboring mn@xmath13 moments by mn@xmath0.@xcite an essential feature of the mn@xmath1sb system that has been largely unaccounted for , both experimentally and computationally , is the local structure around mn@xmath0 .
it has long been recognized that the equatorial mn@xmath0sb contacts of the crystallographic mn@xmath0 site in the mn@xmath1sb unit cell are quite short.@xcite however , few studies have attempted to model the presumed structural relaxation.@xcite yamaguchi and watanabe approximated that mn@xmath0 would be accommodated by distortions of only the sb positions , the magnitude of the local displacements being derived from the concentration dependence of the lattice parameters.@xcite this assumption was used in their analysis of polarized neutron diffuse scattering data .
models with no mn@xmath0 moment , but containing reduced moments on the first or second nearest - neighbor mn atoms in proximity to mn@xmath0 , were compared against calculated scattering for a model with mn@xmath0 aligned antiparallel . although the best agreement was obtained for a reduction of the six nearest - neighbor mn moments , an aspherical mn magnetic form factor appears to have contributed to the result.@xcite the utility of density functional modeling in describing local structural effects and defect physics is well demonstrated .
a variety of approaches can be used to simulate defects ( substitutional , interstitial , antisite , vacancy ) and random alloying , the validity of which is reflected in agreement with a variety of experimental probes of local bonding arrangements , including nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr),@xcite extended x - ray absorption fine structure ( exafs),@xcite and pair distribution function ( pdf ) data obtained from total scattering .
@xcite when the concentration of defects is low , an effective strategy is to model a defect in a sufficiently large supercell such that the defect is approximately isolated ( _ i.e. _ , limiting the interaction between defects when periodic boundary conditions are applied).@xcite at higher levels of substitution , the creation of models on the basis of chemically reasonable , ordered supercells can be an elegant strategy to assess plausible bonding motifs.@xcite random alloys are inherently challenging systems to model in the framework of density functional theory ( dft ) , since even large supercells will necessarily contain elements of periodicity that are absent in a truly random structure , but strategies such as stochastic mixing and the special quasirandom structures approach often provide adequate approximations.@xcite mn@xmath1sb can be regarded as a type of random alloy , with a distribution of interstitials and vacancies over the crystallographic mn@xmath0 site . in the present contribution ,
we examine local structural relaxation in mn@xmath1sb using synchrotron x - ray total scattering and pdf analysis coupled with density functional modeling .
the use of x rays rather than neutrons allows us to base our analysis on the local nuclear structure without interference from magnetic scattering .
particular attention is devoted to the mn@xmath0 environment and its calculated magnetic moment , as well as the compositional and structural influence on the moment of ferromagnetically aligned mn@xmath13 .
structural relaxation has a pronounced effect on the mn@xmath0 environment and enhances electronic localization by a lengthening of equatorial sb contacts , but it does not appear to influence the moments on mn@xmath13 or sb .
a weak diffuse signal is observed near the symmetry - forbidden ( 001 ) bragg position , suggestive of correlated disorder associated with clustering of mn@xmath0 .
these results are discussed in light of the recent work of taylor _ _
the series of polycrystalline mn@xmath1sb ( @xmath21 0.23 ) samples were prepared in alumina crucibles from the elements ( mn flake , noah technologies corporation , 99.99% ; sb shot , alfa aesar , 99% ) .
antimony was recrystallized before use , and surface oxide was removed from mn by heating overnight in an evacuated fused silica tube at 980@xmath22c .
appropriate stoichiometric mixtures sealed in evacuated silica tubes were melted at 930@xmath22c for 16h and then quenched in water .
the obtained ingots were finely powdered in an agate mortar and pressed into pellets , then annealed under vacuum at 700@xmath22c for 48h and water - quenched .
magnetization measurements were performed with a vibrating sample magnetometer on a quantum design , inc .
dynacool ppms .
room - temperature x - ray powder diffraction and x - ray total scattering measurements were conducted at the advanced photon source of argonne national laboratory .
high - resolution synchrotron x - ray powder diffraction patterns were collected at the 11-bm - b beamline using an x - ray energy of about 30kev ( @xmath23).@xcite samples were diluted with amorphous sio@xmath24 to reduce the effects of absorption .
rietveld analyses were performed within the gsas / expgui suite.@xcite x - ray total scattering measurements were performed at the 11-id - b beamline .
data were collected with an amorphous silicon area detector@xcite using two x - ray energies , @xmath25kev ( @xmath26 ) and @xmath27kev ( @xmath28 ) , at sample - to - detector distances of approximately 17 cm and 19 cm , respectively .
calibrations were performed by measurement of a ceo@xmath24 standard at each condition .
the electron density pair distribution function , @xmath29 , was obtained from background - subtracted scattering data by the _ ad - hoc _
approach applied in pdfgetx3.@xcite the reduced scattering structure function , @xmath30 , was transformed to @xmath29 using a maximum momentum transfer of @xmath31@xmath32 for data collected at 58kev , and @xmath33@xmath32 for data collected at 86kev .
a powdered nickel standard was used to determine the resolution truncation parameters @xmath34 and @xmath35 used in pdfgui refinements.@xcite reverse monte carlo ( rmc ) simulations were conducted using the rmcprofile software,@xcite with models constrained to fit @xmath30 and @xmath29 to capture both long- and short - range order .
a `` closest approach '' constraint of 2.2 was applied to all atomic species to prevent the fitting of termination ripples in the low @xmath36 region of the pdf .
simulated diffraction patterns were computed using the diffax software;@xcite input files are provided in the supplemental material . density functional theory ( dft ) calculations were performed using the vienna _ ab - initio _ simulation package ( vasp),@xcite with interactions between the cores ( mn:[ar ] , sb:[kr]4d@xmath37 ) and valence electrons described using the projector augmented wave ( paw ) method.@xcite calculations were performed within the generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) using the functional of perdew , burke , and ernzerhof ( pbe)@xcite to account for the effects of exchange and correlation .
an energy cutoff of 350ev and a @xmath38-centered @xmath39 @xmath40-point sampling were employed for all calculations .
since pdf analysis is a measurement of the ensemble average of all pairwise correlations in a sample , a series of 10 distinct initial supercell configurations were constructed for each of three compositions , mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath42sb@xmath41 , mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath43sb@xmath41 , and mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath44sb@xmath41 ( where mn@xmath0 denotes interstitial manganese ) , which respectively provide compositions close to mn@xmath45sb , mn@xmath46sb , and mn@xmath47sb .
parent mn@xmath41sb@xmath41 supercells were built from orthonormal @xmath48-centered orthorhombic supercells of the conventional crystallographic lattice , with dimensions reflecting the lattice constants obtained by rietveld refinement .
interstitial mn positions were selected stochastically with the aid of rmcprofile@xcite by filling all of the interstitial positions with mn or vacancy ( dummy ) atoms and distributing mn@xmath0 by performing short simulations in which mn@xmath0 atoms were `` swapped '' with vacancy atoms ; simulations lasting 6 seconds typically produced 50,000 atom swap moves , leading to a robust ensemble of starting structural configurations .
relaxations of the supercells were performed at fixed cell dimensions , allowing only the atomic positions to change , and they were deemed to have converged when the forces on all ions were less than 0.01ev@xmath32 .
all calculations were performed with spin polarization , using starting spin configurations in which mn@xmath0 was aligned antiparallel to mn . for select configurations ,
test calculations were performed with an on - site coulomb repulsion term on mn ( gga+@xmath49 ) , or with spin orbit coupling ; neither the inclusion of a hubbard @xmath49 nor the effects of the spin
orbit interaction produced any qualitative changes to the results discussed below .
/@xmath8 ) ratio of the mn@xmath1sb lattice constants as a function of the nominal interstitial mn content , @xmath50 , showing vgard law behavior over most of the compositional range and excellent agreement between rietveld and pdf refinements and literature values.@xcite error bars are smaller than the symbols .
( b ) room temperature saturation magnetization as a function of @xmath50 , and bulk magnetization at 0k obtained from dft calculations of unrelaxed and relaxed supercells of mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath51sb@xmath41 ( @xmath52 ) ; dft moments represent the average of 10 distinct configurations at each composition , with error bars representing the standard deviation of the average .
( c ) room temperature magnetization hysteresis curves of the mn@xmath1sb series of samples .
note that the magnetization curves for @xmath53 and @xmath54 nearly overlay , which is consistent with the samples @xmath55 ratios being nearly the same.,width=288 ] the series of mn@xmath1sb samples ( @xmath56 ) span approximately the entire compositional range and display vgard law behavior of the lattice parameters between @xmath57 , as shown by the linear trend in @xmath55 ratio as a function of @xmath50 , figure [ fig : average]a .
small deviations from linearity are noted for the nominally @xmath53 and @xmath58 compositions , indicating proximity to the phase boundary extrema .
the @xmath53 sample contains a small amount of antimony metal ( @xmath59wt.% ) , and all of the samples contain small impurities of mno , estimated by quantitative phase analysis to be @xmath60wt.% .
there is no evidence of an mn@xmath24sb impurity in the mn@xmath47sb sample , suggesting the solubility limit had not been reached .
axial ratios obtained from rietveld refinements of high - resolution synchrotron x - ray diffraction data ( 11-bm ) agree very closely with the ratios obtained from real - space refinements of pdf data .
a representative rietveld refinement is presented in figure [ fig : rietveld ] for the @xmath61 sample , and a complete list of refined values for both rietveld and pdf refinements is given in table sm-1 .
the mn@xmath0 occupancies estimated by rietveld refinement agree well with the nominal stoichiometries across the @xmath62 range , with estimated errors in the site occupancy of 0.01 .
fractionally occupied mn@xmath0 has a site multiplicity of 2 ( wyckoff position 2@xmath15 ) in the crystallographic model , but this does not imply that interstitial atoms necessarily occur in pairs in a given unit cell of the `` real '' material . consider that for @xmath61 there is only one mn@xmath0 for every 10 unit cells [ _ i.e. _ mn@xmath63(mn@xmath0)@xmath64sb@xmath63 ] : although the crystallographic cell indicates that mn@xmath0 populates both sites of the 2@xmath15 position _ on average _ , it is quite conceivable that interstitial atoms are present _ locally _ in just one of the two interstitial voids .
sb against high resolution synchrotron x - ray diffraction data ( 11-bm , advanced photon source ) . to aid in visual inspection of the fit
, the low and high @xmath18 regions of the diffraction data are omitted .
reflection positions for mn@xmath66sb and the mno impurity are shown as solid vertical lines in the two middle panels.,width=316 ] room - temperature saturation magnetizations ( figure [ fig : average]b ) , taken from the room - temperature hysteresis curves shown in figure [ fig : average]c , decrease linearly as the quantity of interstitial mn increases .
magnetization curves of the @xmath53 and @xmath54 samples are nearly overlaid , which is consistent with their comparable @xmath55 ratios and @xmath50 values obtained by rietveld refinement . in general , pdfs of the mn@xmath1sb series are well described by the conventional crystallographic cell ( constrained by space - group symmetry ) , particularly at low concentrations of mn@xmath0 where there is limited sensitivity to its pair correlations .
real - space refinements ( pdfgui ) over the 230 range for mn@xmath67sb , mn@xmath68sb , and mn@xmath47sb are shown in figure [ fig : pdf]a , and they are representative of fit quality across the complete series of samples ( figure sm-1 ) . these fits worsen as a function of increasing @xmath50 in the low @xmath36 region of the pdfs , but beyond about 5 the crystallographic structures provide very satisfactory fits to the data .
in fact , for samples containing up to 10% mn@xmath0 , better statistical agreement is consistently obtained in refinements over the 6 to 30 range with a mn@xmath69sb model ( _ i.e. _ , without mn@xmath0 ) than for mn@xmath1sb models containing partially occupied mn@xmath0 .
sb , mn@xmath68sb , and mn@xmath47sb , employing the crystallographic structural model in which interstitial mn ( mn@xmath0 ) is located on the @xmath70 site and partially occupied .
( a ) full - range fits , from 2 to 30 .
the vertical line at @xmath71 demarcates different @xmath72-axis scales at shorter and longer @xmath36 .
( b ) panels showing the first - nearest - neighbor region of the three full - range fits ; select pdf partial contributions for mn@xmath13sb ( dotted line ) and mn@xmath0sb ( solid line ) correlations are vertically offset for clarity .
as the amount of mn@xmath0 increases , the crystallographic structural model s deficiency becomes more apparent : there are shorter pair correlations present in the model than observed in the data , and these arise from equatorial mn@xmath0sb distances . , width=316 ]
the corresponding first nearest - neighbor peaks , comprising contributions from mn@xmath13sb , mn@xmath0sb and mn@xmath0mn@xmath13 , are highlighted in figure [ fig : pdf]b ; the pdf partials for mn@xmath13sb and mn@xmath0sb pair correlations are shown below in dotted and solid lines , respectively .
for clarity , mn@xmath13mn@xmath0 partials are not shown as these contribute very weakly at the same distances as mn@xmath13sb .
the crystallographic model predicts contributions at approximately 2.4 , although none are observed experimentally ; this intensity is derived from equatorial mn@xmath0sb correlations of the mn@xmath0 trigonal bipyramid .
the absence of observed intensity at this distance in @xmath29 is evidence that structural relaxation occurs either by or around interstitial atoms , which is also reflected in the poorer description of peak intensity and breadth for the more mn - rich samples .
this result is quantitatively consistent for the pdfs obtained from total scattering with two different x - ray wavelengths .
this feature is also robust considering the nyquist sampling frequency dictated by @xmath73 ( figure sm-2).@xcite comparing the crystallographic structural model against the observed data indicates that the equatorial mn@xmath0sb contacts are longer in the `` real '' material than reflected by the crystallographic cell .
qualitatively , a bond - lengthening around mn@xmath0 would be expected to increase electron localization and its magnetic moment.@xcite the ability to directly inspect pdf data and infer plausible structure property relations is an indisputable asset of the technique .
however , a more rigorous modeling approach is required to support and reconcile the impact of structural relaxation on the properties of mn@xmath1sb .
a series of density functional calculations were performed to assess relaxation by and around interstitial atoms in mn@xmath1sb . to account for the disorder inherent to this system ,
a collection of 10 distinct supercell configurations was created for each of three compositions selected from the compositional range .
all configurations are based on 96 atom mnsb supercells , with mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath42sb@xmath41 , mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath43sb@xmath41 , and mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath44sb@xmath41 formulas chosen to provide compositions close to mn@xmath45sb , mn@xmath46sb , and mn@xmath47sb .
the positions of mn@xmath0 in the supercell configurations were selected stochastically .
representative structural depictions of one configuration for each composition are shown in figure [ fig : supercells ] .
( mn@xmath0)@xmath42sb@xmath41 ( top ) , mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath43sb@xmath41 ( middle ) , and mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath44sb@xmath41 ( bottom ) .
mn@xmath13 is shown as light ( pink ) spheres , sb as dark ( gray ) spheres , and mn@xmath0 ( blue ) in polyhedral rendering .
an outline of the conventional unit cell is shown for reference.,width=168 ] to facilitate comparison with the pdf data , supercells for a given composition were constrained to dimensions commensurate with the experimentally determined unit - cell parameters .
all of the pdfs for different configurations of a given composition are very similar ( figure sm-3 ) , and differences are far less significant than termination artifacts introduced in the fourier transform of @xmath30 . a comparison of fits at short @xmath36 to the pdf of mn@xmath47sb for the crystallographically - constrained structure ( unit - cell model ) versus a representative mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath44sb@xmath41 supercell is shown in figure [ fig : partials]a .
dft relaxation provides a clear improvement in the description of @xmath29 , reflected in the marked reduction of @xmath74 ; for fits over the range 2 to 6 the average @xmath75-factor for all 10 configurations is 13(1)% , whereas @xmath76% for the crystallographic structural model .
statistical improvement with the mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath43sb@xmath41 dft relaxed structures is also found for fits against the mn@xmath46sb pdf data ( not shown ) , with @xmath77% versus @xmath78% . on the other hand ,
relaxed mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath42sb@xmath41 configurations are marginally worse than the crystallographic structure , statistically , in fits against the mn@xmath45sb data ( @xmath79% vs. @xmath80% ) , but this most likely reflects limited sensitivity to mn@xmath0 correlations for this composition . indeed ,
refinement of a mn@xmath69sb unit - cell model against the mn@xmath45sb data provides a better statistical fit ( @xmath81% ) than such a model with partially occupied mn@xmath0 .
refinement @xmath75-factors shown from fits in the range of 2 to 6 ; @xmath74 for the dft relaxed configuration represents the average for all 10 configurations , given with the standard deviation of the average .
( b ) select atom - pair partials extracted from the dft - relaxed and unit cell models , along with pdf partials generated from a reverse monte carlo simulation using a 9,990 atom supercell ( @xmath82%).,width=288 ] select atom - pair partials for the crystallographic mn@xmath47sb structure and relaxed mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath44sb@xmath41 supercell are shown in figure [ fig : partials]b .
the only pronounced differences occur for mn@xmath0sb and sb sb pair correlations , with mn@xmath13sb and mn@xmath13mn@xmath13 partials being notably very similar for the relaxed and unit cell models .
as anticipated , equatorial mn@xmath0sb correlations are clearly shifted to longer @xmath36 in the dft - relaxed model .
differences in the sb sb correlations of the models indicates that the antimony sublattice experiences the largest disruption upon incorporation of mn@xmath0 .
pdf partials for mn@xmath0sb and sb sb correlations obtained from reverse monte carlo simulation ( bottom of figure [ fig : partials]b ) agree well with those obtained by dft , lending additional support to our approach .
( mn@xmath0)@xmath42sb@xmath41 ; middle row : mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath43sb@xmath41 ; bottom row : mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath44sb@xmath41 .
, width=316 ] histograms displaying the amplitudes of atom displacements away from their crystallographic ( average ) structural positions upon dft relaxation are shown in figure [ fig : displace ] , arranged by site , and combined for all 10 supercell configurations of each composition . the mn@xmath13 and mn@xmath0 sites show unimodal distributions extending to roughly 0.1 , 0.15 , and 0.2 , respectively , from lowest to highest mn@xmath0 content .
the approximately bimodal sb histograms show displacements about twice as large for a given composition , with a third region of lower frequency but larger amplitude displacements observed for the mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath43sb@xmath41 and mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath44sb@xmath41 configurations associated with sb that have more than one nearest - neighbor mn@xmath0 .
all of the larger amplitude sb displacements ( @xmath83 ) correspond to equatorial mn@xmath0sb distances , whereas the displacement of axial sb atoms is typically @xmath84 . despite the large degree of relaxation displayed by sb atoms , the local distortions necessary to accommodate mn@xmath0
induce very minimal changes in the mn@xmath13sb and mn@xmath13mn@xmath13 bond distance distributions ( figure [ fig : partials]b ) , which are preserved because of cooperative distortions by mn@xmath13 .
this suggests that relaxation should have a much more pronounced effect on the electronic environment of mn@xmath0 than on either mn@xmath13 or sb .
the average calculated moments of the mn@xmath13 , sb , and mn@xmath0 sites in the dft relaxed supercells , along with the corresponding moments of unrelaxed supercells , are shown in figure [ fig : moments]a .
all 10 configurations are shown for each composition , but there is no relation between configurations of the same number for different compositions .
it is immediately apparent that the moments on mn@xmath13 and sb are insensitive and effectively invariant with respect to the different compositions , the different configurations , and also to structural relaxation . for the mn@xmath13 and sb sites , the standard deviations of the average moments are much smaller than the symbols .
the average moment on mn@xmath0 , however , is consistently of smaller magnitude in unrelaxed configurations than the average mn@xmath0 moment in relaxed supercells , but it is generally opposite in sign to that of mn@xmath13 .
this is reflected in a smaller net magnetization for relaxed structures ( figure [ fig : average]b ) .
for many of the supercells , including both relaxed and unrelaxed structures , there is considerable variability in the individual moments of mn@xmath0 sites , indicated by the error bars which show the standard deviation of the averages .
the individual moments for each mn@xmath0 site in each configuration are shown in figure sm-4 of the supplemental material .
the configuration coordinates are also supplied therein .
types of variability in the mn@xmath0 moments found in individual configurations include the following : ( a ) sites in relaxed configurations that remain antiparallel but with decreased magnitude of the moment , ( b ) sites in relaxed configurations with appreciable magnitude that display parallel alignment with respect to mn@xmath13 , ( c ) sites in unrelaxed configurations that are antiparallel and of significantly greater magnitude than the average moment , and ( d ) sites in unrelaxed configurations that have sizable moments and parallel alignment with mn@xmath13 . what is surprising about this result is that variability in the mn@xmath0 moments does not necessarily appear to be associated with an energetic penalty .
the energies of the relaxed configurations relative to the lowest energy ( most stable ) relaxed configuration for a given composition are shown in figure [ fig : moments]b ; the same comparison is also shown for unrelaxed configurations ( relative to the most stable unrelaxed configuration ) .
for example , configurations # 9 are ( coincidentally ) the lowest energy structures for both mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath42sb@xmath41 and mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath43sb@xmath41 , including both the unrelaxed and relaxed supercells .
configuration 9 of mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath42sb@xmath41 is seemingly well - behaved , with large antiparallel moments in the relaxed structure , and small antiparallel moments in the unrelaxed structure . in configuration 9 for mn@xmath41(mn@xmath0)@xmath43sb@xmath41 ,
on the other hand , one of the mn@xmath0 sites in the relaxed structure has a significantly smaller ( still antiparallel ) moment , and two of the sites in the unrelaxed structure have notably larger moments than the average .
similarly , there are other configurations for each composition that contain substantial variability in the individual mn@xmath0 moments but are lower energy structures than configurations with far less variability . in the case of the relaxed supercells ,
decreased moments are associated with shorter mn@xmath0mn@xmath13 and mn@xmath0sb distances ( figure sm-5 ) .
this is consistent with the general observation that the mn@xmath0 moments are smaller in unrelaxed supercells .
it does not explain why some of the individual moments are large in the unrelaxed structures ; however , it is conceivable that the observed variations result from the imposed periodicities . nevertheless , the general trends in the mn@xmath13 , sb , and mn@xmath0 moments should not be affected significantly .
we now return to the question of the diffuse magnetic scattering observed at the nominally systematically absent ( 001 ) position in the recent report by taylor and co - workers ( reference ) .
the signal was observed at the lowest energies accessible in the inelastic experiment ( @xmath85mev ) , but the presence or absence of an associated elastic diffuse signal could not be determined.@xcite as noted by the authors , the observation of scattering intensity at this location
regardless of whether it is elastic or inelastic implies symmetry breaking between the upper and lower portions of the unit cell along the @xmath9 axis .
such breaking could be induced if some mn@xmath13 are antiferromagnetically aligned along @xmath9 ( which would double the magnetic unit cell ) , but both our work and theirs indicates that this is highly improbable .
an alternative situation that would break the symmetry is the local population of mn@xmath0 in only one of the two interstitial voids of a unit cell , which removes the @xmath86 reflection condition .
this latter possibility , where interstitial atoms do not necessarily occur in pairs in a given unit cell , was introduced earlier in the discussion of rietveld refinements ( section iii a ) .
sb samples ( @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and @xmath6 ) ; container scattering has been subtracted from the data , which was collected at @xmath89@xmath90kev at a sample - to - detector distance of @xmath89@xmath91 cm .
( b ) simulated diffraction patterns of mn@xmath47sb structures built from an infinite number of infinitely - wide discrete layers .
when layers with a singly occupied mn@xmath0 site per unit cell are preferentially stacked adjacent to layers with mn@xmath0 in the same site , the correlated disorder gives rise to a diffuse feature that is consistent with the experimentally observed scattering in regards to both position ( in @xmath18 ) and relative intensity .
cartoon models of the different structures giving rise to the simulated scattering are shown as four layer fragments ; mn@xmath13 ( pink ) , sb ( gray ) , mn@xmath0 ( blue ) . , width=316 ] close examination of our x - ray scattering data reveals a weak diffuse component on top of the systematically absent ( 001 ) reflection that is suggestive of correlated structural disorder . in figure
[ fig : diffuse]a we present the low-@xmath18 region of x - ray diffraction patterns for three mn@xmath1sb samples ( @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and @xmath6 ) , from which the container scattering has been subtracted .
scattering intensities have been normalized to the most intense peak in the x - ray diffraction pattern of mn@xmath1sb [ _ i.e. _ the ( 101 ) reflection ] .
the intensity of the diffuse signal increases with @xmath50 , and the maxima of the diffuse features are all observed at lower @xmath18 ( larger @xmath15-spacing ) than the center of the ( 001 ) reflection on the basis of the @xmath9 lattice constant . a shift of diffuse scattering maxima away from the associated bragg positions
is commonly observed in situations of local structural dilation or contraction.@xcite a series of simulations are presented in figure [ fig : diffuse]b that offer support to the hypothesis that the diffuse signal at low @xmath18 arises from correlated structural disorder associated with `` unpaired '' mn@xmath0 , that is , occupation of just one of the interstitial sites in a unit cell .
diffraction patterns were generated with the diffax software@xcite which explicitly computes the incoherent intensity contribution to a given @xmath92 reflection for structures comprising random and correlated stacking variations of discrete layers .
all simulations were conducted on the basis of the mn@xmath47sb stoichiometry and cell dimensions . as a control diffax simulation ,
a single - layer mn@xmath1sb model containing partially occupied mn@xmath0 in both of the interstitial sites was considered .
this model is designated `` all mn@xmath0 paired '' in figure [ fig : diffuse]b , and it results in no noticeable scattering intensity at the ( 001 ) position .
models containing unpaired mn@xmath0 were constructed with three distinct layer types : ( 1 ) a layer without any interstitial atoms , ( 2 ) a layer with a fully occupied interstitial atom in the lower interstitial void , and ( 3 ) a layer with a fully occupied interstitial atom in the upper interstitial void .
two types of disorder were modeled for structures incorporating layers with singly occupied interstitial voids , namely random disorder and correlated disorder , as labeled in figure [ fig : diffuse ] . for the model containing layers with unpaired mn@xmath0 stacked in a completely random assortment ,
no resolved diffuse intensity is generated at the ( 001 ) reflection .
the rise in intensity at low @xmath18 is the result of the diffuse scattering from completely incoherent contributions , which emanate from ( 000 ) . on the other hand , for an unpaired mn@xmath0 model
in which there is preferential stacking of the layers correlated disorder a well resolved diffuse signal near the ( 001 ) is generated .
more specifically , the preferential stacking modeled here corresponds to an increased probability that a layer containing a single mn@xmath0 in one of the interstitial voids will neighbor layers that also contain mn@xmath0 in the same site .
although this simulation represents a rather coarse example of one type of correlated disorder that could be present in mn@xmath1sb , it offers strong support for the presence of some degree of clustering associated with the interstitial atoms . as noted for the experimentally observed diffuse signal , the maximum of the diffuse component in the simulated pattern is also shifted to lower @xmath18 than the center of the ( 001 ) reflection .
a single - crystal x - ray diffuse scattering study would be better suited to elucidating the origin of this observation .
while these observations and simulations soundly establish the existence of short - range structural order , the specific nature of clustering in mn@xmath1sb remains an open question .
consideration of the many plausible local arrangements is beyond the scope of the present work ; it is easily conceivable that a variety of short range - ordered motifs coexist .
it is important to stress that although the presence of some unpaired mn@xmath0 is a requisite for generating nuclear scattering intensity near the ( 001 ) reflection , this does not imply the absence of local regions with pairs of interstitials .
indeed , this type of diversity is represented in the dft supercells .
a comparison of the relative supercell stabilities does not suggest an obvious penalty for interstitial proximity ( pairing ) , but because of their relatively small sizes and construction by stochastic population of the interstitial sites it would be conjecture to suggest an energetic preference for any particular type of clustering . in summary ,
the observation of a diffuse signal consistent with the symmetry - forbidden ( 001 ) reflection suggests that the diffuse magnetic component observed by taylor _
et al . _
by inelastic neutron scattering is rooted in short - range structural order .
this explanation is further supported by our density functional studies , which challenge previous notions@xcite that mn@xmath0 induces a significant reduction in neighboring mn@xmath13 moments .
analysis of x - ray total scattering data collected on polycrystalline powders of mn@xmath1sb ( @xmath2 ) reveals signatures of structural relaxation associated with the accommodation of interstitial atoms .
in particular , the trigonal bipyramidal site of mn@xmath0 is better described by longer equatorial mn@xmath0sb distances than reflected by the crystallographic unit cell .
density functional relaxation of large supercells for compositions close to @xmath4 , @xmath93 , and @xmath6 , provides excellent structural descriptions of the short - range disorder induced by mn@xmath0 , evidenced by improved fits to the experimental pdfs .
relaxation has a pronounced effect on the calculated moment of mn@xmath0 , which aligns antiparallel to mn@xmath13 , but our results suggest that mn@xmath0 has effectively no influence on the moments of mn@xmath13 in proximity to interstitials .
the observation of a diffuse signal near the ( 001 ) reflection position , which is systematically absent when mn@xmath0 is distributed completely randomly , indicates that some degree of _ correlated _ disorder exists in mn@xmath1sb .
we gratefully acknowledge dr .
kate a. ross for useful discussions , dr . olaf j. borkiewicz for assistance collecting total scattering data , and the instrument scientists at 11-bm for powder diffraction data acquisition .
use of the advanced photon source at argonne national laboratory was supported by the u. s. department of energy , office of science , office of basic energy sciences , under contract no .
de - ac02 - 06ch11357 .
this research utilized the csu istec cray hpc system supported by nsf grant cns-0923386 .
55ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrev.99.446 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1063/1.4867223 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1063/1.1722603 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1063/1.1656875 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1063/1.1661609 } [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase { 10.1063/1.1419048 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1063/1.2884524 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1016/0022 - 3697(68)90080 - 2 } [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ , edited by , , and ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase { 10.1143/jpsj.25.120 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrev.129.2008 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1143/jpsj.41.703 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1143/jpsj.48.435 } [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase { 10.1016/0022 - 3697(83)90054 - 9 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1016/0304 - 8853(80)91139 - 7 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrevb.54.11940 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrevb.31.1980 } [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase { 10.1021/ja304712v } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1039/c3cp53642d } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1038/nature01115 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrevb.70.220101 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrevb.69.144118 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrevb.83.094122 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1021/cm062500i } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1021/cm0709673 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1039/b922993k } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1021/jp911108d } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1021/cm401466r } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1063/1.1682673 } [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrevb.42.9622 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrevb.90.024105 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1107/s0909049508018438 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1063/1.2969260 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1107/s0021889809035717 } [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase { 10.1107/s0021889807007856 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1107/s0021889813005190 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1088/0953 - 8984/19/33/335219 } [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase { 10.1088/0953 - 8984/19/33/335218 } [ * * ( ) , 10.1088/0953 - 8984/19/33/335218 ] link:\doibase { 10.1098/rspa.1991.0062 } [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase { 10.1103/physrevb.59.1758 } [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.84.134105 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.124.41 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) | we report x - ray total scattering and pair distribution function ( pdf ) studies of the structural relaxation around interstitial manganese ( mn@xmath0 ) in ferromagnetic mn@xmath1sb ( @xmath2 ) alloys , guided by density functional theory ( dft ) .
refinements to the experimental pdf using a crystallographically constrained structural model indicate an expansion in the equatorial plane of the mn@xmath0sb@xmath3 trigonal bipyramidal site , which introduces significant positional disorder in addition to the nominally - random occupation of interstitial voids .
observation of a weak diffuse signal near the symmetry - forbidden ( 001 ) reflection position is indicative of correlated disorder from the clustering of mn@xmath0 .
density functional relaxation of supercells approximating the @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 compositions provides improved models that accurately describe the short - range structural distortions captured in the pdfs .
such structural relaxation increases the dft calculated moment on mn@xmath0 , which aligns antiparallel to the primary mn moments , but leads to insubstantial changes in the average mn and sb moments and moments of mn and sb proximal to interstitials , thus providing a more accurate description of the observed bulk magnetic properties . |
resummation is often required in a perturbation theory to avoid infrared ( ir ) divergences to appear at finite energy scales .
examples are 1pi diagram resummation ( schwinger - dyson equation ) to cure the on - shell singularity of the propagator , or daisy resummation @xcite to resum ir divergences of massless theories at finite temperature .
we need leading ( or higher order ) logarithmic resummation near a second order phase transition point @xcite , and the htl resummation @xcite to be able to consistently define finite temperature observables in gauge theories .
resummation means reorganization of the perturbative series in a way that the diagrams that are most important from the point of view of ir behavior , are taken into account first .
however , ir importance does not necessarily means uv importance as well , and so it can happen that those ( counterterm ) diagrams that are needed to make the theory finite , are shifted to a later stage in the resummation process .
then we observe that lower order results are divergent meaning that the resummed perturbation theory is _
inconsistent_. exceptions are the 1pi and leading log resummations , where , by chance , diagrams of ir and uv importance are the same , but other cases ( daisy , super - daisy , htl etc . resummations ) suffer from this difficulty .
therefore , in these cases , the physically well - motivated resummation equations ( gap equations ) are meaningless in principle , and one usually makes some ad hoc assumption to obtain finite results .
recently several papers were published that investigate this problem in various physical situations @xcite . in the present paper we try to go around the question of how to construct countertem diagrams for a given _ momentum independent _ resummation .
we try to give two points of view on the problem : one is a direct method where we make explicit resummation for the counterterm diagrams , induced by the resummation of the `` normal '' diagrams ( section [ sec : massresum ] ) .
the relevant counterterm diagrams can be constructed in each perturbative order , and finally we give an explicit form for the resummed lagrangian . to be more specific , we suggest , in @xmath0 theory , the following reorganization of the mass terms in the lagrangian in @xmath1 scheme to regularize the mass resummation : @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the multiplicative mass renormalization factor in @xmath1 scheme , and @xmath4 .
this proposal is a generalization of the method of banerjee and mallik @xcite . at one hand
this expression is equivalent with @xmath5 , so non - perturbatively we have the same physics .
on the other hand we will prove that , if we take into account the under - braced terms first in one , and two loop levels , respectively , we obtain a mass resummed perturbation theory that consistently removes all the divergencies at any order .
one of the most important corollary of these investigations is the following rule of thumb : we can renormalize the gap equations for mass resummation by _ first renormalizing the diagrams _ in an appropriate mass independent physical scheme ( eg .
@xmath1 ) , and _ afterwards substituting the resummed parameters _ in the finite expressions . as it will be seen later on ,
although this is not the most generic renormalization method , still it is a possible and consistent way to deal with uv divergences .
this strategy was already used in ref .
@xcite , in the study of phase diagram of the quark - meson model .
the other point of view treats resummed perturbation theory as a different renormalization scheme ( section [ sec : rg ] ) .
we call this scheme , in which we impose environment ( @xmath6 or even time ) dependent renormalization conditions as _ resummation ( rs ) scheme_. this is not a physical choice , since changing the environment results in changing of the renormalization scheme . in order to have a meaningful result we have to relate the rs scheme and a bona fide renormalization scheme , eg
. @xmath1 .
this means constructing relations between the parameters of the renormalized lagrangians of the two schemes which formally appear as _
gap equations_. in several applications we need the inverse procedure : one has a physically motivated gap equation , and one would like to know the corresponding structure of counterterms . in this approach
we consider the gap equations as relations between the @xmath1 and some rs scheme . expanding the gap equation in terms of the coupling constant we can read off the finite difference that has to be added to the @xmath1 counterterm to obtain the rs scheme counterterm .
thus the rs scheme is defined , and so we can use perturbation theory to calculate any observables we need . if the choice of the gap equations was good enough , we will observe cancellations between the `` normal '' and counterterm diagrams .
the diagrams that survive cancellation are not part of the resummation , and they can be used eventually to improve the resummation process .
the paper ends with conclusions and an outlook ( section [ sec : conclusion ] ) .
our basic model is the @xmath0 model where the lagrangian reads in terms of renormalized couplings and fields as @xmath7 as it is well known @xcite , in this model perturbation theory becomes unreliable at high temperatures , because of the presence of diagrams giving @xmath8 contribution .
this ( ir ) problem can be cured by summing all the dominant tadpole contribution of the theory ( `` daisy diagrams '' ) . by this procedure one
effectively replaces the mass @xmath9 by the resummed mass @xmath10 ( where , in this theory , @xmath11 to leading order ) , making the ir problem disappear ( apart from the phase transition point @xcite ) . since the daisy resummation does nothing else than replacing the mass with a different mass , it is equivalent with the `` thermal counterterm '' procedure @xcite .
we add to and subtract from the lagrangian the same , temperature dependent term ; the relevant part of the lagrangian therefore reads @xmath12 as usual , the added term is treated as a part of the free lagrangian while the subtracted term , on the other hand , is taken into account one loop later as a ( thermal ) counterterm . by doing this we reinterpreted the perturbation theory , ie .
we defined a resummation .
the value of @xmath13 can be chosen to be the tadpole value , but its `` best value '' can be found out from the condition that at one loop order the self - energy is zero @xmath14 this is a gap equation @xcite which is to be solved to find @xmath13 .
it turns out , however , that this naive definition is not consistent @xcite because of the mismatch in the counterterm diagrams . to see this we calculate the one loop self energy in the @xmath0 theory @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the bosonic tadpole function ; in dimensional regularization it reads : @xmath17 + \frac1{2\pi^2}\int\limits_m^\infty\ !
d\omega\,\sqrt{\omega^2-m^2}\,n(\omega),\ ] ] where @xmath18 is the bose - einstein distribution . we should write @xmath16 with argument @xmath19 , and that is what creates problem here . we , namely , already renormalized the theory at zero temperature , say , in @xmath1 scheme .
that fixes the one - loop mass counterterm as @xmath20.\ ] ] so we have a divergency @xmath21 and a counterterm @xmath22 , that do not cancel each other .
there is an unbalanced divergency , and so the rs scheme is inconsistent .
since at the non - perturbative level ( infinite order ) the resummed theory is equivalent with the original one ( they have the same lagrangian ) , we expect that this divergence vanishes by higher loop effects .
it has been shown @xcite that in the next order ( two loop in case of mass ) we indeed obtain contributions that cancel this divergence however , other new unbalanced divergences appear in this order .
so finally the perturbation theory will not be consistent at any finite loop level . in order to make the theory consistent ,
we should find some method to shift up to one loop level those two - loop diagrams that are necessary to cancel the unbalanced divergences at one loop order : ie .
we have to reorganize ( resum ) the .
the idea is the same as in the case of the thermal mass .
we find the correction to the counterterm , add it to and subtract it from the lagrangian , but classify them to belong to different loop orders .
let us denote the necessary mass term by @xmath23 and call it _ compensating counterterm_. so , instead of ( [ eq : thermmass ] ) , we use the following mass terms in the lagrangian : @xmath24 in perturbation theory the first term is taken into account in the propagator , the second and third are taken into account first at one loop level , while the last term first contributes at two - loop level .
@xmath23 has to be determined order by order in a way that it cancels the remaining divergence of the physical observable at a given order .
although it is temperature dependent and also divergent in the present example , its value is irrelevant from the point of view of the consistency of the complete theory , since the lagrangian is the same as the original one , it does not depend on the value of @xmath25 . using the proposed decomposition of the lagrangian corresponding to ( [ eq : corrthermmass ] )
let us compute the resummed and renormalized self - energy of the @xmath0 model . at one loop level
the self - energy reads with this new counterterm structure as @xmath26 @xmath27 is defined in ( [ msbardeltam2 ] ) ; it cancels a part of the divergence hidden in @xmath16 , the rest has to be canceled by @xmath28 .
we can choose it in analogy with the @xmath1 form ( [ msbardeltam2 ] ) @xmath29.\ ] ] in principle we could add an arbitrary finite term to this form .
this would modify the value of @xmath13 , and finally would lead to a different resummation process . in the language of section
[ sec : rg ] it would correspond to a different renormalization scheme in the zero and finite temperature parts . for further details cf .
section [ sec : rg ] . with this choice , using the form of @xmath16 from ( [ tb ] ) we find @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the @xmath1 renormalized tadpole diagram .
we could obtain this result by first renormalizing the divergent diagrams in @xmath1 scheme , and afterwards by substituting the resummed mass into the finite expression .
now let us turn to the determination of the self - energy at two loop level .
the contribution from two - loop level diagrams is represented symbolically in the following way : @xmath32{setsun.eps } } + \frac{\lambda^2}4\ ; \raisebox{-0.25cm}{\includegraphics[height=1.6cm]{doublescoop.eps } } + \frac{\delta\lambda_1}2 \;\raisebox{-0.25cm}{\includegraphics[height=0.8cm]{tadpole.eps } } + \frac\lambda2 \;\raisebox{-0.25cm}{\includegraphics[height=0.85cm]{fish.eps } } -\delta m_{t1}^2 + \delta m_2 ^ 2 + \delta m_{t2}^2 - \delta z_2 p^2.\ ] ] the propagators have the squared mass @xmath33 , in this resummed theory .
the value of the diagrams in dimensional regularization , writing out explicitly only their divergent part , are : @xmath34{tadpole.eps } } = \frac{m_t^2}{16\pi^2}\left(-\frac1{\varepsilon}+\gamma_e-1+\ln\frac{m_t^2 } { 4\pi\mu^2 } \right ) + t_b^{t\neq0},{\nonumber\\ } & & \raisebox{-0.25cm}{\includegraphics[height=0.85cm]{fish.eps } } = ( -\delta m_t^2 + \delta m_1 ^ 2 + \delta m_{t1}^2 ) \left [ \frac1{16\pi^2}\left(-\frac1{\varepsilon}+\gamma_e + \ln\frac{m_t^2 } { 4\pi\mu^2 } \right ) + i_\mathrm{fish}^{t\neq0}\right],{\nonumber\\}&&\raisebox{-0.3cm}{\includegraphics[height=0.8cm]{setsun.eps } } = \frac{3m_t^2}{(4\pi)^4}\left[\frac1{2{\varepsilon}^2}-\frac1{\varepsilon}\left(\gamma_e -\frac32 + \ln\frac{m_t^2}{4\pi\mu^2}\right)\right ] - \frac{p^2}{4(4\pi)^4 } \frac1{\varepsilon}- \frac3{16\pi^2}\,t_b^{t\neq0}\ , \frac1{\varepsilon}\;+\;i_\mathrm{setsun}^{finite}{\nonumber\\ } & & \raisebox{-0.4 cm } { \includegraphics[height=1.6cm]{doublescoop.eps } } = \frac{m_t^2}{(4\pi)^4 } \left[\frac1{{\varepsilon}^2 } -\frac1{\varepsilon}\left(2\gamma_e-1 + 2\ln\frac{m_t^2}{4\pi\mu^2}\right ) \right ] - \frac1{16\pi^2 } \frac1{\varepsilon}\left(t_b^{t\neq0 } + m_t^2 i_\mathrm{fish}^{t\neq0}\right ) \;+\;i_\mathrm{dsc}^{finite}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since we do resummation in the @xmath1 scheme , the value of @xmath35 and @xmath36 counterterms are fixed , we can not modify them .
@xmath37 , where @xmath38 the other counterterms read as @xmath39 using these values the divergent part is still not canceled , what remains is : @xmath40 to cancel this divergency we can choose @xmath41 , although , of course , an arbitrary finite part could be added to this expression .
with this choice , however , we get further support to the practical observation of the one loop calculation : we first do renormalization in @xmath1 scheme , and substitute the resummation mass in the finite expressions . it should be clear , too , that we could add finite terms for @xmath28 and @xmath42 , and then this statement would not be true any more .
thus this is just a comfortable possibility .
one can conjecture that this feature persists at higher loop orders , since in @xmath1 scheme the overall divergency of a diagram always can be written as @xmath43 with some mass - independent @xmath44 factor .
then , by choosing @xmath45 and @xmath46 , the overall divergency disappears .
this should also be true for any other mass - independent schemes .
we can , therefore , put forward a proposition : * proposition : * if in a renormalization scheme the zero temperature counterterm is @xmath47 and @xmath44 is mass - independent , then at finite temperature the theory with thermal counterterm @xmath13 and compensating counterterm @xmath48 yields finite result at each order of the perturbation theory .
_ proof _ : let us consider a 2-point diagram @xmath49 in the original ( not resummed ) theory that has an overall divergence , and all the subdivergences were consistently subtracted .
then , if the theory is renormalizable , the divergence of the diagram should be proportional to @xmath9 ; the proportionality constant can be obtained as @xmath50 .
since the divergence is canceled by the counterterm @xmath47 , the divergent part should be equal to an appropriate part from the mass renormalization factor @xmath44 , which is mass independent @xmath51 in the resummed theory we have two effects .
one is the substitution of the mass term by the resummed mass : @xmath52 .
the divergent parts of the self energy diagrams , in our mass - independent scheme , are proportional to this new mass term .
but we have also prepared the corresponding counterterm , since the third term of ( [ eq : corrthermmass ] ) reads @xmath53 .
so this part of the divergences disappear in the same way as in the unresummed case .
the other effect is the @xmath54 insertion coming from the second ( thermal ) counterterm of ( [ eq : corrthermmass ] ) .
the sum of the single mass insertion diagrams is just @xmath55 , because at each propagator @xmath56 ( it is evident for feynman propagators , at finite temperature it can be seen using imaginary time propagators ) . its divergent part can be written , using ( [ dz ] ) , as @xmath57 .
this is exactly canceled by the corresponding part of the compensating counterterm at this order : @xmath58 .
so at each diagram the overall divergences are canceled by the proposed counterterms .
using bphz argumentation , this is enough to make the complete theory finite .
now we have a consistent method for how to reorganize the perturbation theory according to a given ( mass ) resummation in such a way as to have finite results in all orders in @xmath1 scheme . in order to generalize the result so as to be able to treat other schemes ( not just @xmath1 ) , or environment dependence of other couplings ( cf .
vertex resummation ) , we change our viewpoint , and we rephrase the complete resummation procedure using the renormalization group ( rg ) argumentation : this will be the topic of the present section .
first we demonstrate at one loop level that we can obtain the results of the previous section using a special renormalization scheme .
we define the mass counterterm of the new scheme as @xmath59 where @xmath60 denotes the @xmath1 counterterm and @xmath61 is an arbitrary , finite expression .
the other counterterms are the same as in @xmath1 scheme
. then the one loop self energy reads @xmath62 this expression differs in a finite term from the corresponding @xmath1 expression . at one hand
it assures finiteness , on the other hand this means that the new mass parameter must be different from the @xmath1 mass parameter in order to describe the same physics .
in fact , applying the ideas of the renormalization theory @xcite to the present case , there must be a choice @xmath63 for which we have the same value _ for all observables _ in the two schemes at a given order .
this function can be read off from the requirement that the bare parameters are the same in the two schemes @xcite : @xmath64 then the counterterm of the new scheme ( [ newscheme ] ) can be written as @xmath65 this is the result of the proposition of subsection [ sec : higherloop ] applied to the one loop case . for the definition of the new scheme we need to specify a value for @xmath61 .
we may , for example , choose the mass shell scheme , where the full self - energy reads @xmath66 . from ( [ newschemeselfen ] ) and ( [ matchnewscheme ] ) we find for the value of @xmath61 @xmath67 where @xmath68 now means the tadpole diagram , renormalized in the @xmath69 scheme .
this equation is the renormalized gap equation for the mass .
this analysis suggests that the mass resummation is equivalent with the choice of a new renormalization scheme . using the relation of the masses of the two schemes
, we can compute finite observables that can be interpreted as the result of the resummed @xmath1 scheme .
the mass relation , together with the definition of the new scheme yields finite gap equation for the new ( resummed ) mass , which is the usual gap equation in case of the mass shell scheme .
motivated by the previous subsection , we can start to build up the resummation strategy from the point of view of renormalization schemes .
resummation itself means that some higher order diagrams are taken into account at lower levels with the consequence that these diagrams are missing from the higher order calculation .
so , at least for the mass and coupling constant resummation , resummation is equivalent with a scheme that cancels these diagrams with a proper choice of the finite part of the counterterms .
since we play only with the finite part of the counterterms , we will still have a consistent scheme .
so this new scheme
the _ resummation ( rs ) scheme _ differs from a general scheme ( eg .
@xmath1 ) in that a certain set of diagrams is missing from the calculation .
the rs scheme is a bona fide scheme while we keep the counterterms fixed : for example we can equally well use the ms and the @xmath1 schemes .
however , at finite temperature , the finite parts of the counterterms will depend on temperature , and so the resummation scheme itself varies with temperature . in a more general case rs scheme can depend on the complete environment @xcite : beyond the temperature on chemical potential , background condensates , time , etc . since results in different schemes have different physical interpretation , rs scheme can not directly describe the effects of the environment variation .
example is the mass shell scheme where @xmath70 , and we have no explicit temperature dependence . to be able to draw physical consequences , we have to project the results to a common reference scheme . technically what we should do is to relate the rs scheme to a physical renormalization scheme for concreteness we will use the @xmath1 scheme .
since both of them are mathematically correct schemes , in case of renormalizable theories , this can be accomplished by changing the values of renormalized parameters of the lagrangian @xcite ( including wave function renormalization ) . in @xmath0 theory there
must exist environment - dependent parameters @xmath71 such as for any @xmath72-point function with momenta @xmath73 we have @xmath74 in perturbation theory the equality holds only up to the computed order ; in fact the difference is the effect of resummation .
the value of the `` running '' parameters can be computed using the fact that the bare quantities are independent of the scheme @xcite . in this way we can use the rs scheme for perturbation theory , enjoying its good ir convergence , and still have results in a physical renormalization scheme ( eg .
@xmath1 ) , where also the parameters of the theory can be obtained from the usual renormalization conditions .
sometimes we can explicitly define the new scheme ( eg . the mass shell scheme for mass resummation ) , but more often we just have a guess for the resummed parameters , and we hope that it performs some kind of resummation .
that is we start with explicit functions of the form of ( [ eq : relation ] ) for the resummed mass and coupling constant ( and eventually , wave function renormalization ) .
according to the line of thought above these relations can be interpreted as generators of a rs scheme : we expand them in power series in @xmath75 @xmath76 and we interpret @xmath77 as the @xmath72th order finite mass counterterm that has to be added to the @xmath1 counterterm ; similarly , @xmath78 is the finite coupling constant counterterm , @xmath79 is the finite wave function renormalization counterterm .
having defined the counterterms , the rs scheme is appropriate to do perturbation theory , and the results can be related to the @xmath1 scheme by the same relations ( [ eq : relation ] ) . if our guess was good enough we will observe cancellation between `` normal '' and counterterm diagrams at higher orders .
the main message , however , is that , independently of whether a choice represents a physically meaningful resummation or not , _ any choice _ leads to a finite , consistent perturbation theory .
so as a possible strategy for resummation , we can do the following : we perform regularized perturbation theory in a generic scheme , keeping counterterms free , at a certain loop order .
the divergent part of the counterterms are then fixed , as usual , to cancel the uv divergences of the diagrams , while the finite parts are fixed to cancel the ir dangerous parts .
so we defined a scheme , which is , however , only a rs scheme , since the counterterms can depend on the environment .
we determine its relation to the @xmath1 scheme of the form ( [ eq : relation ] ) by requiring that the bare parameters should be the same in the two schemes .
this relation , by construction , corresponds to a resummation up to this perturbative order , and we should have some plausible guess to choose the higher order terms , hoping that it still performs some kind of resummation .
different choices , of course , correspond to different resummations .
this procedure can be repeated at each perturbative order , and so the resummation process can be improved .
using the ideas of the previous subsection , in this section we perform both mass and coupling constant resummation .
this latter is important to describe the `` softening '' of the theory close to a phase transition point @xcite , and also to consistently describe vertex resummation @xcite . at one loop level we can start from the effective potential @xmath80 where @xmath81 .
the effective , background dependent mass and coupling constant then reads @xmath82 a possible way of doing coupling constant resummation that we make vanish all of the terms below @xmath83 .
that means : @xmath84 for the mass resummation we demand that @xmath85 ; with the @xmath86 value defined above we obtain @xmath87 this counterterm depends on the background only at @xmath88 order .
if @xmath89 depends on the environment , these two counterterms define an environment dependent rs scheme .
if we denote by @xmath90 and @xmath91 the divergent parts according to the @xmath1 scheme , and by @xmath92 and @xmath93 the finite parts scheme @xmath94 and so @xmath95 , then we can write @xmath96 using the renormalization scheme independence of the bare parameters we can relate the resummed and the @xmath1 parameters at one loop level as @xmath97 these equations determine the relation between the parameters of the rs scheme and of the @xmath1 scheme ; but it can also be interpreted as the formulae for how to resum diagrams in the @xmath1 scheme .
in fact , by the renormalization prescriptions of the rs scheme , @xmath98 is the complete static 4-point function and @xmath9 is the complete mass . the gap equations ( [ gapeq ] ) are derived at one loop level , and are not necessarily useful at higher orders , that is it does not necessarily resum any subset of diagrams .
there are arguments , however , that help to guess the correct form . to achieve super - daisy resummation , for example
, we should use the resummed mass in the one loop expressions : that suggest that we should always use @xmath9 in the right hand side of ( [ gapeq ] ) and @xmath98 if it is multiplied with @xmath99 .
then all the possible mass resummations are done , so we should use @xmath75 for any other appearance of the coupling constant in the expression of the mass resummation . for the explicit coupling constants in the @xmath98 resummation we recall that the double scoop ( two bubbles ) diagram contributes @xmath100 , but
if we iterate the expression for @xmath98 as a function of @xmath75 in ( [ gapeq ] ) , we would get @xmath101 . to cure this problem we should write @xmath102 instead of @xmath103 .
so , finally , the proposed form for the resummation reads @xmath104 and @xmath81 , in agreement with 4pi suggestions @xcite . from ( [ newschemeselfen ] ) and ( [ eq : v ] )
we find @xmath105 , and so we can write @xmath106 it is instructive to examine these expressions for small masses .
since the result of the finite temperature part has @xmath107 as the only dimensionless quantity , this is equivalent to the high temperature approximation @xcite @xmath108 where @xmath109 . then , using the notation @xmath110 , we have @xmath111 then the gap equations read @xmath112 the second term of the rhs of ( [ eq : second ] ) depends on @xmath113 at @xmath88 order , thus it is consistent to omit its background dependence .
the last term is the consequence of the choice of the @xmath1 counterterms .
so we have @xmath114 the solution therefore reads @xmath115 where @xmath116,\qquad w=\frac{\lambda_{{\ensuremath{\overline{\mathrm{ms}}}}}t}{16\pi\kappa},\qquad \kappa = 1 - \frac{\lambda_{{\ensuremath{\overline{\mathrm{ms}}}}}}{32\pi^2}\ln\frac{t^2}{\tilde\mu^2}.\ ] ] the solution has some remarkable properties .
first of all it is a completely finite result , we do not need to bother with renormalization any more . secondly
although coming from a high temperature expansion it nicely extrapolates between the 4d and 3d fixed points of the system . for high scales , namely , ( [ resumresult ] ) can be approximated as ( we set @xmath117 ) @xmath118 the formula for @xmath98 is the result of the non - perturbative renormalization method of @xcite , where it was computed by the explicit summation of bubble diagrams .
we can realize here the running coupling and mass in the @xmath1 scheme , and write @xmath119 where @xmath120 .
this corresponds to a 4d behavior in the @xmath1 scheme . at high temperatures the @xmath121 term takes over in the coupling constant , and
the system follows a different trajectory .
while the mass runs in the same way as before , @xmath122 this resummation describes correctly the second order nature of the phase transition ( as opposed to the daisy resummation ) . denoting @xmath123
, we find @xmath124 for @xmath125 . near the critical point the solution behaves as @xmath126 the critical exponent for the mass is @xmath127 in this case , the fixed point of the coupling constant is @xmath128 ( ie .
it becomes gaussian ) , and the temperature dependence for the approach of this critical point is @xmath129 , where @xmath130 .
this is exactly the behavior of the @xmath131 model at @xmath132 @xcite .
indeed , in this simple approximation we resummed leading order diagrams in the large @xmath133 expansion , thus this agreement is not unexpected @xcite .
in this paper we investigated the question of to what extent the uv and ir regularization of a system , ie .
renormalization and resummation can be reconciled .
we described two methods : one is a constructive method of how to resum higher order counterterm diagrams in order to cure the uv divergences appearing in mass resummation in @xmath1 scheme . similarly to the thermal mass counterterm idea we introduced a `` compensating counterterm '' that has to be added to and subtracted from the original lagrangian , the two terms contributing at different loop order .
the other method is a rephrasing of this idea in the language of the renormalization group .
here we defined a new scheme , the resummation ( rs ) scheme , where the infinite part of the counterterms cancels the uv divergences , the finite part cancels the ir divergences of the theory at a given order .
the drawback of this scheme is that it depends explicitly on the environment , but , with help of the renormalization group , we can project the results of the resummation scheme to a reference scheme , eg .
@xmath1 . from the point of view of the resummation , this projection formally appears as a set of gap equations .
we demonstrated these ideas by performing coupling constant and mass resummation in the @xmath0 model . in practice usually
the problem of resummation and renormalization comes up in two forms .
the first arises when we work on a diagrammatic basis and we compute a gap equation . at first glance the divergences of the resummed diagrams and counterterms
do not cancel each other , so we wonder whether there is a method to consistently renormalize the divergent gap equations .
we give positive answer to this question , proposing to use the compensating counterterm , or renormalization group ideas described in the paper . as a rule of thumb we can use that prescription that , for mass resummation in mass independent scheme , we first renormalize the equation perturbatively , and we apply this finite expression to compute the resummed parameters .
the other type of problem is when we modify our finite gap equation in a well motivated way , hoping that it catches important higher order effects , and we wonder whether the new form is compatible with renormalization .
the answer is again positive : any form of the gap equation is compatible with renormalization .
technically we should treat our gap equations as transformation equations from @xmath1 scheme to a specific rs scheme .
expansion of the solution of gap equations in terms of the coupling constants yields the finite difference of the counterterms in the two schemes at a given order . with the so - defined rs scheme we can do perturbation theory , that gives the possibility to systematically improve the resummation . in the paper we treated only resummations of the parameters of the lagrangian .
as a future prospect we should investigate momentum dependent resummations , too . to extend our ideas we should reinterpret the renormalizable theories , allowing momentum dependence of the parameters .
the authors would like to thank andrs patks and jnos polonyi for useful discussions .
we acknowledge support from hungarian research fund ( otka ) under contract numbers f043465 , t034980 and t037689 .
l. dolan and r. jackiw , phys.rev .
d 9 ( 1974 ) 3320 .
m. dattanasio and m. pietroni , nucl.phys .
b472 ( 1996 ) 711 ; d. boyanovsky , h.j .
de vega and m. simionato , phys.rev .
d63 ( 2001 ) 045007 e. braaten and r. pisarski , nucl.phys .
b 337 ( 1990 ) 569 . ; b 339 ( 1990 ) 662 . j .-
blaizot , e. iancu and u. reinosa , nucl.phys .
a 736 ( 2004 ) 149 ; phys.lett .
b 568 ( 2003 ) 016003 ; h. van hees and j. knoll , phys.rev .
d 66 ( 2002 ) 025028 ; h.c .
de godoy caldas , phys.rev .
d 65 ( 2002 ) 065005 . n. banerjee and s. mallik , phys . rev . *
d * 43 ( 1991 ) 3368 .
a. jakovc , a. patks , zs .
szp and p. szpfalusy , phys .
b 582 ( 2004 ) 179 .
j. frenkel , a. saa and j. taylor , phys.rev .
d 46 ( 1992 ) 3670 ; r. parwani , phys.rev .
d 45 ( 1994 ) 4965 . s. chiku and t. hatsuda , phys .
d58 , ( 1998 ) 076001 ; j.o .
andersen and m. strickland , phys.rev .
d 64 ( 2001 ) 105012 . w. buchmller , z. fodor , t. helbig and d. walliser , annals phys . 234 ( 1994 ) 260 .
f. karsch , a. patks , p. petreczky , phys.lett .
b401 , 69 - 73 , 1997 j. collins , _ renormalization _ ( cambridge university press , 1984 . ) d. oconnor and c.r .
stephens , int.j.mod.phys .
a9 ( 1994 ) 2805 ; erratum - ibid .
a9 ( 1994 ) 5851 .
w. buchmller and o. philipsen , nucl.phys .
b443 ( 1995 ) 47 .
m.e carrington , hep - ph/0401123 ; j. bergess , hep - ph/0401172 .
a. patks , zs .
szp , p. szpfalusy , phys.lett .
b 537 ( 2002 ) 77 s .- k .
ma , _ phase transitions and critical phenomena _ ( academic press , london , 1976 , edited by c. domb and m.s . | resummation , ie .
reorganization of perturbative series , can result in an inconsistent perturbation theory , unless the counterterms are reorganized in an appropriate way . in this paper
two methods are presented for resummation of counterterms : one is a direct method where the necessary counterterms are constructed order by order ; the other is a general one , based on renormalization group arguments .
we demonstrate at one hand that , in mass independent schemes , mass resummation can be performed by gap equations renormalized _ prior to _ the substitution of the resummed mass for its argument .
on the other hand it is shown that any ( momentum - independent ) form of mass and coupling constant resummation is compatible with renormalization , and one can explicitly construct the corresponding counterterms . |
two decades ago , @xcite detected an infrared excess around the da white dwarf g2938 as part of their search for cool companions to white dwarfs . @xcite and @xcite convincingly ruled out the presence of a low - mass stellar companion , and @xcite suggested that the observed infrared excess is caused by a ring of circumstellar dust around the white dwarf , a model further developed by @xcite , and underpinned by spitzer observations @xcite .
another four single white dwarfs with infrared excesses have since then been discovered ( gd362 , @xcite ; gd56 , @xcite ; wd1150 - 153 , @xcite ; wd2115560 , von hippel et al .
2007 ) , plus one additional candidate ( g1678 , @xcite ) .
two common characteristic of all those white dwarfs with circumstellar dust discs are their low temperatures , @xmath2k , and their substantial abundances of photospheric calcium @xcite .
no evidence for the presence of dusty discs has been found around white dwarfs hotter than @xmath3k @xcite .
recently , @xcite detected emission lines of caii@xmath08498,8542,8662 in the da white dwarf sdssj122859.93 + 104032.9 , which has a temperature of 22000k , much hotter than the five white dwarfs exhibiting infrared excess .
the double - peaked shape of the caii emission lines unambiguously identifies the presence of a rotating ring of gas around sdss1228 + 1040 .
time - resolved spectroscopic and photometric follow - up observations of sdss1228 + 1040 ruled out the possibility of it being a close binary system where an accretion disc would form from material lost by the companion star .
the detection of a strong mgii@xmath14481 absorption line identifies sdss1228 + 1040 as a daz white dwarf , and indicates a photospheric magnesium abundance close to the solar value .
given that the gravitational sedimentation time scales in the radiative atmosphere are very short @xcite and radiative levitation is negligible @xcite , it is clear that sdss1228 + 1040 is accreting from the circumstellar gas disc .
the absence of hydrogen or helium emission lines from the ring , along with the absence of helium absorption lines from the photosphere of the white dwarf , indicates that the circumstellar disc must be depleted in volatile elements , and @xcite concluded that the most likely origin of this disc is a tidally disrupted asteroid .
sdss1228 + 1040 with its circumstellar gas disc appears hence as the hot counterpart to g2938 and the other cool daz harbouring dust discs .
@xcite identified sdssj104341.53 + 085558.2 ( henceforth sdss1043 + 0855 ) as a good candidate for being the second white dwarf with a circumstellar gaseous metal disc .
we present here follow - up observations that confirm this suggestion .
intermediate resolution spectroscopy of sdss1043 + 0855 was obtained at the william herschel telescope ( wht ) in service mode on 2007 , february 3 , using the double - arm spectrograph isis .
the blue arm was equipped with the r1200b grating and a 4k@xmath42k pixel eev detector , providing a spectral coverage of @xmath5 at a resolution ( fwhm ) of @xmath6 . in the red arm ,
the r600r grating was used along with the low - fringing 4k@xmath42k pixel redplus detector , providing a spectral coverage of @xmath7 at a resolution of @xmath8 .
a total of 4 pairs of blue / red spectra with individual exposure times of 20min were obtained under poor seeing ( @xmath9 ) conditions . in june 2006
, we also obtained wht spectroscopy of gd362 , which is one of the cool ( @xmath10k , @xcite ) daz white dwarfs exhibiting infrared excess @xcite , and the hotter daz wd1337 + 705 ( grw+70 5824 ) , with an identical setup , except for using the 4.5k@xmath42k pixel marconi detector in the red arm , which is subject to noticeable fringing in the red end of the spectrum .
all data were reduced in a standard way using ` starlink ` software and the ` pamela / molly ` packages . as anticipated from its sdss spectrum , sdss1043 + 0855 displays double - peaked caii@xmath08498,8542,8662 lines ( fig.[f - caii ] , right panel ) , though at substantially lower strengths compared to sdss1228 + 1040 .
the relatively low quality of the @xmath11-band spectra prevents a dynamical analysis of the disc emission , but the morphology of the line profiles in sdss1043 + 0855 is fairly similar to those observed in sdss1228 + 1040 @xcite , suggesting broadly similar parameters .
no significant trace of caii emission is found in wd1337 + 705 , within the limitations imposed by the ccd fringing .
the red spectrum of gd362 contains caii in absorption from the white dwarf photosphere .
the spectra from the blue arm reveal the presence of photospheric mgii@xmath14481 absorption in sdss1043 + 0855 and wd1337 + 705 ( fig.[f - caii ] , left panel ) .
gd362 is too cold @xcite to exhibit significant mgii@xmath14481 absorption .
the absence of zeeman splitting in the ca triplet limits the magnetic field strength in gd362 to @xmath12 kg ( see @xcite for the weakly magnetic dz g1657 ) .
we have used a grid of model spectra calculated with tlusty / synspec @xcite to analyse the sdss and wht spectra of sdss1043 + 0855 .
the model atmospheres were computed assuming a pure hydrogen composition and local thermodynamic equilibrium ( lte ) , and sequences of synthetic spectra were subsequently calculated for a variety of mg abundances . in order to determine the temperature and surface gravity of the white dwarf , we fitted both the entire spectrum , as well as the normalised h@xmath13 to h@xmath14 lines .
the balmer lines reach their maximum equivalent widths around @xmath15k for @xmath16 , or @xmath17k higher ( lower ) for @xmath18 @xmath19 , and consequently a fit to the normalised balmer line profiles results usually in a `` hot '' and a `` cold '' solution of comparable quality .
we use the fit to the entire data , continuum plus lines , to choose the solution which better agrees with the slope of the spectrum .
our fit includes h@xmath13h@xmath14 .
the higher balmer lines , even though more sensitive to the surface gravity ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , are of too poor a quality in the sdss data to be useful . the best - fit @xmath20 and @xmath21 and their 1-@xmath22 errors are obtained from a bicubic spline interpolation to the @xmath23 values on the @xmath24 grid covered by our model spectra .
the parameters from the best fit to the normalised line profiles are @xmath25k and @xmath26 ( fig.[f - opt_fit ] ) . using an updated version of the evolutionary sequences in @xcite , a white dwarf mass of @xmath27 ,
a radius of @xmath28 cm as well as a cooling age of @xmath29y are derived .
the flux scaling factor between the observed and model fluxes implies a distance of @xmath30pc . while we find good agreement with the surface gravity determined by @xcite with their ` autofit ` procedure , @xmath31 .
our effective temperature is hotter by @xmath32k compared to their value of @xmath33 , suggesting that differing details in the fitting procedure cause systematic uncertainties that can be somewhat larger than the statistical errors .
we have determined the photospheric mg abundances of sdss1043 + 0855 and wd1337 + 305 by fitting tlusty / synspec models with the best - fit @xmath20 and @xmath21 but variable mg abundances to the normalised mgii@xmath14481 line profile observed in the wht spectra .
the widths of the observed mgii lines are consistent in both cases with very low rotational velocities , @xmath34 .
we find for sdss1043 + 0855 a mg abundances of @xmath35 times the solar value , or @xmath36 . for wd1337 + 705 , our fit results in a mg abundance of @xmath37 times the solar value , or @xmath38 , which is in good agreement with the measurement of @xcite .
both our and zuckerman s mg abundance measurements are somewhat lower than that of @xcite , @xmath39 , which was determined from a rather noisy spectrum .
we have measured the equivalent widths of the combined caii triplet in out wht spectra of sdss1043 + 0855 , sdss1228 + 1040 ( from @xcite ) , and wd1337 + 705 . for wd1337 + 705 ,
the wht spectrum is consistent with no caii emission at all ( table[t - abundances ] ) .
figure[f - mgline ] shows the correlation between the photospheric mg abundances in sdss1043 + 0855 , sdss1228 + 1040 , and wd1337 + 705 and the equivalent widths of the caii triplet .
.[t - abundances ] photospheric mg abundances and the combined equivalent width of the caii@xmath08498,8542,8662 triplet in sdss1043 + 0855 , wd1337 + 705 , and sdss1228 + 1040 .
[ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] @xmath40 too cold for sublimating circumstellar material at the tidal destruction radius of the white dwarf ( e.g. * ? ? ?
@xmath41 more than one sdss spectrum available , excess clearly visible only in one of them .
@xmath42 this paper .
@xmath43 the white dwarf parameter differ very slightly with respect to those in @xcite due to improvments in our fitting procedure .
the discovery of gaseous discs around the two moderately hot white dwarfs sdss1228 + 1040 and sdss1043 + 0855 and dust discs around white dwarfs with @xmath44k indicates that the white dwarf temperature plays a crucial role in determing the phase state of circumstellar debris discs .
von hippel et al .
( @xcite ) explored the range of white dwarf effective temperatures for which the sublimation radius is inside of the roche radius for tidal disruption , and found good agreement with the observational evidence .
the origin of metals in the photospheres of white dwarfs has been intensively debated ( see @xcite ) . a purely interstellar origin ,
as e.g. worked out in detail by @xcite , appears less likely in the view of the observations collected throughout the past 15 years .
the detection of dusty ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and gaseous discs ( @xcite and this paper ) of hydrogen and helium depleted material offers a viable alternative at least for some systems : accretion from tidally disrupted asteroids @xcite . however , only a relatively small fraction of the cool ( @xmath44k ) daz white dwarfs exhibit infrared excess , and it is currently not clear if the photospheric metals found in the remaining systems is also associated with the presence of planetary debris .
@xcite show that the 5 confirmed white dwarfs with dusty discs have accretion rates at the upper end of what is observed in cool daz , and our observations give some evidence that the strength of the caii emission correlates with the the photospheric mg abundance ( fig.[f - mgline ] ) .
it may hence be that the white dwarfs with clearly visible discs represent only the `` tip of the iceberg '' .
the caii emission lines detected in sdss1228 + 1040 and sdss1043 + 0855 offer substantialy dynamical insight into the structures of the circumstellar discs , and long - term monitoring of these line profiles appears worthwhile to probe for evolution of the disc radii and eccentricities .
js was supported by a pparc pdra . based on observations made with the william herschel telescope , which is operated on the island of la palma by the isaac newton group in the spanish observatorio del roque de los muchachos of the instituto de astrofsica de canarias .
we thank the referee for a constructive report , and ben zuckerman for his comments on the submitted manuscript .
after the submission of this paper , @xcite reported the spitzer detection of an infrared excess for white dwarf pg1015 + 161 ( @xmath45k ) suggesting that gas and dust discs may co - exist over a certain range in white dwarf effective temperature . | intermediate resolution spectroscopy of the white dwarf sdssj104341.53 + 085558.2 contains double - peaked emission lines of caii@xmath08498,8542,8662 and identifies this object to be the second single white dwarf to be surrounded by a gaseous disc of metal - rich material , similar to the recently discovered sdssj1228 + 1040 .
a photospheric magnesium abundance of 0.3 times the solar value , determined from the observed mgii@xmath14481 absorption line , implies that the white dwarf is accreting from the circumstellar material .
the absence of balmer emission lines and of photospheric hei@xmath14471 absorption indicates that the accreted material is depleted in volatile elements and , by analogy with sdss1228 + 1040 , may be the result of the tidal disruption of an asteroid .
additional spectroscopy of the daz white dwarfs wd1337 + 705 and gd362 does not reveal caii emission lines .
gd362 is one of the few cool daz that display strong infrared flux excess , thought to be originating in a circumstellar dust disc , and its temperature is likely too low to sublimate sufficient amounts of disc material to generate detectable caii emission .
wd1337 + 705 is , as sdss1228 + 1040 and sdssj1043 + 0855 , moderately hot , but has the lowest mg abundance of those three stars , suggesting a possible correlation between the photospheric mg abundance and the equivalent width of the emission triplet .
our inspection of 7360 white dwarfs from sdss dr4 fails to unveil additional strong `` metal gas disc '' candidates , and implies that these objects are rather rare .
[ firstpage ] stars : individual : sdssj104341.53 + 085558.2 white dwarfs |
our experience suggests that the symmetry in the time is disrupted and the future and the past play different roles .
the world surrounding us has obvious irreversible nature .
however , poincare showed that @xcite the description of the irreversibility is impossible on the basis of the classical laws of dynamics , since the latter are reversible in time .
the equations of quantum mechanics are reversible too .
the description of the physical world on the basis of fundamental classical and quantum theories as defined by the laws of the nature is determined to be time reversible .
difference between the classical description of the nature and those processes in the nature which we observe creates the conflict situation .
therefore the problem of the description of irreversible world on the bases of the reversible equations of classical and quantum physics is raised .
i will not discuss the solutions of this problem in classical physics , i will examine the quantum mechanics .
first of all it is necessary to note that the question about irreversibility of quantum processes can be examined in connection with the problem of interpretation of quantum mechanics .
briefly , i will examine two most important approaches - copenhagen and everett s interpretations .
+ copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics asserts that we can not speak about the quantum properties of the system before these properties are measured @xcite , @xcite .
in other words , quantum theory describes not quantum world but the fact that we can speak about quantum world after measurement .
let the energy of the quantum system has two values @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 , @xmath4 corresponding wave functions .
if the system is described by the wave function @xmath5 it is possible to present it in the form of the superposition of the functions @xmath3 and @xmath4 : @xmath6 . before measurement the wave function @xmath5 occupies simultaneously two levels and energy of the system does not have a specific value . only after the measurement we will obtain the values @xmath1 or @xmath2 with probabilities @xmath7 , @xmath8 respectively .
the passage from the `` potential possibilities '' which are described by the wave function @xmath5 to the `` actual realities '' , which can be measured , is called reduction or collapse of the wave function .
the physical process leading to collapse is called quantum decoherence .
the process of the measurement leads to the abrupt , irreversible change of the state .
any measurement is not a reversed process .
thus , irreversibility appears when the measurement is carried out . in this case
the behavior of the quantum system is described by neumann s postulate of reduction @xcite which , however , does not answer the question which _ dynamic processes _ lead to irreversibility .
thus , in accordance with copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics the observed processes proceeding in the world are caused by our measurements including , for example , the quantum transitions .
however , as prigogine notes , since the quantum transitions are the basic mechanism of chemical reactions it is difficult to agree with the latter assertion .
is it possible to consider the chemistry as the result of our observation ?
if yes , then who observed the chemical reactions which led to the appearance of life @xcite ?
+ another interpretation of quantum mechanics is proposed by h. everett ( relative state interpretation ) @xcite .
it was developed in the works @xcite , @xcite ( many - world interpretation ) ; @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ( extension of everett s concept ) .
many - world interpretation allows the existence of the infinite numbers of classical realities : each term of quantum superposition corresponds to one classical world . according to the extended everett
s concept the measurement entangles the measured system with the environment , however , linear superposition is not destroyed .
thus , after measurement the linearity of quantum mechanics is preserved . in this case the reduction of the wave function does not occur .
however , at the specific moment of time the observer sees only one result of the measurement - the one classical world .
this occurs because the consciousness of the observer divides the state of quantum world into the classical realities which he receives independently .
the consciousness of the observer subjectively makes the selection of one alternative .
the consciousness continuously creates classical reality @xcite . hence follows : the classical world is the illusion , reduction of the wave function is the illusion too , since they appear subjectively in the consciousness of the observer . in the approach ,
the concepts of the `` arrow of time '' and irreversibility are rather connected with its subjective feeling of the observer then with the objective property of material itself .
it is assumed , the further study of this interpretation will be possible after the construction of the model of `` quantum consciousness '' , which is discussed in the work @xcite .
+ obviously , the approaches examined above contain a subjective , anthropomorphic element .
the interpretations contain a basic distinction between the quantum system and the observer .
the latter fact is undesirable for the theory since it takes us away from the solution of the basic problem : the determination of the objective laws of the nature ( if we believe in the objectivity of the nature ) .
if copenhagen interpretation is the direct consequence of the insufficient realization of the physical sense of the basic postulates of quantum mechanics , then everett s interpretation is a natural consequence of them .
this situation impels one to the alternative formulation of quantum dynamics which does not appeal to the observer excluding the subjective , anthropomorphous element . in the approach
the irreversibility must be represented as the property of material itself and is not defined by the active role of the observer .
+ in the paper i examine the alternative formulation of quantum dynamics in the framework of the brussels - austin group works that has been headed by i. prigogine for many years . in the works , a possible variant of description of nonequilibrium processes at microscopic level in the frame of the liouville space extension of quantum mechanics
is investigated .
the mechanism of the asymmetry of processes in the time which made it possible to accomplish a passage from the reversible evolution to irreversible one was developed .
thus , new irreversible dynamics with the disrupted time symmetry was formulated .
the symmetry in the time disrupted as a result of asymmetric nature of the physically permissible states .
+ at the present moment , it is necessary to continue further development of the brussels - austin group approach in the framework of the realistic models of interaction .
then , the irreversible evolution of a charged spin @xmath0 particle interacting with a magnetic field is investigated on the basis of subdynamics theory . in the work
the survey of the basic principles of the brussels - austin group is carried out . in section 2
the eigenvalue problem is discussed .
perturbative solution of the schroedinger equation in the framework of complex spectral representation is given .
in section 3 the liouville formulation of quantum mechanics is represented .
the task of the complex spectral representation of the liouvillian is solved in section 4 . in section 5 the theory of subdynamics
is discussed .
the time evolution of the density matrix is determined .
the interacting model of positive charged spin @xmath0 particle with magnetic field is examined in section 6 .
the complex eigenvalue problem for the spin system is solved in section 7 .
the expression for the density matrix element describing the irreversible evolution of the charged particle spin system and numerical calculations are obtained in section 8 .
as the first step , in the framework of schroedinger equation , i examine as the asymmetry in time can arise .
i examine the eigenvalue problem for the hamiltonian @xmath9 @xmath10 where @xmath11 - free hamiltonian , @xmath12 - interaction part , @xmath13 - coupling constant . in the conventional case ,
hamiltonian @xmath14 is a hermitian operator , @xmath15 is a perturbed energy of the state - a real number .
it is known that the usual procedure of equation solution on the basis of perturbation method can lead to the appearance of the denominators @xmath16 , where @xmath17 , @xmath18 are the energies corresponding to the unperturbed situation .
obviously , the divergences can arise at @xmath19 .
the basic question now is - what we can do to avoid the divergences , when @xmath20 .
i examine the situation using the simple friedrichs model @xcite ( the model is presented closely to the text of the works @xcite - @xcite ) . despite the fact , that the solution of the problem for the friedrichs model is known it serves as a good example for the demonstration of the essence of situation .
the model describes interaction of two level atom and electromagnetic field . in the friedrichs model
@xmath21 corresponds to the atom in its bare exited level @xcite , @xmath22 corresponds to the bare field mode with the atom in its ground state .
the state @xmath21 is coupled to the state @xmath22 @xmath23 where @xmath24 here @xmath25 or @xmath26 . in the ordinary approach the eigenvalue problem for the hamiltonian @xmath14
is formulated as follows @xmath27 for the eigenstate @xmath28 ( for small @xmath29 ) perturbation method gives the expression @xmath30 if @xmath31 , divergences appear at @xmath32 .
i. prigogine and co - workers noted that in the general case the satisfactory solution of this problem is impossible on the basis of the conventional formulation of quantum dynamics .
however , the eigenvalue problem can be solved if the time ordering of the eigenstates will be introduced .
this procedure can be realized through the introduction into the denominators imaginary terms : @xmath33 for the relaxation processes , which are oriented into the future and @xmath34 for the excitation processes , which are oriented into the past . in this case
the eigenvalue problem is reduced to the complex eigenvalue problem @xmath35 where we must distinguish right - eigenstate @xmath36 and left - eigenstate @xmath37 @xcite .
@xmath38 is a complex @xmath39 here @xmath40 is a renormalized energy and @xmath41 is a real positive value .
this procedure makes it possible to avoid the divergences and leads to the following expressions for the eigenstates @xmath36 , @xmath37 @xcite @xmath42 @xmath43 in the expressions and the designation @xmath44 has been referred to as `` delayed analytic continuation '' @xcite and can be determined through the integration with a test function @xmath45 .
for example , @xmath46 where we first have to evaluate the integration on the upper half - plane @xmath47 and then the limit of @xmath48 must be taken .
thus , the approach makes it possible to solve the problems which could not be solved within the framework of classical and quantum mechanics .
now we can realize the program of heisenberg - to solve task at the eigenvalues which could not be solved within the framework of traditional methods .
the spectral representation of the hamiltonian takes the form @xmath49 for the eigenstates we have relations @xmath50 since , @xmath14 is hermitian the corresponding eigenstates @xmath36 , @xmath37 are outside hilbert space , have no hilbert norm @xmath51 and furthermore have a zero average energy @xmath52 the eigenstates @xmath36 , @xmath53 are called `` gamow vectors '' .
extensive literature is dedicated to the study of `` gamow vectors '' , for example @xcite - @xcite .
+ thus , the hermiticity of @xmath14 leads to the fact that `` usual '' norms of eigenstates @xmath36 , @xmath54 disappear .
however , the eigenstates @xmath36 , @xmath55 have a broken time symmetry .
we can associate @xmath36 with the unstable state , which vanishes for @xmath56 , @xmath57 corresponds to the state , which vanishes for @xmath58 @xmath59 @xmath60 however , the are few unpleasant aspects .
+ using the eigenvectors @xmath36 , @xmath57 it is possible to construct the density operators @xcite @xmath61 they are invariants of motion and they do not describe the process of relaxation .
in addition , `` unusual '' norms and zero average energy , exist .
+ these are the reasons why a more general space of density matrix - liouville space will be examined .
nevertheless , it is important to emphasize : the complex perturbative solution of the eigenvalue problem in the framework of the schroedinger equation makes it possible to determine @xmath41 which has important physical sense .
the value @xmath62 determines the probability of transition between two quantum states @xcite , @xcite .
this result will be important for us in the next sections .
now i will examine the equation which determines the density matrix @xmath63 - liouville - von neumann equation @xmath64 liouville - von neumann operator ( liouvillian ) has the form : @xmath65 here symbol `` @xmath66 '' denotes the operation @xmath67=a@xmath63b .
operator @xmath68 is written down in the sum of free part @xmath69 , that depends on the free hamiltonian @xmath11 and the interaction part @xmath70 , that depends on @xmath71 - hamiltonian of interaction : @xmath72 .
let state @xmath73 be a eigenvector of the free hamiltonian , then we have the equation @xmath74=@xmath75 with the energy @xmath76 .
the dyad of the states @xmath77 is the eigenstate of operator @xmath69 @xmath78 or @xmath79 where the designations @xmath80 and @xmath81 were used .
+ in the liouville space for the dyadic operators we have the relations : + the inner product defined by @xmath82 the matrix elements are given by @xmath83 the biorthogonality and bicompleteness relations have the form : @xmath84 for operator @xmath68 we have the equation ( the text is written close to the materials of the works @xcite ) @xmath85 here @xmath86 , @xmath87 - the eigenvector and eigenvalue of liouville - von neumann operator @xmath68 , where @xmath88 ( @xmath89 ) , @xmath15 ( @xmath90 ) - the eigenvector and eigenvalue of the total hamiltonian . the spectral representation of operator @xmath68 has the form @xmath91 since @xmath92 , the diagonal elements of density matrix do not depend on the time .
therefore , strictly speaking , the conventional formalism does not make it possible to describe the evolution of the system to the equilibrium .
. can be rewritten by using the correlation index @xmath93 : @xmath94 where @xmath95 ( or @xmath96 for the case ) and @xmath97 .
the details of the theory of correlations can be found , for example , in the works @xcite . in equation
@xmath98 if @xmath99 - that is the set of diagonal operators @xmath100 - `` vacuum of correlations '' and @xmath101 is the remaining off - diagonal case .
then , the concept of degree of correlation must be introduced .
the degree of correlation of dyads @xmath102 , @xmath103 , has been defined as the minimum number of interactions @xmath70 by which a dyadic state can reach the vacuum of correlation .
for example , the degree of vacuum of correlation @xmath104 .
the concept of correlation will be examined lately in connection with the model which is investigated in the article .
+ certainly , the problem of the description of irreversibility can be solved on the basis of well known physical approximations @xcite .
the solution is based on the distinction between the open system and its environment .
the environment is assumed to be in the thermodynamic equilibrium .
however , as it was noted @xcite `` this distinction introduces an anthropomorphic element .
indeed , the environment , introduced by one observer , may be different to that seen by another observer .
moreover , this distinction is phenomenological as one avoids answering the most fundamental question of nonequilibrium statistical mechanics , namely , what is the mechanism that governs the approach to thermal equilibrium of the environment , without violating the basic laws of physics . ''
the approach of brussels - austin group is based on the assertion : the irreversibility is the objective property of quantum world .
this objective reality we have to describe without including the anthropomorphic principle , such as lack of our knowledge , coarse - graining approximations , environmental approach @xcite .
the solution of the problems , which was examined above , is proposed on the basis of the _ liouville space extension _ of quantum mechanics @xcite , @xcite or otherwise , on the basis of _ the complex spectral representation _ of liouville - von neumann operator @xmath68 , and _ subdynamics
theory_. in this case , liouvillian has complex eigenvalues , that break time symmetry without introduction of an anthropomorphic element or dissipative terms to the hamiltonian @xcite or to the liouvillian @xcite .
we have a new formulation of the eigenvalue problem : @xmath105 where @xmath106 are the complex values , @xmath93 is a correlation index and @xmath107 is a degeneracy index , since one type of correlation index can correspond to the different states ( the complex eigenvalue problem for the liouvillian is examined in the works @xcite ) . it was shown @xcite that the eigenstates of @xmath68 can be written in the terms of kinetic operators @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
operator @xmath108 creates correlations other than the @xmath93 correlations , @xmath109 is destruction operator .
the use of the kinetic operators allows to write down the expressions for the eigenstates of liouville operator in the following form @xcite @xmath110 where @xmath111 here @xmath112 - is a normalization constant .
the determination of the states @xmath113 , @xmath114 and operators @xmath115 , @xmath108 , @xmath109 can be found in the works @xcite . in the general case , for example
, the operators @xmath115 are determined by the following expressions @xcite @xmath116 let me examine some results obtained in the original works .
the work @xcite shows that @xmath117 , @xmath118 satisfy so - called nonlinear lippmann - schwinger equation . for the @xmath117 we have @xmath119p^{\nu},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the time ordering @xmath120 was introduced .
this is the important moment of the theory because the time ordering breaks time symmetry and , thus , leads to the description of the irreversibility .
the determination of the sign of the infinitesimals @xmath121 is connected with degree of correlation @xmath103 . in accordance with our experience
we will consider the directions to the higher degrees of correlation oriented in the future , for example , the decay of elementary particles , quantum transitions with emission or absorption of energy , and the directions to the lowest degrees of correlation are oriented in the past .
this leads to the relations : @xmath122 for the @xmath118 we have the equation @xmath123 \sum\limits_{\mu\neq\nu } p^{\mu}\frac{1}{w^{\nu}-w^{\mu}-i\varepsilon_{\nu\mu}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] eqs . , determine the kinetic operators of creation @xmath108 and destruction @xmath109 as follows @xmath124p^{\nu},\ ] ] @xmath125 \sum\limits_{\mu\neq\nu } p^{\mu}\frac{1}{w^{\nu}-w^{\mu}-i\varepsilon_{\nu\mu}}.\ ] ] it is evident from the last expressions that @xmath126 , but @xmath127 , where `` @xmath128 '' corresponds to the hermitian conjugation and the action `` @xmath129 '' - the `` star '' conjugation which is hermitian conjugation plus the change @xmath130 .
+ substituting the expression in eq . and multiplying @xmath115 from left on both sides , we obtain @xcite @xmath131 where @xmath132 also , it is possible to show the validity of the following useful relationship @xmath133 the latter will be necessary for us in the future . in eq .
@xmath134 is the collision operator connected with the kinetic operator @xmath108 .
this is non - hermitian dissipative operator which plays the main role in the nonequilibrium dynamics . as it was shown in the work @xcite operator @xmath135
can be reduced to the collision operator in pauli master equation for the weakly coupled systems . comparing eqs .
, we can see that @xmath113 is eigenstate of collision operators @xmath134 with the same eigenvalues @xmath106 as @xmath68 .
+ thus , the time ordering introduces into the theory the `` arrow of the time '' , and leads to the connection of quantum mechanics with kinetic , time irreversible dynamics . as an example , i examine the friedrichs model . in the works
@xcite , @xcite the following results were obtained : @xmath136 @xmath137 where , for example , @xmath138 in - @xmath139 is the operation of the complex conjugation , @xmath38 is determined by relationship , @xmath36 is determined by and @xmath140 , @xmath141 can be found in the works @xcite , @xcite and correspond to the field mode .
+ obviously , the complex eigenvalues @xmath106 of the liouville operator can not be reduced to the simple difference of two eigenvalues of the hamiltonian as in the case .
furthermore , eigenstates @xmath142 , @xmath143 are not the multiplications of the wave functions , they can not be obtained from the schroedinger equation . in this sense
we have the _ alternative formulation of quantum theory_.
equation does not describe the irreversible evolution .
the precise description of irreversibility requires the determination of the new approach .
this approach was developed on the basis of the theory of subdynamics . in the theory of brussels - austin group , subdynamics
is called the construction of a complete set of spectral projectors @xmath144 @xcite ( see also @xcite ) @xmath145 the projectors @xmath144 satisfy the following relations @xmath146 and in our approximation @xmath147 operator @xmath144 can be represented in the following form @xmath148 where @xmath149 is the star - hermitian operator @xmath150 @xmath151 taking it is possible to write down the density matrix @xmath63 in the form @xmath152 where @xmath153 . using , , and
it is possible to write down @xmath154 i examine the component @xmath155 .
it was called the `` privileged '' component of @xmath156 . for the @xmath155
it is easy to obtain @xmath157 where in our case @xmath158 - vacuum of correlations and the relations @xmath159 , @xmath160 were used .
the relation leads to the equation @xmath161 thus , it is shown operators @xmath162 satisfy separate equations of motion .
the equation is the kinetic equation for each @xmath144 subspace .
this is the reason why the projectors @xmath144 can be associated with the introduction of the concept of subdynamics .
+ using i determine the component @xmath163 @xmath164 the expression @xmath165 is determined by for @xmath166 .
the second term has the form @xmath167 the obtained expressions lead @xmath168 taking the time derivative of @xmath163 - component we have @xmath169 the equation consists of two parts : the first one corresponds to the markovian approximation , the second part includes the memory effects and determines the non - markovian processes @xcite .
+ it is possible to conclude , the introduction of the subdynamics makes it possible to determine the eqs . and which are the fundamental equations for the description of the irreversible processes .
i examine the behavior of the positive charged particle in the magnetic field @xcite . as the charged particle
it is possible to examine proton , positron and any positive charged particle with non - zero magnetic moment and with spin @xmath0 .
+ spin @xmath170 of the particle is connected with magnetic moment @xmath171 by the expression @xmath172 where the values @xmath173 , @xmath170 are determined by @xmath174 here @xmath175 , @xmath176 are the charge and the mass of particle , @xmath177 is @xmath178-factor , @xmath179 - pauli matrices .
i use the system of units , where @xmath180 and the speed of light @xmath181 .
+ let the isolated charged particle with magnetic moment @xmath171 be placed into the external magnetostatic field which is directed along @xmath182 axis - @xmath183 .
the hamiltonian operator then becomes @xmath184 in the expression @xmath185 is a @xmath182-component of the vector @xmath179 .
+ particle with spin @xmath0 in the external magnetic field @xmath183 has two energy levels corresponding to two different values of magnetic quantum number @xmath186 @xmath187 the distance between the levels is determined by the energy @xmath188 @xmath189 the transitions of the particle from one energy level to another @xmath190 can occur as a result of the influence on the system of the external magnetic field @xmath191 perpendicular to the field @xmath183 .
the exciting magnetic field @xmath191 must be variable and its frequency @xmath192 must coincide with frequency @xmath193 .
such transitions are accompanied by emission or absorption of energy @xmath188 .
this is the well known phenomenon of the magnetic resonance .
+ strictly speaking , the energy levels are not determined accurately .
they have an uncertainty of the values .
it leads to the spectrum of the radiated energies , which distribution is simulated by the introduction of distribution function @xmath194 with the width @xmath195 .
the distribution function describes lorentzian or gaussian distribution of energy .
lorentzian distribution is described by the function @xcite @xmath196 with norm @xmath197 taking into account the distribution @xmath194 it is possible to determine the rate of the transition between the energy levels @xcite , @xcite @xmath198 in the simplest case , the components of the field @xmath191 change according to the law @xcite @xmath199 where @xmath192 is the frequency of the rotating field in the @xmath200 plane .
then , the hamiltonian operator takes the form @xmath201 whence it follows @xmath202 since , @xmath203 i obtain the expression @xmath204 the first term @xmath205 in the expression determines interaction with the field @xmath183 , the second term @xmath206 determines interaction with the field @xmath191 .
+ i examine the field @xmath207 so that @xmath208 ( see a. abragam @xcite ) .
this condition has the greatest practical interest . in this case for the eigenfunctions @xmath209 , which are determined by the equation @xmath210
i take the approximation @xmath211 then , the function , which describes the behavior of spin , can be determined by the superposition of the functions @xmath212 , @xmath213 @xmath214 for the hermitian conjugated ( @xmath215 ) function @xmath216
i have @xmath217 the expression corresponds to the monochromatic case . for the passage to the general case it is necessary to make the following replacements @xmath218 where the value of the coefficients @xmath219 , @xmath220 will be determined later .
i examine the transition @xmath221 . this transition is accompanied by the emission of the energy @xmath188 .
the transition with the emission of the energy is the irreversible process .
the description of the irreversible evolution of the spin system will be carried out on the basis of the expression .
i will determine the evolution of matrix element @xmath222 which corresponds to the probability of finding the particle in the state with spin @xmath223 at the time moment @xmath224 .
+ the evolution of the system in the kinetic - markovian approximation has the exponential nature @xmath225 .
so , in the work @xcite ( in this work the irreversible evolution of the unstable @xmath226 - meson was defined ) @xmath227 - the rate of the @xmath226 - meson decay .
i assume that in our case @xmath228 , where @xmath229 is the rate under the resonance condition @xmath230 ( @xmath193 is determined by ) .
therefore , the first step will consist of the determination of the value @xmath231 .
this task will be executed on the basis of perturbative solution of complex eigenvalue problem in the framework of the method of the second quantization .
+ let me examine the replacement . according to the method of the second quantization
i define the values @xmath219 , @xmath220 as operators @xmath232 here @xmath233 , @xmath234 are the operators of creation and destruction of photon with the energy @xmath192 .
i assume , these operators satisfy the commutation relation @xmath235=\delta(\omega - \omega ' ) .
\end{split}\ ] ] in the determination , @xmath236 is the function satisfying the condition @xmath237 as will be shown below ( see ) the square of the function @xmath236 is the distribution function .
the coefficients @xmath238 in the expression find the value of the destruction operators of particles with @xmath239 .
for @xmath240 and @xmath241 in we must make @xmath242 , @xmath243 , here @xmath244 are the creation operators .
it is assumed , the operators @xmath238 , @xmath244 satisfy the anti - commutation relation @xmath245_{+ } = \delta_{mm'},~~m~(m')=\pm 1/2 .
\end{split}\ ] ] in this case the hamiltonian of the particle - magnetic field system can be determined in the form @xmath246 where the previous designations of operators are preserved .
now , the values @xmath247 , @xmath248 and hamiltonian can be examined as the operators in the dirac representation .
+ i examine the eigenvalue problem for the hamiltonian @xmath249 , where a free part @xmath250 , and an interaction part @xmath251 .
@xmath252 is a free electromagnetic hamiltonian .
let state @xmath253 ( @xmath254 is the vacuum state : @xmath255 ) be a eigenvector of the free hamiltonian @xmath252 then , @xmath256 , where @xmath192 is the photon energy .
the hamiltonian @xmath252 can be determined as follows @xmath257 as will be shown below ( appendix c ) , for our model , here and in the subsequent expressions integration over @xmath192 have to be carried out in the interval @xmath258 .
i determine the states @xmath259 .
the states @xmath260 are the eigenvectors of the hamiltonian @xmath205 @xmath261 and @xmath262 . in this case
the expression @xmath263 is valid , where @xmath264 .
since , the transition ( @xmath221 ) occurs as the result of interaction with the field @xmath191 that is why the term @xmath206 is defined as the interaction part @xmath12 .
+ i will solve the problem assuming , that the eigenvalue @xmath265 of the hamiltonian @xmath14 is complex ( the general formalism of the complex spectral representation can be found in the works @xcite ) . in accordance with the approach @xcite , in our case , i will distinguish equation for the right eigenstate @xmath266 and for the left eigenstate @xmath267 of hamiltonian @xmath14 @xmath268 i expand the values @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath265 in the perturbation series @xmath269 where @xmath270 in accordance with the definitions - for the first equation of i can write down @xmath271 where @xmath272 is our initial state .
+ hence , it is easy to obtain the expression for the coefficient @xmath273 @xmath274 let us examine the first term in the expression .
the use of the interaction term in leads to @xmath275 the substitution of the expression into and summing up @xmath276 on the both sides of the obtained expression lead to the result @xmath277 whence i obtain @xmath278 let us determine the value @xmath279 . for this purpose
i write down the obvious equality @xmath280 where @xmath281 is our final state .
+ the expression leads to @xmath282 it is assumed , the state with the spin @xmath223 disappears in the future , converting to the state with the spin @xmath0 and photon with the energy @xmath192 .
in this case the time ordering of the expression has to be introduced .
for this purpose i make the replacement @xmath283 here the symbol @xmath284 in infinitesimal @xmath121 corresponds to the state @xmath285 , the symbol @xmath93 corresponds to the state @xmath272 . the state @xmath285 has the high degree of correlation and i assume @xmath286 .
+ for the first term of i have the result @xmath287 the substitution of the expressions , into and summing up @xmath276 lead to @xmath288 taking into account the result , the expression can be represented in the form @xmath289 using the formal expression @xmath290 i present the eigenvalue @xmath265 as follows @xmath291 where @xmath292 is a renormalized energy @xmath293 and @xmath294 comparing the obtained expression for @xmath231 with the expression for the rate @xmath229 we see @xmath295 where the equality @xmath296 is used .
evidently , in this case , the obtained expression @xmath297 coincides with the expression for @xmath298 under the resonance condition @xmath299 .
let us examine the matrix element @xmath300 ( see the expression ) .
the projection operator @xmath301 can be redetermined in the form . for the matrix element
the following designations are valid @xmath302 for the operator @xmath149 the equality @xmath303 is correct .
then , in the first approximation , it is possible to assume that @xmath304 using the expressions , and i obtain @xmath305 first of all , i examine the first term in the expression .
this term corresponds to the markovian approximation . in our case
the initial condition is given by @xmath306 and for our matrix element i have @xmath307 from the expression it follows @xmath308 here it was assumed that @xmath309 according to @xcite operator @xmath108 ( the expression ) , in the first approximation can be represented in the form @xmath310 hence , for the operator @xmath311 i obtain @xmath312 here the symbol @xmath313 corresponds to the vacuum of correlations , @xmath284 in infinitesimal @xmath314 corresponds to the high degree of correlation .
infinitesimal determines the time ordered transition from the vacuum of correlations to the high degree of correlation . in our model
the initial condition cuts from the possible vacuum of correlation states the initial correlation state @xmath315 which corresponds to initial pure state @xmath272 .
high degree of correlations @xmath284 are determined by the correlation final state @xmath316 which corresponds to the final state @xmath317 . in this case @xmath318 .
the details of the evaluation of the expression for the matrix element are examined in the appendix a : @xmath319 the non - markovian effect is determined by the second term in the expression . for it
i have the result @xmath320 the details of calculations of the expression are represented in the appendix b. + taking into account the determination and the results , the time evolution of the charged particle spin system can be represented by the expression @xmath321 the calculation of the integral in the expression ( the features of the calculation are examined in the appendix c ) leads to the final result . @xmath322
the coefficients @xmath323 , @xmath324 in are determined by the expressions @xmath325 @xmath326 the function @xmath327 has the form @xmath328 where @xmath329 and @xmath330 .
+ thus , the privileged component in the determination corresponds to the kinetic , markovian process ( the first term in ) , the non - markovian effect coming from the nonprivileged component ( the second term in ) . + figure 1 presents the calculations of the separate contributions : the markovian and the non - markovian terms .
calculations are executed for proton : proton mass - @xmath331 , @xmath178-factor - 5.58 , nuclear magneton - @xmath332 @xcite , @xcite .
it is seen , the relaxation process is determined by the markovian term .
the kinetic evolution prevails in the entire time interval .
the non - markovian term is determined by the damped oscillations and is not essential .
the other sets of the values ( @xmath183 , @xmath207 , @xmath333 ) substantially decrease the contribution of the latter .
note , that the calculation of the non - markovian effect was carried out earlier , for example , in the work @xcite ( a quantum harmonic oscillator linearly coupled to a bosonic massless scalar field ) , where the contribution of the latter is more noticeable ( see also @xcite , @xcite ) .
a time scale of transition of the evolution from the non - markovian regime to the markovian regime was determined .
thus , it was shown , the non - markovian term corresponds to the well - known quantum zeno effect @xcite .
in conclusion it is necessary to note that the approach i have examined is not the one more additional interpretation of quantum mechanics .
it is not intended to interpret the quantum mechanics , but it is proposed to reformulate it so that the irreversibility naturally would enter into quantum dynamics .
the approach denies the conventional opinion that the irreversibility appears only at the macroscopic level , while the microscopic level can be described by the laws , reversed in the time .
thus , the irreversible nature of quantum physics is asserted . in this case , the basic problem , designated by boltzmann and planck - to formulate the second law of thermodynamics at the microscopic level , is revealed . in the approach the solution of this problem
is proposed in the works @xcite , @xcite , @xcite - @xcite .
the law of the increase of entropy is accepted as fundamental there , that determines the `` arrow of time '' , the difference between the past and the future .
the future corresponds to the larger value of the entropy .
thus , the _ existence of the `` arrow of time '' , the second law of thermodynamics at the microscopic level are determined as the basic postulates_. unconditionally , the interaction with the environment leads to the irreversible effects , but in the brussels - austin group approach the environment is not limited by the special requirements as , for example , to be in the thermodynamic equilibrium .
the preceding calculation of the relaxation time ( fig.1 , markovian term ) for a spin @xmath0 particle interacting with a magnetic field demonstrates the utility of the brussels - austin formalism in a practical problem that may be tested in experiment . + is it possible to speak about the laws of quantum world independently of the observer ?
bohr came to the conclusion about the impossibility of description of the independent quantum processes .
the approach of the brussels - austin group is the attempt to learn to describe the processes in the quantum world as the property of the material itself without active role of the observer .
+ in our approximation the projection operator @xmath301 ( @xmath166 - vacuum of correlations ) can be redetermined in the form @xmath334 where the volume @xmath335 is determined so that @xmath336 and @xmath337 is the delta - function . for the operators @xmath115 ( @xmath101 - high degree of correlations ) i determine @xmath338 then , the following relationships are valid : @xmath339 the expansion of the expression in the series leads to @xmath340 taking into account for the term @xmath341 i obtain @xmath342 where @xmath343 . in our case
@xmath344 here , @xmath345 .
using the determinations @xmath346 @xmath347 where @xmath348 ( @xmath349 ) is delta - function
if the indices @xmath350 , @xmath351 ( @xmath352 , @xmath353 ) correspond to the continuous spectrum and it is kronecker s symbol if the indices correspond to the discrete spectrum , for we will have @xmath354 keeping in mind the result it is possible to determine the equality @xmath355 where @xmath356 is the term of higher order on @xmath175 .
+ in the equality the concept of `` delayed analytic continuation '' is used ( section 2 ) . from the relationship another equality follows @xmath357 in this case
the operation of integration of the expressions , which contain the values of the form @xmath358 is determined by the rule : we first have to evaluate the integration on the lower half - plane and then the limit @xmath359 must be taken .
taking into account , , using the hamiltonian and limiting by order @xmath360 it is easy to obtain @xmath361 comparing the obtained expression with the expression and taking into account the designations , , i can write down @xmath362 making the analogous calculations for the each term of the expression in the limit @xmath363 i will obtain the result .
+ in this appendix i examine the details of the obtaining expression .
the determination of the operator @xmath108 leads to @xmath364 where the action @xmath365 corresponds to the `` star '' conjugation ( section 4 ) . taking into account the determinations , , , , and replacement , in the lower - order approximation for the operator @xmath366 ( see ) @xmath367 it is easy to obtain @xmath368 here , index @xmath369 corresponds to the state @xmath281 , @xmath370 , @xmath299 . in the sum
corresponds to summation ( integration ) over all discrete ( continuous ) indices .
+ the calculation of the integral in the expression will be carried out in the kinematic region , where the function @xmath194 satisfies the condition @xmath371 in this case , the integration can be realized in the interval @xmath372 .
+ since , @xmath373 , we have to deform the contour of integration in the lower half - plane @xcite . in this region
the application of the cauchy s theorem is possible ( see figure 2 ) @xmath374 where @xmath375 if @xmath376 is the lorentzian distribution then , @xmath377 it leads to @xmath378 the replacement @xmath379 , where @xmath380 makes it possible to reduce our integral to the form @xmath381 where @xmath329 and @xmath330 .
it allows us to evalute the obtained integral with the use of the `` mathematica''-program .
this leads to the expression @xmath382 the coefficients @xmath323 , @xmath324 in are determined by the expressions , .
h. poincare , c. r. acad .
( paris ) * 108 * ( 1889 ) 550 .
i. prigogine , from being to becoming , freeman , san francisco , 1980 .
i. prigogine , the end of certainty , the fee press , 1997 .
v. b. braginsky , f. ya .
khalili , quantum measurement , cambridge univ . press , 1992 .
i. prigogine , i. stengers , order out of chaos : man s new dialogue with nature , boulder , c.o . , new science library , 1984 .
h. everett , rev .
* 29 * ( 1957 ) 454 .
b. s. dewitt , n. graham ( eds ) the many - worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics , princenton univ . press , 1973 .
d. deutsch , the fabric of reality , the penguin press .
m. b. mensky , physics@xmath383uspekhi , russia * 170 * ( 2000 ) 631 .
m. b. mensky , physics@xmath383uspekhi , russia * 175 * ( 2005 ) 413 . m. b. mensky , physics@xmath383uspekhi , russia * 177 * ( 2007 ) 415 .
k. friedrichs , comm .
pure appl .
* 1 * ( 1948 ) 361 .
t. y. petrosky , i. prigogine and s. tasaki , physica a * 173 * ( 1991 ) 175 .
g. ordonez , t. petrosky and i. prigogine , phys .
a * 63 * ( 2001 ) 052106 .
e. karpov , g. ordonez , t. petrosky and i. prigogine , phys .
rev . a * 66 * ( 2002 ) 012109 .
t. petrosky , g. ordonez and i. prigogine , phys . rev . a * 64 * ( 2001 ) 062101 .
a. bohm , m. gadella , dirac kets , gamow vectors and gelfand triplets , springer lecture notes on physica * 348 * ( 1989 ) .
i. antoniou , m. gadella , i. prigogine and g. p. pronko , journal of mathematical physics * 39 * ( 1998 ) 2995 .
i. antoniou , m. gadella and g. p. pronko , chaos , solitons and fractals * 12 * ( 2001 ) 2737 .
i. antoniou , m. gadella , e. karpov , i. prigogine and g. p. pronko , chaos , solitons and fractals * 12 * ( 2001 ) 2757 . s. eh .
shirmovsky , physica a * 382 * ( 2007 ) 473
. t. y. petrosky , i. prigogine , physica a * 175 * ( 1991 ) 146 .
i. prigogine , non - equilibrium statistical mechanics .
new york : wiley;1962 . k. blum , density matrix theory and application , university of munster , 1981 .
t. petrosky , v. barsegov , phys . rev . e * 65 * ( 2002 ) 046102 .
t. petrosky , c. o. ting , v. barsegov , chaos , solitons and fractals * 16 * ( 2003 ) 381
. b. b. kadomtsev , physics@xmath383uspekhi , russia * 173 * ( 2003 ) 1223 .
a. isar , particles and nuclei , letters , dubna n2(138 ) , * 4 * ( 2007 ) 231 .
t. petrosky , i. prigogine , chaos , solitons , fractals * 4 * ( 1994 ) 311 .
t. petrosky , i. prigogine , chaos , solitons , fractals * 7 * ( 1996 ) 441 .
t. petrosky , i. prigogine , adv .
chem . phys .
* 99 * ( 1997 ) 1 .
t. y. petrosky , h. hasegawa , physica a * 160 * ( 1989 ) 351 . c. george , physica ( amsterdam ) * 65 * ( 1973 ) 277 .
m. de haan , c. george and f. mayne , physica a * 92 * ( 1978 ) 584 .
a. abragam , the principles of nuclear magnetism , oxford , 1961 .
j. w. emsley , j. feeney and l. h. sutcliffe , high resolution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy , oxford , 1965 . i. j. slonim , a. n. lubimov , nuclear magnetic resonance , moscow , `` chemistry '' press , 1966 .
i. antoniou , s. tasaki , international journal of quantum chemistry * 65 * ( 1993 ) 425 .
i. antoniou , i. prigogine , physica a * 192 * ( 1993 ) 443 .
c. amsler , et al . , phys .
b * 667 * ( 2008 ) 1 .
i. antoniou , e. karpov , g. pronko and e. yarevsky , chaos , solitons and fractals * 17 * ( 2003 ) 311 .
e. c. g. sudarshan , b. misra , j. math .
phys * 18 * ( 1977 ) 756 .
m. de haan , f. henin , physica * 67 * ( 1973 ) 197 .
m. rosenberg , t. petrosky , computer math .
* 34 * ( 1997 ) 533
. i. prigogine , physica a * 263 * ( 1999 ) 528
. t. petrosky , g. ordonez , and i. prigogine , phys .
rev . a * 68 * ( 2003 ) 022107 . | the time evolution of a charged spin @xmath0 particle interacting with a magnetic field is analyzed in the framework of the complex spectral theory , based on prigogine s principles that provide a rigorous description of irreversibility .
a detailed survey of the irreversible relaxation process of the spin @xmath0 particle is carried out on the basis of the subdynamics theory .
we obtain the results for the markovian and the non - markovian evolution of the charged particle .
irreversibility , subdynamics , kinetic , non - markovian |
neutrinos have long been a rich hunting ground for physics beyond the standard model ( bsm ) .
in fact , neutrino mass is so far the only bsm physics that has been established in laboratory experiments .
astrophysical evidence of dark matter suggests the existence of bsm particles , which have nevertheless not been observed yet . among all feasible candidates , weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) are theoretically rather appealing .
these may be observable through their interactions within detectors , as the earth moves through the sea of wimps .
this possibility has triggered a cornucopia of experimental efforts of direct dark matter detection @xcite . in this letter
we examine the physics potential of combining a liquid xenon ( lxe ) detector , designed to search for wimp dark matter , with an intense electron - capture neutrinos source in order to look for neutrino magnetic moments ( @xmath1 mm ) and other new physics in @xmath2 elastic scattering .
the idea of looking for new physics in the neutrino sector using dark matter detectors has been proposed before in the literature , see for instance refs .
direct dark matter detection relies on observing nuclear recoils with electron - equivalent energy down to @xmath3 kev . due to the small values expected for the dark matter interaction cross section ,
large detector masses and low background levels are also required . a lxe time projection chamber ( tpc )
can provide a large volume , low detection thresholds ( sub - kev ) and a very low background rate at the energies of interest . at the same time the electron density is higher in xenon than in any other stable noble gas , thus providing the largest possible target density in any given volume near the source .
the idea of using liquid noble gas detectors to search for @xmath1 mm was first suggested by vogel and engel @xcite , but never developed . as a by - product
we also find non - negligible sensitivity to sterile neutrino oscillations in the @xmath41 ev@xmath5 range suggested by recent terrestrial experiments @xcite .
when a nucleus decays via electron - capture almost all of the available energy goes into a mono - energetic neutrino . among possible nuclei which decay via electron - capture
, @xmath6cr offers several practical advantages : it is readily produced by thermal neutron capture @xcite , has a mean lifetime of 39.96 days and produces two mono - energetic neutrino lines at 750 kev ( 90% ) and 430 kev ( 10% ) .
mega - curie - scale @xmath6cr sources have been produced in the past and used to calibrate the gallium radiochemical solar neutrino detectors gallex @xcite and sage @xcite .
in the presence of a @xmath1 mm , the differential cross section for @xmath2 elastic scattering can be written as @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the electron mass , @xmath9 is the electron recoil energy , @xmath10 is the neutrino energy and @xmath11 is the @xmath1 mm in bohr magnetons ( @xmath12 ) .
the term proportional to @xmath11 produces an increase in the number of events at low electron recoil energies .
this makes two - phase lxe tpcs @xcite , with their low - energy detection threshold , ideal detectors for such a search .
currently , the lowest bounds on @xmath1 mm come from astrophysical observations @xcite : @xmath13 .
the best constraint from terrestrial experiments , on the other hand , has been obtained by the gemma experiment , @xmath14 at 90% cl @xcite . in the sm ,
@xmath1mms are expected to be many orders of magnitude below present bounds , yet many extensions of the sm produce an enhancement of the @xmath1 mm , see for instance ref .
@xcite and references therein . for our sensitivity estimate
, we assume a data taking period of 100 days , using a @xmath6cr source with initial strength of 5 mci .
our choice for the strength of the source is based on simulations conducted for the sox experiment @xcite of the gallex enriched @xmath15cr material @xcite irradiated in the high flux isotope reactor at oak ridge national laboratory .
we consider a generic lxe detector , but for definiteness we chose a design similar to the proposed lz detector @xcite .
we assume a cylindrical fiducial volume with equal diameter and height , @xmath16 m , which contains @xmath17 tons of lxe , and we assume that the radioactive source is placed 1 m below the fiducial volume , along the central axis of the cylinder .
neutrinos are detected via electron elastic scattering in the detector , see eq .
[ eq : xsecmu ] . under these assumptions ,
a total of @xmath18 signal events are expected for a 100 day run .
regarding backgrounds , we have considered contributions from solar neutrino interactions , @xmath19rn and @xmath20kr decay , and the @xmath21xe @xmath22 decay . following ref .
@xcite , the solar neutrino background is estimated to be 1.05 counts per ton and day for @xmath23 neutrinos and 0.51 counts per ton and day for @xmath24be neutrinos .
the @xmath20kr and @xmath21xe backgrounds have been taken directly from fig . 2 in ref .
@xcite and rescaled according to our run length and detector mass , while for @xmath19rn we assume that a goal of 0.1 @xmath25bq / kg can be achieved @xcite , about a factor of 30 reduction with respect to what has been achieved for exo-200 @xcite .
finally , an important source of background could come from the source itself . in 10% of @xmath6cr
decays there is a 320 kev gamma , which can easily be shielded with just a few cm of tungsten .
however , impurities present in the chromium prior to irradiation , can lead to the production of mev gamma emitters @xcite
. these will require significant additional shielding to be reduced down to an acceptable level .
we base our calculation of this background on the measured gamma activity of the gallex source @xcite .
our source is assumed to be shielded by a 17 cm thick tungsten layer , which , when combined with 70 cm of lxe ( present between the tungsten shield and the edge of the detector ) , provides an attenuation of @xmath26 for a 1.5 mev gamma .
nevertheless , with @xmath27 gammas emitted per day ( in all directions ) , we expect about 10 to pass through the shielding and compton scatter in the detector fiducial volume .
most of these would deposit energy in excess of the maximum from a @xmath6cr neutrino , though .
further suppression could come from a veto on mulit - site compton scattering events .
we estimate the surviving background in the fiducial volume from source gammas to be less than 1 event per day at the start of the data taking , and , since @xmath2895% of mev gammas come from short - lived isotopes ( such as @xmath29cu , @xmath30ge and @xmath31na ) , this rate should rapidly decay with time .
therefore , we will neglect these events in our analysis , but we note that care must be taken in the preparation of the @xmath15cr source material to ensure the required level of purity is reached . to constrain the @xmath1 mm ,
the analysis is done in terms of the recoil energy of the electron only .
the recoil energies are smeared on an event - by - event basis according to a gaussian with @xmath32 . generally , we find that the energy resolution does not have a significant impact on the @xmath1 mm sensitivity .
a poissonian @xmath33 is constructed using 0.1 kev wide bins in @xmath9 , from 2 kev to 140 kev unless otherwise stated . in this energy range
a total of @xmath34 signal events are expected , together with a total of @xmath35 background events .
the distribution of signal and background events in electron recoil energy is shown in fig . [ fig : mu ] ( left ) .
reducing the backgrounds does not significantly improve the sensitivity to this observable since in the low - energy region , where the @xmath1 mm enhancement is expected , the background rate is already quite low . on the other hand , we find the low - energy threshold to be the most relevant parameter in this analysis ( as expected from eq .
[ eq : xsecmu ] ) .
[ fig : mu ] ( right ) shows the dependence of the sensitivity as a function of detector threshold . with a fairly conservative threshold of 2
kev the 95% cl bound is @xmath36 .
such values would yield an improvement of a factor of 5 over the currently best terrestrial limit .
a second possible application of the setup studied here would be the search for light sterile neutrinos .
sterile neutrinos arise in most models of neutrino mass generation
. searches for oscillations between active and sterile neutrinos have been conducted using many combinations of neutrino sources , detectors and oscillation channels @xcite .
experimental results are inconclusive , with strong tension between different data sets ( see , _
e.g. _ , refs .
in particular , an analysis of gallex and sage data shows an apparent deficit of events which is consistent with oscillations involving a sterile neutrino with a squared mass difference with the active states @xmath37 and a mixing angle such that @xmath38 @xcite , which is commonly referred to as the _ gallium anomaly_. the smoking gun of a sterile neutrino would be to observe events following an oscillating pattern in @xmath39 , the distance traveled by the neutrino divided by its energy . a monochromatic neutrino source reduces the oscillating pattern to a pure function of @xmath40 . given the energy of the primary @xmath6cr neutrino the oscillation length at @xmath41 would be @xmath42 90 cm and thus the oscillating pattern would be observable _ inside _ a meter - scale detector .
the expected spatial resolution in lxe tpcs is at the sub - cm level , which makes them ideal candidates for such an experiment . in our analysis , we have adopted a phenomenological approach based on a 3 + 1 framework , where there is only one extra sterile state at the ev scale . in this framework , the @xmath0 disappearance oscillation probability can be expressed in terms of one mixing angle and one mass squared splitting only , as : @xmath43 where @xmath10 is the neutrino energy , @xmath40 is the distance between the source and the interaction point in the detector , @xmath44 and @xmath45 is an effective mixing angle .
the sensitivity to sterile neutrino oscillations is computed using the distance between the source and the interaction point ( @xmath40 ) as the main variable in the analysis .
a binned gaussian @xmath33 is built using 3 cm wide bins .
the detector is assumed to have a constant spatial resolution of 1 cm ; however , the largest uncertainty in @xmath40 comes from the shape and size of the radioactive source itself . in the present work
, we assume that the source will be a cylinder with both height and diameter equal to 14 cm .
to achieve such a compact source will require that the chromium material be enriched to @xmath2895% in @xmath15cr .
this is much higher than what was achieved by gallex @xcite , but similar to what was reached by sage @xcite .
a smearing function was generated , by a monte carlo calculation , that simultaneously accounts for the finite source size and the detector resolution .
two nuisance parameters are added to the @xmath33 for signal and background normalization uncertainties .
a gaussian penalty term ( or pull - term ) is added to the @xmath33 for the background uncertainty and marginalization is performed over both nuisance parameters . unless otherwise stated , no constraint is assumed for the flux normalization and it is therefore left completely free during the fit . for the backgrounds ,
an uncertainty of 0.5% is assumed .
we expect this could be achieved by using the data collected during the source - free operation of the detector corresponding to the the dark matter search .
the process is repeated for each point in the @xmath46 parameter space . since the low - end threshold for the electron recoil energy is not expected to have a great impact on the sterile neutrino analysis , it is set to 5 kev in this case .
the results for the sterile neutrino sensitivity are shown in fig .
[ fig : sterile ] .
since the sensitivity mainly comes from a shape analysis , this measurement is far from being limited by systematics .
we find the main limiting factor to be the @xmath21xe background .
the expected number of background events ( across the full energy range ) is around 51,130 , from which around 44,000 are from @xmath21xe @xmath22 decays .
this background can be reduced by using lxe depleted in @xmath21xe , though .
the sensitivities for both possibilities are shown in fig .
[ fig : sterile ] ( left ) .
for contrast , we also compare the lxe sensitivity to that of borexino / sox @xcite using a comparable , 5 mci @xmath6cr source ( the sox proposal is based on 10 mci ) .
the complementarity in @xmath47 coverage of the two experiments is evident . in the case of lxe , the relatively high spatial resolution improves sensitivity at high @xmath47 , while for sox , the relatively large detector volume , or range in @xmath40 , improves the reach at low @xmath47 .
it is remarkable that , for a depleted xe experiment , most of the region favored by the gallium anomaly is covered with _
shape information alone_. therefore , if the gallium anomaly is correct this configuration would , with high likelihood , confirm it by a clear observation of the oscillatory pattern .
both the sterile neutrino and @xmath1 mm searches are statistics limited and would be improved by repeated redeployments of the @xmath6cr source .
repeated deployment has a precedent in gallex , which irradiated and deployed the same source material twice @xcite .
we will consider five deployments , each identical in source strength and duration to our previously considered single deployment . in the case of the @xmath1 mm search ,
the sensitivity with increased statistics is remarkable . at 95% cl , assuming a low - energy threshold of 2 kev , the corresponding bound is pushed down to @xmath48 .
if a lower threshold can be achieved , even the astrophysical limit would be surpassed .
the sensitivity to sterile neutrino oscillations with increased statistics is shown in fig .
[ fig : sterile ] ( right ) . in this case
, we assume 90% depleted xe , and show sensitivities from both a shape - only analysis , and an analysis with the shape information plus a 2% uncertainty in the normalization .
as can be seen in the comparison of the two bounds , no major improvement is expected from imposing the normalization constraint , since the information comes from observing the oscillating pattern in the detector . only in case of large @xmath49 , where the oscillation is averaged out ,
would a normalization constraint help . according to our results , after five deployments the full gallium anomaly as well as a sizable region of the reactor anomaly would be covered at 95% cl . obviously ,
with 10,000 - 50,000 @xmath2 elastic scattering events with momentum transfers in the 100kev range a number of precision tests of the electro - weak sector of the sm become possible .
assuming an absolute normalization at the 1% level and statistical errors at or below 1% , overall accuracies for the total cross section of 1 - 2% appear feasible , providing constraints on the weak mixing angle and its running .
to summarize , our results indicate that the combination of a large liquid xenon detector , designed and built to search for dark matter , with a mega - curie scale electron capture neutrino source would provide excellent reach in the search for the neutrino magnetic moment , exceeding the current laboratory bounds by at least a factor of 5 . with repeated source deployments , such an experiment would even be competitive with the best astrophysical limits .
moreover , this combination would allow a test of the reactor and gallium anomalies ; specifically , their interpretation as oscillations due to an ev - scale sterile neutrino .
its reach would be complementary to other source proposals with sensitivity to the oscillating pattern over almost the entire interesting range of @xmath47 .
clearly , a detailed technical feasibility study is required , but so far no major technological obstacles have been identified .
this work has been supported by the u.s .
department of energy under award numbers and .
we would like to thank the authors of ref .
@xcite for sharing with us their results for the global fit of the reactor and gallium anomalies .
m. pospelov , neutrino physics with dark matter experiments and the signature of new baryonic neutral currents , phys.rev .
d84 ( 2011 ) 085008 . http://arxiv.org/abs/1103.3261 [ ] , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.84.085008 [ ] .
m. pospelov , j. pradler , elastic scattering signals of solar neutrinos with enhanced baryonic currents , phys.rev .
d85 ( 2012 ) 113016 . http://arxiv.org/abs/1203.0545 [ ] , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.85.113016 [ ] .
m. pospelov , j. pradler , dark matter or neutrino recoil ?
interpretation of recent experimental results , phys.rev .
d89 ( 2014 ) 055012 . http://arxiv.org/abs/1311.5764 [ ] , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.89.055012 [ ] .
j. abdurashitov , et al . ,
measurement of the response of the russian - american gallium experiment to neutrinos from a cr-51 source , phys.rev .
c59 ( 1999 ) 22462263 . http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9803418 [ ] , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevc.59.2246 [ ] .
v. lebedenko , et al .
, limits on the spin - dependent wimp - nucleon cross - sections from the first science run of the zeplin - iii experiment , phys.rev.lett .
103 ( 2009 ) 151302 . http://arxiv.org/abs/0901.4348 [ ] , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.103.151302 [ ] .
l. baudis , et al .
, neutrino physics with multi - ton scale liquid xenon detectors , journal of cosmology and astroparticle physics 2014 ( 01 ) ( 2014 ) 044 .
[ ] , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1475-7516/2014/01/044 [ ] .
j. albert , et al .
, an improved measurement of the 2@xmath50 half - life of xe-136 with exo-200 , phys.rev . c89 ( 2014 )
http://arxiv.org/abs/1306.6106 [ ] , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevc.89.015502 [ ] .
j. kopp , p. a. n. machado , m. maltoni , t. schwetz , sterile neutrino oscillations : the global picture , jhep 1305 ( 2013 ) 050 .
http://arxiv.org/abs/1303.3011 [ ] , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep05(2013)050 [ ] .
m. a. acero , c. giunti , m. laveder , limits on nu(e ) and anti - nu(e ) disappearance from gallium and reactor experiments , phys.rev .
d78 ( 2008 ) 073009 . http://arxiv.org/abs/0711.4222 [ ] , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.78.073009 [ ] . | in this letter we point out the possibility to study new physics in the neutrino sector using dark matter detectors based on liquid xenon .
these are characterized by very good spatial resolution and extremely low thresholds for electron recoil energies . when combined with a radioactive @xmath0 source , both features in combination allow for a very competitive sensitivity to neutrino magnetic moments and sterile neutrino oscillations .
we find that , for realistic values of detector size and source strength , the bound on the neutrino magnetic moment can be improved by an order of magnitude with respect to the present value .
regarding sterile neutrino searches , we find that most of the gallium anomaly could be explored at the 95% confidence level just using shape information . |
two - neutron correlations in neutron - rich nuclei is presently one of the fore - front subjects in the physics of unstable nuclei . in two - neutron halo nuclei @xcite such as @xmath1li , the dineutron correlation
was theoretically predicted in many studies @xcite and is supported by experiments @xcite .
dineutron correlations are discussed also in light neutron - rich nuclei such as in @xmath2he @xcite and also in medium - heavy neutron - rich nuclei @xcite as well as asymmetric nuclear matter ( for example , refs .
@xcite and references therein ) .
dineutron correlations are characterized by strong spatial correlations of two neutrons in the @xmath0 channel .
although the neutron - neutron interaction is too weak to form a two - body bound state , the attraction in the @xmath0 channel is rather strong as is known from the large scattering length @xmath3 fm @xcite .
originally the possible existence of a dineutron near the surface of nuclei was predicted by migdal in 1972 @xcite . in his work , it was shown that two interacting particles in a potential well can form a bound state if there is a single - particle level with energy close to zero .
this idea describes the binding mechanism of a borromean system and is extended to the dineutron cluster picture and the dineutron correlation in two - neutron halo nuclei .
recently , dineutron correlations have also been discussed from the point of view of bose - einstein condensation ( bec ) , which is considered along similar lines as deuteron and @xmath4-particle condensation suggested in dilute nuclear matter @xcite as well as @xmath4 condensate states in excited states of @xmath5 even nuclei @xcite .
this @xmath6-bec feature stems from the surprisingly small size of cooper pairs recently revealed in the surface of nuclei @xcite . in nuclear systems ,
the @xmath7 @xmath8 pair correlation in the bardeen - cooper - schrieffer ( bcs ) phase has been known to be very important @xcite . from the analysis of the spatial structure of the cooper pair in neutron matter
, a size shrinking is found to occur at finite low density @xcite .
it indicates that the spatially correlated neutron pair may appear in the transition region from weak coupling bcs regime to strong coupling bec regime .
similar bcs - bec crossover features of the spatially correlated neutron pair were predicted also at the surface of medium - heavy nuclei @xcite . since nuclear pairing increases as the size of nuclei shrinks ( @xmath9 mev ) , one may expect that the bec features are enhanced with respect to the infinite matter case .
thus , the spatial structure of neutron pairs at the surface of neutron - rich nuclei attracts presently great interest .
in particular , bcs - bec cross over features are expected to appear in the environment of dilute neutron matter , such as realized in neutron skins @xcite .
this has been put into evidence in recent studies @xcite where it was found that the extension of a @xmath6-cooper pair strongly decreases when going from inside to the surface before expanding again when leaving the nucleus .
the minimum is very pronounced and the cooper pair attains a minimum size of about 2 - 3fm .
this is very small size reaching the dimension of the deuteron , that is of a bound state .
this is also highlighted by the fact that in @xmath1li even the single cooper pair is very small in the surface @xcite .
the fact that @xmath6-cooper pairs resemble a bound state in the nuclear surface and even become appreciably smaller than in low density neutron matter with maximum gap value , is intriguing . in this work
we want to explore the rather extreme hypothesis that the binding mechanism may be influenced by some quasi two - dimensional features . by quasi two - dimensional ( 2d) , we mean that the bound cooper pairs are confined within a surface layer of about @xmath10 fm and that the degree of freedom in radial direction is approximately frozen .
such a scenario could for example be realized by the fact that the density distribution of valence neutrons in very neutron rich and heavy nuclei are in radial , say @xmath11-direction , concentrated in a surface layer and that the density distribution in @xmath11-direction can be approximated by a frozen gaussian packet , whereas the motion of the neutrons within the layer is free . pursuing the picture to its extreme
, one could imagine a slab of low density neutrons where in the transverse ( @xmath11 ) direction only a single @xmath12 level below the fermi energy is active .
such situation also could eventually be relevant in the lasagne phase in neutron star crusts , where a low - density neutron gas may appear as a layer on the surface of the lasagne structure @xcite . in any case
, one could imagine that in the outer layer of a neutron - rich nucleus , the pairing properties of the valence neutrons are more or less decoupled from the inert core part . for example ,
very neutron - rich sn isotopes with @xmath13 could represent such a scenario . a quasi-2d slab of low density neutron matter with the transverse degrees of freedom approximately frozen
could then , as already mentioned , mimic the situation .
we here insist on the 2d character because it is well known that the dimensionality has great influence on bound state formation and , thus , also on the formation of tight cooper pairs .
such quasi-2d paired systems with low density also have been investigated in cold atom physics e.g. hydrogen atoms on a liquid @xmath14he surface and laser cooled atoms trapped in an planar potential @xcite . at any rate , and for the different reasons mentioned above , it seemed to us interesting to study an idealized situation of quasi-2d low density neutron matter realized within an infinitely extended slab .
the study may turn out academic in the end but if future more detailed and not completely trivial investigations will exhibit a link to the surprisingly strong bound state features of cooper pairs in the nuclear surface , mentioned above , our effort will have been worth while . in this respect
it is of interest to mention that , indeed , our study will show that in 2d matter a cooper pair attains a minimal size of about 2 fm whereas in 3d this value is over twice as large . in the present work ,
we investigate properties of neutron pairs in quasi-2d neutron systems by using finite - range effective nuclear forces .
concerning the degree of freedom in the transverse @xmath11 direction perpendicular to the 2d plane , we for simplicity assume a gaussian packet as mentioned above .
we study the two - neutron wave function in this model of quasi-2d system and show that two neutrons form a tightly bound state with a small size when the width @xmath15 of the gaussian in @xmath11-direction is small enough .
we also investigate pairing properties of neutron matter based on the bcs theory . pairing gap and size of the cooper pair in quasi-2d neutron systems
are analyzed , and bcs - bec crossover phenomena are discussed .
the behaviour of @xmath8 pairing in infinite three - dimensional ( 3d ) matter has been extensively investigated based on the bcs theory @xcite for symmetric matter and neutron matter ( for example , refs .
@xcite and references therein ) . as for a slab of nuclear matter , properties of @xmath8 pairing in symmetric nuclear matter have been studied in refs .
@xcite and it was shown that the pairing gap increases at the surface of the slab .
as for @xmath16 pairing , the gradual transition from bcs to bec involving the deuteron formation was predicted in dilute symmetric matter @xcite .
competition of alpha and deuteron condensation was also discussed @xcite .
there are many varieties of bcs calculations of nuclear matter concerning , e.g. , the treatment of single - particle spectra and the pairing interaction . for convenience ,
effective nuclear forces have been used in some calculations on pairing in nuclear matter instead of dealing with realistic bare nuclear forces .
it was shown that the gogny force @xcite , a finite - range effective nuclear force , gives similar behaviour of nuclear matter pairing to that calculated from realistic nuclear forces with the brueckner - hf ( bhf ) approximation , as well as reasonable pairing properties in finite nuclei @xcite .
therefore , we adopt the gogny d1s force in the present bcs calculations .
we also use the minnesota force @xcite which reproduces features of @xmath17-wave @xmath18-@xmath18 scattering in @xmath16 and @xmath8 channels , and nucleus - nucleus scattering in the light nuclear region such as the @xmath4-@xmath4 system , as well as properties of light nuclei .
the minnesota force is often used in structure studies of light neutron - rich nuclei .
this paper is organized as follows . in the next section ,
we explain our simplified model of quasi-2d systems and formulation of the present work .
the effective nuclear forces are described in section [ sec : interaction ] . in section [ sec : results ] , the results obtained for a two - neutron system and neutron matter are shown , and in section [ sec : discussion ] discussions are outlined .
finally , we give a summary and outlook in section [ sec : summary ] .
here we explain our framework of the simplified model of quasi-2d neutron system confined in a slab with a certain thickness .
we first describe the wave function and the hamiltonian for a quasi-2d neutron matter system .
we then explain the isolated two - neutron system and give the formalism for the quasi-2d system within the bcs theory . according to the outline of the introduction
, we propose a model for a system of neutrons confined in a slab with a certain thickness .
we assume that the neutrons in transverse ( @xmath11 ) direction are represented by a simple gaussian packet of size @xmath15 .
as already mentioned , this size may mimic the concentration of the amplitudes of single particle wave functions in a surface layer , where @xmath11 corresponds to the radial direction in finite neutron - rich nuclei .
therefore , the wave function for a single neutron is written as @xmath19 @xmath20,\ ] ] where @xmath21 indicates the coordinates in the slab , @xmath22 , and @xmath23 is the intrinsic spin .
the thickness , i.e. , the rms width , of the slab is @xmath24 . in a similar way
, a @xmath18-neutron wave function is given as @xmath25 here @xmath26 and @xmath27 are the antisymmetrized many - body wave functions .
neutrons are interacting with each other via two - body nuclear forces .
the interaction @xmath28 between two neutrons is the two - body effective nuclear force in the @xmath8 channel . here
@xmath29 . because the @xmath17-wave neutron pair correlation is studied in the present work , only the central part of the effective nuclear force is considered .
the gogny and minnesota forces are represented by a superposition of two gaussians , @xmath30.\label{eq : gogny}\ ] ] we freeze the the degree of freedom in transverse ( @xmath11 ) direction , as described in the introduction . by integrating over @xmath31 coordinates the three - dimensional schrdinger equation for @xmath26 is reduced to the two - dimensional equation for @xmath27 with respect to @xmath32
. then we get the following equation for quasi-2d neutron systems , @xmath33 @xmath34 where the 2d - kinetic term and the 2d - interaction term are @xmath35 @xmath36,\\ z_{b_m}(a)&\equiv&\left(\frac{b_m^2}{b_m^2 + 2a^2}\right)^{1/2 } \label{eq : strength2d}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as seen from ( [ eq : v2d ] ) and ( [ eq : strength2d ] ) , the strength of the two - body interaction @xmath37 in the quasi-2d system depends on the thickness of the slab with the factor @xmath38 .
the factor decreases with the increase of the width parameter @xmath15 . the thickness of the slab is only reflected in a weakening of the interaction for bigger slab sizes in our genuinely two - dimensional model .
these are , of course , strongly simplified , may be oversimplified , assumptions to describe the detailed behaviour of the valence neutrons because the pauli effect from the core should be more complicated and a long tail of weakly bound neutrons may be not so simple . however , it is expected that such effects may effectively be taken into account by a modification of the width parameter @xmath15 . in the present work ,
we analyze properties of neutron pairs in quasi-2d neutron systems for various values of the slab size @xmath15 . for later comparison
we consider the @xmath17-wave relative wave function @xmath39 for an isolated two - neutron system in the quasi-2d space .
it is obtained by solving the schrdinger equation , @xmath40 @xmath41 is the spatial wave function normalized as @xmath42 , and @xmath43 is the intrinsic - spin wave function for the spin - zero channel . it is important to note that in two dimensions , a bound state can form at any arbitrarily small attraction @xcite . since the nuclear force in the @xmath0 channel is attractive at low energy , a two - neutron bound state in the quasi-2d space
is obtained with an arbitrary width @xmath15 .
we calculate the exact solution of the bound state with a gaussian expansion method .
the size of the two - neutron bound state is given as @xmath44 please note that the size in 3d is given as @xmath45 .
in this section , we investigate the behaviour of neutron pairs in quasi-2d infinite neutron matter in the slab by means of the bcs theory , which is equivalent to the hfb approximation in a homogeneous case @xcite .
the application of bcs theory with the gogny force to a slab of nuclear matter was , e.g. , already performed in ref .
@xcite .
let us explain the equations for @xmath0 pairing in quasi-2d neutron matter .
we apply the bcs theory to the 2d schrdinger equation ( [ eq : schrodinger2d ] ) .
the @xmath17-wave pairing gap depends on @xmath46 and it is written as @xmath47 @xmath48 here @xmath49 and @xmath50 denote @xmath46 and @xmath51 , respectively , and @xmath52 is the pairing force , @xmath53.\ ] ] @xmath54 is the hartree - fock potential , @xmath55 where the exchange term is given as @xmath56.\ ] ] the occupation probability is @xmath57 and the chemical potential @xmath58 is determined so as to satisfy the number equation , @xmath59 where @xmath60 and @xmath61 are the density and the fermi momentum in 2d , respectively . in this paper ,
the @xmath61 dependence of pairing properties in neutron matter is discussed as a function of the ratio @xmath62 , where @xmath63 @xmath64 is the fermi momentum at the normal density of 3d symmetric nuclear matter .
the energy per nucleon for the bcs state is @xmath652v^2_{k}+e_{pair},\ ] ] where the integrated pair energy @xmath66 is @xmath67 with @xmath68 the energy per nucleon for the hf state @xmath69 is determined from @xmath70 to analyze the spatial structure of a @xmath6-cooper pair it is useful to study the pair wave function in the coordinate space .
it is defined by the fourier transform of the anomalous density @xmath71 , @xmath72 here @xmath73 , and @xmath74 is the normalization factor so that @xmath75 . the pair size ( coherence length )
@xmath76 is calculated from the root - mean - square distance of the pair wave function @xmath77 where @xmath78 in the low - density limit @xmath79 , the pair wave function @xmath80 and the energy @xmath81
approach @xmath82 and @xmath83 of the two - neutron bound state of section ii.b .
as already mentioned , in this work we use the gogny d1s force @xcite and the minnesota force @xcite . in the @xmath8 channel ,
the gogny force is density independent and is represented by a superposition of two gaussians ( eq . ( [ eq : gogny ] ) ) .
the parameters for the gogny d1s force are , @xmath84 the minnesota force is also given by a sum of finite - range gaussians , @xmath85 we adopt for the exchange - mixture parameter the value of @xmath86 .
then the first ( second ) term gives the two - body force in the @xmath7 @xmath8 ( @xmath87 @xmath16 ) channel . in principle
the gogny force represents an effective in medium force and the minnesota force a phenomenological nuclear force in free space .
it has , however , been shown that the gogny d1s force gives similar behaviour for the @xmath0 pairing gap of symmetric nuclear matter as that calculated from realistic nuclear forces with the bhf+bcs approximation , and also describes pairing properties in finite nuclei @xcite .
the minnesota force reasonably reproduces the @xmath17-wave @xmath18-@xmath18 scattering in the @xmath7 @xmath8 channel as well as the @xmath87 @xmath16 channel .
it also well describes nucleus - nucleus scattering such as the @xmath4-@xmath4 system , as well as properties of light nuclei .
because the minnesota force has no density - dependent term in the @xmath87 @xmath16 channel , it can not describe the saturation properties of symmetric nuclear matter .
however , it gives a similar density dependence of neutron matter energy as the one obtained with the gogny d1s force , as shown later .
the values of the @xmath88-@xmath88 scattering length @xmath89 in the @xmath0 channel obtained with the gogny d1s force and minnesota force are @xmath90 fm and @xmath91 fm , respectively .
these values semiquantitatively agree with the experimental value @xmath3 fm @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : phase ] , the calculated phase shifts of @xmath18-@xmath18 scattering in the @xmath0 channel are shown as well as those obtained with a realistic force . both the gogny d1s and minnesota forces show a reasonable reproduction of the @xmath0-wave scattering .
figure [ fig : fig3d ] shows the properties of infinite 3d neutron matter calculated with the gogny d1s and minnesota forces by means of the bcs theory as well as from the hf calculations
. figures [ fig : fig3d](a ) and [ fig : fig3d](b ) show the the energy ( @xmath92 ) and the integrated pair energy ( @xmath66 ) per nucleon , and the chemical potential ( @xmath58 ) of the bcs state are shown as well as the energy of the hf state ( @xmath93 ) for 3d neutron matter with the gogny d1s and minnesota forces , respectively .
the density dependence of the neutron matter energy obtained with both forces is in reasonable agreement with that calculated with ab initio methods using realistic nuclear forces @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : fig3d](c ) , the pairing gap of neutron matter is shown .
the difference between the gogny d1s and minnesota forces is not large in the low - density region @xmath94 . in the @xmath95 region ,
the minnesota force gives a much smaller pairing gap than the gogny d1s force because it has a larger repulsive core with 108.15 mev hight at @xmath96 .
let us make a comment on the pairing gap in 3d neutron matter investigated in different approaches .
there are many calculations of the pairing gap in nuclear matter using realistic nuclear forces ( for reviews @xcite ) . in the standard bhf+bcs approximation ,
the pairing gap in 3d neutron matter is about 3 mev at the peak position @xmath97 ( figure 12 of ref .
@xcite ) , which is consistent with the pairing gap calculated in bcs theory with the gogny force . in different approximations with medium polarization effects
, a quenching of the pairing gap in neutron matter was suggested @xcite . the size @xmath98 of a cooper pair in 3d neutron matter is plotted as a function of @xmath62 in fig .
[ fig : fig3d](d ) . as is already discussed in refs .
@xcite , the pair size shrinking in 3d neutron matter is seen at finite low @xmath61 .
similarly to the pairing gap , the difference of the pair size between the gogny and minnesota forces is small in the low - density region . in the @xmath99 region ,
the pair size increases more rapidly because of the weaker pairing with the minnesota force than is the case with the gogny d1s force .
as we show later , also in quasi-2d neutron matter these two forces give qualitatively similar pairing behaviour for low @xmath61 .
with both forces , the @xmath100 region ( @xmath101 is the average inter - neutron distance @xmath102 ) appears at finite low @xmath61 , i.e. , at low density .
it shows the bcs - bec crossover feature as suggested by matsuo @xcite .
= 7 cm = 6 cm
in this section , two - neutron correlations in quasi-2d neutron systems are investigated by performing bcs calculations for 2d neutron matter with the gogny d1s and minnesota forces .
the results for various values of @xmath15 of the confinement in the frozen direction ( @xmath11 ) are analyzed , and the behaviour of the cooper pair in quasi-2d neutron matter is discussed as a function of @xmath62 . by solving the schrdinger equation ( [ eq : schro - nn ] ) , the wave function @xmath41 of two isolated neutrons in a quasi-2d system is obtained . while a two - body bound state in 3d forms only at sufficiently strong attraction , a bound state in 2d can form , as already mentioned , at any arbitrarily small attraction . since the @xmath0 nuclear force is attractive at low energy , the two - neutron bound state is formed in quasi-2d systems with arbitrary width @xmath15 .
the energy @xmath103 and the pair size @xmath104 of the bound state for @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 fm are given in table [ tab : rmsr-2n ] .
energy and size of the dineutron decrease as the width @xmath15 becomes small . in the quasi-2d system with a small width of @xmath105 fm ,
the dineutron size is as small as that of the deuteron in 3d . on the other hand , in the quasi-2d system with a width @xmath107 fm ,
the dineutron has a small binding energy , less than 0.1 mev , and a size larger than 20 fm .
we , therefore , see that in our model the width of the slab has a strong influence on the two body correlations .
it is very interesting that , although two neutrons are unbound in 3d , they form a tightly bound dineutron state with a size comparable to deuteron dimensions when they are confined in a sufficiently thin slab .
to form the small - sized dineutron , the reduction of the dimension from three to two is crucial . in the present model , neutrons
are confined in a gaussian packet with respect to the frozen @xmath11-direction . in slab direction , the potential part @xmath37 is given by almost the same form as the original effective nuclear force @xmath108 except for the factor @xmath38 in ( [ eq : v2d ] ) .
this factor is smaller than one , depending on @xmath15 .
for example , for the case of @xmath105 fm and the interaction range @xmath109 fm as with the long - range attractive term of the gogny d1s force , one gets @xmath110 , that is the strength of @xmath37 is smaller than that in the original interaction @xmath108 .
let us remind the reader that the size of the dineutron state is determined by the balance of the kinetic energy and the potential energy . in a 2d system ,
the kinetic effect is weaker and a small - sized two - particle bound state can more easily be formed than in the 3d case . in fig .
[ fig : wf-2n ] , the wave function @xmath41 and the probability density @xmath111 of two isolated neutrons in a quasi-2d system are shown as a function of the relative coordinate @xmath112 . in the quasi-2d system with @xmath105 and @xmath106 fm ,
the probability density has a peak around @xmath113 fm , which shows the significant spatial correlation between the neutrons . in a quasi-2d system with @xmath107 fm ,
the density distributes in a broad region , and the spatial correlation is much weaker . .
[ tab : rmsr-2n ] energy @xmath83 and size @xmath114 of the two - neutron bound state @xmath41 in the quasi-2d system with the width parameter @xmath115 and 4 fm .
the energy and the size @xmath116 for a deuteron in 3d space obtained with the minnesota force is also shown for comparison . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] = 10 cm we now extend the bcs calculations to quasi-2d neutron matter with varying width parameters @xmath15 .
= 6 cm = 10 cm the pairing gap at the fermi momentum @xmath117 as a function of @xmath62 is shown in fig .
[ fig : gap - linear ] .
the gogny d1s and minnesota forces give qualitatively similar results in the low @xmath61 region . at @xmath118 ,
the pairing gap is more suppressed in case of the minnesota force , because , as already mentioned , the short - range repulsion is larger than with the gogny force . for @xmath105 fm , the pairing gap obtained with the gogny d1s force has a peak about 4 mev high at @xmath119 , while that calculated with the minnesota force has a peak @xmath120 mev high at @xmath121 . with the increase of the width @xmath15 of the slab , the pairing gap @xmath122 is quenched because the attraction of the pairing force is weaker in a wider slab . in fig .
[ fig : hfene ] , the energy ( @xmath92 ) and the integrated pair energy ( @xmath66 ) per nucleon , and the chemical potential ( @xmath58 ) of the bcs state are shown as well as the energy of the hf state ( @xmath93 ) calculated without pairing . compared with the energy of 3d neutron matter shown in fig .
[ fig : fig3d ] , one of the striking features of quasi-2d neutron matter is that @xmath92 , @xmath66 , and the chemical potential have finite negative values even in @xmath123 limit .
this is because , in the @xmath123 limit , the system goes to the strong coupling bec limit , where cooper pairs become identical with the two - particle bound state . in this limit ,
@xmath124 and @xmath125 become equal to the dineutron binding energy . as soon as the chemical potential turns negative , there is true binding between the two neutrons and the strong coupling bec feature is born out . therefore , in quasi-2d neutron matter one can , contrary to the 3d case , follow the transition from bec to the bcs regime . on the other hand , because of the same reason , the pairing gap @xmath122 in the quasi-2d neutron matter shows a linear behaviour at the low @xmath61 limit ( fig . [
fig : gap - linear ] ) , while the pairing gap disappears with a horizontal tangent at small @xmath61 in 3d neutron matter ( fig .
[ fig : fig3d](c ) ) .
= 10 cm = 6 cm the pair size @xmath76 in quasi-2d neutron matter is plotted as a function of @xmath62 in fig .
[ fig : distance ] . in the @xmath123 limit ,
the pair size @xmath76 equals the size of the two - neutron bound state ( @xmath114 in ( [ eq : xinn ] ) ) . with the increase of @xmath61 ,
the pair size reduces first before it becomes large again with further increase of @xmath61 .
thus the minimum pair size @xmath76 is found to be smaller than the size @xmath114 of the isolated two - neutron bound state in the quasi-2d system .
this size reduction of the @xmath6-cooper pair indicates the enhancement of the dineutron correlation at finite low @xmath61 , i.e. due to the existence of a fermi sea .
it should be pointed out that the pair size significantly depends also on the width @xmath15 of the slab .
a striking difference of the pair size between the quasi-2d and 3d neutron matter is that the pair size at @xmath123 limit is finite in the quasi-2d neutron matter while it becomes infinite in the 3d neutron matter . in the 3d neutron matter
, the cooper pair size @xmath98 has a minimum around @xmath126 , and it rapidly increases as @xmath61 goes 0 .
interestingly , the size shrinking of the cooper pair in quasi-2d neutron matter has a close analogy with that of the deuteron in 3d symmetric matter predicted by lombardo and schuck @xcite .
as mentioned above , the spatial correlation of cooper pairs enhances at finite low @xmath61 in quasi-2d neutron matter with a small width @xmath15 , where the bcs - bec crossover phenomena is expected . to discuss pairing properties from the point of view of the bcs - bec crossover
, it is useful to compare the pair size @xmath76 with the average inter - neutron distance @xmath127 as discussed in the works for 3d neutron matter @xcite .
the ratio @xmath128 in quasi-2d neutron matter is shown in fig .
[ fig : rmsr - r ] as well as @xmath129 for the 3d neutron matter . strictly speaking , because the transition from the weak coupling bcs phase to strong coupling bec is known to be a crossover @xcite , there is no critical boundary of the transition .
however , we consider that bcs - bec crossover features arise when the cooper pair size is smaller than the average inter - neutron distance by adopting the same criterion as in refs . @xcite . with this criterion
, the bcs - bec crossover phenomena appears at @xmath130 in quasi-2d neutron matter with @xmath105 fm , and @xmath131 for @xmath106 fm , while in 3d neutron matter it is seen at @xmath132 . in the quasi-2d neutron matter , the ratio @xmath128 monotonically deceases as @xmath61 becomes small , and finally the system goes to the strong coupling bec limit . to reveal the features of bcs - bec crossover it is also useful to analyze the spatial structure of the @xmath6-cooper pair wave function as done in refs .
figures [ fig : wf-2d - rpp ] and [ fig : wf - phi ] show the probability density @xmath133 and pair wave function @xmath134 of the cooper pair in the quasi-2d neutron matter .
let us discuss the results for @xmath106 fm . at low @xmath61 such as @xmath135 and @xmath136 ( fig .
[ fig : wf-2d - rpp](b4 ) and ( b3 ) ) , the spatial correlation of the cooper pair is strong and it indicates a bec - like dineutron pair . from @xmath135 to @xmath136 ,
the first peak becomes narrow due to the pauli principle , stemming from the other cooper pairs .
consequently , the size shrinking of the dineutron occurs at a finite low @xmath61 , as mentioned . with further increase of @xmath61 ,
the nodal structure appears at @xmath137 which indicates the transition from the bcs - bec crossover to the bcs regime , and at @xmath138 the short - range correlation disappears as in the weak coupling bcs phase . the pair wave functions in quasi-2d neutron matter with @xmath106 fm are shown in fig .
[ fig : wf - phi ] .
we also show the two - neutron wave function @xmath41 for the dineutron bound state in the quasi-2d system and @xmath139 in 3d neutron matter . in the @xmath123 limit ,
the pair wave function @xmath134 becomes equal to the isolated two - neutron wave function @xmath41 of the dineutron state in case of quasi-2d neutron matter , while @xmath139 in 3d neutron matter becomes infinitely broad because there is no two - neutron bound state in a 3d system .
= 16 cm = 12 cm
in this section we tentatively associate the strong pairing correlations of valence neutrons in neutron - rich nuclei with the ones in a 2d system . it has recently become evident that in neutron - rich or neutron halo nuclei pairing correlations may show a strong maximum in the surface .
this is for instance evidenced by the fact that the size of the cooper pairs has a sharp minimum in the surface .
this feature has been shown to hold true in the case of a single cooper pair @xcite as well as in cases of many cooper pairs @xcite .
though for the moment , it can not be excluded that the pronounced small cooper pair sizes in the nuclear surface is due to a somewhat trivial , i.e. geometrical effect@xcite , we here make the hypothesis that this is due to a real strong correlation effect , due to the presence of a surface and hence of a 2d influence . the valence nucleons may be confined in a surface shell for different reasons .
for example , if valence neutrons are , in a heavy nucleus , distributed around a high lying principal shell , the corresponding density distribution , for instance if the shell does not contain an @xmath17 wave , may be concentrated in the surface region .
even though low angular momentum orbits with radial nodes have some strength distribution in the inner region , their probability amplitudes may show peak structure in the surface , and therefore , the pairing is expected to be induced by the surface neutrons due to the possible mixing of many states having significant overlap of their radial part in the surface region . on the other hand
it is also well known that finite size _ enhances _ pairing .
this is already documented by the fact that the nuclear gap varies on average like @xmath140 mev , that is the presence of a surface certainly plays a role .
this finite size enhancement is a quite subtle effect as theoretical investigations show @xcite and implies several competing effects .
how much the scenario is influenced by quasi 2d features is still an open question but an interesting and suggestive hypothesis which we wanted to explore in this work .
so one may consider that the strongly correlated cooper pairs with about a rms radius of 2 fm live in a surface sheet about @xmath10 fm across . in section [ sec : formulation ] we mimicked the transverse motion of the neutrons by a simple frozen gaussian @xmath141 .
the motion perpendicular to @xmath11 is considered as planar .
this is , of course , a highly idealized representation of the situation as mentioned several times .
it may nevertheless capture some 2d features which possibly underly the strong pairing correlations in the neutron skin of neutron - rich nuclei . in the previous analysis of pair size in quasi 2d neutron matter in section [ sec :
results ] , the bcs - bec crossover may occur only in dilute 2d matter for densities @xmath142 @xmath143 .
let us estimate how many small sized cooper pairs can condensate in an area @xmath144 of the nuclear surface .
for the dineutron condensation , more than one pair should exist at least . from the condition @xmath142 @xmath143
, two dineutrons can condensate in the surface area for @xmath145 fm , and four dineutrons for @xmath146 fm .
recently , two - neutron correlations in neutron - skin nuclei have been investigated in light nuclei such as @xmath2he and @xmath147c @xcite as well as medium - heavy nuclei @xcite .
@xmath2he is considered to be a neutron - skin nucleus having four valence neutrons surrounding an @xmath4 core , and therefore this nucleus is one of the simple examples to discuss neutron pair correlations in neutron skins . in refs .
@xcite , it was argued that the @xmath2he ground state has spin - zero two - neutron correlations . from the above - mentioned discussion of quasi-2d neutron matter
, the correlation in the ground state is expected to be of bcs - type rather than in the bcs - bec crossover region , because the valence neutron distribution concentrates in the surface with a distance @xmath148 fm , which is smaller than the bcs - bec crossover condition @xmath145 fm for the condensation of two dineutrons . instead of the ground state , the possible existence of an excited state @xmath2he(@xmath149 ) with a dilute gas - like state of dineutrons was suggested by one of the authors @xcite . according to the theoretical results of ref .
@xcite , the dineutrons exist around the region with @xmath150 fm which satisfies the above - mentioned condition for the bcs - bec crossover .
therefore , this state could have bec - like dineutrons at the surface . in medium - heavy nuclei ,
the spatial structure of spin - zero neutron pairing at the surface was investigated based on hfb calculations in refs .
@xcite . to discuss two - neutron correlations in the neutron skin in connection with quasi-2d neutron matter
, one should analyze the radial and angular behaviour separately and focus on the angular correlations ( opening angle ) of neutron pairing , as well as on the size of the cooper pairs .
the transition from bcs phase to bcs - bec crossover is characterized by the change of the pair wave function from a weak - coupling nodal structure to an enhanced single bound state like peak .
if such a structure change is found in the angular behaviour it may be an indication of the bcs - bec crossover , while a clear evidence may not be seen in the radial structure because it might be affected by pauli effect from constituent neutrons of the core .
the spatial structure of spin - zero neutron pairing is displayed in ref .
@xcite , which shows that the nodal structure along the angular direction is seen inside from the surface and it disappears on the outer side of the surface . more detailed analysis of the angular behaviour is requested . on the other hand , a good measure of the correlations
also is the size of the cooper pairs .
their rms radius seems systematically very small in the outer part of the nuclear surface @xcite , that is much smaller than the smallest value in homogeneous 3d matter .
whether this also always goes along with a maximum in the pair correlations at the same place in a finite nucleus , remains to be seen .
let us also comment on other effects omitted in the present model of infinite quasi-2d neutron matter . at the surface of a realistic finite nuclear system ,
valence neutrons feel the centrifugal force and the spin - orbit force which may work so as to break @xmath6-cooper pairs .
periodicity condition on the spherical surface is another effect to be considered .
two - neutron correlations have extensively been investigated in two - neutron halo nuclei by means of three - body models of two neutrons and a core @xcite .
recently , it was suggested that the internal two - neutron wave function analyzed as a function of the distance @xmath151 from the nuclear center shows behaviour similar to the pair wave function of 3d neutron matter in the bcs - bec crossover region @xcite . in the analysis of ref .
@xcite , the inter - neutron wave function has a nodal structure at small @xmath151 , and it shows enhancement of the spatial correlations with increasing @xmath151 .
moreover , in a further analysis of the neutron pair in @xmath1li , size shrinking was found at the surface @xcite .
it was found that there the pair is as small as 3 fm at @xmath152 fm @xcite .
the formation of the small sized dineutron at the surface of @xmath1li may be understood with the picture of a quasi-2d neutron system . as shown in ref .
@xcite with a three - body model , the spin - zero component of two neutrons shows a strong angular correlation and its distribution concentrates at the surface with @xmath153 fm .
the situation corresponds to the quasi-2d neutron where the valence neutrons are confined at the surface region and the neutron pair is formed due to the angular correlation .
it may be interpreted as the reduction of the dimension from three to two , being crucial for the small - sized neutron pair in two - neutron halo nuclei . at the small @xmath151 region ,
i.e. near the core , the size of the neutron pair increases and nodal structure appears in the relative wave function in the three - body model .
this is because the pauli effect from the constituent neutrons of @xmath154li core raises the fermi momentum of the valence neutrons .
this behaviour is similar to the weakening of the pair correlation in the bcs region at @xmath155 in the quasi-2d neutron matter . in spite of the analogous behaviour of the neutron pair in @xmath1li to that of the cooper pair in the quasi-2d neutron matter
, one should keep in mind that two - neutron halo nuclei has only one pair of neutrons and the phenomena there is not regarded as the cooper pair condensation in the bcs picture .
several investigations have , however , revealed that the features of a single cooper pair and the ones of a cooper pair embedded in several others are not drastically different .
it is also interesting to consider two - proton correlation in proton - rich nuclei in analogy to the two - neutron correlation in neutron - rich nuclei .
while the energy of infinite proton matter diverges without charge neutrality , proton - rich matter such as proton halo or proton skin structure can exist in finite nuclei .
moreover , since two - proton decays are allowed from some proton - rich nuclei such as @xmath156be,@xmath2c,@xmath157o and @xmath158ne @xcite , more direct information of @xmath8 pair correlation could be experimentally obtained than for the case of neutron - rich nuclei . in the same way as neutron systems
, we calculate a wave function @xmath159 for the two - proton bound state in quasi-2d systems .
coulomb force ( @xmath160 ) is added to the two - body effective nuclear forces . in fig .
[ fig : wf-2p ] , the obtained two - proton wave functions in the @xmath0-wave channel are shown in comparison with those of the dineutron state .
because of the coulomb force , the spatial correlation of the @xmath8 pair is slightly more suppressed in the two - proton system than in the two - neutron system .
however , the wave functions for @xmath105 fm and @xmath106 fm still have a pronounced peak .
it suggests that the spatial correlation of the @xmath8 pair also is present in proton systems .
singlet @xmath17 ( @xmath0 ) @xmath6 correlations in quasi-2d neutron systems were studied in a simplified model of neutrons confined in a slab with a certain thickness . the finite - range effective nuclear forces , the gogny d1s and minnesota forces , were adopted for the study .
the strength of the two - body interaction in the quasi-2d systems depends on the width @xmath15 of the slab .
namely , the interaction is stronger for thinner slabs than for wider ones . when the width of a slab is small enough , e.g. around @xmath105 fm , two neutrons form a tightly bound dineutron with a size as small as the deuteron size .
the behaviour of the @xmath6-cooper pair in the quasi-2d neutron matter was investigated by means of the bcs theory . in quasi-2d neutron matter
, the transition region of the bcs - bec crossover appears at @xmath130 and for @xmath161 fm .
the size shrinking of the cooper pair occurs at finite low @xmath61 because of the pauli effect .
it is also important to note that , as the width @xmath15 of the slab decreases , the pair correlation in 2d is enhanced and the cooper pair size becomes small because of the stronger attraction in the thinner slab .
this is one of the characteristics different from 3d . in particular
, the reduction of the dimension from 3d to 2d is crucial to form the strongly correlated neutron pair .
the chemical potential becomes negative for @xmath162 and , therefore , there is true two - neutron binding in quasi-2d neutron matter and a genuine bec regime is born out .
the relation of the quasi-2d neutron matter to finite neutron - rich nuclei was also discussed .
several studies of the past have revealed that the size of cooper pairs changes very substantially from inside to outside of a nucleus @xcite .
the subject has been taken up again more recently and the radius dependence of a neutron - neutron ( @xmath6 ) cooper pair has been investigated more systematically @xcite .
it thereby turned out that the old believe that the size of a cooper pair is of the order of the diameter of a large nucleus must be revisited when considered locally , i.e. , as a function of the nuclear radius .
namely , detailed bcs calculations with the d1s gogny force have shown that the rms radius of an @xmath6-cooper pair , though indeed large in the interior , becomes very small in the outer surface of a nucleus , where the density is low , before expanding again when leaving the nucleus .
the minimum extension of a cooper pair attains a size as small as 2 fm , that is the same as the size of a deuteron , a bound state .
although the variation of the pair radius as a function of the density qualitatively follows the one of infinite matter , a factor of two reduction of the pair diameter with respect to the homogeneous case is a quite surprisingly strong effect which calls for an explanation .
we considered this pair size shrinking in the surface of neutron - rich nuclei with the present calculations of quasi-2d neutron systems , based on the hypothesis that the valence neutrons in a neutron - rich nucleus live in radial direction in a surface sheet about @xmath10 fm across because the wave functions of the active shell are essentially concentrated in the surface while the nucleons are free to move within the sheet .
the idea behind this scenario is that the neutrons in the surface sheet are essentially constrained to a two - dimensional world which could give a certain clue to the smallness of the cooper pairs , since in two dimensions even an isolated @xmath6 pair forms a bound state .
pursuing this idea , we further idealized the situation assuming a planar slab of neutrons where for simplicity the motion perpendicular to the slab is frozen into a gaussian wave packet in order to simulate the surface concentration of the valence neutrons in radial direction .
freezing the perpendicular motion means that the neutrons are two - dimensional in the direction of the slab .
the thickness of the slab only influences the strength of the pairing force , as already mentioned above .
we , indeed , find that for reasonable slab thicknesses of @xmath163 fm , the pair radius is of the order of 2@xmath1643 fm in agreement with realistic 3d hfb calculations @xcite .
we are , of course , aware of the fact that our model may be strongly oversimplified and further studies are required in order to ascertain whether a 2d aspect indeed helps to interpret the occurrence of astoundingly small cooper pairs in the nuclear surface .
one also should keep in mind that a local picture may be a little too simple in the sense that the pair size certainly fluctuates a lot .
nevertheless , a classical picture often grasps a good deal of reality , even in so tiny quantum object as nuclei .
neutron pairs much smaller than the dimension of a nucleus may approximately be considered as bosons and a strong coupling bose - einstein condensation scenario of @xmath6 pairs may be realized in the surface of neutron - rich nuclei .
bound state like cooper pairs in the nuclear surface may also allow to reinterpret neutron transfer reactions into superfluid nuclei which are known to have a strongly enhanced cross section @xcite .
2d aspects may also be relevant in the lasagne phase in neutron star crust . in practical application to such systems
, one should extend the model by taking into account finite temperature and also excitation in the @xmath11-direction for higher neutron density .
bcs and bec problems of two - dimensional fermion systems have been discussed also in the field of condensed matter physics in relation to electron systems and atomic systems @xcite .
phenomena of bec and bcs - bec crossover in quasi-2d systems of trapped gases have been discussed in recent works @xcite , and it has been suggested that the condensation in a quasi-2d gas is sensitive to the frequency @xmath165 of the confinement in the `` frozen '' direction .
this feature may have an analogy to the present results for the quasi-2d neutron matter .
the authors would like to thank k. hagino , h. horiuchi , n. pillet , g. rpke , h. sagawa and n. sandulescu for valuable discussions on nuclear pairing and cooper pairs in the nuclear surface .
fruitful discussions during the yipqs international molecule workshop held at yukawa institute for theoretical physics ( yitp ) in october 2008 were useful to complete this work .
the computational calculations of this work were performed by supercomputers at yitp and also by supercomputer projects of high energy accelerator research organization ( kek ) .
this work was supported by grant - in - aid for scientific research from japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps ) .
it is also supported by the grant - in - aid for the global coe program `` the next generation of physics , spun from universality and emergence '' from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) of japan .
0 i.tanihata et al . ,
* 55 * , 2676 ( 1985 ) .
p. g. hansen and b. jonson , europhys .
lett . * 4 * , 409 ( 1987 ) .
g. f. bertsch and h. esbensen , annals phys . * 209 * , 327 ( 1991 ) .
m. v. zhukov , b. v. danilin , d. v. fedorov , j. m. bang , i. j. thompson and j. s. vaagen , phys .
* 231 * , 151 ( 1993 ) .
h. esbensen , g. f. bertsch and k. hencken , phys .
c * 56 * , 3054 ( 1997 ) .
a538 * , 355c ( 1992 ) .
s. aoyama , k. kat , and k. ikeda , prog .
suppl . * 142 * , 35 ( 2001 ) ; t. myo , s. aoyama , k. kat , and k. ikeda , prog .
. phys . * 108 * , 133 ( 2002 ) .
t. myo , s. aoyama , k. kat and k. ikeda , prog .
phys . *
108 * , 133 ( 2002 ) .
t. myo , s. aoyama , k. kat and k. ikeda , phys .
* b576 * , 281 ( 2003 ) . k. hagino and h. sagawa , phys .
c * 72 * , 044321 ( 2005 ) .
t. myo , k. kat , h. toki , k. ikeda , phys .
c * 76 * , 024305 ( 2007 ) .
et al . _ ,
lett . * 70 * , 730 ( 1993 ) .
d. sackett _
et al . _ ,
c * 48 * , 118 ( 1993 ) .
s. shimoura _
et al . _ ,
. lett . * b348 * , 29 ( 1995 ) .
m. zinser _
_ , nucl . phys . *
a619 * , 151 ( 1997 ) .
t. nakamura , _ et al .
lett . * 96 * , 252502 ( 2006 ) .
y. kanada - enyo , phys .
c * 76 * , 044323 ( 2007 ) .
n. itagaki , m. ito , k. arai , s. aoyama and t. kokalova , phys .
c * 78 * , 017306 ( 2008 ) .
k. hagino , n. takahashi and h. sagawa , phys .
c * 77 * , 054317 ( 2008 ) .
m. matsuo , k. mizuyama and y. serizawa , phys .
c * 71 * , 064326 ( 2005 ) .
n. pillet , n. sandulescu and p. schuck , phys .
c * 76 * , 024310 ( 2007 ) .
m. baldo , j. cugmon , a. lejeune and u. lombardo , nucl . phys . * a515 * , 409 ( 1990 ) . t. takatsuka and r. tamagaki , prog .
theor . phys . suppl .
* 112 * , 27 ( 1993 ) .
f. v. de blasio , m. hjorth - jensen , o. elgaroy , l. engvik , g. lazzari , m. baldo and h. j. schulze , phys .
c * 56 * , 2332 ( 1997 ) .
d. j. dean and m. hjorth - jensen , rev .
* 75 * , 607 ( 2003 ) .
m. baldo , e. e. sapershtein and s. v. tolokonnikov , nucl .
* a749 * , 42 ( 2005 ) . m. matsuo , phys .
c * 73 * , 044309 ( 2006 ) .
j. margueron , h. sagawa and k. hagino , phys .
c * 76 * , 064316 ( 2007 ) .
a. a. isayev , phys .
c * 78 * , 014306 ( 2008 ) .
g. f. de tramond and b. gabioud , phys .
c * 36 * , 691 ( 1987 ) .
a. b. migdal , yad . fiz . * 16 * , 427 ( 1972 ) ; sov .
* 16 * , 238 ( 1973 ) .
h. bando and a. kuriyama , prog .
extra number , 69 ( 1968 ) .
m. baldo , u. lombardo and p. schuck , phys . rev .
c * 52 * , 975 ( 1995 ) .
g. ropke , a. schnell , p. schuck and p. nozieres , phys .
lett . * 80 * , 3177 ( 1998 ) .
u. lombardo , p. nozieres , p. schuck , h. j. schulze and a. sedrakian , phys .
c * 64 * , 064314 ( 2001 ) .
a. tohsaki , h. horiuchi , p. schuck and g. ropke , phys .
lett . *
87 * , 192501 ( 2001 ) .
t. yamada and p. schuck , phys .
c * 69 * , 024309 ( 2004 ) .
y. funaki , a. tohsaki , h. horiuchi , p. schuck and g. ropke , phys .
c * 67 * , 051306(r ) ( 2003 ) . p. ring and p. schuck , _ the nuclear many - body problem _
( springer - verlag , new york , 1980 ) .
d.m . brink and r.a .
broglia , _ nuclear superfluidity _
( cambridge university press , new york , 2005 ) .
i. tanihata , d. hirata , t. kobayashi , s. shimoura , k. sugimoto and h. toki , phys .
lett . *
b289 * , 261 ( 1992 ) . t. suzuki _ et al .
_ , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 3241 ( 1995 ) .
a. ozawa , et al .
, nucl.phys . *
a691 * , 599(2001 ) . k. hagino , h. sagawa and p. schuck , arxiv:0812.0658 [ nucl - th ] .
d. g. ravenhall , c. j. pethick and j. r. wilson , phys . rev
. lett . * 50 * , 2066 ( 1983 ) . c. p. lorenz , d. g. ravenhall and c. j. pethick , phys .
lett . * 70 * , 379 ( 1993 ) .
k. oyamatsu , nucl . phys . *
a561 * , 431 ( 1993 ) .
g. watanabe , k. sato , k. yasuoka and t. ebisuzaki , phys .
c * 66 * , 012801(r ) ( 2002 ) ; phys .
c * 68 * , 035806 ( 2003 ) .
a. i. safonov , s. a. vasilyev , i. s. yasnikov , i. i. lukashevich and s. jaakkola , phys .
* 81 * , 4545 ( 1998 ) .
d. s. petrov , m. holzmann , and g.v.shlyapnikov , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 2551 ( 2000 ) .
j. bardeen , l. n. cooper and j. r. schrieffer , j. bardeen , l. n. cooper and j. r. schrieffer , phys .
* 108 * 1175 ( 1957 ) .
m. baldo , u. lombardo , e. saperstein and m. zverev , phys .
* b459 * , 437 ( 1999 ) . m. farine and p. schuck ,
* b459 * , 444 ( 1999 ) . m. baldo , m. farine , u. lombardo , e. e. saperstein , p. schuck and m. v. zverev , eur .
j. a * 18 * , 17 ( 2003 ) .
s. s. pankratov , m. baldo , u. lombardo , e. e. saperstein and m. v. zverev , nucl .
* a811 * , 127 ( 2008 ) .
u. lombardo and p. schuck , phys . rev .
c * 63 * , 038201 ( 2001 ) .
j. decharge and d. gogny , phys .
c * 21 * , 1568 ( 1980 ) .
j. f. berger , m. girod , and d. gogny , comput .
. commun . * 63 * , 365 ( 1991 ) .
h. kucharek , p. ring , p. schuck , r. bengtsson and m. girod , phys .
* b216 * , 249 ( 1989 ) .
e. garrido , p. sarriguren , e. moya de guerra and p. schuck , phys .
c * 60 * , 064312 ( 1999 ) .
d. r. thompson , m. lemere and y. c. tang nucl .
a286 * , 53 ( 1977 ) .
l. d. landau and e. m. lifshitz , _ quantum mechanics : non relativistic theory _
, course of theoretical physics vol . * 3 * ( pergamon , new york , 1989 ) .
a. akmal , v. r. pandharipande and d. g. ravenhall , phys .
c * 58 * , 1804 ( 1998 ) .
j. carlson , j. .
j. morales , v. r. pandharipande and d. g. ravenhall , phys .
c * 68 * , 025802 ( 2003 ) .
schulze , j. cugnon , a. lejeune , m. baldo , and u. lombardo , phys .
b375 * , 1 ( 1996 ) .
u. lombardo , p. schuck and w. zuo , phys .
c * 64 * , 021301(r ) ( 2001 ) . c. shen , u. lombardo , p. schuck , w. zuo and n. sandulescu , phys .
c * 67 * , 061302(r ) ( 2003 ) .
u. lombardo , p .
schuck and c. shen , nucl .
a731 * , 392 ( 2004 ) . l. g. cao , u. lombardo and p. schuck , phys .
c * 74 * , 064301 ( 2006 ) .
v. g. j. stoks , r. a. m. klomp , c. p. f. terheggen and j. j. de swart , phys .
c * 49 * , 2950 ( 1994 ) .
m. randeria , j .-
m . duan , and l .- y .
shieh , phys .
lett . * 62 * , 981 ( 1989 ) ; phys .
b * 41 * , 327 ( 1990 ) . v. m. loktev , r. n. quick and s. g. sharapov , phys . rep . * 349 * , 1 ( 2001 ) . f. pistolesi and g. c. strinati , phys . rev .
b * 53 * , 15168 ( 1996 ) . j. r. engelbrecht , m. randeria and c. a. r. sade melo , phys . rev .
b * 55 * , 15153 ( 1997 ) .
t. papenbrock and g. f. bertsch , phys .
c * 59 * , 2052 ( 1999 ) .
p. nozieres and s. schmitt - rink , j. low . temp .
phys . * 59 * 195 ( 1985 ) .
k. hagino , h. sagawa , j. carbonell and p. schuck , phys .
lett . * 99 * , 022506 ( 2007 ) .
n. sandulescu , private communication .
m. farine , f. w. j. hekking , p. schuck and x. vias , phys .
b * 68 * , 024507 ( 2003 ) .
d. baye , nucl .
* a627 * , 305 ( 1997 ) . k. arai , y. ogawa , y. suzuki and k. varga , prog .
suppl . no.*142 * , 97 ( 2001 ) .
p. descouvemont , e. m. tursunov and d. baye , nucl .
* a765 * , 370 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0512016 ] .
l. v. grigorenko , r. c. johnson , i. g. mukha , i. j. thompson and m. v. zhukov , phys .
c * 64 * , 054002 ( 2001 ) .
f. c. barker , phys .
c * 68 * , 054602 ( 2003 ) .
i. mukha _ et al .
_ , phys .
c * 77 * , 061303(r ) ( 2008 ) . w. von oertzen , a. vitturi , rep .
. phys . * 64 * , 1427 ( 2001 ) . | two - neutron correlation in the @xmath0 channel in quasi two - dimensional ( 2d ) neutron systems at zero temperature is studied by means of the bcs theory with finite - range effective nuclear forces .
the dineutron correlation in low density neutron systems confined in an infinite slab is investigated in a simplified model that neutron motion of one direction is frozen . when the slab is thin enough , two neutrons form a tightly bound dineutron with a small size in the quasi-2d system , and a bose dineutron gas is found in low density limit .
with increase of fermi momentum , the neutron system changes from the bose - gas phase to the superfluid cooper pair phase .
the density dependence of the neutron pairing shows the bcs - bec crossover phenomena at finite low - density region . in the transition region , the size shrinking of neutron pair and enhancement of pairing gap are found .
the relation to dineutron correlation at surface of neutron - rich nuclei is also discussed . |
by an _ octant _ , in this paper we mean an open subset of @xmath1 of the form @xmath4 and the point @xmath5 is called the _ apex _ of the octant . in @xcite
we have shown that every @xmath6-fold covering of a set in @xmath1 by a finite number of octants decomposes into two coverings , i.e. , if every point of some set @xmath7 is contained in at least @xmath6 members of a finite family of octants @xmath8 , then we can partition this family into two subfamilies , @xmath9 , such that every point of @xmath7 is contained in an octant from @xmath10 and in an octant from @xmath11 .
we improve this constant in the following theorem , proved in section [ sec : upper ] .
[ thm:9 ] every @xmath0-fold covering of a point set in @xmath1 by finitely many octants decomposes into two coverings .
the improvement comes from a careful modification of our original proof for @xmath6-fold covering , while the framework remains essentially the same .
the equivalent dual version ( see @xcite ) of this statement is that any finite set of points in @xmath1 can be colored with two colors such that any octant containing at least @xmath0 points contains both colors .
it was discovered in a series of papers by cardinal et al .
@xcite and by us @xcite that this bound implies several further results for which earlier only doubly exponential bounds were known @xcite .
we denote by @xmath12 the smallest integer such that every @xmath12-fold covering of a finite point set in @xmath1 by octants decomposes into two coverings , thus theorem [ thm:9 ] states that @xmath13 . using this new bound ,
the degrees of the polynomials in the following theorems have also been improved .
( a diagram describing the connection between different coloring problems can be found later in figure [ fig : diagram ] . ) for any positive integer @xmath14 and any given triangle @xmath15 , any finite set of points can be colored with @xmath14 colors such that any homothet of @xmath15 containing at least @xmath16 , thus @xmath17 points , contains all @xmath14 colors . for any positive integer @xmath14 , any @xmath18-fold covering of a subset of @xmath19 by
finitely many octants can be decomposed into @xmath14 coverings .
this theorem also has the following straight - forward corollaries .
* for any positive integer @xmath14 , any finite set of points in @xmath1 can be colored with @xmath14 colors so that any octant with @xmath20 points contains all @xmath14 colors . * for any positive integer @xmath14 , any @xmath20-fold covering of a finite point set in @xmath3 by homothets of a triangle decomposes into @xmath14 coverings .
* for any positive integer @xmath14 , any @xmath20-fold covering of a finite point set in @xmath3 by bottomless rectangles decomposes into @xmath14 coverings . here
bottomless rectangle _ refers to a subset of the plane of the form @xmath21 . note that it has been proved by asinowski et al .
@xcite that for any positive integer @xmath14 , any finite set of points in @xmath3 can be colored with @xmath14 colors such that any bottomless rectangle containing at least @xmath22 points contains all @xmath14 colors ( they also proved the lower bound that @xmath22 can not be changed to @xmath23 in this statement ) . a very general conjecture ( * ? ? ?
* problem 6.7 and after ) implies that all the above parameters can also be replaced by @xmath24 .
we also give the following construction , which will be presented in section [ sec : lower ] .
[ thm : lower ] for every triangle @xmath15 there is a finite point set @xmath7 such that for every two - coloring of @xmath7 there is a translate of @xmath15 that contains exactly @xmath2 points and all of these have the same color .
this also implies @xmath25 , as the intersection of octants with the plane @xmath26 give all homothets of the triangle @xmath27
@xmath28 @xmath29 , thus if we place the finite point set @xmath7 on this plane , then for any two - coloring of @xmath7 there will be an octant with exactly @xmath2 points , all of the same color .
we end the paper by discussing problems about coloring ordered intervals that turn out to be equivalent to the problem of decomposing octants , in section [ sec : int ] .
the dual version of theorem [ thm:9 ] is that any finite set of points can be colored with two colors such that any octant containing at least @xmath0 points , contains both colors .
this is equivalent to the original problem .
we will prove the dynamic planar version of the dual problem , which is the following .
a _ quadrant _ or _
wedge _ is a subset of the plane of the form @xmath30 .
we have to two - color a finite ordered planar point set @xmath31 such that for every @xmath32 every quadrant that contains at least @xmath0 points from @xmath33 contains both colors .
this dynamic planar version is also equivalent to the original problem , for the details , see @xcite .
( briefly , the equivalence of the two problems is implied by the following containment - reversing bijections : an octant with apex @xmath5 is bijected to the point @xmath34 that `` appears '' at time @xmath35 , while a point with coordinates @xmath36 is bijected to a mirrored quadrant with apex @xmath36 , i.e. , to the subset @xmath37 . ) a way to imagine this problem is that the points `` appear '' in order and at step @xmath32 we have to color the new point , @xmath38 .
this is impossible to do in an online setting @xcite , i.e. , without knowing in advance which points will come in which order .
moreover , it was shown by cardinal et al .
@xcite that such a coloring is even impossible in a so - called _ semi - online _ model , where points can be colored at any time after their arrival as long as every octant with @xmath0 ( or any other constant number of ) points contains both colors .
our strategy , developed in @xcite , builds a forest on the points such that any time any quadrant containing at least @xmath0 points contains two adjacent points from the same tree - component .
therefore , after all the points arrived , any proper two - coloring of the forest will be such that any octant containing at least @xmath0 points contains both colors .
: the possible relations of two points . ] : @xmath39 is below the staircase , @xmath40 is above the staircase , @xmath41 and @xmath42 are neighboring staircase points and @xmath41 is the left neighbor of @xmath42 . ]
we start by introducing some notation ( see also figure [ fig : comparable ] ) .
[ def : comparable ] we say that point @xmath43 is _ northwest _ ( in short nw ) from point @xmath44 if and only if @xmath45 and @xmath46 . in this case we also say that @xmath40 is _ southeast _ ( in short se ) from @xmath39 and that @xmath39 and @xmath40 are _
similarly , we say that point @xmath43 is _ southwest _ ( in short sw ) from point @xmath44 if and only if @xmath45 and @xmath47 .
in this case we also say that @xmath40 is _ northeast _ ( in short ne ) from @xmath39 and that @xmath39 and @xmath40 are _
we can suppose that all points have different coordinates , as by a slight perturbation we can only get more subsets of the points contained in a quadrant ( without losing others ) . at any step @xmath32 , we define a graph @xmath48 ( which is actually a forest ) on the points of @xmath49 and a vertex set @xmath50 of pairwise incomparable points called the _ staircase _ , recursively .
at the beginning @xmath51 is the empty graph and @xmath52 is the empty set . a point on the staircase is called a _
stair - point_. thus , before the @xmath53 step we have a graph @xmath54 on the points of @xmath55 and a set @xmath56 of pairwise incomparable points . in the @xmath53 step
we add @xmath38 to our point set obtaining @xmath49 and we will define the new staircase , @xmath50 , and also the new graph , @xmath48 , containing @xmath54 as a subgraph . before the exact definition of @xmath50 and @xmath48 , we make some more definitions and fix some properties that will be maintained during the process ( see figure [ fig : stairdef ] ) .
[ def : stair ] we say that a point @xmath39 of @xmath49 is _ above _ the staircase if there exists a stair - point @xmath57 such that @xmath39 is ne from @xmath42 . if @xmath39 is not above or on the staircase , then we say that @xmath39 is _ below _ the staircase . a point below ( resp .
above ) the staircase is called a _ below - point _
( resp . _ above - point _ ) . at any time @xmath32
, we say that two points of @xmath50 are _ neighbors _ if their @xmath58-coordinates are consecutive among the @xmath58-coordinates of the stair - points .
( note that this does not mean that they are connected in the graph . )
we also say that @xmath39 is the _ left _
_ right _ ) neighbor of @xmath40 if @xmath39 and @xmath40 are neighbors and the @xmath58-coordinate of @xmath39 is less ( resp .
more ) than the @xmath58-coordinate of @xmath40 . is good ( resp .
right - good , left - good ) if @xmath59 contains two points that are connected by an edge . ] in any step @xmath32 , we say that a point @xmath39 is _ good _ if any wedge containing @xmath39 already contains two points connected by an edge , which are thus forced to get different colors ( see figure [ fig : goods ] ) .
i.e. , at any time after @xmath32 , a wedge containing @xmath39 will contain points of both colors in the final coloring .
a stair - point @xmath39 is _ almost - good _ if for at least one of its neighbors , @xmath40 , it is true that any wedge containing @xmath39 and @xmath40 contains two points connected by an edge of @xmath48 . additionally ,
if @xmath40 is the left neighbor of @xmath39 , then we say that @xmath39 is _ left - good _ , and if @xmath40 is the right neighbor of @xmath39 , then we say that @xmath39 is _ right - good_. notice that the good points and the neighbors of the good points are always almost - good . in fact ,
good points are also left- and right - good , and a left ( resp .
right ) neighbor of a good point is right ( resp
. left ) good .
now we can state the properties we maintain at any time @xmath32 . 1 .
all above - points are good .
2 . all stair - points are almost - good .
3 . all below - points are in different components of @xmath48 .
@xmath48 is a forest . for @xmath60 ,
all these properties are trivially true .
whenever a new point arrives , we execute the following operations ( see also figure [ fig : operations ] ) repeatedly as long as it is possible , in any order .
this will ensure that the properties remain true .
1above : : : if an above - point @xmath39 is not good , then we connect @xmath39 by an edge with a stair - point that is sw from @xmath39 .
2comparable : : : if for some below - points @xmath61 we have that @xmath40 is ne from @xmath39 , then connect them by an edge and put @xmath40 on the staircase .
4incomparable : : : suppose there are no comparable below - points and there is a wedge @xmath59 that lies entirely below the staircase and contains four incomparable points , @xmath62 and @xmath63 , in order of their @xmath58-coordinates
. then connect @xmath64 with @xmath65 and also @xmath66 with @xmath63 , and put @xmath65 and @xmath66 on the staircase .
1box : : : suppose there are no comparable below - points , and
suppose @xmath67 and @xmath68 are two neighboring stair - points , @xmath67 is nw from @xmath68 , @xmath67 is left - good but not right - good while @xmath68 is right - good but not left - good and @xmath39 is a point in the rectangle defined by the two opposite vertices @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
we connect @xmath39 and @xmath68 , and put @xmath39 on the staircase .
now we have to verify that the properties remain true after executing an operation .
note that this was implicitly proved already in @xcite for _ 1above _ , _
2comparable _ and _ 4incomparable_. first , we make the following observation , which implies that we will have to verify property 2 only for the new stair - points .
[ remainsgood ] if a stair - point is left - good ( resp .
right - good , resp .
good ) , then if after an operation this point is still a stair - point , then it remains left good ( resp . right - good , resp .
. notice that if a stair - point gets a new left - neighbor , then the new neighbor is either good , or right - good .
similarly , if a stair - point gets a new right - neighbor , then the new neighbor is either good , or left - good .
[ szorszalhasogatas ] after doing an operation properties 1 - 4 remain true .
we check each operation and each property . *
_ 1above _ : for property 1 , notice that @xmath39 necessarily has to be the newly arrived point , @xmath38 , and it becomes good after the operation .
property 2 obviously remains true .
for properties 3 and 4 we use that as @xmath39 is the newly arrived point , before the operation it is not connected to any other point . * _ 2comparable _ : property 1 remains true as only points ne from @xmath40 became above - points and thus they all have the edge @xmath69 sw from them .
property 2 remains true as the only new stair - point is @xmath40 , which became good .
properties 3 and 4 remain true as before the operation @xmath39 and @xmath40 were in different tree - components , which are then connected . *
_ 4incomparable _ : property 1 remains true as , using that no below - points were comparable , any point that became an above - point has either both @xmath64 and @xmath65 , or both @xmath66 and @xmath63 sw from it .
property 2 remains true as there are only two new stair - points : @xmath65 becomes left - good and @xmath66 becomes right - good .
properties 3 and 4 remain true as before the operation @xmath70 were all in different tree - components , and after the operation two - two of these are connected in a suitable way . * _ 1box _ : property 1 remains true as , using that no below - points were comparable , there are no new above - points .
property 2 remains true as @xmath39 is the only new stair - point and it is right - good .
properties 3 and 4 remain true if @xmath39 and @xmath68 are in different tree - components .
this will be proved in lemma [ remainslost ] and lemma [ remainslower ] .
[ remainslost ] if there is no below - point in the tree - component @xmath71 of a stair - point @xmath42 , then this remains true , i.e. , later during the process the component containing @xmath42 will never contain a below - point .
suppose that there is no below - point in the tree - component @xmath71 of a stair - point @xmath42 .
this trivially remains true when a new point arrives ( before doing operations ) .
then a simple case analysis shows that none of the operations can introduce a below - point to the tree - component @xmath71 of a stair - point @xmath42 : * _ 1above _ : either @xmath71 does not change or only @xmath39 ( an above - point ) is added to it . * _ 2comparable _ : only the components of the below - points @xmath39 and @xmath40 are joined , as @xmath71 must be a different tree from these two ( as it contained no below - point ) , @xmath71 does not change . *
_ 4incomparable _ : only the components of the below - points @xmath72 change , as @xmath71 must be a different tree from these ( as it contained no below - point ) , @xmath71 does not change . *
_ 1box _ : either @xmath71 does not change or @xmath73 in which case @xmath71 is joined with the tree @xmath74 containing @xmath39 . in the latter case in @xmath74
the only below - point was @xmath39 ( by property 3 ) , which after the operation becomes a stair - point , so the new tree containing @xmath42 , @xmath75 still does not contain a below - point after this operation .
[ remainslower ] suppose @xmath42 is a stair - point and @xmath76 is a below - point in the tree - component @xmath71 containing @xmath42 .
if @xmath42 is right - good but not left - good , then @xmath76 is lower than @xmath42 , that is , @xmath76 has a smaller @xmath77-coordinate than @xmath42 . by observation [ remainsgood ] , we know that if @xmath42 is right - good but not left - good , then this was also true at the time when @xmath42 became a stair - point .
a simple case analysis of the operations shows that at the time when @xmath42 becomes a stair - point , the statement holds : * _ 1above _ : this is not a possible case as in this case no point becomes a stair - point . *
_ 2comparable _ : this is not a possible case as necessarily @xmath42 plays the role of @xmath40 in the operation , in which case @xmath42 is good and thus also left - good , contradicting our assumption on @xmath42 . * _ 4incomparable _ : necessarily @xmath42 plays the role of @xmath66 in the operation , thus @xmath76 is @xmath63 and so it is lower than @xmath42 , as required . *
_ 1box _ : necessarily @xmath42 plays the role of @xmath39 in the operation , thus after the operation the below - point in @xmath71 is necessarily the point which was the below point of @xmath78 before the operation .
as @xmath68 was right - good but not left - good , by induction this below point was lower than @xmath68 , thus it is also lower than @xmath79 , as required . if after some step @xmath71 stops to have a below - point
, then by lemma [ remainslost ] this remains true and so there can be no below - point @xmath76 in @xmath71 as required by the lemma and we are done .
otherwise , if @xmath71 still has a below - point , then by property 3 there is exactly one below - point @xmath76 in @xmath71 , it is lower than @xmath42 , and we have to check that after any operation the below - point in @xmath71 remains below @xmath42 .
the only operation in which the below - point @xmath76 in @xmath71 could go higher is _
4incomparable _ such that @xmath76 plays the role of @xmath65 .
if @xmath80 is sw from @xmath42 , then @xmath42 goes above the staircase , thus stops being a stair - point as required by the lemma and we are done .
if @xmath80 is se from @xmath42 , then the whole wedge @xmath59 must be lower than @xmath42 , and then the new below - point in @xmath71 becomes @xmath64 , also lower than @xmath42 .
this finishes the proof of the lemma and also of proposition [ szorszalhasogatas ] .
now we can finish the proof of the dynamic dual version , and thus also of theorem [ thm:9 ] , by showing that taking any ( partial ) two - coloring of the forest @xmath48 constructed using the above operations , at all times ( i.e. , for every prefix set @xmath81 of the point set ) , any quadrant @xmath59 containing at least @xmath0 points contains both colors .
fix the time after the arrival of the point @xmath38 ( and after we repeatedly applied the operations as long as possible ) .
thus no more operations can be applied , in particular there are no two comparable below - points otherwise we could apply operation _
2comparable_. if @xmath59 contains an above - point , it contains both colors as all above - points are good .
if @xmath59 contains at most one stair - point , @xmath42 , then by `` splitting '' @xmath59 at @xmath42 ( see figure [ split1 ] ) , we get two quadrants that do not contain any stair - point , but contain all other points that @xmath59 contains
. one of these two quadrants must contain at least @xmath2 below - points , thus we could apply operation _
4incomparable _ , a contradiction .
if @xmath59 contains at least @xmath82 stair - points , then it contains a stair - point @xmath42 such that both neighbors of @xmath42 are also in @xmath59 . as every stair - point is almost - good
, @xmath59 must contain both colors .
finally , if @xmath59 contains exactly two ( neighboring ) stair - points , @xmath67 nw from @xmath68 , then the only way for @xmath59 to be monochromatic is if @xmath67 is left - good but not right - good and @xmath68 is right - good but not left - good .
therefore , there can be no points in the rectangle formed by @xmath67 and @xmath68 , as otherwise we could apply operation _
1box _ , a contradiction .
at least one of the two quadrants obtained by `` splitting '' @xmath59 at @xmath67 and @xmath68 ( see figure [ split2 ] ) , must contain at least @xmath2 below - points , thus we could apply operation _
4incomparable _ , a contradiction .
here we construct for any triangle @xmath15 a finite point set @xmath7 such that for every two - coloring of @xmath7 there is a translate of @xmath15 that contains exactly @xmath2 points and all of these have the same color . as the construction is quite hard to describe precisely
, we refer to figure [ fig : haromszogre4nemeleg ] and figure [ fig : haromszogre4nemelegzoom ] for the details and give only a more informal description below . with a simple case analysis
, we will show that in any two - coloring , there is a monochromatic triangle with exactly @xmath2 points .
points.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] on the top part of the figure is the `` big picture '' that shows what the construction looks like from far .
the thicker triangles denote families of triangles that are very close to each other .
the center part has only three points , @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
two of these , without loss of generality @xmath83 and @xmath85 , must receive the same color , say blue .
after this we look more closely at the family @xmath86 that consists of the subfamilies @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 , see the bottom - left figure . unless the triangle @xmath91 is monochromatic , at least one of @xmath92 , @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath95 must be blue . without loss of generality
we suppose @xmath94 is blue .
after this we look more closely at the family @xmath89 that consists of the triangles @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 , see the bottom - right figure
. unless the triangle @xmath100 is monochromatic , at least one of @xmath101 , @xmath102 , @xmath103 and @xmath104 must be blue .
but if @xmath105 is blue , then @xmath106 is monochromatic .
this finishes the proof .
in this section we investigate two - coloring geometric _ dynamic hypergraphs _ defined by intervals on a line .
the vertices of a dynamic hypergraph are ordered and they `` appear '' in this order . knowing in advance the whole ordered hypergraph , our goal is to color the whole vertex set such that at all times any hyperedge restricted to the vertices that have `` arrived so far '' is non - monochromatic if it contains at least @xmath107 vertices that have arrived so far .
this model is also called quasi - online in @xcite .
the exact definitions are as follows . for a hypergraph @xmath108 with an order on its vertices , @xmath109
, we define the _ dynamic closure _ of @xmath110 as the hypergraph on the same vertex set and with hyperedge set @xmath111 . a hypergraph with
an order on its vertices is _ dynamic _ if it is its own dynamic closure .
when @xmath112 is a hypergraph family , is the hypergraph family that contains all the dynamic closures of the family @xmath112 ( with all orderings of their vertex sets ) .
a hypergraph is @xmath107-proper two - colorable if @xmath113 can be two - colored such that for every @xmath114 and @xmath115 if @xmath116 , then @xmath117 contains both colors . for a family of ( ordered ) hypergraphs , @xmath118
, we define the _ midriff _ of the family , @xmath119 , as the smallest number @xmath107 such that every ( ordered ) hypergraph in the family is @xmath107-proper two - colorable .
[ obs : todynamic ] if for two non - ordered hypergraph families , @xmath120 is a subfamily of @xmath121 , then for their dynamic closures , @xmath122 is a subfamily of @xmath123 .
now we look at the hypergraphs that we have studied in the earlier sections using the above terminology .
: : : vertices : a finite set of points from @xmath3 ; + hyperedges : subsets of the vertices ( points ) contained in a quadrant ( of the form @xmath30 ) .
: : : vertices : a finite set of quadrants ; + hyperedges : subsets of the vertices ( quadrants ) that contain a point from @xmath3 .
: : : vertices : a finite set of points from @xmath1 ; + hyperedges : subsets of the vertices ( points ) contained in an octant ( of the form @xmath124 . : : : vertices : a finite set of octants ; + hyperedges : subsets of the vertices ( octants ) that contain a point from @xmath1 . we know that @xmath125 by definition and as we noted already in the previous section , in @xcite it was shown ( not using this terminology ) that decomposing octants is equivalent to its dual problem , i.e. , @xmath126and @xmath127 and that is the same as the ( ordered ) hypergraph family ( regarding the hypergraphs in it without the vertex orders ) . also , @xmath126 . summarizing : equals and therefore + @xmath128 . now we will define the hypergraph families that are the main topic of this section .
the set of all intervals on the real line is denoted by @xmath129 .
: : : vertices : a finite point set ; + hyperedges : subsets of the vertex points contained in an interval @xmath130 . : : : vertices : a finite set of intervals ; + hyperedges : subsets of the vertices ( intervals ) containing a point @xmath131 .
: : : vertices : a finite set of intervals ; + hyperedges : subsets of the vertices ( intervals ) contained in an arbitrary interval @xmath130 .
: : : vertices : a finite set of intervals ; + hyperedges : subsets of the vertices ( intervals ) containing an arbitrary interval @xmath130 .
: : : vertices : a finite set of intervals ; + hyperedges : subsets of the vertices ( intervals ) intersecting an arbitrary interval @xmath130
. now we study the relations among the above five hypergraph families . by exchanging points with small enough intervals
we get that the family is a subfamily of , and the family is a subfamily of , while both and are subfamilies of .
observation [ obs : todynamic ] implies several inequalities among their midriffs , for example , that @xmath132 .
we are only aware of earlier papers studying the first two variants .
it follows from a greedy algorithm that @xmath133 and @xmath134 .
it was shown in @xcite that @xmath135 , and later this was generalized for @xmath14-colors in @xcite .
it was also shown in @xcite that @xmath136 , and later this proof was simplified in @xcite .
it is interesting to note that for the @xmath107-proper coloring problem there is a so - called _ semi - online _
algorithm , that can maintain an appropriate partial @xmath107-proper coloring of the points arrived so far , while it was shown in @xcite that no semi - online algorithm can exist for @xmath107-proper coloring .
here we mainly study the other three hypergraph families .
[ claim : ibiisi ] equals , thus equals . by observation [ obs : todynamic ]
it is enough to prove the first statement .
notice that in both and , we can suppose that the left endpoint of any vertex interval is to the left of the right endpoint of any vertex interval , as if we have a right endpoint such that the closest endpoint to its right is a left endpoint , then swapping them does not change the hypergraphs .
thus , without loss of generality , there is a point that is in all the vertex intervals . instead of a line ,
imagine that the vertex intervals of a hypergraph of are the arcs of a circle such that none of them contains the bottommost point of the circle and all of them contains the topmost point
. can be at most one larger than but we omit discussing this here .
] this is clearly equivalent to the version when the vertex intervals are on the line .
similarly , we can imagine that the vertex intervals of a hypergraph of are the arcs of a circle such that none of them contains the topmost point of the circle and all of them contains the bottommost point .
taking the complement of each arc transforms the families into each other , that is , in a hypergraph @xmath137 of an interval @xmath138 defines the hyperedge @xmath139 while in the hypergraph @xmath140 of whose vertices are the complements of the intervals in @xmath137 , the complement @xmath141 of @xmath138 defines the hyperedge @xmath142 . as @xmath143 if and only if @xmath144 , @xmath137 and @xmath140 are isomorphic , see figure [ fig : circledual ] .
[ lem : ibiisi ] and are both equal to , while is a family of subhypergraphs of hypergraphs from the above , and the same holds for the dynamic variants . by observation [ obs : todynamic ] , it is enough to prove the statements about the non - dynamic families . for an illustration for the proof ,
see figure [ fig:3equi ] .
recall that a quadrant is a set of the form @xmath30 for some apex @xmath34 .
we can suppose that all points of the point set are in the north - eastern halfplane above the line @xmath145 defined by the function @xmath146 , i.e. , @xmath147 for every @xmath148 .
for each point @xmath148 we define an interval , @xmath149 $ ] .
quadrants that lie entirely below @xmath145 do not contain points from @xmath7 .
for the quadrants with apex above @xmath145 , a quadrant whose apex is at @xmath40 contains the point @xmath39 if and only if @xmath150 contains @xmath151 .
this shows that the hypergraphs in and in are the same .
the equivalence of and already follows from proposition [ claim : ibiisi ] , but we could give another proof in the above spirit , by supposing that for all points @xmath148 we have @xmath152 , moreover , that for every quadrant intersecting some of the points there is a quadrant containing the same set of points whose apex @xmath153 has @xmath154 . now for each point @xmath148 we can define the interval @xmath155 $ ] and proceed as before . note that this gives another proof for proposition [ claim : ibiisi ] . finally , taking a @xmath137 in ,
it is isomorphic to the subhypergraph of some @xmath140 in where in @xmath137 for all points @xmath148 we have @xmath152 and we take only the hyperedges corresponding to quadrants whose apex @xmath153 has @xmath156 .
now for each point @xmath148 below @xmath145 we define @xmath155 $ ] , and for each point @xmath153 above @xmath145 we define @xmath157 $ ] , and proceed as before .
this finishes the proof of the theorem .
as it was shown in @xcite that @xmath158 , it follows that also @xmath159 @xmath160 quite surprisingly , we could not find a simple direct proof for the fact that is a family of subhypergraphs of hypergraphs from the families and . from theorems [ thm:9 ] and [ thm : lower ] , and lemma [ lem : ibiisi ] we obtain the following .
@xmath161 and + @xmath162
our concluding diagram can be seen on figure [ fig : diagram ] .
most importantly , for octants we have @xmath163 and the same bound holds for the homothets and the translates of triangles .
it seems to be in reach to determine these parameters exactly . for translates of convex @xmath164-gons for @xmath165 ,
the parameter @xmath107 might depend on the shape of the @xmath164-gon for @xmath164 fixed , and tends to infinity with @xmath164 @xcite .
the upper and lower bounds @xcite are currently very far , already for a square .
also , it is not known whether there exists an @xmath107 ( again depending on the convex @xmath164-gon ) such that any finite point set admits a two - coloring such that any homothet of the convex @xmath164-gon containing at least @xmath107 points is non - monochromatic , not even for the square . on the other hand , for any @xmath107
there is an @xmath107-fold covering by finitely many homothets of any convex @xmath164-gon ( for @xmath165 ) of some set that does not decompose to two coverings @xcite .
a. asinowski , j. cardinal , n. cohen , s. collette , t. hackl , m. hoffmann , k. knauer , s. langerman , m. lason , p. micek , g. rote , t. ueckerdt , coloring hypergraphs induced by dynamic point sets and bottomless rectangles , in proceedings of the 13th algorithms and data structures symposium ( wads 2013 ) , lecture notes in computer science 8037 , 7384 , 2013 . j. cardinal , k. knauer , p. micek , t. ueckerdt , making triangles colorful , journal of computational geometry 4(1 ) : 240246 , 2013 .
j. cardinal , k. knauer , p. micek , t. ueckerdt , making octants colorful and related covering decomposition problems , siam j. discrete math .
28(4 ) : 19481959 , 2014 . m. gibson and k. varadarajan , decomposing coverings and the planar sensor cover problem , discrete and computational geometry 46(2 ) : 313333 , 2011 .
b. keszegh , d. plvlgyi , octants are cover decomposable into many coverings , computational geometry 47(5 ) : 585588 , 2014 . b. keszegh , d. plvlgyi , convex polygons are self - coverable , discrete and computational geometry 51(4 ) : 885895 , 2014 .
i. kovcs , indecomposable coverings with homothetic polygons , discrete and computational geometry 53(4 ) : 817824 , 2015 .
j. pach , d. plvlgyi , g. tth , survey on the decomposition of multiple coverings , in geometry , intuitive , discrete , and convex ( i. brny , k. j. brczky , g. fejes tth , j. pach eds . ) , bolyai society mathematical studies , vol .
24 , springer - verlag , 219257 , 2014 .
d. plvlgyi , indecomposable coverings with concave polygons , discrete and computational geometry 44(3 ) : 577588 , 2010 .
j. pach and d. plvlgyi , unsplittable coverings in the plane , to appear in the proceedings of the 41st international workshop on graph - theoretic concepts in computer science ( wg 2015 ) .
d. plvlgyi and g. tth , convex polygons are cover - decomposable , discrete and computational geometry 43(3 ) : 483496 , 2010 . | in this note we improve our upper bound given in @xcite by showing that every @xmath0-fold covering of a point set in @xmath1 by finitely many translates of an octant decomposes into two coverings , and our lower bound by a construction for a @xmath2-fold covering that does not decompose into two coverings .
the same bounds also hold for coverings of points in @xmath3 by finitely many homothets or translates of a triangle .
we also prove that certain dynamic interval coloring problems are equivalent to the above question . |
ultra - compact binaries refer to double stars with orbital periods typically less than about one hour .
they come in two general flavours : detached systems and interacting binaries in which mass is transferred from one star to the other .
the limit of about one hour is derived from a very simple argument , dating back to ( * ? ? ?
* see also @xcite ) .
each component in a binary has a radius at most the size of its roche lobe , which for a star of mass @xmath0 and radius @xmath1 with a companion of mass @xmath2 can be approximated as @xmath3 @xcite . when combined with kepler s third law to eliminate @xmath4 ( and @xmath2 ! ) using the orbital period @xmath5 this yields @xmath6 .
therefore , the smaller the period , the higher the density of the objects and for periods smaller than one hour , the densities are too high for main sequence stars .
ultra - compact binaries therefore consist of evolved components : white dwarfs , neutron stars , he stars or black holes , which makes them a class apart .
because both components in ultra - compact binaries are evolved stars , their formation is a probe of different uncertain processes in binary evolution : common - envelope evolution , magnetic braking , massive star evolution and ns / bh kicks .
three different formation channels have been proposed ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) : in the wd channel : : the primary evolves to become a compact object that then is engulfed in a common envelope with the secondary . after the common envelope the secondary becomes a wd and gravitational wave ( gw ) radiation brings the wd into contact with the primary at a period of a few minutes .
if the mass transfer is stable ( see [ stab ] ) , the orbit will widen again ( fig . 1 ) .
in the he star channel : : the evolution is largely the same , except that the core of the secondary after the common envelope is a core he burning star that starts mass transfer to the primary at periods of several tens of minutes and first evolves to shorter periods , until a minimum of around 10 minutes is reached and then turns around . in the evolved main - sequence channel
: : the secondary fills its roche lobe to the compact object when it just reaches the end of the main sequence .
it first evolves as a normal low - mass x - ray binary or cataclysmic variable , until the h depleted core of the star becomes exposed .
the system essentially merges onto the he star channel , although in many cases the transferred material still shows traces of h ( e.g. * ? ? ?
work done in utrecht showed that in order to get to very short orbital periods , fine tuning of the initial binary parameters as well as strong magnetic braking is needed @xcite .
[ fig : pmdot ] the onset of mass transfer is an extremely interesting phase in the case of a wd donor .
because wd have an inverted mass - radius relation , the donor will always be the lower mass object .
the stability criterion ( @xmath7 and @xmath8 at all times ) immediately gives an upper limit to the mass ratio of the system ( see * ? ? ?
but even if in principle the mass transfer can be stable , the time scales of the evolution due to gw emission are short and the mass transfer rates high ( fig . 1 ) .
for ns ( and bh ) accretors this means the mass transfer is highly super - eddington .
assuming radiation liberated by accretion is used to expel the excess matter from the inner lagrangian point ( l1 ) one can derive a ( likely ) upper limit on the mass transfer that can still be stable @xcite .
because the mass transfer scales with the donor mass this puts an upper limit to the initial mass of a wd donor of @xmath9 .
therefore he core wd can survive the onset of mass transfer more easily . for wd accretors
another interesting issue arises : at these very short periods , the accretor is relatively big compared to the orbit and in many cases the mass stream from l1 will hit the surface of the accretor directly ( so - called direct impact , see fig . 1 ) .
this complicates the stability analysis of mass transfer , as the usual condition that the angular momentum that the donor loses to the stream is stored in the disk that forms and then via tides put back in the orbit ( and thus can effectively be ignored , see * ? ? ?
* ) is not obvious anymore .
this could seriously destabilise the mass transfer ( see fig . 1 ) , unless there is strong tidal interaction between the orbit and the spinning accretor ( which is unknown , @xcite ) .
the evolution around the onset of mass transfer can give rise to various explosive phenomena : if the mass transfer is unstable the two stars will merge . in the case of two wds with enough mass ,
this has been proposed as a possible origin of type ia supernovae . for lower mass wd
the outcomes are more likely r crb or sdb stars @xcite .
less work has been done on the merger of a wd with a ns , but recently @xcite suggested they may produce sub - luminous supernovae . even if the mass transfer is stable , there may still be fire works .
the two known classes of objects are ultra - compact x - ray binaries ( ucxbs ; a ns accreting he or a c / o mixture , see @xcite and am cvn stars ( a wd accreting he , ( see * ? ? ? * ) ) .
the mass transfer is driven by gw emission and is characterised by rapidly dropping mass transfer rates ( see fig . 1 ) .
in am cvn stars the mass transfer rate of he onto a wd in the early phase is high enough to produce he novae . at periods of around 10 min ,
the mass transfer rate has dropped enough that the ignition mass becomes so large that the layer is degenerate enough for the burning to proceed on a dynamical timescale , leading to a thermonuclear explosion , observable as a sub - luminous supernova , called .ia supernova @xcite . with the advent of wide - field variability surveys such as pan - starrs and pft , there are good chances of finding these supernovae .
indeed several new types have been found ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , but it is ( yet ) unclear which observed types belong to which theories !
) and outer edge of the disk according to several authors as function of mass ratio .
right : sph calculation of a disk in an extreme mass ratio case . from @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] ) and outer edge of the disk according to several authors as function of mass ratio .
right : sph calculation of a disk in an extreme mass ratio case . from @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] [ fig : late ] if the systems survive the early violent evolution , the mass transfer rate continues to go down ( fig . 1 ) .
the mass ratio becomes very extreme ( @xmath10 ) , and the disk has to grow larger and larger to redistribute the angular momentum and it has been suggested that this would be impossible , leading to an instability .
however , @xcite already showed that that was likely not the case and recent sph calculations indeed confirm that the disk becomes large and the system survives ( see fig . 2 and @xcite ) , leading to a large pile up of systems at long orbital periods .
for am cvn systems indeed many long period systems are found ( see * ? ? ? * ) . however , this is not the case for ucxbs .
we explored the options to explain this and conclude that either the systems are invisible most of the time ( e.g. due to thermal instabilities in the disk ) , or the evolution is sped up by x - ray induced wind mass loss from the donor , which is also consistent with the average x - ray luminosity of the few long - period ucxbs and the idea that the millisecond radio pulsar system psr j1719@xmath111438 is a remnant of ucxb evolution ( see @xcite ) .
the evolution of ultra - compact binaries is largely driven by gw radiation .
it is therefore maybe not unexpected that they are important gw sources .
indeed , space detectors such as the elisa mission @xcite should be able to detect several of the known am cvn stars and a detached double wd with a period of only 12 min @xcite .
they thus are guaranteed or verification sources .
more interesting , elisa should detect several thousand new ultra - compact binaries most with periods shorter than 10 minutes !
it should detect _ all _ ns star ( and bh ) binaries with periods shorter than 35 min in the whole galaxy . | we present a short overview of the formation and evolution of ultra - compact binaries .
they are relevant to a surprisingly large number of astrophysical phenomena ( binary interactions , mass transfer stability , explosive phenomena such as type ia supernovae and gravitational waves ) . |
cylindrical semiconductor nanostructures bridge between quasi-1d systems at small diameters and quasi-2d in the opposite limit , thus extending the wealth of physics and applications of low - dimensional solid - state systems .
the controlled growth of semiconductor quantum tubes ( qts ) with diameters in the 10 - 100 nm range has been recently demonstrated through several techniques , including multi - layer overgrowth of nanowires@xcite and strain - induced bending of a planar heterostructure.@xcite in addition to qts with a solid semiconductor core , it is possible to grow _ hollow _ qts , where the charge carriers are confined in a thin semiconductor shell , encompassed by a barrier material which is only a few nm thick.@xcite large surface - to - volume ratios and the possibility of various functionalizations on both the internal and external surfaces make the latter systems particularly interesting for applications.@xcite although experiments concerning the optical properties of these systems are still limited , advancements in the optical quality of the samples point to a rapid increase of these investigations.@xcite the excitonic properties of semiconductor qts are particularly interesting with respect to conventional semiconductor quantum wires , where excitons are confined in the core of the nanostructure.@xcite on the one hand , due to the combined effect of the qt curvature and of the quasi-2d confinement of carriers in the cylindrical shell , excitonic binding energies might be substantially stronger than in bulk , even for large diameter qts . on the other hand , a dielectric medium outside the shell of the qt may result in a dielectric confinement of the electric field felt by the optically excited electron - hole pairs , in most cases enhancing their excitonic binding energy . since the dielectric interface is spatially separated from the carriers , which are confined deep inside the shell , excitonic binding and sensitivity to the medium might be strongly enhanced without spoiling the optical properties of the electronic system,@xcite analogously to core - shell nanowires.@xcite the screening provided by the dielectric environment can be varied in a broad range.@xcite the tunability of the dielectric constant in the core of the qt , obtained , _
e.g. _ , by oxidation,@xcite can further increase such effects .
present work on qts theoretically considered magnetic states,@xcite reported experimental evidence of the aharonov
bohm effect,@xcite and treated optical properties,@xcite but the influence of the dielectric dismatch between the nanostructure and the environment has been studied so far only for conventional quantum wires@xcite and freestanding nanowires.@xcite here we will consider also a dielectric mismatch between the core and the shell , which will lead to a considerable change in the electron - hole interaction , as shown in fig . [
fig : potential ] .
hereafter we investigate the excitonic binding and oscillator strength in hollow and filled qts for different geometries and dielectric configurations . besides increasing due to the reduced screening ,
the excitonic binding strongly depends on the qt diameter and on the dielectric medium .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : model ]
we outline the theoretical model , which includes the exact solution of the poisson equation and the diagonalization of the electron - hole hamiltonian within the envelope - function approximation . in sections
iii and iv we report our results and draw the conclusions , respectively .
the system we consider consists of an infinite tube with cylindrical symmetry@xcite ( see fig . [
fig : tube_scheme ] ) . for simplicity
we assume that the motion in the radial direction is frozen , and that charge carriers are radially confined in a @xmath0-like well at a distance @xmath1 from the tube axis .
this electronic layer is buried in the middle of a coaxial cylindrical shell of thickness @xmath2 with dielectric constant @xmath3 , while the core and the environmet have in general different dielectric constants , @xmath4 and @xmath5 , respectively . since
the shell is a semiconductor material , typically @xmath6.@xcite the invariance under translations along , and rotations around the tube axis warrants the separation of the center of mass and relative coordinates .
the motion of the wannier exciton@xcite in the relative degrees of freedom is determined by the envelope - function hamiltonian @xmath7 - v ( x , y),\ ] ] expressed in units of the effective hartree @xmath8@xmath9 , with @xmath10 the reduced electron - hole mass .
the relative coordinates around the circumference ( @xmath11 ) and along the tube axis ( @xmath12 , see fig .
[ fig : tube_scheme ] ) , are in units of the effective bohr radius , a@xmath13 .
the effective coulomb interaction potential @xmath14 between the confined electron and hole depends parametrically on the dielectric constants ( @xmath15 ) and on the tube geometry through @xmath16 and @xmath1 . in cylindrical coordinates ,
the potential ( scaled with @xmath8 ) generated by a charge at @xmath17 reads @xmath18 g_{m,\alpha}(k , \rho , \rho'),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath19 indicates whether the position of the test - charge @xmath20 is in the core , shell or environment region , respectively , and @xmath21 is the solution of the radial poisson equation in that region ( see the appendix for further details ) .
the interaction @xmath22 in eq . coincides with @xmath23 , with @xmath24 .
as shown in the appendix , @xmath25 \left[\tilde{b}_m^>+c_m^>\right ] \times \nonumber \\ & & i_m(kr ) k_m(kr),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath26 are the bessel functions of the first and second kind ; the coefficients @xmath27 are given in eqs . and in terms of @xmath28 and their derivatives . to illustrate how the electron - hole interaction is influenced by the dielectric environment , we shown in fig .
[ fig : potential ] the potential @xmath22 for i ) a _ filled _ qt , with a core of the same material as the shell , immersed in a substance with a low - dielectric constant ( @xmath29 ) , and ii ) a _ hollow _ qt , with the same low - dielectric constant substance inside and outside the shell ( @xmath30 . for comparison , we also show the dielectrically homogeneous case ( @xmath31 ) , where the @xmath22 reduces to the usual coulomb potential @xmath32 .
figure [ fig : potential](a ) shows the interaction _ along _ the qt @xmath33 , while fig .
[ fig : potential](b ) shows the interaction _ around _ the cylinder @xmath34 .
the coulomb interaction for the hollow and filled cases is for all distances stronger than in the homogeneous case , since the _ average _ dielectric constant of the system is smaller , and the electric field is not screened outside and , for the hollow case , also inside the qt .
the interaction in the filled and hollow case is substantially different only for distances smaller or comparable to the bohr radius , with the interaction in the hollow case being stronger . for larger distances ( inset of fig .
[ fig : potential](a ) ) , on the other hand , the non - trivial influence of the dielectric mismatch between the core and the shell leads to crossing of the potentials for hollow and filled qts , before both converge to the same value . between an electron - hole pair confined to a cylindrical surface with diameter @xmath35 a@xmath36 , buried in a shell with thickness @xmath37 a@xmath38 with dielectric mismatch , as follows .
homogeneous case : @xmath39 . filled case : @xmath40 .
hollow case : @xmath41 .
( a ) interaction along the qt , @xmath42 .
( b ) interaction around the qt , @xmath43 .
inset in ( a ) : @xmath44 in a larger range of @xmath45 . ] a convenient basis set to represent the exciton wavefunction is obtained by multiplying eigenfunctions of the linear momentum operator along @xmath12 ( @xmath46 ) and of the angular momentum operator along the tube axis ( @xmath47 ) .
imposing periodic born - von karman boundary conditions@xcite along @xmath12 , with period @xmath48 sufficiently larger than the effective bohr radius of the material , results in : @xmath49 with @xmath50 .
the wavefunction thus reads @xmath51 where @xmath52 and @xmath53 indicates the @xmath54th exciton state .
the coefficients @xmath55 are obtained from the schrdinger equation in the above basis : @xmath56 \delta_{n , n'}\delta_{p , p'}\\ -u_{{n'\!,p'\atop{\!\!n , p}}}\bigg \ } { \ensuremath{c _ { n'\!,\,p'}^{j}}}=e_j { \ensuremath{c _ { n , p}^{j}}}.\end{gathered}\ ] ] the diagonal term in the first line represents the kinetic energy , whereas the matrix elements of the electron - hole coulomb interaction term are given by @xmath57 in order to reduce the dimension of the hamiltonian matrix we introduce a cutoff energy @xmath58 , set the maximum number of plane waves @xmath59 and choose the maximum number of orbital modes @xmath60 in eq . as the nearest integer to @xmath61
the hamiltonian matrix is block diagonalized using a symmetrized basis set .
in particular , we consider linear combinations of the above basis functions that are even or odd with respect to the inversion of the relative coordinates @xmath62 and @xmath12 , which is the equivalent of inverting the absolute coordinates , since the corresponding inversion operators @xmath63 commute with the relative motion hamiltonian @xmath64 = 0 & , & [ h , \pi_y ] = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the resulting energy @xmath65 is obtained with respect to the energy minimum of the conduction band . therefore the binding energy of the exciton ground state is @xmath66 . in the presence of a photon gauge field the electron - hole pair recombines emitting a photon of energy @xmath67 .
the recombination rate is related to the dimensionless oscillator strength @xmath68 , which in the dipole approximation reads@xcite @xmath69 here @xmath70 is the envelope function of the exciton ground state given by eq .
, @xmath71 the momentum of the center of mass , @xmath72 is the energy gap between valence and conduction band and @xmath73 , where @xmath74 is the energy associated with kane s matrix elements.@xcite
in the following we investigate the excitonic properties of qts made of the direct gap materials , inas , gaas and inp , and two different dielectric configurations : _ filled _ qts , with a core of the same material of the shell ( @xmath75 ) , and _ hollow _ qts , with the core of the same material as the environment ( @xmath76 ) .
we consider qts with diameters in the @xmath77 nm range and a constant shell thickness @xmath78 nm , comparable to state - of - the - art samples.@xcite material parameters used in the calculations are listed in table [ tab : parameters ] . [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] in order to further investigate the effect of the coulomb interaction between the carriers , we plot the squared modulus of the ground state excitonic wave function for three different dielectric environments , for a inas tube of diameters @xmath79 nm ( fig . [ fig : wave_20 nm ] ) and @xmath80 nm ( fig .
[ fig : wave_100 nm ] ) , for both hollow ( top ) and filled ( bottom ) tubes .
these are two relevant cases , since the former exhibits a geometrical confinement caused by the small circumference , whereas the latter falls fully in the 2d regime without any confinement . as shown in fig .
[ fig : wave_20 nm ] , the wave function for small tubes is distributed over all the circumference , best visible in the homogeneous case ( @xmath81 ) . reducing the screening by diminishing @xmath5 affects the wavefunctions only weakly , leading to a slightly increased localization , both of the hollow ( upper panels ) as well as of the filled case ( lower panels ) . on the other hand ,
both dielectric configurations lead to similar wavefunctions , reflected in the energies reported in fig .
[ fig : ene_vs_epsilon ] , too . for large tubes of fig .
[ fig : wave_100 nm ] the wavefunction is no more distributed over all the circumference , but well localized .
therefore the curvature of the tube has no effects on the exciton for larger diameters , making it fully 2d .
again , changing the dielectric configuration , by diminishing @xmath5 as well as by going from hollow ( top panels ) to filled ( bottom panels ) tubes , is changing the wavefunctions only marginally , while the respective energies are very sensitive to it ( see fig . [
fig : ene_vs_epsilon ] ) .
therefore , while the diameter has a definite influence on the dimensionality of the excitonic states , changing the dielectric configuration amounts to modulating the mean screening with nearly no effects on the wavefunction , shifting only the energy .
we have studied theoretically the excitonic properties of semiconductor qts , focusing on the influence of their dielectric environment and its interplay with structural parameters .
we find that , due to the strong increase of the electron - hole interaction and ensuing very large excitonic binding which is possible in these structures , the spectral properties of excitonic absorption are strongly dependent on geometrical parameters and dielectric environment , with energies well below the energies of the dielectrically homogenous case which is always in the 2d regime for typical parameters .
calculations have been performed for inas , gaas and inp .
the low gap material inas shows a peculiar behavior , since in the investigated systems the exciton binding energy is a substantial fraction of the gap .
the very large binding energies , their tunability in a wide range , and the large sensitivity of the excitonic response to the dielectric medium , point to perspective applications of these systems .
we thank financial support from the italian minister for university and research through firb rbin04ey74 and cineca iniziativa calcolo parallelo 2009 .
the inner radius @xmath82 and the outer radius @xmath83 divide the space into three regions : core ( @xmath84 ) , shell ( @xmath85 ) and environment ( @xmath86 ) with dielectric constants @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 , respectively ( see fig . [
fig : tube_scheme ] ) .
the electrostatic potential at point @xmath90 induced by an electron localized in the shell , _
i.e. _ with @xmath91 , screened by @xmath3 has to obey the poisson equation in cylindrical coordinates ( with charge @xmath92 : @xmath93 here @xmath94 indicates one of the three possible regions of the test charge : core ( @xmath95 ) , shell ( @xmath96 ) or environment ( @xmath97 ) .
is solved by the _ ansatz _
@xmath98 where @xmath99 is the solution of the radial poisson equation in each region @xmath100 @xmath101 and can be written as a linear combination of the solutions of the homogeneous laplace equation , _
i.e. _ modified bessel functions of the first kind , @xmath102 , and the second kind , @xmath103 , with the following properties:@xcite where @xmath108 are no green s functions , but solutions of the ( homogeneous ) laplace equation , from which we construct the solution @xmath109 of eq . in the following .
we define @xmath110 $ ] and @xmath111 $ ] . matching components of fields @xmath112 and @xmath113 at the interfaces
is equivalent to @xcite to determine the last two unknowns we use the symmetry of the green s function @xmath109 with respect to the exchange of @xmath115 and @xmath116 making,@xcite @xmath117 and normalization @xmath118 defining @xmath119 and @xmath120 , and the quantities in particular , for two charges localized at the same distance @xmath24 from the center @xmath125
\times \nonumber\\ & \left [ b_m^ > i_m(kr ) + c_m^ >
k_m(kr ) \right ] \nonumber \\ = & \frac{4 \pi}{\epsilon_s } \left [ \tilde{b}_m^ < + \tilde{c}_m^<\right ] \left[\tilde{b}_m^>+c_m^>\right ] \times \nonumber \\ & i_m(kr ) k_m(kr),\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , taking eq . in the special case @xmath24 , gives the coulomb potential for two particles localized in the shell on a cylindrical surface of radius @xmath1 @xmath127 \left[\tilde{b}_m^>+c_m^>\right ] \times \nonumber \\ & i_m(kr ) k_m(kr ) \cos(k(z - z ' ) ) dk.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath128 this reduces to the usual form @xmath129 in cylindrical coordinates,@xcite while for @xmath130 eq .
reproduces the result of ref . .
note that @xmath22 is scalable , since all arguments in eq .
are products of lengths and momenta and thus dimensionless , only the measure @xmath131 of the integral is reciprocal in length .
the latter one scales with the effective bohr length a@xmath132 nm and therefore @xmath22 itself with the effective hartree @xmath8@xmath133 ev . | we study theoretically the optical properties of quantum tubes , one - dimensional semiconductor nanostructures where electrons and holes are confined to a cylindrical shell . in these structures , which bridge between 2d and 1d systems ,
the electron - hole interaction may be modulated by a dielectric substance outside the quantum tube and possibly inside its core .
we use the exact green s function for the appropriate dielectric configuration and exact diagonalization of the electron - hole interaction within an effective mass description to predict the evolution of the exciton binding energy and oscillator strength .
contrary to the homogeneous case , in dielectrically modulated tubes the exciton binding is a function of the tube diameter and can be tuned to a large extent by structure design and proper choice of the dielectric media . |
magnetic fields are thought to play a significant role in all stages of star formation ( e.g. , recent reviews by mouschovias & ciolek 1999 ; shu et al .
1999 ) . however , the magnetic field is the most poorly measured quantity in the star formation process .
observations of the linear polarization from the thermal emission of magnetically aligned dust grains provide a relatively easy approach to explore the magnetic field morphology ( heiles et al .
such observations give the field direction in the plane of the sky perpendicular to the direction of polarization ( davis & greenstein 1951 ; roberge 1996 ) .
information on the magnetic field morphology is useful for testing the predictions of theoretical models and simulations .
the standard star formation theory predicts certain morphological evolution of magnetic fields .
theory predicts that molecular clouds will tend to be flat with their minor axes parallel to the field lines , because magnetic fields prevent collapse perpendicular to the direction of the field lines ( mouschovias 1976 ) . as contracting cores form , the field morphology achieves an hourglass " shape with a collapsing accretion disk @xmath2100 au at the pinch " and a magnetically supported envelope @xmath21000 au ( fiedler & mouschovias 1993 ; galli & shu 1993 ) .
furthermore , the rotation of disks may twist field lines into the direction along the disk and form a toroidal morphology ( holland et al .
numerical simulations performed by ostriker , gammie , & stone ( 1999 ) show that the field morphology is more random for larger ratios of the thermal to magnetic energy . because of the high sensitivity requirement in polarization observations , most previous observations of even the nearest star - forming regions
have been made with single - dish telescopes whose large beams cover a region greater than the physical extent of protostellar cores .
for example , the angular resolution of the james clerk maxwell telescope ( jcmt ) at 850 @xmath3 m is @xmath214 , which corresponds to @xmath26000 au at the distance of the orion molecular cloud .
therefore , in order to test theoretical models and simulations of star formation , it is essential to obtain high - resolution observations of magnetic fields .
the best available approach to acquire high resolution information is to conduct interferometric observations .
pioneer interferometric polarization observations at millimeter wavelengths have been done with the owens valley radio observatory ( akeson & carlstrom 1997 ) .
recently , the berkeley - illinois - maryland - association millimeter array ( bima ) has been able to successfully provide extended polarization maps with high resolution up to 2 ( rao et al .
1998 ; girart , crutcher , & rao 1999 ; lai et al .
2001 , hereafter paper i ) .
ngc2024 , a massive star formation region in the orion b giant molecular cloud ( distance @xmath2 415 pc : anthony - twarog 1982 ) , is a good candidate to explore the magnetic field structure at small scales .
it contains a luminous region with a north - south molecular ridge at its center corresponding to the dust lane in the optical image .
mezger et al .
( 1988 , 1992 ) identify seven dust cores in the molecular ridge at 1300 and 350 @xmath3 m and assign designations using the acronym fir. they interpret these cores as isothermal protostars in the stage of free - fall contraction .
however , detailed studies of fir4/5/6 show that these cores contain either a near - infrared source or strong outflows that are traditionally related to protostellar cores in a more evolved stage ( moore & chandler 1989 ; chandler & carlstrom 1996 ) .
our interest here focuses on the brightest core , fir5 . with a highly collimated unipolar molecular outflow extended over @xmath25 south of the core ( richer et al .
1992 ) , fir5 appears to be the most evolved object among the fir cores in ngc2024 .
continuum observations at 3 mm by wiesemeyer et al .
( 1997 ) resolve fir5 into two compact cores , and they suggest fir5 is a binary disk with an envelope .
the magnetic field structure in ngc2024 has been mapped with vla oh and zeeman observations by crutcher et al .
( 1999 ) and with far - infrared dust polarization by dotson at al .
both observations have beam sizes larger than the fir5 core .
our observations provide new information on detailed field morphology in the fir5 core .
the observations were carried out from 1999 march to 2001 february using nine bima antennas with 1-mm superconductor - insulator - superconductor ( sis ) receivers and quarter - wave plates .
the digital correlator was set up to observe both continuum and the co 21 line simultaneously .
the continuum was observed with a 750 mhz window centered at 226.9 ghz in the lower sideband and a 700 mhz window centered at 230.9 ghz in the upper sideband .
strong co @xmath4=21 line emission was isolated in an additional 50 mhz window in the upper sideband .
the primary beam was @xmath250 at 1.3 mm wavelength .
data were obtained in the d , c , and b array configurations , and the projected baseline ranges were 4.520 , 568 , and 5180 kilowavelengths .
the integration time in the d , c , and b array was 3.4 , 19.1 , and 11 hours , respectively .
the d - array observations were made first on 1999 march with a pointing center between ngc2024 fir5 and fir6 ( @xmath5 , @xmath6 ) .
because the d - array data showed significant amount of polarized flux toward fir5 near the edge of the primary beam , the follow - up c- and b - array observations were therefore made with a pointing center at fir5 ( @xmath7 , @xmath8 ) .
the bima polarimeter and the calibration procedure are described in detail in paper i ( also see rao et al .
2001 , in preparation ) .
the average instrumental polarization of each antenna was 5.6%0.4% for our observations .
the stokes @xmath9 image of the continuum was made by mosaicing the b- , c- , and d - array data with briggs robust weighting of 0.5 ( briggs 1995 ; sault & killeen 1998 ) to obtain a smaller synthesized beam ( hpbw 2314 , pa=9 ) without losing significant amount of flux .
d - array data were needed to recover the extended emission in order to obtain better measurements of the polarization percentage .
the stokes @xmath10 and @xmath11 images were made with b- and c - array data only , because the precise pattern of the off - axis polarization across the primary beam is unknown .
rao et al . ( 1999 ) measured the off - axis instrumental polarization at selected positions and showed that it only provides an uncertainty less than 0.5% ( comparable to the uncertainty of the leakages ) within 4/5 of the primary beam ; therefore , the off - axis polarization calibration was ignored .
natural weighting was used to produce the maps of the stokes @xmath10 and @xmath11 in order to obtain the highest s / n ratio , and the resulting synthesized beam was 24@xmath1214 with pa=8 .
maps of stokes @xmath10 and @xmath11 were deconvolved and binned to approximately half - beamwidth per pixel ( 1206 ) to reduce oversampling in our statistics .
these maps were combined to obtain the linearly polarized intensity ( @xmath13 ) , the position angle ( @xmath14 ) , and the polarization percentage ( @xmath15 ) , along with their uncertainties as described in section 2 of paper i. when weighted with @xmath13 , the average measurement uncertainty in the position angle for our observations was 6023 .
figure 1 shows the b+c - array stokes i map ( contours ) superposed on the d - array stokes i map ( grey - scale ) .
the b+c - array map resolves fir5 and fir6 into several clumps with the highest resolution ever obtained ( 1612 , pa=11 ) .
the clumps with peak flux stronger than 7@xmath16 ( @xmath17 = 3.3 ) are named and tabulated in table 1 .
figure 2 displays the mosaiced map of ngc2024 fir5 overlaid with polarization vectors .
this map contains b , c , and d array data .
polarization vectors are plotted at positions where the observed linearly polarized intensity is greater than 3@xmath18 ( 1@xmath18 = 2.1 ) and the total intensity is greater than 3@xmath16 ( 1@xmath16 = 7.4 ; note that @xmath16 is dominated by incomplete deconvolution rather than thermal noise ) . under these criteria ,
the polarized emission extends over an area of @xmath28 beam sizes .
table 2 lists the polarization measurements in ngc2024 fir5 at selected positions separated by approximately the synthesized beamsize .
the distributions and the model fitting of the polarization angle are plotted in figure 3 and figure 4 respectively , and the distribution of the polarization percentage is shown in figure 5 . the continuum emission of fir5 can be separated into three main components fir5:main , fir5:ne , and fir5:sw ( figure 1 ) .
fir5:main are resolved into seven clumps , and the seven clumps are assigned designations with lcgr ( table 1 ) . only the two brightest clumps ( fir5:lcgr 4 and 6 ) were previously identified at 96 ghz ( wiesemeyer et al .
1997 ; note that we have renamed these two clumps ) .
wiesemeyer et al . (
1997 ) suggested that fir5 is a binary disk ; however , our high resolution data present complex morphology in fir5 . our data also show that the continuum of fir6 consists of two compact sources .
the three main components of fir5 and the two compact sources of fir6 are clearly seen in the 450 @xmath3 m continuum maps of visser et al .
( 1998 ) , suggesting that they are dust dominated sources .
figure 2 shows that our detection of the polarized flux in fir5 is mainly distributed in a @xmath2104 strip along the major axis of fir5:lcgr 4 extending into fir5:lcgr 2 , which is roughly perpendicular to the disk previously proposed by wiesemeyer et al .
the peak of the polarized flux occurs at a position about 18 north of the continuum peak between fir5:lcgr 3 and 4 .
detections with @xmath19 were also made toward positions near fir5:lcgr 7 and in fir5:ne .
the histogram of polarization angles in fir5 is shown in figure 3 .
most of the polarization detected is associated with fir5:lcgr 4 . toward this source
the average position angle is @xmath0606 , and the angles appear to decrease from south to north from @xmath07 to @xmath071 .
compact polarization is also observed associated with fir5:ne and fir5:lcgr 7 .
both these sources show a similar position angle ( average = 549 ) which is very distinct from that of the vectors in fir5:lcgr 4 .
our results are consistent with recent jcmt observations at 850 @xmath3 m , which also show @xmath20 50 in fir5:ne , low polarization around fir5:lcgr 6 , and @xmath20 @xmath060 in fir5:lcgr 4 ( matthews et al . 2001 , private communication ) .
since the magnetic field direction inferred from the dust polarization is perpendicular to the polarization vectors , the variation of the polarization angles around fir5:lcgr 4 suggests that the magnetic field lines are curved .
the curved field lines can be successfully modeled with a set of parabolas with the same focal point , and the best model with minimum @xmath21 is presented in figure 4 .
the symmetry axis of the best model is at @xmath077 , which is consistent with the position angle of the line connecting fir5 : d and f at @xmath067 .
the histogram in figure 4 shows the distribution of the deviation between our measurements and the best model , which shows a gaussian - like distribution with a dispersion of @xmath22=9233 .
after deconvolving the measurement uncertainty in this region ( @xmath23 ) from the observed dispersion , we obtain the intrinsic dispersion of the polarization angles @xmath24 .
the average polarization percentage is 6.0%1.5% in the main core and 10.5%4.7% toward the eastern side of fir5 .
the polarization percentage distribution is plotted in figure 5 .
these plots show that the polarization percentage decreases toward regions of high intensity as well as toward the cloud center .
based on the apparent close correlation in both figure 5(a ) and 5(b ) , we perform a least - squares fit on @xmath25 versus @xmath26 and @xmath15 versus the distance from the peak of fir5:lcgr 4 ( @xmath27 ) .
we obtain the following results : ( 1 ) for all data points , @xmath28 with a correlation coefficient of @xmath00.86 , and ( 2 ) in the main core , @xmath29 with a correlation coefficient of 0.97 . because higher intensity and smaller radius both imply higher density
, our results suggest that the polarization percentage decreases toward the high density region .
this conclusion is consistent with what we reported in paper i for the w51 e1/e2 cores , and our interpretation was the decrease of the dust alignment efficiency toward high density regions .
in 3.2 , we showed that the field lines in ngc2024 fir5 can be modeled with a set of parabolas which may represent part of an hour - glass shape .
the reason that the rest of the hour - glass shape is not detected could be due to the relatively lower dust column density to the east of the region where polarization has been detected .
the hour - glass geometry has been predicted by theoretical work and simulations ( fiedler & mouschovias 1993 ; galli & shu 1993 ) .
when enough matter collapses along field lines and forms a disk - like structure , the gravity in the direction along the major axis of the disk would eventually overcome the supporting forces and pull the field lines into an hour - glass shape .
observations of magnetic fields have found several cases consistent with this geometry , such as in w3 ( roberts et al .
1993 ; greaves , murray , & holland 1994 ) , omc-1 ( schleuning 1998 ) , and ngc1333 iras4a ( girart , crutcher , & rao 1999 ) . our results in ngc 2024 fir5
provide a possible supporting example to the theoretical models at a small scale of few thousand au .
this scale is much smaller than the hour - glass shapes observed in w3 and omc-1 ( @xmath30 au ) , and is comparable to that in ngc1333 iras4a .
the symmetry axis of our hour - glass model is approximately parallel to the binary disk previously proposed by wiesemeyer et al .
such a coincidence could be an indirect evidence for the existence of a collapsing disk .
although our high resolution map shows that fir5:main is more complicated than a binary disk , it is still possible that there is an east - west disk consisting of four clumps ( fir5:lcgr 1 , 4 , 6 , and 7 ) , with the remaining three clumps either collapsing into the disk or being ejected through outflows .
fir5:lcgr 2 is at @xmath31145 direction with respect to fir5:lcgr 4 , which is close to the unipolar outflow at @xmath31170 . since outflows could be deflected by magnetic fields away from the protostellar cores ( girart , crutcher , & rao 1999 ) , it is possible that fir5:lcgr 2 traces the direction of the outflow near the central core .
further high resolution kinematic study is needed to examine the above speculation .
although the magnetic field strength can not be directly inferred from polarization of dust emission , ostriker , stone , & gammie ( 2001 ) show that the chandrasekhar - fermi formula ( chandrasekhar & fermi 1953 ) modified with a factor of 0.5 can provide accurate estimates of the plane - of - sky field strength under strong field cases ( @xmath32 ) for their simulations of magnetic turbulent clouds .
therefore , the projected field strength ( @xmath33 ) can be expressed as @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the average density , @xmath36 is the rms line - of - sight velocity , the number density of molecular hydrogen @xmath37 , and the linewidth @xmath38 . to estimate @xmath33 in ngc2024 fir5 , we must first carefully determine the density of the dust core and the turbulent linewidth .
mezger et al .
( 1992 ) derived high density ( @xmath39 - 3 ) in fir 1 - 7 from dust emission , but their value is significantly higher than that derived from molecular studies ( @xmath210@xmath40 - 3 from cs : schulz et al . 1991 ; @xmath210@xmath41 - 3 from c@xmath42o : wilson , mehringer , & dickel 1995 ) .
it is possible that depletion of molecules in the dense core causes molecules to only trace the envelope of the dense core ; on the other hand , chandler & carlstrom ( 1996 ) showed that the kinetic temperature in the fir cores is higher than what mezger et al .
( 1992 ) assume , implying a lower density .
mangum , wootten , & barsony ( 1999 ) studied the kinetic temperature in ngc2024 with multi - line observations of formaldehyde ( h@xmath43co ) , and their results supported the arguments of chandler & carlstrom ( 1996 ) .
we therefore adopt @xmath44 - 3 for fir5 from mangum , wootten , & barsony s large velocity gradient ( lvg ) calculation .
we also adopt a weighted linewidth of @xmath45 at the position at the peak of fir5 from mangum , wootten , & barsony ( 1999 ) .
note that , just as for other molecules , the peak of h@xmath43co emission does not coincide with the continuum peak ; therefore , the h@xmath43co emission may come from the envelope of the fir5 .
this may be an advantage because the h@xmath43co linewidth is less likely contaminated by the possible dynamical motions in the core and better represents the turbulent motion .
in 3.2 , we calculated the angle dispersion @xmath24 after taking out the systematic field structure in order to identify the dispersion purely from the alfvnic motion .
along with the parameters discussed in the previous paragraph , we obtain @xmath463.5 mg . we can also calculate the lower limit of @xmath33 using the largest angle dispersion , which is the dispersion before taking out the parabolic model ( @xmath4713146 ) ; thus , @xmath481.9 mg . our estimate of the plane - of - sky field strength is much larger than the line - of - sight field strength measured by crutcher et al .
( 1999 ) from oh zeeman observation , which is @xmath49 g at fir5 . except in the unlikely case that the magnetic field direction lies almost on the plane of the sky ,
the low field strength detected with the zeeman measurement can be explained by ( 1 ) the beam - averaging over small scale field structure , and/or ( 2 ) that oh line does not trace high density region of the dust cores .
the small dispersion of the polarization angles observed by us may imply that the turbulent motion is not strong enough to disturb the magnetic field structure . in order
to quantitatively discuss the the relative importance of the turbulent and magnetic energy in ngc2024 fir5 , we calculate the ratio of the turbulent to magnetic energy @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the turbulent linewidth and @xmath52 is the alfvn speed .
statistically , @xmath53 , thus @xmath54 can be estimated from eq .
( 1 ) . therefore ,
@xmath55 in the general conditions prevalent in molecular clouds , the thermal linewidth @xmath56 is much smaller than the turbulent linewidth , so @xmath57
. the ratio of the turbulent to magnetic energy simply depends on the polarization angle dispersion , @xmath58 the 0.5 factor in eq ( 1 ) was obtained under the assumption that the dust alignment efficiency is uniform throughout the cloud .
if dust alignment efficiency is lower in the regions with higher density as we suggest in 3.3 , @xmath59 would be larger for the same @xmath60 and the correction depends on the degree of depolarization . for our case ,
the most conservative estimate of the angle dispersion is @xmath61 , which leads to a small turbulent to magnetic energy ratio , @xmath62 .
therefore , the magnetic field most likely dominates the turbulent motion in the core region of ngc2024 fir5 .
this is also the case in w51 e1/e2 ( see paper i ) .
high - resolution polarization observations are needed to explore the detailed magnetic field structure in star - forming cores .
we have obtained a continuum map of ngc2024 fir5 and fir6 and a polarization map of ngc2024 fir5 with the highest resolution ever obtained ( @xmath22 ) .
our observations resolve fir5 and fir6 into several continuum clumps .
the information revealed by our polarization observations of fir5 are summarized below : * extended polarization is detected associated with the main core at @xmath0606 .
compact polarization is also observed toward the eastern side of fir5 at 549 .
the polarization is low between these two regions and the secondary intensity peak of fir5 has an upper limit of 6% .
* the magnetic field lines in the core are systematically curved with a symmetry axis close to the major axis of a putative disk .
this is consistent with an hour - glass morphology for the magnetic fields predicted by theoretical works .
* the polarization percentage decreases toward regions with high intensity and short distance to the center of the core .
the tight correlations imply that the depolarization is a global effect and may be caused by the decrease of the dust alignment efficiency in high density regions .
* the small dispersion of the polarization angles in the core suggests that the magnetic field is strong ( @xmath63 2 mg ) and the ratio of the turbulent to magnetic energy is small ( @xmath62 ) .
therefore , the magnetic field most likely dominates turbulent motions in ngc2024 fir5 .
this research was supported by nsf grants ast 99 - 81363 and ast 98 - 20651 .
we would like to thank the staff at hat creek , especially rick forster and mark warnock for assistance with the polarimeter control system .
we also thank charles gammie for his helpful comments .
akeson , r. l. , & carlstrom , j. e. 1997 , , 491 , 254 anthony - twarog , b. j. 1982 , , 87 , 1213 briggs , d. s. 1995 , phd dissertation , the new mexico institute of mining and technology ( available at the website http://www.aoc.nrao.edu/ftp/dissertations/dbriggs/diss.html ) chandler , c. j. , & carlstrom , j. e. 1996 , , 466 , 338 chandrasekhar , s. , & fermi , e. 1953 , , 118 , 113 crutcher , r. m. , roberts , d. a. , troland , t. h. , & goss , w. m. 1999 , , 515 , 275 davis , l. , & greenstein , j. l. 1951 , , 114 , 209 dotson , j. l. , davidson , j. , dowell , c. d. , schleuning , d. a. , & hildebrand , r. h. 2000 , , 128 , 335 fiedler , r. a. , & mouschovias , t. ch .
1993 , apj , 415 , 680 galli , d. , & shu , f. h. 1993 , apj , 417 , 243 girart , j. m. , rao , r. , & crutcher , r. m. 1999 , , 525 , 109 greaves , j. s. , murray , a. g. , & holland , w. s. 1994 , , 284 , l19 heiles , c. , goodman , a. a. , mckee , c. f. , & zweibel , e. g. 1993 , in protostars and planets iii , eds . m. matthews , & e. levy ( tuscon : university of arizona press ) , 279 holland , w. s. , greaves , j. s. , ward - thompson , d. , & andre , p. 1996
, , 309 , 267 lai , s .-
p . , crutcher , r. m. , girart , j. m. , & rao , r. 2001 , to be published in the november 10 , 2001 issue ( paper i ) lazarian , a. , goodman , a. a. , & myers , p. c. 1997 , apj , 490 , 273 leahy , p. , vla scientific memoranda no
. 161 mangum , j. g. , wootten , a. , & barsony , m. 1999 , , 526 , 845 mauersberger , r. , wilson , t. l. , mezger , p. g. , gaume , r. , & johnston , k. j. 1992 , , 256 , 640 mezger , p. g. , chini , r. , kreysa , e. , wink , j. e. , & salter , c. j. 1988 , , 191 , 44 mezger , p. g. , sievers , a. w. , haslam , c. g. t. , kreysa , e. , lemke , r. , mauersberger , r. , & wilson , t. l. 1992 , , 256 , 631 moore , t. j. t. , & chandler , c. j. 1989 , , 241 , 19p mouschovias , t. ch . 1976 , , 207 , 141 mouschovias , t. ch . , & ciolek , g. e. 1999 , in the origin of stars and planetary systems , eds .
c. j. lada & n. d. kylafis ( kluwer academic press ) , 305 ostriker , e. c. , gammie , c. f. , & stone , j. m. 1999 , , 513 , 259 ostriker , e. c. , stone , j. m. , & gammie , c. f. 2001 , , 546 , 980 rao , r. , crutcher , r. m. , plambeck , r. l. , & wright , m. c. h. 1998 , , 502 , l75 rao , r. 1999 , ph.d .
dissertation , university of illinois at urbana - champaign rao , r. , crutcher , r. m. , girart , j. m. , lai , s .-
p . , wright , m. c. h. , & plambeck , r. l. 2001 , in preparation richer , j. s. , hills , r. e. , & padman , r. 1992 , , 254 , 525 roberge , w. g. 1996 , asp conf .
ser . 97 : polarimetry of the interstellar medium , 401 roberts , d. a. , crutcher , r. m. , troland , t. h. , & goss , w. m. 1993 , , 412 , 675 sault , r. j. , & killeen , n. e. b. 1998 , miriad users guide ( available at the website http://www.atnf.csiro.au/computing/software/miriad ) sault , r. j. , teuben , p. j. , & wright , m. c. h. 1995 , asp conf . ser . 77 : astronomical data analysis software and systems iv , 4 , 433 schleuning , d. a. 1998 , apj , 493 , 811 schulz , a. , guesten , r. , zylka , r. , & serabyn , e. 1991 , , 246 , 570 shu , f. h. , allen , a. , shang , h. , ostriker , e. c. , & li , z. 1999 , in the origin of stars and planetary systems , eds . c. j. lada & n. d. kylafis ( kluwer academic press),193 thompson , a. r. , moran , j. m. , & swenson , g. w. 1986 , interferometry and synthesis in radio astronomy ( new york : wiley ) visser , a. e. , richer , j. s. , chandler , c. j. , & padman , r. 1998 , , 301 , 585 wiesemeyer , h. , guesten , r. , wink , j. e. , & yorke , h. w. 1997 , , 320 , 287 wilson , t. l. , mehringer , d. m. , & dickel , h. r. 1995 , , 303 , 840 lcccc & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath9 & @xmath15 + source & @xmath66 & & ( ) & ( % ) + fir5:lcgr 1 & 5 41 44.00 & -1 55 40.7 & 46 & @xmath67 17 + fir5:lcgr 2 & 5 41 44.10 & -1 55 44.0 & 64 & 10.3 + fir5:lcgr 3 & 5 41 44.23 & -1 55 36.8 & 39 & @xmath67 25 + fir5:lcgr 4 & 5 41 44.25 & -1 55 40.8 & 293 & 3.8 + fir5:lcgr 5 & 5 41 44.32 & -1 55 35.7 & 40 & @xmath67 21 + fir5:lcgr 6 & 5 41 44.48 & -1 55 42.2 & 107 & @xmath67 6 + fir5:lcgr 7 & 5 41 44.69 & -1 55 43.5 & 55 & @xmath67 14 + fir6 c & 5 41 45.13 & -1 56 04.2 & 67 &
+ fir6 n & 5 41 45.17 & -1 56 00.3 & 26 &
+ ccccl position & stokes @xmath9 & polarization & polarization & note + ( , ) & ( ) & percentage(% ) & angle ( ) & + ( -0.3 , 4.5 ) & 26.67.3 & 23.19.5 & -729 & + ( -1.1 , 3.0 ) & 132.87.3 & 18.71.9 & -712 & polarization peak + ( -1.2 , 1.2 ) & 300.67.3 & 3.90.7 & -645 & intensity peak + ( -1.8 , 4.5 ) & 41.97.3 & 19.56.1 & -667 & + ( -2.6 , 1.2 ) & 153.77.3 & 4.91.4 & -398 & + ( -2.6,-0.8 ) & 137.17.3 & 6.51.6 & -397 & + ( -2.6,-2.7 ) & 45.67.3 & 15.45.2 & - 89 & + ( -3.9,-0.9 ) & 53.27.3 & 20.04.8 & -426 & + ( -4.8,-2.4 ) & 39.17.3 & 17.36.3 & -399 & + ( 10.2 , 8.9 ) & 31.77.3 & 27.19.2 & 637 & fir5:ne + ( 4.1,-0.5 ) & 75.77.3 & 9.32.9 & 319 & near fir5:lcgr 7 + & &
6.01.5 & -606 & average of the main core + & & 10.54.7 & 549 & average of the eastern side of fir5 + | we present the first interferometric polarization maps of the ngc2024 fir5 molecular core obtained with the bima array at approximately 2 resolution .
we measure an average position angle of @xmath0606 in the main core of fir5 and 549 in the eastern wing of fir5 .
the morphology of the polarization angles in the main core of fir5 suggests that the field lines are parabolic with a symmetry axis approximately parallel to the major axis of the putative disk in fir5 , which is consistent with the theoretical scenario that the gravitational collapse pulled the field lines into an hour - glass shape .
the polarization percentage decreases toward regions with high intensity and close to the center of the core , suggesting that the dust alignment efficiency may decrease at high density .
the plane - of - sky field strength can be estimated with the modified chandrasekhar - fermi formula , and the small dispersion of the polarization angles in fir5 suggests that the magnetic field is strong ( @xmath1 mg ) and perhaps dominates the turbulent motions in the core . |
10 bauer e , hilscher g , michor h , paul ch , scheidt e w , gribanov a , seropegin yu , nol h , sigrist m and rogl p 2004 heavy fermion superconductivity and magnetic order in noncentrosymmetric cept@xmath0si _ phys .
lett . _ * 92 * 027003 bauer e , kaldarar h , prokofiev a , royanian e , amato a , sereni j , brmer - escamilla w and bonalde i 2007 heavy fermion superconductivity and antiferromagnetic ordering in cept@xmath0si without inversion symmetry _ j. phys
jpn . _ * 76 * 051009 willers t , fk b , hollmann n , krner p o , hu z , tanaka a , schmitz d , enderle m , lapertot g , tjeng l h and severing a 2009 crystal - field ground state of the non - centrosymmetric superconductor cept@xmath0si : a combined polarized soft x - ray absorption and polarized neutron study _ phys . rev .
_ b * 80 * 115106 fk b , raymond s , braithwaite d , lapertot g and mignot j - m 2008 low - energy magnetic response of the noncentrosymmetric heavy - fermion superconductor cept@xmath0si studied via inelastic neutron scattering _ phys .
b * 78 * 184518 inosov d s , bourges p , ivanov a , prokofiev a , bauer e and keimer b 2011 dispersion and damping of zone - boundary magnons in the noncentrosymmetric superconductor cept@xmath0si _ j. phys . :
condens . matter _ * 23 *
455704 metoki n , kaneko k , matsuda t d , galatanu a , takeuchi t , hashimoto s , ueda t , settai r , @xmath82nuki y and bernhoeft n 2004 magnetic structure and crystal field excitation in heavy fermion superconductor cept@xmath0si _ j. phys . :
condens . matter _
* 16 * l207 kaneko k , stockert o , fk b , raymond s , skoulatos m , takeuchi t and @xmath82nuki y 2014 magnetic - field - enhanced antiferromagnetism in the noncentrosymmetric heavy - fermion superconductor cept@xmath0si _ phys .
_ b * 89 * 241105(r ) | we have determined the magnetic structure of the noncentrosymmetric heavy - fermion superconductor cept@xmath0si using elastic polarized neutron scattering with field - projected ( longitudinal ) xyz polarization analysis .
we find that the magnetic moment has components both in the tetragonal basal plane and along the tetragonal four - fold axis .
such a magnetic structure is not symmetry - allowed if the magnetic phase transition is second order , and may imply that cept@xmath0si has lower symmetry in the superconducting state than originally thought .
the tetragonal heavy - fermion compound cept@xmath0si has received strong attention in recent years because it shows unconventional superconductivity despite its noncentrosymmetric crystal structure @xcite .
this lack of inversion symmetry leads to an antisymmetric spin - orbit coupling of rashba type , which mixes spin - singlet and spin - triplet cooper - pairing channels @xcite .
the superconducting transition occurs at @xmath1 k , well inside the magnetically ordered state that sets in at @xmath2 k. this suggests that magnetism may play an important role in the pairing mechanism , further highlighted by the fact that the cooper pairs are formed by heavy quasiparticles @xcite .
the magnetic excitations in cept@xmath0si are well understood .
the @xmath3 multiplet of the @xmath4 ce@xmath5 ion is split by the tetragonal point symmetry into three doublets .
the doublet ground state is @xmath6 , as shown by a study combining polarized inelastic neutron scattering with soft x - ray absorption spectroscopy @xcite .
the main exchange interactions have been determined from the dispersion of the somewhat damped spin - wave excitations in the magnetically ordered phase by unpolarized inelastic neutron scattering ( ins ) @xcite . above @xmath7 ,
kondo - type spin fluctuations with an anisotropic wave - vector dependence are observed by ins @xcite . as a consequence of the antisymmetric spin - orbit coupling ,
the spin susceptibility is anomalous with an orthorhombic anisotropy , as shown by polarized ins @xcite .
no resonance or any change in the magnetic excitation spectrum is reported in the superconducting state , despite intense search @xcite .
the magnetic structure of cept@xmath0si is characterized by a propagation vector @xmath8 , but the moment direction is not known .
neutron scattering measurements show magnetic bragg peak intensity for wavevector transfers @xmath9 , which implies that the ordered moment is not parallel to the tetragonal @xmath10 axis .
it was therefore assumed that the magnetic structure consisted of sheets of collinear moments aligned along an unknown axis in the @xmath11@xmath12 plane , with the sheets stacked antiferromagnetically along the @xmath10 axis @xcite .
based on this assumption , the magnitude of the ordered moment was determined to [email protected] @xmath14 @xcite , substantially reduced from the 1.72 @xmath14 that can be calculated from the ground - state doublet @xcite .
the hypothesis of the moments lying in the tetragonal basal plane received further support from representation analysis , which showed that for a second - order magnetic phase transition with @xmath8 in the cept@xmath0si space group @xmath15 ( no .
99 ) , the moments are either in the basal plane or along the @xmath10 axis @xcite . very surprisingly , the intensities of the magnetic bragg peaks were found to increase substantially on the application of a magnetic field * b * along the [ 001 ] axis @xcite . on the assumption of moments aligned in the basal plane , this suggested that the moment magnitude would double for a field of only 6.6 t along the @xmath10 axis .
because of the small moment , all magnetic structure determinations in cept@xmath0si are based on elastic neutron scattering measurements on triple - axis spectrometers ( tas ) , a technique that is not very precise in determining moment directions , since it is difficult to normalize the intensities measured on different bragg peaks .
we have therefore redetermined the magnetic structure using elastic polarized neutron scattering with field - projected ( longitudinal ) xyz polarization analysis on the in20 triple - axis spectrometer .
the use of polarized neutrons allows to eliminate the @xmath16-dependent instrumental normalization factors that make unpolarized tas measurements problematic .
we used a standard set - up with heusler monochromator and analyzer and a helmholtz coil at the sample position . to minimize contributions of unpolarized second - order neutrons from the monochromator
, we used an incoming neutron wavevector of @xmath17 @xmath18 and two pyrolytic graphite filters .
the sample was the same image - furnace grown single crystal of mass 6 g used in many of the previous measurements @xcite , mounted with the @xmath11 and @xmath10 axes in the scattering plane ( the lattice parameter are @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) .
the flipping ratio on nuclear bragg peaks exceeded 23 , which makes polarization corrections unnecessary .
for the determination of the magnetic structure , we measured thirteen magnetic bragg peaks , namely @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 with seven different polarized neutron scattering cross - sections @xmath29 : @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35 , and @xmath36 , where @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the incoming and scattered neutron polarization , respectively , the directions @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 correspond to the neutron polarization being along * q * , perpendicular to * q * in the scattering plane , and perpendicular to the scattering plane , respectively , and @xmath42 means antiparallel to @xmath39 .
since neutron scattering observes only the component of the magnetic moment * m * that is perpendicular to * q * , here called @xmath43 , it is straightforward to show that the measured cross - sections @xmath44 are related to the @xmath40 and @xmath41 projected moment components @xmath45 and @xmath46 via @xmath47 the intensities @xmath44 were normalized to the beam monitor , and the background obtained from measurements with the sample rotated away from the bragg position by @xmath48 or in the paramagnetic phase at @xmath49 k was subtracted .
the chiral term @xmath50 obtained from ( [ sfxx ] ) is zero within the precision of the present measurements .
this is expected , since the propagation vector of cept@xmath0si does not lead to any chirality . in the actual geometry of the experiment , with @xmath51
denoting the angle between * q * and the tetragonal basal plane , the magnetic moment components along the crystallographic axes , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 , are related to @xmath55 and @xmath56 via @xmath57 and @xmath58 where in the last equality we have assumed real ( fourier components of the ) magnetic moments , which is justified in the case of a @xmath8 propagation vector . by measuring @xmath59 for several inequivalent values of * q * , and hence several values of @xmath51 , both @xmath52 and @xmath54 can be extracted from ( [ eqmy ] ) .
we introduce the notation @xmath60 for measurements performed at @xmath61 with @xmath62 .
the mixed @xmath63 term can be estimated from the difference @xmath64 within the precision of the measurements , @xmath65 ( see table [ tableresults ] ) .
this mixed term can also be eliminated from ( [ eqmy ] ) , by taking the average of @xmath66 and @xmath67 .
llll moment ratio & spin - flip & non - spin - flip & average + @xmath68 & 0.68(4)@xmath130.03 & 0.62(4)@xmath130.05 & 0.65(3)@xmath130.05 + @xmath69 & 3.2(2)@xmath131.2 & 3.2(2)@xmath130.8 & 3.2(1)@xmath131.0 + @xmath70 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + the ratio of the in - plane components of the magnetic moment are obtained for reflections with @xmath71 ( @xmath72 ) , @xmath73 averaging over the measured magnetic bragg reflections with @xmath71 , we find @xmath74 for both spin - flip and non - spin - flip cross - sections , and hence @xmath75 ( see table [ tableresults ] ) .
this implies that the population of in - plane s domains is unequal , and also that the in - plane component of the moment is not along a [ 110]-type axis . in other words ,
the basal - plane projected moment is either in a general direction with four in - plane s domains or along a [ 100]-type axis with two unequally populated in - plane s domains .
the out - of - plane moment ratio is obtained from ( [ eqmz ] ) and ( [ eqmy ] ) after averaging over @xmath66 and @xmath67 for @xmath76 bragg peaks , as discussed , @xmath77 using the value of @xmath78 determined above .
note that by normalizing the data to @xmath79 , absorption corrections as well as lorentz and magnetic form factors are factored out .
we find that @xmath80 ( or @xmath81 , see table [ tableresults ] ) for both spin - flip and non - spin - flip cross - sections .
this implies that the moment component along the tetragonal @xmath10 axis is _ substantial _ , in contrast to assumptions hitherto .
the observation that the ordered moment direction is neither in the basal plane nor along the tetragonal axis has two important implications .
one is that the field - induced intensity increase of magnetic bragg peaks observed by kaneko _ et al .
_ @xcite can not be directly related to the size of the magnetic moment , since a change in the domain population or a reorientation of the magnetic moment in applied field would also change the bragg peak intensity . for a magnetic field in the [ 001 ] direction ,
a domain repopulation is not likely since all s domains have the same energy .
however , the zeeman energy due to the magnetic field will compete with the anisotropy that produces the initial tilt angle of the moment direction , and the total energy of the system will be lowered if the magnetic moments turn further towards the basal plane .
such a tilting will increase the intensity of the ( 0,0,1/2 ) bragg peak , as observed experimentally @xcite .
the second implication is that the magnetic order established at @xmath7 leads to a lower symmetry than expected for a second order phase transition .
this means that the phase transition is either ( weakly ) first order or that there are two phase transitions close to each other near @xmath7 .
both scenarios lead to a lowering of the symmetry in the magnetically ordered phase , and hence in the superconducting phase , with important consequences for the understanding of the superconducting mechanism . |
* mcelroy * : hello , david .
we are thankful to have the opportunity to discuss your life and career .
could you describe for us the early influences that led you to pursue a career in mathematics ? * findley * : in high school i found algebra and geometry enjoyable and interesting .
i found out decades later that many of my relatives were mathematics teachers , including one who taught in suitland high school , not far from the u.s .
census bureau ( uscb ) .
however , my plan was to study physics , and i decided to become a mathematics major only when i found out that the mathematics department at the university of cincinnati would let me take advanced calculus and linear algebra before completing the basic calculus sequence , whereas the undergraduate program chair of the physics department would not accept the summer version of the general physics course as an adequate prerequisite for the upper - level physics courses that i wanted to take my sophomore year . by majoring in mathematics , i was able to take the physics courses i wanted , including a graduate level electrodynamics course my senior year , along with enough graduate mathematics courses that i was prepared to complete the master s program in mathematics a year later . * mcelroy * : i see ; but this was in cincinnati , whereas you were born in washington , dc . * findley * : i spent the first 12 years of my life in washington dc , but moved with my family to dayton , ohio , which is close to cincinnati .
* holan * : so your interests in mathematics primarily began in high school ?
* findley * : no , i was interested in physics .
i mean , i enjoyed mathematics , but i was set on physics from an early age . perhaps because i had been very impressed by the age of four or five by the atomic bomb , having seen pictures of it on the front page of the newspaper .
* holan * : that leads to our next question : why you chose the university of cincinnati .
did you consider any other schools , such as the ohio state ? * findley * : i only looked at the university of cincinnati ( uc ) , because a high school counselor had recommended it .
he knew that its college of engineering had a strong reputation , and assumed that its physics department would be equally strong , which it was nt at that time .
beyond my getting a solid mathematics background , a few other circumstances there also had a large impact .
the math department s flexibility continued into graduate school .
because of my interest in physics , i was interested in hilbert space theory . there was no expert in functional analysis on the faculty , but
i and two more senior graduate students were allowed to give ourselves a reading course in the area with nominal faculty supervision , working our way through the masterful monograph by riesz and nagy @xcite .
then i was permitted to write a master s thesis in the area on the topic i chose , expositing a russian mathematician s paper on operator representations , generalizing the representation formulas for symmetric and unitary operators , which generalize the representation formulas for symmetric matrices and unitary matrices . as a consequence , the first time i encountered the backshift operator in time series analysis and the cramr integral representation of stationary processes , i recognized them as special cases of unitary operator representations .
this led me to conclude that i had an advantageous background for time series analysis , which led me ( years later ) to choose this as my area of statistics .
my contacts with germany also came from uc .
freshman physics majors were required to take german , and perhaps because of cincinnati s german heritage there were outstanding teachers in the german department .
after three semesters of german courses , i felt i had a solid foundation for studying in germany , when later the idea came to me of combining my desire to live in europe with my desire to get a ph.d . in mathematics .
fortunately , for me , the mathematics department in cincinnati had a professor from germany named arno jaeger , who knew the functional analyst in germany i had wanted to work with , gottfried kthe in heidelberg .
jaeger also knew a german mathematician at the university of maryland in college park , who could offer me a research assistantship after i learned that kthe would be in college park for the 19631964 academic year . *
mcelroy * : after the university of cincinnati , you held a research assistant position at the university of maryland .
what sort of research were you doing at the time , and did this have any influence on the problems you would later consider in your career ? * findley * : the research assistant position had variable duties depending on who you were working for .
i marked test papers for a first year graduate course and proof - read a ph.d .
dissertation . at professor
kthe s request , i presented an exposition of a recently published paper by two japanese mathematicians in the functional analysis seminar series that ran for decades in the home of professor john brace in college park . their paper provided a complicated counter - example to a long - standing open question . later in germany , i learned that seminar presentations like this were the main filter used by professors to select ph.d .
dissertation students .
* holan * : when you were at the university of maryland ( umd ) , were there any young professors there with whom you came into contact ? * findley * : there were two graduate students who showed the rest of us what it was like to be really gifted !
simon levin and james yorke ; james has become very well known for his work in chaotic systems theory .
he was a graduate student there , and he was then hired after graduation by umd .
i know the time series analysts at maryland , but they came later , and i got to know them by giving seminars at the department .
that is where i met my future co - authors ching - zong wei and benedikt ptscher , who later left umd but who were there at the time that i started giving seminars .
* holan * : at the time you were a ph.d .
student , was it common to go study abroad ? * findley * : my parents had traveled in europe , and seemed to enjoy it a lot , and i felt that my german language training was solid enough that i probably would survive .
in heidelberg there were a number of foreign students , and also other mathematics students from the united states .
but , i was the first us citizen to get a doctorate from the faculty of natural sciences of the university of frankfurt .
* holan * : were your classes in german or in english ? * findley * : german ; keep in mind that mathematics is probably the easiest subject to study in a foreign language .
the vocabulary is pretty limited and pretty predictable in its forms ! *
mcelroy * : it seems that during the sequence of your studies , there was an interval of time between heidelberg and frankfurt , at the university of cincinnati . *
findley * : yes . i came back to the us for various personal reasons , including a death in the family , and also to earn enough money to marry my fiance .
also , i wanted some time to decide whether i wanted to continue in mathematics , or return to physics . *
mcelroy * : your ph.d .
work in germany lasted three years . what was your dissertation about ? * findley * : it concerned the study of a quite abstract generalization given in papers in 1963 and 1964 by w. a. j. luxembourg and a. c. zaanen of the general class of vector space of real - valued sequence spaces defined by kthe and his habilitation supervisor otto toeplitz in a 1934 paper .
i was able to prove analogs , in this new abstract setting , of several results established by kthe in a series of papers from 1935 to 1951 , results that made these sequence spaces quite influential in the development of the theory of locally convex topological vector spaces .
the only part of this work i have been able to use in my time series research is a characterization i learned then of compact sets in the vector space of absolutely summable sequences .
this played a minor clarifying role in a later paper with benedikt ptscher and ching - zong wei on almost stationary processes @xcite .
* holan * : so , you decided to go back to the university of cincinnati after graduation ? was this your first job out of school ? * findley * : yes , i felt it was an honor to be invited back .
i knew and liked the department , and also my wife , who is a violinist , wanted to continue studying with the violin teacher she previously had at the college - conservatory of music at the university of cincinnati .
so it suited both of us .
* holan * : so , at the time they just invited you back to apply ?
today it seems to be much more of an adventure finding a job out of school . *
findley * : it was a slightly different time .
perhaps a year or two after i was back at the university of cincinnati , the job market for new ph.d.s in mathematics became quite tight .
however , there were many jobs available at the time i applied .
in fact , i was also encouraged to apply for a position at the university of maryland ; so , i was nt worried about opportunities in mathematics .
* holan * : your return to cincinnati seems to mark the time you transitioned to time series analysis . given your physics interests and the inherent dynamics of many physical processes , it seems to be a natural development . where did you learn time series analysis ? * findley * : i was self - taught .
i found that when i began writing research papers in mathematics that the audience , perhaps because of the area in which i wrote my dissertation , was very small indeed and that the amount of effort necessary to write papers that would get into respected journals was so great that i became somewhat frustrated . additionally , i felt that most mathematicians looked to the mathematics literature for stimulation for research , rather than anything outside .
some were even contemptuous of the mathematical work done in , say , econometrics and other disciplines .
now in frankfurt , through singing together in a chorus , i had become friends with the young professor of stochastics , hermann dinges ( each full professor had his own institute then ) , with whom i had taken advanced seminars in markov processes ; he had suggested a research problem to me involving wiener
hopf factorization .
so i was interested in stochastics , and therefore also in statistics .
so after a year or two i started teaching statistics courses for engineering students , and knew of the book by box and jenkins @xcite . in 1973 , at the invitation of the sole mathematical statistician in uc s mathematics department , manny parzen and grace wabha gave a one day overview of time series analysis . from this overview
i recognized that time series play an important role in many disciplines , and that the field uses mathematical tools that other statistical fields do not .
i decided to become a time series analyst , and to start by reading books with a probabilist colleague who found the one day overview very stimulating .
grace wahba recommended ted anderson s 1971 book to us @xcite , which we worked through very thoroughly .
later , after i accepted an offer for a time series position at the mathematics department of the university of tulsa ( tu ) in the spring of 1975 , i was asked to prepare a course for the fall semester based on david brillinger s 1975 monograph @xcite . after reading his powerful presentation of the frequency domain perspective
, i decided instead to give a semester - long series of lectures for mathematics faculty members on its contents , while presenting a more elementary two - semester course for the graduate students , many of whom worked in exploration seismology for local oil companies .
i taught this two - semester course every year at tu , updating it annually with new material , such as state space methods . *
mcelroy * : what were your reasons for moving to tu ? * findley * : oh , they advertised the position in time series analysis , and that was what i wanted to do . also , they already had three mathematicians on the faculty who had trained themselves in time series analysis perhaps through consulting work for the oil company research labs in tulsa .
so , i knew i would have a community of people to work with . additionally , they were willing to hire someone with no publications in time series analysis , because they were aware that a mathematician could become a competent time series analyst .
* holan * : in addition to your colleagues , you also worked as a consultant at cities service oil .
can you tell us a little about your experience there ?
* findley * : i should back up and mention that every mathematics professor there did consulting work , because it was available .
the university thought it was a perfectly reasonable thing , as long as they did some other academic things .
there were several major oil company research labs in tulsa and neighboring cities , and oil companies have been quite at the forefront of using new technologies .
they were among the first to use radioactivity as a measuring tool , using gamma rays in well logs to discover what was down there .
so , there were interesting scientific problems to work on and , in the particular case of cities service , the university had been given a building which had belonged to the carter oil company .
von neumann had consulted in this building , and it housed on one end most of the engineering college , and at the other end the cities service research laboratories , which the university leased to cities service .
so i walked out the door at one end of the building and in the door of the other end , to consult , which was a very nice arrangement !
also , i helped a geophysicist who was applying state space filtering methodology kalman filtering to some geophysics problems .
i worked on some problems related to time series methods and seismology .
there were pure statistical issues
pure time series issues of a certain kind , arising from physical reasons .
if you calculate wave propagation through a variety of media and assume everything is happening in one dimension , autoregressive processes seem very natural , since partial autocorrelations represent reflectivity coefficients , and anything that is forecastable represents noise , usually arising from echoes of a wave hitting the transition between geologic strata .
thus , anything that was predictable was noise , and hence prediction error filtering was important .
i developed some time - varying methods for predicting fifty steps ahead we were getting perhaps twenty - five hundred measurements a second in these seismograms , so fifty was a useful forecast interval . *
holan * : did any of that consulting work generate mathematical research ? *
findley * : the paper on my algorithm for time - varying forecasting for forecast error analysis was published in one of the symposium proceedings volumes from the two symposia i organized in tulsa @xcite .
it had a different approach to looking at levinson s algorithm @xcite .
( mostly known to statisticians through the special case independently discovered by durbin @xcite . )
i was able to give a geometrical interpretation of it , which seemed possibly new at the time . *
mcelroy * : can you talk a bit about those symposia ?
* findley * : yes , they were a great opportunity .
my colleague j. b. bednar suggested , after i had been at tu for a month or two , that i organize a symposium on time series analysis .
there were now four people in the department interested in the subject , and i saw this as an opportunity to get in contact with the leading time series researchers in a number of different fields .
this was an idea that was very exciting to me .
i asked j. b. bednar to contact a very respected electrical engineer at mit , alan oppenheim , and ask if he would be willing to speak at the conference .
once he received an affirmative answer , i contacted manny parzen , and after he said yes , i contacted henry gray .
after that we were launched , because it began to look very credible !
akaike happened to be on sabbatical leave at harvard ; so i contacted him and he agreed to come .
i wound up inviting people from geophysics , electrical engineering , exploration seismology or seismology in geophysics
mathematics , astronomy , and statistics .
i later discovered that there had been a very successful symposium in 1962 that murray rosenblatt organized at brown university , whose proceedings had been published as a book by wiley , and that the tulsa symposium was the first thing like that , bringing people together from so many different fields .
therefore , there was really great interest in having such a symposium .
additionally , the first symposium was successful enough that , when three years later i organized another such symposium , things went very well from the beginning ! * mcelroy * : were there any econometricians at the symposium ? * findley * : yes : clive granger and rob engle , who shared the nobel prize for economics in 2003 .
they gave very interesting talks , and were delightful , very well - informed and interesting contacts for later work .
* holan * : did you keep in contact with many of the people at the symposia ? * findley * : yes , indeed . when i later left tu and came to the census bureau , i lost contact with people from the geophysics and seismology community , but i certainly maintained contact with most of the statisticians who came . in statistics , there was manny parzen , hirotugu akaike , henry gray , g. s. watson , richard h. jones , doug martin , david donoho , william dunsmuir , will gersch , genshiro kitagawa , wayne woodward and mel hinich .
the electrical engineers alan oppenheim , thomas parks , john makhoul and jerry mendel also attended , as well as the geophysicists enders robinson , sven treitel and freeman gilbert .
will gersch later came to uscb as an asa / nsf - census research fellow , with genshiro kitagawa as his research associate .
akaike , genshiro and i worked together when i visited the institute of statistical mathematics in tokyo .
my contact with akaike was very long - lasting and very fruitful for me .
just about everyone i mentioned is someone i have benefited substantially from at later times , through contacts of one kind or another .
also enders robinson can be classified as both a time series analyst and a geophysicist ; he has written a number of time series books @xcite .
his prediction error methods were very important for exploration seismology .
freeman gilbert was there .
freeman is a very well - known seismologist whom david brillinger has collaborated with .
sven treitel , a leading exploration geophysicist , was there from amoco .
so it was a stellar experience for me to interact with these people !
* holan * : what led you to leave academia for a federal career ?
maybe you could tell us a little about what the census bureau was like ; for example , what the research environment was like and how your transition from academia transpired ? * findley * : i knew of the bureau s reputation in the field of seasonal adjustment and the influence of its x-11 software .
this gave me the sense that any research done by me or my group would be noted and considered by statistical offices and central banks around the world
a larger potential audience than exists for most academic papers . also , i was sure that there would be support for implementing results of research in software designed for public use , making it much more likely that the results would be used in practice .
this is in contrast to the situation with software developed in academia , which usually can only be used by its author .
thus , i felt i could have a greater practical impact by working at uscb than by staying in academia .
finally , i knew from having lived there that the washington , dc area was intellectually stimulating in the field of statistics , because there were a large number of statisticians there .
i was looking forward to working with bob shumway at george washington university ( gwu ) , but he was on sabbatical leave at the university of california , berkeley , and then accepted a position at davis .
so , kirk wolter of uscb wrote to a number of prominent time series analysts , two of whom recommended me to him .
he then contacted me , and i came to the bureau for an interview . * mcelroy * : it is interesting that your answer to that question is almost identical to the answer that agustin maravall gives for why he chose a career at the bank of spain , namely to develop and maintain a major software package . * holan * : so , in the early development of the software that came out of census , were you the original programmer , or
did you oversee the programming?=1 * findley * : no , no ; i was not one of the programmers .
they had a programmer already hired when i came here .
he was someone with a master s degree in mathematics , but he had no background in statistics , and therefore did nt really understand what he was programming .
i was lucky , very early on , that brian monsell showed up .
brian has outstanding programming ability , and also a keen interest in making software usable .
brian was able to work easily with lots of different operating systems and write good code , which programmers at sas and other people who have translated his code have complimented .
so , one needs good luck , and brian s coming along was good luck , as was bill bell s being here , at the time !
bill supervised much of the programming having to do with time series modeling .
but , we did nt start out programming .
i mean , we started out just trying to respond to whatever the needs seemed to be .
our ultimate goal was to improve the practice of seasonal adjustment at the census bureau and elsewhere .
uscb was still using x-11 then , and had nt even made the switch to x-11-arima , so working on that transition was important , and other things came along that also seemed important .
later we realized that there were quite significant things that x-11-arima could nt do , namely estimate regression functions jointly with the arima models so that you could estimate level shifts and other outliers , as well as other kinds of user - defined regressors for special effects .
* holan * : given the production needs at the census bureau , how much time did you spend doing research ? was it your responsibility to ensure that the research have an influence on production ?
* findley * : yes , it was my responsibility . by way of background , in 1978 and then in 1980 , the census bureau had held two large seasonal adjustment conferences with many distinguished speakers , including clive granger . as part of a way of building up momentum for a new time series center at the census bureau , they had hired two statisticians one master s degree statistician and one ph.d . degree statistician in addition to the programmer i mentioned earlier , and already had them working .
kirk wolter , who knew time series analysis , as well as sample survey methodology , had been directing some work .
so , when i arrived , i had to learn about seasonal adjustment myself !
i knew that it existed as a subject and that it had connections with signal processing , but i had a learning curve to go through . but to go back to your question :
kirk wolter had established monthly meetings in which all the people in the census bureau interested in seasonal adjustment attended , and some topic that seemed to be of general interest was discussed .
i found out , perhaps in the first week , that wayne fuller , who did consulting for the census bureau , had said that he would not work on seasonal adjustment until they started doing concurrent seasonal adjustment , namely using all of the data available every month , rather than forecasting seasonal factors from december of the year before .
thus , i had a mandate right away to make a strong case for concurrent seasonal adjustment .
these monthly meetings , where the divisions discussed problems of interest to them , also provided an opportunity where we could respond to their problems ; we could also present the research results we were obtaining on the smaller revisions you got to seasonal adjustments smaller revisions after you recalculated the adjustment using later data that came for most of the time series when you used all of the data available , rather than using forecasted seasonal factors from the december before .
this kind of idea , that you should nt just use projected seasonal factors , had been a big stimulus to estela dagum to introduce arima models to forecast ahead , so that you could at least use forecasted values as replacements for the data that you were nt ready to use , or did nt even have if it went past a certain point .
so , these monthly meetings , which continued for several years , built up a rapport with the other groups in the census bureau .
i think they may have gone on for ten years .
* holan * : in those times , what was the day - to - day process like in terms of research versus production ?
for example , suppose you are sitting at your desk and you figure something out , on the topic of concurrent adjustment , and you say , `` this really looks like what we need to do . '' what was the process for getting things implemented in production back in those days ?
* findley * : it was a matter of talking about it , and presenting results in seminars . also taking series from each one of the production groups there , and giving them the results for each one of their groups .
also , there were other things to talk about .
the next big project that came along was due to someone who , without consultation or approval , seasonally adjusted the january value of a very important series , petroleum imports , that had nt been seasonally adjusted before because it did nt exhibit stable seasonal characteristics .
this happened when shirley kallek , the associate director for economic statistics , was out of town , and she decided that the published adjusted number had to be replaced with the unadjusted number .
this indicated a different direction , which was embarrassing to the government .
so she asked us to develop diagnostics to correctly ascertain when series were not good candidates for seasonal adjustment .
that set off one of the veins of my work that has continued until i left the census bureau , and is still ongoing .
so , diagnostics and model selection are the two most continuous veins of research that i have pursued during my years at the census bureau .
* holan * : so unusually for a federal employee
youve been able to visit numerous different places , and work with many different people , and spend a considerable amount of time away from the census bureau , sort of like an academic on sabbatical . *
findley * : yes ; the thing i was most nervous about in leaving academia was giving up sabbatical leaves , because i had already had one and found it very fruitful to go away for a number of months to another place , and interact with other people and share an office with someone doing something completely different , but something that turned out to be interesting to me .
it was broadening in some way .
it is the international nature of seasonal adjustment work that to some extent led to my receiving invitations to go to other places .
it was also bill bell s presence here on the time series staff , being perfectly capable of taking over for me when i was away , which was probably more important in making it possible .
these visiting positions have always been productive for me , usually enabling me to complete research related to model selection that i could nt find time for at uscb .
i have been especially fortunate to have more than one such visit to the institute of statistical mathematics ( ism ) in japan and the institute of statistical science of academia sinica in taiwan .
both have strong research groups in many areas of statistics , superb libraries and other research resources , and contacts with other organizations , including statistical offices interested in seasonal adjustment .
genshiro kitagawa has always been my host at ism , where akaike had become director .
on my first visit , he provided me with data to try out a slight modification of the order selection procedure for a vector autoregressive model - based ship autopilot , developed by him in collaboration with marine engineers .
i gave an invited presentation on this work at the 1988 american control conference @xcite .
my future gwu ph.d .
student jim cantor was in the audience , and was stimulated to later ask me to direct his dissertation work on the recursive estimation of incorrect time series models @xcite .
i also worked with yoshinori kawasaki at ism , primarily in conjunction with a series of conferences related to seasonal adjustment that alternated venues between tokyo and washington , dc over a six - year period . at academia sinica
, i worked mostly with my host and co - author ching - zong wei , whose death from a rare disease ended a remarkable research career much too soon .
i also interacted with the econometrician jin - lung lin on various topics related to seasonal adjustment .
he was at the institute of economics there , and is now dean of the college of management of taiwan s national dong hwa university in hualien .
* mcelroy * : do you feel that the major goals of time series research at uscb have been met ?
* findley * : the major goal has been to improve seasonal adjustment practice at uscb and elsewhere . this has involved the development of new procedures , models , model selection procedures and diagnostics .
of course , one must evaluate these procedures for efficacy and practicality . finally , it is necessary to implement successful innovations in software .
much of this work has proceeded incrementally , in response to urgently perceived needs or inadequacies with existing procedures or tools , or due to new opportunities for collaboration with other seasonal adjusters .
it was always assumed that we would , in the course of time , develop a new seasonal adjustment program and that we would make greater use of time series models , probably including the purely arima model - based seasonal adjustment procedure of hillmer and tiao @xcite .
george tiao and his students have had a huge impact on the use of models in seasonal adjustment .
when i arrived at the census bureau in 1980 , his students steve hillmer and bill bell were here .
hillmer was finishing his year as an asa / nsf - census research fellow with bill bell as his research associate .
bill was also finishing the writing of his dissertation , which had path - breaking results on nonstationary signal extraction relevant to model - based seasonal adjustment .
i was able to hire bill , and with occasional input and contributions from me , he led the modeling developments for the next two decades and more .
these efforts resulted in modeling innovations that were incorporated into the x-12-arima seasonal adjustment program released by uscb in the 1990s @xcite .
this software is widely used around the world . working with brian monsell and others ,
i led the development of the software s new seasonal adjustment quality diagnostics , as well as model selection options concerned with transformations ( such as logarithms ) and with nonnested choices among candidate regressors for trading day and moving holiday effects .
the uscb plans to soon release the successor to x-12-arima , which is named x-13 arima - seats .
its new capabilities include the option to produce hillmer
tiao model - based adjustments , and to compare them with x-12-arima adjustments using a common set of diagnostics .
this should lead to a greater understanding of both traditional and model - based adjustments .
the model - based adjustments will come from its incorporated version of the seats seasonal adjustment program , thanks to the collaboration of its designer , agustin maravall of the bank of spain .
equally vital to this undertaking has been the outstanding software development ability and statistical understanding of brian monsell , who now leads the time series group .
he and bill bell were my most important hires .
* mcelroy * : over your career you have made many contributions to model selection and seasonal adjustment . of the different projects and papers you have worked on , are there any favorites that you have or that particularly stand out in your mind ? * findley * : this is a question i might give a different answer to every time it is asked !
three papers come to mind in model selection .
i have the feeling that the 1991 aism paper @xcite i did on counter - examples to bic and other parsimonious model selection criteria has some value .
it has been cited fairly often .
what i showed there was that when you are working with models that are not correct , and you are making nonnested model comparisons , that one unneeded parameter s estimate can cause problems for forecasting or parameter estimation , in general , that are significantly larger than the influence of another parameter that is not needed .
in other words , we tend to think : if you have @xmath0 unneeded parameters , then the distribution to describe this is a @xmath1 distribution or something like this , and there is a kind of homogeneity to the effects of these unneeded parameters ; but it is not true in the case of nonnested incorrect model comparisons .
much of my research from early on has tried to address the situation of incorrect models , and i recommended the use of aic at the census bureau , because there is some justification and demonstrable practical advantages for making comparisons between nonnested models with it .
this is something that comes up often in seasonal adjustment , and i think in statistics in general .
additionally , there are nt really systematic ways of addressing nonnested model comparisons .
i m also very pleased with the 2002 jmva paper @xcite i wrote with ching - zong wei on a rigorous development of aic for vector autoregressive models .
there were some powerful new mathematical results that others have used , which were in that paper .
but also the paper contains a precise theory of over - fitting , which says that if you have these unneeded parameters , they are going to corrupt the good results you might have obtained from these models , using an independent replicate of the data .
in this situation , i was able to develop a theory of over - fitting , so that you can take the difference of the likelihood functions and use that as some kind of measure of over - fit .
mathematicians and statisticians talk about over - fitting , but here was a case where i could prove some results and come up with a rather precise measure
it is pretty theoretical , but at least it s a handle on the concept of over - fitting , making it a precise concept .
a third paper that comes to mind is the one i just completed with tucker , published in the 2010 jspi special issue honoring manny parzen @xcite ; because , again , in one case it is another kind of likelihood ratio test for nonnested model comparisons . that paper is generally concerned with the problem of testing the forecasting performance of competing models that is , if you have a statistical test that involves saying , `` these two models are equally good at forecasting , one is not better than the other , '' then you would like to have a test of some kind of this hypothesis .
we analyze an in - sample measure of forecast error , and use as our null hypothesis that these two models forecast equally well , and were able to derive a test statistic , in particular an asymptotic distribution for the difference of the two forecast error measures and a consistent estimate of the variance of this asymptotic distribution which we could use to form a statistic you could use to test whether one model is better than the other .
i had started on this topic , in the context of likelihood ratio tests , in the early 1980s .
i had obtained an asymptotic distribution for the likelihood ratio in the nonnested model case , having been inspired by the work of the econometrician quong vuong , who had done similar things for regression models , but i had never been able to find a consistent variance estimate for the asymptotic distribution , and tucker and i were able to obtain that in our paper .
now , when we find time , we re at work generalizing this to the vector autoregressive situation . those are the papers i like that are concerned with model selection . for seasonal adjustment papers , i particularly like papers that have had good expository value .
i was invited to write a paper that would be the journal of business and economics statistics invited paper for the 1996 joint statistical meetings @xcite , and i wrote that with bill bell and other staff members brian monsell , bor - chung chen and mark otto and we really got a lot of ideas about seasonal adjustment and the role of models and model selection , and even estimation .
it was a discussion paper , and that brought up a lot of other ideas .
so , i regard that as a valuable paper .
i would like to mention the 2006 journal of official statistics paper i did with donald martin on properties of time - domain filters , seasonal adjustment filters applied to nonstationary series that really account for the fact that we are working with a finite sample , and which examined the effects of phase delay @xcite .
i am also very pleased with a paper that catherine hood and i wrote @xcite , just setting out our procedures for seasonally adjusting a bunch of time series we have never seen before .
specifically , how we go about choosing program settings for them , or perhaps even deciding whether they should be seasonally adjusted at all .
the paper was written for a conference sponsored by the italian statistical office , where they gave out a dozen or so time series and asked people to analyze them .
subsequently , i have been very glad to have that paper available to hand out to people when i have taught seasonal adjustment courses .
i like the new trading day regressor that brian monsell and i came up with , which is described in our 2009 journal of official statistics paper @xcite .
it seems to do very well with stock series ( e.g. , inventories ) , better than the regressors we ve had before .
akaike stressed to me the importance of models , and bill bell s concentration on models from his education under george tiao and george box , has certainly reinforced the power of models to me . to convey statistical information , and good statistical practice
, models are an extremely concentrated way of presenting information to people doing statistical work .
* holan * : in 1987 you were elected fellow of the american statistical association .
can you tell us a little bit about your award ? * findley * : yes , the award had particular meaning for me because , while i had had some coursework in stochastic processes in my applied mathematics ph.d .
studies , i had no formal training in statistics or time series analysis .
the award confirmed for me that i had successfully established myself as a statistician and time series analyst .
i was delighted when alan izenman came up to me the day after the award with a warm smile and handshake saying , `` now no one can say you are nt a statistician ! '' * mcelroy * : well , you are now retired from your position at the census bureau .
are there future plans for research , and are you still active in research ? what sorts of things are you doing ?
* findley * : as i mentioned , i am interested in the research you and i are doing in extending our forecasting and likelihood ratio tests to the vector situation , at least for vector autoregressive models .
i should have mentioned that a special aspect of this research is that the effect at least when multi - step ahead forecasting is involved of parameter estimation is taken into account in these tests , in a way that has not been done before with time series models .
so i think the paper s important for that reason , too that it is kind of a breakthrough .
i hope someday we will find a way to understand what gain and phase function graphs mean for nonstationary time series : i think there is some hope for this when only one differencing is involved in transforming the data to stationarity .
but we havent seen any reason to be optimistic under more complicated differencing operations !
i have some other papers on model selection that i have never written up .
i hope i ll get around to writing those up , in time mostly having to do with aic , but for arima models rather than ar models .
also i would like to look at other situations , say where you re trying to decide `` should i use a weibull distribution or a logistic distribution to model a certain kind of data ? ''
i had a project on that , where i got some pretty formulas , but never quite the theory needed to justify the formulas .
* holan * : so , you ve probably experienced a lot of changes in statistics over the years .
what is your assessment of the state of statistics in general and the future of seasonal adjustment in particular ? * findley * : i do nt feel qualified to comment on the state of statistics in general .
but in terms of impact on statistics , the internet has been the most important development!for disseminating data , for disseminating meta - data associated with the data , for disseminating software , for disseminating the results of research , and for maintaining contact with users .
brian monsell gets many messages every month with seasonal adjustment questions ; tucker and i get messages from people we have taught seasonal adjustment courses to and other places , that sometimes turn into research problems and papers . in seasonal adjustment , with the release of x-13 arima - seats , we have just now gotten to the point where it is possible to compare the results of a model - based seasonal adjustment and a seasonal adjustment from the older x-11 filter methodologies .
i think that will be valuable and that , from having one software package , we will learn more about both methods
. we will be able to produce the adjustments easily and at the same time produce some diagnostics that make it easy to compare some aspects of the seasonal adjustments .
basically , you could say that if you run both methods and they give pretty similar results , you should feel very good and not think there is much to worry about ; and if they produce rather different results , it would be very good if you could come up with some kind of understanding of why that is so .
i think both methods have different strengths and different weaknesses , and so i think that this software will help improve the practice of seasonal adjustment .
i also believe that there is room for further variations on the use of these methods .
when akaike developed his baysea program @xcite , it essentially forecasted a moving window of data ; you could set it to take four or five or more years of data , and it would produce a seasonal adjustment of that set of data , and then move to another interval .
additionally , it would take the center adjustment , from however many overlapping spans , as being the final adjustment ; so there would be two years of data in this five year case , in which you would revise the seasonal adjustment .
the econometrician david hendry at oxford , where i visited recently , is very keen on the idea that econometricians should , in many instances , be using moving windows to do the modeling and analyses of data that they want to do .
akaike did this in baysea , that was a kind of structural modeling setup , but i think there is reason to utilize this approach in other cases . you need more than five years of data to estimate arima coefficients , and perhaps seven or eight years of data to estimate arima coefficients well , and you also need about that much data to estimate coefficients for trading day effects and moving holidays like easter , so there is some limitation on how small our estimation window can be .
but maybe there are some tricks we do nt know about in terms of improving parameter estimates in smaller samples .
i think there are still some interesting options to be explored in seasonal adjustment .
i also think that the software that the national bank of belgium is developing for the european statistical office , which is intended to become an official seasonal adjustment software package for the european statistical office , could be of great benefit if it comes out to be as simple to modify and add to as the plan of jean palate , the person directing its development at the national bank of belgium .
new diagnostics and new variations on arima models or other models for seasonal adjustment could be implemented quickly , and tested , and retained if practice shows them to be valuable .
* mcelroy * : on a different note , you have been in washington , dc many years now .
what was the intellectual culture like when you first came here , and how has it changed ?
* findley * : i think dc has for a very long time been an intellectually exciting place in the general sense , because there is a tremendous amount of scientific research done at the universities and the large industrial consulting firms that work on military projects . there is a large number of chapters of the institute of electronic engineers ; the washington statistical society is very large , and has almost weekly seminars . specifically for seasonal adjustment
, there were more people active in seasonal adjustment research at the time i came here at least outside the census bureau , that is to say .
david pierce and bill cleveland were at the federal reserve board ; bob mcintyre was there along with some other people , as well as stuart scott , tom evans and dick tiller at the bureau of labor statistics ( bls ) .
so maybe things at bls are like they were before .
but to speak for the census bureau , i think the arrival of bob groves to be the director and the coming of rod little to fill the newly restarted position of associate director for research andmethodology , will be very exciting .
these areworld - class statisticians in their various branches of work , both of whom have spent substantial amounts of time at the census bureau before , and are going to be very supportive of research of many different kinds , and very knowledgeable in terms of how they make budget decisions regarding research .
i believe our time series staff is still quite strong , so i am quite optimistic about the continued stimulating intellectual atmosphere in the census bureau.=1 * holan * : you brought up something interesting , namely that you developed a lot of software .
your background is mostly in theoretical mathematics , and then you developed software along the way , and did a lot of applied work .
i think , in general , the field of statistics has changed over the last thirty years , with the greater emphasis on computing .
also , certainly upon entering the workplace today , one needs a different skill set than was the case twenty years ago .
what do you see are the important things for people to learn in school , in order to be successful in this environment ? *
findley * : i think i can only speak to what the census bureau would like to see in young statisticians : some training in time series analysis , and some knowledge of a programming language it could be c or something else , but more than just knowledge of a statistical package like sas .
knowledge of r would be a great asset , because that is probably the most important proto - typing language in statistics now
i certainly think that is true for time series analysis
. it would be great if people knew some sampling methodology too , which is taught irregularly at universities , as is time series .
experimental design would be a good thing .
we re always looking for people who can work on experimental design projects that come up at the census bureau in various contexts . *
mcelroy * : well , it s been good talking to you . i know that some time ago you had a statistical science conversation with hirotugu akaike , that you conducted in collaboration with manny parzen @xcite
can you tell us a little about that interview ? * findley * : it was wonderful to be able to work with manny .
it was my idea to have the interview , but manny agreed to work with me as soon as i asked him .
manny was the person in the united states who discovered akaike , who became aware of the work akaike was publishing in japanese journals , and of its very high quality and considerable interest .
this is discussed in the interview , so i think the interview was substantially richer for manny s participation in it .
it was a delight to have this kind of collaboration with manny , whom i ve known for a long time , and asked for assistance on certain other projects , but never done any joint research with .
i learned some interesting things from the interview .
the statement about models being an extremely compressed and portable form of information , is something akaike said in the interview .
another thing he said , was that he did nt like vector autoregressive models , at least initially , because it s so hard to make sense of all the coefficients .
but , he discovered they were extremely powerful in applications , so he decided to like them !
the other thing he said was that a visit he made to princeton , where john tukey was , at tukey s invitation , was very influential for him .
he had been very theoretically based , his doctorate was in mathematics from the university of tokyo , and he had done some reading in statistics .
however , akaike said at princeton he saw tukey give a lecture on robust methods and outliers .
tukey , who was revered as a mathematician ( e.g. , tukey s lemma in topology among other contributions ) presented methods that seemed very sensible , but which lacked a mathematical foundation .
it was very helpful for akaike to see that this was acceptable ; that is , that it seemed a sensible way to practice statistics .
i have felt that , if you ca nt find an appropriate theory to justify what you re doing , but it seems to be producing sensible results , do nt give up on the search for a stronger foundation , but do nt give up on the method either!=1 * mcelroy * : it seems to be a good motto !
anything else you would like to add ? * findley * : it s been very important to whatever success i ve had at uscb and elsewhere , to have really good colleagues to work with .
i think most of us benefit from interactions with colleagues with different backgrounds from ours , but particularly when you are doing applied work and when you are trying to produce software that other people can use , you have to have the right people to work with .
it also helps when you are trying to solve a very difficult theoretical problem , like some of the problems i have worked on with ching - zong wei !
it s certainly important to have some luck .
bill bell was here when i came , brian monsell showed up afterward , and there have been other excellent people that came and left over the years .
i was lucky that the mathematics department at the university of tulsa had its particular composition of mathematicians who knew you could become a time series analyst without formal training .
but i have to say , i am very grateful for the opportunities the census bureau has given me .
i have always gotten good support for my work , even things like permission to go off for months to some other place !
so it has been a very good place to work , and i have no reason to think that the statistical research division is nt just as good a place now to work as it was before , when i was here full time . *
holan * : well , thank you for giving us this opportunity to talk with you today . *
findley * : sure .
* mcelroy * : thank you very much .
the authors would like to thank the editor , jon wellner , for providing a suggestion that helped improve this article .
holan s research was partially supported through the `` summer at census '' research program ( 2010 ) .
this paper is released to inform interested parties of ongoing research and to encourage discussion of work in progress .
the views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the u.s . census bureau . | david findley was born in washington , dc on december 27 , 1940 . after attending high school in lyndon , kentucky , he earned a b.s .
( 1962 ) and m.a .
( 1963 ) in mathematics from the university of cincinnati .
he then lived in germany , studying functional analysis under gottfried kthe , obtaining a ph.d . from the university of frankfurt in 1967 .
returning to the united states , he served as a mathematics professor at the university of cincinnati until 1975 . having transitioned from pure mathematics to statistical time series analysis , findley took a new academic position at the university of tulsa , during which time he interacted frequently with the nearby research laboratories of major oil companies and consulted regularly for cities service oil company ( now citgo ) . in 1980
he was invited to lead the seasonal adjustment research effort at the u.s .
census bureau , and eventually rose to be a senior mathematical statistician before his retirement in 2009 . in 1966
he married mary virginia baker , and they currently live in washington , dc .
david findley has published more than 40 journal articles and book chapters , as well as dozens of technical reports and conference proceedings , many of which are heavily cited and influential .
he has also published two edited volumes ( 1978 and 1981 ) that have had a substantial impact on the field of time series analysis .
numerous honors and awards have accrued to him , including asa fellow ( 1987 ) , the julius shiskin award ( 1996 ) and the u.s .
department of commerce gold medal ( 1997 ) .
. the initial conversation between david findley , scott holan and tucker mcelroy took place on july 13 , 2010 at the u.s . census bureau .
holan and mcelroy later obtained clarifications of certain points from david findley during the following year . |
hl tau is a very young solar - type star surrounded by a dusty circumstellar disk and a remnant envelope .
the object is located at a distance of @xmath3140 pc ( loinard et al . 2007 ) , within the taurus star - forming region . showing all ingredients of a young system in the earliest stages of planet formation ,
hl tau has attracted a lot of attention over the years . for a summary of the early observational data and the results of the first comprehensive radiative transfer modeling we refer to dalessio et al .
( 1997 ) and menshchikov , henning & fischer ( 1999 ) .
hl tau drives an ionized jet indicating on - going accretion ( e.g. , pyo et al .
2005 , anglada et al .
early interferometric observations revealed that emission at cm wavelengths traces the radio counterpart of this collimated jet , while the emission at wavelengths @xmath4 1.3 cm predominantly traces dust emission from a disk ( rodrguez et al .
1994 , wilner et al .
this source attracted renewed interest after high angular resolution interferometric observations indicated that the hl tau disk , despite its youth , may already be forming planets .
observations performed with the combined array for research in millimeter - wave astronomy ( carma ) at 1.3 and 2.7 mm ( @xmath320 - 120 au resolution ) suggested a gravitationally unstable disk which might undergo fragmentation ( kwon et al . 2011 ) . very large array ( vla ) observations at 1.3 cm ( @xmath312 au resolution ) revealed a compact structure in the disk at 65 au radius , interpreted as a protoplanet candidate ( greaves et al .
subsequent high sensitivity vla observations at 7.0 mm ( @xmath37 au resolution ) could not confirm this putative proto - planet , but found evidence for a depression at radius @xmath5 au in the radial density profile of the disk , which was interpreted as being related to the presence of an orbiting protoplanet ( carrasco - gonzlez et al .
2009 ) . with the long baselines of the atacama large millimeter / submillimeter array ( alma ) becoming available ( alma partnership et al .
2015a ) , this facility produced iconic images of the dust emission at 2.9 , 1.3 , and 0.87 mm from the hl tau disk ( @xmath33.5 to 10 au resolution ) , showing a number of axisymmetric bright and dark rings , most probably corresponding to high and low density concentric dust structures in the disk ( alma partnership et al .
the images immediately triggered numerous theoretical works in order to explain these remarkable structures .
planet - related explanations range from the presence of embedded sub - jupiter mass planets ( picogna & kley 2015 , dipierro et al .
2015 , dong et al .
2015 ) to individual more massive planets ( gonzalez et al .
alternative explanations include magnetized disks without planets ( flock et al . 2015 ) , fast pebble growth near condensation fronts ( zhang et al . 2015 ) , and sintering - induced dust rings ( okuzumi et al .
2016 ) . the presence of massive planets ( @xmath310 - 15 m@xmath6 ) in two prominent dips in the dust distribution at @xmath370 au was excluded utilizing deep direct l band imaging with the large binocular telescope ( lbt ) ( testi et al .
2015 ) , but the presence of lower - mass planets in the disk is not yet excluded and remains an interesting possibility .
detailed radiative transfer analysis of the alma data shows that the emission from the various bright rings is probably optically thick , even at the longest alma wavelength of 2.9 mm ( pinte et al .
2016 , jin et al .
the challenge of deriving density profiles and grain size distributions can only be circumvented by observations at even longer wavelengths where the disk will be optically thinner . in this letter , we present new high - sensitivity karl g. jansky vla observations at 7.0 mm of the hl tau disk .
this data provide a deeper view of the hl tau disk , with an angular resolution comparable to the alma images .
we observed hl tau with the vla of the national radio astronomy observatory ( nrao ) using the q band receivers in the c , b , and a configurations ( see table [ tab1 ] for details ) .
we observed the frequency range 39 - 47 ghz ( central wavelength @xmath7 7.0 mm ) .
calibration of the data was performed with the data reduction package common astronomy software applications ( casa ; version 4.4.0 ) , using a modified version of the nrao calibration pipeline .
images were made with the casa task clean using multi - scale multi - frequency synthesis that fits the emission with a taylor series with nterms=2 during the deconvolution ( rau & cornwell 2011 ) . since our multi - configuration observations are sensitive to emission at very different scales ( from @xmath316@xmath82240 au to 0@xmath905@xmath77 au ) , we made images with different angular resolutions by adjusting the briggs robust parameter ( briggs 1995 ) and the gaussian uv - taper in clean .
we also made images by splitting the 8 ghz band in two sub - bands of 4 ghz each ( central wavelengths 6.7 and 7.3 mm ) . for comparison ,
images were aligned by assigning to the position of the central peak of the alma images the same absolute coordinates than in the vla images , @xmath10(j2000)=04@xmath1131@xmath1238@xmath13426 , @xmath14(j2000)=18@xmath1513@xmath1657@xmath923 . in figures [ fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] we present the vla images with different angular resolutions and comparisons with the alma images .
we obtained radial profiles of the intensity of the alma images and our most sensitive vla image at 7.0 mm ( natural weighting ; beam size@xmath70@xmath9067 ) . for a proper comparison , we convolved all images to a common circular beam size of 0@xmath907 ( the smallest beam size obtained from the public 2.9 mm alma uv - data with a uniform weighting ) . from these images
, we obtained the average intensity within concentric elliptical rings of 0@xmath901 width at different radii , using the task iring of the astronomical image processing system ( aips ) .
the dimension and orientation of the elliptical rings match those of the hl tau disk derived from the alma images ( inclination angle , @xmath1746.72@xmath15 , and position angle , [email protected]@xmath15 ; alma partnership et al .
2015b ) .
some contamination from free - free emission from the hl tau jet is expected at 7.0 mm . from our 6.7 and 7.3 mm sub - band images
we obtain a spectral index of @xmath31 at the center of the disk , consistent with comparable contributions from free - free and dust emission . to correct for the free - free contamination , we calibrated vla a configuration archival data at 6 and 2 cm ( project code : 12b-272 ) where emission is dominated by a partially optically thick radio jet in the ne - sw direction . from these images ,
the frequency dependence of the jet s flux density and angular size ( major axis ) can be expressed as @xmath18^{0.4}$ ] @xmath19jy and @xmath20^{-1}$ ] , respectively , consistent with previous 7 mm observations ( e.g. wilner & lay 2000 ) .
thus , an upper limit to the free - free contribution at 7.0 mm is obtained by extrapolating the flux density from cm wavelengths with a spectral index of 0.4 , while a lower limit can be obtained by assuming free - free emission becomes optically thin at 2 cm ( i.e. , spectral index of @xmath210.1 from 2 cm to shorter wavelengths ) .
therefore , we expect unresolved ( @xmath220@xmath907 ) free - free emission with a flux density in the range @xmath3200 - 400 @xmath19jy corresponding to @xmath335 - 65% of the 7.0 mm emission at the disk center .
this correction implies a larger uncertainty in the dust intensity at the center of the disk . from the corrected intensity profiles , we derived brightness temperatures at each wavelength using the planck equation for blackbody radiation , and we computed spectral indices between different wavelengths .
we also derived profiles of optical depth and column density ( assuming dust temperature power - laws and opacity , see 3.1 ) .
radial profiles are shown in figure 3 .
the recent alma images of the hl tau disk revealed several dark and bright rings ( named d1-d7 and b1-b7 , respectively ) ( fig . [ fig1 ] ) .
our new 7.0 mm vla observations are the most sensitive and highest angular resolution observations of the hl tau disk performed to date at such a long wavelength .
the low - angular resolution 7.0 mm image shows an elliptical source with similar size and orientation as the alma images ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ) . at higher angular resolution ,
the vla is able to image with high signal - to - noise ( s / n ) ratio ( @xmath234-@xmath24 ) the 7.0 mm emission from the inner half of the disk ( @xmath450 au ; see figs .
[ fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] ) . in our 7.0 mm images
we clearly identify several of the features seen in the alma images : the central disk and the first pair of dark ( d1 ) and bright ( b1 ) rings ( figs .
[ fig1]-[fig3 ] ) .
the importance of our sensitive 7.0 mm images is that , at such long wavelength , the emission has lower optical depth than in the alma data .
this is especially critical for the study of the innermost part of the disk , where dust becomes opaque at all alma wavelengths and , as a consequence , physical properties are poorly constrained even with detailed modeling ( e.g. pinte et al .
2016 , jin et al .
2016 ) . at the positions of the most opaque regions ,
the center of the disk and the first bright ring , the 7.0 mm brightness temperatures ( @xmath345 and 15 k , resp . ) are @xmath34 times lower than those of the alma 0.87 mm image ( @xmath3130 and 60 k , resp . ) . therefore , assuming that at 0.87 mm the emission from these two structures is optically thick , we obtain optical depths @xmath40.4 at 7.0 mm .
this imply that dust emission at 7.0 mm is well optically thin at all radii , even in the densest parts of the disk . our new high sensitivity 7.0 mm images of the hl tau disk are an excellent basis for future comprehensive radiative transfer modeling to accurately obtain the physical properties of the disk .
they are especially necessary in order to better constrain properties in the inner disk regions , where terrestial planets are thought to form , in principle . in the following ,
we analyze our vla images of the hl tau disk to obtain direct rough estimates of the different physical parameters ( e.g. , mass and grain size distributions ) .
we also analyze possible substructure in the disk and discuss our results in the context of planet formation .
an accurate determination of the mass distribution in the hl tau disk requires detailed radiative transfer modeling . for this paper , we obtain first estimates by assuming a simple power - law for the dust temperature in the form @xmath25 . while the exponent seems to be well constrained in the range @xmath26=0.5 - 0.6 by previous studies , there is large uncertainty in the reference temperature , with different proposed values in the range @xmath2770 - 140 k at @xmath28=10 au ( e.g. , menshchikov et al . 1999 ,
kwon et al .
2011 , pinte et al .
2016 ) . for the dust opacity at 7.0 mm
, we use a range of typical values for the disk - averaged opacity , @xmath290.13 - 0.2 @xmath30 g@xmath31 ( e.g. , menshchikov et al . 1999 ,
prez et al . 2012 ) .
thus , at each radius , we calculate ranges for the optical depth and the dust column density taking into account these uncertainties ( see fig . [ fig3 ] ) .
our calculations are consistent with the inner features of the disk being optically thick at all alma wavelengths , while at 7.0 mm the emission is optically thin at all radii ( see fig .
[ fig3]b ) .
we estimated values of the dust column density around @xmath31 g @xmath32 at the center of the disk ( see fig .
[ fig3]c ) .
this suggest a denser disk at inner radii ( @xmath2250 au ) than previously obtained by detailed modeling ( e.g. , pinte et al .
2016 predict @xmath40.2 g @xmath32 at the center of the disk ) .
we also estimated dust masses for the inner disk ( i d ) and the bright rings ( b1 to b6 ; see table [ tab2 ] ) . for those features which are optically thin in the alma images ,
i.e. b2-b6 , we obtain dust masses consistent with previous estimations ( pinte et al .
however , our optically thin 7.0 mm data suggest large dust masses for the inner disk and the first bright ring ( b1 ) for which only lower limits were obtained previously ( see table [ tab2 ] ) .
finally , we estimate that the total dust mass of the disk is within the range ( 1 - 3)@xmath010@xmath1 m@xmath2 , which is also somewhat larger than previous estimates , @xmath3(0.3 - 1)@xmath010@xmath1 m@xmath2 ( e.g. , menshchikov et al .
1999 , dalessio et al .
1997 , kwon et al .
2008 , pinte et al .
2016 ) .
grain growth and mixing lead to changes in particle - size distribution and dust composition throughout the disk ( henning & meeus 2011 ) .
this has been recently studied in several objects for which segregation by particle - size ( e.g. menu et al .
2014 ) and radial changes in dust optical properties ( e.g. guilloteau et al .
2011 , prez et al .
2012 , 2015 ) are observed . the fully resolved alma and vla images of the hl tau disk offer now an excellent opportunity for a detailed study of the properties of the particle - size distribution in a very young disk .
in particular , changes in the dust properties can be inferred from changes in the spectral index of the emission , @xmath10 , but only for optically thin emission in the rayleigh - jeans regime ( e.g. beckwith et al .
2000 ) . when derived from the short alma wavelengths ,
the observed radial variations of @xmath10 , from @xmath32 to 2.5 ( figure [ fig3]d ) , reflect high optical depths inwards of @xmath350 au .
thus , these alma observations can not be used to infer grain growth in the densest , inner disk regions .
in contrast , the observed radial variations of @xmath10 derived from the two most optically thin wavelengths , 7.0 and 2.9 mm , show a different behavior : ( 1 ) at all radii , except at the location of the dark gap d5 , we obtain @xmath33 , consistent with the emission at shorter wavelengths being more optically thick and not in the r - j regime , and ( 2 ) a clear gradient in @xmath34 is observed between @xmath310 - 50 au , consistent with a change in the dust optical properties and a differential grain - size distribution , with larger grains at smaller radii .
similar results have been inferred for a number of more evolved disks ( e.g. prez et al .
2012 , 2015 ; tazzari et al .
2016 , menu et al .
2014 ) .
some more evolved transitional disks , when observed at long wavelengths , show knotty rings of dust emission ( e.g. , hd 169142 ; see fig .
1c in osorio et al . 2014 ) .
our highest angular resolution vla images of the young hl tau disk also reveal an interesting knotty and not axisymmetric morphology of the first bright ring ( b1 ) ( see fig . [
most of the knots seem to be consistent with small ( 1-@xmath24 ) fluctuations of the brightness ( due to the rms noise of the map ) , suggesting a structure with a roughly uniform brightness .
however , to the ne , there is a compact knot ( labeled as clump candidate " in figs .
[ fig2]b - d ) whose morphology is very different to the rest of the ring .
we made several images with different angular resolutions and different bandwidths ( see 2 ) , and noted that , while the knotty emission changes significantly in different images ( consistent with being small fluctuations in a uniform structure ) , the ne knot is clearly identifiable and the most compact knot in all the images ( see figs .
[ fig2]c and [ fig2]d ) .
this knot also coincides with a local intensity maximum in the 1.3 mm alma image ( see fig .
all this suggests that the 7.0 mm ne knot traces a real structure in the first bright ring .
we note that the position of the ne knot is coincident with the direction of the jet , and thus it could be related to a local increase in the flux density because of the foreground free - free emission .
however , at 7.0 mm , the free - free emission from the jet is expected to be confined within the inner disk ( see 2 ) . moreover , from our sub - band images we derive a spectral index @[email protected] , suggesting that the emission from this knot is dominated by thermal dust emission .
we also noted that this spectral index is slightly smaller than the average spectral index obtained for b1 from 7.0 and 2.9 mm ( see fig . [ fig3 ] ) , suggesting an accumulation of larger dust grains in the clump .
it is known that dense rings could undergo vortex formation by the rossby wave instability and efficiently concentrate large particles ( meheut 2012 ) , then , we speculate that the ne knot traces a dense dust clump formed within the massive bright ring . in this case , we estimate a dust mass in the range 3 - 8 m@xmath37 for this clump . the presence of dark and bright concentric rings has been commonly interpreted as the result of planet formation already ongoing in the hl tau disk .
however , since hl tau is a very young t tauri star , the presence of several ( proto)planets sufficiently massive to carve holes in the disk at this early stage is somewhat surprising . on the other hand , alternative formation mechanisms , not requiring the presence of protoplanets , seem also possible .
moreover , sensitive searches for massive ( proto)planets in the outer dark rings have yielded negative results ( see 1 and references therein ) .
we propose a scenario in which the hl tau disk may have not formed planets yet , but rather is in an initial stage of planet formation . instead of being caused by ( proto)planets , the dense rings could have been formed by an alternative mechanism . our 7.0 mm data suggest that the inner rings are very dense and massive , and then , they can be gravitationally unstable and fragment .
it is then possible that the formation of these rings result in the formation of dense clumps within them like the one possibly detected in our 7.0 mm image .
these clumps are very likely to grow in mass by accreting from their surroundings , and then they possibly represent the earliest stages of protoplanets . in this scenario ,
the concentric holes observed by alma and vla would not be interpreted as a consequence of the presence of massive ( proto)planets .
instead , planets may be just starting to form in the bright dense rings of the hl tau disk .
_ acknowledgments .
_ cc - g , lfr and rg - m acknowledge support from unam - dgapa papiit ia101715 and ia102816 .
lmp acknowledges support from the alexander van humboldt foundation .
tb acknowledges support from the dfg grant ( kl 1469/13 - 1 ) .
ga , em , mo , and jmt acknowledge support from mineco and feder funds .
this paper makes use of the following alma data : ads / jao.alma#2011.0.00015.sv .
alma is a partnership of eso ( representing its member states ) , nsf ( usa ) and nins ( japan ) , together with nrc ( canada ) , nsc and asiaa ( taiwan ) , and kasi ( republic of korea ) , in cooperation with the republic of chile .
the joint alma observatory is operated by eso , aui / nrao and naoj .
lccc obs . &
project & & on - source + date & code & conf . &
total time + 2014-dec-07 & 14b-485 & c & 1.7 h + 2015-feb-15 & 14b-485 & b & 1.6 h + 2015-aug-13 & 14b-487 & a & 1.1 h + 2015-aug-25 & 14b-487 & a & 1.1 h + 2015-sep-19 & 14b-487 & a & 1.7 h + 2015-sep-20 & 14b-487 & a & 3.8 h + 2015-sep-21 & 14b-487 & a & 3.4 h + ccccc & & flux density & & + covered disk & radius & at 7.0 mm & + feature & ( au ) & ( mjy ) & this paper@xmath38 & pinte et al.@xmath39 + i d & @xmath2213 & 0.61 @xmath36 0.04 & 10 - 50 & @xmath232.3 + b1 & 13 - 32 & 1.45 @xmath36 0.02 & 70 - 210 & @xmath2347 + b2 & 32 - 42 & 0.48 @xmath36 0.01 & 30 - 90 & 30 - 69 + b3 & 42 - 50 & 0.35 @xmath36 0.01 & 20 - 80 & 14 - 37 + b4 & 50 - 64 & 0.36 @xmath36 0.01 & 30 - 90 & 40 - 82 + b5 & 64 - 74 & 0.18 @xmath36 0.01 & 10 - 50 & 5.5 - 8.7 + b6 & 74 - 90 & 0.45 @xmath36 0.01 & 40 - 140 & 84 - 129 + | the first long - baseline alma campaign resolved the disk around the young star hl tau into a number of axisymmetric bright and dark rings . despite the very young age of hl tau these structures
have been interpreted as signatures for the presence of ( proto)planets .
the alma images triggered numerous theoretical studies based on disk - planet interactions , magnetically driven disk structures , and grain evolution .
of special interest are the inner parts of disks , where terrestrial planets are expected to form .
however , the emission from these regions in hl tau turned out to be optically thick at all alma wavelengths , preventing the derivation of surface density profiles and grain size distributions . here
, we present the most sensitive images of hl tau obtained to date with the karl g. jansky very large array at 7.0 mm wavelength with a spatial resolution comparable to the alma images . at this long wavelength
the dust emission from hl tau is optically thin , allowing a comprehensive study of the inner disk .
we obtain a total disk dust mass of ( 1 - 3)@xmath010@xmath1 m@xmath2 , depending on the assumed opacity and disk temperature .
our optically thin data also indicate fast grain growth , fragmentation , and formation of dense clumps in the inner densest parts of the disk .
our results suggest that the hl tau disk may be actually in a very early stage of planetary formation , with planets not already formed in the gaps but in the process of future formation in the bright rings . |
the formation and the properties of random structures have been an exciting topic in statistical physics for many years . in the case
that the formation of such structures obeys local rules , these processes can often be expressed in the language of epidemic spreading .
it is well - known that two special spreading processes referred to in this language respectively as simple epidemic with recovery or gribov process @xcite and epidemic with removal ( general epidemic process ) lead to random structures with the properties of percolation clusters : directed percolation @xcite in the former case and isotropic percolation in the latter .
the gribov process , also known in elementary particle physics as reggeon field theory ( rft ) @xcite , is a stochastic multiparticle process that describes the essential features of a vast number of growth phenomena of populations without exploitation of the environment near their extinction threshold .
the transition between survival and extinction of the population ( infected individuals ) is a nonequilibrium continuous phase transition phenomenon and is characterized by universal scaling laws .
the gribov process belongs to the universality class of local growth processes with absorbing states @xcite such as the contact process @xcite and certain cellular automata @xcite , and it is relevant to a vast range of models in physics , chemistry , biology , and sociology . as usual , we refer to this universality class as the directed percolation ( dp ) universality class . for recent reviews
see @xcite .
a continuum description of dp in terms of a density @xmath5 of infected individuals typically arises from a coarse - graining procedure in which a large number of microscopic degrees of freedom are averaged out .
their influence is simply modelled as a gaussian noise - term in a langevin equation .
the process has to respect the absorbing state condition : @xmath6 is always a stationary state .
then the minimal stochastic reaction - diffusion equation for the density @xmath7 is constructed as @xcite@xmath8 \,n\left ( \mathbf{r},t\right ) \nonumber\\ & + \zeta\left ( \mathbf{r},t\right)\ , .
\label{langgl}\ ] ] the gaussian noise @xmath9 must also respect the absorbing state condition , whence @xmath10 up to subleading contributions .
the history of the process in space and time defines directed percolation clusters in a ( @xmath11)-dimensional space . the minimal process defined by eqs .
( [ langgl ] ) and ( [ langnoise ] ) contains all the relevant terms needed for a proper field theoretic description of dp . in realistic situations
the infection can be also long - ranged .
one may think , e.g. , of an orchard where flying parasites contaminate the trees practically instantaneous in a widespread manner if the timescale of the flights of the parasites is much shorter than the mesoscopic timescale of the epidemic process itself .
thus , following a suggestion of mollison @xcite , grassberger @xcite introduced a variation of the epidemic processes with an infection probability distribution @xmath12 which decays with the distance @xmath1 as a power law , @xmath13 .
we will somewhat casually refer to such long - range infection as lvy - flights although a true lvy - flight is defined via its fourier transform as @xmath14 with @xmath15 ( to ensure positiveness of the distribution ) .
in fourier space and in a long - wavelength expansion , the langevin equation ( [ langgl ] ) can be generalized to account for lvy - flights by a term proportional to @xmath16 . in the case of @xmath17 , the long - wavelength behavior
is naively dominated by this new term .
grassberger calculated critical exponents in a 1-loop calculation which were discontinuous in the limit @xmath18 , and therefore the applicability of the results was doubtful . in a former paper @xcite ,
we have shown by applying the wilson momentum shell renormalization group that only two of the critical exponents are independent in long - range dp , and that the critical exponents change continuously when the transition line between long - ranged and short - ranged spreading ( with an @xmath19 ) is crossed .
we have also shown that @xmath20 exactly , where @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 are the usual exponents of short - ranged dp in @xmath0 ( transversal ) dimensions .
these results have been confirmed numerically by hinrichsen and howard @xcite .
note that @xmath25 , which corresponds to the fisher - exponent of equilibrium critical phenomena , is negativ here @xcite .
for a recent review for dp with long - range interactions see @xcite . in this paper
we reconsider the problem using methods of renormalized field theory in conjunction with an expansion in @xmath4 and @xmath26 .
the remainder of this paper is organized as follows : section [ sec : model ] reviews the field theoretic formulation of dp with lvy - flight spreading to set the stage , to provide background information and to establish notation .
section [ sec : model ] first reviews the short - range limit of this model and then discusses our field theoretic analysis of the long - range limit .
section [ sec : hybridmodel ] represents the main part of this paper .
it treats in detail the hybrid model for @xmath27 .
section [ sec : criticalbehavior ] builds up on the results of sec .
[ sec : hybridmodel ] and present results for the critical exponents and logarithmic corrections of various dynamical observables .
section [ sec : concludingremarks ] contains some concluding remarks .
to generalize the diffusional infection rate in the langevin equation ( [ langgl ] ) , we model spreading by writing @xmath28 as a particular model for the positive distribution @xmath12 which contains all relevant properties , we use @xmath29 with a short - range contribution @xmath30 and a lvy - flight part @xmath31 .
@xmath32 denotes a microscopic length scale which , for simplicity , is assumed to be equal in both otherwise independent distributions . fourier transformation leads to @xmath33 and @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the modified bessel - function with index @xmath36 .
long - wavelength expansion leads to @xmath37 \nonumber\\ & + o(q^{4},q^{2+\sigma})\label{inf - spread}\ ] ] with positive , non - singular , @xmath38-dependent constants @xmath39 and @xmath40 .
@xmath41 shows the two typical terms : diffusion @xmath42 and lvy - flights @xmath43 .
it is ir - stable , that is @xmath44 is positive in both regions @xmath45 and @xmath46 if @xmath47 .
note the characteristic pole at @xmath48 that leads to a logarithmic contribution @xmath49 to @xmath50 for @xmath51 . in
the following we use for @xmath52 its long - wavelength approximation ( [ inf - spread ] ) . whereas @xmath52 is always a positive real quantity , its long - wavelength approximation changes the sign at a magnitude @xmath53 of the momentum of order @xmath54 if @xmath46 or if @xmath45 and @xmath55 which leads to a pole in the greens function of the equation of motion .
of course this pole is a non - physical ghost ; it arises when the long - wavelength approximation is used in a momentum regime where it is inapplicable .
this happens in particular in dimensional regularization where integrations over internal momenta are extended to infinity .
hence , this method may become inconsistent if both types of @xmath56-dependencies , @xmath57 and @xmath58 , are used in common .
we come back to this question in sec .
[ sec : landaughost ] .
in contrast , wilsons momentum shell renormalization procedure avoids this dangerous uv - region @xmath59 because all momenta are restricted to the sphere @xmath60 with @xmath61 .
this was the reason for using wilson s renormalization group in our former publication @xcite .
note also , that dimensional regularization leads in the present problem like in other similar problems to the so - called triviality problem at the upper critical dimension , i.e. , the dimensionally regularized theory misses logarithmic corrections and thus has to be viewed as an effective theory for low momenta .
the stochastic equation of motion of the dp - process with the lvy - flight spreading and short - range diffusion can be written as @xmath62 n\left ( \mathbf{r},t\right ) \nonumber\\ & -\left [ \tau+\frac{1}{2}g\,n\left ( \mathbf{r},t\right ) \right ] n\left ( \mathbf{r},t\right ) + \zeta\left ( \mathbf{r},t\right ) \
, , \label{langgl - lr}\ ] ] where we set @xmath63 . here
the lvy - term on the right side is defined in fourier space as @xmath64 . in order to develop a renormalized field theory , it is useful to recast the langevin equation ( [ langgl - lr ] ) as a dynamic response functional @xcite @xmath65 & = \int d^{d}r\,dt\,\lambda\tilde { s}\bigg\ { \lambda^{-1}\partial_{t}+\left [ \tau-\nabla^{2}+c\left ( -\nabla^{2}\right ) ^{1-\alpha}\right ] \nonumber\\ & + \frac{g}{2}\left ( s-\tilde { s}\right ) \bigg\ } s\,,\label{j - anfang}\ ] ] where @xmath66 is the rescaled density which ensures that @xmath67 and for which the time inversion symmetry @xmath68 ( rapidity reversal in rft ) holds .
@xmath69 is a response field that describes the response when a local particle source @xmath70 is added to the langevin equation ( [ langgl - lr ] ) . at the level of the dynamic response functional
, this source leads to an additional term @xmath71 in eq .
( [ j - anfang ] ) . having the dynamic response functional , correlation and response functions
can be computed as functional averages ( path integrals ) of monomials of @xmath72 and @xmath73 with weight @xmath74 . throughout this paper , functional integrals
are interpreted in the sense of the so - called prepoint - discretization that sets the step function @xmath75 equal to zero for @xmath76 @xcite .
we stress that the usual short - ranged dp - model is recovered from the general expression of @xmath77 simply by setting @xmath78 , or @xmath79 with @xmath80 . as a first step towards the renormalization group ( rg ) analysis of this model ,
we discuss its canonical scaling behavior . introducing the usual inverse length scale @xmath81
, we readily find @xmath82 .
for @xmath83 , the long - range lvy - term @xmath84 naively dominates the usual diffusion term @xmath85 .
hence , we may neglect the latter for @xmath83 , and we redefine ( by rescaling of some parameters ) @xmath79 .
this produces an inverse time scale @xmath86 , and @xmath87 for the scaling of the control parameter .
moreover , we obtain @xmath88 , where @xmath89 ( we will reserve the symbol @xmath4 for the short - range case , i.e. , @xmath90 )
. the naive dimension of the coupling constant @xmath91 allows us to identify the upper critical dimension @xmath92 .
this boundary separates trivial ( mean - field or gaussian ) from non - trivial long - range behavior if @xmath83 .
of course , the boundary @xmath80 , @xmath93 separates the regions with trivial long - range and trivial short - range dp , and the boundary @xmath94 , @xmath95 separates trivial and non - trivial short - range dp .
we now turn to perturbation theory . in this section , we will first briefly review the short - range model obtained for @xmath78 , which has been discussed previously at many places ( see @xcite and the references cited therein ) .
then we will treat , also briefly , the long - range model obtained for @xmath96 . as usual in dynamical field theory ,
we focus on those correlation and response functions @xmath97^{n}[\tilde{s}]^{\tilde{n}}\right\rangle\end{aligned}\ ] ] that require renormalization due to the presence of ultraviolet ( uv ) divergences in feynman diagrams as well as the corresponding one - particle irreducible ( 1pi ) vertex functions with @xmath98 ( @xmath99 external @xmath73- ( @xmath72- ) legs , @xmath100 . for background on the methods of renormalization theory
, we refer to @xcite .
we first review ordinary dp which is modeled by @xmath77 as given in eq .
( [ j - anfang ] ) with @xmath78 @xcite .
the upper critical dimension is @xmath101 .
straightforward dimensional analysis shows that there are three superficially divergent vertex functions : @xmath102 , @xmath103 , where the last relation follows from time inversion symmetry . in the following ,
we use the superscript @xmath104 denote bare ( unrenormalized ) couplings , and we use the following renormalization scheme to cure the model of its uv divergences @xmath105 where @xmath106 is a convenient amplitude , @xmath107 represents the dimensionless coupling constant , and the control parameter @xmath108 is zero at the critical point . in dimensional regularization ,
the critical bare value of the control parameter , @xmath109 , is of the form@xmath110 where the symanzik function @xmath111 has simple ir - poles at each @xmath112 with @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 .
hence , @xmath109 is not a perturbational quantity and is formally zero in the @xmath116-expansion .
note , however , that minimal renormalization , i.e. , dimensional regularization in conjunction with minimal subtraction , does not imply the @xmath4-expansion @xcite .
the renormalization factors @xmath117 are functions of @xmath107 and have in minimal renormalization the expansions@xmath118 where the @xmath117 are determined in such a way that the perturbation expansions of renormalized quantities are free of singularities if @xmath4 goes to zero .
they are given to second order by @xcite@xmath119 a renormalization group equation ( rge ) for the model can be derived in a routine fashion by exploiting the fact that the unrenormalized response and correlation functions have to be independent of the inverse length scale @xmath81 introduced by renormalization .
this reasoning leads straightforwardly to the rge @xmath120 g_{n,\tilde{n}}=0\ , , \label{rge - sr}\ ] ] with an rge differential operator @xmath121 ( the @xmath122 indicates that bare quantities are kept fixed while taking the derivates ) given by @xmath123 the rg functions result from the finite logarithmic derivatives of the renormalization factors@xmath124 as@xmath125 their perturbation expansions are@xmath126 u\ , . \label{rge - fu - sr}\ ] ] the asymptotic solution of the rge , eq .
( [ rge - sr ] ) , leads to the stable fixed point @xmath127 with @xmath128 given by @xmath129 , \label{u - dp}\ ] ] as the stable solution of @xmath130 , and to the scaling form @xmath131 of the response and correlation functions , with the three independent critical exponents@xmath132 these are the very well known critical exponent for short - range dp . to second order in @xmath4-expansion ,
they are given by @xmath133 , \nonumber\\ z_{sr } & = 2-\frac{\varepsilon}{12}\left [ 1+\left ( \frac{67}{288}+\frac { 59}{144}\ln\frac{4}{3}\right ) \varepsilon+o(\varepsilon^{2})\right ] , \nonumber\\ \nu_{sr } & = \frac{1}{2}+\frac{\varepsilon}{16}\,\left [ 1+\left ( \frac { 107}{288}-\frac{17}{144}\ln\frac{4}{3}\right ) \varepsilon+o(\varepsilon ^{2})\right ] .
\label{exp - sr - eps}\ ] ] as we have shown in @xcite by using wilson s momentum - shell renormalization group , and as we discussed in the introduction , the discontinuity of short - range and long - range critical exponents at @xmath80 is spurious and can be remedied . in renormalized field theory ,
the key is to recognize @xcite that there is a region of small @xmath27 , where a careful analysis of the rg flow reveals a smooth connection between the @xmath94 , @xmath135 , and @xmath83 regions . here
, we analyze the last case , which belongs to the true long - range region .
the case @xmath136 being a hybrid between short - range and long - range models , will be deferred to the next subsection .
we recall from our discussion at the end of sec .
[ sec : model ] that the upper critical dimension for @xmath137 is @xmath92 , and we define @xmath138 , to be distinguished from @xmath90 .
considering the response functional @xmath77 , eq .
( [ j - anfang ] ) with @xmath139 , we see that the operator @xmath140 is superficially irrelevant compared to @xmath141 and may be dropped formally in the limit @xmath134 .
this limit is feasible after the rescaling @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 .
the canonical dimensions of the fields do not change compared to the short range model .
however , the inverse time - scale changes to @xmath86 , and the canonical dimensions of the remaining parameters are @xmath145 and @xmath146 . as above @xmath102and @xmath103 are superficially divergent for @xmath147 . moreover ,
all divergent contributions to any vertex function are polynomial in the momenta , so that the operator @xmath148 needs no counterterm .
hence , we use the renormalization scheme@xmath149 which produces the renormalized response functional @xmath150 \nonumber\\ & + \bar{z}_{u}^{1/2}\frac{g}{2}\left ( s-\tilde{s}\right ) \bigg\ } s\ , .
\label{j - lr}\ ] ] here and in the following we use an overbar to distinguish the renormalization factors of the long - range and hybrid models from those of the short range model .
@xmath151 is a suitable amplitude whose precise definition will be given later . here , in minimal renormalization ,
@xmath152 with an appropriate symanzik function @xmath153 having simple poles at @xmath154 with @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 .
note by comparing eq .
( [ renschemsr ] ) with eq .
( [ renschemlr ] ) that the renormalization schemes for the short - range and the long - range models are of the same form except for the renormalization factor of the kinetic coefficient , which now is @xmath155 .
here , we have the expansions@xmath156 of course , the functions @xmath157 are different from the functions @xmath158 and have be determined by perturbation theory .
nevertheless , the rg functions for the long - range case can be transcribed from the short - range case , eqs .
( [ rge - sr ] ) , ( [ rge - d ] ) and ( [ log_diff ] ) simply by decorating each rg - function with an overbar and setting @xmath159 , i.e. , @xmath160 the scaling form of the response and correlation functions follows from the rge as @xmath161 with the @xmath162 and @xmath163 given by @xmath164 the third exponent , @xmath165 , is related to these exponents by the exact relation @xmath166 hence , we have only two independent critical exponents in the long - range case , viz.@xmath162 and @xmath163 . after this general discussion
, we now turn to our actual perturbation calculation .
the propagator of the theory reads @xmath167 in wavevector - time representation .
note that the prepoint discretization mandates that we have to use @xmath168 throughout @xcite .
note also , that the propagator is free of the ghost - problem , i.e. , the exponent is always negative . the 1-loop self - energy with frequency @xmath169 and wavevector @xmath170 as the first contribution to the vertex function @xmath102 reads @xmath171 to calculate this self - energy , it is useful to expand in @xmath170 and @xmath169 and to use the identity@xmath172 which leads the calculation of the primitive divergent 1-loop diagrams back to integrals of the usual known short - range type .
we obtain@xmath173 where we have displayed only the pole - terms in @xmath174 .
the pole at @xmath175 is an ir - pole and can be removed by introducing a new mass parameter @xmath176 instead of @xmath108 via introducing @xmath177 ( keeping in mind that it is an ir - poles , one may also simply ignore it in the @xmath174-expansion ) .
the amplitude @xmath151 is defined by@xmath178 note , that @xmath151 becomes @xmath179 if @xmath180 . expanding @xmath181 in @xmath182 , and using the renormalization scheme eq .
( [ renschemlr ] ) , we arrive at the singular part of the vertex function @xmath183 in 1-loop approximation@xmath184 as announced above , there is no singular term proportional to @xmath185 . using the same techniques , we get @xmath186 for the singular part of the other superficially divergent vertex functions .
we read off the 1-loop renormalizations of the long - range model @xmath187 the rg functions here have the expansions @xmath188 instead of those given in eq .
( [ def - rgfu - lr ] ) for the short - range model .
the stable fixed - point is @xmath189 , and the expansions to first order of the long - range critical exponents are @xmath190 which should be compared to the short - range exponents given in eq .
( [ exp - lr ] ) .
as has to be the case , our 1-loop results ( [ exp - lr - exp ] ) are in perfect agreement with the 1-loop results for the long - range exponents derived in @xcite by wilson s method .
here , we turn to the analysis of the key region in @xmath191 space , namely , @xmath27
. the naive @xmath192 limit of the long - range model presupposes @xmath193 and hence fails to resolve the crossover between the sr and lr models which occurs for @xmath27 . for both @xmath26 and @xmath4 small
, we follow the work of honkonen and nalimov @xcite .
our starting point is the renormalized response functional @xmath65 & = \int dt\,d^{d}r\,\bar{\lambda } \tilde{s}\left\ { \bar{z}\bar{\lambda}^{-1}\partial_{t}+\bar{z}_{u}^{1/2}\frac{\bar{g}}{2}\left ( s-\tilde{s}\right ) \right .
\nonumber\\ & \left .
+ \left [ \bar{z}_{\tau}\bar{\tau}-\bar{z}_{\lambda}\nabla ^{2}+c\left ( -\nabla^{2}\right ) ^{1-\alpha}\right ] \right\ } s\ , \label{j - hybr}\ ] ] where we use the renormalization scheme@xmath194 and the abbreviations @xmath195 and @xmath196 . as before
, the term @xmath141 does not need a counter term as long as @xmath197 . using the approach by he honkonen and nalimov
, we construct our renormalization factors @xmath198 by generalizing the minimal renormalzation program that led to the expansions ( [ z - expsr ] ) and ( [ z - explr ] ) . here , the renormalization factors are now functions of @xmath199 and @xmath200 , and they contain poles of all linear combinations @xmath201 with @xmath202 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 and @xmath203 , @xmath204 , @xmath114 , @xmath115:@xmath205 where the coefficients @xmath206 can be chosen such that they are independent of @xmath4 and @xmath26 if both are of the same order .
to explain this , let us consider the primitive divergence of an irreducible diagram consisting of @xmath207 vertices @xmath208 propagators @xmath209 independent loops , and @xmath210 external amputated legs . by definition ,
a primitive divergence is a divergence that arises if all the @xmath211 inner momentum integrations tend uniformly to infinity . in primitive diagrams , they are the only uv - divergences . in non - primitive diagrams , they are the divergences that remain after all divergences of the renormalization parts of the diagrams are tamed by lower order counterterms . after time integrations over the @xmath212 time segments each between vertices , any diagram has the qualitative form@xmath213 here ,
the mass @xmath214 is a linear combination of the control parameter @xmath108 and frequencies @xmath169 and serves as an ir regulator .
@xmath215 is a momentum cutoff , and @xmath216 is the degree of primitive divergence of the diagram . using the topological relations @xmath217 and @xmath218 , hence @xmath219 , we obtain@xmath220 the first part , @xmath221 , is the superficial divergence of the diagram with @xmath210 legs .
the second part , @xmath222 , denotes the combination which is converted to a simple pole in dimensional regularization .
this pole - term must be eliminated by a counterterm if both @xmath4 and @xmath26 become small quantities .
thus , the overall form of the renormalization factor is as given in eq .
( [ z - exp - hybr ] ) . up to now , the constants @xmath223 may still be functions of @xmath4 and @xmath26 .
however , if @xmath224 is finite in the limit @xmath225 , we can neglect this dependencies in the sense of the minimal renormalization .
hence , we can apply this honkonen - nalimov scheme only if @xmath27 .
next , we calculate the logarithmic derivatives of the renormalization factors .
note that in minimal renormalization the only terms of the @xmath21-functions , @xmath226 and @xmath227 , which contain @xmath4 and @xmath26 explicitly come from the @xmath81-factors making @xmath228 and @xmath229 dimensionless , ( cf .
( [ renschem - hyb ] ) ) , i.e. , @xmath230 and @xmath231 .
thus , we obtain from eq .
( [ z - exp - hybr ] ) @xmath232 which should be compared to eq .
( [ log_diff ] ) of the short - range case .
now we can the relate the functions @xmath233 to the original dp - functions @xmath234 , eq .
( [ log_diff ] ) , pertaining to the short - range case . to this end
, we consider the hybrid response functional and its renormalizations for @xmath80:@xmath235 \right\vert _ { \alpha=0 } & = \int dt\,d^{d}r\,\bar{\lambda}\tilde{s}\bigg\ { \bar{z}\bar{\lambda}^{-1}\partial_{t}+\bar{z}_{\tau}\bar{\tau}-\left ( \bar{z}_{\lambda}+w\right ) \nabla^{2 } \nonumber\\ & + \bar{z}_{u}^{1/2}\frac{\bar{g}}{2}\left ( s-\tilde{s}\right ) \bigg\ } s\ , .
\label{j - hybr - alpha-0}\ ] ] this functional takes on the form of the original short - range dp response functional , @xmath65 & = \int dt\,d^{d}r\,\lambda\tilde{s}\bigg\ { z\lambda^{-1}\partial _ { t}+z_{\tau}\tau - z_{\lambda}\nabla^{2 } \nonumber\\ & + z_{u}^{1/2}\frac{g}{2}\left ( s-\tilde{s}\right ) \bigg\ } s\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] if we identify the parameters@xmath236 and the renormalization factors@xmath237 the last identifications lead , by comparison of eq .
( [ z - exp - hybr ] ) with eq .
( [ z - expsr ] ) , to the relations@xmath238 in the case of @xmath239 , @xmath240 , and @xmath241 , and to@xmath242 in the case of @xmath243 .
collecting , we obtain for the logarithmic derivatives , eq .
( [ gamma - hybr ] ) , @xmath244 using the renormalizations ( [ renschem - hyb ] ) , the rg functions become , @xmath245 however , eqs .
( [ param - ident ] ) and ( [ gamma - ident ] ) suggest that it is more appropriate to use instead of @xmath246 , @xmath247 , @xmath199 , and @xmath200 the parameters @xmath248 , @xmath108 , and @xmath107 defined by eq .
( [ param - ident ] ) , and @xmath249 as the parameters of the theory .
the response functional then becomes @xmath65 & = \int dt\,d^{d}r\,\lambda\tilde { s}\bigg\ { z\lambda^{-1}\partial_{t}+z_{\tau}\tau - z_{\lambda}\nabla^{2}\nonumber\\ & + \frac{v}{2\alpha}\left [ \mu^{2\alpha}\left ( -\nabla^{2}\right ) ^{1-\alpha } + \nabla^{2}\right ] + z_{u}^{1/2}\frac{g}{2}\left ( s-\tilde{s}\right ) \bigg\ } s\ .
\label{j - hybr - final}\ ] ] note , that @xmath77 coincides up to a rescaling with @xmath250 , eq .
( [ j - lr ] ) , if @xmath251 .
note also , that the gradient terms of this response functional take the same form as proposed for the long - wavelength or gradient expansion of the general long - range spreading , eq .
( [ inf - spread ] ) .
hence , we expect the same difficulties concerning the positivity of the propagator for momenta @xmath252 and @xmath46 if @xmath253 .
the rg functions for the new variables are easily derived from eq .
( [ def - rgfu - overbar ] ) by using eqs .
( [ gamma - ident ] ) , @xmath254 in comparison with the short - range rg functions , eq .
( [ def - rgfu ] ) , the new gell - mann low function @xmath255 as well as the functions @xmath256 , @xmath257 , and @xmath258 have only an additive contribution of the variable @xmath259 . note that we have to consider both @xmath107 and @xmath259 as being parameters of order @xmath260 . in terms of the new variables ,
the rge is still of the form given in eq .
( [ rge - sr ] ) , however , here @xmath261 has to be inserted as the rg differential operator . in this subsection
we analyze the different scaling regions in a @xmath263-diagram using the results on the hybrid model derived in sec . [
sec : hybridmodelren ] .
the asymptotic scaling of response and correlation functions is governed by the various fixed points of the renormalization group . to find stable fixed points of the rge and the corresponding scaling behavior
, we have to find solutions of the equations @xmath264 with the gell - mann low functions @xmath256 and @xmath255 as given in eqs .
( [ rgfu - hybr ] ) .
the different fixed points can be classified by setting to zero the different factors of these functions .
there is the trivial fixed point @xmath265 . to find its stability conditions we determine the eigenvalues of its stability matrix@xmath266 the eigenvalues of this matrix , @xmath267 and @xmath268 , are positive for @xmath93 and @xmath46 , i.e. , we retrieve the mean - field region of short - range dp . another fixed point , the trivial long - range fixed point , is given by @xmath269 , @xmath270
. its stability matrix reads @xmath271 where the stroke at @xmath272 denotes the derivative with respect to @xmath107 .
the eigenvalues @xmath273 and @xmath274 are positive for @xmath275 , @xmath45 which marks the region of stability of the trivial long - range fixed point .
next we come to the fixed point @xmath276 , @xmath277 , as the solution of @xmath278 .
of course , this is the fixed point of the normal short - range dp with @xmath279 .
the stability matrix is@xmath280 the first eigenvalue of this matrix , @xmath281=@xmath282 shows the stability range of non - trivial short - range dp : @xmath283 . using @xmath284
, we find the stability condition against long - range spreading : @xmath285 now , we come to the interesting lr - region where @xmath277 and @xmath286 . in this domain ,
the stable fixed points of ( [ rgfu - hybr ] ) are solutions of the fixed point equations @xmath287 using the @xmath288-functions which follow from eq .
( [ z_sr ] ) , and which have been utilized in eq . ( [ rge - fu - sr ] )
, we find the fixed point @xmath289 , \nonumber\\ v_{\ast}^{lr } & = 2\alpha+\frac{\bar{\varepsilon}}{14}\left [ 1-\left ( 17 - 526\ln\frac{4}{3}\right ) \frac{\bar{\varepsilon}}{392}+o\left ( \bar{\varepsilon}^{2},\alpha\bar{\varepsilon}\right ) \right ] .
\label{uw - lr}\ ] ] the critical exponents in the lr - region are found from eq .
( [ rgfu - hybr ] ) as @xmath290 and @xmath291 with the expansions@xmath292 \,,\
\nonumber\\ 1/\nu_{lr } & = \sigma-\frac{2\bar{\varepsilon}}{7}\left [ 1+c_{\nu}(\alpha)\bar{\varepsilon}+o\left ( \bar{\varepsilon}^{2}\right ) \right ] \
, , \label{exp - lr - exp - hyb}\ ] ] where @xmath293 note that we have already encountered the first order contributions in eq .
( [ exp - lr - exp ] ) above .
of course , @xmath165 follows from the exact relation ( [ lr - exrel ] ) .
the stability matrix for this fixed point reads @xmath294 with @xmath295 .
the two eigenvalues are given by@xmath296 they are positive as long as @xmath297 .
this condition leads to @xmath298 and @xmath299 .
the long - range fixed point looses its stability if the line @xmath300 is reached . at that point ,
all critical exponents change over continuously to the usual short - range dp - exponents as can be easily seen from eq .
( [ rgfu - hybr ] ) .
hence , stability boundary of the long - range lvy - flight exponent @xmath63 is given by@xmath301 \ , , \label{stabbound}\ ] ] which is less than two .
this fact is astonishing because for @xmath38 lower then @xmath114 but greater then @xmath302 , the long - range part @xmath303 is naively irrelevant in comparison to the normal diffusional part @xmath304 .
however , in an interacting theory it is not the free propagator but rather the response function @xmath305 which is the deciding quantity .
hence , one has to compare @xmath303 with @xmath306 to find out which is leading for @xmath307 .
the other stability boundary is approached if @xmath128 goes to zero , and is given by @xmath308 .
this boundary coincides with the value found above : @xmath309 . at this line
the exponents cross over to their long - range mean - field values . to summarize our findings regarding the scaling regions : all boundaries between the four scaling regions , namely short - ranged dp , long - ranged dp , as well their two mean - field counterparts , are generally given by the four lines in a @xmath310-diagram where one or two of the fixed point values @xmath311 and @xmath312 vanish .
there is no room for other stability lines as some authors argued @xcite .
as we have remarked at several points , the propagator becomes problematic for higher momenta .
consider the @xmath56-dependent part of the inverse renormalized propagator of the hybrid theory , @xmath313 , \ ] ] where @xmath314 to ensure stability ( positivity ) for @xmath315 for both signs of @xmath26 .
the part proportional to @xmath259 changes sign and leads to a loss of stability for negative @xmath26 at a momentum @xmath53 given by @xmath316 for small @xmath26 .
this ghost reminds of landau s ghost in quantum electrodynamics .
the momentum of the ghost goes exponentially to infinity if @xmath317 .
this ghost even arises for positive @xmath26 if @xmath253 .
the fixed point of the hybrid theory does always belong to this region !
the correct interpretation is the following : our asymptotic theory is just an effective theory in the sense that it can only be used in the low momentum limit in a perturbation expansion with @xmath259 as an expansion parameter .
therefore , the second part of eq .
( [ prop ] ) must be considered as a perturbation .
let us demonstrate this in some detail for the inverse response function @xmath102 as an example . to this end
, we work to 1-loop order using @xmath107 , @xmath259 , @xmath4 , and @xmath26 as first order quantities .
the zeroth order is @xmath318 using renormalized perturbation theory , adding both first order terms , and neglecting higher order terms , we obtain @xmath319 + \ldots\nonumber\\ & = \lambda q^{2}\left [ 1-v\ln\left ( \frac{q}{\mu}\right ) + \frac{u}{8}\ln\left ( \frac{q}{2\mu}\right ) \right ] + \ldots\nonumber\\ & = \left ( 1-\frac{u}{8}\ln2\right ) \lambda q^{2}\left [ 1+\left ( \frac { u}{8}-v\right ) \ln\left ( \frac{q}{\mu}\right ) \right ] + \ldots\ ] ] now we use the fixed point result @xmath320 with @xmath321 , to get@xmath322 + \ldots \nonumber\\ & \sim\lambda q^{2\left ( 1-\alpha\right ) } \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] as expected , the rg proves to be the systematic tool to resum all logarithms to yield the correct critical exponent .
this procedure holds for all @xmath323 irrespective of the sign as long as the fixed point with @xmath324 is stable .
otherwise @xmath276 , @xmath325 , and one gets @xmath326 with @xmath327 , i.e. , the known behavior for the short - range case .
we once more point out that the second term ( the lvy - flight contribution ) has to be handled as a perturbation to the desired order and not as a part of the unperturbed propagator .
also , one has to interpret the special case @xmath80 as a relevant logarithmic perturbation @xmath328 of @xmath304 . only if @xmath259 is strictly zero the short range case is recovered .
thus , one can not expect a continuous behavior at @xmath80 comparing the short - range versus the lvy - flight directed percolation .
in this section we will harvest some of our previous results to calculate scaling forms and logarithmic correction for those dynamic quantities in long - ranged dp that are most suitable from the vantage point of numerical simulations @xcite .
two key observables with respect to simulations are the density of infected individuals @xmath329 for @xmath330 if the initial state at time @xmath76 is prepared with a homogeneous initial density @xmath331 , and the response function @xmath332 that yields the density of infected individuals after the epidemic is initialized by a pointlike source at @xmath76 and @xmath333 .
the scaling properties of the density of infected individuals and the response function follow from the rge ( [ rge - sr ] ) taken at the long - range fixed point of eq .
( [ rgfu - hybr ] ) and by identifying @xmath334 and @xmath335 with the green functions @xmath336 and @xmath337 , respectively . the initial density @xmath331 is introduced into the the response functional via a ( bare ) source @xmath338 with renormalization @xmath339 @xcite , which leads to an additional derivative term @xmath340 in the rge .
we obtain the scaling forms@xmath341 where the @xmath342 are appropriate scaling functions .
we drop in this section all the subscripts at the critical exponents because we are interested in the long - range case only .
hence , @xmath343 and @xmath344 , see eqs .
( [ exp - lr - exp - hyb ] ) , and @xmath345 , @xmath346 , @xmath347 .
the expansions of the latter two are@xmath348\ , , \nonumber\\ \theta & = \frac{\bar{\varepsilon}}{7\sigma}\left [ 1+c_{\theta}(\alpha ) \bar{\varepsilon}+o\left ( \bar{\varepsilon}^{2}\right ) \right ] \ , , \label{exp - lr - exp - hyb-2}\ ] ] where @xmath349 at the critical point @xmath350 , eqs .
( [ scal - obs ] ) show that the mean square radius of spreading from the origin scales as @xmath351 , and the average number of infected individuals @xmath352 .
starting with a homogeneous finite value @xmath331 , the critical density first increases in a universal time regime with the same exponent as @xmath353 .
then , after some crossover time , it decreases as @xmath354 . if one starts with a full lattice of infected sites corresponding to an infinite initial value @xmath331 ,
only the last scaling behavior is seen .
because of asymptotic time - reflection invariance of dp ( duality symmetry ) this behavior characterizes also the survival probability @xcite , @xmath355 . to first order all exponents are identical to the lr - exponents derived from eqs .
( [ exp - lr - exp ] ) , of course .
the full @xmath26-content of the functions @xmath356 in eqs .
( [ exp - lr - exp - hyb ] ) and ( [ exp - lr - exp - hyb-2 ] ) must be calculated from the long - range model , eq .
( [ j - lr ] ) .
hence , one has to be careful when applying the expansions to @xmath357 for @xmath80 , e.g. , in @xmath358 where @xmath359 . in figs .
[ fig : z ] to [ fig : theta ] , we compare our results for the exponents @xmath24 , @xmath360 and @xmath361 to numerical results for @xmath358 by hinrichsen @xcite . for this comparison , we use the first order expansions in @xmath174 ( red curves ) , which are exact in @xmath26 , and the second order expansions in @xmath174 where we neglect the @xmath26 dependent parts of the @xmath356 ( green and blue curves ) .
the green curves show our second order result for @xmath24 and results obtained for @xmath360 and @xmath361 by using without further expansion the scaling relations relating @xmath360 and @xmath361 to @xmath24 and @xmath23 .
the blue curves stem from using these scaling relations and then properly expanding @xmath360 and @xmath361 to second order in @xmath174 . for @xmath38 in the range from @xmath362 to roughly @xmath204 , the numerical data and the analytic results agree remarkably well . for larger @xmath38 sigma ,
the agreement suffers , but is well within the expectations for the methods used here . as a function of @xmath38 for @xmath358
the data points stem from simulations by data by hinrichsen @xcite .
the red ( upper ) and the green ( lower ) curve correspond to our 1-loop and 2-loop results , respectively.,width=317 ] as a function of @xmath38 for @xmath358 . for an explanation of the curves ,
see the main text.,width=317 ] as a function of @xmath38 for @xmath358 .
the color - coding of the curves is the same as in fig .
[ fig : delta].,width=317 ] above the boundary between the genuine and the trivial long - range regions ( @xmath363 , @xmath45 ) , the coupling constant @xmath91 tends to zero under the rg .
however , @xmath91 represents a dangerously irrelevant variable here , since it scales various observables , and setting @xmath364 rigorously leads either to zero or infinity for relevant quantities . due to its twofold nature as both a relevant scaling variable and an irrelevant loop - expansion generating parameter , @xmath91 has to be treated very carefully . to set the stage for such a treatment ,
let us briefly review a few fundamentals of dynamic field theory . in broad terms , one attempts to determine the cumulant generating functional defined by the functional integral@xmath365 & = \ln\int\mathcal{d}\left [ \tilde{s},s\right ] \exp\big [ -\mathcal{j}_{\mathrm{lr}}\left [ \tilde{s},s\right ] + \left ( h , s\right ) \nonumber\\ & + ( \tilde{h},\tilde{s } ) \big ] \,.\label{kumgen}\ ] ] functional derivatives with respect to the sources @xmath366 and @xmath367 define the green s functions .
the generating functional for the vertex functions @xmath368 $ ] , the dynamic free energy , is related to the cumulant generating functional via the legendre transformation@xmath369
+ \mathcal{w}_{\mathrm{lr}}\left [ h,\tilde{h}\right ] = \left ( h , s\right ) + \left ( \tilde{h},\tilde { s}\right ) , \label{leg - tr}\ ] ] with @xmath370 and @xmath371 , and vice versa . in terms of @xmath372 , the twofold nature of @xmath91
is lucidly exposed by writing @xmath373=g^{-2}\phi_{\mathrm{lr}}[g\tilde { s},gs;\tau , u]\ , .
\label{lucid - gamma}\ ] ] the expansion of the functional @xmath374 $ ] into a series with respect to @xmath107 yields the loop expansion . the zeroth term @xmath375 $ ] is just the response functional @xmath376 , eq . ( [ j - lr ] ) , itself . the scaling form of the generating functional for the cumulants that corresponds to eq .
( [ lucid - gamma ] ) reads@xmath377=g^{-2}\omega_{\mathrm{lr}}[gh , g\tilde{h};\tau , u]\ , .
\label{lucid - w}\ ] ] to leading order in the logarithmic corrections , we may neglect the dependence of @xmath378 and @xmath379 on @xmath107 .
functional derivation lead the to the green s functions@xmath380 where @xmath381 are the contributions of loopless trees consisting of @xmath382 propagators and @xmath383 vertices .
the characteristic equations that follow from the rg - functions , eqs .
( [ rgfu - lr - exp ] ) , with @xmath384 and @xmath309 , are to lowest order given by @xmath385 solving these equations , we obtain asymptotically for @xmath386 , @xmath387 hence , we get @xmath388 ^{(n+\tilde{n})/2}\nonumber\\ & \times t_{n,\tilde{n}}\left ( \{\ell\mathbf{r},\ell^{\sigma}x_{\lambda } ( \ell)t\},\ell^{-\sigma}x_{\tau}(\ell)\tau,\bar{u}(\ell)^{1/2}\ell^{-\sigma } x(\ell)^{1/2}\rho_{0}\right ) \nonumber\\ & \sim\left\vert \ln\ell\right\vert \,\left [ \ell^{\sigma}\left\vert \ln \ell\right\vert ^{-3/7}\right ] ^{n+\tilde{n}}\nonumber\\ & \times t_{n,\tilde{n}}\left ( \{\ell\mathbf{r},\ell^{\sigma}\left\vert \ln\ell\right\vert ^{1/7}t\},\ell^{-\sigma}\left\vert \ln\ell\right\vert ^{-2/7}\tau,\ell^{-\sigma}\left\vert \ln\ell\right\vert ^{-3/7}\rho _ { 0}\right ) \label{as - green}\ ] ] as solutions of the entire rge . choosing either @xmath389 or @xmath390
, we deduce that at the critical point @xmath391 in the initial time region , @xmath392 in the late time region , and @xmath393 ^{2/\sigma } \ , .
\label{logkorrekt1}\ ] ]
in summary , we studied dp with lvy - flight spreading by using the powerful methods of renormalized field theory .
our work confirms the previously known rg fixed point structure including their stability regions and the fact that the critical exponents change continuously in the crossover between short - range dp and lvy dp .
we calculated the critical exponents for lvy dp , which have hitherto been known to first order , to second order in an expansion in @xmath4 and @xmath26 .
these results agree well with the existing numerical simulations for @xmath358 .
in addition , we calculated the leading logarithmic corrections for several dynamical observables that are typically measured in simulations .
we hope that our work stimulates further interest in long - range dp
. it would be interesting to see further simulation results , e.g. , for the critical exponents for @xmath394 and for logarithmic corrections .
also , it would be interesting to have analytical and numerical results for other universal quantities such as scaling functions and amplitudes . in a forthcoming paper
we will apply the same methods to the long - range gep , that is to dynamic isotropic percolation .
janssen , z. phys .
b : cond . mat . * 23 * , 377 ( 1976 ) ; r. bausch , h.k .
janssen , and h. wagner , z. phys .
b : cond . mat .
* 24 * , 113 ( 1976 ) ; h.k .
janssen , in _ dynamical critical phenomena and related topics _
( _ lecture notes in physics _
104 ) , ed .
enz , ( springer , heidelberg , 1979 ) . | it is well established that the phase transition between survival and extinction in spreading models with short - range interactions is generically associated with the directed percolation ( dp ) universality class . in many realistic spreading processes , however , interactions are long ranged and well described by lvy - flights , i.e. , by a probability distribution that decays in @xmath0 dimensions with distance @xmath1 as @xmath2 .
we employ the powerful methods of renormalized field theory to study dp with such long range , lvy - flight spreading in some depth .
our results unambiguously corroborate earlier findings that there are four renormalization group fixed points corresponding to , respectively , short - range gaussian , lvy gaussian , short - range dp and lvy dp , and that there are four lines in the @xmath3 plane which separate the stability regions of these fixed points .
when the stability line between short - range dp and lvy dp is crossed , all critical exponents change continuously .
we calculate the exponents describing lvy dp to second order in @xmath4-expansion , and we compare our analytical results to the results of existing numerical simulations .
furthermore , we calculate the leading logarithmic corrections for several dynamical observables . |
planetary atmospheres and oceans are strongly turbulent media . however , highly ordered coherent structures arise in a process of self - organization , and dominate the dynamics on slow temporal and large spatial scales . + the spontaneous appearance of coherent structures is a characteristic of two - dimensional fluid flows .
the basic underlying structure of these flows is linked to the existence of two quadratic , positive definite invariants , energy and enstrophy . in spectra of two - dimensional turbulence one
observes two different cascades associated with these conserved quantities ; a direct enstrophy cascade towards small spatial scales , and an indirect energy cascade towards larger spatial scales .
it is the latter which gives rise to vortex merging leading to larger and larger vortices . in this letter
we view the problem as one of weakly nonlinear hydrodynamic stability rather than turbulence phenomenology .
+ most vortices are monopolar , but dipole and even tripole vortices can also appear spontaneously .
monopole vortices are mainly created by shear flow instabilities whereas dipole vortices typically appear when some additional forcing is applied to the flow .
+ the richness and complexity of two - dimensional flows and the simultaneous presence of motion on very different temporal and spatial scales makes a direct analysis of the basic equations of motion very difficult .
the presence of rotation reinforces the two - dimensional character in accordance with the taylor - proudman theorem , but rotation can also introduce baroclinic instability .
the latter is a three - dimensional feature and , thus supports a direct energy cascade towards small scales .
hence , the dynamics is determined by competing two - dimensional and three - dimensional processes @xcite . to study vortices in geophysical fluid dynamics
the primitive equations are further reduced by approximations which allow to focus on temporal and spatial length scales of vortices @xcite .
if additionally baroclinic processes are excluded a further simplification can be made .
the dynamically important variable is the so called potential vorticity @xmath0 .
the resulting quasigeostrophic barotropic vorticity equation @xmath1 describes large scale motion on a slow time scale . here
@xmath2 is the stream function , @xmath3 describes the ambient rotation of the planet and @xmath4 is the fluid depth .
this equation was first derived by charney @xcite , and then independently by obukhov @xcite . in the context of low - frequency drift waves in magnetized plasmas equation ( [ charney ] ) is known as the hasegawa - mima equation @xcite .
this equation has been the mathematical starting point for much of the research done on coherent structures and vortices .
it supports so called modons which are localized soliton - like coherent solutions .
exact modon solutions were obtained by larichev & reznik @xcite for a stationary double - vortex solution which is antisymmetric in longitude .
extensions to more general solutions have been made @xcite , and the spherical geometry of planets has been incorporated @xcite .
however , modons have the drawback that the potential vorticity is not a smooth function of the stream function , but may be multivalued .
therefore interest has grown in low - dimensional models , although a rigorous proof of existence of a low - dimensional attractor in quasigeostrophic systems is still an unsolved problem . strictly speaking
, one can only define a `` slowest invariant manifold '' @xcite , since the small - scale events , i.e. the high - frequency and high - wavenumber processes , enlarge the hausdorff dimension for the attractor without any convergence @xcite .
nevertheless , in order to understand better the particular mechanisms involved in the formation and dynamics of vortices in geophysical fluid dynamics , it is useful to perform asymptotic techniques to derive reduced amplitude equations of the basic quasigeostrophic equations in a multiple scale analysis and study the derived model evolution - equations .
the basic idea is that coherent vortices may be identified with solitary wave solutions of generic nonlinear dispersive wave equations .
+ most research has been done in the frame work of the korteweg - de vries equation or in the framework of the boussinesq equation @xcite . while these models were helpful in describing and identifying mechanisms for atmospheric blocking , cyclogenesis , meandering of oceanic streams and the persistence of the great red spot in the jovian atmosphere , they are all one - dimensional models with their obvious limitations .
+ in this letter we will extend weakly nonlinear , long wave multiple scale analysis to two dimensions and derive the zakharov - kuznetsov equation @xmath5 the zakharov - kuznetsov ( zk ) equation @xcite is one of two well - studied canonical two - dimensional extensions of the korteweg - de vries equation @xcite ; the other being the kadomtsev - petviashvilli ( kp ) equation @xcite .
in contrast to the kp - equation , the zk - equation has so far never been derived in a geophysical fluid dynamics context . for a derivation of the kp equations for internal waves ,
see @xcite . whereas the kp - equation is valid in isotropic situations , the zk - equation is valid in anisotropic settings which is exactly the case for rotating fluids where the differential longitudinal dependence of the rotation rate causes anisotropy between the meridional and the longitudinal directions . moreover , in contrast to the kp - equation the zk - equation supports stable lump solitary waves .
this makes the zk - equation a very attractive model equation for the study of vortices in geophsyical flows .
+ the letter is organized as follows . in section 2
we set up the barotropic vorticity equation and the mean flow configurations under consideration . in the beginning of section 3
we will give a simple heuristic scaling argument based on the linearized barotropic vorticity equation to motivate why the zk - equation is the generic two - dimensional nonlinear wave equation .
in the remainder of section 3 we will derive the zk - equation in an asymptotic multiple scale analysis .
section 4 concludes the letter with a discussion and an outlook on further research .
we shall use a non - dimensional coordinate system , based on a typical horizontal length scale @xmath6 , a typical vertical scale @xmath7 , and typical coriolis parameter @xmath8 .
a typical velocity @xmath9 is taken to be the maximum of the mean current velocity and the time scale is given by @xmath10 .
if we separate the meridional meanflow @xmath11 from the perturbation pressure fields @xmath12 and use the boussinesq approximation , we obtain the following equation for the non - dimensional perturbation pressure field @xcite @xmath13 where @xmath14 with froude number @xmath15 and the jacobian defined by @xmath16 . we investigate a channel flow with a storm track superimposed on a constant meanflow @xmath17 confined at @xmath18 ( see fig.1 ) .
the storm tracks may have a critical layer where @xmath19 .
important is , as we will see , the non - vanishing slope at at least one boundary of the localized storm track .
the boundary conditions are @xmath20 at @xmath21 , and we require that the jet forms a transport barrier to the flow .
before we consider the weakly nonlinear , long wave approximation , we motivate our approach by looking at the linearization of equation ( [ qgp ] ) which yields @xmath22 in terms of @xmath23 we obtain the dispersion relation @xmath24 provided that the meanflow @xmath25 is constant .
if we focus on dynamics on the spatial and temporal time scales @xmath26 , i.e. small @xmath27 , and @xmath28 this is suggestive of the coupled zakharov - kuznetsov equation @xmath29 the reason why we expect an equation of the zakharov - kuznetsov type instead of the usual kadomtsev - petviashvilli type mostly encountered in fluid systems is the anisotropic character of ( [ qgp ] ) caused by the @xmath30-effect .
we consider weakly nonlinear waves riding on a background meanflow .
the meanflow consists of a constant part @xmath17 and a strong but narrow jetstream ( see fig .
the narrow storm track is located on a short meridional scale @xmath31 . in the outer region the problem ( [ qgp ] ) can be reduced to the linear problem ( [ lin1 ] ) with constant meanflow @xmath17 . in the interior
the structure of the storm track does not allow for sinusoidal wave solutions but instead we will derive a nonlinear wave equation . in order for the nonlinear wave equation which is valid only in the inner region where the storm tracks are nonuniform
, the inner solution has to be matched to the outer sinusoidal solution . in the outer region where the meanflow is uniform and constant , ( [ qgp ] ) reduces to the simple linear equation ( [ lin1 ] ) for the streamfunction with constant coefficients @xcite .
+ there the solution of the streamfunction can be written as @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the meridional wave number and is determined by the dispersion relation of the linearized model ( [ lin1 ] ) . in the interior of the storm track on the small scale @xmath31 ,
the meanflow is not constant .
we shall study weakly nonlinear long waves .
we introduce the following scales , @xmath34 where @xmath35 is a small parameter , the inverse of which measures the large scales of the disturbance .
next , we rescale the parameters @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
the scaling of the froude numbers implies that our model is valid for situations where the internal rossby radius of deformation is of the order of the long horizontal scale .
further , the scaling of @xmath30 implies that @xmath38 at the lowest order .
the boundary conditions we use are @xmath39 at @xmath21 and @xmath40 at @xmath18 which simply states that there is no transport of fluid across the jet - stream .
+ substituting this scaling into equation ( [ qgp ] ) yields , @xmath41 counting the orders of @xmath35 we obtain to the lowest order , @xmath42 @xmath43 where @xmath44\ ; .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we look for an amplitude equation , ie we want to write @xmath45 and seek an evolution equation for the slowly varying amplitude @xmath46 .
we easily find @xmath47 where @xmath48 is a constant of integration .
if we allow for zero meanflow within the narrow jet region we need to impose @xmath49 .
we summarize the solution of equation ( [ ord_0 ] ) @xmath50 the meridional structure on the small scale @xmath31 of @xmath2 is entirely determined by the mean currents at the leading order .
+ at the next order , @xmath51 , we obtain a linear inhomogeneous equation for @xmath52 , @xmath53 which can be written , using ( [ varphi0 ] ) , as @xmath54 this equation is again solved by the method of variation of parameters and we obtain @xmath55 with @xmath56 we note that the higher order term @xmath52 is slaved to the @xmath57 term and the dynamics of the corresponding amplitude equation which will be derived shortly . for the same reasons as above we set @xmath58 and obtain @xmath59 the @xmath60 terms give us an evolution equation for the amplitude @xmath61 .
we obtain @xmath62 which , using ( [ psi0 ] ) , can be written as @xmath63 where @xmath64 to assure boundedness of the solutions of ( [ 116 ] ) we have to require a solvability condition in form of a fredholm alternative .
+ the homogeneous adjoint problem to equation ( [ 116 ] ) may be written as @xmath65 with @xmath66 where we have used the boundary conditions @xmath67 at @xmath18 . the adjoint eigenvalue problem ( [ adjoint ] )
has one trivial constant kernel mode @xmath68 and one nontrivial , namely @xmath69 the nontrivial kernel mode @xmath70 has to be discarded because it does not satisfy the boundary condition . to see this note that the fredholm alternative for the elliptic operator [ lop ] together with the boundary condition @xmath67 is equivalent to one for the operator @xmath71-u_y\partial_y\psi - u_{yy}\partial_y\psi$ ] with the boundary condition @xmath72 at @xmath18 .
also note that a non - zero kernel mode @xmath73 is only consistent with the boundary conditions if @xmath74 .
the solvability condition is thus given by the trivial constant kernel mode @xmath75 on substituting the expressions ( [ psi0 ] ) with @xmath76 and ( [ gn ] ) we obtain the desired amplitude equation for @xmath61 , @xmath77 where @xmath78_{-l}^l \ ; , \nonumber \\ i\xi & = & \int_{-l}^l u^2 \ ; dy \ ; , \nonumber\\ i\zeta & = & \left [ u^2(1-y - l ) \right]_{-l}^l\ ; , \nonumber\\ i \mu & = & - \left [ u_{y}^2 \right]_{-l}^l + \left [ uu_{yy } \right]_{-l}^l \ ; , \nonumber\\ i\delta & = & -\int_{-l}^l \beta u \ ; dy \ ; .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that due to the last term of ( [ gn ] ) the zakharov - kuznetsov equation is inhomogeneous in the sense @xmath79 .
it is pertinent to mention that a nonzero @xmath80 requires a nonzero mean flow at at least one of the boundaries of the storm track .
the coefficients of the nonlinear terms @xmath81 require a non - vanishing slope at at least one boundary .
the slope @xmath82 and also @xmath83 at the boundaries of the jet @xmath18 may be determined from a given meanflow configuration by averaging over a very short region , say @xmath84 , where a sudden change of the constant mean flow @xmath17 to the jet occurs . at the lowest order the inner solution ( [ varphi0 ] ) with @xmath49 and the outer solution ( [ psi_out ] ) have to be matched .
the outer solution has been derived on the large scale @xmath85 whereas the inner solution and its associated amplitude equation , the zakharov - kuznetsov equation ( [ zk11 ] ) , were derived on the short scale @xmath31 .
henceforth we need to require that the asymptotic limit of the outer solutions for @xmath86 coincides with the asymptotic limit of the inner solution for @xmath87 .
the limit of the inner solution is @xmath88 .
the limit of the outer solution is @xmath89 .
hence we find @xmath90 , which extends the dynamics of the zakharov - kuznetsov equations to the outer region .
we have derived the nonlinear dispersive zakharov - kuznetsov equation from the quasigeostrophic barotropic vorticity equation .
it is well known that the zk - equation , although it is not integrable by means of the inverse scattering transform , supports a family of steady - shape stable lump solitary waves , moving at an arbitrary velocity @xcite .
these may help to describe two - dimensional coherent structures such as atmospheric blocking events , long lived eddies in the ocean or coherent structures in the jovian atmosphere such as the great red spot .
the model is from an analytical point of view easier to treat than the full barotropic quasigeostrophic equation and its solutions do not exhibit multivalued potential vorticity - stream function relationships as modons do .
+ geophysical flow on large scales is widely accepted to be conservative .
this allows for hamiltonian descriptions of the flow on large scales .
our model also exhibits a hamiltonian structure .
note that the momentum @xmath91 and the hamiltonian with the hamiltonian density @xmath92 are conserved .
+ we have assumed a meridional meanflow @xmath11 which consists of a constant part @xmath17 and a narrow localized storm track .
note that the jet stream may also be a narrow interface between two regions of meanflow with opposite flow direction .
such persistent shear layers exist between the zones and belts in the jovian atmosphere .
+ analysis of the solutions of ( [ zk11 ] ) is planned .
their stability has to be numerically tested within the zakharov - kuznetsov system .
the zk - equation has been derived using asymptotic techniques and is as such an asymptotic limit to the barotropic quasigeostrophic vorticity equation .
however , it is not clear that the same is true for the solutions .
the solutions of the zakharov - kuznetsov equations do not necessarily have to be asymptotically close to the solutions of the full quasigeostrophic system .
this is due to the lack of a centre manifold as discussed in the introduction . in further work
we will test the approximation of the solution numerically by taking solutions of the zk - equation and testing their dynamics in the full quasigeostrophic system .
+ i would like to thank tom bridges , daniel daners , roger grimshaw , charlie macaskill , marcel oliver , dmitry pelinovsky , victor shrira and vladimir zeitlin for valuable discussions . | we study the dynamics of two - dimensional coherent structures in planetary atmospheres and oceans .
we derive the zakharov - kuznetsov equation for large scale motion from the barotropic quasigeostrophic equation in a weakly nonlinear , long wave approximation .
we consider coherent structures emerging out of an instability caused by a narrow jet - like meanflow .
we use multiple scale analysis combined with asymptotic matching .
pacs numbers : 47.35.+i ; 47.32.-y ; 92.10.-c ; 92.60.-e keywords : solitary waves ; zakharov - kuznetsov equation ; barotropic quasigeostrophic equation |
the analysis to determine the @xmath7nn coupling constant should be clear and easily reproducible .
one should do a detailed study for the statistical and systematic errors .
the precise determination is an absolute statement , it could be erroneous and it should be improvable . in this perspective
the goldberger - miyazawa - oehme ( gmo ) sum rule @xcite might be a good candidate .
it is a forward dispersion relation at zero energy for @xmath7n scattering .
it assumes scattering amplitudes to be analytical functions satisfying crossing symmetry . at first isospin symmetry
does not have to be assumed and it reads ( for more details see e.g. @xcite ) with its numerical coefficients : @xmath8 $ ] , where @xmath9 is in mb the weighted integral , @xmath10 $ ] and @xmath11 are the @xmath12 scattering lengths in units of @xmath13 . all ingredients are physical observables but so far the lack of precision in @xmath11 ( contribution of 2/3 to @xmath14 ) led to applications of the gmo relation as consistency check or constraint @xcite .
the 1s width of the @xmath15 atom @xcite determines @xmath16 and assuming isospin symmetry this gives @xmath17 and @xmath18 using @xcite @xmath9= -1.077(47 ) mb .
this is not accurate enough although improvements will come @xcite .
we here report on a possible way to improve the precision on @xmath19 @xcite .
as @xmath20 is precisely known ( @xmath21 ) from energy shift in pionic hydrogen @xcite one can write : @xmath22 and using the above cited @xmath9 ( to be calculated later ) , @xmath23 $ ] .
this ( not our final result ) shows that all the action is in the term @xmath24,which , assuming isospin symmetry , is @xmath25 .
if this quantity is positive @xmath26 is smaller than 14 , if it is negative it is larger .
one way to determine the small @xmath25 is to use the accurate @xmath27 scattering length @xmath28 from the pionic deuterium 1s energy level@xcite . to leading order
this is the coherent sum of the @xmath2 scattering lengths from the proton and neutron , which , assuming charge symmetry ( viz , @xmath29 ) is the term required in our robust relation ( [ eq : gmorobust ] ) the strong cancellation between the two terms is then done by the physics . in order to match the precision using the width , we only need a theoretical precision in the description of the deuteron scattering length to about 30% .
in multiple scattering theory of zero - energy s - wave pion scattering from point - like nucleons and in the fixed scattering - center approximation , the leading contribution is@xcite : @xmath30 with @xmath31 ( a_{\pi ^-p}+a_{\pi^-n}),$ ] @xmath32 and @xmath33 being the nucleon and deuteron masses respectively . the double scattering term @xmath34 is : @xmath35 < 1/r > , \label{eq : d}\ ] ] and with our final scattering lengths @xmath36 quite close to @xmath37 experimental . we shall here follow the recent theoretical multiple scattering investigation of baru and kudryatsev ( b - k ) @xcite . the comparison of typical contributions is listed in table 1 . .
typical contributions to a@xmath38 in units of 10@xmath39 , recall a@xmath40@xcite . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ tab : j - calculation ] we have evaluated the different contributions ( see table 3 ) with no other coulomb and penetration corrections than those introduced by the experimental authors above 2 gev or by the theoretical analysis below 2 gev .
we find , based on ( integration of hadronic cross section ) the sm95 and arndt 12/98 analysis below 2 gev / c @xcite , and on the regge pole pdg94 @xcite and pdg98 @xcite extrapolation beyond 240 gev / c , the values @xmath41 mb and @xmath42 mb respectively .
we have adopted the mean value @xmath43 mb . in our calculation
we have added a systematic uncertainty from coulomb penetration effect of @xmath44 from the region less than 2 gev / c .
we have derived first new values for the @xmath7n scattering lengths from the @xmath2d one : @xmath45 our second conclusion concerns the charged @xmath7nn coupling constant using these new accurate values in ( [ eq : gmorobust ] ) with @xmath43 and charge symmetry : @xmath46 the uncertainty comes mainly from @xmath9 .
this coupling constant which agrees quite well with the text book value , 14.28(18 ) @xcite is intermediate between the low value deduced from the large data banks of nn and @xmath7n scattering data @xcite and the high value from np charge exchange cross sections @xcite .
it is fully compatible with the latter , differing statistically by only about one standard deviation .
g. hhler in _ pion - nucleon scattering _ , ed .
h. schopper , landolt - brnstein , new series , vol .
* 9b * ( springer , new york 1983 ) ; g. hhler , _ determination of the @xmath0nn coupling constant _ , contribution to this symposium .
schrder , a. badertscher , p. f. a. goudsmit , m. janousch , h. j. leisi , _ et al .
_ , _ determination of the @xmath7n scattering lengths from pionic hydrogen _ ,
ethz - ipp pr-99 - 07 , phys
* b * in press .
t. e. o. ericson , b. loiseau and a. w. thomas , invited contribution to panic99 , uppsala 1999 , _ precision determination of the @xmath0 n scattering lengths and the charged @xmath0nn coupling constant _ , nucl .
phys . * a*c to appear .
n. fettes , u .- g .
meissner and s. steininger , _ on the size of isospin violation in low - energy pion - nucleon scattering _ ,
b451 * , 233 ( 1999 ) and n. fettes , _ isospin violation in pion - nucleon scattering _ , contribution to this symposium .
m. m. pavan and r. a. arndt , _ determination of the @xmath0 nn coupling constant in the vpi / gw @xmath7n @xmath47 @xmath7 n partial - wave and dispersion relation analysis _ , contribution to this symposium and private communication . | the isovector gmo sum rule for zero energy forward @xmath0n scattering is critically studied to obtain the charged @xmath1 coupling constant using the precise @xmath2p and @xmath3d scattering lengths deduced recently from pionic atom experiments .
this direct determination leads to @xmath4 ( statistic ) @xmath5 ( systematic ) or @xmath6 .
we obtain also accurate values for the @xmath0n scattering lengths |
with the advent of charm and b - factories , a large amount of data for charmed - meson decays have been accumulated in the last decades . among a number of physical interests , one appealing aspect of studying these charmed - meson decays
is that we can gain information about interactions between light mesons and resonances .
this was particularly highlighted by the e791 collaboration s report on their identification of the @xmath8 meson in the dalitz plot of the @xmath9 decay @xcite .
a similar analysis was also made for the @xmath0 decay to identify the @xmath10 resonance @xcite .
these findings triggered further analyses of the @xmath0 dalitz plot data , paying special attention to the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude , as follows .
oller @xcite analyzed the e791 data @xcite using the @xmath11 @xmath12=1/2 ( @xmath12 : total isospin ) @xmath6-wave amplitude based on the chiral unitary approach @xcite , instead of breit - wigner functions for the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave used in the e791 analysis , and obtained a reasonable fit .
the @xmath12=3/2 @xmath6-wave was not considered in his analysis .
the e791 collaboration reanalyzed their data without assuming a particular functional form for the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude .
rather , they determined it bin by bin , which they call model independent partial - wave analysis ( mipwa ) @xcite .
an interesting finding in the mipwa was that the obtained @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude has the phase that depends on the @xmath5 energy in a manner significantly different from what is expected from the watson theorem combined with the lass empirical amplitude @xcite , assuming the @xmath12=1/2 dominance .
edera et al .
suggested that this difference can be understood as a substantial mixture of the @xmath11 @xmath12=1/2 and 3/2 @xmath6-wave amplitudes @xcite .
this idea was implemented in the dalitz plot analysis done by the focus collaboration @xcite .
they parametrized the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude in terms of the @xmath13-matrix of @xmath12=1/2 and 3/2 that had been fitted to the lass amplitudes @xcite .
they found that the @xmath0 dalitz plot can be well fitted with the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude in which the @xmath12=1/2 and 3/2 components interfere with each other in a rather destructive manner .
the focus collaboration also has done a mipwa in a subsequent work @xcite to find results similar to those of the e791 mipwa .
the quasi - mipwa has also been done by the cleo collaboration @xcite .
their new finding was that @xmath12=2 @xmath1 nonresonant amplitude can give a non - negligible contribution .
meanwhile , an analogous decay , @xmath14 , has been analyzed by the besiii collaboration @xcite .
an interesting finding was that the @xmath15 channel gives by far the dominant contribution .
this implies that , although the @xmath15 contribution is not directly observed in the @xmath0 dalitz plot , it can play a substantial role in the hadronic final state interactions ( fsi ) of the @xmath0 decay , considering that the two @xmath7 decays share the same hadronic dynamics to a large extent .
many of the previous analyses of the @xmath0 dalitz plot have been done with the so - called isobar model in which a @xmath7-meson decays into an excited state @xmath16 ( @xmath17 , etc . ) and a pseudoscalar meson .
the @xmath16 subsequently decays into a pair of light pseudoscalar mesons , while the third pseudoscalar meson is treated as a spectator . the propagation of @xmath16 is commonly parametrized by a breit - wigner function .
the total decay amplitude is given by a coherent sum of these isobar amplitudes supplemented by a flat interfering background .
on the other hand , as mentioned in the above paragraph , some analysis groups modified the conventional isobar model to use the @xmath13-matrix or chiral unitary model for the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude so that the consistency with the lass data for @xmath18 and with the two - body unitarity is maintained .
meanwhile , in ( q)mipwa , the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude is solely determined by the @xmath0 dalitz plot data .
we will refer to these models , which do not explicitly consider three - meson - rescattering required by the three - body unitarity , as isobar - type models .
the basic assumptions common to all of these models are that the spectator pseudoscalar meson interacts with the others very weakly , and/or @xmath19 ( @xmath20 : spectator meson ) vertices with complex coupling constants can absorb such effects .
although each analysis group has obtained a reasonable fit to its own data , their results are not necessarily in conformity with theoretical expectations .
for example , the e791 collaboration reported that the phase of the @xmath12=1/2 @xmath21 @xmath22-wave amplitude used in their mipwa is , according to the watson theorem , not consistent with that of the lass analysis in the elastic region @xcite .
this may be originated from either or both of two possible reasons below , each of which signals a serious problem in the basic assumptions underlying in the analysis model .
one possible reason is that the @xmath12=1/2 @xmath21 @xmath22-wave amplitude in the e791 analysis is given by a coherent sum of breit - wigner functions for @xmath23 and @xmath24 , and it is not consistent with the lass data to the required precision . or the amplitude does not satisfy the two - body unitarity not only formally but also quantitatively .
another possibility is that the ( neglected ) rescattering of the spectator meson with the other mesons actually plays a substantial role to generate an energy - dependent phase so that the watson theorem does not hold in reality , and the analysis model tried to fit it .
not only the e791 analysis but also all the previous analyses mentioned above would share the same problem , and this seems to indicate a need for going beyond the conventional isobar - type analysis ; a unitary coupled - channel approach . in order to extract from data a right physics , e.g. , @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude from @xmath0 dalitz plot data , one needs to use a theoretically sound model so that unnecessary model artifacts do not come into play .
recently , we have developed a unitary coupled - channel framework for describing a heavy - meson decay into three light mesons @xcite ; both the two - body and three - body unitarity are maintained . in the reference , we studied the extent to which the isobar - type description of heavy - meson ( or excited meson ) decays is valid by analyzing simple pseudodata .
we found a significant effect of the channel couplings and multiple rescattering on the dalitz plot distributions .
this study has been extended to an analysis of pseudodata for excited meson photoproductions @xcite . in the present work ,
we apply the formalism of ref .
@xcite with some modifications to a realistic case .
thus , we will perform a coupled - channel analysis of the @xmath0 dalitz plot pseudodata generated from the e791 isobar model @xcite . to the best of our knowledge ,
this is the first coupled - channel dalitz plot analysis of a @xmath25-meson decay into three pseudoscalar mesons .
we will demonstrate that a quantitative coupled - channel partial - wave analysis of the @xmath0 dalitz plot is feasible .
then we will examine the hadronic dynamics in the fsi of the @xmath0 decay within the coupled - channel model .
we will study how the partial - wave amplitudes and their fit fractions are different between an isobar - type model and a model that includes the three - body scattering .
we also examine contributions from the rescattering and channel couplings to the dalitz plot distribution . through these investigations ,
we address the validity of the above - mentioned basic assumptions of the isobar - type model from this more microscopic viewpoint .
so far , the three - body fsi for the @xmath0 decay has been explored by magalhes et al .
@xcite ( see also guimares et al .
they were concerned with whether the difference in the phase between the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitudes from mipwa ( e791 @xcite and focus @xcite ) and the @xmath21 @xmath12=1/2 @xmath6-wave amplitude from the lass analysis can be understood as a result of the fsi .
they calculated the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude in the @xmath0 decay with only the @xmath21 @xmath12=1/2 @xmath6-wave scattering amplitude of the chiral unitary model that had been fitted to the lass amplitude in the elastic region ; other partial waves as well as inelasticities were not taken into account .
an interesting finding in their work was that the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude originated from the weak vector current and the subsequent @xmath6-wave rescattering is in a fairly good agreement with the phases from the mipwa in the elastic region ; the qualitative feature of the modulus of the mipwa amplitude is also described .
this finding was further confirmed in their subsequent works @xcite where @xmath26 contribution was also partly taken into account .
although their results are interesting and suggestive , they should be looked with a caution for the reasons below .
first , their calculated amplitudes are still qualitatively in agreement with those from the mipwa in the elastic region , and more refinements are needed particularly in the inelastic region .
there will be a delicate interplay between new mechanisms to be included for the refinements and the already existing mechanisms , and thus it is not clear if their current findings persist after the refinements .
second , the authors of refs .
@xcite treated the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitudes from the mipwa as data , and did not analyze the dalitz plot directly .
however , we note that the mipwa @xmath6-wave amplitude was obtained under the assumption that all the other partial - wave amplitudes are basically not changed by the fsi . in case the @xmath6-wave amplitude is significantly modified by the fsi , the other partial - wave amplitudes are also probably modified , and the mipwa @xmath6-wave amplitude may no longer be compatible with them . in order to fully examine the fsi effects on each of the partial - wave amplitudes for the @xmath0 decay ,
it is first necessary to analyze the dalitz plot with a model that takes account of all relevant partial waves and the fsi , thereby extracting the partial - wave amplitudes , as we will do in this work
. then , the fsi effects on the extracted amplitudes can be studied . in our analysis
, we use two - pseudoscalar - meson interactions that generate unitary amplitudes for @xmath21 and @xmath1 scatterings , and consider resonances ( @xmath27 , etc . ) as poles in the amplitudes .
the two - body interactions are fitted to the lass and cern - munich @xcite data . with the two - body interactions ,
we solve the faddeev equation for a three - pseudoscalar - meson scattering to obtain an amplitude that respects the three - body unitarity and thus channel couplings .
this amplitude is used to describe the fsi of the @xmath7 decay .
the pseudodata are fitted by adjusting the strengths and phases of ( bare ) @xmath19 vertices , while the two - pseudoscalar - meson interactions are fixed as those obtained by fitting the two - body scattering data . in this way
, we will examine the extent to which we can fit the @xmath7-decay pseudodata , keeping the consistency with the two - body scattering data for _ all _ partial waves considered in our model .
this is in contrast with the previous @xmath0 analyses where some of the resonance parameters were also adjusted along with the @xmath19 vertices .
we consider the @xmath12=1/2 @xmath21 @xmath6- , @xmath22- , and @xmath28-waves as commonly included in the previous analyses .
we also explicitly include the @xmath12=3/2 @xmath21 @xmath6-wave ( @xmath12=2 @xmath1 @xmath6-wave ) as has been done so in the focus @xcite ( cleo @xcite ) analysis .
we also consider the @xmath12=1 @xmath1 @xmath22-wave where the @xmath26 plays a major role .
this partial wave has not been considered in the previous dalitz plot analyses because it does not directly decay into the @xmath29 final state . however
, this partial wave can still contribute to @xmath0 through the channel couplings .
considering the besiii analysis mentioned above , the @xmath15 channel is expected to play a substantial role also here , and we will see that this is indeed the case , at least within our analysis .
now we discuss the last piece of our model .
the fsi of the @xmath0 decay is a three - pseudoscalar - meson scattering .
generally in a three - body scattering , there can exist a mechanism that can not be expressed by a combination of two - body mechanisms , i.e. , a three - body force .
based on the hidden local symmetry ( hls ) model @xcite , in which vector and pseudoscalar mesons are implemented together in a chiral lagrangian , we can actually derive a `` three - meson force '' essentially in a parameter - free fashion , up to form factors we include .
thus we consider some of the hls - based three - meson force acting on important channels , and examine how they play a role in the @xmath0 decay .
if two - pseudoscalar - meson interactions are well determined by precise two - body scattering data , the @xmath30 decays and also other decay modes such as @xmath31 could serve as a ground to study the three - meson force .
the organization of this paper is as follows . in sec .
[ sec : formalism ] , we discuss our coupled - channel model and present formulas to calculate the @xmath0 decay amplitude . then in sec .
[ sec : results ] , we present numerical results from our analyses of the two - pseudoscalar - meson scattering data and of the @xmath0 decay dalitz plot pseudodata .
finally , we give a summary and future prospects in sec .
[ sec : conclusion ] . a derivation and the resulting expressions for the three - meson force , and model parameters
are presented in the appendixes .
we have already developed a formalism to describe a heavy - meson decay into three light mesons in ref .
@xcite . in the present work
, we basically use the same formalism with some modifications .
thus , here we just present expressions that are needed in the following discussions , specifying the modifications we make for this work . for derivations of most of the expressions ,
see sec .
ii of ref .
our formalism can be regarded as a three - dimensional reduction of a fully relativistic formulation .
because we deal with scatterings of light particles , i.e. pions , one may question the validity of this approximation .
although a legitimate concern , we made an argument on this along with improvements needed in the future in sec .
v of ref .
@xcite . in our formalism
, we first construct a two - light - meson ( @xmath32 , @xmath13 ) interaction model that is subsequently applied to three - light - meson scattering .
the following presentations are also given in this order .
we describe two - light - meson scatterings with a unitary coupled - channel model . for example , we consider @xmath1 and @xmath33 channels for a @xmath1 scattering , and @xmath34 and @xmath35 channels for @xmath12=1/2 @xmath6-wave @xmath34 scattering .
we will specify channels for each partial wave later .
we model the two - light - meson interactions with resonance(@xmath16)-excitation mechanisms or contact interactions or both .
we choose this parametrization of the two - meson interactions so that it can be easily applied to a three - meson scattering . a difference from ref .
@xcite is that we include the contact interactions here but we did not in ref .
this is because we include partial - wave amplitudes that do not have resonances in analyzing the @xmath0 decay dalitz plot .
besides , we use a parametrization for @xmath36 ( @xmath37 : pseudoscalar mesons ) vertex functions that are different from those used in the previous work and , with this parametrization , we need to include contact interactions in addition to @xmath16-excitation mechanisms in order to obtain reasonable fits to some empirical partial - wave amplitudes .
diagrammatic representation of two - light - meson partial - wave scattering , @xmath38 .
( a ) two - meson interaction potentials ; ( b ) two - meson partial - wave scattering amplitude ; ( c ) two - meson partial - wave scattering amplitude from separable contact interactions ; ( d ) dressed @xmath36 decay vertex ; ( e ) the inverse of dressed @xmath16 green function . , width=453 ] we consider a partial - wave @xmath38 scattering ( see fig .
[ fig : two - body ] for a diagrammatic representation ) with total energy @xmath39 , total angular momentum @xmath40 , total isospin @xmath12 .
we will also denote the incoming and outgoing momenta by @xmath41 an @xmath42 , respectively ; @xmath43 throughout this paper , except for the appendix
. when @xmath41 is on - shell , it is related to @xmath39 by @xmath44 and @xmath45 ; @xmath46 being the mass of @xmath47 .
first let us consider a @xmath38 scattering that is not accompanied by a resonance excitation . in this case , we use a separable two - light - meson interaction potential [ first term of rhs of fig .
[ fig : two - body](a ) ] as follows : @xmath48 where @xmath49 is a coupling constant , and @xmath50 is a vertex function .
we use the following parametrization for @xmath50 : @xmath51^{2+l/2 } \left(q\over m_\pi\right)^l \ , \label{eq : vf - cont}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath52 is a cutoff parameter .
meanwhile , we allow an exception for @xmath40=0 , @xmath12=2 @xmath1 scattering for which we use a different parametrization for the vertex function : @xmath53^{3 } \ , \label{eq : vf - cont2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where an additional coupling constant @xmath54 has been introduced to obtain a reasonable fit to data . for a later convenience ,
let us define @xmath55 by @xmath56 with the above interaction potential , the partial - wave amplitude is given as follows [ see fig .
[ fig : two - body](c ) for a diagrammatic representation ] : @xmath57 with @xmath58_{a'b',ab } & = & \delta_{a'b',ab } - \sigma^{li}_{a'b',ab}(e ) \ , \\
\sigma^{li}_{a'b',ab}(e ) & = & \int_0^\infty dq\ ; q^2 { h^{li}_{a'b',ab}\left[w^{li}_{ab}(q)\right]^2 \over e - e_a(q)-e_b(q)+i\epsilon } \ .
\label{eq : pw - cont - self}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the amplitude of eq .
( [ eq : pw-2body - cont ] ) can contain resonance pole(s ) , in general .
now we extend the model to include explicit degrees of freedom for excitations of spin-@xmath40 isospin-@xmath12 resonances that contribute to the @xmath38 scattering . in this case , a two - light - meson interaction potential includes bare @xmath16-excitation mechanisms in addition to the contact potential @xmath59 defined in eq .
( [ eq : cont - ptl ] ) as follows [ see also fig . [ fig : two - body](a ) ] : @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the bare mass of @xmath16 ; @xmath62 denotes a bare @xmath36 vertex function and @xmath63 .
following ref .
@xcite , we introduce @xmath64 that is related to @xmath65 as follows : @xmath66 then we employ the following parametrization for the bare vertex function : @xmath67^{1+(l/2 ) } \left ( \frac{q}{m_\pi } \right)^l , \label{eq : pipi - vertex}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath68 and @xmath69 are coupling constant and cutoff , respectively .
this parametrization is different from that used in eq .
( 35 ) of ref .
@xcite , and has a proper kinematical factor . with the potential in eq .
( [ eq : pw-2body - v ] ) , the resulting scattering amplitude is given by [ fig .
[ fig : two - body](b ) ] : @xmath70 where the first term is the scattering amplitude from the contact interactions only , as has been defined in eq .
( [ eq : pw-2body - cont ] ) .
the symbol @xmath71 denotes the dressed vertex that describes the bare @xmath36 decay followed by @xmath72 rescattering through the contact interactions .
expressions for @xmath71 and @xmath73 are [ fig .
[ fig : two - body](d ) ] : @xmath74 in eq .
( [ eq : pw-2body - t ] ) , the dressed green function for @xmath16 , @xmath75 , has been introduced , and is given by [ fig .
[ fig : two - body](e ) ] : @xmath76_{r'r } = ( e - m_r)\delta_{r',r } -\bar\sigma^{li}_{r',r}(e ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath77 is the self - energy of @xmath16 , and is defined by @xmath78 in case @xmath38 interaction is given by only resonant mechanisms [ no first term in eq .
( [ eq : pw-2body - v ] ) ] , which is the case in ref .
@xcite , the corresponding scattering amplitude is obtained from eq .
( [ eq : pw-2body - t ] ) by dropping the first term , and replacing the dressed vertex ( @xmath79 ) with the bare one ( @xmath80 ) in eqs . ( [ eq : pw-2body - t ] ) and ( [ eq : pipi - sigma ] ) . the partial - wave amplitude , @xmath81 in eq .
( [ eq : pw-2body - t ] ) , is related to the @xmath82-matrix by @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the on - shell momentum that satisfies @xmath85 , and @xmath86 is the phase - space factor .
the phase shift and inelasticity are denoted by @xmath87 and @xmath88 , respectively .
the parameters contained in the two - light - meson potentials such as @xmath61 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath49 , and @xmath52 are determined by fitting experimental data .
a particular choice of the potential , such as the number of @xmath16 and contact interactions included , will be specified later for each partial wave and for each of @xmath1 and @xmath21 interactions .
we now consider a case where three light - mesons are scattering .
first , let us assume that the three mesons interact with each other only through the two - meson interactions discussed in the previous subsection . because our two - meson interaction potential is given in a separable form
, we can cast the faddeev equation into a two - body like scattering equation ( the so - called alt - grassberger - sandhas ( ags ) equation @xcite ) for a @xmath89 scattering . here , @xmath90 stands for either @xmath16 or @xmath91 , and @xmath91 is a spurious `` state '' that is supposed to live within a contact interaction in a very short time , and decays ( going to the left in equations ) into the two light - mesons , @xmath72 .
this degree of freedom is introduced merely for extending the ags - type @xmath92 scattering equation used in ref .
@xcite to include the contact two - meson interactions .
thus , the scattering equation for a partial - wave amplitude , @xmath93 , is given as ( see fig .
[ fig:3body - t ] for a diagrammatic representation ) @xmath94 where @xmath95 are the total angular momentum , parity , and the total isospin of the @xmath96 system and they are conserved in the scattering .
the @xmath96 state with the relative orbital angular momentum @xmath97 is denoted by @xmath98 ; the allowed range for @xmath97 is determined by @xmath99 and the spin - parity of @xmath90 .
the magnitude of the incoming ( outgoing ) relative momentum of the @xmath96 ( @xmath100 ) state is denoted by @xmath22 ( @xmath101 ) .
z - diagram for @xmath89 process via @xmath102-exchange .
, width=396 ] z - diagram for @xmath89 process via @xmath102-exchange .
, width=94 ] the driving term of the scattering is a partial - wave form of the so - called z - diagram , @xmath103 .
the z - diagram is a process in which @xmath104 decay is followed by @xmath105-formation , as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : cr - int ] . for a more explicit definition as well as the partial - wave expansion of the z - diagram
, we refer the readers to appendix c of ref .
@xcite ; in particular , eqs .
( c10)-(c12 ) of ref . @xcite
give an explicit expression for @xmath106 ( note @xmath90=@xmath16 and @xmath107=@xmath108 in ref .
@xcite ) in which @xmath109 and @xmath110 defined in eq .
( [ eq : pipi - vertex ] ) can be directly inserted . when @xmath111 ( @xmath112 ) , the corresponding expression for the z - diagram can be practically obtained by replacing @xmath109 ( @xmath110 ) in @xmath106 with @xmath113 ( @xmath114 ) defined in eq .
( [ eq : tilde - w ] ) .
the z - diagrams are known to have the moon - shape singularity @xcite that prevents us from solving eq .
( [ eq : pw - tcr ] ) with the standard subtraction method . here
we employ the spline method ( see ref .
@xcite for detailed explanations ) to obtain numerical solutions from eq .
( [ eq : pw - tcr ] ) . in eq .
( [ eq : pw - tcr ] ) , we have also used the green function , @xmath115 , for @xmath90 and @xmath107 which can be coupled through @xmath116 .
it is given by @xmath117_{cr',cr } & = & [ e - e_{c}(q ) - e_{r}(q ) ] \delta_{r',r } - \sigma^{li}_{r',r}\left(q , e - e_{c}(q)\right ) \
, \label{eq : green - rc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath118 , and @xmath119_{cr'_{a'b'},cr } & = & - \sigma^{li}_{r'_{a'b'},r}\left(q , e - e_{c}(q)\right ) \qquad { \rm for\ } ( { \cal r},{\cal r } ' ) = ( r , r'_{a'b ' } ) \ , \\
\left[g^{-1}(q , e)\right]_{cr',cr_{ab } } & = & - \sigma^{li}_{r',r_{ab}}\left(q , e - e_{c}(q)\right ) \qquad { \rm for\ } ( { \cal r},{\cal r } ' ) = ( r_{ab},r')\ , \\ \left[g^{-1}(q , e)\right]_{cr'_{a'b'},cr_{ab } } & = & \delta_{r_{ab},r'_{a'b ' } } - \sigma^{li}_{r'_{a'b'},r_{ab}}\left(q , e - e_{c}(q)\right ) \quad { \rm for\ } ( { \cal r},{\cal r } ' ) = ( r_{ab},r'_{a'b'})\ , \label{eq : green - rc4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have introduced the self - energies @xmath120 , and also quantities @xmath121 , which is either dimensionless or dimension of square - root of the energy , as defined by @xmath122 ^ 2 } { e - \sqrt{m^2_{ab}(q ) + p^2 } + i\epsilon } , \label{eq : r - self}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath123 , and @xmath124 runs over all two - meson states from @xmath36 decays .
the kinematical factors in the expressions are from the lorentz transformation to boost the @xmath90-at - rest frame to the @xmath96 center - of - mass frame .
so far , we have considered the three - meson scattering due to multiple iterations of the two - meson interactions .
given the two - meson interactions , this is a necessary consequence of the three - body unitarity . in a three - meson system , however , there may be a room for a new mechanism that is absent in a two - meson system to play a role .
we will refer to such mechanisms as a `` three - meson force '' hereafter .
three - meson force _ not _ considered in this work .
( a ) vector - meson exchange between a pseudoscalar - meson pair ( @xmath72 ) in @xmath6-wave and a pseudoscalar meson ( @xmath20 ) .
( b ) @xmath125 interaction via meson - resonance ( @xmath126 ) excitation . , width=264 ] three - meson force _ not _ considered in this work . ( a ) vector - meson exchange between a pseudoscalar - meson pair ( @xmath72 ) in @xmath6-wave and a pseudoscalar meson ( @xmath20 ) .
( b ) @xmath125 interaction via meson - resonance ( @xmath126 ) excitation .
, width=264 ] diagrams shown in fig .
[ fig : vecpot ] can work as a three - meson force .
these are interactions between a vector - meson and a pseudoscalar meson via a vector - meson exchange ; for our particular application to @xmath0 , they are bare @xmath127-@xmath128 , and bare @xmath129-@xmath32 interactions .
these mechanisms are based on the hidden local symmetry ( hls ) model @xcite in which vector and pseudoscalar mesons are implemented in a lagrangian that has a symmetry under nonlinear chiral transformations .
expressions for the lagrangian and the resulting interaction potentials of fig .
[ fig : vecpot ] are presented in appendix [ app : lag ] .
these mechanisms in fig .
[ fig : vecpot ] along with the z - diagram in fig .
[ fig : cr - int ] have been studied by jansen et al .
@xcite to examine the @xmath32-@xmath127 correlation and its relevance to a soft @xmath130 form factor in a @xmath131 potential .
there are also other possible mechanisms that can work as a three - meson force .
we show some diagrams in fig .
[ fig:3meson ] as examples .
the diagram in fig .
[ fig:3meson](a ) describes an interaction between a pseudoscalar - meson - pair ( @xmath72 ) in @xmath6-wave and another pseudoscalar meson ( @xmath20 ) via a vector - meson exchange ; this mechanism is also from the hls lagrangian .
meanwhile , in the diagram of fig .
[ fig:3meson](b ) , an @xmath16 interacts with a pseudoscalar meson to form a resonance ( @xmath126 ) , which is followed by a decay into an @xmath108 and a pseudoscalar meson .
this is a familiar mechanism and often assumed in partial - wave analyses for meson spectroscopy . in this work ,
we consider the vector - pseudoscalar interactions shown in fig .
[ fig : vecpot ] in our analysis of the @xmath0 decay to study their relevance .
thus , the scattering equation in eq .
( [ eq : pw - tcr ] ) is modified by adding the new mechanisms to the z - diagrams : @xmath132 where the added term , @xmath133 , is in the partial - wave form for which we give explicit expressions in eqs.([eq : vvv - pot ] ) , ( [ eq : vvp - pot ] ) , and ( [ eq : partialv ] ) . in eq .
( [ eq : addition ] ) , @xmath16 and @xmath108 are the lightest spin-1 bare states of either @xmath134)=(1,0)$ ] or @xmath135 which we denote `` @xmath127 '' and `` @xmath136 '' , respectively . for our particular application to the @xmath0 decay
, we include @xmath137= ( `` @xmath127''@xmath138,``@xmath127''@xmath138,@xmath127 ) , ( `` @xmath127''@xmath138,``@xmath139''@xmath32,@xmath140 ) , ( `` @xmath139''@xmath32,``@xmath139''@xmath32,@xmath127 ) for the diagram fig . [ fig : vecpot](a ) , and @xmath137= ( `` @xmath127''@xmath138,``@xmath127''@xmath138,@xmath140 ) , ( `` @xmath127''@xmath138,``@xmath139''@xmath32,@xmath141 ) , ( `` @xmath139''@xmath32,``@xmath139''@xmath32,@xmath139 ) for the diagram fig . [
fig : vecpot](b ) . on the other hand ,
we leave examination of mechanisms such as those shown in fig .
[ fig:3meson ] to future work for the following reasons .
as we emphasized in the introduction , even effects of multiple scattering due to the two - meson force on the @xmath25-decay has still not been studied in a realistic setting . in this situation ,
studying the relevance of the three - meson force to the @xmath25-decay is indeed in an exploratory level , and thus a reasonable starting point would be to include it in the most important channel . as we will see , the vector - pseudoscalar ( @xmath127-@xmath128 ) channel plays a very important role in the rescattering process , and therefore it would be good to study the new mechanisms of fig . [
fig : vecpot ] in this channel at first . also , regarding the mechanism in fig .
[ fig:3meson](b ) , no relevant meson - resonance of spin-0 , @xmath12=3/2 , @xmath82=@xmath142 is known in the @xmath25-meson mass region , and thus we do not need to include it for the moment .
diagrammatic representation of @xmath7-decay into three pseudoscalar mesons @xmath143 in our coupled - channel model .
( a ) the isobar - type diagram .
( b ) the rescattering diagram .
the amplitude @xmath144 is from the scattering equation represented by fig .
[ fig:3body - t ] .
the gray blob represents the dressed @xmath90 green function .
, width=415 ] in our coupled - channel model , the decay amplitude for @xmath0 is given by @xmath145 where we have introduced the cyclic summation that takes the sum over @xmath146 = @xmath147 , @xmath148 , @xmath149 , and @xmath150 where @xmath151 is the @xmath152-component of the spin of @xmath90 , and @xmath153 is the green function that has been defined in eqs .
( [ eq : green - rc])-([eq : green - rc4 ] ) .
this decay amplitude in eq .
( [ eq : decay - amp ] ) is diagrammatically represented in fig .
[ fig : d - decay ] .
the symbol @xmath154 denotes a @xmath155 decay vertex function which is explicitly given as @xmath156 where @xmath157 and @xmath55 have been defined in eqs .
( [ eq : tilde - f ] ) and ( [ eq : tilde - w ] ) , respectively ; @xmath158 is the clebsch - gordan coefficient , and @xmath159 is the isospin of meson @xmath47 and @xmath160 is its @xmath152 component .
the kinematical factors in the equations are from the lorentz transformation to boost the @xmath72-pair center - of - mass ( cm ) frame to the total cm frame .
the momentum @xmath161 is the relative momentum of the @xmath72-pair in their cm frame .
the dressed @xmath162 vertex , @xmath163 , has also been introduced in eq .
( [ eq : decay - amp ] ) , and it is explicitly given by @xmath164 where @xmath165 is the @xmath25-meson spin , and @xmath166 for @xmath0 .
we sum over the parity ( @xmath167 ) and total isospin @xmath168 of the final hadronic states because the weak @xmath25-decay does not conserve them .
the last factor in the above equation is given by @xmath169 where @xmath170 is the partial - wave amplitude for @xmath171 scattering obtained by solving the coupled - channel scattering equation , eq .
( [ eq : pw - tcr ] ) . the first term on the rhs corresponds to the isobar - type contribution [ fig .
[ fig : d - decay](a ) ] while the second term is the contribution from the rescattering [ fig .
[ fig : d - decay](b ) ] .
the quantity @xmath172 is the bare @xmath173 vertex function for which we choose a parametrization , @xmath174 } { \sqrt{2 e_c(p ) } } \left ( \frac{(\lambda^{jpt}_{(c{\cal r})_l})^2 } { p^2 + ( \lambda^{jpt}_{(c{\cal r})_l})^2 } \right)^{2+(l/2 ) } \left(\frac{p}{m_\pi}\right)^{l } , \label{eq : bare_mstar}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath175 in eq .
( [ eq : bare_mstar ] ) , @xmath176 , @xmath177 , and @xmath178 are the coupling , phase , and cutoff , respectively , and they will be determined by fitting dalitz plot distribution data .
the couplings @xmath176 are nonzero only when @xmath179 .
the parametrization used in this work [ eq .
( [ eq : bare_mstar ] ) ] is different from the one used in ref .
@xcite in choosing the kinematical factor . the isobar - model - type amplitude [ fig .
[ fig : d - decay](a ) ] for the @xmath0 decay , @xmath180 , is obtained from the above equations ( [ eq : cyclic - sum])-([eq : ar ] ) by just dropping the second term of the rhs of eq .
( [ eq : dressed - g ] ) . the procedure to calculate the dalitz plot distribution from the decay amplitude of eq .
( [ eq : cyclic - sum ] ) is explained in detail in appendix b of ref .
@xcite , and we do not repeat it here .
now we apply the coupled - channel formalism discussed in the previous section to analyses of data .
first we determine parameters in the two - pseudoscalar - meson scattering model by analyzing experimental data for @xmath1 and @xmath34 scatterings .
then we extract resonance parameters from amplitudes of the two - meson interaction model .
this two - meson interaction model is a basic ingredient for the three - meson scattering model . in the subsequent subsection
, we analyze the @xmath0 decay in a realistic setting . for studying the @xmath0 decay in our coupled - channel framework ,
the @xmath1 and @xmath181 scatterings of @xmath182 gev are relevant
. we will determine the model parameters of our @xmath1 and @xmath181 scattering models , i.e. , @xmath49 , @xmath52 , @xmath61 , @xmath68 , and @xmath69 in eqs .
( [ eq : cont - ptl])-([eq : vf - cont2 ] ) , ( [ eq : pw-2body - v ] ) , and ( [ eq : pipi - vertex ] ) , by fitting empirical scattering amplitudes for @xmath182 gev .
we analyze the @xmath181 scattering amplitudes from the lass experiment @xcite . for our application to the @xmath0 decay in the next section ,
we determine the model parameters for @xmath183 = \{0,1/2 } , \{0,3/2 } , \{1,1/2 } , \{2,1/2 } partial waves .
we explain details of our @xmath181 scattering model for each partial wave . for the @xmath183=\{0,1/2 }
wave , we consider @xmath181-@xmath184 coupled channels because the @xmath184 channel is known to play a significant role while @xmath185 does not in this partial wave .
we include two bare @xmath16 states supplemented by a contact @xmath181@xmath186@xmath181 interaction .
for the @xmath183=\{0,3/2 } wave , we consider a contact @xmath181@xmath186@xmath181 interaction only .
for the @xmath183=\{1,1/2 } and \{2,1/2 } waves , we consider coupling of @xmath181 and effective inelastic channels ; masses of the two `` particles '' in the inelastic channel , denoted by @xmath187 and @xmath188 , are also fitted to the data .
we include three bare @xmath16 states for @xmath183=\{1,1/2 } while a single bare @xmath16 state for @xmath189 .
we present the @xmath181 model parameters determined by the fits in table [ tab : kpi ] of appendix [ sec : para ] .
( color online ) phase ( upper ) and modulus ( lower ) of the amplitudes for the @xmath181 scatterings : ( left ) @xmath40=0 for @xmath190 ; ( center ) @xmath183=\{1,1/2 } ; ( right ) @xmath183=\{2,1/2}. data are taken from ref .
@xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( color online ) phase ( upper ) and modulus ( lower ) of the amplitudes for the @xmath181 scatterings : ( left ) @xmath40=0 for @xmath190 ; ( center ) @xmath183=\{1,1/2 } ; ( right ) @xmath183=\{2,1/2}. data are taken from ref .
@xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( color online ) phase ( upper ) and modulus ( lower ) of the amplitudes for the @xmath181 scatterings : ( left ) @xmath40=0 for @xmath190 ; ( center ) @xmath183=\{1,1/2 } ; ( right ) @xmath183=\{2,1/2}. data are taken from ref .
@xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( color online ) phase shifts ( @xmath87 ) of the @xmath191 and @xmath1 scatterings : ( left ) @xmath191 phase shifts for @xmath183=\{0,3/2 } partial wave ; data are from ref
. @xcite .
( right ) @xmath1 phase shifts for @xmath183=\{0,2 } partial wave ; data are from refs .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.0% ] ( color online ) phase shifts ( @xmath87 ) of the @xmath191 and @xmath1 scatterings : ( left ) @xmath191 phase shifts for @xmath183=\{0,3/2 } partial wave ; data are from ref
. @xcite .
( right ) @xmath1 phase shifts for @xmath183=\{0,2 } partial wave ; data are from refs .
title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.0% ] we present the quality of the fits to the empirical partial - wave amplitude @xcite of @xmath190 @xmath40=0 partial wave and @xmath183=\{1,1/2},\{2,1/2 } partial waves in fig . [ fig : pik ] where phases ( upper panels ) and modulus ( lower panels ) of the amplitudes are shown .
also the elastic scattering phase shifts for the @xmath183=\{0,3/2 } partial wave calculated with our model are compared with the data @xcite in fig .
[ fig : pipi - pik](left ) .
the @xmath192 values obtained in the fits are tabulated in table [ tab : chi2 - 2body ] .
.[tab : chi2 - 2body ] @xmath192 values for the fits to empirical @xmath34 and @xmath1 partial - wave amplitudes .
each entry in the row indicated by `` # of parameters '' is the number of model parameters adjusted to fit the data . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] p. c. magalhes , m.r .
robilotta , k.s.f.f .
guimares , t. frederico , w. de paula , a.c . dos reis , and i. bediaga , arxiv:1108.6318 ; p. c. magalhes , m.r .
robilotta , arxiv:1312.2033 ; p. c. magalhes , m.r .
robilotta , arxiv:1504.06346 . | we perform a coupled - channel analysis of pseudodata for the @xmath0 dalitz plot .
the pseudodata are generated from the isobar model of the e791 collaboration , and are reasonably realistic .
we demonstrate that it is feasible to analyze the high - quality data within a coupled - channel framework that describes the final state interaction of @xmath0 as multiple rescatterings of three pseudoscalar mesons through two - pseudoscalar - meson interactions in accordance with the two - body and three - body unitarity .
the two - pseudoscalar - meson interactions are designed to reproduce empirical @xmath1 and @xmath2 scattering amplitudes .
furthermore , we also include mechanisms that are beyond simple iterations of the two - body interactions , i.e. , a three - meson force , derived from the hidden local symmetry model .
a picture of hadronic dynamics in @xmath0 described by our coupled - channel model is found to be quite different from those of the previous isobar - type analyses .
for example , we find that the @xmath3 decay width can get almost triplicated when the rescattering mechanisms are turned on . among the rescattering mechanisms , those associated with the @xmath4 channel , which contribute to @xmath3 only through a channel coupling ,
give a large contribution , and significantly improve the quality of the fits .
the @xmath5 @xmath6-wave amplitude from our analysis is reasonably consistent with those extracted from the e791 model independent partial - wave analysis ; the hadronic rescattering and the coupling to the @xmath4 channel play a major role here .
we also find that the dressed @xmath7 decay vertices have phases , induced by the strong rescatterings , that strongly depend on the momenta of the final pseudoscalar mesons .
although the conventional isobar - type analyses have assumed the phases to be constant , this common assumption is not supported by our more microscopic viewpoint . |
albertson and collins @xcite introduced the distinguishing number @xmath0 of a graph @xmath1 as the least cardinal @xmath2 such that @xmath1 has a labeling with @xmath2 labels which is only preserved by the trivial automorphism .
this seminal concept spawned many papers on finite and infinite graphs .
we are mainly interested in infinite , locally finite , connected graphs of polynomial growth , see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and in graphs of higher cardinality , see @xcite , @xcite . in particular , there is one conjecture on which we focus our attention , the infinite motion conjecture of tom tucker . before stating it , we introduce the notation @xmath8 for the number of elements moved by an automorphism @xmath9 , and call @xmath8 the _ motion _ of @xmath9 .
in other words , @xmath8 is the size of the set of vertices which are not fixed by @xmath9 , that is , the size of its _ support _ , @xmath10 . * the infinite motion conjecture of tom tucker . * _ let @xmath1 be an infinite , locally finite , connected graph .
if every nontrivial automorphism of @xmath1 has infinite motion , then the distinguishing number @xmath0 of @xmath1 is either 1 or 2 .
_ for the origin of the conjecture and partial results compare @xcite .
the conjecture is true if @xmath11 is countable , hence we concentrate on graphs with uncountable group .
the validity of the conjecture for graphs with countable group follows from either one of two different results in @xcite .
one of them replaces the requirement of infinite motion by a lower and upper bound on the size of the automorphism group .
it asserts that every infinite , locally finite , connected graph @xmath1 whose automorphism group is infinite , but strictly smaller than @xmath12 , has countable group , infinite motion , and distinguishing number 2 .
for a precise formulation see theorem [ thm : simon ] .
the proof is not easy and follows from results of either halin @xcite , trofimov @xcite , or evans @xcite .
the other one relaxes the condition of local finiteness and requires that the group is at most countable .
it asserts that countably infinite , connected graphs with finite or countably infinite group and infinite motion are @xmath5-distinguishable , no matter whether they are locally finite or not , see theorem [ thm : tucker ] .
the proof is short and elementary . for uncountable connected graphs with countable motion the infinite motion conjecture need
not be true .
we turn to this case in section [ sec : generalization ] , suggest a version of the conjecture for uncountable connected graphs , and prove its validity under a bound on the size of the automorphism group .
throughout this paper the symbol @xmath13 denotes the set @xmath14 of positive integers , whereas the symbol @xmath15 refers to the set @xmath16 of non - negative integers .
let @xmath1 be a graph with vertex set @xmath17 .
let @xmath18 be a set .
an @xmath18-_labeling _ @xmath19 of @xmath1 is a mapping @xmath20 . for us
@xmath18 will mostly be the set @xmath21 . in this case
, we speak of a _ @xmath5-coloring _ of @xmath1 .
let @xmath19 be an @xmath18-labeling of @xmath1 .
consider an automorphism @xmath22 .
if , for every @xmath23 , @xmath24 , we say that @xmath19 _ is preserved by _
if this is not the case , we say that @xmath19 _ breaks _ @xmath9 .
an @xmath18-labeling @xmath19 of @xmath1 is called _ distinguishing _ if it is only preserved by the trivial automorphism .
the _ distinguishing number _ @xmath0 of @xmath1 is the least cardinal @xmath2 such that there exists a distinguishing @xmath18-labeling of @xmath1 with @xmath25 . given a group @xmath26 equipped with a homomorphism @xmath27
, we say that @xmath26 _ acts on _ @xmath1 .
moreover , we say that @xmath26 _ acts nontrivially _ on @xmath1 if there is an @xmath28 such that @xmath29 moves at least one vertex of @xmath1 . by abuse of language
we write @xmath30 instead of @xmath31 and say that an @xmath18-labeling @xmath19 of @xmath1 _ is preserved by _
@xmath32 if it is preserved by @xmath33 .
the _ ball with center @xmath34 and radius @xmath35 _ is the set of all vertices @xmath23 with @xmath36 and is denoted by @xmath37 , whereas @xmath38 stands for the set of all vertices @xmath23 with @xmath39 .
we call it the _ sphere with center @xmath34 and radius @xmath35 . _
if @xmath1 is clear from the context , we just write @xmath40 and @xmath41 respectively . for terms
not defined here we refer to @xcite .
although our graphs are infinite , as long as they are locally finite , all balls and spheres of finite radius are finite .
the number of vertices in @xmath37 is a monotonically increasing function of @xmath35 , because @xmath42 nonetheless , the growth of @xmath43 depends very much on @xmath1 , and it is helpful to define the growth rate of a graph .
we say that an infinite , locally finite , connected graph @xmath1 has _ polynomial growth _ if there is a vertex @xmath44 and a polynomial @xmath45 such that @xmath46 it is easy to see that this implies that all functions @xmath47 are bounded by polynomials of the same degree as @xmath45 , independent of the choice of @xmath48 . in this context
it should be clear what we mean by _ linear _ and _ quadratic growth_. observe that the two - sided infinite path has linear growth , and that the growth of the grid of integers in the plane is quadratic .
we say that @xmath1 has _ exponential growth _ if there is a constant @xmath49 such that @xmath50 notice that homogeneous trees of degree @xmath51 , that is , infinite trees where every vertex has the same degree @xmath2 , have exponential growth . for the distinguishability of such trees and tree - like graphs , see @xcite and @xcite .
we are mainly interested is the distinguishability of infinite , locally finite , connected graphs of polynomial growth . for us
, the following lemma will be helpful .
[ lem : halfzero ] let @xmath26 be a finite group acting on a graph @xmath1 .
if a coloring of @xmath1 breaks some element of @xmath26 , then it breaks at least half of the elements of @xmath26 .
_ proof . _ the elements of @xmath26 that preserve a given coloring form a subgroup . if some element of @xmath26 is broken , then this subgroup is proper and thus , by lagrange s theorem , can not contain more than half of the elements of @xmath26 .
@xmath52 if the action is nontrivial , then we can always find a coloring that breaks at least one element .
hence , we have the following result . [
lem : halfone ] let @xmath1 be a graph . if @xmath26 is a finite group acting nontrivially on @xmath1 , then there exists a @xmath5-coloring of @xmath1 that breaks at least half of the elements of @xmath26 .
the proof of lemma [ lem : halfone ] is based on the fact that @xmath26 is a group .
but a very similar result holds for any finite family of nontrivial automorphisms , as the following lemma shows .
[ lem : halftwo ] let @xmath1 be a finite graph .
if @xmath26 is a finite set equipped with a mapping @xmath53 , then there exists a @xmath5-coloring of @xmath1 that breaks @xmath29 for at least half of the elements of @xmath26 .
_ let @xmath54 .
for every @xmath55 , let @xmath56 be the set of all @xmath32 with @xmath57 .
we show by induction that the assertion holds for all @xmath56 and , in particular , for @xmath26 . because @xmath58 is the empty set ,
the assertion is true for @xmath58 .
suppose it is true for @xmath59 .
then we can choose a @xmath5-coloring of @xmath1 that breaks @xmath29 for at least half of the elements of @xmath59 .
this remains true , even when we change the color of @xmath60 .
notice that , for every @xmath61 , @xmath29 either maps @xmath60 into a white vertex in @xmath62 or into a black vertex in @xmath62 .
depending on which of the two alternatives occurs more often , we color @xmath60 black or white such that this @xmath5-coloring also breaks @xmath29 for at least half of the elements of @xmath63 and , hence , for at least half of the elements of @xmath56 .
@xmath52 if every nontrivial automorphism of a graph @xmath1 has infinite motion , we say that @xmath1 has _
infinite motion_. for such graphs the following result from @xcite will be of importance .
[ lem : main ] let @xmath1 be an infinite , locally finite , connected graph with infinite motion . if an automorphism @xmath22 fixes a vertex @xmath34 and moves at least one vertex in @xmath64 , then , for every @xmath65 , it moves at least one vertex in @xmath66 .
in @xcite , it was shown that infinite , locally finite , connected graphs with infinite motion and linear growth have countable automorphism group , and therefore distinguishing number either 1 or 2 .
if the growth rate of such graphs becomes nonlinear , then the automorphism group can become uncountable .
this holds , even if the growth rate becomes only slightly nonlinear .
[ thm : stretchedtree ] let @xmath67 .
then there exists an infinite , locally finite , connected graph @xmath1 with uncountable automorphism group , infinite motion , and nonlinear growth function @xmath68 such that , for sufficiently large @xmath69 , @xmath70 is bounded from above by @xmath71 . _ proof .
_ we construct @xmath1 from @xmath72 , that is , the tree in which every vertex has degree 3 . first , choose an arbitrary vertex @xmath73 .
our strategy is to replace the edges of @xmath72 by paths such that , for sufficiently large @xmath69 , @xmath74 . for every @xmath75 , there are @xmath76 edges from @xmath77 to @xmath78 .
if we replace them by paths of the same length , then the cardinality of the balls @xmath79 grows linearly with slope @xmath76 from @xmath77 to @xmath78 .
observe that , given any affine linear function @xmath80 , there is a number @xmath81 such that , for all @xmath82 , @xmath83 .
in particular , we may consider the functions @xmath84 defined by @xmath85 , and choose numbers @xmath86 such that , for every @xmath87 , @xmath88 . as illustrated in figure
[ fig : replacing ] , for every @xmath75 , we replace the edges from @xmath77 to @xmath78 by paths of length @xmath89 . for every @xmath90 and every vertex @xmath23 on such a path from @xmath77 to @xmath78
, we have @xmath91 and , hence , @xmath92 so , for every @xmath93 , @xmath70 is bounded from above by @xmath71 .
every automorphism of @xmath72 that fixes @xmath94 induces an automorphism of @xmath1 .
it is easy to see that this correspondence is bijective .
thus , @xmath11 is uncountable .
furthermore , @xmath1 inherits infinite motion from @xmath72 .
since @xmath11 is uncountable , the result of @xcite mentioned at the beginning of section [ sec : nonlinear ] implies that @xmath1 can not have linear growth .
though we can not assume that the automorphism groups of our graphs are countable , we prove that infinite , locally finite , connected graphs with infinite motion and nonlinear , but moderate , growth are still @xmath5-distinguishable , that is , they have distinguishing number either @xmath4 or @xmath5 .
our construction of a suitable coloring consists of several steps . in lemma [ lem : fixroot ]
we color a part of the vertices in order to break all automorphisms that move a distinguished vertex @xmath95 . in lemma
[ lem : breakautos ] we show how to color some of the remaining vertices in order to break more automorphisms .
iteration of this procedure yields a distinguishing coloring , as shown in theorem [ thm : spheres ] .
[ lem : fixroot ] let @xmath1 be an infinite , locally finite , connected graph with infinite motion and @xmath34 . then , for every @xmath96 , one can @xmath5-color all vertices in @xmath97 and @xmath98 , @xmath99 , such that , no matter how one colors the remaining vertices , all automorphisms that move @xmath95 are broken .
_ if @xmath100 , then we color @xmath94 black and all @xmath101 white , whence all automorphisms that move @xmath95 are broken .
so , let @xmath102 .
first , we color all vertices in @xmath103 , @xmath104 , and @xmath105 black and the remaining vertices in @xmath97 white .
moreover , we color all vertices in @xmath98 , @xmath99 , black and claim that , no matter how we color the remaining vertices , @xmath95 is the only black vertex that has only black neighbors and only white vertices at distance @xmath106 , see figure [ fig : fixroot ] .
it clearly follows from this claim that this coloring breaks every automorphism that moves @xmath94 .
it only remains to verify the claim .
consider a vertex @xmath101 . if @xmath107 is not in @xmath104 , then it is easy to see that @xmath107 can not have the aforementioned properties .
so , let @xmath107 be in @xmath104 and assume it has only black neighbors and only white vertices at distance @xmath5 . then it can not be neighbor to any vertex in @xmath108 , but must be neighbor to all vertices in @xmath109 except itself . therefore , the transposition of the vertices @xmath107 and @xmath94 is a nontrivial automorphism of @xmath1 with finite support .
since @xmath1 has infinite motion , this is not possible .
[ lem : breakautos ] let @xmath1 be an infinite , locally finite , connected graph with infinite motion and @xmath34 .
moreover , let @xmath67 .
then there exists a @xmath96 such that , for every @xmath110 and for every @xmath111 that is sufficiently large and fulfills @xmath112 one can @xmath5-color all vertices in @xmath113 , but not those in @xmath98 , @xmath99 , such that all automorphisms that fix @xmath95 and act nontrivially on @xmath114 are broken . the coloring and the meaning of the variables @xmath115 , @xmath116 , and @xmath117 is illustrated by figure [ fig : breakautos ] .
_ first , choose a @xmath96 that is larger than @xmath118 . then @xmath119 let @xmath110 . by ( [ eq : k ] )
, there is an @xmath120 such that @xmath121 let @xmath111 be sufficiently large , that is , @xmath122 , and assume it fulfills ( [ eq:1 ] ) .
then , the number of spheres @xmath123 that are not of the type @xmath98 , @xmath99 , is at least @xmath124 our goal is to @xmath5-color the vertices in these spheres in order to break all automorphisms that fix @xmath94 and act nontrivially on @xmath114 .
let @xmath125 be the group of all automorphisms that fix @xmath94 .
every @xmath126 induces a permutation @xmath127 of the vertices in @xmath128 .
these permutations form a group @xmath26 . if @xmath129 and @xmath130 are different elements of @xmath26 , then @xmath131 acts nontrivially on @xmath128 . by lemma [ lem : main ]
, it also does so on @xmath132 , which means that @xmath129 and @xmath130 do not agree on @xmath132 .
therefore , the cardinality of @xmath26 is at most @xmath133 , for which the following rough estimate suffices for our purposes : @xmath134 it is clear that , if an element @xmath135 that acts nontrivially on @xmath114 is broken by a suitable @xmath5-coloring of some spheres in @xmath136 , then all @xmath126 with @xmath137 are broken at once .
so it suffices to break all @xmath135 that act nontrivially on @xmath114 by a suitable @xmath5-coloring of some spheres in @xmath136 in order to ensure that all @xmath126 that act nontrivially on @xmath114 are broken . before doing this ,
let us remark that any element @xmath135 that acts nontrivially on the ball @xmath114 , also acts nontrivially on every sphere @xmath138 . this is a consequence of lemma [ lem : main ] , and implies that we can break @xmath129 by breaking the action of @xmath129 on any one of the spheres @xmath138 .
now , consider the subset @xmath139 of all elements that act nontrivially on @xmath114 .
as already remarked , every @xmath140 acts nontrivially on every sphere @xmath138 .
hence , we can apply lemma [ lem : halftwo ] to break at least half of the elements of @xmath141 by a suitable coloring of @xmath142 .
what remains unbroken is a subset @xmath143 of cardinality at most @xmath144 .
now , we proceed to the next sphere .
we can break at least half of the elements of @xmath145 by a suitable coloring of @xmath146 .
what still remains unbroken , is a subset @xmath147 of cardinality at most @xmath148 .
iterating the procedure , but avoiding spheres of the type @xmath98 , @xmath99 , we end up with the empty subset @xmath149 after at most @xmath150 steps , see ( [ eq : automorphisms ] ) .
this is less than the number of spheres not of the type @xmath98 , @xmath99 , between @xmath142 and @xmath132 , see ( [ eq : spheres ] ) .
thus , we remain within the ball @xmath128 . hence , all @xmath151 and , therefore , all @xmath152 that act nontrivially on @xmath114 are broken , and we are done .
@xmath52 [ thm : spheres ]
let @xmath1 be an infinite , locally finite , connected graph with infinite motion and @xmath34 .
moreover , let @xmath67 .
if there exist infinitely many @xmath111 such that @xmath153 then the distinguishing number @xmath0 of @xmath1 is either @xmath4 or @xmath5 .
_ consider the @xmath96 provided by lemma [ lem : breakautos ] .
first , we use lemma [ lem : fixroot ] to @xmath5-color all vertices in @xmath97 and in @xmath98 , @xmath99 , such that , no matter how we color the remaining vertices , all automorphisms that move @xmath95 are broken .
let @xmath154 . among all @xmath111 that satisfy ( [ eq : smallspheres ] ) we choose a number @xmath155 that is larger than @xmath156 and sufficiently large to apply lemma [ lem : breakautos ] .
hence , we can @xmath5-color all vertices in @xmath157 , except those in @xmath98 , @xmath99 , such that all automorphisms that fix @xmath95 and act nontrivially on @xmath158 are broken .
next , let @xmath159 and choose an @xmath160 to apply lemma [ lem : breakautos ] again .
iteration of this procedure yields a @xmath5-coloring of @xmath1 .
if an automorphism @xmath161 moves @xmath94 , then it is broken by our coloring .
if it fixes @xmath94 , consider a vertex @xmath107 with @xmath162 .
since @xmath1 is connected and @xmath163 , there is an @xmath90 such that @xmath107 is contained in @xmath164 .
hence , @xmath9 acts nontrivially on @xmath164 and is again broken by our coloring .
@xmath52 [ cor : growth ]
let @xmath1 be an infinite , locally finite , connected graph with infinite motion and @xmath34 .
moreover , let @xmath67 .
if there exist infinitely many @xmath111 such that @xmath165 then the distinguishing number @xmath0 of @xmath1 is either @xmath4 or @xmath5 . in particular , the infinite motion conjecture holds for all graphs of growth @xmath3 .
_ let @xmath166 be an infinite sequence of numbers that fulfill ( [ eq : smallballs ] ) .
notice that , for every @xmath96 , @xmath167 since @xmath168 we infer that @xmath169 and that , for infinitely many @xmath90 , @xmath170 hence , we can apply theorem [ thm : spheres ] to show that the distinguishing number @xmath0 of @xmath1 is either @xmath4 or @xmath5 .
@xmath52 a result similar to theorem [ thm : spheres ] can also be obtained for graphs with countably many ends , none of which grows too fast .
readers not familiar with the notion of ends may safely skip the rest of this section , as the result is not used elsewhere in the paper .
let @xmath1 be an infinite , locally finite , connected graph with countably many ends and infinite motion .
moreover , let @xmath171 and @xmath67 .
for an end @xmath172 of @xmath1 let @xmath173 be the set of vertices in @xmath132 that lie in the same connected component of @xmath174 as @xmath172 . if , for every end @xmath172 , there are infinitely many @xmath175 such that @xmath176 then the distinguishing number @xmath0 of @xmath1 is either @xmath4 or @xmath5 .
_ basically the proof consists of three steps .
first we color part of the vertex set in order to break all automorphisms that move @xmath94 .
in the second step we break all automorphisms in @xmath125 that do not fix all ends of the graph by coloring some other vertices .
finally , we color the remaining vertices to break the rest of the automorphisms . in order to break all automorphisms that move @xmath94 we apply lemma [ lem : fixroot ] , just as in the proof of theorem [ thm : spheres ] .
the only difference is that we choose @xmath117 twice as large as proposed by lemma [ lem : breakautos ] , because we would like to color some additional spheres in the second step of the proof before applying an argument similar to that in lemma [ lem : breakautos ] .
for the second step consider the spheres @xmath177 , @xmath99 .
we wish to color those spheres such that every automorphism that fixes @xmath94 and preserves the coloring also fixes every end of @xmath1 .
it is not hard to see that the sets @xmath178 , @xmath172 an end of @xmath1 , @xmath99 , carry the following tree structure .
consider @xmath94 , the root , which is connected by an edge to @xmath179 for each end @xmath172 .
for every end @xmath172 of @xmath1 and every @xmath99 , draw an edge from @xmath178 to @xmath180 . to see that this is indeed a tree
just notice that if @xmath181 , then , for every @xmath182 , @xmath183 .
so there can not be any circles . by construction , this tree structure is infinite , locally finite , and does not have any endpoints .
next , notice that every automorphism @xmath184 that does not fix all ends also acts as an automorphism on this tree structure . by @xcite ,
the distinguishing number of infinite , locally finite trees without endpoints is at most @xmath5 .
therefore it is possible to @xmath5-color the sets @xmath178 , @xmath172 an end of @xmath1 , @xmath99 , such that every such automorphism is broken .
it is also worth noting that so far we did not use the countability of the end space of @xmath1 , nor did we use the growth condition on the ends .
let us turn to the third step of the proof .
so far we have colored the ball @xmath185 and the spheres @xmath186 , @xmath187 , in a way that color preserving automorphisms fix @xmath94 and move every @xmath188 into itself .
consider such an automorphism @xmath9 , which acts nontrivially on @xmath1 .
if we remove the fixed points of @xmath9 from @xmath1 , then the infinite motion of @xmath1 implies that the resulting graph has only infinite components .
hence , there is a ray in @xmath1 which contains no fixed point of @xmath9 .
the image of this ray must lie in the same end @xmath172 .
thus , there is an index @xmath189 , such that , for every @xmath190 , @xmath9 acts nontrivially on @xmath173 .
let @xmath191 be an enumeration of the ends of @xmath1 .
choose a function @xmath192 such that , for every @xmath90 , @xmath193 is infinite .
assume that all spheres up to @xmath194 have been colored in the first @xmath195 steps .
in the @xmath196-th step we would like to color some more spheres in order to continue breaking all automorphisms in @xmath197 that act nontrivially on each of the spheres @xmath198 , @xmath199 . this can be done by exactly the same argument as the one used in the proof of lemma [ lem : breakautos ] . as we already mentioned , every automorphism that was not broken in the first two steps acts by nontrivially on the rays of some end .
since , in the procedure described above , every end is considered infinitely often , it is clear that every such automorphism will eventually be broken .
this completes the proof .
if a graph @xmath1 has trivial automorphism group , then @xmath1 is obviously @xmath4-distinguishable , that is , @xmath200 . from now on
we assume that our graphs @xmath1 have nontrivial automorphism group . in this case , the _ motion _ @xmath6 of @xmath1 is defined as @xmath201 as already mentioned , the infinite motion conjecture does not hold for graphs of higher cardinality .
an example is the cartesian product @xmath202 of two complete graphs on infinitely many vertices @xmath203 and @xmath204 with @xmath205 .
by @xcite , @xmath1 has motion @xmath206 , but @xmath207 .
the question arises whether one can adapt the infinite motion conjecture to graphs of higher cardinality .
the starting point is ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) .
it asserts that a finite graph @xmath1 is @xmath5-distinguishable if @xmath208 .
however , a second look at the proof shows that the inequality sign can be replaced by @xmath209 .
for details see section [ se : rusu ] . for finite graphs
we thus infer that @xmath210 which can also be written in the form @xmath211 notice that @xmath212 if @xmath6 is infinite .
we are thus tempted to conjecture for graphs @xmath1 with infinite motion that @xmath213 implies @xmath214 .
we formulate this conjecture as the * motion conjecture . *
_ let @xmath1 be a connected graph with infinite motion @xmath6 and _ @xmath215 _ then @xmath216 .
_ how does this compare with the infinite motion conjecture ?
it asserts that the distinguishing number of a locally finite , connected graph @xmath1 is @xmath5 if @xmath6 is infinite . since locally finite graphs are countable , the condition that @xmath6 is infinite is equivalent to @xmath217 .
furthermore , for countable graphs we have @xmath218hence , for countable graphs , and thus also for locally finite , connected graphs with infinite motion , the inequality of the motion conjecture is automatically satisfied , which means that the infinite motion conjecture is a special case of the motion conjecture .
now , let us focus on the two results from @xcite that imply the validity of the infinite motion conjecture for graphs with countable group .
[ thm : simon ] let @xmath1 be a locally finite , connected graph that satisfies @xmath219 .
then @xmath220 , @xmath217 , and @xmath221 .
notice that the only thing that is required here , besides local finiteness and connectedness , is an upper and a lower bound on the size of @xmath11 . and
it turns out , that @xmath11 is countable , even without the continuum hypothesis . even infinite motion and @xmath221
are consequences of this restriction on the size of the automorphism group .
[ thm : tucker ] let @xmath1 be a countably infinite , connected graph that satisfies the conditions @xmath222 and @xmath217
. then @xmath216 . here ,
without local finiteness , one can not drop the assumption of infinite motion . if we assume that @xmath11 has smaller cardinality than the continuum
, then we can ensure @xmath5-distinguishability if the continuum hypothesis holds , but we do not know whether this is really necessary .
[ cor : tucker ] let @xmath1 be a countably infinite , connected graph with infinite motion . if the continuum hypothesis holds , and if @xmath223 , then @xmath224 .
the next theorem shows that theorem [ thm : tucker ] also holds for graphs of higher cardinality and uncountable motion .
[ thm : special ] let @xmath1 be a connected graph with uncountable motion
. then @xmath222 implies @xmath216 .
_ set @xmath225 , and let @xmath226 be the smallest ordinal number whose underlying set has cardinality @xmath203 . furthermore , choose a well ordering @xmath227 of @xmath228 of order type @xmath226 , and let @xmath229 be the smallest element with respect to @xmath227 .
then the cardinality of the set of all elements of @xmath26 between @xmath229 and any other @xmath230 is smaller than @xmath231 .
now we color all vertices of @xmath1 white and use transfinite induction to break all automorphisms by coloring selected vertices black .
induction base by the assumptions of the theorem , there exists a vertex @xmath94 that is not fixed by @xmath229 .
we color it black .
this coloring breaks @xmath229 .
induction step let @xmath232 .
suppose we have already broken all @xmath233 by pairs of distinct vertices @xmath234 , where @xmath235 is black and @xmath236 white . clearly , the cardinality of the set @xmath237 of all @xmath234 , @xmath233 , is less than @xmath238 . by assumption ,
@xmath239 moves at least @xmath6 vertices .
since there are still @xmath203 vertices not in @xmath237 , there must be a pair of vertices @xmath240 that does not meet @xmath237 .
we color @xmath241 black .
this coloring breaks @xmath239 .
@xmath52 [ cor : special ] let @xmath1 be a connected graph with uncountable motion . if the general continuum hypothesis holds , and if @xmath242 then @xmath224 .
_ under the assumption of the general continuum hypothesis @xmath243 is the successor of @xmath6 . hence @xmath244 , and the assertion of the corollary follows from theorem [ thm : special ] .
in order to show that a finite graph @xmath1 is @xmath5-distinguishable if @xmath208 , russell and sundaram @xcite first defined the cycle norm of an automorphism @xmath9 . if @xmath245 then the _ cycle norm _
@xmath246 of @xmath9 is @xmath247 the cycle norm @xmath246 is related to graph distinguishability as follows : let @xmath1 be randomly @xmath5-colored by independently assigning each vertex a color uniformly from @xmath21 .
then the probability that every cycle of @xmath9 is monochromatic is @xmath248 . in this case , @xmath9 preserves the coloring so chosen .
further , they define the cycle norm @xmath249 of a graph @xmath1 as @xmath250 we now reprove theorem 2 of @xcite with @xmath209 instead of @xmath251 . because @xmath252 and thus @xmath253 we infer from theorem [ thm : rusunew ] below that @xmath1 is @xmath5-distinguishable if @xmath254 .
we propose to call this result `` motion lemma of russell and sundaram '' .
actually , the only difference from the original proof is the insertion of the middle term in ( [ eq : sund ] ) .
_ let @xmath257 be a random @xmath2-coloring of @xmath1 , the probability distribution being given by selecting the color of each vertex independently and uniformly in the set @xmath258 .
for a fixed automorphism @xmath161 consider the probability that the random coloring @xmath257 is preserved by @xmath9 : @xmath259 = \left(\frac{1}{d}\right)^{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{c}}}(\phi ) } \leq \left(\frac{1}{d}\right)^{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{c}}}(g)}\,.\ ] ] collecting these events yields the inequality @xmath260 & \leq & ( |\!{\ensuremath{\operatorname{aut}}}(g)|-1)\left(\frac{1}{d}\right)^{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{c}}}(g ) } \medskip \\ & < & |\!{\ensuremath{\operatorname{aut}}}(g)|\left(\frac{1}{d}\right)^{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{c}}}(g)}\ , .
\end{array}\ ] ] by hypothesis the last term is at most 1 .
thus there exists a coloring @xmath257 such that , for every @xmath161 , there is a @xmath107 for which @xmath261 , as desired .
* acknowledgement .
* we thank the referees for their comments and remarks , as they contributed considerably to the readability of the paper .
furthermore , we are grateful to norbert sauer and claude laflamme for their suggestions pertaining to theorem [ thm : special ] and corollary [ cor : special ] . | the distinguishing number @xmath0 of a graph @xmath1 is the least cardinal @xmath2 such that @xmath1 has a labeling with @xmath2 labels which is only preserved by the trivial automorphism .
we show that the distinguishing number of infinite , locally finite , connected graphs @xmath1 with infinite motion and growth @xmath3 is either @xmath4 or @xmath5 , which proves the infinite motion conjecture of tom tucker for this type of graphs .
the same holds true for graphs with countably many ends that do not grow too fast .
we also show that graphs @xmath1 of arbitrary cardinality are @xmath5-distinguishable if every nontrivial automorphism moves at least uncountably many vertices @xmath6 , where @xmath7 .
this extends a result of imrich et al . to graphs with automorphism groups of arbitrary cardinality .
* keywords : * distinguishing number , automorphisms , infinite graphs . *
msc classes : * 05c25 , 05c63 , 05c15 , 03e10 . |
consider the simplest of hypergeometric integrals , @xmath6 it satisfies the differential equation @xmath7 the difference equation @xmath8 and a similar difference equation with respect to @xmath9 .
the equations ( [ simplekz ] ) and ( [ simpledyn ] ) are clearly compatible .
more general hypergeometric integrals appear in conformal field theory as integral representations for conformal blocks , see @xcite .
it is known that the integrals satisfy the kz differential equations .
the kz equations are generalizations of ( [ simplekz ] ) . in @xcite a system of difference equations , generalizing equation ( [ simpledyn ] ) ,
is proposed .
the system , proposed in @xcite , is compatible with the kz equations .
the difference equations were called the dynamical equations .
both the kz differential equations and the dynamical difference equations are associated to a given lie algebra .
it was conjectured in @xcite that the hypergeometric integrals , which satisfy the kz equations , also satisfy the dynamical equations . in this paper
we prove that the hypergeometric integrals solving the ( trigonometric ) kz equations associated to @xmath4 also satisfy the the dynamical equations .
the trigonometric kz equations have a rational limit called the ( standard ) rational kz equations . under this limiting procedure
the dynamical difference equations turn into a system of ( dynamical ) differential equations compatible with the rational kz equations .
the dynamical differential equations were introduced and studied in @xcite , see also @xcite . in @xcite
it was shown that the hypergeometric solutions of the rational kz equations also satisfy the dynamical differential equations .
the paper is organized as follows . in sections [ tkzsec ] and [ sec2 ]
we introduce notation and define the main objects of our study : the trigonometric and rational kz equations , the dynamical equations for the lie algebra @xmath4 . in section [ hgsol ] ,
following @xcite , we present a construction of hypergeometric solutions of the kz equations with values in a tensor product of highest weight @xmath4-modules . the main result of the paper is theorem [ main_sln ] .
we give new formulae for hypergeometric solutions related to special ( normal ) orders on the set of positive roots of @xmath4 in sections [ spec_ord ] and [ pf.5.2 ] , and new formulae for the dynamical difference equations in terms of the shapovalov form in section [ add_sect ] .
both results are used in the proof of theorem [ main_sln ] , given in section [ mainproof ] . in appendices
a and b we adapt a theorem from @xcite and a theorem from @xcite , respectively , to our setting . in appendix c
we give explicit formulae illustrating the main objects of our study in the case of the lie algebra @xmath10 .
we thank p. etingof , k. styrkas , and v. tarasov for many valuable discussions .
let @xmath0 be a simple complex lie algebra with root space decomposition @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the set of roots .
fix a system of simple roots @xmath13 .
let @xmath14 be the set of positive ( negative ) roots .
. then @xmath16 .
let @xmath17 be an invariant bilinear form on @xmath0 .
the form gives rise to a natural identification @xmath18 .
we use this identification and make no distinction between @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
this identification allows us to define a scalar product on @xmath20 .
we use the same notation @xmath17 for the pairing @xmath21 .
we use the notation : @xmath22 - root lattice ; @xmath23 ; @xmath24 - dual root lattice , where @xmath25 ; @xmath26 - weight lattice ; @xmath27 - cone of dominant integral weights ; @xmath28 - fundamental weights : @xmath29 ; @xmath30 ; @xmath31 - dual weight lattice , where @xmath32 -dual fundamental weights : @xmath33 . define a partial order on @xmath19 putting @xmath34 if @xmath35 . for @xmath36 choose generators @xmath37 so that @xmath38 . for any @xmath39 , the triple @xmath40 forms an @xmath41-subalgebra in @xmath0 , @xmath42=2e_{\alpha},\ , [ h_{\alpha},f_{\alpha}]=-2f_{\alpha},\ , [ e_{\alpha},f_{\alpha}]=h_{\alpha}$ ] .
the chevalley involution @xmath43 of @xmath0 is defined by @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 .
the antipode map @xmath48 of @xmath0 is defined by @xmath49 for @xmath50 .
let @xmath51 be the universal enveloping algebra of @xmath0 .
the chevalley involution , @xmath43 , extends to an involutive automorphism of @xmath51 which permutes @xmath52 and @xmath53 .
the antipode map , @xmath48 , extends to an involutive anti - automorphism of @xmath51 which preserves @xmath52 and @xmath53 .
let @xmath54 denote the simple reflection @xmath55 for all @xmath1 , and let @xmath56 be the weyl group , generated by @xmath57 .
for an element @xmath58 , denote @xmath59 the length of the minimal ( reduced ) presentation of @xmath60 as a product of generators @xmath57 . for any dual fundamental weight @xmath61 define an element @xmath62}=\omega_0\omega_0^k\in \w$ ] where @xmath63 ( respectively , @xmath64 ) is the longest element in @xmath56 ( respectively , in @xmath65 generated by all simple reflections @xmath66 preserving @xmath61 ) .
let @xmath1 be a weight .
let @xmath67 be the one - dimensional @xmath68-module such that @xmath69 with @xmath70 for any @xmath71 and @xmath72 .
the verma module with highest weight @xmath3 is the induced module @xmath73 .
@xmath74 is a free @xmath53- module and can be identified with @xmath53 as a linear space by the map @xmath75 , @xmath76 for any @xmath77 .
a highest weight module of weight @xmath3 is a quotient module of the verma module with highest weight @xmath3 .
all the highest weight modules in this paper are equipped with a distinguished generator , the highest vector .
let @xmath78 be a highest weight @xmath0-module with highest weight @xmath3 and highest weight vector @xmath79 .
we have a weight decomposition @xmath80 $ ] .
define @xmath81^*$ ] the restricted dual module to @xmath78 with the @xmath0-action @xmath82 for every @xmath83 , @xmath84 , @xmath85 .
then @xmath86 is a lowest weight @xmath0-module with the homogeneous lowest weight vector @xmath87 , such that @xmath88 .
the shapovalov form @xmath89 on @xmath78 is the unique symmetric bilinear form such that @xmath90 the form @xmath89 is non - degenerate if and only if @xmath78 is irreducible . in particular
, it is non - degenerate for generic values of @xmath3 .
let @xmath91 be any orthonormal basis of the cartan subalgebra @xmath19 .
set @xmath92 define the casimir operator @xmath93 and the trigonometric r - matrix @xmath94 by @xmath95 let @xmath96 , where @xmath97 is a @xmath0module .
the _ rational kz operators _ , @xmath98 , acting on a function @xmath99 of @xmath100 complex variables with values in @xmath101 are @xmath102 where @xmath103 is a complex parameter .
the _ rational kz equations _
are @xmath104 the rational kz equations are compatible , @xmath105=0 $ ] .
the kz operators commute with the @xmath0 action on @xmath101 .
thus , the kz operators preserve every subspace of @xmath101 consisting of all singular vectors of a given weight .
+ let @xmath106 , where @xmath97 is a @xmath0module .
the _ trigonometric kz operators _ , @xmath107 , with parameters @xmath108 and @xmath109 acting on a function @xmath110 of @xmath111 complex variables with values in @xmath112 are @xmath113 the _ trigonometric kz equations _
are @xmath114 the trigonometric kz equations are compatible , @xmath115=0 $ ] .
the trigonometric kz operators commute with the @xmath19 action on @xmath112 .
thus , the trigonometric kz operators preserve every weight subspace of @xmath112 . for every @xmath116 ,
let @xmath97 be a highest weight @xmath0-module with highest weight @xmath117 and highest weight vector @xmath118 .
set @xmath96 and @xmath106 .
let @xmath119 be the dual module to @xmath120 with the homogeneous lowest weight vector @xmath121 .
define a multi - linear map @xmath122 by @xmath123 , for any @xmath124 .
the following well known fact , see @xcite for example , describes the transition from rational kz equations to trigonometric kz equations .
[ kz2tkz ] fix a weight subspace @xmath125\subset v'$ ] , @xmath126 , where @xmath127 . let @xmath128 be a solution of the rational kz equations with parameter @xmath129 taking values in the subspace of @xmath125 $ ] consisting of all singular vectors .
set @xmath130 .
then @xmath131 is a solution of the trigonometric kz equations with values in the weight subspace @xmath132\subset v$ ] with parameter @xmath133 and the same parameter @xmath129 . a proof is given in appendix b.
let @xmath0 be a simple complex lie algebra . fix a root @xmath137 .
consider the @xmath41 subalgebra of @xmath0 with generators @xmath138 , @xmath139 , @xmath140 . for @xmath141 ,
introduce @xmath142 the series @xmath143 is an element of a suitable completion of @xmath144 . let @xmath106 be a tensor product of highest weight @xmath0modules . for @xmath36 , @xmath1 , the linear operator @xmath145 is defined by the rule : for any @xmath146 , and any @xmath147 $ ] , we have @xmath148 for every simple reflection @xmath149 define @xmath150 by @xmath151 . for every @xmath152 , such that @xmath153 , the operator @xmath154 is defined by the rule . if @xmath155 , where @xmath156 and @xmath157 , then @xmath158 let @xmath159 , @xmath160 , be the standard generators of the lie algebra @xmath161 , @xmath162\,=\,\delta_{l , k'}\,e_{k , l'}\,-\,\delta_{k , l'}\,e_{l , k'}\,.$ ] the lie algebra @xmath4 is the lie subalgebra of @xmath161 such that @xmath163 where @xmath164 and @xmath165 . the invariant scalar product on @xmath4 is defined by @xmath166 .
the roots of @xmath4 are @xmath167 , @xmath168 .
the positive roots are @xmath169 .
the simple roots are @xmath170 , @xmath171 . for a positive root @xmath172 , the elements @xmath173 , @xmath174 , @xmath175 generate the @xmath41 subalgebra associated with @xmath172 .
we have @xmath176 for any root . for any @xmath177
, we have @xmath178\ldots]].\ ] ] define the standard linear order on the set of positive roots , @xmath179 if and only if @xmath180 , or @xmath181 and @xmath182 . the weyl group @xmath56 is the symmetric group @xmath183 permuting coordinates of @xmath1 .
the ( dual ) fundamental weights are @xmath184 , and the permutations @xmath185}^{-1}\in s^n$ ] have the form @xmath185}^{-1}=\left ( { } ^1_{k+1}\,{}^{2}_{k+2}\,{}^{ ... }_{ ... }\,{}^{n - k}_{n}\,{}^{n - k+1}_{1}\ , { } ^{ ... }_{ ... }\,{}^{n}_{k } \right)$ ] , @xmath186 .
the _ dynamical difference equations _ on a @xmath112-valued function @xmath187 for @xmath4 are @xmath188 where @xmath189},v}(\lambda).\ ] ] the operators @xmath190 preserve the weight decomposition of @xmath112 . _ the dynamical equations ( [ dyneq ] ) together with the trigonometric kz equations ( [ tkz ] ) form a compatible system of equations .
namely , @xmath191=0 , \qquad \nabla_j(\kappa,\lambda+\kappa\omega_k^\vee)k_k(z,\lambda)= k_k(z,\lambda)\nabla_j(\kappa,\lambda),\notag\\ & k_k(z,\lambda+\kappa\omega_{l}^\vee)k_{l}(z,\lambda)= k_{l}(z,\lambda+\kappa\omega_{k}^\vee)k_{k}(z,\lambda ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath192 , and @xmath193 .
we use the construction in @xcite of hypergeometric solutions of the rational @xmath4 kz equations in a tensor product of lowest weight modules .
we modify this procedure in appendix a to a construction of solutions of the rational kz equations in a tensor product of highest weight modules , cf .
we present the result below .
then we use proposition [ kz2tkz ] to give hypergeometric solutions of the trigonometric kz equations .
there are different constructions of hypergeometric solutions of kz equations , cf .
one should expect , that all of them give the same result , but this was never checked off as far as we know .
let @xmath194 , where @xmath97 is a highest weight @xmath4 module with highest weight @xmath117 and highest weight vector @xmath118 .
fix a weight subspace @xmath125\subset v'$ ] , @xmath195 , where @xmath196 .
set @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
* the function @xmath199 .
* consider complex spaces @xmath200 with coordinates @xmath201 , and @xmath202 with coordinates @xmath203 , @xmath204 , @xmath205 .
fix an order @xmath206 on the set of coordinates in @xmath202 , @xmath207 if and only if @xmath208 , or @xmath209 and @xmath210 .
define a multi - valued function @xmath211 @xmath212 * the standard pbw - basis . *
any order on the set @xmath213 of positive roots of @xmath4 induces an order on the set @xmath214 which is a basis of @xmath215 , @xmath216 succeeds @xmath217 if and only if @xmath172 succeeds @xmath218 .
the standard order @xmath219 on @xmath213 induces the standard order @xmath219 on @xmath214 , @xmath220 if and only if @xmath180 , or @xmath181 and @xmath182 . the corresponding ( standard )
pbw - basis of @xmath53 is @xmath221 where @xmath222 runs over all sequences of non - negative integers .
let @xmath223 be elements of the standard pbw - basis , @xmath224 .
set @xmath225 .
the corresponding `` monomial '' vector @xmath226 lies in @xmath125 $ ] if @xmath227 denote @xmath228 the set of all indices @xmath229 corresponding to monomial vectors in @xmath125 $ ] .
the set @xmath230 forms a basis of @xmath125 $ ] provided the tensor factors of @xmath101 are verma modules , and generates @xmath125 $ ] otherwise . * the rational function @xmath231 . * for @xmath232 and @xmath233 , define two index sets .
@xmath234 condition ( [ pmn ] ) implies @xmath235 for all @xmath233 .
for every @xmath236 fix a bijection @xmath237 . for @xmath238 , define rational functions @xmath239 set @xmath240 * examples .
* let @xmath241 .
then @xmath242 is a basis of @xmath215 .
. @xmath244 * the integrals . *
consider the integral with values in @xmath125 $ ] @xmath245 where @xmath246 and @xmath247 in @xmath248 is a horizontal family of @xmath249-dimensional cycles of the twisted homology defined by the multi - valued function @xmath250 , see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
for a positive integer @xmath251 , let @xmath252 be the symmetric group on @xmath251 elements .
the group @xmath253 acts on points @xmath254 of @xmath202 permuting coordinates in each group @xmath255 .
denote @xmath256 the union of hyperplanes @xmath257 in @xmath258 .
we always make the following assumption on @xmath247 .
* assumption , @xcite . * _ for any rational function @xmath259 with poles in @xmath256 and any permutation + @xmath260 we have @xmath261 .
_ [ t_mat ] the function @xmath262 takes values in the subspace of singular vectors in @xmath125 $ ] and satisfies the rational kz equations with parameter @xmath129 .
the function @xmath263 is called a hypergeometric solution of the rational kz equation .
different solutions correspond to different choices of the horizontal family @xmath247 . * remark . *
the assumption on the cycles of integration implies that the function @xmath264 does not depend on the choice of bijections @xmath265 .
+ let @xmath266 .
fix a weight subspace @xmath132\subset v$ ] , @xmath130 .
let @xmath267 .
define a function @xmath268 define a rational function @xmath269 with values in the weight subspace @xmath132 $ ] , @xmath270 consider the integral with values in @xmath132 $ ] , @xmath271 , where @xmath272 in @xmath273 is a horizontal family of @xmath249-dimensional cycles of the twisted homology defined by the multi - valued function @xmath274 .
consider the union of hyperplanes @xmath275 in @xmath258 .
we always make the following assumption on @xmath272 . * assumption . * _ for any rational function @xmath259 with poles in @xmath276 and any permutation @xmath260 we have @xmath277 .
_ [ mat_trig ] the function @xmath278 takes values in the weight space @xmath132 $ ] and satisfies the trigonometric kz equations with parameters @xmath129 and @xmath1 . _ proof .
_ the statement of the corollary follows from theorem [ t_mat ] and proposition [ kz2tkz ] .
the function @xmath279 is called a hypergeometric solution of the trigonometric kz equation .
for any @xmath280 we have @xmath281 the product @xmath282 is a univalued function , which never vanishes .
therefore , we can and will consider any horizontal family of @xmath249-dimensional cycles , @xmath272 in @xmath273 , of the twisted homology defined by the multi - valued function @xmath283 as a horizontal family of @xmath249-dimensional cycles of the twisted homology defined by the multi - valued function @xmath284 .
this identification implies , that if we choose a hypergeometric solution of the trigonometric kz equation , @xmath285 for fixed @xmath3 , we obtain a hypergeometric solutions @xmath286 for any @xmath287 .
the following theorem is the main result of this paper .
[ main_sln ] let @xmath288 be a tensor product of highest weight @xmath4 modules .
let @xmath279 be a hypergeometric solution of the trigonometric kz equations ( [ tkz ] ) with values in a weight subspace @xmath132\subset v,$ ] @xmath289 .
then , the function @xmath279 also satisfies the dynamical equations ( [ dyneq ] ) , @xmath290 the theorem is proved in section [ mainproof ] .
* example .
* let @xmath291 and @xmath292 .
denote @xmath39 the positive root of @xmath41 , and let @xmath293 , where @xmath294 is a positive integer and @xmath295 is the @xmath296-dimensional irreducible @xmath41-module with highest weight @xmath297 and highest weight vector @xmath298 . consider a weight subspace @xmath299 $ ] of @xmath295 , where @xmath300 .
let @xmath301 be a hypergeometric solution of the trigonometric kz equation with parameters @xmath1 , @xmath129 , which takes values in @xmath299 $ ] .
up to a multiplicative constant , it has the form @xmath302 where @xmath303 is the selberg integral , see @xcite , @xmath304 the dynamical equation ( [ dyneq ] ) reduces to the following equation satisfied by the selberg integral @xmath305 * application to determinants .
* let @xmath112 be a finite dimensional @xmath4 - module , and @xmath132 $ ] a weight subspace .
for a positive root @xmath39 fix the @xmath41 subalgebra in @xmath4 generated by @xmath306 . consider v as an @xmath41 module .
let @xmath132_\alpha\subset v$ ] be the @xmath41 - submodule generated by @xmath132 $ ] .
let @xmath132_\alpha=\oplus_{m\in\zit_{\geq}}w_m^\alpha\otimes l_{\nu+m\alpha}$ ] be the decomposition into irreducible @xmath41 - modules , where @xmath307 is the irreducible module with highest weight @xmath308 and @xmath309 is the multiplicity space .
set @xmath310 and @xmath311}(\lambda)=\prod_{m=0}^\infty\left ( \prod_{j=1}^m\frac{\gamma(1-\frac1\kappa((\lambda,\alpha)-\frac12(\nu+j\alpha,\alpha ) ) ) } { \gamma(1-\frac1\kappa((\lambda,\alpha)+\frac12(\nu+j\alpha,\alpha)))}\right)^{d_m^\alpha},\ ] ] where @xmath312 is the standard gamma function .
let @xmath288 be a tensor product of finite dimensional @xmath4 modules .
set @xmath313}\lambda^{(i)}$ ] , @xmath314}\omega^{(i , j)}$ ] , @xmath315 , where @xmath192 .
set @xmath316}(z_1,\ldots , z_n,\lambda)=\prod_{i=1}^nz_i^{\frac1\kappa(\lambda_i(\lambda)-\frac12\gamma_i ) } \prod_{1\leq i <
j\leq n}(z_i - z_j)^{\frac{\varepsilon_{i , j}}{\kappa } } \prod_{\alpha\in\sigma_+}x_{\alpha , v[\nu]}(\lambda).\ ] ] fix a basis @xmath317 in a weight subspace @xmath132 $ ] .
suppose that @xmath318 , @xmath319 , is a set of @xmath132 $ ] valued solutions of the trigonometric kz equations and the dynamical equations .
[ t - dettv ] @xmath320}(\lambda)d_{v[\nu]}(z,\lambda),\ ] ] where @xmath321}(\lambda)$ ] is a function of @xmath3 ( depending also on @xmath322 , @xmath323 and @xmath103 ) such that @xmath321}(\lambda)$ ] is @xmath324-periodic , @xmath321}(\lambda+\kappa\omega^\vee)=c_{v[\nu]}(\lambda)$ ] for all @xmath287
. * remark .
* theorem [ main_sln ] implies that theorem [ t - dettv ] can be applied to any set , @xmath325 , of hypergeometric solutions of the trigonometric kz equations , thus giving a formula for the determinant of hypergeometric integrals .
* continuation of the example . * for @xmath291 , @xmath292 , @xmath293
, we have @xmath326 the determinant equals the complex function given as the expression preceding @xmath327 in formula ( [ ex_sl2 ] ) .
denote this function @xmath328 .
the explicit formula for the selberg integral in terms of gamma functions implies @xmath329 therefore , @xmath330}(\lambda)=(m!)^{-1 } \prod_{j=0}^{m-1}\gamma(1+\frac1\kappa(1+j))\gamma(\frac{j - p}{\kappa})(\gamma(1+\frac1\kappa))^{-1}$ ] .
matsuo s construction of hypergeometric solutions uses a pbw - basis of @xmath332 corresponding to the standard order of positive roots .
we rewrite those solutions using pbw - bases of @xmath332 corresponding to some new @xmath331 special ( normal ) orders of positive roots .
the special orders are defined below . a linear order on the set of positive roots @xmath213 of a simple lie algebra @xmath0
is called normal if for every triple of positive roots @xmath333 we have either @xmath334 , or @xmath335 .
the standard order on the set of positive roots of @xmath4 is a normal order .
consider a linear order on @xmath213 .
a permutation @xmath336 of @xmath213 is called _ an elementary transformation _ if @xmath336 is a reversal of a certain sub - system @xmath337 , where @xmath338 has rank 2 and all elements of @xmath338 are located side by side in the system @xmath213 .
an elementary transformation produces a new linear order .
it is known that every elementary transformation converts one normal order into another , and that any two normal orders on @xmath213 can be transformed one into the other by a composition of elementary transformations , see @xcite and @xcite .
* example .
* for a root system of type @xmath339 ( @xmath340 ) we have only two types of elementary transformations .
we compute the change of a pbw - basis under a reversal of type @xmath342 or @xmath343 .
[ elem_trans ] let @xmath0 be a simple lie algebra and let @xmath39 and @xmath344 be two positive roots .
choose arbitrary @xmath345 and @xmath346 .
then , for any triple of non - negative integers we have the following two identities in @xmath53 . @xmath347^c}{c!}\frac{f_{\beta}^b}{b ! } = \sum_{p=0}^{\min(a , b)}\bin{c+p}{p}(-1)^{c}(-1)^{a+b+c - p}\frac{f_{\beta}^{b - p}}{(b - p ) ! } \frac{[f_{\beta},f_{\alpha}]^{c+p}}{(c+p)!}\frac{f_{\alpha}^{a - p}}{(a - p)!}.\notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] _ proof . _
the proof is a straightforward induction on @xmath348 .
+ recall that the set @xmath213 of @xmath4 is @xmath169 .
the standard order on @xmath213 is @xmath179 if and only if @xmath180 , or @xmath181 and @xmath182 . for @xmath233 ,
define the index sets @xmath349 , @xmath350 , @xmath351 .
define a linear order @xmath352 on @xmath213 by the following rules .
* @xmath353 for all @xmath354 , @xmath355 , @xmath356 . * the order within the index set @xmath357 is defined by @xmath358 if and only if @xmath359 , or @xmath181 and @xmath182 for @xmath360 . *
the order within the index set @xmath361 is the standard one . *
the order within the index set @xmath362 is the opposite to the standard one . that is @xmath358 if and only if @xmath208 , or @xmath209 and @xmath359 for @xmath363 .
it is easy to see that @xmath352 is a normal order , and @xmath364 is the standard order .
see figures [ fi : sln_j1 ] and [ fi : sln_j2 ] for a pictorial description .
fix @xmath365 .
let @xmath194 , where @xmath97 is a highest weight @xmath4module with highest weight @xmath117 and highest weight vector @xmath118 .
fix a weight subspace @xmath125\subset v'$ ] , @xmath366 , where @xmath367 . consider the complex space @xmath200 with coordinates @xmath201 .
[ [ the - pbwbasis - of - ugnm - corresponding - to - succ_h . ] ] * the pbw basis of @xmath53 corresponding to @xmath352 .
* + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + for any positive root @xmath172 , set @xmath368 equal to the number of integers @xmath294 , @xmath369 , such that @xmath370 .
the number @xmath368 counts the @xmath343 subsystems of the order @xmath352 which have @xmath172 as their middle root and which are ordered oppositely to the standard order .
set @xmath371 .
@xmath372 is a basis of @xmath215 called the basis corresponding to @xmath352 .
order the basis according to @xmath352 , @xmath373 if and only if @xmath374 .
the corresponding pbw - basis of @xmath53 is @xmath375 where @xmath376 runs over all sequences of positive integers .
let @xmath377 be elements of the pbw - basis of @xmath53 corresponding to @xmath352 .
set @xmath378 and @xmath379 .
the vector @xmath380 belongs to @xmath125 $ ] if @xmath232 .
[ [ the - rational - function - phizth . ] ] * the rational function @xmath381 .
* + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + for any @xmath232 and any @xmath238 , set @xmath382 where @xmath383 is the set of bijections we fixed in the definition of @xmath384 , see section [ hgsol ] . set @xmath385 notice that @xmath386 .
[ [ example . ] ] * example . * + + + + + + + + + + let @xmath241 , @xmath243 .
the basis @xmath387 of @xmath215 corresponds to @xmath388 . if @xmath389 , then @xmath390 if @xmath391 , then @xmath392 the corresponding expressions for @xmath393 are given in the example in section [ hgsol ] , since @xmath394 is the standard order of positive roots of @xmath10 .
@xmath395 the next theorem is our second main result .
[ mat_trig_j]for any @xmath236 , we have @xmath396 .
the proof of the theorem is in section [ pf.5.2 ] . as a corollary
, we obtain new matsuo s type formulae for solutions of the kz equations .
\(a ) let @xmath264 be the hypergeometric solution of the rational kz equations with parameter @xmath129 in the subspace of singular vectors of @xmath125 $ ] indicated in theorem [ t_mat ] .
then , for every @xmath233 , we have @xmath397 ( b ) let @xmath398 be the hypergeometric solution of the trigonometric kz equation with parameters @xmath399 and @xmath1 taking values in the weight space @xmath132 $ ] of @xmath112 indicated in corollary [ mat_trig ] . for every @xmath233 ,
define a function @xmath400 @xmath401 then @xmath402 .
consider a pbw - basis @xmath403 of @xmath53 .
let @xmath1 be generic , and let @xmath74 be the highest weight verma module with highest weight @xmath3 and highest weight vector @xmath79 .
the shapovalov form induces an isomorphism @xmath404 .
the set @xmath405 is a basis of @xmath74 .
let @xmath406 be the dual basis of @xmath407 .
for every @xmath408 , there exists a unique element @xmath409 such that @xmath410 . by definition
, @xmath411 is a ( rational ) function @xmath412 , where @xmath413 .
[ [ remark . ] ] * remark . * + + + + + + + + + @xmath411 is characterized by the property , @xmath414 .
the map @xmath415 corresponds to an element of @xmath416 .
identify @xmath415 with this element . in terms of the basis @xmath417 we have @xmath418 .
[ [ example.-1 ] ] * example . * + + + + + + + + + + let @xmath291 .
then , @xmath419 is a basis of @xmath53 , and @xmath420 explicit formula for the element @xmath415 for @xmath10 is given in appendix c. let @xmath288 be a tensor product of highest weight @xmath4 modules and @xmath132\subset v$ ] a weight subspace . recall that @xmath421 is the chevalley involution , and @xmath422 is the antipode map .
the next theorem is our third main result .
[ main - add ] for every @xmath423 , and every @xmath147 $ ] , we have @xmath424},v}(\lambda+\rho+\frac12\nu)v = \sum_{i_0\in \mathcal{a}(r)}a(f_{i_0}(r))\tau ( p_{i_0}(f(r),\lambda)v,\ ] ] where @xmath425 is the pbw - basis of @xmath53 corresponding to the order @xmath426 , and @xmath427 .
notice that @xmath428 and @xmath429 , while according to the definition , given in section [ sec2 ] , @xmath430},v}$ ] is a product of elements @xmath431 each of which contains @xmath53 and @xmath52 terms .
see proposition [ btv - pres ] as well . the theorem is proved in section [ pf - main - add ] .
* example . * ( a ) let @xmath291 .
then @xmath432,v}(\lambda)=\b^{\alpha_1}(\lambda)$ ] .
\(b ) let @xmath241
. by definition , we have @xmath432,v}(\lambda)=\b^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}(\lambda)\b^{\alpha_1}(\lambda)$ ] and @xmath433,v}(\lambda)=\b^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}(\lambda)\b^{\alpha_2}(\lambda)$ ] . set @xmath434 , for @xmath435 , and @xmath436 $ ] for any @xmath437 .
then , for any @xmath147 $ ] , we have @xmath438,v}(\lambda+\rho+\frac12\nu)v&= \sum_{s , k=0}^{\infty}\frac{e_{3,1}^ke_{3,2}^s}{k!s ! } ( \sum_{j=0}^k \frac { e_{1,2}^{j}e_{1,3}^{k - j}e_{2,3}^{s+j}\bin{k}{j}}{p_{s+j}(\lambda_2 ) p_k(\lambda_2+\lambda_1 + 1)})v,\notag\\ \b_{\omega[1],v}(\lambda+\rho+\frac12\nu)v&= \sum_{s , k=0}^{\infty}\frac{e_{3,1}^ke_{2,1}^s}{k!s ! } ( \sum_{j=0}^k \frac{(-1)^j e_{2,3}^{j}e_{1,3}^{k - j}e_{1,2}^{s+j}\bin{k}{j}}{p_{s+j}(\lambda_1 ) p_k(\lambda_2+\lambda_1 + 1)})v . \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath439 be the quotient field of the algebra @xmath440 . then @xmath439 is isomorphic to the field of rational functions over @xmath19 , using the identification of the cartan subalgebra @xmath19 with its dual .
define algebras @xmath441 .
consider the space @xmath442 , which is a formal series completion of @xmath443 .
for any basis @xmath444 of @xmath445 , an element of @xmath442 has the form @xmath446 , where @xmath447 .
denote @xmath448 the natural projection @xmath449 .
let @xmath91 be an orthonormal basis of @xmath19 .
[ t - abbr ] for every @xmath1 , there exists a unique solution @xmath450 of the abbr - equation @xmath451= -(\sum_{\alpha\in\sigma_+}e_{-\alpha}\otimes e_\alpha)j(\lambda),\ ] ] such that @xmath450 belongs to @xmath442 and @xmath452 .
moreover , @xmath453 is of weight zero , and has the following expansion @xmath454 where @xmath455 , @xmath456 , @xmath457 , for all k , @xmath458 . for technical reasons a proof of the theorem is given at the end of this section .
the solution @xmath450 is called the universal fusion matrix of @xmath51 .
theorem [ c - add - inter ] and equality ( [ e - p_2,1^k ] ) give a formula for the universal fusion matrix of @xmath144 .
see appendix c for a similar formula in the @xmath10 case .
set @xmath459 , cf .
the element @xmath460 belongs to a formal series completion of @xmath461 .
its action is well defined in a tensor product of highest weight @xmath4 modules .
[ ev - t34 ] let @xmath462 be the longest element in the weyl group @xmath56 .
for any @xmath147 $ ] , we have @xmath463 next ,
we present a connection between the shapovalov form and the universal fusion matrix .
[ prop.13.1 ] we have @xmath464 , where @xmath415 is identified with the corresponding element of @xmath416 . more explicitly , in terms of a basis @xmath417 of @xmath53 ,
we have @xmath465 let @xmath453 be a rational function of @xmath1 with values in @xmath439 .
assume that the @xmath3 dependence in @xmath453 is through a finite number of inner products @xmath466 , @xmath467 , where @xmath468 .
set @xmath469 .
the function @xmath470 is a rational function of @xmath1 with values in @xmath439 .
[ c - add - inter ] let @xmath403 be a homogeneous basis of @xmath53 .
. then @xmath472 is well defined , and @xmath473 notice that , in particular , the theorem says that @xmath472 takes values in @xmath474 for any @xmath1 .
the proof of the theorem is given at the end of this section .
we derive the following corollary from theorems [ ev - t34 ] and [ c - add - inter ] .
[ add_w0 ] let @xmath462 be the longest element in the weyl group @xmath56 .
then , @xmath475 for any homogeneous basis @xmath403 of @xmath53 , and any homogeneous element @xmath147 $ ] . indeed , by theorem [ ev - t34 ]
, we have @xmath476 theorem [ c - add - inter ] gives @xmath477 finally , the equality @xmath478 for any @xmath479 , implies @xmath480 _ proof of theorem [ t - abbr ] .
_ fix @xmath109 .
denote @xmath481 the weight function defined on homogeneous elements in @xmath51 with values in @xmath19 .
fix a basis @xmath444 of @xmath445 , such that @xmath482 and @xmath483 , @xmath484 , are homogeneous elements of @xmath53 and @xmath52 , respectively .
let @xmath485 , where @xmath486 the abbr equation ( [ abbreq ] ) is @xmath487 equality ( [ addb_i1 ] ) presents a system of recurrence relations for @xmath488 .
together with the initial conditions @xmath489 , they uniquely determine @xmath490 for all @xmath491 .
moreover , the solution is such that @xmath492 .
set @xmath493 .
@xmath395 _ proof of theorem [ c - add - inter ] .
_ observe that @xmath494 is a function of @xmath3 with values in @xmath439 , it depends on @xmath3 via the inner products @xmath495 , @xmath496 .
thus , the shifted function @xmath497 is well defined for any @xmath491 , and @xmath472 is well defined .
write a system of recurrence relations for @xmath472 by shifting the system of reccurence relations ( [ addb_i1 ] )
. we have @xmath498 equation ( [ addb_i ] ) implies a system of reccurence relations for the functions @xmath499 .
the initial condition is @xmath500 .
therefore , for the unique solution , each @xmath497 is a complex - valued functions .
the shifted universal fusion matrix @xmath472 takes values in @xmath474 .
next we study @xmath501 which is connected to @xmath502 by theorem [ prop.13.1 ] .
the abbr reccurence relations ( [ addb_i1 ] ) applied to @xmath501 give @xmath503 consider @xmath504 @xmath505 .
its action on the vector @xmath506 defines an element of @xmath416 .
notice that @xmath507 , because @xmath43 restricted to @xmath508 is the identity and @xmath43 restricted to @xmath19 is multiplication by @xmath509 .
since @xmath510 , equality ( [ addb_i0 ] ) implies @xmath511 for any @xmath491 , define a complex - valued function @xmath512 , such that @xmath513 .
therefore , we have @xmath514 . now ( [ abbr_0 ] ) takes the form @xmath515 equality ( [ abbr_01 ] ) together with the isomorphism between @xmath74 and @xmath53 imply a system of recurrence relations for the functions @xmath516 with initial condition @xmath517 .
this systems of recurrence relations coincides with the systems of recurrence relations for @xmath518 .
the initial condition in both cases is the same .
therefore the solutions coincide , i.e. for every @xmath491 , @xmath519 and @xmath520 . in our notation ,
theorem [ prop.13.1 ] together with the linear isomorphism between @xmath74 and @xmath53 give the following explicit formula , @xmath521 .
therefore , @xmath522 , which is the statement of the corollary .
let @xmath524 be a reduced decomposition of an element @xmath525 .
set @xmath526,@xmath527 , for @xmath528 .
[ btv - pres ] @xmath529 .
let @xmath530 be a reduced decomposition of the longest element @xmath531 .
then @xmath532 is a normal order on @xmath213 , and any normal order corresponds to a reduced decomposition of the longest element , see @xcite .
[ b_0pres ] if @xmath533 is a normal order on @xmath213 , then @xmath534 fix @xmath535 .
recall that the element @xmath536}$ ] is defined by @xmath536}=\omega_0\omega_0^r\in \w$ ] , where @xmath63 ( respectively , @xmath537 ) is the longest element in @xmath56 ( respectively , in @xmath538 generated by all simple reflections @xmath66 preserving the dual fundamental weight @xmath539 ) .
the explicit form of @xmath540 implies that @xmath538 is generated by the simple reflections @xmath541 .
denote @xmath542 the subgroup of @xmath56 generated by @xmath543 , and denote @xmath544 the subgroup of @xmath56 generated by @xmath545 .
denote @xmath546 the root system with base @xmath547 , and denote @xmath548 the root system with base @xmath549 .
then @xmath544 is the weyl group of @xmath548 , and @xmath542 is the weyl group of @xmath546 , and @xmath550 .
consider the normal order @xmath426 .
set @xmath551 , @xmath552 , @xmath553 , @xmath554 .
write explicitly the order @xmath426 on @xmath213 , @xmath555 .
we have @xmath556 .
moreover , @xmath557 , @xmath558 is the set of positive roots for @xmath546 , @xmath559 is the set of positive roots for @xmath548 , and @xmath560 .
let @xmath561 be the reduced decomposition of @xmath63 corresponding to @xmath426 .
denote @xmath562 , @xmath563 , @xmath564 .
clearly , @xmath565 , @xmath566}$ ] .
let @xmath567 be the set of positive roots corresponding to the reduced presentation @xmath536}=s_{i_{m}}\cdots s_{i_{1+m_2+m_1}}$ ] .
then @xmath430},v}(\lambda)=\b_v^{\beta^{m_3}}(\lambda)\cdots\b_v^{\beta^1}(\lambda)$ ] .
the definition of the correspondence between normal orders and reduced presentations of @xmath63 implies that @xmath568 @xmath569 as ordered sets .
thus , we have @xmath570 + @xmath571 .
[ inverse_a_h ] the reflection @xmath537 reverses @xmath572 , @xmath573 .
therefore , @xmath574},v}(\lambda)=\b_v^{\alpha^{1+m_1+m_2}}(\lambda)\cdots\b_v^{\alpha^m}(\lambda).\ ] ] the proof is a straightforward computation .
[ add - prod ] @xmath575},v}(\lambda).\ ] ] _ proof .
_ consider the normal order @xmath576 on @xmath213 reverse to @xmath426 .
for any @xmath577 we have @xmath578 if and only if @xmath579 . notice that @xmath580 and the order @xmath576 within each of the sets @xmath572 , @xmath558 , @xmath559 is reverse to @xmath426 .
consider the presentation of @xmath581 corresponding to @xmath576 given in corollary [ b_0pres ] .
apply lemma [ inverse_a_h ] to obtain the statement of the corollary . @xmath395 recall that @xmath425 is the pbw - basis of @xmath53 corresponding to @xmath426 .
[ l - binter ] for any homogeneous vector @xmath147 $ ] , we have @xmath574},v}(\lambda+\rho+\frac12 \nu)v = \sum_{i_0\in \mathcal{a}(r)}a(f_{i_0}(r ) ) q_{i_0}(f(r),\lambda)v,\ ] ] where @xmath582 is a subset of homogeneous elements of @xmath52 . _ proof . _ for every positive root @xmath39 , every @xmath109 and every positive integer @xmath583 , set @xmath584 , and @xmath585 .
use formula ( [ p - oper ] ) to obtain @xmath586 since by definition @xmath587 , see figure [ fi : sln_j2 ] , lemma [ inverse_a_h ] implies @xmath588},v}(\lambda+\rho+\frac12 \nu)v=\sum_{s_{r , r+1}=0}^\infty\ldots \sum_{s_{1,n}=0}^\infty \frac{f_{\alpha_{1,n}}^{s_{1,n}}e_{\alpha_{1,n}}^{k_{1,n}}\ldots f_{\alpha_{r , r+1}}^{s_{r , r+1}}e_{\alpha_{r , r+1}}^{s_{r , r+1 } } } { p_{s_{k_{1,n},\lambda,\alpha_{1,n}}}\ldots p_{s_{r , r+1},\lambda,\alpha_{r , r+1}}}v.\ ] ] next , we need to rearrange the right hand side of formula ( [ b - inter ] ) by moving all elements of type @xmath589 to the left through elements of type @xmath590 , using the commutation relations of @xmath4 . since @xmath591 and @xmath175 , we have @xmath592=e_{\alpha_{k',k } } , \mbox { if } k'<k ; \qquad ( b)\quad[e_{\alpha_{k',l}},f_{\alpha_{k , l}}]= f_{\alpha_{k , k ' } } , \mbox { if } k < k';\notag \\ & ( c)\quad[e_{\alpha_{k , l'}},f_{\alpha_{k , l}}]=-e_{\alpha_{l , l ' } } , \mbox { if } l < l ' ; \qquad ( d)\quad[e_{\alpha_{k , l'}},f_{\alpha_{k , l}}]= - f_{\alpha_{l',l } } , \mbox { if } l'<l;\notag\\ & ( e)\quad [ e_{\alpha_{k , l}},f_{\alpha_{k , l}}]=h_{\alpha_{k , l } } ; \qquad ( f)\quad[e_{\alpha_{k',l'}},f_{\alpha_{k , l}}]=0 , \mbox { if } k\ne k ' \mbox { and } l\ne l'.\notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] the initial ordering of the product of @xmath593 s and @xmath417 s in formula ( [ b - inter ] ) is according to the @xmath426 ordering of @xmath572 , @xmath594 is to the left of @xmath595 if and only if @xmath596 .
see figure [ fi : sln_j2 ] for the definition of @xmath426 on @xmath572 .
the set of indices @xmath597 is characterized by @xmath598 .
we first move all @xmath599 s to the left through all @xmath600 s , then we move all @xmath601 s and so on .
the last step is to move all @xmath602 s to the left through all @xmath593 s resulting from the previous steps .
* after each step we have : + ( * ) all @xmath603 s in the respective rearranged version of formula ( [ b - inter ] ) satisfy @xmath604 ; + ( * * ) if @xmath605 , or @xmath606 then any @xmath607 is to the right of any @xmath603 .
in the initial state represented in formula ( [ b - inter ] ) the claim follows from the definition of the order @xmath426 .
now , assume that the claim is valid after @xmath294 rearranging steps .
assume that we move @xmath603 at the @xmath608-st step .
if the @xmath608-st step is of type @xmath609 or @xmath610 , then we get an additional @xmath611 with @xmath612 or @xmath613 .
@xmath593 s of this type does not affect the claim , so it remains valid .
if the @xmath608-st step is of type @xmath614 or @xmath615 , then we get an additional @xmath616 with @xmath617 .
other @xmath417 s are excluded because of condition ( * * ) . moreover
, a simple check up shows that condition ( * * ) remains valid for the additional summand .
condition ( * * ) shows that the @xmath608-st step can not be of type @xmath618 , and after a step of type @xmath619 the claim is trivially satisfied .
inductive argument shows that the claim is satisfied after each step of the rearrangement . as a final result
we get @xmath620},v}(\lambda+\rho+\frac12 \nu)v=\sum_{s_{r , r+1}=0}^\infty\ldots \sum_{s_{1,n}=0}^\infty ( \prod_{k\leq r <
l } f_{\alpha_{k , l}}^{s_{k , l}})\widetilde{q}_{\{s_{k , l}\ } } ( \lambda)v,\ ] ] where each @xmath621 is a homogeneous element of @xmath52 .
finally , identify the set @xmath622 with the set @xmath623 .
the relation @xmath624 together with equality ( [ b - inter1 ] ) imply the statement of the lemma .
since @xmath625 is the longest element in @xmath626 and @xmath627 is the longest element in @xmath628 we can apply corollary [ add_w0 ] to @xmath629 and @xmath630 .
choose @xmath425 as the weighted pbw - basis of @xmath53 .
then , for every @xmath147 $ ] , we have @xmath631 where @xmath632 , and @xmath633 .
it is easy to see that , for any @xmath634 , @xmath635 , we have @xmath636=0 $ ] . therefore , @xmath637 where @xmath638
. apply corollary [ add_w0 ] to the right hand side of corollary [ add - prod ] , and lemma [ l - binter ] and formula ( [ add_w_0^h ] ) to the left hand side of corollary [ add - prod ] . for any @xmath639
, we obtain @xmath640 set @xmath641 the verma module with highest weight @xmath3 .
weight considerations imply @xmath642 the defining property of @xmath643 gives @xmath644 therefore @xmath645 , and @xmath646 if @xmath647 and @xmath648 .
finally , apply equality ( [ eq - add - prod1 ] ) to @xmath649 , for @xmath650 , and use induction on the partialy ordered set @xmath651 to obtain @xmath652 , for any @xmath653 , and thus @xmath654 . the last equality and lemma [ l - binter ]
imply the statement of theorem [ main - add ]
recall that @xmath365 .
the following construction is very important .
namely , there exists a sequence @xmath336 of elementary transformations @xmath656 which converts the normal order @xmath352 into the normal order @xmath655 .
the sequence is such that , for every pair of positive integers @xmath657 , @xmath658 , the @xmath343 elementary transformation of type @xmath659 is used exactly once in this sequence and all other elementary transformations in the sequence are of type @xmath342 .
the sequence is given as follows .
[ [ the - construction - of - sigma . ] ] * the construction of @xmath336 . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we have @xmath660 , and + @xmath661 , @xmath662 . moreover , @xmath663 where @xmath664 , @xmath665 .
the roots @xmath666 are the largest elements in @xmath361 according to @xmath352 and are the largest elements in @xmath667 according to @xmath655 .
the linear order @xmath352 on the set @xmath666 is the same as the linear order @xmath655 .
the roots @xmath668 are the largest elements in @xmath669 according to @xmath655 .
the linear order @xmath352 on the set @xmath668 is the same as the linear order @xmath655 .
the procedure changing the order @xmath352 into the order @xmath655 consists of two parts described in detail below . in part one
, we move the sequence of roots @xmath664 to the left through the set @xmath357 . in part two
, we move the roots @xmath665 to the right through the set @xmath670 .
the result after part two is the order @xmath655 .
the root @xmath671 is the largest root in @xmath361 .
thus , it immediately succeeds the set of roots @xmath357 with respect to the order @xmath352 . on the other hand ,
it is the highest element of the order @xmath655 .
we need to move @xmath671 through all elements of the set @xmath357
. make @xmath672 elementary transformations of type @xmath342 moving @xmath671 over @xmath673 . then perform @xmath674 @xmath675 .
again , make @xmath672 elementary transformations of type @xmath342 moving @xmath671 over @xmath676 . then perform @xmath677 @xmath678 .
after @xmath679 groups of steps of the above type the root @xmath671 is greater than any root of the set @xmath357 .
now , the root @xmath680 is the largest root in @xmath681 and it immediately succeeds the set @xmath357 in the normal order resulting after the above @xmath679 groups of steps . repeat the procedure for the root @xmath680 , and then for the roots @xmath682 .
this is the end of part one .
the resulting order after part one is shown in figure [ fi : part1 ] .
in part one we used exactly one @xmath343 elementary transformation of type @xmath659 for every pair of positive integers @xmath657 , @xmath658 .
all other elementary transformations in part one were of the type @xmath342 .
we need to move the roots @xmath683 from @xmath357 through @xmath670 to put them in front of @xmath362 , see figure [ fi : part1 ] .
we first move @xmath684 , then @xmath685 and so on .
it is easy to see that all elementary transformations we use in this part are of type @xmath342 .
consider again the sequence of elementary transformations @xmath687 .
denote @xmath688 the normal order we obtain from @xmath352 after applying @xmath689 .
set @xmath690 .
we have @xmath691 . from the construction of the sequence
@xmath336 it follows that @xmath343 elementary transformations in @xmath336 are labeled by pairs @xmath657 , @xmath658 .
namely , a pair @xmath657 labels the transformation @xmath692 for @xmath693 ,
let @xmath694 be the set of pairs @xmath657 which label @xmath343 transformations in @xmath695 . for every pair of integers @xmath657 , @xmath177 , set @xmath696 for @xmath697 , and @xmath698 for @xmath699 .
the set @xmath700 is a basis of @xmath215 .
order it according to @xmath701 .
the corresponding pbw - basis of @xmath53 is @xmath702 let @xmath703 be elements of the pbw - basis of @xmath53 corresponding to @xmath701 . set @xmath378 and @xmath704 .
the vector @xmath705 belongs to @xmath125 $ ] if @xmath232 introduce the rational function @xmath706 as @xmath707 for any pair of integers @xmath709 , @xmath710 , let the string of type @xmath709 corresponding to @xmath352 be the oriented graph with @xmath711 vertices labeled by positive integers @xmath712 given in figure [ fi : string_j ] , cases ( a ) , ( c ) , ( e ) . for any @xmath713 ,
let the string of type @xmath709 corresponding to @xmath352 grounded at @xmath714 be the oriented tree with labeled vertices given in figure [ fi : string_j ] , cases ( b ) , ( d ) , ( f ) .
let @xmath376 be a set of non - negative integers .
define the tree @xmath715 as the union of strings corresponding to @xmath352 grounded at @xmath714 , such that the string of type @xmath709 grounded at @xmath714 enters exactly @xmath716 times and all vertices @xmath714 of all strings are then identified , see figure [ fi : tree_j ] .
define the tree @xmath717 as follows . for every @xmath697 take @xmath716 strings of type @xmath709 corresponding to @xmath655 and grounded at @xmath718 . for every @xmath699 take @xmath716 strings of type @xmath709 corresponding to @xmath686 and grounded at @xmath718 .
let @xmath717 be the union of all selected strings with all vertices @xmath718 then identified . for any @xmath719 ,
let the forest @xmath720 be the disjoint union of trees , and let the forest @xmath721 be the disjoint union of trees .
for any @xmath722 , the number of vertices in the forest @xmath723 labeled by @xmath294 equals @xmath724 . for every @xmath294 fix a bijection @xmath725 @xmath726the vertices of @xmath723 labeled by @xmath727 @xmath728 . to every oriented edge @xmath729 from a vertex @xmath730 labeled by an integer @xmath731 to a vertex @xmath732 labeled by an integer
@xmath733 assign the function @xmath734 . to every oriented edge @xmath729 from vertex @xmath730 labeled by an integer @xmath731 to a vertex @xmath732 labeled by a complex number
@xmath714 assign the function @xmath735 .
define rational functions corresponding to a forest ( respectively , a tree , a grounded string , or a string ) as the product of the functions @xmath736 over all edges @xmath729 of the forest ( respectively , the tree , the grounded string , or the string ) .
it is clear that the rational function corresponding to the forest @xmath723 is exactly the function @xmath708 defined in section [ spec_ord ] .
define a rational function corresponding to the forest @xmath737 analogously .
the rational function corresponding to the forest @xmath737 equals @xmath738 .
let @xmath739 .
since @xmath690 , @xmath691 , we have given two different definitions of the basis of @xmath215 corresponding to @xmath740 , the rational function @xmath741 , and the forest @xmath742 , see sections [ hgsol_h ] , [ hgsol_p ] , [ hggeom ] .
we will show that these two definitions are consistent .
in the case @xmath743 , we have @xmath744 .
trivially , @xmath745 , @xmath746 , and @xmath747 for @xmath177 . in the case @xmath743 , we have @xmath748 .
we start with the basis of @xmath215 .
recall that @xmath749 , for any @xmath750 .
the following five cases exhaust all possibilities .
+ @xmath751 if @xmath752 , then @xmath753 by definition .
+ @xmath751 if @xmath754 , then @xmath755 , and @xmath756 .
thus , @xmath757 and @xmath753 .
+ @xmath751 if @xmath758 , then @xmath755 , @xmath759 , and @xmath760 .
thus , @xmath757 and @xmath753 .
+ @xmath751 if @xmath761 , then @xmath755 , @xmath762 .
thus , @xmath757 and @xmath753 .
+ @xmath751 if @xmath763 , then @xmath755 , @xmath764 , and @xmath765 .
thus , @xmath757 and @xmath753 .
+ similarly , for every set of non - negative integers @xmath376 , we compare the tree @xmath766 with the tree @xmath767 . in order to construct the tree
@xmath767 , for every pair @xmath709 , @xmath177 , we took @xmath716 strings of type @xmath709 grounded at @xmath718 which correspond to the order @xmath655 and then we identified all vertices @xmath718 . in the construction of the tree @xmath766 , for every pair @xmath709 , @xmath752 , we took @xmath716 strings of type @xmath709 grounded at @xmath718 which correspond to the order @xmath655 , and for every pair @xmath709 , @xmath768 or @xmath769 , we took @xmath716 strings of type @xmath709 grounded at @xmath718 which correspond to the order @xmath686 .
then we identified all vertices @xmath718 .
for every pair @xmath709 , @xmath768 or @xmath769 , the string of type @xmath709 grounded at @xmath718 which corresponds to the order @xmath655 coincides with the string of type @xmath709 grounded at @xmath718 which corresponds to the order @xmath686 , see figure [ fi : string_j ] .
therefore , the tree @xmath766 coincides with the tree @xmath767 . conclude that the forest @xmath770 coincides with the forest @xmath771 , and we have @xmath772 .
the theorem states that , for any @xmath236 , we have @xmath396 .
the equality @xmath773 is valid by definition .
it suffices to show that @xmath774 for every @xmath236 .
first consider the case @xmath243 . recall that @xmath100 is the number of tensor factors in @xmath101 .
thus , @xmath775 is a verma module .
the discussion in section [ consistency ] implies that @xmath776 in order to finish the case @xmath243 , it suffice to show that @xmath777 fix @xmath778 .
[ [ section ] ] assume that @xmath779 is of type @xmath342 .
we have @xmath780 and @xmath781 for every index @xmath782 .
the case @xmath342 of lemma [ elem_trans ] implies @xmath783 for every index @xmath782 .
this implies ( [ statementb ] ) .
[ [ section-1 ] ] assume that @xmath779 is of type @xmath343 and is labeled by a pair of integers @xmath657 , @xmath752 .
the set @xmath784 equals the set @xmath785 .
let us check , that we can apply the @xmath343 case of lemma [ elem_trans ] to the triple @xmath786 .
set @xmath787 , @xmath788 .
then @xmath789 , @xmath790 , @xmath791&=(-1)^{l - h-1}[e_{l , h},e_{h , k}]= ( -1)^{l - h-1}e_{l , k}=f_{k , l}(h)=f_{k , l}(\succ^p),\notag\\ [ f_\beta , f_\alpha]&=(-1)^{l-(h-1)-1}e_{l , k}= f_{k , l}(h-1)=f_{k , l}(\succ^{p+1 } ) . \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we used the explicit form of the numbers @xmath792 , namely , @xmath793 by lemma [ elem_trans ] , we have @xmath794 use this equality to transform @xmath795 .
set @xmath796 , @xmath797 , @xmath798 , @xmath799 , @xmath800 .
we have @xmath801 and @xmath802 @xmath803 where @xmath804 .
the following claim implies ( [ statementb ] )
. + + * claim . * for every @xmath805 we have @xmath806 [ [ section-2 ] ] the right hand side of ( [ claim ] ) equals the product of the functions @xmath736 over all oriented edges @xmath729 of the tree @xmath807
. the left hand side of ( [ claim ] ) depends on rational functions @xmath808 which correspond to trees @xmath809 . for every @xmath810 , the tree @xmath807 and the tree @xmath811 differ only at the grounded strings of types @xmath812 .
namely , the tree @xmath807 has @xmath813 strings of type @xmath814 grounded at @xmath718 corresponding to @xmath352 , @xmath815 strings of type @xmath816 grounded at @xmath718 corresponding to @xmath352 and @xmath817 strings of type @xmath657 grounded at @xmath718 corresponding to @xmath655 .
the tree @xmath818 has @xmath819 strings of type @xmath814 grounded at @xmath718 corresponding to @xmath352 , @xmath820 strings of type @xmath816 grounded at @xmath718 corresponding to @xmath352 and @xmath821 strings of type @xmath657 grounded at @xmath718 corresponding to @xmath352 .
the claim now follows from identities @xmath822 identity ( [ trng ] ) has a simple tree interpretation shown in figure [ fi : trngl ] .
+ identity ( [ tr_pow ] ) has a tree interpretation shown in figure [ fi : j-1_to_j ] . in figure [ fi : j-1_to_j ]
multiplication of trees means disjoint union of trees , addition is formal , and multiplication distributes through addition , see the example in figure [ fi : ex ] .
the claim is proved .
thus , the statement of theorem [ mat_trig_j ] is proved for @xmath243 .
the statement of theorem [ mat_trig_j ] for arbitrary @xmath111 is proved as the case @xmath243 since we execute the changes of bases and the reorganization of rational functions separately for each tensor factor .
there is no interference between the rational functions corresponding to different tensor factors since the grounding points of the strings are distinct .
let @xmath823 , where @xmath824 is the @xmath4 verma module with highest weight @xmath117 and highest weight vector @xmath118 . set @xmath825 .
fix a weight subspace @xmath132\subset v$ ] , where @xmath826 , and @xmath827 .
recall the notation @xmath828 , @xmath198 .
set @xmath829 .
let @xmath830 be the @xmath4 verma module with highest weight @xmath831 and highest weight vector @xmath832 .
consider the auxiliary space @xmath833 and its weight space @xmath125 $ ] , where @xmath834 . .
for every @xmath232 fix a set of bijections @xmath835 and define a vector space of rational functions @xmath836 .
these functions depend on the complex variables @xmath837 , @xmath186 , @xmath838 , @xmath116 .
denote @xmath839 the restriction @xmath840 .
we will use the same notation @xmath841 for a function in @xmath839 . for every @xmath842 fix a set of bijections @xmath835 and
define a vector space of rational functions @xmath843 .
these functions depend on the complex variables @xmath837 , @xmath186 , @xmath838 , @xmath844 .
identify each index @xmath842 with the index @xmath845 .
since @xmath846 for an appropriate choice of bijections @xmath847 , @xmath835 we will consider @xmath93 as a subset of @xmath839 . consider the set of rational functions with poles in @xmath276 , see section [ hgsol ] . note that it contains @xmath839 .
define an equivalence relation @xmath848 on the set .
namely , let @xmath849 be two elements of the set
. we write @xmath850 if @xmath851 for any horizontal family of integration cycles @xmath272 , which satisfies matsuo s assumption . [ [ examples . ] ] * examples . * + + + + + + + + + + + \(a ) for a fixed @xmath232 , the functions @xmath841 corresponding to different choices of bijections @xmath835 are equivalent under @xmath848 . +
( b ) if there exists a rational form @xmath852 with poles in @xmath276 such that @xmath853 , where @xmath854 denotes the exterior differentiation with respect to the variables @xmath855 , then @xmath850 because @xmath272 is a family of closed cycles .
the set @xmath856 is a basis of @xmath857)^*$ ] , see the definition of @xmath858 in section [ hgsol ] . define a linear map @xmath859)^*\rightarrow \omega'$ ] by setting @xmath860 , for all @xmath232 .
analogously , define a linear map @xmath861)^*\rightarrow \omega$ ] by setting @xmath862 , for all @xmath842 . for indices @xmath842 and @xmath845 we have @xmath863 reformulate theorem [ mat_trig_j ] as follows .
[ mat_trig_j1]for every @xmath233 , we have @xmath864 . moreover , for all @xmath229 , @xmath865 . for every set of non - negative integers @xmath376 , and
every @xmath867 , @xmath868 , denote @xmath869 , where @xmath870 and @xmath871 if @xmath872 .
let @xmath225 , where @xmath873 is a set of non - negative integers .
let @xmath874 denote addition in the component @xmath875 .
[ e - act ] for every @xmath229 , and every @xmath233 , we have @xmath876 the proof is a straightforward computation .
we use the standard pbw - basis of @xmath53 .
[ f - act ] for every @xmath229 , and every @xmath877 , @xmath878 , we have @xmath879 the proof is a straightforward computation .
we use the pbw - basis of @xmath53 corresponding to @xmath352 .
next , we will compute the image of @xmath880 $ ] under @xmath881 . according to lemma [ e - act ] @xmath882 is a sum of rational functions with complex coefficients , @xmath883 . for each index @xmath884
, we can choose a set of bijections @xmath885 such that the function @xmath886 has the form @xmath887 , where @xmath888 is a new variable of type @xmath236 , and @xmath889 is any of the @xmath890 variables fixed by the set of bijections @xmath835 , or a complex number in the set @xmath891 .
[ mat - l.3.4 ] let @xmath238 .
then , we have @xmath892 @xmath893 @xmath614 @xmath894 .
_ ( a ) our choice of @xmath831 is consistent with the definition of the function @xmath895 , that is @xmath896 is the contribution of the point @xmath897 in @xmath895 . observe that @xmath898 and apply lemma [ mat - l.3.4 ] .
\(b ) part ( a ) and lemma [ e - act ] imply statement ( b )
. @xmath395 [ switch - cor ] for any @xmath899 and any @xmath900 , such that @xmath901 $ ] , we have @xmath902 , where @xmath48 is the antipode map . _ proof .
_ it is sufficient to show that for any @xmath233 , we have @xmath903 .
equivalently , we may show @xmath904 .
introduce the logarithmic @xmath905-form @xmath906 we have @xmath907 , and @xmath908 let @xmath909 be the inclusion map @xmath910 , and as usual , @xmath911 denotes the standard volume form on @xmath258 .
we have @xmath912 .
thus , @xmath904 .
@xmath395 let @xmath398 be the hypergeometric solution of the trigonometric kz equation indicated in corollary [ mat_trig ] .
fix @xmath365 . by definition , @xmath913 the function @xmath914
changes as follows .
@xmath915 we study the product @xmath916\phi(z , t)$ ] , using the expansion + @xmath917 obtained in theorem [ mat_trig_j ] .
the identity @xmath918 implies the tree interpretation shown in figure [ fi : tree_0_j ] .
set @xmath919 to be equal to the number of elements of the set @xmath920 . for all @xmath229
, we have @xmath921 . use the equality of rational functions presented in figure [ fi : tree_0_j ] and the definition @xmath922 to obtain @xmath923 therefore , we have @xmath924 we see that the shift of the parameter @xmath3 reduces to the following operation on rational functions .
take each function @xmath708 in the formula for @xmath269 , @xmath925 , @xmath926 , and substitute it with the rational function @xmath927 , which depends on variables @xmath928 , @xmath926 .
then set @xmath897 .
the result is a function that depends on the initial set of variables , @xmath925 , @xmath926 .
[ l - rat2d ] for every @xmath842 we have @xmath929 _ proof .
_ we will compare additive presentations of the two sides of the equality .
the left hand side , after expansion of the products , has the following tree interpretation .
it is the rational function corresponding to a formal sum of forests .
an element of this formal sum is a new forest produced from @xmath723 as follows .
we add one tree , consisting only of strings of type @xmath709 , @xmath930 , corresponding to @xmath352 and grounded at zero . for each string of type @xmath709 belonging to the new tree
, one string of type @xmath709 is removed from one of the trees which belong to the original forest @xmath723 .
the coefficient assigned to the new forest is a combinatorial coefficient times a sign coefficient , namely minus one to the power equal to the number of strings which comprise the additional tree .
recall the definition of the index set @xmath931 .
thus , the additional tree is always of the form @xmath932 for some @xmath933 . in this notation
the sign coefficient in the above description is @xmath934 .
let us give an explicit formula for the combinatorial coefficient .
consider @xmath933 , @xmath935 , where @xmath873 is a set of non - negative integers . in order to remove @xmath936 strings of type @xmath709 from the forest @xmath723 , we should choose numbers @xmath937 , where @xmath938 and @xmath939 .
then , for each @xmath844 , we remove @xmath937 strings of type @xmath709 from the tree @xmath940 . the combinatorial coefficient of this choice is @xmath941
therefore , the left hand side equals @xmath942 next , we consider the right hand side . repeated application of lemma [ f - act ] gives @xmath943 therefore @xmath944 finally , formula ( [ f - lhs ] ) , equality ( [ eq - rhs ] ) , and the definition of the map @xmath881 imply the statement of the lemma .
@xmath395 [ l - d2d ] for every @xmath842 , and every @xmath945
, we have @xmath946 _ proof . _ part ( a ) .
@xmath947 we use the property @xmath948 to write the first equality , corollary [ switch - cor ] to write the second equivalence , and the identification ( [ d=d ] ) for the last step . part ( b )
is trivial .
we write @xmath949 in terms of the dual basis @xmath950 of @xmath132^*$ ] , then use the linear property of the map @xmath951 and the definition of @xmath4-action on the dual space .
@xmath952 finally , we combine all the steps in the following computation .
@xmath953\phi(z , t)= \notag\\ & = \prod_{j=1}^n z_j^{(\omega_h^\vee)^{(j)}}\hspace{-10pt}\sum_{i\in p(\bm , n ) } ( \prod_{(j , k , l ,
q)\in s_h(i)}\hspace{-15pt}(\phi^{(j , k , l , q)}_h-\phi^{(n+1,k , l , q)}_h ) \hspace{-15pt}\prod_{(j , k , l , q)\not\in s_h(i)}\hspace{-15pt}\phi^{(j , k , l , q)}_h)f_iv \notag\\ & = \prod_{j=1}^nz_j^{(\omega_h^\vee)^{(j)}}\hspace{-10pt } \sum_{i\in p(\bm , n)}\sum_{i_0\in \mathcal{a}(h ) } d'(f_{i_0}(h)(f_i(h)v)^*\otimes ( f_{i_0}(h)v_{n+1})^*)f_iv\notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath954}(\lambda_{n+1}+\rho+\frac12 \nu)(f_j(h)v)).\notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have applied equality ( [ z - factor ] ) , lemma [ l - rat2d ] , lemma [ l - d2d ] , contraction of the summation by @xmath229 , and theorem [ main - add ] consequtively .
lemma [ mat_trig_j1 ] asserts that @xmath955 . since @xmath956 and @xmath957}(\lambda)$ ] we have @xmath958\phi(z , t ) \,\backsim\ , k_h(z,\lambda)\phi(z , t),\ ] ] which is equivalent to the statement of the theorem for a hypergeometric solution @xmath398 with values in a tensor product of verma modules .
the statement of the theorem for a hypergeometric solution with values in a tensor product of any highest weight @xmath4-modules follows from the functorial properties of the operator @xmath959.@xmath395
a construction in @xcite gives hypergeometric solutions of the rational kz equations in a tensor product of lowest weight @xmath4 modules .
we modify that procedure to a construction of solutions of the rational kz equations in a tensor product of highest weight @xmath4 modules , cf .
@xcite .
adopt the notation from section [ hgsol ] .
we have defined a function @xmath211 , integration cycles @xmath247 and rational functions @xmath960 .
order the basis @xmath961 of the lie subalgebra @xmath962 by @xmath963 if and only if @xmath964 . the corresponding pbw - basis of
@xmath52 is @xmath965 the index @xmath966 runs over all sequences of non - negative integers .
let @xmath967 , where @xmath968 is a lowest weight @xmath4 module of lowest weights @xmath969 with lowest weight vector @xmath970 .
fix a weight subspace @xmath971\subset w'$ ] , where @xmath972 as in section [ hgsol ] . to every @xmath232 , associate a vector @xmath973 .
[ t_mat_l ] the function @xmath974 takes values in the subspace of singular vectors of @xmath971 $ ] and satisfies the rational kz equations with parameter @xmath129 .
+ [ [ from - lowest - weight - modules - to - highest - weight - modules . ] ] * from lowest weight modules to highest weight modules . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + recall that @xmath43 denotes the chevalley involution .
we have @xmath975 for any @xmath976 .
let @xmath1 , and let @xmath977 be the highest weight verma module of highest weight @xmath3 with highest weight vector @xmath79 , and let @xmath978 be the associated lowest weight verma module of lowest weight @xmath979 with lowest weight vector @xmath980 .
the following proposition is well known .
[ -to+ ] the chevalley involution defines an isomorphism of verma modules @xmath981 for generic @xmath1 .
namely , for all @xmath899 we have @xmath982 .
this isomorphism induces an isomorphism from any lowest weight @xmath4 module to the corresponding highest weight @xmath4 module .
assume that @xmath983 are generic .
let @xmath194 , where @xmath97 is a highest weight module with highest weight @xmath117 and highest weight vector @xmath118 , corresponding to @xmath968 under the isomorphism of proposition [ -to+ ] .
notice that @xmath984 for every set of positive integers @xmath985 .
thus , @xmath986 .
theorem [ t_mat_l ] and proposition [ -to+ ] imply the following corollary .
[ cor_mat ] the function @xmath987 takes values in the subspace of all singular vectors of @xmath125 $ ] and satisfies the rational kz equations with parameter @xmath129 .
recall the statement of proposition [ kz2tkz ] . + _ fix a weight subspace
@xmath125\subset v'$ ] , @xmath126 , where @xmath127 .
let @xmath128 be a solution of the rational kz equations with parameter @xmath129 taking values in the subspace of @xmath125 $ ] consisting of all singular vectors .
set @xmath130 .
_ then @xmath131 is a solution of the trigonometric kz equations with values in the weight subspace @xmath132\subset v$ ] with parameter @xmath133 and the same parameter @xmath129 .
_ set @xmath988 .
the function @xmath989 satisfies the system of equations @xmath990 , @xmath991 .
rewrite this equations separating the input of the @xmath992 point in the sum : @xmath993 multiply equation ( [ eq1 ] ) by @xmath994 and rearrange it using @xmath995 to obtain @xmath996 set @xmath997 . for all @xmath137 , @xmath991 , we have @xmath998 . @xmath999 .
this implies @xmath1000 now we claim that @xmath1001 first write @xmath1002 the coupling @xmath1003 allows us to compute the first summand explicitly @xmath1004 obviously @xmath1005 . since @xmath989 is a singular vector we have @xmath1006 .
equivalently , @xmath1007 .
therefore @xmath1008 since @xmath1009 $ ] we have @xmath1010 let @xmath1011 be the casimir element .
since @xmath1012 we have @xmath1013 we have @xmath1014 .
rewrite ( [ eqn9 ] ) as @xmath1015 combine ( [ eqn10 ] ) , ( [ eqn8 ] ) and ( [ eqn7.5 ] ) to obtain claim ( [ eqn7 ] ) .
equation ( [ eqn6 ] ) for @xmath1016 becomes @xmath1017 finally , @xmath1018 , and equation ( [ eqn12 ] ) implies the proposition .
let @xmath74 be the @xmath10 verma module with highest weight @xmath1 and highest weight vector @xmath79 .
let @xmath112 be a tensor product of highest weight @xmath10-modules .
formulae for the dynamical operators @xmath432,v}(\lambda)=\b^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}(\lambda)\b^{\alpha_1}(\lambda)$ ] and @xmath433,v}(\lambda)=\b^{\alpha_1+\alpha_2}(\lambda)\b^{\alpha_2}(\lambda)$ ] are given in section [ add_sect ] .
let @xmath63 be the longest element of the weyl group .
it has two reduced presentations , @xmath1019 , which imply two presentations for the operator @xmath1020 , + @xmath1021 .
for any @xmath147 $ ] , direct computation gives finaly , given @xmath639 , there is a unique singular vector , @xmath1029 , in @xmath1030 of the form @xmath1031 . in @xcite
the vector @xmath1029 is given in terms of the inverse of the shapovalov form .
as a corollary we get @xmath1032 arnaudon d. , buffenoir e. , ragoucy e. , roche ph . :
universal solutons of quantum dynamical yang - baxter equations , lett .
phys . * 44 * no . 3 , 201 - 214 ( 1998 ) .
asherova , r.s . ,
smirnov , yu .
f. , tolstoy , v.n . :
description of a certain class of projection operators for semi - simple complex lie algebras , matem .
zametki * 26 * , no . 1 , 15 - 25 ( 1979 ) .
cherednik , i. : integral solutions of trigonometric knizhnik - zamolodchikov equations and kac - moody algebras , publ .
rims * 27 * , 727 - 744 , ( 1991 ) .
christie , p. , flume , r. : the four - point correlations of all primary operators of the @xmath1033 conformally invariant @xmath1034 @xmath1035-model with wess - zumino term , nucl
b * 282 * , 466 - 494 , ( 1987 ) .
dotsenko , v. , fateev , v. : conformal algebra and multipoint correlation functions in 2 d statistical models , nucl .
n * 240 * , 312 - 348 , ( 1984 ) .
etingof p.i .
, frenkel i.b . , kirillov , jr .
: lectures on representation theory and kniznik - zamolodchikov equations , math . surveys and monographs , vol . *
58 * , ams , 1998 .
etingof , p. , schiffmann , o. : lectures on the dynamical yang - baxter equations , preprint , math.qa/9908064 etingof , p. , styrkas , k. : algebraic integrability of schrdinger operators and representations of lie algebras , compositio math . *
98 * , no .
1 , 91112 , ( 1995 ) .
etingof , p. , varchenko , a. : dynamical weyl groups and applications , preprint , math.qa/0011001 felder , g. , markov , y. , tarasov , v. , varchenko , a. : differential equations compatible with kz equations , math .
* 3 * , no . 2 , 139 - 177 , ( 2000 ) .
matsuo , a. : an application of aomoto - gelfand hypergeometric functions to the @xmath1036 kniznik - zamolodchikov equation , commun .
phys . * 134 * , 65 - 77 ( 1990 ) .
mehta , m. : random matrices , academic press , inc . ,
boston , ma , ( 1991 ) .
schechtman , v. , varchenko , a. : arrangements of hyperplanes and lie algebra homology , inv . math . * 106 * , 139 - 194 ( 1991 ) .
toledano laredo , v. : a kohno - drinfeld theorem for quantum weyl group , math.qa/0009181 .
tarasov , v. , varchenko , a. : difference equations compatible with trigonometric kz differential equations , internat .
notices * 2000 * , no .
15 , 801829 .
varchenko , a. : multidimensional hypergeometric functions and representation theory of lie algebras and quantum groups , adv . ser .
* 21 * , world scientific , 1995 .
zhelobenko , d.p . :
extremal cocycles on the weyl group , func .
* 21 * , no . 3 , 11 - 21 , ( 1987 ) | the trigonometric kz equations associated to a lie algebra @xmath0 depend on a parameter @xmath1 where @xmath2 is a cartan subalgebra .
a system of dynamical difference equations with respect to @xmath3 compatible with the kz equations is introduced in @xcite .
we prove that the standard hypergeometric solutions of the trigonometric kz equations associated to @xmath4 also satisfy the dynamical difference equations . _
@xmath5 department of mathematics , university of north carolina , chapel hill , + nc 27599 3250 , usa + \{yavmar , anv } @ email.unc.edu_ + * mathematics subject classification : * primary : 35q40 ; secondary 17b10 + * key words : * hypergeometric solutions , dynamical equations , kz equations |
this material is based in part upon work supported by the national science foundation under grant numbers phy-1067973 , phy-1011156 , and the air force office of scientific research grant number fa9550 - 08 - 1 - 0069 .
thanks the alexander von humboldt foundation and the heidelberg center for quantum dynamics for additional support .
kawaguchi , y. & ueda , m. _ phys .
a _ * 84 , * 053616 ( 2011 ) .
leanhardt , a. e. , shin , y. , kielpinski , d. , pritchard , d. e. & ketterle , w. _ phys .
lett . _ * 90 , * 140403 ( 2003 ) .
kawaguchi , y. , nitta , m. & ueda , m. _ phys .
lett . _ * 100 , * 180403 ( 2008 ) .
ji , a .- c . , liu , w. m. , song , j. l. & zhou , f. _ phys .
lett . _ * 101 , * 010402 ( 2008 )
. haddad , l. h. & carr , l. d. _ physica d _ * 238 , * 1413 ( 2009 ) .
haddad , l. h. & carr , l. d. _ europhysics letters _ * 94 , * 56002 ( 2011 ) .
geim , a. k. & novoselov , k. s. _ nat .
mater . _ * 6 , * 183 ( 2007 ) .
wallace , p. r. _ phys .
rev . _ * 71 , * 622 ( 1947 ) .
zhu , s .- l .
, wang , b. & duan , l .- m .
_ * 98 , * 260402 ( 2007 ) .
wu , c. & sarma , s. d. _ phys .
b _ * 77 , * 235107 ( 2008 ) .
tarruell , l. , greif , d. , uehlinger , t. , jotzu , g. & esslinger , t. _ nature _ * 483 , * 302 ( 2012 ) .
asano , k. & hotta , c. _ phys .
b _ * 83 , * 245125 ( 2011 ) . ablowitz , m. j. , nixon , s. d. & zhu , y. _ phys . rev . a _ * 79 , * 053830 ( 2009 ) .
peleg , o. _ et al .
* 98 , * 103901(2007 ) . torrent , d. & sanchez - dehesa , j. _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 108 , * 174301 ( 2012 ) .
nielsen , h. b. & olesen , p. _ nuc .
b _ * 61 , * 45 ( 1973 ) .
seiberg , n. & witten , e. _ nuc .
b _ * 426 , * 19 ( 1994 ) . carr , l. d. , clark , c. w. & reinhardt , w. p. _ phys . rev . a _ * 62 , * 063610 ( 2000 ) .
lee , k. l. , grmaud , b. , han , r. , englert , b - g . & miniatura , c. _ phys .
a _ * 80 , * 043411 ( 2009 ) .
soltan - panahi , p. _ et al .
. phys . _ * 7 , * 434 ( 2011 ) .
grynberg , g. , lounis , b. , verkerk , p. , courtois , j. & salomon , c. _ phys .
lett . _ * 70 , * 2249 ( 1993 ) .
ernst , p. t. _ et al .
. phys . _ * 6 , * 56 ( 2010 ) .
raada , a. f. , raada , m. f. , soler , m. & vzquez , l. _ phys .
d _ * 10 , * 517 ( 1974 ) .
lee , s. y. , kuo , t. k. & gavrielides , a. _ phys .
* 12 , * 2249 ( 1975 ) .
andersen , m. f. _ et al .
lett . _ * 97 , * 170406 ( 2006 ) .
leach , j. , yao , e. & padgett , m. j. _ new j. phys . _ * 6 , * 71 ( 2004 ) .
basistiy , i. v. , pasko , v. a. , slyusar , v. v. , soskin , m. s. & vasnetsov , m. v. _ j. opt . a _ * 6 , * 166 ( 2004 ) .
feder , d. l. , svidzinsky , a. a. , fetter , a. l. & clark , c. w. _ phys .
a _ * 62 , * 053606 ( 2000 ) .
trotzky , s. _ et al .
. phys . _ * 6 , * 998 ( 2010 )
. carr , l. d. & clark , c. w. _ phys .
a _ * 74 , * 043613 ( 2006 ) .
[ cols="^,^,^,<",options="header " , ] _ nlde solutions _ the nlde treats the entire dirac four - spinor . in its simplest realization without mass gaps and in tight binding the upper two components , called a _ weyl spinor _ , are decoupled from the lower two , and can be written @xmath82 .
we obtain vortex solutions by expressing the spinor components in the form : @xmath83 , @xmath84 , and writing the nlde in plane - polar coordinates : @xmath85 where @xmath77 is the integer phase winding and the other parameters are defined in table 1 of the main article . for the case @xmath86 , eqs .
( [ eqn : condpsi7])-([eqn : condpsi8 ] ) give closed form expressions for the radial amplitudes @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
these are the ring - vortex / soliton ( @xmath73 ) and general ring - vortex ( @xmath89 ) solutions . for the case @xmath90 , closed form solutions exist in some cases while others are obtained using a numerical shooting method .
solutions of the nlde are listed in table [ table2 ] .
_ experimental realization of vortices _ relativistic vortices can be excited by starting with all the atoms in the a - sublattice at the dirac point , then applying co - propagating gaussian and laguerre - gaussian laser beams , where the laguerre - gaussian beam carries a single unit of orbital angular momentum .
the transfer of angular momentum to the atoms occurs via the stimulated raman transition @xcite .
the spatial variation of the beam results in mainly the b - sublattice being populated ( the vortex ) throughout most of the 2d lattice , except within a small disk which becomes the core of the vortex .
on the other hand , the a - sublattice is left depleted everywhere ( the soliton ) except near the core of the vortex .
this describes excitation of the vortex / soliton or anderson - toulouse skyrmion @xcite .
the mermin - ho vortex can be obtained by the same process , but by only partially transferring atoms to the b - sublattice .
the sublattice amplitudes far from the vortex core are tuned to satisfy @xmath91 , where @xmath53 is the density of the bec in the first ( second ) four - spinor component in the nlde , and @xmath92 is the associated relativistic fluid velocity , with @xmath93 the phase .
the half - quantum vortex or semion can be excited by using a fractional optical vortex beam in order to provide the required angular phase jump @xcite .
general topological vortices have phase winding @xmath89 , non - zero chemical potential @xmath94 , and satisfy @xmath95 far from the center of the trap .
these can be created by first rotating the lattice to excite the desired @xmath96 state in the a - sublattice , then following up with the laguerre - gaussian transition to produce the correct @xmath77 versus @xmath96 winding differential in the spinor components .
we note that there is an alternative approach to the rotating lattice method .
general topological vortex excitations may be induced by subsequent applications of a two - photon transition with co - propagating laguerre - gaussian / gaussian beams which transfer the condensate between @xmath97 states ( i.e. from @xmath98 to @xmath99 or vice versa ) .
each two - photon transition changes the orbital angular momentum of both the a and b - sublattices by the orbital angular momentum carried by the laguerre - gaussian beams , while maintaining the desired winding differential between the a and b - sublattices .
finally , ring - vortices , characterized by @xmath100 and @xmath101 far from the center of the trap , can be obtained from the other vortices by inducing depletion of the bec from the outer edge of the trap towards the core .
more details regarding solutions of the nlde may be found in ref .
@xcite . _ rlse solutions _ the rlse form a relativistic generalization of the bogoliubov - de gennes equations analogous to the relationship between the nlde and nonlinear schrdinger equation .
thus , in the rlse the quasi - particle amplitudes @xmath102 and @xmath103 are each vector in form , to match the four - spinor ( two - spinor at one dirac point ) they perturb from .
the rlse can be expressed in @xmath104 matrix - vector form : @xmath105 where @xmath106 and @xmath107 are @xmath104 matrices which contain the first - order derivatives @xmath108 and the background bec components @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath109 is the @xmath104 eigenvalue matrix .
note that @xmath110 is the particle interaction .
when broken down , eqs .
( [ eqn : rlse5])-([eqn : rlse6 ] ) form a @xmath111 eigenvalue problem in the quasi - particle amplitudes @xmath112 and @xmath113 ( with momentum @xmath114 ) associated with particle and hole excitations of the a(b)-sublattices at a dirac point .
vortices possess cylindrical symmetry so we express eqs .
( [ eqn : rlse5])-([eqn : rlse6 ] ) in plane - polar coordinates , factor the quasi - particle amplitudes into radial and angular parts , then substitute in the particular solution for @xmath115 .
we then obtain a set of first - order coupled ode s in the radial coordinate to be solved consistently for the functions @xmath116 , @xmath117 and the associated eigenvalues .
we discretize the derivatives and functions using a forward - backward average finite - difference scheme , then solve the resulting discrete matrix eigenvalue problem using a standard numerical diagonalization method . _ vortex lifetimes _ to compute vortex lifetimes , we solve the rlse to obtain the quasi - particle spatial functions and eigenvalues . in general , for vortex solutions of the nlde certain eigenvalues and eigenmodes key to understanding the physical motion correspond to nambu - goldstone modes , i.e. , anomalous with a small imaginary component @xcite .
when thermal losses are small , it is the imaginary part of the linear eigenvalues which depletes the bec .
we define the vortex lifetime by computing the time for depletion to reach a significant fraction of the total fixed number of atoms in the system , and consider only depletion coming from the mode with the largest imaginary term in its eigenvalue .
the lifetime is then given by @xmath118 \mathrm{ln } \left(r_\perp / i \right)$ ] , expressed in terms of the largest linear eigenvalue @xmath119 and the planar radius of the bec @xmath14 , in units of the lattice constant @xmath11 ( see table 1 in the main article ) .
note also that the spatial integral @xmath120 here is specific to each vortex type .
for the experimental parameters of table 1 , we find the longest lived solutions to be the vortex / soliton and anderson - toulouse vortex with @xmath121 , compared to the typical lifetime of a @xmath122 condensate in an optical lattice of less than a second @xcite . _
chemical potential spectra _ in order to have a clear comparative prediction for energies involved in creating our vortices , we solve the nlde using a numerical shooting method in the presence of a weak harmonic trap of frequency @xmath123 along the direction of the lattice .
this is the frequency associated with a planar bec radius equal to @xmath124 times the lattice constant . in this case
vortices come in radially quantized states . for simplicity ,
we focus mainly on the lowest radial excitation . using a generalization of the method in @xcite
, we have obtained the dimensionless ( renormalized ) chemical potential @xmath125 as a function of the normalization @xmath126 for each vortex type , as shown in fig . 4 in the main article .
here , @xmath127 is the number of atoms in the system with the other quantities defined in table 1 . | we present a detailed experimental procedure for preparing relativistic vortices , governed by the nonlinear dirac equation , in a two - dimensional bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) in a honeycomb optical lattice .
our setup contains dirac points , in direct analogy to graphene .
we determine a range of practical values for all relevant physical parameters needed to realize relativistic vortices in bec of @xmath0 atoms .
seven distinct vortex types , including anderson - toulouse and mermin - ho skyrmion textures and half - quantum vortices , are obtained , and their discrete spectra and stability properties are calculated in a weak harmonic trap .
we find that most vortices are stable with a lifetime between @xmath1 and @xmath2 seconds .
multi - component bose - einstein condensates ( becs ) present an ideal setting for studying complex vortex structures @xcite .
such vortices allow for topologically intriguing configurations ranging from skyrmions to knots @xcite .
the usual method for adding a spinor structure to a bec relies on hyperfine degrees of freedom or different atomic species .
instead , we use the band structure and linear dispersion relation around the dirac points at the brillouin zone edge of a honeycomb optical lattice to realize a four - component dirac spinor , in direct analogy to graphene @xcite .
this gives us both pseudospin as well as a relativistic structure . to accomplish this
, we propose starting with a bec of weakly interacting alkali metal atoms in the lowest bloch state of a 2d honeycomb optical lattice , then using bragg scattering to populate bloch states at the two inequivalent dirac points , followed by the application of a laguerre - gaussian laser beam to deliver a net angular momentum to the bec which excites a plethora of vortex structures .
the vortices we obtain are solutions of the nonlinear dirac equation ( nlde ) , whose stability is determined by the relativistic linear stability equations ( rlse ) @xcite .
our work on the nlde+rlse system opens up the field of relativistic simulations in becs at velocities ten orders of magnitude slower than the speed of light . in this letter
we combine the study of dirac points with superfluid vortices , an environment reminiscent of particle physics models where relativistic vortices are commonplace @xcite .
stability of a bec at the dirac points presents a challenge , since bloch states there have finite crystal momentum and nonzero energy .
we handle this problem by introducing an intermediate asymmetry between the a and b - sublattice potential depths which opens up a mass gap .
using a gap enables us to construct initial and final bloch states , @xmath3 and @xmath4 ( with dirac point momentum @xmath5 ) , as superpositions of the two degenerate states at the dirac point with velocities @xmath6 and @xmath7 , respectively .
this produces a state with group velocity equal to zero , relative to the lattice .
stationarity of the bec with respect to the lattice and the lab frame is significant experimentally , since the bec can remain confined in an external trapping potential indefinitely and does not suffer from dynamical instabilities associated with relative motion between the bec and lattice .
the end result is a metastable state in which thermal losses can be managed by maintaining the system at very low temperatures . for realistic experimental parameters our relativistic vortices are stable for up to 10 seconds , as long or longer than the lifetime of typical becs .
relativistic vortices are realized in the emergent nonlinear dirac background , in the long wavelength limit of a 2d honeycomb lattice .
the usual bec parameters in 3d are renormalized , once for the dimensional reduction @xcite , and again after integrating over the lattice wannier functions and going to long wavelengths . consequently
, nlde physics is only experimentally realizable in practice when several energy and length constraints are satisfied .
we list these constraints in table [ table1 ] along with their mathematical definitions . for our calculations
, we use the semiclassical estimate @xcite of the hopping parameter @xmath8 .
it is helpful to consolidate the constraint inequalities to arrive at expressions relating the temperature @xmath9 and length scales of the system , @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 : @xmath15 } \
, , \label{reducedbounds1 } \\
\hspace{-2pc}&&t < \hbar^2/k_b m l_z^2 \ , , \label{reducedbounds2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath12 is the average inter - particle distance defined in terms of the particle density @xmath16 .
all other quantities are defined in table [ table1 ] .
the temperature @xmath9 in eq .
( [ reducedbounds2 ] ) depends indirectly on the ratio @xmath17 through @xmath18 .
we can get an idea of how the particle density affects @xmath9 by evaluating the inequalities for different values of @xmath18 while fixing @xmath19 .
for example , @xmath20 gives @xmath21 and @xmath22 , whereas for @xmath23 we find @xmath24 and @xmath25 . from this
we see that a practical value for @xmath9 requires that densities be considerably larger than @xmath26 , a consequence of the additional constraints in eqs .
( [ reducedbounds1])-([reducedbounds2 ] ) .
( no sublattice asymmetry ) to the hyperfine state @xmath27 via the rf / mw transition @xmath28 , then from the a - sublattice to the b - sublattice via the perturbation @xmath29 , and finally back to the @xmath30 hyperfine state via the @xmath31 transition ( @xmath32 ) .
( b ) the same process showing the associated rf / mw frequencies and the detunings @xmath33 and @xmath34 . ]
ring - vortex , ( c , d ) b - sublattice of mermin - ho skyrmion , ( e , f ) ring - vortex / soliton , ( g , h ) half - quantum vortex , or semion .
all these vortices and more can be made by variations on the experimental techniques of figs .
[ braggscatt1]-[fig : sublatticetransfer ] . ] the honeycomb lattice is composed of two degenerate hexagonal lattices , a and b , which leads to the band crossing and the dirac cones .
the lattice potential is straightforward to implement experimentally @xcite using light tuned either to the blue or to the red of an atomic resonance . for the red - detuned lattice ,
all three laser fields are polarized parallel to the plane of propagation so that the polarization of the net field is spatially dependent .
this polarization gradient produces a spin - dependent lattice potential which is key to our method , allowing for differentiation between different hyperfine ground states .
figure [ braggscatt1](a ) shows the optical potential produced for @xmath35rb atoms in different hyperfine states when the lattice is formed from @xmath36 light @xcite .
preparation of the bec at a dirac point is accomplished by first condensing into the lattice via evaporative cooling , then inducing bragg scattering between crystal momenta @xmath37 and @xmath5 using auxiliary laser fields .
we start with the bec in the lowest - energy bloch state and hyperfine state @xmath38 with the spin - dependent potential turned on so that a mass gap is in place .
the gap is defined as @xmath39 , which measures the difference in potential depths between the a and b - sublattices as shown in [ fig : sublatticetransfer](a ) .
note that @xmath40 is the corresponding mass term in the nlde , with @xmath6 the effective speed of light ( see table i ) .
the lattice depth is then increased adiabatically @xcite .
only the sublattice with the lowest energy is occupied at this point , assumed here to be the a - sublattice .
bragg scattering to a bloch state at a dirac point can be accomplished by applying two laser fields with wavevectors @xmath41 and @xmath42 , which satisfy @xmath43 and have frequencies @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
these frequencies satisfy @xmath46/\hbar$ ] . here
, the function @xmath47 gives the dispersion relation for the lower ( a ) band .
application of this potential results in rabi oscillation between the initial state @xmath48 ( ground state ) , and the final state @xmath49 ( dirac point ) with a rabi frequency @xmath50 , where @xmath51 , @xmath52 are wavefunctions ; @xmath53 is the bec density distribution on the a ( b ) sublattice .
figure [ braggscatt1](b ) shows numerical calculations for @xmath54 as a function of the depth of the honeycomb lattice @xmath55 in units of the depth of the bragg scattering lattice @xmath56 .
we should keep in mind that @xmath57 .
the entire population of atoms in state @xmath48 can be transferred to @xmath49 by applying the bragg scattering potential for a time @xmath58 provided that the amplitude of the bragg potential is chosen such that @xmath59 is significantly smaller than the energy splitting between the upper and lower bands , i.e. , @xmath60 .
note that because of the gap , all the atoms are presently in a state with zero group velocity .
+ with the bec at the dirac point but only in the a - sublattice sites , we populate the b - sublattice by first transferring atoms to a hyperfine state that does not experience the vector light shift and therefore has no mass gap .
we can then populate the b - sublattice bloch state by applying a periodic perturbation which modulates the amplitude of one of the lattice laser fields .
this provides an anisotropy in the tunneling matrix elements , which results in a net transfer of atoms to the b - sublattice , as depicted in both panels of fig .
[ fig : sublatticetransfer ] .
finally , the transfer of atoms to the non - equivalent dirac point @xmath61 can be accomplished again by bragg scattering from a lattice formed using auxiliary laser fields @xcite . the rabi frequency and resulting time - dependent populations for the @xmath62 and @xmath63 points are depicted in fig .
[ braggscatt1](c ) .
we analytically and numerically obtain seven physically distinct nlde vortex types as follows ( a table detailing the functional form of each vortex type is included in supplemental materials , as well as a brief review of the nlde and rlse ) .
( i ) the vortex / soliton is a bright soliton or density peak in the center in the first component with a vortex of phase winding @xmath64 around the outside in the second .
( ii ) the ring - vortex / soliton is also a bright soliton in the first component , but the vortex component is a ring peaked near the healing length @xmath65 .
( iii ) the anderson - toulouse skyrmion has the same core structure as the vortex / soliton , but
the spinor components are continuously interchanged as the distance from the core increases , while staying within the bounds @xmath66 and conserving total density @xmath67 .
( iv ) the mermin - ho skyrmion again has similar behavior near the core but the soliton ( vortex ) amplitude decreases ( increases ) monotonically away from the core within the bounds @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
( v ) the half - quantum vortex or semion is characterized by a phase discontinuity such that far from the core the amplitudes have the form @xmath70 and @xmath71 ; the additional @xmath72 phase is accounted for by a rotation between the dirac spinor components .
so far , all of these solutions have one unit of angular momentum , @xmath73 with @xmath74 , either a phase winding of @xmath64 in one component or a winding of @xmath72 in each component .
additionally , for arbitrary phase winding ( @xmath75 ) ( vi ) ring - vortices and ( vii ) topological vortices exist with @xmath76 ( @xmath77 ) units of winding in the first ( second ) spinor component , but differ in their asymptotic form .
component amplitudes for the ring - vortex peak at around one healing length from the core and quickly decay for large @xmath78 . on the other hand ,
topological vortices retain non - zero density far from the core .
several representative vortices are plotted in fig .
[ relativisticvortices ] .
all of the vortices here can be created using straightforward variations of the transition sequence depicted in fig .
[ fig : sublatticetransfer ] . in the supplemental materials ,
we explain how vortices are realized in practical experiments . for most of vortex types ( i)-(vii ) , we find lifetimes @xmath79 to be long compared to the lifetime of the bec itself . using the rlse ( as detailed in supplemental material ) , we obtain we
obtain the following values for @xmath79 : @xmath80 ; for the vortex / soliton , ring - vortex / soliton , anderson - toulouse , mermin - ho , half - quantum , @xmath81 ring - vortex , and @xmath81 topological vortex , respectively . to complete our description ,
we have computed the discrete spectra pertaining to the case of planar confinement by a weak harmonic trap .
these are plotted in fig .
[ cnfnd3 ] .
note that ring - vortices are minimally affected by the presence of a weak trap , since they are highly localized objects and lie very near the center of the trap . in conclusion ,
we have described in detail a method for constructing a stable bec at the dirac points of a honeycomb optical lattice .
our system allows for relativistic vortex excitations in a macroscopic dirac spinor wavefunction , providing a means of studying high energy field theoretic vortices in a condensed matter setting .
we have completely specified the required physical parameters , lifetimes , and spectra for harmonically bound vortices as a prescription guide for the experimentalist .
variations on the nlde have tremendous potential for a host of relativistic simulations in becs .
interesting examples include soler models @xcite and the extended gross - neveu model @xcite .
our work puts such efforts on a solid experimental footing . |
although the two - dimensional ising model was solved exactly by onsager in 1944 and much work has been done in this field over the last decades , some questions still remain open .
one is the dynamical critical behaviour .
when we take a lattice with initially all spins up , right at the curie point the magnetization @xmath6 decays with time as @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the exponent for the spontaneous magnetization and @xmath9 is the exponent for the correlation length ; both are known exactly .
two main suggestions have been made for the value of @xmath3 in glauber kinetics : one is @xmath5 asymptotically , with simple power law behaviour ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) , the other is @xmath10 with logarithmic corrections to the power law behaviour .
the latter was suggested by domany @xcite and later by swendsen @xcite .
lots of work has been done in order to rule out one of these assumptions ( e. g. @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) , but with no final result .
we want to test these suggestions using new numercial data obtained by using the new supercomputer jump at the research center jlich .
we compare these with older data .
data was generated by initializing a lattice with all spins up and then doing a monte carlo simulation of the ising model with glauber kinetics . to obtain higher speed , multi spin coding and parallelization ( via mpi ) were used .
speed on one @xmath11 ghz power4 + processor was roughly 160 million sites per second .
up to 512 processors were used in parallel for the largest simulations .
although the new supercomputer jump is rather large , there are some restrictions on the size of lattices that can be simulated . we have chosen @xmath2 and @xmath0 ( the old world record for the two - dimensional ising model was @xmath12 @xcite , @xcite ) , with periodic boundary conditions .
thus finite size effects should be negligibly small .
several independent runs were done for @xmath2 for averaging , 50 runs each for the random number generators @xmath13 ( called lcg(@xmath14 ) ) and the 64-bit implementation of ziff s four - tap generator r(471,1586,6988,9689 ) @xcite . for @xmath2
the simulations were done up to 6000 timesteps ( full sweeps through the lattice ) . for the larger lattices , only considerably smaller times were possible , due to restrictions in computing time . for investigating finite - size effects , lattices with @xmath15
were simulated with lcg(@xmath16 ) , again averaging over 50 runs .
the effective exponent @xmath3 can be determined from the @xmath17 data by numercial differentiation : @xmath18 .
even when averaging @xmath17 over several independent runs , fluctuations are visible when calculating the effective @xmath19 .
thus each point in figs .
[ data][fin_size ] represents many @xmath19 ; these points were generated by dividing the data for @xmath20 into several intervals and then doing a least squares fit in each .
each point is the central point of the fit in the interval .
the errorbars for @xmath3 ( not shown in the plots for better legibility ) are of the order of the symbol size for short times and grow to up to @xmath21 for long times . the new data , especially for the large systems , allows for a better fit of the swendsen suggestion .
the new fitted curve has a maximum at about @xmath22 ( @xmath23 ) .
the last point for @xmath2 , corresponding to the interval @xmath24 , is subject to strong fluctuations and thus doubtful .
unfortunately , this is the most interesting data point .
nevertheless , a trend is visible : for larger times , the critical exponent seems to go up , not down , thus being in contradiction to the domany - swendsen suggestion .
this could also be due to finite - size effects : for @xmath15 , the effect of increasing @xmath3 seems to be stronger ( cf .
[ fin_size ] ) , but more simulations would be needed for confirmation .
although it is possible to argue that the numerical data for very long times is doubtful , as the influence of fluctuations on the value of @xmath3 increases , the current precision data seems bad for the domany - swendsen assumption . it would be possible to modify the fit to the data , but the trend for long times rather contradicts the value of @xmath4 . nevertheless , there is still work to do : the influence of various random number generators is important , in order to find one which allows precise data , but is still fast enough for large - scale simulations : for @xmath2 , averaged over 50 runs , ziff s four - tap generator produces results which differ systematically from other generators and system sizes .
this is not the case for a single run with @xmath0 and four - tap generator .
data for @xmath15 , averaged over 25 runs , showed the same behavior as for @xmath2 . for these lattice sizes , r(471,1586,6988,9689 )
seems not to be suited well .
furthermore , the influence of finite - size effects for long times should be investigated in more detail , and the effects of fluctuations in the magnetization in general .
i would like to thank d. stauffer for fruitful discussions and r. h. swendsen for comments on a preliminary version of this paper .
i would also like to thank the research center jlich for computing time on their new supercomputer jump . as a sidenote : the ising program used for this paper was written as a simple test for the shmem - library porting tool in the first place .
thus i would like to thank david klepacki of ibm for help with the turboshmem library , although the program now no longer uses it , but instead straight mpi . c. kalle , _ j. phys .
_ * a17 * , l801 ( 1984 ) .
d. stauffer , _ physica _ * a244 * , 344 ( 1997 ) .
d. stauffer , _ int .
j. mod .
_ * c10 * , 931 ( 1999 ) .
e. domany , _ phys .
lett . _ * 52 * , 871 ( 1984 ) .
r. h. swendsen , conference talk at `` monte carlo and structure optimization methods for biology , chemistry , and physics '' , tallahassee ( 1999 ) ; and private communication .
m. arjunwadkar , m. fasnacht , j. b. kadane , r. h. swendsen , _ physica _ * a323 * , 487 ( 2003 ) . m. p. nightingale , h. w. j. blte , _ phys .
lett . _ * 76 * , 4548 ( 1996 ) .
m. p. nightingale , h. w. j. blte , _ phys . rev . _ * b62 * , 1089 ( 2000 ) .
r. m. ziff , _ computers in physics _
* 12 * , 385 ( 1998 ) .
a. linke , d. w. heermann , p. altevogt , m. siegert , _ physica _ * a222 * , 205 ( 1995 ) . | using the new supercomputer jump at the research center jlich , we were able to simulate large lattices ( up to @xmath0 , meaning a new world record ) for long times ( up to @xmath1 for @xmath2 ) . using this data
, we examined the dynamical critical exponent @xmath3 .
the old assumption of @xmath4 with logarithmic corrections seems very unlikely according to our data , leaving the asymptotic value of @xmath5 .
+ keywords : ising model , critical point , monte carlo , relaxation . |
in heavy - ion collisions with bombarding energies per nucleon in the order of nucleon binding energy , the mean - field approach , in terms of time - dependent hartree - fock equations ( tdhf ) , provides a good approximation for describing the average behavior of the collision dynamics @xcite .
for example , the mean - field approximation gives a good description of energy dissipation and nucleon drift in deep inelastic heavy - ion collisions ( dic ) .
however , the collective motion is treated in nearly classical , deterministic manner and the fluctuations of collective variables are severely underestimated @xcite .
therefore , in the mean - field approach , it is not possible to describe energy distributions and fragment mass and charge distributions in dic .
there are other reactions , such as heavy - ion fusion at near - barrier energies , spinodal dynamics leading to nuclear fragmentation @xcite , in which dynamics of density fluctuations play a dominant role .
much work has been done to improve the transport approach for describing dynamics of density fluctuations beyond the mean - field approximation . basically , there are two different sources of density fluctuations : ( i ) fluctuations induces by binary collisions @xcite and ( ii ) mean - field fluctuations .
fluctuations and dissipation induced by collisional mechanism are important at the intermediate and high energies .
transport description can be extended in a stochastic approach by including the binary collision term and its fluctuating part in an analogous manner to the langevin treatment of brownian motion . in the semiclassical limit , this model is known as the boltzmann - langevin approach . on the other hand , as indicated in a recent work @xcite , the mean - field fluctuations originating from the quantal and thermal fluctuations at the initial state become the dominant source of density fluctuations at low energies .
the theory that includes mean - field fluctuations is referred to as the stochastic mean - field ( smf ) approach . in recent works ,
the smf approach was employed to extract transport coefficients associated with relative momentum and nucleon exchange in low - energy heavy - ion collisions @xcite .
also , some applications of the smf approach have been carried out for analyzing the early development of spinodal instabilities @xcite .
microscopic transport coefficients extracted from the smf have similar forms with those familiar from the phenomenological nucleon exchange model @xcite , but they provide a more refined description of one - body dissipation and the associated fluctuation mechanism . in these initial investigations , for simplicity , we calculated transport coefficients for symmetric central collisions .
it is worth mentioning that the variances of the fragment mass distributions calculated with the microscopic diffusion coefficient extracted from the smf approach compares very well with the empirical result @xmath1 , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 denote the mass variance and the total number of nucleon exchange between projectile and target nuclei up to time @xmath4 , respectively .
this observation provides another convincing support for the validity of the smf approach . in symmetric collisions ,
the mass and charge numbers of the fragment do not change on the average , i.e. , the mean value of nucleon drift coefficient vanishes . in this work ,
we investigate nucleon exchange mechanism in central collisions of asymmetric @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system . in sec .
ii , we study nucleon drift in the basis of the tdhf and compare the results with those obtained the semiclassical limit of smf approach .
we illustrate the influence of the neck motion on nucleon flux through the window area . in sec .
iii , we present a brief description of the smf approach and transport coefficients for nucleon exchange . in sec .
iv , we investigate the nucleon diffusion and variances of fragment mass distributions , and conclusions are given in sec .
as an extension of the previous work , we consider central collisions of asymmetric systems at low energies . for not too heavy systems , collisions above
the coulomb barrier lead to fusion , and at below the barrier energies , colliding nuclei exchange a few nucleons and re - separate . in order to investigate the dynamics of nucleon exchange
, we introduce the window between projectile - like and target - like nuclei according to the procedure outlined in @xcite .
figure 1 illustrates density profiles at the reaction plane , @xmath7 and the window location in collisions of @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system at center - of - mass energy @xmath8 mev at three different times .
the coulomb barrier is @xmath9 mev . in this figure and in the rest of this paper
, we perform the numerical calculations with the three - dimensional tdhf code developed by p. bonche and his collaborators with the sly4d skyrme effective force @xcite .
since the total nucleon number remains constant , we can take the mass number of the target - like nuclei as the independent variable .
, are indicated by contour plots for the central collision of @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system at @xmath8 mev in units of @xmath10 .
the black dot is the center of mass point .
the red lines indicate the positions of the window @xmath11 and @xmath12 denotes velocity of the window.,width=302 ] the mass number of target - like nuclei is determined by integrating the density distribution over the left side of the window , @xmath13 where @xmath14 denotes the position of the neck window . the quantity @xmath15 denotes the step function and @xmath16 is the reduced wigner function along the collision direction .
definition of the mass number of target - like nucleus is equivalent to @xmath17 where @xmath18 denotes the reduced density of nucleons .
the wigner function @xmath19 is defined as a partial fourier transform of the single - particle density matrix according to @xmath20 where the single - particle density matrix is defined as @xmath21 here , the sum runs over the occupied single - particle wave functions with spin - isospin quantum numbers @xmath22 and occupation numbers @xmath23 .
we obtain the reduced wigner function @xmath16 along the collision direction by integrating over the phase space volume on the window area between the colliding nuclei , @xmath24 using tdhf equations , we can deduce that the rate of change of mass number of target - like fragments as @xmath25 where @xmath26 denotes the nucleon drift coefficient determined by the net nucleon flux through the window area , @xmath27 here @xmath28 is the velocity of the neck multiplied by nucleon mass . even though we employ the reduced wigner function for convenience ,
the expression of the drift coefficient is fully quantum mechanical .
since the net nucleon flux is determined by the kinetic term in tdhf , eq .
( [ dadt ] ) does not involve a semiclassical approximation .
the reduced wigner function @xmath29 is exact wigner transform of the reduced density matrix @xmath30 .
the center of mass of the colliding nuclei in fig . 1 is located at @xmath31 .
the red vertical lines indicate the positions of windows @xmath32 .
as seen from the figure , the position of the window does not remain constant relative to the center of mass .
the directions of neck velocities are indicated with arrows during the approach and re - separation phase of nuclei .
figure 2 shows the time dependence of the position of the window relative to the center of mass in collisions of @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system at three different center - of - mass energies . as seen from fig .
2(b ) , at energies below the coulomb barrier , during the approach phase , the neck moves towards the center of mass and then moves away from the center of mass .
we note that the center - of - mass energy @xmath33 mev leads to fusion . however , as seen in fig .
2(a ) , before the system fuses , position of the window undergoes a single oscillation .
ca + @xmath6zr system at three different center - of - mass energies .
the center of mass point is located at x @xmath34.,width=302 ] zr , @xmath35 , is plotted versus time in central collisions of @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system at three different center - of - mass energies .
the dotted curves are calculated directly from eq .
( [ massproj ] ) , the solid lines are obtained by integrating the nucleon flux on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ dadt ] ) over time , and the dashed lines are calculated similarly with solid lines except the motion of the window , second term of the right - hand side of eq .
( [ dadt ] ) , is neglected.,width=302 ] in order to illustrate the effect of window dynamics on nucleon drift , in fig .
3 , we show time evolution of the mean mass number of the target - like nuclei , @xmath36 as a function of time at three different center - of - mass energies , @xmath37 mev ( c ) , @xmath8 mev ( b ) and @xmath33 mev ( a ) . in this figure ,
dotted lines are obtained by integrating the density over the left side of the window from eq .
( [ massproj ] ) and the solid lines are obtained by integrating the nucleon flux across the window from eq .
( [ dadt ] ) .
dashed lines are the result of flux calculations from eq .
( [ dadt ] ) , except window motion is neglected .
we observe that window motion has an important influence on the net nucleon flux or , in terms of transport language , on the mass drift coefficient , at both below and above barrier energies . in this connection
, we remark that in the phenomenological nucleon exchange model , transport coefficients ( mass drift and diffusion ) are usually calculated by assuming a fixed window position relative to the center of mass @xcite . as seen in fig .
3 , keeping the window at rest relative to the center of mass can introduce an error in the order of @xmath38 of the mean number of transferred nucleons . in the smf approach @xcite ,
the mean - field fluctuations are incorporated into the dynamical evolution by including the initial state fluctuations in a stochastic approximation in a similar manner to the idea presented in refs .
@xcite . in the approach , in contrast to the deterministic description of the standard mean - field approach , an ensemble of single - particle density matrices are generated by starting an initial density distribution .
a member of the ensemble of single - particle density matrices , denoted by @xmath39 , can be expanded in terms of a complete set of single - particle wave functions as @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 indicate the spin - isospin quantum numbers of the single - particle wave functions . in the expansion
, elements of density matrices are assumed to be random gaussian numbers with mean values , @xmath43 and variances are determined by @xmath44&.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath45 denotes the average single particle occupation factors , which are values 0 and 1 at zero temperature and given by the fermi - dirac distribution at finite temperatures .
time evolution of the single - particle wave functions is determined by the self - consistent mean - field @xmath46 of the corresponding event ,
@xmath47 we introduce the wigner function @xmath48 corresponding to each event @xmath39 of the ensemble of single - particle density matrices in the same manner as in eq .
( [ eq : wigner ] ) . also , we define the reduced wigner function @xmath49 and the mass number of target - like nuclei @xmath50 in the same manner as in eqs .
( [ eq : wignerx ] ) and ( [ massproj ] ) . the time evolution of the mass number of the target - like fragments in the event @xmath39 obeys the equation @xmath51 which is similar to eq .
( [ aa ] ) except that the nucleon flux through the window is calculated by the reduced wigner function in that event .
it is possible to convert this equation into a langevin equation for stochastic evolution of the mass number of the target - like nuclei .
fluctuations of the nucleon flux through the window can arise from fluctuations of the reduced wigner function originating implicitly from the mass number dependence @xmath52 and explicitly from the fluctuations of single - particle degrees of freedom @xmath53 .
then , the reduced wigner function can be written as @xmath54 here , @xmath55 and @xmath56 denote average quantities taken over the generated ensemble . for small fluctuations ,
the ensemble average quantities are equivalent to the results obtained by ordinary mean - field approximation . as a result ,
the langevin equation for the nucleon exchange becomes , @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the drift coefficient for nucleon exchange given by eq .
( [ dadt ] ) in the standard mean - field approach .
the quantity @xmath59 denotes the fluctuating part of the nucleon flux , @xmath60 the fluctuating part of the flux is considered as a markovian gaussian random force on the nucleon exchange mechanism determined by a correlation function , @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the diffusion coefficient associated with nucleon exchange . in the smf approach , within the semiclassical approximation , it is possible to deduce expressions for the diffusion coefficients associated with macroscopic variables @xcite .
the expression of diffusion coefficient for nucleon exchange is given by @xmath63 where the quantity @xmath64 is defined as @xmath65\right.\nonumber \\ & & \;\left.\pm f_t^{\sigma\tau}(x_0,p_x , t)\left[1 - \frac{f_p^{\sigma\tau}(x_0,p_x , t)}{\omega(x_0,t)}\right]\right\}. \label{e2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ca + @xmath6zr system at three different center - of - mass energies .
the solid lines and dashed lines are obtained from eq .
( [ dadt ] ) and eq .
( [ e4 ] ) , respectively.,width=302 ] is plotted versus time in central collisions of @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system at three different center - of - mass energies .
the solid lines are obtained by taking time integral of the tdhf drift from eq .
( [ dadt ] ) , and the dashed lines are calculated from the semiclassical expression eq .
( [ e4 ] ) of the nucleon drift coefficient.,width=302 ] here , the mean values of the reduced wigner distributions @xmath66 and @xmath67 are defined in terms of single - particle wave functions originating from projectile and target nuclei , respectively . the quantity @xmath68 denotes the phase - space volume on the window and it is calculated with the method explained in ref
the expression of diffusion coefficient has a similar form with that familiar from the phenomenological nucleon exchange model @xcite .
however , diffusion coefficient extracted from the smf approach is not restricted by adiabatic or diabatic conditions , and provides a more refined description of the nucleon diffusion mechanism . in the phenomenological nucleon exchange model , diffusion coefficient
is determined by the sum of fluxes from projectile to target and from target to projectile , while the nucleon drift coefficient is specified by the net flux through the window . in the spirit of nucleon exchange model
, we can infer an approximate expression for the nucleon drift coefficient as @xmath69 we note that the expressions for the nucleon drift and diffusion coefficients , eqs .
( [ e1 ] ) and ( [ e4 ] ) , are valid in the semiclassical approximation .
in particular , at below the barrier energies , the reduced wigner functions @xmath70 obtained from the tdhf calculations exhibit large oscillations in momentum space . in order to obtain semiclassical description of transport coefficients , we need to smooth out these oscillations in the reduced wigner functions .
similar to the gaussian overlap approximation introduced in ref .
@xcite , we develop a smoothing method of the momentum dependence of the reduced wigner functions , which is presented in the appendix .
figure 4 shows the drift coefficients as a function of time at center - of - mass energies below the barrier , @xmath37 mev ( c ) and @xmath8 mev ( b ) , and above the barrier energy @xmath33 mev ( a ) . in the figure , the quantal drift coefficients calculated from eq .
( [ dadt ] ) and the semiclassical approximation of the drift coefficients calculated from eq .
( [ e4 ] ) are indicated by solid and dashed lines , respectively .
the mean - field approach described by tdhf equations provides a quantal treatment of the single particle motion , and hence we can take the tdhf drift coefficient as a reference . as a result , nucleon transfer via barrier penetration
is included into the quantal drift coefficients .
the semiclassical calculations provide a good approximation for the drift coefficients at above the barrier energies .
however , at below the barrier energies , semiclassical calculations underestimate the quantal drift coefficients progressively more and more .
figure 5 shows comparisons of the mean nucleon transfer @xmath35 calculated from eq .
( [ ads ] ) in the standard mean - field tdhf and the smf approaches at the same center - of - mass energies below the barrier @xmath37 mev ( c ) and @xmath8 mev ( b ) , and above the barrier energy @xmath33 mev ( a ) .
we observe that , at above the barrier energies , mean value of the nucleon drift is well described by the semiclassical approximation .
however , at below the barrier energies , quantal effects become important , as a result the semiclassical calculations underestimate the quantal value of nucleon drift by more than 50% at @xmath71 mev . at @xmath72 mev ,
drift in the semiclassical calculation goes in the opposite direction .
figure 6 shows the comparison of asymptotic values of the mean numbers of nucleon transfers in the tdhf and smf calculations as a function of center - of - mass energy . below barrier energies , the asymptotic values ( @xmath73 )
are the mean numbers of nucleon transfer after re - separation . on the other hand , at the over barrier energies , for the asymptotic values , we take the maximum number of nucleon transfer at the initial stage of the fusion . at below the barrier energies ,
quantal effects cause the large differences in the mean number of nucleon transfers between the tdhf and the semiclassical calculations . ) of the mean numbers of nucleon transfer
are plotted versus center - of - mass energy in collisions of @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system .
the coulomb barrier , @xmath74 , is indicated by the arrow . at energies above the barrier , where fusion occurs ,
the maximum numbers of nucleon transfered , for instance the maximum value seen in fig .
5a , are indicated .
the solid lines and dashed lines are calculated from the standard tdhf eq .
( [ massproj ] ) and the smf approaches eq .
( [ e4 ] ) , respectively.,width=321 ]
in this section , we calculate the variance , @xmath75 , of fragment mass distribution in central collisions of @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system .
it follows from the langevin eq .
( [ eq : langevin - mass ] ) , that the variance @xmath76 is determined by @xmath77 where @xmath78 .
ca + @xmath6zr system at three different center - of - mass energies .
the solid lines are obtained from eq .
( [ e1 ] ) , while the dashed lines are calculated by neglecting motion of the window.,width=302 ] solid lines in fig .
7 illustrate the diffusion coefficients as a function of time at center - of - mass energies below the barrier , @xmath37 mev ( c ) and @xmath8 mev ( b ) , and above the barrier energy @xmath33 mev ( a ) .
the solid lines are obtained by eq .
( [ e1 ] ) , while the dashed lines are calculated by neglecting motion of the window .
we observe from this figure that , contrary to behavior of drift coefficients , the motion of the window does not affect diffusion coefficients appreciably .
time dependence of drift coefficients @xmath79 in central collisions of asymmetric @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system at three different center - of - mass energies is illustrated in fig .
4 . in particular , at below the barrier energies , time dependence of drift coefficients in both tdhf and smf approaches arises mainly from time dependence of the window area and time dependence of nucleon density on the window area .
furthermore , because of very small value of the mean nucleon transfer , mass asymmetry degree of freedom is far from equilibrium .
therefore , the reduced mass dependence of the drift coefficients is expected to be very small . in the following ,
we neglect the contribution from drift term and solve the variance equation ( [ variance ] ) to find , @xmath80 figure 8 shows variances of fragment mass distribution at the same center - of - mass energies below the barrier @xmath37 mev ( c ) and @xmath8 mev ( b ) , and above the barrier energy @xmath33 mev ( a ) , as a function of time .
solid lines in the figure are the result of integration over the diffusion coefficients , while solid dots indicate the total number of exchange nucleon @xmath3 until time @xmath4 .
the empirical relation @xmath0 follows from the nucleon exchange model and has been widely used to analyze the experimental data of deep - inelastic collisions @xcite .
figure 8 illustrates , as in the previous investigations for symmetric heavy - ion collisions @xcite , that there is a good agreement between the empirical formulae and the calculations based on the smf approach . even at energies below the coulomb barrier ,
the semiclassical calculations based on the smf approach compares well with the empirical description @xmath81 .
ca + @xmath6zr system at three different center - of - mass energies .
the dotted lines denote total number of exchanged nucleons until a given time @xmath4 , while the solid lines are calculated from eq .
( [ eq : sigma]).,width=302 ]
we investigate nucleon drift and diffusion mechanisms in central collisions of asymmetric @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system in frameworks of the standard mean - field and the smf approaches . in the smf approach
, we do not carry out stochastic mean - field calculations , but we extract diffusion coefficient associated with nucleon exchange in a semiclassical approximation , which has a form similar to that familiar from the phenomenological nucleon exchange model . using this similarity
, we also infer an expression for the nucleon drift coefficient in the semiclassical approximation . in the standard mean - field approach provided by the tdhf equations
, we can only calculate the nucleon drift including quantum mechanical effects in the single - particle level , but we can not describe nucleon diffusion in this framework . at energies below the coulomb barrier , colliding nuclei exchange a few particles and re - separate . at above the barrier energies , since collisions lead to fusion , we limit our calculations of nucleon exchange during the early stages of the collisions .
our calculations show that not only the size of window between nuclei but also motion of window relative to the center of mass play an important role in nucleon drift mechanism . in the phenomenological nucleon exchange model
, the motion of the window relative to the center of mass is often neglected .
we observe that at below the barrier energies , the semiclassical drift coefficient underestimates the nucleon drift deduced from the standard mean - field description with tdhf equations .
this is mainly due to the fact that barrier penetration of the single - particles is not included in the semiclassical description of nucleon drift .
however , in collisions with energies above the coulomb barrier , the semiclassical expression for the nucleon drift provide a good approximation for the quantal drift deduced from the tdhf framework . employing the diffusion coefficient extracted from the smf approach , we calculate the variances of fragment mass distribution at energies below and above the barrier .
in such calculations for central collisions , we can not compare the results with experiments , but can compare them with the empirical relation @xmath0 . as in the symmetric collisions we investigated earlier @xcite ,
our calculations with semiclassical diffusion coefficients for asymmetric system compare well with the empirical relation at energies both below and above the coulomb barrier .
this empirical result has been used to analyze data in dic above the barrier energies @xcite .
however , it is not clear whether such empirical relation @xmath0 is also valid below the coulomb barrier , where quantal effects may become important in nucleon exchange mechanism , as we observe in nucleon drift coefficients .
therefore , in the present calculations , we can not draw any conclusions about the possible quantal effects on nucleon diffusion coefficients and the resulting variances of fragment mass distributions at energies below the coulomb barrier .
we thank p. bonche for providing the 3d - tdhf code . s.a .
, b.y . , and k.w .
gratefully acknowledge ganil for the support and warm hospitality extended to them during their visits .
this work is supported in part by the us doe grant no .
de - fg05 - 89er40530 .
we consider the reduced wigner function @xmath82 which is associated with the single - particle wave functions of the target nucleus .
it can be rewritten as @xmath83 where @xmath84 in these expressions for simplicity , we introduce the notation @xmath85 and @xmath86 with single - particle wave functions originating from the target nucleus . at energies below the coulomb barrier ,
the reduced wigner function @xmath87 exhibits rapid oscillations on the window and can take negative values due to quantal effects . in order to smooth out these oscillations ,
we need to approximate the quantity @xmath88 in terms of a smooth function as a function of @xmath89 , which should be consistent with the following two constraints , a possible choice consistent with these requirements is to approximate @xmath88 in terms of a gaussian function . in order to determine the centroid and the width of the gaussian representation , in eq .
( [ a3 ] ) we expand the single - particle wave functions around @xmath92 up to the second order to find , @xmath93 here , the quantities @xmath94 and @xmath95 are given by @xmath96.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in these expressions , the reduced mass density , the current density , the squared - momentum density , and the kinetic energy density are defined as @xmath97 in mean - field calculations , the expectation value of kinetic energy is computed by using either the reduced kinetic energy density @xmath98 or the reduced squared - momentum density @xmath99 , since these quantities satisfy a sum rule relation , @xmath100 we note that the reduced kinetic energy density , @xmath98 , is positive for all @xmath101 values .
however , the reduced squared - momentum density , @xmath99 , can take small negative values in the vicinity of the window below barrier energies . as an example ,
9 shows the quantities @xmath98 and @xmath99 in central collisions of @xmath6zr and @xmath5ca system at a center - of - mass energy of @xmath102 mev and at time @xmath103 s. we observe that the quantity @xmath99 for target as well as projectile can take small negative value in the vicinity of window position @xmath11 .
consequently , the parameter @xmath94 can take negative values .
( solid line ) and @xmath98 ( dashed line ) are plotted versus position @xmath101 in collisions of @xmath5ca + @xmath6zr system at @xmath102 mev and at time @xmath103 s for target and projectile .
the neck position @xmath11 is indicated by an arrow on the figure.,width=302 ] in the gaussian approximation , in order to produce the correct second order taylor expansion , we introduce a new parameter @xmath104 .
when @xmath105 and @xmath106 , we can approximate the quantity @xmath88 in terms of a single gaussian as @xmath107 by taking the fourier transform , we obtain a gaussian form for the reduced wigner function as well , @xmath108.\ ] ] when the quantity @xmath109 , we can write the expansion eq .
( [ eq : fs ] ) as @xmath110 there are many possibilities to approximate @xmath88 in terms of gaussian functions that have the same second order taylor expansion with eq .
( [ eq : fsn ] ) and that are consistent with the two constraints indicated above . we consider a double gaussian approximation according to @xmath111,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which leads to the wigner function given by @xmath112\right.\nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\left.-\exp\left[-\frac{(p-\hbar\beta)^2}{2\hbar^2|\gamma|}\right]\right\}. \label{asd2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] figure 10 shows an illustration of the reduced wigner functions given by eqs .
( [ asd ] ) and ( [ asd2 ] ) by employing the same @xmath95 and the same magnitude of @xmath113 .
we observe that for @xmath114 , the reduced wigner function exhibits a negative tail , which is closely related to the quantal behavior of the wigner function . in the calculations presented in this work , relatively small negative tails in the reduced wigner functions
do not make a significant effect on the semiclassical expressions of the nucleon diffusion and drift coefficients given by eqs .
( [ e1 ] ) and ( [ e4 ] ) .
substituting eq .
( [ asd ] ) and/or ( [ asd2 ] ) for the reduced wigner functions originating from target and projectile into eq .
( [ e1 ] ) , we obtain the nucleon diffusion coefficient as @xmath118 for @xmath119 and @xmath120 , @xmath121 for @xmath122 and @xmath120 , and @xmath123 for @xmath122 and @xmath124 .
the functions @xmath125 and @xmath126 are defined as @xmath127,\ ] ] @xmath128 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the error function is given by @xmath129 employing the formula given in ref.@xcite for the phase space volume @xmath68 on the window , we obtain for following expressions for the nucleon drift coefficient , eq .
( [ e4 ] ) , @xmath130 for @xmath119 and @xmath120 , @xmath131 for @xmath122 and @xmath120 , and @xmath132 for @xmath122 and @xmath124 .
99 s. e. koonin , prog . part
* 4 * , 283 ( 1980 ) .
k. goeke and p .-
reinhard , _ time - dependent hartree - fock and beyond _ ( bad honnef , germany , 1982 ) . c. simenel , d. lacroix , and b. avez , _
quantum many - body dynamics : applications to nuclear reactions _ ,
( vdm verlag , germany , 2010 ) .
j. w. negele , rev .
phys . * 54 * , 913 ( 1982 ) . k. t. r. davies , k. r. s. devi , s. e. koonin , and m. r. strayer , in _ treatise in heavy - ion science _
d. a. bromley ( plenum , new york , 1984 ) , vol .
ph . chomaz , m. colonna and j. randrup , phys . rep . * 389 * , 263 ( 2004 ) . j. randrup and b. remaud , nucl . phys . *
a514 * , 339 ( 1990 ) .
y. abe , s. ayik , p .-
reinhard , and e. suraud , phys . rep . * 275 * , 49 ( 1996 ) .
d. lacroix , s. ayik , and ph .
chomaz , prog .
52 * , 497 ( 2004 ) .
s. ayik , phys . lett . *
b658 * , 174 ( 2008 ) .
s. ayik , k. washiyama , and d. lacroix , phys .
c * 79 * , 054606 ( 2009 ) .
k. washiyama , s. ayik , and d. lacroix , phys .
c * 80 * , 031602(r ) ( 2009 ) .
s. ayik , n. er , o.yilmaz , and a. gokalp , nucl .
phys . a * 812 * , 44 ( 2008 ) .
s. ayik , o. yilmaz , n. er , a. gokalp , and p. ring , phys .
c * 80 * , 034613 ( 2009 ) .
w. nrenberg , phys . lett . *
b53 * , 289 ( 1974 ) .
j. randrup , nucl . phys . *
a307 * , 319 ( 1978 ) ; nucl . phys .
* a327 * , 490 ( 1979 ) ; nucl . phys .
* a383 * , 468 ( 1982 ) . s. chattopadhyay and d. pal , j. phys .
g * 20 * , 357 ( 1994 ) .
k. washiyama and d. lacroix , phys .
c * 78 * , 024610 ( 2008 ) .
kim , t. otsuka , and p. bonche , j. phys .
g * 23 * , 1267 ( 1997 ) .
h. esbensen , a. winther , r. a. broglia , and c. h. dasso , phys .
lett . * 41 * , 296 ( 1978 ) . c. h. dasso , proc . of the la rabida int .
summer school on nuclear physics , p. 398 , eds .
m. lozano and g. madurga ( world scientific , singapore , 1985 ) . m. w. guidry , r. donangelo , j. o. rasmussen , and m. s. hussein , phys .
c * 36 * , 609 ( 1987 ) . c. h. dasso and r. donangelo , phys .
b276 * , 1 ( 1992 ) .
d. galetti , a. eiras , f. f. desouzacruz , j. r. marinelli , and m. m. w. demoraes , phys .
c * 48 * , 3131 ( 1993 ) .
s. ayik , b. yilmaz , and d. lacroix , phys .
c * 81 * , 034605 ( 2010 ) .
h. freiesleben and j. v. kratz , phys . rep . *
106 * , 1 ( 1984 ) .
g. g. adamian , a. k. nasirov , n. v. antonenko , and r. v. jolos , phys .
* 25 * , 583 ( 1994 ) . | nucleon drift and diffusion mechanisms in central collisions of asymmetric heavy - ions at near - barrier energies are investigated in the framework of a stochastic mean - field approach .
expressions for diffusion and drift coefficients for nucleon transfer deduced from the stochastic mean - field approach in the semiclassical approximation have similar forms familiar from the phenomenological nucleon exchange model .
the variance of fragment mass distribution agrees with the empirical formula @xmath0 .
the comparison with the time - dependent hartree - fock calculations shows that , below barrier energies , the drift coefficient in the semiclassical approximation underestimates the mean number of nucleon transfer obtained in the quantal framework .
motion of the window in the dinuclear system has a significant effect on the nucleon transfer in asymmetric collisions . |
paradigm changes in physics are often accompanied by a transformation of language and a hardening of distinctions .
thus the emphasis on acceleration as the second time derivative of displacement _ in teaching newtonian dynamics _ has hardened @xcite , even as the concept of relativistic mass and inertial frame acceleration is being slowly replaced by lorentz covariant definitions of force and acceleration _ in the teaching of special relativity _ @xcite .
the intent of this note is to assist the second process by showing that : ( i ) introduction of three relativistic time - parameterizations , _ including the newtonian one _ , provides a natural bridge for introductory physics students to some deep truths about relativistic space - time before the comparatively abstract concept of lorentz transforms need be introduced , and ( ii ) there are two relativistic alternatives to the popular inertial - frame perspective , which perspective sometimes makes velocity - dependent mass a tempting simplification @xcite , questions the special - relativistic treatability of acceleration @xcite , and implies that travelers as well as spectators are _ bound _ by inertial velocity light - speed limits @xcite .
we also show why students here have said that `` without the 82 nano - roddenberry speed - limit , and with the right vehicle , it s amazing how little of my time it would take for me to get from point a to point b ! ''
we consider in this paper only one - dimensional constant acceleration , and only observers using the same inertial frame spatial coordinate with which to measure change of position @xmath1 .
we further use the lorentz - invariant proper acceleration @xmath2 for describing traveler motion , so that the relativistic work - energy theorem gives us @xmath3 , independent of the time - parameterization in use . here
m is the rest mass of our accelerated object , _ relativistic energy factor _
@xmath4 is defined dynamically as the accelerated object s total energy in units of the rest energy @xmath5 , and @xmath6 is the speed of light .
consider first the task of assigning to each point on the world line of an accelerated traveler 3 time parameters , namely @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 , referring respectively to inertial , newtonian , and traveler time - maps ( or kinematics ) .
we denote the velocities corresponding to these time maps , respectively , as @xmath10 , @xmath11 , and @xmath12 .
the time maps can be most simply specified , using the work - energy theorem above , by determining the dependence of @xmath4 on the velocities @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 . from the lorentz expression for @xmath4 in terms of relativistic inertial velocity @xmath13 ,
the @xmath16 relationship between inertial and 4-vector velocities , and the familiar newtonian expression for kinetic energy @xmath17 , one can show that @xmath18 .
substitution into the work - energy equation , @xmath19 , yields a _ velocity - distance equation _
, like the familiar newtonian @xmath20 , for _ each _ of the 3 kinematics . taking the time derivative of this displacement equation _ in each of the three kinematics _ yields a relationship between the velocities and time and acceleration . after defining for the traveler kinematic the _ hyperbolic velocity angle _
@xmath21 which is additive under lorentz transform @xcite , and recalling for the inertial kinematic that 4-velocity @xmath15 can be expressed in terms of inertial velocity @xmath13 , these _ velocity - time equations _ can be put into the form @xmath22 . for a fuller comparison ,
the equations used for treating constant acceleration , force , and momentum conservation in introductory physics are summarized in this way in table i , while the exact equations for application of all three kinematics to constant acceleration problems are listed in table ii .
note that , except for a correction to the momentum equation needed at high velocity , namely that momentum @xmath23 becomes @xmath24 , the introductory physics equations for one - dimensional motion remain exact at arbitrarily high speed , even if other velocities and times have to be calculated to provide information on the kinematic variables ( e.g. physical clocks ) of interest . as in introductory physics ,
armed with a displacement and a velocity equation for our kinematic and any three of the 5 variables ( initial / final velocity , time elapsed , distance traveled , and constant acceleration ) , we can solve for the other two .
pairs _ for dealing with this task for _ each _ of the 10 types of initial condition definable within _ each _ of the 3 kinematics are listed in table iii .
if the 3 independent variables for a particular problem include velocities from different kinematics , they can be easily converted to the kinematic of choice using the expressions above for @xmath4 and the fact that @xmath25 .
if time - elapsed values from more than one kinematic are included in the initial inputs , then the equality above _ between _ velocity - time expressions can be used , at least numerically , to find a solution within the kinematic of choice .
of course , once the solution for a particular kinematic is in hand , these same equations allow the 4 velocities and 2 times associated with the other kinematics to be calculated as well . thus for three input variables one now gets 8 quantities of potential interest , instead of only two !
all of the foregoing requires no knowledge of lorentz transforms , since the inertial frame for measuring distance traveled was fixed . of course , once such transformations are understood , it is easy to show other things .
for example , since the spatial component of the velocity 4-vector is @xmath26 , while its time component is @xmath27 , it is easy to show that @xmath2 is the magnitude of the 4-vector acceleration ( i.e. the proper time @xmath9 derivative of the 4-vector velocity ) , and hence is lorentz invariant as well as independent of kinematic .
we ve also found it to be useful ( and enjoyable ) in practice to associate different units with the velocities and times in different kinematics . in relativistic problems we are often dealing with distances on the scale of lightyears , and time on the scale of years , so we often speak of inertial time @xmath28 in `` iyears '' , newtonian time in year or whatever mks units are handy , and traveler time @xmath29 in `` tyears '' .
likewise , we usually speak of inertial velocities @xmath13 in fractional units of the speed of light ( e.g. @xmath30 ) , while leaving newtonian velocities in whatever units fit the problem
. traveler velocities @xmath15 are most interesting of all , since they exceed the speed of light even more enthusiastically than newtonian velocities do ( cf .
the favorite strategy here , among students i ve discussed this with , has been to define one lightyear per year of traveler velocity as 1 roddenberry or [ rb ] , in tribute to gene roddenberry , the producer of the original startrek television series whose offspring continue to ignore the light speed limit as well as the way that space time is put together at high speed .
the approach described here might help a bit , in that `` warp speeds '' ( which still require that one somehow drops out of our space - time if one is to effect such rapid travel withou inertial effects to passengers _ and _ `` temporal effects '' to their colleages at home @xcite ) at least can now be mapped to traveler - frame speeds , rather than to inertial - frame speeds greater than the speed of light ( which given the fabric of spacetime make no sense at all ) .
we illustrate with an example .
describe time - elapsed values and final velocities for a space dragster accelerating from rest at @xmath31 \approx 1.03 [ ly / yr^{2}]$ ] over a distance of 4 lightyears [ ly ] . using only the newtonian equations for constant acceleration
, one can infer ( table iii , row 6 , column 2 ) that our dragster will reach a _ final newtonian velocity _ of @xmath32 $ ] in the _ newtonian time _ of @xmath33 $ ] .
the solution is thus put in hand , and only simple conversion to other kinematics ( cf .
table ii ) remains !
one obtains _ inertial time _
@xmath34 $ ] using @xmath35 and @xmath36 .
this also gives _ final traveler speed _
@xmath37 $ ] .
one obtains _ traveler time _
@xmath38 $ ] given that @xmath39 $ ] and @xmath40 .
finally , given @xmath41 where @xmath42 , it follows that the _ final inertial velocity _ @xmath43 $ ] .
this is only one example .
the rather simple equations of newtonian constant acceleration in one dimension allow one to solve a wide array of types of problems , to which we can now add many relativistic problems as well .
interactive worksheets and example problems for all of the 30 cases listed in table 3 are being assembled on the web at * http://newton.umsl.edu/ run*. in conclusion , this three - kinematic approach allows one to look at and solve some relativistic constant - acceleration problems in a new way .
in particular , it puts both the newtonian equations for constant acceleration and the traveler / proper time equations into a new light as fully alternative relativistic kinematics , even if the former remains self - consistent only in one spatial dimension .
moreover , it seems to provide more new answers per problem ( i.e. 6 ) , than there are new concepts required for a post - introductory physics student to apply and understand them .
thanks to my colleagues in the department of physics and astronomy at the university of missouri in st .
louis , and to the students in my modern physics classes for both their enthusiasm and their patience .
this paper was prepared with support of the u.s .
department of energy grant no .
de - fg02 - 92ch10499 . | when introducing special relativity , an elegant connection to familiar rules governing galilean constant acceleration can be made , by describing first the discovery at high speeds that the clocks ( as well as odometers ) of different travelers may proceed at different rates .
one may then show how to parameterize any given interval of constant acceleration with _ either _ : newtonian ( low - velocity approximation ) time , inertial relativistic ( unaccelerated observer ) time , or traveler proper ( accelerated observer ) time , by defining separate velocities for each of these three kinematics as well .
kinematic invariance remains intact for proper acceleration since @xmath0 .
this approach allows students to solve relativistic constant acceleration problems _ with the newtonian equations _
! it also points up the self - contained and special nature of the accelerated - observer kinematic , with its frame - invariant time , 4-vector velocities which in traveler terms exceed newtonian values and the speed of light , and of course relativistic momentum conservation . ; umstl - cme-951101pf ; gr - qc/9512012 |
it has been 20 years since the discovery of the nonthermal radio filaments ( nrfs ) associated with the galactic center arc was first reported ( yusef - zadeh , morris , & chance 1984 ) .
these observations showed evidence of linear , magnetized features running perpendicular to the galactic plane .
a number of nrfs with similar characteristics to the prototype nrfs have been discovered in the intervening years ( yusef - zadeh 2003 and references therein ) .
several models have suggested that the filaments trace the illuminated component of a large - scale poloidal magnetic field pervasive throughout the galactic center region .
however , the presence of a number of filaments oriented at large angles to the normal to the galactic plane does not support the above interpretation and indicates a different origin .
unlike most models that predict a global , static geometry of the magnetic field around the galactic center , the model described here argues for a local origin . in the proposed picture ,
the nrfs originate in star - forming regions .
the filaments behave like jets extracting mass and energy from embedded young stars or clusters of stars as the jets propagate in a dense ism of the galactic center region .
a more detailed account of this model will be given elsewhere .
recent observations of a number of radio filaments found in the galactic center region show a wide range of morphological structures ( nord et al . 2003 ; yusef - zadeh , hewitt , & cotton 2004 ) .
the new images show structures that suggest nrfs are interacting with their surrounding medium as described here briefly : ( i ) the distortion of the filaments from a straight geometry ; ( ii ) sub - filamentation at the point where the filaments are most distorted ; ( iii ) an increase in the surface brightness in the middle of the filaments ; ( iv ) a gentle curvature and a widening of the filaments ; ( v ) gaps along the length of the filaments .
the interaction hypothesis implies the flow of high velocity nonthermal material along the filaments .
this interpretation is in contrast to earlier models in which the strong preexisting organized magnetic field lines are illuminated by relativistic particles propagating at the alfvn speed .
many of the morphological characteristics described above have also been observed in fr i sources .
the presumably supersonic and super - alfvnic jets of fr i sources are known to propagate and interact with a denser material of their ambient medium ( ferrari 1998 ) .
for example , the decollimation of some of the filaments and their gentle curvature are analogous to the morphology of bent jets , which has been interpreted in terms of collisions with clouds .
the widening of one of the isolated nrfs is shown in figure 1 [ right panel ] as the filament n2 runs almost perpendicular to the galactic plane ; this widening could be explained either by the negative pressure gradient expected in the direction away from the galactic plane or by entrainment of ambient material into the jet .
another example is the lack of bright shocked emission from a hot spot at the terminus of the filament ; this can be interpreted in terms of the deceleration of light jets by the surrounding medium , in similar fashion to fr i sources .
yet another example is the brightness of many nrfs peaking in the middle of the filaments . in the context of the jet model ,
the location of the enhanced surface brightness is where the jet changes its course as a result of an encounter with an obstacle ; this in turn may lead to shocks , particle acceleration , and a change in the spectral and magnetic properties ( clarke , burns , & feigelson 1986 ) .
lastly , the bundles of filaments that make up the arc and sgr c are examples in which the filaments broaden and appear more diffuse with a steeper spectral index in the direction away from the galactic plane ( tsuboi et al .
1986 ) . in analogy with fr
i jets , we believe that these so - called lobes ( see fig . 1 , left panel ) are produced when jets with a low internal - to - ambient density ratio get decelerated and disrupted as they propagate away from the galactic plane ( see fig .
9a of ferrari 1998 ) . | protostellar sources in star forming regions are responsible for driving jets with flow velocities ranging between 300 and 400 km s@xmath0 .
this class of jets consists of highly collimated outflows which include thermal knots with number densities estimated to be greater than that of their ambient medium .
on the other hand , extragalactic fr i jets consist of light fluid with low mach number burrowing through a denser medium as the magnetized jets radiate nonthermal emission . both protostellar and extragalactic jets are believed to be launched by accretion disks .
here we consider a jet model in which the characteristics common to both protostellar and extragalactic jets are used to explain the origin of nonthermal filaments in the galactic center region .
we argue that these filaments are analogous to fr i extragalactic sources but are launched by embedded young stars or clusters of stars in star - forming regions . |
in spite of intensive research over the past decade the nature of the metallic state in low - dimensional strongly correlated materials is still poorly understood .
widely studied materials include cuprate and organic superconductors@xcite .
many of the properties of the cuprates can not be understood within the fermi liquid picture that has so successfully described conventional metals @xcite .
although some properties of the quasi - two - dimensional molecular crystals , @xmath3-(bedt - ttf)@xmath4x ( reference@xcite ) and the quasi - one - dimensional bechgaard salts@xcite ( tmtsf)@xmath0x can be explained within a fermi liquid framework others can not .
a particular challenge is understanding the dependence of the magnetoresistance of the bechgaard salts on the direction of the magnetic field , especially ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath5 under pressures of about 10 kbar @xcite .
the different angular - dependent magnetoresistance effects in quasi - one - dimensional metals are known as the danner @xcite , magic angle ( or lebed ) @xcite , and third angular effects@xcite , depending on whether the magnetic field is rotated in the @xmath6 , @xmath7 , or @xmath8 plane , respectively .
( the most- and least - conducting directions are the @xmath9 and @xmath10 axes , respectively ) .
the magic angle effect is the most poorly understood of these effects and is the focus of this paper .
if @xmath11 is the angle between the magnetic field and the @xmath10 axis then at the `` magic angles '' given by @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the lattice constants in the @xmath15 and @xmath16 directions , lebed predicted dips in the threshold field for formation of a field - induced spin - density - wave @xcite . although these dips are not observed @xcite , features are seen , mostly at @xmath17 in the torque @xcite and in all components of the resistance @xcite . a wide range of physical mechanisms
have been proposed to explain these effects including commensurability effects changing the electron - electron scattering rate @xcite , semi - classical transport @xcite , complicated band structures @xcite , hot spots on the fermi surface @xcite , cold spots on the fermi surface @xcite , electron - electron interactions @xcite , non - fermi liquid effects @xcite , and magnetic field induced changes in effective dimensionality @xcite .
the properties of ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath5 at 10 kbar are particularly difficult to understand .
for example , when the magnetic field is perpendicular to the current direction the magnetoresistance is smaller than when it is parallel , the opposite of what one observes in ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath18 and in conventional metals .
recently , the temperature dependence of the magnetoresistance when the field direction was fixed at the first magic angle was measured @xcite .
it was found to be non - monotonic : as the temperature decreased down to @xmath19 , the magnetoresistance decreased , it increased until @xmath20 , and then decreased .
it has recently been proposed that these two temperatures actually represent phase transitions between metallic and insulating phases @xcite .
the magnetoresistance of the quasi - two - dimensional metal @xmath21-(bedt - ttf)@xmath4mhg(scn)@xmath2 [ m = k , rb , tl ] also exhibits unusual temperature and angular dependence @xcite .
the purpose of this paper is to clarify what properties of the magic angle effects can only be explained within a non - fermi liquid framework by seeing what effects can be explained within fermi liquid theory .
the interlayer magnetoresistance is calculated within the framework of semi - classical transport theory .
it is found that if one takes into account the finite bandwith along the most - conducting direction then dips in the magnetoresistance are observed for @xmath22@xcite .
furthermore , if one assumes a simple fermi liquid form for the temperature dependence of the scattering rate then at the magic angles the interlayer magnetoresistance does have a non - monotonic temperature dependence .
hence , one should be cautious about associating maxima and minima in the temperature dependence with metal - insulator transitions .
however , the results obtained gives a poor description of the observed properties when the field is close to the @xmath23-axis and of the resistivity within the layers .
if the electronic dispersion relation is @xmath24 then the electronic group velocity perpendicular to the layers is @xmath25 the interlayer conductivity can be calculated by solving the boltzmann equation in the relaxation time approximation leading to chambers formula @xcite @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the fermi function and @xmath28 is the scattering time which is assumed to be the same at all points on the fermi surface .
@xmath29 is the electron velocity averaged over its trajectories on the fermi surface , @xmath30 where @xmath31 .
the time dependence of the wave vector @xmath32 is found by integrating the semi - classical equation of motion @xmath33 if the temperature is sufficiently low that @xmath34 then @xmath35 in equation ( [ eq : chambers ] ) can be replaced by a delta function at the fermi energy and equation ( [ eq : chambers ] ) becomes @xmath36 in the tight binding approximation the dispersion relation in an orthorhombic crystal can be written as @xmath37 where @xmath38 and @xmath39 are the inter - site hopping integrals along the different crystal axes . in the bechgaard salts , @xmath40
, the dispersion along the chains can be linearized giving @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the fermi velocity and @xmath43 is the fermi wave vector .
this linear dispersion has been used in a number of papers on the magic angle effect @xcite .
if one solves for the interlayer conductivity within semi - classical transport theory one obtains @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the frequency at which an electron traverses the brillouin zone in the @xmath46-direction when the field is parallel to the @xmath47-axis .
clearly this is a smoothly varying function of @xmath11 and does not exhibit any magic angle effects .
we now show that if the full nonlinear dispersion ( [ dispersion ] ) is used then one does obtain magic angle effects .
we will re - derive a result obtained earlier by maki @xcite with a view to elucidating the physics in the process .
the group velocity for the dispersion relation ( [ dispersion ] ) is @xmath48 the rate of change of the wave vector @xmath49 , in a magnetic field in the @xmath23-@xmath10 plane , @xmath50 , is given by ( [ prop ] ) , @xmath51 where terms involving @xmath52 have been neglected .
this is valid provided @xmath53 .
hence , the results below will not be valid as @xmath54 . in order to calculate the @xmath55-component of the velocity one needs to obtain @xmath56 , which equation ( [ ktime]c ) shows is determined by @xmath57 . to zero - th order in @xmath58 , @xmath59 . integrating equation ( [ ktime]b ) then gives @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the frequency at which an the electron traverses the brillouin zone in the direction of the @xmath62-axis . substituting this into equation ( [ ktime]a ) and integrating gives , to first order in @xmath63 , @xmath64 we obtain @xmath65 by using equation ( [ ktime]c ) and substituting in ( [ kxlebed ] ) , giving @xmath66 , \ ] ] where we have used trigonometric identities to expand @xmath67 .
if we take a linear dispersion relation , the second term in ( [ wavevectlebed ] ) will equal zero and we are left with @xmath68 @xmath69 , where we have assumed that at @xmath70 , the wave vector in the x - direction ( @xmath71 ) is equal to @xmath72 .
now to first order in @xmath73 @xmath74 .
\label{wavevectlebed2}\ ] ] integrating this we obtain @xmath75 where @xmath76 and @xmath77 substitution of ( [ kzt ] ) into the @xmath55-component of the velocity gives @xmath78 where @xmath79 , @xmath80 . the interlayer conductivity given by ( [ chambers2 ] ) can then be written in the form @xmath81 we now expand equation ( [ velbarlebed ] ) using trigonometric identies and substitute the bessel generating functions to obtain @xmath82 \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
+ \cos \left ( ck_{z}(0)+{\omega _ { c}\over \omega _ { b } } \phi ^{'}\right ) \left [ 2\sum _ { k=0}^{\infty } j_{2k+1}(\gamma _ { 0 } \tan \theta ) \sin ( ( 2k+1)(\phi -\phi ^{'}))\right ] \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath83 is obtained by setting @xmath84 . substituting these expressions into equation ( [ condlebed ] ) and performing the integrals over @xmath85 , @xmath86 and @xmath87 the final expression for the conductivity becomes @xmath88 \ , \label{condlebedfinal}\ ] ] where @xmath89 is the interlayer conductivity in zero field .
note that for fixed @xmath90 and @xmath91 @xmath92 maki @xcite obtained a similar result , although he included the corrections to @xmath93 and @xmath94 to next order in @xmath95 .
this raises the general question of to what order in @xmath63 is the above expression for @xmath96 valid .
we only calculated @xmath97 to first order in @xmath63 .
strictly speaking , this means that ( [ condlebedfinal ] ) is valid to second order in @xmath63 .
however , we anticipate that a general solution for @xmath98 will be of the form @xmath99 where @xmath100 is of order @xmath101 .
this means that the coefficients in ( [ condlebedfinal ] ) for @xmath102 will change but be of the same order .
the angular dependence of the interlayer resistivity given by equation ( [ condlebedfinal ] ) is shown in figure [ p4 - 1 ] for several parameter values .
dips occur at the `` magic angles '' given by @xmath103 or @xmath104 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are lattice constants .
the size of the dip at the @xmath105-th magic angle , compared the background magnetoresistance will be of order @xmath106 the size of the dips is determined by the parameter @xmath107 , defined by ( [ ga1 ] ) , which is determined by the geometry of the fermi surface .
note that if @xmath108 , ( [ condlebedfinal ] ) reduces to ( [ nomagicangles ] ) .
this is because the limit @xmath109 corresponds to taking a linear dispersion relation .
if @xmath110 then the dips will decrease in magnitude rapidly with increasing @xmath105 .
for example if @xmath111 then the @xmath112 feature will be five orders of magnitude smaller than the @xmath113 feature .
note that when @xmath105 becomes sufficiently large this will no longer be valid because @xmath114 .
we now consider what is a realistic value for @xmath115 for the ( tmtsf)@xmath0x materials .
if we look at the the form of @xmath115 in equation ( [ ga1 ] ) we note that the factor @xmath116 equals the parameter @xmath117 which determines the periodicity of the danner oscillations @xcite . for (
tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath18 it was estimated to be 0.24 .
the lattice constants for ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath5 are @xmath118 , @xmath119 and @xmath120 , while for ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath18 , @xmath121 is twice as large due to anion ordering @xcite .
the @xmath122 term depends on the band filling . at three - quarter filling @xmath123 , and @xmath124 .
this gives a value for @xmath125 and @xmath126 .
note that for half - filling @xmath127 , and thus @xmath128 and there will be no magic angle effects unless we solve the semi - classical equations to higher order in @xmath58 .
figure [ p4 - 1 ] is qualitatively similar to experimental results for ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath129 at ambient pressure @xcite and at 6.0 kbar @xcite and ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath5 at 6.0 kbar ( 0.3 k and 4 t ) @xcite .
a small difference is that the experimental data shows a small dip near @xmath130 , whereas the theoretical curve shows no such dip .
it is quite possible that the small dips can be explained within semi - classical transport theory if one includes the effect of a finite @xmath131 in the solution of the semi - classical transport equations .
an analogous effect occurs when the field is rotated in the @xmath6 plane : for coherent interlayer transport with finite @xmath131 a peak in the angular - dependent magnetoresistance occurs when the field is parallel to the @xmath9 axis @xcite .
the angular dependence of the interlayer magnetoresistance of ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath5 at pressures of about 10 kbar is quite different from that shown in figure [ p4 - 1 ] at fields less than one tesla the angular dependence is similar to that given by eqn .
( [ nomagicangles ] ) .
however , above one tesla , @xmath132 and so a large dip is observed near @xmath130 and at @xmath130 the in - field resistance is comparable to the zero - field resistance @xcite . a number of theoretical papers @xcite have predicted effects when @xmath133 where @xmath134 is fraction .
in contrast , the model considered here only gives effects for @xmath135 .
a review of the experimental literature shows that the only reproducible fractional features seen have been in ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath18 at @xmath136 3/2 and 5/2 @xcite .
this can be explained within the framework considered here . if ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath18 is slowly cooled anion ordering occurs and the lattice constant in the @xmath23 direction doubles so in ( [ magicangle ] ) @xmath121 should be replaced by @xmath137 . however ,
if a sample which is not completely anion ordered it will produce features at angles corresponding to half - integers for a fully anion - ordered sample .
suppose that the field direction is fixed at a magic angle and the temperature ( and thus the scattering time @xmath28 ) is varied .
_ the first magic angle _ @xmath138 . setting @xmath139 and using the fact that @xmath140 to take just the first term in the series , i.e. @xmath141 , the conductivity is @xmath142 \ , \label{simpsig2}\ ] ] where @xmath143 represents the first magic angle and @xmath144 , where @xmath145 is the ratio of the zero field conductivity to @xmath146 . a plot of interlayer resistivity verses @xmath147 is shown in figure [ p4 - 2 ] for different values of @xmath148 .
the interlayer resistivity is a non - monotonic function of @xmath149 it will be seen below that this leads to non - monotonic temperature dependence .
we now find for what values of @xmath146 the maxima and minima seen in figure [ p4 - 2 ] occur .
finding the extrema of equation ( [ simpsig2 ] ) as a function of @xmath146 gives that the minimun occurs when @xmath150 and the maximum occurs when @xmath151 if @xmath152 , then the maximum will only be observed at sufficiently high fields and in high purity samples . _ the second magic angle _ @xmath153 . to obtain the interlayer conductivity for the second magic angle then a similar argument to that given above
leads to @xmath154 , \ ] ] where we have set @xmath155 and @xmath156 is the @xmath157 magic angle . for small @xmath107 , the minima is again given by @xmath158 . to find the maxima we expand the first two terms in ( [ magicang2sig ] ) to fourth order in @xmath159 the maxima occurs when @xmath160 since this is smaller than ( [ max ] ) by a factor of @xmath161 , in order to see this maximum even higher fields and lower temperatures will be required than for the maximum associated with the first magic angle .
_ conductivity as @xmath162 : _ we can expand the term @xmath163 in the summation in ( [ condlebedfinal ] ) to second order in @xmath164 to obtain @xmath165 where @xmath166 and @xmath167 for @xmath168 .
substitution of this into the conductivity gives @xmath169 \ .\ ] ] this can be simplified using the identities @xmath170 to give @xmath171 the resistivity is quadratic in field as for the case of a linear dispersion , but the co - efficient is smaller .
this is consistent with figure [ p4 - 1 ] which shows that the resistivity near @xmath172 does decrease with increasing @xmath107 .
this field dependence is quite different to what is observed in the ( tmtsf)@xmath0x materials . for ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath129 at 6.0 kbar @xcite a linear field dependence
is observed at high fields . in ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath5 at pressures from 6 to 10 kbar
the resistivity saturates as the field increases @xcite . however , caution is in order because derivation of the quadratic dependence involved assuming that @xmath173 and so we only expect a quadratic dependence slightly away from @xmath172 or in the limit @xmath174 .
_ fermi liquid model for the temperature dependence : _ we now consider a specific model for the temperature dependence of the scattering time @xmath146 . in a fermi liquid the scattering rate , at temperatures
much less than the fermi temperature , has a temperature dependence of the form @xcite @xmath175 where the first term is due to impurity scattering and the second is due to electron - electron scattering . using this expression for @xmath146 in equation ( [ simpsig2 ] ) we can now plot the temperature dependence of the resistivity .
this is shown in figure [ p4 - 3 ] for various values of @xmath176 .
the resistivity is not a monotonic function of temperature but has a minimum when @xmath177 .
if the field is sufficiently high there is also a maximum . using ( [ fl ] )
we see that the minimum occurs at a temperature @xmath178 if @xmath179 then ( [ max ] ) implies @xmath180 we are unaware of any measurements of the temperature dependence of the interlayer magnetoresistance of ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath18 at the magic angles .
although the temperature dependence at the @xmath181 magic angle shown in figure [ p4 - 3 ] is similar to that reported in ref .
for the _ intralayer _ resistance of ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath1 at 9 kbar , the observed temperature dependence of the interlayer magnetoresistance is different @xcite .
it depends weakly on the temperature from 15 k down to about 3 k and then decreases . the temperature dependence shown in figure [
p4 - 3 ] for @xmath182 i.e. , as the magnetic field is aligned with the @xmath183 axis the temperature dependence is qualitatively similar to that observed in ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath18 at ambient pressure @xcite .
again , qualitatively very different behavior was observed @xcite in ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath1 at 10 kbar .
there it was found that the in - field resistance had a temperature dependence similar to the zero - field resistance .
zheleznyak and yakovenko have given a heuristic argument as to the origin of the maximum and minimum temperatures seen in the intralayer resistance in ref .
, suggesting that metal - insulator and insulator - metal phase transitions occur as the temperature passes through these values @xcite .
they argue that @xmath184 and @xmath185 which is independent of field . above @xmath19
the system is a two - dimensional metal .
below @xmath19 , a magnetic field causes the electron motion in the @xmath23 direction to be quantized resulting in a one - dimensional dispersion and correlations producing insulating behavior . below @xmath186 ,
the interlayer coupling becomes important and metallic behavior is recovered .
in contrast we find that @xmath187 and @xmath186 are given by ( [ tmin ] ) and ( [ tmax ] ) , respectively , and both scale with @xmath188 .
careful measurements should be able to distinguish between these two different field dependences .
this paper only considers the interlayer resistivity @xmath189 , whereas magic angle effects are also seen experimentally in the intralayer resistivity @xmath190 .
maki pointed out that @xcite the semi - classical theory will only give resonances in @xmath190 of order @xmath191 whereas they are observed to be much larger . a possible way around this problem
is that experiments that are meant to measure @xmath190 may actually be measuring some of @xmath189 .
this is because in highly anisotropic metals it is difficult to arrange the contacts and current path so it lies completely within the layers .
this potential problem increases the motivation to make thin film samples of these metals .
it has been shown that within semi - classical transport theory a nonlinear dispersion parallel to the chains is necessary to produce dips in the interlayer magnetoresistance at integer magic angles .
if the field direction is fixed at one of the magic angles then one observes both minima and maxima in the temperature dependence of the interlayer magnetoresistance .
this arises from the temperature dependence of the scattering rate . since these maxima and minima can exist within a fermi liquid model one should be cautious about associating them with non - fermi liquid behaviour or metal - insulator transitions . on the other hand , although the fermi liquid model considered here gives a good description of many of the properties of ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath1 at pressures from 6 to 8 kbar and of ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath2 it gives a poor description of their properties when the field is parallel to the layers and of the intralayer transport .
qualitatively very different behavior is observed in ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath1 at pressures of about 10 kbar ; explaining it remains a considerable theoretical challenge .
this work was supported by the australian research council .
we thank p.m. chaikin and m.j .
naughton for very helpful discussions .
we also thank p.m. chaikin for sending us unpublished experimental data .
strong , d. g. clarke , and p. w. anderson , phys .
* 73 * , 1007 ( 1994 ) ; d. g. clarke and s. p. strong , adv . phys . * 46 * , 545 ( 1997 ) ; d. g. clarke , s. p. strong , p. m. chaikin and e. i. chashechkina , science * 279 * , 2071 ( 1998 ) .
l. p. gorkov , j. phys .
i. france * 6 * , 1697 , ( 1996 ) ; l. p. gorkov and m. mochena , phys . rev .
b. * 57 * , 6206 ( 1998 ) . in a quasi - two - dimensional system
there are logarithmic corrections to ( [ fl ] ) . however , such corrections have no qualitative effect on the results presented here .
g. m. danner , n. p. ong , and p. m. chaikin , phys .
* 78 * , 983 ( 1997 ) . at low temperatures
@xmath189 reaches a maximum value , contrary to figure [ p4 - 3 ] .
however , this maximum can be interpreted as due to the presence of a high field superconducting state [ m. j. naughton , i. j. lee , g. m. danner , and p. m. chaikin , synth .
metals * 85 * , 1481 ( 1997 ) ] . | the interlayer magnetoresistance of a quasi - one - dimensional fermi liquid is considered for the case of a magnetic field that is rotated within the plane perpendicular to the most - conducting direction . within semi - classical transport theory dips in the magnetoresistance occur at integer `` magic angles '' only when the electronic dispersion parallel to chains is nonlinear .
if the field direction is fixed at one of the magic angles and the temperature is varied then the resulting variation of the scattering rate can lead to a non - monotonic variation of the interlayer magnetoresistance with temperature .
although the model considered here gives a good description of some of the properties of the bechgaard salts , ( tmtsf)@xmath0pf@xmath1 for pressures less than 8 kbar and ( tmtsf)@xmath0clo@xmath2 it gives a poor description of their properties when the field is parallel to the layers and of the intralayer transport . |
all our description of objects is represented by propositions .
the use of propositions is not a matter of our choice .
in contrast , it is a necessity which is behind each of our attempts to learn something new about nature and to communicate this knowledge with others . it is a necessity which we follow constantly and without any intention and it seems that there is no way to avoid it even if the phenomena to be described and to be understood are highly counterintuitive and distinct from both our everyday experience and the classical world view .
one may even say that there is no need to avoid it .
the reason is that the only way we are able to understand any phenomena in nature , including quantum phenomena , is exclusively through the epistemological structure of classical physics and everyday experience .
bohr ( 1949 ) emphasized that how far the [ quantum ] phenomena transcend the scope of classical physical explanation , the account of all evidence must be expressed in classical terms .
the argument is simply that by the word experiment we refer to a situation where we can tell others what we have done and what we have learned and that , therefore , the account of the experimental arrangement and the result of observation must be expressed in unambiguous language with suitable application of the terminology of classical physics . .
von weizscker ( 1974 ) emphasized that the understanding of new physical theories will also be given in language : " this verbalized language must be the language spoken by those physicists who do not know yet the theory we are telling them .
the language used in order to explain a theory which we propose in mathematical form is the language which has been existed before the theory . on the other hand , it is not self - evident that this language has a clear meaning at all , because if it had a completely clear meaning probable the new theory would not be needed
. thus it may happen that by applying our new formalism to experience - an application made possible by our existing language - we may tacitly or explicitly change the rules of this very language . rigorously speaking a system is nothing else than a construct based on a complete list of propositions together with their truth values .
the propositions from the list could be ( 1 ) the velocity of the object is @xmath1 or ( 2 ) the position of the object is @xmath2 and could be associated both to classical and to quantum objects . yet
, there is an important difference between the two cases . from the theorems of bell ( 1964 ) and of kochen and specker ( 1967 )
we know that for a quantum system one can not assert definite ( noncontextual ) truth values to all conceivable propositions simultaneously .
for example , if the proposition ( 1 ) above is a definite proposition , then the proposition ( 2 ) must necessarily be completely indefinite and vice versa .
the two propositions are mutually exclusive .
this is a specific case of quantum complementarity .
therefore , in an attempt to describe quantum phenomena we are unavoidably put in the following situation . on one hand
the epistemological structure applied has to be inherited from the classical physics : the description of a quantum system has to be represented by the propositions which are used in the description of a classical system , and on the other hand , those propositions can not be assigned to a quantum system simultaneously .
now , a natural question arises : how to join these two , seemingly inconsistent , requirements ?
we suggest to use the concept of `` knowledge '' or `` information '' .
then even in situations where we can not assert simultaneously definite truth - values to mutually exclusive propositions we can assert measures of information about their truth values .
the structure of the theory including the description of the time evolution can then be expressed in terms of measures of information . to us
this seems to be a change with the lowest possible `` costs '' in the epistemological structure of classical physics . and
since some costs are unavoidable anyway we believe that the information - theoretical formulation of quantum physics leads to the easiest " understanding of the theory . from the point of view that the information content of a quantum system
is fundamentally limited we will discuss precisely the empirical significance of the terms involved in formulating quantum theory , particularly the notion of a quantum state .
however we are aware of the possibility that this might not carry the same degree of intuitive appeal for everyone .
it is clear that it may be matter of taste whether one accepts the suggested concepts and principles as self - evident as we do or not .
if not , then one may turn the reasoning around and , following our approach in ( brukner and zeilinger , 1999 ; brukner _ et al .
_ 2001 ) , argue for the validity of the statements given in the paper on the basis of known features of quantum physics .
the conceptual groundwork for the ideas presented here has been prepared most notably by von bohr ( 1958 ) , weizscker ( 1958 ) and wheeler ( 1983 ) .
in contrast to those other authors who look for deterministic mechanisms hidden behind the observed facts , these authors attempt to understand the structure of quantum theory as a necessity for extracting whatever meaning from the data of observations . in recent years several different ideas were put forward suggesting that information can help us to learn more about the foundations of quantum physics .
the foundations of quantum mechanics are interpreted in the light of quantum information ( fuchs , 2001 ; 2002 , caves _ et al .
_ , 2001a ; 2001b ) .
it was also suggested how to reduce quantum theory to few statements of physical significance by generalizing and extending classical probability theory ( hardy , 2001a ; 2001b ) . in another approach
it was shown how certain elements of the structure of quantum theory emerge from looking for invariants of probabilistic observations assuming that any newly gained information shall lead to more accurate knowledge of these invariants ( summhammer , 1988 ; 1994 ; 2000 ; 2001 ) .
one of the most distinct features of quantum physics with respect to classical physics is that prediction with certainty of individual outcomes is only possible for a very limited class of experiments .
such a prediction is equivalent to saying that the corresponding propositions have definite truth values . for all other ( complementary ) propositions the truth values are necessarily indefinite .
we suggest this to be a consequence of the feature that _ the information content of a quantum system is finite . _ with this we mean that a quantum system can not carry enough information to provide definite answers to all questions that could be asked experimentally .
then , by necessity the answer of the quantum system to some questions must contain an element of randomness .
this kind of randomness must then be irreducible , that is , it can not be reduced to
hidden properties of the system .
otherwise the system would carry more information than what is available .
thus , without any additional physical structure assumed , we let the irreducible randomness of an individual event and complementarity , be a consequence of the finiteness of information .
how much information is available to a quantum system ?
if this information is limited than it is natural to assume that if we decompose a physical system , which may be represented by numerous propositions , into its constituents , each such constituent will be described by fewer propositions . this process of subdividing a system can go further until we reach a final limit when an individual system represents the truth value to one single proposition only .
it is then suggestive to replace the above statement by a more precise one ( zeilinger , 1999 ) : _ the most elementary system represents the truth value of one proposition .
_ we call this the principle of quantization of information
. one may consider the above statement as a definition of what is the most elementary system .
note that the truth value of a proposition can be represented by one bit of information with true
being identified with the bit value 1 and false being identified with the bit value 0 .
thus , the principle becomes simply : _ the most elementary system carries 1 bit of information .
we relate the notion of the most elementary system to that of the `` ur '' introduced by von weizscker .
he was the first who introduced the concept of the most basic informational constituent of all objects ( ur ) .
von weizscker wrote ( 1974 ) : it is certainly possible to decide any large alternative step by step in binary alternatives .
this may tempt us to describe all objects as composite systems composed from the most simple possible objects .
the simplest possible object is an object with a two - dimensional hilbert space , the ur. the word ur is introduced to have an abstract term for something which can be described by quantum theory and has a two - dimensional hilbert space , and nothing more . , and then it hits one of the detector plates behind the stern - gerlach magnet .
depending on whether the upper or the lower detector plate is hit by a particle we call the outcome yes and no , respectively.,scaledwidth=30.0% ] how much information is contained in more complex systems consisting of @xmath3 elementary systems ? it is natural to assume that the information content of a complex system is proportional to the number of elementary constituents .
the principle of quantization of information is thus generalized to ( zeilinger , 1999 ) _ n elementary systems represent the truth values of n propositions , _ or equivalently , _ n elementary systems carry n bits . _ the finding compatible with this principle were reported ( donath and svozil , 2002 ; svozil 2002 ) .
again one may consider the two statements as definitions of what is a composite system consisting of @xmath3 elementary systems .
note that the principle given above does not make any statement about how the information contained in @xmath3 propositions ( @xmath3 bits ) is distributed over the @xmath3 systems .
it can be represented by the @xmath3 systems individually or , alternatively , it can be represented by @xmath3 systems jointly .
the latter is the feature of quantum entanglement , discussed in more detail below , for which schrdinger ( 1935 ) wrote : if two separated bodies , each by itself known maximally , enter a situation in which they influence each other , and separate again , then there occurs regularly that which i have just called entanglement of our knowledge of the two bodies .
the combined expectation - catalog consists initially of a logical sum of the individual catalogs ; during the process it develops causally in accord with known law ( there is no question whatever of measurement here ) .
the knowledge remains maximal , but at its end , if the two bodies have again separated , it is not again split into a logical sum of knowledges about the individual bodies .
what still remains of that may have becomes less than maximal , even very strongly so .
-one notes the great difference over against the classical model theory , where of course from known initial states and with known interaction the individual end states would be exactly known .
the fundamental statements given above seem to suggest that binary ( yes - no ) alternatives are representatives of basic information units of all systems .
consider the case of @xmath4-fold ( i.e. ternary , quanternany etc . )
alternatives generalizing the binary ones .
obviously , any @xmath5-fold alternative is decomposable into binary ones .
note that such an alternative can be realized in measurement of @xmath3 elementary systems .
yet , it is not obvious how to decompose or how to consider a general @xmath4-fold alternative with @xmath6 ?
an interesting possibility would be to find the factorization of number @xmath4 into its prime - number factors @xmath7 and then to decompose the @xmath4-fold alternative into a sequential serial of @xmath8-fold alternatives , @xmath9-fold alternatives etc .
obviously such an approach would require to extend the notion of elementary system to all prime - number dimensional systems .
interestingly , as it will be shown later ( see sec .
[ brot ] ) , only in these cases where the dimension of the quantum system is ( a power of ) a prime number , the total information content of the system can be defined unambiguously .
this might suggest that the notion of the elementary system should indeed be extended to all prime - number dimensions .
however , in this manuscript we will mainly restrict our analysis to binary decomposable alternatives .
we would like to stress again that notions such as that a system represents the truth value of a proposition or that it carries
one bit of information only implies a statement concerning what can be said about possible measurement results . for us
a system is no more than a representative of a proposition .
we consider an explicit example of an elementary system , the spin-1/2 particle , and the stern - gerlach experiment as depicted in fig .
[ plates ] schematically . depending on
whether the upper or the lower detector plate is hit by a particle we call the outcome yes and no respectively , where `` yes '' and `` no '' represent the truth values of the proposition for the spin to be up along a chosen direction .
the upper detector plate is hit with probability @xmath10 .
if it is not hit the other detector plate will be hit with probability @xmath11 .
therefore we consider a binary alternative .
different experimental situations are specified by the orientation @xmath12 of the magnet in the stern - gerlach apparatus as shown in fig .
[ plates ] .
consider an elementary system specified by the true proposition the spin along the @xmath13-axis is up ( or , equivalently , by the false proposition the spin along the @xmath14-axis is up ) .
this situation is described by the probabilities @xmath15 and @xmath16 for the yes outcome . because a spin can carry one bit of information only , each proposition : the spin along the direction tilted at an angle @xmath12 @xmath17 from the @xmath13-axes
is up has to be probabilistic ( fig .
[ kontinum ] ) . how does the probability @xmath18 of a yes
count depend upon the angle @xmath12 ?
we assume that the mapping of @xmath12 to @xmath18 is analytic would only be sectionally analytic in @xmath12 then there would be points of nonanalyticity separating two regions in which the function @xmath18 has different analytic forms .
thus the values of the function on a finite segment in the interior of a domain of analyticity would only determine , by the uniqueness theorem for analytic functions , the function up to the next point of nonanalyticity .
clearly , to describe such a system completely we would need catalogs both of functional values on finite segments in the interior of each domain of analyticity and of the positions of the points of nonanalyticity .
such a catalog would require large amount of information to describe the functional dependence and thus contradicts our desideratum of minimal information content of a quantum system . ] and
monotonic . then using the cauchy theorem about continuous and monotonic functions
one concludes that there has to be one and only one angle of orientation of the magnet in the stern - gerlach apparatus where the probabilities for a yes and for a no outcome are equal . because of the symmetry of the problem this obviously has to be the angle @xmath19 .
for each direction @xmath20 in the @xmath2-@xmath21 plane ( the green circle on the sphere in fig .
[ kontinum ] and [ spin ] ) the proposition the spin along the @xmath20-axis is up is completely indefinite , that is , we have absolutely no knowledge which outcome yes or no will be observed in a specific individual measurement . of a yes (
spin up ) count with a gradual change of the orientation @xmath12 of the magnet in the stern - gerlach apparatus .
the measurement along the z - axis gives the result yes with certainty . because of the symmetry of the problem the probabilities for a yes and for a no count in a measurement along any direction in the @xmath2-@xmath21 plane ( the green circle ) are equal ( = 1/2 ) .
how does the probability @xmath18 of a yes
count depend on @xmath12 explicitly?,scaledwidth=65.0% ] note , however , that in principle this equal number of yes - no outcomes could also be achieved by an ensemble of systems each giving a definite result for each direction such that the same number of yes or no results is obtained . yet again
this would imply that an individual system carries enough information to permit assignment of definite truth values to all possible propositions , in contradiction to our basic principle .
consider now the state of a spin-1/2 particle specified by the proposition the spin along the @xmath2-axis is up ( down ) . in this case
we have complete knowledge which outcome will be observed when the stern - gerlach magnet is oriented along the @xmath22-axis at the expense of the fact that we have absolutely no knowledge about the outcome for the orientation of the magnet along _ any direction in the @xmath21-@xmath13 plane ( the yellow circle on the sphere in fig .
[ spin ] ) .
_ finally , consider the state of a spin-1/2 particle specified by the proposition the spin along the @xmath21-axis is up ( down ) . in that case
we know precisely the outcome of the experiment when the stern - gerlach magnet is oriented along the @xmath23-axis at the expense of complete uncertainty about the outcome when it is oriented along any direction in the @xmath24 plane ( the red circle on the sphere in fig .
[ spin ] ) .
there are , therefore , altogether _ three mutually exclusive _ or _ complementary _ propositions ( represented by three intersection points of the green , yellow and red circle on the sphere in fig . [ spin ] ) : the spin along direction @xmath25 is up ( down )
, the spin along direction @xmath26 is up ( down ) and the spin along direction @xmath27 is up ( down )
, where @xmath25 , @xmath26 and @xmath27 are mutually orthogonal directions .
these are propositions with a property of mutually exclusiveness : the total knowledge of one proposition is only possible at the cost of total ignorance about the other two complementary ones . in other words precise knowledge of the outcome of one experiment
implies that all possible outcomes of complementary ones are equally probable .
why are there exactly 3 mutually complementary propositions for the elementary system and not , e.g. , 2 or 4 ?
we do not understand that fully .
however the discussion above indicates that there is a strong link between the number ( 3 ) of mutually complementary propositions and the ( three-)dimensionality of the ordinary space .
we will come back once more to these question in the conclusions .
but it is important to note that in any system with dichotomic ( 2-valued ) observables there are always three complementary propositions even if these can not be linked to the dimensionality of ordinary space .
consider a probabilistic experiment with @xmath4 possible outcomes .
suppose that the experimenter plans to perform @xmath3 trials of the experiment .
all he knows before the trials are performed are the probabilities @xmath28 for all possible outcomes to occur : what kind of prediction can the experimenter make ? in general two cases are conceivable
. the experimenter can ask : `` what is the precise sequence of the @xmath3 outcomes ? '' or `` what is the number of occurrences of the outcome @xmath29 ? '' .
we will say that in answering the first question the experimenter makes a `` deterministic '' prediction and in answering the second one he makes a `` probabilistic '' prediction trials of a probabilistic yes - no experiment , like tossing a coin , in which the outcome `` yes '' occurs @xmath30 times . if we want to tell somebody else the result it is sufficient to state the values of @xmath3 and of @xmath30 . with the deterministic view ,
in which the precise sequence of outcomes is important , we would in general have to communicate many more details to enable the receiver to reconstruct this sequence . ]
( following discussion in summhammer , 2000 ) .
obviously the deterministic prediction can only make sense if different outcomes follow from the intrinsically different individuals of the ensemble measured - the situation which we have in classical measurements .
then the precise sequence of outcomes reveal which property which individual member of the ensemble carries .
one can show that for sufficiently large @xmath3 shannon s measure of information ( shannon , 1948 ) @xmath31 is equal to the mean minimal number of yes - no questions ( when the logarithm in eq .
( [ mrgod ] ) is taken to base 2 ) necessary to determine which particular sequence of outcomes occurs , divided by @xmath3 . as we show in more detail elsewhere
( brukner and zeilinger , 2001 ) this suggests that shannon s measure of information is the adequate measure of the uncertainty in the deterministic prediction and and thus in classical measurements .
-axis ( @xmath2-axis ) [ @xmath21-axis ] gives a definite result , measurement along any direction in the @xmath2-@xmath21 plane , the green circle ( @xmath21-@xmath13 plane , the yellow circle ) or [ @xmath2-@xmath13 plane , the red circle ] will be maximally random , respectively .
there are altogether three mutually complementary spin measurements represented by three intersection points of the green , yellow , and red circle.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] in contrast to classical measurements , quantum measurements , in general , can not be claimed to reveal a property of the individual quantum system existing before the measurement is performed .
this causes certain conceptual difficulties when we try to define the information gain in quantum measurements using the notion of shannon s measure ( for discussion of these points see brukner and zeilinger , 2001 ; hall , 2000 ; brukner and zeilinger 2000 ; timpson 2001 ) .
since outcomes of quantum - mechanical experiments are in general intrinsically probabilistic , there the experimenter can only make probabilistic predictions . if the experimenter decides to perform @xmath3 future experimental trails ,
all he can guess is the number of occurrences of a specific outcome .
such a prediction will now be analyzed for the case of two possible outcomes `` yes '' and `` no '' .
because of the statistical fluctuations associated with any finite number of experimental trials , the number @xmath30 of occurrences of the `` yes '' outcome in future repetitions of the experiment is not precisely predictable is not a particular weakness of the objective empirical use of the concept of probability , but a feature of the objective empirical use of any quantitative concept . if you predict that some physical quantity , say a temperature , will have a certain value when measured , this prediction also means its expectation value within a statistical ensemble of measurements .
the same statement applies to the empirical quantity called relative frequency . but here are two differences which are connected to each other . the first difference : in other empirical quantities the dispersion of the distribution is in most cases an independent empirical property of the distribution and can be al.tered by more precise measurements of other devices ; in probability the dispersion is derived from the theory itself and depends on the absolute number of cases .
the second difference : in other empirical quantities the discussion of their statistical distributions is done by another theory than the one to which they individually belong , namely by the general theory of probability ; in probability this discussion evidently belongs to the theory of this quantity , namely of probability itself .
the second difference explains the first one .
the random variable @xmath30 is subject to a binomial distribution .
since it has a finite @xmath32 deviation , it fulfills chebyshev s inequality ( gnedenko , 1976 ) : @xmath33 where the standard deviation @xmath32 is given by @xmath34 this inequality means that the probability that the number @xmath30 will deviate from the product @xmath35 by more often than @xmath36 deviations is less than or equal to @xmath37 . in the case of small @xmath32 , large deviations of the number of occurrences of the yes outcome from the mean value @xmath35 are improbable . in this case
the experimenter knows the future number of occurrences with a high certainty .
conversely , a large @xmath32 indicates that not all highly probable values of @xmath30 lie near the mean @xmath35 . in that case
the experimenter knows much less about the future number of occurrences .
we suggest to identify the experimenter s uncertainty @xmath38 with @xmath39
. then it will be proportional to the number of trials .
this important property guarantees that each individual performance of the experiment contributes the same amount of information , no matter how many times the experiment has already been performed .
after each trial the experimenter s uncertainty about the specific outcome therefore decreases by @xmath40 this is the lack of information about a specific outcome with respect to a single future experimental trial .
if , instead of two outcomes , we have @xmath4 of them with the probabilities @xmath41 for the individual occurrences , then we suggest to define the total lack of information regarding all @xmath4 possible experimental outcomes as @xmath42 the uncertainty is minimal if one probability is equal to one and it is maximal if all probabilities are equal .
this suggests that the knowledge , or information , with respect to a single future experimental trial an experimentalist possesses before the experiment is performed is somehow the complement of @xmath43 and , furthermore , that it is a function of a sum of the squares of probabilities .
a first ansatz therefore would be @xmath44 .
expressions of such a general type were studied in detail by hardy , littlewood and plya ( 1952 ) . notice that this expression can also be viewed as describing the length of the probability vector @xmath45 . obviously ,
because of @xmath46 , not all vectors in probability space are possible .
indeed , the minimum length of @xmath45 is given when all @xmath47 are equal ( @xmath48 ) .
this corresponds to the situation of complete lack of information in an experiment about its future outcome .
therefore we suggest to normalize the measure of information in an individual quantum measurement as obtaining finally @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the normalization bits of information can be encoded , i.e. @xmath51 .
the normalization there is @xmath52 .
then @xmath53 results in @xmath36 bits of information if one @xmath54 and it results in 0 bits of information when all @xmath47 are equal . ] .
specifically , for a binary experiment the measure of information is given as @xmath55 it reaches its maximal value of 1 bit of information if one of the probabilities is one and it takes its minimal value of 0 bits of information if both probabilities are equal .
consider again a stationary experimental arrangement with two detectors , where only one detector fires in each experimental trial .
the first detector , say , fires ( we call this the yes outcome ) with probability @xmath8 .
if it is does not fire the other detector fires with probability @xmath56 ( the no outcome ) .
note that the experimenter s measure of information for the binary experiment as defined by eq .
( [ sunka ] ) is invariant under permutation of the set of possible outcomes . in other words , it is a symmetrical function of @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
a permutation of the set of possible outcomes can be achieved in two manners , which may be called active and passive . in the passive point of view
the permutation is obtained by a simple relabelling of the possible outcomes and the property of invariance is self evident because relabelling obviously does not make an experiment more predictable . which specifies the orientations of the stern - gerlach magnets in the three experiments .
the three experimental arrangements are associated to the mutually complementary propositions : @xmath57 : the spin along the @xmath2-axis is up
, @xmath58 : the spin is up along the direction tilted at angle @xmath12 from the @xmath13-axes and @xmath59 : the spin is up along the direction tilted at angle @xmath60 from the @xmath13-axes.,scaledwidth=36.0% ] from the active point of view , one retains the same labeling , and the permutation of the set of outcomes refers to a real change of the experimental set - up . for a spin measurement this would be a re - orientation of the stern - gerlach magnet . in that case the property of invariance states that the measure of information is indifferent under certain real physical changes of the experimental situation .
this requirement is more stringent and may be precisely formulated as an invariance of the measure of information under interchange of the following two physical situations : ( a ) the probability for yes is @xmath8 and for no is @xmath9 ; and ( b ) the probability for yes is @xmath9 and for no is @xmath8 . yet
these are different experimental situations . in order to remove this ambiguity in the description of the experiment one can assign probabilities for occurrences or different numbers or other distinct labels to possible outcomes ,
the particular scheme is of no further relevance .
for example , one can use the statement " the probability for the outcome yes is 0.6 , and for the outcome no is 0.4 , or the statement the probability for the outcome yes is 0.4 , and for the outcome no is 0.6 to distinguish between the situations ( a ) and ( b ) given above . note that in both cases the measure of information as defined by ( [ sunka ] ) is @xmath61 . here
we will use a particular description which is based on the quantity @xmath62 then , on one hand , the sign of @xmath29 differs between the two situations in ( a ) and ( b ) , and on the other hand , the square of @xmath29 is equal to the measure of information @xmath63
. therefore @xmath29 represents an economic and complete description of the experimental situation ( equivalent to the assignment of specific probabilities for the two results ) .
our main goal in the next section will be to derive the functional dependence of probability @xmath64 ( recall @xmath65 on the value of the experimental parameter @xmath12 .
we will first derive the functional dependence @xmath66 and therefrom that of @xmath64 . note that for this purpose one could not use @xmath67 instead of @xmath68 because with any value @xmath67 one can associate two physically non - equivalent situations ( a ) and ( b ) which correspond to different values of the probabilities . ]
all the quantum state is meant to be is a representation of that catalog of our knowledge of the system that is necessary to arrive at the set of , in general probabilistic , predictions for all possible future observations of the system .
such a view was assumed by schrdinger ( 1935 ) who wrote - function ) is now the instrument for predicting the probability of measurement results . in it
is embodied the respectively attained sum of theoretically grounded future expectations , somehow like laid down in a _ catalogue .
_ ] : sie ( die @xmath69-funktion ) ist jetzt das instrument zur voraussage der wahrscheinlichkeit von mazahlen
. in ihr ist die jeweils erreichte summe theoretisch begrndeter zukunftserwartungen verkrpert , gleichsam wie in einem _ katalog _ niedergelegt .
the @xmath69 function is characterized by a set of complex numbers which are very remote from our everyday experience . yet ,
if the origin of the structure of quantum theory is to be sought in a theory of observations , of observers , and of meaning , then we should focus our attention not on complex numbers , but rather on real - value quantities which are directly observable .
interestingly , quantum theory allows descriptions of quantum state in terms of real numbers .
an example for this is the description of density operators in terms of the real coefficients in the decomposition into generators of su(n ) algebra ( basis of generalized pauli matrices as used in , e.g. , schlienz and mahler , 1998 ) .
we will use a description of the state of an elementary system by a vector @xmath70 which is a catalog of knowledge about a set of three mutually complementary propositions and where , in the case of spin , @xmath71 is the probability to find the particle s spin up along @xmath2 etc .
it is assumed that the catalog @xmath72 is a complete description of the system in the sense that its knowledge is sufficient to determine the probabilities for the outcomes of all possible future measurements .
denote by @xmath12 an arbitrary direction within the @xmath21-@xmath13 plane and oriented at an angle @xmath12 with respect to the @xmath13-axis .
now , for all @xmath12 the propositions : @xmath57 : the spin is up along the direction @xmath2
, @xmath58 : the spin is up along the direction @xmath12 , and @xmath73 : the spin is up along the direction @xmath60 are mutually complementary .
the different lists of the three mutually complementary propositions are labeled by a single experimental parameter @xmath12 as given in fig .
[ rotation ] .
they correspond to different representations @xmath74 of the catalog of our knowledge of the system as shown in fig .
[ state ] . .
the components @xmath75 of the information vector are associated to the three mutually complementary propositions @xmath76 and @xmath73.,scaledwidth=40.0% ]
the finiteness of the information content of a quantum system comprises not just extreme cases of maximal knowledge of one proposition at the expense of complete ignorance of complementary ones but it also applies to intermediate cases .
for example , it has been pointed out that in the interference experiments one can obtain some partial knowledge about the particle s path and still observe an interference pattern of reduced contrast as compared to the ideal interference situation ( wootters and zurek , 1979 ; englert 1999 ) . in other words
the information content of the system can manifest itself as path information or as modulation of the interference pattern or partially in both to the extent defined by the finiteness of information ( brukner and zeilinger , 2002 ) . how to define then the total information content of a quantum system ?
bohr ( 1958 ) remarked that ... phenomena under different experimental conditions , must be termed complementary in the sense that each is well defined and that together they exhaust all definable knowledge about the object concerned .
this suggests that the total information content of a quantum system is somehow contained in the full set of mutually complementary experiments .
we define the total information ( of 1 bit ) of the elementary ( or binary , or two - state ) system as a sum of the individual measures of information over a complete set of three mutually complementary experiments @xmath77 how to define the total information content of more complex systems ? in a @xmath4-dimensional hilbert space , one needs @xmath78 real parameters to specify a general density matrix @xmath79 , which must be hermitean and have @xmath80 . since measurements within a particular basis set can yield only @xmath81 independent probabilities ( the sum of all probabilities for all possible outcomes in an individual experiment is one )
, one needs @xmath82 distinct basis sets to provide the required total number of @xmath78 independent probabilities .
ivanovi ( 1981 ) showed that the required number @xmath82 of unbiased basis sets indeed exists if @xmath4 is a prime number , and wootters and fields ( 1989 ) showed that it exists if @xmath4 is any power of a prime number .
elementary systems with dimension @xmath5 of the hilbert space is a special case . ] .
this suggests that the complete information represented by the density matrix is fully contained in a complete set of mutually complementary observables . except for an elementary system ( see sec .
[ nnumber ] ) we can not give the justification for the number of mutually complementary observations in the general case from our basic considerations .
we take this number in the further discussion as given in the quantum theory .
generalizing eq .
( [ srce ] ) we suggest to define the total information content of a @xmath4-dimensional quantum system as the sum of individual measures of information @xmath83 over a complete set of @xmath84 mutually complementary measurements @xmath85 here @xmath86 are the probabilities for the outcomes in the @xmath29-th measurement . in the case of a system composed of @xmath3 elementary systems and with appropriate normalization it results in just @xmath3 bits of information ( for the system in a pure state ) . the question whether or not one can find a complete set of mutually complementary observations in the general case of a hilbert space of arbitrary dimensions is still open .
if it should turn out to be the case , then the definition ( [ mast ] ) can be applied to arbitrarily dimensional quantum systems .
if , in contrast , such sets only exist if the dimension is the power of a prime number , then we suggest to take this seriously , as implying that the prime number alternatives are the most basic informational constituents of all objects ( see also introduction ) . on the basis of this assumption the information content of a complex system of general dimension
could be defined as a sum of the information contents of its individual constituents ( each with the dimension of a prime number ) plus the information contained in the correlations between them .
for example , the system of dimension @xmath87 where @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the prime - number factors of @xmath4 can be considered as a composite system consisting of two subsystems of dimensions @xmath8 and @xmath9 ( the lowest dimension for which the existence of a complete set of mutually complementary observables has not been proven is @xmath88 .
there @xmath89 and @xmath90 . ) .
one obtains @xmath91 independent numbers from a complete set of mutually complementary measurements of the first subsystem and @xmath92 independent numbers from such set of measurements of the second subsystems .
additional @xmath93 numbers can be obtained from the correlations for joint measurements of the two subsystems .
therefore one obtains altogether @xmath94 independent parameters , which is the number of independent parameters which completely define the density operators of a system of dimension @xmath95 .
quantum theory predicts @xmath96 for the probability to find the spin up along the direction at an angle @xmath12 with respect to the direction along which the system gives spin up with certainty . from what
deeper foundation emerges this law in quantum mechanics , originally formulated by malus for light ?
the most important contributions so far in that direction are those of wootters ( 1981 ) , summhammer ( 1988 , 1994 ) and fivel ( 1994 ) . in this section
we argue that the most natural functional relation @xmath18 consistent with the principle of quantization of information is indeed the sinusoidal dependence of malus .
we wish to specify a mapping of @xmath12 onto @xmath68 .
it is of importance to note that we can invent this mapping freely .
the reason for this is that @xmath12 will have functional relations to other physical parameters of the experiment .
then , the laws relating those parameters with the information vector @xmath68 can be seen as laws about relations between those parameters and @xmath12 plus a mapping of @xmath12 onto @xmath68 .
what basic assumptions should we follow to obtain the mapping from @xmath12 to @xmath68 most appropriate for quantum mechanics ?
there are two basic assumptions .
the first one is the assumption of the _ invariance _ of the total information content under the change of representation of the catalog of our knowledge of the system . or , in other words , it is the assumption that total information content must be independent of the particular choice of mutually complementary propositions considered ( see fig .
[ setphoton ] ) . in the same spirit as choosing a coordinate system
, one may choose any set of mutually complementary propositions to represent our knowledge of the system and the total information about the system must be invariant under that choice , i.e. for all @xmath12 @xmath97 in fact , this property of invariance is the reason why we may use the phrase the total information content of the system without explicitly specifying a particular reference set of mutually complementary propositions .
-axis which is not shown in the figures ) .
they correspond to the following two sets of mutually complementary propositions : \{@xmath98 : the spin along the @xmath2-axis is up
, @xmath99 : the spin along the @xmath21-axis is up , @xmath100 : the spin along the @xmath13-axis is up } , and \{@xmath101 : the spin along @xmath2-axis is up , @xmath58 : the spin along the direction tilted at angle @xmath12 from the @xmath13-axes is up , @xmath73 : the spin along the direction tilted at angle @xmath60 from the @xmath13-axes is up}. the total information carried by the spin is independent of the particular set of mutually complementary propositions considered , i.e. @xmath102 in the example shown.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=18.0% ] -axis which is not shown in the figures ) .
they correspond to the following two sets of mutually complementary propositions : \{@xmath98 : the spin along the @xmath2-axis is up
, @xmath99 : the spin along the @xmath21-axis is up , @xmath100 : the spin along the @xmath13-axis is up } , and \{@xmath101 : the spin along @xmath2-axis is up , @xmath58 : the spin along the direction tilted at angle @xmath12 from the @xmath13-axes is up , @xmath73 : the spin along the direction tilted at angle @xmath60 from the @xmath13-axes is up}. the total information carried by the spin is independent of the particular set of mutually complementary propositions considered , i.e. @xmath102 in the example shown.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=26.0% ] -axis which is not shown in the figures ) .
they correspond to the following two sets of mutually complementary propositions : \{@xmath98 : the spin along the @xmath2-axis is up
, @xmath99 : the spin along the @xmath21-axis is up , @xmath100 : the spin along the @xmath13-axis is up } , and \{@xmath101 : the spin along @xmath2-axis is up , @xmath58 : the spin along the direction tilted at angle @xmath12 from the @xmath13-axes is up , @xmath73 : the spin along the direction tilted at angle @xmath60 from the @xmath13-axes is up}. the total information carried by the spin is independent of the particular set of mutually complementary propositions considered , i.e. @xmath102 in the example shown.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=21.0% ] -axis which is not shown in the figures ) .
they correspond to the following two sets of mutually complementary propositions : \{@xmath98 : the spin along the @xmath2-axis is up
, @xmath99 : the spin along the @xmath21-axis is up , @xmath100 : the spin along the @xmath13-axis is up } , and \{@xmath101 : the spin along @xmath2-axis is up , @xmath58 : the spin along the direction tilted at angle @xmath12 from the @xmath13-axes is up , @xmath73 : the spin along the direction tilted at angle @xmath60 from the @xmath13-axes is up}. the total information carried by the spin is independent of the particular set of mutually complementary propositions considered , i.e. @xmath102 in the example shown.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=23.0% ] we suggest that only mappings where neighboring values of @xmath12 correspond to neighboring values of @xmath68 are natural .
thus , if we gradually change the orientation of the magnets in a set of stern - gerlach apparata defining a complete set of mutually complementary observables a continuous change of the information vector will result .
the property of invariance defined by eq .
( [ sommer ] ) implies that with a gradual change of the experimental parameter from @xmath103 to @xmath104 the information vector rotates in the space of information @xmath105 such that the length of the information vector is conserved ( fig .
[ kugel ] ) .
the rotation matrix depends on two independent variables @xmath103 and @xmath104 ; here specific arguments @xmath106 and @xmath103 are chosen in the functional dependence for convenience .
equation ( [ fm4 ] ) expresses our expectation that the transformation law is linearprecisely speaking , the invariance property only implies that the transformation law @xmath107 is described by a general mapping @xmath108 which preserves the length of the information vector .
now , consider the situation where with probability @xmath109 a system is prepared in state @xmath110 and with probability @xmath111 in @xmath112
. then the information vector is given by @xmath113 .
this means that the state @xmath114 , where @xmath114 can , just formally , be written as @xmath115 , is equivalent to the state of the system which is with probability @xmath109 prepared in state @xmath116 and with probability @xmath111 in state @xmath117 .
let us now suppose that the experimental parameter in each of the three mutually complementary experiments is changed from the value @xmath103 to @xmath104 .
the individual information vectors @xmath110 and @xmath112 evolve independently , resulting in @xmath118 for the total information vector at @xmath104 .
this shows that the function @xmath108 is linear : @xmath119 for convex sums over @xmath116 and @xmath117 .
for an extension of the proof to arbitrary sums follow the idea from appendix 1 of ( hardy , 2001a ) , which is there applied in a different context .
] , that is , independent of the actual information vector transformed .
@xmath120 is an orthonormal matrix @xmath121 notice that transformation matrices do not build up a group in general because of the explicit dependence on both the initial and final parametric value .
the second basic assumption in the derivation of the malus law in quantum physics is that no physical process _
a priori _ distinguishes one specific value of the physical parameter from others , that is , that the parametric @xmath12-axis is _ homogeneous_. in our example with the orientation of stern - gerlach magnets as an experimental parameter , the homogeneity of the parametric axis becomes equivalent to the _ isotropy _ of the ordinary space .
the homogeneity of the parametric axis precisely requires that if we transform physical situations of three complementary experiments together with the state of the system along the parametric axis for any real number @xmath122 , we can not observe any effect . using a more formal language
this means the following .
suppose two lists each with three mutually complementary experimental arrangements are associated with a specific parametric value @xmath103 and to some other value @xmath123 ( @xmath124 ) respectively .
furthermore , suppose the information vectors @xmath114 and @xmath125 associated with the two lists are equal ( i.e. all components of the two vectors are equal ) .
the homogeneity of the parametric @xmath12-axis then requires that if we change the physical parameter in each experiment by an equal interval of @xmath126 in the two lists of complementary experiments , the resulting information vectors will be equivalent as shown in fig .
[ homogenity ] .
mathematically , if @xmath127 for all @xmath103 implies @xmath128 , then of the parameter .
this can only be done with eq .
( [ smrad ] ) . ] @xmath129 the transformation matrix then depends only on the difference between the initial and final value of the experimental parameter , and not on the location of these values on the parametric @xmath12-axis .
the orthogonality condition leads to the following general form of the transformation matrix @xmath130 where we take @xmath131 for simplicity and @xmath132 and @xmath133 are not yet specified but assumed to be analytical functions satisfying @xmath134 to @xmath135 due to a change of the physical parameter from @xmath103 to @xmath104.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] we further require that a change of the experimental parameter in a set of mutually complementary arrangements from @xmath103 to @xmath104 and subsequently from @xmath104 to @xmath136 must have the same physical effect as a direct change of the parameter from @xmath103 to @xmath136 . the resulting transformation will then be independent , whether we apply two consecutive transformations @xmath137 and @xmath138 or a single transformation @xmath139 @xmath140 this together with the property that for @xmath141 the transformation matrix equals the unity matrix ( since there is no change of the physical situations of the complementary experiments one has @xmath142 ) implies that transformation matrices build up the group of rotations so(3 ) , a connected subgroup of the group of orthogonal matrices o(3 ) which contains the identity transformation .
for the special case of infinitesimally small variation of the experimental conditions , eq .
( [ hunters ] ) reads @xmath143 inserting the form ( [ love ] ) of the transformation matrix into the latter expression , one obtains @xmath144 using conditions ( [ humanrace ] ) , we transform eq .
( [ lola ] ) into the differential equation @xmath145 where @xmath146 is a constant .
the solution of the differential equation reads @xmath147 where we integrate between @xmath148 and @xmath12 using the condition @xmath149 from eq .
( [ humanrace ] ) .
this finally leads to @xmath150 this result directly gives the familiar expression @xmath151 for probability in quantum theory .
-axis.,scaledwidth=46.0% ] mathematically one could consider our result as a direct and immediate consequence of the theory of group representations ; the cosine dependence follows from a particular representation of the rotation group .
however from the physical perspective it is implied by fundamental assumptions : ( 1 ) the total information of the system is invariant under the change of the representation of the catalog of our knowledge about the system and ( 2 ) the parametric space is homogeneous . if ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) are satisfied , then the probability must vary as @xmath152 , where @xmath4 is a parameter not determined by the derivation .
quantum - mechanical probabilities are just of this form , with @xmath12 for a relative polarization angle and with @xmath153 for electrons and neutrinos , or with @xmath154 for photons , or with @xmath155 for gravitons . the same functional dependence @xmath156 undergoes also the probability to find a particle in a specific output beam in the mach - zehnder type of interferometer with the phase shift @xmath157 between two paths inside the interferometer . in the discussion
so far we considered a change of a single experimental parameter and the rotation of the information vector within one plane only .
this can be generalized .
let us define the orientations of the three mutually orthogonal directions @xmath158 , @xmath159 and @xmath160 in ordinary space by the euler angles @xmath161 , @xmath162 , and @xmath163 . then the mutually complementary propositions which are associated to measurements along the three directions can be represented in terms of the euler angles as @xmath164 : the spin along the direction @xmath158 is up ,
@xmath165 : the spin along the direction @xmath159 is up and @xmath166 : the spin along the direction @xmath160 is up .
given a specific set of three orthogonal directions , all other sets of orthogonal directions can be obtained by rotating the reference set . any general rotation for euler s angles @xmath167
can be performed as a sequence of three rotations , the first around the @xmath13-axes by @xmath168 , the second around the new @xmath21-axes by @xmath169 and finally the third around the new @xmath13-axes by @xmath170 .
a list of mutually complementary propositions associated to the spin measurements along directions obtained by the first rotation is @xmath171 , @xmath172 , and @xmath173 .
following the argumentation given above one obtains @xmath174 for the corresponding transformation matrix in the space of information along which a photon s polarization is measured , or three spatially orthogonal directions along which complementary spin components of a spin-1/2 particle are measured ) and directions associated with mutually complementary propositions ( components of an information vector ) in the space of information .
the latter always constitute an orthogonal coordinate system .
these again have to be distinguished from the orthogonal directions in hilbert space which do not correspond to complementary measurements . ] .
if we fix the angle of the first rotation at @xmath175 and consider only propositions @xmath176 , @xmath177 and @xmath178 about spins along directions obtained by the second rotation around the new @xmath21-axis for an angle @xmath179 , the corresponding transformation matrix reads @xmath180 in the last step we fix both the angle @xmath175 of the first rotation and the angle @xmath181 of the second rotation , and consider only sets of mutually complementary propositions @xmath182 , @xmath183 and @xmath184 about spins along directions obtained by the third rotation around the new @xmath13-axis for @xmath185 .
the corresponding transformation matrix is again of the form ( [ evolution ] ) with the angle @xmath186 .
finally , the transformation matrix for a general rotation in the space of information is given as @xmath187 while these relations have an obvious meaningful for spin they hold equally for any elementary system .
specifically they also hold for a two - path interferometer .
entanglement is the feature which distinguishes quantum physics most succinctly from classical physics as quantitatively expressed by the violation of bell s inequalities ( bell 1964 , clauser _ et al .
_ , 1969 ) .
in 1964 john bell obtained certain bounds ( the bell inequalities ) on combinations of statistical correlations for measurements on two - particle systems if these correlations were to be understood within a realistic picture based on local properties of each individual particle . in a such a picture
the measurement results are determined by properties the particles carry prior to and independent of observation . in a local picture
the results obtained at one location are independent of any measurements or actions performed at space - like separation .
quantum mechanics predicts violation of these constraints for certain statistical predictions for the composite ( entangled ) systems . by today
, the predictions of quantum physics have been confirmed in many experiments ( freedman and clauser 1972 ; aspect _ et al . _ , 1981 ; weihs _ et al .
_ , 1998 ; pan _ et al .
_ , 2000 ) in this section we will investigate how much information can be contained in the correlations between quantum systems in order to give an information - theoretic criterion of quantum entanglement .
we suggest that a natural understanding of quantum entanglement results when one accepts that the information in a composite system can reside more in the correlations than in properties of individuals .
the quantitative formulation of these ideas leads to a rather natural criterion of quantum entanglement .
the total information of a composite system can be distributed in various ways within the composite system .
we will consider only that part of the total information of the system which is exclusively contained in correlations , or joint properties of its constituents .
this is also the reason why now we will not consider complete sets of mutually complementary propositions for the composite system but just that subset of them which concerns joint properties of its constituents . as it is our final goal to compare that criterion with the one given by bell - type inequalities where one considers correlations between spin measurements confined on each side within one plane we restrict our analysis to an @xmath2-@xmath21 plane locally defined for each subsystem . as an explicit example of a composite systems a system consisting of two spin-1/2 particles
will be considered .
the propositions about their joint properties will be binary propositions , i.e. will be associated to experiments with two possible outcomes .
the two outcomes will correspond to the proposition of the type : `` the spin of particle 1 along @xmath2 and the spin of particle 2 along @xmath21 are the same '' , and to its negation `` the spin of particle 1 along @xmath2 and the spin of particle 2 along @xmath21 are different .
therefore the measure of information eq .
( [ sunka ] ) for binary experiments can be applied .
if we denote the probabilities for the two outcomes by @xmath188 and @xmath189 respectively , then the information contained in proposition ' ' the spin of particle 1 along @xmath2 and the spin of particle 2 along @xmath21 are the same ( different ) " is given by @xmath190 we first consider a product state e.g. @xmath191 .
this is the case of a composite system composed of two elementary systems carrying therefore @xmath192 bits of information , i.e. representing the truth value of two propositions . here
the state @xmath193 represents the two - bit combination true - false of the truth values of the propositions about the spin of each particle along the @xmath2-axis : ( 1 ) `` the spin of particle 1 is up along @xmath2 '' and ( 2 ) `` the spin of particle 2 is up along @xmath2 '' . instead of the second proposition describing the spin of particle 2 , we could alternatively choose a proposition which describes the result of a joint observation : ( 3 ) `` the two spins are the same along @xmath2 . ''
then the state @xmath193 represents the two - bit combination true - false of the truth values of the propositions ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) . evidently , for pure product states at most one proposition with definite truth - value can be made about joint properties because one proposition has to be used up to define a property of one of the two subsystems .
in other words 1 bit of information defines the correlations . in our example where @xmath194 the correlations are fully represented by the correlations between spin @xmath2-measurements on the two sides , therefore @xmath195 we denote the states with property ( [ prodcorr ] ) as classically composed states .
obviously , the choice of directions @xmath2 and @xmath21 within each of the planes of measurements on the two sides is arbitrary .
it is physically not acceptable that the total information contained in correlations between spin measurements confined on each side within @xmath2-@xmath21 planes depends on this choice .
we therefore require that the total information contained in the correlations must be invariant upon the choice of general @xmath2 and @xmath21 measurement directions within the @xmath2-@xmath21 planes on each side . only with this requirement
the statement `` the total information contained in the correlations between measurements within the @xmath2-@xmath21 planes '' can have a meaning independent of the specific set of mutually complementary measurements considered .
this invariance property can only be guaranteed with our measure of information ( [ measure2 ] ) .
we define the total information contained in the correlations as the sum over the individual measures of information about a complete set of mutually complementary observations within the planes @xmath2-@xmath21 on the two sides .
the total information contained in the correlations is thus defined as the sum @xmath196 of the partial measures of information contained in the set of complementary observations within the @xmath2-@xmath21-planes .
these observations are mutually complementary for product states and the set is complete as there exists no further complementary observation within the chosen @xmath2-@xmath21 planes . by this
we mean that for any product state a complete knowledge contained in any proposition from the set : `` the two spins are equal along @xmath2 '' , `` the spin of particle 1 along @xmath2 and the spin of particle 2 along @xmath21 are the same '' , `` the spin of particle 1 along @xmath21 and the spin of particle 2 along @xmath2 are the same '' and `` the two spins are equal along @xmath21 '' excludes any knowledge about other three propositions . in general there can also be some amount of information contained in the correlations for measurements involving @xmath13 direction , for example , for measurement directions within the @xmath2-@xmath13 planes on the two sides .
obviously if the general @xmath2 and @xmath21 directions are chosen to include directions outside of the old @xmath2-@xmath21 planes measure of information @xmath197 can not be assumed to remain an invariant .
the maximal value of @xmath197 can then be obtained by an optimization over all possible two - dimensional planes of measurements on both sides .
consider now a maximally entangled bell state , e.g. @xmath198 the two propositions here both are statements about results of joint observations ( zeilinger 1997 ) , namely ( 1 ) `` the two spins are equal along @xmath2 '' and ( 2 ) `` the two spins are equal along @xmath21 '' .
now the state represents the two - bit combination false - false of these propositions .
note that here the 2 bits of information are all carried by the 2 elementary systems in a joint way , with no individual elementary system carrying any information on its own .
in other words , as the two available bits of information are already exhausted in defining joint properties , no further possibility exists to also encode information in individuals
. therefore @xmath199 note that in our example of bell - state ( [ bellstate ] ) @xmath200 and @xmath201 .
also , note that the truth value for another proposition , namely , `` the two spins are equal along @xmath13 '' must follow immediately from the truth values of the propositions ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) , as only 2 bits of information are available .
interestingly this is also a direct consequence of the formalism of quantum mechanics as the joint eigenstate of @xmath202 and of @xmath203 is also an eigenstate of @xmath204 .
in contrast to product states we suggest entanglement of two elementary systems to be defined in general such that _ more than one bit _ ( of the two available ones ) is used to define joint properties , i.e. @xmath205 for at least one choice of the planes of measurements for the two elementary systems ( or , equivalently , for that choice of the planes of measurements for which @xmath197 reaches its maximal value ) .
most importantly this simple information - theoretic criterion of entanglement can be shown to be equivalent to a _ necessary _ and _ sufficient _ condition ( horodeccy family , 1995 ) for a violation of a bell - type inequality for two - elementary systems .
a generalization of our information - theoretic criterion for entanglement to @xmath3 elementary systems and its relation to the criteria for violation of bell s inequalities can be found in ( brukner _ et al .
_ , 2001 ) .
any assignment of properties to an object is always a consequence of some observation . using information obtained in previous observations we wish to make predictions about the future .
again our predictions might be formulated as , in general probabilistic , predictions about future properties of a system .
clearly , these predictions can be verified or falsified by performing measurements and checking whether the experimental results agree with our predictions .
it is then important to connect past observations with future observations . or , more precisely , to make , based on past observations , specific statements about possible results of future observations . in quantum mechanics
this connection between past observation and future observation exactly is achieved by the quantum - mechanical liouville equation ( for pure states it reduces to the schrdinger equation ) @xmath206.\ ] ] the initial state @xmath207 represents all our information as obtained by earlier observation .
using the quantum - mechanical liouville equation we can derive a time evolved final state @xmath208 at some future time @xmath209 which gives us predictions for any possible observation of the system at that time . in this section
the dynamics of an elementary system is formulated as a time evolution of the catalog of our knowledge of the system .
this is specified by the evolution of the information vector in the space of information .
the liouville equation will then be derived from the differential equation describing the motion of the information vector in the information space .
we will consider now the time evolution of an elementary system with no information exchange with an environment .
suppose that the state of the system at some initial time @xmath210 is represented by the catalog @xmath211 of our knowledge .
now let the system evolve in time . because there is no information exchange with an environment during the evolution , the total information of the system at some later time @xmath209 must still be the same as at the initial time .
this may be seen as an ultimate constant of the evolution of the system motion independent of the strength , time dependence or any other characteristic of the `` external field '' of the system .
therefore @xmath212 mathematically , the conservation of the total information is equivalent to the conservation of the length of the information vector during its motion in the information space .
this means that time evolution of an isolated quantum system is just a rotation of the information vector in the space of information ( see footnote [ mrkva ] ) @xmath213 where again @xmath214 is a rotation matrix @xmath215 and @xmath216 is its transposed matrix .
the derivative of eq .
( [ fm5 ] ) with respect to time is @xmath217 where @xmath218 .
we will now show that the operator @xmath219 is antisymmetric .
we find @xmath220 where the initial time @xmath210 is identified with the time 0 .
it is a well - known result of vector analysis that with every antisymmetric operator @xmath221 one may uniquely associate the vector of rotation @xmath222 by the relation is represented by an antisymmetric matrix @xmath223 from there we read out the components of the vector of rotation @xmath222 as @xmath224 ] @xmath225 where
@xmath226 denotes vector product . using this result we now rewrite eq .
( [ lifeisover ] ) as @xmath227 mathematically , this equation describes the rotation of the information vector around the axis @xmath228 which itself changes in the course of time .
physically , this is the formulation of the dynamical law for the evolution of the catalog of our knowledge
. one might recognize eq .
( [ please ] ) as a description of the state evolution in terms of the bloch vector .
based on the known features of the quantum formalism we will now argue for the validity of eq .
( [ please ] ) .
suppose that the quantum state of the system is described by the density matrix @xmath229 .
we decompose the density matrix into the unity operator and the generators of su(2 ) algebra ( pauli matrices ) @xmath230 where @xmath231 is spin operator for the direction @xmath232 .
note that the quantity @xmath233 for the spin along the direction @xmath234 is equal to the expectation value of spin along this direction , i.e. @xmath235 .
if we take a derivative of eq .
( [ smisao ] ) in time we obtain @xmath236 inserting eq .
( [ please ] ) on the right - hand side we find @xmath237 since the pauli matrices satisfy @xmath238=2i\sum_{k=1}^3 \epsilon_{ijk}\hat{\sigma}_k$ ] , we proceed with @xmath239 introducing the operator @xmath240 such that @xmath241 we finally obtain the quantum - mechanical lioville equation @xmath206.\ ] ] for the special case of a conservative system , the evolution of a quantum state in time is constrained by a higher constant of motion , namely our information about the energy of the system , apart from the ultimate one of the total information content of the system . in the space of information this corresponds to the rotation of the information vector around a fixed axis that is associated to our knowledge of energy of the system .
this is only possible if the axis @xmath222 in eq .
( [ please ] ) is a fixed axis in time around which the information vector rotates .
this further implies the existence of a minimal interval of time the information vector needs to make one complete rotation in the space of information ( fig .
[ frequency ] ) .
after this time interval the values @xmath29 for all propositions about the system take the same value .
this time interval is known as the debroglie wave - period . obviously
the result given above is just a very first and the simplest step toward an information - theoretical formulation of the quantum - mechanical evolution in time .
mathematically , it is an immediate consequence of the ( nearly ) isomorphism between su(2 ) group of unitary rotations in a two - dimensional hilbert space and so(3 ) group of rotations in the real three - dimensional euclidian space .
obviously one needs to consider more complex systems and to find position- and momentum - representations of the catalog of our knowledge in order to give an information - theoretical formulation of the schrdinger equation .
in this section , it will be argued that identifying the quantum state of a system with the catalog of our knowledge of the system leads to the resolution of many of the seemingly paradoxical features of quantum mechanics connected to the so - called measurement problem . in a quantum measurement
, we find the system to be in one of the eigenstates of the observable defined by the measurement apparatus .
a specific example is the case when we are considering a wave packet as being composed of a superposition of plane waves .
such a wave packet is more or less well - localized , but we can always perform a position measurement on a wave packet which is better localized than the dimension of the packet itself .
this , sometimes called reduction of the wave packet or collapse of the wave function , can only be seen as a measurement paradox if one views this change of the quantum state as a real physical process . in the extreme case
it is often even related to an instant collapse of some physical wave in space .
there is no basis for any such assumption .
in contrast , there is never a paradox if we realize that the wave function is just an encoded mathematical representation of our knowledge of the system .
when the state of a quantum system has a non - zero value at some position in space at some particular time , it does not mean that the system is physically present at that point , but only that our knowledge ( or lack of knowledge ) of the system allows the particle the _ possibility _ of being present at that point at that instant . what can be more natural than to change the representation of our knowledge if we gain new knowledge from a measurement performed on the system ?
when a measurement is performed , our knowledge of the system changes , and therefore its representation , the quantum state , also changes . in agreement with the new knowledge
, it instantaneously changes all its components , even those which describe our knowledge in the regions of space quite distant from the site of the measurement .
then no need whatsoever arises to allude to notions like superluminal or instantaneous transmission of information .
schrdinger ( 1935 ) wrote - function ( = the prediction catalog ) a characteristic , quite sudden change , which _ depends on the measurement result obtained _ , and so _ can not be foreseen _ ; from which alone it is already quite clear that this second kind of change of the @xmath69-function has nothing whatever in common with its orderly development _ between _ two measurements . the abrupt change by measurement
... is the most interesting point of the entire theory .
it is precisely _ the _ point that demands the break with naive realism .
for _ this _ reason one _ can not _ put the @xmath69-function directly in place of the model or of the physical thing . and indeed
not because one might never dare impute abrupt unforseen changes to a physical thing or to a model , but because in the realism point of view observation is a natural process like any other and can not per se bring about an interruption of the orderly flow of natural events . ] : bei jeder messung ist man gentigt , der @xmath69-funktion ( = dem voraussagenkatalog ) eine eigenartige , etwas pltzliche vernderung zuzuschreiben , die von der _ gefundenen mazahl _ abhngt und sich _ nicht vorhersehen lt _ ; woraus allein schon deutlich ist , da diese zweite art von vernderung der @xmath69-funktion mit ihrem regelmssigen abrollen _ zwischen _ zwei messungen nicht das mindeste zu tun hat .
die abrupte vernderung durch die messung ...
ist der interessanteste punkt der ganzen theorie .
es ist genau _ der _ punkt , der den bruch mit dem naiven realismus verlangt .
grund kann man die @xmath69-funktion _ nicht _ direkt an die stelle des modells oder des realdings setzen .
und zwar nicht etwa weil man einem realding oder einem modell nicht abrupte unvorhergesehene nderung zumuten drfte , sondern weil vom realistischen standpunkt die beobachtung ein naturvorgang ist wie jeder andere und nicht per se eine unterbrechung des regelmssigen naturlaufs hervorrufen darf .
a closely related position was assumed also by heisenberg , who wrote in a letter to renninger dated february 2 , 1960 : the act of recording , on the other hand , which leads to the reduction of the state , is not a physical , but rather , so to say , a mathematical process . with the sudden change of our knowledge also the mathematical presentation of our knowledge undergoes of course a sudden change . , as translated by jammer ( 1974 ) .
we will now bring the role of the observer in a quantum measurement to the center of our discussion . in classical physics
we can assume that an observation reveals some property already existing in the outside world .
for example , if we look at the moon , we just find out where it is and it is certainly safe to assume that the property of the moon to be there is independent of whether anyone looks or not .
the situation is drastically different in quantum mechanics and it is just the very attitude of the copenhagen interpretation giving a fundamental role to observation which is a major intellectual step forward over this naive classical realism . with the only exception of the system being in an eigenstate of the measured observable , a quantum measurement changes the system into one of the possible new states defined by the measurement apparatus in a fundamentally unpredictable way , and thus can not be claimed to reveal a property existing before the measurement is performed .
the reason for this is again the fact that a quantum system can not , not even in principle , carry enough information to specify observation - independent properties corresponding to all possible measurements . in the measurement the state therefore must appear to be changed in accord with the new information , if any , _ acquired _ about the system together with unavoidable and irrecoverable _ loss _ of complementary information . unlike a classical measurement , a quantum measurement
thus does not just add ( if any ) some knowledge , it changes our knowledge in agreement with a fundamental finiteness of the total information content of the system we as observers have a significant role in the measurement process , because we can decide by choosing the measuring device which attribute will be realized in the actual measurement
. since the information content of the system is limited , by choosing which measurement device to use we not only decide what particular knowledge will be gained , but simultaneously what complementary knowledge will be lost after the measurement is performed . here , a very subtle position was assumed by pauli ( 1955 ) who writes : the gain of knowledge by means of an observation has as a necessary and natural consequence , the loss of some other knowledge .
the observer has however the free choice , corresponding to two mutually exclusive experimental arrangements , of determining _ what _ particular knowledge is gained and what other knowledge is lost ( complementary pairs of opposites ) .
therefore every irrevocable interference by an observation about a system alters its state , and creates a new phenomenon in bohr s sense .
the laws we discover about nature do not already exist as laws of nature in the outside world .
rather laws of nature are necessities of the mind for any possibility to make sense whatsoever out of the data of experience .
this epistemological structure is a necessity behind the form of all laws an observer can discover . as von weizscker
has put it , and heisenberg quoted in ( 1958 ) paper : nature is earlier than man , but man is earlier than natural science . an observer is inescapably suspended in the situation of obtaining the data from observation , formatting concepts of nature therefrom , and predicting the data of future observations . in observing she /
he is able to distinguish only a finite number of results at each interval of time ( compare summhammer , 2000 ; 2001 ) .
therefore the experience of the ultimate experimenter is a stream of ( yes or no ) answers to the questions posed to nature .
any concept of an existing reality is then a mental construction based on these answers . of course
this does not imply that reality is no more than a pure subjective human construct . from our observations we are able to build up objects with a set of properties that do not change under variations of modes of observation or description .
these are invariants with respect to these variations .
predictions based on any such specific invariants may then be checked by anyone , and as a result we may arrive at an intersubjective agreement about the model , thus lending a sense of independent reality to the mentally constructed objects . in quantum experiments
an observer may decide to measure a different set of complementary variables , thus gaining certainty about one or more variable at the expense of losing certainty about the other(s ) .
thus the measure of information in an individual experiment is not an invariant but depends on the specific experimental context .
however the total uncertainty , or equivalently , the total information , is invariant under such transformation from one complete set of complementary variables to another . in classical physics
a property of a system is a primary concept prior to and independent of observation and information is a secondary concept which measures our ignorance about properties of the system .
in contrast in quantum physics the notion of the total information of the system emerges as a primary concept , independent of the particular complete set of complementary experimental procedures the observer might choose , and a property becomes a secondary concept , a specific representation of the information of the system that is created spontaneously in the measurement itself .
bohr ( 1934 ) wrote that ... a subsequent measurement to a certain degree deprives the information given by a previous measurement of its significance for predicting the future course of phenomena .
obviously , these facts not only set a limit to the _ extent _ of the information obtainable by measurement , but they also set a limit to the _ meaning _ which we may attribute to such information .
theorems like those of bell ( 1964 ) and greenberger - horne - zeilinger ( 1990 ) state that randomness of an individual quantum event can not be derived from local causes ( local hidden variables ) .
quantum physics is not able to explain why ( specific ) events happen as pointed out by bell ( 1990 ) .
it is beyond the scope of quantum physics to answer the question why events happen at all ( that is , why the detectors clicks at all ) . yet
, if events happen , then they must happen randomly .
the reason is the finiteness of the information . any detailed description of the reality that would be able to give an unambiguous answer to bell s question ,
that is , any description that would be able to arrive at an accurate and detailed prediction of the particular process resulting in a particular event , will necessarily include the definition of a number of hidden properties of the system which would carry information as to which specific result will be observed for all possible future measurements . therefore no answer can be given to bell s question , because otherwise , quantum system would carry more information that it is in principle available .
it turns out that the lowest symmetry common for all elementary systems is the invariance of their total information content with respect to a rotation in a three - dimensional space .
the three dimensionality of the information space is a consequence of the minimal number ( 3 ) of mutually exclusive experimental questions we may pose to an elementary system .
this seems to justify the use of three - dimensional space as the space of the inferred world .
such a view was first suggested by v. weizscker ( 1974 ) : `` it [ quantum theory of the simple alternative ] contains a two - dimensional complex vector space with a unitary metric , a two - dimensional hilbert space .
this theory has a group of transformations which is surprisingly near - isomorphic with a group of rotations in the real three - dimensional euclidian space .
this has been known for a very long time .
i propose to take this isomorphism seriously as being the real reason why ordinary space is three - dimensional . ''
we end with another quote of v. weizscker ( 1974 ) : `` but i feel these consideration make it plausible that quantum theory is not just one out of a thousand equally possible theories , and the one which happens to please god so much that he chose to create a world in which it would be true .
i rather think , if we had understood quantum theory just a little bit better than we understand it so far it would turn out to be a fairly good approximation towards the formulation of a theory which contains nothing but the rules under which we speak about future events if we can speak about them in an empirically testable way at all . ''
it has not escape our attention that our considerations presented here may be viewed as providing the necessary justification for this point of view .
we acknowledge discussions with terry rudolph , christoph simon , johann summhammer and marek .
zukowski . this work is supported by the austrian fwf project f1506 , and by the qipc program of the eu .
aspect , a. , p. grangier , and g. roger , 1981 , phys .
rev . lett . * 47 * , 460 - 463 . + bell , j. s. , 1964 , physics 1 , 195 - 200 ; reprinted bell , j. s. , 1987 , _ speakable and unspeakable in quantum mechanics _
( cambridge univ .
+ bell , j. s. , 1990 , physics world ( august 1990 ) .
+ bohr n. , 1949 , in _ albert einstein : philosopher - scientist _ , edited by p.a .
schillp ( the library of living philosophers evanston , il ) 200 .
a copy can be found at the web site ( http://www.emr.hibu.no/lars/eng/schlipp/default.html ) .
+ bohr , n. , 1958 , _ atomic physics and human knowledge _
( wiley , new york ) .
+ brukner , . , and a. zeilinger , 1999 , phys . rev
. lett . * 83 * , 3354 - 3357 .
+ brukner , . and a. zeilinger , 2000 , e - print quant - ph/0008091 .
+ brukner , , m. ukowski , and a. zeilinger , 2001 , e - print quant - ph/0106119 .
+ brukner , . and
a. zeilinger , 2001 , phys . rev .
a * 63 * , 022113 1 - 10 .
+ brukner , . and a. zeilinger , 2002 , phil .
lond . a 360 ( 2002 ) 1061 .
+ caves , c. m. , c. a. fuchs , r. schack , 2001a , e - print quant - ph/0104088 .
+ caves , c. m. , c. a. fuchs , r. schack 2001b , phys .
+ clauser , j. , m. horne , a. shimony , and r. holt , 1969 , phys .
* 23 * , 880 - 884 .
+ donath , n. , and k. svozil , 2002 , phys .
a * 66 * , 044302 .
+ freedman , s. j. , and j. s. clauser , 1972 , phys .
* 28 * , 938 - 941 .
+ englert b. g. , 1996 , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 2154 .
+ fivel , d.i . , 1994 ,
rev . a * 59 * , 2108 .
+ fuchs , c. a. , 2002 , e - print quant - ph/0205039 .
+ fuchs , c. a. , 2001 , e - print quant - ph/0106166 .
+ gnedenko , b. v. , 1976 , _ the theory of probability _ ( mir publishers , moscow ) .
+ greenberger , d. m. , m. horne , a. shimony , and a. zeilinger , 1990 , am . j. phys . * 58 * , 1131 - 1143 .
+ hall , m. j. w. , 2000 , e - print quant - ph/0007116 .
+ hardy g. , j. e. littlewood and g. plya , 1952 _ inequalities _ ( cambridge university press ) . + hardy , l. , 2001a , e - print quant - ph/0101012 .
+ hardy , l. , 2001b , e - print quant - ph/0111068 .
+ heisenberg , w. , 1958 , daedalus * 87 * , 95 .
+ horodecki , r. , p. horodecki , and m. horodecki , 1995 , phys .
a * 200 * , 340 - 344 .
+ ivanovi i. , 1981 , j. phys . a * 14 * , 3241 .
+ jammer , m. , 1974 , _ the philosophy of quantum mechanics _ , ( j. wiley & sons , new york ) .
+ kochen , s. and e. p. specker , 1967 , j. math . and mech .
* 17 * , 59 . + landauer r. , 1991 may , physics today , 23
. + pan , j. w. , d. bouwmeester , h. weinfurter , and a. zeilinger , 2000 , nature * 403 * , 515 - 518 . + pauli w. , 1955 , in
_ writings on philosophy and physics _ edited by c. p. enz and k. von meyenn , translated by robert schlapp ( springer verlag , berlin ) .
+ schlienz j. and g. mahler , 1995 , phys .
a * 52 * , 4396 - 4404 .
+ shannon , c. e. , 1948 , bell syst .
j. * 27 * , 379
. a copy can be found at ( http://cm.bell-labs.com/cm/ms/what/shannonday/paper.html ) .
+ schrdinger , e. , 1935 , naturwissenschaften 23 , 807 - 812 ; 823 - 828 ; 844 - 849 .
translation published in _ proc . am .
_ 124 , p. 323
- 338 and in _ quantum theory and measurement _ edited by j. a. wheeler and w. h. zurek ( princeton university press , princeton ) , p. 152 - 167
. a copy can be found at ( www.emr.hibu.no/lars/eng/cat ) .
+ summhammer , j. , 1988 , found .
. lett . * 1 * , 123 .
+ summhammer , j. , 1994 , int .
. phys . * 33 * , 171 .
+ summhammer , j. , 2000 , e - print quant - ph/0008098 , to appear in `` the third millenium '' edited by cristian calude .
+ summhammer , j. 2001 , e - print quant - ph/0102099 .
+ svozil , k. , 2002 , phys .
a * 66 * , 044306 .
+ timpson , c. g. , 2001 , e - print quant - ph/0112178 .
+ von weizscker , c. f. , 1958 , _ aufbau der physik _
( carl hanser , mnchen ) .
+ von weizscker , c. f. , 1974 , in _ quantum theory and the structures of time and space _ , edited by l. castell , m. drieschner , c. f. von weizscker ( hanser , mnchen , 1975 ) .
papers presented at a conference held in feldafing , july 1974 .
+ weihs , g. , t. jennewein , c. simon , h. weinfurter , and a. zeilinger , 1998 , phys .
* 81 * , 5039 - 5043 .
+ wheeler j. a. , 1983 , law without law in _ quantum theory and measurement _ edited by j. a. wheeler and w. h. zurek ( princeton university press , princeton ) 182 .
+ wheeler j. a. , 1989 , proc .
foundations of quantum mechanics , tokyo , 354 .
+ wootters , w. k. , 1981 , phys .
rev d * 23 * , 357 . + wootters w. k. and b. d. fields , 1989 , ann
* 191 * , 363 . + wootters , w. k. , and w. h. zurek , 1979 , phys . rev .
d * 19 * , 473 .
+ zeilinger , a. , 1997 , phil .
* 1733 * , 2401 - 2404 .
+ zeilinger , a. , 1999 , found .
* 29 * , 631 - 643 . | niels bohr wrote : there is no quantum world .
there is only an abstract quantum physical description .
it is wrong to think that the task of physics is to find out how nature is .
physics concerns what we can say about nature .
in an analogous way , von weizscker suggested that the notion of the elementary alternative , the `` ur '' , should play a pivotal role when constructing physics .
both approaches suggest that the concept of information should play an essential role in the foundations of any scientific description of nature .
we show that if , in our description of nature , we use one definite proposition per elementary constituent of nature , some of the essential characteristics of quantum physics , such as the irreducible randomness of individual events , quantum complementary and quantum entanglement , arise in a natural way .
then quantum physics is an elementary theory of information . *
dedicated to prof . c. f. von weizscker at the occasion of his @xmath0 birthday . * |
microlensing is an important method in detecting extrasolar planets .
it is sensitive to planets around the einstein radius @xcite @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the lens mass , @xmath2 is the lens - source relative parallax , and @xmath3 and @xmath4 are the distances to the lens and source , respectively . for typical microlensing events
, this angular scale corresponds to a physical size on the lens plane ( @xmath5 ) that typically lies somewhat beyond the `` snow line '' , the region that is believed to be the birth place of giant planets ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
to date , dozens of microlensing planets have been detected , enabling statistical studies of the frequency of distant bound planets @xcite , and unbound `` free - floating planets '' @xcite .
however , among dozens of microlensing events that have yielded planet detections , only two systems securely contain two planets @xcite , although most planets are believed to have been formed in multiple - planet systems .
in addition , ogle-2007-blg-349 is either a two - planet event or a single planet system orbited by a stellar binary companion @xcite .
this low yield of multiple - planet systems via microlensing is the result of both the lower probability of detecting these events and the challenge in interpreting the collected data .
the frequency of a microlensing event is @xmath6 yr@xmath7 star@xmath7 , of which only a few percent yield a planet detection .
for example , the optical gravitational lensing experiment ( ogle , * ? ? ?
* ) is monitoring @xmath8 stars in the galactic bulge , resulting in @xmath9 microlensing events per year but only @xmath10 planet detections per year .
the probability of detecting two - planet events is of order the product of the probability of detecting each of them @xcite , meaning that the expected number of two - planet events based on the past 15-year observations is roughly a few , consistent with the number of these events that have been observed .
the interpretation of an observed two - planet event is challenging .
for example , the first two - planet event ogle-2006-blg-109 @xcite shows five distinct caustic - crossing features caused by a jupiter / saturn analog , with both finite source effects and orbital motion effects involved . only with a thorough understanding about the caustic structures
can one figure out that the first , second , third and fifth features are due to one planet while the fourth feature is due to the other ( see the figure 2 of * ? ? ?
in fact , unlike both ogle-2006-blg-109 and ogle-2012-blg-0026 for which the two planets both show noticeable and separated perturbations , two - planet events can show noticeable perturbation(s ) of only one planet ( e.g. , ogle-2007-blg-349 , * ? ? ?
* ) , making it even more difficult to find the correct two - planet ( or triple - lens ) model . on the other hand , in the era of future microlensing experiments , the detection rate of multiple - planet events will increase significantly and thus the current understanding of such events must be improved in order to process the data in a timely way .
numerical simulations of the second - generation microlensing surveys [ i.e. , ogle iv , the microlensing observations in astrophysics ii ( moa , * ? ? ?
* ) , and especially the korea microlensing telescopes network ( kmtnet , * ? ? ?
* ) ] suggest that the planet detection rate will then be increased by at least a factor of several ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
space - based microlensing surveys like the wide field infrared space telescope ( wfirst , * ? ? ?
* ) and euclid @xcite will be able to increase the rate by another factor of @xmath10 .
studies of multiple - planet microlensing events are therefore a necessity .
various studies have been conducted related to multiple - planet events .
@xcite pointed out that multiple - planet events are more likely to be found in high - magnification ( @xmath11 ) events although the joint perturbation pattern around the peak of the light curve makes them difficult to interpret .
@xcite noticed that in many cases the central planetary perturbations induced by multiple planets can be well approximated by the superposition of the single - planet perturbations .
@xcite studied the degeneracies in the triple - lens case from a theoretical aspect .
both @xcite and @xcite found that the light curves produced by multiple - planet systems can sometimes be degenerate with that from a single planet system .
this double / triple lens degeneracy may lead to wrong planetary parameters as well as underestimation of the frequency of multiple - planet systems @xcite .
the present work is a follow - up paper to @xcite ( hereafter paper i ) in which microlensing simulations were conducted for realistic planetary systems drawn from planet population synthesis simulations .
this paper is focused on the ( candidate ) multiple - planet events produced by our simulation . in
2 we give an overview of our simulation .
results concerning the detectability of the second planet in the presence of the first planet , and the recovery of planetary parameters , are presented in 3 .
we discuss our results in 4 .
in paper i , we simulated 6690 microlensing events .
the lens systems are drawn from the @xcite core accretion model for @xmath12 stars .
we extracted 669 systems with at least one planet more massive than @xmath13 from 1000 ida & lin systems , based on which 6690 microlensing light curves for typical bulge microlensing events were simulated ( 10 for each system ) .
light curves were generated by inverse ray shooting @xcite and synthetic photometry generated to match the cadence and precision of kmtnet using the synthetic photometry code of @xcite and blending distributions of @xcite .
see paper i for more details .
simulated light curves were first fitted with a standard single - lens model .
we use @xmath14 to denote the deviation in @xmath15 of the best - fit single - lens model from the simulated data .
events with @xmath16 were picked out to generate single - planet ( double - lens ) light curves for the six most probably detectable planets .
these single - planet light curves were also subjected to single - lens modeling to determine the detectability of each planet considered by itself , which we denote as @xmath17 with @xmath18 the ranking of the planet in that system .
after the removal of `` bad '' events , for which the sources were so bright that the numerical precision of the ray shooting procedure was not adequate , and defining a planet as detectable when its @xmath19 , we finally confirmed @xmath20 planetary events , of which @xmath21 have two detectable planets and none has more than two . , but it can not be claimed as a three - planet event with sufficient confidence . ]
double - lens modeling was performed for the @xmath21 two - planet event candidates to examine the double / triple lens degeneracy .
the result of this double - lens modeling is denoted as @xmath22 , meaning the @xmath15 difference between the best - fit single - planet ( double - lens ) model and the theoretical model . with a threshold of @xmath23 , we then confirmed @xmath24 two - planet events out of the 23 candidate events ; that is , the remaining @xmath25 events with two detectable planets suffers the double / triple lens degeneracy .
statistical studies and implications based on these planetary events and two - planet events were presented in paper i.
we first investigate the influence of the first planet ( primary perturber ) on the detectability of the second planet ( secondary perturber ) .
we quantify the detectability of the second planet in the presence of the first planet as the difference in @xmath15 between the best - fit single - planet ( double - lens ) model and the input model , i.e. , @xmath22 . as is described in section
[ sec : overview ] , the detectability of the second planet when it is alone can be quantified by @xmath26 , which is the @xmath27 between the single - planet light curve ( produced by removing all the other planets except for planet 2 ) and its best - fit single - lens model . if @xmath28 , we consider the detectability of the second planet is suppressed due to the presence of the first planet .
otherwise it is enhanced .
we relate the change in the detectability of the second planet to the similarity between the planetary perturbations caused by the two responsible planets when they are considered separately .
we find that two - planet event candidates can be classified according to the similarity in perturbations .
events in which the two planetary perturbations appear at the same time ( difference of less than 0.2 day ) on the light curve and show either positive or negative correlations , are considered as type i events .
otherwise they are considered as type ii events .
we find that the detectability of the second planet is always suppressed by the presence of the first planet for type i events , as is shown in table [ tab : chi2-all ] .
in fact , in @xmath25 of type i events the suppression is so severe that the second planet is not a secure detection and therefore suffers the double / triple lens degeneracy .
we show two of them in figure [ fig : example - degenerate ] . for type ii events having noticeable planetary features induced by both planets ,
the detectability of the second planet is more or less conserved compared to the case when this planet is considered alone , suggesting that the detection of the two planets are independent .
the published two - planet events , ogle-2006-blg-109 @xcite and ogle-2012-blg-0026 @xcite , belong to this class , and an example of such event from our simulation is shown in figure 3 of paper i. for other type ii events , things are more complicated : the detectability of the second planet can either be suppressed or enhanced , and this can not be distinguished on the basis of the caustic types by which the planets are detected . for example , the two planets in events no.4247 and no.8451 are detected by the resonant caustic ( for planet 1 ) and the central caustic ( for planet 2 ) , but the detectability of the second planet is enhanced in no.4247 event while it is suppressed in no.8451 event . with the results of double - lens modeling of 23 two - planet event candidates , we find that in most cases the residuals in data after the subtraction of the best - fit double - lens model show similar patterns with that caused by the second planet when it was alone , suggesting that the overall planetary perturbation is a superposition of perturbations caused by the two responsible planets .
a similar conclusion has been reached by @xcite .
the lens system consists of detectable and undetectable planets .
the detectable planet(s ) can distort the light curve of a single lens ( the host star ) , while the undetectable planets can also affect the single - lens light curve by changing the center of magnification and the center of mass .
furthermore , due to the degeneracy existing between light curves arising from multiple- and single - planet events @xcite , multiple detectable planets may not all be recovered from the light curve .
in fact , as we have seen in table [ tab : chi2-all ] , 7 events having two planets detectable individually suffer such double / triple lens degeneracy and thus the recovered planetary parameters might not be physical , although in principle they should be close to the true parameters of one of the detectable planets ( the primary perturber ) . here
we investigate the deviation of the recovered planetary parameters from the true parameters .
in paper i we have mentioned that @xmath29 of all single - planet events can be reproduced very well by the corresponding single - planet light curve without any fitting . here
we investigate how the planetary parameters are perturbed in the remaining @xmath30 ( i.e. , 41 ) single - planet events .
when we look into the planetary systems that cause these events , massive ( @xmath31 ) and either far ( @xmath32 ) away from or close ( @xmath33 ) to the host star planets ( in some cases brown dwarfs ) appear in all these 41 cases .
in addition , most of these events are non - caustic - crossing events .
for all these 41 events , we fit a double - lens model to the simulated data , with the true planetary parameters as the initial seed .
the best - fit planetary parameters , i.e. , planet - to - star mass ratio @xmath34 and projected separation @xmath35 , given by these double - lens models , are displayed in figure [ fig : recovery - single ] , with the true parameters shown for comparison .
figure [ fig : recovery - single ] shows that even for events for which undetectable planets perturb the single - planet light curves , the planetary parameters recovered by modeling the light curve still represent the true parameters very well , although in very few cases , the planetary mass ratio can be off by a factor of two ( e.g. , no .
1290 and 3501 events , as are indicated in figure [ fig : recovery - single ] ) , an example of which is shown in figure [ fig : no-1290 ] .
these marginally detected planets appear in non - caustic - crossing events , and are therefore more easily affected by non - detectable planets in the same system , as is confirmed in figure [ fig : comparison - single ] which shows the ratio between the recovered and true planetary parameters with respect to the detectability of the planet quantified by @xmath14 . on the other hand , planets in events with high @xmath14 can all be recovered very well , since the very distinct structures on the light curves due to approaching or crossing the caustics are robust to perturbation by distant planets . due to the similarity between the planetary perturbation patterns caused by the two detectable planets when considered separately , 7 out of the 23 two - planet event candidates do not have large enough @xmath22 to claim the detection of the second planet .
the planetary parameters that are recovered should therefore deviate from the values of either planet 1 or planet 2 .
we quote the closer one between the two detectable planets in the mass ratio - separation parameter space as the true position of the recovered planet .
we list in table [ tab : degeneracy ] and illustrate in figure [ fig : recovery - degenerate ] the most important parameters , i.e. , mass ratio @xmath34 and projected separation @xmath35 , of the two detectable planets and the recovered planet .
we find that the deviation in the projected separation ( @xmath35 ) is below @xmath36 , while the deviation in mass ratio ( @xmath34 ) is within @xmath37 , from the true planet .
therefore , even in events suffering the double / triple lens degeneracy , the planet recovered from modeling the microlensing light curve is still a good representative of one of the true planets .
we show in figure [ fig : psi - dist ] the distributions of intersection angles between two responsible planets for two - planet events with ( i.e. , two - planet event candidates ) and without ( i.e. , confirmed two - planet events ) these double / triple lens degeneracy , with respect to the distribution of all planetary events , in which for single - planet events the intersection angle between two most detectable planets is used .
a kolmogorov - smirnov test between the all planetary events sample and the two - planet event candidates sample shows that the probability of the two distribution being extracted from the same distribution is @xmath38 , while it is @xmath39 between all planetary events sample and the confirmed two - planet events sample .
the discrepancy between the results of these two ks tests suggests that there may be some preferred intersections angles for the double / triple lens degeneracy .
we also investigate the influence of the undetectable planets on the parameter recovery in two - planet events , by employing triple - lens fits to the simulated light curves .
the recovered planetary parameters with respect to the original parameters for 16 two - planet events are shown in figure [ fig : recovery-2p ] , and the ratio between these two as a function of the detectability of the planet is shown in figure [ fig : comparison-2p ] .
similar to what has been seen in the case of single - planet events , the two planets are recovered very well in most events , meaning that the remaining undetectable planets in these systems have a negligible influence on the two detectable planets , although the recovered planet masses in no.8770 event deviate from the true values by a factor of three , which also comes from the perturbation of a distant ( @xmath40 ) massive ( @xmath41 ) planet . the light curve and caustic structure of this event
is shown in figure [ fig : no-8770 ] . as with figure [ fig : comparison - single ] for the single - planet case
, figure [ fig : comparison-2p ] also indicates that the planets detected with lower @xmath27 in two - planet events are more easily affected by the undetectable planets in the same system .
the planetary close / wide degeneracy @xcite has been found in two - planet events , both observationally @xcite and theoretically @xcite , in the case when two planets are both detected via central caustics .
we find that the second planet in no.3194 event also suffers this close / wide degeneracy ( @xmath42 ) , despite the fact that the first planet has noticeable signatures caused by crossing its planetary caustic .
in this work , by simulating microlensing light curves of realistic multi - planet systems , we are trying to answer two questions : 1 ) when will the detectability of a second planet be suppressed or enhanced in the presence of the first planet , and 2 ) whether and how can the other detectable or undetectable planets in the same lens system affect the parameter recovery of the detected planets .
we find that the influence of the first planet on the detectability of the second planet is strongly correlated with the similarity between the planetary perturbations caused by the two detectable planets when they are considered separately .
particularly , when the two detectable planets show similar perturbation patterns , the detectability of the second planet is always suppressed by the presence of the first planet ; in some cases , such suppressions may be so strong that no signs of the perturbation caused by the second planet can be seen in the residuals after the subtraction of the best - fit double - lens ( single - planet ) model , meaning that these events suffer the double / triple lens degeneracy .
our result also confirms the well established result that the overall perturbation pattern in multiple - planet events is usually a superposition of the that of individual planets @xcite , indicating that the modeling of two - planet events can mostly be decomposed . we compared the planetary parameters recovered from modeling the microlensing light curves with the input parameters , for single - planet events , double / triple lens degenerate events and double - planet events . in a large majority of the investigated events
, the planetary parameters can be recovered very well .
however , we also notice that in a very few low - magnification events in which the planets are marginally detected , the recovered planetary mass ratio can deviate from the true value by a factor of two to three , due to the existence of a distant massive companion to the lens star .
the fraction of such events in the two - planet case ( 1/16 ) is larger than , but still statistically consistent with , that in the single - planet case ( 4/274 ) , suggesting that the deviation in planetary parameters due to unmodeled massive planets does not become worse in the multiple - planet case .
however , although such events contribute a very small fraction to the total planetary events in our simulation , we conjecture that this problem may be more serious for the case of more massive companions , namely stars . in paper
i , we confirmed that follow - up observations are still necessary in extracting the full power of high - magnification events in the era of the second - generation microlensing experiments .
in fact , follow - up observations are also necessary for the detection of multiple - planet systems . in two - planet events , for example , although the detectability of the second planet is suppressed by the presence of the first planet in most cases , this suppression can be compensated by the intensive follow - up observations which are more likely initiated by detecting the first planet , since the planetary perturbation of the first planet , the primary perturber , is larger and sustained longer .
the much more intensive ( @xmath43 min compared to 10 min of kmtnet ) observations conducted by the follow - up teams ( e.g. , @xmath44fun , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) can therefore compensate the suppression due to the first planet .
furthermore , with follow - up observations , one would expect to detect more multiple - planet events and more lower - mass planets than under the survey - only mode ( gould et al .
2014 ) .
we would like to thank shigeru ida and doug lin for providing us the data from their population synthesis models , and thijs kouwenhoven and rainer spurzem for providing us their computing facilities .
thanks the chinese academy of sciences for a visiting professorship .
this work has been partly supported by the strategic priority research program `` the emergence of cosmological structures '' of the chinese academy of sciences grant no .
xdb09000000 , and by the national natural science foundation of china ( nsfc ) under grant numbers 11333003 ( sm and wz ) .
this work was also supported by nsf grant ast 1103471 ( wz and ag ) and nasa nngx12ab99 g
( ag ) . an , j. h. 2005 , , 356 , 1409 bennett , d. p. , rhie , s. h. , nikolaev , s. , et al .
2010 , , 713 , 837 bond , i. a. , abe , f. , dodd , r. j. , et al .
2001 , , 327 , 868 cassan , a. , kubas , d. , beaulieu , j .-
, et al .
2012 , , 481 , 167 dominik , m. 1999 , , 349 , 108 dong , s. , gould , a. , cassan , a. , 2014 , in preparation gaudi , b. s. , naber , r. m. , & sackett , p. d. 1998 , , 502 , l33 gaudi , b. s. , bennett , d. p. , udalski , a. , et al .
2008 , science , 319 , 927 gaudi , b. s. 2012 , , 50 , 411 gould , a. , & loeb , a. 1992 , , 396 , 104 gould , a. , udalski , a. , an , d. , et al .
2006 , , 644 , l37 gould , a. , dong , s. , gaudi , b. s. , et al .
2010 , , 720 , 1073 gould , a. , udalski , a. , shin , i .-
, et al .
2014 , science , 345 , 46 han , c. 2005 , , 629 , 1102 han , c. , udalski , a. , choi , j .- y .
, et al .
2013 , , 762 , l28 henderson , c. b. , gaudi , b. s. , han , c. , et al .
2014 , arxiv:1406.2316 kim , s .- l . , park , b .-
g . , lee , c .- u . , et al .
2010 , , 7733 , ida , s. , & lin , d. n. c. 2004 , , 604 , 388 ida , s. , & lin , d. n. c. 2004 , , 616 , 567 ida , s. , & lin , d. n. c. 2005 , , 626 , 1045 ida , s. , & lin , d. n. c. 2008 , , 673 , 487 ida , s. , & lin , d. n. c. 2008 , , 685 , 584 ida , s. , & lin , d. n. c. 2010 , , 719 , 810 mao , s. , & paczynski , b. 1991 , , 374 , l37 penny , m. t. , mao , s. , & kerins , e. 2011 , , 412 , 607 penny , m. t. , kerins , e. , rattenbury , n. , et al .
2013 , , 434 , 2 schneider , p. , & weiss , a. 1986 , , 164 , 237 schneider , p. , & weiss , a. 1987 , , 171 , 49 shvartzvald , y. , & maoz , d. 2012 , , 419 , 3631 smith , m. c. , woniak , p. , mao , s. , & sumi , t. 2007 , , 380 , 805 song , y .- y . ,
mao , s. , & an , j. h. 2014 , , 437 , 4006 spergel , d. , gehrels , n. , breckinridge , j. , et al .
2013 , arxiv:1305.5422 sumi , t. , bennett , d. p. , bond , i. a. , et al .
2010 , , 710 , 1641 sumi , t. , kamiya , k. , bennett , d. p. , et al .
2011 , , 473 , 349 ryu , y .- h . ,
chang , h .- y .
, & park , m .-
2011 , , 412 , 503 udalski , a. 2003 , , 53 , 291 zhu , w. , penny , m. , mao , s. , gould , a. , & gendron , r. 2014 , , 788 , 73 + 290 & 7 & @xmath46 & @xmath47 & @xmath48 & @xmath49 & @xmath50 & @xmath51 & @xmath52 , @xmath53 + 1689 & 56 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & @xmath60 , @xmath61 + 3247 & 18 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 & @xmath68 , @xmath69 + 3689 & 7 & @xmath54 & @xmath70 & @xmath56 & @xmath57 & @xmath71 & @xmath72 & @xmath73 , @xmath74 + 5797 & 25 & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath57 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 , @xmath37 + 7290 & 36 & @xmath48 & @xmath81 & @xmath46 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 , @xmath86 + 7451 & 19 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 , @xmath94 + | we undertake the first study of two - planet microlensing models recovered from simulations of microlensing events generated by realistic multi - planet systems in which 292 planetary events including 16 two - planet events were detected from 6690 simulated light curves .
we find that when two planets are recovered , their parameters are usually close to those of the two planets in the system most responsible for the perturbations .
however , in one of the 16 examples , the apparent mass of both detected planets was more than doubled by the unmodeled influence of a third , massive planet .
this fraction is larger than , but statistically consistent with , the roughly 1.5% rate of serious mass errors due to unmodeled planetary companions for the 274 cases from the same simulation in which a single planet is recovered .
we conjecture that an analogous effect due to unmodeled stellar companions may occur more frequently . for seven out of 23 cases
in which two planets in the system would have been detected separately , only one planet was recovered because the perturbations due to the two planets had similar forms .
this is a small fraction ( 7/274 ) of all recovered single - planet models , but almost a third of all events that might plausibly have led to two - planet models .
still , in these cases , the recovered planet tends to have parameters similar to one of the two real planets most responsible for the anomaly . |
the quest for a quantum theory of gravity is now several decades old and has been studied with approaches ranging from string theory and non - commutative geometry to loop quantum gravity , spin foams , and discrete models of planck - scale spacetime .
most of these take different interpretations of what a quantum theory of gravity should achieve , but with one thing in common : that it should be some merger of general relativity and quantum theory
. the final goal has not yet been achieved , but all these approaches have brought to us new understandings of the problem . we come to the motivation for this paper by putting together a consistent list of features , selectively chosen from among the various indications of what a quantum theory of gravity may be .
such a list is by no means unique , but we will find that it is fruitful ; it leads to a new notion of quantum cosmology and a new formulation of evolution in a planck - scale theory .
our list is the following : 1 ) at energies close to the planck scale , the description of spacetime as a continuous , @xmath0-dimensional manifold breaks down ; this is the usual idea for regularization of quantum field theory .
2 ) causality is still present in planck - scale geometry .
3 ) quantum theory is valid in planck - scale physics .
4 ) in a fundamental theory of the universe , there should be a finite number of degrees of freedom in any finite region of the universe ; this is supported by black hole entropy calculations from both string theory and loop quantum gravity , and bekenstein s physical arguments .
5 ) the theory should be background independent .
quantum causal histories ( qch ) were introduced in @xcite as a formalism for quantum cosmology that realizes most of the above assumptions .
the idea is to use a causal set ( locally finite , partially ordered set ) as the description of the causal structure of the universe .
quantum theory is present through the assignment of finite - dimensional hilbert spaces to these events .
they can be regarded as representing the fundamental building blocks of the universe at the planck scale .
the composite hilbert space for two spacelike separated events is the tensor product of the individual hilbert spaces .
evolution is implemented by unitary operators between complete pairs , special cases of sets of spacelike separated events which can be understood as isolated planck - scale systems , or the discrete equivalent of successive cauchy surfaces of an isolated component of spacetime . clearly , this implements the first four properties above .
the fifth is more difficult ( and will not be resolved here ) .
because it involves a fixed causal structure , a qch is not a completely background independent description .
nevertheless , all other degrees of freedom are quantum , and with the algebraic treatment presented here this may be a step toward a truly background independent model .
quantum causal histories can also describe causal spin foam models ( see the review @xcite ) .
these are pre - spacetime models ; that is , gravity and the familiar spacetime manifold are meant to be derived as the low - energy continuum approximation of such models .
a particular example of a qch is a causal spin network @xcite and this was a principal motivation for the introduction of qch s .
a variation on the idea of a qch was applied to a spin foam model in @xcite . however , as was already discussed in @xcite , the definition of qch there does not adequately take into account the causal structure of the underlying causal set . in particular , the unitary evolution operators in that definition are indifferent to the individual relations interpolating between the ingoing and outgoing events .
the same unitary evolution is admitted regardless of these individual relations .
this means that the quantum evolution does not respect the underlying causal structure .
further , given two related events , there might not be a complete pair containing them , in which case we can not say anything about the relation between states at the two events .
these issues are discussed in detail in the next section . in this paper
we address all of the above issues by giving a revised definition for a quantum causal history in which the causal structure is faithfully reflected in the quantum causal history .
we find that doing so requires working with algebras of operators , instead of hilbert spaces , on the events . following the above idea of local finiteness at the fundamental level ,
these algebras are simple matrix c@xmath1-algebras .
we find that a causal relation in the causal set corresponds to a completely positive map in the qch .
this is not surprising , since this is the most general kind of physical transformation allowed by quantum theory .
we also show that these maps can be regarded as fundamental and the unitary operators of the original definition can be reconstructed from them with no loss of information . as a quantum cosmology ,
a qch is most naturally interpreted as describing the universe as a very large collection of open quantum mechanical building blocks .
unitary evolution arises only where there is a complete pair , which is the discrete analogue of an isolated system .
this is much more general than a wheeler - dewitt type of quantum cosmology . that `` canonical '' approach to quantum gravity is strongly dependent on global hyperbolicity and cauchy surfaces .
in contrast , qch s allow that hyperbolicity may dissolve in the quantum foam .
this seems more likely to describe the apparent non - unitarity of black hole evaporation than does the more traditional approach .
a qch is also especially suited for describing the evolution of localized quantities without having to refer to a path integral or hamiltonian constraint for the entire universe .
aside from cosmology , we see with hindsight that there are several further ways of interpreting a qch ; we discuss these in section [ qft ] and the conclusions .
concretely , the present paper is an in - depth analysis of qch s and opens up several new possibilities for the concrete implementation of models of that type .
for example , it is interesting , and potentially practical , that evolution in a qch is almost identical to the quantum information theoretic description of quantum noise . also , the continuous time analogue of the completely positive evolution in a qch , is a master equation , already extensively used in quantum cosmology .
we comment on these connections in the conclusions .
the outline of this paper is as follows . in section [ qch ] , we review the original definition of quantum causal histories given in @xcite , as well as the definitions of the basic structures in a causal set that are needed for the rest of the paper .
one of our main results is that the relations in a causal set correspond to completely positive maps in the qch . in order to give the reader some intuition about these maps before they have to face the precise definition of a qch and the following proof that unitary evolution can be reconstructed from them , we give in section [ cpmaps ] a basic introduction to completely positive maps and a simple example .
section [ ach ] is the revised , complete definition of a qch .
although this was not a motivation for this work , this definition can be understood as an algebraic quantum field theory on a causal set , with the operator algebras being simple matrix c@xmath1-algebras .
we explain this in section [ qft ] . in section
[ proof ] , we show that nothing is lost in going from the unitary operators of the original definition to the completely positive maps , since the former can be reconstructed from the latter , up to irrelevant phase factors .
we discuss the interpretation of our results and future directions in the conclusions .
in this section we review quantum causal histories .
they were defined in @xcite as a general formalism for causal spin foams in quantum gravity @xcite .
an important and distinguishing feature of the geometry of spacetime ( as opposed to space ) is causal structure .
if a spacetime is time - orientable and has no closed timelike curves , then its causal structure can be completely described as a partial order relation on the events ( points ) of the spacetime .
the definition of the relation is that @xmath2 ( `` @xmath3 precedes @xmath4 '' ) if there exists a future - directed non - spacelike curve from @xmath3 to @xmath4 .
this relation is transitive , i.e. , if @xmath2 and @xmath5 then @xmath6 , because future - directed curves can be concatenated .
the assumption that there exist no closed timelike curves means precisely that @xmath2 and @xmath7 if and only if @xmath8 .
these are the defining properties of a _ partial order relation_. we are concerned here with a discrete analogue of a smooth spacetime .
causal set _
@xmath9 is a locally finite , partially ordered set .
that is , for any two events @xmath10 , there exist ( at most ) finitely many events @xmath11 such that @xmath12 .
if either @xmath2 or @xmath7 , then we say that the events @xmath3 and @xmath4 are _
related_. if two events are not related , then we say that they are _ spacelike separated _ and write @xmath13 . an _ acausal set _ is a subset @xmath14 such that all events in @xmath15 are spacelike separated to one another , i.e. , @xmath16 .
acausal sets play the role of spacelike hypersurfaces in causal sets .
a causal set can usefully represented by the ( directed ) graph of elementary relations ( fig .
[ cpairs ] ) .
the set of vertices is simply @xmath9 .
there is an edge @xmath17 if @xmath2 but there does not exist any @xmath11 such that @xmath12 .
there is a simple analogue of a future - directed non - spacelike curve in a causal set .
a _ future - directed path _ is a directed path through the graph , that is , a sequence of events such that there exists an edge from each event to the next .
a future - directed path is _ future ( past ) inextendible _ if there exists no event in @xmath9 which is in the future ( past ) of the entire path .
note that this graph generates the partial ordering : @xmath2 if and only if there exists a future directed path from @xmath3 to @xmath4 . from this
, we can define complete future and past .
an acausal set @xmath15 is a _ complete future _ of an event @xmath3 if @xmath15 intersects any future - inextendible future - directed path that starts at @xmath3 .
similarly , an acausal set @xmath15 is a _ complete past _ of an event @xmath3 if @xmath15 intersects any past - inextendible future - directed path that ends at @xmath3 . in order to describe a local quantum structure on our causal set , we would like a ( finite - dimensional ) hilbert space @xmath18 for every event @xmath19 . for two spacelike
separated events @xmath20 , the composite state space for @xmath21 is @xmath22 .
more generally , for any acausal set @xmath23 , @xmath24 . in quantum mechanics ,
time evolution is unitary evolution between the hilbert spaces at different times . when should we expect unitary maps between the hilbert spaces for different acausal sets @xmath25 ?
unitarity can be interpreted as meaning that no information is lost or added .
we can only expect that no information is lost in evolving from @xmath15 to @xmath26 if @xmath26 is a complete future of @xmath15 ; otherwise , information coming from @xmath15 might `` miss '' @xmath26 .
likewise , we can only expect a state at @xmath26 to be completely determined by one at @xmath15 if @xmath15 is a complete past of @xmath26 . when both of these conditions are satisfied
@xmath15 is a complete past of @xmath26 and @xmath26 is a complete future of @xmath15 we call @xmath15 and @xmath26 a complete pair and write @xmath27
. we should expect a unitary map @xmath28 if and only if @xmath27 .
one can think of a complete pair as successive cauchy surfaces of an isolated component of spacetime , or of all spacetime ( see fig .
[ cpairs ] ) .
this leads to the definition of a quantum causal history given in @xcite .
it consists of a causal set @xmath9 , a finite - dimensional hilbert space @xmath18 for every @xmath19 , and a unitary map @xmath29 for any complete pair @xmath27 , such that for @xmath30 , @xmath31 with this definition , the unitary maps on the complete pairs tell us very little about the causal relations between the two acausal sets
. there can be many configurations of the interpolating causal relations in a complete pair , for example : the rules of a quantum causal history tell us that there is a unitary map @xmath32 , but not how it should depend on the interpolating causal relations .
this is insufficient .
consider for example the complete pair : if we start with an unentangled pure state @xmath33 , then this will evolve to @xmath34 .
the state at @xmath35 is described by a density matrix , @xmath36 . with this causal structure
, the state at @xmath35 should be completely determined by that at @xmath4 . in other words
@xmath37 should be independent of @xmath38 .
however , with the above definition of a quantum causal history , there is no restriction on @xmath39 that would prevent @xmath37 from depending upon @xmath38 .
another problem with this definition is the reliance on complete pairs . given two related events @xmath2 , there may not exist a complete pair containing these events .
if so , with this definition of a quantum causal history , we do not know anything about the relation between states at @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
there should be some relation , and the concept of quantum causal history must be refined to provide this . in this paper
we address all of the above issues by giving a revised definition of a quantum causal history in which the causal structure of @xmath9 is faithfully reflected in the quantum causal history .
we will define the qch as an assignment of completely positive maps to pairs of causally related events .
these maps relate the local observables at the causally related events . in the next section
we introduce the definition of a completely positive map on open quantum mechanical systems , in order to provide some intuition for the evolution in qch before giving the new definition and results in sections [ ach ] and [ proof ] .
an ordinary quantum mechanical system may be isolated , or it may be coupled to some environment .
the states of the system can be described with density matrices and the most general evolution that quantum mechanics allows for such a system is a linear , trace - preserving , completely positive ( cp ) map . in this section
we define cp maps and discuss their physical interpretation .
consider a system @xmath40 in some mixed state given by @xmath41 , a density matrix on its hilbert space .
let @xmath40 interact with an environment @xmath42 , also in a mixed state @xmath43 .
the evolution of the joint system is given by a unitary operator @xmath44 .
the process could be such that it is not feasible to extract the system @xmath40 again , but instead we extract @xmath45 , which has a density matrix @xmath46 .
see fig.[cpex ] .
the transformation from @xmath41 to @xmath46 is given by a map @xmath47 of the form @xmath48.\ ] ] such generic transformations from a quantum system to another are maps from the set of density matrices on @xmath40 to the set of density matrices on @xmath45 that satisfy the following conditions : _ linear on the set of density matrices : _ a probabilistic mixture of inputs leads to a probabilistic mixture of outputs , i.e. , for probabilities @xmath49 , @xmath50 _ trace - preserving : _
this simply means that the normalization is preserved for any density matrix .
the total probability for _ anything _ to happen is , and remains , @xmath52 . _
positive : _ probabilities are never negative , and so a density matrix has to be a positive operator ( i.e. , self - adjoint with only non - negative eigenvalues ) in order to describe a physical system .
this is preserved by @xmath53 : if @xmath41 is positive , then @xmath54 is also positive .
note that this implies that @xmath55 for any matrix @xmath56 .
_ completely positive : _ it turns out that positivity is not enough for @xmath53 to describe a physical process .
suppose that we couple the system @xmath40 to another system @xmath42 that has trivial dynamics , @xmath57 .
for all such trivial extensions , @xmath58 should also be positive .
this is the condition of complete positivity .
complete positivity ensures that the evolution of @xmath40 is extendible in a trivial way to a physical evolution in a larger system @xmath59 .
it is useful because it covers the case where @xmath40 is initially entangled with some distant isolated system .
a completely positive map on density matrices is equivalent to a completely positive map of observable operators in the opposite direction ( in this case , backwards in time ) .
a trace - preserving cp map of density matrices is dual to a unital . ]
cp map of observables .
the most general setting for completely positive maps is between c@xmath1-algebras ( see @xcite ) . in that context
, there are many important tools for working with cp maps .
in particular , the stinespring construction shows that any unital cp map from a c@xmath1-algebra to the algebra of bounded operators on a hilbert space can be written in a universal form , as a representation of the c@xmath1-algebra on a larger hilbert space , composed with the projection onto the smaller hilbert space .
a quantum causal history can be reexpressed in terms of matrix algebras . nothing is lost but trivial phase factors . to any event @xmath60 , we associate the algebra , @xmath61 \mbox,\ ] ] of matrices acting on @xmath18 .
likewise , for any acausal @xmath62 there is the algebra , @xmath63 = \bigotimes_{x\in\xi } { \mathcal{a}}(x ) \mbox.\ ] ] the inner products on the hilbert spaces lead to involutions on the algebras . in this way , they can be regarded as c@xmath1-algebras .
what do the unitary maps @xmath64 give us ?
for a complete pair @xmath27 , @xmath64 determines a @xmath65-isomorphism , @xmath66 if we are only interested in states ( and not phase - factors ) , then @xmath53 does not lose any important information from @xmath64 .
note that the maps @xmath53 are directed backward in time .
this is because we are regarding the matrix algebras as consisting of observable operators acting on the hilbert spaces of local states .
this is equivalent to a map of states ( density matrices ) in the other direction .
indeed , states should evolve into the future .
however , because the unitary maps we are starting with are invertible , everything that we are doing can be expressed equivalently with time reversed . what does @xmath64 give us more locally ?
if @xmath67 , then @xmath68 can be naturally thought of as a unital subalgebra of @xmath69 .
thus , when @xmath27 and @xmath67 , there is a unital @xmath65-homomorphism , @xmath70 , given by restricting @xmath71 to @xmath68 .
however , this is as far as homomorphisms will go . for @xmath72 and @xmath67
the naturally induced map @xmath73 is not a homomorphism ; it is only completely positive .
see fig.[maps1 ] . before describing the construction , we should note some properties of the algebras that we are working with .
they are simple , finite - dimensional matrix algebras defined on hilbert spaces . as such , they can be viewed in several ways and have convenient structures that are not available with most infinite - dimensional algebras .
we have already noted that they are c@xmath1-algebras .
they are also vonneumann algebras , and because they are simple , they are ( type i ) vonneumann factors .
we will make use of the trace on such an algebra ; however , we will take advantage of the finiteness and use the normalized trace , given by the formula , @xmath74 the advantage of this will be to maintain the time - reversal symmetry of the formalism as explicitly as possible ; the disadvantage is a slightly unorthodox normalization for density matrices ( @xmath75 is correctly normalized ) . using the trace and the involution
, we can construct an inner product on a matrix algebra , @xmath76 making the algebra into a hilbert space as well . since our algebras are hilbert spaces , the linear maps among them have adjoints .
in particular , if @xmath77 is a linear map respecting the involution @xmath65 , the definition of its adjoint , @xmath78 reduces to the property that for any @xmath79 and @xmath80 , @xmath81=\tau_b[v(a)b]$ ] .
we denote the adjoint of a map with a dagger to avoid confusion with the c@xmath1-algebra involution @xmath82 .
the adjoint of a homomorphism will not generally be a homomorphism , however , it will be a completely positive ( cp ) map .
the adjoint of any cp map is cp .
if @xmath77 is cp , and @xmath83 and @xmath84 are subalgebras , then define the _ reduction _ of @xmath85 to @xmath86 to be the cp map @xmath87 , where @xmath88 and @xmath89 are the inclusions . @xmath90
a quantum causal history thus leads to cp maps for pairs of events . specifically , if @xmath27 , @xmath72 , and @xmath67 , then @xmath91 is the reduction of @xmath71 .
maps for pairs of related events give a more local description of a quantum causal history than maps for complete pairs of acausal sets . in a local description
, we should regard the maps @xmath92 as fundamental , and specify consistency conditions on them .
this leads to two questions , do local consistency conditions exist , and is any information lost in going from global homomorphisms to local cp maps ? the answers , we will show , are yes and no . there is one circumstance in which the adjoint of a homomorphism is another homomorphism . [ unitary ]
if @xmath93 is an isomorphism , then @xmath94 is its inverse ( also an isomorphism ) .
homomorphisms in this category are trace - preserving .
so , for @xmath95 and @xmath80 , @xmath96 = \tau_b\left[v(a\,v^{-1}(b))\right ] = \tau_a[a\,v^{-1}(b ) ] \mbox.\ ] ] thus @xmath97 .
so , for @xmath27 , @xmath71 and @xmath98 are both isomorphisms .
there is thus a time - reversal covariance ; this should be reflected in our axioms .
states on matrix algebras are all given by density matrices .
specifically , a density matrix is a positive matrix @xmath41 with @xmath99 ; the expectation value of a matrix @xmath56 is @xmath100 . the map of algebras @xmath101 induces a pullback map from states at @xmath3 to states at @xmath4 .
this is simply the adjoint @xmath102 applied to density matrices .
when the map of algebras is a homomorphism , the map of states will take pure states to pure states .
suppose that @xmath15 and @xmath26 are acausal sets , not necessarily a complete pair , but that @xmath26 is a complete future of @xmath15 . in this case , no information should be lost in going from @xmath15 to @xmath26 , and pure states should map to pure states .
thus , there should be a homomorphism @xmath103 .
conversely , if instead @xmath15 is a complete past of @xmath26 , then there should exist @xmath103 such that @xmath98 is a homomorphism .
suppose that @xmath104 and that @xmath15 is a complete past of both .
the homomorphisms @xmath105 and @xmath106 are restrictions of @xmath107 .
so , for @xmath108 and @xmath109 , @xmath110 thus the images of @xmath105 and @xmath106 must commute .
if such @xmath53 s exist , and the @xmath111 s are reductions of them , then they will satisfy the following properties .
a quantum causal history consists of a simple matrix c@xmath1-algebra @xmath112 for every event @xmath19 and a completely positive map @xmath113 for every pair of related events @xmath2 , satisfying the following axioms .
_ axiom 1 : _ ( extension ) for any @xmath114 and @xmath62 a complete past of @xmath4 , there exists a homomorphism @xmath115 such that for each @xmath72 , the reduction of @xmath116 to @xmath117 is @xmath111 .
likewise , for any @xmath118 a complete future of @xmath4 , there exists a map @xmath119 such that @xmath120 is a homomorphism and for any @xmath67 , the reduction ( restriction ) of @xmath121 to @xmath122 is @xmath123 .
see fig.[ax1 ] _ axiom 2 : _
( spacelike commutativity ) if @xmath124 and @xmath14 is a complete past of @xmath4 and @xmath35 , then the images of @xmath125 and @xmath116 ( in @xmath126 ) commute . likewise ,
if @xmath118 is a complete future of @xmath127 , then the images of @xmath128 and @xmath129 commute .
see fig.[ax2 ] .
_ axiom 3 : _ ( composition ) if @xmath26 is a complete future of @xmath3 and a complete past of @xmath4 , then @xmath130 .
this notion of quantum causal history can also be motivated from the ideas of algebraic quantum field theory .
algebraic quantum field theory ( see @xcite ) is a general approach to quantum field theory based on algebras of local observables , the relations among them , and their representations .
the correct choice of axioms is still a matter of research , but for our purposes , these subtleties are largely irrelevant .
an algebraic quantum field theory associates a vonneumann algebra to each causally complete region of spacetime .
this generalizes easily to causal sets .
the following definitions are exactly the same as for continuous spacetime . for any subset @xmath131 , define the _ causal complement _ as @xmath132 the set of events which are spacelike to all of @xmath133 .
the _ causal completion _ of @xmath133 is @xmath134 , and @xmath133 is _ causally complete _ if @xmath135 . a causal complement is always causally complete ( i.e. , @xmath136 ) . in the most restrictive axiomatic formulation of algebraic quantum field theory
there is a vonneumann algebra @xmath137 for every causally complete region ; these all share a common hilbert space .
whenever @xmath138 , @xmath139 .
for any causally complete region @xmath133 , @xmath140 is @xmath141 , the commutant of @xmath137 .
the algebra associated to the causal completion of @xmath142 is generated by @xmath137 and @xmath143 .
some of the standard arguments about the properties of the local vonneumann algebras are valid for causal sets ; some are not .
the algebras should all be simple ( i.e. , vonneumann factors ) because the theory would otherwise have local superselection sectors . for continuous spacetime
it is believed that the local algebras should be type iii@xmath144 hyperfinite factors ; however , the reasoning involves the assumption that there exists a good ultraviolet scaling limit .
this does not apply here ; the small - scale structure of a causal set is discrete and not self similar at all .
instead , it seems reasonable ( following property 4 in the introduction ) that only a finite amount of structure should be entrusted to each event . in other words ,
each vonneumann algebra should be a finite - dimensional matrix algebra . in vonneumann algebra terms
, these are finite type i factors .
consider the causal completion @xmath145 of a finite acausal set @xmath15 ; @xmath146 should be generated by the algebras @xmath112 for @xmath72 .
in fact , these algebras should commute , and therefore @xmath147 evolution by homomorphisms is sometimes possible . if @xmath15 and @xmath26 are acausal sets such that @xmath148 , then @xmath149 and so @xmath150 .
this inclusion is the evolution homomorphism when @xmath15 is a complete past of @xmath26 .
not surprisingly , simple matrix algebras are much easier to work with than type iii vonneumann factors . using the ( unique ) normalized trace , any state is given by a density matrix .
recall that the adjoint maps @xmath102 in a quantum causal history are the induced maps on density matrices .
suppose that @xmath151 is a density matrix at @xmath3 .
the density matrix @xmath152 is the best approximation to @xmath41 among density matrices at @xmath4 , in the sense that it minimizes the trace norm of the difference .
the trace norm metric on density matrices is equal to the metric on states induced by the operator norm on observables .
so , we see that the obvious notion of an algebraic quantum field theory on a causal set , with the physically reasonable assumption of finite algebras on events , gives the structure of a qch .
the two concepts intersect , but are not equivalent .
one could ignore the arguments about entropy _
et cetera _ and consider a field theory with infinite algebras on events ; however , depending upon the choice of algebras , even this might be described by some suitable generalization of a qch .
likewise , a given qch can not necessarily be derived from an algebraic quantum field theory .
this does mean that the structure of a qch encompasses a reasonable notion of a quantum field theory , and hence is capable of describing matter degrees of freedom .
it also indicates how quantum fields on curved spacetime might be obtained as a limit of some quantum gravity model based on qch s .
finally , this gives the skeptical reader another possible motivation for considering quantum causal histories .
in this section we show that , if we start with the cp maps on the causal relations as the fundamental evolution operators , we can recover the unitary operators between the complete pairs .
the main result is that the axioms in the definition of a quantum causal history imply the following theorem : [ main ] for any acausal sets @xmath153 , if @xmath26 is a complete future of @xmath15 or @xmath15 is a complete past of @xmath26 then there exists a unique map @xmath154 such that 1 . for any @xmath72 and @xmath67 , the reduction of @xmath71 to @xmath73 is @xmath92 .
if @xmath15 is a complete past of @xmath26 , then @xmath71 is a homomorphism .
if @xmath26 is a complete future of @xmath15 , then @xmath98 is a homomorphism .
if @xmath27 is a complete pair , then @xmath71 is an isomorphism .
5 . if @xmath30 , then @xmath155 . in order to prove this , we first need to prove the uniqueness aspect .
let @xmath156 , _ et cetera _ be ( finitely many ) simple , finite - dimensional , matrix algebras .
let @xmath157 .
any unital homomorphism @xmath158 has a reduction @xmath159 for each @xmath160 .
we need to show that two distinct homomorphisms will have distinct reductions .
let @xmath161 be some unital homomorphism .
any other unital homomorphism can be obtained from this by composing it with an automorphism of @xmath162 .
all homomorphisms in this category are injective , so to simplify notation , regard @xmath163 as a subalgebra of @xmath162 and @xmath164 as the natural inclusion .
first we prove the result at the lie algebra level .
denote the canonical inclusions by @xmath165 .
the reductions of @xmath164 are simply @xmath166 .
for any @xmath167 , define @xmath168 by @xmath169_-$ ] .
[ infinitessimal ] for any @xmath167 , if @xmath170 for all @xmath160 , then @xmath171 .
let @xmath172 be the subspace spanned by the @xmath173 s . by the hypothesis , for any @xmath79 , @xmath174_-$ ]
must be orthogonal as a hilbert space . ] to every @xmath173 , and thus to @xmath175 .
hence for any @xmath176 , @xmath177_- ) = \tau ( \beta [ a , c]_- ) \mbox.\ ] ] so @xmath178^\perp$ ] .
we need to show that @xmath179^\perp\subseteq a'$ ] ( the commutant of @xmath163 ) .
the orthogonal complement of @xmath180 is @xmath181 $ ] , so we simply need to prove that @xmath181\subseteq [ a , c]$ ] .
@xmath175 is closed as a lie algebra and acts unitarily on @xmath162 by @xmath182 .
@xmath175 generates @xmath162 as an algebra , therefore the only part of @xmath162 commuting with @xmath175 is the center , @xmath183 .
this is thus the only trivial @xmath175-subrepresentation in @xmath162 , and so @xmath184=[b , b]$ ] .
@xmath179=\operatorname{ad}_c(a)$ ] is the sum of the nontrivial irreducible @xmath175-representations which intersect with @xmath163 .
thus indeed @xmath181\subseteq [ a , c]$ ] , and the claim is proven .
[ reconstruction ] any homomorphism distinct from @xmath164 will have reductions distinct from those of @xmath164 .
let @xmath185 be the subgroup that leaves the reductions of @xmath164 invariant and @xmath186 the subalgebra of @xmath187-invariant elements .
@xmath188 leaves @xmath164 invariant , so @xmath189 and @xmath190 .
@xmath187 is compact , so we can construct the orthogonal projection @xmath191 by averaging over @xmath187 .
each map @xmath166 factors through @xmath192 , @xmath193 let @xmath194 be any element commuting with @xmath186 . for any @xmath79 and @xmath195 , @xmath196_-)=\tau(a[b,\beta]_-)=0 \mbox,\ ]
] so @xmath197 .
thus @xmath198 therefore @xmath199 .
this implies that @xmath200 .
any other homomorphism can be written as @xmath201 with @xmath202 . if this is distinct from @xmath164 then @xmath203 , but if @xmath201 has the same reductions as @xmath164 then @xmath204 . we would then have @xmath187 larger than just @xmath205 and thus @xmath186 would have to be a _ proper _ subalgebra of @xmath163 .
lemma [ reconstruction ] implies the uniqueness of the @xmath206 in axiom 1 .
if @xmath15 is a complete past of @xmath26 , then if a homomorphism @xmath207 exists with the @xmath125 s ( for @xmath67 ) as its reductions , it can be reconstructed by multiplying the @xmath125 s together , so @xmath208 is unique .
conversely , because of axiom 2 , we _ can _ multiply together the @xmath209 s to define @xmath208 .
analogously , for @xmath26 a complete future of @xmath15 , a unique map @xmath210 exists , satisfying the requirements of property 3 .
suppose that both of these are true .
that is , @xmath27 is a complete pair .
we need to show that @xmath211 and is an isomorphism .
because all homomorphisms in this category are injective , the existence of homomorphisms in both directions between @xmath126 and @xmath69 shows that they are of equal dimension and therefore isomorphic .
these homomorphisms must therefore be isomorphisms .
so , @xmath212 is an isomorphism , and by theorem [ unitary ] , @xmath210 is its inverse .
the reductions of @xmath210 are the same as for @xmath208 and as it is a homomorphism , the above uniqueness implies @xmath213 .
now suppose that @xmath30 .
let @xmath72 and @xmath214 .
by what we have proven so far , @xmath215 is a reduction of @xmath216 . by axiom 3 , @xmath217 .
so , @xmath111 is a reduction of @xmath218 . by lemma [ reconstruction ] ,
since the reductions are the same , we must have that @xmath219 .
using lemma [ reconstruction ] again , this shows that @xmath155 .
we have then shown that the system of isomorphisms associated to complete pairs can be reconstructed from the local information of cp maps associated to pairs of events .
because @xmath9 is assumed to be locally finite , there is no problem in going from these isomorphisms of algebras to a system of unitary maps satisfying the original definition of a quantum causal history ; the only arbitrariness is a choice of irrelevant phase factors . on the other hand ,
the local formulation is restrictive . not
every choice of unitary maps for complete pairs can be expressed in terms of cp maps in this way .
this formulation enforces local causality .
in this paper , we have provided a complete definition of a quantum causal history , a pre - spacetime framework for a quantum theory of gravity in which there is a simple matrix algebra of operators for every event in the universe ( represented by a causal set ) and a completely positive evolution map for every causally related pair of events .
these represent the transfer of quantum information between events in the quantum spacetime .
we showed that the axioms in the definition allow us to reconstruct the unitary evolution between complete pairs , a necessary step since complete pairs correspond to isolated systems . in the picture of the universe as a qch
, it can be thought of as a very large collection of quantum - mechanical building blocks .
everything is ( locally ) finite , both the dimensionality of these systems as well as the causal set .
we regard this as a simple way to model the idea that there is a finite number of fundamental degrees of freedom in a finite region of the universe .
although there is certainly no hard evidence for this , such ideas are supported by bekenstein s arguments , by the black hole entropy calculations from both string theory and loop quantum gravity , and is related to holographic ideas and the arguments for a many - hilbert space m - theory in @xcite .
even independent of such motivations , finiteness allows significant simplifications which we have been able to exploit in this paper . it may be possible to generalize a qch to use some infinite - dimensional algebras .
theorem [ main ] may extend to type ii@xmath144 vonneumann factors , which have finite traces .
however , we have not investigated this possibility in detail because the physical motivations for using matrix algebras are much stronger .
it is interesting to note the multiple ways that quantum causal histories can be motivated , including : 1 . the original definition considering them as the general formalism for causal spin networks @xcite .
2 . as an algebraic quantum field theory on a causal set ( section [ qft ] ) .
3 . as an alternative to the usual quantum cosmology of a wavefunction of the universe evolving according to the wheeler - dewitt equation . a qch is a framework for quantum cosmology that is not restricted to globally hyperbolic spacetimes , as is the case with a wdw - type quantum cosmology .
this is discussed in more detail in @xcite .
the local evolution in a qch is well - suited for addressing the important problem of identifying localized propagating degrees of freedom in a spin foam , without having to use the entire partition function .
precisely the same objects that we used ( matrix algebras and cp maps ) are basic tools in quantum information theory .
conceptually , this suggests that the universe modeled as a qch is nothing but a background - independent quantum computer . more practically , the analogue of the much sought - after propagating `` particle '' in a spin foam , in quantum information theoretic language , is a quantum channel .
tools such as the operator - sum representation of cp maps , and even ideas from the theory of error - correction in quantum computation , might be used to identify such objects .
there is an important clarification we should make .
if quantum causal histories are motivated via 2 above , then this is not gravity , but a kind of quantum field theory on a peculiar background .
this is related to the issue of the _ given _ causal set that a qch is built on .
if the procedure is simply `` given a causal set @xmath9 , a qch is constructed via the procedure of section [ ach ] , '' then this can not have much to do with a dynamical theory of space - time . unless , somehow , all the gravitation degrees of freedom are in the algebras and @xmath9 is some auxiliary background , but we are not aware of such a scheme . in the quantum causal histories motivated from spin foams in quantum gravity ( 4 above ) , there is an further step .
the partition function for a ( causal ) spin foam model includes a sum over all causal sets .
this is the usual path integral formulation of quantum gravity , with each term in the path integral being a qch .
it would be very interesting to understand if there is a way for a qch to be a dynamical quantum space - time without the summation of a path integral .
for this , one would need the causal set and the algebras to `` interact '' with each other .
the reason why there are so many ways to understand quantum causal histories is partly the general nature of a cp map .
it is , after all , the most general physical transformation allowed by quantum theory .
completely positive maps already appear in several places in quantum cosmology and we close this paper by referring to a few examples . in the context of continuous time evolution , master equations are the familiar tools used to describe quantum noise , for example in quantum optics .
these are differential equations , governing the non - unitary evolution of the density matrices of dissipative quantum systems ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
when a master equation is integrated , the evolution of the density matrix for a finite time - step is given by a completely positive map .
another interesting comparison is between our cp maps and decoherence .
the term decoherence is used in the literature both to describe quantum noise , and the more specific process of phase damping that is believed to play a role in the emergence of classicality ( see , for example , @xcite ) . using decoherence to mean the second
, we note that it is possible to incorporate processes of that type in a quantum causal history . in @xcite , an interesting scheme for describing decoherence
was proposed that is closely related to quantum causal histories . in this new formulation , with the completely positive maps as the fundamental evolution operators , we obtain a quantum cosmology in which the universe is simply a very large collection of finite quantum systems .
the information gets shuffled around , according to the causal structure .
local observers can lose information simply because , by causality , it is not available to them .
this is much like information loss due to the presence of a horizon .
finally , we note that there are several tools that can be used for the practical implementation of cp maps in a specific model .
these include the operator - sum representation that is frequently used in quantum information theory ( see @xcite , chapter 8 and @xcite for excellent reviews , and , for example , @xcite for the case of dimensionality change from input to output ) , and the stinespring construction in operator algebras @xcite .
we are very grateful to the jesse phillips foundation for providing the funds that brought us together in berlin .
fm would like to thank barbara terhal for very useful pointers to the relevant literature in quantum information theory , mike mosca and david poulin for discussions on this subject , lee smolin and olaf dreyer for their comments on this work , and the albert einstein institute , golm , where part of this work was carried out .
part of this work was supported by nsf grant phy-0090091 . | we provide a precise definition and analysis of quantum causal histories ( qch s ) .
a qch consists of a discrete , locally finite , causal pre - spacetime with matrix algebras encoding the quantum structure at each event .
the evolution of quantum states and observables is described by completely positive maps between the algebras at causally related events .
we show that this local description of evolution is sufficient and that unitary evolution can be recovered wherever it should actually be expected .
this formalism may describe a quantum cosmology without an assumption of global hyperbolicity ; it is thus more general than the wheeler - dewitt approach .
the structure of a qch is also closely related to quantum information theory and algebraic quantum field theory on a causal set .
l + + + |
after more than a century of intensive study of eclipsing binaries ( hereafter ebs ) , they still represent the best method for deriving the masses , radii , and luminosities of stars . thanks to modern ( ground- and space- based ) telescopes , we are able to also study these objects in other galaxies and to apply the same methods as used in our solar neighbourhood . nevertheless , there is still a difference in the precision of eb parameters as derived for galactic ( @xmath02 - 3% ) and extragalactic ( @xmath010% ) eclipsing binaries ( see e.g. @xcite , @xcite ) .
the extragalactic ebs can serve as an independent tool for deriving galactic properties and also help us answer such important questions as `` is the chemical composition of our galaxy the same as the neighbouring ones ? '' or `` what is the binary and multiplicity fraction in other galaxies ? '' studying other galaxies via detailed analysis of individual stars can provide some useful hints for answering these questions .
ebs are quite common , even in some nearby galaxies .
however , one special group of ebs is still rather rare - those undergoing an orbit precession . if the orientation of the eb orbit is moving in space , then the depths of eclipse also change , and we can detect this orbit precession . observing the binary at different time epochs
can help us to derive the inclination towards the observer as a function of time .
this effect is usually caused by the third component orbiting the close pair .
however , we still know of only a few such systems , and detailed analysis has only been carried out for those located in our galaxy at present .
this is the first time such an effect has been studied in an extragalactic source .
the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) is a close galaxy , which has been observed quite frequently during the past decades .
there have been two major photometric surveys of lmc stars , macho @xcite and ogle @xcite , while discovering a huge number of variable stars including the ebs .
the macho survey lasted from 1993 to 1998 and the ogle from 2002 to 2008 .
quite surprisingly , thanks to these two surveys we know more eclipsing binaries in the lmc than in our galaxy @xcite .
however , owing to the low declination of lmc stars , there are still many interesting systems that lack detailed analysis .
the object called macho 82.8043.171 (= ogle - lmc - ecl-17359 , @xmath1 mag ) was observed by both photometric surveys , so we can harvest the databases for a complete light curve analysis . the system is a detached eclipsing binary with its short orbital period of about 1.26 days @xcite . according to its photometric indices ( see below ) ,
it is probably a b2v - type system .
our new observations were obtained during a four - month period in the 2012/2013 season , using the 1.54-meter danish telescope located at the la silla observatory in chile ( hereafter dk154 ) , but operated remotely from the czech republic .
the standard cousins filter @xmath2 was used for our new observations , in agreement with the ogle survey .
therefore , we can make the first analysis of this interesting system ranging over two decades to detect some long - term changes . for a complete light curve analysis , we need up - to - date ephemerides of the binary . using the macho and
ogle photometry and deriving the precise times of minima , the following ephemerides were used for the light curve analysis : @xmath3 these ephemerides are also suitable for planning future observations . from the observations we determine that the orbit is circular ( i.e. no deviation of secondary minima appears ) .
the light curve fitting of available photometric data was performed using the program phoebe , ver .
0.31a @xcite , which is based on the wilson - devinney algorithm @xcite and its later modifications .
the following procedure was used for the analysis .
first , the ephemerides and temperature of the primary component were fixed for the entire computational process .
the temperature of the primary component was estimated from its photometric index .
owing to many different sources and a rather wide range of magnitude values for the red and infrared filters , this approach was found to be problematic .
for example , the @xmath4 photometric index ranges from @xmath50.60 mag @xcite to 0.065 mag @xcite , which yields a range of spectral types from o to a. on the other hand , published the strmgren @xmath6 photometry , which can be transformed into the johnson @xmath7 system .
after these transformations , the unreddened values of the photometric indices @xmath8 mag resulted , as did @xmath9 mag , which clearly show the star to be about a b2v spectral type @xcite . although the star is not single , the two components are rather similar ( see below ) , so we accepted this estimation .
the resulting value of @xmath10 mag was quite surprising , because it is a bit larger than commonly used for lmc binaries , but it is still acceptable .
another source of johnson magnitudes is , for example , the one by @xcite , who published the @xmath11 photometry .
regrettably , this photometry is also unusable due to larger errors and unacceptable @xmath12 values . to conclude , after assuming the b2v spectral type , we fixed the temperature at @xmath13k @xcite for the computing process .
owing to rather different quality of the individual light curves , the first ogle data set ( 2002.5 ) was used as the initial one . with this light curve
we analysed the system , resulting in a set of parameters for both components , see table [ tablc ] .
these parameters are the best we were able to derive from the available light curves . the values for temperature , the secondary component , kopal s modified potential , luminosities , etc .
were used for the subsequent light curve analysis of data obtained at different epochs . however , the lack of other relevant information ( e.g. from spectroscopy ) meant that some of the parameters have to be fixed for the whole analysis .
we assumed a circular orbit ( i.e. @xmath14 ) and a mass ratio @xmath15 .
the albedo coefficient remained fixed at value 1.0 , gravity darkening coefficients at @xmath16 , and the synchronicity parameters at@xmath17 . the limb darkening coefficients were interpolated from the van hamme s tables @xcite .
no third light was detected for any of the light curves .
this analysis is based on the assumption that the two components are rather similar to each other .
this presumption was derived from the resulting parameters from table [ tablc ] ( similar temperatures and luminosities ) , as well as from the @xmath18 photometric index at various orbital phases as derived from the macho data . on the other hand ,
the use of photometry by was obtained during many nights of observations , which did not take the current orbital phase of the binary into account , which means that some of the photometric data points could have been obtained during the eclipses . however , no other better photometry is available , and owing to the duration of eclipses ( both about 1/10 of the orbital period ) , only about 20% of the data points are likely to be influenced by the eclipses .
however , we still believe that this does not play a significant role because of the similarity of the two eclipsing components
. the best way would be to obtain the individual times of observations for the photometry of , but after communicating with the author , this information is no longer available . during the fitting process , the mass ratio can also be fitted . as a result
, we made this attempt , but it did not result in any significant improvement of the fit .
the mass ratio is only poorly constrained here , which agrees with a previous finding that detached eclipsing binaries with only partial eclipses are not suitable for deriving the mass ratio only from the light curves , see e.g. @xcite .
we can therefore only roughly estimate the uncertainty of the mass ratio to be about 0.1 .
a sample of fitted light curve plots at different time epochs is given in fig .
as one can see , the depths of both primary and secondary minima are changing over the two decades . from these fits ,
the individual inclination angles as derived from the wilson - devinney algorithm are given in table [ tabincl ] and plotted in fig.[fig2 ] .
the inclination is seent to change quite fast ( more than 2@xmath19 every year ) , and the amplitude of photometric variation is rather shallow at present .
.,width=321 ] one can also ask how we dealt with the different light curves in different filters for the complete analysis .
our new observations were obtained in the same filter ( @xmath2 ) as the ogle survey .
the second ogle filter ( @xmath20 ) was not used because of a limited dataset . on the other hand ,
both the @xmath21 and @xmath22 filters from the macho survey were used for the analysis .
the light curves in different filters and different epochs were analysed separately , resulting in different inclination angles .
these two values of inclination angles ( but obtained during the same epoch ) were averaged into the value presented in table [ tabincl ] .
we could afford to combine different filters and instruments for the analysis , because the different luminosity levels for different passbands were also computed .
.the parameters of the light curve . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ]
the system undergoes a nodal precession of its orbit , which is probably caused by an orbiting third body .
this effect of binary orbit precession is nothing new ; however , it has been observed and analysed for the first time for an extragalactic source .
one can compute the nodal period from the equation given in : @xmath23 where subscripts 1 and 2 stand for the components of the eclipsing binary , while 3 stands for the third body .
the term @xmath24 is the total angular momentum of the system , while @xmath25 stands for the angular momentum of the wide orbit .
unfortunately , we are not able to derive the nodal period using this equation owing to unknown individual orbital parameters and masses of the components .
we therefore used a simplified approach to fitting the term
@xmath26 " , as given , say , in : @xmath27 where @xmath2 is the inclination of the invariant plane against the observer s celestial plane , @xmath28 is the inclination of the eclipsing binary , and @xmath29 is the inclination between the invariant plane and the orbital plane of the eclipsing binary .
figure [ fig3 ] shows the result of our fitting .
the resulting nodal period is only about 76.9 @xmath30 10.1 years . however , because of the poor coverage of this period with only two decades of data , this result is still rather preliminary .
new and more precise observations ( both photometry and spectroscopy ) are needed in upcoming years .
the resulting period of nodal precession is the second shortest among known systems to date , the fastest motion being that of the well - known system v907 sco @xcite with its nodal period about 68 years . for macho 82.8043.171
, we do expect that the photometric eclipses will stop as late as about 2017 . until that time only very shallow ellipsoidal variations of the order of 0.03 mag ( i filter ) remain . as a by - product we also derived the inclination angles @xmath2 and @xmath29 from the equation for @xmath31 .
these two quantities resulted in @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
the values define the orientation of the system in space and towards the observer ( see fig . 2 in ) .
both these angles could potentially be used for future dynamical studies , should the third - body orbit be discovered via spectroscopy . ''
term and its final fit ( see the text ) . a confidence level of 95%
is shown with the dash - dotted line.,width=321 ]
discovering the nodal precession of macho 82.8043.171 , one can ask whether the third body causing this effect is detectable with current data or facilities .
the easiest method is the light curve analysis and detection of the third light .
however , no such additional light was discovered , so that it gives some constraints on this body . assuming a detection limit of about 1% of the total light , then the undiscovered third component has to be spectral type a2 or later , assuming it lies on the main sequence
. we can only speculate about its period and semimajor axis , so that the amplitudes of radial velocity variations are also questionable .
the absence of any third light makes it similar to the recently discovered system hs hya , where the third body causing the nodal precession of the eclipsing pair also can not be detected in the light curve solution , but was discovered via spectroscopy .
moreover , the configuration of the system has to be hierarchical because of its stability @xcite .
another limiting factor is the fact that any variation in the times of minima is detectable in the @xmath34 diagram of macho 82.8043.171 ( also analogous to hs hya ) . as a result ,
a detection limit of about 0.002 days also yields some constraints on the third - body orbit , mainly the period , see e.g. @xcite
. using the equation introduced in , and applying many ad hoc assumptions ( e.g. orientation of the orbit in space , fixing the eccentricity to zero ) , we can roughly estimate , for example , the orbital period of the third component .
see fig.[fig4 ] for some results , where the predicted masses ( solid curves ) and amplitudes of the light - time effect ( dash - dotted curves ) are plotted with respect to the orbital period @xmath35 .
the individual colours stand for different inclinations of the orbits : 90@xmath19 ( blue ) , 70@xmath19 ( black ) , 50@xmath19 ( red ) , 30@xmath19 ( cyan ) , and 10@xmath19 ( green ) , respectively
. moreover , exists the dynamical stability criterion also exists , and it gives the lower limit of the third - body period : @xmath36 , see e.g. @xcite , resulting in a minimum period of about 6.28 days . considering all these criteria ,
the shadowed area in fig.[fig4 ] shows the most probable solutions .
the expected period @xmath35 should probably be from 6 to 15 days .
moreover , as we can see from fig .
[ fig4 ] , the limit of no detectable period variation of the order of 0.002 days gives a better constraint on the mass of the third body ( about 0.4 m@xmath37 ) than the absence of the third light , which yields an upper limit of mass of about 2 m@xmath37 .
such a companion is therefore probably an m - dwarf star .
besides macho 82.8043.171 , we currently know of only four other systems with derived nodal periods .
however , this unique system is the first analysed eclipsing binary with changing inclination outside our own galaxy .
the authors are aware of the most important deficiency of the present analysis , which is the lack of radial velocity measurements , or the detailed spectroscopic study discovering the third component . on the other hand , as we can see , for example , in the system of hs hya , the third body could have a period of hundreds of days , so to discover it one needs spectroscopic monitoring over several months
. moreover , other ebs within the lmc are much brighter and also have longer periods .
there is still no radial velocity study of an lmc eclipsing binary with such a short orbital period .
precise spectroscopic observations for such a faint target would only be possible using 4 m class telescopes or even larger .
this first analysis of macho 82.8043.171 could serve as a starting point for other astronomers to initiate observing campaigns or to submit observing proposals for this target on large telescopes .
more detailed study of such systems would potentially be very important for several reasons .
first , ebs are still the best method for deriving precise masses and radii of stars , and also for calibrating the cosmic distance ladder .
secondly , the chemical compositions of such systems should be studied in order to compare the lmc and our galaxy .
there are some traces of different composition between lmc , smc , and our galaxy stars , which were derived using ebs @xcite .
additionally , the ebs serve as independent distance indicators to the lmc ( up to 2% , @xcite ) . and
finally , the changing inclination indicates that there is a hidden component orbiting this eb pair , which could tell us something about the stellar multiplicity of the lmc in general .
observing the suspicious ebs would help us discover these third bodies , which is otherwise rather complicated for such distant objects .
( spectroscopy is time - consuming and magnitude - limited , and interferometry can not be used for magellanic clouds . ) additionally , multiple systems with moving orbital planes are ideal astrophysical laboratories for dynamical studies .
the observable quantities can be directly compared with theoretical models .
therefore , each new system is very promising . in our galaxy we know of 11 such systems nowadays .
@xcite noted 17 systems in the lmc , and from the kepler data there were seven more of these binaries @xcite .
an anonymous referee is acknowledged for the useful comments and suggestions that significantly improved the paper .
william hartkopf is also gratefully acknowledged for his help with the language level of the manuscript .
we thank the macho and ogle teams for making all of the observations publicly available .
we are also grateful to the eso team in la silla for their help in maintaining and operating the danish telescope .
this work was supported by the czech science foundation grant no .
p209/10/0715 , by the grant unce 12 of charles university in prague , and by the grant lg12001 of the ministry of education of the czech republic .
this research made use of the simbad database , operated at the cds , strasbourg , france , and of nasa s astrophysics data system bibliographic services .
clausen , j. v. 2004 , newar , 48 , 679 derekas , a. , kiss , l. l. , & bedding , t. r. 2007 , , 663 , 249 drechsel , h. , haas , s. , lorenz , r. , & mayer , p. 1994 , a&a , 284 , 853 faccioli , l. , alcock , c. , cook , k. , et al .
2007 , aj , 134 , 1963 golay , m. 1974 , astrophysics and space science library , 41 , graczyk , d. , soszyski , i. , poleski , r. , et al .
2011 , aca , 61 , 103 harmanec , p. , & boi , h. 2001 , , 369 , 1140 harrington , r. w. 1992 , iau colloq . 135 : complementary approaches to double and multiple star research , 32 , 212 lacy , c. h. s. , helt , b. e. , & vaz , l. p. r. 1999 , aj , 117 , 541 larsen , s. s. , clausen , j. v. , & storm , j. 2000 , , 364 , 455 mayer , p. 1990 , baicz , 41 , 231 pietrzyski , g. , graczyk , d. , gieren , w. , et al .
2013 , , 495 , 76 pra , a. , & zwitter , t. 2005 , apj , 628 , 426 rappaport , s. , deck , k. , levine , a. , et al .
2013 , , 768 , 33 ribas , i. 2004 , newar , 48 , 731 sderhjelm , s. 1975 , a&a , 42 , 229 terrell , d. , & wilson , r. e. 2005 , , 296 , 221 tokovinin , a. 2008 , , 389 , 925 van hamme , w. 1993 , aj , 106 , 2096 vilardell , f. , ribas , i. , & jordi , c. 2006 , a&a , 459 , 321 wilson , r. e. , & devinney , e. j. 1971 , apj , 166 , 605 worthey , g. , & lee , h .- c .
2011 , , 193 , 1 zacharias , n. , monet , d. g. , levine , s. e. , et al .
2004 , baas , 36 , 1418 zaritsky , d. , harris , j. , thompson , i. b. , & grebel , e. k. 2004 , , 128 , 1606 zasche , p. , & paschke , a. 2012 , , 542 , l23 | the main aim of the present paper is the very first analysis of the binary - orbit precession out of our galaxy .
the light curves of an eclipsing binary macho 82.8043.171 in the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) were studied in order to analyse the long - term evolution of its orbit .
it is a detached system that is undergoing rapid orbit precession .
the inclination of the orbit towards the observer has been changing , which has caused the eclipse depth to become lower over the past decade , and this is ongoing .
the period of this effect was derived as only about 77 years , so it is the second fastest nodal motion known amongst such systems nowadays .
this is the first analysis of an extragalactic binary with nodal precession .
this effect is probably caused by a distant third body orbiting the pair , which could potentially be detected via spectroscopy .
some preliminary estimates of this body are presented . however
, even such a result can tell us something about the multiplicity fraction in other galaxies . |
-5 mm recall that for a suitably regular function @xmath0 on the unit disc @xmath1 we can apply integration by parts / stoke s formula twice to obtain for @xmath2 , @xmath3 where @xmath4 so actually we re integrating @xmath5 . in the presence of singularities things
continue to work . for example
suppose @xmath6 is a holomorphic map of complex spaces and @xmath7 a metricised effective cartier divisor on @xmath8 , with @xmath9 , and @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the tautological section , then we obtain , @xmath12 obviously it s not difficult to write down similar formulae for not necessarily effective cartier divisors , meromorphic functions , drop the condition that @xmath9 provided @xmath13 , extend to ramified covers @xmath14 , etc . , but in all cases what is clear is , * facts 1.3 .
* _ ( a ) if @xmath8 is compact then @xmath15 is very close to being positive if @xmath16 , e.g. in the particular hypothesis preceding ( 1.2 ) , @xmath17 _
\(b ) there is no such principle for the usual area function @xmath18 except in extremely special cases such as @xmath19 ample .
equally the essence of the study of curves on higher dimensional varieties lies in understanding their intersection with divisors , and , of course , the principle that a curve not lying in a divisor intersects it positively is paramount to the discussion .
consequently the right notion of intersection number for non - compact curves is the so - called characteristic function defined by either side of the identity ( 1.2 ) . on the other hand intersection number and integration
are interchangeable in algebraic geometry , and whence we will write , * notation 1.4 . * _ let @xmath20 be a @xmath21 form on @xmath1 then for @xmath2 , @xmath22 _ the more traditional characteristic function notation is reserved for the current associated to a map , i.e. * definition 1.5 . * _ let @xmath6 be a map of complex spaces then for @xmath2 , we define , _
@xmath23 evidently in many cases one works with forms which are not quite smooth , so there are variations on the definition . in any case in order to motivate our intersection formalism let us pause to consider ,
-5 mm the basic theorem in the study of subvarieties of a projective variety is grothendieck s existence and properness of the hilbert scheme , or if one prefers a sequence of subvarieties of bounded degree has a convergent subsequence .
of course families of smooth curves do not in general limit on smooth curves but rather semi - stable ones , and as such we must necessarily understand convergence of discs in the sense of gromov [ g ] , i.e. * definition 2.1 . * _ a disc with bubbles @xmath24 is a connected @xmath25-dimensional complex space with singularities at worst nodes exactly one of whose components is a disc @xmath1 and such that every connected component of @xmath26 is a tree of smooth rational curves . _ for @xmath27 and @xmath28 the corresponding tree of rational curves , and
provided @xmath29 we can extend our integral ( 1.4 ) to this more general situation by way of , @xmath30 while if @xmath31 is a map then we have a graph , @xmath32 an appropriate formulation of gromov s compactness theorem is then , * fact 2.2 . *
_ let @xmath33 be the space of maps from discs with bubbles into a projective variety @xmath8 topologised by way of the hausdorff metric on the graphs then for @xmath34 any function and @xmath35 compact the set , @xmath36 where @xmath37 is a metricised ample divisor , is compact . _ under more general hypothesis on @xmath8 ,
2.2 continues to hold , but in the special projective case one has an essentially trivial proof thanks to the ubiquitous jensen formula , cf .
[ m ] v.3.1 .
equally although the appearance of automorphisms looks like an unwarranted complication they are necessitated by , * remarks 2.3 .
* \(a ) the possibility of bubbling at the origin .
\(b ) the defect of positivity for the intersection number as per ( 1.3)(a ) . observe moreover that the introduction of @xmath33 and its precise relation to @xmath38 are both necessary , and easy respectively , i.e. * fact 2.4 . * ( [ m ] v.3.5 ) _ let @xmath39 be such that the bounded subsets in the sense of @xmath40 are relatively compact then @xmath41 . moreover assuming that @xmath8 is not absurdly singular then @xmath42 iff @xmath8 contains no rational curves .
_ one can equally generalise this to a log , or quasi - projective situation by introducing a divisor @xmath19 , whose components @xmath43 should be @xmath44-cartier at which point the appropriate variation thanks to a lemma of mark green , [ gr ] , is , * fact 2.5 . * _ @xmath45 iff @xmath46 and @xmath47 do not contain any affine lines .
_ in particular @xmath48 is relatively compact in @xmath38 if and only if @xmath49 is compact and the boundary is _ mildly hyperbolic _ in the sense that @xmath50 does not contain affine lines
. the latter question is purely algebraic and closely related to the log minimal model programme . in the case of foliations by curves an even more delicate result holds since as brunella has observed , [ b ] , the equivalence of @xmath51 with hom for invariant maps into the orbifold smooth part of a foliated variety is itself equivalent to the said foliated variety being a minimal model .
-5 mm bloch s famous dictum , `` nihil est in infinito quod non fuerit prius in finito '' , might thus be translated as , * question 3.1 .
* suppose for a projective variety @xmath8 , or more generally a log variety @xmath52 there is a zariski subset @xmath53 of @xmath46 through which every non - trivial map @xmath54 must factor then do we have _ hyperbolicity modulo _ @xmath53 , i.e. is it the case that a sequence @xmath55 in @xmath56 not affording a convergent subsequence in @xmath57 must be arbitrarily close ( in the compact open sense ) to @xmath58 . in the particular case that 2.5 is satisfied we can replace @xmath59 by @xmath60 and ask for _ complete hyperbolicity modulo _ @xmath53 , but outside of surfaces ( 2.5 ) seems difficult to guarantee .
regardless in his thesis brody , [ br ] , provided an affirmative answer for both @xmath53 and @xmath19 empty by way of his reparameterisation lemma which was subsequently extended by green to the case of @xmath53 empty and every @xmath61 not containing holomorphic lines .
bearing in mind the singular variant of green s lemma implicit in 2.5 , which for example makes it applicable to stable families of curves , it would appear that the unique known case not covered by the methods of brody and green was a theorem of bloch himself , [ bl ] , i.e. @xmath624 planes in general position@xmath63 , and its subsequent extension by cartan to @xmath64 , [ c ] .
however , even here , a moment s inspection shows that 2.5 holds , so one knows a priori that there can be no bubbling , and whence complete hyperbolicity in the sense of 3.1 trivially implies so - called normal convergence modulo the diagonal hyperplanes , and the correct structure is obscured .
now an extension of the reparameterisation lemma to cover 3.1 would be by far the most preferable way forward , since the non - existence of holomorphic lines is an essentially useless qualitative statement without the quantitative information provided by the convergence of discs .
nevertheless we can vaguely approximate a reparameterisation lemma thanks as ever to jensen s formula .
specifically consider as given , * data 3.2 .
* _ _ * a @xmath44-cartier divisor @xmath65 on a log - variety @xmath52 . * a sequence @xmath66 which neither affords a convergent subsequence nor is arbitrarily close to @xmath67 . in light of ( b )
we can choose convergent automorphisms @xmath68 , such that @xmath69 is bounded away from @xmath67 , and given , modulo subsequencing , the convergence of the @xmath70 we may as well suppose this .
moreover for each @xmath71 we can normalise the current @xmath72 of 1.5 by its degree with respect to an ample divisor @xmath73 , which we ll denote by @xmath74 and take a weak limit for a suitable subset @xmath75 of @xmath76 to obtain a current @xmath77 .
in addition 3.2(b ) also tells us that for some fixed @xmath78 , the degrees of the @xmath55 at @xmath79 go to infinity , and whence by ( 1.1 ) and ( 1.2 ) * pre - fact 3.3 . * _ for @xmath80 , @xmath81 is a positive harmonic current such that , @xmath82 for all effective divisors @xmath83 supported in @xmath67 .
_ what is somewhat less trivial , but once more the key is jensen s formula , is , * fact 3.3(bis ) .
* ( [ m ] v.2.4 ) _ subsequencing in @xmath75 as necessary , then for @xmath80 outside of a set of finite hyperbolic measure ( i.e. @xmath84 ) @xmath81 is closed .
_ obviously there are various choices involved but whenever we re dealing in the context of countably many projective varieties they can all be rendered functorial , up to a constant , with respect to push forward .
the constant itself only causes a problem should it be zero which is usually what one wants to prove anyway , and as such the notation @xmath85 is relatively unambiguous , and represents in a vague sense a parabolic limit of the sequence @xmath55 .
-5 mm applications of course require some knowledge of intersection numbers , and quite generally even for a compact curve @xmath86 there is very little that one can say in general beyond , * observation 4.1 . *
_ let @xmath87 be the derivative @xmath88 in the notation of ega ) with @xmath89 the tautological bundle then , @xmath90 _
this is of course the riemann - hurwitz formula if @xmath91 , and there s an equally trivially log - variant where on the right hand side we have to throw in the number of points in the intersection with the boundary @xmath19 counted without multiplicity the special case of @xmath92 being mason s `` @xmath93 '' theorem for polynomials .
the correct generality for best possible applications is to work with log - smooth deligne - mumford stacks ( or alternatively just orbifolds since the inertia tends to be irrelevant ) , however for simplicity let s stick with log - smooth varieties and metricise @xmath94 by way of a complete metric @xmath95 on @xmath52 , which in turn leads to a mildly singular metricisation @xmath96 of the tautological bundle . supposing for simplicity that @xmath9 with @xmath97 unramified at the origin then jensen s formula yields , * observation 4.2(bis ) . *
_ notations as above , _
@xmath98 combining the concavity of the logarithm and once more jensen s formula , but this time for @xmath99 for any norm on the boundary divisor @xmath19 , immediately yields in the notations of 3.3 , * fact 4.3 . * _ let @xmath100 be the current associated to the logarithmic derivative of a sequence @xmath101 with @xmath102 not arbitrarily close to @xmath19 and which does not afford a convergent subsequence then outwith a set of finite hyperbolic measure , _
@xmath103 the so - called tautological inequality 4.3 is well adapted for applications to convergence of discs ( note incidentally that it s implicit to the formulation that a smooth metric on the bundle @xmath94 is being employed ) . nevertheless for more delicate questions such as quantifying degenerate / non - convergent behaviour .
there is a wealth of information in ( 4.2 ) that is lost in the coarser corollary . indeed even using the concavity of the logarithm
distorts a very delicate term measuring the ` ramification at @xmath104 ' , i.e. the distorsion of the boundary from it s length in the poincar metric , which is closely related to the difficulty of extracting an isoperimetric inequality from a knowledge of hyperbolicity in the sense of 3.1 . while from the still deeper curvature point of view
, 4.2 is simply a doubly integrated tautological schwarz lemma , since by definition metricising @xmath105 by way of a metric @xmath106 of curvature @xmath107 is equivalent to a lower bound of the left hand side of the form , @xmath108 for all infinitely small , and whence all in the large , possible discs . while on the subject of curvature and isoperimetric inequalities , a variant specific to dimension 1 replaces the current @xmath109 implicitly hidden in ( 4.2 ) by the current associated to the boundary of a simply connected region , i.e. * variant 4.4 . * _ suppose @xmath110 , let @xmath111 be simply connected , @xmath112 isomorphisms and put @xmath113 then specific to dimension 1 , @xmath114 is closed and may be written , @xmath115 for @xmath73 an ample divisor of degree 1 .
now apply jensen s formula to recover an integrated form of ahlfor s isoperimetric inequality , and the five island s theorem .
_ returning to varieties and divisors it s still possible to employ ( 4.2 ) to get integrated isoperimetric inequalities for more general situations that preserve some 1-dimensional flavour , i.e. discs which are invariant by foliations by curves , with _
canonical foliation singularities _ ( with the obvious definition of that notion which is functorial with respect to the ideas ) and which do not pass through the singularities .
the latter hypothesis which is reasonable for the study of the leafwise variation of the poincar metric is however somewhat restrictive for other applications , and is probably unnecessary as suggested by the essentially optimal inequality of [ m ] v.4.4 for foliations on surfaces which employs ( 4.2 ) to a very large number of monoidal transformations in the foliation singularities .
regardless here is a genuinely 2-dimensional theorem , * theorem 4.5 . *
( [ m ] v.5 ) _ let @xmath52 be a smooth logarithmic surface with @xmath116 big ( e.g. log - general type , and @xmath117 ) then there is a proper zariski subset @xmath53 of @xmath46 such that @xmath46 is complete hyperbolic ( in the sense of @xmath118 et sequel ) modulo @xmath53 . _ indeed one can even optimally quantify ( cf . op .
the degeneration of the kobayashi metric ( which is evidently continuous and non - zero off @xmath53 ) around @xmath53 . amusingly the theorem only covers @xmath625 planes in general position@xmath63 , although it s a good exercise in the techniques ( cf . op .
v.4 ) to prove bloch s theorem too , at which point a rather small sequence of blow ups replaces all of the original estimation . in any case
( 4.5 ) should only be seen as a stepping stone which in order of ascending difficulty leaves open the following questions , viz , * concluding remarks 4.6 . * for concreteness take a smooth algebraic surface @xmath8 of general type with @xmath119 ( otherwise the following should be understood in terms of higher jets , but not for anything more general than a surface ) then , * do we have an isoperimetric inequality with appropriate degeneration along the subset @xmath53 of ( 4.5 ) .
* is the kobayashi metric negatively curved .
* for each @xmath120 and @xmath121 a tangent direction at @xmath122 , is there a unique up to the usual action of @xmath123 pointed disc with maximal tangent in the direction @xmath121 , and if so does it continue to be so along its image , i.e. is there a continuous ( off @xmath53 ) connection whose geodesics are the discs defining the kobayashi metric .
-5 mm in closing it is a pleasure to thank m. brunella for introducing me to the unit disc and bubbling , together with m. gromov for continuing this education , but above all ccile without whom the reader could never have got this far . | we consider the algebro - geometric consequences of integration by parts .
4.5 mm * 2000 mathematics subject classification : * 32 , 14 . * keywords and phrases : * jensen s formula . |
bose - einstein condensates ( bec ) in optical lattices ( ol ) have recently attracted a great deal of attention due to the possibility of investigating , both at the theoretical and at the experimental level , interesting physical phenomena such as bloch oscillations , landau zener tunneling , mott transitions , etc . @xcite .
the interplay between the nonlinearity ( intrinsic in the interatomic interaction ) and the periodic structure ( induced by the ol ) leads to the formation of localized states trough the mechanism of the modulational instability of the bloch states at the edges of the brillouin zone of the underlying linear periodic system @xcite .
these states , also known as gap - solitons , can exist in presence of both attractive and repulsive interactions @xcite , this last fact being possible only due to the presence of the ol . the existence of gap solitons in repulsive bec was experimentally demonstrated in @xcite .
the phenomena of bloch oscillations , generation of coherent atomic pulses ( atom laser)@xcite , superfluid - mott transition@xcite , were also experimentally observed .
the ols considered in these experiments act as external potentials ( and therefore linearly ) on the condensate , this introducing an intrinsic ( state independent ) periodicity in the system . in the following
we shall refer to this type of lattices as _ linear _ ols ( lols ) . in higher dimensions lols
were shown to be very effective in stabilizing localized states against collapse or decay , leading to the formation of stable multidimensional solitons @xcite .
besides lols , it is also possible to consider _ nonlinear _ ols ( nols ) with symmetry properties which depend on the wavefunction characterizing the state of the system .
a nol can be obtained by inducing a periodic spatial variation of the two body interatomic interaction strength ( atomic scattering length ) , leading to a periodic space modulation of the nonlinear coefficient in the gross - pitaevskii equation ( gpe ) governing the mean field dynamics of the ground state .
this periodic modulation can be experimentally achieved either by means of the standard feshbach resonance method @xcite , taking an external magnetic field near the resonance which is spatially periodic @xcite , or by the optically induced feshbach resonance technique . in the last case
the nonlinear periodic potential can be produced by two counter propagating laser beams with parameters near the optically induced feshbach resonance @xcite .
a periodic variation of the laser field intensity in space and a proper choice of the resonance detuning lead to a spatial dependence of the scattering length @xcite and hence to a spatial dependent nonlinear coefficient in the gpe .
different interesting phenomena occurring in bec in presence of a nol have already been studied , such as the transmission of wave packets through nonlinear barriers , generation of atomic solitons , and existence of localized states refs .
mathematical properties of the ground state and the existence of localized states of quasi-1d bec in nol have also been studied in @xcite .
all these studies @xcite concern mainly with scalar ( single component ) 1d bec in nol .
the possibility of stabilizing multi - dimensional scalar solitons by means of nols is presently under investigation ( preliminary studies show that nols are unable to stabilize 2d solitons if the average nonlinearity is negative ) , while multi - component becs in nol have not been considered yet neither theoretically nor experimentally .
this last problem arises when two or more bec atomic species interact in presence of periodic spatial modulations of the scattering lengths , which can occur between the species ( inter - species ) and/or within the species ( intra - species ) .
the interaction between the two bec components leads to an inter - species nol which can play a stabilizing role for localized states .
spatial modulations of the intra - species scattering length ( giving rise to intra - species nols ) can also lead to the existence of new types of soliton states .
the aim of the present paper is to study the properties of the localized states of two - component bec mixtures in nols .
the case of a sinusoidal variation in space of the intra- and inter - species scattering lengths will be considered . in particular
we show the existence of new types of solitons and study their stability by means of analytical and numerical methods .
the symmetry properties of the localized with respect to the nol are also investigated .
we show that the nol allows the existence of bright soliton modes with equal symmetry in both components , bright localized modes of mixed symmetry type , as well as bright - dark bound states and bright modes on periodic backgrounds .
we also show that , in spite of the quasi 1d nature of the problem , the fundamental symmetric localized modes undergo a delocalizing transition when the strength of the non linear optical lattice is varied .
this transition is associated with the existence of an unstable solution which exhibit a shrinking ( decaying ) behavior for slightly overcritical ( undercritical ) variations in the number of atoms .
the phenomenon of the delocalizing transition was also investigated in @xcite for the case of multidimensional single component bec solitons in lol and in @xcite for the case of one - dimensional bec s with combined linear and nonlinear ol s .
delocalizing transitions in binary bec mixtures have not been previously investigated . for the analysis of strongly localized modes ( i.e. localized in one or few cells of the nol ) we will apply the variational approach which was shown to be effective for such type of problems , while for delocalizing transitions and broad solitons we use a vectorial gross - pitaevskii equation averaged over rapid variations in space of the nonlinear potential .
results are then compared with those obtained by direct numerical simulations of the coupled gpe system . as numerical tools to investigate the above problems we use both self - consistent exact diagonalizations @xcite and generalized relaxing methods @xcite .
the paper is organized as follows . in section
ii we describe the physical model for the two component bec under action of a nol , based on the optical manipulation of the scattering length by optically induced feshbach resonances .
the model equations are introduced in the mean field approximation in terms of two coupled 1d gross - pitaevskii equations with intra- and inter - species interaction terms .
the problem of existence of soliton solutions ( when the inter- and intra - species atomic scattering lengths are periodically modulated in space ) , the symmetry properties of localized modes and their stability are discussed in sections iii .
the delocalizing transitions of fundamental modes and the existence of unstable solutions associated with them are studied in section iv .
the analytical predictions are confirmed by direct numerical simulations of the full gp equation ( sections ii - iv ) .
finally , in section v , the main results of the paper are summarized .
two component condensate represent the mixture of atoms in the different hyperfine states@xcite .
we consider here the dynamics of two - component bec in presence of a nonlinear optical lattice produced either by spatially varying magnetic fields near a feshbach resonance ( fr ) value or by optically induced feshbach resonances @xcite . according to this last approach , the scattering length @xmath0 can be optically manipulated if the incident light is close to the resonance with one of the bound @xmath1 levels of electronically excited molecules .
virtual radiative transitions of a pair of interacting atoms to this level , can change value and/or reverse the sign of the scattering length .
the periodic variation of the laser field intensity in the standing wave , @xmath2 , produces periodic variation of the atomic scattering length , such that @xmath3,\ ] ] where @xmath4 is the scattering length in the absence of light , @xmath5 is the frequency detuning of the light from the fr and @xmath6 is a constant factor . for weak intensities , when @xmath7 , we have that @xmath8 .
periodic variation of the scattering length by a spatially varying external magnetic field @xmath9 near a feshbach resonance ( fr ) , can be described by @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the resonant value and @xmath12 the corresponding width .
examples are : a multicomponent bec of @xmath13na atoms@xcite or the mixture of @xmath14k - @xmath15rb atoms on the surface of a chip
. the periodic variation of @xmath16 can be controlled by the current in a magnetic wire on the chip surface@xcite . for the mixture @xmath14k - @xmath15rb
it was shown recently that the inter - species scattering length @xmath17 can be tuned using the feshbach resonances by varying the external magnetic field in the interval @xmath18 g @xcite .
the mean field equations for the ground state wavefunction of a quasi-1d two - component bec under the action of a nol are given by the following coupled gp equations @xcite
: @xmath19 where @xmath20 refer to the component index , and the full - dimensional space and time variables are given by @xmath21 and @xmath22 . in the above
, @xmath23 is the parameter giving the strength of the inter - species nol and @xmath24 is directly related to the atomic scattering length of the species @xmath25 ( @xmath26 ) . in the following we fix the spatial dependence of @xmath27 and @xmath28 as @xmath29 introducing the dimensionless variables @xmath30 and @xmath31 where @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35 .
below we will consider the particular case @xmath36 , @xmath37 .
we can rewrite the above pair of equations as @xmath38 where the normalization of the total wave - function @xmath39 is related to the components @xmath40 and to the number of atoms @xmath41 by the equation @xmath42 we remark that in experiments the magnitude and sign of both the inter- and the intra - species scattering lengths can be controlled by external magnetic fields @xcite or by counter propagating laser fields @xcite . in the case of immiscibility , when @xmath43 , the repulsive cross - interaction between the components affects strongly the self - interaction between components . in this section
we perform an analytical study in the framework of the variational approach ( va ) for the case of localized ( soliton ) solutions of the form : @xmath44 , where @xmath45 are the chemical potentials . from eq .
( [ gp ] ) we have @xmath46 the total energy can be obtained from eqs .
( [ gp ] ) and ( [ norm ] ) : @xmath47 where @xmath48 @xmath49 + \right . \nonumber\\ & + & \left .
\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dx\ ; \sigma_{12}(x)\;|u_1|^2|u_2|^2 \right\}\frac{1 } { n_1 + n_2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the corresponding lagrangian is given by @xmath50 -\sigma_{12}(x)|u_1|^2 |u_2|^2 \nonumber \\ & = & \sum_{i=1}^2 \left [ \mu_i |u_i|^2 - \left|\frac{\partial u_i}{\partial x}\right|^2 -\frac { ( \gamma_{i0}+\gamma_i\cos(2x ) ) \nonumber\\ & - & ( g_0+g_1\cos(2x))|u_1|^2 |u_2|^2 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in our variational approach we consider @xmath40 given by @xmath51 ^ 2}{2a_i^2}\right)\;\;(i=1,2),\ ] ] where the normalization @xmath41 is related to the number of atoms of the species @xmath25 , @xmath52 is the corresponding width , and @xmath53 is a parameter given the relative initial position of the two components . by substituting this ansatz in eq .
( [ energy ] ) and in the averaged lagrangian @xmath54 , we obtain : @xmath55 + \frac{n_1n_2}{\sqrt{\pi}}g\right\}\frac{1}{n_1+n_2 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath56 - \frac{n_1 n_2}{\sqrt{\pi}}g,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath57.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the euler - lagrange equations @xmath58
, @xmath59 and @xmath60 we obtain the equations for the chemical potentials @xmath45 and number of atoms @xmath41 : @xmath61,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath62,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath63 where @xmath64 from ( [ mui ] ) and ( [ energy1 ] ) , it also follows that @xmath65 for the particular choice of parameters for the symmetric case , when @xmath66 , @xmath67 , we have @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 , with @xmath72 the equations for the chemical potential @xmath73 , energy @xmath74 , and number of atoms @xmath75 become ( @xmath76 ) @xmath77 + \nonumber \\&+ & \frac{n}{\sqrt{2\pi}\;a } \left[(g_0 + g_1e^{-a^2/2})e^{-x_0 ^ 2/2a^2}\right],\label{mus } \\ e & = & \frac{\mu}{2}+\frac{1}{4a^2 } , \\ \frac{n}{\sqrt{2\pi } a}&=&\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}a(p+q)},\;\;\;\;\ ; ( q\equiv q_i , p\equiv p_i ) \label{ns}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath78 { e^{-\frac{x_0 ^ 2}{2a^2 } } } \right\}^{-1 } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath79 .
\label{gx0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath80 , we have @xmath81 , \label{mu1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath82 } \label{n1 } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] by using ( [ n1 ] ) in ( [ mu1 ] ) for the symmetric case with @xmath80 we obtain @xmath83 \label{mu2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] , @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 , with different values of @xmath53 , we show the va results for the number of particles @xmath75 , chemical potential @xmath73 and energy @xmath74 , versus the width @xmath87 .
@xmath75 is given in the upper panel , with @xmath88 ( scale in the lhs ) and @xmath89 ( scale in the rhs ) given in the lower panel .
, width=283,height=207 ] , @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 , with different values of @xmath53 , we show the va results for the number of particles @xmath75 , chemical potential @xmath73 and energy @xmath74 , versus the width @xmath87 .
@xmath75 is given in the upper panel , with @xmath88 ( scale in the lhs ) and @xmath89 ( scale in the rhs ) given in the lower panel .
, width=302,height=207 ] , in the symmetric case with the same parameters as in fig .
[ fig01 ] .
exact results are also shown for the case of @xmath80 ( solid line with empty circles , in both panels ) . here
we observe that the small unstable region , @xmath90 , presented by the va is not confirmed by the full numerical results.,width=283,height=207 ] , in the symmetric case with the same parameters as in fig .
[ fig01 ] .
exact results are also shown for the case of @xmath80 ( solid line with empty circles , in both panels ) . here
we observe that the small unstable region , @xmath90 , presented by the va is not confirmed by the full numerical results.,width=283,height=207 ] , @xmath84 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 , with different values of @xmath53 , we show the va results for the number of particles @xmath75 , chemical potential @xmath73 and energy @xmath74 , versus the width @xmath87 .
@xmath75 is given in the upper panel , with @xmath88 ( scale in the lhs ) and @xmath89 ( scale in the rhs ) given in the lower panel .
, width=275,height=207 ] , @xmath84 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 , with different values of @xmath53 , we show the va results for the number of particles @xmath75 , chemical potential @xmath73 and energy @xmath74 , versus the width @xmath87 .
@xmath75 is given in the upper panel , with @xmath88 ( scale in the lhs ) and @xmath89 ( scale in the rhs ) given in the lower panel .
, width=283,height=207 ] , in the symmetric case with the same parameters as in [ fig03 ] . as we can see , the stable region ( @xmath93 ) is more pronounced for @xmath94 than for @xmath80.,width=283,height=207 ] , in the symmetric case with the same parameters as in [ fig03 ] . as we can see ,
the stable region ( @xmath93 ) is more pronounced for @xmath94 than for @xmath80.,width=283,height=200 ] the stability of the soliton solution can be investigated by using the vakhitov - kolokolov criterion @xcite ( in the present case , implying that for a stable system we should have @xmath95 ) , and also by studying the total energy @xmath74 and chemical potentials @xmath45 as functions of the width @xmath87 .
for the symmetric cases ( when @xmath96 and @xmath97 ) , the results of such study is presented in figs .
[ fig01 ] to [ fig04 ] , considering an attractive inter - species scattering length ( @xmath98 ) in figs .
[ fig01 ] and [ fig02 ] ; and repulsive inter - species scattering length ( @xmath99 ) in figs .
[ fig03 ] and [ fig04 ] . from figs .
[ fig01 ] and [ fig03 ] we obtain the behavior of @xmath75 , chemical potential @xmath73 and energy @xmath74 as functions of @xmath87 .
the behavior of @xmath73 versus @xmath75 , in order to check the vk criterion , is shown in figs .
[ fig02 ] and [ fig04 ] .
this stability study was done mainly by using the variational approach ( va ) , considering different values of the parameter @xmath53 , which gives the position of the soliton solution in respect to the optical lattice . in case of @xmath53
the va solutions are also compared with full numerical results in figs .
[ fig02 ] and [ fig04 ] ( solid lines with empty circles ) .
as observed , the va gives a good qualitative picture of the exact results , with improved quantitative results for large values of @xmath100 .
the dominant @xmath101 behavior of the chemical potential @xmath73 and energy @xmath74 , as functions of the width @xmath87 , are removed in the bottom panels of figs .
[ fig01 ] and [ fig03 ] ( by a multiplicative factor proportional to @xmath102 ) , in order to enhance their @xmath53 dependence .
as we can verify , in both the cases , the most stable configuration is obtained when @xmath94 . as we can see in fig .
[ fig02 ] , the single soliton is stable for @xmath103 .
the va predicts the existence of small instability region , that is not confirmed by the numerical simulations of the system of gp equations .
this instability region corresponds to the broad soliton case with @xmath104 , where the va approach is not applicable . ) with nol parameter values @xmath105 ,
@xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 .
the top panel refers to the case of an equal number of atoms @xmath106 in the two components with equal chemical potentials @xmath107 .
the bottom panel refers to the case of different number of atoms @xmath108 in the two components and different chemical potentials @xmath109 .
dashed lines refer to second components.,width=283,height=207 ] ) with nol parameter values @xmath105 , @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 .
the top panel refers to the case of an equal number of atoms @xmath106 in the two components with equal chemical potentials @xmath107 .
the bottom panel refers to the case of different number of atoms @xmath108 in the two components and different chemical potentials @xmath109 .
dashed lines refer to second components.,width=283,height=207 ]
in this section we investigate the symmetry properties of localized modes with similar number of particles in each component .
these modes can be of equal symmetry or of mixed symmetry type . in order to find these solutions we use both the self - consistent exact diagonalization method and the generalized relaxing method described in the appendix ( these methods provide identical results for all the cases studied below , with the only exception of the state in fig . [ fig08 ] , for which the relaxation method was not effective ) . in fig .
[ fig05 ] we show the fundamental modes obtained in the attractive case ( @xmath110 ) with equal and different number of atoms in the two components . ) of symmetry type is - is ( top panel ) and is - os ( bottom panel ) .
the number of atoms and chemical potentials of the is - is mode are @xmath108 , @xmath111 , while for the is - os mode are @xmath112 , @xmath113 .
the parameters of the nol for the is - is mode are fixed as @xmath105 , @xmath114 , @xmath85 , @xmath115 , while for the is - os mode are fixed as : @xmath105 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 , @xmath115 .
dashed lines refer to second components.,width=283 ] ) of symmetry type is - is ( top panel ) and is - os ( bottom panel ) .
the number of atoms and chemical potentials of the is - is mode are @xmath108 , @xmath111 , while for the is - os mode are @xmath112 , @xmath113 .
the parameters of the nol for the is - is mode are fixed as @xmath105 , @xmath114 , @xmath85 , @xmath115 , while for the is - os mode are fixed as : @xmath105 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 , @xmath115 .
dashed lines refer to second components.,width=283 ] .
left panels refer to first components.,width=283,height=207 ] .
left panels refer to first components.,width=283,height=207 ] in both cases we have that the maximum of the atomic densities are symmetric around the minimum of the corresponding effective potentials ( see appendix a )
. adopting the same terminology introduced in @xcite for the case of a lol , we shall refer to these modes as os - os ( onsite symmetric in both components ) . note that os - os - modes with equal number of atoms have the same chemical potentials , while for different number of atoms the component with a lower number of atoms has also a lower chemical potential . for sufficiently strong nol ( see below ) these modes are very stable under gpe time evolution and represent the fundamental ground states of the system in the case of all attractive interactions . in particular , the gpe time evolution of the density of the os - os mode in fig .
[ fig05 ] with a different number of atoms does not show any deviation from the starting density for a time @xmath118 going from @xmath119 to @xmath120 besides onsite symmetry modes , it is also possible to have modes that are intersite symmetric ( is ) in one or in both components , i.e. symmetric around a maximum of the effective nonlinear potential instead than a minimum .
such modes can be of type is - is ( intersite symmetric in both components ) such as the one shown in the top panel of fig .
[ fig06 ] or of mixed type ( os - is or is - os ) such as the one shown in the bottom panel of fig . [ fig06 ] .
in contrast with the os - os mode , the intersite symmetric localized modes are found to be unstable under gpe time evolution as one can see from figs .
[ fig07 ] and [ fig08 ] for is - is and os - is modes , respectively .
notice that in both cases the states decay into an os - os mode which is the true ground state of the system , and that in the is - os case the decay of the is component give rise to internal oscillations ( relative motion between the two final os components ) which can last for a long time .
internal oscillations of the os - os modes can also be excited trough scattering with other modes .
besides modes that are localized in both components it is also possible to couple a localized mode in one component with an extended mode in the other component such that the extended state acts as a periodic potential for the localized mode and forming a bound state .
such an example is presented in figs .
[ fig08 ] and [ fig09 ] for the case of a binary mixture with an average repulsive interaction for the first component ( @xmath121 , @xmath122 ) and an average attractive interaction for the second component ( @xmath123 , @xmath124 ) .
this combination of signs for the interactions makes the ground state of the system to be extended for the first component and localized in the second one , leading to the formation of the dark - bright bound state depicted in the upper panel of fig .
[ fig08 ] .
another possible solution for the same combination of parameters is also verified , as shown in the lower panel of fig .
[ fig08 ] , with the formation of a bright - bright state , having one bright solution on top of the background . for the considered parameters , both the solutions presented in fig .
[ fig08 ] are quite stable under the gpe time evolution . in fig .
[ fig09 ] we show the time evolution of the dark - bright state shown in the upper panel of fig . [ fig08 ] . ) , obtained with the nol parameters @xmath125 , @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath86 . in both the cases , we have the same chemical potentials @xmath1260.9476 and @xmath1272.746 . the resulting number of atoms in the two components are , respectively , @xmath1282 and @xmath1294.5 for the dark - bright solution ( upper panel ) ; and @xmath12864.246 and @xmath1290.444 for the bright - bright solution ( lower panel).,title="fig : " ] ) , obtained with the nol parameters @xmath125 , @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath86 . in both the cases , we have the same chemical potentials @xmath1260.9476 and @xmath1272.746 .
the resulting number of atoms in the two components are , respectively , @xmath1282 and @xmath1294.5 for the dark - bright solution ( upper panel ) ; and @xmath12864.246 and @xmath1290.444 for the bright - bright solution ( lower panel).,title="fig : " ] .
, width=328,height=366 ]
in this section we investigate the existence of a delocalizing transition for the fundamental os - os symmetry mode . to this
regard we recall that for a single component 1d bec with combined lol and nol there exists a threshold in the number of atoms below which the state becomes delocalized . in the limit of rapidly varying
nols one can show , using the averaging method , that the system can be reduced to a nonlinear schrodinger equation with cubic and quintic nonlinearities for which the existence of a delocalizing transition is known . for binary bec mixtures
the same method leads to a coupled system of cubic - quintic nls equations for which delocalizing transitions are also expected to exist . at the transition
point the localized state becomes spatially more extended and displays properties similar to townes solitons of the 1d quintic nls system or of the 2d nls equation with cubic nonlinearity .
for broad soliton states , i.e. when the soliton width @xmath130 becomes much larger than the periodicity scale @xmath131 , we can consider the expansion @xmath132 , with @xmath133 . at the leading order @xmath134
we obtain @xmath135 substituting into eq .
( [ gp ] ) and averaging over rapid oscillations we get for the slowly varying functions @xmath136 the following coupled system with cubic - quintic interactions @xmath137 ) at the critical strength of the inter - species nol @xmath138 for a delocalizing transition to occur .
the mode has equal critical number of atoms @xmath139 with the same chemical potential @xmath140 and same profiles in both components .
the dashed line represents the corresponding effective potential @xmath141 in eqs .
( [ self1 ] ) and ( [ self2 ] ) .
other parameters are fixed as @xmath142 , @xmath84 , @xmath91 .
bottom panel .
time evolution of the townes soliton mode in the top panel as obtained from eq .
( [ gp]).,title="fig:",width=287 ] ) at the critical strength of the inter - species nol @xmath138 for a delocalizing transition to occur .
the mode has equal critical number of atoms @xmath139 with the same chemical potential @xmath140 and same profiles in both components .
the dashed line represents the corresponding effective potential @xmath141 in eqs .
( [ self1 ] ) and ( [ self2 ] ) .
other parameters are fixed as @xmath142 , @xmath84 , @xmath91 .
bottom panel .
time evolution of the townes soliton mode in the top panel as obtained from eq .
( [ gp]).,title="fig : " ] when @xmath143 , we obtain a system of coupled quintic nls equations . for the symmetric case @xmath144
, the system reduces to the quintic nls equation @xmath145 with @xmath146 the townes soliton solution of eq .
( [ qnls ] ) is @xmath147 with norm given by @xmath148 this solution behaves as a separatrix between collapsing and decaying solutions of the quintic nlse . here
@xmath149 and the vk criterion gives marginal stability .
the total hamiltonian is equal zero on this solution @xmath150 .
for example , for parameters values @xmath151 , we obtain the critical number @xmath152 . a comparison with the numerical results in fig .
[ fig11ms ] shows that the averaged nls quintic equation overestimates the critical number @xmath153 by about @xmath154 percent(notice that for the same parameters values we have @xmath155 in fig .
[ fig11ms ] ) . from this
we conclude that the quintic nls can be used only as a qualitative model for the delocalizing transitions of two component bec in nol . in the following
we shall investigate townes solitons and delocalizing transitions by recurring to numerical methods .
delocalizing transitions in binary bec mixtures with nol and in coupled nls equations with cubic - quintic nonlinearities have not been previously investigated . to show the existence of this phenomenon in a binary bec mixture in a nol we vary in time
the parameter @xmath156 characterizing the intra - species interaction while keeping fixed the inter - species nols to which the two component are subjected .
starting from a given value of @xmath157 , for which a stable os - os mode exists , we adiabatically decrease @xmath156 to a value @xmath158 and then increase it back to the original value . in absence of delocalizing transitions
the state will restore to its original form for any decrement @xmath159 , while in presence of a delocalizing transition a threshold value for @xmath159 will appear above which the state becomes irreversibly delocalized ( it can not be restored to its original form ) . in fig .
[ fig10 ] we show the time evolution of an os - os symmetric state with an equal number of atoms in the two components , during a variation of the inter - species interaction in time according of the form @xmath160\}. \label{g1}\ ] ] .
the top panel shows the time evolution of the mode when the inter - species parameter @xmath156 is varied according to eq .
( [ g1 ] ) with @xmath161 , @xmath162 , @xmath163 .
the bottom panel shows the same evolution but for the case @xmath164 .
other parameters are fixed as @xmath142 , @xmath84 , @xmath91 , @xmath165 .
the chemical potentials of the initial states at @xmath166 are @xmath167.,title="fig:",width=321 ] .
the top panel shows the time evolution of the mode when the inter - species parameter @xmath156 is varied according to eq .
( [ g1 ] ) with @xmath161 , @xmath162 , @xmath163 .
the bottom panel shows the same evolution but for the case @xmath164 .
other parameters are fixed as @xmath142 , @xmath84 , @xmath91 , @xmath165 .
the chemical potentials of the initial states at @xmath166 are @xmath167.,title="fig:",width=321 ] from the top panel of this figure it is clear that for a small decrement @xmath159 the state is able to restore the initial waveform , while for a larger decrement the state becomes fully delocalized . in analogy to what has been done for the nls equation with periodic potential and quintic nonlinearity @xcite
, one can characterize the delocalizing transition in terms of the unstable states which separate localized modes from extended ones . for the parameter used in fig .
[ fig10 ] , the critical value in the strength of the nol for the occurrence of a delocalizing transition is found to be @xmath168 . in fig .
[ fig11ms ] we show the existence of an unstable stationary state found in correspondence of this value , which has properties similar to the townes solitons of the quintic 1d nls or of cubic multidimensional nls .
note that this stationary state corresponds to the unstable branch presented in the bottom panel of fig .
[ fig04 ] [ see the exact results for @xmath80 ] . from fig .
[ fig12ms ] , it is indeed clear that for slight undercritical variations of the norm ( number of atoms ) the state becomes delocalized , while for slight overcritical variations of the norm it shrinks to a fully localized mode , resembling the behavior of townes solitons .
notice that due to the equal number of atoms @xmath170 the modes in the two components have identical chemical potentials and identical profiles . for an undercritical @xmath171 ( top panel ) and overcritical @xmath172 ( bottom panel ) number of atoms .
other parameters are fixed as in fig .
[ fig11ms].,title="fig : " ] for an undercritical @xmath171 ( top panel ) and overcritical @xmath172 ( bottom panel ) number of atoms .
other parameters are fixed as in fig .
[ fig11ms].,title="fig : " ] a delocalizing transition is also observed for os - os states with different number of atoms in the two components . in this case
the system shows a much rich behavior due to the possibility to use the inter - species interaction to stabilize localized states which in absence of interaction would be extended over the whole system .
an example of such inter - species induced localization is given in fig .
[ fig14 ] for an os - os symmetric states of fig .
[ fig13 ] with an unbalanced number of atoms ( a large difference in the number of atoms in the two components ) .
in particular , in absence of the inter - species interactions , the first component has enough atoms to be above the delocalizing threshold , while the second component is taken to be below such a threshold , so that the state delocalizes in absence of interaction . from fig .
[ fig14 ] we see , indeed , that the presence of the inter - species interaction prevents the second component to delocalize , while in absence of the inter - species interaction the first component remains localized and the second one delocalizes in a quite short time . due to the many parameters of the problem , a full investigation of the delocalizing transitions of the fundamental os - os mode in binary bec mixtures with nol requires more extensive numerical investigations .
we plan to do this in a separated publication . ) with unbalanced number of atoms @xmath173 , and for nol parameters : @xmath174 , @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 .
the continuous ( dashed ) curve refer to the first ( second ) component .
the chemical potentials of the modes are @xmath175 the dashed line refers to the second component.,width=283,height=283 ] in the presence ( top panels ) and in the absence ( bottom panels ) of the inter - species nol of strength @xmath176 .
, width=321 ] in the presence ( top panels ) and in the absence ( bottom panels ) of the inter - species nol of strength @xmath176 .
, width=321 ]
in this paper we have investigated the localized states in two - component bec with periodic modulation in space intra - species and inter - species scattering lengths .
the stability regions are analyzed using the variational approach and the vakhitov - kolokolov criterion .
the symmetry properties ( with respect to the nol ) of the localized modes in each component were considered and their stability properties investigated .
we showed that localized modes of os - os type are always stable and represents the fundamental ground states of the system in the presence of attractive interactions .
intersite symmetric modes and mixed symmetry modes also exist but they appear to be metastable under gpe time evolution , decaying into modes of os - os - type . the existence regions in the parameter space of strongly localized modes ( localized on few cells of the nol ) of fundamental type were predicted by mean of the variational ansatz and their stability properties predicted by the vakhitov - kolokolov criterion .
localized modes on tops of periodic backgrounds and of bright - dark solitons were also shown to exist in the case of binary mixtures with opposite interactions in the two components . in spite of the quasi 1d nature of the problem we showed that fundamental solitons undergo a delocalizing transition when
the strength of the intersite non linear optical lattice is varied .
this transition was associated with the existence of an unstable localized solution which extends on many lattice cells of the the nol and which exhibit a shrinking ( decaying ) behavior for slightly overcritical ( undercritical ) variations in the number of atoms .
this behavior was shown to exists for fundamental modes both with equal and unequal numbers of atoms in the two components .
the existence of the delocalizing transition for the fundamental modes was inferred also from a reduced vector gpe obtained by averaging the original gpe system with respect to the rapid spatial oscillations introduced by the nol .
the process of averaging the nol introduces high order nonlinearities ( cubic - quintic ) which make the problem to be effectively equivalent to an higher dimensional vector gpe system for which delocalizing transition , in analogy to single component multidimensional cases , are usually expected . the study of the delocalizing transition for fundamental multi - component solitons in terms of an averaged vector gpe with higher order nonlinearities , as well as the extension of the above analysis to the multidimensional case , appear to be interesting problems which deserve further investigations .
fka and ms wish to thank the instituto de fsica terica , universidade estadual paulista ( unesp ) for hospitality . for the financial support , which makes possible to realize this collaboration , we thank fundao de amparo pesquisa do estado de so paulo ( fapesp ) .
ms acknowledges partial financial support from the mur through the inter - university project prin-2005 : transport properties of classical and quantum systems " .
ag and lt also thank conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico ( cnpq ) for partial financial support .
the numerical methods employed in this paper are described in the following subsections .
we solve the nonlinear eigenvalue problem in ( [ gp ] ) by treating the nonlinear part in self consistent manner .
this amounts to consider the following linear eigenvalue problem @xmath177 with the effective potentials defined as @xmath178 in the discrete coordinate space representation @xmath179 , @xmath180 , @xmath181 . here
@xmath182 denotes the kinetic energy operator @xmath183 , @xmath184 is the length of the system and @xmath185 the number of grid points . by taking as a basis the set of vectors @xmath186 , @xmath187 and noting that @xmath188 is already diagonal in this basis while @xmath182 is diagonal in the momentum representation @xmath189 , we have that the matrix elements of @xmath190 can written as @xmath191 where @xmath192 denotes the fourier ( unitary ) transform of the vector @xmath193 .
standard diagonalization routines are then used to find eigenvalues ( chemical potentials ) and eigenfunctions .
the nonlinear eigenvalue is then solved in self - consistent manner starting from trial wavefunctions @xmath194 , @xmath195 , calculating the effective potentials , solving the eigenvalue problems ( [ self1 ] ) by diagonalizing the correspondig matrices ( [ matrices ] ) , selecting given eigenstates as new trial functions , and iterating the procedure until convergence is reached ( see refs.@xcite for applications to single and multicomponent bec cases ) .
stable states are obtained using standard relaxation algorithm in imaginary time propagation , fixing the normalizations given by number of atoms of the two species , @xmath196 and @xmath197 , and obtaining the chemical potentials @xmath198 and @xmath199 . for the hyperbolic ( unstable ) states we extended to a coupled equation system the method developed in ref.@xcite , scheme c , in which the idea of back renormalization " was used . in this method , it is given the chemical potential to obtain the number of atoms .
for a coupled system , the scheme c of ref .
@xcite can be generalized , evolving the following equations in imaginary time :
@xmath200 where we have normalized @xmath201 and @xmath202 to one , such that @xmath203 and @xmath204 . @xmath205 and @xmath206 are given by eq .
( [ gammas ] ) . where the superscripts ( @xmath210 , @xmath211 , etc ) refer to time steps .
@xmath212 is the crank - nicolson evolution operation corresponding to @xmath213 .
note that , in this coupled system the back renormalization ( of @xmath214 and @xmath215 ) is done by exchanging the corresponding wavefunctions ( as @xmath196 is associated to @xmath201 and @xmath197 to @xmath202 ) .
this procedure is required for stability , as verified in numerical tests .
the excited states is - os and is - is depicted in fig .
[ fig06 ] can be obtained by relaxing eqs .
( [ ap1])-([ap12 ] ) for @xmath216 and imposing the von neumann boundary conditions in the origin , i.e. , at @xmath217 , @xmath218 and @xmath219 .
the present relaxation algorithms are unable to find the state shown in fig .
[ fig08 ] , which was obtained by the approach given in subsection a. b.b .
baizakov , v.v .
konotop , and m. salerno , j. phys .
b * 35 * 5105 ( 2002 ) ; b.b .
baizakov , b.a .
malomed , and m. salerno , europhys .
lett . * 63 * , 642 ( 2003 ) ; e.a .
ostrovskaya , yu.s .
kivshar , phys .
* 90 * , 160407 ( 2003 ) .
s.inouye et al .
nature(london ) * 392 * , 151 ( 1998 ) ; j. stenger et al .
lett . * 82 * , 2422 ( 1999 ) ; j.l .
roberts et al . , phys .
. lett . * 81 * , 5109 ( 1998 ) ; s.l .
cornish , n.r .
claussen , j.l .
roberts , e.a .
cornell , and c.e .
wieman , phys .
lett . * 85 * , 1795 ( 2000 ) ; e.a .
donley et al . ,
nature(london ) * 412 * , 295 ( 2001 ) . | the properties of the localized states of a two component bose - einstein condensate confined in a nonlinear periodic potential [ nonlinear optical lattice ] are investigated .
we reveal the existence of new types of solitons and study their stability by means of analytical and numerical approaches .
the symmetry properties of the localized states with respect to the nol are also investigated .
we show that nonlinear optical lattices allow the existence of bright soliton modes with equal symmetry in both components , bright localized modes of mixed symmetry type , as well as , dark - bright bound states and bright modes on periodic backgrounds . in spite of the quasi 1d nature of the problem ,
the fundamental symmetric localized modes undergo a delocalizing transition when the strength of the nonlinear optical lattice is varied .
this transition is associated with the existence of an unstable solution , which exhibits a shrinking ( decaying ) behavior for slightly overcritical ( undercritical ) variations in the number of atoms . |
many devices exhibit negative differential conductance ( @xmath3 ) as multiple quantum wells , double barrier , double quantum dots , etc ndc1,ndc2,ndc3,ndc4,dqd1,dqds .
the @xmath3 has applications as amplifiers and oscillators in the microwave , mm - wave and terahertz frequency range .
extensive experimental and theoretical investigation have been devoted to the study of the @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics and @xmath3 phenomenon in double quantum dot molecules @xcite .
moreover , there is a wide literature on transport through double quantum dots ( @xmath4 ) in different geometries , e.g , @xmath4 in series and in parallel @xcite .
two aspects of electronic transport through quantum dots have attracted great attention in the last years , the coulomb blockade effect and the kondo effect . recently
kondo effect has been studied in side attached @xcite and parallel quantum dots @xcite .
recent electron transport experiments showed that kondo and fano resonances occur simultaneously @xcite .
multiple scattering of traveling electronic waves on a localized magnetic state are crucial for the formation of both resonances .
the condition for the fano resonance is the existence of two scattering channels : a discrete level and a broad continuum band @xcite .
an alternative configuration consists of a double quantum dot molecule side coupled to a perfect quantum wire ( qw)@xcite . this structure is reminiscent of the t - shaped quantum wave guides @xcite . in this case , the qds act as scattering centers in close analogy with the traditional kondo effect @xcite .
although the electron - electron interaction does play an important role in many systems that exhibit negative differential conductance , as for instance producing bi - stabilities in the current , it is not the driving force of the negative conductance itself . in this work instead , we study a system in the kondo regime with a @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics that possesses a @xmath3 region that is induced by the electronic correlation itself , tuned by the external potential and the parameters of the system .
the system is constituted by a quantum dot molecule side coupled to a quantum wire , as shown in fig .
[ f : esquema ] .
we use the finite-@xmath2 slave boson mean - field approach , which was initially developed by kotliar and ruckenstein @xcite and used later by bing dong and x. l. lei to study the transport through coupled double quantum dots connected to leads dl01 .
this approach enforces the correspondence between the impurity fermions and the auxiliary bosons to a mean - field level to release the @xmath5 restriction .
this allows to treat non - perturbatively the dot - lead coupling for an arbitrary strength of the coulomb interaction @xmath2 @xcite . in a previous work
we study this system in a thermodynamic equilibrium situation .
we found that in the weak interaction regime , when the direct antiferromagnetic interaction between the dots is less than the kondo temperature associated to the internal dot , the transmission spectrum shows a structure with two anti - resonances localized at the renormalized molecular energies of the double quantum dot @xcite .
the ldos of the system shows that when the kondo correlations are dominant the system is in a two stage kondo regime with two different temperatures @xmath6 , each one associated to a dot . in the present paper
we study this system under the effect of a finite external field , which takes it out of the thermodynamic equilibrium , modifying the kondo regime and even destroying it , for enough large fields .
this process has fundamental consequences on the transport properties of the system , and in particular , creates a remarkable @xmath3 in the @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics .
this @xmath3 phenomenon can be understood realizing that the applied bias destroys the lower temperature kondo state of the external dot modifying the capability of the other to interfere on the current that goes along the system .
let us consider a quantum dot molecule side coupled to a perfect quantum wire ( qw ) ( see fig . [
f : esquema ] ) . we describe it by the two - impurity anderson hamiltonian .
each dot has a single level energy @xmath7 ( with @xmath8 ) and equal intra - dot coulomb repulsion @xmath2 .
the side attached quantum - dot molecule is coupled to the qw with coupling @xmath9 .
the qw sites have zero local energies and a hopping parameter @xmath10 .
( 220,100)(0,0 ) ( 40,70)(1,0)140 ( 110,70)(0,-1)60 ( 110,10 ) ( 110,30 ) ( 100,30)(0,0)@xmath11 ( 100,10)(0,0)@xmath12 ( 120,50)(0,0)@xmath9 ( 120,20)(0,0)@xmath13 ( 50,75)(0,0)[b ] ( 70,75)(0,0)[b ] ( 90,75)(0,0)[b]-1 ( 110,75)(0,0)[b]0 ( 130,75)(0,0)[b]1 ( 150,75)(0,0)[b ] ( 170,75)(0,0)[b ] ( 110,90)(0,0)[b]qw ( 150,20)(0,0)[l]dqd ( 80,0)(60,40 ) ( 10,70)(0,0)[r]@xmath14 ( 210,70)(0,0)[l]@xmath15 ( 40,70)(0,0)[r]@xmath16 ( 180,70)(0,0)[l]@xmath16 ( 50,70)(20,0)7 ( 60,65)(20,0)6(0,0)[t ] ( 0,50)(40,70)(0,90 ) ( 220,50)(180,70)(220,90 ) the corresponding model hamiltonian is , @xmath17 + \sum_{l=1,2,\sigma } \left [ \left ( \varepsilon_{l}+\frac{u}{2}\hat{n}_{l,-\sigma}\right ) \hat{n}_{l,\sigma } \right ] \,\ ] ] where @xmath18 ( @xmath19 ) is the creation ( annihilation ) operator of an electron with spin @xmath20 at the @xmath21-th site of the quantum wire ; @xmath22 ( @xmath23 ) is the creation ( annihilation ) operator of an electron with spin @xmath20 in the l - th qd , @xmath24 is the corresponding number operator , @xmath13 is the hopping matrix element between the dots and @xmath7 correspond to the energy of the local states at the dots .
to find the solution of this correlated fermions system for finite u , we appeal to an analytical approach where , generalizing the infinite-@xmath2 slave - boson approximation @xcite the hilbert space is enlarged at each site , to contain in addition to the original fermions a set of four bosons @xcite represented by the creation ( annihilation ) operators @xmath25 ( @xmath26 ) , @xmath27 ( @xmath28 ) , and @xmath29 ( @xmath30 ) for the @xmath31-th dot .
they act as projectors onto empty , single occupied ( with spin up and down ) and doubly occupied electron states , respectively .
then , each creation ( annihilation ) operator of an electron with spin @xmath32 in the l - th qd , is substituted by @xmath33 ( @xmath34 ) where : @xmath35 as the problem is solved adopting the u - finite slave boson mean field approximation ( sbmfa ) , the operator is chosen to reproduce the correct @xmath36 limit in the mean - field approximation without changing neither the eigenvalues nor the eigenvector.@xcite the constraint , i.e. , the completeness relation @xmath37 and the condition among fermions and bosons @xmath38 , is incorporated with lagrange multipliers @xmath39 and @xmath40 into the hamiltonian .
also in the mean - field approximation all the boson operators are replaced by their expectation values @xmath41 and @xmath42 which can be chosen , without loss of generality , as real numbers .
the hamiltonian in this new and enlarged hilbert space , is , @xmath43 , where @xmath44 depends explicitly only upon the boson expectation values ( @xmath45 and equivalently for the others operators ) and the lagrange multipliers .
the hamiltonian @xmath46 can be written , @xmath47 the tight - binding hamiltonian depends implicitly on the boson expectation values through the parameters : @xmath48 , @xmath49 , where @xmath50is the value assumed by the operator @xmath51 when the four boson operators are substituted by their mean values in equation [ e : eq2 ] .
@xmath52 the boson operator expectation values and the lagrange multipliers are determined by minimizing the energy @xmath53 with respect to these quantities .
it is obtained in this way a set of nonlinear equations for each quantum dot , relating the expectation values of the four bosonic operators , the three lagrange multipliers and the electronic expectation values , [ e : minimizing ] @xmath54 where in the absence of external magnetic field the solutions are spin independent . to obtain the electronic expectation values @xmath55
, the hamiltonian , @xmath56 is diagonalized .
their stationary states can be written as @xmath57 where @xmath58 and @xmath59 are the probability amplitudes to find the electron at the site @xmath60 and at the @xmath31-th qd respectively , with energy @xmath61 . as we study the paramagnetic case the spin index is neglected .
the amplitudes @xmath58 and @xmath59 obey the following linear difference equations [ e : diferencias ] @xmath62 in order to study the solutions of eqs . , we assume that the electrons are described by an incident , a reflected and a transmitted plane waves with unitary , @xmath63 and @xmath64 amplitudes , respectively.@xcite that is , [ e : solut ] @xmath65 inserting eqs . into eqs .
, we get an inhomogeneous system of linear equations for @xmath64 , @xmath63 , @xmath58 and @xmath66 , leading to the following expression in equilibrium ( @xmath67 ) @xmath68 where the bonding ( @xmath69 ) and antibonding energy ( @xmath70 ) are defined by @xmath71 and @xmath72 is the renormalized coupling between the double quantum - dot and the quantum wire and @xmath73 is the density of states of the leads at the fermi level . in spite of the apparent simplicity of the expression , it is necessary to remember that the quantities @xmath74 and @xmath75 implicitly depend on the expectation values of the boson and fermion operators . the transmission probability is given by @xmath76 , @xmath77^{2}}{[(\omega -\tilde{\varepsilon}_{-})(\omega -\tilde{% \varepsilon}_{+})]^{2}+[(\omega -\tilde{\varepsilon}_{d2})\tilde{\gamma}]^{2}% } \,.\ ] ] from the amplitudes @xmath78 and @xmath79 we obtain the local density of states ( ldos ) at the quantum dot @xmath31 ( with @xmath80 ) .
@xmath81^{2}+[(\omega -\tilde{\varepsilon}_{d2})\tilde{\gamma}]^{2}}\ , , \\ \rho _ { 2 } & = \frac{1}{\pi } \frac{\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{t}_{c}^{2}}{[(\omega -%
\tilde{\varepsilon}_{-})(\omega -\tilde{\varepsilon}_{+})]^{2}+[(\omega -% \tilde{\varepsilon}_{d2})\tilde{\gamma}]^{2}}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the nonequilibrium case , we suppose a finite source - drain biased with a symmetric voltage drop .
the incident electrons from the left side ( @xmath82 ) are in equilibrium with the thermodynamical potential @xmath83 and those from the right side ( @xmath84 ) with @xmath85 once the amplitudes @xmath86 and @xmath87 are known , the electronic expectation values are obtained from , @xmath88 where @xmath89 the current given by , @xmath90 where @xmath91 it is the fermi function for incident electrons from the @xmath92 side and the sum on @xmath93 is taken up to the maximum value @xmath94 ( solid line ) , @xmath95 for various values of on site energy , @xmath96(solid line ) , @xmath97(dotted line ) @xmath98(dashed line ) ] ( solid line ) , @xmath99 for various values of the gate voltage,@xmath95(solid line),@xmath100(dotted line ) and @xmath101(dashed line ) ] the quantities @xmath102 , the energies of the local states at the dots , are taken to be equal to @xmath103 , where @xmath104 is the gate voltage applied to the quantum dots .
in order to obtain a more clear insight , we study first the system in thermodynamical equilibrium . the dos at each dot of the quantum - molecule is shown in figure [ f : fig2 ] , for various values of @xmath2 , for the case @xmath105 and @xmath106 .
as u increases , @xmath107 , the system passes from the intermediate valence regime into a kondo regime .
this process is clearly seen to occur for qd2 where the resonance shifts and becomes sharper as the system enters into the kondo regime .
the same process takes place for the qd1 although the sharpening is less accentuated .
it is noticeable that as qd2 develops a kondo resonance , a dip appears at the fermi energy in the ldos of qd1 .
this is produced because the spin of the local electron at qd2 is kondo correlated with the conduction band spins through the mediation of the intermediate dot , that is as well at the kondo regime .
this coupling creates a sharp peak at the ldos of qd2 with width @xmath108 and a depletion of this same width at the fermi level of the kondo peak of width @xmath109 corresponding to qd1 .
this result implies the existence of a two stage kondo regime that appears in this system in the weak interacting limit , when @xmath110 @xcite , being @xmath109 and @xmath108 the kondo temperatures associated to each dot .
it is the depletion of the ldos of qd1 at the fermi level that permits the transmission to be unity . in this case , although the side attached qd1 , is in the kondo regime , it does not provide an alternative path for the conducting electrons . as a consequence , there is no destructive interference because there is only the direct path available for them . in figure
[ f : fig3 ] we show the ldos of each qd for different values of @xmath111 in the two stage kondo regime .
as expected , the peaks are pinned at the fermi energy independent of the values of the @xmath104 , a clear signal of the kondo regime .
here it is clearly seen at the fermi energy , the antiresonance at it qd2 and the concomitant resonance at the qd1 .
-@xmath1 characteristics for @xmath112 ( solid line ) and @xmath113 ( dashed line ) for various values of @xmath2 with @xmath114 the previous discussion was restricted to the thermodynamical equilibrium situation and was presented with the purpose of clarifying the concepts involved .
when an external potential is applied the scenario changes completely .
the physics of this new situation can be explained analyzing the current and the differential conductance @xmath115 , two significant and experimentally measurable quantities , as a function of the applied field .
figure [ f : fig4 ] displays the @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics ( solid line ) for two values of @xmath116 and different values of @xmath2 , with @xmath117 . for @xmath98 ,
the @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics shows a plateau that is related to the fano antiresonances in the transmission spectrum .
when the applied potential is of the order of the interdot interaction , the transmission , due to the fano destructive interference , is almost zero in the bonding and antibonding regions giving no additional contribution to the total current as the applied potential is increased .
this is the origin of the plateau behavior , shown in the figure [ f : fig4 ] , when u=0 .
as @xmath2 is increased , a negative differential conductance appears in the @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics that gets more important as @xmath118 is augmented .
( solid line ) and @xmath119 ( dashed line ) , for various values of @xmath2 with @xmath117 ] figure [ f : fig5 ] depicts the differential conductance for the same parameters of fig.[f : fig4 ] .
for @xmath98 it reflects essentially the transmission spectrum . as @xmath2
is increased the differential conductance becomes negative in a region of the applied potential , reflecting the fact that the @xmath3 is a consequence of the coulomb interaction .
it is a small effect in the fluctuating valence regime @xmath121 and develops completely in the kondo regime @xmath122 , increasing with @xmath123 in order to get insight into these results it is convenient to write the transmission ( eq.11 ) as the superposition of a fano and a breit - wigner line shapes , a good approximate expression for large values of @xmath2@xcite .
the results is , @xmath124 where @xmath125 and @xmath126 corresponds to the two kondo temperatures @xmath127 and @xmath128 an analytical expression can be obtain for the current by integrating over @xmath129 the transmission probability given in eq . .
@xmath130 , \label{current}\ ] ] we identify each term of the eq . as follows .
the first term in the right side is the contribution arising from an ideal one dimensional conductor .
the second term arises from the kondo - fano state with temperature @xmath109 giving rise to a quasi plateau for the current and almost zero differential conductance when @xmath131 .
the third term arises from the kondo state weakly coupled to the wire and it is responsible for the rapid increase of the current in the region of small applied potentials .
it is important to emphasize that in this expression the quantities @xmath132 and @xmath133 are functions of @xmath1 obtained through the self - consistent calculation presented above .
the case of @xmath134 is shown in the inset of fig.[f : fig6 ] .
it is clear that increasing @xmath1 , both the kondo temperature of the external dot and the current reduce to zero simultaneously with the disappearance of the @xmath3 phenomenon . as mentioned above ,
this behavior can be understood realizing that the effect of the external quantum dot is to reduce the intermediate dot interference effect on the current circulating along the leads .
this role is exercised by the external quantum dot as far as it is at the kondo regime .
when the external potential is large enough as to disrupt its kondo ground state ( @xmath135)the interference is reestablished and the current goes to zero .
as @xmath108 increases with @xmath13 , for larger values of @xmath13 this disrupting process requires bigger values of the applied potential as shown in fig.[f : fig4 ] .
when @xmath136increases still further it destroys as well the kondo regime of the intermediate quantum dot and the current rises as depicted in this same figure .
this seems to be the behavior of a two stage kondo system under the effect of an external potential .
the kondo regime of the outside quantum dot , not directly connected to the continuum , depends upon the kondo effect of the intermediate quantum dot . as
its kondo temperature is lower , its kondo ground state is disrupted by lower values of @xmath1 than the other dot .
this process manifests in the transport properties by the appearance of a @xmath3 region in the current .
the fig.[f : fig6 ] displays a comparison between the @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics of the numerical calculation and the approximation ( eq .
( 17 ) ) for @xmath137 and @xmath138 .
the approximation over estimates the peak of the current however , qualitatively , it maintains the form .
deriving the current in eq.([current ] ) we obtain @xmath139 \right\ } .\ ] ] @xmath1 characteristics between the numerical calculation ( solid line)and the approximation ( eq.4)(dashed line ) for @xmath140 , @xmath112 with @xmath141 .
@xmath142 in the inset ] in the above equation , the last term is responsible for the negative differential conductance .
this term is negative because @xmath143 .
this expression is able to reproduce very well the results of the differential conductance shown in fig.[f : fig5 ] . regarding the observability of the @xmath3 in the side - coupled double quantum dot molecule , we consider the value of @xmath144 given by sato et al .
sato , @xmath145 .
for @xmath146 and @xmath147 the maximum and minimum of the current are @xmath148 na and @xmath149 na , respectively , giving a peak to valley ratio of 4:1 .
the lower kondo temperature of the external dot for these same parameters is of the order of 2 k. these values of the current and temperature are well above the experimental limits of present day techniques .
in summary we have studied the nonequilibrium transport through a double quantum dot molecule side - coupled to a quantum wire using the finite-@xmath2 slave boson mean field approach at @xmath150 as a function of the parameters that define the system .
we find that the @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics shows a remarkable @xmath3 , different from case reported in the literature , is induced by the electronic correlation .
this @xmath3 behavior is a consequence of the properties of a two stage kondo system under the effect of an external applied potential that takes the system out of equilibrium when the applied potential is large enough to destroy the kondo regime characterized by the lower kondo temperature .
we would like to thank m.a .
davidovich for her very useful comments of the manuscript .
this work was partially financial supported by conicyt / programa bicentenario de ciencia y tecnologia ( cenava , grant act27 ) , ciam ( conicyt - cnpq - nsf ) and fondecyt under grant 1040385 .
thank u.a .
( pei-1305 - 04 ) .
e.v.a . acknowledges support from the brazilian agencies , cnpq and faperj . | electron tunneling through a two stage kondo system constituted by a double quantum - dot molecule side coupled to a quantum wire , under the effect of a finite external potential is studied .
we found that @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristic shows a negative differential conductance region induced by the electronic correlation .
this phenomenon is a consequence of the properties of the two stage kondo regime under the effect of an external applied potential that takes the system out of equilibrium .
the problem is solved using the mean - field finite-@xmath2 slave - boson formalism . |
nasa s _ kepler _ mission has revolutionized our understanding of planetary systems , their occurrence rate , multiplicity and physical properties .
one trend apparent among this new class of small planets was a - priori quite unexpected from traditional theories ; there is a statistically significant excess of planet pairs with period ratios slightly wide of first order mean motion resonances such as 2:1 and 3:2 , and a dearth of them just narrow of these resonances ( @xcite ; figure [ fig : obs ] ) .
interestingly , this trend is absent in planets that were previously discovered via radial velocity ( rv ) surveys ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
smooth gas - disk migration can trap planets in mmrs .
however , such resonant planets are expected to have period ratios with very small offsets from the integer ratio corresponding to the mmr , @xmath0 .
indeed , adjacent planet pairs discovered via past rv surveys show period ratio distribution with a distinct excess at the expected period ratio for the 2:1 mmr with very small @xmath1 , consistent with the expectations from smooth gas - disk driven migration ( @xcite ) .
in contrast , the near - resonant _ kepler _ planet pairs are likely not in actual resonance ( @xcite ) .
nevertheless , the overall close to uniform distribution away from resonance , and the mysterious asymmetric abundance across mmrs , such as 2:1 and 3:2 , indicate that the _ kepler _ planet pairs somehow knew about these resonances .
however , some other process has driven them wide of the resonance and created this asymmetry .
planet - planet scattering can break resonances , however , they bring dramatic changes in the planetary orbits , often making them highly eccentric , which is inconsistent with the multi - transiting architecture of the _ kepler _ systems ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the large ( @xmath2 ) positive offsets in the near - resonant planet pairs observed by _ kepler _ thus has generated a lot of interest .
it is generally believed that these planets were initially trapped in a mmr .
subsequently , some dissipative process drove them wide of their initial period ratios .
the most likely dissipative mechanism responsible for the observed trend is still a matter of debate .
the proposed dissipative mechanisms include dissipation from tide ( @xcite ) , turbulence in protoplanetary disk ( @xcite ) , and scattering with a planetesimal disk ( @xcite ; cf15 ) .
although , the most well studied , the tidal dissipation mechanism is also the most debated .
@xcite argue that even under generous assumptions , the large observed positive @xmath1 for most _ kepler _ planet pairs near a mmr can not be explained by tides alone .
it was also suggested that in - place mass growth of a planet via planetesimal accretion can lead to formation of an over density of particles just wide of a mmr ( @xcite ) .
however , planetesimal accretion typically lead to migration of the planet making the in situ growth assumption questionable . it was also suggested that the observed period ratio distribution may be explained due to overstable libration of the _ kepler _ planets due to gas - disk driven migration coupled with eccentricity damping ( @xcite ) .
however , @xcite present an opposing view . in this article
, we will focus on planet - planetesimal disk interactions as the mechanism for the observed asymmetric period ratio distribution across 2:1 .
planet - planetesimal disk interactions have been well studied in other contexts , especially for the outer solar system , and is generally believed to be a natural consequence of the core - accretion paradigm of planet formation ( e.g. , @xcite ) . in [ s : numeric ] we will briefly describe our numerical setup . in [ s : results ] we will highlight our key results .
first , we will highlight the findings of cf15 with some additional details .
we will also present results from new simulations involving interactions of initially non - resonant planets with a planetesimal disk . finally , in [ s : discuss ] we will summarize our results and discuss the implications .
the simulations presented in this article are from two distinct sets .
one investigates the effects of planetesimal scattering on the orbits of two planets initially trapped in a 2:1 mmr ( cf15 ) .
we call this set 1 .
the other investigates the effects of planetesimal scattering on planet orbits that are not initially trapped in 2:1 mmr but , are just narrow of the mmr .
we call this set 2
. the details of the numerical setup for set 1 are described in cf15 . however , for completeness , we will briefly describe the key aspects .
in general , the physical picture we have in mind is that while a gas disk is present , gas - disk interactions may trap two planets into 2:1 mmr .
once the gas disk is depleted , the resonant planets can freely interact with a residual planetesimal disk .
we are interested in the effects of the latter interactions .
thus , we are interested in a system that initially was dissipative and transitions into a @xmath3-body . ideally , planets , planetesimals , and a gas disk should be modeled together with all physics included , however , this full problem is computationally impractical .
hence , we generate plausible initial conditions for the stage of planet - planetesimal disk interactions in two steps .
first , we use an analytic @xmath4 and @xmath5 prescription to trap two planets in 2:1 mmr ( @xcite ) .
second , we create planetesimal orbits consistent with the presence of the planets in the following way .
the structure of the residual planetesimal disk after gas - disk depletion is uncertain .
nevertheless , we use planetesimal disk profiles described by @xmath6 , where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are the surface density and distance from the star for the planetesimals , respectively . at the epoch of gas disk depletion
, the planetesimal disk profile would not remain a simple power - law .
instead , the planets would alter the planetesimal disk densities near them by dynamically scattering or accreting some of the nearby planetesimals that are on orbits unstable even with the stabilization provided by dissipation from a gas disk ( e.g. , @xcite ) . to imitate this effect we embed the resonant planets in a planetesimal disk with a power - law profile given by @xmath9 .
we treat all planetesimals as test particles .
we let the planets alter the disk for at least @xmath10 orbits of the outer planet . we collect the properties of the planetesimals that survive this phase and create a database of allowed planetesimal orbits for each planet pair .
we call this the clean - up stage
. we randomly choose @xmath11 orbits from this database , assign masses to the planetesimals according to the assumed planetesimal disk mass to planet mass ratio .
we evolve the resonant planets with the planetesimals until the period ratio of the planets orbits stop changing ( @xmath12 years ) .
cf15 has varied the planetesimal disk profile by changing the power - law index @xmath13 between -2.5 to 3 , planet - planet mass ratios @xmath14 between 0.1 to 10 , and the planetesimal disk to planet mass ratio ( @xmath15 ) between 0.1 to 1.5 .
we have started investigating the effects of a residual planetesimal disk on initially non - resonant planets . in this set , set 2 , we closely follow the prescriptions of cf15 summarized above . however , we choose planet pairs with initial orbits such that the initial period ratio is between 1.8 and 2 , just narrow of the 2:1 mmr .
the inner planet s semimajor axis is kept at @xmath16 , a typical value for the _ kepler _ planets .
we generate 50 systems such that the period ratio @xmath17 is between 1.8 and 2 .
the eccentricities of the planets orbits are drawn from a rayleigh distribution with scale 0.005 ( e.g. @xcite ) .
the orbital inclinations ( @xmath18 ) are drawn uniformly in @xmath19 with @xmath18 between @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
planets have equal mass and are equal to the mass of neptune ( @xmath22 ) and have neptune - like densities . for each pair of planetary orbits created this way
, we generate 4 random realizations varying the phase angles in their full range .
the initial planetesimal disk profile is given by @xmath23 .
the planetesimal disk edges are set at orbits with period @xmath24 and @xmath25 . for each planet pair
, we perform the initial cleaning up of planetesimals exactly the same way as prescribed by cf15 . for each case , a database of orbits is generated .
we randomly select @xmath11 orbits and give each planetesimal a mass @xmath26 , such that @xmath27 .
we integrate the planet - pair and planetesimals using the bulirsch - stoer integrator included in mercury ( @xcite ) .
we stop our integrations at @xmath28 year , equivalent to @xmath29 of the inner planet s initial orbital period .
we confirm that the majority of the planetesimal interactions happen much earlier than our chosen integration stopping time .
( a subset of models presented in cf15 ) .
each panel shows results from models with a different @xmath30 value , listed in each panel . in all cases ,
the planet pairs are initially trapped in a 2:1 mmr . as a result ,
the initial period ratios are always close to 2 .
depending on @xmath30 the final period ratio distribution changes . for @xmath31 resonance
is not broken for most planet pairs .
as @xmath30 increases , so fraction of systems for which resonance is broken and the highest @xmath1 attained , both increase . ]
cf15 has investigated the effects of planetesimal interactions on the orbits of planet pairs initially trapped in a 2:1 mmr .
the key results of cf15 are as follows .
if the total mass of planetesimals that had strong interactions with the planets is high enough to break resonance , then planet - planetesimal interactions naturally increase the period ratio .
the final offset from the mmr depends strongly on the ratio of the total mass of planetesimals that interacted with the planets and the planet mass .
when resonance is broken , offset @xmath1 can have large positive values .
if the resonance is not broken due to insufficient mass in nearby planetesimals , @xmath1 remains small ( @xmath32 ) and can have both positive or negative values . as a result ,
it is easier to break resonance and create large positive @xmath1 for low - mass planet pairs typical of those discovered by _ kepler _ , compared to the much higher mass planet pairs discovered via past rv surveys .
figure [ fig : reso ] shows the initial and final period ratio distribution from a subset of simulations presented in cf15 . as the ratio @xmath30 increases , so does the fraction of systems where the resonance is broken and also the value of the highest @xmath1 the planet pairs can attain . ) .
initially @xmath33 , @xmath34 , and @xmath35 . as a result of planetesimal interactions the period ratios generally increase .
as the pairs approach 2:1 mmr from the inside , the resonance is skipped and the period ratio increases to a value @xmath36 .
thus , a dearth of planet pairs with period ratios just smaller than 2 and an excess of pairs with period ratios just higher than 2 are created . ]
cf15 results suggest that planetesimal interactions with resonant planet pairs can naturally redistribute these planet pairs wide of the initial resonance .
however , cf15 do not directly address the dearth of planet pairs with period ratios just narrow of 2:1 .
we have started a systematic study of the effects of planetesimal scattering on planet pairs that are initially not in resonance , rather has period ratios slightly smaller than 2 ( set 2 ) .
this is equivalent to a scenario where planet pairs do not go through significant migration in a gas disk .
thus , period ratios below and up to 2 are populated uniformly before planetesimal scattering can take place .
figure [ fig : noreso ] shows the initial and final period ratio distributions for a large ( @xmath37 ) set of simulations , each involving two planets and @xmath38 planetesimals ( [ s : numeric ] ) .
initially , the planet pairs have period ratios uniformly spaced between 1.8 and 2 .
interactions with planetesimals from the disk generally increase the period ratios .
interestingly , as some of the planet pairs approach the 2:1 mmr via planetesimal driven divergent migration , they tend to skip the resonance and get deposited wide of the resonance . as a result , a dearth of systems is created with period ratios slightly below 2 and an excess of systems is created with period ratios slightly above 2 . in figure
[ fig : combined ] we combine the models from cf15 with @xmath33 , @xmath34 and @xmath39 with those from set 2 .
although the relative initial abundances between initially resonant and non - resonant planets is somewhat ad - hoc , the combined period ratio distribution is qualitatively very similar to what is observed across the 2:1 mmr for _ kepler _ s adjacent planet pairs .
hence , immediately after gas disk dispersal , if planet pairs have period ratios distributed uniformly below 2:1 with some excess of pairs at 2:1 , and there is sufficient mass in nearby planetesimals in a residual planetesimal disk , then after planetesimal interactions the final period ratio distribution will , at least qualitatively , be very similar to what is observed of the _ kepler _ planet pairs near 2:1 ( figure [ fig : obs ] ) . but combining models from cf15 with @xmath33 , @xmath34 , and @xmath39 and those from set 2 ( [ s : numeric ] ) . ]
in this article we summarize the key results of cf15 . in addition , we present preliminary results from a new set of simulations with initially non - resonant planets and a planetesimal disk .
our results suggest that planetesimal scattering may be responsible for both the excess of planet pairs just wide of the 2:1 mmr and the dearth of systems just narrow of it .
we made several simplifying assumptions in this article .
for example , in the new set of simulations with non - resonant planet pairs , we assume that the initial period ratios are distributed uniformly below 2 and all the way up to 2 .
this of course is not necessarily true in reality . sufficiently far away from a mmr
the period ratios of _ kepler _ s planet pairs appear to be random .
however , they may not have been so immediately after gas disk dispersal . in reality
, there may have been a dearth of systems just narrow of a mmr simply because some systems , while migrating within a gas disk , got trapped into the mmr . in that sense ,
our assumption of uniform period ratio distribution below the 2:1 mmr is the most conservative one .
even if after gas disk dispersal the period ratios are uniformly distributed narrow of the 2:1 mmr , planetesimal scattering from a sufficiently massive disk can create a dearth of systems with period ratios just below 2 .
these systems , in turn , pile up with period ratios slightly above 2 . encouraged by our preliminary results , we are exploring this problem more thoroughly by covering a larger parameter space and obtaining a more detailed understanding of the evolution of the planet pairs as they cross the 2:1 mmr from inside out via planetesimal driven migration .
this research has made use of the nasa exoplanet archive , which is operated by the california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration under the exoplanet exploration program .
we thank frederic a. rasio for helpful comments and discussions .
the cf15 simulations were done using the high performance computing ( hpc ) center at university of florida .
the simulations involving initially non - resonant planets were done using the hpc quest at ciera , northwestern university .
sc was partially supported by nasa grant nnx12ai86 g .
sok thankfully acknowledges nasa s summer research grant .
ebf was supported in part by nasa kepler participating scientist program award nnx14an76 g .
the center for exoplanets and habitable worlds is supported by the pennsylvania state university , the eberly college of science , and the pennsylvania space grant consortium .
question : in your simulations you have ignored planetary migration .
if the planets migrate in a gas disk it will clear a larger gap in the planetesimal disk . as a result ,
after gas dispersal there wo nt be many planetesimals near the planets and interactions will be rare .
can you comment on that ?
chatterjee : indeed , planets would migrate in a gas disk .
so would the planetesimals .
in fact , the planetesimals are expected to migrate faster than the planets . as a result , following gas dispersal , the surface density of planetesimals may be enhanced exterior to the planets .
that is why we considered a wide variety of planetesimal surface density profiles , including those for which the surface density increases with the distance from the star . of course , the ideal way to study this problem is to simulate gas disks , planets , and planetesimals all together including all relevant physical effects .
such simulations are unfortunately numerically impractical .
hence we are forced to adopt a scheme that mimics the expected configuration of a system that was dissipative initially and then became pure @xmath3-body .
in particular , we constructed our initial conditions in two steps , first trapping planets in resonance , and then removing planetesimals that would be unstable on short timescales .
we believe that this could mimic the configuration of planets and planetesimal disks at the epoch of gas dispersal , at least qualitatively .
a larger gap in planetesimals would slow down subsequent interactions with the planets , but as long as there are enough planetesimals to interact with the planets , the planetary orbits will diverge leading to a ratio of orbital periods greater than that of the exact resonance .
given that the general outcome of planet - planetesimal interactions is unchanged for the wide range in explored planetesimal disk properties , we believe that the details of planetesimal disk structures are unlikely to change our results qualitatively . | an intriguing trend among _ kepler _ s multi - planet systems is an overabundance of planet pairs with period ratios just wide of mean motion resonances ( mmr ) and a dearth of systems just narrow of them . in a recently published paper @xcite has proposed that gas - disk migration traps planets in a mmr .
after gas dispersal , orbits of these trapped planets are altered through interaction with a residual planetesimal disk .
they found that for massive enough disks planet - planetesimal disk interactions can break resonances and naturally create moderate to large positive offsets from the initial period ratio for large ranges of planetesimal disk and planet properties .
divergence from resonance only happens if the mass of planetesimals that interact with the planets is at least a few percent of the total planet mass .
this threshold , above which resonances are broken and the offset from resonances can grow , naturally explains why the asymmetric large offsets were not seen in more massive planet pairs found via past radial velocity surveys . in this article
we will highlight some of the key findings of cf15 .
in addition , we report preliminary results from an extension of this study , that investigates the effects of planet - planetesimal disk interactions on initially non - resonant planet pairs . we find that planetesimal scattering typically increases period ratios of non - resonant planets
. if the initial period ratios are below and in proximity of a resonance , under certain conditions , this increment in period ratios can create a deficit of systems with period ratios just below the exact integer corresponding to the mmr and an excess just above . from an initially uniform distribution of period ratios just below a 2:1 mmr
, planetesimal interactions can create an asymmetric distribution across this mmr similar to what is observed for the _ kepler _ planet pairs . |
in recent years , specially in view of an increasing interest in high @xmath0 operation scenarios , such as hybrid scenarios for iter @xcite , the impact of electromagnetic effects on the particle and heat transport has attracted much attention .
here @xmath1 , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 are the electron density and temperature .
@xmath4 is defined as the effective field strength @xcite .
recent reports have shown the significant role of electromagnetic modes such as micro - tearing modes ( mtms ) on the electron heat transport in the core of fusion plasmas @xcite .
it has been found that in plasmas where @xmath0 and collisionality are sufficiently high mtms can become the dominant instability . under these conditions ,
mtms generate a major contribution to the anomalous electron heat flux .
the mtms are small - scale in the radial direction , but ion - scale in the binormal direction .
they are electromagnetic modes with an even parity with respect to the perturbed parallel vector potential , @xmath5 ( referred to as _ tearing parity _ ) . in the literature
two drive mechanisms for mtms are proposed : one is the time - dependent thermal force experienced by electrons which results in a parallel current that produces magnetic field perturbations .
if these perturbations then tip the field lines in the direction of an equilibrium electron temperature gradient the thermal force will increase and therefore the instability arises @xcite .
the second mechanism is due to a current carried by nearly trapped electrons in a boundary layer close to the trapped - passing boundary @xcite .
both of these mechanisms require finite electron temperature gradient and collisions .
however , mtms have been observed to arise under conditions which are not well - described by the above mechanisms @xcite .
thus , a complete picture of mtm excitation is not available at present . in the following
we summarize the previous findings reported in refs .
linear simulations for mast @xcite , nstx@xcite , and asdex - ug @xcite plasmas reported that mtms can be the dominant instabilities in the region @xmath6 with the maximum growth rate at mode numbers @xmath7 between @xmath8 . here , @xmath9 is the ion sound larmor radius .
the electron temperature gradient is found to be the drive of the instability and a non - monotonic dependence of the growth rate on the electron - ion collisionality @xmath10 is observed .
the peak of the growth rate coincides with the experimental value of @xmath10 for various considered radial positions .
the non - monotonic dependence of the mtm growth rate on collisionality is due to the fact that , on one hand both of the driving mechanisms mentioned above require finite collisionality , and therefore stability can be expected as @xmath10 reduces , but on the other hand , in a strongly collisional regime the strong rate of scattering of the electrons between the field lines prevents the formation of a current layer , hence mtms are stabilized @xcite . it has also been shown that by increasing the effective ion charge @xmath11 , mtms are destabilized through the @xmath11-dependence of the electron - ion collision frequency , see ref . @xcite . as mtms are electromagnetic in nature a finite @xmath0 is needed for their destabilization . for the studied discharge in ref . @xcite it is found that the @xmath0 threshold is well below the experimentally relevant @xmath0 value and the growth rate increases moderately with increasing @xmath0 .
non - linear simulations confirmed the role of the electron temperature gradient as the drive of the mtm instability in spherical ( nstx ) @xcite as well as standard tokamaks ( asdex - ug ) @xcite .
moreover , it has been shown that the chirikov criterion @xcite for overlapping of the magnetic islands leads to an up - shift of the electron temperature gradient threshold @xcite . in the present paper
we investigate the onset of the mtms and its parametric dependence through local linear gyrokinetic simulations with the gyrocode @xcite , in a spherical tokamak : nstx , and two conventional tokamaks : asdex - ug and jet . for the nstx case we use the plasma parameters reported in ref .
@xcite , and for the asdex - ug case we use the plasma parameters found in ref . @xcite . in the present work we re - examine these discharges with an emphasis on the parametric dependences of the mtm onset . in view of the new iter - like wall experiments on jet , in the presented analysis
we have also considered a set of jet - like parameters .
the remainder of the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : input ] the input parameters are discussed , and in sec .
[ sec:1 ] parametric dependences of the mtm onset are analyzed by presenting scans over mtm driving parameters such as collisionality , @xmath0 and electron temperature / density scaling lengths .
the conclusions are drawn in sec .
[ sec : conclusions ] .
the plasma parameters used in our analysis are shown in table [ table1 ] .
.input parameters for densities , temperatures and their gradients . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ table3 ] in this table , @xmath0 is calculated in cgs units following the expression : @xmath12\;10^{-6 } \;10^{19 } ) ( t_e[kev]\;1.6022\;10^{-9 } ) } { ( 10^{4}\ ; b_{unit}[t ] ) ^2 } , \label{betae}\ ] ] where @xmath13 is the effective field strength with @xmath14 defined through the toroidal magnetic flux @xmath15 @xcite , @xmath16 is the safety factor , and the magnetic shear is @xmath17 .
the generalized magnetohydrodynamic @xmath18 parameter is defined as @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the effective major radius , @xmath21 is the minor radius , and @xmath22 is the total plasma pressure .
@xmath23 is a scaling parameter which allows an artificial adjustment of @xmath24 ( affecting the magnetic curvature drift ) without modifying the background gradients , as presented in ref .
furthermore , @xmath25 is the elongation , @xmath26 is the triangularity .
typical resolution parameters used in our linear analysis are as follows : 40 radial grid points , 12 parallel orbit mesh points ( @xmath27 signs of parallel velocity ) , 16 pitch angles , and 8 energies . a high radial resolution is needed since the linear instability of mtm depends on the presence of narrow resonant current layers centered on the rational surfaces .
the toroidal mode numbers used here , corresponding to the @xmath28 values in table [ table1 ] , are @xmath29 for nstx , @xmath30 for aug , and @xmath31 for jet .
figures [ eigenvalues ] ( a , b ) illustrate the linear growth rate and the real frequency of the most unstable modes in the three machines as functions of @xmath32 .
in nstx and jet , the mtms ( with positive real frequency in electron diamagnetic direction ) are the most unstable modes in the range of @xmath33 , while for asdex - ug the mtms are the most unstable modes only in the narrower wave number range @xmath34 , corresponding to longer wavelengths than those in nstx and jet . ,
@xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath32 .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet . ] in nstx the mtms remain the most unstable mode for the whole considered range of @xmath32 , but in asdex - ug an itg mode ( negative real frequency , in ion diamagnetic direction ) for @xmath36 and an etg mode ( positive real frequency , in electron diamagnetic direction ) for @xmath37 are also found to be unstable .
the @xmath32 corresponding to the maximum growth rate varies between the different machines : in nstx @xmath38 , in asdex - ug @xmath39 and in the jet like case @xmath40 .
the normalized poloidal mode number for the remainder of our calculations are fixed to these values ( see table [ table3 ] ) .
previous studies have discussed the difference in the poloidal mode number corresponding to the maximum of the unstable mtms between the nstx and asdex - ug cases , and it is believed to be due to characteristics of the spherical or conventional tokamaks @xcite .
however , here we find unstable mtms with similar mode numbers in the jet tokamak to that of nstx , which suggests that this is not always the case .
therefore , further studies are needed to determine the reason for the similarities and differences in the mode numbers for maximum growth rates in various machines .
the structure of the @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 eigenmodes , corresponding to the @xmath7 values mentioned above are shown in figures [ modestructure ] ( a - f ) .
the eigenfunctions are normalized so that @xmath44 is unity .
the mtm signature is distinguished by the tearing parity of the @xmath42 eigenmodes .
the nstx case has the strongest electromagnetic character in terms of the relative amplitude of @xmath41 , while the `` most electrostatic '' mode is the aug case .
regarding the strength of the compressional magnetic perturbations , @xmath45 , the situation is the opposite ; the less electrostatic the mode is the stronger the @xmath43 perturbations are .
the characteristic width of the eigenmodes along the field line is similar in all three machines .
( a , b ) , @xmath42 ( c , d ) and @xmath45 ( e , f ) . note that the actual radial resolution of the simulations covers @xmath46.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath47 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d ) , asdex - ug ( b , e ) , and jet ( c , f ) .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath47 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d ) , asdex - ug ( b , e ) , and jet ( c , f ) . ,
title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath47 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d ) , asdex - ug ( b , e ) , and jet ( c , f ) . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] + ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath47 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d ) , asdex - ug ( b , e ) , and jet ( c , f ) .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath47 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d ) , asdex - ug ( b , e ) , and jet ( c , f ) . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath47 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d ) , asdex - ug ( b , e ) , and jet ( c , f ) .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath45 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d and g ) , asdex - ug ( b , e and h ) , and jet ( c , f and i).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath45 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d and g ) , asdex - ug ( b , e and h ) , and jet ( c , f and i).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath45 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d and g ) , asdex - ug ( b , e and h ) , and jet ( c , f and i).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] + ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath45 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d and g ) , asdex - ug ( b , e and h ) , and jet ( c , f and i).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath45 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d and g ) , asdex - ug ( b , e and h ) , and jet ( c , f and i).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath45 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d and g ) , asdex - ug ( b , e and h ) , and jet ( c , f and i).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] + ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath45 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d and g ) , asdex - ug ( b , e and h ) , and jet ( c , f and i).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath45 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d and g ) , asdex - ug ( b , e and h ) , and jet ( c , f and i).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ( red dashed lines ) , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted lines ) , and @xmath45 ( green dotted lines ) versus @xmath32 in nstx ( a , d and g ) , asdex - ug ( b , e and h ) , and jet ( c , f and i).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] figures [ heatfluxes ] and [ particlefluxes ] illustrate the normalized linear energy and particle fluxes , respectively , and the contributions to these from the @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath45 fluctuations , as functions of @xmath32 in all three machines . as seen in figures [ heatfluxes ] ( a - c ) , in the mtm dominated region the electron heat flux is the main channel of the energy transport , and the dominant contribution is generated by @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted line ) . in the nstx case , see figure [ heatfluxes ] ( a ) , this is true for the whole considered range of @xmath32 . the ion heat flux generated by mtms shown in figure [ heatfluxes ] ( d ) ( magenta solid line ) however , is negligibly small compared to the electron heat flux .
the particle fluxes generated by mtms for electrons as seen in figure [ particlefluxes ] ( a - c ) , and both active and passive impurity species shown in figures [ particlefluxes ] ( d - f and g - i ) are also negligible in comparison to the electron heat flux .
we note , that nonlinear mtm simulations for nstx , presented in @xcite also showed negligibly small particle fluxes . in the case of asdex - ug the main contribution to electron heat flux , see figure [ heatfluxes ] ( b ) , is generated by the mtm instability at low @xmath32 , and for higher @xmath32 where the most unstable mode switches to an itg mode , the electron heat flux is significantly reduced .
however , at the very high poloidal mode numbers @xmath48 where an etg is the dominant instability the electron heat flux increases again . also here , @xmath42 ( blue dash - dotted line ) generates the dominant contribution to the electron heat flux in the mtm dominated region while @xmath41 ( red dashed line ) produces the dominant contribution to the electron heat flux in the itg / etg dominated regions . for the ion heat flux
the main contribution comes from the higher @xmath32 region where the itg mode is the most unstable mode present with the maximum around @xmath49 , as illustrated in figure [ heatfluxes ] ( e ) .
the mtm and etg contributions to the ion heat flux are significantly smaller .
also , for the electron and impurity particle fluxes , shown in figures [ particlefluxes ] ( b , e and h ) , the contributions from mtm and etg is negligible compared to the contribution from the itg .
similar trends are observed for heat and particle transport in the jet case .
again here , in the mtm dominated region the electron heat flux , see figure [ heatfluxes ] ( c ) , is the main channel of transport while the ion heat flux , presented in figure [ heatfluxes ] ( f ) , and the particle fluxes shown in figures [ particlefluxes ] ( c , f and i ) are negligibly small in comparison . remarkably , the main ion energy fluxes ( @xmath50 ) generated by the itg modes in the asdex - ug is found to be inward in spite of the positive ion temperature gradient , see figs .
[ heatfluxes ] ( d ) .
however we note , that in the asdex - ug case 1 ) there is a high inward particle flux of main ions which might account for the inward energy flux if most of it is convective , 2 ) the strong positive ion energy flux carried by the nitrogen impurities almost cancel the negative energy flux of the main ions , so the total ion energy flux is close to zero .
figures [ betascan ] ( a , c ) show the linear growth rates and the real frequencies of the unstable modes , corresponding to the fixed values of @xmath32 given in table [ table3 ] , as functions of @xmath0 for the three considered machines . as seen in this figure for the experimental values of @xmath0 ( shown with vertical lines )
the most unstable mode is an mtm for all three tokamaks . in nstx ,
the onset of mtm is well below the experimental value of @xmath0 and an increase in @xmath0 above its experimental value does not increase the growth rate significantly .
the same observation can be made for the jet case , while for asdex - ug , although the mtm onset is well below its experimental value , by further increasing @xmath0 , a kinetic - ballooning mode ( kbm ) ( negative real frequency in ion direction ) appears as the most unstable mode .
these results show that since mtms become unstable due to electromagnetic perturbations a finite level of @xmath0 is needed for their onset , but when unstable , mtms do not strongly depend on @xmath0 variations . in all these scans the value of @xmath24
is calculated consistently with the local beta values and the density and temperature gradients .
, @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath0 ( a and c ) , and @xmath10 ( b and d ) .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet .
the vertical lines represent the base parameters color coded similarly to their respective machine.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] , @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath0 ( a and c ) , and @xmath10 ( b and d ) .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet .
the vertical lines represent the base parameters color coded similarly to their respective machine.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] in order to determine the effect of @xmath24 through the curvature drift a @xmath0 scan , similar to figure [ betascan ] ( a and c ) , is performed where @xmath24 is scaled to zero by setting @xmath51 .
the corresponding results are shown in figure [ betascan2 ] .
the @xmath24-stabilization is not significant in the mtm regime in any of the studied plasmas . in the nstx case
there is a small @xmath24-stabilization only at very high @xmath0 , see figures [ betascan2 ] ( a , d ) . in the asdex - ug case ,
the stabilization of the kbm mode at higher @xmath0 is clearly an @xmath24 effect , since without it the mode is further destabilized by an increase in @xmath0 , see the black dashed lines in figures [ betascan2 ] ( b , e ) . for jet , the situation is different , as seen in figures [ betascan2 ] ( c , f ) . in the electrostatic limit and at low @xmath0
the most unstable mode is an itg which is stabilized as @xmath0 is increased even without @xmath24 effect .
for higher @xmath0 the dominant mode switches to an mtm . without @xmath24 effects ,
by increasing @xmath0 even further the mtm switches to a kbm that is further destabilized by @xmath0 , however with the @xmath24 effect included the kbm appears only at higher @xmath0 ( outside the plotted @xmath0 range ) .
, @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath0 for @xmath52 ( solid lines ) and @xmath51 ( dashed black lines ) . nstx ( a and d ) , asdex - ug ( b and e ) , and jet ( c and f ) .
the vertical lines represent the base parameters color coded similarly to their respective machine.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] , @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath0 for @xmath52 ( solid lines ) and @xmath51 ( dashed black lines ) .
nstx ( a and d ) , asdex - ug ( b and e ) , and jet ( c and f ) .
the vertical lines represent the base parameters color coded similarly to their respective machine.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] , @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath0 for @xmath52 ( solid lines ) and @xmath51 ( dashed black lines ) .
nstx ( a and d ) , asdex - ug ( b and e ) , and jet ( c and f ) .
the vertical lines represent the base parameters color coded similarly to their respective machine.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] as the collisionality is suggested as an important parameter in driving the mtms unstable , here we examine the dependence of the mtm mode characteristics on this parameter . in figures
[ betascan ] ( b , d ) the linear growth rates and the real frequencies of the most unstable modes are shown as functions of the collision frequency @xmath10 for the different tokamaks .
for the experimental values of @xmath10 ( marked with vertical lines ) the most unstable mode is found to be an mtm in all the three considered tokamaks . in nstx , the growth rate increases with collisionality as expected since collisionality is one of the instability drives @xcite , however , a further increase in @xmath10 above the experimental value ( almost doubled ) the mtm growth rate does not increase significantly . in
the asdex - ug the growth rate shows a decline as collisionality increases .
this trend is not surprising since previous studies have shown that the growth rate of the mtm has a non - monotonic dependence on the collisionality @xcite .
as the collisionality further increases beyond the peak value , particles are very much scattered by collisions , and therefore preventing the formation of the current layer necessary for the mtms to become unstable .
hence , as seen in figure [ betascan ] ( b ) we expect that this is the case for the asdex - ug case . for jet
we also observe a ( gentle ) non - monotonic trend , and our base value of the collisionality seems to be positioned near the peak value . in all three machines
no unstable mtms were found for the collisionless case , i.e. @xmath53 , and under this condition these plasmas are found to be tem unstable . using the eigenvalue solver method in gyro@xcite we followed the root corresponding to the mtm instability towards smaller @xmath10 , and the mode
is completely stabilized in the collisionless limit .
the values of @xmath54 corresponding to the maximum growth rate are rather different between the spherical and the conventional tokamak cases ; in nstx it is @xmath55 , while it is @xmath56 and @xmath57 in the aug and the jet cases , respectively . in the literature
the electron temperature gradient is suggested as one of the instability drives for mtms @xcite .
this has been confirmed in previous numerical studies @xcite .
here we compare the role of electron temperature gradient in destabilization of the mtms between the three considered machines by performing a scan over the @xmath58 parameter .
the results of this scan are shown in figures [ altescan ] ( a , c ) where the linear growth rates and the real frequencies of the most unstable modes are illustrated as functions of @xmath58 . as seen in this figure , a finite value of @xmath58 is necessary for the destabilization of the mtms in all three machines , however a clear difference is observed in the variation of mtm growth rates with @xmath58 between spherical and conventional tokamaks . for the nstx case , there is a clear increase of the mtm growth rate with an increase in @xmath58 , while for asdex - ug and jet the mtm growth rates show weaker and a non - monotonic dependence on @xmath58 . by further increase in @xmath58 the most unstable mode switches from an mtm to itg / tem modes ,
corresponding to the last points in the asdex - ug and jet curves in figs .
[ altescan ] ( a and c ) .
, @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath58 ( a and c ) , and @xmath59 ( b and d ) .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet .
the vertical lines represent the base parameters color coded similarly to their respective machine.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] , @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath58 ( a and c ) , and @xmath59 ( b and d ) .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet .
the vertical lines represent the base parameters color coded similarly to their respective machine.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] the @xmath58 threshold for mtm instability is observed to be well below our baseline values ( indicated by vertical lines ) , and it is lower for jet and asdex - ug than for nstx .
the growth rate of mtms is found to be less sensitive to electron temperature gradient for both of the conventional tokamaks than in the spherical tokamak studied here . in order to investigate the reason for this difference we performed a similar scan over @xmath58 and set @xmath51 to eliminate the @xmath24 stabilization effect .
the results are shown in figure [ altewoalpha ] . without @xmath24 stabilization
the mtm still remains the most unstable mode for the baseline parameters , and as @xmath58 increases no significant change is observed for nstx and asdex - ug .
however , for jet case three regions in the @xmath58 space can be distinguished . for low values of @xmath58
the mtm is the dominant instability ; its growth rate increases linearly with @xmath58 . at @xmath60 an itg mode , which was previously stabilized by @xmath24 effects
see figures [ altescan ] ( a , c ) , becomes the dominant instability , which gradually transits to a tem as @xmath58 becomes very large .
therefore , from our observations the stabilizing effect of the @xmath24 parameter on the mtm mode is not significant , but it has an impact on the stability of itg / tem / kbm modes .
the strong suppression of these modes therefore , allows for mtms to remain the dominant instability for a wider range of @xmath58 .
the weaker and non - monotonic dependence of the mtm on the electron temperature gradient in asdex - ug and jet thus , can not be explained by this effect .
, @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath58 with @xmath52 and @xmath51 .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] , @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath58 with @xmath52 and @xmath51 .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] , @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath58 with @xmath52 and @xmath51 .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] one of the main differences between the plasma parameters in the three plasmas considered appears in the @xmath59 values ; a strongly negative electron density gradient , corresponding to a hollow electron density profile , is observed in nstx , while the density profiles were slightly peaked in the asdex - ug and jet plasmas .
thus , we have investigated the dependence of mtm linear growth rates on the @xmath59 parameter .
quasi - neutrality is enforced by slightly varying @xmath61 while keeping the impurity density gradients fixed to the base parameters given in table [ table2 ] .
figures [ altescan ] ( b - d ) show the linear growth rates and the real frequencies of the most unstable modes versus @xmath59 for the different machines . in all three machines , the mtms linear growth rates exhibit a non - monotonic dependence on @xmath59 parameter with maxima corresponding to slightly hollow electron density profiles ( @xmath62 ) .
clearly @xmath59 is not a strong and necessary drive for the mtms , as there are finite mtm growth rates in all machines at @xmath63 . in all the machines the mtm is the most unstable mode over the range of @xmath64 , with a rather weak dependence on this parameter . for sufficiently high electron density gradient the dominant linear mode switches from a mtm to an itg mode in all plasmas .
again we examined the impact of @xmath24 by comparing the results to corresponding simulations with @xmath51 ( black dashed lines in figure [ alnewoalpha ] ) .
similar to the results of the @xmath58 scans shown in figure [ altewoalpha ] , the effect of the @xmath24 parameter on the mtm mode itself is negligible , but it strongly stabilizes the itg mode . as shown in figure [ alnewoalpha ] , without @xmath24 effects in the cases of nstx and jet the @xmath59 threshold of the dominant itg mode is reduced , but in asdex - ug case no significant change is observed . ,
@xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath59 with @xmath52 and @xmath51 .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] , @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath59 with @xmath52 and @xmath51 .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ] , @xmath35 ) as functions of @xmath59 with @xmath52 and @xmath51 .
red solid lines : nstx , blue dashed : asdex - ug , green dash - dotted : jet.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.0% ]
we have investigated the onset and parametric dependences of the mtm instability in the core ( @xmath65 ) of a spherical ( nstx ) , and two conventional tokamaks ( asdex - ug , jet ) .
the quasilinear transport is computed using the gyrokinetic code gyroin the flux - tube ( local ) limit . in confirmation with previous studies
, we found that for the experimentally relevant plasma parameters the mtms are linearly the dominant instability in nstx and asdex - ug . under typical jet baseline parameters considered here the mtms
are also found as the dominant linear instability . in nstx and jet
the maximum of the mtm linear growth rate is located at higher mode numbers than that for asdex - ug .
therefore , the previously discussed idea that the higher mode number mtms are the characteristics of the spherical tokamaks , while lower mode number mtms are the characteristics of the conventional tokamaks is not supported by our results .
parametric scaling of the mtm instability in the core of these plasmas , revealed that a finite level of @xmath10 and @xmath0 are needed in order for mtms to become unstable , and when unstable , they can remain the dominant instability over a wide range in @xmath10 and @xmath0 .
the linear mtm growth rate seems to be only weakly dependent on @xmath0 , and exhibits a weak but non - monotonic dependence on collisionality , @xmath10 . by neglecting the collisionality or @xmath0 effects ,
the itg / tem modes appear as the most unstable modes in all three studied machines .
a strong dependence for the growth rate of mtms on electron temperature gradient is found in nstx , while for asdex - ug and jet the mtm growth rate is found to be less sensitive to this parameter .
the mtm growth rate significantly increases as @xmath58 increases in nstx , but in asdex - ug and jet a weak and non - monotonic dependence on @xmath58 is found .
these results indicate that while @xmath58 is a fundamental drive for the mtms in these plasmas , it can contribute to the stabilization of the mode as well ; this non - trivial behavior is more pronounced in the asdex - ug and jet plasmas .
similar trends are observed in all three machines when scanning for the electron density gradient , where the mtms linear growth rates show again a non - monotonic dependences on @xmath59 parameter with peaks located in the negative @xmath59 region corresponding to slightly hollow electron density profiles .
we have investigated the impact of a finite @xmath24 on the onset and characteristics of mtm instability in various parametric scans , and we have observed that the stabilization of @xmath24 parameter on the mtm mode itself is not significant in all machines . however , its impact on the itg / tem unstable modes can result in a strong suppression of these modes allowing for the mtm to remain the dominant instability for a wider range in considered parameters , i.e. @xmath0 , @xmath58 and @xmath59 .
the non - monotonic and weaker dependence of the mtm on the electron temperature / density gradient however , can not be explained by @xmath24 effects . in the studied cases
the mtm drives mostly electron heat transport through @xmath42 fluctuations , while other transport channels and contributions from @xmath41 and @xmath43 are significantly smaller . for the ion heat flux and particle fluxes , the transport driven by mtms
are negligible , however , if ballooning modes like itg / tem / kbm are also present , even as sub - dominant modes , these fluxes are mainly driven by these modes and therefore the overall ion heat and particle transport may not be negligible . however , these findings are based on linear analysis and further non - linear studies are needed for their confirmation .
finally , we would like to stress that the cases which we have considered have been chosen because they were unstable to mtms .
however , particularly large aspect ratio tokamaks , being unstable to mtms should not be considered a generic property .
the authors would like to thank f jenko , j candy and c angioni for valuable comments , and j candy for providing the gyrocode .
this work was funded by the european communities under association contract between euratom and _ vetenskapsrdet_. the views and opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of the european commission .
11 m. shimada , d. j. campbell , v. mukhovatov , m. fujiwara , n. kirneva , k. lackner , m. nagami , v. d. pustovitov , n. uckan and j. wesley international tokamak physics activity topical group chairs , cochairs and chapter coordinators : n. asakura , a. e. costley , a. j. h. donn , e. j. doyle , a. fasoli , c. gormezano , y. gribov , o. gruber , t. c. hender , w. houlberg , s. ide , y. kamada , a. leonard , b. lipschultz , a. loarte , k. miyamoto , v. mukhovatov , t. h. osborne , a. polevoi and a. c. c. sips , _ nucl . fusion _ * 47 * , s1 ( 2007 ) .
d. c. mcdonald , l. laborde , j. c. deboo , f. ryter , m. brix , c. d. challis , p. de vries , c. giroud , j. hobrik , d. howell , e. joffrin , t. c. luce , j. mailloux , v. pericoli - ridolfini , a. c. c. sips , k. thomsen and jet efda contributors , _ plasma phys .
control . fusion _ * 50 * , 124013 ( 2008 ) .
r. e. waltz and r.l .
miller , _ phys .
plasmas _ * 6 * , 4265 ( 1999 ) .
d. j. applegate , c. m. roach , j. w. connor , s. c. cowley , w. dorland , r. j. hastie and n. joiner , _ plasma phys .
fusion _ * 49 * , 1113 ( 2007 ) .
w. guttenfelder , j. candy , s. m. kaye , w. m. nevins , e. wang , r. e. bell , g. w. hammett , b. p. leblanc , d. r. mikkelsen and h. yuh , _ phys .
lett . _ * 106 * , 155004 ( 2011 ) .
h. doerk , f. jenko , m. j. pueschel and d. r. hatch , _ phys .
lett . _ * 106 * , 155003 ( 2011 ) .
d. told , f. jenko , p. xanthopoulos , l. d. horton and e. wolfrum , _ phys . of plasmas _ * 15 * , 102306 ( 2008 ) .
j. f. drake and y. c. lee , _ phys .
fluids _ * 20 * , 1341 ( 1977 ) . p. j. catto and m. n. rosenbluth , _ phys
. fluids _ * 24 * , 243 ( 1981 ) . j. w. connor , s. c. cowley and r. j. hastie , _ plasma phys .
control . fusion _ * 32 * , 799 ( 1990 ) .
d. dickinson , c. m. roach , s. saarelma , r. scannell , a. kirk and h. r. wilson , _ arxiv:1209.3695v1 _ ( 2012 ) .
w. guttenfelder , j. candy , s. m. nevins , r. e. bell , g. w. hammett , b. p. leblanc and h. yuh , _ phys . of plasmas
_ * 19 * , 022506 ( 2012 ) .
w. guttenfelder , j. candy , s. m. kaye , w. m. nevins , e. wang , j. zhang , r. e. bell , n. a. crocker , g. w. hammett , b. p. leblanc , d. r. mikkelsen , y. ren and h. yuh , _ phys . of plasmas _ * 19 * , 056119 ( 2012 ) .
h. doerk , f. jenko , t. grler , d. told , m. j. pueschel and d. r. hatch , _ phys . of plasmas
_ * 19 * , 055907 ( 2012 ) .
b. v. chirikov , _ phys .
rep . _ * 52 * , 263 ( 1979 ) .
j. candy and r. e. waltz , _ j. comput .
_ , * 186 * , 545 ( 2003 ) . j. candy , _ plasma phys .
control . fusion _ , * 51 * , 105009 ( 2009 ) .
e. a. belli and j. candy , _ phys .
plasmas _ , * 17 * , 112314 ( 2010 ) . | the onset and characteristics of micro - tearing modes ( mtm ) in the core of spherical ( nstx ) and conventional tokamaks ( asdex - ug and jet ) are studied through local linear gyrokinetic simulations with gyro [ j. candy and e. belli , general atomics report ga - a26818 ( 2011 ) ] . for experimentally relevant core plasma parameters in the nstx and asdex - ug tokamaks , in agreement with previous works ,
we find mtms as the dominant linear instability .
also , for jet - like core parameters considered in our study an mtm is found as the most unstable mode . in all these plasmas ,
finite collisionality is needed for mtms to become unstable and the electron temperature gradient is found to be the fundamental drive .
however , a significant difference is observed in the dependence of linear growth rate of mtms on electron temperature gradient .
while it varies weakly and non - monotonically in jet and asdex - ug plasmas , in nstx it increases with the electron temperature gradient . |
we express our gratitude to our colleagues in the cern accelerator departments for the excellent performance of the lhc .
we thank the technical and administrative staff at the lhcb institutes .
we acknowledge support from cern and from the national agencies : capes , cnpq , faperj and finep ( brazil ) ; nsfc ( china ) ; cnrs / in2p3 ( france ) ; bmbf , dfg , hgf and mpg ( germany ) ; sfi ( ireland ) ; infn ( italy ) ; fom and nwo ( the netherlands ) ; mnisw and ncn ( poland ) ; men / ifa ( romania ) ; mines and fano ( russia ) ; mineco ( spain ) ; snsf and ser ( switzerland ) ; nasu ( ukraine ) ; stfc ( united kingdom ) ; nsf ( usa ) .
the tier1 computing centres are supported by in2p3 ( france ) , kit and bmbf ( germany ) , infn ( italy ) , nwo and surf ( the netherlands ) , pic ( spain ) , gridpp ( united kingdom ) .
we are indebted to the communities behind the multiple open source software packages on which we depend .
we are also thankful for the computing resources and the access to software r&d tools provided by yandex llc ( russia ) .
individual groups or members have received support from eplanet , marie skodowska - curie actions and erc ( european union ) , conseil gnral de haute - savoie , labex enigmass and ocevu , rgion auvergne ( france ) , rfbr ( russia ) , xuntagal and gencat ( spain ) , royal society and royal commission for the exhibition of 1851 ( united kingdom ) .
babar collaboration , b. aubert _
et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.90.242001[phys .
rev . lett . * 90 * ( 2003 ) 242001 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ex/0304021 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0304021 ] cleo collaboration , d. besson _
et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.68.032002[phys
* d68 * ( 2003 ) 032002 ] , erratum http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.75.119908[ibid .
* d75 * ( 2007 ) 119908 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ex/0305100 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0305100 ] babar collaboration , b. aubert _
et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.97.222001[phys .
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 222001 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ex/0607082 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0607082 ] belle collaboration , j. brodzicka _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.100.092001[phys
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 092001 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0707.3491[arxiv:0707.3491 ] babar collaboration , b. aubert _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.80.092003[phys
* d80 * ( 2009 ) 092003 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0908.0806 [ arxiv:0908.0806 ] lhcb collaboration , r. aaij _ et al . _ ,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep10(2012)151[jhep * 10 * ( 2012 ) 151 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1207.6016[arxiv:1207.6016 ] e. s. swanson , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2006.04.003[phys . rept .
* 429 * ( 2006 ) 243 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0601110 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0601110 ] j. l. rosner , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0954-3899/34/7/s07[j .
* g34 * ( 2007 ) s127 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0609195 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0609195 ] e. klempt and a. zaitsev , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2007.07.006[phys .
* 454 * ( 2007 ) 1 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0708.4016 [ arxiv:0708.4016 ] p. colangelo , f. de fazio , f. giannuzzi , and s. nicotri , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.86.054024[phys . rev .
* d86 * ( 2012 ) 054024 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1207.6940 [ arxiv:1207.6940 ] f. wagner , m. tabak , and d. m. chew , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0370-2693(75)90637-1[phys .
* b58 * ( 1975 ) 201 ] d. aston _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0370-2693(88)90439-x[phys
* b208 * ( 1988 ) 324 ] g. w. brandenburg _
et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0370-2693(76)90711-5[phys
* b60 * ( 1976 ) 478 ] r. baldi _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0370-2693(76)90279-3[phys
* b63 * ( 1976 ) 344 ] j. blatt and v. e. weisskopf , _ theoretical nuclear physics _ , j. wiley ( new york ) , 1952 r. h. dalitz , http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14786441008520365[phil . mag . * 44 * ( 1953 ) 1068 ] lhcb collaboration , r. aaij _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.90.072003[phys
* d90 * ( 2014 ) 072003 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1407.7712 [ arxiv:1407.7712 ] lhcb collaboration , a. a. alves jr . _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1748-0221/3/08/s08005[jinst * 3 * ( 2008 )
s08005 ] r. aaij _ et al .
_ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1748-0221/8/04/p04022[jinst * 8 * ( 2013 ) p04022 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1211.3055 [ arxiv:1211.3055 ] lhcb collaboration , r. aaij _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.87.071101[phys
* d87 * ( 2013 ) 071101(r ) ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1302.6446 [ arxiv:1302.6446 ] lhcb collaboration , r. aaij _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.87.112009[phys
* d87 * ( 2013 ) 112009 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1304.6317 [ arxiv:1304.6317 ] m. feindt and u. kerzel , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2005.11.166[nucl .
instrum . meth .
* a559 * ( 2006 ) 190 ] m. pivk and f. r. le diberder , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2005.08.106[nucl .
instrum . meth .
* a555 * ( 2005 ) 356 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0402083 [ arxiv : physics/0402083 ] lhcb collaboration , r. aaij _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep02(2013)043[jhep * 02 * ( 2013 ) 043 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1210.1089[arxiv:1210.1089 ] lhcb collaboration , r. aaij _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.87.092007[phys
* d87 * ( 2013 ) 092007 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1302.5854 [ arxiv:1302.5854 ] lhcb collaboration , r. aaij _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.110.182001[phys .
* 110 * ( 2013 ) 182001 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1302.1072[arxiv:1302.1072 ] lhcb collaboration , r. aaij _ et al . _ ,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep06(2013)065[jhep * 06 * ( 2013 ) 065 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1304.6865[arxiv:1304.6865 ] particle data group , j. beringer _ et al . _
, http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.86.010001[phys .
* d86 * ( 2012 ) 010001 ] , and 2013 partial update for the 2014 edition w. d. hulsbergen , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2005.06.078[nucl .
instrum . meth .
* a552 * ( 2005 ) 566 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0503191 [ arxiv : physics/0503191 ] lhcb collaboration , r. aaij _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.89.032001[phys .
d89 * ( 2014 ) 032001 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1311.4823 [ arxiv:1311.4823 ] t. skwarnicki , _ a study of the radiative cascade transitions between the upsilon - prime and upsilon resonances _ , phd thesis , institute of nuclear physics , krakow , 1986 , http://inspirehep.net/record/230779/files/230779.pdf[desy-f31-86-02 ] g. n. fleming , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrev.135.b551[phys
* 135 * ( 1964 ) b551 ] d. morgan , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrev.166.1731[phys
* 166 * ( 1968 ) 1731 ] d. herndon , p. soding , and r. j. cashmore , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.11.3165[phys .
* d11 * ( 1975 ) 3165 ] lass collaboration , d. aston _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0550-3213(88)90028-4[nucl
* b296 * ( 1988 ) 493 ] c. zemach , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrev.133.b1201[phys . rev .
* 133 * ( 1964 ) b1201 ] c. zemach , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrev.140.b97[phys
* 140 * ( 1965 ) b97 ] r. aaij@xmath106 , b. adeva@xmath107 , m. adinolfi@xmath108 , a. affolder@xmath109 , z. ajaltouni@xmath110 , s. akar@xmath111 , j. albrecht@xmath112 , f. alessio@xmath113 , m. alexander@xmath114 , s. ali@xmath106 , g. alkhazov@xmath115 , p. alvarez cartelle@xmath107 , a.a .
alves jr@xmath116 , s. amato@xmath117 , s. amerio@xmath118 , y. amhis@xmath119 , l. an@xmath120 , l. anderlini@xmath121 , j. anderson@xmath122 , r. andreassen@xmath123 , m. andreotti@xmath124 , j.e .
andrews@xmath125 , r.b .
appleby@xmath126 , o. aquines gutierrez@xmath127 , f. archilli@xmath113 , a. artamonov@xmath128 , m. artuso@xmath129 , e. aslanides@xmath111 , g. auriemma@xmath130 , m. baalouch@xmath110 , s. bachmann@xmath131 , j.j .
back@xmath132 , a. badalov@xmath133 , c. baesso@xmath134 , w. baldini@xmath135 , r.j .
barlow@xmath126 , c. barschel@xmath113 , s. barsuk@xmath119 , w. barter@xmath136 , v. batozskaya@xmath137 , v. battista@xmath138 , a. bay@xmath138 , l. beaucourt@xmath139 , j. beddow@xmath114 , f. bedeschi@xmath140 , i. bediaga@xmath141 , s. belogurov@xmath142 , k. belous@xmath128 , i. belyaev@xmath142 , e. ben - haim@xmath143 , g. bencivenni@xmath144 , s. benson@xmath113 , j. benton@xmath108 , a. berezhnoy@xmath145 , r. bernet@xmath122 , m .- o .
bettler@xmath136 , m. van beuzekom@xmath106 , a. bien@xmath131 , s. bifani@xmath146 , t. bird@xmath126 , a. bizzeti@xmath147 , p.m. bjrnstad@xmath126 , t. blake@xmath132 , f. blanc@xmath138 , j. blouw@xmath127 , s. blusk@xmath129 , v. bocci@xmath148 , a. bondar@xmath149 , n. bondar@xmath150 , w. bonivento@xmath151 , s. borghi@xmath126 , a. borgia@xmath129 , m. borsato@xmath119 , t.j.v .
bowcock@xmath109 , e. bowen@xmath122 , c. bozzi@xmath135 , t. brambach@xmath112 , j. van den brand@xmath152 , j. bressieux@xmath138 , d. brett@xmath126 , m. britsch@xmath127 , t. britton@xmath129 , j. brodzicka@xmath126 , n.h .
brook@xmath108 , h. brown@xmath109 , a. bursche@xmath122 , g. busetto@xmath153 , j. buytaert@xmath113 , s. cadeddu@xmath154 , r. calabrese@xmath124 , m. calvi@xmath155 , m. calvo gomez@xmath156 , p. campana@xmath157 , d. campora perez@xmath113 , a. carbone@xmath158 , g. carboni@xmath159 , r. cardinale@xmath160 , a. cardini@xmath154 , l. carson@xmath161 , k. carvalho akiba@xmath117 , g. casse@xmath109 , l. cassina@xmath162 , l. castillo garcia@xmath113 , m. cattaneo@xmath113 , ch .
cauet@xmath112 , r. cenci@xmath125 , m. charles@xmath143 , ph .
charpentier@xmath113 , m. chefdeville@xmath139 , s. chen@xmath126 , s .- f .
cheung@xmath163 , n. chiapolini@xmath122 , m. chrzaszcz@xmath164 , k. ciba@xmath113 , x. cid vidal@xmath113 , g. ciezarek@xmath165 , p.e.l .
clarke@xmath161 , m. clemencic@xmath113 , h.v .
cliff@xmath136 , j. closier@xmath113 , v. coco@xmath113 , j. cogan@xmath111 , e. cogneras@xmath110 , p. collins@xmath113 , a. comerma - montells@xmath131 , a. contu@xmath154 , a. cook@xmath108 , m. coombes@xmath108 , s. coquereau@xmath143 , g. corti@xmath113 , m. corvo@xmath124 , i. counts@xmath166 , b. couturier@xmath113 , g.a .
cowan@xmath161 , d.c .
craik@xmath132 , m. cruz torres@xmath134 , s. cunliffe@xmath165 , r. currie@xmath161 , c. dambrosio@xmath113 , j. dalseno@xmath108 , p. david@xmath143 , p.n.y .
david@xmath106 , a. davis@xmath123 , k. de bruyn@xmath106 , s. de capua@xmath126 , m. de cian@xmath131 , j.m .
de miranda@xmath141 , l. de paula@xmath117 , w. de silva@xmath123 , p. de simone@xmath144 , d. decamp@xmath139 , m. deckenhoff@xmath112 , l. del buono@xmath143 , n. dlage@xmath139 , d. derkach@xmath163 , o. deschamps@xmath110 , f. dettori@xmath113 , a. di canto@xmath113 , h. dijkstra@xmath113 , s. donleavy@xmath109 , f. dordei@xmath131 , m. dorigo@xmath138 , a. dosil surez@xmath107 , d. dossett@xmath132 , a. dovbnya@xmath167 , k. dreimanis@xmath109 , g. dujany@xmath126 , f. dupertuis@xmath138 , p. durante@xmath113 , r. dzhelyadin@xmath128 , a. dziurda@xmath168 , a. dzyuba@xmath115 , s. easo@xmath169 , u. egede@xmath165 , v. egorychev@xmath142 , s. eidelman@xmath149 , s. eisenhardt@xmath161 , u. eitschberger@xmath112 , r. ekelhof@xmath112 , l. eklund@xmath114 , i. el rifai@xmath110 , ch .
elsasser@xmath122 , s. ely@xmath129 , s. esen@xmath131 , h .-
evans@xmath136 , t. evans@xmath163 , a. falabella@xmath170 , c. frber@xmath131 , c. farinelli@xmath106 , n. farley@xmath146 , s. farry@xmath109 , rf fay@xmath109 , d. ferguson@xmath161 , v. fernandez albor@xmath107 , f. ferreira rodrigues@xmath141 , m. ferro - luzzi@xmath113 , s. filippov@xmath171 , m. fiore@xmath124 , m. fiorini@xmath124 , m. firlej@xmath172 , c. fitzpatrick@xmath138 , t. fiutowski@xmath172 , m. fontana@xmath127 , f. fontanelli@xmath173 , r. forty@xmath113 , o. francisco@xmath117 , m. frank@xmath113 , c. frei@xmath113 , m. frosini@xmath174 , j. fu@xmath175 , e. furfaro@xmath159 , a. gallas torreira@xmath107 , d. galli@xmath158 , s. gallorini@xmath118 , s. gambetta@xmath173 , m. gandelman@xmath117 , p. gandini@xmath129 , y. gao@xmath120 , j. garca pardias@xmath107 , j. garofoli@xmath129 , j. garra tico@xmath136 , l. garrido@xmath133 , c. gaspar@xmath113 , r. gauld@xmath163 , l. gavardi@xmath112 , g. gavrilov@xmath115 , a. geraci@xmath176 , e. gersabeck@xmath131 , m. gersabeck@xmath126 , t. gershon@xmath132 , ph .
ghez@xmath139 , a. gianelle@xmath118 , s. gian@xmath138 , v. gibson@xmath136 , l. giubega@xmath177 , v.v .
gligorov@xmath113 , c. gbel@xmath134 , d. golubkov@xmath142 , a. golutvin@xmath178 , a. gomes@xmath179 , c. gotti@xmath162 , m. grabalosa gndara@xmath110 , r. graciani diaz@xmath133 , l.a .
granado cardoso@xmath113 , e. graugs@xmath133 , g. graziani@xmath180 , a. grecu@xmath177 , e. greening@xmath163 , s. gregson@xmath136 , p. griffith@xmath146 , l. grillo@xmath131 , o. grnberg@xmath181 , b. gui@xmath129 , e. gushchin@xmath171 , yu .
guz@xmath182 , t. gys@xmath113 , c. hadjivasiliou@xmath129 , g. haefeli@xmath138 , c. haen@xmath113 , s.c .
haines@xmath136 , s. hall@xmath165 , b. hamilton@xmath125 , t. hampson@xmath108 , x. han@xmath131 , s. hansmann - menzemer@xmath131 , n. harnew@xmath163 , s.t .
harnew@xmath108 , j. harrison@xmath126 , j. he@xmath113 , t. head@xmath113 , v. heijne@xmath106 , k. hennessy@xmath109 , p. henrard@xmath110 , l. henry@xmath143 , j.a .
hernando morata@xmath107 , e. van herwijnen@xmath113 , m. he@xmath181 , a. hicheur@xmath141 , d. hill@xmath163 , m. hoballah@xmath110 , c. hombach@xmath126 , w. hulsbergen@xmath106 , p. hunt@xmath163 , n. hussain@xmath163 , d. hutchcroft@xmath109 , d. hynds@xmath114 , m. idzik@xmath172 , p. ilten@xmath166 , r. jacobsson@xmath113 , a. jaeger@xmath131 , j. jalocha@xmath163 , e. jans@xmath106 , p. jaton@xmath138 , a. jawahery@xmath125 , f. jing@xmath120 , m. john@xmath163 , d. johnson@xmath113 , c.r .
jones@xmath136 , c. joram@xmath113 , b. jost@xmath113 , n. jurik@xmath129 , m. kaballo@xmath112 , s. kandybei@xmath167 , w. kanso@xmath111 , m. karacson@xmath113 , t.m .
karbach@xmath113 , s. karodia@xmath114 , m. kelsey@xmath129 , i.r .
kenyon@xmath146 , t. ketel@xmath152 , b. khanji@xmath162 , c. khurewathanakul@xmath138 , s. klaver@xmath126 , k. klimaszewski@xmath137 , o. kochebina@xmath119 , m. kolpin@xmath131 , i. komarov@xmath138 , r.f .
koopman@xmath152 , p. koppenburg@xmath183 , m. korolev@xmath145 , a. kozlinskiy@xmath106 , l. kravchuk@xmath171 , k. kreplin@xmath131 , m. kreps@xmath132 , g. krocker@xmath131 , p. krokovny@xmath149 , f. kruse@xmath112 , w. kucewicz@xmath184 , m. kucharczyk@xmath185 , v. kudryavtsev@xmath149 , k. kurek@xmath137 , t. kvaratskheliya@xmath142 , v.n .
la thi@xmath138 , d. lacarrere@xmath113 , g. lafferty@xmath126 , a. lai@xmath154 , d. lambert@xmath161 , r.w .
lambert@xmath152 , g. lanfranchi@xmath144 , c. langenbruch@xmath132 , b. langhans@xmath113 , t. latham@xmath132 , c. lazzeroni@xmath146 , r. le gac@xmath111 , j. van leerdam@xmath106 , j .-
lees@xmath139 , r. lefvre@xmath110 , a. leflat@xmath145 , j. lefranois@xmath119 , s. leo@xmath140 , o. leroy@xmath111 , t. lesiak@xmath168 , b. leverington@xmath131 , y. li@xmath120 , t. likhomanenko@xmath186 , m. liles@xmath109 , r. lindner@xmath113 , c. linn@xmath113 , f. lionetto@xmath122 , b. liu@xmath154 , s. lohn@xmath113 , i. longstaff@xmath114 , j.h .
lopes@xmath117 , n. lopez - march@xmath138 , p. lowdon@xmath122 , h. lu@xmath120 , d. lucchesi@xmath153 , h. luo@xmath161 , a. lupato@xmath118 , e. luppi@xmath124 , o. lupton@xmath163 , f. machefert@xmath119 , i.v .
machikhiliyan@xmath142 , f. maciuc@xmath177 , o. maev@xmath115 , s. malde@xmath163 , a. malinin@xmath186 , g. manca@xmath187 , g. mancinelli@xmath111 , a. mapelli@xmath113 , j. maratas@xmath110 , j.f .
marchand@xmath139 , u. marconi@xmath170 , c. marin benito@xmath133 , p. marino@xmath188 , r. mrki@xmath138 , j. marks@xmath131 , g. martellotti@xmath148 , a. martens@xmath143 , a. martn snchez@xmath119 , m. martinelli@xmath138 , d. martinez santos@xmath152 , f. martinez vidal@xmath189 , d. martins tostes@xmath117 , a. massafferri@xmath141 , r. matev@xmath113 , z. mathe@xmath113 , c. matteuzzi@xmath162 , a. mazurov@xmath124 , m. mccann@xmath165 , j. mccarthy@xmath146 , a. mcnab@xmath126 , r. mcnulty@xmath190 , b. mcskelly@xmath109 , b. meadows@xmath123 , f. meier@xmath112 , m. meissner@xmath131 , m. merk@xmath106 , d.a .
milanes@xmath143 , m .-
minard@xmath139 , n. moggi@xmath170 , j. molina rodriguez@xmath134 , s. monteil@xmath110 , m. morandin@xmath118 , p. morawski@xmath172 , a. mord@xmath111 , m.j .
morello@xmath188 , j. moron@xmath172 , a .-
morris@xmath161 , r. mountain@xmath129 , f. muheim@xmath161 , k. mller@xmath122 , m. mussini@xmath170 , b. muster@xmath138 , p. naik@xmath108 , t. nakada@xmath138 , r. nandakumar@xmath191 , i. nasteva@xmath117 , m. needham@xmath161 , n. neri@xmath192 , s. neubert@xmath113 , n. neufeld@xmath113 , m. neuner@xmath131 , a.d .
nguyen@xmath138 , t.d .
nguyen@xmath138 , c. nguyen - mau@xmath193 , m. nicol@xmath119 , v. niess@xmath110 , r. niet@xmath112 , n. nikitin@xmath145 , t. nikodem@xmath131 , a. novoselov@xmath128 , d.p .
ohanlon@xmath132 , a. oblakowska - mucha@xmath172 , v. obraztsov@xmath128 , s. oggero@xmath106 , s. ogilvy@xmath114 , o. okhrimenko@xmath194 , r. oldeman@xmath187 , g. onderwater@xmath195 , m. orlandea@xmath177 , j.m .
otalora goicochea@xmath117 , p. owen@xmath165 , a. oyanguren@xmath189 , b.k .
pal@xmath129 , a. palano@xmath196 , f. palombo@xmath197 , m. palutan@xmath144 , j. panman@xmath113 , a. papanestis@xmath169 , m. pappagallo@xmath114 , l.l .
pappalardo@xmath124 , c. parkes@xmath126 , c.j .
parkinson@xmath198 , g. passaleva@xmath180 , g.d .
patel@xmath109 , m. patel@xmath165 , c. patrignani@xmath173 , a. pazos alvarez@xmath107 , a. pearce@xmath126 , a. pellegrino@xmath106 , m. pepe altarelli@xmath113 , s. perazzini@xmath158 , e. perez trigo@xmath107 , p. perret@xmath110 , m. perrin - terrin@xmath111 , l. pescatore@xmath146 , e. pesen@xmath199 , k. petridis@xmath165 , a. petrolini@xmath173 , e. picatoste olloqui@xmath133 , b. pietrzyk@xmath139 , t. pila@xmath132 , d. pinci@xmath148 , a. pistone@xmath200 , s. playfer@xmath161 , m. plo casasus@xmath107 , f. polci@xmath143 , a. poluektov@xmath201 , e. polycarpo@xmath117 , a. popov@xmath128 , d. popov@xmath127 , b. popovici@xmath177 , c. potterat@xmath117 , e. price@xmath108 , j. prisciandaro@xmath138 , a. pritchard@xmath109 , c. prouve@xmath108 , v. pugatch@xmath194 , a. puig navarro@xmath138 , g. punzi@xmath202 , w. qian@xmath139 , b. rachwal@xmath168 , j.h .
rademacker@xmath108 , b. rakotomiaramanana@xmath138 , m. rama@xmath144 , m.s .
rangel@xmath117 , i. raniuk@xmath167 , n. rauschmayr@xmath113 , g. raven@xmath152 , s. reichert@xmath126 , m.m .
reid@xmath132 , a.c .
dos reis@xmath141 , s. ricciardi@xmath191 , s. richards@xmath108 , m. rihl@xmath113 , k. rinnert@xmath109 , v. rives molina@xmath133 , d.a .
roa romero@xmath110 , p. robbe@xmath119 , a.b .
rodrigues@xmath141 , e. rodrigues@xmath126 , p. rodriguez perez@xmath126 , s. roiser@xmath113 , v. romanovsky@xmath128 , a. romero vidal@xmath107 , m. rotondo@xmath118 , j. rouvinet@xmath138 , t. ruf@xmath113 , f. ruffini@xmath140 , h. ruiz@xmath133 , p. ruiz valls@xmath189 , j.j .
saborido silva@xmath107 , n. sagidova@xmath115 , p. sail@xmath114 , b. saitta@xmath187 , v. salustino guimaraes@xmath117 , c. sanchez mayordomo@xmath189 , b. sanmartin sedes@xmath107 , r. santacesaria@xmath148 , c. santamarina rios@xmath107 , e. santovetti@xmath159 , a. sarti@xmath203 , c. satriano@xmath130 , a. satta@xmath204 , d.m .
saunders@xmath108 , m. savrie@xmath124 , d. savrina@xmath205 , m. schiller@xmath152 , h. schindler@xmath113 , m. schlupp@xmath112 , m. schmelling@xmath127 , b. schmidt@xmath113 , o. schneider@xmath138 , a. schopper@xmath113 , m .- h .
schune@xmath119 , r. schwemmer@xmath113 , b. sciascia@xmath144 , a. sciubba@xmath148 , m. seco@xmath107 , a. semennikov@xmath142 , i. sepp@xmath165 , n. serra@xmath122 , j. serrano@xmath111 , l. sestini@xmath118 , p. seyfert@xmath131 , m. shapkin@xmath128 , i. shapoval@xmath206 , y. shcheglov@xmath115 , t. shears@xmath109 , l. shekhtman@xmath149 , v. shevchenko@xmath186 , a. shires@xmath112 , r. silva coutinho@xmath132 , g. simi@xmath118 , m. sirendi@xmath136 , n. skidmore@xmath108 , t. skwarnicki@xmath129 , n.a .
smith@xmath109 , e. smith@xmath207 , e. smith@xmath165 , j. smith@xmath136 , m. smith@xmath126 , h. snoek@xmath106 , m.d .
sokoloff@xmath123 , f.j.p .
soler@xmath114 , f. soomro@xmath138 , d. souza@xmath108 , b. souza de paula@xmath117 , b. spaan@xmath112 , a. sparkes@xmath161 , p. spradlin@xmath114 , s. sridharan@xmath113 , f. stagni@xmath113 , m. stahl@xmath131 , s. stahl@xmath131 , o. steinkamp@xmath122 , o. stenyakin@xmath128 , s. stevenson@xmath163 , s. stoica@xmath177 , s. stone@xmath129 , b. storaci@xmath122 , s. stracka@xmath208 , m. straticiuc@xmath177 , u. straumann@xmath122 , r. stroili@xmath118 , v.k .
subbiah@xmath113 , l. sun@xmath123 , w. sutcliffe@xmath165 , k. swientek@xmath172 , s. swientek@xmath112 , v. syropoulos@xmath152 , m. szczekowski@xmath137 , p. szczypka@xmath209 , d. szilard@xmath117 , t. szumlak@xmath172 , s. tjampens@xmath139 , m. teklishyn@xmath119 , g. tellarini@xmath124 , f. teubert@xmath113 , c. thomas@xmath163 , e. thomas@xmath113 , j. van tilburg@xmath106 , v. tisserand@xmath139 , m. tobin@xmath138 , s. tolk@xmath152 , l. tomassetti@xmath124 , d. tonelli@xmath113 , s. topp - joergensen@xmath163 , n. torr@xmath163 , e. tournefier@xmath139 , s. tourneur@xmath138 , m.t .
tran@xmath138 , m. tresch@xmath122 , a. tsaregorodtsev@xmath111 , p. tsopelas@xmath106 , n. tuning@xmath106 , m. ubeda garcia@xmath113 , a. ukleja@xmath137 , a. ustyuzhanin@xmath186 , u. uwer@xmath131 , v. vagnoni@xmath170 , g. valenti@xmath170 , a. vallier@xmath119 , r. vazquez gomez@xmath144 , p. vazquez regueiro@xmath107 , c. vzquez sierra@xmath107 , s. vecchi@xmath135 , j.j .
velthuis@xmath108 , m. veltri@xmath210 , g. veneziano@xmath138 , m. vesterinen@xmath131 , b. viaud@xmath119 , d. vieira@xmath117 , m. vieites diaz@xmath107 , x. vilasis - cardona@xmath156 , a. vollhardt@xmath122 , d. volyanskyy@xmath127 , d. voong@xmath108 , a. vorobyev@xmath115 , v. vorobyev@xmath149 , c. vo@xmath181 , h. voss@xmath127 , j.a .
de vries@xmath106 , r. waldi@xmath181 , c. wallace@xmath132 , r. wallace@xmath190 , j. walsh@xmath140 , s. wandernoth@xmath131 , j. wang@xmath129 , d.r .
ward@xmath136 , n.k .
watson@xmath146 , d. websdale@xmath165 , m. whitehead@xmath132 , j. wicht@xmath113 , d. wiedner@xmath131 , g. wilkinson@xmath163 , m.p .
williams@xmath146 , m. williams@xmath166 , f.f .
wilson@xmath191 , j. wimberley@xmath125 , j. wishahi@xmath112 , w. wislicki@xmath137 , m. witek@xmath168 , g. wormser@xmath119 , s.a .
wotton@xmath136 , s. wright@xmath136 , s. wu@xmath120 , k. wyllie@xmath113 , y. xie@xmath211 , z. xing@xmath129 , z. xu@xmath138 , z. yang@xmath120 , x. yuan@xmath120 , o. yushchenko@xmath128 , m. zangoli@xmath170 , m. zavertyaev@xmath212 , l. zhang@xmath129 , w.c . zhang@xmath190 , y. zhang@xmath120 , a. zhelezov@xmath131 , a. zhokhov@xmath142 , l. zhong@xmath120 , a. zvyagin@xmath113 . _
@xmath213centro brasileiro de pesquisas fsicas ( cbpf ) , rio de janeiro , brazil + @xmath214universidade federal do rio de janeiro ( ufrj ) , rio de janeiro , brazil + @xmath215center for high energy physics , tsinghua university , beijing , china + @xmath216lapp , universit de savoie , cnrs / in2p3 , annecy - le - vieux , france + @xmath217clermont universit , universit blaise pascal , cnrs / in2p3 , lpc , clermont - ferrand , france + @xmath218cppm , aix - marseille universit , cnrs / in2p3 , marseille , france + @xmath219lal , universit paris - sud , cnrs / in2p3 , orsay , france + @xmath220lpnhe , universit pierre et marie curie , universit paris diderot , cnrs / in2p3 , paris , france + @xmath221fakultt physik , technische universitt dortmund , dortmund , germany + @xmath222max - planck - institut fr kernphysik ( mpik ) , heidelberg , germany + @xmath223physikalisches institut , ruprecht - karls - universitt heidelberg , heidelberg , germany + @xmath224school of physics , university college dublin , dublin , ireland + @xmath225sezione infn di bari , bari , italy + @xmath226sezione infn di bologna , bologna , italy + @xmath227sezione infn di cagliari , cagliari , italy + @xmath228sezione infn di ferrara , ferrara , italy + @xmath229sezione infn di firenze , firenze , italy + @xmath230laboratori nazionali dellinfn di frascati , frascati , italy + @xmath231sezione infn di genova , genova , italy + @xmath232sezione infn di milano bicocca , milano , italy + @xmath233sezione infn di milano , milano , italy + @xmath234sezione infn di padova , padova , italy + @xmath235sezione infn di pisa , pisa , italy + @xmath236sezione infn di roma tor vergata , roma , italy + @xmath237sezione infn di roma la sapienza , roma , italy + @xmath238henryk niewodniczanski institute of nuclear physics polish academy of sciences , krakw , poland + @xmath239agh - university of science and technology , faculty of physics and applied computer science , krakw , poland + @xmath240national center for nuclear research ( ncbj ) , warsaw , poland + @xmath241horia hulubei national institute of physics and nuclear engineering , bucharest - magurele , romania + @xmath242petersburg nuclear physics institute ( pnpi ) , gatchina , russia + @xmath243institute of theoretical and experimental physics ( itep ) , moscow , russia + @xmath244institute of nuclear physics , moscow state university ( sinp msu ) , moscow , russia + @xmath245institute for nuclear research of the russian academy of sciences ( inr ran ) , moscow , russia + @xmath246budker institute of nuclear physics ( sb ras ) and novosibirsk state university , novosibirsk , russia + @xmath247institute for high energy physics ( ihep ) , protvino , russia + @xmath248universitat de barcelona , barcelona , spain + @xmath249universidad de santiago de compostela , santiago de compostela , spain + @xmath250european organization for nuclear research ( cern ) , geneva , switzerland + @xmath251ecole polytechnique fdrale de lausanne ( epfl ) , lausanne , switzerland + @xmath252physik - institut , universitt zrich , zrich , switzerland + @xmath253nikhef national institute for subatomic physics , amsterdam , the netherlands + @xmath254nikhef national institute for subatomic physics and vu university amsterdam , amsterdam , the netherlands + @xmath255nsc kharkiv institute of physics and technology ( nsc kipt ) , kharkiv , ukraine + @xmath256institute for nuclear research of the national academy of sciences ( kinr ) , kyiv , ukraine + @xmath257university of birmingham , birmingham , united kingdom + @xmath258h.h .
wills physics laboratory , university of bristol , bristol , united kingdom + @xmath259cavendish laboratory , university of cambridge , cambridge , united kingdom + @xmath260department of physics , university of warwick , coventry , united kingdom + @xmath261stfc rutherford appleton laboratory , didcot , united kingdom + @xmath262school of physics and astronomy , university of edinburgh , edinburgh , united kingdom + @xmath263school of physics and astronomy , university of glasgow , glasgow , united kingdom + @xmath264oliver lodge laboratory , university of liverpool , liverpool , united kingdom + @xmath265imperial college london , london , united kingdom + @xmath266school of physics and astronomy , university of manchester , manchester , united kingdom + @xmath267department of physics , university of oxford , oxford , united kingdom + @xmath268massachusetts institute of technology , cambridge , ma , united states + @xmath269university of cincinnati , cincinnati , oh , united states + @xmath270university of maryland , college park , md , united states + @xmath271syracuse university , syracuse , ny , united states + @xmath272pontifcia universidade catlica do rio de janeiro ( puc - rio ) , rio de janeiro , brazil , associated to @xmath117 + @xmath273institute of particle physics , central china normal university , wuhan , hubei , china , associated to @xmath120 + @xmath274institut fr physik , universitt rostock , rostock , germany , associated to @xmath131 + @xmath275national research centre kurchatov institute , moscow , russia , associated to @xmath142 + @xmath276instituto
de fisica corpuscular ( ific ) , universitat de valencia - csic , valencia , spain , associated to @xmath133 + @xmath277kvi - university of groningen , groningen , the netherlands , associated to @xmath106 + @xmath278celal bayar university , manisa , turkey , associated to @xmath113 + @xmath279universidade federal do tringulo mineiro ( uftm ) , uberaba - mg , brazil + @xmath280p.n .
lebedev physical institute , russian academy of science ( lpi ras ) , moscow , russia + @xmath281universit di bari , bari , italy + @xmath282universit di bologna , bologna , italy + @xmath283universit di cagliari , cagliari , italy + @xmath284universit di ferrara , ferrara , italy + @xmath285universit di firenze , firenze , italy + @xmath286universit di urbino , urbino , italy + @xmath287universit di modena e reggio emilia , modena , italy + @xmath288universit di genova , genova , italy + @xmath289universit di milano bicocca , milano , italy + @xmath290universit di roma tor vergata , roma , italy + @xmath291universit di roma la sapienza , roma , italy + @xmath292universit della basilicata , potenza , italy + @xmath293agh - university of science and technology , faculty of computer science , electronics and telecommunications , krakw , poland + @xmath294lifaels , la salle , universitat ramon llull , barcelona , spain + @xmath295hanoi university of science , hanoi , viet nam + @xmath296universit di padova , padova , italy + @xmath297universit di pisa , pisa , italy + @xmath298scuola normale superiore , pisa , italy + @xmath299universit degli studi di milano , milano , italy + @xmath300politecnico di milano , milano , italy + _ | the resonant substructure of @xmath0 decays is studied using a data sample corresponding to an integrated luminosity of @xmath1 of @xmath2 collision data recorded by the lhcb detector .
an excess at @xmath3 is found to be an admixture of spin-1 and spin-3 resonances .
therefore the @xmath4 state previously observed in inclusive @xmath5 and @xmath6 processes consists of at least two particles .
this is the first observation of a heavy flavoured spin-3 resonance , and the first time that any spin-3 particle has been seen to be produced in decays .
the masses and widths of the new states and of the @xmath7 meson are measured , giving the most precise determinations to date .
= 1 european organization for nuclear research ( cern ) lc@r + & & cern - ph - ep-2014 - 183 + & & lhcb - paper-2014 - 035 + & & 20 october 2014 + & & + * * observation of overlapping spin-1 and spin-3 @xmath8 resonances at mass @xmath9 the lhcb collaboration published in phys .
rev .
lett .
cern on behalf of the collaboration , license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/[cc-by-4.0 ] .
studies of heavy meson spectroscopy provide an important probe of quantum chromodynamics .
the observations of the @xmath10 @xcite and @xmath11 @xcite mesons led to renewed activity in the field , as their masses were found to be below the @xmath12 and @xmath13 thresholds , respectively , in contrast to prior predictions .
these states are usually interpreted as being two of the orbitally excited ( 1p ) charm - strange states , the other two being the @xmath14 and @xmath15 resonances .
several other charm - strange states , the @xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 resonances , have been discovered @xcite . however , their quantum numbers and spectroscopic assignments are not known , with the exception of the @xmath16 meson , which has spin - parity @xmath19 and is generally believed to be a radially excited ( 2s ) state .
reviews of the expectations in theoretical models can be found in refs .
@xcite .
a state with @xmath20 would be a clear candidate for a member of the 1d family , a state with two units of orbital excitation .
spin-3 states have been observed in the light unflavoured @xcite and strange @xcite meson sectors , but not previously among heavy flavoured mesons
. production of high - spin states is expected to be suppressed in meson decays , and has not previously been observed @xcite .
however , high - spin resonances are expected to be relatively narrow , potentially enhancing their observability . analysis of the dalitz plot @xcite that describes the phase - space of a three - body decay is a powerful tool for spectroscopic studies .
compared to measurements based on inclusive production processes , the lower background level allows broader states to be distinguished and the well - defined initial state allows the quantum numbers to be unambiguously determined .
specifically , in @xmath21 decays , @xmath22 and @xmath8 resonances appear as horizontal and vertical bands in the dalitz plot formed from the invariant masses squared @xmath23 @xmath24 , and the spin of the resonance can be inferred from the distribution of decays along the band .
measurement of the spin also determines the parity , since only natural spin - parity resonances can decay strongly to two pseudoscalars . in this letter ,
results of the first dalitz plot analysis of the @xmath25 decay are summarised .
the inclusion of charge conjugated processes is implied throughout the paper .
the meson is reconstructed through the @xmath26 decay mode , which is treated as flavour - specific , the heavily suppressed @xmath27 contribution is neglected .
the amplitude analysis technique is used to separate contributions from excited charm - strange mesons and from excited kaon states .
a detailed description of the analysis can be found in ref .
@xcite .
the analysis is based on a data sample corresponding to @xmath1 of integrated luminosity , approximately one third ( two thirds ) of which was collected by the lhcb detector from @xmath2 collisions at a centre - of - mass energy of @xmath28 during 2011 ( 2012 ) .
the detector is a single - arm forward spectrometer covering the range @xmath29 , designed for the study of particles containing or quarks , and is described in detail in ref .
@xcite .
signal candidates are accepted offline if one of the final state particles deposited sufficient energy transverse to the beamline in the hadronic calorimeter to fire the hardware trigger .
events that are triggered at the hardware level by another particle in the event are also retained .
the software trigger @xcite requires a two- , three- or four - track secondary vertex with a large sum of the transverse momentum , , of the tracks and a significant displacement from all primary @xmath2 interaction vertices ( pvs ) .
the offline selection requirements are similar to those used in refs .
@xcite and are optimised using the @xmath30 decay as a control channel . discrimination between signal and background categories is achieved primarily with a neural network @xcite trained on @xmath30 data , where signal and background are statistically separated with the technique @xcite using the candidate mass as discriminating variable .
a total of 16 variables are used in the network .
they include the output of a `` boosted decision tree '' @xcite that identifies mesons produced in hadron decays , together with other variables that characterise the topology and the kinematic distributions of the decay .
a requirement on the network output is imposed that reduces the combinatorial background remaining after the initial selection by a factor of five while retaining more than @xmath31 of the signal .
the four final state tracks also have to satisfy pion and kaon identification requirements . to improve the mass resolution , track momenta
are scaled @xcite with calibration parameters determined by matching the observed position of the dimuon mass peak to the known @xmath32 mass @xcite . in addition , the momenta of the tracks from the @xmath33 candidate are adjusted @xcite so that their combined invariant mass matches the known @xmath33 mass @xcite .
an additional @xmath34 mass constraint is applied in the calculation of the dalitz plot variables .
invariant - mass vetoes are applied to remove backgrounds containing @xmath35 mesons , and from the @xmath36 and @xmath37 decays .
decays of mesons to the same final state but without an intermediate charm meson are suppressed by the @xmath38 boosted decision tree criteria and an additional requirement that the @xmath33 candidate vertex is displaced by at least @xmath39 from the @xmath34 decay vertex .
the signal and background yields are obtained from an extended unbinned maximum likelihood fit to the three - body invariant mass distribution of @xmath40 candidates in the range @xmath41@xmath42 .
in addition to signal decays and combinatorial background , the fit model includes components to describe : partially reconstructed @xmath43 decays , with @xmath44 or @xmath45 and the @xmath46 or @xmath47 not included in the reconstruction ; @xmath48 decays ; and @xmath49 and @xmath50 @xcite decays with misidentification of a final state particle .
contributions from other @xmath34 and @xmath51 decays are negligible .
the signal and @xmath48 shapes are each modelled with the sum of two crystal ball @xcite functions which share a common mean and have tails on opposite sides .
the combinatorial background is modelled using a linear function .
smoothed histograms are used to describe the shapes of @xmath52 , @xmath49 and @xmath53 decays .
these shapes are determined from simulated events reweighted to account for the known dalitz plot distributions of the background decays @xcite and particle identification and misidentification probabilities
. candidate invariant mass distribution .
data points are shown in black , the result of the fit as a solid blue line and the components as detailed in the legend . ]
the results of the fit are shown in fig .
[ fig : fits ] . within a signal region of @xmath54 , where the peak position @xmath55 and core width @xmath56 are taken from the results of the fit
, there are @xmath57 candidates . of these , @xmath58 are signal decays , while @xmath59 are combinatorial background , @xmath60 are @xmath61 decays and @xmath62 are @xmath63 decays .
candidates in the signal region .
the effect of the veto can be seen as an unpopulated horizontal band . ]
the dalitz plot distribution of the candidates in the signal region , shown in fig .
[ fig : signalevents ] , is fitted with a model that includes both signal and background components .
the dalitz plot distribution of combinatorial background is obtained from a sideband region above the signal peak in the candidate mass , while those for @xmath61 and @xmath63 backgrounds are obtained from simulation reweighted in the same way as their candidate mass shapes .
the signal model is defined by considering many possible contributions and removing those that do not significantly affect the fit .
it contains 15 resonant or nonresonant amplitudes added coherently in the isobar @xcite model formalism .
these include the @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 resonances .
the @xmath22 s - wave is modelled using the lass shape @xcite , which combines the @xmath68 resonance with a slowly varying ( nonresonant ) component , in addition to the @xmath69 state .
the @xmath7 and @xmath70 states are included , in addition to both spin-1 and spin-3 resonances near @xmath71 labelled @xmath72 and @xmath73 , respectively .
a nonresonant s - wave @xmath8 component is included , modelled with an exponential form factor , as are additional amplitudes mediated by `` virtual '' resonances ( with peak position outside the phase space of the dalitz plot so that only the tail of the lineshape contributes ) : @xmath74 and @xmath75 in @xmath76 , and @xmath77 in @xmath78 . all components , except those explicitly noted above , are modelled with relativistic breit wigner functions .
the parameters of the lineshapes are fixed to their known values @xcite , except for the masses and widths of the @xmath7 , @xmath72 and @xmath73 resonances , the parameters describing the lass function and the exponential form factor of the nonresonant model , which are free to vary in the fit .
the angular distributions are given in the zemach tensor formalism @xcite and each amplitude includes blatt weisskopf barrier form factors @xcite .
the signal model is multiplied by an efficiency function and normalised to unity when integrated across the dalitz plot .
the efficiency is determined as a function of dalitz plot position from samples of simulated events with corrections applied for known discrepancies between data and simulation in the efficiencies of the trigger , track reconstruction and particle identification .
the trigger efficiency correction is applied separately for candidates in events triggered at hardware level by the signal decay products and for those triggered independently .
the largest source of efficiency variation across the dalitz plot arises due to a rapid decrease of the probability to reconstruct low momentum particles .
the particle identification requirements lead to a maximum efficiency variation of about @xmath79 , while other effects are smaller .
projections of the data and the unbinned maximum likelihood fit result are shown in fig .
[ fig : dpprojections ] .
the largest components in terms of their fit fractions , defined as the ratio of the integrals over the dalitz plot of a single decay amplitude squared and the total amplitude squared , are the @xmath64 ( @xmath80 ) , @xmath7 ( @xmath81 ) , lass ( @xmath82 ) and @xmath8 nonresonant ( @xmath83 ) terms .
the fit fractions for the @xmath72 and @xmath73 components are @xmath84 and @xmath85 , respectively , where the uncertainties are statistical , systematic and from dalitz plot model variations , as described below .
the phase difference between the @xmath72 and @xmath73 amplitudes is consistent with @xmath86 within a large model uncertainty .
, ( b ) @xmath76 and ( c ) @xmath78 , with zooms into @xmath76 around ( d ) the @xmath7 resonance and ( e ) the @xmath4 region .
the data are shown as black points , the total fit result as a solid black curve , and the contributions from different resonances as detailed in the legend ( small components , including the background contributions , are not shown ) .
, title="fig : " ] , ( b ) @xmath76 and ( c ) @xmath78 , with zooms into @xmath76 around ( d ) the @xmath7 resonance and ( e ) the @xmath4 region .
the data are shown as black points , the total fit result as a solid black curve , and the contributions from different resonances as detailed in the legend ( small components , including the background contributions , are not shown ) .
, title="fig : " ] , ( b ) @xmath76 and ( c ) @xmath78 , with zooms into @xmath76 around ( d ) the @xmath7 resonance and ( e ) the @xmath4 region .
the data are shown as black points , the total fit result as a solid black curve , and the contributions from different resonances as detailed in the legend ( small components , including the background contributions , are not shown ) .
, title="fig : " ] , ( b ) @xmath76 and ( c ) @xmath78 , with zooms into @xmath76 around ( d ) the @xmath7 resonance and ( e ) the @xmath4 region .
the data are shown as black points , the total fit result as a solid black curve , and the contributions from different resonances as detailed in the legend ( small components , including the background contributions , are not shown ) .
, title="fig : " ] , ( b ) @xmath76 and ( c ) @xmath78 , with zooms into @xmath76 around ( d ) the @xmath7 resonance and ( e ) the @xmath4 region .
the data are shown as black points , the total fit result as a solid black curve , and the contributions from different resonances as detailed in the legend ( small components , including the background contributions , are not shown ) .
, title="fig : " ] , ( b ) @xmath76 and ( c ) @xmath78 , with zooms into @xmath76 around ( d ) the @xmath7 resonance and ( e ) the @xmath4 region .
the data are shown as black points , the total fit result as a solid black curve , and the contributions from different resonances as detailed in the legend ( small components , including the background contributions , are not shown ) .
, title="fig : " ] to assess the significance of the two states near @xmath71 , the fit is repeated with all combinations of either one or two resonant amplitudes with different spins up to and including 3 .
all other combinations give values of negative log - likelihood more than one hundred units larger than the default fit .
a comparison of the angular distributions in the region near @xmath71 of the data and the best fits with the spin-1 only , spin-3 only and both resonances is presented in fig . [
fig : dsjsep ] . including both spin components visibly improves the fit .
large samples of pseudoexperiments are generated with signal models corresponding to the best fits with the spin-1 or spin-3 amplitude removed , and each pseudoexperiment is fitted under both the one- and two - resonance hypotheses . by extrapolating the tails of the distributions of the difference in negative log - likelihood values to the values observed in data , the statistical significances of the spin-3 and spin-1 components are found to be @xmath87 and @xmath88 standard deviations , respectively .
these significances remain in excess of 10 standard deviations in all alternative models considered below .
system , @xmath89 , for @xmath90 , where @xmath91 is the angle between the @xmath92 and the @xmath33 meson momenta in the @xmath8 rest frame .
the data are shown as black points , with the fit results with different models as detailed in the legend .
the dip at @xmath93 is due to the @xmath33 veto .
comparisons of the data and the different fit results in the 50 bins of this projection give @xmath94 values of 47.3 , 214.0 and 150.0 for the default , spin-1 only and spin-3 only models , respectively . ]
the considered sources of systematic uncertainty are divided into two main categories : experimental uncertainties and model uncertainties .
the experimental systematic uncertainties arise from imperfect knowledge of : the relative amount of signal and background in the selected events ; the distributions of each of the backgrounds across the phase space ; the variation of the efficiency across the phase space ; the possible bias induced by the fit procedure ; the momentum calibration ; the fixed masses of the @xmath34 and @xmath33 mesons used to define the boundaries of the dalitz plot .
model uncertainties occur due to : fixed parameters in the dalitz plot model ; the treatment of marginal components in the default fit model ; the choice of models for the @xmath22 s - wave , the @xmath8 s- and p - waves , and the lineshapes of the virtual resonances .
the systematic uncertainties from each source are combined in quadrature .
the masses and widths of the @xmath7 , @xmath72 and @xmath73 states are determined to be @xmath95 where the first uncertainty is statistical , the second is due to experimental systematic effects and the third due to model variations .
the largest sources of uncertainty on the parameters of the @xmath96 and @xmath97 resonances arise from varying the @xmath22 s - wave description and , for the @xmath72 width , from removing the @xmath67 and @xmath77 components from the model .
the results for the @xmath98 mass and width are determined with significantly better precision than previous measurements .
those for the parameters of the @xmath96 and @xmath97 resonances must be considered first measurements , since previous measurements of the properties of the @xmath99 state @xcite involved an unknown admixture of at least these two particles .
the results for all the complex amplitudes determined by the dalitz plot fit , as well as derived quantities such as branching fractions of the resonant contributions and detailed descriptions of the systematic uncertainties , are given in ref .
@xcite . in summary , results of the first amplitude analysis of the @xmath25 decay show , with significance of more than 10 standard deviations , that a structure at @xmath3 contains both spin-1 and spin-3 components .
the masses of the @xmath100 and @xmath101 states are found to be similar , while a larger width of the spin-1 state than that of the spin-3 state is preferred .
the results support an interpretation of these states being the @xmath19 and @xmath102 members of the 1d family , though the @xmath103 state may be partially mixed with the vector member of the 2s family to give the physical @xmath16 and @xmath100 states .
the discovery of the @xmath104 resonance represents the first observation of a heavy flavoured spin-3 particle , and the first time that a spin-3 state is seen to be produced in @xmath105 decays .
this demonstrates that the spectroscopy of the 1d families of heavy flavoured mesons can be studied experimentally . |
the problem of quickest detection has been known in the engineering literature since the 1930s . since then
there have been various analytical considerations of the quickest detection problem in a variety of models and setups ( see @xcite for an overview ) .
the quickest detection problem , also known as the disorder problem , concerns the detection of a change point in the statistical behavior of a stream of sequential observations . the objective is to blanace the trade off between a small detection delay and small frequency of false alarms . of this problem
there are two main formulations , the bayesian and the min max . in the former , the change point or disorder time
is assumed to have an a priori distribution usually independent of the observation process while in the latter it is assumed to be an unknown constant .
an interesting variation of the bayesian problem in which the change point is assumed to depend on the observations is discussed in @xcite and treated under poisson dynamics in @xcite . yet in all formulations considered thus far , it is assumed that there is either one stream of observations in which there is one @xcite or multiple alternatives regarding the law of the post change distribution of the observations @xcite , or alternatively , multiple streams of observations of various models all undergoing a disorder at the same time @xcite . in our work
, we assume that there are @xmath0 sources of observations coupled by correlated noise .
the observations are assumed to be continuous and thus a wiener model is used .
the problem considered in this work is that in which the @xmath0 different streams of observations coupled by correlated noise may undergo a change at @xmath0 distinct change points .
the objective is then to detect the minimum of the change points or disorder times . of this type of problem
there has thus far been a bayesian formulation in independent streams of poisson observations @xcite .
recently , the case was also considered of change points that propagate in a sensor array @xcite . however , in this configuration the propagation of the change points depends on the _ unknown _ identity of the first sensor affected and considers a restricted markovian mechanism of propagation of the change . in this paper , we consider the case in which the change points can be different and do not propagate in any specific configuration .
in fact , in our formulation the change points or disorder times are assumed to be unknown constants and a min
max approach to their estimation is taken .
in particular , we consider an extended lorden criterion to measure the worst detection delay over all observation paths and change points .
the objective is then to find a stopping rule that minimizes the detection delay subject to a lower bound constraint on the mean time to the first false alarm .
the @xmath0 streams of observations are coupled through correlated noise . in particular ,
correlations are modeled through a stochastic correlation matrix that is assumed to be nonsingular and predictable .
this work is a continuation of the problem considered in @xcite in which the case is considered of independent observations received at each sensor . in that work
, it is seen that the decentralized system of sensors in which each sensor employs its own cumulative sum ( cusum ) @xcite strategy and communicates its detection through a binary asynchronous message to a central fusion center , which in turn decides at the first onset of a signal based on the first communication performs asymptotically just as well as the centralized system . in other words , the minimum of @xmath0-cusums is asymptotically optimal in detecting the minimum of @xmath0 distinct change points in the case of independent observations as the mean time to the first false alarm increases without bound .
the mean time to the first false alarm can be used as a benchmark in actual applications in which the engineer or scientist may make several runs of the system while it is in control in order to uniquely identify , the appropriate parameter that would lead to a tolerable rate of false detection .
the problem of optimal detection then boils down to minimizing the detection delay subject to a tolerable rate of false alarms .
asymptotic optimality is then proven by comparing the rate of increase in detection delay to the rate of false alarms as the threshold parameter varies .
a series of more recent related work includes the case in which the system of sensors is coupled through the drift parameter as opposed to the noise @xcite . in that work
, it is once again seen that the minimum of @xmath0-cusums is also asymptotically optimal in detecting the minimum of @xmath0 distinct change points with respect to a generalized kullback leibler distance criterion inspired by @xcite . yet , in none of the above cases is the case of correlated noise considered even though it is very important in practical applications .
in fact , there are multiple applications of this problem especially in the area of communications where sensor networks are widely used and multiple correlated streams of observations are present .
the change points , usually representing the onset of a signal in a specific sensor , may well be distinct .
the minimum of the change points then represents the onset of a signal in the system .
the presence of correlations is due to the fact that , although sensors are placed typically at different locations , they are subject to the same physical environment . for example , in the case of sensors monitoring traffic in opposite ( same ) directions may have negative ( positive ) correlations due to environmental factors such as the direction of the wind @xcite . moreover ,
the appearance of a signal at one location may or may not cause interference of the signal at another location , thus causing correlations whose structure may even be time or observations dependent .
this happens when the sensors are closely spaced relative to the curvature of the field being sensed .
for example , temperature sensors or humidity sensors that are in a similar geographic region will produce readings that are correlated .
a stochastic correlation matrix would best describe such a situation .
some of the relevant literature that includes such examples can be found in @xcite . in an earlier work @xcite
the authors treat the problem of quickest detection of the minimum of two change points in the special case of two streams of sequential observations when the correlation in the noise of the observations is constant and negative and the same drifts are assumed after each of the disorder times .
this work treats the general case of @xmath0 correlated streams of observations in the presence of partial information regarding the post - change drifts which can as such be different .
moreover , we consider a general stochastic correlation matrix allowing for both positive and negative time and state dependent correlations in the system .
the results found in this work are in fact rather surprising .
it is seen that the minimum of @xmath0-cusum stopping rules maintains its asymptotically optimal character as the mean time to the first false alarm increases without bound even in the case of partially known drifts and a stochastic correlation matrix coupling the noise of @xmath0 streams of observations . in particular , it is proved that the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule ( defined in algorithm [ ncusum ] ) is second - order asymptotically optimal below . ] in the case the post - disorder drift parameters assumed across the @xmath0 streams of observations are the same , and is third - order asymptotically optimal when the post - disorder drift parameters are different for an appropriately chosen set of threshold parameters whose form is explicitly given .
the method used to prove the asymptotic optimality of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule is to bound the optimal detection delay from above and from below .
then we examine the rate at which the difference between the upper and the lower bounds approach each other as the mean time to the first false alarm increases without bound . this method is similar to @xcite .
however , the methodology developed in this work for establishing the upper and lower bounds is more efficient and robust in that it is based on probabilistic arguments . in contrast
, the existing work in continuous - time , which is either relied on brute computation of the asymptotic behaviors of maximum drawdown densities @xcite or on the derivation of sharp solutions to dirichlet problems with neumann conditions @xcite , is very difficult in high - dimension and highly sensitive to the model parameters .
the methodology developed in this paper is universal and can thus handle a non - markovian , predictable correlation matrix process for the noises , which is very useful in practical applications .
finally , our methodology can be applied to other detection problems not covered in this paper , for example , quickest detection with multiple alternatives @xcite . in establishing the lower bound
, we give a nontrivial generalization of a measure change technique developed in @xcite to @xmath0-dimensions .
although we do not get the exact optimality as in one dimension @xcite , we do prove that the optimal detection delay in @xmath0-dimensions is bounded from below by that obtained in one dimension , under any predictable , nonsingular correlation matrix .
in the next section , we formulate the problem mathematically , review the existing results in one dimension , and introduce the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule . in section [ robust ] , we establish a robust upper bound and a robust lower bound for both the optimal detection delay and the detection delay of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule .
these bounds are then used in section [ asympt ] to show the main result of the paper the asymptotic optimality of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule under complete or partial information of the drifts and a stochastic cross - correlated noise structure in the observations .
applications of these results are discussed in section [ applications ] .
we conclude with some closing remarks in section [ conclusion ] .
the proof of the lemma that is omitted can be found in the . throughout the paper ,
we denote by @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 $ ] .
consider a filtered probability space @xmath5 with filtration @xmath6 , and the processes @xmath7 , @xmath8 , are assumed to satisfy the following stochastic differential equations : @xmath9 here , @xmath10 are deterministic but _ unknown _ positive constants or @xmath11 , @xmath12 are positive constants ( but not necessarily the value of it ) , then we can take @xmath13 as the @xmath14th observation process so that the post - change drift is @xmath15 .
we do not treat in this paper , however , the case in which we do not know the sign of the post - change drift . ]
that are either completely known or partially known . in the latter case , we assume that @xmath16 is a known constant , and for @xmath17 , there are known positive constants @xmath18 such that @xmath19 $ ] holds . is known , we can conveniently take @xmath20 . ]
the processes @xmath21 for @xmath22 are @xmath0 correlated standard brownian motions with a predictable , nonsingular , stochastic instantaneous correlation matrix @xmath23 . that is
, @xmath24 is the instantaneous correlation between brownian motions @xmath25 and @xmath26 ( see also @xcite , page 227 ) .
an example covered by the above assumptions is one in which @xmath27 for @xmath28 and some @xmath29 . in other words
, there is a deterministic exponential decay in the instantaneous correlation of the two sensors @xmath14 and @xmath30 .
such a situation may arise by the sudden arrival of a passing rainstorm at sensors @xmath14 and @xmath30 , which are customarily placed in the same geographical region and are therefore also subject to the same climate conditions . yet
our formulation is even more general in that it is also able to capture state dependent correlations which is a very realistic scenario since observations of higher intensity are typically more likely to cause higher correlations in the noise , for instance , @xmath31 and @xmath32 for @xmath33 .
another example of a correlated nonstationary white noise structure arises in the problem of monitoring the vibration of a mechanical system and is discussed in full detail in section 11.1.4.1 of @xcite . to facilitate our analysis
, we introduce a family of probability measures on the canonical space @xmath34 : @xmath35 . here , @xmath36 corresponds to the measure generated on @xmath37 by the processes @xmath38 when the change in the @xmath0-tuple process occurs at the time points @xmath39 , @xmath40 , respectively . in particular
, the measure @xmath41 characterizes the law of @xmath0 correlated standard brownian motions @xmath21 . for other @xmath42 s
, the measure @xmath36 can be defined through the radon nikodym derivative process @xmath43 fulfills the novikov condition : @xmath44 \label{eq : nov } \\[-8pt ] \eqntext{{\displaystyle}\forall t\ge0 , \forall(s_1 , \ldots , s_n)\in(\overline{\mathbb{r}}_+)^n.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we comment that the `` reality '' measure @xmath45 is one unknown element in @xmath46 . to describe the `` marginal '' law of the @xmath14th component of the @xmath0-tuple process @xmath47
, we also introduce the measure @xmath48 , which is the probability measure generated by the process @xmath49 on the space @xmath50 , where @xmath51 for @xmath52 , is the natural filtration of @xmath49 , and @xmath39 is the value of the change - point for process @xmath49 .
our objective is to find a stopping rule @xmath53 , which is adapted to the natural filtration @xmath54 : @xmath55 , needs not to be adapted to @xmath56 .
for example , @xmath57 can be driven by a @xmath0-dimensional brownian motion which is independent of @xmath25 s . ] to balance the trade - off between a small detection delay subject to a lower bound on the mean - time to the first false alarm and will ultimately detect @xmath58 , which will be denoted by @xmath59 in what follows . as a performance measure , we consider @xmath60 where @xmath61 , @xmath62 denotes the expectation under the probability measure @xmath63 , and the supremum over @xmath64 is taken over the set in which @xmath65 .
in other words , we consider the worst detection delay over all possible realizations of paths of the @xmath0-tuple of the stochastic process @xmath66 up to time @xmath67 , and then consider the worst detection delay over all possible @xmath0-tuples @xmath68 over a set in which at least one of the components takes a finite value .
this is because @xmath53 is a stopping rule meant to detect the minimum of the @xmath0 change points and , therefore , if one of the @xmath0 processes undergoes a regime change , any unit of time by which @xmath53 delays in reacting , should be counted toward the detection delay .
although it seems to be a quite pessimistic measure for detection delay , this framework has the merit that one does not need to impose any prior knowledge of the distribution of the change - points @xmath69 s , as discussed in @xcite . in all , this gives rise to the following stochastic optimization problem : @xmath70 where @xmath71 captures the mean time to the first false alarm and as such the above constraint describes the tolerance on the false alarms .
in particular , the constant @xmath72 is the lowest acceptable value of the mean time to the first false alarm . in other words ,
the reciprocal of @xmath73 , namely @xmath74 , captures the highest tolerance to the frequency of false alarms of the family of stopping times considered in this problem .
when detecting @xmath69 is our only concern , and that @xmath75 is a known constant , the problem reduces to an one - dimensional problem of detecting a one - sided change in a sequence of brownian motion observations , whose optimality was found in @xcite and @xcite . it is shown that the optimal stopping rule under lorden s criterion is the continuous time version of page s cusum stopping rule , namely the first passage time of the process @xmath76 \\[-8pt ] \eqntext{{\displaystyle}\mbox{for } \tilde{u}_t^{(i ) } : = \mu_i \xi_t^{(i ) } - \frac{1}{2 } \mu_i^2 t \quad\mbox{and}\quad \tilde{m}_t^{(i ) } : = \inf_{0\le s\le t } \tilde{u}_s^{(i)},}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the cusum stopping rule with the threshold @xmath77 is given by @xmath78 the optimal threshold @xmath79 is chosen so that @xmath80 the corresponding optimal detection delay achieved by the cusum stopping rule @xmath81 is then given by @xmath82 the fact that the worst detection delay in the one - dimensional problem is the same as that incurred in the case that the change point is exactly at @xmath83 is a consequence of the nonnegativity and strong markov property of the cusum process , from which it follows that the worst detection delay occurs when the cusum process is at @xmath83 at the time of the change ( see also @xcite ) .
the optimality of the cusum stopping rule in the presence of only one observation process with a known drift suggests that a cusum type of stopping rule might display similar optimality properties in the case of multiple observation processes for the problem ( [ eqnproblem ] ) . in particular , an intuitively appealing rule , when the detection of @xmath59 is of interest , is to take the minimum of @xmath0-cusum - like stopping rules ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , which we formalize in the following algorithm .
[ ncusum ] the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule with a threshold vector @xmath84 is given by @xmath85 , where for each @xmath8 , @xmath86 \label{cusum1chart } \\[-25pt ] \eqntext{{\displaystyle}\mbox{with } y_t^{(i)}=u_t^{(i)}-m_t^{(i ) } , \mbox{for } u_t^{(i)}:=\underline { \mu } _
i \xi_t^{(i)}-\frac{1}{2}\underline { \mu}_i^2t}\\ \eqntext{{\displaystyle}\mbox{and } m_t^{(i)}:=\inf _ { 0\le s\le t}u_t^{(i)}.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] that is , we use what is known as a multichart cusum stopping rule @xcite , which can be written as @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the semi - martingale defined in ( [ cusum1chart ] ) , for @xmath8 .
we notice that each of the @xmath89 , for @xmath8 , are stopping rules also with respect to each of the smaller filtrations @xmath90 , and thus they can be employed by each one of the sensors @xmath91 , for each @xmath14 independently .
each of the sensors can then subsequently communicate an alarm to a central fusion center once its threshold , say @xmath92 , is reached by its own cusum statistic process @xmath93 .
the resulting rule , namely algorithm [ ncusum ] , can then be devised by the central fusion center in that it will declare a detection at the first instance one of the @xmath0 sensors communicates . from ( [ 1dimpr ] ) and ( [ cusum1chart ] ) , it is easily seen that @xmath94 and @xmath95 , a.s .
, provided that @xmath96 is known .
in particular , we always have @xmath97 and @xmath98 .
while it seems prohibitively difficult to devise a stopping rule that achieves the optimal detection delay @xmath99 under a general nonsingular correlation matrix @xmath100 , the above @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath101 provides a low - complexity candidate detection rule for detecting @xmath59 . in particular , we will show that the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule is asymptotically optimal . to this effect , we give the following definitions of asymptotic optimality as in @xcite .
[ optdef ] given @xmath72 and a stopping time @xmath102 , we say that : 1 .
@xmath103 has the first - order asymptotic optimality for problem ( [ eqnproblem ] ) if and only if @xmath104 2 .
@xmath103 has the second - order asymptotic optimality for problem ( [ eqnproblem ] ) if and only if @xmath105<\infty\quad\mbox{and}\quad \lim _ { \gamma\to\infty}\inf_{t\in \mathcal { t}_\gamma}j^{(n)}(t)=\infty.\ ] ] 3 .
@xmath103 has the third - order asymptotic optimality for problem ( [ eqnproblem ] ) if and only if @xmath105=0\quad \mbox{and}\quad\lim _ { \gamma\to\infty}\inf_{t\in \mathcal { t}_\gamma}j^{(n)}(t)=\infty.\ ] ] below we will investigate the performance of @xmath101 by contrasting it with the optimal detection delay .
in this section , we examine the performance of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule by presenting an upper bound and a lower bound for both the detection delay of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule and the optimal detection delay defined in ( [ eqnproblem ] ) . to this end , we derive a robust upper bound for the detection delay of a particular @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath106 in @xmath107 . because @xmath101 can not beat the unknown optimal stopping rule ( if it ever exists ) , this upper bound will also bound the optimal detection delay from above . we then demonstrate that the optimal detection delay in the @xmath0-dimensional system is bounded from below by the optimal delay in 1-dimensional systems . in this subsection , we derive a robust upper bound for the detection delay of a @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath101 , whose thresholds set @xmath108 is chosen so that @xmath109 for any @xmath72 .
the upper bound , that we obtain , also dominates the optimal detection delay , due to the fact that @xmath110 holds .
now let us introduce @xmath111 for @xmath112 , where @xmath113 is the detection delay of the stopping rule @xmath53 when @xmath114 , implying that the performance measure defined in ( [ jkl ] ) is given by @xmath115 .
we now consider the case when all drifts @xmath75 s are known constants . in this case , we select @xmath108 such that @xmath116 or equivalently [ by ( [ 1dimsol ] ) ] , @xmath117 due to the monotonicity of function @xmath118 , @xmath92 s are uniquely determined once @xmath119 is given .
in general , if we only have partial information about @xmath75 s for @xmath17 , we instead consider @xmath120 by choosing the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath106 in this way , we are able to get an easily computable upper bound for the worst detection delay @xmath121 . the assertion is proved in the following proposition .
[ upb ] suppose that @xmath122 satisfies the equations in ( [ hi ] ) or ( [ hi1 ] ) , then we have for the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath123 , that @xmath124 where the function @xmath118 is defined in ( [ g ] ) . for any @xmath125 such that @xmath126 and @xmath127 , we have @xmath128 where the last equality follows from the fact that the cusum stopping rule @xmath129 is @xmath130-measurable and we can thus use the `` marginal '' law of the @xmath30th component of the @xmath0-tuple process @xmath47 , given in this case by the measure @xmath131 . by taking the essential supremum and then the supremum over @xmath132 such that @xmath114 on both sides of ( [ e < ] ) , and using the definitions in ( [ jkl ] ) and ( [ jjn ] ) for @xmath133 , we get that @xmath134 to get the conditional expectation in the above expression , we use the strong markov property of the processes @xmath135 ( see , e.g. , @xcite , theorem 7.2.4 ) and apply it s formula to @xmath136 ( see , e.g. , @xcite , theorem 4.1.2 ) for the function @xmath118 given in ( [ g ] ) ( see also shiryaev @xcite and moustakides @xcite ) , we obtain that ( by the monotonicity of @xmath118 ) @xmath137 \nonumber \\ \label{sing } & = & \mathbf{1}_{\{t_{h_j}^j > s_j\ } } \biggl[\int_{s_j}^{t_{h_j}^j } \underline{\mu}_j \biggl(\mu_j-\frac{1}{2 } \underline{\mu}_j \biggr)\,{d}s\\ & & \nonumber\hspace*{43pt}{}-\int_{s_j}^{t_{h_j}^j}g ' \bigl(-y_s^{(j)}\bigr)\,{d}m_s^{(j)}+m_{t_{h_j}^j}-m_{s_j } \biggr],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the process @xmath138 is given by ( [ cusum1chart ] ) and the continuous square integrable martingale @xmath139 is given by @xmath140 taking into account that the process @xmath138 decreases only on the random set @xmath141 and the measure @xmath142 off this set , together with the fact that @xmath143 , we conclude that the integral in ( [ sing ] ) can be set equal to zero .
we then take the conditional expectations with respect to the probability measure @xmath144 given @xmath145 in ( [ sing ] ) and by means of the doob s optional sampling theorem ( see , e.g. , @xcite , chapter 1 , theorem 3.22 ) , we have @xmath146 \label{j11 } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & \ge & \frac{\underline{\mu } _ j^2}{2}\mathbb{e}_{s_j}^{j}\bigl\
{ \bigl(t_{h_j}^j - s_j\bigr)^+| \mathcal{g}_{s_j}^j\bigr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , by ( [ j1 < ] ) and ( [ j11 ] ) we have @xmath147 . by the arbitrariness of @xmath30
, we have @xmath148 \label{jn}\\[-8pt ] \nonumber & \le & \max \biggl\ { \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } g(-h_1),\ldots,\frac{2}{\underline { \mu } _
n^2 } g(-h_n ) \biggr\ } = \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2}g(-h_1),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last equality is a consequence of the equations in ( [ hi1 ] )
. condition ( [ hi1 ] ) reduces the thresholds selection problem from @xmath0 dimension to one dimension . in order to bound the optimal detection delay in ( [ eqnproblem ] ) using the result in proposition [ upb ]
, we will choose @xmath149 so that the resulting @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath109 .
that is , @xmath150 to this end , we derive a lower bound for the mean time to the first false alarm @xmath151 , which is robust with respect to the covariance matrix @xmath152 . in the sequel
, we first study the case of equal drift size with complete information , where @xmath153 are known constant , and then treat the case of unequal drift size with complete information , such that @xmath75 s are all known and @xmath154 holds for some @xmath155 .
finally , we study the general case with partial information , where we only know @xmath156 and the intervals @xmath157\ni\mu_i$ ] for all @xmath17 . in this case
, it is assumed that all @xmath75 are known and @xmath158 for all @xmath8 .
then the monotonicity of function @xmath118 and ( [ hi ] ) imply that @xmath159 for the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule .
hence , with a slight abuse of notation , we denote by @xmath160 .
below we derive a lower bound for the mean time of the first false alarm of the latter .
[ thm : false_alarm ] suppose that all thresholds of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule are chosen to be equal to @xmath161 .
then the first false alarm for the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath162 satisfies @xmath163 where the function @xmath118 is defined in ( [ g ] ) . for any @xmath8
, we have @xmath164 \label{r1 } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & = & \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty}\ { t_h \ } + \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty } \bigl\ { \mathbb{e}_{\infty , \ldots,\infty}\bigl\ { t_h^{i } - t_h | \mathcal{f}_{t_h } \bigr\ } \mathbf{1}_{\{t_h^{i } \neq t_h\ } } \bigr\ } , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the third equality follows from the tower property of the conditional expectation and the finiteness of @xmath101 . as in the proof of proposition [ upb ] , we apply it s formula to @xmath165 ( see , e.g. , @xcite , theorem 4.1.2 ) to obtain that @xmath166 where the process @xmath167 is given by ( [ 1dimpr ] ) and the continuous square integrable martingale @xmath168 ( with respect to @xmath41 ) is given by @xmath169 taking into account that the process @xmath167 decreases only on the random set and the measure @xmath170 off this set , together with the fact that @xmath143 , we conclude that the integral in ( [ ito s expansion ] ) can be set equal to zero .
we then take the conditional expectations with respect to the probability measure @xmath41 in ( [ ito s expansion ] ) and by means of the doob s optional sampling theorem ( see , e.g. , @xcite , chapter 1 , theorem 3.22 ) , we have @xmath171 therefore , using equation ( [ ito ] ) in the expression of ( [ r1 ] ) we have that @xmath172 \label{r3 } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & = & \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty}\ { t_h \ } + \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty } \biggl\ { \frac{2}{\mu^2 } \bigl(g(h ) - g\bigl(y^{(i)}_{t_h } \bigr)\bigr ) \mathbf{1}_{\{t_h^{i } \neq t_h\ } } \biggr\ } \nonumber \\ & \leq & \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty}\ { t_h \ } + \frac{2}{\mu^2 } g(h ) \mathbb{p}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty } \bigl ( t_h^{i } \neq t_h \bigr ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the first equality and the function @xmath118 are given by ( [ g ] ) and the third equality follows from the definition of the one - dimensional cusum stopping rule in ( [ cusum1chart ] ) .
it follows that @xmath173 hence , by summing both sides over all @xmath8 , we get @xmath174 which completes the proof of ( [ lbsame ] ) . as a result of proposition [ thm : false_alarm ]
, when @xmath175 for all @xmath8 , for any @xmath72 and any @xmath0-dimensional , predictable , nonsingular , stochastic instantaneous correlation matrix @xmath176 , we can choose the threshold @xmath177 using @xmath178 then we will have @xmath109 .
moreover , proposition [ upb ] implies that , both the optimal detection delay @xmath179 and the detection delay of this @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath180 , are bounded above by @xmath181 . in this case
, it is assumed that all @xmath75 are known and @xmath182 holds for some @xmath155 .
then the monotonicity of function @xmath118 and ( [ hi ] ) imply that @xmath183 , for the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath106 .
when @xmath92 s are all big , the condition ( [ hi ] ) is approximately a linear constraint on @xmath92 s , and hence @xmath184 .
intuitively , with high chances , @xmath185 for @xmath186 will proceed @xmath187 for @xmath188 due to their smaller thresholds .
hence , it is expected that @xmath189 , where the inequality follows from ( [ lbsame ] ) .
below we rigorously show the validness of this heuristic argument .
[ thm : false_alarm_k ] suppose that the drifts @xmath75 of the observation processes @xmath190 , @xmath8 are such that @xmath191 holds .
suppose also that the thresholds @xmath108 satisfy ( [ hi ] ) .
then the mean time to the first false alarm for the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath101 satisfies @xmath192 \label{lbsamek } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & = & \biggl(1-\sum _ { j = k+1}^n\frac{\mu _ j^2}{\mu_1 ^ 2}\frac{g(h_1)}{g(h_{j } ) } \biggr ) \frac{2}{k\mu_1 ^ 2 } g(h_1),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the function @xmath118 is defined in ( [ g ] ) .
let us denote by @xmath193 . for any @xmath188 , following similar arguments to the ones in ( [ r1 ] ) through ( [ r3 ] )
, we have in this case that @xmath194 which implies that @xmath195 on the other hand , for any @xmath186 , we similarly have @xmath196 which implies that @xmath197 summing up both sides of the above inequality for all @xmath186 , we obtain that @xmath198 \label{fal2p } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & = & \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } g(h_1 ) \bigl[1-\mathbb{p}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty}(t_\hbar \neq r_{h_1})\bigr].\end{aligned}\ ] ] however , we also have @xmath199 where we used ( [ eq : bound_prob ] ) in the above inequality .
it follows from ( [ fal2p ] ) and ( [ p2 g ] ) that @xmath200 which completes the proof . as a result of proposition [ thm : false_alarm_k ] , when @xmath201 , then for any @xmath72 and any @xmath0-dimensional , predictable , nonsingular , stochastic instantaneous correlation matrix @xmath176 , we can choose the set of thresholds @xmath108 using ( [ hi ] ) and the transcendental equation @xmath202 \label{inequalh } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad = \biggl(1-\sum _ { j = k+1}^n\frac{\mu_j^2}{\mu_1 ^ 2}\frac{\mathrm{e}^{h_1}-h_1 - 1}{\mathrm{e}^{h_{j}}-h_{j}-1 } \biggr)\frac{2}{k\mu _ 1 ^ 2}\bigl(\mathrm{e}^{h_1}-h_1 - 1\bigr)= \gamma,\end{aligned}\ ] ] then the resulting @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath203 .
again , proposition [ upb ] then implies that , both the optimal detection delay @xmath179 and the detection delay of this @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath121 , are bounded above by @xmath204 . in this case
, it is assumed that only @xmath205 , @xmath17 , are known , and that @xmath206 . without loss of generality , we assume that @xmath207 holds for some @xmath208 .
[ thm : false_alarm_k1 ] suppose that the drifts @xmath75 of the observation processes @xmath190 , @xmath8 are such that @xmath209 holds and @xmath19 $ ] for all @xmath17 .
suppose also that the thresholds @xmath108 satisfy ( [ hi1 ] ) .
then the mean time to the first false alarm for the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath101 satisfies @xmath210 \label{lbsamek1}\\[-12pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad \ge \frac{2}{\sum_{1\le i\le k'}\mu_1(2\overline{\mu}_i-\mu_1 ) } \biggl(1-\sum_{k'+1\le j\le n } \frac { \underline{\mu}_j(2\overline{\mu}_j-\underline{\mu_j})}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \frac{g(h_1)}{g(h_j ) } \biggr ) g(h_1),\hspace*{-23pt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the function @xmath118 is defined in ( [ g ] ) . according to ( [ hi1 ] ) , we have @xmath211 .
let us denote by @xmath212 .
similar ( [ eq : bound_prob ] ) in the proof of proposition [ thm : false_alarm_k1 ] , for any @xmath213 , we have @xmath214 it follows that @xmath215 which implies that @xmath216 \label{eq : bound_prob1 } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & \le & \sum_{k'+1\le j\le n}\frac{\underline{\mu}_j(2\overline{\mu } _
j-\underline{\mu_j})}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \frac{g(h_1)}{g(h_j)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] on the other hand , for any @xmath217 , by it s formula ( see , e.g. , @xcite , theorem 4.1.2 ) we have @xmath218 which implies that @xmath219 summing up both sides of the above inequality for all @xmath217 , we obtain that @xmath220 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad = g(h_1)\bigl[1-\mathbb{p}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty}(t_\hbar\neq r_{h_1})\bigr ] \\ & & \qquad\ge g(h_1 ) \biggl(1-\sum_{k'+1\le j\le n } \frac{\underline{\mu } _
j(2\overline{\mu}_j-\underline{\mu_j})}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \frac { g(h_1)}{g(h_j ) } \biggr ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used ( [ eq : bound_prob1 ] ) in the last step .
the conclusion of the proposition follows immediately . as a result of proposition [ thm : false_alarm_k1 ] ,
when we only known @xmath156 and possible ranges for other drift @xmath75 s , given any @xmath221 and any @xmath0-dimensional , predictable , nonsingular , stochastic instantaneous correlation matrix @xmath176 , we can choose the set of thresholds @xmath108 using ( [ hi1 ] ) and the transcendental equation @xmath222 then the resulting @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath223 .
again , proposition [ upb ] then implies that both the optimal detection delay @xmath179 and the detection delay of this @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath121 , are bounded above by @xmath204 . in this subsection
, we present a robust lower bound for the optimal detection delay @xmath179 .
in fact , we can prove a stronger statement : for any stopping rule @xmath224 , its detection delay @xmath225 , is bounded below by the optimal detection delay in one dimension .
the proof is accomplished by a change of measure argument as in @xcite plus a decomposition formula for the radon nikodym derivative in @xmath0 dimensions .
[ lem : girsanov ] let @xmath226 be the law of the @xmath0-tuple process @xmath227 for the brownian motions defined in ( [ itodynamics ] ) . and
let @xmath228 be the law of the @xmath0-tuple process @xmath229 .
then for all @xmath230 , @xmath231 where @xmath232 is defined in ( [ 1dimpr ] ) and @xmath233 is the stochastic exponential of the local martingale @xmath234 defined in ( [ bt])([wtb ] ) .
moreover , the standard brownian motions driving @xmath234 are independent of @xmath235 .
the proof can be found in the .
[ lemmalb ] for any stopping rule @xmath236 , we have @xmath237 , where @xmath79 satisfies @xmath238 for the function @xmath118 defined in ( [ g ] ) .
let @xmath53 be an arbitrary @xmath56-stopping rule such that @xmath239 holds and observe that @xmath240 where @xmath241 , a.s .
, and @xmath242 is the cusum stopping rule given in ( [ 1dimcusumstop ] ) for some threshold @xmath243 which will be determined later . clearly , @xmath244 is a finite stopping rule . in
what follows , we will demonstrate that for any given @xmath245 , there exists a @xmath246 such that @xmath247 where @xmath248 is chosen so that @xmath249 and the function @xmath118 is given by ( [ g ] ) . because @xmath250 in ( [ ineq2 ] ) can be arbitrarily small , ( [ new index ] ) and ( [ ineq2 ] )
will imply the assertion in the proposition for @xmath251 .
this is in a similar light as in @xcite . by applying it s formula ( see , e.g. , @xcite , theorem 4.1.2 and @xcite ) to @xmath252 and proceed by using similar arguments as in ( [ ito s expansion])([ito ] ) in proposition [ thm : false_alarm ]
, we obtain that , for any fixed @xmath253 , @xmath254 \label{ito 1d } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad = \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \mathbb{e}_{s,\infty,\ldots,\infty } \bigl\ { g\bigl(-y_{t_\nu } ^{(1)}\bigr ) - g\bigl(-y_{s}^{(1 ) } \bigr ) | \mathcal{f}_{s}\bigr\ } { \bf1}_{\{t_\nu \ge s \}}.\\[-18pt ] \nonumber\end{aligned}\]]using girsanov s theorem ( see , e.g. , @xcite , chapter 3 , theorem 5.1 ) and lemma [ lem : girsanov ] at the finite stopping rule @xmath255 for a fixed @xmath256 , we have that @xmath257 \big| \mathcal{f}_{s } \biggr\}\\ & & \quad\qquad{}\times\mathbf{1}_{\{t_\nu \wedge n > s\}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] consider the enlargement of filtration @xmath258 .
then clearly , @xmath259 for all @xmath260 , but on the event @xmath261 , for all @xmath262\subset[0,t_\nu^1]$ ] , we have @xmath263 . by the tower property of conditional expectation , on the event that @xmath264 , @xmath265 \big| \mathcal{f}_{s } \biggr\ } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad = \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty } \biggl\{\mathrm{e}^{u_{t_\nu \wedge n}^{(1 ) } - u_{s}^{(1 ) } } \bigl[g \bigl(-y_{t_\nu\wedge n}^{(1)}\bigr)-g\bigl(-y_{s}^{(1 ) } \bigr)\bigr ] \nonumber \\[-8pt ] \label{girsanov1}\\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & { } \hspace*{47pt}\qquad\quad{}\times \mathbb{e } _ { \infty,\ldots,\infty } \biggl\{\frac{\mathcal{e}(b^{(1)})_{t_\nu \wedge n}}{\mathcal{e}(b^{(1)})_{s } } \big| \mathcal{f}_{s}^a \biggr\ } \big| \mathcal { f}_{s } \biggr\ } \\ & & \qquad = \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty } \bigl\ { \mathrm{e}^{u_{t_\nu \wedge n}^{(1 ) } - u_{s}^{(1 ) } } \bigl[g \bigl(-y_{t_\nu\wedge n}^{(1)}\bigr)-g\bigl(-y_{s}^{(1 ) } \bigr)\bigr ] | \mathcal{f}_{s } \bigr\ } , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last equality is due to the fact that @xmath266 is a @xmath267-exponential martingale [ under assumption equation ( [ eq : nov ] ) ] driven by brownian motions that are independent of @xmath235 ( see lemma [ lem : girsanov ] ) .
similarly , it can be shown that @xmath268 we now let @xmath269 in ( [ girsanov1 ] ) and ( [ girsanov2 ] ) . from the fact that @xmath270 , and the monotonicity of function @xmath271 , we have that @xmath272 and
thus the bounded convergence theorem implies that , on the event @xmath273 , @xmath274 \label{e88g}\\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad = \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty}\bigl\{\mathrm{e}^{u_{t_\nu } ^{(1)}-u_{s}^{(1 ) } } \bigl[g \bigl(-y_{t_\nu}^{(1)}\bigr)-g\bigl(-y_{s}^{(1 ) } \bigr)\bigr ] | \mathcal{f}_{s}\bigr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it follows from ( [ new index ] ) , ( [ ito 1d ] ) , ( [ e88 ] ) and ( [ e88 g ] ) that @xmath275 \label{ineq } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad \ge \mathbb{e}_{s,\infty,\ldots,\infty}\bigl\{(t_\nu - s)^+ | \mathcal{f}_{s}\bigr\}\mathbf{1}_{\{t_\nu > s\ } } \\ & & \qquad= \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2}\mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty}\bigl\{\mathrm{e}^{u_{t_\nu } ^{(1)}-u_{s}^{(1 ) } } \bigl[g\bigl(-y_{t_\nu}^{(1)}\bigr)-g\bigl(-y_{s}^{(1 ) } \bigr)\bigr ] | \mathcal{f}_{s}\bigr\}\mathbf{1}_{\{t_\nu > s\}}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] following the same arguments as in theorem 2 of @xcite , we integrate both sides of the above inequality with respect to @xmath276 for all @xmath277 $ ] and then take the expectation under @xmath41 .
we therefore obtain that @xmath278\bigl(-{d}m_{s}^{(1 ) } \bigr ) \biggr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that the measure @xmath279 is supported on the random set @xmath280 , and that @xmath281 , thus we obtain that @xmath282 g\bigl(-y_{t_\nu } ^{(1 ) } \bigr)\bigr\}.\ ] ] on the other hand , by letting @xmath283 in ( [ ineq ] ) we have that @xmath284 in all , we have that @xmath285 holds .
to relate the detection delay in ( [ ineq3 ] ) to the first false alarm constraint @xmath73 , we use similar arguments as in ( [ ito s expansion])([ito ] ) in proposition [ thm : false_alarm ] , to obtain that @xmath286 by taking the limit as @xmath287 and using monotone convergence theorem , we have that @xmath288 , and @xmath289 , which implies that there exists a large enough @xmath243 , such that @xmath290 holds for any prespecified @xmath245 . now consider the nonnegative function @xmath291 - g(y ) + g(\nu^\star_1)$ ] , using which we trivially have @xmath292 , implying that @xmath293 \label{ineqe } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & \ge & \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty}\bigl\{\mathrm{e}^{y_{t_\nu } ^{(1)}}\bigr\ } g\bigl(- \nu^\star_1\bigr ) -
\frac{\mu_1 ^ 2}{2 } \varepsilon \\ & \ge & \mathbb{e}_{\infty,\ldots,\infty}\bigl\{\mathrm{e}^{y_{t_\nu } ^{(1)}}\bigr\ } \biggl[g \bigl(-\nu^\star_1\bigr ) -
\frac{\mu_1 ^ 2}{2 } \varepsilon \biggr ] , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath294 .
the above inequality in ( [ ineqe ] ) together with ( [ ineq3 ] ) yields ( [ ineq2 ] ) , which completes the proof .
in this section , we demonstrate the asymptotic optimality of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath106 for @xmath108 chosen such that ( [ hi ] ) and either ( [ equalh ] ) or ( [ inequalh ] ) hold , or ( [ hi1 ] ) and ( [ inequalh1 ] ) hold . to this end , we examine the asymptotic behavior of the robust upper and low bounds established in section [ robust ] .
we show that the additional detection delay of @xmath101 over the optimal detection delay remains bounded as the mean time of the first false alarm @xmath73 increases without bound .
let any sufficiently large @xmath72 and recall from section [ robust ] ( in particular propositions [ upb ] and [ lemmalb ] ) that the optimal detection delay in ( [ eqnproblem ] ) is bounded from below and above as @xmath295 where the set of thresholds @xmath248 and @xmath108 is , respectively , determined using @xmath296 and either ( [ hi ] ) together with ( [ equalh ] ) or with ( [ inequalh ] ) , or ( [ hi1 ] ) together with ( [ inequalh1 ] ) , when the drifts sizes @xmath75 are all known and equal or unequal , are different , we do not necessarily require the uniqueness of @xmath108 that solves ( [ hi ] ) and ( [ inequalh ] ) . ] or partially known , respectively .
it is easily seen from result 3 in the appendix of @xcite that , as @xmath297 , @xmath298 moreover , when all the drifts are known and @xmath299 for all @xmath8 , the thresholds @xmath300 for all @xmath8 . using ( [ equalh ] ) and result 3 in the appendix of @xcite we have that , as @xmath297 , @xmath301 \label{up1 } \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } g(-h_1)&=&\frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \biggl(\log \frac{n \mu _ 1 ^ 2}{2}+\log\gamma-1+o(1 ) \biggr).\end{aligned}\ ] ] as a result , we have the following optimality result . [ thm1 ]
assume that the drift sizes are all known and @xmath302 for all @xmath8 .
then for any predictable , nonsingular , stochastic instantaneous correlation matrix covariance matrix @xmath176 , the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath101 defined in algorithm [ ncusum ] , where the set of thresholds @xmath108 is chosen using ( [ hi ] ) and ( [ equalh ] ) , is asymptotically optimal to the problem ( [ eqnproblem ] ) .
more specifically , the difference between the detection delay of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule , @xmath303 , and the optimal detection delay @xmath179 , is bounded above by @xmath304 , as .
the result follows from ( [ ubj ] ) , ( [ lowbound1 ] ) and ( [ up1 ] ) : @xmath305 & \le & \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \biggl(\log\frac{n \mu_1 ^ 2}{2}+\log\gamma- 1 + o(1 ) \biggr ) - \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \biggl(\log\frac{\mu_1 ^ 2}{2}+\log \gamma -1+o(1 ) \biggr ) \\[-2pt ] & = & \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2}\log n+o(1),\end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath297 . on the other hand , in the more general case that the drifts are all known and @xmath306 , using ( [ hi ] ) , ( [ inequalh ] ) and
result 3 in the appendix of @xcite , we obtain that @xmath307 \label{up2 } \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } g(-h_1)&=&\frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \biggl(\log \frac{k \mu _
1 ^ 2}{2}+\log\gamma-1+o(1 ) \biggr).\end{aligned}\ ] ] it follows that we have the following optimality result . [ thm2 ]
assume that the drift sizes are known and @xmath308 .
then for any predictable , nonsingular , stochastic instantaneous correlation matrix @xmath176 , the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath101 defined in algorithm [ ncusum ] , where the set of thresholds @xmath108 is chosen using ( [ hi ] ) and ( [ inequalh ] ) , is asymptotically optimal to the problem ( [ eqnproblem ] ) .
more specifically , the difference between the detection delay of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule , @xmath121 , and the optimal detection delay @xmath179 , is bounded above by @xmath309 , as @xmath297 .
in particular , if @xmath310 , then @xmath101 is equivalent to the optimal solution to ( [ eqnproblem ] ) asymptotically .
the result follows from ( [ ubj ] ) , ( [ lowbound1 ] ) and ( [ up2 ] ) : @xmath311 & \le&\frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \biggl(\log\frac{k \mu_1 ^ 2}{2}+\log\gamma- 1 + o(1 ) \biggr ) - \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } \biggl(\log\frac{\mu_1 ^ 2}{2}+\log \gamma -1+o(1 ) \biggr ) \\[-2pt ] & = & \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2}\log k+o(1),\end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath297 . if @xmath310 , the above upper bound for @xmath312 is @xmath313 , and hence , the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule is equivalent to the optimal solution to ( [ eqnproblem ] ) asymptotically . finally ,
if we only know @xmath156 and have partial information about other drifts , that is , @xmath314 $ ] for all @xmath17 and @xmath315 for some @xmath316 . using ( [ hi1 ] ) , ( [ inequalh1 ] ) and
result 3 in the appendix of @xcite , we obtain that @xmath317 \label{up22 } \frac{2}{\mu_1 ^ 2 } g(-h_1)&=&\frac{2}{\mu_1
^ 2 } \biggl(\log \frac{\sum_{1\le i\le k'}\mu_1(2\overline{\mu}_i-\mu_1)}{2}+\log\gamma-1+o(1 ) \biggr).\end{aligned}\ ] ] it follows that we have the following optimality result . [ thm3 ]
assume that the @xmath156 is known , @xmath318 $ ] for all @xmath17 and that @xmath319 for some @xmath320
. then for any predictable , nonsingular , stochastic instantaneous correlation matrix @xmath176 , the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule @xmath101 defined in algorithm [ ncusum ] , where the set of thresholds @xmath108 is chosen using ( [ hi1 ] ) and ( [ inequalh1 ] ) , is asymptotically optimal to the problem ( [ eqnproblem ] ) .
more specifically , the difference between the detection delay of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule , @xmath121 , and the optimal detection delay @xmath179 , is bounded above by @xmath321 as @xmath297 .
in particular , if @xmath322 , then @xmath101 is equivalent to the optimal solution to ( [ eqnproblem ] ) asymptotically .
the result follows from ( [ ubj ] ) , ( [ lowbound1 ] ) and ( [ up22 ] ) : @xmath323 as @xmath297 .
if @xmath322 , the above upper bound for @xmath312 is @xmath313 , and hence , the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule is equivalent to the optimal solution to ( [ eqnproblem ] ) asymptotically . from definition [ optdef
] , we know that the order of the asymptotic optimality achieved in theorems [ thm1 ] , [ thm2 ] , [ thm3 ] is of the second order . if @xmath156 is strictly smaller than all the other drifts ( @xmath310 in theorem [ thm2 ] and @xmath322 in theorem [ thm3 ] ) , then the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule given by algorithm [ ncusum ] , and either ( [ hi ] ) and ( [ inequalh ] ) , or ( [ hi1 ] ) and ( [ inequalh1 ] ) exhibits third - order asymptotic optimality .
moreover , it can be seen after a perusal of the proofs that the order of the asymptotic optimality of the @xmath0-cusum does not change if we model @xmath75 s as @xmath267-adapted processes bounded by known constants @xmath324 and @xmath325 , for all @xmath17 .
in this section , we discuss one of the applications of the results in decentralized communication systems .
let us now suppose that each of the observation processes @xmath326 become sequentially available at a particular location monitored by sensor @xmath91 , which then employs an asynchronous communication scheme to a central fusion center .
in particular , sensor @xmath91 communicates to the central fusion center only when it wants to signal an alarm , which is elicited according to a cusum stopping rule @xmath89 as in ( [ cusum1chart ] ) adapted to the small filtration @xmath327 .
the observations received at the @xmath0 sensors can change dynamics at distinct unknown points @xmath69 .
an example of such a case is described in @xcite where the motivation suggested arises in the health - monitoring of mechanical , civil and aeronautic structures .
the fusion center , whose objective is to detect the first time when there is a change in at least one of the sensors devises a minimal strategy ; that is , it declares that a change has occurred at the first instance when one of the sensors communicates an alarm .
the implication of the main theorems in section [ asympt ] is that in fact this strategy is the best , at least asymptotically , in that there is no loss in performance , between the case in which the fusion center receives the raw data @xmath328 summarized in the large filtration @xmath329 directly and the case in which the communication that takes place is limited to the decentralized setup . in other words , the cusum stopping rule @xmath101 is a sufficient statistic ( at least asymptotically ) of the minimum @xmath0 possibly distinct change points .
that is , the stopping rule @xmath101 is an asymptotically optimal solution to the problems of quickest detection presented in ( [ eqnproblem ] ) . in practice sensors
are cheap and easy to replace devices whereas central fusion centers or central processing units are not .
transferring most of the processing work to the sensors while incurring no loss in the efficiency of the system is thus valuable and can render cost and speed effective communication systems .
in this paper , we study the problem of detecting the minimum of @xmath0 different change points in a @xmath0-dimensional brownian system with partial information of the drifts and an arbitrary , predictable , nonsingular , stochastic instantaneous correlation matrix @xmath176 .
it is shown that , under an extended lorden s minmax criterion , the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule exhibits asymptotic optimality in the tradeoff between detection delay and false alarms , as the mean time to the first false alarm increases without bound . moreover ,
the performance of the @xmath0-cusum stopping rule under dependence is _ no worse than _ that under independence @xcite .
this optimality result is obtained by establishing a robust upper bound and a robust lower bound for the optimal detection delay .
the contribution of this work can be seen in two folds .
first , we designed a low complexity , efficient stopping rule without using the explicit information of the covariance matrix @xmath176 .
this stopping rule is guaranteed to have a comparable performance or identical performance as the optimal stopping rule , even with cross - correlated observations a nontrivial extension to the existing literature and the first formal treatment of correlated noise in change - point detection .
second , the robust bounds obtained in this work provide a unified robust probabilistic ( rather than analytical ) approach to treat detection problems with multiple change - points or multiple alternatives @xcite .
this is especially useful when the analytical characteristic such as joint density or green functions are not explicitly available .
let us denote by @xmath330 the @xmath331 matrix obtained from @xmath176 by removing its first column and first row , and by @xmath332 the @xmath331 matrix @xmath333 .
we further introduce a local martingale @xmath334 \label{bt}\\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \hspace*{34pt}{}\times \bigl(\sqrt { 1-\bigl(\rho_s^{2,1}\bigr)^2}\,{d}\tilde { w}_s^{(2 ) } , \ldots , \sqrt{1-\bigl ( \rho_s^{n,1}\bigr)^2}\,{d}\tilde { w}_s^{(n ) } \bigr ) ' , \\
\label{wtb } \tilde{w}_t^{(i)}&= & \int _ 0^t\frac{{d}w_s^{(i)}-\rho_s^{i,1}\,{d}w_s^{(1)}}{\sqrt{1-(\rho _ s^{i,1})^2 } } , \qquad 2\le i\le n.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the local martingale @xmath335 will naturally appear in ( [ eq : last ] ) of the following proof .
we are now ready to prove the assertion in lemma [ lem : girsanov ] .
proof of lemma [ lem : girsanov ] since @xmath176 is nonsingular at all time a.s .
, we can use a cholesky decomposition to obtain a lower triangular , nonsingular matrix - valued process @xmath336 , and a @xmath0-dimensional standard brownian motion @xmath337 , such that @xmath338 holds .
in particular , we have @xmath339 , @xmath340 , and @xmath341 for all @xmath342 . using girsanov s theorem ( see , e.g. , @xcite , chapter 3 , theorem 5.1 ) and the condition in ( [ eq : nov ] )
, the measure changes from @xmath343 to @xmath228 is given by the exponential martingale @xmath344 where @xmath345 is a @xmath0-tuple process , such that @xmath346 it is easily seen that @xmath347 .
moreover , from @xmath341 for any @xmath348 , we know that @xmath349 where @xmath350 is a @xmath351 nonsingular matrix - valued process . on the other hand , notice that @xmath352 \label{n2}\\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad=(\tilde{l}_t)^{-1 } \bigl({d}w_t^{(2)}-\rho_{t}^{2,1}\,{d}w_t^{(1 ) } , \ldots , { d}w_t^{(n)}- \rho _ { t}^{n,1}\,{d}w_t^{(1 ) } \bigr)'.\hspace*{-6pt } \ ] ] using the equations in ( [ n1 ] ) and ( [ n2 ] ) , we conclude that @xmath353 & & \qquad = \int_0^t\nu_s^{(1 ) } \,{d}z_s^{(1)}+\int_0^t \bigl(\nu_s^{(2)},\ldots , \nu_s^{(n ) } \bigr ) \bigl({d}z_s^{(2)},\ldots , { d}z_s^{(n ) } \bigr ) ' \nonumber \\[-2pt ] & & \qquad = \mu_1 w_t^{(1)}-\mu_1\int _ 0^t\bigl(\rho_s^{2,1 } , \ldots,\rho _
s^{n,1}\bigr ) \bigl(\tilde { l}_s ' \bigr)^{-1}(\tilde{l}_s)^{-1}\nonumber\\[-2pt ] & & \label{eq : last } \qquad\qquad\hspace*{60pt } { } \times \bigl({d}w_s^{(2)}-\rho _ { s}^{2,1}\,{d}w_s^{(1 ) } , \ldots , { d}w_s^{(n)}- \rho_{s}^{n,1}\,{d}w_s^{(1 ) } \bigr ) ' \\[-2pt ] & & \qquad=\mu_1 w_t^{(1)}-\mu_1\int _ 0^t\bigl(\rho_s^{2,1 } , \ldots,\rho _
s^{n,1}\bigr ) \bigl(\sigma _
\tilde{\sigma}_s^1\bigr)^{-1}\nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{60pt}\qquad\qquad{}\times \bigl(\sqrt { 1-\bigl(\rho_s^{2,1}\bigr)^2}\,{d}\tilde { w}_s^{(2 ) } , \ldots , \sqrt{1-\bigl ( \rho_s^{n,1}\bigr)^2}\,{d}\tilde { w}_s^{(n ) } \bigr ) ' \nonumber \\[-2pt ] & & \qquad=\mu_1 w_t^{(1)}+b_t^{(1 ) } , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the third equality follows from the fact that @xmath354 holds ( see accompanying internet supplement ) .
finally , by the way we construct @xmath335 , we know that the brownian motions that drive @xmath335 and @xmath235 are independent and this completes the proof .
the authors are grateful to the editor and anonymous referees for their comments contributing to the improvement of this manuscript . | we study a wiener disorder problem of detecting the minimum of @xmath0 change - points in @xmath0 observation channels coupled by correlated noises . it is assumed that the observations in each dimension can have different strengths and that the change - points may differ from channel to channel .
the objective is the quickest detection of the minimum of the @xmath0 change - points .
we adopt a min
max approach and consider an extended lorden s criterion , which is minimized subject to a constraint on the mean time to the first false alarm .
it is seen that , under partial information of the post - change drifts and a general nonsingular stochastic correlation structure in the noises , the minimum of @xmath0 cumulative sums ( cusum ) stopping rules is asymptotically optimal as the mean time to the first false alarm increases without bound .
we further discuss applications of this result with emphasis on its implications to the efficiency of the decentralized versus the centralized systems of observations which arise in engineering .
./style / arxiv - general.cfg , |
to fulfill the requirement of high - precision quantum gates , teleportation , or state transfer , the aim of quantum state engineering ( qse ) @xcite is to manipulate the system and attain a target state , typically a pure state , at a designed time @xmath0 ; or more ambitiously , to drive the eigenstates of an initial hamiltonian into those of a final hamiltonian @xcite . to be concrete , for a two - level system
, a passage is constructed through which the system undergoes a transition from an initial state @xmath1 to a final state @xmath2 , with @xmath3 , in an undisturbed way . in a closed - system scenario ,
qse has been considered through time optimal evolution @xcite and robust protocols of realizing qse have been provided by adiabatic passages @xcite and by sequential convex programming @xcite . however , for open systems @xcite , which are under environmental noise due to the onset of the system - bath dynamics @xcite , qse is significantly challenged in both theoretical and experimental implementations . indeed , for decohering systems
, there is a competition between the time required for adiabaticity and the decoherence time scales @xcite , which may limit the applicability of the adiabatic approach @xcite .
identifying protocols that are both fast and fault - tolerant is therefore an important research direction for quantum information processing and quantum control @xcite .
a non - adiabatic approach for qse @xcite , originally defined in the context of closed systems , is the inverse engineering control based on lewis - riesenfeld invariants @xcite . in this approach ,
the quantum dynamics is dictated by a dynamical invariant @xmath4 , which is an operator defined through the von neumann equation , @xmath5=0 $ ] ( setting @xmath6 ) . by denoting the instantaneous eigenbasis of @xmath4 as an orthonormal set @xmath7 , the method of quantum control by invariants first considers the initial state @xmath1 to be one of the eigenstates of @xmath4 ,
say @xmath8 , and the target state to be @xmath9 .
the operator @xmath4 is then designed to conveniently interpolate between @xmath8 and @xmath9 . in particular , the von neumann equation implies that @xmath10 , where @xmath11 denotes the time evolution operator .
then , @xmath11 will satisfy @xmath12 , i.e. a system that is initially prepared in a given eigenlevel of @xmath4 will be kept in the corresponding instantaneous eigenlevel for any time @xmath0 , yielding a non - transitional evolution .
hence , qse by inverse control can be implemented by obtaining a desired evolution operator @xmath11 from @xmath4 , which will give rise in a further step to a time - dependent control hamiltonian able to physically generate the engineered target state @xmath9 at time @xmath0 .
the aim of this work is to propose a scheme to investigate qse by inverse control in presence of decoherence .
this strategy is different from the usual techniques of protecting the system against the external environmental noise through fast pulse sequences , such as bang - bang control @xcite and optimal control @xcite .
moreover , it is also distinct from the direct kinematic controllability of open quantum systems @xcite .
the starting point of our framework is the observation that the von neumann equation implies that the density operator @xmath13 is a lewis - riesenfeld invariant by itself .
indeed , @xmath13 satisfies the same equation of motion as @xmath4 , namely , @xmath14=0 $ ] .
then , @xmath4 and @xmath13 share the same eigenbasis @xmath7 , and @xmath15 where @xmath16 is an arbitrary initial density matrix . for the evolution operator @xmath11
, we obtain @xmath17
. therefore , @xmath13 and @xmath11 are mutually equivalent to each other without considering the lewis - riesenfeld phase @xcite .
hence , the procedure is firstly to get the dynamics of the system as expressed by the time evolution operator @xmath11 . as a second step ,
we inversely obtain the hamiltonian @xmath18 .
noise is then introduced through stochastic fluctuations in the hamiltonian of the system .
such fluctuations will be identified according to specific quantum channels @xcite , which are physically defined as some special pipelines intended to carry quantum information through an open quantum system . in particular , we find the conditions in which the rapid and robust state passage or population transfer could be realized and those in which the qse ends up with a mixed state .
we start from a general time evolution operator for a two - level system , @xmath19 where @xmath20 represents the vector of pauli operator and @xmath21 denotes a unit vector in space .
the hamiltonian could be expressed as @xcite @xmath22.\end{aligned}\ ] ] consider a general unit vector @xmath23 , and substitute it into eq .
( [ h ] ) , then the hamiltonian reads @xmath24 \\ { \nonumber}&+ & { \sigma}_z[-\dot{\theta}\sin\alpha\sin\beta \\ { \nonumber}&-&\dot{\alpha}\sin\theta(\cos\theta\cos\alpha\sin\beta-\sin\theta\cos\beta ) \\
\label{h1 } & -&\dot{\beta}\sin\theta\sin\alpha(\cos\theta\cos\beta + \sin\theta\cos\alpha\sin\beta)].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the hamiltonian @xmath25 in eq .
( [ h1 ] ) is an explicit function of six variables , namely , @xmath26 . in particular , @xmath25 is linear in the variables @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 , and nonlinear in the variables @xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 . within an open - system dynamics ,
any of these variables could be associated with a source of stochastic noise , e.g. the semi - classical dephasing model @xcite .
we will be interested here in the fluctuations of the linear variables . for the sake of simplicity , we will take @xmath33 to illustrate our theory . in this case ,
@xmath25 and @xmath34 read @xmath35 in the absence of noise , when the system is prepared as @xmath36 , it will evolve into @xmath37 which is equivalent to a pure state @xmath38 . here
@xmath39 and @xmath40 represent the two eigenvectors of @xmath41 , with eigenvalues @xmath42 and @xmath43 , respectively .
besides the consistency condition @xmath44 , there is almost no limit on the choices of functions @xmath45 and @xmath46 for engineering the system to reach an arbitrary target state @xmath47 at arbitrary time @xmath0 , as long as @xmath48 and @xmath49 .
for example , if @xmath50 , then a simple choice is @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 .
this control dynamics allows for a target state achieved at an optimal time @xmath0 compatible with the brachistochrone solution @xcite . by adding decoherence to the system ,
the passage described above is not always attainable . in order to develop a protocol for qse under the effect of decoherence
, we will individually consider the special family of hamiltonians given by eq .
( [ h2 ] ) under the effect of stochastic fluctuations over the linear variables @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
a more general setup could be considered by investigating the cases of correlated noise or the noise attached to the nonlinear variables of the hamiltonian . in any case
, the approach introduced in this work can also be generalized to these situations . in presence of noise ,
the density matrix @xmath13 at time @xmath54 can be evaluated by the ensemble average over different realizations of time evolution operator with fluctuating parameters due to noise , i.e. @xmath55 , \label{ensemble}\ ] ] where @xmath56 $ ] denotes ensemble average , @xmath57 the noise parameter , and @xmath58 the instantaneous time evolution operator ( [ ut ] ) .
to evaluate the quality of qse under the effect of noise , we adopt the control fidelity , which is defined by @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the engineered state without noise .
the non - unitary dynamics implied by eq .
( [ ensemble ] ) can be identified with different quantum channels . by identifying prototypical quantum channels
, we can illustrate the state preparation by the inverse engineering procedure .
suppose @xmath27 is not a stable variable , i.e. @xmath61 , where @xmath62 is chosen as gaussian noise .
then , ensemble average yields @xmath63=a(t)+\xi_0 $ ] and @xmath64=g(t , s)$ ] . here
@xmath65 is the mean value ( or the bias ) of @xmath62 .
when @xmath66 , the noise is categorized into a non - biased noise .
the quantity @xmath67 is the correlation function for the non - biased gaussian noise . in order to compute the mean value over eq .
( [ ut ] ) , all of the terms involving @xmath31 are kept unchanged , but @xmath68=e^{-\frac{1}{2}\int_0^tg(s)ds}e^{\pm i[\alpha_0(t)+\xi_0t]}$ ] , where @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
therefore the density matrix is @xmath71}}{2 } \\
\frac{-i\sin(2\theta)re^{i[\alpha_0(t)+\xi_0t]}}{2 } & \frac{1+\cos(2\theta)}{2 } \end{array}\right),\ ] ] where @xmath72 is a time - dependent noise factor determined by the noise correlation function .
for any stationary noise , @xmath73 .
we observe that this stochastic fluctuation over @xmath27 induces a purely dephasing process , i.e. the diagonal terms are not influenced by noise and the off - diagonal terms are damped at the same rate in the density matrix , which will end up with a mixed state @xmath74 in the asymptotic time limit .
if we use @xmath75 to represent the initial density matrix free of noise , as given by eq .
( [ ut ] ) , then eq . ( [ ma ] )
can be expressed in kraus operator - sum representation @xcite for a qubit under dephasing , @xmath76 , where @xmath77 $ ] and @xmath78 $ ] .
@xmath79 $ ] represents the diagonal matrix . concerning the control fidelity , the evaluation of eq .
( [ fidelity ] ) yields @xmath80 in this model , the control fidelity is sensitive to the target state .
in particular , @xmath81 , i.e. it is increased by decreasing @xmath31 , @xmath82 . also the noise bias @xmath83 deteriorates the fidelity , unless the time @xmath0 chosen to arrive the target state satisfies @xmath84 . remarkably , the result with noise is meaningful for pure state control . when the target state is @xmath40 , it is still achievable at time @xmath0 as long as @xmath85 , @xmath86 .
thus a complete population inversion @xcite could be realized , which is robust to the dephasing noise from @xmath27 .
on the other hand , for @xmath66 and @xmath87 representing a slowly varying function of time , we can still attain a target state with high fidelity in a short time @xmath0 .
for instance , suppose @xmath88 , which corresponds to markovian white noise , with @xmath89 and @xmath90 denoting the coupling strength with the environment .
at the same time , suppose that it is required that @xmath91 , a threshold value for quantum information processing .
then , @xmath0 must be less than a critical time @xmath92 , which is given by @xmath93.\ ] ] if @xmath94 and @xmath95 , then @xmath96 . for rydberg atoms in a cavity or electron spins in quantum dots @xcite , we have @xmath97 and @xmath98 .
it is indeed a very hard challenge to the external control time - dependent fields , such as laser pulse sequences .
however , if the noise is not a markovian white noise , then the time for qse would be greatly extended .
here we use the ornstein - uhlenbeck process with the correlation function @xmath99 , to demonstrate the effect of non - markovian noise , where the time - dependent damping function is @xmath100/4\}$ ] .
when @xmath101 , @xmath87 reduces to the exponential decay function as that in the case of markovian noise . on the other hand , for
@xmath102 , the decay rate of @xmath103 is intensively suppressed , which means the fidelity maintains a value very close to unity in a much longer time interval . in fig .
[ fa ] , we plot the dynamics of the control fidelity under the ornstein - uhlenbeck noise .
figure [ fa1 ] shows the effect of @xmath104 with a fixed value of @xmath105 , i.e. @xmath94 . in a strong non - markovian regime @xmath106
, the fidelity could be kept not less than @xmath107 until @xmath108 , i.e. @xmath109 for atoms in a cavity , which is almost @xmath110 times as what we get with the markov noise .
figure [ fa2 ] shows the fidelity dependence on different target state with @xmath111 . for a target state @xmath112 , the population at the high - level @xmath40 is @xmath113 that is monotonic in this scale . yet
the plot is symmetric with respect to @xmath114 , where the survival time for high fidelity qse takes a minimal value .
this means that the difficulty in the state control is not proportional to the state population . in this model
, it is assumed that @xmath115 . by employing the same notation as in the previous analysis ,
we obtain , after ensemble average , that the density matrix is given by @xmath116}{2 } & \frac{ir^4\sin[2\theta_0(t)+2\xi_0t]e^{-i\alpha}}{2 } \\
\frac{-ir^4\sin[2\theta_0(t)+2\xi_0t]e^{i\alpha}}{2 } & \frac{1+r^4\cos[2\theta_0(t)+2\xi_0t]}{2 } \end{array}\right),\ ] ] where @xmath117
. the final state of @xmath13 is the most mixed state @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is the identity matrix .
subsequently , the fidelity is @xmath120},\ ] ] which means that , in this model , the fidelity is independent of the choice of target state .
this is a dramatic difference between the noises induced by @xmath28 and @xmath27 .
dynamics under a non - markovian depolarization noise ( @xmath66 ) with different @xmath104 ( in the unit of frequency ) .
, width=288 ] when @xmath66 , the external noise in @xmath28 induces a standard depolarization quantum channel @xcite for the open system , since under influence of the noise , @xmath121 , where the kraus operators are @xmath122 , @xmath123 , @xmath124 , @xmath125 .
here @xmath103 measures the probability that the system is undisturbed by the noise .
note that this process constitutes a novel quantum microscopic model for depolarization dynamics . when @xmath83 , there is a subtle aspect left for the initial state preparation .
indeed , in eq .
( [ ut ] ) , @xmath36 means @xmath126 for closed systems .
however , for open systems , the initial state is chosen as @xmath127=\sin\xi_0\neq0 $ ] in presence of noise .
this can be resolved by measuring the noise bias through a spectroscopy analysis in an experimental implementation . by taking a markovian noise with @xmath88 and @xmath66 , the critical time @xmath92 for control
is @xmath128 if @xmath95 , then @xmath129 , which is valid for an arbitrary target state .
the control fidelity under the non - markovian depolarization noise is demonstrated in fig .
when @xmath106 , the fidelity could be maintained as @xmath107 until @xmath130 , i.e. @xmath131 for atoms in a cavity , which is about @xmath132 times as that in the case of white noise . a comparison of eqs
( [ falpha ] ) and ( [ ftheta ] ) shows that the depolarization noise plays a more severe role on destroying qse . in principle , there is no chance to perfectly attain an arbitrary pure target state or realize a perfect population transfer with depolarization noise even in the non - markovian regime .
a first important observation is that , for either dephasing induced by @xmath27 or depolarization induced by @xmath28 , the category description of quantum channel for two - level systems holds irrespectively to the statistical properties of the noise .
distinct noises defined by different correlation functions will lead to different damping functions @xmath87 , which will determine the control fidelity .
concerning the critical fidelity , for a quantum system embedded into a non - markovian environment , @xmath87 could be preserved to nearly unity for a long time .
therefore , non - markovianity is a useful tool to achieve a suitable control in qse .
moreover , this universal inverse qse inverse protocol for two - level systems can be extended straightforwardly into higher - dimensional systems .
consider the stimulated raman adiabatic passage ( stirap ) @xcite in a three - level atomic system , which targets on the population transition between @xmath39 and @xmath133 without disturbing the quasi - stable state @xmath40 .
the eigenbasis could be chosen as @xmath134 , @xmath135 , and @xmath136 .
assume @xmath137 .
then @xmath34 and @xmath25 are obtained as @xmath138 as expected , it demonstrates that the linear parameters of hamiltonian are @xmath139 and @xmath28 .
if the system is prepared as @xmath36 , then @xmath140 in case of a closed system .
that would be an ideal stirap . yet , with linear noise @xmath115 ( here we choose @xmath66 ) , the density matrix becomes @xmath141}{2 } & 0 & \frac{-r^4\sin[2\theta_0(t)]}{2 } \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \\ \frac{-r^4\sin[2\theta_0(t)]}{2 } & 0 & \frac{1+r^4\cos[2\theta_0(t)]}{2 } \end{array}\right),\ ] ] which is almost the same as eq .
( [ dep ] ) with @xmath142 , i.e. it is also a depolarization process .
then the control fidelity is given by @xmath143 , which means the noise will definitely destroy the perfect qse .
however , beyond the stirap , if the state is prepared as @xmath40 and the target state is @xmath144 , the fidelity under the _ same _ noise is @xmath145 , which is independent of both the target state and @xmath146 . when @xmath147 , @xmath148 could approach unity , meaning that now the qse is robust against the @xmath28 noise . in comparison with other recent markovian approaches to deal with decoherence due to weak system - bath interactions @xcite
, our inverse qse method has no limitation on the correlation function of the errors in the system parameters , which can imply in more general sources of environmental noises , such as non - markovian evolutions and strong system - bath interactions . in this scenario ,
pure dephasing and depolarization appear as two important quantum channels associated with the fluctuations in the linear parameters of the engineered hamiltonian , but other sources of errors could be considered .
moreover , following the strategy presented in this section , systems with more than two or three levels could be investigated .
in conclusion , we have investigated decoherence in the linear parameters of the hamiltonians of two - level and three - level open quantum systems , discussing its consequences for inverse qse protocol .
exact results have been expressed by different standard quantum channels , each of them imposing different restrictions on the control fidelity .
non - markovian noise is found to be helpful to attain a high fidelity state passage for a much longer time than the markov white noise .
generalization of our approach for other higher - dimensional systems is a promising route to reveal more abundant relations between control and noise .
we acknowledge grant support from the nsfc no .
11175110 , the basque government ( grant it472 - 10 ) , the spanish micinn ( projects no .
fis2012 - 36673-c03 - 01 and -03 ) , the upv / ehu program ufi 11/55 - 01 - 2013 , the brazilian agencies cnpq , faperj , and the brazilian national institute for science and technology of quantum information ( inct - iq ) .
p. zanardi and m. rasetti , , 94 ( 1999 ) ; e. farhi _ et al .
_ , science * 292 * , 472 ( 2001 ) ; l .- m .
duan , j. i. cirac , and p. zoller , , 1695 ( 2001 ) ; j. j. garca - ripoll and j. i. cirac , , 127902 ( 2003 ) ; d. bacon and s. t. flammia , , 120504 ( 2009 ) ; d. bacon and s. t. flammia , , 030303 ( 2010 ) ; a. del campo , m. m. rams , and w. h. zurek , , 115703 ( 2012 ) ; s.
oh _ et al . _ , , 022332 ( 2013 ) .
et al . _ , , 063002 ( 2010 ) ; x. chen , e. torrontegui , and j. g. muga , , 062116 ( 2011 ) ; y. li , l. -a .
wu , and z. d. wang , , 043804 ( 2011 ) ; a. ruschhaupt , x. chen , d. alonso , and j. g. muga , new j. phys .
14 , 093040 ( 2012 ) ; x .- j . lu _
et al . _ , , 033406 ( 2013 ) . | we propose a scheme for inverse engineering control in open quantum systems . starting from an undetermined time evolution operator ,
a time - dependent hamiltonian is derived in order to guide the system to attain an arbitrary target state at a predefined time .
we calculate the fidelity of our inverse engineering control protocol in presence of the noise with respect to the stochastic fluctuation of the linear parameters of the hamiltonian during the time evolution . for a special family of hamiltonians for two - level systems , we show that the control evolution of the system under noise can be categorized into two standard decohering processes : dephasing and depolarization , for both markovian and non - markovian conditions .
in particular , we illustrate our formalism by analysing the robustness of the engineered target state against errors .
moreover , we discuss the generalization of the inverse protocol for higher - dimensional systems . |
axions are likely to be the dark matter ( dm ) that cosmological data require .
axions arise from the solution of the strong @xmath1 problem proposed by peccei & quinn in 1977 ( @xcite , pq hereafter ) , who suggested that @xmath2 parameter , in the effective lagrangian term @xmath3 ( @xmath4 : strong coupling constant , @xmath5 : gluon field tensor ) , causing @xmath1 violations in strong interactions , is a dynamical variable . under suitable conditions @xmath2 approaches zero in our epoch , so that the term ( [ eq : n1 ] ) is suppressed , while residual @xmath2 oscillations yield dm @xcite . in the pq scheme ,
@xmath2 is the phase of a complex field @xmath6 ; its evolution is set by the potential @xmath7 ^ 2 ~ , \label{eq : n2}\ ] ] whose @xmath8 invariance breaks when @xmath9 ( the pq energy scale , which shall be @xmath10gev )
. then @xmath11 settles at the potential minimum , while @xmath2 takes a random value , different in different horizons . when chiral symmetry also breaks down , during the quark
hadron transition , a further term @xmath12
~(1 - \cos \theta ) \label{eq : n3}\ ] ] must be added to the lagrangian , because of instanton effects . at @xmath13 ,
the square bracket approaches @xmath14 ( @xmath15 , @xmath16 : @xmath17meson mass , decay constant ) .
the dependence on the site of initial @xmath2 s will causes later adjustments , as soon as the potential ( [ eq : n3 ] ) switches on .
when @xmath2 is small , @xmath18 and the @xmath19 field , undergoing harmonic oscillations , is dm .
0.05truecm here we wish to discuss recent work [ 4 ] , where the ng potential ( [ eq : n2 ] ) is replaced by a tracker potential @xcite .
then , instead of settling on a value @xmath20 , @xmath11 continues to evolve over cosmological times , at any @xmath21 . as in the pq case ,
the potential involves a complex field @xmath22 and is @xmath8 invariant .
its phase is horizon dependent but , just as in the pq case , evolves only after chiral symmetry breaks , yielding a term similar to ( [ eq : n3 ] ) . at variance from the pq case
, however , the @xmath2 evolution starts and continues while also @xmath11 is still evolving .
this goes on until our epoch , when @xmath11 is expected to account for dark energy ( de ) , while , superimposed to such slow evolution , faster _ transversal _
@xmath2 oscillations occur , accounting for dm .
this scheme , where the @xmath22 fields bears a dual role , with its modulus and phase , will be dubbed here _ dual _ axion model .
the question is whether @xmath11 and @xmath2 dynamics interfere , still allowing @xmath2 to take values so small to solve the @xmath1 problem and preserving harmonic oscillations allowing the prescribed amount of dm .
here we show that the reply is positive .
as it can be expected , however , dm and de are dynamically coupled , although this coupling weakens as we approach the present era . here
we also consider a generalization of the sugra potential @xcite as an example of tracker potential . with an energy scale @xmath23gev
, this model allows suitable values for today s dm and de densities , while @xmath2 is even smaller than for pq .
dm density fluctuations are also able to grow and to account for the observed large scale structure .
we fit the expected angular cbr spectra to data , finding that this model substantially performs as well as @xmath24cdm .
in the dual - axion model we start from the lagrangian @xmath25 which can be rewritten in terms of @xmath11 and @xmath2 , adding also the term breaking the @xmath8 symmetry , as follows : .3truecm @xmath26 - $ ] @xmath27 .3truecm here @xmath28 is the metric tensor .
we shall assume that @xmath29 , so that @xmath30 is the scale factor , @xmath31 is the conformal time ; greek ( latin ) indeces run from 0 to 3 ( 1 to 3 ) ; dots indicate differentiation in respect to @xmath31 .
the mass behavior for @xmath32 will be detailed in section 3 .
the equations of motion read @xmath33 -.8truecm @xmath34 while the energy densities @xmath35 and pressures @xmath36 , under the condition @xmath37 , are obtainable from @xmath38
according to eq . ( [ eq : m3 ] ) , the axion field begins to oscillate when @xmath39 . in the dual axion model ,
just as for pq , axions become massive when the chiral symmetry is broken by the formation of the @xmath40 condensate at @xmath32 . around such @xmath21 , therefore , the axion mass grows rapidly . in the dual axion model , however , a slower growth takes place also later , because of the evolution of @xmath11 .
then @xmath41 is @xmath42 since @xmath43 today , the axion mass is now @xmath44ev , while , according to @xcite , at high @xmath45 @xmath46 this expression must be interpolated with eq .
( [ eq : o2 ] ) , to study the fluctuation onset for @xmath32 .
we solved the equations of section 2 by assuming @xmath47 with @xmath48 . with the selected value ,
when @xmath49 , @xmath41 already approaches its low@xmath21 behavior @xmath50 .
let us finally outline that eqs .
( [ eq : o2 ] ) and ( [ eq : o3 ] ) , as well as the above interpolation , show that @xmath51 is @xmath11independent , as is required to obtain the equation of motion ( [ eq : m4 ] ) .
fig.([fig : mass ] ) shows the ( low)@xmath52 dependence of @xmath50 .
variations cause a dependence of the effective axion mass on scale factor @xmath30 , which is shown here.,title="fig : " ] -3.2truecm notice the rebounce at @xmath53 , whose impact on halo formation could be critical @xcite .
when @xmath2 performs many oscillations within a hubble time , then @xmath54 and @xmath55 . by using eqs .
( [ eq : m3]),([eq : m4]),([eq : kp ] ) , it is easy to see that @xmath56 when @xmath57 is given by eq ( [ eq : o3 ] ) , @xmath58 . at @xmath59 , instead , @xmath60 . here below , the indices @xmath61 , @xmath62 will be replaced by @xmath63 .
( [ eq : m7 ] ) show an energy exchange between dm and de . the former eq .
( [ eq : m7 ] ) can then be integrated , yielding @xmath64 .
this law holds also when @xmath65 , and then the usual behavior @xmath66 is modified , becoming @xmath67 let us now assume that the potential reads @xmath68 ( no @xmath2 dependence ) ; in the radiative era , it will then be @xmath69 with @xmath70 .
this tracker solution holds until we approach the quark
hadron transition .
then , in eq .
( [ eq : m4 ] ) , the de dm coupling term , @xmath71 , exceeds @xmath72 and we enter a different tracking regime .
this is shown in detail in fig.([fig : rho ] ) , -1.2truecm -3.truecm obtained for matter ( baryon ) density parameters @xmath73 ( @xmath74 ) and hubble constant @xmath75 ( in units of 100 km / s / mpc ) . in particular , fig .
( [ fig : rho]a ) shows the transition between these tracking regimes .
( [ fig : rho]b ) then shows the low@xmath52 behavior ( @xmath76 ) , since de density exceeds radiation ( @xmath77 ) and then overcomes baryons ( @xmath78 ) and dm ( @xmath79 ) . fig .
( [ fig : rho]c ) is a landscape picture for all components , down to @xmath80 .
notice the @xmath30 dependence of @xmath81 , occurring according to eq .
( [ eq : m8 ] ) . in fig .
( [ fig : omega ] ) vs. scale factor @xmath30.,title="fig : " ] -0.5truecm the related behaviors of the density parameters @xmath82 ( @xmath83 , i.e. radiation , baryons , dm , de ) are shown .
in general , once the density parameter @xmath84 ( at @xmath85 ) is assigned , a model with dynamical ( coupled or uncoupled ) de is not yet univocally determined .
for instance , the potential ( [ eq : l1 ] ) depends on the parameters @xmath86 and @xmath24 and one of them can still be arbitrarily fixed .
other potentials show similar features . in this model
such arbitrariness no longer exists .
let us follow the behavior of @xmath81 , backwards in time , until the approximation @xmath37 no longer applies .
this must approximately coincide with the time when @xmath87 and @xmath2 enters the oscillation regime . at that time , according to eq .
( [ eq : m8 ] ) , which is marginally valid up to there , and taking @xmath88 , @xmath89\ , \phi^2(a ) ~. \label{eq : k2}\ ] ] the system made by eqs.@xmath90([eq : k1 ] ) and ( [ eq : k2 ] ) , owing to eq .
( [ eq : l2 ] ) , allows to obtain ( i ) the scale factor @xmath91 when fluctuations start and ( ii ) the scale @xmath24 in the potential ( [ eq : l1 ] ) . to do so
, the present density of dm , @xmath92 , ( or @xmath93 ) must be assigned .
but , as we shall soon outline , the observational value of the density in the world forces @xmath91 to lay about the quark
hadron transition , while also @xmath24 is substantially fixed .
the plots in the previous section are for @xmath94 ; then @xmath95gev and @xmath96 are required by the system .
but , when @xmath93 goes from 0.2 to 0.4 , @xmath97 ( almost ) linearly runs in the narrow interval 10.0510.39@xmath90 , while @xmath91 steadily lays at the eve of the quark hadron transition .
besides of predicting fair ratios between the world components , a viable model should also allow the formation of structures in the world .
the dual axion model belongs to the class of coupled de models treated by amendola @xcite , with a time
dependent coupling @xmath98 .
a @xmath11@xmath99 phase therefore exists , after matter radiation equivalence , as the kinetic energy of de is non
neglegible during the matter dominated era .
fluctuation evolution is then obtained by solving the equations in @xcite , with the above @xmath100 . the behavior shown in fig.([fig : flu ] ) ( left ) is then found .
fig ( [ fig : flu ] ) ( center and right ) compare fluctuation evolutions the dual axion model ( solid curves ) , with those in an analogous @xmath24cdm model ( dot dashed curves ) and in a coupled de model with constant coupling @xmath101 ( dashed curves ) .
as shown by the plots , the overall growth , from recombination to now is similar in dual axion and @xmath24cdm models , being quite smaller than in de models with constant coupling .
the differences of dual axion from @xmath24cdm are : ( i ) objects form earlier and ( ii ) baryon fluctuations keep below dm fluctuations until very recently .
we shall then test the dual axion model towards cmb data , together with other dynamical or coupled de cosmologies , by using a parameter space of 7 to 8 dimensions .
we use a markov chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) approach ( e.g. @xcite ) , just as in the original analysis of wmap first
year data @xcite , constraining flat @xmath24cdm in respect to six parameters : @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 , the fluctuation amplitude @xmath106 and the optical depth @xmath31 .
notice that , with the naming convention used here , @xmath107 . here ,
three classes of de are considered : ( i ) sugra dynamical de , requiring the introduction of the parameter @xmath108 , the energy scale in the potential ( 12 ) .
( ii ) constant coupling sugra de , requiring a further parameter , the coupling @xmath109 .
( iii ) coupled models including the dual axion case . for
this model the parameter @xmath110 does not exist , being @xmath111 and also the scale @xmath24 is constrained by the requirement that @xmath84 lays in a fair range ( also solving the strong @xmath1 problem ) , so that @xmath24 and @xmath84 are no longer independent parameters . the ( iii ) class of model , that we call @xmath112 models , is however set keeping @xmath113 as a free parameter .
we aim to test whether data constrain @xmath113 into the right region , turning a generic @xmath112 model into a dual axion model .
-4.5truecm to use the mcmc , we need an algorithm providing the @xmath114 s . here
we use our optimized extension of cmbfast @xcite , able to inspect the cosmologies ( i ) , ( ii ) and ( iii ) .
then , the likelihood of each model is evaluated through the publicly available code by the wmap team @xcite and accompanying data @xcite .
the basic results of our analysis are summarized in the table [ tab : res1 ] , [ tab : res2 ] and [ tab : res3 ] . for each model category
we list the expectation values @xmath115 of each parameter @xmath116 and the associated variance @xmath117 ; we also list the values of the parameters of the best fitting models @xmath118 .
let us however remind that @xmath112 models , whose fitting results are reported in table [ tab : res3 ] , include the dual axion model , but many other cases as well .
our approach was meant to test whether cmb data carry information on @xmath113 and how this information fits the @xmath113 range turning a @xmath112 model into the dual axion model . at variance from uncoupled and costant - coupling sugra models ,
wmap data yield constraints on @xmath113 for @xmath112 models ( see table [ tab : res3 ] ) and the 2@xmath0 @xmath24interval ranges from @xmath119 to @xmath120gev , so including the dual axion model .
.sugra parameters for a @xmath112 model . [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in fig .
( [ fig : cl ] ) the @xmath121 spectra for all best fit models ( apart of @xmath24cdm ) are compared . at large @xmath122
all models yield similar behaviors and this is why no model category prevails .
discrimination could be achieved by improving large angular scale observation , especially for polarization , so to reduce the errors on small@xmath122 harmonics .
a first point worth outlining is that sugra ( uncoupled ) models , bearing precise advantages in respect to @xmath24cdm , are consistent with wmap data .
the ratio @xmath123 at @xmath85 , for most these models , fulfills the constraint @xmath124 .
however , these models exhibit a fast @xmath125 variation , and @xmath125 becomes @xmath126 -0.6 , -0.7 at @xmath1272 . in spite of this sharp decrease ,
however , there is no conflict with data .
the results shown in the previous section were also considered in the presence of some priors . for uncoupled or constant coupling sugra models , adding priors scarsely affects conclusions .
@xmath112models , instead , are to be discussed separately . in the first two categories of models opacity ( @xmath31 )
is pushed to values even greater than in @xmath24cdm ( see also @xcite ) .
this can be understood in two complementary ways : ( i ) dynamical de models , in general , exhibit a stronger isw effect , increasing @xmath121 in the low@xmath122 plateau ( e.g. @xcite ) . to compensate this effect , in the fit of data ,
the spectral index @xmath128 is pushed to greater values . in turn , owing to the @xmath31@xmath105 degeneracy , this is compensated by increasing @xmath31 .
( ii ) if the te correlation is also considered , it is worth reminding that dynamical de lowers the te correlation at low @xmath122 @xcite . to fit the same observed correlation level , a greater @xmath31 is therefore favored .
spectra for the best fit sugra ( solid line ) , constant coupling ( dotted line ) , @xmath112coupling ( dashed ) and dual axion ( dot dashed ) models.,title="fig : " ] -0.3truecm greater @xmath31 s have an indirect impact also on @xmath129 whose best fit value becomes greater , although consistent with @xmath24cdm within 1@xmath0 . if we impose , as a prior , @xmath130 ( bbns estimates @xcite ) , @xmath104 shifts slightly below hst findings , still well within 1@xmath0
. we shall consider the effect of a prior also on @xmath104 .
the prior on @xmath129 affects reionization and the spectral slope : @xmath31 and @xmath128 are lowered to match wmap s findings .
the prior on @xmath104 , in the absence of coupling , favors low@xmath113 models , closer to @xmath24cdm .
quite in general , in fact , the sound horizon at decoupling is unaffected by the energy scale @xmath24 , while the distance of the last scattering band is smaller for greater @xmath113 s .
then , as @xmath113 increases , a lower @xmath104 is favored to match the position of the first peak . in the presence of coupling , there is a simultaneous effect on @xmath110 : greater @xmath110 s yield a smaller sound horizon at recombination , so that the distribution on @xmath104 is smoother .
@xmath112 models exhibit rather different features .
parameters are more strongly constrained in this case , as already outlined for the scale @xmath24 .
the main puzzling feature of @xmath112 models is that large @xmath104 is favored : the best
fit 2@xmath0 interval does not extend below 0.85@xmath90 .
the problem is more severe for dual
axion @xmath113 s values , whose preferred values are well within 2@xmath0 .
this model naturally tends to displace the first @xmath121 peak to greater @xmath122 ( smaller angular scales ) as coupling does in any case does .
the model , however , has no extra coupling parameter and the intensity of coupling is controlled by the scale @xmath24 .
increasing this scale requires a more effective compensation and still greater values of @xmath104 are favored .
this effect appears however related to the choice of sugra potentials , which is just meant to provide a concrete framework for the dual axion model . to deepen its analysis , the contribution to the axion abundance due to the decay of possible topological defects
should also be discussed .
a previous analysis of wmap limits on constant coupling models had been carried on by @xcite . their analysis concerned potentials @xmath131 fulfilling the relation @xmath132 , with suitable @xmath133 and @xmath134 .
they also assumed that @xmath135 .
our analysis deals with a different potential and allows more general parameter variations .
the constraints on @xmath110 we find are less severe . it must be however outlined that @xmath1360.2 is forbidden by a non linear analysis of structure formation @xcite .
the first evidences of dm date some 70 years ago , although only in the late seventies limits on cmb anisotropies made evident that a non baryonic component had to be dominant . de could also be dated back to einstein s _ cosmological constant _ , although only snia data revived it , soon followed by data on cmb and deep galaxy samples .
axions have been a good candidate for dm since the late seventies , although various studies , as well as the occurrence of the sn 1987a , strongly constrained the pq scale around values @xmath137gev .
contributions to dm from topological singularities ( cosmic string and walls ) narrowed the constraints to @xmath20 .
full agreement on the relevance of such contributions has not yet been attained and , in this paper , they are still disregarded , while they could cause shifts in our quantitative predictions .
this point must be therefore deepened in further work .
the fact that dm and de can both arise from scalar fields , just by changing the power of the field in effective potentials , already stimulated the work of various authors .
a potential like ( [ eq : l1 ] ) was considered in the so called _ spintessence _ model @xcite . according to the choice of parameters ,
@xmath22 was shown to behave either as dm or as de .
padmanabhan & choudhury @xcite , instead , built a tachionic model where dm and de arise from a single scalar field . here , the scalar field @xmath22 , accounting for _ both _ de and dm , arises in the solution of the strong@xmath1 problem : as in the pq model , in eq .
( [ eq : n1 ] ) @xmath2 is turned into a dynamical variable , the phase of @xmath22 . here
, however , the modulus of @xmath22 increases in time , approaching @xmath138 by our cosmic epoch , when it is de ; meanwhile , @xmath2 is driven to approach zero , still performing harmonic oscillations which are axion dm .
the critical time for the onset of coherent axion oscillations is the eve of the quark
hadron transition , because of the rapid increase of the axion mass @xmath41 . in our dual axion scheme ,
the constant @xmath20 scale of the pq model is replaced by the slowly varying field @xmath11 . instead of the scale @xmath20
, data fix the scale @xmath24 , in the sugra potential .
this unique setting provides dm and de in fair proportions .
wetterich c. , 1995 a&a 301 , 32 ; ratra b. & peebles p.j.e .
, 1988 , phys.rev.d , 37 , 3406 ; ferreira g.p .
& joyce m. 1998 phys.rev.d 58 , 023503 ; brax , p. & martin , j. , 1999 , phys.lett . ,
b468 , 40 ; brax , p. & martin , j. , 2001 , phys.rev .
d , 61 , 10350 ; brax p. , martin j. , riazuelo a. , 2000 , phys.rev .
d , 62 , 103505 macci a. , quercellini c. , mainini r. , amendola l. , bonometto s.a .
2004 phys.rev.d ( in press ) , astro - ph/0309671 ; see also mainini r. , macci a.v .
, bonometto s.a .
, klypin a. 2003 ap.j .
599 , 24 ; klypin a. , macci a.v . ,
r. , bonometto s.a .
2003 ap.j .
599 , 31 .
christensen n. , meyer r. , knox l. & luey , b. 2001 , classical and quantum gravity , 18 , 2677 ; knox l. , christensen , n. & skordis c. 2001 , apj 63 , l95 ; lewis , a. & bridle , s. 2002 , phys.rev .
d 66 , 103511 ; kosowsky a. , milosavljevic m. & jimenez r. 2002 , phys.rev.d 66 , 63007 ; dunkley j. , et al .
2004 , mnras , submitted , astro
ph/0405462 , 2004 | the strong cp problem was solved by peccei & quinn by introducing axions , which are a viable candidate for dm . here
the pq approach is modified so to yield also dark energy ( de ) , which arises in fair proportions , without tuning any extra parameter .
dm and de arise from a single scalar field and , in the present ecpoch , are weakly coupled .
fluctuations have a fair evolution .
the model is also fitted to wmap release , using a mcmc technique , and performs as well as lcdm , coupled or uncoupled dynamical de .
fit cosmological parameters for different models are mostly within 2@xmath0 level .
the main peculiarity of the model is to favor high values of the hubble parameter . |
recent study of small-@xmath2 physics is realized at rhic by measurements of high-@xmath3 particles in @xmath4 collisions at forward rapidities @xmath5 @xcite .
if a particle with mass @xmath6 and transverse momentum @xmath3 is produced in a hard reaction then the corresponding values of bjorken variable in the beam and the target are @xmath7 .
thus , at forward rapidities the target @xmath1 is @xmath8- times smaller than at midrapidities .
this allows to study coherent phenomena ( shadowing , color glass condensate ( cgc ) ) , which are expected to suppress particle yields .
however , a significant suppression at large @xmath9 for any reaction is observed so far at any energy .
namely , all fixed target experiments ( see examples in @xcite ) have too low energy for the onset of coherence effects since @xmath1 is large .
the rise of suppression with @xmath9 ( with feynman @xmath0 ) shows the same pattern as observed at rhic .
this allows to favor another mechanism common for all reactions arising at any energy .
such a common mechanism based on energy conservation effects in initial state parton rescatterings and leading to @xmath0 scaling of nuclear effects was proposed in @xcite .
the projectile hadron can be decomposed over different fock states .
a nucleus has a higher resolution than a proton due to multiple interactions and so can resolve higher fock components containing more constituents .
corresponding parton distributions fall off steeper at @xmath10 where any hard reaction can be treated as a large rapidity gap ( lrg ) process where no particle is produced within rapidity interval @xmath11 .
the suppression factor as a survival probability for lrg was estimated in @xcite , @xmath12 .
each of multiple interactions of projectile partons produces an extra @xmath13 and the weight factors are given by the agk cutting rules @xcite . as was shown in @xcite
the effective projectile parton distribution correlates with the nuclear target and reads & & f^(a)_q / n(x ) = cf_q / n(x ) + & & , [ 10 ] where @xmath14 is the nuclear thickness function , @xmath15 was evaluated in @xcite and the normalization factor @xmath16 is fixed by the gottfried sum rule . in this paper
we study the rise of suppression with @xmath9 ( @xmath17 ) at fnal reported by the e772 collaboration @xcite for the drell - yan ( dy ) process .
we predict similar nuclear effects also at rhic in the forward region expecting the same suppression pattern as seen at fnal .
the dy process in the target rest frame can be treated as radiation of a heavy photon / dilepton by a projectile quark .
the transverse momentum @xmath3 distribution of photon bremsstrahlung in quark - nucleon interactions , @xmath18 , reads @xcite : & & = _ in , f d^2 r_1d^2 r_2 + & & e^i_t(_1 - _ 2 ) _ ^ * q^*(,_1 ) _ ^ * q(,_2 ) [ 20 ] + & & \{_|qq(x , r_1 ) + _ |qq(x , r_2 ) - _ |qq(x,|_1 - _ 2| ) } , where @xmath19 and the light - cone ( lc ) wave functions of the projectile quark @xmath20 fluctuation @xmath21 are presented in @xcite .
feynman variable is given as @xmath22 and in the target rest frame @xmath23 .
for the dipole cross section @xmath24 in eq .
( [ 20 ] ) we used parametrization from @xcite .
the hadron cross section is given convolving the parton cross section , eq .
( [ 20 ] ) with the corresponding parton distribution functions ( pdfs ) @xmath25 and @xmath26 @xcite , & & = _
x_1 ^ 1 _ q z_q^2 + & & \ { f_q(,q^2 ) + f_|q(,q^2 ) } , [ 30 ] where @xmath27 is the fractional quark charge , pdfs @xmath28 and @xmath29 are used with the lowest order ( lo ) parametrization from @xcite at the scale @xmath30 and the factor @xmath31 accounts for decay of the photon into a dilepton .
the rest frame of the nucleus is very convenient for study of coherence effects .
the dynamics of the dy process is regulated by the coherence length @xmath32 related to the longitudinal momentum transfer , @xmath33 , which controls the interference between amplitudes of the hard reaction occurring on different nucleons .
the condition for the onset of shadowing in a hard reaction is sufficiently long coherence length ( lcl ) in comparison with the nuclear radius , @xmath34 , where l_c = , [ 40 ] and @xmath35 and @xmath36 is the energy and mass of the projectile quark .
the fraction of the proton momentum @xmath37 carried by the quark is related to @xmath17 as @xmath38 . in the lcl limit
the special advantage of the color dipole approach allows to incorporate nuclear shadowing effects via a simple eikonalization of @xmath39 @xcite , i.e. replacing @xmath39 in eq .
( [ 20 ] ) by @xmath40 : _ |qq^a = 2 d^2 b\{1 - ^a } . [ 50 ] the corresponding predictions for nuclear broadening in dy reaction based on the theory @xcite for lcl limit were presented in @xcite . in the short coherence length ( scl ) regime
the coherence length is shorter than the mean internucleon spacing , @xmath41fm . in this limit
there is no shadowing due to very short duration of the @xmath42 fluctuation .
the corresponding theory for description of the quark transverse momentum broadening can be found in @xcite .
here the probability distribution @xmath43 that a valence quark arriving at the position @xmath44 in the nucleus @xmath45 will have acquired transverse momentum @xmath46 can be written in term of the quark density matrix , @xmath47 , & & w_a^q(_t , x_q,,z ) = d^2 r_1 d^2 r_2e^i_t(_1 - _ 2 ) + & & _
q(_1,_2 ) e^- _ |qq ( x_q,_1 - _ 2 ) t_a ( + , z ) , [ 180 ] where @xmath48 with @xmath49@xmath50 representing the mean - square charge radius of the proton .
@xmath51 in eq .
( [ 180 ] ) is the partial nuclear thickness function , @xmath52 .
transverse momentum acquired by a quark on the nucleus , @xmath53 , is obtained averaging eq .
( [ 180 ] ) over the nuclear density @xmath54 : w^qa = d^2 b dz _ a(b , z ) w_a^q(_t , x_q,,z ) . [ 210 ] the cross section , @xmath55 , for an incident quark to produce a photon on a nucleus @xmath45 with transverse momentum @xmath3 can be expressed convolving the probability function @xmath53 with the cross section @xmath56 ( see eq .
( [ 20 ] ) ) , ^qa(,p_t ) = d^2 k_t w^qa(_t , x_q ) ^qn ( , _ t ) , [ 240 ] where @xmath57 . to obtain the transverse momentum distribution for an incident proton one should integrate over @xmath58 similarly as in eq .
( [ 30 ] ) : & & = _
x_1 ^ 1 _ q z_q^2 + & & \{f_q(,q^2 ) + f_|q(,q^2 ) } ^qa(,p_t ) .
[ 250 ] nuclear effects in @xmath59 collisions are usually investigated via the so called nuclear modification factor , defined as r_a(p_t , x_f , m ) = , [ 270 ] where the numerator is calculated in scl and lcl regimes as described above .
corrections for the finite coherence length was realized by linear interpolation using nuclear longitudinal formfactor @xcite ( for more sophisticate green function method see @xcite ) .
note that at rhic energy and at forward rapidities ( large @xmath0 ) the eikonal formula for lcl regime , eqs .
( [ 30 ] ) and ( [ 50 ] ) , is not exact since higher fock components containing gluons lead to additional corrections , called gluon shadowing ( gs ) .
the corresponding suppression factor @xmath60 was derived in @xcite and included in calculations replacing in eq .
( [ 50 ] ) @xmath61 by @xmath62 .
gs leads to reduction of the cronin effect @xcite at moderate @xmath3 and to additional suppression ( see fig . [ fig5 ] ) . for elimination of the coherence effects one can study production of dileptons at large @xmath63 ( see eq .
( [ 40 ] ) ) as has been realized by the e772 collaboration @xcite .
another possibility is to study the dy process at large @xmath64 , when also @xmath65 , and @xmath66 in this limit ( see eq .
( [ 40 ] ) ) .
we start with the dy process in @xmath67 collisions . besides calculations based on eq .
( [ 30 ] ) using grv pdfs @xcite ( see the dashed line in fig . [ fig1 ] ) we present by the solid line also predictions using proton structure functions from @xcite .
[ fig1 ] shows a reasonable agreement of the model with data from the e886 collaboration @xcite .
this encourages us to apply the color dipole approach to nuclear targets as well .
collisions at @xmath68 and @xmath69gev vs. e886 data @xcite . ] of drell - yan cross sections on w and d vs. e772 data for @xmath70gev .
predictions correspond to the long ( lcl ) and short coherence length ( scl ) regimes , and their interpolation ( real ) . the lower and upper series of curves are calculated with and without energy conservation effects , respectively . , width=302,height=253 ] the e772 collaboration @xcite found a significant suppression of dy pairs at large @xmath17 ( see fig .
[ fig2 ] ) .
large invariant masses of the photon allows to minimize shadowing effects ( see a small differences between lines calculated in scl and lcl regimes ) .
if effects of energy conservation are not included one can not describe a strong suppression at large @xmath17 . in the opposite case a reasonable agreement of our model with data
is achieved . finally , we present also predictions for @xmath3 dependence of the nuclear modification factor @xmath71 at rhic energy and at several fixed values of @xmath0 . similarly as in @xcite instead of usual cronin enhancement , a suppression is found ( see fig .
[ fig5 ] ) .
the onset of isotopic effects at large @xmath3 gives a value @xmath72 and can not explain strong nuclear effects .
the predicted huge rise of suppression with @xmath0 in fig .
[ fig5 ] reflects much smaller survival probability @xmath73 at larger @xmath0 and can be tested in the future by the new data from rhic .
note that effects of gs depicted in fig .
[ fig5 ] by the thick lines lead to additional suppression which rises with @xmath0 . at @xmath74gev for several fixed values of @xmath0 with the energy conservation effects ( thin lines ) .
thick lines additionally include gluon shadowing effects .
, width=302,height=253 ]
we present unified approach to large @xmath17 ( @xmath0 ) nuclear suppression based on energy conservation effects in multiple parton rescatterings .
we apply this approach for the dy process and explain well a significant suppression at large @xmath17 in accordance with the e772 data .
the fnal energy range and large invariant masses of the photon allow to minimize the coherence effects , what does not leave much room for other mechanisms , such as cgc .
we predict a significant suppression also in @xmath4 collisions at rhic in the forward region ( see fig .
[ fig5 ] ) . at moderate @xmath3
we show an importance of gs effects and their rise with @xmath0 . | we study a significant nuclear suppression of the relative production rates ( p(d)+a)/(p+d(p ) ) for the drell - yan process at large feynman @xmath0 . since this is the region of minimal values for the light - front momentum fraction variable @xmath1 in the target nucleus , it is tempting to interpret this as a manifestation of coherence or of a color glass condensate .
we demonstrate , however , that this suppression mechanism is governed by the energy conservation restrictions in multiple parton rescatterings in nuclear matter . to eliminate nuclear shadowing effects coming from the coherence ,
we calculate nuclear suppression in the light - cone dipole approach at large dilepton masses and at energy accessible at fnal .
our calculations are in a good agreement with data from the e772 experiment . using the same mechanism we predict also nuclear suppression at forward rapidities in the rhic energy range . |
while cavity - qed systems often contain many interacting degrees of freedom , they are unconventional from the standpoint of traditional many - body physics for two primary reasons
. first , the mediation of interactions through a small number of delocalized cavity modes generally leads to extremely long - ranged interactions @xcite , which suppress the role of fluctuations and often enable accurate mean - field descriptions .
in this sense they are simpler than conventional solid - state realizations of many - body physics , in which short - range interactions promote both quantum and thermal fluctuations to an important role , especially in low spatial dimensions @xcite .
second , cavity - qed systems are typically driven and dissipative ; as a result , even if they reach a time - independent steady state they will generally not be in thermal equilibrium @xcite . in this sense
they are more complicated than conventional solid - state realizations of many - body physics , in which coupling to a thermal reservoir is typically assumed and well justified , leaving the system in thermal equilibrium and enabling the powerful tools of statistical mechanics to be employed @xcite . in recent years
, experimental advances in quantum optics have begun to blur the first of these distinctions @xcite , with platforms including exciton - polariton fluids in semiconductor quantum wells @xcite , circuit - qed @xcite , optical fibers , waveguides , and photonic crystals @xcite , small - mode - volume optical resonators @xcite , and rydberg ensembles @xcite all making progress towards realizing large - scale arrays of short - range coupled quantum optical building blocks .
these developments have led many researchers to revisit fundamental questions surrounding the fate of non - equilibrium quantum - optical systems in situations where , due to the importance of either dissipative or quantum fluctuations , a mean - field description is insufficient @xcite .
the primary goal of this paper is to elucidate the physics of a canonical many - body model made relevant by these developments the driven - dissipative bose hubbard model @xcite by bringing together many closely related ideas from the many - body physics and quantum - optics communities .
first and foremost , we aim to understand the effects of fluctuations on any phase transitions exhibited by the steady state of this model , and the extent to which these phase transitions do or do not admit an equilibrium description .
the driven - dissipative bose - hubbard model furnishes a minimal description of , e.g. , coherently driven exciton - polariton fluids confined in coupled micro - cavities or other patterned semi - conductor devices @xcite ; our theoretical results thus have direct experimental implications , for example determining the universal spectral features of such systems near a dissipative steady - state phase transition .
much of the previous work on the driven - dissipative bose - hubbard model has grown out of early proposals to simulate the equilibrium bose - hubbard model in photonic systems , either in the transient regime of very _ weakly _ dissipative systems @xcite , or through clever strategies to mitigate the effects of particle loss @xcite . in this context , the driven - dissipative model has been considered in an attempt to understand the corruption of equilibrium physics by non - vanishing dissipation in realistic systems , and to identify qualitative signatures of equilibrium bose - hubbard physics
fermionization for strong interactions @xcite or the incompressibility of the zero - temperature mott - insulating phase @xcite that survive in steady state .
the general spirit of this approach is to start from the intuitions and expectations appropriate for the equilibrium bose - hubbard model , and to build outward toward an understanding of the driven - dissipative dynamics ; numerous interesting connections to the equilibrium physics of the bose - hubbard model @xcite , as well as a variety of surprising and genuinely non - equilibrium effects @xcite , have been discovered in this manner .
but there are many reasons to expect that the search for _ universal _ features of the driven - dissipative model benefits from , and perhaps even requires , a fundamentally different approach . for example , the ground - state and thermal phase transitions of the bose - hubbard model are intimately related to u(1 ) symmetry and the associated particle - number conservation @xcite . while the former can be preserved in a driven - dissipative context by pumping the cavities incoherently @xcite , the latter remains absent , calling into question whether in the sense of phase transitions and universality_any _ properties of the bose - hubbard model can survive the presence of driving and dissipation @xcite . here
, we instead pursue an understanding of the driven - dissipative bose - hubbard model from the ground up , starting from the well understood non - equilibrium physics of a single cavity , namely optical bistability @xcite , and adopting a functional integral formalism that is well suited to extending the essential single - cavity physics to a many - body setting @xcite .
as we will show , universal properties of the steady state bear essentially no resemblance to the equilibrium physics of the bose - hubbard model @xcite , but neither do they retain the fundamentally non - equilibrium character of optical bistability . instead , the steady state of the driven - dissipative bose - hubbard model admits an emergent equilibrium description in terms of a finite - temperature classical ising model @xcite .
specifically ( see fig.[fig : schematic ] ) , two collective mean - field steady states are inherited from the optical bistability of the individual cavities ; they play the role of the two local minima in the ising model s mean - field free energy , while dissipation ( i.e.vacuum fluctuations ) plays the role of thermal fluctuations , setting the effective temperature . by connecting two canonical and minimal models of many - body physics
one a cornerstone of non - equilibrium quantum optics and one a cornerstone of traditional equilibrium many - body physics
this paper provides a particularly simple and concrete example of the way in which equilibrium can emerge very naturally from an _ a priori _ non - equilibrium many - body problem , even when mean - field theory fails .
we note that our conclusions build on and justify a preliminary analysis reported in ref.@xcite , where a renormalization - group argument in favor of the ising universality class was advanced . in the present work ,
we identify a small parameter @xmath0 related to the inverse `` system size '' ( in the sense of the system - size expansion often employed in quantum - optics studies of systems with only a few degrees of freedom ) , which controls the overall scale of fluctuations , and thus the effective temperature . in the limit of weak fluctuations ,
the qualitative predictions of ref.@xcite can be justified , made quantitative , and verified numerically . in this way
, we not only identify the model with respect to which an effective thermal description emerges , but also semi - quantitatively obtain the phase boundaries , effective temperature , and near - critical dynamics in terms of microscopic parameters .
is a parameter controlling the density scale , i.e. @xmath1 . hence the low temperature limit of the ising model corresponds to a semi - classical ( large density ) limit of optical bistability . ] before proceeding , we caution that the emergence of an effective equilibrium description as described in this paper , while potentially reasonably generic , should not be taken for granted ; other more genuinely non - equilibrium situations can and do arise in other models @xcite .
ultimately , the goal of this paper is not only to provide a detailed view into the mechanisms by which thermal equilibrium can emerge from the microscopically non - equilibrium setting of many - body cavity - qed , nor by any means to insist that one must emerge , but also to clarify some of the techniques required to understand more unusual behaviors made possible by the strong - coupling regime of quantum optics .
it is natural to expect that analyses of prototypical situations in which equilibrium _ does _ emerge will play an important role in anticipating more exotic situations in which it does _
not_. after presenting the model and reviewing the well - known solution of the single - cavity case in sec.[sec : model ] , our general strategy for the many - body problem will be laid out in sec.[sec : formalism ] .
our approach is based on a well - established exact mapping of the master equation onto a functional integral .
although it imposes some additional notational burden , the functional integral formalism has the virtue of ( 1 ) being a convenient starting point for the identification of approximation schemes , including controlled strategies for going beyond mean - field theory @xcite , and ( 2 ) enabling powerful techniques such as the renormalization group to be applied @xcite . here
, we use the path integral to quickly identify an exactly solvable limit of the problem , around which a semi - classical expansion ( related to the system - size expansion of quantum optics ) can be made . to leading non - trivial order in this expansion
, we obtain a quantitatively accurate mapping of the many - body quantum master equation onto classical non - equilibrium langevin equations , with a small parameter controlling the strength of the noise .
in sec.[sec : mft ] we analyze the mean - field equations of motion near the mean - field critical point , which possess an emergent @xmath2 symmetry in the spirit of ref.@xcite .
we show how the complex order parameter decomposes into two real components , one of which stays massive at the critical point and one of which does not . by adiabatically eliminating the massive component
, we arrive at a time - dependent landau - ginsburg equation for a scalar field , which supports two different homogeneous solutions within the bistable region . near the critical point and inside the bistable region
, we are able to analytically obtain the profile and velocity of domain walls separating domains of these two different phases , and the vanishing of the domain wall velocity gives a zeroth - order approximation to the location of a true ( first - order ) phase transition in more than one spatial dimension . in sec.[sec : langevin ] we consider the effects of fluctuations in both one and two spatial dimensions by ( a ) arguing that near the critical point and for weak noise the non - linear langevin equations become equivalent to model a of the hohenberg and halperin classification , and ( b ) solving the non - equilibrium langevin equations numerically , which is valid even away from the critical point . as our earlier analysis would suggest , the numerical results are qualitatively consistent with the expected equilibrium physics of a classical ising model in a longitudinal field . in one dimension ,
domains are seeded by fluctuations , and the dynamics of their unbound domain walls smooths the mean - field transition into a crossover . in 2d
the domains walls exhibit a surface tension , enabling a line of true first - order phase transitions terminating at a critical point .
the model we consider can arise in a variety of contexts , but for concreteness we consider either a 1d chain or 2d rectangular array of semiconductor microcavities supporting exciton - polaritons ( see e.g. ref.@xcite ) .
we assume that the onsite energies of exciton - polaritons are spatially uniform and equal to @xmath3 , and that the cavities are driven coherently and in phase by a laser with frequency @xmath4 . upon making a unitary transformation to remove the time - dependence of the driving
, we obtain the hamiltonian @xmath5 here , @xmath6 creates(anihilates ) an exciton - polariton in the @xmath7th cavity , @xmath8 parametrizes the strength of a coherent coupling of exciton - polaritons between neighboring cavities , @xmath9 is the detuning of the laser from cavity resonance , @xmath10 sets the two - body interaction energy for exciton - polaritons confined in the same cavity , and @xmath11 is the amplitude of the coherent driving .
the notation @xmath12 implies that the sum should be taken over all nearest - neighbor pairs of sites @xmath7 and @xmath13 .
the driving is necessary to stabilize a non - trivial steady state in the presence of particle loss out of the cavities at a rate @xmath14 .
if the loss of exciton - polaritons is treated in the born - markov approximation , the dynamics of the combined unitary evolution under @xmath15 and loss is described by a markovian master equation @xcite , @xmath16+\frac{\kappa}{2}\sum_{j}\big(2\hat{a}^{\phantom\dagger}_j\hat{\rho } \hat{a}^{\dagger}_j-\hat{\rho}\hat{a}^{\dagger}_j\hat{a}^{\phantom\dagger}_j-\hat{a}^{\dagger}_j\hat{a}^{\phantom\dagger}_j\hat{\rho}\big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] more generally , eqs .
( [ eq : hamiltonian],[eq : meq ] ) provide a natural ( though certainly not unique ) generalization of the bose - hubbard model to the driven ( @xmath11 ) and dissipative ( @xmath14 ) setting of quantum optics .
the case of a single cavity has been thoroughly studied in the quantum optics literature , where it serves as a minimal model for dispersive optical bistability @xcite .
a mean - field description of the problem can be obtained by writing down the equation of motion for @xmath17 , and assuming that expectation values of normal - ordered operator products factorize ( i.e. making the replacement @xmath18 ) , giving @xmath19 the steady - state equation @xmath20 can be recast as a cubic equation for the mean - field density @xmath21 , @xmath22 this equation has either one or two solutions that are dynamically stable to small perturbations , leading to the mean - field phase diagram shown in fig.[fig : mf_phase_diagram]a . , and @xmath23 .
( b ) ( @xmath24 ) .
a cut through the bistable region of the mean - field phase diagram , showing both the mean - field ( blue dashed ) and exact ( orange solid ) solution for the density .
( c ) ( @xmath24 and @xmath25 ) .
full counting statistics of the exact steady - state density matrix , together with that of both mean - field solutions ( i.e. coherent - state distributions , with the relative normalization used as a fitting parameter ) .
( d ) ( @xmath24 and @xmath25 ) .
one trajectory obtained from a quantum trajectories simulation of eq . for a single cavity , showing switching between two mean - field like states ; the densities associated with the two dynamically stable mean - field solution are shown as dashed lines . ] for a single cavity , the full quantum solution of the master equation can be obtained efficiently in a variety of ways , for example by direct numerical integration of eq . within a truncated hilbert space .
steady - state expectation values can even be obtained analytically by mapping the single - cavity version of eq . onto phase - space equations in the complex - p representation @xcite .
reference @xcite provides a comprehensive discussion of the solution , and here we simply summarize its main features , focusing primarily on the relationship between the exact and mean - field solutions . while the mean - field equations of motion can support two dynamically stable steady states , the exact steady - state density matrix of eq .
is always unique , as are all observables calculated from it ( for example , see fig.[fig : mf_phase_diagram]b ) .
while there are never two truly stable steady states , two important signatures of mean - field bistability do survive in the limit of large cavity occupancy : ( 1 ) the full - counting statistics of the exact solution exhibits a bimodal structure within the parameter regime yielding mean - field bistability , with the probability of observing different photon numbers clustering around the two mean - field stable values of the density ( fig.[fig : mf_phase_diagram]c ) .
outside of the bistable region , this bimodality disappears and the exact counting statistics becomes similar to that corresponding to the one stable mean - field solution ; in this sense , the exact solution interpolates between the two mean - field steady states within the bistable region .
( 2 ) if the system is initialized in one of the mean - field steady states , it will only explore the phase space in the vicinity of that solution on the natural time scales of the problem ( i.e. those associated with energy scales appearing explicitly in the master equation ) , and will only sample the phase space in the vicinity of the other mean - field solution on much longer time scales ( fig.[fig : mf_phase_diagram]d ) . this slow time - scale for switching between mean - field - like steady states
is associated with a small gap of the exact quantum liouvillian , which vanishes inside the bistable region in the limit of large photon occupancy @xcite . in this limit , which plays a role analogous to the `` thermodynamic limit '' of a spatially extended system , mean - field bistability
can therefore be identified with the existence of a ( zero - dimensional ) dissipative phase transition .
to analyze the steady - state behavior of many coupled cavities , it is convenient to recast the master equation in terms of an equivalent functional integral @xcite , @xmath26 with action @xmath27 the functional integral in eq .
is over all unconstrained paths for the variables @xmath28 and @xmath29 , the spatial / temporal dependence of which has been suppressed in eqs.([eq : partition_function ] ) and ( [ eq : action ] ) . for a proper discrete - time regularization of @xmath30 . ]
the factor @xmath31 in eq . is the wigner function at the initial time @xmath32 , with @xmath33 being shorthand for the set of field variables @xmath34 at the initial time . in this paper
we will only concern ourselves with steady state properties , and so we can safely set @xmath35 in the integral limits of eq . and exclude the dependence on @xmath36 from @xmath30 . from here forward the integral limits of @xmath37 in the action will be implied and not shown .
the classical hamiltonian @xmath38 in eq . is the weyl - symbol of the hamiltonian in eq .
@xcite ; this should be contrasted with the usual appearance of the q - symbol in the keldysh functional integral ( see appendix [ sec : appendix_a ] for a derivation of this functional integral and further discussion of the emergence of weyl - ordering ) . the functional integral in eq .
is suited to calculating products of operators that are ordered along a closed - time ( or keldysh ) contour @xcite .
in particular , writing the so - called classical ( @xmath39 ) and quantum ( @xmath40 ) fields as @xmath41 and @xmath42 , and writing creation / anihilation operators as @xmath43 , keldysh - ordered correlation functions can be computed as ( restoring spatial / temporal indices and defining @xmath44 ) @xmath45 on the left - hand - side of eq . the expectation value is taken with respect to the initial density matrix , and the operators evolve in the heisenberg picture .
the symbol @xmath46 time - orders all operators whose time arguments have a ` @xmath47 ' superscript , and anti - time orders those with time arguments that have a ` @xmath48 ' superscript , placing all of the latter to the left of all of the former . on the right - hand side of eq .
the expectation value is taken with respect to the functional integral @xmath30 , i.e. it is computed by inserting the relevant fields into the integrand of eq .
( @xmath30 is normalized to unity by construction , as it expresses the trace of the density matrix ) . in the calculations that follow ,
we will exploit a semi - classical limit in which the quantum field is , in a sense to be made precise , parametrically smaller than the classical field ; thus we will be primarily interested in correlations of the classical field alone , which can be converted into operator expectation values by inverting eq .
, @xmath49 while it may appear that such correlation functions can be discontinuous at coinciding times due to the associated change of operator ordering on the right - hand - side of eq . , it is straightforward to show that this is not actually the case . instead , when the times approach each other ( @xmath50 ) , the limit of an arbitrary @xmath51-point correlation function of the classical field @xmath39 smoothly approaches the equal - time value @xmath52 where @xmath53 symmetrizes ( i.e. weyl - orders ) products of creation and annihilation operators @xcite .
in other words , equal - time correlation functions of the classical field reproduce the average of weyl - ordered operator products . for example
, the density can be computed from the two - point correlation function @xmath54 the weyl - symbol of @xmath15 is given by ( ignoring additive constants , which do not affect correlation functions ) @xmath55 here @xmath56 is the discrete laplacian , the lattice coordination number @xmath57 in @xmath58 dimensions , and @xmath59 .
inserting eq . into eq .
yields the action @xmath60 because the path integral is gaussian for @xmath61 , and because optical bistability at the mean - field level can occur at arbitrarily small values of @xmath10 , one might hope that some aspects of the relevant physics can be captured by doing perturbation theory in @xmath10 .
however , this is not the case ; while optical bistability can indeed occur for small @xmath10 , it always occurs when the typical interaction energy per particle , @xmath62 , is comparable to the other energy scales of the problem .
nevertheless , the action can still be organized around a small parameter that enables a controlled approximation . to this end
, we define rescaled fields and parameters @xmath63 in terms of which the action can be rewritten @xmath64 the dimensionless parameter @xmath65 implicitly identifies a one - dimensional family of actions at fixed values of @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath14 , @xmath68 , and @xmath8 , one limit of which ( large @xmath65 ) will be shown to admit a tractable analysis . note that the limit @xmath69 at fixed @xmath67 and @xmath66 is not the same thing as the limit @xmath70 , even though the coupling @xmath10 does become small in this limit . rather , increasing @xmath65 amounts to increasing the drive strength @xmath11 while simultaneously decreasing the coupling @xmath10 in such a way that the typical interaction energy per particle , @xmath62 , remains constant . to see this
, we first evaluate the path integral in the limit @xmath69 , in which only the first term in the action survives .
the functional integral over @xmath71 can be carried out and yields a functional @xmath72-function of the term inside parentheses , thereby enforcing the mean - field equation of motion @xmath73 note that at this level of approximation , varying @xmath65 with @xmath66 and @xmath67 held fixed leaves the equation of motion for @xmath74 invariant .
therefore , as discussed above , the interaction energy per photon @xmath75 stays fixed .
the only consequence is that the actually density , @xmath76 , is enhanced by a factor of @xmath65 , which therefore sets the overall density scale @xcite .
for @xmath65 large but finite , the first term on the second line of eq .
suppresses contributions to the path integral unless @xmath77 .
the final term can therefore be estimated as @xmath78 , and can be safely ignored in the large @xmath65 limit . at this level of approximation ,
the path integral can no longer be solved exactly , but it can be mapped onto stochastic classical equations by standard techniques .
decoupling the term that is quadratic in @xmath71 with a hubbard - stratonovich transformation , @xmath79 the action again becomes linear in @xmath71 .
this time , for fixed @xmath80 , the functional integral over @xmath71 enforces enforces the equation of motion @xmath81 the remaining functional integral over @xmath80 with a gaussian weight @xmath82 indicates that we should interpret eq . as a stochastic differential equation , with @xmath80 being complex , gaussian white noise of variance ( restoring spatial and temporal indices ) @xmath83 hence the dynamics of the rescaled classical field @xmath74 , to this order in @xmath0 , is governed by a stochastic and dissipative gross - pitaevskii equation with parametrically weak noise . rather than @xmath84 owing to the weyl - ordering of the hamiltonian .
the additional term , however , should not be retained when making a consistent expansion in @xmath0 . ]
. can also be derived using more standard phase space techniques , the path integral approach has the advantage that one can assess the consequences of the approximations that lead to eq . within the framework of the renormalization group . in particular , as discussed in ref.@xcite , eq .
should reproduce the correct critical exponents for the phase transition exhibited by the exact steady state of eq .. unlike in ref.@xcite , however , here we have explicitly identified a limit ( large @xmath65 ) in which eq .
yields asymptotically exact results for microscopic observables , and thus can be used to make quantitative predictions about the behavior of correlation functions at the lattice - scale ( rather than just qualitative predictions about their long - distance asymptotics ) . moreover
, the existence of this limit furnishes a more formal justification for the type of perturbative renormalization - group analysis carried out in ref.@xcite .
it is important to realize that , even for a single cavity , eqs . and must be interpreted with some care in order to correctly extract steady - state properties in the large-@xmath65 limit .
the reason is simply that , returning to the full path integral , the limits @xmath69 and @xmath85 do not commute when the parameters are tuned to be inside the mean - field bistable region .
indeed , if we take the limit @xmath69 first , eq . is exact at all times , and we are lead to conclude ( on the same basis as the analysis in sec.[sec : model ] ) that there are two stable steady states .
if we instead take the large @xmath86 limit first , we would find [ based on the analysis of @xmath0 corrections contained in eq . ]
that there is a unique steady state at any finite value of @xmath65 , which is a fluctuation - induced admixture of the two stable steady states computed by reversing the order of limits . if we now take the large-@xmath65 limit , one of those steady states is generally preferred over the other , in the sense that it alone determines all steady - state expectation values .
thus we encounter a sudden ( first - order ) phase transition between a bright and a dark state when traversing through the mean - field bistable region .
and @xmath87 control deviations in a non - orthogonal coordinate system spanned by the dashed arrow .
( b ) setting @xmath88 and scanning @xmath89 from positive to negative causes the order parameter to undergo a cusp bifurcation , at which the solution outside the bistable region goes unstable ( dashed line ) and two new dynamically stable steady states ( solid lines ) emerge continuously . in both plots @xmath90 , and energies are given as dimensionless ratios with @xmath68 . ] from the above considerations it is clear that , at least in the large @xmath65 limit , the steady state can be understood by solving the mean - field equations of motion in the presence of parametrically weak noise .
thus we expect a detailed understanding of the mean - field dynamics in the absence of noise to form a useful starting point for understanding the dynamics of eq .. at the level of eq . , and
assuming that only uniform steady states exist , the steady - state phase diagram is identical to that of single - cavity optical bistability , up to the replacement of @xmath72 by @xmath68 . in terms of the rescaled field @xmath74 and a rescaled density @xmath91 , eq . becomes @xmath92 straightforward analysis of eq .
shows that upon entering the bistable region from outside of it , the additional solution does not in general emerge continuously from the existing one .
however , if one enters the bistable region through the cusp located at ( see fig.[fig : mf_coordinates ] ) @xmath93 the two solutions do emerge continuously from a single solution , @xmath94 ( with critical density @xmath95 ) .
therefore , we can identify the cusp of the bistable region as a mean - field critical point locating a continuous phase transition from one to two steady states .
it is straightforward to show that one can only enter the bistable region through the critical point along the line @xmath96
. it will be convenient in what follows to define new coordinates in the @xmath14-@xmath66 parameter space that naturally parametrize deviations from the mean - field critical point along and away from this line , @xmath97 note that this parameter transformation is designed so that only @xmath89 varies as we enter the bistable region through the critical point
the overall normalization of @xmath89 and @xmath87 is arbitrary , and chosen to make the formulas that follow simpler .
these new variables can be visualized as parameterizing deviations from the mean - field critical point in the non - orthogonal coordinate system shown in fig.[fig : mf_coordinates]a . for @xmath88 , moving from @xmath98 to @xmath99 causes the mean - field solution outside of the bistable region to undergo a cusp bifurcation ( fig.[fig : mf_coordinates]b ) .
for @xmath99 , sweeping @xmath87 from negative to positive traverses the bistable region in such a way that the system goes from supporting only a low - density solution , to having coexisting low - density and high - density solutions , and then eventually to supporting only a high - density solution .
this behavior is in close analogy to that of an ising model : if the dark and bright solutions are identified with the up / down - symmetry - related free - energy minima , then @xmath89 plays the role or the reduced temperature and @xmath87 plays the role of a symmetry - breaking ( longitudinal ) field , causing one to be preferred over the other
. the remainder of sec.[sec : mft ] will formalize this analogy , and in sec.[sec : langevin ] we will argue that it continues to hold even when fluctuations are included .
we are particularly interested in the effects of fluctuations in the vicinity of the mean - field critical point , which requires that we first understand the mean - field response when ( a ) the parameters are tuned close to the mean - field critical point ( both @xmath89 and @xmath87 are small ) and ( b ) the order parameter @xmath74 is perturbed weakly from its steady - state value .
first working directly at the critical point ( @xmath100 , with steady - state solution @xmath101 ) and assuming that @xmath102 is uniform and close to the critical value , we expand eq . to first order in @xmath103 to obtain @xmath104 the r.h.s .
is purely real , and thus only the real part of @xmath103 decays ; the dynamics stops when the r.h.s vanishes , i.e. when @xmath105 .
this observation motivates the following decomposition of the complex - valued @xmath103 into two real components , @xmath106 with the expectation that @xmath107 and @xmath108 will relax quickly and slowly , respectively , in the vicinity of the mean - field critical point . inserting this decomposition into eq . but now keeping all orders in @xmath107 and @xmath108 , we obtain coupled non - linear differential equations for @xmath107 and @xmath108 ( see appendix [ sec : appendix_b ] for a detailed discussion ) .
the fast variable @xmath107 can be adiabatically eliminated by solving @xmath109 for @xmath107 ( perturbatively in @xmath89 and @xmath87 ) and inserting the solution into the equation of motion for @xmath108 . in this way ,
to lowest nontrivial order in @xmath89 we obtain @xmath110 note that we have also dropped higher - order derivative terms for @xmath108 that arise from the adiabatic elimination of @xmath107 ; this omission turns out to be justified ( to lowest non - trival order in @xmath89 ) near the mean - field critical point , where the fields vary slowly in space , even when @xmath8 is not small compared to the other energy scales in eq .
( the perturbative adiabatic elimination of @xmath107 is explained in detail in appendix [ sec : appendix_b ] ) . restoring spatial indices and defining parameters @xmath111 eq .
can be rewritten as @xmath112 where the effective hamiltonian @xmath113 is defined @xmath114 note that , as anticipated , @xmath113 is precisely the energy functional defining the landau theory of a classical ising model , with @xmath108 playing the role of the magnetization .
equation indicates that the dynamics of the slow field in the vicinity of the critical point is purely relaxational , evolving towards the minimum of the effective potential @xmath113 . at the level of mean - field theory
there are two truly stable homogeneous solutions within the bistable region .
however , it is clear that if we place the system in one of the two mean - field steady states , the inclusion of fluctuations will seed defects of the other steady state ; whether these defects shrink or grow will depend on the dynamics of the domain wall separating them from the bulk , and will determine which of the two mean - field steady states is preferred over the other .
thus the identification of a point in the bistable region where the mean - field velocity of a domain wall vanishes gives a first approximation to the location of the phase transition when fluctuations are included .
it is difficult to analytically extract domain - wall dynamics directly from eq .
, so to proceed we make three assumptions : ( 1 ) the parameters are tuned to be inside the bistable region and close to the mean - field critical point , ( 2 ) the domains are smooth , such that a continuum approximation is justified , and ( 3 ) if @xmath115 , the domains are large and thus have vanishing curvature .
the first assumption justifies the use of eq . to calculate the dynamics .
the second assumption requires that @xmath8 is large compared to the local energy scales of the problem , e.g. to the characteristic time - scale associated with dynamics in the potential part of the hamiltonian @xmath116 note that near criticality , this only requires that @xmath8 is large compared to @xmath89 and @xmath87 , and not that @xmath8 is large compared to the energy scales @xmath66 and @xmath117 .
the third assumption is made because the phase that is favored in the limit of weak fluctuations is the one in which asymptotically large defects of the opposite phase are unfavored ( i.e. tend to shrink ) .
the dynamics of a flat domain wall are effectively one - dimensional , and can be ascertained from a one - dimensional continuum version of eq .
, @xmath118 when @xmath88 , the symmetry of eq . under inversions
@xmath119 implies that domain walls must be stationary ; both uniform phases have the same effective potential and relaxational dynamics can not prefer one over the other .
therefore , the line @xmath88 provides a first approximation to the dividing line between parts of the bistable region in which the bright phase is more stable and parts in which the dark phase is more stable .
, valid near the critical point ( red line ) .
the size of the disks reflects the largest expected uncertainty in the numerical determination of these points .
inset : exploded view of the main plot near the critical point , now in terms of the parameters @xmath87 and @xmath89 .
the dashed blue line is an improved estimate of the zero - velocity line obtained by extending eq .
to next leading ( quadratic ) order in @xmath89 .
( b ) numerically extracted domain wall velocity ( red disks ) as a function of @xmath87 [ taken along the black - dotted line shown in the inset of ( a ) ] , compared with the estimate in eq .
( black - dashed line ) .
note that the black - dashed line does not vanish at @xmath88 . while its slope is taken from eq .
, it has been shifted by an amount that we determine by extending eq . to next - to - leading order in the deviations from the critical point [
i.e. the same correction used to produce the blue - dashed line in the inset of ( a ) ] , which clearly agrees well with the numerically calculated shift of the zero - velocity point . ] for @xmath87 small but nonzero , the domain wall velocity can be estimated in the following manner @xcite . making a traveling wave ansatz @xmath120 , with @xmath121 , and denoting derivatives with respect to @xmath122 by dots , eq .
becomes @xmath123 equation can be interpreted as newton s equation for a particle with position @xmath108 and mass @xmath124 , moving in the inverted potential @xmath125 and subject to a linear drag with friction coefficient @xmath126 . inside the mean - field bistable region ( @xmath99 )
there are two stationary solutions of eq .
associated with the two local maxima of the potential energy @xmath125 ( fig.[fig : domains ] ) ; these correspond to the two spatially uniform mean - field steady states . to zeroth order in @xmath87 ,
these solutions are located at @xmath127 , with @xmath128 .
in addition to the two stationary stationary solutions , a solution can be found that interpolates from the higher local maximum to the lower one , which for @xmath129 is located at @xmath130 .
the friction coefficient @xmath126 must be determined self - consistently such that the particle comes to rest at the lower local maximum .
standard analysis of the solutions of eq .
based on conservation of energy yields , to first order in @xmath87 ( see appendix [ sec : appendix_c ] for details ) , @xmath131 the analysis above is corroborated by brute - force numerical integration of eq .. the true zero - velocity line can be determined numerically by solving eq . with a domain wall inserted at @xmath132 , and agrees with the @xmath88 line near the critical point ( fig.[fig : velocity]a ) .
also , as shown in fig.[fig : velocity]b , eq . agrees well with the numerically extracted domain - wall velocity .
mean - field theory suggests that the steady state of the master equation in eq . undergoes an ising - like phase transition in sufficiently high spatial dimensions .
however , in order to understand the detailed nature of this phase transition , and to determine its lower critical dimension , fluctuations must be taken into account . as discussed in sec.[sec : formalism ] , for large @xmath65 the dominant fluctuations are captured by working with the stochastic and dissipative gross - pitaevskii equation in eq . , reproduced here for clarity , @xmath133 at this level of approximation , expectation values of the classical field are obtained by averaging the solution of eq . over realizations of the noise @xmath80 , @xmath134 . though we can not solve eq .
analytically , simple arguments can be made to explain many features of the steady state quantitatively near the mean - field critical point , and qualitatively even away from it .
as before , the near critical dynamics is simplified by decomposing the field as @xmath135 .
adiabatic elimination of @xmath107 can again be performed perturbatively in @xmath87 and @xmath89 ; the only subtlety is that fluctuations cause @xmath107 to undergo a lattice version of the ornstein - uhlenbeck process @xcite , which feeds back into the equation of motion for @xmath108 as non-@xmath72-correlated noise .
however , it is straightforward to show that near the critical point the correlation - time of this additional noise is short compared to the dynamical timescales of @xmath108 , and it can be incorporated as a perturbative renormalization of the @xmath72-correlated noise acting directly on @xmath108 .
details of the calculation are reported in appendix [ sec : appendix_b ] , and here we simply quote the final result , @xmath136 here , @xmath113 is the same energy functional given in eq . , and @xmath137 is ( real ) gaussian white noise with variance @xmath138 equation is a spatially discretized version of model a in the hohenberg - halperin classification @xcite , suggesting that the steady - state phase transition associated with optical bistability in the driven - dissipative bose - hubbard model is , as anticipated , in the universality class of the finite - temperature classical ising model . in particular , steady - state and static observables generated by the stochastic dynamics in eq
can be computed with respect to the boltzmann weight @xmath139 with an effective temperature given by @xmath140 the large @xmath65 limit was designed to suppress fluctuations in the microscopic action and so , unsurprisingly , it corresponds to a low - temperature limit of the effective equilibrium description of the phase transition .
returning to the underlying microscopic degrees of freedom , it is straightforward to see that the dynamics of this effective theory is imprinted on experimentally measurable observables .
the connection is particularly simple near the mean - field critical point .
for example , working to lowest non - trivial order in the deviations of the fields from their mean - field critical values , straightforward algebra yields the equal - time connected density - density correlation function @xmath141 the critical properties of the finite - temperature ising model should , therefore , control the critical fluctuations of the intensity of light emitted from a coherently - driven array of exciton - polariton microcavities . before considering what happens away from the critical point
, we first briefly summarize a qualitative picture of model a dynamics and its connection to the ising model .
suppose that the system is seeded in a locally random initial configuration : we would like to know what happens to it in steady state . at short times and for @xmath99 , we expect the system to form domains of both ( locally stable ) phases , separated by domain walls . in the absence of fluctuations ( i.e. at @xmath142 ) the preferred steady state of the system
can be understood by simple domain - wall dynamics ; for @xmath143 one phase is preferred over the other , and the system will eventually order in that phase . if fluctuations are now turned on , domains of the less favored phase will be seeded , and the consequence of these defects depends crucially on the dimensionality . in one dimension ,
the domain walls enclosing these defects move independently of each other when they are sufficiently far apart , undergoing a biased random walk . as a result , when @xmath144 and the dynamics becomes unbiased , defects proliferate and the system will be disordered at any finite temperature . in two or more spatial dimensions , defects of the less favored phase will still be seeded by fluctuations , but small defects contract aggressively even as @xmath144 due to a surface tension .
therefore , at least at sufficiently small temperature , as @xmath144 the system remains ordered in a phase that depends on whether @xmath87 approaches zero from below or above , indicating a first - order phase transition . .
the left panel is just on the dark side of the crossover , the middle panel is roughly in the middle of the crossover , and the right panel is just on the bright side of the crossover .
the color indicates the density . ]
since the above argument relies very little on the dynamics being relaxational , and primarily on the existence of domain walls that in the absence of fluctuations and for asymptotically large domains have a directional preference that changes as we move through the bistable region , it is reasonable to expect the qualitative picture described above to be valid even away from the critical point .
nevertheless , because the dynamics generated by eq . does not induce an equilibrium steady - state distribution far away from the critical point , it is important to verify this picture numerically . to this end
, we carry out a brute - force numerical integration of eq . using a fixed time - step first - order euler - mayurama method . after a burn - in time , the equations are integrated until statistical error bars ( @xmath145 ) of fractional size 0.01 are achieved for the density .
temporal autocorrelations on time - scales of @xmath146 the total integration time are also required to fall below a similar threshold to ensure that the averaging time is long compared to all dynamical time - scales , which can become anomalously large near the crossover or phase transition .
example results of these numerics in one spatial dimension are shown in fig.[fig : dynamics_1d ] , and reflect the spatio - temporal dynamics of output light intensity that would be observed if the model were realized in an array of exciton - polariton microcavities .
as expected , by sweeping vertically through the mean - field bistable region , we change from a dominantly dark steady - state with small domains of the bright phase to a predominantly bright steady - state with small domains of the dark phase . because the domain walls are unbound
, this change manifests as a smooth crossover rather than a true phase transition , as confirmed in the 1d phase diagram shown in fig.[fig : pd1d]a ( in particular , see the cross - section plotted in fig.[fig : pd1d]c ) . in two dimensions ( figs.[fig : pd1d]b and [ fig : pd1d]d ) , there is a clear first - order phase transition between the bright and dark phases , consistent with the expected equilibrium physics of the 2d ising model . sites ( in both cases periodic boundary conditions were used ) . for both plots ,
the parameters used are @xmath147 .
the solid white line locates the ( near - critical ) condition for a vanishing domain - wall velocity , @xmath88 , while the white circles indicate numerically obtained velocity zeros .
the dashed white lines indicate the parameter regime used for plots ( c , d ) .
note that the phase diagrams are cut off at small @xmath14 , or equivalently low effective temperature , because statistically converged numerical solutions of eq .
require prohibitively long integration times as fluctuations become weaker .
( c , d ) cuts through the phase diagrams indicated by dashed white lines in ( a ) and ( b ) . in 1d ( c )
the mean - field phase transition is smoothed out into a crossover , while in 2d ( d ) bistability leads to a true first - order phase transition .
the error bars in ( c ) and ( d ) are smaller than the size of the plot markers . ]
by bringing together a number of ideas from both quantum optics and condensed - matter physics , we have identified a limit of the driven - dissipative bose - hubbard model in which the dominant fluctuations are captured by non - equilibrium langevin equations , enabling a quantitatively accurate and computationally efficient determination of steady - state properties . near the critical point , these fluctuations are thermal and lead to an effective equilibrium description .
however , we emphasize that the langevin description of the problem should be asymptotically exact in the limit of @xmath69 even away from the critical point , where an equilibrium description is _ not _ valid .
numerically , we find that in 2d the first - order phase transition expected from the mapping onto an ising model remains in tact far from the critical point , where this mapping is not strictly valid .
in addition , the absence of a phase transition in 1d is the result of the same domain - wall phenomenology that prevents ordering of the 1d ising model at finite temperatures . in this way ,
the numerical results reinforce and extend the assertion that the steady - state behavior of the driven - dissipative bose - hubbard model possesses an emergent description in terms of the equilibrium physics of a finite - temperature classical ising model .
these conclusions have direct consequences for a range of experiments in which particle loss is countered by coherent driving , for example a coherently driven exciton - polariton fluid in an array of semiconductor microcavities . here , by tuning the laser driving strength through the mean - field bistable regime , one should be able to observe domain growth , hysteresis , critical fluctuations , and other generic features of the ising model in a longitudinal field , all by simple correlation measurements on the output intensities of the cavities .
we caution that any claims about the universality class of the phase transition require more than just a microscopically accurate treatment of fluctuations
it is also important to identify the relevance of any ignored fluctuations in the sense of the renormalization group , even if they are parametrically small . in other words
, there is no guarantee that small ( @xmath0 ) quantitative errors at the scale of the lattice spacing will not qualitatively affect the nature of the phase transition .
renormalization group arguments in favor of the ising universality class have already been presented @xcite , however the status of the first - order phase transition away from the critical point is less clear .
it would be worthwhile to extend the numerical approach taken in sec.[sec : langevin ] to confirm the universal aspects of both the critical point and the first - order phase transition .
it would also be worthwhile to compare some of the results in 1d with numerically exact calculations based on the density - matrix renormalization group @xcite in order to better understand the importance of higher - order ( in @xmath0 ) corrections that are not captured by the langevin description .
in particular , at large @xmath10 ( small @xmath65 ) , mean - field arguments suggest that the inclusion of fluctuations ignored to leading order in @xmath0 may lead to richer steady - state behaviors @xcite , including phases that spontaneously break discrete spatial - translation symmetry @xcite . in 2d
, the formalism described here could be used to compute other dynamical aspects of the system near the first - order phase transition ; for example , it should be possible to calculate the lifetime of the metastable phase via an instanton approach .
we thank cristiano ciuti , sebastian diehl , howard carmichael , sarang gopalakrishnan , victor gurarie , ana maria rey , murray holland , anzi hu , michael fleischhauer , and chih - wei lai for helpful discussions .
, j.t.y . , and a.v.g .
acknowledge support by arl cdqi , aro muri , nsf qis , aro , nsf pfc at jqi , and afosr .
r.m.w . acknowledges partial support from the national science foundation under grant no .
phys- 1516421 .
m.h . acknowledges support by afosr - muri , onr and sloan foundation .
the path integral presented in sec.[sec : formalism ] is closely related to the usual keldysh functional integral formalism , for which there are many good references ( see for example ref.@xcite ) .
however , there is a subtle difference between the formalism used here and that typically employed in the condensed matter community , and it therefore seems worthwhile to provide an explicit derivation of eqs.([eq : partition_function]-[eq : psi_eq_time ] ) . for simplicity
, we will treat only the single - cavity case , but the generalization to many cavities that yields eqs.([eq : partition_function]-[eq : psi_eq_time ] ) follows immediately . in any path integral formulation of quantum mechanics
, operators must be traded in for classical variables . the usual way to do this , as is the case in the standard approach to the keldysh function integral , is to repeatedly insert coherent - state resolutions of identity during the time - evolution .
operators get sandwiched between coherent states , and if they are normal - ordered they turn into functions of phase space variables . in the language of quantum optics ,
operators are exchanged for their @xmath148-symbols .
however , there are many different ways to associate operators with functions over phase space , and thus many ways to formulate a path integral . in the following derivation
, we will replace operators with classical variables by working in the weyl representation ( see for example ref.@xcite ) . in our opinion , even though this strategy entails some additional overhead in phase - space formalism , it is both more direct and conceptually simpler than the usual approach to the keldysh functional integral . in particular ,
the canonical approach described in refs.@xcite relies on the construction of a formal continuous - time notation that together with simple rules for computing equal - time correlation functions correctly reproduces the continuous - time limit of the greens functions of a non - interacting bose field .
interactions are then included in a self - consistent fashion by ensuring that the rules for gaussian integration produce correct results for the interacting theory at all order of perturbation theory . in the approach taken here ,
the path integral is derived constructively in such a way that an unambiguous continuous - time notation emerges naturally from a properly defined ( i.e. discretized ) functional integral .
the weyl - symbol of an arbitrary operator @xmath149 , denoted @xmath150 , can be defined via the relation @xmath151 here , the weyl - ordered ( and operator valued ) delta function is defined by @xmath152 when convenient , the correspondence between operators and their weyl symbols will be indicated below with the notation @xmath153 . given the special role played by the density operator @xmath154 ,
it is traditional to use a special notation for its weyl symbol , @xmath155 , which is also called the wigner function ; the explicit time - dependence is included because we will work in the schrdinger picture , where the density matrix ( and therefore the wigner function ) evolves in time .
the weyl representation is intimately related to symmetrically ordered operator products ; if an arbitrary operator @xmath149 is expanded in terms of symmetrically - ordered operator products , @xmath156_{\rm s},\end{aligned}\ ] ] then the coefficients in this expansion determine the weyl symbol @xmath150 in a particularly natural way , @xmath157 given the wigner function at an initial time @xmath32 , we would like to understand how it has changed a short time @xmath158 later due to the evolution of the density matrix by the master equation . during this time , the density matrix evolves according to @xmath159 , where the infinitesimal time evolution ( super-)operator @xmath160 satisfies @xmath161\\ & + \delta t\frac{\kappa}{2}\sum_{j}\big(2\hat{a}^{\phantom\dagger}_j\star \hat{a}^{\dagger}_j-\star\hat{a}^{\dagger}_j\hat{a}^{\phantom\dagger}_j-\hat{a}^{\dagger}_j\hat{a}^{\phantom\dagger}_j\star\big)+\mathcal{o}(\delta t^2).\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] this transformation induces a corresponding evolution of the wigner function , which for now we write formally as @xmath162 thereby implicitly defining the infinitesimal phase - space propagator for the wigner function , @xmath163 . from the structure of eqs.([eq : meq_inf],[eq : weq_inf ] ) , it is clear that finding the explicit form of @xmath163 requires us to compute the weyl symbol of products of @xmath154 with creation and annihilation operators . to this end
we define an operator - valued generating function @xmath164 which can be differentiated to produce symmetrically ordered operator products @xmath165_{\rm s}\hat{\rho}(t_0).\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eq . and
eq . , we can expand the product of an arbitrary operator with the density matrix as @xmath166 giving us a prescription to compute the weyl symbol of @xmath167 from the weyl symbol of @xmath168 @xmath169 making use of the standard operator phase - space correspondences @xcite , @xmath170 the commutation relations @xmath171=1 $ ] , @xmath172=0 $ ] , and the baker - campbell - hausdorff formula , the weyl symbol of @xmath168 can be written @xmath173 inserting a standard representation of the delta function and integrating by parts , we obtain @xmath174 note that the choice of a generating function that produced symmetrically ordered operator products also led to all of the derivatives appearing on the left in the first line of eq . , which enabled the integration by parts to proceed in a particularly simple manner to obtain eq .. inserting eq .
into eq . and then using eq . , we obtain @xmath175 given eq . , we can now deduce eq . from eq .. to first order in @xmath158 we find @xmath176 where @xmath177 the wigner function at a general time @xmath86 can be obtained from the wigner function at time @xmath32 by iteration of eq .. breaking the interval @xmath178 $ ] into @xmath179 segments of size @xmath180 , we obtain @xmath181 here we have defined the discretized action @xmath182 defining functional integration measures that include the fields @xmath183 at the final time , @xmath184 the trace of the wigner function at time @xmath86 can now be written @xmath185 the continuous - time limit ( @xmath186 ) of eqs.([eq : discrete_action]-[eq : discrete_partition_function ] ) , generalized to many coherently coupled bosonic modes , yields eqs.([eq : partition_function],[eq : action ] ) of the main text .
the functional integral representation of the wigner function lends itself naturally to calculating correlation functions that are time - ordered along the keldysh contour ( fig.[fig : keldysh ] ) , e.g. @xmath187 here , @xmath188 is written in the heisenberg picture , and @xmath46 orders operators at times with a `` @xmath47 '' superscript such that the times increase from right to left , and orders operators at times with a `` @xmath48 '' superscript such that the times increase from left to right .
note that the heisenberg picture is to be interpreted _ before _ the adiabatic elimination of the reservoir , which we assume proceeds within the born - markov approximation .
assuming without loss of generality that @xmath189 , insisting that the operators be inserted at the discretized time - slices chosen above , ( @xmath190 , with @xmath191 an integer between @xmath192 and @xmath179 ) , and making the notational change @xmath193 , @xmath188 can be written @xmath194 for our purposes we need to rewrite this correlation function in the schrdinger picture , which can be accomplished with the help of the quantum regression formula .
for example , if @xmath195 , we have @xcite @xmath196 the choice of keldysh - ordering is necessary and sufficient to guarantee that , in the quantum regression formula , it will never be necessary to evolve backwards in time . using the path - integral expression for the wigner function at time @xmath86 , together with the phase space correspondences for operators @xmath149 and @xmath197 , we find @xmath198 such correlation functions can be conveniently computed with respect to a generating functional by adding source terms to action,@xmath199 here @xmath200 and @xmath201 with @xmath202 restricting to the special case when the operators @xmath149 and @xmath197 are creation and annihilation operators , defining @xmath203 and taking the continuum limit @xmath204 , we recover the expressions for correlation functions in sec.[sec : formalism ] of the main text .
here we describe the perturbative adiabatic elimination of the field @xmath107 near the mean - field critical point . for simplicity
, we will first treat the case with no fluctuations ( @xmath216 ) , and afterwards we will consider the effect of weak fluctuations . substitution of eq . into eq .
yields coupled equations for @xmath107 and @xmath108 that are fully equivalent to the mean - field dynamics of @xmath74 . to simplify the following expressions we convert all energy / time scales into dimensionless rations with the chemical potential @xmath68 , and in a slight abuse of notation we do not change any of the associated symbols the @xmath68-dependence can be unambiguously restored by insisting on dimensional consistency .
after some algebra , we find @xmath217 where @xmath218 several simplifications can now be made .
first , because we are interested in dynamics near the critical point and after the field has nearly relaxed , @xmath87 , @xmath89 , @xmath107 , and @xmath108 can all be treated as small parameters . though we do not know _ a priori
_ how small the fields @xmath107 and @xmath108 are relative to the parameters @xmath89 and @xmath87 , it is perfectly consistent to keep , at any particular order in one of the parameters , only the lowest non - trivial order in any other parameter .
moreover , while we do nt know how small spatial derivatives of the field are , we do expect them to be small compared to the fields themselves , which should vary slowly in space near the critical point , and thus we formally treat @xmath219 as an additional small parameter ( one can check that this assumption is self consistent at the end of the calculation , where it will be seen that @xmath220 ) . following this logic , and introducing the rescaled parameters @xmath221 and @xmath222 used in the main text , we arrive at the simplified equations @xmath223 terms that are kept with the @xmath224 notation are there to remind us that we do not know for sure whether they are parametrically small compared to other terms that are kept
they will turn out to be unimportant for reasons explained below , which is why we do nt keep track of the exact coefficients .
the justification for adiabatically eliminating @xmath107 near the critical point is now clear : as @xmath225 , the term proportional to @xmath107 in eq
. stays finite , indicating that @xmath107 relaxes to zero exponentially in time even at the critical point ( once @xmath68 is restored , we see that it decays on a timescale @xmath226 ) . on the other hand , the term linear in @xmath108 in eq .
vanishes as @xmath225 , indicating a divergent timescale for relaxation of @xmath108 ( which relaxes algebraically precisely at the critical point , @xmath227 ) . to adiabatically eliminate @xmath107 we set the r.h.s of eq .
to zero , obtaining @xmath228 and then substitute this result into eq .. many derivative terms are generated , but working to lowest order in @xmath229 we find @xmath230 here we have implicitly assumed that @xmath231 to write @xmath232 , which poses no important restriction on what follows . if we ignore the final two terms and solve eq . at @xmath88 and @xmath99 ( inside the bistable region ) , we find two uniform solutions at @xmath233 , which sets the scale of @xmath108 in the relevant near - critical dynamics , @xmath234 . from this scaling , it is easily seen that the final two terms in eq .
are parametrically smaller than the others ; thus we were justified in dropping them , which results in eq . in the main text .
substitution of eq . into eq .
yields coupled stochastic equations for @xmath107 and @xmath108 that are fully equivalent to the non - equilibrium langevin equation for @xmath74 . in the limit of weak noise , an expansion in @xmath107 and @xmath108 is still justified .
moreover , since arbitrarily weak noise will induce arbitrarily small excursions away from the mean - field stationary state , much of the analysis that lead to an effective relaxational description of @xmath108 ( that is approximately decoupled from @xmath107 ) should remain valid , as it assumed nothing more than being close to both the critical point and the steady state . working near the mean - field critical point , the same assumptions that lead from eqs.([eq : rho_expand]-[eq : sigma_expand ] ) to eqs.([eq : eqm_rho]-[eq : eqm_sigma ] ) remain justified and yield ( for now keeping all gradient terms ) @xmath235 in order to avoid confusion regarding the noise variances , here
we have chosen a new symbol for the dimensionless time , @xmath236 ( so @xmath237 , etc . ) , even though we continue to use the same symbols for the ( now dimensionless ) energies @xmath89 , @xmath87 , @xmath124 , and @xmath238 .
the real noises @xmath239 and @xmath240 are defined @xmath241 where @xmath242 and @xmath243 are the real and imaginary components , respectively , of the complex gaussian white noise @xmath244 in eq .. thus from the variances of @xmath244 we have @xmath245 where one factor of @xmath246 has been absorbed into the now dimensionless @xmath14 and one is used to change variables from @xmath86 to @xmath122 in the @xmath72 function .
we would like to eliminate the terms in eq .
that involve @xmath107 , but , strictly speaking , the adiabatic elimination of @xmath107 by setting @xmath247 in eq .
is no longer justified . nevertheless ,
for weak noise and near the critical point , there will be a separation of timescales , length - scales , and typical sizes of the fluctuations of @xmath108 and @xmath107 . because @xmath107 remains massive at the mean - field critical point while @xmath108 does not
, we expect that in the presence of noise the scale of typical fluctuations for @xmath107 will be small compared to the scale of typical fluctuations for @xmath108 .
likewise , @xmath108 will relax more slowly than @xmath107 near the critical point , and will exhibit fluctuations on a longer length - scale , i.e. in the presence of fluctuations it will have a longer autocorrelation time than @xmath107 , and will be roughly spatially homogeneous over the length - scale on which @xmath107 is correlated . on the grounds of the latter statement ,
it is justified to solve eq . at _ fixed _
@xmath108 and within a local - density approximation ( i.e. we assume that @xmath107 is relaxing in a locally homogeneous environment set by the slowly varying value of @xmath108 ) , in which case @xmath107 simply undergoes a lattice version of ornstein - uhlenbeck relaxation to the mean value @xmath248 straightforward analysis reveals that fluctuations of @xmath107 around its mean value , @xmath249 , obey @xmath250 where @xmath251 and @xmath252 are the correlation length and correlation time of the massive field @xmath107 , respectively .
inserting the solution @xmath253 into eq . , and keeping for now all terms that involve the fluctuations @xmath254 we obtain @xmath255 the first and third terms on the second line , @xmath256 and @xmath257 , contain terms that are either higher order in @xmath108 , @xmath89 , or in gradients than other terms on the first line , and thus can be ignored .
the remaining terms depend on @xmath254 ; because the dynamics of @xmath108 is slow and dominated by long wave - length fluctuations , we can approximate @xmath254 as spatially uncorrelated white noise with variance @xmath258 in light of this approximation , the term @xmath259 acts as an additional source of additive white noise it can in principle be taken into account as a ( @xmath124-dependent ) renormalization of the noise @xmath260 that is already present , but if we work to lowest - order in @xmath124 this renormalization can be ignored .
the term @xmath261 acts as a source of multiplicative noise ; since @xmath262 is itself a small parameter , this noise can also be ignored in comparison to the already present white noise @xmath260 .
the term @xmath263 should be interpreted by writing @xmath264 , where @xmath265 is the average of @xmath266 and @xmath267 is its flucuations .
the average @xmath268 can be ignored for weak noise , while the fluctuations @xmath267 obey ( using the fact that @xmath254 is a gaussian variable ) @xmath269 as with @xmath254 , @xmath267 can be interpreted as spatially - uncorrelated gaussian white noise as far as the slow dynamics of @xmath108 is concerned . since it has a variance that is parametrically smaller than that of @xmath240 , it can once again be ignored . with all of the terms on the second line of eq
. dropped , we recover eq .
of the main text .
as described in the main text , the domain wall velocity can be determined by solving for the dynamics of a fictitous particle obeying the equation of motion @xmath270 where @xmath271 here the domain - wall velocity @xmath126 plays the role of a velocity dependent friction coefficient .
we seek solutions of eq .
for which the particle starts ( with @xmath272 ) at the higher local maximum of @xmath125 and comes to rest at the lower one . when @xmath87 is small the two local maxima have similar energies , and the friction coefficient @xmath126 must also be small for the particle to reach the top of the lower potential maximum .
thus the trajectory is similar to that in the case of @xmath88 , for which ( from conservation of energy ) @xmath273 , such that @xmath274 the work done along this trajectory by the friction must be equal to the change in potential energy , @xmath275 inserting eq . into eq .
, taking the integral , and using @xmath276 , we obtain the domain - wall velocity given in the main text , @xmath277 84ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.93.99 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.85.299 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0034-4885/79/i=9/a=096001 [ * * , ( ) ] https://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1604.04433 [ ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/2040-8986/18/i=10/a=104005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1074464 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature05131 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.230602 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys3143 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys2251 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.233603 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevx.4.031043 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ncomms8654 [ * * , ( ) ] https://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1502.04016 [ ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys466 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.100.233602 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.104.203603 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature13188 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1237125 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ncomms4808 [ * * ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature05586 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature05147 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.133602 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature11361 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.113901 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.113.023006 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys1403 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.82.043612 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.257204 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.90.021603 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.195301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevx.6.031011 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevx.5.011017 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.114.040402 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys462 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.103.033601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.233601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.94.033801 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature06334 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.112.116402 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphoton.2015.65 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ncomms11887 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.76.031805 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.053601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.92.174305 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevx.4.031039 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.130.1605 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.40.546 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.90.063821 [ * * , ( ) ] https://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1502.04016 [ ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.206809 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys1223 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.104.113601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.87.053846 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.87.023831 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.93.014307 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.91.051601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.116.245701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.116.070407 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.113.210401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.17.335 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.43.6194 [ * * , ( ) ] https://arxiv.org/abs/1608.00717 [ ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.80.033624 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aop.2010.02.006 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.68.053604 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/00018730902850504 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0003-4916(67)90200-x [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.36.823 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.49.435 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/00018732.2014.933502 [ * * , ( ) ] | many - body systems constructed of quantum - optical building blocks can now be realized in experimental platforms ranging from exciton - polariton fluids to ultracold gases of rydberg atoms , establishing a fascinating interface between traditional many - body physics and the driven - dissipative , non - equilibrium setting of cavity - qed . at this interface ,
the standard techniques and intuitions of both fields are called into question , obscuring issues as fundamental as the role of fluctuations , dimensionality , and symmetry on the nature of collective behavior and phase transitions . here , we study the driven - dissipative bose - hubbard model , a minimal description of numerous atomic , optical , and solid - state systems in which particle loss
is countered by coherent driving . despite being a lattice version of optical bistability
a foundational and patently _ non - equilibrium _ model of cavity - qed the steady state possesses an emergent _ equilibrium _ description in terms of a classical ising model .
we establish this picture by identifying a limit in which the quantum dynamics is asymptotically equivalent to non - equilibrium langevin equations , which support a phase transition described by model a of the hohenberg - halperin classification .
numerical simulations of the langevin equations corroborate this picture , producing results consistent with the behavior of a finite - temperature ising model . |
the investigation of weak decays of mesons composed of a heavy quark and antiquark gives a very important insight in the heavy quark dynamics .
the properties of the @xmath0 meson are of special interest , since it is the only heavy meson consisting of two heavy quarks with different flavor .
this difference of quark flavors forbids annihilation into gluons . as a result ,
the excited @xmath0 meson states lying below the @xmath2 production threshold undergo pionic or radiative transitions to the pseudoscalar ground state which is considerably more stable than corresponding charmonium or bottomonium states and decays only weakly . the collider detector at fermilab ( cdf ) collaboration @xcite reported the discovery of the @xmath0 ground state in @xmath3 collisions .
more experimental data are expected to come in near future from the tevatron and large hadron collider ( lhc ) .
the characteristic feature of the @xmath0 meson is that both quarks forming it are heavy and thus their weak decays give comparable contributions to the total decay rate .
therefore it is necessary to consider both the @xmath4 quark decays @xmath5 with the @xmath6 quark being a spectator and @xmath6 quark decays @xmath7 with @xmath4 quark being a spectator .
the former transitions lead to semileptonic decays to charmonium and @xmath1 mesons while the latter lead to decays to @xmath8 and @xmath9 mesons .
the estimates of the @xmath0 decay rates indicate that the @xmath10 quark decays give the dominant contribution ( @xmath11 ) while the @xmath4 quark decays and weak annihilation contribute about 20% and 10% , respectively ( for a recent review see e.g. @xcite and references therein )
. however , from the experimental point of view the @xmath0 decays to charmonium are easier to identify .
indeed , cdf observed @xmath0 mesons @xcite analysing their semileptonic decays @xmath12 .
the important difference between the @xmath0 semileptonic decays induced by @xmath5 and @xmath13 transitions lies in the substantial difference of their kinematical ranges . in the case of @xmath0
decays to charmonium and @xmath14 mesons the kinematical range ( the square of momentum transfer to the lepton pair varies from 0 to @xmath15 gev@xmath16 for decays to @xmath17 and @xmath18 gev@xmath16 for decays to @xmath1 mesons ) is considerably broader than for decays to @xmath19 and @xmath20 mesons ( @xmath21 gev@xmath16 for decays to @xmath8 and @xmath22 gev@xmath16 for decays to @xmath9 mesons ) . as a result in the @xmath0 meson rest frame the maximum recoil momentum of the final charmonium and @xmath1 mesons is of the same order of magnitude as their masses ,
while the maximum recoil momentum of the @xmath19 and @xmath20 mesons is considerably smaller than the meson masses .
this significant difference in kinematics makes it reasonable to consider @xmath0 decays induced by @xmath4 and @xmath10 quark decays separately . in this paper
we consider weak @xmath0 decays to charmonium and @xmath1 mesons in the framework of the relativistic quark model based on the quasipotential approach in quantum field theory .
this model has been successfully applied for the calculations of mass spectra , radiative and weak decays of heavy quarkonia and heavy - light mesons @xcite . in our recent paper @xcite we applied this model for the investigation of properties of the @xmath0 meson and heavy quarkonia .
the relativistic wave functions obtained there are used for the calculation of the transition matrix elements .
the consistent theoretical description of @xmath0 decays to charmonium and @xmath1 mesons requires a reliable determination of the @xmath23 dependence of the decay amplitudes in the whole kinematical range . in most previous calculations
the corresponding decay form factors were determined only at one kinematical point either @xmath24 or @xmath25 and then extrapolated to the allowed kinematical range using some phenomenological ansatz ( mainly ( di)pole or gaussian ) .
our aim is to explicitly determine the @xmath23 dependence of form factors in the whole kinematical range in order to avoid extrapolations thus reducing uncertainties .
the large values of recoil momentum require the consistent relativistic treatment of these decays .
in particular , the relativistic transformation of the meson wave functions from the moving to the rest reference frame should be taken into account .
on the other hand , the presence of only heavy quarks in @xmath0 and charmonium allows one to use expansions in the inverse powers of heavy quark masses @xmath26 .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ rqm ] we describe the underlying relativistic quark model .
the method for calculating matrix elements of the weak current for @xmath5 transitions in @xmath0 meson decays is presented in sec .
special attention is devoted to the dependence of the decay amplitudes on the momentum transfer .
the @xmath0 decay form factors are calculated in the whole kinematical range in sec .
the @xmath23 dependence of the form factors is explicitly determined .
these form factors are used for the calculation of the @xmath0 semileptonic decay rates in sec .
section [ nl ] contains our predictions for the energetic nonleptonic @xmath0 decays in the factorization approximation , and a comparison of our results with other theoretical calculations is presented .
our conclusions are given in sec .
[ sec : conc ] .
finally , the appendix contains complete expressions for the decay form factors .
in the quasipotential approach a meson is described by the wave function of the bound quark - antiquark state , which satisfies the quasipotential equation @xcite of the schrdinger type @xcite @xmath27 where the relativistic reduced mass is @xmath28 and @xmath29 , @xmath30 are the center of mass energies on mass shell given by @xmath31 here @xmath32 is the meson mass , @xmath33 are the quark masses , and @xmath34 is their relative momentum . in the center of mass system
the relative momentum squared on mass shell reads @xmath35[m^2-(m_1-m_2)^2]}{4m^2}.\ ] ] the kernel @xmath36 in eq .
( [ quas ] ) is the quasipotential operator of the quark - antiquark interaction .
it is constructed with the help of the off - mass - shell scattering amplitude , projected onto the positive energy states .
constructing the quasipotential of the quark - antiquark interaction , we have assumed that the effective interaction is the sum of the usual one - gluon exchange term with the mixture of long - range vector and scalar linear confining potentials , where the vector confining potential contains the pauli interaction .
the quasipotential is then defined by @xcite @xmath37 with @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the qcd coupling constant , @xmath40 is the gluon propagator in the coulomb gauge @xmath41 and @xmath42 ; @xmath43 and @xmath44 are the dirac matrices and spinors @xmath45 here @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the pauli matrices and spinors ; @xmath48 .
the effective long - range vector vertex is given by @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the pauli interaction constant characterizing the long - range anomalous chromomagnetic moment of quarks .
vector and scalar confining potentials in the nonrelativistic limit reduce to @xmath51 reproducing @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the mixing coefficient .
the expression for the quasipotential of the heavy quarkonia , expanded in @xmath54 without and with retardation corrections to the confining potential , can be found in refs .
@xcite and @xcite , respectively .
the structure of the spin - dependent interaction is in agreement with the parameterization of eichten and feinberg @xcite .
the quasipotential for the heavy quark interaction with a light antiquark without employing the expansion in inverse powers of the light quark mass is given in ref .
all the parameters of our model like quark masses , parameters of the linear confining potential @xmath55 and @xmath9 , mixing coefficient @xmath53 and anomalous chromomagnetic quark moment @xmath50 are fixed from the analysis of heavy quarkonium masses @xcite and radiative decays @xcite .
the quark masses @xmath56 gev , @xmath57 gev , @xmath58 gev and the parameters of the linear potential @xmath59 gev@xmath16 and @xmath60 gev have usual values of quark models .
the value of the mixing coefficient of vector and scalar confining potentials @xmath61 has been determined from the consideration of the heavy quark expansion for the semileptonic @xmath62 decays @xcite and charmonium radiative decays @xcite .
finally , the universal pauli interaction constant @xmath63 has been fixed from the analysis of the fine splitting of heavy quarkonia @xmath64- states @xcite .
note that the long - range magnetic contribution to the potential in our model is proportional to @xmath65 and thus vanishes for the chosen value of @xmath63 .
it has been known for a long time that the correct reproduction of the spin - dependent part of the quark - antiquark interaction requires either assuming the scalar confinement or equivalently introducing the pauli interaction with @xmath63 @xcite in the vector confinement .
in order to calculate the exclusive semileptonic decay rate of the @xmath0 meson , it is necessary to determine the corresponding matrix element of the weak current between meson states . in the quasipotential approach ,
the matrix element of the weak current @xmath67 , associated with @xmath68 ( @xmath69 or @xmath70 ) transition , between a @xmath0 meson with mass @xmath71 and momentum @xmath72 and a final meson @xmath73 ( @xmath74 or @xmath14 ) with mass @xmath75 and momentum @xmath76 takes the form @xcite @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the two - particle vertex function and @xmath79 are the meson ( @xmath80 wave functions projected onto the positive energy states of quarks and boosted to the moving reference frame with momentum @xmath81 . contributing to the current matrix element ( [ mxet ] ) .
[ d1 ] ] taking the quark interaction into account .
dashed lines correspond to the effective potential @xmath82 in ( [ qpot ] ) .
bold lines denote the negative - energy part of the quark propagator .
[ d2 ] ] the contributions to @xmath83 come from figs . [ d1 ] and [ d2 ] .
the contribution @xmath84 is the consequence of the projection onto the positive - energy states .
note that the form of the relativistic corrections resulting from the vertex function @xmath84 is explicitly dependent on the lorentz structure of the quark - antiquark interaction . in the leading order of the @xmath54 expansion for @xmath0 and @xmath85 and in the heavy quark limit @xmath86 for @xmath1
only @xmath87 contributes , while @xmath84 contributes already at the subleading order .
the vertex functions look like @xmath88 and @xmath89 where the superscripts ( 1 ) " and ( 2 ) " correspond to figs .
[ d1 ] and [ d2 ] , @xmath90 ; @xmath91 here @xcite @xmath92 and @xmath93 are three four - vectors given by @xmath94 it is important to note that the wave functions entering the weak current matrix element ( [ mxet ] ) are not in the rest frame in general . for example , in the @xmath0 meson rest frame ( @xmath95 ) , the final meson is moving with the recoil momentum @xmath96 .
the wave function of the moving meson @xmath97 is connected with the wave function in the rest frame @xmath98 by the transformation @xcite @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the wigner rotation , @xmath101 is the lorentz boost from the meson rest frame to a moving one , and the rotation matrix @xmath102 in spinor representation is given by @xmath103 where @xmath104 is the usual lorentz transformation matrix of the four - spinor .
the general structure of the current matrix element ( [ mxet ] ) is rather complicated , because it is necessary to integrate both with respect to @xmath105 and @xmath106 .
the @xmath107-function in the expression ( [ gamma1 ] ) for the vertex function @xmath87 permits to perform one of these integrations . as a result
the contribution of @xmath87 to the current matrix element has the usual structure of an overlap integral of meson wave functions and can be calculated exactly ( without employing any expansion ) in the whole kinematical range , if the wave functions of the initial and final meson are known .
the situation with the contribution @xmath84 is different . here , instead of a @xmath107-function
, we have a complicated structure , containing the potential of the @xmath108-interaction in meson .
thus in the general case we can not get rid of one of the integrations in the contribution of @xmath84 to the matrix element ( [ mxet ] ) . therefore , it is necessary to use some additional considerations in order to simplify calculations . the main idea is to expand the vertex function @xmath84 , given by ( [ gamma2 ] ) , in such a way that it will be possible to use the quasipotential equation ( [ quas ] ) in order to perform one of the integrations in the current matrix element ( [ mxet ] )
. * @xmath109 transitions . *
the natural expansion parameters for @xmath0 decays to charmonium are the active heavy @xmath4 and @xmath10 quark masses as well as the spectator @xmath10 quark mass .
we carry such an expansion up to the second order in the ratios of the relative quark momentum @xmath34 and binding energy to the heavy quark masses @xmath110 .
it is important to take into account the fact that in the case of weak @xmath0 decays caused by @xmath5 quark transition the kinematically allowed range is large ( @xmath111 @xmath112 gev for decays to charmonium and @xmath113 gev for decays to @xmath1 mesons ) .
this means that the recoil momentum @xmath96 of a final meson is large in comparison to the relative momentum @xmath34 of quarks inside a meson ( @xmath114 gev ) , being of the same order as the heavy quark mass almost in the whole kinematical range .
thus we do not use expansions in powers of @xmath115 or @xmath116 , but approximate in the expression ( [ gamma2 ] ) for @xmath84 the heavy quark energies @xmath117 by @xmath118 , which become independent of the quark relative momentum @xmath34 . making these replacements and expansions
we see that it is possible to integrate the current matrix element ( [ mxet ] ) either with respect to @xmath105 or @xmath106 using the quasipotential equation ( [ quas ] ) .
performing integrations and taking the sum of the contributions of @xmath87 and @xmath84 we get the expression for the current matrix element , which contains ordinary overlap integrals of meson wave functions and is valid in the whole kinematical range .
thus this matrix element can be easily calculated using numerical wave functions found in our meson mass spectrum analysis @xcite .
the reduced radial wave functions @xmath119 of the @xmath0 meson are shown in fig .
[ bcwf ] .
-states of the @xmath0 meson .
[ bcwf ] ] * @xmath120 transitions . * in this case the heavy @xmath4 quark undergoes the weak transition to the light @xmath70 quark .
the constituent @xmath70 quark mass is of the same order of magnitude as the relative momentum and binding energy , thus we can not apply the expansion in inverse powers of its mass . nevertheless , taking into account the fact that the recoil momentum of the final meson in this decay is large almost in the whole kinematical range ( as it was discussed above )
, we can neglect the relative momentum @xmath34 of quarks inside a meson with respect to the large recoil momentum @xmath96 .
thus in the region of large recoil ( @xmath121 ) we can use the same expressions of the @xmath84 contribution to the current matrix element both for the @xmath122 and @xmath123 transitions . moreover ,
the smallness of the @xmath84 contribution , which is proportional to the small binding energy , and its weak dependence on momentum transfer allows one to extrapolate these formulae to the whole kinematical range . as numerical estimates show ( see below ) , such extrapolation introduces only small uncertainties .
the matrix elements of the weak current @xmath125 for @xmath0 decays to pseudoscalar mesons ( @xmath126 ) can be parametrized by two invariant form factors : @xmath127 + f_0(q^2)\frac{m_{b_c}^2-m_p^2}{q^2}\ q^\mu,\ ] ] where @xmath128 ; @xmath71 is the @xmath0 meson mass and @xmath129 is the pseudoscalar meson mass .
the corresponding matrix elements for @xmath0 decays to vector mesons ( @xmath130 ) are parametrized by four form factors @xmath131 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath132 and @xmath133 are the mass and polarization vector of the final vector meson .
the following relations hold for the form factors at the maximum recoil point of the final meson ( @xmath24 ) @xmath134 @xmath135 in the limit of vanishing lepton mass , the form factors @xmath136 and @xmath137 do not contribute to the semileptonic decay rates . however , they contribute to nonleptonic decay rates in the factorization approximation .
it is convenient to consider @xmath0 semileptonic and nonleptonic decays in the @xmath0 meson rest frame .
then it is important to take into account the boost of the final meson wave function from the rest reference frame to the moving one with the recoil momentum @xmath96 , given by eq .
( [ wig ] ) .
now we can apply the method for calculating decay matrix elements described in the previous section . as it is argued above
, the leading contributions arising from the vertex function @xmath87 can be exactly expressed through the overlap integrals of the meson wave functions in the whole kinematical range .
for the subleading contribution @xmath84 , the expansion in powers of the ratio of the relative quark momentum @xmath34 to heavy quark masses @xmath110 should be performed taking into account that the recoil momentum of the final meson @xmath96 can be large .
such expansion is well justified for @xmath0 decays to charmonium in the whole kinematical range . for @xmath0
decays to @xmath1 mesons , where one of the final quarks is light , a similar expansion is well justified only in the kinematical region of large recoil momentum .
however , the numerical smallness of this subleading contribution due to its proportionality to the small meson binding energy permits its extrapolation to the whole kinematical range . as a result
, we get the following expressions for the @xmath0 decay form factors : \(a ) @xmath138 transitions ( @xmath139 ) @xmath140 @xmath141 \(b ) @xmath142 transition ( @xmath143 ) @xmath144 @xmath145 @xmath146 @xmath147 where @xmath148 , @xmath149 , @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 and @xmath153 are given in appendix
. the superscripts ( 1 ) " and ( 2 ) " correspond to figs .
[ d1 ] and [ d2 ] , @xmath154 and @xmath155 to the scalar and vector potentials of @xmath156-interaction .
the mixing parameter of scalar and vector confining potentials @xmath53 is fixed to be @xmath157 in our model .
it is easy to check that in the heavy quark limit the decay matrix elements ( [ eq : pff1])([eq : vff2 ] ) with form factors ( [ eq : f+])([eq : a0 ] ) satisfy the heavy quark spin symmetry relations @xcite obtained near the zero recoil point ( @xmath158 ) .
.form factors of weak @xmath0 decays ( @xmath5 transitions ) .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we calculated semileptonic and nonleptonic ( in factorization approximation ) @xmath0 decay rates .
our predictions for the branching fractions are summarized in table [ br ] , where we use the central experimental value of the @xmath0 meson lifetime @xcite . from this table
we see that the considered semileptonic decays to charmonium and @xmath1 mesons give in total 1.72% of the @xmath0 decay rate , while the energetic nonleptonic decays give additional 0.63% .
it is expected that the dominant contribution to the @xmath0 total rate comes from the charmed quark decays .
these decays will be considered in a forthcoming publication .
the authors express their gratitude to m. mller - preussker and v. savrin for support and discussions .
two of us ( r.n.f and v.o.g . ) were supported in part by the _ deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft _ under contract eb 139/2 - 2 .
\(a ) @xmath138 transition ( @xmath139 )
@xmath159[\epsilon_b(p)+m_b]}+(m_{b_c}-e_p ) \cr & & \times\left(\frac1{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q}+ \frac1{\epsilon_b(p)+m_b}\right ) \biggrb)+\frac{{\bf p}^2}{[\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q][\epsilon_b(p)+m_b ] } \cr & & + \frac23{\bf p}^2\bigglb(\frac{e_p - m_p } { [ \epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q][\epsilon_b(p)+m_b ] } \left(\frac1{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q}-\frac1{\epsilon_c(p)+m_c}\right)\cr & & + \frac{m_{b_c}-e_p}{e_p+m_p}\left(\frac1{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q}- \frac1{\epsilon_b(p)+m_b}\right)\cr & & \times\left(\frac1{\epsilon_c(p)+m_c}- \frac1{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q}\right)\biggrb)\biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath160 \cr & & + \frac{({\bf p\delta})}{{\bf \delta}^2}\bigglb ( \biggl[\frac1{2\epsilon_q(\delta)}\left(\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q } { \epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q } -\frac{m_{b_c}-e_p}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right ) -\frac1{2m_b}\biggl(\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q } { \epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b}\cr & & + \frac{m_{b_c}-e_p}{\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b}\biggr)\biggr ] \biggl[m_{b_c}+m_p-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p ) -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta\right)\cr & & -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta \right)\biggr ] -\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{2m_b\epsilon_q(\delta ) } \left(1-\frac{m_{b_c}-e_p}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right ) \cr & & \times\left[m_p-\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta \right)\right ] \biggrb)\biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath161 \biggl[m_{b_c}+m_p-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p ) -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta\right)\cr & & -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta \right)\biggr ] + 2\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta ) } \left(\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q } { \epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q } -\frac{m_{b_c}-e_p}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right ) \cr & & \times\left[m_{b_c}-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p)\right ] -\frac{2m_c(\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q)}{\epsilon_q(\delta ) [ \epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q ] } \biggl[m_p -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta\right)\cr & & -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath162[\epsilon_b(p)+m_b ] } \biggrb)+\frac{{\bf p}^2(m_{b_c}-e_p)}{[\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q][\epsilon_b(p)+m_b ] } \cr & & -\frac23{\bf p}^2(e_p - m_p ) \left(\frac1{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q}-\frac1{\epsilon_c(p)+m_c}\right ) \biggl(\frac1{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q}\cr & & - \frac1{\epsilon_b(p)+m_b}-\frac{m_{b_c}-e_p } { [ \epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q][\epsilon_b(p)+m_b]}\biggr ) \biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath163 \cr & & -\frac{({\bf p\delta})}{{\bf \delta}^2}\bigglb ( \biggl[\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}{2m_b[\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b ] } \biggl(1 + \frac{m_{b_c}-e_p}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\biggr ) -\frac1{2\epsilon_q(\delta)}\biggl(\frac{m_{b_c}-e_p } { \epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}-1\biggr)\biggr]\cr & & \times\biggl[m_{b_c}+m_p-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p ) -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta \right)\biggr]\cr & & + \frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}{2m_b\epsilon_q(\delta ) } \left(\frac{m_{b_c}-e_p}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}-
\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right ) \biggl[m_p-\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta\right ) \cr & & -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggrb)\biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath164}\biggl(\frac{m_{b_c}-e_p } { \epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}-1\biggr)\biggr ] \cr & & \times\biggl[m_{b_c}+m_p-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p ) -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta \right)\biggr]\cr & & + \frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)[\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q ] } \left[m_{b_c}-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p)\right ] -\frac{1}{\epsilon_q(\delta)}\left(\frac{m_{b_c}-e_p}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}-
\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right)\cr & & \times \biggl[m_p -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_p+m_p}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath170 \cr & & -\frac{({\bf p\delta})}{{\bf \delta}^2}\frac12 \bigglb(\left(\frac{1}{\epsilon_q(\delta ) } -\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}{m_b[\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b]}\right ) \biggl[m_{b_c}+m_v-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p)\cr & & -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] + \frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{2m_b\epsilon_q(\delta)}\cr & & \times \biggl[m_v-\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggrb ) \biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath173 } \left[m_v-\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\right]\cr & & + \frac{({\bf p\delta})}{{\bf \delta}^2}\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}2 \bigglb(\left(\frac{1}{\epsilon_q(\delta)[\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q ] } + \frac{1}{m_b[\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b]}\right ) \biggl[m_{b_c}+m_v\cr & & -\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p ) -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] + \frac{1}{m_b\epsilon_q(\delta)}\cr & & \times \biggl[m_v-\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggrb)\biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath174\cr & & -\biggl[m_v-\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr]\biggrb ) \cr & & -\left(\frac{1}{\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b } + \frac{m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)[\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q]}\right ) \biggl[m_{b_c}+m_v-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p)\cr & & -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath175+\frac{m_v}{m_{b_c}}\biggrb ) \cr & & + \frac23\frac{{\bf p}^2}{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q } \bigglb(\frac1{2m_b}\biggl[\frac{e_v+m_v}{\epsilon_c(p)+m_c } -\frac12+\frac{m_v}{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q}\cr & & + \frac{m_v}{m_{b_c}}\left ( \frac{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q}{\epsilon_c(p)+m_c}-\frac{e_v+m_v } { \epsilon_c(p)+m_c}+\frac12 -\frac{e_v}{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q}\right)\biggr]\cr & & + \frac{m_v}{m_{b_c}}\left(\frac1{\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q } + \frac1{\epsilon_c(p)+m_c}\right)\biggrb)\biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath176\cr & & \times \left[m_v-\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\right]\cr & & + \frac{({\bf p\delta})}{{\bf \delta}^2 } \bigglb(\biggl(\frac1{2\epsilon_q(\delta ) } \left[\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q } { \epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}+\frac{m_v}{m_{b_c } } \left(\frac{e_v+m_v}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}+\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q } { \epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right)\right]\cr & & + \frac1{2m_b}\biggl(\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b } + 2\frac{m_v(e_v+m_v)}{[\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q][\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b ] } + \frac{m_v}{m_{b_c } } \biggl[\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b}\cr & & + \frac{e_v+m_v}{\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b } \left(1-\frac{2e_v}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right)\biggr]\biggr)\biggr ) \biggl[m_{b_c}+m_v-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p)\cr & & -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] + \frac{1}{2m_b}\biggl(\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)}\cr & & + 2\frac{m_v(e_v+m_v)}{\epsilon_q(\delta)[\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q ] } + \frac{m_v}{m_{b_c } } \biggl[\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)}\left(1- \frac{e_v+m_v}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right)\cr & & -2\frac{e_v(e_v+m_v)}{\epsilon_q(\delta)[\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q ] } \biggr]\biggr ) \biggl[m_v-\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right)\cr & & -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggrb)\biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath177\cr & & + \left[1+\frac{m_v}{m_{b_c}}\left(1 + \frac{e_v+m_v}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right)\right ] \biggl[m_{b_c}-m_v-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p)\cr & & + \epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) + \epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr]\biggrb ) \cr & & + \bigglb(2\frac{m_v(e_v+m_v ) } { [ \epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q][\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b]}\left(\frac{e_v}{m_v } -1\right)-\left ( \frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}{\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b } + \frac{m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)}\right)\cr & & \times\left[\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q } + \frac{m_v}{m_{b_c}}\left ( \frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q } + \frac{e_v+m_v}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right)\right ] \biggrb ) \biggl[m_{b_c}+m_v-\epsilon_b(p)\cr & & -\epsilon_c(p ) -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath178 \left[1+\frac1{2m_b}\left(\frac{{\bf \delta}^2}{m_{b_c}-e_v } + \epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q\right)\right]\biggrb)\cr & & -\frac{{\bf p}^2}{6m_b[\epsilon_q(p+\delta)+m_q]}\biggr\ } \psi_{b_c}({\bf p}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath179\cr & & + \frac{({\bf p\delta})}{{\bf \delta}^2 } \bigglb((m_{b_c}-e_v)\biggl [ \frac{1}{2\epsilon_q(\delta)[\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q ] } \left(1+\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{m_{b_c}-e_v}\right)\cr & & + \frac{1}{2m_b[\epsilon_b(\delta)+m_b ] } \left(1-\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{m_{b_c}-e_v}\right)\biggr ] \biggl[m_{b_c}+m_v-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p)\cr & & -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] -\frac{1}{2m_b}\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)}\cr & & \times \left(1+\frac{m_{b_c}-e_v}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right ) \biggl[m_v-\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right ) \cr & & -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggrb)\biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath180}\cr & & \times \left(1-\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{m_{b_c}-e_v}\right)\biggr ] \biggl[m_{b_c}+m_v-\epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p ) -\epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right)\cr & & -\epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] -\frac{\epsilon_q(\delta)-m_q}{\epsilon_q(\delta)}\bigglb(m_{b_c}- \epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p)\cr & & - \left(1-\frac{m_{b_c}-e_v}{\epsilon_q(\delta)+m_q}\right ) \biggl[m_{b_c}-m_v- \epsilon_b(p)-\epsilon_c(p ) + \epsilon_q\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta\right)\cr & & + \epsilon_c\left(p+\frac{2m_c}{e_v+m_v}\delta \right)\biggr ] \biggrb)\biggr\}\psi_{b_c}({\bf p } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] 99 cdf collaboration , f. abe _
et al . _ ,
d * 58 * , 112004 ( 1998 ) .
i. p. gouz , v. v. kiselev , a. k. likhoded , v. i. romanovsky , and o. p. yushchenko , hep - ph/0211432 . v.
o. galkin , a. yu . mishurov and r. n. faustov , yad .
fiz . * 55 * , 2175 ( 1992 ) [ sov
55 * , 1207 ( 1992 ) ] .
d. ebert , r. n. faustov and v. o. galkin , phys .
d * 62 * , 034014 ( 2000 ) .
d. ebert , v. o. galkin and r. n. faustov , phys .
d * 57 * , 5663 ( 1998 ) ; * 59 * , 019902(e ) ( 1999 ) . v. o. galkin and r. n. faustov , yad .
fiz . * 44 * , 1575 ( 1986 ) [ sov .
* 44 * , 1023 ( 1986 ) ] ; d. ebert , r. n. faustov and v. o. galkin , phys .
b * 537 * , 241 ( 2002 ) .
r. n. faustov and v. o. galkin , z. phys .
c * 66 * , 119 ( 1995 ) ; d. ebert , r. n. faustov and v. o. galkin , phys .
d * 62 * , 014032 ( 2000 ) .
d. ebert , r. n. faustov and v. o. galkin , phys .
d * 56 * , 312 ( 1997 ) ; r. n. faustov , v. o. galkin and a. yu .
mishurov , phys .
d * 53 * , 6302 ( 1996 ) ; * 53 * , 1391 ( 1996 ) .
d. ebert , r. n. faustov and v. o. galkin , phys .
d * 67 * , 014027 ( 2003 ) .
a. a. logunov and a. n. tavkhelidze , nuovo cimento * 29 * , 380 ( 1963 ) .
a. p. martynenko and r. n. faustov , theor .
phys . * 64 * , 765 ( 1985 ) [ teor . mat
. fiz . * 64 * , 179 ( 1985 ) ] .
e. eichten and f. feinberg , phys .
d * 23 * , 2724 ( 1981 ) . h. j. schnitzer , phys .
d * 18 * , 3482 ( 1978 ) .
r. n. faustov , ann . phys . * 78 * , 176 ( 1973 ) ; nuovo cimento a * 69 * , 37 ( 1970 ) .
e. jenkins , m. luke , a. v. manohar and m. savage , nucl .
b * 390 * , 463 ( 1993 ) .
particle data group , k. hagiwara _ et al .
d * 66 * , 010001 ( 2002 ) .
m. a. ivanov , j. g. krner and p. santorelli , phys .
d * 63 * , 074010 ( 2001 ) . v. v. kiselev ,
a. k. likhoded and a. i. onishchenko , nucl .
b * 569 * , 473 ( 2000 ) ; v. v. kiselev , .
a. abd el - hady , j. h. muoz and j. p. vary , phys . rev .
d * 62 * , 014019 ( 2000 ) .
chang and y .- q .
chen , phys .
d * 49 * , 3399 ( 1994 ) .
p. colangelo and f. de fazio , phys .
d * 61 * , 034012 ( 2000 ) .
anisimov , p. yu . kulikov , i. m. narodetskii and k. a. ter - martirosyan , phys .
62 * , 1739 ( 1999 ) [ yad . fiz . * 62 * , 1868 ( 1999 ) ] . m. a. nobes and r. m. woloshyn , j. phys .
g * 26 * , 1079 ( 2000 ) .
g. lu , y. yang and h. li , phys .
b * 341 * , 391 ( 1995 ) .
f . liu and k .-
chao , phys .
d * 56 * , 4133 ( 1997 ) .
m. bauer , b. stech , and m. wirbel , z. phys .
c * 34 * , 103 ( 1987 ) . m. j. dugan and b. grinstein , phys .
b * 255 * , 583 ( 1991 ) . j. d. bjorken , nucl . phys .
b ( proc . suppl . )
* 11 * , 325 ( 1989 ) .
m. beneke , g. buchalla , m. neubert and c. t. sachrajda , phys .
* 83 * , 1914 ( 1999 ) ; nucl .
b * 591 * , 313 ( 2000 ) .
a. j. buras and l. silvestrini , nucl . phys .
b * 569 * , 3 ( 2000 ) . | semileptonic and nonleptonic decays of the @xmath0 meson to charmonium and @xmath1 mesons are studied in the framework of the relativistic quark model .
the decay form factors are explicitly expressed through the overlap integrals of the meson wave functions in the whole accessible kinematical range .
the relativistic meson wave functions are used for the calculation of the decay rates .
the obtained results are compared with the predictions of other approaches . |
in this paper , we study asymptotic models for the propagation of internal waves in a two - fluid system , which consists in two layers of immiscible , homogeneous , ideal , incompressible and irrotational fluids under the only influence of gravity .
we assume that there is no topography ( the bottom is flat ) and that the surface is confined by a flat rigid lid , although the case of a free surface could be handled with our method .
the interface between the two layers of fluids is given as the graph of a function , @xmath0 , which expresses the deviation from its rest position @xmath1 at the spatial coordinate @xmath2 and at time @xmath3 .
as we will focus on scalar models , we restrict ourselves to the case of horizontal dimension one .
the governing equations of such a system , describing the evolution of the deformation of the interface , @xmath0 , as well as the velocity flow inside the two layers of fluid is recalled in figure [ fig : sketchofdomain ] ( see section [ sec : models ] for more details ) .
the mathematical theory for this system of equation ( the so - called full euler system ) is extremely challenging ; see @xcite in particular . which has led to extensive works concerning simplified , asymptotic models , aiming at capturing the main characteristics of the flow with much simpler equations , provided the size of given parameters .
relevant dimensionless parameters that may be small in oceanographic situations include @xmath4 where @xmath5 measures the amplitude of the deformation at the interface with respect to the depth of the layers of fluids , and @xmath6 measures the shallowness of the two layers of fluid , when compared with the typical wavelength of the deformation . among other works
, we would like to highlight @xcite , where many asymptotic models are presented and rigorously justified , in a wide range of regimes . in each case , the resulting model consists in two relatively simple evolution equations coupling the shear velocity and the deformation at the interface .
however , in this work , we are mainly interested in scalar models , which can be used in particular ( but not only as we shall see ) to describe the unidirectional propagation of gravity waves . the derivation and study of such models have a very rich and ancient history , starting with the work of boussinesq @xcite and korteweg - de vries @xcite which introduced the famous _ korteweg - de vries equation _ @xmath7 in the context of propagation of surface gravity waves , above one layer of homogeneous fluid ( which we refer as `` water - wave problem '' ) .
however , let us note that the complete rigorous justification of such model is recent : @xcite .
such a justification is to be understood in the following sense : in the _ long wave regime _ @xmath8 the flow can be accurately approximated as a decomposition into two counterpropagating waves , each component satisfying a kdv equation ( or more generally , with the same order of accuracy , a _
benjamin - bona - mahony equation _
@xmath9 the situation is similar in the case of two layers of immiscible fluids , with a rigid lid ( as well as in the case of two layers with a free surface , except the flow is then decomposed into four propagating waves ) , and corresponding results are presented in @xcite . of course the coefficients ( @xmath10 , _ etc .
_ ) depend on the situation , and a striking difference between the water - wave case and the case of internal waves is that in the latter case , there exists a critical ratio for the two layers of fluid ( depending on the ratio of the mass densities ) for which the nonlinearity coefficient @xmath11 vanishes . in that case ,
heuristic arguments support the inclusion of the next order ( cubic ) nonlinearity , which yields the _ modified kdv equation _ ( see @xcite and references therein ) : @xmath12 for the cubic nonlinearity to be of the same order of magnitude as the dispersive terms , this urges to consider the so - called ( refering to @xcite for this non - standard denomination ) _ camassa - holm regime _ : @xmath13 note that this regime is interesting by itself as it allows larger amplitude waves than the long wave regime , and in particular yields models developing finite time breaking wave singularities @xcite .
thus we ask : _ can we extend to the camassa - holm regime the rigorous justification of the small amplitude ( long wave ) one ? _ as we shall see , the answer is not straightforward , as several evolution equations are in competition , with an accuracy depending on the situation , and in particular the criticality of the depth ratio , and localization in space of the initial data .
in addition to the equations already presented above , we consider the _ extended kdv _ ( or _ gardner _ ) equation @xmath14 as presented in @xcite , studied in @xcite ( among other works ) , and tested against experiments in @xcite .
more generally , we work with the higher order model @xmath15 such a model has been presented and justified ( in the water - wave setting , and in the camassa - holm regime ) in @xcite ; we therefore designate it as _ constantin - lannes _ equation .
this equation is related , though slightly different from the _ camassa - holm _ equation obtained for example in @xcite or higher order models ( see various such models formally derived in @xcite , concerning the water wave or internal wave problem ) .
however , each of these works is limited to the restrictive assumption that only one direction of propagation is non - zero .
we propose to study in detail the justification of the decomposition of the flow ( although the unidirectional case is also treated ) as presented above , and in the case of internal waves with a rigid lid .
our results are expressed in a very general setting : assuming only @xmath16 and expressing the accuracy of the different models as a function of these parameters .
although this complicates the expression of our results , and renders the proofs fairly technical , such choice allows to cover general regimes , including the long - wave as well as the camassa - holm regimes , described above .
we recover in particular the relevance of the kdv approximation in the long wave regime . in the camassa - holm regime , the conclusion not as definite , but depends on the criticality of the depth ratio , the localization in space of the initial data , as well as the time - scale which is considered .
as motivated above , the main of this article is to construct and rigorously justify asymptotic models for the system of equations , presented in figure [ fig : sketchofdomain ] , and which describe the behavior of two layers of immiscible , homogeneous , ideal , incompressible fluids under the sole influence of gravity .
the derivation of such equations is not new ; we briefly recall it in section [ ssec : fulleulersystem ] , and refer to @xcite for more details . the so - called _ full euler system _ can be written as two evolution equations using zakharov s canonical variables , namely @xmath17 the deformation of the interface from its rest position , and the trace of a velocity potential at the interface .
such a formulation is built upon the so - called _ dirichlet - to - neumann _ operators , solving laplace s equation on the two domains of fluid , with suitable neumann or dirichlet boundary conditions .
lastly , we non - dimensionalize the system in order to put forward the relevant dimensionless parameters of the system , and in particular @xmath5 , the nonlinearity parameter , and @xmath6 , the shallowness parameter .
we restrict our study to the following set of parameters : @xmath18 where @xmath19 are positive , finite .
@xmath20 is the depth ratio , and @xmath21 is the mass density ratio . as expressed above , our asymptotic models rely on the assumption that @xmath22 and @xmath23 .
more precisely , our results hold for any @xmath24 , with @xmath25 not necessarily small , but our approximate solutions are accurate if and only if both @xmath5 and @xmath6 are small .
of course , the choice of our regime inevitably restricts the scope of our results , and the validity of our approximate models .
in particular , even if we attach a great attention to impose as weak a constraint as possible on the nonlinearity and shallowness parameters in , we forbid the depth ratio to approach zero or infinity .
in particular , this is incompatible with the intermediate long wave regime ( ilw ) or benjamin - ono regime ( bo ) .
it would be of great interest to extend our results to such regimes , since the equivalent model to our green - naghdi coupled model has been derived in @xcite , together with the proof of energy estimates allowing to handle the full justification process as described below .
let us also recall that one can find a very large family of coupled models in @xcite , associated with a wide range of regimes , and all justified in the sense of consistency .
finally , we would like to emphasize that our results are especially adapted to parameters restricted in the so - called camassa - holm regime : @xmath26 with @xmath27 positive , finite .
[ [ the - green - naghdi - coupled - model . ] ] the green - naghdi coupled model .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the first step of our analysis is to construct a shallow - water ( @xmath28 ) high - order , coupled asymptotic model : the so - called _ green - naghdi model_. the key ingredient is to obtain an expansion of the aforementioned dirichlet - to - neumann operators , with respect to the shallowness parameter , @xmath6 .
such an expansion is provided in the ( one layer ) water - wave case in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 3.8 ) , and a first - order expansion in the bi - fluidic case is obtained in ( * ? ? ?
* section 2 ) ( let us also note that the case of two layers of immiscible fluids with a free surface is given in ( * ? ? ? * section 2.2 ) ) .
we offer a second order expansion of the dirichlet - to - neumann operators , precisely disclosed in proposition [ prop : expgh ] .
when replacing the dirichlet - to - neumann operators by their truncated expansion , and after straightforward computations , one is able to deduce the green - naghdi model , that we disclose below .
our system has two unknowns : @xmath17 representing the deformation of the interface , and @xmath29 the shear layer - mean velocity , as defined by @xmath30 , where @xmath31 are the horizontal velocities integrated across the vertical layer in each fluid : @xmath32 precisely , our green - naghdi model is the following .
@xmath33\bar v \big ) \ + \ ( \gamma+\delta)\partial_x{\zeta } \ + \
\frac{\epsilon}{2 } \partial_x\big(\dfrac{{h_1}^2 -\gamma { h_2}^2 } { ( h_1+\gamma h_2)^2 } |\bar v|^2\big ) \ = \
\mu\epsilon\partial_x\big(\overline{{\mathcal{r}}}[h_1,h_2]\bar v \big ) , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the depth of , respectively , the upper and the lower layer , and where we define the following operators : @xmath36v \ & \equiv \
\frac{-1}{3h_1 h_2}\bigg(h_1 \partial_x \big({h_2}^3\partial_x\big(\frac{h_1\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big)\ + \
\gamma h_2\partial_x \big ( { h_1}^3\partial_x \big(\frac{h_2\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2}\big)\big)\bigg ) , \\
\overline{{\mathcal{r}}}[h_1,h_2]v \ & \equiv \
\frac12 \bigg ( \big ( h_2\partial_x \big ( \frac{h_1\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big)^2\ -\ \gamma\big(h_1\partial_x \big(\frac{h_2\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big)^2\bigg)\\ & \qquad + \frac13\frac{v}{h_1+\gamma h_2}\ \bigg ( \frac{h_1}{h_2}\partial_x\big ( { h_2}^3\partial_x\big(\frac{h_1\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big ) \ - \ \gamma\frac{h_2}{h_1}\partial_x\big({h_1}^3\partial_x \big(\frac{h_2\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2}\big)\big ) \bigg ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] this system is related to the one introduced by choi and camassa in @xcite , and is the two - layers counterpart of the water - wave green - naghdi model introduced in @xcite , and fully justified in @xcite .
we present here the first rigorous justification of the two - layer green - naghdi model , in the sense of consistency .
[ prop : consgreennaghdimeani ] let @xmath37 be a family of solutions of the full euler system , such that @xmath38 with @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and uniformly with respect to @xmath41 ; see .
moreover assume that there exists @xmath42 such that @xmath43 define @xmath44 as above .
then @xmath45 satisfies , up to a remainder @xmath46 , bounded by @xmath47 with @xmath48 . here , and in the following , we denote by @xmath49 any positive constant , depending on the parameters @xmath50 , and whose dependence on @xmath51 is assumed to be nondecreasing .
@xmath52 is a positive constant , which do not depend on all the other parameters involved , and we write @xmath53 if @xmath54 , and @xmath55 if @xmath53 and @xmath56 .
for @xmath57 and @xmath58 a function defined on @xmath59\times{\mathbb{r}}$ ] , we write @xmath60;h^s)$ ] if @xmath61 is uniformly ( with respect to @xmath62 $ ] ) bounded in @xmath63 the @xmath64-based sobolev space .
its norm is denoted @xmath65 , as the sobolev norms are denoted with simple bars : @xmath66 . finally , @xmath67 is the space of functions @xmath68;h^{s+1})$ ] such that @xmath69;h^s)$ ] , endowed with the norm @xmath70 . [
[ consistency - and - full - justification . ] ] consistency and full justification .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + consistency results , such as proposition [ prop : consgreennaghdimeani ] , are part of the procedure that leads to a full justification of asymptotic models , as it has been achieved in the water wave case in @xcite . a model is said to be _ fully justified _
( following the terminology of @xcite ) if the cauchy problem of both the full euler system and the asymptotic model is well - posed for a given class of initial data , and over the relevant time scale ; and if the solutions with corresponding initial data remain close .
as described in ( * ? ? ?
* section 6.3 ) , the full justification of system follows from : * ( consistency ) one proves that families of solutions of the full euler system , existing and controlled over the relevant time scale ( that is @xmath71 here ) , solves the green - naghdi model up to a small residual .
this is proposition [ prop : consgreennaghdimeani ] . *
( existence ) one proves that families of solutions to the full euler system as above do exist .
this difficult step is ensured by theorem 5.8 in @xcite , provided that a small surface tension is added , and that an additional stability criterion is satisfied ( see details therein ) . *
( convergence ) one proves that the solutions of the full euler system , and the ones of the green - naghdi model with corresponding initial data remain close , over the relevant time scale .
the last step requires the well - posedness of the cauchy problem for the green - naghdi model , as well as the stability of its solutions with respect to perturbations .
more precisely , we require that functions satisfying the green - naghdi model up to a small residual remain close to the exact solution with corresponding initial data , so that the first two steps of our procedure ( consistency and existence ) yield the conclusion ( convergence ) , and therefore the full justification of the green - naghdi model .
see theorem 6.1 in @xcite for the application of such procedure for the full justification of the so - called _ shallow - water / shallow - water _ asymptotic model , which corresponds to , when withdrawing @xmath72 terms .
the different models throughout this work are justified through consistency results , with respect to the green - naghdi model .
let us define precisely below what we designate by consistency in the core of this paper .
[ def : consistency ] let @xmath73 be a family of pair of functions , uniformly bounded in @xmath74 ( @xmath75 to be determined ) , depending on parameters @xmath76 ; see .
we say that @xmath77 is _ consistent _ with green - naghdi system at precision @xmath78 , of order @xmath79 and on @xmath80 , if @xmath77 satisfies , for @xmath81 sufficiently small , @xmath82 v^{\mathfrak{p}}\big ) + ( \gamma+\delta)\partial_x{\zeta^{\mathfrak{p } } } + \frac{\epsilon}{2 } \partial_x\big(\dfrac{{h_1}^2 -\gamma { h_2}^2 } { ( h_1+\gamma h_2)^2 } | v^{\mathfrak{p}}|^2\big ) - \mu\epsilon\partial_x\big(\overline{{\mathcal{r}}}[h_1,h_2]\bar v^{\mathfrak{p}}\big ) = { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}^{\mathfrak{p}}\ r_2 , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where @xmath83 and @xmath84 , and with @xmath85 of course , one can apply the procedure described above to any consistent approximate solutions of the green - naghdi system .
consequently , our approximate solutions , described in propositions [ prop : unidiri ] , [ prop : decompositioni ] and [ prop : other ] , are fully justified as approximate solutions of the green - naghdi model , _ and therefore as approximate solutions of the full euler system _ , provided the green - naghdi system , _ or any equivalently consistent model _ , enjoys the following property .
[ conj : stab ] let @xmath86 , as defined in , and @xmath87 , with @xmath79 and @xmath88 sufficiently big . then the following holds . 1 .
there exists @xmath89 and unique strong solutions of the green - naghdi system , @xmath90 , such that @xmath91 and @xmath90 is uniformly bounded on @xmath92 .
2 . let @xmath93 , satisfying @xmath94 , be consistent ( in the sense of definition [ def : consistency ] ) with green - naghdi system on @xmath59 $ ] , of order @xmath79 , at precision @xmath95 .
then the difference between the two families of functions is estimated as @xmath96;h^s ) } \ \leq \ c\ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}\ t,\ ] ] with @xmath97;h^s ) } , \big\vert u^{\mathfrak{p}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^{s+{\bar}s})},\frac{1}{\delta_{\text{min}}},\delta_{\text{max}},\epsilon_{\text{max}},\mu_{\text{max } } \big)$ ] .
both of the properties in hypothesis [ conj : stab ] typically follow from energy estimates on the green - naghdi system .
such a result has been obtained for a well - chosen green - naghdi system in the case of the water - wave problem in @xcite . in the two - layer setting
, the result has been proved for an equivalent system ( the so - called symmetric boussinesq / boussinesq model ) in the long wave regime , @xmath98 , in @xcite .
such result can be extended to the camassa - holm regime , and will be the object of a future publication .
let us emphasize that hypothesis [ conj : stab ] is not necessary for our results to hold , but only to complete the full justification procedure described above .
however , such a result is very useful to perceive the accuracy of our approximate solutions ( in the sense of convergence ) that one expects , especially for the decoupled approximations in propositions [ prop : decompositioni ] and [ prop : other ] .
thus in the discussion of our results in sections [ sec : unidirectional ] and [ ssec : discussion ] , we assume that hypothesis [ conj : stab ] holds .
numerical simulations are in perfect agreement with the resulting estimates .
[ [ the - scalar - models . ] ] the scalar models .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + let us describe the different scalar evolution equations which are considered in this paper .
the higher - order model we study is the _ constantin - lannes _ equation ( cl ) : @xmath99 where @xmath100 ( @xmath101 ) , @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 , are fixed parameters .
note that the constantin - lannes equation can be seen as a generalization of classical lower order models ( obtained when neglecting higher - order terms , or equivalently setting some parameters to zero ) . in the following ,
we consider * the _ inviscid burgers _ equation ( ib ) : @xmath105 * the _ korteweg - de vries _ ( or more precisely _ benjamin - bona - mahony _
@xcite ) equation ( kdv ) : @xmath106 * the _ extended korteweg - de vries _ equation ( ekdv ) : @xmath107 our first result regarding these scalar evolution equations , concerns the long time well - posedness of the cauchy problem , and the persistence in time of the localization in space of initial data .
we treat simultaneously all scalar models by allowing parameters in to vanish . however , we require that @xmath108 , as our proof relies heavily on _ a priori _ estimates of the solution in the following scaled sobolev norm : @xmath109 we also make use of the closed functional subspaces @xmath110 , endowed with the following weighted sobolev norm : @xmath111 [ prop : wpi ] let @xmath112 , with @xmath113 .
let the parameters be such that @xmath114 , and define @xmath115 such that @xmath116 then there exists @xmath117 and a unique @xmath118 such that @xmath119 satisfies and initial condition @xmath120 .
moreover , @xmath119 satisfies the following energy estimate for @xmath121 : @xmath122 assume additionally that for fixed @xmath123 , the function @xmath124 , with @xmath125 and @xmath126 .
then there exists @xmath127 such that for @xmath128 , one has @xmath129 in particular , one has , for @xmath128 , @xmath130 the well - posedness of the cauchy problem for inviscid burgers , kdv and ekdv equations are well - known ( see for example @xcite and references therein ) , and actually do not require @xmath131 .
the case of constantin - lannes equation is provided in proposition 4 in @xcite .
the persistence of the solution in weighted sobolev norms for the constantin - lannes equation is new , as far as we know .
similar results in the case of ( eventually extended ) korteweg - de vries equations are obtained in slightly different setting ( for the most part using weighted @xmath64 spaces intersected with non - weighted sobolev spaces @xmath132 , @xmath133 ) in @xcite .
as mentioned previously , we consider two different approaches concerning the justification of scalar equations such as , to construct approximate solutions of the green - naghdi system , and therefore as asymptotic models for the propagation of internal waves . the first justification , that we call _ unidirectional approximation _ , consists in adjusting carefully the initial data so that solutions of provide a good approximation of the flow . the second justification states that any initial perturbation of the flow can be approximately decomposed into the sum of two decoupled waves , each of them satisfying a scalar equation .
controlling the precision of such _ decoupled approximation _ is of course more difficult , and the unidirectional approximation gains in precision what it lacks in generality .
these two approaches have been successfully developed in the ( one layer ) water wave situation ( see @xcite and references therein ) , and extended to the bifluidic case in the long wave regime in @xcite .
our results may therefore be considered as a continuation of these earlier works .
[ [ unidirectional - propagation . ] ] unidirectional propagation .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + this result follows the strategy developed for the water - wave problem in @xcite .
we prove that if one chooses carefully the initial perturbation ( deformation of the interface as well as shear layer - mean velocity ) , then the flow can be approximated as a solution of the constantin - lannes equation , with a great accuracy .
[ prop : unidiri ] set @xmath134 , and @xmath135 with @xmath113 . for @xmath86 , as defined in , denote @xmath136 the unique solution of the equation @xmath137 where parameters @xmath138 ( @xmath101 ) , @xmath139 , @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 , are precisely enclosed in proposition [ eq : cluni ] .
for given @xmath143 , assume that there exists @xmath144 such that @xmath145 and for any @xmath146 , @xmath147 then define @xmath148 as @xmath149 $ ] , with @xmath150 \ =
\ \zeta + \epsilon\frac{\alpha_1}2\zeta^2 + \epsilon^2 \frac{\alpha_2}{3 } \zeta^3 + \epsilon^3 \frac{\alpha_3}4 \zeta^4 + \mu\nu\partial_x^2\zeta+\mu\epsilon\left(\kappa_1 \zeta\partial_x^2\zeta + \kappa_2 ( \partial_x \zeta)^2\right),\ ] ] where parameters @xmath151 are as above , and @xmath152 , @xmath153 , @xmath154 .
then @xmath77 is consistent with green - naghdi equations , of order @xmath79 and on @xmath155 , with precision @xmath95 , with @xmath156 when @xmath157 and @xmath158 , one recovers the one - fluid model introduced by constantin and lannes in ( * ? ? ?
* section 2.2 ) , with @xmath159 and @xmath160 , using notations therein . in the bi - fluidic case , choi and camassa ( * ? ? ?
* appendix a ) obtained a very similar result .
our approximation consists in solving a scalar evolution equation for the deformation at the interface , followed by a reconstruction of the shear layer - mean velocity from the deformation ( in particular , the initial shear velocity is determined by the initial deformation ) . following @xcite ,
a similar strategy consists in looking for an evolution equation for the shear layer - mean velocity , and reconstruct the deformation at the interface .
we decide not to present the outcome of such strategy , as the result is very similar , and calculations are somewhat heavier in that case . as discussed in (
* proposition 5 ) , specific values of parameters in yield equations with different properties , especially concerning the behavior near the maximal time of definition ( if it is finite ) .
indeed , the proof of ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5 ) can easily be adapted to more general coefficients , and one obtains : * if @xmath161 , @xmath162 and @xmath163 , then singularities can develop in finite time only in the form of _ surging wave breaking_. in other words , if the maximal time of existence of @xmath17 is finite , @xmath164 , then @xmath165 * if @xmath161 , @xmath166 and @xmath167 , then singularities can develop in finite time only in the form of _ plunging wave breaking_. in other words , if the maximal time of existence of @xmath17 is finite , @xmath164 , then @xmath168 identity @xmath169 holds in the line @xmath170 , and in that case , @xmath161 if and only if @xmath171 . restricting to @xmath172 as natural values for the use of bbm trick , one can easily check that if @xmath173 , then singularities may occur only as surging wave breaking , as it is the case in the one - layer situation . on the contrary , if @xmath174 , as is the case in the stratified ocean ( small variation of densities ) then singularities will occur as surging wave breaking if @xmath175 ( thicker upper layer ) , and plunging wave breaking will occur for @xmath176 ( thicker lower layer ) .
[ [ the - decoupled - approximation . ] ] the decoupled approximation .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we now turn to the case of a generic initial perturbation of the flow .
when neglecting any term of size @xmath177 in , one obtains a simple wave equation for @xmath178 , which predicts that the flow splits into two counterpropagating waves , each one moving at velocity @xmath179 .
our aim is to provide a higher precision model , by allowing each of these waves to satisfy a scalar evolution equation .
the strategy presented here has been used in @xcite , where the authors present a similar rigorous justification of the kdv equation as asymptotic model for the ( one fluid ) water wave problem in the long wave regime ( see @xcite for the bi - fluidic case ) . as discussed earlier on
, a major difference of the bifluidic case is the existence of a _
critical ratio _ , for which the quadratic nonlinearity in our models vanish .
this is our main motivation for the present work , which extends the previous results to more general regimes , allowing greater nonlinearities , and higher order scalar equations .
more precisely , we define the following constantin - lannes approximation .
[ def : cl ] let @xmath180 be given scalar functions , and set parameters @xmath181 , as defined in , and @xmath182 .
the constantin - lannes decoupled approximation is then @xmath183 where @xmath184 and @xmath185 with @xmath186 satisfying @xmath187 with parameters disclosed precisely in . as mentioned above
, the constantin - lannes equation is the higher order model we consider .
it is not obvious that such precise model offers a significantly better approximation than lower - order models . as a matter of fact ,
this is generically not the case , as discussed in section [ ssec : discussion ] ( see remark [ rem : differentmodels ] , below ) .
thus we also consider models with formally lower order accuracy .
[ def : other ] let @xmath180 be given scalar functions , and set parameters @xmath181 , @xmath182 . a decoupled approximate solution of the system is @xmath188 where @xmath189 and @xmath185 with @xmath186 satisfying a scalar evolution equation . in
what follows , we consider * the inviscid burgers equation : @xmath190 * the korteweg - de vries ( or more precisely benjamin - bona - mahony ) equation : @xmath191 * the extended korteweg - de vries equation : @xmath192 where the parameters are the same as in definition [ def : cl ] .
let us now state our main results , concerning the justification of the decoupled scalar approximations .
[ prop : decompositioni ] let @xmath193 , with @xmath194 . for @xmath86 ,
as defined in , we denote @xmath195 the unique solution of the cl approximation , as defined in definition [ def : cl ] .
for some given @xmath196 , sufficiently big , we assume that there exists @xmath197 and a family @xmath198 such that @xmath199 then there exists @xmath200 $ ] such that @xmath201 is consistent with green - naghdi equations of order @xmath79 on @xmath202 $ ] for @xmath203 , at precision @xmath204 with @xmath205 with @xmath206 , and the corrector term @xmath207 is estimated as @xmath208;h^{s})}+\big\vert \partial_t u^c \big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t^\star];h^{s } ) } \leq c\ \max(\epsilon(\delta^2-\gamma),\epsilon^2,\mu ) \min ( t , \sqrt t ) .\ ] ] additionally , if there exists @xmath209 , @xmath210 such that @xmath211 then @xmath201 is consistent with green - naghdi equations of order @xmath79 on @xmath202 $ ] for @xmath212 , at precision @xmath213 with @xmath214 with @xmath215 and @xmath207 is uniformly estimated as @xmath216;h^{s})}+\big\vert \partial_t u^c \big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t^\sharp];h^{s } ) } \leq c\ \max(\epsilon(\delta^2-\gamma),\epsilon^2,\mu ) \min ( t , 1).\ ] ] equivalent results can be obtained when following the exact same strategy , but using lower order equations to describe the evolution of the decoupled waves , @xmath217 .
we detail below the accuracy of such approximations .
[ prop : other ] assume that the hypotheses of proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] hold . denote @xmath218 , @xmath219 and @xmath220 , respectively , the solutions of the ekdv , kdv and ib approximations , as defined in definition [ def : other ] . in each case , we assume that the decoupled approximation is uniformly estimated in @xmath221 $ ] , as in proposition [ prop : decompositioni ]
. then a. there exists @xmath222 $ ] such that @xmath223 is consistent with green - naghdi equations of order @xmath79 on @xmath202 $ ] for @xmath203 , at precision @xmath224 , with @xmath225 b. there exists @xmath226 $ ] such that @xmath227 is consistent with green - naghdi equations of order @xmath79 on @xmath202 $ ] for @xmath203 , at precision @xmath228 with @xmath229 c. there exists @xmath230 $ ] such that @xmath231 is consistent with green - naghdi equations of order @xmath79 on @xmath202 $ ] for @xmath203 , at precision @xmath232 with @xmath233 where @xmath215 .
each time , the corrector term @xmath207 is estimated as follows : @xmath208;h^{s})}+\big\vert \partial_t u^c \big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t^\star];h^{s } ) } \leq c\ \max(\epsilon(\delta^2-\gamma),\epsilon^2,\mu ) \min ( t , \sqrt t ) .\ ] ] moreover , if the decoupled approximation is sufficiently localized in space , then all the estimates are improved as in the second part of the proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] ( that is replacing @xmath234 by @xmath235 ) .
[ rem : wc ] the function @xmath207 , which depends only on the decoupled waves @xmath217 , is a first order corrector which allows to take into account the leading order coupling effects , and therefore reach the desired accuracy .
its construction and precise definition is explicitly displayed in the proof of the proposition ; see section [ sec : prop : decompositioni ] , and in particular definition [ def : corrector ] .
the approximate solution given by @xmath201 can be seen as a weakly coupled model of independent interest , in the spirit of @xcite .
[ rem : differentmodels ] in the estimates presented in propositions [ prop : decompositioni ] and [ prop : other ] , the terms growing in @xmath236 come from coupling effects between the two propagating waves , that are neglected in our decoupled models ; this is why the accuracy is significantly better if the initial data is localized in space , as the two counterpropagating waves will be located far away from each other after some time . uniformly bounded terms are the contribution of unidirectional errors , generated by the different manipulations on the equation ( _ e.g. _ bbm trick ) , and eventually neglected terms in lower order approximations for proposition [ prop : other ] , below .
the magnitude of each contribution , and therefore the accuracy of the decoupled approximation , depends on a. the evolution equation considered ( cl , ekdv , kdv , _ etc . _ ) ; b. the size of the parameters @xmath237 as well as @xmath238 ( critical ratio ) ; c. the localization in space of the initial data ; d. the time - scale considered . in that respect , it is not obvious to decide which approximation is the best to consider , that is what is the simplest equation leading to the highest accuracy .
we discuss several important cases ( long - wave regime , camassa - holm regime with critical or non - critical ratio ) in section [ ssec : discussion ] , with several numerical simulations to support our conclusions .
[ [ long - time - behavior ] ] long time behavior + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + a notable difference in the statement of our results , when compared with previous work in @xcite , is that our estimates in propositions [ prop : decompositioni ] and [ prop : other ] ( and similarly proposition [ prop : unidiri ] ) are valid as long as the solution of the approximate scalar model is defined and uniformly estimated .
let us note first that proposition [ prop : wpi ] ensures that these results are not empty , but on the contrary are valid for long times ( provided that @xmath161 and the initial data sufficiently smooth ) . more precisely , one has straightforwardly the following result
. let @xmath239 , and let @xmath41 , with additional restriction @xmath240 .
then there exists @xmath241 , independent of @xmath242 , such that for any @xmath243 , the decoupled approximate solutions defined in propositions [ prop : decompositioni ] and [ prop : other ] are uniquely defined and satisfy the uniform bound of the proposition , with @xmath244 if @xmath245 , then there exists @xmath246 such that for any @xmath247 , one has @xmath248 one question , which is essential in the discussion of section [ ssec : discussion ] , is whether these above estimates are optimal , or in the contrary can be extended to longer times .
let us discuss below some elements of answer .
first , it is well - known that inviscid burgers equation @xmath249 will generate a shock in finite time , for any non - trivial , decreasing at infinity initial data .
a simple scaling arguments shows that the inviscid burgers decoupled approximation will therefore generate shocks in finite time @xmath250 . on the contrary , using conservation laws of the kdv equation , one can extend local well - posedness result inherited from the hyperbolic energy method , to global well - posedness in sufficiently regular spaces @xmath251 ( see @xcite among many other works ) .
the same result holds for the modified kdv ( when the power of the nonlinearity is non - quadratic but sub - critical ) , and is therefore valid for extended korteweg - de vries equations in definition [ def : other ] , provided @xmath252 @xcite . concerning higher order models
, it is known that camassa - holm family of equations , related to , can develop singularities in finite time in the form of wave breaking ( see @xcite ) . in @xcite ,
the authors show that wave breaking of solutions to occurs for a specific set of parameters , at hyperbolic time @xmath250 , provided that the initial data is sufficiently big in @xmath253 norm .
however , as the justification of our model assumes that the initial deformation is bounded in sobolev norm , uniformly with respect to the parameters , assumptions of ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 6 ) can not be justified .
thus the problem of the well - posedness of constantin - lannes equation for longer time than the one expressed in proposition [ prop : wpi ] is still open , as far as we know . as for the localization in space ,
it is clear that our models , as they include dispersive terms , can not be uniformly controlled in weighted sobolev norms , globally in time .
however , as the two counterpropagating waves move away from each other while their spatial localization weakens , it does not seem out of reach to extend propositions [ prop : decompositioni ] and [ prop : other ] in order to uniformly control the coupling effects for very long time . on the other hand , in order to complete the full justification of our asymptotic models as described above , one has to obtain hypothesis [ conj : stab ] over times greater than the typical hyperbolic time scale @xmath71 .
thus the dispersive properties of the scalar models we consider , which are largely overlooked in this work but have been extensively studied in the literature , will play a predominant role in the behavior of the system at very long time . to conclude ,
let us note that , despite all the aforementioned difficulties , numerical simulations in section [ ssec : discussion ] indicate that our uniform estimate in proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] remains valid for times of order @xmath254 . [ [ outline - of - the - paper ] ] outline of the paper + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the precise presentation and justification of the governing ( full euler ) equations of our system is introduced in section [ sec : models ] .
using the shallowness assumption ( @xmath28 ) , we then introduce the so - called green - naghdi model , as written out above .
several equivalently precise models are constructed , using different variables ; a short analysis on the linear well - posedness of these systems supports the choice of the shear layer - mean velocity , which yields .
the well - posedness of the scalar models we consider , as well as the persistence of spatial decay of its solutions ( proposition [ prop : wpi ] ) , is proved in section [ sec : prop : wpi ] . in section [ sec : unidirectional ] , we turn to the case of the unidirectional approximation , and prove proposition [ prop : unidiri ] .
we then numerically investigate if the quite restricting condition on the initial data arises naturally , that is if after some time , the flow generated by any initial perturbation will eventually decompose into two almost purely unidirectional waves .
finally , section [ sec : decomposition ] is dedicated to the study of the decoupled models . in section [ ssec : formal ] , we present a formal argument which allows to derive the decoupled approximations , as defined precisely in definitions [ def : cl ] and [ def : other ] .
as an intermediary step , we introduce a coupled asymptotic models , which we believe is of independent interest : - is a simplified version of the green - naghdi equation , with same precision in the camassa - holm regime , as stated in proposition [ prop : consserre ] .
the main result , proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] , is proved in section [ sec : prop : decompositioni ] .
finally , section [ ssec : discussion ] contains a discussion concerning the competition between the different scalar models , in various scenari , supported by numerical simulations .
this section is dedicated to the construction and justification of the green - naghdi model , which is the groundwork of our study .
we first briefly recall the so - called _ full euler system _ , governing the behavior of two layers of immiscible , homogeneous , ideal , incompressible fluids under the sole influence of gravity .
following craig - sulem @xcite , the system can be written as two evolution equations coupling zakharov s canonical variables @xcite , thanks to the use of dirichlet - to - neumann operators ( definition [ def : d2n ] ) .
after non - dimensionalizing our system of equations in order to make appear the dimensionless parameters at stake , we expand the dirichlet - to - neumann operators with respect to the shallowness , parameter , @xmath6 ( proposition [ prop : expgh ] ) .
green - naghdi models are obtained when replacing the dirichlet - to - neumann operators by their truncated expansion , and one obtains successively , and .
these systems are equivalent , but handle different velocity variables as unknowns .
the latter is the system we base our study on , _
i.e. _ , and considers the shear layer - mean velocity , obtained after integrating the velocity potential across the vertical layer in each fluid . , which allows to approximate zakharov s canonical variables in terms of layer - mean velocity variables . in @xcite , choi and camassa
formally construct similar green - naghdi models using layer - mean velocity variables from start to finish . ]
all of these asymptotic models are justified by a consistency result , stating that solutions of the full euler system satisfy green - naghdi asymptotic models up to a small remainder , of size @xmath255 .
the system we study consists in two layers of immiscible fluids , compelled below by a flat bottom and by a flat , rigid lid ( see figure [ fig : sketchofdomain ] ) .
we restrict ourselves to the two - dimensional case , _
i.e. _ to horizontal dimension @xmath256 .
the domains of the two fluids are infinite in the horizontal dimension , and the fluids are at rest at infinity .
the depth of the upper and lower layers are , respectively , @xmath257 and @xmath258 .
we assume that the interface between the two fluids is given as the graph of a function @xmath0 which expresses the deviation from its rest position @xmath1 at the horizontal spatial coordinate @xmath2 and at time @xmath3 .
therefore , at each time @xmath259 , the domains of the upper and lower fluid ( denoted , respectively , @xmath260 and @xmath261 ) , are given by @xmath262 we assume that the two domains are strictly connected , that is @xmath263 we denote by @xmath264 and @xmath265 the mass density and velocity fields of , respectively , the upper and the lower fluid . the two fluids are assumed to be homogeneous and incompressible , so that the mass densities @xmath266 are constant , and the velocity fields @xmath267 are divergence free . as we assume the flows to be irrotational , one can express the velocity field as gradients of a potential : @xmath268 @xmath269 , and the velocity potentials satisfy laplace s equation @xmath270
the fluids being ideal , they satisfy the euler equations ; the momentum equations can be integrated , which yields bernoulli s equation : @xmath271 where @xmath272 denotes the pressure inside the fluids . from the assumption that no fluid
particle crosses the surface , the bottom or the interface , one deduces kinematic boundary conditions , and the set of equations is closed by the continuity of the pressure at the interface , assuming that there is no surface tension .
altogether , the governing equations of our problem are the following : @xmath273 where @xmath274 is the unit upward normal vector at the interface .
[ [ rewriting - the - system - as - evolution - equations . ] ] rewriting the system as evolution equations .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the system can be reduced into two evolution equations coupling zakharov s canonical variables , namely the deformation of the free interface from its rest position , @xmath17 , and the trace of the upper potential at the interface , @xmath275 : @xmath276 the potentials @xmath277 and @xmath278 are uniquely deduced from @xmath279 as the unique solutions of the following laplace s problems : @xmath280 more precisely , we define the so - called dirichlet - neumann operators .
[ def : d2n ] let @xmath281 , and @xmath282
. then we define @xmath283\psi \ & = \ \sqrt{1+|\partial_x\zeta|^2}\big(\partial_n \phi_1 \big){\left\vert _ { z=\zeta}\right . } \ = \
\big(\partial_z \phi_1\big){\left\vert _ { z=\zeta}\right . }
-(\partial_x \zeta)\big(\partial_x \phi_1\big){\left\vert _ { z=\zeta}\right . } , \\ h[\zeta]\psi \ & = \ \partial_x \big ( { \phi_2}{\left\vert _ { z=\zeta}\right.}\big ) \ = \
\partial_x \big ( \phi_2(t , x,\zeta(t , x))\big),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath277 and @xmath278 are uniquely defined ( up to a constant for @xmath278 ) as the solutions in @xmath284 of .
the well - posedness of laplace s problem , and therefore the dirichlet - neumann operators , follow from classical arguments detailed , for example , in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.1 ) .
one can then rewrite the conservation of momentum equations in at the interface , thanks to chain rule : @xmath285\psi + ( \partial_x\zeta)(\partial_x \big({\phi_2}{\left\vert _ { z=\zeta}\right . } ) \big)^2}{2(1+|\partial_x\zeta|^2 ) } \ = \
_ { z=\zeta}\right.}}{\rho_i}.\ ] ] using the continuity of the pressure at the interface , one deduces from the identities above @xmath286\psi -\rho_1 \partial_x \psi)+g(\rho_2-\rho_1)\partial_x \zeta + \frac12\partial_x \big ( \rho_2 |h[\zeta]\psi|^2 -\gamma |\partial_x \psi|^2\big)\ = \ \partial_x { \mathcal{n}}(\zeta,\psi ) , \ ] ] where @xmath287 is defined as @xmath288\psi + ( \partial_x\zeta)(\partial_x\psi)\big)^2 -\rho_2\big(g[\zeta]\psi + ( \partial_x\zeta)h[\zeta]\psi \big)^2}{2(1+|\partial_x\zeta|^2)}.\ ] ] the kinematic boundary condition at the interface is obvious , and the system is therefore rewritten as @xmath289\psi -\rho_1 \partial_x \psi)+g(\rho_2-\rho_1)\partial_x \zeta + \frac12\partial_x \big ( \rho_2 |h[\zeta]\psi|^2 -\rho_1 |\partial_x \psi|^2\big)=\partial_x { \mathcal{n}}(\zeta,\psi ) , \\ \partial_t \zeta \ = \ g[\zeta]\psi .
\end{array } \right.\ ] ] which is exactly system ( 9 ) in @xcite .
[ [ nondimensionalization - of - the - system . ] ] nondimensionalization of the system .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + thanks to an appropriate scaling , the two - layer full euler system can be written in dimensionless form .
the study of the linearized system ( see @xcite , for example ) , which can be solved explicitly , leads to a well - adapted rescaling .
let @xmath290 be the maximum amplitude of the deformation of the interface .
we denote by @xmath291 a characteristic horizontal length , say the wavelength of the interface .
then the typical velocity of small propagating internal waves ( or wave celerity ) is given by @xmath292 consequently , we introduce the dimensionless variables as the reference vertical length . by doing so
, we implicitly assume that the two layers of fluid have comparable depth , and therefore that the depth ratio @xmath293 do not approach zero or infinity .
note also that @xmath294 as @xmath295 . ]
@xmath296 the dimensionless unknowns @xmath297 and the four independent dimensionless parameters @xmath298 with this rescaling , the system becomes ( we withdraw the tildes for the sake of readability ) @xmath299with @xmath300 and the dimensionless dirichlet - to - neumann operators defined by @xmath301 where @xmath277 and @xmath278 are the solutions of the rescaled laplace problems @xmath302 similarly as in definition [ def : d2n ] , the dirichlet - neumann operators are well defined , provided that @xmath281 , @xmath282 , and the following condition holds : there exists @xmath42 such that @xmath303 any reference of the _ full euler system _ in the following concerns system with operators defined as above .
our aim is now to obtain asymptotic models for the full euler system , using smallness of dimensionless parameters . in the following
, we will consider the case of shallow water , namely @xmath304 the key ingredient comes from the expansions of the dirichlet - neumann operators , in terms of @xmath6 . replacing the operators by the leading order terms of these expansions allow to obtain the desired asymptotic models , which are consequently justified in the sense of consistency . as a second step , we rewrite the equations using the shear layer - mean velocity as unknown .
one benefit of such a choice is that it yields to a much better behavior concerning the linear well - posedness , as we discuss at the end of this section .
our method has been used by alvarez - samaniego and lannes @xcite in the case of the water - wave problem ( one layer of fluid , with free surface ) , and lead the authors to a complete rigorous justification of the so - called green - naghdi equations @xcite . in the case of two layers with a free surface , a shallow water model ( first order ) and boussinesq - type models ( in the long wave regime ) have been derived and justified in the sense of consistency in @xcite ; the analysis below is therefore an extension of their work .
similar models as our green - naghdi system have been formally obtained in @xcite , as well as in @xcite ( with the additional assumption of @xmath305 ) and in @xcite , but it is the first time to our knowledge that a rigorous justification is provided .
let us also mention the work concerning the case of two layers of fluids with an interface and a free surface : green - naghdi - type models have been derived in @xcite , and justified in the sense of consistency in @xcite .
one could formally recover our models from ( * ? ? ?
* ( 44 ) and ( 60 ) ) by forcing the surface to be flat ( @xmath306 using notation therein ) .
* expansion of the dirichlet - neumann operators .
* + the main ingredients of the following proposition are given in @xcite , and we extend their result one order further .
[ prop : expgh ] let @xmath40 and @xmath307 .
let @xmath275 be such that @xmath308 , and @xmath309 .
let @xmath34 and @xmath310 such that is satisfied .
then @xmath311 with @xmath312 .
the estimates are uniform with respect to the parameters @xmath313 , as defined in .
as remarked in @xcite , the operator @xmath314 can be deduced from similar operator in the ( one layer ) water wave case with flat bottom : @xmath315\psi,\ ] ] where @xmath316 is defined in ( * ? ? ?
* section 3 ) , and estimates , follows from proposition 3.8 therein . estimate is given in ( * ? ? ?
* section 2.2.2 ) , and we obtain using the same method , expanding one order further .
let us detail the strategy .
the first step consists in rewriting the scaled laplace problem into a variable - coefficient , boundary - value problem on the flat strip @xmath317 using the diffeomorphism @xmath318 now , one can check ( see @xcite or ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.1 ) ) that @xmath278 solves if and only if @xmath319 satisfies @xmath320 \nabla_{x , z } \underline{\phi_2 } \ = \ 0 & \text { in } { \mathcal{s}}\\ \partial_n \underline{\phi_2}{\left\vert _ { z=0}\right.}=g^{\mu,\epsilon}\psi & \partial_n \underline{\phi_2}{\left\vert _ { z=-1}\right.}=0 , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] with @xmath321 \ \equiv \ \begin{pmatrix } \mu\partial_z\sigma & -\mu\partial_x\sigma \\ -\mu\partial_x\sigma & \frac{1+\mu|\partial_x \sigma|^2}{\partial_z \sigma } \end{pmatrix } \
\frac1{1/\delta+\epsilon\zeta}\begin{pmatrix } 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix}+\mu \begin{pmatrix } 1/\delta+\epsilon\zeta & -(z+1)\epsilon\partial_x\zeta \\ -(z+1)\epsilon\partial_x\zeta & \dfrac{|(z+1)\epsilon\partial_x\zeta|^2}{1/\delta+\epsilon\zeta } \end{pmatrix},\ ] ] and where @xmath322 stands for the upward conormal derivative associated to the elliptic operator involved : @xmath323 the asymptotic expansion of the dirichlet - neumann operator @xmath324 is deduced from the identity @xmath325 the second step consists in computing the formal expansion of @xmath326 the solution of , as @xmath327 one can solve at each order , using the obvious expansion of @xmath328 , as well as the known expansion of the operator @xmath314 .
this yields explicit formulas for @xmath329 , and the estimate follows from adequate control of the residual @xmath330 . at first order , one has @xmath331 so that @xmath332 independent of @xmath333 . at next order ,
one has ( denoting @xmath334 ) @xmath335 where we used that @xmath336 is independent of @xmath333 .
the above system is a second order ordinary differential equation , which is solvable under the condition @xmath337 and whose solution is then @xmath338 with @xmath339 being a function independent of @xmath333 , to be determined later .
note that since the horizontal dimension is one , and using the fact that the fluids are at rest at infinity , integrating the compatibility conditions yields @xmath340 let us turn to the next order .
one has @xmath341 with @xmath342 solving the first identity with boundary condition @xmath343 yields @xmath344 with @xmath345 independent of @xmath333 ( and which can be set to zero for simplicity ) , and solving the boundary condition at @xmath346 yields the compatibility condition : @xmath347 or , equivalently , @xmath348 finally , integrating this identity and using the expression of @xmath349 obtained above , one deduces @xmath350 the final step is as follows .
let us define @xmath351 where @xmath336 and @xmath352 have been obtained by the above calculations .
note that @xmath353 which is exactly the expansion in .
therefore , the result follows from an adequate estimate on @xmath354 let us first note that one has straightforwardly @xmath355 then , using previous calculations , @xmath356 satisfies the system @xmath357 \nabla_{x , z } v \
\mu^2\nabla_{x , z}\cdot \mathbf h & \text { in } { \mathcal{s}}\\ \partial_n \underline{\phi_2}{\left\vert _ { z=0}\right.}=v + \mu^2 \begin{pmatrix } 0\\1 \end{pmatrix } \cdot { \mathbf h}{\left\vert _ { z=0}\right . } & \partial_n \underline{\phi_2}{\left\vert _ { z=-1}\right.}=\mu^2 \begin{pmatrix } 0\\1 \end{pmatrix } \cdot { \mathbf h}{\left\vert _ { z=-1}\right . } , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] with @xmath358 , and @xmath359 , so that yields @xmath360 one can now apply proposition 3 of @xcite , after straightforward adjustments , and deduce @xmath361 the proposition is proved . [ [ the - green - naghdi - models . ] ] the green - naghdi models .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + let us now plug the expansions of proposition [ prop : expgh ] into the full euler system , and withdraw @xmath255 terms .
one obtains @xmath362\partial_x\psi\big ) \ , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where we denote @xmath363\partial_x\psi$ ] , and with the following operators @xmath364v \ & \equiv \
\frac13 \big({h_2}^3\partial_x\big(\frac{h_1}{h_2}v \big)-{h_1}^3\partial_x v\big),\\ { \mathcal{n}}[h_1,h_2]v \ & \equiv \ \frac12 \left ( \big(\partial_x(h_1 v ) -\epsilon(\partial_x{\zeta})\frac{h_1}{h_2}v \big)^2\ -\
\gamma\big(h_1\partial_x^2\psi \big)^2\right ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] our model is justified by the following consistency result .
[ prop : consgreennaghdi1 ] let @xmath37 be a family of solutions of the full euler system , such that holds , and @xmath38 with @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and uniformly with respect to @xmath41 ; see
. then @xmath93 satisfies , up to a remainder @xmath46 , bounded by @xmath47 with @xmath48 .
when plugging @xmath93 into , and after some straightforward computation , one can clearly estimate the remainder using the expansions of the dirichlet - neuman operators in proposition [ prop : expgh ] .
the only non - trivial term comes from @xmath365 , which requires the corresponding expansion of @xmath366 .
this can be obtained as in proposition [ prop : expgh ] , using the elliptic problems satisfied by the time derivative of the potentials .
the expansion follows in the same way , provided that @xmath38 .
see the proof of ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.12 ) for more details .
in @xcite , the authors use the shear velocity as for the velocity variable : @xmath367 the expansion of @xmath324 in allows to obtain approximately @xmath368 as a function of @xmath369 : @xmath370\big(-\frac{h_2}{h_1+\gamma h_2}v\big ) \big ) \ + \ { \mathcal{o}}(\mu^2).\ ] ] here and in the following , we use the notation @xmath371 for estimates as in proposition [ prop : expgh ] . plugging into , and again withdrawing @xmath255 terms , yields @xmath372v \big ) \ = \ 0 , \\ \\
_ { t}v \ + \ ( \gamma+\delta)\partial_x{\zeta } \ + \ \frac{\epsilon}{2 } \partial_x\big(\dfrac{{h_1}^2 -\gamma { h_2}^2 } { ( h_1+\gamma h_2)^2 } |v|^2\big ) \ = \
\mu\epsilon\partial_x\big({\mathcal{r}}[h_1,h_2]v \big ) \ , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] with the following operators : @xmath373v \ & \equiv \ \frac{-1}{3(h_1+\gamma h_2)}\bigg(h_1 \partial_x \big({h_2}^3\partial_x\big(\frac{h_1\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big)\ + \
\gamma h_2\partial_x \big ( { h_1}^3\partial_x \big(\frac{h_2\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2}\big)\big)\bigg ) , \\
{ \mathcal{r}}[h_1,h_2]v \ & \equiv \
\frac12 \bigg ( \big ( h_2\partial_x \big ( \frac{h_1\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big)^2\ -\ \gamma\big(h_1\partial_x \big(\frac{h_2\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big)^2\bigg)\\ & \qquad + \gamma\frac{h_1+h_2}{3(h_1+\gamma h_2)^2}v\ \partial_x\big ( { h_2}^3\partial_x\big(\frac{h_1\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)-{h_1}^3\partial_x \big(\frac{h_2\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2}\big)\big ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] system is justified as an asymptotic model for the full euler system , by a consistency result , with the same precision as .
[ prop : consgreennaghdi2 ] let @xmath37 be a family of solutions of the full euler system , such that holds , and @xmath38 with @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and uniformly with respect to @xmath41 ; see . define @xmath148 as in . then @xmath77 satisfies , up to a remainder @xmath46 , bounded by @xmath47 with @xmath374;h^{s+11/2})},\big\vert \partial_x\psi^{\mathfrak{p}}\big\vert_{w^{1}([0,t];h^{s+13/2 } ) } ) $ ] .
the proof of proposition [ prop : consgreennaghdi2 ] is identical to the proof of proposition [ prop : consgreennaghdi1 ] , once one obtains a rigorous statement of in @xmath375;h^{s+1})$ ] norm , thus we omit it . * using layer - mean velocities . *
+ as we have seen , several different velocity variables are natural when expressing the green - naghdi equations . in the following ,
we choose to use , as in @xcite for example , the _ shear layer - mean velocity _ , defined by @xmath376 where @xmath31 are the layer - mean velocities integrated across the vertical layer in each fluid : @xmath32 we see two main benefits for such a choice .
first , the equation describing the evolution of the deformation of the interface is an exact equation , and not an @xmath255 approximation .
what is more , the system obtained using layer - mean velocities have a better behavior as for the linear well - posedness .
these two facts shall be discussed in more details below . when integrating laplace s equation in against a test function @xmath377 on the lower domain @xmath378 , and using boundary kinematic equations , one has @xmath379 where @xmath380 , so that one deduces that for any @xmath381 , @xmath382 in the same way , one has @xmath383 so that @xmath384 one deduces from the two above identities , imposing zero boundary conditions at infinity ( the fluid is at rest at infinity ) , @xmath385 it follows that the first equation in becomes @xmath386 let us emphasize again that this identity is exact , as opposed to the @xmath255 approximations in previous asymptotic models .
one also deduces an expansion of @xmath387 in terms of @xmath369 , using proposition [ prop : expgh ] ( or , equivalently , identifying the above identity with the first line of ) .
it follows @xmath388\bar v \ + \ { \mathcal{o}}(\mu^2).\ ] ]
system therefore becomes @xmath389\bar v \bigg ) \ + \
( \gamma+\delta)\partial_x{\zeta } \ + \
\frac{\epsilon}{2 } \partial_x\big(\dfrac{{h_1}^2 -\gamma { h_2}^2 } { ( h_1+\gamma h_2)^2 } |\bar v|^2\big ) \ = \
\mu\epsilon\partial_x\big(\overline{{\mathcal{r}}}[h_1,h_2]\bar v \big ) \ , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] with the following operators : @xmath36v \
\frac{-1}{3h_1 h_2}\bigg(h_1 \partial_x \big({h_2}^3\partial_x\big(\frac{h_1\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big)\ + \
\gamma h_2\partial_x \big ( { h_1}^3\partial_x \big(\frac{h_2\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2}\big)\big)\bigg ) , \\
\overline{{\mathcal{r}}}[h_1,h_2]v \ & \equiv \
\frac12 \bigg ( \big ( h_2\partial_x \big ( \frac{h_1\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big)^2\ -\ \gamma\big(h_1\partial_x \big(\frac{h_2\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big)^2\bigg)\\ & \qquad + \frac13\frac{v}{h_1+\gamma h_2}\ \bigg ( \frac{h_1}{h_2}\partial_x\big ( { h_2}^3\partial_x\big(\frac{h_1\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2 } \big)\big ) \ - \ \gamma\frac{h_2}{h_1}\partial_x\big({h_1}^3\partial_x \big(\frac{h_2\ v}{h_1+\gamma h_2}\big)\big ) \bigg ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] this system is exactly our green - naghdi system , as presented in the introduction .
one obtains proposition [ prop : consgreennaghdimeani ] , namely the consistency of the solutions of the full euler system towards our green - naghdi model , in the same way as propositions [ prop : consgreennaghdi1 ] and [ prop : consgreennaghdi2 ] above , after several technical but straightforward computations .
we prove below that system is linearly well - posed , as opposed to system .
[ [ linear - dispersion - relations . ] ] linear dispersion relations .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the linearized system from is @xmath390 let us look for solutions of the form @xmath391 .
this leads to the algebraic system @xmath392 which yields the dispersion relation ( with @xmath393 ) @xmath394 this equation does not have any real solution @xmath395 if @xmath396 , thus _ the system is linearly ill - posed_. the linearized system from is @xmath397 same calculations as above yield the algebraic system @xmath398 so that @xmath399 and the dispersion relation is @xmath400 this equations has always solutions : @xmath401 . thus _ the system using layer - mean velocity variables(namely , or identically ) is linearly well - posed . _
this section is dedicated to the study of the well - posedness of the cauchy problem as well as the persistence of spatial localization ( expressed by weighted sobolev norms ) , for the following equation : @xmath402 where @xmath138 ( @xmath101 ) , @xmath102 , @xmath403 , @xmath404 are fixed parameters ( possibly zero ) and @xmath114 .
more precisely , we prove the assertions of proposition [ prop : wpi ] , recalled below [ prop : wp ] let @xmath112 , with @xmath113 .
let the parameters be such that @xmath114 , and define @xmath115 such that @xmath116 then there exists @xmath117 and a unique @xmath118 such that @xmath119 satisfies and initial condition @xmath120 .
moreover , @xmath119 satisfies the energy estimate for @xmath121 : @xmath405 assume additionally that for fixed @xmath123 , the function @xmath124 , with @xmath125 and @xmath126 .
then there exists @xmath127 such that for @xmath128 , one has @xmath129 in particular , one has , for @xmath128 , @xmath406 the existence and uniqueness of @xmath118 such that @xmath119 satisfies and initial condition @xmath407 @xmath113 has been obtained in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 4 ) ( where the authors used slightly different parameters ) .
the proof is based on an iterative scheme , which relies heavily on the following energy estimate : @xmath408 which is proved to be valid for @xmath409 .
one proves in the same way @xmath410 so that the estimate follows . in order to obtain the estimates in the weighted sobolev norms ,
we introduce the function @xmath411 , where @xmath119 satisfies .
we will prove that estimate , below , holds for any @xmath412 , and for @xmath413 by induction on @xmath414 .
proposition [ prop : wp ] is a straightforward consequence . @xmath415 _ the case @xmath416 .
_ one can easily check that @xmath417 satisfies the equation @xmath418 , { \nonumber}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath419 \ \equiv \ - 2\mu\ \beta \partial_{x}\partial_t u \ + \
3\mu\nu \partial_x^2 u \ + \ \mu\epsilon\ \big((\kappa + \iota)u\partial_x^2 u+2\iota ( \partial_x u)^2\big ) .\ ] ] when taking the ( @xmath420)inner product of with @xmath421 , one obtains ( using that the operator @xmath422 is symmetric for the ( @xmath420)inner product , and @xmath423 is anti - symmetric ) @xmath424 \ , \
\lambda^s v_1 \ \big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , we use that @xmath119 is uniformly bounded through for @xmath425 . *
using cauchy - schwarz inequality , and moser estimates : @xmath426 for @xmath427 , one has @xmath428 * in the same way , and using the definition @xmath429 , @xmath430 * finally , one can check @xmath431 \ , \
\lambda^s v_1 \ \big)\right\rvert
\mu \big\vert v_1\big\vert_{h^s}c(\frac1{s_0 - 1/2},\big\vert u\big\vert_{h^{s+2}}+\big\vert \partial_t u\big\vert_{h^{s+1 } } ) \ \leq
\ \mu c(\frac1{s_0 - 3/2},m , \big\vert u^0 \big\vert_{h^{s+3}_\mu } ) e^s(v_1).\ ] ] altogether , one obtains the following differential inequality , valid for all @xmath425 : @xmath432 gronwall - bihari s inequality ( see @xcite for example ) allows to deduce : @xmath433 when restricting @xmath3 to @xmath434 , it follows that for any @xmath194 , @xmath435 in order to control the time derivative of @xmath436 , we take the ( @xmath420)inner product of with @xmath437 . estimating each term as above , one obtains @xmath438 , \lambda^{s-1}\partial_t v_1 \big)\right\rvert \\ & \leq \
e^{s-1}(\partial_t v_1 ) \left ( c(\frac1{s_0 - 3/2},m , \big\vert u^0 \big\vert_{h^{s+1}_\mu } ) e^s(v_1)+ \mu c(\frac1{s_0 - 3/2},m , \big\vert u^0 \big\vert_{h^{s+2}_\mu } ) \right ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] estimate thus follows for @xmath416 and @xmath439 .
we know turn to @xmath440 , for @xmath441 , @xmath442 .
note that @xmath443 so that @xmath444 one deduces , for @xmath445 , @xmath446 in the same way , one has @xmath447 so that estimate hold for @xmath416 and any @xmath441 . _
the case @xmath448 .
_ let us assume that holds for any @xmath441 and @xmath449 ( with @xmath450 ) .
one can easily check that @xmath451 satisfies the equation @xmath452 , { \nonumber}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath453 & \equiv - 2\mu\ \beta m x^{m-1}\partial_{x}\partial_t u- 2\mu\ \beta m ( m-1)x^{m-2}\partial_t u + 3\mu\nu mx^{m-1}\partial_x^2 u + 3\mu\nu m(m-1)x^{m-2}\partial_x u\\ & \
+ \mu\nu m(m-1)(m-2)x^{m-3 } u + \mu\epsilon m x^{m-1 } \big((\kappa + \iota)u\partial_x^2 u+2\iota ( \partial_x u)^2\big ) + \mu\epsilon m(m-1)x^{m-2}\iota u\partial_x u. \end{aligned}\ ] ] taking the ( @xmath420)inner product of with @xmath454 , one obtains as above @xmath455 \ , \
\lambda^s v_m \ \big)\right\rvert .\ ] ] now , one can easily check @xmath456 \ , \
\lambda^s v_m \ \big)\right\rvert \ & \leq \
\mu c(\frac1{s_0 - 1/2},m ) \big\vert v_m\big\vert_{h^s}c\big(\big\vert x^{m-1}\partial_x \partial_t u\big\vert_{h^{s}}+\big\vert x^{m-2 } \partial_t u\big\vert_{h^{s } } \\
& \qquad + \big\vert x^{m-1 } \partial_x^2 u\big\vert_{h^{s}}+\big\vert x^{m-2 } \partial_x u\big\vert_{h^{s } } + \big\vert x^{m-3 } u\big\vert_{h^{s } } \big ) \\ & \leq \
\mu e^s(v_m)c\big(\frac1{s_0 - 3/2 } , m , m,\sum_{j=0}^{m-1}\big\vert x^{m-1-j } { u^0}\big\vert_{h^{s+2j+1}_\mu}\big ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] as above , gronwall - bihari s inequality allows to deduce @xmath457 for any @xmath458 and for any @xmath113 .
therefore , @xmath459 the similar estimate on the time derivative of @xmath451 , is obtained as above by taking the ( @xmath420)inner product of with @xmath460 .
estimate follows for any @xmath461 and @xmath439 .
we know turn to @xmath462 .
note that for any @xmath441 , @xmath442 , @xmath463 so that @xmath464 using , one deduces by induction on @xmath465 that @xmath466 in the same way , one estimates @xmath467 by induction , using leibniz rule of differentiation .
estimate therefore holds for @xmath461 and any @xmath441 . by induction
, we proved that holds for any @xmath441 and @xmath414 .
estimate follows as a direct consequence ( using the case @xmath439 ) , and proposition [ prop : wp ] is proved .
in this section , we show that if one chooses carefully the initial perturbation ( deformation of the interface as well as shear layer - mean velocity ) , then the flow is unidirectional , in the sense that one can construct an extremely precise approximate solution , driven by a simple unidirectional scalar equation .
this study follows the strategy developed for the water - wave problem in @xcite . the precise result , which has been displayed in the introduction ( proposition [ prop : unidiri ] ) ,
is recalled below , followed by its proof and a brief discussion .
[ prop : unidir ] set @xmath134 , and @xmath135 with @xmath113 . for @xmath86 , as defined in , denote @xmath136 the unique solution of the equation @xmath468 with parameters @xmath469 for given @xmath143 , assume that there exists @xmath144 such that @xmath145 and for any @xmath146 , @xmath147 then define @xmath148 as @xmath149 $ ] , with @xmath470 \ =
\ \zeta + \epsilon\frac{\alpha_1}2\zeta^2 + \epsilon^2 \frac{\alpha_2}{3 } \zeta^3 + \epsilon^3
\frac{\alpha_3}4 \zeta^4 + \mu\nu\partial_x^2\zeta+\mu\epsilon\left(\kappa_1 \zeta\partial_x^2\zeta + \kappa_2 ( \partial_x \zeta)^2\right),\ ] ] where parameters @xmath151 are as above , and @xmath471 .
then @xmath77 is consistent with green - naghdi equations , of order @xmath79 and on @xmath155 , with precision @xmath95 , with @xmath472 in order to simplify the calculations , we use the green - naghdi system expressed using the variables @xmath473 where we define @xmath474 .
the system reads @xmath475\underline{v } \bigg ) \ + \
( \gamma+\delta)\partial_x{\zeta } + \frac{\epsilon}{2 } \partial_x\big(\frac{{h_1}^2 -\gamma { h_2}^2}{(h_1h_2)^2 } |\underline{v}|^2\big ) = \mu\epsilon\partial_x\big(\underline{{\mathcal{r}}}[h_1,h_2]\underline{v } \big ) , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] with the following operators : @xmath476v \ & \equiv \
\frac{-1}{3h_1 h_2}\bigg(h_1 \partial_x \big({h_2}^3\partial_x\big ( \frac{v}{h_2 } \big)\big)\ + \ \gamma h_2\partial_x \big ( { h_1}^3\partial_x \big ( \frac{v}{h_1}\big)\big)\bigg ) , \\
\underline{{\mathcal{r}}}[h_1,h_2]v \ & \equiv \ \frac12 \bigg ( \big ( h_2\partial_x \big ( \frac{v}{h_2 } \big)\big)^2 - \gamma\big(h_1\partial_x \big(\frac{v}{h_1 } \big)\big)^2\bigg)\\ & \qquad + \frac13 v\ \bigg ( \frac{h_1}{h_2}\partial_x\big ( { h_2}^3\partial_x\big(\frac{v}{h_2 } \big)\big ) - \gamma\frac{h_2}{h_1}\partial_x\big({h_1}^3\partial_x \big(\frac{v}{h_1}\big)\big ) \bigg ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] using this system simplifies considerably the analysis .
indeed , it is clear that if @xmath17 is to satisfy the following scalar evolution equation , @xmath477 then @xmath478 shall satisfy ( using the first equation of , and the fact that the system is at rest at infinity : @xmath479 when @xmath480 ) @xmath481 now we will show that one can choose coefficients @xmath482 , _ etc . _
such that the second equation of is satisfied up to a small remainder .
indeed , when plugging and , and expanding in terms of @xmath5 and @xmath6 , one obtains @xmath483 where the remainder @xmath484 can be estimated , provided @xmath485 and @xmath486 , as @xmath487 the left hand side of vanishes when we set @xmath488 such a choice corresponds to parameters of proposition [ prop : unidir ] , with @xmath489 .
the cases @xmath490 and @xmath491 are obtained using the so - called bbm trick and near - identity change of variables , as precisely described in section [ ssec : formal ] .
we detail the calculations below , using for simplicity the notation @xmath492 for any term bounded by @xmath493 . _
bbm trick_. we make use of the first order approximation in : @xmath494 so that one has , for any @xmath495 , @xmath496 plugging this identity into yields @xmath497 conversely , @xmath498 , a solution of ( with zero on the right hand side ) , satisfies with a reaminder bounded by @xmath499 .
one can easily check that , defining @xmath500 as a function of @xmath498 through , @xmath501 satisfies up to a remainder @xmath502 .
proposition [ prop : unidir ] is now proved for @xmath495 and @xmath160 .
_ near identity change of variable_. let us consider @xmath503 where we recall @xmath504 , and with @xmath498 satisfying ( with zero on the right hand side )
. then @xmath505 satisfies @xmath506 again , it is now straightforward though technical to check that , denoting @xmath507 the solution of and defining @xmath508 as a function of @xmath507 through , then @xmath509 satisfies up to a remainder @xmath510 .
proposition [ prop : unidir ] is now proved for any @xmath511 .
[ [ discussion . ] ] discussion .
+ + + + + + + + + + + note that the accuracy of the unidirectional approximate solution , described in proposition [ prop : unidir ] is considerably better than the one of the decoupled model ; see proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] . as a matter of fact
, the accuracy of the unidirectional approximation is as good as the solution of the coupled green - naghdi model , in the camassa - holm regime @xmath512 .
more precisely , provided hypothesis [ conj : stab ] is valid , one obtains the following result ( to compare with corollary [ cor : convergence ] , below ) .
[ cor : convergenceuni]for @xmath86 , as defined in , let @xmath90 be a solution of green - naghdi equations such that the family @xmath513 is uniformly bounded on @xmath132 , @xmath79 sufficiently big , over time interval @xmath514 $ ] , and with initial data satisfying .
assume that hypotheses of proposition [ prop : unidir ] hold , and denote @xmath195 the unidirectional approximation defined therein .
then if hypothesis [ conj : stab ] is true , one has for any @xmath515 , @xmath516;h^s ) } \ \leq \
c\ \max(\epsilon^4,\mu^2)\ t , \ ] ] with @xmath97;h^s ) } , m_{s+5},h^{-1},\delta_{\text{min}}^{-1},\delta_{\text{max}},\epsilon_{\text{max}},\mu_{\text{max}},|\lambda|,|\theta| \big)$ ] .
such a result is supported by numerical simulations . in figures [ fig : uni201 ] and [ fig : uni102 ] , we compute the decoupled constantin - lannes approximation of definition [ def : cl ] , as well as the unidirectional approximation described in proposition [ prop : unidir ] , and compare them with the the solution of the green - naghdi system , in the camassa - holm regime @xmath517 and for a unidirectional initial data ( _ i.e. _ such that is satisfied at @xmath518 ) .
figure [ fig : uni201 ] deals with the case of a critical ratio @xmath238 , whereas the ratio is non - critical in figure [ fig : uni102 ] .
each time , we represent the difference between the green - naghdi model and scalar ( unidirectional and decoupled ) approximations , with respect to time and for @xmath519 . values at times @xmath520 and @xmath521 are marked .
in the two right - hand - side panels , we plot the difference in a log - log scale for more values of @xmath5 ( the markers reveal the positions which have been simulated ) , at aforementioned times .
the pink triangles express the convergence rate .
the bottom panel reproduces the difference with respect to the space variable , at final time @xmath522 . in figure
[ fig : uni201 ] , we choose a set up which is favorable to the decoupled approximation of definition [ def : cl ] : critical ratio @xmath523 and localized initial data , @xmath524 .
we see that the unidirectional approximation offers a greater accuracy than the decoupled approximation .
in particular , the decoupled model predicts a small wave moving on the left ( of size @xmath525 , as @xmath526 in ) , which is not predicted in the unidirectional model , and almost nonexistent in the solution of the green - naghdi system , as we can see in figure [ fig : uni201c ] .
this short - time @xmath525 error of the cl decomposition is preserved over times of order @xmath527 . as for the unidirectional model ,
the produced error is clearly , and as predicted by corollary [ cor : convergenceuni ] , of size @xmath528 . in figure [ fig :
uni102 ] , the ratio is non critical ( @xmath529 ) , and initial data as previously .
the accuracy of the cl approximate solution of definition [ def : cl ] is worse than in the critical case , as the short - time error is of size @xmath530 .
once again , the same error estimates holds over times of order @xmath527
. the accuracy of the unidirectional model is not affected , and is still of size @xmath528 : _ the criticality of the depth - ratio do not play a role in the accuracy of the unidirectional approximation . _
let us now turn to the following question : _ is it true that after a certain time , any perturbation will decompose into two waves , each one satisfying ( approximatively ) an equation of the form ?
our answer is numerical .
we use the numerical simulations of section [ sssec : ch1 ] ( non - critical ratio , localized initial data ) , and test the right wave , defined simply as the part of the signal located in the right half - line @xmath531 , of the numerical solution of the green - naghdi system against .
as we can see in figure [ fig : ztova ] ( where the log of the error is plotted to ease the viewing ) , even with such a rough a crude exploration , a very good agreement appears after a given time @xmath532 , which is independent of @xmath5 ( but rather depends on the thickness , or wavelength of the initial data ) .
the accuracy of this agreement is in our simulation of size @xmath533 , and valid for long times ; see figure [ fig : ztovb ] .
[ [ numerical - scheme . ] ] numerical scheme .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the major difficulty concerning the numerical simulations computed throughout this paper is the fact that as @xmath5 is small ( down to @xmath534 ) , the time domain @xmath535 $ ] ( @xmath536 $ ] in section [ ssec : discussion ] ) , and therefore the space domain of computation becomes very large . the decoupled models can be solved very efficiently by using a frame of reference moving with the decoupled wave , but solving numerically the green - naghdi scheme has to be carried out on the full time / space domain .
thus we need a scheme which allows a great accuracy , with a relatively small computation cost . with this in mind
, we turn to multi - step , explicit and spectral methods .
the space discretization , and in particular the discrete differentiation matrices use trigonometric polynomial on an equispaced grid , as described in @xcite ( precisely ( 1.5 ) ) .
this yields an exponential accuracy with the size of the grid @xmath537 , if the signal is smooth ( note that the major drawback is that the discrete differentiation matrices are not sparse ) .
it turns out setting @xmath538 is sufficient for the numerical errors to be undetectable . after this space discretization
, one has to solve a system of ordinary differential equations in time , and we use the matlab solver ` ode113 ` , which is based on the explicit , multistep , adams - bashforth - moulton method @xcite , with a stringent tolerance of @xmath539 .
in this section , our aim is to obtain approximate solutions to , through a decomposition of the flow into two independent waves , each one satisfying a scalar evolution equation .
our aim is dual .
first , we want to investigate which scalar equation each of these waves should to satisfy , in order to be as accurate as possible .
then , we want to estimate the size of the error we commit by neglecting the coupling between the two components .
we first give a fairly simple formal approach in section [ ssec : formal ] , which allows to heuristically construct the decoupled equations at stake , and consequently the approximate solutions ( as precisely defined in definitions [ def : cl ] and [ def : other ] ) . in section [ sec : prop : decompositioni ] , we give the proof of the rigorous justification of such approximations ; see propositions [ prop : decompositioni ] and [ prop : other ] .
section [ ssec : discussion ] contains a discussion on our result , considering various different regimes and decoupled models , and supported with numerical simulations .
the main idea of the decomposition is that at first order ( that is , setting @xmath540 ) , our system of equations is simply a linear wave equation @xmath541 and @xmath542 .
it is straightforward to check that @xmath543 has two distinct eigenvalues , therefore , we can find a basis of @xmath544 such that reduces to two decoupled equations .
more precisely , there exists @xmath545 now , let us define @xmath546 .
multiplying by @xmath547 ( on the left ) , and keeping only first order terms , yields @xmath548 _ as a conclusion , the solution @xmath542 may be decomposed in the following way : _
@xmath549 now , let us take into account the higher order terms in .
one will make use of the following straightforward expansions : @xmath550{\bar}v \ & = \ - \frac{1+\gamma\delta}{3\delta(\gamma+\delta)}\partial_x^2 { \bar}v-\epsilon\frac{\gamma+\delta}3 \left((\beta-\alpha){\bar}v \partial_x^2\zeta \ + \ ( \alpha+2\beta)\partial_x(\zeta\partial_x{\bar}v)-\beta\zeta\partial_x^2{\bar}v\right ) \ + \ { \mathcal{o}}(\epsilon^2 ) , \\
\overline{{\mathcal{r}}}[h_1,h_2]{\bar}v \ & \equiv \ \alpha\left(\frac12 ( \partial_x { \bar}v)^2+\frac13{\bar}v\partial_x^2 { \bar}v\right ) \ + \ { \mathcal{o}}(\epsilon ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath551 and @xmath552 . using the decomposition as above : @xmath553 , and withdrawing every term of size @xmath554
, one can check that the green - naghdi system becomes the following coupled system in terms of @xmath555 ( left - going wave ) and @xmath556 ( right - going wave ) : where @xmath558 and @xmath558 are defined below : @xmath559 , \\
f_r^{\epsilon,\mu } & = -\epsilon\frac{\alpha_1}2\partial_x \big((\frac13 u_l+u_r)(u_r - u_l)\big ) -
\epsilon^2 \frac{\alpha_2}3\partial_x\big((u_r - u_l)u_r(u_l+u_r)\big)\\ & \qquad -\epsilon^3\frac{\alpha_3}4\partial_x\big((u_r-\frac15u_l)(u_r - u_l)(u_l+u_r)^2\big ) \\ & \qquad -\mu\nu \partial_x^2\partial_t(u_r - u_l ) -\mu\epsilon\kappa_3\partial_x\big ( \frac13(u_r - u_l)(\partial_x^2 u_r-\partial_x^2 u_l)+\frac12(\partial_x u_r-\partial_x u_l)^2 \big ) \\ & \qquad - \mu\epsilon \partial_t\big [ \kappa_1(u_r\partial_x^2u_r - u_l\partial_x^2 u_l)+\kappa_2 ( u_l\partial_x^2u_r - u_r\partial_x^2u_l)+(\kappa_1+\frac{\kappa_2}2)\big((\partial_x u_r)^2-(\partial_x u_l)^2\big)\big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ rem : ch ] one could use higher order expansions with respect to the parameter @xmath5 , which would lead to decoupled models with formally higher accuracy . however , let us note that our results ( see discussion in section [ ssec : discussion ] ) show that the main error of our decoupled models comes from neglecting coupling terms which arise at low order , rather than the unidirectional error which is produced by neglecting higher order terms in the scalar equations . thus including these higher order terms in the evolution equation is unlikely to produce substantial improvement .
[ prop : consserre ] let @xmath561 be strong solutions of , depending on sets of parameters @xmath86 , as defined in .
we assume that for @xmath427 , @xmath562 , uniformly in @xmath242 .
additionally , we assume that there exists @xmath42 such that @xmath563 then @xmath564 is consistent with green - naghdi equations of order @xmath79 on @xmath80 , at precision @xmath565 ( in the sense of definition [ def : consistency ] ) .
proposition [ prop : consserre ] is straightforward once one obtains a rigorous statement of the expansions of @xmath566{\bar}v^{\mathfrak{p}}\ , \
\overline{{\mathcal{r}}}[h_1^{\mathfrak{p}},h_2^{\mathfrak{p}}]{\bar}v^{\mathfrak{p}}$ ] , as stated above , the residual being estimated in @xmath567 norm .
these expansions are easily checked , provided the assumptions of the proposition ( @xmath562 , @xmath568 ) are satisfied , and using uniformly continuous ( for @xmath427 ) sobolev embedding @xmath569 . * _ the bbm trick _ ( from benjamin - bona - mahony @xcite ) . keeping only the first order terms in equations ,
one has the simple transport equations @xmath575 it follows that one can replace time derivatives in higher order terms ( of order @xmath576 ) by spatial derivatives ( up to a sign ) , and both equations have formally the same order of accuracy . in order to simplify
, we consider only equations with spatial derivatives in @xmath576 terms ( if they exist ) .
in particular , becomes + @xmath577 + following a similar idea , we make use of the low order identity obtained from : @xmath578 so that one has , for any @xmath495 , @xmath579 plugging back into and withdrawing @xmath580 terms yields + @xmath581 + where we have defined , after parameters , @xmath582 * _ near identity changes of variables_. we used system as our reference system , and therefore the unknowns we consider are @xmath583 , where @xmath584 is the shear layer - mean velocity . however , other natural variables may also be used , such as the the _ shear velocity at the interface _ ( leading to system ) @xmath585 ( where we use the change of coordinate flattening the fluid domains : @xmath586 ; see @xcite ) , or more generally , using the horizontal derivative of the potential at specific heights ( @xmath587 $ ] : @xmath588 using the expansion of the velocity potentials and layer - mean velocities , as obtained in @xcite , as well as the identity @xmath589 ( obtained through the rigid lid assumption ) , yields the following approximation : @xmath590 with @xmath591 , and @xmath592 a bi - linear differential operator whose precise formula do not play a significant role in our work as we shall discuss below . following this idea ,
we consider @xmath593 if @xmath594 satisfies , then @xmath595 satisfies the following equations , up to terms of order @xmath580 : + @xmath596 + where we have defined , after parameters , @xmath597 + note that in order to fit as much as possible with variables @xmath598 , one could have used more complex change of variables , such as @xmath599 with @xmath600 , and @xmath601 obtained through @xmath592 .
it turns out @xmath602 and @xmath603 would then satisfy the same equation as above : the new parameters do not depend on @xmath604 and @xmath605 , as their contribution is of order @xmath606 , after using bbm trick to suppress higher order derivatives with respect to time .
we thus do not consider such changes of variable . in this section , we give the rigorous justification of the constantin - lannes decoupled approximation , as defined in definition [ def : cl ] .
more precisely , we prove proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] , that we recall below .
[ prop : decomposition ] let @xmath193 , with @xmath194 .
for @xmath86 , as defined in , we denote @xmath195 the unique solution of the cl approximation , as defined in definition [ def : cl ] .
for some given @xmath196 , sufficiently big , we assume that there exists @xmath197 and a family @xmath198 such that @xmath199 then there exists @xmath200 $ ] such that @xmath201 is consistent with green - naghdi equations of order @xmath79 on @xmath202 $ ] for @xmath203 , at precision @xmath204 with @xmath205 with @xmath206 , and the corrector term @xmath207 is estimated as @xmath208;h^{s})}+\big\vert \partial_t u^c \big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t^\star];h^{s } ) } \leq c\ \max(\epsilon(\delta^2-\gamma),\epsilon^2,\mu ) \min ( t , \sqrt t ) .\ ] ] additionally , if there exists @xmath209 , @xmath210 such that @xmath211 then @xmath201 is consistent with green - naghdi equations of order @xmath79 on @xmath202 $ ] for @xmath212 , at precision @xmath213 with @xmath214 with @xmath215 and @xmath207 is uniformly estimated as @xmath216;h^{s})}+\big\vert \partial_t u^c \big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t^\sharp];h^{s } ) } \leq c\ \max(\epsilon(\delta^2-\gamma),\epsilon^2,\mu ) \min ( t , 1).\ ] ] the proof of proposition [ prop : other ] is identical to the one of proposition [ prop : decomposition ] , presented below .
more precisely , the choice of lower - order evolution equations modifies mostly the last term of in lemma [ lem : proofcons ] ( below ) , as the contribution of neglected unidirectional terms should be added .
the additional error is therefore uniformly bounded over times @xmath221 $ ] and @xmath608 $ ] .
the detailed proof of proposition [ prop : other ] is omitted .
our strategy is the following .
inspired by the calculations of section [ ssec : formal ] , we seek an approximate solution of under the form @xmath609 \ , \ ] ] where @xmath217 satisfies the constantin - lannes equation , and @xmath610 contains the leading order coupling terms .
the parameter @xmath611 is assumed to be small , and we want to justify our approximate solutions over times of order @xmath612 . as we shall see , controlling the secular growth of @xmath610 requires to consider separately the short time scale , where the coupling effects may be strong , and long time scale , where the coupling between two localized waves moving in opposite directions can be controlled .
thus we introduce the long time scale @xmath615 , and will seek an approximate solution of as @xmath616(\tau , t , x ) \ , { \nonumber}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with obvious misuses of notation . at next order , and following the calculations of section [ ssec : formal ] ,
one obtains the decoupled equations @xmath619 where parameters satisfy identities of definition [ def : cl ] . in order to deal with the coupling terms ,
we introduce the following first order correction .
[ rem : viscl ] the above discussion does not take into account the use of near identity change of variable as described in section [ ssec : formal ] .
in that case , we set the initial data as follows : @xmath626 thus the function @xmath627 , defined by and with initial data , satisfies precisely @xmath628 where @xmath186 is the solution of as defined in definition [ def : cl ] .
the proof is now as follows .
first , we state that the approximate solution , @xmath629 , constructed as above , does satisfy , up to a small remainder ( although depending on the size of @xmath217 , @xmath630 , and their derivatives ) . the fact that @xmath217 is uniformly bounded follows from the assumptions of the proposition . the key ingredient in the proof
consists in estimating the growth over long times ( that is , in the variable @xmath631 ) , of @xmath630 satisfying .
each of these steps are described in details in the following .
[ [ construction - and - accuracy - of - the - approximate - solution - u_textapp . ] ] construction and accuracy of the approximate solution @xmath632 .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + [ lem : proofcons ] let @xmath193 , with @xmath113 , and @xmath86 , as defined in .
let @xmath633 be defined by , and with initial data .
then define @xmath634 as @xmath635 and set @xmath636(\tau , t , x),\ ] ] where @xmath207 is defined in definition [ def : corrector ] .
then for @xmath5 small enough , @xmath629 satisfies the coupled equations , up to a remainder , @xmath484 , bounded by @xmath637 with a function @xmath638 satisfying @xmath639 . * @xmath641 is the contribution due to the expansion of @xmath642{\bar}v$ ] and @xmath643{\bar}v$ ] with respect to parameter @xmath5 ; * @xmath61 is a linear combination of @xmath644 and @xmath645 as defined in ; * @xmath646 and @xmath647 are respectively the components due to the use of the bbm trick and near - identity change of variable .
let us detail the first terms leading to @xmath641 .
we want to control the contribution of the expansion of @xmath648 , that is , more precisely , estimate @xmath649 where we denote @xmath650 , and @xmath651 .
note that , as we shall prove that @xmath652 is bounded in @xmath653 , there exists @xmath654 such that for any @xmath655 , one has @xmath656 now , one can easily check that , in that case , @xmath657 , where @xmath658 is a polynomial of degree 4 , and estimate @xmath659 follows .
the contributions due to the expansion of @xmath660 is estimated in the same way .
the contribution due to the expansion of @xmath661{\bar}v$ ] requires more derivatives , but may be estimated as above by @xmath662 .
the contribution due to the expansion of @xmath663{\bar}v$ ] involves one time derivative , and is controlled by @xmath664 .
this yields the first line of .
then , one can check that @xmath665 where @xmath272 is a bivariate polynomial of degree 4 , and whose leading order terms are @xmath666 and @xmath667 are bilinear forms . each of these terms are bounded as in .
the bound on @xmath217 is a direct consequence of the assumptions of the proposition , using the identity @xmath670 where @xmath671 is defined through definition [ def : cl ] , and therefore is uniformly controlled as assumed in the proposition .
it follows @xmath672 however , let us note that one can gain extra smallness on @xmath673 ( trading with a loss of derivatives ) from the fact that @xmath674 satisfies . indeed , one has for any @xmath675 , @xmath676 where @xmath677 is a polynomial , so
that , as defined in , and parameters satisfy identities of definition [ def : cl ] , one should replace @xmath678 by @xmath679 . ] @xmath680 let us now study the term @xmath620 , which contains all the coupling effects between the different components .
our aim is to control the secular growth of this term .
this will be achieved through the following two lemmas .
[ lem : lannes ] let @xmath427 , and @xmath691 , @xmath692 .
then there exists a unique global strong solution , @xmath693 , of @xmath694 where @xmath688 , and @xmath695 is a bilinear mapping defined on @xmath544 and with values in @xmath696 .
a. @xmath697 b. using @xmath688 , one has the sublinear growth @xmath698 with @xmath699 . c. if moreover , there exists @xmath209 such that @xmath700 , and @xmath701 , then one has the ( uniform in time ) estimate @xmath702 with @xmath703 .
[ lem : estimatescoupling ] let @xmath217 defined as in lemma [ lem : proofcons ] , for @xmath707
. then there exists a unique @xmath708 such that @xmath620 , with @xmath630 satisfying and @xmath709 .
moreover , one has the estimate for and @xmath710 $ ] @xmath711\times[0,t];h^{s } ) } & \leq c(m^\star_{s+3 } ) \max(\epsilon\alpha_1,\epsilon^2,\mu ) \min ( t , \sqrt t ) , \label{eq : est1}\\ \sigma^2\big\vert \partial_\tau u^c_\pm \big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t]\times[0,t];h^{s } ) } & \leq c(m^\star_{s+6})\max(\epsilon\alpha_1,\epsilon^2,\mu)^2 \min ( t , \sqrt t ) .\label{eq : est2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , if @xmath712 , @xmath427 , and @xmath713 , then one has the uniform estimate @xmath714\times[0,t^\sharp];h^{s } ) } & \leq c(m^\sharp_{s+3 } ) \max(\epsilon\alpha_1,\epsilon^2,\mu ) \min ( t , 1 ) , \label{eq : est3}\\ \sigma^2\big\vert \partial_\tau u^c_\pm \big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t]\times[0,t^\sharp];h^{s } ) } & \leq c(m^\sharp_{s+6 } ) \max(\epsilon\alpha_1,\epsilon^2,\mu)^2 \min ( t , 1 ) .\label{eq : est4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by definition , @xmath715 satisfies @xmath717 and the right - hand - side can be decomposed in the following way : @xmath718 where the parameters @xmath719 , @xmath720 , @xmath721 , @xmath722 and @xmath723 depend on @xmath724 , and where we used @xmath725 .
note that the first order terms @xmath726 and @xmath727 are factored by @xmath728 .
the estimates on @xmath748 are obtained similarly , as @xmath749 one can check that each term of the right hand side satisfies the hypotheses of lemmata [ lem : easy ] or [ lem : lannes ] , and estimate allows to obtain .
note that we use @xmath751 as above , as well as a uniform estimate @xmath752 the latter estimate can be enforced using lemma [ lem : estimatescoupling ] , by restricting the time interval with @xmath753 although such condition is not necessary , as proposition [ prop : decomposition ] is empty for @xmath754 , the accuracy of the decoupled solutions being of order @xmath755 .
[ lem : fullconsistency ] for @xmath193 , with @xmath113 , and @xmath756 , as defined in [ eqn : defregimefnl ] , let @xmath757 be defined as in lemma [ lem : proofcons ]
. then @xmath758 satisfies the coupled equations , up to a remainder , @xmath484 , estimated for @xmath759 by @xmath760 and on @xmath761 by @xmath762 our result takes its full meaning in the light of a conjectured stability result on green - naghdi equations , _ or any consistent model _
, as described in hypothesis [ conj : stab ] .
if such a result holds , then one can deduce from the consistency result of proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] that the difference between the solution of the green - naghdi system ( and in the same way , the solution of the full euler system if it exists ) and the weakly coupled approximate solution @xmath763 is small .
the estimates concerning the difference between the solution of and the fully decoupled solution @xmath764 simply follows from the estimates on @xmath765 , in proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] .
this strategy has been used in the water - wave case in @xcite , and in the case of internal waves ( when restricting to the long wave regime ) in @xcite . throughout this section
, we assume that hypothesis [ conj : stab ] holds , and study the convergence results between solutions of the green - naghdi model and the different approximate solutions which proceeds .
[ cor : convergencewc ] for @xmath86 , as defined in , let @xmath90 be a solution of green - naghdi equations such that the family @xmath513 is uniformly bounded on @xmath132 , @xmath79 sufficiently big , over time interval @xmath514 $ ] .
assume that hypotheses of proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] hold , and denote @xmath766 $ ] the approximate solution , satisfying @xmath767 .
then if hypothesis [ conj : stab ] is valid , for any @xmath768 , one has @xmath769;h^s ) } \ & \leq \
c\ \max(\epsilon^2(\delta^2-\gamma)^2,\epsilon^4,\mu^2)\ t ( 1+\sqrt{t}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath770;h^s ) } , m^\star_{s+6},\frac{1}{\delta_{\text{min}}},\delta_{\text{max}},\epsilon_{\text{max}},\mu_{\text{max}},|\lambda|,|\theta| \big)$ ] .
if moreover , the initial data is sufficiently localized in space , then one has for @xmath771 , @xmath772;h^s ) } \ & \leq \
c\ \max(\epsilon^2(\delta^2-\gamma)^2,\epsilon^4,\mu^2)\ t,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath97;h^s ) } , m^\sharp_{s+6},\frac{1}{\delta_{\text{min}}},\delta_{\text{max}},\epsilon_{\text{max}},\mu_{\text{max}},|\lambda|,|\theta| \big)$ ] .
we therefore see that the weakly coupled model achieves the same accuracy as the fully coupled green - naghdi model , in the camassa - holm regime , if one restricts to critical case @xmath773 , and if the initial data is sufficiently localized in space .
let us now turn to the fully decoupled models .
the following result is a straightforward application of the above corollary , together with the estimate of proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] .
estimates concerning lower order decoupled models are obtained in the same way , using proposition [ prop : other ] .
[ cor : convergence]for @xmath86 , as defined in , let @xmath90 be a solution of green - naghdi equations such that the family @xmath513 is uniformly bounded on @xmath132 , @xmath79 sufficiently big , over time interval @xmath514 $ ] .
denote respectively @xmath774 the decoupled approximations defined in definitions [ def : cl ] and [ def : other ] .
assume that the hypotheses of proposition [ prop : decompositioni ] hold , and hypothesis [ conj : stab ] is valid .
define @xmath775 .
then for any @xmath768 , one has @xmath776;h^s ) } \ & \leq \
c\ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0\ \min(t , t^{1/2 } ) ( 1 \ + \ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0 t ) , \\ \big\vert u_{\text{ekdv}}^{\mathfrak{p}}-{u_{\text{gn}}}^{\mathfrak{p}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ & \leq \
c\ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0\ \min(t , t^{1/2 } ) ( 1 \ + \ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0 t ) \ + \
c\ \max(\epsilon^3,\mu\epsilon)\ t , \\ \big\vert u_{\text{kdv}}^{\mathfrak{p}}-{u_{\text{gn}}}^{\mathfrak{p}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ & \leq \
c\ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0\ \min(t , t^{1/2 } ) ( 1 \ + \ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0 t ) \ + \
c\ \epsilon^2 \ t , \\
\big\vert u_{\text{ib}}^{\mathfrak{p}}-{u_{\text{gn}}}^{\mathfrak{p}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ & \leq \
c\ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0\ \min(t , t^{1/2 } ) ( 1 \ + \ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0 t ) \ + \
c\ \max(\epsilon^2,\mu)\ t,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath770;h^s ) } , m^\star_{s+6},\frac{1}{\delta_{\text{min}}},\delta_{\text{max}},\epsilon_{\text{max}},\mu_{\text{max}},|\lambda|,|\theta| \big)$ ]
. if the initial data is sufficiently localized in space , then one has for @xmath777 , @xmath778;h^s ) } \ & \leq \ c\ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0\ \min(t,1 ) ( 1 \ + \ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0 t ) , \\ \big\vert u_{\text{ekdv}}-u_s\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ & \leq \ c\ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0\ \min(t,1 ) ( 1 \ + \ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0 t ) \ + \
c\ \max(\epsilon^3,\mu\epsilon)\ t , \\ \big\vert u_{\text{kdv}}-u_s\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ & \leq \
c\ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0\ \min(t,1 ) ( 1 \ + \ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0 t ) \ + \
c\ \epsilon^2 \ t , \\
\big\vert u_{\text{ib}}-u_s\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ & \leq \
c\ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0\ \min(t,1 ) ( 1 \ + \ { \boldsymbol\varepsilon}_0 t ) \ + \
c\ \max(\epsilon^2,\mu)\ t,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath770;h^s ) } , m^\sharp_{s+6},\frac{1}{\delta_{\text{min}}},\delta_{\text{max}},\epsilon_{\text{max}},\mu_{\text{max}},|\lambda|,|\theta| \big)$ ] . *
the first ( and often main ) source of error comes from the coupling between the two counterpropagating waves which are neglected by our decoupled models , but recovered at first order by the weakly coupled model ( see corollary [ cor : convergencewc ] ) . following @xcite
, we name the contribution of this term the _ counterpropagation error_. this error grows linearly in time , for times of order @xmath755 , as the two waves are located at the same position ; and coupling effects are _ strong_. however , one is able to control sublinearly in time the _ secular growth _ of such coupling terms , which is the key ingredient of our result , and yields a contribution of size @xmath779 in general , @xmath780 if the initial data is sufficiently localized . * after very long time , one sees the effect of the precision of the consistency result , through the stability hypothesis .
such a contribution is unavoidable , as it appears after many manipulations of the equations , such as the use of bbm trick , or near - identity change of variables .
we call these contributions residual errors .
the error generated in that way affects both the solution of the scalar evolution equation and the coupling term , thus there are two contributions . the so - called _ unidirectional error _ is linear in time as long as the solution of the decoupled model is uniformly bounded , and varies greatly with the choice of the model .
the _ residual error _ coming from the coupling term may be superlinear ( if the initial data is not localized in space ) , as the coupling term grows in time .
all of these contributions are summarized in figure [ fig : sketcherror ] .
the total error of a decoupled models is the sum of the green and the red curves .
the green curve represents the error generated by neglecting the coupling between two waves , and therefore is affected by three of the contributions listed above , at different time scales .
the red curve is the unidirectional contribution , and varies with the choice of the model . however , let us precise that the full pattern is not always visible , as in many cases , one source of error will be negligible in front of the others . in particular , keep in mind that we obtained existence and uniform control in weighted sobolev spaces of the solutions of decoupled models only over times of order @xmath781 ( proposition [ prop : wp ] ) .
consequently , the time domain for which residual contributions appear is out of the scope of our rigorous results . in order to understand the relevance of a specific evolution equation
, one has to look whether the unidirectional contribution , which depends on the evolution equation itself , is smaller or greater than the different sources of error due to coupling .
for example , unidirectional error is always negligible in front of coupling terms in the constantin - lannes model , whereas it is expected to be preponderant in the inviscid burgers model .
let us look precisely at several interesting scenari , in the following subsections .
our discussion is supported by numerical simulations .
each time , we compute the coupled green - naghdi model and various decoupled approximations , for different values of @xmath5 and corresponding @xmath6 ( depending on the situation , @xmath782 or @xmath783 ) , and over times @xmath254 . as pointed out above , such time scale is out of the scope of our rigorous result .
however , interesting behavior appears after times @xmath71 , as we shall see .
each of the figures below contains three panels . on the left - hand side
, we represent the difference between the green - naghdi model and decoupled models , with respect to time and for @xmath519 .
values at times @xmath521 and @xmath784 are marked .
in the two right - hand - side panels , we plot the difference in a log - log scale for several values of @xmath5 ( the markers reveal the positions which have been computed ) , at aforementioned times .
the pink triangles express the convergence rate .
the initial data is fixed such that the left - going wave is initially two - third the right going wave , in order to avoid symmetry cancellations : @xmath785 .
for localized initial data , we choose initial data @xmath786 and for non - localized initial data , we choose @xmath787 .
we set @xmath523 in the critical ratio setting , and @xmath529 in the non - critical ratio setting .
finally , we set @xmath788 and @xmath160 .
the numerical scheme we use has been briefly described at the end of section [ sec : unidirectional ] it follows that _ the decoupled kdv approximation has the same order of accuracy as any higher order model _
, whatever the initial data or critical ratio is .
indeed , one has the same estimates for the decoupled approximations @xmath790 or @xmath791 or @xmath792 : @xmath793;h^s ) } \ \approx \
\big\vert u_{\text{cl}}-u_{\text{gn}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ \leq \
\min(t , t^{1/2 } ) ( 1 \ + \ \mu t ) , \ ] ] for any @xmath794 , and if the initial data is localized , @xmath793;h^s ) } \ \approx \
\big\vert u_{\text{cl}}-u_{\text{gn}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ \leq \
c_0\ \mu\ \min(t,1 ) ( 1 \ + \ \mu
t ) , \ ] ] for any @xmath795 .
let us note that one recovers the results of @xcite , for the kdv approximation .
more precisely , a unidirectional error of size @xmath796 is not detectable , as it is smaller than the coupling terms , presented above , so that the additional error produced by neglecting higher order terms in the constantin - lannes approximation , and considering only the kdv equation , does not change the accuracy of the model .
however , let us note that for localized initial data , unidirectional error of size @xmath796 is the limiting case .
this is why one sees in figure [ fig:21kdva ] a noticeable difference between the kdv approximation and higher order approximations ( ekdv , cl ) .
the rate of convergence in figure [ fig:21kdvb ] , however , is identical : the error is of size @xmath72 at time @xmath797 and @xmath798 at time @xmath799 .
we remark that the last panel of figure [ fig:21kdv ] shows a slight discrepancy with respect to the predicted convergence rate in @xmath798
. this may be due to the fact that higher order sources of error ( typically of size @xmath800 ) are detectable for larger values of @xmath6 ( @xmath801 ) , and eventually becomes negligible for smaller values ( @xmath802 ) , therefore artificially improving the convergence rate .
let us note also that the criticality of the depth ratio do not play a role in this analysis , and that simulations in the case of non - critical ratio gives similar outcome .
in that case , the contribution of the coupling error are always greater than the one of the unidirectional error , and one has the same estimates as for the decoupled approximations @xmath806 , @xmath790 , @xmath791 or @xmath792 : @xmath807;h^s ) } \ \approx \
\big\vert u_{\text{cl}}-u_{\text{gn}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ \leq \
\min(t , t^{1/2 } ) ( 1 \ + \ \sqrt\mu t ) , \ ] ] for any @xmath794 , and if the initial data is localized , @xmath807;h^s ) } \ \approx \
\big\vert u_{\text{cl}}-u_{\text{gn}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ \leq \
c_0\ \sqrt\mu\ \min(t,1 ) ( 1 \ + \ \sqrt\mu
t ) , \ ] ] for any @xmath795 . as a consequence , _
the inviscid burgers approximation is as precise as any higher order decoupled model . _ here , the unidirectional error of the inviscid burgers approximation is of the same order of magnitude as the residual coupling error , if the initial data is sufficiently localized .
therefore , in figure [ fig:11ch ] , one can observe a noticeable difference between the ib approximation and higher order models for long times , although the convergence rate is similar at time @xmath808 .
for longer times , the decoupled approximate solutions do not seem to converge , which may indicate that the exact solution @xmath809 can not be controlled over times @xmath254 , in the setting we use .
we recall that @xmath812 and @xmath813 are known to exist and to be of size @xmath814 , as a result of proposition [ prop : wp ] . over such time , the unidirectional error in the ekdv model is smaller than the coupling errors : one has for both @xmath791 and @xmath792 , @xmath815;h^s ) } \ \approx \
\big\vert u_{\text{cl}}-u_{\text{gn}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ \leq \
c_0\ \mu\ \min(t , t^{1/2 } ) , \ ] ] for any @xmath794 if @xmath816 . if moreover , the initial data is localized , then @xmath815;h^s ) } \ \approx \ \big\vert u_{\text{cl}}-u_{\text{gn}}\big\vert_{l^\infty([0,t];h^s ) } \ \leq \ c_0\ \mu\ \min(t,1),\ ] ] for any @xmath795 if @xmath817 .
the accuracy of both ekdv and cl approximations are of size @xmath818 at time @xmath819 , or improved to size @xmath72 if the initial data is sufficiently localized .
the accuracy of the kdv and ib approximation is of size @xmath798 at the latter time .
however , if one looks at longer times , then the picture is different . in our simulations , we looked at times up to @xmath820 . at that time , the localization in space of the initial data plays an important role .
if the initial data is non - localized in space , then contribution of the coupling terms are predicted to be greater than the unidirectional error of the ekdv approximation : the secular coupling error is dominant up to @xmath821 ( @xmath822 ) , after what the residual coupling term is dominant ( @xmath823 for @xmath824 ) .
thus _ the ekdv approximation is predicted to be as precise as the cl approximation in the camassa - holm regime and if the initial data is non - localized in space , even if the depth ratio is critical_. on the contrary , if the initial data is localized , then the unidirectional error is dominant : @xmath825 for any @xmath826 .
this leads , at time @xmath827 , to an error of size @xmath72 for the cl approximation , and of size @xmath818 for the ekdv approximation . _ if the initial data is localized , then the cl approximation is substantially more accurate than the ekdv approximation after very long time , in the camassa - holm regime with critical depth ratio . _
the difference between localized and non - localized initial data can be clearly seen when comparing figure [ fig:21ch ] and figure [ fig:23ch ] .
the fact the convergence rate of our numerical simulations fit the predictions of corollary [ prop : wp ] , even for times which are out of the scope of our rigorous results , gives hope to extend the validity of the cl approximation to such times , where it becomes more precise than lower order approximations .
h. r. dullin , g. a. gottwald , and d. d. holm .
camassa - holm , korteweg - de vries-5 and other asymptotically equivalent equations for shallow water waves . , 33(1 - 2):7395 , 2003 .
in memoriam prof .
philip gerald drazin 19342002 .
k. r. helfrich and w. k. melville .
long nonlinear internal waves . in _ annual review of fluid mechanics .
vol . 38 _ , volume 38 of _ annu .
fluid mech .
_ , pages 395425 .
annual reviews , palo alto , ca , 2006 . r. j. irio , jr .
kdv , bo and friends in weighted sobolev spaces . in _ functional - analytic methods for partial differential equations ( tokyo , 1989 )
_ , volume 1450 of _ lecture notes in math .
_ , pages 104121 .
springer , berlin , 1990 . t. kato . on the cauchy problem for the ( generalized ) korteweg - de vries equation . in _ studies in applied mathematics _ ,
volume 8 of _ adv .
_ , pages 93128 . academic press , new york , 1983 .
j. nahas and g. ponce . on the persistence properties of solutions of nonlinear dispersive equations in weighted sobolev spaces . in _ harmonic analysis and nonlinear partial differential equations _ , rims kkyroku bessatsu , b26 , pages 2336 .
inst . math .
( rims ) , kyoto , 2011 . | we study the relevance of various scalar equations , such as inviscid burgers , korteweg - de vries ( kdv ) , extended kdv , and higher order equations ( of camassa - holm type ) , as asymptotic models for the propagation of internal waves in a two - fluid system .
these scalar evolution equations may be justified with two approaches .
the first method consists in approximating the flow with two decoupled , counterpropagating waves , each one satisfying such an equation .
one also recovers homologous equations when focusing on a given direction of propagation , and seeking unidirectional approximate solutions .
this second justification is more restrictive as for the admissible initial data , but yields greater accuracy .
additionally , we present several new coupled asymptotic models : a green - naghdi type model , its simplified version in the so - called camassa - holm regime , and a weakly decoupled model .
all of the models are rigorously justified in the sense of consistency . |
is it worthwhile to reinvent classical electrodynamics after it has been with us for more than a century ? and after its quantized version , quantum electrodynamics ( unified with the weak interaction ) had turned out to be one of the most accurately tested successful theories ?
we believe that the answer should be affirmative .
moreover , we believe that this reformulation should be done such that it is also comprehensible and useful for experimental physicists and ( electrical ) engineers .
let us collect some of the reasons in favor of such a reformulation .
first of all an `` axiomatics '' of electrodynamics should allow us to make the fundamental structure of electrodynamics transparent , see , e.g. , sommerfeld @xcite or @xcite .
we will follow the tradition of kottler - cartan - van dantzig , see truesdell & toupin @xcite and post @xcite , and base our theory on two experimentally well established axioms expressed in terms of integrals , conservation of electric charge and magnetic flux , and a local axiom , the existence of the lorentz force .
all three axioms can be formulated in a 4-dimensional ( spacetime ) continuum without using the distance concept ( i.e. without the use of a metric ) , see schrdinger @xcite .
only the fourth axiom , a suitable constitutive law , is specific for the `` material '' under consideration which is interacting with the electromagnetic field .
the vacuum is a particular example of such a material . in the fourth axiom
, the distance concept eventually shows up and gives the 4-dimensional continuum an additional structure .
some of the questions one can answer with the help of such a general framework are : is the electric excitation @xmath5 a _ microscopic _ quantity like the field strength @xmath6 ? is it justified to give @xmath5 another dimension than @xmath6 ?
the analogous questions can be posed for the magnetic excitation @xmath7 and the field strength @xmath8 .
should we expect a magnetic monopole and an explicit magnetic charge to arise in such an electrodynamic framework ?
can we immediately pinpoint the ( metric - independent ) constitutive law for a 2-dimensional electron gas in the theory of the quantum hall effect ?
does the non - linear born - infeld electrodynamics fit into this general scheme ? how do maxwell s equations look in an accelerated reference frame or in a strong gravitational field as around a neutron star ?
how do they look in a possible non - riemannian spacetime ? is a possible pseudoscalar axion field compatible with electrodynamics ? and eventually , on a more formal level , is the calculus of exterior differential forms more appropriate for describing electrodynamics than the 3-dimensional euclidean vector calculus and its 4-dimensional generalization ? can the metric of spacetime be derived from suitable assumptions about the constitutive law ?
it is really the status of electrodynamics within the whole of physics which comes much clearer into focus if one follows up such an axiomatic approach .
from a modern relativistic point of view , the formulation of electrodynamics has to take place in a 4-dimensional continuum ( differentiable manifold ) which eventually is to be identified with spacetime , i.e. with a continuum described by one `` time '' coordinate @xmath9 and three `` space '' coordinates @xmath10 or , in short , by coordinates @xmath11 , with @xmath12 .
let us suppress one space dimension in order to be able to depict the 4-dimensional as a 3-dimensional continuum , as shown in fig.[f1 ] .
we assume that this continuum admits a foliation into a succession of different leaves or hypersurfaces @xmath13 .
accordingly , spacetime looks like a pile of leaves which can be numbered by a monotonically increasing ( time ) parameter @xmath14 . a leaf @xmath15 is defined by @xmath16 .
it represents , at a certain time @xmath14 , the ordinary 3-dimensional space surrounding us ( in fig.[f1 ] it is 2-dimensional , since one dimension is suppressed ) . at any given point in @xmath15
, we can introduce the covector @xmath17 and a 4-vector @xmath18 @xmath19 such that @xmath20 is normalized according to @xmath21 here @xmath22 and @xmath23 .
furthermore , summation over repeated indices is always understood .
the vector @xmath24 is `` normal '' to the leaf @xmath15 , whereas the covector @xmath25 is tangential . ] to it . with the pair
@xmath26 we can construct projectors which decompose all tensor quantities into _ longitudinal _ and _ transversal _ constituents with respect to the vector @xmath20 , see fig.[f2 ] .
indeed , the matrices @xmath27 represent projection operators , i.e. @xmath28 taking an arbitrary covector @xmath29 , we now can write it as @xmath30 obviously @xmath31 describes the longitudinal component of the covector and @xmath32 its transversal component , with @xmath33 .
analogously , for an arbitrary vector @xmath34 , we can write @xmath35 its transversal component @xmath36 fulfills @xmath37 .
this pattern can be straightforwardly generalized to all tensorial quantities of spacetime . for simplicity ,
we confine our attention to the particular case when `` adapted '' coordinates @xmath38 are used and when the `` spatial '' components of @xmath20 vanish , i.e. , @xmath39 . in that case , we simply have @xmath40 and hence @xmath14 can be treated as a formal `` time '' coordinate .
the conservation of electric charge was already recognized as fundamental law during the time of franklin ( around 1750 ) well before coulomb discovered the force law in 1785 . nowadays , at a time ,
at which one can catch single electrons and single protons in traps and can _ count _ them individually , we are more sure than ever that electric charge conservation is a valid fundamental law of nature . therefore matter carries as a _ primary quality _ something called electric charge which only occurs in positive or negative units of an elementary charge @xmath41 ( or , in the case of quarks , in @xmath42th of it ) and which can be counted in principle .
thus it is justified to introduce the physical dimension of charge @xmath43 as a new and independent concept .
ideally one should measure a charge in units of @xmath44 .
however , for practical reasons , the si - unit c ( coulomb ) is used in laboratory physics .
two remarks are in order : charge is an additive ( or extensive ) quantity that characterizes the source of the electromagnetic field .
it is prior to the notion of the electric field strength .
therefore it is _ not _ reasonable to measure , as is done in the cgs - system of units , the additive quantity charge in terms of the unit of force by applying coulomb s law .
coulomb s law has no direct relation to charge conservation .
secondly , in the si - system , for reasons of better realization , the ampere @xmath45 as current is chosen as the new fundamental unit rather than the coulomb .
we have @xmath46 ( @xmath47 second ) . as a preliminary step ,
let us remind ourselves that , in a 4-dimensional picture , the motion of a point particle is described , as in fig.[f2 ] , by a curve in spacetime , by a so - called worldline .
the tangent vectors of this worldline represent the 4-velocity of the particle .
if we mark a 3-dimensional volume @xmath48 which belong to a certain hypersurface @xmath15 , then the total electric charge inside @xmath48 is @xmath49 with @xmath50 as the electric charge density .
the total charge in space , which we find by integration over the whole of space , i.e. , by letting @xmath51 , is _ globally _ conserved .
therefore the integral in ( [ charge ] ) over each hypersurface @xmath52 keeps the same value .
the _ local _ conservation of charge , see fig.[f3 ] , translates into the following fact : if a number of worldlines of particles with one elementary charge enter a prescribed but arbitrary 4-dimensional volume @xmath53 , then , in classical physics , the same number has to leave the volume . if we count the entering worldlines as negative and the leaving ones as positive ( in conformity with the direction of their normal vectors ) , then the ( 3-dimensional ) surface integral over the number of worldlines has to vanish .
now , the natural extensive quantities to be integrated over a 3-dimensional hypersurface are _ vector densities , _ see the appendix . accordingly , in nature there should exist a 4-vector density @xmath54 with 4 independent components which measures the charge piercing through an arbitrary 3-dimensional hypersurface .
therefore , it generalizes in a consistent 4-dimensional formalism the familiar concepts of charge density @xmath50 and current density @xmath55 .
the axiom of local charge conservation then reads @xmath56 where the integral is taken over the ( 3-dimensional ) _ boundary _ of an arbitrary 4-dimensional volume of spacetime , with @xmath57 being the 3-surface element , as defined in the appendix .
if we apply stokes theorem , then we can transform the 3-surface integral in ( [ axiom1 ] ) into a 4-volume integral : @xmath58 since this is valid for an _ arbitrary _
4-volume @xmath53 , we find the local version of the charge conservation as @xmath59 in this form , the law of conservation of charge is valid in arbitrary coordinates . if one defines a particular foliation , then one can rewrite ( [ ax1local ] ) in terms of decomposed quantities that are longitudinal and transversal to the corresponding normal vector @xmath20 .
the 4-vector density @xmath54 decomposes as @xmath60 when adapted coordinates are used , the decomposition procedure simplifies and allows to define the 3-dimensional densities of charge @xmath50 and of current @xmath55 as @xmath61 with this , one can rewrite the definition of charge ( [ charge ] ) in an explicitly coordinate invariant form @xmath62 since on @xmath15 we have @xmath63 and @xmath64 . furthermore , eq.([ax1local ] ) can be rewritten in ( 1 + 3)-form as the more familiar continuity equation @xmath65 the charge @xmath66 in ( [ charge1 ] ) has the absolute dimension .
the _ components _ pick up a @xmath67 ( a @xmath68 ) for an upper ( a lower ) temporal index and an @xmath69 ( an @xmath70 ) for an upper ( a lower ) spatial index . a statement , see @xcite , that @xmath6 and @xmath71 must have the same dimension since they transform into each other is empty without specifying the underlying theory of dimensions . ]
the 4-current is a density in spacetime , and we have @xmath72=q/(t\,l^3)$ ] .
thus the components carry the dimensions @xmath73=[{\cal j}^0]=q / l^3 \stackrel{{\rm si}}{=}c / m^3 $ ] and @xmath74=[{\cal j}^a]=q/(t\,l^2)\stackrel{{\rm si}}{=}a / m^2 $ ] .
because of axiom 1 and according to a theorem of de rham , see @xcite , the electric current density from ( [ axiom1 ] ) or ( [ ax1local ] ) can be represented as a `` divergence '' of the _ electromagnetic excitation _ : @xmath75 the excitation @xmath76 is a contravariant antisymmetric tensor density and has 6 independent components .
one can verify that , due to the antisymmetry of @xmath76 , the conservation law is automatically fulfilled , i.e. , @xmath77 . the 4-dimensional set ( [ jexact ] ) represents the inhomogeneous maxwell equations .
they surface here in a very natural way as a result of charge conservation .
charge conservation should not be looked at as a consequence of the inhomogeneous maxwell equations , but rather the other way round , as shown in this tutorial .
of course , @xmath78 is not yet fully determined since @xmath79 also satisfies ( [ jexact ] ) for an arbitrary covector field @xmath80 .
the @xmath81-decomposition of @xmath76 is obtained similarly to the decomposition of the current ( [ jdecomp ] ) : @xmath82 the nontrivial components of the longitudinal and transversal parts read @xmath83 with the electric excitation @xmath84 ( historical name : `` dielectric displacement '' ) and the magnetic excitation @xmath85 ( `` magnetic field '' ) . here
@xmath86 is the totally antisymmetric 3-dimensional levi - civita tensor density with @xmath87 .
if we substitute the decompositions ( [ jdecomp ] ) and ( [ hdecomp ] ) into ( [ jexact ] ) , we recover the 3-dimensional form of the inhomogeneous maxwell equations , @xmath88 or , in symbolic notation , @xmath89 since electric charge conservation is valid in microphysics , the corresponding maxwell equations ( [ 3dmax ] ) or ( [ 3dmaxsymb ] ) are also _ microphysical _ equations and with them the excitations @xmath84 and @xmath85 are microphysical quantities likewise in contrast to what is stated in most textbooks , see @xcite and @xcite , compare also @xcite , e.g .. from ( [ 3dmax ] ) we can immediately read off @xmath90=[l\,\rho]=q / l^2\stackrel{\rm si}{=}c / m^3 $ ] and @xmath91=[l\,j^a]=q/(t\,l)\stackrel{\rm si}{=}a / m$ ] . before we ever talked about _ forces _ on charges , charge conservation alone gave us the inhomogeneous maxwell equations including the appropriate dimensions for the excitations @xmath84 and @xmath92 . under the assumption that @xmath84 vanishes inside an ideal electric conductor , one can get rid of the indeterminacy of @xmath93 , as spelled out in ( [ hgauge ] ) , and we can measure @xmath93 by means of two identical conducting plates ( `` maxwellian double plates '' ) which touch each other and which are _ separated _ in the @xmath84-field to be measured .
the charge on one plate is then measured .
analogous remarks apply to @xmath92 .
accordingly , the excitations do have a direct _ operational _ significance .
by now we have exhausted the information contained in the axiom 1 of charge conservation .
we have to introduce new concepts in order to complete the fundamental structure of maxwell s theory .
whereas the excitation @xmath94 is linked to the charge current @xmath95 , the electric and magnetic field strengths are usually introduced as forces acting on unit charges at rest or in motion , respectively . in the purely electric case with a test charge @xmath43
, we have in terms of components @xmath96 with @xmath97 as force and @xmath6 as electric field covector .
let us take a ( delta - function - like ) test charge current @xmath98 centered around a point with spatial coordinates @xmath99 .
generalizing ( [ coul ] ) , the simplest relativistic ansatz for defining the electromagnetic field reads : @xmath100 we know from lagrangian mechanics that the _ force _ @xmath101 is represented by a _ covector _ with the absolute dimension of action @xmath102 (
here @xmath102 is _ not _ the planck constant but rather only denotes its _ dimension _ ) .
accordingly , with the covectorial force density @xmath103 , the ansatz ( [ fieldansatz1 ] ) can be made more precise as axiom 2 : @xmath104 the newly introduced covariant 2nd - rank 4-tensor @xmath105 is the electromagnetic field strength .
the force density @xmath103 was postulated to be normal to the current , @xmath106 .
thus the antisymmetry of the electromagnetic field strength is found , i.e. , @xmath105 depends on 6 independent components . we know
the notion of force from mechanics , the current density we know from axiom 1 .
accordingly , axiom 2 is to be understood as an _ operational _ definition of the electromagnetic field strength @xmath105 . with the decomposition @xmath107
we find the identifications for the electric field strength @xmath108 and the magnetic field strength @xmath109 ( historical names : `` magnetic induction '' or `` magnetic flux density '' ) : @xmath110 these identifications are reasonable since for the spatial components of ( [ fieldansatz2 ] ) we recover the lorentz force density and , for the static case , eq.([coul ] ) : @xmath111 symbolically , we have @xmath112 the time component of ( [ fieldansatz2 ] ) represents the electromagnetic power density : @xmath113
axiom 2 on the lorentz force gave us a new quantity , the electromagnetic field strength with the dimension @xmath114=action / charge=\hbar / q=:\phi$ ] , with @xmath115 . here
@xmath116 is the abbreviation for weber .
thus its components carry the following dimensions : @xmath117=[f_{a0}]=\phi/(t\,l ) \stackrel{\rm si}{=}v / m$ ] and @xmath118=[f_{ab}]=\phi / l^2 \stackrel{\rm si}{=}w\!b / m^2=t$ ] ( for tesla ) .
we are in need of an experimentally established law that relates to @xmath119 .
and we would prefer , as in the case of the electric charge , to recur to a counting procedure .
what else can we count in relation to the electromagnetic field
? certainly _ magnetic flux lines _ in the interior of a type ii superconductor which is exposed to a sufficiently strong magnetic field . and
these flux lines are quantized .
in fact , they can order in a 2-dimensional triangular abrikosov lattice , see fig.[f4 ] .
these flux lines carry a unit of magnetic flux , a so - called flux quantum or _ fluxon _ with @xmath120 see tinkham @xcite ; here @xmath13 _ is _ the planck constant and @xmath41 the elementary charge .
these flux lines can move , via its surface , in or out of the superconductor , but they can not vanish ( unless two lines with different sign collide ) or spontaneously come into existence .
in other words , there is a strong experimental evidence that magnetic flux is a conserved quantity .
the number @xmath121 in the relation @xmath122 is due to the fact that the cooper pairs in a superconductor consist of 2 electrons .
moreover , outside a superconductor the magnetic flux is _ not _ quantized , i.e. , we can not count the flux lines there with the same ease that we could use inside .
nevertheless , as we shall see , experiments clearly show that the magnetic flux is conserved also there . as we can take from fig.[f4 ]
, the magnetic flux should be defined as a 2-dimensional spatial integral .
these flux lines are additive and we have @xmath123 here @xmath109 is the magnetic field strength and @xmath124 the spatial 2-surface element .
this definition of the magnetic flux should be compared with the definition ( [ charge ] ) of the charge . here , in ( [ flux ] ) , we integrate only over @xmath121 dimensions rather than over @xmath125 dimensions , as in the case of the charge in ( [ charge ] ) .
thus in a spacetime picture in which one space dimension is suppressed , see fig.[f5 ] , our magnetic flux integral looks like an integral over a finite interval @xmath126 $ ] embedded into the hypersurface @xmath127 .
now we are going to argue again as in sec.3 . if @xmath128 , i.e. , if we integrate over an infinite spatial 2-surface ( @xmath129 ) , then the total magnetic flux at time @xmath130 is given by ( [ flux ] ) .
if we propagate that interval into the ( coordinate ) future , see the interval on the hypersurface @xmath131 , then magnetic flux conservation requires the constancy of the integral @xmath132 . in other words , if we orient the integration domain suitably , the loop integral , the domain of which is drawn in fig.[f5 ] , has to vanish since no flux is supposed to leak out along the dotted `` vertical '' domains at spatial infinity .
analogously as we did in the case of charge conservation , we want to formulate a corresponding local conservation law in an explicitly covariant way .
we saw that the global conservation of magnetic flux is expressed as the vanishing of the integral of @xmath133 over the particular 2-dimensional loop in fig.[f5 ] . in a 4-dimensional covariant formalism
, the natural intensive objects to be integrated over a 2-dimensional region are second order antisymmetric covariant tensors , see the appendix .
the magnetic field strength @xmath133 is just a piece of the electromagnetic field strength @xmath119 .
thus , it is clear that the natural local generalization of the magnetic flux conservation , our axiom 3 , is @xmath134 where the integral is taken over the boundary of an arbitrary 3-dimensional hypersurface of spacetime , as is sketched in fig.[f6 ] .
we apply stokes theorem @xmath135}\ , d^3s_i = 0\,,\ ] ] and , since the volume is arbitrary , we have the local version of magnetic flux conservation as @xmath136 } = 0.\ ] ] we substitute the decomposition ( [ decof ] ) into ( [ axiom3 ] )
. then we find the homogeneous maxwell equations , @xmath137 or , symbolically , @xmath138 thus both , the sourcelessness of @xmath109 and the faraday induction law follow from magnetic flux conservation . both laws are experimentally very well verified and , in turn , strongly support the axiom of the conservation of the magnetic flux .
the recognition that maxwell s theory , besides on charge conservation , is based on magnetic flux conservation , sheds new light on the possible existence of magnetic monopoles .
first of all , careful search for them has not lead to any signature of their possible existence , see @xcite .
furthermore , magnetic flux conservation would be violated if we postulated the existence of a current on the right hand side of ( [ axiom3 ] ) .
now , eq.([ax1local ] ) is the analog of ( [ axiom3 ] ) , at least in our axiomatic set - up .
why should we believe in charge conservation any longer if we gave up magnetic flux conservation ?
accordingly , we assume in contrast to most elementary particle physicists , see cheng & li @xcite that in maxwell s theory proper there is no place for a magnetic current ) could be non - vanishing , as in the case of a dirac monopole with a string , see @xcite .
] on the right hand side of ( [ axiom3 ] ) .
the maxwell equations ( [ jexact ] ) and ( [ axiom3 ] ) or , in the decomposed version , ( [ 3dmaxsymb ] ) and ( [ hommax ] ) , respectively , encompass altogether 6 partial differential equations with a first order time derivative ( the 2 remaining equations can be understood as constraints to the initial configuration ) . since excitations and field strengths add up to @xmath139 independent components ,
certainly the maxwellian set is underdetermined with respect to the time propagation of the electromagnetic field .
what we clearly need is a relation between the excitations and the field strengths .
as we will see , these so - called constitutive equations require additional knowledge about the properties of spacetime whereas the maxwell equations , as derived so far , are of universal validity as long as classical physics is a valid approximation . in particular , in the riemannian space of einstein s gravitational theory the maxwell equations look just the same as in ( [ jexact ] ) and ( [ axiom3 ] ) .
there is no adaptation needed of any kind , see @xcite .
if we investigate macroscopic matter , one has to derive from the microscopic maxwell equations by statistical procedures the _ macroscopic _ maxwell equations .
they are expected to have the same structure as the microscopic ones . but let us stay , for the time being , on the microscopic level .
then we can make an attempt with a _ linear _ constitutive relation between @xmath76 and @xmath140 , @xmath141 with the tensor density @xmath142 that is characteristic for the spacetime under consideration .
we require @xmath143=1 $ ] , i.e. , for the dimensionfull scalar factor factor @xmath144 we have @xmath145=q/\phi = q^2/h\stackrel{\rm
si}{=}c/(vs)=a / v=1/\omega$ ] . the dimensionless `` modulus '' @xmath142 , because of the antisymmetries of @xmath76 and @xmath140 , obeys @xmath146 moreover , if we assume the existence of a lagrangian density for the electromagnetic field @xmath147 , then we have additionally the symmetries @xmath148}=0\,.\ ] ] the vanishing of the totally antisymmetric part comes about since the corresponding euler - lagrange derivative of @xmath149 with respect to the 4-potential @xmath150 identically vanishes ; here @xmath151}$ ] . for @xmath142 ,
this leaves 20 independent components .
one can take such moduli , if applied on a macrophysical scale , for describing the electromagnetic properties of anisotropic crystals , e.g .. then also non - linear ( for ferromagnetism ) and spatially non - local constitutive laws are in use .
the simplest linear law is expected to be valid in vacuum .
classically , the vacuum of spacetime is described by its metric tensor @xmath152 that determines the temporal and spatial distances of neighboring events . considering the symmetry properties of the density @xmath142 , the only ansatz possible
, up to an arbitrary constant , seems to be @xmath153 note that @xmath142 is invariant under a rescaling of the metric @xmath154 , with an arbitrary function @xmath155 . using this freedom
, we can always normalize the determinant of the metric to 1 .
as an example , let us consider the _ flat _
spacetime metric of a minkowski space in minkowskian coordinates , @xmath156 if we substitute ( [ mink ] ) into ( [ vac ] ) and , in turn , eq.([vac ] ) and @xmath157 into ( [ const ] ) , then we eventually find the well - known vacuum ( `` lorentz aether '' ) relations , @xmath158 the law ( [ aether ] ) converts maxwell s equations , for vacuum , into a system of differential equations with a well - determined initial value problem . _ acknowledgments : _ we are grateful to marc toussaint for discussions on magnetic monopoles .
g.f.r . would like to thank the german academic exchange service daad for a graduate fellowship ( kennziffer a/98/00829 ) .
in a 4-dimensional space , in which arbitrary coordinates @xmath11 are used , with @xmath12 , one can define derivatives and integrals of suitable antisymmetric covariant _
tensors _ and antisymmetric contravariant _ tensor densities _ without the need of a metric .
the tensors are used for representing intensive quantities ( how strong ? ) , the tensor densities for extensive ( additive ) quantities ( how much ? ) .
the natural formalism for defining integrals in a coordinate invariant way is exterior calculus , see frankel @xcite .
however , we will use here tensor calculus , see schouten @xcite and also schrdinger @xcite , which is more widely known under physicists and engineers . *
integration over 4-dimensional regions scalar densities * consider a certain 4-dimensional region @xmath53 .
then a integral over @xmath53 is of the form @xmath159 where @xmath160 is the 4-volume element which is a scalar density of weight @xmath161 .
we want this integral to be a scalar , i.e. , that its value does not depend on the particular coordinates we use .
then the integrand @xmath162 has to be a scalar density of weight @xmath163 .
in other words , when using the tensor formalism , the natural quantity required to formulate an invariant integral over a 4-dimensional region is a scalar density of weight @xmath163 .
* integration over 3-dimensional regions vector densities * now we want to define invariant integrals over some 3-dimensional hypersurface @xmath48 in a four - dimensional space which can be defined by the parameterization @xmath164 , @xmath165 , where @xmath166 are also arbitrary coordinates on @xmath48 .
then we call @xmath167 the
_ 3-surface element on @xmath48_. this quantity is constructed by using only objects that can be defined in a general 4-dimensional space without metric or connection .
it can be constructed as soon as we specify the parameterization of @xmath48 . here
@xmath168 is the 4-dimensional levi - civita tensor density of weight @xmath161 and @xmath86 the 3-dimensional levi - civita tensor density of weight @xmath163 on @xmath48 .
furthermore , this hypersurface element turns out to be a covector density of weight @xmath161 with respect to 4-dimensional coordinate transformation . with this integration element to our disposal , the natural form of an invariant integral over @xmath48 is @xmath169 therefore , the natural object to be integrated over @xmath48 in order to obtain an invariant result is a vector density of weight @xmath163 .
* integration over 2-dimensional regions covariant tensors or contravariant tensor densities * analogously , we can parameterize a 2-dimensional region @xmath170 by means of @xmath171 , @xmath172 , where @xmath173 are arbitrary coordinates on @xmath170 .
then we can immediately construct the following 2-surface element @xmath174 where @xmath175 is the levi - civita density of weight @xmath163 on @xmath170 .
this surface element is an antisymmetric second order covariant tensor density of weight @xmath161 .
then an invariant integral is naturally defined as @xmath176 with @xmath177 being an antisymmetric second order contravariant tensor density of weight @xmath163 .
alternatively , one can write the same integral in terms on an antisymmetric second order covariant tensor @xmath178 and an antisymmetric second order contravariant surface element @xmath179 such that @xmath180 since extensive quantities are represented by densities , we would take the first integral for them , whereas for intensive quantities the second integral should be used .
analogous considerations can be applied to ( [ a1 ] ) and ( [ a3 ] ) .
* stokes theorem * stokes theorem gives us as particular cases the following integral identities ( see @xcite p.67 et seq . ) : @xmath181 @xmath182
here we provide the decomposition formulas for totally antisymmetric covariant and contravariant tensors , which are the natural generalization of the decomposition of vectors and covectors .
we start by considering an antisymmetric covariant tensor of rank @xmath183 , namely @xmath184 .
its longitudinal and transversal components are given by @xmath185}\ , , \qquad \underline{u}_{i_1\dots i_p}=(p+1 ) l^m_{\ [ m } u_{i_1\dots i_p]}\,,\ ] ] where @xmath17 , and @xmath186 .
they fulfill the following properties : @xmath187 for @xmath188 we can explicitly write : f.w .
hehl , j. lemke , and e.w .
mielke , two lectures on fermions and gravity , in _ geometry and theoretical physics , _ proceedings of bad honnef school , feb .
1990 , j. debrus and a.c .
hirshfeld , eds .. springer , berlin ( 1991 ) pp .
56 - 140 .
obukhov and f.w .
hehl , space - time metric from linear electrodynamics .
lett . _ * b458 * ( 1999 ) 466 - 470 .
post , _ formal structure of electromagnetics _ general covariance and electromagnetics .
north holland , amsterdam ( 1962 ) and dover , mineola , new york ( 1997 ) . | we will display the fundamental structure of classical electrodynamics . starting from the axioms of ( 1 ) electric charge conservation , ( 2 ) the existence of a lorentz force density , and ( 3 ) magnetic flux conservation , we will derive maxwell s equations .
they are expressed in terms of the field strengths @xmath0 , the excitations @xmath1 , and the sources @xmath2 .
this fundamental set of four microphysical equations has to be supplemented by somewhat less general constitutive assumptions in order to make it a fully determined system with a well - posed initial value problem .
it is only at this stage that a distance concept ( metric ) is required for space - time .
we will discuss one set of possible constitutive assumptions , namely @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
_ file erik8a.tex , 1999 - 07 - 27 _ |
as shown in fig . [ fig : fig1](b ) , 808 nm laser light from a 140fs pulsed titanium : sapphire laser was attenuated via a half wave plate ( hwp ) and polarising beam splitter ( pbs ) , before being frequency doubled via a type - i barium borate ( bbo ) nonlinear crystal .
the subsequent 404 nm light was reflected from dichroic mirrors ( dm ) , filtering the 808 nm light into a beam dump ( bd ) , and focused onto a type - i bismuth borate ( bibo ) nonlinear crystal to generate multiple pairs of photons through spontaneous parametric down conversion ( spdc ) . after passing through an interference filter ( if )
photons are collected into four polarisation maintaining fibres ( pmf ) and delivered to the lpu .
+ the silica - based planar waveguide circuit is fabricated on a silicon wafer using flame hydrolysis deposition , photolithography and reactive ion etching .
the germanium ( @xmath97 ) doped silica core has a cross sectional dimension of @xmath98 , and is surrounded by a silica cladding yielding a core - cladding refractive index difference of @xmath99 .
the input and output waveguides are connected to polarization - maintaining fibre arrays by using ultraviolet curing epoxy adhesive with in- and out - coupling losses of approximately 0.4db / facet ( @xmath100 ) .
the circuit consists of 30 tunable phase shifters , each phase of which is controlled by thin - film thermo - optic heaters fabricated on top of the circuit .
the electric power required for a @xmath101 phase shift is @xmath102 .
directional couplers are designed to have a length of @xmath103 and a waveguide gap of @xmath104 , with each directional couplers loss estimated to be less than 0.02db ( @xmath105 ) . the mean insertion loss ( fibre to fibre ) when averaged over all modes is 2.4db ( @xmath106 ) .
we developed a custom electronic circuit to deliver power to each of the on - chip heaters independently .
this circuit consisted of four sets of the following : one micro - controller for communication , arithmetic , and measurement ; eight 12-bit digital - to - analogue converters ; eight high - power non - inverting drive amplifiers ; eight current - measurement amplifiers ; and eight 12-bit analogue - to - digital converters for reading out the current sourced to each heater .
each of the 32 drive ports delivered up to 20 v , with 4.9 mv resolution , and could source up to 100 ma of current , with a measurement resolution of 24 @xmath107a .
each thermo - optic phase shifter is described by a non - linear phase - voltage relationship @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the resulting phase shift due to an applied voltage @xmath110 and @xmath111 , @xmath112 and @xmath113 are real numbers , which in general vary for each heater due to imperfections in the fabrication process . to determine @xmath114
we inject heralded single photons into the fundamental transverse - magnetic ( tm ) mode of an isolated mzi ( @xmath115 ) or phase shifter ( @xmath116 ) then sweep the voltage @xmath117 producing an interference fringe given by @xmath118 where @xmath119 is the count rate in the cross mode and @xmath120 and @xmath121 , along with @xmath122 and @xmath113 are free parameters to be determined via a least squares fitting procedure .
the triangular arrangement of our device allows each phase shifter to be isolated and characterised independently of any other .
we first characterise the diagonal @xmath123 ( defined in figure [ fig : fig2 ] ) by : 1 . injecting single photons into mode 1 2 .
measure interference fringe on @xmath124 3 .
set @xmath125 4 .
repeat for @xmath123 for @xmath126 $ ] completing the characterisation of @xmath123 .
we repeat this procedure for @xmath115 , @xmath127 $ ] by injecting photons into mode @xmath128 and setting all @xmath129 , thus completing the characterisation of all @xmath115 . we then characterise @xmath130 by : 1 . injecting single photons into mode 5 2 .
set @xmath131 for @xmath132 $ ] 3 .
set @xmath133 for @xmath134 $ ] 4 . set @xmath135 5 .
measure interference fringe on @xmath136 6 .
repeat for @xmath130 , with @xmath137 and @xmath138 $ ] completing the characterisation of @xmath130 .
we then repeat this procedure for @xmath116 , @xmath139 $ ] by injecting photons into mode @xmath140 and setting @xmath141 , thus completing the characterisation of all @xmath116 and therefore all phase shifters .
electrical cross talk was observed due to certain heaters sharing a common ground .
this is corrected for in pre - processing by fully characterising all shared resistances and calculating the set voltages @xmath142 which yields the actual voltages @xmath143 required for a desired phase shift .
once corrected for no evidence of cross talk , thermal or otherwise , is observed .
a final correction is applied due to an observed reduction in quantum interference at certain points within the chip caused by polarisation rotation .
we correct for this by inserting polarising beam splitters at the output of the chip filtering out undesired polarisation states . to determine the accuracy in setting a phase we run a randomized benchmarking type experiment by injecting heralded single photons into mode 1 , then setting 100 different vectors @xmath144 , chosen from the haar measure , to give a mean fidelity @xmath145 between our experimental and theoretical distributions .
we then run a montecarlo simulation of the experiment by applying gaussian noise @xmath146 to each phase shifter and fitting this fidelity @xmath147 as a function of this noise , giving @xmath148 .
we then solve @xmath149 finding @xmath150 rad .
this value lumps together error caused by the circuit , the control electronics and the calibration procedure , so is a good metric for our effective phase accuracy .
all quantum process tomography was performed as follows .
measurement effects were of the form @xmath151 and preparations were of the form @xmath152 where @xmath153 .
an estimate of the choi - jamiolkowski state @xmath154 corresponding to the process was found using maximum - likelihood estimation ( mle ) by minimisation of an approximation to the negative loglikelihood function : @xmath155})^2}{p_{ij}(1-p_{ij } ) } } \bigg\ } \\ & & \text{subject to : } \rho_\mathcal{e}\geq 0,\text { } \operatorname{tr}_a{(\rho_\mathcal{e})}=\mathbb{1}/d \label{eq : minimisation}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath156 are the experimental frequencies and @xmath157 , @xmath128 labelling the preparation and @xmath140 the measurement effect . to avoid problems associated with zero probabilities in mle we use hedged mle @xcite , where the experimental probabilities are adjusted to @xmath158 where @xmath159 is the number of outcomes in the measurement of @xmath160 and @xmath161 is the hedging parameter .
the minimisation is performed by phrasing it as a semidefinite program ( sdp ) and solved using the csdp solver @xcite .
the average gate fidelity , @xmath162 , defined as @xmath163 was calculated from the process fidelity via the relation @xmath164 all errors were calculated by a bootstrapping method , where the raw experimental counts were resampled 100 times with poissonian noise and the statistics of the resulting distributions analysed .
the two photon , unheralded cnot gate is implemented using modes \{2,3 } and \{4,5 } as dual - rail qubits , inputting photons in modes \{2,4 } and post - selecting on coincidence events in modes \{\{2,4},\{2,5},\{3,4},\{3,5}}. to perform the gate we use the following chip phases : @xmath165 where @xmath166 . @xmath167 and @xmath168 can be set to prepare arbitrary pure states of qubits 1 and 2 respectively , and @xmath169 and @xmath170 can be set to perform arbitrary projective measurements on qubits 1 and 2 respectively . to prepare pauli eigenstates and measure pauli observables ,
the following phases are set : [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the unitary operation ( up to input and output phases ) required on our six mode circuit to perform the heralded cnot gate is given by @xmath171 corresponding to a set of phases @xmath172 the truth table of the gate was experimentally tested by inputting four photons , two in the ancilla modes and two in the computational modes .
our photon source is based upon two independent spdc events which produce the state @xmath173 , such that in the four photon subspace we have @xmath174 .
although we do not herald the ideal input @xmath175 , the other terms should not produce output states in the computational subspace and so could be removed in measurement for this proof - of - principle demonstration .
the circuit used for bell state generation was given by the unitary matrix : @xmath176 corresponding to a set of phases @xmath177 to obtain statistics for the @xmath178 measurement on qubit 1 , we create a fibre looped sagnac interferometer between the output of modes @xmath179 and @xmath180 ( see fig .
2b ) injecting the photon back into the chip with a stable phase .
due to the configuration of the circuit , the photon sees a @xmath181 reflectivity mzi between modes 2 and 3 , before a @xmath182 reflectivity mzi between modes 1 and 2 .
this circuit implements a single qubit povm with three elements , @xmath183 where @xmath184 corresponding to detection in modes @xmath86 respectively .
since we can not detect in mode 3 ( this is one of the inputs ) , we postselect on events where the photon is detected in modes 1 and 2 , which should occur with probabilities given by @xmath185 which leads to an expectation value @xmath186 such that , with knowledge of the data from the @xmath187 measurement , we are able to calculate the expectation of @xmath178 .
since the experiment would require both input and detection in mode 1 , we implement it in two stages , first inputting in mode 1 and detecting four - fold coincidences in modes \{2,3,4,5 } and \{2,3,4,6 } , then inputting in mode 2 and detecting four - fold coincidences in modes \{1,3,4,5 } and \{1,3,4,6 } ( note that by inputting in mode 2 , the state would pick up a relative @xmath188 phase shift so this is offset by setting @xmath189 ) . the two data sets are then normalised with respect to each other by the ratio of total counts in each experiment . as in the case of the heralded cnot gate
, it was possible to remove events caused by the non - ideal input from the measurement statistics .
the most general form of the ztl applies to any periodic input state to the ft matrix @xcite . for an @xmath57 photon , @xmath2-periodic initial state @xmath190 input into the ft , final states @xmath191 are suppressed when the sum of the mode assignment list @xmath192 ( i.e. the list of positions of the photons in the output state ) multiplied by @xmath2 is not divisible by @xmath57 @xmath193 for our implementation , we input the periodic state @xmath194 into the ft , and measure three - fold coincidences in the collision - free subspace . in this subspace , 12 out of the total of 20 outputs are suppressed and @xmath195 is calculated as the ratio of events in these 12 outputs to the total events recorded . | linear optics underpins tests of fundamental quantum mechanics and computer science , as well as quantum technologies . here
we experimentally demonstrate the longstanding goal of a single reprogrammable optical circuit that is sufficient to implement all possible linear optical protocols up to the size of that circuit .
our six - mode universal system consists of a cascade of 15 mach - zehnder interferometers with 30 thermo - optic phase shifters integrated into a single photonic chip that is electrically and optically interfaced for arbitrary setting of all phase shifters , input of up to six photons and their measurement with a 12 single - photon detector system .
we programmed this system to implement heralded quantum logic and entangling gates , boson sampling with verification tests , and six - dimensional complex hadamards .
we implemented 100 haar random unitaries with average fidelity 0.999 @xmath0 0.001 .
our system is capable of switching between these and any other linear optical protocol in seconds .
these results point the way to applications across fundamental science and quantum technologies .
[ fig : fig1 ] photonics has been crucial in establishing the foundations of quantum mechanics @xcite , and more recently has pushed the vanguard of efforts in understanding new non - classical computational possibilities .
typical protocols involve nonlinear operations , such as the generation of quantum states of light through optical frequency conversion @xcite , or measurement - induced nonlinearities for quantum logic gates @xcite , together with linear operations between optical modes to implement core processing functions @xcite .
encoding qubits in the polarisation of photons has been particularly appealing for the ability to implement arbitrary linear operations on the two polarisation modes using a series of wave plates @xcite . for path encoding the same operations
can be mapped to a sequence of beamsplitters and phase shifters .
in fact , since any linear optical ( lo ) circuit is described by a unitary operator , and a specific array of basic two - mode operations is mathematically sufficient to implement any unitary operator on optical modes @xcite , it is theoretically possible to construct a single device with sufficient versatility to implement any possible lo operation up to the specified number of modes .
here we report the realisation of this longstanding goal with a six - mode device that is completely reprogrammable and universal for lo .
we demonstrate the versatility of this universal lo processor ( lpu ) by applying it to several quantum information protocols , including tasks that were previously not possible .
we implement heralded quantum logic gates at the heart of the circuit model of lo quantum computing @xcite and new heralded entangling gates that underpin the measurement - based model of lo quantum computing @xcite , both of which are the first of their kind in integrated photonics .
we perform 100 different boson sampling @xcite experiments and simultaneously realise new verification protocols .
finally , we use multi - particle quantum interference to distinguish six - dimensional complex hadamard operations , including newly discovered examples , where full classification remains an open mathematical problem .
the results presented required reconfiguration of this single device to implement @xmath11,000 experiments .
isolated quantum mechanical processes , including lossless lo circuits acting on photons , preserve orthogonality between input and output states , and are therefore described by unitary operators . while the relevant mathematics for parameterising unitary matrices has been known for at least a century @xcite , the theoretical formulation of a lo circuit in which an arbitrary unitary operator could be realised is more recent @xcite . the full space of @xmath2-dimensional unitary matrices ( or unitaries )
can be parametrised as a product of @xmath3 two - dimensional unitary primitives , each with two free parameters .
any given unitary then corresponds to a unique set of parameter values .
an arbitrarily reconfigurable lo network would be realised by implementing these unitary primitives as two - mode mach - zehnder interferometers ( mzis ) with two beamsplitters ( or integrated directional couplers ) and two phase shifters , such that any given lo network corresponds to a set of phase shift values .
such operation can be understood , with reference to the schematic shown in fig .
[ fig : fig1](a ) , as a sequence of @xmath2 sub - unitaries @xmath4 , each of which is guaranteed to enable transformation of the state of a photon input in its top mode into an arbitrary superposition of all its output modes .
the top mzi in each @xmath4 is set to retain the desired probability for a photon occupying the top mode , before imparting the desired phase on the top mode .
the remainder of the photon undergoes a similar operation on the subsequent modes .
full reconfigurability is realised by feeding all output modes from one @xmath5 into all but the uppermost input mode of the following @xmath6 @xcite .
realising such a scheme requires sub - wavelength stability and high fidelity components to support both classical and quantum interference possibilities opened up by integrated quantum photonics @xcite .
a schematic of our lpu is shown in fig .
[ fig : fig1](b ) .
the device , made with planar lightwave circuit ( plc ) technology @xcite , comprises an array of 30 silica - on - silicon waveguide directional couplers with 30 electronically controlled thermo - optic phase shifters , to form a cascade of 15 mzis across six modes ( see appendix for further details ) .
such an lpu can implement any lo protocol , and here we focus on several protocols at the forefront of quantum information science and technology . +
* _ quantum gates : _ * with the addition of single photon sources and measurements , and rapid feed - forward of classical information , both the circuit @xcite and measurement - based @xcite models of digital quantum computing can be efficiently implemented with lo .
basic two - qubit processes are realised probabilistically with lo circuitry , therefore a key requirement for scalability is that a successful operation is heralded by the detection of ancillary photons , to signal that the processed photonic qubits are available for use in the larger architecture @xcite .
we programmed our device to implement a new compact four - photon scheme , suitable for measurement - based quantum computing , which generates the entangled state of two photonic qubits upon the detection of another two _ ancilla _ photons , schematically displayed in fig .
[ fig : fig2](a , b ) . for bell states , measurements in common bases should be correlated while measurements in different bases should be uncorrelated .
we implemented both types of measurement , data shown in fig .
[ fig : fig2](c ) , finding the mean statistical fidelity @xmath7 between all four experimental @xmath8 and theoretical @xmath9 probability distributions to be @xmath10 ( see methods for an explanation of all error analyses ) .
we used these measurements to verify the entanglement of our state by calculating @xmath11 , finding a value of @xmath12 where @xmath13 witnesses entanglement @xcite .
next , we reprogrammed the device to realise a quantum logic gate suitable for use in the circuit model of quantum computing [ figs .
[ fig : fig2](d , e ) ] .
the detection of two ancilla photons heralds the implementation of a controlled - not ( cnot ) operation @xcite between two photonic qubits : the logical state of the _ target _ qubit is flipped ( 0 @xmath14 1 ) if the _ control _
qubit is in the state 1 , and left unchanged if the control qubit is in state 0 .
we measured the logical truth table for this operation , shown in fig .
[ fig : fig2](f ) , and found its mean statistical fidelity averaged over all computational inputs to be @xmath15 with the ideal . while these are the first heralded two - qubit processes in integrated optics , several examples of photonic chips specifically fabricated to implement _ unheralded _ ( and hence not scalable ) two - qubit gates
have been reported @xcite . to compare the performance our universal processor against devices fabricated for a specific task
, we implemented an unheralded two - photon cnot gate @xcite with single qubit preparation and measurement capabilities [ figs .
[ fig : fig2](g , h ) ] and performed full quantum process tomography @xcite [ fig . [ fig : fig2](i ) ] .
the process fidelity was found to be @xmath16 , and the average gate fidelity @xmath17 ( see appendix for details ) , greater than those previously reported @xcite .
combined with two - qubit operations , a small set of single qubit gates [ fig .
[ fig : fig2](j ) ] , including the hadamard ( @xmath18 ) and @xmath19 ( @xmath20 ) gates are sufficient to realise a universal gate set for quantum computing @xcite .
we implemented and performed full quantum process tomography for these two gates and for the three pauli gates , as shown in fig .
[ fig : fig2](k ) , finding an average process fidelity of @xmath21 . note , in multi - photon experiments deviations from unit fidelity are primarily caused by imperfections in the photon source such as reduced quantum interference between different pair creation events @xcite , and higher order terms in the spdc process . to omit these effects and measure the performance of our lpu directly we used one and two - photon ensembles to recover the implemented unitary @xmath22 @xcite and calculated the unitary fidelity @xmath23 with the intended unitary @xmath24 . for the bell state generator ,
the heralded- and unheralded - cnot respectively we found @xmath25 and @xmath26 . + * _ implementing boson sampling : _ * the realisation of a large - scale quantum computer that demonstrates an intrinsic exponential advantage over classical machines would be in conflict with a foundational tenet in computer science : the extended church turing thesis ( ect ) .
the ect conjectures that all realistic physical systems can be efficiently simulated with a probabilistic turing machine , or classical computer .
designed for lo , with no requirement for quantum logic gates or qubit entangling operations , _ boson sampling _
@xcite is a quantum protocol that has been developed as a rapid route to challenge the ect and demonstrate that quantum physics can be harnessed to provide fundamentally new and non - classical computational capabilities .
based on the foundations of computer science , boson sampling is a mathematical proof ( using plausible conjectures ) that a many - photon state , when acted on by a large lo circuit set to implement a haar - random unitary , will give rise to a probability distribution that can not be efficiently sampled by a classical algorithm .
quantum interference among the photons @xcite contributes to the pattern of the probability distribution .
the classical intractability arises because the probability amplitude for each correlated photon detection event is given by a classically hard function , known as the _ permanent _
@xcite , of the submatrix that describes a particular route of photons through the circuit .
experimentally , each detection event represents a sample drawn from that classically forbidden probability distribution . acting on three - photon ensembles we programmed our device to implement 100 different boson sampling routines .
each circuit configuration was chosen randomly from the haar measure , which we implemented via a direct parameterisation of our circuit parameters @xcite , the probability density functions of which are displayed in fig .
[ fig : fig3](a ) .
for each implementation [ fig .
[ fig : fig3](b ) ] , we counted detection events for each of the 20 collision free ways in which three photons can exit the six output ports of the device , and in fig .
[ fig : fig3](c ) plot a histogram of fidelities with statistics based on calculations of matrix permanents , finding a mean statistical fidelity of @xmath27 .
these results show a test of the performance of our lpu over many circuit configurations randomly and unbiasedly chosen from the full space of all possible configurations .
+ * _ verifying boson sampling : _ * an open and important question , particularly in light of the ect , is how to verify that boson sampling continues to be governed by the laws of quantum mechanics when experiments reach the scale that classical computers can no longer simulate @xcite . unlike certain algorithms for digital quantum computers , including shor s factoring algorithm @xcite , where the solution to a classically hard problem can be efficiently classically checked , there seems to be no analogous way to check that large - scale boson sampling is sampling from a probability distribution that arises from many - photon quantum interference . while it is likely that boson sampling is in principle mathematically unverifiable ,
methods have been proposed to gather supporting or circumstantial evidence for the correct operation of the protocol @xcite .
the essence of these methods is to implement experiments that share basic quantum mechanical features with boson sampling , but where certain properties of the experimental output can be predicted and therefore checked .
the zero transmission law ( ztl ) @xcite predicts that correlated photon detection for most of the exponentially growing number of configurations is strictly suppressed if the circuit is set to implement the fourier transform ( ft ) on optical modes .
this is known because the structure of the ft allows these matrix permanents to be efficiently evaluated without explicit calculation . because large scale many - photon quantum interference is at the core of the ztl ,
it has been proposed as a certificate for the capability of a device to implement boson sampling @xcite .
we programmed our device to implement 16 examples of the @xmath28 two - parameter set of six dimensional matrices , including @xmath29 ( the 6 dimensional ft ) , which occurs at @xmath30 . using statistics from three - photon ensembles , we calculated the experimental violation of the ztl as @xmath31 , the ratio of the number of predicted suppressed events @xmath32 to the total number of events @xmath33 ; the results of which are plotted in fig .
[ fig : fig3](d ) alongside the theoretical manifold .
the experimental points follow the shape of the manifold with the minimal violation of the ztl @xmath34 occurring when @xmath29 is implemented .
the average ztl violation of the nine points that are predicted to maximally violate is @xmath35 .
crucially , this verification protocol is implemented in the same device and with the same procedure as that for the boson sampling experiments above .
+ * _ six photon verification : _ * an essential requirement of boson sampling is the indistinguishability among photons . with our device
set to implement @xmath29 , we injected the six - photon state @xmath36 and counted six - photon statistics with an all - fibre beam - splitter between each output mode and two spads to give probabilistic number - resolved photon detection over a total of 12 spads .
we used bayesian model comparison ( see ref .
@xcite ) to update , in realtime , confidence that we are sampling from a ( pre - calculated ) _ quantum _ probability distribution ( arising from completely indistinguishable photons ) or from a _ classical _ probability distribution ( arising from completely distinguishable photons ) ; as shown in fig .
[ fig : fig3](e ) . after collecting 15 six - fold coincidence events , we determine a confidence of @xmath37 that we are sampling from a quantum ( not classical ) distribution . + * _ complex hadamard operations : _ * the ft and @xmath38 are examples in the more general class of complex hadamard matrices ( chms ) , which are related to mutually unbiased bases @xcite and are of fundamental interest in quantum information theory @xcite .
chms are defined as @xmath39 unitary matrices with entries of squared absolute value equal to @xmath40 . while this definition is straightforward , classification of these matrices is far from trivial and
is concerned with identifying chms that are inequivalent up to pre and post multiplication with permutation matrices and diagonal unitaries @xcite . in the @xmath41 case ,
all chms are equivalent to the respective ft matrix , while for @xmath42 there exists a one parameter equivalence class .
whilst a full classification of @xmath43 chms is unknown , it is currently conjectured that the set consists of an isolated matrix @xmath44 which does not belong to any family @xcite , and a newly discovered four - parameter generic family @xmath45 @xcite . in
lo experimental implementations , discrimination among chms can be accomplished via the observation of characteristic patterns of photonic quantum interference @xcite . up until now
, these observations have been too experimentally challenging for the six - dimensional case . here , we reconstruct correlation manifolds of two - photon detection events by scanning over the @xmath38 matrices , displaying four ( out of the 15 sets collected ) in fig . [
fig : fig3](j ) .
we find a mean statistical fidelity of @xmath46 .
we then implemented an instance of @xmath45 ( that is not contained in @xmath38 ) and @xmath44 , and observed their predicted characteristic two - photon quantum interference patterns displayed in figs .
[ fig : fig3](h , i ) respectively , finding statistical fidelities to be @xmath47 and @xmath48 .
the intractability of calculating the permanents of certain chms is an interesting research line , as is the possibility of searching for new chms using photonic statistics .
+ * discussion * + photonic approaches to quantum information science and technology promise new scientific discoveries and new applications .
linear optical circuits lie at the heart of all of these protocols , and a single lpu device with the ability to arbitrarily ` dial - up ' such operations promises to replace a multitude of existing and future prototype systems . in the near term ,
combining lpus with existing higher efficiency sources and detectors will expand their capabilities , while in the mid - term , integration of these components @xcite with larger low - loss circuits @xcite will open up new avenues of research and application .
+ * methods : circuit implementation & analysis * + lo protocols for quantum information processing are typically conceived and explained as a network of optical modes connected with beamsplitters and phase shifters .
provided the total number of modes in such a protocol is not greater than that of an @xmath2-mode lpu , the network can be mapped to the device via its unitary matrix description , or ( due to symmetry and structure ) a direct implementation can be recognised . in the following sections we explain the circuits implemented , and
note that both compiling methods are used .
while the generality of this lpu makes it well suited to implementing random unitaries , it is not optimised for the highly structured unitaries that typically implement qubit operations .
nevertheless , this system demonstrates fidelities greater than those reported for optical chips that have been custom made for lo quantum processing tasks . throughout this manuscript
two error analysis methods are used : those for individual fidelities @xmath49 calculated by propagating poissonian count rate errors , and those for mean fidelities @xmath50 calculated as @xmath51 .
the bar symbol will used to denote which method is used .
+ * _ heralding entangled states : _ * our compact bell state generator ( bsg ) scheme shown in fig .
[ fig : fig2](b ) , accepts four photons into modes @xmath52 .
detection in ancilla modes @xmath53 occurs with probability @xmath54 and heralds the state @xmath55 ( where @xmath56 represents @xmath57 photons in the @xmath58 mode ) over the remaining modes with unit probability in the ideal case .
operating the bsg with the non - ideal state from our spdc source requires the bell state to be detected to remove the unwanted photon terms ( see appendix for details ) . after implementing the bsg , measurements on both qubits in the computational basis @xmath59 are straightforward and arbitrary single qubit measurements on the @xmath60 modes @xmath61 are possible with an unused mzi .
we were also able to measure both qubits in the conjugate basis @xmath62 by adding a fibre - looped sagnac interferometer on the @xmath63 modes to send this qubit back through the chip to meet an mzi at the input facet ( see appendix for details ) .
we found the statistical fidelity for the common basis measurements @xmath59 and @xmath62 to be @xmath64 and @xmath65 respectively , and the uncommon bases @xmath66 and @xmath67 to be @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
+ * _ heralded quantum logic gate : _ * the heralded cnot gate shown in fig .
[ fig : fig2](e ) , is a four - photon scheme @xcite that has been adapted for implementation with the six - mode lpu , plus a seventh auxiliary coupling mode ( mode 0 ) also contained on our chip .
the function of an 8th lossy balancing mode is implemented in post - processing as an equivalent reduction in detection efficiency on the lower ancilla mode ( see appendix for details ) .
control and target qubits @xmath70 and @xmath71 are implemented via the modes @xmath72 respectively , and heralding modes via @xmath73 . in the ideal case
, the detection of the two ancilla photons , which occurs with probability @xmath74 , guarantees the cnot logic has been performed on the two photonic qubits .
once again , the non - ideal input state requires a computational detection to remove unwanted terms .
+ * _ full quantum process tomography for 1 and 2 qubits : _ * the unheralded ( or post - selected ) cnot gate shown in fig .
[ fig : fig2](h ) is a two - photon scheme that requires the detection of the two photonic qubits in a computational state to signal the success of the gate with probability @xmath75 @xcite . as the scheme requires only two photons ( which our source produces with high fidelity ) it allows for a less obfuscated test of our device for logical operations .
computational states @xmath70 and @xmath71 are implemented via modes @xmath76 , and mzis ( shown in orange in fig .
[ fig : fig2](h ) ) allow arbitrary product state preparation and measurement of both qubits , so truth tables may be taken in any bases .
we perform full quantum process tomography using an over complete set of 324 truth tables from all possible combinations of pauli eigenvector input states and pauli basis measurements ( see appendix for details ) , finding a mean statistical fidelity between all experimentally reconstructed truth tables and ideal values to be @xmath77 .
we performed single qubit process tomography on the hadamard ( @xmath78 ) , @xmath19 ( @xmath79 ) and @xmath80 gates , finding process fidelities of @xmath81 , @xmath82 , @xmath83 , @xmath84 , @xmath85 respectively , demonstrating very high fidelities for operations requiring only one - photon interference . + * _ haar random unitaries : _ * along with three - photon ensembles injected into modes @xmath86 , as a benchmarking exercise we injected the one and two photon states @xmath87 and @xmath88 yielding fidelities of @xmath89 and @xmath90 respectively . for three of our three - photon boson sampling unitaries ( those that gave the highest , lowest , and mode fidelity ) we recalculated the statistical fidelities based on the recovered unitary @xmath91 .
this increased the mean statistical fidelity and reduced range @xmath92 from @xmath93 to @xmath94 ; implying dialling errors are non - uniform across the space of unitaries .
+ * _ compiling @xmath38 : _ * figure [ fig : fig3](g ) shows a circuit customised to implement the @xmath38 family of chms , with the defining parameters @xmath95 explicitly realised .
however due to the particular decomposition of our device , compiling @xmath38 onto our lpu requires unique phase shift values across the entire device for each implementation @xmath96 .
68ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) _ _ , @noop ph.d .
thesis , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) , @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ ( , ) pp . @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop @noop @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ ( , ) pp . @noop * * ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ ( , ) pp . @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) _ _ , @noop ph.d .
thesis , ( ) |
the spin - orbit ( so ) interaction in mesoscopic and nano - scale semiconductor structures has been at the center stage of research in condensed matter theory and device engineering in recent times .
the principal reason is its potential application in spintronics , where the possibility of manipulating and controlling the spin of the electron rather than its charge , plays the all important role @xcite .
the spin - orbit fields in a solid are called the rsoi or the dsoi depending on whether the electric field originates from a structural inversion asymmetry or the bulk inversion asymmetry respectively @xcite .
quantum rings formed at the interface of two semiconducting materials are ideal candidates where the interplay of the two kinds of soi might be observed . a quantum ring in a heterojunction
is realized when a two dimensional gas of electrons is trapped in a quantum well due to the _ band offset _ at the interface of two different semiconducting materials .
this _ band offset _ creates an electric field which may be described by a potential gradient normal to the interface @xcite .
the potential at the interface is thus asymmetric , leading to the presence of a rsoi . on the other hand , at such interfaces ,
the bulk inversion symmetry is naturally broken .
in addition to this , the topology of such a ring gives rise to remarkable properties typical of low dimensional systems , for example , the persistent current .
the phenomenon of persistent current in a conducting mesoscopic ring threaded by an aharonov - bohm ( ab ) flux @xmath0 has been established over many decades .
the existence of discrete energy levels and large phase coherence length allow a non - decaying current upon the application of an external magnetic flux @xmath0 .
et al . _
@xcite first studied the behavior of persistent current in a metallic ring , and then many attempts have been made to explore the basic mechanisms of persistent current in mesoscopic ring and cylindrical systems @xcite .
later , several experiments @xcite have also been performed to verify the existence of non - decaying current in these systems .
although the studies involving the mesoscopic rings have already generated a wealth of literature there is still need to look deeper into the problem both from the point of view of fundamental physics and to resolve a few issues that have not yet been answered in an uncontroversial manner . in the present communication
we undertake an in - depth analysis of the band structure of a mesoscopic ring in the presence of both the rsoi and the dsoi within a tight - binding ( tb ) formalism .
we wish to look for a possible method of determining the strength of the dsoi in a simply connected mesoscopic ring . in recent past
there have been a few experiments to measure the strength of the dsoi by optically monitoring the spin precession of the electrons @xcite , through a measurement of the electrical conductance of narrow quantum wires defined in a 2deg @xcite or , by photogalvanic methods @xcite .
several studies already exist which deal with electron spin states in mesoscopic rings in presence of both rsoi and dsoi and the interplay between them @xcite , the persistent current in presence of so interaction @xcite and the spin - hall conductance @xcite using the continuum as well as the tight - binding hamiltonians .
however , an analytical proposal to measure the strength of the dsoi , particularly within a tight - binding formalism , is still lacking , to the best of our knowledge . in the present work we consider a mesoscopic ring threaded by an ab flux , and work within a tight - binding approximation .
both the rsoi and the dsoi are included in the hamiltonian .
while looking for a way to estimate the strength of the dsoi , we work out a method to calculate the energy dispersion of the mesoscopic ring either with rsoi or with the dsoi , thus gaining a clean insight into the band structure .
this method leads finally to the fact that by making the strengths of the rsoi and the dsoi equal , one comes across an absolute minimum in the conductance of the ring . as the rsoi is tuned , and hence estimated by controlling an external gate voltage , the estimation of the dsoi becomes obvious .
the conductance is calculated via the drude weight @xcite numerically , and is found to support the analytical understanding . in the second part ,
we show that the presence of the so interaction leads to an enhancement of persistent current in one - dimensional rings .
in addition to these , we present the detailed energy band structures and the oscillations of persistent current as the rsoi is varied to get a complete picture of the phenomena at the microscopic level .
let us start by referring to fig .
[ ring ] , where a mesoscopic ring is subject to an ab flux @xmath0 ( measured in unit of the elementary flux quantum @xmath1 ) . within a tb framework
the hamiltonian for such an @xmath2-site ring is @xcite ( and references therein ) , @xmath3 here , @xmath4 and , @xmath5 \label{equ3}\ ] ] where , @xmath6 @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath2 is the site index along the azimuthal direction @xmath10 of the ring .
the other factors in eqs .
[ equ22 ] and [ eq44 ] are as follows .
0.2 cm = @xmath11 = @xmath12 = @xmath13 .
+ + here @xmath14 is the site energy of each atomic site of the ring .
@xmath15 is the nearest - neighbor hopping integral and @xmath16 is the phase factor due to the ab flux @xmath0 threaded by the ring . @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the isotropic nearest - neighbor transfer integrals which measure the strengths of rashba and dresselhaus so couplings , respectively , and @xmath19 , where @xmath20 . and are the pauli spin matrices .
@xmath21 ( @xmath22 ) is the creation ( annihilation ) operator of an electron at the site @xmath23 with spin @xmath24 ( @xmath25 ) . throughout the presentation
we choose the units where @xmath26 and measure the so coupling strength in unit of @xmath15 .
an elementary analysis of the effect of the so interaction on the spectral and transport properties of the hamiltonian may now be in order .
to this end , we consider a mesoscopic ring with rsoi and dsoi , but without any ab flux threading the ring .
the so part of the hamiltonian is then re - written as , @xmath27 \label{equ99}\ ] ] which , on expansion becomes , @xmath28 where , @xmath29 a straightforward algebra helps us to recast the above hamiltonian in eq . [ equ99 ] in the form , @xmath30 where , @xmath31 and , @xmath32 with @xmath33 and , + @xmath34 . 0.1
cm we now analyze eq .
[ hso ] for two different cases
. 0.1 cm @xmath35 * * in this limit eq .
[ hso ] leads to the full hamiltonian of a ring with @xmath2 sites . with @xmath36 , and with rsoi alone
, this reads , @xmath37 to get the energy dispersion relations analytically , we define a unitary operator @xmath38 which transforms the old operators to a set of new operators . with the operators defined in the new basis , and using the discrete fourier transform , @xmath39 where , @xmath40 is the lattice spacing ( and set equal to unity in the subsequent discussion ) , one obtains explicit expressions of eigenvalues as , @xmath41 and , @xmath42 where , @xmath43 . in presence of a magnetic flux @xmath44 is replaced by @xmath45 .
a similar analysis can be done to extract the eigenvalues for the dispersion relations of a ring with dsoi only , that is , with rsoi set equal to zero .
however , in presence of both the rsoi and dsoi one has to resort to numerical methods for calculating the eigenvalues and eigenstates
. 0.1 cm @xmath35 * * the expression of @xmath46 ( eq . [ factor ] ) plays a key - role in providing a method of estimation of the strength of the dsoi . in the expression of @xmath46 , the presence of the term @xmath47 under the square root
` generates ' an effective site - dependent hopping integral in the hamiltonian .
this site dependence of the hopping integral enters through the @xmath48 term , and is responsible for scattering as the electron circulates along the arm of the ring .
the scattering reduces the conductivity ( the drude weight ) . from the expression of the factor @xmath49 , we see that , in the absence of @xmath18 , @xmath50 , and the the effective hopping integral becomes site - independent .
the transport is ballistic in this case . on the other hand ,
when @xmath51 the _ fluctuation _ part under the square - root is maximum .
in this case @xmath52 .
the site dependent scattering is strongest in this case , and should produce a minimum in the conductivity .
this is precisely what we observe in the numerical calculations
. 0.1 cm @xmath35 * * we now present numerical results in support of this argument , and in addition to this , on the effect of so interaction on the persistent current in such rings .
while the results in the former case completely agrees with the predictions from the analytical calculations , the latter results exhibit remarkable variations including a marked enhancement in the amplitude of the persistent current in the presence of rsoi alone .
we obtain numerical results for the conductance of a ring with different values of @xmath17 and @xmath18 by calculating the drude weight @xmath53 in accordance with the idea originally put forward by kohn @xcite .
the drude weight for the ring is given by the relation , @xmath54 where , @xmath2 gives total number of atomic sites in the ring .
kohn has shown that for an insulating system @xmath53 decays exponentially to zero , while it becomes finite for a conducting system .
we have investigated the variation of the drude weight @xmath53 as a function of the strength of the rsoi for an ordered ring at half - filling .
the results are depicted in fig .
[ drude ] .
a remarkable feature of the results presented is that , the conductivity ( drude weight ) exhibits an absolute minimum whenever the strength of the dsoi becomes equal to the strength of the rsoi .
this has been verified by choosing different values of @xmath18 for a @xmath55-site ordered ring and with electron number @xmath56 . in each case
, the conductance minimum appears exactly at @xmath57 confirming , as argued earlier , that a clear estimate of the strength of the dsoi may be obtained by noting the conductance minimum of a mesoscopic ring formed at the heterojuncion of two semiconduncting materials . as the strength of the rsoi
is controlled by applying suitable gate voltage , the measurement of the dsoi becomes obvious .
before we end this section we would like to point our that the conclusion regarding the minimum in the drude weight remains independent of the numerical values chosen for @xmath17 , and will occur whenever @xmath51 .
however , the question is about the detectability of this minimum " . in this regard
, we would like to emphasize that observing the minimum numerically depends strongly on the size of the ring ( that is , the number of atoms taken in the ring ) .
one can bring down the minimum in the drude weight to any desirable value of @xmath18 by appropriately increasing the size of the ring .
for example , though in the paper we have presented results for a @xmath55-site ring with the minima beginning at @xmath58 , we have checked that the minimum can be brought down to say , @xmath59 by choosing a ring with @xmath60 sites .
at absolute zero temperature ( @xmath61k ) , the persistent current in the ring described with fixed number of electrons @xmath62 is determined by , @xmath63 where , @xmath64 is the ground state energy .
we compute this quantity to understand unambiguously the role of the rsoi interaction alone on persistent current . before presenting the results for @xmath65 , to make the present communication a self contained study
, we first take a look at the energy spectrum of both an ordered and a disordered ring with and without the so interactions , as the flux through the ring is varied . in fig .
[ energy ] the flux dependent spectra are shown for a @xmath66-site ordered ring and a randomly disordered one ( with diagonal disorder ) in the left and the right columns respectively .
clearly , disorder destroys the band crossings observed in the ordered case .
the presence of the rsoi and the dsoi also lifts the degeneracy and opens up gaps towards the edges of the spectrum . 0.1 cm @xmath35 * * in fig .
[ current ] we examine the effect of the rsoi on the persistent current of an ordered ring with @xmath67 sites .
the dsoi is set equal to zero .
we have examined both the non - half - filled and half - filled band cases , but present results for the latter only to save space . with increasing strength of the rsoi the persistent
current exhibits a trend of an increase in its amplitude .
local phase reversals take place together with the appearance of kinks in the current - flux diagrams which are however , not unexpected even without the rsoi , and are results of the band crossings observed in the spectra of such rings .
the amplitude of the persistent current at a specific value of the magnetic flux is of course not predictable in any simple manner , and is found to be highly sensitive to the number of electrons @xmath62 ( i.e. , the filling factor ) .
issues related to the dependence of the persistent current on the filling factor have been elaborately discussed by splettstoesser _
et al . _
@xcite .
the persistent current in an ordered ring also exhibits interesting oscillations in its amplitude as the rsoi is varied keeping the magnetic flux fixed at a particular value .
the oscillations persist irrespective of the band - filling factor @xmath62 , with or without the presence of the dsoi .
the current exhibits oscillations with growing amplitude as the strength of the rsoi is increased . 0.1 cm @xmath35 * * we now present the results for a disordered ring of @xmath67 sites in fig .
[ currentdisorder1 ] .
disorder is introduced via a random distribution ( width @xmath68 ) of the values of the on - site potentials ( diagonal disorder ) , and results averaged over sixty disorder configurations have been presented .
the dsoi remains zero . without any spin - orbit interaction ,
disorder completely suppresses the persistent current ( an effect of the localization of the electronic states in the ring ) , as it is observed in fig .
[ currentdisorder1 ] ( black curve ) . with the introduction of the rsoi ,
the current starts increasing , and for @xmath69 ( blue curve ) , increases significantly , attaining a magnitude comparable to that in a perfectly ordered ring .
it is to be noted that the strength of the rsoi is strongly dependent on gate voltage .
an enhancement of the persistent current in the presence of disorder can be achieved even with much lower values of the rsoi parameter compared to what have already been presented in the figures . to achieve
this one needs to increase the size of the mesoscopic ring .
we have checked this with a @xmath70-site ring where even with @xmath71 the current increases by an order of magnitude compared to the case when @xmath72 .
however , we present the results using a somewhat larger values of @xmath17 for a better viewing of the results .
similar observations are made by setting @xmath72 and varying @xmath18 .
disorder introduces quantum interference which leads to localization of the electronic states .
rsoi , on the other hand , introduces spin flip scattering in the system , which can destroy quantum interference effect , leading to a possible delocalization of the electronic states .
this leads to an enhancement of the persistent current in the presence of disorder .
the competition between the strength of disorder and the rsoi is also apparent in fig .
[ typicalcurrentdisorder ] . for small values of the rsoi ,
the disorder dominates .
as the strength of the rsoi is increased , the spin flip scattering starts dominating over the quantum interference effect , and finally the oscillations become quite similar to that in a ballistic ring . as the
so interaction is a natural interaction for a quantum ring grafted at a heterojunction , we are thus tempted to propose that the spin - orbit interaction is responsible for an enhanced persistent current in such mesoscopic disordered rings .
before we end this section , we would like to mention that the presence of dsoi alone leads to exactly similar results as expected , since the rashba and the dresselhaus hamiltonians are related by a unitary transformation .
this does not change the physics .
we have also computed the persistent current in the presence of both the interactions .
the amplitude of the current does not increase significantly compared to the case where only one interaction is present .
however , the precise magnitude of the current is sensitive to the strength of the magnetic flux threading the ring .
the observation remains valid even when the strengths of the rashba and dresselhaus spin - orbit interactions are the same .
in conclusion , we have investigated the spectrum and the magnetic response of a tight - binding mesoscopic ring with rashba and dresselhaus spin - orbit interactions both analytically and numerically .
two principal results have been obtained and discussed .
first , after an exact analysis of the spin dependent hamiltonian we argue that a minimum in the conductance of the ring system when the dsoi equal the strength of the rsoi provides a method of estimating the strength of the former
. second , we present numerical results of the band structure of the ring system when it is threaded by an ab flux @xmath0 .
the effect of the spin - orbit terms on the energy bands are shown .
this is followed by an exhaustive numerical calculation of the persistent current in ordered and disordered rings in the presence of the spin - orbit interactions .
the result for the disordered ring exhibits a large persistent current , of the same order of magnitude as that in a perfectly ordered ring , in the presence of rashba spin - orbit interaction .
i. zutic , j. fabian , and s. das sarma , rev .
mod . phys . * 76 * , 323 ( 2004 ) .
s. datta and b. das , appl .
. lett . * 56 * , 665 ( 1990 ) . , edited by t. ando , y. arakawa , k. furuya , s. komiyama , and h. nakashima ( springer , berlin , 1998 ) .
g .- h . ding and b. dong , phys .
b * 76 * , 125301 ( 2007 ) . s. bellucci and p. onorato , phys . rev .
b * 78 * , 235312 ( 2008 ) .
a. aharony , o. e .- wohlman , y. tokura , and s. katsumoto , phys .
b * 78 * , 125328 ( 2008 ) .
a. aharony , o. e .- wohlman , y. tokura , and s. katsumoto , physica e * 42 * , 629 ( 2010 ) .
r. citro and f. romeo , phys .
b * 75 * , 073306 ( 2007 ) . j. s. sheng and k. chang , phys . rev .
b * 74 * , 235315 ( 2006 ) .
j. splettstoesser , m. governale , and u. zlicke , phys .
b * 68 * , 165341 ( 2003 ) .
f. e. meijer , a. f. morpurgo , and t. m. klapwijk , phys .
b * 66 * , 033107 ( 2002 ) .
l. meier , g. salis , i. shorubalko , e. gini , s. schn , and k. ensslin , nature physics * 3 * , 650 ( 2007 ) .
j. premper , m. trautmann , j. henk , and p. bruno , phys .
b * 76 * , 073310 ( 2007 ) .
m. bttiker , y. imry , and r. landauer , phys . lett . *
96a * , 365 ( 1983 ) .
h. f. cheung , y. gefen , e. k. riedel , and w. h. shih , phys . rev .
b * 37 * , 6050 ( 1988 ) .
b. l. altshuler , y. gefen , and y. imry , phys .
lett . * 66 * , 88 ( 1991 ) .
a. schmid , phys .
lett . * 66 * , 80 ( 1991 ) .
v. ambegaokar and u. eckern , phys .
* 65 * , 381 ( 1990 ) .
p. a. orellana and m. pacheco , phys .
b * 71 * , 235330 ( 2005 ) . l. k. castelano , g .- q .
hai , b. partoens , and f. m. peeters , phys .
b * 78 * , 195315 ( 2008 ) .
m. abraham and r. berkovits , phys .
. lett . * 70 * , 1509 ( 1993 ) .
g. bouzerar , d. poilblanc , and g. montambaux , phys . rev .
b * 49 * , 8258 ( 1994 ) .
l. p. levy , g. dolan , j. dunsmuir , and h. bouchiat , phys .
* 64 * , 2074 ( 1990 ) .
v. chandrasekhar , r. a. webb , m. j. brady , m. b. ketchen , w. j. gallagher , and a. kleinsasser , phys .
* 67 * , 3578 ( 1991 ) .
e. m. q. jariwala , p. mohanty , m. b. ketchen , and r. a. webb , phys .
86 * , 1594 ( 2001 ) .
r. deblock , r. bel , b. reulet , h. bouchiat , and d. mailly , phys .
. lett . * 89 * , 206803 ( 2002 ) .
w. rabaud , l. saminadayar , d. mailly , k. hasselbach , a. benoit , and b. etienne , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 3124 ( 2001 ) .
d. mailly , c. chapelier , and a. benoit , phys .
* 70 * , 2020 ( 1993 ) .
h. bluhm , n. c. koshnick , j. a. bert , m. e. huber , and k. a. moler , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 136802 ( 2009 ) .
m. studer , m. p. walser , s. baer , h. rusterholz , s. schn , d. schuh , w. wegscheider , k. ensslin , and g. salis , phys .
b * 82 * , 235320 ( 2010 ) .
m. scheid , m. kohda , y. kunihashi , k. richter , and j. nitta , phys .
* 101 * , 266401 ( 2008 ) .
a. r. dedigama , d. jayathilaka , s. h. gunawardana , s. q. murphy , m. edirisoorya , n. goel , t. d. mishima , and m. b. santos , springer proceedings in physics * 119 * , 35 ( 2008 ) . c. yin , b. shen , q. zhang , f. xu , n. tang , l. cen , x. wang , y. chen , and j. yu , appl .
* 97 * , 181904 ( 2010 ) . c. p. moca and d. c. marinescu , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 18 * , 127 ( 2006 ) .
w. kohn , phys .
* 133 * , a171 ( 1964 ) . | electronic transport in a one - dimensional mesoscopic ring threaded by a magnetic flux is studied in presence of rashba and dresselhaus spin - orbit interactions .
a completely analytical technique within a tight - binding formalism unveils the spin - split bands in presence of the spin - orbit interactions and leads to a method of determining the strength of the dresselhaus interaction .
in addition to this , the persistent currents for ordered and disordered rings have been investigated numerically .
it is observed that , the presence of the spin - orbit interaction , in general , leads to an enhanced amplitude of the persistent current .
numerical results corroborate the respective analytical findings . |
layered superconductors , such as high-@xmath5 cuprates ( htsc ) or organic bedt systems , have been a subject of extensive research effort for decades .
these systems show rich novel phenomena , including superconducting fluctuations , pancake vortex , complicated vortex phase diagrams , and interlayer josephson effects .
cuprate superconductors have been investigated extensively as prototypical layered superconductors .
the cuprates have a merit that their carrier concentration can be controlled by chemical substitutions and/or oxygen contents . on the other hand
, it has not been easy to control the interlayer distance in cuprates . in general , superconductivity of these layered systems
is deeply related to in - plane features as well as interlayer couplings . for overall understanding of superconductivity in these systems
, it would be essential to elucidate interplay between in - plane and interplane properties . despite extensive research effort ,
however , detailed roles of dimensionality are yet to be clarified in these systems .
recently , superconductivity was discovered in zrncl and hfncl intercalated with alkali atoms ( li , na , k ) @xcite .
systems based on zrncl have superconducting transition temperatures @xmath11 k , while those based on hfncl have @xmath12 k. these systems can be co - intercalated with organic molecules , such as thf ( tetrahydrofuran ) or pc ( propyrene carbonate ) .
the parent compounds zrncl and hfncl are insulators which have a layered structure as shown in fig .
zr(hf)-n honeycomb double layers are sandwiched by cl layers , and a composite cl-(zrn)-(zrn)-cl layers form a stacking unit .
adjacent stacking units are bonded by weak van der waals force . alkali metal atoms and polar organic molecules such as thf or pc can be co - intercalated into the van der waals gap of the parent compounds as shown schematically in fig .
intercalated alkali metal atoms are supposed to release electrons into zr(hf)-n double layers , which makes the system metallic and superconducting . on the other hand ,
intercalated organic molecules expand interlayer distance without changing zr(hf)-n honeycomb double layers .
so we can control two separate parameters , carrier concentration and the stacking unit distance , in a single series of nitride chlorides with the common superconducting slab .
this unique feature could allow studies of layered superconductors from a new angle . in this paper
, we will present synthesis and characterization of a series of intercalated zrncl and hfncl samples , together with studies of their superconducting properties using muon spin relaxation ( @xmath0sr ) , magnetization , and resistivity measurements .
a part of this work was presented in a conference @xcite , where we reported @xmath0sr results in hfncl - li@xmath13-thf@xmath14 , showed that @xmath5 and the 2-d superfluid density in this system follow the correlations found in cuprates and bedt systems , and discussed that this feature likely comes from departure from bcs condensation , which can be understood in terms of crossover from bose - einstein to bcs condensation .
subsequently , tou _ et al . _
@xcite reported an nmr knight shift study which inferred a rather small density of states at the fermi level in hfncl - li - thf , and discussed difficulty in explaining the high transition temperature @xmath5 in terms of the conventional bcs theory .
_ @xcite also reported a rather high upper critical field @xmath15 kg , for the field applied perpendicular to the conducting planes , from magnetization and nmr measurements .
extensive @xmath0sr measurements of the magnetic field penetration depth @xmath8 have been performed to date in various superconducting systems , such as high-@xmath5 cuprates ( htsc ) @xcite , fullerides @xcite , and two - dimensional ( 2-d ) organic bedt systems @xcite .
universal nearly linear correlations have been found between @xmath5 and the muon spin relaxation rate @xmath16 ( superconducting carrier density / effective mass ) in the underdoped region of many htsc systems and in some other exotic superconductors @xcite such correlations are seen also in htsc superconductors having extra perturbations , such as overdoping @xcite , ( cu , zn ) substitutions @xcite , or spontaneous formation of nano - scale regions with static stripe spin correlations @xcite . in all these systems ,
@xmath5 follows the correlations with superfluid density found for less perturbed standard htsc systems .
these results indicate that the superfluid density is a determining factor for @xmath5 in the cuprates @xcite .
in general , a strong dependence of @xmath5 on the carrier density is not expected in conventional bcs theory@xcite where @xmath5 is determined by the mediating boson ( phonon ) energy scale and the density of states of carriers at the fermi level which govern the charge - boson ( electron - phonon ) coupling . for 2-d metals ,
the density of states does not depend on the carrier density in the simplest case of non - interacting fermion gas .
therefore , the bcs theory has a fundamental difficulty in explaining the observed correlations .
in contrast , an explicit dependence of @xmath5 can be expected for the condensation temperature @xmath17 in bose - einstein ( be ) condensation of a simple bose gas , as well as for the kosterlitz - thouless transition temperature @xmath18 for a 2-d superfluid @xcite . in
be and kt transitions , the transition temperature is determined simply by the number density and the mass , since the condensation is decoupled from the formation of condensing bosons in these two cases .
the universality of the @xmath5 vs @xmath2 relationship observed beyond the difference of systems , such as cuprates , fullerides , orangics , etc .
, may be related to this feature .
pictures proposed to explain the correlations between @xmath5 and the superfluid density in the cuprates include crossover from bose - einstein to bcs condensation @xcite and phase fluctuations @xcite . in the present work , we extend our study to intercalated nitride - chloride systems , seeking further insights into such phenomenology .
we have also determined the upper critical field @xmath7 of nitride - chloride systems from magnetization and resistivity measurements . although it is not easy to determine @xmath7 in layered superconductors due to the strong superconducting fluctuations , hao _
@xcite developed an approach to overcome such difficulty using a model for reversible diamagnetic magnetization of type - ii superconductors which have high @xmath19 values .
here , @xmath19 is the ginzburg - landau parameter defined as the ratio of the penetration depth @xmath8 to the coherence length @xmath20 . in this model , one calculates the free energy including the supercurrent kinetic energy , the magnetic - field energy , as well as the kinetic - energy and condensation - energy terms arising from suppression of the order parameter in the vortex core .
this method has been successfully applied to various high-@xmath5 cuprate superconductors .
we will apply this model to superconducting hf(zr)ncl in the temperature and field region where the effect of superconducting fluctuations is negligible .
the parent compounds hfncl and zrncl were synthesized by the reaction of zr or hf powder with vaporized nh@xmath21cl at 600 @xmath22c for 30 minutes in n@xmath23 flow @xcite .
the resulting powder was sealed in a quartz ampule and was purified by a chemical vapor transport method with temperature gradient @xcite . for the purification , an end of the ampule with pre - reacted powder was kept at 800 @xmath22c and the other end , where purified powder is collected , at 900 @xmath22c for three days .
no impurity phase was detected in the purified powder from x - ray diffraction .
since a li - intercalated sample is sensitive to air , intercalation was performed in a glove box .
we used three intercalation methods @xcite to prepare a variety of samples : ( i ) li - intercalated zrncl samples were prepared by soaking parent zrncl powder in three kinds of butyllithium solution .
we used 2.0 @xmath24 ( @xmath25 ) @xmath26-butyllithium solution in cyclohexane , 1.3 @xmath24 @xmath27-butyllithium solution in cyclohexane , and 1.7@xmath24 @xmath28-butyllithium solution in pentane for this purpose . in this order
, reducing ability becomes stronger and therefore higher concentration of li atoms can be intercalated into the parent compound .
we used solution which contained butyllithium corresponding to more than 2 , 5 , and 5 equivalents of zrncl for @xmath26- , @xmath27- , and @xmath28-butyllithium , to avoid the dilution of butyllithium in the intercalation process .
( ii ) we performed co - intercalation of li and organic molecules into zrncl by soaking li intercalated zrncl powder ( prepared by the method ( i ) using @xmath26-butyllithium solution ) in enough thf or pc .
( iii ) li- and thf - co - intercalated hfncl samples were prepared by soaking hfncl powder in various concentrations ( 2.5 - 100 @xmath29 ) of lithium naphthalene ( li - naph ) solution in thf . since phase separation
was often observed in the samples prepared by the method ( iii ) , we selected single phase samples for the measurements in this study via characterization from @xmath5 as well as c - axis lattice constant .
the li- and thf - co - intercalated hfncl sample with the largest c - axis lattice constant according to the method ( iii ) was prepared at hiroshima university , while all the other samples at columbia university .
table 1 shows a list of these samples .
the chemical composition was determined by inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy ( icp - aem ) and chn elemental analysis .
the powder samples were pressed into pellets under uniaxial stress and sealed in cells made of kapton film and epoxy glue for x - ray measurements .
the x - ray rocking curve of @xmath30 peaks for cleaved surface ( inside of a pellet ) shows a peak with half width at half maximum of @xmath31 8 degrees , which indicates that the bulk of the samples have well - aligned preferred orientation and are suitable for studies of anisotropic properties .
essentially similar rocking curves were also observed for as - prepared surfaces of pellets .
the superconducting transition temperature of the samples was determined from measurements of magnetic susceptibility @xmath32 . in fig .
2 , we show the results of @xmath32 in intercalated zrncl specimens which were examined by @xmath0sr measurements .
the values of @xmath33 are of the order for ideal perfect diamagnetism @xmath34 for spherical samples and @xmath35 for long cylindrical samples with the field parallel to the cylinder axis . the determination of the absolute values of @xmath32 , however , can be affected by such factors as non - spherical sample shape , sample morphology and residual field in a squid magnetometer .
these factors might have caused deviation of some of the zero - field cooled shielding values of @xmath32 from @xmath35 . in table 1 , we summarize the composition , synthesis method , distance between adjacent stacking units ( 1/3 of the c - axis lattice constant @xmath36 , see fig .
1 ) , and the superconducting transition temperature @xmath5 for these samples .
the stacking unit distance is 9.4 for the li - intercalated samples prepared by the method ( i ) without co - intercalation of organic molecules .
this value is almost the same as that for unintercalated parent compound ( 9.3 ) without li .
with increasing li concentration @xmath6 from 0.17 to 0.6 ( in the samples without co - intercalation of organic molecules ) , @xmath5 decreases from 14.2 k to 11.7 k. figure 3(a ) shows the @xmath6 dependence of @xmath5 in li@xmath1zrncl and li@xmath1hfncl samples , with / without co - intercalation , obtained in the present study . in fig . 3 and table 1
, we find that : ( 1 ) @xmath5 shows a slow reduction with increasing @xmath6 ; ( 2 ) for close @xmath6 values , @xmath5 does not depend much on the stacking - unit distance @xmath37/3 ( see fig .
3(b ) ) . these results are qualitatively consistent with the reported results in the li , k , and na doped zrncl samples with / without co - intercalation of organic molecules @xcite .
decrease of @xmath5 with increasing charge doping is reminiscent of the case of overdoped high-@xmath5 cuprate superconductors . to the best of our knowledge ,
this is the first report of success in li - thf intercalation into zrncl by @xmath27- and @xmath28-butyllithium .
the stacking unit thickness is 13.3 or 18.7 for the methods ( ii ) and ( iii ) .
as has been reported , @xmath5 is almost unaffected by the expansion of the stacking - unit distance from @xmath31 9.4 to @xmath31 13.3 for the samples with li content @xmath38 ( see fig . 2 ( b ) ) .
systems based on hfncl has @xmath5 = 25.5 k , nearly a factor of two higher than that for intercalated zrncl .
our @xmath0sr experiments were performed at triumf , the canadian national accelerator laboratory located in vancouver , canada , which provided a high intensity and polarized beam of positive muons .
each pressed pellet sample , with the c - axis aligned , was sealed in a sample cell which has a kapton window and mounted in a he gas - flow cryostat with the c - axis parallel to the direction of muon beam .
transverse external field ( tf ) was applied parallel to the beam direction , while muons are injected with their initial spin polarization perpendicular to the field / beam direction .
low - momuntum ( surface ) muons with the incident momentum of 29.8 mev / c were implanted in the pellet specimens .
the average stopping depth , 100 - 200 mg/@xmath39 , assured that the majority of muons are stopped within the specimen , after going through kapton windows of the cryostat and the sample cell .
plastic sintillation counters were used to detect the arrival of a positive muon and its decay into a positron , and the decay - event histogram was obtained , as a function of muon residence time @xmath40 which corresponds to the time difference of the muon arrival and positron decay signals .
the time evolution of muon spin direction / polarization was obtained from the angular asymmetry of positron histograms , after correction for the exponential decay @xmath41 , where @xmath42 = 2.2 @xmath0s is the mean lifetime of a positive muon .
details of @xmath0sr technique can be found , for example , in refs @xcite .
the asymmetry time spectra @xmath43 were fit to a functional form ; @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the initial decay asymmetry at @xmath40 = 0 .
the muon spin precesses at the frequencies @xmath46 , where @xmath47 is the gyromagnetic ratio of a muon ( @xmath48 mhz / kg ) and @xmath49 denotes the transverse external magnetic field . as shown in fig .
4 , for an example of li@xmath50zrncl , this oscillation exhibits faster damping in the superconducting state due to inhomogeneous distribution of internal magnetic fields in the flux vortex structure . in pressed pellet samples of random or oriented powder
, this relaxation can usually be approximated by a gaussian decay which defines the muon spin relaxation rate @xmath51 . for systems except for zrncl - li - thf
, the @xmath0sr results were analysed by assuming a single - component signal , which shows a reasonble agreement to the data as in fig .
4(b ) . in zrncl co -
intercalated with li and thf , the relative value of the shielding susceptibility was significantly lower than those of other samples , as shown in fig .
although it is not clear , this reduced susceptibility could possibly imply a finite fraction of superconducting volume . as a precautionary measure , by fitting selected low - temperature signals in field - cooled and zero - field cooled procedures to an asymmetry function having two - component signals
, we estimated an upper - limit of the relaxation rate for the superconducting fraction .
this upper - limit is shown ( in figs . 6 and 7 ) by the error - bar placed to the right side of the main point for @xmath51 which was obtained for a single - component asymmetry function .
figure 4 shows time spectra of muon decay asymmetry for a representative sample above and below @xmath5 . in the normal state above @xmath5
, the oscillation shows a small relaxation due to nuclear dipole fields .
we denote this relaxation rate as @xmath52 . below @xmath5 ,
the relaxation becomes faster due to additionaal field distribution from the flux vortex lattice .
for each specimen , the zero - field @xmath0sr spectra obtained above and well below @xmath10 did not show any difference .
this assures that the temperature dependence of the relaxation rate observed in tf is due to superconductivity alone , and also implies that there is no detectable effect of time - reversal symmetry breaking , contrary to the case of upt@xmath53 @xcite and sr@xmath54ruo@xmath55 @xcite .
the effect of the superconducting vortex lattice can be obtained by subtracting this normal - state background @xmath52 from the observed relaxation rate @xmath56 . since the nuclear dipolar broadening and superconducting broadening of the internal fields do not add coherently , here we adopt quadratic subtraction to obtain the relaxation rate @xmath51 due to superconductivity as : @xmath57 and @xmath58 note that this procedure makes the error bar rather large around @xmath51 = 0 .
figure 5(a ) shows the temperature dependence of the relaxation rate @xmath51 for the samples co - intercalated with organic molecules having expanded interlayer distance . with decreasing temperature
, the relaxation rate begins to increase below the superconducting transition temperature @xmath5 . at the flux - pinning temperature @xmath59 ,
the zero - field - cooling ( zfc ) curve begins to deviate from the field - cooling ( fc ) curve . in the zfc procedures ,
flux vortices are required to enter the specimen from its edge and move a large distance before reaching their equilibrium position . below the pinning temperature @xmath59
, this long - distance flux motion could be prevented by the flux pinning , resulting in an highly inequilibrium flux lattice and more inhomogeneous field distribution at muon sites .
this behavior has been observed in earlier @xmath0sr studies of htsc @xcite , bedt @xcite and some other systems . in both systems shown in fig .
5(a ) , we find that @xmath59 is much lower than @xmath5 , which is a characteristic feature for highly 2-d superconductors .
the @xmath0sr results of @xmath59 for the present systems agree well with those from magnetization measurements discussed in section vii .
we performed fc measurements using a wide range of external transverse magnetic fields @xmath49 , and found no significant dependence of @xmath51 on @xmath49 from 40 g to 1000 g , as shown in fig .
5 . in tf-@xmath0sr measurements in highly 2-d superconductors , such as bi2212 or ( bedt - ttf)@xmath23cu(ncs)@xmath23 , application of a high external magnetic field transforms 3-d flux vortex structure into 2-d pancake vortices , since higher field implies stronger coupling of flux vortices within a given plane and higher chance for the vortex location in each plane to be determined by random defect position on each plane @xcite .
the absence of field dependence in our measurements implies that corrections for the 2-d vortex effect is not necessary in the present study .
this situation is expected for our c - axis aligned powder specimens .
the relaxation rate @xmath60 shows a tendency of saturation at low temepratures in all of the measured samples of nitride - chloride systems in the present study .
this behavior is characteristic for s - wave superconductors .
however , experiments using high - quality single crystals are required for a conclusive determination of the superconducting pairing symmetry . in the case of htsc cuprates ,
d - wave pairing was established only after @xmath0sr results on high - quality crystals of yba@xmath23cu@xmath61o@xmath62 became available @xcite .
figure 5(b ) shows the temperature dependence of @xmath51 for the samples without organic co - intercalant .
the dependence of @xmath51 on temperature @xmath63 and field @xmath49 of the field - cooling results was essentially similar to that for specimens with co - intercalation in fig .
5(a ) . in these systems
, we determined the pinning temperature @xmath59 by magnetization measurements instead of by @xmath0sr , and show the results in section vii .
the @xmath0sr relaxation rate due to the penetration depth is related to the superconducting carrier density @xmath64 , effective mass @xmath65 , the coherence length @xmath20 and the mean free path @xmath66 as @xmath67 the proportionality to @xmath2 comes from the fact that this effect is caused by the superconducting screening current , and consequently reflecting the current density in a similar way to the normal state conductivity of a metal which is proportional to the carrier density divided by the effective mass . as will be shown later , @xmath20 is estimated to be 80 - 90 in the present nitride - chloride systems .
the mean free path can not be determined at the moment , since a high - quality single crystal is not yet available .
in this situation , we proceed with the following arguments by assuming that the system falls in the clean limit ( @xmath68 ) .
clean limit has been confirmed in many other strongly type - ii superconductors , such as the cuprates and bedt systems . in highly anisotropic 2-d superconductors ,
the penetration depth measured with the external field parallel and perpenducular to the conducting plane could be very different .
for the geomentry with @xmath49 perpendicular to the conducting plane , related to the in - plane penetration depth @xmath4 as in the present study , the superconducting screening current flows within the plane , resulting in the more effective partial screening of @xmath49 and the shorter @xmath8 compared to the case with @xmath49 parallel to the planes . in the present work , our specimen has a highly - oriented c - axis direction within + /-
8 degrees , and we regard our specimen as equivalent to single crystal specimens in terms of anisotropy .
a theory / simulation work @xcite shows that for un - oriented ceramic specimens of highly 2-d superconductors , value of @xmath51 should be reduced by a factor of 1/1.4 from the value for single crystals observed with @xmath49 applied perpenducular to the conducting planes . in fig .
6 , in a plot of @xmath5 versus the low - temperature relaxation rate @xmath69 , we compare the results of the present nitride - chloride systems with those from cuprate and organic bedt superconductors .
the point for the bedt system was obtained in @xmath0sr measurements using single crystal specimens @xcite .
the shaded area denoted as cuprates represents the universal linear correlations found for un - oriented ceramic specimens of underdoped ybco systems : we multiplied the relaxation rate in these ybco by a factor of 1.4 to account for the difference between single crystal and un - oriented ceramic specimens .
the data points lie in possibly two different groups having different slopes in the @xmath5/@xmath51 relation .
the first group with a higher slope includes the present nitride - chloride systems with co - intercalation of organic molecules and the bedt system , all of which having highly 2-d character as demonstrated by their depinning temperature @xmath59 being nearly a 1/3 to 1/2 of @xmath5 .
the second group includes ybco cuprates and nitride - chloride systems without organic co - intercalation , all of which have more 3 dimensional ( 3-d ) character in the flux pinning property with @xmath59 closer to @xmath5 .
the irreversibility and depinning behavior in li@xmath1zrncl without organic co - intercalation was studied not by @xmath0sr but by magnetization measurements as described in section vii .
the relaxation rate observed by @xmath0sr is determined by the 3-d superfluid density @xmath2 , as this is a phenomenon caused by the screening supercurrent density in bulk specimens . with the knowledge of interlayer spacing @xmath70
, one can convert 3-d density @xmath2 into 2-d density on each conducting plane as @xmath71 . for systems having double - layer conducting planes , such as the present nitride chlorides or some family of the cuprates ,
the average interlayer spacing depends on whether or not the double layer is regarded as a single conducting unit or two . in our previous reports for cuprates
@xcite , we treated the double layer as two single layers .
we shall follow this approach here , and define the @xmath70 to be a half of the stacking unit distance as @xmath72 . in fig .
7 , we show a plot of @xmath5 versus the 2-d superefluid density @xmath73 represented by the value @xmath74 .
we include a point obtained in c - axis oriented ceramic specimen of yba@xmath23cu@xmath61o@xmath75 @xcite ( without multiplying a factor 1.4 to @xmath51 since this specimen had an almost perfect alignment of c - axis direction ) .
we find that most of the data points share a unique slope in fig .
7 . this result suggests two features : ( 1 ) within the nitride - chloride systems , 2-d superfluid density @xmath73 is a determining factor for @xmath5 ; and ( 2 ) the 2-d superfluid density may even be a fundamental determining factor for @xmath5 among different superconducting systems .
however , the second conclusion ( 2 ) must be taken with caution , because , this analysis depends on our treatment regarding single versus double layers , and also because recent data on tl2201 @xcite . and
bi2201 @xcite cuprates , having very large interlayer distance @xmath7612 , show universal behavior with the results from ybco ( @xmath77 6 ) only in a 3-d plot like fig . 6 but not in a 2-d plot like fig . 7 @xcite .
in contrast , the conclusion ( 1 ) is more robust , since all the nitride - chloride systems have double conducting layers , and since the predominant 2-d character is consistent with the absence of dependence of @xmath5 on interlayer spacing in nitride - chlorides shown in fig .
since the fermi energy of a 2-d metal is proportional to the 2-d carrier density @xmath78 divided by the in - plane effective mass @xmath79 , as @xmath80 , the horizontal axis of fig .
7 can be converted into an energy scale representing superconducting condensate .
this conversion from penetration depth to the superfluid energy scale was first attempted by uemura _
_ @xcite in 1991 and later followed by other researchers , including emery and kivelson @xcite .
in order to do such a conversion , one needs to obtain absolute values of the penetration depth @xmath8 from the relaxation rate @xmath51 .
the numerical factor in this @xmath51 to @xmath8 conversion in @xmath81 depends on models used for analyses of relaxation function line shapes , fitting range of data analyses , treatment of single crystal versus ceramic samples , and some other factors .
the gaussian decay , which fits most of the data from ceramic samples quite well , is significantly different from the ideal field distribution @xmath82 expected for a perfect abrikosov vortex lattice in triangular lattice .
so , using a theoretical second moment for @xmath82 in abrikosov lattice is not necessarily appropriate for data analyses in real experiments .
after various simulations and consistency checks , we decided to adopt a factor which gives @xmath8 = 2,700 for @xmath51 = 1 @xmath0s@xmath83 for a triangular lattice . note
that this conversion is for a standard triangular lattice , contrary to the statements of tou and collabrators @xcite who have erroneously cited that we calculated @xmath8 for a square vortex lattice .
then we can derive @xmath73 from the observed values of @xmath51 and known values of @xmath70 . in the horizontal axis of fig .
7 , we attach the 2-d fermi temperature @xmath84 corresponding to the 2-d superfluid density obtained in the above - mentioned procedure . a 2-d superfluid of bose gas , such as thin films of liquid he , undergoes superfluid to normal transition via a thermal excitation of unbound flux vortices , as shown by kosterlitz and thouless ( kt ) @xcite . for paired fermion systems composed of @xmath26 fermions with mass @xmath85 , forming a superfluid with boson density @xmath86 and mass @xmath87 ,
the kosterlitz - thouless transition temprature @xmath18 becomes 1/8 of the 2-d fermi temperature @xmath84 of the corresponding fermion system . in the kt theory ,
the 2-d superfluid density at the transition temperture @xmath18 should follow system - independent universal behavior : namely , @xmath88 at @xmath89 equals @xmath90 .
this universal relation was first confirmed by an experiment on he thin films @xcite . in systems close to ideal bose - gas
, the 2-d superfluid density shows almost no reduction between @xmath91 and @xmath92 @xcite .
thus , in such a case , we would expect the points in fig . 7 ( based on @xmath93 ) to lie on the @xmath18 line . in thin films of bcs superconductors ,
the superfluid density shows much reduction from the value of @xmath91 to @xmath94 , and the `` kt jump of superfluid density '' becomes invisible .
this corresponds to the situation where the points in fig .
7 lie far in the right side of the @xmath18 line . in fig
. 7 , most of the points lie about a factor of 2 away from the @xmath18 line .
the linear relation between @xmath5 and @xmath93 suggests relevance to the kt transition , as pointed out by emery and kivelson@xcite .
however , the deviation from the @xmath18 line implies serious difference from the ideal kt situation .
magnetization measurements were performed using a squid magnetometer ( quantum - design ) at columbia .
aligned pressed samples were sealed in quartz ampules .
the raw response curve was corrected by the subtraction of the quartz background curve measured in advance . in the normal state of the superconducting hf(zr)ncl samples , as well as the parent compounds ,
weak - ferromagnetic behavior is observed up to room temperature .
this weak - ferromagnetic behavior changes by the intercalation . therefore , we subtracted the weak - ferromagnetic contribution .
we estimated this by extrapolating temperature dependence , assuming the curie - weiss law ( @xmath95 ) and fitting the normal state magnetization in the temperature range of @xmath96 .
in this temperature range , superconducting fluctuations can be neglected and the temperature dependence is slightly concave .
we only used the data with the extrapolated weak - ferromagnetic contribution smaller than 10 % of the diamagnetic magnetization , to avoid an error from the assumption of the curie - weiss temperature dependence .
the model developed by hao _
@xcite was applied to the analysis of the reversible region . in this model ,
reduced ( dimensionless ) magnetization @xmath97 and field @xmath98 scales as a single function that contains the ginzburg - landau parameter @xmath19 as a unique parameter . in our analysis , we optimized @xmath99 , in addition to @xmath19 as a parameter independent of temperature .
resistivity measurements were performed using a well - aligned pressed sample with four electrodes that is sealed in a cell made of kapton film and epoxy glue .
magnetization measurements were performed in li@xmath50zrncl and li@xmath100thf@xmath101zrncl with magnetic fields applied parallel to the c - axis .
figure 8 shows the results obtained after the corrections for the quartz ample background and for the weak - ferromagnetic contribution .
we note that a crossing point exists in the @xmath102 curve under various magnetic fields for each system , which is characteristic of quasi - two - dimensional superconductors @xcite .
there are reversible temperature regions where zfc and fc magnetization curves overlap each other . below a certain temperature
( the pinning temperature @xmath59 ) , zfc and fc magnetization curves deviate .
we notice that the reversible region is wider for li@xmath100thf@xmath101zrncl .
this result is consistent with a picture that , by the expansion of the interlayer distance , the interlayer coupling become weaker and the pinning of the vortices becomes less effective . in the data analyses in the reversible region of li@xmath50zrncl and li@xmath100thf@xmath101zrncl
, we confined to the temperature region apart from @xmath103 in order to avoid ambiguity due to the superconducting fluctuations .
as shown in fig .
9 , the data scale quite well to hao s model in the whole reversible temperature range below @xmath5 for the both systems . for all the data , @xmath104 and hence the demagnetization factor can be ignored .
this analysis yielded values of @xmath19 ranging between 50 and 80 ( see table 1 ) , which indicates that these compounds are extreme type - ii superconductors . in fig .
10 , we show the values of the upper critical field @xmath105 obtained down to @xmath106 k in this process using hao s model .
the temperature dependence of @xmath105 fits well to an empirical formula @xmath107 $ ] , as shown by the dashed lines in fig .
we emphasize that the low temperature limit value @xmath108 can be obtained almost without any extrapolation using this formula : the resulting values are shown in table 1 .
the @xmath109 value of @xmath31 4 - 5 t in zrncl - li - thf system is about a factor of 2 smaller than @xmath110 10 t in hfncl - li - thf system reported by tou _
et al _ @xcite .
these results might indicate that @xmath7 roughly scales with @xmath5 .
a similar nearly linear relation between @xmath7 and @xmath5 can be found in the @xmath7 values for high-@xmath5 cuprate superconductors in the optimum doping region .
the critical temperature @xmath5 obtained using hao s model is 14.9 k for both samples , which agrees with the estimate from the onset of diamagnetism due to superconductivity .
we notice that at @xmath111 kg above @xmath112 , a diamagnetic behavior due to superconducting fluctuation was observed in magnetization as shown in fig .
similar results due to critical fluctuations have been reported in htsc @xcite and bedt @xcite systems .
we obtained the in - plane coherence length @xmath113 and the in - plane penetration depth @xmath114 using expressions @xmath115 and @xmath116 .
these results are also summarized in table 1 .
we note that @xmath112 , and @xmath113 are almost unaffected by the interlayer distance .
this agrees with the view that the essence of the superconductivity in hf(zr)ncl is dominated in hf(zr)-n honeycomb double layers .
the values of the penetration depth determined both from @xmath0sr and magnetization show reasonable agreement , although the former is @xmath117 % smaller than the latter for both compounds . in magentization measurements ( see fig . 8) and @xmath0sr measurements ( see fig .
5(a ) ) , the results become history dependent below a pinning temperature @xmath59 for a given external field @xmath49 .
this feature can be expressed by defining the irreversibility field @xmath118 for a given temperature @xmath63 as @xmath119 .
figure 10 also includes @xmath118 as a function of temperature , determined from magnetization and @xmath0sr measurements .
the results obtained from the two different techniques exhibit excellent agreement .
zrncl superconductors have a quite large reversible region in the @xmath120-@xmath63 plane .
the temperature dependence of the irreversibility field fits well to a functional form @xmath121 , obtained for three - dimensionally fluctuating vortices@xcite , with @xmath122 at low fields below @xmath123 tesla .
this provides support to our assumption of 3-d vortex lines which we adopted in our analyses of tf-@xmath0sr spectra taken below @xmath124 tesla . at higher fields ,
the fitting becomes worse , similarly to ref .
this may be related to a dimensional crossover from 3- to 2-d vortex fluctuations .
more careful measurements are necessary to conclude this point . in order to provide a cross - check for the results of @xmath125 , we performed magnetoresistance measurements on li@xmath50zrncl .
the temperature dependence of resistivity for two sets of field and current configurations is shown in fig .
high resistivity of the order of 100 @xmath126 and negative slope of the resistivity in the normal state at low temperatures could be due to grain boundaries and may not be intrinsic .
the observed superconducting transition is broadened by superconducting fluctuations , weakly superconducting regions such as grain boundaries , and by vortex motion due to lorenz force .
we notice that the resistive broadening is slightly larger for @xmath127 , which is a natural consequence of significant superconducting fluctuations only for @xmath127 .
we defined @xmath128 where resisitivity shows 50 % drop of the maximum value .
figure 12 shows @xmath125 obtained in this procedure .
these absolute values of @xmath129 for @xmath130 agree reasonably well with those from magnetization measurements , in spite of the unreliable definition due to the broad resistive transition .
the difference between the temperature dependences of the magnetization ( fig .
10 ) and resistive ( fig .
12 ) @xmath7 data may be due the above - mentioned limitations of the resistive measurements .
the anisotropy ratio of the upper critical field @xmath131 is roughly 3 as shown in fig .
although we do not have data for the system with co - intercalation of thf or pc , the anisotropy ratio would presumably increase in more 2-d systems with larger stacking unit distance .
the quasi - two - dimensional nature of the superconducting state appears in various superconducting properties of intercalated hf(zr)ncl . @xmath5
correlates with a 2-d superconducting carrier density @xmath132 devided by effective mass @xmath79 rather than the 3-d counterpart .
diamagnetic magnetization due to superconducting fluctuation for @xmath127 is observed at high temperatures and high fields .
the crossing point exists in @xmath102 curves measured at various fields .
the reversible region of magnetization becomes larger with the increase of interlayer distance , suggesting weaker interlayer coupling .
in addition to these results , we note that @xmath5 , @xmath73 , and @xmath133 ( @xmath134 ) , all show moderte dependence on chemical doping level which presumably represents the in - plane normal - state carrier concentration , while remaining almost independent of the stacking unit distance .
these parameters are closely related to the superconductivity mechanism of this layered superconductor .
since the coherence length is a measure for the pair size , independence of @xmath133 on interlayer distance implies that interlayer coupling does not affect the pair formation .
it is then possible to consider a picture in which fluctuating superconductivity exists within a given layer , while the layers are coupled weakly by josephson coupling to achieve 3-d bulk superconductivity .
on the other hand , @xmath4 and @xmath59 are strongly affected by the interlayer distance .
the reduction of @xmath4 with increasing stacking - unit distance can be understood as a simple reduction of the supercurrent density caused by lower density of the planes .
the strong dependence of @xmath59 on @xmath70 is not surprising : this behavior has been seen in many htsc cuprates .
our results show that hf(zr)ncl with variable interlayer distance as well as carrier concentration is suitable for systematic studies of layered superconductors .
in addition , low @xmath7 value of this compound makes it easier to cover the whole superconducting region in the @xmath120-@xmath63 plane , and helps our study of vortex phase diagram . in fig .
6 and fig . 7 , we have compared the results from the nitride - chlorides with other layered superconductors .
all the arguments in the previous paragraphs , as well as fig .
7 , give an impression that 2-d properties are predominantly important factor of all of these layered superconductors .
however , comparison among different cuprate systems having different interlayer spacing @xmath70 indicates that the 3-d interlayer coupling plays a very important role in determing @xmath5 in the cuprates .
furthermore , the observed results in fig . 7 show about a factor 2 deviation from the @xmath18 line .
these results indicate that a simple theory for kt transition , whose @xmath135 is unrelated to the interlayer coupling , is not applicable either to the cuprates nor to the nitride - chloride systems .
further experimental and theoretical studies are required to determine the origin of this deviation .
studies of crossover from bose einstein to bcs condensation , in the case of 2-d systems , might provide a clue for understanding this feature .
the absolute values of the penetration depth @xmath8 , obtained from the @xmath0sr and magnetization measurements , show a reasonable agreement .
we notice , however , about 20 - 30 % difference in the values from the two different methods ( see table 1 ) . @xmath0sr and magnetization estimates of @xmath8 often exhibit some disagreement of this magnitude , as can be found also in the cases of htsc and organic systems .
ambiguity of @xmath8 with 20 - 30 % would , however , correspond to @xmath31 50 % ambiguity in the estimate of the superfluid density .
in this situation , it would be ideal if there were a method to cross - check the superfluid density derived from @xmath0sr results in a completely different perspective . in bi2212 cuprate systems ,
@xcite measured the frequency dependent superfluid response , and found temperature @xmath18 above which the superfluid density depends on the measuring frequency .
the superfluid density observed at @xmath92 was consistent with the value expected in the universal argument of kt .
this provides an excellent system - independent calibration to the superfluid density .
the difference between the superfluid density at @xmath18 and at @xmath136 should correspond to the distance ( in the horizontal direction ) of the corresponding data point in fig .
7 from the @xmath18 line .
the @xmath0sr bi2212 data point in a plot like fig . 7 lie about a factor 2 - 3 away from the @xmath18 line .
this factor agrees reasonably well with the reduction of the superfluid density from the @xmath91 value to the @xmath92 value observed by corson _
@xcite in bi2212 system in a similar doping region .
this satiafactory cross - check for the bi2212 system indicates that our choice of the conversion factor between @xmath51 and @xmath8 was reasonable , and the superfluid density derived by @xmath0sr is very reliable .
of course , comparisons among @xmath0sr data for different systems in a relative scale can be performed without being affected by an ambiguity of their absolute values of the superfluid density .
we performed @xmath0sr measurements on three different specimens based on zrncl with li concentraitons 0.15 , 0.17 and 0.4 , and found that the results of 2-d superfluid density @xmath73 for these systems do not show much difference among one another .
this phenomenon could be explained by two different possibilities : ( a ) not all the li atoms donnate carriers on the zrn planes , and the li concentration @xmath6 does not serve as an indicator of normal - state carrier concentraion ; or ( b ) all the li atoms donnate electrons to the zrn planes , but only a finite fraction of those normal - state carriers participate in the superfluid .
the situation ( b ) is similar to the case of overdoped htsc cuprates @xcite , where an energy - balance in the condensation process seems to determine the superfluid density .
further experiments on normal - state transport properties are required to distinguish between ( a ) and ( b ) in the nitride - chloride systems . in conclusion , we have synthesized and characterized several different specimens of intercalated nitride - chloride superconductors , and performed @xmath0sr and magnetization measurements .
the superconducting transition temperature @xmath5 and the upper critical field @xmath137 exhibit a nearly linear relation with the 2-d superfluid density @xmath73 , while showing almost no dependence on the stacking unit distance .
these features suggest a highly two - dimensional nature of superconductivity in the nitride - chloride system .
we are grateful to a.r .
moodenbaugh for x - ray rocking curve measurement , y. mawatari for discussion about reversible magnetization , and h. stormer for help in resistance measurements .
this work was supported primarily by the national science and engineering initiative of the national science foundation under nsf award che-01 - 17752 .
the work at columbia was also supported by nsf - dmr-01 - 02752 and nsf - int-03 - 14058 .
the work at hiroshima univ . was supported by the grant - in - aid for scientific research ( b ) ( no.14350461 ) and the coe research ( no .
13e2002 ) ) of the ministry of education , science , sports , and culture of japan , and by crest , japan society for science and technology ( jst ) .
research at mcmaster is supported by nserc and ciar ( quantum materials program ) . also at correlated electron research center ( cerc ) ,
aist , japan .
author to whom correspondences should be addressed .
e - mail : [email protected] s. yamanaka , h. kawaji , k. hotehama , and m. ohashi , _ a new layered - structured nitride superconductor : li - intercalated @xmath138 zirconium nitride chloride li@xmath1zrncl _ , adv .
* 8 * , 771 ( 1996 ) .
s. yamanaka , k. hotehama , and h. kawaji , _ superconductivity at 25.5 k in electron - doped layered hafnium nitride _ ,
nature * 392 * , 580 ( 1998 ) .
uemura , y. fudamoto , i.m .
gat , m.i .
larkin , g.m .
luke , j. merrin , k.m .
kojima , k. itoh , s. yamanaka , r.h .
heffner , d.e .
maclaughlin , _
@xmath0sr studies of intercalated hfncl superconductors _ , physica * b289 * ( 2000 ) 389
. h. tou , y. maniwa , t. koiwasaki , s. yamanaka , _ unconventional superconductivity in electron - doped layered li@xmath139(thf)@xmath62hfncl _ , phys .
* 86 * ( 2001 ) 5775 .
h. tou , y. maniwa , t. koiwasaki , s. yamanaka , _ evidence for quasi - two - dimensional superconductivity in electron - doped li@xmath139(thf)@xmath62hfncl _ , phys . rev .
* b 63 * ( 2000 ) 020508(r ) .
uemura , g.m .
luke , b.j . sternlieb , j.h .
brewer , j.f .
carolan , w.n .
hardy , r. kadono , j.r .
kempton , r.f .
kiefl , s.r .
kreitzman , p. mulhern , t.m .
riseman , d.ll .
williams , b.x .
yang , s. uchida , h. takagi , j. gopalakrishnan , a.w .
sleight , m.a .
subramanian , c.l .
chien , m.z .
cieplak , gang xiao , v.y .
lee , b.w .
statt , c.e .
stronach , w.j .
kossler , and x.h .
yu , _ universal correlations between @xmath5 and @xmath2 ( carrier density over effective mass ) in high-@xmath5 cuprate superconductors _ , phys .
* 62 * , ( 1989 ) 2317 .
uemura , l.p .
luke , b.j .
sternlieb , w.d .
brewer , t.m .
riseman , c.l .
seaman , m.b .
maple , m. ishikawa , d.g .
hinks , j.d .
jorgensen , g. saito , and h. yamochi , _
basic similarities among cuprate , bithmuthate , organic , chevrel - phase and heavy - fermion superconductors shown by penetration - depth measurements _ , phys .
* 66 * , ( 1991 ) 2665 .
uemura , a. keren , l.p .
luke , w.d .
wu , y. kubo , t. manako , y. shimakawa , m. subramanian , j.l .
cobb , and j.t .
markert , _ magnetic field penetration depth in tl@xmath23ba@xmath23cuo@xmath140 in the overdoped regime _
, nature ( london ) * 364 * ( 1993 ) 605 .
b. pmpin , h. keller , w. kndig , i.m .
savi , j.w .
schneider , h. simmer , p. zimmermann , e. kaldis , s. rusiecki , c. rossel , _
@xmath0sr in oxygen deficient yba@xmath23cu@xmath61o@xmath1 ( 6.5 @xmath141 7.0 ) _ , hyperfine interact .
* 63 * ( 1990 ) 25 .
seaman , j.j .
neumeier , m.b .
maple , l.p .
luke , b.j .
sternlieb , y.j .
uemura , j.h .
brewer , r. kadono , r.f .
kiefl , s.r .
kreitzman , t.m .
riseman , _ magnetic penetration depth of y@xmath142pr@xmath1ba@xmath23cu@xmath61o@xmath143 measured by muon - spin relaxation _ ,
b42 * ( 1990 ) 6801 .
tallon , c. bernhard , u. binninger , a. hofer , g.v.m .
williams , e.j .
ansaldo , j.i .
budnick , ch .
niedermayer , _ in - plane
anisotropy of the penetration depth due to superconductivity on the cu - o chains in yba@xmath23cu@xmath61o@xmath144 , y@xmath23ba@xmath21cu@xmath75o@xmath145 , and yba@xmath23cu@xmath21o@xmath146 _ phys .
* 74 * ( 1995 ) 1008 .
niedermayer , c. bernhard , u. binninger , h. glckler , j.l .
tallon , e.j .
ansaldo , and j.i .
budnick , _ muon spin rotation study of the correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath2 in overdoped tl@xmath23ba@xmath23cuo@xmath140 _ , phys .
* 71 * ( 1993 ) 1764 . c. bernhard , j.l
tallon , th .
blasius , a. golnik , ch .
niedermayer , _
anomalous peak in the superconducting condensate density of cuprate high-@xmath5 superconductors at a unique doping state _ , phys .
* 86 * ( 2001 ) 1614 .
uemura , a. keren , g.m .
luke , l.p .
sternlieb , w.d .
wu , j.h .
brewer , r.l .
whetten , s.m .
huang , sophia lin , r.b .
kaner , f. diederich , s. donnovan , g grner , k. holczer , _
magnetic field penetration depth in k@xmath61c@xmath147 measured by muon spin relaxation _ , nature * 352 * ( 1991 ) 605 .
uemura , a. keren , l.p .
le , g.m .
luke , w.d .
tsai , k. tanigaki , k. holczer , s. donovan , r.l .
whetten , _
system dependence of the magnetic - field penetration depth in c@xmath147 superconductors _ , physica * c235 * -*240 * ( 1994 ) 2501 .
luke , b.j .
sternlieb , w.d .
wu , y. j. uemura , j.h .
brewer , t.m .
riseman , c. e. stronach , g. saito , h. yamochi , h.h .
wang , a.m. kini , k.d .
carlson , j.m .
williams _ muon - spin - relaxation measurements of magnetic penetration depth in organic superconductors ( bedt - ttf)@xmath23-x : x = cu(ncs)@xmath23 and cu[n(cn)@xmath23]br _ phys .
. lett . * 68 * , ( 1992 ) 1923 .
uemura , _ microscopic phase separation in the overdoped region of high-@xmath5 cuprate superconductors _
, solid state commun .
* 120 * ( 2001 ) 347 .
b. nachumi , a. keren , k. kojima , m. larkin , g.m .
luke , j. merrin , o. tchernyshov , y.j .
uemura , n. ichikawa , m. goto , and s. uchida , _
muon spin relaxation studies of zn - substitution effects in high-@xmath5 cuprate superconductors _ , phys .
rev . lett .
* 77 * ( 1996 ) 5421 .
savici , y. fudamoto , i.m .
gat , t. ito , m.i .
larkin , y.j .
uemura , g.m .
luke , k.m .
kojima , y.s .
lee , m.a .
kastner , r.j .
birgeneau , k. yamada , _ muon spin relaxation studies of incommensurate magnetism and superconductivity in stage-4 la@xmath23cuo@xmath149 and la@xmath150sr@xmath151cuo@xmath21 _ , phys . rev .
* b66 * ( 2002 ) 014524 .
kojima , s. uchida , y. fudamoto , i.m .
gat , m.i .
larkin , y.j .
uemura , g.m .
luke , _ superfluid density and volume fraction of static magnetism in stripe - stabilized la@xmath152cu@xmath62sr@xmath100cuo@xmath21 _ , physica * b 326 * ( 2003 ) 316 .
uemura , _ superfluid density of high-@xmath5 cuprate systems : implication on condensation mechanisms , heterogeneity and phase diagram _ , solid state commun .
* 126 * ( 2003 ) 23 , _ ibid _ 425 ( erratum ) .
j. bardeen , l.n .
cooper and j.r .
schrieffer , _ theory of superconductivity _ , phys . rev .
* 108 * ( 1957 ) 1175 .
kosterlitz and d.j .
thouless , _ ordering , metastability and phase - transitions in 2-dimensional systems _
, j. phys .
* c : solid state phys . * * 6 * , ( 1973 ) 1181 y.j .
uemura , _ energy scales of exotic superconductors _ , in _ polarons and bipolarons in high - t@xmath153 superconductors and related materials _ , proceedings of the international workshop on polarons and bipolarons in high - t@xmath153 superconductors and related materials , cambridge , uk , april , 1994 , ed . by e. salje , a.s .
alexandrov and y. liang , cambridge university press ( 1995 ) , p.p .
453 - 460 .
uemura , _ energy scales of high-@xmath5 cuprates , doped fullerenes , and other exotic superconductors _ ,
proceedings of international symposium / workshop on high-@xmath5 superconductivity and the c@xmath147 family , may 1994 , beijing , ed .
ren , gordon and breach ( new york ) , ( 1995 ) , p.p .
113 - 142 .
uemura , _
bose - einstein to bcs crossover picture for high-@xmath5 cuprates _
, physica * c282 * -*287 * ( 1997 ) 194 .
p. nozires and s. schmitt - rink , _
bose condensation in an attractive fermion gas - from weak to strong coupling superconductivity _
j. low temp .
* 59 * ( 1985 ) 195 .
m. randeria , _ crossover from bcs theory to bose - einstein condensation _ , in _ bose - einstein condensation _ , ed . by a. griffin , d.w .
snoke , s. stringari , cambridge university press , cambridge , 1995 , p.p .
355 - 391 , and references therein .
v. emery and s. kivelson , _ importance of phase fluctuations in superconductors with small superfluid density _ , nature * 374 * ( 1995 ) 434 .
zhidong hao , j.r .
clem , m. w. mcelfresh , l. civale , a. p. malozemoff , f. holtzberg , _ model for the reversible magnetization of high-@xmath19 type - ii superconductors : application to high - tc superconductors _ , phys . rev . *
b43 * ( 1991 ) 2844 .
m. ohashi , s. yamanaka , m. sumihara , and m. hattori , j. solid state chem .
* 75 * , 99 ( 1988 ) .
m. ohashi , s. yamanaka , and m. hattori , j. solid state chem .
* 77 * , 342 ( 1988 ) .
m. ohashi , k. uyeoka , s. yamanaka , and m. hattori , bull .
jpn . * 64 * , 2814 ( 1991 ) . h. kawaji , k. hotehama , and s. yamanaka , _ superconductivity in alkali metal intercalated @xmath138 zirconium nitride chloride , a@xmath1zrncl ( a = li , na , k ) _ , chem .
* 9 * , 2127 ( 1997 ) . for general aspects and historical development of @xmath0sr ,
see proceedings of nine international conferences on muon spin rotation / relaxation/ resonance in hyperfine interact .
* 6 * ( 1979 ) ; * 8 * ( 1981 ) ; * 17 * -*19 * ( 1984 ) ; * 31 * ( 1986 ) ; * 63 * -*65 * ( 1990 ) ; * 85 * -*87 * ( 1994 ) ; * 104 * -bf 106 ( 1997 ) ; physica * b 289 * -*290 * ( 2000 ) ; and physica * b * ( proceedings for @xmath0sr 2002 , williamsburg , virginia , june , 2002 ) , in press . for a general review of @xmath0sr , see , for example , a. schenck , _ muon spin rotation spectroscopy _ , adam hilger , bristol , 1985 . for a recent reviews of @xmath0sr studies in topical subjects ,
see _ muon science : muons in physics , chemistry and materials _ , proceedings of the fifty first scottish universities summer school in physics , st .
andrews , august , 1988 , ed . by s.l .
lee , s.h .
kilcoyne , and r. cywinski , inst . of physics publishing , bristol , 1999 .
luke , a. keren , l.p .
le , w.d.wu , y.j .
uemura , d.a .
bonn , l. taillefer , j.d .
garrett , _ muon spin relaxation in upt@xmath61 _ phys .
* 71 * ( 1993 ) 1466 .
luke , y. fudamoto , k.m .
kojima , m.l .
larkin , j. merrin , b. nachumi , y.j .
uemura , y. maeno , z.q .
mao , y. mori , h. nakamura , m. sigrist , _ time - reversal symmetry breaking superconductivity in sr@xmath23ruo@xmath21 _ , nature * 394 * ( 1998 ) 558 .
wu , a. keren , l.p .
sternlieb , g.m .
luke , y.j .
uemura , p. dosanjh , t.m .
riseman _ muon - spin - relaxation studies of flux pinning in bi@xmath23sr@xmath23cacu@xmath23o@xmath146 and pb@xmath154bi@xmath155sr@xmath23cacu@xmath23o@xmath146 _
phys . rev .
* b47 * ( 1993 ) 8172 .
s. lee , _ using muons to probe the vortex lattice in superconductors _ , in _ muon science : muons in physics , chemistry , and materials _ , edited by s. h. lee _ et al . _
( institute of physics publishing , bristol and philadelphia , 1999 ) .
sonier , j.h .
brewer , r.f .
@xmath0sr studies of the vortex state in type - ii superconductors _ , rev .
* 72 * ( 2002 ) 769 .
w. barford and j.m.f .
gunn , _ the theory of the measurements of the london penetration depth in uniaxial type - ii superconductors by muon spin rotation _
, physica * c156 * ( 1988 ) 515 .
uemura , b.j .
sternlieb , d.e .
cox , v.j .
emery , a.r .
moodenbaugh , m. suenaga , j.h .
brewer , j.f .
carolan , w.n .
hardy , r. kadono , j.r .
kempton , r.f .
kiefl , s.r .
kreitzman , g.m .
luke , p. mulhern , t.m .
riseman , d.ll .
williams , b.x .
yang , w.j .
kossler , x.h .
shoene , c.e .
stronach , j. goparakrishnan , m.a .
subramanian , a.w .
sleight , h.r .
hart , k.w .
ley , h. takagi , s. uchida , y. hidaka , t. murakami , s. etemad , p. barboux , d. keane , v.y .
lee , d.c .
johnston , _
@xmath0sr studies on high-@xmath5 superconductivity _ , j. physique ( paris ) colloque * 49 * , c8:2087-c8:2092 ( 1988 ) .
russo , a.savici , y.j .
uemura , y. ando , unpublished work ( 2003 ) .
d.j . bishop and j.d .
reppy , _ study of superfluid transition in 2-dimensional he-4 films _ , phys .
* 40 * ( 1978 ) 1727 .
kes , c.j .
van der beek , m.p .
maley , m.e .
mchenry , d.a .
huse , m.j.v .
menken , a.a .
menovsky , _ field - induced suppression of the phase transition on bi@xmath23sr@xmath23cacu@xmath23o@xmath146 _ , phys .
* 67 * ( 1991 ) 2383 .
u. welp , s. fleshler , k.w .
kwok , r.a .
klemm , v.m .
vinokur , j. downey , b. veal , g.w .
crabtree , _ high - field scaling behavior of thermodynamic and transport quantitites of yba@xmath23cu@xmath61o@xmath144 near the superconducting transition _ , phys .
* 67 * ( 1991 ) 3180 .
z. tesanovic , l. xing , l. bulaevskii , q. li and m. suenaga , _ critical fluctuations in the termodynamic quasi - two - dimensional type - ii superconductors _ , phys
* 69 * ( 1992 ) 3563 .
a. li , m. suenaga , l.m .
bulaevskii , t. hikata , k. sato , _ thermodynamics of superconducting bi@xmath23sr@xmath23ca@xmath23cu@xmath61o@xmath156 in the critical fluctuation region near the h@xmath157 line _
, phys . rev . *
b 48 * ( 1993 ) 13865 .
m. lang , f. steglich , n. toyota , t. sasaki , _ fluctuation effects and mixed - state properties of the layered organic superconductors @xmath19-(bedt - ttf)@xmath23cu(ncs)@xmath23 and @xmath19-(bedt - ttf)@xmath23cu[n(cn)@xmath23]br _ phys . rev . *
b 49 * ( 1994 ) 15227 .
a. schilling , r. jin , j.d .
guo , h.r .
ott , _ irreversibility line of monocrystalline bi@xmath23sr@xmath23cacu@xmath23o@xmath146 : experimental evidence for a dimensional crossover of the vortex ensemble _ , phys .
* 71 * ( 1933 ) 1899 .
j. corson , r. mallozzi , j. orenstein , j.n .
eckstein , i. bozovic , _ vanishing of phase coherence in underdoped bi@xmath23sr@xmath23cacu@xmath23o@xmath158 _ , nature ( london ) * 398 * ( 1999 ) 221 .
uemura , _ microscopic phase separation in the overdoped region of high-@xmath5 cuprate superconductors _ , solid state commun .
* 120 * ( 2001 ) 347 - 351 .
.synthesis method ( see the text for details ) , stacking unit distance ( @xmath159 ) , superconducting transition temperature @xmath5 estimated from magnetization , magnetic field penetration depth @xmath160 at zero temperature limit estimated from tf-@xmath0sr , ginzburg - landau parameter @xmath19 , upper critical field at zero temperature @xmath112 , coherence length at zero temperature @xmath113 , and magnetic penetration depth at zero temperature @xmath114 estimated from reversible magnetization for intercalated hfncl and zrncl systems reported in the present work .
tf-@xmath0sr and magnetization measurements were performed under the magnetic field parallel to the @xmath161-axis . [ cols="<,<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] | we report muon spin relaxation ( @xmath0sr ) and magnetization measurements , together with synthesis and characterization , of the li - intercalated layered superconductors li@xmath1hfncl and li@xmath1zrncl with / without co - intercalation of thf ( tetrahydrofuran ) or pc ( propylene carbonate ) .
the 3-dimensional ( 3-d ) superfluid density @xmath2 ( superconducting carrier density / effective mass ) , as well as the two dimensional superfluid density @xmath3 ( 2-dimensional ( 2-d ) area density of superconducting carriers / ab - plane effective mass ) , have been derived from the @xmath0sr results of the magnetic - field penetration depth @xmath4 observed with external magnetic field applied perpendicular to the 2-d honeycomb layer of hfn / zrn . in a plot of @xmath5 versus @xmath3 ,
most of the results lie close to the linear relationship found for underdoped high-@xmath5 cuprate ( htsc ) and layered organic bedt superconductors . in li@xmath1zrncl without thf intercalation , the superfluid density and @xmath5 for @xmath6 = 0.17 and 0.4 do not show much difference , reminiscent of @xmath0sr results for some overdoped htsc systems .
together with the absence of dependence of @xmath5 on average interlayer distance among zrn / hfn layers , these results suggest that the 2-d superfluid density @xmath3 is a dominant determining factor for @xmath5 in the intercalated nitride - chloride systems .
we also report @xmath0sr and magnetization results on depinning of flux vortices , and the magnetization results for the upper critical field @xmath7 and the penetration depth @xmath8 .
reasonable agreement was obtained between @xmath0sr and magnetization estimates of @xmath8 .
we discuss the two dimensional nature of superconductivity in the nitride - chloride systems based on these results .
# 1@xmath9#1 |
we start with the scattering of two color dipoles ( concretely , e.g. two quark - antiquark pairs ) of respective transverse sizes @xmath2 and @xmath3 with the ordering @xmath4 . at low energy ,
the forward elastic scattering amplitude of the dipoles consists in the exchange of a pair of gluons .
since the dipoles are colorless , this exchange can take place only if their sizes are comparable ( on a logarithmic scale ) , and if the scattering occurs at coinciding impact parameters .
once these conditions are fulfilled , the cross section is parametrically proportional to @xmath5 .
let us go to larger center - of - mass energies @xmath6 by boosting the small dipole to the rapidity @xmath7 .
the most probable fock state at the time of the interaction is then a dense state of gluons , which may be represented by a set of dipoles @xcite ( see the sketch in fig .
[ fig : picture]a ) .
the amplitude is now enhanced by the number of these dipoles which have a size of the order of @xmath3 .
we may define a `` one - event amplitude '' @xmath8 , which is related to the probability that gluons are exchanged between one given realization of the dipole evolution and the target dipole . if @xmath9 denotes the number of dipoles in a given realization of the evolution up to rapidity @xmath10 of size @xmath11 , starting with a dipole of size @xmath2 , then @xmath12 , where it is understood that the impact parameters of the dipoles which scatter need to coincide ( up to a distance of order of the smallest size ) .
of course , the dipole number fluctuates from event to event , and so does @xmath8 .
the physical amplitude measured in an experiment is proportional to the average of the latter over events , namely over realizations of the dipole evolution .
we conclude that _ the scattering of two dipoles of respective sizes @xmath2 and @xmath3 probes the density of gluons of transverse size @xmath3 , at a given impact parameter , in typical quantum fluctuations of a source dipole of size @xmath2 appearing in the quantum evolution over the rapidity @xmath10_. + m0.35 | m0.35 diagrams contributing to the forward elastic scattering amplitude of a dipole off another dipole ( a ) , and off a nucleus ( b ) . in the latter case ,
the nucleons , represented by small disks , are assumed independent and present in large numbers .
this picture is valid in the restframe of the target dipole and nucleus , in such a way that all quantum evolution takes place in the projectile dipole ( initially of transverse size @xmath2 ) . in the large number - of - color limit ,
the fock state of the projectile is a set of color dipoles at the time of the interaction @xcite . in the dipole - dipole case ,
the scattering consists in the exchange of a pair of gluons between one of the dipoles resulting from the evolution , and the target dipole . in the dipole - nucleus case , the dipoles
whose size is larger than the inverse saturation momentum of the nucleus exchange an arbitrary number of pairs of gluons with independent nucleons in the nucleus , eventually leading to a resummation _ la _ glauber - mueller , and physically , to absorption . ] & diagrams contributing to the forward elastic scattering amplitude of a dipole off another dipole ( a ) , and off a nucleus ( b ) . in the latter case ,
the nucleons , represented by small disks , are assumed independent and present in large numbers .
this picture is valid in the restframe of the target dipole and nucleus , in such a way that all quantum evolution takes place in the projectile dipole ( initially of transverse size @xmath2 ) . in the large number - of - color limit ,
the fock state of the projectile is a set of color dipoles at the time of the interaction @xcite . in the dipole - dipole case ,
the scattering consists in the exchange of a pair of gluons between one of the dipoles resulting from the evolution , and the target dipole . in the dipole - nucleus case , the dipoles
whose size is larger than the inverse saturation momentum of the nucleus exchange an arbitrary number of pairs of gluons with independent nucleons in the nucleus , eventually leading to a resummation _ la _ glauber - mueller , and physically , to absorption . ]
+ & we turn to the case in which instead of the dipole of size @xmath3 , the target consists in a large nucleus . at low energy ,
the dipole now scatters through multiple gluon exchanges since the nucleus is dense .
the glauber - mueller summation of the latter implemented in the mclerran - venugopalan model @xcite gives the scattering amplitude in the form @xmath13 .
a new momentum scale @xmath14 is generated : it is the saturation momentum of the nucleus , and grows with the nucleus mass number @xmath15 like @xmath16 .
this amplitude may actually be approximated by a heaviside @xmath17 function : @xmath18 $ ] .
this has the advantage of simplifying the interpretation of the scattering of the evolved dipole with the nucleus .
if one increases the center - of - mass energy by boosting the dipole , then at the time of the interaction , in each event , the nucleus `` sees '' a set of dipoles .
the interaction takes place if and only if at least one dipole in this set has a size larger than the inverse saturation momentum .
hence @xmath19 if at least one of the dipoles in the evolution is larger than @xmath20 , or 0 else .
the cross section that is measured in an experiment by counting events ( which technically is an averaging of @xmath21 over the events ) is thus the probability that at least one dipole in the fock state of the source dipole evolved to the time of the interaction has a size larger than @xmath20 ( see fig . [
fig : picture]b ) .
hence , while dipole - dipole scattering probes the bulk of the quantum state , _ the scattering of a dipole of size @xmath2 with a nucleus is sensitive to the probability distribution of the size of the largest fluctuation generated in the quantum evolution of the dipole , _ namely , in a mathematical language , to the _ statistics of extremes . _
we have just argued that scattering amplitudes can be thought of as probes of the quantum fluctuations of the dipole .
the latter are best pictured with the help of the color dipole model .
we shall now describe the way how these fluctuations build up ( see ref .
@xcite for an extensive discussion ) , in order to arrive at a model that leads to quantitative predictions for the scattering amplitudes . in these matters ,
useful intuition can be gained from numerical implementations of the dipole model in the form of a monte carlo event generator @xcite .
therefore , we shall illustrate our arguments with the help of simulations of the toy model constructed in ref .
+ the quantum evolution of the dipole proceeds through successive independent splittings @xmath22 , with rate per unit rapidity given by the probability distribution @xmath23 , where @xmath2 is the size vector of the initial dipole , @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the size vectors of the offspring , and @xmath26 .
the stochastic process of dipole evolution is a _
branching diffusion_. indeed , if one looks at the distribution of the log of the dipole sizes at a _ given _ impact parameter , it has a gaussian - like shape growing exponentially with the rapidity , see fig .
[ fig : dipole]a .
the stochasticity has a strong effect wherever the number of dipoles is of order unity , namely either in the beginning of the evolution ( for low rapidities ) , or at the edges of the distribution .
elsewhere , in the bulk of the distribution , the law of large numbers applies , and therefore , the rapidity evolution of the dipole density is nearly deterministic . according to these observations , in ref .
@xcite , we conjectured that there are essentially two types of fluctuations : the `` front fluctuations '' that come from the early stages of the evolution , and the `` tip fluctuations '' occurring throughout the evolution in the regions in which the dipole density is low .
both kinds of fluctuations shift the distribution of dipoles towards larger sizes , by say @xmath27 and @xmath28 respectively , in logarithmic scale .
we conjectured that the latter random variables are distributed exponentially , @xmath29 and @xmath30 , where @xmath31 is a number determined by the eigenvalues of the bfkl kernel .
+ m0.5 | m0.5 _ at zero impact parameter _ in bins of the logarithm of the dipole size ( normalized to the size @xmath2 of the dipole in the initial state ) .
the shaded rectangle of height unity indicates the target dipole of size @xmath3 . ( a )
no saturation in the dipole evolution .
one sees that setting e.g. @xmath32 , unitarity would be violated for @xmath33 in this event .
( note the logarithmic scale on the @xmath10-axis ) .
( b ) saturation in the dipole evolution .
the maximum density of dipoles is around @xmath34 . in both cases
, one sees that the density of dipoles has fluctuations , which self - average in the bins in which the density is large .
[ fig : dipole ] , title="fig : " ] & _ at zero impact parameter _ in bins of the logarithm of the dipole size ( normalized to the size @xmath2 of the dipole in the initial state ) .
the shaded rectangle of height unity indicates the target dipole of size @xmath3 .
( a ) no saturation in the dipole evolution .
one sees that setting e.g. @xmath32 , unitarity would be violated for @xmath33 in this event .
( note the logarithmic scale on the @xmath10-axis ) .
( b ) saturation in the dipole evolution .
the maximum density of dipoles is around @xmath34 . in both cases
, one sees that the density of dipoles has fluctuations , which self - average in the bins in which the density is large .
[ fig : dipole ] , title="fig : " ] + & the way how the scattering probes the quantum evolution is represented in figs .
[ fig : dipole ] and [ fig : nucleus ] .
since the number of dipoles grows exponentially with the rapidity , @xmath35 would at some point violate unitarity if the formula for @xmath36 applied without restrictions .
but we know that saturation effects ( for example rescatterings , gluon recombination ... ) may occur in the course of the evolution so that the effective number of dipoles does never grow larger than @xmath37 ( see fig .
[ fig : dipole]b ) .
these saturation effects are crucial in the dipole case , since the scattering is sensitive to the shape of the bulk of the distribution of the quantum fluctuations .
they make the averaging over events nontrivial . ; see e.g. @xcite for a discussion of how this scale comes about . ]
+ m0.5 | m0.5 two realizations ( a ) and ( b ) of the same dipole evolution without saturation in the simplified model of ref . @xcite . as in fig .
[ fig : dipole ] , we plot the dipole number @xmath9 in bins of the logarithm of the dipole size .
the shaded zone represents the target nucleus of saturation momentum @xmath14 , which absorbs all dipoles of size larger than @xmath38 .
hence this time , the scattering probability in one realization is 1 if at least one dipole is larger than @xmath38 , and 0 else .
the solid lines represent the dipole density _ integrated over the impact parameter _ , to which the nucleus would actually be a priori sensitive ,
while the dashed lines represent the density _ at zero impact parameter_. we see that the largest dipole is always at zero impact parameter , which illustrates that it is enough to understand the properties of the dipole distribution at fixed impact parameter in order to be able to compute the scattering amplitude .
the ( a)-realization turns out to have a larger density than the ( b)-realization , since the scattering would occur for smaller values of @xmath39 in the former case than in the latter case . note that the scale on the @xmath10-axis is logarithmic in both cases .
, title="fig : " ] & two realizations ( a ) and ( b ) of the same dipole evolution without saturation in the simplified model of ref . @xcite . as in fig .
[ fig : dipole ] , we plot the dipole number @xmath9 in bins of the logarithm of the dipole size .
the shaded zone represents the target nucleus of saturation momentum @xmath14 , which absorbs all dipoles of size larger than @xmath38 .
hence this time , the scattering probability in one realization is 1 if at least one dipole is larger than @xmath38 , and 0 else .
the solid lines represent the dipole density _ integrated over the impact parameter _ , to which the nucleus would actually be a priori sensitive ,
while the dashed lines represent the density _ at zero impact parameter_. we see that the largest dipole is always at zero impact parameter , which illustrates that it is enough to understand the properties of the dipole distribution at fixed impact parameter in order to be able to compute the scattering amplitude .
the ( a)-realization turns out to have a larger density than the ( b)-realization , since the scattering would occur for smaller values of @xmath39 in the former case than in the latter case . note that the scale on the @xmath10-axis is logarithmic in both cases .
, title="fig : " ] + & in the nucleus case ( fig .
[ fig : nucleus ] ) , it is the size of the largest dipole which determines the shape of the amplitude . therefore , both front and tip fluctuations must be taken into account .
on the other hand , the shape of the amplitude is less sensitive to saturation effects in the dipole evolution , at variance with the dipole case , at least for rapidities parametrically less than @xmath40 .
+ in the regions in which the dipole distribution is deterministic , the latter essentially has the shape @xmath41 near the large - size tip of the distribution , where @xmath42 is the saturation momentum . here , @xmath43 may be thought of as the smallest dipole size @xmath2 for which , in a typical event , there is an overlap of the dipole number distribution with the target .
the expression of @xmath42 is given in ref .
from our model for the fluctuations , an elementary calculation leads to the shape of the scattering amplitudes in the dipole - dipole and dipole - nucleus cases : @xmath44 the calculation simply averages the amplitude @xmath45 over events , assuming that the stochasticity is fully captured by the distribution of the random variables @xmath27 and @xmath28 , see again ref .
@xcite for all details and more results .
y. kovchegov , and e. levin , _ quantum chromodynamics at high energy _
, cambridge monographs on particle physics , nuclear physics and cosmology , cambridge university press , 2012 , isbn 9780521112574 , http://books.google.fr/books?id=f2nhp-new6uc . | we develop a picture of dipole - nucleus ( namely dilute - dense ) and dipole - dipole ( dilute - dilute ) scattering in the high - energy regime based on the analysis of the fluctuations in the quantum evolution .
we emphasize the difference in the nature of the fluctuations probed in these two processes respectively , which , interestingly enough , leads to observable differences in the scattering amplitude profiles .
address = centre de physique thorique , cole polytechnique , cnrs , palaiseau , france this paper introduces and summarizes the results recently published in ref .
@xcite , from a less technical viewpoint ( see ref .
@xcite for a complementary presentation ) , and with illustrations from numerical simulations ( see figs . [
fig : dipole ] and [ fig : nucleus ] below ) .
our goal is to understand the qualitative properties of the short - lived and short - distance ( with respect to @xmath0 ) quantum fluctuations , namely the ones that are probed most efficiently in deep - inelastic scattering experiments in the small-@xmath1 regime , or in observables in proton - proton and proton - nucleus scattering whose cross sections may be related to dipole amplitudes ( see e.g. ref .
@xcite ) .
( a recent general review of high - energy qcd can be found in ref .
@xcite ) .
we shall first describe qualitatively the scattering of two color dipoles and of a dipole off a nucleus , before turning to an analysis of the quantum fluctuations .
we shall eventually review the most striking quantitative prediction derived from our discussion .
our picture relies on the well - known color dipole model @xcite , which describes , in the framework of perturbative quantum chromodynamics , how the quantum state of a hadron builds up from a cascade of dipole splittings . |
explaining the origin of short - period ( sp ) comets ( periods @xmath7 yr ) is a long - standing problem .
the main difficulty lies in the differences and apparent inconsistency between the respective numbers and orbital distributions of jupiter - family ( jf ) and halley - type ( ht ) comets .
these we classify using the tisserand parameter @xmath8 with respect to jupiter ( carusi et al .
1987 ) , jf comets having @xmath9 ( and @xmath10 usually below 20 years ) , ht comets having @xmath11 ( and @xmath10 usually between 20 and 200 years ) .
when sp comets are classified this way the number of observed ht comets is found to be less than , or at most comparable to , the number of observed jf comets ( see section [ obs - sp ] below ) .
however , most dynamical theories of their origin from the near - parabolic flux predict a far greater proportion of ht comets ( emelyanenko and bailey 1998 ) , with the overall number of observed jf comets conversely being much too large relative to the calculated number ( joss 1973 ; delsemme 1973 ) .
this discrepancy is associated with the well - known fading problem for long - period comets originating in the oort cloud and has , at least in part , led to the idea that the two classes of sp comet may have different physical structures and different proximate sources in the present solar system .
thus , although there have been many advances in understanding the diverse populations of small bodies in the solar system , neither a single source dominated by trans - neptunian objects nor one dominated by the traditional oort cloud near - parabolic flux at small perihelion distances seems capable of explaining the entire distribution of orbital elements of sp comets . in particular the observed jf comet inclination distribution was recognized to have too many comets at low @xmath12 relative to the calculated distribution ( duncan et al .
1988 ; quinn et al . 1990 ) . for these reasons ,
the majority of authors nowadays consider jf and ht comets to be physically as well as dynamically distinct classes , presumably formed in separate regions of the early solar system and having different dynamical and physical evolutionary histories . under this viewpoint ,
jf comets are often regarded as originating largely in the proto - planetary disc beyond neptune , for example in or close to the edgeworth - kuiper belt ( ekb ) .
the idea that jf comets might originate in a primordial disc or ` belt ' of comets located near or beyond the orbit of neptune was investigated by a number of authors ( e.g. fernndez 1980 , 1982 ; duncan et al .
1988 ; torbett 1989 ; torbett and smoluchowski 1990 ; quinn et al .
the discovery of 1992 qb@xmath13 ( jewitt and luu 1993 ) and of further edgeworth - kuiper objects played a pivotal role in theories of the origin of sp comets , and important advances building on this evidence were made in particular by duncan et al .
( 1995 ) , duncan and levison ( 1997 ) , levison and duncan ( 1997 ) , and levison et al .
a key point ( duncan and levison 1997 ) was recognition of the potentially important role played by the ` scattered ' disc , introduced by torbett ( 1989 ) and detected a few years later ( luu et al .
1997 ) , in which it appears that the scattered disc of primordial objects originally formed in the region of the major planets is the principal source of observed jf comets , rather than the ekb . under the viewpoint of distinct jf and ht classes ,
ht comets are regarded as objects captured from the oort cloud ( levison et al .
2001 ) , a structure that would have been produced inevitably as a by - product of planetary , stellar and other perturbations acting on planetesimals or cometary nuclei originally formed by accretion within the planetary region of the proto - planetary disc . however , a rather unsatisfactory feature of this general picture is the assumption that ht comets coming from the oort cloud must disintegrate very quickly in order to explain the small number of objects observed ( emelyanenko and bailey 1998 ; levison et al .
the number of observed inert ht ` asteroids ' is also very small , and it seems as if the disintegration of a kilometre - size comet nucleus , into presumably an initial trail of much smaller boulder - size objects and then finally dust , must proceed fairly rapidly and lead to eventual extinction of the original comet .
on the other hand , dynamical theories appear to require that a high proportion of the jf comet source flux should survive dynamical transfer into the inner solar system to become active jf comets and that these jf comets should survive for @xmath610@xmath14 revolutions in the inner solar system .
this difference in the physico - dynamical evolution of the two types of objects is the fading problem for sp comets .
it is probably not unreasonable to assume that comets that formed in different parts of the proto - planetary disc have different physical properties and therefore different lifetimes in the observable region , and it appears that this idea has become very deeply rooted
. what is missing , however , is direct observational evidence to support the idea of two qualitatively distinct types of sp comet , correlating with dynamical class .
thus , present theories of the origin of sp comets rely on a poorly understood fading hypothesis to accommodate the observations , and there is no satisfactory physico - dynamical explanation as to why two very different types of sp comet should exist and yet appear observationally almost indistinguishable .
indeed , although comets show a very diverse range of properties , covering a very broad range of sizes , densities , dust - to - gas ratios and so on , there is as yet no compelling observational evidence for the expected bimodality of physical characteristics corresponding to ht versus jf dynamical class ( lamy et al .
2004 ) . in this work ,
whilst recognizing that comets may have different physical properties depending for example on their sizes or where they might have formed in the proto - planetary disc , we present a model for the common origin and evolution from the oort cloud of the majority of comets in the solar system .
we define the oort cloud as the region containing objects with semimajor axes @xmath15 au ( i.e. , objects from the oort cloud have at some point during their evolution reached @xmath15 au ) .
this definition is consistent with those used by other authors ; e.g.wiegert and tremaine ( 1999 ) and rickman et al . (
2008 ) used similar values of semimajor axis , i.e. @xmath16 au , to define the inner boundary of the oort cloud .
dones et al.(2004 ) introduced a further restriction , namely that the maximum value of perihelion distance @xmath17 during an object s orbital evolution should exceed 45 au for it to be counted as an ` oort cloud ' object .
however , objects with @xmath18 au spend nearly all their time at large heliocentric distances , whatever their value of @xmath17 , and therefore in the oort cloud . in this paper
we have chosen to define oort - cloud objects solely according to @xmath19 because the influence of stellar and galactic perturbations is determined mainly by @xmath19 for near - parabolic orbits .
it has been shown ( e.g. emelyanenko 2005 ) that the dynamical pathways by which objects with @xmath15 aureach the planetary region are different from those of typical trans - neptunian objects ( tnos ) .
while the evolution of tnos is largely determined only by planetary perturbations , stellar and galactic perturbations play a more substantial role in the process that drives the perihelia of objects with @xmath15 au towards and through the planetary region , regardless of their previous @xmath17 . in the present paper ( section [ integ ] onwards )
we numerically integrate a much larger number of objects than in the oort cloud model of emelyanenko et al .
( 2007 ) , in particular to obtain statistically significant numbers of sp comets captured from the oort cloud and allow a comparison of the model sp numbers and orbital distributions with the corresponding distributions of observed ht and jf comets .
first ( section [ obs - com ] ) , in order that our model parameters can be constrained by observations , we assess the known characteristics of the various populations of cometary bodies .
we took data from the mpc ( minor planet center ) and jpl ( jet propulsion laboratory ) lists of discovered comets with @xmath7 yr and @xmath5 au near the present epoch .
the completeness level in the discovery of sp comets is slightly uncertain , especially for ht comets and when results are extrapolated to fainter magnitudes and larger perihelion distances .
however , many discussions ( e.g. fernndez et al . 1999 ; levison et al .
2001 ) have indicated a relatively high degree of completeness in the observed sample of active comets at small perihelion distances ( @xmath5 au ) .
this level of completeness is supported too by studies of long - period comets , essentially none of which have been missed at @xmath20 au since 1985 ( fernndez and sosa 2012 ) .
we excluded soho comets because these have rather uncertain physical and dynamical characteristics ; this only affects the distribution near very small @xmath17 , a region that we do not study here .
we also excluded multiple - apparition comets that have not been observed for a number of revolutions and are now treated as dead or inert . for split comets we took only the orbit of the main nucleus . in the end
we obtained a list of 103 observed objects that we regard as representing the present - day set of active sp comets with @xmath5 au .
of these , 75 have @xmath9 ( jf comets ) and 28 have @xmath11 ( ht comets ) . and @xmath19 for observed short - period comets with @xmath5 au . ] and @xmath12 for observed short - period comets with @xmath5 au . ] figures [ atql1.5 ] and [ itql1.5 ] present orbital element distributions of these observed objects .
the inclinations ( figure [ itql1.5 ] ) show jf comets ( @xmath9 ) are concentrated close to the ecliptic and prograde ht comets outnumber retrograde ones ( fernndez and gallardo 1994 ; levison et al.2001 ) .
additionally the intrinsic numbers of jf and ht comets are a key constraint for our model .
fernndez et al .
( 1999 ) found that about a hundred active jf comets should currently exist in the region @xmath5 au , down to nuclear radius @[email protected] km .
the number appears to drop very rapidly for smaller bodies ( fernndez et al .
1999 ; snodgrass et al .
this estimate could be modified to take account of more recent comet discoveries ( cf .
section 2.1 of di sisto et al . 2009 ) but the result would not be significantly changed . for ht comets , their longer
average orbital periods constitute the principal bias against their discovery relative to jf comets .
that is , although we expect that most active comets passing perihelion with sufficiently small @xmath17 will be found at the current level of observational searches , many ht comets have not yet returned to perihelion during the last few decades when searches have been at such levels . in this way , taking account of the ht period distribution , levison et al .
( 2001 ) , from 22 observed ht comets with @xmath22au , estimated a population of 57 active ht comets ( @xmath20 ) .
this result can be extrapolated to about a hundred objects with @xmath5 au . in a later paper ( levison et al .
2006 ) the observed number has only increased to 24 , suggesting the estimate is reliable .
we conclude that there are roughly a hundred active jf comets and a comparable number , i.e.approximately a hundred , of active ht comets to be explained in the region @xmath5 au at times near the present epoch .
certainly the number of already known active jf comets shows that their intrinsic number can not be much below a hundred , while the intrinsic ht number can not be much above a hundred without implausibly many bright comets being missed by observational searches .
the flux of dynamically new comets from the oort cloud is a fundamental parameter underpinning all dynamical models of the small - body populations in the solar system , including the estimates in this paper .
there are uncertainties in the frequency , @xmath23 , of comets with @xmath24 au passing perihelion per au in @xmath17 per year , but @xmath23 is usually estimated to lie in the range 2 to 4 for present - day comets in near - earth space ( bailey and stagg 1988 ; fernndez and gallardo 1999 ; wiegert and tremaine 1999 ; francis 2005 ) . for quantitative estimates in this paper
we adopt @xmath25 , within the observable region @xmath5 au .
francis ( 2005 ) undertook a detailed discussion of the objects that the linear survey should discover for a given intrinsic cometary population .
considering also the question of the cometary absolute magnitude distribution , he found that very faint ( on average presumably smaller ) comets are only slightly more abundant than somewhat brighter ( presumably larger ) ones .
thus statements about cometary numbers , while evidently depending in detail on the adopted absolute - magnitude cutoff , are not strongly dependent on the precise value of that cutoff . in order to fix ideas , our adopted value @xmath26 comets with @xmath24 au passing perihelion per au in @xmath17 per year may be assumed to apply to comets with total visual absolute magnitudes @xmath27 .
the quantity @xmath28 is the magnitude normalized to 1 au from earth and sun ( e.g. everhart 1967 ) .
the inclusion of fainter comets ( e.g. extrapolating results from @xmath28 = 11 to @xmath29 ) makes very little practical difference to our results ( francis 2005 ; sosa and fernndez 2011 ) , although the calibration factor , @xmath23 , would of course increase .
the relative lack of very small ( diameters @xmath30 km ) comets ( fernndez and sosa 2012 ) suggests that the physical response of the smallest dynamically ` new ' comets from the oort cloud to the thermal shock of their first passage at small perihelion provides a clue to the underlying rapid fading of new comets from the oort cloud , necessary to explain the detailed shape of the observed @xmath31-distribution ( cf .
bailey 1984 ) .
.centaurs ( objects with @xmath32 au and @xmath3 au , excluding a few resonant trans - neptunian objects and trojans ) that have a probable source in the oort cloud .
the majority of such objects have @xmath33 au and after observational debiasing would be extremely numerous .
centaurs with @xmath34 au are listed if @xmath35 . only centaurs with an observational arc larger than 100 days ( asteroid orbits from mpc ) and comets of orbital classes 1 and 2 ( marsden and williams 2008 ) are included .
a unified classification scheme for centaurs was proposed by horner et al .
( 2003 ) . [ cols= " > , < , > , < , > , > " , ] @c r@@xmath36l r@@xmath36l r@@xmath36l r@@xmath36l @ + initial region : & 510 au & 1025 au & 2536 au & tn + @xmath37 & 1.0&@xmath38 & 1.8&@xmath39 & 4.3&@xmath39 & + @xmath40 & 8.0&@xmath41 & 5.0&@xmath42 & 2.5&@xmath39 &
+ @xmath43 & 1.0&@xmath38 & 1.3&@xmath39 & 1.8&@xmath39 & + @xmath44 & 0 & 1.0&@xmath38 & 2.6&@xmath42 & + @xmath45 & 0 & 3.0&@xmath46 & 7.9&@xmath38 &
+ @xmath47 & 3.0&@xmath48 & 9.0&@xmath41 & 9.3&@xmath46 & + @xmath49 & 0 & 1.0&@xmath50 & 6.6&@xmath41 & + @xmath51 & & & & 8.3&@xmath38 + @xmath52 & & & & 6.6&@xmath41 + @xmath53 & & & & 4.2&@xmath41 + @xmath54 & 0.01 & 0.97 & 1.52 & + @xmath55 & 0 & 1 & 41 &
+ @xmath56 & & & & 51 + @xmath57 & 0 & 7 & 101 & 0 + and @xmath19 in perihelia for sp comets with @xmath5 au coming from the oort cloud . ] and @xmath12 in perihelia for sp comets with @xmath5 au coming from the oort cloud . ]
table [ nmod ] summarizes our results for one of the best - fitting models .
the parameters are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
our model is consistent with the observed features of sp comets , centaurs and tnos , and table [ nmod ] estimates the numbers of present - day cometary objects coming from the various original source regions .
the regions correspond to three ranges of initial @xmath62 for objects that have visited the oort cloud , with objects originating from the ` primordial ' trans - neptunian population that have never been in the oort cloud listed in the final column ( tn ) .
the notation in table [ nmod ] is as introduced earlier , with data also listed for the subset of centaurs having @xmath34 au . whereas the model strongly constrains the initial @xmath62 distribution ,
results are not highly sensitive to the initial @xmath63 distribution , adopted as uniform in the range 50300 au .
for example , for the best - fitting model of table [ nmod ] , changing the distribution from uniform to @xmath64 per unit interval of @xmath63 , by applying appropriate weights to the integrated particles , changes @xmath55 from 42 to 41 and @xmath57 from 108 to 77 ( cf .
table [ dmod ] ) .
although our paper is mainly concerned with the origin of sp comets , we can compare our results for various cometary populations with other work .
fernndez et al .
( 2004 ) , following trujillo et al .
( 2000 ) estimate 7.5@xmath3610@xmath65 objects with radius @xmath66 km and @xmath67 au @xmath68 au but note an order of magnitude uncertainty in this number . moreover , our estimates are based on the flux of new comets with @xmath69 corresponding to @xmath70 km according to fernandez and sosa ( 2012 ) .
the number of such objects should be larger than the number of objects with @xmath66 km .
thus the estimate of fernndez et al.(2004 ) does not contradict our possible values of @xmath44 .
estimates for the number of comets in the outer oort cloud range up to 10@xmath71 ( cf .
heisler 1990 ; weissman 1996 ; section 2.4 of dones et al .
2004 ) , while the distribution of comets in different parts of the oort cloud is consistent with other models ( cf .
emelyanenko et al .
2007 ; dybczyski et al . 2008 ; leto et al .
2008 ) .
our data correspond to an initial population of approximately 1.6@xmath3610@xmath71 objects with @xmath70 km in the region @xmath72 au , @xmath73 au .
this is quite consistent with the value of @xmath63@xmath36@xmath74 objects with @xmath75 km and cometary albedos in the original trans - neptunian planetesimal disc , presented in figure 1 of morbidelli et al .
( 2009 ) .
the data of table [ nmod ] show that almost all jf comets originate from orbits with initial perihelia in the outer planetary system , and that over 90% of the steady - state number of ht comets come from the same @xmath72 au region .
this indicates that the majority of observed ht comets would have had initial orbits with perihelion distances largely overlapping the range of perihelia of the objects that eventually became jf comets .
this is in contrast to the general picture described in section 1 , where jf comets largely originate from initial orbits in the trans - neptunian region and ht comets from initial orbits in the region of the giant planets , with subsequent very different dynamical histories .
for all the models in table [ dmod ] , the orbital distributions of sp objects with @xmath5 au coming from the oort cloud have similar characteristics .
figures [ atall ] and [ itall ] show the orbital element distributions in perihelia ( i.e. equal weight to each perihelion passage ) for sp objects with @xmath5 au coming from the oort cloud , applying the restrictions @xmath61 , @xmath60 , @xmath59 ( all objects are equally presented , thus formally @xmath76 in these plots ) .
the figures show that in our model , jf comets ( @xmath9 ) are concentrated near the ecliptic plane , approximately 70% of them having @xmath77 . regarding ht comets ( @xmath11 ) , although the model reveals both prograde and retrograde orbits , prograde ht comets outnumber retrograde ones . in these ways
the basic features of these distributions are consistent with those of the observed distributions in figures [ atql1.5 ] and [ itql1.5 ] . in our model , all the modelled objects with periods under 20 yr have inclinations @xmath78 .
there are several reasons for this .
first , the majority of objects captured to the jf population originate from the inner oort cloud ( emelyanenko 2005 ) . in our model ,
the inner oort cloud is a rather flattened source of comets ( emelyanenko et al . 2007 ) .
secondly , the majority of such objects are injected from the inner oort cloud on to orbits with perihelia in the region of the outer planets by external perturbations .
their subsequent evolution is similar to the scheme described for trans - neptunian objects by kazimirchak - polonskaya ( 1972 ) and levison and duncan ( 1997 ) .
the latter showed that preferentially objects with tisserand parameters near 3 with respect to a planet cross the orbit of this planet .
this suggests that mainly objects on prograde orbits are transferred to the inner planetary region . our results from analysing observed sp comets about the initial distribution of objects that form the oort cloud are consistent with the standard picture of the origin of the solar system .
the conclusion was that @xmath79 : this corresponds to comets originally from the outer planetary region having a greater probability of survival and thus a longer lifetime as active comets , with objects originating from regions with small heliocentric distances conversely becoming extinct more quickly .
this accords with the amount of water ( as the main driver of cometary activity ) being larger for more distant objects in the early solar system .
we have developed a model of the origin and evolution of the oort cloud which is consistent with the basic observed orbital distributions of comets , centaurs and high - eccentricity trans - neptunian objects . rather than requiring intrinsically different fading properties for jupiter - family and halley - type short - period comets ,
the model instead adopts the hypothesis that the physical lifetime of objects as active comets in the inner planetary region at the present epoch is a function of their initial perihelion distance in the early solar system , and is the same for both jf and ht comets .
the observed jf and ht populations also constrain the initial distribution of objects versus perihelion distance .
our results show that : 1 .
the mean physical lifetime of comets is @xmath80200 revolutions in the region @xmath5 au .
this implies a significant cometary contribution to the distribution of small bodies ( ` boulders ' and dust ) making up the near - earth interplanetary complex .
2 . no model in which the initial number of comets is a decreasing function of their initial perihelion distance @xmath62 in the early solar system can explain the present observed distribution of short - period comets .
3 . models in which the initial distribution of objects versus perihelion distance is concentrated more towards the outer planetary region , and in which their present active physical lifetime is an increasing function of @xmath62 , are consistent with the present orbital distributions and numbers of both ht and jf comets . 4 .
essentially all the observed ht comets and nearly half the observed jf comets come from a proximate oort - cloud source ( i.e. have experienced orbits with @xmath81 au ) .
the remaining @xmath650% of observed jf comets come from the _ observed _ near - neptune high - eccentricity ( nnhe ) population , a dynamically unstable region in which the cometary numbers decline by 95% over 4 gyr .
in addition , more than 90% of all centaurs ( @xmath2 au , @xmath3 au ) come from the oort cloud .
the model predicts that there is a significant oort - cloud contribution to the nnhe population .
the number of such objects is comparable to the debiased number of objects already discovered in the nnhe region , but they are still undetected owing to observational biases ( e.g. considering large semimajor axes or high inclinations ) .
vve would like to acknowledge the support provided by the federal targeted programme ` scientific and educational human resources of innovation - driven russia ' for 20092013 , and the stfc - funded visitor programme of the armagh observatory .
astronomy at armagh observatory is supported by grant - in - aid from the northern ireland department of culture , arts and leisure .
we thank julio fernndez and ramon brasser for their reviews .
fernndez , t. gallardo , from the oort cloud to halley - type comets . in evolution and source regions of asteroids and comets ,
iau colloq .
173 , ed . by j. svore , e.m .
pittich , h. rickman ( astron .
slovak acad .
, tatransk lomnica , 1999 ) , pp . 327338 j.a .
fernndez , t. gallardo , a. brunini , the scattered disk population as a source of oort cloud comets : evaluation of its current and past role in populating the oort cloud .
icarus 172 , 372381 ( 2004 ) b. gladman , b.g .
marsden , g. vanlaerhoven , nomenclature in the outer solar system . in the solar system beyond neptune , ed . by m.a .
barucci , h. boehnhardt , d.p .
cruikshank , a. morbidelli ( univ .
arizona press , tucson , 2008 ) , pp
. 4357 e.i .
kazimirchak - polonskaya , the major planets as powerful transformers of cometary orbits . in the motion , evolution of orbits , and origin of comets , proc .
iau symp .
45 , ed . by g.a .
chebotarev , e.i .
kazimirchak - polonskaya , b.g .
marsden ( reidel , dordrecht , 1972 ) , pp .
373397 n. peixinho , a. doressoundiram , a. delsanti , h. boehnhardt , m.a .
barucci , i. belskaya , reopening the tnos color controversy : centaurs bimodality and tnos unimodality . astron .
astrophys .
410 , l29l32 ( 2003 ) a. sosa , j.a .
fernndez , masses of long - period comets derived from non - gravitational effects
analysis of the computed results and the consistency and reliability of the non - gravitational parameters .
mon . not .
r. astron . soc .
416 , 767782 ( 2011 ) s.c .
tegler , j.m .
bauer , w. romanishin , n. peixinho , colors of centaurs . in the solar system beyond neptune , ed . by m.a .
barucci , h. boehnhardt , d.p .
cruikshank , a. morbidelli ( univ .
arizona press , tucson , 2008 ) , pp . | a numerical simulation of the oort cloud is used to explain the observed orbital distributions and numbers of jupiter - family and halley - type short - period comets .
comets are given initial orbits with perihelion distances between 5 and 36 au , and evolve under planetary , stellar and galactic perturbations for 4.5 gyr .
this process leads to the formation of an oort cloud ( which we define as the region of semimajor axes @xmath0 au ) , and to a flux of cometary bodies from the oort cloud returning to the planetary region at the present epoch .
the results are consistent with the dynamical characteristics of short - period comets and other observed cometary populations : the near - parabolic flux , centaurs , and high - eccentricity trans - neptunian objects . to achieve this consistency with observations
, the model requires that the number of comets versus initial perihelion distance is concentrated towards the outer planetary region .
moreover , the mean physical lifetime of observable comets in the inner planetary region ( @xmath1 au ) at the present epoch should be an increasing function of the comets initial perihelion distances . virtually all observed halley - type comets and
nearly half of observed jupiter - family comets come from the oort cloud , and initially ( 4.5 gyr ago ) from orbits concentrated near the outer planetary region .
comets that have been in the oort cloud also return to the centaur ( @xmath2 au , @xmath3 au ) and near - neptune high - eccentricity regions .
such objects with perihelia near neptune are hard to discover , but centaurs with characteristics predicted by the model ( e.g. large semimajor axes , above 60 au , or high inclinations , above @xmath4 ) are increasingly being found by observers .
the model provides a unified picture for the origin of jupiter - family and halley - type comets .
it predicts that the mean physical lifetime of all comets in the region @xmath5 au is less than @xmath6200 revolutions .
example.eps gsave newpath 20 20 moveto 20 220 lineto 220 220 lineto 220 20 lineto closepath 2 setlinewidth gsave .4 setgray fill grestore stroke grestore |
dans tout cet article , @xmath0 est un
nombre premier , @xmath2 est un corps parfait de caractristique @xmath0 , et @xmath3 est une extension finie du corps des fractions @xmath4 de lanneau des vecteurs de witt sur @xmath2 . on se fixe une
clture algbrique @xmath5 de @xmath3 , et on pose @xmath6 .
utilisant lanneau de priodes @xmath0-adiques @xmath7 , fontaine a dfini la notion de reprsentation de _ de rham _ de @xmath8 .
si @xmath9 est une telle reprsentation et si @xmath10 est une extension finie de @xmath3 , on dfinit @xmath11 comme tant lensemble des classes de cohomologie qui dterminent une extension @xmath12 de reprsentations de @xmath13 telle que @xmath14 est une reprsentation de de rham de @xmath13 . on crira
@xmath15 pour dsigner lensemble des racines @xmath16-mes de lunit , et on dfinit @xmath17 ainsi que @xmath18 . on pose @xmath19 et @xmath20 .
lalgbre diwasawa est lalgbre de groupe complte @xmath21 $ ] .
la cohomologie diwasawa de @xmath9 est dfinie par @xmath22 o @xmath23 est un rseau de @xmath9 stable par @xmath8 et @xmath24 est la limite projective pour les applications corestriction ce qui fait de @xmath25 un @xmath26-module .
par construction , on a des applications @xmath27
et lobjet de cet article est ltude du module @xmath28 des normes universelles , lensemble des @xmath29 tels que pour tout @xmath30 on ait @xmath31 .
si @xmath32 est la plus grande sous - reprsentation de @xmath9 do nt tous les poids de hodge - tate sont @xmath33 , alors @xmath32 est de de rham et on peut montrer que @xmath34 .
le rsultat principal de cet article est le suivant : [ main_theo ] si @xmath9 est une reprsentation de de rham , alors 1 .
si @xmath9 na pas de sous - quotient stable par @xmath35 , alors @xmath36 ; 2 .
en gnral , @xmath37 et le quotient est un @xmath26-module de torsion .
la dmonstration est trs similaire celle quen a donne perrin - riou dans @xcite pour les reprsentations cristallines , et dans @xcite pour les reprsentations semi - stables , du groupe de galois dun corps non - ramifi sont entires , voir le dbut des paragraphes ( * ? ? ? * , 4.1 ) ] mais au lieu dutiliser son exponentielle largie , on utilise les constructions de @xcite ( qui redonnent lexponentielle largie dailleurs , comme on le montre dans @xcite ) et au lieu dutiliser des considrations de cran de la filtration et dordre , on utilise la thorie des @xmath38-modules qui encodent toutes ces informations .
cela simplifie la dmonstration de perrin - riou et nous permet de plus de ltendre au cas des reprsentations de de rham du groupe de galois dun corps ventuellement ramifi .
remarquons que lon nutilise pas le fait que les reprsentations de de rham sont potentiellement semi - stables .
indiquons brivement do provient cette conjecture .
on renvoie larticle @xcite de perrin - riou pour plus dinformations .
si @xmath14 est une courbe elliptique dfinie sur @xmath3 , on sintresse au module des normes universelles @xmath39 .
le calcul de ce module a t fait ( pour une courbe elliptique , une varit ablienne ou mme un groupe formel , et pour une @xmath40-extension quelconque ) dans certains cas par mazur @xcite , puis par hazewinkel @xcite , schneider @xcite et perrin - riou @xcite entre autres .
dans @xcite , coates et greenberg ont formul une conjecture assez gnrale dcrivant le module des normes universelles .
du rsultat que nous dmontrons est due nekov et concerne les normes universelles dans lextension cyclotomique pour une reprsentation @xmath0-adique de de rham .
si on lapplique au module de tate dune courbe elliptique @xmath14 , on retrouve , via la thorie de kummer , certains rsultats des auteurs cits prcdemment : si @xmath14 est ordinaire , alors @xmath41 est un @xmath42-module de rang @xmath43 et si @xmath14 est supersingulire , alors il est nul .
* remerciements * : je remercie pierre colmez pour ses nombreuses suggestions , de la dmonstration du thorme principal la rdaction finale de cet article .
je remercie aussi jan nekov pour ses encouragements et ses commentaires .
lobjet de ce premier chapitre est de rappeler et complter certains points de la thorie des @xmath38-modules .
ensuite , on rsout un problme dalgbre diffrentielle .
dans le deuxime chapitre , on verra comment cela sapplique aux reprsentations @xmath0-adiques .
dans tout cet article , @xmath2 dsigne un corps parfait de caractristique @xmath0 , et @xmath3 est une extension finie de @xmath4 , le corps des fractions de lanneau des vecteurs de witt sur @xmath2 . on crit @xmath15 pour dsigner lensemble des racines @xmath16-mes de lunit ,
et on dfinit @xmath17 ainsi que @xmath18 .
soit @xmath6 et @xmath19 le noyau du caractre cyclotomique @xmath44 et @xmath45 le groupe de galois de @xmath46 , qui sidentifie via le caractre cyclotomique un sous - groupe ouvert de @xmath47 .
enfin , soit @xmath48 lextension maximale non - ramifie de @xmath4 contenue dans @xmath49 et @xmath50 le corps rsiduel de @xmath48 . on note
@xmath51 le frobenius absolu ( qui relve @xmath52 sur @xmath50 ) .
dfinissons ici quelques anneaux de sries formelles ( ces constructions sont faites en dtail dans @xcite ) : si @xmath53 est un rel positif , soit @xmath54 lanneau des sries formelles @xmath55 o @xmath56 est une suite borne telle que @xmath57 converge sur la couronne @xmath58 .
cet anneau est muni dune action de @xmath59 , qui est triviale sur les coefficients et donne par @xmath60 et on peut dfinir un frobenius @xmath61 qui est @xmath51-semi - linaire sur les coefficients et tel que @xmath62 .
le thorme de prparation de weierstrass montre que @xmath63 est un corps .
ce corps nest pas complet pour la norme de gauss et on appelle @xmath64 son complt qui est un corps local de dimension @xmath65 do nt le corps rsiduel sidentifie @xmath66 .
lextension @xmath67 est une extension finie de degr de ramification @xmath68 $ ] et par la thorie du corps de normes de @xcite il lui correspond une extension sparable @xmath69 de degr @xmath70 $ ] qui nous permet de dfinir des extensions non - ramifies @xmath71 et @xmath72 de degr @xmath70 $ ] .
on peut montrer que @xmath73 o @xmath74 est un @xmath54-module libre de rang @xmath70 $ ] qui sidentifie un anneau de sries formelles @xmath75 o @xmath76 est une suite borne telle que @xmath77 converge sur la couronne @xmath78 .
llment @xmath79 vrifie une quation deisenstein sur @xmath80 quon peut relever en une quation sur @xmath81 ; laction de @xmath82 stend naturellement @xmath74 de mme que le frobenius @xmath83 .
un @xmath38-module est un @xmath84-espace vectoriel @xmath85 de dimension finie , muni dun frobenius @xmath86 et dune action de @xmath82 qui sont semi - linaires par rapport ceux de @xmath84 . on dit
que @xmath85 est _ tale _ si @xmath87 possde un rseau @xmath88 stable par @xmath89 sur lanneau des entiers @xmath90 de @xmath91 , tel que @xmath92 engendre @xmath88 sur @xmath90 .
dfinissons loprateur @xmath93 qui nous servira dans la suite .
on peut montrer que tout lment @xmath94 scrit de manire unique @xmath95 .
[ psi ] si @xmath95 , alors on pose @xmath96 .
ceci fait de @xmath97 un inverse gauche de @xmath89 qui commute laction de @xmath82 et qui vrifie @xmath98 si @xmath99 et @xmath100 .
il existe @xmath101 tel que si @xmath102 , alors on a une application injective @xmath103 $ ] ( cest lapplication @xmath104 de @xcite ) .
par exemple si @xmath105 , alors @xmath106 o @xmath107 est une racine primitive @xmath16-me de @xmath43 et @xmath108 agit par @xmath109 sur les coefficients .
on peut montrer ( voir @xcite ) que lensemble des sous @xmath74-modules de type fini @xmath110 de @xmath85 tels que @xmath111 admet un plus grand lment @xmath112 et quil existe @xmath113 que lon peut supposer @xmath114 tel que si @xmath115 , alors @xmath116 . on utilise
@xmath108 pour dfinir @xmath117 \otimes^{\iota_n}_{{\mathbf{b}^{\dagger , r}}_k } d^{\dag , r}$ ] et @xmath118 .
le lemme suivant sera utile par la suite : [ gam_tor_pg ] si @xmath119 , alors il existe @xmath120 $ ] tel que @xmath121 si et seulement si @xmath122 .
un petit calcul montre que @xmath123 est un @xmath124-espace vectoriel de dimension @xmath125 ( il suffit de remarquer que des lments de @xmath123 qui sont lis sur @xmath84 le sont sur @xmath126 ) et donc quil existe @xmath127 $ ] en fait tel que @xmath128 annule @xmath123 .
montrons donc la rciproque .
supposons que @xmath129 est une relation de longueur minimale avec @xmath130 . on peut
supposer que lun des @xmath131 est gal @xmath43 .
en appliquant @xmath97 et en utilisant le fait que dune part @xmath132 et que dautre part @xmath97 agit par @xmath133 sur @xmath48 , on voit que @xmath134 pour tout @xmath135 et on suppose donc partir de maintenant que @xmath127 $ ] .
nous utiliserons ci - dessous le rsultat suivant : si @xmath127 $ ] , alors il existe une constante @xmath136 telle que pour tout @xmath110 qui est un @xmath137$]-module libre de rang @xmath138 , muni dune action semi - linaire de @xmath82 par automorphismes , le @xmath48-espace vectoriel @xmath139 est de dimension @xmath140 . fixons @xmath115 et considrons , pour @xmath141 tel que @xmath142 , le @xmath117$]-module libre de rang @xmath138 dfini ci - dessus : @xmath117 \otimes^{\iota_n}_{{\mathbf{b}^{\dagger , r}}_k } d^{\dag , r}$ ] . on voit que
lon a une injection : @xmath143 \otimes_{k_n[[t ] ] } k_n[[t ] ] \otimes^{\iota_n}_{{\mathbf{b}^{\dagger , r}}_k } d^{\dag , r } \right)^{p(\gamma)=0},\ ] ] ce qui fait que @xmath144 est un @xmath48-espace vectoriel de dimension @xmath140 et donc que @xmath145 est un @xmath48-espace vectoriel de dimension @xmath140 .
comme @xmath89 commute @xmath128 , @xmath146 est un @xmath48-espace vectoriel de dimension finie et stable par @xmath89 ce qui fait que @xmath147 est bijectif .
si @xmath148 , alors @xmath149 pour un @xmath150 et donc @xmath151 ce qui fait que @xmath152 et donc que @xmath153 ( ceci gnralise un rsultat de @xcite ) . pour conclure , il suffit de remarquer que si @xmath132 et @xmath154 , alors @xmath155 et donc @xmath156 .
dans ce paragraphe , on dfinit les @xmath38-modules de de rham et on rappelle certains des rsultats de @xcite leur sujet .
[ pg_dr ] on dit quun @xmath38-module @xmath85 est de _ de rham _ , si et seulement sil existe @xmath157 , @xmath158 avec @xmath159 , tels que le @xmath3-espace vectoriel @xmath160 est de dimension @xmath161 .
si cest le cas , alors @xmath162 est de dimension @xmath161 pour tous les @xmath157 , @xmath158 tels que @xmath159 .
nous allons rappeler les rsultats de @xcite qui permettent de donner une autre caractrisation des @xmath38-modules de de rham .
ces rsultats sont aussi expliqus dans le sminaire bourbaki @xcite .
lanneau @xmath74 sidentifiant un anneau de sries formelles convergeant sur une couronne , il est naturellement muni dune topologie de frchet , la topologie de la convergence compacte , et son complt @xmath163 pour cette topologie sidentifie lanneau de sries formelles @xmath75 o @xmath164 est une suite non ncessairement borne telle que @xmath77 converge sur la couronne @xmath78 .
par exemple , si on pose @xmath165 , alors @xmath166 pour tout @xmath167 .
lanneau @xmath168 est lanneau de robba .
ces anneaux ont t tudis dans @xcite et nous allons rappeler quelques - uns des rsultats qui nous seront utiles dans la suite .
lapplication @xmath108 se prolonge en une application injective @xmath169 $ ] .
laction de @xmath82 sur @xmath163 stend en une action de lalgbre de lie de @xmath82 donne par @xmath170 pour @xmath171 assez proche de @xmath43 .
si @xmath172 alors @xmath173 .
si @xmath174 alors on pose @xmath175 ce qui fait que si @xmath172 alors @xmath176 et que si @xmath177 vrifie une quation algbrique @xmath178 sur @xmath179 telle que @xmath180 , alors on peut aussi calculer @xmath181 par la formule @xmath182 . en particulier @xmath183
si et seulement si @xmath184 .
si @xmath85 est un @xmath38-module , on dfinit @xmath185 par @xmath186 . lalgbre de lie de @xmath82 agit sur @xmath185 par la formule @xmath187 pour @xmath171 assez proche de @xmath43 et on a donc aussi une application @xmath188 .
la proposition suivante se dmontre exactement de la mme manire que ( * ? ? ?
* thorme 5.10 ) .
[ ndr_pg ] si @xmath85 est de de rham , si @xmath115 , et si @xmath189 est lensemble des @xmath190 $ ] tels que pour tout @xmath141 tel que @xmath142 , on ait @xmath191 \otimes_k ( k_n((t ) ) \otimes^{\iota_n}_{{\mathbf{b}^{\dagger , r}}_k } d^{\dag , r})^{\gamma_k},\ ] ] et si on pose @xmath192 , alors @xmath193 est un @xmath194-module libre de rang @xmath138 stable par les actions induites de @xmath89 et de @xmath82 , tel que @xmath195 et tel que @xmath196={d^\dag_{\mathrm{rig}}}[1/t]$ ] .
nous tablirons quelques proprits de @xmath193 dans le paragraphe [ ii1 ] .
donnons nous une variable @xmath197 sur laquelle on fait agir @xmath198 par @xmath199 .
si @xmath161 , alors on dit que le @xmath38-module @xmath85 est 1 .
_ cristallin _ , si @xmath200)^{\gamma_k}$ ] est un @xmath4-espace vectoriel de dimension @xmath138 ; 2 .
_ semi - stable _ , si @xmath201[1/t])^{\gamma_k}$ ] est un @xmath4-espace vectoriel de dimension @xmath138 .
il nest pas difficile de voir que cristallin implique semi - stable et que semi - stable implique de de rham ; on a dailleurs dans ce cas @xmath202 \otimes_f ( { d^\dag_{\mathrm{rig}}}[\ell_y][1/t])^{\gamma_k } \right)^{d / d\ell_y=0}.\ ] ] de plus , le thorme de monodromie @xmath0-adique pour les quations diffrentielles ( dmontr indpendamment dans @xcite ) montre que @xmath85 est de de rham si et seulement sil existe une extension finie @xmath10 de @xmath3 telle que @xmath203 est semi - stable .
nous nutiliserons pas cela par la suite . on aura besoin
dans la suite dun argument qui est une variante du dterminant wronskien et qui est lobjet de ce chapitre .
soient @xmath204 un corps diffrentiel , do nt on notera @xmath205 la drivation , et @xmath2 , @xmath206 et @xmath207 trois entiers @xmath33 .
on tend naturellement @xmath205 @xmath208 . on se donne
@xmath209 vecteurs @xmath210 qui satisfont les deux conditions ci - dessous : 1 .
dune part , les @xmath206 vecteurs @xmath211 pour @xmath212 sont linairement indpendants sur @xmath204 ; 2 .
dautre part , les @xmath209 vecteurs @xmath213 pour @xmath214 sont linairement dpendants sur @xmath204 . [ wronski ] sous les hypothses ci - dessus , les @xmath209 vecteurs @xmath215 pour @xmath214 sont lis sur @xmath216 .
comme on suppose que les @xmath217 sont lis sur @xmath204 , il existe des lments @xmath218 tels que @xmath219 , ce qui se traduit par le fait que pour tout @xmath220 , on a la relation @xmath221 : @xmath222 comme on a suppos que les @xmath223 sont libres , on voit que @xmath224 et on peut donc supposer que @xmath225 ce que lon fait partir de maintenant .
si on drive @xmath221 , on trouve que @xmath226 si @xmath227 , alors le premier terme de la relation ci - dessus est nul par @xmath228 et on trouve que @xmath229 pour @xmath227 et donc que @xmath230 puisque @xmath225 .
ceci nous donne une relation @xmath231 entre les @xmath223 et comme on a suppos que ceux - ci sont libres , cest que @xmath232 pour tout @xmath214 . on a donc montr que
si les @xmath233 sont lis sur @xmath204 , alors ils sont lis sur @xmath216 . en considrant la premire composante de @xmath217 , on trouve : [ wronski_coro ] sous les hypothses ci - dessus , il existe des constantes @xmath234
pour @xmath214 , non toutes nulles , telles que @xmath235 dans ce paragraphe , nous allons montrer la proposition suivante : [ pg_diff ] soit @xmath85 un @xmath38-module de de rham qui vrifie @xmath236 et @xmath237 .
si @xmath100 et @xmath238 sont tels que @xmath239 , alors il existe @xmath120 $ ] tel que @xmath121 .
si @xmath240 , alors le fait que @xmath237 implique immdiatement que @xmath241 . on suppose dsormais que @xmath242 , et on se fixe @xmath198 dordre infini .
comme @xmath85 est un
@xmath84-espace vectoriel de dimension finie , il existe un entier @xmath243 tel que @xmath244 sont libres sur @xmath84 , mais @xmath245 sont lis sur @xmath84 , ce qui fait que pour tout @xmath246 , il existe des lments @xmath247 de @xmath84 tels que @xmath248 si lon drive @xmath2 fois la relation ci - dessus , on trouve que : @xmath249 supposons que lon se donne un entier @xmath250 et des lments @xmath251 de @xmath84 tels que pour tout @xmath252 et pour tout @xmath253 , on ait @xmath254 .
bien sr , de tels lments ( non tous nuls ) existent si @xmath255 . on voit alors
que @xmath256 montrons que cela implique que @xmath254 pour @xmath257 et pour @xmath253 , ce qui est quivalent au fait que les deux termes de lquation ( [ eqn01 ] ) ci - dessus sont nuls . on a @xmath258 et le terme de gauche de lquation ( [ eqn01 ] ) est donc dans @xmath259 tandis que le terme de droite est dans @xmath85 ce qui fait que les deux termes sont nuls puisquon a suppos que @xmath237 .
pour @xmath260 , posons @xmath261 et @xmath262 ainsi que @xmath263 .
si @xmath250 est le plus petit entier tel que les @xmath264 pour @xmath212 sont libres et les @xmath264 pour @xmath214 sont lis , alors les calculs prcdents montrent _ quen plus _ , les @xmath217 pour @xmath214 sont _ eux aussi _ lis . on peut alors appliquer le corollaire [ wronski_coro ] pour en dduire lexistence de @xmath265 pour @xmath214 tels que @xmath235 si lon combine cela avec le fait que par dfinition , on a @xmath266 , on trouve que @xmath267 ceci montre bien quil existe @xmath268 $ ] tel que @xmath154 .
lobjet de ce chapitre est de montrer comment le rsultat dmontr au chapitre prcdent ( la proposition [ pg_diff ] ) implique le thorme principal de cet article .
pour cela , on rappelle la correspondance entre reprsentations @xmath0-adiques et @xmath38-modules , puis on utilise la formule rciprocit de cherbonnier - colmez pour se ramener la situation du chapitre prcdent . on conclut par un argument de dvissage .
une reprsentation @xmath0-adique est un @xmath124-espace vectoriel @xmath9 de dimension finie @xmath269 , muni dune action linaire et continue de @xmath8 .
afin dtudier les reprsentations @xmath0-adiques , fontaine a construit ( voir @xcite par exemple ) un certains nombre danneaux de priodes @xmath0-adiques , ce qui conduit la dfinition des reprsentations _ cristallines _ , _ semi - stables _ ou de _ de rham_. dautre part , en combinant les constructions de fontaine ( voir @xcite ) et un thorme de cherbonnier - colmez ( voir @xcite ) , on dfinit un foncteur @xmath270 qui induit une quivalence de catgories entre la catgorie des reprsentations @xmath0-adiques et la catgorie des @xmath38-modules tales .
si par exemple @xmath35 agit trivialement sur @xmath9 , alors @xmath271 et on rcupre @xmath9 partir de @xmath272 par @xmath273 . en gnral
, la situation est plus complique mais on peut quand mme montrer que @xmath274 ce do nt nous aurons besoin par la suite .
rappelons que pour un @xmath38-module @xmath85 , on a dfini au paragraphe [ i1 ] un rel @xmath113 tel que si @xmath275 , alors @xmath276 et on posera dans la suite @xmath277 .
les rsultats de @xcite montrent que si @xmath9 est une reprsentation @xmath0-adique , et si @xmath278 , alors @xmath279 et donc que @xmath9 est de de rham si et seulement si @xmath272 est de de rham au sens de la dfinition [ pg_dr ] . on dispose alors
dune part des applications @xmath280 et dautre part de lquation diffrentielle @xmath0-adique @xmath281 qui est le module @xmath193 do nt on a rappel la construction dans la proposition [ ndr_pg ] .
les rsultats de @xcite montrent par ailleurs quune reprsentation @xmath9 est cristalline ( ou semi - stable ) si et seulement si son @xmath38-module @xmath272 est cristallin ( ou semi - stable ) .
on retrouve alors les invariants associs @xmath9 par la thorie de hodge @xmath0-adique de la manire suivante : @xmath282)^{\gamma_k}$ ] et @xmath283[1/t])^{\gamma_k}$ ] .
nous allons avoir besoin de quelques rsultats concernant @xmath281 , et on suppose partir de maintenant que @xmath9 est de de rham .
[ ht_ndr ] si @xmath9 est une reprsentation de de rham , do nt les poids de hodge - tate sont @xmath284 , alors @xmath285 et si @xmath286 , alors les poids de hodge - tate de @xmath9 sont @xmath33 . tant donne la construction de @xmath287 que lon a donne dans la proposition [ ndr_pg ] , on voit quil suffit pour montrer le premier point de montrer que si @xmath288 et @xmath289 et si @xmath142 , alors @xmath290 \otimes_k { \mathbf{d}_{\mathrm{dr}}}(v)$ ] . on sait par les
constructions de @xcite que @xmath291 et le rsultat suit du fait que si les poids de hodge - tate de @xmath9 sont @xmath284 , alors @xmath292 .
dautre part , la dmonstration de ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5.15 ) montre que le @xmath293-module engendr par @xmath294 est @xmath295 .
de mme , le @xmath293-module engendr par @xmath296 est @xmath297 et la deuxime assertion suit du fait que si @xmath298 , alors les poids de hodge - tate de @xmath9 sont @xmath33 .
[ ndr_sub ] si @xmath9 est une reprsentation de de rham do nt les poids de hodge - tate sont @xmath284 et si @xmath299 est une sous - reprsentation de @xmath9 , alors @xmath300 .
on voit que @xmath301 est un sous @xmath194-module de @xmath302 qui est libre de rang @xmath303 ( parce que @xmath304={\mathbf{d}^{\dagger } _ { \mathrm{rig}}}(v)[1/t]$ ] ) et qui est stable par @xmath305 ( qui concide avec loprateur induit par @xmath306 ) , ce qui fait que @xmath307 par dfinition de @xmath308 ( voir ( * ? ? ? * thorme 5.10 ) ) .
[ no_divis ] si @xmath9 est une reprsentation de de rham do nt les poids de hodge - tate sont @xmath284 et qui nadmet pas de sous - reprsentation do nt les poids de hodge - tate sont @xmath33 , alors @xmath309 .
si @xmath310 , alors on voit que lintersection @xmath311 des sous @xmath84-espaces vectoriels de @xmath272 stables par @xmath89 et @xmath82 et contenant @xmath312 vrifie @xmath313 .
la proposition @xcite implique dautre part que @xmath311 est un sous @xmath38-module tale de @xmath272 et donc quil existe une reprsentation @xmath0-adique @xmath314 telle que @xmath315 . on voit alors
que @xmath316 par le lemme [ ndr_sub ] et donc que les poids de hodge - tate de @xmath317 sont tous @xmath33 , par la proposition [ ht_ndr ] , et donc que @xmath318 ce qui fait que @xmath152 .
rappelons que lon a une application @xmath319 et on en dduit une application @xmath320 o @xmath321 est lapplication coefficient de @xmath322 .
[ divis_t ] si @xmath323 est tel que pour tout @xmath324 , on ait @xmath325 \otimes_k { \mathbf{d}_{\mathrm{dr}}}(v)$ ] , alors @xmath326 . en particulier ,
si @xmath327 pour tout @xmath324 , alors @xmath326 .
fixons @xmath328 tel que @xmath329 .
la dmonstration de la proposition @xcite montre est surjective - elle est surjective modulo @xmath330 pour tout @xmath331 . ]
quil existe une base @xmath332 de @xmath189 do nt les images par @xmath108 sont une base de @xmath117 \otimes_k { \mathbf{d}_{\mathrm{dr}}}(v)$ ] pour tout @xmath324 .
si lon crit que @xmath333 , et si @xmath325 \otimes_k { \mathbf{d}_{\mathrm{dr}}}(v)$ ] , alors @xmath334 pour tout @xmath324 et donc @xmath335 divise @xmath336 dans @xmath194 ce qui fait que @xmath326 .
rappelons que herr a montr dans @xcite comment construire les groupes de cohomologie galoisienne @xmath337 partir du @xmath38-module associ @xmath9 .
nous utiliserons la version quen ont donne cherbonnier et colmez dans @xcite et que nous rappelons brivement .
rappelons que lon a dfini ( voir dfinition [ psi ] ) un oprateur @xmath338 .
dans @xcite , une application @xmath339 est construite pour tout @xmath30 .
ces applications @xmath340 donnent lieu ( par un thorme non publi de fontaine do nt on trouvera une dmonstration dans @xcite ) un isomorphisme entre @xmath341 et la cohomologie diwasawa @xmath25 par passage la limite sur @xmath141 . on
suppose prsent que @xmath9 est de de rham , et on va voir quelle condition @xmath342 si @xmath343 .
loprateur @xmath344 que lon a dfini au paragraphe [ secpgdr ] vrifie @xmath345 o @xmath346 si lon combine le thorme ( * ? ? ?
* iv.2.1 ) avec des proprits bien connues
de lexponentielle duale de bloch - kato , et le fait que @xmath347 pour @xmath238 , alors on trouve que : [ ch_co ] il existe @xmath348 que lon peut supposer @xmath349 tel que si @xmath350 , alors @xmath351 et si @xmath343 , @xmath352 et @xmath238 , alors on a @xmath353 si et seulement si @xmath354 . enfin pour terminer , on calcule la @xmath355$]-torsion de @xmath341 . [ gam_tor ] si @xmath343 , alors il existe @xmath120 $ ] tel que @xmath121 si et seulement si @xmath356 .
tant donn que @xmath274 comme on la rappel au paragraphe [ ii1 ] , cest une consquence immdiate du lemme [ gam_tor_pg ] .
perrin - riou a en fait dtermin la structure du @xmath357-module @xmath25 .
son sous - module de torsion sidentifie @xmath358 et @xmath359 est ( au moins si @xmath360 est finie ) un @xmath357-module libre de rang @xmath361\dim(v)$ ] .
dans ce paragraphe , on montre le thorme [ main_theo ] . on commence par
un rsultat un peu plus faible ( la proposition [ univ_irred ] ci - dessous ) puis on montre comment en dduire le cas gnral en dvissant un peu .
si @xmath299 est une reprsentation @xmath0-adique , soit @xmath362 lensemble des @xmath363 tels que pour tout @xmath30 , on ait @xmath364 .
[ univ_irred ] si @xmath238 et si @xmath9 est une reprsentation de de rham do nt les poids de hodge - tate sont @xmath365 et qui nadmet pas de sous - reprsentation do nt les poids de hodge - tate sont @xmath366 , alors @xmath367 .
dautre part , on a @xmath368 si @xmath369 et @xmath370 si @xmath242 .
posons @xmath371 et @xmath372 .
comme les poids de hodge - tate de @xmath373 sont @xmath284 , le lemme [ ht_ndr ] montre que @xmath374 .
dautre part , le fait que @xmath9 nadmet pas de sous - reprsentation do nt les poids de hodge - tate sont @xmath366 et le lemme [ no_divis ] montrent que @xmath375 .
enfin , la proposition [ ch_co ] montre que si @xmath376 pour tout @xmath30 , alors @xmath377 pour tout @xmath324 et donc que @xmath378 pour tout @xmath324 et le lemme [ divis_t ] ( appliqu @xmath373 ) montre que @xmath379 . on est donc en mesure dappliquer la proposition [ pg_diff ] , qui montre quil existe @xmath268 $ ] tel que @xmath121 .
le lemme [ gam_tor ] montre enfin que @xmath380 , ce qui dmontre le premier point .
ensuite , si @xmath240 et @xmath381 , alors @xmath382 et donc @xmath368 . enfin si @xmath242 et @xmath380 , alors @xmath383 pour tout @xmath30 et donc @xmath370 .
pour terminer , on donne les arguments de dvissage permettant de dduire le thorme principal de la proposition [ univ_irred ] .
[ g_ext ] si @xmath384 est une suite exacte de reprsentations @xmath0-adiques , alors on a une suite exacte : @xmath385 la thorie des @xmath38-modules nous donne une suite exacte : @xmath386 et le lemme du serpent implique que lon a : @xmath387 le lemme rsulte
alors du fait ( voir ( * ? ? ?
* , ( iii ) ) ) que les sous - quotients des reprsentations de rham sont de de rham .
si @xmath299 est une reprsentation de hodge - tate et @xmath388 , soit @xmath389 la plus grande sous - reprsentation de @xmath299 do nt tous les poids sont @xmath390 .
[ no_fil_fil ] on a @xmath391 .
soit @xmath392 la projection naturelle .
si @xmath393 a tous ses poids @xmath390 , alors on a une suite exacte @xmath394 et donc @xmath395 est une reprsentation de hodge - tate , extension de deux reprsentations de hodge - tate poids @xmath390 , et donc elle - mme poids @xmath390 , ce qui fait que @xmath396 et donc que @xmath397 .
nous pouvons enfin montrer le rsultat principal de cet article .
pour cela , rappelons que lon a un isomorphisme @xmath398 .
[ main_in ] si @xmath9 est une reprsentation de de rham , alors 1 .
si @xmath9 na pas de sous - quotient stable par @xmath35 , alors @xmath399 ; 2 . en gnral
, @xmath400 et le quotient est un @xmath26-module de torsion .
le fait que @xmath401 suit du fait ( dmontr en ( * ? ? ? * lemme 6.5 ) par exemple ) que si @xmath299 est une reprsentation de de rham do nt tous les poids de hodge - tate sont @xmath33 , alors toute extension de @xmath124 par @xmath299 est elle - mme de de rham .
nous allons maintenant montrer le ( 2 ) , cest - - dire que @xmath402 est un @xmath26-module de torsion .
par un argument de dvissage , il suffit de montrer que pour tout @xmath238 , @xmath403 est un @xmath357-module de torsion ce que nous allons maintenant faire . on a une suite exacte : @xmath404 et la reprsentation @xmath405 a des poids @xmath365 et nadmet pas de sous - reprsentation do nt les poids sont @xmath366 par le lemme [ no_fil_fil ] .
la proposition [ univ_irred ] montre que @xmath406 et donc que @xmath407 est un @xmath26-module de torsion .
ceci montre le ( 2 ) .
les calculs ci - dessus montrent de plus que si @xmath9 na pas de sous - quotient stable par @xmath35 , alors en fait @xmath408 car dans ce cas , @xmath409 pour tout @xmath238 et donc @xmath410 pour tout @xmath238 .
ceci montre le ( 1 ) . reprenons la dmonstration du thorme [ main_in ] ci - dessus .
limage de @xmath411 dans @xmath412 sidentifie une sous - reprsentation @xmath413 de @xmath414 ; cest donc une reprsentation de @xmath8 fixe par @xmath35 et do nt le seul poids de hodge - tate est @xmath415 ( notons aussi que @xmath416 ) .
comme il ny a pas dextensions non - triviales entre de tels objets qui soit encore fixe par @xmath35 ( ou , ce qui revient au mme , il ny a pas dextensions non - triviales entre de tels objets chez les @xmath26-modules ) , on en dduit que si lon splice les suites exactes ( [ eqn2 ] ) pour @xmath238 , on trouve : @xmath417 ce qui permet de prciser ( au moins en principe ) le thorme [ main_theo ] .
voici une liste des principales notations du texte , dans lordre o elles apparaissent : [ i1 ] : @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath418 , @xmath419 , @xmath49 , @xmath8 , @xmath35 , @xmath420 , @xmath82 , @xmath48 , @xmath51 , @xmath54 , @xmath89 , @xmath421 , @xmath64 , @xmath422 , @xmath84 , @xmath91 , @xmath74 , @xmath85 , @xmath97 , @xmath101 , @xmath108 , @xmath112 , @xmath113 . | on calcule le module des normes universelles pour une reprsentation @xmath0-adique de de rham .
le calcul utilise la thorie des @xmath1-modules ( la formule de rciprocit de cherbonnier - colmez ) et lquation diffrentielle associe une reprsentation de de rham .
we compute the module of universal norms for a de rham @xmath0-adic representation .
the computation uses the theory of @xmath1-modules ( cherbonnier - colmez s reciprocity formula ) and the differential equation attached to a de rham representation . |
let @xmath3 be an abelian surface over the complex numbers , and @xmath4 the sign involution .
the quotient surface @xmath5 is a normal surface with 16 rational double points of type @xmath2 , whose minimal resolution @xmath6 is a k3 surface .
one also says that @xmath6 is a kummer k3 surface ; they play a fairly central role in the theory of all complex k3 surfaces .
it is easy to see that the kummer construction works in positive characteristics @xmath7 as well .
in contrast , shioda @xcite and katsura @xcite observed that the kummer construction breaks down in characteristic @xmath8 for supersingular abelian surfaces @xmath3 . in this case
, they showed that singularities on the quotient surface @xmath9 are elliptic singularities , and that the minimal resolution @xmath6 is a rational surface .
the goal of this paper is to give a new type of kummer construction in the supersingular situation at @xmath8 . to explain this construction ,
let me discuss the case where @xmath3 is superspecial , that is , isomorphic to the selfproduct @xmath10 of supersingular elliptic curves .
my idea is to replace the supersingular elliptic curve @xmath11 by a cuspidal rational curve @xmath12 , and the group action of @xmath13 by a suitable group scheme action of the infinitesimal group scheme @xmath14 . in particular , we start with the _ nonnormal _ surface @xmath15 . nevertheless , it turns out that the quotient @xmath16 is a normal surface , whose singularities are rational double points of type @xmath0 , @xmath17 , or @xmath1 , at least if the ground field is perfect .
the first main result of this paper is the following : the minimal resolution of singularities @xmath18 is a k3 surface .
there are complications for nonperfect ground fields .
it seems that the minimal resolution could be a regular surface with trivial canonical class that is not geometrically regular .
this seems to be an interesting subject matter in its own right , but i do not pursue this topic in the present paper .
the kummer construction also plays an important role in the theory of supersingular k3 surfaces in characteristic @xmath19 . recall that a k3 surface @xmath6 is called _ supersingular _ ( in the sense of shioda ) if its picard number equals the second betti number , that is , @xmath20 .
artin @xcite introduced for such k3 surfaces an integer invariant @xmath21 called the _
artin invariant _ , which can be defined in terms of discriminants of the intersection form .
shioda @xcite proved for @xmath7 that the supersingular k3 surfaces with artin invariant @xmath22 are precisely the kummer k3 surfaces coming from supersingular abelian surfaces .
the second main result of this paper is : our k3 surfaces @xmath6 are supersingular with artin invariant @xmath23 .
this depends on an analysis of the degenerate fibers in the quasielliptic fibrations @xmath24 induced from the projections on @xmath15 .
drops in the artin invariants are due to confluence of a pair of @xmath0-singularities into a single @xmath1-singularity .
oort @xcite showed that any supersingular abelian surface is an infinitesimal quotient of a superspecial abelian surface .
this implies that supersingular abelian surfaces @xmath3 form a 1-dimensional family , in which the action of @xmath13 is constant . in our new kummer construction
, it is the other way round : the nonnormal surface @xmath15 does not move , but the action of @xmath14 lies in a moving family .
this is reminiscent of the moret - bailly construction @xcite .
our construction gives a family @xmath25 of normal surfaces with rational double points over the punctured affine plane @xmath26 . according to the work of brieskorn @xcite and artin @xcite ,
simultaneous resolutions exist rarely without base change .
this is indeed the case in our situation : the family of normal surface @xmath25 admits a simultaneous minimal resolution of singularities after certain purely inseparable base change .
we achieve simultaneous resolution by successively blowing up weil divisors in multiple fibers on the quasielliptic fibrations @xmath27 .
the purely inseparable base change enters the picture , because the original family contains integral fibers switching to multiple fibers over the perfect closure .
it turns out that the resulting family of k3 surfaces @xmath28 , where @xmath29 is the purely inseparable base change , is induced from a family of @xmath30 surfaces parameterized by the projective line @xmath31 .
this is in accordance with results of rudakov and shafarevich @xcite and ogus @xcite on the moduli of marked supersingular k3 surfaces .
the paper is organized as follows : section [ generalities ] discusses the interplay between restricted lie algebras and infinitesimal group schemes of height @xmath32 , in particular @xmath33 .
section [ quotients ] contains some results on the behavior of quotients with respect to base change and singularities . in section [ cuspidal ]
we examine the rational cuspidal curve @xmath12 in characteristic two , determine its restricted lie algebra , and read off all possible @xmath14-actions . in section [ selfproduct ]
, we consider the selfproduct @xmath15 , define @xmath14-actions on it , and establish some basic properties .
this is refined in the following two sections , where we determine the structure of singularities on the quotient @xmath16 .
i return to global properties of @xmath34 in section [ quasielliptic ] , where we analyse quasielliptic fibrations . in section [ k3 ]
we turn to the the resolution of singularities @xmath6 , and establish that it is a supersingular k3 surface provided that the parameters do not vanish simultaneously . in section [ discriminants ] , we determine the artin invariant . here
we crucially use the structure of the singularities and the quasielliptic fibration .
sections [ blowing ] contains some material on blowing up rational surface singularities along curves .
we use this in section [ genus ] , where we consider blowing ups of weil divisors in genus - one fibrations .
this is crucial in section [ simultaneous ] , where we view our normal k3 surfaces as lying in a family @xmath25 , and show that this family admits a simultaneous resolution @xmath35 after a purely inseparable base change @xmath29 . in the last section we show that this family is induced from a family @xmath36 .
i wish to thank torsten ekedahl and nick shepherd - barron for helpful discussion .
they pointed out to me the necessity of purely inseparable base change to obtain simultaneous resolution of singularities .
i also thank otto kerner for helpful discussions on restricted lie algebras , eckart viehweg for discussions on moduli spaces , and le van schrer for magma programming and careful proofreading .
moreover , i wish to thank the referee for writing a thorough report and for pointing out some mistakes .
[ generalities ] let @xmath37 be a ground field of characteristic @xmath19 . then there is a group scheme @xmath33 whose values on @xmath37-algebras @xmath38 are @xmath39 , with addition as group law . as a scheme , we have @xmath40/(t^p)$ ] , which is finite and infinitesimal .
such group schemes exist only in characteristic @xmath19 ; it is frequently possible to explain characteristic-@xmath41-phenomena in terms of @xmath33-actions . in this section
i collect some well - known facts on finite infinitesimal group schemes , and in particular on @xmath33 .
proofs are omitted .
the book of demazure and gabriel @xcite is an exhaustive reference .
the lie algebra @xmath42)$ ] is the 1-dimensional vector space @xmath43 $ ] .
the generator @xmath44 corresponds to the derivation @xmath45/(t^p){\rightarrow}k$ ] given by the kronecker delta @xmath46 .
the interpretation @xmath47/(t^p),k)$ ] shows that both the lie bracket @xmath48=d\circ d'-d'\circ d$ ] and the @xmath41-th power operation @xmath49}=d\circ\ldots\circ d$ ] ( @xmath41-fold composition ) vanish . in other words
, @xmath50 is a restricted lie algebra whose lie bracket and @xmath41-map both vanish .
recall that a _ restricted lie algebra _ over @xmath37 is a lie algebra @xmath51 endowed with a @xmath41-map @xmath52 , @xmath53}$ ] ( sometimes restricted lie algebras are also called _ @xmath41-lie algebras _ ) . by definition , @xmath41-maps
satisfy three axioms .
the first axiom relates them with scalar multiplication : @xmath54 } = \lambda^p x^{[p ] } \quad\text{for all $ \lambda\in k$ , $ x\in { \mathfrak{g}}$}.\ ] ] the second axiom relates @xmath41-maps with lie brackets : @xmath55},y]=[x,[x,[\ldots,[x , y ] ] ] ] \quad\text{for all $ x , y\in{\mathfrak{g}}$},\ ] ] where the right - hand side is a @xmath41-fold iterated lie bracket .
the third axiom relates @xmath41-maps to addition : @xmath56}=x^{[p ] } + \lambda_p(x , y ) + y^{[p ] } \quad\text{for all $ x , y\in { \mathfrak{g}}$},\ ] ] where @xmath57 is a universal expression in terms of iterated lie brackets due to jacobson . rather than explaining this tricky matter , i refer to @xcite , chapter ii , section 7.2 .
note , however , that in characteristic @xmath8 things simplify and we have @xmath58}=x^{[2 ] } - [ x , y ] + y^{[2]}$ ] .
the group scheme @xmath33 is entirely determined by its restricted lie algebra @xmath50 .
this correspondence works , more generally , for finite infinitesimal group schemes @xmath59 of height @xmath32 .
let me recall the basic steps in this correspondence .
if @xmath60 is the restricted lie algebra , one may interpret the restricted universal enveloping algebra @xmath61}({\mathfrak{g}})$ ] as the _ algebra of distributions _ on @xmath59 at the neutral element @xmath62 , and its @xmath37-linear dual @xmath61}({\mathfrak{g}})^\vee$ ] as the _ algebra of functions _ on @xmath59 .
in particular , we have @xmath63}({\mathfrak{g}})^\vee).\ ] ] here the diagonal map @xmath64 induces the multiplication in @xmath61}({\mathfrak{g}})^\vee$ ] .
recall that @xmath61}({\mathfrak{g}})$ ] is the quotient of the universal enveloping algebra @xmath65 modulo the ideal generated by the elements @xmath66}$ ] with @xmath67 . from this discussion
it follows that the canonical map @xmath68 is bijective for all group schemes @xmath69 , where @xmath70 .
now consider the special case that @xmath71 for some @xmath37-scheme @xmath34 , such that @xmath72 .
then the set of @xmath59-actions on @xmath34 is in correspondence to the set of homomorphisms @xmath73 of restricted lie algebras .
indeed , such a homomorphism of restricted lie algebras induces a homomorphism of @xmath37-algebras @xmath61}({\mathfrak{g}}){\rightarrow}{\operatorname{diff}}({\mathcal{o}}_y,{\mathcal{o}}_y)$ ] into the algebra of differential operators , and the adjoint map @xmath74}({\mathfrak{g}})^\vee$ ] then defines the desired action @xmath75 . in the case
@xmath76 , the preceding discussion simplifies as follows . to give a homomorphism of group schemes
@xmath77 is nothing but to give a vector @xmath78 with @xmath79}=0 $ ] , by setting @xmath80 . as a special case we have @xmath81 and @xmath82 .
if we change the vector @xmath83 by a nonzero factor @xmath84 , we only compose the homomorphism @xmath77 with an automorphism of @xmath33 , but do not change its image .
note that the subset @xmath85}=0\right\}\subset { \operatorname{lie}}(h)\ ] ] is a cone , but in general not a subgroup .
it follows that the space of nonzero homomorphisms @xmath77 may have several connected components .
for later use we record : [ action vector ] let @xmath34 be a @xmath37-scheme . then there is a bijection between the set of @xmath33-actions on @xmath34 and the vectors @xmath86 with @xmath79}=0 $ ] .
it is worthwile to see this correspondence explicitly : write @xmath87/(t^p)$ ] and @xmath88 , where @xmath46 is given by the kronecker delta .
the restricted universal enveloping algebra is the truncated polynomial algebra @xmath61}({\mathfrak{g}})=k[\partial]/(\partial^p)$ ] .
the monomials @xmath89 with @xmath90 form a basis in @xmath61}({\mathfrak{g}})$ ] . its dual basis in @xmath61}({\mathfrak{g}})^\vee$ ]
are the divided powers @xmath91 . now suppose we have a vector field @xmath86 with @xmath79}=0 $ ] . then the corresponding @xmath33-action on @xmath34 is given by the formula @xmath92}({\mathfrak{g}})^\vee,\quad
f\longmapsto \sum_{i=0}^{p-1}\frac{\delta^i(f)}{i!}\otimes t^i.\ ] ] note that the formula involves differential operators @xmath93 , @xmath94 , which are in general not derivations . for @xmath8
, however , the situation simplifies a lot , for we just have @xmath95 .
using formula ( [ action formula ] ) , it is now easy to understand invariant or fixed subschemes : let @xmath96 be a closed subscheme with ideal @xmath97 .
it follows from formula ( [ action formula ] ) that @xmath3 is _ invariant _ if and only if @xmath98 , or equivalently that the composition @xmath99 is zero .
the schematic image @xmath100 of the morphism @xmath101 is called the _ orbit _ of @xmath3 .
its ideal @xmath102 is the intersection of the kernels for the @xmath37-linear maps @xmath103 for @xmath104 , again by formula ( [ action formula ] ) .
for @xmath8 we simply have @xmath105 .
the induced action on an invariant closed subscheme @xmath96 is trivial if and only if @xmath106 .
equivalently , the composite map @xmath107 vanishes .
in particular , a closed point @xmath108 with maximal ideal @xmath109 is a _ fixed point _ if and only if @xmath110 . the fixed closed subsets correspond to the quasicoherent ideals containing the abelian subsheaf @xmath111 .
[ quotients ] we keep the situation as in the preceding section .
let @xmath86 be a vector field with @xmath79}=0 $ ] , which defines an @xmath33-action on @xmath34 .
in this section we discuss quotients and their properties . according to @xcite ,
chapter iii , proposition 3.2 quotients by finite infinitesimal group schemes always exist .
for @xmath33 this works as follows : the underlying topological space for @xmath112 is homeomorphic to @xmath34 , so that the quotient map @xmath113 is a homeomorphism , and the structure sheaf @xmath114 is the kernel of the derivation @xmath115 .
if @xmath34 is of finite type over @xmath37 , so is @xmath9 , and the morphism @xmath113 is finite . in any case
, this morphism is integral . from this
it follows that there is a unique maximal fixed closed subset @xmath116 , which is called the _
fixed scheme_. its ideal is the quasicoherent ideal that is locally generated by the abelian subsheaf @xmath111 . if there are no fixed points , then @xmath113 is an @xmath33-torsor in the fppf - topology , by @xcite , chapter iii , proposition 3.2 . in particular
, @xmath113 is flat of degree @xmath41 , with geometric fibers isomorphic to the spectrum of @xmath117/(t^p)$ ] .
we now discuss singular and nonsmooth points on the quotient .
let @xmath108 be a point , and @xmath118 be its image .
we assume that @xmath34 and hence @xmath9 are of finite type over @xmath37 .
the following two results are very useful in determining the nonsmooth locus on the quotients @xmath9 .
[ isolated fixed ] suppose that @xmath34 is of dimension @xmath119 and satisfies serre s condition @xmath120 .
let @xmath108 be an isolated fixed point .
then @xmath9 is not smooth near @xmath118 .
the problem is local in @xmath9 . seeking a contradiction
, we assume that @xmath9 is affine and smooth , and that @xmath121 is the only fixed point . set @xmath122 and @xmath123 .
then the quotient morphism @xmath113 induces an @xmath33-torsor @xmath124 . according to ekedahl s purity result @xcite , proposition 1.4
, this @xmath33-torsor extends to an @xmath33-torsor @xmath125 . by assumption
, @xmath34 satisfies serre s condition @xmath120 , and @xmath126 is obviously cohen macaulay .
it follows that both restriction maps @xmath127 and @xmath128 are bijective , which implies @xmath129 .
the maps @xmath130/(t^p)$ ] and @xmath131/(t^p)$ ] defining the @xmath33-actions are uniquely determined by their restriction @xmath132 .
it follows that the action on @xmath34 is free , contradiction . over nonperfect ground fields
@xmath37 , one has to distinguish regularity and geometric regularity (= formal smoothness ) .
i do not know if , in the preceding situation , the quotient @xmath9 could be regular .
the next lemma deals with regularity rather then smoothness .
[ projective dimension ] suppose @xmath108 is not a fixed point .
let @xmath133 be the ideal of the orbit @xmath134 .
then @xmath135 is regular if and only if the ideal @xmath136 has finite projective dimension . in this case , @xmath137 is generated by @xmath138 elements .
the problem is local in @xmath9 , so we may assume that @xmath9 is affine and that @xmath113 is an @xmath33-torsor .
suppose first that @xmath135 is regular .
then the maximal ideal @xmath139 has finite projective dimension , and is generated by @xmath140 elements .
the exact sequence @xmath141 induces by flatness an exact sequence @xmath142 hence @xmath143 . using flatness again
, we infer that @xmath137 has finite projective dimension and is generated by @xmath140 elements .
suppose conversely @xmath137 has finite projective dimension , say @xmath144 .
choose a resolution @xmath145 with @xmath146 free and finitely generated . pulling back ,
we obtain an exact sequence @xmath147 by hilbert s syzygy theorem , @xmath148 is free .
it follows from descent theory that already @xmath149 must be free ( @xcite , expos vii , corollary 1.11 ) .
hence @xmath150 , so the local ring @xmath135 is regular .
this gives a handy criterion in terms on embedding dimensions on @xmath34 for singularities on @xmath9 : [ embedding criterion ] suppose that @xmath108 is a rational point that is not fixed , with @xmath151 .
then the local ring @xmath135 is not regular .
let @xmath152 be the maximal ideal of @xmath108 , and @xmath153 be the ideal for its orbit .
then we have a short exact sequence @xmath154 , where the quotient @xmath155 is a @xmath37-vector space of dimension @xmath156 .
tensoring with @xmath37 gives an exact sequence @xmath157 whatever the contribution from the tor terms on the left , the @xmath37-vector space @xmath158 has dimension @xmath159 . by the nakayama lemma
, it is impossible to generate @xmath160 with @xmath138 elements . according to proposition [ projective dimension ]
, the local ring @xmath135 must be singular .
provided that the group scheme action is free , the scheme @xmath34 satisfies serre s condition @xmath161 if and only if the quotient @xmath9 satisfies @xmath161 , by @xcite , corollary 6.4.2 . for nonfree action , we at least have the following : [ serre condition ] suppose that @xmath34 satisfies serre s condition @xmath120
. then the quotient @xmath112 satisfies serre s condition @xmath120 as well .
we may assume that @xmath9 is affine .
let @xmath162 be an open subset whose complement has codimension @xmath119 .
we have to check that the restriction map @xmath163 is bijective .
injectivity is clear , because @xmath164 contains no torsion sections . as to surjectivity , suppose @xmath165 . by assumption
, it extends to a section @xmath166 .
the section @xmath167 vanishes on @xmath168 , hence vanishes everywhere , whence @xmath169 is a section for @xmath114 extending @xmath170 .
the following result on dualizing sheaves on quotients is useful in constructing calabi
yau quotients ; we shall use it in section [ k3 ] .
[ dualizing quotient ] suppose that @xmath34 is gorenstein with @xmath171 , that the fixed scheme @xmath172 is empty , and that @xmath173
. then @xmath9 is gorenstein with @xmath174 .
the morphism @xmath175 is flat with gorenstein fibers , because the group scheme action is free .
hence @xmath176 is invertible . by assumption ,
the dualizing sheaf @xmath177 is invertible .
using descent theory , we infer that @xmath178 is invertible , that is , @xmath9 is gorenstein .
we next check that @xmath176 is trivial .
let @xmath179 be the ideal of the diagonal .
the group scheme action is free by assumption , hence @xmath180 .
it follows that @xmath181 as @xmath182-module . according to kunz @xcite , page 363
there is a canonical map @xmath183 , which is bijective .
the term on the right is the dual of @xmath176 , which therefore is trivial .
it remains to check that the preimage map @xmath184 is injective .
for this we may assume that our ground field @xmath37 is algebraically closed .
jensen showed in @xcite , section 2 that we have an exact sequence @xmath185 of group - valued functors . here
@xmath186 is the cartier dual , which in our case is uncanonically isomorphic to @xmath33 , hence contains no point but the origin .
note that jensen assumed that @xmath34 is proper , but his arguments go through with the weaker assumption @xmath173 .
we infer that @xmath184 is injective , and hence @xmath174 .
we next discuss base - change properties for quotients .
suppose that @xmath34 is endowed with a morphism @xmath187 onto some affine @xmath37-scheme , and that our derivation @xmath83 lies in @xmath188 .
then the group scheme action @xmath189 is an @xmath38-morphism , and the quotient @xmath9 is an @xmath38-scheme .
the following base - change property is standard : [ base free ] the formation of @xmath112 commutes with flat base change in @xmath38 .
if the fixed scheme @xmath172 is empty , it commutes with arbitrary base change in @xmath38 .
consider the exact sequence of quasicoherent @xmath114-modules @xmath190 on @xmath9 . given a flat @xmath38-algebra @xmath191
, we obtain another exact sequence by applying @xmath192 , so taking the quotient commutes with flat base change .
now suppose our action is free .
the inclusion @xmath193 remains injective after tensoring with @xmath194 for all @xmath118 , because @xmath195 .
since the @xmath33-action is free , the quasicoherent @xmath114-module @xmath182 is locally free of rank @xmath41 . shrinking @xmath9
, we may assume that the inclusion admits a splitting , hence the the exact sequence ( [ base change ] ) remains exact after tensoring with arbitrary @xmath38-algebras @xmath191 .
for the geometric constructions i have in mind , it is crucial to work with group actions with fixed points .
i see no reason why the base - change property should hold in general . to discuss this problem ,
suppose for simplicity that @xmath196 is affine , such that @xmath197 , where @xmath198 is defined by the exact sequence @xmath199 the issue is as follows : [ flatness discussion ] suppose that @xmath34 is @xmath38-flat
. then the quotient @xmath9 is @xmath38-flat if and only if the @xmath38-module @xmath200 has flat dimension @xmath201 . the formation of @xmath112 commutes with arbitrary base change in @xmath38 if and only if @xmath200 is @xmath38-flat . by assumption ,
the @xmath38-module @xmath3 is flat .
the exact sequence ( [ flat sequence ] ) gives @xmath202 for flat dimensions , hence the first assertion .
for the second assertion , let @xmath191 be an @xmath38-algebra , and consider the induced sequence @xmath203 suppose that @xmath200 is flat .
then the exact sequence ( [ flat sequence ] ) is a flat resolution , so the preceding sequence remains exact , which means that the formation of the quotient commutes with base change .
conversely , suppose the preceding sequence stays exact for all @xmath191 .
then @xmath204 , whence @xmath200 is flat .
let me record the following consequence : [ 2-dimensional flat ] suppose that @xmath205 $ ] is a polynomial ring in two variables
. then @xmath206 is flat .
the ring @xmath205 $ ] has homological dimension @xmath207 , hence also tor - dimension @xmath208 ( confer @xcite , section 4.1 ) .
hence @xmath200 has projective dimension @xmath201 , so proposition [ flatness discussion ] applies .
we shall use the following base - change - property in section [ selfproduct ] , which i formulate for a rather special situation : suppose that @xmath8 and @xmath209 $ ] is a polynomial algebra in two variables
. then we have @xmath210 for some @xmath211 $ ] , where @xmath212 and @xmath213 .
[ 2-dimensional change ] in the preceding situation , suppose that @xmath211 $ ] are monic polynomials .
then the formation of @xmath16 commutes with arbitrary base change in @xmath38 .
we check that @xmath200 is a free @xmath38-module .
all terms in the exact sequence ( [ flat sequence ] ) are modules over @xmath214 $ ] , because the derivation @xmath83 is @xmath215-linear .
moreover , @xmath3 is a free @xmath215-module of rank four , with basis @xmath216 .
the matrix of @xmath83 with respect to this basis is @xmath217 hence @xmath218 .
the first summand is a free @xmath38-modules , because @xmath219 are monic , and the last summand is obviously free .
the middle summand sits in an exact sequence @xmath220 hence is a free @xmath38-module as well .
[ cuspidal ] let @xmath37 be a ground field of characteristic @xmath8 , and @xmath12 be the cuspidal curve of arithmetic genus @xmath221 . to be explicit , we choose an indeterminate @xmath222 and write @xmath223 \;\cup\
; { \operatorname{spec}}k[u^{-1}].\ ] ] the goal of this section is to determine the restricted lie algebra of @xmath224 and read off all possible @xmath14-actions on @xmath12 .
this extends results of bombieri and mumford ( @xcite , proposition 6 ) , who already studied @xmath224 in connection with quasielliptic fibrations in the enriques classification of surfaces .
i start by describing the lie algebra @xmath225 in lie - theoretic terms without referring to geometry : let @xmath226 be the 3-dimensional restricted lie algebra over @xmath37 with trivial lie brackets @xmath227=0 $ ] and trivial @xmath41-map @xmath228}=0 $ ] .
let @xmath229 be the 1-dimensional restricted lie algebra endowed with a generator @xmath230 with @xmath231}=b$ ] .
any linear endomorphism of @xmath226 is a derivation , because @xmath226 is commutative .
the linear map @xmath232 , @xmath233 commutes with lie brackets . as explained in @xcite , 1.7 this homomorphism yields a semidirect product lie algebra @xmath234 , whose lie bracket is @xmath235=\lambda a'-\lambda ' a.\ ] ] we remark in passing that the ideal @xmath236 is the _ derived ideal _
@xmath237 $ ] , whence @xmath238 and @xmath51 is solvable . on the other hand , @xmath51 has trivial center , so @xmath51 it is not nilpotent . [ unique restricted ]
there is precisely one @xmath41-map on the semidirect product lie algebra @xmath234 such that the canonical inclusions @xmath239 are restricted inclusions .
if it exists , the @xmath41-map for @xmath51 is uniquely determined : for @xmath8 the axioms for @xmath41-maps give @xmath58}=x^{[2]}+y^{[2 ] } - [ x , y]$ ] .
therefore the @xmath41-map in our semidirect product must be @xmath240}=a^{[2 ] } + ( \lambda b)^{[2 ] } + [ a,\lambda b ] = \lambda ( a+\lambda b).\ ] ] it remains to check that this meets the remaining two axioms for @xmath41-maps .
indeed , given any scalar @xmath241 , we obviously have @xmath242}=\mu\lambda(\mu(a+\lambda b ) ) = \mu^2(a+\lambda b)^{[2]}.\ ] ] moreover , we easily compute @xmath243},a'+\lambda'b ] = [ \lambda a+\lambda^2b , a'+\lambda'b ] = \lambda^2a'+\lambda\lambda'a,\ ] ] which equals @xmath244=[a+\lambda
b,\lambda a'+\lambda ' a ] = \lambda(\lambda a'+\lambda'a).\ ] ] hence formula ( [ power map ] ) indeed defines a @xmath41-map .
the book of strade and farnsteiner @xcite contains more information on the existence of @xmath41-maps in lie algebras .
we now come back to our cuspidal curve @xmath12 of arithmetic genus one : the restricted lie algebras @xmath245 and @xmath234 are isomorphic .
consider the two affine open subsets @xmath246 $ ] and @xmath247 $ ] .
the only relation between the generators @xmath248 on @xmath132 is the obvious one , namely @xmath249 .
whence @xmath250 is generated by the differentials @xmath251 modulo the relation @xmath252 . since @xmath253 is torsion free , the dual @xmath254 is a free @xmath255-module of rank one , generated by the form @xmath256 .
on the overlap @xmath257 , this form becomes @xmath258 , where @xmath259 is taking derivative with respect to @xmath222 .
we shall use the same symbol @xmath258 to denote this form on @xmath132 , although the two individual factors @xmath260 and @xmath261 do not make sense on @xmath132 .
the affine open subset @xmath168 is smooth . here
@xmath262 is free of rank one , generated by the differential @xmath263 .
the dual @xmath264 is free of rank one as well , generated by the form @xmath265 .
on the overlap @xmath257 we have @xmath266 , so our form becomes @xmath267 . from this
we infer that the lie algebra @xmath268 is a @xmath37-vector space of rank 4 , with basis @xmath269 let @xmath270 be the subspace generated by the derivations with even coefficients , that is , @xmath271 . then one easily computes that both lie bracket and @xmath41-map vanish on @xmath226 .
moreover , we have @xmath272=u^{2i}d_u$ ] for all integers @xmath273 .
whence @xmath270 is the derived lie algebra for @xmath274 .
the resulting extension of lie algebras @xmath275 splits , because @xmath229 is 1-dimensional .
the element @xmath276 defines a splitting , and we have @xmath277}=ud_u$ ] .
we now regard @xmath274 as a semidirect product .
any such semidirect product is given by a homomorphism @xmath232 . in our case
, this map sends the generator @xmath278 to the identity @xmath279 .
it follows that @xmath268 and @xmath234 are isomorphic as lie algebras . by lemma
[ unique restricted ] , they also have the same @xmath41-maps .
our algebraic computations translate into the following geometric statement : [ parameter space ] the set of @xmath14-operations on the cuspidal curve @xmath12 of arithmetic genus one is parameterized by the affine space @xmath280 .
according to proposition [ action vector ] , the set in question is the set of all @xmath281 with @xmath282}=0 $ ] . by formula ( [ power map ] ) , each vector @xmath283 from the derived ideal @xmath236 has this property . on the other hand , each vector @xmath284 with @xmath285
has @xmath282}=\lambda(a+\lambda b)\neq 0 $ ] .
[ selfproduct ] let @xmath12 be the cuspidal curve of arithmetic genus one over a ground field @xmath37 of characteristic @xmath8 , as in the preceding section .
throughout we consider the selfproduct @xmath15 , which is a nonnormal integral proper surface with unibranch singularities and normalization @xmath286 .
we shall use coordinates @xmath287 on the first factor of @xmath288 , and coordinates @xmath289 on the second factor : @xmath223 \cup { \operatorname{spec}}k[u^{-1 } ] { \quad\text{and}\quad}c={\operatorname{spec}}k[v^2,v^3 ] \cup { \operatorname{spec}}k[v^{-1}].\ ] ] i want to define @xmath14-actions on @xmath15 depending on two parameters @xmath290 . in the following
, we have to allow parameters from various parameter rings ( for example fields , dual numbers , polynomial rings and so forth ) . to unify notation , let us fix a @xmath37-scheme @xmath291 and two global sections @xmath292 , and consider the scheme @xmath293 viewed as a proper flat family of surfaces over @xmath291 .
the derivation @xmath294 defines a global vector field @xmath295 .
a straightforward computation shows that @xmath296 .
hence @xmath83 defines an @xmath297-action on @xmath298 over @xmath291 .
let us first examine the fixed scheme for this action .
[ fixed scheme ] the fixed scheme @xmath299 is contained in the open subset @xmath300\subset y\times s$ ] , and its ideal is generated by the two elements @xmath301 and @xmath302 .
the ideal @xmath303 generated by the image of the derivation @xmath83 defines the fixed scheme in question . since @xmath304
, we have @xmath305 for all points @xmath306 outside @xmath300 $ ] . over @xmath300
$ ] , we compute @xmath307 and the result follows .
we see that the geometric fibers of @xmath308 contain precisely four fixed points over the open subset @xmath309 .
these fixed points come together in pairs over the closed subsets @xmath310 and @xmath311 . on the intersection @xmath312 ,
precisely one fixed point remains .
next , we examine the quotient scheme @xmath313 with respect to the @xmath14-action on the product family @xmath298 . here
i use the fracture letter @xmath314 , to emphasize that the resulting morphism @xmath25 usually is not a product family ( this has nothing to do with formal schemes ) .
[ flatness change ] the resulting morphism @xmath25 is flat and commutes with arbitrary base change in @xmath291 .
we first check the base - change property . by proposition [ base free ]
, the base - change property holds outside the fixed points . in light of corollary [ 2-dimensional change ] and formula ( [ inverse derivation ] ) , the base - change property holds near the fixed points as well . to check flatness , it therefore suffice to treat the universal situation @xmath315 $ ] , and then flatness holds by corollary [ 2-dimensional flat ] . throughout the paper , we shall frequently pass back and forth between the family @xmath25 and its fibers @xmath316 , @xmath317 .
we just saw that the fiber @xmath316 is also the quotient of @xmath318 by the induced @xmath14-action . to simplify notation ,
we usually write @xmath319 to denote fibers ; making base change , we then usually assume that @xmath291 is the spectrum of our ground field @xmath37 and write @xmath320 .
[ family normal ] the fibers @xmath319 of the flat family @xmath25 are normal .
we may assume that @xmath321 and that @xmath37 is algebraically closed . by proposition [ serre condition ] , the surface @xmath9 is cohen macaulay .
it remains to check that it is regular in codimension one .
for this we may ignore the fixed points , which are isolated by proposition [ fixed scheme ] .
let @xmath322 be the regular locus minus the fixed locus ; by proposition [ projective dimension ] , the quotient @xmath9 is regular on the image of @xmath132 .
to finish the argument , let @xmath108 be a singular point defined by the maximal ideal @xmath323 for some @xmath84 with @xmath324 .
then the ideal @xmath325 is @xmath83-invariant , whence the spectrum of @xmath326/(u^6)$ ] must be the orbit of @xmath121 . clearly , the ideal @xmath137 has finite projective dimension , whence @xmath9 is regular at the image of @xmath121 . summing up , @xmath9 is regular in codimension one . in light of proposition
[ isolated fixed ] , the four fixed points on @xmath34 contribute to the singular points @xmath118 .
it turns out that these singularities are _ geometrically _ isomorphic , because the automorphism group scheme @xmath327 acts transitively on them . more precisely : [ automorphism group ]
assume that @xmath321 , and that @xmath328 are squares .
let @xmath329 be fixed points , and @xmath330 be the corresponding singular points .
then there are automorphisms @xmath331 with @xmath332 and @xmath333 with @xmath334 such that the diagram @xmath335 commutes . in case @xmath336 , there is precisely one fixed point @xmath108 , and we have nothing to prove .
suppose @xmath337 .
let @xmath331 be the involution defined by @xmath338 .
it is easy to see that the corresponding @xmath13-action commutes with the @xmath14-action on @xmath34 .
it therefore descends to an involution @xmath333 .
now suppose that @xmath339 .
then we have similar involutions on @xmath34 and @xmath9 induced by @xmath340
. obviously , the subgroup generated by these involutions acts transitively on the set of singularities on @xmath9 coming from fixed points on @xmath34 .
[ singularity ] we keep the notation from the preceding section , but we assume for simplicity that our parameter space @xmath341 is affine . recall that @xmath342 , and @xmath343 is the quotient by the @xmath14-action defined by the vector field @xmath344 with parameters @xmath345 . set @xmath346 $ ] , and let @xmath347 be the kernel of the derivation @xmath348 .
then @xmath349 is an affine open neighborhood containing fiberwise the point of embedding dimension four , which is defined by the ideal @xmath350 , and @xmath351 is an affine open neighborhood containing fiberwise the corresponding singularities . [ invariants embedding ] we have @xmath352 $ ] as @xmath38-subalgebras inside @xmath3 . in light of proposition [ flatness change ] , we may assume that @xmath205 $ ] is a polynomial algebra in two variables .
consider the @xmath37-subalgebra @xmath353 $ ] inside @xmath3 .
obviously , we have @xmath354 .
moreover , @xmath3 is a free @xmath215-module of rank four , with basis @xmath355 . given @xmath356 ,
we compute @xmath357 suppose this expression vanishes .
comparing coefficients , we see @xmath358 and hence @xmath359 . using the factoriality of @xmath215
, we infer that @xmath360 and @xmath361 are multiples of @xmath362 and @xmath363 , respectively . hence @xmath364 $ ] .
the invariant subring @xmath347 also admits a simple description as a quotient ring : [ quotient embedding ] we have @xmath365/(c^2 + a^3+b^3 + s^2a^3 b^2 + r^2a^2b^3)$ ] .
it suffices to treat the universal situation @xmath205 $ ] . in particular
, we may assume that @xmath38 is noetherian .
set @xmath366/(c^2 + a^3+b^3 + s^2a^3 b^2 + r^2a^2b^3)$ ] .
the mapping @xmath367 clearly induces a surjective homomorphism @xmath368 . to see that it is also injective , it suffices to treat the case @xmath369 , by the nakayama lemma . being a complete intersection , the ring @xmath370 is cohen macaulay .
a straightforward computation of @xmath371 reveals that the singular locus on @xmath372 is 0-dimensional .
it follows that the 2-dimensional ring @xmath370 is integral .
being a surjection between integral 2-dimensional rings @xmath368 , the map in question is bijective .
let me now recall some facts from singularity theory .
suppose @xmath373 is a local noetherian ring that is normal , 2-dimensional , with resolution of singularities @xmath374 .
one says that @xmath375 is a _ rational double point _ if @xmath376 and @xmath377 .
each rational singularity comes along with an _ irreducible root systems _ , which are classified by dynkin diagrams .
this goes as follows : let @xmath378 be the reduced exceptional divisor , @xmath379 be its integral components , and @xmath168 the real vector space generated by the @xmath380 endowed with the scalar product @xmath381 .
then the vectors @xmath382 form a root basis for an irreducible root system . note that in characteristic @xmath383 there are nonisomorphic rational double points with the same root system , as artin observed in @xcite .
when the residue field @xmath37 is algebraically closed , only dynkin diagrams of type @xmath384 appear , which are precisely dynkin diagrams with equal root lengths .
such dynkin diagrams are also called _
simply laced_. when @xmath37 is not algebraically closed , dynkin diagrams with unequal root lengths show up as well .
this means that some field extensions @xmath385 are nontrivial .
the degree of the field extensions are determined by the cartan numbers .
now suppose that the parameter ring @xmath38 is our ground field @xmath37 , and let @xmath118 be the singularity defined by the maximal ideal @xmath386 , which corresponds to the closed point @xmath108 defined by the maximal ideal @xmath350 , which is the unique point of embedding dimension four .
[ d4 b3 ] the local ring @xmath135 is a rational double point .
it is of type @xmath0 if the ground field @xmath37 contains a third root of unity , and of type @xmath17 otherwise .
figure : the dynkin diagrams @xmath0 and @xmath17 .
if the ground field @xmath37 is algebraically closed , it suffices to check for the defining equation @xmath387 in one of the available lists of normal forms for rational double points in characteristic two ( see artin @xcite or greuel and krning @xcite ) . to recheck this , and to cover arbitrary ground fields as well ,
let us do the blowing up @xmath388 of the ideal @xmath386 .
the scheme @xmath389 is covered by two affine open subsets @xmath390 .
the first one is the spectrum of @xmath391 $ ] , where we set @xmath392 and @xmath393 , modulo the relation @xmath394 a computation with differentials reveals that the reduced locus of nonsmoothness on @xmath395 lying on the exceptional divisor has ideal @xmath396 .
now suppose that the ground field @xmath37 contains a third root of unity @xmath397 .
then @xmath398 , hence @xmath395 contains three singularities , each with residue field @xmath37 , and a straightforward computation shows that these are rational double points of type @xmath2 . by symmetry
, the other open subset @xmath399 does not contribute any further singularities .
from this we infer that @xmath135 is a rational double point of type @xmath0 .
finally , suppose that @xmath37 does not contain a third root of unity .
then we have an irreducible decomposition @xmath400 , hence @xmath395 contains two singularities .
again we easily see that each one is of type @xmath2 , but one has residue field @xmath37 , and the other has residue field isomorphic to the splitting field of @xmath401 .
if follows that @xmath135 is a rational double point of type @xmath17 . finally , suppose that @xmath38 is a @xmath37-algebra with residue field @xmath37 , and set @xmath402 and @xmath403 .
we now view the @xmath38-algebra @xmath198 as a deformation of the @xmath404-algebra @xmath405 . to understand this deformation near the singularity @xmath406
, we have to pass the completion @xmath407/(c^2+a^3+b^3+s^2a^3b^2+r^2a^2b^3)$ ] .
it turns out that this deformation is trivial : [ trivial deformation ] the deformation @xmath408 is isomorphic to the trivial deformation @xmath409 .
set @xmath410 , and suppose we have a power series @xmath411 .
we will show that there is an automorphism @xmath412 of @xmath413 $ ] with @xmath414 , which clearly implies the assertion .
write @xmath415 with @xmath416 , and @xmath417 , and @xmath418 .
consider the nonzero monomials in @xmath419 with minimal total degree @xmath420 , and pick among them the monomial @xmath421 with minimal @xmath283-degree @xmath422 .
suppose for the moment @xmath423 .
then @xmath424 defines an automorphism @xmath425 of @xmath413 $ ] .
we have @xmath426 and the last two summands have total degree @xmath427 . a similar computation of @xmath428
, @xmath429 gives that @xmath430 lies in @xmath431 , and that @xmath432 has only monomials of total degree @xmath427 , or of total degree @xmath433 and @xmath283-degree @xmath434 . in the case @xmath435 , we have @xmath436 , and we may apply the preceding arguments with @xmath437 instead of @xmath283 . proceeding by induction , we see that we obtain the desired automorphism @xmath412 in the form @xmath438 , @xmath439 for certain inductively determined coefficients @xmath440 .
according to @xcite , there are two isomorphism classes of rational double points of type @xmath0 , which are called @xmath441 and @xmath442 .
the upper index has to do with the versal deformation : the smaller the upper index , the larger the dimension of the versal deformation .
the preceding arguments show that our singularity is of type @xmath441 .
[ singularities ] our next goal is to analyse the singularities on @xmath343 coming from the fixed points on @xmath443 for the @xmath14-action . in this section
, we set @xmath444 $ ] and define @xmath347 to be the kernel of the derivation @xmath348 .
then @xmath349 is an affine open neighborhood for the fixed points , and @xmath351 is an affine open neighborhood for singularities coming from fixed points . [ invariants fixed ] we have @xmath445 $ ] as subalgebras inside @xmath3 .
fiberwise over @xmath38 , the @xmath198-module @xmath3 is reflexive of rank two , but not locally free .
the arguments for the first statement are as in the proof for proposition [ invariants embedding ] , and left to the reader . for the second statement
, we may assume that @xmath369 . according to @xcite , section iv , proposition 11 , the @xmath198-module @xmath3 is cohen macaulay .
hence it must be reflexive .
consider the maximal ideal @xmath446 inside @xmath198 .
we have @xmath447/(u^{-2},v^{-2 } ) , $ ] which has length four instead of two .
it follows that @xmath3 is not locally free as @xmath198-module . setting @xmath448 and @xmath449 and @xmath450
, we obtain as in proposition [ quotient embedding ] the following description of @xmath198 as a complete intersection : [ quotient fixed ] we have @xmath365/(c^2+a(b^4+s^2b^2 ) + b(a^4+r^2a^2))$ ] . in what follows ,
we assume @xmath369 and write @xmath320 .
let @xmath118 be the rational point defined by the ideal @xmath451 , which is the image of a fixed point on @xmath34 .
we want to understand the singularity @xmath135 .
note that if the ground field @xmath37 is perfect , the other singularities on @xmath9 corresponding to the fixed points on @xmath34 are isomorphic to @xmath118 , by proposition [ automorphism group ] . for our purposes
it therefore suffices to understand @xmath135 .
we first treat the generic case : [ d4 ] suppose the parameters @xmath328 are both nonzero .
then the local ring @xmath135 is a rational double point of type @xmath0 . to see this
, one has to make an explicit blowing up @xmath452 of the ideal @xmath453 as in the proof for proposition [ d4 b3 ] .
we leave this for the reader and immediately turn to the more interesting case where one of the parameters @xmath290 degenerates : [ d8 ] suppose precisely one of the parameters @xmath328 vanishes . then the local ring @xmath135 is a rational double point of type @xmath1 .
figure : the dynkin diagram @xmath1 .
we may assume @xmath454 .
then the defining equation is @xmath455 with @xmath337 .
we view the corresponding affine scheme as a double covering of the affine plane @xmath456 $ ] . to produce a resolution for @xmath135
we compute a blowing - up @xmath457 $ ] so that the reduced transform of the equation @xmath458 defines a divisor with normal crossings .
it turns out that , if @xmath459 denotes a local equation for this normal crossing divisor , the partial derivatives of @xmath459 vanish precisely at the singularities of the normal crossing divisor ( and luckily nowhere outside the divisor ) .
hence the equation @xmath460 has at most rational double points of type @xmath2 ( even in characteristic @xmath8 ) , and one immediately reads off the configuration of the exceptional divisor for a resolution of @xmath461 .
this is indeed the @xmath1-configuration , and @xmath457 $ ] is a sequence of three blowing ups .
i do not want to reproduce these computations in detail ; but let me explain the first blowing up of @xmath462 $ ] : on the @xmath463 $ ] chart , the transform of @xmath458 is @xmath464 . removing the square factor @xmath465 we obtain @xmath466 , and this is already normal crossing along the exceptional curve @xmath467 . on the @xmath468 $ ] chart ,
the transform divided by square factors is @xmath469 .
there is a unique singularity , which is located at @xmath470 , but this singularity is not yet normal crossing . here we have to repeat the process , which i leave to the reader .
it remains to treat the case of totally degenerate parameters @xmath336 .
here we do not get rational singularities .
instead , we get an elliptic singularity .
let me first recall the terminology .
suppose that @xmath375 is a local ring that is 2-dimensional and normal , with resolution of singularities @xmath374 .
the _ arithmetic genus _
@xmath471 is defined as the maximal arithmetic genus @xmath472 , where @xmath473 ranges over all divisors supported by the exceptional locus .
the rational singularities are precisely those with @xmath474 , according to @xcite , theorem 1.7 .
singularities with @xmath475 are called _ elliptic_. wagreich @xcite obtained a list of elliptic singularities . for us ,
the following elliptic singularities are important : figure : wagreich s elliptic singularity of type @xmath476 , and a twisted form . in the elliptic singularity of type @xmath476
, the central exceptional curve @xmath477 has selfintersection number @xmath478 , whereas the others have @xmath479 . in the twisted form ,
the exceptional curve on the left is @xmath480 for some quadratic field extension @xmath481 .
[ elliptic singularity ] suppose @xmath336 .
then @xmath135 is an elliptic singularity . if the ground field @xmath37 contains a third root of unity , it is the elliptic singularity of type @xmath476 from wagreich s list . otherwise , it is the twisted form in figure 3 .
we have @xmath482 $ ] modulo the relation @xmath483 . if the ground field @xmath37 contains a third root of unity , the factor @xmath484 splits into linear factors . according to @xcite , corollary on page 449 , the singularity is then elliptic of type @xmath476 .
if @xmath37 does not contain a third root of unity , a similar analysis as in the proof for proposition [ quotient embedding ] shows that the singularity is the twisted form in figure 3 .
wagreich s elliptic singularity of type @xmath476 also showed up in katsura s analysis of the classical kummer construction in characteristic two @xcite .
i do not know whether there is a structural reason for this .
[ quasielliptic ] we keep the notation from the preceding section and work over a ground field @xmath369 , such that @xmath9 is a proper normal surface , defined as the quotient of @xmath15 by an @xmath14-action depending on two parameters @xmath328 .
the goal of this section is to study fibrations on @xmath9 .
first note that the composite morphism from the normalization @xmath485 is a finite universal homeomorphism of degree two .
it follows that the induced mapping @xmath486 becomes bijective after tensoring with @xmath487 $ ] .
consequently , the proper normal surface @xmath9 has picard number @xmath488 .
moreover , the two projections @xmath489 induce fibrations @xmath27 , because @xmath490 . throughout , we shall use the projection @xmath491 onto the second factor , and denote by @xmath492 the induced fibration , such that the diagram @xmath493 commutes . in accordance with our notation @xmath494 \cup { \operatorname{spec}}k[v^{-1}]$ ]
, we write the projective line as @xmath495)$ ] .
this should cause no confusion .
[ quasielliptic fibration ] the canonical map @xmath496 is bijective , and the fibration @xmath492 is quasielliptic .
suppose that the inclusion @xmath497 is not bijective .
using the inclusion @xmath164 we infer that @xmath419 factors birationally over @xmath12 .
it also must factor over the normalization of @xmath498 , because @xmath9 is normal . in turn , the projection @xmath499 factors over @xmath500 , which is absurd .
whence @xmath501 .
let @xmath502 be the generic point , and @xmath503 be the corresponding function field .
the generic fiber @xmath504 is a curve over the function field @xmath505 .
since @xmath9 is normal , @xmath506 is a regular curve . saying that the fibration @xmath507 is _ quasielliptic _ means that @xmath506 is a twisted form of the cuspidal curve @xmath508 of arithmetic genus one . to check this ,
let @xmath509 be the function field of @xmath12 , and consider the commutative diagram @xmath510 the morphisms are equivariant with respect to the induced @xmath14-actions on @xmath511 and @xmath512 , and the horizontal arrows are @xmath14-torsors .
more precisely , the @xmath14-action on @xmath513 is the diagonal action , coming from actions on @xmath508 and @xmath512 . passing to the algebraic closure @xmath514
, the induced torsor @xmath515 becomes trivial .
this implies that the quotient of @xmath516 by the action is isomorphic to @xmath517 . summing up , @xmath518 and @xmath517 are isomorphic .
in what follows , @xmath519 denote the function fields for @xmath520 , respectively .
note that , with the notation from the preceding proof , the composite morphism @xmath521 is a finite universal homeomorphism .
our first task is to determine the set of @xmath505-rational points @xmath522 .
this depends in a strange way on the parameters : [ sections ] 1 .
suppose that @xmath523 , @xmath524 , @xmath525 .
then the generic fiber @xmath506 contains precisely four @xmath505-rational points . 2 .
suppose that either @xmath526 or that @xmath527 or that @xmath523 , @xmath528 , @xmath529
. then @xmath506 contains only one @xmath505-rational point .
3 . in all other cases
, @xmath506 contains exactly two @xmath505-rational points .
let @xmath530 be a @xmath505-rational point .
its preimage under the quotient map @xmath531 is a closed subscheme of @xmath505-length two , which is invariant under the diagonal @xmath14-action .
hence the preimage must be an @xmath14-invariant @xmath532-rational point on @xmath533 .
the latter might be viewed as an equivariant section for the structure map @xmath534 .
since the diagram @xmath535 is cartesian , such sections are equivariant @xmath505-morphisms @xmath536 . note that the @xmath14-actions on @xmath508 and @xmath532 are given by the derivations @xmath537 and @xmath538 , respectively .
summing up , the @xmath505-rational points on @xmath506 correspond to the equivariant @xmath505-morphisms @xmath536 .
clearly , the image of @xmath539 must lie in the smooth locus of @xmath508 .
so @xmath539 is given by a ring homomorphism @xmath540{\longrightarrow}l,\quad u^{-1}\longmapsto \alpha v^{-1}+\beta\ ] ] for some @xmath541 .
equivariance means that @xmath542 maps to @xmath543 , which gives the equation @xmath544 comparing coefficients , we obtain three equations @xmath545 the first equation simply means @xmath546 .
unraveling the other two equations , we reach the assertion .
for example , consider the case that both @xmath523 .
the second equation then means @xmath547 or @xmath548 .
this gives two or one possibilities for @xmath360 , depending on whether @xmath549 is contained in @xmath550 or not .
the third equation means that @xmath551 or @xmath552 .
again we have two or one possibility , depending on whether @xmath553 is a square in @xmath505 or not . summing up , we have either one , two , or four rational points in the generic fiber @xmath506 , depending on the values @xmath549 and @xmath554 as claimed in the assertion .
the other cases are similar , and left to the reader .
for example , in the case @xmath555 , the homomorphism @xmath556{\rightarrow}l$ ] given by @xmath557 corresponds to the rational point on @xmath506 given by @xmath558 , @xmath559 , with maximal ideal @xmath560 .
[ sections perfect ] for later use we record the outcome if @xmath525 , for example if @xmath505 is perfect . then the number of @xmath505-rational points in the generic fiber @xmath506 depends only on the ratio @xmath561 viewed as a point in the projective line @xmath31 . if @xmath562 we have precisely one rational point .
if @xmath454 , or @xmath523 and @xmath563 we have precisely two rational points . and in case @xmath523 , @xmath564 we have four rational points .
next , we look at the closed fibers @xmath565 of the quasielliptic fibration @xmath492 .
the situation is particularly simple for fibers over which the @xmath14-action is free : [ multiplicity one ] let @xmath566 be a rational point so that @xmath567 contains no fixed points
. then @xmath568 is isomorphic to the cuspidal curve of arithmetic genus one .
i make the computation for the special case @xmath569 , the other cases being similar .
consider the commutative diagram ( [ generic square ] ) .
the fiber @xmath570 is the spectrum of the artin ring @xmath571/(v^2)$ ] . in other words
, we have @xmath572 $ ] , where @xmath44 denotes the residue class of @xmath573 .
our derivation @xmath574 acts as @xmath575 .
the fiber @xmath576 is hence equivariantly isomorphic to @xmath577 with diagonal @xmath14-action .
we have @xmath578 because the group scheme action is free on @xmath579 , by proposition [ base free ] . clearly , the quotient @xmath580 is the rational cuspidal curve of arithmetic genus one , hence the assertion .
next , we come to multiple fibers : [ multiplicity two ] let @xmath566 be the rational point defined by the maximal ideal @xmath581 .
then the curve @xmath582 is nonreduced , and we have an equality @xmath583 of weil divisors .
let @xmath584 be the canonical morphism from diagram ( [ total square ] ) .
the fiber @xmath585 is the spectrum of the artin ring @xmath586/(v^{-2})$ ] . in other words
, we have @xmath572 $ ] , where @xmath44 denotes the residue class of @xmath587 .
our derivation @xmath574 acts as @xmath588 .
the fiber @xmath576 is therefore equivariantly isomorphic to @xmath589 $ ] , where @xmath14 acts via the derivation @xmath590 on the first factor , and trivially on the second factor .
hence the quotient is isomorphic to @xmath591 $ ] . according to proposition [ base free ] ,
this quotient and the fiber @xmath582 are isomorphic on a dense open set , and the assertion follows . in case that the parameter @xmath592 is a square
, the fiber @xmath582 over the closed point @xmath566 defined by the maximal ideal @xmath593 is a double fiber as well .
this follows from proposition [ automorphism group ] .
the situation is different if @xmath592 is not a square , which can happen only over nonperfect ground fields : suppose that @xmath592 is not a square .
let @xmath594 be the rational point defined by the maximal ideal @xmath593 .
then the irreducible curve @xmath582 is integral , but not geometrically integral .
we just discussed that the fiber @xmath582 has geometric multiplicity two .
the fiber @xmath585 is the spectrum of the artin ring @xmath595/(v^{-2}-s)$ ] , which is a field . as in the preceding proof , we argue that the fiber @xmath582 is birational to the integral curve @xmath480 .
we shall see in section [ simultaneous ] that the existence of such integral but geometrically multiple fibers is responsible for the nonexistence of simultaneous resolutions .
the following result also gives a hint that some purely inseparable base change is necessary : [ generic isomorphism ] let @xmath27 be the quasielliptic surface defined by parameters @xmath328 , and @xmath596 be the quasielliptic surface defined by @xmath597 for some nonzero @xmath598 .
then there is a commutative diagram @xmath599 such that the horizontal maps are isomorphisms , and @xmath502 is the generic point .
this is an exercise in weierstrass equations .
the generic fibers @xmath600 are isomorphic to regular cubics in @xmath601 containing a rational point . according to proposition [ quotient embedding ] ,
the weierstrass equation for @xmath602 is @xmath603 where we set @xmath604 and @xmath605 , and @xmath606 is a transcendental generator .
applying the substitutions @xmath607 and @xmath608 and @xmath609 , we obtain the corresponding weierstrass equation for @xmath610 up to a factor @xmath611 .
[ k3 ] we keep the notation of the preceding two sections , such that @xmath9 is a proper normal surface , defined as the quotient @xmath16 and depending on two parameters @xmath328 .
we also assume that our ground field @xmath37 is perfect .
let @xmath612 be the minimal resolution of singularities .
note that we now have three surfaces @xmath613 , and all three are cohen
macaulay , hence each has a dualizing sheaf .
[ gorenstein ] the proper normal surfaces @xmath34 and @xmath9 are gorenstein , and their dualizing sheaves are trivial as invertible sheaves . if at least one parameter @xmath328 is nonzero , the same holds for @xmath6 . the surface @xmath15 is gorenstein and the invertible sheaf @xmath614 trivial , because the same holds for the curve @xmath12 .
let @xmath322 be the complement of the fixed locus , and @xmath162 be the corresponding open subset .
the induced morphism @xmath124 is an @xmath14-torsor . by proposition [ dualizing quotient ]
the quotient @xmath168 is gorenstein and the invertible sheaf @xmath615 is trivial .
using that @xmath34 is cohen macaulay , we infer that the invertible sheaf @xmath171 is trivial as well .
suppose the parameters @xmath328 do not vanish simultaneously .
we saw in sections [ singularity ] and [ singularities ] that the singularities on @xmath9 are then rational double points , hence the relative dualizing sheaf @xmath616 is trivial .
we conclude that @xmath617 .
using the enriques classification of surfaces , it is now easy to determine the nature of the smooth proper surface @xmath6 : [ k3 surface ] the smooth proper surface @xmath6 is a k3 surface if at least one parameter @xmath328 is nonzero .
otherwise it is a geometrically rational surface .
we may assume that the ground field is algebraically closed .
suppose @xmath328 do not vanish simultaneously .
we saw in proposition [ gorenstein ] that @xmath618 is trivial .
it follows that the regular surface @xmath6 contains no @xmath619-curves , in other words , @xmath6 is minimal . by the enriques classification of surfaces , @xmath6 is either an abelian surface , or an enriques surface , or a k3 surface .
such surfaces have second betti number @xmath620 , @xmath621 , and @xmath622 , respectively . in sections [ singularity ] and [ singularities ] we showed that the normal surface @xmath9 contains either five rational double points of type @xmath0 , or one rational double point of type @xmath0 and two of type @xmath1 . in any case , these singularities contribute twenty exceptional curves on @xmath6 , and this implies @xmath623 .
it follows that @xmath6 must be a k3 surface .
now suppose @xmath336 .
we shall apply the castelnuovo criterion for rationality . according to proposition [ elliptic singularity ] ,
the normal surface @xmath9 contains an elliptic singularity .
let @xmath624 be the corresponding exceptional divisor , and @xmath473 be a curve supported by @xmath11 .
using @xmath625 we infer @xmath626 .
since the intersection form on the divisors supported on @xmath11 is negative definite , the relative canonical class @xmath627 , which is a divisor supported on @xmath11 , has negative coefficients . if we choose @xmath628 with arithmetic genus @xmath629 , we have @xmath630 .
the upshot is that @xmath631 is negative , and all plurigenera @xmath632 , @xmath633 vanish . by serre duality
, @xmath634 vanishes , hence the picard scheme @xmath635 is reduced .
since we have a quasielliptic fibration @xmath636 , the albanese map for @xmath6 is trivial , and we conclude that @xmath376 . now the castelnuovo criterion tells us that @xmath6 is rational .
we are mainly interested in k3 surfaces .
let us therefore assume that @xmath328 do not vanish simultaneously , such that @xmath6 is a k3 surface .
let @xmath24 be the quasielliptic fibration induced by @xmath492 .
suppose for the moment that the ground field @xmath37 is algebraically closed . obviously , quasielliptic k3 surfaces are _ unirational _ , that is , there is a surjective morphism from a rational surface onto @xmath6 . in our situation , we may choose as rational surface the fiber product @xmath637 , where @xmath638 is the normalization of @xmath34 .
unirational k3 surfaces are _ supersingular _ ( in the sense of shioda ) , that is , the picard number is @xmath639 .
there is a slight complication over nonclosed ground fields : [ picard number ] we have @xmath639 if the ground field @xmath37 contains a third root of unity , and @xmath640 otherwise .
we check this with the tate shioda formula . for each @xmath566 , let @xmath641 be the number of reducible components in the fiber @xmath642 .
clearly , @xmath643 is the number of irreducible components in the exceptional divisor for the resolution of singularities @xmath18 .
it follows from the results in sections [ singularity ] and [ singularities ] that this sum equals 20 if the ground field @xmath37 contains a third root of unity , and 19 otherwise .
the group @xmath644 for the generic fiber @xmath645 is 2-torsion .
hence the tate
shioda formula for the quasielliptic fibration @xmath24 takes the form @xmath646 and the result follows . our next task is to understand the intersection form on the nron
severi group @xmath647 , which for k3 surfaces is isomorphic to the picard group .
for this , we have to analyse the reducible fibers of the quasielliptic fibration @xmath24 .
recall that reducible fibers in genus - one fibrations with regular total space @xmath6 correspond to root systems .
the correspondence is as follows : decompose the fiber @xmath648 into integral components , and let @xmath168 be the real vector space generated by the @xmath380 , endowed with the positive semidefinite bilinear form @xmath381 .
suppose that @xmath477 is a component with multiplicity one .
then the remaining @xmath649 form a root basis .
note that @xmath650 is then the longest root , and its multiplicities can be read off from the bourbaki tables @xcite .
one usually uses the symbols for positive semidefinite coxeter matrix ( @xmath651 , @xmath652 ) to denote the fiber type . in our situation
it is very simple to determine the fiber type of @xmath653 , @xmath566 .
we only need to know the types of singularities @xmath118 lying in the fiber @xmath582 , which we determined in sections [ singularity ] and [ singularities ] , and the multiplicity of the closed fiber @xmath654 , which we did in section [ quasielliptic ] .
the proofs for the following two assertions are straightforward whence omitted .
[ fiber d4 ] suppose @xmath568 is the fiber containing the rational double point @xmath118 corresponding to the quadruple point @xmath108 . then @xmath642 is a fiber of type @xmath655 if the ground field @xmath37 contains a third root of unity , and of type @xmath656 otherwise .
the strict transform of the closed fiber @xmath582 corresponds to the white vertices in figure 4 .
figure : the extended dynkin diagrams @xmath655 and @xmath656 .
we next examine fibers related to the fixed points of the @xmath14-action on @xmath6 .
[ fiber d4d8 ] suppose @xmath568 is a fiber containing two rational double points @xmath657 , say of type @xmath0 or @xmath1 .
then @xmath642 is a fiber of type @xmath658 or @xmath659 , respectively .
the strict transform of the closed fiber @xmath582 corresponds to the central white vertex , as in figure 5 .
figure : the extended dynkin diagram @xmath658 .
[ fiber e8 ] suppose @xmath568 is a fiber containing precisely one rational double point @xmath657 corresponding to a fixed point on @xmath34 .
then @xmath642 is a fiber of type @xmath660 , and the strict transform of the closed fiber @xmath582 corresponds to the white vertex in figure 6 .
figure : the extended dynkin diagram @xmath660 .
clearly , only the fiber types @xmath660 or @xmath658 are possible . in the latter case ,
the strict transform of the closed fiber @xmath582 must be one of the four outer vertices .
the outer vertices , however , appear with multiplicity one in the fiber , contradicting that @xmath582 has multiplicity two .
[ discriminants ] let @xmath6 be a k3 surface over an algebraically closed ground field @xmath37 of characteristic @xmath19 with picard number @xmath639 . in other words
, @xmath6 is supersingular .
artin @xcite introduced an integer invariant for such surfaces called the _
artin invariant_. one way to define it is in terms of the intersection form on the nron
severi group @xmath647 .
artin showed that its discriminant is of the form @xmath661 for some integer @xmath21 , which is the artin invariant @xmath662 .
it is not difficult to compute the artin invariant in the presence of a quasielliptic fibration @xmath24 with a section @xmath663 .
let @xmath664 be the subgroup generated by the section @xmath663 , together with all curves @xmath665 inside the closed fibers of the quasielliptic fibration @xmath24 . as ito explained in @xcite , section 2 ,
the quotient group @xmath666 is a finite group annihilated by @xmath41 , say of order @xmath667 .
this group acts freely and transitively on the set of rational points in the generic fiber @xmath645 .
hence the group order @xmath667 is also the number of rational points on @xmath645 . for each point @xmath566 ,
let @xmath668 be the unique integral component with @xmath669 .
the remaining irreducible components @xmath670 form a root basis , whose type corresponds to the fiber type of @xmath653 .
let @xmath671 be the determinant of the corresponding intersection form .
bourbaki calls this number the _ connection index _
( @xcite , chapter iv , 1.9 ) . clearly , there are only finitely many points @xmath672 whose fibers are reducible . to simplify notation , we set @xmath673 . [ artin formula ] under the preceding assumptions , the artin invariant @xmath674 for the quasielliptic k3 surface @xmath6 is given by the formula @xmath675 by definition , the subgroup @xmath664 has index @xmath667 .
according to @xcite , chapter iii , 2 , proposition 5 , we have @xmath676 , and it remains to compute the discriminant of @xmath532 .
let @xmath677 be the subgroup generated by the section @xmath663 and a closed fiber @xmath642 .
using @xmath678 and @xmath679 and @xmath680 , we have @xmath681 . for
each @xmath682 let @xmath683 be the subgroup generated by the integral components of @xmath684 , where @xmath685 is the unique integral component with @xmath686 .
it is easy to see that we have an orthogonal decomposition @xmath687 , and the result follows .
we now return to the situation of the preceding section , such that @xmath6 is our quasielliptic k3 surface in characteristic @xmath8 depending on two parameters @xmath328 , which do not vanish simultaneously .
we then obtain a point @xmath688 .
the artin invariant of @xmath6 now depends on whether or not this point lies inside the subset @xmath689 .
[ ] our supersingular k3 surface @xmath6 has artin invariant @xmath690 if @xmath691 .
otherwise , it has artin invariant @xmath692 .
suppose first that @xmath562 . according to proposition [ sections ] and remark [ sections perfect ]
, the generic fiber @xmath645 contains only @xmath693 rational point . by propositions [ fiber d4 ] and [ fiber e8 ]
, there are three reducible fibers , one of type @xmath655 , the others of type @xmath660 .
the connection indices are @xmath694 and @xmath695 . by the formula in lemma [ artin formula ] , we have @xmath696 .
now suppose that @xmath337 , @xmath454 .
then the the generic fiber contains precisely @xmath697 rational points . by proposition
[ ] , we have one fiber of type @xmath655 and one fiber of type @xmath658 , which both have connection index @xmath698 .
the formula for the artin invariant again gives @xmath696 . in case that @xmath523 but @xmath528 we also have only two rational points in the generic fiber , but three fibers of type @xmath655 .
this implies @xmath692 .
finally , suppose we have @xmath523 and @xmath524 .
then we have @xmath699 rational points in the generic fiber and again three fibers of type @xmath655 , and this leads to @xmath696 .
there seems to be a close relation between our family of k3 surfaces and the family studied in @xcite .
[ blowing ] the next task is to construct simultaneous resolutions of singularities for our flat family of normal k3 surfaces . by the work of brieskorn @xcite and artin @xcite ,
simultaneous resolutions in flat families rarely exist without base change . in our case , it turns out that a purely inseparable base change is necessary .
after that , simultaneous resolution is achieved by blowing up weil divisors inside the quasielliptic fibration , which easily extends to the family .
the goal of this section is to collect some useful facts on blowing up curves on rational surface singularities . throughout
, @xmath373 is a 2-dimensional normal local ring , with resolution of singularities @xmath700 .
we assume that @xmath375 is a _ rational singularity _ , that is , @xmath376 .
let @xmath701 be a reflexive ideal , which defines a curve @xmath702 without embedded components . how to compute the schematic fiber @xmath703 on the resolution of singularities ?
the following arguments are adapted from artin s paper @xcite , where he considered maximal ideals instead of reflexive ideals .
let @xmath624 be the reduced exceptional divisor , and @xmath704 be its decomposition into integral components , and @xmath705 be the strict transform of @xmath702 .
consider nonzero divisors @xmath706 with coefficients @xmath707 satisfying @xmath708 for all @xmath709 . as in @xcite , page 131
there is a unique minimal cycle @xmath9 with these properties .
( in artin s situation , this cycle is called the _ fundamental cycle_. ) one may determine this cycle by computing a sequence of cycles @xmath710 inductively as follows : start with @xmath711 , where @xmath380 is any component with @xmath712 .
suppose we already defined @xmath713 for some @xmath714 .
if @xmath715 for all @xmath709 , we set @xmath716 and are done . otherwise , we have @xmath717 for some integral component @xmath380 .
we then define @xmath718 and proceed by induction .
this algorithm stops after finitely many steps and yields the desired cycle @xmath9 .
[ fundamental cycle ] we have @xmath719 as subschemes of the resolution of singularities @xmath6 .
the arguments are as in the proof for @xcite , theorem 4 .
this result shows that in the algorithm to compute @xmath9 , we may start by letting @xmath720 be the fundamental cycle of the singularity @xmath375 .
note that the fundamental cycle corresponds to the longest roots , which can be read off from the bourbaki tables @xcite .
mumford @xcite defined a linear preimage from the group of 1-cycles on @xmath721 to the group of 1-cycles with rational coefficients on @xmath291 .
note that the schematic fiber @xmath722 usually differs from the linear preimage @xmath723 .
[ two generators ] let @xmath160 be a reflexive fractional @xmath375-ideal .
then the @xmath37-vector space @xmath724 is at most 2-dimensional .
we may assume that the local ring @xmath375 is henselian , and that the fractional ideal @xmath160 is an ideal in @xmath375 , which defines a local curve @xmath702 .
it induces an ideal sheaf @xmath725 on the resolution of singularities @xmath291 .
i claim that the canonical map @xmath726 is bijective . to see this , consider the commutative diagram @xmath727 the vertical map in the middle is surjective , because @xmath375 is normal and @xmath374 is proper and birational .
the vertical map on the right is injective , because @xmath728 has no embedded components .
now the snake lemma tells us that @xmath729 is bijective .
i claim that there are two global sections @xmath730 generating the stalk @xmath731 for all points @xmath732 . to construct @xmath733 , choose a divisor @xmath734 whose support is disjoint from @xmath735 and @xmath736 , and whose degree on @xmath380 equals the intersection number @xmath737 for all @xmath709 .
note that the closed subscheme @xmath722 indeed has no embedded points , hence is a cartier divisor , according to lemma [ fundamental cycle ] .
since @xmath375 is henselian , we may extend @xmath734 to a cartier divisor @xmath738 by @xcite , proposition 21.9.11 . by construction @xmath739 using that @xmath375 is rational , we conclude that the invertible sheaf @xmath740 is trivial , whence there is an isomorphism @xmath741 . repeating the same construction
, we find another divisor @xmath742 as above , and whose support is disjoint from @xmath628 .
this yields the desired surjection @xmath743 .
we obtain an exact sequence @xmath744 , which induces a long exact sequence @xmath745 the sheaf @xmath746 is invertible .
taking determinants , one sees that @xmath746 is isomorphic to the dual @xmath747 .
consequently , @xmath748 .
using @xcite , proposition 1.9 , we infer @xmath749 .
summing up , @xmath750 and hence @xmath160 are generated by two elements .
next , consider the class group @xmath751 of reflexive fractional ideals @xmath160 . given a class @xmath752\in{\operatorname{cl}}({\mathcal{o}}_z)$ ] , we form the blowing up @xmath753 it depends , up to isomorphism , only on the ideal class and not the ideal itself .
note that the induced map @xmath754 is projective and birational .
[ factorization blowing ] the resolution of singularities @xmath700 factors over our blowing up @xmath754 .
we may assume that the fractional ideal @xmath160 is an ideal in @xmath375 , defining a curve @xmath702 . according to lemma [ fundamental cycle ] ,
the schematic preimage @xmath722 is a cartier divisor . by the universal property of blowing ups
, this means that @xmath553 factors over @xmath539 .
the next result tells us that the induced morphism @xmath755 coincides with its stein factorization , whence is uniquely determined by its exceptional curves .
[ normal blowing ] the scheme @xmath389 is normal .
we may assume that @xmath160 is an ideal in @xmath756 .
the quotient @xmath728 has no embedded primes .
let @xmath757 be any proper birational morphism , with @xmath758 reduced . in light of lipman s results @xcite , it suffices to check that the canonical map @xmath759 is bijective . for this
, we argue as in lemma [ two generators ] .
we infer that the fibers of the blowing up are as small as possible : [ blowing fiber ] suppose that @xmath752\neq 0 $ ] .
then the closed fiber @xmath760 is isomorphic to the projective line @xmath761 .
write @xmath762 .
this defines a closed embedding @xmath763 , hence the fiber @xmath760 is a closed subset of @xmath31 .
suppose we have @xmath764 .
then the closed fiber is finite , hence @xmath754 is finite and birational . since @xmath375 is normal ,
we conclude that @xmath765 . in turn
, @xmath160 must be invertible , contradiction .
in light of the preceding results , it is possible to compute the blowing up @xmath766 of some reflexive fractional ideal @xmath160 via a resolution of singularities @xmath700 as follows : let @xmath624 be the reduced exceptional divisor , and assume that @xmath160 is an ideal defining a curve @xmath702 .
the scheme @xmath767 is obtained from @xmath6 by contracting all integral components @xmath379 but one .
the next result tells us which ones : [ blown down ] the integral components @xmath379 that are contracted by @xmath755 are precisely those with @xmath768 .
the cartier divisor @xmath769 is @xmath539-antiample .
the projection formula implies that @xmath770 if @xmath380 is not contracted , and @xmath768 if @xmath380 is contracted .
[ genus ] we now apply the results from the previous section to the following situation .
suppose @xmath6 is a smooth surface endowed with a genus - one fibration @xmath24 .
we assume that the fibration is relatively minimal , admits a section , and that the generic fiber @xmath645 is a regular curve of arithmetic genus one .
fix a rational point @xmath566 , and decompose the closed fiber @xmath771 into integral components .
let @xmath612 be the contraction of some integral components in @xmath642 .
we seek to recover the minimal resolution of singularities with a sequence @xmath772 of blowing ups so that each step @xmath773 has as center a weil divisor @xmath774 inside the fiber .
this approach has its merits when it comes to deformations : such 1-dimensional centers behave much better in families than 0-dimensional centers . a convenient way to describe the centers @xmath775 is via its strict transforms on @xmath6 .
suppose now that the fiber @xmath653 has fiber type @xmath658 , and let @xmath612 be the contraction of all integral components but @xmath776 , which corresponds to the white vertex as depicted in figure 7 . as usual , the choice of indices is taken from the bourbaki tables @xcite . throughout , the integral component @xmath777 shall correspond to the vertex with number @xmath273 .
note that the situation is as in proposition [ fiber d4d8 ] .
figure : the fiber type @xmath658 .
[ reach d8 ] under the preceding assumptions , we reach the resolution of singularities with the sequence of blowing ups @xmath778 , in which the centers @xmath779 have strict transforms @xmath780 , respectively .
all centers have arithmetic genus @xmath781 . by assumption ,
the normal surface @xmath9 contains precisely two singularities , which are rational double points of type @xmath0 .
let @xmath782 be the blowing up whose center @xmath783 has strict transform @xmath784 .
note that this center is nothing but the half fiber . using the algorithm in section [ blowing ] ,
we compute its schematic preimage @xmath785 on the minimal resolution of singularities .
it turns out that @xmath786 which has @xmath787 .
therefore , the exceptional curve for @xmath782 corresponds to @xmath788 .
we now have to repeat this , quite mechanically .
my findings are summarized in the following table : @xmath789{l |l| l |l } & \text{rdp } & \text{center } & \text{schematic preimage of center}\\ \hline&&&\\[-2ex ] z^{(0 ) } & 2d_4 & e_4 & e_0+e_1 + 2e_2 + 2\underline{e_3 } + e_4 + 2\underline{e_5}+2e_6+e_7+e_8 \\ z^{(1 ) } & 2a_3 & 2e_5 & 2e_5 + 2e_6+e_7+e_8 \\
z^{(2 ) } & 2a_3 & e_3 & e_0+e_1 + 2\underline{e_2}+ e_3 \\
z^{(3 ) } & 2a_1+a_3 & e_2 & \underline{e_0}+\underline{e_1}+e_2\\ z^{(4 ) } & a_3 & e_5 & e_5 + 2\underline{e_6}+ e_7+e_8\\ z^{(5 ) } & 2a_1 & e_6 & e_6+\underline{e_7}+\underline{e_8 } \end{array}\ ] ] table : the second column displays the types of rational double points on @xmath790 . the third column gives the strict transforms of the centers @xmath791 on @xmath6 .
the last column contains the schematic preimage of the center @xmath775 on @xmath6 .
the underlined irreducible components are those with nonzero intersection number with the preimage , hence give the exceptional curves for @xmath773 .
note that the weil divisor @xmath792 is already cartier , such that @xmath793 is the identity .
i have included this seemingly superfluous step here because we need it later when it comes to simultaneous resolutions in families .
it remains to check @xmath794 .
i do this for @xmath795 and @xmath796 , the other cases being similar .
the strict transform @xmath776 for @xmath797 is clearly isomorphic to @xmath31 , so the possibly nonnormal points on @xmath783 must appear at the singularities @xmath118 . to see that @xmath783 is normal , it suffices to check that @xmath798 . according to @xcite , theorem 4 , the fiber @xmath799 is the fundamental cycle for the singularity , which in our case equals @xmath800 , and we see @xmath801 .
it follows @xmath802 .
as above , one checks that @xmath803 . the center @xmath792 and its strict transform @xmath804
are nonreduced .
they are _ ribbons _ in the terminology of bayer and eisenbud , that is , infinitesimal extension of a reduced scheme by an invertible sheaf .
the strict transform @xmath804 is the infinitesimal extension of @xmath31 by @xmath805 .
let @xmath806 be the singularity lying on @xmath792 , which is a rational double point of type @xmath807 .
as above , one shows that its preimage on @xmath808 is the intersection @xmath809)$ ] .
this implies that @xmath792 is an extension of @xmath31 by @xmath810 , as explained in @xcite , corollary 1.10 .
the exact sequence @xmath811 gives @xmath812 .
we now turn to the following case : suppose that @xmath653 has fiber type @xmath660 , and that @xmath18 is the contraction of all irreducible components @xmath777 except @xmath813 , which corresponds to the white vertex in figure 8 .
note that the situation is precisely as in proposition [ fiber e8 ] .
figure : the fiber type @xmath660 .
[ reach e8 ] under the preceding assumptions , we reach the resolution of singularities with the sequence of blowing ups @xmath778 , in which the centers @xmath779 have strict transforms @xmath814 , respectively . all centers have arithmetic genus @xmath781 . by assumption ,
the normal surface @xmath9 contains precisely one singularity , which is a rational double point of type @xmath1 .
let @xmath782 be the blowing up whose center @xmath783 has strict transform @xmath813 .
note that this is nothing but the half fiber . using the algorithm in section [ blowing ] , we compute its schematic preimage @xmath785 on the minimal resolution of singularities .
it turns out that @xmath815 which has @xmath816 .
therefore , the exceptional curve for @xmath782 corresponds to @xmath817 .
further calculations are summarized as above in the following table : @xmath818{l
|l| l |l } & \text{rdp } & \text{center } & \text{schematic preimage of center}\\ \hline&&&\\[-2ex ] z^{(0 ) } & d_8 & e_1 & e_1 + 3e_2 + 4\underline{e_3}+6e_4 + 5e_5 + 4e_6 + 3e_7 + 2e_8+e_0 \\
z^{(1 ) } & a_7 & 2e_3 & 2e_2 + 2e_3 + 4e_4 + 4e_5 + 4\underline{e_6 } + 3e_7 + 2e_8+e_0 \\
z^{(2 ) } & 2a_3 & e_3 & e_2+e_3 + 2\underline{e_4}+e_5\\ z^{(3 ) } & 2a_1+a_3 & e_4 & \underline{e_2}+e_4+\underline{e_5 } \\
z^{(4 ) } & a_3 & e_2+e_3 + 2e_4 + 2e_5 + 2e_6 & e_2+e_3 + 2e_4 + 2e_5 + 2e_6 + 2e_7 + 2\underline{e_8}+e_0\\ z^{(5 ) } & 2a_1 & e_8 & \underline{e_7}+e_8+\underline{e_0 } \end{array}\ ] ] table : blowing ups in the @xmath660-fiber . the first assertion follows . checking that @xmath819 is as in the proof for proposition [ reach d8 ] .
[ simultaneous ] let @xmath820 $ ] be the complement of the origin , and @xmath25 be our projective flat family of normal k3 surfaces with rational double points , as constructed in section [ selfproduct ] .
in this section we seek a simultaneous resolution of singularities . by brieskorn s work ,
such simultaneous resolutions seldomly exist without base change @xcite .
artin introduced the _ resolution functor _
@xmath821 to remedy the situation @xcite . given an @xmath291-scheme @xmath822 ,
the resolution functor takes as values @xmath823 the set of isomorphism classes of simultaneous resolutions over @xmath822 , that is , commutative diagrams @xmath824 where @xmath35 is a proper smooth family of k3 surfaces , and for each point @xmath825 , the canonical morphism @xmath826 is the minimal resolution of singularities .
artin s insight was that the resolution functor is representable by an algebraic space that , however , is only locally quasiseparated .
the goal of this section is to show that simultaneous resolutions exist after purely inseparable base change : [ simultaneous resolution ] there exist a simultaneous resolution @xmath35 for the family @xmath827 over the purely inseparable flat base change @xmath828 } k[\sqrt{r},\sqrt{s}]$ ] .
recall that the quadruple point @xmath829 induces a family of @xmath0-singularities in @xmath25 .
according to proposition [ trivial deformation ] , this family of singularities is formally trivial .
it is then easy to see that a simultaneous resolution already exists over @xmath291 without base change .
the trouble comes from the other singularities , which indeed necessitate a base change . to proceed we cover the quasiaffine scheme @xmath830 $ ] by the two affine open subsets @xmath831 and @xmath832 .
let us first concentrate on the restriction @xmath833 to the first affine open subset . as discussed in section [ quasielliptic ] , the second projection @xmath491 induces a family of quasielliptic structures @xmath834 . in accordance with our notation , we write the base as @xmath835 $ ] . for each @xmath836 ,
the induced fibration @xmath837 has over @xmath838 and @xmath839 degenerate fibers , of type @xmath658 over the open subset @xmath257 , and of type @xmath660 over the closed subset @xmath840 .
it is precisely this point where we use base change , in order to apply proposition [ automorphism group ] .
now let @xmath841 be the generic point .
we discussed in the preceding section how to obtain the minimal resolution of @xmath842 via a sequence of blowing ups @xmath843 whose centers @xmath844 are weil divisors in the reducible fibers .
i claim that this procedure extends to the family @xmath845 . indeed : the first center @xmath846 is nothing but the half fiber inside the degenerate fibers .
let @xmath847 be the schematic closure of @xmath848 .
on the smooth part of @xmath833 this is a relative cartier divisor , and its restrictions @xmath849 , @xmath836 gives the half fibers . at the singularities , the schematic fibers @xmath849 could pick up embedded components .
this , however , is impossible , because @xmath850 by propositions [ reach d8 ] and [ reach e8 ] , and the euler characteristic @xmath851 is constant by flatness .
we deduce that the blowing up of @xmath847 yields fiberwise the first step in the resolution of singularities . repeating the preceding argument inductively for the other centers ,
we see that after six steps we reach a simultaneous resolution @xmath852 , at least over the open subset @xmath257 where the fiber type is constantly @xmath658 . using the tables in the preceding section we can check that centers in the @xmath658-fibers specialize to the centers in the @xmath660-fibers ,
hence we obtain the desired resolution of singularities over @xmath132 .
below is a table describing how the integral components of the @xmath658-fibers specialize to curves on the @xmath660-fiber .
note that this specialization respects intersection numbers .
the existence of such a specialization seems to be interesting in its own right .
@xmath853{l|l|l|l|l|l|c|l|l|l } \text{$\tilde{d}_8$-fiber } & e_0 & e_1 & e_2 & e_3 & e_4 & e_5 & e_6 & e_7 & e_8\\ \hline&&&\\[-2ex ] \text{$\tilde{e}_8$-fiber } & e_2 & e_5 & e_4 & e_3 & e_1 & e_2+e_3 + 2e_4 + 2e_5 + 2e_6+e_7 & e_8 & e_7 & e_0 \end{array}\ ] ] table : specialization from @xmath658-fiber to @xmath660-fiber .
the reason for this specialization behavior is as follows : on @xmath854 , the @xmath784-curve in the @xmath658-fibers specialize to the @xmath813-curve in the @xmath660-fibers .
we then do the first blowing up @xmath855 . according to tables 1 and table 2 in section [ genus ] ,
its center is the family of curves comprising the @xmath784-curve on the @xmath658-fibers and the @xmath813-curve on the @xmath660-fibers .
the preimage on @xmath856 of the center is the family of curves comprising the @xmath857-curve on the @xmath658-fibers and @xmath858-curve on the @xmath660-fibers .
consequently , both the @xmath859-component and the @xmath808-component specialize to the @xmath859-component .
the @xmath784-components specialize to the @xmath813-component .
note that the preimage of the center is the cartier divisor corresponding to the canonical section into @xmath860 .
next , we do the second blowing up @xmath861 .
now the center is the family comprising the @xmath804-curve on the @xmath658-fibers and the @xmath862-curve on the @xmath660-fibers .
the preimage on @xmath863 of the center is the family consisting of the @xmath804-curve on the @xmath658-fibers and @xmath864-curve on the @xmath660-fibers .
hence the @xmath808-component specializes to the @xmath865-curve .
the @xmath859-components specializes to the @xmath859-component , and the @xmath784-component to the @xmath813-component .
now we come to the third blowing up @xmath866 . here
the center is the family comprising the @xmath859-curve on both the @xmath658-fibers and the @xmath660-fibers .
the preimage of the center is the family comprising the @xmath867-curves on the @xmath658-fibers and @xmath868-curve on the @xmath660-fibers .
so the @xmath859-component specializes to @xmath859 , and the @xmath869-component specialize to @xmath784 .
the @xmath784-component keeps on specializing to the @xmath813-component , because this family is disjoint from the exceptional locus of the blowing - up .
the specialization of the @xmath808-component on the @xmath658-fibers is more interesting : it is necessarily of the form @xmath870 for some integer @xmath633 . using the fact that the whole fibers specializes to a whole fiber , we infer @xmath871 .
the arguments for the remaining two steps in the blowing up process are similar , and left to the reader .
it remains to extend this simultaneous resolution to @xmath822 .
using the first projection @xmath872 rather than the second projection , we obtain a simultaneous resolution @xmath873 for the family @xmath874 .
the two resolutions @xmath875 and @xmath873 coincide over the overlap @xmath257 .
indeed , the degenerate fibers in @xmath876 have constant fiber type @xmath658 over @xmath257 , and the fiberwise integral components of the exceptional divisors in the simultaneous resolution @xmath877 constitute relative cartier divisors over @xmath257 .
such simultaneous resolutions are necessarily unique
. the result may be rephrased by saying that there is a morphism @xmath878 .
this does not seem to be an isomorphism , because our simultaneous resolution @xmath35 does not appear to be unique .
this nonuniqueness leads to nonseparability phenomena , as discussed by burns and rapoport in @xcite , section 7 .
[ isomorphic ] in the preceding section we constructed a smooth family of supersingular k3-surfaces @xmath35 with artin invariants @xmath879 , which is defined over the complement @xmath880 of the origin , where @xmath881 $ ] . according to rudakov and shafarevich @xcite
, such families should depend only on one effective parameter .
this is indeed the case , and can be made explicit as follows .
write @xmath882 $ ] , and consider the canonical projection @xmath883
. the assertion would be obvious if the moduli space of polarized k3 surfaces would be fine .
this , however , does not seem to be the case .
instead we shall work with moduli space of marked k3 surfaces .
for this we have to check that our family admits a marking .
let @xmath884 be the function field of the pointed affine plane @xmath822 , and choose a separable closure @xmath885 .
the galois group @xmath886 acts on the the module @xmath887 , where @xmath888 denotes the generic fiber .
this action must be trivial : according to the explicit description of fibers and sections in @xmath889 in sections [ singularity ] and [ singularities ] and proposition [ sections ] , the pullback map @xmath890 is bijective .
we conclude that the sheaf @xmath891 on @xmath822 in the tale topology is constant on some open affine subset @xmath892 .
whence there is bijection @xmath893 .
this bijection extends to a homomorphism @xmath894 , thanks to the explicit description of relative cartier divisors inside the flat family @xmath35 discussed in the previous section .
the homomorphism @xmath894 is a _ marking _ in the sense of ogus @xcite .
he proved in loc .
cit . , theorem 2.7 that the functor of isomorphism classes of @xmath895-marked k3 surfaces is representable by a algebraic space @xmath896 .
note that ogus works in his paper under the general assumption @xmath897 , which seems appropriate for several arguments involving quadratic forms .
however , the result concerning the existence of @xmath896 holds true in all characteristics .
indeed , it is easy to see that the cofibered groupoid @xmath898 of @xmath895-marked families of k3 surfaces is a stack , and indeed an algebraic stack (= artin stack ) .
the latter involves grothendieck s algebraization theorem and openness of versality in the usual way . according to rudakov and shafarevich @xcite , section 8 , proposition 3 ,
the automorphism group of any marked k3 surface is trivial .
by @xcite , lemma 2.2 this carries over to families of marked k3 surfaces .
it follows that the algebraic stack @xmath898 is equivalent to its coarse moduli space @xmath896 , which is a nonseparated algebraic space .
the upshot is that the algebraic space @xmath896 is a fine moduli space .
our @xmath895-marked flat family @xmath35 induces a morphism @xmath899 . according to proposition [ generic isomorphism ] , this morphism is constant along all pointed lines , that is , fibers of the canonical projection @xmath883 .
the image @xmath900 is therefore a 1-dimensional algebraic space .
any algebraic space is generically a scheme , whence we obtain a rational morphism @xmath901 that extends as a continuous map on the underlying topological spaces .
a local computation then shows that the rational morphism extends to a morphism @xmath902 of algebraic spaces .
pulling back the universal family from @xmath822 to @xmath31 , we obtain the desired family @xmath36 inducing our original family @xmath35 . | the classical kummer construction attaches to an abelian surface a k3 surface . as shioda and katsura showed ,
this construction breaks down for supersingular abelian surfaces in characteristic two . replacing supersingular abelian surfaces by the selfproduct of the rational cuspidal curve , and the sign involution by suitable infinitesimal group scheme actions ,
i give the correct kummer - type construction for this situation .
we encounter rational double points of type @xmath0 and @xmath1 , instead of type @xmath2 .
it turns out that the resulting surfaces are supersingular k3 surfaces with artin invariant one and two .
they lie in a 1-dimensional family obtained by simultaneous resolution , which exists after purely inseparable base change . |
source 79 in the radio catalog of kesteven ( 1968 ) lies directly in the galactic plane , @xmath3 ne of the galactic center .
it is a moderately large supernova remnant ( snr ) and is sometimes called g33.6 + 0.1 . radio observations ( velusamy , becker & seward 1991 )
show an outer shell , @xmath4 in diameter , which is approximately circular over the sw half of the remnant but with large indentations in the n and e boundaries .
the brightest part of the radio remnant is an interior region with shell - like form .
the southern part of this `` inner shell '' has the highest surface brightness in the remnant .
the distance has been determined by neutral h absorption measurements to be @xmath5 kpc by frail & clifton ( 1989 ) .
the first x - ray detection of kes 79 was made using the einstein observatory ( seaquist & gilmore 1982 ; velusamy , becker & seward 1991 ) and showed amorphous structure with a bright center .
this inspired a rosat observation ( seward & velusamy 1995 ) to search for crab - like structure in the interior .
the results , however , showed no indication of a central pulsar or pulsar - wind nebula .
the southern arc of the inner ring was found to be bright in x - rays and faint emission was observed from the outer shell , particularly close to the eastern indentation . assuming a thermal spectrum , analysis of the rosat data indicated an age of @xmath6 years , an x - ray luminosity of @xmath7 erg s@xmath2 , and an energy release of @xmath8 ergs in the sn explosion .
subsequent observations with asca ( sun & wang 2000 ) showed that the spectrum was indeed thermal with strong lines from mg , si and s. the global spectrum was fit well by a single nei model .
seward & velusamy ( 1995 ) speculated that this remnant might be younger and closer than believed and the result of a type ia supernova .
as evidence they cited : the circular shell , the fact that the absorption was the same as that in the path to w44 ( @xmath9 distant in the plane of the sky and only 3 kpc distant from the sun ) , and the lack of an observable pulsar .
the chandra observation described here shows that this is not the case .
in this paper we report the detection of a point - like source at the center of the remnant , which is likely to be a neutron star created in the sn explosion .
we discuss the spectrum , the apparent absence of any surrounding synchrotron emission , and briefly compare the source with similar objects .
discussion of the snr shell is defered to a subsequent publication .
chandra observed kes 79 on 31 july 2001 .
the observation was undertaken to better determine the shell - like structure and to measure spectra from different regions .
an exposure of 30 ks was obtained and there were no `` flares '' from particle - induced background .
the remnant was centered in the acis - i array and consequently spread over the four , @xmath10 square chips comprising the detector .
the telescope was dithered and images are exposure corrected so the gaps between chips do not appear in the images . because of the cti degradation of the detector ( chandra x - ray center 2001 ) , the spectral resolution is better along the ne and sw edges of the remnant than at the center .
we took this into account using appropriate tasks from the ciao software , version 2.1 , which was used for data analysis .
figure 1 shows the chandra image .
the data have been adaptively smoothed ( with the csmooth algorithm ) and show the bright inner shell of the remnant .
emission from the outer shell is weak and is hard to see ( except in the e indentation ) in this figure .
five unresolved sources are easily seen , including 3 within the shell .
the brightest , by an order of magnitude , is the source at the middle which is the subject of this paper .
the sources are labeled 1 - 5 in figure 1 , and table 1 lists their properties . the may 2002 chandra aspect solution was used . for sources within @xmath11 of the telescope axis the 90% certainty radius in the chandra position is @xmath12 .
positions were compared with the gsc 2.2 catalog ( stsci 2001 ) .
sources 3 ( @xmath13 off - axis ) and 4 ( @xmath14 off - axis ) are probably stars ; the x - ray spectra are soft and the x - ray source positions are @xmath15 and @xmath16 from optical counterparts , which shows the accuracy of the aspect determination for these parts of the field .
hardness ratios are given for eventual comparison with 2 surveys of serendipitous chandra sources , extragalactic ( green et al 2002 ) and galactic ( grindlay et al .
the hardness ratio , hr = h - s / h+s where s is the number of counts from 0.3 to 2.5 kev and h is the number of counts from 2.5 to 8 kev .
there is no counterpart brighter than r magnitude 19 for the central source ( 1 ) or for sources 2 and 5 .
because the spectra of sources 2 and 5 are hard , they are probably background agn . the radial profile of the central source is consistent with the expected chandra point - spread - function .
any extent is @xmath17 . thinking this likely to be an isolated neutron star , we searched for time variability and pulsations .
the light curve is constant within statistics - @xmath18 fluctuations @xmath19 20% on an hourly basis .
the search for periodicity was limited to periods longer than 6.4 s because the acis instrument , in normal mode , integrates for 3.2 s. an fft analysis showed no coherent power significantly above the noise , giving an upper limit of @xmath20% for pulsed power in this range . since many young pulsars are embedded in diffuse synchrotron radiation from a surrounding pwn , we searched for such a pwn at high energies . in the range 5 - 8 kev ,
the central source is still visible but diffuse emission is absent , both from the bright inner shell and from the vicinity of the central source . in the range 3 - 5 kev , shown in figure 2 ,
the inner ring is discernable and there is a small feature adjacent to the central source and extending sw .
the spectrum of emission from this sw feature shows mg and si lines , indicating that much of the emission is thermal .
since there are only 300 counts from this feature , model parameters can not be accurately determined from spectral fits . by subtracting
the thermal spectrum observed elsewhere in the remnant we estimate that up to about 1/3 of the emission from this @xmath21 feature could be non - thermal . assuming a power - law spectrum with photon index = 2 ( like the crab nebula ) , the upper limit to the luminosity of a pwn at this location is calculated to be @xmath22 ergs s@xmath2 .
this upper limit is about 1/4 the luminosity of the point - like source .
we note that a pwn is usually more luminous than the pulsar itself [ 20:1 for the crab pulsar ( toor & seward 1977 ) , 1.3:1 for the vela pulsar ( helfand et al 2001 ) ] the spectrum of the central source is shown in figure 3 and table 2 lists the results of spectral fits .
723 counts were extracted from a circle of radius @xmath23 , grouped over 9 acis energy channels , and were restricted to the energy band 0.8 - 4.7 kev .
the sherpa software was used for spectral fitting .
a power - law gives a fit which , although it produces an acceptable @xmath24 = 1.2 , is obviously too weak in the range 2 - 4 kev and too strong in the range 4 - 6 kev .
furthermore , the photon index , @xmath25 , is higher than observed for most cosmic sources and the value for absorption is high .
the asca measured @xmath26 was @xmath27 atoms @xmath28 and spectral fits to the bright thermal emission in our chandra data yield @xmath29 atoms @xmath28 . the central source spectrum is soft , softer than expected from an agn ( @xmath30 ) or from a pwn ( @xmath31)(e.g .
slane et al 2000 ) .
a single blackbody spectrum gives a good fit , shown in figure 3 , but with @xmath26 a bit lower than expected .
it is also not difficult to achieve good fits with 2-component spectra .
the soft component can be either blackbody or power law and is not well constrained .
a power law does not work well as the hard component and , if used as the soft component , only makes a small contribution to the emission .
if we require that @xmath32 atoms @xmath28 , the absorption observed by chandra for the diffuse part of the remnant , then a 2-component spectrum produces a better fit than a single blackbody spectrum but the relative contribution of the soft component is small .
values of parameters are given in table 2 .
chandra spectra of various parts of the diffuse remnant are all thermal .
the mg , si , and s lines detected by asca are prominent and there is not much variation from region to region . these data and their interpretation will be the subject of a second paper ( sun et al .
2002 ) .
central objects in snrs were well - understood when the only two known were the crab and vela pulsars .
for each of these objects , the pulsar characteristic age , p/2p , and the age of the surrounding remnant are about the same ( 950 years for the crab and @xmath33 years for the vela remnant ) , most of the energy radiated from the vicinity of the pulsar is nonthermal , and spin - down energy is adequate to power all emission from the pulsar and pwn .
now that more objects have been discovered , the situation is complex .
some putative neutron stars within remnants show no sign of non - thermal emission .
there is no pwn , the x - ray spectrum is more blackbody than power law , and no radio or gamma - ray pulsations have been observed .
these have been called `` radio - quiet '' pulsars and/or ccos ( compact central objects ) .
such objects are found in cas a ( murray et al . 2001 ; chakrabarty et al . 2001 ) , pup a ( zavlin et al . 1999 ) , pks 1209 - 51/52 ( zavlin et al . 2000 ; pavlov et al . 2002 ) and g347.3 - 0.5 ( slane et al .
properties of these objects are reviewed by pavlov , sanwal , garmire , and zavlin ( 2002 ) .
the kes 79 source appears to be of this type .
all have luminosities , @xmath0 between @xmath34 and @xmath35 erg s@xmath2 .
there is only one convincing case for pulsed emission ; the central source in pks 1209 - 51/52 has a period of 0.424 s , a sinusoidal pulse shape , and a pulsed fraction of @xmath36% ( zavlin et al .
2000 ; pavlov et al .
2002 ) .
we note that kes 79 was searched for radio pulsations by gorham et al .
( 1996 ) at 430 and 1420 mhz .
no pulsations were observed above a level of 0.7 mjy at 1420 mhz .
( this is rather weak support of the `` radio - quiet '' classification since a large fraction of pulsars discovered in modern surveys , ( e.g. manchester et al 2001 ) have lower fluxes than this limit . )
the x - ray spectra of all these objects are close to blackbody spectra .
the classical blackbody model , however , predicts a temperature which is too high and a surface area which is too small when compared with generally accepted models of neutron stars .
for example , chakrabarty et al .
( 2001 ) have fit the spectrum of the cas a object and find a temperature of 0.49 kev and star radius of 0.52 km ; compared with the 8 - 16 km radius expected .
the radiation source could be a single hot spot on the star surface but this is hard to reconcile with the observed lack of pulsations ( @xmath37 pulsed ) determined by murray et al .
. a light - element atmosphere will reduce the derived temperature and increase the derived radius .
lloyd , hernquist & heyl ( 2002 ) have calculated emergent spectra and find that the actual temperature , @xmath38 , is always less than the temperature , @xmath39 , derived by fitting a blackbody spectrum to the observed data .
chakrabarty et al .
( 2000 ) find that a h atmosphere model applied to the cas a source yields a temperature of 0.26 kev and a radius of 2.2 km .
they conclude that existing surface - radiation models do not explain the cas a object and that accretion models also fail to account for the lack of an optical counterpart .
the more luminous kes 79 object , if a classical blackbody , would require a radius of only 1.0 km to achieve the observed luminosity at the measured temperature of @xmath39 = 0.48 kev .
application of the light atmosphere model of lloyd , hernquist and heyl predicts that @xmath38 is a factor of 1.8 lower than @xmath39 , or 0.27 kev . this lower temperature would increase the required radius to 3.2 km , still short of the 8 - 16 km expected . since the theoretical models used so far have been simple , perhaps adjustments might be made in the model atmosphere to achieve a fit with a standard radius . obviously better models are needed . among the 5 central compact objects ( ccos )
mentioned , the most luminous is in the largest remnant , g347.3 - 0.5 .
the source in kes 79 is the second most luminous .
kes 79 is about the same size as pks 1209 - 51/52 but in a denser environment , so is probably older .
thus the central source in kes 79 may also be the second oldest specimen of the `` radio - quiet '' isolated pulsar group .
this agrees exactly with the conclusion of pavlov , sandwal , & garmire ( 2002 ) that the older ccos are more luminous .
if these central objects are similar , they are certainly not cooling rapidly and the apparent increase in emitting area with age is a mystery . certainly , the source in kes 79 is worthy of more study .
it happens to be in a remnant which has a well defined outer shell and , interpreting this as a shock , one can derive information about the sn explosion which produced it .
future work should include sensitive searches for radio and/or x - ray pulsations and , although none is expected , a sensitive search for an optical counterpart . | a chandra x - ray observation has detected an unresolved source at the center of the supernova remnant kes 79 . the best single - model fit to the source spectrum is a blackbody with an x - ray luminosity @xmath0(0.3 - 8.0 kev)=@xmath1 ergs s@xmath2 .
there is no evidence for a surrounding pulsar wind nebula .
there are no cataloged counterparts at other wavelengths , but the absorption is high .
the source properties are similar to the central source in cas a even though the kes 79 remnant is considerably older . |
it has been considered that the origin of heavy neutron - rich elements like uranium is mainly due to the @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis that occurs during the supernova explosions and/or neutron star mergers @xcite .
the main issue concerning the @xmath0-process research is to reproduce the three peaks ( @xmath3 80 , 130 , and 195 ) in the abundance pattern for the @xmath0-elements in the solar system . among models of the @xmath0-process , it has been believed that supernovae are the most plausible astrophysical site @xcite .
the explosion is triggered by the gravitational collapse of massive stars of @xmath4(e.g .
* ) . since a proto - neutron star is formed after the explosion , neutron - rich elements seem to be easily ejected by the supernova shock .
unfortunately all realistic numerical simulations concerning the collapse - driven supernovae have failed to explode the outer layer outside the fe - core @xcite .
therefore , plausible site / mechanism of the @xmath0-process has not yet been clarified . on the other hand , explosive nucleosynthesis that produces most elements up to
fe - group nuclei has been calculated under the assumption that the explosion is triggered from outside the fe - core whose location is defined as the _ mass cut _ @xcite ; the calculated abundances from c to ge are consistent with the supernova observations and the chemical evolution of galaxies @xcite . however
, this situation can not be applied to the @xmath0-process due to the large electron fraction @xmath5 and the low entropy distribution above the @xmath6 . a specific model of neutrino - wind with the very high entropy per baryon ( @xmath7 and @xmath8 ) has been suggested to reproduce up to the third peak in the abundance pattern of the @xmath0-process @xcite .
it should be noted that this model includes artificial parameters such as mass loss rates and initial conditions of hydrodynamical calculations @xcite . on the other hand ,
detailed @xmath0-process calculations that include the fission have not been fully performed .
if the @xmath0-process occurs along the paths of the neutron - drip line , the fission process should become important @xcite .
the explosive nucleosynthesis under the jet - like explosion is investigated with use of the two - dimensional hydrodynamical code @xcite , where strong @xmath9-rich freezeout region has emerged .
recently , two - dimensional magnetohydrodynamical ( mhd ) calculations have been performed under the various initial parameters concerning the rotation and magnetic field @xcite .
the zeus-2d code developed by @xcite has been modified to include a tabulated equation of state @xcite , electron captures , and neutrino transport @xcite .
various combinations have been investigated for the initial ratio of the rotational energy ( @xmath10 ) and/or magnetic energy ( @xmath11 ) to the gravitational energy ( @xmath12 ) . in case of the cylindrical profiles of the rotation and magnetic field , it is found that the shape of the shock wave becomes prolate compared to the case without magnetic fields though detailed studies of neutrino transport must be developed .
furthermore , the confined magnetic fields behind the shock front push the shock wave strongly
. the aspect ratio of the polar to the equatorial radius in the stalled shock front becomes 1.4 for the initial values of @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
it is noted that whether the initial models of stellar evolution include magnetorotational effects @xcite or not @xcite , no significant differences in the hydrodynamical features are found . in the present paper , we will carry out the calculations of the mhd explosion of the he - core of 3.3 @xmath1 whose mass in the main sequence stage is about 13 @xmath1 star .
thereafter , we investigate the r - process nucleosynthesis using the results of mhd calculations . we find new @xmath0-process site thanks to a large nuclear reaction network that includes fission ; we obtain the region that produces the @xmath0-process elements under the low @xmath15 . in 2 the full nuclear reaction network necessary to the @xmath0-process calculation
is constructed .
we describe initial models in 3 and give explosion models based on the mhd simulations .
the results of the @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis calculations are presented in 4 .
we summarize and discuss the results in 5 .
we have developed the nuclear reaction network that had been constructed for the rapid - proton capture process @xcite .
the network is extended toward the neutron - rich side to the neutron - drip line .
the full network consists of about 4000 nuclear species up to @xmath16 = 100 .
we include two body reactions , i.e. , ( n,@xmath17 ) , ( p,@xmath17 ) , ( @xmath9,@xmath17 ) , ( p , n ) , ( @xmath9,p ) , ( @xmath9,n ) , and their inverses .
this network contains specific reactions such as three body reactions , heavy ion reactions and weak interactions .
as shown in table [ tab : ntwk ] we construct two kinds of the network a and b that consist of different nuclear data set . for nuclear masses , the experimental data @xcite is used if available ; otherwise , the theoretical data by mass formula frdm @xcite is adopted in the range @xmath18 , and/or etfsi @xcite in @xmath19 .
most reaction rates are taken from the compilation ( reaclib ) of @xcite that includes experimental and theoretical data for the reaction rates and partition functions with use of frdm ( network a ) or etfsi ( network b ) .
reaction rates for @xmath20 that are not available in reaclib are taken from @xcite .
the rates on decay channels , @xmath9- , @xmath21-decay , and @xmath2-delayed neutron emission , are taken from jaeri @xcite , that includes experimental and theoretical decay rates of nuclei near the stability line .
on the @xmath2-decay rates not available in jaeri , theoretical rates by @xcite for network a or those by @xcite are adopted for network b. the same fission data is adopted for both network a and b. ( a ) _ spontaneous fission _ : experimental half lives and branching ratios of spontaneous fission are taken from @xcite and @xcite .
while theoretical formula of half life ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 23 ) ) with empirical fission barrier @xcite is adopted for nuclei whose half lives are not known experimentally , for all nuclei of both @xmath22 155 and @xmath23 240 , the life times of the decay are set to be @xmath24 s @xcite .
@xmath2-delayed fission _ : branching ratios of @xmath2-delayed fission are taken from @xcite . ( c ) _ fission yields _ : empirical formula ( * ? ? ?
( 5 ) ) is adopted about decay products .
since many charged particles participate in the nucleosynthesis during the explosion , we have included the screening effects for all relevant reactions @xcite .
we also use theoretical weak interaction rates that are the function of the density and temperature @xcite .
cr|cr|cr|cr|cr & & & & & & & & & + h & 1 3 & sc & 39 67 & nb & 83 125 & pm & 143 187 & tl & 203 263 + & 3 & & 67 & & 129 & & 187 & & 255 + he & 3 6 & ti & 40 70 & mo & 86 126 & sm & 144 188 & pb & 204 264 + & 6 & & 72 & & 132 & & 188 & & 259 + li & 6 8 & v & 43 73 & tc & 90 129 & eu & 151 189 & bi & 209 265 + & 8 & & 76 & & 133 & & 193 & & 263 + be&7 12 & cr & 44 74 & ru & 96 130 & gd & 152 190 & po & 210 266 + & 12 & & 78 & & 136 & & 196 & & 267 + b & 8 14 & mn & 46 77 & rh & 101 141 & tb & 155 198 & at & 211 269 + & 14 & & 81 & & 137 & & 197 & & 269 + c & 11 18 & fe & 47 78 & pd & 102 142 & dy & 156 212 & rn & 215 270
+ & 18 & & 84 & & 138 & & 202 & & 270 + n & 12 21 & co & 50 81 & ag & 105 149 & ho & 161 215 & fr & 218 271 + & 21 & & 85 & & 147 & & 203 & & 271 + o & 14 22 & ni & 51 82 & cd & 106 150 & er & 162 216 & ra & 221 272 + & 22 & & 86 & & 148 & & 208 & & 272 + f & 17 26 & cu & 56 91 & in & 111 155 & tm & 167 221 & ac & 224 273 + & 26 & & 89 & & 149 & & 215 & & 273 + ne & 7 30 & zn & 57 94 & sn & 112 156 & yb & 168 222 & th & 227 274 + & 34 & & 92 & & 154 & & 218 & & 274 + na&20 34 & ga & 60 95 & sb & 119 162 & lu & 173 224 & pa & 230 278 + & 37 & & 97 & & 161 & & 225 & & 277 + mg&20 36 & ge & 61 102 & te & 120 164 & hf & 174 226 & u & 232 280 + & 38 & & 100 & & 164 & & 228 & & 280 + al&22 41 & as & 64 103 & i & 123 171 & ta & 179 235 & np & 235 284 + & 41 & & 101 & & 165 & & 229 & & 284 + si&24 44 & se & 65 106 & xe & 124 180 & w & 180 236 & pu & 238 287 + & 46 & & 104 & & 168 & & 232 & & 288 + p & 27 45 & br & 68 117 & cs & 129 181 & re & 183 239 & am & 241 290 + & 49 & & 117 & & 181 & & 235 & & 292 + s & 28 48 & kr & 69 118 & ba & 130 182 & os & 184 240 & cm & 244 294 + & 50 & & 118 & & 182 & & 236 & & 296 + cl&31 51 & rb & 74 119 & la & 135 183 & ir & 189 241 & bk & 247 298 + & 51 & & 119 & & 183 & & 239 & & 300 + ar&32 56 & sr & 77 120 & ce & 136 184 & pt & 190 242 & cf & 250 302 + & 54 & & 120 & & 184 & & 243 & & 304 + k & 35 55 & y & 79 121 & pr & 141 185 & au & 195 257 & es & 253 306 + & 57 & & 121 & & 185 & & 247 & & 308 + ca&36 62 & zr & 81 122 & nd & 142 186 & hg & 196 258 & fm & 256 310 + & 60 & & 124 & & 186 & & 251 & & 312 +
the presupernova model has been calculated from the evolution of he - core of 3.3 @xmath25 that corresponds to 13 @xmath25 in the main sequence stage @xcite .
the mass of the fe - core is 1.18 @xmath1 that is the smallest fe - core in massive stars obtained from the stellar evolutionally calculation with the limitation of the spherical symmetry .
the edge of the fe - core that has steep density gradient is at @xmath26 cm from the center .
the mass of the si - rich layer is @xmath27 and the layer extends to @xmath28 cm above the fe - core . since the central density exceeds @xmath29 ( @xmath30 ) and temperature @xmath31 in units of @xmath32 k , the fe - core just begins to collapse .
initial models for the collapse calculations ( precollapse models ) are constructed by using the density and temperature distributions of the original fe+si core .
we adopt cylindrical properties of the angular velocity @xmath33 and the toroidal component of the magnetic field @xmath34 as follows @xcite : @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath16 are the distances from the rotational axis and the equatorial plane with @xmath37 and @xmath38 being model parameters .
both @xmath39 and @xmath40 are the initial values at @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
initial parameters of four precollapse models are given in table [ tab : ini ] .
the spherically symmetric case is denoted by model 1 . in model 2 ,
the profiles of rotation and magnetic field in the fe - core are taken to be nearly uniform .
we present model 4 as the case having a differentially rapid rotating core and strong magnetic fields .
an intermediate example , model 3 between model 2 and model 4 is prepared for reference . since the value of @xmath43 is higher compared to that used in @xcite by a few percents , we regard the present case of @xmath44 % as rather rapid rotating stars with the moderate magnetic field . in all computations ,
spherical coordinates @xmath45 are adopted . the computational region is set to be @xmath46 km and @xmath47 , where the included mass in the precollapse models amounts to @xmath48 .
the first quadrant of the meridian section is covered with @xmath49 mesh points .
to get information of mass elements , five thousand tracer particles are placed within the region of @xmath50 between @xmath51 ( @xmath52 km ) and @xmath53 ( @xmath54 km ) .
.initial parameters of precollapse models .
[ tab : ini ] [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we perform the calculations of the collapse , bounce , and the propagation of the shock wave with use of zeus-2d in which the realistic equation of state @xcite has been implemented by @xcite .
we do not include the neutrino transport , since our aim is to clarify the differences in the nucleosynthesis between spherical and mhd jet explosion .
it is noted that the contribution of the nuclear energy generation is usually negligible compared to the shock energy . in table
[ tab : res ] , our results of mhd calculations are summarized .
@xmath55 is the explosion energy when the shock reaches the edge of the fe - core @xcite . in model 3 ,
the explosion is failed due to the specific combination of rotation and magnetic field between the values of model 2 and model 4 ; although @xmath55 still exists , the radial distance from the center in the generated shock front at the bounce shrinks gradually after a few oscillations of the front .
therefore , it does not always depend on @xmath43 and/or @xmath56 whether the explosion succeeds or not . in figs .
[ fig : part1 ] and [ fig : part2 ] trajectories of tracer particles are shown for some specified values of @xmath15 . while the jet - like explosion occurs along the equator in model 2 ( fig .
[ fig : part1 ] ) , collimated jet is emerged from the rotational axis in model 4 ( fig .
[ fig : part2 ] ) .
figure [ fig : rts ] shows the density , temperature , and entropy per baryon in @xmath57 of the tracer particles in fig .
[ fig : part2 ] .
we find after the jet - like explosion of model 4 that it remains 1.24 @xmath1 proto - neutron star inside the radius 300 km accompanying successive accretion onto the star with @xmath58 at @xmath59 s. ) of @xmath60 ms during the simulation ( model 2 ) .
the edge of the fe - core in the precollapse model is shown by the thick - dotted line .
the values of @xmath15 correspond to those in the last stage of nse for each tracer particle .
[ fig : part1],title="fig:",width=604 ] + but for the final stage ( @xmath61 ) of @xmath62 ms ( model 4 ) .
[ fig : part2],title="fig:",width=1133 ] + .
each curve corresponds to that in fig .
[ fig : part2 ] ( model 4 ) .
[ fig : rts],title="fig:",width=340 ] .
each curve corresponds to that in fig .
[ fig : part2 ] ( model 4 ) .
[ fig : rts],title="fig:",width=340 ] + .
each curve corresponds to that in fig .
[ fig : part2 ] ( model 4 ) .
[ fig : rts],title="fig:",width=340 ] +
during the explosion , the temperature exceeds @xmath64 k around the layers of the si+fe core , where the region of the nuclear statistical equilibrium ( nse ) is realized as shown in fig .
[ fig : rts ] .
therefore , we follow the change in @xmath15 of the ejected tracer particle due to the weak interactions of electron / positron captures , and @xmath65-decays until the last stage of nse .
we set this stage to be @xmath66 ; afterward the temperature decreases in time as shown in fig .
[ fig : rts ] .
the change in @xmath15 is calculated from the relation @xmath67y_i , \ ] ] where for the abundance @xmath68 , @xmath69 consists of the @xmath70 and positron capture rates , and @xmath71 consists of the @xmath72 and electron capture rates , respectively .
time evolutions of @xmath15 relevant to the @xmath0-process are shown in fig .
[ yetm ] ( left panels ) .
the trajectories of tracer particles with @xmath73 are depicted in fig .
[ fig : part1 ] for model 2 and those with @xmath74 in fig .
[ fig : part2 ] for model 4 , respectively ; the values of @xmath15 indicate those of the last stage of the nse calculation . in model 4 , the polar region
is ejected having rather high value of @xmath8 .
the lowest value of @xmath75 is discovered from around the region inclined at 20 30 degrees from the rotational axis .
thereafter , using the compositions obtained from the last nse stage and the profiles of the density and temperature during the explosion , we perform the @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis with the nuclear reaction network described in 2 .
we remark that after the last stage of the nse , the changes in @xmath15 for fig .
[ yetm ] are obtained from the calculations by the full network .
after the time @xmath76 , both the temperature and density are extrapolated to @xmath77 s ( @xmath78 ) in proportion to @xmath79 with @xmath80 for the temperature and @xmath81 for the density , respectively @xcite .
we consider that the qualitative results of the @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis do not depend much on the value of @xmath82 .
figures [ yetm ] ( right panels ) show the ejected mass in @xmath1 against @xmath15 in the range @xmath83 . for the spherical explosion , materials with @xmath84
is ejected .
the ejection for @xmath85 occurs from inside the fe - core in the range of @xmath86 km . on the other hand
, ejection occurs in the direction of the equator with @xmath87 for model 2 . as shown in fig .
[ fig : part2 ] , materials with @xmath88 are emerged for the jet - like explosion along the rotational axis ( model 4 ) . for both models 2 and 4
, the ejection for @xmath89 comes from the si - rich layer .
we recognize that as against the spherical explosion , jet - like explosion of model 4 decreases @xmath15 significantly .
+ + + we calculated the @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis during the mhd explosion using networks a and b. the progress in the @xmath0-process is shown in fig .
[ rpro ] at three epochs in model 4 .
since @xmath15 decreases to 0.158 at the last stage of nse , the @xmath0-process paths reach to the neutron drip line .
figures [ modelfrdm ] and [ modelet ] show the comparison of the solar @xmath0-process abundances with obtained abundances .
generally , compared to the spherical explosion the jet - like explosion results in the increase of the nuclei for @xmath90 .
the reproduction of the peaks in the distributions of the @xmath0-elements depends on the decrease in @xmath15 during the early phase of the explosion ( @xmath91 ) . in model 1 ,
the produced @xmath0-elements are not enough to explain even the second peak in the @xmath0-process pattern . in model 2 , although the second peak is reproduced well , the amount of the produced @xmath0-elements are too small to explain the third peak . for model 4
we succeed in making the global abundance pattern of the @xmath0-elements from the first to the third peak . moreover , we find that the fission cycling leads to the normal @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis based on ( n,@xmath17 ) @xmath92 ( @xmath17,n ) equilibrium accompanied with @xmath2-decays for the low @xmath15 region ( @xmath93 ) . on the other hand , distribution of final products
are found to be much sensitive to the mass formula as seen in the differences between figs .
[ modelfrdm ] and [ modelet ] .
this is because the global @xmath0-process pattern and the profiles of the peaks in the abundance pattern depend on the @xmath2-decay rates that have been calculated using the mass formulae explained in 2 .
-process nucleosynthesis during the jet - like explosion of model 4 ; ( @xmath94 , @xmath15 ) = ( 0.489 s , 0.161 ) : upper , ( 1.650 s , 0.312 ) : middle , and ( 2.760 s , 0.372 ) : lower .
the tracer particle has @xmath95 in the last stage of nse : @xmath96 at @xmath97 s from the beginning of the collapse.,title="fig:",width=566 ] -process nucleosynthesis during the jet - like explosion of model 4 ; ( @xmath94 , @xmath15 ) = ( 0.489 s , 0.161 ) : upper , ( 1.650 s , 0.312 ) : middle , and ( 2.760 s , 0.372 ) : lower .
the tracer particle has @xmath95 in the last stage of nse : @xmath96 at @xmath97 s from the beginning of the collapse.,title="fig:",width=566 ] -process nucleosynthesis during the jet - like explosion of model 4 ; ( @xmath94 , @xmath15 ) = ( 0.489 s , 0.161 ) : upper , ( 1.650 s , 0.312 ) : middle , and ( 2.760 s , 0.372 ) : lower .
the tracer particle has @xmath95 in the last stage of nse : @xmath96 at @xmath97 s from the beginning of the collapse.,title="fig:",width=566 ] + + + + + + + +
using zeus-2d , we find the thermodynamical conditions for the @xmath0-process to occur . the appropriate condition of the density , temperature and @xmath15 can be satisfied under the initial rotation law and the magnetic field strength of the precollapse model ; the jet between the polar and the equatorial radius produces the @xmath0-process elements which emerge from the si - rich layers above the fe - core .
contrary to the calculation under an artificial explosion energy and a @xmath6 located outside the fe - core in the spherical model @xcite , we have pursued the calculation from the collapse to the bounce , and shock wave propagation that attains to the edge of the fe - core .
while the spherical explosion reproduces at most to the beginning of the second peak in the abundance pattern of the solar @xmath0-elements , jet - like explosion due to the effects of mhd in the direction of the rotational axis succeeds in reproducing the third peak . however , our results depend on the initial parameters for both the strength of the rotation and magnetic field . for
the jet - like explosion from the equator , the reproduction of the @xmath0-elements is limited to the second peak .
we stress that the @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis can have many variations if the mhd effects play an important role in the supernova explosion . the shape and the position of peaks depend crucially on the mass formula and @xmath2-decay rates .
however , it is considered that theoretical data on @xmath2-decay rates has large uncertainty .
therefore , model 4 can reproduce well the solar @xmath0-process abundance pattern within the uncertainties of @xmath2-decay rates .
the @xmath2-decay rates calculated by the gross theory are tend to become small compared to those obtained by shell model computations . as a consequence ,
network a makes the three peaks more clearly than network b. small abundance peak around @xmath98 is not built enough in the present calculations for both networks .
it is hoped that the information of the @xmath0-process acquired through theoretical and observational studies may give severe constraints to the nuclear data . in the present calculation
, the fission process does not play an important role , since the ejected mass of the very low @xmath15 region is small . however , production of abundances for @xmath99 may need the region of @xmath100 as suggested in figs .
[ modelfrdm ] and [ modelet ] .
furthermore , fission should be included in the @xmath0-process calculation for the situation of very low @xmath15 such as a neutron star merger with @xmath101 @xcite . as shown in table [ tab : res ] ejected mass of the @xmath0-elements amounts to @xmath102 in case of model 4 that is one tenth of the total ejected mass .
since the ejected mass of oxygen is @xmath103 for the spherical explosion of the @xmath104 helium core @xcite , the ratio @xmath105 is large by a factor of 100 compared to the corresponding solar ratio of @xmath106 .
it has been pointed out for the explosion of massive stars the underproduction of the p - nuclides with respect to oxygen , when normalized to the solar values @xcite .
however it is found that as far as the case in the 3.3 @xmath1 helium core , produced p - nuclides are free from the problem of the underproduction @xcite .
considering uncertainties neglected in the present simulations and the differences in the nucleosynthesis between the spherical and jet - like explosion , the problem of the overproduction in the @xmath0-elements should be worth while to examine in detail . in the present investigation , as the first step
we ignore the effects of neutrino transport .
it is known that neutrinos take off the explosion energy significantly .
therefore , delayed explosion by neutrino heating is the most promising scope of the supernova explosion
. however , there exists difficulties related to the two dimensional treatment of neutrino transport @xcite : even one dimensional simulations that include the detailed neutrino transport process do not succeed in the explosion @xcite .
our purpose has been to study the effects of the mhd jet on the @xmath0-process and elucidate the differences in the produced @xmath0-elements from the spherical explosion .
for the next step , some investigations that include the neutrino transport will be pursued .
audi , g. , & wapstra , a. h. 1995 , , 595 , 409 freiburghaus , c. , rosswog , s. , thielmann , f .- k . 1999 , apj , 525 , l121 fuller , g. m. , fowler , w. a. , & newman , m. 1980 , apjs 42 447 fuller , g. m. , fowler , w. a. , & newman , m. 1982 , apjs 48 279 goriely , s. ( 2002 ) , in proc . of nuclei in the cosmos vii ( japan , july 2002 ) in press ,
most : http://www-astro.ulb.ac.be/nucdata hashimoto , m. , nomoto , k. , @xmath107 shigeyama , t. 1989 , a@xmath107a , 210 , l5 .
hashimoto , m. 1995 , prog .
theor . phys .
heger , a. , woosley , s. e. , langer , n. , & spruit , h. c. in iau symp .
215 , stellar rotaion , in press ( astro - ph/0301374 ) horiguchi , t. , tachibana , t. , & katakura , t. 1996 , chart of the nuclides ( ibaraki : nucl .
data center ) k@xmath108ppeler , f. , beer , h. and wisshak , k. 1989 , rep .
52 945 janka , h .- th .
192 , in press ( astro - ph/0401461 ) kinsey , r. r. et al .
, the nudat / pcnudat program for nuclear data , the 9 th international symposium of capture - gamma - ray spectroscopy and related topics , budapest , hungary , october ( 1996 ) kodama , t. , @xmath107 takahashi , k. 1975 nucl .
koike , o. , hashimoto , m. , kuromizu , r. , fujimoto , s. , 2004 , , 603 , 242 kotake , k. , sawai , h. , yamada , s. , & sato , k. 2004 , , 608 , 391 kotake , k. , yamada , s. , sato , k. , sumiyoshi , k. , ono , h. , & suzuki , h. 2004 , phys .
d. , 609 , 124004 kotake , k. , yamada , s. , & sato , k. 2005 , , 618 , 474 mamdouh , a. , pearson , j.m . , rayet , m. , & tondeur , f. 1999 , .
644 , 389 mamdouh , a. , pearson , j.m . ,
rayet , m. , & tondeur , f. 2001 , .
679 , 337 m@xmath109ller , p. , myers , w. d. , & swiatecki , w. j. 1995 , at .
data nucl .
data tables , 59 , 185 m@xmath109ller , p. , nix , j. r. , kratz , k .-
1997 , atomic data and nuclear data tables , vol .
nagataki , s. , hashimoto , m. , sato , k. , & yamada , s. 1997 , , 486 , 1026 panov , i. v. , freiburghaus , c. , thielmann , f .- k .
2001 , nucl .
a688 587c .
qian y .- z .
2003 , prog .
50 , 153 qian , y - z .
2005 , first argonne / msu / jina / int ria wokshop rauscher , t. , & thielemann , f .- k .
2000 , at .
data nucl .
data tables 75 1 rauscher , t. , & thielemann , f .- k .
2001 , at .
data nucl .
data tables , 79 47 rayet , m. , arnould , m. , hashimoto , m. , prantzos , n. , & nomoto , k. 1995 , a&a 298 , 517 staudt , a. , klapdor - kleingrothaus , h. v. 1992 , nucl .
a549 254 rosswog , s.k . ,
freiburghaus , c. , & thielemann , f .- k .
2001 , nucl .
a688 , 344 shen , h. , toki , h. , oyamatsu , k. , & sumiyoshi , k. 1998 , nucl . phys .
a. , 637 , 435 stone , j. m. , & norman , m. l. 1992 , , 80 , 791 sumiyoshi , k. et al .
2000 , pub .
japan , 52 601 sumiyoshi , k. et al .
2001 , , 561 , 880 tachibana , t. , & yamada , m. proc .
conf on exotic nuclei and atomic masses , arles , 1995 , p.763 takiwaki , t. , kotake , k. , nagataki , s. , & sato , k. 2004 , , 616 , 1086 thielemann , f .- k . ,
nomoto , k. , & hashimoto , m. , 1996 , , 460 , 408 thielemann , f .- k .
proceedings of 1crc 2001 : 1copernicus gesellschaft 2001 timmes , f. x. , woosley , s. e. , & weaver , t. a. 1995 , , 98 , 617 tsujimoto , t. , iwamoto , k. , hashimoto , m. , nomoto , k. , & f - k thielemann + 1993 in origin and evolution of the elements , world scientific , 50 woosley , s. e. , & weaver , t. a. 1995 , , 101 , 181 yamada , s. , & sawai , h. , 2004 , , 608 , 907 yamada , s. , kotake , k. , & yamasaki , t. 2004 , new .
j. phys . , 6 , 79 | we investigate @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis during the magnetohydrodynamical ( mhd ) explosion of supernova in a massive star of 13 @xmath1 .
contrary to the case of the spherical explosion , jet - like explosion due to the combined effects of the rotation and magnetic field lowers the electron fraction significantly inside the layers above the iron core .
we find that the ejected material of low electron fraction responsible for the @xmath0-process comes out from the silicon rich layer of the presupernova model .
this leads to the production up to the third peak in the solar @xmath0-process elements .
we examine whether the fission affects the @xmath0-process paths by using the full nuclear reaction network with both the spontaneous and @xmath2-delayed fission included .
moreover , we pay particular attention how the mass formula affects the @xmath0-process peaks with use of two mass formulae .
it is found that both formulae can reproduce the global abundance pattern up to the third peak though detailed distributions are rather different .
we point out that there are variations in the @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis if the mhd effects play an important role in the supernova explosion . |
the theory that the star formation process in a molecular cloud is controlled by the magnetic field and ambipolar diffusion has been studied for many years ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in the theory , the mass - to - flux ratio , which corresponds to the relative strength of gravity and the magnetic field , is an important parameter for the process .
if the mass - to - flux ratio is greater than its critical value ( i.e. , supercritical : gravity dominates the magnetic field ) , the cloud is likely to collapse or fragment on the dynamical timescale .
if the mass - to - flux ratio is less than its critical value ( i.e. , subcritical : the magnetic field dominates gravity ) , the gravitational driven collapse or fragmentation occurs on the ambipolar diffusion timescale ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) instead of the dynamical timescale as long as the diffusion timescale is longer than the dynamical timescale . although there are some observational difficulties to determine whether the mass - to - flux ratio of molecular clouds are greater or lesser than the critical value prior to core formation ( e.g. * ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , subcritical molecular clouds are consistent with some observations that show that molecular clouds are associated with large - scale ordered magnetic fields ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . here , we focus on fragmentation and core formation in subcritical molecular clouds
. the first numerical simulations of fragmentation in subcritical clouds with ambipolar diffusion were performed by @xcite under the assumption of a two - dimensional infinitesimally thin sheet .
@xcite carried out simulations of magnetized sheets including the effect of a finite disk half - thickness that was consistent with hydrostatic equilibrium .
a three - dimensional simulation of fragmentation and core formation in subcritical clouds with ambipolar diffusion , including full gravitational stratification along the magnetic field , was first performed by @xcite .
these numerical calculations confirmed that the gravitationally driven fragmentation and core formation in subcritical clouds occur on the ambipolar diffusion timescale .
core formation in subcritical clouds generally explains the low star formation rate in our galaxy , since the typical ambipolar diffusion time is more than 10 times longer than the dynamical time in molecular clouds . on the other hand ,
a problem has been pointed out that the ratio of starless and stellar cores is smaller than that is expected from the theory ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the observations mean that core formation is likely to occur on up to several dynamical times , i.e. , the usual ambipolar diffusion time is about @xmath0 times longer than that expected from the observations .
ideas to solve the timescale problem were proposed by @xcite , who pointed out that fluctuating magnetic fields and density in turbulent molecular clouds can enhance the ambipolar diffusion rate because the ambipolar diffusion is a process of nonlinear diffusion .
their analysis indicated that the density fluctuation enhances the diffusion rate more efficiently when the amplitude of the fluctuation is large .
their idea is consistent with the fact that supersonic turbulence is considered to be a significant factor in molecular clouds as well as for magnetic fields during the early stage of star formation ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , since the supersonic turbulence tends to enhance the density through compression .
@xcite carried out numerical simulations of fragmentation in subcritical clouds with a thin - sheet approximation , including both ambipolar diffusion and supersonic turbulent flow .
they found that the timescale of core formation in subcritical clouds is reduced by the supersonic turbulent flow as long as the turbulence is dominated by large - scale fluctuations .
@xcite confirmed the fast core formation by nonlinear large - scale turbulent flows with a numerical simulation using the thin - sheet approximation .
they also found that the subcritical clouds experienced rebounds after the first compression and showed several oscillations before the core formation as long as the initial flow speed is trans - alfvnic .
these results were also confirmed by @xcite and @xcite through three - dimensional simulations without the thin - sheet approximation .
@xcite found that the core formation time ( @xmath1 ) roughly scales as @xmath2 , where @xmath3 represents the first density peak created by the compression induced by the supersonic turbulent flow .
@xcite also confirmed that the core formation time is shorter when the turbulent flow speed is greater .
although these results indicate that the density enhancement in subcritical clouds is an important factor to shorten the core formation time , they did not clarify the physical process of how the density enhancement shortens the core formation time as well as how the core formation time depends on the turbulent flow speed .
this motivates us to carry out further investigations of the induced core formation by nonlinear flows in subcritical clouds .
previous studies indicated that large - scale compression would be the key process to enhance the ambipolar diffusion rate . in this short paper
, we present the investigation of the core formation under a simple large - scale nonlinear flow rather than complex turbulent flows .
we study basic properties of the core formation in subcritical clouds to achieve a clear explanation of how the fast ambipolar diffusion is induced by large - scale compression in the clouds .
this paper is organized as follows .
we have a brief description of the setup for numerical simulations in section 2 . the numerical results and its semi - analytical explanation
are given in section 3 .
we summarize the results and have some discussions in section 4 .
the numerical setup in this paper is similar to that used in @xcite , but spatial symmetry is assumed in one of the directions perpendicular to the magnetic field . we effectively solve the magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) equations in two spacial dimensions with self - gravity and ambipolar diffusion . the equation for the time evolution of the magnetic field with ambipolar diffusion is assumed to be the one - fluid model as @xmath4 , \label{eq : ind}\ ] ] where @xmath5 is the magnetic field , @xmath6 is the velocity , @xmath7 is the density of neutral gas , @xmath8 g@xmath9@xmath10 s is used as the typical value in molecular clouds ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
in the two - dimensional cartesian coordinate system @xmath11 , the initial magnetic field is assumed to be uniform along the @xmath12-direction : @xmath13 where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the magnetic field components of the @xmath16- and @xmath12-directions , respectively , and @xmath17 is constant . in this coordinate system , we assume physical variables are constant along the direction perpendicular to both the @xmath16- and @xmath12-directions . the initial hydrostatic equilibrium of a self - gravitating cloud along the magnetic field ( @xmath12-direction ) is assumed .
if the temperature of the cloud is uniform throughout the region , the analytic density distribution @xmath18 was obtained by @xcite : @xmath19 where @xmath20 @xmath21 is the density at @xmath22 , @xmath23 is the sound speed , and @xmath24 is the gravitational constant . instead of the uniform temperature , we use the hyperbolic tangent function for temperature distribution that shows a sharp transition from low temperature to 10 times higher temperature around @xmath25 ( see * ? ? ?
this function mimics the situation that warm gas commonly surrounds the isothermal molecular cloud .
the initial hydrostatic density distribution obtained from the temperature distribution is almost the same as that of equation ( [ eq : sp ] ) in the low temperature region in which we are interested .
we model molecular clouds in the number density range @xmath26 @xmath27 @xmath28 . since the the cooling time is much shorter than the dynamical time in this density range , we adopt isothermality for each lagrangian fluid element @xcite . in the sheet
we mimic the largest mode of a turbulent flow with an initial sinusoidal velocity fluctuation along the @xmath16-direction : @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the velocity component of @xmath16-direction , @xmath31 is the velocity amplitude of the fluctuation and a variable parameter in this work , and @xmath32 is fixed to equal @xmath33 throughout the paper
. the most unstable wavelength of gravitational instability is about @xmath34 in the case with no magnetic field @xcite , and the corresponding wavelength with magnetic field is expected to be close to @xmath34 unless the cloud is marginally critical @xcite . due to this sinusoidal velocity fluctuation , the initial flow converges the cloud toward @xmath35 .
since the symmetry is assumed in the direction perpendicular to the @xmath16- and @xmath12-directions , the converging flow makes a filamentary structure rather than a spherical one . in the previous three - dimensional simulations of large - scale turbulent flows with energy spectrum of @xmath36 ( kudoh & basu 2011 ) , where @xmath37 is the wave number of the turbulence , a similar filamentary structure is produced in the cloud before the gravitational fragmentation .
the sinusoidal velocity fluctuation is a simple model to simulate the fragmentation and collapse in a large - scale turbulent flow . as units for this problem , @xmath38 , @xmath23 , and @xmath21
are chosen for length , velocity , and density , respectively .
these give a time unit @xmath39 .
the strength of the initial magnetic field brings one dimensionless free parameter , @xmath40 the parameter @xmath41 represents the initial ratio of gas to magnetic pressure at @xmath22 , and has a relation with @xmath42 as @xmath43 where @xmath42 is the the mass - to - flux ratio normalized to the critical value of the cloud whose density distribution is described by equation ( [ eq : sp ] ) ( see * ? ? ? * ) . since we are interested in subcritical clouds , we take @xmath44 values less than @xmath45 in this paper .
dimensional values can be obtained by specifying @xmath21 and @xmath23 . in the case of @xmath46
km s@xmath47 and @xmath48 @xmath28 where @xmath49 , we obtain @xmath50 pc , @xmath51 year , and @xmath52 g if @xmath53 .
the numerical methods are based on those of @xcite for solving the mhd equations and @xcite for solving the self - gravity .
the calculating area is taken to be @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
the number of grid points is 256 for the @xmath16-direction and 40 for the @xmath12-direction . a mirror - symmetric boundary at @xmath22 and periodic boundaries in the @xmath16-directions are used .
a mirror - symmetric boundary is also used at the upper boundary ( @xmath56 ) for convenience except for the gravitational potential ( see details and discussion in @xcite ) . as it was done before @xcite
, the ambipolar diffusion term is assumed to work only when the density exceeds a certain value , @xmath57 to prevent small time steps occurring outside of the low temperature cloud .
the summary of the models and parameters for the simulations are given in table 1 . in this table ,
the values of the free parameters @xmath41 and @xmath31 are listed .
the parameter @xmath31 is listed both normalized by the sound speed @xmath23 and the initial alfvn speed @xmath58 on the midplane ( @xmath22 ) of the clouds , where @xmath59 .
the core formation time @xmath1 , which is characterized as the time when the maximum density attained 100 @xmath21 , is also listed .
the definition of @xmath1 is the same as that in @xcite .
although @xmath1 is defined from a practical restriction of the numerical simulation , the center of the core always showed the features of runaway collapse at that time . in the models
a003 to a10 , the amplitude of the initial velocity fluctuation @xmath31 is changed with the fixed @xmath60 . in the models
b01 to b15 , @xmath31 is changed with the fixed @xmath61 . in the models
c1 to c7 , @xmath31 is also changed with the fixed @xmath62 . in the models
d3 to d15 , @xmath31 is changed with a fixed @xmath63 .
in addition to these models , the model e5 is also introduced , with the same parameters as those of model a5 except that the ambipolar diffusion is artificially switched off . in figure
[ fig1 ] , the snapshot of the logarithmic density for the model a5 is shown as a color map , when the maximum density becomes greater than a hundred times of the initial density .
the vectors overlaid in figure [ fig1 ] indicate the velocity .
since the initial flow converges the cloud toward @xmath35 , the figure shows that a collapsing core is located at the origin of the coordinate .
the shape of the core is approximately oblate whose apse line is along the @xmath16-direction in spite of the converging flow .
this is because the core formation does not occur during the first compression , but it occurs gradually in the oscillating cloud .
we will see this process in figure [ fig5 ] later .
the logarithmic plasma @xmath64 ( the ratio of gas pressure to magnetic pressure ) for the model a5 is shown in figure [ fig2 ] at the same time as that of figure [ fig1 ] . figure [ fig2 ] shows that @xmath64 is greater than 1 near the center of the core , though the initial @xmath64 is @xmath65 on @xmath22 ( @xmath53 ) .
it means that the magnetic flux has been removed from the core and the mass - to - flux ratio of the collapsing core is expected to be greater than 1 ( see equation [ eq : bms ] ) , i.e. , the core is supercritical around the center .
we will see this feature again in the following discussion .
figure [ fig3 ] shows the snapshot ( @xmath66 ) of the spatial profiles of density , magnetic field strength , and x - velocity along @xmath16 on @xmath22 for the model a5 .
both the density and magnetic field have peaks at @xmath35 where the flow converges .
the flow remains large scale and does not become turbulent in this simulation .
figure [ fig4 ] shows the snapshot ( @xmath66 ) of spatial profiles of surface density ( @xmath67 ) and normalized mass - to - flux ratio ( @xmath68 ) along @xmath16 for the same model a5 .
they are conventionally defined in the following equations : @xmath69 @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the upper boundary value in the calculating area , and @xmath72 is the @xmath12 component of the magnetic field at @xmath22 .
the normalized mass - to - flux ratio is greater than 1 near the peak of the surface density .
this means that the region has evolved from a subcritical to supercritical state through the removal of magnetic flux . in figure
[ fig4 ] , the square root of plasma @xmath64 at @xmath22 is also plotted .
it shows that @xmath73 follows a similar profile as that of the normalized mass - to - flux ratio , and @xmath64 is nearly greater than 1 where @xmath68 is greater than 1 . since @xmath64 is locally defined in the simulation , it is convenient to use @xmath64 as an approximate indicator of the magnetic criticality of the cloud , although it is not exactly the same as @xmath68 .
figure [ fig5 ] shows the time evolution of the density at the location of the core center ( @xmath74 ) , i.e. , @xmath75 .
the solid line shows the case of model a5 .
the density increases during the first compression of the cloud .
next , it bounces and undergoes oscillations .
finally , the dense region goes into runaway collapse after @xmath76 .
figure [ fig6 ] shows the time evolution of @xmath64 at the the core center ( @xmath77 ) . in the very initial stage of the compression ( @xmath78 ) ,
@xmath77 rapidly decreases , but it increases soon as the density reaches a peak around @xmath79 .
after that , it decreases and shows oscillations as seen in the time evolution of the density .
eventually , it gradually increases with oscillations and becomes greater than @xmath45 when the runaway collapse happens .
since @xmath77 approximately equals the square of the mass - to - flux ratio , the runaway collapsing core is expected to be supercritical .
figure [ fig6 ] , as well as figure [ fig2 ] and figure [ fig4 ] , shows that @xmath77 can be a good indicator of the mass - to - flux ratio during the oscillations , even though the gravitational equilibrium of the gas is not exactly established at the final stage of the simulation .
the first rapid decrease of @xmath77 ( @xmath78 ) could be a result of the non - equilibrium of the gas along the magnetic field .
the dotted lines in figures [ fig5 ] and [ fig6 ] show the case of model e5 in which the parameters are the same as those of model a5 except that the ambipolar diffusion is artificially switched off .
when the ambipolar diffusion is switched off , the density and @xmath77 do not show the feature of collapse while they do show oscillations .
this also indicates that the collapse is caused by the removal of the magnetic flux through the ambipolar diffusion . in figures [ fig5 ] and [ fig6 ] ,
the dashed lines show the case of model a3 whose initial converging flow speed is smaller than that of model a5 , and dotted - dashed lines show the case of the model a10 whose initial flow speed is larger than that of the model a5 .
the overall features of the time evolutions are qualitatively similar , though the core formation time is shorter when the initial flow speed is greater . when the initial flow speed is high enough ( for the model a10 ) , @xmath77 becomes greater than @xmath45 at the first peak . in that case , it rebounds a little bit , but goes into runaway collapse very soon .
figure [ fig7 ] shows the core formation time as a function of the initial flow speed @xmath31 .
the flow speed is normalized by the sound speed .
the filled circles show the case of @xmath53 ( the models a003 to a10 ) .
the open squares show the case of @xmath80 ( the models b01 to b15 ) .
the open triangles show the case of @xmath81 ( the models c1 to c7 ) .
the filled triangles show the case of @xmath82 ( the models d3 to d15 ) . as the flow speed increases , the core formation time decreases for each set of @xmath44 values .
the case of the smaller @xmath44 , i.e. , the smaller initial mass - to - flux ratio , shows a longer core formation time for the same initial flow speed .
the flow speed normalized by the sound speed may be useful when the results are compared with observations . on the other hand , in figure [ fig8 ] , we plot the core formation time as a function of @xmath31 , like in figure [ fig7 ] , but normalized by the initial alfvn speed on the midplane of the clouds ( @xmath58 ) . in figure [ fig8 ] , all results fall on the same line regardless of the value of @xmath44 .
the core formation time is approximately the same for the same initial flow speed if it is normalized by the alfvn speed .
the dashed line shows the semi - analytic result which is obtained in the next subsection .
the core formation time is in inverse proportion to the square of @xmath31 , when @xmath31 is greater than @xmath58 .
we will have a detailed discussion of this result in the next subsection .
the core formation time is also shown in figure [ fig9 ] as a function of @xmath3 , defined as the value of the density peak during the first compression in the time evolution of the central density at @xmath35 and @xmath22 . as we have discussed in our previous paper ( figure @xmath83 in @xcite ) , the core formation time is proportional to @xmath84 when @xmath85 is enough greater than @xmath45 .
the dashed line shows the semi - analytic result obtained in the next subsection , which shows @xmath2 .
figure [ fig9 ] shows the relation clearly , and the figure also indicates that the relation does not depend on @xmath44 , i.e. , the initial mass - to - flux ratio .
the result is also discussed in the next subsection in detail . in this subsection
, we find the semi - analytical formulas of core formation time and compare them with the numerical results in the previous subsections . since figure [ fig5 ] and figure [ fig6 ] shows the oscillation of the cloud , we considered the cloud to be in an approximate force balance for a time average of the period .
when we assume force balance between the magnetic force and gravity along the @xmath16-axis in the cylindrical subcritical cloud @xcite , @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the line mass along the cylinder , @xmath88 is the half - size of the cloud in the @xmath16-direction , and @xmath89 is the half thickness of the cloud in @xmath12-direction . the magnetic field is derived from these two equations as @xmath90 from the equation ( [ eq : ind ] ) , the ambipolar diffusion time ( @xmath91 ) is estimated to be @xmath92 since the most unstable wave length of the subcritical cloud is about @xmath93 , we take @xmath94 therefore , we get @xmath95 this is the same equation that was derived in @xcite .
although we derive it for cylindrical clouds , the result does not depend on the geometry of the cloud .
the dashed line in figure [ fig9 ] is drawn from the equation ( [ eq : ambdt ] ) , when we use @xmath96 approximately .
the figure [ fig9 ] shows that the scaling relation agrees with the result of the numerical simulations .
the relation also indicates that it does not depend on the initial mass - to - flux ratio .
next , we consider the local pressure balance during the compression by the large scale flows . since the cloud is subcritical , the thermal pressure can be negligible .
then , the pressure balance along @xmath16 axis will be @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the nonlinear flow speed in the cloud and the subscripts @xmath99 mean the values before the compression .
when we assume that there is sufficient time for the vertical density structure to be put back into hydrostatic equilibrium , i.e. , @xmath100 , @xmath89 is estimated to be @xmath101 therefore , the equation ( [ eq : pb ] ) becomes @xmath102 in the isothermal gas , and this leads to @xmath103 when the ambipolar diffusion time is longer than the compression time , flux - freezing can be a good approximation during the compression , i.e. , @xmath104 where @xmath105 is the surface density . since @xmath106 ,
equation ( [ eq : flfz ] ) is compatible with @xmath107 in our approximation .
finally , equation ( [ eq : pb3 ] ) then becomes @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the square of the alfvn speed of the cloud . by using this equation ,
the equation for the ambipolar diffusion time ( [ eq : ambdt ] ) is expressed using the flow speed as @xmath110^{-1}. \label{eq : ambdtv}\ ] ] the dashed line in figure [ fig6 ] is drawn from the equation ( [ eq : ambdtv ] ) , when we use @xmath111 as an average speed .
the figure [ fig6 ] shows that the scaling relation agrees with the results of the numerical simulations .
when the flow speed is comparable to the alfvn speed , the ambipolar diffusion time is estimated to be @xmath112 which means the the ambipolar diffusion time is about three times shorter than that without the disturbance . when the flow speed is greater than the alfvn speed , @xmath113 which means that the ambipolar diffusion time is inversely proportional to the square of the nonlinear flow speed in a subcritical magnetic cloud
since the core formation time ( @xmath1 ) is almost comparable to the ambipolar diffusion time in a subcritical magnetic cloud , the relations @xmath114 and @xmath115^{-1 } \label{eq : cftv}\ ] ] are consistent with the results of the numerical simulations in figure [ fig8 ] and figure [ fig9 ] as long as the turbulent velocities ( @xmath116 ) are large enough to compress the cloud , using @xmath96 as a representative density and @xmath117 as an average speed .
when the observed turbulent speed is comparable to the alfvn speed , the core formation time is reduced by about @xmath118 times from the usual ambipolar diffusion time .
furthermore , the core formation time is considerably reduced when the turbulent speed is larger than the alfvn speed , i.e. , the core formation time is inversely proportional to the square of the turbulent speed . the equations ( [ eq : ambdt ] ) and ( [ eq : cftd ] ) are the same as those considered by @xcite .
although @xcite considered the static force balance of a subcritical cloud , we showed here that similar relations are applicable to the dynamically oscillating cloud .
in addition to the global force balance , a local pressure balance between the magnetic and dynamic pressure is assumed in the dynamically compressible subcritical cloud to obtain the velocity dependence of the ambipolar diffusion time , i.e. , the equations ( [ eq : ambdtv ] ) and ( [ eq : cftv ] ) . when equation ( [ eq : ambdtv ] ) is derived , the relation @xmath119 is used in the turbulent flows assuming magnetic flux freezing as in equation ( [ eq : flfz ] ) and ( [ eq : fluxf ] ) .
@xcite studied ambipolar diffusion with the limit of long - wave fluctuations and suggested that there is no net enhancement of the ambipolar diffusion when the density fluctuation depends on the magnetic field fluctuation as @xmath119 . in our case , however , the diffusion is enhanced even when the relation is satisfied .
the difference possibly may come from the fact that @xcite used a one - dimensional slab model in which the self - gravitational force does not change during the compression along the magnetic field lines if the surface density is constant . in our two - dimensional slab model ,
the compression perpendicular to the magnetic field enhances the self - gravitational force as well as the density .
our result essentially demonstrates the same result as that of the gravitationally driven ambipolar diffusion " discussed in @xcite etc , but the density enhancement along with that of the self - gravity is induced by the large - scale compressive turbulent flows .
we showed that the large - scale turbulence associated with density enhancement is an important factor for the fast core formation in turbulent subcritical clouds . in our analysis , the turbulence whose scale is larger than about @xmath34 , which is about @xmath120 pc for typical molecular clouds , is needed to get an effective fast ambipolar diffusion .
although the origin of the turbulence in molecular clouds has not yet been identified , the scale of the energy source of the turbulence is supposed to be larger than @xmath121 pc to realize the fast core formation considered in this paper . by comparison ,
the small - scale turbulence is also considered to be an important factor for the turbulent diffusion processes .
for example , the fast ambipolar diffusion rate in a turbulent medium was studied by @xcite to explain low magnetic field strength in dense interstellar gas .
@xcite pointed out that the turbulent reconnection diffusion " is also effective to remove the magnetic flux from subcritical cores .
these processes would be more efficient if the energy source of the turbulence in molecular clouds is originated in smaller scales .
since the large - scale turbulent flows even in two- or three - dimensional spaces tend to compress the cloud in a one - dimensional manner to make filamentary structures , as seen in @xcite and @xcite , our results can explain generally how core formation is accelerated by the nonlinear large - scale turbulent flows in subcritical magnetic clouds .
the results obtained in this paper would be applicable to a filamentary molecular cloud @xcite if it is created by a large - scale compression @xcite .
once the filamentary structure becomes supercritical by the accelerated ambipolar diffusion , the fragmentation along the filament would occur on a dynamical timescale to produce several cores .
when @xmath31 is much smaller than the the alfvn speed , figure [ fig8 ] shows that the equation ( [ eq : ambdtv ] ) does not fit to the numerical results well .
this comes from the fact that the equation ( [ eq : ambdt ] ) also does not fit to the numerical results well in figure [ fig9 ] , when the density peak is small .
when the density peak is very small , the assumption of the force balance between gravity and magnetic force for the density peak , which is used to derive equation ( [ eq : ambdt ] ) , may not be acceptable .
thus , the formula may not be well applied to the quasi - linear regime of the compression , although it is applicable to the nonlinear regime in which we are mostly interested in this paper .
when @xmath31 is much greater than the alfvn speed , the collapse may happen more quickly during the compression . if the flow speed is large enough that vertical hydrostatic equilibrium along the magnetic field can not be attained , then @xmath122 and @xmath123 @xcite .
( the scaling law of @xmath91 is derived from equation ( [ eq : tauadb ] ) by using @xmath124 . ) in this case , the ambipolar diffusion can occur more quickly when the compression leads to large values of @xmath7 .
this process would be happening for @xmath78 even in our results , although the overall timescale of the core formation is dominated by the time after the vertical hydrostatic equilibrium is reestablished .
the simulation with greater @xmath31 was not successful in our case because the density after the first compression becomes so great that the simulation does not have enough spatial resolution for the high density self - gravitating cores .
adaptive mesh refinement or nested grid techniques might be needed for the further investigation in the case of greater @xmath31 .
however , the turbulent flows in molecular clouds are observed to not be highly super alfvnic ( see the fit to data in @xcite ) .
the parameters we used in this paper can be considered to be within a proper range for typical molecular clouds . in the case of @xmath82 , in figure [ fig8 ]
, the core formation time seems to be slightly smaller than what is expected from the semi - analytic formula .
this may be caused by the fact that the approximation of flux - freezing during the compression , which is used in equation ( [ eq : flfz ] ) , is not a good approximation when the parameter @xmath44 is small .
the local ambipolar diffusion time ( @xmath91 ) is estimated to be @xmath125 when we use equation ( [ eq : flfz ] ) .
when @xmath126 , @xmath127 and @xmath128 , we can get @xmath129 .
this means that the local ambipolar diffusion time after the compression becomes nearly comparable to the compression time when @xmath82 .
if the local ambipolar diffusion time is comparable to the compression time , the density can be much more enhanced than estimated from equation ( [ eq : d - enhance ] ) for the same velocity because the magnetic pressure after the compression is reduced by the diffusion .
this density enhancement leads to a smaller core formation time through equation ( [ eq : ambdt ] ) that seems to be satisfied even in the case of @xmath82 from figure [ fig9 ] .
the parameter @xmath82 corresponds to @xmath130 .
the case of even lesser initial mass - to - flux ratio may result in a shorter core formation time than is estimated from equation ( [ eq : ambdt ] ) .
this should be confirmed in the future , and will require greater spatial resolution because a stronger magnetic field generally requires greater density near the core center before the onset of runaway collapse . from table 1 and figure [ fig7 ] , the dimensional core formation time is estimated to be about @xmath131 year , when the flow speed in the cloud is 10 times greater than the sound speed , in the case that the initial mass - to - flux ratio is about half of the critical value ( i.e. , @xmath53 ) .
this core formation time is consistent with those of the previous three - dimensional simulations with turbulent flows @xcite , although the core formation time of the present simulation is slightly longer than that of the three - dimensional simulation with the same initial flow speed .
this is because that the flow speeds in the three dimensional simulations were the averages of the turbulent flows , and the flow components with speeds greater than the average could slightly shorten the core formation times . in both cases ,
our simulations show that the core formation time is estimated to be the order of a few to several @xmath132 years for the subcritical molecular clouds whose initial mass - to - flux ratios are about half of the critical value given that initial large - scale flow speeds ( whether they are turbulent or not ) are @xmath0 times greater than the sound speed .
numerical simulations were performed on the sx-9 and on the pc cluster at the center for computational astrophysics in national astronomical observatory of japan .
is supported by a discovery grant from the natural sciences and engineering research council ( nserc ) of canada .
cccccc a003 & 0.25 & 0.03 & 0.011 & 132 & + a01 & 0.25 & 0.1 & 0.035 & 108 & + a03 & 0.25 & 0.3 & 0.11 & 85.6 & + a05 & 0.25 & 0.5 & 0.18 & 75.2 & + a1 & 0.25 & 1.0 & 0.35 & 60.5 & + a3 & 0.25 & 3.0 & 1.1 & 36.0 & + a5 & 0.25 & 5.0 & 1.8 & 24.5 & + a6 & 0.25 & 6.0 & 2.1 & 20.8 & + a7 & 0.25 & 7.0 & 2.5 & 17.4 & + a8 & 0.25 & 8.0 & 2.8 & 14.2 & + a9 & 0.25 & 9.0 & 3.2 & 11.0 & + a10 & 0.25 & 10.0 & 3.5 & 8.36 & + b01 & 0.09 & 0.1 & 0.021 & 121 & + b1 & 0.09 & 1.0 & 0.21 & 70.1 & + b3 & 0.09 & 3.0 & 0.64 & 43.8 & + b5 & 0.09 & 5.0 & 1.1 & 31.2 & + b8 & 0.09 & 8.0 & 1.7 & 20.8 & + b10 & 0.09 & 10.0 & 2.1 & 16.4 & + b12 & 0.09 & 12.0 & 2.5 & 13.1 & + b15 & 0.09 & 15.0 & 3.2 & 8.50 & + c1 & 0.49 & 1.0 & 0.50 & 46.8 & + c2 & 0.49 & 2.0 & 1.0 & 34.0 & + c3 & 0.49 & 3.0 & 1.5 & 26.5 & + c4 & 0.49 & 4.0 & 2.0 & 21.3 & + c5 & 0.49 & 5.0 & 2.5 & 17.0 & + c6 & 0.49 & 6.0 & 3.0 & 13.8 & + c7 & 0.49 & 7.0 & 3.5 & 9.41 & + d3 & 0.04 & 3.0 & 0.42 & 47.5 & + d5 & 0.04 & 5.0 & 0.71 & 34.6 & + d8 & 0.04 & 8.0 & 1.1 & 23.1 & + d10 & 0.04 & 10.0 & 1.4 & 18.3 & + d15 & 0.04 & 15.0 & 2.1 & 9.88 & + e5 & 0.25 & 5.0 & 1.8 & @xmath133 & no ambipolar diffusion + | we clarify the mechanism of accelerated core formation by large - scale nonlinear flows in subcritical magnetic clouds by finding a semi - analytical formula for the core formation time and describing the physical processes that lead to them .
recent numerical simulations show that nonlinear flows induce rapid ambipolar diffusion that leads to localized supercritical regions that can collapse . here , we employ non - ideal magnetohydrodynamic simulations including ambipolar diffusion for gravitationally stratified sheets threaded by vertical magnetic fields .
one of the horizontal dimensions is eliminated , resulting in a simpler two - dimensional simulation that can clarify the basic process of accelerated core formation .
a parameter study of simulations shows that the core formation time is inversely proportional to the square of the flow speed when the flow speed is greater than the alfvn speed .
we find a semi - analytical formula that explains this numerical result .
the formula also predicts that the core formation time is about three times shorter than that with no turbulence , when the turbulent speed is comparable to the alfvn speed . |
the technique for identification of volatile organic compounds by differences of ion mobility is one of the most efficient techniques applied for detection of explosives , drugs and industrial toxic compounds @xcite .
the detection limit of this technique is found to be of the order of @xmath0 ( ppb ) .
it has a very rapid response time , which makes it very attractive for situations of high control demands .
the ions of the molecule to be identified acquire a velocity under the influence of an external electric field @xmath1 . at the lowest order @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the mobility .
if the field is intense enough it has been reported @xcite that one should go two orders higher ( cubic ) in the field dependence .
a way to understand this result is by considering a power series expansion on @xmath4 .
assuming isotropy of @xmath3 and applying symmetries on spatial transformations , the vectorial properties of @xmath5 and @xmath4 determines that only odd terms in such expansion are possibles .
besides the interaction of the ions with the field @xmath4 , they collides with molecules of the carrier gas that flow through the detection system under a laminar flux . the explicit dependence of @xmath3 on the pressure due to the carrier gas , the temperature , the ion charge , its mass and the cross section can be obtained from general considerations when the field @xmath4 is not very intense @xcite .
working on the center of mass framework to describe the collisions between two bodies , and the reduced mass @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the mass of ions and @xmath8 the mass of the molecules of the gas , the variation of the linear momentum of ion - gas system is due to the external impulse of force , _
i.e. _ @xmath9 , being @xmath10 the ion charge and @xmath11 the characteristic time between collisions .
it can thus be established that @xmath12 furthermore @xmath11 can be related to a collision cross section of the ion - gas system @xmath13 and the density of this system , which is approximately equal to the gas density @xmath14 .
considering the characteristic length @xmath15 and the average rate @xmath16 of the reduced system ion - gas between collisions , it is estimated that in the volume @xmath17 a collision should typically occur .
hence @xmath18 and eq . (
[ eq : v_e ] ) can be written @xmath19 one can approximate @xmath20 because the kinetic energy of the ion - gas system is mainly due to thermal agitation of value @xmath21 for each degree of freedom .
then @xmath22 being @xmath23 the boltzman constant and @xmath24 the absolute temperature . in eq .
( [ eq : v_efinal ] ) there is a factor @xmath25 that should be replaced by @xmath26 when more advanced molecular calculations are considered @xcite .
we include such derivation here because it contains the right dependence with the physical parameters of interest and its derivation is straightforward . in the calculations presented in this work we employ instead
the mobility usually reported in the literature @xcite , which is obtained from @xmath27 this mobility is standardized at normal @xmath28 pressures and @xmath29 temperatures through @xmath30 @xmath31 and @xmath28 depends on the system of unities used to refer to 1013 hpa .
@xmath32 is known as the reduced mobility .
a decade ago the identification of species by separation techniques @xcite was based on the differences in the reduced mobilities given by eq.([eq : k_0 ] ) . since
then substantial modifications have been made in the design and size of sensor devices .
using asymmetric electric fields in the range of radio - frequency and by micro - machining the detection cell , a field asymmetric or fa - ims variant was proposed @xcite .
identifications of up to 0.1 ppm of toluene and also a resolution threshold of 60 ppb for a mix of gases of acetone - benzene and acetone - toluene were reported .
it has been recently proposed @xcite a combination of mass spectroscopy and ion mobility to improve the transmittance in an ion mass mobility spectroscopy through a focus cell by means of periodical electrostatic fields distributed on a very long arrangement of electrode rings ( 1 m of length ) .
it has also been proposed recently an ims type cell by swept - field scanning @xcite in which a plane and parallel detectors system produces an electric field perpendicular to the flux of the ions being detected .
the operating principle of this device for mobility identification is based on the differences of the average path described by the ions within the detection cell .
[ fig : barrido ] , @xmath33 represent two of the seven detectors contained in the cell .
the detectors are earthed and the anode is kept at @xmath34 potential .
the left path corresponds to an ion with higher mobility with respect to the right path.,title="fig : " ] in fig .
[ fig : barrido ] an example of two ion paths corresponding to ions with different mobility is given .
due to the velocity of the carrier flux , the ions reach a detection zone with velocity @xmath35 parallel to the detectors plane . by the action of the transversal field @xmath4 ,
the ions acquire , according to eq .
( [ eq : k_def ] ) , a vertical component velocity @xmath5 proportional to the mobility @xmath3 . by adjusting the geometrical parameters of the cell , the flux of the carrier gas and the potentials among electrodes , it is possible to obtain a typical ion distribution for each compound on the @xmath36 and @xmath33 detectors , where @xmath37 are labels
this is characterized by a greater accumulation of charges on the detectors , whose positions measured from the gas input in the cell are more distant for ions with less mobility , as is suggested schematically in fig .
[ fig : barrido ] . a modification in the swept - field scanning detection was recently proposed .
it includes an ion - focusing just before the introduction of ions in the detection cell @xcite . in this variant
, the flux of both the carrier gas and the ionized gas are separated through geometrical constrictions .
this increase the precision of the positions reached by the ions in the detection cell . in that sense ,
the aim of such a proposal is not meant to obtain a fingerprint for each compound .
indeed it proposes that the identification shall be determined by the average time taken by each species to reach a specific detector @xcite .
although the ion time of flight has been analyzed for different values of carrier gas flux and potentials between electrodes in order to evaluate the focalization conditions , it has been found in this work that identification of species by statistical analysis of their traces on detectors is more accurate if few restrictions are imposed by operational conditions , _
i.e. _ , work pressure and non - radioactive ionization method .
furthermore , due to the fact of a very high difference of electric potential generated by the crown effect , fragments of the molecule to identify are produced , each one with a different mobility . in our work
we have found that this effect is consistent with the formation of a fingerprint for each species at the moment of measuring the total charge deposited on the detector assembly .
basically , the main idea behind a fingerprint identification is the following : a system is designed in such a way that traces of given chemical components are well defined under specific operating conditions . with this purpose , numerical simulations
are first performed , which allow us to identify these specific conditions .
the algorithm used to simulate the ion detection system has proven to be sufficiently robust for the design of ion mobility detection cells @xcite . furthermore in our work ,
the design of an experimental prototype is analyzed for obtaining traces of ethanol , acetone and toluene .
the statistical study of these traces was performed by the principal components analysis @xcite , known as pca ( acronyms from principal components analysis ) , which was used earlier on similar identifications within the design of an electronic sniffer @xcite .
we present our work in the following way . in section [ sec : exp ] we describe the experimental configuration of the prototype device and the procedure we followed for the measurement of signals in the identification of three different chemical species .
in section [ sec : simu ] we present a brief description of the algorithm used for the simulation of ion paths .
we divided section [ sec : results ] in four parts in order to show the experimental results in subsection [ subsec : exp ] , time of flight simulations in subsection [ subsec : tof ] and collected charges in subsection [ subsec : ca ] . in subsection
[ subsec : pca ] we present the analysis of principal components and section [ sec : conclusion ] is devoted to the main conclusions .
an experimental device has been designed as indicated in fig . [
fig : esquemaexp ] .
it consists of three principal parts : i ) the carrier gas flux inlet , ii ) the ionization chamber and iii ) the detection cell .
the sample is introduced as a gas in the ionization chamber together with the carrier gas where , through a type of crown discharge , is ionized .
the pointer shaped electrode , shown in the central part of fig .
[ fig : esquemaexp ] , is a stainless steel needle of 0,8 mm of diameter fixed inside a teflon cylinder .
an earthed copper tube of 8 mm of diameter closes the discharge circuit of the pulse .
the ionization discharge is recorded with an oscilloscope ( tektronix p6015 ) .
the needle is concentric to the copper tube ; hence the distance between electrodes is approximately 4 mm .
a stainless steel mesh is placed between the ionization chamber and the detection cell in order to screen the high field produced during the ionization discharge within that last zone .
the detection arrangement is similar to that proposed by solis _
@xcite ; the field @xmath4 is transversal to the ion flux determined by the carrier gas .
our ion detection device is an assembly of 7 earthed detectors placed in a plane as shown in fig .
[ fig : esquemaexp ] and connected to a constant potential which is fixed in the range between 10 and 100v .
the dimensions of the detection cell are 17 mm @xmath38 11 mm @xmath38 2 mm .
a dry carrier gas of n@xmath39 is used in order to avoid humidity problems in the air ( indura 99,998% , h@xmath39o @xmath40 3mg / ml ) .
the gas flux is controlled by a flux measuring device : brooks model 6 - 658 .
the testing organic substances are absorbed in a piece of cotton placed in a glass tramp .
a flux of n@xmath39 gas passes through the tramp dragging the steam of the sample at room temperature and directed to the ionization zone .
the ions generated are dragged by the same flux of n@xmath39 gas towards the detection cell .
each electrode is connected to a resistance of 3.2 m@xmath13 and the electrical signal generated by the ions is measured in a oscilloscope instek gds 810s synchronized with the pulse of the discharge of the ionization needle .
all the system is controlled with a pc and due to the high signal / noise relationship , only 8 signals are necessary to average the response of each detector . with this system it is possible to study : absolute ethanol ( merck , pro - analysis , 99.8% ) , toluene ( mallinckrodt , analytical , 99.8% ) and acetone ( sintorgan , analytical , 99.5% ) .
all of them were used without any previous treatment .
the ion paths in the detection cell were simulated with the simion 8.0 code . the sds module was implemented .
this module combines the dynamics of a particle in a viscous medium and its interaction with the carrier gas at room pressure @xcite .
we give here a brief description of such a simulation . in order to define an ion path , the equation of motion
is considered , in which acceleration has a viscosity component due to velocity in eq.([eq : k_def ] ) , and another coulombic component due to the electrostatic potential of the cell .
furthermore when the sds module is implemented , a diffusion model is incorporated .
the statistics of the distance covered after 10@xmath41 collisions in 10@xmath41 ion samples was applied . from the ion - gas mass relationship data of 1 , 10 , 100 , 1000 and 10000 , the distance corresponding to intermediate values of mass were calculated by interpolation .
such distance is used to modelling the size of the jump in a step of the path .
the direction within the 3d space of the cell should be calculated with a uniform distribution in order to modelling the expected local isotropy . in this sense , an appropriate sample space should be chosen .
for instance , if a point within a cube is randomly taken in order to obtain a random direction , the appropriate sample space is defined only by those points that belong to the sphere inscribed in such a cube @xcite . once the path is defined , the algorithm reports the positions of the ion s impact .
we have instrumented a couple of codes written in interpretative language ( perl ) to process the data accompanying each ion path . with these codes
we obtain the charge collected as a function of time . through a numerical derivation of the collected charge ,
the current in each detector as a function of the time of flight was obtained .
the simion 8.0/sds algorithm @xcite allows us to estimate ( from the mass data ) or to take as a predeterminated information , the mobilities of the ions whose paths will be modeled .
two types of ion path simulations were considered : one without fragmentation and the other with fragmentation .
this means that , for each species studied , ions of the whole molecules were considered first , and secondly , the fragments of such molecules according to their relative abundances @xcite being the least of them higher than 10% . surface potential energy view of the ion path simulation of a toluene ( black ) - acetone ( light gray ) - ethanol ( gray ) mixture obtained by simion 8.0 .
the ions come from the rigth top side of figure .
the top part of the traces correspond to the potential of needle discharge ( 5000v ) .
the carrier flux with velocity 30 m / s allows the flow of the ions go into detector zone where potential increments are indicated by the surface potential level . in the left bottom side of figure ions impacts to detector at 0v at the lowest part of the surface potential .
the anode is opposite to it in the upper part of the surface potential at 50v.,width=453 ] fig .
[ fig : juntos ] shows the surface potential energy view obtained with simion 8.0 for the simulation of paths considering only primary ions ( without fragmentation ) of toluene , acetone and ethanol .
results indicate that the ions of acetone and ethanol with greater mobility are collected preferentially in the detectors closer to the capture cell inlet ( see also fig .
[ fig : esquemaexp ] ) .
in this section , experimental results and numerical simulations of the device proposed here for the detection cell by swept - field scanning are presented .
flight times are analyzed as well as the collected charges in detectors for different combination of carrier gas flux and detector potentials .
the analysis of the principal components for one of the selected combinations is also presented .
the experimental results are given in the first subsection , and in the following subsections the results of simulations and numerical calculations are shown .
under normal conditions of pressure and temperature different tests were performed as described in section [ sec : exp ] for acetone , ethanol and toluene at saturated steam pressure using the device shown in fig .
[ fig : esquemaexp ] .
the location of the detectors in the detection cell is shown in fig .
[ fig : detectores ] . ion gas moves from left
to right as indicated by the arrow .
the charge collected during the detection process was obtained for each detector . in fig .
[ fig : detallexp ] these data for each substance are displayed . according to eq.([eq : v_e ] ) , the differences in mobility allows to correlate time with position taken by an ion which arrives on a detector . in order to explain experimental results , we need to consider that the mobility of toluene ( @xmath42 ) is lower than that of ethanol ( @xmath43 ) and acetone ( @xmath44 ) @xcite and that with the configuration proposed , the electric field is perpendicular to the direction of the carrier gas ( see fig .
[ fig : barrido ] ) .
hence , toluene ions should travel longer distances without being deviated compared with ethanol and acetone ions .
for these last ones , the scarce relative difference of 3.5% reported between the acetone ( larger ) and ethanol ( smaller ) mobilities @xcite , might yields to similar path deflection and nearly the same distance of impact on detectors produced by the swept - field scanning .
in general , it is expected that lighter ions have larger mobilities as they have smaller inertial mass .
although this rule applies for a large number of molecules @xcite there are some exceptions where the opposite is true .
such exceptions can be explained in terms of a fragmentation process of the primary ion to lighter secondary ions and , therefore , with greater mobility . due to the type of ionization proposed in this work ,
we suppose that the fragmentation of acetone and ethanol produce secondary ions with highly relative abundance @xcite .
consequently , each species aquire a different mobility compared to that expected in terms of primary ions mass alone .
the velocity of the carrier gas and the difference of electric potential within the cell can be conveniently combined in order to modulate the amount of ions that goes to a given place of the experimental device .
we shall analyse here the time of flight for each ion and the average rate of the collected charge in each detector as a function of both the velocity of the carrier gas and the difference of electric potential . in fig .
[ fig : tof2 ] we display the normalized current generated in each detector by the ions of toluene when the velocity of the carrier gas is 3 , 9 and 30 m / s and the differences of electric potential in each detector cell are 15 and 150 v. a pattern that spreads the current over time of flights when both the velocities @xmath45 and potentials diminishes is observed .
this can be explained considering that the contribution to the ion s energy from the interaction between the ions and the carrier gas do compete with the electrical counterpart .
increasing the electric potential differences of the cell will give a larger kinetic energy contributtion to the ions compared with the contribution from the brownian motion .
thus , such electric potential increment clearly produce a lesser diffuse and so more defined and streched ion paths .
for that reason , in fig .
[ fig : tof2 ] it is observed that , as both the velocity of the carrier gas and the potential decrease , the average rate of ions that arrive at the same time also decrease .
this means that in such case the ions arrival are expanded over the whole detection zone . counting the amount of collected charge in each detector offers an alternative way to get the times of flight .
their results are also in agreement with experimental data .
we present here the measurement of the collected charge when the velocity of the carrier gas is 30 m / s and the difference of potential in the cell is 50 v. it is verified that the times of flight are larger for ions that arrive on detectors which are farther to cell inlet . for instance , in fig . [
fig : tolacetethaqvst ] the same graph for detectors @xmath46 and @xmath47 is shown for the collected charge @xmath48 divided by total charge @xmath49 of ions when toluene , acetone and ethanol are tested separately . when mobility is estimated from ion mass , as should be if we consider the case of fragmentation process during the ions generation , the charge collected in each detector as a function of time of flight follows the simple rule expected by inertial mass considerations .
this can be observed in fig .
[ fig : tolacetethaqvst ] . the collected charge for ethanol is greater than that of acetone for times of flight between 280 and 350@xmath50s corresponding to the arrival of ions at the detector @xmath46 .
however , if we consider the mobilities reported in the literature we could expect that this result should be the opposite one .
for that reason , we performed our simulation also considering groups of secondary ions .
we supposed that when acetone , ethanol and toluene were ionized they would form groups of ions from the fragmentation of the primary ion .
we considered the ions with a relative abundance greater than 10% .
furthermore , using secondary ions , we found out a large defocusing and a low temporal definition due to a wide charge distribution on the detectors assembly .
then as an improvement we considered more appropriate to represent the collected charges in each detector taking care also of the secondary ions for each species .
normalized collected charge @xmath51 in each detector obtained from the fragmentation product of the primary ion with relative abundance greater than 10% for acetone ( light gray ) , ethanol ( gray ) and toluene ( dark gray ) .
over 6000 ion paths are averaged for each species considering carrier gas velocities between 20 and 30 m / s .
numeration and configuration of detectors is the same as that of the experimental device .
, height=226 ] in fig .
[ fig : qvsdet ] we display such results . in this case a charge distribution closer to that expected in terms of acetone ion mobilities is obtained .
however , a larger amount of ethanol ions than that of acetone ions in detectors ( @xmath52,@xmath53 ) is still observed .
such detectors are the first pair from the entrance to the cell of the carrier gas .
the second pair of detectors is ( @xmath54,@xmath46 ) . for this second pair ,
the method of secondary ions seems to be more consistent with the expected result in terms of known mobilities .
the detector pair that follows is ( @xmath55,@xmath47 ) . in this last case ,
the result that arise when considering fragmentation is again opposite to that which would be expected from mobilities .
based on the previous background on simulation and experimental results we are be able do another step forward .
our working assumption is now that once the cell geometry and the operational conditions of our device are given ( the carrier gas flux and the cell potential values ) the charge collected in each detector has its own statistics for each unknown species .
specifically , the analysis of the principal components applied to our device allows us to determine the fingerprint of each species corresponding to our experimental configuration .
we associate a random variable @xmath56 ( @xmath57 ) to the collected charge @xmath48 in each detector , normalized with the total charge @xmath49 and distributed on all the detectors .
thus , @xmath56 are real numbers in the interval [ 0 , 1 ] .
each measurement of the collected charge in a detector corresponds to an event of the random variable @xmath56 .
therefore , if we perform @xmath58 measurements for each variable , we can construct the vector @xmath59 whose coordinates are the result of these measurements .
the notation @xmath60 means the transpose of @xmath61 . from the definition of the mean value @xmath62 and experimental covariance @xcite ,
a real symmetric and covariant matrix @xmath63 is obtained , whose dimension is equal to the number of detectors , _ i.e. _ 7@xmath387 .
their elements are defined by @xmath64 where @xmath65 .
we now introduce the similarity transformation @xmath66 where @xmath67 is a diagonal matrix and @xmath68 is an orthogonal matrix containing the eigenvectors of @xmath69 ordered by columns . from the last matrix it is possible to define the transformation @xmath70 that enable us to change from random variables of detectors @xmath71 to a new set of random variables @xmath72 from this output a principal subgroup can be obtained @xmath73 being @xmath74 the matrix formed by the first @xmath75 eigenvectors of @xmath69 ordered in decreasing order of its eigenvalues .
the final results @xmath76 contain the expected principal components .
different criteria were proposed for getting @xmath77 @xcite , although all of them consider the minor subspace in which the greatest quantity of data is concentrated @xcite . the results of eq.([eq : y ] )
can be understood in terms of a coordinate transformation . within the new coordinate system ,
each component is independent .
this allows us to define an orthogonal space that represent the data obtained from measurements of collected charges for each species .
the principal eigenvectors used show in turn the specific combination of the original detectors that intervene in the output of the measurement . the first two principal components for 5 measurements of the charge collected in each detector when using all of them .
ethanol ( plus symbol ) , acetone ( cross symbol ) and toluene ( asterisk symbol ) averaged on 6000 runs each species .
, height=226 ] fig .
[ fig : pca7det ] shows the coordinates of the two first principal components for a set of 5 measurements of the collected charge in each detector for ethanol , acetone and toluene ions and fragments of them .
each one of these measurements is similar to that represented in fig .
[ fig : qvsdet ] and corresponds to the average values on a sample of 6000 ion paths , considering the carrier gas velocities between 20 and 30 m / s .
only 2% of data remains outside the analyzed set by the two first principal components , distributing 91% in the first and 7% in the second of them .
[ fig : pca6det ] shows the coordinates the first 2 principal components for 5 measurements of collected charge in each detector , but without detector number 4 .
ethanol ( plus symbol ) , acetone ( cross symbol ) and toluene ( asterisk symbol ) averaged on 6000 runs each species .
, height=226 ] in the two first principal components of measurements on the same system considered in fig .
[ fig : pca7det ] , but with one variable less due to detector number 4 was not considered . in this case it is observed that 99% of data is represented by the first two components and 98% only by the first one . this is explained by the fact that being very scarce the collected charges on detector 4 , as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : qvsdet ] , the diminution of the number of variables decreases the dimension of the total space considered with a very little alteration of the sample size .
therefore , the concentration of data in the first two principal components increase .
the relevance of the pca result is considerable regarding the separation of the three set of data for all species we have studied .
the identification of an unknown sample is positive if its representation fits within any of the clearly non - overlapping region of our three set of data ( see figs .
[ fig : pca7det ] and [ fig : pca6det ] ) .
our simulation clearly shows that for the trace of ions , the carrier gas velocity and the cell potential are directly correlated .
the analysis of fragmented ions partially explain the traces of acetone and ethanol when their mobilities are estimated from fragments mass .
however , the integrated signals which were obtained experimentally show the same trend that our simulation . as shown in fig .
[ fig : detallexp ] , when comparing the signals of detectors ( @xmath52,@xmath53 ) with the subsequent pair ( @xmath54,@xmath46 ) , it is observed that they maintain almost the same proportion between all substances for each detector , but the whole amount is increased in the second pair . in the third pair , ( @xmath55,@xmath47 ) , the proportion of the trend between substances almost remains the same , but decreasing the total amount of the set . only in the most distant detector
the result is different and shows the proportions between species following the expected results in terms of tabulated mobilities @xcite .
since the simulations of the times of flight for each substance shows a characteristic distribution for both , charges and currents obtained through the detectors assembly , i.e. a _ fingerprint _ , the statistical correlation in the distribution of collected charges in the detectors using the principal component analysis can be applied . for the experimental prototype proposed here a set of specific parameters ( velocity of carrier gas and electric potential of the cell ) to define acetone
, ethanol and toluene traces were optimized by numeric simulation . afterwards a pca statistical analysis of the collected ion charges in the set of detectors is used to define a non - overlapping region in a appropriated diagram for each of the above mentioned compounds .
thus , our procedure , which involves a training to develop the proper fringerprint of each compound , can be used in the designing of devices for the identification with certainty of unknown compounds ,
gpo acknowledge illuminating discussions with w. luis mochn and useful comments of patricio f. provasi and rodolfo h. romero .
this work was supported by foncyt ( grant pae 22592/2004 nodo nea:23016 and nodo cac:23831 ) . | ion mobility spectrometry ( ims ) is a well - known , sensitive and rapid technique to detect dangerous organic compounds .
we propose a system in which a crown type discharge generates a ionic flux that is swept towards an array of collectors by a transverse electric field .
the ions are separated as they enter the cell according to their mobility .
thus , the distribution of the charge collected at the detector assembly constitutes a _ fingerprint _ for each organic compound .
simulations of our cell and experiments were performed for small amount of acetone , ethanol and toluene .
the dependence on the cell parameters of the current and charge versus time of flight was analyzed .
our simulation reproduces only qualitatively the experimental results .
however , a pca statistical analysis of the simulated results shows that such a fingerprint can be used to identify those compounds with certainty . |
one of the most important goals of _ ab initio _ computational electronic - structure theory is the development of accurate methods for describing interatomic bonding . quantum monte carlo ( qmc ) techniques are useful in this regard as they can provide a highly accurate description of electron correlation effects .
although qmc methods are computationally expensive , they can be applied to systems which are large enough to model condensed matter . in this study
we have considered solid neon , in which the bonding arises from the competition between short - range repulsion and the van der waals attraction between the atoms .
high - quality experimental measurements of the equation of state ( eos ) exist , which can be used as reference data .
furthermore , various neon pair potentials have been developed using experimental and theoretical data , which can also be used for comparison purposes .
solid neon is therefore an ideal system in which to test the descriptions of van der waals bonding and short - range repulsion offered by various theoretical methods .
we have calculated theoretical eos s for crystalline neon using the qmc and density - functional theory ( dft ) _ ab initio _ electronic - structure methods as well as various interatomic pair potentials .
standard dft methods do not describe van der waals bonding accurately , but they might be expected to work quite well at high densities , where the short - range repulsion dominates .
the high - pressure properties of neon are of some experimental interest , because neon is often used as a pressure - conducting medium in diamond - anvil - cell experiments.@xcite we have therefore extended the range of our qmc eos for neon to very high pressures ( about 400 gpa ) .
the zero - point energy ( zpe ) of the lattice - vibration modes makes a small but important contribution to the total energy of solid neon .
we have therefore studied the lattice dynamics of solid neon within the quasiharmonic - phonon approximation and within the einstein approximation , using dft methods and pair potentials . for some time
there has been considerable interest in developing neon pair potentials in order to test the accuracy of theoretical methods for calculating the properties of materials.@xcite we have performed a direct calculation of the neon pair potential using qmc .
we compare the accuracy of the eos predicted by this pair potential with the results obtained using other pair potentials , including one obtained from coupled - cluster ccsd(t ) calculations.@xcite detailed information about our computational methodologies is given in sec .
[ sec : methodology ] and dft calculations of the phase stability and band gap of solid neon are reported in sec .
[ sec : prelims ] .
the calculation of a neon pair potential using qmc is described in sec .
[ sec : dmc_pair_pot ] .
the lattice dynamics of solid neon are studied in sec .
[ sec : neon_latt_dyn ] .
we compare the eos s obtained using different methods in sec .
[ sec : neon_eos ] . finally , we draw our conclusions in sec . [
sec : conclusions ] .
hartree atomic units ( a.u . ) are used throughout , in which the dirac constant , the magnitude of the electronic charge , the electronic mass , and @xmath0 times the permittivity of free space are unity : @xmath1 methodology [ sec : methodology ] ----------------------------- our dft calculations were performed using the castep plane - wave - basis code.@xcite the local - density approximation ( lda ) and perdew - burke - ernzerhof ( pbe ) generalized - gradient - approximation@xcite exchange - correlation functionals were used .
the ne@xmath2 ionic cores were represented by ultrasoft pseudopotentials.@xcite the eos calculations were performed using a @xmath3 monkhorst - pack @xmath4-point mesh and a plane - wave cutoff energy of 200 a.u .
, for which the dft energies have converged to about 7 significant figures .
the self - consistent - field calculations were judged to have converged when the fractional change in the energy was less than @xmath5 .
the dft band - gap calculations reported in sec . [ sec : bandgap ] were performed using the same parameters , except that the plane - wave cutoff energies ranged from 100 a.u .
for the lowest densities to 800 a.u.for the highest densities .
we used the quasiharmonic approximation@xcite to evaluate the dft zpe of the lattice - vibration modes and we used the method of finite displacements and the hellmann - feynman theorem to evaluate the density - dependent force constants .
symmetry and newton s third law were imposed iteratively on the matrix of force constants.@xcite the dft force - constant calculations were carried out using a plane - wave cutoff energy of 60 a.u .
, a @xmath6 monkhorst - pack @xmath4-point mesh , and ultrasoft pseudopotentials.@xcite the force constants were converged to about @xmath7 a.u . with respect to the plane - wave cutoff energy and the @xmath4-point mesh .
in the production force - constant calculations , the displacement of the neon atom from its equilibrium position was @xmath8% of the nearest - neighbor distance in each case , which ensures that anharmonic effects are negligible .
the force - constant calculations were carried out in both @xmath9 and @xmath10 supercells of the primitive unit cell , and the difference in the resulting zpe s was found to be negligible . the dispersion curves shown in sec .
[ sec : neon_latt_dyn ] were produced using a @xmath11 supercell , while the zpe s that were combined with the static - lattice eos s were calculated in a @xmath12 supercell .
dft - lda calculations were performed in order to generate orbitals for the trial wave functions used in the qmc calculations .
the qmc calculations made use of relativistic hartree - fock neon pseudopotentials,@xcite and these were also used in the dft orbital - generation calculations .
the hartree - fock pseudopotentials are much harder than the ultrasoft pseudopotentials .
plane - wave cutoffs in excess of 250 a.u . were used in each orbital - generation calculation , so the dft energy was converged to around @xmath13 a.u .
this cutoff is very large by the normal standards of dft calculations , but there is evidence that using large basis sets reduces the variance of the energy in qmc calculations.@xcite in the variational quantum monte carlo ( vmc ) method , expectation values are calculated using an approximate trial wave function , the integrals being performed by a monte carlo technique . in diffusion quantum monte carlo@xcite ( dmc )
the imaginary - time schrdinger equation is used to evolve an ensemble of electronic configurations towards the ground state .
the fermionic symmetry is maintained by the fixed - node approximation,@xcite in which the nodal surface of the wave function is constrained to equal that of a trial wave function .
furthermore , the use of nonlocal pseudopotentials to represent the ne@xmath2 cores necessitates the use of the locality approximation,@xcite which leads to errors that are second order in the quality of the trial wave function.@xcite our qmc calculations were performed using the casino code.@xcite the trial wave functions were of slater - jastrow form , with the orbitals in the slater wave function being taken from dft calculations and the free parameters in the jastrow factor being optimized by minimizing the unreweighted variance of the energy.@xcite the dft - generated orbitals were represented numerically using splines on a grid in real space rather than an expansion in plane waves in order to improve the scaling of the qmc calculations with system size.@xcite the jastrow factors consisted of isotropic electron - electron , electron - nucleus , and electron - electron - nucleus terms.@xcite the electron - electron terms describe long - ranged correlations and therefore play the most important role in describing van der waals forces .
the qmc simulations of crystalline neon were carried out in supercells of finite size subject to periodic boundary conditions .
the electrostatic energy of each electron configuration was calculated using the ewald method.@xcite the qmc energy per atom obtained in a finite cell differs from the energy per atom of the infinite crystal due to _ single - particle _ finite - size effects and _ coulomb _ finite - size effects .
the former result from the fact that the allowed @xmath4 points for the bloch orbitals form a discrete lattice , so that the single - particle energy components change when the size of the simulation supercell is changed .
the latter , which are the more important in insulators , are caused by the interaction of the charged particles with their periodic images . at
any given instant , each electron feels itself to be part of an infinite crystal of electrons.@xcite the resulting bias is negative , and is generally believed to fall off as @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the number of atoms in the simulation cell.@xcite in order to eliminate the finite - size bias , simulations were carried out in supercells consisting of @xmath10 and @xmath16 primitive unit cells .
the error in the dft results arising from the use of a @xmath10 @xmath4-point mesh is small ( about @xmath17 a.u . ) , so we conclude that single - particle finite - size effects are negligible .
the assumed form of the coulomb finite - size bias was therefore used to extrapolate the results to infinite system size . the static - lattice energy per atom in the infinite - system limit is given by @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the vinet fit ( see sec . [
sec : eos_models ] ) to the dmc static - lattice energy - volume data obtained in a set of @xmath15-atom simulation supercells , @xmath20 is the primitive - cell volume , and @xmath21 is a parameter determined by fitting . since we only have energy - volume data for two different system sizes , @xmath15 and @xmath22 , we may eliminate @xmath21 and write @xmath23 the pressure due to the static - lattice energy at infinite system size is given by @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the static - lattice pressure in an @xmath15-atom simulation supercell . the zero - temperature ,
static - lattice energy - volume curves of neon , calculated using dmc in different sizes of simulation supercell are shown in figs .
[ fig : neon_e_of_v ] and [ fig : neon_e_of_v_highden ] .
vinet eos s are fitted to the data .
the corresponding pressure - volume data are shown in figs .
[ fig : neon_qmc_pressures ] and [ fig : neon_qmc_pressures_highden ] .
it can be seen that the dmc pressure - volume curves converge steadily with system size , and that the dmc pressure extrapolated to infinite system size using eq .
( [ eqn : pressure_extrap ] ) is close to the pressure of the @xmath26 supercell .
this implies that the error introduced by the extrapolation is small , because the extrapolation is itself a small correction .
primitive unit cells using different time steps @xmath27 .
[ fig : neon_e_of_v ] ] , but at higher densities .
[ fig : neon_e_of_v_highden ] ] primitive unit cells and at different time steps @xmath27 .
the pressure extrapolated to infinite system size is also shown .
[ fig : neon_qmc_pressures ] ] , but at higher densities .
[ fig : neon_qmc_pressures_highden ] ] the fixed - node dmc green s function is only exact in the limit of zero time step ; the use of a nonzero time step biases the dmc energy .
an example of the bias in the dmc energy of a pseudoneon crystal is shown in fig .
[ fig : neon333_dt_bias ] . on the other hand , as shown by the @xmath12 supercell results in figs .
[ fig : neon_qmc_pressures ] and [ fig : neon_qmc_pressures_highden ] , the pressure is very insensitive to the time step .
we used time steps of @xmath28 a.u . and @xmath29 a.u . in our production calculations for the @xmath30 and @xmath3 supercells ,
a time - step of @xmath31 a.u . was used in the dmc pair - potential calculations .
the target population was at least 320 configurations in each case , while a target population of 1000 configurations was used for the pair - potential - generation calculations .
fcc primitive unit cells .
the primitive - cell volume is @xmath32 a.u .
960 configurations were used in the dmc simulations .
[ fig : neon333_dt_bias ] ] we have used the following forms of pair potential : ( i ) the hfd - b potential proposed by aziz and chen@xcite with the parameter values given by aziz and slaman@xcite ; ( ii ) the form of potential proposed for helium by korona _
et al._,@xcite containing the parameter values determined by cybulski and toczyowski@xcite using all - electron double - excitation coupled - cluster theory with a non - iterative perturbational treatment of triple excitations ( ccsd(t ) ) and an av5z@xmath33 gaussian basis set ; and ( iii ) a fit of the potential of korona _ _ et al.__@xcite to our dmc energy data , as described in sec .
[ sec : dmc_pair_pot ] .
we believe the hfd - b pair potential to be the most accurate neon pair potential in the literature to date .
let the pair potential between two neon atoms at @xmath34 and @xmath35 be @xmath36 .
let @xmath37 be a large radius .
we evaluate the static - lattice energy per atom as @xmath38 where the @xmath39 are the lattice sites and @xmath40 is the number density of neon atoms .
this expression becomes exact as @xmath37 goes to infinity .
the integral in eq .
( [ eqn : ppsl ] ) was evaluated analytically for each pair potential , while the sum was evaluated by brute force .
@xmath37 was increased until @xmath41 converged .
pair potentials were used to generate force - constant data for a quasiharmonic@xcite calculation of the zpe of neon .
the method of finite displacements@xcite was used to generate the force constants in a finite supercell subject to periodic boundary conditions .
it was ensured that the force constants were highly converged with respect to the size of the displacements and the number of periodic images of the neon atoms that contributed to the force constants .
following the evaluation of the force constants , the calculation of the zpe proceeded as described in sec .
[ sec : dft_fc_calcs ] .
let @xmath42 be the total energy of a neon crystal as a function of primitive - cell volume @xmath20 .
it has previously been noticed@xcite that a vinet eos of the form @xmath43 where the zero - pressure volume @xmath44 , bulk modulus @xmath45 , pressure - derivative of the bulk modulus @xmath46 , and integration constant @xmath47 are fitting parameters , gives a better fit than a third - order birch - murnaghan eos , @xmath48 to dft results for solid neon .
in some cases the vinet eos gives a lower @xmath49 value when fitted to our dmc data than the birch - murnaghan eos ; in others it gives a higher @xmath49 value .
for example , using dmc data obtained in simulation cells consisting of @xmath50 primitive cells and a time step of @xmath51 a.u . , the vinet and birch - murnaghan eos models give @xmath49 values of @xmath52 and @xmath53 , respectively , whereas at a time step of @xmath54 a.u.the eos models give @xmath49 values of @xmath55 and @xmath56 , respectively .
the resulting pressure - volume curves are essentially indistinguishable in each case , however . to be consistent ,
we have fitted vinet eos s to all of our theoretical data .
we have compared the dft energies of face - centered cubic ( fcc ) and hexagonal close - packed ( hcp ) phases of solid neon . for hcp
neon the lattice - parameter ratio @xmath57 was optimized , but the optimal ratio always turned out to be @xmath58 , which is the ratio appropriate for an ideal hcp lattice .
the dft energy difference between the fcc and hcp phases is typically less than @xmath59 a.u . : too small for us reliably to identify any phase transition .
experimentally , hemley _
_ et al.__@xcite have found that solid neon adopts the fcc phase up to pressures of at least 110 gpa at 300 k. we have therefore used the fcc lattice in all of our calculations , apart from those described in this section . the band gap of solid neon , calculated using dft , is shown in fig .
[ fig : bandgap_v_vol ] .
the band gap is large at the equilibrium volume , and increases significantly when the material is compressed .
the dft calculations predict that neon is still an insulator when it is compressed to a primitive - cell volume of 2 a.u .
, corresponding to a pressure of about 366 tpa .
the use of the ultrasoft neon pseudopotential ( with a core radius of 0.9 a.u.)probably causes the dft results to become unreliable at such high densities ; nevertheless , our results indicate that the metalization pressure of neon is of the order of hundreds of tpa .
et al.__@xcite concluded that neon remains a wide - gap insulator over the range of pressures that they studied using diamond - anvil cells ( up to 110.4 gpa ) , while hawke _ _
et al.__@xcite used a magnetic - flux compression device to show that solid neon remains an insulator up to at least 500 gpa . ] the dft - lda and dft - pbe band gaps at the experimental equilibrium primitive - cell volume ( 150 a.u . )
are 11.85 ev and 12.04 ev , respectively , compared with the experimentally determined value of 21.51 ev.@xcite as usual , dft substantially underestimates the band gap .
the _ gw _ band gap of 20.04 ev , calculated by galami - mulaomerovi and patterson , is relatively accurate.@xcite the dmc method can also be used to perform highly accurate band - gap calculations,@xcite although we have not done this for neon .
the difference between the dmc pair potential , evaluated as the fixed - nucleus total energy of a neon dimer , and the hfd - b potential is shown in fig .
[ fig : dmc_pair_pot ] .
the dmc energy data have been offset by a constant that was determined by fitting the data to a pair - potential model.@xcite we have used the form of potential proposed by korona _
et al . _
for helium,@xcite which can be written as @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the separation of the neon atoms .
the dispersion coefficients @xmath62 are taken from cybulski and toczyowski@xcite ( @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 ) and @xmath69 is the damping function proposed by tang and toennies,@xcite @xmath70 @xmath37 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , and @xmath73 are adjustable parameters , which were determined by a @xmath49 fit to the dmc data , as was the constant offset . the fitted parameter values ( in a.u . )
are @xmath74 , @xmath75 , @xmath76 , and @xmath77 .
the difference of the resulting pair potential with the hfd - b potential is shown in fig .
[ fig : dmc_pair_pot ] , as is the corresponding curve for the ccsd(t ) data .
it can be seen that over a wide range of separations the dmc pair potential lies closer to the hfd - b pair potential than the ccsd(t)-generated pair potential . ]
by comparing the results obtained using a lennard - jones potential in the harmonic approximation with the vmc@xcite results obtained using the same potential by hansen,@xcite pollock _ _ et al.__@xcite have demonstrated that the harmonic approximation is valid for solid neon at high pressures .
we consider two methods for calculating the zpe : ( i ) the zpe of quasiharmonic phonons can be evaluated in a supercell of several primitive cells , or ( ii ) the zpe can be computed within the einstein approximation by evaluating the quadratic potential felt by each atom as it is displaced from its equilibrium position with all the other atoms held fixed .
examples of phonon dispersion curves at two different densities are shown in figs .
[ fig : neon_disp_curve_bx2.75 ] and [ fig : neon_disp_curve_equilvol ] .
inelastic neutron - scattering data@xcite are also shown in fig .
[ fig : neon_disp_curve_equilvol ] . at high density
the dft - lda and dft - pbe dispersion curves are in good agreement , but at low density the dft - lda phonon frequencies are significantly lower than the dft - pbe frequencies .
unstable ( imaginary ) phonon modes start to occur at a primitive - cell volume of about 133 a.u . in the lda . by contrast , there are no unstable phonon modes , even at a primitive - cell volume of 182.25 a.u .
, when the pbe functional is used .
the dft and pair - potential results are in agreement at high densities , indicating that the dft results are accurate in this regime .
overall , the dft - pbe dispersion curves appear to be more accurate ( that is , closer to the hfd - b and experimental results ) than the dft - lda dispersion curves . ] , but with a primitive - cell volume of 149.06894 a.u .
( close to the experimental equilibrium density ) . experimental data from ref
. are also shown .
the imaginary frequencies of unstable modes are plotted as negative numbers .
the einstein frequencies evaluated using dft - pbe , the hfd - b pair potential , the ccsd(t ) pair potential , and the dmc pair potential are 5.37853 mev , 4.07895 mev , 6.73975 mev , and 6.06113 mev , respectively .
the quasiharmonic zpe evaluated using the hfd - b potential is 0.000216603 a.u .
[ fig : neon_disp_curve_equilvol ] ] the pressure arising from the zpe of solid neon as calculated using different methods is plotted relative to the hfd - b results in fig .
[ fig : zpp_graph ] . within dft
, the einstein approximation is excellent .
it can be seen that the difference between the lda and pbe results is appreciable at low densities , but that the difference between the einstein and quasiharmonic zero - point pressures is more significant at high densities . as expected from examination of the dispersion curves ,
the hfd - b zero - point pressure is closer to the dft - pbe results than the dft - lda ones ; nevertheless , all the zero - point - pressure results are in good agreement . ]
the dft quasiharmonic zero - point pressures have been added to the corresponding static - lattice pressures to give the final eos s .
the dft - pbe quasiharmonic zero - point pressure has been added to the dmc static - lattice pressure to give the final dmc eos . for the pair potentials ,
the quasiharmonic zero - point pressure calculated using each pair potential has been added to the corresponding static - lattice pressure in order to obtain the final eos .
zero - temperature eos s for solid neon , calculated using dft - lda , dft - pbe , dmc [ extrapolated to infinite system size using eq .
( [ eqn : pressure_extrap ] ) ] , and pair potentials are shown in fig .
[ fig : neon_p_of_v_inc_zpp ] , and the differences of the theoretical eos s with the experimental eos are plotted in fig . [
fig : neon_p_of_v_inc_zpp_new ] .
( the low - density experimental pressure - volume data of anderson _ _ et al.__@xcite shown in fig . [ fig : neon_p_of_v_inc_zpp ] were obtained at 4.2 k , while the high - density experimental data of hemley _ _ et al.__@xcite were obtained at 300 k. hemley _
et al . _
reduced their pressure - volume data to the zero - temperature isotherm using a mie - grneisen model and fitted their results to a third - order birch - murnaghan eos , with the zero - pressure primitive - cell volume and bulk modulus being the values obtained by anderson _
the resulting eos@xcite is valid at both low and high densities and is regarded as being the definitive experimental eos . ) the parameter values for a vinet fit ( eq . ( [ eqn : vinet_eos ] ) ) to our dmc data ( including the dft - pbe zpe ) are @xmath78 a.u . , @xmath79 gpa , and @xmath80 . ] ] at low densities the dft - lda and dft - pbe eos s differ markedly .
the strong dependence of the dft results on the choice of exchange - correlation functional implies that the description of van der waals bonding within dft is unreliable , as one would expect , given the local nature of the approximations to the exchange - correlation functional .
dmc produces a considerably more accurate eos than dft , suggesting that dmc is capable of giving a proper description of van der waals bonding .
the hfd - b pair potential@xcite gives an eos of similar accuracy to the dmc eos at low to intermediate densities . at higher densities ,
the eos calculated using dmc is better than any of the pair - potential eos s .
although the difference between the dmc and experimental pressures is significant at high densities , it should be emphasized that the fractional error remains small .
the pair potential calculated using ccsd(t ) theory@xcite gives a poorer eos than the dmc - generated pair potential . on the other hand ,
the eos obtained using the dmc pair potential is significantly poorer than the hfd - b eos . taken together with the fact that the direct dmc eos is excellent , this suggests that many - body interactions play a significant role in solid neon , and that such interactions are included to some extent in the hfd - b potential .
we have performed dmc calculations of the energy of fcc solid neon as a function of the lattice constant and the energy of the neon dimer as a function of atomic separation .
other calculations using dft methods and pair potentials have been performed to evaluate the zpe and for comparison purposes .
we have calculated the phonon dispersion curves of solid neon using the dft - lda and dft - pbe methods , the hfd - b pair potential , and ccsd(t)- and dmc - derived pair potentials .
we believe the results obtained with the hfd - b pair potential are likely to be the most accurate .
dft - pbe gives more accurate dispersion curves than dft - lda , for which the phonon frequencies are too low .
the dispersion curves obtained with the dmc pair potential are more accurate than those obtained using either dft or the ccsd(t ) pair potential .
we have calculated the zpe of solid neon using the dft - lda and dft - pbe methods , and the hfd - b , ccsd(t ) , and dmc pair potentials , within the quasiharmonic approximation . at low pressures
the zpe depends on the calculation method used , but the contribution to the eos is small , while at high pressures the dependence on the calculation method is relatively weak , although the contribution of the zpe to the eos is significant .
the einstein model gives zpe s in very good agreement with the quasiharmonic values over the pressure range considered .
we have calculated the zero - temperature eos of solid neon using the dft and dmc methods , including corrections for the zpe .
we have shown that the dft results depend strongly on the choice of exchange - correlation functional , while the dmc results are close to the experimental eos .
we therefore have evidence that dmc gives a better description of van der waals bonding in real materials than dft . at high pressures
the dmc eos is closer to the experimental results than the eos obtained using the hfd - b pair potential .
however , the statistical errors of about 0.0002 a.u . in the dmc energy data for solid neon are too large to determine an accurate value for the lattice constant of the solid .
we have shown that the neon pair potential determined by dmc calculations gives a more accurate eos than the pair potential determined by ccsd(t ) calculations , although the dmc pair - potential results are not as accurate as those obtained using the semiempirical hfd - b potential .
overall , our results demonstrate the accuracy and reliability of the dmc method and the high quality of the neon pseudopotentials that we have used .
financial support has been provided by the engineering and physical sciences research council ( epsrc ) , uk .
computing resources have been provided by the cambridge - cranfield high performance computing facility .
we thank j. r. trail for providing the relativistic hartree - fock pseudopotential used in this work .
e. gregoryanz , r. j. hemley , h .- k .
mao , and p. gillet , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 3117 ( 2000 ) ; j. li , h .- k .
mao , y. fei , e. gregoryanz , m. eremets , and c. s. zha , phys .
minerals * 29 * , 166 ( 2002 ) ; s. d. jacobsen , h. spetzler , h. j. reichmann , and j. r. smyth , proc .
usa * 101 * , 5867 ( 2004 ) ; j .- f .
lin , v. v. struzhkin , s. d. jacobsen , m. y. hu , p. chow , j. kung , h. liu , h .- k .
mao , and r. j. hemley , nature * 436 * , 377 ( 2005 ) .
the short - range modifications to the hfd - b potential proposed by aziz and slaman are irrelevant in this work , because the potential is only modified at a separation of less than 2.36 a.u .
, corresponding to an fcc primitive - cell volume of 9.32 a.u .
we have determined the constant offset to the energy data during the fitting procedure instead of subtracting the energy of two isolated neon atoms in order to improve the accuracy of the fit . the fixed - node error in a neon dimer is larger than the fixed - node error in an isolated neon atom .
therefore a direct evaluation of the absolute value of the pair potential is a ( slight ) systematic overestimate . while hansen@xcite used the vmc method to calculate the ground - state of the _ atoms
_ , interacting with lennard - jones potentials , we use the vmc method to calculate the ground state of the _ electrons _ within the born - oppenheimer approximation . | we report quantum monte carlo ( qmc ) , plane - wave density - functional theory ( dft ) , and interatomic pair - potential calculations of the zero - temperature equation of state ( eos ) of solid neon .
we find that the dft eos depends strongly on the choice of exchange - correlation functional , whereas the qmc eos is extremely close to both the experimental eos and the eos obtained using the best semiempirical pair potential in the literature .
this suggests that qmc is able to give an accurate treatment of van der waals forces in real materials , unlike dft .
we calculate the qmc eos up to very high densities , beyond the range of values for which experimental data are currently available . at high densities
the qmc eos is more accurate than the pair - potential eos .
we generate a different pair potential for neon by a direct evaluation of the qmc energy as a function of the separation of an isolated pair of neon atoms .
the resulting pair potential reproduces the eos more accurately than the equivalent potential generated using the coupled - cluster ccsd(t ) method . |
the theory of cosmological perturbations @xcite relies essentially on two assumptions , namely that the background is described by pure classical general relativity ( gr ) , while the perturbations thereof stem from quantum fluctuations , although they are subsequently evolved classically . quite apart from the computational usefulness of this scheme ,
this state of affairs is rather incomplete , and one would expect instead a fully quantum treatment of both the background and the perturbations to be achievable .
in fact , the overwhelming majority of classical backgrounds possess an initial singularity at which the classical theory is expected to break down . in recent years
, many quantum background cosmological models have been proposed , which share the attractive property of exhibiting neither singularities nor horizons @xcite , leading the universe evolution through a bouncing phase due to quantum effects , and a contracting phase from infinity before the bounce .
these new features of the background introduce a new picture for the evolution of cosmological perturbations : vacuum initial conditions may now be imposed when the universe was very big and almost flat , and effects due to the contracting and bouncing phases , which are not present in the standard background model , may change the subsequent evolution of perturbations in the expanding phase . hence
, it is quite important to study the evolution of perturbations in these quantum backgrounds .
the aim of the present paper is to provide a step in this direction by considering tensor perturbations in quantum minisuperspace background solutions . interpreting the quantum theory in an ontological way @xcite allows to define quantum scale factor trajectories , which can then be used in the second order tensorial modes perturbation equations as show in ref .
@xcite . note that such models may be viewed as alternatives to the standard inflationary paradigm @xcite .
most known alternatives @xcite to inflation present a primordial bouncing phase @xcite .
note that such a phase can also be seen as a complementary ingredient necessary for a complete cosmological scenario to make actual sense , _
i.e. _ not to be plagued with a singularity @xcite , or to avoid facing any trans - planckian problem @xcite if , for instance , the bounce occurs at a scale such that all relevant cosmological scales now never went trans - planckian .
the bounce phase has recently been the subject of a lot of attention , in particular in view of the fact that in many instances , it was found to have the ability to modify the primordial spectrum of scalar perturbations , thus paving the way to confront them to the observational data @xcite . in the case of bounces in quantum cosmological
models , although the evolution equations for the perturbations may be constructed @xcite , they are rather complicated due to the fact that the background does not satisfy classical einstein s equations . hence , all works in this area had to rely on a semiclassical approximation . in this paper
, we calculate the gravitational wave background spectrum produced at the bounce transition when this phase is described by a perfect fluid and the theory is fully quantized : this is the first time such a calculation , not involving any semiclassical approximation is performed .
the restriction to gravitational waves stems from the fact that the perturbation equations for this type of modes can be substantially simplified , even when the background is quantized @xcite .
scalar and vector modes , however , exhibit technical difficulties which have not been solved yet , so that tensor modes are , for the time being , the only modes that can be studied in a completely quantum way . the paper is organized as follows .
recalling in sec .
[ sec : mode ] how the ontological interpretation allows a simple separation between the background and the perturbations , we explain in sec .
[ sec : traj ] how the bohmian trajectories for the scale factor are derived , and discuss their generality
. then , sec .
[ sec : mu ] , which is the core of this work , provides the tensorial modes indices in the known cases .
we end in sec .
v with conclusions and discussions .
the action we shall begin with is that of gr with a perfect fluid , the latter being described by the formalism due to schutz @xcite , _
i.e. _ @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the planck length in natural units ( @xmath2 ) , @xmath3 is the perfect fluid pressure whose density @xmath4 is provided by the relation @xmath5 , @xmath6 being a constant .
the metric @xmath7 in eq . ( [ action ] ) is of the friedman - lematre - robertson - walker ( flrw ) type , whose line element we choose to be given by @xmath8 _
i.e. _ we assume it is perturbed to first order and restrict attention to tensorial perturbations only , with @xmath9 and @xmath10 , indices being raised and lowered by means of the background metric @xmath11 of the spacelike hypersurfaces ( the bar denotes a covariant derivative with respect to this metric ) ; the lapse function @xmath12 , once fixed , defines the gauge . after inserting eq .
( [ adm2 ] ) into the action ( [ action ] ) , and performing legendre and canonical transformations , the hamiltonian up to second order reads ( see ref .
@xcite for details ) @xmath13 \right\ } , \label{h1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is nothing but the hamiltonian of ref .
@xcite expressed for a perfect fluid . in eq .
( [ h1 ] ) and in what follows , we shall denote by @xmath14 the spatial curvature ( @xmath15 for flat , open and closed space respectively ) in order to avoid confusion with the wavenumber @xmath16 below .
the quantities @xmath17 are the momenta canonically conjugate to the scale factor , the tensor perturbations , and to the fluid degree of freedom , respectively .
these quantities have been redefined in order to be dimensionless .
for instance , the physical scale factor @xmath18 can be obtained from the adimensional @xmath19 present in ( [ h1 ] ) through @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the comoving volume of the background spacelike hypersurfaces .
this hamiltonian , which is zero due to the constraint @xmath22 , yields the correct einstein equations both at zeroth and first order in the perturbations , as can be checked explicitly . in order to obtain its expression ,
no assumption has been made about the background dynamics . in the quantum regime
, this hamiltonian can be substantially simplified through the implementation of the quantum canonical transformation generated by @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the self - adjoint operators associated with the corresponding classical variables , yielding , for a particular factor ordering of ( [ h1 ] ) ( see ref .
@xcite for details ) , @xmath26 .
\label{h200}\ ] ] as we are here also quantizing the background , the quantization procedure is now to impose @xmath27 .
the wheeler - dewitt equation in this case reads @xmath28\right\}\psi , \label{es2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have chosen @xmath29 as the time variable , which is equivalent to impose the time gauge @xmath30 .
note that such a choice is possible in the case at hand because we are considering a a perfect fluid , for which one can use the variable which describes the fluid as a clock @xcite .
now , if one uses an ontological interpretation of quantum mechanics like the one suggested by de broglie and bohm @xcite , and makes the separation ansatz for the wave functional @xmath31=\varphi(a , t)\psi[a , w_{ij},t]$ ] , with @xmath32=\psi_1[w_{ij},t]\int { \mbox{d}}a \varphi^{-2}(a , t ) + \psi_2[w_{ij},t]$ ] , then eq . ( [ es2 ] )
can be split into two , yielding @xmath33 and @xmath34\psi .
\label{es22}\ ] ] using the bohm interpretation , eq .
( [ es20 ] ) can now be solved as in ref .
@xcite , yielding a bohmian quantum trajectory @xmath35 , which in turn can be used in eq .
( [ es22 ] ) .
indeed , since one can view @xmath35 as a function of @xmath29 , it is possible to implement the canonical transformation generated by @xmath36 \exp\left\ { i \left [ \int { \mbox{d}}^3 x \left ( \frac{w_{ij}\pi ^{ij } + \pi ^{ij } w_{ij}}{2 } \right ) \ln\left ( \frac{\sqrt{12}}{a } \right ) \right]\right\},\ ] ] where , as @xmath35 is a given quantum trajectory coming from eq . ( [ es20 ] ) , eq .
( [ qct0 ] ) must be viewed as the generator of a time dependent canonical transformation to eq .
( [ es22 ] ) .
it yields @xmath37 \psi . \label{es27}\ ] ] through the redefinition of time @xmath38 , we obtain @xmath39 \right\ } \psi(\mu_{ij},\eta ) .
\label{nense}\ ] ] this is the most simple form of the schrdinger equation which governs tensor perturbations for a quantum minisuperspace model with fluid matter source .
the equation for the modes @xmath40 which can be derived from eq .
( [ nense ] ) reads ( for that point on , the @xmath16-index will be omitted ) @xmath41 which has the same form as the one obtained for classical backgrounds ( see ref .
@xcite ) , with the important difference that the function @xmath42 is no longer the classical solution for the scale factor , but the quantum bohmian solution . in this way
, we can proceed with the usual analysis , with the quantum bohmian solution @xmath42 coming from eq .
( [ es20 ] ) acting as the new pump field .
in order to obtain the background quantum solutions , we choose the following factor ordering for the kinetic term of the background schrdinger equation ( from now on @xmath43 ) : @xmath44 \varphi - { { \cal k}}a^{3\omega+1}\varphi \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{4 } \left\ { a^{(3\omega-1)/2}\frac{\partial}{\partial a } \left [ a^{(3\omega-1)/2}\frac{\partial}{\partial a}\right ] \right\}\varphi- { { \cal k}}a^{3\omega+1}\varphi , \label{es201}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is the factor ordering yielding a covariant schrdinger equation under field redefinitions @xcite . the quantum bohmian trajectories are obtained from the solutions of eq .
( [ es201 ] ) .
there are two distinct situations : whether the spacelike hypersurfaces are flat or not . with the factor ordering chosen in eq .
( [ es201 ] ) with @xmath45 , we can change variables to @xmath46 , obtaining the simple equation @xmath47 note that this is just the time reversed schrdinger equation for a one dimensional free particle constrained to the positive axis . as @xmath19 and @xmath48 are positive , solutions which have unitary evolution must satisfy the condition @xmath49 ( see ref .
@xcite for details ) .
we will choose the initial normalized wave function @xmath50 where @xmath51 is an arbitrary constant which determines the width of the gaussian and hence the probability amplitude of initial scale factors .
the gaussian @xmath52 satisfies condition ( [ cond27 ] ) .
it is a commonly used initial condition when the time gauge is fixed and one gets a schrdinger equation of the type of eq .
( [ es202 ] ) @xcite , and even when the time gauge is not fixed when constructing wave packets @xcite .
using the propagator procedure of refs .
@xcite , we obtain the wave solution for all times in terms of @xmath19 : @xmath53^{1/4 } \exp\biggl[\frac{-4t_0a^{3(1-\omega)}}{9(t^2+t_0 ^ 2)(1-\omega)^2}\biggr ]
\exp\left\{-i\left[\frac{4ta^{3(1-\omega)}}{9(t^2+t_0 ^ 2)(1-\omega)^2 } + \frac{1}{2}\arctan\biggl(\frac{t_0}{t}\biggr)-\frac{\pi}{4}\right]\right\ } .\ ] ] due to the chosen factor ordering , the probability density @xmath54 has a non trivial measure and it is given by @xmath55 .
its continuity equation coming from eq .
( [ es201 ] ) reads @xmath56=0 , \ ] ] which implies in the bohm interpretation that @xmath57 in accordance with the classical relations @xmath58 and @xmath59 . inserting the phase of ( [ psi1 t ] ) into eq .
( [ guidance ] ) , we obtain the bohmian quantum trajectory for the scale factor : @xmath60^\frac{1}{3(1-\omega ) } .\ ] ] note that this solution has no singularities and tends to the classical solution when @xmath61
. remember that we are in the gauge @xmath30 , and @xmath62 is related to conformal time through @xmath63^{3\omega-1 } { \mbox{d}}t.\ ] ] the solution ( [ at ] ) can be obtained for other initial wave functions ( see ref .
@xcite ) . in this case , only for @xmath64 ( radiation ) are there analytic solutions available .
here , @xmath65 , and there is no factor ordering ambiguity in the kinetic term .
equation ( [ es20 ] ) [ or ( [ es201 ] ) ] reduces to the time reversed schrdinger equation for harmonic or anharmonic oscillators . now the condition for unitary evolution reads @xmath66 the probability density @xmath54 is the trivial one , namely @xmath67 , satisfying the continuity equation @xmath68 yielding the guidance relation @xmath69 given the same initial wave function as before , we obtain ( see ref .
@xcite ) , @xmath70}\right\}^{1/4 } \exp\left[\frac{-\eta_0 a^{2}\mathcal{k } } { \eta_0 ^ 2\mathcal{k}\cos^2\left ( \sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right ) + \sin^2\left ( \sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right)}\right]\times\nonumber \\ & & \times\exp\left(-i\left\{\frac{\left(1-\mathcal{k } \eta_0 ^ 2\right ) \sqrt{\mathcal{k}}a^2 \cos \left ( \sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right ) \sin\left ( \sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right ) } { \left [ \eta_0 ^ 2\mathcal{k}\cos^2\left ( \sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right ) + \sin^2\left ( \sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right)\right ] } + \frac{1}{2}\arctan\left[\frac{\eta_0\sqrt{\mathcal{k } } \cos\left(\sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right ) } { \sin\left ( \sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right)}\right]- \frac{\pi}{4}\right\}\right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( we change @xmath51 to @xmath71 when @xmath64 ) . the bohmian quantum scale factor obtained through the substitution of the phase of eq .
( [ psikt ] ) into eq .
( [ guidance2 ] ) reads @xmath72^\frac{1}{2}= a_0 \left[\cos^2\left(\sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right)+ \frac{\sin^2\left(\sqrt{\mathcal{k}}\eta\right)}{\mathcal{k}\eta_0 ^ 2 } \right]^\frac{1}{2}\ ] ] for @xmath73 and radiation , we can obtain the wave solution and bohmian trajectories either by taking the respective limits from eqs .
( [ psi1 t ] ) and ( [ at ] ) or eqs ( [ psikt ] ) and ( [ atk ] ) .
the resulting bohmian scale factor is @xmath74 note that , for the curved space section solutions be realistic , there must have a long epoch after the bounce when the scale factor recover its classical evolution and the curvature is negligible , i.e. when the scale factor in eq .
( [ atk ] ) can be approximated in some large interval of @xmath75 to @xmath76 in order for the model to be compatible with standard nucleosynthesis and cosmological observations .
this can be accomplished if @xmath77 .
it means that the initial wave function ( [ initial ] ) must be a very centered gaussian around zero .
the flatness problem is then translated to the quantum cosmological language to the question : why an initial gaussian wave function of the universe is so centered around a null value for the scale factor ?
having obtained in the previous sections the propagation equation for the full quantum tensorial modes , namely eq . ( [ mu ] ) , in the bohmian picture with the scale factor assuming the form ( [ at ] ) or ( [ atk ] ) , it is our goal in this section to solve this equation in order to obtain the gravitational wave power spectrum as predicted by such models .
the first two subsections deal with the flat spatial section case for @xmath78 .
the final one treat the curved spatial cases for @xmath64 .
our first task consists in going from the conformal time @xmath75 to the more convenient time variable @xmath62 stemming from the change ( [ jauge ] ) . with a dot indicating a derivative with respect to @xmath62
, the mode potential reads @xmath79,\ ] ] and eq .
( [ mu ] ) transforms into @xmath80 v = 0,\ ] ] in which we have defined @xmath81 .
specializing to the flat @xmath73 case and setting @xmath82 we obtain @xmath83 \bar{v } = 0.\ ] ] which is in a useful form for the practical purpose of numerical resolution .
we shall assume the usual vacuum state initial condition for the modes , _
i.e. _ we set @xcite @xmath84,\ ] ] where @xmath85 is an arbitrary ( and physically irrelevant as was checked numerically ) constant conformal time , which we set to zero in what follows without loss of generality
[ fig : v01 ] to [ fig : v07 ] show the actual mode calculated numerically with eq .
( [ vbar ] ) . the power spectrum can now be defined as @xcite @xmath86 leading to @xmath87 which , although in general being a time - dependent quantity , happens to be constant in the expanding phase for the time period we are interested in .
therefore , it suffices to solve eq .
( [ vbar ] ) with the initial condition ( [ mu_ini ] ) to obtain the gravitational wave power spectrum we are seeking .
this is how we obtained the figures .
given eq .
( [ at ] ) and the relation ( [ jauge ] ) between the two time parameters , one has @xmath88 t , \ ] ] where @xmath89 is a hypergeometric function and we have assumed a common origin for both times ( _ i.e . _
@xmath90 for @xmath91 ) . this can be simplified by considering that one is mostly interested , either for setting initial conditions or for observing the resulting power spectrum , for times much larger than the typical bounce duration , _
i.e. _ for @xmath92
. then , one recovers the usual perfect fluid power law solution for the scale factor , allowing us to write @xmath93 .
( [ mu ] ) with @xmath45 has a potential for gravitational waves that is written @xmath94 , and which can be expressed in terms of the @xmath95 variable as @xmath96,\ ] ] where the constant @xmath97 is given by @xmath98 ^ 2.\ ] ] for large values of @xmath75 , hence of @xmath95 , and provided @xmath99 , one gets @xmath100 which vanishes asymptotically for all cases of practical interest ( @xmath101 ) .
the case @xmath102 is a very special and simple one : the time @xmath62 is conformal time @xmath75 , eq .
( [ nensecampeao ] is identical to eq .
( [ mu ] ) , and @xmath103^{1/2}$ ] . in a different context , this same mode equation ( with @xmath104 ) was treated in ref .
@xcite , yielding an spectral index @xmath105 given by @xmath106 .
let us determine the end of potential domination point , denoted by @xmath107 in what follows , i.e. , the time at which @xmath108 .
this is @xmath109^{\frac{3 \left(\omega-1\right)}{2\left ( 1 + 3\omega \right)}}.\ ] ] this point will also be used to match different solutions and thus propagate the mode through the bounce .
it is interesting to note that the corresponding point for the evolution of @xmath110 , namely the point obtained by annihilating the bracket in eq .
( [ vbar ] ) , called @xmath111 , is @xmath112 so that the ratio is @xmath113 which , for long wavelengths ( @xmath114 ) is much less than one ( recall that @xmath115 )
. therefore , the modes we consider in the numerical solution have no time to start oscillating before reaching @xmath107 .
putting eq .
( [ vasym ] ) into eq .
( [ mu ] ) and using ( [ keta ] ) , we arrive at the conclusion that , sufficiently far from the bounce , the perturbation mode satisfies @xmath116\mu = 0,\ ] ] whose solution is @xmath117,\ ] ] with @xmath118 @xmath119 and @xmath120 being two constants depending on the wavelength , @xmath121 being hankel functions .
this solution applies asymptotically , where one can impose initial conditions on the mode , as well as in the matching region for which @xmath122 , provided @xmath123 .
demanding the bunch - davies vacuum normalization ( [ mu_ini ] ) then implies @xmath124 the solution can also be expanded in powers of @xmath125 according to the formal solution @xcite @xmath126\nonumber \\ & + & a_2(k ) \biggl[\int^\eta\frac{{\mbox{d}}\bar{\eta}}{a^2 } - k^2 \int^\eta \frac{{\mbox{d}}\bar{\eta}}{a^2 } \int^{\bar{\eta } } a^2 { \mbox{d}}\bar{\bar{\eta } } \int^{\bar{\bar{\eta } } } \frac{{\mbox{d}}\bar{\bar{\bar{\eta}}}}{a^2 } \biggr],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath127 and @xmath128 are two constants depending only on the wavenumber @xmath16 through the initial conditions . neglecting the @xmath129 terms , for the expanding phase
, the @xmath128 term is known as the decaying mode , and the power spectrum ( [ ps ] ) can then be approximated accurately by a constant ; this constant power spectrum is the one we are looking for .
although this form is particularly valid as long as @xmath130 , _
i.e. _ when the mode is below its potential , eq .
( [ solform ] ) should formally apply for all times .
in the matching region , the @xmath129 terms may give contributions to the amplitude , but they do not alter the @xmath16-dependence of the power spectrum .
for the solution ( [ at ] ) , the leading order of the solution ( [ solform ] ) reads @xmath131 where in the last steps we have taken the limit @xmath132 and identified the leading orders in @xmath95 , with @xmath133 and @xmath134 .
propagating this solution on the other side of the bounce , in the expanding epoch , yields the required power spectrum , _
i.e. _ the limit for @xmath135 , namely @xmath136 where we have taken only the constant part of the modes .
in order to get the spectrum of gravitational waves produced by our bouncing model , it suffices to match @xmath137 and @xmath138 at @xmath139 , corresponding to @xmath107 given by ( [ xend ] ) through ( [ keta ] ) . at this point ,
the mode function ( [ bessel ] ) and its derivative read @xmath140 where the constants @xmath141 and @xmath142 are given by @xmath143 and @xmath144 \bigg\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath145 this is also expressed as @xmath146 with @xmath147 and @xmath148 . matching @xmath137 [ eqs .
( [ solmu0 ] ) and ( [ mum ] ) ] and its derivative with respect to conformal time , namely @xmath149 , one obtains , to leading order @xmath150 \tilde k^\frac{3\left(1-\omega\right)}{2\left(3\omega+1\right)},\label{a1}\\ \tilde a_2 & = & \left [ \frac{2}{3\beta\left(1-\omega\right ) } \tilde c - a_0^{3\omega-1 } t_0 \alpha \tilde d \right ] \tilde k^\frac{3\left(\omega-1\right)}{2\left(3\omega+1\right)},\label{a2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath151^{-1/(1 + 3\omega)}\ ] ] and @xmath152^{\frac{1 - 3\omega}{2(1 + 3\omega)}}.\ ] ] the coefficients @xmath153 and @xmath154 contain each a power - law behaviors in @xmath16 . because @xmath155 , the power in @xmath156 [ eq . ( [ a2 ] ) ] is negative definite and that in @xmath153 [ eq . ( [ a1 ] ) ] is positive definite .
therefore , @xmath154 is the dominant mode and gives the spectral index , while @xmath153 provides the sub - dominant mode that happens , incidentally , to correspond to an unaltered propagation of the initial conditions .
one then gets the spectrum ( [ specend ] ) , and finally the spectral index @xmath157 writing @xmath158 and we get @xmath159 note that the limit @xmath160 of eq .
( [ index ] ) gives the correct index for radiation ( see ref .
@xcite ) , although the calculation , in this case , should not be valid ; this is due to the expected continuity of the spectral index with the equation of state .
the spectrum as calculated numerically is plotted on fig [ fig : spectrum ] for various values of @xmath6 together with the approximation ( [ index ] ) .
it is interesting to note that this result was also presented in the semiclassical approximation ( classical background and quantum perturbations ) in ref .
@xcite . in ref .
@xcite , the asymptotic behaviors both in the past and future infinities are two , possibly different , power laws for the contraction and expansion phases , whereas the type of bounces we studied here is restricted to equal asymptotic behaviors , i.e. , for @xmath161 .
since the potentials in the equations for @xmath137 are smooth and large compared to @xmath16 around the bounce , it looks like the full quantum effects and details of the bounce do not change significantly the main spectral features of the gravitational wave produced .
it would be interesting to verify if this results still holds for other bounces , e.g. those having different asymptotic behaviors and/or more complicated shapes of the potential for @xmath137 . in this last situation , and if the results of ref .
@xcite apply , one would expect the actual spectra to be different .
in this subsection we consider the power spectrum of tensor perturbations for quantum cosmological backgrounds with curved spatial sections . as mentioned in sec .
iii , only in the radiation case one can obtain analytic solutions for the quantum background . hence , we will restrict ourselves to this fluid from now on . inserting eq .
( [ atk ] ) into eq .
( [ mu ] ) , and noting that @xmath162 , where @xmath163 is an integer greater or equal to @xmath164 for @xmath165 , and a real number greater than zero for @xmath166 , we obtain @xmath167 ^ 2 } \right\}\mu = 0.\ ] ] the effective potential @xmath168 ^ 2}\ ] ] has one maximum given by @xmath169 and goes to zero when @xmath170 for @xmath166 .
it oscillates between @xmath169 and @xmath171 , which are respectively a maximum and a minimum provided @xmath172 , when @xmath173 . indeed , as we have seen in sec .
[ sec : traj ] , in order for the background models to be realistic , one must have @xmath174 . hence , the maxima of the effective potential are very high in both cases and the minima are very small in the @xmath165 case .
large wavelengths ( small @xmath163 ) will cross the effective potential and the perturbations will be amplified at each bounce .
this induces an instability of the model because this enhancement happens an infinite number of times , and therefore , however small the initial perturbation might have been , there is a time at which the linear theory is no longer valid and the cosmological setup breaks down . curved case filled with radiation . for @xmath175 ,
the amplitude behaves , as expected at least for the case @xmath176 , as a power law since then @xmath177.,width=321 ] for @xmath166 , the situation is very similar to the flat case .
the conformal time @xmath178 of potential crossing is given as the solution of the equation @xmath179 which has a real solution provided @xmath180 .
thus , the mode crosses the potential only in this case .
this constraint is however satisfied for the situations we are interested in , namely , @xmath77 and @xmath175 .
one then obtains @xmath181 we have two limiting cases , namely @xmath182 and @xmath183 yielding , respectively , latexmath:[\[\label{etamg } latexmath:[\[\label{etamp } the effect of the potential for @xmath137 is to increase its amplitude by a factor shown on fig .
[ fig : mukm1 ] , as well as to mix the exponential terms .
this can be easily seen by the following approximation .
for @xmath77 , the maximum of the effective potential at @xmath90 is very large while for @xmath185 it behaves like @xmath186 , which goes to zero when @xmath187 .
hence the effective potential ( [ veffk ] ) can be well approximated to a dirac delta in this limit .
its integration reads @xmath188^{-2}\cr & & \cr & = & \frac{\left(\eta_0 ^ 2 + 1\right ) \sinh\left(2\eta\right)}{2\left[\left(\eta_0 ^ 2 - 1\right ) + \left(\eta_0 ^ 2 + 1\right ) \cosh\left(2\eta\right)\right ] } \cr & & \cr & & + \frac{1-\eta_0 ^ 2}{2\eta_0 } \tan^{-1 } \left(\frac{\tanh\eta}{\eta_0}\right ) , \label{veffint}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which implies @xmath189 where in the last step we have assumed that @xmath77 . hence , one can approximate the effective potential by a dirac distribution @xcite @xmath190 .
the solution for @xmath191 is then simply eq .
( [ mu_ini ] ) with @xmath16 substituted by @xmath163 for @xmath192 , and @xmath193 for @xmath194 .
demanding that @xmath137 be continuous across the potential and imposing eq .
( [ muk ] ) then leads to another matching condition , namely @xmath195 one then finds that @xmath196 and finally , in the long wavelength approximation for which @xmath175 , that @xmath197 .
this is exactly what is obtained numerically , as shown on fig .
[ fig : mukm1 ] . note also that when the curves reach the @xmath198 region , the amplitude is the initial one : the mode has not crossed the potential as explained above .
note incidentally that solution ( [ coef ] ) is exatly the same as the one obtained in ref .
@xcite and in the present paper for radiation with @xmath199 , where we used the matching method .
this is because also in this case one can approximate the potential to a dirac distribution as @xmath200 when @xmath185 , which goes to zero in the limit @xmath201 .
however , for the parabolic scale factor @xmath202 $ ] also treated in ref .
@xcite , which solutions are quite different from ( [ coef ] ) , the potential is @xmath203 , whose limit for @xmath185 is @xmath204 , independent of @xmath71 . hence in this case , the effective potential can not be approximated by a dirac distribution , and the final spectrum is very different .
we thus confirm that the power spectrum of perturbations through a bounce may depend significantly of the details of the bounce itself . with the coefficients ( [ coef ] )
, one can calculate the spectrum @xmath205 for the two possible matching points ( [ etamg],[etamp ] ) , yielding @xmath206 and @xmath207 . note that , as expected , the case @xmath183 yields the same spectrum as the flat case : the two scale factors are quite similar in that limit .
we have obtained the power spectrum of tensor perturbations in bouncing quantum cosmological models with a perfect fluid satisfying @xmath5 for flat spatial sections and @xmath208 , and for curved spatial sections with @xmath209 . for flat spatial sections ,
the spectral index for large wavelengths is @xmath210 .
the positive curved spatial section model is unstable , while the negative curved spatial section model amplifies the modes , changing the amplitude to a power index of @xmath211 or @xmath212 , depending on the parameters .
all cases lead to oscillations in the primordial spectrum .
the most interesting case is the one of radiation , which is the best perfect fluid model for the early universe ( all particles are ultra - relativistic ) . for almost flat spatial sections we have @xmath213 , which is different from the predictions of inflation .
hence , this model can be potentially tested against inflation in future observations , specially concerning the polarization of the cosmic microwave background , planck observations , and gravitational wave detectors if we calculate the amplitude of these perturbations .
the next step would be to calculate the spectrum of scalar perturbations of these models .
the dynamical equations for scalar perturbations are not , however , as simple as eq .
( [ mu ] ) .
the steps we have taken in sec .
( 2 ) in order to arrive at eq . ( [ mu ] ) in the case where the background is also quantized are not so simple in the case of scalar perturbations , specially due to the matter terms .
this is work in progress .
attainment of the power spectrum of scalar perturbations is crucial not only to test the model against wmap observations , but also to calibrate and obtain the precise spectrum of tensor perturbations for possible comparisons with ligo and virgo future data .
we would like to thank cnpq of brazil for financial support .
we would also like to thank both the institut dastrophysique de paris and the centro brasileiro de pesquisas fsicas , where this work was done , for warm hospitality .
we very gratefully acknowledge various enlightening conversations with jrme martin .
we also would like to thank capes ( brazil ) and cofecub ( france ) for partial financial support .
a. guth , , 347 ( 1981 ) ; a. linde , phys .
b * 108*,389 ( 1982 ) ; a. albrecht and p. j. steinhardt , , 1220 ( 1982 ) ; a. linde , phys .
b * 129 * , 177 ( 1983 ) ; a. a. starobinsky , pisma zh .
. fiz . * 30 * , 719 ( 1979 ) [ jetp lett . * 30 * , 682 ( 1979 ) ] ; v. mukhanov and g. chibisov , jetp lett . * 33 * , 532 ( 1981 ) ; s. hawking , phys . lett .
b * 115 * , 295 ( 1982 ) ; a. a. starobinsky , phys .
b * 117 * , 175 ( 1982 ) ; j. m. bardeen , p. j. steinhardt , and m. s. turner , , 679 ( 1983 ) ; a. guth , s. y. pi , , 1110 ( 1982 ) .
g. veneziano , phys .
b * 265 * , 287 ( 1991 ) ; m. gasperini and g. veneziano , astropart .
* 1 * , 317 ( 1993 ) ; see also j. e. lidsey , d. wands , and e. j. copeland , phys .
* 337 * , 343 ( 2000 ) and g. veneziano , in _ the primordial universe _ ,
les houches , session lxxi , edited by p. bintruy _ et al .
_ , ( edp science & springer , paris , 2000 ) g. murphy , phys . rev . *
d8 * , 4231 ( 1973 ) ; a. a. starobinsky , sov .
lett . 4 , * 82 * ( 1978 ) ; m. novello and j. m. salim , phys . rev .
* d20 * , 377 ( 1979 ) ; v. melnikov and s. orlov , phys .
lett * a70 * , 263 ( 1979 ) ; p. peter and n. pinto - neto , , 023513 ( 2002 ) ; p. peter and n. pinto - neto , , 063509 ( 2002 ) ; v.a .
de lorenci , r. klippert , m. novello and j.m .
salim , , 063501 ( 2002 ) ; j. c. fabris , r. g. furtado , p. peter and n. pinto - neto , 124003 ( 2003 ) ; p. peter , n. pinto - neto and d. a. gonzalez , jcap * 0312 * , 003 ( 2003 ) .
j. martin and r. brandenberger , , 123501 ( 2001 ) ; r. brandenberger and j. martin , mod .
a * 16 * , 999 ( 2001 ) ; j. niemeyer , , 123502 ( 2001 ) ; a. a. starobinsky , jetp lett . * 73 * , 371 ( 2001 ) ; m. lemoine , m. lubo , j. martin , and j. p. uzan , , 023510 ( 2002 ) . | we discuss the gravitational wave background produced by bouncing models based on a full quantum evolution of a universe filled with a perfect fluid .
using an ontological interpretation for the background wave function allows us to solve the mode equations for the tensorial perturbations , and we find the spectral index as a function of the fluid equation of state . |
negative thermal expansion ( nte ) is a rare and counter - intuitive phenomenon found primarily in low density materials with crystal structures that are networks of linked coordination polyhedra .
the study of these materials is not only of fundamental scientific importance , but also has many technological applications such as aerospace technologies @xcite , optics @xcite , and electronics @xcite .
while much effort has been put into finding new materials and investigating the origin of nte in them , much less attention has been paid to the change in nte behaviour subject to heating and stress , which holds great importance for the possible applications of the material .
for example , due to stresses and heating , problems such as phase transitions of the nte filler and thermal expansion misfit between the nte filler and matrix are always encountered in designed composites with tailored thermal expansion @xcite . in this paper
, we conduct a simulation study of zn(cn)@xmath0 focusing on the pressure and temperature effects on its negative thermal expansion .
we chose this material for several reasons .
firstly , zn(cn)@xmath0 is a well - known representative nte material @xcite .
it has a framework structure consisting of tetrahedral groups of atoms linked by diatomic rods of c
n and has exceptionally large isotropic nte of @xmath1 mk@xmath2 ( twice as large as that of zrw@xmath0o@xmath3 @xcite ) .
secondly , the material shows a variety of exotic properties in experiments @xcite , including reduction of its nte on heating , pressure - enhanced thermal contraction , and pressure - induced softening , none of which are fully understood .
thirdly , with previous dft calculations of zn(cn)@xmath0 @xcite explaining the origin of nte of the material in terms of grneisen theory , it would be useful to draw a clear link between the values of the grneisen parameters in energy space and the structural vibrations in real space with full anharmonicity ( which should be important in such an nte system ) based on theoretically reproducing the aforementioned exotic properties . here ,
we have built a zn(cn)@xmath0 potential model based on first - principles calculations .
lattice - dynamic calculations and large - scale molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations were carried out for the material using this model which was justified by comparing against the available experimental data .
the results in both energy and real space provide us fundamental clues to understand the nte as well as the related exotic behaviours of zn(cn)@xmath0 .
c c c c potential & form of the potential & type of bond & values of parameters + & & zn c & @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 + & & zn n & @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 + & & c zn c & @xmath10 , @xmath11 + harmonic three - body potential & @xmath12 & c zn n & @xmath13 , @xmath11 + & & n zn
n & @xmath14 , @xmath11 + & & zn c n & @xmath15 + & & zn
c & @xmath16 + & & c c & @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 + buckingham potential & @xmath20 & c n & @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 + & & n n & @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 + [ table1 ] we started with total - energy calculations for a [ zn(cn)@xmath27@xmath28 cluster .
the @xmath29 charge comes from the fact that every zinc is shared by four neighbour atoms ( c or n ) , and that the bond should be highly ionic according to an initial judgment of zinc having much smaller electronegativity than carbon and nitrogen .
four cn@xmath30 molecular ligands around each zn@xmath31 would give us a @xmath29 charge on the cluster .
geometry optimization of the cluster resulted in a perfect tetrahedral conformation .
total energies for different configurations of the cluster ( with bond stretching and angular distortions ) were computed using dft in gamess(us ) with the pbe0 functional @xcite .
correlation - consistent basis sets up to aug - cc - pvqz were tested , and an aug - cc - pvtz basis set was found to have sufficient accuracy and no significant basis set superposition errors ( bsse ) at different configurations .
various interatomic potential forms were then fitted to the calculated energy curves to obtain the initial potential parameters .
the short - range interactions are the morse potential for zn
c / n , a harmonic three - body - bond - bending term for c / n zn
n / c and a linear - three - body term for the angular distortion of zn
n n / c .
the long - range van der waals interactions are described by a buckingham potential with parameters from williams @xcite .
two types of clusters with zn
c n order and zn
c order are used .
the multipoles on each cluster were calculated by distributed multipole analysis ( dma ) @xcite using cam @xcite .
the effective point charges on the atoms were then obtained by fitting to the electrostatic potential from the rank 4 ( hexadecapole ) distributed multipoles using the mulfit program @xcite .
[ fig1 ] shows the difference in the electrostatic potential between the point - charge model and the dma result . the root mean square of the difference is less than @xmath32 kj / mol and @xmath33 kj / mol for clusters of zn c n and zn
c , respectively , corresponding to about 1% relative difference in the electrostatic potential around the clusters .
the averaged effective point charges on each atom are ( in electron units ) @xmath34 for zn , @xmath35 for c and @xmath36 for n. the initial potential model was then refined by refitting to dft energy surfaces of various cluster configurations .
the point charges were fixed during this process .
this gave us final potential parameters that implicitly incorporate the effects of higher - ranking multipole moments and atomic polarization .
due to the high strength of the c
n bond @xcite , this group was treated as a rigid rod in all cases .
the potentials with their parameters are listed in table [ table1 ] .
harmonic lattice dynamics ( hld ) and quasi - harmonic lattice dynamics ( qhld ) calculations were carried out using gulp @xcite .
molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations were performed using dl@xmath37poly @xcite for a @xmath38 supercell containing @xmath39 atoms with periodic - boundary conditions .
a constant stress constant temperature ( n@xmath40 t ) ensemble with a nos - hoover thermostat @xcite was used .
the long - range coulomb interactions were calculated using the ewald method with precision of 10@xmath41 .
the equations of motion were integrated using the leapfrog algorithm with a time step of @xmath42 ps .
a total of @xmath43 time steps were used to achieve equilibration . at different temperatures and pressures , snapshots of atomic trajectories
after equilibration were recorded every @xmath44 ps up to a total of @xmath45 ps for the follow - up analysis .
both ordered model with @xmath46 symmetry and disordered model with @xmath47 were used .
the latter was constructed by randomly switching c and n atoms in the supercell .
we compared some basic quantities obtained from the model against experiment .
the optimized structure gave the cell parameter as @xmath48 , and the zn
c / n bond length as @xmath49 compared to @xmath50 and @xmath51 from an experiment at @xmath52 k @xcite .
the model is found to be stable in lattice - dynamic calculations , and the calculated phonons are in good agreement with the spectroscopy data @xcite , as shown in table [ freqtable ]
. the dispersion curves shown in fig .
[ fig : freqsoft ] generally agree well with previous dft calculations @xcite .
.calculated phonon frequencies at the @xmath53 point for both cn ordered and cn disordered ( virtual crystal ) models .
experimental infra - red and raman @xcite data and dft calculated results @xcite are provided for comparison .
frequencies are in cm@xmath2 .
[ cols= " < , < , < , < , < , < " , ] [ freqtable ] it is worth noting the close similarity between the dispersion relations of wave vectors along @xmath53x r and r m@xmath53 , as well as the near - mirror symmetry of the dispersion curves along @xmath53r ( the middle line of @xmath53r is the mirror line ) .
this makes sense given the existence of the two interpenetrating cristoablite - like networks in the material . for the lowest - frequency mode at wave vector r
, the two networks would translate like acoustic modes but out of phase with each other , leading to a dispersion relation that has the appearance of an acoustic mode and a positive grneisen parameter but with a non - zero band gap .
the frequency of this mode is 0.16 thz , lower than the values of 0.69 thz and 0.48 thz from the dft calculations in ref . and ref .
, respectively , suggesting a softer long - range interaction between the two networks in our model .
[ fig : freqsoft ]
[ fig3 ] [ fig3c ] the calculated nte curves of zn(cn)@xmath0 under different pressures from @xmath55 to @xmath56 gpa with increments of @xmath57 gpa are shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] . the pressure - enhanced @xmath58 ( averaged over @xmath45@xmath59 k ) at @xmath55 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 gpa
are @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64mk@xmath2 , respectively , compared to the experimental values @xcite of @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67mk@xmath2 at the corresponding pressures .
the md successfully captured the gradual reduction of nte on heating which has been observed in x - ray scattering @xcite . according to the md
, @xmath68 is @xmath69 mk@xmath2 at 300 k , much lower than the value at 25 k , @xmath70 mk@xmath2 .
experiment @xcite has confirmed that zn(cn)@xmath0 exists in a disordered form with @xmath47 symmetry , i.e. the carbon and nitrogen atoms are randomly placed on their symmetric sites in the structure , compared to the ordered model with @xmath46 symmetry .
nte of the disordered model from the md calculation is displayed as symbol plots in fig .
[ fig3c ] compared to that of the ordered model in solid lines .
clearly , there is no significant difference between the nte of these two systems .
pressure and temperature dependence of the bulk modulus of zn(cn)@xmath0 .
results calculated using the @xmath71@xmath72 data from md simulations and standard thermodynamic relations .
pressure has far less influence on the bulk modulus than temperature.,width=309 ] the bulk modulus @xmath73 is directly related to the coefficient of thermal expansion @xmath74 according to the classical form @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the specific heat and the sum is over all modes with frequencies @xmath77 .
@xmath78^ { - 1}$ ] is the bose - einstein relation with @xmath79 the boltzmann constant .
the overall grneisen parameter @xmath80 is calculated by summing over all mode grneisen parameters weighed with their contribution to the specific heat . at 300 k , the values of the bulk modulus @xmath81 and its first derivative with respect to pressure @xmath82 at zero pressure obtained by using the @xmath83rd - order birch - murnaghan equation of states to fit to the isotherms calculated from our md are @xmath84 gpa and @xmath85 .
both are in good agreement with the experimental values of @xmath86 gpa and @xmath87 , respectively @xcite
. however , the values of the bulk modulus obtained from the previous dft calculations @xcite are much higher than the experiment .
we obtained the bulk modulus of zn(cn)@xmath0 at different temperatures and pressures by numerically computing derivatives of the @xmath71@xmath72 data from the md simulations .
as shown in fig .
[ fig5 ] , on cooling from 300 k to 50 k , @xmath73 increases by 26% compared to the experiment of 15% @xcite .
note that @xmath73 does nt change much with pressure , but changes largely with temperature . referring to fig .
[ fig3 ] , we found that a @xmath88% decrease in volume caused by heating at zero pressure corresponds to as much as @xmath89% decrease in the bulk modulus , while the same amount of volume decrease caused by compression would only reduce the bulk modulus by less than @xmath88% .
this means that the bulk modulus of the material not only depends on the volume change per se , but also on the means of changing the volume by heating or compression .
this breaks birch s law of corresponding states @xcite .
the same anomaly has been observed experimentally in zrw@xmath0o@xmath3 , where the bulk modulus increases by @xmath90% on cooling from @xmath59 k to @xmath91 k @xcite .
pressure and temperature - dependence of zn(cn)@xmath0 volume , calculated using md .
the inset shows the change in volume with pressure up to @xmath92 gpa at @xmath59 k. a high - pressure phase settles down after the clear discontinuity at @xmath93 gpa.,width=302 ] according to the thermodynamic expressions of @xmath94 and @xmath95 combined with maxwell relation @xmath96 , the pressure enhanced nte of the material follows naturally from the relation @xmath97 since the temperature dependence of @xmath73 is negative as shown in fig .
[ fig5 ] , @xmath98 would become more negative on compression .
this is consistent with what seen in the positive expansion materials where @xmath99 so that @xmath98 would decrease on compression .
we found that the value of @xmath82 from a lattice - dynamic calculation using gulp @xcite is @xmath100 compared to its negative value at 300 k. this suggests that all the mechanical contributions at @xmath101 are from the zn c / n bonds that become stiffened on compression .
with elevated temperature , one can imagine that the zn
c / n n / c angle flexing starts to contribute to the change of volume on pressure .
this mechanism costs much less energy than compressing the zn
c / n bonds as suggested by values of the parameters in the morse potential and the linear - three - body potential of the model ( table [ table1 ] ) . as a result , the bulk modulus decreases on compression hence the negative @xmath82 , i.e. pressure - induced softening of the material . at high temperature
, @xmath82 is expected to become less negative on heating due to the rising energy cost of further increasing the zn c /
n n / c angle vibrational amplitude on compression .
the temperature dependence of @xmath82 is specially discussed in our other work @xcite .
in fig . [ fig6 ] , simulations were conducted for zn(cn)@xmath0 at different temperatures in a much broader range of pressure from @xmath102 to @xmath92 gpa , and there is clearly a phase transition of the material caused by compression at each temperature .
with elevated temperature , the phase - transition pressure indicated by the discontinuity in the volume change increases , implying that the phase transition may be triggered by some soft modes that can be stabilized on heating due to the anharmonic term in their frequencies . indeed , as shown in fig .
[ fig : freqsoft ] , if we compare the dispersion curves calculated at a pressure beyond 1.0 gpa ( in light red ) to that at zero pressure ( in black ) , we find softening of the acoustic modes around the zone boundaries , especially the modes at m and the mid - point of @xmath53r @xmath103 which are the first ones to become unstable . the concurrent softening of the optic modes ( @xmath104 thz ) directly above these acoustic modes suggests a possible hybridization between the acoustic modes and the optic modes , resulting in a @xmath105 energy behaviour @xcite at @xmath106 .
same result was found for the disordered model .
the inset of fig .
[ fig6 ] shows the change of volume with pressure up to @xmath92 gpa at @xmath59 k. the volume discontinuities at @xmath107 and @xmath93 gpa may suggest hysteresis in the phase transition .
we found that the new high - pressure phase is orthorhombic with @xmath108 space group ( @xmath109 , @xmath110 , @xmath111 ) .
this is compared to an orthorhombic phase with @xmath112 space group found beyond 1.3 gpa in the x - ray diffraction experiment @xcite .
the zn(cn)@xmath0 phonon density of states at 297 k. solid lines are data from our md calculations ; filled circles are neutron scattering experimental results@xcite . the two agree well with one another.,width=302 ]
the fourier transformation of the atomic velocity auto - correlation function ( vacf ) gives us the phonon density of states ( dos ) @xcite of the material . to obtain the dos at different pressures and temperatures
, we used the trajectory data of atoms from md to calculate the vacf of zn(cn)@xmath0 . the correlation function @xmath113 at time @xmath114 can be expressed as , @xmath115 where @xmath116 is the velocity component of the @xmath117th atom .
@xmath118 is the time interval of @xmath44 ps .
@xmath119 is the total number of time steps .
the system was simulated for a total of @xmath45 ps which corresponds to @xmath120 .
the correlation function was calculated for each atom with a time length of @xmath121 ps ( @xmath122 ) .
a gaussian profile was used before fourier transformation to suppress the ripple effect caused by time cut - off .
the vacf of angular velocities of the c n rigid rods rotating about their center of mass was also calculated .
the fourier transformation then gave us the dos of the pure rotational modes of these rigid rods . to obtain the phonon spectrum ,
the calculated dos was first multiplied by a weighting factor @xmath123 containing the scattering length @xmath124 and the atomic mass @xmath125 of the @xmath126th atom .
then , in order to mimic experimental resolution @xcite , the dos is convolved with a gaussian with fwhm of @xmath127% of the energy transfer .
[ fig7 ] shows the good agreement between the calculated spectrum and the experiment @xcite
. vibrational dos calculated using md at 300 k and at 0.026 gpa , 0.20 gpa , 0.46 gpa and 0.65 gpa .
( a ) shows the full dos for the cn - disordered model ; ( b ) shows the full dos for the cn - ordered model ; ( c ) shows the dos for only c n rigid rod rotations in the ordered model .
the peaks at around 14 thz , corresponding to pure zn
c(n ) bond flexing , increase in frequency on compression.,width=302 ] in order to draw links between the atomic vibrations and the phonon properties , we computed both the overall dos and the angular dos of rigid rod c
n , as shown in fig .
[ fig9 ] and [ fig8 ] . fig .
[ fig9 ] ( a ) and ( b ) shows the dos at ambient temperature ( @xmath59 k ) under different pressures for the disordered and ordered model , respectively .
the acoustic peak around 0.5 thz is softened on compression .
the optic peaks around @xmath128 thz and @xmath129 thz follow the same trend , which means that all these modes have negative grneisen parameters ( @xmath130 ) and contribute to the nte of the material .
the highest energy peak around @xmath131 thz is stiffened under compression , suggesting positive @xmath130 for the zn c / n bond flexing modes .
the only difference between the disordered model and the ordered one is that the former has broader peaks , especially the merged two peaks around @xmath129 thz ( with a broadening of @xmath132 thz ) , due to the ` fluffiness ' caused by random positions of c and n atoms .
vibrational dos calculated using md at 0.0 gpa and temperatures 162 k , 297 k , 473 k and 603 k. ( a ) shows the full dos ; ( b ) shows the dos for only c n rigid rod rotations .
the peaks in the full dos at around 14 thz , corresponding to pure zn
c(n ) bond flexing , broaden and decrease in frequency on heating.,width=302 ] by comparing fig .
[ fig8](b ) with fig . [ fig8](a ) , we found that about half of the acoustic peak around @xmath133 thz is from vibrations involving rotations of the c
n rod around its centre of mass ( bearing in mind that the angular dos in fig .
[ fig8](b ) is renormalized , so that only the relative heights of the peaks are indicative ) .
optic peaks round 2.0 and 9.0 thz are hardly changed , because much of their motions can be cast onto the rotations of the c
the peak with the highest frequency in the overall dos is from pure zn
c / n bond flexing it completely disappears in the angular dos . unlike the acoustic peak
, this peak is softened on heating due to the thermal expansion of the zn c / n bond , and flattens with elevated temperature due to the finite life time of the corresponding phonon .
full dos calculated using lattice - dynamics .
( a ) each bin is coloured according to its average grneisen parameter : red bins have an average @xmath134 value of @xmath135 ; white bins have a positive average @xmath134 .
( b ) each bin is coloured according to its average rum component .
red bins are pure rums ; blue bins have zero rum character.,width=302 ] profiles of mode grneisen parameters of zn(cn)@xmath0 calculated at three different pressures from lattice dynamics : black curve is 0.0 gpa ; blue curve is 0.2 gpa ; red curve is 0.4 gpa .
the grneisen parameters of the modes around 0.5 thz , 2.0 thz and 9.0 thz become more negative as elevated pressures , resulting in a more negative overall grneisen parameter as pressure is increased.,width=302 ] previously , the peak around @xmath133 thz has been found to be the major contributor to the nte in both experiment @xcite and calculations @xcite due to its large negative @xmath130 . however , if one can further identify the corresponding real - space picture of the vibrations , the reason of why the peak has the most negative @xmath130 compared to the other optic peaks can be revealed . to understand the nature of various peaks in the dos , we decided to categorize the vibrational modes in the material using the rigid unit mode model @xcite .
first , we calculated @xmath130 from phonon frequencies of expanded and contracted ( @xmath1360.01% ) unit - cell volumes .
we then coloured the dispersion curves according to both magnitudes and signs of @xmath130 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : dispersioncuves](a ) .
this representation highlights the most important phonon branches responsible for nte of the material , namely the low - lying acoustic modes around @xmath133 thz and the lowest - energy optic branches around @xmath128 thz , which both have the most negative @xmath130 and span the entire brillouin zone .
this was also highlighted in the dos in fig .
[ fig10](a ) , where we coloured the dos according to the mean values of @xmath130 for each frequency bin .
then , we calculated the rigid unit modes ( rums ) of zn(cn)@xmath0 using the crush code @xcite as the set of eigenvectors of the dynamical matrix whose eigenvalues are zero .
we took the dot product between the eigenvectors of the rums and the eigenvectors from the lattice - dynamic calculation , and then coloured the dispersion curves in fig .
[ fig : dispersioncuves](b ) by the extent to which each mode eigenvector can be described in terms of correlated whole - body translations ( in blue ) and rotations ( in red ) of [ zn(c / n)@xmath27 tetrahedra .
the dos in fig .
[ fig10](b ) was also coloured accordingly .
one can see that all the modes with negative @xmath130 that contribute to the nte of the material are rums . as shown by fig .
[ fig : dispersioncuves](c ) , the acoustic modes around @xmath133 thz , like those at m and x , are characterized by translational motions of the rigid tetrahedral units , partly involving angular rotations of the c
the optic modes around @xmath128 and 9.0 thz can be seen as neighbouring tetrahedral rotating against each other , as respectively shown by fig .
[ fig : dispersioncuves](d ) and ( e ) .
the rum nature of these modes guarantees their low frequencies and large negative @xmath130 .
the relatively high frequencies of the optic rums is due to the breaking of the zn c /
n n / c alignment , and the magnitudes of their negative @xmath130 suffer accordingly .
study of the eigenvectors also directly revealed that the non - rum modes around @xmath127 and @xmath131 thz correspond to the pure angular vibration of c / n zn n / c within the tetrahedra and the pure bond flexing of zn
c / n , respectively .
we also found that , besides the negative @xmath137 , zn(cn)@xmath0 also has negative @xmath138 and @xmath139 .
[ fig11 ] shows the profiles of @xmath130 up to @xmath61 gpa calculated in hld .
it is clear that @xmath137 becomes more negative on compression due the contributions from the rums around @xmath133 thz , @xmath128 thz and @xmath129 thz , with the translational rums having the most negative @xmath130 ( refer to fig .
[ fig10](a ) ) contributing the most .
the negativity of the pressure derivatives of @xmath137 would result in negative @xmath140 at non - zero temperatures @xcite . calculated temperature dependence of the nte with both anharmonicity and quantum effects included ( ` md+qe ' , solid curve ) , together with the results from md ( dashed curve ) and qhld ( dash - dot curve ) .
the former clearly has a better agreement with the experiment ( empty circle ) @xcite.,width=302 ] we found that the acoustic peak in the dos ( see fig . [ fig10 ] ) with frequencies less than 1 thz ( @xmath141 k ) accounts for half of the nte ( @xmath142 mk@xmath2 is reduced to @xmath143 mk@xmath2 when excluding these modes , calculated by eq . [ eq1 ] at 300 k in qhld ) .
this suggests that even at low temperatures these modes will not be ` frozen ' out and can still be excited and contribute to nte and its relevant properties such as pressure - enhanced nte and pressure - induced softening of the material .
thus , the classical md results at low temperatures would not have too much difference from the real quantum picture and can give a good qualitative agreement with experiments .
( a ) calculated normalized ( in red solid ) , implicit ( in red dash ) and intrinsic ( in red dots ) anharmonicity using cumulative distributions of dos from the md at 180 and 240 k , compared to the total anharmonicity from the experiment dos at the same two temperatures @xcite .
( b ) calculated normalized anharmonicity ( using cumulative distributions of dos from md at 180 and 240
k ) at different pressures .
the important modes around 0.5 , 2.0 and 9.0 thz have positive anharmonicity with the translational rums ( around 0.5 thz ) shows the largest value compared to others . the modes around 15 thz corresponding to zn
c(n ) bond flexing show negative anharmonicity .
the anharmonicity of all these modes is enhanced by compression.,width=302 ] however , with the following method , we can include the effect of both anharmonicity and quantum effects in the temperature dependence of nte of the material .
first , at a certain temperature , we calculate two dos from md for two adjacent volumes ( with @xmath144 difference ) .
then we can obtain phonon frequencies and mode grneisen parameters by using the cumulative distributions of these two dos .
finally , @xmath98 can be calculated by eq .
we then repeat this process at different temperatures up to 600 k , and obtain the temperature dependence of nte of the material . as such
, anharmonicity is accounted for by the use of the dos from the md , while quantum effects are included in the formalism of eq .
[ eq1 ] to calculate @xmath98 .
together with the direct md and qhld results , the temperature dependence of the nte from this method ( ` md+qe ' ) is shown in fig .
[ figa1 ] . at low temperatures ,
the curve acts like the qhld result due to quantum quenching . at high temperatures
, the curve becomes less negative like md due to anharmonicity , making the curve in a better agreement with the experiment .
from the same analysis , we can also obtain the temperature and pressure dependence of anharmonicity .
the normalized anharmonicity @xcite measuring the change of mode frequency with temperature at constant pressure is defined as @xmath145 where , on the right - hand side , the first term is the intrinsic anharmonicity and the second term is the contribution from the contraction of lattice ( implicit ) . by using the dos from the md at 180 and 240 k ,
the normalized anharmonicity of each mode was calculated , as shown in fig .
[ figa2](a ) .
the results of the important modes around 0.5 , 2.0 and 9.0 thz , as indicated by the vertical lines , agree quite well with the experiment ( using dos at the 180 and 240 k ) @xcite .
the implicit anharmonicity was calculated using the mode grneisen parameters and the ` md+qe ' value of @xmath98 at 180 k. the intrinsic anharmonicity was then obtained from eq . [ eq7 ] .
temperature dependence of the normalized anharmonicity at 0.0 gpa . at 25 , 280 and 560 k ,
calculations were conducted using the cumulative distributions of couples of dos at 25/45 k , 280/300 k and 560/590 k , respectively .
the general trend is that the mode frequencies change less rapidly with temperature on heating.,width=302 ] the normalized anharmonicity at different pressures is shown in fig .
[ figa2](b ) .
as mentioned in the former sections , the modes around 0.5 , 2.0 and 9.0 thz , corresponding to the translational and rotational rums , respectively , are stiffened on heating with positive normalized anharmonicity . among these , the translational rums ( around 0.5 thz ) show the largest normalized anharmonicity of more than @xmath146 k@xmath2 at 0.0 gpa .
the modes around 15 thz corresponding to pure bond flexing of zn c(n ) are softened on heating with negative anharmonicity .
the normalized anharmonicity of all these peaks is strengthened on compression .
we further calculated the normalized anharmonicity at low ( 25 k ) , medium ( 280 k ) and high ( 560 k ) temperatures to see its temperature dependence , as shown in fig .
[ figa3 ] . at each temperature ,
two dos with temperature difference less than 30 k are used .
the low - temperature ( 25 k ) value of the anharmonicity of the modes around 0.5 thz is @xmath147 k@xmath2 , in good agreement with the experimental value of @xmath148 k@xmath2 in ref . .
the figure also shows that the mode frequency would change less rapidly on heating at high temperatures .
the same trend is seen for the 0.5 thz peak in the experiment in ref . .
distributions of ( a ) the zn
c / n bond length ; ( b ) the cosine of zn
c / n n / c angle distortion ; ( c ) the n / c zn c / n angle within the tetrahedral unit at 0.0 gpa.,width=302 ] in real space , variations of geometrical features of the material , such as the zn c / n bond length , the n / c zn c / n angle within the tetrahedral unit , and the zn
c / n n / c angle are important for us to build a local picture of the system subject to both compression and heating .
distributions of these quantities , as shown in fig .
[ fig12 ] , were obtained from the atomic trajectory data of the md .
the large spread of the distributions suggests large vibrations of these quantities at high temperature .
the slightly expansion - biased broadening of the bond - length distribution on heating indicates an enhanced thermal expansion in the bond .
we found that the deviation of the average n / c zn c / n angle in the tetrahedral unit from its equilibrium of @xmath149 is trivially small ( @xmath150 ) even at very high temperature ( @xmath151 k ) and pressure ( @xmath152 gpa ) .
averaged zn
c / n bond length as a function of temperature , calculated from md at pressures @xmath55 gpa , @xmath60 gpa , @xmath61 gpa and @xmath153 gpa .
the bond length increases with elevated temperature .
the inset shows superlinear behaviour of the bond length on heating.,width=302 ] the average bond length and the average angle distortion in zn(cn)@xmath0 as functions of both temperature and pressure are shown in fig .
[ fig13 ] and [ fig13 - 2 ] , respectively .
compression progressively increases the zn
c / n n / c angle with elevated temperature . at very low and zero temperature ,
the trend is that the angle will be hardly changed by pressure .
this is exactly what expected in the previous section where we suggested that , at zero temperature , the volume change of the material due to the pressure arises solely from the compression of the zn c / n bonds , resulting in positive @xmath82 .
it is when the zn c / n n / c angle starts to increase under compression and contribute to the volume change that the material shows negative @xmath82 , i.e. the pressure - induced softening .
the inset of fig .
[ fig13 ] shows the increase of bond length with temperature .
the superlinear behaviour indicates the softening of the bond at higher temperature due to the thermal expansion . in fig .
[ fig13 - 2 ] , the inset shows the increase of the zn c / n n / c angle with elevated temperature .
the sublinear behaviour suggests that the angle will become more rigid , which should result in a less negative @xmath82 at high temperatures @xcite .
both the superlinearity and the sublinearity in the plots rely on the capture of the anharmonicity of the material .
averaged zn
c / n n / c angle as a function of temperature , calculated from md at pressures @xmath55 gpa , @xmath60 gpa , @xmath61 gpa and @xmath153 gpa .
the angle distortion increases with elevated temperature and pressure .
the inset shows the sublinear behaviour of the angle distortion on heating.,width=287 ] to see the real - space picture of rums in zn(cn)@xmath0 , we quantified the proportion of thermal - excited rigid - unit rotations at different pressures . using our gasp code @xcite
, we compared ten snapshots of an md simulation , where each snapshot is separated by 2 ps , with the ideal structure .
this is repeated for various pressures and temperatures .
gasp , using geometric algebra , can partition the atomic displacements for every comparison made into the mean squared rigid - tetrahedron rotations , translational displacements and unit deformations .
we then computed the average proportion of rigid - unit rotations at each temperature . to exclude those rigid - unit rotations due to pure topology reasons , i.e. rotations that accidentally maintain the shape of the tetrahedral unit under thermal excitation but are not because of the features of motion
, we set up a benchmark calculation using an ideal cristobalite structure without any interactions other than bonds to hold zn
c / n and c n .
the reason to use the single - framework lattice is to avoid the problem of two interpenetrating frameworks crushing into each other in the md due to the lack of long - distance interactions .
[ fig14 ] shows the results at different pressures and temperatures with coloured areas .
the proportion of the rigid - unit rotation of a real silica system is given in the plot as a comparison .
the figure suggests that compression will enhance the rigid - unit rotations . at ambient temperature
@xmath154 k , for example , the average proportions are @xmath155 at @xmath55 gpa , @xmath156 at @xmath60 gpa , @xmath157 at @xmath61 gpa and @xmath158 at @xmath153 gpa , compared to @xmath159 of the benchmark and @xmath160 of the silica system .
another important point is that , at certain pressure , the proportion of rigid - unit rotation will decrease with elevated temperature .
this trend corresponds to the peaks around @xmath133 , @xmath128 and @xmath129 thz in dos stiffened on heating , as shown in fig .
the grneisen parameters of these modes will consequently become less negative , and so does the coefficient of thermal expansion .
plot showing the proportion of rotational rums present in zn(cn)@xmath0 as a function of temperature , calculated using gasp and data from md simulations .
data is presented for four pressures plus two additional benchmark systems .
the green region is the rotational component present in the ideal cristobalite structure ; the yellow region is the additional rotational component present in zn(cn)@xmath0 at 0.0 gpa ; the orange region is the additional component present at 0.2 gpa , the pink region is the additional component at 0.4 gpa ; the red region is the additional component at 0.6 gpa and the dark red region is the additional component present in amorphous silica .
the results clearly show the enhancement of the rotational rums in zn(cn)@xmath0 under pressure , as well as the reduction of the rotational rums on heating.,width=302 ] there is a puzzling observation from the x - ray pair distribution function measurements of zn(cn)@xmath0 @xcite that instantaneous zn@xmath161zn distances contract less rapidly on heating than does the cell length , while crystallographically the two should be linked .
the explanation relies on the nature of the acoustic modes as translational rums .
the acoustic modes around @xmath133 thz are translational rums which count for half of the nte of the material as mentioned in sec .
vii . unlike rotational rums around @xmath128 and @xmath129 thz that will reduce the nearest zn@xmath161zn distance
, the translational rums correspond to collective translations of the neighbouring rigid units that moves zinc atoms off site and retains the distance of the nearest - neighbour zincs , as seen in fig .
[ fig : dispersioncuves](c ) .
this kind of vibration involves the rotation of c
n rod around its centre of mass , consistent with the previous finding in the dos that part of the acoustic modes are from the c
n rod rotations .
we calculated the average distance of the nearest zn@xmath161zn using the the trajectory data from the md simulations .
[ fig15 ] shows the temperature dependence of the average distance under different pressures . at zero pressure ,
the ratio between the linear coefficient of thermal expansion ( cte ) of the averaged zn@xmath161zn distance , @xmath162 , and the overall linear cte of the material , @xmath58 , is 0.67 , with @xmath163mk@xmath2 and @xmath164mk@xmath2 .
this result agrees well with the experimental ratio @xcite of 0.71 , with @xmath165mk@xmath2 and @xmath166mk@xmath2 .
variation of the averaged nearest - neighbour zn@xmath161zn distance , calculated using md .
distances have been calculated for the temperature range of 0500 k and at pressures 0.0 gpa , 0.2 gpa , 0.4 gpa and 0.6 gpa .
the inset shows the cte of the nearest - neighbour zn@xmath161zn distance as a function of pressure.,width=302 ]
this study shows that almost all the modes responsible for the nte of zn(cn)@xmath0 are rums .
we managed to categorize these modes in terms of their vibrational motions .
the ta modes around 0.5 thz spanning to the lowest energy correspond to collective motions of zn cn zn as a rigid body , which can keep the distance of the nearest - neighbour zincs . the low energy hence the most negative grneisen parameters of these modes
are due to this kind of collective motion without involving relatively high - energetic angle bending in the zn cn
zn linkage .
these modes contribute half of the nte of the material .
the optic modes around 2.0 thz and 9.0 thz correspond to rotations of the neighbouring tetrahedral units against each other involving angle bending in the zn cn
zn linkage , resulting in higher mode energy and less negative grneisen parameters .
although the increase of pressure or temperature would both result in volume contraction in zn(cn)@xmath0 , the pressure and temperature dependence of the nte in zn(cn)@xmath0 are totally different .
increasing temperature stiffens the low - frequency peaks and softens the high - frequency peaks in the dos ( fig .
[ fig8 ] and fig .
[ figa2 ] ) accompanied by the reduction of nte , while compression would soften the low - frequency peaks and stiffen the high - frequency peaks ( fig .
[ fig9 ] ) resulting in nte enhancement . raising
temperature slows the mode softening caused by compression , and postpones the phase transition .
the enormous decrease of the bulk modulus on heating contrasts the small change of the bulk modulus on compression , which disobeys birch s law of corresponding states . the pressure and temperature dependence of the zn c / n bond and the n / c zn c / n angle are also intriguing . the large vibrational amplitude of the n / c zn c / n angle extends the zn c / n bond , which can be seen ( under constant pressure ) in fig . [ fig13 ] .
the superlinearity suggests an enhancement of the thermal expansion in the bond with more distorted angle at higher temperature .
the sublinearity of the average angle distortion corresponds to the stiffened rums involving the rotational vibrations of the c n rods .
the ability to carry out md for zn(cn)@xmath0 using the potential model is vital in this study .
it allows us to capture the anharmonicity to reproduce the exotic properties of the material , and to study their pressure and temperature dependence .
the origins of various properties are revealed by linking features in both energy and real space .
one example is the pressure - enhanced nte , which has been well reproduced in fig .
[ fig3](a ) .
this behaviour is a natural result followed by softening of the bulk modulus on heating ( eq . [ eq4 ] ) , and is linked to the feature in energy space that the modes around @xmath133 , @xmath128 and @xmath129 thz are softened under compression ( as in fig .
[ fig9 ] ) , as well as the rising proportion of the rigid - unit rotations in real space on compression ( as in fig .
[ fig14 ] ) .
another example is the reduction of nte with elevated temperature .
stiffening of the modes around @xmath133 , @xmath128 and @xmath129 thz on heating ( as shown in the dos in fig .
[ fig8 ] ) makes their grneisen parameters less negative , hence the reduction of nte in the material . in real space ,
[ fig14 ] clearly shows the trend of reduction in the proportion of rigid - unit rotations on heating .
the third example is the temperature dependence of the bulk modulus and its first derivative @xmath82 .
the large decrease of the bulk modulus on heating is due to the involvement of the zn c / n n / c angular vibrations at non - zero temperature and the softening of the zn c / n bond , which can be seen both in the dos ( fig . [ fig8](a ) ) and in the real - space picture of fig .
[ fig12 ] , [ fig13 ] and [ fig13 - 2 ] . as shown in fig .
[ fig13 - 2 ] , the average zn c /
n n / c angle starts to possess an almost linear pressure dependence at medium temperature and contributes to the pressure - induced volume change of the material .
according to a simple geometrical relation @xcite , the relative decrease in cell is roughly proportional to the zn c / n n / c angle squared , hence to the pressure squared , resulting in negative @xmath82 .
however , this contribution from the pressure - induced change in the zn
c / n n / c angle to the volume contraction will be hindered at high temperature due to the anharmonic stiffening of the corresponding modes ( fig .
[ fig8](a ) and fig .
[ figa2 ] ) . on the other hand ,
the contribution from zn
c / n bond compression will increase due to the thermal softening of the bond . the combined effect of these two trends is expected to result in a less negative @xmath82 at high temperatures @xcite .
we gratefully acknowledge financial support from the cambridge international scholarship scheme ( ciss ) of the cambridge overseas trust and fitzwilliam college of cambridge university ( hf ) , nerc and crystalmaker software ltd .
the md simulations were performed using the camgrid high - throughput environment of the university of cambridge .
the interatomic potential was developed through our membership of the uk hpc materials chemistry consortium , funding by epsrc ( ep / f067496 ) , using the hector national high - performance computing service provided by uoe hpcx ltd at the university of edinburgh , cray inc and nag ltd , and funded by the office of science and technology through epsrc s high end computing programme .
m. s. gordon , m. w. schmidt , _ in `` theory and applications of computational chemistry , the first forty years '' _ , 2005 , chapter 41 , 1167 - 1189 , c. e. dykstra , g. frenking , k. s. kim , g. e. scuseria , elsevier , amsterdam .
a. j. misquitta and a. j. stone , `` cam : a program for studying intermolecular interactions and for the calculation of molecular properties in distributed form '' , 2012 .
http://www-stone.ch.cam.ac.uk/programs.html .
g. g. ferenczy , c. a. reynolds , p. j. winn , and a. j. stone _ mulfit : a program for calculating electrostatic potential - fitted charges _ , 1998 .
may be obtained by contacting a. j. stone , email address : [email protected] . | pressure and temperature dependence of the negative thermal expansion in zn(cn)@xmath0 is fully investigated using molecular dynamics simulations with a built potential model .
the advantage of this study allows us to reproduce the exotic behaviours of the material , including the negative thermal expansion ( nte ) , the reduction of nte with elevated temperature , the pressure enhancement of nte and the pressure - induced softening .
results of the study provide us detailed data to link the properties in the energy space and the real space , giving us insights to understand the properties and the connections between them . |
understanding the string - black hole transition is an important problem in string theory .
the radius of a schwarzschild blackhole becomes smaller with rising temperature and at a certain temperature the blackhole transits to a gas of strings @xcite .
this is a difficult problem to address as it needs a proper understanding of non - perturbative effects in string theory .
the finite temperature of a schwarzschild blackhole breaks supersymmetry and string loop corrections are uncontrolled . in @xcite
it was demonstrated that the problem of the string - blackhole transition can be formulated in a space - time with @xmath7 boundary conditions .
this enabled one to use the ads / cft correspondence @xcite to map the string - blackhole transition phenomenon to a gross - witten - wadia ( gww ) type phase transition @xcite in the boundary gauge theory defined on @xmath8 .
the compactness and positive curvature of the space @xmath2 permits one to integrate out all other modes to get an effective multi - trace unitary matrix model for the zero mode of the polyakov line . based on the works @xcite ,
this type of effective unitary matrix model was analyzed in @xcite to show the existence of the gww type transition .
the @xmath9 part of the gauge theory effective action was also calculated in a double scaled region near the transition temperature .
the @xmath9 part is universally given in terms of @xmath10 , where @xmath11 satisfies the following differential equation @xmath12 and @xmath13 is the painleve ii function , and @xmath14 is a scaled variable proportional to @xmath15 .
the derivation of the effective unitary matrix model from the gauge theory is a subtle one . in a weakly coupled gauge theory
one may demonstrate this explicitly in perturbation theory at large @xmath0 @xcite .
however the situation is less clear in the strong coupling regime .
one difficulty comes from the gregory - laflamme transition for a small @xmath7 blackhole .
this transition breaks the @xmath4 symmetry of @xmath16 and the question arises whether there is a new zero mode associated with this transition , and whether the unitary matrix model is a good description after this transition . in @xcite it has been shown , using a supergravity analysis within the ads / cft correspondence , that even at strong coupling , the unitary matrix model serves as an effective description .
given the physical relevance of the gww transition , it is important to see if this phenomenon occurs when one is not dealing with the dynamics ( however complicated ) of a single unitary matrix or the quantum mechanics of a single unitary matrix .
it is not at all obvious that this large-@xmath0 transition occurs in more complicated models of non - commuting matrices and gauge theories . in the past
this question has been explored by douglas and kazakov@xcite in their study of two - dimensional yang - mills theory on @xmath17 .
however this problem too , gets recast into a problem of a single unitary matrix because the partition function turns out to be the heat kernel on the unitary group . in order to answer these questions
, there seems to be no analytic tools as is usually the case with complicated dynamical problems .
hence we use numerical monte carlo methods to explore and exhibit the large-@xmath0 gww transition and also study the question of r - symmetry breaking at large @xmath0 . since the full @xmath1 sym theory on @xmath8 is too difficult , in the first run we study the gauge theory restricted to the zero modes of the bosonic sector .
it is likely that this reduction captures the essential features of the dynamics .
it is motivated by the fact that the metric of the small schwarzschild black hole is uniform on @xmath2 .
regarding fluctuations in the bulk , the zero mode gauge theory has correspondence with fluctuations in the bulk which are independent of @xmath2 and only depend on the radial @xmath18 coordinate and time .
the importance of exhibiting this transition lies in the fact that in the vicinity of the critical temperature @xmath3 , the system goes critical and the fluctuations give rise to universal formulas ( [ painleve ] ) which solely depend on the multi - critical point which is characterized by the exponent @xmath19 in the scaling law @xmath20 .
hence the formulas for the black hole cross over which were derived using the effective unitary matrix model in @xcite are also valid while working directly with the zero mode sector of the gauge theory .
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
, we introduce the zero mode action of the bosonic part of the @xmath1 sym theory on @xmath8 . in section 3
, we discuss the numerical studies of the gww - type phase transition . in section 4 , we study the @xmath4 r - symmetry using monte carlo simulation .
section 5 is devoted to conclusions and future outlook .
we study the @xmath1 sym theory , when all the bosonic fields are restricted to their zero modes on @xmath2 .
@xmath21^{2 } + m^{2 } \sum_{\mu=1}^{d } { { \rm tr\,}}m^{2}_{\mu } ( t ) \right ) , \nonumber \\ \label{action}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath22 is a covariant derivative defined by @xmath23 .
\label{covariant}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath24 is the dimensionality of the model , and the dynamical variables @xmath25 and @xmath26 ( @xmath27 ) are @xmath28 hermitian matrices , which can be regarded as the gauge field and the @xmath29 adjoint scalars , respectively .
this model has a @xmath30 gauge symmetry @xmath31 the euclidean time @xmath14 in the action ( [ action ] ) has a finite extent @xmath32 , which is the inverse temperature @xmath33 .
both the gauge and the scalar fields obey the periodic boundary conditions @xmath34 while this model has three parameters , @xmath32 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 , these are not independent of each other , as @xmath36 can always be set to unity by the following redefinitions @xmath37 and rescaling of the fields @xmath38 the periodic boundary condition ( [ periodic_bc ] ) prevents us from fixing the @xmath39 gauge .
however we can fix a gauge where the gauge field is static and diagonal : @xmath40 where @xmath41 $ ] . the indices @xmath42 run over @xmath43 .
this gives rise to the fadeev - popov term @xmath44 whose derivation is given in full detail in @xcite . in the following , we study the action @xmath45 we study the model ( [ action_gf ] ) numerically by monte carlo simulation .
the details of the algorithm are given in @xcite .
we simulate the model with the time direction discretized .
we apply the heat bath algorithm to the scalar fields and metropolis algorithm to the gauge field , respectively .
it turns out that taking 10 lattice points of the time direction is enough and that increasing the lattice points further does not affect the result .
in this section , we study the gww type phase transition of the simplest unitary matrix model , for which an analytical solution is available @xcite .
this model is useful to test the accuracy of the numerical method .
we start with the numerical simulation of the unitary matrix model consisting only of @xmath47 without adjoint scalar fields , where @xmath48 @xmath49 denotes the path - ordered product .
we consider the partition function @xmath50 and define @xmath51 for an integer @xmath52 . in the static and diagonal gauge ( [ gauge_fixing ] ) ,
@xmath53 these are the moments of the density of eigenvalues : @xmath54 .
the first two moments are given by @xmath55 the third - order transition at the point @xmath56 is the gww transition .
this is a transition between the gapped and ungapped phases of the eigenvalue distribution of the unitary matrix model . for a generic unitary matrix model , all @xmath57 s show a similar non - analytical behavior like @xmath58 , because near the gap opening point , the relevant operator is given by a linear combination of @xmath57@xcite .
we first verify this result numerically using monte carlo simulation . to this end , we take static and diagonal gauge ( [ gauge_fixing ] ) and add the fadeev - popov term ( [ fp_ghost ] ) .
namely , we apply the metropolis algorithm to the action @xmath59 we plot the vev s @xmath60 against @xmath61 in figure [ gw-0502227 ] for @xmath62 , and find that they actually agree with the result ( [ tru_analytic ] ) .
we next study the saddle point of the gauge field by adding the chemical potential @xmath63 to the action ( [ action_gf ] ) .
namely , we study the matrix model @xmath64 where the terms @xmath65 and @xmath66 are defined in ( [ action ] ) and ( [ fp_ghost ] ) , respectively , and @xmath67 is the polyakov line defined in @xmath68 .
we first study the @xmath69 case , in which the numerical simulation of large @xmath0 is reachable at a reasonable cpu time .
the phase transition of the one - dimensional matrix quantum mechanics with respect to the temperature has been studied in @xcite in the absence of the chemical potential .
the polyakov line @xmath70 is small in the low - temperature region , while it is large in the high - temperature region .
we focus on the low - temperature region @xmath71 , in which the polyakov line @xmath70 is small for @xmath72 .
we plot the result of the @xmath69 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 case in figure [ d2-case ] .
the graph above indicates a signature of the phase transition ( possibly third or higher order ) near the critical point @xmath75 at which the polyakov line is @xmath76 .
this is expected from the fact that @xmath77 near the transition point . to understand the nature of the transition we first numerically plot the derivative @xmath78 in figure [ d2-case ] ( left ) .
the derivative seems to be continuous , and hence the possible transition should at least be of third order .
numerical errors prevent us from going further and calculating the higher derivatives directly from our data .
instead , in figure [ d2-case ] ( right ) we try to fit our data with analytic functions in the regime @xmath79 and @xmath80 and extrapolate the information about derivatives from the fitted functions .
it should be noted that the fitted functions do not necessarily represent the correct analytic form of the exact answer , but they can be viewed as a close approximation .
we fit the vev @xmath70 with the function @xmath81 we exploit the fact that in the large-@xmath0 limit , @xmath82 is 0 at @xmath83 and @xmath84 as @xmath85 . and
from the fact that @xmath86 and its first derivative @xmath87 are continuous at the critical point @xmath88 , we obtain the condition for @xmath89 and @xmath90 .
@xmath91 the parameters @xmath92 are fitted as @xmath93 in this case , the coefficients @xmath94 are @xmath95 and @xmath96 , respectively .
we find that the contribution of the terms @xmath97 for @xmath98 and @xmath99 for @xmath80 is small compared to the rest of the terms in ( [ u1_fit ] ) .
since its second derivative @xmath100 is discontinuous at the critical point @xmath101 , this system undergoes the gww type third - order phase transition .
the vev @xmath102 is small when @xmath98 , and in this region @xmath102 is closer to zero at larger @xmath0 . when @xmath80 , it is fitted with the following function similarly to the unitary matrix model .
@xmath103 next , we turn our attention to the high - temperature case @xmath104 , in which the vev s of the polyakov line @xmath105 are large even in the absence of the chemical potential .
we plot @xmath106 against @xmath107 for @xmath69 , @xmath108 , @xmath109 case for @xmath74 in figure [ d2-high ] .
in contrast to the low - temperature case , we find that there is no gww type third - order phase transition in this case and that the vev s of the polyakov line increase monotonically .
we next study a different dimensionality , @xmath110 .
similarly , we plot the vev s @xmath60 against @xmath107 in the @xmath110 , @xmath111 , @xmath73 case for @xmath112 in figure [ d6-case ] .
we read off the critical point as @xmath113 then , we fit them with the functions ( [ u1_fit ] ) and ( [ u2_fit ] ) . in this case , the parameters are @xmath114 the coefficients @xmath94 are @xmath115 and @xmath116 , which suggests that the contribution of the @xmath94 terms is smaller than that of the rest of the terms in ( [ u1_fit ] ) .
we find that the result is similar to the @xmath69 case .
in this section , we study the spontaneous breaking of the @xmath4 r - symmetry of the model ( [ action_gf ] ) by monte carlo simulation . throughout this section ,
we focus on the @xmath110 dimensional case . in analogy with the ikkt - type matrix model @xcite
, we consider the following observable @xcite , @xmath117 in our case , we integrate the operator @xmath118 with respect to the time direction and obtain the `` integrated moment of inertia tensor '' @xmath119 we define the eigenvalues of this @xmath120 matrix @xmath121 , which are all real positive , as @xmath122 with the specific order @xmath123 we consider the following @xmath4 invariant quantity @xcite , @xmath124 this quantity measures the variance of the eigenvalue distribution of @xmath121 . using large-@xmath0 factorization we get @xmath125 using the fact that the vev of any @xmath4 two - tensor is proportional to @xmath126 , i.e. @xmath127 , we get @xmath128 . this relationship is not true in general and we expect @xmath129 at finite @xmath0 . in the case when @xmath130 is non - zero , the width of the eigenvalue distribution of @xmath121 is non - zero .
the above scenario implies that the dominant contribution of the path integral comes from the configurations for which the eigenvalues of @xmath131 are not equal and consequently the @xmath4 symmetry is broken .
hence by plotting the vev s of the eigenvalues of @xmath131 and measuring the width of the distribution , we can figure out the possibility of @xmath4 symmetry breaking at large @xmath0 .
this leads us to evaluate the vev s of these eigenvalues @xmath132 in the large-@xmath0 limit .
after diagonalization , the residual @xmath4 transformations permute the eigenvalues @xmath122 . hence an unbroken @xmath4 symmetry implies , @xmath133 whereas a broken @xmath4 symmetry implies that for some @xmath134 . to this end , we extrapolate the large-@xmath0 limit from the simulation of finite @xmath0 .
if the eigenvalues @xmath132 are all equal in the large-@xmath0 limit , this suggests that the @xmath4 symmetry is unbroken .
we first study the @xmath4 r - symmetry breaking when gauge field @xmath135 is integrated . to this end
, we update the gauge field @xmath135 , as well as the scalar fields @xmath26 via the usual algorithm .
we extrapolate the large-@xmath0 limit from the finite-@xmath0 results of @xmath136 for the high - temperature @xmath137 and the middle - temperature @xmath138 cases .
we plot the eigenvalues @xmath132 against @xmath139 in figure [ teig1-vacuum ] .
it turns out that the eigenvalues @xmath132 converge to the same value in the large-@xmath0 limit .
this behavior is qualitatively the same for other parameter regions of the action ( [ action_gf ] ) .
this indicates that the @xmath4 r - symmetry is unbroken in the matrix model ( [ action_gf ] ) .
we next study the @xmath4 r - symmetry breaking in the specific configurations of the gauge field , which correspond to @xmath7 and a black hole . to this end
, we put the constraints on the gauge fields . in the following , we focus on the high - temperature @xmath140 and massive @xmath141 case , and
take @xmath142 . [
[ uniform - distribution ] ] 1 .
uniform distribution + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we take the diagonal part of the gauge field ( [ gauge_fixing ] ) as @xmath143 in this case , the polyakov line @xmath67 satisfies @xmath144 for any nonzero integer @xmath52 . in the ads
/ cft correspondence uniform distribution , which is depicted in figure [ gauge - distribution ] ( 1 ) , corresponds to the @xmath145 spacetime @xcite . to realize this configuration , we skip the metropolis algorithm to update the gauge field @xmath135 and fix the configuration of the gauge field to be ( [ gauge - uni ] ) .
we update only the scalar fields @xmath146 via heat bath algorithm .
[ [ clumped - distribution ] ] 2 .
clumped distribution + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in the clumped distribution , we constrain the gauge fields in a small region @xmath147 $ ] , which is opposite to the gapped distribution .
this distribution is depicted in figure [ gauge - distribution ] ( 2 ) .
similarly to the gapped distribution , we take @xmath148 .
if @xmath149 goes out of the region @xmath150 $ ] , we automatically reject that configuration .
this configuration coming from a gapped distribution of eigenvalues corresponds to the blackhole state as can be indicated by an analysis of large-@xmath0 perturbation theory around the gapped phase @xcite .
similar to the case when we updated the configuration of the gauge field , we make a large-@xmath0 extrapolation of the eigenvalues @xmath132 .
we plot in figure [ teig1-specific ] the eigenvalues @xmath132 against @xmath139 for the high - temperature @xmath140 and @xmath73 case . in these cases , too , the eigenvalues @xmath132 converge to the same value at large @xmath0 .
we find that the @xmath4 r - symmetry of the scalar field is unbroken for these configurations of the gauge field .
in this paper , we have exhibited the gww large-@xmath0 phase transition using monte carlo simulation in the zero mode reduction of the bosonic part of the @xmath1 sym theory on the @xmath8 space .
we have studied the saddle point by adding a chemical potential to the reduced action , and observed a third - order phase transition in the large-@xmath0 limit .
its significance is that the large-@xmath0 transition signals critical behavior and the the properties of the model in the vicinity of the critical point are universal .
hence we expect that the @xmath9 free energy is given by ( [ painleve ] ) .
we have also numerically found that the @xmath4 r - symmetry is not spontaneously broken , in the large-@xmath0 limit . in the @xmath151 and @xmath152 unitary matrix models the physical mechanism for the gww transition
is well understood . in the @xmath151 models
the repulsion between eigenvalues , from the measure , and their attraction in the potential well , are competing effects which lead to this transition @xcite .
limit , in terms of the saddle point in the space of the young tableaux density .
this density and the eigenvalue density provide a very interesting phase space picture of the large-@xmath0 transition . ] in the @xmath152 models the phase transition is signaled when the fermi level reaches the hump ( maximum ) of the potential @xcite . in
the more complicated models we have explored , there are typically non - commuting matrices and explanation seems to be less obvious . in the future
it would be instructive to go beyond the zero mode approximation and develop numerical methods to include the variation of the fields on @xmath2 .
also , it would be interesting to be able to include the adjoint fermions of the gauge theory in the numerical calculation .
+ the authors would like to thank rajesh gopakumar , shiraz minwalla , shingo takeuchi and toby wiseman for valuable discussions .
thanks sourendu gupta for help in the use of the computer system .
part of the simulations were performed on the computer cluster of the physics theory group of the national technical university of athens .
srw would like to thank the j. c. bose fellowship of the govt . of india .
l. alvarez - gaume , p. basu , m. marino and s. r. wadia , `` blackhole / string transition for the small schwarzschild blackhole of @xmath153 and critical unitary matrix models , '' eur . phys .
j. c * 48 * , 647 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0605041 ] .
l. susskind , `` some speculations about blackhole entropy in string theory , '' hep - th/9309145 .
g. t. horowitz and j. polchinski , `` a correspondence principle for blackholes and strings , '' phys .
d * 55 * , 6189 ( 1997 ) [ hep - th/9612146 ] .
a. sen , `` extremal blackholes and elementary string states , '' mod .
lett . a * 10 * , 2081 ( 1995 ) [ hep - th/9504147 ] .
m. j. bowick , l. smolin and l. c. r. wijewardhana , `` does string theory solve the puzzles of blackhole evaporation ?
, '' gen .
* 19 * , 113 ( 1987 ) .
m. j. bowick , l. smolin and l. c. r. wijewardhana , `` role of string excitations in the last stages of blackhole evaporation , '' phys .
lett . * 56 * , 424 ( 1986 ) . j. m. maldacena , `` the large n limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity , '' adv .
* 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) [ int .
j. theor .
phys . * 38 * , 1113 ( 1999 ) ] [ hep - th/9711200 ] .
d. j. gross and e. witten , `` possible third order phase transition in the large n lattice gauge theory , '' phys .
d * 21 * , 446 ( 1980 ) .
s. wadia , `` a study of u(n ) lattice gauge theory in two - dimensions , '' efi-79/44-chicago s. r. wadia , `` n = infinity phase transition in a class of exactly soluble model lattice gauge theories , '' phys .
b * 93 * , 403 ( 1980 ) .
l. alvarez - gaume , c. gomez , h. liu and s. wadia , `` finite temperature effective action , ads(5 ) blackholes , and 1/n expansion , '' phys .
d * 71 * , 124023 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0502227 ] .
p. basu and s. r. wadia , `` r - charged ads(5 ) black holes and large n unitary matrix models , '' phys .
d * 73 * , 045022 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0506203 ] .
b. sundborg , `` the hagedorn transition , deconfinement and n = 4 sym theory , '' nucl .
b * 573 * , 349 ( 2000 ) [ hep - th/9908001 ] .
a. m. polyakov , `` gauge fields and space - time , '' int .
j. mod .
a * 17s1 * , 119 ( 2002 ) [ hep - th/0110196 ] .
o. aharony , j. marsano , s. minwalla , k. papadodimas and m. van raamsdonk , `` the hagedorn / deconfinement phase transition in weakly coupled large n gauge theories , '' adv .
* 8 * , 603 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0310285 ] .
h. liu , `` fine structure of hagedorn transitions , '' hep - th/0408001 .
j. hallin and d. persson , `` thermal phase transition in weakly interacting , large n(c ) qcd , '' phys .
b * 429 * , 232 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9803234 ] .
o. aharony , j. marsano , s. minwalla , k. papadodimas and m. van raamsdonk , `` a first order deconfinement transition in large n yang - mills theory on a small @xmath2 , '' phys .
d * 71 * , 125018 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0502149 ] .
m. r. douglas and v. a. kazakov , phys .
b * 319 * , 219 ( 1993 ) [ hep - th/9305047 ] .
k. furuuchi , e. schreiber and g. w. semenoff , `` five - brane thermodynamics from the matrix model , '' hep - th/0310286 .
n. kawahara , j. nishimura and k. yoshida , `` dynamical aspects of the plane - wave matrix model at finite temperature , '' jhep * 0606 * , 052 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0601170 ] .
n. kawahara , j. nishimura and s. takeuchi , `` phase structure of matrix quantum mechanics at finite temperature , '' jhep * 0710 * , 097 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0706.3517 [ hep - th ] ] .
m. hanada , j. nishimura and s. takeuchi , `` non - lattice simulation for supersymmetric gauge theories in one dimension , '' phys .
lett . * 99 * , 161602 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0706.1647 [ hep - lat ] ] .
k. n. anagnostopoulos , m. hanada , j. nishimura and s. takeuchi , `` monte carlo studies of supersymmetric matrix quantum mechanics with sixteen supercharges at finite temperature , '' arxiv:0707.4454 [ hep - th ] .
n. kawahara , j. nishimura and s. takeuchi , `` exact fuzzy sphere thermodynamics in matrix quantum mechanics , '' jhep * 0705 * , 091 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0704.3183 [ hep - th ] ] .
o. aharony , j. marsano , s. minwalla and t. wiseman , `` black hole - black string phase transitions in thermal 1 + 1 dimensional supersymmetric yang - mills theory on a circle , '' class .
grav . * 21 * , 5169 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0406210 ] .
o. aharony , j. marsano , s. minwalla , k. papadodimas , m. van raamsdonk and t. wiseman , `` the phase structure of low dimensional large n gauge theories on tori , '' jhep * 0601 * , 140 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0508077 ] . n. ishibashi , h. kawai , y. kitazawa and a. tsuchiya , `` a large - n reduced model as superstring , '' nucl .
b * 498 * , 467 ( 1997 ) [ hep - th/9612115 ] .
t. hotta , j. nishimura and a. tsuchiya , `` dynamical aspects of large n reduced models , '' nucl .
b * 545 * , 543 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9811220 ] .
j. ambjorn , k. n. anagnostopoulos , w. bietenholz , t. hotta and j. nishimura , `` large n dynamics of dimensionally reduced 4d su(n ) super yang - mills theory , '' jhep * 0007 * , 013 ( 2000 ) [ hep - th/0003208 ] .
j. ambjorn , k. n. anagnostopoulos , w. bietenholz , t. hotta and j. nishimura , `` monte carlo studies of the iib matrix model at large
n , '' jhep * 0007 * , 011 ( 2000 ) [ hep - th/0005147 ] .
j. ambjorn , k. n. anagnostopoulos , w. bietenholz , f. hofheinz and j. nishimura , `` on the spontaneous breakdown of lorentz symmetry in matrix models of superstrings , '' phys .
d * 65 * , 086001 ( 2002 ) [ hep - th/0104260 ] .
k. n. anagnostopoulos and j. nishimura , `` new approach to the complex - action problem and its application to a nonperturbative study of superstring theory , '' phys .
d * 66 * , 106008 ( 2002 ) [ hep - th/0108041 ] .
j. nishimura , `` exactly solvable matrix models for the dynamical generation of space - time in superstring theory , '' phys .
d * 65 * , 105012 ( 2002 ) [ hep - th/0108070 ] .
j. nishimura , t. okubo and f. sugino , `` gaussian expansion analysis of a matrix model with the spontaneous breakdown of rotational symmetry , '' prog .
* 114 * , 487 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0412194 ] .
e. witten , `` anti - de sitter space , thermal phase transition , and confinement in gauge theories , '' adv .
theor . math .
* 2 * , 505 ( 1998 ) [ hep - th/9803131 ] .
s. dutta and r. gopakumar , `` free fermions and thermal ads / cft , '' arxiv:0711.0133 [ hep - th ] . | in the study of the small ten - dimensional schwarzschild blackhole , the blackhole to string transition is an important problem . in @xcite
, a possible identification is made between the gross - witten - wadia ( gww ) type third - order large-@xmath0 phase transition in the boundary gauge theory and the string - black hole transition in the bulk . in this paper
, we exhibit the existence of the gww transition by monte carlo simulation in the zero mode bosonic action of the finite - temperature @xmath1 sym theory on @xmath2 . exhibiting
this transition in the truncated but highly non - trivial gauge theory implies that in the vicinity of the critical temperature @xmath3 , the system goes critical , and the fluctuations give rise to universal formulas derived in @xcite .
we also discuss the issue of @xmath4 r - symmetry breaking .
@xmath5 [ cols= " < " , ] + + + monte carlo studies of the gww phase transition + in large-@xmath0 gauge theories takehiro azuma , pallab basu@xmath6 and spenta r. wadia address after dec . 1 , 2007 : university of british columbia , vancouver , canada . ] |
our model consists of two ni - ligand clusters , roughly equivalent to two nio@xmath4 octahedra , each containing a ni @xmath0 shell , a ni @xmath1 shell , and a ligand shell .
the ligand shell orbitals are defined as linear combinations of the actual oxygen @xmath0 like wannier - orbitals having the same rotation properties as the ni @xmath43 orbitals within the @xmath15 point group used here @xcite .
the general form of our hamiltonian is : @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 refer to the short and long bond sites , respectively ( or identical sites when no breathing distortion is present ) and @xmath55 is the part of the hamiltonian that couples the two clusters together . taken separately , @xmath56 and @xmath57 are independent multiplet ligand field theory hamiltonians . for @xmath56 , we have : @xmath58 with , + [ cols= " < , < " , ] the hamiltonian for site @xmath54 is analogous to @xmath56 .
below we list each term in the hamiltonian in more detail .
[ [ section ] ] the onsite energy of the ni @xmath0 core electrons is given as : @xmath59 with @xmath60 labeling the 6 different ni @xmath0 spin - orbitals with @xmath61 and @xmath62 , @xmath63 ( @xmath64 ) the operator creating ( annihilating ) an electron in orbital @xmath60 and @xmath65 defined in terms of @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 as @xcite : @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the formal number of @xmath1 electrons per ni ( @xmath71 for the nickelates studied here ) .
[ [ section-1 ] ] the onsite energy of the ni @xmath1 valence electrons is given as : @xmath72 with @xmath60 labeling the 10 different ni @xmath1 spin - orbitals belonging either to the @xmath18 irreducible representation ( @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 ) or to the @xmath17 irreducible representation ( @xmath76 , and @xmath77 ) with either spin up or spin down , @xmath78 ( @xmath79 ) the operator creating ( annihilating ) an electron in orbital @xmath60 , @xmath80 the shell average energy defined in terms of @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 as @xcite : @xmath81 and @xmath82 the onsite part of the cubic crystal - field splitting .
the value of @xmath82 depends on the the breathing distortion , being larger for the smaller site . in terms of the non - breathing value @xmath83 , the breathing distortion is approximated by harrison s rules for hybridization @xcite as @xmath84 where , @xmath27 is the average bond length and @xmath24 is the positive ( negative ) displacement from average for the long ( short ) bond octahedron @xmath54 ( @xmath53 ) .
[ [ section-2 ] ] the ligand orbitals are linear combinations of the valence states of the infinite solid such that the local ni @xmath43 orbitals directly interact only with these orbitals @xcite . for each ni spin - orbital
there is exactly one ligand orbital , independent of crystal symmetry and breathing distortion .
the ligand orbitals can have a different onsite energy depending if they belong to the local @xmath18 or @xmath17 irreducible representation .
the hamiltonian thus takes a very similar form as @xmath85 namely : @xmath86 with @xmath60 labeling the 10 different ligand spin - orbitals belonging either to the @xmath18 irreducible representation ( @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 ) or to the @xmath17 irreducible representation ( @xmath76 , and @xmath77 ) with either spin up or spin down , @xmath87 ( @xmath88 ) the operator creating ( annihilating ) an electron in orbital @xmath60 , @xmath89 the shell average energy defined in terms of @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 as @xcite : @xmath90 and @xmath91 roughly the hopping strength between two ligand o @xmath0 orbitals @xcite .
the value of @xmath91 depends on the breathing distortion and can be expressed in terms of @xmath92 , the positive ( negative ) displacement from average for the long ( short ) bond octahedron @xmath54 ( @xmath53 ) and the non - breathing value @xmath93 , using rules defined by harrison @xcite as @xmath94 [ [ section-3 ] ] the interaction between the ni @xmath1 orbitals and the ligand orbitals is given as : @xmath95 with @xmath60 labeling the 10 different ni @xmath1 or ligand spin - orbitals belonging either to the @xmath18 irreducible representation ( @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 ) or to the @xmath17 irreducible representation ( @xmath76 , and @xmath77 ) with either spin up or spin down , @xmath78 , @xmath87 ( @xmath79 , @xmath88 ) the operator creating ( annihilating ) an electron in orbital @xmath60 and either the @xmath43 or ligand shell .
@xmath96 and @xmath97 are the individual hopping strengths between the @xmath43 and ligand orbitals .
the parameter @xmath98 determines the ratio between the hopping within a single ligand field cluster and between two ligand - field clusters .
[ [ section-4 ] ] the interaction between cluster @xmath53 and cluster @xmath54 is given as : @xmath99 with the individual terms defined as in the previous section .
the definition of the hybridization interaction using the parameter @xmath98 is such that the overall hopping strength is independent of the coupling between the two clusters . for perfect periodic boundary conditions @xmath100 . in this case one can create bonding and anti - bonding linear combinations of the ligand orbitals of cluster @xmath53 and cluster @xmath54 and
the anti - bonding linear combination will be non - bonding with respect to the ni @xmath1 orbitals .
although this senario on first sight looks like a good cluster model , it highly overestimates the ni - ni exchange interactions . for nearest neighbor clusters only one out of six oxygens
is shared and one might expect @xmath101 to yield reasonable results , assuming 180 degree ni - o - ni bonds .
we used @xmath98 as an empirical parameter , as one can not claim convergence with respect to cluster size for a two site calculation . due to the presence of non - local excitations ,
the xas spectrum is quite sensitive to @xmath98 and we find best agreement with experiment using @xmath102 , which is quite close to the expected value of @xmath103 .
the fact that we find a value slightly smaller than @xmath103 is likely due in part to the octahedral tilts in the real materials , which decrease the ni - o - ni bond angle from 180 degrees and reduce the effective ni - ni hopping .
[ [ section-5 ] ] the onsite coulomb repulsion between two @xmath43 electrons is defined as : @xmath104 with , @xmath105 c^{\left(k\right)}\left[l_4=2,m_4;l_2=2,m_2\right ] \times f^{\left(k\right)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath60 are combined spin and orbital indices , @xmath106 are spin indices , @xmath107 and @xmath108 are angular momentum indices ( @xmath109 for @xmath43 electrons ) , @xmath110 are the radial ( slater ) integrals , and @xmath111 = \bra{y_{m_1}^{\left(l_1\right ) } } c^{\left(k\right)}_{m_1-m_2 } \ket{y_{m_2}^{\left(l_2\right)}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] are angular integrals of spherical harmonics @xmath112 and renormalized spherical harmonics @xmath113 . the slater integrals @xmath114 and @xmath115 are related to the multipole interaction between two @xmath43 electrons and responsible for the multiplet splitting between the different levels .
they can be approximated by @xmath116 albeit at the loss of the experimentally observed multiplet structure .
@xmath117 is the spherical averaged coulomb interaction , i.e. the monopole part of the interaction .
@xmath117 is related to @xmath118 by : @xmath119 [ [ section-6 ] ] the onsite interaction between the ni @xmath0 and ni @xmath1 electrons is given as : @xmath120 with @xmath121 c^{\left(k\right)}\left[l_4=1,m_4;l_2=1,m_2\right ] \times f^{\left(k\right)}_{pd},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath122 c^{\left(k\right)}\left[l_4=2,m_4;l_2=1,m_2\right ] \times g^{\left(k\right)}_{pd}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the monopole part of the @xmath123-@xmath43 interaction ( @xmath124 ) is related to @xmath125 by : @xmath126 [ [ section-7 ] ] the spin - orbit coupling interaction within either the @xmath0 or @xmath1 shell of ni is given as : @xmath127 where here @xmath108 is the orbital index , @xmath107 the angular momentum , i.e. either @xmath123 or @xmath43 , @xmath106 is the spin index , and @xmath128 the coupling constant .
the operator @xmath129 corresponds to @xmath130 or @xmath131 for the valence @xmath1 or core @xmath123 shells respectively .
both the inter- and intra - cluster hybridization interactions are affected by the breathing distortion . this dependence is contained in the hopping integrals @xmath96 and @xmath97 of equations [ eqn : hhyb ] and [ eqn : hmix ] . in terms of the non - breathing values @xmath132 and @xmath133 , the hybridization parameters are defined using harrison s rules @xcite , as @xmath134 where @xmath24 is the bond length displacement as defined above .
the values used for @xmath132 and @xmath133 are provided in the section below .
parameter values enter into our model in the form of coulomb interactions , on - site energies , spin orbit interactions , and hopping integrals .
the values for these parameters have been quite well established over several decades of core level spectroscopy and other techniques , and here we do not deviate in any way from standard values ( discussions of typical values can be found in references , among many others ) . for the monopole coulomb interaction parameters we use @xmath135 ev and @xmath136 ev . for the charge transfer energy we use @xmath137 ev ( see the following paragraph for a discussion of the exact definition of @xmath68 ) . for the non - breathing - distorted values of on - site energies we use @xmath138 ev and @xmath139 ev . for non - breathing - distorted intra - cluster hopping integrals we use @xmath140 ev and @xmath141 ev . for inter - cluster hopping , we find best agreement with experiment using @xmath142 .
spin orbit interaction parameters are taken as the atomic values for ni @xmath7 , @xmath143 ev and @xmath144 mev .
finally , the multipole coulomb interaction parameters are taken as 80% of their atomic hartree - fock values for ni
@xmath7 @xcite : @xmath145 , @xmath146 , @xmath147 , @xmath148 , and @xmath149 , all expressed in units of electron volts . there
exist several different ways to define the charge transfer energy @xmath68 .
as detailed in the preceding sections , in our model @xmath68 contributes to the shell average energies @xmath80 , @xmath89 , and @xmath65 .
thus , our value of @xmath137 ev sets the energy of the @xmath150 configuration 0.5 ev lower than the @xmath151 configuration _ before _ the inclusion of multiplet , spin - orbit , crystal field , and ligand - ligand hopping terms .
these terms all modify the energy separation between the lowest @xmath151 and @xmath150 states , thus affecting the effective charge transfer energy .
for example , the ligand - ligand hopping shifts the ligand @xmath17 orbitals up by @xmath93 and shifts the ligand @xmath18 orbitals down by @xmath93 , which ends up shifting the @xmath150 configuration lower by @xmath93 with respect to the @xmath151 configuration , thus decreasing the effective delta further .
once all of the on - site energy effects are considered , we find that the lowest @xmath150 eigenstate is 0.6 ev lower than the lowest @xmath151 eigenstate ( before the inclusion of hybridization ) , thus giving an effective charge transfer energy of @xmath152 ev .
after finding the ground state wavefunction of our model , we simulate the core xas and mcd spectra using a lanczos - based green s function method @xcite . for xas
we calculate the isotropic signal via the sum of spectra using @xmath153 , left circular , and right circular polarized dipole transition operators .
the mcd response ( i.e. the fundamental mcd spectrum , or @xmath154 component of the atomic scattering tensor ) is the difference between left and right circular polarized spectral functions
. the resonant magnetic diffraction signal of the nickelates has been intensively studied of late , with experiments probing the collinearity of moments via the azimuthal dependence of the diffraction signal @xcite . for this work
we are interested in the energy dependence of the rmd signal , so for simplicity we assume a collinear arrangement of spins with a structure factor of @xmath155 = 1\cdot f^{\left(1\right)}_{a1 } + i\cdot f^{\left(1\right)}_{b1 } - 1\cdot f^{\left(1\right)}_{a2 } - i\cdot f^{\left(1\right)}_{b2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath154 denote the complex valued , energy dependent , magnetic circular dichroic form factors and @xmath156 and @xmath157 refer to short bond sites in different antiferromagnetic planes ( similar for long bond sites @xmath54 ) .
given an antiferromagnetic alignment of @xmath156 and @xmath157 and thus a negation of the form factor ( @xmath158 , and similar for @xmath54 ) , our structure factor simplifies to @xmath155 = 2 \left ( f^{\left(1\right)}_{a } + i\cdot f^{\left(1\right)}_{b } \right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] and , neglecting polarization effects for simplicity , the spectral intensity is therefore @xmath159 where we have restored the dependence on energy , @xmath160 .
note that this expression does assume a particular domain structure , as @xmath161 in our model , i.e. the ordering in eqn .
[ eqn : rmd ] is ( @xmath162~\spinup[10pt]~\spindn[6pt]~\spindn[10pt]~$ ] ) .
one can assume the alternate ordering ( @xmath163~\spinup[6pt]~\spindn[10pt]~\spindn[6pt]~$ ] ) with @xmath164 and @xmath165 switched in eqn .
[ eqn : rmd ] and obtain a slightly different energy dependence of the magnetic scattering .
the spectra of both arrangements are shown along with the xas for @xmath166 in fig .
[ fig : srmd ] below .
while both spectra are qualitatively similar , having the magnetic scattering intensity strongest at the energy of the first xas peak and a small shoulder at higher energy , there are differences in overall intensity and in the fine details of the peaks . in the manuscript , we plot the average of these two responses . for the two different spin arrangements shown .
, width=384 ]
10ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.85.165113 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.55.418 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.33.8060 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.28.4363 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.66.763 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/108/57004 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.106804 [ * * , ( ) ] | we present a theory describing the local electronic properties of the perovskite rare earth nickelates materials which have negative charge transfer energies , strong o @xmath0
ni @xmath1 covalence , and breathing mode lattice distortions at the origin of highly studied metal - insulator and antiferromagnetic ordering transitions . utilizing a full orbital , full correlation double cluster approach , we find strong charge fluctuations in agreement with a bond disproportionation interpretation .
the unique double cluster formulation permits the inclusion of necessary orbital degeneracies and coulomb interactions to calculate resonant x - ray spectral responses , with which we find excellent agreement with well - established experimental results .
this previously absent , crucial link between theory and experiment provides validation of the recently proposed bond disproportionation theory , and provides an analysis methodology for spectroscopic studies of engineered phases of nickelates and other high valence transition metal compounds .
the perovskite rare - earth nickelate compounds ( @xmath2nio@xmath3 ) possess a rich phase diagram , exhibiting metal - insulator and antiferromagnetic ordering transitions with temperatures tunable via the rare earth ionic size @xcite .
the transition into the low temperature insulating phase is concomitant with a structural change where alternating nio@xmath4 octahedra are expanded and compressed in a rocksalt - pattern breathing mode distortion ( see fig . [ fig:1](a ) ) . below the nel temperature in this distorted phase ,
the nickelates are e-type antiferromagnets , with an uncommon @xmath5 ordering vector . remarkably , pressure @xcite , strain @xcite , reduced dimensionality @xcite , and the engineering of various heterointerfaces @xcite have all been found to tune the ground state in various ways .
such a diversity of control mechanisms driving fascinating and useful emergent properties has fueled a wealth of interest in the nickelates in recent years .
a key property underlying the physics of the nickelates is the unusually high formal 3 + oxidation state imposed on the ni ions .
oxides with ni@xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) ions are relatively rare , and recent work suggests that the ni here has a valence closer to 2 + , with compensatory holes present in the oxygen @xmath0 band .
having such a negative charge transfer energy @xcite in the zsa classification scheme @xcite , the nickelates can accordingly be described as _ self - doped _
mott insulators @xcite .
theoretical studies which assume a negative charge transfer energy _ a priori _ find a novel explanation for the metal - insulator transition in the form of bond disproportionation @xcite . here ,
in the low temperature insulating phase , the self - doped oxygen @xmath0 holes mix strongly with alternating ni sites leading to a rocksalt - type superlattice distortion which can be identified roughly as collapsed @xmath8 and expanded @xmath9 ni - o octahedra ( where @xmath10 denotes a ligand hole ) .
a strong antiferromagnetic interaction between the ligand and ni holes then leads reduced moments on the collapsed octahedra , such that short and long bond ni have spins tending toward @xmath11 and @xmath12 , respectively . with indications of such a unique electronic structure at the origin of fascinating and tunable macroscopic phenomena , experiments
which can directly probe the relevant properties of the nickelates are crucial .
x - ray absorption spectroscopy ( xas ) at the ni @xmath13 edge has proven to be one such technique , having strong sensitivity to the metal - insulator transition ( mit ) and negative charge transfer behavior @xcite , and clear trends exist in the xas when moving across the phase diagram @xcite .
closely related to the xas is the resonant magnetic diffraction ( rmd ) response , which probes the antiferromagnetic ordering by studying the magnetic bragg reflection with photon energies tuned to the ni @xmath13 resonance .
recent studies have used xas and rmd to characterize variations of the mit due to strain @xcite , to examine orbital polarization effects @xcite , and to study the collinearity of the magnetic moments @xcite . however , while the xas and rmd show strong sensitivity to the electronic and magnetic structures , a satisfactory theoretical interpretation of each has yet to emerge for the nickelates . on one hand
the bond disproportionation models studied to date do not include the necessary orbital degeneracies for core level spectroscopy analysis , and thus to date have not been verified experimentally . on the other hand
the typical single cluster model approaches which are used for spectroscopy falter due to the negative charge transfer energy and breathing distortion .
a bond disproportionation model which could be tested against xas and rmd would simultaneously provide validation of the theory and a way to thoroughly analyze the ubiquitous , detailed spectra which have emerged from both bulk nickelates and engineered heterostructures @xcite . in this work ,
we formulate a novel full correlation , double cluster model to describe the insulating and magnetic phases of the nickelates .
the formulation permits the inclusion of negative charge transfer , bond- and charge - disproportionation and , most importantly , the necessary orbital degeneracies and coulomb interactions to simulate core level spectroscopy , providing a key test of bond disproportionation against resonant x - ray experiments .
our approach finds the same instability toward @xmath8 ( @xmath11 ) and @xmath9 ( @xmath14 ) alternating octahedra in the presence of a breathing distortion that was found in recent restricted - orbital studies .
further , we find moment sizes for each sublattice in agreement with those determined experimentally . at the same time , we find spectral responses for xas and rmd which are in excellent agreement with experiment , including pronounced trends across the rare earth series . while the model provides a previously missing validation of bond disproportionation against experiment , it is also a powerful tool for the precise analysis of engineered phases of nickelates as well as many other high valence transition metal oxides . in fig .
[ fig:1](a ) , we depict the prototypical structure of the nickelates .
alternating octahedra are shaded to distinguish the long ( green ) and short ( grey ) bond nio@xmath4 octahedra present in the breathing mode distorted insulating phase .
this distortion forms a rocksalt pattern , with each long ( short ) bond octahedron surrounded by six short ( long ) bond octahedra in an @xmath15 symmetric manner as exemplified in fig . [ fig:1](b ) . to enable a calculation which includes the full local coulomb interactions necessary for core level spectroscopy simulations
, we develop a model similar in nature to the multiplet ligand field theory approximation which has had great success in this area @xcite
. however , instead of the typical approach of a exact diagonalization on a single nio@xmath16 cluster , we create two clusters , one representing each sublattice of the rocksalt distortion .
each of our two ni - o octahedral clusters are constructed from a standard ligand field theory hamiltonian , including all local @xmath1 ( and ni @xmath0 ) coulomb interactions , crystal field splittings , @xmath1-ligand hybridization , and spin - orbit interaction @xcite . recalling the rocksalt pattern formed by the two distinct octahedra in the solid ,
we then couple our two cluster models via @xmath15 symmetric hybridization operators ( having @xmath17 and @xmath18 symmetry ) .
the coupling is shown diagrammatically in fig . [ fig:1](c ) .
the individual clusters have standard ligand field ni - ligand hopping @xmath19 and @xmath20 , and intercluster ni - ligand hopping is shown as @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
the general form of our hamiltonian is then @xmath23 where the first two terms are the independent ligand field hamiltonians for the two distinct octahedra , and the final term introduces the @xmath15-symmetric mixing ( full details of the hamiltonian and parameters are presented in the supplemental material @xcite ) .
the breathing distortion is introduced into the model by a modulation of the hopping and crystal field terms , according to harrison s rules @xcite .
the computations are performed with our second quantization programming language and exact diagonalization code , _ quanty _ @xcite .
figures [ fig:1](d - h ) display the ground state properties of the model as function of the breathing distortion , @xmath24 .
we parameterize the breathing distortion as the difference in long and short bond lengths @xmath25 and @xmath26 from the mean value @xmath27 ( @xmath28 ) . in fig .
[ fig:1](e ) , we find very little change in the ni @xmath1 occupation occurs via the breathing distortion .
the @xmath18 orbitals stay fully occupied and only a minor variation of the @xmath17 occupation occurs , with a total average occupation of .17ex8 electrons per ni , consistent with the negative charge transfer scenario .
the oxygen orbitals , in contrast to the ni , are very active under the breathing distortion . as shown in fig .
[ fig:1](f ) , with no distortion there is one ( self - doped ) @xmath17 ligand hole per cluster .
however , the holes shift to the compressed octahedron when the breathing distortion is introduced .
this action of the oxygen holes leads to a reduction of the spin on the compressed octahedron , as shown in fig .
[ fig:1](g ) , since the holes are strongly antiferromagnetically coupled to the holes in the ni @xmath1 shell .
this leaves the expanded octahedron ni unscreened , and its spin accordingly approaches @xmath14 , the expected value for a high spin , ionic @xmath29 configuration . for honio@xmath3 , where breathing distortions and spin moments have been measured experimentally @xcite ,
we find good agreement with our model .
the general behavior of figs .
[ fig:1](e - g ) , and summarized pictorially for @xmath30 in fig .
[ fig:1](d ) , also agrees with recent theory studies which were restricted to the active @xmath17 orbital basis @xcite .
overall , the calculations show a clear transition from a @xmath31 hole occupation of the two octahedra toward a @xmath32 hole arrangement for the compressed and expanded octahedra , respectively , with spins accordingly transitioning from @xmath33 to @xmath34 .
this transition is detailed in fig .
[ fig:1](h ) , where we plot the projection of the ground state onto the relevant basis states .
we emphasize that even with no breathing distortion a dynamic charge ordering is present , while the bond disproportionated configuration @xmath32 dominates the ground state for large distortions . in figure
[ fig : spec ] we show the resonant soft x - ray responses of our model , which has the full ni @xmath1 and @xmath0 orbital degeneracies and their coulomb interactions necessarily included in order to capture the detailed multiplet features in the spectra . in fig .
[ fig : spec](a ) , we compare the double cluster model ( with no breathing distortion ) to a conventional single cluster model , where the intercluster hopping @xmath35 is set to zero .
increasing @xmath35 from zero leads to a pronounced first peak being separated out below both the @xmath36 and @xmath37 edges .
such a first @xmath36 peak is a distinct characteristic of the insulating nickelates @xcite and , importantly , we find that the peak also has a strong magnetic circular dichroism ( mcd ) signal , consistent with rmd experiments which find the magnetic diffraction to be strongest at that peak @xcite .
given that no breathing distortion is introduced yet in this plot , the peak arises due to non - local excitations between the two clusters .
such an effect is perhaps not surprising , given the negative charge transfer energy and strong covalence , but it demonstrates that even in the absence of breathing distortions , a proper interpretation of the spectra of high valence transition metal oxides might require at least a double cluster model where such excitations can be captured .
similar inter - site effects requiring extensions beyond the single cluster approximation were recently identified in the xas of strongly covalent mixed valence systems @xcite .
we note that our value of @xmath38 is slightly less than one might expect for 180 degree bonds between adjacent ni atoms @xcite , in accordance with octahedral tilting that is present in the real materials .
figure [ fig : spec](b ) shows the effect of the breathing distortion on the xas spectra . in the presence of the distortion
there are distinct spectra , one arising from each of the two inequivalent sites , and as such we show these two spectra , along with their sum . here
it is evident that the spectrum from the long ( short ) bond octahedron shifts to lower ( higher ) energies as the breathing distortion is increased . in the extreme case ,
the sharp pre - peak arises entirely from the long bond ni .
this trend is in excellent agreement with the nickelate phase diagram , where smaller rare earths lead to larger breathing distortions and a larger separation of the xas peaks @xcite .
figure [ fig : spec](c ) details the magnetic response for the same three breathing distortions of fig .
[ fig : spec](b ) .
the total xas is shown again for comparison , and the site - decomposed mcd spectra are shown .
consistent with the tendency toward @xmath11 and @xmath14 moments on the short and long bond sites , as was shown in fig .
[ fig:1 ] , the mcd spectrum of the long ( short ) bond site becomes stronger ( weaker ) as the breathing distortion is introduced . as the long bond site contributes the most to the sharp first peak , the mcd response is then concentrated mostly on that peak as well . for comparison to experiment
, we also show the calculated resonant magnetic diffraction ( rmd ) response , which peaks strongly at the xas first peak and has a weak shoulder at higher energies , in excellent agreement with previous experiments @xcite .
the effects of intercluster hopping on the xas spectra of fig .
[ fig : spec](a ) demonstrate the importance of non - local excitations and accordingly suggest a highly covalent nature of the ground state captured in our double cluster model .
we verify this in fig .
[ fig : char ] by a decompositional analysis of the ground state wavefunction . within the configuration interaction approach taken here ,
the wavefunction is built up of determinants belonging to specific electronic configurations . in conventional single cluster theory ,
the ground state is thus given by @xmath39 , where @xmath40 gives the weight of configuration @xmath41 . in the nickelates , @xmath42 , and one is therefore limited to 4 configurations .
the weight of these configurations in the single cluster limit of our model are plotted on the right in fig .
[ fig : char](a ) . in green
we show the calculations including electron - electron correlations , i.e. the hamiltonian including the full coulomb interaction is solved by exact diagonalization . in red
we show the weight of the different configurations approximating the coulomb interaction by a potential as one would do in a local density or hartree - fock approximation .
correlations induced by the coulomb interaction reduce the amount of charge fluctuations .
one configuration gains more weight , reducing the weight of all others and thus changing the variance of the ni @xmath43 electron count .
interestingly it is not the @xmath44 configuration that gains the most weight in the strongly correlated limit , but the @xmath45 configuration .
the local symmetry is still that of a @xmath44 configuration , i.g . @xmath46 and one has a local doublet , defining the formal valence to be ni@xmath6 . in the double cluster model many more configurations are possible ( @xmath47 , in general ) due to charge fluctuations between the clusters .
we plot the configuration weights for the double cluster model with no breathing distortion on the left in fig .
[ fig : char](a ) . again correlations ( green ) reduce the amount of charge fluctuations on the ni site and , like the single cluster calculation , the @xmath48 configurations have the most weight .
the ligand charge fluctuations are not reduced between the correlated ( green ) and uncorrelated ( red ) calculations .
the local state can thus be thought of as a superposition of @xmath49 , @xmath45 , @xmath50 .
magnetically the local cluster state is thus a superposition of a triplet , doublet and singlet with ni - ligand cluster formal valences of 2 + , 3 + , and 4 + respectively .
are compared for the present double cluster model ( left , green ) and conventional ligand field theory ( right , green ) , demonstrating the new determinants which arise in negative charge transfer situations not captured by single cluster theory . in both cases
the weights for the non - interacting approximation are shown in red for comparison .
divisions on the bars have values of 0.05 for the double cluster and 0.10 for the single .
( b ) the compressed octahedron exhibits a wavefunction with dominant ligand hole - rich @xmath48 determinants , while the expanded octahedron has a much more ionic wavefunction .
, width=324 ] in fig .
[ fig : char](b ) , we show the effects of the breathing distortion on the @xmath48 derived configurations of the double cluster model . as demonstrated above , for no breathing distortion
there is a strong mixture of configurations ( high covalency ) .
however , upon the introduction of the breathing distortion the ligand hole character strongly shifts , such that the compressed octahedron has mostly @xmath8 ( and to a lesser extent , @xmath51 ) character ( reflecting what was shown in fig . [ fig:1](f ) ) .
the expanded octahedron , however , becomes much more ionic , being dominated by the @xmath9 configuration .
it is this ionic character of the long bond sublattice which has led to suggestions that the nickelate mit can be described as a _ site selective _
mott transition @xcite .
alternatively , given the active oxygen electronic structure due to the negative charge transfer energy , and the lattice breathing distortion , the mit might be more aptly described as peierls - like .
our double cluster model bridges the gap between electronic structure experiments and theories of negative charge transfer and bond disproportionation in the rare earth nickelates . by accounting for self - doped holes in the oxygen @xmath0 band as well as structural breathing distortions ,
we find pronounced bond disproportionation effects in the ground state , including unequal spin moments on the two sublattices in excellent agreement with experiments .
additionally , we show the effect of bond disproportionation on the soft x - ray spectral response , again finding excellent agreement with experiment and providing a tool for future studies of engineered phases . the highly covalent wavefunctions and non - local excitations captured by the double cluster model developed here
show that it will be important for other high oxidation state transition metal oxides , even in the absence of breathing distortions .
new insights into highly studied materials such as perovskite manganates , ferrates , cobaltates , etc . , and their resonant scattering responses , should also be captured by the model .
we thank m. hepting , e. benckiser , y. lu , i. elfimov , m. berciu , t. schmitt , and v. bisogni for helpful discussions .
this work was supported by nserc , cifar , and the max planck - ubc centre for quantum materials .
39ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty http://stacks.iop.org/0953-8984/9/i=8/a=003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.4902138 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.3451462 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.106804 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms3714 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1202647 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.113.227206 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nmat2958 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.114.026801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev - matsci-070115 - 032057 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.186402 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.67.1638 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.55.418 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.80.4305 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.61.11263 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.176406 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.156402 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.112.106404 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.126404 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.91.075128 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1142/s0218625x02003615 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.71.020406 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.elspec.2015.07.006 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.88.075116 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.88.125124 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.73.100409 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.85.165113 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _
( , ) @noop link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.28.4363 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.90.085102 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/108/57004 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.64.144417 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.61.1756 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0953-8984/23/i=3/a=036002 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0295-5075/93/i=4/a=47008 [ * * , ( ) ] * _ supplementary information for _ `` bond disproportionation and dynamical charge fluctuations in the perovskite rare earth nickelates '' * |
we present a web - based facility for the comparison of measurements of hadronic final states and the expectations of physics calculations and simulations .
the physics motivation is discussed .
then follows an outline of the design and technology used in the jetweb server .
section 4 contains a user guide to the server , as presented on the web , while sections 5 and 6 cover the implementation of the server with a view to further development and future plans .
particle physics experiments at high - energy accelerators have provided a wealth of data on the final state in electron - positron , lepton - proton and proton - antiproton interactions .
these data have seen the triumph of the standard model in precision electroweak measurements and the verification of the qcd sector of the standard model to a reasonable degree of precision . despite these successes ,
the final state in hadron - hadron collisions is in general poorly understood .
the hadronisation stage of a collision is not calculable in perturbative qcd , and calculations of ( for example ) multijet production are impractical at higher orders in qcd .
other problems include the description of non - perturbative remnant - remnant interactions , and the determination of the intrinsic transverse momentum of partons in the incoming hadron .
all these areas are calculated and/or modelled to some degree in general purpose monte - carlo simulation programs such as pythia @xcite and herwig @xcite .
these packages provide an invaluable tool in several distinct ways .
* they provide physically motivated input to detector simulations , thus facilitating the evaluation of acceptances and resolutions for detectors . *
they allow the estimation of the effects of hadronisation and other uncalculated effects on cross sections so that physically observable hadronic cross sections may be compared to partonic variables calculated to high orders in qcd . *
they allow predictions to be made for collisions at future colliders , which are vital input to the motivation and design of facilities . for all these reasons ,
consistent tuning of the free parameters of these generators , and confirmation of the physics assumptions they contain , is of critical importance for the accuracy and interpretation of measurements at current and future high - energy colliders .
however , determining whether such models are consistent with the wide range of available data is a non - trivial matter since the measurements are made with a variety of colliding beams , in many different regions of phase space , and for many complex observables .
detailed and successful fits have been performed using lep data but these give no information on physics specific to incoming hadrons .
in addition , there is an urgent need for the preservation of expertise and access to this data .
the jetweb server is designed to provide the ability to compare quickly and efficiently existing or future calculations and models with all relevant collider data .
this is an ambitious and long term ( indeed indefinite ) task .
currently a subset of hera , lep and tevatron jet data are included and only the herwig and pythia generators are used .
however , the server is designed to be scalable , with clean interfaces between the various technologies used for ease of development and maintenance and the inclusion of new data and simulations .
the components of the jetweb server and their functions and interactions are illustrated in figure [ fig : jwfig ] . at the centre of jetweb
is a java object model ( figures [ fig : jw1fig ] and [ fig : jw2fig ] ) containing the properties and interactions of models , papers , plots and fits .
the data underlying this model are stored in the jetweb database - a mysql database ( figure [ fig : jwdbfig ] ) .
the approximate correspondences between tables and object model classes are given in table 1 . .
approximate correspondence between classes in the object model and tables in the database .
[ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] a `` model '' completely specifies a unique generator , version and set of parameters .
a `` logparms '' consists of a subset of these parameters relevant to a specific set of colliding beams ( for example , proton - proton logparms do not define a photon parton distribution , and photon - photon logparms likewise do not specify a proton parton distribution ) .
consquently one model can currently have up to three logparms associated with it ( @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 ) .
a `` logfile '' for an individual simulation run is associated with a single logparms .
a `` paper '' encapsulates the measured data from a single publication and is associated with measured cross sections .
a `` fit '' contains the results of a comparison between real data and the predictions of a specific model . for more detail on the constituents of the object model ,
see figures [ fig : jw1fig ] and [ fig : jw2fig ] .
data is added to the database as follows : * mc results from hztool @xcite are processed by a fortran routine which reads in hbook @xcite histogram files and writes out histograms in the form of xml files in the java analysis studio @xcite ( jas ) plotml dtd format @xcite . * the jetweb xmlreader facility is a java class , used to convert plotml data into the java object model .
it processes the xml data using the jdom api @xcite , wrapping a sax parser .
* data held within the java object model is written to the jetweb database via jdbc @xcite .
the interface between object model and database is provided by the database manager classes within the ucl.hep.jetweb.db package .
these stages are initiated by commands from the maintainer ( privileged access user interface , see below ) .
the user accesses jetweb via the web user interface ( ui ) , which consists of java servlets run on a tomcat @xcite server , delivering html pages written using the jetweb htmlwriter facility ( ucl.hep.jetweb.html package ) .
the servlets access the jetweb database via the jdbc calls encapsulated within the java object model .
there are two levels of access to jetweb : * normal access allows the user to query the jetweb database for existing job results .
the user can fit these results to the data from a range of papers stored on the database .
+ fit data is loaded from the database into the object model .
if this fit has been requested before , the static webpages will already exist .
a comparison is made between the timestamp in the database and the date of these pages .
if the pages are more up - to - date , they are served to the user ( this avoids the extremely time consuming regeneration of histogram graphics files ) . if the pages predate any relevant data in the database they are regenerated . in this case
an html summary of the fit is written , and ucl.hep.jetweb.plots.dataplot and its subclasses access jas to write gif plot files .
plot files are incorporated into html generated by servlets using the htmlwriter utility .
the graphics generation is done in a separate thread to improve response time for the user .
+ if there are no results stored for the user s specified set of parameters , a new job request with the required parameters can be generated .
the job requests are moderated and submitted by an administrator on the server side .
* privileged access is available to allow maintenance of the jetweb server .
it allows the update of the static webpages associated with the application .
it controls the upload of new data to the jetweb database .
it also manages the running of new batch jobs , facilitating submission of new jobs and monitoring of incomplete runs .
this section outlines the expected use of the web pages ( http://jetweb.hep.ucl.ac.uk ) for a normal ( unprivileged ) user .
the top - level welcome page ( figure [ fig : frontpagefig ] ) provides the user with several options . down
the left hand side are various short cuts to static web pages .
these include * a short - cut to the current best fit for each simulation package used .
* lists of all fits currently in the database . * an extensive bibliography with references to the data used in jetweb , presentations using results from jetweb , and other related work .
* documentation of the simulations currently available in hztool . *
links to the experiments whose data are used in jetweb . in the central section of the page
are links allowing the user to * query the database directly * access previously prepared searches a selection of standard queries relating to specific parameters or physics studies are listed on the jetweb welcome page . following the links from here
gives access to all the fits as well as a summary of conclusions to be drawn from them . on the welcome page ,
clicking ` search the database ' causes a parameter input form to be displayed , as shown in figure [ fig : searchpagefig ] . * common parameters ; various parameters common to all generators
can be entered on first part of form * generator specific parameters : the search may be restricted to specialised parameters for a particular generator .
currenly herwig and pythia are implemented . * * herwig parameters .
check generator - herwig .
click ` change herwig parameters ' .
this will display additional fields for the herwig parameters to be entered . * * pythia parameters .
check generator - pythia .
click ` change pythia parameters ' .
boxes will be displayed to enter the number and value of each mstp and parp parameter to be specified .
enter the values and press ` add ' .
mstp and parp parameters which have been set will be displayed on the form . to remove a value , enter its number in the relevant field , but leave the corresponding box blank , then press ` add ' .
specify all the parameters required in this way before continuing with the search . *
the sort order of results can be specified by choosing a value from the ` sort results ... ' list at the top of the form .
* results can be filtered by selecting a value for the ` only show results .. ' list at the top of the form .
some models in the database will have been compared to a subset of the available data only .
this option allows the user to exclude any models that have not been compared to the chosen data . *
submit a search by clicking ` get results ' at the top of the form .
if a search is successful , brief summaries of the available results will be listed .
each job result will also have a link ( ` plots etc ' ) for access to a detailed description of the fit and the actual histograms showing the comparison ( figure 7 ) .
if there are no data corresponding to the input search parameters , the jetweb request form will be displayed with the required parameters filled in . from here
, a request can be made for a new job to be run .
job requests can be made in two contexts * search fails to find results - this brings up the jobrequest form with the failed search parameters filled in . *
a request for additional data can be made from the fit details page , figure [ fig : fitpagefig ] , for each job .
first , the collider must be selected .
more data for a particular collider ( with unchanged job parameters ) can be requested using the ` request highwer statistics ' option , while ` request similar data ' allows a new job to be specified with altered parameters .
the latter option accesses the job request form , allowing the user to vary a subset of parameters while guaranteeing that all others will remain identical to those of the originally selected fit .
this section is intended to outline ways in which the application could be altered or enhanced to expand its scope .
it should be used as a guide for developers in conjunction with javadoc for the jetweb java application , and other documentation on the jetweb website ( jetweb.hep.ucl.ac.uk ) .
mysql is a simple relational sql database with a jdbc driver available .
the database is accessed from the java object model using the ucl.hep.jetweb.db package .
minimal changes would be required to convert to another sql database ( probably just changing the relevant jdbc driver ) . for conversion to a different type of database , new database manager classes
would be required , implementing the same interface as the existing dbmanager , dbfitmanager and dbplotmanager .
the interface of the ucl.hep.jetweb.servlet package would have to be implemented by any alternative ui .
this application was originally run using a java swing ui .
it should be very straightforward to implement a simple command - line interface .
a new ui would replace the ucl.hep.jetweb.servlet package ; accessing the same methods on ucl.hep.jetweb.resultmanager .
there is a main method on paper which adds new realplots to the database . to produce new predictedplots ,
the appropriate hztool routines must be provided and called , and the fortran modified to output xml data files for the new histograms .
the major work here would be to interface the new package to hztool ( or an equivalent package capable of producing suitable output files - see below ) .
in addition , tables would have to be added to the database specifying any extra parameters needed to define a model with the new simulation package . the ucl.hep.jetweb.html package and specifically the htmlwriter class is responsible for constructing the jetweb web pages .
thus , changing the layout or content of these pages necessitates modification of this class s methods .
the user requests fits by filling in an html form . a ucl.hep.jetweb.resultsearchpattern and a ucl.hep.jetweb.plotselection
are built from the html form .
a database query is constructed from these objects . to add new parameters to user queries , the relevant fields
must be added to resultsearchpattern and plotselection , and the database query methods updated to incorporate these new fields .
the prepared searches available from the welcome page are simple html forms that are submitted to the server .
these forms can be used as templates for users to prepare their own standard ( or often repeated ) searches .
data is loaded into the jetweb application in the form of xml files generated by the hztool fortran routine .
the format of these files is derived from the jas dtd - plotml .
although the xml files produced are valid plotml files , in fact only a subset of the elements in plotml are used .
thus , the jetweb xml format can also be represented by a reduced size plotml ( figures [ fig : plotmlfig ] and [ fig : plotmldatafig ] ) .
an example xml file using this reduced plotml dtd is included in the appendix .
the ucl.hep.jetweb.plots.jetwebxmlreader reads in xml documents ( reduced plotml format ) using the jdom utility @xcite .
jetwebxmlreader will ignore any additional elements present in the files .
the xmlreader utility could also be adapted to read * a wider range of plotml documents ; * a different xml format . however , it would be simpler to retain the original plotml reader and use an xsl stylesheet to convert between xml formats , if this should be required .
one consequence of adopting the plotml input format for the java object model is that any program capable of producing plotml histograms can be used to provide simulation data for jetweb .
currently a fortran routine ( h2xml ) is provided ( and is available from the web pages ) to convert hbook histograms to the reduced plotml format described above . to allow jetweb to read data from other formats , similar conversion facilities would be required .
the ucl.hep.jetweb.html package is responsible for producing the web front end for jetweb .
some of the classes ( including paper , dataplot and jobresult ) have _ tohtml _ methods .
these should really be migrated to the html package in future releases .
the jdom functionality could be used in an xmlwriter class which would reconstruct the xml documents from the object model .
the documents could be constructed in plotml , or another dtd .
xsl stylesheets can be used to convert xml documents from one format to another .
if several formats were required , only a single xmlwriter utility , used in conjunction with stylesheets , could produce multiple output formats including xml , html - allowing direct visualisation of data on a webpage - and plain text .
ucl.hep.jetweb.plots.dataplot and its subclasses can be output as gif files using the jas utility .
this utility is still under development and supports an increasing variety of output formats , including encapsulated postscript .
if an unsupported format of plot file were required , it would probably be simplest to extract the data in xml format to be submitted to the plotting facility .
job submission from the server side is made in several ways .
there are options for submission to uk particle physics grid @xcite as well as direct submission to local batch systems .
this is transparent to the general user . to submit to new facilties ,
template scripts must be provided and the extra protocols added to the ucl.hep.jetweb.script package .
there are several obvious and important developments of the jetweb facility which should take place .
some of these are described below . server side submission of jobs to the grid has already been implemented .
it is also likely that the database itself will become directly accessible as a grid data resource .
the fortran library hztool should eventually be augmented or replaced by a similar package following an object - oriented design .
this is motivated by the advantages of oo design principals , the declining knowledge base in fortran and the likely future requirement to validate c++ versions of the general purpose generators , pythia7 & herwig++ , which are currently under development .
in addition to the new versions of those generators , several next - to - leading order qcd generators are under development and these could be tested with this facility .
finally , there are major data sets and classes of data which should be added to a truly ` global ' validation facility , for example lep and sld hadronic data from the @xmath3 , hera deep inelastic scattering data and data from proton machines other than the tevatron .
thanks to brian cox and ben waugh for useful discussions , encouragement and cpu .
xml version="1.0 " encoding="iso-8859 - 1 " ? >
< ! doctype plotml system " plotml.dtd " > < plotml > < plot >
< title > < border type="none"/ > < label text="jet et & gt ; 4 gev " > < font style="bold " points="14 " face="sansserif"/ > < /label > < /title
> < legend visible="never " > < /legend
> < dataarea > < border type="none"/ > < ! -- each of the following data1d elements contains a single point .
this handles variable bin widths .
( for a constant bin width histogram , only one data1d element would be required , with all data points in a single string , separated by carriage returns ) -- > < data1d axis="y0 " > <
bins1d title= " " > 0.49,0.14,0.14 < /bins1d >
< binneddataaxisattributes max="-1.4 " numberofbins="1 " min="-1.15 " type="double " axis="x"/ > < style1d datapointsize="6 " showerrorbars="true " histogrambarsfilled="true " showlinesbetweenpoints="false " errorbarcolor="black " datapointstyle="dot " showhistogrambars="false " linecolor="black " datapointcolor="black " showdatapoints="true " histogrambarcolor="blue"/ > < /data1d
> < data1d axis="y0 " > <
bins1d title= " " > 0.88,0.22,0.22 < /bins1d > < binneddataaxisattributes axis="x " numberofbins="1 " min="-0.8999999999999999 " type="double " max="-1.15"/ >
< style1d datapointsize="6 " showerrorbars="true " histogrambarsfilled="true " showlinesbetweenpoints="false " datapointstyle="dot " errorbarcolor="black " showhistogrambars="false " linecolor="black " datapointcolor="black " showdatapoints="true " histogrambarcolor="red"/ > < /data1d
> < data1d axis="y0 " >
< bins1d title= " " > 0.92,0.24,0.24 < /bins1d > < binneddataaxisattributes axis="x " numberofbins="1 " min="-0.7 " type="double " max="-0.9000000000000001"/ > < style1d datapointsize="6 " showerrorbars="true " histogrambarsfilled="true " showlinesbetweenpoints="false " datapointstyle="dot " errorbarcolor="black " showhistogrambars="false " linecolor="black " datapointcolor="black " showdatapoints="true " histogrambarcolor="fuchsia"/ > < /data1d
> < data1d axis="y0 " >
< bins1d title= " " > 0.83,0.14,0.14 < /bins1d > < binneddataaxisattributes axis="x " numberofbins="1 " min="-0.5 " type="double " max="-0.7"/ >
< style1d datapointsize="6 " showerrorbars="true " histogrambarsfilled="true " showlinesbetweenpoints="false " datapointstyle="dot " errorbarcolor="black " showhistogrambars="false " linecolor="black " datapointcolor="black " showdatapoints="true " histogrambarcolor="yellow"/ > < /data1d
> < data1d axis="y0 " >
< bins1d title= " " > 0.85,0.17,0.17 < /bins1d >
< binneddataaxisattributes axis="x " numberofbins="1 " min="-0.30000000000000004 " type="double " max="-0.5"/ > < style1d datapointsize="6 " showerrorbars="true " histogrambarsfilled="true " showlinesbetweenpoints="false " datapointstyle="dot " errorbarcolor="black " showhistogrambars="false " linecolor="black " datapointcolor="black " showdatapoints="true " histogrambarcolor="lime"/ > < /data1d
> < data1d axis="y0 " >
< bins1d title= " " > 0.78,0.14,0.14 < /bins1d > < binneddataaxisattributes axis="x " numberofbins="1 " min="-0.10000000000000003 " type="double " max="-0.3"/ >
< style1d datapointsize="6 " showerrorbars="true " histogrambarsfilled="true " showlinesbetweenpoints="false " datapointstyle="dot " errorbarcolor="black " showhistogrambars="false " linecolor="black " datapointcolor="black " showdatapoints="true " histogrambarcolor="orange"/ > < /data1d
> < data1d axis="y0 " >
< bins1d title= " " > 0.54,0.12,0.12 < /bins1d > < binneddataaxisattributes axis="x " numberofbins="1 " min="0.04000000000000001 " type="double " max="-0.1"/ >
< style1d datapointsize="6 " showerrorbars="true " histogrambarsfilled="true " showlinesbetweenpoints="false " datapointstyle="dot " errorbarcolor="black " showhistogrambars="false " linecolor="black " datapointcolor="black " showdatapoints="true " histogrambarcolor="aqua"/ > < /data1d
> < axis logarithmic="false " showoverflows="false " numberofbins="50 " allowsuppressedzero="true " type="double " location="x0 " > < label text="xgamma " >
< font style="plain " face="dialog " points="12"/ > < /label >
< font style="plain " face="dialog " points="12"/ > < /axis
> < axis logarithmic="false " showoverflows="false " min="0.0 " allowsuppressedzero="true " type="double " max="1.0120000000000002 " location="y0 " >
< label text="d(sigma)/d(xgamma ) ( nb ) " > < font style="plain " face="dialog " points="12"/ > < /label >
< font style="plain " face="dialog " points="12"/ > < /axis
> < /dataarea
> < bounds width="400 " height="400"/ > < colorscheme foregroundcolor="default " backgroundcolor="(255,215,0)"/ > < /plot
< /plotml > .... | a world wide web interface to a monte carlo validation and tuning facility is described .
the aim of the package is to allow rapid and reproducible comparisons to be made between detailed measurements at high - energy physics colliders and general physics simulation packages .
the package includes a relational database , a java servlet query and display facility , and clean interfaces to simulation packages and their parameters .
` ucl / hep 2002 - 04 ` + ` october ` ` 2002 ` j. m. butterworth + s. butterworth + + university college london + gower st .
london wc1e
6bt + england _ pacs : _
+ _ keywords : monte carlo simulation ; qcd final states ; jets ; database ; java ; mysql ; www _ |
the dynamics of conservative systems consists of different types of motion , from regular over quasi - regular to chaotic , depending on the perturbation parameter .
usually , in @xmath4 dimensional conservative systems regular islands ( kolmogorov - arnold - moser kam tori ) can break as the perturbation parameter increases , and chaotic trajectories may coexist with regular islands @xcite .
this regime is called quasiregular .
chaotic trajectories may be trapped around stable islands creating `` sticky '' motion ( for a review see @xcite ) . in such cases
the dynamics in phase space can be very structured and the motion is non - ergodic .
analytical results for physical quantities in the quasiregular regime are rare and it is very desirable to obtain tools which quantify degrees of ergodicity and hyperbolicity , as for example the angle between the stable and unstable manifolds obtained via the covariant lyapunov vectors @xcite .
even for apparently totally chaotic systems , tiny regular islands may appear which induce sticky motion as exemplified in fig .
[ pss1]a with the phase space of the @xmath4 dimensional kicked rotor [ eqs .
( [ sm ] ] for the nonlinearity parameter @xmath5 .
the dynamics looks totally chaotic yet , tiny regular islands appear near the points @xmath6 ( see boxes ) , if enough initial conditions are sampled .
such islands become visible with sufficient magnification ( figs .
[ pss1]b - c ) . .
( b ) and ( c ) are magnifications from the boxes shown in ( a).,scaledwidth=100.0% ] .
( b ) and ( c ) are magnifications from the boxes shown in ( a).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] .
( b ) and ( c ) are magnifications from the boxes shown in ( a).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=77.0% ] hence , the question arises how these tiny regular islands can be identified with not more information than provided by fig .
[ pss1]a . in higher dimensions , the information equivalent to fig .
[ pss1]a must be cast in a different form since poincar surfaces of section ( pss ) can not be plotted .
in fact , for @xmath7 dimensional conservative systems , due to arnold diffusion , the kam surfaces do not divide the whole phase space into a set of closed volumes .
although the effect of stickiness of @xmath8-dimensional invariant tori has been analyzed for the asymptotic decay of correlations and anomalous diffusion @xcite , to the best of our knowledge , the behavior of sticky trajectories in higher - dimensional systems has never been quantified and explored systematically . in the following we present extensive numerical simulations to detect and quantify sticky motion in the phase space of quasiregular and chaotic conservative systems with up to 20 dimensions .
to fulfill this task we analyze small changes in the finite time lyapunov exponents ( ftle ) distribution using four quantities : the variance @xmath9 , the skewness @xmath10 , the kurtosis @xmath11 and @xmath12 , the normalized number of occurencies of the most probable finite time lyapunov exponent .
the first three quantities were analyzed in the two - dimensional standard map for the distribution of the finite time stability exponents to detect islands @xcite and to study the fluctuations of the mean ftle for specific trajectories and the corresponding kolmogorov like entropy @xcite .
the ftles are the average of local divergence of trajectories and for ergodic systems they converge to the le obtained in the limit of infinite times , which is independent of initial conditions @xcite . in such cases
the ftle distribution has gaussian form ( normal distribution ) @xcite .
however , in quasiregular systems the chaotic trajectories may visit the neighborhood of regular islands , being trapped there for a while , and the ftles do not converge quite well .
such small changes in the ftles distribution can be used for many purposes : to obtain information about algebraic or exponential stretching in phase space @xcite , to quantify ergodicity @xcite , to study stretching processes in chaotic flows @xcite , to detect the bimodal @xcite or multimodal @xcite behavior of the local ftles , to analyze the time correlations @xcite and poincar recurrence @xcite in coupled maps , to detect the sticky motion @xcite and the arise of regular islands @xcite for interacting particles in one- and two - dimensional billiards via @xmath12 and , as we will see here , to detect and quantify sticky motion in higher - dimensional nonintegrable conservative systems .
in addition , ftles have been used in dissipative systems to distinguish between strange chaotic and nonchaotic attractors ( see @xcite for some examples ) . in these cases the trajectory switches between long times on the periodic attractor ( negative ftle ) and smaller times on the chaotic saddle with positive ftles .
this is quite the opposite of what is observed in conservative chaotic systems , where the trajectory evolves for longer times in the chaotic region of the phase space and smaller times near the regular island .
in contrast to the large literature related to the analysis of sticky motion via the distribution of the _ local _
ftles for some specific trajectories and as a function of time , in this work we analyze the ftles distribution _ after _
@xmath13 iteration of the map and over @xmath14 initial conditions distributed uniformly in phase space .
our investigations show that even for such large times the ftles still depend on initial conditions when sticky motion is present .
such times are large enough to give a good convergence of the ftles and to detect the sticky motion .
if the iteration times increase too much ( @xmath15 ) , effects of sticky motion on the distribution start to dissapear since for infinite times the distribution approaches the @xmath16function in chaotic systems .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ model ]
we describe the properties of the variance @xmath9 and the distribution of the most probable lyapunov exponent @xmath12 for a two - dimensional conservative system ( the standard map ) and compare them with higher cummulants ( @xmath17 and @xmath11 ) . in section
[ coupled ] we couple @xmath8 conservative maps and by increasing @xmath18 we analyze carefully the changes observed in the the quantities @xmath12 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 .
section [ conclusions ] summarizes the main results of the paper .
the standard map is an ideal model for a conservative chaotic system to study the behavior of ftle distributions , specially if one is interested in an extension to higher dimensions .
the original @xmath4 dimensional map @xmath19 was proposed by chirikov @xcite and is defined by @xmath20 where @xmath21 and @xmath22 are the dynamical variables of the system after the @xmath23th iteration and @xmath2 is the nonlinear parameter .
this map locally approximates more general nonlinear mappings @xcite .
the ftle spectrum is determined numerically for a conservative system using bennetin s algorithm @xcite which includes the gram - schmidt re - orthonormalization procedure .
the sum of all ftles is zero and they come in pairs @xmath24
( @xmath25 is for the @xmath25th unstable direction ) .
hence , it is sufficient to analyze the @xmath26 .
the ftles can be defined by @xmath27 with the discrete iterations @xmath23 .
@xmath28 , and @xmath29 are the jacobian matrices determined at each iteration @xmath23 .
@xmath30 represents the unit vector in the @xmath25th unstable direction .
these vectors are re - orthonormalized at each iteration and the ftle spectrum is obtained using eq .
( [ lambda ] ) .
the usual le is obtained from @xmath31 which is independent of the initial conditions .
calculated over @xmath32 trajectories up to @xmath33 iterations . with increasing @xmath34 the color changes from light to dark ( white over yellow and blue to black ) .
( b ) the corresponding mean value @xmath35.,title="fig:",width=309 ] calculated over @xmath32 trajectories up to @xmath33 iterations . with increasing @xmath34 the color changes from light to dark ( white over yellow and blue to black ) .
( b ) the corresponding mean value @xmath35.,title="fig:",width=321 ] figure [ mp]a shows the ftles distributions @xmath34 as a function of the nonlinearity parameter @xmath2 for @xmath32 initial conditions and up to @xmath13 iterations . for each initial condition
we reckon one ftle @xmath36 , which is the time average of all local ftle along the trajectory . in fig .
[ mp]a the color changes from light to dark ( white over yellow and blue to black ) with increasing @xmath34 .
the gray points below the main curve are related to ftles from chaotic trajectories which were trapped for a while close to regular islands . for these trapped chaotic trajectories ( or `` sticky '' motion )
the _ local _ ftle decreases and consequently the final @xmath36 also decreases . in such cases
the ftle distribution is not gaussian anymore but contains interesting information about the dynamics .
figure [ mp]a also reveals that for some specific values of @xmath2 the amount of sticky trajectories changes , which will be quantified and characterized next .
note , that such information is not provided by the mean ftle shown in fig . [ mp]b . clearly , anomalies in the ftle distribution reflect sticky motion - however , the entire distribution is not a convenient tool to identify and measure sticky motion .
instead , we will analyze the following four measures : a. ) : : the number of occurencies of the most probable ftles @xmath37 which informs how many initial conditions ( normalized ) lead to the mode of the distribution @xcite .
@xmath38 means that for all initial conditions the ftles are equal ( within the precision @xmath39 ) .
therefore we expect @xmath38 for a totally chaotic ( or totally regular ) system and large times . in cases
the sticky motion appears or if the normal distribution did not converge to the given precision , @xmath40 .
b. ) : : the variance defined by @xmath41 which is the second cummulant of the ftle distribution .
it should increase for sticky motion .
we will analyze the properties of the relative variance @xmath42 which is more appropriate for higher - dimensional systems .
in such cases it is possible to detect small differences relative to each unstable direction .
c. ) : : the skewness is defined by + @xmath43 + it is the third cummulant of the ftle distribution and detects the asymmetry of the distribution around its mean value . for
@xmath44 we have the regular distribution .
since sticky motion usually reduces the ftle , the asymmetry of the distribution leads to @xmath45 .
d. ) : : the kurtosis is defined by @xmath46 and detects the shape of the distribution . when @xmath47 indicates that the distribution is flatter than the regular distribution ( @xmath48 ) , while @xmath49 reveals a sharper distribution than the normal one .
these four quantities will be used to characterize the degree of sticky motion in the transition from low- to higher - dimensional systems .
altogether they should give all relevant informations which can be extracted from the distributions . to compare with the higher dimensional cases to be discussed
later we summarize here @xmath4 results for the ftles distributions of the standard map in a slightly different @xmath2 regime than considered by @xcite . for the standard map measured with ( a ) @xmath50 , ( b ) @xmath51 , ( c ) @xmath52 and ( d ) @xmath53.,width=340 ] for all simulations we have used @xmath54 values of @xmath2 in the interval @xmath55 ( stepsize @xmath56 ) .
as can be seen from fig .
[ n1]a @xmath12 has many minima in the interval @xmath55 . for all minima of @xmath12 a certain amount of sticky motion
is expected .
this is indeed true , as we have checked constructing the pss ( not shown ) for some values of @xmath2 where minima in @xmath12 appear and for all of them we found sticky motion .
comparing @xmath12 with fig .
[ n1]b we see that @xmath9 has maxima only for values of @xmath2 in the interval @xmath57 and close to @xmath58 , i.e. , the variance does not detect all the sticky regions
. however , skewness ( fig .
[ n1]c ) and kurtosis ( fig .
[ n1]d ) detect sticky motion as identified by @xmath12 in ( fig .
both parameters behave as expected . in fig .
[ n1]c we plotted the skewness @xmath10 as a function of @xmath2 . for almost all minima of @xmath12
we observe that the skewness ( fig .
[ n1]c ) is negative .
this implies that the sticky motion induces a left asymmetry in the ftles distribution . in other words ,
the tail on the left side of the distribution is larger than the tail on the right side . for almost all minima of @xmath12 the kurtosis @xmath11 ( fig .
[ n1]d ) has a maximum .
this is expected since a small @xmath12 implies widely distributed @xmath59 and consequently a relatively flat distribution ( large @xmath11 ) . obviously , in the two - dimensional case @xmath12 , and the cummulants @xmath10 and @xmath11 are sensitive and consistent detectors of sticky phase space trajectories , with the latter two being more sensitive , while @xmath12 is less sensitive , but gives additional information ( see , e.g. , the interval @xmath60 ) , which will become more obvious in the higher dimensional cases .
coupled conservative maps are convenient systems to investigate sticky motion in higher dimensional phase space systematically .
the equations for @xmath8 coupled conservative maps read @xmath61 where @xmath62 .
we consider periodic boundary conditions @xmath63 and unidirectional next nearest neighbor coupling . in eq .
( [ coupmaps ] ) we must use modulus @xmath64 .
translational invariance occurs in the @xmath65coordinate and the lyapunov spectrum always possesses two null exponents since two eigenvalues from the jacobian of the coupled maps are equal to @xmath66 . for @xmath67
our model can be written has a time - one map of a delta - function kicked hamiltonian flow and the translational symmetry implies , via noethers theorem , that the total momentum @xmath68 is a constant of motion . however , for @xmath69 our model can not be written as a time - one map of a hamiltonian flow and the total momentum @xmath70 is not a constant of motion anymore ( noethers theorem is applied for hamiltonian systems ) . in all numerical simulations we checked that the sum of all les is close to @xmath71 and that their come in pairs .
in addition , the condition @xmath72 , for @xmath73 is equivalent to the trivial uncoupled maps case @xmath74 , where the linear momentum @xmath75 of each site is a constant of motion .
very close to this condition we can use the approximation @xmath76 , and the total momentum becomes an approximated conserved quantity for any @xmath8 .
this will be nicely observed in the simulations when stickiness occurs . in this case
the system eq .
( [ coupmaps ] ) has one positive , one negative and two zero ftles .
we show results related to the positive ftle in fig .
[ n2 ] .
( the curve @xmath78 shows results for the standard map calculated at @xmath79 , see text ) with ( b ) @xmath12 , ( c ) @xmath51 , ( d ) @xmath52 and ( e ) @xmath53 in the interval @xmath55 and for @xmath67.,title="fig:",width=340 ] ( the curve @xmath78 shows results for the standard map calculated at @xmath79 , see text ) with ( b ) @xmath12 , ( c ) @xmath51 , ( d ) @xmath52 and ( e ) @xmath53 in the interval @xmath55 and for @xmath67.,title="fig:",width=340 ] clearly , the mean value @xmath80 increases with @xmath2 ( fig .
[ n2]a ) . for @xmath67
the equations of @xmath81 ( [ coupmaps ] ) decouple in center of mass and relative coordinates .
the map in the relative coordinate is the standard map but with parameter @xmath82 .
therefore , the curve in fig .
[ n2]a should match those obtained for the standard map with parameter values @xmath79 .
to check this we plotted @xmath80 in fig .
[ n2]a ( dashed line ) for the standard map with values @xmath79 .
both curves are identical .
for all minima of @xmath12 ( fig .
[ n2]b ) the skewness @xmath10 ( fig .
[ n2]d ) and the kurtosis @xmath11 ( fig . [ n2]e ) have also minima and maxima , respectively . at the corresponding values of @xmath2
many trapped trajectories are expected .
since this case is the standard map with larger nonlinearity parameter ( @xmath82 ) , we do not discuss further details .
the case @xmath84 has six ftles , two positive , two negative and two zero .
the analysis will be done for the distributions of the two positive ftles which are labeled such that @xmath85 . for @xmath84 the interval @xmath86 does not exhibit structures in the ftle distributions pointing to sticky trajectories . for @xmath84.,width=340 ] hence , we analyze the interval @xmath87 which is close to the non - chaotic case @xmath74 .
figure [ mn3 ] shows the mean values of the first and second ftles as a function of @xmath2 .
both ftles increase with @xmath2 , but @xmath88 increases faster and has a minimum close to @xmath89 .
close to this value @xmath90 starts to be finite .
figures [ n3 - 1 ] and [ n3 - 2 ] show the quantities ( a ) @xmath91 , ( b ) @xmath92 , ( d ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 as a function of @xmath2 for @xmath95 and @xmath96 , respectively . with ( b ) @xmath97 , ( c ) @xmath98 and ( d ) @xmath99 in the interval @xmath87 and @xmath84.,width=340 ] with ( b ) @xmath100 , ( c ) @xmath101 and ( d ) @xmath102 in the interval @xmath87 and @xmath84.,width=340 ] by comparing these plots
we see that both distributions detect the sticky motion for @xmath103 . in this region the minimum value of @xmath93
is @xmath104 for @xmath105 and @xmath106 for @xmath107 .
the maximum value of @xmath94 is @xmath108 for @xmath105 and @xmath109 for @xmath107 .
for @xmath110 we observe in fig .
[ n3 - 2 ] that @xmath111 , meaning that all initial conditions lead to the same @xmath112 .
however , @xmath101 and @xmath102 show that the distribution around @xmath112 is not gaussian . by changing @xmath113
the distribution changes slightly from the right asymmetric form [ @xmath114 to the left asymmetric form [ @xmath115 . the kurtosis is always flat ( @xmath116 ) but approaches a regular distribution when @xmath117 .
similar behavior is observed in fig .
[ n3 - 1 ] for @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
the relative variance is shown to be relevant only at very low values of @xmath2 ( for both ftles ) .
for @xmath118 the distribution related to @xmath119 detects the sticky motion at @xmath120 and @xmath121 , while for @xmath122 it detects @xmath123 and @xmath124 ( but only @xmath102 ) .
this shows the intuitively expected result that when the nonlinearity parameter increases the most unstable dimension ( related to @xmath119 ) is more sensitive to the sticky motion . for @xmath126.,width=328 ] in fig .
[ mn5 ] the mean values for the positive ftles @xmath127 are shown as a function of @xmath2 . for smaller values of @xmath128 , @xmath129 and @xmath130
are almost zero , while @xmath131 increases initially very fast for @xmath132 and then slowly for @xmath133 . for @xmath2 above @xmath134
all mean ftles increase linearly with different slopes size - wise ordered as the ftles themselves . ,
( b ) @xmath135 , ( c ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 in the interval @xmath136 , @xmath126 and for all @xmath137.,title="fig:",width=340 ] , ( b ) @xmath135 , ( c ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 in the interval @xmath136 , @xmath126 and for all @xmath137.,title="fig:",width=340 ] , ( b ) @xmath135 , ( c ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 in the interval @xmath136 , @xmath126 and for all @xmath137.,title="fig:",width=340 ] , ( b ) @xmath135 , ( c ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 in the interval @xmath136 , @xmath126 and for all @xmath137.,title="fig:",width=340 ] figure [ n5 ] shows that for @xmath138 the distributions from all ftles approach the normal ( gaussian ) form expected for a totally chaotic regime in contrast to the cases @xmath139 discussed before , where sticky motion also occurs for higher values of @xmath2 .
therefore , there is a clear transition from the quasiregular to the totally chaotic dynamics at @xmath140 _ simultaneously _ in all unstable directions . on the other hand ,
all quantities detect the sticky motion for @xmath141 .
interestingly , above a critical value @xmath142 , the four indicators of sticky motion have a similar qualitative behavior for all ftles , i. e. , independently of the unstable directions .
for example , the distributions for _ all _ ftles have a small left asymmetry ( @xmath143 ) with no flatness ( @xmath144 ) at @xmath145 , and a left asymmetry ( @xmath146 ) with flatness ( @xmath147 ) at @xmath148 .
two exemplary distributions are shown in fig .
[ n5d ] for @xmath149 and @xmath150 .
left asymmetry and flatness are evident . and @xmath150.,width=340 ]
the critical value @xmath142 is the point where @xmath151 detects the sticky motion from the distribution of the last ( the _ smallest _ ) ftle [ see fig .
[ n5]a ] . the value of @xmath152 can also be determined approximately from the onset of linear @xmath2-dependence of the mean ftles in fig .
[ mn5 ] .
these results show that the sticky motion induces differences between the distributions of @xmath153 only for @xmath154 .
since sticky motion is a consequence of regular structures in phase space , this suggests that there could exist independent invariant regions in phase - space . in the interval @xmath155 on the other hand
, the sticky motion affects all unstable dimensions by the same amount leading to similar distributions for different ftles .
finally , in the totally chaotic regime @xmath156 all unstable directions are affected proportionally to each other . to explain this better we show in fig .
[ traj5 ] the time evolution of @xmath153 ( @xmath137 ) for one exemplary trajectory in the three distinct regions of @xmath2 .
figure [ traj5](a ) shows the behavior of the ftles for @xmath157 and no sticky motion is observed since no ftle goes to zero for some shorter time intervals . for the intermediate case
@xmath158 we see in fig .
[ traj5](b ) that for times around @xmath159 ( see arrow ) _ all _ four ftles are zero , so the sticky motion occurs in all unstable directions and a common behavior is observed .
physically what happens is that the linear momentum of _ each _ site becomes approximately constant during sticky motion .
this is clearly shown in fig.[p5](a ) , where @xmath160 is plotted as a function of @xmath23 .
at the sticky time @xmath161 ( see black box ) , @xmath75 is constant for _ all _ sites .
( @xmath137 ) for one exemplary trajectory with @xmath126 and ( a ) @xmath157 , ( b ) @xmath158 , ( c ) @xmath162.,width=377 ] this agrees with the conjecture made by froeschl @xcite and observed later in coupled maps by @xcite , i. e. , that a conservative system with @xmath163 has @xmath8 or one ( the energy ) constants of motion . in other words , following this conjecture when the sticky motion occurs all ftles should temporarily be very close to zero , as already observed .
however , this changes when the region @xmath154 is analyzed , as can be observed in fig .
[ traj5](c ) for times around @xmath159 and @xmath164 ( see arrows ) .
only @xmath88 is larger and the remaining three ftles are very close to zero . in this case , at the sticky time @xmath161 ( see black box ) , the momenta @xmath165 and @xmath166 are not conserved anymore .
see fig .
[ p5](b ) .
( @xmath167 ) for the trajectory from fig [ traj5 ] ( a ) @xmath158 , ( b ) @xmath162 .
black boxes show the sticky region.,width=377 ] the case @xmath169 has nine positive ftles . in this section
we analyze again the interval @xmath136 but with @xmath170 initial conditions only . , for @xmath169.,width=340 ] in fig .
[ mn10 ] the mean values for the ftles are plotted as a function of @xmath2 . for @xmath171
all mean ftles increase linearly and the largest ones increase faster .
for @xmath172 the @xmath2 dependence is different for different ftles . for @xmath110 almost all
( but two @xmath173 ) are very close to zero .
, ( b ) @xmath135 , ( c ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 as a function of @xmath136 , for @xmath174 and @xmath169.,title="fig:",width=340 ] , ( b ) @xmath135 , ( c ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 as a function of @xmath136 , for @xmath174 and @xmath169.,title="fig:",width=340 ] , ( b ) @xmath135 , ( c ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 as a function of @xmath136 , for @xmath174 and @xmath169.,title="fig:",width=340 ] , ( b ) @xmath135 , ( c ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 as a function of @xmath136 , for @xmath174 and @xmath169.,title="fig:",width=340 ] figure [ n10 ] compares ( a ) @xmath91 , ( b ) @xmath135 , ( c ) @xmath93 and ( d ) @xmath94 in the interval @xmath136 for all positive ftles ( @xmath174 ) . for @xmath175
all quantities indicate that the distributions from all ftles approach the normal form expected for a totally chaotic regime .
therefore , again we have a clear transition from quasi - regular to totally chaotic dynamics at @xmath176 which occurs _ simultaneously _ in all unstable directions .
for @xmath177 all quantities detect the sticky motion . also here
we observe that for @xmath2 above the critical value @xmath178 the four quantities behave similarly , independent of the ftles .
the distributions for all ftles have a small left asymmetry ( @xmath143 ) with no flatness ( @xmath144 ) at @xmath145 , and a left asymmetry ( @xmath146 ) with flatness ( @xmath147 ) at @xmath148 .
the critical value @xmath178 is again exactly the point where @xmath179 detects the sticky motion from the distribution of the last ( the _ smallest _ ) ftle [ see fig . [
n5](a ) ] .
it can be observed that the distribution of the largest ftle is the last ( when @xmath2 increases from @xmath180 ) to `` join '' the common behavior for @xmath181 [ please see fig .
[ n10](b)-(d ) ] .
the value @xmath152 can also be determined approximately from the region in fig .
[ mn10 ] where the @xmath2 dependence of the mean ftles is not linear .
figure [ traj10 ] shows the time evolution of @xmath153 ( @xmath182 ) for one exemplary trajectory in the three distinct regions of @xmath2 . in fig .
[ traj10](a ) with @xmath157 no sticky motion is observed since no ftle goes to zero for some shorter time intervals .
for the intermediate case @xmath158 we see in fig .
[ traj10](b ) the two different scenarios as conjectured . for times around @xmath183
( see arrow ) _ all _ nine ftles are close to zero indicating that the sticky motion occurs in all unstable directions . for times around @xmath184 ( see arrow ) on the other hand , eight ftles go to zero but the largest one remains positive .
( @xmath182 ) for one exemplary trajectory with @xmath169 and ( a ) @xmath157 , ( b ) @xmath158 , ( c ) @xmath162.,width=377 ] this behavior is observed even more clearly in the region @xmath154 , see fig .
[ traj10](c ) . for times in the interval @xmath185
to @xmath186 only @xmath88 is large and the remaining eight ftles are very close to zero .
it is well known that the dynamics of conservative systems consists of qualitatively different types of motion , from regular over quasi - regular to chaotic , depending on the perturbation parameter .
it is difficult to identify these types of motion in high - dimensional systems , especially in the quasi - regular regime where the sticky motion can suppress arnold diffusion and distinct stochastic regions with different properties may appear @xcite .
therefore , it is very desirable to develop tools which quantify the degree of sticky motion , hyperbolicity and ergodicity .
following ideas from @xcite the purpose of the present work is to quantify the degree of sticky motion in the phase space of higher - dimensional systems . to fulfill this task
we have systematically analyzed small changes in the ftle distributions using the skewness @xmath10 , which detects the asymmetry of the distribution , the kurtosis @xmath11 , which measures the flatness of the distribution and the normalized number of occurencies of the most probable finite time lyapunov exponent @xmath12 , which indicates to which extent all trajectories started are under the influence of the same ftle . using coupled conservative maps with nonlinearity parameter @xmath2
we show that the quantities @xmath187 and @xmath50 are very sensitive to detect the sticky motion and capable to characterize the dynamics when the dimension @xmath188 of the system increases ( @xmath189 ) .
simulations were realized up to times @xmath190 , which are large enough to detect the sticky motion but not too large to destroy the sticky effect on the distribution , which for infinite times should approach the @xmath16function .
this should be valid for not too small values of the nonlinearity @xmath2 .
for very small values of @xmath2 and higher dimensions , the large amount of invariant structures make trajectories stay almost all times at the sticky motion . in such cases it is hard to say what times should be used in general . besides detecting accurately all cases of sticky motion , we found the following additional interesting results : i ) ( @xmath191 ) the largest ftle is most sensitive to the sticky motion ; ii ) ( @xmath3 ) the smallest ftle defines the critical nonlinearity parameter @xmath152 , below which independent invariant regions in phase - space are expected and @xmath192 behaves nonlinearly .
for @xmath156 a clear transition from the quasiregular to the totally chaotic dynamics occurs _
simultaneously _ in all unstable directions . in the interval @xmath155 all quantities detect the presence of sticky motion and distributions for _ different _ ftles behave _ similarly _ , meaning that the sticky motion affects all unstable directions proportionally by the same amount and a kind of common behavior of the distributions is observed .
physically what happens is that the linear momentum of _ all _ sites is constant at the sticky motion .
close - to - zero ftles play also an important role in other higher - dimensional system , for example in connection to hydrodynamic modes @xcite ( among others ) and the analysis of hyperbolicity @xcite .
results of the present work contribute to categorize the rich and complicated quasiregular dynamics of higher - dimensional conservative systems and also to understand how nonlinearity is distributed along different unstable directions @xcite .
the authors thank finep ( under project ctinfra-1 ) for financial support . c.m .
also thanks cnpq for financial support and prof .
giulio casati for the hospitality by the center for nonlinear and complex systems at the universit dellinsubria where part of this work was done . | `` sticky '' motion in mixed phase space of high dimensional conservative systems is difficult to detect and to characterize .
its effect on quasi - regular motion is quantified here with four different measures , related to the distribution of the finite time lyapunov exponents .
we study systematically conservative maps from the uncoupled two - dimensional case up to coupled maps of dimension @xmath0 .
we find sticky motion in all unstable directions above a threshold @xmath1 of the nonlinearity parameter @xmath2 for the high dimensional cases @xmath3 .
moreover , as @xmath2 increases we can clearly identify the transition from quasiregular to totally chaotic motion which occurs simultaneously in all unstable directions .
results show that all four statistical measures sensitively probe sticky motion in high dimensional systems .
finite time lyapunov exponent distribution , stickiness , chaos , high dimensions |
we recently obtained a new hamiltonian for a lattice which includes interactions with internal nuclear degrees of freedom @xcite .
we started with a dirac model for electrons and for nucleons on equal footing , then allowed the nuclei to be described by a finite basis expansion , and finally developed an approximation appropriate for low nuclear velocity .
our original motivation for this was to obtain a model capable of describing the mass shift associated with excited nuclear states in a configuration interaction calculation .
however , the new model unexpectedly contains a new coupling term which provides for a direct interaction between lattice vibrations and nuclear transitions . on the face of it
, this new interaction term looks like it should allow for the strongly - coupled transitions that we have sought @xcite in connection with the generalized lossy spin - boson models @xcite that we proposed to account for some of the anomalies ( such as excess heat @xcite and collimated x - ray emission @xcite ) that have been reported in experiments in recent years .
what is needed at this point is an explicit calculation for some nuclear system to see how it works , what states are coupled to , and how big the interaction is . in general nuclear structure models
are much more complicated than atomic structure models due to the more complicated strong force interaction
. we would like to work with empirical strong force models derived from scattering experiments and few - body bound state binding energies . in recent years
these models have achieved impressive results @xcite ; however , some of these strong force models involve a fair amount of work to implement .
if we go back a few decades we can find simpler versions of strong force models that are easier to work with , and are sufficiently accurate to clarify the issues of interest here . in the computations that follow we will focus on the old hamada - johnston potential model @xcite . without question the simplest compound nucleus which should show the effects of interest is the deuteron , and so we will focus on this system in what follows . in this formulation
we have modeled the nucleons as elementary dirac particles .
as nucleons are made up of strongly interacting quarks , we know that they are not elementary dirac particles .
to do better in the case of coupling with the deuteron , we would require a description in terms of the six constituent quarks .
we would expect from such a model a coupling matrix element likely somewhat different from what we calculated in this work .
even so , it makes sense here to pursue this simpler deuteron model based on simple dirac nucleons as a step forward in the modeling process .
in a recent paper we discussed the derivation of a finite basis approximation for a moving nucleus in the many - particle dirac model which leads to the new coupling that we are interested in .
we begin with the ( relativistic ) finite basis model that we obtained . in @xcite
we developed finite basis eigenvalue relations in the form @xmath2 where the off - diagonal matrix elements were written as @xmath3 here @xmath4 is the relative coupling matrix element @xmath5 we defined @xmath6 as @xmath7 the notation for the two - body version of the problem is a bit different than what we used for the many - particle problem .
it is useful to recast the relative matrix element as @xmath8 the relative part of the off - diagonal matrix element corresponds to the rest frame interaction terms , which might come about from strong force interactions as in the development above for the nonrelativistic deuteron problem .
what is new is the coupling with the center of mass momentum @xmath9 that appears in @xmath10 .
we are interested in these new matrix elements .
in @xcite we discussed the reduction of the new interaction matrix element to the nonrelativistic case .
the results can be expressed as @xmath11 @xmath12 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_j \cdot c \hat{{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}}_j ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle\ ] ] @xmath13 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_j \cdot c \hat{\bf p } ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle \bigg ] \ ] ] as above , this is written for the many - particle problem , and we wish to recast it in terms of the two - body problem ; we may write @xmath14 @xmath15 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_1 \cdot c \hat{\bf p } ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle\ ] ] @xmath16 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_1 \cdot c \hat{\bf p } ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle \bigg ] \ ] ] @xmath17 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_2 \cdot c \hat{\bf p } ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle\ ] ] @xmath18 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_2 \cdot c \hat{\bf p } ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle \bigg ] \ ] ] it is possible to split up this new interaction term into a contribution that takes the nucleon masses to be equal , and a small correction term that depends on the difference between the nucleon masses . in what follows
our focus will be on the larger equal mass terms , which is equivalent to making an equal mass approximation . in this case
we may write @xmath19 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_1 \cdot c \hat{\bf p } ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ ] ] @xmath20 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_1 \cdot c \hat{\bf p } ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle \bigg ] \ ] ] @xmath21 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_2 \cdot c \hat{\bf p } ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle\ ] ] @xmath22 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}_2 \cdot c \hat{\bf p } ) \bigg | \phi_i \bigg \rangle \bigg ] \ ] ] where we have assumed that @xmath23 in this approximation there is no longer an explicit dependence on the state energy @xmath24 .
it is possible to develop a nonrelativistic approximation using @xmath25 in this case , a finite basis model that includes center of mass dynamics to lowest order could be developed starting from a nonrelativistic hamiltonian of the form @xmath26 where @xmath27 is an operator that returns the rest mass energy of the nuclear state , and where @xmath28 in the equal mass approximation is @xmath29 @xmath30\ ] ]
we know from the literature that the deuteron at rest can be modeled using a triplet s and triplet d state , since the tensor interaction mixes the two .
since the kinetic energy and potential terms preserve @xmath31 and @xmath32 , each of the triplet s states mixes with a triplet d state that has the same @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
the new interaction term causes these states to mix with singlet p states . in general
, the new term does not preserve @xmath32 , so that we would require a finite basis approximation that distinguishes the different sublevels .
however , it is possible to focus on a special case of the new interaction which does preserve @xmath32 .
this occurs if we restrict our attention to @xmath34 we find in this case that mixing occurs for @xmath35 , but not for @xmath36 . in response , we might write @xmath37 with the understanding that @xmath38 nuclear state construction is usually carried out in the isospin scheme , with antisymmetry enforced through the application of the generalized pauli principle .
the two - body problem is particularly simple in this regard , with spin , isospin and spatial components restricted to being either symmetric @xmath39 or antisymmetric @xmath40 ; we may write for the three states @xmath41 @xmath42 @xmath43 the antisymmetric spin and isospin terms @xmath44 and @xmath45 are singlets , and the symmetric spin and isospin terms @xmath46 and @xmath47 are triplets . the s state is a triplet spin state , so we may write it as @xmath48 @xmath49 the @xmath50 are spherical harmonics ; we choose @xmath51 and @xmath52 since we are working with an s state .
the @xmath53 are spin functions for the neutron and proton spins ; the @xmath54 are isospin functions , and we have used an isospin singlet function here . we can develop a d state by applying the tensor @xmath55 operator on an s state .
this approach was used early on as a convenient way of generating few - body wavefunctions for variational calculations in nuclear physics .
we may write @xmath56\ ] ] this construction is convenient since @xmath57 - 2 \psi_{^3d}\ ] ] the singlet p state for a particular calculation can be specified using @xmath58 @xmath59 including an @xmath60 here leads to real coupling coefficients in what follows .
we can evaluate the normalization integral for these states simply ; we write @xmath61 @xmath62 we are interested in developing coupled channel equations that include the new interaction . for the problem in the rest frame , this is most easily accomplished by developing an expression for the total energy and then using the variational principle .
we can use the same basic approach here for the moving frame version of the problem .
we begin with @xmath63 @xmath64 @xmath65 @xmath66 we can evaluate the diagonal matrix elements directly using mathematica to obtain @xmath67 u(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath68 v(r)dr\ ] ] @xmath69 w(r ) dr\ ] ] in the case of the hamada - johnston potential , there occur off - diagonal matrix elements between the triplet s and singlet d states , which are given by @xmath70 the superscript @xmath71 in the associated potentials here is connected with the even triplet channel , since the hamada - johnston potentials are fit for the different channels separately . for the off - diagonal matrix elements of the new interaction , we have used mathematica to compute @xmath72 @xmath73 u(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath74 dr\ ] ] @xmath75 u(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath76 dr\ ] ] @xmath77 dr \bigg \rbrace\ ] ] @xmath78 @xmath79 v(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath80 dr\ ] ] @xmath81 v(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath82 dr\ ] ] @xmath83 v(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath84 dr\ ] ] @xmath85 v(r ) dr \bigg \rbrace\ ] ] @xmath86 @xmath87 w(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath88 dr\ ] ] @xmath89 w(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath90 dr\ ] ] @xmath91 w(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath92 dr\ ] ] @xmath93 w(r ) dr \bigg \rbrace\ ] ] @xmath94 @xmath95 2(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath96 dr\ ] ] @xmath97 w(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath98 dr\ ] ] @xmath99 v(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath100 dr\ ] ] @xmath101 v(r ) dr \bigg \rbrace\ ] ]
we have specified a finite basis problem with three channels , which would produce three complicated coupled - channeled equations if we decided to treat the different basis states on equal footing . however
, since the momentum @xmath9 that we are interested in for applications of this model is small , the triplet s and d channels are then best considered to constitute the unperturbed deuteron problem , and the singlet p channel will contain the weak response of the deuteron to the @xmath102 perturbation . in this case , it seems appropriate to develop the coupled triplet s and d channels consistent with the rest frame deuteron problem .
once the associated wavefunctions are known , then we can use them to approximate the occupation of the singlet p channel . given the approach outlined above
, we can optimize the channel wavefunctions @xmath103 and @xmath104 by minimizing the rest frame energy @xmath105 @xmath106 u(r ) dr\ ] ] @xmath107 v(r)dr\ ] ] @xmath108 the minimization of this rest frame energy leads to the constraints @xmath109 u(r ) + \bigg [ - 3\sqrt{8 } v_{t}^{et}(r ) \bigg ] v(r)\ ] ] @xmath110 v(r)\ ] ] @xmath111 u(r)\ ] ] where @xmath112 is the relative energy .
we recognize these as the rarita - schwinger equations based on the hamada - johnston potential model .
we have solved the rarita - schwinger equations to obtain the channel wavefunctions plotted in figure [ deuteron1 ] .
the triplet s channel wavefunction @xmath103 is larger and extends out to a relatively large radial separation , and the triplet d channel wavefunction @xmath104 is smaller and localized to much smaller radial separation .
we can see the effect of the hard core potential in the zero boundary condition at the cut off radius .
= 4.00 in = 3.200 in [ t ] in the perturbation theory approach outlined above , we can approximate the occupation of the singlet p channel in terms of known triple s and d channel wavefunctions .
the associated constraint on the channel wavefunction can be written as @xmath113 w(r ) ~=~ m_j \left ( { 1 \over 2 mc^2 } \right ) \left ( { 1 \over 2 m_{av } c^2 } \right ) ( \hbar c ) ( c \hat{p}_z ) \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ ] ] @xmath114 u(r ) + 12 \sqrt{3 } v_t^{et}(r ) \left [ { d \over dr } u(r ) + { u(r ) \over r } \right ] + 8 \sqrt{3 } \left [ { d \over dr } v_t^{et}(r ) \right ] u(r)\ ] ] @xmath115 - 2 \sqrt{3 } v_{ll}^{et}(r ) \left [ { d \over dr } u(r ) - { u(r ) \over r } \right ] \bigg \rbrace\ ] ] @xmath116 v(r)\ ] ] @xmath117 + 4 \sqrt{6 } \left [ { d \over dr } v_t^{et}(r ) \right ] v(r ) - \sqrt{8 \over 3 } v_{ls}^{et}(r ) \left [ { d \over dr } v(r ) + 2{v(r ) \over r } \right ] \ ] ] @xmath118 v(r ) - 2 \sqrt{6 } v_{ll}^{et}(r ) \left [ { d \over dr } v(r ) + 2{v(r ) \over r } \right ] - \sqrt{6 } \left [ { d \over dr } v_{ll}^{et}(r ) \right ] v(r ) \bigg \rbrace\ ] ] we have solved this equation numerically assuming that @xmath103 and @xmath104 are fixed solutions of the rarita - schwinger equations , and the resulting normalized solution for @xmath119 is shown in figure [ singletp ] .
= 4.00 in = 3.200 in [ t ] from the computation outlined above we can derive an equivalent two - level system model in the form @xmath120 we compute @xmath121 @xmath122 @xmath123 the off - diagonal coupling matrix elements are somewhat smaller than we were hoping for , and future work will be needed to understand if this coupling is sufficiently large to account for experimental results .
in addition , we have found that these off - diagonal matrix element depend on the nuclear spin , which suggests that the system may respond to net spin alignment .
we recently proposed a new fundamental hamiltonian for condensed matter lattice problems that includes coupling to nuclear internal degrees of freedom . from our perspective
this new coupling seems to be what is needed to account for the excess heat effect in the fleischmann - pons experiment . what has been needed in order to evaluate the models
that result is an estimate for the coupling matrix element .
the development of an estimate for this matrix element is challenging for a variety of reasons .
we have presumed in the derivation of the fundamental hamiltonian that it is sufficient to model the nucleons as elementary dirac particles .
however , we know that nucleons are composite particles made up of quarks and gluons , and that it is unlikely that using a dirac model as we have done is going to give accurate results . to do better we probably need to go back and develop a better fundamental hamiltonian based on quarks and electrons . if it is possible to obtain reasonable nucleon models from empirical potentials , then we may be able to develop a better estimate for the deuteron coupling matrix element .
working directly with bound state qcd at this stage does not seem to be an attractive option .
once we have decided on the simpler model that adopts an elementary dirac particle model for nucleons , then it is an issue of whether to use a relativistic or nonrelativistic model , and further it is an issue of what potential to use .
since these computations involve a fair amount of work , it seemed sensible to adopt a nonrelativistic model since it is simpler , and to work with an older relatively simple nuclear model .
the hamada - johnston potential fits the bill in this regard , as it is sufficiently simple that we are able to complete a calculation in relatively short order .
perhaps the most work in this computation was the evaluation of the spin , isospin , and angular momentum algebra ; for this we relied on brute force mathematica calculations . in the end , we have developed a model for the coupling between the different nuclear spin states of the ground state deuteron and lattice - induced coupling to a highly - excited singlet p virtual state .
the energy of this virtual state is about 125 mev in this model , which is consistent with our expectations .
the coupling matrix element fell short of what we had hoped for by about an order of magnitude .
we will need to clarify in future calculations if this is sufficiently large to be relevant to experimental results .
the coupling matrix element in this model is proportional to @xmath32 , which is interesting in connection with the reported dependence of excess heat on the strength of an applied magnetic field .
since the matrix element is proportional to @xmath32 , there is the potential for a larger coupling if the deuteron spins can be aligned .
we are interested in pursuing this possibility in future work .
0 a. b. karabut and s. a. kolomeychenko , `` experiments characterizing the x - ray emission from a solid - state cathode using a high - current glow discharge , '' _ condensed matter nuclear science , proc .
iccf10 _ , edited by p. l. hagelstein and s. r. chubb , p. 585
( 2003 ) .
a. b. karabut , `` research into characteristics of x - ray emission laser beams from solid state cathode medium of high - current glow discharge , '' _ condensed matter nuclear science , proc .
iccf11 _ , edited by j. p. biberian , p. 253
( 2004 ) .
a. b. karabut , `` study of energetic and temporal characteristics of x - ray emission from solid state cathode medium of high - current glow discharge , '' _ condensed matter nuclear science , proc .
iccf12 _ , edited by a. takahashi , k .-
ota , and y. iwamura , p. 344
( 2005 ) .
a. b. karabut , e. a. karabut , p. l. hagelstein , `` spectral and temporal characteristics of x - ray emission from metal electrodes in a high - current glow discharge , '' _ j. cond . mat .
( in press ) .
h. kamada , a. nogga , w. glckle , e. hiyama , m. kamimura , k. varga , y. suzuki , m. viviani , a. kievsky , and s. rosati , `` benchmark test calculation of a four - nucleon bound state , '' _ phys .
c _ * 64 * ( 2001 ) 044001 . | we recently put forth a new fundamental lattice hamiltonian based on an underlying picture of electrons and deuterons as elementary dirac particles . within this model
there appears a term in which lattice vibrations are coupled to internal nuclear transitions .
this is interesting as it has the potential to provide a connection between experiment and models that describe coherent energy transfer between two - level systems and an oscillator . in this work
we describe a calculation of the coupling matrix element in the case of the deuteron based on the old empirical hamada - johnston model for the nucleon - nucleon interaction .
the triplet s and d states of the the deuteron in the rest frame couples to a singlet p state through this new interaction .
the singlet p state in this calculation is a virtual state with an energy of 125 mev , and a coupling matrix element for @xmath0-directed motion given by @xmath1 . |
diffuse radio emission without an apparent host galaxy is found in an increasing number of clusters of galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these objects can roughly be divided into radio halos close to the cluster centre which appear comparatively smooth in radio images and radio relics with a far more distorted and knotty appearance .
the latter are usually found further away from the central regions @xcite .
here we concentrate on radio relic sources .
a large number of possible explanations for radio relics has been proposed .
all of these aim at explaining the production of a population of relativistic electrons responsible for the observed radio synchrotron emission .
the suggested mechanisms range from the turbulent wakes of galaxies moving in the cluster s gravitational potential to cluster mergers . in the present paper we concentrate on the picture of relics as remnants of once powerful radio galaxies or radio - loud quasars .
this scenario is based on the idea that the relics are the lobes of former radio galaxies , the jets of which ceased to supply them with energy some time ago ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the relativistic electrons , the emission of which we observe today , were accelerated at the strong shocks at the ends of the active jets .
the electrons lose their energy due to synchrotron losses , inverse compton scattering of cosmic microwave background photons and , possibly , further adiabatic expansion of the relics themselves . as the relativistic electrons are not replenished by the active jets ,
the radiative energy losses introduce a spectral cut - off moving towards low frequencies in time .
this can potentially explain the observed steep radio spectra of relics .
note however that not all relics may be consistent with the picture of the passively fading remnant of a radio galaxy .
some relics are extended and show a rather smooth structure resembling in some ways the appearance of radio haloes , while others are composed of a number of individual knots .
the variety of morphologies different from the appearance of active radio galaxies may very well indicate that our interpretation of relics as the remnants of radio galaxies is incorrect in many cases . however , it is not clear what the fate of the material forming the large scale radio structure of a formerly active radio galaxy is .
buoyant rise in the gravitational potential well of the cluster will certainly play a role ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , but the movement of the parent galaxy through the cluster gas and cluster mergers may fragment the remnant as well .
it is therefore not surprising that the morphology of relics is seldomly reminiscent of active radio galaxies . even if all relics were indeed , as we assume here , the remnants of radio galaxies , the evolution of the remnant may imply significant departures from the simple pressure evolution envisaged in the model introduced here . another problem is the possibility of re - acceleration of the relativistic electrons even after the jets have switched off .
@xcite present radio observations of the relics in a13 , a85 , a133 and a4038 .
the substantial substructure in these sources may well be the signature of some highly dynamic processes being at work which could lead to further acceleration of relativistic particles . in this paper
we will neglect any re - acceleration processes which may take place in relics .
the question then is whether or not a passively evolving population of relativistic electrons produces a radio spectrum consistent with observations .
the main problem is that the radio spectra of relics are shallow at around 100mhz and considerably steeper in the ghz ; but they do not show exponential cut - offs .
the spectra are therefore not consistent with a single population of electrons accelerated all at the same time and passively losing their energy . taking this extended injection period into account
, @xcite showed that two breaks appear in the spectrum .
the lower break is located at the frequency cut - off of the ` oldest ' electrons while the higher break is determined by the ` youngest ' electrons .
the comparatively mild steepening of the spectra between the breaks is roughly consistent with the observations .
nevertheless , @xcite found that for effective pitch - angle scattering of the relativistic electrons the steepening of the spectrum was still too strong .
therefore they had to suppress pitch - angle scattering to further flatten their model spectra .
the exponential cut - off in the spectrum is also avoided in the case of inhomogeneous magnetic field strengths inside the relic .
the relativistic electrons spend most of their time in the low - field regions and only occasionally diffuse into the high - field regions . thus their energy losses are reduced and by careful adjustment of the efficiency of the diffusion process an emission spectrum with mild steepening at high frequencies can be achieved @xcite .
@xcite fitted a model based on this idea to the spectra of relic sources and found good agreement .
@xcite assumed that the relics or their progenitors were in pressure equilibrium with their surroundings even at the time of the injection of relativistic electrons .
in this paper we expand this model by taking into account the evolution of the lobes during the injection of relativistic particles .
if the lobes of radio galaxies of type frii @xcite are the progenitors of the radio relics , then during the time the jets are still active , the lobes are expanding into the surrounding material .
this implies that the pressure inside the lobes and therefore also the strength of the magnetic field are not constant during the particle injection .
in fact , the strength of the magnetic field is decreasing and thus relativistic electrons injected at later times can survive for longer . we show that this effect results in radio spectra of the resulting relic sources without exponential cut - offs and a spectral slope comparable to that in observed relics . at the time the jets switch off , the lobes may still be overpressured with respect to the ambient gas and therefore continue to expand .
we derive expressions for the temporal behaviour of the volume and the pressure of such ` coasting ' relics .
we take such a coasting phase into account in our calculation of model radio spectra from relic sources .
finally , we show that our models fit the observed spectra very well .
unfortunately , we find that none of the important source parameters , like the source age , or the physical processes taking place in the relics can be determined from the radio spectra alone . in section [ sec :
spherical ] we derive the temporal behaviour of a coasting relic source after the jets have switched off .
we use the results found to calculate the radio spectra of relic sources in section [ sec : radio ] . here
we also show how the variation of the main model parameters influences the results . in section
[ sec : compa ] we fit the observed spectra of relic sources with our model and show that very little useful information about the conditions in the sources and their environments can be gained from the models .
we summarise our results in section [ sec : conc ] .
after the jets of a powerful radio sources switch off , the cocoon inflated during the active phase may still be overpressured with respect to the external medium .
it will then enter the ` coasting phase ' while continuing to expand behind a strong bow shock .
this situation is somewhat reminiscent of the early evolution of a supernova remnant or the explosion of a nuclear weapon .
the dynamics of a strong explosion in a uniform atmosphere are described by the similarity solution of taylor and sedov ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
it is straightforward to generalise this solution for the case of a power - law density distribution in the external medium with @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the scale height or core radius of the distribution .
we will assume this density distribution for all model calculations in this paper .
the radius of the spherical bow shock then grows as @xmath2 . despite the fact that the cocoons of radio galaxies are usually not spherical
, one might expect that their expansion during the coasting phase is governed by the same proportionality once the jet activity has ceased .
however , in the following we will show that the presence of the contact discontinuity defining the cocoon boundary in radio galaxies requires a different dynamical behaviour .
@xcite present a different solution to this problem based on their assumption that the dynamics of the radio source expansion are not influenced by the mass of the external gas swept up by the bow shock .
the dynamical behaviour of active radio sources strongly suggests that their cocoons are underdense with respect to the external medium ( e.g. * ? ? ?
therefore it is very unlikely that this assumption can be made for the problem considered here .
for simplicity we will assume that the bow shock and the cocoon are both spherical .
in practice both are elongated along the jet axis but this different geometry results only in a change of the constants of proportionality .
the dynamical behaviour , i.e. the time dependence of the physical parameters of the flow , will be the same .
the cocoon volume is then given by @xmath3 and that of the layer of shocked gas in between the bow shock and the cocoon is @xmath4 .
furthermore , we also assume that the pressure , @xmath5 , inside the cocoon and in the shocked layer surrounding it , is uniform . again
, this greatly simplifies the problem and will not change our results apart from the exact numerical values of the normalisations . during the active phase , while the jets are still switched on , conservation of energy for the gas inside @xmath6 requires @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the adiabatic index of the cocoon material and @xmath9 is the energy transport rate of the jets .
we will keep @xmath9 constant during the lifetime of the jets at the end of which it drops to zero instantaneously .
similarly , for the shocked gas inside @xmath10 we find @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the adiabatic index of the shocked material .
the expression on the right of equation ( [ shock ] ) is the rate at which kinetic energy flows into the bow shock ( see * ? ? ?
* ) . finally , since we consider only strong shocks , the pressure within the source is balanced by the ram pressure of the external medium , @xmath13 equations ( [ cocoon ] ) through ( [ ram ] ) are identical to the system of equations studied by @xcite for the case of intermittent jet sources .
we are interested in steady - state similarity solutions for this set of equations with the three unknown functions @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath5 being power laws of time .
we find @xmath16 ^{1/3 } \left ( \frac { q_{\rm j } t^3}{\rho _ 0 a_0^{\beta } } \right ) ^{1/\left ( 5 - \beta \right ) } \nonumber\\ r_{\rm s } & = & \left ( k \frac{q_{\rm j}t^3}{\rho _ 0 a_0^{\beta } } \right ) ^{1/\left ( 5 -\beta \right ) } \label{active } \\ p & = & \frac{9}{\left ( 5 - \beta \right ) ^2 } \left [ k ^{2-\beta } q_{\rm j } ^{2-\beta } \left ( \rho _ 0 a_0^{\beta } \right ) ^3 t^{-4-\beta } \right]^{1/ \left ( 5 - \beta \right ) } \nonumber,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath17 the exponents of the time variable in these equations are equal to those found by @xcite and @xcite for sources with active jets . after the jets cease to supply energy to the cocoon , the source enters the coasting phase and we have to set @xmath18 .
we assume that the cocoon stays overpressured with respect to the surrounding medium . in this case ,
equation ( [ cocoon ] ) describes the now adiabatic expansion of the cocoon , i.e. @xmath19 . with this , equations ( [ shock ] ) and ( [ ram ] ) in principle again yield power - law similarity solutions with @xmath20 .
note that this is different from the taylor - sedov solution .
this difference is caused by the adiabatic behaviour of the cocoon driving the bow shock for which there is no analogon in the case of a strong explosion .
the ratio of the radius of the spherical cocoon and the bow shock is given by @xmath21 ^{1/3}.\ ] ] obviously , this solution can not be correct for @xmath22 or @xmath23 which includes the case of a relativistic cocoon ( @xmath24 ) surrounded by ` cold ' material ( @xmath25 ) .
nevertheless , we will see in section [ sec : num ] that in the latter scenario the steady - state solution is an excellent approximation to the evolution of @xmath14 . for @xmath22
all terms containing @xmath14 in equation ( [ shock ] ) cancel and a different steady - state solution is possible with @xmath26 this implies that the ratio @xmath27 is no longer a constant . despite this , the expansion of the bow shock and that of the cocoon are still intrinsically self - similar . all of the solutions derived in the previous section describe steady - state configurations . to assess how quickly a spherical radio source would change from one of these states to another when the jets are switched off , we also integrated the equations ( [ cocoon ] ) to ( [ ram ] ) numerically .
for this we set @xmath28ergss@xmath29 , @xmath30g@xmath31 , @xmath32pc and @xmath33 .
the same values were used by @xcite and they imply that @xmath34g@xmath35 . at a source lifetime of @xmath36years , we ` switched off ' the jets by setting @xmath37 . for the integration we used a standard runge - kutta algorithm .
the initial conditions were derived from equations ( [ active ] ) . .
upper panel , solid lines : numerical results for @xmath14 ( lower line ) and @xmath15 ( upper line ) ; short dashed lines : analytical solution for active jets ; long dashed lines : analytical solutions for ` coasting phase ' .
lower panel : analytical solutions divided by numerical solutions . dashed line : ratio for @xmath14 , solid line : ratio for @xmath15.,width=319 ] figure [ fig : same ] shows the results of this numerical integration for the radius of the bow shock , @xmath15 , and that of the cocoon , @xmath14 for the case @xmath38 .
the analytical solutions for the still active jets are calculated from equations ( [ active ] ) .
for the coasting phase we used equations ( [ same ] ) .
here we are free to choose the normalisation of the analytical solutions as these are not constrained by the equations .
we have chosen the normalisation such that the analytical solution agrees with the numerical results at @xmath39years .
the lower panel of figure [ fig : same ] shows the ratio of the analytical solutions and the numerical results .
we have used the analytical solutions for the active phase for times less than @xmath36years and those for the coasting phase for later times .
the discrepancy between the two solutions is always less than 20% . but with @xmath40 and @xmath25.,width=319 ] figure [ fig : dif ] compares the numerical results for the case @xmath24 and @xmath25 with the steady - state similarity solutions .
as expected , the agreement is worse .
particularly the radius of the bow shock grows more quickly than predicted by the power - law solution .
however , the radius of the cocoon is still well described by the steady - state solution . the disagreement between the numerical integration and the analytical power - law is comparable for this case to that for @xmath22 .
we therefore conclude that the dynamical behaviour of the cocoon of a spherical radio source adjusts quickly to the cessation of the energy supply by the jets .
the cocoons of radio sources are elongated along the jet axis .
because of the different external density the various source parts are immersed in , this deviation from purely spherical shape may lead to a different dynamical behaviour at the tip of the cocoon compared to its base . in steady - state
this adds only numerical factors to the solutions discussed above .
however , it may prolong the transition to the coasting phase at the end of the lifetime of the jets . to investigate this possibility ,
fully 3-dimensional simulations of radio sources making the transition from active to coasting are needed ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . to date the evidence from these simulations is somewhat inconclusive
nevertheless , it is unlikely that the geometrical shape of the radio source strongly influences its evolutionary behaviour .
so far we have implicitly assumed that the information that the jets have ceased to supply energy to the cocoon propagates instantaneously through the whole cocoon . this is a good approximation
if the cocoon is small and the internal sound speed is very high .
@xcite show that in the absence of significant mixing of the cocoon material with the surrounding gas across the cocoon boundary the internal sound speed is indeed high . in cases where mixing is important
, the sound travel time along the cocoon may become comparable to or even exceed the dynamical timescale .
most of the cocoon will then continue for a significant time to expand as if it was still in the active phase ( e.g. * ? ? ?
in any scenario the pressure in the cocoon will eventually become comparable to the thermal pressure of the surrounding gas . at this point , the expansion will slow down and the bow shock weakens .
once pressure equilibrium is reached , the expansion stops altogether and the pressure does not change anymore . when exactly this happens depends on the temperature of the external gas . again
the transition of the cocoon from expansion to pressure equilibrium will be a gradual process with those regions of the cocoon close to the centre of the density distribution coming into pressure equilibrium first ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . even in this
equilibrium phase the cocoon will not be static .
as it is underdense with respect to the surrounding gas it will start rising due to buoyancy ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and the pressure inside the cocoon is decreasing .
however , the timescale for this rise usually exceeds the lifetime of the relativistic electrons .
the equilibrium phase was also considered by @xcite . for simplicity
we study in this paper the case of a radio source which comes into pressure equilibrium with its surroundings at the same time as the jets switch off .
we will also assume that the transition is instantaneous and that the pressure within the cocoon is uniform . in the following study of the radio emission from coasting or equilibrium radio sources we will concentrate on three limiting cases .
in each case the jets stop to supply energy to the cocoon at time @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the time of observation . 1 .
the internal sound speed is slow and so the cocoon continues to evolve as if the jets were still supplying it with energy , i.e. @xmath43 and @xmath44 even for @xmath45 .
2 . the internal sound speed is fast and so the cocoon immediately changes from the active phase to the coasting phase , i.e. for @xmath46 and @xmath45 we use equations ( [ same ] ) .
the source is in pressure equilibrium with its surroundings from the time @xmath47 . in this case @xmath14 and @xmath5 are both constants between @xmath47 and @xmath42 .
the relativistic electrons responsible for the emission of radio synchrotron emission are accelerated by the shocks at the end of the active jets and injected into the cocoon .
they subsequently loose their energy due to adiabatic expansion of the cocoon , synchrotron radiation and inverse compton scattering of cmb photons .
all these processes are cumulative and so relativistic electrons injected into the cocoon later may still radiate while material injected earlier may have faded already .
the model of @xcite for active sources allows to track the evolution of the energy distribution of the relativistic electrons injected at a given time @xmath48 .
the total radio spectrum is then found by integrating up the contributions of all electrons injected into the cocoon between @xmath49 and @xmath50 , where @xmath42 is the current age of the source . in the following we will use this model with the modifications detailed in @xcite also for the calculation of the emission of sources in the coasting phase .
the model employed relies on all relevant physical quantities having power - law dependencies on time .
we have seen in the previous sections that this is , at least approximately , the case for the coasting phase .
we find the total radio emission of the cocoon for model a by simply setting the upper limit of the integration over @xmath48 to @xmath41 at which the jets switched off .
in addition , for models b and c we have to slightly modify the basic approach of @xcite .
the relativistic electrons injected into the cocoon at time @xmath48 during a short time interval @xmath51 are contained in a volume @xmath52 . to determine the radio synchrotron emission from @xmath52 , we need to know the energy distribution of the relativistic electrons and the energy density of the magnetic field inside @xmath52 .
these are completely determined by the evolution of @xmath52 and the pressure , @xmath5 , as functions of time .
defining @xmath53 and @xmath54 , yields for model b at @xmath55 @xmath56 where we have assumed that each volume element @xmath57 undergoes adiabatic expansion with @xmath58 .
this follows naturally as the sum of all volume elements @xmath52 must be equal to the total volume of the cocoon .
the time dependencies are then given by equations ( [ same ] ) .
obviously , for model c we have @xmath59 and @xmath60 for all times @xmath55 . with this
it is now straightforward to compute the synchrotron emission of each @xmath52 and numerically integrate over the injection time @xmath48 as described in @xcite .
@xcite assume efficient pitch - angle scattering for the relativistic electrons moving in the magnetic field .
this is usually referred to as jp - type models @xcite . for inefficient scattering ,
the electrons with large pitch - angles , @xmath61 , loose their energy faster than those with small @xmath61 ( kp - type models : * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
it is straightforward to modify the present model to account for negligible pitch - angle scattering by assuming a uniform pitch - angle distribution and the introduction of one further integral over @xmath61 .
we calculate the radio emission from all models with and without pitch - angle scattering .
the model for the radio emission depends on the following parameters ( see also * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) : @xmath42 the current age of the source , @xmath47 the time at which the jets switched off , @xmath62 , the pressure in the cocoon at @xmath47 , @xmath63 , the aspect ratio of the cocoon , @xmath64 , the exponent of the initial power - law energy distribution of the relativistic electrons , @xmath65 , the high energy cut - off of this distribution , @xmath66 , the exponent of the density distribution of the external medium and , @xmath67 , the cosmological redshift of the source .
@xcite shows that most of these parameters are degenerate in the sense that their values do not determine the shape of the radio spectrum in a unique way .
we therefore concentrate on the effects of changing @xmath62 , @xmath42 and @xmath47 and keep all other parameters fixed at their fiducial values given in table [ tab : fiducial ] .
we also assume that , at least at the time of injection into the cocoon , the magnetic field is in equipartition with the relativistic particles in each @xmath52 .
we neglect any contribution to the cocoon pressure from non - radiating particles , i.e. thermal electrons or protons . with these assumptions and free parameters a model spectrum
is completely determined except for a multiplicative normalisation constant , @xmath68 .
for the fiducial model we set @xmath69 . from @xmath62 , @xmath47 and @xmath68
it is possible to infer the energy transport rate of the jets , @xmath9 , and @xmath70 , which describes the density distribution of the gas surrounding the source ( see * ? ? ?
* for details ) .
.model parameters for the fiducial model ( see text ) .
[ cols="<,^,^ " , ] [ tab : paras ] the best - fitting model parameters are summarised in table [ tab : paras ] and the resulting spectra are plotted in figures [ fig : mol0100 ] through [ fig:3c464 ] . in practically all cases the best - fitting spectra from the various models
are almost indistinguishable from each other . in the following
we briefly discuss the results for each source individually . _
mol 0100 - 221 _ : the spectrum is well fitted by all models ( reduced @xmath71 between 0.99 and 1.03 ) .
the jp and kp - type models give somewhat different results for the free model parameters .
however , within each family of models they are roughly consistent with each other .
this indicates that the shape of the spectrum is mainly determined during the active phase of the source .
the exact behaviour of the cocoon in the subsequent coasting phase has little influence .
the jp - type models prefer older ages , higher jet powers and less dense environments compared to the kp - type models .
kp - type models are marginally preferred over jp - type models . _
cul 0038 - 096 _ : both variants of the source spectrum can be successfully fitted by the models .
however , the goodness of fit and the values of the free parameters vary significantly for each variant .
the best fit achieved has a reduced @xmath71-value of only 0.3 , but predicts a very low density of the external gas .
three of the bets - fitting models ( a@xmath72 for variant a , a@xmath72 and b@xmath72 for variant b ) have ages very close to the maximum age , @xmath73years , allowed for the fit . at least for models
a and b the jp - type and kp - type models give similar results , but models c are quite different from these .
the spectrum of this source can be fitted reasonably well with all the models discussed here . however , a clear trend for the model parameters is not apparent . _
4c 38.39 _ : for this source models with high external densities are clearly preferred . however , the spread in the value of @xmath74 is considerable .
there is also no agreement between the models with respect to the source age . from figure [ fig:4c38 ]
it seems that the rather flat spectral break at high frequencies causes problems for all models .
again there is no discernible trend in the best - fitting parameters . _
4c 63.10 _ : the spectrum of this source is fitted about equally well by all models . in terms of the jet power ,
@xmath75 , and the external density parameter , @xmath70 , jp and kp - type models agree well with each other for models a and b , but there is a large range for the predicted source age .
models c require a somewhat lower density and they predict very low source ages . _
3c 318.1 _ : the model fits to the spectrum are very good with a reduced @xmath71 of around 0.12 .
values for @xmath9 and @xmath70 are similar for all models but again for this source there is a large spread for the source age . _
3c 464 _ : except for model a@xmath76 , all models predict rather low source ages .
the best fits are achieved by both models c with rather high external densities .
the predicted values of @xmath9 are fairly uniform but the external density vary strongly between models . _ 1253 + 275 _ : the model parameters agree with each other for kp - type and jp - type models . however , the parameters are inconsistent between the two groups .
the kp - type models prefer a young source age with virtually no influence of the phase in the source evolution when the jets are switched off .
the predicted densities and pressures are very high . in the absence of radiative energy losses
, our choice of @xmath77 for the power law exponent of the energy distribution of the relativistic electrons at injection time , implies a spectral index of about @xmath78 .
the observed spectrum of 1253 + 275 shows a spectral index of around @xmath79 with no spectral break .
the in general flatter spectra resulting from the kp - type models do not fit this steep spectrum well .
therefore , the model requires high external densities causing high pressure inside the lobes which subsequently show substantial energy losses and steeper spectra .
the predictions of the jp - type model for an old source with moderate pressure values are more realistic .
the low jet powers predicted by all models are caused by the substantially lower radio flux of this relic compared to the other sources .
we have developed a model for the evolution of the lobes of radio galaxies and radio - loud quasars of type frii after the jets of the central agn have stopped supplying them with energy . in the case that the lobes are still overpressured with respect to their surroundings , we show that their volume is proportional to @xmath80 the proportionality given above for @xmath81 is , strictly speaking , not a solution of the equations governing the hydrodynamics .
however , we have shown that is provides an excellent fit for the numerically found correct solution .
the numerical calculations also show that the transition from the active phase with jets to the coasting phase without jets is fast .
we identify the lobes in the coasting phase with radio relic sources .
the calculated model spectra depend only on a small number of source and environment parameters : the total age of the source , @xmath42 , the age of the source when the jets were switched off , @xmath47 , and the pressure inside the lobes at that time , @xmath62 .
we consider three limiting cases for the lobe evolution : the lobes continue to expand as if the jets were still supplying energy ( model a ) , the lobes continue to expand but with the modified dynamics found for the coasting phase and summarised above ( model b ) and the lobes come into pressure equilibrium at the time the jets switch off and stop expanding ( model c ) .
we also investigate the effects of efficient pitch - angle scattering ( jp - type models ) and its absence ( kp - type models ) .
all our models can provide satisfactory to excellent fits to the observed spectra of radio relics .
taking into account the evolution of the strength of the magnetic field inside the lobe during the injection of relativistic electrons flattens the spectra sufficiently to explain the observations .
thus we can not rule out efficient pitch - angle scattering as suggested by @xcite .
unfortunately , the good fits provided by all models also imply that the radio spectra of relic sources alone do not constrain any of the important source or environment parameters .
the situation is aggravated by the findings of @xcite that the spectra can also be fitted using the alternative assumption of inhomogeneous magnetic fields inside the relics .
furthermore , even the inactive lobes may be re - ignited by compression during cluster mergers @xcite .
note here that the model of @xcite for radio relics does not require the radio plasma to originate in a powerful frii - type radio galaxy .
the morphologies of radio relics are very varied and only rarely resemble the well - defined lobes of active radio galaxies .
this strongly suggests that fluid flows in the clusters significantly influence the evolution of radio galaxy remnants . any re - acceleration or energisation due to compression
would make it even more difficult to determine the original conditions in the relic .
a possible solution could be the combination of radio spectra with x - ray observations of sufficient spatial resolution to identify inverse compton scattered photons originating in the relativistic plasma of the relics .
the x - ray observations could then be used to estimate the electron density while the radio emission would constrain the strength of the magnetic field . despite the problems , it is interesting to note that our simple models can fit the radio spectra of all relic sources studied here .
this includes the clearly curved spectrum of cul 0038 - 096 , a relic with substantial substructure , as well as the spectrum of 1253 + 275 without any significant spectral break and a comparatively smooth appearance .
this would imply that , whatever the history of the relic source , even a rather simplistic model can explain the observed spectra in a variety of different ways thus making it impossible to constrain the conditions within the relic sources .
we can not rule out a complex history or re - acceleration of relativistic electrons influencing the properties of the relic sources .
however , in the light of our results , such more complicated models are not required to fit the available radio data .
the degeneracy of model parameters can , however , also be turned to advantage in the case of statistical studies of the radio source population . for example
, we can use the known radio luminosity function of active frii objects and make predictions for the cosmological distribution of their remnants .
because of the mentioned degeneracy , these predictions will be almost model - independent .
such statistical studies can be used to predict the detection rate of radio galaxy remnants in low frequency radio surveys with high surface brightness sensitivity ( cotter & kaiser , in preparation ) .
in fact , it is not yet clear whether radio relic sources are actually the remains of the lobes of powerful radio galaxies .
deep observations of radio galaxies in which the jet flows have stopped comparatively recently are necessary to decide whether the conditions inside their lobes point towards them evolving into relics ( e.g. * ? ? ?
clearly , the radio relic sources continue to challenge our understanding of the physics of radio galaxies and clusters .
we would like to thank the anonymous referee for many helpful suggestions . | radio relic sources in galaxy clusters are often described as the remnants of powerful radio galaxies . here
we develop a model for the evolution of such relics after the jets cease to supply energy to the lobes .
this includes the treatment of a relic overpressured with respect to its gaseous surroundings even after the jets switch off .
we also determine the radio emission of relics for a large variety of assumptions .
we take into account the evolution of the strength of the magnetic field during the phase of relativistic particle injection into the lobes .
the resulting spectra show mild steepening at around 1ghz but avoid any exponential spectral cut - offs .
the model calculations are used to fit the observed spectra of seven radio relics .
the quality of the fits is excellent for _ all _ models discussed .
unfortunately , this implies that it is virtually impossible to determine any of the important source parameters from the observed radio emission alone .
galaxies : active galaxies : jets intergalactic medium radio continuum : galaxies |
given a general elliptic fibration @xmath1 , we learn by computing @xmath2 that there must be 24 nodal fibers . for more general irreducible curve classes on a k3 , yau and
zaslow @xcite argued that taking the euler characteristic of the relative compactified jacobian would again yield the number of maximally degenerate fibers ; the arguments were clarified by beauville @xcite and by fantechi , van straten , and the first author @xcite . for more general families of curves ,
similar arguments may be made in terms of the relative hilbert schemes of points .
let @xmath3 be a family of reduced planar curves of arithmetic genus @xmath4 , and let @xmath5 } \to b$ ] be the relative hilbert schemes .
certain string - theoretic ideas of gopakumar and vafa @xcite motivate the consideration of the following series , and the following change of variables : @xmath6 } ) = \sum_{i=0}^\infty n^i_{\cc / b } \cdot \left(\frac{q}{(1-q)^2}\right)^{i+1-g}\ ] ] in the case of a single curve @xmath7 , we write simply @xmath8 .
pandharipande and thomas @xcite prove that @xmath9 when @xmath10 has cogenus @xmath11 . from macdonald s calculation of the cohomology of symmetric products of curves ,
it follows that for @xmath10 smooth we have @xmath12 and @xmath13 for @xmath14 . more generally , whenever the singularities of @xmath10 are unions of smooth branches , the last nonvanishing term is calculated either from @xcite or @xcite to be @xmath15 .
in the relative situation , it is helpful to view @xmath16 as a constructible function @xmath17 given by @xmath18 ; evidently @xmath19 .
the @xmath16 have an enumerative interpretation .
suppose that @xmath20 is the maximum cogenus of any curve in the family , that there are finitely many curves of cogenus @xmath20 , and that all these curves are immersed .
then @xmath21 is just the number of these curves .
one exploits this observation by finding another way to express the euler characteristics of the relative hilbert schemes .
in particular , the following two results have recently been established : [ thm : mult ] @xcite .
fix @xmath10 a reduced plane curve , @xmath22 a versal deformation of its singularities , and @xmath23 the locus of cogenus @xmath24 curves .
then @xmath25 is the multiplicity of @xmath26 .
[ thm : univ ] @xcite .
let @xmath27 be a surface , and @xmath28 a @xmath24-very - ample line bundle .
then the number of @xmath24-nodal curves in a general @xmath29 is @xmath30 , which moreover is given by a certain explicit combination of integrals of chern classes of @xmath31}$ ] and @xmath32}$ ] .
the significance of the second result is that , due to a theorem of ellingsrud , lehn , and the first author @xcite , such integrals depend in a universal way on the chern classes of @xmath28 and @xmath27 .
such universality of the counts of nodal curves had previously been conjectured by the first author @xcite , and previously proven by @xcite .
the present article poses the following question : _ does replacing the topological euler characteristic on the left hand side by more sophisticated invariants have an enumerative counterpart on the right ? _
we begin in section [ sec : curve ] by studying the case of a single curve .
the arguments of @xcite may be adapted to show that , for @xmath10 a locally planar reduced curve of arithmetic genus @xmath4 and @xmath33 its normalization of genus @xmath34 , there exist classes @xmath35 in the grothendieck ring of varieties such that @xmath36 } ] } { \sum_{n=0}^\infty q^{n+1-\widetilde{g } } [ \widetilde{c}^{[n ] } ] } = \sum_{i=0}^\delta \widetilde{n}^i_c \left ( \frac{q}{(1-q)(1-q [ \mathbb{a}^1 ] ) } \right)^{i-\delta}\ ] ] the right hand side moreover splits into a product over the singularities of @xmath10 . according to theorem [ thm : mult ] , the euler number @xmath37 gives the multiplicity of a certain locus , and is in particular positive . in examples we see a stronger positivity : @xmath38 $ ] .
this conjecture is verified computationally for singularities of the form @xmath39 where @xmath40 and @xmath41 using the formulas of @xcite for the classes of the hilbert schemes .
the meanings of the @xmath35 remain mysterious , but there is some evidence that they may be related to real geometry .
we define real analogues @xmath42 of the @xmath16 by using the compactly supported euler number of the real locus , and show these again vanish for @xmath43 .
these have an interpretation analogous to theorem [ thm : mult ] .
recall that nodes of real curves come in three types : elliptic ( @xmath44 ) , hyperbolic ( @xmath45 ) , and pairs of complex conjugate nodes .
thus in the real deformation , the loci @xmath46 of @xmath47-nodal curves split into components according to the types of the nodes .
let @xmath10 be a real reduced plane curve , and let @xmath3 be a locally versal deformation of its singularities .
let @xmath48 be the locus of nodal curves with @xmath24 nodes of which @xmath49 are hyperbolic .
let @xmath50 be a general real disc of dimension @xmath51 passing near @xmath52 \in b$ ] . then @xmath53 note in particular that while the individual terms on the rhs of the formula may depend on the location of the disc , the theorem asserts that their sum does not . for the simple singularities , we give a combinatorial formula for the @xmath35 in terms of the dynkin diagram .
( this refines the analogous prescription for the multiplicities given in @xcite . )
the formula may be interpreted as the choice of a particular real form and a particular disc @xmath54 in the above statement so that the coefficient of @xmath55 in @xmath56 is @xmath57 . for @xmath58
, duco van straten has conjectured that such a disc may be found for any singularity . in section [ sec : families ] , we turn to the case of linear systems of curves on surfaces . from the point of view of the argument in @xcite , it is natural to refine the euler characteristic to hirzebruch s @xmath59 genus , since the latter both factors through the grothendieck ring of varieties and may be calculated in terms of chern classes . by an appropriate change of variable , one can define invariants @xmath60 $ ] which refine the @xmath61 of theorem [ thm : univ ] above .
@xmath62 } ) = \sum_{i=0}^\infty n^i_{\cc / b } \cdot \left(\frac{q}{(1-q)(1-qy)}\right)^{i+1-g}\ ] ] one virtue of the @xmath59 genus is that , for a single curve , the @xmath63 vanish for @xmath43 ; the analogous statement does not hold for the virtual poincar polynomials .
vanish even in the grothendieck ring of varieties ; the point being that the @xmath63 and @xmath35 have different virtual poincar polynomials but the same @xmath59 genus .
ultimately this is because the @xmath59 genus of an abelian variety vanishes . ] however , unlike in the euler characteristic setting , one can not `` integrate over the base '' to conclude the vanishing for @xmath64 .
nonetheless , the experimental evidence suggests : [ conj : vanishing ] let @xmath28 be a line bundle on a surface @xmath27 , and @xmath29 a linear subsystem with tautological curve @xmath65 .
assume that @xmath66 contains no non - reduced curves , and that the total space of the relative hilbert scheme @xmath5}$ ] is smooth for all @xmath67 .
then @xmath64 vanishes for @xmath68 .
we are able to show : the conjecture holds when @xmath69 is numerically trivial .
we also give some evidence for the general statement .
by @xcite , one can reduce the validity of the conjecture to the case of @xmath70 and @xmath71 . here
we may calculate in low degrees by equivariant localization . regarding the hypotheses ,
note that when @xmath72 , pandharipande and fantechi @xcite have found families of smooth curves over a smooth base curve with nonzero invariants @xmath73 for some @xmath14 .
the base curves are always of genus @xmath74 , and indeed no such examples can exist over a simply connected base .
we are not sure what further aspects of the geometry of families of curves on surfaces are implicated .
a calculation of migliorini has shown that the vanishing can not be expected for the analogous expression involving hodge polynomials , already over a one dimensional base . in section [ sec : deepest ] , we focus on the invariants @xmath75 . assuming conjecture [ conj : vanishing ] , this is the last nonvanishing @xmath73 , and we show that there is an expression of the form @xmath76 where @xmath28 is k - very - ample , and the @xmath77 are some universal power series in @xmath78[[s]]$ ] . to avoid carrying around the @xmath79 , we simply define @xmath80}$ ] to be the coefficient of @xmath81 on the rhs ; the brackets in the notation serve to remind us that it depends only on the cobordism class of @xmath82 . as in @xcite
, it is easiest to express the @xmath77 after a change of variable .
consider the following series in @xmath83[[q]]$ ] @xmath84_y^2}{d } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and let @xmath85 . above @xmath86_y:= \frac{y^{n/2}- y^{-n/2}}{y^{1/2}-y^{-1/2}}$ ] .
it is also convenient to introduce the notation @xmath87 } : = y^{-\delta } n^\delta_{\delta,[s , l]}$ ] ; these invariants are symmetric under @xmath88 .
[ conj : bs ] there exist power series @xmath89 , @xmath90 in @xmath83[[q]]$ ] , such that @xmath91}(y)\widetilde{dg}_2^\delta=\frac{(\widetilde{dg}_2/q)^{\chi(l)}b_1(y , q)^{k_s^2}b_2(y , q)^{lk_s } } { \big(\widetilde\delta(y , q)\ , d \widetilde{dg}_2/q^2)^{\chi(o_s)/2}}.\ ] ] the first 11 terms of the series @xmath92 are given explicitly in section [ sec : deepest ] . assuming conjecture [ conj : vanishing ] , the content of the above assertion is exhausted by the case where
@xmath27 is a k3 surface .
moreover as in @xcite it may be reformulated without the expansion in powers of @xmath93 : [ conj : k3a ] let @xmath94 be k3 surfaces of genus @xmath4 with irreducible polarizations .
then for any @xmath47 , @xmath95}(y ) = \frac{\widetilde{dg}_2(y , q)^k}{\widetilde{\delta}(y , q)}.\ ] ] similarly , if @xmath96 are abelian surfaces of genus @xmath4 with irreducible polarizations , @xmath97 } q^{g-1 } = \widetilde{dg}_2(y , q)^k d\widetilde{dg}_2 ( y , q)\ ] ] because of the existence of k3 and abelian surfaces of all genera , and the multiplicative nature of the formulas , we show that conjecture [ conj : k3a ] would follow from its validity at @xmath98 .
we have been able to check this case for the k3 surface , but not for the abelian surface .
conjecture [ conj : k3a ] would also follow from its validity for all @xmath47 for the k3 surface alone . here
we note a remarkable coincidence : the series on the rhs of the above formula appears in the work of @xcite on computing descendant invariants in the ( reduced ) gromov - witten or stable pairs theory of a k3 surface .
this leads to a further reformulation : let @xmath99 be a irreducibly polarized @xmath100 surface of genus @xmath4 , and let @xmath101 be the hyperplane class on @xmath102 . then for all @xmath47 , @xmath103 } = \sum_{n=0}^\infty y^{n+1-g } \int_{\cc^{[n]}_{|l| } } c_{n+g - k}(t \cc^{[n]}_{|l|})\cdot \rho^*(h^k)\ ] ] thus far we have been discussing curves with a number of nodes small compared to the ampleness of the line bundle @xmath28 ; this is the regime to which the conjectures of @xcite and the arguments of @xcite apply .
however , when the surface is @xmath70 , the recursion of caporaso and harris @xcite determines the degrees of _ all _ such loci of nodal curves , without any such restriction on the ampleness .
indeed , it determines more : fix a line @xmath104 , and sequences @xmath105 of integers specifying respectively fixed and moving tangency conditions to @xmath101 .
then the caporaso - harris recursion determines the degrees @xmath106 of the loci of curves with @xmath24 nodes and satisfying the tangency conditions @xmath105 .
we treat these as well ; we have restricted in the introduction to @xmath70 just for ease of notation . ] in section [ sec : severi ] we study the following formal refinement of the caporaso - harris recursion .
we take from @xcite the notation @xmath107 and @xmath108 ; note that the curves counted by @xmath109 have degree @xmath110 .
the polynomials @xmath111 $ ] are defined by the following recursion : @xmath112_y \cdot \overline n^{\delta}(\alpha+e_k,\beta - e_k ) + \sum_{\alpha',\beta',\delta ' } \left ( \prod_i [ i]_y^{\beta_i'-\beta_i } \right ) \binom{\alpha}{\alpha'}\binom{\beta'}{\beta } \overline n^{\delta'}(\alpha',\beta')\ ] ] the limits on the sum and the initial conditions are the same as for the caporaso - harris recursion and are given explicitly in section [ sec : severi ] .
the refined recursion immediately specializes to the caporaso - harris recursion upon setting @xmath113 , so certainly @xmath114 . on the other hand ,
we know that for @xmath115 that the severi degrees @xmath116 are given by the universal formulas , i.e. , equal to the numbers @xmath117}$ ] .
we conjecture a refined analogue : [ conj : chrefined ] for @xmath118 , we have @xmath119}$ ] .
the equality at @xmath113 follows from @xcite . at @xmath120 ,
the recursion simplifies , allowing the rhs to be calculated explicitly ; on the other hand , a result of scala allows the lhs to be calculated as well @xcite ; the answers match .
empirically we have verified the equality for some small @xmath121 . in section [ sec : rrt ] , we note a connection to real enumerative geometry and to some ideas from tropical geometry . on a real toric surface @xmath27 , there are real enumerative invariants , counting real @xmath24-nodal curves with suitable signs , the real analogues of the severi degrees .
if @xmath27 is an unnodal del pezzo surface , they coincide with the welschinger invariants , real analogues of the gromov - witten invariants .
mikhalkin @xcite has shown that the severi degrees and the real enumerative invariants can be computed via tropical geometry : he introduces tropical severi degrees and tropical welschinger invariants by assigning gromov - witten and welschinger multiplicities to tropical curves , and shows that they coincide with the severi degrees and the real enumerative invariants respectively .
the caporaso - harris formula has been derived tropically by gathmann and markwig @xcite , and an analogue for the tropical welschinger invariants by itenberg , kharlamov , and shustin @xcite .
these are specializations of the above recursion , specialized at @xmath122 and @xmath123 respectively .
in particular the refined severi degrees specialize to the severi degrees and the tropical welschinger invariants . in @xcite ,
block and the first author define and study tropical refined severi degrees by assigning polynomial multiplicities to the tropical curves which specialize to the gromov - witten and welschinger multiplicities . on the right hand side of conjecture
[ conj : chrefined ] , the specialization @xmath124 has an entirely different meaning : we are taking the signatures of the relative hilbert schemes and rearranging them in a certain way . on the other hand
, a signed count of real nodal curves in a general @xmath66 is obtained from the @xmath125 defined earlier . in order
that @xmath125 match @xmath126 , the following property would suffice : let @xmath127 be a linear system determined by a subtropical collection of real points . if @xmath5}/{{\bbb p}}^\delta$ ] is smooth , then its signature is equal to the euler characteristic of its real locus . here roughly speaking a collection of points in @xmath128 is called subtropical , if it can be degenerated to a tropical collection of points without crossing walls , for the precise definition see ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 2.7.(3 ) ) .
we remark briefly on related work . in the physics literature
there is the notion of the refined topological string , which gives in some cases a one - parameter deformation of the various curve counting invariants @xcite .
notably it does not have a `` worldsheet '' definition , even in the sense of physics .
mathematically , the refined theory is supposed to correspond @xcite to the motivic dt theory @xcite ; the lack of a worldsheet definition corresponds to the fact that we do not know how to correspondingly refine the gromov - witten invariants .
there have also been intimations that a specialization of the refined theory is related to real invariants ( * ? ? ?
our approach falls roughly into this paradigm insofar as @xmath129 are assembled from @xmath59 genera of relative hilbert schemes , which under the relevant assumptions on @xmath66 are just the same as stable pairs spaces .
it might plausibly be hoped that the refined severi degrees also admit an interpretation in the stable pairs theory @xcite or its surface variant @xcite .
* acknowledgements*. we thank paolo aluffi , florian block , barbara fantechi , ilia itenberg , davesh maulik , luca migliorini , grigory mikhalkin , hiraku nakajima , andrei okounkov , rahul pandharipande , sam payne , duco van straten , richard thomas , kota yoshioka , and don zagier for helpful discussions .
the first named author thanks friedrich hirzebruch for interesting and useful discussions on the subject of this paper , and also for his help and guidance over many years . v. s. is supported by the simons foundation
. * notation . *
we denote quantum numbers as @xmath130_y : = \frac{y^{n/2}- y^{-n/2}}{y^{1/2}-y^{-1/2}}\ ] ] by the hirzebruch genus @xmath131 we mean the characteristic class which on a bundle @xmath132 with chern roots @xmath133 takes the value @xmath134[[x_i]]\ ] ] also let @xmath135 setting by definition @xmath136 we have according to hirzebruch @xmath137 when @xmath138 we suppress it from the notation .
note that @xmath139 where @xmath140 are the hodge numbers of @xmath141 . note the specializations to topological euler characteristic @xmath142 , holomorphic euler characteristic @xmath143 , and signature @xmath144 .
let @xmath10 be a complete , reduced , gorenstein , complex curve of genus @xmath4 .
we consider the following series with coefficients in the grothendieck group of varieties @xmath145 : @xmath146 } q^{n+1-g}\ ] ] note @xmath147 } = { { \bbb p}}^n$ ] .
writing @xmath148 for the class of the affine line , we have : @xmath149 we define classes @xmath150 by the following formula : @xmath151 } q^{n+1-g } = \sum_{i=0}^\infty n^i_c \cdot z_{{{\bbb p}}^1}^{i+1-g}\ ] ] recall that the euler characteristic factors through @xmath145 , so it makes sense to write @xmath152 .
when @xmath10 is smooth of genus @xmath4 , it follows from macdonald s calculation of the cohomology of symmetric products that @xmath153 for @xmath14 . however it certainly need not be the case that @xmath154 .
for instance if @xmath132 is an elliptic curve , then @xmath155}$ ] is the projectivization of a rank @xmath67 vector bundle over @xmath132 for @xmath156 , hence @xmath157 and @xmath158 , and the higher @xmath73 vanish .
[ lem : hart ] @xcite .
let @xmath10 be a gorenstein curve , and let @xmath159 be a torsion free sheaf on @xmath10 .
write @xmath160 for @xmath161 . then @xmath162 and @xmath163 .
serre duality holds in the form @xmath164 . for @xmath159
rank one and torsion free , define its degree @xmath165 .
this satisfies @xmath166 , and , for @xmath28 any line bundle , @xmath167 .
the following result lifts ( * ? ? ?
3.13 ) from euler characteristics to @xmath145 ; the proof is essentially the same .
[ prop : bps ] let @xmath10 be a gorenstein curve .
then @xmath168 for @xmath169 .
fix a degree one line bundle @xmath170 on @xmath10 .
let @xmath171 denote the moduli space of rank one , degree zero , torsion free sheaves @xcite .
we map @xmath172 }
\to \overline{j}^0(c)$ ] by sending the ideal @xmath173 to the sheaf @xmath174 ; the fibre is @xmath175 . for @xmath176 ,
we write the hilbert function as @xmath177 .
stratify @xmath171 into strata over which @xmath178 is constant .
the restriction of @xmath172}$ ] to each stratum is the projectivization of a vector bundle of rank @xmath179 .
thus we have the equality @xmath180 } ] = \sum_h [ \{f\,|\,h_{f } = h\ } ] \sum_{d=0}^{\infty } q^d [ { { \bbb p}}^{h(d)-1}]\ ] ] fix @xmath181 for some @xmath159 .
evidently @xmath182 is supported in @xmath183 , and by riemann - roch and serre duality is equal to @xmath184 in @xmath185 . inside
@xmath186 $ ] , it either increases by 0 or 1 at each step . let @xmath187 ; evidently @xmath188 $ ] and @xmath189 $ ] , and @xmath190 = \sum_{d \in \phi_-(h ) } q^d { \mathbb{l}}^{h(d)-1 } - \sum_{d \in \phi_+(h ) } q^{d } { \mathbb{l}}^{h(d-1)}\ ] ] this is a polynomial in @xmath191 of degree at most @xmath192 .
now let @xmath193 , and @xmath194 . by serre duality and riemann - roch , @xmath195 ,
so in particular , @xmath196 .
summing over possible @xmath182 , we learn that @xmath197}]$ ] is a polynomial of degree at most @xmath192 , satisfying @xmath198 . from this
the vanishing of the higher @xmath73 follows by trivial algebraic manipulations .
we always have @xmath199 and @xmath200 + ( g-1)(1+{\mathbb{l}})$ ] .
given the vanishing , only @xmath201 contributes large powers of @xmath191 ; on the other hand when @xmath202 the map @xmath203 } \to \overline{j}^0(c)$ ] is a projective bundle .
comparison of these terms reveals @xmath204 .
let @xmath205 , @xmath206 , @xmath207 be rational curves that are smooth , have one node , and have one cusp respectively .
* @xmath208 . * @xmath209 and @xmath210 . * @xmath211 and @xmath212 . in each case
proposition [ prop : bps ] ensures the higher @xmath73 vanish .
let @xmath33 be the normalization of @xmath10 . to avoid incorporating the global geometry of @xmath10 into the invariants
, we define @xmath35 by the formula : @xmath213 note when @xmath10 is rational , @xmath214 .
one sees by a straightforward stratification argument that the series on the left hand side only depends on formal neighborhoods of the singularities of @xmath10 .
each such singularity may be found on a rational curve with no other singularities ( * ? ? ?
thus it follows from the previous result that @xmath215 for @xmath43 . or in other words , @xmath216 [ conj : positive ] @xmath217 $ ] . * remark . * theorem [ thm : mult ] realizes @xmath37 as the multiplicity of the stratum of curves of cogenus @xmath20 inside the versal deformation of @xmath10 , whence it follows that @xmath218 for @xmath219 .
it may be hoped that this conjecture indicates a refinement of this geometric structure , i.e. , that the coefficients of the @xmath35 count something . for rational @xmath10 , we have @xmath220 $ ] ; by @xcite these jacobians are known to receive a bijective morphism from an affine springer fiber for @xmath221 .
it is known that such affine springer fibers in other types _ are not necessarily _ in @xmath222 $ ] ( * ? ? ?
* appendix ) , however according to lusztig the status of the @xmath221 affine springer fibers is unknown . from the work of piontkowski
@xcite it follows that that for unibranch singularities with a single puiseux pair , and for unibranch singularities whose links are two - cablings of links of simple unibranch singularities , one has at least @xmath223 $ ] . the stated positivity has been checked for unibranch singularities with a single puiseux pair ( e.g. @xmath224 ) for @xmath225 and @xmath226 using the explicit formula for @xmath227 given in ( *
5 ) . from the fact that @xmath228
, we see that @xmath229 , and in particular that the @xmath8 vanish for @xmath43 .
this fact was used in @xcite as evidence that the @xmath8 were in fact the gopakumar - vafa invariants , and was exploited in @xcite to count curves on surfaces . here
we note the hirzebruch @xmath59 genus has the same property , which suggests that it is a more sensible refinement than working in the ring of varieties .
for @xmath10 a smooth curve of genus @xmath4 , @xmath230 .
the hodge structures of symmetric products are known explicitly @xcite .
in particular , @xmath232 for @xmath43 . according to conjecture [ conj : positive ] , the @xmath35 may be recovered from @xmath233 by @xmath234 .
conversely , one may separate conjecture [ conj : positive ] into two pieces , one asking that @xmath235 $ ] and the second asking that @xmath233 have positive coefficients . here
we express the refined bps invariants of curves with simple singularities in terms the associated dynkin diagram . in figure
[ fig : ade ] , we recall the ade classification of simple singularities . [
lem : adeinfinity ] we define @xmath236 to be the germ at the origin of the curve cut out by @xmath237 .
similarly we define @xmath238 by @xmath239 and @xmath240 by @xmath241 .
then , for @xmath242 , we have an equality @xmath243 } = x_\infty^{[i]}$ ] as subsets of @xmath244}$ ] for any @xmath20 up to the delta invariant of @xmath245 .
any subscheme of length at most @xmath24 supported at the origin is annihilated by @xmath246 . in each case
, the rhs of the equation of @xmath245 already belongs to this ideal .
[ prop : adeinfinity ] @xmath247 } ] q^n & = & \frac{1}{(1-q)(1-q^2 { \mathbb{l } } ) } \\
\sum [ d_\infty^{[n ] } ] q^n & = & \frac{1-q+q^3 { \mathbb{l}}^2}{(1-q)^2(1-q^2 { \mathbb{l } } ) } \\
\sum [ e_\infty^{[n ] } ] q^n & = & \frac{1}{(1-q)(1-q^2 { \mathbb{l}})(1-q^3 { \mathbb{l}}^2 ) } \\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] the cases @xmath248
are special cases of ( * ? ? ?
we treat @xmath238 .
an arbitrary element in @xmath249/xy^2 $ ] takes the form @xmath250 , where @xmath251 are constants .
fix an ideal @xmath252 and consider @xmath253 .
this is generated by some @xmath254 .
now consider @xmath255 .
a general element has the form @xmath256 .
if @xmath257 , then multiplying by @xmath258 we find @xmath259 hence @xmath260 and moreover we may take @xmath261 .
multiplying by @xmath262 we may eliminate @xmath263 as well , and we have @xmath264 . such ideals ( of finite colength ) are of the form @xmath265 .
thus let us assume every element in @xmath255 is of the form @xmath266 .
multiplying by invertible elements , we may assume @xmath267 are monomial .
note that if @xmath252 is of finite colength , some elements with nonzero @xmath263 must appear .
so choose an element @xmath268 with @xmath67 minimal .
we are constrained by @xmath269 .
thus the possibilities are @xmath270 , where if @xmath271 then @xmath272 .
finally @xmath273 , where @xmath274 , the constant @xmath275 is arbitrary and @xmath263 should be chosen of degree less than @xmath67 .
[ thm : simple ] let @xmath141 be a curve , smooth away from a simple singularity . color the dots of the associated dynkin diagram as in figure [ fig : ade ] .
let @xmath276 be the number of ways to choose @xmath277 white dots and @xmath278 black ones such that no two dots are adjacent .
then @xmath279 @xmath280 is symmetric and determined by its terms of degree less than @xmath281 . by lemma [ lem : adeinfinity ] , these are determined by the series for @xmath282 , which we have computed . matching to the numbers @xmath276 is an exercise in combinatorics . for @xmath283 ,
the nonvanishing invariants are @xmath284 the @xmath285 are not generally symmetric . for @xmath286 ,
the nonvanishing invariants are @xmath287 for @xmath288 , the nonvanishing invariants are @xmath289 for the simple singularities , we have the following remarkable statement , which may be proven by comparing theorem [ thm : simple ] to the description of the versal deformation of a simple singularity as the quotient of the hyperplane arrangement of the same name by the weyl group @xcite . [ duco ]
let @xmath141 be a simple singularity .
then there exists some curve @xmath10 containing as its unique singularity a real form of @xmath141 , and a real disc @xmath50 in the real locus of the versal deformation of @xmath141 such that @xmath290 where @xmath291 is the locus of real nodal curves with @xmath51 total nodes of which @xmath20 are hyperbolic .
this result was known to van straten when @xmath292 ; he had conjectured in this case that it holds for all singularities ( see @xcite[conj .
4.7 ] ) on the evidence of its validity for the simple singularities and its validity at @xmath113 for all singularities @xcite .
theorem [ thm : mult ] asserts the validity of the above statement at @xmath293 for all singularities , so one might analogously conjecture that the statement of theorem [ duco ] holds always .
now suppose @xmath10 is defined over @xmath294 .
let @xmath295 denote the compactly supported topological euler characteristic of the real locus .
note this is additive and multiplicative . by way of examples , @xmath296 , @xmath297 , and @xmath298 .
let @xmath299})\ ] ] we have @xmath300 , and so we define integers @xmath301 by the following formula : @xmath302 } ) \,\ , q^{n - g+1 } = \sum_{i=0}^\infty n^{i,{{\bbb r}}}_c \left(\frac{q}{1-q^2 } \right ) ^{i - g+1}\ ] ] [ lem : realbpssmooth ] for @xmath10 a smooth real curve of genus @xmath4 , @xmath303 .
equivalently , @xmath304 and @xmath305 for @xmath14 .
let @xmath306 be the complex conjugation .
we have a stratification @xmath307 anything coming from @xmath308 fibres over circles and never contributes to the euler characteristic .
therefore @xmath309 this establishes the lemma . for a point @xmath310 on a curve @xmath10 , write @xmath311 for the germ at @xmath310 , and @xmath312}$ ] for the locus in the hilbert scheme of points on @xmath10 of subschemes set - theoretically supported at @xmath310 . for @xmath313 ,
we write @xmath314 and @xmath315 for respectively the number of real and complex points above @xmath310 in the normalization of @xmath10 .
we have by stratification @xmath316 } ) } { \sum q^{n+1-\widetilde{g } } \chi_{{\bbb r}}(\widetilde{c}^{[n ] } ) } & = & \prod_{p \in c^{\mathrm{sing}}({{\bbb r}})}q^{-\delta(p)}\frac{\sum q^n \chi_{{\bbb r}}(c , p)^{[n ] } } { ( 1-q^2)^{-cb(p)/2 } ( 1-q)^{-rb(p ) } } \\ & \times & \prod_{p \in c^{\mathrm{sing}}({\mathbb{c}})/\sigma}q^{-2\delta(p ) } \frac{\sum q^{2n } \chi ( c , p)^{[n ] } } { ( 1-q^2)^{cb(p)}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now compute @xmath317 for a curve @xmath10 with @xmath24 nodes and no other singularities . by the product formula above , it suffices to do this in three special cases .
the only nonvanishing invariants of a curve @xmath318 of arithmetic genus @xmath122 with a single node analytically of the form
@xmath319/(x^2 \pm y^2)$ ] are @xmath320 and @xmath321 .
( caution : @xmath322 is the one with a node that looks like @xmath323 . ) the only nonvanishing invariants of a curve of arithmetic genus two with a pair of complex conjugate nodes are @xmath324 and @xmath325 and @xmath326 .
we conclude : for a nodal curve @xmath10 with @xmath327 nodes , where @xmath328 are of the form @xmath319/(x^2 \pm y^2)$ ] and the @xmath329 are complex conjugates , @xmath330 moreover , @xmath305 for @xmath68 .
[ thm : realmult ] let @xmath10 be a real reduced plane curve , and let @xmath3 be a versal deformation of its singularities .
let @xmath331 be the locus of nodal curves with @xmath24 nodes of which @xmath49 are of the form @xmath319/(x^2 - y^2)$ ] .
let @xmath50 be a general disc of dimension @xmath51 , preserved by complex conjugation , passing near @xmath52 \in b$ ] .
then @xmath332 in particular , @xmath333 for @xmath334 .
view @xmath335 as a constructible function on @xmath336 taking @xmath337 .
let @xmath338 be a general ( complex but preserved by conjugation ) disc of dimension @xmath20 containing @xmath52 $ ] . then according to @xcite , the first @xmath339}_{d^i_0}$ ] are all smooth , and if @xmath340 then all @xmath5}_{d^i_0}$ ] are smooth .
the real locus of a smooth variety is smooth , so the same holds upon passing to real points . taking @xmath341 a disc containing @xmath342 and @xmath343 a sufficiently nearby slice , we have by smoothness that the spaces @xmath5}_{d^\delta_0}({{\bbb r}})$ ] and @xmath5}_{d^\delta_1}({{\bbb r}})$ ] are diffeomorphic and therefore have the same compactly supported euler characteristics .
note that the first @xmath51 hilbert schemes suffice to determine @xmath335 . by additivity
it follows that @xmath344 we first show the vanishing of the @xmath335 for @xmath334 .
note we have already established it for smooth and nodal curves .
we induct on @xmath345 .
take @xmath346 in equality [ eq : intequal ] .
by @xcite , the locus of curves of cogenus at least @xmath24 is of codimension @xmath24 and is the closure of the locus of @xmath24-nodal curves .
thus by genericity its only intersection with @xmath342 is at the central point @xmath52 $ ] , and its only intersection with @xmath343 is in finitely many nodal curves .
thus by induction and our explicit verification in the case of nodal curves , the integral on the right vanishes for @xmath68 , hence so does the integral on the left , which again by induction is equal to @xmath301 .
now we consider the remaining @xmath347 .
take @xmath348 in the above equality . then by the same reasoning
the only contribution to the integral on the left is @xmath301 , and the only contribution to the integral on the right is the @xmath51-nodal curves . by our previous calculation ,
these contribute as required .
if @xmath10 has a real line bundle of degree @xmath122 then the proof of proposition [ prop : bps ] carries through in @xmath349 ; we may use this instead to conclude that @xmath305 for @xmath350 .
however we have not found an analogous argument if @xmath10 has no such bundle . in @xcite , the proof of theorem [ thm : mult ] used as an input the vanishing of the @xmath8 for @xmath68 ; the argument given above shows this was unnecessary .
thus a necessary condition for the statement of theorem [ duco ] to hold for a singularity @xmath141 is the existence a curve @xmath10 containing a real form of @xmath141 with @xmath351 .
[ cor : realbps ] let @xmath3 be a family of reduced real plane curves in which all curves have cogenus @xmath352 and there are finitely many curves of cogenus @xmath24 , all nodal . then defining @xmath353 by @xmath354 } ) \,\ , q^{n - g+1 } = \sum_{i=0}^\infty n^{i,{{\bbb r}}}_{\cc / b } \left(\frac{q}{1-q^2 } \right ) ^{i - g+1}\ ] ] the number of @xmath24-nodal curves counted with signs @xmath355 is @xmath356 .
let @xmath357 be a family of plane curves , and @xmath358}:\cc^{[n]}\to b$ ] the relative hilbert schemes .
denote by @xmath359 the mixed hodge modules @xcite over @xmath360 .
we define : @xmath361 } _ ! { { \bbb q}}_{\cc^{[n ] } } q^{n+1-g } \in k_0({\mathrm{mhm}}(b))[[q]]\ ] ] we define invariants @xmath362 by the formula @xmath363 } _ ! { { \bbb q}}_{\cc^{[n ] } } q^{n+1-g } = \sum_{i=0}^\infty \mathcal{n}^i_{\cc / b } \times \mathcal{z}_{\p^1/\mathrm{pt}}^{i+1-g}\ ] ] [ prop : mhmbps ] if @xmath357 is a family of integral plane curves and moreover @xmath5}$ ] is smooth for all @xmath67 , then @xmath364 for @xmath169 .
in fact , according to @xcite we know much more : @xmath365(1 ) ) \sum_{n=0}^\infty q^{n } \pi^{[n ] } _ ! { { \bbb q}}_{\cc^{[n]}}[\dim b + n ] = \sum_{n=0}^{2 g } q^n \mathrm{ic}(b , \lambda^i r^1 \widetilde{\pi } _ * { { \bbb q}}_{\cc}[\dim b + g])[-i]\ ] ] here @xmath366 is the restriction of the map to the locus on the base where it is smooth .
we deduce the vanishing of the @xmath367 from the symmetry @xmath368 .
one may write the same definition in @xmath369 , but then we do not know whether @xmath370 vanishes for @xmath169 .
the problem arises already for families of smooth curves ; the question here is whether a family of jacobians is equivalent to its torsors in the grothendieck group of varieties .
we may take pointwise euler characteristic to define an integer valued constructible function @xmath371 , or global euler characteristic to define @xmath372 .
since @xmath16 is supported on the locus of curves of cogenus @xmath20 , certainly @xmath373 vanishes if @xmath47 is greater than the maximum cogenus of any curve in the family .
note that @xmath373 can be defined directly by the formula @xmath374 } ) q^{n+1-g } = \sum_{i=0}^\infty n^i_{\cc / b } \left ( \frac{q}{(1-q)^2}\right)^{i+1-g}\ ] ] we define @xmath375 .
equivalently we can apply @xmath376 to both sides of equation [ eq : nymhm ] in order to directly define @xmath377 by the formula @xmath378 } ) q^{n+1-g } = \sum_{i=0}^\infty n^i_{\cc / b}(y ) \left ( \frac{q}{(1-q)(1-qy)}\right)^{i+1-g}\ ] ] from proposition [ prop : mhmbps ] , we see that @xmath377 vanishes for @xmath20 greater than the maximum genus of any curve in a family whose relative hilbert schemes are nonsingular .
but for both the @xmath59 invariants of a single curve , and the @xmath379 invariants of families , we had vanishing beyond the maximum _
cogenus_. thus we may at least plausibly ask whether this holds for @xmath380 .
in fact it need not : fantechi and pandharipande observed that this vanishing can fail already for @xmath360 a curve of positive genus and @xmath3 a family of smooth curves .
however , empirically , the situation appears to be better for linear systems of curves in surfaces .
we have the following conjecture : [ cochyfam ] let @xmath28 be a line bundle on a surface @xmath27 , @xmath381 the tautological family of curves , and @xmath382 be a linear subsystem
. assume the relative hilbert schemes @xmath5}_{{{{\bbb p}}}^\delta}$ ] are nonsingular for all @xmath383 .
then @xmath384 for @xmath68 . from the smoothness criterion in @xcite
one may deduce that the maximum cogenus of any curve in any such @xmath66 is @xmath24 .
the assumption holds in the following situations : [ thm : whensmooth ] let @xmath28 be a line bundle on a surface @xmath27 , @xmath381 the tautological family of curves , and @xmath29 a general linear subsystem .
then all relative hilbert schemes @xmath5}_{{{{\bbb p}}}^\delta}$ ] are nonsingular in the following situations : * @xmath27 is arbitrary and @xmath28 is @xmath24-very ample @xcite .
relative hilbert schemes are nonsingular under this hypothesis , and the less obvious fact that the assumption implies that no non - reduced curves or curves of cogenus @xmath385 occur in the @xmath66 . consequently the smoothness criteria in @xcite may be used to establish smoothness of the remaining relative hilbert schemes . ] * @xmath27 is a k3 or abelian surface and @xmath28 is irreducible @xcite .
* @xmath27 is a rational surface and @xmath66 contains no non - reduced curves , and no curves with components which intersect @xmath69 non - negatively @xcite . in particular , for a general @xmath386 . rather than simply integrate to get @xmath387
, we can extract more refined information by taking chern - schwarz - macpherson classes @xmath388 .
we recall that @xmath388 is the unique map from constructible functions to homology which commutes with pushforward and satisfies the normalization @xmath389 $ ] when @xmath141 is smooth projective ; its existence was conjectured by deligne and grothendieck and established by macpherson @xcite .
now taking @xmath390 , we see by macpherson s theorem that @xmath391 } _ * ( c(t \cc^{[n ] } ) \cap [ \cc^{[n ] } ] ) q^{n+1-g } = \sum_{i=0}^\infty \mathbf{n}^i_{\cc / b } \left(\frac{q}{(1-q)^2}\right)^{i+1-g}\ ] ] of course we are also free to take this as the definition of the @xmath392 and conclude from macpherson s theorem that @xmath392 vanishes if @xmath20 is greater than the maximum cogenus of any curve in the family .
in good cases , the constructible function @xmath16 and the class @xmath393 carry singularity - theoretic meaning : [ thm : euob ] let @xmath394 be a family of reduced plane curves with all @xmath395}$ ] nonsingular .
let @xmath396 be the locus of curves of cogenus @xmath20 , and let @xmath397 be the sublocus of curves smooth away from @xmath20 nodes .
assume @xmath398 for all @xmath399 .
then @xmath400 here @xmath401 is the local euler obstruction .
moreover , @xmath392 is the chern - mather class of @xmath402 .
the first equality was asserted in @xcite in the case of a locally versal family , but in fact the same argument applies in the above generality .
let @xmath403 be any stratum of a whitney stratification for @xmath396 , other than the big open set given by the intersection of @xmath397 and the smooth locus of @xmath396 .
let @xmath404 be a generic small disc transverse to @xmath403 at some @xmath306 ; note that @xmath405 .
let @xmath406 be a general linear slice not passing through @xmath306 .
let @xmath407 denote the constructible function @xmath408}_b)$ ] . by the result of @xcite on smoothness of relative hilbert schemes ( note @xmath405 ) , @xmath409 as the @xmath16 are linear combinations of the @xmath410 , they satisfy the same formula : @xmath411 by induction on codimension of the strata this formula determines @xmath412 uniquely from its constant value @xmath122 on the smooth locus of @xmath397 .
but according to dubson - brylinksi - kashiwara @xcite , the euler obstruction satisfies ( and is determined by ) the same slice formula . between smooth varieties , @xmath413 where the @xmath414 are
some constants and the @xmath415 are the following nonsmoothability loci : @xmath416 the relation to the present situation is that the assumption and the smoothness criteria of @xcite guarantee @xmath417 . now
the coefficients @xmath418 may be calculated at a smooth point of @xmath402 . ]
the identification of @xmath393 with the chern - mather class of @xmath402 now follows from macpherson s construction of the functorial chern class .
the assumption on genericity of nodal curves in theorem [ thm : euob ] holds for a locally versal family by @xcite , for the general @xmath29 when @xmath28 is @xmath24-very - ample by @xcite , for the general @xmath29 when @xmath28 is irreducible on a general k3 surface ( the genericity of nodal curves in maximal cogenus is @xcite ) , and it was known classically for the general @xmath419 containing no nonreduced curves .
aluffi @xcite has shown that the multiplicity and and euler obstruction of the discriminant of cubic curves on @xmath70 differ at a triple line .
the argument above fails here because the total space of the restriction of the universal family to a one dimensional disc passing through this point is necessarily singular .
aluffi has also managed to extract enumerative information about curves with singularities more complicated than nodes from the chern - mather and chern - schwarz - macpherson classes of discriminants ; perhaps the same can be done with the higher severi strata .
the map @xmath420 admits a refinement due to brasselet , schrmann , and yokura .
we denote it @xmath421 $ ] .
it commutes with pushforward and obeys the normalization @xmath422 $ ] for @xmath423 proper smooth .
thus we may apply their functor to the @xmath367 and conclude that there are @xmath424 $ ] such that @xmath425 for @xmath20 greater than the arithmetic genus of the curves ( in a family of integral curves with nonsingular relative hilbert schemes ) , and : @xmath391 } _ * ( x_{-y}(t \cc^{[n ] } ) \cap [ \cc^{[n ] } ] ) q^{n+1-g } = \sum_{i=0}^\infty \mathbf{n}^i_{\cc / b}(y ) \left(\frac{q}{(1-q)(1-qy ) } \right)^{i+1-g}\ ] ] in the case of interest when @xmath426 , we denote by abuse @xmath427 the poincar dual class of @xmath428 .
since @xmath429 is , in good cases , the chern - mather class of the ( codimension i ) severi variety of cogenus i curves , we might expect : [ cochyfam : stronger ] let @xmath28 be a line bundle on a surface @xmath27 , and let @xmath382 be a linear subsystem of reduced curves over which the relative hilbert schemes @xmath5 } \to { { { \bbb p}}}^\delta$ ] are nonsingular for all @xmath383 .
then @xmath430 is a polynomial of minimal degree @xmath20 in @xmath101 , and in particular vanishes for @xmath68 .
we will see shortly that this conjecture is in fact equivalent to conjecture [ cochyfam ] .
first we recall how the hirzebruch genera of the relative hilbert schemes may be computed .
following hirzebruch @xcite , we take a ( normalized ) genus to mean a natural transformation of contravariant functors @xmath431 ( where @xmath22 is a commutative ring ) such that * for the trivial bundle @xmath432 , we have @xmath433 .
* sums go to products : @xmath434 .
* there is a power series @xmath435 $ ] such that , for a line bundle @xmath28 , we have @xmath436 . in the remainder of the paper we will be concerned only with the hirzebruch genus @xmath437 , for which @xmath438 $ ] and @xmath439 . in any case
fix some @xmath440 .
we write @xmath441 .
let @xmath27 be a surface , @xmath28 a line bundle on it , @xmath382 some linear system , @xmath442 .
let @xmath443}$ ] be the hilbert scheme of @xmath67 points on @xmath27 , and let @xmath444}$ ] be the universal family , with the projections @xmath445 , @xmath446}$ ] .
let @xmath31}:=p_*q^*l$ ] .
this is a vector bundle of rank @xmath67 on @xmath443}$ ] with fibre @xmath447 over @xmath448}$ ] .
let @xmath449 be the universal curve over @xmath450 and denote by @xmath358}:\cc_{{{{\bbb p}}}^\delta}^{[n ] } \to { { { \bbb p}}}^\delta$ ] the relative hilbert scheme of points .
the relative hilbert scheme always has the expected dimension @xmath451 @xcite , and is the scheme theoretic zero locus of a tautological section of @xmath31}\boxtimes h$ ] ; when @xmath452}$ ] is nonsingular this section is transverse . as a book - keeping device ,
let @xmath453 denote a trivial line bundle with nontrivial @xmath454 action giving equivariant first chern class @xmath455 , i.e. , @xmath456 .
let @xmath457 } } \phi(ts^{[n ] } ) \frac{c_n(l^{[n ] } \otimes e^x ) } { \phi(l^{[n ] } \otimes e^x ) } \in \lambda[[x]]\ ] ] [ prop : hilbgenus ] assume @xmath5}_{{{{\bbb p}}}^\delta}$ ] is nonsingular
. then @xmath458 } _ * ( \phi(t\cc^{[n]}_{{{{\bbb p}}}^\delta } ) \cap [ \cc^{[n ] } ] ) = f_\phi(h)^{\delta+1 } d_n^{s , l,\phi}(h ) \cap [ \p^\delta]\ ] ] in particular , @xmath459}_{{{{\bbb p}}}^\delta } ) = { \operatornamewithlimits{res}}_{x=0 } \left ( \frac{f_\phi(x)}{x}\right)^{\delta+1 } d_n^{s , l,\phi}(x)\ ] ] denote @xmath460}\to pt$ ] and @xmath461
. then @xmath462 } _ * ( \phi(t\cc^{[n]}_{{{{\bbb p}}}^\delta } ) \cap [ \cc^{[n ] } ] ) \\ & = & ( q \times 1_{\p^\delta } ) _ * \left ( c_n(l^{[n ] } \boxtimes h ) \frac{\phi(ts^{[n ] } ) \phi(t{{{\bbb p}}}^{[\delta ] } ) } { \phi(l^{[n ] } \boxtimes h ) } \cap [ s^{[n ] } ] \right ) \cap [ \p^\delta ] \\ & = & \phi(h)^{\delta+1 } q_*\left [ \left .
\phi(ts^{[n ] } ) \frac{c_n(l^{[n ] } \otimes e^x ) } { \phi(l^{[n ] } \otimes e^x ) } \right]\right|_{x = h } \cap [ \p^\delta ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] the formula makes sense without requiring smoothness , if we view it as a virtual contribution .
the description of @xmath463}$ ] as zero locus of a section of @xmath31}\boxtimes h$ ] gives it a virtual fundamental class and a virtual tangent bundle ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
thus independent of the singularities of @xmath463}$ ] , what is computed here is @xmath464})$ ] with this virtual structure .
the @xmath465 enjoy a certain multiplicativity .
introduce the series @xmath466 we denote by @xmath467 $ ] the algebraic cobordism class of the pair of the surface @xmath27 and the line bundle @xmath28 . for us
this is the equivalence class of pairs @xmath82 , where two such @xmath468 , @xmath469 are equivalent if the numbers @xmath470 , @xmath471 , @xmath472 , @xmath473 coincide for @xmath474 .
these form a group where in particular @xmath475+[s_2,l_2]=[s_1\sqcup s_2,l]$ ] with @xmath28 the line bundle which is @xmath476 on @xmath477 and @xmath478 on @xmath479 .
[ dlprod ] the map
@xmath467 \mapsto d^{s , l,\phi}$ ] is a homomorphism from the cobordism group of surfaces with bundles to the multiplicative group of invertible power series in @xmath191 with coefficients in @xmath22 .
in particular there exist universal power series @xmath480 $ ] such that @xmath481 the @xmath482 are defined by a genus applied to @xmath31}$ ] and @xmath483}}$ ] , so the first statement follows from the arguments in @xcite .
the second follows formally .
the multiplicativity of proposition [ dlprod ] allows @xmath482 ( and therefore also @xmath464})$ ] and the bps invariants ) to be computed by localization in the following standard way .
if @xmath484 , @xmath485 are such that the @xmath486 vectors @xmath487 are linearly independent , then for any @xmath82 we can write @xmath467=a_1[s_1,l_1]+a_2[s_2,l_2]+ a_3[s_3,l_3]+a_4[s_4,l_4]$ ] , with @xmath488 and thus @xmath489 thus to compute the @xmath490 it is enough to compute them for the @xmath484 . we can choose the @xmath484 as @xmath491 , @xmath492 , @xmath493 , @xmath494 .
in this case @xmath495 is a toric surface , i.e. it has an action by a torus @xmath496 with finitely many fixed points , and @xmath497 has an natural equivariant lifting .
the action of @xmath496 on @xmath27 induces in a natural way an action on @xmath443}$ ] , and the equivariant lifting of @xmath28 induces an equivariant lifting of @xmath31}$ ] .
thus we can apply equivariant localization to compute @xmath482 , in terms of the weights of the action on the fibres of @xmath483}}$ ] and @xmath31}$ ] at the fixed points .
the fixed points are parametrized by tuples of young diagrams and the weights of the action can be expressed explicitly in terms of this data . for more details in a slightly different situation
see e.g. @xcite . from now on
we specialize to @xmath437 and abbreviate @xmath498 , @xmath499 . in this case
a computer calculation yields the @xmath500 for @xmath501 and modulo @xmath502 .
the @xmath503})$ ] are computed from this by proposition [ prop : hilbgenus ] .
let @xmath504 be the chern roots of the tangent bundle of the hilbert scheme , and let @xmath505 be the chern roots of the bundle @xmath506}$ ] .
in the previous subsection we introduced the series @xmath507 } } \prod_{i=1}^{2n } \frac{t_i(1-ye^{-t_i(1-y)})}{(1-e^{-t_i(1-y ) } ) } \prod_{j=1}^n \frac{(1-e^{-(l_j+x)(1-y)})}{(1-ye^{-(l_j+x)(1-y ) } ) } \in { { \bbb q}}[y][[x]][[q]]\ ] ] for convenience we write @xmath508 . ] which specializes to the following formulas involving catalan numbers , @xmath509 note also that @xmath510 $ ] and @xmath511 $ ] . ] by proposition [ prop : hilbgenus ] we have @xmath512 [ dlconj ] for any surface @xmath27 and line bundle @xmath28 , we have @xmath513[[x , xq]]\ ] ] conjectures [ cochyfam ] , [ cochyfam : stronger ] , and [ dlconj ] are equivalent .
note @xmath514[[x]]$ ] is invertible . from equation [ dpow ] , we see that conjecture [ dlconj ] implies conjecture [ cochyfam ] and conjecture [ cochyfam : stronger ] .
assume conjecture [ cochyfam ] .
now consider some fixed linear system @xmath515 on some surface @xmath27 such that all the relative hilbert schemes @xmath5 } \to \p^\delta$ ] are nonsingular .
conjecture [ cochyfam : stronger ] amounts to the statement @xmath516 + o(x^{\delta+1})\ ] ] this obviously holds at @xmath517 ; let us prove it holds at @xmath24 by induction .
if we know this statement holds for some @xmath518 and wish to check it for @xmath519 , since @xmath520 $ ] we already know the statement modulo @xmath521 .
so we need only check @xmath522 but this is precisely the assertion of conjecture [ cochyfam ] for @xmath523 .
and since all the relative hilbert schemes will also be smooth over a general @xmath524 for any @xmath525 , the hypothesis of conjecture [ cochyfam ] is satisfied and we may deduce conjecture [ cochyfam : stronger ] .
finally , conjecture [ cochyfam : stronger ] asserts that conjecture [ dlconj ] holds modulo @xmath526 .
we have an expression @xmath527 where the @xmath528 are power series starting with @xmath122 .
thus we compare @xmath529 for various surfaces and line bundles to conclude the statement of conjecture [ dlconj ] for the series @xmath528 , modulo some @xmath530 .
taking @xmath531 by choosing increasingly ample line bundles recovers the statement for @xmath529 .
the above argument implies in particular that conjecture [ dlconj ] holds in the euler charateristic limit @xmath293 . from this
it follows formally that for _ any _ @xmath515 , with no assumptions on the reducedness or irreducibility of the curves that appear or on the smoothness of the relative hilbert schemes , there are integers @xmath532 such that @xmath533}]^{vir } } c_{top}(t^{vir } \cc^{[n ] } ) = \sum_{i=0}^{\delta } n^i_{\cc/\p^\delta } \left(\frac{q}{(1-q)^2}\right)^{i+1-g}\ ] ] recall that @xmath529 can be expressed in four universal power series , @xmath534 to avoid writing @xmath535 we adjust these series slightly .
we write @xmath536 .
we also take @xmath537 , @xmath538 , and @xmath539 , @xmath540 in order that @xmath541 .
we have @xmath542[[x , q]]$ ] for all @xmath543 , hence the same is true for the @xmath544 .
similarly , conjecture [ dlconj ] is equivalent to the assertion that @xmath545[[x , xq]]$ ] for all @xmath20 .
@xmath546[[x , xq]]$ ] .
let @xmath547 be a primitively polarized abelian surface of picard rank 1 . if @xmath548 then @xmath549 and the curves in @xmath102 have arithmetic genus @xmath550 .
note such @xmath547 exist for all @xmath47 .
by @xcite the relative hilbert schemes are smooth , and so from proposition [ prop : mhmbps ] we find that the @xmath73 vanish beyond the arithmetic genus . by this vanishing and the formula ( [ dpow ] ) extracting the @xmath73 from @xmath529 : @xmath551 we write @xmath552[[x , q]]$ ] .
we want to show @xmath553[[x , xq]]$ ] ; since this evidently holds for @xmath554 and we may take roots of power series starting with @xmath122 , it suffices to show this for @xmath555 .
so we have @xmath556 .
the following argument is completely formal and does not involve the geometric meaning of @xmath555 .
we write @xmath557 .
let @xmath558 , assuming this set is nonempty .
then @xmath559 , since no lower ( in @xmath455 ) degree term can contribute such a high power of @xmath560 .
there are two cases , @xmath561 or @xmath562 . in the first case ,
consider @xmath563 .
there will be a contribution from products of two terms of the form @xmath564 , which gives the highest possible power of @xmath560 and thus can not be canceled .
but then @xmath565 , which is a contradiction . in the second case ,
consider @xmath566 . in order that the degree @xmath567 contribution from products of three terms @xmath568 be cancelled , there must be some @xmath569 with @xmath570 and @xmath571 .
by minimality of @xmath572 , we have @xmath573 hence @xmath574 .
let @xmath575 .
finally consider @xmath576 .
there is a contribution from products of terms the form @xmath577 and @xmath578 ; since @xmath579 this contribution can not be cancelled .
this is a contradiction .
so finally we must have @xmath580 for all @xmath47 , hence @xmath581[[x , xq]]$ ] , hence the same holds for @xmath582 .
now let @xmath583 be a primitively polarized k3 surface of picard rank 1 . if @xmath584 then @xmath585 and the curves in @xmath102 have genus @xmath4 . such @xmath583 exist for all @xmath4 .
by vanishing of the @xmath73 beyond the arithmetic genus we have @xmath586 since we know @xmath587[[x , xq]]$ ] , we may conclude the same for @xmath588 .
conjectures [ cochyfam ] , [ cochyfam : stronger ] , and [ dlconj ] hold for surfaces with numerically trivial canonical class .
note the slightly curious nature of the proof of the theorem and corollary : for geometric reasons , namely smoothness of the relative hilbert schemes and the near equality of the genus and dimension of the linear system for certain line bundles on k3 and abelian surfaces , we know the conjecture for _ complete _ linear systems on k3 surfaces and something close for abelian surfaces . then by leveraging the universality of the expressions , and the existence of k3 and abelian surfaces of all genera , we can conclude the result also for _ not - necessarily - complete _ linear systems .
this sort of approach was suggested to the authors by pandharipande @xcite , who further suggested that the other power series may be similarly constrained by finding enough other surfaces with nontrivial canonical class but for which nonetheless the genus and dimension of linear systems are close .
however to use these ( or any ) surfaces for the present purposes , one must establish smoothness of the relative hilbert schemes , which we do not know how to do . using the localization calculation described in section [ sec : genera ]
, we can give evidence for conjecture [ dlconj ] for arbitrary surfaces .
conjecture [ dlconj ] holds modulo @xmath589 and @xmath502 .
therefore , if @xmath590 and @xmath515 is a linear system over which the relative hilbert scheme is smooth , there exist polynomials @xmath591 $ ] , where @xmath592 , such that @xmath593})q^{n+1-g}\equiv \sum_{l=0}^\delta n^i_{\cc/\p^\delta } ( y ) q^{l+1-g}\mod o(q^{11 + 1 - g}),\ ] ] and furthermore these polynomials are explictly computed .
if moreover @xmath594 and all curves are irreducible , then the equality is established to all orders .
for example , conjecture [ cochyfam ] holds for a general @xmath595 in @xmath596 .
the relation between the various @xmath597 and the series @xmath529 has in this section always been contingent on the smoothness of the relative hilbert schemes over the appropriate linear subsystem @xmath29 .
to avoid continually making this hypothesis , we introduce the following : for a surface @xmath27 and a line bundle @xmath28 , we define @xmath598}$ ] by the formula @xmath599 } { q}^{i } = \left(\frac{h(1-y e^{-h(1-y)})}{1-e^{-h(1-y)}}\right)^{\delta+1 } \widetilde{d}^{s , l}(y , h , q)\ ] ] and similarly for the specializations @xmath600 . by comparison with equation [ dpow ] , we see that for a linear system @xmath382 containing only reduced curves , and whose relative hilbert schemes are smooth , @xmath601}$ ] .
for a linear system @xmath515 , the numbers @xmath602 have the clearest enumerative significance , counting the number of @xmath24-nodal curves in the linear system .
thus we might also hope that the @xmath603 have an enumerative meaning refining this . in any case , assuming conjecture [ dlconj ] , the @xmath80}(y)$ ] are the easiest to compute and their generating function is multiplicative .
assume conjecture [ dlconj ] , or @xmath604 .
view @xmath605 as an element of @xmath606[[x , s]]$ ] with @xmath607 .
then @xmath608 } s^\delta = \widetilde{d}^{s , l}(y , x=0,s).\ ] ] [ produc ] assume conjecture [ dlconj ] , or @xmath604 .
then there exist series @xmath609[[s]]$ ] such that @xmath610 } ( y ) s^\delta = a_1^{l^2}a_2^{lk_s}a_3^{k_s^2}a_4^{c_2(s)}.\ ] ] viewing @xmath611 $ ] where @xmath607 , take @xmath612 . in the unrefined ( @xmath113 ) setting , more explicit formulas were expressed after substituting for @xmath613 a certain quasimodular form .
specifically , in ( * ? ? ?
2.4 ) , the following expansion was proposed : @xmath614 } \cdot ( dg_2)^\delta=\frac{(dg_2/q)^{\chi(l)}b_1^{k_s^2}b_2^{lk_s } } { ( \delta \cdot d dg_2/q^2)^{\chi(o_s)/2}}\ ] ] here @xmath615 is the eisenstein series , @xmath616 is the discriminant : @xmath617 the series @xmath618 $ ] are not known explicitly , although their first several coefficients may be computed and are given in @xcite .
we also write @xmath619 .
the above formula is by now a theorem , since the existence of universal formulas has been established @xcite , and the case of k3 surface ( where @xmath604 hence the @xmath620 do not appear ) was solved explicitly @xcite .
we write @xmath621}:=n^\delta_{\delta,[s , l]}/y^{\delta}$ ] .
now we give a conjectural refinement of equation [ gform - unref ] .
the series @xmath622 are refined as follows:[multiblock footnote omitted ] @xmath84_y^2}{d } \end{aligned}\ ] ] [ gconj ] there exist universal power series @xmath89 , @xmath90 in @xmath83[[q]]$ ] , such that @xmath623}(y ) ( \widetilde{dg}_2)^\delta=\frac{(\widetilde{dg}_2/q)^{\chi(l)}b_1(y , q)^{k_s^2}b_2(y , q)^{lk_s } } { \big(\widetilde\delta(y , q)\ , d \widetilde{dg}_2/q^2)^{\chi(o_s)/2}}\ ] ] here , to make the change of variables , all functions are viewed as elements of @xmath83[[q]]$ ] .
this conjecture is again checked modulo @xmath589 ; and we get that @xmath624 at @xmath293 , we recover modulo @xmath589 the functions @xmath625 , @xmath626 of @xcite . as in ( * ? ? ?
2.6 ) , the expansion in @xmath93 may be exchanged for an expansion in @xmath191 while simultaneously trading a sum over varying numbers of point conditions while fixing the line bundle for a sum over line bundles while fixing the point conditions .
note the latter form is more natural from the point of view of the gw / dt / pairs theories , and indeed this is the form in which the k3 is solved in @xcite . in detail
this procedure is as follows . for any power series @xmath627 $ ] and @xmath628 $ ]
, we may expand @xmath629 in terms of @xmath4 by the residue formula : @xmath630\right|_{q=0}\ ] ] conjecture [ gconj ] asserts that @xmath87}$ ] is the coefficient of @xmath631 of a certain expression ; taking this coefficient by the above residue formula gives the equivalent formulation : @xmath632}(y ) & = & \left.\left[\widetilde{dg}_2^{-\delta-1 } d\widetilde{dg}_2 \frac{(\widetilde{dg}_2/q)^{\chi(l)}b_1(y , q)^{k_s^2}b_2(y , q)^{lk_s } } { \big(\widetilde\delta(y , q)\ , d \widetilde{dg}_2/q^2)^{\chi(o_s)/2}}\right ] \right|_{q=0 } \\ & = & \mathrm{coeff}_{q^{(l^2 - lk_s)/2}}\left ( \frac{(\widetilde{dg}_2)^{\chi(l)-1-\delta } d \widetilde{dg}_2 b_1(y , q)^{k_s^2}b_2(y , q)^{lk_s } } { \big(\widetilde\delta(y , q)\ , d \widetilde{dg}_2)^{\chi(o_s)/2 } } \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we would now like to collect coefficients of @xmath191 to write the entire series in the @xmath633 in terms of the @xmath634 .
so we must choose some values of @xmath635 $ ] such that @xmath636 and @xmath637 remain constant , but @xmath638 assumes every integer value starting from @xmath639 .
in other words , the cobordism class of the surface , the number of point conditions @xmath640 , and @xmath641 are fixed , and @xmath642 varies .
note that it is not necessarily possible to find a fixed surface @xmath27 and honest line bundles @xmath643 which realize all the desired values .
this causes no difficulties as the @xmath644}$ ] may be viewed as just functions of the four values @xmath645 . making this dependence explicit we write @xmath646}((l^2-lk_s)/2 , lk_s):=\overline{n}^{\chi(l)-1-k}_{\chi(l)-1-k,[s , l]}$ ] , where the rhs is viewed just as a function of two integers and
is determined by evaluating the lhs on the cobordism class @xmath467 $ ] with the specified invariants . in terms of the @xmath647
, we have : @xmath648}(l , lk_s)q^l = \widetilde { dg}_2(y , q)^k \frac { b_1(y , q)^{k_s^2}b_2(y , q)^{lk_s } d \widetilde { dg}_2(y , q)}{(\widetilde \delta(y , q)d\widetilde { dg}_2(y , q))^{\chi(\oo_s)/2}}.\ ] ] we can also express this in a slightly different way , fixing @xmath641 , @xmath47 and varying @xmath24 : write @xmath649}(\delta , lk_s):=\overline n^{\delta}_{\delta,[s , l]}$ ] with @xmath650 . then @xmath651}(\delta , lk_s)q^\delta = ( \widetilde { dg}_2(y ,
q)/q)^k \frac { b_1(y , q)^{k_s^2}b_2(y , q)^{lk_s } ( d \widetilde { dg}_2(y , q)/q)}{(\widetilde \delta(y , q)\cdot d\widetilde { dg}_2(y , q)/q^2)^{\chi(\oo_s)/2}}.\ ] ] when @xmath27 is a k3 surface , the rhs simplifies dramatically . moreover , on the lhs we may actually choose each term k3 surfaces @xmath652 of genus @xmath4 , with irreducible line bundles @xmath653 giving the polarization .
that is , @xmath654}(g-1 , 0 ) = \overline{n}^{g - k}_{g - k,[s_g , l_g]}$ ] .
the relative hilbert schemes over the general @xmath655 are all smooth @xcite , so the @xmath656}$ ] are equal to the geometric @xmath657 . summarizing the preceding discussion , [ conj : gconjk3 ] for any @xmath47 , @xmath95}(y ) = \frac{\widetilde{dg}_2(y , q)^k}{\widetilde{\delta}(y , q)}\ ] ] assume conjecture [ dlconj ] .
then conjectures [ gconj ] and [ conj : gconjk3 ] are equivalent . according to proposition [ produc ] ,
from conjecture [ dlconj ] we can deduce that the @xmath634 have a multiplicative generating series .
the two of its components which are made explicit in conjecture [ gconj ] are determined by the case when @xmath27 is a k3 surface , and we have seen that the posited explicit formula is equivalent to that given in conjecture [ conj : gconjk3 ] .
conjecture [ conj : gconjk3 ] is true at @xmath658 .
the relative hilbert schemes over the general @xmath655 are smooth , so the quantity @xmath659}$ ] is the @xmath59 genus of the relative compactified jacobian of the tautological family of curves @xmath660 .
in fact , kawai and yoshioka compute the hodge polynomial of this space @xcite .
alternatively , as in @xcite one may note that the relative compactified jacobian over @xmath661 is birational to the hilbert scheme of points @xmath662}$ ] ; since both are hyperkhler they are deformation equivalent by @xcite , and the hodge polynomial of the hilbert scheme of points was computed in @xcite . in either case
the result is given by the rhs .
we do not know how to compute the @xmath59 genera of relative hilbert schemes over linear subsystems for k3 surfaces .
in fact , while the euler numbers of these spaces are known , the only known calculation of them ( due to maulik , pandharipande , and thomas ) is extremely indirect , and involves at least two uses of the gromov - witten / pairs correspondence @xcite .
rather remarkably , the same series which we have conjectured describes the @xmath663 is found in @xcite to encode _ all _ the euler numbers of relative hilbert schemes over linear subsystems .
@xcite [ thm : mpt ] for each @xmath4 , let @xmath664 be a k3 surface of genus @xmath4 , and assume @xmath653 is irreducible .
let @xmath101 be the hyperplane class on @xmath661 .
then for any @xmath47 , @xmath665}_{|l_g| } } c_{n+g - k}(t \cc^{[n]}_{|l_g| } ) \cdot \rho^*(h^k ) \\\ ] ] comparing powers of @xmath191 , we see that given @xcite , conjecture [ conj : gconjk3 ] is equivalent to the following statement : [ conj : tryresidue ] let @xmath99 be a @xmath100 surface of genus @xmath4 with @xmath28 irreducible . for all @xmath47 , @xmath103 } = \sum_{n=0}^\infty y^{n+1-g } \int_{\cc^{[n]}_{|l| } } c_{n+g - k}(t \cc^{[n]}_{|l|})\cdot \rho^*(h^k)\ ] ] the statement of theorem [ thm : mpt ] in @xcite differs slightly ; there are some signs owing to the use of @xmath666 rather than @xmath667 , and it is formulated in terms of the space of `` stable pairs '' rather than the relative hilbert scheme .
but since @xmath653 is irreducible , these are the same space as per ( * ? ? ?
* appendix b ) . in the language of @xcite , conjecture [ conj : tryresidue ] may be viewed as asserting that the @xmath634 encode certain descendent integrals in the stable pairs theory , or equivalently in the gromov - witten theory .
we may instead specialize to abelian surfaces .
let @xmath668 denote a primitively polarized abelian surface with @xmath669 and hence @xmath670 and @xmath671 ; assume @xmath28 is irreducible .
note such surfaces exist for all @xmath672 .
equation [ eq : ms ] specializes to @xmath673 } q^{g-1 } = \sum_{l = k+1}^\infty \overline{m}_{k,[a]}(l,0)q^l = \widetilde{dg}_2(y , q)^k d\widetilde{dg}_2 ( y , q)\ ] ] the above formula is not equivalent to conjecture [ gconj ] , since @xmath674 .
moreover we do not know how to establish it , even at @xmath658 .
however : assume conjecture [ dlconj ] or @xmath604 .
conjecture [ gconj ] is equivalent to the following two formulas : @xmath675 } q^{g-1 } & = & \widetilde{\delta}(y , q)^{-1 } \\
\label{gforma } \sum_{g=2}^\infty \overline{n}^{g-2}_{g-2,[a , l_g ] } q^{g-1 } & = & d \widetilde{dg}_2(y , q)\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is enough to show that the given invariants of the complete linear system suffice to determine the series @xmath676 and then apply the residue trick explained above . but @xmath677}(y )
= { \mathop{\text{\rm coeff}}}_{s^{g-2 } } a_1(y , s)^{2g-2}$ ] . beginning at @xmath678 this allows to iteratively determine the coefficients of @xmath206
. then @xmath679}(y ) = { \mathop{\text{\rm coeff}}}_{s^g } a_1(y , s)^{2g-2 } a_4(y , s)^{24}$ ] ; since we now know @xmath206 this determines @xmath680 .
as we have established equation [ gformk3 ] , it remains only to compute the invariants for complete linear systems on abelian surfaces . in the future we hope to do so by the methods of @xcite
the _ severi degrees _ @xmath681 are the numbers of @xmath24-nodal reduced degree @xmath682 curves in @xmath683 though @xmath684 general points . the famous caporaso - harris formula @xcite gives a recursive method of computing the severi degrees .
the recursion involves the _ relative severi degrees _ @xmath685 which count delta - nodal curves with tangency conditions along a fixed line in @xmath683 . more generally , for a line bundle @xmath28 on a surface @xmath27 , one can define the _ severi degree _
@xmath686 as the number of @xmath24-nodal reduced curves in @xmath102 though @xmath687 general points , provided this number is finite .
we begin by a review of the caporaso - harris recursion formula ; we will use the more general formulation of vakil @xcite , which also applies to rational ruled surfaces . by a _ sequence _ we mean a collection @xmath688 of nonnegative integers , almost all of which are zero .
we write @xmath682 for the sequence @xmath689 and @xmath690 for the sequence whose @xmath47-th element is @xmath122 and all other ones @xmath691 . for two sequences
@xmath692 , @xmath693 we define @xmath694 , @xmath695 , @xmath696 , @xmath697 .
we write @xmath698 to mean @xmath699 for all @xmath20 . throughout this section
we take @xmath27 to be @xmath683 or a rational ruled surface . in case @xmath700 , let @xmath132 be a line in @xmath683 , in case @xmath27 is a rational ruled surface @xmath701 , let @xmath132 be the class of the section with @xmath702 .
we denote @xmath101 the hyperplane class on @xmath683 , @xmath159 the class of a fibre on @xmath703 .
[ chrec ] @xcite let @xmath28 be a line bundle on @xmath27 and let @xmath692 , @xmath693 be sequences with @xmath704 , and let @xmath705 be an integer
. let @xmath706 .
the relative severi degrees @xmath707 are recursively given as follows : @xmath708 if @xmath709 .
if @xmath710 , then @xmath711 here the second sum runs through all @xmath712 satisfying the condition @xmath713 * initial conditions : * if @xmath714 we have @xmath708 unless we are in one of the following cases 1 . in case
@xmath700 we put @xmath715 , 2 . in case @xmath716 , let @xmath159 be the class of a fibre of the ruling ; we put @xmath717 .
we put @xmath718 . in case @xmath700 , we write @xmath719 and @xmath720 we formally introduce a refinement of this recursion . [ refchrec ] with the same notations , assumptions , limits of summation , and initial values as for the relative severi degrees in recursion [ chrec ] , we define the refined relative severi degrees @xmath721 for @xmath710 by : @xmath722 we abbreviate @xmath723 , and , in case @xmath700 , @xmath724 , @xmath725 . as with the refined invariants ,
we define normalized refined relative severi degrees which are laurent polynomials in @xmath726 , symmetric under @xmath727 .
the _ normalized ( relative ) refined severi degrees _
@xmath728 are defined by @xmath729 the @xmath730 are determined by the same initial conditions as the @xmath721 and the recursion @xmath731_y \cdot \overline n^{l,\delta}(\alpha+e_k,\beta - e_k ) + \sum_{\alpha',\beta',\delta ' } \left(\prod_i [ i]_y^{\beta_i'-\beta_i}\right ) \binom{\alpha}{\alpha'}\binom{\beta'}{\beta } \overline n^{l - e,\delta'}(\alpha',\beta')\ ] ] with the same conditions on @xmath712 as above .
in particular @xmath730 is symmetric under @xmath727 .
it is enough to prove that every summand on the right hand side of is obtained from the corresponding summand of by multiplying by @xmath732 .
each summand in the first sum is multiplied by @xmath733 with @xmath734 each summand in the second sum is multiplied by @xmath733 with @xmath735 where we use @xmath736 .
it is clear that the recursions for the refined severi degrees specialize at @xmath293 to the recursion for the usual severi degrees .
thus , @xmath737 . according to @xcite ,
if the general @xmath29 contains no non - reduced curves and no curves containing components with negative self intersection , the severi degrees are computed by the universal formulas : @xmath738}$ ] .
we expect the same for refined severi degrees .
[ ref - sev ] let @xmath27 be @xmath683 or a rational ruled surface , let @xmath28 be a line bundle , and assume @xmath29 contains no non - reduced curves and no curves containing components with negative self intersection
. then the refined severi degrees are computed by the universal formulas : @xmath739}$ ] .
explicitly , 1 .
on @xmath683 we have @xmath740}$ ] , for @xmath741 .
2 . on @xmath742
we have @xmath743}^\delta$ ] for @xmath744 .
3 . on @xmath703 with @xmath745 , we have @xmath746}$ ] for @xmath747 .
directly from the defining recursion [ refchrec ] we have computed all the @xmath748 for @xmath749 and @xmath750 .
assuming the vanishing conjecture [ dlconj ] and part ( 1 ) of conjecture [ ref - sev ] , the refined severi degrees suffice to determine all the power series in corollary [ produc ] or equivalently in conjecture [ gconj ] .
note that recursion [ refchrec ] is much more computationally tractable than equivariant localization . thus under the above assumption , we have verified conjecture [ gconj ] modulo @xmath751 and determined @xmath89 and @xmath90 modulo @xmath751 .
denote by @xmath752 the irreducible severi degrees , i.e. informally the number of irreducible @xmath24-nodal curves in @xmath753 passing though @xmath754 general points .
in @xcite getzler observes in the case @xmath700 that the @xmath755 can be expressed in terms of the severi degrees @xmath681 by the relation @xmath756 the generalization of this to @xmath752 is in @xcite .
the same formula can be used to define the irreducible normalized refined severi degrees @xmath757 by @xmath758 and the irreducible refined severi degrees by @xmath759 . here
@xmath760 are elements of the novikov ring , i.e. @xmath761 . evidently @xmath757 is a laurent polynomial in @xmath258 invariant under @xmath727 , and @xmath762 .
@xcite @xmath763 has nonnegative integer coefficients . from this positivity
, one can conclude vanishing results for @xmath763 from the analogous ( known ) results for @xmath752 .
for instance @xmath764 for @xmath765 since there are no irreducible curves of cogenus greater than @xmath766 .
we list the first few of the @xmath767 .
write @xmath768 .
we have computed the @xmath769 for @xmath770 .
we have @xmath771 on @xmath742 we have computed the @xmath772 for @xmath773 .
we list the first few ; write @xmath774 .
we have @xmath775 now we compute the specialization of the refined severi degrees at @xmath120 . for a sequence @xmath693
we write @xmath776 [ chi0 ] @xmath777 in particular @xmath778 .
it is easy to see that the statement holds for the initial values .
setting @xmath120 in the recursion formula gives the two recursion formulas @xmath779 the first formula gives @xmath780 the second formula shows in particular that @xmath781 is independent of @xmath692 , thus @xmath782 ; the last equality is by .
thus @xmath783 finally , writing @xmath784 with @xmath785 , we prove @xmath786 by induction over @xmath787 . by induction the second equation of becomes @xmath788
thus we need to show the identity @xmath789 note that by the the multinomial formula we have @xmath790 thus the right hand side of becomes @xmath791=(1+t)^{g(l)}.\ ] ] using the tropical interpretation of the @xmath792 of @xcite using refined multiplicities ( see also section [ sec : rrt ] ) , this result has been generalized in @xcite to arbitrary toric surfaces . for @xmath423 a line bundle on @xmath27 , let @xmath793}$ ] , where @xmath794}\to s^{(n)}$ ] and @xmath795 are the natural morphisms , and @xmath796 is the @xmath797 projection .
it is well - known that @xmath798}}=(k_s)_n$ ] .
[ sca ] @xmath799},\lambda^k(l^{[n]})^\vee)x^kq^n= \frac{(1+xq)^{\chi(l^\vee)}}{(1-q)^{\chi(\oo_s)}}.\ ] ] this is a corollary to ( * ? ? ?
5.2.1 ) , which implies for line bundles @xmath800 on @xmath27 that @xmath801},\lambda^kl^{[n]}\otimes m_n)=\binom{\chi(l\otimes m)}{k}\binom{\chi(m)+n - k-1}{n - k}$ ] .
we apply this with @xmath802 .
thus we have by applying serre duality on @xmath443}$ ] and on @xmath27 : @xmath803},\lambda^k(l^{[n]})^\vee)=\chi(s^{[n]},\lambda^kl^{[n]}\otimes ( k_s)_n)\\&= \binom{\chi(l\otimes k_s)}{k}\binom{\chi(k_s)+n - k-1}{n - k}=\binom{\chi(l^\vee)}{k}\binom{\chi(\oo_s)+n - k-1}{n - k},\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is equivalent to the statement of the lemma .
[ chi01 ] @xmath804}(0)=0 $ ] for @xmath805 , and for all @xmath806 we have @xmath804}(0)(0)=\binom{\chi(l^\vee)}{l}=\binom{g(l)+\chi(\oo_s)-1}{l}$ ] . in particular if @xmath27 is a rational surface , then @xmath80}(0)=\binom{g(l)}{\delta}$ ] .
let @xmath807 be the universal curve over the sublinear system @xmath808 . by proposition [ prop : hilbgenus ]
, we have @xmath809}_\delta)={\mathop{\text{\rm res}}}_{x=0}\int_{s^{[n ] } } \left(\frac{1}{1-e^{-x}}\right)^{\delta+1}\frac{c_n(l^{[n]}\cdot e^x)td(s^{[n]})}{td(l^{[n]}\cdot e^x)}dx.\ ] ] note that by definition @xmath810}\cdot e^x)}{td(l^{[n]}\cdot e^x)}=\sum_{k=0}^n ( -e^{-x})^k { \operatorname{ch}}(\lambda^k(l^{[n]})^\vee).$ ] thus by riemann - roch @xmath809}_\delta)={\mathop{\text{\rm res}}}_{x=0}\left[\left(\frac{1}{1-e^{-x}}\right)^{\delta+1}\sum_{k=0}^n ( -e^{-x})^k \chi(s^{[n]},\lambda^k(l^{[n]})^\vee)dx\right].\ ] ] we put @xmath811 and apply lemma [ sca ] to obtain @xmath812}_\delta)q^n&=-{\mathop{\text{\rm res}}}_{t=1}\left[\left(\frac{1}{1-t}\right)^{\delta+1}\sum_{n\ge 0}\sum_{k=0}^n ( -t)^kq^n \chi(s^{[n]},\lambda^k(l^{[n]})^\vee)\frac{dt}{t}\right]\\ & = -{\mathop{\text{\rm res}}}_{t=1}\left[\left(\frac{1}{1-t}\right)^{\delta+1}\frac{(1-tq)^{\chi(l^\vee)}}{(1-q)^{\chi(\oo_s ) } } \frac{dt}{t}\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting @xmath813 this becomes @xmath814}_\delta)q^n={\mathop{\text{\rm res}}}_{\alpha=0}\left[\frac{1}{\alpha^{\delta+1 } } \frac{(1-q+\alpha q)^{\chi(l^\vee)}}{(1-q)^{\chi(\oo_s)}}\sum_{l\ge 0}\alpha^l d\alpha \right]\\ & = \sum_{l=0}^\delta \binom{\chi(l^\vee)}{l } q^l(1-q)^{\chi(l^\vee)-l-\chi(\oo_s)}= \sum_{l=0}^\delta \binom{\chi(l^\vee)}{l } q^l(1-q)^{g(l)-l-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] proposition [ chi01 ] and proposition [ chi0 ] can be subsummed in the following statements : 1 . for any line bundle @xmath28 on a surface
@xmath27 we have @xmath610}(0 ) q^\delta=(1+q)^{\chi(l^\vee)}.\ ] ] 2 .
if @xmath28 is an effective divisor on @xmath683 or a rational ruled surface @xmath27 , then @xmath610}(0)n^{l,\delta}(0 ) q^\delta=(1+q)^{g(l)}=\sum_{\delta\ge 0 } n_{\delta,[s , l]}^\delta(0 ) q^\delta.\ ] ] we want to give a conjectural extension of these two statements to higher powers of @xmath258 .
we start with the analogue of ( 1 ) [ yconj ] let @xmath28 be a line bundle on a surface @xmath27 .
then we have for all @xmath815 @xmath816}(y ) q^\delta\right ] = ( 1+q)^{\chi(l^\vee)-3i}p^i_{l}(q).\ ] ] here @xmath817 is a polynomial in @xmath191 of degree at most @xmath818 . in particular if @xmath819 then @xmath820}(y)=0 $ ] for @xmath821 .
assuming conjecture [ dlconj ] we get by remark [ produc ] @xmath822}^\delta(y ) q^\delta = f_1^{\chi(l^\vee)}f_2^{lk_s/2}f_3^{k_s^2}f_4^{\chi(\oo_s)},\ ] ] with @xmath823[[q]]$ ] we put @xmath824 , @xmath825 , @xmath826 , @xmath827 . [ ciconj ] for @xmath828 we have @xmath829[[y^{1/3}q]]\cap { { \bbb q}}[q][[y]]$ ] . assuming conjecture [ ciconj ] , conjecture [ yconj ] holds .
furthermore @xmath830 by definition @xmath831}^\delta(y(1+q)^3 ) q^{\delta}.\ ] ] therefore @xmath832}^\delta(y ) q^{\delta}\right]=(1+q)^{\chi(l^\vee)-3i}{\mathop{\text{\rm coeff}}}_{y^i}\left[c_1^{\chi(l^\vee ) } c_2^{lk_s/2}c_3^{k_s^2}c_4^{\chi(\oo_s)}\right].\ ] ] as by conjecture [ ciconj ] all @xmath833 are in @xmath606[[y^{1/3}q]]$ ] , we see that the coefficient of @xmath834 is a polynomial of degree at most @xmath818 in @xmath835 .
conjecture [ ciconj ] has been verified modulo @xmath589 .
assuming conjecture [ ref - sev ] it has been verified modulo @xmath751 .
we list the power series @xmath836 , @xmath837 , @xmath838 , @xmath839 modulo @xmath840 .
@xmath841 now we formulate the conjectural analogue of ( 2 ) . for simplicity
we only deal with the case of @xmath683 and @xmath842 . 1 .
let @xmath700 and assume @xmath843 , then @xmath844=(1+q)^{g(dh)-3i}p^i_{dh}(q).\ ] ] 2 .
let @xmath845 and assume @xmath846 , then @xmath847=(1+q)^{g(nf+mg)-3i}p^i_{nf+mg}(q).\ ] ] for @xmath770 , and for @xmath848 this conjecture has been checked modulo @xmath589 and , assuming conjecture [ ref - sev ] , modulo @xmath751 .
mikhalkin @xcite has shown that the severi degrees of projective toric surfaces can also be computed using tropical geometry : the severi degrees @xmath686 count with multiplicities simple tropical curves through @xmath849 points in @xmath850 in tropical general position . roughly speaking
a simple tropical curve @xmath10 is a trivalent graph @xmath851 immersed in @xmath850 together with some extra data . from this data ,
one assigns to each vertex @xmath852 of @xmath851 a multiplicity @xmath853 and defines the _ complex multiplicity @xmath854 _ as the product of the @xmath855 over the vertices of @xmath851 . in @xcite a proof of the caporaso - harris recursion formula
is given via tropical geometry .
the analogues of the gromov - witten invariants in real algebraic geometry are the welschinger invariants @xcite .
these were originally defined to count real pseudoholomorphic curves in real symplectic manifolds .
we restrict attention to the case that @xmath27 is a smooth projective toric surface .
as toric varieties are defined over @xmath856 , they certainly carry a real structure , and we write @xmath306 for the associated anti - holomorphic involution .
a real curve in @xmath27 is an algebraic curve @xmath857 with @xmath858 , and the real locus of @xmath10 is @xmath859 .
fix a generic set @xmath403 of @xmath687 general real the numbers @xmath860 which count real curves passing through @xmath861 real points and @xmath862 pairs of complex conjugate points . ]
points on @xmath27 .
the real enumerative invariant is @xmath863 , where @xmath10 runs through the possibly reducible real curves @xmath864 of geometric genus @xmath865 , passing through all the points of @xmath403 , and @xmath866 is the number of isolated real nodes of @xmath10 , i.e. the points where @xmath10 analytically locally has the equation @xmath867 .
we denoted by @xmath868 the corresponding sum for irreducible curves . if @xmath27 is an unnodal ( i.e. it contains no rational curve with self intersection @xmath869 , with @xmath870 ) del pezzo surface then the real enumerative invariants coincide with the welschinger invariants . in @xcite
it was proven that @xmath871 , i.e. the count of curves of geometric genus @xmath691 , is independent of the generic @xmath403 .
we will denote it just by @xmath872 .
in general @xmath873 and @xmath874 will depend on @xmath403 via a system of walls and chambers . in a sense
, we have already seen these invariants . for a family of real curves
@xmath394 , let @xmath875 be defined by the same formula as the @xmath301 introduced for individual curves in section [ sec : curve ]
. then we have : let @xmath28 be a real line bundle on @xmath27 , and let @xmath29 be a linear subsystem determined by the real point conditions @xmath403 .
assume that all curves in @xmath66 are reduced , that no curves have cogenus greater than @xmath24 , and that all curves of cogenus @xmath24 are nodal .
then @xmath876 the real enumerative invariants of toric surfaces can also be computed via tropical geometry ( * ? ? ?
* thm . 6 ) . for any real line bundle @xmath28 and any @xmath705 ,
the tropical welschinger invariant @xmath877 counts simple tropical curves in @xmath10 in @xmath102 passing through @xmath754 points in @xmath850 in tropically general position . here
the tropical curves @xmath10 are counted with the _ welschinger multiplicity @xmath878 _ : @xmath879 the irreducible welschinger invariants @xmath880 are defined by summing over only irreducible curves . it is proven in @xcite that this is independent of the points as long as they are in tropical general position .
finally @xcite shows that there exists a set @xmath403 of @xmath687 real points of @xmath27 , so that @xmath881 , and @xmath882 . if @xmath27 is @xmath683 or a rational ruled surface , there is a recursion for the tropical welschinger invariants @xcite .
we write it in a modified form which makes the close relation to the recursion for the severi degrees more evident .
let @xmath28 be a line bundle on @xmath27 and let @xmath692 , @xmath693 be odd sequences with @xmath704 , and a let @xmath705 be an integer . with the same notations and assumptions and initial values as for the relative severi degrees in recursion [ chrec ]
the relative tropical welschinger invariants @xmath884 are given by the following recursion formula : if @xmath710 , @xmath885 here the second sum runs through all odd sequences @xmath886 and all @xmath887 satisfying .
in particular , the recursion for the refined severi degrees interpolates between the caporaso - harris recursion for severi degrees and the itenberg - kharlamov - shustin recursion for tropical welschinger invariants .
thus , in @xcite , block and the first author relate the refined severi degrees to tropical geometry and study them by the methods of tropical geometry .
they introduce the refined multiplicity @xmath894_y$ ] , which specializes to @xmath855 at @xmath293 and to @xmath895 at @xmath0 .
then the refined tropical severi degrees @xmath896 are defined by counting curves with multiplicity @xmath897 .
note this definition applies to any smooth toric surface .
it is shown that , for @xmath700 or a rational ruled surface , and @xmath403 a `` vertically stretched '' configuration of points , the @xmath896 satisfy the recursion .
thus @xmath898 .
itenberg and mikhalkin have in the meantime shown in @xcite that @xmath896 is independent of @xmath403 , and so we drop it from the notation . for @xmath899 or a rational ruled surface , conjecture [ ref - sev ]
then implies that the @xmath900 agree with the @xmath621}$ ] when @xmath28 is @xmath24 very ample .
more generally one expects : [ conj : bg ] @xcite let @xmath27 be a smooth projective toric surface and @xmath28 a real line bundle on @xmath27 .
if @xmath28 is @xmath24-very ample , then @xmath901 } = \overline{n}^{\delta , l}_{\trop}$ ] . using the refined multiplicity , in @xcite the @xmath896
are studied using methods similar to those employed in @xcite for the nonrefined severi degrees .
in particular it is shown that , for @xmath28 sufficiently ample with respect to @xmath24 , they are given by refined node polynomials , and the conjecture says that these agree with the @xmath901}$ ] .
[ gsconj ] @xmath904}(-1)\overline g_2(\tau)^\delta=\frac { ( \overline g_2(\tau)/q)^{\chi(l)}b_1(-1,q)^{k_s^2}b_2(-1,q)^{lk_s } } { \big(\eta(\tau)^{16}\eta(2\tau)^2\ , d\overline g_2(\tau)/q^2\big)^{\chi(o_s)/2}}\ ] ] this conjecture has been checked modulo @xmath905 and the coefficients of @xmath906 have been determined modulo @xmath905 .
( these computations are numerically easier than those involving the indeterminate @xmath258 , thus we get to a higher order in @xmath191 ) .
the values of the series @xmath620 are computed to be : @xmath907 when @xmath908 or a rational ruled surface , the severi degrees @xmath909 agree with the universal numbers @xmath910}$ ] somewhat beyond the regime where @xmath28 is @xmath24 very ample .
specifically , it is conjectured in @xcite and proven in @xcite that it suffices for the general @xmath29 to contain no nonreduced curves , and no curves containing components with negative self intersection .
we expect the same to hold for the comparison between refined severi degrees @xmath911 and the universal numbers @xmath912}$ ] , and a fortiori for the specialization at @xmath123 .
however for this specialization more seems to be true : [ welam ] assume @xmath700 or @xmath716 , and the following subloci of @xmath102 have codimension more than @xmath24 : ( 1 ) the nonreduced curves with a component of multiplicity at least @xmath913 , ( 2 ) curves containing a component with negative self intersection .
then @xmath914}^\delta(-1)$ ] .
explicitly the condition amounts to : using the recursion formula this conjecture has been checked for @xmath921 . assuming ( 1 ) of conjecture [ welam ] , and using the recursion formula the conjecture [ gsconj ] has been checked modulo @xmath922 and @xmath923 and @xmath924 have been determined modulo @xmath922 .
note that the recursion for @xmath925 is much more efficient than those of the @xmath926 or @xmath685 because only odd sequences @xmath692 and @xmath693 occur .
we have seen @xmath927 . in the sufficiently ample setting ,
taking a linear system @xmath66 determined by subtropical point conditions , and assuming all conjectures , this implies @xmath928 .
more generally we conjecture : [ conj : harnack ] let @xmath28 be a sufficiently ample real line bundle on a real toric surface , and let @xmath29 be determined by a subtropical collection of point conditions .
then the signatures of the relative hilbert schemes agree with the compactly supported euler characteristics of their real loci .
that is , @xmath929}_{{{\bbb p}}^\delta } ) = \chi_c(\cc^{[n]}_{{{\bbb p}}^\delta}({{\bbb r}}))$ ] . making the bps change of variables
, it follows that @xmath930 .
this has been the subject of some classical study , one general result being that for a `` m - variety '' , i.e. one for which the total dimension of the @xmath932 cohomology is equal for the real and complex locus , the equality holds modulo 16 @xcite .
evidently the equality holds for any variety whose class in the grothendieck ring of varieties over @xmath933 lies inside @xmath934 $ ] .
in particular , @xmath935 , toric surfaces , and hilbert schemes of points on toric surfaces qualify .
the relative hilbert schemes are cut out of a product of these by a section of a vector bundle , and the signature behaves predictably under taking such sections .
thus , to study conjecture [ conj : harnack ] it would also suffice to give criteria for the euler characteristic of the real locus to exhibit the same behavior .
in @xcite it is shown this holds in a tropical sense for complete intersections in toric varieties .
the conjectured relation between the refined invariants at @xmath936 and the welschinger invariants is in a sense a global analogue of a conjecture of van straten ( * ? ? ?
4.6 , 4.7 ) ( see also theorems [ duco ] and [ thm : realmult ] above and the nearby discussion ) . | we define refined invariants which `` count '' nodal curves in sufficiently ample linear systems on surfaces , conjecture that their generating function is multiplicative , and conjecture explicit formulas in the case of k3 and abelian surfaces .
we also give a refinement of the caporaso - harris recursion , and conjecture that it produces the same invariants in the sufficiently ample setting .
the refined recursion specializes at @xmath0 to the itenberg - kharlamov - shustin recursion for welschinger invariants .
we find similar interactions between refined invariants of individual curves and real invariants of their versal families . |
the extreme cases of star formation ( sf ) in the universe are exhibited by classes of galaxies such as luminous infrared galaxies ( lirgs ; defined as galaxies with ir luminosities of @xmath2 ) and ultra - luminous ir galaxies ( ulirgs ; @xmath3 ) and as a result , it is impossible to discuss the phenomenon of extreme sf in the universe without the mention of lirgs and ulirgs .
these galaxies are good laboratories to attempt to understand the nature and detailed mechanism of these exotic forms of sf and they have been the focus of many studies ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
it has long been clear that very strong star forming galaxies in the local universe are related to mergers and interactions ( e.g. * ? ? ? * and references therein ) .
their ir output correlates with the level of their interaction and merger stage , with low-@xmath1 galaxies being often associated with early stages of interactions while the high-@xmath1 ones , especially ulirgs , are usually in later stages of merging , or are merger remnants . at higher redshifts
the situation is less clear , however .
some observational studies show that high-@xmath4 lirgs and ulirgs are in fact forming stars in more modest and quiescent fashions with minimal contribution from interactions and mergers @xcite .
herschel space observatory studies have revealed that levels of sf which would be considered extreme locally originate in the `` main sequence '' of spiral - like star forming galaxies defined by a tight sfr-(@xmath5 ) trend in the high redshift universe @xcite .
this sf scenario is also supported by numerical simulations , according to which steady accretion of cold gas is the driving mechanism for high sf rates , and consequently lirgs and ulirgs at high redshift should be dominated by extended disky morphology and more quiescent form of sf @xcite . on the other hand ,
there are studies indicating that extreme sf at high-@xmath4 is not much different from the local universe @xcite in that a significant fraction of lirgs and ulirgs experience a violent central starburst suggesting the importance of mergers and interactions to acquire their gas .
these studies further revealed that the @xmath1 output of these classes of galaxies at @xmath6 is tightly correlated with their morphology , like their local counterparts : the fraction of mergers and interaction increases with @xmath1 while the fraction of disk - like objects declines with @xmath1 . from the discussion above , it is clear that galaxy interaction and merger are some of the mechanisms driving extreme form of star formation though the extent of their influence as a function of cosmic time is arguable .
this sends a clear message that galaxy environment has a role to play in the matter .
global environment is one form of environment that has influence on extreme form of star formation ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * ) and hence understanding the global environment in detail can shed light on the mechanisms of the extreme form of star formation in the local universe which , in turn , helps to construct a clear picture of its time evolution .
the global environment of lirgs is not generally much investigated to date in stark contrast to studies conducted on their immediate surroundings ( within tens of kpc ) and on their one - to - one interaction ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
the few studies conducted so far were based on number counts of galaxies to measure global environments of lirgs , and they seem to agree that these galaxies do not live in cluster environments . @xcite studied the mpc scale global environment of lirgs and concluded that they preferentially live in group environments and avoid cluster and field environments .
another study by @xcite concluded that local lirgs and ulirgs do not live in cluster environments .
this work attempts to further constrain the global environments of lirgs using a different approach . instead of the traditional galaxy count
, we use the sizes of host dark matter halos as a measure of global environments .
in this work , we have made use of volume - limited samples extracted from two redshift surveys : the iras point source redshift survey ( pscz ; @xcite ) and the 2mass redshift survey ( 2mrs ; @xcite ) .
our main objective is to study the local environments of ir galaxies , especially lirgs , in terms of the size of the dark matter halos that they are associated with .
the ir - selected sample from the iras pscz catalogue is used as the target sample , and is hereafter referred to as the target galaxy sample . the k - band selected sample from the 2mrs
was used to identify groups based on the mass of their dark matter halo , and is hereafter referred to as the density field sample .
this 2mrs sample was also used as a control galaxy sample to compare with the target sample .
we constructed volume - limited samples from the 2mrs survey in order to satisfy two requirements .
first , the volume enclosed by the volume - limited sample redshift limit must have a maximum number of 2mrs galaxies , and second , when the same redshift limit is applied to the target galaxy sample , the resulting volume - limited pscz sample must have a statistically reasonable number of lirgs . using these criteria , we selected a 2mrs volume - limited sample with @xmath7 and @xmath8 . in order to probe down to lower halo masses
, we also chose a second sample with @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
hereafter , these @xmath9 and 0.024 samples are referred to as v2m1 and v2m2 and they contain 5044 and 5457 galaxies , respectively . for both 2mrs volume - limited samples , we constructed corresponding target galaxy volume - limited samples from pscz .
the maximum redshift for each sample was fixed to that of the corresponding density field 2mrs sample described above .
the choice of the minimum @xmath1 limit for these target galaxy samples was made in such a way as to include the lirgs of interest in the samples , while at the same time ensuring that the pscz and the 2mrs magnitude limits are roughly similar . in order to do this , we obtained k - band magnitudes for the pscz galaxies by matching to the full 2mass survey , and then studied the resulting relation between @xmath11 and @xmath1 ( see fig .
[ fig : mk_lir ] ) . a simple fit to this data yields the relation @xmath12 .
while there is obvious scatter in this relation due to different populations of galaxies in the sample , it is satisfactory for the purpose of setting a statistical flux limit for the sample ; no physical parameters are derived from the relation . according to this relation , our 2mrs sample limit of @xmath13 corresponds to an ir luminosity of @xmath14 , which is safely higher than the pscz completeness limit in these volumes and
is close to the nominal lirg limit of @xmath15 .
therefore , @xmath16 was chosen as the luminosity limit for both pscz volume - limited samples .
this ensures that the k - band luminosities of our target and control samples are roughly similar .
we have checked that the exact choice of the @xmath1 limit within the scatter range evident in the figure [ fig : mk_lir ] makes no difference to the final results .
the pscz volume - limited samples are hence characterized by the following redshift and @xmath1 limits : @xmath9 and @xmath17 , and @xmath18 and @xmath17 .
hereafter , we refer to these samples as vp1 and vp2 respectively .
the magnitude and redshift limits of all samples described above are summarized in table [ tab : mk_vol_table1 ] . and
@xmath1 values of pscz galaxies .
the @xmath11 values are estimated from matching the pscz galaxies to the 2mass survey .
the line represents the best fit , and is used to decide the luminosity limit of the iras galaxiy volume - limited samples . ] c c c c name & magnitude limit & @xmath19 & no . of galaxies + v2m1 & @xmath10 & 0.02 & 5044 + v2m2 & @xmath8 & 0.024 & 5457 + vp1 & @xmath20 & 0.02 & 290 + vp2 & @xmath20 & 0.024 & 565 + + groups from the two 2mrs volume - limited samples
were identified using the well - known friends - of - friends @xmath21 group finding algorithm ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the algorithm is specifically custom - designed by @xcite so that it groups together galaxies living in the same dark matter halo .
table [ tab : identifid_systems ] shows the breakdown of the total number of identified systems into isolated galaxies , pairs , and systems with more than two galaxies .
c c c c c name & isolated & pairs & @xmath22 3 galaxies + & systems & & & + v2m1 & 2291 & 882 & 1871 + v2m2 & 2592 & 982 & 1883 + + the k - band group luminosity is computed for each of the identified groups by summing up the k - band light of the individual detected galaxies in the groups .
the total k - band absolute magnitude of a group is thus defined as @xmath23 where @xmath24 are the k - band absolute magnitudes of the individual galaxies in a group .
this group magnitude is not equal to the actual total magnitude of the group because the underlying 2mrs samples are only complete to a certain absolute magnitude limit .
we thus only use these computed group magnitudes to determine the rank order of groups according to k - band luminosity .
we then assume a monotonic relation between a group s luminosity and the mass of its underlying dark matter halo to assign rough virial masses to our groups ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
specifically , we match the measured space density of ranked groups to the theoretical space density of dark matter halos that is predicted by the concordance cosmological model @xcite . this technique is usually referred to as `` abundance matching '' .
we note that this method assumes no scatter in mass at a given luminosity and the result is only meant to produce approximate statistical values of halo mass .
the right ascension and declination of the groups are defined by the centroid of the group members , and the mean redshift @xmath25 of the group is calculated from a simple mean of all the individual members @xmath26 . since groups of galaxies appear stretched in the line - of - sight direction due to radial peculiar velocities of member galaxies , we assume that the identified groups have an approximate cylindrical geometry with a radius equal to their virial radius ( @xmath27 ) given by @xcite and presented as @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the virial mass and @xmath30 is the mean density of the universe .
the length of the cylinder is two times the maximum rotational velocity of the halo , 2@xmath31 , where @xmath31 is determined from the rotational velocity profile that relates velocity and radius . since our ultimate goal in this work is to find out what type of environment , or halo size , iras pscz galaxies are preferentially living in , we correlate the individual pscz galaxies with the 2mrs group catalogue in order to identify the host halo for each target galaxy .
we check whether a particular pscz galaxy belongs to a particular 2mrs group by calculating the distance of the galaxy from the group centre and comparing to the group size .
suppose a target iras galaxy in question has @xmath32 and @xmath33 as the line - of - sight and perpendicular distances respectively from the geometric centre of a particular group .
@xmath34 is then given by @xmath35 for a small angle @xmath36 between the line of sight to the group and the galaxy in question , @xmath37 can be approximated to good accuracy as @xmath38 both distances are given in units of @xmath39 .
a galaxy is considered to be part of a certain group if it lies inside the cylinder defined by @xmath34 and @xmath37 as its length and radius , respectively .
this in other words means that a galaxy belongs to a certain group if @xmath34 @xmath40 @xmath41 and @xmath37 @xmath40 @xmath27 . in cases where a galaxy might lie in the cylinder of more than one group ,
then the three - dimensional distance from each group to the galaxy weighted by the @xmath27 and @xmath42 is calculated as @xmath43 and the galaxy finally belongs to the group with the smallest value of @xmath44 .
we repeat the exact same procedure replacing the pscz target sample with the 2mrs control sample . in other words ,
we associate each 2mrs control galaxy with a group using these cylindrical criteria .
this may seem strange given that 2mrs galaxies were already associated with groups during the group - finding .
however , the cylindrical linking volume that we use for the target sample is not equal to the effective volume resulting from the friends - of - friends algorithm , and it is important to use the same exact criteria for the target and control samples so that they may be directly compared .
now that we have assigned halo masses to both target and control galaxy samples , we can study their halo environments .
note that we do not included cases of isolated iras pscz galaxy systems since no halo mass can be associated to them .
this will not change the trends observed in the plotted range in any way , however .
we estimate the probability distribution of halo masses for pscz galaxies by taking the ratio of the number of pscz galaxies in halo mass bins to the total number of pscz galaxies . the result is shown in red triangles in the two panels of figure [ fig : 2mrs_groupmember_bin ] .
the trends indicate that the probabilities decline with the size of the galaxy systems they are associated with . at the higher mass end ( cluster regime )
the probability is much smaller than at the lower mass end .
we also estimate a similar probability distribution for the 2mrs control samples in order to make a comparison of the lirg s environment with that of the general population of galaxies .
these probability distributions are shown as black squares in the panels of figure [ fig : 2mrs_groupmember_bin ] and they exhibit similar trends as the lirgs . the declining probability with halo mass observed both for the lirgs and the 2mrs samples is simply a reflection of the deficiency of high mass systems ( such as clusters ) as compared to low mass systems @xcite . in order to eliminate this effect from the result and also to make a comparison between the environments of lirgs and 2mass galaxies , we take the ratio of their probability distributions .
the blue solid circles in both panels of figure [ fig : 2mrs_groupmember_bin ] show the relative probability of finding lirgs in a given halo mass with respect to 2mrs control sample galaxies .
error bars on all points are calculated assuming poisson statistics .
these results clearly show that lirgs do not simply trace 2mass galaxies in their distribution of host halo masses .
instead , lirgs have a preference for halos of intermediate ( group size ) masses , avoiding both smaller ( milky way size ) and larger ( cluster size ) halos relative to normal 2mass galaxies .
this effect is fairly large , with the fraction of lirgs in group size systems being as much as @xmath45% larger than the fraction of 2mass galaxies in similar size systems . on the other hand , the fraction of lirgs in clusters or the field are as much as @xmath46% lower than that for normal galaxies .
the two panels of figure [ fig : 2mrs_groupmember_bin ] show that results for the two volume - limited samples are slightly different despite the fact that the lirgs in both cases are the same galaxy types .
if halo finding and mass assignment were perfect then a halo found using a fainter 2mrs sample would also be found with the brighter sample ( with fewer galaxies per halo ) and they would result in the same mass .
the only difference would be some lower mass halos in the fainter sample not being found in the brighter sample , which is reflected by the increasing lower - limit of halo masses going from the top to the bottom panel in figure [ fig : 2mrs_groupmember_bin ] .
however , since the halos are found using two different 2mrs samples , the differences seen at higher masses must be caused by halo identification and mass assignment errors , and possibly also by real cosmic variance since the volumes probed are somewhat different .
nevertheless , the basic trends remain the same in both samples and are thus likely robust against such effects . in the previous section we discussed the sizes of halos that lirgs
are associated with .
however , it is known that the sf properties of galaxy populations in general is also a function of where they are located within their halo environment , for example outskirts vs. central regions of clusters @xcite .
galaxies at the outskirts of galaxy systems tend to have more sf than galaxies falling towards the centre as a result of various processes such as high fly - by interactions @xcite and ram - pressure stripping @xcite that are effective in shutting off sf . in light of this , to better understand the sf - environment relations , it is beneficial to also identify where the lirgs dwell inside their respective halos .
we compute the projected distance ( @xmath47 ) of each lirg from the centre of the halo that it is associated with ( restricting the sample to halos more massive than @xmath48 ) , and then normalize by the halo virial radius ( @xmath27 ) .
figure [ fig : dis_cen_includingfield ] shows these normalized radii versus the @xmath1 values of the individual galaxies .
the different symbols correspond to different halo mass ranges of the galaxy groups .
the red diamonds show the mean values of @xmath49 after binning along the @xmath1 axis in a bin size of 0.1 dex .
these average points in figure [ fig : dis_cen_includingfield ] reveal that there is a correlation between the projected distance and @xmath1 .
galaxies with high @xmath1 , a proxy for the sf rate , are found closer to the centres of their host halos than lower luminosity galaxies .
this average relation is calculated over all halo masses , but breaking it down to smaller halo mass bins ( the different symbols ) does not reveal any clear trend between the location of lirgs within their host halo and the host halo mass .
in this work , we have characterized the local environment of lirg galaxies in terms of the virialized halo that they inhabit , where halos were identified using a galaxy group catalog .
specifically , we have focused on the masses of the halos that host lirgs , as well as their locations within these halos .
based on the mass of the host dark matter halo , the environment of galaxies can be roughly classified into three traditional environmental classes : field , groups , and clusters .
roughly speaking , a dark matter halo with @xmath50 is classified as field ; @xmath51 is classified as a group and @xmath52 is classified as a cluster @xcite . adopting this classification ,
we see from the results in figure [ fig : 2mrs_groupmember_bin ] that lirgs preferentially live in groups relative to normal 2mass galaxies . specifically , the fraction of lirgs in groups is @xmath53% higher than that of normal galaxies , while the fraction of lirgs in the field or in clusters is @xmath46% lower than that of normal galaxies .
the significance of this result is limited by the fairly large error bars that are due to the small size of our lirg sample .
it is important to compile larger volume samples of lirgs in order to improve on the statistics of this study .
the @xmath1 range of the lirgs that are found in association with galaxy systems in both target galaxy samples is in a relatively narrow range in between @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
moreover , the number of galaxies is considerably smaller at the higher @xmath1 end of this range than at the lower end .
hence , we can not extend the results for the entire range of lirgs or into the ulirg regime . in previous work using galaxy counts , we established a correlation between the global environmental density and the @xmath1 values spanning both the lirg and ulirg regimes @xcite . in that work the lirgs with lower @xmath1 values corresponding to those investigated in this paper turned out to also be in the group regime .
we thus confirm our earlier results by establishing the preferred environment of local lirgs using an independent technique and , moreover , defining the environment in a physically meaningful way .
while it is clear that ulirgs tend to be galaxy mergers , or remnants thereof , the reason for the elevated sf of lirgs in particular has not been well established uniquely since they obviously include apparently isolated galaxies in addition to interacting galaxies , mergers and wide pairs .
our results both in this work and in @xcite paint the picture where the larger scale environment of lirgs is something that sets them apart from normal galaxies .
lirgs preferentially live in group environments , and they are under - abundant in cluster _ and _ field environments .
this preferred group size environment supports the hypothesis that star formation in lirgs is driven by interactions and mergers , as is often observed in individual lirg cases @xcite , since groups are the environment where most galaxies interact in the present universe . in the field ,
the density of galaxies is generally too low for mergers to occur , whereas in massive clusters merger timescales are too long .
an alternative hypothesis perhaps supported by these findings is that star formation in lirgs is elevated due to larger scale tidal fields of high - density environments @xcite .
we have also investigated the locations of lirgs within their host halos and found a trend such that more luminous lirgs reside closer to the centres of their host halos than galaxies with lower @xmath1 .
this is perhaps a further indication that galaxy interactions are responsible for high star formation rates in lirgs , since interactions are more likely to occur near the halo centre .
we do not however find any correlation of this trend with halo mass , though this may be due to the small size of our lirg sample .
77 natexlab#1#1 e. f. , papovich c. , wolf c. , le floch e. , caldwell j. a. r. , barden m. , egami e. , mcintosh d. h. , meisenheimer k. , prez - gonzlez p. g. , rieke g. h. , rieke m. j. , rigby j. r. , rix h .- w . , 2005 , apj , 625 , 23 a. a. , frieman j. , weinberg d. h. , blanton m. r. , warren m. s. , abazajian k. , scranton r. , hogg d. w. , scoccimarro r. , bahcall n. a. , brinkmann j. , gott iii j. r. , kleinman s. j. , sdss collaboration 2006 , apjs , 167 , 1 r. g. , quilis v. , balogh m. l. , 2002 , in fusco - femiano r. , matteucci f. , eds , chemical enrichment of intracluster and intergalactic medium vol .
253 of astronomical society of the pacific conference series , feedback and the intra - cluster medium .
p. 435
w. , sutherland w. j. , maddox s. j. , keeble o. , oliver s. j. , rowan - robinson m. , mcmahon r. g. , efstathiou g. p. , tadros h. , white s. d. m. , frenk c. s. , carramiana a. , hawkins m. r. s. , 2000 , mnras , 317 , 55 | this work investigates the preferred environment of local luminous ir galaxies ( lirgs ) in terms of the host halos that they inhabit , and in comparison to a control galaxy sample .
the lirgs are drawn from the iras point source catalogue redshift survey ( pscz ) , while the control sample is drawn from the 2mass redshift survey ( 2mrs ) .
a friends - of - friends algorithm was run on the 2mrs sample to identify galaxies living in the same dark matter halos and the pscz galaxies were then associated with these identified halos .
we show that the relative probability of finding local lirgs with respect to 2mass galaxies is largest in approximately group size halos ( @xmath0 ) , and declines both in the cluster regime and in smaller halos .
this confirms , using a different technique than in previous work , that local lirgs are indeed more abundant in group environments than elsewhere .
we also find a trend between the @xmath1 values of lirgs and their location within their host dark matter halos , such that the average location of lirgs with high ir luminosity is closer to the halo centre than for low ir luminosity galaxies . moreover
, this trend does not seem to depend on halo mass .
+ infrared : galaxies - galaxies : star formation - galaxies : evolution - galaxies : haloes . |
image segmentation is the basic approach in image processing and computer vision @xcite . it is used to locate special regions and then extract information from them .
image segmentation is used to partition an image into different components or objects and is an essential procedure for image preprocessing , object detection and extraction , and object tracking .
image segmentation is also related to edge detection . even though there is no unified theory for image segmentation ,
some practical methods have been studied over the years such as thresholding , edge based segmentation , region growing , clustering ( unsupervised classification ) , and split - and - merge segmentation , to name a few .
@xmath0-connected segmentation is a technique in the category of region growing segmentation .
it was proposed to find an object having the property of gradual variation @xcite
@xcite @xcite @xcite @xcite .
this paper attempts to find an automated way to better determine the parameters for image segmentation , especially the connectivity value of @xmath0 in @xmath0-connected segmentation .
this paper first reviews some major segmentation techniques to explain why segmentation is difficult , and how a special technique would be selected in specific applications .
we then focus on our problem of determining segmentation parameters in @xmath0-connected segmentation .
based on the philosophies of the maximum entropy method and otsu s minimum variance method , we propose : ( 1)maximum entropy connectedness determination : a method that uses maximum entropy to determine @xmath0 value , and ( 2 ) minimum variance connectedness determination : a method that uses the principle of minimum variance to determine @xmath0 value . applying these optimization techniques in real images ,
the experimental results have shown the great promise of the new methods . in the end , we extend the above method to a more general case in order to compare it with the famous mumford - shah method that uses variational principle and geometric measure @xcite .
in this section , we first review currect technology of image segmentation : five types of techniques , their characteristics , and uses .
we then focus on the connectedness - based image segmentation technique . as we know
, there is no unified theory for image segmentation , some practical methods have been studied over the years such as thresholding , edge based segmentation , region growing , clustering ( unsupervised classification , e.g. k - mean or fuzzy c - mean ) , and split - and - merge segmentation .
these segmentation algorithms have been developed for solving different problems @xcite .
however , they are all based on one or more of the five philosophies listed below : \(1 ) a segment is a class / cluster , so one can use a classification / clustering method to segment the image .
classification methods usually do not need to use the location / position information .
clustering for unsupervised classification technology can perform better to find an object for sampled points within the subset of data frames .
typical techniques include isodata and k - mean or fuzzy c - mean .
@xmath1-mean or fuzzy @xmath2-mean is a standard classification method that is often used in image segmentation @xcite .
this method classifies the pixels into different groups in order to minimize the total `` errors , '' where the `` error '' is the distance from the pixel value to the center of its own group .
\(2 ) a segment is a homogeneous region .
if an object or region can be identified by absolute intensity ( the pixel value ) , we usually use threshold segmentation . in other words
, an object will be recognized as a geometrically connected region whose values / intensities are between a certain high - limit and a low - limit .
we usually assume that the high limit is the highest value of the image .
therefore , in practice , one only needs to determine the low - limit .
maximum entropy and minimum variance ( also called otsu s method ) are two of the most popular methods for determining the best threshold for single image @xcite .
multilevel thresholding is similar to threshold segmentation and uses the same philosophy , but multiple thresholds are produced at once .
it needs an extremely high time cost for computation @xcite @xcite .
we will discuss these two methods in detail in section 3 .
\(3 ) a segment is a `` smoothly - connected '' region . in a region
where intensity changes smoothly or gradually , the region is viewed as a segment .
smoothness can be measured by a limit .
a popular segmentation method is called mean - based region growing segmentation in this paper @xcite .
a pixel will be included in a region if the updated region is homogeneous , meaning that the difference between pixel intensity and the mean of the region is limited by @xmath3 , a small real number .
the @xmath0-connected segmentation follows the same philosophy .
this is to link all pixels that have the similar intensity .
this method is related to a fuzzy method created by rosenfeld who treated an image as a 2d fuzzy set .
then , he used @xmath4-cut to segment the image into components . another way is to measure two pixels to see if they are `` fuzzy '' connected .
a pixel set is @xmath0-connected if for any two points there is a path that is @xmath0-connected where @xmath0 is a fuzzy value between 0 and 1 @xcite@xcite@xcite @xcite@xcite .
this is a generalization of threshold segmentation in some cases .
this method can be used to divide ( partition ) different intensity levels without calculating different thresholds or clip - level values . however , for a complex image , how to calculate the value of @xmath0 remains unknown .
a fast algorithm can be designed to perform a segmentation .
in fact , the simple form of both threshold segmentation and @xmath0-connected segmentation can be done in linear time .
we can see that mean - based region growing segmentation is a statistical approach , but the @xmath0-connected approach is a graph - theoretic method .
we can combine them by requiring that the @xmath0-connected segment also be within a @xmath3 limit of the mean . or
after the mean - based segmentation , we can do a @xmath0-connected segmentation.@xcite ( 4)split - and - merge segmentation uses quadtree to determine the order in which pixel(s ) should be treated or computed @xcite .
it is an algorithmic way to find an object or to force a merge order .
this is because this method is based on the mean of the merged region .
it does not guarrantee a transitive relation .
again , the mean - based segmentation is not an equivalence relation .
this method splits an image into four sections and checks if each part is homogenous .
the homogenous segments are then merged together .
if the segments are not homogenous , the splitting process is repeated .
this process is also called quadtree segmentation .
the method is more accurate for some complex images .
however , it costs more time to segment an image .
the time complexity of this method ( process ) is @xmath5 .
this was proved by chen in 1991.@xcite \(5 ) a segment is surrounded by one or several closed edges . if we can detect and track the edges , we can determine the location and outline of the segments .
the fifth philosophy is edge detection . to find low or high frequency pixels are very common in edge detection .
however , not all edge - detection methods can be used in image segmentation since enhancing edge is not the primary purpose of image segmentation .
the purpose of image segmentation is to find components .
the number of edges should be relatively small .
otherwise , the extraction of the closed curves will be the major problem .
recent development indicated that the mumford - shah method is promising .
the method uses the variational principal @xcite .
this method has captured a considerable amount of attention .
the mumford - shah method considers three factors in segmentation : ( 1 ) the total length of all the segments ? ?
edges , ( 2 ) the unevenness of the image without its edges , and ( 3 ) the total error between the original image and the proposed segmented images where each segment has unique or similar values in its pixels . when the three weighted factors are minimized , the resulting image is a solution of the mumford - shah method .
recently , zhan and vese proposed level - sets to simplify the mumford - shah method so that it produced better results @xcite
. however , level - sets use contour boundaries that may limit the flexibility of the original mumford - shah method .
the mumford - shah method also needs an alternative process and its algorithm performance is still unknown .
the @xmath6-mean or fuzzy c - mean , maximum entropy , and the mumford - shah method all require an iterated process that is good at detailed or fine segmentation .
this is not a quick solution for fast segmentation .
the fast segmentation methods are only used for region growing including the original threshold method , mean - based and lambda - connected search , and split - and - merge method . in practice , @xmath6-mean or fuzzy c
- mean and maximum entropy are still the most popular .
however , for some types of sequential images , these two methods do not obtain stable results when we process a set of meteorological data to find areas with the most water vapor indicating ( most likely ) the location of a hurricane @xcite .
@xmath0-connected segmentation , on the other hand , has worked very well .
a problem the @xmath0-connected method faced was that the @xmath0 value needed to be assigned even though that value can be used throughout each data frame in the data set . to find a way to automatically determine
the @xmath0-value is a longtime goal for the author .
some methods have been proposed such as maximum connectedness spanning tree @xcite @xcite and the golden cut point @xcite . in this paper ,
the author proposes optimization methods based on maximum entropy and minimum variance , respectively .
@xmath0-connected segmentation is based on the philosophy that an object must have a smooth inside and has a gap at its boundary ( in terms of intensity ) . trying to find a closed curve / boundary that indicates the intensity of the jump is the key to this method .
a measure of connectedness can be used to partition a set of data into connected components based on adjacency or neighborhood systems . using connectedness to divide an image
does not require transforming the image into binary form .
after the data is partitioned , a fast algorithm such as the breadth - first - search algorithm can be applied to find a connected component @xcite@xcite .
@xmath0-connected search was introduced to segment such an image without transferring the image into a @xmath7-image .
however , the value of @xmath0 , usually between 0 and 1 , determines the fineness of the segmentation .
@xmath0-connectedness can be defined on an undirected graph @xmath8 with an associated ( potential ) function @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the @xmath11-dimensional real space @xcite .
given a measure @xmath12 on each pair of adjacent points @xmath13 based on the values @xmath14 , we define @xmath15 where @xmath16 $ ] with @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
@xmath19 is used to measure `` neighbor - connectivity . ''
the next step is to develop path - connectivity so that @xmath0-connectedness on @xmath20 can be defined in a general way . in graph theory , a finite sequence @xmath21
is called a path , if @xmath22 .
the path - connectivity @xmath23 of a path @xmath24 is defined as @xmath25 or @xmath26 finally , the degree of connectedness or connectivity of two vertices @xmath13 with respect to @xmath27 is defined as : @xmath28 for a given @xmath29 $ ] , point @xmath30 and @xmath31 are said to be @xmath0-connected if @xmath32 . in image processing , @xmath33 is the intensity of a point @xmath34 and @xmath30 defines a pixel .
it is a natural and unavoidable question how we determine @xmath0 value in connectedness - based segmentation ?
it is somehow similar to determine the clip level in threshold segmentation ; however , @xmath35 value is not as sensitive as the clip - level in thresholding .
there are fewer @xmath0 values to be selected than clip - levels . in chapter 10 of @xcite
, chen provided the detail analysis on this issue .
some techniques have been proposed and tested such as the binary search - based method and the maximum connectedness spanning tree method @xcite @xcite .
we also proposed a golden - cut technique for bone density measurement in @xcite . in this section ,
we propose two new methods to determine the @xmath0 value for the segmentation .
the new methods are based on maximum entropy and minimum variance , respectively . in this subsection , we propose a method that uses the maximum entropy method to determine the @xmath0 value . it can be called maximum entropy connectedness determination .
the maximum entropy method was first proposed by kapur , sahoo , and wong @xmath36 .
it is based on the maximization of inner entropy in both the foreground and background .
the purpose of finding the best threshold is to make both objects in the foreground and background , respectively , as smooth as possible .
@xcite @xcite @xcite if @xmath37 and @xmath38 are in the foreground and background classes , respectively , the maximum entropy can be calculated as follows ; @xmath39 @xmath40 where @xmath41 can be viewed as the number of pixels whose value is @xmath42 ; @xmath43 is the number of pixels in background , and @xmath44 is the number of pixels in foreground .
the maximum entropy is to find the threshold value @xmath45 that maximizes @xmath46 .
such an idea can be used for @xmath0-connected segmentation .
however , the total inner entropy for the image is to calculate the entropy for each segment ( @xmath0-connected component ) , not for the thresholding clipped foreground / background .
this is because in @xmath0-connected segmentation there is no specific background .
each @xmath0-connected segment can be viewed as foreground , and the rest may be viewed as the background .
it is different from the original maximum entropy where the range of pixel values determines the inclusion of pixels .
therefore , we need to summarize all inner entropies in all segments . @xmath47 we will select the @xmath0 such that @xmath48 will be maximized .
we call this @xmath0-value the maximum entropy connectedness .
this unique value is a new measure for images .
since the maximum entropy means the minimum amount of information or minimum variation , we want the minimum change inside each segment .
this matches the philosophy of the original maximum entropy method .
in other words , the @xmath0-connected maximum entropy has a better meaning in some applications .
we use the @xmath49 such that @xmath50 \}.\ ] ] assume there are @xmath11 @xmath0-components , define inner entropy of each @xmath0-component @xmath51 : @xmath52}{n } \log \frac { histogram[k ] } { n}\ ] ] where @xmath53 is the number of points in the component @xmath54 . @xmath55 $ ]
is the number of pixels whose values are @xmath6 in the segment .
thus , @xmath56 the maximum entropy connectedness can be viewed as a measure of a special connectivity for the image .
if @xmath0 value is calculated in the above formula for an image that makes @xmath48 to be maximum , we call that the image have the maximum entropy connectedness @xmath0 , denoted as @xmath49 . in @xcite
, we proposed a golden cut method for finding the @xmath0-value for bone density connectedness calculation .
we have obtained a @xmath0=0.96 , 0.97 for a bone image ( the size of the picture is different from the one used in this paper ) . for a similar image , using the maximum entropy connectedness presented in this section
, we got @xmath49=0.95 .
the result is quite reasonable . the original image and both of the segmented images are shown in fig . 1 - 4
no pre - cut ( preprocessing ) is performed in the segmentation .
what we can see in the above three segmented images ( fig . 2 - 4 ) .
2 seemed to be the same as the original image fig .
it is possible that fig . 4 may represent the better understanding of bone connectivity
. however , what we state here is that @xmath49 can provide us the meaningful result and it was done automatically .
for the commonly used testing image `` lena , '' fig.5 , the result of @xmath0-connected segmentation is quite interesting .
whatever we use a pre - threshold cut or not , @xmath49 is always 0.99 ( fig .
an original maximum entropy arrived at the clip - level of 125 counts of the 8-bit gray level image ( 0 - 255 of the pixel value range .
the reason is that the `` lena '' image does not contain many `` continuous '' parts . in the @xmath0-connected segmentation
, we can see that @xmath49 ( = 0.99 ) connected segmentation has connected the continuous component especially at the face and shoulder .
this matches the result of using the maximum entropy cut , fig .
7 ( we use nih @xmath57 to perform the cut . ) thus , we can say that our new method is still reasonable .
when we use @xmath58 for the image , we get fig .
8 . for the image having gradual variation property
, @xmath0-connected segmentation usually has an advantage .
we have extensively tested a set of sequential images in order to find the outlier of meteorological data that indicates ( most likely ) the hurricane center @xcite .
the data frames we used are water vapor images . except the standard threshold method and the @xmath0-connected segmentation method , all other methods we tested failed including famous @xmath6-mean and maximum entropy @xcite .
what we found was that the key for this sequential images is that the pre - cut is necessary .
interesting enough for us , @xmath59 of the pick value of each image for the cut receives the best result .
after that , we can use @xmath0=0.95 for the segmentation parameter and extract the largest component for the outlier searching result .
the problem here is that @xmath59 of the pick value as clip - level is not automatically calculated .
if we want a totally automatic process , we might to use maximum entropy to make the first cut . in this testing set
, we have 12 image frames .
for some beginning images , the method worked well as expected . for other images ,
the new method proposed in this paper consistently got wrong results since the @xmath49 calculated is always greater than or equal to 0.97 .
we can not get @xmath0 to be 0.95 using `` maximum entropy connectedness . '' after looking into the detail images , we have found two problems : ( 1 ) the pixel values are not `` continuous '' around `` the desired outlier , '' and ( 2 ) the largest component criteria for the outlier is not quite represent the nature of hurricane centers ( outliers ) , we need to change the criteria to `` the largest and the brightest . '' for ( 1 ) , we have done a smoothing process . for ( 2 ) , we change the outlier criteria from the largest component to the total intensity of the component ( not only testing its size ) .
smoothing preprocess is reasonable , and it is good for the @xmath0-connected segmentation to find large component .
the following image shows such a treatment .
we have applied an automatic pre - cut by using maximum entropy instead of the pre - cut using the @xmath59 of pick value .
9 shows an original image .
10 shows the result using our new method plus a maximum entropy threshold cut of preprocessing .
a threshold value=23 is calculated by standard maximum entropy .
then , we perform the automated finding process to get @xmath49 described above . @xmath60 was obtained and used .
if we just use the standard maximum entropy at threshold = 23 , we will have the following image fig .
11 . using maximum entropy is a type of philosophical change .
in fact , we can consider other formulas .
for example we can select another way to calculate the entropy of one segment . here
we propose a different formula .
we can calculate the inner entropy of a component , then treat the rest of the image as the background for the component .
the total entropy generated by this segment is the summation of both
. we can apply this process to all components / segments while segmenting .
let @xmath61 be the image , @xmath62 is the complement of component @xmath63 @xmath64 we can use the following formula for the the basis of optimzation . @xmath65 the outer ( background )
entropy is the total .
@xmath66 in @xmath67 , a pixel is calculated multiple times .
we may need to use the average @xmath68 where @xmath11 is the number of segments .
the relationship between this formula and the formula we used in the previous subsection is also interesting .
furthermore , we should consider the following general model .
@xmath69 where @xmath70 and @xmath71 can be constant or function of segmentations . in this subsection
, we develop a minimum variance - based method for finding the best @xmath0 value in @xmath0-connected segmentation .
minimum variance was first studied by otsu in image segmentation @xmath72 @xmath73 .
in other words , otsu s segmentation was the first global optimization solution for image segmentation .
it is used to clip the image into two parts : the object and the background .
assume that @xmath74,@xmath75 , @xmath76 represent the within - class variance , between - class variance , and the total variance , respectively .
the optimum threshold will be determined by maximizing one of the following criterion with respect to threshold @xmath45 @xmath72 @xmath73 : @xmath77 @xmath78 is the standard derivation .
since @xmath76 is constant for a certain image , this segmentation process is to make between - class variance large and within - class variance small .
therefore , our task is to make the within - class variance as small as possible .
the original design of otsu s method is not able to be implemented directly for @xmath0-connected segmentation which is similar to the case of maximum entropy .
this is because there were only two categories , the object and the background .
for the first and second criteria , in @xmath0-connected segmentation there are many components and it would be very hard to find between - class variance . we could consider the total between - class variance , by considering every pair of components . or we could consider between - class variance for the components that are the neighbors .
the third criterion seems likely to be valid , however , when we only consider the variance within a connected component , what will happen is @xmath79 if @xmath80 .
@xmath81 will be infinite and will always be the greatest value . in order to make use of otsu s philosophy , we modify the original formula by adding a term that is the number of segments or components , @xmath82 .
we try to minimize the following formula : @xmath83 where @xmath2 is a constant .
we could let @xmath84 .
the calculation of the inner variance of a @xmath0-component is to compute the variance ( square of standard deviation ) of the pixels in the component .
the following formula is to find minimum average variance ( for each component ) .
@xmath85 we want to find @xmath86 such that @xmath87\}\ ] ] this strategy only works for the meteorological data .
the experimental results show that the method is promising . for the other two kinds of images tested in maximum entropy connectedness , `` lena '' and the bone image
, we still need to find an appropriate way under minimum variance philosophy .
the following images show the process on the same picture with a preprocessing threshold cut using the maximum entropy cut or @xmath59 peak cut .
then , we perform the automated process of finding of @xmath0-value .
12 shows that we arrived at @xmath86=0.97 using the method of minimum variance connectedness determination described in this subsection . without smoothing the original image ,
we pre cut the image using maximum entropy threshold .
the result is not what we expected .
when we smoothed the image , we got @xmath86=0.90 , and the result turned to be correct , see fig . 13 .
how do we use mumford - shah s idea to find the optimal segmentation ?
we can define @xmath88 as the total length of the edge of all segments . @xmath89 where @xmath4 and @xmath23 are constants . more generally , we can do the normal @xmath0-connected fit @xcite @xcite on each @xmath0-connected component .
the total variance ( or standard deviation ) of the ( normal @xmath0-connected ) fitted image is denoted as @xmath90 .
@xmath88 is still the total length of edges of segments ( components ) , and @xmath91 is the difference between the fitted image and the original image . using mumford - shah s method , we can minimize the following equation to get the @xmath92 .
@xmath93 @xmath94\}\ ] ]
even though we calculated the entropy or variance in each connected component that is different from the standard maximum entropy and the otsu s method in image segmentation , the philosophy remains the same as in these two popular methods .
the results are very promising .
these two new methods can be easily applied in other region - growing segmentations .
a large amount of further research should be done to support and the new methods .
we will implement the method proposed in subsection e in section iii , and compare it with the results obtained in @xcite .
99 abdulkadir sengur , ibrahim turkoglu , m. cevdet ince , a comparative study on entropic thresholding methods , istanbul university journal of electrical @xmath95 electronics engineering year vol 6 no 2 , pp 183 - 188 , 2006 .
t. chan and l. vese , active contours without edges .
ieee trans on image processing , vol 10 , no 2 pp 266 - 277 .
l. chen three - dimensional fuzzy digital topology and its applications(i ) , _ geophysical prospecting for petroleum _
, vol 24 , no 2 , pp 86 - 89 , 1985 . l. chen , the lambda - connected segmentation and the optimal algorithm for split - and - merge segmentation , _ chinese j. computers _ vol 14 , pp 321 - 331 , 1991 .
l. chen , @xmath0-connected approximations for rough sets , in lecture notes in computer science , springer , vol 2457 , 572 - 577 , 2002 .
l. chen , discrete surfaces and manifolds : a theory of digital - discrete geometry and topology , s@xmath95p computing , 2004 l. chen , @xmath0-measure for bone density connectivity , proceedings of ieee international symposium on industrial electronics , 2006 montreal , quebec , canada , 489 - 494 .
l. chen , h.d .
cheng , and j. zhang , fuzzy subfiber and its application to seismic lithology classification , _ information science : applications _ , vol 1 , no 2 , pp 77 - 95 , 1994 .
l. chen , and o. adjei @xmath0-connected segmentation and fitting : three new algorithms , proceedings of ieee conference on system , man , and cybernetics 2004 .
l. chen , o. adjei , and d. h. cooley , @xmath0-connectedness : method and application , _ proceedings of ieee conference on system , man , and cybernetics 2000 , _ pp 1157 - 1562 , 2000 .
m. cheriet , j.n .
said , c.y .
suen , a recursive thresholding technique for image segmentation , _ ieee transection on iamge processing _ , vol 7 no 6 , 1998 , 918 - 921 t. h. cormen , c.e .
leiserson , and r.l .
rivest , _ introduction to algorithms _ , mit press , 1993 .
r. c. gonzalez , and r. wood , _ digital image processing _ , addison - wesley , reading , ma , 1993 .
l. hertz and r. w. schafer , multilevel thresholding using edge matching , _ comput .
vis . graph . image process .
279 - 295 , 1988 .
t. kanungo , d. m. mount , n. netanyahu , c. piatko , r. silverman , and a. y. wu , an efficient k - means clustering algorithm : analysis and implementation , _ ieee trans .
pattern analysis and machine intelligence _
, 24 ( 2002 ) , 881 - 892 .
j. kittler and j. illingworth , minimum error thresholding , _ pattern recognit .
41 - 47 , 1986 .
r. kohler , a segmentation system based on thresholding , _ comput .
graphics image process .
319 - 338 , 1981 .
t. a. runkler , j. c. bezdek , and l. o. hall , clustering very large data sets : the complexity of the fuzzy c - means algorithm , _ proc .
eunite 2002 , ed .
k. lieven , publ . by elite fndn , aachen _ , germany , isbn 3 - 89653 - 919 - 1 , 420 - 425 , 2002 .
p. k. sahoo , s. soltani , and a. k. c. wong , survey : a survey of thresholding techniques , _ comput .
vis . graph . image process .
233 - 260 , 1988 . m. spann and r. wilson , a quad - tree approach to image segmentation which combines statistical and spatial information , _ pattern recognit . _ ,
257 - 269 , 1985 .
l. tsai and f.t .
berkey , ionogram analysis using fuzzy segmentation and connectedness techniques , _ radio science _ , vol 35 , no 2 , 1173 - 1186 , 2000 .
l. tsai , f. t. berkey , and j. y. liu , automatic ionogram trace identification using fuzzy classification techniques , _ computer aided processing of ionograms and ionosonde records _ ,
france , pp 45 - 50 , 1996 .
s. wang and r. m. haralick , automatic multithreshold selection , _ comput .
vis . graph . image process .
_ , vol . 25 , pp . 46 - 67 , 1984 | image segmentation is to separate an image into distinct homogeneous regions belonging to different objects .
it is an essential step in image analysis and computer vision .
this paper compares some segmentation technologies and attempts to find an automated way to better determine the parameters for image segmentation , especially the connectivity value of @xmath0 in @xmath0-connected segmentation .
based on the theories of the maximum entropy method and otsu s minimum variance method , we propose:(1)maximum entropy connectedness determination : a method that uses maximum entropy to determine the best @xmath0 value in @xmath0-connected segmentation , and ( 2 ) minimum variance connectedness determination : a method that uses the principle of minimum variance to determine @xmath0 value . applying these optimization techniques in real images ,
the experimental results have shown great promise in the development of the new methods . in the end , we extend the above method to more general case in order to compare it with the famous mumford - shah method that uses variational principle and geometric measure . |
on july 4th 2012 the atlas @xcite and cms @xcite collaborations announced the discovery of a scalar particle at cern s large hadron collider ( lhc ) .
this new particle with a mass of about @xmath8 gev was later identified as the higgs boson , responsible for the generation of all particle masses through the mechanism of spontaneous symmetry breaking @xcite .
so far , the measured properties of the higgs boson have shown a remarkable consistency with those predicted by the standard model ( sm ) of particle physics .
nevertheless , it is by now clear that the sm can not explain all the observed physical phenomena , as for instance it fails to provide a candidate for dark matter or a means to explain the matter anti - matter asymmetry in the universe .
however , as more data is being accumulated and analysed at the lhc , it becomes increasingly clear that any new physics theory has to resemble very much the sm at the electroweak scale . in the first run ,
the atlas and cms collaborations have studied in great detail the main four higgs production modes at the lhc @xcite , namely gluon fusion ( including @xmath9 fusion ) , vector boson fusion ( vbf ) , associated production ( @xmath10 , with @xmath11 ) and @xmath12 production , with centre of mass energies of 7 and 8 tev . for each production mode several decay channels were considered and analysed in great detail .
the production of the higgs boson in association with a top quark - anti - quark pair , @xmath13 @xcite , constitutes the only way ( together with single top plus higgs which has an even smaller cross section ) to directly probe the top - quark yukawa couplings .
moreover , it is also contaminated by a huge background coming mainly from @xmath14 . for this particular production process
several decay channels have been studied @xcite .
the very complex final states , together with the huge backgrounds to the process , makes it the most difficult higgs channel to study at the lhc .
nevertheless , with just a few events , both collaborations have reach a sensitivity down to about 2 3 times the sm value which constitutes a remarkable achievement .
the current studies @xcite , use the kinematic information of the events to separate the signal from the backgrounds . in this work we advocate the introduction of new variables that make use of the information from ( lack of ) spin correlations in the signal and background processes @xcite : the top and anti - top quarks are natural spin analysers of this process .
we will show that part of the spin information that is present in the matrix elements survives the parton showering , detector simulation , event selection and event reconstruction .
these new variables could play an important role in background discrimination , possibly leading to an improvement in the precision of the measurement of the top - quark yukawa coupling . even though we will consider only the irreducible @xmath5 background , without a highly - optimized event - reconstruction method
, we will argue that our findings are also valid in a more general and realistic case .
we should also note that the type of variables proposed in this work can then be used to probe the cp nature of the top - yukawa coupling @xcite .
in many models like the cp - violating two - higgs doublet model @xcite ( the status of this model after the lhc run 1 was recently presented in @xcite ) , cp violation appears explicitly in the higgs sector via mixing of cp - even and cp - odd states .
the determination of the cp nature of the higgs boson and its interactions is of the utmost importance at the lhc .
finally one should note that @xmath6 production can be studied at future linear colliders such as the ilc , which will lead to a tremendous improvement in the precision of measurements of the yukawa couplings @xcite .
given that the goal of this work is to study how well spin information can be used to improve the current search strategies , we only consider the signal and its dominant irreducible background .
the signal ( @xmath12 ) and background ( @xmath15 ) processes were generated , at leading order ( lo ) , using madgraph5amc@nlo @xcite with the nnpdf2.3 pdf sets @xcite .
the full spin correlations information of the @xmath16 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 decays , with @xmath17 , was retained by allowing madspin @xcite to perform the decay of the heavy particles . although other decay modes of the top quarks and higgs boson could be considered , in this paper we focus on the most challenging leptonic decay channel i.e. , the dileptonic decay of the @xmath18 system together with a higgs decaying to the dominant sm decay ( @xmath19 ) .
we argue the full kinematical reconstruction of the undetected neutrinos in such events , even if difficult , still preserves the angular distributions that could help in discriminating signal from irreducible backgrounds .
the events were generated for the lhc with a centre of mass energy of 13 tev with the default dynamic factorization and renormalization scales , setting the masses of the top quark and the sm higgs boson to @xmath20 gev and @xmath8 gev , respectively .
we do not attempt to investigate possible departures from the sm nature of the higgs boson in this paper , assumed to be a scalar particle ( @xmath21 ) .
the generated events were then passed to pythia 6 @xcite for shower and hadronization . in order to obtain more realistic results , for example for differential cross sections and efficiencies
, we passed the generated events through delphes @xcite to perform a fast detector simulation of a general - purpose collider experiment at the lhc .
we used the atlas default card for the simulation and performed the analysis of the generated and simulated events with madanalysis 5 @xcite in the expert mode @xcite .
the full kinematical reconstruction of @xmath6 events is very challenging in the dileptonic decays of the @xmath18 system , since both undetected neutrinos need to be reconstructed . in this paper
, we explore the advantages of fully reconstructing the @xmath6 system in the dileptonic topology , by applying a kinematic fit to the events using mass constraints and energy - momentum conservation .
events , after detector simulation , are accepted if they had at least four reconstructed jets and two charged leptons with transverse momentum @xmath22 gev and pseudo - rapidity @xmath23 .
no cuts are applied to the events transverse missing energy ( @xmath24 ) . in the following
we will normalise the distributions of signal and background to equal area , irrespective of their ( fiducial ) cross sections and efficiencies : for our goal it suffices to show which observables are sensitive to the difference in spin information in the signal and background events and how well this information can be retained in a realistically reconstructed event .
for the same reason we also abstain from performing a careful analysis of the uncertainties in the event generation as well as the inclusion of next - to - leading order corrections in the strong coupling .
as previously stated we will perform @xmath25 event reconstruction in final states with two charged leptons and at least four jets , after delphes simulation .
we do not attempt to tag the flavour of jets from the hadronization of @xmath26 quarks , i.e. , we do not use any @xmath26-tagging tool to help with the identification of the heavy flavour component of jets ; a task left outside the scope of this paper .
the full kinematical reconstruction requires the knowledge of the jet and charged lepton momenta , together with the transverse missing energy .
we use the @xmath27 and the top quark masses as constraints .
the higgs boson mass ( @xmath28 gev ) is used to maximise the probability of the best combination of two jets chosen among the ones which were not utilised in the @xmath18 system kinematical reconstruction .
the transverse missing energy is re - fitted to improve the resolution of the experimental measurement . after applying the constraints ,
six unknowns need to be fully reconstructed in the dileptonic @xmath25 events , which are the 3-momenta of the two neutrinos present in the events . to find a kinematic solution
we assume the neutrinos are responsible for the missing transverse energy , i.e. , @xmath29 in addition we apply the following mass constraints to the @xmath18 system of the events , @xmath30 while @xmath31 represent the @xmath32 and @xmath33 components of the transverse missing energy , @xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) correspond to the two lepton ( two @xmath26-jets ) four momenta , respectively , from the @xmath36 ( @xmath37 ) decays .
@xmath38 are the @xmath27-boson and top quark masses , respectively .
the mass of the @xmath27-boson was set to @xmath39 gev .
we study the performance of the reconstruction with respect to the generated parton - level monte carlo information . to make sure the kinematical reconstruction produces sensible results ,
the reconstruction is first applied to truth - matched objects , i.e. , jets and leptons which are matched to their parton - level generated quarks and charged leptons , using a @xmath40 criterion ( the minimum distance in the pseudorapidity - azimuthal angle plane , @xmath40 , between the reconstructed jet or lepton and the parton - level quark or charged lepton , ensures the matching ) . even though we use a rather simple kinematical reconstruction method the efficiency using truth - matched objects
is 62% . in figure
[ fig : genrec_rec1 ] the neutrino ( left ) and antineutrino ( right ) @xmath41 from signal events are shown .
the generated distributions ( filled histograms ) are compared with the truth - match reconstructed ones ( solid lines ) . in the bottom plot ,
the ratio between the two distributions is shown .
although a slight slope is visible in the ratio plot , more significant at high @xmath42 due to radiation effects not explicitly corrected for at the moment , good agreement between the reconstructed distributions is observed with respect to the parton - level neutrino distributions , making clear that the full kinematical reconstruction of @xmath6 events is possible . in figures [ fig : genrec_rec2 ] and [ fig : genrec_rec3 ] the @xmath42 distributions of the @xmath36 ( @xmath37 ) quarks and @xmath43 ( @xmath44 ) bosons are shown , respectively , for the @xmath6 events .
once again we see a similar behaviour as observed for the neutrino @xmath42 distributions , i.e. , good agreement between the reconstructed kinematic distributions and the corresponding ones at parton level , in spite of the slight slope for higher @xmath42 values , in the ratio plot .
although the kinematical fit can correct , to a large extend , the effects of radiation , at high values the differences between reconstructed and generated distributions may require an additional correction . even though this would not difficult to implement ,
we have decide not to apply it here once it may depend on the exact experimental environment conditions and does not contribute significantly to the main discussion of the paper . in a second step ,
the truth match condition is dropped , bringing the analysis closer to what can be done at collider experiments . for this particular case
we perform all possible combinations of reconstructed jets and charged leptons ( after detector simulation ) in order to reconstruct the top and anti - top quarks , together with the higgs boson . for the @xmath18 system reconstruction we used the same procedure based on equations eq . - .
we calculate the probability @xmath45 that the event is compatible with the equations , using probability density functions for the neutrino and anti - neutrino @xmath42 distributions , the top and anti - top quarks mass distributions as well as the @xmath43 and @xmath44 bosons mass distributions , obtained at parton level . to identify the two - jet combination , among the ones not used in the @xmath18 reconstruction , that best matches the jets from the higgs boson decay , we associate to each combination , a weight @xmath46
, @xmath47 related to how close the higgs boson mass ( @xmath28 gev ) is to the invariant mass of each particular jet - pair combination .
the solution with highest @xmath48 is chosen as the right one for the full kinematical reconstruction of the events .
this fixes completely the assignment of jets and charged leptons to their parent @xmath36 , @xmath37 quarks and higgs boson . due to the increase in the number of possible combinations which can satisfy eq
. - , 88% of all events are reconstructed by the kinematic fit .
this will obviously lead to an increase of the combinatorial background but , as we will see later , the kinematics are in most cases distinct from the right combinations . in figures [ fig : genrec_exp2 ] and [ fig : genrec_exp3 ] we show the @xmath42 distributions of the top quarks and @xmath27 bosons , respectively . the kinematically reconstructed @xmath42 , with no jets and leptons truth match ,
is compared with the parton - level distribution .
we see a good correlation between the kinematically reconstructed distributions with respect to the parton - level ones , thus ensuring that the reconstruction works fairly well .
we did not attempt to further optimise the event reconstruction because , again , the main goal here is to show that a reconstruction is possible with a reasonable efficiency .
we will focus on angular distributions in fully reconstructed @xmath6 events involving three - dimensional angles between the decay products of the @xmath6 dileptonic final states . following the full reconstruction of events ,
we define two reference frames : * frame 1 : the full @xmath6 centre - of - mass system , built by using the laboratory four - momenta and , * frame 2 : the @xmath49 centre - of - mass system recoiling against the @xmath36 quark , in the @xmath6 system ( i.e. , in frame 1 as defined above ) . for the generated distributions ( with and without the @xmath42 and @xmath50 cuts applied in the event selection )
, we use the parton - level four - momenta of all relevant objects . for the reconstructed distributions ( with and without truth match ) , we use the four - momenta obtained after applying the kinematic fit reconstruction . we define the angle between the higgs momentum direction ( in the @xmath49 centre - of - mass ) with respect to the @xmath49 direction ( in the @xmath6 system ) as @xmath51 and the angle of the @xmath52 top quarks or higgs decay products ( @xmath43,@xmath44,@xmath53,@xmath54 , @xmath26 and @xmath55 jets ) momentum ( in the higgs centre - of - mass system ) with respect to the higgs direction ( in the @xmath49 system ) as @xmath56 .
we should stress the fact that , when boosting @xmath52 to the centre of mass of the higgs boson , the laboratory four - momenta were used ( in a direct , rotation - free boost ) . in figure
[ fig : genncang1 ] we show distributions at parton level , without any cuts , for the product of @xmath57 , and @xmath58 , for @xmath59(left ) and @xmath60(right ) .
we can see the distributions are quite different between signal and background events .
the effect of applying the @xmath42 and @xmath50 cuts to jets and leptons is seen in figure [ fig : genwcang1 ] . a clear reduction on the number of events is observed due to the cuts applied . in figure
[ fig : recang1 ] we can see the effect of the kinematic fit reconstruction , still with the truth match information .
the information on the angular distribution is preserved to a large extent , even after the full kinematical reconstruction .
as we will see this is also true when the reconstruction is performed without truth match . in figure
[ fig : expang1 ] we show the reconstructed product ( without truth match ) of @xmath61 and @xmath58 , for @xmath59(left ) and @xmath60(right ) . in figures [ fig : expang2 ] and [ fig : expang3 ] we show the same distributions but with the charged leptons replaced by the @xmath27-bosons and @xmath26-quarks from the higgs decay , respectively .
it is quite apparent that some of the angular distributions allow discrimination between signal and background even after the full kinematical reconstruction without the truth match .
since we did not try to optimise the kinematical reconstruction , it is foreseeable that better results could be obtained in the future .
based on the angular distributions introduced in the previous section , we propose to use several forward - backward asymmetries ( @xmath62 ) in this paper , defined using the double angular product + @xmath63 the asymmetries can be easily calculated , both at parton level and after the kinematic fit reconstruction , and are defined as , @xmath64 where @xmath65 and @xmath66 correspond to the total number of events in the corresponding angular distribution with @xmath67 above and below zero , respectively .
these asymmetries can be quite different between the signal @xmath6 and the irreducible background @xmath7 . in table
[ tab : asymgenexp ] we present the values of the asymmetries , with no cuts applied to the events , at parton level ( and at lo ) for different choices of the final state particle ( @xmath52 ) that is boosted to the centre of mass of the higgs boson .
as we can see , there are clear differences for some of the asymmetries i.e. , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 ( @xmath55 from @xmath37 ) , between signal and background .
we show in figure [ fig : genncasym1 ] an example of two - binned angular distributions for @xmath60 and @xmath59 , respectively , evaluated at parton level without any @xmath42 or @xmath50 cuts applied to the events .
.values for the asymmetry for @xmath6 and @xmath7 events at the lhc .
the second and third column show the observed asymmetries at the parton level ( without any cuts ) , while the fourth and last column show same asymmetries after applying the selection cuts and the kinematical reconstruction ( without truth match ) . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] | the associated production of a higgs boson and a top - quark pair , @xmath0 , in proton - proton collisions is addressed in this paper for a center of mass energy of 13 tev at the lhc .
dileptonic final states of @xmath1 events with two oppositely charged leptons and four jets from the decays @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 , are used .
signal events , generated with madgraph5amc@nlo , are fully reconstructed by applying a kinematic fit .
new angular distributions of the decay products as well as angular asymmetries are explored in order to improve discrimination of @xmath0 signal events over the dominant irreducible background contribution , @xmath5 . even after the full kinematic fit reconstruction of the events , the proposed angular distributions and asymmetries are still quite different in the @xmath6 signal and the dominant background ( @xmath7 ) . |
the great obstacle to the practical tasks of quantum information processing is the destruction of quantum correlations arising from the inevitable interactions of the systems of interest with their environments @xcite .
the fundamental quantum correlations are contained in nonclassical states .
it is known that the entanglement measure can only quantify quantum correlations for inseparable states .
recently , a large amount of experimental and theoretical studies have discovered that quantum discord @xcite is a more general measure of nonclassical correlations in comparison with the entanglement @xcite .
quantum correlation introduced by henderson and vedral @xcite is identical to the quantum discord defined by ollivier and zurek @xcite in the case of two qubits @xcite .
specially , the separable mixed states with nonzero quantum discord are also considered as one kind of useful resources contributing to the speedup of some quantum computations .
therefore , the dynamics of quantum correlations have received much attention . until now
, the markovian and non - markovian decoherences of correlations have been investigated in refs .
it is found that the exponential decay of quantum discord is distinct from the sudden death of the entanglement @xcite at finite time in the markovian environments .
the decline of quantum discord can be delayed in the non - markovian channels @xcite .
but quantum correlations are usually less than classical correlations in a large time interval . in many interesting studies
, it is assumed that qubits are coupled to local reservoirs which are similar to each other .
however , the properties of local environments are often different from each other .
this means that the practical environments are asymmetric .
the asymmetric characterizations of the decoherence channels for every qubit must bring about the positive or negative effects on the behavior of quantum and classical correlations . in this paper , we study the dynamics of quantum and classical correlations in the influence of asymmetric and non - markovian local environments . for the spin system consisting of two noninteracting qubits @xmath0 and @xmath1 , the non - markovian decoherence channel of each qubit is given by the post - markovian phenomenological approach in ref .
the effects of the bit - flip channel and phase - flip channel are taken into account . in section
ii , the time evolution of quantum states is analytically obtained when a general class of bell - diagonal mixed states are chosen to be initial ones . in section iii , three different types of the behavior of quantum discord and classical correlations are deduced with the change of initial states .
a simple discussion concludes the paper .
the shabani and lidar post - markovian master equation @xcite is used to describe the time evolution of quantum bipartite states @xmath2 in the non - markovian environments .
the general form of the master equation is expressed by @xmath3 where the operator @xmath4 is the markovian liouvillian and @xmath5 is the kernel characterizing the environment memory effects .
specially , @xmath6 in the markovian case . for a given system and environment , the kernel can be experimentally engineered via quantum state tomography @xcite .
for the pauli channels , @xmath7 where @xmath8 corresponds to the bit flip , the bit - phase and phase flip channel respectively .
the parameter @xmath9 represents the decaying rate . according to ref .
@xcite , the post - markovian channels are adopted to describe the actual dynamics approximately . for simplicity , qubits @xmath0 and @xmath1 are subjected to the two different channels of bit flip @xmath10 and phase flip one @xmath11 respectively .
the bit flip channel for the @xmath12 qubit can be given by @xmath13 $ ] , @xmath14 $ ] , @xmath15 $ ] and @xmath16 $ ] .
here @xmath17 is the eigenstate of @xmath18 with the corresponding eigenvalue @xmath19 and @xmath20 is the identity operator of qubit @xmath21 . if the kernel is assumed to be @xmath22 , the parameter @xmath23 is decided by @xmath24 where @xmath25 ^ 2}$ ] .
the phase flip channel can also be defined by @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 the initial states of two qubits are one important bell - diagonal mixed states in the general form of @xmath30 where the real number satisfies @xmath31 .
these symmetric states are ones with maximally mixed marginals , i. e. , @xmath32 . under the two asymmetric decoherence channels , quantum bipartite states at any time can be analytically calculated by @xmath33.\ ] ] the expression of @xmath34 is given by @xmath35 where the four bell states are defined by @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
the coefficients @xmath38 are written by@xmath39 $ ] and @xmath40 $ ] where @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 .
it is shown that quantum states also keep the symmetric bell - diagonal expression under the asymmetric pauli channels .
the mixing proportions of bell states are varied in time .
to clearly describe the dynamics of correlations , we use quantum discord as one general measure for quantum correlation . for an arbitrary bipartite state @xmath44 ,
the total correlations are expressed by quantum mutual information @xmath45 where @xmath46 represents the reduced density matrix of subsystem @xmath21 and @xmath47 is the von neumann entropy .
henderson and vedral @xcite proposed one measure of bipartite classical correlation @xmath48 based on a complete set of local projectors @xmath49 on one subsystem @xmath1 .
after the local measurements , the reduced state of subsystem @xmath0 can be written by @xmath50.$ ] here @xmath51 is the measurement probability for the @xmath52 local projector .
then the classical correlation in the bipartite quantum state @xmath44 can be given by @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the conditional entropy of subsystem @xmath0 and @xmath55 signifies the minimal value of the entropy with respect to a complete set of local measurements .
quantum discord is simply defined by @xmath56 according to ref .
@xcite , the quantum mutual information for bell - diagonal mixed states @xmath34 in eq .
( 4 ) is given by @xmath57 and the classical correlation @xmath58.\ ] ] here @xmath59 . to obtain the interesting behavior , we focus on three kinds of initial states .
if the initial states @xmath60 satisfy the relation of @xmath61 and @xmath62 , the mutual information is expressed by @xmath63\log_{2}[1+(-1)^j p(t)c_x],\ ] ] and the classical and quantum correlations are given by @xmath64 this point means that the decoherence of quantum correlations is identical to that of classical correlations . because the classical correlations are easily measured in the practical situations ,
the behavior of quantum correlations can also be observed indirectly .
figure 1 clearly shows the case of @xmath65 .
when the kernel of the environments satisfies @xmath66 , the exponential decay of classical and quantum correlations is plotted in fig .
compared to the markovian case , the decline of quantum and classical correlations is slow and delayed to a large time interval .
it is also proven that the environment memory effects can yield some positive results for the realization of quantum information technology owing to the control of the system - reservoir interactions . when the kernel is changed to be @xmath67 ,
the values of @xmath65 are decaying sinusoidally and the continuous changes between nonzero values and zero ones are illustrated in fig .
if another one kind of initial states are chosen to be @xmath68 and @xmath69 , the quantum mutual information is obtained by @xmath70}{2}\log_{2}[1+(-1)^j p(t)c_x]&\\ \nonumber & + \sum_{j=1,2}\frac { [ 1+(-1)^j p(t)]}{2}\log_{2}[1+(-1)^j p(t)]&.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second term of the above equation always coincides with the classical correlation @xmath48 .
it is found that the change rate of quantum correlation is proportional to that of classical correlation decided by the decaying rate of the environment @xmath23 .
this synchronous phenomenon of quantum and classical correlations is plotted in figure 2 .
it is clearly seen that the values of classical correlations are always larger than those of quantum correlations .
the decreasing and increasing of @xmath71 and @xmath72 simultaneously happen .
the initial states of @xmath73 are used to reveal the sudden changes of quantum and classical correlations . from figure 3
, it is shown that there exists one certain characteristic time @xmath74 where the decaying rates of both quantum and classical correlations vary suddenly . to study the sudden changes ,
we analytically derive the classical correlation .
it is found that @xmath75}{2}\log_{2}[1+(-1)^j p(t)c_x ] , & |p(t)| < |p(t_c)| , & \\
\nonumber c(\rho^{ab})=&\sum_{j=1,2}\frac { [ 1+(-1)^j p^2(t)c_y]}{2}\log_{2}[1+(-1)^j p^2(t)c_y ] , & |p(t)| > |p(t_c)|,&\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath76 . according to the expressions of @xmath48
, it is clearly shown that the decay of the classical correlation suddenly changes at the characteristic time @xmath74 .
it is known that the sudden changes of quantum and classical correlations are caused by the variation of the inherent properties of the states .
the distances from a given state to the closest state are drawn on to understand the physical origin of the sudden changes . according to ref .
@xcite , the distance between the state @xmath44 and the closest classical state @xmath77 can quantify the quantum correlations defined by the relative entropy @xmath78 for bell - diagonal states , @xmath79 .
it is the fact that the sudden change of quantum correlation is closely dependent on the variation of the closest classical state . for @xmath80
, the closest classical state can be written by @xmath81 while the closest classical state for @xmath82 , @xmath83 via the control of the kernel , the values of quantum correlations are greater than those of classical correlations in the large time interval from fig .
3(a ) and 3(b ) .
when the kernel satisfies @xmath66 , the characteristic time is obtained by @xmath84 and numerically plotted in fig .
it is seen that the characteristic time can be enlarged by the increasing of the ratio @xmath85 . for the time interval @xmath80 ,
quantum correlation decline more slowly than classical correlation .
the decoherence of quantum and classical correlations is investigated in the condition that two noninteracting qubits are asymmetrically subjected to different non - markovian pauli channels .
it is found that the destruction of quantum and classical correlations can be delayed via the engineering of the kernel characterizing the environment memory effects .
the dynamical behavior of quantum and classical correlations are dependent on the selection of the initial states . for one class of bell - diagonal mixed states ,
quantum correlations measured by quantum discord vary synchronously with classical correlations .
this phenomena provide us a convenient way to evaluate quantum correlations by the direct observation of classical correlations .
meanwhile , the decaying rates of quantum correlations suddenly change at the characteristic time . for @xmath80 ,
quantum correlation decline more slowly than classical correlation . in a large time interval ,
classical correlations are less than quantum correlations which is useful for the realization of quantum information processing .
the physical explanation of sudden changes of quantum correlations is obtained by the distance between the quantum state and the closest classical state .
the work was supported by the research program of natural science for colleges and universities in jiangsu province grant no . 09kjb140009 and the national natural science foundation grant no .
10904104 .
m. a. nielsen and i. l. chuang , _ quantum computation and quantum information_(cambridge university press , cambridge , 2000 ) .
w. h. zurek , rev .
phys . * 75 * , 715(2003 ) . h. ollivier and w. h. zurek , phys .
rev . lett . * 88 * , 017901(2001 ) .
l. henderson and v. vedral , j. phys .
a * 34 * , 6899(2001 ) .
r. horodecki , p. horodecki , m.horodecki , and k. horodecki , rev .
81 * , 865(2009 ) .
a. datta , a. shaji , and c. m. caves , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 050502(2008 ) .
b. p. lanyon , m. barbieri , m. p. almeida , and a. g. white , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 200501(2008 ) .
s. luo , phys .
a * 77 * , 022301(2008 ) .
m. s. sarandy , phys .
a * 80 * , 022108(2009 ) .
r. dillenschneider and e. lutz , euro .
phys . lett . *
88 * , 50003(2009 ) .
t. werlang , s. souza , f. f. fanchini , and c. j. villas - boas , phys .
a * 80 * , 024103(2009 ) .
m. piani , p. horodecki , and r. horodecki , phys .
* 100 * , 090502(2008 ) .
k. modi , t. paterek , w. son , v. vedral , and m. williamson , phys .
lett . * 104 * , 080501(2010 ) .
mazhar ali , a. r. p. rau , and g. alber , phys .
a * 81 * , 042105(2010 ) .
f. f. fanchini , t. werlang , c. a. brasil , l. g. e. arruda , and a. o. caldeira , phys .
a * 81 * , 052107(2010 ) .
b. wang , z. y. xu , z. q. chen , and m. feng , phys .
a * 81 * , 014101(2010 ) .
t. werlang and g. rigolin , phys .
a * 81 * , 044101(2010 ) .
j. maziero , l. c. celeri , r. m. serra , and v. vedral , phys .
a * 80 * , 044102(2009 ) .
j. maziero , t. werlang , f. f. fanchini , l. c. cleri , and r. m. serra , phys .
a * 81 * , 022116(2010 ) .
l. c. celeri , a. g. s. landulfo , r. m. serra , and g. e. a. matsas , phys .
a * 81 * , 062130(2010 ) .
l. mazzola , j. piilo , and s. maniscalco , phys .
* 104 * , 200401(2010 ) . j. s. xu , x. y. xu , c. f. li , c. j. zhang , x. b. zou and g. c. guo , nat . commun . * 1 * , 7(2010 ) .
he zhi , zou jian , li jian and shao bin , commun .
53 * , 837(2010 ) .
chen yi - xin and yin zhi , commun .
. phys . * 54 * , 60(2010 ) .
r. c. ge , m. gong , c. f. li , j. s. xu and g. c. guo , phys .
a * 81 * , 064103(2010 ) .
t. yu and j. h. eberly , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 140404(2004 ) .
a. shabani and d. a. lidar , phys .
a * 71 * , 020101(r)(2005 ) .
j. tan , t. h. kyaw , and y. yeo , phys .
a * 81 * , 062119(2010 ) .
the dynamics of correlations are plotted when the initial state is chosen to be @xmath86 .
( a ) . the parameters of the kernel @xmath66 ; ( b ) .
the kernel satisfies @xmath67 .
the solid lines denote quantum and classical correlations and the dotted line represents the dynamics of correlations in the markovian case .
the dynamics of correlations are plotted when the initial state is chosen to be @xmath87 and @xmath88 . (
the parameters of the kernel @xmath66 ; ( b ) .
the kernel satisfies @xmath67 .
the solid lines denote quantum correlations and the dashed lines represent classical correlations .
the dynamics of correlations are plotted when the initial state is chosen to be @xmath89 and @xmath90 for the kernel satisfying @xmath66 .
the dynamics of correlations are plotted when the initial state is chosen to be @xmath89 and @xmath90 for the kernel satisfying @xmath67 .
the characteristic time @xmath91 is plotted with the change of @xmath92 when @xmath89 and @xmath66 . | the non - markovian decoherence of quantum and classical correlations is analytically obtained when two qubits are asymmetrically subjected to the bit flip channel and phase flip channel . for one class of initial mixed states , quantum correlations quantified by quantum discord decay synchronously with classical correlations .
the discovery that the decaying rates of quantum and classical correlations suddenly change at the characteristic time is physically interpreted by the distance from quantum state to the closest classical states . in a large time interval ,
quantum correlations are greater than classical correlations .
the quantum and classical correlations can be preserved over a longer period of time via the kernel characterizing the environment memory effects .
pacs : 03.65.ta , 03.67.mn , 75.10.jm , 75.10.pq keywords : decoherence , quantum discord , non - markovian environments interaction |
low - mass helium - core white dwarf stars ( he wds ) are thought to be the result of the evolution of certain close binary systems .
mass - transfer episodes in binary systems are required to form low mass he wds because an isolated star would need a timescale much longer than the present age of the universe to reach a wd configuration with a helium - rich interior .
low mass wds have been detected in large surveys ( bragaglia et al . 1990 ; bergeron , saffer & liebert 1992 ; bragaglia , renzini & bergeron 1995 ; saffer , livio & yungelson 1998 ) and represent an appreciable fraction of the total population of wd stars . since he wds began to be found in numerous binary configurations ( marsh 1995 ; marsh , dhillon & duck 1995 ; lundgren et al .
1996 ; moran , marsh & bragaglia 1997 ; orosz et al .
1999 ; van kerkwijk et al .
2000 ) , they have captured the attention of many researchers who have devoted much effort to their study .
recent works with the emphasis on the evolutionary properties of these stars include benvenuto & althaus ( 1998 ) , hansen & phinney ( 1998 ) , driebe et al .
( 1998 ) , sarna , ergma & antipova ( 2000 ) , althaus , serenelli & benvenuto ( 2001a ) and serenelli et al .
in particular , althaus et al .
( 2001a ) have explored their evolution in a self - consistent way with nuclear burning , time dependent element diffusion and the history of the wd progenitor .
althaus et al .
( 2001a ) find that element diffusion induces thermonuclear hydrogen shell flashes in he wds with stellar masses greater than @xmath3 0.18 m@xmath1 . as a result , he wds more massive than 0.18 m@xmath1 are characterized by thin hydrogen envelopes and a fast evolution , while less massive he wds evolve much more slowly . as shown by althaus et al .
( 2001a ) , this behaviour solves the discrepancies between the spin - down ages of the millisecond pulsars b1855 + 09 , psr j0034 - 0534 and psr j1012 + 5307 and the cooling ages of their he wd companions .
the evolution of the althaus et al .
( 2001a ) stellar models in the colour - colour and in the colour - magnitude diagrams have been analysed by serenelli et al .
( 2001 ) who find , on the basis of detailed non - grey model atmospheres , that the emergent spectrum of low mass he wds becomes bluer within time - scales of astrophysical interest when the effective temperature decreases below 4000k . because serenelli et al .
( 2001 ) were interested in the late stages of he wd evolution , they did not attempt a detailed modeling of the emergent spectrum of these stars at high effective temperature stages .
interestingly , he wds have also been detected or inferred in open and globular clusters ( anderson 1997 ; landsman et al .
1997 ; edmonds et al . 1999 ) .
more recently , edmonds et al . ( 2001 ) have optically detected the he wd companion to a millisecond pulsar in 47 tucanae .
in addition , taylor et al .
( 2001 ) have presented evidence for a sequence of he wd canditates in the globular cluster ngc 6397 .
a proper interpretation of the observations of he wds in globular clusters requires evolutionary calculations for hewd progenitors with much lower metallicities than the solar one . in this regard ,
the present work is designed to extend the evolutionary calculations presented in serenelli et al .
( 2001 ) to the case of low metallicities .
in addition , the present calculations constitute an improvement over those presented in serenelli et al .
( 2001 ) . here
a more detailed treatment of the microphysics entering the wd model atmosphere than that presented in that work is considered , thus enabling us to derive accurate colours and magnitudes for he wds at high effective temperatures where the effects of line broadening opacities are not negligible . finally , a much more realistic treatment of mass loss phases than that attempted in althaus et al .
( 2001a ) and serenelli et al .
( 2001 ) is considered in the present study .
details about our atmosphere models , evolutionary code and mass loss treatment are briefly described in section 2 .
results are presented in section 3 and section 4 is devoted to making some concluding remarks .
in this section we describe the main characteristics and the input physics of both the model atmosphere and evolutionary codes .
computational details concerning calculation of pre - wd evolution are also presented . at low effective temperatures ,
wd cooling is sensitive to the treatment of the outer boundary condition .
thus , appropriate outer boundary conditions for the cooling he wd models are derived on the basis of detailed non - grey model atmospheres , as done in serenelli et al .
this is an important aspect as far as cool wd ages are concerned .
additionally , these model atmospheres allow us to provide a grid of colour indices and magnitudes for our evolving models .
the model atmospheric structure is described at length in rohrmann ( 2001 ) .
briefly , it is based on the assumption of constant gravity , local thermodynamic equilibrium and plane - parallel geometry , and includes the hydrogen and helium species ( zero metallicity ) . energy transfer by radiation and convection is considered and a standard linearization technique is employed to solve the resulting equations .
the following species are taken into account : h , h@xmath4 , e@xmath5 , h@xmath5 , h@xmath6 , h@xmath4@xmath6 , h@xmath7@xmath6 , he , he@xmath6 and he@xmath8 .
all relevant bound - free , free - free and scattering processes contributing to opacity have been included in our calculations .
up - to - date collision - induced absorptions ( cia opacities ) due to h@xmath4-h@xmath4 , h@xmath4-he and h - he collisions are taken from the cross section calculations by borysow , jorgensen & fu ( 2001 ) , jorgensen et al .
( 2000 ) and gustafsson & frommhold ( 2001 ) , respectively .
cia represents a major source of opacity in the infrared and dominates the shape of the emergent spectrum at low effective temperatures .
broadband colour indices have been calculated using the optical @xmath9 and infrared @xmath10 passbands of bessell ( 1990 ) and bessell & brett ( 1988 ) , respectively .
we use the callibration constants as derived on the basis of the synthetic flux of the model ( = 9400 k , @xmath11 ) calculated by kurucz ( 1979 ) for vega , rather than the constants of bergeron , ruiz & leggett ( 1997 ) we employed in serenelli et al .
( 2001 ) . in the present work ,
important improvements have been incorporated in our model atmospheres , which have enabled us to derive accurate colours and magnitudes for both early and advanced stages of the cooling .
specifically , hydrogen line opacities from the lyman , balmer and paschen series and pseudo - continuun absorptions have been included in our calculations .
also , non - ideal effects in the computation of chemical equilibrium of mixed hydrogen and helium gases are accounted via the occupation formalism of hummer & mihalas ( 1988 ) , together with a modified version of the optical simulation of dppen , anderson & mihalas ( 1987 ) to assess opacities in non - ideal gases . for more details about the model atmospheres used in this work
we refer the reader to rohrmann et al .
( 2002 ) . and @xmath0= 0.0002 .
effective temperatures and surface gravities are indicated in each panel .
models are characterized by pure hydrogen outer layers , resulting from element diffusion .
solid lines show the present calculations including line opacity , non - ideal gas model and up - to - date cia opacities .
dotted lines indicate the results obtained with our previous treatment of model atmospheres.,title="fig:",width=321 ] -.5 cm in fig .
[ fig.flu ] we show the emergent spectrum of our 0.280 m@xmath1 he wd model at some selected points of its evolution .
the prediction of the present calculations , plotted with solid lines , are compared with our older treatment given in serenelli et al .
note that for effective temperatures above @xmath3 7000k , hydrogen lines strongly modify the shape of the flux distribution , so their effect is expected to affect particularly the u and b colours . at low effective temperature ,
the emergent spectrum is modeled by the cia opacity , and the bulk of radiation is forced to emerge at higher frequencies as compared with the blackbody prediction . as a result , most colour indices will exhibit a pronounced turnoff to the blue as the effective temperature decreases below @xmath3 4000k .
note finally that the present calculation predicts a flux distribution somewhat different from that of our older treatment .
this is due partly to the inclusion of nonideal effects and the use of updated cia opacity data as well .
the evolutionary calculations presented in this work have been carried out with the same evolutionary code that described in althaus et al .
( 2001a ) .
we present briefly here the main physical inputs of the code and refer the reader to that article for a more comprehensive description .
wd evolution is accomplished in a self - consistent way with abundance changes as predicted by element diffusion and nuclear burning . in order to achieve this , gravitational settling , and chemical and thermal diffusion of nuclear species
have been fully taken into account following the multicomponent gas treatment of burgers ( 1969 ) .
hydrogen burning is considered through a complete network of thermonuclear reactions for the proton - proton chain and the cno bi - cycle . as a result of the various diffusion processes ,
the metallicity distribution evolves with time ; thus radiative opacities are calculated consistently with predictions from element diffusion and are taken from opal opacity tables ( iglesias & rogers 1996 ) .
initial he wd
models have been obtained by abstracting mass from a 1 m@xmath1 model at appropriate stages of its evolution off the main sequence .
we have considered two different metallicity values for our wd progenitor models , @xmath0= 0.001 and @xmath0= 0.0002 , chosen in order to be representative of low metallicity environments that are found in many globular clusters . for
he wd models more massive than 0.2 m@xmath1 in the case of a metallicity value @xmath0= 0.001 and more massive than 0.23 m@xmath1 for @xmath0=0.0002 , mass loss was invoked at different stages during the evolution along the red giant branch .
however , for less massive models we have followed a different procedure .
mass loss is initiated soon after the 1 m@xmath1 model leaves the main sequence and starts its excursion redwards in the hertzsprung - russell diagram ( hrd ) .
we have followed the accepted idea that he wds ( particularly low mass he wds ) are formed in binary systems where the he wd progenitor undergoes a strong mass loss phase due to roche lobe overflow .
indeed , for low mass models we have computed pre - wd evolution by imposing that mass loss rates are fixed by the condition that the stellar radius must remain close to the radius of the roche lobe . to compute the radius of the roche lobe
we assume that our 1 m@xmath1 model has a 1.4 m@xmath1 companion ( representative of a pulsar companion ) .
given the initial semiaxis of the orbit , we obtain the radius of the roche lobe by means of the analytic approximation given by eggleton ( 1983 ) @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the radius of the roche lobe , @xmath14 the semiaxis of the orbit and @xmath15 is the mass ratio .
we have assumed that mass loss from our 1 m@xmath1 is fully non - conservative , i.e. all the matter lost from the wd progenitor leaves the system and carries off its intrinsic angular momentum . to this end , we have followed the formulation given by podsiadlowski , joss & hsu ( 1992 ) , that is @xmath16 here , @xmath17 means the total angular momentum , @xmath18 its time derivative caused by mass loss and @xmath19 the total mass of the system .
sub - indices 1 and 2 refer to the wd progenitor and the 1.4@xmath20 companion respectively .
finally @xmath21 is the mass loss rate of the wd progenitor .
in addition , we have also considered angular momentum losses due to gravitational wave radiation ( landau & lifshitz 1971 ) @xmath22 which is an important contribution to angular momentum losses in binaries with very short periods .
finally , magnetic stellar wind braking when a convective envelope developes has also been accounted for as in sarna et al .
( 2000 ) : @xmath23 in order to follow the time evolution of @xmath17 , we integrate the equation @xmath24 and with the aid of kepler s third law we finally get @xmath14 ( and @xmath13 through eq . [ eq.egg ] ) .
the present treatment for mass loss is not self - consistent since the mass loss rate is not incorporated as a new unknown quantity to be solved during the iteration procedure in the henyey scheme used to solve the stellar structure equations , but instead is fixed in advance for each model .
however , we want to recall that our main interest in this work is not to analyse the properties ( initial / final periods , masses , semiaxis ) of binary systems that lead to the formation of hewd - millisecond pulsar pairs , but to study the cooling time - scales and photometric properties of cooling hewds . also , it is worth mentioning that the algorithm applied in the present work to simulate mass loss phases represents a much better approach to obtain physically sound initial hewd models than that of simply abstracting mass as done previously in althaus et al .
( 2001a ) .
wd progenitor with initially 1 m@xmath1 and @xmath0=0.0002 . dotted line depicts the evolution during mass loss phase , which starts when the star fills its roche lobe at r= 1.6 r@xmath1 .
the initial and final semiaxis are 5.25 and 4.6 r@xmath1 respectively .
the initial and final periods are 0.9d in both cases.,title="fig:",width=311 ] -3.5 cm for the purpose of illustration , we show in fig .
[ fig.bin ] the evolution in the hrd for the 0.219 m@xmath1 wd progenitor having initially 1 m@xmath1 .
note that during the first stages of mass loss , the wd progenitor evolves at almost constant radius .
small deviations from constant - radius evolution are caused by the fact that the semiaxis increases slightly as a result of mass loss from the least massive component of the pair .
as evolution proceeds , an outer convection zone developes and magnetic braking starts to play an important role with the consequent result that the orbit starts to shrink . during the final stage of mass loss
, the wd progenitor evolves again at constant radius until it eventually shrinks within the roche lobe and mass loss halts .
to place our results on a more quantitative basis we list in table [ tab.bin ] the main characteristics for some of our less massive wd progenitors .
in particular , for a given wd model , we list the metallicity , the surface hydrogen abundance at the end of mass loss phase and the initial and final period and semiaxis .
we want to mention that our results agree quite well with more detailed calculations in which the mass loss phase is calculated self - consistently ( sarna et al . 2000 ) .
.main characteristics of some low mass pre - wd progenitor calculations . [ cols="^,>,<,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab.bin ] we want to mention that the assumptions made in our mass loss treatment give rise to initial he wd models with relatively large hydrogen envelopes , which favours the occurrence of appreciable hydrogen burning and cno thermonuclear flashes during the wd stage .
this is also true if progenitor stars are more massive than the 1 m@xmath1 value assumed in this work .
we have checked this assertion by performing additional calculations on the basis our mass loss prescription .
however , it is possible that he wds may also be formed in binary systems which have experienced mass loss episodes via a common - envelope stage , in which case mass transfer would be unstable
. this could be the case for instance if the accretor is a c / o wd ( see , for instance , han 1998 ) .
this different evolutionary history for the he wd progenitor could affect the hydrogen layer thickness and accordingly the he wd cooling rate .
the treatment of the common envelope stage is a difficult one and it has not been considered in this paper . as stated before ,
two low metallicity values have been considered in this study : @xmath0= 0.001 and @xmath0= 0.0002 and we have computed a grid of models for each of these values . in the case of @xmath0= 0.0002 , we have followed the evolution of he wd models with stellar masses of 0.199 , 0.209 , 0.219 , 0.225 , 0.243 , 0.266 , 0.280 , 0.300 and 0.319 m@xmath1 ; and for the case of @xmath0= 0.001 we considered 0.172 , 0.183 , 0.197 , 0.230 , 0.244 , 0.300 , 0.336 , 0.380 , 0.390 , 0.422 and 0.449 m@xmath1 .
all of these models were evolved from the end of mass - loss phase , during the pre - wd evolution , through the stages of hydrogen shell flashes ( when they take place ) down to very advanced stages of evolution .
qualitatively , the evolution of he wds with low metallicity is not markedly different from the case of solar metallicity analysed in our previous studies ( althaus et al .
indeed , we find that objects with masses above a certain threshold value experience several episodes of hydrogen thermonuclear flashes due to the massive hydrogen envelopes resulting from binary evolution .
the existence of such flash episodes affect the further cooling history of the star .
however , the low metal content has an important effect on the evolution of hewds , particularly regarding the occurrence and characteristics of cno thermonuclear flashes . in broad outline ,
cno flashes become less intense as the metal content is decreased .
this is the main reason why loops in the hrd induced by cno flashes are markedly less extended in the case of lowest metallicity .
this is illustrated in figs .
[ fig.tck02 ] and [ fig.tck1 ] , where we present the evolutionary tracks of some selected hewd sequences with an initial metal content @xmath0= 0.0002 and @xmath0= 0.001 respectively .
-6.2 cm -6.2 cm it is worth mentioning that the stellar mass threshold ( m@xmath25 ) for the occurrence of cno hydrogen flashes depends on the assumed metal content . specifically , for @xmath0= 0.001 and @xmath0= 0.0002 we find a lower mass limit for the occurrence of cno flashes of m@xmath26 0.22 and 0.26 m@xmath1 , respectively ( in the case of solar metallicity m@xmath25 becomes @xmath3 0.18 m@xmath1 ; see althaus et al .
with regard to the upper mass boundary , our most massive model with @xmath0= 0.0002 and 0.319 m@xmath1 is fully unstable , whilst for the case @xmath0= 0.001 we find a cno hydrogen flash even for a stellar mass value as high as 0.422 m@xmath1 , but not in the sequence with @xmath27 0.449 m@xmath1 .
we also want to comment on the fact that the mass range for the occurrence of hydrogen flashes depends on whether element diffusion is considered or not , as we find previously for the solar metallicity case ( althaus et al .
for instance , in the absence of diffusion , only our 0.280 , 0.300 and 0.319 m@xmath1 sequences undergo thermal instabilities in the case of @xmath0= 0.0002 . for the other metallicity value , @xmath0= 0.001
, models in the range between 0.24 and 0.35 m@xmath1 approximately , suffer from this instabilities .
a feature worthy of comment predicted by our calculations is the existence of thermal instabilities in models with @xmath0= 0.0002 at more advanced stages of evolution than those at which cno flashes occur .
these instabilities are related to unstable hydrogen burning via the proton - proton chains ( pp ) which dominate hydrogen burning at advanced ages .
the existence of such pp flashes can be understood on the basis of a much thicker hydrogen envelope characterizing these models .
this is a result of the cno burning being inefficient in depleting the hydrogen content of the envelope of the star during the pre - wd evolution as well as during cno flashes .
after the end of cno flash episodes , the radial extent of the upper boundary of the hydrogen burning shell diminishes as evolution proceeds . at the same time
, some hydrogen chemically diffuses downwards to hotter layers .
when the burning shell is thin enough , nuclear burning becomes unstable , as predicted by the instability criterion of kippenhahn & weigert ( 1990 ) ( see driebe et al .
1999 for an application of this instability criterion in the context of cno flashes in hewds ) @xmath28 where @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the gravothermal and constant pressure specific heats respectively , @xmath31 is the adiabatic gradient , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 is the radial coordinate of the shell and @xmath35 its radial extent ( defined as the point at which nuclear burning falls below 0.001 of the maximum value ) .
we find that this criterion is fulfilled in our models at the onset of pp flashes at @xmath3 8500k .
in particular , this is because of the large values reached by the quantity @xmath36 , which exceeds 10 at the onset of the flash ; while @xmath37 and @xmath38 are close to 0.85 and 0.60 respectively .
pp - induced flashes differ from their cno counterparts in some respects .
for instance , in most cases pp flashes are less intense than the cno ones and during flash episodes convective mixing in the outer layers of the star is less frequent than for cno flashes .
an interesting characteristic of these flashes is that after a pp hydrogen flash is initiated , the star is forced to move in the hr diagram following lines of almost constant radii close to the cooling track .
also , during each of these pp flashes , the total amount of hydrogen in the star is barely reduced by nuclear burning with the result that the star in general will experience numerous episodes of this kind . in the sequences with
@xmath0= 0.001 only those models which lack cno flashes experience pp hydrogen flashes , but they occur at extremely high ages .
all of our sequences with @xmath0= 0.0002 are characterized by pp hydrogen flashes even if they have experienced cno flashes earlier in their evolution .
the important point to emphasize here is that the pp flashes are induced by chemical diffusion that carries some hydrogen downwards deep enough for the star to ignite hydrogen there . except for the less massive models ( @xmath39 0.25 m@xmath1 ) , pp flashes in the sequences with @xmath0= 0.0002 take place between 2 and 4 gyr after the end of mass loss episodes . in general , the more massive the he wd , the earlier in the life of the star these pp flashes occur .
it is worth emphasizing again that the existence of such pp flashes in he wds is restricted to the case of metallicity much lower than the solar metallicity .
for instance , such flashes are absent in the case of models with @xmath0= 0.02 , and only our 0.172 and 0.183 m@xmath1 models with @xmath0= 0.001 suffer from them .
the fact that essentially models with extremely low metal content experience pp flashes can be understood on the basis that such models are left with hydrogen envelopes so massive that the tail of hydrogen distribution chemically diffusing inwards reaches hot enough layers .
this increases the hydrogen burning by pp reactions and leads to a thermal instability .
( @xmath0= 0.0002 ) . for more massive models ,
spikes correspond to evolutionary stages during flash episodes .
it is clear that models which experience unstable burning reach very low effective temperatures well within 15 gyr.,title="fig:",width=302 ] -3.5 cm ( @xmath0= 0.001 ) .
spikes correspond to evolutionary stages during flash episodes . as shown in fig .
[ fig.age02 ] , models characterized by unstable burning reach very low effective temperatures well within 15 gyr . for the 0.449 m@xmath1 sequence a short evolutionary time - scale
is obtained even in the absence of thermonuclear flashes.,title="fig:",width=302 ] -3.5 cm in figs .
[ fig.age02 ] and [ fig.age1 ] we show the effective temperature as a function of cooling age for the same stellar mass values as given in figs . [ fig.tck02 ] and [ fig.tck1 ] respectively .
note that the lack of cno thermonuclear flashes in less massive models leads to a very slow rate of evolution , that is such models remain relatively bright even at very large ages .
this is so because stable hydrogen shell burning via pp nuclear reactions constitutes the main source of luminosity over most of the entire evolution of these models . on the contrary
, the existence of diffusion - induced cno thermonuclear flashes leads eventuallyto he wd models with hydrogen envelope masses small enough for nuclear burning not to appreciably contribute to the luminosity budget of the star .
accordingly , such models are characterized by short evolutionary time - scales .
this age dichotomy between models with and without cno flashes manifests also itself in cooling sequences with a solar metal content ( althaus et al .
it is worth noting that such a dichotomy is less accentuated in the case of models with very low metal content . to place this assertion on a more quantitative basis , we mention that in reaching a value of teff= 8000 k , models with 0.219 , 0.243 , 0.280 and 0.319 m@xmath1 ( @xmath0= 0.0002 ) need about 10 , 8.7 , 3.1 and 2.3 gyr , respectively . in the case of @xmath0= 0.001 ,
models with 0.197 , 0.300 , 0.380 and 0.449 m@xmath1 need about 10 , 1 , 2.2 and 3.1 gyr , respectively .
the dependence of the cooling history on the assumed initial metallicity can be understood by inspecting fig .
[ fig.nuc ] in which we show the time dependence of hydrogen burning luminosity for our 0.300 m@xmath1 sequences with @xmath0= 0.001 and @xmath0= 0.0002 . in the case of @xmath0= 0.001 ,
after 1.5 gyr of the occurrence of cno flashes , stable hydrogen burning reaches a maximum contribution to surface luminosity of 35% .
afterwards , nuclear burning becomes less important as evolution proceeds .
for instance , at 4 gyr , it only contributes less than 10% to the star s luminosity .
in contrast , in the case of @xmath0= 0.0002 , stable nuclear burning contributes appreciably to surface luminosity even at an age of 6 gyr .
after cno flashes , stable nuclear burning contributes more than 60% of the energy radiated by the star within the first 5 gyr .
this contribution drops rather abruptly during the subsequent stages of evolution , eventually reaching 10% at 7 gyr . with regard to fig .
[ fig.nuc ] , let us finally mention that we have also included the 0.197 m@xmath1 sequence ( @xmath0= 0.001 ) which does not suffer from flash episodes . in this case , the stellar luminosity is completely supported by stable hydrogen burning along the entire cooling branch , which is clearly shown in fig . [ fig.nuc ] .
= 0.001 ) and 0.300 ( @xmath0= 0.001 and @xmath0=0.0002 ) he wd models .
note that for the lowest mass shown , the lack of thermonuclear flashes causes surface luminosity to be almost exclusively supported by stable hydrogen burning .
in contrast , for more massive models , stable nuclear burning following the flash episodes contributes only partially to the energy budget of the star .
note also that as z is increased , the contribution of residual hydrogen burning becomes less important.,title="fig:",width=302 ] -4.1 cm in figs .
[ fig.iso1 ] and [ fig.iso02 ] we plot the isochrones for some selected ages in the mass - effective temperature plane for our @xmath0= 0.001 and @xmath0= 0.0002 models respectively .
note that at the stellar mass threshold , m@xmath25 , the isochrone plots exhibit a pronounced discontinuity .
this is not surprising in view of the age dichotomy discussed earlier .
the plot corresponding to @xmath0= 0.001 models resembles that of he wd models with an initial solar - like metal content ( althaus et al .
this is particularly true regarding the presence of an age dichotomy at , in this case , m@xmath40 m@xmath1 .
we judge that future observations of low mass wds with millisecond pulsar companions formed in low - metallicity environments could eventually place our predictions on solid observational grounds .
another feature worthy of comment depicted by fig .
[ fig.iso1 ] is the existence of a bump in the isochrone curves at 0.380 - 0.390 m@xmath1 , particularly at low ages .
this behaviour can be understood on the basis of the role played by stable pp hydrogen burning after cno flash episodes .
specifically , after experiencing only one cno flash , the 0.380 and 0.390 m@xmath1 models are left with a hydrogen envelope thin enough so as to inhibit the occurrence of another cno flash .
however , envelopes are thick enough to mantain an appreciable amount of nuclear energy release through stable pp hydrogen burning , thus slowing the cooling rate at intermediate stages of evolution .
finally , note the increase of the isochrone curves for the most massive sequence , which does not undergo any thermonuclear flash , thus resulting in comparatively large cooling ages .
the situation for the case of @xmath0= 0.0002 sequences is qualitatively similar , though the age dichotomy is less noticeable and it is located at m@xmath41 m@xmath1 . as explained earlier , this is a result of the fact that , in this case , during flash episodes cno cycle reactions are less efficient than for higher metallicities and thus , hydrogen envelope is not so drastically consumed . -.2
cm = 0.001 .
the abrupt drop shown by isochrones in the range 0.20 - 0.22 m@xmath1 is a consequence of the existence of a mass threshold for the occurrence of cno flashes .
much shorter cooling ages result if the mass of the model is above this threshold value .
the bump exhibited by the isochrones at @xmath3 0.38 m@xmath1 is related to an increase in the efficiency of pp stable nuclear burning at low ages . for more details , see text.,title="fig:",width=321 ] -4.7 cm -.2 cm but for the case @xmath0= 0.0002 .
here isochrones exhibit a not so pronounced drop as in the case of @xmath0= 0.001 models . for models that not suffer from cno flashes
, calculations were stopped before pp flashes begin and thus , some low mass models have not reached ages as large as 10 gyr ( because of this reason , the 10 and 12 gyr isochrones do not join up).,title="fig:",width=321 ] -4.7 cm the evolution of our he wd models in the colour - magnitude diagrams is illustrated in fig .
[ fig.col ] , which shows the run of the absolute visual magnitude @xmath42 for our models as a function of the colour indices @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
note that models which have suffered from cno thermonuclear flashes show a turn - off in the @xmath44 colour at @xmath45 16 and @xmath46 1.4 .
this turn - off , which results from the strong cia opacity by molecular hydrogen at low temperatures , is reached well within 15 gyr , mostly by he wds with @xmath0= 0.001 . after reaching the turn - off ,
the emergent spectrum becomes bluer and remains brighter than @xmath47 17 with subsequent cooling .
a similar trend has been also found for the case of solar metallicity ( serenelli et al . 2001 ) , though in that situation he wds with stellar masses even as low as @xmath3 0.19 m@xmath1 reach high magnitude values .
-4.5 cm in fig .
[ fig.col ] we have also included the recent observational data of taylor et al ( 2001 ) and edmonds et al .
( 2001 ) for the he wd candidates in the globular clusters ngc 6397 and 47 tucanae , respectively . for ngc 6397
we have adopted a distance modulus ( m - m)@xmath48= 12.29 and e(b - v)= 0.18 ( cool et al .
1998 ) . in the case of 47 tucanae ,
( m - m)@xmath49= 13.39 and e(b - v)= 0.055 ( zoccali et al . 2001 ) were used to transform to absolute magnitudes and to deredden colour indices . in both cases , exctintion laws from holtzman et al .
( 1995 ) were applied .
let us consider first the hewd candidates in ngc 6397
. given the metal content for ngc 6397 ( [ fe / h= -1.82 ] ; anthony - twarog & twarog 2000 ) , then our @xmath0= 0.0002 sequences are appropriate for a direct comparison with observations .
note that the six hewd candidates in ngc 6397 can be split into two groups .
in particular , for the three brightest stars of the observed sequence , our evolutionary models fit the observational data quite well .
we find that such he wds would be characterized by stellar mass values in the range 0.2 - 0.22 m@xmath1 , which is below the mass value for the occurrence of cno flashes .
with regard to age determination , we find ages between 0.5 - 1.5 gyr for these stars .
by contrast , the three dimmest stars appear to have larger radii even as compared with our least massive model ( @xmath50m@xmath1 ) , as it is clear from the lower right panel of fig .
[ fig.col ] .
we want to point out that , based on our mass loss treatment , we find a minimum mass value for the resulting he core remnant which is very close to 0.2 m@xmath1 for progenitors with @xmath0= 0.0002 .
we have checked this by performing additional pre - wd calculations for different initial binary configurations . in this context ,
burderi , dantona & burgay ( 2002 ) have also found that their evolutionary models have smaller radii than those required to fit the observational data .
in addition , they also find a minimum mass limit of @xmath50m@xmath1 for hewds with very low metallicity progenitors .
however , it is worth noting that our models are somewhat less compact than those presented by burderi et al .
we judge that this difference could be a result of the fact that in our calculations we have included chemical element diffusion which leads to pure hydrogen envelopes and thus to models with larger radii ( althaus et al .
2001a ) , thus reducing the discrepancy with observations .
another point worthy of comment in connection with this second group of hewd candidates is related to their ages .
indeed , our least massive sequence yields cooling ages between 10 and 15 gyr for these stars . value for the occurrence of cno thermonuclear flashes . ]
if we take into account the time elapsed during the pre - wd evolution ( which is about 6 - 7 gyr for a 1 m@xmath1 progenitor ) , then the age of these stars would be in the range 16 - 21 gyr , larger than the age of the cluster , which is @xmath51 gyr ( anthony - twarog & twarog 2000 ) .
this suggests that the progenitors of these hewd candidates should have been more massive than 1 m@xmath1 with , therefore , shorter pre - wd evolutionary ages . to explore this possibility
, we have performed additional calculations with our mass loss prescription .
for instance , we found that starting from a 1.4 m@xmath1 progenitor with a 1.4 m@xmath1 companion and an initial period of 0.5 days , the pre - wd evolution lasts for about 3 gyr and the mass of the wd remnant is 0.195 m@xmath1 .
this would help to alleviate the age discrepancy mentioned above . in this regard ,
we believe that a more comprehensive exploration of the binary nature leading to the formation of hewds , particularly for progenitors with very low metal content , is worth carrying out . with regard to the he wd candidate in the globular cluster 47 tucanae
, we find that our evolutionary models with @xmath0= 0.001 , a metallicity value not very different from that of 47 tucanae ( [ fe / h= -0.76 ] ) , yield a good agreement with observations for the @xmath43 index .
in particular , we derive a stellar mass value of @xmath3 0.17 m@xmath1 and a cooling age of about 1.5 gyr for the wd .
this age is consistent with the 2 gyr corresponding to the spin - down age of the millisecond pulsar companion to the wd ( edmonds et al .
2001 and referenced cited therein ) .
note that , as far as the @xmath44 index is concerned , we find no agreement with observational data .
in fact , our evolutionary models are located too far to the blue .
a lower stellar mass value ( m @xmath3 0.15 - 0.16 m@xmath1 ) than our lowest mass sequence would be needed to match the observed @xmath44 . in the case of @xmath0= 0.0002 and for the stellar masses we considered ,
we find no agreement with observations for neither of the metallicities . finally , we list in table [ tab.z1 ] and [ tab.z2 ] some colour indices for he wd models with , respectively , @xmath0= 0.0002 and @xmath0= 0.001 at selected effective temperature values .
we also list the surface gravity ( @xmath52 ) , the age ( in gyr ) , the bolometric correction ( @xmath53 ) and the absolute visual magnitude ( @xmath42 ) .
in this study we have explored the evolution of helium - core white dwarf ( he wd ) stars with progenitors having much lower metallicities than the solar metallicity usually assumed in the modeling of these stars .
the models presented here are appropriate for the interpretation of recent and future observations of low - mass wds in globular clusters .
specifically , two low metallicity values have been considered : @xmath0= 0.001 and @xmath0= 0.0002 . in the case of @xmath0= 0.0002 ,
we have followed the evolution of he wd models with stellar masses of 0.199 , 0.209 , 0.219 , 0.225 , 0.243 , 0.266 , 0.280 , 0.300 and 0.319 m@xmath1 ; and for the case of @xmath0= 0.001 we considered 0.172 , 0.183 , 0.197 , 0.230 , 0.244 , 0.300 , 0.336 , 0.380 , 0.390 , 0.422 and 0.449 m@xmath1 .
all of these models were evolved from the end of mass - loss phase down to very advanced phases of evolution .
the binary nature of our he wd models has been simulated by abstracting mass from a 1 m@xmath1 model at appropriate stages of its evolution off the main sequence .
specifically , to obtain physically sound initial low - mass he wd models , mass transfer rates were derived by imposing that the stellar radius remains close to the radius of the roche lobe .
a fully non - conservative approach was assumed and the loss of angular momentum caused by gravitational wave emission as well as magnetic stellar wind braking have been taken into account . the evolution of our he wd models has been computed in a self - consistent way with the predictions of time - dependent element diffusion and nuclear burning . a non - gray treatment for the atmosphere that considered the energy transfer by radiation and convection has been employed to derive the outer boundary conditions of our evolving models .
models atmosphere are based on a detailed treatment of the microphysics entering the wd atmospheres , such as non - ideal effects in the equation of state ( as given by the occupation formalism of hummer & mihalas 1988 ) and the inclusion of hydrogen line ( from the balmer , lyman and paschen series ) and pseudo - continuum opacities .
also , up - to - date collision - induced absorption data ( rohrmann et al . 2002 ) were incorporated in the computations .
such a detailed description allowed us to provide a grid of accurate colour indices and magnitudes at both early and advanced evolutionary stages , strongly improving previous efforts ( serenelli et al .
2001 ) .
a feature worthy of comment predicted by our calculations is the existence of thermonuclear flash episodes for most of our he wd sequences . in part
, this is a result of including in our computations the various chemical diffusion processes .
we find that the lower the metallicity @xmath0 , the larger the minumum stellar mass for the occurrence of hydrogen thermonuclear flashes induced by the cno cycle reactions .
specifically , for @xmath0= 0.001 and @xmath0= 0.0002 we find a lower mass limit for the existence of cno flashes of @xmath54 0.22 and 0.26 m@xmath1 , respectively ( in the case of @xmath0= 0.02 such a limit becomes @xmath3 0.18 m@xmath1 ; see althaus et al .
in addition , cno flashes become less intense as the metal content of the star is decreased and the mass range for the occurrence of such instabilities depends strongly on the inclusion of chemical diffusion processes in evolutionary calculations .
we also find that the existence of a mass threshold for the occurrence of diffusion - induced cno flashes leads to an age dichotomy ( particularly for @xmath0= 0.001 ) between he wd models with and without cno thermonuclear flashes : he wds which do not experience cno thermonuclear flashes evolve very slowly , so they remain relatively bright even at very large ages , whilst those which suffer from such flashes are characterized by a fast cooling , reaching very low effective temperature stages within cooling times less than 15 gyr .
such an age dichotomy is translated into distinctive features in the isochrone plots which could eventually be compared with observational expectations .
it is worth mentioning that during the short - lived , cno diffusion - induced flashes , an appreciable amount of hydrogen is burnt , ultimately implying that the wd is left with a relatively thin hydrogen envelope which prevents stable hydrogen burning from being an important energy source at late cooling stages . as a result ,
the star has a much lower amount of available energy , which implies much shorter evolutionary time scales as compared with the situation when cno flashes are absent .
another finding of this work is related to the fact that some of our he wd models experience several episodes of thermal instabilities related to unstable hydrogen burning via the proton - proton ( pp ) nuclear reactions .
these pp flashes , which take place at more advanced stages of evolution than those at which the cno flashes occur , are experienced by all of our sequences with @xmath0= 0.0002 .
in addition , our 0.172 and 0.183 m@xmath1 models with @xmath0= 0.001 suffer from pp flashes , but at exceedingly high ages .
we find that pp thermal instabilities are triggered by chemical diffusion that carries some hydrogen downwards deep enough for the star to ignite hydrogen there . except for the less massive models ( @xmath55 0.25 m@xmath1 ) ,
pp flashes take place between 2 and 4 gyr after the end of mass loss episodes , and in general , the more massive the he wd , the earlier in the star life they occur .
the evolution of our he wd models has also been analysed in the colour - magnitude diagrams .
we find that models which have suffered from cno flashes exhibit a turn - off in most of their colours at m@xmath2 16 .
this turn - off , which results from the strong cia opacity by molecular hydrogen at low temperatures , is reached well within 15 gyr , mostly by he wds with @xmath0= 0.001 .
finally , the predictions of our models for the colour - magnitude diagrams have been compared with recent observational data of he wd candidates in the globular clusters ngc 6397 and 47 tucanae ( taylor et al .
2001 and edmonds et al .
2001 , respectively ) . in this connection
, we find that the three brightest hewd candidates in ngc 6397 can indeed be identified as hewds characterized by stellar mass values of 0.20 - 0.22 m@xmath1 ( which is below the mass value for the occurrence of cno flashes ) and ages ranging from 0.5 to 1.5 gyr .
however , in the case of the three dimmest candidates , the agreement with observational data is not so evident as in the case of the brightest objects .
indeed , our models appear to be more massive than required by observations .
specifically , our mass - loss treatment gives rise to a minimum value of @xmath560.2 m@xmath1 an hewd may have from progenitors with initially @xmath0= 0.0002 .
however , it is worth noting that a @xmath57 would allow a very good agreement between theoretical predictions and observations . in this sense
, it is remarkable that the quoted uncertainty in the case of the hewd candidate in 47 tucanae is very close to this value ( see fig.10 ) .
finally the he wd in 47 tucanae is particularly relevant because the spin - down age of its millisecond pulsar companion yields a wd age estimate . specifically , the pulsar age of 2 gyr ( see edmonds et al .
2001 ) is in agreement with the prediction of our @xmath0= 0.001 he wd sequences .
in addition , the observational data for the m@xmath49 and @xmath43 is consistent with our 0.17 m@xmath1 sequence .
@ccccccccccccc@ @xmath58 & & @xmath59 & @xmath60 ( gyr ) & u - b & b - v & v - r & v - k & r - i & j - h & h - k & bc & m@xmath61 + 0.199 & 8920 & 4.3218 & 0.295 & -0.09 & 0.10 & 0.04 & 0.12 & 0.06 & 0.07 & -0.09 & -0.09 & 4.41 + & 10780 & 4.5281 & 0.494 & -0.24 & -0.05 & -0.03 & -0.20 & -0.02 & 0.02 & -0.10 & -0.40 & 4.42 + & 14220 & 5.0085 & 0.683 & -0.52 & -0.13 & -0.07 & -0.45 & -0.07 & -0.02 & -0.12 & -1.08 & 5.09 + & 16150 & 5.3500 & 0.791 & -0.64 & -0.15 & -0.08 & -0.54 & -0.09 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.41 & 5.72 + & 16880 & 5.5465 & 0.861 & -0.68 & -0.16 & -0.08 & -0.57 & -0.10 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.52 & 6.14 + & 17110 & 5.6901 & 0.924 & -0.69 & -0.15 & -0.08 & -0.58 & -0.10 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.56 & 6.47 + & 16810 & 5.9008 & 1.054 & -0.68 & -0.14 & -0.08 & -0.56 & -0.10 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.51 & 7.03 + & 16430 & 5.9817 & 1.124 & -0.66 & -0.13 & -0.08 & -0.55 & -0.09 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.45 & 7.27 + & 15960 & 6.0522 & 1.201 & -0.64 & -0.12 & -0.08 & -0.53 & -0.09 & -0.03 & -0.13 & -1.37 & 7.49 + & 15430 & 6.1141 & 1.283 & -0.61 & -0.11 & -0.07 & -0.50 & -0.08 & -0.03 & -0.12 & -1.28 & 7.71 + & 14870 & 6.1704 & 1.375 & -0.58 & -0.09 & -0.07 & -0.47 & -0.08 & -0.02 & -0.12 & -1.19 & 7.91 + & 14280 & 6.2219 & 1.478 & -0.54 & -0.08 & -0.07 & -0.45 & -0.07 & -0.02 & -0.12 & -1.08 & 8.11 + & 13700 & 6.2699 & 1.594 & -0.51 & -0.06 & -0.06 & -0.41 & -0.06 & -0.01 & -0.12 & -0.97 & 8.30 + & 13110 & 6.3151 & 1.725 &
-0.47 & -0.04 & -0.06 & -0.38 & -0.06 & -0.01 & -0.12 & -0.86 & 8.49 + & 12530 & 6.3582 & 1.876 & -0.43 & -0.01 & -0.05 & -0.34 & -0.05 & 0.00 & -0.12 & -0.74 & 8.68 + & 11960 & 6.4003 & 2.058 & -0.39 & 0.02 & -0.04 & -0.29 & -0.04 & 0.01 & -0.11 & -0.63 & 8.88 + & 11430 & 6.4419 & 2.295 & -0.36 & 0.05 & -0.03 & -0.24 & -0.02 & 0.02 & -0.11 & -0.53 & 9.07 + & 10930 & 6.4858 & 2.669 & -0.35 & 0.08 & -0.02 & -0.18 & -0.01 & 0.03 & -0.11 & -0.43 & 9.28 + & 10470 & 6.5314 & 3.356 & -0.35 & 0.11 & 0.00 & -0.12 & 0.01 & 0.03 & -0.11 & -0.34 & 9.49 + & 9990 & 6.5726 & 4.351 & -0.37 & 0.15 & 0.03 & -0.04 & 0.04 & 0.05 & -0.10 & -0.26 & 9.72 + & 9510 & 6.6103 & 5.577 & -0.39 & 0.18 & 0.06 & 0.08 & 0.07 & 0.06 & -0.10 & -0.21 & 9.98 + & 9040 & 6.6448 & 6.985 &
-0.42 & 0.22 & 0.10 & 0.21 & 0.10 & 0.08 & -0.09 & -0.17 & 10.24 + & 8570 & 6.6772 & 8.658 & -0.45 & 0.26 & 0.13 & 0.34 & 0.13 & 0.10 & -0.08 & -0.14 & 10.53 + & 8110 & 6.7069 & 10.622 & -0.47 & 0.29 & 0.17 & 0.49 & 0.17 & 0.13 & -0.07 & -0.13 & 10.82 + & 7250 & 6.7575 & 15.738 & -0.48 & 0.36 & 0.23 & 0.81 & 0.23 & 0.18 & -0.04 & -0.11 & 11.42 + + 0.243 & 15050 & 4.4210 & 0.131 & -0.59 & -0.18 & -0.08 & -0.51 & -0.09 & -0.03 & -0.12 & -1.21 & 3.29 + & 21020 & 5.0959 & 0.161 & -0.84 & -0.23 & -0.10 & -0.72 & -0.13 & -0.07 & -0.14 & -2.10 & 4.42 + & 23930 & 5.4719 & 0.178 & -0.93 & -0.24 & -0.11 & -0.80 & -0.14 & -0.08 & -0.15 & -2.44 & 5.13 + & 25070 & 5.7041 & 0.190 & -0.95 & -0.24 & -0.12 & -0.82 & -0.15 & -0.08 & -0.15 & -2.56 & 5.63 + & 25360 & 5.8768 & 0.201 & -0.96 & -0.24 & -0.12 & -0.83 & -0.15 & -0.09 & -0.16 & -2.59 & 6.04 + & 24650 & 6.1290 & 0.229 & -0.94 & -0.23 & -0.12 & -0.81 & -0.14 & -0.08 & -0.15 & -2.51 & 6.72 + & 23920 & 6.2282 & 0.250 & -0.93 & -0.22 & -0.11 & -0.79 & -0.14 & -0.08 & -0.15 & -2.43 & 7.02 + & 23020 & 6.3141 & 0.277 & -0.91 & -0.21 & -0.11 & -0.77 & -0.14 & -0.07 & -0.15 & -2.33 & 7.30 + & 22000 & 6.3880 & 0.310 & -0.88 & -0.19 & -0.10 & -0.74 & -0.13 & -0.07 & -0.15 & -2.21 & 7.56 + & 20900 & 6.4526 & 0.350 & -0.85 & -0.18 & -0.10 & -0.71 & -0.12 & -0.06 & -0.14 & -2.08 & 7.81 + & 19780 & 6.5089 & 0.396 & -0.81 & -0.16 & -0.10 & -0.67 & -0.12 & -0.06 & -0.14 & -1.93 & 8.05 + & 18650 & 6.5594 & 0.451 & -0.77 & -0.14 & -0.09 & -0.64 & -0.11 & -0.05 & -0.14 & -1.78 & 8.27 + & 17540 & 6.6058 & 0.517 & -0.72 & -0.12 & -0.09 & -0.59 & -0.10 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.61 & 8.49 + & 16460 & 6.6489 & 0.596 & -0.68 & -0.10 & -0.08 & -0.55 & -0.09 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.44 & 8.71 + & 15420 & 6.6900 & 0.695 & -0.63 & -0.08 & -0.07 & -0.51 & -0.08 & -0.03 & -0.13 & -1.27 & 8.92 + & 14450 & 6.7296 & 0.826 & -0.57 & -0.05 & -0.07 & -0.46 & -0.07 & -0.02 & -0.12 & -1.10 & 9.13 + & 13540 & 6.7702 & 1.031 & -0.52 & -0.02 & -0.06 & -0.41 & -0.06 & -0.01 & -0.12 & -0.93 & 9.34 + & 12700 & 6.8121 & 1.418 & -0.46 & 0.01 & -0.05 & -0.35 & -0.05 & 0.00 & -0.12 & -0.77 & 9.57 + & 11870 & 6.8494 & 1.999 & -0.42 & 0.05 & -0.04 & -0.28 & -0.03 & 0.01 & -0.11 & -0.61 & 9.79 + & 11060 & 6.8826 & 2.771 & -0.41 & 0.09 & -0.01 & -0.20 & 0.00 & 0.03 & -0.11 & -0.45 & 10.02 + & 10290 & 6.9114 & 3.712 & -0.42 & 0.14 & 0.02 & -0.08 & 0.03 & 0.04 & -0.11 & -0.31 & 10.27 + & 9560 & 6.9384 & 4.897 & -0.44 & 0.18 & 0.07 & 0.09 & 0.07 & 0.06 & -0.10 & -0.23 & 10.58 + & 8240 & 6.9865 & 8.308 & -0.49 & 0.26 & 0.16 & 0.46 & 0.16 & 0.12 & -0.07 & -0.14 & 11.25 + + 0.300 & 24990 & 6.9774 & 0.065 & -0.97 & -0.21 & -0.12 & -0.82 & -0.15 & -0.08 & -0.16 & -2.53 & 8.57 + & 23390 & 6.9941 & 0.067 & -0.93 & -0.19 & -0.11 & -0.78 & -0.14 & -0.07 & -0.15 & -2.36 & 8.73 + & 21800 & 7.0043 & 0.076 & -0.89 & -0.17 & -0.10 & -0.74 & -0.13 & -0.07 & -0.15 & -2.18 & 8.88 + & 20050 & 7.0178 & 0.105 & -0.83 & -0.15 & -0.10 & -0.68 & -0.12 & -0.06 & -0.14 & -1.96 & 9.06 + & 18730 & 7.0331 & 0.133 & -0.79 & -0.13 & -0.09 & -0.64 & -0.11 & -0.05 & -0.14 & -1.78 & 9.21 + & 17510 & 7.0495 & 0.162 & -0.74 & -0.10 & -0.09 & -0.60 & -0.10 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.60 & 9.36 + & 16160 & 7.0699 & 0.199 & -0.68 & -0.08 & -0.08 & -0.54 & -0.09 & -0.03 & -0.13 & -1.39 & 9.55 + & 14930 & 7.0903 & 0.241 & -0.62 & -0.05 & -0.07 & -0.48 & -0.07 & -0.02 & -0.12 & -1.18 & 9.73 + & 13770 & 7.1113 & 0.293 & -0.55 & -0.01 & -0.06 & -0.42 & -0.06 & -0.01 & -0.12 & -0.97 & 9.93 + & 12870 & 7.1293 & 0.350 & -0.50 & 0.03 & -0.05 & -0.36 & -0.05 & 0.00 & -0.12 & -0.80 & 10.10 + & 12050 & 7.1470 & 0.424 & -0.46 & 0.06 & -0.04 & -0.29 & -0.03 & 0.01 & -0.12 & -0.64 & 10.27 + & 11110 & 7.1691 & 0.558 & -0.45 & 0.10 & -0.01 & -0.20 & 0.00 & 0.02 & -0.11 & -0.45 & 10.48 + & 10270 & 7.1897 & 0.749 & -0.46 & 0.15 & 0.03 & -0.06 & 0.04 & 0.04 & -0.11 & -0.32 & 10.75 + & 9470 & 7.2094 & 1.024 & -0.48 & 0.19 & 0.08 & 0.12 & 0.08 & 0.07 & -0.09 & -0.23 & 11.06 + & 8870 & 7.2239 & 1.336 & -0.50 & 0.22 & 0.12 & 0.28 & 0.12 & 0.09 & -0.08 & -0.19 & 11.34 + a & 8290 & 7.2368 & 1.766 & -0.51 & 0.26 & 0.16 & 0.46 & 0.16 & 0.12 & -0.07 & -0.15 & 11.63 + b
& 7800 & 7.2634 & 2.776 & -0.51 & 0.30 & 0.19 & 0.61 & 0.20 & 0.15 & -0.06 & -0.13 & 11.94 + & 7150 & 7.2688 & 2.796 & -0.48 & 0.37 & 0.24 & 0.85 & 0.25 & 0.19 & -0.03 & -0.12 & 12.32 + & 6570 & 7.2731 & 3.751 & -0.42 & 0.44 & 0.29 & 1.09 & 0.30 & 0.23 & -0.01 & -0.11 & 12.69 + & 6060 & 7.2852 & 4.394 & -0.33 & 0.53 & 0.35 & 1.33 & 0.35 & 0.27 & 0.01 & -0.12 & 13.08 + & 5210 & 7.3257 & 5.748 & -0.11 & 0.72 & 0.47 & 1.82 & 0.47 & 0.32 & 0.07 & -0.21 & 13.93 + & 4840 & 7.3486 & 6.969 & 0.00 & 0.82 & 0.53 & 2.07 & 0.53 & 0.35 & 0.09 & -0.31 & 14.40 + & 4470 & 7.3622 & 8.269 & 0.12 & 0.92 & 0.59 & 2.23 & 0.59 & 0.33 & 0.04 & -0.42 & 14.89 + & 4110 & 7.3696 & 9.479 & 0.22 & 1.01 & 0.65 & 2.12 & 0.65 & 0.12 & -0.02 & -0.46 & 15.32 + & 3770 & 7.3743 & 10.729 & 0.29 & 1.07 & 0.69 & 1.67 & 0.68 & -0.14 & -0.14 & -0.41 & 15.65 + & 3460 & 7.3785 & 12.260 & 0.36 & 1.13 & 0.72 & 1.12 & 0.68 & -0.30 & -0.28 & -0.31 & 15.93 + & 3180 & 7.3835 & 15.016 & 0.44 & 1.19 & 0.72 & 0.59 & 0.60 & -0.37 & -0.36 & -0.16 & 16.16 + & 2920 & 7.3858 & 16.606 & 0.51 & 1.24 & 0.69 & 0.05 & 0.43 & -0.38 & -0.47 & 0.01 & 16.37 + 0.172 & 9390 & 4.6630 & 0.349 & -0.13 & 0.07 & 0.02 & 0.02 & 0.03 & 0.05 & -0.09 & -0.16 & 5.27 + & 12420 & 5.2994 & 0.973 & -0.40 & -0.07 & -0.05 & -0.33 & -0.05 & 0.00 & -0.11 & -0.74 & 6.22 + & 12760 & 5.4971 & 1.173 & -0.42 & -0.07 & -0.05 & -0.35 & -0.05 & 0.00 & -0.11 & -0.81 & 6.67 + & 12700 & 5.6392 & 1.356 & -0.42 & -0.06 & -0.05 & -0.35 & -0.05 & 0.00 & -0.11 & -0.79 & 7.03 + & 12410 & 5.7509 & 1.544 & -0.40 & -0.05 & -0.05 & -0.33 & -0.05 & 0.00 & -0.11 & -0.73 & 7.35 + & 12010 & 5.8440 & 1.746 & -0.37 & -0.03 & -0.04 & -0.30 & -0.04 & 0.01 & -0.11 & -0.65 & 7.64 + & 11540 & 5.9253 & 1.971 & -0.33 & 0.00 & -0.04 & -0.26 & -0.03 & 0.01 & -0.11 & -0.56 & 7.93 + & 11040 & 5.9987 & 2.223 & -0.30 & 0.04 & -0.03 & -0.20 & -0.02 & 0.02 & -0.11 & -0.46 & 8.21 + & 10520 & 6.0664 & 2.511 & -0.29 & 0.07 & -0.01 & -0.14 & 0.00 & 0.03 & -0.10 & -0.36 & 8.48 + & 10000 & 6.1303 & 2.849 & -0.30 & 0.12 & 0.02 & -0.06 & 0.03 & 0.04 & -0.10 & -0.26 & 8.77 + & 9500 & 6.1927 & 3.279 & -0.33 & 0.16 & 0.05 & 0.06 & 0.06 & 0.06 & -0.10 & -0.20 & 9.08 + & 9050 & 6.2590 & 3.974 & -0.36 & 0.19 & 0.09 & 0.18 & 0.09 & 0.07 & -0.09 & -0.16 & 9.42 + & 8660 & 6.3336 & 5.723 & -0.39 & 0.22 & 0.12 & 0.30 & 0.12 & 0.09 & -0.08 & -0.14 & 9.78 + & 8230 & 6.3987 & 8.461 & -0.42 & 0.26 & 0.15 & 0.44 & 0.15 & 0.12 & -0.07 & -0.12 & 10.14 + & 7330 & 6.5018 & 15.655 & -0.45 & 0.34 & 0.23 & 0.77 & 0.23 & 0.17 & -0.04 & -0.10 & 10.88 + & 6880 & 6.5439 & 20.326 & -0.42 & 0.40 & 0.26 & 0.95 & 0.27 & 0.20 & -0.02 & -0.09 & 11.26 + + 0.230 & 30010 & 6.4188 & 0.203 & -1.06 & -0.27 & -0.13 & -0.94 & -0.17 & -0.10 & -0.17 & -2.98 & 7.12 + & 28220 & 6.4678 & 0.203 & -1.02 & -0.25 & -0.13 & -0.90 & -0.16 & -0.10 & -0.17 & -2.84 & 7.37 + & 26430 & 6.5134 & 0.203 & -0.99 & -0.23 & -0.12 & -0.86 & -0.15 & -0.09 & -0.16 & -2.68 & 7.61 +
& 25000 & 6.5480 & 0.203 & -0.96 & -0.22 & -0.12 & -0.82 & -0.15 & -0.08 & -0.15 & -2.54 & 7.80 + & 23350 & 6.5868 & 0.203 & -0.92 & -0.20 & -0.11 & -0.78 & -0.14 & -0.07 & -0.15 & -2.36 & 8.02 + & 22030 & 6.6168 & 0.204 & -0.89 & -0.19 & -0.10 & -0.74 & -0.13 & -0.07 & -0.15 & -2.21 & 8.19 + & 20710 & 6.6461 & 0.205 & -0.85 & -0.17 & -0.10 & -0.70 & -0.12 & -0.06 & -0.14 & -2.05 & 8.37 + & 19200 & 6.6727 & 0.214 & -0.79 & -0.15 & -0.09 & -0.65 & -0.11 & -0.05 & -0.14 & -1.85 & 8.56 + & 17860 & 6.6782 & 0.251 & -0.74 & -0.13 & -0.09 & -0.61 & -0.10 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.66 & 8.70 + & 16620 & 6.6907 & 0.299 & -0.69 & -0.10 & -0.08 & -0.56 & -0.09 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.47 & 8.85 + & 15380 & 6.7116 & 0.345 & -0.62 & -0.08 & -0.07 & -0.50 & -0.08 & -0.03 & -0.13 & -1.26 & 9.04 + & 14310 & 6.7331 & 0.390 & -0.56 & -0.05 & -0.07 & -0.45 & -0.07 & -0.02 & -0.12 & -1.07 & 9.21 + & 13320 & 6.7549 & 0.442 & -0.50 & -0.02 & -0.06 & -0.39 & -0.06 & -0.01 & -0.12 & -0.89 & 9.40 + & 12400 & 6.7768 & 0.501 & -0.44 & 0.02 & -0.05 & -0.33 & -0.04 & 0.01 & -0.12 & -0.71 & 9.59 + & 11530 & 6.7990 & 0.570 & -0.40 & 0.06 & -0.03 & -0.25 & -0.02 & 0.02 & -0.11 & -0.55 & 9.79 + & 10730 & 6.8210 & 0.648 & -0.40 & 0.11 & 0.00 & -0.15 & 0.01 & 0.03 & -0.11 & -0.38 & 9.99 + & 9910 & 6.8455 & 0.751 & -0.41 & 0.15 & 0.04 & 0.00 & 0.05 & 0.05 & -0.10 & -0.26 & 10.28 + & 9220 & 6.8699 & 0.868 & -0.44 & 0.20 & 0.09 & 0.17 & 0.09 & 0.07 & -0.09 & -0.20 & 10.59 + & 8600 & 6.8939 & 1.015 & -0.47 & 0.24 & 0.13 & 0.35 & 0.14 & 0.10 & -0.08 & -0.16 & 10.91 + & 8070 & 6.9151 & 1.193 & -0.48 & 0.28 & 0.17 & 0.51 & 0.17 & 0.13 & -0.06 & -0.13 & 11.21 + & 7000 & 6.9588 & 1.824 & -0.46 & 0.38 & 0.25 & 0.90 & 0.26 & 0.20 & -0.03 & -0.10 & 11.91 + & 6460 & 6.9796 & 2.341 & -0.40 & 0.45 & 0.30 & 1.13 & 0.30 & 0.24 & -0.01 & -0.10 & 12.31 + & 5970 & 6.9984 & 2.930 & -0.31 & 0.54 & 0.36 & 1.37 & 0.36 & 0.27 & 0.02 & -0.12 & 12.71 + & 5150 & 7.0477 & 4.075 & -0.09 & 0.74 & 0.47 & 1.86 & 0.47 & 0.32 & 0.08 & -0.23 & 13.59 + & 4810 & 7.0820 & 4.780 & 0.02 & 0.83 & 0.54 & 2.11 & 0.53 & 0.35 & 0.10 & -0.32 & 14.07 + & 4460 & 7.1098 & 5.792 & 0.14 & 0.93 & 0.60 & 2.29 & 0.60 & 0.35 & 0.06 & -0.43 & 14.58 + & 4110 & 7.1265 & 6.876 & 0.24 & 1.02 & 0.66 & 2.23 & 0.66 & 0.18 & 0.00 & -0.49 & 15.04 + & 3780 & 7.1369 & 7.948 & 0.32 & 1.09 & 0.70 & 1.85 & 0.69 & -0.08 & -0.11 & -0.46 & 15.39 + & 3450 & 7.1443 & 9.157 & 0.39 & 1.15 & 0.73 & 1.25 & 0.69 & -0.27 & -0.26 & -0.35 & 15.69 + & 3210 & 7.1486 & 10.232 & 0.46 & 1.20 & 0.74 & 0.74 & 0.64 & -0.36 & -0.35 & -0.22 & 15.89 + & 2980 & 7.1522 & 11.469 & 0.52 & 1.25 & 0.72 & 0.27 & 0.51 & -0.38 & -0.43 & -0.07 & 16.07 + & 2760 & 7.1552 & 12.897 & 0.59 & 1.29 & 0.69 & -0.16 & 0.33 & -0.36 & -0.54 & 0.08 & 16.26 + & 2530 & 7.1593 & 15.744 & 0.68 & 1.35 & 0.62 & -0.70 & 0.04 & -0.29 & -0.69 & 0.26 & 16.46 + & 2310 & 7.1624 & 18.216 & 0.78 & 1.40 & 0.55 & -1.27 & -0.34 & -0.20 & -0.87 & 0.45 & 16.69 + + 0.336 & 21420 & 7.1810 & 0.045 & -0.88 & -0.16 & -0.10 & -0.73 & -0.12 & -0.06 & -0.14 & -2.13 & 9.22 + & 19620 & 7.1907 & 0.049 & -0.82 & -0.13 & -0.10 & -0.67 & -0.11 & -0.05 & -0.14 & -1.90 & 9.40 + & 18260 & 7.1978 & 0.065 & -0.78 & -0.11 & -0.09 & -0.62 & -0.10 & -0.05 & -0.14 & -1.71 & 9.54 + & 17010 & 7.2109 & 0.090 & -0.72 & -0.09 & -0.08 & -0.58 & -0.09 & -0.04 & -0.13 & -1.52 & 9.69 + & 15840 & 7.2270 & 0.121 & -0.67 & -0.06 & -0.08 & -0.53 & -0.08 & -0.03 & -0.13 & -1.33 & 9.85 + & 14640 & 7.2464 & 0.161 & -0.61 & -0.03 & -0.07 & -0.47 & -0.07 & -0.02 & -0.12 & -1.12 & 10.03 + & 13540 & 7.2658 & 0.210 & -0.55 & 0.01 & -0.06 & -0.41 & -0.06 & -0.01 & -0.12 & -0.92 & 10.22 + & 12620 & 7.2830 & 0.268 & -0.50 & 0.05 & -0.05 & -0.34 & -0.04 & 0.01 & -0.12 & -0.75 & 10.40 + & 11810 & 7.2986 & 0.337 & -0.48 & 0.08 & -0.03 & -0.27 & -0.02 & 0.01 & -0.12 & -0.59 & 10.56 + & 10880 & 7.3163 & 0.445 & -0.48 & 0.12 & 0.00 & -0.16 & 0.01 & 0.03 & -0.11 & -0.41 & 10.78 + & 10020 & 7.3328 & 0.582 & -0.48 & 0.16 & 0.05 & 0.00 & 0.06 & 0.05 & -0.10 & -0.29 & 11.06 + & 9370 & 7.3454 & 0.719 & -0.50 & 0.20 & 0.09 & 0.16 & 0.09 & 0.07 & -0.09 & -0.23 & 11.33 + & 8720 & 7.3573 & 0.889 & -0.52 & 0.23 & 0.13 & 0.33 & 0.13 & 0.10 & -0.08 & -0.18 & 11.62 + & 8120 & 7.3681 & 1.092 & -0.52 & 0.27 & 0.17 & 0.51 & 0.17 & 0.13 & -0.06 & -0.15 & 11.93 + & 7460 & 7.3795 & 1.370 & -0.51 & 0.33 & 0.22 & 0.73 & 0.22 & 0.17 & -0.04 & -0.12 & 12.29 + & 6950 & 7.3883 & 1.640 & -0.47 & 0.39 & 0.26 & 0.93 & 0.26 & 0.20 & -0.03 & -0.11 & 12.61 + & 6390 & 7.3987 & 2.023 & -0.40 & 0.47 & 0.31 & 1.17 & 0.31 & 0.24 & 0.00 & -0.11 & 13.00 + & 5870 & 7.4099 & 2.492 & -0.29 & 0.56 & 0.37 & 1.43 & 0.37 & 0.28 & 0.03 & -0.13 & 13.41 + & 5000 & 7.4416 & 3.926 & -0.05 & 0.77 & 0.50 & 1.96 & 0.50 & 0.34 & 0.08 & -0.26 & 14.32 + & 4610 & 7.4569 & 5.361 & 0.07 & 0.88 & 0.57 & 2.18 & 0.57 & 0.35 & 0.06 & -0.38 & 14.83 + & 4240 & 7.4669 & 6.985 & 0.18 & 0.97 & 0.63 & 2.16 & 0.63 & 0.20 & -0.01 & -0.44 & 15.29 + & 3890 & 7.4727 & 8.597 & 0.26 & 1.05 & 0.68 & 1.80 & 0.67 & -0.08 & -0.10 & -0.42 & 15.65 + & 3610 & 7.4760 & 9.997 & 0.32 & 1.10 & 0.70 & 1.28 & 0.68 & -0.26 & -0.25 & -0.34 & 15.90 + & 3300 & 7.4790 & 11.832 & 0.40 & 1.16 & 0.72 & 0.76 & 0.64 & -0.36 & -0.34 & -0.21 & 16.17 + & 3020 & 7.4813 & 14.033 & 0.47 & 1.21 & 0.70 & 0.22 & 0.51 & -0.39 & -0.43 & -0.05 & 16.39 + + 0.449 & 36370 & 7.2604 & 0.002 & -1.16 & -0.28 & -0.14 & -1.00 & -0.18 & -0.12 & -0.17 & -3.45 & 8.13 + & 34060 & 7.2999 & 0.004 & -1.13 & -0.27 & -0.14 & -0.99 & -0.18 & -0.11 & -0.17 & -3.27 & 8.34 + & 32270 & 7.3577 & 0.011 & -1.11 & -0.26 & -0.14 & -0.97 & -0.17 & -0.11 & -0.17 & -3.13 & 8.58 + & 30310 & 7.4037 & 0.023 & -1.09 & -0.25 & -0.13 & -0.94 & -0.17 & -0.10 & -0.17 & -2.98 & 8.82 + & 28220 & 7.4342 & 0.035 & -1.05 & -0.23 & -0.13 & -0.90 & -0.16 & -0.10 & -0.17 & -2.82 & 9.04 + & 26220 & 7.4605 & 0.049 & -1.01 & -0.21 & -0.12 & -0.86 & -0.15 & -0.09 & -0.16 & -2.64 & 9.24 + & 24310 & 7.4844 & 0.068 & -0.97 & -0.19 & -0.12 & -0.81 & -0.14 & -0.08 & -0.15 & -2.45 & 9.44 + & 22530 & 7.5065 & 0.093 & -0.93 & -0.16 & -0.11 & -0.76 & -0.13 & -0.07 & -0.15 & -2.25 & 9.63 + & 20860 & 7.5270 & 0.128 & -0.88 & -0.14 & -0.10 & -0.71 & -0.12 & -0.06 & -0.14 & -2.05 & 9.81 + & 19290 & 7.5462 & 0.174 & -0.83 & -0.11 & -0.10 & -0.66 & -0.11 & -0.05 & -0.14 & -1.84 & 9.99 + & 17830 & 7.5638 & 0.237 & -0.78 & -0.09 & -0.09 & -0.61 & -0.10 & -0.04 & -0.14 & -1.63 & 10.17 + & 16470 & 7.5796 & 0.320 & -0.72 & -0.06 & -0.08 & -0.56 & -0.09 & -0.03 & -0.13 & -1.42 & 10.34 + & 15200 & 7.5938 & 0.429 & -0.66 & -0.02 & -0.07 & -0.50 & -0.07 & -0.02 & -0.13 & -1.21 & 10.51 + & 14030 & 7.6063 & 0.570 & -0.60 & 0.01 & -0.07 & -0.44 & -0.06 & -0.01 & -0.12 & -1.00 & 10.69 + & 12920 & 7.6173 & 0.749 & -0.55 & 0.06 & -0.05 & -0.36 & -0.04 & 0.00 & -0.12 & -0.80 & 10.87 + & 11890 & 7.6273 & 0.982 & -0.54 & 0.09 & -0.03 & -0.28 & -0.02 & 0.01 & -0.12 & -0.59 & 11.04 + & 10910 & 7.6365 & 1.289 & -0.53 & 0.13 & 0.01 & -0.15 & 0.02 & 0.03 & -0.11 & -0.41 & 11.26 + & 10030 & 7.6452 & 1.672 & -0.53 & 0.17 & 0.05 & 0.02 & 0.06 & 0.05 & -0.10 & -0.30 & 11.54 + & 9220 & 7.6532 & 2.148 & -0.54 & 0.21 & 0.10 & 0.21 & 0.11 & 0.08 & -0.09 & -0.23 & 11.85 + & 8460 & 7.6606 & 2.728 & -0.55 & 0.25 & 0.15 & 0.41 & 0.15 & 0.11 & -0.07 & -0.18 & 12.19 + & 7770 & 7.6674 & 3.349 & -0.54 & 0.30 & 0.20 & 0.63 & 0.20 & 0.15 & -0.05 & -0.14 & 12.54 + & 7130 & 7.6741 & 3.969 & -0.49 & 0.36 & 0.24 & 0.86 & 0.25 & 0.19 & -0.03 & -0.12 & 12.91 + & 6540 & 7.6806 & 4.611 & -0.42 & 0.44 & 0.30 & 1.10 & 0.30 & 0.23 & -0.01 & -0.10 & 13.28 + & 6020 & 7.6874 & 5.330 & -0.32 & 0.54 & 0.35 & 1.34 & 0.35 & 0.26 & 0.02 & -0.12 & 13.67 + & 5540 & 7.6959 & 6.189 & -0.21 & 0.63 & 0.41 & 1.59 & 0.41 & 0.29 & 0.05 & -0.14 & 14.07 + & 5110 & 7.7067 & 7.472 & -0.09 & 0.74 & 0.48 & 1.88 & 0.48 & 0.33 & 0.07 & -0.24 & 14.55 + & 4710 & 7.7160 & 9.455 & 0.04 & 0.85 & 0.55 & 2.10 & 0.55 & 0.34 & 0.05 & -0.34 & 15.04 + & 4330 & 7.7221 & 11.582 & 0.14 & 0.94 & 0.61 & 2.10 & 0.61 & 0.20 & -0.01 & -0.41 & 15.49 + & 3970 & 7.7258 & 13.651 & 0.22 & 1.02 & 0.66 & 1.79 & 0.65 & -0.06 & -0.09 & -0.40 & 15.85 + & 3640 & 7.7282 & 15.838 & 0.30 & 1.08 & 0.69 & 1.19 & 0.66 & -0.28 & -0.26 & -0.31 & 16.16 + | the present work is designed to explore the evolution of helium - core white dwarf ( he wd ) stars for the case of metallicities much lower than the solar metallicity ( @xmath0= 0.001 and @xmath0= 0.0002 ) .
evolution is followed in a self - consistent way with the predictions of detailed and new non - grey model atmospheres , time - dependent element diffusion and the history of the white dwarf progenitor .
reliable initial models for low mass he wds are obtained by applying mass loss rates to a 1 m@xmath1 stellar model in such a way that the stellar radius remains close to the roche lobe radius . the loss of angular momentun caused by gravitational wave emission and magnetic stellar wind braking are considered .
model atmospheres , based on a detailed treatment of the microphysics entering the wd atmosphere ( such as the formalism of hummer - mihalas to deal with non - ideal effects ) as well as hydrogen line and pseudo - continuum opacities , enable us to provide accurate colours and magnitudes at both early and advanced evolutionary stages .
we find that most of our evolutionary sequences experience several episodes of hydrogen thermonuclear flashes .
in particular , the lower the metallicity , the larger the minimum stellar mass for the occurrence of flashes induced by cno cycle reactions .
the existence of a mass threshold for the occurrence of diffusion - induced cno flashes leads to a marked dichotomy in the age of our models .
another finding of this study is that our he wd models experience unstable hydrogen burning via pp nuclear reactions at late cooling stages as a result of hydrogen chemically diffusing inwards .
such pp flashes take place in models with very low metal content .
we also find that models experiencing cno flashes exhibit a pronounced turn - off in most of their colours at m@xmath2 16.finally , colour - magnitude diagrams for our models are presented and compared with recent observational data of he wd candidates in the globular clusters ngc 6397 and 47 tucanae .
[ firstpage ] stars : evolution - stars : interiors - stars : white dwarfs - stars : atmospheres - stars : fundamental parameters |
Subsets and Splits
Data Mining Abstracts
This query searches for and retrieves 2000 documents containing the phrase 'data mining' in the abstract, providing limited but specific document samples.