id
stringlengths
32
39
title
stringlengths
7
232
authors
stringlengths
5
6.98k
categories
stringlengths
12
178
summary
stringlengths
3
3.12k
link_pdf
stringlengths
32
39
updated
timestamp[s]
published
timestamp[s]
embeddings
dict
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04258v1
IoT-Based Environmental Control System for Fish Farms with Sensor Integration and Machine Learning Decision Support
D. Dhinakaran, S. Gopalakrishnan, M. D. Manigandan, T. P. Anish
eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.LG
In response to the burgeoning global demand for seafood and the challenges of managing fish farms, we introduce an innovative IoT based environmental control system that integrates sensor technology and advanced machine learning decision support. Deploying a network of wireless sensors within the fish farm, we continuously collect real-time data on crucial environmental parameters, including water temperature, pH levels, humidity, and fish behavior. This data undergoes meticulous preprocessing to ensure its reliability, including imputation, outlier detection, feature engineering, and synchronization. At the heart of our system are four distinct machine learning algorithms: Random Forests predict and optimize water temperature and pH levels for the fish, fostering their health and growth; Support Vector Machines (SVMs) function as an early warning system, promptly detecting diseases and parasites in fish; Gradient Boosting Machines (GBMs) dynamically fine-tune the feeding schedule based on real-time environmental conditions, promoting resource efficiency and fish productivity; Neural Networks manage the operation of critical equipment like water pumps and heaters to maintain the desired environmental conditions within the farm. These machine learning algorithms collaboratively make real-time decisions to ensure that the fish farm's environmental conditions align with predefined specifications, leading to improved fish health and productivity while simultaneously reducing resource wastage, thereby contributing to increased profitability and sustainability. This research article showcases the power of data-driven decision support in fish farming, promising to meet the growing demand for seafood while emphasizing environmental responsibility and economic viability, thus revolutionizing the future of fish farming.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04258v1
2023-11-07T14:35:16
2023-11-07T14:35:16
{ "title": [ 0.014526367, 0.0027542114, -0.02810669, -0.028198242, 0.013587952, -0.035064697, 0.016967773, -0.019424438, -0.0030879974, 0.040649414, -0.064453125, 0.0040359497, 0.030044556, -0.005832672, -0.047821045, -0.022262573, -0.009536743, 0.032684326, 0.0077667236, -0.030090332, 0.0012950897, -0.037506104, 0.03982544, -0.014984131, 0.004020691, -0.018661499, -0.113342285, 0.0049972534, -0.046783447, -0.043792725, -0.030944824, 0.062408447, 0.061065674, 0.015686035, -0.054992676, 0.03491211, -0.048034668, 0.028717041, -0.027404785, 0.047088623, 0.021118164, -0.0025405884, -0.013549805, -0.0049057007, -0.024291992, 0.0045166016, -0.046295166, -0.021224976, -0.016159058, 0.006668091, 0.024993896, 0.003112793, 0.022354126, 0.015670776, -0.00027775764, -0.021820068, 0.01373291, -0.058776855, 0.052886963, 0.0029792786, -0.024719238, -0.07873535, 0.045013428, -0.024642944, -0.0074539185, -0.026351929, 0.036010742, 0.03213501, 0.04849243, -0.031173706, -0.008453369, 0.06225586, 0.005897522, 0.037384033, -0.04034424, -0.061676025, 0.06347656, -0.0021400452, 0.008415222, 0.016799927, 0.0016527176, -0.0015487671, 0.012199402, -0.011238098, 0.010475159, -0.01939392, -0.015838623, -0.015899658, -0.023406982, -0.028182983, -0.009712219, 0.0030899048, -0.014541626, 0.024429321, -0.014968872, -0.03353882, -0.0048980713, 0.023208618, 0.009788513, -0.00080251694, -0.028717041, 0.0071411133, -0.044311523, -0.026107788, 0.0071525574, 0.052856445, 0.031433105, 0.0020561218, 0.0031166077, 0.0006432533, -0.011978149, -0.0038051605, 0.010940552, -0.009712219, 0.008903503, 0.017501831, 0.0010051727, 0.0104522705, 0.021514893, 0.02217102, -0.002527237, 0.005607605, -0.0056877136, 0.00894165, 0.0036449432, 0.0012788773, -0.030014038, 0.006126404, -0.03930664, -0.010398865, 0.0018539429, 0.064086914, -0.04159546, -0.052368164, -0.04562378, 0.03994751, 0.03564453, 0.002571106, -0.00017893314, -0.010360718, 0.018081665, -0.004360199, -0.000037133694, 0.016326904, 0.013572693, -0.0084991455, 0.064208984, 0.0066337585, -0.039123535, -0.010421753, -0.03427124, 0.03845215, 0.024871826, 0.0072364807, -0.034576416, -0.020019531, -0.094055176, -0.0054359436, 0.035247803, -0.0076179504, 0.04168701, 0.007987976, -0.016174316, 0.022720337, 0.054534912, -0.022155762, -0.02798462, 0.032226562, -0.0036144257, 0.022735596, -0.032226562, -0.0020580292, 0.025314331, -0.017959595, -0.008033752, 0.015487671, 0.011482239, 0.042633057, 0.026687622, -0.06173706, -0.04043579, -0.03189087, 0.045410156, 0.0063934326, -0.029159546, -0.043670654, 0.0046653748, 0.00970459, 0.059539795, 0.015914917, -0.07043457, -0.006702423, -0.042266846, -0.03540039, -0.02104187, 0.0034255981, 0.022628784, 0.037963867, -0.008880615, -0.014060974, -0.052612305, 0.014091492, -0.03353882, 0.04360962, -0.0020503998, -0.020828247, -0.0009560585, 0.008522034, -0.021102905, 0.024505615, 0.037322998, -0.015457153, 0.00014412403, -0.03314209, -0.032806396, -0.039215088, 0.023880005, 0.012390137, -0.008514404, -0.01285553, -0.017150879, -0.010108948, 0.00014054775, 0.038970947, -0.008529663, 0.03768921, -0.0012512207, 0.009048462, 0.055358887, 0.05630493, 0.109436035, -0.07550049, 0.04776001, -0.012176514, -0.027435303, 0.013511658, -0.010520935, -0.015991211, -0.0090408325, 0.024551392, 0.00995636, -0.044067383, -0.0015001297, 0.024108887, 0.0037384033, -0.0413208, 0.00039815903, 0.02909851, 0.040130615, 0.060272217, 0.04486084, 0.010398865, 0.02218628, 0.009529114, 0.0014295578, 0.042175293, -0.008277893, 0.026916504, -0.01802063, -0.014297485, 0.012237549, -0.011634827, -0.010543823, -0.0079422, -0.049621582, 0.005569458, -0.02041626, 0.0069618225, -0.00061130524, 0.021560669, 0.029891968, -0.02204895, 0.0008921623, -0.0008687973, -0.0062675476, -0.011955261, -0.016708374, 0.019363403, 0.00724411, -0.03857422, -0.017120361, 0.022964478, 0.020385742, -0.008872986, -0.0037498474, -0.023040771, 0.017044067, -0.0021095276, 0.010345459, 0.0025157928, 0.05532837, 0.012580872, -0.001996994, 0.0007944107, 0.014602661, -0.010101318, 0.07904053, 0.08685303, -0.04547119, 0.02947998, -0.10192871, -0.018920898, 0.005870819, -0.043640137, 0.01725769, 0.008460999, 0.03353882, -0.0025730133, -0.02180481, 0.037902832, -0.078063965, 0.026809692, -0.008644104, -0.05722046, -0.020507812, -0.03237915, -0.019851685, -0.048950195, -0.02079773, 0.054260254, 0.0073661804, 0.021438599, -0.022369385, -0.006011963, 0.02558899, -0.011741638, -0.052490234, -0.020126343, -0.027648926, -0.0037574768, 0.02279663, -0.000056266785, -0.052124023, 0.034057617, 0.009437561, 0.025650024, -0.01625061, 0.053131104, -0.01966858, -0.017211914, -0.010246277, -0.06903076, -0.007171631, -0.008415222, -0.0029888153, -0.038116455, 0.0026664734, 0.017807007, -0.03677368, 0.0036239624, 0.022750854, -0.028289795, -0.05441284, -0.0036716461, 0.016906738, -0.038269043, 0.023895264, -0.005596161, -0.028518677, -0.035949707, 0.030700684, 0.03152466, 0.0019407272, -0.068481445, 0.006641388, -0.0670166, -0.025894165, -0.01625061, -0.021636963, 0.03338623, -0.06933594, -0.018005371, -0.02381897, -0.00705719, -0.00970459, 0.0435791, -0.029663086, -0.03765869, -0.012214661, -0.04788208, 0.0042648315, -0.027328491, 0.010910034, -0.031585693, 0.06854248, 0.0052833557, -0.0074691772, 0.011810303, 0.03074646, 0.0012216568, -0.0032978058, -0.0032749176, -0.023956299, -0.020339966, 0.039123535, 0.028930664, -0.019302368, 0.0011663437, -0.06616211, -0.019180298, 0.029785156, -0.012954712, -0.027511597, 0.023239136, -0.060791016, -0.002029419, 0.000090658665, -0.016342163, 0.028320312, 0.020874023, 0.0022296906, 0.0096206665, 0.01222229, -0.017456055, 0.010810852, -0.02960205, -0.046569824, 0.0435791, -0.03062439, -0.05697632, 0.0028514862, 0.011131287, -0.039794922, -0.03652954, -0.03086853, 0.047058105, 0.022460938, 0.027954102, -0.003332138, -0.029525757, -0.0001732111, -0.039886475, 0.017837524, -0.010169983, -0.052490234, 0.00223732, -0.008705139, 0.05078125, 0.023071289, -0.007896423, -0.044128418, 0.012290955, -0.0046844482, 0.032440186, 0.011413574, -0.032440186, -0.0053977966, -0.04510498, 0.008583069, -0.020065308, 0.006916046, -0.007873535, 0.021118164, -0.00061273575, -0.009819031, 0.03643799, 0.012062073, 0.021194458, -0.026046753, -0.017684937, 0.040130615, -0.01272583, -0.07019043, 0.031188965, 0.0095825195, -0.01902771, 0.041992188, -0.0011730194, -0.017349243, 0.005218506, -0.026062012, 0.03289795, 0.028411865, -0.0048561096, 0.0032958984, 0.028244019, -0.007797241, -0.011505127, -0.016860962, -0.0022144318, -0.004169464, 0.017852783, -0.06317139, -0.032348633, 0.010940552, 0.0007376671, -0.08306885, -0.053009033, 0.0234375, -0.06451416, -0.03253174, -0.0690918, 0.019256592, -0.026779175, -0.012863159, -0.012916565, 0.007888794, -0.056396484, -0.030822754, -0.062042236, -0.066711426, 0.06829834, 0.0028476715, 0.014808655, -0.0056381226, 0.0009050369, -0.000207901, -0.010925293, 0.023330688, -0.00724411, -0.0018281937, -0.0029239655, -0.0063667297, 0.042938232, -0.023406982, 0.034332275, 0.00548172, 0.053741455, -0.022842407, -0.0034255981, 0.023712158, 0.008346558, -0.0068092346, 0.04650879, 0.03173828, -0.01184082, -0.047332764, 0.0006046295, 0.012176514, -0.034820557, -0.0012187958, 0.007297516, 0.00042200089, 0.040130615, 0.008781433, 0.05331421, -0.008712769, 0.038208008, -0.009521484, -0.07727051, -0.02053833, 0.0018587112, 0.034057617, -0.033813477, 0.0016975403, -0.0009908676, -0.023010254, 0.057006836, -0.07122803, 0.014762878, -0.007965088, 0.004749298, -0.046813965, -0.01247406, -0.044189453, -0.0569458, -0.036621094, 0.03012085, -0.016937256, -0.014015198, 0.02998352, -0.01033783, -0.061523438, 0.036224365, 0.033050537, -0.011070251, -0.003850937, -0.069885254, 0.013084412, -0.017684937, -0.07952881, -0.04421997, 0.0011777878, 0.027572632, 0.026657104, -0.006855011, -0.022705078, 0.03817749, 0.028778076, 0.09631348, 0.04977417, -0.0013523102, -0.081848145, 0.072631836, -0.0049438477, 0.0051879883, -0.003780365, 0.024871826, 0.004096985, -0.0062294006, -0.009315491, -0.017684937, -0.009117126, 0.0015964508, 0.020950317, -0.026931763, 0.021133423, -0.017486572, 0.079833984, 0.01411438, 0.03048706, 0.019821167, -0.000010073185, -0.03375244, -0.02180481, -0.021713257, 0.061950684, -0.03567505, 0.026916504, 0.03753662, 0.00667572, -0.009109497, -0.0022792816, 0.03390503, 0.019561768, -0.037750244, -0.006980896, 0.012519836, -0.012680054, -0.016693115, 0.010536194, 0.022949219, 0.042053223, -0.05404663, 0.03366089, -0.025375366, 0.001876831, 0.03967285, 0.0016736984, 0.011512756, 0.002161026, 0.020141602, -0.061767578, -0.024993896, -0.0058937073, 0.028259277, -0.046936035, -0.027801514, -0.022384644, 0.00995636, 0.030075073, 0.02142334, 0.02178955, 0.0014638901, -0.020828247, 0.005191803, 0.017349243, -0.025787354, -0.024002075, -0.012329102, -0.008216858, 0.0048294067, -0.054992676, 0.003982544, -0.030563354, -0.0015935898, 0.015319824, 0.031280518, -0.01499939, -0.056274414, 0.023162842, 0.038635254, 0.02571106, -0.030639648, -0.01184082, -0.016067505, 0.02166748, 0.04006958, -0.015525818, 0.044525146, 0.015686035, -0.048583984, 0.013717651, 0.02859497, 0.02229309, 0.016708374, 0.016586304, 0.0053138733, -0.01928711, -0.012611389, 0.038269043, 0.043914795, -0.020980835, 0.029083252, -0.042266846, 0.036712646, -0.019577026, -0.030532837, -0.00015509129, -0.017196655, -0.02217102, 0.015808105, -0.01776123, -0.006225586, -0.008361816, -0.0036354065, 0.0075187683, -0.04675293, -0.008293152, -0.028945923, 0.015365601, 0.00573349, 0.02911377, 0.0017404556, 0.0128479, 0.022659302, -0.05392456, -0.0013847351, 0.013023376, 0.028167725, 0.03543091, -0.007896423, -0.037841797, -0.0019407272, -0.0023822784, -0.03555298, -0.019760132, 0.020965576, 0.009788513, -0.0029773712, -0.014289856, -0.035491943, -0.003238678, 0.0071983337, 0.011260986, 0.03564453, -0.03253174, 0.012046814, -0.028533936, -0.027557373, 0.018859863, 0.049072266, 0.026733398, -0.0075187683, -0.0152282715, -0.04763794, 0.021347046, -0.030792236, -0.029876709, 0.014854431, -0.042541504, 0.021331787, 0.0032596588, 0.00548172, -0.03237915, -0.00182724, 0.02168274, -0.024536133, -0.04348755, -0.025344849, 0.03829956, -0.04498291, -0.05697632, -0.006526947, 0.0060272217, -0.00090551376, 0.06958008, -0.042236328, -0.058654785, -0.024398804, -0.072021484, -0.042236328, 0.007549286, 0.05795288, 0.02809143, 0.07739258, -0.0413208, 0.006095886, -0.049560547, 0.012573242, -0.0068511963, -0.0025138855, 0.0057411194, 0.029876709, -0.022766113, 0.021331787, -0.019836426, -0.0035629272, 0.041381836, 0.041015625, 0.000013411045, 0.0362854, -0.042236328, -0.014785767, -0.03781128, -0.006340027, 0.040985107, 0.021850586, 0.003921509, 0.06762695, -0.037750244, 0.027572632, 0.022613525, 0.031311035, 0.05630493, 0.03753662, -0.00198555, 0.0031986237, 0.002571106, -0.023132324, -0.03564453, -0.062347412, -0.012535095, -0.030380249, 0.0056533813, -0.039093018, -0.0049705505, 0.0039100647, -0.025131226, 0.04067993, -0.010932922, 0.018859863, 0.021606445, 0.016159058, 0.019897461, 0.012664795, -0.01966858, 0.008613586, -0.00083494186, -0.004096985, 0.021316528, 0.028640747, -0.021240234, 0.034118652, -0.022277832, 0.014595032, 0.009635925, -0.022888184, 0.00894928, -0.012962341, -0.003704071, -0.013511658, 0.03668213, -0.006385803, 0.026916504, 0.058441162, 0.064086914, -0.044311523, -0.01574707, 0.016357422, 0.0131073, -0.006061554, -0.008888245, 0.033050537, -0.04067993, 0.019119263, -0.01689148, -0.03286743, -0.010803223, 0.042297363, 0.015731812, -0.04345703, -0.0016613007, 0.010131836, 0.021911621, -0.0054512024, 0.036102295, -0.033966064, -0.035247803, 0.015686035, 0.030715942, -0.028198242, 0.01449585, 0.020843506, 0.068725586, -0.027389526, 0.041381836, 0.0050354004, 0.007522583, -0.014564514, 0.016098022, -0.08111572, 0.026641846, 0.026168823, -0.033599854, 0.032409668, 0.0016803741, -0.026824951, 0.019592285, 0.026428223, 0.018722534, 0.06958008, 0.056549072, 0.011528015, -0.017807007, 0.030975342, -0.06427002, 0.0027713776, 0.04901123, -0.029388428, 0.0066375732, -0.035369873, -0.03805542, 0.011253357, -0.023117065, 0.0496521, -0.021591187, 0.016937256, -0.022338867, -0.00054740906, 0.04522705, -0.055541992, -0.04147339, -0.0076408386, -0.025756836, -0.035949707, -0.041534424, -0.018630981, -0.045196533, -0.043029785, 0.055267334, -0.029190063, -0.0061836243, -0.0045280457, -0.04812622, -0.016677856, -0.008033752, 0.0055732727, -0.00026917458, 0.058044434, -0.0052490234, 0.0045394897, -0.02418518, -0.014289856, -0.03164673, 0.0029678345, -0.07904053, -0.024658203, -0.026657104, 0.019882202, 0.008277893, -0.024734497, -0.009422302, 0.012908936, -0.005290985, -0.014839172, -0.022918701, 0.016159058, -0.031311035, -0.045806885, -0.020248413, -0.02015686, 0.023025513, 0.029388428, -0.007896423, 0.0231781, 0.040130615, -0.012710571, -0.0345459, -0.021347046, 0.0002720356, -0.003293991, -0.0178833, -0.026977539, 0.04989624, 0.0067214966, -0.06915283, 0.002155304, 0.0013847351, 0.06915283, -0.034729004, 0.066345215, -0.005859375, 0.008071899, 0.034179688, 0.07513428, 0.0060424805, -0.06304932, -0.07904053, -0.044799805, 0.07147217, 0.013244629, -0.021530151, -0.056884766, 0.019546509, 0.023544312, 0.010612488, 0.035858154, -0.02760315, 0.018630981, 0.011985779, 0.0440979, 0.009765625, -0.032287598, -0.014030457, 0.02909851, 0.004081726, 0.018997192, -0.01928711, 0.02418518, 0.0018367767, 0.04397583, -0.009963989, -0.06359863, 0.07757568, 0.016815186, 0.038269043, 0.059326172, 0.04257202, -0.040039062, -0.026062012, 0.0124053955, 0.00932312, 0.031097412, 0.011177063, -0.00093364716, 0.030075073, -0.043670654, -0.032196045, -0.029449463, -0.04058838, 0.03491211, -0.029144287, -0.003314972, -0.0154800415, -0.030334473, -0.0035057068, 0.017990112, 0.018081665, -0.024414062, -0.025878906, -0.043182373, 0.02772522, -0.017974854 ], "summary": [ 0.060546875, -0.0055770874, 0.028244019, -0.011703491, -0.011764526, -0.034301758, 0.0345459, -0.039245605, 0.040130615, 0.034606934, -0.113342285, 0.011955261, 0.021133423, 0.01335907, -0.026855469, -0.04095459, 0.00061655045, 0.048309326, 0.040985107, -0.014564514, -0.000026166439, -0.013511658, 0.011016846, -0.03237915, -0.007785797, -0.0043563843, -0.08392334, 0.008728027, -0.031921387, -0.0041389465, -0.021148682, 0.031173706, 0.03781128, 0.011940002, -0.049804688, 0.0178833, 0.013214111, -0.004119873, -0.03387451, 0.073913574, 0.023544312, -0.005596161, 0.03692627, -0.036132812, 0.0079422, 0.017837524, 0.0019607544, -0.022903442, 0.0030574799, -0.0073661804, 0.03781128, -0.0044517517, 0.035125732, -0.010131836, -0.01574707, 0.011184692, 0.02217102, -0.046020508, 0.043121338, -0.0064964294, -0.02468872, -0.039855957, 0.031402588, -0.033599854, -0.006259918, -0.025985718, 0.10662842, 0.014541626, 0.03111267, -0.045318604, -0.004032135, 0.064453125, 0.01965332, 0.023239136, -0.015335083, -0.062164307, 0.02659607, -0.022384644, -0.0010404587, 0.027664185, 0.01272583, 0.025115967, 0.031707764, -0.028381348, -0.00028181076, -0.027145386, -0.020019531, -0.01033783, 0.0059776306, -0.010223389, -0.018463135, 0.0023345947, -0.012924194, 0.028793335, 0.0024547577, -0.037506104, 0.024368286, 0.0002310276, 0.018936157, 0.032592773, -0.017623901, -0.030258179, 0.036315918, -0.0395813, -0.018157959, 0.060333252, 0.036499023, 0.004333496, -0.018173218, -0.003112793, -0.0049858093, -0.03604126, -0.017028809, -0.04019165, 0.00012397766, 0.05166626, 0.008514404, 0.0040626526, 0.012481689, 0.009780884, -0.018600464, 0.020874023, -0.020126343, 0.020843506, -0.012428284, 0.005153656, 0.01197052, -0.0015687943, -0.042999268, 0.00774765, -0.0056762695, 0.020202637, 0.047943115, 0.026000977, -0.008987427, -0.0059165955, 0.04977417, -0.012084961, 0.008926392, -0.034698486, 0.056884766, 0.012794495, -0.0011367798, 0.037322998, 0.037078857, -0.019897461, 0.031555176, 0.031829834, 0.016738892, 0.054840088, -0.030853271, 0.04937744, 0.033813477, -0.011688232, -0.018325806, -0.067993164, -0.032409668, -0.0047569275, 0.042541504, -0.015052795, 0.043670654, 0.005680084, -0.010818481, 0.01626587, 0.0054130554, -0.015670776, -0.022903442, 0.010025024, -0.0008573532, -0.053863525, -0.046539307, 0.028442383, 0.040863037, -0.01977539, 0.004928589, 0.017532349, -0.025482178, 0.06274414, 0.029800415, -0.083496094, -0.047912598, -0.055603027, 0.054718018, -0.008041382, 0.008964539, -0.025665283, -0.0027561188, 0.05770874, 0.052581787, 0.032440186, -0.07293701, -0.04940796, -0.025161743, 0.011054993, 0.001543045, 0.013450623, -0.0104904175, 0.044433594, -0.0011501312, -0.057891846, -0.0000757575, 0.010749817, -0.026382446, 0.007232666, -0.04437256, -0.0064430237, -0.016052246, 0.005207062, -0.0039138794, -0.033599854, 0.0016231537, -0.06689453, 0.021377563, -0.027908325, -0.048553467, -0.01071167, 0.00009858608, 0.0070495605, -0.00041770935, -0.02078247, 0.004470825, 0.006298065, 0.00073719025, 0.033233643, -0.030059814, 0.020324707, 0.00093460083, 0.039489746, 0.05380249, 0.028503418, 0.12902832, -0.06750488, 0.020706177, -0.01701355, -0.035705566, 0.014404297, 0.007904053, -0.05606079, -0.0090408325, 0.045532227, 0.008003235, -0.018539429, -0.03591919, -0.011924744, -0.031066895, -0.033050537, 0.004875183, -0.0053100586, 0.01474762, 0.081726074, 0.022369385, -0.002216339, -0.015670776, -0.02507019, 0.004886627, 0.018920898, -0.016296387, 0.008651733, 0.0121154785, -0.015686035, 0.017105103, -0.014701843, -0.02293396, -0.0038890839, -0.024475098, -0.023468018, -0.00920105, 0.0031166077, 0.006084442, -0.026611328, 0.009010315, -0.024383545, -0.006088257, -0.018325806, -0.022888184, -0.03967285, -0.013183594, 0.028045654, -0.0010890961, -0.03338623, -0.006099701, 0.028045654, -0.0019216537, -0.006252289, 0.017959595, -0.04058838, -0.0109939575, -0.0030498505, 0.04901123, 0.04736328, 0.060913086, -0.0032691956, -0.0101623535, 0.027175903, 0.018341064, -0.024215698, 0.022323608, 0.06695557, -0.028335571, -0.0050468445, -0.036346436, -0.00712204, -0.022506714, -0.03527832, 0.019760132, 0.0041275024, 0.035491943, -0.0058288574, 0.02180481, 0.03237915, -0.040924072, 0.05102539, -0.008659363, -0.00044107437, -0.05291748, -0.035217285, -0.039276123, -0.021087646, 0.008926392, 0.1038208, 0.03173828, 0.061401367, -0.0017728806, 0.011497498, 0.040771484, -0.028671265, -0.01096344, -0.015853882, -0.037872314, -0.008453369, -0.03665161, -0.008338928, -0.02267456, 0.078186035, 0.0053367615, 0.007637024, 0.0016031265, 0.064697266, -0.007572174, -0.02079773, 0.010025024, -0.06793213, -0.03189087, 0.027679443, -0.047668457, -0.009208679, 0.022140503, 0.00037956238, -0.020965576, -0.01586914, 0.021118164, -0.023208618, -0.056488037, 0.03741455, -0.018753052, -0.039489746, 0.07501221, -0.0058288574, -0.064331055, -0.052825928, 0.020751953, 0.014945984, -0.020889282, -0.08392334, 0.0158844, -0.031921387, -0.024932861, -0.025054932, 0.0154418945, 0.049224854, -0.053527832, 0.037872314, -0.019836426, -0.010635376, -0.010597229, 0.03982544, 0.024108887, 0.0005993843, 0.017974854, 0.013298035, 0.020629883, -0.017608643, 0.0335083, -0.04043579, 0.06939697, -0.003835678, -0.00060749054, 0.03463745, 0.023513794, -0.008041382, -0.021057129, -0.015716553, -0.0053138733, -0.042053223, 0.031097412, 0.023086548, -0.012649536, 0.0050849915, -0.0022907257, -0.02947998, 0.0018386841, 0.015670776, 0.008010864, 0.002948761, -0.030685425, 0.0027484894, -0.009979248, -0.0154953, 0.024810791, -0.034118652, 0.029220581, 0.0032844543, 0.009605408, 0.0015144348, -0.0021362305, -0.047332764, 0.051635742, 0.034484863, -0.03024292, -0.059448242, -0.0023460388, 0.08465576, -0.011688232, -0.035308838, -0.0043945312, 0.04321289, 0.00447464, 0.0178833, -0.01411438, -0.015266418, 0.003736496, -0.032440186, 0.018814087, 0.0040893555, -0.04849243, 0.020645142, 0.011360168, 0.011360168, 0.035461426, -0.03265381, -0.043792725, -0.002998352, -0.018035889, 0.013038635, 0.005180359, -0.016571045, -0.01512146, -0.057037354, 0.017288208, -0.055725098, -0.0031986237, -0.0014543533, 0.10205078, 0.02217102, 0.0008196831, 0.02067566, -0.013519287, 0.041809082, 0.032989502, 0.0011825562, 0.049591064, -0.0054626465, -0.060180664, 0.04949951, 0.0006670952, 0.0039043427, 0.012069702, 0.010650635, -0.017715454, 0.0043411255, 0.0057525635, 0.0071792603, 0.009346008, -0.016540527, -0.014175415, -0.020767212, 0.046936035, -0.0026683807, 0.011871338, -0.057800293, -0.023803711, 0.01171875, -0.06793213, -0.005264282, 0.010971069, 0.0015239716, -0.05355835, -0.04336548, 0.015106201, -0.04812622, -0.020446777, -0.04547119, 0.03189087, -0.03878784, 0.010734558, -0.02116394, 0.013504028, -0.030410767, -0.020690918, -0.025375366, -0.06793213, 0.017456055, -0.003129959, -0.0034732819, -0.051208496, 0.019058228, 0.02545166, -0.014884949, -0.010658264, -0.050354004, -0.004508972, -0.042297363, 0.02607727, 0.010757446, -0.004081726, 0.030807495, -0.022140503, 0.06878662, -0.03375244, -0.020217896, 0.04949951, 0.0546875, 0.002916336, 0.0068855286, 0.019058228, -0.0027313232, -0.021026611, 0.006252289, 0.006877899, -0.0501709, 0.0011281967, 0.052856445, -0.027252197, 0.027832031, -0.0035057068, -0.0067710876, -0.015640259, 0.015090942, -0.0141067505, -0.043518066, -0.023162842, 0.002653122, 0.021530151, -0.006904602, 0.015174866, -0.012031555, -0.014266968, 0.037506104, -0.111328125, 0.0423584, -0.01360321, -0.010543823, -0.039916992, -0.029708862, 0.015136719, -0.06866455, -0.0129470825, 0.0075645447, -0.010360718, -0.026168823, -0.017578125, -0.018493652, -0.0211792, 0.024368286, 0.0066452026, 0.02861023, -0.022644043, -0.05670166, -0.022354126, -0.014137268, -0.039520264, -0.018005371, -0.00024676323, 0.009902954, -0.01902771, -0.002670288, -0.034820557, 0.030517578, 0.02482605, 0.11352539, 0.039367676, 0.022354126, -0.080200195, 0.02609253, -0.011627197, 0.039886475, -0.012435913, 0.02545166, -0.013031006, 0.011108398, -0.022369385, -0.004886627, -0.020187378, 0.00819397, 0.015319824, 0.017913818, -0.00308609, -0.0023860931, 0.07940674, 0.008552551, 0.042144775, -0.011116028, 0.0025596619, -0.0029258728, -0.022918701, -0.066223145, 0.023010254, -0.002609253, 0.007545471, -0.008590698, -0.00415802, -0.022903442, 0.022415161, 0.018447876, 0.011726379, -0.021270752, -0.02684021, 0.03744507, 0.032043457, 0.0011844635, 0.011688232, 0.023391724, 0.000010073185, -0.0340271, -0.02079773, 0.013458252, 0.01966858, 0.04598999, -0.009468079, 0.03152466, 0.03414917, 0.003025055, -0.050964355, -0.028671265, -0.026123047, 0.034606934, -0.018539429, -0.040802002, -0.024139404, -0.009765625, 0.00868988, -0.0021018982, 0.005214691, 0.02255249, -0.016616821, 0.00040388107, 0.024261475, -0.0052452087, 0.0004911423, -0.018447876, 0.018600464, -0.012382507, -0.040802002, -0.019500732, 0.020629883, -0.0025558472, 0.024032593, 0.040649414, -0.035247803, -0.03768921, -0.015060425, -0.014602661, -0.0020618439, -0.066589355, 0.0151901245, -0.021194458, -0.024291992, 0.012741089, -0.032470703, 0.024383545, -0.020202637, -0.032592773, -0.009094238, -0.005012512, -0.00022220612, 0.012680054, 0.00014007092, 0.018554688, -0.021942139, -0.0071907043, 0.027954102, 0.049468994, -0.031402588, -0.0019779205, -0.01713562, 0.04888916, -0.04736328, -0.0025463104, 0.00007623434, 0.007434845, -0.0020370483, 0.009338379, 0.008712769, -0.0026741028, -0.012908936, -0.01586914, 0.031463623, -0.020721436, -0.03829956, -0.040618896, 0.005393982, 0.02218628, 0.036468506, 0.037384033, -0.049926758, 0.002506256, 0.0011577606, -0.009086609, 0.020706177, 0.04827881, -0.010063171, -0.064575195, -0.007133484, -0.009048462, -0.008964539, 0.0019283295, 0.026473999, 0.029373169, 0.0126953125, 0.005706787, -0.016342163, -0.00046515465, 0.021011353, -0.016784668, 0.008392334, 0.015075684, -0.013908386, 0.004875183, -0.040649414, -0.037719727, 0.02444458, 0.009277344, 0.0009918213, -0.010101318, -0.010093689, -0.050994873, 0.030960083, -0.01574707, -0.0059432983, -0.0027542114, -0.02960205, 0.006954193, 0.019515991, 0.0034236908, -0.022323608, -0.014839172, 0.012413025, 0.0007739067, -0.057678223, -0.03805542, 0.0017518997, -0.013038635, -0.060546875, -0.005466461, 0.035247803, 0.028396606, 0.020217896, -0.036712646, -0.06549072, 0.0059127808, -0.053344727, -0.003250122, -0.01777649, 0.017456055, 0.03213501, 0.052886963, -0.0010185242, 0.0069007874, -0.008285522, 0.0068588257, 0.016555786, -0.034088135, 0.013809204, 0.05239868, 0.00705719, 0.04043579, -0.034576416, 0.036712646, 0.040222168, 0.022369385, -0.03036499, 0.060455322, 0.009941101, 0.0013856888, -0.03213501, 0.031219482, 0.024673462, 0.039093018, 0.022918701, 0.049835205, -0.008628845, 0.009895325, 0.018295288, -0.007347107, 0.03161621, 0.0090789795, -0.021652222, -0.0069465637, -0.040496826, -0.025604248, -0.04144287, -0.015731812, -0.056365967, -0.009025574, -0.022949219, 0.047210693, 0.026672363, -0.02557373, -0.06365967, 0.062347412, -0.021743774, 0.022369385, 0.0657959, -0.03540039, 0.042999268, -0.03555298, -0.034301758, -0.0054512024, 0.013504028, -0.008666992, 0.01259613, 0.02532959, -0.02029419, 0.030593872, 0.007133484, 0.04006958, -0.006122589, -0.04421997, 0.007858276, -0.049560547, 0.00017225742, 0.011436462, 0.030853271, 0.027145386, 0.04559326, -0.004737854, 0.01398468, -0.016967773, 0.005508423, 0.0044517517, 0.023162842, 0.0050621033, -0.0033950806, -0.0121536255, 0.034454346, 0.004169464, 0.009239197, -0.026611328, 0.020446777, 0.026123047, 0.027633667, -0.039916992, -0.002210617, -0.006565094, 0.0028076172, -0.018493652, 0.030151367, -0.027526855, -0.022399902, 0.03353882, 0.0010690689, -0.025299072, -0.019058228, 0.023880005, 0.049804688, -0.029647827, 0.07312012, 0.003616333, 0.009788513, 0.0005059242, 0.00756073, -0.12176514, 0.014762878, 0.057525635, 0.0031051636, 0.020355225, 0.028198242, -0.021331787, 0.062805176, 0.0013885498, 0.038116455, 0.09942627, 0.056396484, -0.019332886, 0.022766113, 0.08166504, -0.039764404, 0.010864258, 0.0058784485, -0.010047913, -0.031585693, -0.024612427, 0.0059814453, -0.026611328, -0.022140503, 0.01197052, -0.018173218, -0.0064964294, -0.015975952, -0.010665894, 0.0155181885, -0.010398865, -0.039642334, -0.012825012, -0.031158447, -0.025817871, -0.014640808, -0.006336212, -0.03189087, -0.06665039, 0.037963867, -0.035095215, -0.02243042, -0.02281189, -0.031341553, 0.021606445, -0.051605225, 0.021896362, -0.025909424, 0.101745605, -0.010040283, 0.008964539, -0.0034637451, -0.0059051514, -0.040130615, 0.009460449, -0.059173584, -0.004776001, -0.01953125, 0.018630981, 0.008598328, -0.020645142, -0.022583008, 0.038970947, 0.0069122314, -0.006702423, 0.007335663, -0.0006098747, -0.007736206, -0.020126343, -0.010131836, -0.014930725, 0.0037727356, -0.00009894371, 0.010681152, 0.015403748, 0.05279541, -0.0012655258, -0.04849243, -0.01902771, -0.030517578, 0.0135650635, -0.0072746277, -0.034088135, 0.03010559, 0.001791954, -0.048950195, 0.013290405, 0.010429382, 0.046539307, -0.039123535, 0.0074539185, -0.013793945, 0.009048462, 0.07702637, 0.083984375, 0.014312744, -0.052459717, -0.084350586, -0.062316895, 0.0770874, -0.03225708, -0.038146973, -0.06161499, 0.030029297, 0.00047302246, -0.011512756, 0.010147095, -0.010879517, -0.025100708, 0.018432617, 0.01777649, 0.0025043488, -0.037109375, -0.037628174, 0.0234375, -0.011276245, -0.0035743713, -0.008888245, 0.020751953, -0.00047063828, 0.025283813, -0.025787354, -0.034606934, 0.033477783, -0.007472992, 0.012420654, -0.0066871643, 0.046844482, -0.019592285, -0.00818634, 0.019165039, 0.015930176, 0.05227661, 0.01776123, -0.01020813, 0.020477295, -0.08239746, -0.011482239, -0.049224854, -0.011428833, -0.00069856644, -0.024765015, 0.0024662018, 0.030761719, -0.02558899, 0.020401001, 0.006038666, 0.05581665, 0.011802673, -0.0019626617, -0.02607727, 0.0071640015, -0.004131317 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04765v1
The voraus-AD Dataset for Anomaly Detection in Robot Applications
Jan Thieß Brockmann, Marco Rudolph, Bodo Rosenhahn, Bastian Wandt
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
During the operation of industrial robots, unusual events may endanger the safety of humans and the quality of production. When collecting data to detect such cases, it is not ensured that data from all potentially occurring errors is included as unforeseeable events may happen over time. Therefore, anomaly detection (AD) delivers a practical solution, using only normal data to learn to detect unusual events. We introduce a dataset that allows training and benchmarking of anomaly detection methods for robotic applications based on machine data which will be made publicly available to the research community. As a typical robot task the dataset includes a pick-and-place application which involves movement, actions of the end effector and interactions with the objects of the environment. Since several of the contained anomalies are not task-specific but general, evaluations on our dataset are transferable to other robotics applications as well. Additionally, we present MVT-Flow (multivariate time-series flow) as a new baseline method for anomaly detection: It relies on deep-learning-based density estimation with normalizing flows, tailored to the data domain by taking its structure into account for the architecture. Our evaluation shows that MVT-Flow outperforms baselines from previous work by a large margin of 6.2% in area under ROC.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04765v1
2023-11-08T15:39:27
2023-11-08T15:39:27
{ "title": [ -0.00030183792, -0.0034618378, -0.032226562, -0.03173828, 0.0028305054, -0.02961731, -0.005306244, -0.014190674, -0.024032593, 0.019165039, -0.04244995, 0.020050049, -0.018447876, -0.011810303, -0.016403198, -0.017791748, -0.0028495789, 0.04940796, 0.014640808, -0.0008177757, -0.0020599365, -0.0087890625, 0.0473938, 0.0036029816, 0.017913818, -0.009315491, -0.066711426, -0.0043258667, -0.02420044, -0.03555298, -0.0058021545, 0.013000488, 0.04055786, 0.01676941, -0.00035214424, 0.015167236, -0.04623413, 0.031021118, 0.011222839, -0.0011320114, 0.022766113, -0.019241333, 0.010879517, -0.021530151, -0.021835327, 0.05496216, -0.048431396, -0.01852417, -0.013717651, 0.06329346, 0.020141602, 0.028762817, -0.012611389, 0.07147217, 0.0234375, -0.024139404, -0.02973938, -0.04647827, 0.04067993, 0.08898926, 0.024093628, -0.07702637, 0.012718201, -0.035308838, -0.03540039, -0.006565094, -0.008552551, 0.020721436, 0.046569824, -0.010032654, -0.013320923, 0.01474762, -0.010650635, 0.03152466, -0.036254883, -0.031829834, 0.057525635, -0.0012950897, 0.007904053, 0.010932922, 0.0065345764, -0.004463196, 0.025039673, 0.0031318665, -0.024856567, -0.042297363, -0.008354187, -0.008415222, -0.04244995, -0.0491333, -0.016921997, -0.034729004, -0.0031223297, 0.012237549, -0.031143188, -0.007068634, -0.006793976, 0.017868042, 0.016525269, -0.02432251, 0.01663208, -0.0065345764, -0.015853882, -0.012374878, 0.027297974, 0.0027236938, -0.025756836, -0.0803833, 0.0107421875, 0.015281677, -0.045135498, 0.050720215, 0.009269714, 0.0104904175, -0.016204834, -0.009536743, -0.00023019314, -0.027923584, 0.005001068, -0.019454956, -0.014976501, -0.015640259, 0.027114868, -0.03173828, 0.035186768, 0.00573349, -0.037902832, -0.017974854, 0.020950317, 0.00052309036, 0.014694214, 0.021606445, -0.080444336, -0.04699707, -0.025909424, 0.04977417, 0.005428314, -0.01473999, 0.003440857, -0.005680084, -0.004283905, -0.00566864, 0.0017232895, 0.00554657, -0.046966553, -0.0007209778, 0.04699707, 0.019088745, -0.049591064, -0.037109375, -0.022888184, 0.017791748, 0.024230957, 0.0067863464, 0.010528564, -0.008956909, -0.05380249, -0.02960205, 0.016860962, 0.004886627, 0.005596161, -0.0022201538, -0.01953125, -0.024124146, 0.024291992, 0.0033817291, 0.01852417, 0.026046753, 0.00774765, 0.056762695, 0.00029826164, 0.015159607, 0.012664795, -0.020706177, -0.022491455, -0.034088135, 0.020263672, 0.009094238, 0.04043579, -0.04736328, -0.021118164, -0.017837524, 0.020843506, 0.03048706, -0.041931152, -0.042755127, 0.0060539246, -0.00497818, 0.026489258, 0.015411377, -0.055755615, 0.045684814, -0.03164673, -0.022521973, -0.042755127, -0.00749588, 0.030639648, 0.04837036, -0.0003311634, -0.0071525574, -0.03869629, 0.0007801056, -0.039642334, 0.015022278, -0.022827148, -0.029174805, -0.021835327, 0.024307251, -0.04928589, 0.059936523, 0.06744385, 0.009994507, -0.055511475, 0.05810547, 0.028579712, -0.06616211, 0.0019330978, 0.0022506714, -0.019088745, 0.014213562, -0.06524658, 0.003156662, -0.030517578, 0.0058784485, 0.044708252, 0.01423645, -0.008369446, -0.033569336, 0.08331299, 0.016235352, 0.07543945, -0.030181885, 0.040985107, 0.014968872, -0.00008666515, -0.0143585205, -0.024993896, -0.015563965, 0.015586853, 0.017211914, -0.0006904602, -0.023071289, -0.018966675, 0.028656006, 0.050598145, -0.02368164, -0.0110321045, 0.03894043, 0.0019159317, 0.0077209473, 0.049591064, 0.03451538, 0.059509277, 0.029800415, -0.006248474, 0.06750488, 0.04168701, -0.011459351, -0.025009155, 0.032226562, 0.010787964, -0.00932312, -0.04827881, 0.023132324, -0.054229736, 0.011238098, 0.00096845627, 0.030426025, 0.026641846, -0.001326561, 0.0023479462, -0.031188965, 0.00617218, 0.010536194, 0.012870789, 0.008178711, -0.013496399, 0.0012483597, 0.007434845, -0.03994751, -0.024734497, -0.031036377, 0.035064697, -0.0029296875, 0.056610107, 0.02659607, 0.020141602, -0.055358887, -0.006580353, -0.00030446053, 0.064086914, 0.012924194, 0.010765076, -0.028762817, -0.00030851364, -0.012207031, 0.064697266, 0.085998535, -0.034301758, 0.0362854, -0.054351807, 0.004070282, -0.016738892, 0.008583069, 0.015930176, -0.015525818, 0.027557373, 0.0362854, -0.0070724487, 0.028503418, -0.08514404, -0.0031032562, 0.011856079, -0.0209198, -0.02810669, -0.051330566, -0.011154175, -0.022979736, -0.074035645, -0.06549072, 0.045074463, -0.040527344, 0.008285522, 0.0013837814, -0.0060272217, -0.037353516, -0.0036678314, -0.008712769, -0.023345947, 0.03289795, 0.048736572, 0.058929443, -0.022613525, 0.023880005, -0.0009613037, 0.017501831, -0.013999939, 0.028289795, -0.016967773, -0.005138397, 0.009399414, -0.039611816, 0.002527237, -0.052642822, -0.0015983582, -0.04711914, 0.018692017, 0.021835327, -0.051635742, -0.010383606, 0.042236328, -0.047088623, -0.045837402, -0.01902771, 0.05682373, -0.05569458, -0.0141067505, 0.007358551, 0.026367188, -0.023971558, 0.03024292, 0.025466919, 0.004863739, -0.017486572, -0.041656494, -0.04660034, 0.02670288, -0.021728516, 0.021514893, 0.057922363, -0.05328369, 0.029190063, -0.059143066, -0.0093688965, 0.004425049, 0.028686523, -0.025924683, -0.051361084, 0.0087509155, -0.022537231, -0.010261536, 0.01626587, -0.02796936, 0.044128418, 0.07458496, 0.014221191, 0.018585205, 0.022842407, 0.053588867, -0.015464783, 0.013885498, 0.007045746, -0.004787445, -0.022979736, 0.001789093, -0.0003786087, -0.008918762, 0.022857666, -0.042633057, -0.0071372986, -0.004245758, 0.03189087, -0.017211914, 0.03225708, -0.042663574, 0.02015686, -0.0062713623, -0.03439331, 0.016281128, 0.07312012, 0.013389587, -0.013725281, 0.03741455, -0.039276123, 0.021255493, -0.027923584, -0.051635742, 0.03668213, -0.015213013, -0.055847168, -0.00040555, -0.017684937, -0.04824829, -0.03451538, -0.018875122, 0.008476257, 0.030090332, 0.015136719, 0.0096588135, -0.01007843, -0.012397766, -0.02897644, -0.0025672913, -0.004917145, -0.06237793, -0.02279663, -0.0015764236, 0.030410767, 0.071899414, -0.023010254, -0.008773804, 0.008171082, 0.0014982224, 0.043670654, 0.021987915, -0.031829834, 0.006416321, 0.008926392, -0.028518677, -0.011375427, -0.031097412, 0.0047416687, -0.036071777, 0.018875122, -0.007751465, 0.041503906, 0.0021400452, -0.008415222, -0.02557373, -0.016998291, 0.0061454773, -0.01473999, -0.06707764, -0.023666382, 0.002626419, -0.0042762756, 0.0037403107, -0.002313614, -0.0049705505, -0.0053482056, -0.020309448, 0.06512451, 0.010925293, -0.00084781647, -0.004299164, 0.02230835, -0.028961182, -0.020080566, 0.002462387, 0.038848877, -0.017578125, 0.013153076, -0.003314972, -0.08569336, -0.0033302307, 0.0008945465, -0.091674805, 0.0007843971, 0.02911377, -0.035308838, -0.017501831, -0.066345215, 0.0064697266, -0.008239746, -0.031311035, -0.0017871857, -0.012084961, -0.03665161, -0.029678345, -0.08654785, -0.030059814, 0.055511475, 0.025161743, 0.02130127, 0.044281006, 0.011711121, -0.026626587, -0.02760315, 0.0048294067, -0.013877869, 0.03213501, -0.019485474, 0.0010490417, 0.052459717, -0.04348755, 0.024414062, -0.0019874573, 0.031280518, -0.036346436, -0.0019550323, -0.024871826, -0.01977539, -0.005168915, 0.054229736, 0.010627747, -0.01348114, -0.05960083, 0.03262329, -0.011772156, -0.014663696, 0.017715454, -0.0057411194, -0.008964539, 0.0048179626, 0.037231445, 0.068359375, -0.0007376671, 0.013252258, 0.02720642, -0.015022278, -0.032989502, -0.020751953, 0.033111572, 0.005077362, 0.015075684, 0.022857666, 0.009742737, 0.021133423, -0.010391235, -0.020645142, -0.01096344, 0.012466431, -0.036712646, -0.027664185, -0.04714966, -0.03253174, -0.0061073303, 0.0068740845, 0.0012397766, 0.004623413, 0.036346436, -0.018981934, -0.04034424, 0.014640808, 0.07696533, 0.013343811, -0.0048217773, -0.08868408, -0.000055134296, -0.00522995, -0.03778076, -0.018814087, 0.02508545, 0.008583069, 0.034362793, -0.014320374, -0.013008118, 0.0020751953, 0.028411865, 0.07397461, 0.07312012, 0.024291992, -0.064086914, 0.048583984, -0.041229248, 0.0005493164, 0.04638672, -0.025054932, -0.010421753, -0.010513306, 0.020462036, -0.011383057, 0.0095825195, 0.009170532, 0.005065918, -0.032836914, 0.03756714, -0.041931152, 0.030258179, 0.009941101, -0.019226074, 0.008888245, 0.010177612, -0.045684814, 0.00064086914, 0.0022640228, 0.025390625, -0.03778076, 0.036590576, 0.042144775, 0.005264282, -0.015563965, -0.015220642, 0.042999268, 0.005542755, -0.040924072, 0.009460449, 0.01789856, -0.04071045, -0.027999878, 0.0068588257, 0.016937256, 0.046813965, -0.03540039, 0.027053833, -0.0024375916, -0.018356323, 0.028060913, -0.013946533, -0.01335907, 0.0038928986, -0.0024223328, -0.061584473, -0.095581055, -0.0077819824, 0.0914917, -0.014221191, -0.008865356, 0.009124756, 0.027923584, 0.022521973, 0.038238525, 0.035583496, 0.0053253174, -0.022979736, -0.02645874, -0.0063438416, -0.03237915, -0.05368042, 0.03250122, -0.024215698, 0.011581421, 0.019561768, -0.0236969, -0.06726074, 0.0019235611, 0.013824463, 0.0028572083, 0.008705139, -0.06530762, 0.018920898, 0.039764404, -0.005722046, 0.008010864, -0.017623901, 0.03881836, 0.06008911, 0.036376953, 0.03277588, -0.015510559, 0.03338623, -0.008979797, -0.0011482239, -0.008918762, -0.010536194, 0.03677368, 0.025527954, 0.012542725, 0.011390686, -0.030059814, 0.029342651, 0.01423645, -0.01663208, -0.0077209473, -0.029586792, 0.008888245, -0.009971619, 0.013511658, 0.021606445, 0.008781433, -0.021865845, 0.008392334, 0.009262085, -0.024276733, -0.009590149, 0.017364502, -0.027557373, -0.08496094, 0.026428223, -0.031280518, -0.01928711, -0.01084137, 0.032440186, -0.029251099, 0.02507019, 0.049316406, -0.04373169, 0.016311646, -0.02470398, 0.015914917, 0.046905518, 0.028915405, -0.0043678284, -0.0005583763, -0.0020713806, -0.06060791, -0.05609131, 0.013252258, 0.0017852783, 0.004142761, -0.03451538, -0.049346924, -0.008155823, -0.02861023, 0.00031995773, 0.011054993, -0.027893066, 0.001914978, 0.0012989044, -0.02230835, 0.019744873, 0.032348633, 0.02381897, 0.0016174316, -0.019485474, -0.019424438, 0.0104904175, 0.0024642944, 0.010139465, 0.01626587, -0.08227539, 0.021881104, 0.013908386, 0.022277832, -0.0060424805, 0.010253906, 0.030471802, 0.028167725, 0.016082764, 0.0042037964, 0.07196045, -0.035125732, -0.018203735, -0.014533997, 0.008178711, -0.020126343, 0.035888672, -0.025848389, -0.033111572, -0.032196045, -0.033569336, -0.02909851, 0.02041626, 0.039154053, -0.021438599, 0.035217285, -0.030441284, 0.021820068, -0.0368042, -0.016708374, -0.038391113, 0.011184692, -0.00680542, -0.036834717, 0.045776367, 0.0035057068, 0.025985718, -0.043121338, -0.0055236816, 0.0017623901, 0.0206604, -0.010719299, -0.038116455, 0.0024719238, -0.023498535, -0.01322937, 0.025894165, 0.00016117096, 0.002960205, 0.04058838, -0.048095703, 0.035614014, 0.01889038, 0.04434204, 0.05105591, 0.010177612, 0.015617371, 0.003271103, -0.03466797, -0.040527344, -0.019836426, -0.04034424, -0.037872314, -0.035858154, -0.015716553, -0.048553467, 0.006175995, 0.011993408, 0.03640747, -0.0044898987, 0.011138916, 0.0068626404, 0.020324707, 0.023864746, -0.014930725, 0.05621338, 0.0039596558, 0.011329651, -0.0206604, -0.01134491, 0.02482605, 0.032165527, -0.0028133392, 0.016433716, -0.0040626526, -0.045135498, 0.014205933, 0.05682373, 0.020553589, -0.038116455, -0.019714355, -0.05050659, 0.030761719, -0.008422852, 0.041503906, 0.04812622, 0.04135132, -0.005455017, -0.016815186, 0.007446289, -0.042816162, -0.024276733, -0.010047913, 0.025512695, -0.054016113, 0.043823242, -0.032470703, -0.023895264, -0.01499939, 0.02305603, 0.01576233, -0.06304932, -0.04763794, 0.029968262, 0.03918457, 0.030776978, 0.009880066, -0.043518066, -0.020843506, -0.028671265, 0.00024724007, 0.018005371, 0.031433105, 0.027282715, 0.020126343, -0.03668213, -0.003004074, -0.009635925, 0.04562378, -0.037109375, 0.015205383, -0.049102783, 0.03869629, -0.050872803, -0.041412354, 0.009422302, -0.0061302185, -0.053222656, -0.031707764, 0.091430664, -0.0040359497, 0.034057617, 0.052459717, 0.021530151, -0.017318726, -0.0061454773, -0.0597229, 0.0027637482, 0.027572632, -0.028945923, 0.018508911, -0.015457153, -0.0423584, 0.07183838, -0.046966553, 0.09173584, -0.050231934, 0.025665283, -0.025878906, 0.013534546, 0.01260376, -0.059448242, 0.01927185, -0.031143188, 0.014755249, 0.0061950684, 0.026428223, -0.055786133, -0.006427765, 0.02229309, 0.002779007, 0.020309448, -0.024627686, -0.02760315, -0.006916046, -0.06756592, -0.006511688, -0.03387451, 0.02029419, -0.010360718, -0.019729614, -0.057861328, 0.016555786, -0.00087451935, 0.010688782, 0.009979248, -0.00036668777, -0.085998535, -0.03152466, 0.013122559, 0.010734558, -0.021835327, 0.004272461, -0.041534424, 0.015411377, -0.024627686, 0.0023956299, 0.02432251, -0.021530151, -0.0473938, -0.0051345825, -0.022003174, 0.009971619, -0.0059547424, -0.026885986, 0.008483887, 0.0138549805, -0.02520752, 0.022735596, 0.023330688, 0.06549072, -0.025970459, -0.029296875, 0.0076179504, 0.05545044, 0.03149414, -0.038269043, 0.009681702, 0.012016296, -0.0063209534, -0.0017223358, 0.048980713, 0.0009784698, 0.025222778, 0.015655518, 0.07208252, 0.015266418, -0.07904053, -0.045043945, -0.064819336, 0.02784729, 0.053863525, -0.009315491, -0.018463135, 0.043701172, 0.020233154, -0.0005545616, 0.031066895, 0.009605408, 0.023757935, 0.0020122528, 0.060180664, -0.02810669, 0.0000936985, -0.012237549, 0.00881958, 0.009796143, 0.049102783, -0.033447266, 0.0184021, 0.00034213066, 0.04360962, -0.005088806, -0.06951904, 0.04348755, 0.02520752, 0.018173218, 0.01158905, -0.017929077, -0.028717041, -0.005519867, -0.0017728806, 0.0035820007, 0.008354187, 0.0069999695, -0.014419556, 0.0059890747, -0.07739258, -0.019622803, 0.006362915, -0.014480591, 0.041748047, -0.036071777, 0.002954483, -0.04321289, -0.023132324, -0.021881104, 0.030410767, -0.016906738, -0.037261963, -0.028381348, -0.028198242, 0.04977417, -0.016357422 ], "summary": [ 0.057403564, -0.010925293, 0.0034923553, -0.049591064, -0.0049743652, -0.022888184, -0.004825592, -0.005836487, 0.01663208, 0.00026154518, -0.06640625, 0.015602112, -0.019042969, -0.0051651, 0.007461548, -0.04147339, -0.0006980896, 0.07659912, 0.07006836, 0.00642395, 0.015945435, 0.010055542, 0.021881104, -0.030914307, -0.0090789795, 0.04135132, -0.013252258, -0.0102005005, 0.0069885254, 0.008636475, 0.00011283159, -0.019454956, 0.0035266876, -0.0004594326, 0.020187378, 0.028884888, -0.0006556511, 0.010650635, 0.02230835, 0.014717102, 0.029022217, -0.0063095093, 0.0947876, -0.036590576, 0.030517578, 0.06085205, -0.015914917, -0.025283813, 0.0095825195, 0.03945923, -0.0001578331, 0.021484375, -0.01512146, 0.023605347, -0.0008826256, -0.00995636, -0.062805176, -0.0385437, 0.02748108, 0.09100342, 0.02583313, -0.055633545, -0.0061302185, -0.060394287, 0.020706177, 0.012565613, 0.029220581, 0.021316528, -0.0054969788, 0.008934021, 0.019561768, -0.011909485, -0.02217102, 0.029083252, -0.029785156, -0.0287323, 0.030258179, -0.016571045, -0.013496399, 0.03488159, -0.005718231, -0.0059776306, 0.0055770874, -0.01979065, -0.043426514, -0.05734253, -0.018295288, 0.008811951, -0.033966064, -0.001461029, -0.0385437, -0.04522705, -0.031585693, 0.02835083, 0.012580872, -0.016098022, 0.02508545, 0.021987915, 0.022735596, 0.01789856, 0.047058105, -0.072021484, 0.047729492, -0.047302246, 0.020385742, -0.034454346, -0.013725281, -0.10449219, 0.00019097328, -0.006931305, -0.06939697, 0.05029297, 0.008323669, -0.04916382, -0.02243042, 0.033325195, 0.04019165, -0.015335083, 0.023925781, -0.027633667, 0.005634308, 0.033935547, -0.016830444, -0.013069153, 0.005554199, 0.0033569336, -0.022094727, -0.00945282, 0.015541077, -0.007537842, -0.0061569214, -0.0002937317, -0.012252808, 0.016525269, -0.0014619827, 0.0054473877, 0.048706055, 0.008682251, 0.020339966, -0.04208374, 0.061767578, 0.0027370453, -0.048828125, 0.064086914, -0.030670166, 0.011360168, 0.005519867, 0.024597168, -0.0064315796, -0.013938904, 0.0013093948, 0.0026836395, 0.010688782, -0.014984131, 0.011482239, -0.044281006, -0.01586914, -0.005264282, 0.04248047, -0.0028686523, -0.01751709, -0.0039138794, -0.0018482208, 0.013404846, -0.013145447, 0.022399902, 0.03665161, 0.010978699, -0.0008177757, 0.009033203, -0.014694214, 0.026733398, 0.02407837, -0.006549835, 0.0017547607, -0.017211914, -0.001991272, 0.027664185, -0.0026874542, -0.017196655, -0.028198242, -0.05496216, -0.038391113, 0.010406494, -0.008224487, 0.0046539307, -0.017211914, -0.005264282, 0.022460938, -0.0018520355, -0.012329102, 0.04714966, -0.026565552, 0.02128601, -0.017288208, -0.010375977, -0.038604736, 0.02178955, -0.03640747, -0.010871887, 0.024475098, -0.012763977, 0.019805908, -0.007472992, -0.030563354, 0.013160706, -0.016098022, 0.012901306, -0.05633545, 0.034576416, 0.042175293, -0.025238037, -0.0491333, 0.07330322, 0.044189453, -0.03189087, 0.012832642, -0.049224854, -0.03086853, -0.008201599, -0.056365967, 0.03387451, -0.061431885, 0.008491516, 0.008270264, 0.014907837, -0.0124435425, 0.0051994324, 0.079711914, 0.012496948, 0.072021484, -0.054779053, -0.0037517548, -0.018493652, -0.015991211, 0.0018548965, 0.0015010834, -0.07159424, 0.015777588, 0.045440674, 0.0154418945, 0.024261475, -0.009468079, 0.047027588, 0.05114746, -0.015304565, -0.013710022, 0.030792236, -0.03439331, 0.011001587, 0.033050537, 0.03692627, 0.01928711, -0.001701355, -0.015960693, 0.033996582, 0.040740967, -0.0107803345, -0.020736694, 0.01322937, 0.018997192, -0.04660034, -0.06939697, 0.01625061, -0.008888245, -0.0019874573, 0.015838623, 0.010093689, 0.017166138, -0.015602112, -0.00983429, -0.024536133, 0.0029621124, 0.0044059753, -0.007881165, -0.003063202, -0.011383057, -0.0006313324, 0.03338623, -0.0067100525, -0.021606445, -0.0014705658, 0.01499939, -0.024627686, 0.03111267, 0.056854248, 0.0058021545, -0.07495117, 0.016357422, 0.05218506, 0.06500244, 0.0052948, -0.015975952, -0.014305115, -0.0049934387, -0.019882202, 0.02947998, 0.04714966, -0.009155273, -0.028289795, 0.004886627, 0.015563965, -0.07196045, 0.0418396, 0.031280518, -0.019073486, 0.030166626, 0.0003912449, 0.0059318542, 0.041381836, -0.10046387, -0.023773193, 0.024642944, 0.07098389, -0.03152466, -0.040252686, -0.010978699, 0.057250977, -0.028793335, -0.046173096, 0.03414917, -0.014823914, 0.0030460358, 0.014045715, -0.021606445, -0.025787354, 0.019058228, -0.014152527, -0.027862549, 0.03869629, -0.020309448, 0.024429321, -0.011367798, 0.047943115, -0.0058517456, 0.025665283, 0.0041770935, 0.030548096, -0.0069351196, -0.052825928, -0.012428284, -0.030563354, -0.01259613, 0.011909485, -0.042510986, -0.028839111, 0.019989014, 0.0027770996, -0.03894043, -0.016342163, 0.049560547, -0.02104187, -0.06274414, -0.041259766, 0.00044226646, -0.01550293, 0.04373169, -0.029541016, 0.0079422, -0.051116943, 0.021148682, 0.041290283, 0.008087158, -0.0413208, -0.058410645, -0.021911621, 0.019332886, -0.0041160583, 0.037597656, 0.064453125, -0.024856567, 0.052581787, -0.037231445, -0.005207062, -0.013069153, 0.008331299, 0.007972717, -0.021652222, -0.0029449463, -0.0069007874, 0.019989014, 0.014099121, 0.020019531, 0.029281616, 0.06518555, 0.0031929016, 0.0140686035, 0.05206299, 0.044067383, -0.012275696, 0.015792847, 0.024887085, -0.0009036064, -0.050567627, -0.0049705505, 0.024368286, -0.0005083084, 0.035217285, 0.031829834, -0.031555176, 0.015350342, 0.039855957, 0.0047569275, 0.012573242, 0.00026082993, 0.02168274, -0.0022182465, -0.020889282, 0.0036716461, 0.036224365, 0.035980225, -0.037261963, 0.051971436, -0.028579712, 0.023773193, -0.03488159, 0.052520752, 0.013496399, -0.02178955, -0.0345459, 0.02923584, -0.0031337738, 0.017349243, -0.029541016, -0.027404785, 0.01008606, -0.006626129, 0.022506714, -0.019195557, 0.02319336, -0.014961243, -0.010147095, 0.029190063, -0.011161804, -0.107055664, -0.038208008, 0.0057792664, 0.0446167, 0.070617676, -0.06500244, 0.024459839, -0.012283325, -0.01550293, 0.02015686, 0.011360168, -0.01725769, 0.0038547516, 0.02003479, -0.0009870529, 0.015144348, -0.022277832, 0.00015580654, -0.004257202, 0.017166138, -0.02130127, 0.038391113, -0.0071907043, 0.026657104, 0.04296875, -0.04119873, 0.0043907166, 0.004558563, -0.059814453, 0.007843018, -0.01940918, 0.011367798, -0.01637268, 0.028030396, -0.008232117, -0.016433716, -0.0098724365, 0.05505371, -0.041748047, -0.028671265, -0.01776123, -0.016830444, 0.059906006, -0.030700684, 0.09338379, -0.026641846, -0.017150879, 0.010238647, -0.016479492, -0.05230713, -0.020401001, 0.017288208, -0.08642578, -0.026031494, 0.014724731, -0.003993988, 0.041900635, -0.048706055, 0.054595947, -0.030822754, -0.023468018, -0.01852417, -0.0038528442, 0.020141602, -0.03463745, -0.07110596, -0.023162842, -0.025390625, 0.05432129, 0.05807495, -0.0073509216, 0.010482788, 0.03387451, -0.020095825, -0.022247314, -0.016311646, 0.023223877, -0.061584473, 0.01058197, 0.029296875, -0.034301758, 0.028411865, -0.039642334, 0.011146545, -0.046142578, 0.011581421, -0.0018014908, 0.012573242, -0.012939453, 0.0015106201, 0.046539307, -0.009902954, -0.022903442, 0.048706055, -0.005092621, -0.03137207, 0.016845703, 0.05444336, -0.04638672, -0.003982544, 0.032165527, -0.030273438, -0.028793335, 0.00077199936, 0.0075531006, 0.01802063, -0.04257202, -0.041931152, 0.030395508, 0.03112793, -0.014877319, 0.0099105835, -0.0256958, 0.020324707, -0.02885437, -0.011810303, -0.007850647, 0.0016908646, -0.029632568, -0.04168701, -0.021453857, 0.004764557, 0.014373779, 0.008514404, 0.006549835, -0.06518555, -0.026535034, -0.008377075, 0.011177063, 0.012718201, 0.025024414, 0.045654297, -0.05783081, -0.07763672, -0.03250122, 0.007865906, -0.02520752, -0.003932953, 0.0035934448, -0.04272461, 0.0022392273, -0.02444458, -0.0057640076, 0.009788513, 0.026046753, 0.07141113, 0.036102295, 0.048431396, -0.04824829, 0.030914307, -0.06021118, 0.0131073, 0.06213379, -0.032714844, -0.019348145, -0.00049877167, 0.029342651, -0.006668091, 0.027954102, 0.038116455, -0.025939941, -0.054504395, 0.028656006, -0.058013916, 0.046783447, -0.019958496, -0.027114868, -0.0067977905, -0.007671356, -0.021606445, 0.06011963, 0.010597229, 0.015045166, -0.036071777, 0.04547119, -0.014839172, -0.021972656, -0.075927734, -0.011436462, 0.09301758, -0.013839722, -0.06738281, -0.019317627, -0.00012981892, 0.014083862, 0.0073776245, 0.02520752, -0.00749588, 0.004459381, 0.0026683807, 0.013877869, 0.08691406, -0.0390625, 0.05404663, -0.0008029938, -0.019302368, 0.028121948, -0.039764404, -0.058013916, -0.08270264, -0.03353882, 0.097351074, -0.020080566, -0.049041748, -0.027755737, 0.0034828186, 0.0055274963, 0.016815186, 0.00095272064, 0.0030994415, -0.017044067, -0.0023212433, -0.010261536, -0.019546509, -0.01637268, -0.0032520294, -0.03414917, 0.0072288513, 0.02508545, -0.003862381, -0.0118255615, 0.028137207, -0.011390686, -0.0010652542, -0.010246277, -0.02279663, -0.03439331, 0.016647339, -0.028625488, 0.029327393, 0.0063095093, 0.009780884, 0.02368164, 0.009284973, 0.01235199, -0.041229248, -0.0070533752, -0.009643555, 0.019592285, -0.007381439, -0.0012741089, 0.013015747, 0.02116394, 0.005710602, 0.00087690353, -0.0259552, 0.0011577606, -0.025436401, -0.026000977, -0.021224976, 0.0007328987, 0.015106201, -0.034576416, 0.03933716, 0.002796173, 0.03161621, -0.006290436, 0.029373169, 0.031585693, 0.0137786865, -0.026794434, 0.0016736984, -0.011306763, -0.040405273, 0.0022506714, -0.025634766, 0.0021457672, -0.006629944, 0.027542114, -0.0053977966, -0.015731812, 0.0077705383, -0.046844482, 0.033813477, 0.0039863586, 0.019836426, 0.01449585, -0.02142334, -0.04498291, -0.0020713806, 0.0026836395, -0.015701294, -0.044006348, -0.02319336, -0.022201538, 0.029907227, -0.04751587, -0.023742676, 0.0021762848, -0.03439331, 0.0021533966, -0.005519867, -0.036132812, -0.029891968, -0.017837524, -0.0362854, -0.013313293, -0.0032196045, 0.030319214, -0.026657104, -0.048339844, 0.015686035, 0.014709473, 0.016967773, 0.03640747, -0.020050049, -0.084350586, 0.014320374, 0.027252197, 0.037139893, 0.04006958, 0.026641846, 0.033721924, 0.034454346, -0.01625061, 0.013381958, 0.021881104, -0.022598267, -0.026947021, -0.03137207, 0.027252197, -0.02293396, 0.0060272217, -0.025497437, -0.037902832, -0.0010900497, -0.0012550354, -0.0031375885, -0.013214111, -0.0028495789, -0.029846191, 0.030838013, -0.037261963, -0.03567505, -0.03074646, -0.026809692, -0.036071777, 0.0101623535, -0.022827148, -0.022872925, 0.052459717, -0.015411377, 0.002746582, -0.0015306473, 0.016082764, -0.0020542145, -0.028396606, 0.04763794, 0.02305603, 0.009002686, -0.013214111, 0.04147339, -0.00070238113, 0.015167236, 0.007724762, -0.013458252, -0.047424316, 0.01927185, -0.01033783, -0.017059326, -0.0132369995, -0.009628296, 0.0033855438, -0.012672424, -0.0357666, -0.03378296, -0.0317688, -0.009544373, -0.09857178, -0.04928589, -0.04800415, 0.032684326, -0.0047302246, -0.035461426, -0.038513184, 0.030059814, -0.009666443, -0.021072388, 0.042419434, -0.060394287, 0.03390503, -0.03100586, 0.008056641, 0.00233078, -0.03527832, -0.030822754, 0.02822876, 0.034423828, -0.00087594986, 0.01828003, 0.034698486, 0.022354126, 0.021011353, -0.006965637, -0.01725769, -0.0703125, 0.05218506, -0.03970337, 0.021484375, -0.009536743, 0.049957275, 0.023239136, 0.0052108765, -0.013717651, 0.0061531067, 0.015365601, 0.011001587, -0.016174316, 0.02331543, 0.018310547, -0.01637268, 0.0041999817, 0.0036239624, -0.009857178, 0.012741089, 0.026504517, 0.028411865, -0.049560547, 0.0029449463, -0.00030493736, 0.015670776, -0.013961792, 0.03970337, -0.021408081, -0.032714844, -0.05706787, -0.029434204, 0.0345459, 0.023330688, 0.014274597, -0.017501831, -0.04562378, 0.033599854, -0.029632568, 0.0680542, -0.049316406, 0.012130737, -0.09008789, 0.026260376, -0.046417236, -0.024978638, 0.022384644, -0.009422302, -0.0038223267, -0.023361206, 0.084472656, 0.004306793, 0.0026359558, 0.013801575, 0.008987427, -0.0019464493, 0.008049011, -0.020004272, -0.025665283, 0.036132812, -0.0039978027, -0.006099701, 0.011962891, 0.010345459, 0.03793335, 0.032073975, 0.04901123, -0.02444458, -0.0158844, -0.03829956, 0.024475098, -0.05783081, -0.012313843, 0.037628174, -0.066467285, 0.04763794, 0.011787415, 0.03604126, -0.03439331, 0.032989502, 0.021240234, -0.013641357, 0.040527344, -0.030410767, 0.016571045, 0.012702942, -0.04071045, -0.022247314, -0.043762207, 0.024536133, -0.007160187, -0.03845215, -0.022613525, -0.0038852692, 0.019683838, 0.038970947, 0.017089844, 0.0211792, -0.060943604, -0.09118652, 0.035949707, 0.0059127808, -0.031311035, -0.017562866, -0.061157227, 0.004722595, -0.025039673, 0.04107666, 0.024505615, 0.0053215027, -0.024978638, 0.008964539, -0.0012464523, 0.002445221, -0.04147339, -0.022277832, 0.0051193237, 0.030044556, -0.031799316, 0.006374359, -0.007785797, 0.011558533, -0.015930176, -0.002193451, -0.0039749146, 0.03439331, 0.049346924, -0.012397766, 0.027908325, 0.01398468, -0.026916504, -0.01399231, 0.055236816, -0.017089844, 0.04135132, 0.019119263, 0.10949707, 0.01676941, -0.066833496, -0.029708862, -0.029769897, 0.028778076, 0.012451172, -0.022857666, -0.010948181, 0.043304443, -0.0028133392, -0.028045654, 0.008163452, 0.025924683, -0.021514893, 0.010253906, 0.028167725, -0.031585693, -0.023498535, 0.012702942, 0.0062942505, -0.0029888153, 0.027359009, -0.03793335, 0.012016296, 0.012565613, 0.0011720657, 0.033691406, -0.02557373, 0.0010328293, -0.009925842, 0.045043945, -0.047943115, 0.018127441, -0.04168701, -0.0053634644, 0.009788513, 0.020980835, 0.03692627, 0.027328491, -0.045928955, -0.0066833496, -0.09667969, 0.01436615, -0.03050232, -0.017364502, 0.030227661, -0.03250122, -0.009979248, -0.012290955, -0.022659302, 0.01524353, 0.010955811, -0.014045715, -0.004219055, 0.015899658, -0.028015137, -0.007873535, 0.008430481 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05792v1
Is a Seat at the Table Enough? Engaging Teachers and Students in Dataset Specification for ML in Education
Mei Tan, Hansol Lee, Dakuo Wang, Hariharan Subramonyam
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
Despite the promises of ML in education, its adoption in the classroom has surfaced numerous issues regarding fairness, accountability, and transparency, as well as concerns about data privacy and student consent. A root cause of these issues is the lack of understanding of the complex dynamics of education, including teacher-student interactions, collaborative learning, and classroom environment. To overcome these challenges and fully utilize the potential of ML in education, software practitioners need to work closely with educators and students to fully understand the context of the data (the backbone of ML applications) and collaboratively define the ML data specifications. To gain a deeper understanding of such a collaborative process, we conduct ten co-design sessions with ML software practitioners, educators, and students. In the sessions, teachers and students work with ML engineers, UX designers, and legal practitioners to define dataset characteristics for a given ML application. We find that stakeholders contextualize data based on their domain and procedural knowledge, proactively design data requirements to mitigate downstream harms and data reliability concerns, and exhibit role-based collaborative strategies and contribution patterns. Further, we find that beyond a seat at the table, meaningful stakeholder participation in ML requires structured supports: defined processes for continuous iteration and co-evaluation, shared contextual data quality standards, and information scaffolds for both technical and non-technical stakeholders to traverse expertise boundaries.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05792v1
2023-11-09T23:51:08
2023-11-09T23:51:08
{ "title": [ 0.00086688995, 0.004386902, -0.032836914, -0.011154175, 0.015838623, -0.029785156, 0.022994995, -0.022537231, -0.045013428, 0.003271103, -0.060302734, 0.016082764, -0.020446777, -0.015655518, -0.010192871, -0.05947876, -0.014587402, 0.024108887, -0.019622803, -0.0256958, 0.0023059845, -0.043640137, 0.01537323, -0.016418457, 0.033294678, -0.009407043, -0.08477783, 0.009422302, -0.045440674, -0.037322998, -0.0053482056, 0.02796936, 0.03289795, -0.00010198355, 0.006717682, 0.018814087, -0.037994385, 0.016555786, -0.020339966, 0.007648468, 0.0022888184, -0.016326904, -0.037597656, -0.022262573, -0.04031372, 0.015808105, -0.07092285, -0.0043640137, -0.009468079, 0.017990112, -0.003534317, 0.021514893, 0.00047039986, 0.021469116, 0.016159058, -0.0030021667, -0.014839172, -0.0134887695, 0.02545166, 0.036712646, 0.022766113, -0.020721436, 0.017654419, -0.0029335022, -0.010063171, -0.026657104, -0.019241333, 0.026443481, 0.07055664, 0.016525269, -0.023147583, 0.03111267, -0.009376526, 0.029449463, -0.048828125, 0.010795593, 0.05996704, 0.026031494, 0.019927979, -0.016525269, -0.003168106, 0.0075950623, -0.0060310364, -0.038513184, 0.030181885, -0.008018494, -0.014671326, -0.008934021, -0.027450562, -0.05657959, -0.008651733, -0.017868042, 0.006702423, 0.004863739, -0.03161621, -0.036499023, -0.01576233, 0.048065186, -0.014129639, -0.014465332, -0.06335449, 0.0635376, -0.10235596, -0.0037593842, 0.020629883, 0.035827637, -0.009262085, -0.030441284, 0.0151901245, 0.021392822, -0.015853882, 0.008125305, 0.009468079, -0.028869629, -0.019927979, -0.0019798279, -0.011207581, -0.006187439, 0.031036377, -0.009117126, -0.0031337738, -0.009994507, -0.004135132, 0.015541077, 0.026947021, 0.020309448, -0.029586792, 0.0041236877, 0.0025234222, 0.036895752, 0.010498047, 0.029708862, -0.11175537, -0.070251465, -0.051849365, 0.03540039, 0.011199951, 0.0033550262, -0.013198853, 0.011947632, 0.02859497, -0.006801605, 0.034942627, 0.00919342, -0.0072402954, 0.00831604, 0.05529785, 0.0025634766, -0.05819702, -0.050872803, -0.0052604675, 0.00094270706, 0.0060653687, -0.00983429, -0.050231934, 0.007217407, -0.12219238, 0.01927185, 0.027389526, 0.032226562, 0.019226074, 0.022460938, 0.01725769, 0.026153564, 0.05834961, -0.024673462, -0.00023424625, 0.023269653, 0.0017299652, -0.0018234253, -0.0015983582, 0.012367249, 0.049682617, -0.030685425, -0.023101807, -0.0021572113, 0.0018901825, -0.015640259, 0.013198853, 0.029922485, 0.01852417, -0.027069092, -0.025268555, 0.04321289, -0.01838684, -0.043060303, -0.000664711, -0.02418518, 0.044921875, 0.007911682, -0.040008545, 0.030761719, -0.02909851, -0.05038452, -0.038879395, -0.03857422, 0.04119873, 0.002084732, 0.0015239716, 0.03161621, -0.039886475, 0.022735596, -0.04800415, 0.026870728, -0.015731812, -0.021331787, -0.0070266724, 0.0390625, -0.038360596, 0.051361084, 0.05984497, 0.025527954, -0.043670654, 0.023803711, 0.015106201, -0.06573486, 0.01637268, -0.03744507, -0.020904541, -0.0357666, -0.00831604, -0.0079574585, -0.005794525, 0.049438477, -0.032287598, 0.019821167, 0.002702713, 0.0032482147, 0.043640137, 0.023803711, 0.12548828, -0.06549072, 0.048431396, 0.043823242, -0.0006432533, 0.007133484, 0.023147583, -0.032806396, -0.00054073334, 0.0009293556, 0.009773254, -0.03945923, -0.0067749023, 0.0049362183, 0.0141067505, -0.0046653748, 0.023849487, -0.016693115, -0.0049476624, -0.0018072128, 0.081604004, 0.007736206, 0.044708252, 0.006931305, -0.023376465, 0.042510986, -0.008735657, -0.00050354004, -0.006439209, -0.0011644363, 0.004562378, 0.05999756, 0.023223877, 0.019851685, -0.06695557, 0.014381409, -0.035064697, 0.0082473755, 0.017074585, 0.007598877, 0.017547607, -0.03390503, 0.010009766, 0.006717682, -0.04888916, 0.016998291, -0.0023403168, 0.032196045, 0.00033974648, -0.03930664, 0.0072898865, 0.0020008087, 0.050079346, -0.0019683838, 0.037750244, 0.024032593, 0.018005371, -0.022827148, -0.016555786, -0.011993408, 0.042816162, 0.002084732, 0.0026340485, -0.023513794, 0.027709961, -0.01159668, 0.11187744, 0.087402344, -0.038635254, 0.024520874, -0.06329346, 0.0064086914, 0.01058197, -0.00969696, 0.0231781, 0.012611389, 0.01121521, -0.0040664673, -0.014709473, 0.008224487, -0.0073394775, 0.04837036, 0.007007599, 0.0068244934, -0.028411865, -0.050567627, 0.0036373138, -0.017700195, -0.03817749, -0.010261536, 0.07873535, -0.023849487, -0.018753052, -0.02104187, -0.015449524, -0.019165039, -0.014038086, -0.043121338, 0.0038394928, 0.02293396, 0.059387207, 0.035736084, -0.045074463, -0.02571106, 0.010093689, 0.024841309, -0.008834839, -0.0031814575, -0.025222778, 0.021087646, -0.00920105, -0.040039062, 0.016464233, -0.047576904, -0.01108551, -0.04071045, 0.008277893, -0.004005432, 0.027694702, 0.014144897, -0.0019273758, 0.013519287, -0.0056877136, -0.021438599, 0.031585693, 0.007007599, -0.018463135, -0.0046157837, 0.013877869, -0.040222168, 0.062927246, 0.007499695, 0.016525269, -0.0395813, -0.018356323, -0.036132812, -0.008392334, -0.029876709, -0.029525757, 0.0234375, -0.021728516, -0.034240723, -0.036895752, -0.014862061, -0.011306763, 0.009468079, -0.024139404, -0.035705566, -0.016738892, -0.026626587, 0.009025574, -0.005958557, 0.007858276, 0.003660202, 0.058288574, -0.0050621033, 0.002084732, 0.044555664, 0.015808105, -0.007423401, -0.009719849, 0.0018100739, -0.0035076141, -0.0032444, 0.009925842, 0.020965576, -0.035858154, -0.0067749023, -0.07080078, 0.0077552795, 0.075805664, -0.012283325, -0.03149414, 0.027282715, -0.06536865, 0.005580902, 0.028747559, -0.005016327, 0.02078247, 0.022262573, -0.015533447, 0.012161255, 0.005039215, -0.031158447, 0.014038086, -0.040527344, -0.098083496, 0.032592773, -0.054748535, -0.012550354, 0.04449463, -0.04547119, -0.044311523, -0.029052734, 0.014877319, 0.054016113, 0.058685303, 0.007194519, 0.032592773, -0.038757324, 0.033203125, -0.04953003, -0.01789856, -0.03591919, -0.023010254, -0.0010032654, -0.005844116, 0.0413208, 0.00055933, 0.0033302307, -0.026626587, 0.0060424805, 0.015975952, 0.04711914, -0.00076150894, -0.022888184, 0.0025863647, -0.01939392, -0.0035572052, 0.022445679, -0.0031814575, -0.0012922287, -0.023330688, -0.0007677078, -0.026321411, -0.0065994263, 0.010414124, 0.030441284, -0.025604248, -0.008529663, 0.034973145, -0.026153564, -0.038513184, 0.025665283, 0.03579712, -0.009887695, 0.0635376, 0.0021781921, -0.033477783, 0.036956787, 0.009613037, -0.03692627, -0.000895977, 0.014221191, 0.0077705383, 0.0287323, -0.038513184, 0.027999878, -0.06585693, 0.028076172, -0.015525818, 0.017532349, -0.02798462, -0.07055664, -0.040618896, 0.021087646, -0.11187744, -0.061523438, 0.029251099, -0.037231445, -0.022628784, -0.04928589, 0.022979736, -0.022720337, -0.007911682, 0.012573242, -0.018218994, 0.036376953, 0.01737976, -0.058044434, -0.01335144, 0.083984375, 0.0036888123, 0.009414673, 0.06628418, 0.015716553, 0.013244629, -0.018936157, 0.0014619827, 0.03491211, 0.015235901, -0.013748169, -0.010437012, 0.028564453, -0.031585693, 0.024307251, 0.005970001, -0.0035057068, -0.01977539, 0.013313293, 0.030288696, 0.023468018, -0.023605347, 0.03387451, 0.033599854, -0.006286621, -0.05859375, 0.0021533966, 0.006259918, -0.010314941, 0.030960083, 0.00025558472, 0.04208374, 0.027160645, -0.026321411, 0.03869629, -0.008262634, -0.038879395, -0.017410278, 0.009170532, -0.016952515, -0.003698349, 0.013328552, 0.023483276, -0.0030345917, 0.04876709, -0.011016846, 0.04800415, -0.050445557, -0.010574341, 0.0057754517, 0.03768921, -0.04272461, -0.017303467, -0.06744385, -0.04550171, -0.051818848, 0.039154053, 0.020202637, 0.014038086, 0.018585205, 0.00995636, -0.046966553, 0.01574707, 0.011047363, 0.0132369995, -0.005306244, -0.037017822, 0.0007452965, -0.006439209, -0.08062744, -0.033813477, -0.01864624, -0.00617218, 0.028900146, -0.00035500526, -0.032958984, 0.018966675, -0.00015723705, 0.034576416, 0.032806396, 0.00095415115, -0.024719238, 0.044281006, -0.0158844, -0.0062026978, -0.0009112358, 0.029968262, -0.016342163, -0.032989502, -0.026519775, 0.006187439, 0.012329102, -0.029724121, 0.009811401, -0.016708374, 0.007675171, -0.03543091, 0.011161804, 0.009742737, -0.010482788, 0.0019416809, 0.00023460388, -0.04736328, 0.024108887, -0.00844574, 0.02027893, -0.022949219, 0.024230957, 0.047180176, 0.0054130554, 0.024032593, -0.02758789, 0.003326416, 0.0032844543, -0.014823914, 0.032989502, -0.016021729, -0.035705566, -0.040283203, -0.012176514, 0.019973755, 0.036895752, -0.056274414, 0.037506104, -0.016403198, 0.027404785, 0.028060913, -0.008674622, 0.030456543, 0.016189575, 0.015563965, -0.03314209, -0.059051514, -0.007621765, 0.051727295, -0.024261475, -0.009895325, -0.007385254, 0.016601562, -0.000027894974, 0.053710938, 0.036956787, -0.024475098, 0.03540039, -0.013504028, -0.013938904, -0.012374878, -0.022491455, -0.0075912476, -0.04425049, 0.011222839, -0.03704834, 0.016586304, -0.015533447, -0.009307861, 0.0044937134, -0.011230469, 0.008033752, -0.062194824, 0.033966064, 0.06100464, -0.03125, 0.035827637, -0.022033691, 0.025436401, 0.041992188, 0.036193848, 0.00762558, -0.0069847107, 0.030075073, -0.017608643, -0.017074585, -0.014045715, 0.04360962, 0.032226562, 0.019500732, 0.025314331, 0.013137817, -0.06137085, 0.044158936, 0.017303467, -0.052856445, 0.0038719177, -0.023208618, 0.019317627, -0.020080566, 0.014709473, 0.0032043457, -0.05206299, -0.018829346, 0.02482605, -0.03479004, 0.012779236, 0.034118652, 0.002796173, -0.043914795, -0.058929443, 0.0049552917, -0.0052871704, 0.0034332275, -0.012176514, 0.02331543, -0.044708252, 0.0289917, 0.008674622, -0.03479004, -0.013763428, 0.0099105835, -0.0028705597, 0.03262329, 0.019165039, -0.051849365, -0.006465912, 0.009109497, -0.053771973, -0.04336548, -0.004272461, -0.013793945, 0.00001513958, -0.008674622, -0.02268982, -0.01260376, -0.02003479, 0.010955811, 0.013763428, -0.043518066, 0.021240234, -0.003648758, 0.006126404, -0.007106781, 0.019546509, 0.012512207, -0.008979797, 0.000119030476, -0.014350891, 0.012825012, -0.022079468, 0.003068924, -0.02986145, -0.07342529, 0.0076522827, 0.011558533, 0.005256653, 0.0039596558, 0.034423828, 0.025268555, 0.08850098, 0.0025424957, 0.0075416565, 0.06945801, -0.027908325, -0.028427124, -0.020462036, 0.0118255615, -0.0158844, 0.06365967, -0.008995056, -0.0184021, -0.035186768, -0.039215088, -0.033996582, 0.0073623657, 0.025726318, 0.01638794, 0.0413208, -0.016357422, -0.0053482056, -0.051727295, -0.015281677, -0.046539307, 0.03555298, -0.031707764, -0.032958984, 0.046325684, -0.019744873, -0.0060920715, -0.026535034, 0.044708252, 0.029663086, -0.008102417, 0.023742676, -0.04989624, 0.0023822784, -0.044830322, -0.00944519, 0.03955078, 0.037261963, -0.055541992, 0.034729004, -0.0231781, 0.0670166, 0.005924225, 0.037902832, 0.020095825, -0.0037441254, 0.008575439, 0.0040512085, -0.007797241, -0.034332275, 0.011917114, -0.05218506, -0.016540527, -0.068115234, -0.015914917, -0.08325195, -0.014549255, 0.004676819, 0.004814148, 0.031173706, -0.00010329485, -0.002002716, 0.012908936, 0.023208618, 0.048553467, 0.04989624, -0.07470703, -0.031402588, 0.022537231, 0.009643555, 0.025802612, 0.036499023, -0.008659363, 0.01902771, -0.042388916, 0.008110046, -0.011886597, -0.0013237, -0.0059890747, -0.038269043, 0.011779785, -0.032226562, 0.02909851, -0.024337769, 0.0034942627, 0.076660156, 0.052490234, 0.0009331703, -0.04269409, 0.017303467, 0.007270813, 0.0124053955, -0.021560669, 0.024749756, -0.023513794, 0.012702942, -0.018127441, -0.03756714, 0.010261536, 0.044677734, 0.030822754, -0.05596924, -0.005138397, 0.013130188, 0.021453857, 0.0003182888, 0.0048980713, -0.023010254, -0.007949829, 0.043640137, 0.015655518, -0.0040397644, 0.05630493, 0.05255127, 0.02255249, -0.020523071, -0.04385376, 0.019958496, -0.010787964, 0.010299683, 0.030776978, -0.011100769, 0.064208984, -0.025604248, -0.03668213, 0.009246826, -0.0032672882, -0.081848145, 0.0050315857, 0.0072784424, 0.057647705, 0.06677246, 0.091674805, 0.020187378, -0.005428314, 0.035064697, -0.031829834, 0.020858765, 0.038391113, -0.0309906, 0.03277588, -0.032226562, -0.047027588, 0.03652954, -0.059539795, 0.03793335, -0.026184082, 0.023117065, -0.029144287, 0.031677246, 0.009895325, -0.054138184, -0.0060691833, -0.0068359375, -0.031280518, 0.016677856, 0.06451416, -0.011146545, -0.0138549805, 0.008003235, -0.006881714, 0.0024089813, 0.02368164, 0.027160645, -0.036987305, -0.0501709, 0.044036865, 0.015960693, 0.07318115, -0.01576233, -0.0058517456, 0.0152282715, 0.005558014, 0.00894928, -0.0016441345, -0.04144287, 0.024719238, 0.01600647, -0.021957397, 0.012214661, 0.023391724, -0.021331787, -0.060943604, -0.010147095, -0.010665894, -0.02734375, 0.042633057, 0.050964355, -0.052490234, -0.018630981, 0.022842407, -0.029449463, 0.06402588, 0.012145996, 0.012901306, 0.0044136047, 0.021469116, -0.0090789795, -0.039489746, 0.01966858, 0.031463623, 0.0155181885, -0.018203735, -0.033447266, 0.026947021, 0.017654419, -0.07733154, -0.090026855, 0.0062217712, 0.056121826, 0.01965332, 0.040863037, -0.015686035, 0.002861023, 0.014694214, 0.032104492, 0.009994507, -0.03314209, -0.021835327, -0.025344849, 0.038635254, 0.04269409, -0.013679504, -0.002620697, 0.027954102, 0.011184692, 0.0034370422, 0.012886047, 0.014404297, -0.0022850037, 0.005039215, 0.030883789, -0.01914978, -0.034210205, -0.05419922, 0.00082445145, 0.0032634735, 0.0001988411, -0.016921997, 0.033203125, -0.035003662, 0.041931152, -0.021514893, -0.042816162, 0.03842163, 0.043060303, 0.009094238, 0.059051514, -0.02166748, -0.023971558, -0.023788452, -0.0033626556, 0.00030469894, -0.004108429, 0.020996094, -0.028671265, 0.013786316, -0.052581787, -0.038391113, -0.007709503, -0.028625488, 0.04510498, -0.034576416, -0.0104599, -0.02583313, -0.014717102, 0.017120361, 0.010856628, 0.021408081, -0.014389038, -0.037261963, -0.024765015, 0.0143585205, -0.005882263 ], "summary": [ 0.0013875961, -0.028701782, -0.0077705383, 0.0013179779, -0.025436401, -0.016433716, 0.015655518, -0.008369446, -0.030700684, 0.015068054, -0.039916992, 0.026901245, -0.016418457, -0.015701294, 0.026977539, -0.04800415, -0.026367188, 0.05682373, 0.028747559, -0.0059432983, 0.007411957, -0.025680542, -0.023849487, -0.09088135, 0.018112183, -0.0143585205, -0.105651855, 0.026733398, -0.005138397, 0.023590088, 0.012039185, -0.0004351139, 0.00680542, 0.015594482, -0.0014133453, 0.00920105, 0.005882263, -0.006919861, -0.0025043488, 0.03555298, 0.048187256, -0.020370483, 0.06500244, -0.022842407, -0.005420685, 0.029220581, 0.01890564, 0.004425049, 0.005836487, 0.014732361, -0.018295288, 0.031829834, -0.020935059, -0.020812988, 0.015930176, 0.02885437, -0.004131317, -0.008270264, 0.0021076202, 0.029922485, 0.015563965, 0.025100708, 0.004436493, 0.0022850037, 0.0016536713, 0.01373291, -0.016693115, 0.016342163, 0.066833496, 0.029708862, -0.019546509, 0.009605408, -0.007801056, -0.02420044, 0.032562256, 0.04107666, 0.014533997, 0.032592773, -0.0029277802, 0.009681702, 0.01663208, 0.035125732, -0.020629883, -0.051971436, -0.010238647, -0.036254883, 0.0059661865, -0.0053520203, -0.00349617, -0.0155181885, -0.018234253, 0.022659302, 0.017349243, -0.003036499, -0.028549194, 0.0073051453, -0.0029792786, 0.030166626, 0.0038375854, -0.011291504, -0.028762817, 0.014038086, -0.06866455, -0.003145218, 0.0014019012, 0.053009033, -0.015083313, -0.028152466, 0.012748718, 0.025924683, 0.012619019, -0.05517578, 0.010635376, -0.0826416, -0.008384705, 0.05206299, 0.035125732, -0.0030536652, 0.0284729, -0.05630493, -0.034942627, 0.00422287, -0.008255005, 0.018218994, 0.028961182, 0.016555786, 0.010360718, 0.0019359589, 0.0009813309, 0.024902344, -0.014305115, 0.015777588, -0.048583984, -0.011001587, -0.029434204, -0.019210815, 0.014091492, 0.015823364, -0.007511139, -0.016342163, 0.020767212, 0.036590576, 0.039154053, -0.019943237, 0.007411957, 0.024795532, 0.0418396, 0.0115356445, -0.025512695, -0.036010742, 0.02079773, -0.00737381, 0.016677856, -0.014022827, -0.0076065063, -0.037384033, -0.086364746, 0.032226562, 0.038146973, 0.03491211, 0.012634277, 0.0076179504, 0.04660034, 0.058288574, 0.055023193, -0.0107803345, 0.00086545944, -0.006252289, 0.0042037964, -0.05368042, 0.011528015, 0.028060913, 0.014549255, -0.007080078, 0.020385742, -0.006175995, 0.017547607, 0.015022278, -0.0043411255, 0.047973633, 0.029449463, -0.014083862, 0.01991272, 0.006248474, 0.0065193176, -0.0072517395, -0.0003170967, -0.008613586, 0.018096924, 0.00856781, -0.020111084, 0.024978638, -0.0014810562, 0.00049448013, -0.013755798, -0.050872803, 0.013031006, -0.011932373, 0.000093877316, -0.009651184, -0.011856079, 0.044189453, -0.027069092, -0.0012254715, -0.032806396, 0.020095825, -0.01007843, 0.05734253, -0.028793335, 0.039978027, 0.025680542, 0.0057029724, -0.047973633, 0.064208984, 0.04849243, -0.03363037, 0.006450653, -0.041137695, -0.004070282, -0.031219482, 0.0028190613, 0.014305115, -0.03164673, 0.022766113, -0.070739746, 0.031555176, -0.02319336, 0.04156494, 0.01763916, 0.0056991577, 0.13049316, -0.054870605, 0.020858765, 0.04736328, 0.02166748, 0.0040893555, 0.020141602, -0.092163086, 0.0098724365, 0.016174316, 0.030197144, -0.012634277, -0.026733398, -0.018936157, -0.026016235, -0.04699707, 0.009178162, -0.009986877, -0.011932373, 0.012245178, 0.05340576, -0.007659912, 0.0234375, 0.0345459, -0.042633057, 0.022460938, -0.016281128, -0.00724411, 0.024414062, -0.0418396, 0.006340027, -0.015701294, -0.0033397675, -0.004924774, -0.07147217, -0.047546387, -0.037353516, -0.022506714, 0.04043579, -0.050720215, 0.010475159, -0.036132812, -0.0059051514, -0.0032958984, -0.06262207, 0.014007568, -0.007194519, 0.025054932, -0.031158447, -0.020385742, 0.011054993, 0.025268555, 0.03173828, -0.0074043274, 0.045959473, 0.048614502, 0.009475708, 0.0020256042, 0.05456543, 0.033599854, 0.030883789, 0.008911133, -0.0084991455, 0.03967285, 0.024215698, -0.027175903, 0.07824707, 0.029296875, -0.011795044, -0.008285522, -0.00566864, 0.018173218, -0.03527832, -0.0039367676, -0.007507324, -0.018707275, 0.005531311, -0.016815186, -0.0013961792, -0.025894165, 0.024749756, 0.06964111, 0.016708374, 0.056640625, -0.034362793, -0.042236328, 0.0024318695, 0.041809082, -0.019546509, 0.009628296, 0.11682129, -0.010650635, -0.012939453, -0.006072998, -0.013290405, -0.049743652, 0.01914978, -0.043884277, -0.015930176, -0.030426025, -0.009918213, -0.018569946, -0.007896423, 0.019546509, -0.0010356903, -0.0030994415, -0.0056114197, -0.029541016, -0.014305115, -0.0069770813, -0.0043296814, -0.029800415, 0.017486572, -0.041534424, -0.031707764, 0.011947632, 0.0075416565, -0.0040359497, -0.0031604767, -0.0109939575, 0.018951416, 0.010406494, 0.0007109642, -0.015167236, 0.0014858246, 0.04135132, -0.008598328, -0.026611328, -0.009346008, -0.06677246, 0.052490234, 0.009490967, -0.0027427673, -0.087768555, -0.0062408447, -0.015548706, 0.013420105, -0.058807373, -0.021865845, 0.015548706, -0.0019893646, -0.026748657, -0.0033359528, -0.008422852, -0.025024414, 0.04067993, 0.03250122, -0.012199402, 0.008178711, 0.009765625, 0.043518066, 0.004432678, 0.028945923, -0.02168274, 0.06695557, -0.012107849, 0.015914917, 0.044128418, 0.038024902, 0.0058670044, -0.015930176, -0.03604126, 0.06750488, -0.015960693, 0.004688263, -0.014717102, -0.01033783, 0.030258179, -0.039398193, -0.006454468, 0.07800293, 0.004501343, 0.015182495, 0.006603241, -0.020553589, 0.012748718, 0.027053833, 0.011932373, 0.03161621, -0.0007863045, -0.0038089752, -0.0015325546, 0.015274048, -0.053222656, 0.0062026978, -0.023712158, -0.06536865, 0.017715454, -0.089904785, 0.039276123, 0.037384033, 0.019195557, -0.028579712, -0.016342163, -0.0061950684, 0.039978027, 0.0181427, 0.028900146, -0.010604858, -0.007259369, 0.017196655, -0.040618896, -0.003408432, 0.02305603, -0.060791016, -0.021392822, -0.005405426, -0.064453125, 0.051879883, -0.07800293, -0.0029735565, 0.025039673, 0.031799316, 0.023025513, 0.0024166107, 0.0051841736, 0.04248047, -0.018234253, 0.0126953125, 0.045654297, -0.0110321045, -0.017486572, 0.0022621155, 0.03918457, -0.02357483, 0.003982544, -0.005378723, 0.030380249, -0.0023097992, -0.0045394897, 0.030380249, -0.010665894, -0.036865234, 0.011550903, 0.003929138, 0.042877197, 0.0011844635, 0.014823914, -0.05441284, 0.030029297, 0.035247803, -0.06512451, -0.07281494, -0.01638794, 0.040649414, 0.015312195, -0.023239136, 0.006286621, 0.006252289, 0.012832642, -0.049804688, 0.039489746, -0.06451416, -0.06561279, -0.029373169, 0.0007610321, -0.06970215, -0.07196045, 0.005241394, -0.019973755, -0.06121826, -0.01966858, 0.014823914, -0.030090332, -0.003162384, 0.03842163, -0.029434204, 0.10296631, 0.041015625, -0.025741577, -0.0017271042, -0.0028247833, 0.030456543, -0.010482788, 0.0061950684, 0.041107178, 0.06573486, -0.026062012, -0.00806427, -0.018127441, 0.046081543, -0.060302734, 0.016494751, -0.010040283, -0.015396118, 0.026428223, -0.004047394, -0.050720215, -0.0006456375, 0.01474762, 0.05444336, 0.06561279, -0.048950195, -0.013839722, 0.047332764, -0.0015363693, -0.036743164, 0.021865845, 0.008422852, 0.024169922, 0.021591187, 0.022323608, -0.0026130676, -0.017486572, -0.0031814575, -0.054870605, -0.02154541, -0.083618164, -0.074279785, 0.014221191, -0.012687683, 0.0022029877, 0.015792847, 0.04244995, -0.021957397, 0.010215759, -0.052642822, 0.021118164, -0.01058197, -0.009857178, 0.005634308, 0.0057525635, 0.009010315, 0.006866455, -0.010871887, 0.0020141602, -0.06222534, 0.03262329, 0.0014772415, 0.043273926, -0.009849548, 0.007385254, -0.023620605, 0.010070801, 0.044677734, 0.01108551, 0.010894775, -0.034118652, -0.022964478, -0.028244019, -0.047668457, 0.0008854866, -0.048553467, -0.031707764, -0.027572632, 0.015129089, -0.033569336, 0.044158936, -0.05392456, -0.0007266998, 0.009529114, 0.005874634, -0.0025482178, 0.055480957, 0.002035141, 0.005580902, -0.004634857, 0.021484375, -0.01777649, -0.02746582, -0.02935791, 0.007873535, -0.0059127808, -0.032989502, -0.004585266, 0.017105103, -0.0657959, -0.0031604767, 0.043121338, 0.013343811, 0.020706177, -0.019927979, -0.0014295578, -0.011940002, 0.040374756, -0.03604126, 0.016357422, 0.01965332, -0.005874634, -0.004421234, -0.0074157715, 0.017715454, -0.018447876, 0.012390137, -0.03149414, -0.010543823, 0.04953003, -0.022613525, 0.006088257, -0.032196045, 0.014297485, 0.027267456, 0.016479492, 0.039978027, 0.022918701, -0.03857422, -0.007003784, 0.010505676, 0.0024776459, 0.024353027, 0.01033783, 0.0146865845, -0.027328491, -0.01777649, -0.0074005127, 0.027618408, -0.025161743, -0.027145386, -0.02720642, -0.005340576, 0.006111145, 0.032684326, 0.03616333, -0.034973145, 0.03491211, -0.0021038055, -0.0051612854, -0.0016498566, -0.012588501, -0.013206482, -0.05178833, 0.0010519028, -0.0154418945, -0.0037994385, 0.034301758, -0.019882202, 0.025024414, 0.0027389526, -0.028457642, -0.05203247, -0.03125, -0.03515625, -0.031677246, -0.009712219, -0.0020656586, -0.020614624, 0.00090646744, 0.022613525, -0.031707764, -0.0038547516, -0.004142761, -0.05505371, -0.0044059753, 0.008239746, 0.008705139, 0.028656006, -0.026046753, -0.0060424805, -0.04458618, 0.031280518, 0.017089844, 0.011062622, -0.024887085, -0.038909912, 0.0178833, 0.052947998, -0.01826477, 0.005722046, -0.014251709, -0.052490234, 0.0049591064, 0.023651123, -0.033691406, 0.010513306, 0.06530762, 0.020492554, -0.014587402, -0.056915283, -0.029312134, -0.009353638, 0.020263672, -0.03062439, 0.027404785, -0.041778564, -0.016433716, -0.0053710938, 0.022918701, 0.00063705444, 0.014266968, 0.0061454773, -0.015289307, 0.012145996, -0.0075569153, 0.0074806213, -0.011047363, -0.015342712, -0.029891968, -0.040374756, -0.027709961, 0.05557251, -0.018234253, 0.024261475, -0.019104004, -0.053894043, 0.01586914, -0.0149383545, -0.04824829, -0.0013856888, 0.00087594986, -0.008384705, -0.026824951, 0.025375366, -0.03012085, -0.009635925, 0.016189575, 0.031829834, 0.0013990402, -0.044433594, -0.049682617, -0.017807007, -0.020523071, 0.004310608, 0.00793457, -0.006717682, 0.003282547, -0.016845703, -0.010856628, 0.0859375, -0.0073928833, -0.011909485, 0.044799805, 0.006515503, -0.029922485, -0.033447266, 0.014541626, -0.015174866, 0.041748047, -0.025512695, -0.03567505, -0.0020484924, -0.011512756, 0.01133728, -0.025848389, -0.021575928, 0.0022888184, -0.004722595, 0.008102417, -0.0030460358, 0.0029125214, -0.01626587, -0.037078857, -0.009498596, -0.042877197, -0.027938843, 0.10473633, 0.013153076, -0.022903442, -0.022460938, 0.016998291, 0.0025138855, 0.010444641, 0.002626419, 0.04598999, 0.016464233, -0.041046143, 0.04446411, -0.008132935, 0.075683594, -0.06463623, -0.022994995, 0.021011353, 0.051879883, 0.011917114, -0.040496826, -0.045013428, -0.054260254, 0.015808105, -0.011314392, -0.077941895, -0.023162842, 0.04257202, -0.016540527, -0.050842285, -0.05545044, -0.056610107, -0.011413574, 0.012130737, -0.014656067, -0.009109497, 0.04284668, 0.0073013306, -0.015434265, 0.053985596, -0.07312012, 0.06970215, -0.013893127, -0.076660156, -0.049621582, 0.020019531, 0.01663208, 0.008666992, 0.039733887, -0.0041389465, 0.0047950745, -0.046203613, 0.008178711, 0.014053345, -0.015434265, -0.024871826, -0.042175293, 0.04043579, -0.036834717, 0.03253174, 0.014854431, 0.03778076, 0.032104492, -0.00030350685, 0.03744507, -0.039215088, 0.019134521, 0.011512756, -0.0035743713, 0.0021476746, -0.02128601, 0.02583313, -0.020187378, 0.0005636215, -0.0059165955, 0.048095703, -0.015563965, 0.08496094, -0.074645996, -0.04559326, 0.027374268, 0.023071289, -0.049041748, -0.006111145, -0.0066871643, -0.0054512024, 0.0206604, -0.01689148, 0.026138306, 0.02848816, -0.007881165, 0.0023403168, 0.020858765, 0.006439209, 0.013053894, 0.031707764, 0.023910522, 0.029586792, -0.018218994, 0.008613586, -0.020965576, -0.01234436, 0.009559631, 0.016036987, -0.033447266, 0.044891357, 0.022399902, 0.1005249, 0.079589844, 0.09680176, -0.022583008, 0.02041626, 0.09283447, 0.0028743744, 0.024215698, 0.023483276, -0.011230469, 0.019210815, -0.021072388, 0.0072746277, -0.0012769699, -0.026809692, -0.0340271, -0.014137268, 0.044799805, -0.008842468, -0.010887146, -0.01625061, -0.004852295, 0.01386261, 0.012268066, -0.036621094, 0.015960693, 0.039215088, -0.015068054, 0.015403748, -0.021575928, -0.03668213, -0.01739502, 0.01309967, 0.023651123, -0.018249512, -0.018997192, 0.05947876, 0.024658203, 0.093933105, -0.008102417, -0.039398193, 0.0013999939, 0.020263672, 0.03112793, -0.01852417, -0.037628174, 0.028274536, 0.034210205, 0.009963989, 0.024734497, 0.050994873, -0.014595032, -0.10095215, 0.013244629, -0.024765015, -0.04727173, 0.054382324, 0.0058898926, -0.02748108, 0.00907135, 0.031829834, -0.010635376, 0.004600525, -0.024993896, 0.018035889, -0.026031494, 0.048461914, -0.0043907166, -0.06149292, -0.007709503, -0.02508545, -0.010574341, -0.020217896, -0.034362793, 0.0041007996, 0.0066833496, -0.04522705, -0.07928467, 0.018173218, 0.04043579, 0.038391113, 0.0005893707, -0.04119873, -0.0141067505, 0.007030487, 0.039367676, -0.000010073185, 0.0034751892, 0.035369873, 0.010017395, 0.004108429, 0.03845215, -0.013664246, 0.023254395, 0.02079773, 0.013809204, -0.008369446, 0.006122589, 0.024505615, -0.02420044, 0.013114929, 0.033111572, -0.029083252, -0.03677368, -0.034454346, -0.031585693, 0.009651184, -0.009605408, -0.02067566, 0.01776123, -0.053131104, 0.019134521, -0.0036449432, -0.017974854, -0.031173706, 0.019805908, -0.013748169, 0.04083252, -0.024642944, -0.038635254, -0.025466919, 0.018966675, 0.018325806, 0.019165039, 0.0017538071, -0.015731812, 0.027130127, -0.0657959, -0.011306763, -0.064086914, -0.014144897, 0.013870239, -0.006038666, -0.01285553, 0.03866577, -0.011688232, 0.02357483, -0.020507812, -0.014595032, 0.022247314, -0.015731812, -0.010353088, -0.053833008, 0.002866745 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06101v1
In-Context Learning for MIMO Equalization Using Transformer-Based Sequence Models
Matteo Zecchin, Kai Yu, Osvaldo Simeone
cs.IT, cs.AI, cs.LG, math.IT
Large pre-trained sequence models, such as transformer-based architectures, have been recently shown to have the capacity to carry out in-context learning (ICL). In ICL, a decision on a new input is made via a direct mapping of the input and of a few examples from the given task, serving as the task's context, to the output variable. No explicit updates of model parameters are needed to tailor the decision to a new task. Pre-training, which amounts to a form of meta-learning, is based on the observation of examples from several related tasks. Prior work has shown ICL capabilities for linear regression. In this study, we leverage ICL to address the inverse problem of multiple-input and multiple-output (MIMO) equalization based on a context given by pilot symbols. A task is defined by the unknown fading channel and by the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) level, which may be known. To highlight the practical potential of the approach, we allow for the presence of quantization of the received signals. We demonstrate via numerical results that transformer-based ICL has a threshold behavior, whereby, as the number of pre-training tasks grows, the performance switches from that of a minimum mean squared error (MMSE) equalizer with a prior determined by the pre-trained tasks to that of an MMSE equalizer with the true data-generating prior.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06101v1
2023-11-10T15:09:04
2023-11-10T15:09:04
{ "title": [ -0.0012407303, 0.021514893, -0.018035889, 0.0070343018, 0.013267517, -0.01625061, 0.020431519, -0.04837036, 0.0096206665, 0.07611084, -0.03479004, 0.008575439, 0.060394287, -0.012763977, -0.034820557, 0.016738892, 0.012489319, 0.033966064, 0.0006570816, -0.030883789, 0.044921875, -0.018615723, -0.02519226, 0.08905029, -0.0178833, -0.015838623, -0.05609131, 0.034057617, -0.032226562, -0.039031982, -0.016571045, 0.019332886, 0.031158447, -0.0184021, 0.030563354, -0.042388916, -0.050598145, 0.026763916, 0.00012105703, -0.017974854, 0.039886475, -0.032318115, -0.011512756, -0.03793335, -0.01423645, 0.016860962, 0.005619049, -0.0013923645, -0.019851685, 0.060302734, 0.0060577393, 0.0067596436, -0.00894928, 0.06982422, 0.012863159, -0.06222534, -0.031982422, 0.018859863, 0.018966675, 0.08874512, 0.038330078, 0.011299133, -0.015808105, -0.05368042, 0.007881165, -0.021377563, 0.0030593872, 0.018249512, 0.037109375, 0.013671875, 0.0015077591, -0.00016367435, 0.017456055, -0.0035324097, -0.07623291, 0.010215759, 0.07098389, 0.027709961, 0.021072388, -0.07965088, 0.03845215, 0.04675293, 0.039276123, -0.055877686, 0.045532227, -0.02949524, -0.006542206, -0.018005371, -0.035827637, -0.04260254, -0.026245117, 0.0129470825, -0.012397766, -0.014854431, -0.035827637, -0.03189087, 0.006034851, 0.03643799, 0.008331299, -0.00932312, -0.043701172, 0.004966736, -0.03704834, -0.03451538, -0.004562378, -0.03125, -0.0061683655, -0.006614685, 0.018493652, 0.023742676, -0.06225586, 0.021087646, 0.019348145, -0.01309967, -0.0068130493, -0.00049877167, 0.0075798035, 0.0028209686, 0.020614624, -0.016098022, 0.009895325, -0.014602661, 0.033172607, -0.010253906, 0.047973633, 0.0027656555, -0.018814087, -0.038238525, -0.019714355, 0.029281616, -0.0024967194, 0.036224365, -0.06921387, -0.04888916, -0.057922363, 0.029159546, 0.015853882, -0.007888794, -0.016082764, -0.02748108, 0.013458252, -0.0018968582, 0.0072784424, -0.026733398, 0.021469116, 0.028869629, 0.051208496, -0.012077332, -0.05014038, -0.03387451, -0.018554688, 0.068481445, 0.017486572, -0.015792847, 0.0031433105, -0.03540039, -0.055847168, -0.031677246, 0.030166626, -0.0054359436, 0.03805542, 0.0021743774, -0.021469116, 0.064819336, 0.027709961, -0.012611389, 0.03488159, 0.02645874, 0.0012016296, 0.028167725, -0.021835327, 0.013916016, 0.0151901245, 0.0022010803, 0.0035858154, 0.015625, -0.0060539246, -0.0051193237, 0.029769897, -0.026275635, 0.010116577, -0.016311646, -0.023239136, 0.03527832, -0.033081055, -0.004962921, -0.0107040405, 0.029525757, 0.048858643, 0.004497528, -0.053131104, 0.0011081696, -0.05227661, -0.024032593, -0.039611816, 0.014266968, 0.020553589, 0.037475586, -0.0064468384, 0.0075302124, -0.00995636, 0.022720337, -0.034851074, 0.018127441, -0.02444458, -0.042877197, 0.009269714, 0.010612488, 0.0049705505, 0.034118652, 0.016799927, -0.03945923, 0.017059326, -0.024856567, -0.020111084, -0.03567505, 0.038635254, -0.022766113, -0.0143585205, -0.045806885, -0.021743774, -0.01838684, -0.026397705, 0.053863525, -0.0158844, -0.010848999, 0.0055236816, -0.007698059, 0.03555298, -0.004562378, 0.10455322, -0.046691895, 0.0019159317, 0.038970947, -0.0064964294, -0.024215698, -0.0446167, -0.03970337, 0.033325195, 0.012084961, 0.016143799, -0.026916504, -0.006828308, 0.012580872, 0.031921387, -0.017486572, 0.00034952164, 0.007293701, -0.00057554245, 0.002943039, 0.05166626, -0.012123108, 0.021575928, -0.06958008, 0.032196045, 0.025741577, -0.016967773, 0.02986145, -0.008216858, -0.009490967, 0.022872925, 0.0075645447, 0.024047852, 0.0060691833, 0.036865234, 0.0073242188, 0.023971558, 0.02218628, -0.039794922, 0.0473938, 0.02279663, -0.0064315796, 0.0061836243, -0.0345459, -0.037506104, 0.0064926147, 0.005290985, 0.035491943, -0.016021729, -0.043792725, -0.0013713837, -0.025543213, -0.033416748, -0.018081665, 0.07556152, 0.03286743, -0.010093689, -0.0158844, 0.0051193237, 0.017150879, 0.034179688, 0.035705566, 0.014579773, 0.011756897, 0.008453369, 0.009933472, 0.018035889, 0.058410645, -0.018478394, 0.016677856, -0.08343506, -0.0041770935, 0.026229858, -0.012519836, -0.008804321, 0.012184143, 0.024230957, -0.0036411285, -0.025619507, 0.04449463, -0.077697754, -0.014732361, 0.016921997, -0.0043525696, -0.030929565, -0.03479004, -0.009307861, 0.0006160736, -0.012542725, 0.012809753, 0.1105957, 0.000044465065, -0.007827759, 0.031188965, -0.011856079, -0.045684814, 0.019836426, -0.03540039, 0.011360168, 0.021560669, -0.00092458725, 0.0362854, -0.057922363, 0.025436401, -0.000975132, 0.0015830994, 0.015838623, -0.1104126, -0.021087646, 0.047546387, 0.054229736, -0.032806396, 0.015617371, -0.023452759, -0.023254395, -0.0015630722, -0.0077819824, 0.01965332, -0.014877319, 0.0007119179, 0.011009216, -0.025146484, -0.036193848, 0.052886963, 0.03048706, -0.039398193, 0.015258789, 0.047302246, -0.03933716, 0.010055542, 0.06817627, 0.037841797, 0.038238525, -0.0064964294, -0.029464722, -0.079833984, 0.0340271, -0.042633057, -0.036621094, -0.0014533997, -0.056732178, -0.03387451, -0.008270264, -0.005176544, 0.010070801, 0.0541687, 0.030059814, -0.025817871, -0.010803223, 0.0066337585, 0.0058517456, 0.003643036, -0.027359009, 0.002603531, 0.042388916, -0.010406494, -0.006980896, 0.025299072, 0.030197144, -0.009407043, -0.0018939972, 0.007083893, -0.01210022, -0.021743774, 0.017074585, -0.016525269, -0.011856079, 0.012298584, -0.050689697, -0.009681702, 0.05041504, -0.018341064, -0.022277832, 0.013938904, -0.034576416, -0.013916016, 0.02961731, -0.02470398, 0.0045166016, 0.026351929, 0.0030841827, -0.016235352, 0.0007119179, -0.040252686, 0.03756714, -0.04724121, -0.059417725, 0.042419434, -0.051330566, -0.01525116, 0.022155762, 0.009513855, -0.022201538, -0.02848816, -0.020401001, 0.0024776459, 0.050354004, 0.015670776, -0.015357971, -0.013626099, -0.0022201538, -0.047424316, -0.010505676, -0.004989624, -0.008071899, 0.047912598, 0.015235901, 0.017715454, 0.030761719, -0.014953613, 0.0013532639, -0.0008511543, 0.01965332, 0.04788208, -0.0012454987, -0.01966858, -0.028015137, 0.017547607, -0.004261017, 0.031341553, -0.032226562, -0.012176514, -0.053253174, 0.020065308, -0.0435791, 0.093444824, -0.011367798, 0.022659302, 0.005203247, -0.0024642944, 0.045684814, 0.0017795563, -0.05630493, 0.020111084, 0.030075073, -0.013038635, 0.03375244, 0.0093307495, -0.009971619, 0.0055732727, 0.022842407, -0.03692627, -0.015312195, -0.0112838745, 0.027191162, 0.014198303, -0.041259766, -0.024398804, 0.006916046, 0.010292053, -0.010574341, 0.010375977, -0.07434082, -0.056030273, 0.014183044, -0.0034713745, -0.062469482, -0.0143585205, 0.027496338, -0.010093689, -0.007385254, -0.046295166, 0.004699707, 0.030029297, -0.015594482, 0.017837524, -0.016677856, -0.016693115, -0.004901886, -0.0748291, -0.009971619, 0.047302246, 0.0038871765, 0.015487671, 0.0041122437, -0.019012451, 0.01210022, -0.00920105, 0.015670776, -0.03475952, 0.062561035, -0.011161804, -0.0053863525, 0.036834717, -0.0018892288, -0.04269409, 0.10656738, -0.007904053, 0.014083862, -0.00033020973, 0.041412354, 0.008659363, -0.0012874603, 0.040527344, 0.0042762756, -0.003993988, -0.043548584, -0.02420044, -0.011604309, -0.017181396, -0.033996582, -0.0030727386, 0.00011640787, 0.024154663, 0.03878784, 0.02633667, 0.010612488, -0.020202637, 0.030212402, 0.005531311, 0.0011520386, -0.0060577393, 0.00069618225, -0.00068330765, -0.0018720627, 0.027862549, -0.0024929047, 0.05718994, -0.032409668, -0.010269165, 0.0146484375, 0.032287598, 0.0027770996, 0.008338928, -0.06878662, 0.034851074, -0.032348633, 0.012107849, -0.010910034, 0.043792725, 0.02607727, 0.0020999908, -0.040405273, 0.03616333, -0.009735107, 0.0024166107, -0.030792236, -0.06262207, -0.004096985, 0.0040512085, -0.054260254, -0.025405884, -0.02029419, -0.014587402, 0.04623413, -0.009979248, -0.029678345, 0.004283905, 0.026626587, 0.01737976, 0.040893555, -0.012580872, -0.0670166, -0.018203735, -0.0010089874, -0.03555298, 0.048675537, 0.020553589, -0.0019483566, -0.018157959, 0.045928955, -0.041015625, 0.038482666, -0.021514893, 0.005115509, -0.051940918, 0.049438477, -0.05114746, 0.002981186, -0.004760742, -0.017822266, 0.020370483, 0.0013208389, -0.022445679, 0.03555298, 0.05050659, 0.032409668, -0.00497818, -0.007675171, -0.00060224533, 0.016571045, 0.057403564, -0.00041294098, -0.02229309, 0.028259277, 0.0057029724, 0.012565613, 0.0067710876, -0.048461914, -0.0446167, -0.0011358261, -0.009757996, 0.03363037, -0.019760132, 0.027267456, 0.04486084, 0.04486084, 0.036132812, -0.009010315, 0.04421997, 0.01108551, -0.00045967102, -0.09490967, -0.040405273, -0.04248047, 0.048919678, -0.050964355, -0.011764526, 0.0049858093, -0.012046814, 0.0368042, 0.01586914, 0.05203247, -0.013717651, -0.021316528, -0.01071167, 0.026824951, 0.0124435425, -0.022125244, 0.0052871704, 0.021194458, 0.026184082, 0.0031547546, -0.01260376, -0.033599854, 0.026275635, -0.019363403, -0.032562256, -0.014320374, -0.061035156, -0.0010614395, 0.018096924, 0.009338379, -0.0065956116, -0.013717651, -0.0004386902, -0.011680603, 0.0395813, -0.016906738, 0.0284729, 0.04446411, -0.06506348, 0.03225708, -0.023605347, 0.009712219, -0.006832123, 0.043182373, -0.0028457642, 0.05117798, -0.06707764, 0.026306152, 0.008422852, -0.04156494, 0.01966858, -0.03366089, 0.042297363, 0.0154800415, -0.015670776, 0.016143799, -0.040771484, -0.03552246, -0.0016803741, -0.012580872, -0.029907227, 0.023651123, -0.015571594, -0.05670166, -0.017944336, 0.042541504, 0.0042037964, 0.014717102, -0.007160187, -0.009613037, -0.0413208, 0.014930725, 0.04522705, -0.04083252, 0.022583008, 0.029037476, 0.015823364, 0.0541687, 0.014762878, -0.030715942, 0.005756378, -0.014503479, -0.062927246, -0.07727051, 0.034332275, 0.0010719299, -0.0037345886, 0.022064209, 0.019012451, -0.00037026405, -0.008651733, 0.014160156, -0.0082473755, 0.0012302399, 0.049987793, -0.009124756, -0.018127441, 0.03781128, 0.01689148, 0.0033226013, 0.02508545, -0.004371643, -0.006374359, -0.0053977966, 0.0003950596, -0.0234375, 0.014007568, -0.042907715, 0.009887695, 0.007896423, -0.022964478, 0.02458191, 0.05606079, 0.035583496, 0.0552063, 0.016693115, 0.031951904, 0.019317627, -0.028015137, -0.007686615, -0.031799316, -0.016189575, -0.01576233, 0.09283447, -0.029251099, -0.02218628, -0.04067993, -0.047821045, -0.024169922, 0.00207901, 0.0064430237, -0.02041626, -0.017318726, -0.038360596, 0.022491455, -0.04171753, -0.012123108, -0.03225708, 0.016799927, -0.019119263, -0.01914978, 0.025527954, -0.026763916, 0.026641846, -0.038269043, -0.004459381, 0.004814148, 0.020401001, -0.015029907, -0.0619812, -0.010231018, -0.024505615, -0.001200676, 0.05001831, 0.009757996, -0.021972656, 0.03375244, -0.018676758, 0.028320312, -0.0029335022, 0.02154541, -0.004135132, -0.0032424927, 0.006011963, 0.009979248, -0.012771606, -0.030014038, -0.0014619827, -0.056488037, 0.015625, -0.064331055, -0.010070801, -0.08703613, -0.009162903, 0.0021324158, 0.033813477, 0.006641388, 0.008361816, 0.034057617, -0.018676758, 0.0024414062, -0.050994873, 0.048339844, -0.040802002, 0.008865356, -0.026153564, -0.03353882, 0.0236969, 0.026153564, -0.013938904, 0.027069092, 0.00077342987, -0.0345459, -0.0033683777, 0.015449524, 0.028366089, -0.055725098, -0.029632568, -0.033355713, 0.061798096, 0.005695343, 0.061157227, 0.035186768, 0.027862549, -0.024902344, -0.009857178, -0.0024604797, 0.060913086, -0.02519226, 0.040161133, 0.06793213, -0.049621582, 0.023010254, -0.006011963, -0.02935791, -0.010040283, 0.016326904, 0.02722168, -0.083496094, -0.025772095, 0.031158447, 0.022964478, -0.047973633, 0.06341553, -0.0015830994, 0.0009756088, 0.0074691772, 0.014717102, 0.025497437, 0.0602417, 0.011871338, 0.016357422, -0.008918762, 0.019546509, -0.022018433, 0.05697632, -0.049316406, 0.014541626, -0.074645996, 0.024795532, 0.0149002075, -0.04498291, 0.000010192394, 0.008331299, -0.032318115, -0.0008921623, -0.04901123, 0.07922363, 0.06713867, 0.076538086, -0.021209717, -0.010719299, 0.080566406, -0.02418518, -0.0073013306, -0.0056495667, -0.04864502, 0.008117676, -0.003829956, -0.018920898, 0.039367676, -0.029586792, 0.017089844, -0.022094727, -0.008491516, -0.039794922, 0.0074310303, 0.013839722, -0.06713867, -0.03253174, -0.021255493, -0.06896973, 0.007583618, 0.002046585, 0.027267456, -0.010650635, -0.01713562, 0.0362854, 0.026977539, 0.032806396, 0.043823242, -0.014450073, -0.047210693, 0.013031006, -0.012573242, 0.05368042, -0.013977051, -0.019943237, -0.03274536, 0.003850937, 0.02645874, 0.012298584, -0.042419434, 0.046417236, -0.021408081, -0.013641357, 0.0015258789, 0.012710571, 0.002702713, -0.016052246, 0.03253174, 0.0132369995, -0.01637268, 0.0032138824, 0.02255249, -0.023712158, -0.052978516, -0.0074768066, -0.033966064, 0.012504578, 0.015945435, 0.006210327, 0.010986328, 0.008056641, -0.0058021545, -0.010757446, 0.006023407, 0.028213501, 0.005695343, -0.032958984, 0.034942627, -0.009338379, 0.049591064, -0.05038452, -0.027038574, -0.0129776, 0.066223145, -0.0090789795, 0.04348755, -0.0020580292, 0.004699707, 0.013046265, 0.009109497, 0.005844116, -0.025009155, 0.005180359, 0.056365967, 0.051574707, 0.04434204, -0.044189453, 0.022872925, 0.0018835068, -0.027648926, -0.019805908, -0.01676941, 0.013015747, -0.04324341, -0.0050468445, -0.001917839, -0.011871338, -0.02355957, -0.04006958, 0.00061130524, 0.0047912598, 0.005596161, -0.008132935, 0.01424408, -0.016143799, 0.048980713, -0.0066184998, -0.020950317, 0.038269043, -0.0113220215, 0.035339355, -0.01309967, 0.017822266, -0.0012369156, -0.012184143, 0.011238098, 0.020050049, 0.030532837, 0.011795044, -0.0051498413, 0.038482666, -0.07562256, -0.028884888, -0.027954102, -0.03302002, 0.04156494, -0.025390625, 0.010467529, 0.012252808, -0.018188477, -0.015335083, -0.006336212, -0.004211426, -0.030029297, -0.06774902, -0.07336426, 0.03225708, -0.02508545 ], "summary": [ 0.04574585, -0.005783081, 0.010185242, -0.0033607483, -0.018447876, -0.016143799, 0.0037155151, -0.058044434, 0.0046195984, 0.04699707, -0.03479004, -0.0035476685, 0.024780273, -0.022018433, -0.008399963, -0.022857666, 0.020874023, 0.02772522, 0.019470215, -0.016937256, 0.019607544, 0.0016059875, -0.018463135, 0.06427002, 0.007293701, 0.004085541, -0.06616211, 0.019515991, -0.0017089844, -0.0015983582, -0.0059394836, 0.0037517548, 0.00869751, -0.01725769, 0.054260254, -0.021148682, -0.043273926, 0.018722534, 0.022598267, -0.013961792, 0.029769897, -0.023590088, 0.013366699, -0.028213501, -0.011276245, 0.025360107, 0.0049972534, -0.00749588, 0.00091791153, 0.04550171, 0.0022907257, 0.017150879, -0.00541687, 0.007858276, -0.01953125, -0.053497314, -0.09020996, 0.028778076, 0.01134491, 0.1227417, 0.0513916, 0.0031166077, -0.04385376, -0.06689453, 0.0073547363, -0.009788513, 0.040039062, 0.018753052, 0.023544312, -0.0025138855, 0.00080013275, 0.02885437, 0.033935547, -0.049865723, -0.03326416, 0.049041748, 0.052734375, 0.04434204, -0.0006804466, -0.08605957, 0.046844482, 0.036132812, 0.039001465, -0.044921875, 0.014465332, -0.042999268, -0.0033512115, -0.0049858093, -0.025268555, -0.02784729, -0.028930664, 0.0023460388, -0.04232788, 0.01071167, 0.0034008026, -0.014167786, 0.00982666, 0.0011901855, 0.01864624, 0.0030555725, -0.018417358, -0.022369385, -0.009407043, -0.024978638, 0.00091934204, -0.0025157928, -0.01626587, -0.0009536743, 0.03805542, 0.024642944, -0.028564453, 0.0064849854, 0.006565094, -0.033996582, -0.030334473, -0.011367798, 0.0043792725, 0.014701843, 0.022766113, -0.02444458, 0.014160156, 0.036132812, 0.019012451, -0.051757812, 0.037628174, 0.013519287, -0.01361084, -0.050811768, -0.019058228, 0.028274536, -0.029022217, 0.033721924, 0.003255844, -0.023101807, -0.049865723, -0.017562866, 0.023406982, -0.020370483, 0.0028705597, -0.008346558, 0.029434204, -0.028366089, -0.022766113, 0.023910522, 0.020751953, 0.061523438, 0.029312134, -0.027359009, -0.027114868, -0.041259766, -0.0009407997, 0.028823853, 0.02822876, -0.019821167, 0.013267517, -0.06506348, -0.028427124, -0.032470703, 0.044769287, -0.025283813, 0.030303955, -0.0040664673, -0.004951477, 0.054473877, 0.013053894, -0.0051612854, 0.012359619, -0.0007843971, 0.0047683716, 0.023620605, -0.000849247, 0.025939941, 0.02104187, -0.0015954971, -0.0029907227, -0.019165039, -0.03277588, 0.031173706, 0.017730713, -0.0076141357, 0.0074920654, -0.02708435, 0.012710571, 0.031921387, -0.01789856, -0.0033130646, -0.02609253, 0.04675293, 0.066711426, 0.0034236908, -0.026443481, -0.04220581, -0.025512695, -0.012336731, -0.03878784, 0.023284912, 0.018585205, 0.04559326, -0.027389526, 0.014968872, 0.018035889, 0.014663696, -0.018615723, -0.015045166, -0.03869629, 0.0045204163, -0.010757446, 0.024215698, 0.009407043, 0.009376526, -0.017333984, -0.029220581, 0.044921875, -0.088134766, -0.029418945, 0.0016431808, 0.025268555, -0.019958496, 0.0038337708, -0.015151978, 0.010154724, 0.007232666, -0.028381348, 0.03439331, -0.014808655, -0.008056641, -0.001452446, 0.014823914, 0.04232788, -0.0067443848, 0.11468506, -0.042388916, -0.02015686, 0.04788208, -0.00022745132, -0.032928467, -0.0069847107, -0.06939697, 0.061462402, 0.03237915, 0.031219482, -0.00484848, -0.018463135, 0.027420044, -0.01373291, -0.009544373, 0.020050049, 0.0019311905, -0.010917664, -0.012580872, 0.0038986206, -0.02658081, 0.027526855, -0.06854248, 0.038116455, 0.010215759, -0.013328552, 0.005420685, 0.0063056946, -0.013687134, 0.021331787, -0.0052986145, -0.023880005, 0.003019333, 0.04837036, -0.008224487, 0.053344727, 0.03125, -0.005077362, 0.0011129379, 0.0017442703, -0.010978699, -0.014816284, -0.046295166, -0.052612305, -0.0038032532, -0.027267456, 0.052856445, -0.010803223, -0.039093018, -0.0044517517, -0.027526855, -0.058654785, -0.013214111, 0.035736084, 0.027191162, -0.00021541119, 0.03152466, 0.01966858, 0.06488037, 0.045013428, 0.026870728, 0.020202637, 0.003768921, 0.002243042, 0.00060129166, -0.015625, 0.008476257, 0.018356323, -0.045410156, -0.015975952, 0.00844574, -0.021652222, -0.015838623, 0.004989624, -0.022857666, 0.0007839203, 0.024108887, 0.015991211, 0.01826477, -0.035827637, 0.016921997, 0.042663574, 0.057556152, -0.013114929, -0.009506226, -0.004814148, 0.056915283, 0.04272461, 0.060028076, 0.109436035, 0.0006585121, 0.028900146, 0.0033893585, -0.006072998, -0.053741455, 0.03616333, -0.019699097, 0.019882202, 0.0068244934, -0.026290894, 0.019454956, -0.020828247, 0.040405273, 0.0011968613, -0.0131073, 0.028656006, -0.08691406, 0.0017614365, 0.037719727, 0.06842041, -0.015052795, -0.008888245, -0.0068511963, -0.055511475, 0.010520935, -0.008903503, 0.014183044, -0.0023097992, -0.02015686, 0.018325806, -0.033843994, -0.04034424, 0.074523926, -0.011886597, -0.025009155, 0.05114746, 0.04119873, -0.044555664, -0.016235352, 0.07891846, 0.045776367, 0.064086914, -0.03933716, -0.0524292, -0.056121826, 0.04623413, -0.048797607, -0.029907227, 0.0007042885, -0.029769897, 0.019729614, -0.04675293, -0.031311035, -0.025665283, 0.04751587, 0.068847656, -0.003145218, 0.0069465637, 0.05380249, 0.032165527, 0.03277588, -0.03692627, -0.00491333, 0.070251465, 0.011451721, 0.016403198, 0.05065918, 0.03277588, -0.017364502, 0.0015211105, 0.022659302, -0.009017944, -0.022262573, 0.006416321, 0.0003130436, -0.0071144104, -0.0019254684, -0.027389526, -0.033935547, 0.039154053, 0.0009226799, 0.009773254, -0.0018224716, 0.00078582764, 0.034210205, 0.02708435, -0.0025482178, 0.008377075, 0.019180298, 0.029754639, -0.04171753, 0.022888184, -0.047668457, 0.018615723, -0.023498535, 0.018737793, 0.034210205, -0.07348633, -0.008880615, 0.01739502, 0.07269287, -0.015945435, -0.03387451, 0.006587982, 0.040222168, -0.0037345886, 0.011550903, -0.03503418, -0.025344849, -0.01625061, -0.043273926, 0.007091522, 0.043121338, -0.026626587, 0.037841797, -0.009979248, -0.068481445, 0.030899048, -0.078186035, 0.01133728, -0.022720337, -0.022064209, 0.016601562, -0.026687622, -0.013702393, -0.013313293, -0.0010385513, -0.009025574, 0.005908966, -0.02998352, -0.021743774, -0.029205322, 0.037475586, -0.025421143, 0.109558105, -0.023422241, 0.023208618, 0.055236816, -0.018722534, 0.029220581, -0.00079250336, -0.068481445, 0.026275635, 0.016464233, 0.036468506, -0.008384705, 0.035827637, 0.0011463165, -0.01979065, 0.030517578, -0.037872314, -0.033599854, 0.0023670197, -0.00056123734, 0.007911682, 0.013214111, -0.012283325, 0.020843506, -0.012641907, -0.042175293, 0.017044067, -0.052459717, -0.022537231, 0.0037021637, 0.007789612, -0.023223877, -0.02468872, 0.025131226, 0.017807007, 0.03616333, -0.073791504, 0.041748047, 0.0009775162, -0.030090332, 0.016235352, -0.026428223, 0.052978516, -0.026794434, -0.06427002, 0.016998291, -0.033416748, 0.0064315796, 0.045440674, -0.046783447, 0.008262634, 0.022399902, -0.013618469, 0.01322937, -0.05142212, 0.015464783, -0.04385376, -0.017211914, 0.022750854, -0.007881165, -0.022277832, 0.066101074, 0.029785156, 0.008857727, -0.026123047, 0.07196045, 0.050323486, 0.009086609, 0.018539429, -0.008354187, 0.0065231323, -0.030822754, -0.01676941, -0.03463745, -0.011405945, 0.0085372925, 0.04827881, 0.004337311, 0.0035953522, 0.024093628, -0.0026664734, 0.0009045601, -0.0017557144, 0.040771484, 0.008628845, 0.0022697449, -0.033569336, -0.027709961, -0.005657196, -0.0064964294, 0.030334473, 0.03186035, 0.056610107, -0.09259033, 0.014694214, 0.02458191, 0.03842163, -0.005962372, -0.038085938, -0.043914795, 0.08685303, 0.00207901, -0.0067100525, -0.014801025, 0.027633667, -0.008636475, 0.0006594658, -0.024261475, 0.04168701, -0.032226562, 0.032104492, -0.06689453, -0.06921387, -0.015220642, -0.012496948, -0.029006958, -0.015037537, -0.014854431, -0.052368164, 0.009674072, -0.008483887, -0.028961182, 0.020263672, -0.0035743713, 0.0014123917, 0.030700684, -0.016571045, -0.070007324, -0.03704834, -0.003929138, -0.03744507, 0.052581787, 0.0037326813, 0.006084442, 0.003824234, 0.042663574, -0.045715332, 0.031158447, -0.042877197, -0.014427185, -0.032440186, 0.040252686, -0.015838623, -0.00023674965, 0.0032749176, -0.016281128, 0.024475098, -0.0036182404, -0.002796173, 0.024917603, 0.04916382, 0.02319336, 0.016494751, -0.008399963, 0.0012722015, -0.0054512024, 0.06274414, -0.035583496, -0.019439697, -0.008125305, 0.0011978149, 0.025466919, 0.0017375946, -0.018920898, -0.053710938, -0.0066871643, 0.004432678, -0.0021648407, 0.005218506, -0.0037059784, 0.04864502, 0.026031494, 0.04623413, -0.009132385, 0.012298584, 0.03125, -0.010131836, -0.09240723, -0.021896362, -0.04046631, 0.0440979, -0.057434082, -0.05041504, -0.0071411133, -0.031799316, 0.025878906, 0.00014615059, 0.011245728, -0.010749817, 0.015930176, 0.0020618439, 0.0289917, 0.021392822, -0.0017433167, -0.04840088, -0.01448822, 0.011749268, 0.01852417, -0.013946533, 0.013305664, 0.0005016327, -0.032165527, -0.008842468, -0.018920898, -0.04348755, -0.062072754, -0.028121948, 0.021392822, -0.025772095, 0.016906738, 0.016098022, -0.030029297, 0.022567749, -0.010948181, -0.0068855286, 0.001953125, -0.048583984, -0.00045466423, -0.019012451, 0.018234253, 0.012924194, 0.03857422, 0.019454956, 0.032196045, -0.060272217, 0.00033187866, -0.0064048767, 0.0037326813, -0.024978638, -0.0018405914, 0.031341553, -0.010055542, -0.00039196014, 0.01574707, -0.0064964294, -0.016815186, -0.009048462, -0.0040130615, -0.03768921, 0.023864746, -0.015090942, -0.00944519, 0.028823853, 0.024795532, -0.017349243, 0.016998291, 0.025527954, 0.0076446533, 0.017227173, -0.018966675, 0.019470215, 0.0026550293, 0.030166626, 0.015777588, -0.0036964417, 0.020339966, 0.008728027, -0.047332764, 0.006828308, -0.02003479, -0.035583496, -0.044921875, 0.017837524, 0.011016846, 0.014122009, 0.015335083, 0.026382446, 0.04776001, -0.0017652512, 0.031143188, -0.0012979507, -0.017227173, 0.012786865, -0.024002075, -0.05718994, 0.020492554, 0.051574707, -0.026184082, 0.004798889, -0.003955841, -0.018447876, 0.031066895, -0.016159058, -0.0045928955, 0.026611328, -0.018218994, 0.023757935, 0.02432251, 0.0012111664, 0.025802612, 0.04953003, 0.025115967, 0.012184143, 0.025131226, 0.021759033, -0.007293701, -0.00025606155, -0.0074691772, -0.026947021, 0.0048561096, 0.0047416687, 0.07714844, -0.027908325, -0.036956787, -0.03567505, -0.031677246, 0.009117126, -0.004611969, 0.00084257126, -0.03213501, 0.006706238, -0.02444458, 0.004005432, 0.0084991455, -0.03543091, -0.018173218, 0.0031318665, -0.008995056, 0.018417358, 0.048553467, -0.019683838, 0.004558563, -0.012207031, -0.013633728, 0.010719299, 0.016921997, -0.013725281, -0.03289795, 0.001540184, -0.017227173, 0.031036377, 0.017578125, 0.016281128, -0.0007724762, 0.01322937, -0.023895264, 0.022537231, 0.017608643, -0.008857727, -0.0440979, -0.068481445, 0.002298355, 0.028381348, 0.0029735565, -0.030319214, 0.02432251, -0.020050049, -0.014709473, -0.040924072, -0.034729004, -0.033721924, 0.008636475, -0.0036964417, 0.014091492, 0.0309906, 0.006504059, 0.040740967, 0.034118652, -0.060791016, -0.018737793, -0.00025749207, 0.045410156, 0.02305603, -0.044952393, -0.035827637, -0.0034694672, 0.029052734, 0.014053345, 0.023635864, 0.023727417, -0.028640747, 0.021636963, 0.0049324036, -0.0048828125, -0.06451416, 0.0079574585, -0.03152466, 0.0289917, 0.008262634, 0.08514404, 0.00422287, 0.012168884, -0.0073051453, 0.011367798, -0.012298584, 0.07672119, -0.012550354, 0.051483154, 0.048187256, -0.014968872, 0.0084991455, 0.015487671, -0.029708862, 0.0135650635, 0.004425049, 0.031341553, -0.06097412, -0.018600464, -0.00058984756, 0.010169983, -0.022094727, 0.03692627, 0.0031776428, 0.016448975, -0.0066566467, -0.009666443, 0.045440674, 0.05633545, -0.011352539, -0.024307251, -0.018310547, 0.008049011, -0.0033893585, 0.06994629, -0.017715454, 0.0146484375, -0.08093262, -0.0034389496, 0.008087158, -0.019348145, -0.015426636, 0.04800415, -0.027862549, 0.045013428, -0.012992859, 0.07720947, 0.07623291, 0.07531738, -0.049743652, 0.025375366, 0.07873535, 0.008514404, 0.03353882, -0.056549072, -0.022232056, -0.024047852, -0.027893066, 0.011672974, -0.017120361, -0.038757324, -0.011482239, -0.010185242, 0.023513794, -0.03488159, 0.010681152, -0.0181427, -0.06713867, -0.0053367615, -0.0236969, -0.07128906, 0.017150879, 0.0014371872, 0.028945923, 0.004234314, -0.017837524, 0.017166138, 0.036193848, 0.03086853, 0.054748535, -0.023330688, -0.0028476715, -0.0024414062, -0.0056381226, 0.053100586, -0.0075950623, -0.04916382, -0.0009431839, -0.0015926361, 0.05343628, 0.004257202, -0.04534912, 0.033233643, 0.011238098, 0.00349617, 0.0057640076, 0.03387451, 0.0055160522, -0.036468506, 0.010879517, 0.01108551, -0.024642944, 0.03765869, 0.023162842, -0.004436493, -0.045410156, 0.0077590942, -0.01776123, 0.021896362, -0.021347046, -0.0034561157, -0.009597778, 0.011207581, -0.038848877, -0.049102783, 0.006298065, 0.025283813, 0.008277893, -0.02986145, 0.029907227, -0.032592773, 0.016403198, -0.04559326, 0.01776123, -0.022399902, 0.08294678, 0.01763916, 0.0037879944, -0.021072388, -0.008705139, 0.015457153, 0.00014817715, 0.005458832, -0.009719849, 0.039520264, 0.076660156, 0.052246094, 0.020431519, -0.053985596, 0.04019165, -0.010246277, -0.068603516, -0.017974854, -0.02168274, 0.012992859, -0.048217773, 0.00038838387, -0.009918213, -0.009979248, -0.017196655, -0.023254395, -0.040252686, 0.020690918, 0.00010114908, -0.018966675, 0.013061523, -0.04046631, 0.023864746, 0.02319336, 0.017868042, 0.012481689, -0.035369873, 0.051483154, -0.038726807, 0.025894165, -0.01638794, -0.0035114288, 0.010879517, 0.0209198, 0.036193848, 0.01802063, -0.048675537, 0.030929565, -0.10192871, 0.0025081635, -0.05996704, -0.0234375, 0.008407593, -0.03845215, -0.0013542175, 0.022705078, -0.034210205, 0.009178162, -0.01436615, -0.028411865, -0.00020503998, -0.018081665, -0.036895752, -0.004463196, 0.0036449432 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06278v1
Boosting Stock Price Prediction with Anticipated Macro Policy Changes
Md Sabbirul Haque, Md Shahedul Amin, Jonayet Miah, Duc Minh Cao, Ashiqul Haque Ahmed
q-fin.ST, cs.AI, cs.LG
Prediction of stock prices plays a significant role in aiding the decision-making of investors. Considering its importance, a growing literature has emerged trying to forecast stock prices with improved accuracy. In this study, we introduce an innovative approach for forecasting stock prices with greater accuracy. We incorporate external economic environment-related information along with stock prices. In our novel approach, we improve the performance of stock price prediction by taking into account variations due to future expected macroeconomic policy changes as investors adjust their current behavior ahead of time based on expected future macroeconomic policy changes. Furthermore, we incorporate macroeconomic variables along with historical stock prices to make predictions. Results from this strongly support the inclusion of future economic policy changes along with current macroeconomic information. We confirm the supremacy of our method over the conventional approach using several tree-based machine-learning algorithms. Results are strongly conclusive across various machine learning models. Our preferred model outperforms the conventional approach with an RMSE value of 1.61 compared to an RMSE value of 1.75 from the conventional approach.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06278v1
2023-10-27T04:57:45
2023-10-27T04:57:45
{ "title": [ 0.0069770813, 0.020065308, -0.03994751, -0.06854248, 0.023635864, -0.0029277802, -0.009208679, -0.0143585205, -0.032043457, 0.03567505, -0.024902344, 0.010635376, -0.009208679, -0.0013332367, -0.027801514, -0.010299683, 0.01374054, 0.038024902, 0.018676758, -0.030715942, -0.008880615, -0.040252686, 0.076660156, 0.009559631, 0.041046143, -0.035491943, -0.056671143, 0.008460999, -0.011070251, -0.020446777, -0.0034618378, 0.0017585754, 0.03326416, 0.029251099, -0.004043579, 0.05529785, -0.032562256, 0.028671265, 0.028640747, -0.02696228, 0.0018548965, -0.003232956, -0.0040779114, -0.037139893, -0.03781128, 0.030426025, -0.06304932, 0.0063056946, -0.01159668, 0.02041626, 0.017333984, 0.01914978, 0.00029993057, 0.047668457, 0.019363403, -0.020889282, -0.0619812, 0.020492554, 0.028900146, 0.08496094, 0.035491943, -0.028930664, 0.0012454987, -0.030700684, -0.06762695, 0.0037136078, -0.006061554, -0.0031814575, 0.07891846, -0.033599854, -0.028701782, 0.042755127, -0.0039787292, 0.028747559, -0.037139893, -0.028503418, 0.0524292, 0.007133484, 0.019989014, -0.0027999878, 0.00806427, -0.0211792, 0.018554688, -0.046569824, 0.03656006, -0.02722168, -0.0071525574, -0.01638794, -0.044403076, -0.04397583, -0.014663696, -0.016220093, -0.015975952, 0.011314392, -0.016098022, -0.013153076, -0.0362854, 0.0524292, -0.036987305, -0.035095215, -0.055145264, 0.04623413, -0.09539795, -0.012313843, 0.008804321, 0.0423584, 0.015808105, -0.016845703, 0.0013904572, 0.0034008026, -0.015602112, 0.013771057, 0.0015926361, 0.0068092346, -0.021469116, 0.01687622, 0.00472641, -0.015281677, 0.0027122498, 0.012046814, 0.030395508, 0.008361816, -0.0035762787, -0.009880066, 0.02168274, 0.0024929047, -0.05630493, -0.0068130493, -0.047851562, 0.06488037, 0.014404297, 0.0129776, -0.112976074, -0.070495605, -0.062286377, 0.026062012, 0.030899048, 0.034973145, -0.0032253265, -0.027008057, 0.010879517, -0.020095825, 0.006828308, 0.023010254, 0.014350891, 0.0018234253, 0.060638428, -0.001115799, -0.02217102, 0.004722595, -0.06201172, 0.028839111, 0.017456055, 0.0066452026, -0.055877686, -0.01322937, -0.09466553, -0.029525757, 0.030166626, -0.027938843, 0.026885986, -0.019958496, -0.04559326, 0.013404846, 0.033203125, 0.018447876, 0.017959595, 0.04751587, 0.012458801, 0.02720642, -0.01739502, 0.01184845, 0.00907135, -0.008056641, -0.0055999756, 0.0030021667, 0.017074585, -0.0016107559, 0.03439331, -0.009384155, 0.012741089, -0.012962341, 0.04168701, 0.04434204, -0.041900635, -0.033843994, 0.012962341, -0.017974854, 0.038726807, 0.006816864, -0.018844604, 0.028640747, -0.061187744, -0.06085205, -0.02999878, 0.016189575, 0.016616821, 0.027542114, 0.005809784, 0.019180298, -0.03010559, 0.00705719, -0.039367676, 0.01902771, -0.0065727234, -0.036590576, -0.001455307, 0.01184082, -0.026611328, 0.05380249, 0.04119873, 0.004623413, -0.03161621, 0.028198242, 0.004463196, -0.054260254, 0.011924744, -0.00018930435, 0.0060691833, -0.034698486, -0.006198883, -0.0011816025, 0.0073661804, 0.041412354, 0.024154663, 0.014122009, -0.005794525, -0.018310547, 0.045898438, 0.021331787, 0.057159424, -0.027938843, 0.020507812, 0.0013275146, -0.014930725, -0.022018433, -0.019317627, -0.039794922, 0.0104522705, 0.030563354, -0.0036506653, -0.04345703, -0.023208618, 0.029907227, 0.042510986, 0.024459839, 0.0046577454, 0.03277588, 0.023651123, 0.021011353, 0.08319092, 0.02748108, 0.03857422, 0.00037670135, 0.028198242, 0.05328369, 0.01574707, 0.03503418, -0.04437256, 0.03024292, -0.008369446, 0.04196167, 0.018478394, 0.012435913, -0.046691895, 0.020584106, -0.048950195, 0.005493164, -0.012870789, 0.022888184, 0.034179688, -0.009857178, 0.0013694763, -0.023117065, -0.017913818, -0.022354126, -0.027786255, 0.034851074, 0.008605957, -0.05999756, -0.013977051, 0.034179688, 0.016906738, -0.0052757263, -0.0011177063, 0.0052375793, -0.005844116, -0.00869751, -0.012191772, -0.035247803, 0.050231934, 0.02003479, -0.0031871796, -0.018234253, 0.0012044907, -0.016113281, 0.02619934, 0.055358887, -0.013374329, 0.03250122, -0.09320068, 0.0234375, 0.03466797, -0.026153564, 0.0029525757, 0.037017822, 0.024108887, 0.0021648407, -0.034729004, 0.025787354, -0.05847168, 0.0143585205, 0.0036239624, -0.041778564, -0.023529053, -0.024932861, -0.007205963, -0.03439331, -0.0049819946, 0.008560181, 0.019241333, -0.01876831, -0.025253296, -0.020355225, -0.013084412, 0.008293152, -0.020126343, -0.021224976, -0.020874023, 0.029632568, 0.03881836, -0.013114929, -0.07141113, -0.024307251, 0.0058021545, 0.028564453, -0.005039215, 0.06463623, -0.020355225, -0.021850586, -0.010246277, -0.020904541, 0.010124207, -0.017288208, 0.042236328, -0.060516357, -0.0023097992, 0.011787415, 0.013404846, 0.015701294, -0.0011806488, -0.0104522705, -0.060058594, -0.026138306, 0.008804321, -0.0076522827, 0.023406982, 0.008842468, 0.012001038, -0.027236938, 0.03640747, 0.017044067, -0.0012159348, -0.08117676, 0.020812988, -0.05215454, -0.034057617, -0.030471802, -0.03149414, 0.058898926, -0.05871582, -0.015296936, -0.03643799, -0.011909485, -0.022003174, 0.035095215, -0.021835327, -0.034362793, 0.002193451, -0.025360107, 0.0064468384, -0.015197754, 0.0041236877, -0.042907715, 0.07537842, -0.002937317, -0.05807495, -0.01083374, 0.015029907, 0.018600464, -0.026107788, 0.0004427433, -0.04711914, 0.005519867, 0.018005371, 0.014411926, -0.0044136047, -0.008972168, -0.09869385, -0.006919861, 0.050811768, -0.00064373016, -0.018508911, 0.038635254, -0.06951904, 0.01852417, -0.014038086, -0.013015747, 0.02583313, 0.01928711, 0.0042381287, 0.015960693, 0.011375427, -0.031219482, 0.015159607, -0.05303955, -0.07751465, 0.03793335, -0.032165527, -0.0597229, 0.026565552, -0.07421875, -0.016967773, -0.024871826, -0.013145447, 0.040771484, 0.031188965, 0.023468018, 0.0063667297, -0.036468506, 0.007091522, -0.0501709, -0.01927185, -0.03466797, -0.0066108704, 0.00655365, -0.02885437, 0.07775879, -0.024551392, 0.019958496, -0.044799805, -0.023208618, 0.002916336, 0.029174805, 0.012268066, -0.04055786, -0.02229309, -0.022018433, 0.012252808, 0.0065231323, 0.0032806396, -0.016555786, 0.0013618469, 0.0034294128, -0.018707275, 0.016860962, 0.013389587, -0.00466156, -0.01852417, -0.027450562, -0.012802124, -0.023986816, -0.059417725, -0.011734009, -0.0013790131, -0.004020691, 0.046722412, -0.020584106, -0.04928589, 0.036132812, -0.046173096, 0.020385742, 0.0074920654, -0.018157959, -0.015975952, -0.017578125, -0.0008649826, -0.004108429, 0.0049476624, -0.028289795, 0.03604126, -0.0023097992, 0.04888916, -0.080444336, -0.014923096, 0.0040740967, -0.15063477, -0.05508423, 0.014854431, -0.052825928, -0.022247314, -0.045898438, 0.00030732155, -0.003162384, -0.03942871, -0.010536194, -0.008911133, -0.032348633, 0.0074424744, -0.061187744, -0.03643799, 0.09295654, -0.009979248, 0.008003235, 0.0063095093, 0.013389587, 0.015716553, -0.017105103, 0.022445679, -0.017318726, 0.045440674, -0.010482788, 0.0029182434, 0.053619385, -0.047729492, -0.0023918152, 0.039276123, 0.043151855, -0.013725281, 0.0011177063, 0.011978149, 0.03137207, -0.03704834, 0.055999756, 0.02482605, -0.031280518, -0.049072266, 0.00015306473, -0.020111084, 0.0017309189, -0.0046653748, -0.00014591217, -0.012260437, -0.018203735, 0.041046143, 0.04309082, -0.019119263, 0.013961792, 0.04763794, -0.00806427, -0.022781372, -0.016067505, 0.02218628, 0.045318604, 0.019195557, 0.032958984, -0.008369446, 0.0552063, -0.029968262, 0.01991272, -0.02003479, -0.008216858, -0.042266846, 0.00081825256, -0.048828125, -0.071899414, -0.055023193, 0.032928467, -0.0129470825, 0.027297974, 0.026779175, -0.013618469, -0.026641846, 0.018798828, 0.045074463, -0.0024681091, 0.0061569214, -0.056640625, -0.022094727, 0.004348755, -0.054595947, -0.018707275, 0.005050659, -0.009422302, 0.029052734, -0.017684937, -0.0055007935, 0.019363403, 0.006374359, 0.016342163, 0.011749268, -0.01638794, -0.0074653625, 0.06365967, -0.015563965, -0.05206299, 0.025344849, 0.009094238, -0.01675415, -0.053375244, -0.003206253, -0.015579224, 0.0034542084, -0.022537231, 0.023483276, -0.013687134, 0.031341553, -0.045532227, 0.018554688, 0.023498535, 0.014968872, 0.022262573, 0.019348145, -0.02204895, -0.015106201, 0.031341553, 0.04547119, 0.021591187, 0.0036373138, 0.03186035, 0.019241333, -0.0075035095, 0.013938904, -0.0056877136, 0.034179688, 0.01675415, -0.036621094, 0.05340576, -0.011665344, -0.030029297, 0.010002136, -0.00008612871, 0.03479004, -0.054473877, 0.014945984, 0.008056641, 0.021575928, 0.026809692, -0.02947998, 0.026062012, 0.0014352798, 0.017044067, -0.062805176, -0.03640747, 0.0105896, 0.027526855, -0.03616333, 0.0029659271, 0.02609253, 0.029067993, 0.048187256, 0.05218506, 0.06262207, -0.010597229, -0.013786316, -0.0076026917, 0.0033912659, -0.016586304, -0.030700684, 0.009712219, 0.02633667, 0.020477295, -0.09680176, 0.042114258, -0.03201294, -0.0058784485, -0.002708435, 0.009307861, 0.014839172, -0.068237305, 0.012893677, 0.035003662, 0.02734375, -0.010063171, 0.018417358, 0.033172607, 0.04748535, 0.045928955, 0.022903442, 0.033111572, 0.021148682, -0.030136108, -0.0027713776, 0.0027828217, 0.03338623, -0.009552002, 0.020019531, 0.01638794, -0.006881714, -0.05392456, 0.03918457, -0.026184082, -0.056854248, 0.0087509155, -0.031555176, -0.0046577454, 0.0015649796, 0.03515625, 0.004623413, -0.03060913, -0.03149414, 0.009216309, -0.038330078, -0.015068054, 0.02418518, -0.01864624, -0.0357666, -0.057006836, 0.011795044, -0.00605011, 0.013931274, -0.011871338, 0.005554199, -0.048950195, 0.01184082, 0.045715332, -0.03237915, -0.01374054, -0.0181427, 0.019546509, 0.0413208, 0.0036087036, -0.029022217, -0.0070228577, -0.014419556, -0.034576416, 0.004634857, 0.033233643, 0.031463623, -0.007865906, -0.018692017, -0.032226562, 0.013046265, -0.02003479, 0.011108398, 0.025634766, -0.022613525, 0.012283325, 0.0006952286, 0.010620117, -0.000014841557, 0.02633667, 0.032073975, -0.0129852295, -0.0072250366, -0.05432129, 0.03451538, -0.009002686, -0.007507324, -0.0012979507, -0.043548584, 0.009880066, 0.010597229, 0.0009088516, -0.033813477, 0.015586853, 0.032073975, -0.030578613, 0.010673523, 0.014198303, 0.08282471, -0.0496521, -0.030670166, -0.012687683, 0.000975132, -0.008735657, 0.09063721, -0.023406982, -0.031555176, -0.051116943, -0.036956787, -0.022888184, 0.007904053, 0.01689148, -0.019683838, 0.02999878, -0.01737976, 0.008392334, -0.03918457, -0.022094727, -0.028579712, 0.055358887, 0.002943039, -0.010398865, -0.03326416, -0.030700684, -0.0039024353, -0.0029563904, 0.01940918, 0.030090332, -0.013465881, 0.010375977, -0.04724121, 0.016693115, -0.014678955, -0.03012085, 0.037750244, 0.0087509155, -0.02305603, 0.022598267, -0.011459351, 0.055419922, 0.023956299, 0.037322998, 0.036224365, 0.013969421, -0.0044288635, 0.0033550262, 0.025024414, -0.0496521, -0.000582695, -0.037139893, -0.021652222, -0.0635376, -0.010925293, -0.08178711, 0.021820068, -0.0055618286, 0.019119263, 0.027236938, 0.0011711121, 0.0008111, 0.004901886, 0.040405273, 0.02558899, 0.051635742, 0.05847168, 0.0155181885, -0.020828247, -0.0029201508, 0.0011224747, 0.013938904, 0.009391785, 0.013023376, -0.02986145, -0.015686035, 0.021011353, -0.026473999, 0.02418518, -0.0037002563, -0.036895752, -0.030639648, 0.047088623, -0.020523071, 0.029663086, 0.034088135, 0.04095459, -0.0044288635, -0.024963379, 0.008155823, 0.01083374, -0.029815674, 0.009933472, 0.047424316, -0.07287598, 0.036987305, -0.01713562, -0.036834717, 0.032287598, 0.021362305, 0.026351929, -0.06903076, -0.07171631, 0.023208618, 0.039855957, 0.024261475, 0.0287323, -0.038085938, -0.02947998, -0.007865906, 0.027038574, -0.021575928, 0.01071167, 0.001156807, 0.06304932, -0.018493652, 0.012565613, -0.0011262894, 0.013435364, -0.02909851, 0.024414062, -0.04724121, 0.045318604, -0.003616333, -0.049560547, 0.0014858246, 0.008872986, -0.04827881, -0.027252197, 0.030258179, 0.031280518, 0.020935059, 0.05831909, 0.0062332153, -0.024658203, -0.005722046, -0.04058838, 0.03378296, 0.0574646, -0.04119873, 0.020095825, -0.012664795, -0.035827637, 0.055480957, -0.012496948, 0.0491333, -0.046081543, 0.037109375, 0.0027217865, -0.015823364, 0.055480957, -0.054534912, -0.04547119, 0.029922485, -0.036712646, -0.011657715, -0.009506226, 0.0034179688, -0.030715942, -0.011352539, 0.034118652, 0.021713257, 0.0034656525, 0.00415802, -0.025253296, -0.074645996, 0.013000488, -0.024856567, 0.034423828, -0.008239746, -0.0076065063, -0.019958496, 0.00724411, -0.002418518, -0.027069092, -0.026916504, -0.017623901, -0.013946533, -0.045440674, 0.03881836, 0.02607727, -0.018600464, -0.0013561249, -0.045837402, 0.004878998, -0.022003174, -0.014221191, 0.033721924, -0.030654907, -0.047302246, -0.0033111572, -0.039123535, 0.037963867, 0.04043579, -0.015052795, 0.018066406, 0.02696228, -0.013557434, -0.029296875, 0.0031776428, 0.02772522, 0.0029907227, -0.0770874, 0.03378296, 0.025924683, 0.057128906, -0.027770996, 0.010307312, 0.022750854, 0.0058898926, -0.022827148, 0.041503906, 0.03250122, 0.00016307831, -0.014839172, -0.004272461, -0.007019043, -0.021316528, -0.03717041, -0.028503418, 0.02935791, 0.07348633, -0.0008664131, 0.0032253265, 0.050079346, 0.007827759, 0.002658844, -0.0058021545, 0.0005197525, -0.0024681091, -0.008407593, 0.017669678, -0.017486572, -0.025466919, 0.01158905, 0.026870728, -0.008895874, 0.039611816, -0.028533936, -0.00033521652, 0.022125244, 0.0076522827, -0.031234741, -0.020736694, 0.023422241, 0.02494812, 0.017196655, 0.03225708, -0.020614624, 0.003282547, -0.0069274902, 0.014053345, -0.007713318, 0.02746582, 0.0074424744, 0.0044059753, 0.02696228, -0.008911133, -0.033111572, -0.00818634, -0.014915466, 0.037963867, -0.05078125, 0.006980896, -0.04373169, -0.029281616, -0.003900528, 0.014968872, 0.030593872, -0.028259277, -0.058502197, -0.011787415, 0.04748535, -0.008453369 ], "summary": [ 0.051940918, 0.007736206, 0.039733887, -0.029968262, -0.008140564, 0.0011253357, 0.00605011, -0.026000977, -0.0034828186, 0.030914307, -0.020248413, -0.0054359436, -0.0138168335, -0.02116394, -0.011421204, -0.050872803, 0.024490356, 0.045898438, 0.07397461, -0.015274048, 0.008964539, -0.010322571, 0.061035156, -0.0066184998, 0.036468506, -0.06173706, 0.02859497, 0.020599365, 0.052612305, 0.0413208, 0.03955078, -0.07659912, -0.013221741, 0.041259766, 0.008544922, 0.029373169, 0.010726929, 0.02229309, 0.06591797, -0.05230713, 0.007621765, 0.01209259, 0.078063965, -0.037506104, -0.0078086853, 0.042236328, -0.0317688, -0.019042969, 0.024353027, -0.018676758, 0.0041046143, 0.010864258, 0.02279663, -0.019683838, -0.028717041, -0.0072669983, 0.0079574585, -0.000105917454, -0.0012388229, 0.01689148, -0.0033988953, 0.030532837, 0.029403687, -0.0065307617, -0.05670166, 0.00031900406, 0.0418396, -0.013458252, 0.030090332, -0.05621338, 0.007583618, 0.046783447, -0.0036792755, -0.021255493, -0.0569458, -0.006980896, 0.021514893, -0.03579712, 0.008079529, -0.0027675629, -0.012367249, 0.012069702, -0.0013799667, -0.08337402, 0.039733887, -0.04083252, -0.0058517456, -0.004108429, -0.056671143, 0.004497528, -0.028640747, -0.0064468384, -0.07293701, 0.02154541, 0.006729126, -0.018234253, -0.03274536, -0.0008149147, -0.041412354, 0.029312134, -0.06048584, 0.02684021, -0.026397705, -0.021972656, -0.015213013, 0.07220459, 0.026107788, -0.031051636, -0.028518677, -0.024291992, -0.0096206665, -0.02154541, -0.0003194809, -0.025848389, -0.024154663, 0.068237305, 0.024520874, -0.022491455, 0.0062332153, -0.0057792664, 0.026947021, 0.056884766, -0.017837524, -0.010124207, 0.03665161, 0.04135132, -0.015083313, -0.017593384, 0.0012454987, 0.059570312, -0.013015747, -0.026916504, -0.014190674, -0.029708862, -0.035705566, -0.032104492, 0.054138184, 0.015411377, 0.01398468, -0.01890564, 0.048675537, -0.0019369125, -0.012237549, 0.031280518, 0.0052604675, 0.005455017, 0.010559082, 0.008079529, 0.018630981, 0.011604309, -0.022277832, 0.0031585693, 0.038269043, -0.0063056946, -0.038238525, -0.06951904, -0.03894043, -0.033935547, 0.048706055, -0.058166504, 0.05130005, -0.020263672, -0.03967285, 0.04043579, -0.0038986206, 0.008544922, 0.044067383, 0.025756836, 0.016586304, -0.049987793, 0.00983429, 0.022766113, 0.027893066, -0.01322937, 0.00856781, 0.0008177757, -0.023422241, -0.0019836426, 0.027359009, -0.009521484, 0.01285553, -0.011978149, 0.020706177, 0.031097412, -0.017074585, 0.01361084, 0.0014791489, 0.049591064, 0.019805908, 0.011199951, -0.010231018, -0.0051231384, 0.010063171, -0.025726318, 0.003955841, 0.0008511543, -0.025054932, 0.010749817, -0.011985779, -0.029022217, -0.023803711, -0.007247925, -0.011787415, 0.010414124, -0.019760132, -0.018173218, 0.0007200241, 0.0112838745, -0.05819702, -0.023162842, 0.036468506, -0.03656006, -0.015701294, 0.03390503, 0.017059326, -0.022964478, 0.024780273, -0.029052734, 0.0037136078, -0.029876709, 0.0013771057, 0.042785645, -0.02355957, 0.054656982, -0.0062332153, -0.0074806213, -0.008117676, 0.009262085, 0.019348145, 0.0016508102, 0.032989502, -0.007160187, 0.010688782, 0.027526855, -0.009483337, -0.007701874, 0.017471313, -0.076049805, 0.0118637085, 0.030731201, 0.012702942, 0.014823914, -0.06781006, -0.052368164, 0.06262207, 0.025863647, -0.0146865845, 0.007507324, 0.0050964355, -0.004447937, 0.0690918, -0.0013561249, 0.026275635, -0.006916046, 0.059020996, 0.0045318604, 0.020401001, 0.057250977, -0.05102539, 0.014785767, -0.019012451, 0.027114868, 0.015930176, 0.00009828806, -0.010040283, 0.005332947, -0.01864624, -0.018539429, -0.016708374, -0.012268066, 0.019454956, -0.020828247, 0.00504303, -0.040863037, -0.06365967, -0.057037354, -0.033721924, 0.05166626, 0.018707275, -0.06750488, 0.00907135, 0.066589355, -0.03375244, -0.014404297, -0.018569946, 0.00074863434, -0.018981934, 0.03945923, 0.024520874, 0.033081055, 0.053222656, -0.0102005005, -0.050689697, 0.027038574, -0.025497437, -0.023910522, -0.09979248, 0.0052108765, 0.010185242, -0.046813965, -0.067871094, 0.025100708, -0.022949219, 0.018661499, 0.017410278, 0.021453857, 0.031799316, 0.001991272, 0.0066337585, 0.030517578, -0.0748291, -0.021316528, 0.0026054382, 0.009437561, -0.020629883, -0.00944519, -0.014549255, 0.0044174194, 0.008483887, 0.01701355, 0.029953003, -0.0345459, -0.023483276, 0.003074646, -0.033447266, 0.011451721, 0.030960083, -0.026367188, -0.039520264, -0.008132935, -0.014274597, -0.053863525, -0.059661865, 0.040771484, -0.0143585205, 0.014976501, 0.020828247, 0.055786133, 0.028686523, -0.03060913, 0.016708374, 0.026611328, -0.023986816, -0.01625061, 0.014694214, -0.035461426, -0.0038719177, -0.0013160706, 0.07342529, 0.0231781, -0.026901245, 0.0006799698, -0.056884766, -0.005168915, -0.04421997, 0.026855469, 0.08129883, -0.0006175041, -0.016448975, -0.050323486, 0.03540039, 0.005821228, 0.0033168793, -0.07269287, -0.0181427, -0.022521973, -0.024673462, -0.0015621185, -0.034820557, 0.03036499, 0.0005903244, 0.009063721, -0.03189087, -0.014274597, -0.07324219, 0.0078125, 0.035125732, 0.0047683716, 0.026824951, 0.035705566, 0.035827637, -0.019439697, 0.046569824, -0.054748535, 0.030822754, 0.00020813942, -0.06903076, 0.0008845329, -0.0050582886, 0.009483337, -0.013206482, 0.004058838, 0.024261475, -0.014854431, 0.0018358231, 0.0036506653, -0.007411957, 0.027328491, -0.033355713, -0.024017334, 0.016098022, 0.00012409687, 0.008163452, 0.0008392334, -0.008781433, 0.048309326, 0.033447266, 0.000004708767, 0.016098022, -0.024414062, 0.02961731, -0.00687027, 0.016830444, -0.011917114, 0.024871826, -0.06689453, 0.028961182, 0.0045318604, -0.01626587, -0.027648926, 0.009231567, -0.01109314, 0.019714355, 0.0023956299, -0.018081665, 0.049987793, -0.0023288727, 0.028717041, -0.037017822, -0.009307861, 0.018859863, -0.044647217, -0.019744873, -0.05706787, -0.016555786, -0.0057373047, -0.017196655, 0.025527954, -0.032470703, 0.00021111965, -0.002298355, 0.016143799, 0.02017212, 0.014640808, 0.039764404, -0.03414917, 0.01687622, 0.017730713, 0.07244873, 0.0072288513, -0.0030326843, -0.014945984, 0.09698486, 0.011276245, -0.035186768, -0.0076789856, -0.008140564, 0.0018606186, 0.048797607, -0.02909851, -0.038330078, -0.014526367, -0.048553467, -0.023971558, -0.016403198, 0.026046753, 0.04336548, 0.01625061, -0.015068054, 0.0017032623, 0.0037403107, -0.028366089, -0.022842407, -0.0491333, -0.0029964447, -0.043273926, 0.025878906, 0.014678955, 0.052337646, -0.04248047, -0.03451538, 0.023849487, 0.042541504, -0.07489014, -0.03652954, 0.004299164, -0.07775879, -0.0690918, -0.003622055, -0.017822266, 0.019729614, -0.0049552917, 0.0158844, -0.016601562, -0.020080566, -0.02734375, -0.0012979507, 0.012321472, -0.0041122437, -0.049438477, -0.022705078, 0.02418518, 0.00029325485, -0.006137848, -0.087524414, 0.033203125, 0.07330322, -0.010284424, 0.0076904297, -0.08892822, 0.03652954, -0.05230713, 0.012954712, 0.02949524, -0.040222168, -0.009262085, 0.023086548, 0.056488037, -0.034698486, -0.014801025, 0.030776978, 0.047058105, -0.013572693, 0.006839752, 0.0010480881, 0.0048561096, -0.02330017, 0.029815674, -0.03591919, -0.014144897, -0.021881104, 0.04940796, -0.049591064, -0.031280518, 0.051330566, -0.03414917, -0.046936035, -0.020980835, 0.03186035, 0.03488159, -0.034210205, -0.007385254, -0.0076904297, 0.070129395, 0.008392334, 0.020141602, -0.019042969, 0.060028076, -0.047729492, 0.071899414, -0.0395813, -0.041412354, -0.009475708, -0.020019531, -0.007865906, -0.03994751, -0.0345459, 0.0074691772, 0.018661499, 0.019348145, -0.020401001, 0.008491516, 0.041778564, -0.028686523, 0.029403687, 0.052093506, -0.029373169, -0.02986145, -0.03488159, 0.012641907, -0.02897644, -0.024871826, -0.011009216, -0.025283813, -0.0014162064, -0.015052795, -0.014030457, 0.003944397, 0.0036563873, 0.010269165, -0.039031982, 0.010574341, -0.0056762695, -0.028274536, -0.020996094, -0.024734497, 0.0039100647, -0.010498047, -0.046447754, -0.04425049, 0.011802673, -0.0035419464, 0.010429382, -0.020004272, 0.0116119385, 0.013038635, 0.0070533752, -0.08258057, -0.025817871, -0.012641907, 0.031463623, -0.00065135956, 0.0015850067, 0.00016796589, 0.0046081543, 0.015068054, 0.024765015, 0.023468018, 0.02684021, 0.03555298, -0.009437561, -0.042236328, 0.012237549, 0.027816772, 0.02420044, -0.011184692, -0.054901123, 0.03869629, 0.032318115, -0.017471313, 0.025512695, 0.016937256, -0.002937317, 0.02658081, -0.024505615, 0.031402588, 0.013092041, 0.02192688, -0.031280518, 0.008132935, 0.016220093, -0.009902954, -0.018310547, -0.013122559, 0.01914978, 0.000033140182, -0.01713562, -0.010154724, -0.014785767, 0.018234253, 0.029205322, 0.007827759, 0.029525757, -0.019561768, -0.04232788, -0.0385437, -0.014884949, 0.012031555, 0.003112793, -0.028411865, 0.0075187683, 0.013061523, -0.09448242, 0.028167725, 0.080078125, -0.021484375, 0.018447876, 0.006324768, -0.026000977, -0.03945923, -0.044525146, -0.05178833, -0.046325684, -0.037322998, 0.04748535, 0.0015201569, -0.026412964, 0.023956299, -0.01828003, 0.017700195, -0.008506775, -0.022583008, 0.041290283, 0.0023345947, 0.016967773, 0.0038471222, -0.005744934, -0.00036787987, -0.011428833, -0.0019340515, 0.017944336, -0.028259277, -0.027816772, -0.0146865845, -0.008544922, 0.0010852814, -0.030349731, 0.045196533, -0.0002194643, -0.015365601, -0.0006093979, 0.04208374, -0.018432617, 0.032287598, 0.029144287, -0.00066185, -0.0055999756, -0.036987305, -0.046813965, -0.00724411, 0.0032100677, -0.017120361, 0.07208252, -0.0031375885, -0.051361084, 0.0004608631, 0.022384644, 0.01309967, 0.001534462, 0.029067993, -0.018127441, -0.033111572, -0.058288574, -0.0141067505, -0.027374268, -0.009536743, 0.009971619, 0.073913574, 0.066101074, 0.005970001, 0.0017309189, -0.012626648, 0.05065918, -0.05090332, 0.009254456, -0.016799927, 0.036346436, -0.013046265, -0.011398315, 0.0099487305, 0.01197052, 0.014511108, 0.014350891, -0.010795593, -0.010894775, -0.042510986, 0.038269043, -0.0029335022, 0.013069153, 0.0005645752, -0.012611389, -0.012435913, 0.038024902, -0.007003784, -0.023864746, -0.00018370152, -0.0015411377, -0.058929443, 0.035491943, -0.0060195923, 0.06817627, -0.0016622543, -0.02571106, -0.011497498, -0.0046844482, -0.02406311, 0.0473938, 0.02519226, -0.0020542145, -0.024932861, 0.011489868, 0.0011949539, -0.032592773, -0.011985779, -0.045196533, -0.0028381348, -0.00015592575, -0.04321289, -0.04373169, -0.0019140244, 0.013328552, 0.053985596, 0.0011367798, 0.026824951, -0.072143555, -0.045684814, 0.014099121, 0.019134521, -0.0015392303, -0.0048675537, -0.03253174, 0.053863525, -0.03225708, 0.017471313, -0.0062942505, 0.025650024, 0.023956299, -0.007129669, -0.006290436, -0.009025574, -0.00724411, 0.03149414, -0.018066406, 0.0073547363, 0.0014638901, -0.0049057007, 0.033813477, -0.011329651, -0.027893066, -0.034423828, 0.003894806, 0.010902405, -0.063964844, -0.0625, -0.048431396, -0.0013303757, 0.06964111, -0.07849121, -0.015335083, 0.07055664, -0.009819031, 0.008369446, 0.014289856, -0.027908325, 0.06719971, 0.009162903, 0.055419922, 0.01663208, -0.010070801, 0.012886047, -0.018081665, 0.0124435425, 0.01902771, 0.0184021, -0.0007362366, 0.018051147, 0.03074646, -0.023513794, -0.036499023, -0.06567383, 0.04071045, -0.045196533, 0.051849365, 0.024459839, 0.021331787, 0.027008057, 0.027557373, 0.01171875, -0.02670288, 0.025772095, 0.047729492, -0.031082153, 0.041381836, 0.042816162, -0.058013916, 0.006374359, 0.045837402, -0.030014038, 0.029449463, 0.03479004, 0.015419006, -0.04321289, -0.014091492, -0.008369446, 0.0052223206, 0.043792725, 0.012863159, -0.03274536, -0.026000977, 0.02027893, -0.0035762787, -0.0032043457, 0.007896423, 0.012397766, 0.028167725, -0.0021743774, 0.047088623, 0.032196045, 0.014770508, 0.036224365, 0.013435364, -0.0859375, 0.018798828, 0.022827148, -0.028427124, 0.013092041, 0.024810791, 0.022064209, -0.012374878, 0.03643799, 0.06201172, 0.061645508, 0.058776855, -0.0491333, 0.0110321045, 0.07897949, -0.02507019, 0.031051636, 0.016189575, -0.0008664131, -0.010856628, 0.01499939, 0.020950317, 0.011383057, 0.039215088, 0.002538681, -0.032104492, 0.015159607, -0.008796692, -0.016159058, -0.015197754, -0.0014591217, -0.003145218, -0.0042877197, -0.08886719, 0.0115356445, 0.051208496, 0.03579712, -0.016616821, -0.05908203, -0.005264282, -0.0043525696, 0.021575928, 0.043518066, -0.007965088, 0.012992859, 0.008880615, -0.008338928, 0.06689453, -0.02458191, -0.013427734, 0.0011816025, 0.04360962, -0.0042152405, -0.038513184, -0.0026855469, 0.03225708, 0.019073486, -0.053863525, 0.03616333, 0.035125732, -0.035186768, -0.049346924, -0.03845215, -0.008293152, -0.034240723, 0.015029907, 0.01423645, 0.011497498, -0.03375244, -0.0038890839, -0.019241333, 0.000705719, -0.026229858, 0.03668213, 0.024154663, 0.034057617, 0.046661377, -0.032989502, 0.023071289, 0.0021324158, 0.004928589, -0.077697754, 0.042022705, -0.01751709, 0.04989624, -0.0057258606, 0.028198242, 0.012084961, 0.012893677, -0.0076560974, -0.02067566, 0.012779236, -0.013633728, 0.032409668, 0.01309967, 0.0012731552, -0.009841919, -0.040374756, -0.043762207, 0.070251465, 0.030395508, -0.033569336, -0.0065460205, 0.045928955, 0.006298065, -0.01864624, 0.018981934, 0.047698975, -0.013031006, 0.0027198792, 0.005569458, -0.04647827, -0.06719971, 0.028396606, 0.018753052, -0.03213501, 0.010810852, -0.029708862, -0.009689331, 0.0022258759, -0.04727173, -0.016525269, 0.08026123, -0.040496826, -0.04119873, 0.028259277, -0.004085541, 0.0034637451, 0.03189087, -0.013244629, 0.016586304, 0.017562866, 0.017868042, 0.006286621, 0.02822876, 0.025741577, -0.00944519, -0.011993408, -0.027862549, -0.006340027, 0.013191223, -0.020370483, 0.015037537, 0.013160706, -0.033416748, 0.018173218, 0.028335571, 0.0074157715, 0.0035209656, 0.010192871, 0.029342651, -0.008453369, 0.008102417 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06413v1
Forte: An Interactive Visual Analytic Tool for Trust-Augmented Net Load Forecasting
Kaustav Bhattacharjee, Soumya Kundu, Indrasis Chakraborty, Aritra Dasgupta
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.SP
Accurate net load forecasting is vital for energy planning, aiding decisions on trade and load distribution. However, assessing the performance of forecasting models across diverse input variables, like temperature and humidity, remains challenging, particularly for eliciting a high degree of trust in the model outcomes. In this context, there is a growing need for data-driven technological interventions to aid scientists in comprehending how models react to both noisy and clean input variables, thus shedding light on complex behaviors and fostering confidence in the outcomes. In this paper, we present Forte, a visual analytics-based application to explore deep probabilistic net load forecasting models across various input variables and understand the error rates for different scenarios. With carefully designed visual interventions, this web-based interface empowers scientists to derive insights about model performance by simulating diverse scenarios, facilitating an informed decision-making process. We discuss observations made using Forte and demonstrate the effectiveness of visualization techniques to provide valuable insights into the correlation between weather inputs and net load forecasts, ultimately advancing grid capabilities by improving trust in forecasting models.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06413v1
2023-11-10T22:15:11
2023-11-10T22:15:11
{ "title": [ 0.01914978, 0.003993988, -0.048614502, -0.074401855, 0.0051574707, -0.003835678, -0.0074768066, -0.0029850006, -0.006504059, 0.028961182, -0.019577026, 0.015563965, -0.02557373, -0.02998352, -0.043884277, -0.020843506, -0.0027713776, 0.0057907104, -0.045654297, -0.042297363, -0.004306793, -0.06262207, 0.03326416, 0.07904053, 0.025680542, -0.027297974, -0.042999268, 0.0038166046, -0.0025863647, -0.0075149536, -0.015007019, -0.006214142, 0.0345459, -0.011749268, 0.011764526, -0.0035133362, -0.027694702, 0.013137817, 0.0033626556, -0.0055885315, 0.015022278, -0.017578125, 0.009490967, -0.026428223, -0.03540039, 0.052215576, -0.07684326, -0.016799927, -0.013244629, 0.035583496, 0.012672424, 0.013153076, 0.014884949, 0.028686523, 0.012687683, -0.02999878, -0.08123779, 0.051116943, 0.027648926, 0.048980713, 0.025726318, -0.054473877, 0.009719849, 0.00356102, -0.04876709, -0.017578125, 0.0056114197, 0.000111699104, 0.101745605, -0.015670776, -0.02810669, 0.064208984, 0.0047721863, 0.022506714, -0.020370483, -0.029449463, 0.039733887, 0.0031223297, 0.036499023, 0.0022678375, -0.0033073425, -0.013000488, 0.010673523, 0.005302429, -0.0143585205, 0.008010864, -0.011482239, -0.009803772, -0.003768921, -0.005836487, -0.0076904297, 0.022003174, 0.04647827, 0.022506714, -0.04788208, -0.003873825, -0.025787354, 0.02130127, -0.00258255, -0.036468506, -0.033233643, 0.0423584, -0.091552734, -0.000025808811, 0.012039185, 0.081726074, 0.004055023, 0.014167786, 0.018005371, 0.0053710938, 0.01751709, -0.018341064, 0.028778076, 0.058776855, -0.03668213, -0.0005326271, 0.011482239, -0.008399963, -0.026351929, 0.053619385, -0.031066895, -0.030548096, -0.006450653, 0.018585205, 0.03314209, -0.01777649, -0.022583008, 0.034606934, -0.036895752, 0.0546875, 0.001086235, 0.012420654, -0.06542969, -0.04824829, -0.049316406, 0.019744873, -0.0056114197, 0.018829346, 0.008071899, -0.0022621155, 0.01914978, -0.022155762, 0.014549255, 0.039093018, 0.08093262, 0.0009083748, 0.04309082, 0.010772705, 0.0023918152, 0.0053977966, 0.015014648, 0.022750854, 0.003211975, 0.0038032532, -0.016357422, -0.0039138794, -0.05734253, -0.019195557, 0.006904602, -0.0004246235, -0.012214661, -0.015914917, -0.0070610046, 0.0024909973, 0.03503418, 0.012748718, 0.01108551, 0.026062012, 0.012535095, 0.051605225, -0.014541626, -0.03665161, 0.01638794, -0.006614685, -0.01285553, 0.038360596, 0.020996094, 0.00831604, 0.033721924, -0.0149002075, 0.0006532669, -0.012481689, 0.0289917, 0.016723633, -0.03579712, -0.04067993, -0.0023651123, -0.029373169, 0.036376953, 0.0031871796, -0.01777649, 0.040222168, -0.027023315, -0.022872925, -0.029022217, -0.0061683655, -0.004173279, 0.026504517, -0.015701294, -0.0066604614, -0.017730713, 0.015068054, -0.048980713, 0.017349243, -0.046173096, -0.04547119, -0.0025291443, 0.027542114, 0.0036125183, 0.04309082, 0.032196045, -0.000022292137, -0.033721924, 0.00029444695, -0.014053345, -0.04574585, 0.026062012, -0.042419434, -0.010406494, -0.018753052, -0.0023498535, 0.017410278, -0.015144348, 0.02810669, -0.015037537, -0.023498535, 0.012275696, -0.022354126, 0.029083252, -0.00242424, 0.08404541, -0.012496948, 0.041931152, 0.029418945, 0.021728516, -0.00667572, 0.02671814, -0.029205322, 0.010856628, 0.011566162, 0.02003479, -0.023208618, -0.016418457, -0.012863159, 0.016067505, -0.01259613, 0.026565552, -0.0057258606, 0.048309326, 0.020492554, 0.050811768, 0.014801025, 0.050476074, 0.05380249, 0.03074646, 0.039489746, -0.016494751, 0.008743286, -0.0026664734, -0.01499939, 0.017349243, 0.04425049, 0.0062561035, 0.022613525, -0.039489746, 0.014404297, -0.032196045, 0.009376526, -0.007381439, 0.02166748, 0.038879395, -0.032226562, -0.004184723, -0.038208008, -0.015213013, -0.036346436, -0.048583984, 0.060058594, -0.00039482117, -0.061798096, 0.0040626526, 0.010559082, 0.035247803, -0.012420654, 0.018554688, 0.013847351, 0.0071105957, -0.006816864, 0.0016622543, 0.02973938, 0.03488159, 0.06695557, 0.02607727, 0.01675415, 0.0025100708, 0.026107788, 0.052734375, 0.048828125, -0.00894165, 0.030761719, -0.05090332, 0.022277832, 0.013206482, -0.0034008026, -0.010437012, 0.04650879, 0.042755127, 0.0010232925, -0.04425049, -0.009422302, -0.053588867, -0.01763916, 0.012123108, -0.056549072, -0.022338867, -0.03540039, -0.014549255, -0.024017334, -0.035827637, 0.031982422, -0.018432617, -0.030700684, -0.009513855, 0.0033988953, -0.0033855438, 0.017944336, -0.009086609, -0.0026988983, -0.044647217, 0.00818634, 0.029968262, -0.014160156, -0.052520752, 0.010223389, 0.011619568, 0.023117065, -0.017837524, -0.0131073, -0.0357666, -0.0011930466, -0.0513916, 0.0025634766, 0.021606445, -0.06878662, -0.011474609, -0.062072754, 0.0021018982, -0.011856079, -0.030822754, 0.0021800995, 0.04598999, 0.006511688, -0.026947021, -0.023544312, 0.022857666, -0.029129028, 0.0030956268, -0.018478394, -0.0062561035, -0.035247803, 0.031204224, 0.006023407, -0.00907135, -0.041900635, 0.005466461, -0.052490234, -0.00010210276, -0.040893555, -0.032440186, 0.049102783, -0.020904541, -0.02607727, -0.04083252, -0.030059814, -0.053497314, -0.00484848, 0.019119263, -0.0055999756, -0.006679535, -0.0050354004, 0.02494812, 0.023162842, 0.009643555, 0.01625061, 0.097961426, 0.010047913, 0.044677734, 0.026351929, 0.04196167, -0.020980835, -0.004383087, -0.02519226, -0.029327393, 0.0154418945, 0.012199402, -0.010940552, -0.02192688, 0.015312195, -0.11621094, 0.024551392, 0.013206482, 0.012062073, -0.016464233, 0.00070142746, -0.048706055, -0.0234375, -0.018417358, -0.027816772, 0.04006958, 0.02720642, 0.006298065, 0.013076782, -0.0040779114, 0.004840851, -0.0039405823, -0.03640747, -0.04562378, 0.017303467, -0.027740479, -0.014823914, 0.019256592, -0.03994751, -0.005622864, 0.011367798, 0.026290894, 0.05029297, 0.040161133, -0.009887695, 0.014877319, -0.03503418, 0.021728516, -0.046661377, 0.0035152435, -0.03729248, -0.043640137, -0.031707764, -0.013420105, 0.062347412, 0.011520386, -0.0032424927, -0.041046143, -0.005695343, -0.008171082, 0.022277832, 0.0039367676, -0.0395813, -0.00041747093, -0.015930176, 0.012931824, -0.0060539246, 0.015960693, -0.00069475174, 0.053131104, 0.0022907257, -0.00081062317, -0.027252197, 0.022644043, 0.019958496, 0.010871887, -0.008079529, 0.03753662, -0.0053367615, -0.07281494, 0.021072388, 0.024520874, 0.0029850006, 0.07159424, -0.006248474, -0.028503418, 0.025665283, -0.01979065, -0.024169922, 0.0068092346, -0.005115509, -0.01386261, -0.02583313, -0.011650085, 0.006549835, 0.016921997, -0.012557983, 0.03918457, -0.0010662079, 0.0055274963, -0.049224854, 0.0017814636, -0.002412796, -0.10858154, -0.027023315, 0.012367249, -0.0063476562, -0.0024776459, -0.015792847, 0.029434204, -0.015312195, -0.021484375, -0.0079422, -0.008918762, 0.002664566, -0.00082826614, -0.117492676, 0.010223389, 0.08734131, 0.01966858, 0.060272217, 0.0256958, 0.023010254, 0.008605957, -0.011245728, 0.002029419, -0.045043945, 0.022247314, -0.031433105, -0.03866577, 0.041778564, -0.028289795, 0.007873535, 0.021865845, 0.0053215027, -0.008361816, 0.0038852692, 0.039794922, 0.058532715, -0.04067993, 0.033996582, 0.031799316, -0.035003662, -0.057739258, 0.01020813, -0.012107849, -0.008720398, -0.0022792816, -0.0041770935, 0.01902771, 0.015670776, 0.025268555, 0.033691406, -0.011917114, 0.028762817, 0.017181396, -0.05206299, -0.018295288, -0.008613586, 0.011764526, 0.008621216, 0.030334473, 0.029785156, 0.06329346, 0.08721924, -0.040985107, 0.03225708, -0.012008667, 0.026672363, -0.06677246, 0.0007162094, -0.03970337, -0.053009033, -0.05026245, 0.037902832, -0.029159546, 0.0017414093, 0.03149414, 0.0035648346, -0.040008545, 0.010055542, 0.026947021, 0.00043702126, -0.0014829636, -0.05645752, -0.008407593, 0.00025224686, -0.055725098, -0.03338623, -0.014274597, -0.007293701, 0.015670776, -0.015281677, 0.001329422, 0.051513672, -0.00818634, 0.0066337585, 0.027770996, -0.018615723, -0.01637268, 0.08581543, -0.0014820099, -0.035736084, 0.021957397, 0.021759033, 0.00484848, -0.03100586, -0.0101623535, -0.017578125, -0.015357971, -0.011672974, 0.025436401, -0.0021362305, 0.03112793, -0.01725769, 0.039489746, 0.0056991577, 0.011405945, 0.019424438, 0.014755249, -0.029327393, 0.00818634, 0.031173706, 0.032409668, 0.025314331, -0.0073509216, 0.026412964, 0.015838623, -0.0022792816, 0.018951416, -0.0027389526, 0.016220093, 0.014877319, -0.032928467, 0.04699707, 0.027770996, -0.02015686, 0.02998352, -0.002658844, 0.025421143, -0.023345947, 0.025390625, -0.012527466, 0.00907135, 0.02166748, -0.016738892, 0.020477295, -0.007659912, 0.01449585, -0.032287598, -0.07312012, 0.020065308, 0.056884766, -0.021911621, 0.00063085556, -0.01979065, 0.03967285, 0.010177612, 0.06402588, -0.0032405853, 0.026657104, 0.061431885, 0.019561768, 0.011222839, -0.029418945, -0.029373169, 0.0015716553, 0.013946533, -0.0064888, -0.0848999, 0.005191803, -0.034210205, -0.031707764, 0.004802704, -0.021957397, 0.010368347, -0.08154297, 0.027359009, 0.034576416, 0.013000488, 0.006263733, 0.011795044, 0.03942871, 0.037109375, 0.041290283, 0.018066406, 0.009468079, 0.008056641, 0.0062179565, 0.05331421, -0.011238098, -0.014305115, -0.023361206, 0.04574585, -0.013648987, 0.027816772, -0.037597656, 0.02935791, 0.04626465, -0.02406311, 0.023391724, -0.049987793, 0.01828003, 0.016098022, 0.00856781, 0.025283813, -0.05419922, -0.017333984, -0.0024318695, -0.03640747, -0.03930664, 0.016326904, -0.01576233, -0.03149414, -0.0135650635, -0.0073432922, -0.0076522827, -0.021072388, 0.02619934, 0.04699707, 0.011329651, 0.017211914, 0.054473877, -0.047027588, 0.034942627, -0.03286743, 0.008804321, 0.03756714, 0.021942139, 0.0022087097, -0.0015153885, -0.045440674, -0.04385376, -0.016647339, 0.0050582886, 0.018798828, 0.04534912, -0.014915466, -0.034729004, -0.0017280579, 0.013069153, 0.026885986, 0.038208008, -0.030654907, 0.020202637, -0.008110046, -0.0119018555, 0.024642944, 0.05831909, 0.020843506, 0.017929077, -0.002046585, -0.025665283, 0.058654785, -0.04748535, -0.027069092, -0.028823853, -0.06762695, 0.017654419, 0.014305115, -0.010002136, -0.053619385, 0.0013866425, 0.02255249, -0.036224365, -0.010299683, -0.022079468, 0.057128906, -0.028579712, -0.07299805, -0.040893555, 0.0032653809, -0.032165527, 0.029022217, 0.01689148, -0.050994873, -0.012916565, -0.054748535, -0.025909424, 0.004627228, 0.044708252, 0.010597229, 0.04449463, -0.072753906, -0.013793945, -0.05026245, -0.00831604, -0.04534912, 0.048858643, -0.0028190613, -0.03201294, -0.018844604, -0.016204834, -0.0031108856, 0.017990112, 0.018585205, 0.021652222, -0.025177002, 0.043395996, -0.07128906, -0.0022583008, -0.0317688, -0.029129028, 0.024154663, 0.027832031, -0.048461914, 0.031951904, 0.013298035, 0.048797607, 0.011367798, 0.042175293, 0.042877197, 0.018356323, 0.005996704, 0.000849247, -0.025894165, -0.040985107, -0.009101868, -0.049957275, -0.0012807846, -0.031951904, -0.006187439, -0.060302734, 0.0052375793, 0.018249512, 0.019348145, 0.028030396, 0.0022068024, 0.037109375, 0.014328003, -0.004020691, 0.0011692047, 0.049438477, 0.025756836, 0.00072574615, -0.011268616, 0.019729614, 0.037384033, 0.031173706, 0.0118255615, 0.00894928, -0.035858154, -0.039001465, 0.0044822693, 0.01940918, 0.017181396, -0.025680542, -0.024475098, -0.041900635, 0.01852417, -0.028167725, 0.0068588257, 0.07537842, 0.0413208, 0.038360596, -0.048919678, 0.018859863, 0.022445679, -0.029434204, 0.020477295, 0.07507324, -0.07122803, 0.0021781921, -0.026626587, -0.03451538, 0.036956787, 0.0259552, 0.04586792, -0.08642578, -0.06048584, 0.054229736, 0.029800415, 0.010047913, -0.012367249, -0.04324341, -0.021636963, 0.0152282715, 0.03479004, -0.011512756, 0.0010919571, -0.018127441, 0.033203125, -0.010177612, 0.012832642, -0.024505615, 0.037231445, -0.07647705, 0.015426636, -0.046813965, 0.020568848, -0.009170532, -0.043273926, 0.000364542, 0.015449524, -0.044128418, -0.024642944, 0.0035572052, 0.04360962, 0.01259613, 0.058502197, 0.028442383, -0.016403198, -0.017288208, -0.03640747, 0.044006348, 0.03665161, -0.039031982, 0.019332886, -0.038848877, -0.049957275, 0.044830322, -0.057525635, 0.053009033, -0.013061523, 0.009773254, -0.04525757, 0.030807495, 0.022476196, -0.06097412, 0.02508545, -0.012809753, -0.04449463, -0.0026378632, 0.0023021698, 0.01612854, -0.01928711, -0.0009160042, 0.0309906, 0.02861023, 0.0050239563, 0.014419556, -0.016448975, -0.056915283, 0.036712646, -0.016433716, 0.07067871, -0.024856567, -0.021438599, -0.008987427, 0.01626587, 0.014465332, -0.031799316, -0.026351929, -0.026168823, -0.0056648254, -0.043182373, 0.005203247, 0.008666992, -0.030090332, -0.023468018, 0.048797607, -0.016921997, -0.011703491, 0.020889282, 0.046173096, -0.034362793, -0.034851074, 0.0064048767, -0.0390625, 0.037902832, -0.013343811, -0.002878189, -0.015342712, 0.03186035, -0.013748169, -0.020431519, 0.0054359436, 0.022033691, -0.005432129, -0.045135498, 0.0057029724, 0.037628174, 0.027893066, -0.029876709, -0.019226074, 0.02947998, 0.03161621, -0.034820557, 0.02432251, 0.040008545, 0.01776123, 0.0075187683, 0.01637268, 0.0016374588, -0.045776367, -0.07446289, -0.05041504, 0.033935547, 0.026977539, -0.0028629303, -0.041168213, 0.037231445, 0.014099121, -0.018630981, 0.014839172, -0.007156372, -0.02758789, 0.0070762634, 0.007724762, -0.0115737915, -0.047607422, 0.030349731, 0.04284668, -0.02015686, 0.026290894, -0.011047363, -0.00027799606, 0.020828247, -0.0018548965, 0.0024337769, -0.05593872, 0.032318115, 0.030197144, 0.0026378632, 0.05618286, 0.0013561249, -0.033843994, -0.017349243, -0.020599365, -0.019744873, -0.015213013, 0.06774902, -0.054901123, -0.004070282, -0.03225708, -0.05117798, 0.0029182434, -0.019927979, 0.022628784, -0.06854248, 0.046813965, -0.046051025, -0.019470215, 0.014472961, 0.0044174194, 0.002418518, 0.00012540817, -0.06793213, -0.03286743, 0.0017499924, -0.027328491 ], "summary": [ 0.046295166, -0.0016174316, -0.000059604645, -0.08325195, -0.023849487, 0.01096344, -0.053863525, 0.0046157837, 0.033355713, 0.013435364, -0.03161621, 0.013320923, -0.03125, -0.015426636, -0.032928467, -0.03201294, 0.0068740845, -0.01449585, -0.02822876, -0.037261963, 0.03741455, -0.03933716, -0.013198853, 0.06112671, 0.024291992, -0.008125305, -0.06585693, 0.013374329, 0.0107040405, 0.029922485, -0.0019931793, -0.013305664, 0.041046143, -0.03503418, -0.004459381, -0.01927185, 0.0021343231, -0.030456543, -0.028900146, 0.013954163, 0.03567505, -0.041107178, 0.02078247, -0.04058838, -0.016311646, 0.047607422, -0.021728516, -0.012062073, 0.030654907, 0.031677246, 0.008407593, 0.009841919, 0.0060272217, 0.0045661926, -0.035339355, -0.04824829, -0.10131836, 0.047088623, 0.0026493073, 0.064697266, 0.030059814, -0.031234741, -0.009292603, -0.008026123, -0.036010742, 0.00025749207, 0.008125305, -0.009635925, 0.07208252, -0.017868042, -0.015975952, 0.046142578, 0.0029201508, 0.013725281, 0.0055885315, -0.036712646, 0.011238098, -0.011314392, 0.014175415, 0.031799316, -0.0014848709, 0.017623901, 0.052459717, -0.018356323, -0.03918457, -0.026153564, -0.019119263, 0.004070282, 0.027679443, 0.024856567, -0.02116394, 0.04046631, 0.030578613, 0.06137085, -0.02998352, 0.024810791, -0.023727417, -0.0146102905, 0.003604889, -0.029006958, 0.023345947, -0.02609253, -0.0289917, 0.009628296, -0.0074920654, 0.123413086, 0.034301758, 0.024215698, -0.010101318, -0.02104187, 0.032440186, -0.0793457, -0.0031337738, 0.016998291, -0.045928955, 0.037322998, 0.006164551, -0.003572464, -0.0058517456, 0.051513672, -0.026443481, 0.00869751, -0.07434082, 0.035705566, -0.007347107, -0.03201294, 0.0209198, 0.052093506, -0.02784729, 0.031036377, -0.035583496, 0.013076782, 0.02116394, 0.0072402954, -0.0340271, -0.023544312, 0.02330017, -0.018539429, -0.0034236908, -0.0068092346, 0.0058021545, -0.013435364, 0.006511688, 0.026397705, 0.0715332, 0.009857178, 0.00907135, 0.029266357, 0.020477295, 0.00982666, 0.03933716, -0.0047454834, 0.012252808, 0.002216339, -0.0012216568, -0.009338379, -0.0019989014, -0.008155823, -0.0017147064, -0.007949829, 0.008361816, -0.00844574, 0.0003194809, 0.025482178, 0.007255554, 0.0000692606, -0.004459381, 0.009155273, 0.0006322861, 0.019195557, -0.032104492, -0.037231445, -0.012916565, -0.004764557, -0.004322052, 0.044677734, 0.02279663, 0.027267456, 0.017044067, -0.0023727417, -0.02394104, -0.03817749, 0.048309326, -0.017471313, 0.027359009, -0.07336426, 0.017456055, -0.03164673, 0.01776123, 0.017837524, -0.012397766, 0.007850647, -0.011749268, -0.002658844, -0.02835083, 0.013877869, -0.02848816, 0.034240723, -0.021347046, -0.013023376, -0.019226074, 0.00793457, -0.0076904297, -0.008453369, -0.046905518, -0.005809784, -0.0017595291, 0.04724121, -0.026992798, -0.0063705444, 0.025009155, -0.029129028, -0.011161804, -0.0079574585, -0.018417358, -0.02619934, 0.029556274, -0.06518555, 0.0024986267, -0.029342651, 0.002752304, 0.064575195, -0.0418396, 0.0602417, -0.037750244, -0.040130615, 0.015838623, 0.006362915, 0.031463623, -0.0115737915, 0.07696533, -0.027053833, 0.034240723, 0.02557373, 0.00699234, 0.014961243, 0.06335449, -0.060760498, 0.008773804, 0.030258179, 0.008880615, 0.016601562, -0.02935791, 0.009010315, 0.012046814, -0.005634308, 0.007167816, 0.023498535, 0.020050049, 0.037109375, -0.004760742, 0.0037403107, 0.023422241, 0.01348114, -0.009384155, 0.034973145, -0.016326904, -0.013900757, 0.043792725, 0.0044441223, -0.009269714, 0.07757568, 0.04309082, 0.024383545, 0.0075263977, -0.015090942, -0.031341553, -0.02670288, -0.018173218, -0.0017681122, 0.030975342, -0.042755127, -0.027862549, -0.0357666, 0.008255005, -0.026321411, -0.04928589, 0.056640625, -0.011711121, -0.036254883, -0.011734009, 0.014778137, 0.003862381, -0.01576233, 0.011962891, 0.017547607, 0.018707275, -0.008331299, 0.0435791, 0.07067871, 0.035858154, 0.0635376, 0.013580322, 0.039093018, -0.0031967163, 0.011703491, 0.016479492, 0.015625, 0.0022945404, -0.011878967, -0.026535034, 0.03503418, -0.0015439987, -0.023071289, -0.025512695, 0.034484863, 0.009429932, -0.0014829636, -0.016906738, -0.004070282, -0.06726074, 0.0034732819, 0.0181427, -0.010879517, 0.013664246, -0.0040893555, -0.019210815, 0.016357422, -0.018920898, 0.051330566, -0.03643799, 0.0006375313, -0.011619568, 0.011642456, 0.0009899139, 0.018356323, 0.01612854, 0.015060425, -0.028778076, -0.02734375, -0.026657104, -0.04977417, -0.011352539, 0.03289795, -0.003458023, -0.011878967, -0.010475159, -0.018478394, -0.029525757, -0.015419006, -0.056121826, -0.043823242, 0.00031399727, -0.052978516, -0.02708435, -0.031585693, -0.0026741028, -0.010345459, -0.062164307, -0.013381958, 0.05508423, -0.0035972595, -0.029327393, -0.031921387, -0.004798889, -0.033050537, 0.031982422, -0.050079346, -0.026016235, -0.0758667, 0.0013132095, -0.0132369995, -0.05218506, -0.07165527, 0.041503906, -0.005001068, -0.0043945312, -0.055725098, -0.028198242, 0.035858154, 0.017242432, 0.011459351, -0.040130615, -0.037261963, -0.067871094, 0.004928589, 0.07751465, 0.01991272, 0.015312195, 0.055267334, 0.061523438, 0.043426514, 0.016113281, 0.008583069, 0.101623535, 0.0061950684, 0.053344727, 0.043701172, 0.042022705, -0.008483887, -0.027877808, -0.03933716, 0.014099121, -0.008903503, 0.0051612854, -0.0061798096, -0.030349731, 0.015808105, -0.07141113, 0.006034851, -0.013885498, 0.030883789, 0.026794434, -0.0154800415, -0.020309448, 0.00024020672, -0.021713257, -0.022918701, 0.019561768, 0.048034668, 0.007801056, -0.0044441223, 0.0024032593, -0.0016517639, -0.0068969727, 0.008148193, 0.045013428, -0.0104904175, 0.011413574, -0.01651001, 0.014350891, -0.010643005, 0.03213501, 0.017074585, 0.035491943, 0.029632568, 0.012748718, -0.025360107, 0.013595581, -0.025054932, 0.0049819946, -0.035339355, -0.007904053, -0.032196045, -0.04537964, -0.0037250519, -0.002735138, 0.042999268, 0.005794525, -0.03302002, -0.00856781, 0.004688263, -0.00945282, 0.003036499, -0.0007548332, -0.012573242, 0.030975342, 0.008285522, 0.024551392, -0.050628662, -0.009597778, 0.0007362366, 0.09814453, 0.02142334, 0.020401001, 0.00074386597, 0.0057754517, 0.046813965, 0.047027588, -0.00095415115, 0.030197144, -0.007118225, -0.04260254, 0.029510498, 0.007144928, -0.008674622, 0.036865234, -0.00060129166, -0.01637268, 0.009666443, -0.015052795, 0.005645752, -0.018798828, -0.014640808, -0.0007472038, -0.029693604, 0.013664246, -0.009788513, 0.047424316, -0.025604248, 0.014533997, 0.0074539185, -0.053985596, -0.0075683594, 0.00044035912, 0.0022945404, -0.04559326, -0.018554688, 0.024963379, 0.042877197, 0.028152466, 0.0070228577, 0.051879883, 0.012077332, 0.0013856888, 0.008995056, -0.01675415, 0.055541992, -0.0102005005, -0.09020996, 0.037628174, -0.023651123, 0.049438477, 0.06762695, -0.007194519, 0.039611816, 0.052764893, -0.0042266846, -0.009338379, -0.016723633, 0.019760132, -0.05065918, 0.0024318695, 0.024215698, -0.028076172, -0.008621216, 0.011352539, 0.009521484, -0.03414917, 0.0034255981, 0.031982422, 0.041992188, -0.0068626404, -0.009880066, 0.04058838, -0.01991272, 0.0025787354, 0.024917603, 0.0026168823, -0.004875183, -0.010971069, 0.00642395, -0.006626129, 0.008560181, 0.024871826, -0.029006958, -0.03677368, 0.007850647, 0.0000641942, -0.042388916, -0.027709961, -0.017837524, -0.004638672, 0.023208618, 0.021194458, 0.010948181, 0.047424316, 0.08935547, -0.10180664, 0.08050537, 0.0044403076, 0.0077400208, -0.04119873, 0.0052108765, 0.021194458, -0.034301758, -0.043884277, 0.019363403, -0.008895874, 0.016815186, 0.023956299, -0.03793335, -0.015235901, 0.025527954, 0.025390625, 0.011993408, -0.025054932, -0.08258057, -0.0025901794, -0.022766113, -0.0262146, -0.044006348, -0.03817749, -0.013381958, -0.024963379, 0.006061554, -0.0039100647, 0.0501709, -0.038635254, 0.003698349, 0.032073975, 0.0060043335, -0.024963379, 0.06311035, -0.016403198, -0.010421753, -0.007633209, 0.02130127, -0.02909851, -0.036895752, -0.0030059814, 0.0000039339066, -0.019454956, -0.013290405, 0.034942627, 0.021133423, 0.02748108, -0.022140503, 0.017623901, 0.0005631447, 0.027542114, 0.013786316, 0.0076942444, 0.00035238266, -0.014602661, 0.026153564, 0.0066070557, 0.055877686, -0.008049011, -0.023223877, -0.0025024414, -0.019699097, 0.022979736, 0.022705078, 0.0034332275, -0.02709961, -0.0018310547, 0.016677856, 0.0657959, -0.015327454, 0.031204224, 0.022720337, -0.004989624, 0.021820068, -0.0052452087, 0.0042266846, 0.0028915405, 0.039855957, -0.018661499, -0.0045204163, 0.019378662, -0.008552551, -0.024047852, -0.06921387, -0.0055503845, 0.06555176, 0.0042915344, -0.008865356, -0.019821167, 0.02293396, -0.0158844, 0.0546875, -0.026367188, -0.010269165, 0.13330078, 0.009094238, 0.0035247803, 0.016708374, 0.018798828, 0.0004696846, 0.047210693, -0.0132369995, -0.076538086, -0.027114868, 0.03253174, -0.027313232, 0.04083252, -0.0019226074, -0.012741089, -0.07128906, -0.04486084, -0.033111572, -0.012130737, -0.06323242, 0.060577393, 0.017456055, 0.02986145, 0.031463623, 0.0099105835, 0.0053138733, -0.027709961, 0.03277588, 0.009391785, -0.03665161, -0.01574707, 0.015342712, 0.028274536, -0.004787445, 0.011642456, -0.018173218, 0.009689331, 0.04248047, 0.0039138794, 0.009635925, -0.030807495, 0.03024292, 0.005241394, 0.0045051575, 0.030593872, -0.0284729, 0.010986328, 0.00674057, -0.005809784, -0.023483276, -0.012901306, -0.00044870377, -0.023986816, -0.0032787323, -0.02709961, -0.0008740425, -0.030685425, 0.014694214, 0.048706055, 0.014175415, -0.028167725, 0.00737381, 0.012924194, 0.04348755, -0.01676941, 0.0023269653, 0.008354187, 0.012771606, 0.014030457, -0.0010795593, -0.045837402, -0.02204895, 0.010192871, -0.03201294, -0.0036849976, 0.06738281, -0.017211914, -0.02217102, 0.03274536, 0.0031089783, 0.007965088, 0.066223145, -0.026321411, 0.015686035, -0.0012044907, -0.018112183, 0.042297363, 0.018966675, -0.032989502, 0.011856079, 0.018539429, -0.0023059845, 0.05001831, -0.021118164, -0.021331787, -0.02154541, -0.030776978, 0.018539429, 0.013374329, 0.004585266, -0.05709839, -0.014411926, -0.02368164, -0.048858643, -0.0014438629, -0.044952393, 0.03262329, 0.02911377, -0.06842041, -0.02909851, 0.003271103, -0.015457153, 0.005126953, 0.011459351, -0.037200928, 0.0032691956, -0.04953003, 0.013244629, -0.018920898, 0.0052261353, 0.050567627, 0.023483276, -0.045074463, 0.001282692, -0.011177063, -0.00069379807, -0.00035071373, 0.0496521, -0.008384705, -0.030349731, -0.027938843, -0.00055885315, -0.035369873, 0.06323242, 0.025421143, 0.0206604, -0.034240723, 0.062927246, -0.035888672, -0.009735107, -0.03201294, 0.008903503, 0.001531601, 0.0602417, -0.059753418, 0.011772156, 0.040985107, 0.043823242, 0.017456055, 0.013313293, 0.031677246, 0.029083252, 0.02394104, 0.0005311966, -0.026382446, -0.012908936, -0.0184021, -0.03704834, -0.040039062, -0.008331299, -0.025680542, 0.036743164, -0.014930725, 0.00055646896, -0.017623901, 0.067871094, -0.019119263, 0.022384644, 0.03805542, -0.06072998, 0.053527832, -0.007423401, 0.0028076172, -0.020248413, 0.0063323975, 0.0021018982, 0.021514893, 0.041778564, 0.00092458725, 0.010253906, -0.017578125, -0.022781372, 0.008575439, 0.010025024, -0.0033302307, -0.024627686, -0.0158844, -0.027862549, 0.023025513, -0.0077552795, 0.010948181, 0.05770874, 0.015930176, 0.1048584, -0.05871582, 0.01084137, 0.0791626, -0.04144287, 0.05050659, 0.062316895, -0.03778076, -0.057037354, -0.015014648, -0.020050049, 0.04989624, 0.012886047, 0.031982422, -0.06652832, -0.06402588, 0.048339844, 0.023544312, 0.021392822, -0.017150879, -0.043273926, -0.021774292, 0.01600647, 0.006591797, -0.010231018, -0.027038574, -0.023162842, 0.009887695, -0.010292053, 0.039031982, -0.013725281, 0.042419434, -0.05105591, 0.0015296936, -0.053344727, 0.0028762817, 0.009361267, -0.023986816, 0.011993408, 0.01763916, -0.0071105957, -0.004962921, 0.007270813, 0.06756592, 0.016937256, 0.05545044, -0.016159058, 0.0019989014, 0.027832031, 0.01121521, 0.01828003, 0.010292053, -0.0016145706, 0.025466919, -0.040527344, -0.013549805, 0.024154663, -0.0395813, 0.04751587, -0.016845703, 0.022537231, -0.05029297, 0.025115967, -0.04336548, -0.020523071, 0.036468506, -0.039855957, -0.073913574, 0.013694763, 0.0019721985, 0.0236969, 0.018615723, -0.03286743, -0.00919342, 0.027114868, -0.006008148, 0.017807007, 0.0034313202, -0.02229309, 0.030914307, -0.002790451, 0.070617676, 0.006225586, -0.040130615, 0.0041503906, 0.024398804, 0.030166626, -0.013687134, -0.013771057, 0.013793945, 0.02458191, -0.053009033, 0.020309448, 0.01486969, -0.024795532, -0.06829834, 0.09008789, -0.034606934, -0.012535095, 0.049102783, 0.039520264, 0.0016326904, -0.046295166, 0.007286072, -0.025817871, 0.019226074, -0.046813965, 0.02558899, -0.042938232, 0.035858154, 0.006038666, -0.06713867, 0.005821228, -0.005256653, -0.003583908, -0.0385437, -0.010299683, 0.011894226, 0.028259277, -0.017227173, -0.026153564, 0.03479004, 0.016677856, -0.019088745, 0.0019836426, -0.00032114983, -0.0023975372, 0.008125305, 0.057006836, -0.0060920715, -0.02861023, -0.047790527, -0.048797607, 0.016845703, -0.0035705566, -0.017578125, -0.0413208, 0.04159546, -0.007118225, -0.0154800415, 0.013847351, -0.020996094, -0.043884277, -0.005886078, -0.018951416, 0.010269165, -0.070617676, 0.031280518, 0.026809692, -0.030776978, -0.009315491, -0.009963989, -0.0038642883, 0.009681702, -0.035491943, 0.00592041, -0.04510498, 0.004459381, -0.001832962, 0.003314972, 0.01083374, 0.031951904, -0.03793335, 0.006122589, -0.029083252, -0.028839111, -0.020263672, 0.07330322, -0.09942627, -0.04498291, -0.016921997, -0.029022217, -0.025787354, -0.01687622, 0.01651001, -0.0335083, 0.026489258, -0.00029850006, -0.0065307617, 0.025527954, -0.0073509216, -0.032226562, 0.036254883, -0.03366089, -0.0032157898, -0.056549072, -0.015060425 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07178v1
Game Solving with Online Fine-Tuning
Ti-Rong Wu, Hung Guei, Ting Han Wei, Chung-Chin Shih, Jui-Te Chin, I-Chen Wu
cs.AI, cs.GT, cs.LG
Game solving is a similar, yet more difficult task than mastering a game. Solving a game typically means to find the game-theoretic value (outcome given optimal play), and optionally a full strategy to follow in order to achieve that outcome. The AlphaZero algorithm has demonstrated super-human level play, and its powerful policy and value predictions have also served as heuristics in game solving. However, to solve a game and obtain a full strategy, a winning response must be found for all possible moves by the losing player. This includes very poor lines of play from the losing side, for which the AlphaZero self-play process will not encounter. AlphaZero-based heuristics can be highly inaccurate when evaluating these out-of-distribution positions, which occur throughout the entire search. To address this issue, this paper investigates applying online fine-tuning while searching and proposes two methods to learn tailor-designed heuristics for game solving. Our experiments show that using online fine-tuning can solve a series of challenging 7x7 Killall-Go problems, using only 23.54% of computation time compared to the baseline without online fine-tuning. Results suggest that the savings scale with problem size. Our method can further be extended to any tree search algorithm for problem solving. Our code is available at https://rlg.iis.sinica.edu.tw/papers/neurips2023-online-fine-tuning-solver.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07178v1
2023-11-13T09:09:52
2023-11-13T09:09:52
{ "title": [ 0.026611328, -0.017242432, 0.044433594, -0.04031372, -0.015090942, 0.0033855438, 0.011329651, -0.024230957, -0.011413574, 0.021591187, -0.017852783, 0.0016183853, -0.03793335, -0.020736694, -0.0062942505, -0.010955811, 0.020858765, 0.0049819946, -0.0008292198, -0.035369873, -0.023880005, -0.013031006, 0.01020813, 0.06112671, 0.0012817383, 0.014198303, -0.07147217, 0.025222778, -0.022918701, -0.014099121, -0.007045746, 0.0068855286, 0.056396484, 0.002046585, -0.013664246, 0.018707275, 0.011077881, -0.009277344, -0.018417358, 0.025726318, 0.0035686493, -0.00756073, -0.065979004, 0.017440796, -0.08026123, 0.0048065186, -0.041168213, 0.006755829, -0.028549194, 0.021392822, -0.02154541, -0.012413025, -0.012336731, 0.06756592, 0.014259338, -0.028778076, -0.0155181885, -0.030853271, 0.029190063, 0.028701782, -0.00038933754, -0.031829834, 0.03930664, -0.014198303, -0.015289307, -0.023666382, -0.0065612793, 0.03074646, 0.079589844, 0.001411438, -0.034698486, 0.030136108, -0.0014801025, 0.03137207, -0.028152466, -0.03451538, 0.052612305, 0.025543213, 0.010978699, 0.0011501312, 0.0037078857, -0.026565552, -0.000202775, -0.033233643, 0.018295288, -0.03378296, 0.01108551, -0.0036315918, -0.026107788, -0.054595947, -0.003780365, 0.025177002, -0.031921387, 0.015838623, -0.022598267, -0.013977051, -0.035736084, 0.0006327629, 0.007457733, -0.016204834, -0.030319214, -0.0068740845, -0.015487671, -0.030639648, -0.007888794, 0.015914917, 0.036895752, -0.028289795, -0.03274536, 0.015510559, -0.04437256, 0.0152282715, 0.032287598, 0.012771606, 0.016082764, -0.0040130615, -0.0043792725, 0.022888184, 0.006641388, 0.01576233, -0.04144287, -0.02861023, 0.0060310364, -0.021575928, 0.026473999, 0.009101868, -0.01701355, 0.0059394836, 0.0017786026, 0.033569336, -0.0541687, 0.049102783, -0.035339355, -0.104003906, -0.043304443, -0.003736496, 0.003932953, 0.008201599, -0.014053345, -0.0138549805, 0.029006958, -0.008552551, 0.023086548, 0.008766174, 0.027572632, -0.014015198, 0.051361084, 0.031799316, -0.020751953, 0.01725769, 0.009185791, 0.04083252, -0.026611328, 0.032409668, 0.006504059, 0.012619019, -0.07556152, -0.0018806458, 0.06100464, 0.04159546, 0.0007658005, -0.013671875, 0.018325806, 0.02619934, 0.009216309, 0.046539307, -0.012718201, 0.015274048, 0.006641388, 0.06427002, -0.02923584, 0.013450623, 0.020339966, -0.016464233, -0.025115967, -0.0014705658, 0.026824951, 0.016845703, 0.013923645, -0.01158905, 0.012992859, -0.017913818, -0.0067443848, 0.03074646, -0.055603027, -0.061187744, -0.021957397, -0.043304443, 0.06707764, 0.0020008087, -0.03201294, 0.02659607, -0.035614014, -0.04751587, -0.044128418, 0.010360718, 0.027908325, 0.051727295, -0.0033874512, 0.018157959, -0.03086853, 0.0017194748, -0.03237915, 0.017868042, -0.006504059, -0.03567505, 0.01348114, -0.00094127655, -0.009353638, 0.022109985, 0.046875, -0.008651733, -0.029556274, 0.024108887, -0.019470215, -0.028411865, -0.0056877136, -0.029556274, -0.008033752, -0.010314941, 0.007896423, -0.0061149597, -0.00019037724, 0.045440674, 0.022247314, 0.021636963, 0.005306244, -0.009887695, 0.06427002, 0.022964478, 0.07495117, -0.058410645, 0.050628662, 0.0395813, 0.0008635521, -0.018356323, 0.019683838, -0.040893555, 0.013961792, 0.032196045, 0.010894775, -0.00066423416, -0.03378296, 0.0013513565, 0.0040512085, -0.061065674, -0.0041236877, 0.0012321472, 0.052246094, 0.03366089, 0.024673462, -0.008995056, 0.05630493, 0.0030765533, 0.023773193, 0.062561035, -0.0015258789, 0.018798828, -0.033233643, 0.055908203, -0.009506226, 0.037231445, 0.028793335, -0.006958008, -0.009933472, -0.007797241, -0.013122559, 0.022125244, -0.01322937, 0.027893066, 0.015838623, -0.02758789, 0.0024662018, -0.043823242, -0.0056381226, 0.016311646, -0.04067993, 0.023727417, 0.03982544, -0.047973633, 0.012023926, 0.03753662, 0.060333252, 0.018966675, -0.0039367676, 0.0078125, 0.054260254, 0.036865234, 0.015853882, -0.02658081, 0.05404663, 0.032562256, 0.0019416809, 0.021652222, 0.010612488, -0.00920105, 0.01737976, 0.06121826, -0.027252197, 0.0046691895, -0.059387207, 0.015930176, 0.031982422, -0.034576416, 0.009117126, 0.033111572, 0.052764893, 0.015365601, -0.008903503, 0.025619507, -0.048950195, -0.005138397, -0.008918762, -0.03479004, -0.06341553, -0.053985596, -0.011657715, -0.070373535, -0.056152344, -0.020431519, 0.014663696, 0.0035305023, -0.040161133, 0.0027332306, 0.0074157715, -0.011833191, -0.014640808, -0.0052375793, -0.021759033, 0.0034999847, 0.03237915, -0.0011119843, -0.04776001, -0.024719238, 0.0155181885, 0.015289307, 0.005958557, 0.00919342, -0.0041275024, 0.019485474, 0.012451172, 0.009010315, 0.0033187866, -0.04840088, 0.0064926147, -0.04333496, -0.039886475, 0.017623901, -0.00088119507, -0.034118652, 0.046966553, -0.03756714, -0.025527954, 0.040740967, 0.06640625, -0.017974854, 0.0021781921, 0.08758545, 0.057250977, 0.010070801, 0.043029785, 0.02041626, 0.027420044, -0.008880615, -0.023757935, -0.06866455, 0.009727478, -0.0044937134, 0.012107849, 0.0513916, -0.026031494, -0.027557373, -0.019454956, 0.019805908, 0.008644104, 0.0026359558, 0.016799927, -0.031921387, -0.019943237, -0.015060425, 0.00894928, 0.016616821, -0.008743286, 0.028686523, 0.07287598, 0.0072402954, 0.01020813, 0.026031494, 0.01512146, 0.011413574, -0.035095215, -0.05307007, 0.006954193, 0.008522034, -0.012336731, -0.020614624, 0.014045715, -0.024398804, -0.0927124, 0.0013933182, 0.06591797, -0.02909851, -0.04220581, 0.019897461, -0.07055664, 0.0340271, 0.0132369995, -0.02835083, 0.020187378, 0.025604248, -0.028442383, 0.010375977, 0.02949524, -0.066345215, 0.031433105, -0.03515625, -0.049316406, 0.035614014, -0.014205933, -0.032073975, 0.0043945312, -0.012237549, -0.0087509155, 0.0014820099, -0.011184692, 0.05999756, 0.017089844, 0.021514893, 0.0021152496, 0.0044822693, 0.014595032, -0.0055732727, 0.0045166016, 0.011062622, -0.032806396, -0.0036373138, -0.03378296, 0.033203125, 0.035888672, -0.026641846, -0.06390381, -0.0023326874, -0.046142578, 0.016708374, -0.02458191, -0.03692627, -0.010223389, -0.08282471, -0.05593872, -0.018325806, -0.03488159, 0.004840851, -0.036254883, 0.008361816, 0.0074653625, 0.061157227, -0.001124382, 0.02229309, -0.020339966, -0.014480591, 0.011604309, -0.018203735, -0.07928467, 0.015342712, -0.024230957, 0.009132385, 0.0023555756, -0.0037708282, -0.023895264, -0.000029206276, -0.040924072, 0.040100098, 0.0046195984, -0.013336182, 0.01953125, -0.02748108, -0.02319336, 0.03164673, -0.040039062, -0.01499176, 0.025497437, 0.0044784546, 0.0063819885, -0.03994751, 0.008407593, 0.011405945, -0.07086182, 0.014503479, -0.015380859, 0.02748108, -0.028030396, -0.031463623, -0.0019817352, -0.021453857, -0.06866455, 0.0068092346, -0.009094238, 0.0077171326, -0.0017023087, -0.061676025, -0.035858154, 0.06173706, -0.012252808, 0.0031280518, 0.049346924, -0.02458191, -0.039093018, -0.005847931, 0.02999878, 0.025878906, 0.027923584, -0.0041770935, 0.005924225, 0.027145386, -0.021835327, 0.008079529, 0.042938232, 0.023330688, -0.011749268, 0.0062675476, 0.007865906, 0.02810669, -0.034454346, 0.035369873, 0.05593872, -0.005027771, -0.061584473, 0.036499023, -0.0053596497, -0.014816284, -0.007865906, -0.055664062, 0.024093628, 0.025177002, 0.044891357, 0.0826416, -0.0076942444, -0.027267456, 0.047668457, 0.012901306, 0.015090942, -0.030303955, -0.049804688, 0.03375244, -0.010475159, -0.00819397, -0.022750854, 0.062408447, 0.020309448, 0.0110321045, 0.024291992, -0.004009247, -0.05883789, -0.0084991455, -0.047424316, 0.0073051453, -0.03677368, 0.026901245, -0.055114746, -0.0028820038, 0.0231781, 0.0103302, -0.008720398, -0.008132935, 0.022018433, 0.0052261353, -0.015777588, -0.06011963, -0.023483276, -0.0018806458, -0.07788086, -0.02760315, 0.013305664, 0.01499939, 0.012260437, -0.0032215118, -0.0034809113, 0.019622803, 0.040649414, 0.005207062, 0.06707764, -0.027038574, -0.046081543, 0.057006836, 0.007610321, -0.024414062, 0.0079956055, -0.03845215, -0.0024528503, -0.037597656, -0.0026855469, 0.0066986084, -0.006313324, -0.046875, 0.036499023, -0.011642456, 0.05581665, -0.0028839111, 0.005630493, 0.040863037, 0.008666992, 0.003944397, 0.009468079, -0.049713135, 0.038635254, -0.022247314, 0.072265625, -0.044006348, -0.03604126, -0.01701355, 0.0345459, -0.010627747, -0.007865906, 0.0060539246, -0.020980835, 0.048706055, 0.02015686, 0.039031982, -0.009094238, -0.019424438, 0.011947632, 0.0068588257, 0.038757324, -0.06561279, 0.049865723, 0.0031814575, -0.020431519, 0.04675293, 0.002752304, 0.020767212, 0.0121154785, 0.0054092407, -0.059509277, -0.04067993, 0.003501892, 0.04232788, -0.03225708, 0.006996155, -0.0058898926, 0.020233154, 0.02407837, 0.03543091, 0.022888184, -0.0005774498, -0.0035762787, -0.003320694, 0.022094727, -0.011131287, -0.05505371, -0.021499634, -0.002029419, 0.030685425, -0.06488037, 0.09661865, -0.0066947937, 0.020523071, 0.010398865, 0.0019989014, 0.010139465, -0.06341553, 0.010910034, 0.039154053, -0.00017893314, -0.017822266, -0.00983429, -0.021575928, 0.0074157715, 0.035949707, -0.007926941, -0.015060425, 0.037384033, -0.06854248, 0.010192871, -0.0119018555, 0.013725281, -0.0002810955, 0.013465881, 0.021514893, 0.025894165, -0.04055786, 0.019622803, 0.025360107, -0.0066833496, -0.0054016113, -0.047058105, 0.026031494, -0.009651184, 0.013710022, 0.03265381, -0.03640747, -0.04269409, -0.03640747, -0.007575989, -0.06781006, 0.00945282, 0.016281128, -0.009643555, -0.047821045, 0.031280518, -0.018218994, 0.010604858, 0.0049705505, 0.023803711, -0.01348114, 0.029159546, 0.031311035, -0.021255493, 0.017501831, -0.020355225, 0.0016641617, 0.041229248, 0.042755127, -0.014312744, 0.01008606, -0.02418518, -0.03564453, -0.029571533, 0.004383087, 0.0038471222, 0.006919861, -0.028884888, -0.036865234, -0.02911377, -0.005142212, 0.011543274, 0.0234375, -0.0690918, 0.018737793, 0.009605408, -0.0074882507, 0.026901245, 0.030914307, -0.009468079, 0.019729614, 0.017410278, -0.014640808, 0.043029785, -0.0056533813, -0.0259552, -0.009567261, -0.07159424, 0.023864746, 0.015022278, -0.012420654, -0.0013418198, 0.029174805, 0.02407837, 0.03704834, -0.033966064, 0.0038814545, 0.03793335, -0.020065308, 0.009269714, -0.008178711, -0.0066986084, -0.026153564, 0.05419922, -0.017501831, -0.00907135, -0.052856445, -0.05706787, -0.027236938, -0.0016422272, 0.03778076, 0.0085372925, 0.013336182, -0.0574646, -0.020141602, 0.031829834, 0.0055007935, -0.026779175, 0.0082473755, -0.006580353, -0.048553467, 0.013847351, 0.04800415, 0.0018186569, -0.0011701584, 0.030288696, 0.031021118, 0.0023002625, -0.009941101, -0.05819702, -0.0041885376, -0.017028809, -0.03463745, 0.037506104, 0.035614014, -0.034088135, 0.038757324, -0.019210815, 0.06842041, 0.017456055, 0.05718994, 0.052337646, 0.0395813, 0.0000872612, 0.014724731, 0.01448822, -0.020721436, 0.043029785, -0.07269287, 0.03552246, -0.040893555, 0.008514404, -0.10217285, 0.015823364, 0.028060913, 0.03955078, 0.004043579, 0.009712219, 0.008735657, -0.018447876, 0.06536865, 0.009971619, 0.082458496, -0.04055786, -0.018112183, -0.009094238, -0.029281616, 0.020187378, 0.048339844, 0.021392822, -0.01373291, -0.0018510818, -0.05895996, 0.022903442, 0.049591064, 0.03186035, -0.015167236, -0.02949524, -0.05227661, 0.023483276, -0.00078201294, 0.0019464493, 0.07373047, 0.026611328, 0.008422852, -0.031402588, 0.041137695, 0.004047394, -0.061309814, 0.032928467, 0.051849365, -0.083740234, 0.029708862, -0.026397705, -0.026306152, -0.00041222572, -0.00042963028, 0.055480957, -0.03414917, -0.015602112, 0.019897461, 0.03375244, -0.013023376, 0.02154541, -0.017120361, -0.00080251694, 0.026168823, 0.0077590942, 0.02142334, 0.018081665, 0.008216858, 0.03414917, -0.0023727417, 0.01889038, 0.017654419, 0.008705139, -0.02381897, 0.012573242, -0.039733887, 0.017120361, 0.0036029816, -0.034118652, -0.011711121, 0.029525757, -0.05517578, 0.0020217896, -0.022521973, 0.11230469, 0.0657959, 0.072509766, 0.005908966, -0.028503418, 0.06402588, -0.02645874, 0.017074585, 0.033111572, -0.02166748, 0.05053711, -0.027770996, -0.035736084, 0.07366943, -0.03491211, 0.060272217, -0.040802002, 0.051635742, -0.027191162, -0.0030708313, -0.023834229, -0.029846191, 0.0017213821, -0.0236969, -0.04284668, 0.024093628, -0.0029411316, -0.032592773, -0.000600338, -0.0067253113, -0.0009498596, 0.049743652, -0.0077934265, 0.042633057, -0.02583313, -0.062927246, -0.012435913, -0.026550293, 0.01991272, -0.007335663, -0.02268982, 0.0073394775, 0.01763916, -0.0011854172, -0.046417236, -0.033447266, -0.0103302, 0.008636475, -0.04751587, 0.008918762, 0.022567749, -0.016616821, 0.009384155, -0.022964478, 0.018234253, -0.0063934326, -0.03173828, 0.025726318, -0.019546509, -0.041259766, -0.009132385, -0.015304565, 0.017166138, 0.027252197, -0.014152527, -0.0037288666, 0.045562744, -0.044281006, -0.038208008, -0.028411865, 0.002111435, 0.011016846, -0.037506104, -0.007293701, 0.039886475, 0.06414795, -0.026062012, -0.028671265, 0.014877319, 0.015777588, -0.01474762, 0.06402588, -0.030517578, -0.01626587, 0.024917603, 0.037261963, 0.0039482117, -0.021713257, -0.038879395, 0.0055999756, 0.028518677, 0.01802063, -0.012886047, -0.011161804, 0.007461548, -0.04321289, 0.012557983, -0.019241333, -0.02949524, 0.005218506, -0.004135132, -0.00065612793, -0.014419556, 0.054595947, -0.023040771, 0.03100586, -0.009223938, 0.0072784424, -0.023132324, 0.029937744, -0.023284912, 0.009849548, -0.03753662, 0.0070266724, -0.019561768, 0.04626465, -0.014572144, 0.04699707, -0.055603027, 0.014701843, 0.012878418, 0.013267517, -0.010795593, -0.0037460327, 0.020843506, 0.008270264, -0.010643005, -0.015342712, -0.028930664, -0.0064201355, -0.028305054, 0.033294678, -0.014831543, -0.00233078, -0.008460999, -0.01473999, -0.005027771, 0.009819031, 0.04196167, -0.06222534, -0.012809753, 0.008171082, 0.06695557, 0.014907837 ], "summary": [ 0.017684937, -0.024780273, 0.06994629, 0.026046753, -0.045684814, 0.01424408, 0.019210815, -0.066101074, -0.00869751, 0.014884949, -0.007007599, 0.018966675, -0.042907715, -0.0096206665, -0.0014619827, -0.024734497, 0.01940918, 0.012969971, 0.033416748, -0.021133423, -0.006038666, -0.009086609, 0.011726379, 0.040649414, 0.008888245, 0.021957397, -0.05697632, 0.051971436, -0.004676819, 0.023147583, 0.012969971, -0.0259552, 0.035461426, -0.03643799, 0.03036499, 0.034484863, 0.04421997, -0.031829834, 0.0038013458, 0.024291992, 0.020401001, -0.023529053, -0.02748108, 0.04888916, -0.050048828, -0.034332275, 0.014381409, -0.004940033, 0.036193848, 0.0046081543, -0.016403198, -0.013320923, -0.016143799, 0.019210815, -0.02142334, -0.017028809, -0.0060157776, -0.054595947, 0.018569946, 0.03363037, 0.0146102905, -0.010353088, 0.003583908, -0.027267456, -0.04031372, -0.0017194748, -0.0019760132, -0.026123047, 0.047454834, -0.01991272, 0.0048103333, 0.025894165, 0.029754639, 0.031402588, -0.007827759, -0.0848999, 0.033233643, 0.0015325546, 0.013061523, 0.017684937, 0.016967773, -0.0115356445, 0.03302002, -0.037597656, 0.0016546249, -0.013175964, -0.006942749, 0.00019431114, -0.0103302, -0.03164673, -0.012756348, 0.020446777, -0.022964478, -0.019195557, -0.012786865, -0.04144287, -0.045135498, -0.05581665, -0.013320923, 0.022232056, 0.00730896, -0.025863647, 0.044769287, -0.007217407, -0.014305115, 0.046661377, 0.031433105, -0.04034424, -0.038208008, -0.021560669, -0.010139465, -0.03869629, 0.0036621094, -0.045684814, 0.005458832, 0.06341553, 0.034454346, 0.034576416, 0.024047852, 0.050994873, -0.053100586, -0.007472992, -0.0033226013, 0.011802673, 0.02961731, 0.02255249, 0.02758789, -0.000003993511, 0.057891846, 0.010986328, -0.05432129, 0.0059318542, 0.020324707, -0.022537231, -0.010757446, -0.024398804, 0.034606934, 0.027420044, 0.012641907, -0.018325806, 0.023101807, 0.0051498413, 0.024230957, 0.017868042, 0.066101074, 0.0059165955, 0.034179688, 0.028533936, 0.000048041344, 0.031188965, 0.025314331, 0.019866943, -0.015991211, -0.001627922, 0.002614975, -0.03717041, -0.06561279, 0.0017843246, 0.06237793, 0.0054626465, -0.036346436, -0.0029182434, 0.045562744, 0.043701172, 0.004058838, 0.026733398, 0.035736084, -0.016937256, 0.0052337646, 0.014091492, 0.008323669, 0.0099105835, 0.020706177, -0.023834229, -0.019943237, -0.016479492, -0.0023403168, 0.02217102, -0.0079422, 0.029586792, 0.0155181885, -0.032287598, -0.025741577, 0.03704834, -0.0072784424, -0.025512695, -0.018615723, -0.049957275, 0.047668457, -0.007865906, -0.038879395, 0.036621094, -0.029785156, 0.0076408386, -0.027786255, -0.006603241, 0.024475098, 0.040771484, -0.0155181885, -0.017593384, 0.0010919571, 0.015144348, -0.03579712, 0.039916992, -0.04559326, 0.0009551048, -0.012046814, 0.014015198, -0.03363037, 0.0062942505, 0.032226562, 0.00053215027, -0.038513184, 0.004005432, 0.015350342, -0.016281128, 0.014213562, -0.0262146, 0.0043029785, -0.020126343, -0.004070282, 0.002445221, -0.032562256, 0.021835327, 0.008735657, 0.013328552, -0.0066070557, 0.002752304, 0.05960083, 0.014152527, 0.06854248, -0.036346436, 0.04373169, 0.048095703, 0.013771057, 0.016616821, 0.05038452, -0.051574707, 0.008804321, 0.0068893433, 0.026565552, 0.024490356, -0.055725098, -0.026016235, -0.014633179, -0.06933594, -0.028930664, 0.01625061, 0.028198242, 0.028167725, 0.03161621, -0.021026611, 0.01966858, -0.018493652, 0.024520874, 0.02078247, -0.028839111, 0.01878357, -0.037841797, 0.016586304, -0.011001587, 0.009353638, 0.03756714, -0.010925293, -0.0024700165, -0.001572609, 0.0023593903, -0.0035743713, -0.014007568, 0.0055503845, 0.014625549, -0.04071045, -0.004184723, -0.060668945, -0.018173218, -0.012001038, -0.05078125, 0.04788208, 0.04006958, -0.03967285, 0.051452637, 0.06945801, 0.0031223297, 0.003293991, 0.0016546249, -0.008865356, -0.0020446777, 0.08880615, 0.021148682, 0.031036377, 0.05130005, 0.021865845, 0.007572174, 0.016555786, -0.031402588, -0.0058174133, -0.02684021, 0.044708252, -0.020568848, -0.0034885406, -0.034057617, 0.027450562, 0.024261475, -0.04675293, 0.026794434, 0.011253357, 0.06561279, 0.0035514832, 0.02079773, 0.028671265, -0.045288086, -0.015388489, 0.015472412, 0.05621338, -0.032165527, -0.03982544, 0.008422852, 0.004085541, -0.048583984, -0.035614014, 0.0065689087, -0.0087890625, -0.027786255, 0.0042533875, 0.0030326843, 0.0010271072, 0.003227234, -0.0015335083, 0.029266357, -0.05557251, -0.031829834, -0.02758789, -0.03326416, 0.020477295, -0.00029921532, -0.02331543, 0.021911621, -0.0070495605, 0.0038051605, 0.005130768, 0.03213501, 0.04901123, -0.020523071, -0.020004272, -0.028839111, 0.014022827, -0.06750488, 0.026657104, 0.027496338, -0.04348755, 0.007385254, -0.033447266, -0.024993896, 0.02508545, 0.006668091, 0.03253174, 0.023071289, 0.05883789, 0.04043579, -0.0011377335, 0.03060913, 0.035339355, 0.0317688, -0.00248909, -0.07513428, -0.028808594, 0.03793335, 0.0047416687, 0.034576416, 0.03643799, -0.0050697327, 0.0026187897, -0.036895752, 0.009880066, 0.016738892, 0.0025863647, 0.0647583, -0.02394104, 0.030700684, 0.04421997, 0.0023021698, 0.032684326, -0.04257202, 0.0107421875, 0.08782959, -0.014968872, 0.0046653748, 0.049468994, 0.014755249, 0.014709473, -0.04260254, -0.054382324, 0.043701172, -0.016067505, -0.0029411316, -0.0012245178, -0.0054359436, 0.0008096695, -0.030075073, -0.019454956, 0.020248413, -0.0020866394, -0.021606445, 0.009727478, -0.025939941, 0.037353516, 0.036895752, -0.026916504, 0.027893066, -0.02053833, 0.007686615, -0.023025513, 0.024276733, -0.061584473, 0.005771637, -0.029708862, 0.04171753, 0.011993408, -0.020248413, -0.006801605, 0.014320374, 0.03137207, 0.025436401, 0.029800415, -0.027740479, 0.034606934, -0.020477295, 0.009353638, -0.015716553, 0.013420105, -0.006324768, -0.0017118454, 0.019927979, 0.018997192, -0.048950195, 0.021652222, -0.017791748, 0.007232666, 0.03463745, -0.059906006, -0.059448242, -0.010810852, -0.0637207, -0.0069465637, -0.05340576, -0.011238098, 0.0003106594, -0.0914917, -0.035003662, -0.035705566, -0.030853271, -0.0016851425, -0.004501343, 0.02166748, 0.0057144165, 0.060455322, -0.038757324, 0.011886597, 0.047332764, -0.030914307, -0.033843994, -0.006679535, -0.06359863, 0.013801575, -0.031982422, 0.042541504, -0.010040283, 0.00472641, -0.034088135, 0.0051994324, -0.019699097, 0.01713562, 0.0018339157, -0.024902344, 0.031799316, -0.06378174, 0.0006260872, 0.0259552, -0.018539429, -0.024917603, 0.0011720657, -0.00086832047, 0.009819031, 0.010108948, 0.024795532, 0.0011062622, -0.023452759, -0.010215759, -0.034362793, 0.0513916, 0.021652222, 0.022155762, 0.0109939575, 0.017807007, -0.040649414, -0.00071048737, -0.02355957, 0.09429932, 0.026931763, -0.020248413, -0.0029239655, -0.024780273, -0.025131226, -0.0335083, 0.011192322, 0.033691406, -0.015029907, 0.0031833649, 0.0029468536, -0.031555176, 0.0031280518, -0.041870117, 0.017669678, 0.019577026, -0.0064468384, 0.0055618286, 0.022613525, 0.012107849, -0.0066871643, -0.0010280609, -0.007080078, -0.028671265, -0.004142761, -0.012710571, 0.031585693, 0.036071777, -0.03955078, 0.078186035, -0.0005726814, 0.0012178421, -0.0018167496, -0.031921387, -0.0034046173, 0.01689148, 0.04321289, 0.034362793, -0.033050537, -0.053588867, 0.011459351, 0.05291748, -0.013298035, -0.06707764, -0.04498291, 0.07519531, -0.04711914, -0.009300232, -0.04989624, 0.040130615, -0.010528564, 0.010498047, 0.025756836, 0.0055885315, -0.068237305, -0.039733887, -0.0068893433, 0.07116699, 0.004776001, -0.00844574, -0.044830322, 0.03086853, -0.008483887, 0.014968872, 0.031204224, -0.034423828, 0.01663208, 0.045715332, -0.038269043, -0.046142578, -0.04095459, -0.010177612, -0.05130005, -0.011405945, 0.030914307, 0.008583069, -0.009109497, -0.02217102, -0.006706238, 0.0284729, 0.013969421, 0.04046631, 0.05682373, -0.014251709, -0.07739258, 0.030334473, -0.019454956, -0.046661377, 0.0103302, -0.025756836, -0.02381897, -0.05834961, 0.030670166, -0.00434494, -0.02154541, -0.03753662, 0.014022827, 0.013587952, 0.06100464, 0.00007224083, -0.019363403, 0.028961182, -0.017623901, 0.0051879883, 0.009941101, -0.025268555, 0.028289795, -0.009635925, 0.023391724, -0.042907715, -0.047668457, -0.029373169, 0.016326904, -0.029785156, 0.013511658, -0.004638672, -0.007003784, 0.0345459, 0.043945312, 0.004562378, 0.0011997223, -0.0340271, 0.003129959, 0.005695343, -0.0022258759, -0.03250122, 0.041412354, 0.046691895, -0.031799316, 0.06530762, 0.0060539246, -0.026779175, 0.014060974, -0.027648926, -0.046295166, 0.003742218, 0.0038394928, 0.019302368, -0.03277588, -0.013198853, -0.026260376, -0.026428223, 0.037139893, -0.011878967, -0.040649414, -0.05609131, -0.002937317, -0.0025310516, -0.023788452, 0.01902771, -0.025344849, -0.044281006, -0.0012359619, 0.0034122467, -0.093688965, 0.096191406, 0.06762695, 0.027160645, 0.031951904, 0.015838623, -0.011985779, -0.042755127, -0.029754639, -0.017166138, -0.012207031, -0.049194336, 0.027038574, -0.024383545, -0.03277588, 0.004463196, -0.0178833, -0.015899658, -0.022125244, -0.07928467, 0.017486572, -0.006713867, 0.007549286, 0.017715454, -0.00030612946, 0.0076293945, -0.014030457, 0.0037269592, 0.010139465, 0.011077881, 0.0070114136, 0.019699097, -0.04925537, 0.014503479, -0.059417725, 0.0056114197, 0.028915405, 0.022583008, 0.001789093, -0.037139893, 0.014221191, -0.07562256, -0.028015137, 0.0007967949, 0.012840271, -0.052001953, -0.028121948, -0.02041626, 0.012123108, -0.011039734, 0.04812622, 0.018936157, -0.0012149811, -0.010238647, 0.018966675, -0.0038757324, 0.018218994, -0.0066070557, -0.00818634, 0.026062012, 0.014930725, 0.009857178, -0.013008118, -0.016662598, -0.019470215, 0.002576828, -0.016082764, 0.015205383, -0.032073975, -0.0016937256, -0.0014324188, -0.059051514, -0.01222229, -0.016815186, -0.0440979, -0.017959595, -0.0003554821, -0.006591797, 0.05908203, 0.05545044, -0.05355835, 0.027801514, 0.036468506, -0.018493652, 0.03970337, -0.013038635, -0.022598267, -0.028915405, -0.055908203, -0.00020492077, 0.019348145, -0.038848877, 0.034729004, 0.003194809, 0.016098022, 0.05105591, -0.051116943, -0.0020637512, 0.0042381287, -0.035736084, 0.00674057, 0.021728516, 0.043762207, 0.03062439, 0.033355713, -0.037139893, -0.022003174, -0.01651001, 0.0061531067, 0.02407837, 0.015731812, 0.03010559, 0.0002670288, 0.033569336, -0.026306152, -0.020202637, -0.02003479, 0.013435364, -0.0029716492, -0.022109985, -0.015113831, -0.014831543, 0.0368042, 0.051513672, 0.014030457, 0.0055618286, 0.011047363, -0.010375977, -0.01600647, -0.0016012192, -0.0039749146, 0.020568848, -0.028198242, -0.0033836365, 0.023880005, 0.031051636, -0.020477295, 0.018096924, 0.0138549805, 0.021224976, 0.0021190643, 0.022750854, 0.020645142, 0.018997192, 0.022781372, -0.010551453, 0.012016296, -0.015022278, 0.037231445, -0.05279541, 0.032928467, -0.03048706, -0.0065574646, -0.012245178, 0.05935669, -0.03378296, 0.02357483, 0.06768799, 0.008918762, 0.0096206665, 0.019546509, 0.038330078, 0.06488037, 0.07019043, -0.02178955, -0.008575439, -0.001958847, -0.038726807, 0.010948181, 0.04763794, 0.030410767, -0.020370483, 0.031311035, -0.056152344, 0.015731812, 0.007881165, 0.018630981, -0.052490234, -0.0154953, -0.04248047, 0.035614014, -0.012023926, 0.021514893, 0.048980713, 0.02319336, 0.030517578, -0.026428223, 0.03149414, -0.017074585, -0.06262207, 0.040130615, 0.02835083, -0.092163086, 0.030059814, -0.01084137, -0.019210815, -0.012519836, 0.01499176, 0.040771484, -0.030685425, 0.00026988983, 0.030426025, 0.0065193176, -0.02015686, -0.014160156, -0.012710571, 0.042663574, 0.06713867, -0.02017212, 0.030166626, -0.0287323, -0.0027160645, 0.032562256, -0.013053894, 0.017150879, 0.014701843, -0.03866577, 0.014846802, 0.029312134, -0.032348633, -0.013771057, 0.018875122, -0.013839722, -0.021713257, 0.03555298, -0.01586914, 0.016433716, -0.025848389, 0.105651855, 0.020843506, 0.06890869, -0.03668213, -0.002866745, 0.052703857, 0.029815674, 0.026245117, 0.052093506, -0.005126953, 0.030548096, -0.008117676, -0.00349617, 0.048950195, -0.0050849915, 0.0035762787, -0.047698975, 0.039794922, -0.026397705, 0.040771484, -0.082092285, -0.0053634644, 0.03665161, -0.013832092, -0.002506256, 0.045288086, 0.025482178, -0.06298828, 0.037506104, 0.007709503, -0.031433105, 0.035125732, -0.012748718, 0.008453369, 0.001250267, -0.019302368, -0.01322937, 0.0012168884, 0.021224976, 0.03152466, -0.02760315, 0.04055786, 0.053375244, 0.007987976, -0.101623535, -0.06555176, 0.026351929, 0.109558105, -0.054016113, 0.04598999, 0.044067383, 0.0040664673, 0.039764404, -0.019592285, 0.026031494, -0.0019273758, 0.00035643578, 0.02178955, -0.012825012, -0.033416748, -0.015174866, -0.014717102, 0.011634827, -0.0008940697, -0.0058135986, 0.022003174, 0.032104492, -0.020263672, -0.013465881, -0.022491455, -0.014984131, -0.0045547485, 0.006767273, 0.0078125, 0.025894165, 0.03552246, -0.01121521, 0.034179688, -0.0069503784, -0.031585693, 0.039916992, 0.03765869, -0.064819336, -0.009094238, 0.05368042, 0.023757935, 0.031677246, -0.016098022, -0.03125, -0.00248909, 0.027252197, 0.01701355, -0.015274048, 0.00046539307, 0.03074646, -0.051452637, -0.0016784668, -0.0026187897, -0.042938232, -0.00982666, -0.011947632, -0.051940918, -0.032226562, 0.056671143, -0.036743164, 0.050567627, -0.029937744, -0.03277588, -0.004928589, 0.03945923, -0.021652222, -0.049957275, -0.005508423, 0.07312012, -0.076171875, -0.006832123, 0.005104065, 0.016906738, -0.048187256, 0.014961243, 0.045013428, -0.006839752, -0.027359009, -0.018157959, 0.0070495605, 0.012565613, -0.05239868, 0.017150879, -0.021057129, -0.0021572113, -0.017654419, 0.03149414, -0.010810852, -0.0055007935, 0.018157959, -0.014160156, 0.016448975, 0.028213501, 0.06573486, -0.032196045, 0.04272461, 0.016403198, 0.04537964, 0.02961731 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08379v2
Scheming AIs: Will AIs fake alignment during training in order to get power?
Joe Carlsmith
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG
This report examines whether advanced AIs that perform well in training will be doing so in order to gain power later -- a behavior I call "scheming" (also sometimes called "deceptive alignment"). I conclude that scheming is a disturbingly plausible outcome of using baseline machine learning methods to train goal-directed AIs sophisticated enough to scheme (my subjective probability on such an outcome, given these conditions, is roughly 25%). In particular: if performing well in training is a good strategy for gaining power (as I think it might well be), then a very wide variety of goals would motivate scheming -- and hence, good training performance. This makes it plausible that training might either land on such a goal naturally and then reinforce it, or actively push a model's motivations towards such a goal as an easy way of improving performance. What's more, because schemers pretend to be aligned on tests designed to reveal their motivations, it may be quite difficult to tell whether this has occurred. However, I also think there are reasons for comfort. In particular: scheming may not actually be such a good strategy for gaining power; various selection pressures in training might work against schemer-like goals (for example, relative to non-schemers, schemers need to engage in extra instrumental reasoning, which might harm their training performance); and we may be able to increase such pressures intentionally. The report discusses these and a wide variety of other considerations in detail, and it suggests an array of empirical research directions for probing the topic further.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08379v2
2023-11-15T18:30:24
2023-11-14T18:42:40
{ "title": [ -0.039123535, 0.00023448467, -0.030303955, 0.048431396, -0.019348145, -0.0155181885, 0.039642334, -0.019592285, -0.07110596, 0.017532349, -0.014877319, 0.015945435, 0.008399963, -0.056518555, 0.057373047, -0.041809082, -0.010185242, 0.0054092407, 0.0034923553, -0.039123535, -0.0050735474, -0.0552063, 0.05279541, 0.0019187927, 0.05621338, -0.0069236755, -0.07281494, 0.011116028, 0.016937256, 0.009315491, 0.029342651, -0.016204834, 0.012298584, 0.0140686035, 0.013542175, 0.0026054382, -0.007019043, 0.02079773, 0.024169922, -0.016403198, 0.011230469, -0.0044898987, -0.047058105, -0.012664795, -0.05618286, -0.007286072, -0.024597168, 0.02116394, 0.030654907, 0.033355713, -0.010574341, 0.007255554, -0.011024475, 0.03048706, -0.0026130676, 0.010261536, -0.048339844, 0.0024967194, 0.022750854, 0.010726929, 0.009674072, -0.016326904, 0.02229309, -0.014930725, 0.016616821, -0.040924072, -0.048858643, 0.040771484, -0.01890564, 0.034820557, 0.051361084, -0.05102539, 0.004524231, 0.03213501, -0.030471802, -0.06286621, 0.018295288, -0.002084732, 0.017974854, 0.0069351196, -0.012016296, -0.024520874, 0.0005545616, -0.05432129, 0.016143799, -0.03881836, -0.008613586, 0.015701294, 0.025222778, -0.02053833, -0.00687027, -0.01348114, 0.023620605, 0.042541504, -0.033813477, -0.023452759, 0.009239197, 0.045196533, -0.017852783, 0.015991211, -0.03375244, -0.0027751923, -0.011787415, -0.031051636, 0.036193848, 0.008018494, -0.024612427, -0.04547119, 0.021499634, 0.015991211, -0.03186035, 0.04574585, 0.022583008, -0.026184082, 0.016540527, -0.008766174, -0.007633209, 0.03366089, -0.0019483566, 0.008659363, -0.0009737015, 0.038024902, 0.036224365, 0.029449463, 0.008369446, 0.04095459, 0.017791748, -0.07659912, -0.0018367767, -0.012878418, -0.021255493, 0.059387207, -0.010696411, -0.03048706, -0.028060913, 0.016235352, 0.023361206, -0.044525146, -0.0118255615, 0.0124435425, 0.035614014, -0.036468506, 0.0058784485, 0.018676758, -0.049804688, 0.013267517, 0.03866577, 0.007987976, -0.025878906, -0.057434082, -0.011131287, 0.0048294067, -0.03842163, 0.0074920654, 0.052368164, 0.03768921, -0.031433105, 0.030151367, 0.04083252, 0.06109619, 0.036895752, 0.00932312, -0.010284424, 0.020904541, 0.025863647, -0.028564453, -0.009437561, 0.01663208, 0.00856781, 0.038024902, 0.015144348, 0.019378662, -0.0026626587, 0.019256592, 0.019622803, 0.0046653748, 0.017227173, -0.022888184, -0.010810852, -0.0015096664, -0.011161804, -0.025344849, -0.031463623, 0.024383545, -0.024337769, -0.010124207, -0.018951416, -0.030319214, 0.032440186, -0.010070801, 0.005970001, 0.017456055, -0.055145264, -0.054748535, -0.01058197, 0.07696533, -0.014694214, 0.04269409, 0.000813961, -0.035461426, -0.009269714, 0.009513855, -0.011207581, 0.014038086, -0.038848877, -0.0051345825, -0.00793457, 0.024139404, 0.015396118, 0.029281616, -0.0075035095, -0.03466797, 0.02015686, -0.017944336, -0.023757935, -0.052642822, 0.0087509155, -0.07006836, -0.011497498, -0.023956299, -0.03326416, 0.0725708, -0.074157715, 0.014953613, -0.015594482, 0.011871338, 0.0030994415, 0.008300781, -0.0013608932, 0.037750244, 0.04220581, -0.030944824, 0.035339355, 0.05984497, -0.049591064, -0.02027893, -0.0317688, -0.02281189, 0.00024843216, 0.051239014, 0.0017652512, -0.03466797, -0.026809692, -0.0013542175, 0.0049209595, -0.024475098, 0.013259888, -0.0053482056, 0.015838623, 0.004070282, 0.009506226, 0.0029296875, 0.040863037, 0.021728516, 0.035705566, 0.04321289, -0.022628784, 0.006877899, -0.004333496, -0.001159668, 0.008995056, 0.04446411, 0.017959595, 0.019927979, -0.030456543, 0.040130615, -0.021911621, 0.020095825, -0.0317688, 0.056121826, 0.021514893, -0.035339355, 0.015182495, 0.01737976, -0.031951904, -0.05267334, -0.028060913, 0.02609253, -0.009048462, -0.02482605, 0.01473999, 0.018081665, 0.015975952, -0.0063209534, 0.012527466, 0.037750244, 0.009315491, 0.016174316, -0.072021484, -0.03378296, -0.013420105, 0.05239868, -0.005973816, -0.009315491, 0.052734375, 0.002248764, 0.0048065186, 0.057769775, -0.0095825195, 0.0015926361, -0.089782715, -0.002313614, 0.0078086853, -0.016967773, 0.021102905, 0.0040397644, 0.011543274, 0.015472412, 0.009483337, 0.0016527176, -0.07507324, -0.043670654, 0.019134521, 0.046051025, -0.012748718, -0.03414917, 0.0051879883, 0.037872314, 0.0064849854, 0.039733887, 0.04006958, 0.030258179, -0.029129028, -0.022033691, -0.007736206, -0.014640808, -0.03579712, -0.01789856, 0.034851074, -0.021835327, 0.019165039, -0.015281677, -0.052978516, -0.0597229, 0.009254456, -0.013664246, 0.015075684, 0.01335144, 0.010307312, -0.011459351, 0.03225708, -0.01222229, 0.008384705, 0.033843994, 0.025543213, -0.041534424, 0.021087646, -0.013580322, 0.0022258759, 0.034820557, -0.012039185, -0.009140015, 0.008399963, 0.010536194, 0.052978516, -0.024017334, -0.0155181885, 0.064575195, 0.046081543, -0.00031208992, 0.0473938, 0.008758545, 0.00881958, -0.05303955, -0.0040779114, -0.033203125, -0.037628174, -0.017089844, 0.019332886, 0.013244629, -0.045654297, -0.0067481995, -0.0013246536, 0.0053100586, 0.023925781, 0.017654419, -0.02973938, -0.046051025, 0.03540039, -0.0059318542, -0.023651123, -0.028640747, 0.03894043, 0.018630981, 0.031829834, -0.021820068, -0.06866455, 0.007331848, 0.0016698837, 0.035980225, -0.013504028, -0.025466919, -0.031280518, -0.024963379, 0.040008545, 0.028457642, -0.05996704, -0.024246216, -0.07757568, 0.013755798, -0.02078247, -0.007331848, -0.007926941, 0.005268097, -0.035095215, -0.012069702, -0.0209198, -0.025405884, 0.0096206665, 0.0597229, 0.018447876, 0.0024471283, 0.044158936, -0.0209198, 0.014877319, -0.017562866, -0.07849121, 0.004360199, -0.07897949, 0.0725708, 0.039489746, 0.023925781, -0.031280518, 0.021484375, 0.006679535, 0.00806427, 0.008460999, -0.012748718, 0.016311646, -0.013977051, -0.001332283, -0.030273438, -0.0026130676, -0.032318115, -0.046051025, -0.041137695, -0.010612488, 0.011428833, 0.02532959, -0.0109939575, -0.021240234, -0.016220093, -0.020828247, 0.01272583, 0.00092458725, -0.012512207, -0.02911377, -0.034332275, -0.011177063, -0.021820068, 0.0044021606, 0.0129470825, 0.0070762634, 0.014083862, -0.0056610107, 0.0473938, 0.020355225, 0.050323486, -0.0037021637, 0.006587982, 0.027694702, -0.017120361, -0.04095459, 0.01651001, 0.010131836, -0.041168213, 0.03302002, -0.0017118454, 0.0062065125, -0.015930176, -0.019622803, 0.037353516, 0.004600525, -0.00007241964, 0.015365601, 0.004497528, -0.035064697, 0.0007286072, -0.021408081, 0.008628845, 0.022888184, 0.0009937286, 0.01890564, -0.012619019, -0.018325806, 0.020080566, -0.088378906, -0.050994873, 0.012031555, -0.06304932, -0.03717041, -0.0038070679, 0.012359619, -0.050689697, -0.0070533752, -0.0058174133, -0.015838623, 0.014640808, 0.0026931763, -0.047943115, 0.0043754578, -0.0003569126, -0.017242432, 0.0020198822, -0.0021972656, -0.015655518, -0.0031089783, 0.022750854, 0.014663696, 0.023895264, 0.004009247, 0.023712158, -0.021591187, 0.01222229, -0.043029785, 0.053833008, -0.055541992, -0.017425537, -0.019210815, 0.01309967, 0.017059326, 0.036987305, -0.04675293, 0.01890564, 0.07720947, 0.0038051605, -0.08843994, 0.048828125, -0.022842407, -0.07281494, 0.030715942, 0.01852417, -0.0042915344, 0.030776978, 0.003446579, 0.03878784, -0.035064697, 0.029434204, -0.013572693, -0.009605408, -0.060180664, -0.046142578, 0.036834717, 0.016357422, 0.011497498, -0.00881958, -0.0065345764, 0.012641907, 0.039154053, -0.018569946, -0.012374878, -0.010955811, -0.07739258, -0.020996094, 0.004638672, -0.039398193, -0.056610107, 0.024749756, 0.0044898987, -0.032196045, 0.006942749, -0.02923584, -0.027282715, 0.01576233, -0.014755249, 0.0016794205, 0.0047073364, -0.05117798, -0.06762695, -0.0037937164, -0.083740234, -0.028503418, -0.07330322, -0.025634766, -0.02961731, -0.00024163723, 0.015357971, 0.045562744, -0.0046310425, 0.017929077, 0.023452759, -0.024276733, -0.037750244, 0.027755737, -0.033355713, -0.008903503, -0.002254486, 0.026428223, -0.019042969, -0.019165039, 0.019317627, -0.020568848, -0.015174866, -0.028793335, 0.012229919, 0.023788452, 0.012413025, -0.028366089, -0.01247406, 0.0065231323, 0.0017652512, -0.012687683, -0.010063171, -0.032470703, 0.05419922, 0.03955078, 0.06488037, -0.014503479, -0.009422302, -0.026687622, 0.03152466, -0.00025367737, -0.022659302, 0.037841797, -0.027832031, -0.022033691, 0.083496094, -0.048461914, -0.027313232, -0.040863037, 0.010627747, 0.00605011, 0.02470398, -0.00011742115, 0.03955078, -0.053985596, -0.04324341, -0.0006842613, 0.010620117, 0.009971619, 0.030944824, 0.008583069, 0.015777588, -0.002632141, 0.051696777, 0.0060043335, -0.0047454834, -0.0026302338, -0.033721924, 0.02229309, 0.030349731, 0.012710571, -0.014656067, -0.036346436, 0.037994385, 0.0020198822, -0.018798828, -0.008148193, -0.028564453, -0.030563354, -0.02230835, 0.020217896, -0.029266357, 0.05984497, 0.019866943, 0.010696411, -0.010551453, 0.019226074, 0.0077400208, 0.0041275024, 0.010314941, 0.07873535, -0.02192688, 0.024047852, -0.009513855, -0.0034694672, 0.040863037, 0.012023926, 0.0041236877, -0.030334473, 0.0076026917, -0.0054855347, -0.041656494, -0.03189087, 0.029403687, 0.030197144, 0.01838684, 0.035217285, 0.02418518, -0.062927246, 0.0015945435, -0.039642334, -0.01083374, 0.015975952, -0.021575928, 0.044952393, 0.016799927, -0.021087646, -0.0135650635, -0.043640137, -0.024368286, 0.043121338, -0.05770874, 0.023956299, 0.009048462, -0.040893555, -0.0099105835, -0.035339355, 0.048950195, -0.026626587, 0.021240234, 0.0067863464, -0.016647339, -0.04345703, -0.004878998, 0.015609741, -0.059448242, 0.036590576, 0.005458832, 0.007118225, 0.036499023, 0.020248413, -0.046020508, -0.022262573, -0.013015747, -0.00072431564, 0.010513306, 0.018676758, 0.015457153, 0.013923645, -0.014717102, -0.007286072, -0.02960205, -0.010017395, 0.010276794, -0.009864807, -0.061431885, 0.0074424744, -0.010375977, -0.00016713142, 0.023406982, 0.049804688, -0.016937256, 0.015670776, 0.015350342, -0.045074463, 0.018814087, -0.026489258, -0.02809143, -0.0073509216, -0.016555786, -0.00422287, 0.001250267, 0.006450653, 0.0102005005, 0.055908203, 0.041778564, -0.00843811, 0.025238037, 0.041412354, 0.05090332, -0.044799805, -0.045837402, -0.03793335, -0.006038666, -0.07171631, -0.011291504, 0.032073975, -0.018508911, 0.00623703, -0.036590576, 0.0017662048, -0.0020370483, 0.027618408, -0.015129089, 0.03074646, -0.053649902, -0.016403198, -0.043121338, 0.0048332214, -0.0038414001, 0.025741577, -0.021987915, -0.007926941, 0.010383606, -0.008010864, -0.006576538, 0.0060920715, 0.011672974, 0.045318604, 0.0012722015, 0.037322998, -0.04425049, -0.02293396, -0.000118911266, -0.025161743, 0.0003106594, -0.013244629, 0.004245758, -0.010902405, -0.026687622, 0.023391724, 0.028213501, 0.021774292, 0.028411865, 0.05038452, 0.034210205, 0.0009007454, 0.038482666, 0.017700195, -0.0088272095, -0.04711914, 0.070251465, 0.074157715, 0.031173706, -0.023605347, -0.018997192, 0.093933105, 0.039001465, 0.00881958, 0.03439331, 0.05291748, -0.022079468, 0.034942627, -0.07611084, 0.074401855, -0.005744934, -0.004119873, -0.007881165, -0.04083252, 0.0058898926, 0.033966064, -0.010360718, 0.020462036, 0.016586304, -0.021209717, 0.011291504, 0.006362915, 0.0044555664, -0.005924225, 0.01638794, -0.0073013306, -0.044281006, -0.020126343, -0.014602661, 0.020584106, 0.038848877, -0.06500244, 0.05368042, 0.027557373, 0.029342651, -0.02468872, 0.038116455, 0.06738281, -0.09979248, 0.03933716, 0.02760315, -0.047210693, 0.008834839, 0.078063965, -0.016174316, 0.0058135986, 0.014190674, 0.0026893616, -0.002122879, 0.072387695, 0.011878967, -0.029647827, -0.03616333, -0.0009899139, 0.010574341, -0.00008791685, 0.02709961, 0.0057144165, 0.027770996, -0.0031223297, 0.0063552856, -0.01184845, -0.029907227, -0.01852417, 0.020523071, 0.0074539185, 0.06427002, -0.023086548, -0.038757324, 0.04647827, 0.0007762909, -0.017532349, 0.003982544, 0.00843811, -0.01889038, -0.027297974, -0.0049057007, -0.026397705, -0.004886627, -0.04864502, 0.016418457, 0.0395813, 0.043640137, -0.0022907257, 0.017211914, -0.0050964355, -0.026885986, 0.044708252, 0.010498047, 0.06713867, 0.013534546, -0.003063202, -0.03201294, -0.030471802, 0.021728516, -0.036987305, 0.018203735, -0.060394287, -0.0070648193, 0.0143966675, -0.00010704994, -0.0093307495, 0.0131073, 0.03286743, 0.045898438, 0.07220459, 0.037506104, 0.049835205, -0.034240723, 0.010093689, 0.034210205, 0.024520874, 0.074279785, 0.01360321, -0.0345459, -0.053527832, 0.07373047, 0.025939941, 0.008888245, -0.023025513, 0.08013916, -0.005466461, -0.038024902, 0.027313232, 0.021881104, -0.016693115, -0.034729004, -0.013313293, -0.010192871, -0.016693115, 0.015808105, 0.06542969, 0.029144287, -0.16296387, -0.021255493, -0.027236938, 0.022598267, -0.030288696, -0.025482178, 0.027664185, 0.01713562, -0.030838013, 0.036987305, 0.024276733, 0.06237793, -0.03717041, -0.017471313, -0.014030457, -0.00092220306, 0.011856079, -0.05319214, -0.10443115, 0.0030574799, 0.0736084, 0.015457153, -0.023712158, 0.010810852, 0.04840088, 0.013244629, 0.023376465, 0.0072898865, -0.068603516, -0.006412506, 0.00014960766, 0.026367188, 0.02017212, -0.020431519, 0.0038375854, 0.013931274, -0.01134491, 0.0021533966, -0.0038108826, -0.000025749207, 0.009284973, -0.013923645, 0.013923645, -0.035461426, 0.01033783, 0.018753052, 0.02911377, -0.019714355, -0.0036716461, -0.00014281273, 0.0039711, 0.001534462, 0.037719727, 0.047851562, -0.019866943, -0.0010967255, 0.024963379, 0.021377563, 0.0541687, -0.004825592, -0.058013916, -0.03225708, 0.038085938, 0.007881165, 0.051818848, 0.03048706, 0.011009216, 0.030883789, -0.017959595, -0.016616821, 0.0234375, -0.008613586, 0.011817932, -0.023986816, 0.024871826, 0.015533447, -0.02619934, 0.03225708, 0.034240723, 0.02407837, 0.04849243, -0.017730713, -0.054718018, -0.0063171387, -0.014877319 ], "summary": [ -0.007835388, -0.0041275024, 0.022201538, 0.06738281, -0.022949219, -0.021316528, 0.0463562, -0.050628662, -0.06488037, 0.020874023, 0.034423828, 0.027557373, 0.019058228, -0.04989624, 0.05328369, -0.003709793, -0.031463623, 0.03326416, 0.020004272, -0.045806885, 0.023742676, -0.072265625, 0.030059814, -0.03277588, 0.028823853, -0.016357422, -0.041168213, 0.02619934, 0.020523071, 0.03237915, 0.02470398, -0.03314209, 0.01550293, -0.002204895, 0.032806396, 0.0074005127, 0.020080566, -0.008666992, -0.014823914, 0.04812622, 0.011688232, -0.0070648193, -0.014892578, -0.031799316, -0.03793335, 0.018630981, -0.030670166, -0.008094788, 0.07421875, 0.035186768, -0.011772156, 0.03451538, -0.034729004, 0.008468628, -0.0014667511, 0.025466919, -0.0061912537, -0.028518677, 0.010787964, 0.058135986, 0.018173218, -0.009277344, -0.0031738281, -0.056274414, 0.008308411, -0.018203735, 0.015808105, 0.019683838, -0.0067214966, 0.008369446, 0.04458618, -0.0075798035, -0.010391235, 0.018936157, -0.013267517, -0.051361084, 0.056121826, 0.015960693, -0.0072135925, 0.027297974, 0.029251099, -0.027145386, -0.023010254, -0.011047363, -0.0036392212, -0.017715454, 0.008621216, -0.0018901825, 0.01777649, -0.025268555, -0.0074653625, -0.011642456, 0.018112183, 0.004005432, -0.0259552, -0.05065918, -0.005744934, -0.011062622, 0.0012197495, 0.004070282, 0.021697998, -0.037261963, 0.006614685, -0.008705139, 0.019226074, 0.05621338, -0.022567749, -0.044555664, 0.007461548, -0.008331299, -0.008544922, -0.015258789, 0.031036377, -0.029693604, 0.0067481995, -0.010551453, 0.006965637, 0.05218506, 0.00932312, 0.004295349, -0.010292053, 0.017669678, -0.011672974, 0.07946777, -0.0043029785, 0.05734253, 0.046051025, -0.052825928, -0.010566711, 0.01360321, -0.018127441, 0.012123108, -0.015090942, -0.013626099, -0.02696228, -0.012107849, 0.06463623, -0.043273926, -0.010688782, -0.005378723, 0.049591064, -0.01247406, -0.019088745, -0.0009202957, -0.037017822, 0.0042648315, 0.013267517, 0.0018024445, -0.017578125, -0.016082764, -0.025817871, -0.01600647, -0.030700684, 0.01473999, 0.0014066696, 0.02722168, -0.07305908, 0.06726074, 0.028625488, 0.063964844, 0.045318604, -0.005039215, -0.02003479, 0.027893066, -0.018112183, -0.00030183792, -0.027893066, 0.0062217712, 0.012931824, -0.013916016, 0.02267456, 0.023254395, 0.01737976, 0.0015363693, 0.007194519, -0.013519287, 0.040985107, -0.009681702, 0.006313324, -0.022491455, -0.004184723, -0.015403748, 0.036224365, -0.0040359497, -0.0362854, 0.031433105, -0.010231018, 0.03579712, 0.035491943, -0.015586853, 0.016998291, 0.014556885, -0.08282471, -0.030578613, 0.0126571655, 0.087402344, -0.048950195, 0.02130127, -0.001581192, -0.013847351, 0.05734253, 0.004184723, -0.0043678284, -0.065979004, -0.11352539, -0.0009775162, -0.02734375, 0.048431396, -0.0637207, -0.020248413, 0.029159546, -0.035064697, -0.0057258606, 0.044158936, 0.019348145, 0.0036907196, 0.01927185, -0.027832031, -0.0077934265, -0.02923584, -0.0090789795, 0.01335144, -0.045410156, 0.010307312, -0.033843994, 0.0067481995, -0.01751709, 0.009979248, -0.008575439, 0.028915405, 0.042663574, -0.016921997, 0.022994995, 0.060394287, -0.014450073, -0.025970459, -0.044006348, -0.06842041, 0.01638794, 0.04147339, 0.008743286, 0.019592285, -0.062469482, -0.025741577, 0.0004849434, 0.0029716492, 0.004753113, -0.0075035095, -0.007358551, 0.011138916, 0.015007019, -0.005859375, 0.026229858, -0.010940552, -0.017562866, 0.033111572, -0.006084442, -0.032165527, 0.029937744, -0.014152527, 0.009941101, -0.015113831, -0.028366089, 0.009239197, -0.016784668, -0.015930176, -0.023544312, -0.024841309, 0.0022563934, -0.008201599, 0.023406982, -0.044006348, 0.008338928, 0.00010597706, -0.011253357, -0.045410156, -0.04547119, 0.018508911, 0.026916504, -0.019958496, 0.032470703, 0.061187744, 0.0021629333, -0.011260986, 0.026855469, 0.036010742, -0.018814087, 0.012718201, -0.012176514, 0.020858765, 0.041046143, 0.021957397, -0.0021572113, 0.0079956055, -0.0131073, -0.0063705444, 0.020309448, 0.02507019, -0.007335663, 0.0052871704, 0.002960205, 0.05117798, -0.0126953125, 0.0062942505, -0.0010852814, 0.04425049, 0.037139893, 0.024902344, -0.000831604, -0.020965576, -0.044036865, -0.08996582, 0.036895752, 0.074279785, 0.000518322, -0.025619507, 0.028839111, 0.066711426, 0.050109863, 0.05633545, 0.07043457, 0.0047721863, -0.013671875, -0.00605011, -0.021957397, -0.029083252, 0.009986877, -0.028305054, 0.023162842, -0.0063972473, 0.019729614, -0.0004620552, -0.030014038, -0.016235352, 0.006412506, -0.009803772, 0.00033164024, 0.05230713, 0.0023002625, -0.012107849, 0.032226562, 0.009124756, 0.03640747, 0.04699707, 0.008331299, -0.062408447, -0.013092041, -0.009269714, 0.043792725, 0.021453857, -0.0078086853, 0.018753052, 0.00712204, 0.038116455, 0.02468872, 0.027893066, 0.016296387, 0.07922363, 0.03881836, 0.011672974, 0.08117676, 0.033996582, 0.029800415, -0.11077881, -0.062286377, -0.032684326, 0.014076233, -0.053619385, 0.05215454, 0.06439209, -0.064208984, 0.08605957, -0.027236938, -0.0128479, 0.031280518, 0.012046814, 0.059387207, 0.00484848, -0.0073623657, 0.031066895, 0.03805542, 0.029144287, -0.011817932, -0.018188477, 0.04763794, -0.032165527, -0.06958008, 0.011795044, 0.0026817322, 0.045562744, -0.029266357, -0.04458618, -0.01285553, -0.04006958, -0.00894165, 0.027160645, -0.040100098, -0.024414062, -0.004180908, -0.0023498535, 0.0001693964, -0.005844116, -0.014945984, -0.008918762, -0.024002075, 0.025650024, -0.0074653625, -0.010093689, 0.013114929, 0.02079773, 0.025115967, -0.022872925, 0.023391724, -0.019897461, 0.00491333, -0.022857666, -0.020141602, 0.0007405281, -0.033050537, 0.013763428, -0.0011758804, 0.04763794, -0.021148682, 0.01512146, 0.02116394, 0.0056152344, 0.025787354, -0.030899048, 0.0062446594, 0.044708252, 0.025405884, -0.0035057068, 0.019546509, 0.026504517, -0.05883789, -0.016555786, -0.012191772, -0.03463745, 0.06274414, -0.07232666, -0.009918213, -0.010955811, -0.054504395, 0.000011503696, -0.024124146, -0.011505127, -0.01701355, -0.05215454, -0.00068616867, -0.021911621, 0.012489319, 0.001039505, 0.05230713, 0.013069153, -0.0032253265, 0.05267334, 0.022460938, 0.011581421, 0.035980225, -0.0211792, -0.0025138855, 0.030136108, -0.075683594, -0.002981186, 0.043182373, -0.00008457899, -0.013183594, 0.015640259, 0.007904053, -0.013435364, 0.033111572, -0.029418945, -0.010322571, -0.0057525635, -0.014312744, -0.014083862, 0.0028629303, 0.018096924, 0.015716553, 0.0025730133, -0.0074691772, 0.008338928, 0.029129028, -0.08691406, -0.030380249, 0.017089844, -0.093933105, -0.06542969, 0.028808594, -0.045532227, -0.025863647, -0.0259552, 0.031677246, -0.03778076, 0.028808594, -0.00056505203, -0.02758789, 0.045959473, 0.02709961, -0.045410156, 0.023086548, 0.019607544, 0.028121948, -0.015167236, -0.0079956055, 0.036193848, 0.028182983, 0.033721924, 0.014831543, -0.042236328, 0.041137695, -0.016845703, -0.033813477, 0.028793335, -0.049713135, 0.016937256, -0.03152466, 0.030929565, -0.040008545, -0.009124756, 0.019180298, 0.057403564, -0.06768799, -0.008651733, 0.08648682, 0.028747559, -0.105529785, 0.0836792, -0.04269409, -0.024719238, 0.03540039, 0.049713135, -0.0065345764, -0.013153076, 0.009002686, 0.0065345764, -0.041412354, -0.040405273, 0.012550354, 0.07531738, -0.03564453, -0.010124207, 0.01852417, 0.10559082, -0.014213562, 0.0012273788, -0.043792725, 0.011711121, -0.011474609, 0.0024356842, 0.006336212, -0.009246826, -0.092285156, -0.03451538, -0.008079529, -0.031799316, -0.030761719, 0.026184082, -0.008598328, -0.0077819824, -0.021224976, -0.04547119, 0.0027122498, 0.04748535, 0.0064353943, 0.03793335, -0.055267334, -0.059265137, -0.058258057, 0.010055542, -0.03643799, -0.015083313, -0.029769897, -0.024993896, -0.04385376, -0.008850098, 0.020492554, 0.024917603, 0.009239197, 0.021224976, 0.03451538, 0.0035820007, -0.031219482, 0.050994873, -0.011352539, -0.0045661926, -0.010467529, -0.00806427, -0.018341064, -0.020996094, 0.029083252, -0.026397705, 0.0059890747, -0.045837402, -0.03302002, 0.004432678, -0.003068924, -0.01335907, -0.025650024, -0.006340027, 0.0181427, 0.00058221817, 0.010765076, 0.0029640198, -0.00083065033, 0.0035686493, 0.010253906, 0.03677368, -0.019012451, -0.0059165955, 0.020370483, 0.007698059, -0.008621216, 0.0067329407, -0.009346008, -0.007965088, 0.07531738, -0.03543091, -0.013336182, -0.047943115, 0.010673523, 0.026870728, 0.010971069, 0.04751587, -0.0012817383, 0.01058197, -0.009590149, 0.016647339, -0.008987427, 0.012001038, 0.016708374, -0.012176514, -0.007675171, -0.044525146, 0.021408081, 0.07720947, -0.015449524, -0.020751953, -0.07635498, 0.0066375732, 0.013168335, 0.011184692, -0.026367188, -0.024108887, 0.06951904, -0.007671356, -0.00762558, 0.015930176, -0.010864258, -0.024093628, -0.002275467, 0.011108398, -0.051818848, 0.0284729, 0.06970215, -0.041015625, 0.009010315, 0.0070610046, -0.0056533813, -0.039215088, -0.030471802, 0.0029411316, -0.013824463, -0.020721436, -0.01927185, -0.01600647, 0.026748657, 0.02255249, -0.03591919, 0.008743286, -0.0010881424, 0.016723633, -0.03918457, -0.022949219, 0.05569458, 0.0385437, 0.0043792725, 0.039276123, -0.0030498505, -0.05456543, -0.013122559, -0.011016846, 0.0026283264, 0.011222839, -0.00844574, 0.020553589, 0.06124878, 0.017929077, -0.00844574, 0.0020370483, -0.0129470825, 0.01763916, -0.011566162, 0.026016235, 0.014701843, 0.006931305, 0.030639648, -0.024887085, 0.01852417, -0.08959961, -0.005126953, 0.020324707, -0.010437012, 0.0076560974, -0.024810791, 0.011489868, -0.055511475, 0.019256592, 0.0037021637, 0.031982422, 0.0074043274, -0.028778076, 0.02684021, -0.0018415451, -0.011924744, 0.0050354004, 0.02029419, -0.030349731, -0.046966553, 0.047790527, -0.011672974, 0.017593384, 0.005340576, 0.004512787, 0.037902832, -0.022583008, -0.05517578, -0.007686615, -0.025634766, -0.04925537, 0.03451538, 0.0211792, -0.06695557, 0.022491455, 0.0127334595, 0.021087646, -0.0037021637, 0.015899658, -0.01902771, -0.0071487427, -0.014854431, -0.012557983, 0.015625, 0.015068054, 0.028015137, 0.018875122, 0.024902344, -0.0110321045, 0.041259766, 0.037200928, 0.07165527, -0.03010559, 0.005004883, -0.03451538, -0.019546509, -0.054229736, 0.02418518, 0.030654907, -0.0063285828, -0.015312195, -0.062042236, 0.0012626648, -0.029541016, -0.008865356, 0.029083252, 0.00023972988, 0.026260376, 0.037597656, -0.015541077, -0.027908325, -0.0017910004, -0.008628845, -0.011047363, -0.034057617, 0.08001709, -0.019180298, 0.0023460388, 0.03201294, -0.007217407, 0.00034070015, -0.026916504, 0.04119873, -0.042541504, 0.010719299, 0.015853882, -0.019439697, -0.0031795502, -0.021530151, 0.00724411, 0.004425049, -0.028884888, 0.020095825, 0.017074585, -0.011756897, -0.027053833, -0.0011901855, 0.058563232, -0.0051460266, 0.0034160614, 0.0053634644, 0.01360321, -0.05178833, 0.00793457, -0.009864807, -0.017837524, 0.014419556, -0.007396698, 0.019882202, 0.0017938614, 0.016464233, 0.0211792, 0.031219482, 0.008842468, -0.008018494, -0.061767578, 0.013313293, 0.00774765, 0.008888245, -0.0018062592, -0.06549072, 0.0072517395, 0.048431396, -0.0121154785, 0.0038490295, 0.008262634, 0.0146102905, 0.023635864, -0.019058228, -0.02885437, -0.03768921, 0.021194458, -0.02468872, 0.02897644, 0.013412476, 0.05596924, -0.008666992, 0.023529053, -0.03515625, 0.026931763, 0.0011053085, 0.023803711, -0.023086548, 0.038879395, 0.027954102, -0.036102295, 0.021972656, 0.025161743, -0.033447266, 0.0019340515, 0.019042969, 0.01133728, -0.0309906, -0.015541077, -0.0029716492, 0.025894165, 0.03527832, -0.025985718, -0.03366089, -0.03414917, 0.001912117, 0.012916565, -0.011634827, 0.018051147, 0.017425537, 0.035980225, -0.0061569214, 0.007221222, -0.006942749, -0.027374268, -0.015625, 0.014884949, -0.007411957, 0.051513672, 0.028060913, -0.014183044, 0.032440186, 0.015823364, -0.026412964, 0.028625488, -0.010223389, 0.015335083, 0.028518677, 0.019577026, -0.055358887, 0.0033073425, 0.02204895, -0.0067863464, 0.05871582, -0.033996582, 0.0041275024, 0.004070282, -0.016036987, -0.002696991, 0.026809692, -0.000161767, 0.067993164, -0.012504578, 0.022827148, -0.00894928, -0.041259766, 0.020202637, -0.009239197, 0.0050201416, -0.020584106, 0.021881104, 0.010231018, 0.018035889, -0.014945984, 0.017227173, 0.035064697, 0.035369873, 0.077697754, 0.012008667, 0.03643799, -0.006038666, 0.008895874, -0.018325806, -0.009033203, 0.03894043, -0.008087158, -0.043304443, -0.029571533, 0.070251465, 0.047424316, 0.00566864, -0.04220581, 0.09033203, 0.030654907, -0.062927246, 0.044769287, 0.04437256, -0.0048217773, 0.005908966, -0.06311035, 0.0098724365, -0.028762817, -0.0027313232, 0.06951904, 0.04119873, -0.11425781, -0.016540527, -0.040039062, 0.009963989, -0.042022705, -0.022399902, 0.041015625, 0.016784668, -0.04159546, 0.03579712, 0.018463135, 0.045715332, -0.035247803, -0.05404663, -0.0069389343, 0.019500732, 0.010467529, 0.0013561249, -0.015655518, 0.051513672, 0.028076172, -0.0044174194, -0.01727295, -0.020645142, 0.0011930466, 0.032348633, 0.039886475, -0.0018978119, -0.04849243, -0.040374756, 0.02935791, 0.05581665, 0.0020923615, -0.009635925, -0.02368164, -0.0102005005, -0.04748535, -0.034179688, -0.019485474, 0.03427124, -0.039031982, 0.0076828003, -0.0023078918, -0.045532227, -0.009407043, -0.0024490356, -0.0069465637, -0.008255005, -0.015335083, 0.0056915283, 0.004837036, -0.018692017, 0.03704834, 0.025772095, 0.032104492, -0.009742737, -0.0079422, 0.026473999, 0.014480591, -0.005130768, -0.013999939, -0.013504028, 0.02583313, 0.0143966675, 0.026794434, 0.022338867, -0.026321411, 0.0010976791, -0.0059318542, -0.04776001, -0.0011606216, -0.021240234, 0.009475708, -0.021453857, 0.03060913, 0.036071777, 0.00037431717, 0.024993896, 0.009628296, 0.052093506, 0.051696777, -0.020019531, -0.022491455, 0.00944519, -0.01939392 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08460v1
Surrogate Modeling for Computationally Expensive Simulations of Supernovae in High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations
Keiya Hirashima, Kana Moriwaki, Michiko S. Fujii, Yutaka Hirai, Takayuki R. Saitoh, Junichiro Makino, Shirley Ho
astro-ph.GA, cs.AI, cs.LG
Some stars are known to explode at the end of their lives, called supernovae (SNe). The substantial amount of matter and energy that SNe release provides significant feedback to star formation and gas dynamics in a galaxy. SNe release a substantial amount of matter and energy to the interstellar medium, resulting in significant feedback to star formation and gas dynamics in a galaxy. While such feedback has a crucial role in galaxy formation and evolution, in simulations of galaxy formation, it has only been implemented using simple {\it sub-grid models} instead of numerically solving the evolution of gas elements around SNe in detail due to a lack of resolution. We develop a method combining machine learning and Gibbs sampling to predict how a supernova (SN) affects the surrounding gas. The fidelity of our model in the thermal energy and momentum distribution outperforms the low-resolution SN simulations. Our method can replace the SN sub-grid models and help properly simulate un-resolved SN feedback in galaxy formation simulations. We find that employing our new approach reduces the necessary computational cost to $\sim$ 1 percent compared to directly resolving SN feedback.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08460v1
2023-11-14T19:00:03
2023-11-14T19:00:03
{ "title": [ 0.0016536713, -0.021484375, 0.006504059, -0.05441284, -0.009521484, -0.005493164, -0.011207581, 0.0053138733, -0.029342651, 0.045013428, 0.027175903, -0.0032348633, 0.026672363, -0.043548584, -0.010856628, 0.007335663, 0.009216309, 0.006259918, -0.011474609, -0.035705566, 0.022155762, -0.013282776, 0.04067993, 0.05557251, 0.023239136, -0.016937256, -0.08453369, 0.0021095276, -0.020751953, -0.038726807, -0.016235352, 0.03567505, -0.0010643005, 0.03427124, 0.014205933, 0.03173828, -0.06762695, 0.0501709, 0.06021118, -0.04449463, 0.0074806213, -0.020507812, 0.033721924, -0.022232056, 0.019485474, 0.056549072, -0.070617676, -0.06427002, 0.017486572, 0.051361084, 0.0057907104, 0.0010910034, -0.014656067, 0.06512451, -0.009597778, -0.020721436, -0.0015077591, -0.022903442, 0.044830322, 0.003414154, 0.0079956055, -0.014823914, 0.026672363, 0.018432617, -0.016159058, -0.010437012, 0.021377563, -0.008285522, 0.08105469, 0.021209717, -0.0061454773, 0.028366089, 0.02128601, -0.016204834, -0.027404785, 0.010856628, 0.015487671, 0.010795593, 0.032684326, -0.048583984, 0.013038635, -0.029678345, 0.018356323, 0.0050086975, 0.024658203, 0.026321411, 0.00077438354, -0.020202637, 0.000020325184, -0.020355225, 0.0032615662, -0.035888672, 0.013198853, 0.03778076, -0.013412476, -0.023132324, -0.008018494, -0.019378662, 0.032562256, 0.023483276, -0.014007568, -0.006313324, 0.017608643, -0.032409668, 0.011756897, 0.04373169, -0.04171753, -0.02911377, 0.016494751, 0.035736084, 0.009819031, -0.04547119, 0.01979065, -0.009407043, -0.008651733, -0.01473999, -0.0070877075, 0.0043563843, 0.019744873, 0.0028648376, 0.022140503, -0.0045204163, 0.026687622, -0.037506104, 0.02130127, -0.027618408, -0.08178711, 0.010383606, -0.025619507, 0.029846191, -0.0033626556, 0.021743774, -0.06732178, -0.023223877, -0.039764404, 0.033325195, 0.030090332, 0.014328003, -0.026473999, 0.03540039, 0.04574585, -0.046417236, -0.0029850006, -0.0020809174, -0.008804321, -0.008605957, 0.04272461, 0.035064697, -0.015914917, -0.027770996, -0.008026123, 0.046691895, 0.045715332, -0.0053863525, -0.047027588, -0.009063721, -0.054870605, -0.024017334, -0.0035953522, -0.026626587, -0.014793396, -0.015838623, -0.025482178, -0.013031006, 0.0027484894, 0.022567749, 0.038238525, 0.010231018, 0.011726379, 0.04196167, -0.026260376, -0.0016517639, -0.009887695, -0.023010254, -0.015914917, 0.008155823, 0.00223732, -0.017074585, 0.0026302338, 0.047027588, 0.042114258, -0.0033836365, -0.02748108, 0.056549072, -0.022109985, -0.02911377, -0.026428223, -0.06866455, 0.042541504, 0.0070114136, -0.05505371, 0.051879883, -0.05279541, -0.017410278, -0.049835205, -0.002943039, 0.013671875, 0.027648926, -0.005756378, 0.015235901, -0.085876465, 0.027069092, -0.055908203, 0.045684814, -0.011161804, -0.017654419, -0.011604309, 0.036468506, -0.033477783, 0.05621338, 0.055511475, 0.06488037, -0.073913574, 0.03048706, 0.011878967, -0.03866577, -0.02281189, -0.0095825195, -0.02355957, -0.0013837814, -0.029190063, -0.004951477, -0.0031795502, 0.02645874, 0.016067505, -0.03277588, 0.026779175, -0.020904541, 0.029174805, 0.03894043, 0.0036792755, -0.019622803, 0.015701294, 0.04244995, 0.0090789795, 0.008865356, 0.027770996, 0.01979065, -0.00077819824, -0.016281128, 0.0018997192, -0.006538391, -0.002828598, 0.02168274, 0.03463745, -0.007659912, 0.022842407, 0.00554657, 0.028869629, 0.012390137, 0.027526855, -0.018127441, 0.04135132, -0.018249512, 0.032989502, 0.038513184, -0.010757446, 0.0124435425, -0.02305603, -0.02796936, 0.038085938, 0.06604004, 0.012550354, 0.031234741, -0.049835205, 0.021942139, -0.014228821, 0.020889282, 0.008918762, 0.010017395, 0.019699097, -0.032348633, 0.019515991, -0.0009675026, -0.041900635, -0.022155762, -0.006629944, 0.012046814, 0.0039634705, -0.05630493, -0.014961243, 0.010902405, 0.049804688, -0.007423401, -0.0044898987, -0.009552002, 0.022521973, -0.033081055, -0.0044937134, -0.02178955, 0.044891357, 0.01084137, 0.0026168823, -0.018493652, -0.02029419, -0.013641357, 0.051757812, 0.011451721, 0.012863159, 0.004371643, -0.05609131, 0.02722168, 0.031234741, -0.022079468, -0.0135650635, -0.0061187744, -0.012825012, 0.019882202, -0.0385437, -0.040252686, -0.014175415, 0.03265381, 0.028839111, -0.016296387, -0.0095825195, -0.016403198, 0.007419586, -0.0023231506, -0.024917603, 0.00308609, 0.05065918, -0.010971069, 0.00009357929, -0.02015686, -0.0006480217, -0.02468872, -0.022109985, -0.021911621, -0.013305664, 0.023773193, 0.06036377, 0.010925293, -0.03878784, -0.028442383, -0.0035572052, 0.010559082, -0.024337769, 0.006713867, -0.02848816, 0.045776367, 0.014205933, -0.017044067, 0.028335571, -0.06750488, 0.0066604614, -0.046966553, 0.0073165894, -0.01008606, 0.0006828308, 0.012870789, 0.0069007874, 0.005672455, -0.026290894, -0.009025574, 0.024017334, 0.044769287, 0.019973755, 0.02859497, 0.057556152, -0.022872925, -0.027801514, -0.0011615753, -0.04916382, -0.021621704, 0.041870117, -0.03768921, -0.04144287, -0.0020141602, -0.015563965, 0.023529053, -0.014160156, -0.014717102, -0.058929443, -0.0068893433, 0.008255005, 0.004573822, -0.035186768, -0.04937744, 0.0027923584, -0.020843506, 0.015579224, 0.02607727, -0.043823242, 0.034362793, 0.09063721, -0.024993896, -0.044677734, 0.004508972, 0.0042686462, 0.02949524, -0.02998352, -0.022598267, 0.01927185, -0.017059326, -0.027008057, -0.023086548, -0.017608643, 0.0033836365, -0.045715332, 0.022949219, -0.0001552105, 0.008712769, -0.017913818, 0.018051147, -0.05239868, 0.023773193, -0.038208008, -0.010437012, 0.013710022, -0.007965088, -0.004497528, -0.02456665, -0.007888794, -0.059783936, 0.01424408, -0.052825928, -0.10015869, 0.020812988, -0.054992676, -0.0017309189, -0.0012130737, 0.018112183, -0.04611206, -0.006626129, 0.036621094, 0.038024902, 0.023406982, -0.06628418, 0.048736572, 0.031341553, 0.015396118, 0.0059509277, -0.0126571655, -0.030960083, 0.0008940697, -0.0014305115, -0.021606445, 0.0473938, 0.0014228821, 0.0113220215, 0.021331787, 0.006225586, -0.00762558, 0.045898438, -0.007247925, -0.050201416, 0.0013685226, 0.017196655, 0.0013875961, 0.040039062, -0.015823364, 0.015602112, -0.03677368, 0.0015792847, -0.03515625, -0.04071045, 0.041900635, 0.0048065186, -0.070373535, -0.0259552, -0.018585205, -0.011940002, -0.025497437, -0.04550171, -0.010665894, -0.010559082, 0.033294678, -0.004436493, -0.033172607, 0.025161743, -0.012542725, 0.01676941, 0.030548096, 0.007701874, -0.008560181, 0.015945435, -0.020523071, 0.004043579, -0.017745972, 0.01134491, 0.0154800415, -0.017623901, 0.005836487, -0.048065186, 0.024276733, 0.0019435883, -0.070739746, 0.020446777, 0.010299683, -0.04336548, 0.00712204, -0.014633179, 0.02180481, -0.009117126, -0.0066452026, -0.015563965, -0.010322571, 0.0009274483, 0.018432617, -0.04534912, -0.03869629, 0.07501221, -0.02709961, -0.0029506683, 0.000104010105, 0.008651733, 0.024246216, -0.026443481, 0.005279541, -0.030273438, 0.042907715, -0.012886047, -0.027526855, 0.02281189, -0.020355225, -0.022750854, 0.062561035, -0.004760742, 0.0062065125, -0.008560181, 0.005935669, 0.0236969, -0.014526367, 0.078186035, -0.0054740906, -0.029220581, -0.0657959, -0.0031166077, -0.020904541, -0.027664185, -0.011856079, -0.011665344, -0.0026664734, 0.019256592, 0.06011963, 0.066589355, 0.0067214966, -0.00957489, 0.014801025, -0.02267456, -0.010658264, -0.013267517, 0.00038194656, 0.020874023, 0.016448975, 0.037139893, 0.012329102, 0.053497314, -0.032684326, 0.014633179, -0.016281128, -0.0016832352, -0.0028820038, -0.026275635, -0.090148926, 0.033935547, 0.00036382675, 0.0037231445, -0.0061454773, 0.033691406, 0.003408432, 0.006526947, -0.044403076, 0.01751709, 0.009468079, 0.015541077, -0.034454346, -0.053527832, 0.038269043, -0.018157959, -0.06732178, -0.048858643, 0.014137268, -0.003944397, 0.03729248, -0.023345947, -0.009254456, -0.008796692, 0.00054979324, -0.016433716, 0.06744385, -0.035125732, -0.042755127, -0.06719971, -0.010017395, -0.017166138, 0.0021514893, 0.006126404, -0.028579712, -0.051727295, -0.01335144, 0.00844574, -0.019485474, -0.027191162, 0.027374268, -0.010192871, 0.07519531, -0.019119263, 0.010910034, 0.019989014, 0.029586792, 0.0022506714, 0.0057640076, -0.040252686, -0.01586914, -0.00705719, 0.03552246, -0.012779236, 0.014709473, 0.026626587, 0.0019054413, -0.022018433, -0.004322052, 0.019332886, -0.010978699, -0.013259888, -0.046173096, 0.05621338, 0.012023926, -0.020904541, 0.0006170273, -0.025482178, 0.00730896, -0.02784729, 0.016479492, -0.05380249, 0.042297363, -0.021896362, -0.030563354, 0.0178833, -0.05645752, 0.012702942, -0.049072266, -0.10571289, -0.00182724, 0.07965088, 0.0022640228, -0.00047254562, 0.014839172, 0.030334473, 0.008323669, 0.050354004, 0.02268982, 0.011169434, -0.004966736, -0.009994507, -0.0047454834, -0.04626465, -0.0423584, -0.01096344, -0.0446167, 0.016555786, -0.011955261, 0.035247803, -0.06262207, 0.017303467, -0.0046577454, 0.0058517456, 0.027694702, -0.07904053, -0.0010175705, 0.035125732, 0.013031006, -0.036956787, 0.026260376, 0.039215088, 0.030136108, 0.048919678, 0.005607605, 0.033843994, 0.037109375, -0.01802063, 0.050933838, -0.0019073486, -0.0021533966, 0.016067505, 0.033935547, -0.0021953583, 0.047424316, -0.04837036, 0.0062561035, 0.0011453629, 0.02355957, 0.00945282, -0.04534912, 0.012878418, 0.016479492, -0.0034561157, 0.033477783, 0.004924774, 0.004550934, 0.013000488, 0.015029907, -0.027053833, 0.0011816025, 0.007713318, -0.0385437, -0.03111267, 0.029220581, -0.01158905, -0.014335632, -0.010070801, 0.020187378, -0.035125732, 0.021347046, 0.05722046, -0.011581421, 0.036987305, -0.0052452087, 0.00041985512, 0.061279297, 0.03036499, -0.025161743, 0.0065994263, 0.021362305, -0.045562744, -0.05657959, -0.00957489, -0.034484863, -0.011627197, -0.029342651, -0.032562256, -0.029464722, -0.012954712, 0.018463135, 0.008102417, -0.040405273, 0.0049209595, -0.028335571, -0.037231445, 0.023086548, 0.035003662, -0.032073975, 0.018218994, 0.014518738, -0.02355957, 0.02708435, -0.04232788, -0.036590576, 0.01322937, -0.018234253, 0.0060577393, 0.00274086, -0.0023880005, -0.03475952, 0.016708374, 0.029449463, -0.06866455, 0.015930176, 0.0082092285, 0.08062744, -0.05758667, -0.035308838, -0.033477783, -0.017303467, -0.05419922, -0.0039978027, 0.016860962, -0.022918701, -0.018661499, -0.04611206, -0.019134521, 0.013870239, 0.022232056, 0.027130127, 0.025878906, -0.029266357, 0.015991211, -0.041778564, -0.028076172, -0.06286621, 0.028411865, -0.024658203, -0.017700195, 0.038238525, -0.04156494, 0.00023543835, -0.036865234, 0.024551392, 0.050354004, 0.012916565, 0.029388428, -0.07739258, -0.04034424, -0.008865356, -0.028625488, 0.018707275, 0.015975952, -0.042053223, 0.029434204, -0.03527832, 0.06121826, 0.009460449, 0.023834229, 0.04925537, 0.04171753, -0.03579712, -0.0039749146, -0.0060806274, -0.037963867, 0.00178051, -0.058258057, -0.010971069, -0.046081543, -0.017349243, -0.026824951, -0.029922485, 0.029922485, 0.026550293, -0.0057792664, 0.012969971, -0.0005002022, 0.011352539, 0.04812622, 0.056854248, 0.06945801, 0.021942139, 0.0017700195, 0.004425049, 0.012191772, 0.01675415, 0.029373169, -0.00024199486, 0.011695862, -0.05340576, -0.0104522705, 0.0066070557, 0.007575989, -0.014579773, 0.00029301643, -0.004295349, -0.039276123, 0.04559326, 0.009025574, -0.0035362244, 0.057556152, 0.040740967, 0.05340576, -0.034820557, 0.012496948, 0.020492554, -0.02519226, 0.054534912, 0.09753418, -0.09649658, 0.06890869, 0.02078247, -0.06185913, 0.0027618408, 0.037078857, 0.03237915, -0.027648926, -0.011505127, 0.023040771, 0.026138306, 0.011528015, -0.018127441, -0.028518677, 0.010658264, 0.060028076, 0.028442383, -0.008850098, 0.0038280487, 0.02835083, -0.00995636, 0.0074920654, -0.07336426, 0.034301758, -0.0151901245, 0.014823914, 0.02079773, 0.025741577, 0.023590088, -0.000035881996, -0.033813477, 0.0018663406, -0.002796173, -0.030349731, -0.012870789, -0.037841797, 0.046844482, -0.0039711, 0.0073928833, -0.017791748, -0.052520752, 0.04171753, -0.041656494, 0.015342712, 0.0021209717, -0.029678345, 0.0066871643, -0.015388489, -0.05215454, 0.035217285, -0.038757324, 0.054901123, -0.0524292, 0.023468018, -0.046875, 0.034484863, 0.015136719, -0.07080078, -0.03262329, -0.02709961, -0.034088135, -0.004043579, -0.006855011, -0.0017910004, -0.08026123, -0.036621094, 0.05670166, -0.020095825, 0.009178162, 0.021591187, 0.00919342, -0.06665039, 0.010696411, -0.03970337, 0.039520264, -0.082336426, -0.026229858, -0.021438599, 0.020812988, 0.034606934, -0.002954483, -0.015808105, -0.0149002075, -0.012893677, -0.06732178, 0.026824951, 0.021835327, -0.019515991, -0.018844604, -0.04333496, -0.0009665489, -0.017929077, 0.004753113, 0.03817749, -0.03640747, -0.027938843, 0.010139465, -0.054748535, 0.032165527, 0.005203247, 0.006462097, -0.025756836, 0.030822754, 0.0026836395, -0.026397705, 0.056121826, 0.055664062, -0.023010254, -0.058898926, 0.04232788, -0.03060913, 0.049346924, -0.033691406, -0.07421875, -0.00094509125, 0.036071777, -0.010879517, 0.025421143, 0.025604248, 0.009185791, -0.030517578, 0.040802002, -0.011795044, -0.043426514, 0.028930664, -0.046691895, 0.014953613, 0.03933716, -0.016952515, -0.002029419, 0.013702393, 0.017440796, 0.036224365, -0.013885498, -0.030639648, 0.03918457, -0.02607727, 0.043762207, -0.0032577515, 0.05444336, -0.004589081, -0.030960083, 0.010185242, 0.0014038086, -0.034698486, 0.019454956, -0.04309082, 0.006095886, -0.015716553, -0.014434814, 0.005268097, 0.040374756, 0.0057525635, 0.043670654, -0.042633057, -0.028839111, -0.018539429, -0.0015268326, 0.016052246, -0.0023269653, -0.008972168, 0.03366089, 0.02067566, -0.00623703, -0.06964111, 0.017349243, -0.042907715, 0.040405273, -0.05001831, 0.04147339, -0.014595032, -0.009361267, 0.0008120537, 0.016067505, 0.0064811707, -0.021560669, -0.037841797, -0.05203247, 0.021453857, -0.025466919 ], "summary": [ -0.0051345825, -0.0028476715, -0.015777588, -0.012245178, -0.005241394, -0.006401062, -0.019683838, -0.016799927, -0.0024089813, 0.050231934, 0.018798828, -0.007545471, 0.05065918, -0.03375244, 0.011062622, -0.010734558, 0.052124023, -0.00762558, 0.021438599, -0.0093688965, -0.0102005005, 0.044006348, 0.03540039, 0.05307007, -0.016464233, -0.028915405, 0.015655518, -0.006603241, -0.012496948, -0.0104904175, -0.013374329, 0.019332886, -0.010757446, 0.042114258, 0.0031871796, -0.004623413, -0.018569946, 0.031280518, 0.031463623, -0.0072784424, -0.0013217926, 0.012565613, 0.091552734, -0.047332764, 0.0335083, 0.032409668, -0.046875, -0.07836914, 0.031280518, 0.01713562, -0.020843506, 0.012298584, -0.030944824, 0.010482788, -0.015014648, -0.017959595, 0.008605957, -0.009056091, 0.013511658, -0.0011920929, -0.00034546852, 0.013542175, 0.025222778, 0.0046043396, 0.0074424744, 0.0020656586, 0.033294678, 0.017105103, 0.043029785, 0.0107040405, -0.022949219, 0.017364502, -0.011955261, -0.03842163, -0.0013742447, 0.06311035, -0.010871887, 0.01991272, -0.010269165, 0.005126953, -0.0008993149, -0.016052246, -0.008346558, -0.03591919, 0.015686035, 0.005252838, -0.0027980804, -0.00756073, 0.019989014, 0.03692627, -0.016693115, -0.026641846, 0.017990112, 0.0690918, 0.017456055, -0.019134521, -0.0032653809, -0.03475952, 0.011528015, 0.03326416, 0.04034424, -0.051513672, 0.06628418, -0.037200928, 0.014129639, 0.08306885, -0.016662598, -0.033569336, -0.007736206, 0.015151978, 0.013702393, -0.079589844, -0.0030937195, 0.004600525, -0.015319824, 0.012054443, -0.009468079, -0.0067214966, -0.014595032, 0.024795532, 0.014305115, 0.041900635, -0.0023422241, -0.049316406, 0.0056648254, -0.028656006, -0.050079346, 0.0026493073, -0.03302002, 0.021453857, -0.023757935, 0.0062408447, 0.03427124, 0.019302368, -0.005558014, -0.018554688, 0.022888184, 0.032348633, 0.016220093, 0.017364502, 0.024169922, -0.025665283, 0.01626587, 0.016082764, 0.041870117, -0.0029640198, 0.04284668, 0.02798462, -0.0030536652, 0.01979065, 0.01474762, 0.054534912, 0.061431885, -0.007987976, -0.05886841, -0.07305908, -0.035583496, -0.041992188, 0.00819397, -0.06311035, -0.043670654, -0.014282227, 0.01625061, 0.01625061, 0.0126571655, 0.023284912, 0.020980835, 0.007881165, 0.0051078796, -0.023864746, 0.01335144, -0.03945923, 0.016448975, -0.04135132, -0.022705078, 0.017364502, 0.017852783, -0.016830444, -0.008758545, 0.02607727, 0.011367798, -0.036712646, -0.05508423, 0.027328491, 0.048065186, -0.07733154, 0.0048713684, -0.08294678, -0.008895874, 0.018127441, -0.0143966675, 0.032104492, -0.026687622, -0.021652222, 0.021133423, 0.027191162, -0.00592041, 0.015716553, -0.0037937164, -0.019866943, -0.015472412, 0.02482605, -0.006313324, 0.0024108887, -0.036712646, 0.022460938, -0.019851685, 0.04711914, -0.0289917, -0.0030937195, 0.040618896, 0.004219055, -0.066345215, 0.058532715, -0.012054443, -0.016571045, -0.0016670227, -0.009681702, -0.0041236877, 0.025924683, -0.023834229, 0.040222168, -0.049346924, 0.0055999756, 0.0446167, -0.03491211, 0.009963989, -0.027114868, 0.050933838, 0.00957489, -0.0072746277, -0.000041425228, 0.01637268, 0.0009899139, -0.03375244, 0.013671875, 0.031341553, -0.025543213, -0.0018196106, 0.021987915, 0.011726379, -0.0038528442, -0.013130188, 0.015029907, 0.0070762634, -0.029083252, 0.018615723, 0.006416321, 0.0047035217, 0.06335449, -0.008148193, 0.022857666, 0.007423401, -0.003314972, -0.013511658, 0.041137695, -0.004058838, -0.012741089, 0.018844604, -0.004295349, 0.020339966, 0.036743164, -0.0128479, 0.024734497, -0.033050537, 0.016113281, 0.00094747543, 0.010879517, 0.02067566, -0.012969971, 0.0010490417, -0.028060913, 0.0026493073, 0.029159546, -0.07757568, -0.012756348, -0.03491211, 0.029632568, 0.011520386, -0.015541077, -0.012901306, 0.0030155182, 0.056762695, -0.019897461, 0.020324707, -0.026931763, 0.018493652, -0.047180176, 0.040130615, 0.04815674, 0.032562256, 0.052978516, 0.0027008057, 0.03149414, 0.030776978, 0.0099105835, 0.052856445, -0.0049705505, 0.0029773712, -0.021408081, -0.001531601, 0.040161133, 0.020263672, -0.04171753, -0.0011377335, 0.033111572, 0.014480591, 0.0018558502, -0.016983032, -0.07171631, 0.020324707, -0.01247406, 0.015083313, 0.008399963, 0.014678955, 0.00010240078, 0.008430481, 0.039794922, 0.046447754, 0.07336426, 0.12158203, 0.034484863, 0.017822266, -0.028030396, 0.021514893, -0.04336548, -0.03338623, -0.03375244, -0.007888794, 0.01348114, 0.02243042, 0.0066108704, 0.008132935, 0.06222534, 0.0132369995, -0.011276245, 0.0003273487, -0.008956909, -0.011871338, -0.020736694, 0.010238647, -0.00945282, -0.010147095, -0.0027179718, 0.0029850006, -0.038085938, 0.03149414, 0.0047912598, 0.00970459, 0.007019043, 0.014411926, -0.004600525, -0.0129852295, 0.034210205, 0.03466797, 0.017425537, 0.01928711, 0.078552246, 0.054718018, -0.0010471344, -0.044158936, -0.02532959, -0.08911133, -0.03866577, 0.06604004, 0.011054993, -0.052368164, -0.029266357, -0.026794434, 0.029266357, 0.018737793, -0.0143966675, -0.028823853, -0.0126953125, -0.03262329, 0.01020813, 0.013900757, -0.029220581, -0.004962921, 0.003610611, -0.010887146, 0.013008118, -0.025344849, 0.0018606186, 0.077697754, -0.027618408, -0.06573486, -0.012931824, 0.020019531, 0.049957275, -0.023880005, -0.06210327, 0.07098389, -0.019104004, -0.016433716, -0.025527954, -0.00026535988, 0.036834717, -0.008239746, -0.014076233, 0.00374794, 0.046020508, 0.025360107, 0.013206482, -0.062438965, 0.08337402, -0.043518066, 0.00605011, 0.00055885315, -0.030899048, 0.012359619, -0.03781128, 0.0012073517, -0.034820557, 0.020996094, -0.058380127, -0.011543274, 0.016662598, -0.052520752, -0.00907135, -0.025009155, 0.06958008, -0.014770508, -0.015563965, 0.061279297, 0.01979065, -0.009178162, -0.07269287, 0.054351807, 0.053527832, 0.019073486, 0.015380859, -0.045410156, -0.017593384, 0.007545471, 0.057373047, 0.024963379, 0.001294136, 0.038269043, -0.020706177, 0.005092621, 0.0025024414, 0.03930664, 0.027664185, 0.0121154785, -0.017150879, 0.022064209, 0.023162842, 0.008728027, -0.0056991577, -0.049621582, 0.0061836243, 0.031829834, 0.024414062, -0.020553589, -0.02104187, 0.0151901245, 0.020248413, 0.0029525757, -0.051696777, -0.010360718, -0.02268982, -0.029129028, -0.018630981, -0.011817932, -0.02659607, 0.078186035, -0.0020217896, -0.010246277, 0.004722595, -0.047790527, 0.018997192, -0.00031256676, -0.029373169, -0.017181396, -0.027832031, 0.026412964, -0.013008118, 0.048736572, 0.0030555725, -0.030212402, 0.005256653, -0.008491516, -0.00078201294, 0.03982544, -0.009414673, 0.0034046173, 0.01197052, 0.029785156, -0.041503906, -0.048706055, -0.0013990402, 0.039093018, -0.026733398, 0.028518677, 0.000869751, -0.008277893, 0.03286743, 0.00017130375, -0.026123047, -0.016525269, -0.014602661, -0.011138916, 0.010314941, 0.0025634766, 0.020309448, 0.05645752, 0.027328491, -0.012329102, -0.005771637, 0.05328369, -0.029449463, 0.048187256, 0.018478394, 0.0039634705, -0.0037441254, 0.054382324, 0.03552246, 0.0045318604, -0.0132751465, -0.020431519, 0.07104492, -0.005016327, 0.045135498, -0.018539429, -0.030456543, -0.022521973, 0.036956787, -0.016845703, -0.010848999, -0.028289795, 0.013923645, -0.02633667, -0.0015897751, 0.07373047, -0.0022201538, -0.008293152, -0.0029735565, -0.0054130554, -0.017837524, -0.0029907227, 0.0010547638, 0.005077362, 0.00022280216, -0.015464783, -0.009483337, -0.0077552795, 0.029830933, -0.040130615, -0.0115356445, 0.0087509155, 0.029281616, -0.006164551, -0.03643799, -0.01374054, 0.008651733, 0.014564514, -0.032806396, -0.014640808, 0.033172607, -0.044708252, -0.048797607, 0.01751709, 0.037963867, -0.0127334595, 0.03378296, -0.024383545, -0.03918457, -0.0074424744, 0.0057907104, -0.021530151, -0.01360321, 0.019943237, -0.043182373, 0.0011110306, -0.03289795, -0.02330017, -0.0037155151, 0.011100769, 0.011871338, 0.029937744, -0.030334473, -0.040161133, -0.10357666, -0.010009766, 0.040130615, -0.03778076, 0.013328552, -0.034057617, -0.016815186, -0.044799805, 0.035125732, -0.025405884, -0.008918762, 0.030014038, 0.04257202, 0.03933716, -0.056640625, -0.027709961, 0.0030555725, 0.01537323, 0.0124435425, 0.018539429, -0.0010318756, -0.024719238, 0.025299072, 0.009490967, 0.04663086, 0.01687622, 0.021743774, -0.0038604736, -0.038391113, -0.02406311, 0.034210205, -0.013931274, -0.044677734, -0.053375244, 0.05569458, 0.024536133, 0.0012292862, 0.0020065308, -0.025115967, -0.019851685, -0.024368286, -0.025772095, 0.029144287, 0.04360962, -0.032989502, -0.054260254, 0.03479004, -0.042144775, 0.012550354, -0.066467285, -0.06738281, -0.02659607, 0.05984497, -0.012191772, -0.04458618, 0.013847351, 0.0039634705, -0.0099487305, 0.027267456, -0.016906738, 0.031555176, 0.04711914, 0.016235352, 0.009994507, -0.013519287, -0.022155762, -0.04058838, 0.0072898865, 0.033569336, 0.0031089783, 0.040924072, -0.0054626465, 0.026672363, 0.009925842, 0.025100708, 0.004173279, -0.040527344, -0.050964355, -0.011695862, 0.016204834, -0.07305908, 0.053253174, 0.010688782, 0.0031585693, 0.02432251, -0.026794434, 0.049926758, -0.010620117, -0.005443573, 0.021331787, -0.028656006, 0.011528015, 0.011817932, 0.015327454, 0.011993408, 0.01991272, -0.052215576, -0.0005617142, -0.024215698, 0.010650635, -0.014205933, -0.006965637, 0.01838684, -0.004962921, 0.014823914, 0.011253357, 0.010719299, -0.007949829, 0.02394104, -0.0014533997, -0.030899048, 0.006340027, -0.0067634583, -0.008285522, -0.039642334, 0.039611816, -0.040924072, 0.008018494, -0.022903442, 0.005630493, -0.01739502, -0.046173096, 0.0129852295, -0.010284424, 0.036071777, -0.036346436, 0.0012378693, -0.010879517, 0.008110046, -0.041168213, -0.00055933, 0.0011205673, -0.051208496, -0.07635498, -0.01838684, -0.028366089, 0.026870728, -0.019897461, -0.045654297, 0.0074043274, 0.009384155, 0.03845215, -0.016983032, -0.03363037, -0.016525269, -0.005722046, -0.015159607, -0.0007352829, -0.025665283, -0.027755737, -0.008285522, -0.0068130493, 0.008140564, -0.0037994385, -0.023025513, -0.027618408, 0.0317688, 0.036712646, -0.014907837, 0.021087646, -0.006702423, -0.037322998, -0.002872467, 0.016220093, -0.07849121, 0.02319336, -0.022827148, 0.081970215, -0.030303955, -0.02798462, -0.046844482, -0.00042700768, -0.07965088, -0.033203125, 0.048461914, 0.005718231, -0.0017032623, -0.014511108, 0.014808655, -0.007209778, 0.006576538, -0.003358841, 0.032806396, -0.042022705, -0.010139465, 0.0049705505, -0.025604248, -0.0055618286, 0.045532227, -0.0032539368, -0.024734497, 0.0076675415, -0.055847168, -0.0004093647, -0.0010824203, 0.004924774, 0.025405884, -0.024841309, 0.04272461, -0.024337769, -0.0014533997, -0.02079773, 0.0032787323, 0.07336426, 0.00472641, 0.006439209, 0.06604004, 0.024337769, 0.02507019, -0.02192688, -0.04711914, -0.01838684, -0.020355225, -0.039031982, -0.034851074, 0.016799927, -0.039978027, 0.02949524, -0.05206299, -0.0262146, -0.022521973, -0.038970947, 0.034729004, -0.06781006, 0.050567627, -0.03253174, 0.012107849, -0.008895874, -0.017822266, 0.04397583, -0.03387451, 0.06903076, -0.013656616, 0.0234375, -0.0027999878, -0.013336182, -0.008621216, -0.0057029724, 0.029342651, 0.018600464, 0.010498047, -0.03387451, -0.009590149, 0.07836914, -0.029525757, -0.04574585, 0.011299133, 0.019363403, -0.044189453, 0.028213501, -0.0030269623, 0.008094788, 0.056121826, 0.0118637085, 0.06365967, -0.031051636, 0.03640747, 0.0748291, -0.048217773, 0.08380127, 0.075805664, -0.039123535, 0.026000977, 0.031829834, -0.05102539, -0.0126953125, 0.04812622, 0.0064811707, -0.0073661804, 0.006877899, -0.0028381348, 0.0051994324, 0.007820129, -0.10058594, -0.061157227, -0.017456055, 0.064208984, 0.035491943, -0.052124023, -0.046844482, 0.026947021, 0.043151855, -0.0181427, -0.03945923, 0.02355957, -0.07092285, 0.009422302, 0.023895264, 0.028961182, 0.021591187, -0.031585693, -0.024261475, 0.013771057, 0.007194519, -0.009048462, -0.023162842, 0.03439331, -0.0044898987, -0.006038666, -0.027053833, -0.0793457, -0.037078857, 0.058624268, -0.013015747, 0.04763794, -0.016143799, 0.0012454987, -0.00995636, -0.005340576, 0.007347107, 0.006614685, 0.011482239, 0.025314331, -0.04034424, 0.024414062, -0.016479492, -0.03668213, -0.0012712479, -0.018966675, 0.01576233, -0.044921875, -0.013656616, -0.022949219, -0.018447876, -0.008201599, -0.09289551, -0.053527832, 0.10864258, -0.038238525, -0.016281128, 0.008529663, 0.017089844, -0.023483276, -0.050628662, -0.03173828, 0.0029315948, -0.0463562, -0.027328491, 0.011161804, 0.0119018555, 0.033935547, 0.0024223328, -0.032836914, 0.03955078, 0.012260437, -0.06616211, 0.03918457, 0.040405273, -0.022842407, -0.030334473, -0.012382507, -0.010597229, -0.008850098, 0.023345947, 0.022705078, -0.0030136108, -0.018844604, -0.00054836273, -0.028289795, 0.00566864, -0.025238037, 0.015823364, 0.045562744, 0.015792847, 0.03579712, -0.02407837, 0.01675415, 0.00012385845, 0.004524231, -0.06488037, 0.008872986, -0.039093018, 0.006095886, -0.02519226, -0.05630493, 0.034179688, 0.044067383, 0.0051841736, -0.017349243, 0.01890564, -0.0049705505, 0.0090789795, -0.0049705505, 0.0046424866, -0.018081665, 0.018188477, -0.0016174316, -0.028457642, 0.013381958, -0.010154724, -0.0013551712, 0.006816864, -0.017654419, 0.015823364, -0.048034668, -0.033935547, 0.0021247864, -0.033416748, -0.0076026917, -0.0112838745, 0.09161377, -0.032165527, -0.041992188, 0.016433716, -0.032409668, -0.024124146, 0.021255493, -0.066345215, -0.0029258728, 0.02507019, 0.029251099, -0.049224854, 0.0041923523, 0.013160706, 0.011108398, -0.044433594, -0.030380249, 0.012084961, 0.010955811, 0.0027179718, 0.022750854, -0.010986328, 0.0152282715, -0.003993988, -0.033081055, -0.07159424, 0.023223877, -0.036102295, 0.008811951, -0.013160706, 0.03543091, 0.07342529, -0.0029678345, 0.021820068, 0.003944397, 0.03616333, -0.028701782, 0.004508972, 0.017181396, 0.009208679, 0.003698349 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09127v1
Jailbreaking GPT-4V via Self-Adversarial Attacks with System Prompts
Yuanwei Wu, Xiang Li, Yixin Liu, Pan Zhou, Lichao Sun
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Existing work on jailbreak Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has focused primarily on adversarial examples in model inputs, with less attention to vulnerabilities in model APIs. To fill the research gap, we carry out the following work: 1) We discover a system prompt leakage vulnerability in GPT-4V. Through carefully designed dialogue, we successfully steal the internal system prompts of GPT-4V. This finding indicates potential exploitable security risks in MLLMs; 2)Based on the acquired system prompts, we propose a novel MLLM jailbreaking attack method termed SASP (Self-Adversarial Attack via System Prompt). By employing GPT-4 as a red teaming tool against itself, we aim to search for potential jailbreak prompts leveraging stolen system prompts. Furthermore, in pursuit of better performance, we also add human modification based on GPT-4's analysis, which further improves the attack success rate to 98.7\%; 3) We evaluated the effect of modifying system prompts to defend against jailbreaking attacks. Results show that appropriately designed system prompts can significantly reduce jailbreak success rates. Overall, our work provides new insights into enhancing MLLM security, demonstrating the important role of system prompts in jailbreaking, which could be leveraged to greatly facilitate jailbreak success rates while also holding the potential for defending against jailbreaks.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09127v1
2023-11-15T17:17:39
2023-11-15T17:17:39
{ "title": [ -0.0026664734, 0.015365601, -0.018661499, -0.009002686, 0.0008788109, -0.023498535, 0.008224487, -0.026901245, -0.05859375, 0.03050232, 0.021759033, 0.00082588196, -0.010108948, -0.055358887, -0.021743774, -0.010696411, 0.00029277802, -0.00040626526, -0.025482178, -0.03338623, -0.014518738, -0.027389526, 0.01637268, -0.015556335, -0.029083252, -0.0058898926, -0.020324707, -0.025680542, -0.033233643, -0.06365967, -0.012191772, 0.05456543, 0.021942139, 0.040130615, -0.011398315, 0.052764893, -0.04031372, 0.05783081, 0.018417358, 0.009796143, -0.0050849915, 0.010398865, -0.036102295, -0.0039901733, -0.047668457, -0.0005302429, -0.059570312, -0.013038635, -0.00057172775, 0.08190918, -0.0024986267, 0.03982544, -0.026138306, 0.080566406, 0.022003174, -0.014633179, -0.0109939575, -0.029556274, 0.036102295, 0.07727051, 0.019989014, -0.04296875, 0.012702942, -0.059265137, -0.016998291, -0.0141067505, -0.010551453, 0.021835327, 0.051483154, 0.010169983, 0.0034751892, 0.00894928, 0.0076408386, 0.008758545, -0.048065186, -0.014846802, 0.056518555, 0.012237549, 0.011459351, -0.01058197, 0.029510498, 0.016174316, -0.009590149, -0.047790527, 0.035369873, -0.03515625, -0.013725281, -0.0049209595, -0.0076026917, -0.041107178, 0.0070495605, -0.034729004, -0.0022087097, 0.0178833, 0.006629944, -0.06329346, 0.0009794235, 0.015083313, 0.012893677, -0.027038574, -0.019607544, -0.0019330978, -0.03439331, -0.017990112, -0.0058517456, -0.0026760101, 0.016204834, 0.010231018, -0.0005273819, 0.021514893, -0.037475586, 0.008804321, 0.02810669, 0.022506714, -0.03656006, -0.006252289, 0.023468018, -0.015335083, -0.015342712, 0.028274536, -0.013793945, -0.018218994, 0.02053833, -0.0022716522, 0.05831909, 0.029281616, -0.041748047, 0.006916046, -0.024108887, 0.020111084, 0.0052871704, 0.061676025, -0.078430176, -0.0692749, -0.06262207, 0.020004272, -0.00032186508, 0.0024433136, -0.014892578, 0.00819397, 0.023757935, -0.039215088, -0.0112838745, 0.006412506, -0.035308838, 0.014793396, 0.04071045, 0.0059394836, -0.028823853, -0.055480957, -0.025604248, -0.04046631, -0.006378174, 0.026916504, 0.02217102, 0.018615723, -0.034484863, -0.0036334991, 0.029632568, 0.028076172, 0.03289795, -0.009765625, -0.004760742, 0.068359375, 0.07110596, 0.032348633, -0.02142334, 0.037078857, 0.00093078613, 0.045288086, -0.027191162, 0.01965332, 0.031921387, -0.02961731, -0.013168335, -0.0010070801, 0.0050964355, -0.015419006, 0.023208618, -0.013511658, 0.0016126633, -0.01247406, 0.0020580292, 0.032226562, -0.039367676, -0.03378296, 0.008628845, 0.02746582, 0.042907715, 0.019073486, -0.0496521, -0.014663696, -0.044036865, 0.010253906, -0.0026474, 0.0012359619, -0.004837036, 0.03869629, -0.010513306, -0.043426514, -0.022003174, 0.006778717, -0.021255493, 0.0026988983, -0.059539795, -0.016479492, -0.026535034, 0.044067383, -0.00983429, 0.027893066, 0.035705566, -0.016082764, -0.016296387, -0.014152527, -0.010635376, -0.024917603, 0.00030136108, 0.025421143, 0.0020198822, 0.016860962, 0.017868042, -0.028778076, 0.023956299, -0.00579834, 0.030258179, 0.03161621, 0.0011940002, -0.0034656525, 0.06707764, 0.06237793, 0.037597656, -0.061065674, 0.038757324, 0.018615723, -0.046020508, -0.036315918, -0.027114868, -0.029434204, 0.024780273, 0.051605225, 0.015823364, -0.04168701, -0.026367188, -0.037231445, 0.068115234, -0.02305603, 0.00014901161, -0.0042800903, 0.031341553, 0.012298584, 0.028762817, -0.008712769, 0.060058594, -0.008079529, 0.02319336, 0.060333252, 0.016189575, 0.041412354, -0.024978638, 0.005264282, -0.0063934326, 0.060333252, 0.019622803, 0.029815674, -0.029876709, -0.017211914, -0.035064697, 0.005771637, -0.021957397, 0.014129639, 0.0368042, -0.03540039, -0.0041656494, -0.021255493, 0.050994873, -0.049194336, -0.038391113, 0.016357422, 0.01108551, -0.046020508, -0.020355225, -0.016098022, 0.021957397, -0.00040006638, 0.033599854, 0.0062026978, 0.029327393, 0.0072135925, -0.06173706, -0.0020561218, 0.04559326, 0.034118652, -0.0009851456, -0.00059986115, -0.0065956116, 0.023834229, 0.06829834, 0.05496216, -0.021148682, 0.019989014, -0.02583313, 0.010375977, -0.0028152466, -0.00084495544, 0.010116577, 0.027435303, 0.03604126, -0.033172607, -0.03479004, 0.044006348, -0.06781006, 0.014701843, -0.0007171631, 0.023712158, -0.07537842, -0.06945801, -0.04373169, -0.011207581, -0.043151855, -0.018447876, 0.068115234, -0.021743774, 0.017288208, -0.011421204, 0.0017089844, -0.06463623, 0.015174866, -0.019973755, -0.031433105, 0.005683899, 0.05606079, 0.00027370453, -0.033599854, -0.011604309, 0.021881104, 0.022888184, 0.000057578087, 0.044799805, -0.029647827, -0.024398804, -0.019577026, -0.0368042, -0.013328552, -0.024749756, 0.011161804, -0.029571533, -0.0058937073, 0.01739502, -0.06323242, -0.013435364, 0.042419434, -0.05596924, 0.015342712, -0.014015198, 0.05883789, 0.00030064583, -0.04525757, -0.0021381378, 0.049621582, -0.033691406, 0.02420044, 0.045074463, 0.038269043, -0.01802063, -0.03378296, -0.06384277, -0.0059661865, 0.031311035, 0.004211426, 0.029876709, -0.01235199, 0.00049209595, -0.04336548, -0.012542725, 0.0030574799, -0.017959595, -0.033935547, -0.050201416, -0.0043296814, -0.043670654, 0.022506714, -0.00051546097, 0.0060920715, -0.0071105957, 0.08831787, -0.0024909973, -0.016784668, 0.011528015, -0.0059661865, -0.0076026917, -0.023117065, -0.03277588, -0.01876831, 0.005054474, 0.038208008, 0.0055999756, -0.032928467, -0.0056114197, -0.09942627, 0.0017347336, 0.064941406, -0.055847168, -0.05633545, 0.010505676, -0.034851074, -0.0703125, 0.03756714, -0.027908325, 0.025863647, 0.026245117, 0.0008249283, -0.00037693977, 0.038330078, -0.04626465, 0.024520874, -0.020874023, -0.09185791, 0.023788452, 0.0071029663, -0.02508545, -0.032287598, -0.0023002625, -0.043273926, -0.018081665, -0.03012085, 0.008583069, 0.031951904, 0.022979736, 0.0020618439, 0.013298035, 0.0033245087, -0.015716553, 0.005580902, 0.0026855469, -0.016067505, 0.019332886, 0.011184692, 0.011444092, 0.04522705, -0.01449585, -0.022781372, 0.009048462, -0.014183044, 0.03793335, 0.0050468445, -0.050354004, -0.012641907, -0.045196533, -0.030456543, 0.004852295, 0.0066337585, 0.023361206, -0.026107788, 0.0042037964, -0.018096924, 0.045074463, 0.013595581, 0.027404785, -0.024108887, -0.009895325, 0.01084137, -0.00051116943, -0.0340271, -0.005420685, -0.025650024, -0.05215454, 0.05001831, -0.0059051514, -0.023773193, 0.009437561, -0.05038452, 0.072631836, -0.0020923615, 0.0340271, -0.0011930466, 0.0039138794, -0.029266357, 0.055664062, -0.078186035, 0.0011034012, -0.011207581, 0.013702393, -0.009506226, -0.034484863, -0.037200928, 0.034362793, -0.056518555, -0.017700195, 0.00497818, -0.047790527, -0.05935669, -0.02947998, 0.0060272217, -0.03414917, -0.021621704, -0.0052223206, 0.010025024, -0.027038574, -0.011459351, -0.061645508, -0.059753418, 0.07751465, -0.025375366, -0.0031051636, 0.03768921, -0.012313843, -0.017166138, 0.02507019, 0.021194458, 0.025970459, 0.043518066, 0.0069465637, -0.02053833, 0.062347412, -0.050628662, 0.053771973, -0.01751709, -0.012954712, -0.006877899, 0.028793335, 0.020858765, 0.032318115, -0.04827881, 0.047668457, 0.03338623, 0.0013303757, -0.107177734, 0.030975342, 0.011459351, -0.09277344, -0.0022468567, -0.027267456, -0.033416748, 0.060577393, 0.03778076, 0.08337402, -0.009246826, -0.0008687973, -0.012786865, -0.026611328, -0.019821167, -0.039764404, 0.0046195984, -0.019470215, -0.024276733, 0.0058898926, -0.020004272, 0.049682617, -0.0446167, -0.011802673, 0.0047187805, 0.01612854, -0.050842285, -0.02041626, -0.082458496, 0.044799805, -0.011703491, 0.021743774, -0.010406494, 0.0032863617, 0.046020508, -0.028457642, -0.02432251, -0.0121536255, 0.039154053, -0.023239136, 0.018554688, -0.06573486, -0.031066895, 0.018096924, -0.07006836, -0.038330078, -0.016799927, -0.0009946823, -0.010009766, -0.03173828, -0.01600647, 0.0060157776, 0.021759033, 0.05508423, 0.026062012, 0.013847351, -0.026809692, 0.0357666, 0.012214661, -0.01550293, -0.021957397, 0.0066833496, -0.001502037, -0.025161743, -0.00504303, -0.015625, 0.011238098, -0.041931152, 0.010299683, -0.03869629, 0.0579834, -0.017227173, 0.0014820099, 0.0010213852, -0.0024662018, -0.007980347, -0.007007599, -0.031951904, 0.03640747, 0.03488159, 0.03125, 0.028076172, 0.011772156, 0.024429321, 0.030883789, 0.012840271, -0.044067383, 0.025512695, -0.010192871, 0.0078125, -0.035736084, 0.042419434, -0.003063202, 0.0055618286, 0.015930176, -0.014320374, 0.02659607, -0.06945801, 0.029312134, -0.057128906, 0.027801514, 0.03555298, 0.008422852, 0.0055770874, 0.02420044, 0.015037537, -0.026626587, -0.02708435, 0.03164673, 0.010139465, -0.025558472, 0.0027713776, 0.008384705, 0.023422241, 0.03274536, 0.04397583, 0.004673004, -0.02658081, -0.022018433, -0.01134491, -0.016326904, -0.04928589, -0.040527344, -0.015159607, -0.02949524, 0.028198242, -0.01058197, 0.04309082, -0.025222778, 0.0058555603, -0.0019292831, -0.0035076141, 0.0029125214, -0.058258057, -0.0137786865, 0.015022278, -0.023620605, -0.006755829, 0.0005774498, 0.031280518, 0.03414917, 0.03781128, 0.00907135, -0.0030670166, 0.022262573, 0.004749298, 0.025131226, 0.012168884, 0.021636963, 0.0028572083, 0.051696777, -0.0001707077, 0.022720337, -0.051452637, 0.016738892, 0.03491211, -0.014190674, 0.060638428, -0.06567383, 0.020965576, 0.0005850792, -0.013427734, -0.008255005, -0.033569336, -0.03845215, 0.019744873, -0.035949707, 0.009246826, 0.02166748, -0.0141067505, -0.017944336, -0.021408081, 0.047027588, -0.023544312, 0.012260437, 0.009719849, -0.010108948, -0.02798462, 0.013259888, 0.008781433, -0.047790527, -0.035247803, 0.019180298, 0.031219482, 0.01159668, 0.008468628, -0.041778564, 0.0051231384, -0.07714844, -0.03967285, -0.019317627, -0.03225708, -0.002620697, 0.058044434, -0.006477356, -0.05255127, -0.011016846, 0.021575928, 0.034454346, 0.019989014, -0.023483276, 0.024536133, -0.018798828, 0.0033664703, 0.0014324188, 0.03253174, -0.01096344, 0.002281189, 0.008049011, -0.030395508, 0.024353027, 0.017730713, 0.022781372, -0.0022468567, -0.009651184, 0.0004723072, 0.036132812, 0.00017917156, -0.032318115, -0.007507324, 0.012481689, -0.032989502, -0.012207031, -0.015464783, 0.07116699, -0.022460938, -0.009162903, -0.007144928, -0.012870789, -0.022598267, 0.092163086, 0.0040740967, -0.027938843, -0.044769287, -0.05316162, -0.0234375, 0.015510559, 0.027526855, 0.024642944, 0.033416748, -0.068481445, -0.0021209717, -0.043304443, -0.008049011, -0.020095825, 0.018295288, -0.02468872, -0.013702393, 0.036315918, -0.0060920715, -0.018356323, -0.006336212, 0.045562744, -0.0026474, -0.009849548, -0.0016288757, 0.023849487, -0.0049209595, -0.04788208, 0.015167236, 0.036102295, 0.031204224, -0.020187378, 0.047851562, -0.04257202, 0.055725098, 0.028411865, 0.01361084, 0.03543091, 0.033111572, 0.015312195, 0.01424408, -0.0024147034, -0.01146698, -0.0014038086, -0.06201172, 0.029144287, -0.033996582, 0.010864258, -0.058258057, 0.027435303, 0.006259918, 0.047943115, 0.014579773, 0.025726318, 0.05203247, 0.00038409233, 0.021453857, -0.046051025, 0.07885742, 0.015556335, 0.028396606, -0.013763428, -0.030731201, 0.025894165, 0.012313843, -0.04260254, 0.061553955, -0.005428314, -0.0036849976, 0.029647827, -0.022781372, 0.025009155, -0.028030396, -0.0209198, -0.017700195, -0.014274597, -0.012840271, -0.012413025, 0.049438477, 0.042755127, 0.0071144104, -0.023849487, 0.0022220612, -0.007286072, 0.018096924, -0.024978638, 0.052093506, -0.03778076, 0.032592773, 0.0012273788, -0.034942627, -0.042419434, 0.046051025, 0.0059814453, 0.0020828247, -0.0088272095, 0.051940918, 0.015510559, 0.047851562, -0.0206604, -0.02394104, -0.019012451, 0.046905518, 0.023345947, -0.001285553, 0.018157959, 0.0012187958, 0.043823242, -0.016403198, 0.024429321, -0.024276733, 0.013343811, -0.036224365, 0.027008057, -0.04446411, 0.012580872, -0.01574707, -0.035339355, 0.029891968, 0.0023937225, -0.0052604675, 0.00026011467, 0.022644043, 0.04336548, 0.025527954, 0.06958008, 0.022735596, -0.01184082, 0.005332947, 0.008270264, 0.011024475, 0.013687134, -0.023757935, -0.0018825531, -0.028442383, -0.028686523, 0.0062828064, -0.029815674, 0.037719727, 0.0140686035, 0.033843994, -0.03866577, -0.025665283, 0.059326172, -0.06561279, -0.00017869473, -0.0062828064, 0.049194336, -0.0236969, -0.025848389, -0.03933716, -0.008140564, 0.005718231, 0.046661377, 0.039001465, 0.011405945, 0.005897522, -0.045562744, -0.018081665, 0.07055664, 0.019805908, 0.07745361, 0.008026123, -0.024841309, -0.009025574, 0.018249512, -0.0026950836, -0.01499176, -0.012664795, -0.007221222, -0.014038086, 0.020339966, -0.014945984, 0.0008831024, -0.025924683, -0.023529053, -0.03186035, 0.034729004, -0.03189087, 0.029769897, 0.02142334, -0.03302002, -0.060180664, 0.0025539398, -0.033813477, 0.03994751, 0.010009766, -0.03982544, 0.039276123, -0.022567749, -0.0050621033, 0.028747559, 0.023162842, 0.04949951, -0.06036377, -0.02041626, -0.012924194, 0.02909851, 0.017562866, -0.07110596, -0.045074463, -0.012741089, 0.07861328, -0.012321472, 0.012237549, -0.019683838, -0.008338928, 0.03161621, 0.047424316, 0.0071487427, -0.04296875, -0.011230469, -0.005332947, 0.05444336, 0.024963379, -0.020904541, -0.013999939, 0.0026283264, -0.0082473755, 0.018218994, 0.005455017, -0.018676758, 0.020629883, -0.005756378, 0.02494812, -0.02798462, 0.030838013, 0.034179688, 0.043182373, -0.0143966675, 0.02230835, -0.0074043274, -0.0064849854, 0.00957489, 0.0042915344, -0.0032348633, -0.02923584, 0.009643555, 0.026824951, -0.0028934479, 0.06628418, -0.014602661, -0.0206604, 0.005001068, 0.009124756, -0.01234436, 0.0025043488, 0.027450562, -0.020095825, -0.004119873, -0.017044067, -0.042816162, -0.036621094, -0.010734558, 0.017440796, -0.041412354, 0.03100586, -0.02470398, -0.017089844, 0.008224487, 0.039855957, 0.022888184, 0.028808594, -0.031707764, -0.05319214, 0.015342712, -0.023773193 ], "summary": [ -0.031433105, -0.030685425, -0.025360107, 0.007873535, -0.047821045, -0.005344391, -0.041259766, -0.015464783, -0.04360962, 0.011924744, 0.029769897, 0.009597778, -0.018569946, -0.060180664, 0.025115967, -0.025650024, -0.017440796, 0.0060539246, -0.0071754456, -0.033843994, 0.022476196, -0.04269409, 0.0014448166, -0.029296875, 0.0007200241, -0.012840271, 0.009605408, 0.0034484863, -0.015655518, -0.018600464, 0.00011050701, 0.024032593, 0.019882202, 0.022994995, -0.032958984, 0.049682617, -0.0309906, 0.032592773, 0.026031494, -0.00048303604, 0.03604126, -0.0039520264, -0.0033817291, 0.01965332, -0.0368042, 0.03994751, -0.013191223, -0.012207031, 0.02708435, 0.040283203, -0.00919342, 0.008483887, -0.028747559, -0.0031108856, -0.009147644, -0.031311035, -0.018157959, -0.011894226, 0.012397766, 0.13146973, 0.03390503, 0.005279541, -0.05218506, -0.117492676, -0.0013074875, 0.017913818, 0.010246277, -0.0068740845, 0.044647217, 0.019989014, -0.01197052, -0.0028533936, 0.01675415, -0.046325684, -0.012771606, 0.059570312, 0.007545471, 0.0309906, 0.015136719, -0.037261963, 0.031921387, 0.03878784, -0.007003784, -0.060516357, 0.033843994, -0.049194336, -0.0031719208, -0.024124146, 0.018127441, -0.0003170967, -0.0054397583, 0.009239197, -0.0029621124, 0.060516357, 0.010475159, -0.036956787, 0.01727295, 0.026977539, 0.0047416687, -0.00969696, 0.018875122, -0.036743164, 0.001613617, -0.03967285, -0.00919342, 0.05697632, 0.030517578, -0.014701843, -0.017669678, -0.010017395, -0.024124146, -0.0020771027, 0.011497498, -0.00957489, -0.047576904, 0.012672424, 0.019897461, -0.00712204, 0.0016460419, 0.013641357, -0.048431396, -0.025115967, -0.010520935, 0.0070495605, 0.023742676, 0.006011963, -0.0025043488, 0.024475098, -0.05078125, 0.030776978, 0.032165527, 0.049072266, -0.06878662, -0.024261475, -0.054260254, 0.0021514893, 0.006084442, 0.030410767, 0.004337311, 0.011169434, 0.0011034012, -0.03479004, 0.001033783, 0.008476257, -0.031951904, 0.02798462, 0.006565094, 0.012931824, 0.01033783, -0.042999268, -0.0053634644, -0.051330566, -0.005050659, 0.009857178, 0.023605347, 0.014656067, -0.0056152344, 0.014968872, 0.009468079, 0.012168884, 0.020065308, -0.014549255, 0.030822754, 0.07489014, 0.021255493, 0.03277588, -0.034820557, -0.0110321045, 0.010734558, 0.032043457, -0.05419922, 0.040283203, 0.029006958, -0.00793457, 0.0049438477, 0.006000519, 0.0001680851, 0.039733887, 0.04159546, -0.03881836, 0.0039100647, -0.02330017, 0.105895996, -0.021377563, -0.037872314, -0.0357666, 0.016571045, 0.06933594, 0.054656982, 0.027160645, -0.008285522, -0.07434082, -0.031341553, 0.016189575, 0.020584106, -0.0015821457, -0.025405884, 0.02017212, -0.015670776, -0.049346924, 0.025405884, 0.0077590942, -0.018478394, -0.034362793, -0.08892822, -0.013008118, -0.023529053, 0.02734375, 0.02053833, 0.017349243, 0.013793945, -0.0016040802, -0.050842285, 0.030319214, -0.007698059, -0.008346558, -0.00806427, 0.04598999, 0.023925781, 0.0008878708, 0.051208496, -0.03555298, 0.049316406, 0.021133423, -0.030715942, -0.006072998, -0.0004723072, 0.018692017, 0.025726318, 0.030151367, 0.046661377, -0.055541992, 0.018127441, 0.0058555603, -0.02670288, -0.03768921, -0.015625, -0.113220215, 0.025543213, 0.076049805, 0.014724731, 0.02067566, -0.05065918, -0.055267334, 0.02885437, 0.0012111664, 0.024978638, -0.020721436, -0.00070524216, 0.031173706, -0.00033903122, -0.010276794, 0.018951416, -0.04067993, -0.015991211, 0.041168213, 0.01890564, -0.021102905, -0.011810303, 0.0060653687, 0.03753662, 0.00037384033, -0.06347656, 0.02355957, -0.044525146, -0.05935669, -0.045654297, -0.03805542, 0.009925842, -0.034454346, 0.028961182, -0.068603516, 0.0057640076, -0.048583984, 0.013946533, -0.035125732, -0.038604736, 0.0184021, 0.03604126, -0.036499023, -0.03024292, -0.033325195, -0.062805176, -0.015289307, 0.041656494, 0.034057617, -0.005218506, -0.008239746, -0.03842163, 0.07128906, 0.0546875, 0.059143066, 0.020095825, -0.0035953522, -0.034240723, 0.050323486, 0.06866455, 0.029632568, 0.005695343, 0.0033283234, 0.02960205, 0.027816772, -0.030303955, 0.0025596619, 0.0041770935, 0.03326416, 0.026916504, 0.0044174194, -0.003955841, 0.014671326, -0.038085938, -0.008262634, 0.018035889, 0.0869751, -0.069885254, -0.04626465, -0.021636963, 0.033355713, -0.013725281, 0.005218506, 0.1083374, -0.0395813, 0.033935547, 0.021911621, -0.023986816, -0.07696533, 0.06286621, -0.022460938, -0.026672363, 0.0043182373, 0.013710022, -0.024307251, -0.0048294067, -0.00077199936, 0.006351471, -0.0064735413, -0.0057907104, 0.071899414, -0.00667572, -0.015655518, 0.004901886, -0.024551392, -0.016525269, 0.00756073, -0.021713257, -0.023254395, 0.0054473877, 0.0033493042, -0.025238037, -0.0072898865, 0.029586792, -0.029266357, 0.011100769, 0.0146484375, 0.049560547, 0.0024490356, -0.035369873, 0.025726318, 0.029846191, -0.02558899, 0.025253296, 0.043121338, 0.0131073, -0.036499023, -0.030441284, -0.046661377, 0.0008573532, 0.0055656433, 0.04309082, 0.003993988, 0.015510559, -0.0068969727, -0.003835678, 0.0078125, 0.055267334, -0.013298035, 0.0496521, -0.019927979, 0.015411377, 0.020706177, 0.011482239, 0.02507019, -0.014587402, 0.02658081, 0.14611816, -0.021408081, -0.013496399, 0.0703125, 0.01474762, 0.013328552, -0.044006348, -0.06774902, -0.030273438, -0.006439209, 0.030059814, -0.0052719116, 0.005958557, 0.026947021, -0.06097412, -0.02357483, 0.06695557, -0.038909912, -0.025100708, -0.010437012, 0.0017719269, -0.048065186, 0.05441284, -0.0039978027, 0.024291992, 0.00017654896, 0.029312134, -0.045959473, 0.024215698, -0.050598145, 0.015464783, -0.02558899, -0.049102783, -0.00333786, 0.012130737, 0.005268097, -0.016830444, 0.013374329, -0.029876709, 0.01687622, -0.02519226, 0.066223145, -0.031799316, 0.004043579, -0.008911133, 0.057159424, 0.008079529, 0.017211914, 0.002445221, 0.03994751, -0.013656616, 0.05215454, 0.025344849, -0.010681152, 0.068359375, -0.05529785, -0.020751953, -0.0046463013, -0.012321472, -0.013427734, 0.0036811829, -0.05041504, 0.0138549805, -0.018875122, -0.024856567, 0.006439209, -0.031951904, 0.011245728, 0.024383545, 0.030258179, -0.0054397583, 0.039489746, -0.014831543, 0.021865845, 0.027053833, -0.026062012, 0.0031661987, 0.007118225, -0.056854248, -0.008712769, -0.019424438, -0.0023937225, -0.005039215, 0.024459839, 0.003643036, -0.025238037, -0.0025596619, 0.049743652, -0.011352539, 0.007881165, -0.008399963, -0.0036125183, 0.012130737, 0.031951904, -0.020751953, -0.016708374, -0.084106445, 0.049468994, -0.014419556, -0.07318115, -0.06488037, 0.024551392, -0.052215576, -0.037841797, -0.018096924, 0.0030765533, -0.016906738, -0.009048462, 0.036834717, -0.043823242, -0.016799927, 0.0023555756, -0.0046081543, -0.017211914, -0.0013456345, -0.019592285, -0.047332764, 0.019256592, 0.014518738, 0.00007212162, 0.018325806, 0.0004079342, -0.008460999, 0.02029419, 0.022918701, 0.0054626465, 0.012451172, -0.009361267, -0.03314209, 0.014892578, -0.018981934, 0.045898438, -0.008773804, -0.028457642, 0.016433716, 0.016540527, 0.009689331, 0.049560547, -0.01586914, 0.020462036, -0.008651733, 0.02267456, -0.07537842, 0.035064697, -0.0101623535, -0.038116455, 0.0054512024, 0.004917145, -0.042419434, 0.008377075, 0.048919678, 0.033172607, -0.037994385, 0.01876831, 0.003932953, -0.028015137, -0.0463562, -0.025726318, 0.021224976, 0.018417358, -0.018585205, 0.020736694, -0.02267456, 0.035980225, -0.012664795, -0.017288208, 0.013404846, 0.020645142, -0.0046577454, -0.046203613, -0.052612305, 0.042938232, 0.02178955, -0.008979797, -0.0034294128, 0.019882202, 0.03286743, -0.029159546, 0.017044067, -0.022842407, 0.052642822, -0.0074501038, 0.0022392273, -0.07824707, -0.015975952, 0.025497437, -0.016738892, -0.008003235, -0.006290436, -0.029800415, -0.036743164, -0.04373169, -0.030899048, 0.022506714, -0.03387451, 0.011253357, 0.040740967, 0.02293396, -0.034576416, 0.026947021, 0.0071411133, 0.012252808, 0.009094238, 0.0062332153, 0.0067214966, 0.0090789795, 0.00029611588, -0.016998291, -0.004348755, 0.008399963, 0.004840851, -0.008087158, 0.032928467, -0.052490234, 0.009475708, 0.0009355545, -0.022247314, -0.016906738, -0.00030231476, -0.011833191, 0.038208008, 0.031219482, -0.04626465, 0.05380249, -0.01914978, 0.02709961, 0.006652832, 0.040985107, -0.024291992, -0.019515991, -0.007217407, 0.024002075, -0.047424316, 0.06842041, 0.043701172, -0.033813477, 0.013580322, 0.005039215, -0.020751953, 0.011039734, -0.02368164, -0.010948181, 0.039916992, 0.03591919, -0.01953125, 0.009376526, 0.027999878, -0.01512146, -0.003326416, -0.027450562, 0.0317688, 0.010131836, 0.003610611, 0.0017023087, -0.029922485, -0.018081665, 0.014915466, 0.005935669, -0.016784668, -0.028884888, -0.0070152283, -0.013313293, -0.023895264, -0.022827148, -0.022460938, -0.053253174, -0.025146484, 0.028900146, 0.013061523, 0.05218506, -0.011375427, 0.023483276, 0.015655518, -0.024017334, -0.015960693, -0.08166504, -0.064941406, -0.054992676, -0.025390625, -0.03414917, 0.02279663, 0.01637268, 0.010536194, 0.023239136, -0.004837036, 0.0035991669, -0.0042419434, 0.018066406, 0.029647827, -0.012519836, 0.013328552, 0.010520935, 0.028137207, 0.012527466, 0.023391724, -0.04058838, 0.0026683807, 0.009613037, -0.016464233, 0.06384277, -0.05319214, 0.035369873, -0.017211914, -0.008918762, -0.021713257, 0.031311035, -0.058441162, -0.024978638, -0.0054969788, -0.027450562, -0.03744507, -0.04333496, -0.028167725, -0.01966858, 0.03439331, -0.014801025, -0.002811432, -0.0029716492, -0.0028457642, -0.018173218, -0.0028133392, 0.01171875, 0.020812988, -0.043273926, 0.030090332, 0.036132812, -0.021820068, 0.002866745, -0.040405273, -0.005756378, -0.04071045, -0.015319824, -0.037841797, -0.021102905, -0.009971619, 0.044158936, -0.014541626, 0.003604889, 0.050201416, -0.0019779205, 0.052001953, 0.011894226, -0.013031006, 0.0037670135, -0.03286743, -0.040161133, 0.021255493, -0.041778564, -0.02067566, 0.017364502, -0.014465332, -0.021347046, 0.041503906, -0.01737976, -0.003627777, 0.004562378, 0.039031982, -0.00009280443, 0.034454346, -0.025894165, -0.043395996, 0.012779236, 0.007335663, -0.024429321, -0.0033111572, -0.02949524, 0.024291992, 0.017456055, -0.00806427, 0.008728027, -0.0043945312, -0.009780884, 0.053771973, 0.014045715, -0.00868988, -0.0345459, -0.060943604, 0.00642395, 0.012229919, -0.004852295, 0.047454834, 0.022018433, -0.0152282715, 0.054595947, -0.0028820038, -0.033050537, -0.04574585, 0.014305115, -0.02230835, -0.0340271, 0.07623291, -0.003982544, -0.0335083, -0.008453369, -0.011177063, 0.0031013489, 0.020385742, -0.002714157, 0.04840088, -0.0064849854, -0.038391113, 0.021469116, 0.02444458, 0.03842163, -0.002456665, 0.0340271, 0.0035915375, 0.03817749, 0.055786133, 0.014717102, 0.011390686, -0.009208679, 0.034942627, 0.031677246, -0.006198883, -0.016174316, 0.014472961, -0.023361206, -0.039123535, -0.043945312, -0.041656494, -0.007167816, 0.032592773, -0.022628784, 0.010986328, 0.06378174, 0.014663696, 0.054260254, 0.005115509, -0.033050537, -0.046081543, 0.022262573, 0.0051956177, -0.005947113, 0.039855957, -0.037750244, 0.0104522705, 0.048339844, -0.020889282, 0.021240234, -0.0085372925, 0.018463135, 0.032073975, -0.059143066, -0.012954712, -0.046417236, 0.010253906, -0.028900146, -0.007259369, -0.006542206, 0.014007568, 0.04360962, -0.011520386, 0.04751587, -0.023712158, 0.00039720535, -0.038330078, 0.015571594, -0.038085938, -0.01210022, -0.01675415, 0.021316528, 0.016921997, -0.014724731, 0.0019330978, 0.0418396, 0.035858154, -0.033966064, 0.009902954, 0.032684326, -0.00806427, -0.028137207, -0.03717041, -0.032196045, -0.0029640198, 0.020202637, 0.011222839, 0.005760193, -0.019042969, -0.034362793, 0.017913818, -0.00036931038, 0.015068054, -0.032958984, 0.010528564, -0.042907715, 0.02456665, -0.020599365, -0.023345947, -0.005279541, -0.017868042, -0.022140503, 0.01637268, 0.0038375854, -0.0026416779, 0.031677246, 0.08105469, 0.06304932, 0.06866455, -0.038909912, 0.012145996, 0.08154297, 0.0041160583, 0.011268616, -0.0024604797, 0.003982544, -0.031036377, -0.02406311, -0.0023937225, -0.0075302124, -0.027999878, 0.030349731, -0.004737854, 0.03945923, -0.0440979, -0.01889038, -0.007965088, -0.053710938, 0.042419434, -0.011306763, 0.0054244995, -0.012168884, -0.012321472, -0.035461426, -0.0011701584, -0.024658203, 0.009460449, 0.010437012, 0.007209778, 0.021881104, -0.019546509, -0.000073969364, 0.012687683, 0.00881958, 0.06097412, 0.005924225, -0.021881104, 0.016540527, 0.017242432, -0.0039405823, -0.027816772, -0.019866943, 0.015327454, 0.0046157837, 0.01852417, -0.029891968, 0.0020961761, -0.03100586, -0.024765015, -0.025436401, 0.027832031, -0.04397583, 0.07525635, 0.0446167, -0.02293396, -0.07208252, 0.018005371, -0.016418457, 0.057617188, -0.019119263, -0.01625061, 0.023513794, -0.005378723, 0.0027618408, 0.017150879, 0.03778076, 0.034240723, -0.04736328, -0.070617676, 0.00819397, -0.008560181, 0.015296936, -0.021484375, -0.0362854, 0.027450562, 0.05340576, -0.023742676, -0.0715332, -0.01826477, -0.022964478, 0.07086182, 0.06384277, 0.010536194, -0.04949951, 0.034606934, 0.022018433, 0.041107178, -0.013496399, -0.035064697, 0.026641846, -0.018951416, -0.06945801, -0.0070114136, -0.00094795227, -0.0014371872, -0.0042266846, 0.002040863, 0.009117126, -0.035980225, 0.00073194504, 0.024856567, 0.0335083, -0.035491943, -0.010375977, 0.0021762848, -0.009613037, -0.006259918, -0.0019893646, -0.037475586, 0.01864624, -0.027038574, -0.0017757416, -0.00705719, 0.013442993, -0.0021915436, 0.033416748, 0.026351929, 0.015258789, 0.0041542053, 0.0076560974, -0.019683838, 0.0069084167, -0.017700195, -0.038360596, -0.05508423, -0.06732178, -0.04360962, -0.0038490295, -0.02003479, 0.041900635, 0.042541504, 0.0011882782, 0.026000977, 0.056549072, 0.015098572, 0.04510498, -0.014671326, -0.0043754578, 0.017456055, -0.013389587 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09312v1
H-Packer: Holographic Rotationally Equivariant Convolutional Neural Network for Protein Side-Chain Packing
Gian Marco Visani, William Galvin, Michael Neal Pun, Armita Nourmohammad
q-bio.BM, cs.AI, cs.LG, J.3; I.2.0
Accurately modeling protein 3D structure is essential for the design of functional proteins. An important sub-task of structure modeling is protein side-chain packing: predicting the conformation of side-chains (rotamers) given the protein's backbone structure and amino-acid sequence. Conventional approaches for this task rely on expensive sampling procedures over hand-crafted energy functions and rotamer libraries. Recently, several deep learning methods have been developed to tackle the problem in a data-driven way, albeit with vastly different formulations (from image-to-image translation to directly predicting atomic coordinates). Here, we frame the problem as a joint regression over the side-chains' true degrees of freedom: the dihedral $\chi$ angles. We carefully study possible objective functions for this task, while accounting for the underlying symmetries of the task. We propose Holographic Packer (H-Packer), a novel two-stage algorithm for side-chain packing built on top of two light-weight rotationally equivariant neural networks. We evaluate our method on CASP13 and CASP14 targets. H-Packer is computationally efficient and shows favorable performance against conventional physics-based algorithms and is competitive against alternative deep learning solutions.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09312v1
2023-11-15T19:12:47
2023-11-15T19:12:47
{ "title": [ -0.064941406, -0.014083862, -0.07800293, -0.044067383, -0.020584106, -0.006450653, -0.061462402, 0.023712158, -0.010070801, 0.028823853, -0.010154724, -0.011886597, 0.016906738, -0.040130615, 0.0074882507, -0.003768921, 0.02796936, 0.030380249, 0.01020813, -0.012176514, -0.011054993, 0.007232666, 0.04864502, 0.07019043, -0.0020866394, -0.06341553, -0.029907227, 0.011787415, -0.01625061, -0.024978638, -0.0046577454, 0.004886627, 0.057006836, 0.022277832, -0.046936035, 0.014183044, -0.01828003, 0.019058228, -0.0051231384, 0.019546509, -0.004047394, 0.018127441, -0.0055732727, -0.05026245, -0.038269043, 0.040161133, -0.072265625, -0.004623413, 0.013473511, 0.057403564, 0.016036987, -0.041412354, 0.0021018982, 0.046844482, -0.0071144104, -0.038757324, -0.040100098, 0.0129852295, 0.04272461, 0.04953003, 0.013954163, -0.04611206, 0.00919342, -0.04159546, -0.05065918, -0.0149002075, -0.04373169, 0.015731812, 0.013221741, -0.040618896, 0.006565094, -0.00434494, -0.0181427, -0.016036987, -0.028320312, 0.018814087, 0.035491943, 0.023513794, -0.0031471252, -0.0206604, -0.01940918, -0.023498535, -0.011314392, 0.0039138794, -0.002658844, 0.009536743, -0.03338623, -0.013420105, -0.00042414665, -0.016052246, 0.007045746, 0.031829834, 0.026748657, 0.009605408, -0.035949707, -0.037841797, -0.025924683, -0.037353516, 0.027832031, 0.049957275, 0.027297974, -0.022644043, 0.07757568, -0.025527954, 0.024520874, 0.036254883, -0.03756714, -0.05593872, 0.024658203, 0.018585205, -0.008239746, -0.0038833618, 0.009468079, -0.010139465, 0.06915283, 0.011932373, -0.01247406, 0.09088135, -0.008735657, 0.04360962, -0.012710571, -0.005958557, 0.007347107, -0.017089844, 0.038726807, 0.021652222, -0.017715454, -0.012893677, -0.06829834, 0.052764893, 0.020019531, 0.020721436, -0.05343628, 0.001701355, -0.032989502, 0.033111572, 0.0418396, 0.026000977, 0.0066871643, -0.014381409, 0.032348633, -0.001616478, -0.022216797, -0.0025997162, -0.04727173, 0.037139893, 0.06121826, -0.028366089, -0.09075928, -0.08404541, -0.022354126, 0.0098724365, 0.026473999, 0.008346558, -0.056152344, -0.018295288, -0.054138184, -0.023010254, -0.017211914, -0.036102295, -0.01184845, -0.010681152, -0.0044403076, -0.012016296, 0.025970459, -0.0011529922, 0.0076446533, 0.027786255, 0.01159668, 0.031555176, -0.0014181137, 0.017974854, -0.0003836155, -0.015075684, -0.0028953552, -0.0060195923, 0.051727295, -0.04345703, -0.009399414, 0.020721436, -0.0090789795, -0.020370483, -0.037139893, 0.023208618, -0.04168701, -0.02822876, -0.03427124, -0.056640625, 0.066223145, -0.009742737, -0.022064209, 0.033081055, -0.044708252, -0.008239746, -0.04107666, 0.02230835, 0.00592041, 0.041809082, -0.0031909943, -0.0050582886, -0.09552002, -0.0181427, -0.004814148, 0.027832031, 0.020858765, -0.023223877, 0.0062179565, 0.006542206, -0.009513855, 0.030960083, 0.023605347, -0.017700195, -0.015029907, -0.010093689, -0.022506714, -0.067993164, 0.028549194, 0.022262573, -0.025512695, 0.0368042, -0.040893555, -0.004558563, -0.033050537, 0.026733398, 0.032958984, -0.005138397, 0.015960693, -0.042816162, 0.03994751, 0.015571594, 0.016189575, 0.011306763, -0.00819397, -0.04095459, -0.036956787, 0.016098022, -0.01235199, 0.0041160583, -0.0063095093, 0.020050049, -0.00248909, -0.006160736, -0.02305603, 0.019454956, 0.054901123, 0.03842163, 0.02897644, 0.0029888153, 0.027420044, 0.056488037, 0.052764893, 0.028778076, 0.027145386, 0.006011963, 0.013626099, 0.03439331, 0.012245178, 0.022476196, -0.00907135, 0.020950317, -0.020202637, 0.06439209, 0.043304443, 0.009605408, -0.011314392, -0.03363037, -0.0051612854, 0.010047913, 0.02357483, -0.011299133, 0.015930176, -0.032836914, 0.008476257, -0.013885498, -0.030288696, -0.075927734, -0.013252258, 0.019073486, -0.01626587, -0.06982422, 0.0035152435, 0.018692017, 0.01675415, -0.0034427643, 0.030548096, -0.018859863, 0.0005493164, -0.008018494, -0.0096206665, 0.017562866, 0.03475952, 0.03010559, 0.009460449, -0.013259888, 0.04019165, 0.0062332153, 0.05154419, 0.064208984, -0.04031372, 0.04309082, -0.055786133, 0.0016794205, 0.02909851, -0.0592041, -0.010055542, 0.032196045, 0.015312195, 0.0059814453, -0.032470703, -0.00081157684, -0.05810547, -0.011627197, -0.006137848, -0.054473877, -0.060516357, -0.04196167, -0.046875, -0.052215576, -0.07525635, -0.0135650635, 0.02859497, -0.0015888214, -0.0027580261, -0.005897522, 0.0056648254, -0.023986816, -0.028045654, -0.021636963, -0.012908936, 0.024856567, 0.06109619, 0.04840088, -0.033050537, 0.011604309, 0.019515991, 0.023483276, -0.003894806, -0.016326904, -0.025436401, 0.0028762817, -0.0070266724, -0.0018882751, 0.022491455, -0.048706055, -0.00026154518, -0.030090332, 0.02583313, 0.0068626404, -0.021850586, -0.0043563843, 0.026443481, -0.024459839, -0.020309448, 0.007549286, 0.024276733, 0.008605957, 0.011993408, 0.029342651, 0.0070533752, -0.012893677, 0.022659302, -0.009979248, -0.021224976, -0.05569458, 0.0031356812, -0.033813477, -0.014175415, -0.024551392, 0.021850586, 0.05279541, -0.042907715, 0.012702942, -0.026931763, 0.0036354065, 0.012107849, -0.009628296, -0.04135132, -0.033447266, -0.012458801, -0.037506104, 0.016799927, 0.010986328, -0.01776123, -0.0058021545, 0.042510986, 0.0107803345, -0.00040888786, 0.009254456, 0.0057296753, -0.019882202, -0.0069732666, 0.022628784, 0.024963379, -0.0079956055, -0.0020160675, 0.0016107559, -0.0026760101, -0.016296387, -0.046875, 0.0016946793, 0.016220093, 0.01210022, -0.01449585, 0.0023117065, -0.0635376, -0.010307312, -0.035064697, -0.014472961, 0.000626564, 0.08135986, -0.049987793, -0.013206482, -0.03768921, 0.0042152405, 0.031799316, -0.021331787, -0.08074951, 0.00868988, 0.0104522705, -0.003419876, -0.023208618, 0.028045654, -0.039916992, 0.018661499, -0.0059547424, -0.0064353943, 0.030349731, 0.008850098, 0.0053520203, 0.013122559, 0.0032958984, -0.028503418, -0.020584106, -0.0071029663, 0.0064048767, -0.015449524, -0.027160645, -0.0020427704, 0.00018846989, 0.0006752014, -0.046417236, -0.0032730103, 0.026809692, 0.011009216, 0.01260376, -0.02798462, 0.010139465, 0.013374329, 0.0023517609, 0.013954163, -0.03857422, -0.0064849854, -0.036865234, 0.018081665, -0.04522705, 0.011016846, -0.0064048767, 0.02267456, -0.026229858, -0.031951904, 0.020233154, -0.011543274, -0.082336426, 0.029251099, -0.018203735, -0.0067596436, 0.040649414, -0.02444458, -0.047729492, 0.0317688, -0.0496521, 0.05593872, 0.028457642, -0.025131226, 0.019744873, -0.034973145, -0.02507019, -0.0015745163, -0.01436615, -0.015167236, -0.009941101, 0.008766174, -0.022857666, -0.0657959, 0.011802673, 0.006259918, -0.07800293, -0.030899048, 0.030639648, -0.03970337, -0.08270264, -0.04067993, 0.013519287, -0.033996582, -0.010925293, 0.039978027, -0.00005853176, -0.047332764, 0.046936035, -0.020721436, -0.027648926, 0.08605957, -0.0132369995, -0.007789612, 0.023895264, -0.014350891, -0.030715942, 0.003376007, 0.010612488, -0.03274536, 0.06329346, 0.009597778, -0.0003170967, 0.03277588, -0.044952393, -0.0033397675, 0.01159668, -0.0395813, 0.002544403, 0.033081055, 0.025222778, 0.027328491, -0.019683838, 0.06616211, -0.0035533905, 0.0020523071, -0.090026855, -0.0056495667, -0.0063934326, -0.003288269, -0.0075531006, 0.01687622, 0.0017662048, 0.022445679, 0.041870117, 0.016906738, -0.005054474, 0.03942871, 0.010650635, -0.052947998, -0.025344849, 0.023529053, 0.051879883, -0.020462036, 0.0087890625, 0.030715942, 0.019622803, 0.02217102, 0.025314331, -0.06317139, -0.016189575, 0.036315918, -0.06500244, -0.04220581, -0.018234253, -0.042755127, 0.011558533, 0.018539429, -0.044128418, 0.015274048, 0.035949707, 0.020401001, -0.03982544, -0.015174866, 0.032836914, -0.017028809, 0.0006136894, -0.072143555, 0.011161804, -0.037750244, -0.072143555, -0.054901123, -0.014984131, 0.019699097, 0.008384705, 0.008094788, -0.011047363, 0.0020542145, 0.041412354, 0.0574646, 0.06048584, 0.014701843, -0.053527832, 0.031219482, -0.035339355, -0.022323608, 0.0067481995, 0.033325195, -0.011077881, -0.019958496, 0.035247803, -0.012863159, -0.03817749, -0.044708252, 0.029800415, -0.0025749207, 0.030670166, 0.03878784, 0.050720215, 0.034942627, 0.02558899, 0.03640747, 0.016403198, -0.017852783, -0.057006836, 0.05432129, 0.02911377, 0.01737976, 0.016571045, -0.004009247, 0.013038635, -0.047210693, 0.005771637, 0.051605225, 0.018753052, -0.057769775, 0.03173828, -0.006893158, -0.03164673, -0.02935791, 0.016693115, 0.0003540516, 0.053497314, -0.018295288, 0.054656982, 0.0024795532, -0.0037555695, 0.03503418, -0.013267517, -0.0031661987, -0.0051841736, -0.011444092, -0.046722412, -0.10369873, -0.0079574585, 0.09069824, 0.0033454895, -0.023788452, 0.01525116, 0.046447754, 0.028869629, 0.037078857, 0.07171631, -0.0152282715, -0.019424438, -0.008041382, 0.01727295, -0.010261536, -0.04876709, -0.0019378662, 0.011276245, -0.0037021637, -0.03744507, -0.037841797, -0.033569336, -0.056915283, -0.017044067, -0.014595032, 0.035827637, -0.046844482, 0.010520935, 0.08148193, -0.010734558, 0.03375244, 0.030578613, 0.023651123, 0.006412506, 0.0046806335, 0.0152282715, 0.019134521, -0.013137817, -0.016830444, 0.05984497, -0.0003554821, 0.009033203, -0.026779175, -0.0011968613, -0.022232056, -0.0017156601, -0.0340271, 0.014312744, 0.015022278, 0.013504028, 0.020721436, -0.035308838, 0.0061912537, 0.013298035, -0.004547119, 0.024230957, -0.0011539459, -0.008728027, 0.012741089, -0.0059928894, -0.043884277, -0.012557983, -0.010047913, -0.03366089, -0.046783447, 0.03213501, -0.0076065063, -0.011077881, -0.021621704, 0.028457642, -0.018676758, 0.006023407, 0.03427124, 0.012664795, 0.030166626, -0.0099487305, -0.008575439, 0.045562744, 0.037231445, -0.06451416, -0.027572632, 0.0012645721, -0.017303467, 0.031951904, 0.056640625, 0.04751587, -0.026351929, -0.011833191, -0.013046265, -0.00579834, 0.0023918152, 0.024093628, 0.01576233, -0.04925537, 0.01486969, -0.0063591003, -0.018829346, 0.031402588, 0.0128479, -0.028427124, 0.030303955, 0.019180298, -0.010559082, -0.007408142, -0.0074043274, -0.017715454, 0.015716553, -0.049743652, 0.01965332, 0.008049011, 0.012588501, 0.042419434, 0.02519226, 0.03048706, 0.042755127, -0.0317688, 0.01586914, 0.028427124, -0.053009033, -0.009849548, -0.016616821, 0.011444092, -0.0357666, 0.008979797, -0.044128418, -0.0019760132, -0.017730713, -0.08129883, -0.041412354, -0.017318726, 0.043151855, 0.030075073, 0.03591919, -0.06439209, -0.01058197, -0.05810547, 0.018371582, -0.041259766, 0.010734558, -0.0103302, 0.01663208, -0.0019245148, -0.012626648, -0.028640747, -0.013336182, 0.018615723, 0.059326172, 0.008338928, 0.018630981, -0.05618286, -0.034454346, 0.0015029907, -0.022033691, 0.0065994263, -0.020187378, -0.0042648315, -0.020812988, 0.00957489, 0.04296875, 0.026275635, 0.053222656, 0.021194458, -0.019439697, -0.00012397766, 0.026031494, 0.025283813, -0.034942627, -0.0057640076, -0.04055786, 0.035888672, -0.018478394, 0.002779007, -0.037719727, 0.03741455, 0.0027427673, 0.016693115, 0.019363403, -0.004131317, 0.024551392, 0.013900757, 0.029724121, 0.0036621094, 0.048095703, -0.006969452, 0.005088806, 0.010185242, -0.0076942444, 0.017990112, 0.026138306, -0.020462036, 0.0317688, -0.008071899, 0.0032691956, 0.018295288, 0.0030269623, 0.014778137, 0.01322937, 0.0033435822, -0.0003080368, 0.06854248, 0.022644043, 0.060150146, 0.03540039, 0.035247803, -0.029418945, -0.0023765564, -0.0059432983, 0.0047187805, -0.017562866, 0.023712158, 0.020889282, -0.049926758, 0.056152344, 0.0071258545, -0.036346436, -0.036590576, 0.031021118, 0.03314209, -0.012413025, -0.04043579, 0.04711914, 0.055877686, 0.0259552, 0.006351471, -0.049957275, -0.05041504, 0.04434204, 0.045043945, -0.058410645, -0.025985718, 0.025924683, 0.0206604, 0.010787964, -0.03564453, 0.031707764, -0.007709503, 0.039520264, 0.035827637, -0.027282715, 0.010559082, 0.014694214, -0.03515625, 0.024597168, 0.026046753, -0.0211792, 0.009475708, 0.022109985, 0.024810791, 0.05596924, 0.07220459, 0.00894928, 0.0155181885, -0.017288208, -0.046081543, 0.050750732, 0.018737793, -0.01499939, 0.0065956116, -0.023101807, -0.03692627, 0.016616821, -0.027359009, 0.051818848, -0.033203125, -0.013595581, -0.02067566, 0.0032749176, 0.050720215, -0.03427124, -0.040924072, -0.035308838, 0.0012998581, 0.0107803345, 0.022857666, -0.030303955, -0.034942627, 0.0034332275, 0.049041748, 0.0016937256, -0.009933472, 0.0070991516, -0.019805908, -0.064941406, -0.007843018, -0.011581421, 0.02848816, 0.028945923, 0.014015198, -0.019073486, 0.00932312, 0.012641907, -0.045013428, -0.031082153, -0.011161804, -0.022262573, -0.03970337, 0.013183594, 0.0043792725, -0.009262085, 0.036132812, 0.021652222, 0.013130188, -0.003129959, -0.045715332, 0.02859497, -0.018508911, 0.02545166, -0.009124756, -0.019607544, 0.011909485, 0.0016775131, -0.053375244, 0.052825928, -0.0059928894, -0.0569458, 0.03878784, -0.018478394, 0.020584106, -0.026855469, -0.045959473, -0.00932312, 0.058044434, 0.05697632, -0.026367188, -0.0463562, 0.040252686, 0.02142334, -0.025390625, 0.018051147, 0.02319336, -0.01586914, -0.018112183, 0.04046631, -0.0065193176, -0.005706787, -0.021911621, -0.017807007, 0.01687622, 0.03427124, -0.017684937, 0.01399231, 0.05596924, -0.05456543, 0.0017318726, 0.02229309, 0.026550293, 0.008811951, -0.011756897, 0.035095215, -0.02746582, -0.06726074, 0.023071289, 0.019973755, -0.00012201071, 0.047607422, -0.02394104, 0.005126953, 0.007095337, 0.04788208, -0.016998291, -0.013908386, 0.0067367554, 0.031799316, 0.0033569336, 0.03933716, -0.03314209, -0.014221191, -0.001947403, -0.02128601, -0.022109985, -0.037109375, 0.03918457, -0.023254395, -0.012992859, -0.014701843, -0.05480957, -0.08630371, -0.046722412, 0.007701874, -0.030288696, 0.035064697, 0.025848389, -0.032928467, -0.020996094, 0.0006351471, 0.021240234, -0.022476196, -0.06311035, -0.055786133, 0.04345703, -0.020599365 ], "summary": [ -0.027786255, -0.007926941, -0.06222534, -0.028152466, -0.044403076, -0.03213501, -0.05987549, 0.010414124, 0.0019721985, 0.01889038, 0.009498596, -0.00793457, 0.01576233, -0.042266846, 0.020645142, -0.012710571, 0.04220581, 0.01335144, 0.01927185, -0.004558563, 0.020248413, 0.018371582, 0.011444092, 0.072631836, -0.010185242, -0.057403564, 0.037200928, 0.026290894, -0.001914978, 0.013961792, 0.020736694, -0.017120361, 0.054504395, -0.021484375, -0.025848389, 0.04019165, -0.003627777, -0.01499939, -0.018981934, 0.02519226, 0.01663208, -0.0051879883, 0.04473877, -0.06335449, -0.011779785, 0.06768799, -0.009849548, 0.0034694672, 0.052093506, 0.021224976, 0.0033931732, -0.04925537, -0.018554688, 0.035217285, -0.043029785, -0.05029297, -0.04449463, 0.034820557, 0.017456055, 0.042938232, 0.01007843, 0.017654419, -0.009727478, -0.019348145, -0.04336548, -0.016342163, -0.021438599, 0.00039744377, -0.005027771, -0.030303955, 0.022613525, 0.003314972, -0.01272583, -0.02696228, -0.03050232, 0.039001465, -0.0007457733, 0.023651123, -0.005252838, -0.020111084, -0.046295166, -0.01448822, -0.017654419, -0.012702942, -0.0064353943, 0.016159058, -0.03265381, -0.008590698, 0.014503479, 0.020187378, -0.0017366409, 0.05606079, 0.010276794, 0.04525757, -0.00006431341, -0.019989014, -0.026016235, -0.07293701, 0.049072266, 0.060455322, 0.04748535, -0.066223145, 0.123413086, -0.030380249, 0.002357483, 0.05722046, -0.018737793, -0.08569336, -0.022277832, 0.0075645447, -0.017166138, -0.054534912, -0.0017080307, -0.045135498, 0.05078125, 0.039215088, -0.005859375, 0.091430664, 0.0033912659, 0.058929443, -0.0035209656, 0.026306152, -0.025878906, -0.0067367554, 0.037872314, 0.026687622, 0.0021076202, -0.017425537, -0.061065674, 0.03161621, -0.0026569366, -0.0049209595, 0.016296387, 0.061767578, 0.0109939575, -0.0036888123, 0.070251465, 0.014289856, -0.0011386871, -0.035064697, 0.0423584, 0.011978149, -0.035125732, -0.006351471, -0.064575195, 0.049621582, 0.0418396, -0.02407837, -0.08453369, -0.0647583, -0.022338867, -0.014465332, 0.05014038, -0.0028858185, -0.042144775, -0.028793335, -0.011238098, -0.023010254, -0.0074043274, -0.044403076, -0.012687683, -0.012641907, 0.0076828003, -0.011489868, -0.015777588, 0.010650635, 0.020614624, 0.002166748, 0.016189575, 0.0036144257, -0.001531601, 0.010498047, 0.0069999695, -0.02519226, -0.010040283, -0.014976501, 0.041778564, -0.04248047, -0.025543213, 0.019256592, -0.037628174, -0.04156494, -0.050231934, -0.0033931732, 0.0013847351, -0.017654419, -0.020050049, -0.019851685, 0.04425049, 0.012512207, -0.028839111, 0.015930176, -0.053100586, 0.008377075, -0.006126404, 0.04434204, -0.01335144, 0.033843994, -0.005252838, -0.040740967, -0.099365234, 0.0049209595, -0.011619568, 0.034088135, 0.01260376, -0.013809204, 0.017852783, 0.016174316, -0.007926941, 0.017074585, 0.0075149536, -0.041015625, -0.022216797, 0.034210205, -0.0046844482, -0.045135498, 0.014877319, 0.009300232, -0.036254883, 0.03933716, -0.06567383, -0.014442444, -0.05404663, 0.033294678, 0.032104492, -0.044830322, 0.0051078796, -0.03881836, 0.040740967, -0.0073928833, -0.021011353, 0.020141602, 0.025390625, 0.0013713837, -0.044067383, 0.014961243, 0.0115737915, 0.007789612, -0.020935059, 0.020095825, 0.012557983, 0.038635254, -0.029800415, -0.002840042, 0.07104492, 0.024475098, 0.00299263, 0.000060796738, 0.022491455, 0.08880615, 0.023498535, 0.007736206, 0.014282227, -0.0025367737, 0.009178162, 0.033416748, 0.0010681152, 0.008201599, 0.012489319, -0.0048942566, 0.0026512146, 0.05645752, 0.02407837, 0.00920105, 0.009841919, -0.029067993, 0.0146484375, 0.016952515, 0.025115967, -0.03527832, -0.00945282, -0.041412354, 0.0131073, -0.04849243, -0.06567383, -0.07165527, 0.00983429, 0.029510498, -0.007286072, -0.06890869, 0.0104904175, 0.015464783, -0.037963867, 0.001493454, 0.022033691, -0.014053345, -0.024551392, 0.019897461, 0.04107666, 0.05899048, 0.046966553, 0.038269043, 0.017715454, 0.01939392, 0.043945312, -0.00730896, 0.02947998, 0.058502197, -0.03250122, 0.014122009, -0.0262146, 0.023361206, 0.023529053, -0.059509277, 0.003156662, 0.027526855, 0.020141602, -0.013938904, -0.006668091, -0.011001587, -0.01776123, 0.00020110607, 0.0021915436, 0.010917664, -0.05532837, -0.02607727, -0.044799805, -0.0019073486, -0.047088623, 0.020126343, 0.02822876, -0.002904892, -0.012893677, 0.0236969, -0.016189575, -0.019851685, 0.02468872, -0.0079574585, 0.01763916, 0.024215698, 0.026000977, 0.04071045, -0.030960083, 0.004371643, 0.016403198, 0.020996094, 0.014785767, -0.032165527, -0.008850098, -0.0093307495, 0.015510559, -0.0055656433, -0.013519287, -0.015640259, -0.021133423, -0.0066604614, 0.02218628, -0.0014638901, -0.0055503845, -0.0029621124, 0.0066375732, -0.024780273, -0.014923096, 0.023101807, -0.007255554, 0.016494751, 0.021713257, 0.013397217, -0.008811951, -0.03125, 0.016189575, -0.009361267, -0.034454346, -0.02003479, 0.0031795502, -0.011138916, 0.02357483, -0.02772522, 0.051452637, 0.053955078, -0.034484863, 0.06500244, -0.0524292, 0.015464783, 0.029556274, 0.011734009, 0.03375244, -0.0008621216, 0.006931305, 0.03152466, 0.041046143, 0.004825592, 0.019134521, -0.059448242, 0.02748108, 0.0131073, 0.010612488, 0.05090332, 0.0061683655, -0.033172607, -0.015899658, 0.044555664, 0.060516357, -0.019714355, 0.013160706, 0.0017910004, -0.03778076, -0.003929138, -0.018966675, -0.009086609, 0.04498291, 0.025863647, 0.0078125, 0.006324768, -0.051971436, 0.020065308, -0.0059547424, 0.010871887, 0.0034713745, 0.044006348, 0.0028076172, -0.04083252, -0.02279663, -0.008422852, 0.021102905, -0.014884949, -0.0002937317, 0.01687622, 0.008903503, -0.03427124, -0.038726807, 0.10571289, -0.015472412, -0.0068740845, 0.012176514, -0.0020008087, 0.0075798035, -0.010314941, 0.03366089, 0.03463745, 0.015075684, -0.0082473755, -0.014701843, 0.0008392334, -0.012374878, -0.01474762, -0.029449463, -0.020950317, 0.021057129, -0.03213501, -0.054229736, 0.019927979, 0.037994385, 0.028945923, 0.013961792, -0.012527466, 0.0146484375, -0.021377563, 0.03012085, 0.03729248, -0.03338623, -0.006099701, 0.020690918, 0.026992798, -0.053344727, -0.016113281, -0.01197052, 0.039886475, 0.01776123, -0.0060539246, 0.046661377, -0.0014467239, -0.062408447, 0.029312134, -0.014457703, 0.02067566, -0.022003174, 0.0021629333, -0.059051514, 0.027328491, -0.01701355, 0.023208618, 0.013366699, -0.032440186, 0.016967773, -0.064941406, 0.0041503906, -0.004283905, 0.016082764, -0.025100708, -0.042541504, 0.021194458, -0.0015249252, -0.057403564, -0.019515991, 0.017288208, -0.053131104, -0.049560547, 0.031677246, -0.030014038, -0.055755615, -0.03552246, 0.037322998, -0.032958984, 0.016464233, 0.047546387, 0.0049819946, 0.02368164, 0.037261963, -0.012199402, -0.013755798, 0.010734558, -0.020263672, -0.016708374, -0.009590149, 0.02041626, 0.041900635, 0.03665161, -0.0032291412, -0.031555176, 0.064453125, -0.02671814, 0.0056381226, 0.008483887, -0.03527832, -0.0051994324, -0.010803223, -0.019210815, -0.010566711, 0.018600464, 0.040802002, 0.0758667, -0.040039062, 0.017318726, 0.033172607, 0.0146484375, -0.05899048, 0.033477783, -0.004425049, 0.0055885315, 0.005317688, 0.039154053, -0.0032234192, 0.002532959, 0.028152466, -0.06011963, -0.016830444, 0.007411957, -0.008468628, -0.02960205, -0.023788452, 0.010101318, 0.02067566, -0.020477295, 0.0039405823, 0.022567749, 0.010574341, 0.001868248, -0.004257202, -0.049713135, -0.005393982, 0.023239136, -0.06323242, -0.062347412, 0.010658264, -0.013633728, 0.027832031, -0.0023403168, -0.026901245, -0.005706787, 0.010231018, 0.03805542, -0.012825012, -0.03265381, 0.013061523, 0.013679504, -0.026031494, -0.061828613, -0.0016813278, -0.04397583, -0.044830322, -0.055725098, -0.060821533, -0.01398468, -0.035217285, 0.011634827, -0.02420044, -0.011016846, 0.034088135, 0.0435791, 0.020584106, 0.010368347, -0.034179688, -0.036621094, -0.05343628, -0.002571106, 0.032287598, 0.021835327, -0.021347046, -0.0034885406, 0.033111572, -0.024307251, -0.03829956, -0.049713135, 0.012626648, -0.013870239, 0.023590088, 0.044311523, 0.06677246, 0.015045166, -0.0050468445, 0.04232788, 0.016571045, 0.0020542145, -0.034301758, 0.05657959, 0.0024852753, 0.027252197, 0.020004272, -0.016830444, 0.011528015, -0.07330322, 0.00093221664, 0.06109619, 0.0021591187, -0.050964355, 0.036224365, -0.046081543, -0.024002075, -0.03753662, 0.0054779053, -0.013771057, 0.020080566, 0.04345703, 0.010925293, 0.014854431, -0.008026123, 0.029159546, -0.020141602, -0.018493652, 0.008682251, -0.018569946, -0.015312195, -0.11303711, 0.008857727, 0.07952881, 0.045135498, -0.03277588, 0.0020637512, 0.038391113, 0.03933716, 0.016357422, 0.072753906, -0.048950195, -0.025634766, -0.011924744, 0.015098572, 0.022262573, -0.01802063, 0.010063171, 0.0029277802, -0.011726379, -0.010047913, -0.066467285, 0.0032157898, -0.047332764, -0.019744873, 0.006752014, 0.031921387, -0.038116455, -0.047454834, 0.039794922, -0.0027256012, 0.005584717, 0.09246826, 0.0060043335, -0.0046691895, 0.0115737915, -0.0124435425, 0.045654297, -0.041503906, -0.014282227, 0.05960083, -0.010429382, 0.026519775, 0.0062065125, -0.035614014, 0.005218506, -0.009223938, -0.015930176, -0.02897644, 0.0062408447, 0.042785645, 0.017868042, -0.0309906, 0.007167816, 0.034851074, 0.0016918182, -0.007045746, 0.032165527, -0.008407593, -0.0030899048, 0.0041503906, -0.017852783, -0.038970947, -0.02722168, -0.015167236, -0.031585693, -0.0023078918, -0.022064209, -0.009521484, -0.003917694, 0.008995056, -0.01663208, -0.022415161, -0.009811401, 0.045410156, 0.032226562, 0.006855011, -0.011054993, 0.010314941, 0.031402588, -0.084472656, -0.030685425, -0.015403748, -0.009689331, 0.022644043, 0.019561768, 0.042816162, 0.028793335, -0.021499634, 0.023910522, 0.02798462, -0.013473511, 0.031829834, 0.007575989, -0.06665039, -0.00096035004, -0.035247803, -0.06604004, 0.04257202, 0.014656067, -0.07348633, 0.029327393, 0.03933716, -0.008331299, 0.023925781, 0.0069007874, -0.013404846, 0.014984131, -0.004196167, 0.00491333, 0.016967773, -0.016311646, 0.06518555, 0.04034424, 0.032165527, 0.02420044, 0.0019264221, 0.034210205, 0.026107788, -0.025634766, 0.0018253326, -0.021148682, 0.02456665, -0.03753662, -0.035369873, -0.030456543, 0.00422287, 0.010139465, -0.059661865, -0.014266968, -0.053497314, 0.014884949, 0.0041885376, 0.004322052, -0.031402588, -0.022903442, -0.045013428, -0.0079574585, -0.017669678, 0.00919342, -0.01689148, 0.0006084442, 0.025802612, -0.016067505, 0.0039749146, -0.0128479, 0.018371582, 0.045013428, -0.01335144, 0.033203125, -0.055877686, -0.016479492, 0.01247406, -0.00573349, 0.008079529, -0.029434204, 0.0025405884, -0.03955078, 0.031677246, 0.021133423, 0.00023496151, 0.041381836, -0.005054474, -0.0178833, 0.008552551, 0.016113281, 0.017120361, -0.032226562, -0.0033454895, -0.007408142, -0.004386902, 0.015838623, -0.012207031, 0.0047454834, 0.034088135, 0.012565613, -0.010650635, 0.051818848, -0.010101318, 0.020324707, 0.019470215, -0.028747559, 0.01576233, -0.0047035217, 0.029815674, 0.004016876, 0.0104522705, -0.03515625, -0.0018129349, 0.027267456, -0.022949219, 0.04724121, 0.023513794, 0.008277893, 0.022735596, -0.004928589, -0.00365448, -0.010757446, 0.031066895, -0.004875183, 0.045135498, 0.018844604, 0.042816162, 0.015716553, -0.011009216, 0.0368042, -0.007411957, -0.009437561, 0.011024475, 0.02809143, -0.011978149, -0.015396118, -0.03652954, 0.016448975, 0.046936035, -0.0035743713, -0.006160736, 0.024047852, 0.012954712, -0.014808655, -0.033294678, 0.021057129, 0.029876709, 0.02281189, -0.008132935, -0.053710938, -0.044525146, 0.032592773, 0.029251099, -0.061553955, -0.05718994, 0.025115967, 0.031707764, 0.0151901245, -0.029571533, 0.04071045, -0.040924072, 0.0703125, 0.03326416, -0.031188965, -0.013206482, 0.03164673, -0.025024414, 0.038330078, -0.0026226044, 0.051483154, 0.018066406, -0.023040771, 0.04586792, 0.07330322, 0.03475952, -0.06628418, 0.02507019, 0.07720947, -0.013076782, 0.060577393, -0.009155273, 0.023330688, -0.011329651, -0.0317688, -0.008056641, -0.012077332, -0.0113220215, 0.052520752, -0.04559326, -0.02607727, -0.035247803, 0.024871826, -0.029296875, -0.00085926056, -0.010040283, -0.055358887, 0.031585693, 0.026397705, 0.03552246, -0.05215454, -0.01725769, -0.0011663437, 0.008293152, 0.00005185604, 0.0023555756, 0.023956299, -0.020874023, -0.03488159, 0.0060272217, 0.008506775, 0.03540039, 0.04446411, -0.001824379, 0.025100708, 0.0041275024, 0.02355957, -0.0982666, -0.0440979, -0.029342651, 0.03503418, -0.043762207, 0.024017334, 0.016448975, -0.0076026917, 0.028030396, 0.048919678, 0.0072135925, -0.007205963, -0.01197052, 0.034851074, -0.0046920776, 0.029174805, 0.0058250427, -0.018661499, -0.0039634705, -0.027313232, -0.057434082, 0.07397461, -0.014663696, -0.047302246, 0.033081055, -0.033081055, -0.017745972, -0.04257202, -0.009025574, -0.012016296, 0.036468506, 0.040618896, -0.020187378, 0.005130768, 0.024108887, -0.003610611, -0.012901306, -0.010650635, 0.008560181, -0.009437561, 0.011375427, 0.024520874, 0.0069732666, -0.0032043457, -0.010055542, -0.019119263, 0.033294678, 0.0137786865, -0.035705566, 0.0231781, 0.03366089, -0.048034668, -0.0076293945, 0.009750366, 0.026031494, -0.0064849854, -0.0064811707, 0.013069153, -0.04446411, -0.03866577, 0.024337769, 0.015853882, -0.020126343, -0.01675415, -0.0011110306, -0.0059013367, -0.021697998, -0.005584717, 0.009292603, 0.031188965, -0.047943115, 0.0067253113, 0.014022827, 0.00038671494, -0.0435791, -0.01600647, 0.050598145, -0.023971558, -0.03475952, -0.03427124, 0.045318604, -0.024993896, -0.06286621, 0.020492554, -0.020614624, -0.119140625, -0.049072266, -0.0040664673, 0.0007882118, 0.005996704, 0.055786133, -0.028030396, 0.006336212, 0.0025024414, 0.01927185, 0.006717682, -0.0006942749, -0.04473877, 0.010032654, -0.0018062592 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09349v1
Generative AI-Based Probabilistic Constellation Shaping With Diffusion Models
Mehdi Letafati, Samad Ali, Matti Latva-aho
cs.IT, cs.AI, cs.LG, math.IT
Diffusion models are at the vanguard of generative AI research with renowned solutions such as ImageGen by Google Brain and DALL.E 3 by OpenAI. Nevertheless, the potential merits of diffusion models for communication engineering applications are not fully understood yet. In this paper, we aim to unleash the power of generative AI for PHY design of constellation symbols in communication systems. Although the geometry of constellations is predetermined according to networking standards, e.g., quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM), probabilistic shaping can design the probability of occurrence (generation) of constellation symbols. This can help improve the information rate and decoding performance of communication systems. We exploit the ``denoise-and-generate'' characteristics of denoising diffusion probabilistic models (DDPM) for probabilistic constellation shaping. The key idea is to learn generating constellation symbols out of noise, ``mimicking'' the way the receiver performs symbol reconstruction. This way, we make the constellation symbols sent by the transmitter, and what is inferred (reconstructed) at the receiver become as similar as possible, resulting in as few mismatches as possible. Our results show that the generative AI-based scheme outperforms deep neural network (DNN)-based benchmark and uniform shaping, while providing network resilience as well as robust out-of-distribution performance under low-SNR regimes and non-Gaussian assumptions. Numerical evaluations highlight 30% improvement in terms of cosine similarity and a threefold improvement in terms of mutual information compared to DNN-based approach for 64-QAM geometry.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09349v1
2023-11-15T20:14:21
2023-11-15T20:14:21
{ "title": [ -0.03527832, -0.0022850037, -0.043548584, -0.0340271, -0.013282776, 0.0005402565, -0.027053833, -0.0042266846, 0.008369446, 0.022399902, 0.0049095154, 0.0042419434, 0.013595581, -0.04675293, -0.013870239, 0.015548706, 0.013595581, -0.0045280457, -0.016479492, -0.043548584, -0.001124382, -0.041992188, 0.014961243, 0.11248779, 0.0070648193, -0.046844482, -0.048309326, 0.015136719, -0.021652222, -0.024597168, -0.0043907166, 0.025543213, 0.026931763, -0.002286911, 0.039367676, 0.03237915, -0.0552063, 0.03491211, 0.03616333, -0.019592285, 0.0034732819, 0.0066490173, 0.013763428, -0.018630981, -0.022277832, 0.020263672, -0.060546875, -0.027053833, -0.010498047, 0.05923462, 0.0026741028, 0.028533936, -0.01939392, 0.05255127, 0.012367249, -0.026153564, -0.01889038, -0.0093307495, 0.0042304993, 0.060058594, 0.039611816, 0.004764557, 0.011352539, -0.0070381165, -0.027282715, -0.03164673, -0.030075073, 0.040252686, 0.05657959, 0.01727295, -0.010414124, 0.008308411, 0.015625, -0.011177063, -0.06329346, -0.011436462, 0.052947998, 0.0028152466, 0.03918457, -0.04458618, 0.0317688, -0.0021820068, 0.00579834, -0.03125, 0.012275696, -0.036590576, -0.006877899, -0.018325806, -0.004146576, -0.042022705, -0.007041931, 0.011184692, 0.02267456, 0.016555786, -0.033325195, -0.024841309, -0.018035889, 0.020095825, 0.011360168, -0.002281189, 0.010009766, -0.0121154785, 0.022949219, -0.049224854, 0.0009899139, 0.027114868, -0.0024490356, -0.008895874, 0.019927979, 0.032928467, 0.0034942627, 0.020477295, 0.02911377, 0.03741455, -0.0019683838, -0.012771606, -0.0005545616, 0.02180481, -0.036865234, 0.032348633, -0.02722168, -0.042053223, 0.05609131, -0.0062217712, 0.02633667, -0.01109314, -0.04937744, 0.0050849915, -0.025024414, 0.003353119, -0.011146545, 0.044128418, -0.009521484, -0.033966064, -0.022232056, 0.020568848, -0.0058174133, -0.0025939941, 0.0096206665, -0.027267456, 0.05029297, 0.012031555, 0.0423584, -0.0012073517, 0.0052452087, -0.0021362305, 0.04071045, 0.004512787, -0.011932373, 0.015350342, -0.030853271, 0.020614624, 0.008903503, 0.03149414, 0.014373779, 0.025863647, -0.037872314, -0.007007599, 0.0041503906, 0.023788452, 0.031799316, 0.00983429, -0.011009216, 0.03567505, 0.07232666, -0.035217285, -0.030731201, 0.023269653, 0.015182495, 0.0284729, -0.010665894, 0.01260376, -0.010314941, -0.014579773, -0.006175995, 0.006839752, 0.07348633, 0.0024147034, 0.01133728, 0.0126571655, 0.015914917, 0.006752014, 0.04864502, 0.007583618, -0.050750732, -0.027893066, 0.0018262863, -0.003566742, 0.031173706, 0.022659302, -0.009185791, 0.008682251, -0.09613037, -0.03677368, -0.03567505, 0.01574707, 0.01713562, 0.031402588, 0.0054855347, 0.023391724, -0.019546509, -0.0046577454, -0.03036499, 0.029449463, -0.032470703, -0.025482178, -0.018173218, 0.020706177, -0.009613037, 0.031280518, 0.050964355, 0.004623413, -0.037322998, -0.006706238, -0.021743774, -0.05038452, 0.021438599, -0.0206604, -0.00008440018, -0.00026869774, -0.022216797, 0.016738892, -0.032318115, 0.0012407303, 0.047576904, -0.018539429, 0.021438599, -0.05734253, 0.058166504, 0.022872925, 0.021865845, -0.0047798157, -0.0013637543, -0.008666992, -0.026931763, -0.00063610077, -0.029922485, 0.008758545, -0.006061554, 0.013137817, 0.0014686584, 0.0011358261, -0.013130188, 0.04449463, 0.046661377, -0.025039673, -0.00066280365, 0.04714966, 0.04244995, 0.084228516, 0.01826477, 0.030807495, 0.014831543, -0.018920898, 0.007247925, 0.057159424, 0.008857727, -0.018371582, -0.017868042, 0.0027809143, 0.013420105, -0.012611389, -0.035064697, 0.010688782, -0.032440186, -0.01423645, -0.014343262, 0.009300232, 0.0138549805, -0.009223938, 0.019378662, -0.03842163, -0.00006455183, -0.03881836, -0.021224976, -0.014350891, -0.03668213, 0.04336548, 0.0077552795, -0.06890869, 0.0069465637, 0.045776367, 0.04638672, -0.021484375, 0.024291992, 0.006214142, -0.005466461, -0.02494812, 0.012031555, 0.011634827, 0.042053223, 0.055480957, 0.021392822, 0.019226074, 0.023162842, 0.012565613, 0.006664276, 0.04660034, -0.000156641, 0.008613586, -0.06866455, 0.015472412, -0.008171082, -0.0008893013, -0.010299683, 0.099487305, 0.017028809, 0.006099701, -0.0129470825, -0.018844604, 0.009750366, -0.0024318695, -0.0103302, -0.053863525, -0.019622803, -0.040008545, -0.0078125, -0.03387451, -0.009773254, 0.026947021, 0.09222412, -0.00026631355, -0.014381409, -0.0048599243, 0.012535095, -0.04815674, -0.007534027, -0.041107178, -0.017150879, -0.0005764961, 0.037841797, 0.041015625, -0.019500732, 0.055389404, 0.012634277, -0.0104599, 0.0011377335, -0.032836914, -0.008575439, 0.021011353, 0.029205322, 0.05810547, 0.011489868, -0.05899048, -0.027160645, -0.035186768, 0.025360107, 0.0026569366, 0.008712769, 0.009681702, 0.033477783, -0.0072669983, -0.0047187805, 0.042175293, 0.06365967, -0.027664185, -0.029937744, 0.037475586, 0.009887695, -0.027175903, 0.033569336, 0.01361084, -0.00687027, -0.01499176, 0.0035705566, -0.06866455, 0.013084412, -0.029266357, -0.029785156, 0.018081665, -0.08917236, -0.023040771, 0.019592285, -0.0067253113, 0.0011472702, 0.05178833, -0.0067214966, -0.01838684, -0.015235901, -0.009597778, 0.020141602, 0.061309814, -0.04248047, 0.07611084, 0.07147217, 0.00045394897, -0.02041626, -0.04257202, 0.057403564, 0.029037476, 0.017929077, -0.05090332, -0.004711151, -0.0036525726, 0.035247803, 0.01285553, -0.023895264, 0.013771057, -0.09942627, -0.009689331, -0.010246277, 0.017333984, -0.013397217, 0.01600647, -0.043548584, -0.0020256042, -0.02268982, -0.030761719, 0.023773193, 0.06512451, -0.016143799, -0.006374359, -0.01474762, -0.014663696, 0.014694214, -0.023162842, -0.028701782, 0.034423828, -0.026504517, -0.043426514, 0.015296936, -0.059783936, -0.032043457, -0.026748657, -0.0073127747, 0.059661865, 0.021697998, 0.021759033, 0.0077171326, -0.04159546, 0.0031223297, -0.03286743, -0.0112838745, -0.014793396, -0.017913818, 0.008148193, 0.0055732727, 0.023010254, 0.03164673, -0.0032787323, -0.076049805, -0.033294678, -0.02482605, 0.025131226, 0.00078868866, -0.019119263, -0.029891968, -0.07287598, 0.0009775162, -0.026947021, 0.002407074, -0.0070228577, 0.026992798, 0.0116119385, -0.011642456, 0.06161499, 0.016799927, 0.0022659302, 0.013404846, -0.018493652, 0.011550903, -0.002462387, -0.06829834, 0.01461792, 0.0206604, 0.012161255, -0.009635925, -0.020141602, -0.012542725, -0.0124435425, -0.022277832, 0.032592773, 0.010215759, 0.0010499954, -0.026947021, -0.024047852, 0.017929077, 0.0357666, -0.0014801025, -0.029891968, 0.017318726, -0.013534546, -0.011169434, -0.03756714, 0.019821167, -0.006401062, -0.08380127, -0.008880615, 0.0112838745, -0.011520386, -0.034973145, -0.048858643, 0.021942139, -0.016571045, -0.034179688, 0.02406311, -0.007701874, -0.031433105, 0.019805908, -0.07110596, -0.0020828247, 0.07196045, -0.017700195, 0.0011425018, 0.030014038, 0.0075416565, 0.021316528, -0.008514404, -0.0043182373, 0.010925293, 0.062805176, -0.018493652, -0.009780884, 0.03414917, -0.011070251, 0.023834229, 0.040985107, 0.015426636, 0.011764526, 0.00730896, 0.017044067, 0.016784668, -0.0129470825, 0.017807007, 0.04714966, -0.016571045, -0.04928589, 0.006702423, -0.022399902, -0.052001953, -0.0039901733, -0.0031814575, -0.024765015, 0.014434814, 0.04949951, 0.054260254, -0.016418457, -0.009162903, 0.03152466, 0.006198883, -0.0068206787, 0.030471802, 0.0121536255, 0.038513184, -0.011131287, -0.0026683807, -0.028121948, 0.044647217, -0.03173828, 0.0042266846, -0.013267517, 0.0030574799, -0.029769897, -0.02470398, -0.07678223, -0.0158844, -0.01537323, 0.0039138794, -0.009422302, 0.029556274, 0.014442444, -0.004180908, -0.044799805, 0.015975952, 0.017044067, 0.0025482178, -0.012519836, -0.043273926, 0.02168274, -0.018051147, -0.048065186, -0.019714355, 0.0045776367, -0.0018405914, 0.027389526, -0.0129470825, -0.014190674, 0.01991272, 0.027908325, 0.028686523, 0.039093018, -0.007972717, -0.04586792, 0.011665344, 0.019882202, -0.07751465, 0.014907837, -0.021514893, -0.0052871704, -0.044952393, 0.034240723, -0.04220581, -0.040405273, -0.022827148, 0.045684814, 0.008842468, 0.06689453, 0.010269165, 0.06011963, 0.031799316, 0.060516357, -0.004676819, 0.0078086853, -0.021896362, -0.04977417, -0.013252258, 0.07196045, 0.0045814514, -0.005214691, 0.039794922, 0.024902344, 0.0062026978, 0.02494812, 0.0034427643, 0.0385437, 0.011711121, 0.01965332, 0.028961182, -0.061431885, -0.019805908, -0.0056114197, -0.006137848, 0.044769287, -0.070739746, 0.032440186, -0.023117065, 0.021728516, 0.016479492, -0.014297485, 0.037017822, -0.002796173, 0.026519775, -0.08685303, -0.07305908, -0.038909912, 0.08154297, -0.064453125, -0.011238098, -0.0061302185, -0.022064209, 0.0052757263, 0.055847168, 0.035827637, 0.006134033, 0.0154953, -0.0064468384, 0.015823364, -0.02178955, -0.06713867, 0.004875183, 0.004447937, 0.03829956, 0.008323669, 0.0069847107, -0.06274414, 0.01637268, -0.03933716, -0.041931152, 0.047943115, -0.072021484, -0.008087158, 0.06921387, -0.009994507, 0.04751587, -0.0053596497, 0.02835083, 0.019104004, 0.032714844, 0.010551453, 0.0005784035, 0.020645142, -0.016860962, 0.06298828, 0.008392334, 0.022827148, 0.0019130707, 0.019638062, -0.014343262, 0.016052246, -0.023742676, 0.023757935, -0.01939392, -0.02671814, 0.01940918, -0.03955078, 0.0018148422, 0.00003951788, 0.00086450577, 0.0036830902, -0.03378296, -0.04776001, -0.039093018, -0.02658081, -0.0748291, 0.043182373, 0.011436462, -0.041503906, -0.038269043, 0.032226562, -0.010292053, -0.016021729, 0.0033054352, 0.031341553, -0.017974854, 0.019317627, 0.055877686, -0.039154053, -0.028671265, -0.008308411, 0.014404297, 0.021972656, 0.0038585663, -0.030731201, 0.0054359436, -0.046020508, -0.058563232, -0.039916992, 0.0024356842, 0.0014638901, 0.038085938, -0.0010900497, -0.02720642, -0.0047187805, 0.024291992, 0.04336548, -0.008010864, -0.046417236, 0.035888672, 0.015235901, 0.014373779, 0.019760132, 0.013160706, -0.029327393, 0.016967773, 0.02619934, -0.0107421875, -0.010887146, 0.042999268, -0.02432251, -0.0060768127, -0.014701843, -0.013465881, 0.024215698, -0.033203125, -0.0018444061, 0.031173706, 0.017074585, -0.054138184, 0.057922363, 0.024536133, 0.07489014, -0.054992676, -0.014038086, 0.023895264, -0.00005710125, -0.01474762, 0.03112793, -0.01838684, -0.018112183, -0.032409668, -0.06719971, -0.026535034, 0.009513855, 0.060272217, 0.048095703, 0.078308105, -0.060791016, -0.014717102, -0.03366089, 0.0025901794, -0.026397705, 0.039794922, 0.0005311966, -0.02583313, -0.023071289, -0.01864624, -0.016830444, -0.00009351969, 0.03778076, 0.046020508, -0.017578125, 0.05947876, -0.057006836, -0.036346436, -0.0054244995, -0.009819031, 0.051696777, -0.024627686, 0.015945435, 0.039855957, -0.018463135, 0.029525757, -0.0013637543, -0.0064811707, 0.014732361, 0.016616821, 0.015419006, -0.0037899017, -0.004459381, -0.024124146, 0.04989624, -0.064453125, 0.009048462, -0.06695557, -0.020507812, -0.068237305, -0.010269165, 0.021606445, -0.013282776, -0.0073928833, -0.0029468536, 0.013061523, 0.03778076, 0.03579712, -0.0036258698, 0.023422241, 0.015716553, 0.009231567, -0.0058021545, -0.010276794, -0.0011749268, 0.03173828, -0.005016327, 0.0064926147, -0.007713318, -0.020111084, 0.020187378, 0.002878189, 0.0022468567, -0.016326904, -0.0053520203, -0.029586792, 0.07574463, 0.0059890747, 0.052734375, 0.07720947, 0.037750244, 0.03845215, -0.048797607, 0.00084495544, 0.046905518, -0.028884888, 0.031463623, 0.06817627, -0.008651733, 0.010826111, -0.04751587, -0.043426514, 0.032592773, -0.027862549, 0.059692383, -0.080444336, -0.06585693, 0.014755249, 0.050323486, -0.019744873, 0.043273926, -0.050323486, -0.025802612, -0.031036377, 0.019744873, -0.0099487305, 0.0020809174, 0.012245178, 0.02947998, -0.03942871, -0.021011353, 0.00071144104, -0.011039734, -0.03277588, 0.015434265, -0.010314941, -0.007987976, -0.0047569275, -0.028762817, 0.0027122498, 0.011672974, -0.031555176, 0.0011329651, 0.023117065, 0.053710938, 0.017028809, 0.024276733, -0.027038574, -0.038757324, 0.04888916, -0.05456543, 0.022994995, 0.02960205, -0.019592285, 0.021728516, -0.030273438, -0.019958496, 0.033233643, -0.027664185, 0.020233154, -0.02734375, -0.011360168, -0.013504028, -0.00024867058, 0.027557373, -0.04714966, -0.033416748, -0.02444458, -0.019744873, -0.022918701, -0.03604126, -0.027755737, -0.050354004, -0.017150879, 0.07897949, -0.006668091, -0.012794495, -0.0025463104, 0.0046424866, -0.050323486, 0.011817932, -0.03765869, 0.04928589, -0.053710938, -0.03274536, -0.021255493, 0.00756073, 0.030563354, -0.012557983, -0.036621094, 0.0064811707, 0.0012845993, -0.020874023, 0.0014543533, 0.0073280334, -0.004550934, 0.009689331, 0.028335571, 0.020492554, -0.024765015, 0.0035572052, 0.02330017, -0.038726807, -0.028778076, -0.009277344, -0.01737976, 0.033599854, 0.014862061, -0.020828247, -0.0024528503, 0.017852783, -0.03567505, -0.00043034554, 0.006690979, 0.04034424, -0.028640747, -0.033477783, 0.013511658, 0.0060577393, 0.021148682, -0.042419434, -0.07672119, 0.008506775, 0.038635254, 0.009994507, 0.014320374, 0.037872314, 0.006111145, -0.0017080307, -0.032836914, -0.012992859, -0.029571533, -0.010948181, 0.017730713, 0.061645508, 0.029190063, -0.01399231, -0.009262085, 0.0016622543, -0.027633667, 0.016601562, -0.0073623657, -0.023391724, 0.021469116, -0.010253906, 0.03857422, -0.011512756, 0.021240234, -0.028793335, -0.048736572, 0.030578613, 0.013122559, -0.0041160583, 0.018447876, -0.045715332, 0.0826416, -0.03137207, -0.030441284, 0.015731812, 0.04168701, -0.020889282, 0.05529785, -0.047729492, 0.003332138, -0.01777649, 0.0017852783, -0.003780365, 0.00831604, -0.0019130707, -0.010231018, 0.020645142, -0.01448822, -0.068481445, -0.034179688, -0.052764893, 0.013793945, -0.027160645, 0.04888916, -0.003786087, 0.012397766, -0.0010728836, -0.0016050339, 0.00422287, -0.0020160675, -0.06970215, -0.11090088, 0.006008148, -0.028823853 ], "summary": [ -0.022338867, -0.0181427, -0.011299133, 0.042755127, -0.041931152, -0.010047913, 0.00459671, -0.04196167, 0.036132812, 0.027679443, 0.006038666, -0.013656616, 0.041259766, -0.05596924, 0.005130768, 0.009590149, 0.0131073, -0.01638794, 0.0051345825, -0.045837402, 0.03744507, -0.031219482, -0.009223938, 0.0871582, -0.017730713, 0.024215698, 0.02973938, 0.0042877197, -0.021224976, -0.022140503, -0.0049438477, 0.0095825195, -0.018096924, 0.00060224533, 0.04421997, -0.0011587143, -0.014205933, 0.026733398, 0.04663086, -0.023757935, 0.008010864, -0.006187439, 0.074157715, -0.010025024, 0.019760132, 0.03768921, -0.03112793, -0.0597229, 0.03237915, 0.05819702, -0.0063438416, 0.032043457, -0.024658203, 0.03744507, -0.0034618378, -0.029647827, -0.05456543, 0.030197144, -0.009857178, 0.06500244, 0.05496216, 0.027038574, -0.016189575, -0.015327454, 0.0020656586, -0.022262573, 0.002500534, 0.024734497, 0.023544312, 0.023971558, 0.012458801, 0.0022621155, 0.018112183, -0.03225708, -0.045074463, 0.008575439, 0.033996582, -0.0060157776, 0.020706177, -0.039794922, 0.020065308, 0.0044670105, 0.0023002625, -0.03552246, 0.012702942, -0.022918701, 0.0018043518, -0.009384155, -0.006095886, -0.006793976, -0.015655518, 0.03326416, -0.038146973, 0.021133423, 0.008850098, -0.03591919, -0.01525116, -0.0072402954, -0.0010328293, 0.0446167, 0.024368286, -0.038330078, 0.08660889, -0.0619812, -0.0015411377, 0.024475098, -0.018218994, -0.021453857, 0.02041626, 0.02859497, -0.011383057, -0.014877319, 0.010101318, -0.0345459, 0.0015106201, 0.04748535, 0.017074585, 0.026947021, -0.0052452087, 0.024505615, -0.01802063, -0.014961243, 0.019073486, 0.0368042, 0.04071045, 0.023971558, -0.019546509, -0.0018644333, 0.003742218, 0.0032463074, -0.017044067, 0.027801514, 0.048675537, 0.011222839, -0.016204834, -0.0069351196, 0.0053863525, 0.002407074, -0.003250122, -0.020080566, 0.054840088, 0.027526855, 0.039215088, 0.025314331, -0.018875122, 0.014663696, 0.016204834, -0.00844574, -0.003982544, -0.0037174225, -0.047729492, 0.010154724, 0.013259888, 0.021347046, 0.010887146, -0.00856781, 0.0052833557, -0.008270264, 0.013244629, -0.0014429092, 0.040496826, 0.017730713, 0.0031795502, 0.068481445, 0.04232788, -0.021148682, -0.0046424866, -0.004558563, 0.0056648254, -0.0017204285, -0.01637268, 0.016845703, -0.022888184, -0.030761719, -0.0045928955, -0.008110046, 0.027450562, -0.015594482, 0.013549805, 0.020446777, -0.0071792603, -0.02279663, 0.0413208, -0.0043678284, -0.039001465, 0.0129470825, -0.007949829, 0.023101807, 0.049743652, -0.0018167496, 0.029693604, -0.033050537, -0.064697266, -0.014541626, -0.0041542053, 0.011856079, -0.017074585, 0.0043258667, 0.000066280365, 0.013702393, -0.0031356812, -0.016677856, -0.010322571, 0.0072669983, -0.06347656, -0.005924225, -0.02406311, 0.023910522, -0.027145386, 0.010375977, 0.0309906, -0.008636475, -0.013923645, -0.01675415, -0.013397217, -0.039154053, 0.010513306, -0.026184082, -0.006084442, -0.029342651, -0.02633667, 0.042175293, -0.050964355, 0.026672363, 0.020828247, -0.037841797, 0.01928711, -0.030380249, 0.04260254, 0.011734009, 0.014701843, -0.019683838, 0.0107803345, 0.025878906, -0.022003174, -0.0049591064, -0.020629883, -0.03414917, -0.0017251968, 0.039916992, 0.022201538, -0.0011119843, -0.025344849, -0.006958008, 0.017196655, -0.024246216, 0.0020046234, 0.00894165, 0.010467529, 0.06719971, 0.011367798, 0.0016031265, -0.01197052, -0.05783081, 0.0154418945, 0.016586304, 0.002035141, -0.022872925, 0.030944824, -0.008651733, 0.008094788, 0.005329132, -0.02279663, 0.019485474, -0.022598267, -0.013870239, -0.002614975, 0.0028629303, 0.022949219, -0.029663086, 0.0048561096, -0.04421997, -0.022323608, -0.048828125, -0.050109863, -0.03378296, -0.04714966, 0.07342529, -0.015731812, -0.05984497, 0.013557434, 0.020019531, 0.013191223, -0.018508911, 0.05847168, 0.023849487, -0.01499176, -0.013938904, 0.05645752, 0.07910156, 0.06542969, 0.04434204, 0.038146973, 0.015052795, 0.00035858154, 0.0072288513, -0.08843994, 0.040039062, 0.014228821, -0.033996582, -0.054016113, 0.030807495, -0.023132324, 0.018951416, -0.012680054, 0.09643555, 0.030700684, -0.016555786, 0.009056091, -0.024627686, 0.04333496, 0.0015602112, -0.0024032593, -0.025863647, -0.00434494, -0.024291992, -0.028503418, -0.015602112, 0.00017595291, 0.07342529, 0.07293701, 0.026504517, 0.032958984, 0.0023384094, 0.016616821, -0.04928589, 0.0005955696, -0.012283325, 0.0035095215, -0.01600647, 0.001168251, 0.0051841736, -0.01184845, 0.0758667, 0.017959595, -0.00409317, 0.020446777, -0.07891846, 0.012016296, 0.050872803, 0.05731201, 0.05441284, 0.0034389496, -0.028335571, -0.044036865, 0.0032615662, 0.031234741, -0.0035247803, 0.034362793, 0.01007843, 0.008491516, -0.009613037, 0.006210327, 0.05593872, 0.03286743, -0.021209717, -0.019683838, 0.053131104, 0.001077652, -0.023010254, 0.039123535, 0.03829956, 0.03225708, -0.016174316, -0.05255127, -0.045806885, 0.02835083, -0.0028476715, -0.037231445, -0.0345459, -0.07470703, -0.015045166, 0.031143188, -0.008522034, 0.00390625, 0.06939697, 0.04675293, -0.018356323, -0.003232956, 0.028549194, 0.027999878, 0.08441162, -0.03010559, 0.089416504, 0.03036499, -0.0061454773, -0.047058105, -0.039398193, 0.053833008, 0.0418396, 0.024093628, -0.02798462, 0.015052795, -0.030838013, 0.021652222, 0.026550293, -0.027328491, -0.0007777214, -0.015563965, -0.03213501, 0.010955811, 0.025527954, 0.014289856, -0.0015630722, -0.0019168854, 0.0047416687, 0.0069732666, -0.013648987, 0.01020813, 0.036865234, -0.010574341, -0.029800415, -0.025405884, -0.008354187, 0.00047254562, -0.010116577, 0.041656494, 0.023162842, -0.03652954, -0.033966064, 0.037200928, -0.020843506, 0.001162529, -0.013076782, 0.0046195984, 0.0256958, -0.0057029724, 0.013404846, -0.032043457, -0.03048706, -0.0017604828, -0.039489746, -0.01939392, 0.017486572, -0.020980835, 0.036224365, 0.016433716, -0.033325195, 0.06561279, -0.05307007, -0.078186035, -0.05029297, -0.013381958, 0.00089788437, -0.0030918121, -0.010299683, -0.032104492, -0.07281494, 0.008308411, -0.002111435, 0.012077332, -0.0071754456, 0.046783447, 0.012054443, -0.025543213, 0.051849365, -0.018600464, 0.0076560974, 0.0446167, -0.014709473, -0.0018920898, 0.01890564, -0.06021118, -0.012184143, 0.028701782, 0.016235352, -0.032592773, -0.0008430481, -0.023925781, 0.004852295, 0.023773193, 0.005680084, -0.01133728, -0.02519226, -0.026321411, -0.055541992, 0.07128906, 0.027145386, 0.020584106, -0.072753906, -0.032440186, 0.013999939, -0.052825928, -0.008102417, -0.0058517456, 0.0048675537, -0.03062439, -0.04067993, 0.022918701, 0.016830444, 0.034240723, -0.043945312, 0.04611206, 0.00856781, -0.015617371, 0.01953125, -0.020996094, 0.049560547, 0.029769897, -0.031036377, 0.024673462, -0.018814087, -0.020202637, -0.0052490234, 0.0062332153, 0.03765869, 0.026519775, 0.036254883, -0.006439209, -0.037139893, 0.05215454, -0.0234375, 0.03564453, 0.0015411377, 0.0038108826, 0.010307312, 0.030731201, -0.005622864, 0.011276245, 0.010017395, 0.04425049, 0.06378174, -0.00541687, -0.0059394836, 0.038726807, -0.007255554, -0.038848877, 0.0067481995, -0.021820068, -0.028076172, 0.005645752, 0.01940918, -0.056365967, -0.008155823, 0.052947998, -0.0019874573, -0.02684021, -0.015319824, 0.02230835, 0.033416748, -0.02507019, 0.0037326813, 0.018341064, 0.056274414, -0.022079468, -0.0061073303, -0.04711914, 0.032714844, -0.08105469, 0.019897461, -0.004650116, -0.0039749146, -0.029571533, -0.051452637, -0.058166504, 0.038238525, 0.0074539185, -0.0053100586, 0.0075683594, 0.0036087036, 0.007381439, -0.018417358, 0.0012760162, 0.0007314682, 0.058898926, 0.02607727, -0.013999939, -0.06506348, 0.008666992, -0.024505615, -0.02355957, -0.017684937, 0.0035209656, -0.034606934, 0.010223389, -0.020095825, 0.000934124, 0.017501831, 0.017837524, 0.040374756, 0.012321472, 0.01374054, -0.02633667, 0.0074386597, 0.021575928, -0.0814209, 0.006324768, -0.04663086, -0.00920105, -0.048828125, 0.03289795, -0.039154053, -0.04244995, -0.0011606216, 0.041046143, 0.030776978, 0.037261963, -0.013664246, 0.030792236, 0.022994995, 0.04296875, -0.0039520264, 0.01737976, 0.0026607513, -0.05908203, -0.008972168, 0.0054397583, 0.036499023, -0.006011963, 0.05328369, -0.0018177032, -0.045898438, 0.04135132, 0.008743286, 0.048675537, 0.018692017, 0.035003662, -0.008979797, -0.03062439, -0.0021438599, 0.004009247, -0.0045394897, 0.04034424, -0.017532349, -0.005718231, -0.035583496, 0.018936157, 0.03036499, -0.0026302338, 0.001490593, 0.020523071, -0.0037117004, -0.0647583, -0.06561279, -0.038970947, 0.08154297, -0.029556274, -0.018478394, -0.03149414, -0.047668457, -0.0029850006, -0.016937256, -0.009346008, 0.041381836, -0.0131073, -0.0067825317, 0.034118652, 0.0073394775, -0.018310547, -0.015571594, -0.0082092285, 0.012077332, 0.045532227, -0.01625061, -0.015609741, 0.017745972, -0.019165039, -0.035949707, 0.017227173, -0.042816162, -0.051971436, 0.0110321045, -0.03967285, 0.010658264, 0.0039253235, 0.008926392, -0.037261963, 0.012817383, -0.03338623, -0.005218506, 0.0031661987, -0.07409668, 0.07128906, -0.005680084, 0.017593384, 0.03048706, 0.023651123, -0.0045661926, 0.039520264, -0.02067566, -0.020065308, -0.03982544, 0.03515625, 0.017730713, -0.024627686, 0.03668213, 0.026977539, -0.032318115, -0.0132751465, -0.011955261, -0.049987793, -0.035491943, -0.00046777725, -0.032287598, 0.0023059845, -0.008575439, -0.03994751, -0.013328552, 0.0071525574, -0.0050582886, -0.015296936, 0.0020008087, 0.010116577, -0.008720398, -0.04034424, 0.032440186, -0.022781372, 0.0062332153, -0.0010080338, 0.035583496, -0.012710571, -0.050842285, -0.02470398, 0.0039787292, -0.033935547, -0.041381836, -0.044281006, -0.014083862, -0.021850586, 0.04647827, 0.010261536, 0.028778076, 0.0074882507, 0.02331543, 0.044067383, -0.047332764, -0.04083252, 0.02557373, 0.004558563, 0.0025177002, 0.028686523, -0.00040102005, -0.044189453, 0.014198303, 0.020492554, 0.009231567, 0.008117676, 0.014213562, -0.020446777, -0.008285522, -0.029510498, 0.0041999817, 0.009338379, -0.0178833, 0.031951904, 0.026687622, 0.008903503, -0.04055786, 0.0758667, 0.042419434, 0.061309814, -0.03994751, -0.024154663, 0.0037708282, 0.020111084, 0.0010557175, -0.020874023, -0.011787415, -0.017089844, 0.0016527176, -0.051574707, -0.0032405853, -0.0010175705, 0.049835205, 0.037231445, 0.09039307, -0.06365967, -0.05142212, -0.023834229, -0.01033783, -0.011833191, 0.04244995, -0.006587982, 0.011367798, -0.013023376, -0.04714966, -0.026245117, 0.012268066, 0.02279663, 0.043395996, -0.019332886, 0.06524658, -0.019134521, -0.010108948, -0.007484436, 0.023498535, 0.029281616, 0.010223389, 0.031066895, 0.019195557, 0.015686035, 0.0006427765, -0.012504578, -0.043273926, 0.0026454926, 0.00484848, -0.022964478, -0.02218628, -0.03845215, -0.027877808, 0.082092285, -0.023361206, -0.05343628, -0.11029053, -0.07556152, -0.026855469, 0.007774353, -0.037078857, -0.036071777, 0.026153564, -0.009033203, 0.018936157, 0.022109985, -0.019454956, -0.025985718, -0.0181427, -0.017990112, -0.0063552856, -0.020370483, 0.0062713623, -0.016952515, 0.025802612, 0.009208679, 0.011985779, 0.0345459, -0.006916046, 0.04360962, -0.017211914, 0.0041999817, -0.06585693, 0.009231567, -0.026412964, 0.062408447, 0.016860962, 0.044036865, 0.032073975, -0.017959595, 0.068359375, -0.048583984, 0.0025119781, 0.060760498, -0.027145386, 0.035125732, 0.039733887, 0.040130615, -0.01828003, -0.035308838, -0.03604126, 0.03503418, -0.026275635, 0.06573486, -0.07940674, -0.03463745, 0.019134521, 0.03314209, -0.051849365, 0.04031372, -0.044281006, -0.020996094, -0.027908325, -0.015419006, -0.027709961, -0.051818848, 0.0028629303, 0.009765625, -0.016952515, -0.0010089874, 0.023284912, -0.012184143, 0.014190674, 0.017578125, -0.026412964, -0.009056091, -0.029891968, -0.0236969, 0.012779236, 0.00096035004, 0.0031776428, -0.008979797, 0.04067993, 0.068481445, 0.032562256, 0.0053138733, -0.05734253, -0.023544312, 0.08880615, -0.009307861, 0.0042381287, -0.0006542206, -0.007736206, -0.0118637085, -0.011680603, 0.011833191, 0.012771606, -0.00018811226, 0.020904541, -0.031433105, -0.00843811, -0.02217102, 0.012992859, -0.021652222, -0.022766113, -0.043640137, -0.040496826, -0.011909485, -0.033416748, -0.046051025, -0.036071777, -0.04168701, -0.05368042, 0.064941406, -0.01852417, 0.0033607483, 0.036956787, -0.014129639, 0.014305115, -0.018173218, 0.014846802, 0.059570312, -0.04486084, -0.052246094, -0.0052948, 0.011428833, 0.0569458, -0.0044136047, -0.043701172, 0.035095215, 0.038604736, -0.0055274963, -0.0090408325, 0.0057640076, -0.02722168, -0.029296875, 0.013145447, 0.023376465, -0.026626587, 0.047546387, -0.0053634644, -0.0077667236, -0.0044136047, 0.011375427, -0.0071144104, 0.0033550262, -0.015335083, -0.0058059692, 0.012207031, 0.014343262, -0.01235199, 0.004425049, 0.03488159, 0.039489746, 0.004802704, -0.046936035, 0.0008893013, -0.017318726, 0.022628784, -0.004085541, -0.06060791, 0.028198242, 0.010002136, 0.016708374, -0.03152466, 0.022003174, 0.018814087, -0.01600647, -0.008354187, -0.010154724, -0.03842163, 0.016296387, 0.04071045, 0.065979004, -0.011634827, -0.032226562, -0.014167786, -0.03213501, -0.048431396, 0.015731812, -0.01828003, -0.020645142, 0.0021438599, -0.023345947, 0.0206604, -0.007911682, 0.024871826, -0.040374756, -0.060699463, 0.031204224, 0.005519867, -0.0057144165, 0.028671265, -0.03564453, 0.058135986, -0.030151367, 0.012062073, 0.005317688, 0.008766174, 0.0021762848, -0.030273438, -0.0021572113, 0.032287598, -0.0046577454, 0.023040771, 0.006515503, 0.029251099, 0.006416321, -0.027282715, 0.001865387, -0.011703491, -0.061401367, -0.0993042, -0.05029297, 0.0027828217, -0.027709961, 0.044006348, 0.032440186, 0.0071525574, 0.015274048, -0.017562866, 0.03451538, 0.01739502, -0.010398865, -0.121520996, -0.02180481, 0.0051193237 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1510.02693v1
Feedforward Sequential Memory Neural Networks without Recurrent Feedback
ShiLiang Zhang, Hui Jiang, Si Wei, LiRong Dai
cs.NE, cs.CL, cs.LG
We introduce a new structure for memory neural networks, called feedforward sequential memory networks (FSMN), which can learn long-term dependency without using recurrent feedback. The proposed FSMN is a standard feedforward neural networks equipped with learnable sequential memory blocks in the hidden layers. In this work, we have applied FSMN to several language modeling (LM) tasks. Experimental results have shown that the memory blocks in FSMN can learn effective representations of long history. Experiments have shown that FSMN based language models can significantly outperform not only feedforward neural network (FNN) based LMs but also the popular recurrent neural network (RNN) LMs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1510.02693v1
2015-10-09T15:04:11
2015-10-09T15:04:11
{ "title": [ -0.0047416687, -0.0030841827, -0.024261475, -0.056396484, 0.030731201, -0.0032730103, -0.0044059753, -0.021224976, 0.011268616, 0.028427124, 0.0058670044, -0.007369995, -0.031219482, -0.024978638, -0.06738281, 0.00422287, 0.005256653, 0.02885437, -0.014877319, -0.032348633, -0.008018494, -0.028366089, 0.04397583, 0.07116699, 0.031433105, -0.040374756, -0.08502197, 0.021759033, -0.052642822, -0.03274536, -0.01399231, 0.022994995, 0.026153564, 0.039398193, 0.0067253113, -0.018615723, -0.05709839, 0.039520264, 0.018875122, -0.009849548, -0.0016880035, 0.004901886, -0.013504028, -0.030380249, -0.030319214, 0.010803223, -0.06756592, -0.035369873, -0.046661377, 0.03918457, 0.032104492, 0.0104599, -0.007663727, 0.04248047, 0.02998352, -0.03475952, -0.0368042, -0.0010108948, 0.030975342, 0.093322754, 0.047576904, -0.03125, -0.008323669, -0.02696228, -0.052490234, -0.0023441315, -0.007911682, 0.021957397, 0.07348633, -0.0039863586, -0.034942627, 0.028137207, -0.0051116943, 0.017089844, -0.0635376, -0.0029716492, 0.04776001, 0.0013446808, 0.035827637, -0.03591919, -0.018737793, -0.014312744, -0.021148682, -0.030471802, 0.016601562, -0.03466797, -0.031188965, -0.006084442, -0.047180176, -0.07159424, -0.02545166, -0.009262085, -0.0032539368, -0.020980835, -0.043029785, -0.020599365, -0.020843506, 0.009346008, -0.0076522827, -0.004184723, -0.007507324, 0.016036987, -0.020065308, -0.003189087, 0.00504303, -0.0022125244, -0.04348755, -0.040130615, 0.011444092, 0.052520752, -0.018447876, -0.0035915375, 0.02178955, -0.013160706, 0.0019321442, 0.022735596, 0.024337769, 0.0047073364, 0.024002075, 0.0082473755, -0.01486969, -0.04675293, 0.013969421, 0.003768921, 0.04260254, 0.011306763, -0.046844482, 0.0059547424, -0.0050086975, 0.019515991, 0.005695343, 0.034210205, -0.08380127, -0.06945801, -0.04824829, 0.046173096, -0.0060424805, 0.0065689087, 0.0057754517, 0.002670288, 0.0025997162, -0.030181885, -0.020645142, 0.0069847107, 0.02810669, 0.016204834, 0.0725708, -0.002746582, -0.04763794, -0.03591919, -0.02079773, 0.02609253, 0.030944824, 0.016174316, -0.060699463, -0.013069153, -0.124816895, -0.013679504, 0.030090332, 0.006137848, 0.039031982, 0.0009250641, -0.037322998, 0.019546509, 0.036468506, -0.0021629333, -0.018417358, 0.023864746, 0.0032901764, 0.022491455, 0.008110046, 0.027557373, 0.0054397583, -0.0016040802, -0.0014066696, -0.004611969, 0.032440186, -0.00630188, 0.039611816, -0.031829834, -0.0051193237, -0.024307251, 0.010566711, 0.04537964, -0.073913574, 0.0010309219, -0.011299133, 0.0050811768, 0.07165527, 0.00497818, -0.04071045, 0.0029125214, -0.021865845, -0.037384033, -0.03805542, -0.037994385, 0.037750244, 0.017471313, -0.00009274483, 0.020202637, -0.041992188, -0.01537323, -0.03253174, -0.012023926, -0.012130737, -0.03265381, -0.010810852, 0.026657104, -0.03189087, 0.045837402, 0.06149292, 0.016281128, -0.046295166, 0.007911682, -0.00415802, -0.068359375, 0.015167236, 0.0069084167, -0.0013475418, 0.007396698, -0.036071777, -0.013771057, -0.008796692, 0.03930664, 0.030456543, 0.008171082, -0.0021915436, -0.04434204, 0.058441162, 0.004219055, 0.07714844, -0.01663208, -0.007045746, -0.026016235, -0.023605347, -0.025436401, -0.028961182, -0.016174316, 0.010932922, 0.024749756, 0.003370285, -0.026412964, -0.011245728, 0.027618408, 0.036010742, -0.0046539307, 0.0019073486, 0.023223877, 0.014076233, 0.013793945, 0.08905029, 0.037322998, 0.06188965, 0.000013053417, 0.039855957, 0.049835205, 0.01838684, 0.020736694, -0.018936157, 0.009796143, -0.001080513, 0.035491943, -0.0042533875, 0.021728516, -0.030395508, -0.0013961792, -0.022201538, 0.008911133, -0.0023097992, 0.027145386, 0.03643799, -0.021774292, 0.023254395, -0.037322998, -0.0289917, -0.029251099, -0.0090408325, 0.01890564, 0.012420654, -0.07556152, -0.0075263977, 0.012252808, 0.04611206, 0.009536743, 0.041778564, 0.00044202805, 0.009239197, -0.014389038, 0.0010671616, 0.0010728836, 0.05529785, 0.037719727, 0.0127334595, -0.0026302338, 0.0053863525, -0.00030326843, 0.06329346, 0.079833984, -0.03869629, 0.04660034, -0.033050537, 0.026992798, 0.015716553, -0.01777649, 0.016113281, 0.015068054, 0.006580353, 0.03137207, -0.029647827, 0.032592773, -0.08300781, 0.004524231, 0.0028362274, -0.021881104, -0.03277588, -0.053619385, 0.0073661804, -0.056365967, -0.012451172, 0.003583908, 0.06915283, 0.0023784637, -0.020996094, 0.0016727448, 0.014404297, -0.019561768, -0.019256592, -0.026412964, -0.012260437, 0.010108948, 0.05239868, 0.012123108, -0.039398193, -0.01689148, -0.004837036, -0.0030326843, -0.0115737915, 0.054260254, -0.007484436, 0.007987976, 0.021011353, -0.029403687, 0.035095215, -0.02243042, -0.0061531067, -0.025100708, -0.00045704842, 0.036102295, -0.04534912, -0.005466461, 0.027572632, -0.034454346, -0.05407715, 0.04901123, 0.04840088, 0.0061683655, 0.012130737, 0.053741455, 0.03778076, 0.00095176697, 0.010185242, -0.014518738, -0.019577026, -0.04977417, 0.005382538, -0.026168823, -0.0037155151, -0.02420044, -0.017089844, 0.06951904, -0.06512451, 0.0053634644, -0.043914795, -0.023147583, -0.008125305, 0.04650879, 0.02166748, -0.025405884, -0.03967285, 0.0018339157, -0.0008506775, 0.023376465, -0.04724121, 0.00995636, 0.07348633, -0.012428284, -0.036834717, -0.0003838539, 0.04067993, 0.02192688, -0.01687622, -0.012763977, -0.036743164, 0.0048675537, 0.028747559, 0.013633728, 0.008003235, -0.0345459, -0.09863281, -0.024459839, 0.05102539, 0.008369446, -0.030212402, 0.018753052, -0.04067993, 0.0041046143, 0.008232117, -0.023986816, 0.015655518, 0.053466797, 0.015075684, 0.0062179565, 0.029052734, -0.035095215, 0.04815674, -0.051330566, -0.08343506, 0.034362793, -0.01864624, -0.05847168, -0.011810303, -0.042388916, -0.05291748, -0.016967773, 0.004257202, 0.01676941, 0.030212402, 0.0096206665, -0.0146102905, -0.0181427, -0.0022125244, -0.03753662, -0.029525757, -0.028015137, 0.028335571, 0.023529053, -0.018966675, 0.018096924, -0.008071899, 0.0028533936, -0.017181396, -0.013267517, 0.001288414, 0.045288086, 0.005317688, -0.03765869, -0.013679504, -0.0044822693, -0.012054443, -0.018493652, -0.004890442, -0.0003759861, -0.017852783, 0.0016851425, -0.014404297, 0.028518677, 0.004043579, 0.00069475174, 0.0014133453, -0.025909424, 0.0046844482, -0.028259277, -0.057159424, 0.014099121, 0.025741577, 0.022323608, 0.01826477, -0.01890564, -0.026321411, 0.02848816, -0.04660034, 0.014289856, 0.011528015, -0.0002810955, -0.01574707, 0.025268555, -0.030548096, -0.0017986298, -0.029037476, 0.01272583, 0.028686523, -0.0068511963, -0.01979065, -0.034240723, 0.019470215, -0.006164551, -0.08502197, 0.0015115738, 0.0030212402, -0.020462036, -0.055847168, -0.03866577, 0.022781372, -0.015235901, -0.026565552, 0.01096344, -0.023788452, -0.041503906, -0.02192688, -0.03463745, -0.041870117, 0.07305908, -0.012771606, 0.014976501, 0.033294678, -0.007293701, -0.03994751, -0.023208618, 0.0077400208, -0.036132812, 0.03387451, -0.009239197, 0.0146865845, 0.06048584, -0.031433105, 0.015098572, 0.031707764, 0.03955078, -0.029937744, -0.01965332, -0.0011348724, -0.009254456, -0.027145386, 0.047088623, 0.012893677, -0.016998291, -0.07940674, 0.0051116943, -0.012077332, -0.009307861, 0.01878357, -0.0054893494, 0.032928467, 0.018203735, 0.00008779764, 0.04937744, -0.010681152, 0.011581421, 0.07684326, -0.024749756, -0.014289856, 0.0056915283, 0.022720337, 0.005554199, 0.024047852, 0.019760132, 0.024963379, 0.04763794, -0.042938232, -0.025894165, 0.0032863617, 0.02142334, -0.03137207, -0.021728516, -0.06060791, -0.02859497, 0.010757446, -0.010536194, -0.030441284, 0.032684326, 0.045562744, -0.00080776215, -0.03894043, 0.010551453, -0.0010309219, -0.013198853, 0.010635376, -0.039215088, -0.011894226, -0.0076408386, -0.053497314, -0.029647827, -0.009300232, -0.017684937, 0.014518738, -0.012191772, 0.0030021667, 0.001335144, 0.037384033, 0.081726074, 0.056152344, -0.0077209473, -0.06585693, 0.0137786865, -0.010467529, -0.006641388, 0.03086853, -0.005821228, 0.00029730797, -0.019439697, -0.0043754578, -0.021255493, -0.0028152466, -0.034118652, 0.0024871826, -0.0019521713, 0.017501831, -0.02418518, 0.02079773, 0.01512146, -0.00086164474, 0.0357666, 0.019821167, -0.029846191, -0.02999878, 0.050201416, 0.05114746, 0.016143799, 0.009162903, 0.037200928, 0.008308411, -0.011421204, 0.0060539246, 0.024871826, 0.01939392, 0.006164551, -0.02331543, 0.01133728, -0.039276123, -0.027038574, 0.012611389, -0.0018978119, 0.06451416, -0.056640625, 0.0657959, -0.024047852, -0.010383606, 0.041259766, -0.005241394, -0.005126953, 0.013839722, 0.012077332, -0.07867432, -0.064575195, -0.013511658, 0.06286621, -0.03152466, 0.012870789, 0.003921509, 0.011383057, 0.030166626, 0.042877197, 0.021896362, -0.009353638, -0.0039787292, -0.019012451, -0.009109497, -0.020080566, -0.035491943, 0.026016235, -0.0063171387, 0.00011301041, -0.043182373, -0.024459839, -0.066223145, -0.01197052, -0.01550293, -0.010688782, 0.0011940002, -0.07354736, 0.0031929016, 0.056671143, 0.022399902, 0.012870789, 0.025665283, 0.012634277, 0.0015621185, 0.043548584, 0.010246277, 0.049102783, 0.017669678, -0.05404663, 0.018859863, -0.020339966, 0.022994995, 0.019973755, 0.0056648254, 0.0256958, 0.03845215, -0.074279785, 0.026290894, 0.0033016205, -0.021957397, 0.040374756, -0.055114746, 0.0149002075, 0.0059013367, 0.0054740906, 0.007648468, -0.037200928, -0.022445679, 0.018569946, -0.034332275, -0.040924072, 0.022476196, -0.02142334, -0.02722168, -0.0126953125, 0.008460999, -0.012184143, 0.007881165, 0.01007843, 0.013366699, -0.023162842, 0.010986328, 0.034210205, -0.06500244, 0.0010757446, -0.008743286, 0.022216797, 0.034332275, 0.004055023, -0.03314209, 0.0013036728, -0.0062065125, -0.03945923, -0.024032593, 0.0335083, 0.01008606, -0.024230957, -0.0045204163, -0.015151978, 0.031280518, -0.011695862, 0.021728516, 0.007045746, -0.024612427, 0.02708435, 0.026107788, 0.033050537, -0.016860962, 0.006439209, 0.0058135986, -0.010009766, -0.0031089783, -0.03387451, 0.0039901733, 0.010917664, 0.031158447, 0.012496948, -0.049835205, 0.0054473877, 0.027435303, 0.035888672, 0.001074791, 0.021377563, 0.03881836, -0.00078105927, -0.015731812, 0.010513306, 0.05368042, -0.053131104, -0.034484863, -0.02003479, 0.0016727448, -0.043151855, 0.04525757, -0.022781372, -0.030685425, -0.033813477, -0.07165527, -0.040039062, 0.0058631897, 0.056488037, 0.023544312, 0.046142578, -0.05722046, 0.00018024445, -0.02986145, -0.009788513, -0.020599365, 0.011566162, -0.013282776, -0.010566711, 0.013618469, 0.0018320084, 0.015930176, -0.043121338, 0.043060303, 0.008255005, -0.005264282, 0.020965576, -0.029907227, 0.005859375, -0.03378296, -0.04168701, 0.03390503, 0.012168884, -0.0067481995, 0.061187744, -0.036468506, 0.05758667, 0.034362793, 0.063964844, 0.07513428, 0.00041031837, -0.00016748905, 0.0076942444, -0.0048332214, -0.05078125, 0.008918762, -0.045715332, -0.005756378, -0.061401367, -0.014556885, -0.04574585, -0.009216309, 0.016799927, 0.03100586, -0.0036182404, 0.01876831, -0.0074005127, 0.006626129, 0.054351807, -0.0032596588, 0.052703857, 0.025177002, 0.010025024, 0.020446777, -0.009429932, 0.0017938614, 0.03289795, 0.0073242188, 0.00687027, -0.01259613, -0.016616821, 0.01676941, 0.011604309, 0.013633728, -0.039855957, -0.028503418, -0.04586792, 0.055480957, 0.007461548, 0.05618286, 0.040100098, 0.04852295, -0.016113281, -0.0049438477, -0.0028495789, 0.014122009, -0.024276733, 0.00818634, 0.0592041, -0.089782715, 0.0056114197, -0.021438599, -0.015594482, -0.012916565, 0.037384033, 0.011329651, -0.05142212, -0.019302368, 0.006702423, 0.041412354, 0.009780884, 0.016067505, -0.042388916, -0.01259613, 0.02003479, 0.046783447, -0.020553589, -0.0007777214, 0.015464783, 0.028442383, -0.017364502, -0.007118225, 0.012672424, 0.03112793, -0.023849487, 0.033081055, -0.04232788, 0.047973633, 0.011253357, -0.046569824, 0.027633667, 0.009002686, -0.06774902, -0.00459671, 0.018005371, 0.0713501, 0.04937744, 0.08288574, 0.011222839, -0.013175964, 0.022140503, -0.05307007, 0.028915405, 0.025985718, -0.029251099, 0.032287598, -0.034942627, -0.02885437, 0.032165527, -0.041870117, 0.053497314, -0.03967285, -0.00011819601, -0.015525818, 0.019638062, 0.038391113, -0.05117798, -0.023986816, -0.0184021, -0.020431519, -0.017242432, -0.012802124, -0.023468018, -0.035583496, -0.015571594, 0.02859497, 0.009170532, -0.0062675476, -0.015838623, -0.017684937, -0.06719971, 0.0011453629, -0.025863647, 0.03338623, -0.017364502, 0.01398468, 0.009284973, -0.0035858154, -0.020324707, -0.0231781, -0.024139404, 0.00869751, -0.0418396, -0.038726807, 0.0038719177, 0.0042877197, -0.023086548, 0.014266968, -0.07086182, 0.02923584, -0.01890564, -0.0014305115, 0.030853271, -0.039886475, -0.034057617, 0.009521484, -0.034088135, 0.042938232, 0.021820068, 0.0013065338, -0.006729126, 0.012901306, -0.014862061, -0.0014390945, 0.028823853, 0.064086914, -0.025939941, -0.045959473, 0.008934021, 0.04473877, 0.04257202, -0.066101074, -0.03326416, 0.0069503784, 0.034820557, -0.010795593, 0.06866455, 0.0071372986, 0.0003912449, 0.03967285, 0.039031982, 0.014976501, -0.05130005, -0.032440186, -0.029190063, 0.04135132, 0.040496826, -0.012031555, -0.02456665, 0.023147583, -0.019180298, -0.017822266, -0.0061416626, 0.004917145, -0.018066406, -0.0025806427, 0.025604248, -0.01826477, -0.026855469, -0.04171753, 0.006198883, 0.007396698, 0.043518066, -0.029968262, 0.01663208, 0.0008430481, 0.07879639, -0.016143799, -0.04232788, 0.049041748, 0.017684937, 0.0345459, 0.020431519, -0.021240234, -0.0065307617, -0.008613586, -0.008010864, -0.012680054, 0.0118637085, 0.016036987, -0.020751953, 0.026260376, -0.033843994, -0.029815674, -0.014595032, -0.03652954, 0.044036865, -0.045318604, 0.0066070557, -0.033966064, -0.023361206, -0.016784668, -0.0053367615, 0.02583313, -0.029815674, -0.05065918, -0.047454834, 0.048919678, -0.019485474 ], "summary": [ -0.009643555, -0.0028209686, -0.025848389, -0.029251099, -0.021865845, -0.011787415, -0.022735596, 0.019439697, -0.0072250366, 0.00920105, 0.006160736, -0.030456543, -0.014945984, -0.035003662, -0.009819031, -0.038116455, 0.0016822815, 0.0066871643, 0.00522995, -0.016738892, 0.017028809, -0.00036597252, -0.0018186569, 0.020751953, 0.017807007, -0.04763794, -0.0020446777, 0.020858765, 0.007865906, 0.0019035339, 0.018676758, -0.019424438, -0.0012340546, 0.01687622, 0.0059509277, -0.08227539, -0.004764557, 0.011566162, -0.008003235, -0.009887695, -0.021743774, 0.00484848, 0.06072998, -0.046905518, 0.019378662, 0.030044556, -0.044891357, -0.0960083, 0.01134491, 0.009239197, -0.0026607513, -0.00970459, -0.0017871857, 0.047851562, -0.012504578, -0.032409668, -0.042266846, 0.027664185, -0.019500732, 0.10656738, 0.049926758, 0.06890869, -0.052764893, -0.054718018, -0.012489319, 0.011817932, 0.035705566, 0.006450653, 0.014785767, -0.0010728836, -0.012489319, -0.0043907166, 0.011222839, -0.042755127, -0.058746338, 0.0026626587, 0.03552246, -0.029907227, 0.018814087, -0.042785645, -0.031555176, 0.038269043, -0.031311035, -0.070251465, 0.02015686, -0.050628662, -0.024841309, 0.00242424, -0.04525757, -0.008804321, -0.031433105, -0.0028018951, -0.05126953, 0.00699234, -0.0038337708, -0.0104522705, -0.020507812, -0.04663086, -0.0038089752, -0.015075684, -0.001964569, -0.0031166077, -0.027709961, 0.02406311, -0.0085372925, -0.006828308, -0.03753662, -0.064819336, 0.0047721863, 0.03704834, -0.024719238, -0.033966064, 0.007904053, -0.051574707, -0.016418457, 0.03805542, 0.009506226, 0.013900757, 0.030151367, 0.0021800995, -0.02168274, -0.011756897, -0.018966675, 0.040863037, 0.006679535, 0.010017395, 0.012184143, 0.010673523, -0.013336182, 0.036315918, -0.009338379, 0.006378174, -0.041168213, 0.00178051, -0.029144287, -0.010948181, -0.009124756, 0.005012512, 0.0118637085, 0.001405716, 0.03982544, -0.011680603, 0.0029716492, 0.029785156, 0.016525269, 0.029693604, 0.024978638, -0.018325806, -0.020080566, -0.048919678, 0.00023198128, -0.0025501251, 0.022491455, -0.0059814453, -0.023071289, -0.0335083, -0.058532715, 0.008529663, 0.020431519, 0.00018560886, 0.03503418, -0.006580353, -0.044952393, -0.0020103455, -0.024856567, -0.031585693, 0.019989014, 0.015686035, 0.01473999, -0.017654419, 0.009346008, 0.036102295, -0.021484375, -0.016952515, 0.01537323, -0.014427185, -0.012641907, 0.011207581, 0.0022678375, 0.019607544, 0.014694214, -0.032684326, 0.018371582, 0.02368164, -0.0362854, 0.013832092, -0.022827148, 0.047424316, 0.07116699, 0.011795044, -0.030441284, -0.046142578, 0.022720337, -0.0085372925, -0.029678345, 0.0035552979, 0.03933716, 0.05810547, 0.00042891502, -0.055358887, 0.021575928, 0.0132369995, -0.010147095, -0.016983032, -0.05987549, -0.0006494522, -0.011497498, 0.0206604, 0.04724121, 0.028503418, -0.009162903, -0.018966675, -0.0029029846, -0.008598328, -0.041503906, -0.019592285, 0.024291992, -0.018722534, 0.0041160583, -0.0027389526, -0.016998291, 0.023590088, -0.02217102, 0.037719727, -0.0064926147, -0.009017944, -0.03149414, -0.0025482178, -0.03955078, -0.0036697388, 0.0112838745, 0.03994751, -0.046661377, -0.030700684, -0.023254395, -0.014205933, -0.002603531, -0.05331421, 0.02168274, 0.03274536, 0.015602112, 0.004016876, -0.014266968, 0.041778564, 0.005050659, -0.0059318542, 0.012260437, 0.022415161, -0.017715454, 0.00623703, 0.031311035, 0.025497437, 0.022445679, 0.02998352, 0.0074386597, 0.022491455, 0.010475159, 0.036071777, -0.01902771, -0.015548706, 0.013298035, 0.03652954, -0.010643005, 0.01727295, 0.044128418, -0.059295654, -0.0024700165, -0.027053833, -0.024780273, -0.020980835, 0.03390503, -0.039520264, 0.0052375793, -0.06555176, -0.06829834, -0.041809082, -0.014717102, 0.05419922, 0.00415802, -0.06762695, -0.007205963, 0.012626648, -0.012397766, -0.008621216, 0.020751953, -0.008018494, 0.00894928, -0.0070114136, 0.057037354, 0.088012695, 0.07928467, 0.047027588, 0.023071289, 0.050628662, -0.018844604, 0.008621216, -0.026794434, 0.051452637, -0.02923584, 0.0048980713, -0.0023708344, 0.035583496, -0.015388489, -0.0051116943, 0.022613525, 0.008659363, 0.0158844, 0.015716553, -0.0010766983, 0.032470703, -0.08453369, -0.0048828125, 0.019332886, 0.054016113, -0.026382446, -0.04663086, 0.010818481, 0.028305054, 0.020751953, 0.0435791, 0.054382324, 0.00699234, 0.020828247, 0.025894165, 0.0034236908, -0.041809082, 0.03817749, -0.017089844, 0.031402588, -0.03652954, -0.016693115, -0.0019989014, -0.047058105, 0.036254883, 0.019317627, 0.006702423, 0.0075263977, 0.014564514, -0.0027313232, -0.021133423, 0.016906738, -0.0069389343, 0.021896362, 0.013313293, -0.033935547, 0.02973938, -0.0041236877, 0.023788452, 0.007499695, -0.0134887695, -0.0020751953, -0.037353516, -0.019592285, 0.07550049, -0.005367279, -0.010940552, 0.038848877, 0.06378174, -0.014297485, 0.004272461, -0.010749817, -0.0146484375, -0.03741455, -0.046447754, -0.00095939636, 0.014205933, 0.00039625168, -0.010719299, 0.035339355, 0.033050537, 0.030181885, 0.050689697, -0.08734131, -0.025146484, -0.0112838745, -0.021011353, 0.13330078, 0.009750366, -0.025131226, 0.078063965, -0.0103302, 0.015319824, -0.040161133, -0.01737976, 0.032684326, 0.004508972, -0.06732178, -0.0033435822, 0.00013637543, 0.026672363, -0.0057792664, 0.0069274902, -0.013824463, -0.0024375916, 0.025894165, 0.01033783, 0.0014276505, -0.025375366, -0.053253174, -0.027542114, 0.07067871, 0.011436462, -0.009803772, 0.016311646, 0.013839722, 0.003604889, 0.08081055, -0.008369446, 0.014015198, -0.0077285767, 0.044677734, -0.07208252, 0.041656494, -0.09863281, 0.045684814, -0.037994385, -0.00141716, 0.012245178, -0.04058838, -0.0025558472, 0.051361084, -0.044921875, 0.0021877289, -0.00037407875, 0.047912598, 0.039123535, 0.011787415, -0.023849487, 0.017730713, -0.00077199936, 0.016799927, -0.037322998, -0.038116455, -0.012939453, 0.02255249, 0.03451538, -0.008758545, -0.015533447, -0.0037155151, 0.0005912781, -0.0076904297, 0.0044822693, -0.013763428, 0.007575989, -0.01133728, -0.018630981, 0.011940002, -0.0118637085, -0.002822876, 0.039215088, -0.004085541, 0.0059814453, -0.006626129, 0.0141067505, -0.036315918, -0.0034275055, -0.0140686035, 0.012489319, 0.06756592, -0.039611816, -0.037200928, -0.005218506, -0.01448822, -0.008522034, 0.024520874, 0.010795593, -0.036224365, -0.0037555695, -0.044006348, 0.023880005, -0.014480591, 0.012748718, 0.032104492, -0.019546509, -0.019821167, -0.056671143, 0.03778076, -0.020309448, 0.0362854, -0.051605225, -0.03149414, 0.011077881, -0.08605957, -0.0121154785, -0.010444641, 0.007724762, -0.024032593, -0.020507812, 0.014884949, 0.006313324, -0.052520752, -0.01751709, 0.0395813, -0.02418518, -0.0003066063, 0.033569336, -0.015640259, 0.056243896, -0.01876831, -0.04437256, 0.0040626526, -0.042175293, 0.013366699, 0.037628174, -0.0060653687, 0.043426514, -0.012680054, 0.038879395, 0.014434814, -0.059753418, -0.01461792, -0.022735596, 0.046142578, 0.05041504, -0.020599365, -0.024795532, 0.04269409, 0.041870117, -0.014717102, -0.016098022, 0.0027122498, 0.03164673, -0.035888672, 0.027435303, -0.0061950684, 0.017562866, -0.066101074, 0.037384033, -0.00630188, 0.003490448, 0.0045433044, 0.019760132, -0.0030822754, 0.011383057, 0.00007909536, -0.051574707, -0.015350342, 0.010910034, 0.047912598, -0.0016098022, 0.010635376, 0.029418945, -0.0033664703, 0.0069465637, -0.008140564, -0.0335083, -0.012718201, 0.007144928, -0.023956299, -0.028564453, 0.016708374, 0.006916046, -0.0044517517, -0.025817871, 0.0031795502, -0.046844482, 0.007129669, -0.016555786, -0.0064468384, 0.042053223, -0.011482239, 0.011116028, -0.0075302124, 0.00090551376, -0.01928711, 0.024902344, -0.025146484, -0.019058228, -0.06365967, 0.016052246, -0.053009033, -0.03274536, -0.072021484, -0.044830322, -0.05895996, 0.003522873, -0.008216858, 0.014060974, 0.03564453, 0.08227539, 0.067993164, -0.0025177002, -0.09820557, 0.0056762695, 0.00078105927, 0.032409668, -0.004386902, 0.033691406, 0.010353088, -0.02053833, -0.046203613, -0.006160736, -0.014419556, -0.017578125, -0.04156494, 0.0030536652, -0.025985718, 0.014579773, 0.055023193, 0.0032730103, -0.02607727, 0.019607544, -0.0028419495, -0.008926392, 0.013877869, 0.076538086, -0.015579224, 0.040283203, 0.024841309, 0.056610107, -0.028366089, -0.052703857, 0.027191162, 0.0143585205, 0.021865845, 0.014282227, 0.0008068085, -0.015777588, -0.027999878, 0.017211914, 0.021011353, -0.035461426, 0.033935547, -0.004131317, -0.004688263, 0.0046844482, 0.011039734, 0.049835205, -0.0066108704, -0.017562866, 0.047180176, -0.022460938, -0.03643799, -0.06188965, -0.008766174, 0.059692383, 0.00667572, 0.0063972473, 0.010093689, 0.0076560974, 0.00333786, 0.023757935, -0.0011529922, -0.061676025, 0.027160645, -0.013999939, -0.027557373, -0.0024223328, 0.0064735413, 0.020385742, -0.0076560974, -0.018295288, -0.021652222, -0.0758667, 0.011268616, -0.011222839, -0.026626587, 0.007534027, -0.00030589104, -0.025527954, -0.029342651, 0.034942627, 0.003376007, 0.03704834, 0.06311035, 0.0035972595, -0.029464722, 0.012054443, -0.015159607, 0.056671143, -0.024887085, -0.07879639, -0.005268097, -0.048828125, 0.011428833, -0.00381279, 0.021881104, 0.028518677, 0.0385437, -0.07397461, -0.0068893433, -0.041656494, 0.021347046, 0.012580872, -0.021621704, 0.021438599, 0.006137848, -0.004432678, -0.035736084, 0.0042800903, -0.025512695, 0.017318726, -0.049438477, -0.017501831, -0.021148682, -0.08428955, -0.037109375, 0.038482666, -0.010597229, 0.0023021698, 0.025970459, 0.011177063, -0.030960083, -0.008903503, -0.004261017, 0.014289856, -0.034729004, -0.010307312, 0.03353882, 0.039154053, -0.01689148, -0.035003662, -0.009101868, -0.015808105, 0.008575439, -0.031799316, -0.024398804, 0.017913818, -0.026000977, 0.019546509, -0.0003566742, 0.01235199, 0.045043945, -0.043548584, -0.0059127808, 0.045654297, -0.0050582886, 0.020248413, 0.010437012, 0.02166748, 0.019088745, -0.03656006, 0.023513794, 0.0034713745, -0.005580902, -0.0357666, 0.03390503, 0.03717041, 0.05923462, 0.014320374, -0.039489746, 0.0074157715, 0.046295166, 0.023666382, 0.020217896, 0.03225708, 0.040527344, -0.0046463013, -0.0045776367, 0.018981934, 0.040374756, -0.046569824, -0.013427734, -0.037628174, 0.032073975, -0.09442139, -0.12768555, 0.019973755, 0.026443481, 0.032348633, -0.08312988, -0.0082473755, 0.0046539307, 0.06072998, 0.045654297, 0.07678223, 0.010902405, 0.028564453, 0.017730713, -0.027526855, -0.023498535, 0.029907227, -0.0071144104, -0.015991211, 0.03643799, -0.016906738, 0.013130188, 0.012550354, 0.012542725, -0.022003174, -0.029067993, 0.036743164, -0.0026168823, 0.014335632, 0.024093628, -0.03741455, 0.020004272, -0.017105103, 0.015823364, 0.006175995, 0.026626587, 0.007724762, 0.0463562, 0.029067993, 0.02961731, -0.033569336, -0.0064582825, 0.027267456, -0.0023059845, -0.027328491, 0.018157959, 0.007709503, -0.018478394, -0.009719849, -0.020019531, -0.031921387, 0.025985718, 0.009216309, 0.020233154, 0.03024292, 0.00541687, 0.0076026917, 0.007888794, -0.01802063, -0.005657196, 0.02015686, 0.044311523, -0.001912117, 0.020584106, -0.029846191, 0.011421204, 0.050994873, 0.011009216, 0.0010719299, 0.022705078, -0.007419586, 0.014152527, 0.005001068, -0.0076560974, -0.07678223, 0.01008606, -0.04269409, 0.019622803, 0.03427124, 0.034729004, -0.0076179504, 0.03591919, -0.04159546, 0.035461426, 0.018295288, 0.019424438, -0.0075149536, 0.0044174194, 0.018508911, -0.057678223, -0.023345947, 0.02999878, -0.0034160614, 0.0015640259, 0.05307007, 0.022201538, -0.048858643, 0.047424316, 0.027770996, -0.02407837, -0.03744507, -0.008575439, -0.02607727, -0.002708435, 0.034606934, 0.01197052, 0.004547119, 0.0045776367, -0.0003941059, -0.006011963, -0.0138168335, -0.021560669, 0.014381409, 0.007472992, 0.0060424805, 0.025497437, -0.02407837, 0.054870605, 0.06298828, -0.012313843, 0.031280518, 0.043914795, -0.022064209, 0.035125732, -0.021560669, 0.09661865, 0.06573486, 0.050476074, -0.055114746, 0.014457703, 0.09082031, -0.019073486, 0.052124023, -0.052856445, -0.013595581, 0.008644104, -0.014762878, 0.02557373, 0.010871887, -0.018356323, 0.008888245, -0.013397217, 0.012283325, -0.024047852, -0.003824234, 0.001373291, -0.022521973, 0.009414673, -0.013313293, -0.06121826, 0.020065308, 0.04977417, -0.029067993, -0.039489746, -0.026885986, -0.011604309, -0.020217896, -0.0069007874, 0.019210815, -0.014328003, -0.0015277863, 0.0064468384, 0.0041389465, 0.049987793, -0.018539429, 0.018997192, 0.0579834, -0.0019798279, -0.044769287, -0.040863037, -0.00440979, 0.015655518, 0.008682251, -0.02331543, -0.02659607, -0.05355835, -0.051086426, -0.022125244, -0.082336426, 0.046539307, -0.041809082, -0.0046577454, 0.025497437, 0.0052871704, -0.0009994507, 0.0028381348, -0.012573242, 0.009254456, 0.0010147095, -0.027832031, 0.002407074, -0.0079193115, -0.040924072, 0.005924225, 0.01713562, 0.028945923, -0.038238525, 0.01134491, 0.004196167, 0.011703491, 0.018539429, -0.06341553, 0.013847351, -0.03591919, 0.02255249, 0.020736694, -0.021148682, -0.015144348, -0.0036907196, 0.042053223, -0.0004017353, 0.017913818, -0.027679443, 0.019134521, -0.010368347, 0.012634277, 0.019515991, -0.010688782, 0.005207062, 0.01600647, -0.025039673, -0.04916382, 0.03744507, 0.027450562, -0.03756714, 0.02772522, 0.008018494, -0.032836914, -0.09698486, -0.026870728, 0.02619934, -0.019973755, 0.014434814, -0.010375977, 0.016983032, -0.0012226105, 0.026000977, -0.005130768, 0.031982422, 0.006679535, -0.0066947937, 0.03527832, -0.06732178, 0.03515625, 0.01689148, 0.007751465, 0.008972168, 0.0104904175, 0.030303955, -0.01209259, -0.011352539, 0.006877899, -0.0541687, 0.007396698, -0.082336426, -0.02671814, 0.015838623, -0.08465576, 0.01763916, -0.05908203, -0.006954193, 0.0006456375, -0.030853271, -0.016494751, -0.031433105, 0.0042915344, -0.04031372, -0.030532837, 0.024169922 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1909.09586v1
Understanding LSTM -- a tutorial into Long Short-Term Memory Recurrent Neural Networks
Ralf C. Staudemeyer, Eric Rothstein Morris
cs.NE, cs.CL, cs.LG
Long Short-Term Memory Recurrent Neural Networks (LSTM-RNN) are one of the most powerful dynamic classifiers publicly known. The network itself and the related learning algorithms are reasonably well documented to get an idea how it works. This paper will shed more light into understanding how LSTM-RNNs evolved and why they work impressively well, focusing on the early, ground-breaking publications. We significantly improved documentation and fixed a number of errors and inconsistencies that accumulated in previous publications. To support understanding we as well revised and unified the notation used.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1909.09586v1
2019-09-12T15:44:51
2019-09-12T15:44:51
{ "title": [ 0.00013637543, -0.000003695488, -0.04345703, -0.049560547, 0.0340271, -0.016555786, -0.006088257, -0.02041626, -0.011398315, 0.034423828, -0.0073242188, 0.0034217834, 0.0028266907, -0.029220581, -0.024017334, 0.010848999, 0.00062322617, 0.020309448, -0.029525757, -0.034820557, -0.030563354, -0.035308838, 0.047027588, 0.06311035, 0.035705566, -0.029327393, -0.060699463, 0.011367798, -0.043548584, -0.03652954, -0.0004863739, 0.026123047, 0.037902832, 0.015167236, 0.008613586, 0.012329102, -0.057281494, 0.017532349, -0.0028495789, 0.0033435822, 0.00011253357, 0.012130737, -0.04324341, -0.037231445, -0.04748535, -0.0006494522, -0.07122803, -0.012779236, -0.012397766, 0.067871094, 0.03237915, -0.00982666, -0.026260376, 0.059753418, 0.022445679, -0.034973145, -0.02734375, -0.010734558, 0.016479492, 0.07922363, 0.026626587, -0.030929565, 0.014343262, -0.028320312, -0.05908203, -0.00756073, -0.02078247, 0.040649414, 0.06008911, -0.027709961, -0.03555298, 0.023910522, -0.012435913, 0.008583069, -0.061401367, -0.008224487, 0.07293701, 0.017684937, 0.015075684, -0.02003479, 0.017715454, -0.029953003, -0.000019729137, -0.03842163, 0.02178955, -0.05114746, -0.008346558, 0.0029258728, -0.0138168335, -0.06542969, -0.012138367, 0.008934021, -0.018432617, 0.013023376, -0.034301758, -0.012626648, 0.0050468445, 0.016433716, -0.024963379, -0.026229858, -0.011520386, 0.011634827, -0.025161743, -0.004371643, 0.01701355, 0.025665283, -0.024459839, -0.029571533, 0.00983429, 0.03982544, -0.014961243, 0.03543091, 0.007575989, -0.0112838745, 0.006576538, 0.019439697, -0.012413025, 0.020843506, 0.01953125, 0.028213501, -0.0034217834, -0.045928955, 0.019973755, 0.0129852295, 0.0287323, 0.015594482, -0.06237793, 0.013580322, -0.019439697, 0.028778076, -0.002374649, 0.059020996, -0.09527588, -0.090270996, -0.076293945, 0.028869629, -0.0098724365, 0.0070495605, -0.0021743774, 0.0134887695, -0.009628296, -0.048461914, -0.01991272, 0.006351471, 0.006717682, 0.022460938, 0.06921387, -0.018630981, -0.043548584, -0.037200928, -0.021255493, 0.01285553, 0.038269043, 0.013587952, -0.06958008, 0.0146484375, -0.14294434, 0.0039100647, 0.006866455, 0.014190674, 0.03640747, 0.010597229, -0.026382446, 0.0014438629, 0.0435791, -0.029876709, -0.022232056, 0.036376953, -0.0063705444, 0.009307861, -0.0036296844, 0.018371582, -0.0023670197, -0.0064353943, 0.00223732, 0.00026607513, 0.02078247, -0.0048942566, 0.052001953, -0.02709961, -0.014320374, -0.023757935, 0.0066947937, 0.056793213, -0.049041748, -0.006340027, 0.006538391, 0.009422302, 0.051757812, 0.022872925, -0.057281494, 0.020645142, -0.015579224, -0.06213379, -0.054992676, -0.01436615, 0.05807495, 0.052978516, -0.006340027, 0.0074768066, -0.041046143, -0.0028629303, -0.016586304, 0.0027370453, 0.014923096, -0.010597229, -0.0047569275, 0.028030396, -0.015777588, 0.053344727, 0.0513916, 0.03717041, -0.028121948, -0.022216797, -0.014198303, -0.04498291, 0.020889282, -0.0087509155, -0.004096985, -0.00774765, -0.02810669, -0.005970001, -0.010856628, 0.060028076, 0.021697998, 0.017120361, -0.009490967, -0.02909851, 0.035186768, 0.038482666, 0.058502197, -0.048339844, 0.029525757, 0.0009975433, -0.02558899, -0.014518738, -0.018508911, 0.002609253, -0.002588272, 0.024383545, 0.0102005005, -0.01826477, -0.009536743, 0.031555176, 0.06726074, -0.0003311634, -0.0079193115, 0.014152527, 0.046905518, 0.03527832, 0.048950195, 0.016693115, 0.07147217, -0.008018494, 0.026062012, 0.06744385, 0.0058059692, 0.04031372, -0.029388428, -0.0033016205, -0.007133484, 0.005317688, -0.0005507469, 0.000364542, -0.03338623, 0.008552551, -0.03656006, -0.0019407272, -0.014144897, 0.029724121, 0.057922363, -0.017059326, 0.01979065, -0.006542206, -0.01852417, -0.033355713, -0.011245728, 0.007972717, 0.0068740845, -0.06121826, -0.019515991, 0.0051193237, 0.035491943, 0.021453857, 0.03439331, -0.018737793, 0.015556335, -0.0073051453, -0.017486572, -0.009353638, 0.030593872, 0.04989624, 0.0046157837, -0.00074863434, 0.026000977, 0.022521973, 0.07446289, 0.06744385, -0.031951904, 0.034179688, -0.04763794, 0.030563354, 0.014892578, -0.025848389, 0.01802063, 0.024429321, 0.034454346, 0.0096588135, -0.03982544, 0.024810791, -0.07751465, 0.010238647, 0.01222229, -0.029312134, -0.029815674, -0.04421997, -0.0031433105, -0.040649414, -0.025924683, -0.02331543, 0.064208984, -0.012031555, -0.0051651, -0.010932922, 0.0063934326, -0.027633667, -0.019317627, -0.03201294, -0.0057525635, 0.008514404, 0.050720215, 0.012565613, -0.05130005, -0.023117065, 0.0003464222, 0.019302368, -0.020187378, 0.034729004, -0.018554688, -0.0079193115, 0.003704071, -0.0027198792, 0.031311035, -0.037200928, -0.004096985, -0.026229858, 0.016357422, 0.024597168, -0.03010559, 0.011207581, 0.024627686, -0.02394104, -0.043121338, 0.027450562, 0.059265137, -0.034210205, -0.0061836243, 0.054870605, 0.04046631, -0.014076233, 0.012062073, -0.0031147003, -0.0074272156, -0.041015625, -0.0129776, -0.038513184, -0.02482605, 0.008552551, -0.0084991455, 0.05709839, -0.060272217, 0.0054626465, -0.025238037, -0.012794495, -0.015365601, 0.028121948, -0.015296936, -0.03866577, -0.022003174, -0.022247314, -0.0063056946, 0.0039100647, -0.006023407, -0.020889282, 0.07128906, -0.004299164, -0.02330017, 0.002046585, 0.04638672, 0.009048462, -0.0143966675, -0.029724121, -0.039733887, 0.024963379, 0.007904053, 0.0037403107, 0.0045814514, -0.027038574, -0.13684082, -0.0076904297, 0.039916992, 0.012016296, -0.03945923, 0.026977539, -0.069885254, 0.0231781, -0.0010204315, -0.017837524, 0.0357666, 0.042633057, 0.0007710457, 0.010910034, 0.026916504, -0.046539307, 0.018569946, -0.027038574, -0.08905029, 0.012870789, 0.0005917549, -0.0017375946, 0.005153656, -0.06866455, -0.052825928, -0.0009727478, 0.023513794, 0.0077552795, 0.028015137, -0.011947632, -0.0035057068, 0.0046806335, -0.007045746, -0.018676758, -0.032409668, -0.029571533, 0.02154541, 0.021530151, -0.015090942, 0.045532227, 0.0074043274, 0.017623901, -0.03955078, -0.011039734, 0.0124435425, 0.015556335, 0.011741638, -0.03189087, -0.003522873, -0.017944336, -0.0129776, 0.0037765503, -0.03225708, -0.0017948151, -0.029876709, 0.01612854, -0.026397705, 0.033355713, 0.014091492, 0.030044556, 0.0018815994, -0.010604858, 0.012062073, -0.03942871, -0.05001831, 0.025054932, 0.018310547, 0.010269165, 0.01965332, -0.006187439, -0.004940033, 0.007987976, -0.04763794, 0.01876831, 0.017578125, 0.010513306, -0.01612854, 0.011764526, -0.037475586, -0.0021953583, -0.016494751, 0.0473938, 0.0074005127, -0.0057029724, -0.04458618, -0.045928955, 0.0025253296, -0.012039185, -0.08251953, -0.019378662, 0.007083893, -0.04248047, -0.052459717, -0.066101074, 0.019348145, -0.029006958, -0.0423584, 0.01411438, -0.025863647, -0.049591064, -0.02986145, -0.06124878, -0.026412964, 0.06262207, 0.007522583, 0.037841797, 0.047058105, -0.018966675, -0.039764404, -0.03265381, 0.010925293, 0.020126343, 0.027359009, -0.007648468, 0.015182495, 0.059143066, -0.042236328, 0.02607727, 0.019638062, 0.031585693, -0.02104187, -0.004009247, 0.009025574, 0.0256958, -0.0154953, 0.03918457, -0.005176544, -0.0024795532, -0.07458496, 0.015991211, 0.002811432, 0.0016365051, 0.016647339, 0.0016517639, 0.013465881, 0.016021729, 0.004673004, 0.025222778, -0.026000977, 0.019821167, 0.047698975, -0.027648926, -0.017074585, 0.017669678, 0.0206604, 0.0043754578, -0.0052833557, 0.021713257, 0.022125244, 0.0413208, -0.0635376, -0.02861023, 0.007713318, 0.027999878, -0.03756714, -0.008430481, -0.064941406, -0.01826477, -0.019088745, 0.0065956116, -0.00094747543, 0.0035171509, 0.045715332, -0.032165527, -0.020736694, -0.004840851, -0.007499695, -0.0063095093, 0.0036697388, -0.058685303, -0.026763916, -0.018966675, -0.054138184, -0.037017822, -0.0060157776, -0.022140503, 0.014717102, 0.00092983246, 0.012489319, 0.00894928, 0.038024902, 0.08428955, 0.04751587, 0.0030460358, -0.07165527, 0.016067505, -0.005718231, -0.016799927, 0.0045814514, -0.019592285, -0.003829956, -0.038024902, -0.006652832, -0.015991211, -0.012969971, -0.01902771, 0.010169983, 0.012260437, 0.03036499, -0.015266418, 0.03237915, 0.014404297, 0.00090932846, 0.01335144, 0.0030403137, -0.026641846, -0.012565613, 0.035369873, 0.054473877, 0.025177002, -0.004863739, 0.047546387, 0.02218628, -0.014411926, 0.0104599, 0.01360321, 0.036224365, -0.01713562, -0.010299683, 0.028961182, -0.023544312, -0.021881104, 0.011947632, 0.010520935, 0.05783081, -0.053375244, 0.05065918, -0.03302002, -0.0006570816, 0.03024292, -0.016647339, -0.013885498, -0.0016174316, 0.013946533, -0.06378174, -0.05029297, -0.024963379, 0.054779053, -0.029006958, -0.005378723, -0.014480591, 0.0075798035, 0.012557983, 0.050231934, 0.03201294, -0.01449585, 0.015426636, -0.03652954, -0.022415161, -0.013153076, -0.04321289, 0.0024738312, 0.018112183, 0.01586914, -0.028244019, -0.019317627, -0.053649902, -0.035247803, 0.013137817, -0.006034851, 0.017074585, -0.070129395, 0.033966064, 0.083496094, -0.004600525, 0.02835083, -0.0019311905, 0.0023155212, 0.01889038, 0.030075073, 0.0065612793, 0.025772095, 0.01713562, -0.037322998, 0.01751709, -0.0074501038, 0.01210022, 0.01864624, 0.007835388, 0.010856628, 0.0050354004, -0.05319214, 0.02835083, -0.010803223, -0.029937744, 0.047332764, -0.060516357, 0.021057129, -0.012802124, -0.010047913, -0.005821228, -0.025344849, -0.052215576, -0.00007212162, -0.037750244, -0.036956787, 0.031951904, -0.021774292, -0.04043579, -0.045074463, 0.050628662, 0.009101868, -0.0011005402, -0.015716553, 0.015563965, -0.045806885, 0.02973938, 0.0075683594, -0.052612305, 0.005584717, -0.001200676, 0.013183594, 0.03894043, 0.029937744, -0.022262573, 0.0033721924, -0.019760132, -0.06341553, -0.02532959, 0.023803711, 0.005722046, -0.004890442, -0.0014381409, -0.028152466, 0.01902771, -0.00806427, 0.011474609, 0.025421143, -0.020065308, 0.035369873, 0.0015087128, -0.0058517456, 0.006324768, 0.019348145, -0.0031032562, -0.0013723373, 0.010757446, -0.03869629, 0.012123108, -0.009559631, 0.0132751465, -0.000113129616, -0.08441162, 0.01876831, 0.025848389, 0.03778076, 0.016830444, 0.039520264, 0.042816162, 0.008056641, -0.00793457, 0.03186035, 0.06567383, -0.07165527, -0.02986145, -0.021484375, -0.021347046, -0.05419922, 0.07147217, 0.0022411346, -0.021331787, -0.045135498, -0.048034668, -0.019607544, 0.0046424866, 0.037109375, 0.030670166, 0.057159424, -0.04611206, -0.014198303, -0.024917603, -0.011787415, -0.0063552856, 0.020614624, -0.013656616, -0.025238037, 0.01713562, -0.0019683838, -0.014152527, -0.0362854, 0.04486084, 0.013916016, -0.009773254, 0.020706177, -0.005882263, -0.004020691, -0.023071289, -0.010543823, 0.07208252, -0.013381958, 0.00040268898, 0.03692627, -0.02772522, 0.055511475, 0.027038574, 0.06286621, 0.074645996, 0.007095337, 0.010795593, -0.000020802021, 0.011260986, -0.0368042, 0.004310608, -0.021148682, 0.000011861324, -0.045196533, -0.018203735, -0.051483154, 0.015945435, 0.019714355, 0.017333984, -0.014526367, 0.013877869, -0.004749298, 0.010414124, 0.05795288, 0.0014181137, 0.055755615, 0.014526367, 0.016784668, -0.007881165, -0.012557983, -0.010604858, 0.024276733, 0.019317627, 0.0036182404, -0.020904541, 0.0063819885, -0.00969696, 0.02670288, 0.0010995865, -0.03262329, 0.0021972656, -0.03668213, 0.028961182, -0.020965576, 0.03050232, 0.06762695, 0.055725098, -0.03173828, -0.006061554, 0.010398865, -0.01725769, -0.025726318, 0.0015535355, 0.04824829, -0.09197998, 0.035705566, -0.028930664, -0.04107666, -0.02696228, 0.04159546, 0.01171875, -0.040161133, -0.022537231, -0.005039215, 0.04284668, 0.020812988, 0.020584106, -0.038238525, -0.0070343018, 0.023986816, 0.037963867, -0.012580872, 0.014640808, 0.032806396, 0.040496826, -0.0067749023, 0.002090454, -0.003112793, 0.022232056, -0.010185242, 0.028503418, -0.030593872, 0.04232788, 0.009109497, -0.054107666, 0.043670654, -0.0030536652, -0.054382324, -0.009971619, 0.012489319, 0.04324341, 0.03643799, 0.060180664, 0.0090789795, -0.02154541, -0.017852783, -0.044952393, 0.0335083, 0.03302002, -0.02519226, 0.01953125, -0.035858154, -0.028579712, 0.024169922, -0.03060913, 0.068725586, -0.025527954, 0.013015747, -0.0017242432, 0.023544312, 0.017120361, -0.046081543, -0.013183594, 0.0069084167, -0.013648987, -0.022888184, -0.010498047, -0.014762878, -0.039093018, -0.010818481, 0.059143066, 0.007774353, 0.0014104843, 0.00819397, -0.034423828, -0.055755615, 0.0069503784, -0.009773254, 0.038116455, -0.03793335, -0.0026798248, -0.024459839, 0.019729614, -0.0037727356, -0.022415161, -0.022583008, 0.034088135, -0.041290283, -0.011627197, 0.0024585724, 0.006134033, -0.02659607, -0.028640747, -0.024551392, 0.013946533, -0.024993896, -0.0335083, 0.04220581, -0.031402588, -0.037597656, -0.014892578, -0.0289917, 0.048034668, 0.027420044, -0.018692017, 0.004146576, 0.021377563, -0.02722168, -0.016708374, -0.0059165955, 0.036468506, -0.030593872, -0.023605347, -0.009643555, 0.028167725, 0.036590576, -0.081970215, -0.045776367, -0.013893127, 0.04058838, 0.011413574, 0.066711426, -0.006340027, -0.0010108948, 0.026107788, 0.0446167, 0.017547607, -0.048950195, -0.033935547, -0.049102783, 0.04736328, 0.039794922, -0.018295288, -0.023162842, 0.03881836, 0.0032157898, -0.0009908676, 0.026657104, 0.00049877167, 0.023223877, -0.0012702942, 0.038238525, -0.024917603, -0.023422241, -0.015342712, 0.01234436, -0.00932312, 0.038970947, -0.026229858, 0.012237549, -0.0033245087, 0.070495605, -0.019821167, -0.06726074, 0.05718994, 0.030593872, 0.0155181885, 0.04824829, -0.012275696, -0.012962341, 0.009414673, -0.0022640228, -0.0063819885, 0.021865845, 0.005958557, -0.027282715, 0.006450653, -0.033050537, -0.022384644, -0.0211792, -0.040222168, 0.06262207, -0.032592773, -0.016082764, -0.012893677, -0.0335083, -0.011550903, 0.018722534, 0.0003349781, -0.018325806, -0.046722412, -0.03768921, 0.033172607, -0.017196655 ], "summary": [ 0.006641388, -0.0010175705, -0.025375366, 0.01828003, -0.017150879, -0.029434204, 0.0063667297, -0.030395508, -0.03982544, 0.023391724, -0.004814148, -0.002981186, -0.025741577, -0.026107788, 0.0052452087, -0.047943115, 0.029022217, -0.0043258667, -0.01889038, -0.026931763, -0.019699097, -0.012481689, -0.016448975, 0.11981201, 0.03829956, -0.046722412, 0.0033054352, 0.0022335052, 0.016601562, 0.01285553, 0.02168274, -0.017150879, 0.0043411255, 0.00080013275, 0.039001465, -0.010520935, 0.0390625, -0.007587433, 0.028869629, -0.0035152435, -0.00037693977, -0.0038223267, 0.06188965, -0.099853516, 0.008552551, 0.048858643, -0.052764893, -0.04434204, 0.028198242, 0.0013217926, 0.0022945404, 0.014381409, 0.0073165894, -0.011627197, -0.019989014, -0.024246216, -0.018371582, -0.020965576, 0.019363403, 0.013946533, 0.014984131, 0.009681702, 0.025894165, 0.003484726, -0.010147095, -0.00063180923, 0.05783081, 0.0069618225, 0.008293152, -0.022521973, -0.008995056, 0.01638794, -0.022994995, -0.055389404, -0.01411438, 0.026626587, 0.01777649, -0.014907837, -0.020721436, 0.003435135, 0.04660034, -0.012557983, 0.016326904, -0.06347656, 0.04284668, -0.027038574, 0.0048446655, -0.0013456345, -0.002067566, -0.018569946, -0.012626648, -0.006008148, -0.036224365, 0.034088135, 0.0066184998, -0.032806396, -0.011039734, -0.04220581, 0.0054397583, -0.03302002, 0.026565552, -0.031585693, -0.023590088, 0.013786316, -0.030944824, -0.032073975, -0.011894226, -0.039123535, -0.019332886, 0.034362793, -0.05444336, -0.043823242, -0.015510559, -0.05596924, 0.013671875, 0.026153564, -0.037109375, 0.074157715, 0.033203125, 0.044525146, 0.0021839142, 0.018112183, -0.0041389465, 0.003540039, -0.00015163422, 0.012748718, -0.0048713684, -0.021713257, 0.018188477, 0.03125, 0.0015707016, 0.017440796, -0.062194824, -0.023269653, -0.057037354, -0.0065307617, -0.00415802, -0.0022449493, 0.024215698, -0.010643005, 0.048828125, -0.050842285, -0.027191162, 0.06378174, 0.021514893, 0.04156494, 0.027755737, -0.013572693, 0.010543823, -0.023284912, -0.008605957, -0.014221191, 0.0141067505, 0.0019989014, -0.019897461, -0.029953003, -0.03414917, -0.013580322, 0.04159546, -0.004611969, 0.08300781, 0.032348633, -0.025680542, 0.025756836, 0.0020942688, -0.07910156, -0.013122559, -0.00035119057, 0.018478394, -0.042419434, 0.024383545, 0.029006958, 0.0071907043, 0.0032043457, 0.023239136, 0.0064430237, -0.03717041, 0.017684937, 0.022994995, 0.0029735565, 0.01197052, -0.026351929, 0.022018433, 0.023071289, -0.021133423, 0.0014028549, 0.0025691986, 0.058166504, 0.053863525, 0.017791748, -0.051879883, -0.037109375, 0.04107666, -0.007865906, 0.0038833618, -0.004383087, -0.025421143, 0.024093628, -0.011665344, -0.04107666, -0.0066604614, -0.006504059, 0.0023269653, -0.019714355, -0.025787354, -0.009719849, -0.0015697479, 0.023361206, 0.038116455, 0.0146102905, -0.0079956055, -0.027786255, -0.005355835, 0.029022217, -0.053009033, -0.042297363, 0.032562256, -0.011756897, -0.019134521, -0.015434265, -0.033691406, -0.01638794, -0.03729248, 0.037353516, -0.014053345, 0.03112793, -0.047027588, 0.02947998, -0.011688232, 0.022155762, 0.01876831, 0.0065307617, -0.019256592, 0.022415161, -0.017745972, -0.02128601, -0.017868042, -0.051483154, 0.03302002, 0.031555176, 0.031280518, 0.01979065, -0.023803711, -0.031585693, 0.026382446, 0.006790161, 0.019943237, -0.04699707, 0.015403748, 0.020568848, -0.0040626526, -0.013061523, 0.02468872, -0.04208374, 0.020904541, 0.033813477, 0.012519836, 0.107543945, -0.022827148, 0.0074424744, -0.03967285, 0.025299072, 0.046051025, -0.020507812, 0.021987915, -0.040374756, -0.0049438477, -0.014099121, -0.005508423, -0.009841919, 0.027801514, -0.05529785, 0.009407043, 0.02128601, -0.010231018, -0.023361206, -0.017196655, 0.0037250519, -0.00027799606, 0.008071899, -0.017242432, -0.010223389, -0.008659363, -0.0015277863, 0.029205322, -0.010810852, 0.03189087, 0.016601562, 0.023345947, 0.07098389, 0.029022217, 0.08917236, 0.06896973, 0.009750366, 0.03640747, 0.042663574, 0.0143585205, 0.045440674, -0.0050735474, -0.01537323, -0.012649536, 0.019577026, -0.029144287, 0.0088272095, 0.029907227, 0.012046814, 0.06121826, -0.043548584, -0.0046653748, 0.066101074, -0.08984375, 0.0033016205, 0.015853882, 0.07092285, -0.04159546, -0.055145264, -0.0181427, 0.023330688, -0.012832642, 0.0008945465, 0.014663696, 0.042999268, 0.015464783, 0.0027656555, 0.035095215, -0.032104492, -0.009529114, -0.003528595, 0.022857666, -0.005279541, 0.006088257, 0.02861023, 0.010421753, 0.056671143, 0.01309967, -0.005405426, 0.01625061, 0.050994873, 0.011077881, -0.052642822, 0.034057617, 0.004058838, -0.002401352, 0.041809082, -0.021469116, 0.015457153, -0.008338928, 0.004547119, -0.0005207062, 0.012886047, -0.018356323, -0.02619934, -0.013374329, 0.022598267, 0.011726379, -0.04248047, 0.011924744, 0.040893555, -0.015838623, -0.036224365, 0.01939392, 0.01234436, 0.0039367676, -0.033355713, -0.05731201, -0.008369446, -0.00013661385, 0.031982422, -0.026641846, 0.032592773, -0.0340271, 0.028778076, -0.03338623, -0.026382446, -0.034576416, 0.028320312, 0.030426025, -0.015594482, 0.0029125214, 0.022720337, 0.0032539368, -0.0032176971, 0.0003004074, -0.044677734, -0.0010128021, 0.011138916, -0.04345703, -0.02935791, 0.026687622, 0.01449585, 0.0043525696, 0.0011034012, -0.035614014, -0.011474609, 0.022888184, 0.0004746914, -0.015098572, 0.0028152466, -0.06958008, -0.022567749, 0.031677246, -0.005393982, -0.019973755, 0.02130127, -0.030059814, 0.07824707, 0.02986145, -0.011764526, 0.01537323, 0.0057792664, 0.040008545, -0.060546875, 0.03842163, -0.046661377, 0.03692627, -0.035339355, -0.009223938, -0.015472412, -0.009048462, -0.006690979, 0.029403687, -0.03930664, 0.019714355, 0.018463135, 0.0692749, -0.00081539154, 0.033721924, -0.06976318, 0.020736694, 0.07556152, 0.026046753, 0.02217102, -0.009063721, -0.0052223206, -0.046691895, 0.008010864, -0.011260986, 0.0090789795, 0.0006875992, -0.036346436, 0.010429382, -0.008468628, -0.008407593, -0.0072898865, -0.009986877, -0.009757996, 0.005695343, -0.002714157, 0.06008911, 0.024017334, 0.0317688, -0.017196655, 0.0993042, -0.0042533875, -0.03262329, -0.04486084, -0.026473999, 0.017288208, 0.072143555, -0.027328491, -0.037078857, -0.019500732, 0.021224976, -0.008468628, -0.013557434, 0.004699707, -0.032318115, 0.016433716, -0.01776123, 0.010269165, -0.0020961761, 0.03930664, -0.00083875656, -0.022338867, -0.036193848, -0.040863037, 0.06262207, -0.0059547424, 0.03189087, -0.06933594, -0.041748047, 0.017852783, -0.12756348, -0.025024414, -0.016784668, -0.0041160583, -0.040985107, -0.05758667, 0.030883789, -0.07128906, -0.078308105, -0.079956055, 0.005836487, -0.031921387, 0.016174316, 0.028198242, -0.015686035, 0.090148926, -0.001250267, -0.048461914, 0.024536133, -0.02961731, 0.013580322, 0.032287598, -0.025100708, 0.016342163, 0.039093018, 0.0062294006, 0.01436615, -0.018997192, 0.035858154, -0.037139893, 0.059020996, 0.023666382, -0.0048942566, 0.018981934, -0.0051994324, 0.03591919, -0.019638062, -0.00920105, 0.039489746, 0.07495117, -0.017791748, 0.013542175, 0.0038051605, 0.029968262, -0.07342529, 0.01953125, -0.0034332275, -0.01134491, 0.046447754, 0.047729492, -0.015075684, -0.01499939, -0.011505127, -0.051849365, -0.029571533, -0.017578125, 0.045806885, 0.017044067, -0.0058021545, 0.010009766, -0.0048675537, 0.025054932, 0.0046424866, 0.018997192, 0.0317688, 0.035095215, -0.075805664, -0.011260986, 0.0004386902, 0.02255249, -0.064575195, -0.044006348, -0.024215698, -0.00982666, -0.02684021, 0.0054359436, -0.0043144226, -0.014678955, 0.006549835, 0.004634857, 0.020217896, -0.041290283, 0.050750732, 0.015823364, -0.017822266, -0.04736328, -0.07348633, -0.002691269, -0.03488159, 0.0002092123, 0.012962341, -0.025436401, -0.01751709, -0.0141067505, -0.0043525696, -0.0021381378, 0.046569824, 0.0769043, 0.034301758, -0.012031555, -0.0925293, -0.05355835, 0.0027256012, 0.046203613, -0.013259888, 0.03387451, -0.000269413, -0.0026779175, -0.04788208, 0.0055122375, 0.0026664734, 0.007255554, -0.017745972, 0.013320923, -0.034576416, -0.054870605, 0.018005371, -0.00541687, -0.016738892, -0.00856781, -0.014663696, -0.010101318, 0.04458618, 0.029678345, 0.001821518, 0.052093506, 0.008277893, 0.04736328, -0.02357483, -0.06085205, 0.017120361, 0.015335083, 0.013214111, 0.028137207, -0.004173279, 0.0022830963, 0.00012302399, -0.014160156, 0.03668213, -0.02609253, 0.03111267, 0.03466797, 0.02230835, -0.014907837, 0.018112183, 0.021484375, -0.011375427, -0.0010967255, -0.0071258545, -0.00844574, -0.044891357, -0.05014038, -0.0501709, 0.044189453, -0.010551453, -0.04248047, -0.024780273, 0.014480591, 0.016601562, 0.03451538, 0.03488159, -0.05831909, -0.0067977905, -0.0335083, -0.027023315, 0.002161026, -0.0052261353, 0.017868042, 0.05859375, 0.007419586, -0.048583984, -0.014045715, 0.025054932, 0.008026123, -0.015274048, -0.0043640137, 0.024414062, -0.0256958, -0.015205383, 0.051849365, -0.033477783, 0.027191162, 0.04916382, 0.027069092, -0.021331787, 0.015541077, -0.0033359528, 0.011398315, -0.0051231384, -0.03842163, 0.010955811, -0.030548096, 0.02029419, 0.023025513, 0.024841309, 0.02420044, 0.02848816, -0.056671143, 0.0033111572, -0.10235596, -0.015029907, -0.02154541, 0.014160156, -0.007369995, 0.0042037964, 0.028808594, -0.027923584, -0.029006958, -0.018661499, 0.044311523, -0.05456543, 0.011962891, 0.014823914, -0.06768799, -0.0056610107, -0.020126343, 0.029205322, -0.0335083, 0.028060913, -0.012672424, -0.05569458, -0.04248047, 0.00793457, -0.031036377, -0.040802002, -0.026992798, 0.047943115, 0.0362854, -0.010635376, -0.03878784, -0.044708252, -0.021255493, 0.01525116, -0.018859863, -0.02407837, 0.022750854, 0.008071899, -0.015090942, 0.008239746, 0.014801025, 0.019805908, -0.070495605, -0.018585205, 0.015655518, 0.013046265, 0.028793335, -0.025558472, -0.047973633, -0.006542206, -0.0007586479, -0.055633545, -0.008293152, 0.017333984, -0.002286911, 0.008399963, 0.04660034, 0.039245605, -0.0009508133, -0.07312012, 0.00447464, 0.03161621, 0.01878357, 0.05731201, 0.022476196, 0.033294678, 0.051818848, -0.03753662, 0.03753662, 0.014480591, -0.047668457, -0.029006958, -0.059539795, 0.00016367435, -0.095214844, -0.038482666, 0.030715942, 0.008544922, 0.012275696, -0.035949707, 0.019439697, 0.022537231, 0.036895752, 0.012084961, 0.054992676, -0.043029785, 0.010643005, -0.019577026, -0.036254883, -0.01828003, 0.03225708, -0.015975952, -0.041229248, 0.041503906, -0.035491943, -0.0048446655, -0.0023498535, 0.029083252, 0.0059165955, -0.014625549, 0.02079773, -0.017974854, 0.006000519, 0.000022351742, 0.027267456, 0.017105103, 0.0009889603, 0.024017334, 0.007949829, -0.005104065, 0.004447937, 0.014755249, 0.0149002075, -0.0071868896, -0.046905518, 0.017227173, 0.012680054, -0.029266357, -0.033203125, 0.013519287, 0.00039196014, 0.00010204315, -0.002878189, -0.020019531, -0.013595581, 0.064086914, 0.005378723, -0.02029419, 0.0025787354, 0.003616333, -0.029342651, 0.026107788, 0.021011353, 0.03704834, 0.014282227, -0.0031166077, 0.008514404, -0.03640747, -0.05783081, 0.03125, 0.046020508, 0.020233154, -0.002670288, -0.025054932, 0.0035552979, -0.015930176, 0.013938904, -0.041290283, -0.08294678, 0.014335632, -0.0552063, 0.0209198, 0.041809082, 0.03439331, -0.022491455, 0.01852417, -0.039886475, 0.045440674, -0.0017776489, 0.0036811829, -0.020370483, 0.029083252, 0.015594482, -0.00086021423, 0.0073547363, -0.015151978, -0.03161621, -0.0049552917, 0.0440979, 0.009971619, -0.022567749, 0.04095459, -0.01991272, -0.006465912, -0.006286621, -0.003944397, -0.032928467, -0.0066070557, 0.059509277, 0.021636963, -0.009132385, 0.0009317398, 0.02809143, -0.03387451, -0.003540039, -0.016906738, -0.009056091, 0.06750488, -0.026123047, 0.023147583, -0.0095825195, 0.053009033, 0.009895325, -0.027191162, 0.046325684, 0.017211914, -0.03591919, 0.01576233, 0.004020691, 0.006603241, 0.058654785, 0.023147583, -0.030288696, 0.009979248, 0.037597656, -0.039794922, 0.03125, 0.012191772, 0.016662598, -0.016052246, -0.016311646, 0.023117065, -0.028274536, 0.04812622, 0.0078125, -0.003030777, 0.020065308, -0.039398193, -0.002696991, -0.045196533, -0.022644043, 0.06750488, -0.025985718, -0.027404785, 0.0072364807, 0.041992188, 0.0024147034, 0.00074005127, -0.004917145, 0.013923645, 0.022460938, 0.023376465, 0.0362854, -0.019424438, 0.068725586, 0.03527832, 0.023208618, 0.07543945, -0.040496826, 0.0075569153, 0.016479492, 0.054382324, -0.03881836, -0.026428223, -0.0055274963, 0.101867676, -0.0095825195, -0.040863037, 0.010986328, -0.00028038025, -0.011726379, -0.026412964, -0.029846191, 0.016784668, -0.024154663, -0.02671814, 0.032470703, 0.020339966, -0.074035645, -0.031341553, 0.004299164, 0.0014696121, 0.0071105957, -0.010055542, 0.045776367, 0.0105896, -0.017852783, 0.011199951, 0.01360321, -0.0007224083, -0.01436615, -0.012863159, -0.0017328262, 0.006828308, 0.012237549, -0.05569458, 0.015586853, -0.0010795593, 0.053131104, 0.029632568, 0.02116394, -0.039886475, -0.008041382, 0.01802063, 0.04598999, 0.016021729, -0.027038574, 0.00030732155, -0.040100098, 0.044281006, 0.019332886, -0.02281189, -0.022094727, 0.019760132, 0.023208618, -0.035064697, 0.03439331, 0.0063552856, -0.023910522, 0.002401352, -0.014976501, -0.05444336, -0.019714355, -0.028808594, 0.012573242, -0.009269714, 0.016998291, -0.017700195, 0.020324707, 0.0010690689, 0.03744507, 0.00919342, 0.030670166, 0.015609741, 0.0070724487, 0.042633057, -0.051483154, 0.029449463, 0.011405945, -0.00843811, 0.015548706, 0.018051147, 0.029678345, -0.007259369, -0.000021755695, 0.019088745, -0.03543091, 0.019317627, -0.016494751, -0.014015198, 0.04510498, -0.07147217, -0.023956299, -0.0625, -0.019226074, 0.015899658, 0.0013008118, 0.010093689, -0.02281189, 0.006385803, 0.011657715, 0.0014219284, 0.01890564 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1507.05053v1
Massively Deep Artificial Neural Networks for Handwritten Digit Recognition
Keiron O'Shea
cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.NE
Greedy Restrictive Boltzmann Machines yield an fairly low 0.72% error rate on the famous MNIST database of handwritten digits. All that was required to achieve this result was a high number of hidden layers consisting of many neurons, and a graphics card to greatly speed up the rate of learning.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1507.05053v1
2015-07-17T17:48:49
2015-07-17T17:48:49
{ "title": [ -0.016448975, 0.005756378, -0.035308838, -0.040405273, 0.019500732, -0.012458801, -0.009559631, -0.009735107, 0.0018444061, 0.038360596, -0.032714844, 0.006290436, -0.003774643, -0.0068092346, -0.040130615, -0.0012645721, 0.0062446594, 0.03274536, -0.015136719, -0.032928467, 0.00008094311, -0.03225708, 0.046875, 0.04714966, 0.03933716, -0.058685303, -0.09851074, 0.018478394, -0.044158936, -0.040924072, -0.0076026917, 0.04156494, 0.04751587, 0.019485474, -0.006839752, 0.025497437, -0.052947998, 0.027496338, 0.012214661, -0.016647339, 0.0026226044, -0.0014925003, -0.028366089, -0.015419006, -0.04269409, 0.028152466, -0.09057617, -0.015823364, -0.026931763, 0.067871094, 0.030014038, 0.014228821, -0.020370483, 0.059326172, 0.031585693, -0.033599854, -0.042266846, 0.0016889572, 0.040527344, 0.08911133, 0.03390503, -0.05014038, -0.0018320084, -0.039031982, -0.046569824, -0.02017212, -0.028549194, 0.016693115, 0.07312012, -0.008354187, -0.012489319, 0.020889282, 0.0015077591, -0.014091492, -0.053222656, 0.021835327, 0.04574585, 0.022644043, 0.041625977, -0.049835205, 0.0060920715, -0.020462036, 0.00009983778, -0.012939453, 0.02128601, -0.02293396, -0.017929077, -0.014305115, -0.054016113, -0.056152344, -0.0062294006, -0.020202637, -0.035369873, 0.0007658005, -0.012565613, -0.022155762, -0.027069092, 0.013038635, 0.00059080124, 0.007297516, -0.0035324097, 0.011550903, 0.0013694763, -0.019592285, 0.011009216, 0.025680542, -0.022109985, -0.04522705, -0.010803223, 0.02394104, -0.030578613, -0.0020046234, 0.010650635, -0.026763916, 0.0011987686, 0.016326904, -0.0031280518, 0.0231781, 0.03491211, 0.01928711, 0.0006375313, -0.039001465, 0.012084961, 0.0027503967, 0.047973633, 0.014709473, -0.056274414, 0.007949829, 0.0039863586, 0.01890564, 0.00027823448, 0.045715332, -0.11273193, -0.092041016, -0.060699463, 0.047027588, -0.0082092285, 0.0073623657, -0.0050735474, 0.00029563904, 0.021194458, -0.02470398, -0.016159058, 0.033050537, -0.006626129, 0.018096924, 0.07122803, -0.007926941, -0.064208984, -0.0552063, -0.016067505, 0.010253906, 0.027435303, 0.016204834, -0.031234741, -0.005191803, -0.09564209, -0.030578613, 0.0074005127, 0.0044174194, 0.035949707, 0.0063438416, -0.011413574, 0.031143188, 0.070129395, -0.014518738, -0.024429321, 0.022918701, 0.009048462, -0.009056091, -0.009742737, 0.028930664, 0.042297363, 0.0008735657, -0.0046157837, 0.015541077, 0.041015625, 0.00076818466, 0.017959595, 0.010353088, 0.008796692, -0.027862549, 0.0022411346, 0.04272461, -0.060455322, -0.0074424744, 0.00025510788, 0.0037345886, 0.06665039, 0.011024475, -0.059906006, 0.009384155, -0.055725098, -0.03225708, -0.051635742, -0.016693115, 0.04034424, 0.032196045, -0.0018939972, 0.031555176, -0.037200928, -0.01171875, -0.026733398, 0.004699707, -0.009094238, -0.034301758, -0.017929077, 0.012336731, -0.033966064, 0.05316162, 0.058013916, 0.021652222, -0.036468506, 0.008522034, 0.0047798157, -0.066467285, 0.027313232, -0.00063085556, -0.009513855, -0.017181396, -0.056365967, 0.0030517578, -0.01550293, 0.038848877, 0.010513306, 0.011962891, -0.00818634, -0.02456665, 0.01600647, 0.03048706, 0.050231934, -0.02885437, 0.01638794, 0.022659302, -0.00026226044, -0.03717041, -0.004714966, -0.022628784, 0.030593872, 0.016815186, 0.004322052, -0.015380859, -0.0028858185, 0.027282715, 0.051452637, 0.0039253235, 0.011726379, 0.0044555664, 0.01751709, 0.01524353, 0.047912598, 0.024215698, 0.057647705, 0.0031414032, 0.017654419, 0.051361084, 0.01966858, 0.026107788, -0.025909424, 0.00074243546, -0.0042877197, 0.024963379, 0.0045280457, 0.017669678, -0.064453125, 0.011154175, -0.04812622, -0.008583069, 0.0006580353, 0.033355713, 0.042938232, -0.03604126, 0.016220093, -0.026916504, -0.025756836, -0.017959595, -0.01096344, 0.020233154, 0.012466431, -0.07196045, -0.015357971, -0.011772156, 0.023117065, 0.009613037, 0.02885437, -0.009590149, 0.015853882, -0.013442993, -0.022415161, -0.017181396, 0.046569824, 0.036102295, 0.01763916, -0.041168213, 0.014434814, 0.009941101, 0.062316895, 0.07366943, -0.020935059, 0.025421143, -0.057617188, 0.023010254, -0.003967285, -0.012435913, 0.0037994385, 0.02796936, 0.022399902, 0.026046753, -0.024505615, 0.015068054, -0.04989624, 0.010643005, 0.0029621124, -0.017333984, -0.04333496, -0.058807373, -0.0017709732, -0.054260254, -0.053009033, -0.020141602, 0.043273926, -0.036132812, -0.03756714, -0.018325806, -0.02003479, 0.0099487305, -0.027404785, -0.028427124, -0.027572632, 0.03225708, 0.050598145, 0.025756836, -0.052947998, -0.012573242, -0.0020503998, 0.024429321, -0.017303467, 0.026992798, -0.018417358, 0.0076904297, 0.009346008, -0.0013303757, 0.02571106, -0.054748535, -0.022979736, -0.03491211, 0.019119263, 0.024093628, -0.07965088, -0.01828003, 0.05795288, -0.038085938, -0.04055786, -0.006084442, 0.030517578, 0.027496338, 0.011444092, 0.0027256012, 0.024856567, -0.030578613, 0.025299072, 0.022659302, 0.0059547424, -0.03390503, -0.024124146, -0.052612305, 0.0016555786, -0.010261536, -0.00223732, 0.06713867, -0.049743652, -0.0031719208, -0.0104599, -0.014160156, 0.009132385, 0.0068969727, -0.021606445, -0.037597656, -0.026031494, -0.021270752, 0.00762558, 0.01550293, -0.0038967133, 0.006011963, 0.033355713, 0.01574707, -0.040222168, -0.014129639, 0.0236969, 0.007259369, -0.0056877136, 0.018218994, -0.025344849, 0.005783081, 0.028305054, 0.010398865, -0.010383606, -0.007320404, -0.12005615, -0.014595032, 0.02330017, 0.009101868, -0.026519775, 0.020111084, -0.056427002, -0.0023097992, -0.021697998, -0.021133423, 0.022644043, 0.072509766, 0.00415802, 0.010848999, 0.0040359497, -0.0014152527, 0.014801025, -0.025161743, -0.09423828, 0.024368286, -0.0234375, -0.033691406, -0.0021438599, -0.03265381, -0.059051514, -0.016906738, 0.0118637085, 0.03817749, 0.013252258, -0.010055542, 0.013969421, 0.0024261475, 0.0029888153, -0.019165039, -0.019332886, -0.026687622, -0.013954163, -0.010284424, -0.019958496, 0.032165527, 0.017929077, -0.008605957, -0.013313293, -0.009735107, -0.0027389526, 0.036621094, 0.01134491, -0.043426514, -0.0184021, -0.0040893555, -0.016418457, 0.021575928, -0.0067367554, 0.0010433197, -0.03024292, 0.012016296, -0.024734497, 0.003534317, 0.016235352, 0.0018396378, -0.0018196106, -0.03543091, 0.006088257, -0.028717041, -0.05633545, 0.009422302, 0.01537323, 0.007003784, 0.008071899, -0.021026611, -0.03552246, 0.0236969, -0.0340271, 0.014953613, 0.015571594, -0.016586304, -0.011955261, -0.0013504028, -0.005332947, -0.009674072, -0.014427185, 0.005504608, -0.0011806488, -0.0028591156, -0.023361206, -0.029876709, 0.011024475, -0.0044288635, -0.08013916, -0.008773804, 0.017944336, -0.025100708, -0.050231934, -0.046447754, 0.02368164, -0.02798462, -0.031051636, 0.03353882, -0.016708374, -0.034057617, -0.02243042, -0.06286621, -0.0395813, 0.08325195, 0.0059280396, 0.01725769, 0.040618896, 0.010055542, -0.049987793, -0.033203125, 0.0076293945, -0.016708374, 0.016738892, -0.011756897, -0.026672363, 0.0435791, -0.048919678, 0.01928711, 0.015777588, 0.02947998, -0.019851685, -0.011352539, 0.006225586, 0.0062065125, -0.020217896, 0.050048828, 0.015167236, -0.015991211, -0.080566406, 0.0044059753, 0.0015287399, -0.008766174, 0.023849487, -0.01525116, 0.04055786, 0.027740479, -0.0149383545, 0.0680542, -0.012359619, -0.004386902, 0.04034424, -0.03189087, -0.009735107, 0.0023155212, 0.018981934, 0.009712219, 0.0033054352, 0.043395996, 0.0047302246, 0.048675537, -0.025924683, -0.025802612, 0.009902954, 0.02027893, -0.03579712, -0.017715454, -0.07684326, -0.041259766, -0.020370483, 0.02293396, -0.00680542, -0.00756073, 0.04711914, -0.0010271072, -0.028442383, -0.0032997131, 0.045654297, -0.008758545, 0.011726379, -0.053527832, 0.02494812, -0.022964478, -0.055389404, -0.04397583, 0.020736694, 0.00034856796, 0.03756714, -0.016357422, -0.01335907, 0.013824463, 0.016189575, 0.05633545, 0.039916992, -0.009895325, -0.05041504, 0.040893555, -0.030838013, -0.014831543, 0.026062012, -0.013191223, -0.0075798035, -0.028640747, 0.004878998, -0.016311646, -0.001332283, -0.040893555, 0.0132369995, -0.0037174225, 0.011642456, -0.017974854, 0.024765015, 0.009094238, 0.0024909973, 0.026382446, 0.021392822, -0.03225708, -0.047546387, 0.019561768, 0.03527832, -0.011810303, 0.01309967, 0.04840088, 0.011276245, -0.018981934, 0.021759033, 0.01550293, 0.046844482, -0.0063323975, 0.0047340393, 0.016571045, -0.06591797, -0.039245605, -0.0063934326, 0.0030593872, 0.058532715, -0.052947998, 0.055267334, -0.012817383, -0.00024461746, 0.020065308, -0.013504028, 0.006088257, -0.02128601, 0.022399902, -0.06665039, -0.06500244, -0.022201538, 0.05908203, -0.02267456, 0.0075950623, 0.0025577545, 0.01638794, 0.026153564, 0.046173096, 0.03564453, 0.0051841736, -0.01083374, -0.015205383, 0.0023937225, -0.02671814, -0.054016113, 0.014945984, -0.02218628, 0.0029525757, -0.039611816, -0.001543045, -0.06573486, -0.027160645, -0.003332138, -0.017166138, 0.013031006, -0.0803833, 0.014305115, 0.06774902, 0.0011873245, 0.022598267, 0.015838623, 0.019317627, 0.03326416, 0.042388916, 0.02468872, 0.019119263, 0.01373291, -0.024780273, 0.027954102, 0.0009088516, 0.030899048, 0.0058174133, 0.0046043396, 0.010124207, 0.012939453, -0.052368164, 0.02772522, 0.009117126, -0.028060913, 0.054718018, -0.06402588, 0.013320923, -0.003736496, -0.0045661926, 0.010772705, -0.027236938, -0.008331299, 0.022018433, -0.024246216, -0.019104004, 0.022506714, -0.013076782, -0.025054932, -0.06768799, 0.017227173, -0.017837524, -0.005393982, -0.008728027, 0.025817871, -0.040618896, 0.036254883, 0.02458191, -0.06915283, -0.008758545, 0.0066833496, 0.02394104, 0.04638672, 0.007835388, -0.042175293, 0.001244545, -0.0051841736, -0.04812622, -0.03439331, 0.024795532, 0.016296387, -0.016708374, -0.00422287, -0.035186768, 0.012710571, 0.0016260147, 0.02330017, -0.007926941, -0.013656616, 0.017700195, 0.011062622, 0.014877319, -0.006465912, 0.033569336, -0.000027179718, -0.0032367706, 0.012252808, -0.03744507, 0.023483276, -0.016021729, 0.019592285, -0.009284973, -0.06762695, 0.013206482, 0.017196655, 0.028793335, 0.006877899, 0.015914917, 0.033569336, 0.0029277802, 0.014015198, 0.03225708, 0.085632324, -0.052978516, -0.030029297, -0.008338928, 0.0047073364, -0.026351929, 0.064208984, -0.019104004, -0.028381348, -0.0390625, -0.07598877, -0.040527344, 0.011238098, 0.048065186, 0.02104187, 0.05645752, -0.07269287, -0.011688232, -0.043151855, -0.0209198, -0.02684021, 0.012649536, -0.013549805, -0.016983032, 0.032470703, -0.018066406, 0.0019626617, -0.029083252, 0.035461426, -0.006504059, -0.01020813, -0.0040779114, -0.012893677, 0.020202637, -0.026489258, -0.03845215, 0.041107178, 0.00095033646, -0.0095825195, 0.04840088, -0.020004272, 0.06439209, -0.0006542206, 0.052215576, 0.059020996, 0.0030879974, -0.006515503, -0.010116577, -0.004535675, -0.06121826, -0.0019836426, -0.03527832, -0.01878357, -0.061431885, -0.026382446, -0.05380249, -0.007980347, 0.018676758, 0.03640747, 0.021896362, 0.014816284, 0.0037612915, -0.01939392, 0.051116943, 0.0006737709, 0.06317139, 0.011665344, 0.013092041, 0.004196167, -0.024917603, 0.018463135, 0.036132812, -0.0015974045, 0.016479492, 0.006954193, -0.024627686, 0.006149292, 0.03564453, 0.015853882, -0.024383545, -0.0143966675, -0.035186768, 0.050231934, 0.0015678406, 0.03857422, 0.05307007, 0.036743164, 0.0008583069, -0.024917603, 0.0010490417, 0.004589081, -0.013458252, 0.0020065308, 0.038238525, -0.043029785, 0.024383545, -0.014907837, -0.029434204, -0.023162842, 0.043395996, 0.016281128, -0.040985107, -0.029449463, 0.022491455, 0.038330078, 0.015296936, 0.005645752, -0.042816162, 0.007232666, 0.025283813, 0.031280518, -0.011253357, -0.017242432, 0.01234436, 0.023712158, -0.00031876564, -0.010025024, 0.012290955, 0.035125732, 0.011276245, 0.03894043, -0.037963867, 0.028549194, -0.008659363, -0.03781128, -0.008049011, 0.018478394, -0.06921387, -0.024353027, 0.05618286, 0.03945923, 0.068481445, 0.0848999, 0.030776978, -0.0075035095, -0.0032138824, -0.06262207, 0.038360596, 0.021957397, -0.029144287, 0.0047454834, -0.022064209, -0.02267456, 0.033843994, -0.0031585693, 0.095214844, -0.030715942, -0.0008401871, -0.01777649, 0.030883789, 0.023071289, -0.045013428, 0.0023841858, -0.02168274, -0.01499939, -0.024414062, -0.015457153, -0.0025615692, -0.034698486, -0.0020561218, 0.050598145, 0.022994995, 0.006122589, -0.01600647, -0.035186768, -0.04763794, 0.018600464, -0.013900757, 0.055633545, -0.0178833, 0.00258255, -0.0074539185, -0.0039596558, -0.008293152, -0.033355713, -0.029403687, -0.0011787415, -0.021408081, -0.021072388, 0.01626587, 0.03048706, -0.018997192, -0.0113220215, -0.088256836, 0.017654419, -0.034423828, -0.005836487, 0.013999939, -0.057006836, 0.014549255, 0.013191223, -0.037506104, 0.035308838, 0.042236328, -0.004714966, -0.006477356, 0.022064209, -0.03173828, -0.007671356, 0.027236938, 0.058135986, 0.000035643578, -0.03894043, -0.00365448, 0.04458618, 0.056732178, -0.061828613, -0.03744507, 0.008758545, 0.016479492, -0.010101318, 0.054260254, 0.003419876, -0.0022010803, 0.019973755, 0.028289795, 0.017150879, -0.03567505, -0.015106201, -0.01550293, 0.04373169, 0.059692383, -0.014755249, 0.008651733, 0.03665161, -0.02217102, -0.0041389465, 0.0119018555, 0.017852783, 0.008239746, -0.0004968643, 0.03741455, -0.028839111, -0.02217102, -0.015556335, 0.031219482, -0.01713562, 0.019165039, -0.011810303, 0.00085544586, -0.00078487396, 0.052368164, -0.037109375, -0.06378174, 0.0552063, 0.028366089, 0.007255554, 0.026611328, -0.019897461, -0.014030457, -0.005645752, -0.007331848, 0.0017614365, 0.017288208, 0.025787354, -0.059753418, 0.011436462, -0.042816162, -0.044677734, -0.037719727, -0.051971436, 0.062072754, -0.043395996, -0.0049209595, -0.027130127, -0.013587952, -0.017944336, 0.017913818, 0.005153656, -0.030181885, -0.04208374, -0.048431396, 0.05114746, -0.022537231 ], "summary": [ -0.033325195, -0.002029419, 0.0007891655, 0.066223145, -0.024963379, 0.0071258545, 0.01550293, -0.039489746, 0.041778564, 0.01374054, -0.08166504, 0.019363403, 0.013504028, -0.0055885315, -0.0021514893, -0.032287598, 0.0015974045, 0.034729004, -0.0059127808, -0.023666382, 0.001958847, -0.0055618286, -0.011795044, 0.014312744, 0.035186768, -0.014480591, -0.03567505, 0.008399963, -0.024520874, -0.015220642, -0.009094238, 0.061950684, 0.030059814, -0.013160706, 0.041412354, 0.074157715, 0.008666992, -0.003829956, 0.009941101, 0.032928467, -0.004096985, 0.002998352, 0.040649414, -0.026504517, -0.012588501, 0.016708374, -0.026763916, -0.04095459, 0.013160706, -0.015052795, 0.026763916, -0.0048103333, 0.036254883, 0.00072336197, -0.02279663, -0.0033626556, -0.017456055, -0.0077705383, 0.03994751, -0.017166138, -0.008552551, -0.020324707, 0.02835083, -0.006713867, -0.025772095, -0.011398315, -0.017486572, 0.010719299, -0.005680084, -0.022277832, 0.018676758, -0.006385803, 0.009780884, -0.01902771, -0.030776978, -0.0040664673, 0.023391724, 0.010803223, 0.0023097992, -0.014411926, 0.019119263, 0.0031394958, 0.01637268, 0.0058021545, -0.038970947, 0.015701294, -0.016098022, -0.018463135, -0.026947021, -0.021316528, -0.013557434, -0.017547607, -0.051513672, 0.02154541, 0.015541077, -0.033325195, 0.0054130554, -0.032318115, 0.0022029877, -0.009429932, 0.02029419, -0.030471802, 0.002483368, 0.0048599243, 0.02859497, -0.012863159, -0.07171631, -0.066833496, 0.055877686, 0.048706055, -0.010650635, 0.023376465, -0.04083252, -0.07086182, -0.00077819824, 0.03161621, -0.05722046, 0.020843506, 0.02029419, -0.006477356, -0.011047363, -0.008613586, 0.008033752, 0.035308838, -0.009506226, 0.0032920837, -0.009208679, -0.007827759, 0.02420044, 0.049316406, -0.0060577393, -0.0024356842, -0.033325195, -0.022262573, -0.045776367, -0.024780273, -0.008102417, 0.014930725, 0.0025043488, -0.017242432, 0.04623413, -0.0035648346, 0.016357422, 0.008232117, 0.007003784, 0.04714966, 0.026000977, -0.007385254, -0.02470398, -0.0592041, 0.012145996, -0.0073242188, 0.0027866364, 0.01737976, 0.0031528473, -0.010131836, -0.042419434, 0.010398865, 0.041992188, 0.024841309, 0.07397461, 0.012649536, -0.016281128, 0.09466553, 0.04647827, -0.010406494, 0.0071029663, 0.0087890625, 0.004108429, -0.05923462, -0.0021438599, 0.0000551939, 0.05831909, -0.016937256, 0.006011963, 0.025024414, 0.03152466, 0.0011453629, -0.009033203, 0.07775879, 0.032196045, -0.017654419, -0.0018482208, 0.012214661, 0.016738892, -0.01889038, -0.0178833, -0.0016107559, 0.04147339, 0.015388489, -0.06085205, -0.015090942, 0.032440186, 0.0055618286, -0.01322937, -0.059692383, 0.022705078, 0.00504303, -0.016693115, 0.0047683716, -0.013969421, -0.004535675, 0.019592285, -0.018096924, -0.006629944, -0.0065345764, -0.011207581, 0.028701782, -0.051208496, -0.007762909, 0.035064697, -0.038879395, -0.034240723, 0.055847168, 0.024230957, -0.020462036, -0.029388428, 0.030334473, -0.011390686, 0.010360718, -0.040985107, -0.001282692, -0.014854431, -0.005176544, -0.012458801, 0.0340271, -0.032440186, 0.01890564, -0.023834229, 0.016342163, 0.011245728, 0.030288696, -0.043701172, 0.06652832, 0.009712219, -0.020355225, -0.0045166016, -0.031051636, 0.05731201, 0.0043182373, 0.022140503, 0.038391113, -0.024902344, -0.015838623, 0.033325195, 0.014778137, 0.040374756, -0.026168823, -0.0110321045, 0.009292603, 0.029205322, 0.0075683594, 0.026412964, -0.044403076, -0.0026798248, 0.026809692, -0.027786255, 0.049804688, 0.021697998, -0.01637268, -0.012832642, 0.078186035, 0.06512451, 0.00856781, -0.05899048, 0.01737976, -0.008453369, -0.002445221, 0.018814087, 0.00063323975, 0.002521515, -0.0569458, 0.0024166107, -0.05038452, -0.08703613, -0.011138916, -0.03387451, 0.07159424, 0.007129669, -0.068115234, 0.029037476, 0.01134491, 0.048217773, 0.017730713, 0.016830444, -0.0013923645, 0.041290283, 0.0713501, -0.0063209534, 0.070251465, 0.06854248, 0.05883789, 0.03451538, -0.009986877, -0.013427734, 0.038848877, 0.012283325, 0.015548706, 0.012275696, -0.004890442, 0.027755737, 0.04171753, -0.0031929016, -0.0063056946, 0.014228821, 0.0635376, 0.013725281, 0.02494812, 0.023910522, -0.016296387, -0.004676819, 0.012321472, 0.025558472, 0.019561768, -0.0042495728, -0.023284912, -0.017242432, 0.0121536255, -0.024597168, 0.004016876, 0.06304932, 0.075927734, -0.037628174, 0.018371582, 0.028167725, -0.023086548, -0.007835388, -0.034301758, 0.052764893, -0.02218628, -0.044555664, 0.011268616, -0.040771484, 0.026443481, 0.0059280396, -0.0025749207, 0.011955261, 0.09057617, 0.004600525, -0.06536865, 0.004802704, 0.019561768, -0.006919861, 0.031951904, -0.07287598, 0.02519226, 0.002248764, 0.005405426, -0.04135132, -0.032440186, 0.045715332, -0.02357483, -0.023773193, 0.003894806, -0.006717682, 0.020889282, 0.033691406, 0.01675415, 0.031707764, -0.018692017, -0.0051002502, 0.06048584, 0.017486572, -0.045837402, -0.047027588, -0.054992676, 0.02809143, -0.00009602308, 0.058746338, 0.029968262, -0.011482239, 0.06185913, -0.012611389, -0.0020561218, 0.020004272, -0.035980225, 0.05557251, -0.02268982, -0.0034618378, 0.019943237, -0.00031280518, -0.000197649, 0.0046310425, -0.02468872, 0.0309906, -0.017181396, -0.019851685, 0.029510498, 0.024978638, 0.019104004, -0.007949829, -0.005264282, 0.050354004, -0.026916504, -0.050842285, -0.0018262863, -0.005130768, -0.064453125, 0.025939941, 0.010002136, 0.03137207, -0.00023341179, -0.0042266846, -0.005455017, 0.0035495758, -0.038635254, 0.026412964, -0.010925293, -0.008201599, 0.06274414, 0.033447266, -0.07543945, 0.05407715, -0.07147217, 0.060760498, -0.031402588, -0.06842041, -0.016967773, -0.02659607, 0.049346924, 0.0017614365, 0.024459839, -0.043945312, 0.012268066, 0.0012865067, -0.0077819824, -0.003250122, -0.010673523, -0.012031555, 0.062194824, -0.0029277802, 0.0102005005, -0.027023315, -0.0064048767, 0.0027675629, 0.0052833557, -0.006729126, -0.0413208, 0.007865906, -0.025009155, -0.055389404, -0.048461914, -0.04888916, -0.0039138794, -0.0040130615, -0.030349731, -0.05368042, -0.049468994, 0.054138184, 0.0009365082, 0.0008497238, -0.014717102, 0.005405426, -0.0012216568, -0.033447266, 0.039367676, -0.040893555, -0.0044670105, 0.037231445, 0.004131317, -0.023666382, 0.0023994446, 0.021469116, -0.015037537, 0.039001465, -0.032562256, -0.0029659271, 0.008262634, 0.009963989, -0.018753052, -0.009536743, 0.042236328, 0.018569946, -0.023223877, -0.013900757, -0.06536865, 0.040863037, 0.006011963, 0.015823364, -0.061584473, -0.02305603, 0.0021648407, 0.014595032, 0.023254395, 0.0015649796, 0.006996155, -0.022491455, -0.014480591, 0.00919342, -0.0029411316, -0.030685425, 0.008285522, 0.045898438, -0.02583313, 0.016998291, 0.021621704, 0.00045776367, 0.04989624, 0.015098572, -0.064453125, -0.004638672, 0.0036201477, -0.001241684, -0.004142761, 0.010070801, 0.015594482, -0.03164673, -0.013221741, 0.011985779, -0.023788452, -0.018173218, -0.03253174, 0.04586792, 0.034088135, -0.028076172, 0.04949951, -0.037628174, 0.016098022, -0.02810669, -0.0035953522, 0.043273926, 0.081848145, -0.050109863, -0.004825592, 0.088134766, -0.010520935, -0.061065674, 0.03829956, 0.019012451, -0.036193848, -0.0045280457, -0.022216797, 0.024719238, 0.070495605, -0.008911133, 0.031433105, -0.009117126, -0.0068855286, 0.020126343, 0.01637268, 0.00044751167, 0.0012302399, 0.007297516, 0.01361084, 0.013214111, -0.024932861, 0.03768921, 0.024978638, -0.022460938, -0.013122559, 0.007259369, 0.032348633, 0.008872986, -0.035888672, -0.059539795, -0.008659363, -0.009178162, 0.00045847893, 0.007896423, 0.008850098, 0.02218628, -0.01878357, -0.014457703, 0.015853882, -0.018554688, 0.016433716, -0.032440186, -0.043518066, 0.06201172, -0.012939453, -0.009674072, -0.028167725, 0.045166016, -0.012878418, 0.00082302094, -0.03857422, -0.008766174, 0.012481689, 0.012992859, 0.07098389, 0.05718994, 0.0019664764, -0.081604004, 0.005130768, -0.03918457, -0.049926758, 0.032714844, -0.07409668, -0.023529053, -0.037139893, 0.07696533, -0.011993408, -0.025299072, -0.061523438, -0.0014371872, 0.03302002, 0.013183594, -0.010002136, -0.02027893, 0.008346558, -0.056549072, 0.022949219, 0.013069153, -0.00894165, 0.033813477, 0.07879639, -0.069885254, 0.06933594, 0.0028324127, 0.012496948, -0.02798462, -0.0066986084, -0.0072250366, 0.009803772, -0.023498535, -0.021591187, 0.067993164, -0.008430481, -0.005748749, -0.023147583, 0.031585693, 0.04071045, 0.034332275, -0.0016269684, 0.007888794, -0.020523071, 0.0044441223, 0.037841797, -0.006439209, -0.016296387, 0.031066895, -0.010398865, -0.04547119, -0.028182983, 0.011894226, 0.034210205, -0.007827759, -0.004673004, -0.021026611, -0.016616821, 0.044433594, 0.035705566, 0.015220642, -0.06970215, -0.03765869, -0.014793396, -0.032684326, -0.04434204, -0.009544373, 0.011268616, -0.035949707, -0.0074424744, 0.011222839, -0.03540039, 0.0056915283, 0.003047943, -0.04232788, 0.020401001, -0.007133484, -0.00097465515, -0.050964355, 0.0030765533, -0.0062789917, 0.010192871, -0.008743286, -0.011001587, 0.013442993, 0.014266968, -0.010154724, -0.0085372925, 0.0063972473, 0.0044937134, 0.05517578, -0.040008545, 0.017562866, 0.05886841, -0.051727295, 0.026687622, 0.036346436, -0.023483276, -0.008148193, -0.008773804, 0.053497314, 0.0096588135, -0.03414917, -0.0006222725, 0.0126571655, 0.0048713684, -0.00017213821, -0.02067566, 0.04598999, 0.089416504, -0.016326904, 0.03829956, 0.001791954, -0.024459839, -0.019485474, 0.011642456, 0.023147583, -0.029724121, -0.016708374, 0.015670776, -0.017471313, -0.009590149, 0.00029563904, -0.004146576, -0.055603027, -0.02029419, 0.014518738, 0.03543091, -0.01966858, -0.042144775, -0.0158844, -0.010620117, 0.016326904, 0.0037384033, 0.030715942, -0.011405945, -0.016998291, 0.012161255, 0.044525146, 0.022521973, 0.059936523, -0.026916504, 0.039215088, -0.03253174, 0.05883789, 0.058410645, -0.0058059692, -0.010147095, 0.01285553, -0.018463135, -0.05596924, 0.012878418, 0.03781128, -0.048217773, 0.0031757355, 0.024139404, 0.0357666, -0.043029785, -0.019882202, -0.025390625, 0.04525757, 0.009162903, 0.036315918, -0.020080566, -0.010276794, 0.03366089, 0.030090332, 0.008804321, 0.085754395, -0.009155273, -0.011756897, -0.01259613, 0.022140503, -0.037384033, 0.002313614, 0.025268555, 0.007457733, -0.023468018, -0.05706787, 0.0023002625, -0.016326904, -0.0027256012, 0.020828247, 0.015357971, -0.057037354, -0.020690918, -0.013793945, -0.011177063, -0.005680084, 0.00982666, -0.023788452, -0.054351807, 0.05831909, 0.004337311, 0.018295288, -0.002336502, 0.015823364, -0.049041748, -0.021972656, -0.017089844, -0.009864807, 0.042663574, -0.02720642, 0.039978027, 0.019622803, 0.03161621, -0.0079422, 0.014213562, -0.0056266785, 0.027862549, 0.010597229, -0.033569336, -0.034484863, -0.01524353, 0.024169922, -0.0026836395, -0.0096206665, -0.008155823, -0.010017395, 0.018035889, -0.021865845, -0.018218994, -0.03427124, -0.028411865, 0.05407715, -0.012748718, -0.004146576, 0.027389526, 0.013320923, -0.004047394, -0.016967773, -0.025115967, -0.023498535, 0.00097608566, 0.00060224533, -0.012374878, 0.041137695, -0.015472412, -0.0072135925, 0.02835083, -0.0020866394, 0.01637268, 0.033050537, -0.013786316, 0.05307007, 0.0034542084, -0.026306152, -0.05368042, 0.03289795, -0.049987793, 0.046875, 0.050750732, 0.048217773, -0.0077209473, -0.0047302246, 0.023040771, -0.012771606, -0.0023288727, -0.0047187805, -0.019119263, 0.045318604, -0.0012598038, -0.022064209, 0.05706787, 0.023620605, -0.029891968, 0.016235352, 0.045440674, 0.031463623, -0.01626587, 0.031341553, -0.020248413, 0.00844574, 0.008682251, -0.0035552979, -0.0546875, -0.05834961, 0.020080566, 0.006538391, -0.035705566, -0.018295288, 0.07318115, -0.027130127, -0.029296875, -0.033843994, -0.00598526, 0.0236969, 0.004776001, 0.032043457, -0.019241333, 0.103759766, 0.019195557, -0.011054993, 0.04171753, 0.02468872, -0.07879639, 0.037506104, 0.05682373, 0.072143555, 0.09136963, 0.07659912, -0.045959473, 0.01852417, 0.0847168, -0.023452759, 0.040252686, -0.015174866, 0.019424438, -0.01600647, -0.026382446, 0.011375427, -0.016601562, 0.005493164, 0.032806396, -0.03274536, -0.0023727417, -0.024398804, 0.009101868, -0.039794922, 0.007396698, 0.015113831, -0.032562256, 0.0052833557, -0.005405426, 0.025360107, -0.021270752, -0.03781128, -0.008460999, 0.055603027, -0.0013389587, -0.0040283203, 0.04220581, -0.025283813, -0.05328369, 0.041229248, 0.011505127, 0.06616211, -0.008155823, -0.013755798, 0.019973755, 0.008613586, -0.00017619133, -0.035949707, -0.024810791, 0.018875122, -0.0015687943, -0.0231781, -0.019577026, -0.020217896, -0.035858154, -0.020462036, -0.08538818, 0.03137207, -0.03604126, -0.020355225, 0.019363403, -0.007648468, -0.0062408447, -0.00970459, -0.042236328, 0.0041236877, 0.016662598, -0.0037612915, -0.01309967, 0.0423584, -0.05407715, -0.03817749, -0.005306244, 0.021713257, 0.01852417, -0.024963379, 0.017288208, 0.006477356, 0.055541992, 0.0020771027, -0.010643005, -0.0044784546, -0.038604736, 0.003868103, -0.0418396, -0.012382507, -0.020553589, -0.036956787, 0.033203125, -0.011489868, -0.0029182434, 0.024459839, 0.0014925003, 0.021331787, -0.0048332214, -0.01727295, -0.0022068024, 0.0046844482, -0.019851685, -0.04550171, 0.042907715, 0.031173706, -0.020385742, 0.024963379, 0.035614014, -0.054992676, -0.036895752, 0.01713562, -0.009864807, 0.002735138, 0.016159058, 0.0038547516, -0.012031555, 0.0037975311, 0.038024902, -0.009857178, 0.012756348, 0.0032310486, 0.00038933754, 0.024902344, -0.022583008, 0.022903442, 0.0058250427, -0.013557434, -0.019714355, 0.010658264, 0.00283432, 0.036102295, -0.097595215, -0.020111084, -0.034484863, 0.0034236908, 0.008743286, -0.014091492, 0.041259766, -0.064819336, 0.0054130554, -0.06298828, 0.027008057, 0.014350891, 0.014251709, 0.033111572, 0.0059661865, 0.0023021698, -0.0713501, -0.0056915283, 0.00038337708 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1907.01368v1
Pathologist-Level Grading of Prostate Biopsies with Artificial Intelligence
Peter Ström, Kimmo Kartasalo, Henrik Olsson, Leslie Solorzano, Brett Delahunt, Daniel M. Berney, David G. Bostwick, Andrew J. Evans, David J. Grignon, Peter A. Humphrey, Kenneth A. Iczkowski, James G. Kench, Glen Kristiansen, Theodorus H. van der Kwast, Katia R. M. Leite, Jesse K. McKenney, Jon Oxley, Chin-Chen Pan, Hemamali Samaratunga, John R. Srigley, Hiroyuki Takahashi, Toyonori Tsuzuki, Murali Varma, Ming Zhou, Johan Lindberg, Cecilia Bergström, Pekka Ruusuvuori, Carolina Wählby, Henrik Grönberg, Mattias Rantalainen, Lars Egevad, Martin Eklund
cs.CV, cs.AI, eess.IV
Background: An increasing volume of prostate biopsies and a world-wide shortage of uro-pathologists puts a strain on pathology departments. Additionally, the high intra- and inter-observer variability in grading can result in over- and undertreatment of prostate cancer. Artificial intelligence (AI) methods may alleviate these problems by assisting pathologists to reduce workload and harmonize grading. Methods: We digitized 6,682 needle biopsies from 976 participants in the population based STHLM3 diagnostic study to train deep neural networks for assessing prostate biopsies. The networks were evaluated by predicting the presence, extent, and Gleason grade of malignant tissue for an independent test set comprising 1,631 biopsies from 245 men. We additionally evaluated grading performance on 87 biopsies individually graded by 23 experienced urological pathologists from the International Society of Urological Pathology. We assessed discriminatory performance by receiver operating characteristics (ROC) and tumor extent predictions by correlating predicted millimeter cancer length against measurements by the reporting pathologist. We quantified the concordance between grades assigned by the AI and the expert urological pathologists using Cohen's kappa. Results: The performance of the AI to detect and grade cancer in prostate needle biopsy samples was comparable to that of international experts in prostate pathology. The AI achieved an area under the ROC curve of 0.997 for distinguishing between benign and malignant biopsy cores, and 0.999 for distinguishing between men with or without prostate cancer. The correlation between millimeter cancer predicted by the AI and assigned by the reporting pathologist was 0.96. For assigning Gleason grades, the AI achieved an average pairwise kappa of 0.62. This was within the range of the corresponding values for the expert pathologists (0.60 to 0.73).
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.01368v1
2019-07-02T13:52:02
2019-07-02T13:52:02
{ "title": [ 0.024627686, 0.008758545, -0.014915466, -0.031921387, -0.0112838745, -0.016998291, 0.008514404, -0.020812988, 0.0043411255, 0.032409668, -0.028381348, -0.013244629, 0.021118164, -0.04550171, -0.014976501, -0.00065517426, 0.008270264, 0.029281616, 0.010429382, -0.03302002, 0.021987915, -0.031341553, 0.01878357, 0.059265137, -0.020614624, 0.06213379, -0.07977295, -0.040802002, -0.030303955, -0.016586304, -0.018676758, 0.022094727, -0.017532349, 0.027191162, 0.019973755, 0.0803833, 0.0017757416, 0.041381836, 0.051116943, -0.02229309, -0.0066871643, -0.00642395, 0.021362305, -0.012275696, -0.025299072, 0.050689697, -0.084106445, -0.017959595, 0.020080566, 0.01424408, 0.006919861, 0.00010687113, 0.02255249, 0.013710022, -0.0056533813, 0.0012044907, 0.00085401535, -0.02204895, 0.04623413, -0.016143799, -0.018234253, -0.043151855, 0.06524658, -0.017868042, -0.035980225, -0.036102295, -0.014091492, 0.006793976, 0.043670654, 0.0011167526, 0.01890564, 0.03768921, -0.003414154, 0.017715454, -0.04348755, -0.014457703, 0.0015850067, 0.007774353, 0.05593872, -0.03390503, 0.033966064, -0.038482666, 0.0496521, -0.022384644, 0.007881165, -0.010818481, 0.015365601, -0.0036258698, -0.049682617, -0.036621094, -0.023803711, 0.007659912, -0.06970215, 0.017944336, 0.000022470951, -0.039855957, -0.040893555, -0.042541504, 0.028701782, -0.0015468597, 0.00006330013, -0.0025558472, -0.004714966, -0.0016908646, 0.009124756, 0.0062065125, 0.003786087, -0.02609253, -0.0049476624, 0.02999878, -0.03994751, 0.00074481964, 0.0140686035, -0.05343628, -0.0015563965, 0.010894775, -0.0011758804, 0.012908936, 0.047607422, -0.013420105, 0.0056266785, -0.008346558, 0.026443481, -0.0016202927, 0.016906738, -0.00086832047, -0.044921875, -0.014053345, -0.03869629, 0.044311523, -0.005443573, 0.04421997, -0.06677246, -0.064941406, -0.05117798, -0.0046043396, -0.008613586, -0.008285522, -0.024276733, 0.009796143, 0.027175903, -0.022018433, 0.017974854, 0.015853882, -0.024597168, -0.009628296, 0.041229248, 0.035247803, -0.047821045, -0.020553589, -0.016525269, 0.020370483, -0.0077323914, 0.012168884, -0.026397705, -0.014160156, -0.05065918, -0.010955811, 0.0317688, 0.011421204, 0.077697754, 0.0079422, -0.037200928, 0.061401367, 0.05517578, -0.0075531006, -0.013023376, 0.036102295, 0.0011634827, -0.025939941, 0.019744873, 0.004917145, 0.027175903, -0.021713257, 0.0045433044, 0.0000054240227, 0.008399963, 0.023635864, -0.013557434, -0.0064430237, 0.0033245087, -0.033843994, -0.00081443787, 0.016998291, -0.020004272, -0.020248413, -0.008018494, 0.00074481964, 0.051239014, 0.009529114, -0.060516357, 0.03111267, -0.012908936, -0.057159424, -0.028701782, 0.0049591064, 0.025482178, 0.03640747, -0.0049095154, 0.02394104, -0.061553955, 0.006095886, -0.02760315, 0.04107666, 0.0033416748, -0.02331543, -0.0031204224, 0.008728027, -0.0107040405, 0.033477783, 0.019958496, -0.021575928, 0.024627686, -0.039123535, -0.008087158, -0.049865723, -0.00003552437, -0.04776001, -0.04360962, -0.047729492, -0.05419922, 0.027191162, -0.05102539, 0.03451538, 0.0004658699, 0.030914307, -0.0022354126, -0.007247925, 0.05419922, 0.029586792, 0.083862305, -0.016448975, 0.064453125, 0.037902832, -0.018478394, -0.0025482178, 0.03515625, -0.022598267, -0.0052948, 0.015045166, 0.021362305, -0.0025024414, 0.04043579, 0.024520874, 0.10247803, 0.052581787, 0.040039062, -0.019821167, 0.041229248, 0.0259552, 0.0056877136, -0.0101623535, 0.07183838, 0.03111267, 0.013427734, 0.051452637, 0.00141716, 0.009544373, -0.03753662, 0.019439697, -0.0016641617, 0.042419434, 0.01322937, 0.014457703, -0.027008057, 0.032226562, -0.0016498566, 0.03036499, -0.021713257, 0.02684021, 0.032562256, -0.016174316, 0.016036987, -0.024230957, -0.031921387, -0.0032310486, -0.049682617, 0.019851685, 0.045562744, -0.026504517, -0.018447876, 0.012107849, 0.07458496, -0.0023384094, 0.00084257126, 0.013404846, 0.06750488, 0.01586914, -0.06008911, -0.03201294, 0.013450623, 0.052246094, 0.010269165, -0.03540039, 0.056610107, 0.0062026978, 0.00040912628, 0.06555176, -0.010429382, -0.009735107, -0.08618164, -0.0028190613, -0.009140015, -0.02368164, -0.008216858, 0.030334473, 0.008140564, -0.0051956177, -0.011260986, -0.003566742, -0.042175293, 0.02519226, 0.028259277, -0.042266846, 0.011444092, -0.022521973, -0.036010742, -0.0010080338, -0.074279785, -0.046142578, 0.028457642, -0.021331787, -0.019744873, -0.023925781, -0.016525269, -0.012451172, -0.038360596, -0.008132935, 0.014579773, 0.0050735474, -0.0015878677, -0.0075416565, -0.08306885, -0.015571594, 0.021575928, 0.040496826, -0.0073928833, 0.039367676, 0.0033035278, -0.063964844, -0.030349731, 0.031707764, -0.017913818, -0.025009155, 0.016967773, -0.03274536, -0.011604309, -0.023025513, -0.00982666, 0.004184723, 0.018096924, 0.007255554, -0.006454468, 0.00044870377, 0.029922485, -0.015037537, 0.006652832, 0.033966064, 0.041412354, -0.00843811, 0.030258179, 0.06011963, 0.029296875, -0.006515503, -0.06036377, -0.08294678, 0.012374878, 0.017730713, -0.013000488, 0.02406311, -0.033111572, -0.014060974, -0.03189087, -0.002281189, 0.0023555756, 0.008102417, -0.031097412, -0.029876709, -0.030181885, -0.042144775, 0.017868042, 0.018539429, 0.007881165, 0.025909424, 0.045410156, 0.025985718, 0.022628784, 0.024307251, 0.0090789795, -0.010620117, -0.032073975, 0.004386902, -0.018615723, -0.0015268326, 0.00687027, 0.02507019, -0.042236328, -0.026428223, -0.06518555, 0.013763428, -0.017089844, 0.016571045, -0.019714355, 0.03050232, -0.041534424, 0.011772156, -0.008560181, -0.02468872, 0.029785156, 0.05078125, -0.020095825, 0.011482239, 0.011306763, -0.016937256, 0.0026779175, 0.004432678, -0.0758667, 0.011543274, -0.015457153, 0.0007138252, -0.0038661957, 0.03378296, -0.041259766, -0.023727417, -0.019683838, 0.031829834, 0.06298828, 0.031021118, 0.0013132095, 0.014945984, 0.03765869, -0.030670166, 0.0063972473, -0.05819702, -0.022842407, -0.003566742, -0.044281006, 0.07751465, -0.038757324, 0.010131836, -0.03817749, -0.0065307617, 0.00920105, 0.042541504, 0.01158905, -0.020843506, -0.029510498, -0.038848877, -0.05065918, 0.005542755, -0.0013284683, 0.030380249, -0.005241394, 0.010131836, -0.0079193115, 0.0037765503, -0.003162384, 0.047607422, -0.015670776, -0.032806396, 0.0044174194, -0.04232788, -0.0041275024, 0.0154953, -0.0135269165, 0.01777649, 0.017913818, 0.009483337, -0.022613525, 0.012542725, -0.0014009476, -0.0055007935, 0.013938904, -0.015594482, -0.0043182373, -0.05029297, -0.002986908, 0.033935547, -0.028625488, -0.02658081, -0.001461029, 0.017089844, -0.0052871704, -0.06414795, -0.032470703, 0.011665344, -0.12371826, -0.08843994, 0.040649414, -0.06616211, -0.060455322, -0.06677246, 0.009712219, -0.028320312, -0.006465912, 0.018493652, 0.012054443, 0.017486572, 0.0072898865, -0.06591797, -0.07952881, 0.04876709, -0.026412964, 0.0046310425, 0.012001038, 0.012634277, -0.01651001, -0.017837524, -0.012542725, -0.0051460266, 0.017868042, -0.03942871, -0.03866577, 0.037139893, -0.044128418, 0.04232788, 0.0016670227, 0.016616821, -0.021591187, 0.007598877, -0.0039138794, 0.012680054, -0.01361084, 0.055755615, 0.005870819, -0.023849487, -0.04119873, 0.015853882, -0.0014419556, -0.06854248, 0.0418396, -0.0014419556, 0.025436401, 0.076293945, -0.009407043, 0.06933594, -0.02494812, -0.0001950264, 0.018005371, -0.032562256, -0.021728516, 0.007091522, 0.021636963, 0.015319824, -0.031234741, 0.033447266, -0.02482605, 0.059783936, 0.034729004, -0.05883789, 0.036590576, 0.05227661, -0.03656006, -0.040863037, -0.0713501, -0.016693115, -0.00025844574, 0.010627747, -0.0023880005, -0.011764526, 0.040649414, -0.006313324, -0.024810791, -0.007381439, 0.02458191, -0.004711151, -0.012550354, -0.080322266, 0.02619934, -0.04611206, -0.05810547, -0.083984375, 0.0087890625, 0.057800293, -0.0074386597, -0.0037193298, -0.0059127808, 0.011207581, 0.031311035, 0.014770508, 0.035247803, -0.0085372925, -0.035095215, 0.0064735413, -0.013420105, -0.014335632, -0.023742676, 0.041137695, -0.017288208, -0.020080566, 0.012809753, -0.026931763, -0.031082153, -0.06750488, 0.015342712, 0.00868988, 0.023498535, 0.025741577, 0.020843506, 0.03491211, 0.019119263, 0.046722412, 0.017974854, -0.015007019, -0.0546875, 0.050476074, 0.046447754, 0.029037476, 0.019927979, 0.05731201, 0.014808655, -0.017364502, -0.0072746277, 0.017288208, 0.041534424, -0.025848389, -0.012786865, 0.009117126, -0.04675293, -0.013465881, -0.008979797, -0.036743164, 0.02961731, -0.05819702, 0.018203735, 0.011955261, 0.008964539, 0.008140564, -0.022247314, -0.00007468462, -0.039154053, 0.001042366, -0.017196655, -0.032318115, 0.017364502, 0.031219482, -0.010406494, -0.0015087128, -0.017837524, 0.02885437, 0.013259888, 0.028198242, -0.000746727, 0.014015198, -0.010215759, -0.0005583763, 0.0027332306, -0.041625977, -0.028396606, -0.03515625, -0.02468872, -0.0030002594, -0.013206482, 0.0026569366, -0.026168823, -0.025878906, -0.02519226, -0.010131836, 0.031707764, -0.04309082, 0.02255249, 0.09326172, -0.03756714, 0.028137207, -0.010429382, -0.013710022, 0.02545166, 0.030303955, -0.021087646, -0.014930725, 0.020980835, -0.027038574, 0.029403687, 0.009727478, 0.049102783, 0.022277832, -0.010238647, 0.0048446655, 0.0025119781, -0.029144287, 0.013336182, 0.018173218, 0.040802002, -0.0016641617, -0.0390625, 0.031463623, 0.0071029663, -0.024841309, 0.017425537, -0.066833496, -0.016540527, 0.034057617, -0.047424316, -0.005126953, 0.024841309, -0.018188477, -0.018478394, -0.03793335, 0.025405884, 0.0013961792, -0.016052246, -0.010215759, 0.056854248, -0.010818481, 0.026992798, 0.01638794, -0.048095703, 0.012939453, 0.003446579, 0.0052452087, 0.03338623, 0.03237915, -0.058807373, -0.023345947, 0.0034427643, -0.057403564, -0.026779175, 0.02859497, 0.014312744, -0.01953125, -0.012451172, -0.05569458, -0.05090332, -0.0008573532, 0.014823914, -0.024551392, -0.056121826, 0.0076904297, -0.0061035156, 0.025497437, -0.019760132, 0.025741577, 0.055603027, -0.020523071, -0.0029125214, -0.03717041, 0.015220642, 0.02897644, 0.01927185, -0.031097412, -0.021469116, -0.015914917, 0.045135498, 0.0074005127, 0.021942139, 0.05203247, 0.03656006, 0.05999756, -0.009559631, 0.054718018, 0.07354736, -0.057281494, -0.06994629, -0.020629883, 0.005962372, -0.023910522, 0.060150146, 0.008201599, -0.058624268, -0.019424438, -0.038879395, -0.02456665, 0.008674622, 0.04034424, 0.011291504, 0.04522705, -0.007156372, 0.0009646416, -0.048583984, -0.008132935, -0.024978638, 0.029571533, -0.027648926, 0.0039901733, 0.025848389, -0.011512756, 0.007911682, -0.03805542, 0.035308838, 0.018432617, 0.0043029785, 0.0061149597, 0.0004813671, -0.0129852295, -0.05810547, 0.022872925, 0.014968872, 0.08502197, -0.07977295, 0.010253906, -0.024505615, 0.0814209, 0.003894806, -0.008293152, 0.012619019, 0.048431396, 0.030838013, -0.014350891, -0.0068473816, 0.0011730194, -0.019882202, -0.06890869, 0.0043258667, -0.0051460266, 0.0044441223, -0.04827881, -0.0129776, 0.040222168, 0.030471802, 0.011398315, 0.00015354156, 0.031982422, 0.021026611, 0.019851685, -0.02357483, 0.05404663, -0.0005674362, 0.0027561188, -0.0034236908, -0.027389526, 0.0037288666, 0.018692017, 0.00058174133, 0.026809692, -0.0309906, -0.00969696, 0.012496948, -0.0019006729, 0.021896362, -0.05230713, -0.010124207, -0.035217285, 0.049743652, -0.007408142, -0.011108398, 0.059417725, 0.058898926, -0.020080566, -0.0045814514, 0.022979736, -0.016784668, 0.023849487, -0.043914795, 0.036468506, -0.03845215, 0.03488159, -0.015266418, -0.04083252, -0.05130005, 0.045288086, 0.0012512207, 0.018417358, 0.043182373, 0.01348114, 0.0052833557, 0.016571045, 0.044433594, -0.02418518, -0.01574707, -0.003227234, -0.022399902, 0.024017334, 0.06262207, 0.05407715, 0.019042969, 0.01940918, 0.0014476776, -0.013038635, 0.024490356, -0.038757324, 0.018859863, -0.016296387, 0.046417236, -0.033935547, -0.03552246, 0.013549805, 0.023101807, -0.042877197, -0.01373291, 0.03982544, 0.00029945374, 0.0020103455, 0.05810547, 0.039367676, 0.00566864, -0.038238525, -0.009178162, 0.015052795, 0.026626587, -0.014099121, 0.0063171387, -0.013511658, -0.022201538, 0.045654297, -0.00030064583, 0.09136963, 0.0023956299, 0.001291275, -0.020431519, -0.029785156, 0.025970459, -0.014091492, 0.014694214, -0.017288208, -0.009521484, -0.02279663, -0.0027866364, -0.0026073456, -0.033355713, -0.026992798, 0.03552246, -0.01486969, 0.012046814, 0.03515625, -0.032562256, -0.039520264, 0.041290283, 0.024505615, 0.054595947, 0.011207581, -0.0058250427, -0.016784668, 0.0071105957, -0.0044822693, 0.016540527, -0.0018863678, 0.028671265, -0.04751587, -0.03375244, 0.014808655, 0.035308838, -0.034576416, -0.06768799, 0.045074463, -0.0126953125, -0.033111572, -0.024719238, 0.017623901, -0.014007568, -0.04458618, -0.013542175, -0.034851074, -0.008720398, 0.01184082, -0.019210815, 0.012680054, -0.0035476685, -0.00031805038, 0.006198883, 0.031402588, 0.04437256, -0.028366089, -0.013298035, -0.025787354, 0.04638672, 0.058685303, -0.022964478, -0.037719727, 0.009735107, 0.020996094, -0.035888672, 0.03704834, 0.007835388, 0.014945984, 0.046936035, 0.050354004, 0.008323669, -0.033996582, -0.020202637, -0.010856628, 0.04373169, 0.023605347, -0.021224976, 0.003622055, 0.027648926, -0.010406494, 0.0087509155, -0.00006866455, -0.007888794, 0.017501831, -0.0061531067, 0.014572144, -0.007858276, -0.015602112, -0.0010204315, 0.021240234, -0.021697998, -0.0060653687, -0.007472992, 0.0066490173, -0.0236969, 0.024917603, 0.010360718, 0.024337769, 0.004055023, 0.009338379, 0.022567749, 0.017364502, -0.01878357, -0.007659912, -0.024169922, -0.007507324, 0.0021877289, -0.006061554, 0.056488037, -0.032592773, 0.018753052, -0.02130127, -0.029067993, -0.027542114, -0.023483276, 0.053375244, -0.048065186, 0.007888794, -0.05697632, -0.021148682, 0.029815674, 0.014259338, 0.054595947, -0.014427185, -0.0045776367, 0.019699097, 0.028640747, 0.0025672913 ], "summary": [ 0.03152466, 0.018981934, 0.0112838745, -0.0076560974, -0.00079631805, -0.0071029663, -0.0069732666, -0.033996582, 0.014579773, 0.027572632, -0.0011062622, -0.011955261, 0.014022827, -0.037994385, -0.02305603, 0.0035095215, -0.016479492, 0.042053223, 0.0061836243, -0.045776367, 0.02015686, -0.053527832, -0.013084412, 0.07562256, -0.021087646, 0.068481445, -0.05105591, 0.00095033646, -0.03942871, 0.017425537, -0.013053894, -0.019729614, -0.020324707, 0.03137207, 0.03656006, 0.06890869, 0.020736694, 0.018508911, 0.06329346, -0.00881958, -0.0011310577, 0.0065193176, 0.10058594, -0.046905518, 0.008979797, 0.07507324, -0.058380127, -0.030792236, 0.006752014, 0.002735138, 0.00774765, 0.014816284, 0.012611389, -0.0031166077, -0.009750366, 0.0087509155, -0.015396118, 0.003440857, 0.03363037, -0.0072288513, -0.0011816025, -0.03186035, 0.035339355, -0.017868042, -0.054901123, -0.008155823, 0.042144775, -0.010719299, 0.016036987, -0.023269653, 0.029937744, 0.044525146, 0.019470215, -0.019622803, -0.027069092, 0.019317627, -0.021743774, -0.0058670044, 0.046691895, -0.045166016, 0.02822876, -0.014167786, -0.0035572052, 0.011962891, -0.01360321, 0.0056037903, -0.002981186, -0.024658203, -0.016677856, -0.009117126, -0.028533936, -0.033691406, -0.050445557, 0.06689453, 0.015144348, -0.03665161, -0.056671143, -0.06365967, -0.005256653, 0.04296875, 0.018035889, -0.022338867, 0.062408447, -0.019195557, -0.017486572, 0.029525757, 0.028930664, -0.052215576, -0.031799316, -0.0050582886, -0.032348633, -0.016235352, -0.010864258, -0.08703613, -0.0033740997, 0.042022705, 0.031402588, -0.0090408325, 0.042938232, -0.06652832, -0.02078247, -0.013458252, 0.022949219, 0.0017271042, 0.022583008, 0.015449524, -0.0062713623, -0.01751709, -0.050933838, 0.06549072, 0.0025119781, -0.0021514893, -0.011238098, -0.0079422, -0.041412354, -0.027633667, -0.0035324097, -0.02281189, -0.008514404, 0.000052154064, 0.029846191, -0.012832642, -0.009384155, 0.015899658, -0.014343262, 0.008583069, 0.017120361, 0.022354126, -0.022537231, -0.027664185, 0.033203125, -0.0287323, 0.040802002, -0.024887085, -0.020584106, -0.06555176, -0.015930176, -0.026687622, 0.007019043, -0.034210205, 0.07977295, -0.005264282, -0.028274536, 0.051849365, 0.00459671, -0.0054397583, -0.037231445, 0.002986908, 0.009017944, -0.07366943, 0.03579712, 0.039215088, 0.0005464554, -0.020095825, 0.032440186, -0.017471313, 0.013542175, 0.044769287, -0.0009508133, -0.028442383, -0.015144348, -0.056610107, 0.06640625, -0.032287598, 0.0036945343, 0.033477783, -0.02053833, -0.0015335083, 0.019042969, -0.002193451, -0.03652954, 0.035705566, -0.00856781, -0.041778564, -0.005332947, 0.0035915375, -0.0018930435, -0.006095886, -0.024246216, 0.033691406, -0.006126404, -0.026275635, 0.011131287, 0.0045318604, -0.02659607, 0.003200531, -0.018356323, 0.0043411255, -0.013221741, -0.007598877, 0.015007019, -0.05340576, 0.012016296, 0.0044555664, -0.020706177, -0.0065345764, 0.005554199, -0.04345703, -0.032470703, -0.064453125, -0.030639648, 0.050231934, -0.052764893, 0.03955078, -0.010726929, 0.00365448, 0.005065918, -0.015930176, 0.039245605, 0.008102417, 0.072143555, -0.015144348, 0.05331421, 0.046539307, 0.008468628, 0.03213501, 0.08355713, -0.020874023, -0.014472961, -0.019302368, 0.022750854, 0.017822266, 0.016448975, -0.004673004, 0.082214355, 0.039764404, 0.037841797, -0.028396606, -0.0026168823, 0.021606445, -0.013580322, 0.017532349, 0.044891357, -0.015838623, 0.00091695786, 0.057281494, 0.018981934, 0.00041937828, -0.025817871, 0.014533997, 0.01260376, 0.034698486, -0.040283203, 0.034729004, -0.04498291, 0.012001038, -0.00045013428, 0.0005393028, 0.0039596558, -0.021148682, 0.014274597, -0.027557373, 0.007068634, -0.05053711, -0.039031982, -0.0054359436, -0.046936035, 0.02368164, 0.06304932, -0.03326416, -0.0072364807, 0.006439209, 0.01852417, -0.00982666, 0.019638062, -0.0050811768, 0.023544312, 0.021240234, -0.0067749023, 0.016082764, 0.034118652, 0.04244995, 0.014251709, -0.028244019, 0.07989502, -0.014564514, -0.01234436, 0.035949707, 0.016647339, -0.027832031, -0.050750732, 0.021194458, -0.04788208, 0.013343811, -0.0065078735, 0.037902832, -0.023391724, 0.027236938, 0.005592346, -0.04547119, 0.019943237, 0.014976501, 0.031585693, -0.018005371, 0.010131836, -0.0067214966, -0.03253174, 0.03277588, -0.028015137, 0.0082092285, 0.059326172, -0.039733887, -0.0116119385, -0.032226562, -0.02192688, -0.011428833, -0.023086548, -0.0115356445, -0.0009870529, 0.009307861, -0.051818848, -0.04159546, -0.052703857, -0.009292603, -0.0038337708, 0.005844116, -0.00009560585, 0.03277588, 0.008102417, -0.043670654, -0.01449585, 0.06097412, -0.011734009, -0.0047569275, -0.0062942505, 0.00541687, -0.008232117, -0.014022827, -0.017471313, 0.008773804, 0.00023400784, -0.0032901764, -0.022842407, 0.057678223, 0.011360168, 0.01210022, 0.03717041, 0.025146484, 0.0046844482, -0.023254395, 0.03543091, 0.051879883, 0.03717041, -0.01687622, -0.07757568, -0.04888916, 0.01889038, 0.024429321, -0.013710022, 0.0446167, -0.03829956, 0.033477783, -0.022262573, -0.025650024, -0.005794525, 0.014213562, 0.026855469, -0.008476257, -0.004760742, 0.015563965, -0.003932953, 0.02810669, -0.008171082, 0.05215454, 0.042266846, -0.00097465515, 0.031097412, 0.06506348, 0.008384705, -0.013420105, -0.008033752, 0.022628784, 0.013793945, -0.03201294, -0.027633667, 0.023986816, -0.040374756, -0.045440674, 0.037109375, -0.0076560974, -0.066223145, 0.039367676, -0.005290985, 0.007156372, -0.016937256, -0.01033783, -0.03540039, -0.04147339, 0.021194458, 0.040924072, -0.016204834, 0.009399414, -0.014450073, 0.003578186, -0.0058937073, 0.0072631836, -0.0019989014, -0.0045204163, -0.0040512085, 0.001537323, -0.023544312, 0.09289551, -0.0625, -0.009803772, -0.009994507, 0.027801514, 0.038848877, 0.019683838, -0.010978699, 0.016677856, 0.03491211, -0.020355225, 0.031555176, -0.032226562, -0.05142212, -0.007095337, -0.046722412, 0.049102783, -0.019424438, -0.040222168, -0.018676758, -0.010032654, 0.0011234283, -0.00016486645, -0.014671326, -0.0024909973, 0.0016241074, 0.0035133362, -0.043273926, -0.00078868866, -0.0016126633, 0.027160645, 0.024917603, 0.03338623, 0.0005054474, 0.024429321, -0.011924744, 0.02986145, 0.047424316, -0.036987305, -0.015670776, -0.015167236, -0.024398804, 0.005519867, 0.02784729, 0.03173828, -0.015594482, 0.013435364, -0.013938904, 0.017944336, 0.032714844, -0.044830322, 0.007461548, -0.030273438, 0.0004067421, -0.07067871, 0.02935791, 0.001332283, 0.046569824, -0.022857666, -0.036987305, 0.031143188, -0.024169922, -0.08648682, -0.0463562, 0.010597229, -0.10131836, -0.09033203, 0.016952515, -0.01927185, -0.020843506, -0.06173706, 0.02079773, -0.0014095306, -0.00919342, 0.024673462, -0.0035133362, 0.06842041, 0.022338867, -0.01979065, -0.04147339, -0.017501831, -0.006336212, 0.0020370483, -0.02961731, 0.05819702, 0.006454468, -0.028823853, -0.031585693, -0.10083008, 0.007881165, -0.09020996, -0.037109375, 0.031829834, -0.045928955, 0.051483154, -0.029647827, 0.027908325, -0.01763916, -0.009521484, -0.019470215, -0.03086853, 0.04147339, 0.02268982, -0.009017944, -0.0064468384, 0.017349243, 0.028366089, -0.002199173, -0.049316406, 0.06011963, 0.021453857, 0.019378662, 0.04562378, -0.008743286, 0.03857422, -0.016601562, -0.019241333, 0.008232117, -0.0071640015, -0.012992859, 0.029006958, 0.01737976, 0.027893066, -0.029815674, 0.024337769, -0.004016876, 0.011810303, 0.030212402, -0.09472656, 0.029541016, 0.06341553, 0.003293991, -0.044708252, -0.030090332, 0.013511658, 0.0385437, -0.009941101, 0.002521515, -0.021560669, 0.015579224, -0.013198853, -0.0018672943, -0.0020809174, 0.010147095, -0.006122589, 0.0051345825, -0.055633545, 0.026824951, -0.031555176, 0.017623901, -0.039764404, 0.032684326, 0.049102783, -0.016815186, -0.012008667, -0.0021514893, -0.0005092621, 0.025985718, -0.0065727234, -0.004650116, 0.0034370422, -0.013977051, -0.04135132, -0.020523071, -0.019943237, -0.007801056, 0.01159668, -0.027496338, 0.00023007393, 0.05895996, -0.022827148, -0.035461426, -0.04309082, -0.016525269, 0.047729492, -0.002986908, 0.017837524, 0.011985779, 0.016479492, 0.01953125, 0.05697632, 0.013999939, 0.014816284, -0.073791504, 0.08166504, 0.01838684, 0.051116943, 0.013214111, 0.05493164, 0.009437561, -0.030395508, 0.019470215, 0.009529114, 0.045043945, -0.013404846, -0.025817871, 0.022476196, -0.0029010773, -0.015174866, 0.010375977, -0.010482788, 0.01373291, -0.012893677, 0.0041618347, 0.041992188, -0.0049705505, 0.007774353, -0.046813965, -0.007762909, -0.039093018, -0.01776123, -0.016479492, -0.042266846, 0.014892578, 0.017807007, 0.012649536, -0.0025482178, -0.032562256, 0.009437561, -0.0044937134, 0.0077705383, -0.014892578, 0.019897461, -0.02381897, -0.013298035, -0.0073165894, -0.033843994, -0.024490356, -0.034576416, -0.016677856, -0.020370483, -0.004814148, -0.019180298, -0.024673462, -0.022521973, -0.0031356812, -0.021408081, 0.0054359436, -0.040771484, 0.012512207, 0.05307007, -0.058288574, 0.034484863, 0.02545166, -0.014083862, -0.032806396, 0.015327454, -0.032470703, -0.0028362274, -0.01424408, -0.03137207, 0.03842163, -0.022125244, 0.016937256, 0.05722046, -0.03060913, 0.012939453, 0.0035877228, -0.00541687, -0.0067443848, -0.0073890686, 0.062927246, -0.035308838, -0.019973755, 0.037353516, -0.0017118454, -0.018615723, 0.007888794, -0.02053833, -0.00541687, 0.026107788, -0.00970459, 0.00843811, 0.0085372925, -0.00066900253, -0.029754639, -0.007896423, -0.0152282715, 0.0037631989, -0.011459351, 0.01625061, 0.04333496, -0.0065841675, -0.00844574, -0.021133423, -0.03250122, -0.02456665, 0.02923584, 0.011009216, -0.013389587, -0.0068511963, -0.05557251, -0.013664246, -0.0023536682, -0.018295288, -0.02607727, 0.025650024, 0.009231567, -0.005241394, -0.017852783, -0.014007568, -0.019866943, -0.012512207, 0.01499176, -0.03652954, -0.05960083, -0.008560181, 0.0027275085, 0.020736694, -0.031829834, -0.01033783, 0.026733398, -0.02279663, -0.00069379807, -0.045166016, -0.0064582825, 0.0005745888, 0.015602112, -0.03591919, -0.0039367676, -0.011627197, 0.02986145, 0.017532349, 0.04724121, 0.040283203, 0.022369385, 0.08355713, -0.016296387, 0.03375244, 0.029632568, -0.016540527, -0.09094238, -0.023895264, 0.035369873, 0.014213562, -0.0030059814, -0.033721924, -0.0748291, 0.035705566, -0.04840088, 0.00868988, 0.016677856, 0.011184692, 0.030303955, 0.042022705, -0.011329651, 0.016204834, -0.038269043, -0.01928711, 0.000893116, -0.00068950653, -0.009567261, -0.009796143, 0.0385437, -0.0137786865, -0.01272583, -0.031204224, 0.00919342, 0.012397766, 0.02470398, 0.03050232, 0.042816162, -0.0158844, -0.030059814, 0.043121338, 0.008834839, 0.06335449, -0.06756592, -0.023864746, 0.0037937164, 0.05368042, 0.0023708344, -0.04675293, -0.046783447, 0.005756378, 0.030136108, -0.021530151, -0.039123535, -0.009010315, -0.014389038, -0.019973755, -0.036499023, -0.018249512, -0.038391113, 0.027664185, 0.026535034, -0.022262573, -0.0047683716, 0.031204224, 0.0025043488, 0.033294678, 0.059631348, 0.0027561188, -0.017623901, 0.012397766, 0.06665039, 0.021270752, 0.01525116, -0.041809082, -0.016555786, 0.029708862, 0.018966675, 0.013175964, -0.038604736, -0.0256958, 0.011360168, 0.0146484375, -0.021743774, -0.09094238, -0.015640259, -0.077697754, 0.045532227, 0.019683838, 0.021591187, 0.03277588, 0.006801605, 0.039733887, -0.019165039, 0.0046691895, -0.006565094, 0.033233643, -0.041625977, 0.011703491, -0.041656494, 0.022903442, 0.020507812, -0.012214661, -0.02357483, 0.034057617, 0.0104522705, -0.003622055, 0.050720215, -0.013786316, 0.0027065277, -0.02357483, 0.03213501, -0.025726318, 0.00623703, -0.002248764, -0.041900635, 0.047058105, 0.053009033, 0.05392456, -0.012672424, 0.02960205, 0.030303955, -0.0059013367, 0.06677246, -0.011550903, 0.018173218, -0.043640137, 0.013587952, -0.022857666, -0.019836426, -0.007347107, 0.028701782, -0.05218506, 0.001750946, 0.050994873, -0.003616333, 0.007835388, 0.04840088, 0.012893677, 0.01260376, -0.047973633, -0.007858276, 0.02368164, 0.00932312, 0.014335632, -0.023956299, 0.0023651123, -0.015686035, 0.040222168, 0.037384033, 0.11279297, -0.0079422, -0.010902405, -0.000015258789, -0.042266846, -0.008811951, 0.02468872, 0.03463745, -0.01612854, 0.0034751892, -0.015106201, 0.024398804, -0.0054092407, -0.036071777, -0.017486572, 0.04046631, -0.019210815, 0.009483337, 0.013954163, -0.008773804, -0.020050049, 0.018981934, 0.011489868, 0.06964111, 0.021102905, -0.005012512, 0.013870239, 0.013366699, -0.03250122, 0.01574707, 0.019866943, 0.065979004, -0.014099121, -0.04675293, 0.035705566, 0.052124023, -0.03173828, -0.056030273, 0.04296875, -0.019256592, -0.023101807, 0.0138549805, -0.0074272156, -0.0038871765, -0.0073165894, -0.010955811, 0.0010929108, 0.004043579, -0.009483337, 0.0029258728, 0.035858154, -0.0033664703, -0.000032126904, 0.028427124, 0.036956787, 0.023361206, -0.028152466, -0.008666992, -0.013084412, 0.055786133, 0.027267456, -0.009376526, 0.01902771, 0.040222168, -0.011810303, -0.030258179, -0.0121154785, -0.016723633, 0.0181427, 0.11047363, 0.06201172, 0.03125, -0.05102539, -0.023208618, 0.0053253174, 0.05126953, 0.019378662, -0.0141067505, -0.015357971, 0.025680542, -0.017562866, -0.0158844, -0.02166748, -0.0045166016, -0.024215698, -0.00422287, -0.021194458, -0.023406982, -0.01121521, 0.0002477169, -0.016403198, -0.031341553, -0.055755615, 0.0021972656, -0.0031738281, -0.05807495, -0.008773804, -0.011222839, 0.08984375, -0.029449463, -0.024505615, 0.0385437, -0.016082764, -0.016235352, 0.044769287, 0.005455017, -0.014472961, -0.009033203, -0.015335083, 0.06011963, -0.09454346, -0.034057617, -0.022262573, -0.008552551, -0.026107788, -0.02218628, 0.04510498, -0.0058937073, -0.010429382, -0.0075035095, -0.040985107, 0.022369385, 0.0045166016, 0.06542969, -0.028335571, 0.031021118, 0.037750244, 0.03753662, 0.021987915 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2105.07540v2
Deep learning for detecting pulmonary tuberculosis via chest radiography: an international study across 10 countries
Sahar Kazemzadeh, Jin Yu, Shahar Jamshy, Rory Pilgrim, Zaid Nabulsi, Christina Chen, Neeral Beladia, Charles Lau, Scott Mayer McKinney, Thad Hughes, Atilla Kiraly, Sreenivasa Raju Kalidindi, Monde Muyoyeta, Jameson Malemela, Ting Shih, Greg S. Corrado, Lily Peng, Katherine Chou, Po-Hsuan Cameron Chen, Yun Liu, Krish Eswaran, Daniel Tse, Shravya Shetty, Shruthi Prabhakara
eess.IV, cs.AI, cs.CV
Tuberculosis (TB) is a top-10 cause of death worldwide. Though the WHO recommends chest radiographs (CXRs) for TB screening, the limited availability of CXR interpretation is a barrier. We trained a deep learning system (DLS) to detect active pulmonary TB using CXRs from 9 countries across Africa, Asia, and Europe, and utilized large-scale CXR pretraining, attention pooling, and noisy student semi-supervised learning. Evaluation was on (1) a combined test set spanning China, India, US, and Zambia, and (2) an independent mining population in South Africa. Given WHO targets of 90% sensitivity and 70% specificity, the DLS's operating point was prespecified to favor sensitivity over specificity. On the combined test set, the DLS's ROC curve was above all 9 India-based radiologists, with an AUC of 0.90 (95%CI 0.87-0.92). The DLS's sensitivity (88%) was higher than the India-based radiologists (75% mean sensitivity), p<0.001 for superiority; and its specificity (79%) was non-inferior to the radiologists (84% mean specificity), p=0.004. Similar trends were observed within HIV positive and sputum smear positive sub-groups, and in the South Africa test set. We found that 5 US-based radiologists (where TB isn't endemic) were more sensitive and less specific than the India-based radiologists (where TB is endemic). The DLS also remained non-inferior to the US-based radiologists. In simulations, using the DLS as a prioritization tool for confirmatory testing reduced the cost per positive case detected by 40-80% compared to using confirmatory testing alone. To conclude, our DLS generalized to 5 countries, and merits prospective evaluation to assist cost-effective screening efforts in radiologist-limited settings. Operating point flexibility may permit customization of the DLS to account for site-specific factors such as TB prevalence, demographics, clinical resources, and customary practice patterns.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2105.07540v2
2021-10-29T22:41:00
2021-05-16T22:56:06
{ "title": [ 0.017944336, 0.014907837, -0.027267456, -0.05883789, 0.0131073, -0.014175415, -0.022613525, -0.030227661, 0.009269714, 0.014816284, -0.06109619, -0.0028381348, -0.031707764, -0.029144287, -0.053741455, -0.03656006, 0.019760132, -0.0077400208, -0.01878357, -0.020065308, 0.010032654, -0.026535034, 0.055236816, 0.064697266, 0.0003926754, -0.03414917, -0.047607422, 0.012214661, -0.054595947, -0.05596924, 0.0032577515, 0.060791016, 0.02619934, 0.04159546, -0.037719727, 0.046844482, -0.05340576, 0.041259766, 0.020507812, -0.018630981, 0.005519867, -0.0045394897, 0.05606079, -0.039123535, 0.01096344, 0.066223145, -0.09790039, -0.047821045, -0.023971558, 0.059783936, 0.016326904, -0.010101318, -0.0009965897, 0.03048706, 0.02180481, -0.032684326, -0.0096588135, 0.0023880005, 0.057159424, 0.03463745, -0.017288208, -0.059448242, 0.019546509, -0.039367676, -0.033996582, -0.033447266, 0.0049819946, 0.018417358, 0.05117798, 0.006008148, 0.012290955, 0.05142212, 0.01159668, 0.01852417, -0.07165527, -0.015510559, 0.04901123, 0.014465332, 0.04727173, -0.057006836, 0.006298065, -0.018753052, 0.02394104, 0.017425537, -0.008087158, 0.0025634766, -0.014625549, -0.015129089, -0.03186035, -0.057525635, -0.00198555, -0.058441162, -0.059417725, 0.02708435, 0.03475952, -0.0713501, -0.04425049, -0.02532959, 0.028366089, 0.021987915, -0.00048279762, 0.0050468445, -0.0007004738, -0.003982544, 0.001783371, 0.009796143, -0.025405884, -0.08081055, -0.016098022, 0.030410767, -0.032196045, -0.014137268, 0.020980835, -0.019226074, 0.013977051, 0.011047363, 0.018630981, 0.020065308, 0.027893066, -0.010643005, 0.011299133, -0.0236969, 0.041381836, 0.04071045, 0.034332275, 0.024963379, -0.044128418, -0.008911133, -0.04763794, 0.053527832, 0.02961731, 0.04559326, -0.10296631, -0.07952881, -0.07531738, 0.031280518, 0.0019931793, -0.0047569275, -0.016937256, -0.0018253326, 0.02708435, -0.030593872, -0.02432251, 0.016189575, -0.012626648, 0.017990112, 0.047210693, -0.012123108, -0.058502197, -0.058166504, -0.029586792, 0.012062073, 0.045928955, -0.006454468, -0.055114746, 0.0072898865, -0.033996582, -0.02746582, -0.030548096, -0.036346436, 0.07330322, -0.003414154, -0.03137207, 0.0770874, 0.08892822, -0.014526367, -0.024932861, 0.03665161, 0.0151901245, -0.0044898987, 0.0016756058, 0.00592041, 0.031219482, -0.009399414, 0.006374359, 0.010932922, 0.05706787, 0.030899048, 0.0052948, -0.01499176, -0.0030517578, -0.025619507, 0.03250122, 0.0056114197, -0.024383545, -0.04171753, -0.0067367554, -0.006790161, 0.060668945, 0.011741638, -0.07598877, 0.012550354, -0.06488037, -0.005508423, -0.035705566, -0.0053215027, 0.03656006, 0.03955078, 0.0060768127, -0.0009717941, -0.011833191, -0.014198303, 0.005126953, -0.002111435, -0.012817383, -0.031921387, -0.0049819946, 0.0053100586, -0.03253174, 0.041259766, 0.049560547, -0.0102005005, -0.036834717, 0.024490356, 0.031219482, -0.038909912, 0.013999939, -0.00869751, -0.027252197, -0.014465332, -0.051513672, -0.0090789795, -0.01776123, 0.012306213, 0.03302002, 0.026977539, -0.00756073, -0.02041626, 0.030059814, 0.046905518, -0.013420105, -0.01108551, -0.0390625, -0.03189087, -0.029708862, -0.020843506, -0.016586304, 0.018371582, 0.022918701, 0.00466156, 0.00592041, -0.010887146, -0.005584717, 0.029205322, 0.040039062, 0.010147095, 0.009887695, 0.011978149, 0.020736694, 0.0077552795, 0.021270752, -0.0023536682, 0.06274414, -0.004562378, -0.010391235, 0.058776855, -0.020385742, 0.0014953613, -0.0077323914, 0.00025248528, -0.0025501251, 0.01739502, 0.032440186, 0.0051612854, -0.041381836, 0.032836914, -0.021896362, 0.011062622, -0.015777588, 0.044189453, 0.0236969, -0.038146973, 0.008628845, 0.029083252, 0.0012340546, 0.010108948, -0.018508911, -0.007621765, 0.026168823, -0.0046463013, -0.0073242188, -0.007369995, 0.040771484, 0.0026741028, 0.027526855, 0.0019950867, 0.02684021, 0.0056991577, -0.06488037, -0.041534424, 0.011894226, 0.022491455, -0.028213501, -0.024261475, 0.017150879, -0.004814148, 0.044433594, 0.08416748, -0.018585205, 0.03213501, -0.061279297, 0.00045990944, -0.01751709, 0.0022792816, -0.010597229, 0.04156494, -0.026977539, 0.015327454, -0.012840271, -0.031311035, 0.017547607, 0.04537964, -0.0063056946, -0.045166016, -0.045318604, -0.047790527, -0.058898926, -0.02166748, -0.0546875, 0.026153564, 0.012741089, -0.005558014, -0.04269409, -0.0051574707, 0.0073127747, 0.004257202, -0.023498535, -0.030593872, 0.0129852295, 0.008651733, 0.033294678, 0.018966675, -0.05444336, -0.025604248, 0.009963989, 0.008781433, 0.006259918, 0.02418518, -0.020477295, -0.038726807, -0.00040507317, 0.0025634766, 0.0008044243, -0.0026416779, -0.02368164, 0.0019216537, 0.012718201, 0.013977051, -0.09576416, -0.014091492, 0.05670166, -0.0440979, -0.04373169, -0.020965576, 0.002456665, 0.05697632, 0.04385376, -0.035949707, 0.03201294, -0.03845215, 0.014297485, 0.021575928, 0.00019979477, -0.025787354, -0.0077934265, -0.05404663, -0.011703491, -0.015151978, 0.010284424, 0.022781372, -0.06518555, -0.020141602, -0.0015935898, 0.009513855, 0.044799805, 0.017807007, -0.00970459, -0.0034618378, -0.04006958, -0.025680542, 0.03741455, 0.0036888123, -0.0043182373, -0.017959595, 0.05001831, -0.00036668777, 0.008796692, -0.006832123, 0.045013428, -0.009460449, 0.01689148, 0.003850937, -0.0035533905, -0.015388489, 0.025665283, 0.02268982, -0.04827881, -0.022857666, -0.076416016, 0.009140015, 0.010726929, -0.020019531, -0.040100098, 0.0076293945, -0.03552246, -0.02772522, 0.0075263977, -0.024887085, 0.02230835, 0.06793213, 0.0040283203, 0.00856781, 0.001332283, 0.0057411194, 0.019454956, -0.0046958923, -0.079589844, 0.0118637085, -0.018829346, -0.026351929, 0.00056123734, 0.015594482, -0.058776855, -0.021102905, 0.0013532639, 0.04034424, 0.021636963, -0.014480591, 0.041625977, -0.014808655, 0.0059432983, -0.012374878, -0.0033283234, -0.045898438, -0.0051498413, -0.0004892349, -0.022064209, 0.06616211, -0.021148682, 0.015960693, -0.027786255, -0.0026817322, 0.024414062, 0.038146973, 0.010284424, -0.015457153, -0.009048462, -0.009269714, -0.015930176, 0.028930664, -0.020111084, -0.0035076141, -0.029571533, 0.023422241, -0.032287598, 0.0126953125, -0.007209778, 0.02230835, 0.014411926, -0.01612854, 0.024551392, -0.030685425, -0.015579224, 0.024627686, 0.0262146, -0.002450943, 0.033050537, -0.006313324, -0.026275635, 0.022964478, -0.017059326, -0.016906738, 0.009513855, -0.01247406, -0.0030460358, -0.039093018, -0.01210022, 0.033569336, -0.030029297, -0.011154175, -0.03527832, 0.027877808, 2.9802322e-7, -0.05090332, -0.017333984, 0.0069122314, -0.060577393, -0.02935791, 0.026138306, -0.04046631, -0.008895874, -0.05331421, 0.025772095, -0.02960205, -0.02229309, 0.021972656, -0.008674622, 0.011955261, 0.02571106, -0.052215576, -0.035247803, 0.07110596, 0.008377075, 0.0003809929, 0.0129776, -0.024932861, -0.016403198, -0.012550354, 0.019104004, 0.014411926, -0.0015573502, 0.014053345, 0.010375977, 0.020980835, -0.015113831, 0.014083862, -0.0019664764, 0.020889282, -0.027145386, 0.012199402, 0.040618896, 0.016525269, 0.0059661865, 0.042510986, 0.0055007935, -0.014511108, -0.042266846, -0.01134491, -0.010520935, -0.0030994415, 0.032196045, 0.014556885, 0.04574585, 0.027923584, -0.008224487, 0.021774292, -0.01058197, -0.039031982, -0.0048828125, 0.002199173, -0.013145447, -0.012512207, 0.018447876, 0.026428223, -0.0058250427, 0.006504059, -0.022598267, 0.028961182, -0.030166626, -0.011177063, 0.0033302307, 0.008102417, -0.062683105, -0.0524292, -0.06933594, 0.0025806427, 0.0030536652, 0.004463196, -0.0047340393, -0.009590149, 0.019302368, 0.011520386, -0.03643799, -0.0035991669, 0.034942627, -0.013031006, -0.008995056, -0.05432129, -0.0055389404, -0.026000977, -0.08502197, -0.036254883, -0.02180481, -0.0040359497, 0.04147339, -0.0021686554, -0.014015198, -0.003271103, 0.022888184, 0.0024166107, 0.03878784, -0.01612854, -0.035949707, -0.01777649, -0.025863647, -0.034698486, 0.037017822, 0.03970337, -0.011131287, -0.028762817, 0.010284424, -0.045196533, -0.02670288, -0.055999756, 0.022537231, 0.01398468, 0.014289856, 0.029327393, 0.019989014, 0.010185242, 0.02027893, 0.039154053, 0.011146545, -0.028411865, -0.05545044, 0.023498535, 0.04977417, -0.0020942688, 0.014793396, 0.04043579, 0.022705078, -0.023284912, 0.0012769699, 0.032714844, 0.02444458, -0.019073486, -0.019714355, 0.016937256, -0.040008545, -0.03289795, -0.0026817322, -0.021759033, 0.03338623, -0.05230713, 0.047607422, -0.014923096, 0.011108398, 0.03137207, -0.0031223297, -0.01033783, -0.0077438354, 0.0038013458, -0.067871094, -0.06463623, -0.02168274, 0.067871094, -0.023223877, -0.018951416, 0.012748718, 0.013122559, 0.004753113, 0.04272461, -0.0020961761, 0.019836426, -0.0048675537, -0.0017957687, -0.0055160522, -0.056121826, -0.015434265, 0.010665894, -0.004497528, 0.002696991, -0.04434204, -0.059051514, -0.029266357, -0.04763794, 0.000116467476, -0.0014410019, 0.01826477, -0.0637207, 0.018798828, 0.055877686, 0.0062179565, 0.0003376007, 0.0029888153, -0.006958008, 0.055786133, 0.04498291, 0.0037326813, 0.024032593, 0.030273438, -0.022216797, -0.007030487, 0.021591187, 0.051971436, 0.015296936, -0.044921875, 0.002035141, -0.035980225, -0.020614624, 0.017044067, 0.021591187, -0.00983429, 0.037872314, -0.046203613, 0.02619934, 0.0077209473, -0.039916992, 0.005897522, -0.019195557, -0.00061035156, 0.036346436, -0.03640747, 0.01033783, 0.009117126, -0.02708435, -0.039855957, -0.047943115, 0.04888916, -0.008964539, -0.020111084, -0.006088257, 0.009925842, -0.045074463, 0.013366699, -0.013137817, -0.10223389, 0.011451721, -0.0026226044, 0.02859497, 0.0184021, -0.0037956238, -0.072509766, -0.017074585, 0.029296875, -0.045837402, -0.052612305, 0.04373169, 0.014144897, -0.047546387, -0.0035705566, -0.0041236877, -0.0042381287, -0.0024032593, 0.030563354, -0.012519836, -0.038116455, 0.018203735, -0.006958008, 0.008850098, 0.0031108856, 0.031280518, -0.025238037, 0.012519836, 0.03955078, -0.03387451, 0.03250122, 0.022201538, 0.054107666, 0.023513794, -0.05166626, 0.021560669, 0.01828003, 0.026351929, -0.0035438538, 0.023666382, 0.030761719, 0.019729614, 0.023376465, 0.018463135, 0.08850098, -0.039520264, -0.04837036, -0.016815186, 0.00522995, -0.027236938, 0.039978027, -0.019866943, -0.04272461, -0.023483276, -0.07891846, -0.028289795, 0.014465332, 0.030578613, 0.0058059692, 0.007598877, -0.099609375, 0.00021076202, -0.08673096, -0.006374359, -0.017425537, 0.012763977, -0.028015137, -0.024627686, 0.027496338, -0.01701355, -0.0017929077, -0.029708862, 0.03277588, -0.013763428, -0.023391724, 0.0026779175, 0.022842407, 0.0038547516, -0.027511597, -0.014953613, 0.052093506, -0.001080513, 0.007850647, 0.043060303, -0.006412506, 0.018936157, 0.012512207, 0.053588867, 0.04196167, 0.010063171, 0.0141067505, 0.011024475, -0.027130127, -0.04220581, 0.033447266, -0.05206299, -0.008483887, -0.05911255, -0.03048706, -0.06161499, -0.0063819885, 0.015945435, 0.035125732, 0.025436401, -0.0038166046, 0.015792847, 0.009063721, 0.031829834, 0.013389587, 0.053619385, 0.07208252, 0.021636963, -0.0024852753, -0.0077705383, 0.0042304993, 0.018936157, -0.001876831, 0.0385437, 0.030761719, -0.00969696, -0.017791748, 0.0151901245, 0.011566162, -0.021987915, 0.013870239, -0.009216309, 0.09515381, 0.016815186, 0.044921875, 0.06021118, 0.050933838, -0.031799316, -0.020812988, 0.0013027191, 0.014976501, 0.0072288513, -0.01524353, 0.04748535, -0.03060913, 0.025054932, -0.0124053955, -0.03717041, -0.021820068, 0.033172607, 0.020187378, -0.033325195, -0.006187439, 0.009567261, 0.02557373, 0.022094727, 0.018066406, -0.03652954, -0.0055007935, 0.029144287, 0.020568848, -0.02331543, -0.027755737, 0.011314392, 0.013282776, 0.016067505, 0.015319824, 0.0045166016, 0.03414917, -0.00869751, 0.045837402, -0.041778564, 0.012161255, -0.025512695, -0.03048706, -0.0018882751, 0.007873535, -0.026748657, -0.02859497, 0.058776855, 0.000021994114, -0.005180359, 0.040283203, 0.03189087, -0.011184692, -0.035736084, -0.039367676, -0.006866455, 0.037078857, -0.006336212, -0.011878967, 0.0027637482, -0.039001465, 0.04574585, 0.012359619, 0.11206055, -0.037902832, -0.01939392, -0.051574707, 0.047332764, -0.016860962, -0.035858154, 0.0010519028, -0.061798096, -0.0016441345, -0.01777649, -0.003282547, -0.04434204, -0.038208008, -0.01260376, 0.021972656, -0.016952515, 0.010017395, -0.007987976, -0.028686523, 0.00057554245, 0.051971436, 0.015548706, 0.07849121, 0.044189453, -0.001335144, -0.013305664, -0.017791748, 0.01751709, -0.0019950867, -0.014602661, -0.004261017, -0.0262146, -0.0014219284, -0.0017080307, 0.029296875, -0.031341553, -0.068481445, -0.0013885498, 0.0004582405, -0.040618896, -0.010055542, 0.0335083, -0.052368164, 0.006965637, 0.0018510818, -0.03289795, 0.06329346, 0.029632568, 0.0015554428, -0.011734009, 0.0345459, -0.019729614, 0.0052986145, 0.0059661865, 0.020614624, -0.01739502, -0.04107666, -0.015159607, 0.033233643, 0.0052375793, -0.052001953, -0.049713135, 0.032836914, 0.07659912, -0.021118164, 0.0012302399, 0.017105103, 0.02029419, 0.02053833, 0.039001465, 0.0068626404, -0.04345703, -0.024978638, -0.010421753, 0.06100464, 0.029647827, -0.023040771, -0.0016870499, 0.021408081, -0.03390503, -0.010375977, -0.012664795, 0.002210617, -0.004638672, 0.008468628, 0.0284729, 0.0009689331, -0.018203735, -0.010437012, 0.028518677, -0.0039901733, 0.034698486, -0.020004272, 0.02331543, 0.010169983, 0.0513916, -0.008575439, -0.025405884, 0.076049805, 0.018173218, 0.034973145, 0.00040626526, 0.020446777, -0.00077581406, 0.010261536, -0.023452759, -0.019897461, -0.018844604, 0.07092285, -0.050109863, -0.017150879, -0.048736572, -0.041259766, 0.004837036, -0.037597656, 0.037017822, -0.038330078, 0.02532959, -0.043945312, 0.010139465, 0.013450623, 0.012649536, 0.0234375, -0.024017334, -0.022415161, -0.019104004, 0.042663574, -0.00919342 ], "summary": [ 0.027755737, 0.014465332, 0.002817154, -0.060638428, -0.016082764, 0.0063209534, -0.07745361, -0.030578613, 0.036193848, -0.029083252, -0.0881958, 0.00014638901, -0.057556152, -0.029754639, -0.0038795471, -0.05105591, 0.021118164, 0.0003578663, 0.0028362274, -0.028396606, 0.010848999, -0.021942139, 0.021911621, 0.04348755, -0.027450562, 0.023117065, -0.028671265, -0.00894165, -0.041625977, -0.005256653, -0.010688782, 0.024749756, 0.0051574707, 0.027557373, 0.012954712, 0.045013428, -0.033325195, 0.031219482, 0.035186768, -0.012199402, 0.013847351, -0.0043678284, 0.140625, -0.061431885, 0.046813965, 0.0692749, -0.026870728, -0.058685303, 0.01586914, 0.03756714, 0.008720398, 0.014823914, 0.003929138, 0.0014743805, -0.0029773712, -0.017181396, -0.028778076, 0.004962921, 0.029846191, 0.04107666, -0.006679535, -0.018859863, 0.0037250519, -0.025146484, -0.020980835, -0.008972168, 0.044708252, 0.006061554, 0.055755615, -0.0007638931, -0.0026893616, 0.05517578, 0.028427124, 0.0063591003, -0.0473938, -0.027542114, 0.010864258, -0.0039024353, 0.04421997, -0.033843994, 0.03353882, 0.010635376, 0.031311035, 0.016845703, 0.0032100677, 0.02456665, -0.012588501, -0.046539307, -0.012641907, -0.053649902, -0.020553589, -0.034301758, -0.05819702, 0.013145447, 0.02734375, -0.081848145, -0.007133484, -0.031143188, 0.0052452087, -0.021392822, 0.033203125, -0.0287323, -0.020370483, 0.017227173, -0.016586304, 0.021942139, -0.015296936, -0.084350586, -0.019592285, 0.024383545, -0.022720337, -0.049682617, 0.01965332, -0.042816162, 0.0069847107, 0.015670776, 0.02041626, 0.033843994, 0.029525757, -0.022537231, 0.016586304, 0.010520935, 0.032226562, 0.047668457, -0.014801025, 0.014251709, -0.03677368, -0.038208008, -0.038635254, 0.03692627, 0.024856567, 0.03074646, -0.031280518, -0.020446777, -0.059661865, -0.01121521, 0.048065186, -0.011756897, 0.01586914, -0.019454956, 0.031280518, -0.017745972, -0.03540039, 0.026046753, -0.015930176, 0.013336182, 0.029632568, 0.025939941, -0.04107666, -0.049194336, 0.03289795, 0.0070648193, 0.057891846, -0.008285522, -0.080200195, -0.023895264, -0.013053894, -0.020889282, -0.021331787, -0.06414795, 0.07739258, -0.00945282, -0.04324341, 0.06173706, 0.027709961, -0.01626587, 0.0054359436, 0.012786865, 0.02809143, -0.04196167, 0.05871582, -0.007835388, 0.04034424, 0.011550903, 0.01626587, 0.008346558, -0.008857727, 0.060760498, 0.028564453, -0.074523926, -0.014915466, -0.040740967, 0.057403564, -0.0059318542, 0.025512695, -0.042297363, -0.003282547, -0.012207031, 0.017608643, 0.02418518, -0.04940796, 0.009048462, -0.026000977, 0.006580353, -0.005859375, 0.007827759, -0.010864258, 0.020706177, -0.009506226, -0.030838013, 0.04748535, -0.030166626, 0.04067993, -0.04043579, -0.017333984, -0.021316528, 0.005886078, 0.0015439987, 0.015083313, 0.01966858, -0.005191803, -0.040039062, -0.011192322, 0.035339355, 0.016952515, 0.012420654, -0.015792847, -0.022216797, 0.0028133392, 0.0022125244, 0.013648987, 0.010108948, -0.020431519, -0.025131226, 0.011276245, 0.04156494, -0.03390503, 0.022033691, 0.015541077, 0.04095459, -0.011604309, -0.018951416, -0.05307007, -0.0099105835, -0.020217896, -0.011909485, 0.025680542, 0.007663727, 0.022659302, 0.00819397, 0.017044067, -0.008232117, -0.020492554, 0.03717041, -0.002632141, -0.03643799, -0.0064697266, 0.024917603, -0.008224487, -0.01007843, -0.015777588, -0.025787354, 0.06347656, -0.034606934, -0.020904541, 0.058746338, -0.0340271, -0.039245605, 0.033477783, -0.018600464, 0.017318726, 0.048919678, 0.013458252, 0.017684937, -0.040222168, 0.025878906, -0.0073890686, 0.014190674, 0.006336212, 0.007949829, -0.0019493103, -0.058135986, 0.010932922, 0.009513855, -0.016479492, 0.04006958, -0.012718201, -0.01838684, 0.028366089, 0.017669678, -0.023986816, -0.031311035, -0.0022506714, -0.0038642883, 0.04046631, -0.01436615, 0.030960083, -0.0012674332, -0.035980225, -0.037231445, 0.025314331, -0.016571045, -0.035308838, -0.0021209717, 0.008178711, -0.050323486, 0.024429321, 0.055541992, -0.008491516, 0.008110046, 0.0031280518, 0.01914978, -0.022781372, 0.014190674, -0.0024471283, 0.006839752, -0.019973755, 0.04156494, 0.026397705, -0.066101074, 0.062561035, 0.060943604, -0.012496948, -0.027999878, -0.05343628, -0.03994751, -0.06201172, -0.011642456, -0.06088257, 0.040924072, 0.0056610107, 0.012367249, -0.043304443, 0.014671326, 0.012367249, 0.004562378, 0.002904892, -0.027526855, 0.0006775856, 0.004558563, 0.015792847, -0.02999878, -0.03540039, -0.05355835, 0.013114929, 0.0026760101, 0.011558533, 0.0051116943, 0.0013561249, -0.007835388, 0.033477783, -0.003376007, 0.010360718, 0.026763916, -0.044891357, 0.04232788, 0.00031352043, 0.022155762, -0.09234619, -0.022781372, 0.027450562, -0.051940918, -0.03451538, -0.016098022, -0.015640259, 0.047424316, 0.042999268, -0.02798462, 0.013801575, -0.0635376, 0.05819702, 0.039001465, 0.037994385, -0.05770874, -0.07470703, -0.033416748, 0.018630981, -0.01335907, 0.066711426, 0.038726807, -0.033325195, 0.062805176, -0.04284668, 0.003288269, 0.0440979, 0.004234314, 0.070739746, 0.0051994324, -0.039367676, 0.032958984, -0.0023784637, -0.0048675537, -0.0058135986, -0.03277588, 0.024597168, 0.014785767, 0.0597229, -0.00022137165, 0.056640625, -0.042053223, 0.028579712, 0.0016965866, 0.011688232, -0.027679443, 0.00041222572, 0.008956909, -0.017150879, -0.0015134811, -0.010932922, -0.017822266, -0.03326416, 0.0010213852, -0.018173218, -0.021774292, 0.008422852, -0.05557251, -0.010246277, -0.04638672, 0.017410278, 0.0074691772, 0.0007481575, 0.0050811768, -0.020248413, 0.011932373, -0.007534027, -0.020706177, 0.00033926964, 0.004463196, -0.000065505505, -0.027648926, 0.0040664673, 0.029846191, -0.030654907, 0.0019168854, 0.037506104, 0.027557373, 0.024658203, -0.034362793, 0.055541992, -0.0050735474, 0.019546509, -0.009933472, -0.009132385, -0.039886475, -0.03604126, -0.017364502, -0.023239136, 0.014541626, -0.0009379387, -0.01499176, -0.050598145, -0.0236969, 0.02154541, 0.014122009, 0.0040740967, 0.009773254, -0.00944519, -0.019302368, -0.013381958, 0.015716553, -0.0033855438, 0.0058555603, 0.022644043, 0.032073975, -0.012634277, -0.0055503845, -0.054260254, 0.02558899, 0.049194336, -0.015312195, -0.007194519, -0.029449463, 0.013298035, 0.008003235, 0.0385437, 0.016540527, 0.014785767, 0.0038032532, -0.0062446594, 0.010520935, 0.010795593, -0.044525146, -0.006614685, -0.010101318, -0.0018577576, -0.05593872, 0.008811951, 0.053833008, -0.013221741, -0.025970459, -0.05831909, 0.03161621, 0.023529053, -0.053466797, -0.034698486, 0.019821167, -0.024475098, -0.03656006, 0.0028514862, 0.046325684, 0.025924683, -0.003112793, 0.024887085, 0.0071983337, -0.018798828, 0.015213013, -0.0137786865, 0.07122803, 0.020187378, -0.041809082, 0.007587433, -0.00006335974, 0.012367249, -0.01625061, -0.009773254, -0.010566711, -0.018829346, 0.005176544, 0.023239136, -0.005382538, -0.034118652, -0.00422287, 0.033721924, -0.00919342, -0.0039367676, 0.027618408, 0.018310547, -0.0068588257, 0.0040740967, 0.0039711, 0.022766113, 0.014816284, 0.03967285, 0.02709961, -0.032226562, -0.018157959, 0.008110046, -0.008659363, -0.0054092407, -0.0036888123, 0.018234253, 0.022109985, 0.03189087, 0.014526367, 0.0071411133, -0.00036215782, -0.017318726, -0.048095703, 0.005672455, 0.060668945, -0.021316528, -0.030059814, -0.0069732666, 0.0637207, -0.015258789, -0.0155181885, -0.021621704, -0.0025348663, -0.025619507, -0.050598145, 0.025131226, 0.030441284, -0.053131104, -0.04675293, -0.028015137, 0.06604004, 0.016082764, -0.0038585663, -0.016693115, -0.00548172, -0.0025367737, 0.016693115, 0.000115573406, -0.02911377, 0.029129028, 0.014343262, -0.007858276, -0.037353516, 0.0020713806, -0.034088135, -0.04925537, -0.026153564, -0.021606445, -0.030181885, 0.0001642704, 0.0051841736, -0.020004272, -0.0026664734, -0.00390625, -0.025497437, 0.018081665, 0.0135650635, -0.009841919, -0.060577393, -0.013870239, -0.0138549805, 0.052215576, 0.030532837, 0.015525818, -0.012878418, -0.008590698, -0.043273926, -0.014251709, -0.09906006, -0.00069236755, 0.029312134, -0.01373291, 0.047943115, -0.00008922815, 0.009216309, 0.02746582, 0.034698486, 0.0126953125, -0.011619568, -0.04244995, 0.013046265, 0.040222168, 0.006187439, -0.017425537, -0.0022907257, 0.028167725, 0.0062828064, -0.019348145, 0.008636475, -0.016403198, -0.018814087, -0.006629944, 0.01826477, 0.019851685, -0.045806885, 0.012664795, -0.0084991455, -0.015731812, 0.027893066, 0.018814087, 0.027618408, 0.020599365, 0.010665894, -0.026748657, 0.00055646896, -0.02180481, -0.005580902, -0.055755615, -0.05340576, -0.016098022, 0.049316406, -0.008155823, -0.014450073, 0.008773804, -0.005897522, -0.009498596, 0.03262329, -0.0017337799, 0.010025024, 0.007797241, -0.013542175, -0.00023913383, -0.024749756, -0.004634857, -0.017868042, 0.033996582, -0.00019943714, -0.009056091, -0.062072754, 0.002325058, -0.051727295, 0.0051078796, 0.0021209717, 0.002286911, -0.049957275, -0.03225708, 0.018966675, -0.013183594, -0.014312744, 0.010009766, -0.006767273, 0.055908203, 0.02268982, -0.009117126, 0.0033054352, -0.0010547638, -0.0071411133, -0.026794434, -0.023406982, 0.0105896, 0.03186035, -0.044830322, 0.017333984, -0.015609741, -0.00724411, -0.023635864, 0.02027893, 0.058898926, -0.0017061234, -0.019851685, 0.053466797, 0.042053223, -0.040374756, -0.002817154, 0.010498047, -0.016708374, -0.00046992302, -0.009849548, 0.0036258698, -0.006515503, -0.024368286, 0.00233078, -0.06311035, 0.018875122, -0.023620605, -0.0032901764, -0.016220093, 0.031097412, -0.021362305, -0.005218506, -0.00026011467, -0.05999756, 0.009132385, 0.03024292, 0.026763916, 0.018920898, -0.0064849854, -0.062927246, -0.024261475, 0.04675293, -0.04840088, -0.036254883, 0.031555176, -0.00466156, -0.05090332, -0.0077056885, 0.051574707, 0.024215698, -0.04446411, 0.01927185, -0.009429932, -0.056854248, 0.015731812, 0.0051498413, -0.008987427, 0.039855957, -0.0061454773, -0.092041016, 0.0423584, 0.06518555, -0.0031337738, 0.044555664, 0.013450623, 0.03857422, 0.016723633, -0.048614502, 0.020874023, 0.018005371, 0.025634766, 0.00333786, 0.022567749, 0.008682251, 0.046051025, 0.043914795, 0.01625061, 0.04373169, 0.0287323, -0.07122803, -0.002210617, 0.031097412, 0.03692627, 0.036193848, -0.024810791, -0.075927734, 0.003396988, -0.09509277, 0.018157959, 0.0055389404, 0.012039185, 0.04537964, 0.022079468, -0.061340332, 0.03778076, -0.0289917, -0.012771606, -0.014518738, 0.008323669, -0.020385742, -0.020385742, 0.049865723, -0.010513306, 0.010902405, -0.018859863, 0.030670166, -0.041412354, -0.031173706, 0.01751709, 0.062683105, 0.025817871, -0.044769287, 0.06652832, 0.04458618, 0.042236328, -0.03552246, -0.009933472, 0.02041626, 0.0135650635, 0.016815186, 0.008590698, 0.013938904, 0.009994507, 0.026733398, -0.009101868, -0.04135132, -0.020004272, 0.009292603, 0.00086545944, -0.011375427, 0.009132385, -0.020446777, -0.007484436, 0.011779785, 0.029632568, 0.022903442, 0.03286743, 0.009559631, 0.000808239, 0.024017334, -0.003288269, 0.030273438, 0.0335083, 0.038513184, 0.0110321045, 0.026153564, -0.02319336, -0.014839172, 0.02468872, 0.026290894, 0.0104599, -0.033935547, 0.020492554, -0.017089844, -0.0031776428, -0.015007019, 0.0072669983, 0.03753662, -0.0087509155, 0.12359619, 0.057769775, 0.07373047, 0.014213562, 0.016708374, 0.017944336, -0.048675537, -0.0057029724, -0.008430481, -0.0073280334, 0.0048103333, -0.0068740845, -0.012901306, 0.021987915, 0.0061454773, -0.012199402, 0.036987305, 0.024917603, 0.0014238358, -0.04623413, -0.021133423, -0.000097334385, 0.0098724365, 0.022598267, 0.014328003, -0.04309082, -0.008293152, 0.0019283295, -0.008651733, -0.011558533, -0.051239014, -0.0014209747, -0.02708435, 0.036102295, 0.015312195, 0.009315491, 0.05947876, 0.021575928, 0.042419434, -0.04348755, 0.0067596436, -0.02204895, -0.023635864, -0.01171875, 0.012557983, -0.020477295, -0.013206482, 0.01134491, -0.021209717, -0.04135132, -0.003206253, -0.008163452, -0.012046814, -0.0501709, -0.010620117, -0.0019264221, 0.036376953, 0.037139893, 0.022033691, -0.018920898, -0.022918701, 0.06359863, 0.032958984, 0.12133789, -0.028366089, -0.0209198, -0.07318115, 0.053009033, -0.07714844, -0.013595581, 0.04019165, -0.0770874, 0.004825592, -0.011268616, -0.021194458, -0.031051636, -0.016860962, -0.028793335, 0.024780273, -0.0000059604645, 0.0056037903, 0.003660202, -0.010353088, 0.018356323, 0.031555176, 0.031829834, 0.073913574, 0.03161621, -0.019134521, 0.009986877, -0.019104004, 0.010726929, 0.03277588, 0.019317627, 0.01902771, -0.03604126, -0.0134887695, -0.003232956, 0.02507019, -0.0423584, -0.07043457, 0.041992188, -0.00039958954, -0.028808594, -0.008110046, 0.020263672, -0.03704834, 0.04736328, 0.0012750626, -0.0055351257, 0.05999756, 0.020233154, 0.0090408325, 0.04348755, 0.0063285828, -0.01184845, 0.0026454926, 0.021072388, -0.0027389526, 0.0151901245, -0.05026245, -0.011695862, 0.011375427, -0.014823914, -0.052764893, -0.017349243, 0.05407715, 0.11260986, -0.021942139, -0.034698486, -0.002254486, -0.013084412, 0.03829956, 0.044830322, 0.006980896, -0.0289917, -0.025726318, -0.005279541, 0.017318726, 0.010810852, 0.00137043, -0.016418457, 0.017318726, -0.033081055, -0.025512695, -0.0034217834, 0.027679443, -0.015388489, 0.010719299, 0.03781128, -0.01676941, -0.030944824, 0.014282227, -0.02357483, 0.0054969788, -0.0057868958, -0.03250122, 0.00005787611, -0.034179688, 0.005680084, -0.04727173, 0.00869751, 0.037902832, -0.010482788, 0.018936157, -0.03692627, 0.05239868, 0.046844482, 0.048461914, -0.024612427, -0.021270752, -0.011077881, 0.080200195, -0.073791504, -0.09051514, -0.03527832, -0.014541626, 0.022369385, -0.018661499, 0.02154541, 0.015007019, 0.0016469955, 0.027999878, -0.008377075, 0.02355957, -0.005130768, 0.047424316, -0.022094727, 0.028671265, 0.027160645, 0.019058228, 0.03137207 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2202.08303v1
OpenKBP-Opt: An international and reproducible evaluation of 76 knowledge-based planning pipelines
Aaron Babier, Rafid Mahmood, Binghao Zhang, Victor G. L. Alves, Ana Maria Barragán-Montero, Joel Beaudry, Carlos E. Cardenas, Yankui Chang, Zijie Chen, Jaehee Chun, Kelly Diaz, Harold David Eraso, Erik Faustmann, Sibaji Gaj, Skylar Gay, Mary Gronberg, Bingqi Guo, Junjun He, Gerd Heilemann, Sanchit Hira, Yuliang Huang, Fuxin Ji, Dashan Jiang, Jean Carlo Jimenez Giraldo, Hoyeon Lee, Jun Lian, Shuolin Liu, Keng-Chi Liu, José Marrugo, Kentaro Miki, Kunio Nakamura, Tucker Netherton, Dan Nguyen, Hamidreza Nourzadeh, Alexander F. I. Osman, Zhao Peng, José Darío Quinto Muñoz, Christian Ramsl, Dong Joo Rhee, Juan David Rodriguez, Hongming Shan, Jeffrey V. Siebers, Mumtaz H. Soomro, Kay Sun, Andrés Usuga Hoyos, Carlos Valderrama, Rob Verbeek, Enpei Wang, Siri Willems, Qi Wu, Xuanang Xu, Sen Yang, Lulin Yuan, Simeng Zhu, Lukas Zimmermann, Kevin L. Moore, Thomas G. Purdie, Andrea L. McNiven, Timothy C. Y. Chan
physics.med-ph, cs.AI, cs.CV
We establish an open framework for developing plan optimization models for knowledge-based planning (KBP) in radiotherapy. Our framework includes reference plans for 100 patients with head-and-neck cancer and high-quality dose predictions from 19 KBP models that were developed by different research groups during the OpenKBP Grand Challenge. The dose predictions were input to four optimization models to form 76 unique KBP pipelines that generated 7600 plans. The predictions and plans were compared to the reference plans via: dose score, which is the average mean absolute voxel-by-voxel difference in dose a model achieved; the deviation in dose-volume histogram (DVH) criterion; and the frequency of clinical planning criteria satisfaction. We also performed a theoretical investigation to justify our dose mimicking models. The range in rank order correlation of the dose score between predictions and their KBP pipelines was 0.50 to 0.62, which indicates that the quality of the predictions is generally positively correlated with the quality of the plans. Additionally, compared to the input predictions, the KBP-generated plans performed significantly better (P<0.05; one-sided Wilcoxon test) on 18 of 23 DVH criteria. Similarly, each optimization model generated plans that satisfied a higher percentage of criteria than the reference plans. Lastly, our theoretical investigation demonstrated that the dose mimicking models generated plans that are also optimal for a conventional planning model. This was the largest international effort to date for evaluating the combination of KBP prediction and optimization models. In the interest of reproducibility, our data and code is freely available at https://github.com/ababier/open-kbp-opt.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2202.08303v1
2022-02-16T19:18:42
2022-02-16T19:18:42
{ "title": [ -0.04537964, -0.0209198, -0.03213501, -0.05041504, -0.02633667, 0.01322937, -0.07165527, -0.024993896, -0.029815674, 0.0048942566, -0.04550171, 0.039794922, -0.038360596, -0.01927185, 0.009033203, -0.010505676, 0.013000488, 0.014717102, -0.047973633, -0.036834717, -0.012939453, -0.037353516, 0.008293152, 0.09240723, 0.029525757, -0.042419434, -0.08337402, 0.023422241, -0.059020996, -0.037231445, -0.02142334, 0.052612305, 0.036865234, -0.018173218, 0.03161621, 0.002193451, -0.03564453, 0.014076233, 0.0019273758, 0.0013113022, 0.006729126, -0.003818512, -0.029159546, -0.038024902, -0.0657959, 0.048583984, -0.09100342, 0.006893158, -0.02935791, 0.06738281, 0.02722168, 0.0013494492, 0.008644104, 0.050323486, 0.016448975, -0.039764404, -0.00945282, -0.013648987, 0.036254883, 0.04058838, 0.0050582886, -0.056243896, 0.03213501, -0.013427734, -0.060150146, -0.023361206, -0.0028858185, 0.016815186, 0.0703125, -0.03527832, -0.0231781, 0.0692749, 0.014045715, 0.008842468, -0.0340271, -0.025100708, 0.04724121, -0.0068588257, 0.03137207, -0.03237915, -0.010238647, 0.0048599243, -0.013145447, -0.029373169, -0.014587402, -0.058746338, -0.023406982, -0.0015420914, -0.037384033, -0.06390381, -0.0063972473, 0.006866455, -0.062438965, 0.021270752, -0.01902771, -0.029953003, -0.026153564, 0.0017814636, 0.008857727, -0.014419556, 0.006793976, 0.00017511845, -0.037017822, -0.0135269165, 0.00049209595, 0.0680542, -0.0031166077, -0.006664276, -0.016601562, 0.019561768, 0.0027065277, -0.029159546, -0.0017080307, -0.0028762817, 0.010910034, 0.009887695, -0.024002075, 0.015235901, 0.0013170242, -0.006690979, -0.024841309, -0.026641846, 0.014762878, 0.010978699, 0.04437256, 0.023422241, -0.045440674, 0.022964478, -0.0056381226, 0.04360962, 0.030075073, 0.043548584, -0.12017822, -0.105773926, -0.08282471, 0.036834717, 0.012466431, -0.01878357, -0.011688232, -0.006095886, -0.013366699, -0.00089502335, 0.017944336, -0.033477783, 0.02670288, 0.026123047, 0.05303955, -0.014564514, -0.028671265, -0.028945923, 0.0044021606, 0.0060157776, 0.02961731, -0.009231567, -0.03515625, -0.04046631, -0.10534668, -0.028625488, 0.046295166, -0.013038635, 0.0206604, -0.009155273, -0.018997192, -0.011062622, 0.014709473, 0.007385254, -0.026626587, 0.02267456, -0.0023040771, 0.04827881, -0.031463623, -0.016693115, -0.01914978, -0.024215698, -0.037994385, 0.0158844, 0.057556152, -0.0075149536, -0.0026721954, 0.032348633, 0.02960205, -0.000626564, 0.008110046, 0.029312134, -0.05038452, -0.013496399, 0.0048599243, -0.009521484, 0.04031372, 0.003917694, -0.0051002502, 0.036712646, -0.013587952, -0.05239868, -0.011543274, -0.021514893, 0.030014038, 0.0075645447, -0.004776001, -0.0024967194, -0.04019165, -0.011077881, -0.02607727, 0.01701355, 0.022384644, -0.046722412, 0.0079422, 0.019866943, -0.0047454834, 0.04321289, 0.035858154, 0.018859863, -0.04135132, 0.026733398, -0.019821167, -0.051361084, 0.014350891, -0.03149414, -0.0036449432, -0.0058021545, 0.02142334, -0.0029125214, -0.0006117821, 0.045135498, -0.018112183, 0.00049448013, -0.002960205, -0.027633667, 0.029251099, 0.02368164, 0.056488037, -0.043640137, -0.019378662, 0.043670654, 0.014343262, -0.023376465, -0.018081665, -0.0036849976, 0.018569946, 0.00472641, 0.0013608932, -0.010215759, -0.0012168884, 0.045715332, 0.04562378, -0.0052833557, 0.02041626, 0.018569946, 0.004470825, 0.020065308, 0.070373535, 0.02973938, 0.039093018, 0.070251465, -0.022781372, 0.039398193, -0.03353882, -0.027801514, 0.019592285, -0.021911621, 0.009162903, -0.03857422, -0.015213013, -0.0046157837, -0.016738892, -0.01071167, 0.0012464523, 0.026535034, 0.003206253, -0.012496948, 0.02772522, 0.025802612, 0.00390625, -0.037322998, -0.0016889572, -0.020141602, -0.036132812, 0.039031982, 0.02407837, -0.06573486, -0.0037631989, 0.030471802, 0.03250122, -0.0074043274, 0.022766113, -0.0023117065, -0.0022525787, -0.0129852295, -0.025146484, -0.034576416, 0.031829834, 0.01676941, -0.020874023, 0.015899658, 0.031677246, -0.019104004, 0.04046631, 0.0904541, -0.03326416, 0.038848877, -0.033599854, 0.008728027, 0.008934021, -0.02961731, 0.0043411255, 0.023956299, 0.04244995, 0.011314392, -0.025360107, -0.033081055, -0.009773254, 0.009422302, 0.014167786, -0.05984497, 0.009063721, -0.011756897, 0.014335632, -0.033996582, 0.001127243, 0.021850586, 0.015029907, -0.016143799, -0.018051147, 0.002937317, 0.01789856, -0.010108948, -0.014709473, -0.013618469, -0.021240234, 0.018447876, 0.022338867, 0.0039100647, -0.066711426, -0.017242432, -0.0063591003, 0.016235352, -0.0042877197, 0.01512146, -0.031433105, -0.013313293, -0.0027694702, -0.014511108, 0.0143585205, -0.032836914, 0.031921387, -0.086364746, -0.0031108856, 0.004878998, 0.025238037, 0.02053833, 0.009857178, -0.0049324036, -0.029724121, -0.021331787, 0.044555664, -0.037994385, 0.0033473969, -0.008758545, -0.0029716492, -0.043029785, 0.068115234, 0.015136719, 0.039886475, -0.0524292, -0.02923584, -0.06890869, -0.0043792725, -0.041168213, -0.0030384064, 0.055664062, -0.09185791, 0.03515625, -0.027175903, -0.016555786, -0.023117065, 0.024215698, 0.009132385, -0.021942139, -0.02508545, -0.008514404, 0.0058059692, 0.027694702, -0.04196167, 0.029296875, 0.088134766, -0.008079529, -0.017532349, 0.01108551, 0.033477783, 0.00333786, -0.0074424744, -0.036254883, 0.0010080338, -0.0030822754, 0.0027828217, 0.016448975, -0.02268982, -0.018478394, -0.07366943, 0.009162903, -0.005054474, -0.009468079, -0.018295288, -0.009109497, -0.057281494, -0.03543091, -0.04522705, -0.036102295, 0.0435791, 0.04928589, 0.0073890686, 0.032989502, 0.011894226, -0.006690979, 0.0016107559, -0.015602112, -0.078552246, 0.025619507, -0.031173706, -0.010169983, 0.0059547424, -0.008026123, -0.054748535, -0.010543823, -0.0022411346, 0.04156494, 0.03845215, 0.03314209, 0.00856781, -0.050476074, 0.027267456, -0.056610107, -0.027557373, -0.024932861, -0.007423401, -0.039001465, -0.018310547, 0.033935547, 0.025268555, -0.004524231, -0.019363403, -0.006690979, -0.011566162, 0.018844604, 0.0057868958, -0.042907715, 0.020004272, -0.013847351, 0.024017334, -0.024963379, -0.0053215027, -0.0021209717, 0.0028362274, 0.0053253174, -0.008636475, 0.008460999, 0.008163452, -0.0015096664, 0.00340271, 0.00111866, 0.03225708, 0.00030589104, -0.119140625, 0.010612488, 0.02583313, 0.016906738, -0.008331299, -0.008666992, -0.032470703, 0.008369446, -0.038513184, 0.023849487, 0.017562866, 0.0069084167, -0.008529663, -0.0017776489, -0.0008401871, 0.0063819885, -0.03540039, -0.013786316, 0.009605408, 0.011810303, 0.0025482178, -0.05267334, -0.03366089, 0.033447266, -0.10675049, -0.0149002075, 0.001282692, -0.008956909, 0.013679504, -0.044799805, 0.015205383, -0.016906738, -0.03152466, -0.01890564, -0.01474762, 0.022491455, 0.017471313, -0.05807495, -0.028015137, 0.072265625, 0.011428833, -0.011512756, 0.00932312, -0.000038981438, 0.008056641, -0.041259766, 0.011276245, -0.026473999, 0.037902832, -0.029937744, -0.006061554, 0.030029297, -0.023025513, 0.04107666, 0.0006599426, 0.025512695, -0.017349243, -0.00982666, 0.04360962, 0.044281006, -0.0335083, 0.02027893, 0.05130005, 0.0015687943, -0.08013916, 0.025054932, 0.015029907, 0.012390137, -0.0066375732, -0.05001831, -0.0038261414, 0.0018806458, 0.051483154, 0.04940796, -0.013267517, -0.0013198853, 0.04638672, -0.007648468, 0.00050878525, 0.036834717, 0.013404846, 0.018722534, -0.0042381287, 0.0107040405, -0.01259613, 0.029785156, 0.012954712, -0.029647827, 0.002023697, 0.016586304, -0.045562744, -0.015419006, -0.018127441, -0.048217773, 0.0009965897, -0.004261017, -0.019104004, 0.016326904, 0.026809692, -0.00944519, -0.026046753, -0.0056648254, 0.0473938, 0.0049057007, 0.011306763, -0.036956787, 0.016036987, -0.022979736, -0.059906006, -0.037017822, -0.04425049, -0.03515625, 0.040618896, 0.010429382, -0.036590576, 0.018539429, 0.013572693, 0.075927734, 0.034576416, 0.016906738, -0.04284668, 0.06591797, -0.023971558, 0.0014505386, 0.018096924, -0.032470703, -0.0058784485, 0.0008354187, 0.014785767, -0.0014743805, -0.029510498, -0.03591919, 0.02394104, -0.0029144287, 0.037139893, 0.03945923, 0.056854248, 0.031799316, 0.04510498, 0.005874634, 0.014976501, -0.04547119, -0.05105591, -0.0256958, 0.047454834, 0.005607605, 0.006111145, 0.06225586, 0.011299133, -0.0007009506, 0.023132324, -0.016983032, 0.040222168, 0.010765076, -0.051086426, 0.05923462, 0.020080566, -0.039794922, 0.014251709, -0.00081920624, 0.01928711, -0.018981934, 0.051849365, -0.0390625, 0.011734009, 0.017669678, -0.024154663, 0.009651184, -0.003736496, 0.030151367, -0.029556274, -0.06726074, 0.0050354004, 0.04827881, -0.022949219, -0.0055351257, -0.0104522705, 0.03152466, 0.02684021, 0.04852295, 0.041870117, -0.031341553, -0.0015287399, -0.008735657, -0.008270264, -0.013755798, -0.061553955, -0.014099121, 0.008094788, 0.02670288, -0.03262329, 0.030151367, -0.0680542, 0.00007766485, -0.020004272, -0.027038574, 0.015144348, -0.06262207, 0.018295288, 0.074279785, -0.013679504, 0.057373047, 0.024307251, 0.0013866425, -0.035827637, 0.048797607, -0.035461426, 0.060394287, 0.01626587, -0.062438965, -0.008346558, 0.011459351, 0.030715942, -0.020095825, 0.020462036, -0.0078125, -0.02130127, -0.031173706, 0.022064209, 0.01663208, 0.01625061, -0.01965332, -0.03640747, 0.033111572, 0.0044403076, -0.01890564, 0.050567627, -0.028930664, -0.018295288, -0.00004762411, 0.013137817, -0.040649414, 0.0068969727, 0.060302734, 0.0031604767, -0.023101807, 0.001074791, -0.053863525, 0.008460999, 0.03237915, 0.014846802, 0.003320694, -0.0028076172, 0.012382507, -0.030334473, 0.006252289, -0.02684021, 0.0064849854, 0.009284973, 0.008415222, -0.035980225, 0.008888245, -0.033843994, -0.05657959, -0.051239014, -0.011024475, 0.0037841797, 0.039154053, -0.015068054, -0.03982544, -0.036132812, -0.01448822, 0.019042969, -0.020492554, -0.024963379, 0.02810669, 0.008338928, 0.012130737, -0.0038375854, -0.03338623, 0.00957489, -0.0018892288, -0.02810669, 0.022949219, 0.019058228, -0.013870239, -0.01725769, -0.019165039, -0.05758667, 0.0075531006, 0.016662598, 0.011985779, -0.0057411194, 0.018447876, 0.042022705, 0.05621338, -0.047668457, -0.0015745163, 0.032958984, -0.050872803, -0.040039062, 0.0107040405, -0.0056648254, 0.0023326874, 0.084350586, 0.0013446808, -0.032348633, -0.039001465, -0.055877686, -0.023925781, 0.0010223389, 0.0135650635, -0.00040960312, 0.014480591, -0.033843994, 0.034118652, -0.00374794, -0.011482239, -0.02848816, 0.006504059, 0.0073127747, -0.016174316, 0.021102905, 0.010414124, 0.016921997, -0.015335083, -0.017425537, 0.009613037, -0.007904053, 0.021514893, -0.06707764, 0.0020446777, -0.021957397, 0.00434494, 0.027389526, 0.009048462, -0.054718018, -0.0013561249, -0.021438599, 0.06036377, 0.04711914, -0.0011701584, 0.026687622, 0.020004272, 0.011428833, 0.00818634, 0.03741455, -0.01008606, 0.036376953, -0.021606445, -0.008148193, -0.05291748, -0.02557373, -0.06915283, 0.013938904, 0.02116394, 0.0031280518, 0.015029907, 0.014656067, 0.006969452, 0.00617218, 0.03967285, 0.023986816, 0.05822754, 0.029342651, 0.0013380051, 0.025421143, 0.02558899, -0.0011138916, 0.028823853, 0.010551453, -0.012329102, -0.041992188, -0.0020065308, -0.008575439, 0.000036001205, 0.01071167, -0.011116028, 0.0030708313, -0.024108887, 0.040283203, -0.013114929, 0.026657104, 0.06677246, 0.044189453, -0.011161804, -0.025894165, 0.023132324, -0.014259338, -0.02104187, 0.0055770874, 0.057037354, -0.0960083, 0.043640137, 0.0035133362, -0.032104492, 0.0032157898, 0.028518677, 0.060150146, -0.052581787, -0.03756714, 0.023071289, 0.03765869, -0.0035877228, -0.00957489, -0.035186768, 0.0023078918, 0.053131104, 0.033294678, -0.0026626587, 0.017303467, 0.029785156, 0.05117798, 0.0038261414, 0.013038635, -0.0027484894, 0.014122009, -0.03062439, 0.018096924, -0.018081665, 0.012397766, -0.009361267, -0.04748535, 0.018615723, 0.005077362, -0.05050659, 0.0029525757, -0.001917839, -0.0020179749, 0.034301758, 0.055419922, 0.026306152, 0.004337311, -0.025344849, -0.059448242, 0.041931152, 0.043518066, -0.034698486, 0.028640747, -0.030883789, -0.044189453, 0.03894043, -0.066711426, 0.026428223, -0.048217773, -0.028213501, -0.022155762, 0.018508911, 0.032958984, -0.016952515, -0.046722412, -0.024215698, -0.014160156, -0.010093689, 0.006965637, -0.020095825, -0.015129089, 0.0033569336, 0.035614014, 0.030410767, 0.013336182, 0.0036468506, -0.021133423, -0.073913574, 0.037231445, -0.006626129, 0.077697754, -0.019744873, -0.047058105, -0.042236328, 0.0016889572, 0.041290283, -0.022842407, -0.02355957, -0.05114746, -0.006801605, -0.0054016113, 0.022918701, 0.021652222, -0.022018433, -0.0009460449, 0.028533936, 0.018798828, -0.015487671, -0.0074768066, 0.0005726814, -0.034362793, -0.017425537, 0.0003476143, -0.0345459, 0.020980835, 0.025558472, -0.01763916, 0.036254883, 0.012557983, -0.03161621, -0.01727295, -0.004737854, 0.02079773, 0.012619019, -0.024169922, -0.012863159, 0.054382324, 0.032806396, -0.051483154, -0.0039634705, 0.03286743, 0.021377563, 0.0121154785, 0.09246826, 0.0021953583, 0.016952515, -0.024230957, 0.07287598, 0.004196167, -0.046905518, 0.00034999847, -0.00078344345, 0.0015239716, 0.043884277, -0.0018968582, 0.0047035217, 0.03390503, -0.025039673, 0.000620842, -0.009300232, 0.0096206665, 0.012741089, 0.012237549, 0.08215332, -0.009254456, 0.009048462, -0.022109985, 0.005104065, 0.0026931763, 0.021087646, -0.029693604, 0.025985718, -0.029403687, 0.022628784, -0.034088135, -0.015052795, 0.052520752, 0.035491943, 0.013153076, 0.044036865, -0.0034599304, 0.0043907166, 0.0043754578, 0.0027275085, -0.017318726, -0.004814148, 0.045440674, -0.018005371, -0.013458252, 0.012779236, -0.049804688, 0.024749756, -0.027008057, 0.02355957, -0.04269409, 0.018249512, -0.009300232, -0.031158447, 0.006000519, 0.021057129, -0.019363403, -0.03302002, -0.038909912, 0.013893127, 0.033416748, -0.015655518 ], "summary": [ 0.009460449, -0.024154663, 0.0011081696, -0.0635376, -0.0284729, 0.008354187, -0.06896973, -0.012039185, -0.057678223, 0.038116455, 0.032562256, 0.045013428, -0.01826477, -0.037841797, 0.034057617, 0.008155823, 0.02217102, 0.028945923, 0.012619019, -0.01687622, 0.040374756, -0.0046577454, -0.027053833, 0.1270752, 0.016448975, -0.045166016, -0.07556152, 0.039916992, -0.057647705, -0.015464783, -0.0021018982, 0.068237305, -0.015106201, 0.022125244, 0.026000977, 0.010597229, 0.0032844543, 0.02986145, 0.053588867, -0.013221741, 0.023712158, -0.024215698, 0.11004639, -0.02420044, 0.01828003, 0.060455322, -0.014793396, -0.039367676, 0.030059814, 0.034942627, 0.0025863647, 0.0076522827, 0.020584106, -0.008132935, -0.016479492, -0.03111267, -0.03314209, -0.01826477, 0.023986816, 0.04144287, 0.01979065, -0.019592285, 0.0018119812, -0.010772705, -0.02760315, 0.0022277832, 0.020507812, -0.0044021606, 0.011703491, -0.051330566, -0.0050811768, 0.031402588, 0.040924072, -0.023956299, -0.03326416, 0.00004196167, 0.016723633, -0.012527466, 0.030471802, -0.040771484, -0.016555786, 0.0006518364, -0.016525269, -0.024215698, -0.025970459, -0.040893555, -0.0154418945, 0.015914917, -0.030380249, -0.0047683716, -0.04095459, 0.0075531006, -0.032440186, 0.032836914, -0.004169464, -0.007129669, -0.086364746, -0.08874512, -0.02659607, 0.0030975342, 0.008842468, 0.0074310303, 0.0015954971, 0.0012359619, -0.017791748, 0.061920166, -0.00021803379, -0.0024490356, 0.0020599365, 0.0064582825, 0.021972656, -0.053131104, -0.0036296844, -0.0362854, -0.005207062, 0.017410278, -0.00076436996, 0.009422302, 0.012046814, -0.011436462, -0.01914978, 0.0040359497, 0.0149383545, 0.027374268, -0.0018720627, 0.011177063, -0.004058838, -0.0020503998, -0.037200928, 0.04135132, 0.023544312, 0.011940002, -0.058685303, -0.018096924, -0.05090332, 0.0021152496, 0.030090332, -0.0107803345, -0.01626587, 0.023544312, -0.028656006, -0.013092041, 0.035064697, -0.030273438, -0.0046653748, 0.03881836, 0.022125244, -0.01739502, -0.00944519, -0.047180176, -0.0019741058, -0.01828003, 0.030044556, -0.019058228, -0.054016113, -0.06048584, -0.016296387, -0.049621582, 0.021240234, -0.05758667, 0.04058838, 0.0035438538, 0.007659912, -0.009552002, -0.036193848, -0.016235352, -0.0340271, -0.0028305054, 0.0036582947, 0.06695557, -0.027053833, -0.03866577, -0.036132812, -0.01448822, -0.02268982, 0.025543213, 0.010536194, -0.006839752, 0.019256592, 0.01651001, -0.005115509, -0.031204224, 0.040222168, -0.0067481995, -0.005218506, -0.011871338, -0.010681152, -0.0016345978, 0.055114746, 0.007003784, -0.045288086, -0.020126343, 0.03427124, -0.0077209473, 0.029312134, -0.034210205, 0.012992859, 0.008712769, 0.0030975342, -0.039916992, -0.008575439, 0.0017585754, -0.0006275177, 0.0027656555, -0.017196655, -0.009414673, -0.0037441254, 0.022613525, -0.026611328, 0.018981934, 0.034729004, 0.005077362, -0.04522705, 0.0340271, 0.0032806396, -0.02458191, -0.020019531, 0.05581665, -0.011367798, 0.03793335, -0.003019333, -0.04623413, -0.0002977848, 0.020492554, 0.034088135, 0.0021896362, -0.0020656586, -0.0011730194, 0.044525146, 0.014259338, 0.007369995, -0.007797241, -0.009292603, 0.045013428, -0.022644043, 0.022460938, 0.036987305, 0.10308838, -0.008773804, -0.026855469, -0.005203247, 0.025436401, -0.048614502, 0.013618469, 0.03564453, 0.022369385, 0.008522034, 0.0049705505, -0.00077676773, 0.03201294, 0.022323608, -0.012123108, -0.0132369995, -0.050750732, -0.011413574, 0.009933472, -0.06060791, -0.030181885, 0.03942871, -0.060302734, 0.010032654, -0.049743652, 0.0013227463, -0.026367188, 0.023391724, -0.032928467, 0.007888794, 0.0025920868, 0.017929077, -0.020751953, 0.00013661385, -0.06347656, -0.0012397766, -0.05419922, -0.046844482, -0.002040863, -0.049865723, 0.055480957, 0.025527954, -0.047058105, -0.024230957, -0.01058197, -0.024551392, -0.026947021, 0.022735596, 0.011497498, -0.024002075, -0.03314209, -0.014411926, -0.003932953, 0.029754639, 0.0023765564, -0.013847351, 0.011360168, 0.033294678, -0.018157959, -0.07159424, 0.009117126, 0.021896362, -0.02607727, -0.014450073, 0.045928955, -0.010986328, 0.012107849, -0.014732361, 0.052246094, 0.008995056, 0.0011806488, -0.016082764, -0.047027588, 0.033050537, -0.0011825562, 0.034301758, 0.0071258545, 0.033966064, -0.0014190674, 0.0012969971, 0.042877197, -0.020843506, -0.0012664795, 0.017807007, 0.020477295, 0.0055274963, 0.014823914, 0.03768921, -0.035217285, 0.015396118, 0.0045318604, 0.0037670135, 0.028961182, 0.015312195, -0.005847931, -0.05303955, -0.027130127, 0.0002732277, 0.02861023, -0.00566864, 0.026779175, -0.016403198, -0.0033493042, -0.021102905, -0.020355225, 0.0116119385, -0.02027893, 0.0040397644, -0.03665161, 0.0020980835, -0.03225708, 0.1126709, 0.043273926, -0.05682373, 0.02897644, -0.040130615, 0.039886475, -0.009628296, -0.03137207, 0.04748535, 0.005859375, -0.04574585, -0.041137695, 0.03817749, 0.015991211, 0.012565613, -0.025177002, -0.049041748, -0.028182983, 0.05166626, -0.046539307, 0.031463623, 0.043914795, -0.02532959, 0.054016113, -0.026535034, -0.013404846, -0.0033569336, -0.015609741, 0.053771973, 0.00074243546, -0.0003244877, 0.030654907, 0.019515991, 0.029968262, -0.0047187805, 0.005970001, 0.057678223, 0.020599365, 0.038146973, 0.026626587, 0.03616333, -0.014877319, -0.0030002594, 0.007385254, 0.07989502, -0.024993896, -0.05923462, -0.00315094, -0.052093506, -0.054779053, 0.03186035, 0.022018433, -0.07720947, 0.018127441, 0.039733887, -0.054595947, -0.015579224, -0.07543945, -0.087402344, -0.028930664, 0.026657104, 0.006427765, 0.015007019, -0.010177612, 0.015731812, -0.01979065, -0.027618408, -0.0036849976, 0.0061149597, 0.020202637, -0.03161621, 0.0005888939, 0.009437561, 0.060943604, -0.002248764, 0.025848389, 0.028839111, 0.04437256, 0.025436401, -0.0033836365, 0.010314941, -0.013839722, 0.049682617, -0.04095459, -0.046844482, -0.05908203, 0.00340271, 0.0023117065, -0.0047187805, 0.047424316, -0.011871338, 0.013893127, -0.05001831, -0.0049552917, -0.007633209, 0.0079193115, -0.004878998, -0.030181885, 0.01777649, -0.040527344, 0.01576233, 0.0007252693, -0.02482605, 0.011680603, 0.04067993, 0.022918701, -0.012062073, -0.0034103394, -0.03567505, 0.0013237, 0.0927124, -0.016616821, 0.0062713623, 0.00907135, -0.09240723, 0.010246277, 0.027175903, -0.00031208992, 0.00033950806, -0.0077819824, 0.007621765, -0.028182983, -0.0027046204, 0.022750854, -0.0023765564, -0.0119018555, -0.0017261505, -0.016693115, 0.029449463, 0.017349243, -0.023330688, -0.045166016, -0.0042304993, 0.009727478, 0.009941101, -0.034088135, -0.042877197, 0.04034424, -0.071777344, -0.00969696, 0.017303467, 0.016204834, 0.03253174, -0.016448975, 0.041625977, 0.00065898895, -0.0079422, -0.01612854, -0.016479492, 0.03427124, 0.0158844, -0.037628174, 0.0056648254, -0.010726929, 0.022949219, -0.004699707, -0.07861328, -0.0044555664, 0.07281494, -0.009521484, 0.02760315, -0.06512451, 0.04159546, -0.026443481, 0.009155273, 0.0079574585, -0.011657715, 0.0011281967, 0.009544373, 0.021911621, -0.019226074, -0.01689148, 0.06738281, 0.09875488, -0.023513794, 0.008232117, 0.023620605, -0.04849243, -0.03036499, -0.008125305, 0.020889282, 0.0032863617, -0.036712646, -0.039886475, -0.042907715, 0.0028095245, 0.09088135, -0.00566864, -0.028244019, -0.025543213, 0.051330566, 0.044433594, -0.017288208, 0.013427734, -0.0028076172, 0.074157715, -0.02508545, -0.051483154, -0.043151855, -0.0135650635, 0.029144287, -0.054107666, 0.025619507, 0.030639648, -0.0014944077, -0.04449463, 0.007080078, 0.005821228, 0.019561768, -0.03491211, 0.0056381226, 0.040130615, -0.00097084045, 0.023880005, -0.00541687, -0.01638794, 0.018478394, 0.022628784, -0.0047073364, -0.022216797, 0.0008339882, -0.015266418, -0.05545044, -0.0070381165, -0.037261963, -0.06677246, 0.010528564, -0.0048599243, -0.040100098, -0.022735596, 0.0039863586, 0.030670166, -0.004360199, 0.032470703, -0.011268616, -0.059265137, 0.002292633, -0.015296936, -0.031188965, -0.0050354004, -0.029663086, -0.031585693, 0.0030574799, 0.0051841736, -0.022109985, -0.066223145, 0.01134491, 0.020736694, 0.005924225, 0.019348145, -0.0071487427, 0.021362305, 0.026290894, 0.011131287, 0.012809753, -0.00217247, -0.05895996, 0.014625549, -0.010643005, 0.06402588, -0.017059326, 0.05532837, -0.019363403, -0.03475952, 0.061462402, -0.04800415, 0.053588867, 0.04711914, -0.058288574, 0.04699707, 0.06402588, -0.011955261, 0.03414917, -0.0043411255, 0.0116119385, 0.04135132, -0.011047363, 0.009788513, -0.004371643, 0.014831543, -0.018569946, 0.008056641, 0.020629883, -0.006942749, -0.028244019, -0.07550049, -0.015007019, 0.055999756, 0.00381279, -0.024215698, -0.0026283264, 0.032043457, 0.033172607, 0.017166138, -0.0038642883, -0.02166748, -0.025436401, 0.0054130554, -0.009178162, -0.034576416, -0.0069122314, -0.019577026, -0.010429382, -0.023391724, -0.0259552, -0.050445557, 0.024398804, -0.05041504, -0.012756348, -0.00003629923, -0.0019683838, -0.03942871, -0.0031852722, 0.041107178, 0.000114798546, 0.010696411, 0.055877686, -0.027740479, -0.020233154, 0.044281006, -0.053009033, 0.0670166, -0.013206482, 0.0016975403, 0.02758789, 0.010559082, 0.005695343, -0.01285553, 0.022613525, -0.011238098, -0.033935547, 0.012290955, -0.01322937, 0.018234253, 0.07946777, -0.027023315, -0.012687683, 0.051818848, 0.03930664, -0.034973145, -0.0019426346, -0.050201416, -0.024429321, -0.0021591187, -0.023101807, -0.016433716, 0.030395508, 0.013626099, -0.0146865845, -0.021072388, 0.0058784485, -0.035247803, -0.0057868958, 0.01399231, 0.008575439, -0.00047302246, -0.016784668, -0.017166138, -0.04989624, -0.02078247, 0.00034451485, 0.022506714, -0.035339355, -0.010696411, -0.031021118, -0.011451721, -0.010803223, -0.022567749, -0.035858154, -0.027297974, -0.030929565, 0.046813965, 0.0152282715, -0.040618896, 0.013511658, -0.0019664764, 0.022720337, -0.010322571, 0.002319336, 0.032043457, -0.011238098, -0.024627686, 0.008644104, 0.00034856796, 0.009208679, -0.0007686615, -0.023117065, -0.018051147, 0.041015625, -0.00843811, 0.019058228, -0.037139893, -0.00041365623, -0.0034065247, 0.03967285, -0.011512756, -0.008865356, 0.036102295, 0.009773254, 0.050354004, -0.031951904, -0.012771606, -0.026855469, 0.027511597, -0.06112671, -0.011779785, 0.019104004, 0.017578125, 0.073791504, 0.014183044, -0.055999756, -0.0028190613, -0.05984497, 0.0009860992, -0.012451172, 0.005092621, 0.016494751, 0.0031433105, -0.010276794, 0.021820068, 0.0020160675, -0.044311523, -0.03213501, -0.017547607, -0.025421143, -0.03555298, 0.09832764, 0.008796692, 0.024810791, -0.025970459, -0.016098022, -0.0017414093, 0.007045746, 0.00039100647, -0.0154953, 0.007297516, -0.021774292, 0.064331055, -0.015380859, 0.050354004, -0.060028076, -0.044006348, -0.012763977, 0.051849365, 0.03918457, -0.070495605, -0.018203735, -0.011108398, -0.010543823, 0.0047950745, 0.046722412, 0.001865387, 0.05105591, 0.000025808811, 0.010948181, -0.01776123, -0.023712158, -0.031082153, 0.031311035, 0.021514893, 0.0014343262, 0.03604126, 0.001373291, 0.015571594, 0.01222229, 0.006084442, 0.0010700226, 0.03363037, 0.10040283, 0.004283905, 0.05517578, -0.03503418, -0.025726318, 0.040130615, 0.019546509, -0.009841919, 0.008415222, 0.0038585663, 0.04949951, -0.040039062, -0.02746582, -0.05609131, 0.024139404, -0.042633057, 0.052337646, 0.0071487427, 0.046081543, 0.040008545, 0.021606445, 0.031982422, -0.036834717, 0.012039185, 0.017791748, -0.027038574, 0.013725281, 0.025863647, -0.038146973, 0.0050811768, -0.0030841827, -0.018676758, 0.016082764, 0.011299133, 0.029037476, -0.018997192, 0.0021953583, -0.0071754456, 0.015510559, 0.014129639, 0.036315918, 0.0004491806, 0.008911133, 0.06951904, 0.028060913, 0.018585205, 0.06939697, 0.031585693, 0.042053223, -0.011299133, 0.025604248, -0.02279663, -0.0078125, -0.059448242, 0.025161743, -0.012382507, -0.026260376, -0.0042495728, -0.026031494, 0.010299683, -0.0044059753, 0.009254456, -0.0044517517, -0.039093018, 0.033203125, 0.02607727, 0.045654297, 0.007507324, 0.009941101, 0.019454956, -0.008735657, 0.0072746277, 0.029373169, -0.010040283, 0.004245758, -0.018112183, -0.00026535988, -0.00031638145, -0.011001587, -0.03515625, -0.034851074, 0.00018680096, -0.044067383, 0.044830322, -0.049743652, -0.026748657, -0.007865906, -0.022125244, -0.02619934, -0.004047394, 0.012954712, -0.019760132, -0.021896362, -0.035888672, 0.01876831, -0.014572144, 0.038116455, 0.04888916, -0.014389038, -0.011680603, 0.048736572, -0.004211426, 0.09411621, -0.048431396, -0.042907715, 0.0035858154, 0.0055122375, 0.060302734, -0.05621338, -0.053131104, -0.020523071, 0.057922363, -0.004005432, -0.011772156, -0.0069274902, -0.0206604, 0.0062332153, 0.040863037, 0.02885437, -0.002254486, 0.024963379, 0.009315491, -0.00019979477, -0.023223877, -0.0008234978, -0.020584106, -0.024917603, -0.025680542, -0.016555786, 0.055267334, 0.035247803, -0.03640747, 0.0028800964, -0.029083252, -0.03164673, -0.0025787354, -0.036590576, 0.0009994507, 0.013465881, -0.0037879944, -0.024108887, -0.008628845, 0.05102539, 0.016616821, -0.005432129, 0.04623413, -0.009880066, 0.023254395, -0.0052452087, 0.08441162, 0.0023841858, -0.038391113, -0.023086548, -0.014518738, 0.017654419, 0.01777649, -0.022415161, -0.00869751, 0.029327393, -0.012527466, -0.019165039, -0.0059318542, 0.017044067, -0.013839722, 0.007019043, 0.04019165, -0.010475159, 0.00052785873, -0.032470703, 0.03643799, -0.027267456, -0.02482605, 0.015327454, 0.007171631, -0.010772705, 0.023117065, -0.04345703, 0.050689697, -0.006587982, -0.021820068, 0.013893127, -0.020187378, 0.020248413, 0.04928589, 0.008728027, -0.0054969788, -0.015182495, -0.0143966675, 0.033294678, -0.014816284, -0.04244995, 0.040405273, -0.015289307, -0.07434082, -0.017593384, -0.007965088, 0.012107849, -0.0027809143, 0.05203247, -0.039031982, 0.033691406, 0.00868988, 0.02217102, 0.00039434433, 0.014625549, 0.02722168, -0.010375977, 0.014526367 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1012.0729v1
Agnostic Learning of Monomials by Halfspaces is Hard
Vitaly Feldman, Venkatesan Guruswami, Prasad Raghavendra, Yi Wu
cs.CC, cs.AI, cs.LG
We prove the following strong hardness result for learning: Given a distribution of labeled examples from the hypercube such that there exists a monomial consistent with $(1-\eps)$ of the examples, it is NP-hard to find a halfspace that is correct on $(1/2+\eps)$ of the examples, for arbitrary constants $\eps > 0$. In learning theory terms, weak agnostic learning of monomials is hard, even if one is allowed to output a hypothesis from the much bigger concept class of halfspaces. This hardness result subsumes a long line of previous results, including two recent hardness results for the proper learning of monomials and halfspaces. As an immediate corollary of our result we show that weak agnostic learning of decision lists is NP-hard. Our techniques are quite different from previous hardness proofs for learning. We define distributions on positive and negative examples for monomials whose first few moments match. We use the invariance principle to argue that regular halfspaces (all of whose coefficients have small absolute value relative to the total $\ell_2$ norm) cannot distinguish between distributions whose first few moments match. For highly non-regular subspaces, we use a structural lemma from recent work on fooling halfspaces to argue that they are ``junta-like'' and one can zero out all but the top few coefficients without affecting the performance of the halfspace. The top few coefficients form the natural list decoding of a halfspace in the context of dictatorship tests/Label Cover reductions. We note that unlike previous invariance principle based proofs which are only known to give Unique-Games hardness, we are able to reduce from a version of Label Cover problem that is known to be NP-hard. This has inspired follow-up work on bypassing the Unique Games conjecture in some optimal geometric inapproximability results.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1012.0729v1
2010-12-03T13:11:22
2010-12-03T13:11:22
{ "title": [ 0.0029335022, 0.013687134, -0.03353882, -0.021499634, -0.017562866, -0.03189087, 0.020431519, -0.0054473877, -0.0025253296, 0.054138184, -0.049041748, -0.024246216, 0.01852417, -0.024673462, -0.025634766, -0.017471313, 0.010101318, 0.0038757324, -0.038146973, -0.022476196, -0.043029785, -0.0065727234, -0.020721436, 0.0041236877, -0.008171082, 0.022613525, -0.07952881, 0.014335632, 0.017196655, 0.012283325, 0.0057678223, -0.008903503, 0.013641357, 0.023544312, 0.017608643, 0.039794922, -0.047088623, 0.049316406, 0.030166626, -0.013534546, -0.0041122437, 0.004840851, -0.015151978, -0.011993408, -0.04849243, 0.036224365, -0.05657959, -0.0047035217, 0.0030899048, 0.028167725, -0.010231018, -0.008888245, -0.023208618, 0.033721924, -0.006248474, -0.046142578, -0.021728516, 0.014778137, 0.008758545, 0.04071045, 0.007232666, 0.023376465, 0.020843506, -0.03967285, 0.009239197, -0.030563354, -0.00907135, 0.007659912, 0.08691406, 0.04257202, -0.006706238, 0.027404785, 0.0051994324, 0.03137207, -0.009284973, -0.057922363, 0.061401367, 0.026138306, -0.0026302338, 0.028289795, -0.002313614, -0.008018494, -0.06793213, 0.016525269, -0.015716553, 0.04208374, -0.01600647, -0.019973755, 0.021942139, -0.055480957, 0.0027980804, 0.036224365, -0.02330017, 0.04058838, -0.012962341, -0.054016113, -0.03552246, -0.0022411346, -0.00137043, -0.0692749, 0.0012378693, -0.014030457, -0.05517578, 0.0042533875, 0.0039367676, -0.030044556, -0.017242432, 0.008468628, 0.045196533, 0.045959473, -0.040649414, 0.03378296, -0.0020332336, -0.014099121, 0.017044067, 0.025512695, -0.010215759, 0.019439697, 0.00970459, 0.02116394, -0.020843506, -0.023132324, -0.004009247, 0.033233643, 0.033813477, 0.042175293, -0.030349731, 0.005554199, 0.008575439, 0.026412964, -0.0040740967, 0.04156494, -0.118774414, -0.06591797, -0.060668945, 0.007003784, -0.0049552917, 0.0068588257, -0.012969971, 0.0033283234, -0.018844604, -0.041809082, 0.024673462, -0.022659302, -0.050109863, 0.056152344, 0.05215454, -0.008041382, -0.053375244, -0.1295166, -0.050476074, 0.05706787, 0.022750854, 0.01751709, -0.037200928, 0.016326904, -0.09020996, 0.044433594, 0.00018537045, 0.03427124, 0.04171753, -0.0033779144, -0.028549194, 0.02003479, 0.011520386, -0.003320694, -0.0037631989, 0.031677246, 0.017333984, 0.008407593, -0.011390686, 0.018447876, -0.011650085, -0.005748749, 0.015464783, 0.014419556, 0.0007748604, -0.027893066, 0.004108429, 0.071899414, 0.055541992, 0.0035133362, -0.0914917, 0.058685303, -0.027801514, 0.0055770874, -0.033203125, -0.0006785393, 0.03451538, 0.009185791, -0.034973145, 0.03967285, -0.013900757, -0.0071525574, -0.015701294, -0.009124756, 0.0016584396, -0.0002462864, -0.0058517456, 0.0063819885, -0.04324341, 0.032073975, -0.024108887, 0.049194336, 0.035186768, -0.019958496, 0.009101868, 0.0146484375, -0.012893677, 0.052490234, 0.031051636, -0.007549286, -0.053344727, 0.07159424, 0.0065956116, -0.06335449, 0.025146484, -0.010604858, -0.0032234192, -0.02507019, 0.004886627, -0.008529663, -0.027679443, 0.0413208, -0.03942871, 0.02142334, -0.025604248, 0.018859863, 0.0065574646, 0.018829346, 0.08135986, -0.0025119781, -0.035949707, -0.011749268, -0.035308838, -0.009231567, 0.011688232, 0.032043457, 0.017959595, 0.015159607, 0.0029640198, -0.0064888, 0.01499939, 0.045532227, 0.021194458, 0.0211792, 0.03378296, 0.0043258667, -0.00920105, -0.013961792, 0.03945923, 0.01928711, 0.019226074, 0.025024414, -0.016677856, 0.04647827, 0.030044556, 0.026367188, 0.024261475, 0.016662598, -0.019622803, 0.02709961, 0.022781372, 0.00039696693, -0.011116028, 0.0018520355, 0.010879517, 0.028442383, 0.0013990402, 0.015281677, -0.011558533, -0.060150146, -0.0043182373, -0.031433105, 0.016967773, -0.04373169, -0.047668457, 0.031280518, 0.0056648254, -0.053222656, -0.02784729, 0.03555298, 0.041412354, -0.002161026, 0.0024814606, 0.019241333, 0.034851074, -0.0050697327, -0.02217102, 0.0047073364, 0.041229248, 0.057281494, 0.03805542, -0.001250267, 0.021438599, 0.013191223, 0.04827881, 0.056243896, -0.0446167, 0.024505615, -0.0061187744, 0.012649536, 0.00054979324, 0.0009274483, 0.007881165, 0.033355713, 0.03250122, 0.007949829, 0.009819031, 0.006290436, -0.035339355, 0.02279663, 0.023239136, 0.04498291, -0.025863647, -0.041900635, -0.00023686886, 0.019897461, -0.020095825, -0.033691406, 0.048858643, 0.020202637, 0.0041542053, -0.026824951, 0.03286743, -0.047424316, -0.05166626, -0.017974854, 0.051361084, -0.027496338, -0.10046387, -0.04660034, -0.10888672, -0.039489746, -0.014663696, 0.009803772, 0.008575439, -0.018325806, -0.0043754578, 0.008049011, 0.02166748, -0.020904541, -0.007217407, -0.034454346, -0.018692017, -0.018630981, -0.048919678, 0.015350342, -0.038208008, -0.037475586, 0.034057617, -0.030914307, -0.00039696693, 0.05621338, 0.040649414, 0.035003662, -0.0031719208, 0.012863159, 0.01574707, -0.036834717, 0.04397583, 0.035614014, 0.022155762, 0.0039043427, -0.005596161, -0.07635498, -0.015571594, 0.020446777, -0.0074539185, 0.018936157, -0.059814453, -0.00088500977, -0.03753662, 0.01247406, 0.007583618, 0.047058105, 0.016937256, -0.05218506, -0.023590088, -0.010643005, 0.0005021095, 0.00806427, -0.024032593, 0.004245758, 0.053710938, -0.005432129, -0.0051994324, -0.015930176, 0.032165527, 0.012641907, -0.02192688, -0.037017822, -0.028411865, -0.019866943, 0.014793396, 0.03378296, -0.026687622, -0.07543945, -0.010940552, 0.001581192, 0.06665039, -0.03677368, -0.030288696, 0.011390686, -0.043762207, 0.05404663, 0.01448822, -0.00029301643, 0.044891357, 0.008369446, 0.012062073, 0.0155181885, 0.05593872, -0.034057617, -0.011650085, 0.0009422302, -0.07141113, 0.0011453629, -0.02192688, 0.024261475, -0.01802063, 0.042755127, -0.041381836, -0.0030612946, -0.03933716, -0.024902344, 0.03729248, 0.03741455, -0.01285553, 0.03729248, -0.010688782, -0.026565552, 0.0073280334, 0.028503418, 0.0035629272, 0.045898438, -0.019973755, 0.035614014, 0.025375366, -0.022720337, 0.017150879, -0.012702942, -0.0335083, 0.060424805, -0.047546387, 0.030822754, -0.020935059, -0.015777588, -0.017440796, 0.028427124, -0.026870728, 0.020233154, -0.034057617, 0.0016880035, -0.039611816, 0.019058228, 0.0020313263, 0.04446411, -0.022109985, -0.0048446655, 0.0012969971, -0.041748047, -0.014251709, 0.016021729, -0.020614624, 0.012184143, 0.047058105, -0.011802673, -0.029174805, 0.0029449463, -0.042785645, 0.022979736, -0.007843018, 0.00737381, 0.00068473816, 0.008781433, -0.03527832, 0.055480957, -0.06463623, -0.024795532, 0.007259369, 0.012207031, 0.010543823, -0.0059890747, -0.020507812, 0.030410767, -0.0368042, -0.009124756, 0.040496826, -0.015022278, -0.009056091, -0.05682373, 0.02166748, -0.017105103, -0.034942627, 0.015808105, -0.009056091, 0.052337646, 0.035705566, -0.0647583, -0.036834717, 0.031188965, -0.014038086, -0.051818848, 0.011077881, -0.02470398, -0.018814087, -0.033477783, 0.015792847, 0.01663208, 0.0034332275, -0.023071289, 0.00065517426, -0.00066423416, -0.017303467, 0.02986145, 0.0065574646, -0.015037537, 0.015945435, 0.009941101, -0.004283905, -0.043945312, 0.026992798, 0.020370483, 0.013427734, 0.009674072, -0.025268555, 0.03643799, -0.017913818, -0.04135132, 0.036132812, 0.011558533, 0.04559326, 0.05871582, -0.0070495605, 0.043182373, 0.0001937151, -0.01121521, -0.03866577, -0.03515625, -0.055633545, -0.014511108, 0.021102905, -0.0025787354, -0.020492554, 0.02670288, -0.0037212372, 0.057250977, -0.016296387, -0.0087509155, 0.010910034, 0.01802063, -0.050842285, -0.027694702, -0.03463745, 0.006965637, -0.0134887695, 0.009773254, -0.015548706, 0.012573242, 0.03173828, 0.014419556, -0.05593872, -0.0032844543, -0.026992798, 0.006225586, 0.016860962, -0.030883789, -0.053649902, -0.009246826, -0.095581055, -0.032226562, -0.049560547, -0.015426636, -0.004501343, 0.0073394775, -0.020721436, 0.027282715, -0.00031757355, 0.0019702911, 0.028289795, -0.01020813, -0.040283203, 0.017150879, -0.023422241, -0.0236969, 0.06536865, -0.03237915, -0.01272583, 0.006286621, 0.04736328, -0.033935547, -0.0077667236, -0.0725708, 0.001709938, -0.03503418, 0.05001831, 0.042175293, -0.0015211105, 0.03466797, 0.01979065, 0.005844116, -0.0074005127, -0.024368286, -0.0023670197, 0.036987305, 0.066833496, 0.010375977, 0.008728027, 0.062316895, 0.031051636, -0.0038204193, -0.037872314, -0.007858276, 0.009925842, 0.025466919, 0.020004272, 0.012413025, -0.098083496, -0.042297363, -0.030838013, -0.05026245, 0.0034217834, -0.06829834, 0.0070724487, -0.034576416, -0.02583313, 0.04598999, 0.009056091, -0.016052246, 0.04663086, -0.008255005, -0.050750732, 0.010353088, 0.030654907, 0.016357422, -0.033935547, -0.0065231323, -0.0014133453, -0.0181427, 0.016479492, 0.008666992, 0.04095459, -0.039154053, -0.034118652, -0.033172607, -0.0017404556, 0.008453369, -0.043151855, -0.0146484375, -0.014465332, 0.046173096, 0.03189087, 0.032348633, -0.032806396, 0.02394104, -0.03036499, 0.017486572, 0.0075912476, -0.059631348, -0.026779175, 0.018798828, 0.064575195, -0.028457642, 0.007926941, -0.0075416565, 0.009971619, 0.003458023, -0.028808594, 0.0011997223, -0.010421753, -0.04031372, 0.031982422, 0.0027446747, -0.01751709, -0.0042419434, 0.041931152, -0.018630981, 0.011665344, -0.0103302, 0.01890564, 0.015411377, 0.010910034, 0.0005245209, -0.03781128, 0.0423584, -0.023895264, -0.004600525, 0.0070152283, -0.035369873, -0.006767273, 0.059326172, -0.0057678223, 0.02420044, -0.018066406, -0.010650635, 0.035858154, -0.03451538, 0.061584473, -0.05178833, 0.010147095, 0.0057411194, -0.0129852295, -0.0026245117, -0.0065574646, 0.023071289, 0.024017334, 0.013473511, 0.03237915, 0.029052734, 0.022918701, -0.009407043, -0.04940796, -0.016479492, 0.035491943, -0.027618408, -0.008049011, -0.004146576, -0.022613525, -0.008369446, 0.011352539, 0.004600525, 0.014633179, -0.034576416, 0.024398804, 0.0019483566, -0.004562378, 0.026824951, 0.013381958, 0.037322998, 0.004261017, -0.0013742447, 0.007785797, -0.00039076805, 0.019760132, -0.004055023, -0.006515503, 0.026229858, -0.034332275, 0.023239136, 0.044067383, -0.02986145, 0.031341553, -0.020401001, 0.027267456, 0.027877808, 0.002855301, 0.09289551, -0.010643005, 0.039520264, 0.05606079, -0.015090942, -0.033721924, -0.02798462, -0.013999939, -0.025390625, 0.037750244, -0.028747559, -0.019485474, -0.02142334, -0.07220459, -0.014259338, -0.001033783, 0.034454346, 0.008758545, -0.0023517609, 0.013977051, 0.07836914, -0.026031494, -0.0256958, -0.042938232, 0.033111572, -0.041290283, -0.06774902, 0.047027588, -0.036590576, 0.025238037, -0.06616211, 0.016067505, 0.027679443, 0.028518677, -0.025405884, -0.030639648, -0.021026611, -0.022781372, 0.031951904, 0.03225708, 0.016357422, -0.031341553, 0.0059547424, -0.013702393, 0.04171753, -0.0029335022, 0.021209717, 0.00021779537, 0.0023899078, -0.0033435822, 0.007904053, -0.00078487396, -0.025344849, 0.023986816, -0.054595947, 0.0069007874, -0.021377563, -0.025772095, -0.056884766, -0.024353027, 0.028411865, 0.03955078, -0.01197052, 0.0076179504, 0.024734497, 0.041870117, 0.02645874, 0.0047340393, 0.0496521, 0.0010538101, 0.017990112, -0.052825928, -0.01474762, -0.011375427, 0.008987427, -0.00080919266, 0.049468994, -0.0134887695, -0.034820557, 0.015655518, 0.013061523, 0.018218994, -0.0262146, -0.02017212, -0.028167725, -0.0013227463, -0.009056091, 0.013847351, 0.06970215, -0.0077552795, -0.033447266, -0.012748718, 0.0077438354, 0.026062012, -0.04434204, 0.024429321, 0.041503906, -0.05810547, 0.030395508, -0.009170532, -0.037750244, 0.018600464, 0.06854248, 0.033996582, -0.010948181, -0.0007324219, 0.041900635, 0.0041503906, 0.05041504, 0.03704834, -0.029129028, -0.019348145, -0.023406982, -0.0076293945, 0.0048446655, 0.004058838, -0.014595032, 0.032226562, -0.0027866364, -0.027572632, 0.029449463, -0.03439331, 0.021072388, 0.026947021, 0.03756714, 0.08074951, -0.028244019, -0.012390137, 0.037750244, 0.020614624, -0.067871094, 0.021011353, 0.051696777, 0.11468506, 0.060699463, 0.07318115, -0.015960693, 0.007583618, 0.07476807, 0.00039625168, 0.01991272, 0.04159546, 0.014297485, 0.031219482, -0.028396606, -0.032165527, 0.023345947, -0.006767273, 0.06427002, -0.009689331, -0.007926941, -0.043121338, 0.011619568, 0.0068092346, -0.030975342, -0.02619934, -0.01675415, -0.031677246, 0.006248474, -0.0046539307, -0.0060310364, -0.050750732, -0.02848816, 0.06506348, 0.001244545, 0.011795044, 0.008491516, -0.020401001, 0.0059890747, 0.046295166, 0.015991211, 0.078552246, 0.0024089813, -0.034301758, -0.0126571655, 0.006477356, 0.03036499, 0.0020561218, -0.01725769, -0.004589081, -0.045898438, -0.022232056, -0.021347046, -0.030731201, -0.033477783, -0.01751709, 0.0047950745, 0.02458191, -0.027816772, 0.0038204193, -0.020706177, -0.03579712, -0.0020427704, -0.02482605, -0.0023517609, 0.020233154, 0.036621094, -0.020187378, -0.019729614, -0.022384644, 0.005645752, 0.00014483929, 0.042266846, 0.05166626, -0.04751587, -0.03253174, -0.0016994476, 0.013664246, 0.055877686, -0.01876831, 0.0024871826, 0.010520935, 0.03390503, -0.0074272156, -0.0015153885, 0.0024490356, -0.02748108, 0.03289795, -0.01776123, -0.012374878, 0.019439697, 0.033294678, 0.061767578, 0.044128418, 0.022094727, -0.043701172, 0.025283813, 0.0052986145, -0.01637268, -0.016983032, 0.0033035278, 0.023544312, -0.018127441, -0.0020656586, 0.02168274, -0.015731812, -0.038635254, -0.011604309, -0.016433716, 0.0012693405, 0.0032691956, -0.006198883, 0.002243042, -0.036834717, 0.06958008, -0.024902344, -0.0052871704, -0.0016021729, 0.03918457, -0.005680084, 0.004131317, 0.0064888, 0.011314392, -0.04309082, -0.0057678223, 0.017974854, -0.0015115738, 0.020736694, -0.013343811, 0.04095459, -0.030792236, -0.03189087, -0.014022827, 0.01499939, -0.0045051575, -0.041748047, 0.018341064, 0.0020332336, -0.03567505, 0.01083374, -0.010360718, 0.016311646, -0.023910522, -0.04257202, -0.03878784, 0.0016326904, -0.00447464 ], "summary": [ 0.023406982, -0.007041931, 0.016540527, 0.023391724, -0.022720337, -0.0104904175, 0.025817871, -0.034484863, -0.022399902, 0.016174316, -0.03466797, 0.014137268, -0.025421143, -0.01889038, -0.012268066, -0.042938232, 0.0068130493, 0.010505676, -0.021057129, -0.038208008, -0.026062012, -0.022140503, -0.011299133, 0.02734375, -0.0046653748, 0.04324341, -0.007835388, 0.033081055, 0.029205322, 0.027313232, 0.017501831, -0.060577393, 0.020812988, 0.012008667, 0.018615723, 0.02470398, -0.0039978027, 0.022781372, 0.021240234, 0.0005970001, -0.009986877, 0.0017204285, 0.012680054, -0.06390381, -0.030578613, 0.044311523, -0.025161743, 0.010948181, 0.011329651, 0.012252808, -0.0066108704, 0.050354004, -0.0029087067, 0.03149414, -0.0022506714, -0.029769897, -0.04119873, -0.03930664, -0.007549286, 0.07507324, 0.051513672, -0.017974854, 0.0008111, -0.025024414, -0.008628845, -0.03894043, -0.0029449463, 0.013900757, 0.02470398, 0.013710022, 0.03564453, 0.006954193, 0.029891968, 0.009262085, -0.03152466, -0.01965332, 0.06500244, 0.058410645, -0.014022827, -0.005970001, 0.011383057, 0.018920898, -0.05053711, -0.03643799, 0.021484375, 0.0051193237, -0.021133423, -0.021606445, 0.0146484375, 0.0043754578, -0.004562378, -0.009521484, 0.028884888, 0.03616333, -0.011123657, -0.03515625, 0.0011863708, 0.0060691833, 0.017044067, -0.03744507, -0.00774765, -0.025131226, -0.051818848, 0.0034828186, -0.010658264, -0.020019531, -0.022033691, -0.026916504, 0.013961792, 0.041259766, -0.027038574, -0.0067977905, -0.005378723, -0.037506104, 0.03036499, 0.028060913, -0.014801025, 0.06585693, 0.01234436, 0.022201538, -0.005256653, 0.011711121, -0.061706543, 0.06738281, 0.02619934, 0.029464722, 0.011299133, 0.020858765, -0.020645142, 0.023666382, 0.010261536, 0.019058228, -0.08154297, -0.031707764, -0.057128906, 0.0013179779, 0.006340027, 0.0075569153, 0.024887085, -0.024139404, 0.0055007935, -0.02279663, 0.046936035, 0.015808105, -0.0065078735, 0.04763794, 0.009292603, -0.017166138, 0.013504028, -0.057403564, -0.03994751, 0.0066452026, 0.04727173, -0.009902954, -0.026123047, -0.05368042, -0.008628845, -0.013404846, -0.0132369995, -0.028686523, 0.048553467, -0.028182983, -0.023925781, 0.06427002, 0.026168823, 0.021362305, -0.033966064, 0.012542725, 0.0073013306, -0.014083862, 0.01776123, 0.021942139, 0.0009689331, -0.015136719, 0.005645752, 0.0005335808, -0.008705139, -0.017440796, -0.034851074, 0.072753906, 0.04147339, -0.026550293, -0.10180664, 0.053710938, 0.00021409988, -0.036346436, -0.022766113, -0.020751953, 0.04849243, 0.015151978, -0.03817749, -0.014320374, 0.0010280609, -0.017059326, -0.010795593, -0.006511688, -0.010673523, 0.014823914, -0.016616821, -0.016952515, 0.0020256042, 0.00003093481, -0.0046691895, 0.02684021, -0.00035238266, -0.014907837, -0.0032901764, 0.0060806274, -0.05859375, 0.03656006, 0.03894043, -0.018936157, -0.03515625, 0.05505371, 0.047424316, -0.03567505, 0.029342651, -0.020706177, -0.009544373, -0.045013428, -0.010719299, -0.014984131, -0.037902832, 0.049804688, -0.014312744, 0.036346436, -0.022857666, 0.02949524, 0.026229858, 0.02748108, 0.04611206, -0.010253906, -0.022216797, -0.03036499, -0.04083252, -0.00016987324, -0.0057754517, -0.02458191, 0.006790161, 0.03781128, 0.026382446, 0.001502037, -0.020874023, 0.0027217865, 0.003332138, 0.0068626404, 0.01902771, -0.0012168884, -0.02519226, 0.013259888, 0.04840088, -0.0069770813, 0.004486084, 0.015327454, -0.022720337, 0.011291504, 0.04171753, 0.016647339, 0.022354126, 0.0038375854, -0.018249512, 0.05895996, 0.019638062, 0.018035889, 0.0413208, -0.030273438, 0.008270264, -0.011276245, 0.011795044, 0.0149383545, -0.016693115, -0.12597656, -0.011520386, -0.02331543, 0.023925781, -0.023742676, -0.04425049, 0.026046753, 0.017303467, -0.029891968, -0.02305603, 0.00028252602, 0.030410767, -0.00029039383, 0.0032653809, -0.011390686, 0.048858643, 0.00027775764, -0.008758545, 0.04333496, 0.020339966, 0.084106445, 0.028625488, -0.004333496, 0.012641907, 0.026016235, -0.022277832, 0.0019369125, 0.005970001, -0.019546509, -0.010520935, 0.045715332, -0.0071411133, 0.00333786, -0.0003361702, 0.017211914, 0.027877808, -0.009857178, -0.016952515, -0.024490356, -0.03164673, -0.045532227, 0.012992859, 0.072265625, -0.015899658, -0.03375244, 0.018157959, 0.047546387, 0.026687622, 0.023086548, 0.061584473, 0.030441284, 0.022979736, -0.0011978149, 0.017471313, -0.057373047, -0.0060310364, -0.025680542, 0.029006958, 0.0015869141, -0.08874512, -0.011558533, -0.061462402, 0.012390137, -0.016647339, -0.0013551712, 0.010360718, -0.0076904297, 0.006160736, -0.014816284, 0.038085938, 0.019729614, 0.0049591064, 0.00819397, -0.06866455, 0.0025920868, -0.039398193, 0.018112183, -0.033081055, -0.059539795, 0.06719971, -0.025665283, -0.006122589, 0.03744507, 0.019332886, 0.03866577, 0.0025043488, 0.055511475, 0.041168213, -0.0036945343, 0.04434204, 0.050354004, 0.03756714, -0.0657959, -0.075683594, -0.047698975, 0.0012922287, 0.0064201355, 0.021972656, 0.021820068, 0.011772156, 0.012229919, -0.070251465, -0.01209259, -0.015701294, 0.0075531006, 0.033843994, -0.023742676, -0.023040771, 0.0013170242, 0.0004799366, -0.005252838, -0.013168335, -0.016326904, 0.032440186, 0.015266418, -0.0042381287, 0.016174316, 0.027862549, -0.0041389465, 0.0000962615, 0.024902344, -0.008255005, -0.054626465, -0.021072388, 0.026855469, 0.01940918, -0.06689453, 0.103759766, -0.03338623, 0.016021729, -0.014129639, 0.0023956299, -0.0067100525, -0.008239746, 0.042053223, 0.015083313, -0.013458252, 0.030136108, 0.01890564, 0.05130005, -0.025482178, 0.07922363, -0.02722168, -0.000705719, -0.014480591, 0.044525146, 0.0119018555, -0.028549194, -0.012939453, 0.0037727356, 0.061798096, -0.030822754, -0.022705078, -0.01285553, -0.04437256, -0.006614685, 0.015350342, -0.03265381, 0.038757324, -0.0066070557, -0.022369385, 0.00029921532, 0.02381897, -0.03378296, 0.027679443, 0.024093628, -0.0003490448, 0.07324219, -0.058624268, -0.013969421, -0.020309448, -0.013534546, 0.022766113, -0.029800415, 0.026397705, -0.017288208, 0.0036201477, -0.032958984, 0.046661377, -0.039367676, 0.019073486, -0.031921387, 0.016601562, -0.034057617, 0.009101868, -0.036193848, 0.027404785, 0.01637268, -0.05114746, -0.026229858, -0.030258179, -0.02357483, -0.0017786026, 0.010948181, 0.019500732, -0.002614975, 0.011520386, -0.0071029663, -0.021270752, 0.005264282, 0.001865387, -0.0017271042, 0.00045633316, 0.005306244, -0.02305603, 0.002325058, 0.04736328, -0.05218506, -0.030059814, -0.0137786865, -0.007587433, 0.024353027, -0.029937744, -0.01763916, 0.022842407, -0.059936523, 0.017852783, 0.031799316, 0.03994751, 0.04486084, -0.042907715, 0.034057617, 0.017562866, -0.018554688, 0.016708374, -0.03314209, 0.085998535, 0.01398468, -0.050476074, 0.034088135, -0.014389038, 0.039123535, 0.0021457672, -0.036254883, 0.022354126, 0.02305603, -0.013847351, 0.014144897, -0.029418945, -0.023117065, -0.047668457, 0.06109619, 0.0099105835, -0.0031108856, 0.03894043, 0.045440674, 0.00060129166, 0.03692627, -0.009971619, 0.05065918, 0.014152527, 0.026260376, -0.015625, 0.030075073, 0.0236969, -0.00573349, 0.00039935112, 0.0027236938, -0.019439697, 0.05142212, -0.019515991, 0.010101318, 0.027526855, -0.01184845, 0.031463623, -0.024353027, -0.017333984, -0.015594482, 0.0012102127, -0.04473877, -0.010383606, 0.011756897, 0.025543213, -0.021697998, 0.0077171326, -0.06427002, -0.014549255, -0.031921387, -0.019927979, -0.006668091, -0.0060157776, -0.08404541, -0.029052734, -0.005176544, 0.061157227, -0.034423828, 0.022521973, -0.0030574799, 0.00088214874, -0.0154953, 0.027694702, -0.049713135, 0.034454346, -0.03390503, 0.030029297, -0.029006958, -0.04534912, -0.04663086, 0.0023212433, -0.052642822, 0.0030403137, 0.005634308, -0.051239014, 0.025054932, -0.044952393, 0.0031585693, 0.015357971, 0.01878357, 0.020721436, 0.01991272, 0.010398865, -0.02330017, 0.01096344, -0.020095825, 0.0006055832, 0.039123535, -0.037994385, 0.009254456, -0.002161026, 0.011909485, -0.014190674, -0.05493164, -0.10119629, 0.019561768, 0.013397217, 0.0769043, 0.097473145, 0.020370483, 0.06713867, -0.01499176, 0.019515991, 0.022445679, -0.015556335, -0.012786865, 0.013557434, -0.014694214, 0.0072669983, 0.015930176, 0.064819336, -0.012062073, -0.005016327, 0.006587982, -0.018844604, 0.03555298, -0.013336182, 0.011634827, -0.004234314, -0.07305908, -0.011047363, -0.012290955, -0.03074646, 0.0017309189, -0.05532837, 0.0029258728, 0.0006132126, -0.00094509125, 0.07446289, 0.0052223206, -0.023223877, 0.04574585, -0.034179688, -0.06237793, -0.026809692, -0.0005669594, 0.058685303, -0.031677246, -0.006664276, -0.0059547424, -0.025985718, 0.044189453, -0.019515991, -0.0015983582, -0.033721924, -0.053619385, -0.016113281, -0.013504028, 0.011764526, -0.03488159, -0.00042796135, 0.004020691, 0.016693115, -0.024108887, 0.029190063, -0.011444092, 0.02394104, -0.0076942444, 0.027709961, -0.0039405823, -0.06500244, -0.07501221, -0.055267334, 0.042175293, -0.055786133, 0.00083494186, -0.0068588257, -0.0085372925, -0.0072669983, -0.03414917, -0.0005354881, -0.02558899, -0.022705078, 0.040252686, 0.011253357, -0.014465332, 0.0039596558, 0.026641846, -0.020874023, -0.013595581, 0.0022087097, -0.0039367676, -0.0129852295, 0.056762695, -0.05230713, -0.012863159, 0.004627228, -0.0023765564, 0.025421143, 0.004714966, 0.040222168, 0.020187378, 0.024291992, 0.031097412, -0.009101868, -0.05935669, -0.013496399, 0.030578613, -0.033721924, -0.036193848, -0.047973633, 0.02973938, -0.0013465881, 0.011680603, -0.0076141357, -0.022354126, 0.011528015, 0.020431519, 0.005207062, 0.042022705, 0.022659302, 0.006641388, -0.023864746, -0.06463623, -0.018493652, 0.047973633, -0.009567261, -0.012321472, -0.040893555, -0.04714966, 0.010284424, -0.0132369995, 0.04144287, 0.0345459, -0.07458496, -0.0037460327, -0.003440857, 0.0009841919, 0.030151367, -0.0037879944, -0.004184723, 0.0054244995, -0.0049819946, -0.03375244, -0.0024814606, 0.018569946, -0.03866577, 0.024795532, 0.0017490387, -0.012191772, 0.0121536255, 0.05319214, -0.023956299, 0.04107666, -0.01550293, 0.023361206, 0.022491455, 0.009407043, 0.049102783, 0.015289307, 0.016082764, 0.03817749, 0.0033740997, 0.012992859, -0.028839111, 0.023284912, -0.018463135, 0.037231445, -0.046142578, -0.0042495728, -0.036590576, -0.07800293, 0.004096985, -0.018203735, 0.011062622, 0.049987793, -0.004020691, 0.016021729, 0.083862305, -0.018463135, -0.06072998, -0.03704834, 0.014221191, -0.027755737, -0.021118164, 0.08514404, -0.060668945, 0.05709839, -0.074035645, -0.022033691, -0.00051021576, 0.03805542, -0.048095703, -0.04574585, 0.009994507, -0.000062048435, -0.014045715, 0.050476074, -0.015144348, -0.0026359558, 0.015296936, 0.03881836, 0.0116119385, 0.0073051453, -0.022064209, -0.032196045, -0.0033397675, 0.018875122, 0.0034618378, -0.0016555786, -0.008529663, 0.035614014, -0.015151978, -0.022994995, -0.038116455, -0.03918457, -0.030273438, 0.014953613, -0.009063721, 0.0011043549, 0.022872925, 0.008666992, 0.025894165, 0.037872314, -0.047698975, -0.017745972, -0.009773254, -0.008872986, 0.009628296, 0.000036597252, -0.013694763, -0.01574707, 0.011802673, -0.037963867, 0.062408447, 0.019348145, -0.03933716, 0.0064926147, 0.016998291, -0.0020542145, -0.04953003, -0.0012569427, -0.04458618, 0.013641357, 0.009315491, 0.03277588, 0.027404785, -0.019836426, 0.027389526, -0.027755737, -0.011177063, -0.012527466, 0.0008625984, 0.0054893494, -0.03250122, 0.056243896, 0.013870239, -0.017349243, -0.010231018, 0.026855469, 0.026168823, 0.047210693, -0.068115234, -0.01335144, 0.032562256, -0.006336212, -0.03564453, 0.0014467239, -0.032073975, -0.022262573, -0.056915283, -0.014724731, 0.02168274, -0.004814148, -0.040405273, 0.0063972473, -0.018936157, -0.010231018, 0.021606445, -0.0046806335, -0.0022792816, 0.008872986, -0.0007724762, 0.033691406, 0.020370483, -0.008369446, -0.00818634, 0.04550171, -0.040863037, 0.028320312, 0.002960205, 0.1352539, 0.08001709, 0.064331055, -0.03540039, 0.001750946, 0.11053467, -0.00737381, 0.017700195, -0.002286911, 0.010932922, 0.018920898, 0.0019159317, 0.029541016, 0.057861328, 0.062561035, 0.0736084, 0.009635925, -0.01348114, -0.035247803, 0.0029582977, -0.015792847, -0.031402588, 0.033294678, -0.046966553, 0.014953613, -0.0043182373, 0.03564453, -0.038757324, -0.005695343, -0.013793945, 0.0077705383, -0.006263733, -0.011123657, -0.001698494, -0.023483276, 0.03579712, 0.018066406, 0.028701782, 0.076538086, 0.050750732, -0.02041626, 0.027679443, 0.009925842, -0.002155304, -0.06506348, -0.022094727, -0.039398193, 0.014328003, -0.026351929, -0.027786255, -0.026428223, -0.03591919, 0.04562378, 0.025344849, 0.03842163, -0.013435364, 0.015655518, -0.023406982, -0.0146102905, -0.019714355, -0.0033302307, 0.005996704, 0.00078487396, 0.01651001, 0.0002834797, 0.030731201, -0.0037727356, 0.0016527176, -0.0027046204, 0.027328491, 0.006462097, -0.018661499, -0.03805542, 0.006149292, 0.01096344, 0.046325684, -0.00075531006, 0.038024902, 0.02229309, -0.022735596, -0.007446289, 0.011306763, -0.011650085, -0.0178833, 0.025802612, 0.008895874, -0.001876831, 0.026855469, 0.009994507, 0.045043945, 0.043029785, 0.030380249, -0.0335083, 0.03274536, 0.010650635, -0.057678223, -0.035949707, -0.010276794, 0.0065994263, -0.06640625, -0.0041999817, -0.036499023, -0.015640259, -0.040618896, -0.025238037, -0.019439697, 0.0049934387, -0.029083252, -0.0015335083, 0.00053310394, -0.06225586, 0.02432251, -0.018569946, 0.035217285, -0.031829834, 0.017715454, 0.0030708313, -0.019989014, -0.023239136, 0.023803711, 0.0037403107, -0.023025513, -0.0008029938, -0.020095825, 0.041107178, -0.046051025, -0.010665894, -0.043792725, -0.038269043, -0.00137043, -0.006839752, 0.011772156, -0.015487671, 0.013435364, 0.066589355, -0.056671143, 0.018951416, 0.011566162, 0.032714844, -0.01838684, -0.005317688, 0.030044556, 0.034240723, 0.019348145 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1102.3919v1
Inferring Disease and Gene Set Associations with Rank Coherence in Networks
TaeHyun Hwang, Wei Zhang, Maoqiang Xie, Rui Kuang
q-bio.GN, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.MN
A computational challenge to validate the candidate disease genes identified in a high-throughput genomic study is to elucidate the associations between the set of candidate genes and disease phenotypes. The conventional gene set enrichment analysis often fails to reveal associations between disease phenotypes and the gene sets with a short list of poorly annotated genes, because the existing annotations of disease causative genes are incomplete. We propose a network-based computational approach called rcNet to discover the associations between gene sets and disease phenotypes. Assuming coherent associations between the genes ranked by their relevance to the query gene set, and the disease phenotypes ranked by their relevance to the hidden target disease phenotypes of the query gene set, we formulate a learning framework maximizing the rank coherence with respect to the known disease phenotype-gene associations. An efficient algorithm coupling ridge regression with label propagation, and two variants are introduced to find the optimal solution of the framework. We evaluated the rcNet algorithms and existing baseline methods with both leave-one-out cross-validation and a task of predicting recently discovered disease-gene associations in OMIM. The experiments demonstrated that the rcNet algorithms achieved the best overall rankings compared to the baselines. To further validate the reproducibility of the performance, we applied the algorithms to identify the target diseases of novel candidate disease genes obtained from recent studies of GWAS, DNA copy number variation analysis, and gene expression profiling. The algorithms ranked the target disease of the candidate genes at the top of the rank list in many cases across all the three case studies. The rcNet algorithms are available as a webtool for disease and gene set association analysis at http://compbio.cs.umn.edu/dgsa_rcNet.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1102.3919v1
2011-02-18T21:01:38
2011-02-18T21:01:38
{ "title": [ -0.016159058, 0.006580353, -0.064086914, -0.078063965, 0.0234375, -0.0040664673, -0.057128906, -0.0065956116, -0.005683899, 0.023010254, 0.01574707, 0.0022182465, -0.020980835, -0.033081055, -0.033416748, 0.0033740997, -0.01663208, 0.02571106, -0.013412476, -0.036956787, -0.024337769, -0.049835205, 0.06323242, -0.009681702, 0.020706177, -0.026153564, -0.044128418, 0.019317627, -0.03881836, -0.024246216, -0.011070251, 0.006111145, 0.055145264, 0.022659302, -0.040252686, -0.03314209, -0.054595947, 0.0078125, -0.020309448, -0.0017585754, 0.0063209534, -0.0060577393, 0.03829956, -0.072631836, 0.010810852, 0.0418396, -0.042053223, -0.033569336, -0.013877869, 0.02053833, 0.0010251999, 0.032073975, -0.015823364, 0.014846802, 0.008804321, -0.03427124, 0.007209778, -0.034240723, 0.0435791, 0.010856628, 0.0025997162, -0.062164307, 0.027435303, 0.0007696152, -0.03326416, -0.012229919, -0.019546509, 0.032165527, 0.031799316, -0.021606445, -0.02458191, 0.012634277, 0.024215698, 0.0015106201, -0.03253174, 0.0011425018, 0.053527832, 0.035339355, 0.024215698, -0.031555176, -0.0069465637, -0.022399902, -0.03338623, 0.0073165894, 0.014587402, 0.00046563148, -0.024505615, -0.022567749, -0.02949524, -0.047576904, -0.016235352, -0.021591187, -0.0008420944, 0.013542175, -0.033111572, -0.021621704, 0.017166138, 0.06347656, 0.00034570694, -0.018814087, -0.020233154, 0.0008907318, -0.047332764, -0.018371582, 0.0067329407, 0.026733398, 0.007331848, -0.0077285767, 0.004501343, 0.01966858, -0.011054993, 0.020355225, -0.0129852295, 0.01361084, -0.009048462, 0.0050354004, -0.028762817, 0.022415161, -0.0041885376, 0.040283203, 0.004207611, -0.009231567, -0.029403687, -0.0010719299, 0.0072135925, -0.031021118, -0.022598267, 0.016616821, -0.08270264, 0.037719727, 0.027954102, 0.03414917, -0.085632324, -0.05255127, -0.05142212, 0.042175293, -0.004737854, -0.025360107, -0.0065689087, 0.013908386, 0.0070877075, -0.024017334, 0.015060425, -0.008346558, -0.014816284, -0.0020503998, 0.059509277, 0.009284973, -0.07055664, -0.029510498, -0.03149414, 0.072143555, 0.036956787, -0.014694214, -0.08148193, -0.010368347, -0.12658691, -0.0079422, -0.0019416809, -0.009895325, 0.0209198, -0.008522034, -0.034942627, -0.014305115, 0.0022964478, -0.000017821789, -0.03149414, 0.027282715, 0.015129089, 0.0063323975, 0.014167786, 0.002532959, 0.03829956, 0.01776123, 0.0069503784, 0.019378662, 0.032806396, -0.036712646, 0.016525269, 0.035583496, 0.017959595, 0.0037212372, -0.013900757, 0.061187744, -0.07287598, -0.0010204315, 0.0013980865, 0.009529114, 0.054840088, -0.00566864, -0.0287323, 0.040130615, -0.054718018, -0.035308838, -0.0368042, -0.0038909912, 0.04763794, 0.03778076, -0.00014948845, -0.010414124, 0.002040863, 0.031555176, -0.04232788, 0.0121154785, -0.00051546097, -0.033691406, 0.006160736, 0.012145996, 0.0055656433, 0.030761719, 0.044067383, -0.0005617142, -0.022369385, 0.010559082, -0.024810791, -0.023773193, 0.053131104, -0.02835083, -0.027618408, -0.013832092, -0.050476074, 0.024658203, -0.05041504, 0.059051514, -0.0011901855, -0.022018433, 0.024383545, -0.040283203, -0.0025749207, -0.0005135536, 0.053863525, -0.022338867, 0.005428314, 0.015342712, -0.0074005127, -0.0050468445, -0.011352539, 0.018356323, 0.0059280396, -0.0070266724, 0.0030593872, -0.013938904, -0.035705566, -0.011665344, 0.03189087, 0.0020980835, 0.011665344, -0.0121154785, 0.008331299, 0.03062439, 0.06616211, 0.04135132, 0.027709961, 0.015853882, 0.0012407303, 0.06149292, 0.022033691, 0.032226562, -0.027862549, 0.018859863, -0.0057029724, 0.041412354, 0.006778717, 0.020187378, -0.06451416, -0.007972717, -0.06149292, -0.023986816, -0.0025844574, 0.014526367, 0.03466797, -0.016525269, 0.011909485, 0.023422241, 0.037322998, -0.026657104, -0.006095886, -0.017440796, 0.012565613, -0.030090332, -0.027862549, -0.018188477, 0.020996094, -0.00009125471, 0.033416748, -0.00422287, 0.013702393, -0.017715454, -0.006542206, 0.017105103, 0.061645508, 0.033416748, 0.030731201, -0.028381348, 0.01727295, 0.013000488, 0.03265381, 0.026153564, -0.015113831, 0.022033691, -0.046783447, 0.03829956, 0.031982422, -0.028167725, -0.0049743652, 0.057403564, -0.0036315918, 0.010910034, -0.045928955, -0.013832092, -0.029312134, 0.00522995, 0.007762909, -0.04321289, -0.025131226, -0.032806396, -0.024307251, -0.03668213, -0.053466797, -0.031082153, 0.06951904, 0.0096588135, -0.041870117, -0.023651123, 0.015792847, -0.01071167, -0.044067383, -0.04107666, -0.046173096, 0.004009247, -0.0008211136, -0.016204834, -0.057128906, -0.015312195, 0.0059509277, 0.016601562, -0.0023784637, 0.022201538, -0.01852417, -0.021011353, 0.0044059753, -0.0014476776, -0.00017178059, -0.020614624, 0.019439697, -0.043945312, -0.0121536255, 0.03286743, -0.037475586, -0.018615723, 0.019622803, -0.023498535, -0.014961243, 0.0138549805, 0.049835205, -0.0095825195, -0.028411865, 0.032196045, 0.019607544, -0.027664185, 0.009178162, 0.04562378, 0.012290955, -0.028717041, -0.037872314, -0.059509277, -0.015594482, 0.016723633, 0.00116539, 0.0473938, -0.06970215, -0.03186035, 0.0013408661, 0.0040740967, 0.041534424, 0.02180481, -0.043762207, -0.031951904, 0.0021152496, -0.033050537, -0.008888245, -0.010131836, -0.005836487, 0.012794495, 0.09210205, -0.0049362183, 0.015075684, 0.03475952, 0.04296875, 0.003030777, -0.017089844, -0.034942627, -0.014930725, 0.0068969727, -0.0028686523, 0.021224976, -0.009773254, -0.030944824, -0.06573486, -0.010238647, 0.051849365, -0.0013389587, -0.042388916, 0.040649414, -0.060333252, 0.014221191, 0.008743286, -0.0068893433, 0.029907227, 0.07696533, -0.027770996, 0.033325195, -0.029953003, 0.029052734, -0.0029411316, -0.0028438568, -0.07080078, 0.02268982, -0.02734375, -0.03744507, 0.013145447, -0.03152466, -0.03225708, 0.010185242, -0.006752014, 0.040405273, 0.019638062, 0.015853882, 0.0112838745, -0.02810669, 0.0012483597, -0.022155762, -0.018066406, -0.03665161, -0.027053833, -0.018951416, -0.00504303, 0.035888672, 0.0028038025, 0.013259888, -0.042419434, -0.036346436, -0.011375427, 0.012954712, -0.001572609, -0.01574707, -0.023391724, 0.0087509155, -0.025894165, -0.010246277, -0.019760132, 0.002588272, -0.005367279, 0.028549194, -0.0079956055, 0.05331421, 0.025863647, -0.0025501251, -0.03463745, -0.010375977, 0.022598267, -0.01272583, -0.0848999, 0.0043678284, 0.021865845, 0.023635864, -0.0368042, -0.009666443, -0.02935791, 0.011955261, -0.004421234, 0.018875122, 0.011482239, -0.0046195984, 0.005092621, 0.021087646, -0.024490356, 0.00970459, -0.039916992, 0.0035686493, 0.03668213, 0.0032176971, -0.00025320053, -0.07366943, -0.022628784, 0.0017967224, -0.16235352, -0.052825928, 0.019927979, -0.050354004, -0.024505615, -0.044799805, 0.024551392, -0.026168823, -0.013786316, -0.02041626, -0.02508545, 0.036071777, -0.02243042, -0.10546875, 0.020965576, 0.03967285, 0.05279541, 0.053222656, 0.0020828247, -0.0017080307, 0.033325195, -0.052612305, -0.0047721863, -0.016433716, 0.053771973, -0.041625977, -0.0021266937, 0.04385376, -0.03744507, -0.017196655, 0.029937744, 0.0071792603, -0.0121154785, 0.009254456, 0.016342163, 0.0362854, 0.008605957, 0.049835205, -0.0034618378, -0.043670654, -0.0038394928, -0.020339966, -0.016906738, 0.0008301735, 0.022857666, 0.008422852, 0.020645142, -0.0017738342, 0.0029449463, 0.034576416, -0.0059814453, 0.015449524, 0.047729492, -0.0077819824, -0.017425537, 0.029785156, 0.0345459, 0.018981934, 0.008811951, 0.014205933, 0.0103302, 0.035186768, -0.0074882507, -0.04864502, 0.017868042, 0.046081543, -0.01789856, 0.009757996, -0.04006958, -0.06677246, -0.028549194, -0.007385254, -0.02003479, 0.072265625, 0.011581421, 0.0049476624, -0.034698486, 0.0013332367, 0.008560181, 0.0017776489, 0.016464233, -0.031463623, 0.022857666, -0.011703491, -0.059143066, -0.045043945, -0.0033855438, 0.011482239, 0.039764404, -0.0033798218, -0.031188965, -0.008262634, 0.018005371, 0.05215454, 0.039276123, 0.0001424551, -0.03918457, -0.009635925, 0.02532959, -0.026062012, -0.00094366074, 0.0057029724, 0.019012451, -0.021835327, -0.045837402, -0.028533936, -0.010398865, -0.041412354, -0.008705139, -0.0076179504, 0.014823914, 0.024459839, 0.06298828, 0.012863159, -0.016494751, 0.007797241, 0.012557983, -0.04626465, -0.013870239, 0.006095886, 0.005432129, -0.015579224, 0.015296936, 0.024032593, 0.0028438568, -0.0020599365, -0.013076782, 0.020248413, 0.014846802, -0.0068588257, -0.02168274, 0.018066406, -0.00844574, -0.043914795, 0.0057296753, 0.009292603, 0.04550171, -0.0033454895, 0.037231445, -0.015510559, 0.0020179749, 0.0038032532, -0.024993896, 0.036987305, -0.022827148, 0.02760315, -0.072021484, -0.07849121, -0.025100708, 0.08648682, -0.03375244, -0.022720337, -0.009483337, 0.023406982, 0.018417358, 0.048736572, 0.019882202, 0.0056991577, -0.021453857, -0.0035266876, -0.000813961, -0.020355225, -0.041412354, 0.023269653, 0.028701782, 0.015670776, 0.0005235672, -0.0446167, -0.070617676, -0.010696411, 0.015533447, -0.021774292, 0.031280518, -0.085754395, 0.018569946, 0.033447266, -0.002210617, 0.00018632412, -0.0024909973, 0.02142334, 0.051940918, 0.041992188, 0.0054855347, 0.033081055, 0.017227173, -0.037902832, 0.03466797, -0.008026123, 0.010826111, -0.023040771, 0.01586914, -0.005958557, 0.004878998, -0.05706787, 0.018295288, 0.025619507, 0.033966064, -0.0004911423, -0.059417725, 0.019821167, 0.002450943, -0.012214661, 0.024475098, -0.041046143, -0.0019359589, 0.019744873, -0.022460938, -0.028915405, 0.051818848, 0.02079773, -0.040893555, -0.054351807, -0.017227173, -0.0021076202, 0.0102005005, -0.016296387, 0.032684326, -0.035736084, 0.032440186, 0.029418945, -0.07086182, -0.008880615, -0.010719299, 0.03591919, 0.03643799, -0.0019989014, -0.04031372, -0.000011622906, -0.022491455, -0.054382324, -0.054718018, 0.031707764, 0.021987915, 0.0037841797, -0.001414299, -0.011108398, 0.02658081, -0.0056991577, 0.031585693, -0.0010213852, 0.004989624, 0.028427124, 0.013702393, 0.0034275055, -0.0053596497, 0.03074646, -0.016494751, 0.008598328, 0.015777588, -0.047027588, 0.006427765, 0.0070610046, -0.0041618347, -0.027053833, -0.0619812, -0.00026917458, 0.004711151, -0.012825012, 0.02319336, 0.01084137, 0.034240723, 0.061828613, -0.008621216, 0.015823364, 0.06323242, -0.021331787, -0.04196167, -0.0017137527, 0.008255005, -0.014312744, 0.047729492, 0.006401062, -0.021774292, -0.030838013, -0.078186035, -0.040496826, 0.007949829, 0.027923584, 0.03765869, 0.027175903, -0.012336731, 0.047210693, -0.02079773, -0.030334473, -0.027816772, 0.042663574, 0.009475708, -0.036010742, 0.004211426, -0.023132324, -0.003982544, -0.029052734, 0.028717041, 0.012886047, -0.0021820068, -0.014343262, -0.02961731, 0.012924194, -0.022201538, -0.030532837, 0.009613037, 0.032836914, -0.016571045, 0.03074646, -0.016677856, 0.034851074, 0.034606934, 0.088378906, 0.045013428, 0.036621094, 0.070007324, 0.0140686035, 0.028289795, -0.028274536, 0.012054443, -0.04067993, 0.016220093, -0.03161621, 0.010444641, -0.095825195, 0.040802002, 0.022415161, 0.042938232, 0.00894165, 0.017059326, 0.029632568, -0.00057792664, 0.0362854, -0.0052375793, 0.06890869, 0.016464233, 0.0096206665, -0.022399902, -0.01626587, 0.013504028, 0.02909851, 0.011810303, 0.013458252, -0.034973145, -0.0129852295, 0.004951477, 0.023162842, 0.00024819374, 0.021194458, 0.011482239, -0.01838684, 0.047729492, 0.007633209, 0.04458618, 0.02494812, 0.038513184, 0.021774292, -0.013534546, -0.01802063, -0.020523071, -0.03338623, -0.0059165955, 0.03390503, -0.07299805, 0.017120361, -0.019943237, -0.011268616, -0.021347046, 0.023239136, 0.030197144, -0.04888916, -0.05142212, 0.033599854, 0.045837402, 0.0121536255, 0.043121338, -0.027023315, -0.011207581, -0.0011425018, 0.019134521, 0.020065308, 0.040618896, 0.02986145, 0.037078857, -0.015197754, -0.028656006, 0.020385742, -0.018203735, -0.007659912, 0.024536133, -0.009094238, 0.02204895, -0.0065956116, -0.045043945, 0.0009784698, 0.011604309, -0.03616333, -0.030029297, 0.030563354, 0.026885986, 0.042816162, 0.08105469, 0.039245605, -0.0033473969, -0.021987915, -0.039520264, 0.017318726, 0.053497314, -0.020263672, 0.024429321, -0.035583496, -0.054138184, 0.045837402, -0.03265381, 0.101379395, -0.060546875, 0.011291504, 0.016082764, -0.006210327, 0.026733398, -0.022903442, -0.020507812, -0.0009870529, -0.053222656, 0.0088272095, -0.019088745, -0.031066895, -0.021224976, -0.022094727, 0.019439697, 0.012390137, -0.018005371, -0.040985107, -0.0035762787, -0.037841797, 0.014862061, -0.031982422, 0.03552246, -0.030731201, -0.027801514, -0.057922363, 0.011566162, 0.03842163, 0.0022830963, -0.021774292, -0.0017585754, -0.043823242, -0.07397461, 0.030349731, 0.020401001, -0.035980225, -0.02720642, 0.0047569275, -0.0149002075, -0.023010254, -0.0287323, 0.017745972, -0.039398193, -0.050750732, -0.015808105, -0.034942627, 0.034118652, 0.04724121, -0.022659302, 0.027160645, 0.04046631, -0.023345947, 0.013755798, 0.00014996529, 0.01852417, -0.025604248, -0.05996704, 0.019134521, 0.037506104, 0.03955078, -0.035949707, 0.01612854, 0.04171753, -0.0015592575, 0.0034866333, 0.03768921, 0.019210815, -0.01940918, -0.015396118, -0.0026111603, 0.009590149, -0.0121154785, -0.08728027, -0.06945801, 0.028961182, -0.0022258759, 0.012924194, -0.06567383, 0.038482666, -0.011001587, -0.002922058, 0.023956299, 0.008628845, 0.027389526, -0.013023376, 0.017852783, -0.038238525, -0.016311646, 0.0030097961, -0.008613586, 0.0076065063, 0.03567505, -0.050079346, 0.017486572, -0.023498535, 0.015304565, -0.019165039, -0.001964569, 0.02947998, 0.014328003, 0.032409668, 0.0079422, -0.0035858154, 0.0017547607, 0.0026607513, -0.034301758, -0.016937256, -0.04437256, 0.06402588, -0.03955078, -0.010513306, -0.000497818, -0.043640137, 0.052337646, -0.01260376, 0.025543213, -0.060180664, 0.031402588, -0.035003662, -0.044036865, -0.007068634, -0.0031967163, 0.029129028, -0.029769897, -0.030548096, -0.012390137, 0.034729004, -0.006565094 ], "summary": [ -0.002090454, -0.016799927, -0.009803772, -0.035888672, -0.024627686, 0.00843811, -0.057647705, -0.0019350052, -0.027160645, 0.011169434, 0.035369873, -0.008293152, -0.025039673, -0.058776855, 0.021774292, -0.031311035, -0.020126343, 0.036102295, 0.017120361, -0.04159546, -0.0039520264, -0.061157227, 0.025024414, 0.008804321, -0.023254395, -0.0016078949, -0.029144287, -0.03805542, -0.021499634, -0.007865906, -0.010482788, 0.042053223, 0.012359619, 0.023956299, -0.043823242, -0.036468506, -0.0040359497, -0.0056610107, -0.027435303, 0.014480591, 0.01272583, -0.012054443, 0.1340332, -0.09472656, 0.066223145, 0.044952393, 0.008583069, -0.06384277, 0.021255493, 0.011665344, -0.031097412, 0.03250122, -0.028656006, -0.007965088, -0.017562866, -0.012214661, 0.008270264, -0.04940796, 0.004524231, -0.017166138, 0.004573822, -0.022415161, 0.024627686, 0.006713867, -0.016021729, 0.019165039, 0.04751587, -0.010520935, 0.034057617, -0.0036067963, -0.0118637085, 0.013771057, 0.016784668, -0.010765076, -0.024429321, 0.031829834, 0.031829834, 0.04159546, 0.0132369995, -0.019088745, 0.02418518, 0.0067481995, -0.010261536, 0.016479492, -0.00831604, 0.04067993, -0.0031852722, -0.030227661, -0.030319214, -0.025619507, -0.025512695, -0.017959595, -0.04837036, 0.007183075, 0.010505676, -0.046173096, 0.058502197, -0.007522583, 0.027755737, 0.023330688, 0.038146973, -0.07232666, 0.06274414, -0.03213501, -0.021743774, 0.033813477, 0.05606079, 0.037231445, -0.004737854, -0.008155823, -0.006084442, -0.021026611, 0.0020942688, -0.0011453629, -0.04724121, 0.020629883, 0.006175995, -0.027618408, -0.007499695, -0.017044067, 0.014579773, 0.04171753, -0.047454834, 0.015914917, -0.026809692, -0.026290894, 0.006324768, -0.0011348724, -0.09350586, 0.06439209, 0.020339966, 0.0049552917, -0.009124756, 0.0051116943, -0.041015625, -0.027282715, 0.0043907166, -0.047729492, 0.008712769, -0.014694214, 0.060150146, -0.022888184, -0.020523071, 0.05114746, 0.033111572, 0.01134491, 0.032318115, 0.011688232, -0.009483337, 0.0009264946, -0.019638062, 0.073913574, 0.050231934, -0.030334473, -0.07171631, -0.064819336, -0.04638672, -0.0014638901, -0.008773804, -0.06573486, 0.010169983, 0.010292053, -0.0079422, -0.062469482, -0.039520264, -0.06402588, -0.027908325, 0.0067443848, 0.013938904, -0.055877686, 0.039611816, -0.0050735474, 0.051239014, -0.00207901, 0.010215759, 0.007762909, 0.00472641, -0.03012085, -0.011253357, 0.07513428, 0.028244019, -0.008888245, -0.013130188, 0.017227173, -0.042144775, 0.004837036, 0.019973755, 0.043029785, 0.044769287, 0.011497498, 0.004470825, 0.0079422, -0.022445679, -0.008163452, -0.036621094, 0.011260986, -0.008598328, 0.03488159, -0.026809692, 0.0072021484, 0.039642334, 0.0063095093, -0.0047035217, 0.023483276, -0.03692627, 0.00022184849, -0.0016546249, 0.01826477, 0.03930664, -0.005016327, -0.0035915375, -0.005142212, 0.0035133362, -0.011672974, -0.03439331, 0.013687134, 0.04925537, -0.03173828, -0.027236938, -0.03265381, -0.018554688, 0.03878784, -0.056640625, 0.072265625, -0.01374054, 0.00006121397, -0.017822266, -0.0048179626, -0.024230957, 0.027420044, -0.012817383, -0.020767212, -0.0069770813, 0.013641357, 0.015609741, 0.026931763, 0.045715332, -0.03451538, 0.0051193237, -0.008285522, 0.032806396, 0.048034668, -0.047912598, -0.045166016, 0.025772095, -0.035461426, 0.0016183853, -0.018539429, -0.010528564, 0.035888672, 0.019119263, 0.031082153, 0.02267456, 0.005012512, 0.0048828125, 0.032592773, 0.011108398, 0.013420105, -0.007091522, -0.004852295, 0.008239746, 0.030685425, -0.01902771, 0.018081665, 0.004360199, -0.025466919, -0.018051147, -0.016357422, -0.014816284, -0.015625, 0.021469116, -0.0005774498, 0.0077667236, 0.02494812, 0.043304443, -0.047180176, 0.001666069, -0.017486572, 0.03479004, -0.0022945404, -0.011306763, -0.016311646, -0.0110321045, -0.010559082, 0.030456543, 0.0047073364, 0.016525269, 0.025421143, -0.003835678, 0.054901123, 0.051635742, 0.042633057, 0.02116394, 0.015686035, -0.01235199, 0.023147583, -0.057434082, 0.018035889, -0.009979248, -0.012001038, -0.01083374, 0.044006348, -0.0020618439, 0.0047912598, -0.0010328293, 0.013832092, -0.0035820007, 0.021606445, 0.007019043, -0.045196533, 0.008003235, 0.011375427, 0.030258179, 0.037353516, -0.003528595, -0.03466797, -0.025024414, 0.020004272, -0.041870117, -0.038085938, 0.026489258, 0.025970459, -0.02520752, -0.020736694, 0.010925293, -0.01473999, -0.025146484, -0.008514404, 0.0043144226, -0.033996582, -0.030731201, -0.057617188, -0.03945923, -0.022613525, 0.019546509, -0.011245728, -0.00086688995, -0.016906738, -0.013954163, -0.024841309, 0.0077819824, 0.010887146, 0.016586304, -0.010383606, 0.0063056946, -0.027755737, 0.003955841, 0.0027236938, 0.010894775, 0.0023155212, -0.020736694, -0.013961792, -0.020431519, 0.03491211, 0.017105103, -0.013496399, 0.017303467, 0.028198242, 0.0012493134, -0.033935547, 0.008995056, 0.089538574, 0.022155762, -0.06414795, -0.06628418, -0.07598877, 0.01184082, -0.008590698, 0.04107666, 0.05114746, -0.01676941, 0.034484863, 0.0024929047, -0.012413025, 0.005760193, -0.02659607, 0.047058105, 0.0028057098, -0.013656616, 0.018737793, 0.03048706, -0.002565384, 0.020492554, -0.007461548, 0.06842041, -0.004459381, 0.051086426, 0.042816162, 0.045776367, -0.0072288513, -0.019882202, -0.032989502, 0.014198303, -0.015167236, -0.032958984, -0.0009236336, 0.035705566, 0.014144897, 0.01902771, -0.033050537, 0.04248047, 0.018051147, -0.0013742447, 0.00920105, -0.017868042, 0.020462036, 0.03060913, 0.002275467, 0.018218994, 0.028396606, 0.024353027, 0.036712646, -0.006664276, 0.061309814, -0.009864807, -0.025848389, 0.018844604, 0.016586304, -0.04006958, -0.023590088, 0.013534546, 0.022033691, -0.00017130375, 0.006286621, 0.012794495, 0.025527954, -0.018356323, -0.00705719, -0.023727417, -0.012245178, -0.010948181, -0.0076828003, -0.0050086975, -0.025161743, -0.056915283, -0.044799805, -0.0099487305, -0.01007843, 0.028274536, -0.041625977, -0.036102295, -0.03152466, 0.050964355, 0.0073394775, 0.055511475, 0.009338379, -0.02456665, 0.025909424, 0.003818512, -0.031921387, -0.014755249, 0.007118225, 0.05368042, 0.029434204, 0.0051956177, 0.050323486, -0.018966675, 0.013198853, 0.016983032, -0.045898438, -0.0435791, -0.024307251, -0.02772522, -0.019699097, 0.008140564, 0.053833008, -0.03829956, 0.013465881, -0.0060310364, -0.0023460388, 0.024383545, -0.017349243, -0.016525269, -0.03845215, 0.0039405823, -0.05596924, 0.043151855, 0.015068054, 0.014099121, -0.0501709, 0.0016326904, 0.0040130615, 0.01979065, -0.091674805, -0.035064697, 0.013839722, -0.12902832, -0.06732178, 0.028808594, -0.043792725, 0.00008904934, -0.035858154, 0.056854248, -0.03451538, 0.020050049, -0.038848877, -0.026550293, 0.09033203, -0.020767212, -0.0947876, 0.06072998, -0.02986145, 0.04043579, 0.054229736, -0.039031982, 0.046325684, 0.08392334, -0.009216309, -0.013893127, -0.022583008, 0.030273438, -0.06616211, 0.026138306, 0.0104522705, -0.014045715, -0.040008545, 0.036193848, 0.009773254, -0.015052795, 0.014770508, 0.04321289, 0.06695557, 0.012046814, 0.012680054, -0.010261536, -0.06011963, 0.02746582, -0.039031982, -0.016540527, 0.008110046, 0.029815674, 0.046173096, 0.006515503, -0.009979248, 0.0063476562, -0.043914795, -0.023376465, -0.016815186, 0.031021118, 0.035125732, -0.020874023, 0.024261475, 0.016448975, 0.06341553, -0.009590149, 0.0079422, 0.022766113, 0.028121948, -0.01826477, -0.027572632, 0.025558472, 0.046142578, -0.024810791, -0.04373169, 0.00774765, -0.036865234, 0.026916504, -0.033477783, -0.016723633, 0.051605225, -0.029159546, 0.06866455, -0.03152466, 0.0093307495, -0.021606445, 0.02217102, -0.010482788, -0.007987976, 0.02796936, -0.025238037, -0.04473877, -0.040771484, -0.017593384, -0.012397766, 0.022140503, 0.009788513, -0.050842285, -0.01348114, 0.029907227, 0.0637207, 0.024169922, -0.0052337646, -0.07385254, -0.07220459, 0.027404785, 0.0101623535, -0.031219482, 0.032287598, 0.011703491, -0.014503479, -0.07305908, -0.013542175, -0.030288696, -0.036102295, -0.008453369, 0.034729004, -0.009269714, 0.037841797, 0.05831909, 0.017501831, -0.015434265, -0.0049591064, 0.0008225441, -0.01638794, 0.01979065, -0.00028181076, 0.0006585121, -0.029510498, 0.00674057, 0.019744873, -0.028167725, -0.005065918, 0.0059661865, -0.0031833649, 0.030441284, -0.036895752, -0.058776855, 0.051513672, 0.051971436, -0.01876831, 0.026412964, -0.00699234, -0.01550293, 0.015220642, -0.02053833, -0.005218506, 0.0038585663, 0.006454468, -0.013244629, 0.000070512295, 0.020446777, -0.0020618439, -0.056243896, -0.037994385, -0.04196167, 0.054840088, -0.020767212, -0.049926758, 0.006214142, 0.0016317368, 0.010147095, -0.00598526, 0.0013942719, -0.011184692, -0.051940918, -0.026565552, -0.0043907166, 0.009216309, 0.0023097992, -0.008911133, 0.040649414, -0.014312744, 0.0013055801, -0.05960083, 0.0066184998, -0.022964478, 0.018829346, -0.0090408325, 0.026107788, -0.061798096, -0.05670166, -0.023040771, -0.029541016, -0.048034668, -0.008880615, 0.002981186, 0.027740479, 0.027740479, -0.027801514, 0.010368347, -0.004611969, 0.018234253, 0.030593872, -0.0104904175, 0.005054474, -0.020141602, 0.046661377, -0.007827759, 0.016326904, -0.04296875, -0.007980347, 0.010848999, 0.032043457, -0.014518738, -0.022644043, 0.031829834, -0.02507019, 0.005886078, -0.009841919, -0.03353882, -0.000682354, 0.018951416, -0.04232788, -0.011871338, 0.039123535, -0.01499939, -0.0024089813, -0.036254883, -0.009963989, -0.01272583, 0.013587952, -0.023986816, 0.04034424, -0.0014591217, 0.01777649, -0.019424438, -0.101745605, -0.028305054, 0.06530762, 0.057769775, -0.002008438, -0.06311035, -0.025222778, 0.003786087, -0.0046691895, -0.03387451, -0.07019043, 0.0040626526, -0.02633667, 0.020767212, 0.016937256, -0.0042877197, 0.03152466, -0.026855469, 0.002532959, -0.017837524, 0.0029182434, 0.0463562, -0.016143799, -0.04324341, -0.01902771, 0.018081665, -0.061584473, 0.0016994476, 0.03829956, -0.02659607, 0.026473999, -0.0007138252, 0.013343811, -0.03616333, -0.07562256, -0.004837036, 0.02279663, -0.0060920715, 0.048034668, 0.037353516, 0.017288208, 0.07727051, -0.015129089, 0.039154053, 0.010482788, -0.0009508133, -0.06921387, -0.046051025, 0.022537231, -0.023330688, 0.034057617, -0.001241684, -0.050811768, 0.0051460266, -0.06793213, -0.00035238266, 0.0007839203, 0.01499176, 0.029251099, 0.021118164, -0.0010471344, 0.020019531, -0.0236969, -0.013084412, -0.024765015, 0.02305603, -0.027832031, -0.020187378, 0.042510986, 0.007335663, -0.0038280487, 0.0047340393, 0.010719299, 0.00806427, -0.030471802, 0.028060913, -0.05154419, 0.0022964478, -0.025115967, 0.00762558, -0.009384155, 0.07092285, -0.026138306, 0.024841309, -0.006252289, 0.020843506, -0.009468079, 0.072143555, 0.01777649, 0.031234741, 0.03479004, 0.020568848, 0.037719727, -0.022521973, -0.032318115, -0.0009598732, -0.0051460266, 0.014221191, 0.0061035156, 0.000032007694, 0.081726074, -0.015617371, -0.0034751892, 0.052093506, 0.012634277, 0.009376526, -0.0010795593, 0.012924194, 0.0049705505, 0.03503418, -0.03390503, 0.01576233, -0.0309906, -0.026397705, 0.012359619, 0.036956787, 0.0043678284, 0.012176514, -0.0054512024, 0.009666443, 0.024414062, 0.018661499, -0.026229858, 0.028518677, 0.06518555, -0.0031223297, 0.0034999847, 0.026947021, 0.03765869, -0.023651123, -0.026504517, 0.08782959, -0.028900146, -0.016021729, -0.0043182373, -0.025314331, 0.014404297, 0.011138916, -0.018615723, 0.016738892, -0.024475098, -0.019088745, 0.043304443, 0.028717041, 0.0335083, -0.018508911, 0.0044822693, -0.0058937073, 0.010040283, 0.007637024, 0.0033435822, -0.02734375, -0.014984131, -0.004234314, -0.015625, 0.028366089, 0.030456543, 0.028457642, -0.017944336, 0.019638062, 0.00038695335, 0.006122589, 0.039276123, 0.019378662, 0.022781372, -0.045898438, -0.016479492, -0.017227173, -0.034484863, 0.0073280334, 0.006511688, 0.038879395, -0.021484375, -0.0017795563, 0.031829834, 0.04473877, 0.07354736, 0.00084400177, 0.026123047, 0.01965332, 0.0023937225, 0.025512695, 0.0055236816, -0.0011005402, 0.023849487, -0.017242432, -0.006603241, 0.022415161, -0.017150879, 0.027786255, -0.029418945, -0.015586853, -0.0020771027, -0.013885498, -0.008308411, 0.00617218, -0.012557983, -0.044281006, -0.03036499, 0.027130127, 0.01777649, -0.042785645, 0.0013551712, -0.02557373, -0.030029297, -0.0020561218, -0.0057868958, -0.005874634, 0.008026123, 0.025741577, 0.011116028, 0.016571045, 0.04019165, -0.005443573, -0.035186768, -0.0008635521, -0.005302429, 0.038391113, -0.035614014, -0.013076782, -0.025909424, -0.00064754486, -0.07232666, 0.018829346, 0.009376526, -0.049743652, -0.04260254, 0.07141113, -0.021408081, -0.01158905, -0.0062026978, 0.026794434, 0.02168274, -0.027618408, -0.017425537, -0.008956909, -0.013183594, -0.0335083, -0.02760315, -0.0066833496, 0.04724121, -0.044006348, 0.038970947, -0.013465881, 0.022857666, -0.054779053, -0.032287598, -0.008178711, 0.022750854, 0.037139893, -0.010276794, 0.004524231, 0.03387451, -0.011260986, 0.001490593, 0.01486969, -0.027511597, -0.03375244, 0.0061912537, 0.038208008, -0.004043579, 0.0127334595, -0.109069824, -0.033721924, 0.030792236, -0.050109863, 0.0017213821, -0.093811035, 0.029556274, -0.021408081, -0.027633667, 0.010765076, 0.04232788, -0.013824463, 0.007080078, 0.013137817, -0.043792725, -0.05831909, 0.045715332, -0.029724121, -0.00028800964, 0.02293396, -0.036895752, -0.021881104, -0.019119263, -0.021850586, 0.008987427, 0.046936035, -0.024673462, -0.0146484375, 0.04333496, -0.037750244, 0.0072669983, 0.0010757446, 0.0035915375, -0.06585693, 0.010215759, -0.08508301, 0.04135132, -0.044281006, -0.025527954, -0.02935791, -0.032196045, 0.03286743, -0.0072784424, 0.0028686523, -0.031341553, 0.013160706, 0.012077332, -0.02885437, 0.01977539, -0.019332886, 0.004196167, -0.053833008, 0.03552246, 0.0032958984, 0.0019416809, 0.029907227 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1203.3376v1
Learning, Social Intelligence and the Turing Test - why an "out-of-the-box" Turing Machine will not pass the Turing Test
Bruce Edmonds, Carlos Gershenson
cs.AI, cs.LG, nlin.AO, F.1.1; I.2.0
The Turing Test (TT) checks for human intelligence, rather than any putative general intelligence. It involves repeated interaction requiring learning in the form of adaption to the human conversation partner. It is a macro-level post-hoc test in contrast to the definition of a Turing Machine (TM), which is a prior micro-level definition. This raises the question of whether learning is just another computational process, i.e. can be implemented as a TM. Here we argue that learning or adaption is fundamentally different from computation, though it does involve processes that can be seen as computations. To illustrate this difference we compare (a) designing a TM and (b) learning a TM, defining them for the purpose of the argument. We show that there is a well-defined sequence of problems which are not effectively designable but are learnable, in the form of the bounded halting problem. Some characteristics of human intelligence are reviewed including it's: interactive nature, learning abilities, imitative tendencies, linguistic ability and context-dependency. A story that explains some of these is the Social Intelligence Hypothesis. If this is broadly correct, this points to the necessity of a considerable period of acculturation (social learning in context) if an artificial intelligence is to pass the TT. Whilst it is always possible to 'compile' the results of learning into a TM, this would not be a designed TM and would not be able to continually adapt (pass future TTs). We conclude three things, namely that: a purely "designed" TM will never pass the TT; that there is no such thing as a general intelligence since it necessary involves learning; and that learning/adaption and computation should be clearly distinguished.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1203.3376v1
2012-03-15T14:47:26
2012-03-15T14:47:26
{ "title": [ -0.0017204285, 0.007286072, 0.025787354, 0.031707764, -0.014381409, -0.024093628, 0.052978516, -0.05923462, -0.018310547, 0.032806396, -0.076660156, 0.018005371, -0.022125244, 0.0016651154, -0.007835388, -0.057556152, -0.009109497, 0.021270752, -0.0030593872, -0.0262146, 0.013923645, -0.03265381, 0.02154541, 0.0087509155, 0.056396484, -0.00793457, -0.051635742, 0.0065841675, 0.0017366409, -0.0211792, 0.017181396, 0.0024490356, 0.007926941, 0.044067383, -0.03933716, -0.026519775, -0.0579834, 0.040039062, -0.013893127, 0.0058631897, -0.029129028, 0.016296387, 0.007255554, -0.01889038, -0.022583008, -0.004802704, -0.029190063, -0.001750946, -0.0046043396, 0.0069389343, 0.0034923553, 0.029571533, 0.015312195, 0.05117798, 0.006801605, 0.010971069, -0.011634827, -0.035461426, 0.036315918, -0.013626099, -0.01260376, -0.022491455, 0.029663086, -0.02243042, 0.0038795471, -0.044708252, -0.02861023, 0.025268555, 0.023452759, 0.02230835, 0.0041122437, -0.00064849854, -0.0019216537, 0.031463623, -0.059509277, -0.042266846, 0.046020508, -0.0038795471, 0.020614624, -0.016403198, -0.04055786, -0.045654297, -0.032806396, -0.034179688, -0.011665344, -0.028182983, -0.008773804, 0.029037476, -0.01966858, -0.051483154, -0.009925842, 0.023529053, -0.03527832, -0.015289307, -0.028366089, -0.052612305, 0.02166748, 0.018325806, 0.01966858, -0.017044067, -0.032318115, 0.00014042854, -0.0496521, -0.019012451, 0.024032593, 0.0024490356, -0.00047898293, -0.007575989, 0.01965332, 0.028274536, -0.0413208, 0.038726807, 0.0015630722, -0.039855957, -0.0009226799, -0.0040397644, -0.048431396, 0.04647827, 0.015289307, 0.016281128, 0.039978027, 0.005683899, 0.051574707, 0.01574707, 0.031341553, 0.03213501, -0.06512451, -0.049224854, 0.011398315, 0.018707275, 0.027359009, 0.061950684, -0.09887695, -0.08117676, -0.087768555, 0.019073486, 0.016052246, 0.032989502, -0.021820068, 0.022216797, 0.012084961, -0.028671265, 0.02508545, 0.006538391, -0.014320374, 0.044189453, 0.04751587, -0.01776123, -0.04522705, -0.059051514, -0.036895752, 0.015419006, -0.021774292, 0.010063171, 0.004135132, -0.010505676, -0.07678223, 0.017074585, 0.060791016, 0.02949524, 0.04800415, 0.031555176, 0.011886597, 0.047607422, 0.056610107, -0.035064697, -0.048095703, 0.007484436, 0.015525818, 0.037261963, 0.003408432, -0.021209717, 0.04336548, -0.020492554, -0.022949219, -0.010299683, 0.011077881, -0.0041770935, -0.023269653, 0.034851074, 0.00008016825, -0.04498291, -0.04498291, 0.04522705, -0.04083252, 0.006729126, 0.017944336, 0.009971619, 0.008987427, -0.008720398, 0.014213562, 0.025619507, -0.037475586, -0.05831909, -0.024902344, 0.020095825, 0.04534912, 0.03213501, 0.022506714, 0.007587433, -0.043121338, 0.01184845, -0.04147339, 0.009239197, -0.028411865, -0.043151855, 0.0072364807, 0.027252197, -0.0067253113, 0.049041748, 0.01638794, -0.005710602, 0.011230469, -0.025436401, -0.0015201569, -0.027832031, 0.01637268, -0.029342651, -0.011894226, -0.036499023, -0.02319336, 0.024795532, -0.03060913, 0.0024929047, -0.0057525635, 0.03488159, -0.01725769, 0.033050537, 0.030441284, 0.033416748, 0.07446289, -0.060150146, 0.018081665, 0.031280518, -0.03250122, -0.010025024, -0.012229919, -0.0066986084, 0.00048708916, 0.04156494, 0.012184143, 0.0076675415, -0.004295349, 0.009796143, 0.04989624, 0.014793396, 0.022903442, -0.012557983, -0.0025310516, -0.017105103, 0.02078247, -0.012634277, 0.052764893, 0.017547607, 0.0047073364, 0.045654297, -0.019729614, 0.00831604, -0.028930664, 0.006942749, 0.02281189, 0.043945312, 0.0036754608, 0.020599365, -0.023071289, -0.00434494, -0.022842407, -0.0126571655, -0.024154663, 0.009811401, 0.046142578, -0.058380127, -0.011383057, 0.008544922, -0.010749817, -0.0054626465, -0.035064697, 0.029281616, -0.0022525787, -0.008148193, 0.045196533, 0.0690918, 0.078308105, -0.004962921, 0.014511108, 0.026809692, 0.02067566, 0.0014543533, -0.06188965, -0.016159058, 0.029220581, 0.049346924, 0.0076828003, -0.0075187683, 0.0032482147, 0.01121521, 0.036865234, 0.07543945, -0.012413025, -0.019180298, -0.07324219, -0.004219055, -0.028793335, -0.020263672, 0.014350891, 0.005554199, 0.032165527, -0.0021362305, -0.014305115, 0.018447876, -0.083496094, -0.018615723, 0.034210205, 0.023040771, 0.026153564, -0.012924194, 0.0231781, 0.036315918, -0.0007328987, -0.017700195, 0.011268616, 0.014930725, -0.021514893, -0.04626465, 0.0056381226, 0.0024642944, -0.07775879, -0.015563965, 0.0036296844, -0.016860962, 0.019165039, -0.028167725, -0.038330078, -0.04647827, 0.012130737, -0.002729416, -0.0024909973, 0.016204834, -0.017425537, -0.06137085, -0.016921997, -0.034057617, -0.0012950897, 0.011520386, 0.014511108, -0.06124878, -0.020462036, -0.008132935, -0.012413025, -0.009765625, 0.006755829, 0.0041046143, 0.013748169, -0.012054443, 0.053009033, -0.061950684, -0.03564453, 0.05380249, 0.04498291, -0.011390686, 0.05105591, 0.019515991, 0.019226074, -0.026382446, -0.06604004, -0.032318115, -0.0052223206, 0.03564453, -0.00078582764, 0.005344391, -0.032470703, 0.022216797, -0.06222534, -0.01979065, -0.019363403, 0.026550293, -0.022094727, -0.032989502, -0.017181396, -0.016845703, 0.0027999878, -0.010986328, 0.026672363, -0.000010192394, 0.0073127747, 0.03010559, -0.004272461, 0.018325806, -0.006111145, -0.023498535, -0.018127441, 0.039886475, -0.034118652, -0.021057129, 0.030548096, 0.014709473, -0.02508545, -0.01713562, -0.058502197, -0.009651184, 0.06222534, -0.025772095, -0.047729492, 0.049865723, -0.06463623, 0.034942627, 0.030426025, -0.009590149, 0.009185791, 0.036895752, 0.01675415, -0.03717041, 0.047729492, -0.049316406, 0.030853271, -0.026672363, -0.094177246, 0.019317627, -0.05255127, 0.020492554, -0.00869751, 0.051849365, -0.040283203, 0.0048103333, -0.036468506, -0.022018433, 0.034088135, 0.04559326, 0.006549835, 0.021057129, 0.025146484, -0.028121948, -0.009536743, -0.0075035095, -0.01322937, 0.029388428, -0.013122559, 0.059295654, 0.003610611, 0.0107803345, 0.016479492, -0.019332886, -0.026351929, 0.051239014, -0.01574707, -0.020004272, -0.03744507, -0.007472992, -0.048339844, 0.040374756, -0.043792725, 0.031555176, -0.04586792, 0.028793335, -0.015281677, 0.00566864, 0.016616821, 0.05831909, 0.0014190674, -0.03778076, -0.005718231, -0.041107178, -0.03225708, 0.0011320114, 0.011955261, -0.024841309, 0.06506348, -0.00019919872, -0.0028476715, 0.004512787, -0.02961731, 0.009643555, 0.008865356, -0.021743774, 0.023330688, -0.008155823, -0.029876709, 0.019622803, -0.029220581, 0.0055160522, -0.0022296906, -0.000046372414, -0.011039734, -0.033233643, -0.026306152, 0.009284973, -0.08441162, -0.031188965, 0.0050849915, -0.070007324, -0.033996582, -0.027938843, 0.020019531, -0.05883789, -0.014656067, -0.013252258, -0.016113281, 0.01838684, 0.031066895, -0.026184082, 0.012245178, 0.014541626, -0.019638062, -0.027694702, 0.018875122, -0.038085938, -0.033935547, -0.006767273, 0.037231445, 0.060791016, -0.0065956116, 0.019332886, -0.012771606, 0.03955078, -0.041778564, 0.042663574, -0.00674057, -0.016555786, 0.0015544891, 0.020233154, 0.008415222, -0.0050315857, -0.0141067505, 0.0418396, 0.01335907, 0.038879395, -0.0848999, 0.03793335, -0.0025539398, -0.09277344, 0.030853271, 0.008857727, 0.021408081, 0.08343506, -0.048095703, 0.07495117, 0.00315094, 0.0010824203, 0.022354126, 0.020431519, -0.026138306, -0.053894043, -0.012687683, 0.0095825195, -0.004802704, 0.01802063, -0.0045661926, 0.0040779114, -0.01739502, -0.052093506, 0.019897461, 0.0423584, -0.023101807, -0.038024902, -0.028823853, -0.015258789, -0.008361816, 0.0063934326, 0.005344391, 0.011154175, 0.00409317, 0.0038642883, -0.02482605, 0.005821228, 0.023162842, 0.029403687, -0.01651001, -0.047180176, -0.011558533, -0.00819397, -0.06915283, -0.028213501, -0.02116394, -0.017944336, -0.013198853, -0.0032806396, -0.009803772, 0.013137817, 0.018035889, 0.07373047, -0.022506714, 0.025558472, -0.017044067, 0.04559326, -0.030197144, 0.014389038, -0.011489868, 0.007865906, -0.019485474, -0.02041626, 0.011405945, 0.0016117096, 0.0037670135, -0.03387451, 0.00806427, -0.007835388, 0.01637268, -0.020690918, 0.0058135986, 0.0071983337, -0.049560547, 0.005706787, -0.007247925, -0.029830933, 0.07397461, 0.056854248, 0.037902832, -0.007659912, 0.018508911, 0.035736084, 0.001045227, 0.03894043, -0.06530762, 0.012168884, -0.02027893, -0.04727173, 0.018173218, -0.007659912, -0.053833008, -0.009880066, 0.012298584, -0.009941101, 0.037139893, -0.03439331, 0.070007324, -0.03314209, -0.06524658, -0.013496399, 0.0014467239, 0.018844604, -0.020339966, 0.012161255, -0.021606445, -0.028274536, -0.004837036, -0.004951477, 0.0036716461, 0.019470215, 0.012016296, -0.02154541, 0.02078247, 0.032104492, 0.0070152283, -0.0154418945, 0.028701782, -0.0013551712, 0.014808655, 0.00055360794, -0.011528015, -0.0127334595, -0.0155181885, 0.022949219, -0.030319214, 0.04324341, 0.011039734, 0.023971558, -0.0146865845, 0.007259369, 0.05444336, -0.03427124, -0.022506714, 0.049468994, -0.0038013458, -0.0047912598, -0.0011606216, -0.01751709, 0.04434204, 0.023376465, -0.0074920654, 0.000426054, 0.008056641, -0.020812988, 0.03387451, -0.007850647, 0.024993896, 0.011734009, 0.035614014, 0.013748169, 0.01586914, -0.070373535, 0.011756897, 0.0078086853, -0.004611969, 0.030044556, -0.047180176, 0.043304443, -0.004447937, -0.011932373, -0.0041542053, -0.05810547, 0.0010919571, 0.056488037, -0.044769287, 0.042236328, 0.030059814, -0.015617371, -0.024627686, -0.056549072, 0.029647827, -0.024597168, -0.008132935, -0.012283325, 0.009643555, -0.029541016, 0.0014972687, 0.020309448, -0.046813965, 0.011940002, 0.015960693, 0.018554688, 0.021743774, -0.0033416748, -0.037719727, -0.014625549, 0.038482666, -0.054473877, -0.022979736, 0.018203735, -0.0052337646, -0.03466797, -0.00059747696, -0.008018494, -0.014190674, -0.035827637, -0.0020122528, 0.00015676022, -0.02709961, 0.029815674, -0.011024475, -0.015533447, 0.037841797, 0.022872925, 0.017730713, 0.003616333, -0.005405426, -0.036865234, 0.040374756, -0.0037708282, -0.0064468384, -0.014633179, -0.013015747, -0.018722534, 0.024353027, -0.015342712, 0.038879395, 0.011642456, 0.021148682, 0.044433594, 0.02508545, 0.022094727, 0.07574463, -0.020721436, -0.0211792, -0.03729248, 0.00014460087, -0.060424805, 0.028686523, 0.026657104, -0.0006914139, -0.022720337, -0.03173828, -0.019241333, -0.00869751, 0.03845215, -0.026870728, 0.044677734, -0.024490356, -0.016036987, -0.03869629, -0.0037326813, -0.017318726, 0.024215698, -0.018966675, -0.010047913, 0.011199951, 0.012016296, 0.015335083, -0.016204834, 0.01890564, 0.024597168, -0.01890564, 0.015434265, -0.07159424, -0.012664795, -0.02508545, -0.030029297, 0.033233643, 0.014152527, -0.0154953, 0.028259277, -0.008804321, 0.05380249, 0.0056610107, 0.047790527, 0.03552246, 0.026229858, 0.020874023, 0.003818512, 0.031082153, -0.012283325, -0.010101318, -0.05657959, 0.016296387, -0.00434494, 0.003271103, -0.06317139, -0.022994995, 0.049468994, 0.009056091, 0.03579712, -0.0025672913, 0.004890442, 0.006351471, 0.007572174, 0.037841797, 0.04324341, -0.017120361, -0.015106201, 0.01751709, 0.012580872, 0.018035889, 0.024795532, 0.0037059784, 0.047912598, 0.03189087, -0.012390137, 0.0062179565, -0.00027656555, 0.03289795, -0.044799805, -0.0062332153, -0.011734009, 0.0034160614, -0.0146102905, -0.025436401, 0.03717041, 0.03692627, -0.022644043, 0.0030117035, 0.03237915, 0.020492554, -0.0005130768, 0.025344849, 0.03137207, -0.05239868, 0.040924072, 0.015197754, -0.046295166, -0.021347046, 0.10839844, -0.023239136, 0.03414917, 0.06750488, -0.013267517, -0.01235199, 0.03527832, 0.026657104, -0.029129028, 0.0009918213, 0.03640747, -0.006504059, 0.00095939636, -0.016799927, 0.012237549, 0.052734375, -0.025100708, -0.00097322464, -0.012023926, -0.0040359497, -0.044555664, 0.015449524, -0.012237549, 0.08068848, -0.0065574646, -0.031585693, 0.010009766, 0.017074585, -0.061553955, 0.0010375977, -0.018478394, 0.06008911, 0.041015625, 0.06732178, -0.018005371, -0.0004131794, 0.033447266, 0.0024471283, 0.03643799, 0.07281494, -0.0002450943, 0.00006151199, -0.031066895, -0.039367676, 0.014526367, 0.0054969788, 0.08319092, -0.003063202, 0.016525269, -0.02859497, 0.003982544, 0.0033550262, -0.044799805, 0.0020618439, -0.020599365, 0.007858276, -0.007255554, -0.020507812, -0.005207062, 0.030685425, -0.023635864, 0.005027771, 0.04095459, 0.05935669, 0.05230713, -0.08081055, -0.013450623, 0.11663818, 0.05886841, 0.14624023, 0.04309082, -0.03656006, -0.004753113, 0.005531311, -0.009338379, -0.0030117035, -0.0009446144, -0.0090408325, -0.01083374, 0.01838684, -0.025985718, -0.010505676, -0.008384705, -0.024917603, -0.02772522, 0.029144287, -0.039031982, -0.015541077, 0.017715454, 0.00043344498, -0.07141113, -0.02394104, -0.018203735, 0.0082092285, 0.018936157, 0.0074691772, -0.009147644, 0.0395813, -0.006877899, -0.022720337, 0.03237915, 0.0541687, 0.0050964355, -0.008323669, -0.016799927, 0.0016908646, 0.01966858, -0.08679199, -0.056121826, -0.024414062, 0.07904053, -0.0017137527, 0.0020999908, -0.00095653534, 0.032806396, 0.022033691, 0.02633667, 0.0013895035, -0.049865723, -0.021316528, -0.021347046, 0.03074646, 0.01600647, -0.028121948, 0.0082092285, 0.01600647, -0.017562866, 0.030776978, 0.007598877, -0.011306763, 0.020599365, -0.009719849, 0.047088623, -0.016937256, -0.008544922, -0.009902954, 0.01071167, -0.00075769424, 0.032287598, -0.030059814, 0.03274536, 0.0096206665, 0.03869629, 0.03970337, -0.028335571, 0.016082764, 0.0181427, 0.032318115, 0.045715332, -0.021514893, -0.062316895, -0.017211914, 0.015213013, 0.019119263, 0.025772095, -0.018173218, 0.017349243, 0.021194458, -0.0037899017, -0.020141602, 0.034088135, -0.0063705444, 0.022384644, -0.053131104, 0.023284912, -0.012710571, -0.01626587, 0.016830444, 0.003929138, 0.04232788, -0.016235352, -0.034454346, 0.0009822845, 0.02609253, -0.0051231384 ], "summary": [ 0.033416748, 0.00095272064, 0.063964844, 0.0657959, -0.031799316, -0.024841309, 0.06161499, -0.086242676, 0.0033435822, 0.011451721, -0.051452637, 0.010604858, -0.054534912, 0.005378723, -0.03062439, -0.05908203, 0.006526947, 0.0079193115, 0.0000019669533, -0.020187378, -0.004020691, -0.015991211, -0.017150879, -0.013389587, 0.035736084, 0.008483887, -0.033843994, 0.006122589, 0.034454346, 0.01928711, 0.021133423, -0.046966553, 0.004184723, 0.03579712, -0.042053223, -0.08862305, -0.018661499, 0.016525269, -0.044647217, 0.030395508, -0.015136719, 0.009002686, 0.028640747, -0.0463562, -0.021026611, 0.022415161, -0.021484375, -0.0011854172, 0.034301758, -0.06274414, -0.024719238, 0.044952393, -0.0032653809, -0.008804321, -0.014701843, 0.0063285828, 0.025512695, -0.0748291, 0.016998291, -0.0023097992, 0.012649536, 0.0077323914, 0.019119263, 0.004337311, 0.0060653687, -0.008956909, 0.03579712, 0.0093688965, 0.011497498, 0.004047394, 0.005241394, 0.0057411194, 0.045715332, -0.024612427, -0.06161499, -0.0038146973, 0.0104904175, -0.0059394836, 0.03074646, -0.06542969, -0.017471313, -0.051116943, -0.0077438354, -0.02192688, 0.007926941, 0.012512207, -0.0023612976, 0.007358551, -0.0020618439, -0.02230835, -0.017745972, 0.027252197, -0.011009216, -0.019424438, -0.024627686, -0.044555664, -0.019012451, -0.054229736, 0.032806396, -0.002286911, 0.02583313, -0.03805542, 0.017410278, -0.0011415482, 0.004497528, 0.018112183, -0.0024700165, -0.023025513, 0.019561768, 0.025039673, -0.023773193, 0.04547119, -0.007888794, -0.02520752, -0.004016876, 0.015434265, -0.024856567, 0.052856445, 0.018295288, 0.056915283, -0.014122009, 0.0023078918, 0.026351929, 0.04547119, -0.004257202, 0.028778076, -0.00045871735, -0.050872803, 0.052459717, -0.012298584, -0.0021400452, 0.041870117, -0.03967285, -0.038848877, -0.04748535, 0.009086609, 0.017868042, -0.022460938, -0.004371643, 0.01586914, 0.004058838, -0.003709793, 0.030807495, -0.02178955, -0.050476074, 0.054901123, 0.026733398, -0.021011353, -0.029586792, -0.07720947, -0.0259552, -0.019805908, 0.00054883957, -0.011581421, -0.0006017685, -0.02835083, -0.07891846, 0.013053894, 0.06616211, 0.033294678, 0.014404297, 0.018249512, 0.010406494, 0.025466919, 0.0146484375, -0.02166748, -0.0015335083, 0.0055351257, 0.024810791, 0.0102005005, 0.050079346, 0.0014333725, 0.035461426, 0.0016899109, -0.0013065338, -0.027542114, 0.006416321, 0.0015096664, -0.01612854, 0.045288086, 0.03149414, -0.042297363, -0.03479004, 0.02519226, -0.032226562, 0.03591919, 0.020065308, 0.050048828, -0.001452446, 0.0029907227, -0.004623413, 0.053253174, -0.026611328, 0.0076789856, 0.025009155, -0.02178955, -0.03186035, -0.02861023, 0.007045746, -0.007587433, 0.034942627, 0.0046958923, -0.03289795, -0.039855957, -0.13391113, -0.0031471252, -0.040100098, 0.03878784, 0.001077652, 0.02078247, -0.0073623657, -0.03363037, -0.016937256, 0.06750488, -0.012413025, -0.025222778, 0.0061683655, -0.030029297, -0.017944336, -0.0131073, -0.050201416, 0.024642944, -0.07354736, -0.011146545, -0.03829956, 0.014915466, -0.023803711, 0.025543213, 0.01777649, 0.020507812, 0.064819336, -0.040985107, 0.009933472, 0.031951904, -0.032104492, -0.028823853, -0.030395508, -0.08111572, 0.017028809, 0.06970215, 0.0368042, -0.0013027191, -0.007709503, -0.028701782, 0.054718018, 0.040802002, 0.032928467, -0.032287598, -0.02305603, 0.0038490295, 0.015281677, 0.003862381, 0.043518066, 0.008895874, -0.015365601, 0.03677368, -0.025558472, 0.020584106, 0.043060303, -0.048828125, -0.006713867, -0.017852783, 0.022537231, -0.0033092499, 0.009765625, -0.007068634, -0.022476196, -0.012550354, -0.017807007, 0.017120361, 0.03353882, -0.032928467, -0.006576538, 0.01071167, 0.01058197, -0.0041999817, -0.043518066, 0.026123047, 0.012107849, -0.004322052, 0.0057144165, 0.035308838, -0.026809692, -0.022964478, -0.016555786, -0.021057129, -0.0028457642, 0.01626587, 0.015792847, 0.0345459, 0.056365967, 0.0062942505, -0.005836487, 0.030929565, -0.029129028, -0.024215698, -0.0058403015, 0.054901123, -0.00051021576, -0.0335083, -0.02456665, 0.015106201, -0.04901123, 0.017822266, -0.0019130707, -0.0061836243, -0.047180176, 0.039916992, 0.004501343, -0.018081665, -0.036346436, 0.014762878, 0.030532837, 0.054901123, 0.025985718, -0.005279541, 0.034454346, 0.050720215, 0.064697266, 0.043395996, 0.049621582, 0.017532349, -0.026321411, -0.01939392, 0.012802124, -0.011199951, -0.046569824, -0.023925781, -0.019699097, -0.019073486, -0.009735107, -0.051940918, -0.043548584, -0.05130005, 0.004463196, -0.00932312, 0.0058403015, 0.024017334, 0.005504608, -0.043640137, 0.0074272156, -0.050964355, -0.014457703, 0.029037476, -0.022354126, -0.0135650635, -0.0049972534, 0.0012226105, -0.028366089, -0.005256653, 0.0047035217, -0.020355225, -0.0028572083, 0.012557983, 0.040008545, -0.02810669, -0.024871826, 0.047668457, 0.029220581, -0.03390503, 0.037719727, 0.015312195, 0.031951904, -0.014274597, -0.053100586, -0.028030396, 0.0065345764, 0.022979736, 0.008666992, 0.058502197, 0.033081055, 0.04876709, -0.12841797, -0.038024902, -0.059814453, 0.00079774857, 0.06530762, -0.012420654, -0.02168274, 0.039093018, 0.0048599243, 0.032592773, -0.042297363, 0.02645874, -0.000059902668, 0.0340271, 0.0015716553, -0.00806427, 0.021362305, -0.006580353, -0.010658264, 0.00598526, 0.0039138794, -0.03414917, -0.0023231506, -0.018875122, -0.021835327, 0.014434814, -0.013206482, -0.015808105, 0.066345215, -0.010398865, -0.035095215, 0.045684814, -0.028549194, 0.07647705, 0.05105591, -0.015388489, -0.01889038, 0.03213501, 0.010948181, -0.051330566, 0.013877869, -0.041931152, 0.053894043, -0.048034668, 0.013366699, 0.015045166, -0.037353516, -0.010826111, 0.005744934, 0.031921387, -0.016296387, -0.009140015, -0.015037537, -0.0184021, 0.035125732, 0.012908936, 0.006248474, 0.070373535, 0.04309082, -0.008506775, -0.043792725, 0.003736496, 0.0107803345, 0.059570312, 0.009292603, 0.02619934, 0.016983032, -0.009292603, -0.002002716, 0.009613037, -0.01474762, -0.010238647, -0.02973938, -0.009963989, 0.03955078, -0.00020730495, -0.0362854, 0.042816162, -0.037322998, 0.014083862, 0.0058288574, 0.03515625, -0.015533447, 0.015304565, -0.007095337, 0.03451538, 0.049865723, -0.058258057, -0.013824463, -0.020263672, -0.035308838, 0.010810852, 0.026306152, 0.0047836304, -0.005580902, 0.007850647, -0.024719238, 0.017608643, 0.018859863, -0.026809692, 0.0010519028, -0.009689331, -0.0110321045, -0.014099121, 0.018829346, 0.0020160675, 0.016174316, 0.0053138733, -0.020706177, 0.009056091, -0.046936035, -0.068603516, -0.059692383, 0.028900146, -0.092163086, -0.020996094, 0.008903503, -0.025268555, -0.0115737915, 0.002817154, 0.041046143, -0.025497437, 0.008468628, -0.035247803, -0.026809692, 0.08404541, 0.041870117, -0.026473999, 0.040618896, -0.012756348, 0.020751953, -0.042266846, 0.0395813, 0.011566162, -0.012191772, 0.010681152, 0.020019531, 0.030151367, -0.009918213, -0.010421753, -0.0385437, 0.0101623535, -0.05227661, 0.050598145, -0.03942871, -0.0066337585, -0.01576233, 0.0048675537, 0.009262085, 0.036224365, -0.0070610046, 0.00027799606, 0.043151855, -0.011695862, -0.011779785, 0.057891846, -0.02418518, -0.052978516, 0.07574463, 0.06237793, 0.005455017, 0.024490356, -0.044952393, 0.01777649, -0.047454834, -0.017700195, 0.028503418, 0.04043579, -0.037200928, -0.039855957, -0.011268616, 0.08215332, -0.010978699, -0.004447937, -0.047729492, 0.0015735626, -0.024261475, -0.004131317, 0.007160187, 0.0036621094, -0.057037354, -0.035705566, -0.010864258, 0.013305664, 0.0064201355, -0.0088272095, -0.025985718, 0.01373291, 0.0045776367, -0.005126953, 0.024368286, -0.005859375, 0.068603516, 0.023162842, 0.009605408, -0.039276123, -0.035705566, 0.01197052, -0.0592041, -0.021072388, -0.064086914, -0.05908203, -0.03250122, -0.013092041, -0.022994995, 0.033081055, 0.013549805, 0.083618164, -0.008666992, 0.011947632, -0.042877197, 0.04385376, -0.025756836, -0.018447876, 0.043762207, -0.0138549805, -0.0066566467, 0.002166748, 0.048583984, -0.021484375, -0.0077705383, -0.023406982, -0.003967285, 0.0022792816, -0.0055122375, -0.011909485, 0.03262329, 0.0075912476, -0.054107666, 0.028656006, 0.006088257, -0.008270264, 0.0345459, 0.08099365, -0.006374359, -0.00075912476, -0.02583313, -0.021942139, 0.01651001, 0.045562744, -0.023361206, -0.015716553, -0.034210205, -0.017944336, 0.019607544, -0.01285553, -0.025115967, -0.012023926, 0.022766113, -0.0006375313, 0.025375366, 0.025863647, 0.064941406, 0.001329422, -0.09625244, -0.017593384, 0.0006699562, -0.0021190643, -0.021972656, -0.0011959076, -0.073913574, 0.00096416473, 0.0017604828, 0.009605408, -0.03427124, 0.0129776, 0.011192322, -0.10461426, 0.048614502, 0.0031585693, -0.028518677, -0.0793457, 0.022628784, 0.013076782, -0.0074768066, 0.014678955, -0.036376953, -0.040527344, -0.013023376, 0.006351471, 0.011985779, -0.0029888153, -0.018554688, -0.012641907, -0.008270264, 0.0049324036, 0.01486969, -0.039001465, -0.049224854, -0.0023593903, 0.0068244934, -0.005630493, 0.042816162, 0.008651733, -0.029541016, 0.0008916855, -0.01953125, 0.03137207, -0.038085938, -0.0335083, 0.0015125275, -0.023376465, 0.024963379, 0.03164673, -0.010398865, 0.015213013, -0.00048971176, -0.03881836, 0.013809204, 0.023345947, 0.03652954, -0.0034942627, -0.031982422, 0.023254395, -0.053588867, 0.0030651093, -0.0033798218, -0.0074501038, -0.014526367, 0.035308838, -0.025756836, -0.017593384, 0.0006928444, -0.03756714, 0.0059509277, -0.02217102, 0.0076789856, -0.048553467, 0.0024375916, 0.006038666, 0.024002075, 0.017211914, -0.0047950745, 0.0036849976, 0.0032367706, 0.0018634796, 0.042114258, 0.008613586, 0.0054779053, -0.000086545944, -0.007827759, 0.00258255, 0.022766113, -0.016433716, -0.009384155, -0.028793335, -0.043182373, 0.03378296, -0.019088745, 0.021087646, 0.0035381317, -0.017211914, 0.022750854, -0.0030765533, -0.07171631, 0.0068740845, -0.015396118, -0.045928955, 0.01134491, -0.016998291, -0.04333496, -0.0013561249, -0.0028266907, -0.04119873, -0.016921997, 0.01751709, -0.021850586, -0.0029296875, -0.0038070679, -0.023406982, 0.007881165, -0.0035305023, 0.050231934, 0.022750854, 0.014442444, 0.033111572, 0.052856445, 0.025634766, 0.048583984, 0.0075683594, 0.0040359497, 0.0027751923, 0.025848389, -0.004371643, 0.02507019, -0.0010347366, 0.0069007874, -0.0181427, -0.061340332, -0.010292053, -0.028182983, 0.036621094, 0.012550354, 0.02532959, -0.011886597, -0.00091028214, 0.010955811, -0.015617371, 0.018508911, -0.048706055, 0.010025024, 0.0137786865, 0.07495117, 0.0524292, 0.026473999, 0.022018433, -0.014831543, -0.043792725, -0.037841797, 0.026321411, -0.0067367554, 0.044036865, -0.020141602, 0.0023040771, 0.00038433075, 0.02923584, -0.035705566, -0.0066375732, -0.012718201, 0.055603027, 0.021560669, -0.002325058, -0.014167786, -0.022109985, -0.0012073517, 0.0065612793, 0.0054244995, -0.011314392, -0.004219055, -0.025100708, -0.04019165, -0.022369385, -0.019500732, -0.0014638901, 0.018478394, -0.019256592, -0.041290283, 0.062805176, -0.014831543, -0.02067566, 0.0066337585, -0.053375244, 0.037902832, -0.033111572, -0.022644043, -0.02557373, 0.024810791, 0.004917145, -0.0017433167, 0.033233643, -0.011405945, 0.036468506, 0.037994385, -0.018508911, 0.0206604, -0.016967773, -0.0010385513, -0.066345215, 0.010276794, -0.040771484, 0.016952515, 0.010757446, 0.048706055, 0.004463196, 0.022766113, 0.0043678284, 0.008934021, 0.0010280609, -0.031585693, 0.030441284, -0.006565094, -0.040863037, 0.053253174, 0.041015625, 0.016540527, -0.026901245, -0.018203735, 0.0859375, 0.012313843, 0.021713257, 0.06756592, -0.005382538, -0.010093689, -0.022018433, -0.039794922, -0.0390625, 0.012916565, 0.046539307, 0.00409317, -0.0053100586, -0.023666382, -0.011184692, 0.020965576, -0.028289795, 0.0031528473, -0.023284912, 0.034332275, -0.066345215, 0.0059776306, -0.01625061, 0.032684326, 0.030288696, -0.0041542053, 0.0029449463, 0.042999268, -0.025268555, 0.03845215, 0.009559631, 0.07550049, 0.05340576, 0.04156494, -0.03677368, -0.0002579689, 0.079833984, 0.0014276505, 0.023422241, 0.021499634, -0.0010566711, 0.010498047, -0.0070152283, 0.017684937, 0.031555176, 0.053375244, 0.033966064, -0.032196045, -0.018630981, -0.049072266, 0.016418457, -0.005558014, -0.014320374, -0.013114929, -0.06793213, 0.019821167, 0.000007748604, -0.030944824, -0.06384277, 0.058013916, -0.02659607, -0.032196045, 0.042236328, 0.015014648, 0.0155181885, -0.062805176, -0.049682617, 0.058929443, 0.038391113, 0.08782959, 0.06149292, -0.0385437, 0.035461426, 0.0053749084, 0.02999878, -0.013038635, -0.039031982, 0.03656006, 0.028076172, 0.022460938, -0.0154418945, 0.011497498, -0.0042533875, 0.009788513, -0.08465576, 0.06359863, -0.038116455, -0.010925293, -0.00007939339, 0.00079345703, -0.07104492, -0.015113831, -0.010620117, 0.0072250366, 0.043701172, 0.02418518, 0.0027217865, 0.06958008, -0.010665894, -0.014190674, 0.009689331, 0.007713318, 0.014579773, -0.03805542, 0.01727295, -0.032165527, -0.004234314, -0.040802002, -0.0056877136, -0.008911133, 0.040649414, -0.0052757263, -0.032989502, 0.00699234, 0.009925842, 0.015853882, 0.013580322, -0.009895325, -0.038269043, 0.0008969307, 0.031951904, 0.03463745, 0.027114868, -0.027038574, 0.020553589, 0.00737381, -0.060333252, -0.013908386, -0.026611328, 0.031311035, -0.03604126, 0.0013017654, 0.02494812, -0.027709961, -0.035003662, -0.036315918, -0.006500244, -0.0005002022, -0.012924194, 0.010551453, 0.0062713623, -0.035308838, 0.023590088, 0.012184143, 0.037017822, -0.030227661, -0.020828247, 0.030700684, -0.0077438354, 0.00047945976, -0.011688232, 0.0033226013, 0.0016965866, 0.01638794, 0.0041885376, -0.016784668, -0.004360199, 0.007587433, -0.07598877, -0.006954193, 0.062683105, 0.0010194778, 0.0103302, -0.004714966, -0.002199173, 0.010643005, 0.006011963, 0.020462036, 0.026000977, 0.048919678, -0.0018062592, 0.01890564, 0.0021343231, 0.010818481, 0.0055389404 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1211.6727v1
Graph Laplacians on Singular Manifolds: Toward understanding complex spaces: graph Laplacians on manifolds with singularities and boundaries
Mikhail Belkin, Qichao Que, Yusu Wang, Xueyuan Zhou
cs.AI, cs.CG, cs.LG
Recently, much of the existing work in manifold learning has been done under the assumption that the data is sampled from a manifold without boundaries and singularities or that the functions of interest are evaluated away from such points. At the same time, it can be argued that singularities and boundaries are an important aspect of the geometry of realistic data. In this paper we consider the behavior of graph Laplacians at points at or near boundaries and two main types of other singularities: intersections, where different manifolds come together and sharp "edges", where a manifold sharply changes direction. We show that the behavior of graph Laplacian near these singularities is quite different from that in the interior of the manifolds. In fact, a phenomenon somewhat reminiscent of the Gibbs effect in the analysis of Fourier series, can be observed in the behavior of graph Laplacian near such points. Unlike in the interior of the domain, where graph Laplacian converges to the Laplace-Beltrami operator, near singularities graph Laplacian tends to a first-order differential operator, which exhibits different scaling behavior as a function of the kernel width. One important implication is that while points near the singularities occupy only a small part of the total volume, the difference in scaling results in a disproportionately large contribution to the total behavior. Another significant finding is that while the scaling behavior of the operator is the same near different types of singularities, they are very distinct at a more refined level of analysis. We believe that a comprehensive understanding of these structures in addition to the standard case of a smooth manifold can take us a long way toward better methods for analysis of complex non-linear data and can lead to significant progress in algorithm design.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1211.6727v1
2012-11-28T20:10:42
2012-11-28T20:10:42
{ "title": [ 0.030578613, 0.0053977966, 0.008392334, -0.018966675, -0.017303467, -0.025604248, -0.0015125275, -0.027770996, -0.022857666, 0.0071258545, -0.017959595, 0.006462097, -0.0011177063, -0.045684814, 0.013999939, -0.019226074, 0.015594482, 0.022079468, 0.019470215, -0.008453369, -0.032958984, -0.0065574646, 0.06567383, 0.008232117, 0.018051147, 0.027862549, 0.0110321045, -0.018844604, 0.009490967, -0.031707764, 0.0049743652, -0.004348755, -0.00053167343, 0.055419922, -0.025100708, 0.051879883, -0.024765015, 0.04095459, 0.0309906, 0.009521484, 0.016952515, -0.0061073303, -0.032958984, -0.023498535, -0.021606445, -0.0002105236, -0.011878967, -0.01953125, 0.002407074, 0.022247314, -0.010192871, 0.0023536682, 0.003917694, 0.057891846, -0.007129669, -0.019805908, -0.041290283, -0.021774292, 0.020812988, 0.012771606, 0.003566742, -0.027770996, 0.022262573, -0.016952515, 0.005420685, -0.04449463, -0.11273193, 0.036010742, 0.01576233, 0.0009584427, 0.0031223297, -0.015556335, -0.0074157715, 0.043029785, -0.031188965, -0.03640747, 0.014778137, 0.002702713, 0.03149414, 0.0012750626, -0.035125732, -0.020431519, 0.018615723, -0.015686035, -0.022872925, -0.01689148, -0.012321472, 0.0154800415, -0.0070381165, -0.026321411, -0.002609253, -0.018569946, -0.0519104, 0.025009155, 0.021942139, -0.068115234, 0.0078086853, -0.02545166, 0.023361206, -0.0262146, 0.0076522827, -0.036834717, -0.025268555, -0.0013980865, 0.03286743, 0.00497818, -0.016418457, -0.017654419, 0.037902832, 0.029876709, -0.030700684, 0.03942871, 0.036193848, 0.010406494, 0.030944824, -0.06213379, -0.03765869, 0.0881958, 0.0068244934, 0.0317688, -0.013000488, -0.012145996, -0.034576416, 0.0158844, 0.025756836, 0.008613586, -0.008255005, 0.032073975, -0.0036697388, -0.0284729, -0.00077056885, 0.055023193, -0.046417236, -0.025512695, -0.048309326, 0.033935547, -0.011405945, 0.014892578, -0.002691269, 0.0051193237, 0.04159546, -0.027359009, 0.0007238388, 0.052856445, -0.04574585, 0.02986145, 0.043060303, 0.005428314, -0.07989502, -0.11706543, 0.038726807, -0.024841309, 0.018234253, 0.0058059692, -0.010513306, -0.002412796, 0.03201294, -0.044647217, -0.0016727448, -0.043640137, 0.025756836, 0.0026016235, 0.008590698, 0.01486969, 0.010864258, -0.0000218153, 0.002073288, 0.0107040405, -0.0007791519, 0.031188965, -0.03164673, 0.0017127991, -0.02798462, -0.018203735, 0.0009994507, -0.0051841736, 0.010116577, -0.033721924, 0.016998291, 0.062286377, 0.033172607, -0.03152466, -0.045715332, 0.037384033, 0.010177612, -0.0395813, -0.022094727, -0.05429077, 0.036193848, 0.0064888, -0.037200928, 0.028457642, -0.021453857, 0.010467529, -0.018035889, -0.00932312, 0.039886475, 0.034942627, 0.0040016174, -0.021484375, -0.042144775, 0.044952393, -0.03213501, 0.03930664, 0.06335449, -0.046417236, 0.046844482, 0.0022602081, 0.041931152, 0.035827637, 0.0022468567, -0.0052337646, 0.03527832, -0.07086182, -0.052734375, -0.037994385, 0.021118164, -0.016220093, -0.019332886, -0.027664185, -0.026870728, 0.014328003, -0.034301758, 0.051635742, 0.013473511, -0.025115967, 0.017959595, -0.011520386, 0.028335571, 0.038116455, -0.019470215, -0.025115967, 0.0018453598, 0.04208374, -0.024932861, 0.0006766319, 0.03656006, 0.08074951, 0.008651733, -0.01158905, 0.021316528, -0.019302368, 0.014373779, 0.027664185, 0.019134521, 0.01525116, 0.03479004, -0.018585205, 0.0043754578, -0.033203125, 0.05029297, 0.0013484955, 0.05065918, 0.047607422, 0.03378296, 0.033325195, 0.02961731, 0.05706787, -0.07897949, 0.0345459, -0.010375977, 0.103027344, 0.031280518, 0.032409668, -0.06402588, 0.027053833, -0.014633179, 0.016616821, -0.015220642, 0.019256592, 0.026184082, -0.020721436, -0.012542725, -0.0058517456, -0.03982544, -0.019348145, -0.024734497, 0.0340271, -0.001698494, -0.03338623, 0.0014944077, -0.012893677, 0.048828125, 0.006427765, 0.031829834, 0.018310547, 0.06222534, 0.013153076, -0.0006942749, 0.013618469, 0.04748535, 0.06439209, 0.02142334, 0.016326904, 0.026016235, 0.015090942, 0.039855957, 0.042236328, -0.02003479, 0.02029419, -0.029190063, 0.017120361, 0.041229248, -0.02696228, 0.006839752, 0.031341553, 0.03805542, 0.0035896301, -0.013999939, -0.010597229, -0.03591919, -0.0018405914, 0.001917839, 0.01586914, -0.007987976, -0.035064697, -0.0012264252, 0.003238678, -0.032318115, -0.03274536, 0.05987549, -0.027740479, -0.03765869, -0.021942139, -0.032470703, -0.009689331, 0.008010864, -0.030151367, -0.016616821, -0.01436615, -0.04837036, -0.055541992, -0.06713867, 0.031921387, -0.009017944, 0.020492554, -0.005168915, -0.042053223, -0.02949524, 0.010215759, 0.00026154518, -0.034088135, 0.0042762756, -0.035186768, 0.002357483, -0.01260376, 0.016555786, 0.00034809113, 0.016571045, 0.028823853, -0.024124146, 0.010673523, -0.009887695, -0.0058784485, 0.060150146, -0.06890869, -0.021408081, 0.041748047, 0.01638794, -0.0038986206, -0.0045776367, 0.015457153, -0.0046424866, -0.007911682, -0.0013017654, -0.049194336, -0.0064811707, 0.021514893, 0.03982544, 0.022766113, -0.026000977, 0.0015354156, 0.005115509, 0.014129639, 0.049682617, -0.027740479, -0.03945923, -0.049560547, -0.0034923553, -0.036499023, 0.0041656494, -0.011268616, 0.023361206, 0.006137848, 0.0803833, -0.031173706, -0.011886597, 0.03414917, 0.03451538, 0.015563965, -0.013038635, -0.026367188, 0.008300781, -0.015014648, 0.019470215, -0.0030117035, 0.034942627, 0.003791809, -0.034362793, -0.011009216, 0.0026378632, 0.031555176, 0.0038261414, 0.025253296, -0.072387695, 0.060546875, -0.039520264, -0.007083893, 0.00983429, 0.044067383, -0.015411377, -0.029434204, 0.019332886, -0.04397583, 0.014793396, -0.02229309, -0.01663208, 0.010795593, 0.018325806, -0.024230957, -0.017318726, 0.027786255, -0.034973145, -0.011276245, -0.026016235, 0.009689331, 0.027313232, 0.017929077, -0.010986328, 0.02494812, 0.008224487, -0.038909912, 0.004398346, 0.032318115, 0.013175964, 0.049804688, -0.025970459, 0.0013923645, 0.017868042, -0.017669678, -0.027618408, -0.0006632805, 0.009742737, 0.042419434, -0.01927185, 0.0040397644, -0.000013649464, -0.023086548, -0.008399963, 0.07220459, -0.051574707, 0.0287323, -0.058776855, 0.024551392, -0.040527344, -0.035614014, -0.041168213, 0.00793457, -0.055908203, 0.027282715, 0.029891968, 0.012420654, -0.011878967, -0.04776001, -0.019958496, -0.030532837, 0.041809082, 0.0014600754, -0.0033092499, -0.014884949, -0.03302002, 0.042877197, -0.01940918, -0.019577026, 0.03829956, 0.02330017, -0.023986816, 0.0034866333, -0.011131287, 0.0008368492, 0.015396118, -0.0045661926, 0.017868042, -0.004508972, -0.0001963377, 0.024993896, -0.05697632, -0.0043258667, 0.0006337166, -0.024719238, 0.021453857, -0.02796936, 0.01210022, -0.017227173, -0.02911377, -0.040374756, -0.029754639, 0.017654419, 0.0051956177, -0.056884766, 0.039886475, -0.012962341, -0.028884888, 0.010772705, 0.018371582, -0.012550354, 0.007633209, 0.022567749, 0.04385376, 0.048217773, 0.028366089, 0.025817871, 0.07446289, 0.031555176, -0.013664246, 0.007019043, 0.022918701, -0.0066490173, 0.005355835, 0.0098724365, -0.026397705, 0.017852783, -0.030654907, 0.044006348, 0.015029907, -0.026901245, -0.016525269, 0.059326172, 0.017196655, -0.025619507, 0.023727417, 0.0011119843, 0.012062073, 0.036254883, 0.0064926147, 0.024353027, 0.0010519028, -0.019378662, -0.00705719, -0.022323608, 0.012016296, -0.017166138, -0.026550293, -0.026855469, -0.004005432, 0.022109985, 0.013504028, 0.054779053, 0.011444092, -0.029373169, 0.026031494, 0.050476074, -0.030654907, -0.019897461, -0.019500732, -0.09008789, -0.037872314, 0.034057617, 0.023712158, -0.012496948, 0.05331421, 0.060058594, -0.050842285, -0.036376953, -0.0060577393, -0.018341064, 0.006969452, -0.05444336, 0.011810303, -0.0077552795, -0.023544312, -0.032592773, 0.013748169, -0.0059394836, -0.008384705, -0.021881104, 0.020614624, 0.033996582, 0.021026611, -0.002161026, -0.0259552, -0.0154418945, -0.00447464, 0.026779175, -0.008300781, -0.04953003, 0.002872467, -0.0066719055, -0.0033473969, -0.054534912, 0.010482788, -0.010757446, -0.001408577, -0.055786133, 0.0019292831, -0.034729004, 0.013542175, 0.029708862, 0.05355835, 0.0034828186, -0.0026493073, 0.030197144, 0.0027656555, -0.010856628, 0.015655518, 0.06726074, 0.030227661, 0.026535034, 0.050201416, 0.06567383, -0.022537231, -0.05831909, 0.03982544, 0.010169983, 0.056610107, -0.027236938, 0.030685425, -0.011505127, -0.055603027, -0.010398865, -0.018295288, -0.02142334, 0.020126343, -0.045806885, -0.035003662, -0.058532715, 0.025497437, -0.013847351, -0.015655518, 0.009933472, 0.012619019, 0.0023975372, -0.009384155, -0.032226562, 0.018447876, 0.03414917, -0.0060157776, -0.018997192, 0.003320694, 0.051635742, 0.0034503937, 0.018051147, 0.0037727356, 0.027282715, -0.0116119385, -0.025970459, -0.01449585, -0.02116394, -0.02041626, 0.0052604675, -0.033355713, -0.012908936, 0.032958984, -0.07330322, -0.03643799, -0.045196533, -0.036315918, 0.02961731, 0.04171753, 0.017288208, 0.052734375, 0.14831543, -0.01058197, 0.06567383, 0.00737381, -0.0085372925, 0.046051025, -0.005027771, 0.006942749, -0.023086548, 0.017303467, -0.0715332, 0.045562744, -0.00579834, -0.00630188, -0.01889038, 0.04446411, -0.0067749023, 0.0031909943, -0.03967285, 0.014122009, -0.005367279, 0.017440796, -0.005680084, -0.0181427, 0.022262573, 0.008529663, 0.014656067, 0.012611389, -0.062805176, -0.01020813, 0.05734253, -0.03652954, 0.023864746, 0.026138306, 0.017669678, -0.0690918, -0.05239868, 0.079589844, 0.005645752, -0.028747559, -0.039916992, -0.017471313, -0.076293945, 0.03366089, 0.04071045, -0.0345459, 0.016433716, -0.0027256012, 0.009651184, 0.039642334, 0.019378662, 0.02848816, 0.008239746, 0.001285553, -0.06768799, -0.028244019, 0.0073547363, -0.027786255, 0.005279541, -0.013038635, 0.0028762817, 0.035949707, -0.023880005, 0.027694702, 0.004245758, -0.009918213, 0.011505127, 0.007904053, 0.020370483, -0.0061149597, 0.01965332, 0.017745972, -0.010131836, -0.006336212, 0.014282227, 0.025421143, -0.017471313, -0.046905518, 0.05960083, -0.012763977, 0.023208618, -0.0028095245, -0.0008816719, -0.03829956, 0.0077667236, 0.020843506, -0.015281677, -0.0011816025, -0.0071105957, 0.07543945, -0.039916992, -0.024719238, -0.00015211105, 0.015960693, -0.005317688, 0.030685425, -0.00020086765, -0.015571594, -0.019058228, -0.03805542, 0.0079193115, 0.015266418, 0.01838684, 0.010856628, 0.042999268, -0.11071777, -0.06524658, -0.056762695, -0.0102005005, -0.004207611, 0.06378174, -0.026489258, -0.057769775, -0.0032215118, -0.03152466, 0.015960693, -0.00056409836, 0.028396606, 0.0016002655, -0.009651184, -0.018692017, -0.03262329, 0.008712769, 0.016738892, 0.018157959, 0.012145996, -0.03189087, -0.01184082, -0.023071289, -0.0491333, 0.038970947, 0.028900146, 0.056396484, 0.027297974, 0.010772705, 0.0138549805, 0.010345459, -0.027862549, -0.030700684, 0.020050049, -0.042541504, 0.004863739, -0.031433105, -0.01574707, -0.05807495, 0.004508972, 0.020568848, 0.003709793, 0.061920166, -0.013458252, 0.007183075, 0.0051612854, 0.008224487, 0.037963867, 0.045562744, -0.01411438, -0.003540039, -0.030822754, 0.006088257, 0.010818481, 0.015319824, -0.0006418228, 0.021820068, -0.01979065, -0.014602661, 0.023468018, -0.016525269, 0.009719849, 0.023971558, 0.015838623, -0.012184143, -0.047973633, -0.019760132, -0.03967285, 0.03555298, 0.030792236, 0.0087890625, 0.0073776245, 0.040039062, 0.016052246, -0.037261963, 0.018707275, 0.04537964, -0.076660156, 0.01436615, -0.00020265579, -0.020950317, 0.0101623535, 0.025131226, 0.037261963, -0.056671143, -0.022994995, 0.036743164, 0.0046958923, -0.01197052, -0.0040130615, -0.019088745, 0.017303467, 0.018814087, -0.01676941, 0.034423828, -0.027832031, -0.004928589, 0.03491211, -0.0077400208, 0.0038032532, -0.002609253, -0.0043296814, -0.0065231323, 0.01576233, -0.026733398, 0.06048584, -0.06317139, -0.06274414, 0.012496948, -0.011451721, -0.041259766, -0.057891846, -0.007095337, 0.03213501, 0.008811951, 0.03062439, -0.006046295, -0.010238647, 0.013114929, -0.014289856, -0.027938843, 0.021102905, -0.02255249, -0.013412476, -0.0035629272, -0.017333984, 0.03010559, -0.025558472, 0.0357666, 0.022735596, 0.046569824, 0.0022258759, -0.0052490234, 0.035095215, -0.058654785, 0.008026123, 0.04333496, -0.036590576, 0.012573242, -0.02772522, -0.04421997, 0.051757812, -0.017105103, -0.058776855, 0.05441284, 0.033111572, 0.04156494, -0.04055786, -0.0096588135, 0.05822754, 0.025131226, 0.08905029, 0.036712646, -0.04421997, -0.04812622, -0.004966736, 0.0065307617, 0.09643555, 0.022399902, 0.028274536, -0.09899902, 0.028015137, 0.007858276, 0.040405273, -0.0070228577, -0.05126953, 0.07147217, -0.01108551, -0.022094727, 0.019699097, -0.015945435, 0.003627777, -0.060302734, -0.008323669, -0.038757324, -0.029922485, 0.0038433075, -0.006717682, -0.0038051605, 0.018661499, -0.022720337, -0.021728516, 0.023147583, 0.03604126, -0.013252258, 0.013084412, -0.019760132, 0.035369873, 0.044677734, -0.03692627, -0.029067993, -0.020477295, -0.011695862, 0.007762909, 0.026000977, -0.0006432533, 0.0013666153, -0.018249512, 0.011077881, 0.0013656616, -0.02067566, -0.00083875656, -0.03326416, 0.021774292, 0.038238525, -0.039093018, 0.043640137, 0.05001831, -0.010177612, 0.035491943, 0.0692749, -0.043792725, 0.040893555, -0.018920898, -0.001004219, -0.039978027, -0.00762558, 0.03970337, 0.032592773, -0.022323608, 0.043426514, -0.01537323, -0.0079193115, 0.022460938, 0.0076675415, -0.010749817, 0.0014429092, -0.0061149597, -0.014892578, 0.016571045, -0.014190674, 0.027252197, -0.018417358, -0.011581421, 0.016113281, 0.010688782, 0.03704834, 0.00573349, -0.034423828, -0.001616478, -0.02558899, 0.021514893, 0.03201294, -0.01713562, 0.07354736, -0.05038452, -0.029083252, -0.046020508, -0.034301758, -0.008422852, 0.026611328, -0.041503906, -0.004966736, -0.046875, -0.027542114, -0.009361267, -0.024520874 ], "summary": [ 0.076660156, -0.0061836243, 0.03074646, 0.013191223, -0.0012340546, -0.055633545, 0.047698975, -0.03463745, 0.015396118, -0.00006151199, -0.025604248, 0.014442444, -0.022003174, -0.013755798, 0.019760132, -0.035339355, 0.01158905, 0.036895752, 0.04660034, -0.022247314, -0.011810303, -0.02142334, 0.050994873, 0.0021419525, 0.021362305, 0.0075531006, 0.03756714, -0.01675415, 0.024932861, -0.007949829, 0.022781372, -0.024993896, -0.01335144, 0.09283447, -0.059570312, 0.04171753, -0.020248413, 0.05316162, 0.024658203, 0.035247803, 0.01348114, -0.0124435425, 0.027801514, -0.04763794, -0.010017395, 0.034576416, -0.009117126, -0.022064209, 0.02368164, 0.0007138252, -0.0041885376, 0.040740967, 0.0064888, 0.015312195, -0.013809204, -0.013031006, -0.059265137, -0.040161133, 0.018066406, 0.08856201, 0.042175293, -0.022262573, -0.012680054, -0.0435791, 0.0096588135, -0.026687622, -0.071899414, 0.015174866, 0.018173218, 0.013977051, 0.023254395, -0.028411865, 0.012527466, 0.0022697449, -0.0035266876, -0.00090408325, 0.001739502, 0.012664795, 0.01725769, 0.0054893494, -0.011306763, -0.023254395, 0.00012886524, -0.0118255615, -0.016067505, 0.0031261444, -0.020050049, 0.0063934326, -0.014884949, 0.0058937073, -0.020690918, -0.030838013, -0.035125732, 0.05886841, 0.03326416, -0.040222168, -0.040649414, -0.07098389, 0.035339355, -0.0124053955, 0.08770752, -0.07055664, 0.024749756, 0.00088882446, 0.025665283, 0.026504517, -0.032043457, -0.066711426, 0.045043945, 0.01676941, -0.0043754578, 0.03677368, 0.025817871, -0.022567749, 0.0007123947, -0.05130005, -0.03302002, 0.1005249, 0.038604736, 0.026519775, -0.023986816, 0.019088745, -0.04812622, 0.014045715, 0.039886475, 0.023971558, 0.015068054, 0.012527466, 0.009689331, 0.027282715, -0.0077438354, 0.0030879974, -0.025619507, -0.0033283234, -0.027786255, 0.0010137558, -0.04446411, -0.033050537, -0.0057029724, -0.003452301, 0.015563965, -0.05078125, -0.013336182, 0.03302002, -0.031402588, 0.041259766, 0.008911133, 0.010444641, -0.03189087, -0.09954834, 0.058654785, -0.054901123, 0.031982422, -0.019134521, -0.017547607, -0.050750732, 0.021972656, -0.035247803, 0.014335632, -0.04196167, -0.002922058, -0.028289795, -0.02104187, 0.023956299, -0.0112838745, 0.044769287, 0.014854431, 0.006603241, 0.017211914, -0.01725769, 0.016998291, -0.02897644, -0.0446167, -0.027954102, 0.0042915344, 0.018966675, 0.009880066, -0.0036392212, -0.006641388, 0.03555298, 0.033996582, -0.035186768, -0.05682373, 0.035614014, 0.0011014938, -0.030578613, 0.0034370422, -0.020584106, 0.032806396, 0.013442993, -0.0006084442, 0.016311646, 0.0049209595, 0.004673004, -0.017318726, -0.025772095, 0.0110321045, 0.017364502, 0.0019216537, -0.023727417, -0.00076675415, 0.010231018, -0.00028896332, 0.020385742, -0.017745972, -0.00009649992, 0.0067749023, 0.01828003, 0.020690918, 0.010734558, -0.0032234192, -0.02961731, 0.016098022, 0.010429382, -0.0152282715, -0.047424316, 0.06756592, -0.023040771, 0.00011271238, -0.044036865, 0.0047912598, 0.050048828, -0.042053223, 0.058776855, 0.00023007393, -0.013633728, -0.011940002, 0.0013656616, 0.031097412, 0.015899658, -0.003742218, -0.013511658, -0.018875122, 0.055755615, -0.009979248, -0.009246826, 0.04043579, 0.037322998, 0.02796936, 0.0032749176, 0.010612488, 0.004852295, -0.0152282715, 0.020568848, -0.011405945, 0.029525757, 0.04107666, -0.017700195, 0.0063552856, -0.025283813, 0.016555786, -0.020446777, 0.060028076, 0.0052948, 0.033599854, 0.023101807, 0.00013971329, 0.026931763, -0.049804688, 0.0309906, -0.017593384, 0.039489746, 0.03262329, 0.0019989014, -0.067871094, -0.026382446, -0.026672363, -0.031341553, 0.027923584, -0.04031372, 0.00919342, -0.053588867, -0.014297485, -0.031799316, -0.042755127, -0.05908203, -0.053253174, 0.06311035, -0.0057258606, -0.032073975, -0.008010864, -0.050201416, -0.012062073, 0.013084412, 0.0496521, 0.006072998, 0.035980225, 0.034240723, 0.040405273, 0.077819824, 0.057556152, 0.068481445, 0.030181885, 0.018112183, -0.012924194, 0.024978638, 0.052093506, 0.04019165, -0.03982544, 0.01965332, 0.015449524, 0.023727417, 0.0070724487, -0.013442993, -0.0010681152, 0.05886841, 0.040405273, -0.03656006, -0.027282715, 0.0024356842, -0.034606934, -0.026855469, 0.02658081, 0.0993042, -0.037750244, -0.041534424, 0.002313614, 0.050109863, 0.007270813, 0.010635376, 0.06976318, -0.054107666, -0.008728027, -0.02708435, -0.04144287, -0.02519226, 0.019546509, -0.010673523, -0.008087158, -0.014976501, -0.064086914, -0.059143066, -0.055999756, 0.035125732, -0.00932312, -0.009422302, 0.001086235, -0.05053711, -0.022949219, 0.006340027, -0.0015125275, -0.019851685, 0.0011234283, -0.047180176, -0.06713867, 0.024307251, -0.02960205, 0.0073013306, -0.019546509, -0.02180481, 0.042510986, -0.0029830933, -0.0030021667, -0.017745972, 0.028747559, 0.020843506, -0.009307861, 0.020355225, 0.05819702, -0.029754639, -0.007320404, 0.0079193115, -0.023910522, -0.021316528, 0.0060157776, -0.02557373, 0.0116119385, -0.0057868958, 0.054656982, 0.023834229, -0.0016222, 0.024520874, -0.033966064, -0.002828598, 0.04345703, -0.029846191, 0.021987915, -0.037384033, -0.023376465, -0.011314392, 0.0027160645, 0.009788513, -0.01084137, 0.012336731, 0.1081543, -0.016143799, 0.0011491776, 0.03567505, 0.06451416, 0.020202637, -0.02067566, -0.038513184, 0.050750732, -0.03579712, 0.007850647, -0.004589081, 0.005050659, 0.016708374, 0.016082764, -0.006038666, 0.020980835, 0.025146484, 0.0068359375, 0.017242432, -0.04586792, 0.107055664, -0.027832031, 0.007987976, 0.012550354, 0.02809143, 0.00009423494, -0.02848816, 0.0037059784, 0.0016365051, -0.010658264, -0.017227173, 0.03881836, 0.006011963, 0.0063819885, -0.027694702, -0.014877319, 0.057403564, -0.014785767, -0.016052246, -0.038208008, -0.041656494, 0.020935059, 0.07055664, -0.03149414, 0.018341064, 0.0022659302, -0.042144775, -0.011871338, 0.017242432, -0.008903503, 0.011413574, -0.014213562, -0.003145218, 0.02468872, -0.04788208, -0.009284973, 0.001958847, -0.017684937, 0.038024902, -0.03555298, -0.0046691895, 0.024337769, -0.036956787, 0.03186035, 0.06585693, -0.035614014, -0.0018520355, -0.014076233, 0.011497498, -0.053619385, -0.040924072, -0.040100098, 0.005180359, -0.022583008, -0.012992859, -0.0006608963, 0.008834839, -0.026489258, -0.037231445, 0.0048103333, 0.0045394897, 0.032562256, 0.013633728, -0.0037117004, -0.016708374, 0.009094238, -0.0135650635, -0.022064209, -0.034576416, 0.045013428, 0.0047569275, -0.012870789, -0.019363403, 0.045288086, 0.007843018, -0.049591064, 0.0149383545, 0.018569946, -0.041107178, -0.019256592, 0.025405884, -0.018173218, -0.0077590942, 0.025817871, 0.027679443, 0.055999756, -0.049591064, 0.038482666, 0.022323608, -0.024215698, -0.001627922, -0.035247803, 0.050445557, 0.020050049, -0.07324219, 0.0569458, -0.039642334, 0.021957397, -0.000069499016, -0.01902771, 0.029327393, 0.019134521, 0.0362854, 0.04345703, -0.015098572, 0.00077962875, 0.00014650822, 0.0340271, 0.009429932, -0.01184082, 0.03112793, 0.024612427, -0.0037117004, 0.02267456, -0.030715942, -0.022628784, -0.0016431808, -0.011161804, 0.031921387, 0.028381348, 0.013328552, -0.024154663, 0.054016113, 0.0065956116, -0.0019054413, 0.002407074, -0.0134887695, 0.01689148, 0.042419434, 0.027572632, 0.012512207, -0.015533447, -0.0005598068, 0.04748535, -0.00831604, 0.012557983, 0.017044067, -0.0018463135, 0.006198883, -0.01184082, 0.021438599, 0.009178162, 0.030578613, 0.00187397, -0.05050659, 0.03552246, 0.053771973, -0.034576416, -0.024459839, 0.017730713, -0.033325195, -0.020629883, -0.0018901825, 0.0058021545, -0.00434494, 0.0007505417, 0.027938843, -0.016830444, -0.004219055, -0.011177063, 0.027740479, -0.059020996, -0.081726074, -0.02935791, 0.010154724, -0.0060195923, 0.0016269684, 0.027816772, -0.045013428, 0.0036678314, -0.050567627, -0.0032958984, -0.003545761, 0.022506714, 0.026184082, 0.0093688965, 0.002243042, -0.020843506, -0.040222168, -0.020370483, -0.026000977, 0.01651001, 0.0008263588, -0.035369873, -0.04336548, 0.013656616, -0.005393982, 0.008026123, -0.044311523, -0.02078247, -0.036102295, -0.011634827, 0.006439209, 0.045013428, 0.0043258667, -0.010658264, 0.019683838, 0.012123108, -0.0134887695, -0.00969696, 0.024383545, -0.025177002, 0.013458252, 0.028396606, 0.035369873, -0.016525269, -0.075927734, 0.014526367, 0.023468018, 0.03842163, -0.002029419, 0.008636475, -0.019012451, -0.048614502, -0.01158905, 0.0021400452, -0.029174805, 0.022705078, 0.0028095245, -0.07006836, 0.017120361, 0.055389404, -0.012992859, -0.042938232, 0.012390137, -0.018554688, -0.0011005402, -0.014144897, -0.06100464, 0.016830444, 0.052856445, 0.015007019, -0.018539429, 0.02583313, 0.05557251, -0.00079774857, 0.030822754, 0.004863739, 0.0032691956, -0.008857727, -0.016067505, -0.007797241, -0.020019531, -0.014160156, -0.001745224, -0.021972656, 0.0027236938, 0.025146484, -0.081970215, -0.015945435, -0.050994873, -0.03149414, 0.0006480217, -0.0032787323, -0.011146545, -0.00447464, 0.03439331, -0.02607727, 0.036590576, -0.01550293, 0.021820068, 0.037139893, -0.0005412102, 0.0067749023, -0.032043457, 0.0021820068, -0.010505676, 0.034332275, 0.0019483566, 0.005607605, -0.01878357, 0.029190063, -0.0104522705, -0.0104522705, -0.015380859, 0.017288208, 0.008468628, 0.015205383, -0.02281189, -0.008605957, 0.03253174, -0.010360718, 0.0064582825, 0.024871826, -0.017486572, 0.030807495, 0.062927246, -0.008155823, 0.010047913, 0.04107666, 0.027374268, -0.021453857, -0.07739258, 0.02760315, -0.017593384, -0.010757446, -0.03161621, 0.025680542, -0.048950195, -0.023956299, 0.029754639, -0.018737793, 0.007904053, -0.016998291, 0.021514893, 0.005256653, -0.013923645, 0.01675415, 0.0010538101, 0.015625, -0.04949951, -0.051940918, -0.014480591, -0.037109375, 0.02848816, -0.0068740845, 0.05783081, 0.07055664, -0.049865723, 0.037872314, -0.02960205, 0.0024738312, -0.0042915344, -0.026412964, -0.012306213, -0.027770996, -0.010551453, 0.046051025, -0.04244995, -0.03817749, -0.031982422, 0.018920898, 0.0105896, 0.0013389587, 0.009216309, 0.009468079, -0.004634857, 0.021347046, -0.0005931854, -0.03857422, -0.019958496, -0.009254456, -0.030136108, 0.02468872, -0.027664185, 0.082092285, -0.018981934, -0.0065994263, -0.021347046, 0.010284424, -0.010734558, 0.03970337, -0.031341553, 0.0014896393, -0.02619934, -0.031021118, 0.018493652, -0.0034046173, 0.0056991577, -0.008125305, 0.0057525635, -0.07885742, -0.044769287, -0.015594482, -0.050445557, -0.019897461, 0.05871582, -0.008613586, -0.06008911, 0.031402588, -0.07348633, 0.0058937073, 0.020523071, 0.02267456, -0.019897461, -0.007129669, -0.033569336, 0.006717682, 0.025177002, -0.0028133392, 0.039794922, -0.020431519, 0.0079574585, -0.03491211, -0.03515625, -0.018600464, 0.05114746, 0.009239197, -0.030593872, -0.05105591, -0.036712646, 0.034729004, -0.0022792816, -0.027145386, -0.0154953, -0.023544312, -0.0146102905, -0.05429077, -0.016464233, -0.01940918, 0.0038776398, 0.030471802, -0.024505615, -0.052581787, 0.11071777, -0.029571533, 0.015205383, 0.034973145, -0.035980225, 0.04144287, -0.027709961, 0.018585205, -0.010734558, -0.035369873, 0.011489868, 0.020111084, 0.027404785, 0.01373291, 0.019058228, -0.005836487, -0.045715332, 0.050231934, 0.0046195984, 0.005332947, 0.045806885, -0.004146576, -0.02708435, -0.010971069, 0.01058197, 0.026672363, -0.009719849, -0.022872925, 0.08337402, -0.015853882, -0.012641907, 0.051818848, -0.023422241, 0.023956299, 0.05041504, -0.016586304, -0.012832642, 0.0015230179, -0.007972717, 0.06585693, -0.011390686, 0.047576904, -0.09753418, -0.054382324, 0.0031013489, 0.018936157, -0.0317688, -0.0256958, -0.03451538, 0.015457153, 0.0040016174, -0.02154541, 0.01361084, -0.016616821, -0.0019159317, 0.012283325, -0.010437012, -0.0023078918, 0.015556335, 0.002046585, 0.0115737915, 0.012504578, -0.028076172, 0.030334473, -0.05984497, -0.04336548, -0.0029659271, -0.0038833618, -0.052215576, -0.023544312, 0.039001465, 0.05532837, 0.040008545, 0.028259277, -0.028381348, -0.00554657, 0.064086914, -0.011001587, -0.04397583, 0.016967773, 0.0027103424, 0.008323669, -0.013847351, -0.009124756, 0.032470703, -0.006275177, 0.02809143, -0.013900757, 0.06768799, 0.0048713684, -0.013114929, -0.03225708, -0.015098572, 0.046051025, 0.028762817, -0.019958496, 0.043823242, 0.027008057, -0.051879883, 0.06060791, 0.013832092, -0.07019043, 0.060943604, 0.006713867, 0.014221191, -0.008781433, -0.029632568, 0.009429932, 0.00024700165, 0.06616211, 0.023498535, -0.033966064, -0.029190063, 0.0040779114, 0.04171753, 0.074279785, -0.007736206, 0.08227539, -0.072143555, 0.0071983337, -0.0029468536, 0.007865906, -0.005214691, 0.007785797, -0.004459381, 0.018341064, -0.027542114, 0.056732178, -0.050445557, -0.015281677, -0.010025024, 0.017120361, -0.032287598, -0.044799805, -0.0034046173, 0.015319824, 0.017318726, 0.004005432, 0.0039978027, 0.00040125847, 0.058532715, 0.048034668, 0.014945984, -0.03277588, 0.0073776245, 0.03817749, 0.036895752, 0.006958008, 0.068237305, 0.02583313, -0.015167236, -0.0045776367, -0.020202637, -0.0018863678, 0.010353088, 0.03527832, 0.0074005127, 0.012672424, -0.03781128, 0.017166138, 0.0099487305, 0.035858154, 0.032226562, -0.03756714, 0.03656006, 0.0340271, -0.027893066, 0.002658844, 0.031097412, -0.02558899, -0.006801605, -0.015296936, -0.027175903, -0.02166748, 0.0015869141, -0.002981186, 0.0022907257, 0.0021800995, -0.0062408447, -0.009811401, 0.006336212, -0.025543213, -0.013809204, 0.0099105835, 0.029541016, -0.060333252, -0.009635925, 0.01789856, -0.039733887, -0.03250122, -0.00050878525, -0.0019388199, -0.010147095, 0.005126953, -0.009681702, 0.033416748, -0.06451416, -0.02355957, -0.06945801, 0.01777649, 0.040008545, -0.029678345, 0.0826416, -0.01687622, -0.032440186, -0.010673523, -0.022033691, 0.0044555664, 0.014259338, 0.013130188, 0.0041542053, -0.016677856, -0.031311035, -0.01725769, -0.008743286 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1506.05692v1
A hybrid algorithm for Bayesian network structure learning with application to multi-label learning
Maxime Gasse, Alex Aussem, Haytham Elghazel
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG
We present a novel hybrid algorithm for Bayesian network structure learning, called H2PC. It first reconstructs the skeleton of a Bayesian network and then performs a Bayesian-scoring greedy hill-climbing search to orient the edges. The algorithm is based on divide-and-conquer constraint-based subroutines to learn the local structure around a target variable. We conduct two series of experimental comparisons of H2PC against Max-Min Hill-Climbing (MMHC), which is currently the most powerful state-of-the-art algorithm for Bayesian network structure learning. First, we use eight well-known Bayesian network benchmarks with various data sizes to assess the quality of the learned structure returned by the algorithms. Our extensive experiments show that H2PC outperforms MMHC in terms of goodness of fit to new data and quality of the network structure with respect to the true dependence structure of the data. Second, we investigate H2PC's ability to solve the multi-label learning problem. We provide theoretical results to characterize and identify graphically the so-called minimal label powersets that appear as irreducible factors in the joint distribution under the faithfulness condition. The multi-label learning problem is then decomposed into a series of multi-class classification problems, where each multi-class variable encodes a label powerset. H2PC is shown to compare favorably to MMHC in terms of global classification accuracy over ten multi-label data sets covering different application domains. Overall, our experiments support the conclusions that local structural learning with H2PC in the form of local neighborhood induction is a theoretically well-motivated and empirically effective learning framework that is well suited to multi-label learning. The source code (in R) of H2PC as well as all data sets used for the empirical tests are publicly available.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1506.05692v1
2015-06-18T14:24:19
2015-06-18T14:24:19
{ "title": [ -0.034973145, -0.008270264, -0.050201416, -0.048919678, -0.0031318665, -0.007381439, -0.036834717, 0.003490448, -0.019210815, -0.0037269592, -0.015602112, 0.009101868, -0.040039062, -0.03152466, -0.008491516, -0.011550903, -0.0129470825, 0.029678345, -0.030578613, -0.027709961, -0.024932861, -0.03567505, 0.023651123, 0.0141067505, 0.049316406, -0.04949951, -0.049316406, 0.028274536, -0.021469116, -0.018188477, 0.0013227463, -0.011917114, 0.045959473, 0.027420044, -0.015472412, 0.018569946, -0.02217102, 0.008590698, 0.017181396, 0.0090408325, 0.011192322, 0.0079193115, 0.019958496, -0.018173218, -0.009300232, 0.011459351, -0.05822754, -0.057281494, -0.029663086, 0.029708862, 0.028015137, 0.033233643, -0.0012607574, 0.046661377, 0.018753052, -0.03878784, -0.00042653084, -0.052124023, 0.045166016, 0.06500244, 0.0103302, -0.06323242, 0.017425537, -0.046783447, -0.041809082, -0.043395996, -0.016860962, 0.01914978, 0.068603516, 0.0022945404, -0.00573349, 0.037139893, -0.00242424, 0.038635254, -0.07800293, -0.028945923, 0.07897949, 0.01777649, 0.026351929, -0.038269043, 0.014579773, -0.012916565, -0.02722168, -0.018569946, 0.03692627, -0.018173218, -0.010757446, -0.015899658, -0.057922363, -0.05227661, -0.017562866, -0.028884888, -0.026870728, 0.011924744, -0.01537323, -0.021865845, -0.018661499, 0.016403198, -0.0096588135, -0.043762207, -0.011405945, 0.027694702, -0.076293945, -0.002155304, 0.015342712, 0.021392822, -0.0042762756, -0.028808594, 0.00869751, 0.013061523, -0.024520874, 0.043029785, -0.006916046, -0.012252808, 0.0058059692, 0.035125732, -0.009155273, 0.014671326, 0.010231018, 0.029022217, -0.028259277, -0.032409668, -0.013702393, 0.022766113, 0.019973755, -0.001739502, -0.021606445, 0.0259552, -0.039855957, 0.011955261, 0.032836914, 0.04220581, -0.08630371, -0.05053711, -0.052764893, 0.048095703, 0.008613586, -0.0037879944, -0.011024475, 0.0051841736, 0.03164673, -0.029403687, -0.015411377, -0.0067100525, -0.0021095276, 0.019851685, 0.07348633, -0.0041770935, -0.080078125, -0.045532227, -0.021331787, 0.033843994, 0.053955078, -0.01335144, -0.074279785, -0.031051636, -0.09741211, -0.027297974, 0.0047569275, -0.034179688, 0.026535034, -0.0038795471, -0.0012369156, 0.011695862, 0.03805542, -0.006729126, -0.04031372, 0.014411926, 0.012321472, 0.0062179565, -0.011299133, 0.029327393, 0.032806396, -0.016540527, -0.0079422, -0.00111866, 0.051818848, 0.013404846, 0.005783081, 0.026504517, 0.025787354, -0.022735596, 0.00023400784, 0.039276123, -0.0791626, -0.020126343, -0.008972168, 0.011482239, 0.06738281, 0.0015068054, -0.019577026, 0.004966736, -0.07196045, -0.06384277, -0.029891968, 0.031280518, 0.017868042, 0.03274536, -0.001832962, -0.0034179688, -0.042144775, 0.027526855, -0.03289795, 0.029373169, 0.054595947, -0.03488159, 0.022094727, 0.005092621, -0.036621094, 0.04660034, 0.05834961, 0.000043094158, -0.040161133, 0.025985718, 0.0043296814, -0.0519104, 0.03857422, -0.038848877, -0.0032863617, -0.01473999, -0.02949524, -0.0018444061, -0.034088135, 0.056793213, 0.03253174, -0.03164673, -0.0058670044, -0.058624268, 0.02281189, -0.0087890625, 0.02758789, -0.005126953, 0.024047852, 0.031173706, -0.0017499924, -0.03060913, -0.017410278, 0.008239746, 0.0055885315, 0.013587952, -0.0021018982, -0.00069236755, -0.0039596558, 0.038024902, 0.035064697, -0.018051147, -0.0060691833, 0.02545166, 0.005645752, 0.047943115, 0.05142212, 0.06585693, 0.03866577, 0.040985107, 0.012718201, 0.07470703, 0.01322937, -0.012336731, -0.027801514, 0.027313232, 0.01727295, 0.006210327, -0.033721924, 0.025756836, -0.05114746, 0.021072388, -0.01285553, 0.023925781, 0.026687622, 0.002746582, 0.010810852, -0.037872314, 0.0021686554, -0.021240234, -0.019577026, -0.025314331, -0.019058228, 0.020431519, 0.009689331, -0.05908203, -0.024017334, 0.017730713, -0.0004172325, 0.0048294067, 0.0021877289, 0.015838623, 0.011566162, -0.019165039, -0.018218994, -0.012870789, 0.054138184, 0.021118164, 0.0035305023, -0.027252197, -0.0005302429, -0.012184143, 0.042510986, 0.07055664, -0.021713257, 0.04598999, -0.07745361, 0.029312134, 0.035369873, -0.035736084, 0.00006324053, 0.039215088, 0.026382446, 0.016281128, -0.036071777, 0.0032157898, -0.041656494, 0.017791748, -0.001004219, -0.04699707, -0.038482666, -0.043182373, -0.0029678345, -0.039855957, -0.026504517, 0.0017356873, 0.06921387, 0.0068092346, -0.02508545, -0.005924225, 0.013511658, -0.027832031, -0.020141602, -0.033111572, -0.0018987656, 0.036376953, 0.033599854, 0.036315918, -0.07409668, -0.03189087, -0.0104522705, 0.017700195, -0.011306763, 0.00957489, -0.0076789856, 0.023025513, 0.039367676, 0.0015945435, 0.03189087, -0.03414917, -0.02230835, -0.03881836, 0.00598526, 0.023712158, -0.042144775, -0.003736496, 0.031463623, -0.028167725, -0.047546387, 0.02658081, 0.054779053, -0.07879639, -0.0056037903, 0.04876709, 0.0054244995, -0.005771637, 0.005958557, 0.023361206, -0.015487671, -0.06378174, -0.03729248, -0.037231445, 0.02130127, -0.02885437, 0.011161804, 0.06604004, -0.048919678, -0.0115356445, -0.01109314, 0.009178162, 0.003709793, 0.00059843063, -0.016433716, -0.029632568, 0.0107421875, -0.015449524, -0.0068626404, 0.0031013489, -0.03164673, 0.01398468, 0.08862305, 0.018218994, -0.0070648193, 0.0006637573, 0.042999268, 0.0015716553, -0.014724731, -0.008331299, -0.020065308, 0.009239197, -0.007904053, 0.0143585205, 0.0009937286, -0.015686035, -0.068237305, -0.0013465881, 0.007507324, -0.0036468506, -0.03164673, 0.0057373047, -0.04043579, -0.0047569275, -0.0055122375, -0.034820557, 0.045776367, 0.057281494, 0.021865845, -0.0030441284, 0.040374756, -0.029251099, 0.002199173, -0.021026611, -0.051574707, 0.03930664, -0.029922485, -0.07128906, 0.00022053719, -0.008583069, -0.04446411, -0.04055786, -0.02456665, 0.0395813, 0.016860962, 0.047790527, 0.0017786026, -0.043151855, -0.014274597, -0.046539307, -0.023223877, -0.041870117, -0.029403687, -0.023498535, -0.014312744, 0.053985596, -0.01108551, 0.0063095093, -0.042785645, -0.01586914, -0.015022278, 0.018875122, -0.011955261, -0.03604126, 0.0018081665, -0.00667572, 0.003522873, -0.010223389, -0.026229858, -0.02003479, 0.012763977, 0.006866455, -0.01109314, 0.017974854, 0.0017576218, 0.0044937134, -0.04220581, -0.014457703, 0.01651001, -0.020095825, -0.062072754, 0.0074157715, 0.022109985, 0.007751465, 0.018157959, -0.009559631, -0.028152466, 0.0088272095, -0.03933716, 0.0032520294, 0.003921509, 0.017486572, -0.00016283989, 0.050567627, -0.025772095, 0.006500244, -0.03488159, 0.026412964, -0.0003118515, 0.0038871765, 0.010299683, -0.08325195, -0.002653122, -0.0021896362, -0.12890625, -0.030929565, 0.013427734, -0.026916504, -0.034240723, -0.060516357, 0.012176514, 0.0009860992, -0.037475586, 0.02128601, -0.029449463, 0.022109985, -0.008071899, -0.058929443, -0.031234741, 0.043273926, 0.019729614, 0.0073394775, 0.029907227, -0.008972168, 0.007698059, -0.035186768, 0.017044067, -0.0044136047, 0.05456543, -0.015625, 0.0012102127, 0.039154053, -0.022140503, 0.02923584, 0.044281006, 0.019165039, 0.008300781, -0.0038986206, 0.0027275085, 0.018005371, -0.031341553, 0.03643799, 0.0413208, -0.031402588, -0.0579834, 0.0154800415, -0.007858276, -0.003917694, 0.013755798, 0.012687683, 0.037872314, 0.022338867, -0.005458832, 0.026275635, -0.013168335, -0.017333984, 0.022232056, -0.015808105, -0.010887146, 0.007850647, 0.009986877, 0.025177002, 0.011154175, 0.007926941, -0.01637268, 0.017700195, -0.031311035, -0.029327393, -0.011680603, 0.008308411, -0.003238678, -0.0015659332, -0.057250977, -0.039398193, -0.0035171509, -0.004501343, -0.0069885254, 0.02670288, 0.024795532, -0.009132385, -0.04348755, 0.010887146, -0.003200531, -0.00970459, 0.007091522, -0.027313232, 0.0058135986, -0.0063705444, -0.04626465, -0.047576904, -0.042388916, -0.016403198, 0.03225708, 0.009178162, -0.03704834, 0.0104599, 0.044067383, 0.10656738, 0.029266357, -0.0042495728, -0.06402588, 0.02267456, -0.021224976, 0.003452301, 0.019546509, 0.009094238, 0.0013332367, -0.009803772, -0.015670776, -0.011566162, -0.025756836, -0.048675537, 0.015388489, -0.017166138, 0.03656006, 0.032684326, 0.053222656, 0.03869629, -0.017349243, 0.029327393, 0.03387451, -0.03427124, -0.036590576, 0.006477356, 0.009361267, 0.0104522705, 0.024642944, 0.04156494, 0.005268097, 0.0045280457, -0.020446777, 0.014251709, 0.018997192, -0.0034732819, -0.010566711, 0.024139404, -0.044708252, -0.028945923, 0.003578186, -0.018814087, 0.039520264, -0.03274536, 0.017807007, -0.028411865, 0.02279663, 0.02279663, -0.011756897, 0.009284973, 0.012275696, 0.016738892, -0.08459473, -0.07556152, -0.046722412, 0.0725708, -0.031707764, -0.024230957, 0.008728027, 0.018569946, 0.034851074, 0.04333496, 0.05291748, -0.029022217, -0.023254395, -0.015213013, -0.0023918152, -0.00680542, -0.06036377, 0.036956787, -0.0056381226, 0.009346008, -0.04598999, -0.010681152, -0.057128906, -0.012184143, -0.0076942444, -0.008605957, 0.008605957, -0.09649658, -0.0034427643, 0.020446777, 0.046295166, 0.0008583069, -0.04046631, 0.00003296137, 0.03793335, 0.04840088, 0.0025196075, 0.010314941, 0.06463623, -0.060943604, 0.02458191, 0.02406311, 0.03062439, -0.017456055, 0.05545044, -0.007331848, -0.0022411346, -0.05609131, 0.027633667, -0.0032424927, -0.003419876, 0.001748085, -0.046783447, 0.019836426, -0.006149292, -0.0069847107, 0.002822876, -0.0231781, -0.021484375, -0.005771637, -0.018249512, -0.038909912, 0.0051574707, -0.01361084, -0.025543213, -0.0513916, 0.01109314, -0.023422241, 0.016525269, -0.013084412, 0.0016288757, -0.043060303, -0.0021400452, 0.03479004, -0.040100098, 0.016662598, -0.033416748, 0.017410278, 0.03768921, -0.0031147003, -0.07385254, -0.013847351, -0.00077342987, -0.048309326, -0.031021118, 0.036621094, 0.04006958, -0.01927185, 0.00484848, -0.031921387, 0.028335571, 0.0034942627, 0.02658081, 0.024734497, -0.0072250366, 0.04425049, 0.016281128, 0.020339966, -0.001821518, -0.004245758, 0.004306793, -0.00024461746, 0.019119263, -0.055511475, 0.01626587, -0.019378662, -0.003446579, 0.009284973, 0.007888794, -0.000031352043, 0.024459839, 0.0015668869, -0.02130127, 0.0101623535, 0.032592773, 0.0236969, 0.004787445, 0.0018978119, 0.05697632, -0.020690918, -0.0390625, -0.0077438354, -0.0023612976, -0.035736084, 0.05178833, -0.003786087, -0.01928711, -0.03479004, -0.05307007, -0.025222778, 0.017471313, 0.01285553, 0.039794922, 0.037506104, 0.006374359, 0.07501221, -0.018707275, -0.0129470825, -0.031143188, 0.050811768, 0.0036067963, -0.040008545, -0.016525269, -0.03656006, 0.0048599243, -0.026763916, 0.018478394, 0.01864624, -0.010971069, 0.009468079, -0.047698975, 0.0017318726, -0.013397217, -0.02494812, 0.034423828, -0.00011438131, -0.01876831, 0.023666382, -0.022537231, 0.054382324, 0.02935791, 0.05456543, 0.018661499, 0.013008118, 0.04876709, 0.014678955, 0.023422241, -0.024597168, 0.016738892, -0.035308838, -0.015487671, -0.068725586, -0.0146102905, -0.087768555, 0.003370285, 0.015365601, 0.010559082, 0.017303467, -0.002040863, 0.016403198, 0.01701355, 0.048431396, 0.008918762, 0.06378174, -0.01108551, -0.00491333, -0.012702942, 0.017486572, 0.035064697, 0.044128418, 0.009857178, 0.00034475327, -0.024963379, -0.017959595, 0.025985718, 0.014564514, -0.0058784485, 0.018188477, 0.008506775, -0.036102295, 0.028518677, 0.0034103394, 0.048034668, 0.02961731, 0.03265381, -0.015182495, 0.0047302246, -0.007221222, -0.0046653748, -0.013763428, -0.007949829, 0.035583496, -0.05014038, 0.00030994415, -0.03338623, -0.015686035, 0.009613037, 0.03024292, 0.040740967, -0.09692383, -0.052001953, 0.042419434, 0.030960083, -0.016067505, 0.02998352, -0.037902832, -0.009887695, -0.0184021, 0.013893127, 0.019500732, 0.026733398, 0.015426636, 0.030288696, -0.01448822, -0.0035972595, 0.0032405853, 0.0413208, -0.021774292, 0.032043457, -0.021728516, -0.008338928, 0.012611389, -0.035614014, 0.0030384064, 0.008598328, -0.019561768, 0.0067749023, 0.025283813, 0.061767578, 0.07354736, 0.068603516, 0.019241333, -0.0024280548, 0.03579712, -0.060394287, 0.02027893, 0.006465912, -0.0362854, 0.009132385, -0.015960693, -0.022018433, 0.060455322, -0.023147583, 0.06341553, -0.04232788, 0.003332138, -0.026153564, 0.02178955, 0.021377563, -0.05709839, -0.0003156662, -0.028121948, -0.038391113, -0.013183594, -0.030380249, -0.025360107, -0.012588501, -0.011077881, 0.0077781677, 0.02305603, -0.009651184, -0.022628784, -0.013954163, -0.054748535, 0.00049829483, -0.030136108, 0.027542114, 0.012382507, -0.015640259, -0.020706177, 0.012016296, 0.011230469, -0.053527832, -0.037017822, -0.01537323, 0.005191803, -0.020477295, -0.005592346, 0.009765625, -0.02709961, -0.018707275, 0.06048584, -0.0024299622, -0.020706177, -0.041229248, 0.05380249, -0.047180176, 0.0004427433, -0.008232117, -0.022766113, 0.057678223, 0.022781372, -0.023239136, 0.011116028, 0.018188477, -0.029449463, -0.055480957, -0.038330078, -0.024490356, -0.018188477, -0.027252197, -0.018478394, 0.045806885, 0.043762207, -0.06225586, -0.04019165, 0.021255493, 0.014770508, -0.009521484, 0.05316162, 0.033813477, -0.00995636, -0.02760315, 0.008705139, -0.013069153, -0.02017212, -0.06213379, -0.01914978, 0.049713135, 0.041656494, -0.004676819, -0.014816284, 0.05255127, -0.025512695, -0.023468018, 0.00207901, 0.02760315, -0.010414124, 0.01902771, 0.027282715, -0.03286743, -0.035888672, -0.016326904, 0.012077332, 0.0023937225, 0.006454468, -0.0018730164, 0.005001068, -0.029251099, 0.027893066, -0.041381836, -0.048461914, 0.050964355, 0.038604736, 0.016082764, 0.019577026, -0.013191223, 0.012680054, 0.0018987656, -0.0052337646, -0.01977539, 0.0039711, 0.035217285, -0.025802612, 0.01222229, -0.021240234, -0.0209198, -0.03366089, -0.047576904, 0.03866577, -0.04534912, 0.019989014, -0.06439209, 0.0005373955, -0.0077590942, 0.025894165, 0.03186035, -0.057006836, 0.0021362305, -0.01751709, 0.08135986, 0.0018634796 ], "summary": [ -0.015731812, -0.02998352, -0.03463745, -0.035095215, -0.0552063, -0.00037908554, -0.049987793, 0.022216797, -0.0053863525, -0.014389038, -0.028549194, -0.0048446655, -0.024795532, -0.030731201, 0.035736084, -0.041229248, 0.0048713684, 0.0013179779, -0.026306152, -0.016586304, -0.00066041946, -0.02192688, -0.022232056, -0.002067566, 0.022644043, -0.006790161, 0.05709839, 0.024276733, 0.026321411, 0.017181396, 0.032226562, -0.045043945, 0.0021209717, 0.054382324, -0.03277588, -0.005050659, 0.010017395, 0.014625549, 0.01272583, 0.025375366, -0.0128479, 0.017044067, 0.08911133, 0.012168884, 0.011543274, 0.012580872, -0.02279663, -0.064331055, 0.009010315, -0.021133423, 0.010879517, -0.008224487, 0.009727478, 0.0078086853, -0.023269653, -0.013748169, -0.011116028, -0.061401367, 0.022125244, 0.05911255, 0.016296387, -0.030776978, 0.01084137, -0.051849365, -0.025314331, -0.02407837, 0.0065689087, -0.0011863708, 0.043395996, -0.004322052, 0.012825012, 0.036254883, 0.011054993, 0.008094788, -0.073791504, -0.001912117, 0.070617676, 0.02230835, -0.004108429, -0.038085938, -0.006324768, -0.0107421875, -0.05505371, -0.04550171, 0.041931152, -0.0074806213, -0.007385254, -0.009231567, -0.036102295, -0.012763977, -0.035125732, -0.015731812, -0.008644104, 0.0006299019, -0.014083862, -0.03387451, -0.01612854, -0.03225708, 0.014778137, -0.010879517, 0.023925781, -0.019592285, -0.014823914, -0.007751465, 0.00068330765, 0.0149002075, -0.0012741089, -0.05529785, -0.017456055, -0.0037269592, -0.03616333, 0.0076446533, -0.0052261353, -0.04827881, -0.004760742, 0.046020508, -0.0011606216, 0.035858154, 0.020004272, 0.023040771, -0.0016479492, 0.020233154, -0.04046631, 0.062042236, 0.009017944, 0.03744507, 0.01550293, 0.022445679, -0.004928589, -0.054840088, 0.009788513, 0.043182373, 0.004764557, 0.022766113, -0.014328003, 0.018981934, 0.036224365, -0.032287598, -0.016952515, 0.01991272, 0.032714844, -0.021942139, -0.02696228, 0.015090942, -0.004234314, 0.03161621, 0.03552246, 0.0020217896, -0.029953003, -0.024902344, -0.028274536, 0.04824829, 0.058013916, -0.018692017, -0.05331421, -0.07293701, -0.0004386902, -0.045776367, -0.00018465519, -0.072753906, 0.04849243, -0.0059318542, -0.0041618347, 0.022155762, 0.011650085, -0.022415161, -0.016998291, 0.002161026, 0.006164551, -0.053985596, 0.019180298, -0.00065660477, 0.04046631, -0.04550171, -0.014862061, 0.0008363724, -0.014884949, 0.034698486, -0.016677856, 0.052246094, 0.03781128, -0.028152466, -0.020614624, 0.032592773, -0.047973633, 0.0060195923, -0.011520386, 0.03466797, 0.036987305, 0.0056266785, 0.014122009, -0.021942139, -0.055419922, -0.024658203, 0.015716553, 0.06561279, -0.032562256, 0.022888184, 0.008384705, -0.046081543, -0.04260254, 0.034820557, -0.019378662, 0.016906738, 0.029388428, -0.014350891, 0.030090332, 0.007751465, -0.04421997, -0.031585693, 0.04269409, -0.032165527, -0.035369873, 0.021972656, -0.0109939575, -0.0096206665, 0.012275696, -0.045959473, -0.00472641, -0.028625488, -0.0184021, 0.032440186, -0.044921875, 0.029296875, 0.031021118, -0.022766113, -0.02128601, -0.008552551, 0.013076782, -0.0024375916, -0.019073486, 0.030456543, -0.0010604858, 0.05819702, -0.004798889, -0.020401001, 0.011672974, -0.012336731, 0.030380249, 0.015548706, 0.0008583069, 0.03967285, -0.03564453, 0.021652222, 0.014350891, -0.02658081, -0.0121536255, 0.033996582, -0.013465881, 0.053710938, -0.00566864, 0.06274414, 0.014678955, 0.04562378, -0.00092077255, 0.04345703, 0.0012483597, -0.011497498, -0.02909851, 0.039215088, -0.00137043, 0.017410278, -0.015731812, -0.0022697449, -0.018157959, -0.008605957, 0.026306152, 0.016708374, 0.03164673, -0.029800415, -0.009292603, -0.053741455, 0.01676941, -0.028884888, -0.05657959, -0.026321411, -0.028289795, 0.016677856, 0.057006836, -0.027420044, -0.032348633, -0.04034424, -0.054870605, -0.006717682, 0.037963867, -0.015090942, 0.002817154, -0.014015198, 0.02142334, 0.047607422, 0.06732178, 0.023620605, 0.035247803, -0.02709961, 0.0023593903, -0.0038108826, -0.06616211, 0.030059814, -0.010307312, 0.007911682, -0.03164673, 0.03918457, 0.024261475, -0.02128601, 0.009414673, 0.02961731, 0.022949219, -0.0046691895, -0.004234314, -0.013572693, -0.029373169, 0.018325806, 0.029876709, 0.018676758, -0.0061531067, -0.0135650635, -0.0059890747, 0.02822876, -0.027740479, 0.0005106926, 0.04156494, 0.06298828, -0.0035133362, 0.016799927, 0.032684326, -0.021347046, -0.00705719, -0.023162842, 0.011398315, 0.015930176, -0.016555786, -0.00034236908, -0.044067383, -0.013549805, -0.006000519, -0.007858276, 0.014045715, -0.041107178, -0.0011558533, 0.037384033, 0.070739746, 0.000808239, 0.03692627, -0.0018119812, -0.062408447, -0.010406494, 0.027053833, -0.015136719, -0.025512695, -0.026138306, 0.05029297, -0.025878906, -0.044281006, 0.031829834, 0.014503479, -0.04675293, 0.033050537, 0.041412354, 0.012054443, -0.023376465, 0.0055236816, 0.05621338, 0.006427765, -0.11193848, -0.060943604, -0.03111267, 0.024520874, -0.017120361, 0.028518677, 0.034606934, -0.016571045, 0.023849487, -0.00089502335, 0.0060768127, -0.0075035095, -0.011642456, 0.057617188, -0.020828247, 0.016357422, 0.030975342, -0.015686035, -0.009147644, -0.011627197, -0.025848389, 0.06286621, 0.01878357, 0.03213501, 0.034576416, 0.04034424, -0.018188477, 0.004928589, 0.003780365, -0.01411438, -0.018539429, -0.009902954, 0.013519287, -0.014045715, -0.04425049, -0.0062675476, -0.015533447, -0.023834229, -0.002773285, -0.0105896, -0.017028809, -0.02178955, 0.0067253113, -0.01826477, -0.034179688, 0.03427124, 0.03866577, 0.023071289, -0.019836426, 0.05984497, -0.04019165, -0.012245178, -0.0033798218, 0.040527344, 0.022537231, -0.019165039, -0.060272217, -0.019683838, 0.07678223, -0.009887695, -0.0259552, -0.046875, 0.013366699, -0.019607544, 0.054138184, -0.023849487, -0.016647339, -0.026260376, -0.033081055, -0.020126343, -0.056793213, -0.04360962, -0.016143799, -0.0027542114, 0.059661865, 0.010169983, -0.016571045, -0.05239868, -0.01701355, 0.005542755, -0.013404846, -0.008079529, -0.015235901, 0.0014247894, -0.026550293, 0.018936157, 0.053100586, -0.052734375, -0.016738892, 0.049316406, 0.026748657, -0.029403687, 0.0028133392, -0.00868988, 0.03491211, 0.024124146, -0.023239136, -0.0025577545, -0.02658081, 0.0032901764, 0.004360199, 0.031143188, 0.031066895, -0.0029506683, 0.0033054352, -0.025680542, 0.011665344, 0.004348755, -0.048095703, 0.0052719116, 0.036132812, -0.047180176, 0.032592773, 0.03024292, 0.016540527, 0.0037498474, -0.0030212402, -0.04232788, 0.028793335, 0.023834229, -0.07446289, -0.035736084, 0.021469116, -0.07928467, -0.06842041, 0.008872986, 0.024658203, -0.028762817, -0.023925781, 0.024871826, 0.011619568, -0.009490967, 0.038604736, -0.027999878, 0.107177734, 0.018936157, -0.018997192, -0.019012451, -0.03704834, 0.021072388, -0.010948181, -0.017623901, 0.046325684, 0.045013428, 0.011932373, -0.005493164, -0.013404846, 0.013145447, -0.05621338, 0.027770996, 0.018630981, -0.0018129349, 0.03677368, 0.03250122, 0.016708374, 0.018218994, -0.0054473877, 0.0362854, 0.081848145, -0.047790527, -0.0034122467, 0.050201416, -0.016693115, -0.044006348, 0.041534424, 0.019119263, -0.014480591, 0.024337769, 0.031921387, 0.010002136, 0.03366089, -0.00969696, -0.02911377, -0.034240723, -0.030014038, 0.024520874, 0.024047852, -0.005001068, -0.028274536, -0.024108887, 0.04949951, 0.0013837814, -0.035339355, -0.02406311, -0.017333984, -0.034118652, -0.03213501, 0.0030174255, 0.011230469, -0.048858643, -0.045288086, 0.018920898, -0.011329651, 0.019561768, -0.023513794, -0.013259888, 0.027877808, -0.0036449432, 0.033081055, -0.038513184, -0.0038013458, -0.05505371, 0.012809753, -0.016647339, -0.011444092, -0.046875, 0.002609253, -0.044555664, -0.025985718, -0.09869385, -0.07165527, -0.025726318, 0.018630981, -0.028701782, -0.00029110909, 0.03765869, 0.06304932, -0.018554688, 0.008880615, -0.029388428, -0.025054932, -0.06976318, 0.06536865, 0.028625488, 0.0317688, -0.029876709, 0.02017212, -0.020095825, 0.025375366, -0.029418945, -0.04348755, -0.00003170967, 0.0053215027, 0.0077285767, 0.049438477, 0.06317139, 0.025894165, -0.009719849, 0.024429321, 0.023422241, -0.01864624, -0.03665161, 0.01008606, -0.02558899, -0.0035934448, 0.01789856, 0.03439331, -0.014266968, -0.040039062, -0.01537323, 0.014953613, 0.01525116, -0.0078125, -0.009902954, 0.018310547, -0.005268097, -0.017532349, 0.016052246, -0.010688782, -0.0007162094, 0.0025615692, -0.028366089, -0.010826111, 0.011314392, 0.010101318, -0.01272583, 0.006713867, 0.021865845, -0.0007095337, -0.049957275, -0.07800293, -0.05316162, 0.07952881, -0.0053138733, -0.08135986, -0.029693604, 0.014053345, 0.038604736, 0.020767212, 0.037750244, -0.07562256, -0.017562866, -0.017166138, -0.0149002075, 0.008644104, -0.037017822, -0.004009247, 0.016799927, 0.018234253, -0.009185791, 0.01576233, -0.0008454323, 0.027557373, -0.003665924, 0.017456055, -0.023986816, -0.0519104, -0.052886963, -0.04598999, 0.030532837, -0.037261963, -0.011886597, -0.011833191, 0.00349617, 0.028305054, -0.025985718, -0.012054443, 0.025360107, -0.012191772, 0.040100098, 0.008911133, 0.013290405, -0.038604736, 0.047424316, 0.0016794205, -0.0042495728, -0.03881836, 0.010848999, -0.00030136108, 0.00932312, -0.020370483, -0.02015686, 0.04144287, -0.028869629, 0.0071868896, 0.002779007, 0.016113281, -0.0023021698, -0.007858276, 0.007972717, -0.038146973, -0.024230957, -0.03488159, 0.027114868, -0.035491943, 0.010612488, -0.048339844, 0.03277588, 0.0013132095, -0.023010254, -0.009208679, -0.059051514, -0.008872986, -0.005126953, 0.025161743, -0.020446777, 0.016143799, -0.0004503727, -0.019683838, -0.091918945, -0.0017442703, -0.013839722, -0.02468872, -0.06994629, 0.03086853, 0.026046753, 0.0070533752, 0.003967285, 0.012512207, 0.03451538, -0.024734497, 0.0101623535, 0.02130127, -0.02154541, 0.029922485, -0.00016701221, 0.0061569214, 0.0038146973, -0.02798462, -0.014862061, -0.007888794, 0.020431519, -0.04385376, 0.015609741, -0.008666992, -0.015388489, 0.009613037, 0.032073975, -0.0024166107, 0.022384644, -0.006137848, 0.041107178, 0.009971619, 0.026565552, 0.023468018, 0.033996582, 0.025115967, 0.04763794, -0.016693115, -0.004650116, -0.000025987625, 0.010925293, -0.03036499, -0.010017395, -0.00019776821, 0.017593384, -0.029571533, -0.046936035, 0.016311646, -0.013755798, -0.027557373, 0.05001831, 0.016967773, 0.03781128, 0.08013916, 0.009056091, -0.04196167, -0.017974854, 0.050750732, -0.00022006035, -0.017059326, 0.0149383545, -0.09307861, 0.011833191, -0.016662598, 0.012634277, 0.0077056885, -0.011642456, 0.0064697266, -0.023788452, -0.0015201569, -0.00024211407, 0.0059928894, 0.011123657, -0.012863159, -0.005207062, -0.024978638, 0.0069274902, 0.042144775, 0.04348755, 0.042297363, -0.0037651062, -0.0070266724, 0.05029297, 0.026443481, 0.019973755, -0.009376526, 0.031707764, -0.045715332, -0.042663574, -0.05911255, -0.040496826, -0.028045654, -0.018432617, -0.017089844, 0.0015869141, 0.06286621, 0.006439209, 0.010887146, 0.04321289, -0.00088357925, 0.03994751, 0.03289795, -0.041900635, -0.037506104, -0.012901306, 0.03237915, 0.036071777, 0.045532227, 0.03866577, -0.00856781, -0.009719849, -0.0010194778, 0.06555176, -0.017303467, -0.049835205, -0.026885986, 0.044952393, -0.05630493, 0.04156494, 0.033569336, 0.05731201, 0.005958557, -0.010185242, 0.047332764, -0.020217896, -0.007820129, 0.03878784, 0.028152466, -0.02935791, 0.0034923553, -0.021347046, -0.047973633, 0.023651123, 0.020996094, 0.020874023, -0.026046753, 0.05960083, -0.09088135, -0.029144287, 0.035736084, 0.014411926, -0.054870605, 0.034240723, -0.037139893, -0.020385742, -0.03668213, -0.018737793, 0.019226074, -0.0023822784, 0.009552002, 0.0055236816, -0.016998291, 0.008628845, 0.0037117004, 0.012664795, -0.01020813, 0.0236969, -0.043395996, -0.015792847, 0.06506348, -0.008529663, 0.0024585724, 0.027618408, 0.040222168, 0.04901123, -0.048339844, 0.059020996, 0.06774902, 0.028762817, -0.0435791, -0.0012559891, 0.10461426, -0.02848816, 0.0075950623, -0.04119873, -0.004585266, -0.01121521, -0.0046463013, 0.016708374, 0.023498535, 0.022079468, 0.055908203, -0.03540039, 0.01184845, -0.053894043, 0.04055786, -0.052734375, -0.036376953, 0.0060157776, -0.05154419, -0.039611816, 0.012519836, 0.0050354004, -0.037628174, 0.022003174, -0.019958496, -0.044525146, 0.028533936, 0.0075950623, 0.024536133, -0.014595032, -0.014785767, -0.0057258606, 0.024169922, 0.02180481, 0.0262146, -0.029037476, 0.035888672, 0.0075912476, 0.020370483, -0.05114746, -0.04058838, 0.0045204163, 0.047973633, -0.032043457, -0.006504059, 0.009803772, -0.017166138, 0.017501831, 0.088256836, -0.00010365248, -0.009475708, -0.021026611, 0.03125, -0.011749268, 0.044128418, -0.00027394295, -0.0051727295, 0.012580872, -0.0039787292, -0.02444458, 0.019332886, 0.019470215, 0.005996704, -0.031433105, -0.04019165, -0.06591797, -0.042541504, 0.0045814514, -0.045654297, 0.039611816, 0.040985107, -0.03555298, -0.0070724487, 0.013191223, 0.018112183, 0.021102905, 0.04135132, -0.020050049, -0.034851074, -0.03753662, -0.00009959936, -0.008766174, 0.04095459, -0.019882202, -0.013877869, 0.044891357, 0.018310547, -0.037017822, 0.023162842, 0.047058105, -0.036834717, -0.026397705, 0.016326904, 0.01826477, -0.037841797, 0.03050232, 0.014564514, -0.045837402, -0.052825928, 0.009147644, 0.022537231, -0.023483276, -0.041046143, 0.0005636215, -0.010025024, -0.032287598, -0.022354126, -0.011398315, 0.048095703, -0.020462036, -0.013694763, 0.03186035, -0.039916992, 0.014503479, 0.034179688, -0.0011110306, 0.003440857, -0.0006275177, 0.0008940697, 0.0435791, -0.032043457, -0.0070228577, -0.016464233, -0.017654419, -0.07165527, -0.055023193, 0.036193848, -0.053375244, 0.03390503, -0.022033691, 0.00032925606, 0.0033493042, 0.024230957, 0.0017623901, -0.05038452, 0.055480957, 0.015457153, 0.040405273, 0.030563354 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1512.01124v2
Deep Reinforcement Learning with Attention for Slate Markov Decision Processes with High-Dimensional States and Actions
Peter Sunehag, Richard Evans, Gabriel Dulac-Arnold, Yori Zwols, Daniel Visentin, Ben Coppin
cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
Many real-world problems come with action spaces represented as feature vectors. Although high-dimensional control is a largely unsolved problem, there has recently been progress for modest dimensionalities. Here we report on a successful attempt at addressing problems of dimensionality as high as $2000$, of a particular form. Motivated by important applications such as recommendation systems that do not fit the standard reinforcement learning frameworks, we introduce Slate Markov Decision Processes (slate-MDPs). A Slate-MDP is an MDP with a combinatorial action space consisting of slates (tuples) of primitive actions of which one is executed in an underlying MDP. The agent does not control the choice of this executed action and the action might not even be from the slate, e.g., for recommendation systems for which all recommendations can be ignored. We use deep Q-learning based on feature representations of both the state and action to learn the value of whole slates. Unlike existing methods, we optimize for both the combinatorial and sequential aspects of our tasks. The new agent's superiority over agents that either ignore the combinatorial or sequential long-term value aspect is demonstrated on a range of environments with dynamics from a real-world recommendation system. Further, we use deep deterministic policy gradients to learn a policy that for each position of the slate, guides attention towards the part of the action space in which the value is the highest and we only evaluate actions in this area. The attention is used within a sequentially greedy procedure leveraging submodularity. Finally, we show how introducing risk-seeking can dramatically improve the agents performance and ability to discover more far reaching strategies.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1512.01124v2
2015-12-16T17:34:55
2015-12-03T15:51:30
{ "title": [ 0.011955261, 0.016998291, -0.02633667, -0.03677368, 0.022155762, -0.03579712, 0.011856079, -0.017578125, -0.026153564, 0.016723633, -0.041046143, 0.012954712, -0.015327454, -0.008239746, -0.009849548, -0.03503418, -0.011917114, 0.0066604614, -0.026779175, -0.05203247, 0.003211975, -0.06976318, 0.061920166, 0.072631836, 0.03466797, -0.038208008, -0.099975586, 0.042236328, -0.03274536, -0.020965576, -0.0077056885, 0.010574341, 0.046966553, -0.0025157928, -0.00065612793, 0.051879883, -0.03677368, 0.01108551, 0.017211914, -0.014572144, 0.01108551, -0.008079529, -0.018325806, -0.035339355, -0.031707764, 0.034423828, -0.071777344, -0.018920898, -0.02885437, 0.07141113, 0.03543091, 0.04095459, 0.0038604736, 0.072143555, 0.03894043, -0.025009155, -0.030944824, -0.036468506, 0.03894043, 0.07397461, 0.031555176, -0.04837036, 0.00041365623, -0.03543091, -0.012207031, -0.0385437, -0.00018572807, 0.034423828, 0.0574646, 0.01612854, 0.006980896, 0.022521973, 0.0076179504, 0.0209198, -0.06311035, -0.0087890625, 0.08087158, 0.04168701, 0.014549255, -0.0385437, -0.017959595, -0.028335571, 0.020065308, -0.017745972, 0.0206604, -0.014221191, -0.024368286, -0.009017944, -0.028060913, -0.086364746, 0.00017881393, 0.020721436, -0.039093018, -0.0054397583, -0.03366089, -0.04446411, -0.02758789, 0.017730713, 0.0058288574, 0.0067977905, -0.022491455, 0.0127334595, -0.02204895, -0.015090942, -0.00042033195, -0.009277344, 0.00070238113, -0.037322998, -0.0071144104, 0.032562256, -0.031951904, 0.02130127, 0.028015137, 0.007335663, 0.011985779, -0.035858154, -0.025497437, 0.058624268, 0.008560181, 0.022705078, -0.012817383, -0.020309448, 0.012054443, -0.0063056946, 0.03540039, 0.015365601, -0.037902832, 0.002412796, 0.0051193237, 0.051727295, 0.0066184998, 0.04156494, -0.1126709, -0.09814453, -0.07531738, 0.026641846, -0.010795593, 0.0035514832, -0.009666443, 0.0034637451, 0.008666992, -0.020767212, 0.0074920654, 0.02470398, 0.009628296, -0.0015172958, 0.05319214, 0.003276825, -0.040496826, -0.020202637, -0.025604248, 0.014167786, 0.009475708, 0.012756348, -0.01348114, 0.0056114197, -0.07507324, -0.013572693, 0.015342712, -0.0009446144, 0.05090332, 0.024841309, 0.016159058, 0.047851562, 0.06414795, -0.034698486, -0.038513184, 0.01600647, 0.0003437996, 0.04840088, -0.018661499, 0.021850586, -0.010604858, -0.0102005005, -0.011650085, -0.015586853, 0.032073975, 0.016113281, -0.005306244, -0.011306763, 0.015113831, -0.0423584, -0.011878967, 0.044067383, -0.044403076, -0.010643005, -0.0031604767, -0.0006055832, 0.04660034, 0.015182495, -0.04550171, 0.015991211, -0.041412354, -0.024658203, -0.0592041, -0.0066223145, 0.048736572, 0.049194336, -0.011184692, 0.013137817, -0.026779175, -0.007411957, -0.021194458, -0.004055023, -0.022491455, -0.031921387, -0.0049934387, 0.018707275, -0.04675293, 0.06262207, 0.047180176, 0.0023441315, -0.027236938, 0.011405945, 0.015457153, -0.052703857, 0.0209198, -0.018920898, -0.0023727417, -0.021942139, -0.016296387, 0.001083374, -0.008422852, 0.030593872, 0.02355957, 0.0070381165, 0.0010547638, -0.012199402, 0.029815674, 0.034973145, 0.03326416, -0.05227661, -0.012207031, -0.0058174133, -0.013793945, -0.022903442, -0.0015821457, -0.016525269, 0.035247803, 0.020401001, -0.006225586, 0.0074882507, 0.010696411, 0.049835205, 0.054748535, 0.011039734, 0.0005311966, 0.021026611, 0.0005412102, 0.02041626, 0.06451416, 0.028427124, 0.045318604, -0.005519867, 0.010551453, 0.05255127, 0.0064849854, 0.004211426, -0.021697998, 0.006351471, -0.0026454926, 0.0019264221, 0.012290955, -0.005531311, -0.05569458, 0.011116028, -0.039611816, -0.005455017, -0.0017442703, 0.025039673, 0.033935547, -0.050445557, 0.0046806335, -0.0043563843, 0.010795593, -0.011543274, -0.016693115, 0.011291504, 0.009109497, -0.052703857, -0.0013780594, -0.0020446777, 0.031799316, 0.008171082, 0.013847351, 0.004676819, 0.030471802, 0.005138397, -0.028289795, -0.043182373, 0.04284668, -0.004108429, -0.00065517426, -0.03289795, 0.031173706, -0.03050232, 0.080200195, 0.088378906, -0.02809143, 0.03778076, -0.052093506, 0.016555786, -0.013420105, 0.003408432, 0.0061531067, 0.015792847, 0.028121948, 0.03616333, -0.010948181, 0.017303467, -0.06060791, -0.011383057, 0.0017061234, -0.012062073, -0.048950195, -0.036499023, -0.0036792755, -0.026489258, -0.036499023, -0.0059318542, 0.09765625, -0.03201294, 0.0004749298, -0.009208679, -0.01878357, -0.04046631, -0.0014925003, -0.028701782, -0.035095215, 0.047332764, 0.049072266, 0.03302002, -0.023269653, -0.00957489, -0.011451721, 0.009864807, -0.0048561096, 0.035064697, -0.01348114, -0.046051025, 0.00038194656, -0.048614502, 0.00970459, -0.0030155182, 0.01525116, -0.06738281, 0.0057792664, 0.015625, -0.031982422, -0.0037460327, 0.030807495, -0.025115967, -0.031677246, 0.02798462, 0.045074463, -0.010513306, 0.004135132, 0.046813965, 0.027297974, -0.0028438568, 0.016403198, -0.00045514107, -0.014785767, -0.0982666, 0.0046958923, -0.01864624, -0.024505615, -0.030914307, -0.0129852295, 0.041412354, -0.058380127, 0.0005340576, -0.025238037, -0.014518738, -0.00040912628, 0.023544312, -0.020965576, -0.02444458, -0.041900635, -0.033294678, 0.0072517395, 0.028747559, -0.027862549, 0.015914917, 0.06463623, 0.0034618378, -0.035003662, -0.031829834, 0.0440979, 0.01576233, -0.0030536652, -0.019897461, -0.0126953125, 0.0028076172, 0.02734375, 0.013214111, -0.025619507, -0.039978027, -0.09698486, -0.0072402954, 0.009895325, 0.023529053, -0.013206482, 0.037719727, -0.05645752, 0.041870117, -0.0079193115, -0.031082153, 0.024002075, 0.012588501, 0.021408081, -0.023529053, 0.026184082, -0.051330566, 0.009819031, -0.042877197, -0.056884766, 0.04550171, -0.041931152, -0.042877197, 0.011817932, -0.021621704, -0.021484375, -0.01725769, 0.0024795532, 0.045196533, 0.006149292, -0.0072402954, 0.023498535, -0.010498047, -0.0067863464, -0.023788452, -0.023269653, -0.014450073, -0.01751709, -0.0015907288, -0.017532349, 0.024459839, -0.003255844, 0.000063836575, -0.05633545, -0.0385437, 0.0007071495, 0.029129028, 0.007843018, -0.02633667, -0.032928467, -0.034362793, -0.014152527, 0.009544373, -0.028274536, -0.011505127, -0.03918457, 0.014678955, -0.026412964, 0.06500244, -0.0071792603, 0.013137817, -0.019699097, 0.0019798279, 0.026412964, -0.031433105, -0.01133728, 0.013587952, 0.04598999, -0.011581421, -0.014976501, -0.010398865, -0.036254883, 0.033172607, 0.002046585, 0.0121536255, -0.0025100708, -0.0037021637, -0.027893066, -0.020584106, 0.023132324, 0.024856567, -0.0231781, -0.030822754, 0.01398468, -0.0121154785, 0.001619339, -0.028457642, 0.012756348, 0.0031051636, -0.09887695, -0.022628784, 0.022903442, -0.022506714, 0.02255249, -0.051635742, 0.046051025, -0.036621094, -0.040008545, -0.0060691833, -0.016723633, -0.0124053955, -0.008125305, -0.045196533, -0.0524292, 0.06958008, 0.017837524, 0.012123108, 0.02243042, -0.0010871887, -0.0031261444, -0.0206604, 0.021652222, 0.013504028, 0.025054932, 0.0005540848, 0.02619934, 0.046661377, -0.021987915, 0.009880066, 0.0579834, 0.06149292, -0.017349243, -0.015365601, -0.013183594, 0.01210022, -0.04486084, 0.054870605, 0.044891357, -0.03540039, -0.06524658, 0.0016794205, -0.010238647, 0.0062675476, 0.013534546, -0.022766113, 0.03475952, 0.019317627, 0.006652832, 0.05847168, -0.0071029663, -0.023147583, 0.013153076, 0.005672455, -0.011550903, 0.00057935715, 0.0013427734, 0.017181396, 0.0017385483, 0.05429077, 0.010719299, 0.07366943, -0.008430481, 0.0032920837, -0.0049209595, 0.007259369, -0.04135132, -0.005607605, -0.042053223, -0.04446411, -0.016448975, 0.007633209, -0.023666382, 0.03793335, 0.02885437, -0.003824234, -0.036010742, 0.011421204, 0.053527832, -0.0014648438, -0.005290985, -0.062072754, 0.0047416687, -0.034118652, -0.05303955, -0.039611816, -0.016616821, -0.014656067, 0.023986816, -0.006385803, -0.035064697, 0.020599365, 0.04663086, 0.107543945, 0.038635254, -0.0019016266, -0.057739258, 0.0317688, -0.031921387, -0.0052986145, 0.022842407, 0.008148193, -0.0028820038, -0.01838684, 0.021530151, -0.014175415, -0.01473999, -0.025726318, 0.026443481, -0.015853882, 0.05053711, 0.0038051605, 0.03717041, 0.029205322, 0.03479004, 0.02230835, 0.019165039, -0.033843994, -0.049682617, -0.012672424, 0.046844482, 0.0034103394, 0.011405945, 0.025726318, 0.030670166, 0.011413574, 0.0070495605, 0.009895325, 0.021820068, -0.029418945, -0.025604248, 0.044006348, -0.01751709, -0.028717041, 0.015182495, -0.011299133, 0.036499023, -0.034942627, 0.058563232, -0.013053894, 0.0029010773, 0.049072266, -0.0057792664, -0.011123657, -0.0053253174, -0.009391785, -0.054656982, -0.0793457, -0.024414062, 0.04019165, -0.013389587, -0.008079529, 0.01083374, 0.02142334, 0.03363037, 0.06921387, 0.06958008, -0.037506104, -0.030441284, -0.012527466, -0.0102005005, -0.031280518, -0.038146973, -0.010040283, 0.004081726, 0.011779785, -0.056274414, 0.031982422, -0.049591064, 0.0019569397, -0.00630188, -0.012428284, 0.024108887, -0.06842041, 0.007041931, 0.060150146, 0.0067710876, 0.030853271, 0.013755798, 0.024475098, 0.015617371, 0.03717041, 0.0070610046, 0.028213501, 0.023468018, -0.0289917, 0.031097412, -0.0014543533, 0.030166626, -0.0019454956, -0.010269165, 0.009490967, -0.000828743, -0.04449463, 0.040924072, 0.0034255981, -0.040100098, 0.0073165894, -0.024765015, 0.0021266937, 0.014755249, 0.024291992, 0.028915405, -0.04800415, -0.0256958, 0.002811432, -0.0068359375, -0.020370483, 0.004928589, 0.0048599243, 0.0035114288, -0.06323242, 0.03793335, -0.06604004, 0.028717041, 0.002336502, -0.026855469, -0.026367188, 0.019958496, 0.025787354, -0.039733887, -0.025543213, -0.017669678, 0.031204224, 0.008056641, -0.0063819885, -0.078430176, -0.00868988, -0.0058250427, -0.059753418, -0.066101074, 0.024871826, 0.023391724, -0.006855011, -0.025985718, -0.027832031, -0.02305603, -0.0039024353, 0.01322937, -0.0026855469, -0.052368164, 0.019119263, 0.004650116, 0.016662598, -0.008079529, 0.017349243, -0.009529114, -0.011192322, 0.00497818, 0.0006904602, 0.0063095093, -0.00024914742, 0.011566162, -0.0039405823, -0.064819336, 0.008522034, 0.015396118, 0.013671875, -0.020462036, 0.010223389, 0.037078857, -0.020477295, -0.024215698, -0.0027217865, 0.06188965, -0.05899048, 0.024810791, -0.008102417, 0.001947403, -0.032989502, 0.06695557, -0.034118652, -0.0017604828, -0.066589355, -0.066589355, -0.028961182, 0.013923645, 0.03869629, -0.0017375946, 0.024093628, -0.042877197, 0.0075912476, -0.059417725, -0.004825592, -0.013046265, -0.010665894, -0.01701355, -0.01727295, 0.032928467, 0.007167816, 0.012580872, -0.015335083, 0.003168106, -0.011070251, -0.0057525635, 0.0030841827, -0.022659302, 0.021514893, -0.004737854, -0.010139465, 0.03552246, -0.025680542, -0.022140503, 0.007896423, -0.037475586, 0.05682373, 0.029220581, 0.04168701, 0.054626465, 0.015899658, 0.007286072, 0.011627197, 0.009086609, -0.032226562, 0.024673462, -0.05178833, -0.007987976, -0.037902832, -0.022216797, -0.06713867, -0.003080368, 0.018463135, 0.041900635, 0.030090332, 0.0012741089, 0.018081665, 0.0072288513, 0.029891968, -0.008407593, 0.05718994, 0.029571533, 0.010787964, -0.011169434, -0.003479004, 0.011764526, 0.031951904, 0.019943237, 0.004558563, -0.035095215, -0.015655518, 0.0032596588, 0.0037631989, 0.009651184, -0.0052757263, -0.03250122, -0.043823242, 0.06829834, 0.0011920929, 0.035888672, 0.048217773, 0.040161133, -0.045288086, -0.009185791, 0.006275177, -0.010551453, -0.0340271, 0.017547607, 0.030395508, -0.05050659, 0.029037476, -0.009498596, -0.02217102, -0.028884888, 0.05001831, 0.017578125, -0.035247803, -0.019897461, 0.029907227, 0.02671814, 0.013374329, 0.018676758, -0.03326416, -0.026733398, 0.0021953583, 0.036743164, -0.01071167, 0.029327393, 0.008613586, 0.040130615, -0.025894165, 0.010772705, -0.013069153, 0.045654297, -0.061706543, 0.02003479, -0.034942627, 0.058654785, 0.026672363, -0.0256958, 0.015808105, 0.012504578, -0.0715332, 0.003353119, 0.00881958, 0.038238525, 0.03363037, 0.06341553, 0.014450073, -0.023590088, -0.00024795532, -0.03656006, 0.02432251, 0.021453857, -0.034332275, -0.008903503, -0.0025749207, -0.028381348, 0.033477783, -0.026779175, 0.05142212, -0.028778076, 0.010925293, -0.017990112, 0.020965576, 0.052947998, -0.06298828, -0.05130005, -0.014884949, -0.0418396, 0.0060195923, 0.014099121, 0.0033454895, -0.012382507, 0.0021152496, 0.016693115, 0.04156494, -0.029846191, -0.039245605, -0.010192871, -0.09008789, -0.013847351, -0.041015625, 0.015716553, 0.0309906, -0.013313293, -0.007881165, 0.0030517578, -0.007648468, -0.024002075, -0.026107788, -0.0029621124, 0.0016489029, -0.027145386, 0.044158936, 0.051635742, 0.0069389343, -0.0069847107, -0.0003054142, -0.004108429, -0.010269165, -0.011154175, 0.039855957, -0.02003479, -0.05114746, -0.0096206665, -0.028320312, 0.020263672, 0.005405426, -0.019210815, -0.020080566, 0.023162842, -0.048858643, -0.046661377, 0.0028476715, 0.04360962, -0.019470215, -0.040283203, -0.008888245, 0.044952393, 0.05267334, -0.033416748, -0.04257202, 0.027191162, -0.006000519, -0.018157959, 0.037200928, 0.0037899017, -0.010177612, -0.007904053, 0.046844482, 0.005039215, -0.027557373, -0.024398804, -0.009559631, 0.06451416, 0.051086426, -0.019012451, 0.013900757, 0.028808594, -0.017959595, -0.011924744, -0.0033893585, 0.012863159, -0.001657486, 0.008659363, 0.0440979, -0.02041626, 0.0058059692, -0.03289795, 0.047851562, -0.027908325, 0.01374054, 0.00030732155, 0.012077332, 0.020446777, 0.053955078, -0.039489746, -0.038116455, 0.059570312, 0.060180664, 0.011161804, 0.022094727, -0.021835327, -0.0005311966, 0.0019283295, 0.010154724, -0.011627197, 0.025497437, 0.0423584, -0.05505371, -0.008377075, -0.031921387, -0.05001831, -0.0011405945, -0.0423584, 0.038909912, -0.034179688, 0.011062622, -0.013549805, -0.019439697, -0.018051147, 0.016235352, -0.012718201, -0.06347656, -0.014381409, -0.020141602, 0.04534912, 0.0013341904 ], "summary": [ 0.04537964, 0.0026512146, -0.002872467, 0.0052490234, -0.019699097, -0.046203613, 0.012069702, -0.025283813, -0.023590088, 0.0062408447, -0.05303955, 0.020492554, -0.011383057, -0.00522995, 0.018829346, -0.053894043, -0.008735657, -0.00043177605, -0.013793945, -0.04788208, 0.016235352, -0.04989624, 0.009651184, 0.043121338, 0.009757996, -0.0013818741, -0.023452759, 0.018814087, 0.0071754456, 0.0012550354, 0.0044403076, -0.0050582886, -0.005748749, 0.003578186, 0.054016113, 0.042999268, 0.002817154, 0.0005517006, 0.05529785, -0.008766174, 0.024841309, -0.030273438, -0.0070228577, -0.07293701, -0.036712646, 0.08691406, -0.044769287, 0.009918213, 0.0045166016, 0.056396484, 0.02319336, 0.024383545, 0.013641357, 0.0211792, 0.006313324, -0.013267517, -0.037719727, -0.014732361, 0.012321472, 0.10559082, 0.059417725, -0.0051460266, -0.019882202, -0.06549072, 0.026824951, -0.023849487, 0.040252686, 0.024459839, 0.005542755, 0.033599854, 0.03652954, -0.0154953, 0.015541077, 0.01651001, -0.043426514, -0.0032730103, 0.05984497, 0.042663574, -0.0007157326, -0.023925781, -0.048034668, -0.032287598, -0.011672974, -0.046020508, 0.0068893433, -0.026550293, -0.030319214, 0.007987976, -0.015777588, -0.042144775, -0.0018510818, 0.035614014, -0.06665039, 0.028427124, -0.00793457, -0.044830322, 0.009056091, 0.010437012, 0.032104492, 0.009185791, 0.0017499924, -0.036102295, 0.023345947, -0.032592773, -0.025512695, 0.0043754578, 0.04058838, -0.02458191, -0.027023315, 0.011680603, -0.037902832, -0.014411926, 0.046875, -0.029205322, 0.009819031, -0.026504517, -0.0054092407, 0.07476807, 0.016143799, 0.011405945, -0.02078247, 0.004886627, 0.015281677, -0.013404846, 0.011642456, 0.012176514, -0.010749817, -0.0050849915, 0.03414917, 0.04046631, -0.008102417, 0.010643005, -0.054138184, -0.039215088, -0.058532715, -0.014060974, 0.020065308, -0.0075302124, 0.0014562607, -0.0073776245, 0.02406311, -0.018218994, 0.010292053, 0.029083252, -0.0119018555, -0.004722595, 0.013305664, 0.030731201, -0.017547607, -0.016677856, 0.004070282, 0.0010652542, 0.011062622, 0.0034008026, -0.004131317, -0.030471802, -0.025680542, -0.0029411316, 0.030059814, -0.012763977, 0.04800415, 0.016494751, 0.020889282, 0.07006836, 0.03552246, -0.035003662, -0.038238525, 0.0032749176, -0.00674057, 0.047607422, -0.038116455, 0.043395996, -0.009971619, -0.0060272217, -0.000364542, -0.018569946, 0.017562866, 0.016799927, -0.028839111, -0.021453857, 0.02116394, -0.039764404, -0.021530151, 0.02607727, -0.022583008, 0.013336182, -0.015235901, 0.0206604, 0.022750854, -0.0005059242, 0.0029258728, 0.0037460327, -0.011383057, -0.029144287, -0.05718994, 0.010627747, 0.01449585, 0.04437256, -0.032165527, 0.0129470825, 0.04751587, 0.023849487, 0.00029063225, -0.026550293, -0.046020508, -0.0004351139, 0.009773254, 0.02545166, -0.055633545, 0.02243042, 0.023452759, -0.044128418, -0.017486572, 0.027664185, 0.012771606, -0.049072266, 0.028320312, -0.029510498, 0.013442993, -0.03439331, 0.008880615, 0.0236969, -0.02809143, 0.016571045, 0.022415161, 0.0065956116, -0.02166748, 0.009941101, 0.025970459, 0.031463623, -0.0023612976, -0.012084961, -0.0070495605, 0.0119018555, -0.024139404, -0.020050049, 0.026000977, -0.038269043, 0.046203613, 0.023986816, 0.005748749, 0.04486084, -0.0032920837, 0.034118652, -0.0049934387, -0.024505615, 0.0021438599, 0.0055160522, -0.025894165, 0.033355713, 0.051574707, 0.026519775, 0.0048675537, 0.0024337769, 0.00957489, 0.03451538, 0.013572693, -0.018829346, -0.0019264221, 0.01537323, -0.0074386597, 0.016998291, -0.0029525757, 0.014411926, -0.034973145, -0.0052108765, -0.015670776, -0.015327454, 0.021026611, -0.016189575, 0.006843567, -0.040008545, -0.018127441, -0.03137207, 0.025802612, -0.042816162, -0.038391113, 0.04058838, -0.0011692047, -0.040740967, 0.00868988, -0.0029640198, 0.002161026, 0.003332138, 0.019348145, 0.021850586, 0.03878784, 0.040100098, 0.030136108, 0.031158447, 0.0440979, 0.022766113, 0.011734009, 0.00036501884, 0.030273438, -0.013999939, 0.026809692, 0.046417236, -0.008125305, 0.007926941, -0.01612854, 0.031341553, -0.036987305, 0.020858765, 0.02319336, 0.017715454, 0.06524658, 0.0057029724, 0.013336182, 0.032409668, -0.048095703, -0.013168335, 0.03286743, 0.060150146, -0.025360107, -0.007801056, 0.0018606186, 0.05496216, 0.0012626648, 0.010665894, 0.16149902, -0.06237793, 0.0003569126, -0.02229309, -0.064697266, -0.06512451, 0.04336548, -0.030227661, -0.032196045, 0.032196045, 0.018447876, -0.0009822845, -0.015037537, -0.009521484, 0.0021457672, 0.0046310425, 0.009140015, 0.064453125, 0.019958496, -0.060638428, 0.02658081, -0.036224365, -0.02607727, 0.054595947, -0.004711151, -0.05038452, -0.008171082, -0.017425537, -0.0017290115, -0.0024642944, 0.018630981, -0.0028266907, -0.034942627, 0.037475586, -0.0009813309, 0.03652954, 0.04949951, 0.046539307, 0.042785645, 0.007144928, 0.022964478, 0.0009288788, -0.00995636, -0.105651855, -0.01158905, -0.0062561035, -0.022064209, -0.04055786, 0.0027809143, 0.040100098, -0.034484863, 0.07525635, -0.052764893, -0.035583496, -0.039367676, 0.011985779, 0.03640747, -0.0146865845, 0.0027618408, 0.009902954, 0.026000977, 0.029174805, -0.0021762848, 0.014923096, 0.041137695, 0.011741638, -0.020507812, -0.016464233, 0.030090332, 0.012817383, -0.01789856, -0.028411865, -0.00005722046, -0.007972717, -0.00034213066, 0.009643555, -0.03677368, -0.061065674, -0.034606934, -0.012809753, -0.017120361, 0.04989624, 0.02406311, 0.01146698, -0.004901886, 0.023544312, -0.0015115738, -0.028793335, 0.015541077, 0.0005760193, 0.040008545, -0.04736328, 0.06011963, -0.07354736, 0.025360107, -0.01965332, 0.027496338, 0.02911377, -0.06347656, -0.02482605, 0.035461426, 0.03074646, 0.022583008, 0.0031414032, -0.013710022, 0.0287323, -0.026885986, -0.0020008087, -0.0028591156, 0.014724731, -0.013908386, -0.009346008, -0.018173218, -0.0124435425, -0.03363037, -0.0023441315, -0.009155273, 0.02027893, 0.03552246, -0.022354126, -0.052459717, -0.045654297, 0.009902954, 0.03942871, -0.0032539368, 0.012702942, -0.04699707, -0.044067383, -0.00881958, 0.010025024, -0.021011353, 0.0020885468, 0.040039062, 0.028640747, -0.010398865, 0.055603027, -0.017349243, 0.036621094, 0.05130005, -0.00042796135, -0.0027713776, -0.023651123, 0.036499023, 0.018478394, 0.03692627, -0.022140503, 0.0044403076, 0.008155823, -0.010925293, 0.01637268, 0.016540527, 0.004398346, -0.0049934387, -0.006801605, -0.02368164, -0.08874512, 0.048553467, 0.07556152, -0.024429321, -0.07531738, 0.000233531, 0.012428284, 0.028839111, -0.020645142, -0.013404846, 0.026245117, -0.07751465, -0.0519104, 0.00065660477, 0.009361267, 0.040527344, -0.025253296, 0.045715332, -0.022445679, -0.017547607, -0.017990112, -0.011878967, 0.037963867, -0.010009766, -0.03213501, -0.028701782, -0.019302368, 0.0010461807, 0.02166748, -0.034454346, 0.033203125, 0.01637268, 0.0017471313, -0.0017147064, -0.035614014, -0.0022220612, -0.029296875, 0.048675537, 0.013687134, 0.006248474, -0.026779175, 0.09338379, 0.0647583, 0.0034275055, -0.029586792, 0.019454956, 0.039276123, -0.04611206, 0.018051147, 0.04562378, -0.008506775, -0.052947998, 0.010360718, 0.012138367, 0.016906738, 0.013755798, -0.014587402, 0.005420685, 0.013137817, 0.01448822, -0.014083862, -0.00086069107, -0.044891357, -0.015914917, 0.04446411, -0.017196655, -0.02609253, -0.007610321, 0.03768921, 0.009307861, 0.04244995, 0.010810852, 0.034301758, -0.009529114, 0.01537323, -0.01651001, -0.017562866, -0.06335449, -0.037506104, 0.017501831, -0.04498291, -0.00995636, -0.00484848, -0.0043029785, 0.020080566, -0.014518738, 0.055389404, -0.009933472, -0.009819031, 0.0335083, 0.050842285, -0.06964111, -0.053771973, 0.01675415, -0.044128418, -0.03439331, -0.030853271, -0.035888672, -0.042022705, -0.0022144318, -0.000101447105, -0.013893127, -0.020446777, 0.084106445, 0.11065674, 0.021362305, 0.037017822, -0.040771484, -0.04611206, -0.06604004, 0.026382446, 0.0692749, 0.0009889603, 0.011741638, 0.04019165, 0.06738281, -0.019699097, -0.038269043, -0.029449463, 0.008766174, 0.0287323, 0.020385742, 0.032470703, 0.040924072, 0.029251099, 0.059539795, 0.019866943, 0.025634766, -0.006839752, -0.07885742, -0.029846191, -0.001914978, 0.055541992, -0.029006958, -0.0028362274, 0.040100098, -0.0028858185, 0.044891357, -0.0046195984, 0.037963867, -0.007587433, -0.022720337, 0.04916382, 0.01600647, -0.026504517, 0.03894043, -0.033966064, 0.0107040405, 0.01739502, 0.012542725, 0.038146973, 0.01838684, 0.0619812, -0.0052108765, -0.018814087, 0.008323669, -0.033203125, -0.032958984, -0.07232666, -0.030334473, 0.030944824, 0.02482605, -0.045776367, 0.018325806, 0.052581787, 0.020126343, 0.060058594, 0.06500244, -0.06793213, 0.008628845, 0.0076293945, -0.0069351196, -0.022766113, -0.013397217, -0.041503906, 0.03302002, -0.0047836304, -0.015319824, 0.0013856888, 0.008377075, -0.011878967, -0.006187439, -0.0184021, 0.03704834, -0.07513428, -0.07232666, -0.02330017, 0.0006084442, -0.026687622, 0.043884277, -0.0020980835, -0.014213562, 0.031402588, -0.032287598, 0.026641846, 0.0014247894, -0.027999878, 0.0102005005, -0.008285522, 0.029327393, -0.009590149, 0.0044784546, 0.020248413, -0.00868988, -0.035491943, 0.023712158, -0.013847351, -0.010696411, -0.04437256, 0.0074043274, 0.011978149, -0.0065956116, 0.026260376, 0.028152466, -0.017990112, -0.0039138794, -0.02104187, 0.022598267, -0.0680542, 0.008651733, 0.0041122437, 0.033966064, -0.07922363, 0.026031494, -0.09906006, 0.019836426, 0.010978699, -0.024276733, -0.0038166046, -0.033233643, 0.017471313, -0.0028572083, -0.00642395, -0.015731812, 0.03274536, -0.037628174, -0.04244995, -0.08679199, -0.008155823, -0.029159546, -0.046691895, -0.08905029, 0.016952515, 0.0067481995, 0.030456543, -0.02017212, 0.026809692, 0.006664276, -0.04626465, 0.017868042, -0.024841309, -0.035827637, -0.007801056, -0.010848999, -0.020751953, -0.010917664, -0.013977051, -0.025360107, 0.00023174286, -0.010887146, 0.03137207, 0.023635864, 0.008514404, 0.025924683, -0.034484863, 0.0061302185, -0.016525269, 0.03527832, 0.0024223328, -0.000042021275, 0.026535034, 0.020019531, 0.005710602, -0.026641846, 0.0011816025, 0.008300781, -0.014221191, 0.05368042, -0.007511139, 0.022857666, -0.016540527, 0.050720215, -0.0463562, 0.016159058, -0.04574585, -0.07446289, -0.00617218, -0.037872314, 0.020217896, 0.003648758, -0.013206482, -0.0023517609, 0.013687134, -0.004501343, -0.010276794, -0.017456055, -0.0110321045, -0.01890564, -0.0023937225, 0.057250977, 0.017211914, 0.006198883, 0.03591919, -0.04534912, -0.004306793, 0.009094238, 0.02243042, -0.03302002, 0.012260437, -0.0039482117, 0.0121536255, 0.025222778, 0.0016613007, -0.02468872, -0.012084961, 0.024108887, 0.052947998, 0.02758789, -0.0066070557, 0.012054443, -0.006629944, -0.006816864, 0.011878967, -0.00466156, -0.02583313, 0.017166138, -0.04055786, -0.02645874, -0.024307251, -0.04067993, 0.009529114, 0.01889038, -0.015022278, 0.013244629, 0.08831787, -0.006828308, 0.03842163, 0.01612854, -0.07098389, -0.004142761, 0.012245178, 0.031173706, 0.0015802383, -0.00060653687, 0.0082092285, -0.034179688, 0.015304565, 0.02949524, 0.01234436, -0.04953003, -0.005168915, 0.008781433, -0.028747559, -0.00022757053, -0.016281128, -0.015808105, -0.031204224, 0.031982422, -0.010429382, 0.02130127, 0.044952393, 0.033294678, 0.0041999817, -0.013328552, 0.030395508, 0.03387451, -0.018096924, 0.017089844, -0.007411957, 0.035858154, -0.02558899, -0.0043792725, -0.0082092285, 0.023849487, -0.013763428, 0.050720215, -0.042541504, -0.0390625, 0.04043579, 0.010665894, -0.00308609, 0.0054969788, -0.032562256, -0.04498291, -0.047210693, -0.01928711, 0.007007599, 0.016555786, 0.008148193, -0.012214661, 0.0014772415, 0.029312134, -0.017349243, 0.06695557, -0.052886963, 0.02003479, -0.039398193, 0.060546875, 0.03543091, -0.013786316, 0.031402588, 0.023345947, -0.038146973, 0.035064697, -0.0041542053, 0.04916382, 0.053497314, 0.04385376, -0.027618408, 0.008956909, 0.07366943, 0.0015277863, 0.0051231384, -0.018615723, -0.009109497, -0.035980225, 0.023971558, 0.021438599, 0.008636475, 0.03604126, 0.03427124, -0.023452759, 0.036895752, -0.008590698, -0.030838013, 0.022018433, -0.033203125, -0.024841309, -0.023651123, -0.0077934265, 0.015808105, 0.01197052, -0.04598999, 0.041748047, -0.0030708313, -0.061920166, 0.037139893, -0.027374268, -0.009986877, 0.0036067963, -0.0234375, -0.03289795, -0.010635376, 0.0059280396, 0.02684021, -0.024414062, 0.03050232, -0.011856079, 0.020477295, -0.033477783, -0.044067383, 0.017791748, 0.042266846, -0.02192688, 0.01828003, 0.025146484, 0.0008840561, 0.035461426, 0.036865234, 0.017547607, -0.0012302399, 0.0043258667, 0.03543091, 0.0071029663, -0.054016113, 0.005596161, -0.024261475, -0.0042762756, -0.01399231, 0.01676941, -0.03173828, 0.025650024, -0.014976501, -0.06124878, 0.008621216, 0.008644104, -0.0069503784, -0.03378296, -0.014678955, 0.023864746, 0.030212402, -0.013908386, -0.0025291443, 0.036346436, -0.006061554, 0.012825012, 0.01007843, -0.026138306, -0.022079468, -0.029220581, 0.062805176, -0.0069732666, 0.004421234, 0.010299683, 0.025146484, 0.09338379, 0.015235901, -0.041931152, 0.0289917, 0.00018465519, -0.035217285, -0.011726379, -0.037994385, 0.050109863, -0.033447266, -0.0049591064, 0.03100586, -0.018798828, -0.01940918, 0.004940033, 0.04058838, -0.027664185, -0.007167816, 0.018920898, -0.01713562, 0.022720337, 0.04067993, -0.04272461, 0.049926758, -0.0055351257, 0.007385254, 0.009147644, 0.017730713, -0.0022277832, 0.046966553, 0.039093018, 0.02053833, -0.004180908, 0.040985107, 0.031051636, -0.047668457, -0.052001953, -0.062408447, -0.022384644, -0.024124146, -0.022949219, 0.029510498, -0.030776978, 0.0069885254, 0.015991211, -0.026641846, 0.016326904, 0.008758545, -0.032348633, -0.019119263, 0.031677246, 0.03213501, -0.008407593, 0.025146484 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1603.03833v4
From virtual demonstration to real-world manipulation using LSTM and MDN
Rouhollah Rahmatizadeh, Pooya Abolghasemi, Aman Behal, Ladislau Bölöni
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
Robots assisting the disabled or elderly must perform complex manipulation tasks and must adapt to the home environment and preferences of their user. Learning from demonstration is a promising choice, that would allow the non-technical user to teach the robot different tasks. However, collecting demonstrations in the home environment of a disabled user is time consuming, disruptive to the comfort of the user, and presents safety challenges. It would be desirable to perform the demonstrations in a virtual environment. In this paper we describe a solution to the challenging problem of behavior transfer from virtual demonstration to a physical robot. The virtual demonstrations are used to train a deep neural network based controller, which is using a Long Short Term Memory (LSTM) recurrent neural network to generate trajectories. The training process uses a Mixture Density Network (MDN) to calculate an error signal suitable for the multimodal nature of demonstrations. The controller learned in the virtual environment is transferred to a physical robot (a Rethink Robotics Baxter). An off-the-shelf vision component is used to substitute for geometric knowledge available in the simulation and an inverse kinematics module is used to allow the Baxter to enact the trajectory. Our experimental studies validate the three contributions of the paper: (1) the controller learned from virtual demonstrations can be used to successfully perform the manipulation tasks on a physical robot, (2) the LSTM+MDN architectural choice outperforms other choices, such as the use of feedforward networks and mean-squared error based training signals and (3) allowing imperfect demonstrations in the training set also allows the controller to learn how to correct its manipulation mistakes.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.03833v4
2017-11-22T02:44:36
2016-03-12T00:47:38
{ "title": [ 0.014266968, 0.009399414, -0.04284668, -0.057495117, 0.006164551, -0.02748108, -0.030090332, -0.014785767, -0.0368042, 0.035827637, 0.007408142, -0.014663696, 0.026992798, -0.0440979, -0.004573822, 0.0017414093, 0.003124237, 0.010910034, -0.020996094, -0.04220581, -0.021316528, -0.040100098, 0.045562744, 0.047180176, 0.028152466, -0.042663574, -0.079711914, 0.018203735, -0.044006348, -0.037994385, 0.0032691956, 0.045288086, 0.042114258, 0.005039215, 0.0072898865, -0.015083313, -0.030410767, 0.0102005005, -0.013313293, 0.017608643, 0.0040512085, 0.016204834, -0.070495605, -0.040893555, -0.07977295, 0.011451721, -0.07342529, -0.0053138733, -0.014190674, 0.051086426, 0.013954163, 0.006336212, -0.027252197, 0.03274536, 0.013114929, -0.012580872, -0.056671143, 0.002840042, 0.029815674, 0.10003662, 0.031097412, -0.05102539, -0.004589081, -0.061035156, -0.027694702, -0.030532837, -0.02331543, 0.043518066, 0.055908203, 0.004840851, -0.015159607, 0.016357422, -0.011077881, 0.0047683716, -0.047210693, -0.005207062, 0.06549072, 0.03515625, 0.0071105957, -0.0070877075, 0.01512146, 0.022262573, -0.017730713, -0.034973145, 0.016143799, -0.04067993, -0.011604309, -0.016784668, -0.018188477, -0.04537964, -0.0070724487, -0.000351429, 0.009269714, 0.01802063, -0.03036499, -0.027648926, -0.02116394, -0.01977539, 0.0022945404, -0.004322052, 0.018447876, -0.015686035, 0.015083313, -0.0057296753, 0.017211914, -0.0022659302, -0.003118515, -0.033813477, 0.017837524, 0.024627686, -0.033599854, 0.044006348, 0.006542206, -0.013809204, 0.02557373, 0.021057129, -0.005554199, 0.026016235, 0.008964539, 0.019226074, -0.029968262, -0.031433105, 0.020721436, 0.008682251, 0.028457642, 0.017593384, -0.03302002, -0.000099122524, -0.0057296753, 0.03555298, -0.03552246, 0.043518066, -0.039794922, -0.08343506, -0.042053223, 0.022003174, -0.00053310394, -0.0021839142, 0.012786865, -0.019546509, -0.0052490234, -0.013679504, 0.01737976, -0.019805908, 0.018081665, 0.04260254, 0.05581665, -0.02355957, -0.03326416, -0.048461914, -0.0017414093, -0.011512756, -0.000003874302, 0.005077362, 0.004722595, 0.015319824, -0.11199951, 0.010177612, 0.025848389, 0.045715332, 0.02986145, 0.03112793, -0.004676819, -0.008995056, 0.04135132, -0.06384277, -0.028961182, 0.01953125, 0.005970001, 0.039123535, -0.022506714, 0.00033950806, -0.006160736, -0.014884949, -0.008506775, 0.004966736, 0.033050537, 0.005962372, 0.03970337, -0.0023403168, 0.010063171, -0.0126953125, 0.035247803, 0.03704834, -0.051452637, -0.018081665, -0.016601562, -0.02619934, 0.075683594, 0.0061950684, -0.05227661, 0.025543213, -0.010513306, -0.048736572, -0.03942871, -0.013618469, 0.035186768, 0.047729492, -0.007858276, -0.003129959, -0.05429077, -0.002363205, 0.008422852, 0.0053367615, 0.040496826, -0.0022277832, -0.00056648254, 0.027633667, -0.024871826, 0.038208008, 0.049591064, -0.00592041, -0.03225708, 0.011383057, -0.03036499, -0.08294678, 0.052703857, 0.0045051575, -0.0023403168, -0.016113281, -0.01436615, -0.03463745, -0.0051002502, 0.0670166, -0.0027122498, 0.035186768, -0.015975952, -0.011505127, 0.028762817, 0.041900635, 0.055511475, -0.04751587, 0.00642395, 0.0025539398, -0.01713562, -0.021148682, -0.034484863, -0.032836914, 0.011428833, 0.0335083, -0.0019302368, -0.009223938, -0.013320923, 0.041412354, 0.034820557, -0.005001068, -0.0054473877, 0.014556885, 0.043060303, 0.0154418945, 0.06488037, 0.0234375, 0.055419922, 0.031921387, 0.033966064, 0.054626465, 0.02079773, 0.018554688, -0.017486572, 0.016937256, -0.009803772, -0.011695862, 0.0032367706, 0.0004580021, -0.039642334, 0.0013341904, -0.02619934, -0.0013608932, 0.0066108704, 0.023803711, 0.036468506, -0.051116943, 0.018127441, -0.014503479, -0.036743164, -0.017837524, -0.031311035, 0.032836914, 0.035247803, -0.06311035, -0.021347046, -0.005039215, 0.04598999, 0.007610321, 0.0390625, -0.0018177032, 0.022842407, -0.021697998, 0.01247406, 0.010284424, 0.051727295, 0.022903442, 0.0027828217, 0.006855011, 0.01209259, -0.011871338, 0.064208984, 0.0690918, -0.030685425, 0.017181396, -0.043029785, 0.004261017, -0.0053634644, -0.015930176, 0.0152282715, 0.016647339, -0.0018310547, 0.018981934, -0.014984131, 0.029693604, -0.055603027, 0.0569458, -0.012512207, -0.029037476, -0.061920166, -0.059295654, -0.028167725, -0.05154419, -0.07385254, -0.025924683, 0.07836914, -0.02659607, -0.01574707, -0.009254456, -0.0032577515, -0.04147339, -0.0024642944, -0.03503418, -0.0031700134, 0.009895325, 0.057739258, 0.06707764, -0.030273438, 0.0005979538, 0.006587982, -0.0025863647, -0.005580902, 0.0061683655, -0.008918762, -0.0015306473, 0.015426636, 0.018661499, 0.0074691772, -0.037994385, 0.010925293, -0.01512146, 0.007221222, 0.025131226, -0.024551392, 0.0067596436, 0.012825012, -0.053771973, -0.024871826, 0.022994995, 0.043823242, -0.016403198, -0.0051231384, 0.043121338, 0.031280518, -0.012069702, 0.040924072, 0.02017212, 0.020309448, -0.035003662, -0.030563354, -0.06365967, -0.000916481, -0.013183594, 0.008506775, 0.06451416, -0.06744385, 0.040496826, -0.054748535, -0.027999878, -0.016708374, 0.0345459, -0.0048561096, -0.033691406, -0.04296875, -0.013252258, -0.003419876, 0.003982544, -0.027008057, 0.013038635, 0.10058594, 0.003288269, 0.0032291412, -0.010864258, 0.08807373, 0.01474762, -0.0010404587, -0.06604004, -0.01789856, 0.012832642, 0.008979797, -0.0050315857, 0.0039901733, -0.0027198792, -0.12042236, -0.014060974, -0.016159058, 0.01259613, -0.019119263, -0.00021409988, -0.047607422, 0.005466461, -0.025146484, -0.037200928, 0.024246216, 0.08679199, -0.017181396, -0.021133423, 0.013824463, -0.030151367, 0.035614014, -0.0074691772, -0.08276367, 0.013809204, -0.009849548, -0.021743774, -0.012512207, -0.028274536, -0.041168213, -0.009346008, 0.036376953, 0.010948181, 0.05734253, -0.015686035, 0.0082473755, 0.004184723, 0.016586304, -0.024765015, -0.029312134, -0.027923584, -0.04949951, -0.01739502, 0.0018253326, 0.04119873, 0.04559326, -0.010612488, -0.03137207, 0.0029029846, -0.012329102, 0.003540039, 0.01776123, -0.044067383, 0.018936157, -0.0035057068, -0.01789856, -0.0060157776, -0.030960083, 0.005809784, -0.008361816, 0.015388489, -0.016784668, 0.027709961, 0.020309448, 0.013214111, 0.029312134, -0.015686035, 0.013755798, -0.023513794, -0.05657959, 0.028839111, 0.022521973, 0.01940918, 0.020889282, -0.016662598, -0.0020580292, 0.01878357, -0.025970459, -0.004562378, 0.005584717, 0.0071792603, -0.008720398, 0.02041626, -0.017181396, -0.005428314, -0.010124207, 0.041870117, -0.0023059845, 0.0025863647, -0.04095459, -0.07330322, -0.0001283884, -0.003824234, -0.101745605, -0.03326416, 0.01386261, -0.022033691, -0.074035645, -0.052764893, 0.006122589, -0.03012085, -0.038391113, 0.030349731, -0.017440796, -0.003753662, 0.002023697, -0.053466797, -0.05859375, 0.06008911, 0.053985596, -0.007850647, 0.06298828, -0.018478394, -0.05340576, -0.020370483, 0.017425537, 0.021072388, 0.01638794, 0.009857178, -0.0014448166, 0.04284668, -0.03778076, 0.022232056, 0.0259552, 0.050842285, -0.018081665, -0.007926941, 0.018127441, 0.033935547, -0.012489319, 0.037139893, 0.009719849, 0.02418518, -0.10046387, 0.024978638, -0.012580872, -0.030288696, 0.036621094, 0.013504028, 0.032806396, 0.028823853, -0.024505615, 0.043548584, -0.027801514, 0.0016441345, 0.030639648, -0.016281128, -0.029968262, 0.032928467, 0.039245605, 0.017288208, -0.00066185, 0.020050049, 0.008201599, 0.046051025, -0.048919678, -0.011192322, 0.0012817383, 0.012428284, -0.051239014, -0.015602112, -0.061065674, -0.0703125, -0.019439697, 0.006549835, -0.009918213, 0.007713318, 0.037078857, -0.026931763, -0.030807495, 0.0043411255, -0.006210327, 0.0022392273, -0.013374329, -0.05029297, -0.0052108765, -0.013244629, -0.05105591, -0.022583008, 0.013870239, 0.0016040802, 0.013381958, -0.010894775, 0.007408142, 0.0052948, 0.05230713, 0.08520508, 0.049804688, -0.005355835, -0.06970215, 0.03225708, -0.010467529, -0.0041885376, 0.003162384, -0.032989502, -0.003376007, -0.0032997131, 0.017608643, -0.011444092, -0.0078048706, 0.0028381348, 0.0051116943, 0.0143966675, 0.035339355, -0.04660034, 0.018569946, 0.0141067505, -0.011360168, 0.010803223, -0.0028324127, -0.03793335, 0.0116119385, 0.0093688965, 0.035736084, 0.000995636, 0.0019893646, 0.025360107, 0.013389587, -0.0096206665, 0.017181396, 0.02458191, 0.013999939, -0.0040740967, 0.015296936, -0.0003592968, -0.035125732, -0.021743774, 0.020523071, -0.0057640076, 0.06161499, -0.0043182373, 0.06439209, -0.002527237, -0.00497818, 0.029434204, -0.027526855, -0.0076828003, 0.004840851, 0.012481689, -0.062805176, -0.052856445, -0.023971558, 0.068359375, -0.04449463, -0.0034828186, -0.03036499, -0.047088623, 0.00091791153, 0.060516357, 0.03793335, -0.037231445, 0.01586914, -0.03475952, -0.034851074, -0.019165039, -0.06414795, 0.00036120415, 0.00017809868, 0.00074386597, -0.04043579, -0.011116028, -0.058013916, -0.042663574, -0.007926941, -0.007820129, 0.015037537, -0.041870117, 0.045837402, 0.101135254, -0.015731812, 0.062164307, 0.009475708, 0.01864624, 0.008934021, 0.02420044, 0.007160187, 0.017288208, 0.006664276, -0.007797241, 0.016540527, 0.006793976, 0.0009698868, -0.009933472, 8.34465e-7, -0.0030975342, -0.013511658, -0.015853882, 0.03640747, -0.009880066, -0.037322998, 0.030349731, -0.04324341, 0.020599365, -0.01512146, -0.021240234, -0.009559631, -0.048034668, -0.03213501, -0.00057697296, -0.05041504, -0.051208496, 0.048858643, -0.037078857, -0.03933716, -0.07458496, 0.029418945, -0.0075798035, 0.01940918, -0.027389526, 0.0022697449, -0.060058594, -0.0043296814, -0.0041999817, -0.0137786865, 0.0079574585, 0.0010509491, 0.014167786, 0.018920898, 0.0052108765, -0.03967285, 0.0014324188, -0.0039711, -0.049468994, -0.015914917, 0.008666992, 0.01525116, 0.0020618439, 0.0013284683, -0.030334473, -0.009338379, 0.0007863045, 0.010818481, 0.0014095306, -0.035217285, 0.04019165, -0.007671356, -0.027175903, 0.0053634644, 0.0051727295, -0.037841797, 0.011192322, 0.01033783, -0.0074043274, 0.012283325, 0.0016622543, 0.007129669, 0.02394104, -0.04800415, 0.021011353, 0.02709961, 0.0002937317, -0.003200531, 0.026504517, 0.019851685, 0.017791748, -0.012039185, 0.009567261, 0.052337646, -0.030136108, -0.0062408447, -0.0058059692, -0.012199402, -0.053833008, 0.05731201, 0.006816864, -0.0037517548, -0.03665161, -0.048187256, -0.018493652, 0.017028809, 0.03817749, 0.018920898, 0.039276123, -0.043518066, 0.012634277, -0.023040771, -0.00017035007, -0.014144897, 0.011550903, -0.001616478, -0.0064582825, 0.011810303, 0.0054740906, -0.013313293, 0.003622055, 0.03326416, 0.01235199, -0.008605957, 0.014160156, -0.020736694, 0.00089120865, -0.024536133, 0.021713257, 0.05621338, -0.0118637085, 0.0015163422, 0.037322998, -0.034362793, 0.048339844, 0.02116394, 0.07141113, 0.0418396, -0.009315491, 0.015289307, 0.023620605, 0.00554657, -0.04928589, 0.022079468, -0.044677734, -0.021148682, -0.05432129, -0.03491211, -0.053833008, -0.00894165, 0.0049819946, -0.019134521, 0.021255493, -0.0043411255, 0.018997192, 0.040924072, 0.03692627, 0.0152282715, 0.032043457, -0.002298355, 0.01159668, -0.026504517, 0.008842468, 0.002494812, 0.031021118, 0.021224976, 0.011604309, -0.044555664, -0.0013160706, -0.009010315, 0.030792236, -0.019989014, -0.0067329407, 0.019577026, -0.027542114, 0.034362793, -0.010566711, 0.016540527, 0.06707764, 0.041229248, -0.02482605, -0.011207581, 0.016448975, -0.009361267, -0.016326904, 0.0023937225, 0.051452637, -0.0770874, 0.03186035, -0.010063171, -0.040985107, 0.012359619, 0.035003662, 0.020767212, -0.034606934, -0.029434204, -0.007972717, 0.02973938, 0.02999878, -0.007820129, -0.044708252, -0.02558899, 0.03149414, 0.043548584, -0.02848816, 0.03262329, 0.060577393, 0.0018205643, -0.013954163, -0.0040130615, -0.009651184, 0.045806885, -0.02835083, 0.02671814, -0.012458801, 0.047851562, 0.004901886, -0.039764404, 0.022506714, 0.020324707, -0.07281494, 0.011459351, 0.02381897, 0.042510986, 0.027404785, 0.06451416, 0.032165527, -0.012840271, -0.029373169, -0.03933716, 0.006259918, 0.03540039, -0.039611816, 0.007106781, -0.013832092, -0.037750244, 0.02659607, -0.033996582, 0.039154053, -0.037963867, 0.0005836487, -0.014152527, -0.016937256, 0.03262329, -0.022735596, -0.021057129, -0.02482605, -0.01586914, 0.011131287, 0.015136719, -0.037872314, -0.01890564, 0.026977539, 0.023376465, 0.040527344, 0.013900757, -0.0072517395, -0.033294678, -0.053009033, 0.054656982, -0.0062713623, 0.08135986, 0.0023460388, -0.02406311, -0.045043945, 0.03930664, 0.018722534, -0.032684326, -0.023925781, 0.0418396, -0.017791748, -0.029541016, -0.004650116, 0.0024719238, -0.015312195, -0.0039978027, -0.064819336, 0.02645874, -0.029418945, -0.0065231323, 0.02885437, -0.04748535, 0.012428284, 0.008956909, -0.02420044, 0.055541992, 0.023162842, -0.01928711, 0.024902344, 0.011398315, -0.032165527, 0.011779785, -0.0109939575, 0.016418457, -0.012252808, -0.029434204, -0.01890564, 0.0335083, 0.0154800415, -0.064697266, -0.050476074, 0.004032135, 0.040496826, 0.01184082, 0.06390381, -0.011184692, 0.007118225, 0.020629883, 0.04220581, 0.004142761, -0.042663574, -0.011856079, -0.032592773, 0.04812622, 0.02885437, -0.018798828, -0.003528595, 0.025680542, -0.008049011, -0.010894775, 0.010887146, 0.03503418, 0.013015747, 0.01689148, 0.06793213, -0.01902771, -0.018829346, 0.012336731, 0.058654785, -0.03475952, 0.0043144226, -0.001906395, 0.005970001, -0.0107803345, 0.01826477, -0.016647339, -0.048980713, 0.06323242, 0.04244995, 0.023590088, 0.034423828, 0.005290985, -0.031158447, -0.007980347, 0.001291275, -0.011070251, 0.017211914, 0.03643799, -0.014183044, 0.01360321, -0.058166504, -0.022918701, -0.013061523, -0.03302002, 0.04586792, -0.008903503, -0.016830444, -0.013031006, -0.014503479, -0.010635376, -0.00044178963, 0.0012903214, -0.02154541, -0.03125, 0.0020961761, 0.0126571655, -0.014152527 ], "summary": [ 0.07043457, 0.007183075, 0.0082092285, -0.040008545, 0.006690979, -0.040496826, -0.0025520325, -0.027053833, -0.016113281, 0.0044403076, -0.025054932, -0.00605011, 0.021514893, -0.045043945, 0.05215454, -0.034576416, 0.0017995834, 0.041381836, 0.04232788, -0.016815186, 0.0011997223, -0.004940033, 0.055023193, 0.0124435425, 0.035583496, -0.040771484, -0.08984375, 0.005859375, -0.00008785725, -0.00042247772, 0.009559631, 0.014961243, 0.03289795, -0.028427124, 0.007843018, -0.034606934, 0.01663208, -0.024383545, -0.0368042, 0.039093018, 0.019058228, -0.008644104, -0.008003235, -0.068115234, -0.041015625, 0.044555664, -0.036712646, 0.00579834, -0.014801025, 0.032287598, 0.016784668, -0.0061531067, -0.001616478, 0.00907135, 0.003118515, 0.02458191, -0.044158936, -0.038391113, 0.045440674, 0.07067871, 0.013374329, -0.040222168, -0.015388489, -0.06921387, -0.0013437271, -0.0067634583, -0.019088745, 0.023132324, 0.03515625, -0.0030899048, -0.01109314, -0.013961792, -0.0030670166, 0.011047363, -0.021759033, -0.01146698, 0.052886963, 0.02671814, -0.027572632, 0.011985779, -0.010276794, 0.017303467, 0.042877197, -0.04840088, -0.012786865, -0.053985596, -0.015716553, 0.015365601, -0.027999878, -0.0066490173, -0.014846802, 0.00680542, -0.061035156, 0.027496338, 0.0064201355, -0.028457642, -0.034942627, -0.07006836, 0.014228821, 0.019760132, 0.083740234, -0.06378174, 0.09436035, -0.025527954, 0.004924774, -0.022232056, 0.0025939941, -0.06549072, 0.000009000301, 0.017044067, -0.060760498, 0.053375244, -0.018066406, -0.0395813, -0.011962891, 0.03982544, -0.009529114, 0.004688263, -0.0038795471, -0.012123108, -0.012573242, 0.031799316, -0.006752014, 0.029434204, -0.00466156, 0.01727295, 0.022445679, -0.046447754, 0.032440186, -0.040924072, -0.06286621, 0.030334473, 0.089904785, 0.01612854, 0.017501831, -0.0010662079, -0.0008277893, 0.0049095154, 0.033233643, -0.033294678, 0.013374329, -0.013801575, 0.01134491, 0.018035889, 0.00057554245, 0.07098389, 0.036010742, -0.016464233, -0.03366089, -0.10308838, 0.03479004, -0.0137786865, -0.02218628, -0.0048942566, 0.06713867, -0.033203125, -0.027511597, -0.009140015, 0.07281494, 0.03363037, 0.033325195, 0.05899048, 0.02029419, -0.021026611, -0.012428284, -0.09991455, -0.01751709, 0.0062446594, 0.0129852295, 0.0914917, 0.0022563934, -0.00069618225, -0.028717041, -0.013702393, -0.015731812, -0.03050232, -0.019714355, 0.030395508, 0.02407837, -0.048461914, -0.026901245, -0.02545166, 0.0335083, 0.004760742, 0.005657196, -0.026672363, -0.023635864, -0.0284729, 0.042816162, 0.0059127808, -0.04031372, 0.020339966, 0.0026187897, -0.019638062, -0.015571594, 0.0054359436, -0.026809692, 0.016479492, -0.018463135, -0.011619568, 0.0079422, -0.024658203, 0.029754639, -0.01828003, -0.03677368, 0.002714157, -0.012123108, 0.005168915, -0.06347656, 0.01121521, 0.04623413, -0.018173218, -0.028137207, 0.04095459, 0.018920898, -0.039733887, 0.016921997, -0.007648468, -0.005760193, -0.02822876, -0.0015926361, -0.015686035, -0.031921387, 0.037261963, -0.0046958923, -0.00025081635, -0.031051636, 0.006401062, 0.021652222, -0.0023269653, 0.044006348, -0.008361816, -0.03302002, -0.022033691, -0.020111084, -0.012962341, 0.009864807, -0.0625, 0.052124023, 0.036987305, 0.009262085, -0.011993408, 0.00084495544, 0.07196045, -0.030548096, -0.038024902, -0.0030708313, 0.026412964, -0.05795288, -0.0115356445, 0.02645874, 0.036865234, 0.016479492, 0.013916016, -0.018478394, 0.03338623, 0.015792847, -0.014717102, -0.020462036, -0.011108398, 0.025009155, -0.08093262, -0.068237305, -0.0129470825, -0.01626587, -0.03829956, -0.003774643, -0.017837524, 0.02355957, -0.033966064, 0.0104904175, -0.06341553, -0.012161255, -0.03741455, -0.011054993, -0.028015137, -0.054473877, 0.04849243, 0.05606079, -0.024520874, 0.0066337585, -0.0050735474, 0.040802002, -0.0013113022, 0.028198242, 0.0071144104, 0.030654907, 0.0054130554, 0.035858154, 0.061828613, 0.06781006, -0.014152527, -0.012420654, 0.0059051514, 0.021453857, -0.03616333, -0.0032176971, 0.048858643, -0.015991211, -0.0088272095, -0.00881958, 0.024810791, -0.020324707, -0.00072813034, 0.027755737, -0.03378296, 0.01739502, 0.020217896, 0.0043029785, 0.0129776, -0.04586792, 0.04171753, 0.018310547, 0.07476807, -0.034942627, -0.044677734, -0.018829346, 0.043121338, -0.0141067505, 0.016448975, 0.026977539, -0.024291992, 0.010871887, 0.048065186, -0.0067481995, -0.04043579, 0.08074951, 0.0043563843, 0.048797607, 0.024429321, 0.035308838, 0.06732178, -0.005680084, -0.0062828064, 0.0036354065, -0.0127334595, 0.012176514, 0.010810852, 0.016479492, -0.004749298, 0.050354004, 0.037231445, -0.005558014, 0.012466431, -0.012893677, -0.015075684, -0.007217407, 0.005382538, -0.008384705, -0.0051498413, 0.0030612946, -0.03024292, -0.02508545, 0.04574585, 0.009765625, -0.05117798, 0.012329102, 0.047058105, -0.027770996, -0.008094788, 0.022613525, 0.015602112, -0.00005543232, -0.06100464, -0.009292603, -0.047576904, 0.0009841919, -0.036102295, 0.030700684, 0.059417725, -0.032104492, 0.08569336, -0.05807495, -0.024383545, -0.02067566, 0.01687622, 0.051757812, -0.019683838, -0.00843811, 0.03439331, 0.011802673, -0.00093460083, -0.01121521, 0.00522995, 0.04095459, 0.012832642, 0.011329651, 0.01374054, 0.055267334, 0.003107071, 0.0026302338, -0.017242432, -0.012931824, 0.00018787384, -0.00932312, -0.020965576, 0.01374054, 0.021575928, -0.06585693, -0.032196045, 0.0066108704, 0.018859863, -0.017501831, 0.0012521744, 0.010650635, -0.0066108704, 0.03189087, -0.027923584, 0.015167236, 0.04196167, 0.013053894, -0.04650879, 0.0491333, -0.04385376, 0.030303955, 0.00043296814, 0.011703491, 0.005001068, -0.033416748, -0.00093507767, 0.020217896, 0.02911377, -0.010055542, -0.013328552, 0.03845215, -0.0062026978, 0.023590088, -0.008575439, -0.009239197, -0.0041770935, 0.008544922, -0.03463745, 0.00541687, 0.0059013367, -0.077697754, 0.0065612793, 0.005466461, 0.040985107, 0.05508423, -0.05331421, -0.011184692, -0.00086021423, 0.0021247864, 0.010047913, 0.032684326, -0.038513184, -0.001748085, -0.023956299, -0.03945923, -0.006439209, -0.030883789, 0.013687134, -0.022781372, 0.034240723, 0.003145218, 0.09136963, -0.0058898926, 0.029373169, 0.09283447, -0.06719971, -0.02923584, -0.02128601, -0.05480957, 0.03463745, 0.005443573, -0.0055618286, 0.00034284592, 0.0010690689, -0.02796936, 0.019622803, -0.0052833557, 0.014823914, -0.00894165, -0.025360107, 0.0052604675, -0.025436401, 0.0118637085, -0.016647339, 0.042663574, -0.013412476, -0.029205322, 0.01096344, -0.075805664, -0.028366089, -0.018936157, 0.0064086914, -0.056640625, -0.0051994324, 0.0027980804, 0.008140564, -0.023223877, -0.02909851, 0.021026611, -0.028945923, -0.03375244, 0.028259277, -0.008430481, 0.009651184, -0.023330688, -0.037902832, -0.037109375, -0.022827148, 0.0625, 0.027236938, 0.009994507, -0.01007843, -0.01965332, 0.014984131, 0.036834717, -0.0017318726, 0.0056610107, 0.0073890686, 0.056854248, 0.022659302, -0.005420685, -0.009399414, 0.03060913, 0.07165527, -0.03942871, -0.029830933, 0.042785645, 0.04925537, -0.037353516, 0.0014762878, 0.037628174, 0.01247406, -0.06738281, 0.03173828, -0.03427124, -0.020965576, 0.05343628, 0.027709961, 0.0052871704, -0.010314941, 0.0026454926, 0.02545166, -0.015319824, -0.01651001, 0.012054443, 0.014190674, -0.042175293, -0.029312134, 0.019943237, 0.043792725, 0.008178711, -0.034301758, -0.009010315, 0.0036716461, -0.03277588, -0.01991272, 0.005241394, 0.01537323, -0.026290894, -0.030136108, -0.019897461, 0.005279541, 0.010063171, 0.0014486313, -0.01777649, -0.011184692, -0.0063171387, -0.00207901, 0.0019607544, 0.0018196106, 0.028060913, 0.024337769, -0.03253174, -0.055511475, -0.030853271, 0.011352539, -0.053741455, -0.01373291, -0.052978516, -0.0345459, -0.020385742, 0.0026550293, -0.02532959, 0.0063056946, 0.036193848, 0.09790039, 0.041992188, 0.0066490173, -0.080566406, -0.01965332, -0.023406982, 0.01272583, -0.0000046491623, -0.008712769, -0.015533447, 0.006980896, 0.02319336, -0.018218994, -0.009819031, -0.0035591125, -0.015068054, -0.029220581, 0.039093018, 0.0026664734, 0.06124878, 0.0018968582, -0.042907715, 0.0062408447, -0.015731812, -0.025878906, 0.060058594, 0.03729248, 0.03829956, -0.047210693, 0.0053520203, 0.009521484, 0.021713257, 0.027389526, -0.025115967, 0.0118637085, -0.013839722, -0.052764893, 0.0020694733, -0.020065308, 0.025466919, 0.014480591, 0.037017822, -0.003610611, 0.019470215, 0.05130005, 0.039916992, 0.0056533813, -0.049682617, 0.022094727, 0.0052108765, -0.005176544, 0.01979065, -0.018218994, -0.07513428, -0.080566406, -0.045532227, 0.09906006, -0.025939941, -0.021270752, -0.0206604, -0.038970947, 0.035888672, 0.03479004, 0.02758789, -0.049957275, 0.012245178, -0.006439209, -0.012916565, -0.0018844604, -0.02418518, -0.01499939, -0.04168701, -0.0028533936, -0.016540527, -0.0045547485, 0.009841919, -0.002494812, -0.014137268, -0.0042915344, 0.03024292, -0.02746582, -0.048217773, 0.031173706, -0.017700195, 0.0014944077, 0.05429077, 0.010612488, -0.011581421, 0.011940002, 0.0030517578, 0.008522034, -0.01512146, -0.047821045, 0.0970459, -0.008987427, -0.0037345886, 0.03173828, -0.003271103, -0.0099105835, 0.027450562, -0.0031147003, 0.0014753342, -0.016921997, -0.006816864, -0.0006432533, -0.017959595, 0.017044067, -0.0024852753, 0.023376465, -0.01776123, -0.0104522705, -0.021636963, -0.0010499954, -0.0287323, -0.03378296, -0.009498596, -0.06451416, 0.00042796135, -0.05984497, -0.046325684, -0.025100708, 0.036346436, -0.020095825, 0.028823853, -0.016052246, 0.0033092499, -0.002784729, -0.010734558, 0.021148682, 0.061462402, 0.019042969, 0.029022217, -0.0042800903, -0.030456543, 0.0035266876, 0.005592346, 0.00038051605, -0.02305603, -0.0079956055, -0.018707275, 0.019470215, -0.032928467, -0.02053833, -0.021194458, -0.030410767, -0.008712769, -0.0037574768, -0.041503906, -0.0082092285, -0.03479004, -0.0770874, 0.020812988, -0.05984497, -0.023880005, 0.007221222, -0.029708862, 0.02558899, 0.019729614, 0.01020813, 0.0039863586, 0.046173096, 0.023452759, -0.00592041, 0.039215088, 0.0075263977, 0.0095825195, 0.042175293, 0.017410278, 0.029312134, 0.018798828, 0.015281677, 0.029907227, 0.015838623, 0.018844604, -0.021392822, 0.016815186, -0.032470703, 0.019683838, -0.022125244, 0.0037078857, -0.02973938, -0.01676941, 0.0049324036, 0.009529114, 0.04360962, -0.018936157, 0.0541687, -0.046203613, -0.018112183, 0.0042419434, -0.0070343018, -0.016036987, -0.008354187, -0.011482239, -0.014846802, 0.04034424, 0.026550293, -0.006137848, -0.0058555603, 0.014892578, -0.0011453629, -0.004547119, 0.020263672, 0.017669678, 0.00016093254, 0.0012931824, 0.013595581, 0.016967773, -0.0051498413, 0.026367188, 0.009407043, -0.019012451, 0.015106201, 0.0048332214, 0.02192688, -0.021942139, -0.022842407, 0.024902344, 0.01651001, -0.0004529953, -0.03277588, 0.046691895, -0.033325195, -0.041931152, -0.05215454, -0.064086914, -0.01574707, -0.02885437, -0.0047569275, -0.045898438, 0.061767578, -0.009666443, -0.0019168854, 0.054992676, -0.026412964, 0.056610107, -0.032928467, 0.0036525726, -0.008460999, -0.013900757, 0.014663696, -0.002544403, 0.027938843, 0.013320923, 0.0357666, -0.014656067, -0.0010499954, 0.026550293, -0.0037250519, -0.022201538, -0.050842285, 0.020507812, -0.04360962, -0.0011920929, -0.020904541, 0.0015544891, 0.049468994, 0.017929077, 0.034820557, -0.027236938, 0.02986145, -0.051208496, 0.016647339, -0.025482178, -0.006526947, -0.04006958, 0.03753662, 0.009971619, -0.018707275, 0.008300781, 0.089416504, -0.012565613, 0.0032615662, 0.05630493, -0.0158844, -0.021713257, 0.02748108, 0.027542114, -0.029266357, -0.05230713, -0.022384644, -0.00090646744, 0.0042648315, 0.033416748, 0.036895752, -0.0031814575, 0.045196533, 0.032104492, -0.031707764, 0.07989502, -0.029846191, 0.02204895, -0.011360168, 0.01725769, 0.0184021, -0.0047073364, 0.04348755, 0.013122559, 0.012191772, 0.036071777, 0.009300232, 0.034210205, 0.0070648193, 0.032440186, -0.010940552, -0.0063552856, 0.003709793, 0.011016846, -0.018005371, -0.003736496, -0.008857727, -0.039245605, -0.00944519, 0.0099487305, -0.010025024, 0.015419006, 0.018295288, -0.048706055, 0.019165039, -0.015258789, -0.035705566, 0.0073165894, -0.006996155, 0.00554657, -0.038146973, -0.0036792755, 0.025161743, 0.063964844, -0.030838013, 0.08319092, 0.0055122375, -0.10058594, 0.05166626, 0.025772095, 0.01828003, -0.035217285, 0.010253906, 0.018936157, 0.041992188, 0.05117798, 0.044403076, -0.05645752, -0.030578613, 0.025848389, 0.057281494, 0.0075263977, -0.03475952, 0.062805176, 0.004081726, -0.029129028, -0.011398315, -0.020751953, -0.020629883, 0.064697266, -0.09588623, 0.06530762, -0.026870728, 0.023254395, 0.0256958, -0.018234253, -0.0104522705, 0.024597168, -0.052124023, 0.026489258, -0.021270752, -0.0030078888, 0.035308838, 0.021194458, -0.009399414, 0.03765869, 0.013183594, 0.014923096, 0.006576538, -0.010406494, -0.015716553, 0.0052452087, 0.00042009354, -0.042236328, -0.016220093, 0.009246826, 0.017288208, 0.0014505386, -0.00030517578, -0.031311035, -0.017791748, 0.02670288, 0.05001831, 0.0019359589, -0.01927185, -0.009773254, 0.011306763, 0.035064697, 0.007461548, -0.016983032, 0.007156372, 0.01966858, -0.0413208, -0.017532349, -0.039489746, 0.036254883, -0.024871826, 0.0030612946, 0.040527344, -0.014419556, -0.011116028, -0.032958984, 0.01689148, -0.008865356, 0.0036830902, -0.013511658, 0.019805908, -0.012458801, 0.03201294, 0.0055274963, -0.0071029663, 0.010231018, 0.009468079, 0.033233643, -0.030654907, 0.004501343, -0.0075187683, 0.0135269165, 0.0057296753, 0.008018494, 0.026885986, 0.008110046, -0.04168701, -0.003276825, -0.10284424, -0.010856628, -0.020523071, -0.026687622, 0.020141602, -0.0043411255, -0.008796692, 0.055145264, -0.01574707, 0.019729614, -0.037963867, 0.031555176, 0.0044670105, 0.007904053, -0.008033752, -0.030151367, 0.020629883 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1611.06221v6
Foundations of Structural Causal Models with Cycles and Latent Variables
Stephan Bongers, Patrick Forré, Jonas Peters, Joris M. Mooij
stat.ME, cs.AI, cs.LG, 62A09, 68T30 (Primary) 68T37 (Secondary)
Structural causal models (SCMs), also known as (nonparametric) structural equation models (SEMs), are widely used for causal modeling purposes. In particular, acyclic SCMs, also known as recursive SEMs, form a well-studied subclass of SCMs that generalize causal Bayesian networks to allow for latent confounders. In this paper, we investigate SCMs in a more general setting, allowing for the presence of both latent confounders and cycles. We show that in the presence of cycles, many of the convenient properties of acyclic SCMs do not hold in general: they do not always have a solution; they do not always induce unique observational, interventional and counterfactual distributions; a marginalization does not always exist, and if it exists the marginal model does not always respect the latent projection; they do not always satisfy a Markov property; and their graphs are not always consistent with their causal semantics. We prove that for SCMs in general each of these properties does hold under certain solvability conditions. Our work generalizes results for SCMs with cycles that were only known for certain special cases so far. We introduce the class of simple SCMs that extends the class of acyclic SCMs to the cyclic setting, while preserving many of the convenient properties of acyclic SCMs. With this paper we aim to provide the foundations for a general theory of statistical causal modeling with SCMs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1611.06221v6
2021-11-22T12:56:11
2016-11-18T20:54:03
{ "title": [ 0.0037612915, -0.009536743, -0.043914795, -0.08630371, 0.015213013, -0.0045318604, -0.041931152, -0.00084733963, -0.01600647, 0.0031032562, -0.022369385, 0.019714355, -0.05883789, -0.031188965, -0.02130127, -0.011650085, -0.0038814545, 0.016616821, -0.0231781, -0.028884888, -0.047302246, -0.04058838, 0.052886963, -0.027252197, 0.06121826, -0.0073165894, -0.030014038, 0.014671326, -0.032104492, -0.034606934, 0.0020503998, -0.015914917, 0.03933716, 0.03189087, 0.007572174, -0.032989502, -0.041229248, 0.018203735, 0.0031795502, 0.014511108, -0.00044369698, 0.003736496, 0.015472412, -0.058807373, -0.03353882, 0.01676941, -0.058380127, -0.043701172, -0.02142334, 0.035186768, 0.007434845, 0.044403076, -0.02859497, 0.043518066, 0.025177002, -0.034301758, -0.036102295, -0.004688263, 0.027923584, 0.09375, 0.024276733, -0.032958984, -0.006958008, -0.038757324, -0.038879395, -0.009414673, -0.03338623, 0.04537964, 0.06915283, -0.0009636879, -0.035064697, 0.0058937073, -0.01953125, 0.021240234, -0.040039062, -0.0053749084, 0.057861328, -0.0029678345, 0.018188477, -0.00020265579, -0.009002686, -0.010261536, -0.027008057, -0.0012140274, 0.0096206665, -0.015777588, -0.037353516, -0.008491516, -0.0045547485, -0.058013916, -0.011802673, -0.015388489, 0.003250122, 0.015655518, -0.022705078, -0.02494812, -0.012756348, 0.032928467, -0.006011963, -0.029846191, -0.058776855, 0.031463623, -0.07342529, -0.006580353, -0.007904053, -0.021652222, -0.0026741028, -0.02305603, 0.005218506, 0.046966553, -0.031097412, 0.03439331, 0.011924744, 0.02192688, 0.0033855438, 0.0044288635, -0.017105103, 0.03930664, -0.0057144165, 0.04901123, -0.0016698837, -0.017654419, 0.009002686, 0.010345459, 0.008232117, -0.002696991, -0.0496521, -0.0032463074, -0.0463562, 0.04525757, 0.0075187683, 0.030075073, -0.045410156, -0.040039062, -0.034057617, 0.01373291, 0.0045700073, -0.03933716, -0.04336548, 0.03665161, -0.030914307, -0.026489258, 0.016601562, -0.046875, 0.020080566, 0.0096588135, 0.06439209, -0.0076522827, -0.038208008, -0.0015497208, -0.01965332, 0.028442383, 0.057617188, 0.017486572, -0.1026001, -0.006565094, -0.12915039, 0.005050659, -0.0046310425, -0.016143799, 0.009101868, -0.009757996, -0.024673462, 0.001991272, 0.026321411, -0.0036201477, -0.012214661, 0.046783447, 0.025817871, 0.05340576, -0.0017623901, 0.01876831, -0.005001068, 0.022338867, -0.0038795471, 0.013008118, 0.030319214, -0.0066452026, 0.026916504, 0.008956909, 0.022583008, -0.009750366, -0.012046814, 0.06549072, -0.059906006, -0.03265381, -0.006286621, -0.0073928833, 0.062316895, 0.016647339, -0.038909912, 0.028869629, -0.07244873, -0.07397461, -0.06036377, 0.006095886, 0.05328369, 0.03062439, 0.004005432, 0.036865234, 0.043670654, -0.02168274, -0.003627777, -0.018218994, -0.0053100586, -0.02960205, -0.0031337738, -0.009933472, -0.02798462, 0.06088257, 0.060424805, 0.013381958, -0.02420044, 0.00071048737, -0.004131317, -0.05050659, 0.046447754, -0.025054932, 0.0029907227, -0.03451538, -0.007587433, -0.0053596497, -0.00308609, 0.07678223, 0.0075569153, -0.020965576, 0.014564514, -0.048950195, 0.050750732, 0.024810791, 0.051940918, -0.042266846, 0.023605347, -0.00071668625, -0.028808594, -0.014038086, -0.016937256, 0.009140015, -0.0059318542, 0.023162842, -0.021942139, -0.03869629, -0.020843506, 0.0647583, -0.016967773, -0.008964539, -0.005996704, 0.053009033, -0.0019550323, -0.0072746277, 0.07080078, 0.012519836, 0.066589355, -0.0071754456, -0.005634308, 0.07281494, -0.00023686886, -0.018478394, -0.0055503845, 0.035003662, 0.0020275116, 0.002401352, -0.014930725, 0.0062675476, -0.034820557, -0.018371582, -0.031982422, 0.00041365623, -0.00018918514, 0.00116539, 0.039642334, -0.022659302, 0.01751709, -0.03237915, -0.009925842, -0.0020656586, -0.014274597, 0.020263672, -0.008872986, -0.06958008, -0.01953125, 0.001578331, 0.054229736, 0.009773254, 0.0074310303, 0.022369385, 0.049804688, -0.000207901, 0.03012085, -0.0077171326, 0.04522705, 0.027053833, 0.001660347, 0.019714355, 0.02330017, -0.023284912, 0.052246094, 0.055664062, -0.022613525, 0.0345459, -0.05307007, 0.020477295, 0.03265381, -0.023025513, 0.005542755, 0.024490356, 0.046051025, 0.013328552, -0.032958984, -0.0104904175, -0.02243042, 0.01828003, 0.008644104, -0.012664795, 0.0023784637, -0.019744873, 0.040130615, -0.021224976, 0.019882202, 0.0064926147, 0.04321289, 0.01348114, -0.049957275, 0.007820129, 0.014503479, -0.0023670197, -0.015975952, -0.035308838, -0.023345947, 0.02859497, 0.057800293, 0.03010559, -0.053222656, -0.03604126, -0.0035514832, 0.00907135, -0.011016846, 0.017501831, -0.013153076, -0.011787415, -0.014450073, -0.039978027, 0.023101807, -0.04626465, 0.0022258759, -0.044555664, 0.023422241, 0.02772522, -0.024353027, 0.017303467, 0.021759033, -0.021606445, -0.019866943, 0.0055618286, 0.07336426, -0.014572144, -0.029373169, 0.04788208, 0.05935669, -0.025985718, 0.013618469, -0.011138916, -0.03152466, -0.037384033, 0.027069092, -0.045166016, -0.03842163, -0.028869629, -0.024612427, 0.032104492, -0.06378174, -0.0317688, -0.028320312, 0.015899658, 0.019210815, 0.06384277, -0.014587402, -0.025726318, -0.04888916, -0.03729248, -0.010887146, -0.012611389, -0.0206604, -0.018508911, 0.0848999, -0.01751709, 0.00052928925, 0.0087890625, 0.06958008, 0.025283813, -0.012550354, -0.042236328, -0.04421997, -0.0061798096, 0.027191162, 0.030563354, 0.0058898926, -0.01411438, -0.06933594, -0.029800415, 0.046661377, -0.023223877, -0.035186768, 0.0054359436, -0.050567627, 0.02331543, -0.009544373, -0.0020313263, 0.041290283, 0.072265625, -0.02432251, 0.02319336, -0.010101318, -0.012519836, 0.0019264221, 0.0011739731, -0.0496521, 0.016082764, -0.006324768, -0.060791016, 0.021820068, -0.05621338, -0.02609253, -0.012840271, 0.007873535, 0.03878784, 0.013435364, 0.01689148, 0.014022827, -0.02897644, -0.0069274902, -0.01928711, -0.025421143, -0.014228821, 0.00970459, -0.002571106, -0.017486572, 0.025604248, 0.016723633, 0.00011444092, -0.009986877, -0.02558899, -0.0074310303, 0.007698059, -0.021697998, -0.014694214, -0.0036582947, 0.020874023, -0.007232666, -0.028427124, -0.032196045, -0.0065689087, -0.032806396, 0.018157959, -0.009490967, 0.041656494, -0.0009288788, -0.010848999, -0.0524292, 0.012023926, 0.012336731, -0.0143966675, -0.048797607, -0.014045715, 0.018188477, -0.015090942, 0.062561035, -0.026290894, 0.0062828064, -0.0013809204, -0.058502197, 0.029556274, 0.030426025, 0.002090454, 0.0034065247, 0.028167725, -0.015357971, -0.011764526, -0.031433105, 0.011878967, 0.055023193, -0.0074386597, 0.037750244, -0.06616211, -0.009254456, 0.016479492, -0.14660645, -0.01272583, 0.0021018982, -0.056152344, -0.06390381, -0.0340271, 0.012199402, -0.015007019, -0.0121154785, -0.018997192, -0.032592773, -0.03161621, -0.01424408, -0.088378906, 0.012756348, 0.06329346, 0.033966064, 0.016525269, 0.004322052, -0.017745972, 0.008491516, -0.05545044, 0.014953613, -0.0181427, 0.04522705, -0.01966858, 0.0061149597, 0.039978027, -0.02154541, 0.034088135, 0.054138184, 0.010055542, 0.023590088, -0.009750366, 0.0072288513, 0.011131287, 0.018341064, 0.019760132, 0.037017822, -0.02897644, -0.010116577, 0.022888184, -0.014884949, 0.026107788, -0.009178162, 0.014404297, 0.03503418, 0.004119873, 0.018447876, 0.006416321, -0.0054359436, -0.008155823, 0.0541687, -0.004638672, -0.0063552856, 0.017990112, -0.0027503967, 0.011207581, 0.023223877, -0.011009216, 0.008369446, 0.041381836, -0.027145386, -0.006454468, -0.0054512024, 0.0017595291, 0.00003606081, 0.0181427, -0.058532715, -0.05102539, -0.04296875, 0.004360199, -0.006160736, 0.04525757, 0.02104187, -0.016067505, -0.017181396, -0.0032024384, -0.0017690659, 0.009895325, 0.00095176697, -0.050994873, 0.01637268, -0.03262329, -0.033813477, -0.04663086, -0.023330688, -0.0135650635, 0.0256958, 0.0075302124, -0.011444092, 0.028808594, 0.021713257, 0.050750732, 0.07171631, -0.0066223145, -0.04373169, 0.04119873, 0.015014648, 0.004814148, -0.008544922, 0.018585205, 0.02406311, -0.018341064, -0.032958984, -0.023086548, 0.0015554428, -0.028457642, 0.0022068024, -0.0395813, 0.06021118, 0.025131226, 0.043182373, 0.029373169, -0.002128601, 0.010673523, 0.0066223145, -0.042053223, -0.029846191, 0.026046753, 0.037231445, 0.011100769, 0.012870789, 0.03189087, 0.001203537, -0.010253906, 0.019622803, 0.004875183, 0.021438599, -0.0073547363, -0.0055351257, 0.024520874, -0.00894165, -0.024307251, 0.025863647, 0.021270752, 0.041656494, -0.037841797, 0.038635254, -0.01977539, 0.012191772, 0.018112183, -0.01626587, 0.012641907, -0.0022392273, 0.01751709, -0.06304932, -0.06097412, -0.01777649, 0.047332764, -0.026367188, -0.003768921, 0.0039405823, 0.030090332, 0.00982666, 0.047302246, 0.04446411, -0.015556335, 0.013465881, -0.027023315, -0.011650085, -0.011474609, -0.059906006, 0.025024414, 0.01524353, 0.022094727, -0.047424316, -0.006061554, -0.08215332, 0.009727478, -0.02494812, -0.025756836, 0.014831543, -0.08532715, -0.0013771057, 0.051940918, 0.018692017, 0.05770874, 0.0017671585, 0.015640259, 0.04736328, 0.044799805, 0.01687622, 0.017486572, 0.01361084, -0.028274536, 0.01348114, -0.0043792725, 0.018493652, 0.03363037, -0.00067424774, 0.00050640106, 0.0042266846, -0.022872925, 0.02557373, 0.005870819, 0.008293152, 0.003616333, -0.058258057, -0.00907135, 0.0016908646, 0.012634277, 0.012214661, 0.009490967, -0.041809082, 0.006439209, -0.008270264, -0.012504578, 0.04309082, 0.011680603, -0.04220581, -0.021621704, 0.0077667236, 0.000333786, 0.011276245, -0.0007266998, 0.0060577393, -0.027923584, -0.00025224686, 0.015319824, -0.041656494, 0.015487671, -0.027328491, 0.013061523, 0.040222168, 0.009132385, -0.013633728, 0.004447937, -0.038146973, -0.054748535, -0.018920898, 0.050750732, 0.01864624, -0.0029239655, -0.006626129, -0.027008057, -0.007171631, 0.006958008, 0.01612854, 0.026245117, -0.034820557, 0.04034424, 0.0057525635, 0.0014238358, 0.004890442, -0.005683899, -0.016799927, 0.0040893555, 0.00957489, -0.047668457, 0.016189575, -0.0026779175, -0.0071258545, -0.000603199, -0.053833008, 0.018051147, 0.023132324, 0.009727478, -0.043701172, 0.01864624, 0.027389526, -0.0137786865, -0.028244019, -0.018707275, 0.037261963, -0.015129089, -0.07086182, 0.02935791, -0.006580353, -0.0012521744, 0.058776855, 0.012329102, -0.054504395, -0.02192688, -0.053771973, -0.04309082, 0.0024280548, 0.062316895, 0.0064201355, 0.05279541, -0.011528015, 0.002910614, -0.0146484375, -0.012496948, 0.009933472, 0.009124756, 0.012031555, -0.019226074, -0.004398346, -0.022354126, -0.008087158, -0.026519775, 0.009185791, 0.010040283, 0.0017957687, 0.0025310516, -0.028244019, 0.00022435188, 0.013641357, -0.03781128, 0.04650879, -0.045440674, 0.017074585, 0.036102295, -0.05316162, 0.02885437, 0.014556885, 0.08496094, 0.032958984, 0.022613525, 0.0335083, 0.014411926, 0.035614014, -0.03225708, 0.0287323, -0.022583008, -0.024887085, -0.0793457, -0.023132324, -0.07086182, 0.010368347, 0.0059661865, 0.01108551, -0.013771057, 0.008804321, -0.026763916, 0.031707764, 0.0541687, 0.075683594, 0.05392456, 0.03741455, 0.004547119, 0.013534546, -0.02142334, -0.015083313, 0.032318115, 0.01612854, -0.016174316, -0.01737976, -0.004348755, 0.010124207, 0.020599365, -0.016021729, -0.007972717, 0.009162903, -0.022537231, 0.033416748, 0.0061416626, 0.049560547, 0.02204895, 0.024139404, 0.009338379, -0.0031394958, -0.0049705505, -0.014183044, -0.027023315, -0.0073127747, 0.047698975, -0.07122803, 0.030807495, -0.012489319, -0.034484863, -0.018753052, 0.004676819, 0.037109375, -0.07421875, -0.065979004, 0.0030212402, 0.052581787, 0.030975342, 0.028839111, -0.034423828, 0.000025808811, 0.012374878, 0.016479492, 0.019454956, 0.031829834, 0.010009766, 0.03265381, -0.011558533, -0.012008667, 0.00504303, 0.023361206, -0.030685425, 0.020843506, -0.018157959, -0.021835327, 0.014289856, -0.025756836, 0.011764526, 0.0025100708, -0.032043457, 0.00041627884, 0.005493164, 0.032226562, 0.061676025, 0.08526611, 0.0287323, 0.0025234222, -0.008522034, -0.055725098, 0.03866577, 0.03527832, -0.004535675, 0.036895752, -0.04498291, -0.053741455, 0.04522705, -0.031082153, 0.10736084, -0.05065918, -0.0065231323, -0.013572693, 0.0025787354, 0.041412354, -0.038604736, -0.023071289, -0.023895264, -0.002281189, 0.008956909, -0.008682251, -0.05596924, -0.021240234, 0.02444458, 0.028366089, 0.035186768, -0.027282715, -0.032714844, -0.019592285, -0.049041748, -0.0028266907, -0.022354126, 0.028518677, -0.01159668, -0.030883789, -0.043792725, 0.016143799, 0.041748047, -0.0017004013, -0.0435791, 0.035858154, -0.036071777, -0.028579712, 0.022415161, 0.034240723, -0.01007843, -0.0027332306, -0.018005371, 0.0028915405, -0.004673004, -0.042297363, 0.015136719, -0.034179688, -0.010414124, -0.017150879, 0.001572609, 0.021240234, 0.03265381, -0.007751465, 0.028167725, 0.028671265, -0.04058838, -0.034088135, -0.02784729, 0.0054855347, 0.0075569153, -0.041015625, 0.0026550293, 0.036468506, 0.0206604, -0.05758667, 0.0010051727, 0.044921875, 0.023513794, -0.01084137, 0.046691895, 0.044281006, 0.009010315, 0.005493164, -0.010475159, -0.011581421, -0.048187256, -0.029891968, -0.03427124, 0.031066895, 0.029541016, 0.0011997223, -0.018966675, 0.03805542, -0.021530151, -0.0040626526, 0.0016431808, -0.022506714, -0.013328552, 0.010375977, 0.036132812, 0.0022506714, -0.017303467, -0.00035715103, -0.049957275, 0.015960693, 0.019317627, -0.03277588, -0.00060129166, -0.048095703, 0.082214355, -0.014427185, 0.005794525, 0.017791748, 0.014045715, 0.048034668, 0.01914978, -0.012046814, 0.0064582825, 0.02418518, -0.019683838, -0.024383545, -0.011787415, 0.04031372, -0.038024902, -0.02998352, -0.0015087128, -0.013549805, 0.020446777, -0.03668213, 0.05331421, -0.045959473, -0.005973816, -0.0690918, -0.01776123, -0.013336182, 0.0049552917, -0.005168915, -0.06573486, -0.034454346, -0.0035095215, 0.046539307, 0.007926941 ], "summary": [ 0.022018433, -0.02041626, 0.009963989, -0.070617676, -0.035339355, 0.021057129, -0.0703125, 0.018722534, -0.011199951, -0.015792847, -0.015182495, 0.00667572, -0.042999268, -0.03994751, 0.029708862, -0.033813477, -0.014175415, 0.024047852, -0.012664795, -0.036315918, -0.008460999, -0.03466797, -0.0038394928, -0.03881836, 0.016082764, -0.0060043335, 0.06677246, 0.0018892288, 0.039642334, 0.033935547, 0.018173218, -0.08648682, 0.017196655, 0.011734009, 0.0051994324, -0.01826477, -0.0046195984, -0.0012340546, -0.0052337646, 0.014007568, -0.0073509216, -0.014045715, 0.10681152, -0.07373047, 0.050750732, 0.021865845, -0.013069153, -0.07354736, 0.039916992, 0.020431519, -0.0011806488, 0.03086853, 0.00035095215, 0.0075187683, -0.019882202, -0.025161743, -0.03375244, 0.005722046, 0.019714355, 0.07678223, 0.02407837, 0.006454468, -0.025787354, -0.047943115, 0.005634308, 0.0138549805, -0.0068893433, 0.009002686, 0.016067505, 0.018539429, 0.0063323975, -0.026229858, -0.01902771, 0.0021381378, -0.008659363, 0.01663208, 0.03112793, 0.012374878, -0.0058288574, 0.041107178, -0.040527344, 0.014083862, -0.04434204, -0.011886597, 0.0030460358, 0.011047363, -0.03274536, -0.008598328, -0.0013494492, -0.009483337, -0.012588501, -0.056427002, -0.0011119843, 0.03515625, 0.007686615, -0.016952515, -0.004459381, 0.009399414, -0.010848999, -0.040039062, -0.030654907, 0.030883789, -0.07922363, 0.009811401, -0.01335144, 0.011932373, -0.0037212372, -0.021240234, 0.022491455, 0.020385742, -0.01235199, 0.034851074, 0.054229736, 0.014518738, 0.018692017, -0.041748047, 0.0019264221, 0.10534668, -0.006969452, 0.07672119, -0.031173706, 0.005256653, -0.021606445, 0.0690918, -0.023452759, 0.01675415, 0.040374756, -0.0034332275, -0.059448242, 0.016235352, -0.015274048, 0.01763916, 0.03744507, 0.05029297, 0.01134491, -0.027755737, -0.019363403, -0.07116699, -0.034057617, 0.026855469, 0.0022792816, -0.011703491, 0.03768921, -0.012176514, 0.035461426, 0.008811951, 0.04034424, 0.021011353, -0.037872314, 0.009033203, -0.004272461, 0.056793213, 0.061828613, -0.015182495, -0.11254883, -0.05343628, -0.057434082, -0.014968872, -0.020645142, -0.058624268, 0.016098022, -0.005493164, -0.014541626, 0.043060303, -0.0007019043, -0.008560181, 0.026855469, 0.011207581, 0.030258179, -0.030685425, 0.047668457, -0.0062446594, 0.034362793, 0.01776123, 0.00730896, 0.025253296, -0.04562378, -0.0099487305, 0.0076828003, 0.03842163, 0.03768921, -0.018554688, -0.05117798, 0.08099365, -0.06921387, 0.00032281876, -0.00036168098, 0.06781006, 0.056488037, 0.017852783, 0.016616821, -0.025726318, -0.014122009, -0.03845215, -0.012275696, -0.005683899, 0.007843018, -0.011741638, -0.004611969, 0.040252686, 0.046447754, -0.03286743, 0.0022029877, -0.029174805, -0.00046300888, -0.058258057, 0.014350891, -0.017578125, 0.012031555, 0.030792236, 0.009208679, -0.024734497, 0.0020599365, 0.0054016113, -0.012763977, -0.03540039, 0.058807373, -0.06951904, -0.015007019, -0.070251465, -0.030166626, 0.014190674, -0.052490234, 0.10296631, 0.03552246, -0.018676758, 0.0035133362, -0.01586914, 0.061920166, -0.014053345, 0.06854248, 0.0008301735, -0.0065841675, 0.010887146, -0.012069702, 0.010391235, -0.018951416, -0.01802063, 0.00674057, 0.020889282, 0.009735107, -0.038360596, -0.03942871, 0.029052734, -0.040618896, -0.01335144, 0.019195557, 0.018478394, -0.046844482, -0.04159546, 0.040283203, 0.0032081604, 0.050201416, -0.027908325, 0.0009784698, 0.037506104, -0.0060195923, -0.02619934, -0.029296875, 0.035827637, 0.018997192, -0.0041389465, -0.020721436, -0.0011930466, 0.031219482, -0.07879639, 0.024932861, -0.016952515, 0.050201416, -0.08453369, -0.012809753, -0.06506348, -0.000192523, -0.013153076, -0.0090789795, -0.020233154, -0.049346924, 0.029220581, 0.032287598, -0.01083374, 0.003774643, 0.0067367554, 0.038085938, 0.00025892258, 0.0011348724, 0.03878784, 0.048461914, 0.005672455, 0.053497314, 0.0635376, 0.06451416, 0.016799927, 0.014724731, 0.008773804, -0.028900146, -0.019943237, -0.043029785, -0.01008606, 0.0039367676, -0.040863037, -0.027008057, 0.056732178, 0.021148682, -0.03579712, -0.015945435, 0.0035362244, -0.015670776, -0.01966858, -0.022567749, -0.02355957, -0.03894043, 0.014663696, 0.04272461, 0.080078125, 0.0043640137, -0.010772705, 0.020370483, 0.070007324, 0.05307007, 0.04159546, 0.08654785, 0.029403687, 0.015426636, 0.0043144226, 0.018234253, -0.05239868, 0.02432251, -0.021362305, 0.0076026917, -0.017196655, -0.0061073303, -0.023330688, -0.049987793, 0.0039138794, 0.018692017, 0.011070251, 0.0038089752, -0.021652222, -0.0132369995, -0.011299133, 0.03250122, -0.06222534, 0.03994751, 0.019866943, 0.0076522827, -0.017211914, 0.024658203, 0.004737854, 0.041107178, 0.038024902, -0.028640747, -0.004802704, -0.0019283295, 0.030395508, 0.027572632, 0.02809143, 0.017990112, 0.06915283, 0.070495605, -0.011688232, 0.001616478, 0.002658844, -0.04812622, -0.023483276, 0.041412354, -0.02078247, 0.0018253326, -0.055664062, 0.035095215, 0.027023315, -0.04446411, 0.023895264, -0.07141113, 0.02142334, 0.05532837, 0.03378296, 0.04360962, -0.011405945, 0.031143188, 0.040405273, 0.009155273, 0.010360718, -0.012397766, -0.0053215027, 0.05810547, 0.0038871765, 0.00223732, 0.020233154, 0.014213562, 0.0154800415, -0.026000977, -0.009391785, -0.02758789, -0.039886475, 0.012718201, 0.020706177, 0.020401001, -0.011856079, 0.046813965, -0.048950195, -0.009689331, 0.0030612946, -0.018737793, 0.00274086, -0.027999878, 0.029953003, -0.012413025, -0.04244995, 0.004547119, -0.011146545, 0.03250122, -0.042877197, 0.011528015, -0.043762207, 0.008659363, -0.02947998, 0.005191803, 0.0206604, -0.020706177, -0.073913574, 0.017562866, -0.022827148, -0.0024604797, -0.024765015, 0.015510559, 0.004550934, 0.0129852295, 0.007003784, -0.0011491776, -0.0093307495, 0.004589081, -0.04144287, -0.018554688, -0.0061683655, 0.003124237, 0.02859497, -0.012207031, -0.030212402, -0.0074768066, -0.025512695, 0.0035572052, -0.037841797, -0.007926941, 0.019515991, -0.028076172, 0.02041626, -0.051757812, 0.0009059906, -0.029434204, 0.0010538101, -0.043701172, 0.0047073364, -0.027709961, 0.038116455, -0.005268097, 0.05014038, -0.05908203, 0.015151978, 0.004623413, -0.017791748, -0.018737793, 0.0075569153, -0.028701782, -0.036071777, 0.024734497, -0.06008911, 0.057617188, -0.018310547, -0.0064964294, 0.0041885376, -0.0146102905, 0.0068893433, -0.0027370453, 0.013900757, -0.03793335, 0.007724762, 0.020401001, 0.006565094, 0.025558472, 0.005340576, 0.012428284, 0.010368347, 0.033203125, -0.029937744, -0.017852783, 0.013061523, -0.07788086, -0.036010742, 0.010986328, -0.0680542, -0.050750732, -0.031280518, 0.01574707, 0.009346008, 0.026779175, -0.032043457, -0.0211792, 0.051116943, 0.032958984, -0.051849365, 0.011703491, -0.0128479, 0.009536743, -0.022705078, -0.057861328, 0.025360107, 0.10913086, -0.002702713, -0.012023926, -0.04260254, 0.06665039, -0.04373169, 0.057891846, 0.018508911, -0.000011026859, 0.013748169, 0.043121338, 0.04119873, 0.002632141, -0.027435303, 0.013473511, 0.031555176, -0.003370285, -0.009605408, 0.02835083, 0.0028572083, -0.0037956238, 0.05078125, 0.015510559, -0.00459671, -0.002210617, 0.01234436, -0.013412476, 0.029525757, -0.008796692, -0.030929565, -0.026504517, -0.016433716, 0.027893066, 0.043762207, -0.02468872, -0.00944519, 0.020858765, 0.06304932, -0.0118255615, 0.0071258545, -0.04525757, 0.03451538, -0.024337769, -0.0016040802, 0.0022773743, -0.003967285, -0.0101623535, -0.010223389, 0.032104492, -0.04840088, -0.01864624, -0.013076782, 0.0047798157, 0.047302246, -0.021942139, 0.029281616, -0.0049362183, -0.0036716461, -0.030059814, 0.015220642, 0.008987427, -0.007217407, -0.007003784, -0.016921997, 0.0014762878, -0.045440674, -0.042938232, -0.028244019, -0.023239136, 0.0047912598, -0.008552551, 0.018203735, 0.028167725, 0.022415161, 0.036346436, -0.016983032, -0.044921875, -0.0079956055, 0.0085372925, 0.07989502, -0.029327393, 0.07147217, 0.02947998, 0.023422241, -0.09173584, 0.0031757355, -0.002670288, -0.041137695, -0.017242432, -0.0134887695, 0.019424438, 0.030410767, 0.029251099, 0.018493652, -0.003698349, 0.019958496, 0.0063552856, -0.013870239, -0.0029125214, 0.04525757, -0.006629944, 0.046783447, -0.027114868, 0.020065308, 0.00011622906, 0.010345459, 0.017456055, -0.03543091, 0.024993896, 0.019714355, 0.051635742, 0.01864624, 0.04586792, -0.023590088, 0.030792236, 0.039978027, 0.0019550323, -0.005142212, -0.024780273, 0.012275696, 0.024475098, 0.005744934, -0.011665344, 0.005756378, 0.02456665, -0.009979248, 0.0021800995, -0.009422302, -0.0069274902, 0.0029354095, 0.0011072159, -0.044952393, -0.019805908, 0.04284668, -0.012397766, 0.0043678284, 0.0035572052, -0.03149414, 0.024215698, -0.03048706, -0.020004272, 0.010009766, -0.0335083, 0.0037250519, 0.03744507, 0.018173218, 0.034088135, -0.06689453, -0.03289795, -0.036468506, -0.030410767, 0.01222229, 0.016036987, -0.028778076, -0.048095703, 0.029815674, 0.02709961, 0.00033831596, -0.0040130615, -0.006706238, 0.0184021, 0.05178833, -0.03970337, 0.030822754, 0.018997192, 0.0042152405, 0.035461426, -0.027160645, 0.020233154, 0.004306793, -0.002500534, -0.00667572, 0.012214661, -0.030059814, -0.02456665, -0.015113831, 0.06689453, 0.03152466, -0.056732178, 0.02027893, -0.02319336, -0.023590088, -0.002614975, 0.051574707, -0.032958984, 0.011947632, 0.019805908, 0.01676941, -0.008422852, 0.00522995, 0.007858276, 0.003047943, 0.0065193176, -0.036468506, 0.019561768, 0.01335144, 0.012390137, 0.019439697, -0.044830322, 0.008659363, -0.026229858, 0.029174805, -0.00060510635, 0.0284729, 0.0039520264, -0.04864502, -0.036346436, -0.011817932, -0.02659607, -0.003993988, -0.00013494492, 0.033325195, 0.025863647, 0.033203125, 0.010574341, 0.023345947, 0.021453857, -0.014709473, 0.009399414, -0.0024433136, -0.029815674, 0.03439331, -0.0003774166, -0.0061302185, 0.011566162, -0.0018510818, -0.016479492, 0.002544403, 0.017669678, -0.022384644, 0.014434814, 0.027511597, -0.008285522, 0.026046753, -0.004722595, -0.01159668, 0.020843506, -0.025054932, -0.03286743, -0.018966675, -0.0062179565, -0.027145386, -0.0110321045, -0.040130615, 0.03387451, -0.003414154, -0.042114258, 0.004962921, 0.035858154, -0.007446289, -0.011642456, 0.007068634, -0.024841309, 0.001285553, -0.04660034, -0.0011110306, -0.00056123734, 0.025344849, 0.02468872, 0.040527344, 0.01701355, 0.013298035, -0.005065918, -0.015838623, 0.00039863586, 0.050933838, 0.003162384, 0.008476257, -0.031463623, -0.046966553, -0.03439331, -0.0090789795, 0.021392822, 0.040985107, 0.019012451, 0.042114258, -0.010871887, -0.02949524, 0.02017212, -0.021377563, 0.012741089, -0.014732361, 0.014762878, -0.0031108856, 0.008354187, 0.0034866333, 0.047729492, 0.06689453, 0.04232788, 0.026351929, 0.06304932, 0.032989502, -0.0126571655, -0.012252808, 0.035705566, 0.0070114136, -0.060424805, -0.049987793, -0.050231934, -0.01612854, 0.042022705, -0.037841797, 0.0007266998, 0.009231567, 0.005054474, -0.04650879, 0.020095825, -0.015777588, 0.052764893, 0.015640259, 0.032104492, -0.041015625, 0.04345703, 0.016189575, -0.0104904175, 0.03451538, 0.045928955, 0.0016956329, 0.052520752, -0.017913818, 0.04598999, -0.0065193176, -0.011947632, -0.06915283, 0.007461548, -0.041778564, 0.0009484291, 0.019439697, 0.035003662, -0.011245728, -0.017852783, 0.032836914, 0.0033130646, -0.0109939575, 0.046813965, -0.0022945404, -0.005592346, 0.019424438, 0.013160706, -0.030380249, 0.0074005127, -0.010879517, 0.042144775, 0.03111267, 0.051849365, -0.070739746, -0.0000526309, 0.019226074, -0.0096206665, -0.046447754, 0.022506714, -0.034240723, 0.016906738, -0.011550903, -0.035614014, 0.04562378, 0.025543213, 0.0098724365, 0.04537964, 0.018920898, 0.009933472, 0.002029419, -0.0070533752, 0.0029506683, 0.021011353, 0.013404846, -0.021484375, 0.024993896, -0.01725769, 0.022918701, 0.0034313202, 0.019210815, 0.020843506, -0.04309082, 0.06222534, 0.08203125, 0.07366943, -0.017242432, 0.019042969, 0.078430176, -0.017059326, 0.029312134, -0.009666443, 0.019454956, 0.0026836395, -0.04824829, -0.011558533, 0.00894928, -0.02444458, 0.08148193, -0.0029525757, 0.0038642883, -0.049224854, 0.025543213, -0.014549255, -0.05444336, 0.025726318, -0.04675293, -0.008911133, 0.011627197, -0.0096206665, -0.06518555, 0.014572144, -0.0070724487, -0.013168335, 0.032592773, -0.0041503906, 0.027236938, -0.032806396, 0.0021419525, 0.0023441315, 0.04196167, 0.054656982, 0.007247925, -0.018554688, -0.021591187, 0.06512451, 0.0057029724, -0.03265381, -0.038330078, 0.06707764, 0.018554688, -0.030807495, 0.02128601, 0.041229248, -0.018859863, -0.033294678, 0.02671814, -0.0067749023, -0.014556885, -0.011421204, 0.024887085, 0.0032749176, 0.003545761, 0.005393982, -0.018753052, -0.008575439, -0.025863647, -0.0015268326, 0.015945435, 0.0619812, -0.047729492, -0.03692627, -0.04248047, -0.05038452, 0.00730896, -0.0057792664, -0.013061523, 0.024414062, 0.02355957, -0.033233643, 0.0037994385, 0.014801025, -0.0010528564, 0.0116119385, -0.03277588, 0.020599365, -0.0071754456, -0.008682251, -0.038391113, -0.019836426, -0.005897522, -0.004486084, -0.016098022, 0.040130615, -0.00086545944, -0.013313293, -0.011024475, 0.0056533813, -0.008430481, -0.010169983, 0.01751709, -0.0035800934, -0.033935547, 0.0046310425, 0.004924774, -0.020721436, -0.047943115, 0.04473877, -0.047546387, 0.0039787292, -0.015457153, -0.010528564, -0.028045654, -0.04940796, 0.021896362, -0.01626587, 0.047943115, -0.018203735, -0.026046753, 0.029663086, -0.018844604, 0.032043457, 0.021362305, -0.001906395, -0.005836487, -0.024398804, -0.019561768, 0.03466797, -0.05758667, -0.028167725, 0.04714966, 0.031951904, 0.004676819, -0.013244629, 0.066833496, -0.04660034, -0.030960083, -0.059265137, -0.028305054, 0.017959595, -0.017456055, -0.005428314, -0.020095825, -0.005622864, 0.04498291, -0.033569336, 0.024307251 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1309.0866v1
On the Robustness of Temporal Properties for Stochastic Models
Ezio Bartocci, Luca Bortolussi, Laura Nenzi, Guido Sanguinetti
cs.LO, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SY
Stochastic models such as Continuous-Time Markov Chains (CTMC) and Stochastic Hybrid Automata (SHA) are powerful formalisms to model and to reason about the dynamics of biological systems, due to their ability to capture the stochasticity inherent in biological processes. A classical question in formal modelling with clear relevance to biological modelling is the model checking problem. i.e. calculate the probability that a behaviour, expressed for instance in terms of a certain temporal logic formula, may occur in a given stochastic process. However, one may not only be interested in the notion of satisfiability, but also in the capacity of a system to mantain a particular emergent behaviour unaffected by the perturbations, caused e.g. from extrinsic noise, or by possible small changes in the model parameters. To address this issue, researchers from the verification community have recently proposed several notions of robustness for temporal logic providing suitable definitions of distance between a trajectory of a (deterministic) dynamical system and the boundaries of the set of trajectories satisfying the property of interest. The contributions of this paper are twofold. First, we extend the notion of robustness to stochastic systems, showing that this naturally leads to a distribution of robustness scores. By discussing two examples, we show how to approximate the distribution of the robustness score and its key indicators: the average robustness and the conditional average robustness. Secondly, we show how to combine these indicators with the satisfaction probability to address the system design problem, where the goal is to optimize some control parameters of a stochastic model in order to best maximize robustness of the desired specifications.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1309.0866v1
2013-09-03T23:40:49
2013-09-03T23:40:49
{ "title": [ -0.015113831, 0.023834229, -0.051971436, -0.072509766, 0.031051636, -0.0047073364, -0.032043457, -0.02935791, 0.021484375, 0.02130127, -0.017288208, 0.021331787, -0.026763916, -0.0068511963, -0.05630493, 0.009841919, -0.002368927, 0.02330017, -0.040740967, -0.04534912, -0.023803711, -0.06500244, 0.035369873, 0.0395813, 0.059051514, -0.030395508, -0.059265137, 0.011772156, -0.0022563934, -0.0054130554, 0.003440857, -0.022521973, 0.03756714, 0.05429077, -0.023101807, 0.006580353, -0.04208374, 0.029296875, 0.008506775, 0.0037117004, 0.01260376, -0.014953613, 0.008338928, -0.015029907, -0.024749756, 0.016906738, -0.024276733, -0.03250122, -0.025665283, 0.064208984, -0.0011148453, 0.029815674, -0.036254883, 0.050109863, 0.027618408, -0.02810669, -0.03643799, -0.00434494, 0.021743774, 0.06732178, 0.018951416, -0.02418518, 0.008560181, 0.0049209595, -0.01864624, -0.027816772, -0.026229858, 0.022369385, 0.07849121, 0.031051636, -0.024627686, 0.00005877018, 0.019638062, -0.014846802, -0.020263672, 0.004722595, 0.011528015, -0.010597229, 0.043518066, -0.010276794, 0.034088135, 0.0034179688, 0.0028133392, -0.024353027, 0.032287598, -0.042510986, -0.006126404, -0.016479492, -0.021026611, -0.04525757, -0.009269714, -0.011787415, 0.027786255, -0.013885498, -0.027267456, -0.021987915, -0.027648926, 0.05593872, -0.02444458, -0.027633667, -0.0129852295, 0.025558472, -0.06402588, -0.014678955, -0.022415161, 0.005558014, 0.007873535, -0.0024795532, -0.015777588, 0.044708252, -0.014205933, 0.019226074, 0.0034561157, 0.016845703, 0.00016069412, 0.0014533997, -0.0067481995, 0.011161804, 0.012893677, 0.030838013, -0.010658264, -0.014205933, -0.011062622, -0.016036987, 0.021362305, -0.033416748, -0.043670654, 0.004753113, -0.026443481, 0.025375366, 0.016448975, 0.043304443, -0.12243652, -0.07043457, -0.059753418, 0.04574585, 0.024551392, -0.01763916, -0.029434204, -0.0063972473, 0.011413574, -0.03201294, 0.0006041527, -0.0023345947, -0.0020046234, 0.028427124, 0.0519104, -0.00374794, -0.043426514, -0.04714966, -0.014251709, -0.014930725, 0.056488037, -0.016067505, -0.08270264, -0.024841309, -0.09124756, -0.031036377, 0.0211792, -0.03930664, 0.022338867, -0.016525269, -0.04611206, 0.0074691772, 0.03503418, 0.007904053, -0.01260376, 0.03704834, 0.016479492, 0.05871582, -0.03982544, 0.014282227, -0.010513306, 0.025375366, 0.011375427, 0.04345703, 0.033081055, -0.0154418945, 0.05569458, -0.017166138, 0.00035595894, -0.00055933, 0.02658081, 0.0418396, -0.045898438, -0.088012695, 0.0037498474, -0.048065186, 0.06488037, 0.027145386, -0.022842407, -0.005332947, -0.070129395, -0.0066108704, -0.04751587, -0.0027828217, 0.03717041, 0.05770874, -0.013061523, -0.018203735, -0.030410767, -0.0021095276, -0.034057617, 0.02104187, -0.0063285828, -0.023498535, -0.00047183037, 0.022125244, -0.012672424, 0.06112671, 0.06542969, 0.011016846, -0.044677734, 0.029449463, -0.0073280334, -0.052124023, 0.024353027, 0.011154175, -0.0007157326, 0.0031776428, -0.0390625, -0.01436615, 0.0037574768, 0.057403564, -0.008018494, -0.0042877197, 0.014251709, -0.023605347, 0.04864502, 0.01751709, 0.085632324, -0.06072998, -0.0023784637, -0.01524353, -0.009391785, -0.030334473, -0.021469116, -0.038024902, 0.030258179, 0.033477783, 0.0022182465, -0.017868042, 0.0046424866, 0.07293701, 0.020568848, -0.004966736, 0.016296387, 0.03302002, 0.01499939, -0.012130737, 0.0524292, 0.0066108704, 0.07519531, -0.0036239624, 0.008216858, 0.072021484, -0.0043754578, 0.007965088, -0.034057617, 0.050720215, -0.021697998, -0.008659363, -0.0040130615, -0.0042915344, -0.029342651, -0.016647339, -0.021636963, 0.003047943, 0.017227173, -0.008842468, 0.0234375, -0.059906006, 0.011650085, 0.0043296814, -0.012245178, -0.017196655, -0.0013484955, 0.014709473, -0.01826477, -0.041992188, -0.0043525696, 0.018341064, 0.07305908, 0.0138168335, 0.0152282715, -0.0059509277, 0.053222656, 0.006591797, 0.026855469, 0.005168915, 0.065979004, 0.006664276, 0.004207611, -0.0014276505, -0.021591187, -0.038848877, 0.046661377, 0.04812622, 0.011932373, 0.023361206, -0.07287598, 0.025634766, 0.025375366, -0.02154541, -0.0007109642, 0.045318604, 0.021087646, 0.0056915283, -0.029342651, 0.0042800903, -0.05996704, -0.005680084, 0.015075684, -0.026779175, 0.002878189, -0.016952515, 0.014541626, -0.01285553, 0.010879517, 0.0021018982, 0.029342651, 0.013153076, -0.028060913, -0.01134491, 0.028671265, -0.012023926, -0.05218506, -0.023864746, -0.04547119, 0.0184021, 0.05657959, 0.0019378662, -0.033599854, -0.013656616, -0.0009860992, 0.019180298, -0.01927185, 0.088134766, -0.011482239, -0.05267334, -0.019821167, -0.038269043, 0.009902954, -0.0011301041, -0.008636475, -0.0141067505, 0.0073127747, 0.0209198, -0.035949707, 0.016235352, -0.000073850155, -0.028518677, -0.04220581, 0.036499023, 0.059326172, -0.023742676, -0.0042686462, 0.06774902, 0.029006958, 0.01234436, 0.04147339, -0.01499939, -0.022354126, -0.044891357, -0.00084638596, -0.023544312, -0.0061683655, -0.03567505, -0.05368042, 0.044281006, -0.07086182, -0.043701172, -0.03125, 0.0019493103, -0.010650635, 0.053741455, -0.02468872, -0.04055786, -0.014984131, -0.032958984, -0.00819397, 0.006340027, -0.010177612, 0.006164551, 0.070739746, -0.00002026558, -0.0079574585, 0.01524353, 0.025268555, 0.0074920654, -0.032196045, -0.012138367, -0.0065078735, -0.016601562, 0.0012493134, 0.010818481, -0.009513855, -0.038116455, -0.039489746, -0.005756378, 0.051208496, -0.02645874, -0.016693115, 0.0113220215, -0.0602417, 0.051116943, -0.0013952255, 0.004699707, 0.021621704, 0.022201538, -0.004173279, -0.0031604767, 0.016830444, -0.050476074, 0.016357422, -0.06561279, -0.07043457, 0.031188965, -0.026031494, -0.067993164, 0.0036754608, -0.06109619, -0.032836914, -0.011016846, 0.008079529, 0.0146102905, 0.047180176, -0.00091314316, 0.017318726, -0.004508972, 0.0018453598, -0.023376465, -0.024017334, -0.01084137, -0.007408142, -0.0077781677, -0.013961792, 0.010643005, -0.004272461, 0.0034809113, 0.00737381, -0.013504028, -0.023605347, 0.036621094, -0.0056610107, -0.042053223, -0.0055885315, 0.0041046143, 0.022949219, -0.026535034, -0.02482605, -0.016906738, 0.0010204315, 0.0079193115, 0.0026054382, 0.05899048, 0.031097412, 0.01828003, -0.04675293, -0.0011997223, 0.031982422, -0.029891968, -0.037506104, -0.010826111, 0.009101868, 0.0054512024, -0.0015602112, -0.007709503, -0.015586853, -0.008262634, -0.04067993, 0.04977417, 0.029312134, 0.013587952, -0.02041626, 0.037322998, -0.009429932, -0.0031032562, -0.027542114, 0.014808655, 0.032165527, -0.018814087, -0.027694702, -0.042114258, 0.0018701553, -0.0018014908, -0.10675049, 0.022033691, -0.010894775, -0.0390625, -0.03387451, -0.036865234, -0.008346558, -0.000746727, -0.05303955, -0.008155823, -0.024658203, -0.05432129, -0.017364502, -0.070495605, -0.020370483, 0.07409668, 0.01473999, 0.023468018, 0.006996155, -0.012313843, 0.012413025, -0.049957275, 0.025817871, -0.0045928955, 0.04019165, -0.025360107, 0.023956299, 0.053100586, -0.015838623, 0.029312134, 0.024215698, 0.035491943, -0.015281677, -0.010505676, 0.040618896, 0.05001831, 0.0003824234, 0.041107178, 0.035247803, -0.04019165, -0.032592773, -0.020828247, -0.017715454, 0.015022278, 0.0046539307, -0.013786316, 0.021408081, -0.0036296844, 0.031463623, 0.03692627, -0.0028152466, 0.0055351257, 0.026473999, -0.01902771, -0.027755737, -0.005847931, 0.028274536, 0.012229919, 0.019470215, 0.026931763, -0.0020542145, 0.036499023, 0.0007648468, 0.0030899048, -0.033569336, -0.012008667, -0.0051612854, -0.0006480217, -0.06665039, -0.021911621, -0.0005350113, 0.0093688965, -0.013847351, 0.031066895, 0.022827148, -0.010139465, -0.050811768, 0.01348114, 0.00945282, -0.013191223, 0.035461426, 0.002922058, 0.030456543, -0.012710571, -0.018569946, -0.0413208, -0.026992798, -0.00033950806, 0.030227661, 0.018569946, -0.03149414, 0.005783081, 0.025009155, 0.056762695, 0.03488159, -0.02255249, -0.04473877, -0.013504028, -0.010375977, -0.021575928, 0.029724121, 0.012496948, -0.0048942566, -0.031311035, 0.020584106, -0.023910522, 0.016952515, 0.0064697266, 0.037841797, -0.0637207, 0.0814209, -0.048065186, 0.036254883, 0.019302368, -0.0211792, 0.00881958, 0.0031776428, -0.039245605, 0.014968872, 0.020187378, 0.046783447, 0.0073509216, 0.010536194, 0.06072998, 0.002840042, 0.032318115, 0.0044555664, -0.029129028, 0.039489746, 0.013389587, 0.025146484, -0.009239197, -0.0035438538, -0.039978027, 0.0021381378, 0.030532837, 0.04321289, -0.014732361, 0.05609131, -0.028625488, 0.034301758, 0.015914917, -0.022109985, 0.008102417, -0.03125, 0.015853882, -0.06008911, -0.05709839, -0.0075416565, 0.047851562, -0.029205322, -0.003610611, -0.018341064, 0.020202637, 0.030136108, 0.053985596, 0.040618896, 0.0006170273, -0.016738892, -0.028335571, -0.01285553, -0.030822754, -0.06097412, 0.012336731, 0.020401001, 0.016555786, -0.050201416, 0.026519775, -0.07501221, 0.007499695, 0.001909256, 0.004890442, -0.011566162, -0.08496094, 0.034057617, 0.039733887, 0.031280518, 0.018600464, -0.004722595, 0.021530151, 0.051208496, 0.041748047, 0.024719238, 0.028961182, 0.036865234, -0.016403198, 0.017959595, -0.00068569183, 0.02973938, 0.021011353, 0.03967285, 0.0124435425, 0.021530151, -0.054626465, 0.024612427, 0.011489868, 0.011451721, 0.021606445, -0.05895996, 0.0003669262, -0.00042891502, 0.009239197, 0.030227661, -0.005065918, -0.03265381, -0.0038013458, 0.014129639, -0.03164673, 0.0059394836, 0.027679443, -0.03250122, -0.0126953125, 0.02029419, -0.012672424, -0.002281189, 0.019882202, -0.0014801025, -0.030853271, 0.0152282715, 0.020523071, -0.0513916, 0.009170532, -0.008674622, 0.014030457, 0.041046143, 0.009628296, -0.026992798, -0.0088272095, 0.015945435, -0.05596924, 0.0018310547, 0.020721436, 0.026504517, -0.01525116, -0.013832092, -0.005672455, -0.0025672913, -0.022033691, 0.019607544, 0.020904541, -0.030761719, 0.036132812, 0.015991211, 0.023544312, -0.000014603138, -0.01725769, 0.018722534, -0.0046463013, -0.010108948, -0.048034668, 0.020370483, 0.012481689, -0.013786316, 0.0124435425, -0.038604736, 0.014556885, 0.009132385, -0.0039367676, -0.044891357, -0.011039734, 0.02279663, -0.040649414, -0.003522873, -0.025665283, 0.060333252, -0.046905518, -0.025131226, -0.0049476624, 0.00041770935, -0.026229858, 0.068237305, -0.020248413, -0.027114868, -0.03756714, -0.03564453, -0.027618408, -0.006164551, 0.022827148, -0.0049552917, 0.011482239, -0.021942139, 0.0018348694, 0.0042915344, -0.016586304, -0.0073165894, 0.03717041, 0.024993896, 0.00041532516, -0.044006348, -0.028930664, -0.020187378, -0.00945282, 0.020385742, 0.031173706, 0.020996094, 0.012580872, -0.02609253, -0.018569946, -0.0071525574, -0.03930664, 0.046417236, -0.02671814, -0.024597168, 0.043273926, -0.039245605, 0.049865723, 0.032684326, 0.029556274, 0.042510986, 0.021453857, 0.017120361, -0.0016975403, 0.005470276, -0.042755127, 0.007297516, -0.026901245, -0.04626465, -0.066711426, -0.030471802, -0.05065918, 0.0066184998, -0.0052757263, 0.0013170242, 0.021987915, 0.0024795532, 0.00699234, -0.0096588135, 0.035858154, -0.0031471252, 0.041748047, 0.03491211, 0.0045166016, 0.011772156, 0.0014629364, -0.0031223297, 0.032928467, 0.012023926, -0.014526367, -0.011116028, -0.032684326, 0.019012451, 0.006954193, -0.007411957, -0.014953613, -0.0067749023, -0.051818848, 0.021438599, -0.021591187, 0.0317688, 0.05819702, 0.0067749023, 0.054504395, -0.028427124, -0.019119263, 0.023986816, -0.031173706, 0.0017728806, 0.05078125, -0.05657959, -0.014656067, -0.015838623, 0.001789093, 0.0007119179, 0.028198242, 0.03439331, -0.072143555, -0.061035156, 0.0065231323, 0.0317688, 0.014633179, 0.007335663, -0.0259552, 0.001964569, 0.035888672, 0.047698975, 0.016647339, 0.039886475, -0.0062713623, 0.0019779205, -0.042388916, -0.03970337, 0.007701874, 0.03656006, -0.02923584, 0.021453857, -0.048950195, 0.027328491, -0.043762207, -0.044799805, -0.003271103, 0.00021529198, -0.07141113, -0.040039062, 0.037231445, 0.036193848, 0.027328491, 0.047668457, -0.019882202, -0.02645874, 0.028182983, -0.06842041, 0.0076408386, 0.026672363, -0.014350891, 0.041778564, -0.04824829, -0.035003662, 0.05328369, -0.038360596, 0.06347656, -0.053619385, 0.008865356, -0.035583496, 0.044647217, 0.0061912537, -0.060760498, -0.026016235, -0.0138168335, -0.040771484, -0.0061683655, -0.0041618347, -0.017303467, -0.045074463, -0.020477295, 0.025146484, 0.012382507, -0.016311646, -0.005744934, -0.024993896, -0.10498047, -0.037139893, -0.030059814, -0.010070801, -0.026031494, -0.01737976, -0.018066406, -0.0048217773, -0.01826477, -0.010154724, -0.009422302, -0.022964478, -0.050231934, -0.033172607, 0.017211914, 0.0022029877, -0.013465881, 0.019882202, 0.008796692, 0.016036987, -0.0027198792, 0.02684021, 0.02859497, -0.05859375, -0.022705078, 0.02432251, -0.030700684, 0.039642334, -0.0029792786, 0.007472992, -0.0064697266, 0.048919678, -0.03479004, -0.024536133, -0.002571106, 0.048583984, -0.0066871643, -0.07678223, 0.0385437, 0.017486572, 0.041046143, -0.011909485, -0.014656067, 0.036346436, -0.02407837, -0.02508545, 0.0791626, 0.037475586, 0.02418518, 0.029067993, 0.021118164, 0.014907837, -0.060699463, -0.068359375, -0.03552246, 0.043518066, 0.04522705, 0.0012693405, -0.025863647, 0.05545044, -0.0126953125, -0.0021572113, -0.022720337, -0.012390137, -0.008018494, -0.012756348, 0.024536133, -0.008781433, 0.024795532, -0.0035896301, -0.020751953, 0.00749588, 0.0060577393, -0.02281189, 0.0031356812, -0.021881104, 0.06628418, -0.031433105, 0.0060806274, 0.014297485, -0.013137817, 0.026107788, 0.005821228, -0.0030517578, 0.024902344, -0.004146576, 0.0046577454, -0.0034675598, 0.019226074, 0.045196533, -0.04751587, 0.006690979, -0.027450562, -0.02961731, 0.06112671, -0.020599365, 0.036590576, -0.032226562, -0.0023727417, -0.029846191, -0.044952393, -0.023895264, -0.0016222, -0.0055122375, -0.07232666, -0.045196533, -0.058807373, 0.04309082, -0.002696991 ], "summary": [ 0.031051636, 0.004886627, -0.01637268, -0.03768921, -0.008239746, -0.012863159, -0.051940918, -0.035064697, 0.02104187, 0.0066337585, -0.041992188, -0.000061392784, 0.01977539, -0.017852783, -0.006916046, -0.041534424, 0.004787445, 0.0016880035, 0.0112838745, -0.03161621, 0.029022217, -0.035064697, 0.025497437, 0.010543823, 0.016845703, -0.0074882507, 0.0018262863, 0.017623901, 0.023422241, 0.0121536255, 0.012489319, -0.030227661, 0.03942871, 0.009246826, -0.018341064, -0.013557434, 0.0769043, -0.039794922, -0.022064209, 0.050872803, 0.031066895, -0.027877808, 0.09063721, -0.035949707, 0.047729492, 0.020690918, 0.040496826, -0.050811768, 0.012123108, 0.016845703, -0.019180298, -0.0019140244, -0.02180481, 0.03677368, -0.0206604, -0.019180298, -0.000916481, -0.038757324, 0.0079193115, 0.057861328, 0.01725769, -0.018920898, -0.0027999878, -0.05050659, 0.03717041, -0.03262329, 0.00014412403, 0.030715942, 0.041992188, 0.040130615, 0.0017738342, 0.009971619, 0.02583313, -0.03491211, 0.009986877, -0.009307861, -0.011131287, -0.014511108, 0.026412964, -0.010475159, 0.022750854, -0.03390503, 0.024459839, -0.022659302, 0.0413208, 0.02078247, -0.010223389, -0.014778137, 0.0038318634, 0.006504059, -0.008605957, 0.045959473, -0.008232117, 0.0072288513, 0.0062675476, -0.0234375, 0.0072898865, 0.012214661, 0.018005371, 0.016342163, 0.05368042, -0.050933838, 0.044158936, -0.039093018, -0.037200928, 0.05834961, 0.05001831, -0.0026874542, -0.052581787, -0.008766174, -0.0045204163, -0.068359375, 0.011199951, -0.042419434, 0.0076446533, 0.027328491, -0.0061187744, 0.038360596, 0.00045681, 0.023666382, -0.016616821, 0.030426025, -0.07318115, 0.005405426, 0.005508423, -0.015098572, 0.03668213, 0.022949219, -0.05871582, 0.034240723, 0.024658203, 0.035064697, -0.0058059692, 0.008071899, -0.04147339, 0.003189087, 0.022445679, 0.0022029877, -0.017913818, -0.027282715, 0.020950317, 0.024505615, 0.03378296, -0.019042969, -0.0209198, 0.030639648, 0.017318726, 0.012519836, -0.027450562, -0.029312134, -0.010284424, -0.022537231, 0.055114746, -0.019561768, -0.0904541, -0.061950684, -0.06738281, -0.02015686, -0.0020694733, -0.048614502, 0.017150879, 0.013908386, 0.03265381, 0.0345459, 0.030380249, -0.04345703, -0.04458618, 0.0020980835, 0.0076828003, -0.042785645, 0.0035324097, 0.012275696, 0.0012989044, -0.01436615, 0.014305115, 0.026763916, -0.0022640228, -0.008987427, 0.00856781, 0.02633667, 0.0035820007, -0.023742676, -0.035461426, 0.022628784, -0.0107040405, -0.060913086, 0.0060920715, 0.01210022, 0.057922363, 0.031921387, 0.0039901733, -0.04269409, -0.044921875, 0.019241333, -0.021484375, -0.005947113, 0.002632141, 0.017456055, -0.016662598, 0.00040459633, -0.012016296, 0.03994751, -0.0012083054, -0.004398346, -0.011100769, 0.039215088, -0.0002963543, 0.054351807, -0.017990112, 0.028259277, 0.023147583, -0.027877808, -0.0025596619, -0.0040779114, -0.011955261, -0.04159546, 0.024307251, -0.025741577, -0.042938232, 0.006072998, -0.059173584, -0.010276794, -0.06964111, 0.07281494, -0.0116119385, 0.00024330616, -0.021865845, 0.0011043549, 0.016601562, 0.014053345, 0.03967285, -0.006942749, -0.015548706, -0.018432617, -0.011528015, -0.020309448, -0.016021729, -0.10070801, 0.03213501, 0.060272217, 0.03793335, 0.01360321, -0.0023994446, -0.00027012825, -0.006198883, -0.05557251, 0.017456055, -0.013465881, -0.019058228, -0.018478394, 0.0012245178, -0.036010742, 0.050689697, -0.0390625, -0.0014867783, 0.033935547, -0.04196167, -0.02897644, 0.0035266876, 0.02458191, -0.007194519, -0.03289795, -0.0028438568, -0.02305603, 0.004272461, -0.0892334, -0.017623901, -0.032684326, 0.03982544, -0.07397461, -0.00025868416, -0.103027344, 0.0031604767, -0.026672363, -0.045959473, -0.09246826, 0.0234375, 0.020248413, -0.022949219, -0.068847656, 0.0033569336, 0.025390625, 0.08215332, 0.012527466, 0.007194519, 0.01309967, 0.047973633, -0.00491333, 0.027557373, 0.024963379, 0.070739746, -0.023010254, -0.009017944, -0.0038394928, -0.022460938, -0.045135498, -0.0055389404, 0.021652222, 0.014259338, -0.013977051, -0.019546509, 0.025390625, -0.0060043335, -0.021835327, 0.00037837029, 0.035491943, 0.008468628, -0.01965332, -0.026535034, -0.0014696121, -0.041870117, -0.017715454, 0.05053711, 0.01449585, 0.039367676, 0.027908325, 0.010246277, 0.087524414, 0.05050659, 0.07366943, 0.009086609, 0.038970947, 0.0440979, -0.0035629272, 0.054382324, -0.04458618, -0.008003235, -0.0016994476, -0.055847168, 0.008598328, 0.02154541, -0.025726318, -0.022338867, 0.024307251, 0.011192322, 0.04034424, 0.000852108, 0.11730957, 0.0033836365, -0.11218262, -0.04031372, -0.06188965, -0.031799316, 0.048309326, -0.0026111603, -0.02558899, 0.018936157, -0.012832642, 0.03543091, 0.020477295, -0.016555786, 0.0012931824, -0.023269653, 0.06536865, 0.012771606, -0.048858643, 0.032409668, 0.09185791, -0.008377075, 0.014564514, 0.05569458, 0.0025157928, 0.0012483597, -0.010665894, -0.0345459, -0.021652222, 0.042999268, -0.03744507, -0.0016698837, 0.01184845, -0.032928467, 0.0072288513, -0.037384033, -0.00083494186, 0.004219055, 0.024246216, 0.009803772, -0.021514893, 0.024871826, 0.0041275024, 0.022262573, 0.019515991, 0.042236328, 0.016220093, 0.054992676, 0.02154541, 0.04562378, 0.056640625, 0.016571045, -0.021697998, -0.022109985, -0.0027713776, 0.023269653, -0.04989624, -0.020004272, -0.0038604736, 0.0005068779, 0.0016889572, 0.052215576, -0.013847351, 0.05166626, 0.00793457, 0.032470703, 0.0023212433, -0.0713501, 0.049438477, -0.02810669, 0.0184021, -0.001452446, -0.03225708, 0.0078048706, -0.060913086, 0.029083252, -0.08117676, 0.052886963, -0.06518555, 0.05834961, 0.015487671, 0.012145996, -0.07159424, 0.008651733, -0.012527466, 0.026123047, -0.0052948, -0.0082092285, 0.006134033, 0.012069702, 0.02218628, -0.0032749176, 0.004142761, 0.010688782, -0.019805908, -0.015655518, 0.0051498413, -0.0033054352, -0.010467529, -0.011352539, -0.026931763, 0.031143188, -0.030181885, -0.039978027, -0.033172607, -0.022445679, 0.011665344, -0.042114258, 0.024871826, -0.00027775764, -0.038024902, -0.0006084442, -0.012886047, -0.03286743, 0.0034389496, 0.056030273, 0.027877808, -0.0038700104, 0.03692627, -0.005130768, -0.008590698, 0.027038574, -0.04248047, -0.053222656, 0.0015106201, -0.023742676, -0.04699707, -0.016067505, -0.027832031, -0.027374268, 0.026260376, -0.016418457, -0.014015198, -0.014152527, 0.0791626, 0.00856781, -0.0068130493, 0.012496948, 0.016098022, 0.0010900497, -0.010757446, 0.00957489, 0.007446289, 0.008399963, -0.010726929, 0.008468628, -0.023468018, -0.02722168, 0.019805908, -0.0993042, -0.003501892, 0.013000488, -0.035461426, 0.0052871704, 0.0006170273, 0.013755798, 0.002439499, -0.005012512, -0.047424316, -0.012649536, 0.02394104, -0.012809753, -0.062805176, -0.0002104044, 0.0068969727, 0.014930725, 0.04486084, -0.0034370422, 0.055603027, 0.035003662, -0.009765625, -0.021011353, -0.02468872, 0.022827148, -0.059143066, 0.016586304, 0.030273438, -0.03112793, 0.04736328, -0.009025574, 0.03527832, -0.005142212, -0.018188477, 0.06719971, 0.072753906, 0.007896423, 0.02734375, 0.01777649, -0.0345459, 0.014755249, -0.029846191, -0.021896362, -0.016540527, 0.025848389, 0.012870789, -0.03503418, 0.00031208992, 0.028167725, 0.0053367615, -0.012611389, -0.030349731, -0.023773193, 0.01348114, -0.018066406, -0.014450073, 0.021896362, 0.01638794, -0.009811401, 0.064819336, -0.011581421, 0.054138184, -0.013702393, 0.020492554, -0.015533447, -0.011238098, 0.004875183, -0.031311035, -0.012931824, 0.020065308, 0.010231018, -0.011627197, 0.0073051453, 0.034240723, 0.0027313232, 0.0032653809, -0.022109985, 0.0007019043, 0.039489746, 0.006904602, 0.035827637, -0.017059326, 0.014030457, -0.032196045, -0.049957275, -0.043121338, -0.0791626, -0.011360168, -0.02104187, 0.037719727, -0.038909912, -0.0065307617, 0.015777588, 0.050872803, -0.0015096664, 0.02041626, -0.03756714, -0.020965576, 0.009231567, -0.013420105, 0.0006594658, 0.0033988953, 0.007648468, 0.008766174, 0.02168274, -0.03326416, -0.030776978, 0.018966675, 0.051696777, -0.020706177, 0.060546875, -0.047302246, 0.02960205, 0.019943237, -0.017562866, 0.01007843, -0.0020637512, -0.0068626404, 0.032073975, 0.030883789, 0.0035858154, 0.03475952, -0.023498535, -0.0051193237, 0.008987427, 0.045928955, -0.019607544, -0.018844604, -0.01033783, 0.0057373047, 0.026870728, -0.015655518, 0.014801025, -0.017837524, 0.022735596, 0.017745972, 0.014060974, 0.0035171509, 0.010414124, -0.030807495, -0.003419876, 0.019729614, -0.020965576, -0.022399902, -0.008895874, -0.0024471283, -0.038848877, -0.079711914, -0.01651001, 0.084472656, -0.0093688965, -0.042633057, -0.02746582, -0.011833191, 0.008644104, 0.0039901733, -0.021606445, -0.023422241, -0.0027236938, -0.024261475, -0.022247314, -0.027740479, -0.0309906, -0.019134521, 0.025802612, 0.016845703, 0.017303467, -0.022827148, -0.028427124, -0.008911133, 0.0057640076, 0.027679443, -0.035247803, -0.009963989, 0.009727478, 0.028411865, -0.042114258, 0.026870728, 0.015991211, -0.008720398, 0.03491211, 0.038970947, -0.013557434, 0.00289917, 0.010475159, -0.007637024, -0.012939453, 0.000010609627, 0.034423828, 0.039489746, 0.025512695, 0.0289917, -0.012870789, -0.025009155, -0.011642456, 0.012916565, 0.054382324, 0.031280518, -0.037902832, 0.039245605, 0.02696228, -0.031280518, 0.03555298, 0.015510559, -0.024734497, -0.0102005005, 0.03326416, -0.026397705, -0.018417358, 0.018325806, -0.00011986494, -0.06341553, -0.030166626, -0.034484863, 0.035095215, -0.01210022, 0.0024337769, -0.030029297, -0.012084961, 0.007534027, -0.03515625, 0.007209778, 0.008728027, 0.028701782, -0.0045814514, -0.031829834, -0.037017822, -0.013534546, 0.028427124, 0.010261536, 0.027389526, 0.0024604797, -0.0067329407, 0.010765076, -0.0118637085, 0.043273926, 0.014785767, -0.03591919, 0.011650085, 0.01159668, -0.06304932, 0.020431519, 0.0022583008, -0.020492554, -0.0026378632, 0.007331848, -0.013366699, 0.008514404, -0.0022354126, -0.001045227, -0.003709793, 0.023635864, -0.008743286, 0.003921509, 0.007106781, -0.0152282715, 0.010444641, -0.019577026, -0.018707275, -0.015274048, 0.011161804, 0.012298584, -0.053253174, -0.04058838, 0.01008606, -0.027618408, -0.021621704, -0.024047852, 0.0154418945, -0.020751953, 0.025558472, -0.04119873, -0.03338623, -0.005748749, -0.03656006, -0.0023212433, -0.012931824, 0.015556335, -0.0025367737, -0.0035305023, -0.0063476562, -0.018112183, 0.043884277, -0.020721436, -0.033294678, -0.0104522705, 0.013679504, 0.035491943, 0.06604004, 0.008010864, -0.020401001, 0.021194458, -0.0016021729, 0.018127441, -0.0036125183, 0.039916992, 0.020217896, 0.007724762, -0.005443573, -0.018356323, 0.010681152, 0.0047454834, -0.018707275, -0.00004017353, 0.012191772, 0.04434204, 0.021636963, -0.037841797, -0.008926392, 0.027450562, 0.0067100525, -0.016540527, 0.0046806335, -0.0022239685, 0.011711121, -0.010848999, -0.050445557, -0.019973755, -0.030654907, 0.016525269, 0.0031433105, -0.0020503998, -0.006954193, 0.04547119, 0.001964569, 0.008300781, -0.011199951, -0.03375244, -0.014015198, 0.008338928, -0.016952515, -0.021865845, 0.005050659, 0.003572464, 0.0049552917, 0.03665161, 0.007320404, 0.002298355, 0.020339966, 0.014526367, 0.03945923, -0.036376953, -0.046539307, -0.08087158, 0.04812622, -0.05050659, 0.013389587, -0.012001038, 0.03353882, 0.03604126, -0.040161133, 0.13134766, -0.06185913, -0.02986145, -0.025177002, -0.0075645447, -0.036376953, -0.022445679, 0.01600647, -0.033081055, -0.017623901, 0.011703491, -0.031799316, 0.0892334, 0.023544312, 0.037475586, 0.0881958, -0.02041626, -0.018081665, -0.024169922, 0.009559631, -0.015068054, -0.016296387, 0.03100586, 0.015838623, 0.02720642, 0.078552246, 0.008483887, -0.019607544, -0.010787964, -0.02520752, -0.004634857, 0.016555786, -0.006855011, 0.02532959, -0.030715942, 0.0041275024, -0.022872925, -0.022369385, 0.025726318, -0.012786865, 0.035217285, -0.0017147064, 0.014602661, 0.030776978, 0.085754395, 0.053894043, -0.040771484, 0.021011353, 0.09320068, -0.036834717, 0.030593872, -0.014862061, 0.0115737915, -0.0076026917, -0.039611816, 0.002500534, 0.0022525787, 0.0051612854, 0.03479004, -0.04852295, -0.007621765, -0.07318115, 0.070739746, -0.067993164, -0.022094727, -0.010383606, -0.064697266, -0.02722168, 0.005191803, -0.023864746, -0.028244019, -0.0031490326, -0.04498291, -0.0061531067, 0.022247314, -0.020217896, 0.04171753, -0.034851074, -0.08105469, -0.01939392, 0.02519226, 0.020217896, 0.010360718, -0.026275635, 0.019424438, -0.012634277, -0.029190063, -0.024932861, 0.023727417, -0.057403564, -0.0435791, -0.01965332, -0.01184082, 0.0025596619, -0.027160645, 0.017303467, 0.042816162, 0.01537323, -0.0072784424, -0.00037240982, 0.007347107, -0.03265381, 0.0038070679, 0.01473999, -0.018066406, 0.018417358, 0.024398804, 0.020309448, 0.009399414, 0.068847656, -0.04083252, -0.018005371, -0.038604736, -0.024780273, 0.016021729, -0.029632568, 0.0012407303, -0.0028381348, 0.050964355, 0.0027503967, -0.08325195, 0.008712769, -0.042266846, -0.0149002075, -0.0025177002, -0.0054473877, 0.019302368, 0.036712646, 0.05340576, -0.00011712313, -0.039642334, -0.05947876, -0.025115967, 0.029663086, -0.008888245, -0.010971069, -0.035461426, 0.0178833, -0.020187378, 0.0020599365, -0.04522705, 0.023910522, 0.007850647, -0.023010254, 0.020492554, -0.031158447, 0.05090332, 0.040863037, 0.003042221, -0.008720398, -0.0057411194, -0.022323608, -0.011917114, -0.010604858, -0.019348145, 0.0061683655, 0.072143555, -0.024093628, -0.037719727, 0.04336548, -0.03326416, 0.021453857, 0.028305054, 0.0060272217, 0.028152466, -0.006263733, 0.028274536, 0.02760315, 0.01209259, -0.019042969, -0.015602112, -0.012550354, 0.046203613, 0.014091492, 0.02230835, -0.0074310303, -0.0104904175, 0.03744507, -0.047058105, 0.016204834, -0.005420685, 0.03643799, -0.038116455, 0.04232788, -0.03729248, 0.0026435852, 0.03189087 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1309.4714v1
Temporal-Difference Learning to Assist Human Decision Making during the Control of an Artificial Limb
Ann L. Edwards, Alexandra Kearney, Michael Rory Dawson, Richard S. Sutton, Patrick M. Pilarski
cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
In this work we explore the use of reinforcement learning (RL) to help with human decision making, combining state-of-the-art RL algorithms with an application to prosthetics. Managing human-machine interaction is a problem of considerable scope, and the simplification of human-robot interfaces is especially important in the domains of biomedical technology and rehabilitation medicine. For example, amputees who control artificial limbs are often required to quickly switch between a number of control actions or modes of operation in order to operate their devices. We suggest that by learning to anticipate (predict) a user's behaviour, artificial limbs could take on an active role in a human's control decisions so as to reduce the burden on their users. Recently, we showed that RL in the form of general value functions (GVFs) could be used to accurately detect a user's control intent prior to their explicit control choices. In the present work, we explore the use of temporal-difference learning and GVFs to predict when users will switch their control influence between the different motor functions of a robot arm. Experiments were performed using a multi-function robot arm that was controlled by muscle signals from a user's body (similar to conventional artificial limb control). Our approach was able to acquire and maintain forecasts about a user's switching decisions in real time. It also provides an intuitive and reward-free way for users to correct or reinforce the decisions made by the machine learning system. We expect that when a system is certain enough about its predictions, it can begin to take over switching decisions from the user to streamline control and potentially decrease the time and effort needed to complete tasks. This preliminary study therefore suggests a way to naturally integrate human- and machine-based decision making systems.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1309.4714v1
2013-09-18T17:29:03
2013-09-18T17:29:03
{ "title": [ 0.02671814, 0.010978699, -0.037261963, -0.03363037, 0.024856567, -0.043182373, 0.052642822, -0.006134033, -0.05105591, 0.015037537, -0.05206299, 0.041259766, -0.016708374, -0.0043907166, -0.004798889, -0.030563354, 0.013252258, 0.012611389, -0.026260376, -0.029830933, -0.024291992, -0.013885498, 0.024810791, 0.06945801, 0.027038574, -0.018630981, -0.10760498, 0.018493652, -0.02909851, -0.03543091, -0.006706238, 0.037109375, 0.033081055, 0.008865356, -0.0036811829, -0.024871826, -0.025344849, 0.019317627, -0.0135269165, 0.032348633, 0.0137786865, -0.01348114, -0.0769043, -0.0059928894, -0.06829834, 0.007663727, -0.051940918, -0.004119873, -0.038909912, 0.046051025, 0.017929077, -0.006713867, 0.020324707, 0.07336426, -0.0015325546, -0.034179688, -0.054351807, 0.0064888, 0.03604126, 0.05419922, 0.003604889, -0.03552246, 0.0040359497, -0.03741455, -0.007549286, -0.018188477, 0.02633667, 0.024734497, 0.0982666, 0.027313232, -0.047576904, 0.04888916, 0.014701843, 0.02911377, -0.031555176, -0.024993896, 0.044189453, 0.029571533, 0.022888184, -0.0038757324, -0.00019061565, -0.00079774857, 0.0146102905, -0.06124878, 0.023666382, -0.072631836, -0.004245758, 0.019515991, -0.05142212, -0.040863037, -0.02178955, 0.002532959, -0.024887085, -0.028030396, -0.040649414, -0.019683838, -0.021591187, -0.019515991, 0.0071029663, -0.0041122437, -0.0095825195, 0.00021183491, -0.004398346, -0.01146698, -0.010414124, -0.004535675, 0.021987915, -0.04196167, 0.008079529, 0.021652222, -0.0435791, 0.055755615, 0.022491455, -0.00089788437, -0.0044784546, -0.02482605, -0.024597168, 0.010940552, 0.02067566, -0.032684326, 0.0013227463, -0.00009471178, 0.014122009, 0.0031433105, 0.03741455, 0.018630981, -0.02658081, -0.020904541, 0.02432251, 0.039611816, 0.0035438538, 0.03564453, -0.09088135, -0.07647705, -0.066467285, 0.026275635, -0.005252838, 0.012245178, -0.0011196136, -0.03277588, 0.021957397, -0.013809204, -0.0043678284, 0.008422852, -0.013191223, 0.03543091, 0.029464722, -0.011062622, -0.03982544, -0.056640625, -0.017242432, -0.02394104, -0.01184082, 0.0079422, 0.008293152, -0.02178955, -0.100097656, -0.0047569275, 0.08929443, 0.021911621, 0.030181885, 0.012298584, -0.028701782, -0.0140686035, 0.02015686, -0.03967285, -0.021560669, 0.03237915, 0.012527466, 0.052337646, -0.012008667, -0.012901306, 0.0015420914, -0.022750854, -0.017532349, 0.016815186, -0.005718231, 0.011795044, 0.039123535, -0.0368042, -0.018432617, -0.026245117, 0.03768921, 0.009841919, -0.015304565, -0.040985107, -0.025131226, -0.050842285, 0.06530762, 0.0045204163, -0.054534912, 0.032226562, -0.04220581, -0.043762207, -0.056915283, 0.002193451, 0.029632568, 0.025970459, -0.024230957, 0.05380249, -0.07421875, 0.015197754, -0.042297363, 0.05819702, -0.016860962, -0.01890564, -0.008369446, 0.0061836243, -0.027618408, 0.048980713, 0.036712646, -0.0010509491, -0.029891968, 0.036987305, 0.011131287, -0.05529785, 0.01574707, -0.018844604, -0.009307861, -0.02658081, -0.018157959, 0.014976501, -0.013839722, 0.02758789, -0.006626129, 0.012413025, -0.02709961, -0.020965576, 0.024368286, 0.013473511, 0.06524658, -0.005794525, -0.016403198, -0.015960693, -0.014564514, -0.008148193, -0.019973755, -0.017074585, 0.012779236, 0.013832092, -0.010658264, -0.003545761, 0.0055007935, 0.052490234, 0.056274414, 0.015426636, 0.0033607483, 0.014984131, 0.0008406639, -0.024627686, 0.08508301, 0.0054626465, 0.045043945, 0.019836426, 0.021621704, 0.04837036, 0.0056648254, -0.005168915, -0.010047913, 0.02217102, -0.005607605, -0.006706238, 0.016845703, 0.0012998581, -0.016235352, -0.015426636, 0.0058250427, 0.0115737915, 0.014831543, -0.013908386, 0.03326416, -0.012802124, 0.011383057, -0.048614502, -0.04333496, -0.056152344, -0.013420105, 0.050354004, 0.024551392, -0.07952881, -0.022140503, 0.030883789, 0.018508911, -0.013725281, -0.005947113, -0.021713257, 0.026062012, -0.04043579, -0.0006828308, -0.0029449463, 0.056793213, -0.009712219, -0.021087646, -0.0050086975, -0.0016775131, -0.033721924, 0.016937256, 0.10595703, -0.042541504, 0.030059814, -0.09625244, -0.011291504, 0.006668091, -0.037841797, 0.0093688965, -0.013793945, -0.01687622, 0.027954102, -0.011688232, -0.001627922, -0.036590576, 0.055725098, 0.0068626404, -0.020401001, -0.004558563, -0.019012451, 0.017196655, -0.008964539, -0.013008118, 0.0048217773, 0.015014648, -0.027877808, 0.028442383, -0.012626648, 0.015777588, -0.043518066, -0.031402588, 0.006515503, -0.020996094, 0.021606445, 0.04034424, 0.03881836, -0.019577026, 0.027420044, 0.0025844574, 0.0016126633, -0.011695862, 0.05340576, -0.01235199, -0.0234375, -0.0067443848, -0.010848999, 0.006164551, -0.021774292, -0.032196045, -0.0012197495, -0.0259552, 0.010223389, 0.021499634, -0.0035705566, -0.0045394897, -0.012641907, -0.02482605, 0.03338623, 0.056640625, -0.042510986, 0.006248474, 0.06488037, 0.028656006, 0.025878906, 0.048950195, 0.013946533, 0.030578613, 0.013946533, -0.027496338, -0.06878662, 0.034606934, -0.0031642914, -0.010627747, 0.04321289, -0.06781006, 0.017105103, -0.03363037, -0.022567749, -0.003168106, 0.034973145, 0.0055274963, -0.023742676, -0.054504395, -0.021148682, 0.021835327, 0.013038635, -0.040222168, 0.0026130676, 0.05819702, -0.009147644, -0.021224976, -0.02696228, 0.06210327, 0.017333984, 0.019989014, -0.02909851, -0.0028915405, -0.0068893433, 0.039794922, -0.0024642944, -0.021194458, 0.009628296, -0.096069336, -0.003627777, 0.004966736, 0.014122009, -0.023895264, 0.027862549, -0.039276123, 0.03186035, 0.0008263588, -0.033996582, 0.0009794235, 0.06567383, -0.015602112, -0.0067749023, 0.020980835, -0.0209198, 0.02319336, -0.033203125, -0.046936035, 0.033081055, -0.026123047, -0.059509277, 0.014167786, -0.044708252, -0.038208008, -0.03161621, 0.011230469, 0.037353516, 0.051940918, -0.007232666, 0.039855957, -0.0025749207, 0.03869629, -0.032043457, -0.009490967, -0.03643799, -0.041809082, -0.008056641, -0.00092458725, 0.08270264, -0.0016851425, 0.00070858, -0.010040283, 0.0033550262, -0.0057029724, 0.01928711, 0.0061302185, -0.04751587, 0.003929138, -0.010894775, -0.020645142, -0.060302734, 0.00093889236, 0.008049011, 0.0038414001, -0.0017652512, 0.012306213, 0.070617676, 0.02166748, 0.023605347, 0.005996704, 0.001742363, 0.0158844, -0.024490356, -0.040893555, 0.02180481, -0.012809753, 0.014266968, 0.027236938, -0.0020046234, -0.01751709, -0.0061683655, -0.030456543, 0.021499634, -0.013000488, -0.0018444061, 0.004043579, -0.00484848, -0.025665283, 0.00504303, 0.004600525, 0.021499634, -0.0051345825, 0.018157959, -0.07147217, -0.056488037, -0.028457642, 0.0155181885, -0.07183838, -0.009674072, 0.022903442, -0.057495117, -0.04473877, -0.04937744, 0.013786316, -0.058044434, -0.036468506, 0.004558563, -0.0044784546, -0.0042800903, 0.025054932, -0.019729614, -0.052459717, 0.061431885, 0.00957489, -0.035247803, -0.007209778, -0.019927979, -0.0104522705, -0.026992798, 0.02281189, -0.025604248, 0.009712219, -0.0007247925, 0.026031494, 0.051208496, -0.0184021, -0.005683899, 0.057861328, 0.09185791, -0.027252197, -0.025894165, -0.011489868, 0.021072388, -0.03237915, 0.060058594, 0.018493652, -0.013282776, -0.06506348, 0.044403076, -0.016540527, -0.011985779, 0.013343811, -0.005542755, 0.0022411346, -0.008369446, 0.026565552, 0.044281006, 0.010314941, -0.019821167, 0.014930725, -0.0015277863, -0.022201538, -0.0018491745, 0.0048217773, 0.012634277, 0.0024757385, 0.021606445, 0.0005235672, 0.048950195, -0.017532349, -0.014625549, 0.008255005, 0.026855469, -0.058502197, -0.023529053, -0.03338623, -0.032409668, -0.020614624, 0.014480591, -0.020996094, 0.011779785, 0.026046753, 0.0068244934, -0.06021118, 0.009216309, -0.009788513, 0.006149292, -0.020858765, -0.036712646, -0.03765869, -0.005428314, -0.07269287, -0.03765869, -0.06567383, -0.016830444, -0.01890564, 0.005092621, -0.025039673, 0.009613037, 0.07110596, 0.13232422, 0.055419922, -0.018493652, -0.09033203, 0.023666382, -0.041931152, -0.019821167, 0.04864502, -0.021377563, -0.017501831, -0.027160645, 0.03665161, 0.00016009808, -0.016174316, -0.044189453, 0.026184082, -0.037872314, 0.048034668, 0.0009832382, 0.031707764, 0.03338623, -0.016662598, 0.016815186, 0.0051460266, -0.035705566, 0.043518066, 0.016082764, 0.033477783, -0.021820068, 0.002691269, 0.010246277, 0.027618408, -0.007133484, -0.0018320084, 0.017913818, 0.0056610107, 0.018951416, 0.008720398, 0.023071289, -0.0057678223, -0.017608643, 0.020568848, -0.019042969, 0.04135132, -0.02053833, 0.08319092, -0.030914307, -0.04623413, -0.0031433105, 0.0087509155, 0.020874023, -0.011329651, 0.01727295, -0.06530762, -0.0680542, -0.016403198, 0.07751465, -0.029052734, -0.017807007, -0.011817932, -0.0071792603, 0.024429321, 0.035339355, 0.023330688, -0.020187378, 0.007472992, -0.00819397, -0.00053071976, -0.0103302, -0.048065186, 0.007873535, 0.0140686035, 0.027160645, -0.019989014, 0.02911377, -0.060699463, 0.043792725, -0.018432617, -0.006729126, 0.007850647, -0.05581665, 0.005744934, 0.036987305, -0.014312744, 0.019302368, -0.001250267, 0.0124435425, 0.01676941, 0.03717041, -0.0063438416, 0.013656616, 0.03768921, -0.04623413, -0.0077323914, -0.027267456, -0.00016617775, 0.024398804, 0.028030396, 0.017471313, 0.048461914, -0.04675293, 0.041870117, 0.026901245, -0.017303467, -0.011528015, -0.030136108, 0.04916382, 0.010513306, -0.013458252, -0.0013151169, -0.040008545, -0.04675293, -0.0138549805, -0.03793335, -0.05834961, 0.03717041, -0.037139893, -0.03012085, -0.079956055, 0.012176514, -0.037506104, -0.0018644333, -0.013458252, 0.027755737, -0.027938843, 0.0056152344, 0.04006958, -0.040100098, 0.014579773, 0.0087509155, 0.023376465, 0.03189087, -0.030197144, -0.014350891, -0.0035076141, 0.016662598, -0.016433716, 0.0058631897, 0.018920898, 0.0035820007, -0.012962341, -0.018493652, 0.000058591366, -0.0025138855, -0.01991272, 0.01776123, 0.008041382, -0.051727295, 0.028396606, -0.008102417, -0.0045051575, 0.015563965, -0.007286072, 0.004497528, 0.0028839111, -0.0096588135, -0.000096559525, 0.022628784, -0.011138916, -0.0005955696, -0.0019435883, -0.050750732, 0.010215759, 0.022003174, -0.010032654, -0.021438599, 0.025650024, 0.030761719, -0.026885986, -0.0062217712, -0.0071907043, 0.05328369, -0.035369873, -0.021621704, -0.01826477, -0.011772156, -0.04107666, 0.04937744, 0.016113281, -0.026229858, -0.020523071, -0.012039185, -0.015914917, 0.017623901, 0.02330017, -0.019256592, 0.01991272, -0.054779053, -0.023864746, -0.010597229, 0.0029010773, -0.018844604, -0.01637268, 0.012680054, 0.00894928, 0.020202637, 0.02027893, 0.035095215, -0.06329346, 0.0109939575, -0.02255249, 0.016983032, -0.03274536, -0.02192688, 0.015167236, -0.019088745, 0.00894928, 0.029022217, -0.01499939, 0.012054443, 0.022644043, -0.04019165, 0.03793335, 0.010643005, 0.051818848, 0.020996094, 0.02420044, 0.0211792, 0.01991272, -0.011192322, -0.031280518, -0.016235352, -0.05429077, -0.046844482, -0.039031982, -0.020248413, -0.058380127, -0.033935547, 0.024353027, -0.002773285, 0.023330688, -0.009803772, 0.0062446594, 0.030670166, 0.027252197, 0.0107421875, 0.030441284, -0.0034980774, 0.007888794, -0.01727295, 0.016662598, 0.009162903, 0.023864746, 0.010803223, 0.031280518, 0.013420105, -0.0013103485, 0.0029449463, 0.0019292831, 0.011161804, -0.032226562, -0.00052309036, -0.019882202, 0.020629883, -0.019622803, -0.006210327, 0.059936523, 0.058502197, -0.053588867, 0.013938904, 0.03479004, -0.00031113625, -0.015792847, 0.013465881, 0.023712158, -0.041870117, 0.03930664, 0.0048217773, -0.039031982, -0.004776001, 0.05731201, -0.009475708, -0.0076828003, 0.0012159348, 0.0035057068, 0.0236969, 0.057128906, 0.017074585, -0.028289795, -0.032348633, 0.04663086, 0.044921875, -0.04067993, -0.0004863739, 0.010925293, -0.03149414, -0.021133423, -0.03286743, -0.035125732, 0.087402344, -0.075805664, 0.026229858, -0.013130188, 0.07141113, 0.023544312, -0.029022217, 0.026473999, 0.009689331, -0.047943115, 0.0126953125, 0.018859863, 0.025405884, 0.023284912, 0.06774902, -0.005607605, -0.006565094, -0.0040359497, -0.016296387, 0.029220581, 0.006175995, -0.024002075, -0.008926392, -0.016952515, -0.018829346, 0.033294678, -0.0029258728, 0.07574463, -0.030838013, 0.0035800934, -0.022232056, 0.0033664703, 0.03756714, -0.04019165, -0.053771973, -0.015686035, -0.015060425, 0.004085541, 0.019851685, -0.019592285, 0.0039749146, 0.015007019, -0.010322571, 0.037902832, 0.03213501, 0.027496338, -0.031341553, -0.07293701, 0.04425049, 0.00818634, 0.07165527, 0.0012407303, -0.03842163, -0.03237915, -0.0010070801, 0.015975952, 0.01537323, -0.023757935, 0.013763428, -0.037200928, -0.02229309, 0.0036907196, 0.014930725, 0.0022506714, 0.0597229, -0.01133728, 0.027252197, -0.0048446655, -0.0002834797, 0.009597778, -0.021453857, 0.014465332, 0.014968872, -0.054534912, 0.007041931, 0.017700195, -0.020309448, -0.0016479492, 0.014480591, -0.010185242, -0.02659607, -0.012710571, 0.027709961, -0.022964478, -0.036193848, 0.010215759, -0.009727478, 0.0035438538, -0.06506348, -0.07507324, -0.0014028549, 0.07495117, -0.014953613, 0.019943237, -0.026748657, -0.029647827, 0.035491943, 0.05999756, 0.0051078796, -0.03074646, -0.028533936, 0.0075798035, 0.034484863, 0.040161133, -0.019470215, 0.0036067963, 0.021881104, -0.018234253, -0.03010559, 0.006298065, 0.0015153885, -0.023773193, 0.023452759, 0.055725098, -0.0028266907, -0.0015172958, 0.01965332, 0.010375977, 0.014762878, 0.019897461, -0.022003174, 0.009529114, -0.0039749146, 0.0155181885, -0.032928467, -0.019805908, 0.03604126, 0.042053223, 0.02331543, 0.025543213, 0.000895977, 0.009559631, -0.018798828, 0.008346558, 0.004234314, 0.02053833, 0.034301758, -0.025146484, 0.024154663, -0.038208008, -0.0368042, 0.009216309, -0.016021729, 0.028625488, -0.034423828, 0.018371582, -0.020706177, -0.03692627, 0.0060310364, 0.02998352, 0.04714966, -0.005279541, -0.043914795, -0.007686615, 0.051696777, -0.048217773 ], "summary": [ 0.061645508, 0.013427734, 0.014717102, 0.014778137, -0.010566711, -0.036010742, 0.014961243, -0.050445557, -0.04949951, 0.012626648, -0.029693604, 0.010597229, -0.020111084, -0.023254395, 0.025466919, -0.057739258, 0.003271103, 0.021530151, 0.013893127, -0.030532837, 0.001540184, -0.03765869, 0.015007019, 0.025909424, 0.00092220306, 0.008033752, -0.06335449, 0.026641846, -0.010528564, 0.014152527, 0.0028800964, -0.0020828247, 0.002872467, -0.030166626, 0.05206299, -0.025100708, 0.017089844, -0.0037403107, 0.021972656, -0.0005187988, 0.034332275, -0.008842468, -0.013725281, -0.044799805, -0.022888184, 0.014450073, 0.012275696, -0.02229309, 0.011871338, 0.0491333, 0.01637268, 0.014442444, 0.008522034, 0.051940918, -0.011550903, -0.017807007, -0.034454346, -0.0033893585, 0.010475159, 0.103271484, 0.014839172, -0.0014600754, -0.023590088, -0.07598877, 0.0098724365, -0.009559631, 0.023330688, 0.017349243, 0.06732178, 0.017990112, -0.017288208, 0.029754639, -0.018112183, -0.0020885468, -0.034973145, 0.031433105, 0.027236938, 0.022644043, -0.020080566, 0.005420685, 0.006416321, 0.020599365, 0.010513306, -0.079589844, 0.047607422, -0.056549072, -0.003490448, 0.014480591, -0.047027588, 0.004032135, -0.039398193, 0.015945435, -0.047790527, 0.0019760132, 0.0019798279, -0.015075684, -0.030197144, -0.05545044, 0.030914307, 0.03387451, 0.023147583, -0.03857422, 0.06695557, -0.022338867, -0.0115737915, 0.04208374, 0.03918457, -0.04800415, -0.009651184, -0.0079956055, -0.02935791, 0.03805542, 0.030654907, 0.010765076, -0.029968262, -0.02645874, -0.008728027, 0.008148193, -0.02168274, -0.03152466, -0.011375427, 0.024414062, -0.023422241, 0.021530151, 0.015426636, 0.00856781, 0.008415222, -0.008728027, -0.016860962, 0.06359863, -0.0016469955, -0.004436493, -0.032409668, 0.018417358, -0.042388916, -0.016586304, 0.022155762, -0.0070266724, 0.01398468, -0.008682251, 0.036590576, -0.023971558, -0.027328491, 0.034179688, -0.0061798096, 0.04360962, 0.005126953, -0.0016536713, 0.00440979, -0.036590576, -0.00024020672, -0.031921387, -0.030853271, -0.00070619583, 0.05810547, -0.024414062, -0.036346436, 0.002588272, 0.09869385, 0.032287598, 0.0039634705, 0.008178711, 0.016586304, -0.022491455, -0.004207611, -0.03173828, -0.028717041, 0.019500732, 0.0067710876, 0.022125244, -0.00006788969, 0.0077400208, -0.024429321, -0.011253357, -0.004688263, -0.004322052, -0.015266418, 0.032562256, 0.0031490326, -0.023452759, -0.021820068, -0.053375244, 0.01676941, -0.008270264, 0.03366089, -0.013648987, -0.037506104, -0.052001953, 0.047821045, -0.0010566711, -0.059692383, 0.017700195, -0.008842468, -0.00035905838, 0.001074791, -0.0236969, 0.011634827, 0.013221741, -0.008338928, -0.0052833557, 0.0597229, -0.010971069, -0.019424438, -0.027801514, -0.11065674, -0.002532959, -0.03390503, 0.0052337646, -0.06112671, 0.035461426, 0.03262329, -0.031341553, -0.0385437, 0.05618286, 0.043060303, -0.03225708, 0.027694702, 0.0129776, 0.005306244, -0.01939392, 0.00039243698, -0.008110046, -0.010612488, 0.043151855, -0.040374756, -0.0031414032, -0.039764404, 0.017684937, -0.0141067505, 0.0034885406, 0.053100586, 0.008834839, -0.010818481, -0.00793457, -0.023971558, -0.0073623657, 0.0063552856, -0.03387451, 0.012649536, 0.027816772, 0.004261017, -0.0101623535, -0.0007314682, 0.042144775, 0.019348145, 0.01940918, 0.0037517548, 0.012870789, 0.001821518, -0.016723633, 0.04815674, -0.021743774, 0.030303955, -0.013084412, 0.050598145, 0.006954193, 0.0021133423, -0.02961731, 0.032226562, -0.019882202, 0.009902954, -0.045166016, -0.028259277, 0.0061073303, -0.0072250366, -0.014701843, -0.019836426, -0.0076789856, 0.00034165382, -0.0039024353, 0.024002075, -0.0289917, -0.010215759, -0.05783081, -0.013328552, -0.068481445, -0.049743652, 0.07067871, 0.04006958, -0.06976318, -0.006893158, -0.008705139, -0.02494812, -0.012397766, 0.0368042, -0.01373291, 0.0065307617, -0.002199173, 0.05807495, 0.058807373, 0.055358887, 0.01398468, 0.0025558472, 0.029708862, -0.0045204163, -0.013389587, -0.021026611, 0.04949951, -0.0010414124, -0.015594482, -0.035064697, 0.015716553, -0.027114868, -0.006587982, 0.0074501038, -0.018936157, -0.015579224, 0.030532837, 0.016418457, -0.03048706, 0.016586304, 0.051513672, 0.013450623, 0.047943115, -0.042907715, -0.0423584, -0.015342712, 0.035827637, -0.011138916, 0.012893677, 0.074279785, -0.018859863, 0.039489746, 0.0093688965, -0.0058021545, -0.055908203, 0.043121338, -0.00093126297, -0.04586792, 0.026550293, -0.004261017, 0.013465881, 0.0061416626, 0.064331055, -0.015434265, -0.0004911423, -0.0067710876, 0.1027832, 0.0038871765, -0.05831909, -0.022994995, -0.010101318, -0.012840271, 0.019805908, -0.03326416, 0.0030002594, -0.044403076, 0.0058898926, 0.021224976, -0.013259888, -0.00945282, -0.005214691, -0.019989014, 0.066467285, 0.015655518, -0.015037537, 0.0284729, 0.047821045, 0.00041770935, -0.0014944077, 0.055236816, 0.027999878, 0.035705566, -0.013641357, -0.036132812, -0.05731201, 0.04458618, -0.029571533, 0.0055618286, 0.052642822, -0.059509277, 0.045928955, -0.03463745, -0.01524353, -0.011558533, 0.046325684, 0.0826416, -0.0010309219, -0.0138168335, 0.03817749, 0.042053223, 0.030761719, -0.030258179, -0.012039185, 0.042419434, 0.007965088, 0.017944336, -0.001783371, 0.06726074, -0.0012273788, 0.018341064, -0.010398865, -0.0064353943, -0.009521484, 0.032165527, 0.0012683868, -0.032989502, 0.033996582, -0.07885742, -0.01398468, -0.007183075, 0.04196167, 0.015792847, 0.028442383, -0.02973938, 0.06604004, 0.0059661865, -0.020065308, 0.001868248, 0.016189575, 0.023880005, -0.03149414, 0.018936157, -0.010253906, 0.034698486, -0.04208374, 0.025405884, 0.018463135, -0.019622803, -0.035461426, 0.012626648, 0.0009608269, 0.008338928, -0.016159058, 0.014511108, 0.032684326, -0.00039196014, -0.01789856, 0.0032520294, 0.009689331, 0.0065994263, -0.020584106, 0.0052833557, -0.011619568, -0.0635376, 0.0061569214, 0.002565384, 0.047302246, 0.023468018, -0.043548584, -0.048950195, 0.009880066, 0.004524231, -0.006454468, 0.0033855438, -0.026367188, 0.02519226, -0.027908325, -0.06829834, -0.10449219, -0.016677856, 0.035949707, 0.03466797, 0.03756714, 0.054351807, 0.07110596, 0.020935059, 0.031707764, 0.070007324, -0.0289917, -0.0021858215, -0.006252289, -0.042114258, 0.013252258, 0.021728516, -0.014793396, -0.0041999817, 0.016693115, -0.0009946823, 0.008598328, 0.018447876, 0.011207581, -0.03894043, -0.010253906, -0.0009870529, -0.004211426, 0.014907837, 0.009185791, 0.029754639, -0.004878998, -0.034057617, 0.018493652, -0.04837036, -0.07208252, -0.035736084, 0.017318726, -0.07342529, -0.020339966, 0.005554199, -0.056671143, -0.010360718, -0.050628662, 0.049102783, -0.07928467, -0.024169922, -0.03149414, -0.020080566, 0.038482666, 0.014030457, -0.02204895, -0.0023651123, 0.0032653809, 0.04147339, -0.01108551, -0.034851074, 0.015525818, 0.020751953, -0.008430481, 0.014343262, -0.055114746, 0.016082764, -0.04623413, 0.12335205, 0.036193848, 0.011207581, 0.0012521744, 0.058502197, 0.10839844, -0.020385742, -0.03942871, 0.02406311, 0.064575195, -0.04296875, 0.018081665, 0.03692627, -0.008705139, -0.049591064, 0.043945312, -0.0045051575, -0.040374756, 0.019821167, 0.029312134, 0.014724731, 0.036376953, -0.010009766, 0.0017662048, 0.00655365, -0.029708862, -0.004333496, 0.018066406, -0.029754639, -0.015899658, 0.010871887, -0.002878189, -0.021209717, 0.007507324, -0.01802063, 0.021972656, -0.006187439, -0.034484863, 0.03982544, 0.04360962, -0.05014038, -0.056854248, -0.018829346, -0.036499023, -0.00116539, -0.0076408386, 0.0063476562, 0.0036373138, 0.002811432, -0.02218628, -0.024291992, 0.02760315, 0.00006747246, 0.012229919, -0.017868042, -0.036590576, -0.06237793, 0.008682251, -0.05822754, -0.016983032, -0.091308594, -0.049713135, -0.045654297, -0.00023245811, -0.046844482, 0.0037612915, 0.02798462, 0.123413086, 0.048980713, 0.0211792, -0.10369873, -0.027496338, -0.03955078, 0.015357971, 0.024047852, -0.019165039, -0.008995056, 0.012916565, 0.02748108, -0.008125305, -0.031829834, -0.020462036, -0.009246826, -0.005710602, 0.024368286, 0.028274536, 0.05429077, 0.011550903, -0.034118652, -0.0013895035, -0.007446289, -0.029907227, 0.04852295, 0.014923096, 0.0046310425, -0.023727417, 0.024841309, -0.0055503845, -0.005508423, -0.015319824, -0.014915466, 0.034362793, -0.00944519, -0.027740479, -0.024505615, 0.032470703, 0.040130615, 0.011260986, 0.03237915, -0.0005874634, 0.012535095, 0.026397705, 0.041412354, -0.006549835, -0.031555176, -0.00039052963, -0.0126953125, 0.017227173, -0.010284424, 0.0063705444, -0.04525757, -0.015716553, -0.0024318695, 0.031036377, -0.031555176, -0.035461426, -0.03439331, -0.03060913, 0.019165039, 0.014404297, -0.011947632, -0.025299072, -0.016464233, -0.003850937, -0.014930725, -0.024459839, -0.032562256, -0.03225708, 0.009819031, 0.025131226, 0.05050659, -0.009559631, -0.030014038, 0.01448822, -0.016906738, 0.0026664734, -0.0064964294, -0.037902832, -0.05831909, -0.017837524, -0.016677856, -0.0053710938, 0.010803223, -0.014717102, -0.024124146, 0.021316528, -0.036956787, -0.0121536255, 0.00705719, -0.039764404, -0.00040864944, -0.036224365, -0.007881165, 0.013824463, 0.0068130493, 0.021636963, 0.026672363, -0.02558899, 0.014549255, 0.025436401, 0.032318115, -0.052368164, -0.0057640076, 0.036865234, 0.009025574, 0.015167236, -0.027709961, -0.046417236, -0.06137085, -0.034210205, -0.04345703, -0.06903076, 0.021209717, -0.06982422, -0.018844604, -0.056640625, -0.0037784576, -0.028396606, -0.023910522, -0.0034656525, 0.07098389, 0.01876831, -0.017150879, 0.013313293, -0.034698486, 0.016098022, 0.05407715, 0.0496521, 0.016860962, -0.05368042, -0.03265381, -0.0036239624, -0.0029449463, -0.0059814453, -0.008918762, -0.021972656, -0.018920898, 0.044830322, -0.030853271, 0.023986816, 0.0041236877, -0.07110596, -0.008270264, -0.0058174133, -0.030395508, -0.008377075, -0.01889038, -0.0317688, 0.012084961, 0.023345947, -0.012756348, -0.0061912537, -0.007259369, 0.0034370422, 0.030807495, -0.0019483566, 0.017044067, 0.025222778, 0.011764526, 0.005367279, 0.035461426, 0.0033226013, -0.04006958, 0.024154663, 0.015655518, -0.03668213, 0.022155762, -0.014846802, 0.028961182, 0.009597778, 0.010818481, -0.0034294128, 0.014198303, -0.023544312, -0.0061683655, -0.012931824, 0.009567261, -0.009643555, -0.0006227493, 0.018539429, -0.006214142, -0.0049743652, -0.009178162, 0.0075302124, -0.026657104, -0.044952393, 0.028701782, 0.0036125183, 0.014175415, -0.030532837, 0.010383606, 0.03970337, -0.005744934, 0.051452637, 0.013648987, -0.043701172, 0.013427734, -0.017089844, 0.014892578, 0.007801056, 0.034820557, 0.008033752, -0.01159668, 0.027908325, 0.014450073, 0.0040664673, 0.015556335, -0.0007414818, -0.024597168, 0.036254883, 0.019210815, 0.0044288635, -0.0037593842, -0.019897461, 0.016403198, 0.0149002075, 0.01739502, -0.024414062, -0.0077934265, -0.027435303, -0.04937744, -0.01939392, -0.024551392, -0.009223938, -0.003929138, -0.0022888184, -0.028274536, 0.05532837, -0.014465332, 0.0052452087, 0.043945312, -0.018112183, 0.026351929, -0.00630188, 0.026062012, -0.005558014, 0.007949829, 0.023864746, -0.005695343, 0.027297974, 0.0071411133, 0.035949707, -0.004508972, -0.004989624, 0.052215576, -0.014770508, -0.046722412, -0.04901123, 0.03314209, -0.05706787, 0.014282227, -0.012886047, 0.013397217, 0.034484863, 0.058410645, -0.03930664, 0.023849487, 0.04458618, -0.005722046, -0.0033683777, 0.029174805, 0.011833191, 0.028900146, 0.036468506, -0.0021820068, -0.043792725, 0.0309906, 0.055755615, 0.018157959, -0.0026493073, 0.022918701, 0.0016851425, 0.014266968, 0.016433716, 0.012306213, -0.03479004, -0.033966064, 0.0046539307, -0.001625061, -0.025894165, 0.0034751892, 0.020462036, -0.016235352, -0.01687622, 0.016296387, -0.06890869, 0.094177246, -0.10449219, 0.01612854, -0.009361267, 0.05050659, 0.0061454773, -0.0181427, 0.02935791, 0.029571533, -0.03677368, 0.03262329, 0.012321472, -0.011100769, 0.024383545, 0.04434204, -0.0016088486, 0.016525269, -0.020050049, -0.013626099, 0.007801056, -0.023620605, -0.017410278, -0.037078857, 0.006526947, 0.009735107, 0.016967773, 0.022064209, 0.043304443, -0.030975342, -0.035949707, -0.012588501, -0.014266968, -0.0020046234, 0.015449524, -0.025878906, -0.0513916, -0.019897461, 0.032409668, 0.06414795, -0.011695862, 0.051635742, 0.015586853, -0.06524658, 0.06695557, 0.037719727, 0.06384277, -0.0473938, -0.011932373, 0.02835083, 0.04840088, 0.0715332, 0.011299133, -0.036468506, 0.009719849, 0.011909485, 0.012809753, -0.023773193, -0.04119873, 0.045532227, 0.03881836, -0.031829834, 0.02168274, 0.026565552, -0.0010261536, 0.03491211, -0.018951416, 0.024673462, -0.010513306, 0.0049591064, -0.0005221367, 0.0050201416, -0.004623413, 0.0003619194, -0.057128906, -0.020980835, -0.010528564, -0.026916504, 0.027832031, 0.0042686462, -0.012283325, -0.045959473, -0.019577026, -0.011695862, -0.0073242188, -0.015914917, -0.010696411, -0.007598877, 0.011543274, -0.05279541, -0.041229248, 0.005393982, 0.043304443, -0.00969696, -0.026947021, -0.042388916, -0.021835327, 0.062072754, 0.060699463, 0.010620117, -0.009117126, -0.038024902, 0.015563965, 0.078125, 0.010253906, -0.034423828, 0.0005097389, 0.0074501038, -0.039245605, -0.059143066, -0.041931152, 0.056427002, -0.053894043, 0.022277832, 0.014556885, -0.037353516, -0.022384644, 0.027114868, -0.03100586, 0.0048446655, -0.008361816, -0.025390625, -0.003540039, -0.032928467, -0.0000052452087, 0.0048980713, 0.021697998, -0.013473511, -0.02859497, 0.031463623, -0.013084412, 0.033721924, 0.0012903214, -0.0051727295, 0.016479492, -0.005207062, 0.033081055, 0.035858154, -0.0107421875, 0.0143585205, -0.040283203, -0.013755798, -0.038635254, -0.000073850155, -0.009605408, -0.026870728, 0.015899658, 0.018081665, -0.037963867, 0.016937256, 0.033111572, 0.032440186, 0.030517578, 0.017196655, 0.018630981, 0.018203735, -0.010955811 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1311.6594v2
Auto-adaptative Laplacian Pyramids for High-dimensional Data Analysis
Ángela Fernández, Neta Rabin, Dalia Fishelov, José R. Dorronsoro
cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Non-linear dimensionality reduction techniques such as manifold learning algorithms have become a common way for processing and analyzing high-dimensional patterns that often have attached a target that corresponds to the value of an unknown function. Their application to new points consists in two steps: first, embedding the new data point into the low dimensional space and then, estimating the function value on the test point from its neighbors in the embedded space. However, finding the low dimension representation of a test point, while easy for simple but often not powerful enough procedures such as PCA, can be much more complicated for methods that rely on some kind of eigenanalysis, such as Spectral Clustering (SC) or Diffusion Maps (DM). Similarly, when a target function is to be evaluated, averaging methods like nearest neighbors may give unstable results if the function is noisy. Thus, the smoothing of the target function with respect to the intrinsic, low-dimensional representation that describes the geometric structure of the examined data is a challenging task. In this paper we propose Auto-adaptive Laplacian Pyramids (ALP), an extension of the standard Laplacian Pyramids model that incorporates a modified LOOCV procedure that avoids the large cost of the standard one and offers the following advantages: (i) it selects automatically the optimal function resolution (stopping time) adapted to the data and its noise, (ii) it is easy to apply as it does not require parameterization, (iii) it does not overfit the training set and (iv) it adds no extra cost compared to other classical interpolation methods. We illustrate numerically ALP's behavior on a synthetic problem and apply it to the computation of the DM projection of new patterns and to the extension to them of target function values on a radiation forecasting problem over very high dimensional patterns.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1311.6594v2
2014-05-20T10:17:31
2013-11-26T09:03:10
{ "title": [ -0.020248413, 0.0051193237, -0.041046143, -0.036254883, 0.013931274, -0.01071167, -0.021438599, -0.01335907, -0.00028896332, 0.016189575, 0.002855301, -0.012382507, -0.022094727, -0.018127441, -0.041809082, -0.011894226, 0.025894165, -0.0074768066, -0.018966675, -0.030059814, -0.025115967, -0.03555298, 0.08294678, 0.048431396, 0.030456543, -0.0037937164, -0.07550049, 0.0074882507, -0.0036563873, -0.014770508, -0.012268066, -0.011520386, 0.0340271, 0.037261963, -0.00068950653, 0.041168213, -0.05996704, 0.04611206, 0.013954163, 0.011520386, -0.0023841858, 0.0075302124, -0.03213501, -0.032226562, -0.036712646, 0.016571045, -0.07965088, -0.027282715, -0.0060577393, 0.013702393, 0.012962341, 0.01473999, -0.011016846, 0.028915405, 0.01727295, -0.014190674, -0.02078247, -0.00995636, 0.034301758, 0.07885742, 0.025299072, -0.053863525, 0.0021095276, -0.04260254, -0.046722412, -0.013267517, -0.040100098, 0.011871338, 0.07208252, -0.01637268, -0.009552002, 0.02960205, -0.0008945465, 0.00983429, -0.022918701, -0.01878357, 0.037200928, 0.011741638, 0.030548096, -0.006942749, -0.014328003, -0.02456665, 0.021484375, -0.023345947, 0.03250122, -0.013412476, -0.031982422, -0.007850647, -0.017303467, -0.08123779, 0.0007200241, -0.03189087, -0.019882202, 0.00592041, -0.023345947, -0.047576904, -0.041809082, -0.0041770935, -0.0033245087, 0.0045928955, 0.027511597, -0.019973755, 0.019088745, -0.017211914, 0.011161804, 0.024612427, -0.026916504, -0.066101074, 0.014030457, 0.04257202, 0.005455017, 0.013511658, 0.03289795, 0.009849548, -0.0018424988, -0.01991272, 0.003900528, 0.040374756, 0.025283813, 0.020477295, -0.0049972534, -0.017181396, -0.017089844, -0.0028533936, 0.024475098, -0.0003578663, -0.041168213, 0.016204834, -0.009773254, 0.026855469, 0.004009247, 0.015396118, -0.08959961, -0.035125732, -0.033966064, 0.033416748, 0.0020713806, 0.0048828125, 0.0047416687, -0.023117065, 0.03213501, -0.027740479, -0.031707764, 0.015083313, -0.021331787, -0.0005950928, 0.06713867, 0.015731812, -0.07470703, -0.05029297, -0.008529663, 0.046569824, 0.037017822, -0.0026168823, -0.05645752, 0.0038089752, -0.10333252, -0.0143966675, -0.008522034, 0.0053520203, 0.0038452148, -0.012611389, -0.022888184, 0.0016231537, 0.022216797, 0.011772156, -0.022216797, 0.01739502, 0.021240234, 0.021957397, 0.012413025, 0.017944336, 0.0647583, 0.010734558, -0.0072402954, 0.007007599, 0.027618408, 0.016113281, 0.0357666, -0.017089844, 0.034118652, -0.010475159, -0.011161804, 0.07562256, -0.041107178, -0.002538681, -0.007789612, 0.018508911, 0.04144287, 0.023910522, -0.09301758, 0.012878418, -0.054656982, -0.013381958, -0.01448822, -0.03036499, 0.06304932, 0.018356323, 0.014381409, -0.028045654, -0.038635254, -0.0061836243, -0.04574585, 0.0035362244, -0.015731812, -0.03491211, -0.00522995, 0.022979736, 0.018035889, 0.04748535, 0.04345703, 0.0001912117, -0.015464783, -0.0035858154, -0.030715942, -0.06512451, 0.045135498, -0.029388428, -0.010925293, -0.014678955, -0.029067993, 0.01084137, -0.028900146, 0.06329346, -0.0044403076, -0.030212402, 0.023773193, -0.048919678, 0.053588867, -0.015838623, 0.0803833, -0.02923584, -0.018112183, -0.016494751, 0.0047912598, 0.00096178055, -0.0031547546, 0.021194458, 0.018249512, -0.0037612915, -0.007675171, -0.009254456, -0.02444458, 0.020080566, 0.06097412, 0.02192688, -0.0035305023, 0.031280518, 0.0154800415, -0.013656616, 0.054504395, 0.026412964, 0.0637207, 0.021759033, 0.0032043457, 0.08935547, 0.0016069412, 0.046051025, -0.028625488, 0.020309448, -0.027252197, 0.021194458, 0.030807495, -0.004398346, -0.01373291, -0.00022268295, -0.0015172958, 0.013031006, -0.0064430237, 0.021072388, 0.027038574, -0.0044937134, 0.006504059, -0.029769897, -0.027893066, -0.0038452148, 0.0031986237, 0.02230835, -0.0054359436, -0.067993164, -0.015289307, -0.0022258759, 0.026870728, 0.0024375916, 0.03302002, -0.008491516, 0.015472412, -0.012619019, 0.0067367554, -0.0038585663, 0.052612305, 0.017196655, -0.0019721985, 0.0061035156, -0.0003042221, -0.0032749176, 0.078552246, 0.09869385, -0.041656494, 0.047912598, -0.027160645, 0.003704071, -0.014434814, -0.0035305023, -0.017715454, 0.072021484, -0.004047394, 0.00730896, -0.03753662, -0.0143585205, -0.0385437, -0.005584717, 0.0070266724, -0.0047073364, -0.054473877, -0.06829834, -0.009254456, -0.043426514, -0.055603027, -0.06530762, 0.09265137, -0.021255493, -0.041900635, -0.028549194, -0.01184082, -0.028945923, -0.017501831, -0.033355713, -0.030517578, 0.01449585, 0.013381958, -0.006965637, -0.054016113, -0.02130127, -0.023635864, -0.0057678223, -0.023956299, -0.013442993, -0.025619507, 0.02319336, 0.015686035, 0.011619568, 0.051696777, -0.043670654, -0.0079956055, -0.002588272, 0.006351471, 0.036712646, -0.010154724, -0.0005221367, 0.01399231, -0.041900635, -0.06707764, 0.0034732819, 0.034698486, -0.03942871, 0.005378723, 0.043670654, 0.021896362, -0.006427765, 0.028656006, 0.013542175, 0.004032135, -0.016662598, -0.00749588, -0.070129395, -0.007347107, -0.011177063, 0.0024528503, 0.06225586, -0.07385254, 0.0037727356, -0.013160706, -0.0042533875, 0.020584106, 0.021606445, -0.010948181, -0.03604126, -0.01008606, -0.015365601, 0.015174866, 0.032989502, -0.025268555, 0.024017334, 0.10632324, -0.014343262, -0.016342163, -0.011398315, 0.06121826, 0.025878906, -0.027709961, -0.059692383, -0.009552002, -0.003435135, 0.021194458, 0.015777588, 0.010856628, 0.013587952, -0.08660889, -0.017730713, 0.030776978, -0.0027217865, -0.009025574, 0.007888794, -0.05508423, 0.015281677, -0.023254395, -0.0037002563, 0.03540039, 0.06890869, -0.021148682, 0.032958984, 0.012741089, -0.018066406, 0.0045394897, -0.0058021545, -0.060668945, 0.030639648, -0.0037994385, -0.058258057, -0.02519226, -0.01524353, -0.060272217, -0.029388428, -0.0140686035, 0.040161133, 0.02166748, 0.05038452, 0.00036978722, -0.044281006, -0.009902954, -0.058807373, -0.025131226, -0.03527832, -0.005428314, -0.01965332, -0.0178833, 0.064331055, -0.008384705, 0.011238098, -0.008056641, -0.0071029663, -0.024627686, 0.033721924, -0.008239746, -0.056793213, 0.012184143, -0.019485474, 0.019836426, 0.028808594, -0.021377563, -0.009902954, -0.03074646, -0.0000150203705, -0.038726807, -0.011054993, 0.0031013489, -0.008399963, -0.032104492, -0.003660202, -0.009384155, -0.012680054, -0.037597656, -0.0019950867, 0.035949707, 0.009506226, 0.0016889572, -0.0027637482, -0.0051612854, -0.0033073425, -0.012908936, 0.008491516, -0.0033493042, -0.0020427704, -0.008804321, 0.012664795, -0.007896423, 0.025756836, -0.02607727, 0.003944397, 0.012893677, -0.0048332214, -0.012504578, -0.08258057, 0.014579773, 0.005680084, -0.1116333, -0.020187378, 0.01864624, -0.033996582, -0.023635864, -0.045288086, 0.012908936, 0.0053596497, -0.016860962, -0.020812988, -0.023956299, -0.026367188, 0.0017747879, -0.0826416, -0.009681702, 0.064453125, -0.0016174316, 0.01637268, 0.0030117035, -0.0025978088, -0.0019264221, -0.031707764, -0.000975132, -0.01247406, 0.029846191, -0.011886597, 0.018737793, 0.03765869, -0.027664185, 0.005180359, 0.011550903, 0.021560669, -0.022705078, 0.00522995, -0.0008401871, 0.018829346, -0.012748718, 0.046539307, 0.0045051575, 0.00970459, -0.07299805, 0.018066406, -0.01108551, 0.016311646, 0.015197754, 0.0158844, 0.024047852, 0.0069122314, 0.006340027, 0.011688232, -0.0118255615, 0.015098572, 0.056915283, -0.023239136, -0.003780365, 0.009742737, 0.017211914, 0.02116394, 0.016921997, 0.022338867, 0.012107849, 0.045074463, -0.009857178, -0.029327393, -0.015563965, 0.015975952, -0.02507019, 0.0070762634, -0.046142578, -0.08166504, -0.033111572, 0.010414124, -0.00047278404, 0.017074585, 0.042785645, 0.023223877, -0.02861023, -0.02772522, 0.03668213, -0.00025367737, 0.0063323975, -0.04937744, 0.017333984, -0.02128601, -0.03161621, -0.030944824, 0.021652222, -0.018814087, 0.034210205, -0.019927979, -0.009880066, 0.013473511, 0.03765869, 0.06750488, 0.048553467, -0.024139404, -0.06286621, -0.0022697449, -0.0095825195, -0.013687134, 0.0289917, 0.0010728836, -0.0036849976, -0.008918762, 0.0069274902, -0.025375366, -0.019119263, -0.023208618, 0.0017671585, -0.016555786, 0.027267456, 0.029312134, 0.07574463, 0.028900146, -0.004650116, 0.006252289, 0.022537231, -0.048217773, -0.032562256, 0.00856781, 0.018814087, -0.020492554, 0.013412476, 0.049804688, 0.000688076, -0.051727295, 0.044158936, 0.02722168, 0.047790527, -0.015434265, -0.01878357, 0.028335571, -0.055786133, -0.030776978, -0.0020618439, -0.0037784576, 0.05834961, -0.057556152, 0.008041382, -0.0007314682, 0.02986145, 0.051513672, -0.024093628, -0.0024814606, 0.028427124, -0.004764557, -0.0690918, -0.082458496, -0.024719238, 0.07672119, -0.030548096, -0.01285553, 0.0116119385, 0.034698486, -0.011657715, 0.042266846, 0.021057129, 0.004753113, -0.025512695, -0.041656494, -0.019332886, -0.0309906, -0.038146973, 0.03253174, 0.030258179, 0.016860962, -0.03286743, -0.030181885, -0.0715332, -0.006385803, -0.001414299, 0.0013580322, -0.004550934, -0.06311035, 0.012313843, 0.048919678, 0.0012187958, 0.029022217, -0.021118164, 0.026687622, 0.029266357, 0.026031494, 0.027816772, 0.010292053, 0.02508545, -0.0007915497, 0.027893066, -0.023284912, -0.016296387, 0.0057296753, 0.033691406, -0.017089844, 0.019973755, -0.035308838, 0.034851074, 0.002199173, -0.026031494, 0.03378296, -0.05117798, 0.004627228, -0.007587433, -0.0059127808, 0.046051025, -0.0041885376, -0.021453857, -0.01612854, 0.004486084, -0.053833008, 0.002632141, 0.04788208, -0.03074646, -0.057617188, 0.012641907, -0.013679504, 0.017333984, -0.015274048, 0.033203125, -0.03918457, 0.057159424, 0.01083374, -0.03201294, -0.046325684, 0.006893158, 0.013839722, 0.02079773, 0.02923584, -0.0579834, -0.012672424, -0.039794922, -0.05166626, -0.04486084, 0.0018796921, 0.025344849, 0.020248413, -0.01360321, 0.011131287, 0.029434204, -0.030700684, 0.02357483, 0.010177612, -0.032440186, 0.012763977, -0.00011944771, -0.00541687, -0.006668091, 0.021713257, 0.0032844543, -0.0057678223, 0.0058631897, -0.039123535, 0.02558899, -0.021194458, -0.013923645, 0.023712158, -0.08282471, 0.033233643, -0.0013027191, -0.0012369156, -0.021591187, 0.015060425, 0.028411865, 0.0020542145, 0.022506714, 0.014472961, 0.08215332, -0.035339355, -0.06774902, -0.013114929, -0.006401062, -0.0155181885, 0.06262207, -0.0051879883, -0.04928589, -0.017501831, -0.07019043, -0.034332275, 0.006752014, 0.051116943, 0.0345459, 0.057250977, -0.039123535, 0.019714355, -0.036376953, -0.026397705, -0.032684326, 0.030349731, 0.0040016174, -0.00642395, 0.0178833, -0.052124023, -0.0053215027, -0.038208008, 0.0027809143, 0.009780884, 0.022888184, -0.0037460327, -0.0519104, -0.0053520203, -0.019134521, 0.0020751953, 0.026901245, -0.00029563904, -0.030899048, 0.016983032, -0.051483154, 0.068603516, 0.020706177, 0.019943237, 0.038208008, 0.02381897, -0.0058937073, -0.0079422, 0.018722534, -0.04019165, 0.010856628, -0.03768921, 0.00020802021, -0.07281494, -0.00844574, -0.07208252, 0.022369385, -0.0035552979, 0.0019721985, 0.011222839, -0.0019950867, -0.015655518, 0.013687134, 0.03475952, 0.03074646, 0.037109375, -0.0008149147, 0.00047421455, -0.003835678, 0.008728027, 0.0087890625, 0.022201538, -0.009819031, 0.016204834, -0.043395996, -0.005340576, -0.018844604, 0.032836914, 0.028549194, 0.023010254, -0.018493652, -0.02192688, 0.05581665, 0.011276245, 0.04095459, 0.041168213, 0.04626465, -0.002122879, -0.018051147, -0.002325058, 0.0099487305, -0.027816772, 0.002954483, 0.045898438, -0.06616211, 0.019714355, -0.026260376, -0.032714844, 0.011558533, 0.026275635, 0.044555664, -0.084228516, -0.05569458, 0.027389526, 0.042114258, 0.0021476746, 0.005203247, -0.03302002, 0.00010174513, -0.002439499, 0.020614624, 0.02973938, 0.024780273, 0.021835327, 0.027267456, -0.036010742, -0.011772156, 0.027877808, 0.017837524, 0.0031929016, 0.018859863, -0.041778564, 0.024124146, -0.0050964355, -0.03668213, 0.011268616, 0.005344391, -0.07324219, -0.0015735626, 0.01826477, 0.062438965, 0.057556152, 0.074645996, -0.004020691, -0.008369446, 0.01890564, -0.05053711, 0.035583496, 0.03543091, -0.020584106, 0.011917114, -0.02696228, -0.03567505, 0.017791748, -0.046875, 0.037475586, -0.05847168, 0.022842407, 0.0069847107, 0.0036735535, 0.01914978, -0.020736694, 0.006942749, 0.013893127, -0.029022217, 0.01008606, 0.0118637085, -0.05404663, -0.030853271, 0.01159668, 0.015914917, 0.02609253, -0.018814087, -0.024871826, -0.01146698, -0.05090332, -0.010635376, -0.018615723, 0.032684326, 0.011581421, -0.022155762, -0.027709961, 0.0064430237, 0.021530151, -0.005016327, -0.028137207, -0.0033893585, -0.01663208, -0.015777588, 0.030975342, 0.03918457, -0.0041275024, -0.0077934265, -0.0008277893, 0.0039863586, -0.02192688, 0.0077552795, 0.0053749084, -0.04837036, -0.07366943, -0.00018966198, -0.041778564, 0.03567505, 0.029281616, -0.0055885315, 0.0096206665, 0.021713257, 0.0036029816, -0.017623901, 0.015586853, 0.02809143, -0.02748108, -0.066833496, -0.0043525696, 0.047546387, 0.04373169, -0.025665283, 0.00013148785, 0.049072266, 0.004737854, -0.0015478134, 0.042297363, -0.0007133484, -0.017974854, 0.02822876, 0.010650635, 0.01158905, -0.0317688, -0.040039062, -0.043426514, 0.055877686, 0.032836914, -0.022750854, 0.0047836304, 0.056274414, -0.018585205, -0.01739502, 0.034423828, -0.0067329407, 0.009208679, 0.009132385, 0.03768921, -0.015548706, -0.010948181, 0.041534424, -0.017089844, 0.008216858, 0.013000488, -0.009643555, -0.017166138, -0.040771484, 0.036071777, -0.045806885, -0.015548706, 0.03152466, 0.008590698, 0.012428284, 0.00044465065, -0.011482239, 0.027297974, -0.002954483, -0.020858765, -0.013313293, -0.011764526, 0.040374756, -0.042114258, 0.0012273788, -0.060272217, -0.04083252, 0.02217102, -0.045318604, 0.062927246, -0.041778564, 0.0146102905, -0.048217773, -0.01109314, -0.00737381, 0.013023376, -0.0023593903, -0.020721436, -0.039520264, -0.009338379, 0.033691406, -0.01335907 ], "summary": [ 0.031036377, -0.006916046, 0.008918762, 0.0014877319, -0.031921387, -0.010147095, -0.012496948, -0.03881836, -0.029388428, -0.0073432922, -0.00819397, 0.015365601, -0.021881104, -0.032806396, 0.036590576, -0.036315918, 0.04067993, -0.024475098, 0.011711121, -0.023529053, -0.0033397675, -0.0105896, 0.03781128, 0.06781006, 0.011619568, 0.025558472, -0.0033092499, -0.034332275, 0.012992859, 0.00020825863, 0.020965576, -0.0146102905, -0.018127441, 0.040405273, 0.005996704, -0.023773193, -0.04550171, 0.040863037, 0.024154663, -0.02078247, 0.019012451, -0.016021729, 0.049468994, -0.02607727, -0.0047836304, 0.05178833, -0.035308838, -0.012550354, 0.026016235, -0.007965088, 0.0048332214, 0.02519226, 0.01637268, -0.023330688, -0.030181885, -0.030899048, -0.040985107, 0.019943237, 0.020965576, 0.057128906, 0.016052246, 0.014671326, -0.026611328, -0.05130005, -0.00894165, -0.0017118454, -0.026901245, -0.0077781677, 0.023162842, -0.0088272095, 0.015548706, -0.0107803345, -0.0032958984, 0.025482178, -0.0015382767, -0.015426636, 0.037719727, 0.032684326, 0.0027828217, 0.02003479, -0.034606934, -0.015960693, -0.014808655, -0.048828125, 0.014709473, 0.009185791, -0.03186035, 0.0018167496, -0.015296936, -0.06896973, -0.014450073, -0.034240723, -0.058044434, 0.0102005005, -0.009338379, -0.05899048, -0.07141113, -0.059753418, -0.018676758, 0.032989502, 0.028564453, -0.03591919, 0.08642578, -0.049865723, 0.017349243, 0.059143066, -0.018356323, -0.060821533, 0.0031852722, 0.0020771027, -0.00035595894, -0.043151855, 0.013656616, -0.040100098, -0.005897522, 0.0053863525, 0.0035972595, 0.037597656, 0.032409668, 0.0069274902, -0.030059814, 0.016143799, -0.052825928, 0.024597168, 0.031585693, 0.012298584, 0.018051147, 0.019836426, 0.018600464, 0.024337769, -0.028259277, -0.013923645, -0.03781128, 0.010116577, 0.0038089752, -0.017150879, 0.025344849, -0.011444092, 0.015586853, -0.029571533, 0.04953003, -0.013519287, -0.033813477, 0.050048828, -0.009773254, 0.013824463, 0.018753052, 0.02432251, -0.038879395, -0.046722412, 0.04876709, 0.013092041, 0.043304443, -0.032073975, -0.0038089752, -0.0519104, -0.004398346, -0.034698486, 0.0127334595, -0.030258179, -0.023208618, -0.04345703, -0.041290283, 0.0011367798, -0.035827637, 0.054840088, 0.028625488, 0.0074310303, 0.028396606, 0.013679504, 0.036376953, -0.009902954, 0.016998291, 0.0211792, 0.002943039, 0.01461792, -0.054901123, 0.012832642, 0.030303955, 0.0054969788, 0.038238525, -0.006652832, -0.0056381226, 0.080078125, 0.016540527, -0.009017944, 0.006122589, 0.053863525, 0.012710571, 0.030166626, -0.052886963, -0.02305603, -0.02861023, 0.0010137558, 0.016220093, -0.008049011, 0.0058288574, -0.0056037903, 0.015510559, -0.053497314, -0.031555176, 0.014831543, -0.036712646, 0.01398468, -0.028915405, -0.024139404, 0.0024795532, 0.03149414, 0.024627686, 0.013259888, 0.004047394, -0.033813477, 0.00012290478, 0.015319824, -0.017852783, -0.04385376, 0.055023193, -0.05859375, -0.037017822, -0.03918457, -0.044158936, 0.029586792, -0.08709717, 0.0703125, 0.0118255615, -0.051361084, 0.020187378, -0.03765869, 0.057525635, -0.027191162, 0.04498291, 0.010574341, -0.05935669, -0.038269043, -0.028320312, 0.0025577545, -0.008644104, -0.014831543, 0.028182983, 0.025100708, 0.012969971, 0.0050811768, -0.003145218, 0.04626465, 0.07183838, 0.0552063, 0.00762558, 0.023284912, -0.015586853, -0.032958984, 0.03564453, -0.013656616, 0.050628662, -0.008384705, 0.022888184, 0.040100098, -0.004383087, 0.05770874, -0.03894043, -0.0007801056, -0.029922485, -0.0050964355, 0.023376465, -0.020187378, 0.049041748, -0.037963867, 0.03012085, 0.026168823, -0.0017375946, -0.05029297, 0.009513855, 0.0041046143, -0.018737793, -0.07086182, -0.08117676, -0.029678345, -0.015129089, 0.074523926, -0.028915405, -0.059783936, 0.0038433075, 0.037628174, -0.0068244934, -0.027709961, 0.0013980865, -0.00054597855, 0.0033168793, 0.017852783, 0.01260376, 0.031555176, 0.032562256, 0.03933716, 0.0134887695, 0.0009160042, 0.03237915, -0.005809784, -0.039489746, 0.058410645, -0.02217102, -0.03579712, -0.057739258, -0.0044441223, -0.023025513, -0.031555176, -0.019515991, 0.06237793, 0.0022773743, -0.035858154, -0.029266357, -0.01889038, -0.031463623, -0.03189087, 0.027755737, 0.074157715, -0.023971558, -0.049804688, -0.0016260147, 0.03161621, -0.039489746, -0.060150146, 0.076293945, -0.0134887695, -0.0625, -0.005760193, -0.04144287, -0.005317688, 0.005958557, -0.029876709, 0.016662598, -0.016403198, -0.033081055, -0.018341064, -0.05493164, -0.01600647, -0.0028438568, -0.013412476, -0.0071372986, -0.04714966, -0.023101807, 0.020004272, -0.011047363, 0.025253296, 0.030410767, -0.046203613, -0.052947998, 0.01576233, -0.018615723, 0.010826111, 0.023757935, -0.019714355, 0.020263672, -0.03302002, -0.045684814, 0.018447876, -0.0065727234, -0.008338928, 0.040527344, 0.041778564, 0.012931824, -0.022476196, 0.023788452, 0.026229858, 0.00856781, -0.036254883, -0.012458801, -0.05429077, 0.016586304, -0.028182983, 0.02520752, 0.055267334, -0.064331055, 0.023117065, -0.026824951, 0.010009766, 0.030944824, 0.012580872, 0.039031982, -0.028244019, 0.036987305, 0.039245605, 0.022857666, 0.030044556, 0.0037155151, 0.003293991, 0.07385254, 0.0054969788, -0.00055265427, 0.022354126, 0.04348755, 0.0158844, -0.030410767, -0.03918457, 0.011062622, -0.035308838, 0.013313293, 0.025344849, -0.022628784, -0.020584106, 0.004486084, -0.029067993, -0.025802612, 0.016098022, -0.0033397675, 0.00020599365, -0.03427124, 0.023803711, -0.041625977, -0.019073486, 0.014945984, 0.045654297, -0.012420654, -0.0043144226, 0.009857178, -0.012664795, 0.01763916, -0.0065231323, 0.022750854, 0.03213501, -0.014518738, -0.04473877, -0.027633667, 0.07574463, -0.018920898, -0.029190063, -0.013298035, 0.025054932, -0.011001587, 0.0140686035, -0.022338867, 0.0032234192, 0.010017395, -0.036102295, -0.0090408325, -0.046539307, -0.06378174, -0.011962891, -0.008102417, 0.03173828, 0.0076179504, -0.03540039, -0.0013504028, -0.009483337, -0.014923096, 0.024429321, -0.014038086, -0.016723633, 0.0044937134, 0.008987427, 0.03768921, 0.05593872, -0.03552246, -0.006790161, 0.008407593, 0.007472992, -0.052001953, -0.009361267, -0.018218994, 0.008026123, 0.013595581, -0.027511597, -0.015640259, -0.005218506, -0.024475098, -0.015548706, 0.0012674332, 0.00043845177, 0.031402588, 0.032562256, 0.015594482, -0.036895752, 0.02708435, 0.0012264252, -0.012962341, 0.0000030398369, -0.00630188, 0.012062073, 0.023880005, 0.017959595, -0.028411865, -0.019226074, -0.036346436, 0.025436401, -0.05001831, -0.07098389, -0.016052246, 0.017074585, -0.07342529, -0.061798096, 0.031707764, 0.016952515, 0.037719727, -0.013557434, 0.056243896, 0.022628784, 0.020141602, -0.020874023, -0.017074585, 0.04348755, 0.01449585, -0.058013916, 0.031585693, -0.029708862, -0.007297516, 0.013435364, -0.04724121, 0.049987793, 0.021713257, 0.010185242, 0.0028896332, -0.064208984, 0.009544373, -0.043762207, 0.02142334, 0.015853882, -0.017150879, 0.02659607, 0.009483337, 0.0060653687, -0.008926392, -0.0074882507, 0.031829834, 0.009773254, 0.016860962, 0.019073486, -0.010131836, 0.025131226, -0.009757996, 0.010856628, -0.0038337708, 0.016815186, 0.0017948151, 0.037139893, -0.000074505806, -0.012817383, 0.016815186, -0.04522705, -0.02557373, 0.022628784, 0.05557251, 0.00009697676, -0.013221741, -0.0033569336, -0.00642395, 0.039733887, -0.0038337708, 0.014472961, -0.0015964508, 0.028930664, -0.047698975, 0.007858276, -0.004753113, 0.009017944, -0.036895752, -0.02456665, -0.00058698654, -0.025802612, -0.028503418, -0.010276794, -0.0049819946, 0.022903442, 0.0040130615, 0.0836792, -0.01109314, -0.042022705, 0.064575195, 0.0259552, -0.02532959, -0.038909912, -0.04812622, 0.011161804, -0.03665161, -0.024749756, -0.007835388, -0.02418518, -0.010299683, -0.027572632, -0.03744507, 0.0011034012, 0.008422852, 0.034851074, 0.01360321, -0.023910522, -0.05307007, -0.066101074, -0.012512207, -0.03225708, 0.04083252, -0.0049476624, -0.003042221, -0.0076026917, 0.011062622, -0.032318115, -0.015617371, -0.06347656, -0.026382446, 0.013664246, -0.035217285, 0.037322998, 0.043670654, 0.010192871, 0.0032749176, 0.020965576, 0.020431519, -0.026809692, -0.04031372, 0.004764557, 0.019866943, -0.028335571, 0.0040893555, 0.038238525, -0.045318604, -0.047424316, 0.07476807, -0.014732361, 0.081726074, 0.011688232, 0.0005698204, -0.010902405, -0.0055999756, -0.013877869, 0.017364502, -0.0014677048, 0.025375366, 0.015686035, -0.05633545, 0.066589355, 0.04095459, 0.024246216, -0.04800415, -0.009689331, 0.0049743652, -0.026367188, -0.033966064, -0.101257324, -0.024017334, 0.07354736, 0.0055999756, -0.02835083, 0.020751953, 0.040527344, -0.03744507, 0.014770508, 0.018173218, 0.0062217712, 0.003288269, -0.04296875, -0.010284424, -0.0010471344, -0.02293396, -0.0006556511, 0.040222168, 0.015312195, -0.0038852692, -0.04107666, -0.010147095, -0.017929077, -0.020080566, -0.001745224, -0.0052337646, -0.050811768, -0.06506348, -0.037322998, 0.0033130646, -0.013183594, -0.0064926147, 0.00762558, 0.030014038, 0.011253357, 0.001958847, 0.007194519, -0.019836426, 0.017227173, 0.049346924, -0.028884888, -0.007858276, 0.029830933, 0.035217285, -0.018371582, 0.029663086, -0.017974854, 0.003419876, -0.026306152, -0.008613586, 0.008956909, -0.021820068, 0.02772522, -0.031402588, -0.020401001, 0.038024902, -0.009033203, 0.007980347, 0.007232666, 0.012039185, -0.03366089, -0.00242424, 0.04333496, 0.03475952, -0.040985107, -0.023849487, -0.07220459, 0.020645142, 0.0209198, 0.02293396, 0.020248413, 0.009719849, -0.0020618439, -0.01939392, -0.020355225, 0.004146576, 0.022109985, -0.02432251, -0.00077819824, -0.025131226, 0.007232666, -0.06719971, -0.036743164, -0.08294678, -0.027923584, -0.025863647, 0.094177246, -0.01209259, 0.09197998, 0.060760498, -0.07208252, 0.012069702, 0.022277832, -0.037506104, 0.0093688965, -0.025512695, -0.046813965, -0.024047852, 0.016998291, 0.008575439, -0.019210815, -0.010444641, -0.037750244, 0.04788208, -0.019012451, -0.029891968, 0.0368042, -0.03555298, 0.033935547, -0.016479492, -0.028625488, -0.0036888123, 0.010787964, 0.005882263, -0.026138306, 0.026062012, -0.0012521744, 0.019485474, 0.010948181, -0.06225586, -0.008277893, 0.01234436, 0.007633209, 0.048858643, 0.016082764, -0.054260254, 0.0026874542, -0.06311035, -0.0015115738, -0.013847351, 0.044189453, 0.02557373, 0.070373535, -0.033966064, -0.018859863, -0.02923584, -0.034332275, -0.03753662, 0.051971436, -0.03945923, -0.06744385, 0.043395996, -0.051879883, 0.0025177002, -0.028320312, -0.01600647, 0.03604126, 0.03439331, 0.021133423, -0.0552063, -0.015960693, -0.0014038086, 0.009803772, -0.014076233, 0.023803711, -0.03515625, -0.004470825, -0.022033691, 0.051513672, -0.01133728, -0.07397461, -0.010269165, 0.002445221, -0.040374756, -0.028045654, -0.030639648, -0.036468506, 0.042144775, -0.031402588, -0.00819397, -0.036315918, -0.039794922, -0.023468018, 0.0116119385, 0.00023281574, -0.04660034, 0.017990112, -0.023849487, -0.014526367, 0.074401855, -0.054473877, 0.03387451, -0.04586792, 0.005859375, -0.010238647, -0.022155762, 0.0062332153, 0.016281128, 0.026443481, -0.02154541, 0.044158936, -0.02229309, 0.014831543, -0.0004696846, -0.026504517, 0.014816284, -0.01802063, 0.013946533, -0.012924194, 0.061645508, 0.024246216, 0.024871826, 0.020767212, 0.004623413, 0.11126709, -0.058380127, 0.015853882, 0.020248413, -0.004650116, 0.008262634, 0.011886597, -0.025741577, 0.0044059753, 0.0005245209, -0.010940552, 0.044708252, 0.0024738312, 0.049987793, -0.07043457, -0.021057129, 0.026550293, 0.006038666, -0.037078857, 0.023620605, -0.015533447, -0.018417358, -0.03778076, -0.017974854, 0.03717041, 0.031799316, -0.0043144226, 0.027069092, -0.0036563873, 0.019485474, 0.008491516, 0.0040245056, -0.0011491776, 0.025405884, -0.0357666, 0.013595581, -0.020965576, -0.032989502, 0.000044941902, 0.0051879883, -0.029373169, -0.0012388229, 0.008010864, 0.03274536, 0.06512451, 0.051940918, -0.018051147, 0.028747559, 0.053375244, -0.019104004, 0.010314941, 0.026992798, 0.01576233, -0.029968262, -0.019302368, 0.006340027, -0.01676941, 0.006679535, 0.021057129, -0.03390503, 0.04949951, -0.008232117, -0.011909485, -0.031799316, -0.026977539, 0.020599365, 0.0037059784, -0.02520752, 0.018432617, 0.037506104, -0.04647827, 0.012710571, -0.017349243, -0.028915405, 0.0044441223, 0.00023961067, 0.019607544, -0.00055885315, 0.0070724487, -0.0038051605, 0.005973816, 0.044830322, -0.0054397583, -0.042907715, -0.016036987, -0.009498596, 0.051452637, -0.0107803345, -0.024261475, -0.0149002075, 0.008178711, -0.011489868, -0.012741089, -0.008712769, -0.034484863, -0.014846802, 0.041046143, 0.01335144, -0.0256958, 0.046539307, 0.012054443, 0.0098724365, -0.10583496, -0.009529114, -0.008636475, -0.011405945, -0.025482178, -0.020065308, 0.03878784, -0.0028095245, 0.003200531, 0.0068969727, 0.018341064, 0.006904602, -0.026855469, -0.030258179, -0.014984131, 0.036743164, 0.029937744, -0.010848999, 0.055236816, 0.03869629, 0.011932373, -0.0037059784, 0.00983429, -0.045532227, -0.0073509216, 0.059753418, 0.05307007, 0.01763916, -0.034851074, 0.005695343, -0.030929565, 0.04977417, -0.02218628, -0.037994385, -0.007850647, 0.011123657, -0.014976501, 0.00381279, 0.005771637, -0.023345947, 0.0022201538, -0.015304565, -0.00308609, 0.0078048706, -0.006126404, 0.0041236877, -0.014350891, 0.014289856, -0.019836426, 0.01083374, -0.0043258667, -0.034576416, 0.026855469, -0.045959473, 0.045440674, 0.005584717, -0.021881104, 0.030044556, -0.06201172, 0.019866943, 0.06402588, -0.001156807, -0.010383606, 0.018341064, -0.019973755, 0.044952393, -0.06201172, -0.006351471, -0.079956055, -0.017913818, 0.0014381409, -0.029510498, 0.04788208, -0.044555664, 0.011756897, -0.0031528473, -0.012039185, 0.028625488, -0.02279663, 0.007987976, 0.020629883, -0.019577026, -0.033966064, -0.038757324, 0.009124756 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1403.5029v3
Network-based Isoform Quantification with RNA-Seq Data for Cancer Transcriptome Analysis
Wei Zhang, Jae-Woong Chang, Lilong Lin, Kay Minn, Baolin Wu, Jeremy Chien, Jeongsik Yong, Hui Zheng, Rui Kuang
cs.CE, cs.AI, cs.LG
High-throughput mRNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) is widely used for transcript quantification of gene isoforms. Since RNA-Seq data alone is often not sufficient to accurately identify the read origins from the isoforms for quantification, we propose to explore protein domain-domain interactions as prior knowledge for integrative analysis with RNA-seq data. We introduce a Network-based method for RNA-Seq-based Transcript Quantification (Net-RSTQ) to integrate protein domain-domain interaction network with short read alignments for transcript abundance estimation. Based on our observation that the abundances of the neighboring isoforms by domain-domain interactions in the network are positively correlated, Net-RSTQ models the expression of the neighboring transcripts as Dirichlet priors on the likelihood of the observed read alignments against the transcripts in one gene. The transcript abundances of all the genes are then jointly estimated with alternating optimization of multiple EM problems. In simulation Net-RSTQ effectively improved isoform transcript quantifications when isoform co-expressions correlate with their interactions. qRT-PCR results on 25 multi-isoform genes in a stem cell line, an ovarian cancer cell line, and a breast cancer cell line also showed that Net-RSTQ estimated more consistent isoform proportions with RNA-Seq data. In the experiments on the RNA-Seq data in The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA), the transcript abundances estimated by Net-RSTQ are more informative for patient sample classification of ovarian cancer, breast cancer and lung cancer. All experimental results collectively support that Net-RSTQ is a promising approach for isoform quantification.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1403.5029v3
2015-09-15T15:48:46
2014-03-20T02:35:15
{ "title": [ -0.03527832, 0.0064964294, -0.07977295, -0.07800293, 0.024536133, -0.01701355, -0.04776001, 0.021347046, -0.02368164, 0.031066895, -0.020553589, 0.018173218, -0.019683838, -0.012367249, -0.03237915, 0.003665924, 0.0022716522, 0.008422852, -0.02470398, -0.03652954, 0.0053901672, -0.040252686, 0.028442383, 0.028442383, 0.025299072, -0.039764404, -0.0357666, 0.017669678, -0.055603027, -0.03479004, -0.026809692, 0.037719727, 0.028015137, 0.04660034, -0.039245605, 0.009269714, -0.05340576, 0.041015625, 0.0064315796, -0.010948181, 0.012718201, -0.008522034, 0.006576538, -0.05218506, 0.006389618, 0.051086426, -0.0446167, -0.05102539, -0.017425537, 0.022781372, 0.009963989, 0.014572144, 0.0116119385, 0.030944824, 0.015991211, -0.045806885, 0.018661499, -0.054107666, 0.04586792, 0.025756836, 0.025390625, -0.034362793, 0.025253296, -0.011909485, -0.038269043, -0.021575928, -0.0090408325, 0.013397217, 0.077819824, -0.0010280609, -0.019882202, 0.039276123, 0.009178162, -0.023910522, -0.051361084, 0.050628662, 0.02319336, 0.03289795, 0.03314209, -0.0463562, 0.010795593, -0.013374329, 0.0031166077, 0.0018081665, 0.004486084, 0.0020618439, -0.019760132, -0.016174316, -0.00012624264, -0.061676025, -0.011917114, -0.011360168, 0.025497437, 0.02128601, -0.0574646, -0.007713318, -0.008155823, -0.012123108, 0.0014886856, -0.017532349, 0.018478394, -0.012573242, -0.010856628, 0.0016107559, 0.011299133, 0.020843506, -0.0055122375, -0.020187378, 0.014343262, 0.030166626, -0.009521484, 0.021865845, -0.019821167, -0.039093018, -0.0010519028, 0.029281616, -0.015899658, 0.010688782, 0.03286743, -0.0026340485, 0.002128601, -0.014724731, -0.007972717, -0.006462097, 0.002412796, -0.028900146, -0.024139404, 0.004562378, -0.074401855, 0.034606934, 0.048553467, 0.030700684, -0.11102295, -0.042419434, -0.053588867, 0.048950195, 0.006336212, -0.03475952, -0.020202637, 0.031311035, 0.017166138, -0.04824829, -0.017318726, 0.017242432, 0.014961243, 0.034118652, 0.07366943, -0.021026611, -0.04623413, -0.022369385, -0.055877686, 0.07147217, 0.051574707, -0.018814087, -0.094055176, -0.037322998, -0.11242676, -0.036895752, 0.00944519, -0.04446411, 0.009933472, -0.004383087, -0.03414917, -0.042633057, 0.015403748, -0.0011224747, -0.006855011, 0.039245605, 0.0022678375, -0.0178833, -0.018478394, 0.026153564, 0.033172607, 0.006362915, -0.012481689, 0.008453369, -0.01121521, -0.017837524, 0.015388489, 0.014144897, 0.01473999, -0.029754639, -0.01737976, 0.07183838, -0.061187744, 0.018875122, -0.01676941, 0.0035591125, 0.049743652, -0.011207581, -0.010765076, 0.03353882, -0.019744873, -0.027023315, -0.049713135, -0.032409668, 0.030258179, 0.027648926, -0.02128601, 0.008323669, -0.026931763, -0.0024280548, -0.024887085, 0.0016431808, -0.0060768127, -0.019744873, 0.0019350052, 0.01638794, -0.01878357, 0.03604126, 0.041259766, -0.0044174194, -0.029525757, -0.0031375885, -0.024642944, -0.018432617, 0.010375977, -0.023925781, -0.028442383, 0.0051574707, -0.06451416, 0.009231567, -0.02420044, 0.05557251, 0.002609253, -0.019165039, 0.003545761, -0.03930664, 0.030258179, -0.0041503906, 0.059906006, -0.03111267, 0.0046043396, -0.025146484, 0.0026416779, 0.0070343018, 0.012550354, -0.005264282, -0.009536743, -0.003189087, 0.015960693, -0.022537231, -0.0143966675, -0.011962891, 0.055847168, 0.0021858215, 0.021408081, -0.021621704, 0.02960205, 0.06335449, 0.020050049, 0.029647827, 0.03250122, -0.031311035, 0.022109985, 0.04220581, 0.0006928444, 0.039215088, -0.034332275, 0.0030403137, 0.014625549, 0.053833008, 0.0036563873, 0.026412964, -0.026535034, -0.0022907257, -0.027496338, 0.007843018, -0.0069351196, 0.015266418, 0.0418396, 0.008239746, 0.016174316, 0.0057678223, -0.0016307831, -0.0033302307, -0.0038776398, -0.0033721924, 0.016601562, -0.047546387, 0.00069475174, 0.00957489, 0.035095215, -0.0038585663, 0.031463623, -0.0067596436, 0.0031757355, 0.0011558533, -0.03463745, -0.030563354, 0.035858154, 0.009643555, -0.022445679, -0.015625, 0.01008606, -0.019226074, 0.07659912, 0.029174805, -0.00065135956, 0.027893066, -0.028213501, 0.041534424, 0.026870728, -0.026443481, -0.0045547485, 0.01826477, 0.022781372, 0.01689148, -0.044921875, -0.003780365, -0.058776855, -0.021514893, 0.013641357, -0.022918701, -0.024887085, -0.04425049, -0.005744934, -0.027450562, -0.047027588, -0.0619812, 0.06890869, -0.0048599243, -0.02003479, -0.008926392, 0.018356323, -0.011978149, -0.028381348, -0.023788452, -0.027053833, 0.025939941, 0.009017944, -0.024291992, -0.0715332, -0.06781006, -0.011451721, 0.025238037, -0.010276794, 0.041229248, 0.0023975372, 0.008583069, 0.03189087, -0.012390137, 0.03125, -0.009170532, 0.026412964, -0.06335449, -0.004989624, 0.0043945312, -0.016571045, 0.0041618347, -0.0007419586, -0.010505676, -0.019210815, -0.0036182404, 0.056488037, -0.022994995, -0.03363037, 0.029922485, 0.030303955, -0.024230957, -0.02897644, 0.026824951, -0.020401001, 0.00093746185, -0.010658264, -0.048065186, -0.0018033981, -0.00003862381, -0.0027656555, 0.0574646, -0.064453125, -0.026657104, 0.009552002, 0.004295349, 0.030593872, 0.0059318542, -0.06161499, -0.04940796, -0.022598267, -0.052764893, -0.010894775, 0.019485474, -0.02557373, 0.049621582, 0.064697266, 0.006881714, 0.012504578, 0.010360718, 0.015686035, 0.0012836456, -0.037841797, -0.016036987, -0.020935059, -0.0054893494, -0.004611969, 0.010910034, 0.01348114, -0.030639648, -0.043518066, -0.021881104, 0.035614014, -0.008155823, -0.032958984, 0.023727417, -0.043701172, 0.014328003, -0.002073288, -0.014694214, 0.02130127, 0.05996704, -0.015274048, 0.013687134, 0.00258255, -0.024353027, 0.00932312, -0.010810852, -0.06329346, 0.03048706, -0.039093018, -0.06036377, 0.0033340454, 0.007446289, -0.043945312, -0.0023994446, -0.030029297, 0.051727295, 0.03967285, 0.02331543, 0.007499695, -0.02999878, 0.021026611, -0.041503906, -0.041748047, -0.019165039, -0.0018157959, 0.012313843, -0.006664276, 0.033416748, -0.007381439, 0.0019817352, -0.04776001, -0.01184082, 0.06762695, 0.0357666, 0.013206482, -0.010795593, -0.017105103, 0.00957489, -0.0020446777, 0.0078125, -0.0011873245, -0.011413574, -0.0037574768, 0.008720398, -0.025817871, 0.0014448166, 0.022415161, 0.024230957, -0.030792236, -0.038360596, 0.018173218, -0.04232788, -0.06161499, 0.024124146, 0.02696228, 0.022109985, -0.037231445, 0.0070762634, -0.0062789917, 0.0012397766, 0.0066566467, 0.025665283, -0.004398346, -0.0011901855, -0.0068893433, 0.026672363, -0.02003479, -0.0064582825, -0.03010559, 0.010627747, -0.003698349, 0.01499176, -0.018188477, -0.07598877, 0.00040864944, -0.0013475418, -0.108947754, -0.029083252, 0.011642456, -0.044311523, -0.0005788803, -0.05731201, 0.019454956, -0.03050232, -0.03262329, -0.019561768, -0.018005371, 0.004890442, -0.010444641, -0.046081543, -0.021850586, 0.050811768, -0.008987427, 0.03250122, 0.029815674, -0.0031108856, 0.004261017, -0.058044434, 0.004634857, 0.0070991516, 0.03286743, -0.01777649, -0.017105103, 0.031402588, -0.0368042, 0.006958008, 0.0067253113, -0.038726807, -0.0044555664, 0.012390137, 0.029678345, -0.00730896, 0.017974854, 0.04849243, -0.019805908, -0.022994995, -0.03262329, -0.020980835, -0.007888794, 0.0104599, 0.019363403, -0.0006093979, 0.04559326, 0.008842468, -0.0017223358, 0.048583984, -0.0093307495, -0.0032997131, 0.030395508, -0.016799927, -0.009269714, -0.0044021606, 0.016738892, 0.028961182, 0.0009393692, 0.0001642704, 0.007396698, 0.049957275, -0.021987915, -0.022521973, 0.025863647, 0.032958984, -0.0038089752, -0.00015890598, -0.07055664, -0.022705078, -0.04196167, 0.025375366, -0.008338928, 0.037902832, 0.03149414, 0.009407043, -0.06774902, 0.023986816, -0.011116028, -0.012924194, 0.017822266, -0.024963379, 0.0055999756, -0.011993408, -0.027648926, -0.03970337, 0.0009198189, 0.0008559227, 0.02859497, 0.016845703, -0.04067993, -0.020965576, 0.032073975, 0.06750488, 0.022476196, 0.006549835, -0.046691895, -0.022277832, -0.009757996, -0.014205933, 0.005138397, 0.020431519, 0.00044250488, -0.0385437, -0.026397705, -0.014228821, -0.009544373, -0.017089844, 0.009605408, -0.0064735413, 0.0496521, -0.007484436, 0.018875122, 0.023788452, 0.005657196, -0.0048713684, -0.010574341, -0.03302002, 0.0124053955, 0.017807007, 0.06222534, -0.03744507, 0.023269653, 0.052337646, 0.004634857, -0.034057617, 0.020477295, 0.0074806213, 0.040222168, -0.0055732727, -0.01348114, 0.036315918, 0.0016317368, -0.040771484, -0.0029201508, 0.043121338, 0.028320312, -0.062438965, 0.000310421, -0.02330017, 0.008781433, -0.00035262108, -0.027679443, 0.017959595, -0.026901245, 0.022598267, -0.06549072, -0.06939697, -0.0034809113, 0.05154419, -0.034240723, -0.0146102905, 0.024795532, 0.034576416, -0.007827759, 0.05090332, 0.038635254, 0.030944824, -0.02003479, -0.009094238, 0.009971619, -0.03942871, -0.036254883, 0.02027893, 0.043060303, 0.014915466, -0.00081157684, -0.017593384, -0.09118652, 0.008026123, -0.01586914, -0.0146865845, 0.01335907, -0.04953003, 0.0015201569, 0.05505371, -0.011367798, 0.019104004, -0.010383606, 0.043304443, 0.023254395, 0.039520264, 0.017196655, 0.0064811707, 0.04473877, -0.030212402, -0.024597168, 0.0025920868, 0.00730896, 0.021942139, 0.053588867, 0.016601562, 0.009292603, -0.04824829, 0.010246277, 0.017807007, 0.030471802, 0.001490593, -0.04989624, 0.03314209, -0.0045814514, -0.031234741, 0.0070228577, -0.04425049, -0.0034389496, 0.015388489, -0.026885986, -0.04458618, 0.02885437, -0.016143799, -0.041992188, -0.0034236908, 0.0025100708, 0.002363205, 0.0022449493, 0.020843506, -0.0004618168, -0.017028809, 0.05496216, 0.032592773, -0.039154053, -0.031341553, 0.03262329, 0.0015048981, 0.04434204, 0.010375977, -0.05001831, -0.0030384064, -0.014579773, -0.047546387, -0.030807495, 0.030212402, 0.030014038, 0.002565384, 0.017242432, -0.027023315, 0.040374756, 0.000025749207, 0.02330017, 0.01979065, 0.020751953, 0.05545044, 0.005088806, -0.008056641, 0.016906738, 0.024368286, 0.0028915405, 0.0052871704, 0.0027179718, -0.040374756, -0.0070114136, 0.01675415, 0.0022525787, 0.003698349, -0.08404541, 0.017059326, -0.010116577, 0.012420654, 0.016479492, 0.025985718, 0.0137786865, 0.10681152, -0.031036377, 0.0049057007, 0.023651123, 0.0006737709, -0.010353088, -0.0052452087, 0.03289795, 0.013557434, 0.074279785, -0.038360596, -0.016967773, -0.044158936, -0.07470703, -0.02986145, 0.010192871, 0.037841797, 0.03756714, 0.041137695, 0.032958984, 0.08148193, -0.03378296, -0.016906738, -0.023544312, 0.018875122, -0.006816864, -0.023010254, 0.0015764236, -0.007949829, -0.0075569153, -0.030059814, 0.049041748, 0.018035889, 0.020126343, -0.016418457, -0.044525146, -0.010597229, -0.026855469, -0.02432251, -0.00630188, 0.04748535, -0.04647827, 0.009208679, -0.016616821, 0.04800415, 0.03111267, 0.0647583, 0.058502197, 0.0020771027, 0.015777588, 0.020202637, 0.022705078, -0.03665161, -0.032836914, -0.016937256, -0.02494812, -0.050323486, -0.0052223206, -0.053985596, 0.06542969, -0.027832031, 0.018707275, 0.030960083, -0.007926941, 0.018920898, 0.01675415, 0.03955078, 0.023757935, 0.06750488, 0.040252686, 0.014251709, -0.00084257126, -0.031341553, 0.019897461, 0.03213501, 0.010101318, -0.004119873, -0.0010871887, -0.03933716, 0.012779236, 0.032104492, 0.014289856, -0.01876831, -0.0077781677, -0.03805542, 0.031707764, -0.012557983, 0.009536743, 0.049621582, 0.02670288, 0.03753662, -0.021774292, 0.0013580322, -0.011116028, -0.008682251, -0.014503479, 0.04623413, -0.091552734, 0.01108551, -0.012077332, -0.008003235, -0.0005507469, 0.047821045, 0.024169922, -0.05718994, -0.030044556, 0.03137207, 0.041992188, 0.0033454895, 0.03451538, -0.021209717, -0.032958984, 0.019104004, 0.03881836, -0.003156662, 0.058929443, 0.029144287, -0.00012946129, 0.0067367554, -0.042388916, 0.018875122, 0.0256958, -0.012718201, 0.019943237, 0.0052948, 0.007080078, 0.013572693, -0.039764404, 0.004432678, 0.014442444, -0.022994995, -0.030136108, 0.033111572, 0.033599854, 0.01600647, 0.08496094, 0.041229248, -0.008506775, -0.04824829, -0.038635254, 0.04196167, 0.017425537, -0.03930664, -0.009506226, -0.00166893, -0.042388916, 0.040893555, -0.04534912, 0.06744385, -0.034820557, -0.007926941, 0.0062065125, 0.032989502, 0.04168701, -0.05429077, -0.06390381, 0.015777588, -0.016052246, 0.0040283203, 0.023727417, -0.03488159, -0.07531738, -0.009841919, 0.030883789, -0.0181427, -0.016525269, 0.018676758, -0.0016002655, -0.079589844, -0.0068855286, -0.038726807, 0.032073975, -0.06286621, -0.006259918, -0.044281006, 0.00073957443, 0.032470703, 0.011177063, -0.01234436, 0.00073719025, -0.04559326, -0.043914795, 0.023910522, 0.012001038, -0.045013428, -0.019943237, 0.035003662, -0.002609253, -0.019622803, -0.02104187, 0.034454346, -0.024230957, -0.02331543, 0.010261536, -0.03050232, 0.0362854, 0.010017395, -0.02607727, 0.035247803, 0.0146102905, -0.04324341, 0.019851685, 0.009986877, 0.03479004, -0.023910522, -0.04135132, 0.01776123, 0.024978638, 0.04626465, -0.06665039, -0.038238525, 0.012191772, 0.039764404, -0.019119263, 0.07501221, 0.004436493, 0.0024032593, 0.000060617924, 0.035064697, 0.0075798035, -0.028518677, -0.08874512, -0.08416748, 0.03942871, 0.021743774, 0.010925293, -0.05154419, 0.076049805, -0.0026283264, 0.01108551, 0.0037937164, -0.008987427, 0.0053520203, -0.006690979, 0.045532227, -0.009994507, 0.0066108704, 0.025314331, 0.012229919, -0.0026607513, 0.027618408, -0.048797607, -0.0078125, 0.0022277832, -0.001613617, -0.058441162, -0.04208374, 0.02027893, 0.02720642, -0.0060691833, 0.04244995, -0.02319336, -0.0039863586, 0.00068998337, -0.03048706, -0.023452759, -0.018371582, 0.06085205, -0.039245605, -0.0007138252, -0.053588867, -0.03805542, -0.021026611, -0.022705078, 0.051361084, -0.058654785, 0.016571045, -0.04058838, -0.015106201, -0.0039367676, 0.024108887, -0.000080406666, -0.028457642, -0.045837402, 0.008079529, 0.026977539, -0.032470703 ], "summary": [ 0.010673523, -0.008735657, -0.043395996, -0.04208374, -0.008460999, -0.031951904, -0.041229248, 0.00087308884, -0.010978699, 0.041107178, -0.028930664, -0.01550293, -0.0072135925, -0.0042915344, -0.044311523, -0.045562744, -0.019714355, 0.018478394, 0.0073280334, -0.033599854, 0.00843811, -0.045074463, 0.0010595322, -0.032714844, -0.014137268, -0.026245117, 0.05496216, -0.0025997162, -0.013473511, -0.006729126, -0.006164551, 0.029220581, 0.011817932, 0.02885437, -0.02557373, -0.00356102, -0.028564453, 0.016952515, 0.0065841675, -0.018661499, -0.0028877258, 0.004333496, 0.12438965, -0.095458984, 0.058776855, 0.07409668, -0.013000488, -0.06756592, 0.033050537, 0.028640747, -0.01335144, -0.0006122589, -0.02619934, 0.025772095, -0.01727295, -0.021255493, 0.010398865, -0.051483154, 0.013641357, 0.011390686, 0.0050201416, 0.0010023117, 0.017578125, -0.0132751465, -0.014205933, -0.009803772, 0.03765869, -0.0023860931, 0.022949219, -0.0068969727, 0.01461792, 0.033416748, 0.023147583, -0.047851562, -0.0063209534, 0.07513428, -0.021499634, 0.030532837, 0.033416748, -0.036499023, 0.022857666, 0.016143799, 0.028656006, -0.022369385, -0.012275696, -0.016983032, -0.011726379, -0.00034213066, -0.00749588, -0.01146698, -0.021987915, -0.00055360794, 0.008491516, 0.036956787, -0.017913818, -0.0085372925, -0.006717682, -0.017562866, 0.0395813, 0.03250122, 0.06210327, -0.06542969, 0.041900635, -0.027954102, -0.019256592, 0.016021729, 0.01525116, 0.0017375946, 0.0024967194, 0.024551392, -0.0135650635, -0.006290436, -0.028060913, -0.0803833, 0.010253906, 0.056121826, -0.012748718, 0.0099487305, 0.036254883, -0.022018433, 0.033721924, 0.047424316, -0.038269043, -0.01876831, -0.0014295578, -0.008880615, -0.019744873, -0.0048103333, -0.10437012, 0.039733887, 0.029541016, 0.019943237, -0.053741455, 0.022018433, -0.04849243, -0.0037670135, 0.012413025, -0.02456665, -0.011360168, -0.01222229, 0.056610107, -0.04119873, -0.040161133, 0.047332764, 0.004009247, 0.025924683, 0.0368042, -0.008834839, 0.010284424, -0.021987915, -0.049865723, 0.06573486, 0.07312012, -0.037231445, -0.084228516, -0.08892822, -0.06225586, -0.04156494, 0.018539429, -0.06500244, 0.007381439, -0.0067634583, -0.023330688, -0.04272461, -0.020111084, -0.007965088, 0.0019464493, 0.018920898, 0.013671875, -0.07171631, 0.010421753, -0.007232666, 0.058502197, -0.014945984, -0.0050582886, 0.026641846, -0.025238037, -0.014961243, 0.0009403229, 0.015327454, -0.0035247803, -0.041290283, -0.039031982, 0.052520752, -0.033203125, 0.013908386, -0.029647827, 0.013366699, 0.0413208, -0.014404297, 0.023727417, -0.005718231, 0.004699707, -0.0070343018, -0.011016846, -0.012283325, 0.009605408, 0.016616821, -0.016937256, -0.016448975, 0.044952393, -0.0064735413, 0.027572632, -0.022537231, -0.015045166, -0.011688232, 0.010787964, 0.015975952, 0.025436401, 0.009941101, 0.007507324, -0.011680603, -0.021484375, 0.010467529, -0.05380249, -0.013755798, 0.023040771, -0.054107666, -0.03173828, -0.026535034, -0.04711914, 0.03955078, -0.06100464, 0.038391113, 0.0053482056, -0.029663086, -0.006614685, -0.029891968, 0.02746582, -0.013031006, 0.016464233, -0.004711151, -0.008056641, 0.011138916, -0.0019207001, 0.031158447, 0.043182373, 0.023086548, -0.0033359528, -0.011558533, 0.02796936, -0.0015325546, -0.026229858, -0.04473877, 0.03591919, -0.025848389, 0.015792847, -0.054504395, 0.021057129, 0.113220215, -0.029647827, 0.052886963, -0.0051345825, -0.031951904, 0.019546509, 0.031311035, 0.008071899, 0.010673523, 0.0021438599, -0.0158844, 0.03161621, 0.047027588, -0.022766113, 0.028198242, 0.02255249, 0.016159058, 0.003704071, -0.0007805824, -0.052612305, 0.024642944, 0.032958984, 0.0073280334, 0.0037555695, -0.0071105957, -0.019424438, 0.008338928, 0.016738892, -0.008163452, 0.023635864, -0.015235901, -0.0016536713, -0.028717041, 0.012329102, 0.005519867, 0.036834717, -0.013404846, 0.037963867, 0.040100098, -0.03112793, -0.0040512085, 0.016403198, 0.015220642, -0.007881165, 0.007095337, -0.0012111664, -0.014923096, 0.006401062, -0.008369446, 0.0032749176, -0.0066986084, 0.018508911, 0.05203247, 0.030685425, -0.02897644, 0.01626587, -0.0075416565, -0.003627777, 0.009407043, 0.0023384094, -0.021347046, -0.024658203, 0.023971558, 0.0368042, 0.0051231384, -0.0044822693, -0.017501831, -0.03866577, 0.017807007, -0.053588867, -0.02192688, 0.08911133, 0.015853882, -0.013641357, 0.0032844543, 0.01600647, -0.0395813, 0.0010633469, -0.020202637, -0.01524353, -0.01838684, -0.044677734, -0.079589844, -0.043548584, -0.062805176, -0.010314941, -0.007904053, 0.0048942566, 0.018234253, 0.024017334, 0.012390137, 0.05392456, -0.04989624, 0.0006017685, 0.019729614, 0.027679443, -0.06427002, -0.010986328, -0.018325806, 0.019638062, 0.014579773, -0.003768921, 0.0012683868, -0.024978638, -0.01939392, 0.023376465, -0.029922485, -0.0028209686, 0.055023193, 0.040527344, -0.006904602, -0.0033740997, 0.039520264, -0.012535095, -0.038238525, -0.015579224, -0.045928955, 0.000045657158, -0.01979065, 0.016479492, 0.0335083, -0.012413025, 0.0014028549, -0.0014390945, -0.004306793, -0.007713318, -0.029785156, -0.008056641, -0.036132812, -0.03515625, -0.020217896, -0.00016009808, 0.0054473877, 0.020233154, 0.021316528, 0.063964844, 0.015045166, 0.050201416, 0.046447754, 0.012908936, -0.028366089, -0.046661377, -0.0047454834, 0.000077068806, -0.046661377, -0.014450073, 0.023254395, 0.009269714, -0.025848389, 0.04800415, -0.03643799, 0.042510986, 0.0020141602, -0.0063095093, 0.005153656, -0.014945984, -0.024612427, 0.018920898, -0.0050468445, 0.0064582825, 0.0071983337, 0.027114868, -0.03982544, 0.03225708, -0.042053223, 0.024765015, -0.03050232, 0.047332764, 0.0023059845, -0.010543823, -0.029434204, -0.0070381165, 0.07550049, -0.0052604675, -0.0031909943, 0.0013685226, 0.010520935, 0.0021896362, 0.0007658005, -0.03604126, -0.00831604, 0.011161804, -0.039276123, 0.0016860962, 0.011299133, -0.010948181, -0.004940033, -0.025863647, -0.02520752, 0.01663208, -0.055755615, -0.029571533, -0.027420044, 0.054138184, 0.03387451, -0.0030975342, 0.02696228, -0.01928711, 0.002840042, 0.018585205, 0.025100708, 0.005252838, -0.009239197, 0.028060913, 0.006000519, -0.03881836, 0.027328491, -0.0017499924, 0.016021729, 0.024459839, -0.035186768, -0.034851074, -0.027282715, -0.021560669, -0.0013837814, 0.032714844, 0.021759033, -0.052124023, 0.042144775, 0.0002770424, 0.0073776245, 0.0748291, -0.008834839, -0.019058228, -0.015792847, -0.008354187, -0.01259613, -0.0012655258, -0.008232117, 0.028137207, 0.0006585121, -0.01739502, 0.02281189, -0.013618469, -0.04159546, -0.026397705, 0.016586304, -0.058135986, -0.034362793, 0.009170532, 0.0060157776, 0.0011396408, -0.035125732, 0.02722168, -0.007797241, -0.01890564, -0.0034866333, -0.0206604, 0.017974854, -0.01574707, -0.06530762, 0.053619385, -0.026321411, 0.030853271, 0.04473877, -0.0317688, 0.037261963, 0.09173584, -0.00919342, -0.004589081, 0.0038833618, 0.047180176, -0.039520264, -0.031158447, -0.0021762848, -0.022994995, -0.008605957, 0.012138367, -0.052246094, 0.016937256, 0.017715454, 0.061920166, 0.012367249, 0.046295166, 0.012176514, -0.02432251, -0.023376465, 0.014289856, -0.04623413, 0.0059814453, 0.022628784, 0.012771606, 0.031921387, -0.0019292831, -0.018569946, 0.009666443, -0.0546875, -0.020492554, 0.020050049, 0.0440979, 0.019851685, -0.027023315, -0.02583313, 0.009498596, 0.057037354, 0.012359619, -0.007507324, 0.023452759, 0.005180359, -0.04147339, 0.0031051636, -0.009651184, 0.002708435, 0.0034275055, -0.0036029816, 0.015617371, 0.0051078796, -0.029830933, 0.000095546246, -0.020523071, 0.043548584, -0.008644104, 0.02848816, -0.026412964, 0.0020332336, -0.02507019, 0.0063285828, -0.014785767, -0.023803711, 0.01586914, -0.04864502, -0.0032176971, -0.022262573, 0.00274086, -0.009109497, 0.029083252, 0.019943237, -0.022079468, -0.0053138733, 0.032684326, 0.006038666, -0.016845703, -0.0017747879, -0.02268982, -0.064453125, -0.0076675415, 0.038024902, -0.013717651, 0.009490967, -0.009140015, -0.01499176, -0.022659302, 0.0032291412, -0.01687622, -0.028396606, -0.0042495728, 0.044006348, 0.0011644363, -0.011520386, 0.013763428, 0.019638062, 0.02243042, -0.018508911, -0.005203247, -0.004547119, 0.042541504, -0.016983032, 0.0022678375, 0.016784668, 0.0064430237, 0.009109497, 0.00019013882, -0.08874512, 0.043395996, 0.030975342, 0.04119873, 0.0032844543, -0.04660034, 0.059661865, 0.05834961, -0.031341553, 0.018630981, 0.0028514862, -0.019165039, -0.010055542, -0.044433594, -0.00064754486, 0.06488037, 0.009750366, -0.029525757, 0.015945435, 0.0012302399, 0.005302429, -0.044281006, -0.040771484, -0.03375244, 0.062561035, -0.04067993, -0.064086914, -0.022445679, 0.014640808, -0.020584106, 0.044403076, 0.019577026, -0.008377075, -0.02078247, -0.02078247, -0.014846802, -0.047424316, -0.026153564, -0.01448822, 0.07006836, 0.032592773, 0.046325684, 0.0033950806, -0.0680542, 0.0524292, -0.01235199, 0.017486572, -0.013343811, -0.008331299, -0.019592285, 0.018478394, -0.030288696, -0.0016431808, 0.036468506, 0.035339355, 0.014007568, 0.04559326, -0.004009247, 0.0015563965, 0.026229858, -0.003932953, 0.019104004, -0.020767212, -0.022338867, 0.04421997, 0.02960205, 0.00944519, 0.031463623, -0.024337769, -0.016479492, -0.0017776489, 0.034729004, -0.0009613037, -0.023910522, 0.04736328, 0.014808655, -0.023529053, -0.0101623535, -0.025512695, 0.024291992, 0.008369446, -0.022888184, -0.03805542, 0.0033187866, -0.033294678, -0.0019493103, 0.038024902, -0.01727295, -0.016403198, 0.0061035156, 0.032470703, 0.009185791, 0.03729248, 0.023361206, 0.00033259392, -0.054748535, -0.0013141632, 0.0715332, 0.013748169, 0.01737976, -0.018463135, -0.058624268, -0.01600647, -0.017440796, -0.025268555, -0.023971558, 0.028213501, 0.017425537, 0.019119263, 0.024932861, -0.025405884, 0.029541016, -0.024246216, -0.0057029724, 0.001540184, 0.04510498, 0.06124878, -0.031036377, -0.053222656, -0.0021457672, 0.020141602, -0.04296875, -0.009017944, 0.022445679, -0.024597168, -0.003692627, 0.03591919, 0.013763428, -0.014183044, -0.10406494, 0.014251709, 0.010269165, 0.03286743, 0.032836914, 0.068237305, 0.013542175, 0.14746094, -0.04537964, 0.014778137, -0.02696228, 0.030899048, 0.0029659271, -0.011779785, 0.04232788, 0.008621216, 0.009170532, -0.062683105, -0.012039185, 0.008659363, -0.07873535, 0.0036506653, -0.00048160553, 0.016845703, 0.029571533, 0.0021209717, 0.0059394836, 0.07623291, 0.007598877, -0.0052108765, -0.018371582, -0.009132385, -0.010063171, 0.030944824, 0.027069092, 0.018615723, -0.02420044, 0.009757996, -0.0059661865, 0.0335083, 0.027404785, 0.019577026, -0.035888672, -0.03375244, -0.03378296, -0.0007133484, -0.02708435, 0.07141113, -0.07751465, -0.021911621, 0.019882202, 0.058013916, 0.054229736, 0.024978638, -0.009849548, -0.016204834, 0.046691895, 0.016906738, 0.0046539307, -0.0033111572, -0.04260254, 0.004085541, -0.03878784, -0.027328491, -0.011817932, 0.0023288727, 0.09869385, -0.066345215, -0.0066871643, 0.060394287, -0.0103302, 0.03692627, 0.037475586, -0.024749756, 0.012840271, 0.021728516, 0.041168213, 0.007385254, -0.027359009, -0.031280518, 0.020721436, 0.029541016, 0.011566162, 0.011245728, 0.019958496, -0.019821167, 0.03881836, 0.035339355, -0.031707764, -0.011352539, 0.055145264, -0.027038574, 0.019134521, 0.020950317, 0.030548096, -0.0099487305, 0.010253906, 0.08050537, -0.011627197, -0.01727295, 0.035369873, -0.004589081, 0.0143966675, 0.012069702, -0.027282715, -0.016403198, 0.011169434, -0.013847351, 0.004940033, 0.023727417, 0.0496521, -0.03338623, 0.00055933, 0.029724121, 0.022369385, -0.03866577, 0.02960205, -0.022384644, -0.0340271, -0.01109314, -0.01474762, 0.019180298, 0.032440186, 0.00724411, -0.0262146, 0.0132369995, -0.035095215, 0.025222778, 0.010559082, 0.027557373, 0.0138168335, -0.012298584, 0.0045661926, 0.011016846, -0.012809753, 0.009017944, 0.02482605, -0.0078125, 0.008369446, 0.009399414, 0.028884888, 0.01663208, 0.08239746, 0.00466156, 0.02760315, -0.022750854, 0.01676941, 0.058441162, -0.040283203, -0.028427124, -0.031433105, 0.02192688, 0.014190674, 0.021255493, 0.035491943, 0.04522705, -0.040985107, -0.014144897, -0.0077934265, 0.0018377304, -0.0036354065, -0.006954193, -0.045654297, -0.039489746, -0.012054443, 0.016647339, 0.036071777, -0.053985596, -0.049926758, -0.035186768, -0.01184845, -0.053344727, -0.003660202, 0.040374756, -0.0014009476, -0.047088623, 0.010917664, 0.0042648315, 0.033081055, -0.018814087, -0.014320374, -0.0013113022, 0.031982422, 0.028884888, -0.022827148, -0.03048706, 0.056030273, 0.014251709, -0.09082031, 0.03466797, 0.0000487566, -0.03955078, -0.013725281, 0.08746338, -0.02128601, -0.0022087097, -0.027130127, 0.005367279, 0.014656067, 0.01651001, -0.0018873215, -0.0073242188, -0.035186768, -0.031158447, -0.040618896, 0.052215576, 0.014122009, -0.056610107, 0.041931152, -0.017593384, 0.005695343, -0.027786255, -0.025100708, 0.015930176, -0.0047454834, 0.031143188, -0.043701172, -0.040924072, -0.013175964, 0.039093018, -0.030532837, 0.02973938, -0.005504608, -0.0036945343, 0.04348755, 0.057281494, -0.005004883, -0.02456665, -0.060333252, -0.06286621, 0.033050537, -0.007545471, -0.0062294006, -0.05734253, 0.030303955, 0.0066490173, -0.03164673, 0.01789856, -0.005897522, -0.031463623, 0.0119018555, 0.0065078735, -0.029464722, -0.01550293, 0.035217285, 0.008201599, -0.010612488, 0.008628845, -0.040283203, 0.00042271614, -0.010566711, -0.04434204, -0.04232788, 0.02571106, -0.030380249, -0.036254883, 0.015701294, 0.017074585, 0.019729614, 0.02281189, 0.002166748, -0.05432129, 0.012619019, -0.03555298, 0.05496216, -0.087402344, -0.018447876, -0.095214844, -0.040863037, 0.020736694, -0.020095825, 0.02998352, -0.045837402, 0.03881836, 0.007724762, -0.01360321, 0.01777649, 0.024246216, -0.0022029877, -0.019180298, 0.0037708282, 0.058166504, 0.010047913, 0.00045204163 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1501.02629v4
Scaling-up Empirical Risk Minimization: Optimization of Incomplete U-statistics
Stéphan Clémençon, Aurélien Bellet, Igor Colin
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG
In a wide range of statistical learning problems such as ranking, clustering or metric learning among others, the risk is accurately estimated by $U$-statistics of degree $d\geq 1$, i.e. functionals of the training data with low variance that take the form of averages over $k$-tuples. From a computational perspective, the calculation of such statistics is highly expensive even for a moderate sample size $n$, as it requires averaging $O(n^d)$ terms. This makes learning procedures relying on the optimization of such data functionals hardly feasible in practice. It is the major goal of this paper to show that, strikingly, such empirical risks can be replaced by drastically computationally simpler Monte-Carlo estimates based on $O(n)$ terms only, usually referred to as incomplete $U$-statistics, without damaging the $O_{\mathbb{P}}(1/\sqrt{n})$ learning rate of Empirical Risk Minimization (ERM) procedures. For this purpose, we establish uniform deviation results describing the error made when approximating a $U$-process by its incomplete version under appropriate complexity assumptions. Extensions to model selection, fast rate situations and various sampling techniques are also considered, as well as an application to stochastic gradient descent for ERM. Finally, numerical examples are displayed in order to provide strong empirical evidence that the approach we promote largely surpasses more naive subsampling techniques.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1501.02629v4
2016-04-19T06:30:09
2015-01-12T12:58:45
{ "title": [ -0.031158447, 0.024337769, -0.040039062, -0.02973938, 0.00868988, 0.006587982, -0.03955078, -0.038757324, -0.044677734, 0.015487671, -0.018112183, 0.035858154, 0.012687683, -0.032440186, 0.018188477, -0.0042037964, 0.00032114983, 0.022644043, -0.025970459, -0.04537964, -0.019943237, -0.054534912, 0.042297363, 0.07739258, -0.016418457, -0.032409668, -0.0051116943, 0.013641357, -0.060546875, -0.045532227, -0.016448975, 0.058166504, 0.026748657, 0.018814087, 0.022460938, 0.01373291, -0.02456665, 0.014305115, 0.01928711, 0.024230957, -0.012741089, 0.006603241, 0.019424438, -0.021148682, -0.012878418, 0.013847351, -0.042236328, -0.026351929, -0.03189087, 0.05722046, 0.014968872, -0.032196045, 0.001285553, 0.04046631, 0.016281128, -0.01939392, -0.008705139, -0.029846191, 0.036376953, 0.056121826, 0.0051116943, -0.046447754, 0.004020691, -0.04107666, -0.012451172, -0.028549194, -0.023132324, 0.032043457, 0.050048828, 0.043426514, -0.001086235, 0.014099121, 0.018066406, 0.035827637, -0.03665161, -0.038970947, 0.03933716, -0.0023937225, 0.044708252, 0.0021800995, -0.008865356, -0.0390625, -0.028060913, -0.035980225, 0.024917603, -0.02508545, -0.006576538, -0.0019721985, 0.004699707, -0.03353882, -0.0047798157, -0.035339355, -0.001077652, 0.050567627, -0.008911133, -0.009063721, -0.008842468, 0.043029785, 0.03152466, -0.020568848, -0.0051574707, -0.0010089874, -0.06213379, -0.006752014, 0.003250122, 0.026626587, -0.018463135, -0.029586792, 0.018722534, 0.018066406, -0.0039482117, -0.014419556, 0.005142212, 0.006706238, 0.006893158, 0.0031776428, -0.006931305, 0.028305054, 0.00040388107, 0.030944824, -0.020370483, -0.0055007935, -0.007041931, -0.024856567, 0.03060913, -0.026947021, -0.029464722, 0.023651123, -0.025665283, 0.01399231, -0.003364563, 0.053344727, -0.0848999, -0.064208984, -0.068481445, 0.030853271, -0.05319214, -0.03842163, 0.004032135, -0.01423645, 0.03250122, -0.041259766, 0.014503479, 0.023513794, 0.013641357, 0.014015198, 0.052581787, -0.0063209534, -0.03567505, -0.011184692, -0.04058838, 0.04031372, 0.03439331, -0.009925842, -0.07910156, -0.014518738, -0.11810303, 0.0027675629, 0.025650024, 0.0005965233, 0.012123108, -0.017486572, -0.046447754, 0.006263733, 0.03503418, 0.007713318, 0.0066337585, 0.043548584, 0.012062073, 0.04598999, -0.019363403, -0.0033130646, 0.009170532, 0.010643005, -0.0030021667, 0.020385742, 0.03515625, 0.041259766, 0.021331787, -0.054229736, 0.010871887, -0.015701294, 0.046295166, 0.04095459, -0.07171631, -0.005168915, -0.022979736, -0.0010309219, 0.062561035, 0.0010061264, -0.015335083, 0.009254456, -0.09234619, -0.04257202, -0.036590576, 0.015975952, -0.0014019012, 0.022872925, -0.00983429, 0.037200928, -0.022384644, 0.01084137, -0.05078125, 0.026412964, 0.011543274, -0.05722046, 0.003036499, -0.0009031296, -0.052734375, 0.05126953, 0.0680542, 0.0008687973, -0.061828613, 0.04171753, 0.03567505, -0.034057617, 0.046844482, -0.0048217773, -0.019622803, -0.025772095, -0.02104187, 0.0104522705, -0.020584106, 0.083862305, 0.027893066, 0.015655518, -0.00045204163, -0.03652954, 0.059265137, 0.006034851, 0.0625, -0.009155273, -0.018920898, 0.017715454, -0.0017652512, 0.012901306, 0.0071754456, 0.06329346, 0.00083494186, -0.016525269, 0.020767212, -0.005569458, 0.0115356445, 0.017669678, 0.033599854, 0.007671356, 0.028137207, -0.0024681091, 0.019989014, -0.0021038055, 0.09136963, 0.004196167, 0.064208984, 0.019485474, 0.031433105, 0.057006836, -0.021987915, 0.038482666, -0.029785156, 0.02017212, -0.02053833, 0.0040779114, 0.027908325, -0.019180298, -0.050079346, -0.012825012, -0.012130737, 0.015670776, 0.02319336, -0.021636963, 0.022384644, -0.041809082, 0.008514404, -0.011947632, 0.0027694702, -0.0063056946, 0.0004775524, 0.015029907, 0.007583618, -0.05239868, -0.0019054413, 0.031066895, 0.054656982, 0.007583618, 0.0104522705, -0.008705139, 0.022857666, 0.0026397705, 0.026397705, -0.010246277, 0.055633545, 0.004234314, -0.0029182434, 0.0076522827, 0.01751709, -0.03074646, 0.010665894, 0.03149414, -0.020050049, 0.026779175, -0.044433594, 0.028396606, 0.04727173, -0.030700684, 0.02027893, 0.053649902, 0.04852295, 0.025100708, 0.0055618286, 0.003660202, -0.014839172, 0.016784668, 0.01247406, -0.04864502, -0.01411438, -0.025146484, 0.0010967255, -0.022155762, -0.014556885, 0.0062789917, 0.024429321, 0.005722046, -0.034576416, -0.038970947, 0.021392822, -0.017211914, -0.07232666, -0.018692017, -0.014823914, -0.0043411255, 0.0056610107, -0.013031006, -0.076293945, -0.04397583, -0.013885498, -0.010848999, -0.017242432, 0.06762695, -0.019836426, 0.017913818, -0.021316528, -0.033477783, 0.00932312, -0.06100464, -0.003993988, -0.029266357, -0.005241394, 0.01550293, -0.057678223, 0.0030078888, 0.016647339, -0.032562256, -0.05999756, -0.0023326874, 0.012237549, 0.0060691833, 0.037475586, 0.013198853, 0.012039185, -0.020568848, 0.057739258, 0.00044679642, -0.009048462, -0.019622803, 0.015716553, -0.076049805, -0.0036144257, -0.046844482, -0.004386902, 0.068603516, -0.040039062, -0.008987427, -0.07800293, -0.012702942, -0.0126953125, 0.013145447, -0.008682251, -0.02760315, -0.037841797, -0.0234375, -0.0018911362, -0.0048179626, 0.00086402893, -0.0013751984, 0.10455322, -0.0030345917, 0.0034599304, 0.019088745, 0.03466797, 0.008148193, -0.03338623, -0.04473877, 0.0018453598, 0.0049438477, -0.010131836, 0.022735596, -0.008743286, -0.04812622, -0.03189087, 0.008979797, 0.038970947, -0.04800415, -0.025344849, -0.018722534, -0.03842163, 0.008155823, -0.009376526, -0.0032291412, 0.026184082, 0.0592041, -0.024597168, 0.026184082, 0.0072021484, -0.032562256, 0.012290955, -0.00012898445, -0.047851562, 0.048980713, -0.031234741, -0.078308105, -0.0002529621, 0.0062446594, -0.033050537, -0.01965332, -0.011016846, 0.027542114, 0.026123047, 0.021636963, 0.00039863586, 0.0035972595, 0.003145218, -0.02432251, -0.013046265, -0.013252258, -0.011192322, -0.014122009, -0.026062012, 0.008331299, -0.015556335, 0.0022563934, -0.0149002075, -0.027679443, 0.010047913, 0.033721924, 0.015144348, -0.028259277, -0.035949707, -0.0065612793, 0.023468018, 0.053253174, -0.02796936, -0.024551392, -0.052642822, 0.0049209595, -0.059051514, 0.06567383, 0.006160736, 0.032989502, -0.0149002075, -0.016403198, -0.01259613, -0.032958984, -0.01020813, 0.012084961, -0.011238098, 0.013702393, 0.043762207, -0.0090789795, -0.0132369995, -0.010520935, -0.048950195, 0.031204224, 0.011787415, 0.024261475, -0.03338623, 0.0126953125, -0.005218506, 0.02432251, -0.0184021, 0.00006645918, 0.04586792, -0.022628784, 0.037322998, -0.046325684, -0.0061035156, 0.021575928, -0.10394287, -0.004043579, -0.014556885, -0.026382446, -0.03378296, -0.030258179, 0.00009614229, -0.019851685, -0.040740967, -0.020431519, -0.0067634583, -0.015380859, 0.017227173, -0.043670654, -0.02607727, 0.07116699, -0.020248413, 0.002456665, -0.007949829, 0.00058460236, -0.007843018, -0.0463562, 0.0069351196, -0.0501709, 0.024520874, -0.035308838, -0.005657196, 0.02319336, -0.013885498, -0.010635376, 0.033325195, 0.012512207, -0.024368286, -0.0018930435, -0.000072836876, 0.031707764, -0.037261963, 0.05328369, 0.056671143, -0.04055786, -0.054504395, 0.0012359619, 0.010856628, -0.017120361, 0.009002686, -0.02507019, 0.005630493, 0.023788452, 0.02053833, 0.040039062, 0.0015001297, -0.005065918, 0.016983032, -0.03756714, -0.017501831, 0.009094238, 0.025650024, 0.0052490234, -0.020111084, -0.014091492, -0.057861328, 0.0017910004, 0.013580322, -0.026245117, -0.009353638, 0.0060768127, -0.022247314, -0.014373779, -0.07562256, 0.023147583, -0.015419006, 0.01940918, -0.012001038, 0.020874023, -0.004875183, -0.047027588, -0.042663574, 0.052642822, 0.05606079, 0.002117157, -0.0029506683, -0.053771973, 0.016067505, 0.013435364, -0.025894165, -0.05307007, 0.031921387, 0.001408577, 0.024017334, -0.036102295, -0.0006570816, 0.025741577, 0.020141602, -0.0027828217, 0.029434204, -0.03189087, -0.026611328, -0.012741089, -0.037231445, -0.015060425, 0.049316406, -0.021011353, -0.009483337, -0.0070533752, 0.04159546, -0.022155762, -0.032348633, -0.0012950897, 0.02355957, -0.0044517517, 0.03567505, 0.021362305, 0.087890625, 0.030670166, 0.021957397, 0.011802673, 0.020568848, -0.029815674, 0.013282776, 0.028427124, 0.033355713, 0.06427002, 0.002292633, 0.03527832, 0.0007343292, -0.04171753, 0.022750854, 0.011383057, 0.041381836, 0.016998291, 0.0046653748, 0.03125, -0.0036010742, -0.021255493, -0.0007195473, 0.011947632, 0.015487671, -0.082214355, 0.011650085, 0.0001154542, 0.013122559, 0.025238037, -0.021453857, 0.027572632, 0.030685425, 0.014282227, -0.06088257, -0.033050537, 0.009918213, 0.051239014, -0.036132812, -0.004211426, -0.027038574, 0.032562256, -0.005382538, 0.06286621, 0.0146484375, 0.015350342, -0.005455017, -0.01852417, -0.005050659, -0.038024902, -0.057434082, -0.009803772, 0.0049705505, 0.013641357, -0.05078125, 0.04196167, -0.049926758, 0.008224487, -0.0026950836, 0.036346436, -0.015296936, -0.056274414, 0.012161255, 0.017242432, 0.054229736, -0.016189575, -0.041625977, -0.003862381, 0.05319214, 0.013633728, 0.026992798, -0.037872314, 0.0121154785, 0.0034751892, 0.00017237663, -0.018310547, 0.0256958, -0.027236938, 0.026107788, -0.0054016113, 0.003145218, -0.08135986, 0.02658081, 0.033813477, 0.006099701, -0.012069702, -0.03277588, 0.0033111572, 0.016281128, -0.0036792755, 0.016311646, 0.023773193, -0.00054359436, 0.024154663, -0.019882202, -0.028564453, -0.021972656, -0.023391724, -0.038879395, 0.017166138, -0.015327454, -0.0036182404, 0.011413574, 0.021636963, 0.03387451, 0.0002310276, 0.021102905, 0.055267334, -0.05633545, -0.0029277802, -0.017364502, 0.029067993, 0.022918701, 0.005355835, -0.04498291, 0.013656616, -0.041015625, -0.046661377, -0.033416748, 0.0026302338, 0.00932312, 0.028778076, -0.0034275055, -0.00013279915, 0.048950195, 0.0072898865, 0.052978516, 0.03390503, -0.02986145, 0.03591919, 0.010818481, -0.015899658, 0.0025978088, 0.00541687, -0.012626648, 0.008636475, 0.024108887, -0.04043579, 0.02709961, -0.017410278, -0.022033691, -0.028320312, -0.0033855438, -0.0069999695, 0.02381897, -0.026000977, -0.03048706, 0.031402588, 0.030166626, 0.016174316, -0.019851685, -0.010215759, 0.046295166, -0.021697998, -0.06994629, 0.0065460205, -0.0030975342, 0.0022182465, 0.057373047, 0.020019531, -0.049682617, -0.020904541, -0.014320374, -0.03579712, -0.008666992, 0.020309448, -0.022659302, 0.023895264, -0.018966675, 0.0029945374, -0.016067505, -0.018096924, -0.032958984, 0.02482605, -0.010185242, -0.060546875, 0.019332886, -0.0027103424, -0.0055351257, -0.037963867, 0.005207062, -0.007217407, 0.014373779, -0.020721436, -0.008239746, 0.0071754456, -0.019821167, -0.046783447, 0.04925537, 0.009399414, -0.023223877, 0.07623291, -0.02909851, 0.036376953, 0.029037476, 0.01675415, 0.082336426, 0.07128906, -0.030670166, -0.006427765, -0.0013189316, -0.019424438, -0.050750732, -0.011474609, -0.0035438538, -0.0035915375, 0.016433716, -0.07489014, 0.05508423, 0.011100769, 0.009223938, 0.013214111, 0.0004837513, -0.004673004, -0.01651001, 0.011024475, 0.023803711, 0.063964844, 0.04776001, -0.00015258789, 0.0070877075, 0.029663086, -0.013114929, 0.023971558, 0.012268066, 0.01235199, -0.044769287, -0.021621704, 0.0018825531, 0.024414062, 0.019683838, 0.00157547, -0.025466919, -0.040405273, 0.05014038, 0.028213501, 0.041778564, 0.031036377, 0.0035533905, 0.015434265, -0.04067993, -0.00730896, 0.019256592, -0.060180664, 0.046875, 0.06124878, -0.10321045, 0.014076233, -0.0072746277, -0.016403198, 0.04647827, 0.024124146, 0.04876709, -0.06573486, -0.06781006, 0.019515991, 0.033996582, 0.035247803, 0.04333496, -0.032287598, -0.012161255, -0.0012865067, 0.027664185, 0.014709473, 0.013496399, -0.024261475, -0.0009121895, -0.024124146, -0.040374756, 0.015640259, 0.035858154, -0.004852295, 0.035583496, -0.023239136, 0.05029297, -0.00022244453, -0.039642334, 0.02507019, 0.0029449463, -0.076416016, 0.012939453, 0.017868042, 0.0099487305, 0.017227173, 0.032043457, 0.0028018951, -0.016693115, -0.02545166, -0.05645752, 0.0317688, 0.015380859, -0.0112838745, 0.047546387, -0.066467285, -0.05014038, 0.068481445, -0.05065918, 0.083984375, -0.03741455, 0.02418518, -0.00077724457, -0.00006902218, 0.04135132, -0.03338623, -0.027618408, 0.009384155, -0.0064697266, -0.0014314651, 0.0066375732, -0.004787445, -0.041503906, 0.0035896301, 0.05670166, 0.0037384033, 0.002696991, 0.014335632, -0.02243042, -0.06530762, 0.0048675537, -0.038970947, 0.04763794, -0.025466919, -0.024871826, -0.01739502, 0.00011873245, 0.021255493, -0.058166504, -0.023849487, -0.062438965, -0.01751709, -0.0026683807, -0.0019197464, 0.0076293945, -0.024871826, -0.022399902, 0.06451416, -0.0071868896, -0.027175903, 0.0104599, 0.026977539, -0.038116455, -0.02861023, 0.008094788, -0.020126343, 0.0647583, 0.013900757, -0.0134887695, -0.033172607, 0.039611816, -0.018585205, -0.041168213, -0.0067329407, 0.009399414, -0.043914795, -0.05834961, 0.010032654, 0.05319214, 0.06726074, -0.0041923523, 0.007091522, 0.029006958, -0.034576416, -0.021469116, 0.019210815, 0.020126343, 0.0022830963, 0.014480591, 0.05203247, -0.006149292, -0.04284668, -0.017486572, -0.006252289, 0.039764404, 0.039031982, 0.00094890594, -0.016738892, 0.0074806213, 0.0061149597, 0.003232956, 0.01626587, -0.012008667, -0.0012645721, 0.0041122437, 0.05343628, 0.0033683777, -0.045959473, -0.01776123, 0.013191223, 0.007286072, -0.020187378, 0.030975342, 0.017288208, -0.04043579, 0.07751465, -0.01399231, -0.01309967, 0.020828247, 0.021606445, 0.020401001, -0.007247925, -0.010002136, 0.014549255, -0.009895325, -0.002456665, -0.0007019043, 0.004257202, 0.0090408325, -0.03503418, 0.017089844, -0.049194336, -0.046661377, -0.007205963, -0.050048828, 0.033996582, -0.003484726, 0.02420044, -0.010269165, 0.003118515, 0.013656616, 0.023208618, 0.03753662, -0.020431519, -0.025436401, -0.018661499, 0.03930664, -0.0036811829 ], "summary": [ 0.018966675, 0.0014438629, 0.021438599, 0.013328552, -0.030532837, -0.0010318756, -0.0119018555, -0.05319214, -0.04446411, 0.0002527237, -0.08654785, 0.052490234, 0.020217896, -0.0067825317, 0.071777344, -0.04925537, 0.005519867, 0.04360962, 0.018676758, -0.022140503, 0.0033683777, -0.014709473, 0.0017271042, 0.014152527, 0.0007619858, -0.010910034, -0.012397766, 0.005844116, -0.009338379, 0.005001068, 0.0038471222, 0.00024175644, -0.014633179, 0.0501709, 0.0022125244, 0.03161621, 0.001912117, 0.022033691, 0.040496826, 0.0032958984, -0.0035629272, 0.0015268326, 0.0859375, -0.040893555, 0.023010254, 0.044677734, -0.012237549, -0.031921387, 0.004962921, 0.023040771, 0.0040016174, 0.0025939941, 0.0023784637, 0.026260376, -0.017745972, -0.014305115, 0.004486084, -0.037963867, 0.016906738, 0.05618286, 0.014633179, 0.0078048706, -0.011230469, -0.04107666, 0.0143585205, -0.010002136, 0.019210815, -0.0020427704, 0.0008325577, 0.048858643, 0.051727295, 0.0059890747, 0.026504517, -0.025039673, -0.008979797, -0.013305664, 0.04827881, -0.0026893616, -0.0040245056, -0.0066604614, -0.010887146, 0.012428284, -0.028839111, -0.078308105, 0.019378662, -0.04324341, -0.019866943, 0.005432129, 0.013206482, -0.018707275, -0.014724731, -0.047332764, -0.018798828, 0.04663086, 0.011329651, -0.02178955, -0.0019102097, 0.0046844482, 0.0317688, -0.03744507, 0.012138367, -0.020767212, -0.045135498, 0.00806427, -0.006313324, 0.038208008, 0.019561768, -0.02619934, 0.002122879, -0.008361816, -0.016799927, -0.021087646, -0.01751709, -0.05722046, -0.0013818741, 0.06335449, 0.027496338, 0.013916016, 0.021133423, -0.00057697296, -0.028030396, 0.018463135, -0.036590576, 0.009941101, 0.023605347, -0.000446558, 0.024414062, 0.009407043, -0.031585693, 0.03817749, -0.016845703, 0.031036377, -0.06188965, -0.04055786, -0.06286621, -0.023208618, -0.022598267, -0.006816864, -0.003932953, -0.03640747, 0.0368042, -0.03112793, -0.018798828, 0.02507019, 0.012123108, 0.012794495, 0.013648987, -0.00080776215, -0.011390686, -0.0012464523, -0.04473877, 0.02810669, 0.031311035, -0.019729614, -0.06173706, -0.0418396, -0.06311035, 0.0068092346, 0.04458618, -0.016281128, 0.002281189, -0.033325195, -0.057891846, 0.04827881, 0.010116577, 0.035491943, 0.052368164, 0.015686035, 0.008666992, -0.002626419, 0.0042419434, -0.011688232, 0.009674072, 0.021560669, 0.018035889, 0.037384033, 0.01737976, 0.06347656, -0.021575928, 0.018005371, 0.03555298, -0.031311035, 0.05117798, 0.011077881, -0.023101807, -0.02961731, -0.018875122, 0.0023155212, 0.07720947, 0.015174866, -0.0048599243, -0.03451538, -0.048919678, -0.012451172, -0.029129028, 0.018371582, -0.01348114, 0.011169434, -0.018035889, 0.029556274, -0.014266968, 0.008979797, -0.041381836, 0.017669678, -0.03555298, -0.030929565, 0.007144928, 0.014587402, -0.07080078, 0.028335571, 0.03543091, -0.012466431, -0.04837036, 0.082458496, 0.062438965, -0.04055786, 0.032409668, -0.012283325, -0.033477783, -0.026672363, -0.019714355, 0.012512207, -0.036132812, 0.07965088, 0.019058228, 0.03756714, -0.02722168, 0.026168823, 0.025558472, 0.017471313, 0.03451538, 0.0023155212, -0.026535034, 0.02748108, 0.0013551712, 0.009475708, 0.029769897, 0.00061893463, 0.026870728, 0.0059165955, 0.025619507, -0.006877899, -0.010543823, -0.006061554, 0.0446167, 0.019882202, 0.020019531, -0.016540527, -0.03213501, -0.009559631, 0.08355713, -0.00093984604, 0.011680603, -0.01828003, 0.01398468, 0.014190674, -0.01461792, 0.014778137, -0.0059394836, -0.0135650635, -0.010215759, -0.02116394, 0.005268097, -0.019989014, -0.033325195, -0.01713562, -0.0028018951, 0.0012645721, 0.035491943, -0.041748047, -0.0032234192, -0.06021118, -0.011619568, -0.028259277, -0.04043579, -0.043945312, -0.03414917, 0.062194824, -0.011222839, -0.036010742, 0.0013380051, 0.027999878, 0.028839111, -0.008224487, 0.014442444, -0.015197754, 0.028747559, 0.005268097, 0.03579712, 0.03262329, 0.07067871, -0.015350342, -0.005367279, -0.0068244934, -0.00079250336, -0.04333496, 0.0038318634, 0.0027103424, 0.0015487671, -0.00039935112, 0.0031051636, 0.043518066, 0.01687622, -0.022125244, 0.017211914, 0.02947998, 0.028366089, 0.0051116943, 0.0015106201, -0.008651733, -0.03189087, -0.011314392, 0.02796936, 0.030441284, -0.018051147, -0.028396606, -0.017822266, 0.025039673, 0.0066337585, 0.05493164, 0.056427002, 0.027130127, -0.032470703, 0.0033740997, 0.006717682, -0.020019531, -0.001584053, -0.026672363, 0.005634308, -0.010726929, -0.04699707, -0.021194458, -0.059326172, -0.014472961, -0.010169983, -0.00674057, 0.010215759, 0.034240723, 0.0020713806, 0.009902954, 0.0070152283, 0.0035438538, -0.0004451275, -0.038726807, -0.057128906, -0.0028800964, 0.000477314, -0.0028648376, -0.057861328, -0.013916016, 0.04019165, -0.017730713, -0.068237305, 0.018066406, -0.02859497, 0.025634766, 0.088012695, 0.023666382, -0.00047636032, -0.013046265, 0.019363403, 0.012390137, -0.004749298, -0.07055664, -0.020721436, -0.04446411, -0.003484726, -0.026504517, -0.01625061, 0.041809082, -0.031555176, 0.035217285, -0.060546875, -0.026428223, -0.016677856, 0.033355713, 0.07067871, 0.0060310364, -0.021362305, 0.029006958, 0.0037555695, -0.012458801, 0.021392822, -0.023086548, 0.048065186, -0.000041902065, -0.013504028, 0.00806427, 0.027114868, 0.007835388, -0.011398315, -0.0073890686, 0.057739258, -0.021011353, -0.03829956, -0.006904602, -0.002193451, -0.021621704, 0.040893555, 0.016342163, 0.0065841675, -0.04916382, -0.026519775, -0.0023536682, 0.011741638, 0.03387451, 0.016067505, -0.02015686, 0.019805908, -0.012916565, 0.012016296, -0.03491211, 0.0340271, -0.061309814, -0.00932312, -0.010765076, 0.047424316, 0.021408081, -0.04876709, -0.056854248, -0.0078125, 0.07904053, -0.006401062, -0.02923584, 0.0018358231, -0.026138306, 0.0049743652, 0.004299164, -0.04220581, 0.05621338, 0.011146545, -0.010406494, 0.0031414032, 0.00071668625, -0.050598145, 0.019302368, -0.010604858, 0.020462036, 0.008270264, -0.0423584, -0.007827759, 0.009849548, 0.04446411, 0.04034424, 0.019729614, -0.002445221, -0.004085541, -0.01713562, 0.029052734, 0.053588867, -0.033843994, -0.022583008, -0.006164551, 0.025894165, -0.051361084, 0.0519104, 0.0070152283, 0.038238525, -0.0018892288, -0.026428223, -0.0057640076, -0.019699097, -0.007045746, -0.003955841, 0.03286743, 0.0067749023, -0.017044067, -0.006011963, -0.024124146, 0.016098022, -0.009483337, -0.001004219, -0.003047943, -0.015289307, -0.008262634, -0.035125732, 0.017929077, 0.019943237, 0.015838623, -0.020126343, -0.01007843, 0.0069007874, -0.0027751923, -0.06213379, -0.012870789, 0.01373291, -0.06616211, -0.028030396, 0.0074768066, 0.025802612, 0.009788513, -0.0033893585, 0.06072998, 0.0058059692, 0.009346008, 0.004131317, -0.01663208, 0.081726074, 0.031219482, -0.0231781, 0.0076522827, -0.019958496, -0.0011100769, -0.00868988, -0.052520752, 0.026657104, 0.07196045, 0.0029144287, 0.015075684, -0.059936523, 0.06274414, -0.049804688, 0.03591919, 0.020736694, -0.013389587, -0.024215698, 0.025283813, 0.02230835, -0.02330017, -0.0062408447, 0.031311035, 0.044525146, -0.02355957, 0.008903503, 0.036224365, 0.009674072, -0.033843994, 0.02381897, -0.020629883, 0.0046081543, 0.034484863, 0.033996582, -0.0034618378, -0.013076782, -0.006340027, -0.038269043, -0.019256592, -0.024505615, -0.030181885, -0.009490967, -0.03451538, -0.01197052, 0.020080566, 0.029708862, -0.017440796, -0.0184021, -0.024429321, 0.010246277, -0.030258179, 0.00983429, -0.0019626617, -0.0038223267, -0.023391724, -0.022918701, -0.015434265, 0.052368164, -0.028701782, 0.008888245, -0.0013532639, 0.011108398, -0.018615723, -0.030288696, -0.004798889, 0.03137207, 0.034576416, 0.020584106, -0.013923645, -0.04486084, -0.06756592, 0.025970459, -0.023162842, 0.0011177063, -0.016098022, -0.031341553, -0.012336731, -0.027496338, -0.03152466, 0.019622803, 0.02859497, 0.05709839, -0.0028190613, -0.021224976, -0.057647705, -0.06976318, -0.04763794, -0.018341064, 0.072387695, -0.048095703, -0.0146484375, -0.0025024414, 0.056640625, -0.015213013, -0.074035645, -0.0037727356, 0.034118652, 0.015457153, 0.05441284, 0.06781006, 0.11047363, 0.040283203, 0.008171082, 0.051086426, 0.037109375, -0.011482239, -0.027893066, 0.03488159, -0.017044067, 0.05267334, 0.0019426346, 0.012260437, -0.027832031, -0.024169922, 0.020050049, -0.020645142, 0.036743164, 0.012130737, -0.002872467, 0.026870728, -0.012435913, -0.010681152, 0.00062179565, -0.019256592, -0.002960205, -0.03451538, -0.021347046, 0.029663086, 0.004928589, 0.0256958, -0.017547607, 0.00969696, 0.03237915, -0.006542206, -0.033111572, -0.02230835, -0.002298355, 0.038238525, -0.008483887, -0.026779175, -0.023986816, 0.013412476, 0.008728027, -0.0006322861, -0.03074646, -0.046844482, -0.023422241, -0.035461426, -0.035980225, -0.0151901245, -0.022445679, -0.031951904, 0.025527954, 0.020889282, -0.021972656, 0.037139893, -0.004814148, 0.02961731, -0.030883789, 0.037841797, -0.035339355, -0.034088135, -0.04525757, -0.027526855, 0.053588867, -0.05404663, -0.016357422, 0.0014982224, 0.024291992, -0.010017395, 0.02128601, -0.072143555, -0.019836426, 0.015014648, 0.025756836, -0.017547607, 0.036895752, 0.0069351196, 0.0017995834, -0.006374359, 0.01626587, -0.05569458, -0.0027236938, 0.034301758, 0.039764404, -0.024337769, -0.023330688, 0.031982422, -0.011413574, -0.016296387, -0.004470825, 0.03567505, 0.054840088, 0.07098389, -0.01751709, 0.009399414, -0.03643799, -0.03817749, 0.0118255615, -0.0020427704, -0.028121948, -0.07550049, -0.0030002594, 0.042541504, -0.012512207, 0.023468018, -0.021911621, 0.015655518, -0.012710571, 0.015098572, 0.014968872, 0.031463623, 0.011772156, -0.026016235, -0.049835205, 0.010902405, -0.040100098, -0.034729004, -0.052246094, -0.0022296906, 0.021850586, 0.05267334, -0.0035858154, 0.0491333, 0.09197998, -0.07232666, 0.03338623, 0.0066871643, 0.014312744, 0.008590698, -0.01979065, -0.025863647, 0.003080368, -0.01966858, 0.007972717, 0.0023021698, -0.001581192, -0.049804688, 0.034973145, 0.00730896, 0.03427124, -0.0070877075, 0.022903442, -0.011009216, 0.03125, 0.00008267164, -0.012649536, -0.000056684017, 0.00548172, 0.010147095, -0.009338379, -0.014442444, 0.043548584, -0.010520935, -0.018707275, -0.022369385, 0.007091522, -0.060058594, 0.0020751953, 0.031433105, 0.0036334991, -0.020828247, -0.022857666, -0.0036354065, -0.01979065, -0.010147095, -0.028503418, -0.022781372, 0.0018157959, 0.0005745888, -0.020614624, -0.06854248, -0.038482666, 0.031799316, -0.02015686, -0.08123779, 0.08154297, -0.06274414, 0.013221741, -0.040863037, 0.023071289, -0.009109497, 0.01083374, -0.00033855438, 0.026443481, 0.017288208, -0.01777649, 0.0033988953, 0.03640747, 0.014213562, -0.017562866, 0.027374268, 0.0129776, 0.034423828, 0.058807373, -0.05126953, 0.006084442, -0.018234253, -0.041778564, 0.0010480881, -0.031082153, -0.023956299, -0.037078857, 0.01864624, -0.057678223, -0.010246277, -0.022949219, 0.0057144165, 0.049468994, -0.024673462, -0.007987976, 0.05368042, -0.015625, 0.017211914, 0.033050537, -0.074035645, 0.01084137, -0.014175415, -0.01689148, -0.017822266, -0.0101623535, 0.025222778, -0.0028800964, 0.023269653, -0.004764557, 0.04864502, -0.014404297, -0.024169922, 0.06817627, -0.027893066, -0.02684021, -0.047424316, 0.013885498, -0.06439209, 0.04434204, 0.016784668, 0.04208374, 0.022872925, -0.032043457, 0.05230713, -0.041778564, -0.011154175, 0.035949707, -0.052001953, 0.056121826, 0.051940918, -0.04647827, 0.0027008057, 0.011161804, -0.015625, 0.09472656, 0.061706543, 0.01751709, -0.042388916, -0.026184082, 0.008155823, -0.002254486, 0.023712158, 0.025466919, -0.017578125, -0.009735107, 0.0074424744, 0.0099487305, 0.011558533, 0.036102295, -0.009544373, -0.025390625, -0.046142578, -0.021774292, 0.018096924, 0.033203125, -0.0049819946, 0.010047913, -0.055877686, 0.06774902, 0.032196045, -0.015068054, 0.040740967, 0.039123535, -0.06414795, 0.05886841, 0.025436401, 0.07574463, 0.038879395, 0.058624268, -0.014953613, 0.0007481575, 0.043884277, -0.003742218, 0.021850586, -0.035308838, 0.0061836243, 0.005836487, -0.018981934, 0.00932312, 0.02330017, -0.0054473877, 0.043182373, -0.04034424, 0.0028324127, -0.00687027, -0.027175903, -0.027908325, 0.011932373, 0.046691895, -0.04486084, -0.030014038, 0.018051147, 0.06311035, -0.03125, -0.031082153, -0.013877869, -0.02406311, -0.03857422, 0.008735657, 0.04434204, -0.020248413, -0.024276733, 0.03845215, -0.011520386, 0.076416016, -0.047546387, -0.0072669983, 0.024795532, 0.010055542, 0.0077705383, -0.09173584, -0.026672363, -0.048614502, 0.038116455, -0.04547119, -0.00031256676, 0.017959595, -0.02142334, -0.025146484, 0.0541687, -0.007286072, -0.020950317, 0.020309448, 0.006843567, -0.023147583, -0.011528015, 0.01600647, -0.034820557, 0.022201538, 0.00831604, 0.0107040405, -0.035583496, 0.028213501, -0.0029144287, -0.020706177, 0.027175903, 0.027526855, -0.010353088, -0.04473877, -0.01033783, 0.03640747, 0.08282471, 0.015258789, 0.01486969, 0.027542114, -0.059906006, -0.023483276, -0.015327454, -0.006511688, 0.011703491, 0.0491333, 0.039916992, -0.0019369125, -0.027801514, 0.0077667236, -0.00356102, 0.060791016, 0.015403748, -0.04244995, 0.029067993, -0.0027103424, -0.012123108, 0.0017595291, -0.012504578, 0.0023040771, -0.03543091, -0.0036067963, 0.027191162, 0.011123657, -0.052215576, -0.026306152, -0.03074646, 0.015136719, -0.032806396, 0.034606934, -0.0055618286, -0.05493164, 0.06506348, 0.004337311, 0.0069732666, -0.0034370422, -0.018997192, 0.03564453, -0.05038452, 0.025146484, 0.012718201, -0.02571106, -0.004146576, 0.015930176, 0.022506714, 0.022262573, -0.050872803, 0.024261475, -0.085632324, -0.039886475, -0.00093460083, -0.045562744, 0.03466797, -0.039520264, 0.030090332, 0.0075302124, -0.016464233, 0.034118652, -0.015380859, 0.052734375, 0.0033931732, 0.04284668, 0.008468628, -0.010955811, 0.0152282715 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1703.01026v1
Unsupervised Basis Function Adaptation for Reinforcement Learning
Edward W. Barker, Charl J. Ras
cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
When using reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms to evaluate a policy it is common, given a large state space, to introduce some form of approximation architecture for the value function (VF). The exact form of this architecture can have a significant effect on the accuracy of the VF estimate, however, and determining a suitable approximation architecture can often be a highly complex task. Consequently there is a large amount of interest in the potential for allowing RL algorithms to adaptively generate approximation architectures. We investigate a method of adapting approximation architectures which uses feedback regarding the frequency with which an agent has visited certain states to guide which areas of the state space to approximate with greater detail. This method is "unsupervised" in the sense that it makes no direct reference to reward or the VF estimate. We introduce an algorithm based upon this idea which adapts a state aggregation approximation architecture on-line. A common method of scoring a VF estimate is to weight the squared Bellman error of each state-action by the probability of that state-action occurring. Adopting this scoring method, and assuming $S$ states, we demonstrate theoretically that - provided (1) the number of cells $X$ in the state aggregation architecture is of order $\sqrt{S}\log_2{S}\ln{S}$ or greater, (2) the policy and transition function are close to deterministic, and (3) the prior for the transition function is uniformly distributed - our algorithm, used in conjunction with a suitable RL algorithm, can guarantee a score which is arbitrarily close to zero as $S$ becomes large. It is able to do this despite having only $O(X \log_2S)$ space complexity and negligible time complexity. The results take advantage of certain properties of the stationary distributions of Markov chains.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.01026v1
2017-03-03T03:24:03
2017-03-03T03:24:03
{ "title": [ 0.002204895, 0.009254456, -0.026992798, -0.032165527, 0.03074646, -0.019836426, 0.0099487305, -0.026565552, -0.007286072, 0.013114929, -0.029220581, 0.012161255, -0.0491333, -0.00667572, -0.02935791, -0.016220093, 0.0033493042, 0.021438599, -0.029464722, -0.041046143, 0.011940002, -0.04498291, 0.023208618, 0.06951904, 0.030426025, -0.015060425, -0.12207031, 0.037475586, -0.039611816, -0.016174316, -0.022262573, 0.017913818, 0.037200928, 0.02168274, -0.0063667297, -0.000323534, -0.0552063, 0.0259552, -0.003627777, 0.0049591064, 0.01991272, -0.0078125, -0.029388428, -0.031234741, -0.025436401, -0.0050315857, -0.022338867, -0.022033691, -0.02746582, 0.052337646, 0.025466919, 0.011016846, -0.021697998, 0.047058105, 0.030532837, -0.04473877, -0.025466919, -0.015930176, 0.049194336, 0.08782959, 0.017150879, -0.06304932, 0.0017547607, -0.05529785, -0.041778564, -0.036743164, 0.0037174225, 0.019699097, 0.08660889, 0.015899658, -0.019424438, 0.0513916, 0.0041770935, 0.04675293, -0.039093018, -0.051086426, 0.07489014, 0.011985779, 0.021347046, 0.0016860962, -0.009567261, -0.029907227, 0.008453369, -0.009292603, 0.0067367554, -0.030029297, -0.016067505, 0.00019145012, -0.03677368, -0.057159424, -0.009963989, 0.009277344, -0.029754639, 0.0062789917, -0.03390503, -0.021728516, -0.036590576, -0.010566711, 0.01474762, 0.0043296814, 0.00035619736, 0.012184143, -0.012641907, -0.0015163422, -0.01550293, 0.008155823, -0.0039520264, -0.029281616, -0.015403748, 0.03152466, -0.033050537, 0.009971619, 0.024261475, 0.025726318, -0.027236938, -0.01638794, 0.000011146069, -0.0011034012, 0.006084442, 0.007698059, -0.013648987, -0.02420044, 0.024215698, -0.017974854, 0.038482666, 0.018493652, -0.0423584, -0.017837524, -0.022506714, 0.038116455, 0.001543045, 0.027954102, -0.09509277, -0.06707764, -0.044799805, 0.02708435, -0.011558533, 0.016220093, -0.0031604767, 0.006706238, 0.0126953125, -0.020202637, 0.004432678, 0.01802063, 0.016662598, 0.01260376, 0.049804688, -0.009880066, -0.025161743, -0.031234741, -0.030822754, 0.016738892, 0.012916565, 0.01966858, -0.04095459, 0.0064086914, -0.10681152, -0.014770508, 0.04107666, 0.00819397, 0.034057617, 0.011650085, -0.0075187683, 0.031555176, 0.050842285, -0.0033130646, -0.014846802, 0.023803711, 0.0033473969, 0.030197144, -0.001250267, 0.002380371, -0.002576828, 0.0055351257, -0.0011348724, 0.009063721, 0.018539429, 0.037017822, 0.026443481, -0.023269653, 0.037261963, -0.028533936, 0.02079773, 0.05810547, -0.033294678, -0.05960083, 0.007423401, -0.01574707, 0.046173096, 0.036254883, -0.055999756, 0.010848999, -0.05227661, -0.03265381, -0.04486084, -0.011444092, 0.022003174, 0.028778076, -0.010307312, 0.01689148, -0.018600464, -0.004589081, -0.030334473, 0.0042877197, -0.007419586, -0.03894043, 0.0019464493, 0.016052246, -0.036071777, 0.05316162, 0.05569458, 0.026779175, -0.047790527, 0.018051147, 0.004901886, -0.050354004, 0.026290894, -0.033416748, -0.009468079, -0.031219482, -0.026657104, 0.017974854, -0.012084961, 0.06536865, 0.0037841797, -0.0046958923, 0.004211426, -0.032562256, 0.01826477, 0.009635925, 0.062805176, -0.027694702, -0.0076675415, -0.010566711, -0.015945435, -0.022583008, -0.02720642, 0.009506226, 0.02508545, 0.015960693, -0.0017843246, -0.010009766, -0.0018281937, 0.030059814, 0.061431885, 0.026245117, 0.0053482056, 0.015914917, 0.009742737, 0.020965576, 0.051879883, 0.028396606, 0.047698975, 0.008049011, 0.009628296, 0.059539795, -0.00062561035, 0.018234253, 0.0017290115, -0.0050086975, -0.0011434555, -0.0015792847, 0.006629944, -0.004459381, -0.06210327, 0.0066604614, -0.035064697, 0.0003502369, -0.00415802, 0.015350342, 0.04159546, -0.0152282715, 0.005054474, -0.028045654, -0.013336182, -0.03363037, -0.008285522, 0.0345459, 0.009391785, -0.073791504, 0.015045166, 0.031707764, 0.036712646, 0.0025482178, 0.039855957, 0.0061187744, -0.008453369, -0.026245117, -0.006942749, -0.02961731, 0.04937744, 0.0075912476, -0.0072631836, -0.008056641, -0.011795044, -0.025421143, 0.06542969, 0.08227539, -0.027938843, 0.03375244, -0.06707764, 0.015235901, 0.018569946, -0.021697998, -0.0075569153, 0.044525146, 0.014122009, 0.033203125, -0.021194458, 0.012580872, -0.04473877, -0.021194458, -0.012840271, -0.027648926, -0.05368042, -0.056030273, 0.0037288666, -0.06555176, -0.052520752, -0.018478394, 0.08203125, 0.003068924, -0.020523071, 0.01260376, 0.0039520264, -0.030517578, 0.0049743652, -0.030151367, -0.01386261, 0.05593872, 0.028427124, 0.041656494, -0.056762695, -0.022583008, -0.014633179, 0.01966858, -0.017715454, 0.020904541, -0.016082764, 0.004310608, 0.017715454, -0.003255844, 0.0390625, -0.04751587, -0.00055742264, -0.04724121, 0.009086609, 0.021911621, 0.006126404, -0.0010433197, 0.024230957, -0.022979736, -0.040802002, 0.05517578, 0.042114258, -0.0068473816, 0.01197052, 0.03491211, -0.00024676323, -0.0074653625, 0.03265381, -0.0044021606, -0.0044021606, -0.066833496, 0.007610321, -0.04977417, -0.02784729, -0.027374268, -0.008255005, 0.0791626, -0.07159424, 0.0045547485, -0.027160645, -0.015419006, -0.014930725, 0.031036377, 0.02508545, -0.020721436, -0.020629883, 0.0096206665, -0.0014982224, 0.03491211, -0.05706787, 0.019729614, 0.08270264, -0.0041046143, -0.04510498, -0.018463135, 0.036132812, 0.026153564, -0.0028247833, -0.028182983, -0.0019798279, 0.01675415, 0.0071105957, 0.00022685528, -0.025344849, -0.038146973, -0.117248535, 0.0020923615, 0.026473999, -0.009140015, -0.036346436, 0.021057129, -0.029876709, 0.012466431, 0.016845703, -0.042755127, 0.025680542, 0.042022705, 0.0022850037, -0.012283325, 0.016921997, -0.050598145, 0.021224976, -0.018966675, -0.050750732, 0.041534424, -0.031188965, -0.048461914, 0.0041007996, -0.020431519, -0.040252686, -0.023391724, 0.015823364, 0.029632568, 0.044189453, -0.0017251968, 0.028762817, -0.0007572174, 0.019836426, -0.03137207, -0.036865234, -0.03479004, -0.0146102905, 0.0073547363, -0.002576828, 0.049957275, 0.022232056, 0.0016517639, -0.02772522, -0.02041626, -0.007598877, 0.038513184, 0.010414124, -0.03933716, -0.021408081, -0.015174866, -0.015823364, -0.02067566, -0.01713562, -0.0048942566, -0.02999878, 0.0129470825, -0.009475708, 0.06384277, -0.0047950745, 0.008621216, -0.018630981, -0.019165039, 0.019424438, -0.038024902, -0.040771484, 0.0013465881, 0.025344849, -0.0042419434, 0.032165527, -0.01197052, -0.017623901, 0.019042969, -0.021240234, 0.0034313202, -0.002401352, -0.010879517, 0.012771606, 0.025650024, -0.008552551, -0.007713318, -0.022079468, 0.0069007874, 0.0073928833, -0.0132369995, -0.026306152, -0.035705566, 0.016525269, -0.009124756, -0.088134766, 0.011650085, 0.012481689, -0.013343811, 0.006690979, -0.047698975, 0.03439331, -0.016311646, -0.04107666, -0.0013418198, -0.016860962, -0.0053863525, -0.0102005005, -0.041168213, -0.05166626, 0.0680542, 0.0032234192, 0.008338928, 0.021469116, -0.011444092, -0.025726318, -0.04763794, 0.031799316, -0.017608643, 0.010246277, -0.0062217712, 0.03164673, 0.07763672, -0.032165527, 0.012283325, 0.047576904, 0.061401367, -0.025268555, -0.019485474, 0.0037231445, 0.021194458, -0.014503479, 0.042510986, 0.00982666, -0.012687683, -0.05050659, 0.00060367584, -0.018005371, 0.011894226, 0.007835388, -0.015258789, 0.012039185, -0.00019574165, 0.022399902, 0.048736572, -0.024673462, 0.005191803, 0.06512451, 0.0034008026, -0.01386261, 0.016708374, 0.020462036, 0.042785645, 0.0069084167, 0.023269653, -0.003271103, 0.034332275, -0.019546509, -0.021606445, -0.0023536682, 0.012329102, -0.03161621, -0.010215759, -0.075805664, -0.020889282, -0.018112183, 0.014129639, -0.022262573, 0.013725281, 0.019256592, -0.031158447, -0.014846802, 0.023025513, 0.060333252, 0.0044784546, -0.0007171631, -0.055908203, -0.0004312992, -0.019180298, -0.055908203, -0.041656494, -0.03265381, -0.022766113, 0.017944336, -0.0071411133, -0.04611206, 0.00045847893, 0.03805542, 0.11871338, 0.04269409, 0.014457703, -0.062072754, 0.0038795471, -0.020721436, -0.02520752, 0.04437256, -0.02330017, -0.0021152496, -0.03100586, 0.02017212, -0.012527466, -0.018432617, -0.035705566, 0.035064697, -0.0016736984, 0.039093018, 0.020080566, 0.05178833, 0.04034424, -0.0026054382, 0.01322937, 0.017181396, -0.03930664, -0.00944519, -0.013343811, 0.039886475, -0.04473877, 0.030899048, 0.05154419, 0.0067329407, 0.0015821457, -0.016677856, 0.0181427, 0.018371582, -0.018371582, -0.031707764, 0.045898438, -0.030899048, -0.009155273, -0.0006532669, -0.00074625015, 0.044921875, -0.07501221, 0.064941406, -0.002872467, 0.007980347, 0.045013428, -0.016311646, -0.005203247, -0.0040016174, -0.006916046, -0.06951904, -0.064453125, -0.0073928833, 0.049621582, -0.030548096, 0.0064315796, -0.007820129, 0.012145996, 0.033691406, 0.047912598, 0.032104492, -0.0059280396, -0.027038574, -0.0052757263, -0.0013256073, -0.029464722, -0.062927246, -0.0099487305, 0.00554657, 0.024978638, -0.047607422, 0.038085938, -0.05316162, -0.0050354004, 0.0026187897, -0.013450623, 0.017852783, -0.09185791, -0.010238647, 0.04058838, 0.015159607, 0.0036125183, 0.006462097, 0.019165039, 0.014289856, 0.032043457, 0.025115967, 0.02709961, 0.015716553, -0.034423828, 0.016143799, 0.0046043396, 0.03274536, -0.014625549, 0.031097412, 0.0018339157, 0.013946533, -0.05908203, 0.032073975, -0.009429932, -0.035217285, 0.0035266876, -0.029708862, 0.0027179718, 0.025283813, 0.015777588, 0.023223877, -0.032104492, -0.03894043, -0.014045715, -0.0040664673, -0.042541504, 0.01499176, 0.003068924, -0.022399902, -0.08001709, 0.03375244, -0.035949707, 0.011459351, -0.018661499, -0.0018253326, -0.041168213, 0.022781372, 0.02406311, -0.03137207, 0.014953613, -0.010665894, 0.013412476, 0.048980713, 0.019500732, -0.04675293, -0.008735657, 0.0016908646, -0.04031372, -0.010925293, 0.040374756, 0.021484375, -0.02947998, -0.0073165894, -0.040008545, 0.0077934265, 0.0030765533, 0.01789856, 0.0058135986, -0.015686035, 0.04437256, 0.006046295, 0.008934021, -0.02999878, -0.00091457367, -0.008018494, -0.023147583, 0.010536194, -0.03375244, -0.0042800903, -0.005340576, -0.01096344, 0.010650635, -0.021896362, 0.0044403076, 0.011680603, -0.0040512085, -0.01600647, 0.015640259, 0.03616333, 0.021118164, -0.0025844574, 0.0024852753, 0.052093506, -0.034851074, 0.0038661957, -0.0065345764, -0.005584717, -0.023254395, 0.09326172, -0.0006904602, -0.0087509155, -0.06060791, -0.02909851, -0.03048706, 0.005722046, 0.037261963, -0.009986877, 0.015464783, -0.026489258, 0.007534027, -0.025512695, -0.0037879944, -0.028320312, 0.014892578, -0.011474609, -0.035461426, 0.0059776306, 0.004749298, 0.019546509, -0.03945923, -0.0016775131, -0.022918701, -0.0009756088, -0.011230469, -0.025863647, 0.03161621, -0.01725769, -0.018051147, 0.038482666, -0.016967773, -0.0071258545, 0.025680542, -0.04888916, 0.045532227, 0.017593384, 0.03704834, 0.028076172, 0.0011110306, 0.0023040771, 0.0036201477, 0.02748108, -0.041534424, 0.0413208, -0.055877686, -0.0020103455, -0.06616211, -0.032318115, -0.0736084, 0.0005054474, -0.0015926361, 0.026351929, 0.037963867, 0.0019950867, 0.0058135986, -0.010864258, 0.06732178, 0.014335632, 0.074157715, 0.037109375, -0.00007665157, 0.001162529, -0.016967773, 0.005756378, 0.035064697, 0.0060653687, 0.00008648634, -0.03845215, -0.031143188, 0.020477295, 0.021102905, 0.002948761, 0.023880005, -0.014823914, -0.034973145, 0.0619812, -0.008354187, 0.031585693, 0.06365967, 0.03488159, -0.017333984, -0.015975952, 0.014671326, 0.0014533997, -0.03753662, 0.024047852, 0.04800415, -0.08404541, 0.02708435, -0.0104522705, -0.01802063, -0.022460938, 0.0440979, 0.016540527, -0.056427002, -0.03491211, 0.035858154, 0.030960083, 0.013160706, 0.030029297, -0.031280518, -0.02355957, 0.00006479025, 0.036346436, -0.0067443848, 0.04611206, 0.030044556, 0.0026493073, -0.036590576, 0.010169983, -0.013771057, 0.07055664, -0.05670166, 0.018951416, -0.04714966, 0.036590576, 0.04058838, -0.021759033, 0.017410278, 0.026489258, -0.066345215, 0.015296936, 0.0003798008, 0.050842285, 0.05029297, 0.06262207, 0.0137786865, -0.0211792, 0.022018433, -0.06567383, 0.008430481, 0.020233154, -0.031173706, 0.023330688, -0.020019531, -0.020019531, 0.053344727, -0.039367676, 0.038085938, -0.031982422, 0.0015516281, -0.009277344, -0.005126953, 0.042785645, -0.058044434, -0.0059547424, -0.0231781, -0.0044822693, 0.004425049, 0.028259277, -0.012931824, -0.01626587, 0.0121536255, 0.015090942, 0.044677734, -0.0036182404, -0.013298035, -0.008483887, -0.06323242, 0.005092621, -0.035339355, 0.034484863, -0.008369446, -0.020568848, -0.031585693, 0.0012636185, 0.015258789, -0.0178833, -0.02456665, -0.014152527, -0.025558472, -0.011352539, 0.015144348, 0.03289795, -0.0020065308, 0.021820068, -0.0058403015, 0.018920898, -0.01689148, -0.010505676, 0.03414917, -0.019760132, -0.042816162, 0.0019044876, -0.012672424, 0.020462036, 0.0016546249, -0.003616333, -0.0015096664, 0.04043579, -0.035064697, -0.001458168, 0.016204834, 0.048950195, -0.0057296753, -0.036346436, 0.005935669, 0.04019165, 0.04937744, -0.054748535, -0.024505615, 0.0043411255, 0.014289856, -0.022766113, 0.05078125, 0.013908386, -0.0009851456, 0.032684326, 0.03845215, 0.0073165894, -0.03894043, -0.08081055, -0.035827637, 0.07165527, 0.045715332, -0.013793945, -0.023651123, 0.0473938, -0.021453857, -0.0065956116, 0.007835388, 0.0073661804, 0.011268616, -0.0059013367, 0.038269043, -0.02798462, -0.0016183853, -0.046142578, 0.020370483, -0.0049362183, 0.03161621, -0.004447937, 0.014389038, 0.0039138794, 0.09399414, -0.040496826, -0.027282715, 0.055847168, 0.013977051, 0.036987305, 0.012245178, -0.0063705444, 0.012168884, -0.009727478, 0.0056877136, 0.0055503845, 0.02986145, 0.026519775, -0.037719727, 0.017990112, -0.05255127, -0.056671143, -0.0058631897, -0.051483154, 0.037384033, -0.044799805, 0.019744873, -0.02998352, -0.0038909912, -0.013679504, 0.022399902, 0.028762817, -0.04421997, -0.027572632, -0.038909912, 0.06311035, -0.014656067 ], "summary": [ 0.018707275, -0.0033931732, 0.04257202, 0.038604736, -0.028915405, -0.009483337, 0.022628784, -0.0635376, -0.04031372, -0.014228821, -0.022125244, 0.0037403107, -0.05026245, -0.028778076, 0.010848999, -0.06536865, 0.030014038, -0.0055351257, 0.025268555, -0.035308838, 0.019622803, -0.022903442, 0.021560669, 0.08129883, 0.04486084, -0.0041007996, -0.042144775, 0.013748169, 0.07281494, 0.06317139, 0.030090332, -0.08795166, 0.013153076, -0.0035858154, 0.025115967, -0.0069389343, -0.0030403137, 0.0013818741, -0.0044937134, 0.020614624, 0.018630981, -0.026245117, 0.07043457, -0.07678223, 0.04623413, 0.037200928, 0.03881836, -0.044403076, -0.011291504, 0.0017700195, -0.009590149, 0.044433594, -0.023529053, 0.03277588, 0.018203735, 0.0068588257, -0.0132751465, -0.040008545, 0.020385742, 0.02079773, -0.00078105927, -0.018707275, 0.01449585, -0.042388916, -0.0143585205, 0.0041999817, 0.02407837, -0.016677856, 0.06915283, 0.013679504, -0.020996094, 0.025985718, -0.00094652176, 0.032806396, -0.053833008, -0.06616211, 0.05847168, -0.015716553, -0.0024719238, 0.006401062, 0.0099487305, 0.005252838, 0.062805176, -0.021865845, -0.012062073, -0.02935791, -0.018493652, -0.0044441223, -0.049987793, -0.017288208, -0.019424438, 0.047607422, -0.06762695, -0.029174805, 0.0023517609, -0.023773193, -0.010253906, -0.01449585, 0.042388916, -0.0036582947, 0.033233643, -0.054229736, 0.029815674, -0.008842468, -0.027801514, 0.031829834, 0.028961182, -0.0020942688, -0.013938904, 0.013626099, -0.0041770935, -0.018630981, 0.023895264, 0.028640747, -0.041229248, -0.015289307, -0.010810852, 0.011566162, -0.02015686, 0.014762878, -0.029129028, 0.010910034, 0.009284973, 0.035064697, -0.018630981, 0.012702942, 0.0047721863, -0.013832092, 0.03869629, -0.009735107, -0.008041382, 0.039611816, -0.03652954, -0.0368042, -0.032287598, 0.0018692017, 0.0041770935, 0.008491516, 0.0028095245, -0.016815186, 0.053222656, 0.008171082, 0.022323608, 0.028869629, -0.016296387, 0.05154419, 0.0061149597, -0.002456665, 0.014663696, -0.068359375, 0.012992859, -0.06384277, -0.0011873245, -0.0034694672, 0.0154800415, -0.02293396, -0.052581787, 0.012321472, 0.06976318, 0.022842407, -0.008026123, -0.012542725, -0.004096985, 0.059539795, 0.022415161, 0.04473877, 0.02911377, 0.0048828125, 0.012435913, 0.0501709, 0.020645142, -0.013717651, -0.03262329, -0.02267456, -0.0049362183, -0.013046265, -0.021987915, 0.029693604, -0.012557983, -0.017730713, 0.03591919, -0.03390503, -0.027526855, 0.0569458, -0.0016450882, -0.076416016, 0.0052223206, -0.0019493103, 0.0259552, 0.0357666, -0.010498047, -0.023162842, -0.04522705, 0.0063972473, -0.007003784, 0.012069702, -0.04953003, 0.017089844, -0.011756897, -0.03604126, 0.002111435, 0.0066070557, 0.000100553036, 0.022903442, -0.017028809, 0.022628784, -0.006462097, 0.018692017, -0.04135132, 0.021118164, 0.023483276, -0.017730713, -0.0435791, 0.055603027, 0.02532959, -0.039916992, 0.054992676, -0.08111572, -0.008377075, -0.07672119, -0.005973816, 0.059051514, -0.056488037, 0.08508301, 0.0018138885, -0.032165527, -0.0018787384, -0.004085541, -0.0018692017, -0.0006313324, 0.023117065, 0.021057129, -0.0690918, 0.0040512085, -0.019973755, -0.03881836, -0.030471802, -0.054626465, 0.05505371, 0.044799805, 0.0034656525, 0.022521973, -0.024810791, 0.04208374, -0.025314331, -0.029632568, 0.0011863708, 0.017425537, -0.017456055, 0.03289795, 0.049682617, 0.014770508, 0.0021514893, -0.019729614, -0.011192322, 0.04901123, 0.015220642, -0.0036640167, 0.010513306, -0.0066833496, 0.016174316, -0.004283905, -0.020385742, 0.005344391, -0.028213501, -0.036376953, -0.019683838, -0.019195557, 0.0155181885, -0.031829834, 0.011947632, -0.026153564, -0.00042819977, -0.07305908, -0.056518555, -0.08605957, -0.014350891, 0.07611084, 0.018936157, -0.074157715, 0.020324707, 0.0023899078, -0.023757935, -0.00121212, 0.033599854, -0.00068330765, 0.0046195984, 0.039642334, -0.0038547516, 0.022109985, 0.05126953, -0.0038490295, -0.007572174, -0.020462036, -0.0046463013, -0.024398804, 0.0026950836, 0.049865723, -0.009017944, 0.010391235, -0.026519775, 0.023223877, 0.0007929802, -0.014137268, 0.0072364807, 0.022659302, -0.015571594, 0.048553467, 0.027267456, -0.014122009, -0.003698349, -0.013298035, 0.010787964, 0.04006958, -0.01651001, -0.015419006, 0.021377563, 0.01574707, 0.007194519, 0.015731812, 0.1149292, 0.013580322, 0.0026798248, 0.023712158, -0.01576233, -0.058258057, 0.045043945, -0.027374268, 0.009132385, 0.014701843, -0.033721924, -0.010284424, -0.067993164, -0.022354126, 0.005054474, 0.015701294, -0.017044067, 0.077941895, -0.007873535, -0.062347412, -0.023880005, -0.024841309, 0.0014181137, 0.010147095, -0.02407837, -0.0124053955, 0.0031318665, -0.012275696, 0.041381836, 0.0021038055, 0.00038862228, 0.0023555756, -0.033294678, 0.07513428, 0.0178833, 0.011375427, 0.03805542, 0.07287598, 0.026931763, 0.0027942657, 0.04949951, 0.023086548, 0.017944336, -0.1060791, -0.020645142, -0.031555176, -0.006526947, -0.044891357, -0.03173828, 0.020401001, 0.015960693, -0.0011920929, -0.040740967, -0.0340271, -0.08862305, 0.012107849, 0.07940674, -0.018630981, 0.013015747, 0.04348755, -0.006839752, 0.033050537, -0.0519104, 0.04928589, 0.05847168, 0.021224976, -0.031051636, -0.019424438, 0.009811401, 0.009422302, -0.011932373, -0.022338867, 0.05407715, -0.01524353, -0.018630981, -0.018234253, 0.019256592, -0.024398804, 0.015388489, -0.0067749023, 0.018585205, -0.020568848, -0.006706238, -0.0046424866, 0.00010710955, 0.04940796, 0.025253296, -0.020553589, 0.019210815, -0.0068092346, 0.055358887, -0.06793213, 0.08105469, -0.093933105, 0.041168213, -0.05987549, 0.040863037, 0.026733398, -0.0715332, -0.034088135, 0.024139404, 0.031311035, 0.02557373, -0.009231567, 0.02154541, 0.017807007, 0.031921387, -0.005970001, 0.010719299, -0.0060043335, 0.025466919, -0.026901245, -0.016830444, -0.020812988, -0.047088623, 0.010726929, -0.017211914, -0.004917145, 0.024291992, -0.031799316, -0.06542969, -0.023605347, 0.0074882507, 0.021011353, 0.010147095, -0.003736496, -0.018707275, -0.051879883, -0.03756714, -0.012916565, -0.028701782, 0.0059051514, 0.0062332153, 0.042785645, 0.0062026978, 0.06317139, -0.01550293, 0.019622803, 0.016937256, -0.053894043, -0.06341553, -0.028640747, 0.0146865845, -0.038879395, 0.01977539, 0.019485474, -0.031433105, 0.022979736, -0.043701172, 0.01940918, 0.039764404, -0.024032593, -0.00258255, -0.033294678, 0.008811951, -0.056518555, 0.018798828, 0.002773285, 0.034362793, -0.03778076, -0.029785156, 0.014778137, -0.022064209, -0.029632568, -0.016983032, 0.002729416, -0.046203613, -0.016113281, 0.02432251, 0.009803772, 0.043182373, -0.05947876, 0.072143555, -0.040893555, -0.018875122, 0.007293701, -0.0060195923, 0.01146698, 0.004852295, -0.015838623, -0.022125244, -0.0154800415, 0.019927979, 0.0028457642, -0.027130127, 0.017196655, 0.029830933, -0.0066947937, -0.002773285, -0.024002075, 0.030349731, -0.036895752, 0.08654785, 0.048828125, -0.004623413, 0.019226074, 0.044891357, 0.0579834, -0.0070724487, -0.035949707, 0.049713135, 0.0068130493, -0.0064468384, -0.017410278, 0.053833008, 0.020584106, -0.03152466, 0.0034217834, -0.011054993, -0.0064048767, 0.04208374, 0.010002136, -0.012626648, 0.008911133, 0.013748169, 0.007381439, -0.0103302, 0.0025520325, 0.01878357, 0.013977051, -0.010696411, 0.007385254, -0.004878998, 0.013687134, -0.002986908, 0.020904541, -0.004032135, 0.015151978, 0.043914795, -0.022140503, 0.006324768, 0.005680084, -0.0524292, -0.033813477, -0.01285553, 0.03250122, -0.0079956055, -0.015007019, -0.030151367, 0.029647827, 0.006412506, -0.0151901245, -0.00045108795, 0.016159058, 0.0289917, 0.02494812, -0.031066895, -0.06994629, -0.04425049, -0.011665344, -0.051239014, -0.010284424, -0.028182983, -0.018630981, -0.014694214, -0.0068740845, -0.051116943, -0.018844604, 0.028289795, 0.07537842, 0.01876831, 0.038391113, -0.035980225, -0.04458618, 0.007789612, 0.023483276, 0.017074585, 0.023483276, 0.023925781, -0.007205963, -0.018173218, -0.017959595, -0.041748047, -0.03250122, 0.019195557, -0.010047913, 0.017669678, 0.041107178, 0.08392334, 0.01940918, -0.0015325546, 0.005756378, -0.003736496, -0.010520935, 0.012641907, -0.0021629333, 0.010551453, 0.012321472, 0.01461792, -0.0068855286, -0.02204895, 0.022613525, -0.026809692, 0.0015192032, -0.0030117035, -0.023239136, 0.03378296, 0.009666443, 0.005432129, -0.015731812, -0.0071029663, 0.0066108704, -0.006881714, -0.011009216, 0.019226074, 0.0368042, -0.027496338, 0.07904053, 0.0023326874, -0.03265381, 0.046142578, -0.046173096, -0.028503418, -0.03768921, 0.01247406, 0.011154175, 0.0004682541, -0.01008606, -0.0024719238, 0.01058197, 0.05770874, -0.0034885406, -0.021087646, -0.043701172, -0.014083862, 0.017166138, -0.00894928, -0.0046463013, -0.037841797, -0.040863037, 0.0126953125, 0.038116455, -0.023529053, 0.06567383, 0.005680084, 0.023590088, -0.036468506, -0.00440979, 0.004261017, -0.05105591, -0.064208984, -0.007785797, 0.0038013458, -0.012145996, 0.0362854, -0.04434204, -0.024093628, 0.000623703, -0.031021118, 0.037872314, -0.030227661, -0.03274536, 0.035369873, -0.0027542114, 0.014755249, -0.0069274902, 0.02180481, -0.0023345947, 0.016723633, -0.027130127, -0.008544922, -0.055023193, 0.028778076, -0.027267456, -0.0059318542, -0.011672974, 0.00016641617, 0.03842163, 0.040618896, -0.015182495, -0.026550293, -0.013870239, 0.010246277, -0.035095215, -0.00730896, 0.024230957, 0.025314331, -0.04147339, -0.012458801, -0.051483154, 0.031280518, 0.0017261505, -0.011207581, -0.005508423, -0.012023926, 0.011398315, 0.011489868, -0.011421204, 0.041778564, 0.028182983, 0.009094238, -0.018585205, -0.055786133, -0.0028629303, -0.05545044, -0.017669678, -0.030838013, -0.0044441223, 0.010948181, 0.055541992, -0.005279541, 0.024795532, 0.043762207, -0.05847168, 0.0053367615, -0.00020051003, -0.0055503845, 0.01600647, -0.026977539, -0.019699097, -0.00843811, 0.039123535, -0.0056152344, -0.020111084, 0.0037193298, -0.034088135, 0.023330688, 0.012084961, 0.015617371, 0.023986816, 0.029144287, -0.007827759, 0.03741455, -0.005874634, -0.019470215, -0.007007599, -0.005054474, -0.009483337, 0.03982544, -0.010375977, 0.060821533, 0.018814087, 0.019317627, -0.007457733, 0.0030574799, -0.023620605, 0.060577393, 0.017929077, 0.015411377, -0.051574707, 0.00051498413, 0.008735657, -0.016662598, 0.021591187, -0.010673523, 0.033966064, 0.005683899, -0.058166504, 0.011390686, -0.026062012, -0.003156662, 0.012336731, 0.0026130676, -0.023483276, 0.027954102, -0.014373779, 0.03036499, -0.008522034, -0.014022827, -0.016616821, -0.017211914, 0.011772156, -0.023101807, 0.017929077, -0.012145996, 0.0021038055, 0.0039405823, -0.000538826, -0.03024292, -0.013198853, -0.0035896301, 0.035003662, 0.014259338, -0.043060303, -0.0418396, -0.019485474, 0.03894043, -0.00041484833, 0.0005044937, -0.0048980713, 0.048706055, -0.0423584, -0.0064086914, -0.01725769, -0.032196045, -0.027389526, -0.0073928833, 0.015991211, 0.0070114136, 0.070617676, 0.0036640167, 0.020324707, 0.0050468445, -0.010528564, -0.014289856, 0.039764404, 0.04876709, -0.004333496, -0.021118164, -0.00705719, 0.007865906, 0.033477783, 0.015960693, 0.015281677, -0.014602661, -0.004131317, 0.07116699, -0.0049438477, -0.05621338, 0.0061187744, 0.061401367, -0.04522705, 0.040405273, 0.030731201, 0.018218994, 0.038635254, -0.004383087, 0.08251953, -0.040283203, 0.0093688965, 0.015792847, -0.021057129, 0.0368042, -0.0052719116, 0.0028762817, 0.0259552, 0.013320923, -0.015083313, 0.026321411, 0.021697998, 0.048095703, -0.04864502, 0.045196533, -0.024505615, -0.003955841, -0.04309082, 0.023727417, -0.019882202, -0.021636963, -0.010192871, -0.0072021484, 0.018997192, 0.066711426, 0.016921997, 0.0113220215, -0.06506348, 0.034606934, -0.014633179, 0.03881836, -0.062683105, 0.010253906, -0.05657959, 0.05709839, 0.031097412, -0.028137207, 0.022415161, 0.01977539, -0.035186768, 0.039916992, -0.045928955, 0.077819824, 0.047973633, 0.06732178, 0.0038032532, 0.013877869, 0.047973633, -0.0019378662, -0.030670166, -0.03729248, -0.0104599, -0.052520752, 0.007873535, 0.011619568, -0.0036334991, 0.0071868896, -0.009178162, -0.045928955, 0.028381348, -0.022079468, 0.028259277, -0.0357666, -0.024780273, -0.010513306, -0.037963867, 0.018692017, 0.023513794, 0.046081543, -0.01209259, 0.03152466, 0.01889038, -0.008934021, 0.048950195, 0.0037174225, 0.02748108, -0.013809204, 0.010932922, -0.013313293, 0.016342163, 0.0231781, 0.0072784424, -0.027191162, 0.026229858, -0.018310547, 0.023620605, -0.021896362, -0.022750854, -0.0037250519, -0.0042686462, -0.0010251999, -0.018508911, 0.011886597, -0.014015198, -0.0016555786, -0.02609253, 0.025665283, -0.024932861, -0.0256958, 0.054504395, 0.017120361, -0.074645996, -0.021850586, 0.0029697418, 0.010093689, -0.0127334595, -0.0075149536, -0.00033688545, 0.023757935, -0.05947876, -0.039367676, -0.029006958, -0.009155273, -0.009338379, -0.044036865, -0.0063056946, 0.039093018, 0.05203247, 0.004787445, 0.06048584, 0.055023193, 0.011131287, 0.0031261444, 0.000044584274, -0.020889282, -0.011558533, -0.010223389, 0.03744507, -0.003250122, -0.008781433, -0.033813477, 0.004459381, 0.037139893, -0.0041542053, -0.013008118, 0.0039482117, 0.018569946, -0.06347656, -0.001250267, -0.02519226, -0.0018949509, -0.012763977, -0.008895874, 0.013710022, -0.022964478, 0.021133423, -0.025726318, -0.016723633, 0.0048065186, -0.012542725, 0.0051345825, 0.00869751, -0.019226074, 0.06185913, -0.03881836, 0.0463562, -0.029785156, 0.0038661957, 0.006187439, -0.005493164, -0.022140503, 0.03781128, -0.010620117, 0.00248909, 0.019378662, 0.0033435822, 0.018508911, -0.053344727, 0.011405945, -0.0647583, -0.07287598, 0.00554657, -0.037017822, -0.00055933, -0.050933838, 0.061920166, 0.033111572, -0.012435913, 0.008605957, 0.049865723, 0.04284668, -0.018417358, 0.037231445, -0.0022621155, 0.05154419, 0.0154418945 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1707.03377v2
Learning like humans with Deep Symbolic Networks
Qunzhi Zhang, Didier Sornette
cs.AI, cond-mat.dis-nn, cs.LG
We introduce the Deep Symbolic Network (DSN) model, which aims at becoming the white-box version of Deep Neural Networks (DNN). The DSN model provides a simple, universal yet powerful structure, similar to DNN, to represent any knowledge of the world, which is transparent to humans. The conjecture behind the DSN model is that any type of real world objects sharing enough common features are mapped into human brains as a symbol. Those symbols are connected by links, representing the composition, correlation, causality, or other relationships between them, forming a deep, hierarchical symbolic network structure. Powered by such a structure, the DSN model is expected to learn like humans, because of its unique characteristics. First, it is universal, using the same structure to store any knowledge. Second, it can learn symbols from the world and construct the deep symbolic networks automatically, by utilizing the fact that real world objects have been naturally separated by singularities. Third, it is symbolic, with the capacity of performing causal deduction and generalization. Fourth, the symbols and the links between them are transparent to us, and thus we will know what it has learned or not - which is the key for the security of an AI system. Fifth, its transparency enables it to learn with relatively small data. Sixth, its knowledge can be accumulated. Last but not least, it is more friendly to unsupervised learning than DNN. We present the details of the model, the algorithm powering its automatic learning ability, and describe its usefulness in different use cases. The purpose of this paper is to generate broad interest to develop it within an open source project centered on the Deep Symbolic Network (DSN) model towards the development of general AI.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1707.03377v2
2017-07-13T12:00:38
2017-07-11T17:29:51
{ "title": [ -0.025283813, 0.0040130615, -0.02998352, -0.024276733, 0.0018558502, -0.017837524, -0.021362305, -0.02734375, -0.0129852295, 0.031707764, -0.01436615, 0.017089844, -0.026901245, -0.004310608, -0.05014038, 0.0020942688, -0.00027275085, 0.026412964, -0.015853882, -0.037384033, -0.016967773, -0.03967285, 0.056274414, 0.047607422, 0.04800415, -0.06439209, -0.056427002, 0.03265381, -0.044952393, -0.038726807, -0.0045776367, 0.015945435, 0.043945312, 0.04434204, -0.02633667, 0.009666443, -0.053466797, 0.028259277, 0.002275467, 0.0022296906, 0.016113281, -0.0070114136, -0.043518066, -0.025421143, -0.05621338, 0.025772095, -0.064331055, -0.004322052, -0.01322937, 0.041107178, 0.014198303, 0.031677246, -0.032104492, 0.018661499, 0.027893066, -0.038360596, -0.029327393, -0.0463562, 0.0473938, 0.08850098, 0.04232788, -0.06604004, 0.01373291, -0.055786133, -0.056671143, -0.018798828, -0.0014228821, 0.00894928, 0.05545044, -0.0058937073, -0.004634857, 0.02607727, 0.011268616, 0.01020813, -0.052886963, -0.031799316, 0.05731201, 0.010482788, 0.0335083, -0.032348633, 0.009384155, -0.02482605, -0.010910034, -0.0211792, 0.0154953, -0.03161621, -0.012893677, -0.0045928955, -0.0440979, -0.060424805, -0.012145996, -0.0067253113, -0.029296875, -0.004257202, -0.018981934, -0.030090332, -0.021530151, 0.010269165, -0.010009766, -0.022323608, 0.0046920776, 0.014022827, -0.03111267, -0.0074920654, 0.0042495728, 0.012481689, -0.028778076, -0.045806885, -0.006996155, 0.041900635, -0.026947021, -0.0010318756, 0.006542206, -0.030792236, 0.009231567, 0.027114868, -0.0035133362, 0.029418945, 0.043548584, 0.027328491, 0.00116539, -0.02130127, 0.033355713, 0.016983032, 0.024749756, 0.022644043, -0.03237915, -0.041656494, 0.013999939, 0.013694763, -0.011238098, 0.035369873, -0.09033203, -0.075805664, -0.051452637, 0.04333496, -0.02192688, 0.003929138, -0.009880066, 0.012535095, 0.007335663, -0.027832031, 0.015319824, 0.0050086975, -0.0060157776, 0.03451538, 0.0670166, -0.032440186, -0.061584473, -0.03866577, -0.03062439, 0.013343811, 0.02607727, 0.0056610107, -0.058746338, 0.012306213, -0.13708496, -0.0064315796, 0.012199402, 0.01939392, 0.029037476, 0.017364502, -0.0007677078, 0.03540039, 0.06604004, -0.020751953, -0.01979065, 0.022888184, 0.0073661804, 0.00970459, 0.0043640137, 0.02760315, 0.022720337, -0.01550293, -0.02293396, -0.018310547, 0.039916992, -0.00016129017, 0.019470215, 0.00017249584, 0.0039482117, -0.024368286, 0.008285522, 0.030029297, -0.05618286, -0.016830444, -0.011009216, -0.021408081, 0.06365967, 0.0016422272, -0.049713135, 0.031280518, -0.04937744, -0.036499023, -0.04888916, -0.015823364, 0.041046143, 0.028381348, 0.003627777, 0.018432617, -0.03643799, -0.008239746, -0.013725281, -0.002380371, -0.016601562, -0.0048065186, -0.026824951, 0.02758789, -0.03289795, 0.04852295, 0.058135986, 0.005176544, -0.03527832, 0.014503479, -0.0059890747, -0.06036377, 0.026046753, -0.0050621033, -0.0033607483, -0.0028266907, -0.010231018, -0.003484726, 0.0011548996, 0.05706787, -0.007156372, 0.013130188, -0.010810852, -0.022354126, 0.012969971, 0.023025513, 0.071777344, -0.03149414, 0.015213013, -0.008926392, -0.024795532, -0.024734497, -0.01878357, -0.0070228577, 0.01663208, 0.027542114, -0.0010156631, -0.01033783, -0.022033691, 0.0040779114, 0.05847168, 0.0008702278, 0.004425049, 0.0019407272, 0.013031006, 0.009277344, 0.05227661, 0.02746582, 0.05505371, 0.005809784, 0.005138397, 0.06262207, 0.021194458, 0.020721436, -0.0032215118, 0.015716553, -0.013214111, 0.011894226, 0.0028038025, 0.009849548, -0.04522705, -0.009147644, -0.04046631, 0.00032520294, 0.00793457, 0.013404846, 0.047210693, -0.011886597, 0.018875122, -0.0057144165, -0.017410278, -0.055664062, -0.012008667, 0.017349243, 0.01398468, -0.07647705, -0.018600464, 0.002878189, 0.04058838, 0.008178711, 0.02368164, -0.0021038055, 0.020019531, -0.01977539, -0.014091492, -0.02053833, 0.030639648, 0.054626465, 0.017196655, -0.0035953522, 0.018325806, 0.007232666, 0.06317139, 0.08947754, -0.027008057, 0.035003662, -0.059265137, 0.018859863, 0.007572174, -0.017456055, 0.0048179626, 0.024673462, 0.01776123, 0.03439331, -0.025268555, 0.0064353943, -0.05178833, 0.013717651, 0.003982544, 0.008712769, -0.048461914, -0.055236816, 0.01789856, -0.034179688, -0.028533936, -0.029830933, 0.09741211, -0.019836426, -0.03579712, -0.018936157, -0.013664246, -0.020858765, -0.022964478, -0.04232788, -0.008476257, 0.023834229, 0.034332275, 0.028656006, -0.049468994, -0.023849487, -0.008232117, 0.009918213, 0.00091695786, 0.01184082, -0.002773285, 0.012611389, 0.04425049, -0.015853882, 0.0231781, -0.033843994, -0.004299164, -0.04901123, 0.014762878, 0.016845703, -0.016647339, -0.0027599335, 0.022079468, -0.02810669, -0.037963867, 0.034332275, 0.070007324, -0.01966858, -0.019104004, 0.055023193, 0.033691406, -0.015388489, 0.01977539, 0.008926392, 0.002632141, -0.036315918, -0.026779175, -0.029067993, -0.0004696846, 0.0026721954, -0.014320374, 0.05923462, -0.07305908, 0.0037631989, -0.03768921, -0.01411438, 0.005302429, 0.041870117, -0.0051498413, -0.028015137, -0.03665161, -0.010566711, -0.0116119385, 0.017501831, -0.042236328, 0.014343262, 0.06829834, 0.014373779, -0.019256592, -0.0069274902, 0.050811768, 0.012191772, -0.008140564, -0.012878418, -0.02230835, 0.0052261353, 0.02130127, 0.0049972534, -0.006690979, -0.0005836487, -0.12451172, -0.014892578, 0.032318115, 0.022247314, -0.016494751, 0.045074463, -0.078186035, 0.013694763, -0.013542175, -0.021194458, 0.013755798, 0.038848877, 0.00073957443, -0.0071754456, 0.0016298294, -0.026489258, 0.03579712, -0.059173584, -0.09075928, 0.021942139, -0.038146973, -0.013572693, 0.007221222, -0.030532837, -0.061187744, -0.018585205, -0.009857178, 0.012268066, 0.025161743, 0.023040771, 0.007896423, -0.00818634, -0.0099487305, -0.026000977, -0.026245117, -0.018676758, -0.030517578, -0.019119263, -0.010566711, 0.05496216, 0.02458191, -0.01461792, -0.037384033, -0.021697998, -0.028152466, 0.030136108, -0.0033836365, -0.034240723, -0.022781372, -0.031585693, -0.026138306, 0.013656616, -0.024658203, -0.0026378632, -0.009475708, 0.017807007, -0.016189575, 0.028579712, 0.0025901794, -0.00919342, -0.001285553, -0.019012451, 0.01184845, -0.014137268, -0.058776855, -0.0057907104, 0.038208008, -0.007499695, 0.010116577, -0.023834229, -0.044677734, 0.047180176, -0.033721924, 0.0015211105, 0.020355225, -0.007320404, -0.016586304, -0.0039138794, -0.009223938, 0.00036740303, -0.013313293, 0.012031555, -0.009178162, 0.0009446144, -0.022460938, -0.066101074, -0.0039138794, -0.00566864, -0.103027344, -0.018737793, 0.007610321, -0.026733398, -0.02658081, -0.06750488, 0.025238037, -0.038238525, -0.04916382, 0.017166138, -0.02078247, -0.0077285767, -0.02041626, -0.06088257, -0.03111267, 0.061309814, 0.019897461, 0.010391235, 0.036590576, -0.008712769, -0.046691895, -0.03414917, 0.013763428, -0.029785156, 0.023849487, -0.012748718, -0.0012454987, 0.042236328, -0.042785645, 0.019500732, 0.023773193, 0.02154541, -0.022064209, 0.0066108704, 0.0075950623, 0.031021118, -0.026016235, 0.048553467, 0.0003042221, 0.008102417, -0.095703125, 0.026626587, -0.007549286, -0.014732361, 0.05114746, 0.006225586, 0.032836914, 0.009124756, -0.038970947, 0.0440979, -0.022994995, -0.017715454, 0.029663086, 0.005180359, -0.02633667, -0.0007328987, 0.016586304, 0.022445679, -0.0022697449, 0.025222778, -0.012573242, 0.0423584, -0.039855957, -0.025650024, 0.020324707, 0.025970459, -0.023269653, -0.0033187866, -0.06112671, -0.067871094, -0.02670288, 0.0011730194, -0.008483887, 0.044311523, 0.03555298, 0.015617371, -0.025802612, -0.01638794, 0.017654419, -0.003358841, -0.0003466606, -0.031066895, -0.0063323975, -0.015426636, -0.033203125, -0.02468872, 0.00970459, -0.007522583, 0.034210205, -0.015975952, -0.022766113, 0.014335632, 0.02420044, 0.08496094, 0.047973633, -0.006088257, -0.06463623, 0.03930664, -0.01902771, -0.007675171, 0.013076782, -0.012664795, -0.004142761, -0.012565613, 0.01979065, -0.019012451, -0.020141602, -0.05770874, 0.0121154785, 0.011268616, 0.02142334, 0.0024414062, 0.011787415, 0.025787354, -0.0074501038, 0.028701782, 0.015075684, -0.029006958, -0.029754639, 0.029724121, 0.041503906, -0.006816864, 0.019821167, 0.044311523, 0.014953613, -0.007965088, 0.01612854, 0.016418457, 0.032684326, -0.027069092, -0.003004074, 0.031204224, -0.05731201, -0.025299072, -0.0069236755, 0.00048208237, 0.051696777, -0.05960083, 0.05935669, -0.015838623, -0.0025615692, 0.029693604, -0.01474762, 0.005836487, -0.013404846, 0.011413574, -0.080566406, -0.05734253, -0.049865723, 0.050445557, -0.03564453, -0.0015468597, 0.008911133, -0.013748169, 0.020370483, 0.06500244, 0.052124023, -0.03225708, 0.010124207, -0.023620605, -0.01701355, -0.020874023, -0.05368042, 0.011413574, -0.004501343, 0.010795593, -0.006515503, -0.009796143, -0.08459473, -0.01361084, 0.016921997, -0.016326904, 0.012680054, -0.06329346, 0.030059814, 0.07598877, -0.029373169, 0.038269043, 0.011444092, 0.024917603, 0.010604858, 0.0496521, 0.0071983337, 0.021636963, 0.020050049, -0.030838013, 0.038513184, 0.008995056, 0.022598267, 0.003036499, 0.0287323, 0.0033283234, 0.011413574, -0.052856445, 0.032958984, -0.022613525, -0.025314331, 0.021347046, -0.04449463, 0.0051612854, 0.01625061, 0.014007568, 0.0013589859, -0.030319214, -0.035339355, -0.011878967, -0.024627686, -0.0446167, 0.008857727, -0.011299133, -0.029922485, -0.06976318, 0.033081055, -0.019058228, 0.0009908676, -0.011833191, 0.0041122437, -0.049804688, 0.016174316, 0.03829956, -0.053375244, 0.008102417, -0.0184021, 0.02029419, 0.040374756, 0.00043702126, -0.043182373, -0.006793976, 0.0033893585, -0.041870117, -0.026138306, -0.0072784424, 0.009498596, -0.0023536682, -0.0023975372, -0.010566711, 0.027648926, -0.008262634, 0.032348633, -0.008529663, -0.020553589, 0.027511597, 0.015853882, 0.009246826, -0.0058021545, -0.0018501282, -0.012771606, 0.006462097, 0.010154724, -0.025299072, 0.023635864, -0.011245728, 0.013031006, 0.0066375732, -0.03869629, 0.01977539, 0.018035889, 0.023605347, 0.015777588, 0.017654419, 0.031829834, 0.03253174, -0.015792847, 0.030303955, 0.048736572, -0.04937744, 0.0065460205, -0.022964478, 0.0077552795, -0.04321289, 0.07086182, -0.05215454, -0.005634308, -0.054595947, -0.07678223, -0.037017822, 0.01360321, 0.04763794, 0.037719727, 0.037109375, -0.05670166, 0.024429321, -0.017333984, -0.00793457, -0.024429321, -0.0041046143, 0.002658844, -0.015792847, 0.028671265, 0.026260376, 0.0071144104, -0.01940918, 0.03463745, -0.0015935898, -0.016281128, 0.02053833, -0.015403748, 0.025115967, -0.015808105, -0.026138306, 0.03262329, -0.019943237, 0.00806427, 0.022872925, -0.046539307, 0.050689697, 0.0045433044, 0.044525146, 0.038391113, 0.00248909, 0.0184021, -0.0043640137, -0.005176544, -0.039978027, 0.019042969, -0.042877197, -0.006752014, -0.069885254, -0.018096924, -0.06359863, 0.01424408, 0.0007777214, 0.012924194, 0.03643799, 0.0084991455, 0.032684326, -0.003396988, 0.04824829, -0.016433716, 0.039031982, 0.022766113, 0.012771606, 0.012031555, 0.005252838, 0.0058059692, 0.034179688, 0.018432617, 0.0011377335, -0.017410278, -0.030303955, 0.008857727, 0.042236328, 0.0019874573, -0.0026760101, -0.016586304, -0.038208008, 0.017700195, -0.008285522, 0.015197754, 0.04763794, 0.04586792, 0.0022335052, -0.014297485, 0.0060195923, -0.02458191, -0.007091522, -0.012023926, 0.015899658, -0.05831909, 0.016113281, -0.01448822, -0.005088806, -0.022094727, 0.04449463, 0.031143188, -0.034057617, -0.020065308, 0.013244629, 0.046447754, 0.011726379, 0.009353638, -0.040405273, -0.021087646, 0.0010185242, 0.029830933, 0.0029888153, 0.039733887, 0.037109375, 0.04043579, -0.042022705, -0.0008416176, -0.0069999695, 0.025543213, -0.04107666, 0.02519226, -0.049987793, 0.040161133, -0.008522034, -0.041900635, 0.023757935, 0.0039863586, -0.061035156, -0.010749817, 0.041534424, 0.06500244, 0.059387207, 0.0814209, 0.013175964, -0.012611389, 0.0048828125, -0.050933838, 0.039855957, 0.04751587, -0.0317688, 0.018493652, -0.027938843, -0.031677246, 0.048675537, -0.0018863678, 0.08123779, -0.038024902, -0.004425049, -0.004585266, -0.011566162, 0.037384033, -0.03074646, 0.00029706955, -0.03527832, -0.02519226, -0.013053894, -0.0019741058, -0.013893127, -0.024032593, -0.0040512085, 0.026611328, 0.018692017, -0.008033752, -0.02520752, -0.030593872, -0.064208984, 0.023452759, -0.01687622, 0.059326172, -0.0021686554, -0.018463135, -0.036315918, 0.009376526, 0.006919861, -0.009269714, -0.02507019, 0.017364502, -0.042114258, -0.034332275, 0.0098724365, 0.019165039, -0.023101807, -0.016494751, -0.04611206, 0.018218994, -0.023025513, 0.011009216, 0.023651123, -0.052215576, -0.01965332, 0.0067253113, -0.033081055, 0.04043579, 0.025756836, -0.003856659, -0.0104522705, 0.026855469, -0.035736084, -0.034576416, -0.0082092285, 0.02003479, -0.005680084, -0.043884277, 0.00087308884, 0.045562744, 0.03286743, -0.0690918, -0.033843994, 0.020446777, 0.038635254, -0.012001038, 0.056243896, 0.01309967, -0.0036201477, 0.039215088, 0.018157959, 0.008094788, -0.039916992, -0.029022217, -0.0075149536, 0.0625, 0.046020508, -0.02067566, -0.0070991516, 0.024459839, -0.03326416, 0.013694763, 0.009292603, 0.008857727, 0.0287323, -0.010574341, 0.059631348, -0.011329651, -0.015289307, -0.02645874, 0.02935791, -0.01348114, 0.030029297, -0.023849487, 0.0072288513, 0.0059013367, 0.05496216, -0.04055786, -0.068237305, 0.061767578, 0.04711914, 0.013969421, 0.032165527, -0.023590088, -0.010498047, 0.011451721, -0.010177612, -0.01171875, 0.0063972473, 0.02468872, -0.026748657, -0.0042762756, -0.036956787, -0.03152466, -0.021896362, -0.02947998, 0.03540039, -0.03945923, 0.0036296844, -0.047973633, -0.013595581, -0.013946533, 0.0032482147, 0.007881165, -0.031341553, -0.056518555, -0.056518555, 0.043029785, -0.015235901 ], "summary": [ 0.022613525, 0.012863159, 0.0098724365, 0.040252686, -0.03161621, -0.029342651, -0.00057029724, -0.06829834, 0.0090789795, 0.011070251, -0.024093628, -0.014350891, 0.014526367, -0.03527832, 0.005897522, -0.02999878, 0.03552246, -0.018753052, 0.038208008, -0.0024337769, 0.010284424, 0.02041626, 0.068847656, 0.012680054, 0.038116455, -0.05441284, -0.001449585, 0.015327454, 0.014923096, 0.009231567, 0.024963379, -0.006526947, 0.009681702, 0.005508423, 0.014846802, -0.04989624, -0.01751709, 0.0014066696, -0.0008997917, -0.009437561, -0.001247406, 0.003780365, 0.07562256, -0.030593872, 0.00137043, 0.06561279, -0.046966553, -0.0289917, 0.042938232, 0.030548096, -0.023986816, 0.051574707, -0.04208374, -0.0029411316, 0.014839172, -0.0033512115, -0.070129395, -0.014381409, 0.03265381, 0.06842041, 0.02746582, -0.046051025, -0.0033626556, -0.068725586, -0.01625061, 0.0005412102, 0.02128601, -0.023254395, 0.011192322, 0.006969452, 0.03289795, 0.0038337708, 0.029205322, -0.041107178, -0.041046143, -0.02357483, 0.035980225, -0.016342163, 0.0041923523, -0.051727295, -0.02999878, -0.003118515, -0.02027893, -0.0059928894, -0.016540527, -0.003145218, -0.024734497, -0.0017566681, -0.044067383, 0.009819031, -0.032165527, 0.02067566, -0.06939697, 0.01222229, 0.020751953, -0.024963379, -0.058380127, -0.05493164, -0.035705566, 0.0054397583, 0.030410767, -0.0017271042, 0.018035889, -0.02128601, -0.041168213, -0.013748169, -0.010314941, -0.06774902, -0.04574585, 0.028137207, -0.060424805, -0.11437988, -0.025375366, -0.06970215, 0.012359619, 0.07183838, -0.01701355, 0.043884277, 0.0146102905, 0.034606934, -0.004322052, 0.01158905, 0.04144287, 0.02168274, 0.013847351, 0.035614014, -0.008972168, -0.041748047, 0.046569824, -0.012184143, -0.020965576, 0.02935791, 0.010986328, -0.00749588, -0.029296875, -0.010482788, -0.03616333, 0.0062942505, 0.019424438, -0.0065956116, 0.0395813, -0.030593872, 0.0076789856, 0.049743652, -0.030883789, 0.03933716, 0.022506714, -0.014701843, -0.037841797, -0.05984497, -0.005050659, -0.0049552917, 0.01953125, 0.004043579, -0.014427185, -0.02217102, -0.035308838, -0.01373291, 0.019317627, 0.0018997192, 0.03527832, 0.037322998, 0.010940552, 0.0848999, 0.07043457, -0.046966553, 0.023208618, 0.018432617, 0.010253906, -0.045715332, 0.017822266, 0.055603027, -0.00415802, -0.009277344, 0.025756836, -0.023162842, -0.04598999, 0.0026721954, 0.026473999, 0.01890564, 0.043304443, -0.021743774, -0.009506226, 0.052001953, -0.030044556, 0.084350586, -0.00630188, 0.05822754, 0.033081055, -0.007709503, -0.043792725, 0.0473938, 0.007827759, -0.008850098, -0.03378296, 0.004009247, -0.0011043549, 0.049957275, -0.023239136, -0.014694214, 0.003353119, 0.016021729, 0.011787415, -0.02722168, -0.061706543, 0.04144287, -0.020629883, 0.047454834, -0.024917603, -0.009124756, 0.025772095, -0.054229736, -0.00730896, 0.012260437, -0.019134521, -0.030349731, 0.015525818, -0.0209198, 0.00044369698, -0.01083374, -0.014060974, 0.055725098, -0.027359009, 0.012840271, 0.012741089, -0.010040283, 0.0007958412, -0.008506775, 0.05026245, 0.0101623535, 0.039642334, -0.016662598, 0.012756348, 0.023483276, -0.04260254, -0.036468506, -0.018951416, -0.022277832, 0.01751709, 0.0597229, 0.01676941, 0.028244019, -0.041625977, -0.05633545, 0.04119873, -0.018859863, 0.0018444061, -0.02067566, -0.042297363, -0.027511597, 0.024307251, 0.015602112, 0.036499023, 0.02545166, -0.027053833, 0.037750244, -0.007572174, -0.0032634735, 0.007980347, -0.023208618, 0.010406494, 0.046325684, 0.0029335022, 0.03515625, -0.011619568, -0.03353882, -0.02116394, -0.023529053, -0.0004310608, -0.018661499, 0.039093018, -0.028167725, -0.016464233, -0.041168213, -0.015930176, -0.07110596, -0.008300781, 0.043701172, -0.011329651, -0.06451416, -0.0052871704, -0.0067214966, -0.028121948, -0.009155273, -0.0018529892, -0.012313843, 0.018127441, 0.03338623, 0.042999268, 0.06365967, 0.053100586, 0.047576904, 0.039733887, 0.020721436, 0.013839722, 0.0044784546, -0.055603027, 0.060760498, -0.017425537, -0.0046310425, 0.01802063, 0.045318604, -0.025756836, 0.022033691, 0.0068893433, -0.016830444, 0.005710602, -0.012931824, -0.011016846, 0.010818481, -0.051513672, 0.038482666, 0.012123108, 0.030059814, -0.026657104, -0.032287598, -0.009468079, 0.024917603, -0.02268982, 0.023757935, 0.08288574, 0.0069847107, -0.015640259, -0.0118255615, 0.012565613, -0.024597168, -0.02053833, -0.028701782, -0.020050049, -0.01687622, -0.022766113, -0.04159546, -0.020996094, 0.013008118, -0.0033340454, 0.0004117489, 0.033325195, -0.055511475, 0.037506104, 0.05618286, 0.11248779, 0.0104904175, -0.004337311, -0.014968872, 0.013076782, -0.03656006, 0.03451538, 0.0027046204, -0.0002515316, 0.026504517, -0.017608643, -0.024154663, -0.0038871765, 0.025253296, 0.02696228, 0.0048294067, 0.0041542053, 0.040252686, 0.023284912, -0.015472412, 0.026031494, 0.0048217773, 0.0077590942, -0.020904541, -0.04156494, -0.014175415, -0.0071983337, 0.017410278, 0.007835388, 0.03643799, -0.06329346, 0.0597229, -0.023269653, -0.026824951, -0.008232117, 0.02293396, 0.109069824, -0.0026340485, -0.024169922, 0.060638428, -0.005771637, 0.04776001, -0.05923462, 0.029266357, 0.046173096, 0.014587402, -0.0087890625, -0.0051574707, 0.03567505, 0.0065841675, -0.006668091, -0.011741638, 0.028930664, 0.0025691986, 0.03942871, 0.013198853, -0.033477783, 0.0053482056, -0.060516357, -0.028549194, 0.015975952, 0.016021729, 0.022323608, -0.010009766, -0.02178955, 0.0129852295, 0.013397217, -0.0013971329, 0.0001154542, -0.034057617, 0.008270264, -0.017715454, -0.0052375793, -0.03250122, 0.03186035, -0.053009033, 0.0011901855, 0.00068616867, -0.06048584, 0.004917145, 0.041625977, 0.0062026978, 0.02168274, 0.016189575, -0.033721924, 0.018127441, -0.024353027, 0.031799316, 0.0059280396, 0.023269653, -0.02558899, -0.0026836395, -0.029052734, -0.024337769, -0.027236938, -0.026123047, -0.0013303757, 0.0060424805, 0.020019531, -0.027770996, -0.02116394, 0.00046348572, -0.03604126, 0.008148193, -0.012931824, -0.011413574, -0.00071430206, -0.036071777, -0.013633728, 0.0259552, -0.012062073, 0.028274536, 0.004924774, 0.016036987, -0.024307251, -0.044952393, -0.023666382, 0.02709961, 0.016067505, 0.004753113, 0.014297485, -0.008232117, 0.0009255409, 0.0032024384, 0.016174316, 0.013809204, -0.014915466, -0.012054443, -0.047302246, 0.032562256, -0.011306763, -0.019302368, 0.010902405, -0.011405945, -0.03704834, -0.043701172, 0.037719727, 0.013366699, 0.04925537, -0.02470398, -0.046783447, 0.019104004, -0.039855957, -0.033416748, -0.042816162, 0.009933472, -0.036499023, -0.020050049, 0.0121536255, 0.009010315, 0.018463135, -0.039978027, 0.03225708, 0.0039749146, -0.01838684, 0.010505676, -0.02571106, 0.1182251, 0.0045166016, -0.066711426, 0.041381836, -0.04434204, 0.0491333, 0.02571106, 0.010871887, 0.018585205, -0.017852783, 0.022720337, -0.002380371, -0.06866455, 0.043029785, -0.035583496, 0.0052375793, 0.037872314, -0.048950195, -0.020370483, -0.011993408, 0.032592773, -0.06506348, 0.015991211, 0.006755829, 0.061401367, -0.039093018, 0.028045654, 0.006164551, -0.006954193, -0.06188965, 0.03845215, -0.015159607, -0.008781433, 0.060455322, 0.0501709, -0.011306763, 0.0030174255, -0.026855469, -0.022384644, 0.0013027191, -0.047424316, 0.013084412, 0.04248047, 0.0063591003, -0.0036773682, -0.026031494, 0.040618896, -0.02142334, 0.011146545, -0.03555298, 0.040985107, -0.093444824, 0.018112183, 0.0037784576, -0.00075912476, -0.05026245, -0.05419922, 0.014564514, -0.07556152, 0.008865356, -0.0072135925, 0.018661499, -0.011955261, -0.028457642, 0.052337646, 0.015205383, -0.033813477, 0.024505615, 0.047058105, -0.040100098, -0.02407837, -0.046844482, -0.015235901, 0.0015888214, -0.013786316, 0.029190063, 0.00080776215, -0.02633667, -0.019821167, 0.0075263977, 0.025482178, 0.02659607, 0.047668457, 0.038085938, -0.0010185242, -0.0619812, 0.02243042, -0.0021781921, 0.03262329, -0.046661377, 0.0345459, -0.00548172, 0.00573349, -0.009597778, -0.008003235, -0.0061416626, -0.07043457, -0.0063591003, -0.0002975464, -0.0016899109, 0.020202637, 0.0046577454, 0.010353088, -0.0017175674, 0.034942627, 0.014755249, 0.008171082, -0.037109375, 0.049041748, 0.00059986115, 0.042236328, -0.00047516823, 0.05911255, 0.0043258667, -0.013893127, 0.01626587, -0.0099487305, 0.034820557, -0.010375977, 0.015548706, -0.008705139, -0.0012273788, -0.0018110275, 0.029266357, -0.0058250427, 0.025634766, 0.035247803, 0.0048599243, -0.022979736, 0.019241333, -0.023788452, -0.025131226, 0.01751709, -0.023422241, 0.016662598, -0.07232666, -0.04547119, -0.049621582, 0.05697632, -0.010353088, -0.028640747, 0.0098724365, -0.03543091, 0.03640747, 0.034973145, 0.009689331, -0.09454346, 0.008087158, -0.007461548, -0.03604126, -0.0113220215, -0.016204834, -0.038146973, 0.008781433, 0.008522034, 0.048675537, -0.029586792, -0.027816772, -0.0023612976, -0.014976501, -0.004688263, 0.038116455, -0.013114929, -0.01826477, 0.054016113, -0.056549072, 0.03152466, 0.05731201, -0.0043754578, -0.023208618, 0.0070266724, -0.031951904, 0.01612854, -0.035736084, -0.034423828, 0.061645508, -0.0036354065, -0.0012292862, -0.00015115738, 0.041656494, -0.0064430237, 0.028579712, -0.035827637, -0.02230835, -0.08477783, 0.023468018, 0.014312744, -0.010520935, 0.002948761, 0.021270752, 0.012451172, -0.02104187, 0.011131287, 0.002002716, 0.026794434, -0.027313232, 0.025115967, -0.025238037, -0.029418945, -0.0010433197, -0.071777344, 0.029052734, -0.05508423, 0.031204224, -0.027404785, -0.029006958, -0.04559326, -0.04260254, 0.02293396, -0.021743774, 0.042816162, 0.015602112, 0.022583008, 0.008468628, -0.051086426, 0.0076560974, 0.011543274, 0.023483276, -0.0044555664, -0.036071777, -0.052947998, -0.0690918, 0.03237915, -0.009208679, 0.0362854, 0.048583984, -0.034332275, 0.023025513, -0.006465912, -0.029815674, 0.008056641, 0.0023880005, -0.009376526, 0.011383057, -0.03945923, -0.05303955, -0.0015678406, 0.03161621, -0.0524292, 0.032806396, -0.022338867, -0.0112838745, 0.018447876, -0.025604248, 0.016281128, 0.01436615, 0.0025482178, 0.015312195, 0.014434814, 0.018829346, 0.0034542084, 0.01574707, 0.021377563, 0.040618896, -0.031677246, 0.010467529, -0.046295166, 0.023605347, -0.06286621, -0.036987305, -0.024734497, 0.018936157, -0.0005707741, -0.0637207, 0.0018806458, 0.0040283203, 0.06100464, 0.04852295, 0.07891846, -0.01159668, 0.013290405, -0.044677734, 0.023880005, 0.017242432, -0.014839172, -0.030914307, -0.0068740845, 0.010437012, 0.040039062, -0.009399414, 0.019012451, 0.028503418, 0.001499176, -0.042022705, 0.045776367, 0.0050239563, 0.020462036, 0.008903503, 0.017807007, 0.029830933, -0.0234375, 0.024612427, -0.01701355, 0.0037937164, 0.015174866, -0.013267517, 0.0084991455, -0.01033783, -0.020370483, 0.016693115, -0.021835327, -0.045959473, -0.033050537, 0.028686523, 0.015266418, -0.044921875, -0.039489746, -0.04800415, -0.041748047, 0.04510498, -0.01537323, -0.014297485, 0.030563354, 0.008056641, -0.0039596558, -0.020721436, -0.0025806427, -0.01373291, 0.010650635, 0.06365967, 0.0035552979, -0.011352539, -0.008857727, -0.01473999, 0.041229248, 0.038360596, -0.0027828217, 0.0021362305, -0.009170532, -0.0009365082, 0.012031555, -0.012046814, -0.031066895, 0.026992798, -0.025939941, -0.022872925, 0.004875183, 0.007686615, -0.0026607513, 0.018112183, 0.0055351257, 0.028564453, 0.020950317, 0.01953125, 0.03201294, -0.02885437, -0.008392334, 0.015655518, -0.033416748, -0.006954193, -0.003501892, 0.017654419, 0.035461426, 0.0055770874, -0.03378296, 0.010292053, -0.00031781197, 0.0040664673, 0.026611328, 0.005504608, -0.041015625, -0.00025510788, 0.016494751, -0.01574707, 0.0012302399, -0.016860962, 0.016708374, 0.030441284, -0.0064048767, 0.029724121, -0.0059928894, 0.0014314651, -0.027801514, 0.036376953, -0.026382446, -0.0038967133, 0.013137817, -0.016174316, -0.0060691833, 0.025604248, 0.0015535355, 0.011779785, 0.0008716583, 0.07824707, 0.09710693, 0.04901123, -0.048583984, 0.019180298, 0.11035156, -0.026947021, 0.043914795, -0.0040740967, -0.000600338, -0.050048828, -0.016830444, -0.0071754456, -0.011711121, 0.006034851, 0.092285156, -0.00084352493, -0.007575989, -0.026763916, -0.026473999, 0.011054993, -0.019302368, 0.036956787, -0.057281494, -0.016525269, 0.005783081, 0.004283905, -0.012550354, 0.009170532, -0.035858154, -0.0034255981, 0.0036735535, 0.013710022, -0.014724731, -0.030532837, 0.04550171, 0.052368164, 0.06011963, 0.08251953, 0.054626465, -0.02609253, 0.015113831, -0.007904053, 0.023910522, -0.00819397, -0.020553589, 0.01737976, -0.016830444, -0.050689697, -0.016586304, -0.020126343, -0.051361084, -0.039245605, -0.069885254, 0.028167725, -0.027862549, 0.02809143, 0.01889038, -0.020339966, -0.0051498413, 0.018814087, -0.024261475, 0.015510559, -0.0012187958, -0.0033187866, 0.026916504, 0.00039052963, 0.0071411133, -0.026031494, -0.0017681122, -0.026870728, -0.0076408386, -0.010803223, -0.026382446, 0.0070991516, 0.01285553, -0.05078125, -0.04220581, 0.017227173, 0.026260376, -0.0051002502, -0.029434204, -0.007068634, 0.007209778, 0.06762695, 0.015899658, 0.00920105, -0.038238525, 0.0003938675, -0.003921509, 0.04837036, -0.029632568, -0.020706177, -0.0043525696, -0.0006289482, -0.06298828, 0.016662598, 0.025497437, -0.008506775, 0.030929565, 0.005138397, 0.05731201, -0.0052604675, -0.009414673, 0.0052490234, 0.013465881, 0.0048103333, 0.0236969, -0.002439499, 0.004283905, 0.021530151, 0.04751587, -0.04324341, -0.034088135, 0.023651123, 0.04348755, -0.018753052, -0.043640137, -0.018218994, 0.022949219, 0.010482788, 0.012077332, -0.003627777, 0.009208679, 0.0016002655, -0.006313324, -0.00001424551, -0.03427124, -0.0029067993, -0.0713501, -0.030700684, 0.03692627, -0.062438965, -0.006793976, -0.049682617, -0.011993408, 0.00970459, -0.028778076, -0.005050659, 0.0061912537, -0.02279663, -0.022064209, -0.02796936, 0.015930176 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1801.05757v1
Experience-driven Networking: A Deep Reinforcement Learning based Approach
Zhiyuan Xu, Jian Tang, Jingsong Meng, Weiyi Zhang, Yanzhi Wang, Chi Harold Liu, Dejun Yang
cs.NI, cs.AI, cs.LG
Modern communication networks have become very complicated and highly dynamic, which makes them hard to model, predict and control. In this paper, we develop a novel experience-driven approach that can learn to well control a communication network from its own experience rather than an accurate mathematical model, just as a human learns a new skill (such as driving, swimming, etc). Specifically, we, for the first time, propose to leverage emerging Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) for enabling model-free control in communication networks; and present a novel and highly effective DRL-based control framework, DRL-TE, for a fundamental networking problem: Traffic Engineering (TE). The proposed framework maximizes a widely-used utility function by jointly learning network environment and its dynamics, and making decisions under the guidance of powerful Deep Neural Networks (DNNs). We propose two new techniques, TE-aware exploration and actor-critic-based prioritized experience replay, to optimize the general DRL framework particularly for TE. To validate and evaluate the proposed framework, we implemented it in ns-3, and tested it comprehensively with both representative and randomly generated network topologies. Extensive packet-level simulation results show that 1) compared to several widely-used baseline methods, DRL-TE significantly reduces end-to-end delay and consistently improves the network utility, while offering better or comparable throughput; 2) DRL-TE is robust to network changes; and 3) DRL-TE consistently outperforms a state-ofthe-art DRL method (for continuous control), Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient (DDPG), which, however, does not offer satisfying performance.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1801.05757v1
2018-01-17T17:09:01
2018-01-17T17:09:01
{ "title": [ -0.007865906, -0.0072021484, -0.027282715, -0.041168213, 0.0256958, -0.0090408325, -0.001335144, -0.021438599, -0.02355957, 0.027297974, 0.0001270771, 0.022872925, -0.017471313, -0.0413208, -0.0075263977, 0.006286621, -0.014328003, 0.019882202, -0.02633667, -0.040618896, -0.023025513, -0.04736328, 0.03817749, 0.05734253, 0.023284912, -0.009216309, -0.07867432, 0.022064209, -0.03656006, -0.019180298, -0.010543823, 0.0039405823, 0.031463623, 0.029800415, -0.027038574, -0.021469116, -0.06854248, 0.018127441, -0.018981934, 0.015571594, 0.014816284, -0.008911133, -0.0059013367, -0.058044434, -0.025268555, 0.033935547, -0.06112671, -0.023101807, -0.013298035, 0.06573486, 0.026504517, 0.040405273, -0.014060974, 0.06317139, 0.03253174, -0.017532349, -0.022506714, -0.03729248, 0.04699707, 0.052490234, 0.008468628, -0.064819336, 0.029129028, -0.023452759, -0.043762207, -0.034576416, 0.05935669, 0.027175903, 0.047454834, -0.0011291504, -0.0014104843, 0.046051025, -0.0043792725, 0.017715454, -0.03515625, -0.0063438416, 0.057250977, 0.023635864, 0.0087509155, -0.00034284592, -0.018493652, 0.005744934, -0.012840271, -0.023010254, 0.0016012192, -0.042022705, -0.022521973, -0.009864807, -0.008125305, -0.04336548, 0.0021743774, -0.003643036, 0.017074585, 0.046844482, -0.029754639, 0.0018529892, -0.036743164, -0.0038833618, 0.0041656494, 0.0006303787, -0.020935059, 0.008255005, -0.017944336, -0.019088745, -0.0007610321, 0.005104065, -0.010665894, -0.004135132, 0.010948181, 0.047332764, -0.012397766, 0.028915405, 0.022994995, 0.042388916, -0.020523071, -0.021255493, -0.006412506, 0.0037193298, -0.019546509, 0.03741455, -0.025543213, -0.040130615, 0.014770508, 0.025939941, 0.025894165, 0.008804321, -0.023773193, -0.0008716583, -0.018157959, 0.030349731, 0.0005326271, 0.032348633, -0.087768555, -0.07861328, -0.059570312, 0.04510498, -0.021850586, -0.002363205, 0.015129089, -0.016311646, 0.029067993, -0.03161621, -0.011695862, 0.033081055, 0.025787354, 0.00062417984, 0.053466797, -0.008056641, -0.026626587, 0.0049057007, -0.03753662, 0.020431519, 0.015098572, 0.010894775, -0.0063972473, 0.02357483, -0.09454346, -0.005596161, 0.0289917, 0.027450562, 0.023742676, 0.008735657, -0.007167816, 0.034973145, 0.066833496, -0.016418457, -0.019454956, 0.024627686, -0.0066375732, 0.044830322, -0.031829834, 0.029830933, -0.011123657, -0.017242432, 0.0066223145, -0.0016269684, 0.04360962, 0.024154663, 0.036346436, -0.0060310364, 0.021118164, -0.0053863525, 0.04901123, 0.043395996, -0.04849243, -0.02268982, -0.002691269, -0.008605957, 0.054992676, 0.012245178, -0.035583496, 0.018173218, -0.061523438, -0.05340576, -0.061920166, -0.003408432, 0.04763794, 0.05380249, -0.0078048706, 0.038208008, -0.038116455, -0.006252289, -0.027435303, 0.012245178, 0.0016298294, -0.03439331, -0.008239746, 0.0090408325, -0.004802704, 0.046569824, 0.038482666, 0.01687622, -0.013511658, -0.02973938, -0.018218994, -0.0602417, 0.015159607, -0.013595581, -0.00025200844, 0.0014781952, -0.018692017, 0.003709793, -0.009254456, 0.034820557, 0.02017212, 0.010818481, -0.005706787, -0.02444458, 0.029327393, 0.03186035, 0.06286621, -0.037078857, 0.019058228, -0.009132385, -0.030761719, -0.009963989, -0.0062828064, 0.010673523, 0.0055351257, 0.010299683, -0.0076904297, -0.014533997, -0.0093307495, 0.04473877, 0.0022010803, -0.032958984, 0.0007972717, 0.019805908, 0.01499176, 0.033966064, 0.04562378, 0.050323486, 0.06591797, 0.046203613, 0.009864807, 0.068115234, 0.0040130615, 0.022323608, -0.012542725, 0.021469116, -0.0005249977, 0.03805542, 0.019180298, 0.021362305, -0.06915283, -0.0032520294, -0.039916992, -0.003709793, 0.0054244995, 0.014221191, 0.03869629, -0.013336182, 0.0031280518, 0.010169983, 0.0020275116, -0.013412476, -0.022644043, 0.013450623, -0.0011978149, -0.050201416, -0.0178833, 0.0028839111, 0.03491211, -0.00024151802, 0.039276123, -0.012863159, 0.007003784, -0.0446167, -0.0020542145, -0.029129028, 0.044403076, 0.0038318634, -0.018432617, -0.00018918514, 0.011291504, -0.029724121, 0.027816772, 0.09698486, -0.04611206, 0.036010742, -0.05444336, 0.0064582825, 0.017410278, -0.034118652, -0.008560181, 0.034851074, 0.008796692, 0.021850586, -0.02116394, -0.0006747246, -0.03616333, 0.031799316, -0.00045847893, -0.039245605, -0.052764893, -0.05239868, -0.019836426, -0.056671143, -0.05303955, -0.0043907166, 0.097229004, -0.023330688, -0.027954102, -0.0021133423, -0.023803711, -0.0390625, -0.012687683, -0.035186768, -0.036468506, 0.029327393, 0.038879395, 0.017364502, -0.04727173, 0.006034851, -0.0038471222, 0.015609741, 0.000043153763, -0.0024051666, -0.018066406, 0.010734558, 0.032592773, -0.041870117, 0.009971619, -0.020614624, -0.0104904175, -0.048614502, -0.00048589706, 0.01461792, -0.022232056, -0.00007224083, 0.035217285, -0.01777649, -0.060699463, 0.0178833, 0.05645752, -0.035369873, 0.00048279762, 0.055419922, 0.040222168, 0.0060195923, -0.0007686615, 0.014472961, -0.016189575, -0.06298828, 0.007408142, -0.028656006, -0.016342163, -0.013999939, -0.052490234, 0.033416748, -0.048553467, -0.04827881, 0.0032615662, -0.015174866, -0.03378296, 0.04864502, 0.009788513, -0.009117126, -0.03945923, -0.013710022, 0.013885498, 0.023880005, -0.03274536, -0.0057868958, 0.07623291, -0.0017547607, -0.030792236, -0.0068855286, 0.05368042, 0.011459351, 0.009353638, -0.026535034, 0.0053977966, 0.018920898, 0.022415161, 0.0036449432, 0.009109497, 0.014427185, -0.12512207, -0.022598267, 0.04663086, 0.019989014, -0.017654419, 0.0135269165, -0.044433594, -0.018203735, 0.018630981, -0.013511658, 0.029800415, 0.08239746, 0.016662598, -0.009147644, 0.02822876, -0.034851074, 0.04168701, -0.02848816, -0.03768921, 0.030807495, -0.048858643, -0.04953003, 0.0021438599, 0.00022125244, -0.05630493, -0.036010742, 0.03390503, 0.023849487, 0.044555664, -0.011497498, 0.044555664, 0.005027771, 0.0055351257, -0.015159607, -0.01499176, -0.016418457, -0.034362793, -0.027755737, 0.00881958, 0.02909851, 0.05404663, -0.021987915, -0.042877197, -0.030685425, 0.028625488, 0.024734497, 0.039978027, -0.03933716, -0.026428223, -0.01626587, -0.0061569214, -0.030776978, -0.0079956055, -0.01134491, -0.017578125, 0.014274597, -0.0057525635, 0.06604004, 0.022033691, -0.00774765, -0.024719238, 0.007381439, 0.026733398, -0.0062294006, -0.06021118, 0.0010137558, 0.06384277, 0.004760742, 0.012817383, -0.021392822, -0.033416748, 0.035736084, -0.023849487, -0.027938843, 0.010551453, -0.018249512, -0.0072402954, 0.004585266, 0.0009560585, -0.015525818, 0.0050811768, 0.0034942627, 0.024536133, -0.00096797943, -0.022094727, -0.02859497, 0.0046691895, 0.0025310516, -0.10076904, -0.017669678, -0.003293991, -0.00016903877, -0.011512756, -0.05307007, 0.01638794, -0.005794525, -0.04663086, 0.00869751, -0.030456543, 0.012893677, -0.0018100739, -0.06878662, 0.0006599426, 0.042541504, 0.016983032, 0.00081157684, 0.036315918, -0.013916016, -0.023864746, -0.016921997, 0.0026931763, 0.00617218, 0.046051025, -0.0018930435, 0.019882202, 0.040222168, -0.020370483, 0.010437012, 0.030639648, 0.033813477, -0.01826477, -0.0015134811, 0.05795288, 0.050842285, -0.020065308, 0.032104492, 0.008888245, -0.01852417, -0.063964844, -0.0038852692, -0.012008667, -0.027297974, 0.017440796, 0.023712158, 0.012413025, 0.009552002, 0.014099121, 0.026321411, -0.014038086, -0.011329651, 0.032226562, -0.0014066696, -0.00894165, 0.009963989, 0.026824951, 0.0151901245, 0.007736206, -0.0054244995, -0.014694214, 0.040374756, -0.06329346, 0.0010719299, 0.011482239, 0.016189575, -0.028427124, -0.009727478, -0.0519104, -0.018554688, -0.011688232, -0.0060806274, -0.027740479, 0.028167725, 0.024810791, -0.023147583, -0.017959595, 0.0115737915, 0.03503418, 0.002199173, -0.022064209, -0.073913574, 0.012145996, -0.029800415, -0.03326416, -0.035491943, -0.009651184, -0.014465332, 0.01991272, -0.010421753, -0.033355713, 0.024154663, 0.03552246, 0.087402344, 0.062194824, -0.014427185, -0.070495605, 0.029953003, -0.016693115, -0.01979065, 0.0032596588, -0.01259613, -0.007926941, -0.018844604, 0.02279663, -0.01939392, -0.02243042, -0.01727295, 0.017944336, 0.01763916, 0.031951904, 0.000120818615, 0.068115234, 0.020462036, 0.015296936, 0.0140686035, 0.022537231, -0.034301758, -0.034698486, -0.0051498413, 0.05657959, -0.024780273, 0.019165039, 0.046020508, 0.01991272, 0.00028562546, -0.0070495605, 0.017333984, 0.014251709, -0.008514404, 0.0038967133, 0.013580322, -0.026611328, -0.009208679, 0.011222839, 0.017623901, 0.040039062, -0.0491333, 0.08227539, -0.017745972, -0.009773254, 0.027526855, -0.013549805, 0.0118637085, -0.018112183, 0.011833191, -0.08874512, -0.062683105, -0.036499023, 0.051086426, -0.040527344, -0.012329102, 0.0047950745, 0.0046310425, 0.02494812, 0.054260254, 0.05847168, -0.0138168335, -0.02003479, -0.013267517, -0.0034637451, -0.031311035, -0.058563232, 0.0052452087, -0.014595032, 0.024978638, -0.037231445, 0.023956299, -0.07128906, 0.006416321, 0.017990112, -0.023117065, 0.0043792725, -0.071777344, 0.017211914, 0.04547119, -0.0231781, 0.025527954, 0.038635254, 0.018630981, 0.017181396, 0.039642334, 0.011070251, 0.037628174, 0.0052719116, -0.043914795, 0.02281189, -0.013198853, 0.017990112, -0.011550903, 0.0035705566, 0.006164551, 0.010543823, -0.052093506, 0.04156494, 0.0064697266, -0.04107666, 0.006816864, -0.0418396, -0.0011205673, -0.0019035339, 0.028869629, 0.021774292, -0.043823242, -0.030838013, -0.006412506, -0.012077332, -0.037384033, 0.046722412, 0.023605347, -0.029342651, -0.06304932, 0.0070266724, -0.015281677, 0.011192322, -0.005584717, 0.0067710876, -0.038513184, 0.0020198822, 0.030471802, 0.011894226, 0.017318726, 0.0008120537, 0.018630981, 0.04510498, 0.024856567, -0.05001831, 0.0024471283, 0.0058898926, -0.061553955, -0.07733154, -0.003856659, -0.00085926056, -0.011795044, 0.008552551, -0.019927979, 0.01939392, 0.0052871704, 0.03302002, 0.004688263, -0.025726318, 0.044158936, 0.0060310364, 0.017196655, -0.0068511963, 0.0022697449, -0.035339355, -0.0019197464, 0.022216797, 0.0055122375, 0.0046653748, 0.0017242432, -0.005680084, 0.010612488, -0.05996704, 0.019638062, 0.017745972, 0.016738892, -0.0012636185, 0.007701874, 0.02809143, 0.014877319, -0.0016880035, 0.00617218, 0.06695557, -0.03363037, 0.050231934, 0.0017271042, 0.0043029785, -0.047668457, 0.024353027, -0.021972656, 0.033081055, -0.052520752, -0.068847656, -0.018875122, 0.02041626, 0.032318115, 0.03665161, 0.05645752, -0.07080078, 0.017349243, -0.014175415, -0.00020825863, 0.013038635, -0.015396118, 0.025344849, -0.0009074211, -0.01171875, 0.041748047, 0.019302368, -0.021942139, 0.031036377, -0.022140503, -0.031433105, -0.00592041, -0.028747559, 0.030044556, -0.01574707, -0.0052375793, 0.031097412, -0.0047950745, -0.0022563934, 0.03161621, -0.073913574, 0.0423584, 0.010887146, 0.05633545, 0.0501709, 0.029251099, 0.031463623, 0.006954193, 0.018920898, -0.035949707, 0.042877197, -0.04647827, -0.027786255, -0.078186035, -0.037994385, -0.09118652, 0.005138397, 0.002035141, 0.025405884, 0.03466797, 0.0047454834, 0.035705566, -0.015838623, 0.040802002, -0.000024557114, 0.06347656, 0.0031471252, 0.0012893677, -0.013069153, 0.027832031, 0.013168335, 0.026016235, -0.008522034, 0.033233643, -0.0135650635, -0.011489868, -0.004463196, 0.027664185, -0.001830101, 0.0038414001, 0.0073165894, -0.022140503, 0.053375244, -0.011062622, 0.021270752, 0.075927734, 0.05899048, -0.0071868896, -0.025726318, 0.026428223, 0.020248413, -0.05178833, 0.048950195, 0.05795288, -0.08416748, 0.021911621, -0.013137817, -0.02696228, -0.0050811768, 0.021743774, 0.03540039, -0.054107666, -0.026184082, 0.022628784, 0.028442383, -0.0025367737, 0.0057144165, -0.05038452, 0.0018663406, 0.029541016, 0.03314209, -0.017959595, -0.008865356, 0.015197754, 0.034240723, -0.010025024, 0.006000519, 0.0043907166, 0.042785645, -0.003206253, 0.026870728, -0.053100586, 0.017456055, 0.003376007, -0.03955078, 0.040283203, -0.004962921, -0.038604736, -0.0040245056, 0.0084991455, 0.03378296, 0.021331787, 0.05343628, 0.005683899, -0.036315918, -0.023956299, -0.038085938, 0.017288208, 0.03579712, -0.04434204, 0.0066871643, -0.022232056, -0.040283203, 0.03378296, -0.047454834, 0.047576904, -0.036071777, 0.0020427704, -0.008239746, 0.0005455017, 0.062316895, -0.068481445, -0.035949707, -0.023773193, -0.027664185, -0.0030555725, 0.006565094, -0.02835083, -0.005592346, 0.01235199, 0.014907837, 0.024902344, -0.030227661, -0.035949707, 0.0056266785, -0.054870605, -0.029571533, -0.07922363, 0.012290955, -0.04550171, -0.019805908, -0.0211792, 0.0064201355, 0.000767231, -0.011543274, -0.020065308, 0.029251099, -0.021987915, -0.04458618, 0.023422241, 0.026016235, -0.0021686554, 0.021820068, -0.018371582, 0.016296387, -0.0012054443, -0.037139893, 0.03942871, -0.04248047, -0.010894775, -0.026245117, -0.03112793, 0.038208008, 0.033447266, -0.013931274, 0.0034999847, 0.015991211, -0.03491211, -0.0063095093, 0.0008983612, 0.052093506, -0.0073165894, -0.027038574, -0.0028743744, 0.04385376, 0.03488159, -0.056854248, -0.016403198, 0.0034542084, 0.04260254, -0.0060272217, 0.059692383, 0.010276794, -0.005088806, 0.017166138, 0.0446167, 0.007843018, -0.050445557, -0.047851562, -0.01940918, 0.057739258, 0.026641846, 0.0024757385, -0.045013428, 0.029754639, -0.0035419464, 0.0064582825, 0.021865845, -0.014228821, 0.015975952, 0.007167816, 0.048431396, -0.008285522, 0.018951416, -0.029373169, 0.042999268, -0.011672974, 0.029846191, -0.0014152527, 0.018127441, 0.004890442, 0.051513672, -0.017242432, -0.04876709, 0.043670654, 0.044891357, 0.01828003, 0.021224976, -0.029693604, -0.017105103, 0.023010254, 0.0039100647, -0.017684937, 0.02130127, 0.04031372, -0.037200928, -0.00932312, -0.047943115, -0.06011963, -0.0019359589, -0.047973633, 0.013648987, -0.028839111, 0.02796936, -0.0041923523, -0.006965637, -0.010826111, 0.010299683, -0.011680603, -0.051940918, -0.04360962, 0.010612488, 0.048095703, 0.0030384064 ], "summary": [ 0.038909912, -0.0044822693, 0.004081726, -0.013793945, -0.009117126, -0.0044403076, -0.0064468384, -0.022460938, -0.010040283, 0.004383087, -0.0012788773, 0.007358551, -0.026977539, -0.057403564, 0.030303955, -0.030670166, 0.005252838, -0.0013017654, 0.0077400208, -0.036224365, 0.012649536, -0.046295166, 0.022628784, 0.06088257, -0.005054474, 0.034118652, -0.078552246, 0.034851074, -0.028747559, 0.004322052, 0.0013217926, 0.002904892, -0.015388489, 0.054351807, -0.04815674, -0.06161499, -0.05996704, 0.034851074, -0.012718201, 0.011398315, 0.0340271, -0.0029659271, 0.0692749, -0.017974854, 0.0008277893, 0.03503418, -0.0010251999, -0.034423828, 0.019165039, 0.054626465, -0.0018854141, 0.025680542, -0.03677368, 0.03643799, 0.0062026978, 0.005859375, -0.010864258, -0.024612427, 0.03277588, 0.0368042, 0.0023441315, -0.03326416, 0.017684937, -0.020874023, 0.016021729, -0.034301758, 0.06915283, 0.0032615662, 0.025238037, 0.033599854, 0.02218628, 0.03164673, 0.0066566467, -0.025772095, 0.0072250366, 0.027862549, 0.011245728, 0.03326416, -0.0033950806, 0.012008667, -0.032989502, 0.023757935, 0.006587982, -0.023391724, -0.016555786, -0.028686523, -0.029052734, -0.0034656525, 0.0115737915, 0.0132369995, -0.0017442703, 0.07989502, -0.0236969, 0.02859497, 0.008003235, -0.028869629, -0.014907837, -0.059020996, 0.020584106, 0.03277588, -0.015991211, -0.03149414, 0.047821045, -0.022003174, -0.008674622, -0.012771606, 0.008926392, -0.0005221367, 0.0075683594, 0.03137207, -0.032287598, 0.015411377, 0.013961792, 0.009391785, -0.015304565, 0.005012512, 0.003419876, 0.02420044, -0.024246216, 0.0395813, -0.028015137, 0.00023496151, 0.026550293, 0.021087646, 0.02104187, 0.022262573, 0.007896423, -0.01600647, 0.014350891, -0.004470825, -0.027938843, 0.031402588, 0.00013029575, -0.028152466, -0.042938232, -0.0065727234, -0.01902771, -0.019226074, 0.016189575, -0.008834839, 0.027069092, -0.022155762, -0.01725769, 0.046722412, 0.0032348633, 0.034362793, 0.019195557, -0.0044555664, 0.0011367798, -0.012619019, -0.011886597, 0.01108551, 0.020858765, 0.005519867, -0.01574707, -0.032592773, -0.027450562, -0.021942139, 0.03677368, -0.02848816, 0.041168213, 0.019943237, 0.013267517, 0.063964844, 0.036621094, -0.03552246, -0.021560669, 0.0039978027, -0.01235199, -0.0061912537, -0.017623901, 0.022888184, -0.044158936, -0.052825928, 0.0021266937, -0.023239136, -0.026657104, 0.033233643, 0.015319824, -0.008743286, 0.017807007, -0.0289917, 0.016479492, 0.034851074, -0.024505615, 0.0035247803, -0.0049858093, 0.008781433, 0.028137207, -0.008804321, 0.0055618286, -0.0021953583, -0.021255493, 0.004886627, -0.04949951, -0.00623703, -0.015235901, 0.019485474, -0.035186768, 0.035980225, 0.0061531067, -0.00409317, 0.005908966, -0.018157959, -0.043945312, -0.003900528, -0.017990112, 0.018432617, -0.0006637573, 0.01727295, 0.01928711, 0.0068969727, -0.015838623, -0.030960083, -0.037506104, -0.02406311, 0.014305115, -0.03112793, -0.009300232, -0.016143799, -0.0099487305, 0.027038574, -0.024139404, 0.077819824, 0.017974854, 0.013153076, -0.000035583973, 0.0047569275, 0.057556152, 0.008377075, 0.071899414, -0.036621094, -0.018630981, 0.032318115, -0.0064926147, -0.01826477, -0.01939392, -0.058563232, 0.02960205, 0.0317688, 0.013221741, 0.016479492, -0.018157959, 0.0049476624, -0.013893127, -0.0690918, -0.010169983, 0.0023555756, 0.00299263, -0.0018539429, 0.037017822, -0.011779785, 0.0368042, 0.016601562, 0.057891846, 0.009002686, -0.018112183, 0.0029067993, 0.004714966, 0.006149292, 0.013420105, 0.0028476715, 0.00579834, -0.003025055, 0.0024318695, -0.025283813, 0.021224976, 0.008140564, 0.018051147, -0.024398804, -0.010444641, -0.041259766, -0.003129959, -0.0013589859, -0.055603027, 0.008476257, -0.029754639, 0.035186768, -0.0048980713, -0.013244629, -0.021972656, -0.016601562, -0.024246216, -0.02178955, 0.038635254, -0.003019333, -0.00016605854, -0.03213501, 0.030197144, 0.030349731, 0.06384277, -0.02407837, -0.022903442, -0.005882263, 0.006427765, -0.046142578, -0.057250977, 0.060455322, -0.029968262, 0.006046295, -0.0021820068, 0.0287323, -0.013031006, 0.0075416565, 0.0011777878, 0.03338623, 0.016708374, 0.001115799, 0.015975952, 0.011245728, -0.04360962, 0.006931305, 0.0039367676, 0.0033111572, -0.02468872, -0.0211792, -0.036254883, 0.002538681, -0.011016846, 0.06555176, 0.08917236, -0.02217102, -0.015266418, 0.015716553, -0.03186035, -0.028121948, 0.029266357, -0.028335571, -0.051818848, 0.019012451, -0.02909851, -0.024673462, -0.029129028, 0.053833008, -0.004714966, 0.017623901, 0.013214111, -0.009094238, -0.0032997131, -0.008384705, 0.020355225, -0.08111572, -0.02267456, 0.025848389, -0.052459717, 0.020202637, 0.023208618, -0.015342712, 0.021118164, 0.032043457, -0.019683838, -0.010543823, -0.038879395, 0.03173828, 0.001291275, -0.0289917, 0.03274536, 0.0574646, -0.007293701, 0.00056934357, -0.00036907196, 0.05606079, 0.009231567, -0.070617676, -0.015151978, -0.018936157, -0.0014066696, -0.0127334595, -0.022644043, 0.0021400452, -0.030853271, -0.0062179565, 0.02986145, -0.021072388, -0.02015686, 0.03074646, 0.070739746, -0.0043411255, -0.0021343231, 0.04034424, 0.033813477, 0.034484863, -0.04248047, -0.014602661, 0.030380249, -0.02458191, -0.06384277, -0.029434204, 0.054748535, 0.044433594, 0.049346924, -0.034576416, 0.005882263, -0.019348145, 0.016357422, -0.002450943, 0.016601562, 0.049438477, -0.045837402, -0.04171753, 0.03515625, 0.016098022, 0.015388489, -0.012901306, -0.023406982, -0.008255005, 0.01071167, 0.006008148, 0.008148193, 0.015052795, 0.028274536, -0.038024902, 0.026000977, -0.047973633, 0.040924072, -0.04046631, 0.08654785, 0.01890564, -0.050689697, -0.042633057, 0.028060913, 0.044281006, -0.003168106, -0.02696228, 0.04547119, 0.018417358, 0.026275635, -0.032196045, -0.0068855286, 0.066711426, 0.032806396, -0.012451172, -0.018173218, 0.019927979, -0.010948181, 0.021072388, 0.012382507, -0.016921997, 0.05307007, -0.046051025, -0.077819824, -0.057678223, 0.012039185, 0.012924194, 0.039001465, -0.023635864, -0.055786133, -0.059295654, 0.0036811829, -0.05886841, -0.015655518, -0.006340027, 0.034240723, 0.034454346, 0.006767273, 0.07946777, -0.012420654, 0.00592041, 0.007095337, 0.010238647, 0.023452759, 0.013999939, -0.029830933, -0.020767212, 0.05432129, 0.0033359528, -0.021743774, 0.0051879883, -0.038757324, 0.021057129, 0.035949707, -0.061920166, 0.0004837513, -0.0056533813, -0.023834229, -0.01448822, 0.048339844, -0.008262634, 0.028839111, -0.04171753, -0.016708374, 0.0057868958, -0.04724121, 0.007171631, 0.016479492, 0.008041382, -0.04953003, -0.021392822, -0.004131317, 0.04925537, 0.05718994, -0.036071777, 0.015388489, 0.026229858, -0.045074463, 0.004421234, -0.0413208, 0.111694336, 0.04095459, -0.05001831, 0.08544922, -0.032287598, 0.030258179, -0.0009560585, 0.009757996, 0.0054779053, 0.03262329, 0.0395813, 0.023742676, 0.014038086, 0.048431396, 0.0022125244, 0.066711426, 0.02468872, 0.01158905, -0.012634277, 0.041931152, 0.05706787, -0.021759033, -0.022827148, 0.098083496, 0.07165527, -0.014862061, -0.00440979, 0.008674622, 0.017623901, -0.060516357, -0.003709793, -0.025772095, -0.027740479, 0.057006836, 0.081604004, 0.023132324, 0.0077171326, -0.043701172, -0.049804688, -0.00015509129, -0.041259766, 0.014450073, 0.04748535, 0.011398315, -0.012046814, -0.021499634, 0.024871826, 0.0040664673, -0.02104187, -0.022140503, 0.026031494, -0.104003906, 0.0418396, 0.00907135, -0.0054893494, -0.037841797, -0.02734375, 0.01071167, -0.014968872, -0.005264282, -0.016204834, -0.033996582, 0.0345459, -0.01713562, -0.0008234978, 0.023284912, -0.0096588135, 0.015594482, 0.030593872, -0.029190063, -0.031951904, 0.011993408, -0.026931763, -0.052764893, -0.04373169, -0.06616211, -0.07647705, -0.027740479, 0.013076782, -0.013336182, 0.026260376, 0.041900635, 0.076049805, 0.042053223, 0.02619934, -0.049224854, 0.057434082, 0.008743286, -0.03048706, 0.0053482056, -0.0050468445, 0.003627777, -0.005970001, 0.025360107, -0.024398804, -0.05441284, 0.0022850037, 0.027633667, 0.029937744, 0.011360168, 0.022140503, 0.078125, 0.021942139, 0.022979736, 0.0018701553, 0.007835388, -0.013908386, -0.04574585, -0.022720337, 0.008483887, 0.010528564, 0.0039253235, 0.030014038, 0.0052261353, -0.018737793, 0.0059051514, 0.0057296753, 0.008628845, -0.005832672, 0.0005903244, -0.00034618378, 0.044158936, 0.01399231, 0.033111572, 0.01902771, 0.0033683777, 0.028335571, -0.0050735474, 0.012565613, 0.039520264, 0.015899658, -0.02645874, 0.013534546, -0.0013151169, 0.008979797, -0.054351807, -0.0770874, -0.03427124, 0.068603516, -0.019119263, -0.05508423, -0.032470703, -0.0033493042, 0.011924744, 0.0047187805, 0.02406311, -0.010429382, -0.031829834, -0.014549255, -0.0014219284, -0.014678955, -0.033843994, 0.0015001297, -0.014533997, 0.017349243, 0.015777588, 0.014038086, -0.0026168823, 0.047790527, 0.013061523, -0.0013599396, -0.04360962, -0.008460999, -0.0049057007, -0.0077705383, -0.055633545, -0.007774353, 0.077819824, -0.032348633, -0.058807373, 0.021011353, -0.054016113, 0.040527344, -0.0048103333, -0.105407715, 0.020751953, -0.013404846, 0.04296875, -0.03152466, 0.03744507, 0.0126953125, 0.018371582, -0.0758667, 0.00623703, 0.012207031, -0.002960205, -0.019515991, -0.015914917, 0.020629883, -0.007965088, 0.020706177, 0.020843506, -0.030960083, 0.0043296814, 0.023483276, -0.008178711, -0.005962372, 0.018081665, -0.0129470825, -0.0077400208, -0.019622803, 0.013427734, -0.027664185, 0.008377075, 0.011749268, -0.008140564, -0.0035686493, -0.03152466, -0.00051116943, 0.051574707, 0.00073480606, 0.026611328, 0.025817871, -0.0047416687, -0.0138549805, -0.051239014, -0.0070266724, -0.0011386871, -0.040863037, -0.08404541, -0.005290985, -0.022827148, 0.027542114, 0.009338379, 0.08514404, 0.027175903, -0.040740967, 0.02960205, -0.013656616, -0.04824829, 0.03036499, 0.0050582886, -0.00071144104, -0.001490593, -0.019973755, -0.07775879, 0.0070343018, 0.038208008, 0.04547119, 0.035369873, 0.028747559, 0.035308838, 0.0000113248825, -0.03353882, -0.0034942627, 0.04046631, -0.003118515, -0.000579834, 0.042877197, 0.010902405, -0.01108551, 0.01953125, 0.00042915344, 0.018829346, 0.021972656, 0.02192688, 0.005077362, 0.008338928, -0.025177002, 0.009857178, 0.0042419434, 0.021026611, -0.029373169, -0.04547119, 0.018615723, 0.009521484, 0.011116028, 0.03274536, 0.030838013, -0.040252686, 0.009513855, -0.032318115, 0.018951416, 0.04333496, -0.019317627, -0.0038547516, 0.034301758, -0.012901306, 0.035888672, 0.006717682, -0.0062828064, 0.0041923523, -0.024246216, -0.0012292862, -0.022994995, 0.01600647, 0.019760132, 0.0015993118, 0.0155181885, 0.012298584, -0.01890564, 0.03213501, 0.01473999, -0.052825928, 0.022277832, 0.018478394, 0.038146973, 0.027664185, 0.009841919, 0.0043640137, 0.024429321, 0.009353638, -0.032836914, 0.08099365, -0.010467529, -0.10418701, -0.10510254, -0.09851074, -0.03149414, 0.011985779, -0.061553955, -0.029968262, 0.08306885, -0.012145996, 0.04901123, -0.00617218, -0.03048706, -0.020507812, -0.011512756, 0.031707764, -0.005844116, 0.0039787292, 0.029281616, -0.015197754, 0.022460938, 0.018951416, 0.023132324, 0.0039749146, -0.025497437, 0.016738892, 0.016845703, -0.012145996, -0.02368164, 0.029190063, -0.02558899, 0.025634766, -0.006095886, 0.0071525574, 0.053741455, 0.022872925, 0.009140015, -0.0070533752, 0.03857422, 0.0592041, -0.0418396, 0.07537842, 0.031555176, -0.010139465, -0.00015175343, 0.006450653, -0.035827637, 0.0115737915, 0.027801514, 0.02809143, -0.041503906, -0.00033593178, 0.053131104, -0.0066719055, -0.015274048, -0.017700195, -0.036193848, -0.02607727, 0.034240723, 0.014793396, -0.026535034, -0.0340271, -0.0009965897, 0.008659363, -0.052764893, 0.05819702, -0.0079422, 0.04714966, -0.029769897, 0.0184021, -0.12780762, 0.013206482, 0.03375244, -0.014129639, 0.0418396, 0.016952515, 0.018997192, 0.03036499, -0.015594482, 0.0129470825, -0.004447937, 0.005340576, -0.04446411, -0.018875122, 0.017089844, -0.002603531, -0.01084137, 0.024902344, -0.022781372, -0.027496338, -0.0029792786, -0.017654419, 0.009315491, -0.034210205, 0.013694763, -0.010955811, 0.0064735413, -0.0335083, -0.011657715, 0.014480591, -0.052825928, -0.01259613, -0.059692383, -0.02545166, 0.024551392, 0.032409668, -0.024291992, 0.005718231, -0.0024223328, -0.012771606, 0.029663086, -0.02470398, -0.0033416748, 0.009239197, -0.00207901, -0.026123047, -0.035980225, 0.028121948, -0.041625977, -0.028671265, 0.012916565, 0.0041999817, 0.013504028, -0.0074043274, -0.014694214, 0.034729004, 0.00831604, -0.06378174, 0.031677246, 0.028656006, 0.015945435, 0.06951904, 0.020187378, 0.019515991, 0.026504517, -0.020187378, 0.0647583, -0.0032196045, -0.019958496, -0.00434494, -0.056152344, 0.021911621, -0.024765015, -0.0011405945, 0.034332275, -0.017471313, 0.0016651154, -0.0028591156, 0.04196167, 0.03829956, 0.008155823, -0.0015363693, -0.012886047, 0.024627686, 0.041137695, -0.029159546, 0.03390503, -0.0054855347, 0.030075073, -0.004283905, 0.011238098, -0.026428223, 0.0020446777, 0.06866455, 0.07763672, 0.011413574, -0.040771484, -0.040740967, -0.020767212, 0.08343506, -0.0060195923, -0.031158447, -0.026397705, 0.01638794, 0.0044670105, -0.004333496, -0.02923584, 0.0058021545, -0.005847931, 0.0014276505, 0.023864746, -0.011665344, 0.035736084, -0.011383057, 0.037139893, -0.019485474, -0.0061073303, 0.012168884, 0.011947632, 0.01121521, 0.0037384033, -0.011398315, 0.042114258, -0.021728516, -0.014953613, 0.012245178, -0.024856567, -0.009765625, 0.033843994, 0.03768921, 0.019958496, 0.0024356842, 0.030776978, 0.03250122, -0.042877197, -0.02432251, -0.08319092, -0.030380249, -0.033477783, -0.019699097, -0.0073661804, -0.013145447, 0.02255249, 0.053741455, -0.022338867, 0.0046844482, 0.03616333, -0.0211792, -0.010978699, 0.0075416565, 0.026824951, 0.017105103, 0.011772156 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1803.08784v4
Causal Modeling of Dynamical Systems
Stephan Bongers, Tineke Blom, Joris M. Mooij
cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ME, stat.ML
Dynamical systems are widely used in science and engineering to model systems consisting of several interacting components. Often, they can be given a causal interpretation in the sense that they not only model the evolution of the states of the system's components over time, but also describe how their evolution is affected by external interventions on the system that perturb the dynamics. We introduce the formal framework of structural dynamical causal models (SDCMs) that explicates the causal semantics of the system's components as part of the model. SDCMs represent a dynamical system as a collection of stochastic processes and specify the basic causal mechanisms that govern the dynamics of each component as a structured system of random differential equations of arbitrary order. SDCMs extend the versatile causal modeling framework of structural causal models (SCMs), also known as structural equation models (SEMs), by explicitly allowing for time-dependence. An SDCM can be thought of as the stochastic-process version of an SCM, where the static random variables of the SCM are replaced by dynamic stochastic processes and their derivatives. We provide the foundations for a theory of SDCMs, by (i) formally defining SDCMs, their solutions, stochastic interventions, and a graphical representation; (ii) studying existence and uniqueness of the solutions for given initial conditions; (iii) providing Markov properties for SDCMs with initial conditions; (iv) discussing under which conditions SDCMs equilibrate to SCMs as time tends to infinity; (v) relating the properties of the SDCM to those of the equilibrium SCM. This correspondence enables one to leverage the wealth of statistical tools and discovery methods available for SCMs when studying the causal semantics of a large class of stochastic dynamical systems. The theory is illustrated with examples from different scientific domains.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1803.08784v4
2022-03-27T20:52:33
2018-03-23T13:20:56
{ "title": [ 0.0013990402, 0.0062789917, -0.031188965, -0.076293945, 0.025650024, -0.0007724762, -0.033111572, -0.021255493, -0.001750946, 0.029190063, -0.0027809143, -0.0096588135, -0.005355835, -0.031951904, -0.029129028, 0.013847351, 0.009544373, 0.021133423, -0.018478394, -0.024642944, -0.03503418, -0.035858154, 0.039855957, 0.0037899017, 0.029373169, -0.012870789, -0.049835205, 0.019302368, -0.03982544, -0.024505615, -0.00983429, 0.0016403198, 0.051879883, 0.026931763, -0.0049057007, -0.022109985, -0.047607422, 0.008117676, -0.015792847, 0.029937744, -0.004348755, 0.008552551, -0.0052490234, -0.038482666, -0.040649414, 0.0020046234, -0.03866577, -0.021194458, -0.013305664, 0.0848999, 0.015655518, 0.02468872, -0.036224365, 0.07421875, 0.026168823, -0.0184021, -0.029525757, -0.02482605, 0.02192688, 0.08905029, 0.031707764, -0.03253174, 0.0036449432, -0.023803711, -0.0463562, -0.013244629, -0.043701172, 0.038909912, 0.071899414, -0.0065956116, -0.046569824, 0.008140564, -0.011245728, 0.035614014, -0.046966553, -0.026687622, 0.060913086, -0.006664276, 0.001042366, 0.018798828, 0.018753052, -0.007865906, -0.0028839111, -0.00982666, -0.013381958, -0.053344727, -0.015838623, -0.00299263, -0.021331787, -0.05596924, -0.015686035, 0.014846802, 0.0019893646, 0.028564453, -0.03515625, 0.00598526, -0.02229309, 0.014884949, 0.00274086, -0.015792847, -0.01927185, 0.012413025, -0.029724121, -0.0045661926, -0.003074646, 0.006088257, 0.009124756, -0.0032253265, 0.008224487, 0.039764404, -0.017166138, 0.0368042, 0.014015198, 0.025650024, 0.015914917, -0.00983429, -0.016525269, 0.035308838, -0.01687622, 0.03189087, -0.020385742, -0.0335083, -0.014572144, -0.008132935, 0.012939453, -0.02645874, -0.044769287, 0.022567749, -0.028060913, 0.028717041, -0.010345459, 0.03274536, -0.06878662, -0.043823242, -0.022598267, 0.015670776, -0.009597778, -0.023284912, -0.026931763, 0.0259552, -0.023040771, -0.028778076, 0.024780273, -0.028213501, 0.009178162, 0.008392334, 0.05871582, -0.0049362183, -0.031585693, -0.004295349, -0.022583008, 0.011558533, 0.053619385, 0.014152527, -0.07220459, 0.0077438354, -0.12133789, -0.01864624, -0.00026488304, -0.0035743713, 0.024734497, -0.0056648254, -0.035949707, -0.013092041, 0.019882202, -0.0032138824, -0.018188477, 0.038269043, 0.011962891, 0.051116943, -0.010002136, 0.023529053, -0.005405426, 0.004901886, -0.009315491, 0.0041007996, 0.01675415, -0.025466919, 0.050445557, 0.0025615692, 0.026306152, 0.006160736, -0.018371582, 0.0927124, -0.05419922, -0.04284668, -0.0035820007, -0.021209717, 0.044525146, 0.018005371, -0.04522705, 0.020431519, -0.054016113, -0.04940796, -0.045288086, -0.016677856, 0.042755127, 0.03201294, 0.00012624264, 0.019378662, -0.015731812, -0.0032444, -0.014511108, -0.009773254, 0.0013866425, -0.020004272, 0.004234314, 0.016921997, -0.018722534, 0.049041748, 0.06072998, 0.035583496, -0.025039673, -0.014312744, -0.01197052, -0.052734375, 0.0155181885, -0.031677246, -0.00655365, -0.007457733, -0.033172607, 0.0042915344, -0.020401001, 0.06536865, 0.006324768, -0.015670776, 0.014724731, -0.045166016, 0.056365967, 0.017059326, 0.07757568, -0.05517578, 0.022613525, -0.015396118, -0.015319824, -0.0140686035, -0.03111267, -0.013870239, -0.006401062, 0.02571106, -0.0028934479, -0.033477783, -0.0009660721, 0.07476807, -0.005168915, -0.030639648, 0.0064964294, 0.039245605, 0.0037708282, -0.015014648, 0.08831787, 0.019638062, 0.078186035, 0.022384644, 0.0069847107, 0.06793213, 0.014137268, 0.0030670166, -0.0047912598, 0.03817749, 0.010818481, 0.01424408, -0.031677246, 0.017608643, -0.03982544, -0.020690918, -0.04537964, 0.0007095337, -0.005908966, 0.014282227, 0.044647217, -0.032928467, 0.013801575, -0.020614624, -0.016174316, -0.011558533, -0.016021729, 0.025741577, -0.0025596619, -0.068725586, -0.012748718, 0.020111084, 0.040527344, 0.00944519, 0.018447876, -0.0012187958, 0.019577026, -0.007858276, 0.028396606, 0.019607544, 0.05682373, 0.0418396, 0.017028809, 0.018066406, 0.0064468384, 0.005722046, 0.05407715, 0.057861328, -0.010017395, 0.035217285, -0.059539795, 0.03555298, 0.052459717, -0.033172607, -0.0048713684, 0.038391113, 0.02281189, -0.0046043396, -0.046569824, 0.00605011, -0.060028076, 0.011100769, 0.013137817, -0.04458618, 0.005607605, -0.032287598, 0.021438599, -0.030471802, -0.00023698807, 0.0063819885, 0.052612305, -0.0069122314, -0.03564453, 0.013137817, 0.009681702, -0.023086548, -0.018310547, -0.037902832, -0.036499023, 0.021072388, 0.062805176, 0.018066406, -0.038482666, -0.033599854, -0.0067596436, 0.00749588, -0.02027893, 0.035705566, -0.02178955, -0.013809204, 0.0019607544, -0.031463623, 0.04284668, -0.029464722, 0.011009216, -0.03942871, 0.011932373, 0.027053833, -0.008522034, 0.008758545, 0.0015258789, -0.032348633, -0.044525146, 0.024887085, 0.06976318, -0.033416748, -0.015731812, 0.061798096, 0.047943115, -0.016921997, 0.031677246, -0.008613586, -0.018569946, -0.040496826, 0.02268982, -0.04360962, -0.034210205, -0.033081055, -0.014793396, 0.059020996, -0.081848145, -0.017730713, -0.009490967, 0.016601562, 0.019012451, 0.052215576, 0.00006020069, -0.037719727, -0.041290283, -0.02255249, 0.0025348663, 0.028808594, -0.030700684, 0.017578125, 0.08874512, -0.012031555, 0.011756897, 0.0052452087, 0.07861328, 0.028778076, -0.017150879, -0.040924072, -0.042266846, 0.006500244, 0.005619049, 0.013221741, 0.026031494, -0.030334473, -0.07800293, -0.02029419, 0.022979736, 0.0006670952, -0.026535034, 0.017074585, -0.07397461, 0.026260376, -0.034820557, -0.012580872, 0.04525757, 0.049072266, -0.008766174, 0.03060913, 0.032836914, -0.042236328, 0.007671356, -0.017578125, -0.0552063, 0.023666382, -0.023269653, -0.05731201, 0.010421753, -0.04849243, -0.02949524, -0.010192871, 0.018814087, 0.031234741, 0.037078857, 0.011375427, 0.03152466, -0.025512695, -0.010314941, -0.020706177, -0.02671814, -0.0015830994, 0.005836487, -0.0005970001, -0.0038452148, 0.01676941, 0.028518677, -0.008407593, -0.03363037, -0.030410767, -0.0040626526, 0.019454956, 0.0010242462, -0.032806396, -0.019744873, -0.0042762756, -0.013809204, -0.054718018, -0.024734497, 0.002571106, -0.0018930435, 0.021896362, 0.015449524, 0.05758667, 0.028137207, -0.00049877167, -0.058654785, 0.0017271042, 0.023651123, -0.027069092, -0.075927734, -0.029006958, 0.03466797, -0.03237915, 0.087524414, -0.030960083, 0.0014390945, 0.007762909, -0.059295654, 0.02368164, 0.014839172, 0.014022827, -0.007205963, 0.028686523, -0.040374756, 0.0038871765, -0.023483276, 0.03781128, 0.046691895, -0.0138549805, -0.0030326843, -0.055541992, -0.002412796, 0.004020691, -0.13232422, 0.0070610046, -0.009559631, -0.028656006, -0.046661377, -0.035186768, 0.019714355, -0.017059326, -0.046325684, -0.0039482117, -0.030136108, -0.033233643, -0.012191772, -0.045898438, -0.009864807, 0.07696533, 0.0045928955, 0.010032654, 0.013618469, -0.015007019, -0.0025978088, -0.051940918, 0.0027694702, -0.01727295, 0.047576904, -0.033325195, 0.008560181, 0.054748535, -0.028320312, 0.033721924, 0.07116699, 0.06072998, -0.0021400452, -0.03302002, 0.003824234, 0.0062408447, 0.024139404, 0.025878906, 0.027038574, -0.0413208, -0.005077362, 0.009605408, -0.03012085, 0.0070228577, 0.016494751, 0.019622803, 0.022827148, -0.010894775, 0.02748108, 0.024459839, -0.013442993, -0.0008125305, 0.0440979, -0.01348114, -0.026641846, 0.02230835, 0.020126343, 0.0289917, 0.020751953, 0.008583069, 0.003112793, 0.04864502, -0.031829834, -0.0036830902, -0.0051879883, 0.0075149536, 0.012908936, 0.022460938, -0.055847168, -0.055358887, -0.028640747, 0.00042319298, -0.0035514832, 0.04336548, 0.013084412, -0.023925781, -0.028381348, 0.009414673, -0.008346558, 0.0068893433, 0.0077781677, -0.031051636, 0.038879395, -0.014213562, -0.045684814, -0.055236816, -0.017471313, -0.026992798, 0.013832092, 0.006526947, -0.017654419, 0.008506775, 0.021759033, 0.050598145, 0.06555176, -0.009132385, -0.050476074, -0.00819397, 0.018035889, -0.0056610107, -0.01626587, 0.0050086975, 0.012680054, -0.025878906, -0.026626587, -0.021575928, 0.0067367554, -0.014472961, 0.0025520325, -0.03277588, 0.049102783, -0.010238647, 0.04272461, 0.014877319, -0.0055122375, 0.012901306, 0.005657196, -0.03152466, -0.034332275, 0.026321411, 0.04837036, 0.004966736, 0.009490967, 0.041290283, 0.024551392, 0.01663208, -0.002254486, 0.0026226044, 0.022583008, -0.011100769, -0.0017681122, 0.025238037, 0.006385803, -0.0075302124, 0.03060913, 0.029190063, 0.062469482, -0.031341553, 0.06201172, -0.029815674, 0.02658081, 0.015266418, -0.01864624, 0.01977539, -0.011810303, 0.025482178, -0.07598877, -0.087768555, -0.03479004, 0.08105469, -0.040374756, -0.007686615, -0.00023066998, 0.030517578, -0.002374649, 0.062469482, 0.056243896, 0.0113220215, 0.00060749054, -0.04144287, -0.00818634, -0.037750244, -0.05114746, 0.034454346, -0.005504608, 0.02659607, -0.02279663, -0.005176544, -0.073913574, 0.014259338, -0.0001603365, -0.014770508, 0.00655365, -0.082214355, 0.022079468, 0.06677246, -0.009178162, 0.038879395, -0.010009766, 0.0015716553, 0.04107666, 0.04550171, 0.0030651093, 0.02154541, 0.010681152, -0.032226562, -0.0022659302, -0.0076141357, 0.011062622, 0.003932953, 0.01374054, 0.01424408, 0.004047394, -0.032440186, 0.02180481, 0.01890564, -0.0074882507, 0.019256592, -0.05331421, 0.000082314014, 0.0029087067, 0.024612427, 0.017181396, -0.012107849, -0.048706055, -0.0013065338, -0.009979248, -0.030853271, 0.040039062, 0.012008667, -0.018417358, -0.036254883, 0.024658203, -0.00818634, 0.028167725, -0.009994507, 0.009155273, -0.037109375, -0.0007557869, 0.027511597, -0.043670654, 0.036376953, -0.044555664, 0.006149292, 0.044830322, 0.02444458, -0.005168915, 0.010650635, -0.014465332, -0.06072998, -0.015327454, 0.030349731, 0.0017318726, -0.010658264, -0.004550934, -0.037475586, 0.0030765533, 0.016433716, 0.027832031, 0.029953003, -0.029891968, 0.050689697, 0.01474762, -0.0045051575, -0.0052452087, 0.018692017, -0.022994995, 0.0025959015, 0.013633728, -0.03414917, 0.0009250641, 0.013519287, -0.018829346, 0.021087646, -0.032806396, 0.0077285767, 0.018707275, 0.02104187, -0.04550171, 0.0067443848, 0.023254395, -0.025344849, -0.014526367, -0.026657104, 0.048919678, -0.015213013, -0.029052734, 0.022583008, -0.009346008, -0.006084442, 0.072265625, -0.002653122, -0.039733887, -0.050628662, -0.053009033, -0.02911377, -0.0037612915, 0.049804688, 0.018630981, 0.04812622, -0.035980225, -0.014305115, -0.006362915, 0.00009024143, 0.00774765, 0.0259552, 0.0035972595, -0.041015625, -0.006679535, 0.010192871, 0.0078048706, -0.05480957, 0.009529114, 0.012702942, 0.0070228577, 0.013694763, -0.033935547, -0.0070343018, -0.0075645447, -0.046173096, 0.044281006, -0.025650024, -0.013046265, 0.03161621, -0.044189453, 0.044036865, 0.016571045, 0.0637207, 0.055786133, 0.033477783, 0.02508545, 0.009513855, 0.039276123, -0.024307251, 0.018203735, -0.022476196, -0.018859863, -0.062469482, -0.024551392, -0.068359375, 0.019317627, 0.0067825317, 0.011184692, -0.008277893, 0.0010910034, -0.021530151, 0.0033054352, 0.047302246, 0.0496521, 0.05404663, 0.026062012, 0.0043907166, 0.01928711, -0.013175964, -0.018997192, 0.042816162, 0.008415222, -0.009475708, -0.0068130493, -0.022872925, 0.026046753, 0.019012451, -0.0009126663, -0.0019454956, 0.0012435913, -0.032165527, 0.032104492, -0.0011091232, 0.028198242, 0.06451416, 0.03451538, 0.023254395, -0.030532837, 0.011482239, 0.007183075, -0.026473999, 0.016448975, 0.053771973, -0.078125, 0.033813477, -0.0109939575, -0.026992798, -0.025848389, 0.023742676, 0.04437256, -0.05331421, -0.049591064, 0.0056114197, 0.049194336, 0.015213013, 0.034973145, -0.036987305, 0.015129089, 0.02809143, 0.017913818, 0.027435303, 0.03515625, 0.01374054, 0.033294678, -0.018722534, -0.0041999817, 0.0008125305, 0.030334473, -0.04525757, 0.014289856, -0.027282715, -0.026107788, 0.007003784, -0.03186035, 0.008277893, -0.0013608932, -0.028503418, -0.0074920654, -0.0017633438, 0.022781372, 0.037628174, 0.07714844, 0.010238647, -0.015777588, -0.023223877, -0.050842285, 0.033477783, 0.016311646, -0.013961792, 0.012504578, -0.038116455, -0.035583496, 0.039154053, -0.036956787, 0.06512451, -0.06201172, 0.0022621155, -0.009353638, 0.025741577, 0.024978638, -0.043884277, -0.05899048, -0.008323669, -0.007713318, -0.0054244995, -0.0026302338, -0.03555298, -0.026382446, -0.0058937073, 0.020736694, 0.01285553, -0.0067825317, -0.009246826, -0.036712646, -0.06262207, -0.009239197, -0.006504059, 0.018066406, -0.021102905, -0.013000488, -0.033843994, 0.0138168335, -0.0049438477, 0.00630188, -0.02178955, 0.019973755, -0.064941406, -0.024841309, 0.00466156, 0.00491333, -0.012565613, 0.0345459, -0.02645874, 0.026809692, -0.000869751, -0.012825012, 0.01524353, -0.045288086, -0.007801056, 0.007972717, -0.029830933, 0.020751953, 0.0088272095, -0.0057296753, 0.020324707, 0.02998352, -0.03768921, -0.031402588, -0.023620605, 0.012268066, -0.004508972, -0.052093506, 0.02305603, 0.019851685, 0.041778564, -0.050720215, -0.030288696, 0.027023315, 0.018371582, -0.01083374, 0.076049805, 0.018112183, 0.01020813, 0.03845215, 0.039978027, 0.0012245178, -0.05218506, -0.042510986, -0.032958984, 0.037963867, 0.036102295, 0.0076446533, -0.025741577, 0.04699707, -0.010726929, 0.00881958, 0.018920898, -0.032226562, 0.017562866, -0.0012769699, 0.022491455, -0.018814087, 0.0134887695, 0.007331848, -0.031555176, 0.0007557869, 0.022232056, -0.032073975, -0.009765625, -0.037200928, 0.07171631, -0.01171875, -0.018051147, 0.015777588, 0.01953125, 0.02671814, 0.017089844, -0.040618896, -0.0049209595, 0.0209198, -0.008834839, -0.007156372, -0.0021572113, 0.018295288, -0.033447266, -0.025314331, -0.010040283, -0.030670166, 0.01802063, -0.038238525, 0.06402588, -0.022857666, -0.0068244934, -0.01461792, -0.029708862, -0.013381958, -0.0066986084, 0.0027866364, -0.04864502, -0.059448242, -0.0062942505, 0.050842285, -0.0061569214 ], "summary": [ 0.013015747, -0.0073127747, 0.00623703, -0.05657959, -0.03378296, 0.020584106, -0.06585693, -0.016036987, 0.009292603, -0.017868042, -0.023971558, 0.005924225, -0.019332886, -0.02885437, 0.026885986, -0.033721924, 0.007911682, 0.0005841255, -0.004169464, -0.023361206, -0.000112473965, -0.014808655, 0.036102295, -0.031799316, 0.033477783, -0.015838623, 0.029937744, 0.021484375, 0.02796936, 0.011260986, 0.021026611, -0.05557251, 0.011421204, 0.03189087, -0.010177612, -0.004600525, -0.0037708282, 0.0069847107, 0.008094788, 0.025527954, -0.002281189, -0.019760132, 0.10699463, -0.057495117, 0.06945801, 0.0105896, -0.0039024353, -0.09082031, 0.008056641, 0.033416748, 0.026473999, 0.016143799, 0.014251709, 0.034088135, -0.029266357, -0.022583008, -0.050933838, -0.0033416748, 0.021057129, 0.086242676, 0.028808594, 0.004135132, -0.021530151, -0.054138184, -0.0030612946, 0.013130188, -0.020126343, 0.013343811, 0.018875122, -0.0021533966, -0.015464783, -0.015022278, -0.020385742, -0.0211792, 0.03717041, 0.015129089, 0.0020866394, 0.012931824, -0.00982666, 0.055603027, 0.0132751465, -0.0009908676, -0.0013961792, -0.022460938, -0.013885498, -0.03277588, -0.008880615, 0.0009851456, 0.028320312, -0.005619049, -0.0075149536, 0.023635864, 0.006008148, 0.014823914, -0.006084442, -0.019073486, -0.003921509, 0.016448975, 0.00504303, -0.0015039444, -0.019424438, -0.0015573502, -0.005908966, -0.015701294, -0.02670288, 0.02658081, 0.05581665, 0.016677856, -0.018981934, -0.0046577454, -0.03048706, -0.018554688, 0.0463562, 0.019439697, 0.002817154, -0.04147339, 0.0016231537, 0.062805176, -0.013519287, 0.033477783, -0.04510498, -0.0016679764, -0.031433105, 0.06451416, -0.007255554, 0.025939941, 0.048431396, -0.0017623901, -0.029800415, 0.020751953, -0.021087646, 0.0087890625, 0.013397217, 0.03842163, 0.0060424805, -0.009384155, -0.03656006, -0.047668457, -0.026123047, -0.0048942566, 0.008308411, 0.0001553297, 0.04748535, -0.0045051575, 0.01209259, 0.008605957, 0.029953003, 0.01965332, -0.020324707, 0.011886597, -0.01928711, 0.020233154, 0.049468994, -0.004383087, -0.089660645, -0.029251099, -0.03363037, -0.021942139, -0.028945923, -0.040039062, 0.02204895, -0.02508545, -0.030212402, 0.072143555, 0.02078247, 0.036987305, 0.034729004, 0.0037574768, 0.02230835, -0.0025596619, 0.014678955, 0.0032691956, -0.014404297, -0.020370483, -0.010345459, 0.0013818741, -0.07196045, -0.036712646, 0.020629883, 0.055999756, 0.04815674, -0.0053863525, -0.061431885, 0.098083496, -0.03274536, -0.048187256, 0.011299133, 0.0076408386, 0.04800415, 0.017486572, 0.028656006, -0.02748108, -0.04046631, -0.028945923, -0.023635864, 0.0058250427, 0.010520935, 0.01184082, -0.016601562, 0.025787354, 0.019943237, -0.0013904572, -0.0017518997, -0.013946533, 0.018310547, -0.036712646, 0.028778076, 0.0048942566, 0.009338379, 0.018325806, 0.0112838745, -0.029327393, -0.00075244904, 0.006969452, -0.03375244, -0.07208252, 0.035125732, -0.06756592, -0.028182983, -0.06542969, -0.04019165, -0.015350342, -0.059906006, 0.0970459, 0.04458618, 0.003320694, 0.006603241, -0.0046043396, 0.10571289, 0.009223938, 0.077941895, -0.030807495, 0.0060691833, 0.012573242, -0.0041122437, 0.009269714, -0.01576233, -0.054779053, 0.0023880005, 0.034942627, 0.0087890625, -0.01222229, -0.008308411, 0.058288574, -0.024627686, -0.043121338, 0.008674622, 0.03793335, -0.024230957, -0.00217247, 0.03274536, 0.018493652, 0.032196045, -0.04208374, 0.026626587, 0.027648926, -0.0095825195, -0.04095459, -0.01725769, 0.017227173, 0.027862549, -0.016448975, -0.041748047, 0.011352539, 0.011077881, -0.04434204, 0.0065994263, -0.0031204224, 0.03643799, -0.051361084, -0.011352539, -0.083618164, -0.011108398, -0.034606934, -0.03274536, -0.060821533, 0.00015890598, 0.026321411, -0.011245728, -0.051116943, 0.0008158684, 0.012718201, 0.03286743, 0.002866745, -0.00025248528, -0.0020198822, 0.034729004, 0.025222778, 0.047546387, 0.07476807, 0.074523926, 0.030227661, 0.014205933, 0.02470398, -0.038482666, -0.008255005, -0.026672363, 0.028457642, -0.020446777, 0.0065460205, -0.038360596, 0.035949707, 0.05203247, -0.056488037, -0.0021076202, -0.0001502037, 0.017196655, -0.050750732, -0.04550171, 0.024459839, -0.10241699, -0.0075302124, 0.04006958, 0.050994873, 0.016586304, -0.0071525574, 0.003982544, 0.05569458, 0.038024902, 0.061065674, 0.06939697, 0.014190674, 0.0037269592, 0.022781372, 0.013221741, -0.053009033, 0.02407837, -0.019744873, -0.018066406, -0.0049362183, 0.0030994415, -0.0009880066, -0.016235352, 0.020492554, -0.002527237, 0.014030457, -0.00017237663, 0.011512756, -0.016464233, -0.0124435425, 0.026565552, -0.056488037, 0.02633667, 0.019195557, 0.03552246, -0.02684021, 0.019180298, 0.01499176, 0.047607422, 0.03427124, -0.05014038, -0.022476196, -0.020080566, 0.038879395, 0.0146102905, -0.01852417, 0.026290894, 0.072753906, 0.019439697, -0.0055160522, -0.0052452087, -0.0023651123, -0.048583984, -0.043121338, 0.036590576, -0.0013542175, -0.005836487, -0.041259766, -0.0099105835, -0.008270264, -0.07299805, 0.009124756, -0.01965332, 0.0017080307, 0.047302246, 0.06677246, 0.021987915, -0.02444458, 0.039245605, 0.019515991, -0.0032348633, -0.005634308, 0.01184082, -0.013679504, 0.050964355, -0.020599365, -0.027999878, 0.037902832, 0.013015747, 0.032409668, -0.042785645, -0.025680542, -0.013679504, -0.0345459, 0.00970459, -0.002527237, 0.036621094, 0.024780273, 0.00598526, -0.034973145, 0.032318115, -0.0019235611, -0.0049858093, 0.007209778, -0.048858643, 0.04397583, -0.012054443, -0.009147644, 0.008148193, -0.036956787, 0.04611206, -0.048828125, 0.013320923, -0.029022217, 0.006263733, -0.049957275, 0.024856567, -0.000385046, 0.0034313202, -0.03894043, 0.046875, -0.08148193, 0.040222168, 0.014945984, 0.01638794, 0.005329132, 0.035705566, 0.015380859, 0.008361816, 0.012886047, 0.02279663, -0.04269409, -0.04055786, -0.002943039, -0.00036764145, 0.034118652, 0.016143799, -0.03375244, 0.029846191, -0.028869629, -0.008148193, -0.046447754, -0.0064430237, 0.011741638, -0.009056091, 0.012123108, -0.038513184, 0.014671326, -0.0060195923, -0.032470703, -0.024002075, -0.0010318756, 0.044189453, 0.022583008, 0.0014181137, 0.005393982, -0.03363037, 0.008049011, 0.010566711, -0.04324341, -0.03213501, -0.000936985, -0.055999756, -0.040374756, 0.024963379, -0.0847168, 0.0713501, -0.031341553, -0.0051460266, 0.016601562, -0.044311523, 0.035949707, -0.0013742447, -0.019042969, 0.021270752, 0.02722168, -0.010238647, -0.012771606, -0.00233078, 0.008430481, 0.020355225, 0.0021209717, 0.009284973, -0.029800415, -0.0033779144, 0.01461792, -0.08856201, -0.013305664, 0.0018463135, -0.013923645, -0.052215576, 0.0013866425, 0.029663086, -0.019989014, -0.0030937195, 0.011795044, -0.020843506, 0.0440979, 0.027282715, -0.050842285, 0.039794922, -0.012260437, 0.031433105, 0.0051956177, -0.033355713, 0.022613525, 0.075683594, -0.002254486, -0.012794495, -0.0029678345, 0.05239868, -0.037994385, 0.03062439, 0.015792847, -0.0141067505, 0.031555176, 0.044952393, 0.038757324, 0.016815186, -0.036132812, 0.04156494, 0.032806396, -0.0056266785, -0.0045700073, 0.057556152, -0.03050232, 0.013977051, 0.012161255, -0.015007019, 0.017684937, 0.0005373955, 0.05419922, -0.0009417534, -0.020111084, 0.010726929, -0.06707764, -0.006263733, 0.029678345, 0.00274086, 0.0061683655, -0.033996582, -0.011802673, 0.040618896, 0.023284912, -0.012756348, 0.033935547, -0.042785645, 0.030853271, -0.029937744, 0.016937256, -0.025970459, -0.02911377, -0.008811951, -0.0009918213, 0.04626465, -0.09289551, -0.030685425, -0.012710571, 0.009590149, 0.04916382, -0.021530151, 0.003074646, -0.0072631836, 0.020858765, -0.026916504, 0.03378296, -0.016021729, -0.028900146, -0.0069885254, -0.022262573, -0.026367188, -0.040924072, -0.056121826, -0.026443481, -0.026626587, 0.030685425, -0.033966064, 0.012916565, 0.008613586, 0.047332764, 0.033721924, -0.014434814, -0.049041748, -0.012039185, -0.013931274, 0.07611084, -0.025421143, 0.06939697, 0.021865845, 0.03164673, -0.04257202, -0.01701355, 0.0039024353, -0.029220581, -0.0024433136, -0.028549194, 0.021606445, -0.008956909, 0.033996582, 0.012145996, -0.005428314, 0.011558533, 0.0022697449, -0.023651123, 0.011016846, 0.032714844, 0.027297974, -0.009376526, -0.010803223, 0.030807495, 0.008811951, -0.0041923523, 0.007080078, -0.0118255615, 0.018981934, 0.008720398, 0.035217285, -0.01159668, 0.026184082, -0.01398468, 0.028717041, 0.013870239, 0.017028809, 0.011817932, -0.028289795, 0.015594482, 0.012001038, -0.015098572, -0.022842407, 0.049072266, 0.0069084167, 0.013450623, -0.013641357, -0.05355835, -0.03149414, 0.030639648, 0.011009216, -0.061676025, 0.0060806274, 0.07293701, -0.015670776, 0.013938904, -0.0074157715, -0.049316406, 0.08062744, -0.024475098, -0.027313232, 0.016082764, -0.027709961, -0.0016269684, -0.01083374, 0.01776123, 0.028137207, -0.024551392, -0.034454346, 0.02178955, -0.013931274, 0.0060157776, -0.013847351, 0.0013990402, -0.010551453, 0.018585205, -0.035980225, 0.040740967, 0.03125, -0.045898438, 0.024276733, 0.040496826, -0.03744507, 0.026382446, -0.00072574615, -0.01008606, 0.0395813, -0.030700684, 0.025756836, 0.017364502, 0.031463623, 0.017181396, 0.04119873, -0.068359375, -0.010925293, -0.02520752, 0.049591064, 0.0013723373, -0.031311035, 0.020889282, -0.014137268, -0.0033035278, -0.0041656494, 0.019958496, -0.010124207, 0.011436462, -0.007232666, 0.004173279, 0.0028095245, -0.025344849, -0.00051116943, -0.043304443, 0.004070282, -0.041046143, 0.029205322, -0.009346008, 0.0005578995, -0.014404297, -0.024734497, -0.0029888153, -0.018936157, 0.056610107, 0.000008225441, 0.014289856, 0.030258179, -0.011428833, 0.0062675476, 0.0057411194, -0.031829834, -0.016357422, 0.01826477, 0.031097412, 0.020980835, 0.039215088, -0.027145386, 0.024505615, -0.013191223, -0.01146698, 0.017807007, -0.010719299, -0.079589844, 0.00018274784, 0.004917145, 0.0015640259, 0.027954102, -0.0074768066, -0.02696228, 0.023132324, 0.028244019, -0.021102905, -0.012489319, 0.01550293, -0.05847168, 0.04925537, -0.028747559, -0.004142761, -0.008506775, -0.021148682, -0.041046143, -0.060455322, -0.015060425, -0.036010742, -0.04510498, -0.06500244, 0.027755737, -0.019943237, -0.027633667, 0.0009422302, 0.015548706, -0.017059326, 0.013954163, -0.00075531006, -0.035583496, -0.01889038, -0.016799927, -0.009803772, -0.03375244, 0.00047373772, -0.030792236, -0.014633179, 0.029006958, -0.020446777, 0.02796936, 0.0041236877, -0.007194519, 0.020492554, 0.021621704, 0.027511597, -0.022613525, 0.004425049, -0.021331787, -0.0010643005, 0.0007996559, 0.028747559, 0.027633667, 0.035827637, -0.0036563873, -0.022949219, 0.0071105957, -0.0050086975, 0.00881958, -0.020889282, 0.013076782, -0.005695343, 0.013465881, -0.0004105568, 0.04458618, 0.03050232, 0.019088745, 0.05697632, 0.08581543, 0.014762878, 0.00023818016, 0.012557983, 0.01574707, 0.010635376, -0.078125, -0.047668457, -0.06561279, -0.0069084167, 0.015930176, -0.030700684, -0.020050049, 0.023239136, -0.004447937, -0.036590576, 0.03152466, -0.022827148, 0.08227539, -0.0026950836, 0.036712646, -0.034698486, 0.02960205, 0.073913574, -0.028045654, 0.007507324, 0.07116699, -0.0007710457, 0.008399963, -0.0036506653, 0.026931763, 0.0014600754, -0.053710938, -0.05859375, 0.049072266, -0.05709839, 0.024337769, 0.025863647, 0.036102295, -0.009338379, 0.00021958351, 0.042297363, -0.0067825317, -0.0121154785, 0.03665161, -0.015060425, 0.025970459, 0.014312744, 0.022613525, -0.0368042, 0.001493454, -0.0034885406, 0.016418457, 0.04196167, 0.029159546, -0.021743774, 0.013069153, 0.0047721863, -0.0030555725, -0.01676941, 0.042266846, -0.0063705444, 0.04586792, 0.06707764, -0.03152466, 0.059692383, 0.04446411, 0.03024292, 0.03225708, -0.010719299, -0.006427765, -0.0025405884, -0.007820129, -0.027404785, 0.027023315, -0.0024681091, -0.03475952, 0.012268066, -0.009521484, 0.010147095, 0.016067505, 0.04522705, -0.012710571, -0.012702942, 0.046966553, 0.09106445, 0.057037354, -0.028381348, 0.025848389, 0.093322754, -0.038238525, 0.037139893, 0.030471802, 0.017486572, -0.020736694, -0.028259277, -0.007572174, -0.0007724762, 0.0013618469, 0.058502197, -0.063964844, -0.0057373047, -0.039886475, 0.05557251, -0.048095703, -0.0069847107, -0.07324219, -0.03955078, 0.017227173, -0.011871338, -0.006137848, -0.052825928, -0.01171875, -0.043029785, 0.0071983337, -0.021072388, 0.01197052, 0.024475098, -0.031219482, 0.024124146, -0.00080633163, 0.037841797, 0.04812622, 0.003698349, -0.011581421, -0.005836487, 0.047698975, -0.023132324, -0.026870728, -0.019363403, 0.055358887, -0.033599854, -0.015975952, 0.002855301, 0.022781372, -0.015701294, -0.017333984, 0.015075684, 0.004814148, -0.008354187, -0.005027771, 0.00006824732, -0.012908936, 0.038391113, -0.0005002022, -0.00737381, -0.017196655, 0.0022277832, 0.018341064, 0.0025463104, 0.06976318, -0.020706177, -0.03302002, -0.03945923, -0.05328369, 0.015235901, -0.02470398, 0.007434845, 0.009544373, 0.026916504, -0.009246826, -0.038085938, 0.03265381, -0.026901245, -0.0006480217, -0.007610321, 0.021057129, -0.0006542206, -0.009254456, 0.007888794, -0.020507812, -0.006263733, -0.016616821, -0.001124382, 0.026611328, -0.0018434525, -0.011177063, -0.0035305023, 0.009681702, -0.033081055, -0.002506256, 0.009849548, -0.026870728, -0.018493652, -0.010009766, -0.030670166, -0.024673462, 0.0013093948, 0.049102783, -0.036224365, 0.0026683807, -0.013916016, -0.025650024, -0.015960693, -0.039855957, -0.013000488, -0.012626648, 0.08392334, -0.029953003, -0.037200928, 0.049713135, -0.0143966675, 0.034576416, 0.032318115, -0.01512146, 0.010734558, -0.016723633, 0.0004916191, 0.02418518, 0.017227173, 0.016586304, 0.040283203, 0.019927979, 0.018295288, -0.0099487305, 0.076171875, -0.037231445, -0.01473999, -0.046691895, -0.021575928, -0.0026664734, -0.026184082, -0.0513916, -0.04598999, 0.003774643, -0.007129669, -0.04244995, 0.034698486 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1803.09702v3
HAMLET: Interpretable Human And Machine co-LEarning Technique
Olivier Deiss, Siddharth Biswal, Jing Jin, Haoqi Sun, M. Brandon Westover, Jimeng Sun
cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, stat.ML
Efficient label acquisition processes are key to obtaining robust classifiers. However, data labeling is often challenging and subject to high levels of label noise. This can arise even when classification targets are well defined, if instances to be labeled are more difficult than the prototypes used to define the class, leading to disagreements among the expert community. Here, we enable efficient training of deep neural networks. From low-confidence labels, we iteratively improve their quality by simultaneous learning of machines and experts. We call it Human And Machine co-LEarning Technique (HAMLET). Throughout the process, experts become more consistent, while the algorithm provides them with explainable feedback for confirmation. HAMLET uses a neural embedding function and a memory module filled with diverse reference embeddings from different classes. Its output includes classification labels and highly relevant reference embeddings as explanation. We took the study of brain monitoring at intensive care unit (ICU) as an application of HAMLET on continuous electroencephalography (cEEG) data. Although cEEG monitoring yields large volumes of data, labeling costs and difficulty make it hard to build a classifier. Additionally, while experts agree on the labels of clear-cut examples of cEEG patterns, labeling many real-world cEEG data can be extremely challenging. Thus, a large minority of sequences might be mislabeled. HAMLET has shown significant performance gain against deep learning and other baselines, increasing accuracy from 7.03% to 68.75% on challenging inputs. Besides improved performance, clinical experts confirmed the interpretability of those reference embeddings in helping explaining the classification results by HAMLET.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1803.09702v3
2018-08-21T05:41:09
2018-03-26T16:29:03
{ "title": [ -0.0038604736, 0.014022827, -0.031555176, -0.033081055, -0.0005259514, -0.020874023, -0.020858765, -0.035888672, -0.03149414, 0.036376953, -0.013694763, 0.007183075, -0.00092697144, -0.020645142, -0.03656006, -0.005130768, -0.017318726, 0.041900635, -0.0446167, -0.023101807, -0.039611816, -0.03439331, 0.006095886, 0.021835327, 0.028884888, -0.026153564, -0.07550049, 0.010826111, -0.01876831, -0.02923584, -0.0056915283, 0.007297516, 0.04458618, 0.031219482, -0.023910522, 0.050872803, -0.04055786, 0.030929565, -0.00015366077, 0.024291992, 0.003446579, 0.0044670105, -0.009178162, -0.024810791, -0.03753662, 0.01373291, -0.05480957, -0.00040102005, -0.027954102, 0.035186768, 0.014808655, 0.016647339, -0.017227173, 0.06341553, 0.028808594, -0.017623901, -0.018188477, -0.011520386, 0.03189087, 0.050964355, 0.0018196106, -0.060028076, 0.025848389, -0.041259766, -0.049041748, -0.024459839, -0.030441284, 0.028717041, 0.087402344, -0.006664276, -0.026855469, 0.04559326, -0.0002629757, -0.0066719055, -0.03994751, -0.0036354065, 0.048797607, 0.033691406, 0.022705078, -0.0317688, 0.006515503, -0.021316528, 0.007499695, -0.018035889, 0.019241333, -0.02217102, -0.007801056, -0.01322937, -0.06304932, -0.057891846, -0.02079773, -0.01197052, -0.044158936, 0.01285553, -0.016311646, -0.009086609, -0.009750366, 0.013092041, 0.016143799, -0.025939941, -0.015991211, 0.02420044, -0.053985596, 0.003047943, 0.03463745, 0.03845215, -0.023834229, -0.033477783, 0.018722534, 0.024810791, -0.009811401, 0.02027893, 0.0018520355, -0.018753052, 0.01638794, 0.02696228, -0.023864746, 0.02999878, 0.012886047, 0.048217773, 0.014282227, -0.0038928986, 0.01386261, -0.00088882446, 0.008430481, -0.008560181, -0.043151855, -0.01448822, -0.0154800415, 0.020767212, 0.008598328, 0.0725708, -0.113586426, -0.09863281, -0.085510254, 0.04623413, -0.013793945, -0.0072250366, -0.018875122, 0.013069153, 0.0018854141, -0.033111572, 0.0008511543, 0.0060806274, -0.005470276, 0.011810303, 0.058898926, -0.011207581, -0.027572632, -0.048797607, -0.033935547, 0.0093688965, 0.012969971, -0.016159058, 0.0017213821, -0.005554199, -0.12182617, -0.0023040771, 0.038604736, 0.04525757, 0.030319214, 0.0023536682, -0.013969421, 0.028915405, 0.07434082, -0.016525269, -0.016815186, 0.032043457, 0.004283905, 0.026229858, -0.012039185, -0.0038852692, 0.030883789, -0.0033912659, -0.01777649, 0.011100769, 0.020004272, 0.013900757, 0.027053833, -0.036346436, -0.0158844, -0.03173828, -0.0012559891, 0.045837402, -0.052612305, -0.010566711, 0.0015897751, 0.0034770966, 0.041137695, 0.010368347, -0.031677246, 0.04095459, -0.05621338, -0.04336548, -0.039855957, -0.011123657, 0.051605225, 0.043823242, -0.0029182434, 0.00051164627, -0.016677856, -0.001405716, -0.03289795, 0.008171082, -0.037322998, -0.023284912, -0.014015198, 0.031829834, -0.036590576, 0.06665039, 0.047851562, 0.00969696, -0.02809143, 0.0072746277, 0.024520874, -0.047729492, 0.010528564, -0.00087070465, -0.005382538, -0.0011138916, -0.002313614, -0.025283813, 0.0069503784, 0.017440796, -0.012260437, 0.012924194, 0.0037021637, -0.009437561, 0.03466797, 0.03475952, 0.11376953, -0.06274414, 0.074401855, 0.042999268, -0.03277588, -0.026504517, -0.013076782, -0.0008416176, 0.0059547424, 0.030654907, 0.011459351, -0.025024414, -0.018478394, 0.0023326874, 0.06439209, -0.018539429, -0.0071144104, -0.0007123947, 0.03390503, 0.021331787, 0.06365967, 0.0003631115, 0.053497314, 0.015899658, -0.014030457, 0.06112671, 0.011497498, 0.0178833, -0.022003174, 0.017669678, -0.011924744, 0.0055274963, 0.0034008026, 0.0014228821, -0.07305908, 0.02947998, -0.025161743, 0.010971069, 0.018753052, 0.009109497, 0.031921387, 0.0012598038, 0.023849487, 0.008987427, 0.008239746, -0.0061798096, -0.009407043, -0.009468079, 0.040527344, -0.03842163, -0.012672424, 0.025268555, 0.031188965, -0.0046691895, 0.011909485, 0.0058784485, 0.012130737, -0.02470398, -0.01184082, -0.012023926, 0.038391113, 0.04714966, 0.022537231, -0.00818634, 0.03137207, 0.008415222, 0.09033203, 0.0793457, -0.025894165, 0.012031555, -0.0637207, 0.004283905, -0.01687622, -0.006816864, 0.0027885437, 0.026550293, 0.017227173, 0.014465332, -0.028579712, 0.0033569336, -0.039367676, 0.040222168, 0.005115509, -0.010429382, -0.040985107, -0.04949951, -0.0126571655, -0.032348633, -0.036834717, -0.016906738, 0.08135986, -0.008834839, -0.02267456, -0.027038574, 0.0065841675, -0.026321411, -0.037017822, -0.03451538, -0.020431519, 0.018707275, 0.023635864, -0.0002259016, -0.06896973, -0.010551453, -0.0019817352, 0.022415161, -0.013259888, -0.016098022, -0.024047852, 0.0064048767, 0.009338379, 0.00415802, 0.02078247, -0.05657959, -0.00017762184, -0.058898926, -0.010147095, 0.004234314, -0.013473511, -0.022155762, 0.045074463, -0.011802673, -0.029251099, 0.027954102, 0.05407715, -0.034851074, -0.011474609, 0.05206299, 0.02015686, -0.0074310303, 0.04208374, 0.019714355, 0.021453857, -0.03225708, -0.020065308, -0.059051514, -0.002664566, -0.00086307526, -0.016586304, 0.049560547, -0.057281494, -0.015609741, -0.014556885, -0.008934021, -0.019500732, 0.019195557, -0.000787735, -0.039093018, -0.027267456, -0.009361267, -0.025238037, 0.004875183, -0.022979736, 0.0154800415, 0.086242676, 0.016174316, 0.006000519, 0.004119873, 0.055541992, -0.012573242, -0.013999939, -0.03086853, -0.039367676, 0.029586792, 0.015022278, -0.0013332367, -0.0059318542, 0.0041999817, -0.15783691, 0.0077705383, 0.036834717, 0.0126571655, -0.020599365, 0.035949707, -0.07171631, 0.051330566, -0.003742218, -0.012077332, 0.019088745, 0.05303955, -0.025024414, 0.028060913, -0.004550934, -0.015525818, 0.021957397, -0.030838013, -0.095947266, 0.030334473, -0.025726318, -0.017318726, 0.00008261204, -0.031799316, -0.060180664, -0.024765015, -0.009796143, 0.030136108, 0.030853271, 0.020599365, 0.028869629, -0.005344391, -0.0019741058, -0.02973938, -0.013725281, -0.029953003, -0.020980835, -0.002746582, -0.017913818, 0.072021484, 0.0154800415, 0.0038452148, -0.04144287, -0.015281677, -0.00035119057, 0.031829834, -0.015899658, -0.0025634766, -0.012649536, -0.029678345, -0.014625549, 0.012557983, -0.010009766, -0.006877899, -0.005256653, 0.007648468, -0.021087646, 0.036987305, 0.014022827, 0.010269165, -0.00674057, -0.025222778, 0.02394104, -0.014472961, -0.09136963, 0.0023880005, 0.029251099, -0.009757996, 0.04650879, -0.010444641, -0.027694702, 0.040405273, -0.02168274, -0.025787354, -0.008422852, -0.020858765, 0.019073486, -0.014022827, -0.036346436, 0.0025196075, -0.0013713837, 0.036590576, 0.014831543, -0.011047363, -0.011260986, -0.07928467, -0.009147644, 0.006980896, -0.11541748, -0.027816772, 0.01260376, -0.045074463, -0.048339844, -0.0473938, 0.030410767, -0.04953003, -0.024978638, 0.0013685226, -0.013580322, -0.037841797, -0.025863647, -0.0748291, -0.051086426, 0.074157715, 0.010871887, 0.014099121, 0.035369873, -0.02204895, -0.013542175, -0.03387451, 0.023864746, 0.012817383, 0.041259766, -0.0024375916, -0.0035934448, 0.05029297, -0.039611816, 0.037384033, 0.02519226, 0.037200928, -0.0027866364, -0.0036029816, 0.0075416565, 0.042541504, -0.022750854, 0.049072266, 0.017791748, -0.010467529, -0.07110596, 0.027526855, 0.003458023, -0.02168274, 0.03829956, 0.014518738, 0.010444641, 0.026443481, -0.014541626, 0.024749756, -0.021743774, 0.013259888, 0.019348145, -0.009170532, -0.040405273, 0.005874634, 0.05114746, 0.01360321, -0.010406494, 0.013504028, -0.003063202, 0.04196167, -0.026428223, -0.017868042, 0.015388489, 0.011550903, -0.044677734, 0.0027370453, -0.046936035, -0.021636963, -0.049072266, 0.011512756, -0.0050697327, 0.036499023, 0.040222168, -0.0039043427, -0.04888916, 0.002532959, 0.020690918, 0.0006155968, -0.016921997, -0.059936523, -0.013626099, -0.022506714, -0.09051514, -0.051696777, -0.033599854, 0.0042266846, 0.02305603, 0.014579773, -0.01159668, 0.030441284, 0.026885986, 0.06088257, 0.036834717, -0.022354126, -0.06707764, 0.031402588, -0.036499023, -0.0021514893, 0.012565613, -0.016845703, -0.010398865, -0.03173828, 0.02192688, 0.0022296906, -0.023605347, -0.032562256, 0.013877869, 0.010223389, 0.024871826, 0.009254456, 0.045654297, 0.026947021, -0.0033473969, 0.018325806, 0.012786865, -0.03616333, -0.02458191, 0.014472961, 0.03427124, -0.0018730164, 0.029205322, 0.06768799, 0.003364563, -0.00818634, 0.017150879, 0.017227173, 0.045684814, -0.024093628, 0.0005517006, 0.012313843, -0.05267334, -0.044036865, -0.0037288666, -0.0062179565, 0.05404663, -0.03024292, 0.04888916, 0.0050468445, -0.005153656, 0.02279663, -0.017562866, 0.016571045, -0.001373291, 0.016433716, -0.05496216, -0.061187744, -0.013084412, 0.059051514, -0.02532959, 0.0033416748, -0.0051231384, -0.0019321442, 0.029052734, 0.05206299, 0.034301758, -0.011703491, 0.0018491745, -0.009262085, -0.008331299, -0.0340271, -0.047729492, 0.008041382, 0.00447464, 0.01689148, -0.03286743, 0.016448975, -0.06689453, -0.007827759, -0.00012397766, -0.0041656494, 0.020584106, -0.06817627, 0.014373779, 0.064819336, -0.0025920868, 0.034576416, -0.023284912, 0.013328552, 0.011993408, 0.024398804, 0.00055360794, 0.019134521, 0.011276245, -0.02406311, 0.0030841827, 0.014221191, 0.032073975, 0.029129028, 0.0030460358, 0.0087890625, -0.011222839, -0.018249512, 0.03463745, 0.015098572, -0.011375427, 0.0033626556, -0.04135132, 0.020431519, 0.0069503784, -0.006881714, 0.012161255, -0.030899048, -0.0395813, -0.013977051, -0.014328003, -0.037017822, 0.015380859, 0.00573349, -0.01939392, -0.03930664, 0.0357666, -0.025512695, 0.0019493103, 0.011528015, 0.011482239, -0.013305664, 0.0010070801, 0.034454346, -0.04550171, 0.023910522, -0.0077285767, 0.016296387, 0.032196045, 0.011329651, -0.044799805, -0.008117676, 0.0046195984, -0.06121826, -0.022979736, 0.022094727, 0.022109985, -0.025131226, 0.000050008297, -0.04525757, -0.016662598, -0.003604889, 0.014038086, -0.012168884, -0.018737793, 0.030441284, 0.008308411, 0.005443573, -0.01852417, 0.0039596558, 0.00793457, -0.010101318, 0.00166893, -0.019607544, 0.019378662, -0.032318115, -0.011245728, -0.0055122375, -0.026901245, 0.010169983, 0.023956299, 0.012458801, -0.019165039, 0.010620117, 0.031677246, 0.032287598, -0.010169983, 0.006664276, 0.07305908, -0.04827881, -0.0289917, -0.031188965, -0.013580322, -0.038879395, 0.083618164, -0.0066452026, -0.035247803, -0.047027588, -0.0435791, -0.02041626, 0.001578331, 0.009185791, 0.02017212, 0.025726318, -0.047546387, 0.0070991516, -0.011436462, -0.0069236755, -0.023925781, -0.0031433105, 0.00015676022, -0.0065345764, 0.042510986, 0.014533997, -0.007713318, -0.009216309, 0.02557373, 0.013412476, -0.0043411255, 0.016448975, -0.043121338, 0.009971619, -0.03152466, -0.008872986, 0.059692383, 0.0076026917, -0.014602661, 0.05267334, -0.049957275, 0.064453125, 0.022888184, 0.023162842, 0.050231934, 0.024993896, 0.014015198, -0.0015640259, 0.0059432983, -0.026504517, 0.009346008, -0.03717041, -0.03479004, -0.066223145, -0.023956299, -0.0925293, -0.0030899048, 0.011444092, 0.019073486, 0.0069084167, 0.01171875, 0.002401352, 0.0018777847, 0.019683838, 0.014915466, 0.046203613, -0.024307251, -0.016479492, 0.01687622, -0.0022411346, 0.010826111, 0.031402588, -0.010322571, 0.023208618, -0.02128601, -0.011787415, -0.00026464462, 0.020584106, 0.025894165, -0.0390625, -0.026412964, -0.031921387, 0.010391235, -0.03555298, 0.014457703, 0.0769043, 0.056274414, -0.026489258, -0.022506714, 0.005554199, -0.02281189, -0.020874023, -0.0034923553, 0.023345947, -0.05206299, 0.042144775, -0.023223877, -0.03845215, -0.018615723, 0.058624268, 0.021331787, -0.022949219, -0.0140686035, 0.03552246, 0.026351929, 0.0090408325, -0.018371582, -0.049621582, -0.007686615, 0.03189087, 0.034118652, -0.024856567, 0.010810852, 0.02406311, 0.03527832, -0.01574707, -0.0056266785, -0.0025787354, 0.024368286, -0.011001587, 0.027420044, -0.044189453, 0.029281616, 0.008010864, -0.03466797, 0.0050697327, 0.033569336, -0.06896973, 0.016357422, 0.029159546, 0.02986145, 0.014381409, 0.06378174, 0.0014190674, -0.0231781, -0.04119873, -0.030090332, 0.05783081, 0.024734497, -0.04827881, 0.01725769, -0.015068054, -0.029968262, 0.033935547, -0.02168274, 0.039367676, -0.068359375, 0.001452446, -0.020050049, 0.00869751, 0.031707764, -0.038604736, -0.046417236, -0.034240723, -0.022918701, -0.0051574707, 0.007709503, -0.019210815, -0.014503479, -0.0037631989, 0.018371582, 0.01158905, 0.0024795532, -0.0055503845, -0.033081055, -0.057495117, 0.020690918, -0.027755737, 0.054504395, -0.018356323, -0.022491455, -0.02734375, 0.016723633, 0.016784668, -0.03100586, -0.038757324, 0.012413025, -0.0014476776, -0.0256958, 0.017181396, 0.022247314, -0.017166138, -0.039154053, 0.003168106, -0.0049362183, -0.022644043, -0.015991211, 0.035705566, -0.037872314, -0.041229248, -0.01473999, -0.04144287, 0.042541504, 0.040039062, -0.019424438, -0.004436493, 0.015144348, -0.010467529, -0.023345947, -0.0107803345, 0.019378662, -0.025299072, -0.033111572, -0.0102005005, 0.028427124, 0.027267456, -0.061676025, -0.02897644, 0.002325058, 0.038330078, 0.011413574, 0.060333252, 0.0055351257, -0.0039138794, -0.0010614395, 0.007381439, 0.00049972534, -0.018356323, -0.055023193, -0.03918457, 0.02029419, 0.048431396, -0.003112793, -0.008766174, 0.046051025, -0.005821228, -0.019958496, 0.0141067505, 0.0053520203, -0.016830444, 0.015991211, 0.014541626, -0.028808594, -0.02708435, -0.023330688, 0.04055786, -0.019546509, 0.021575928, -0.006454468, 0.012611389, -0.00623703, 0.04537964, -0.009780884, -0.04095459, 0.032928467, 0.025741577, 0.027893066, 0.03213501, -0.011070251, -0.031188965, -0.006340027, -0.01159668, -0.0042800903, 0.003835678, 0.04421997, -0.058135986, 0.010246277, -0.07336426, -0.046539307, -0.05996704, -0.022399902, 0.018676758, -0.04031372, 0.020507812, -0.024353027, -0.022872925, 0.006652832, 0.047027588, 0.027862549, 0.00006967783, -0.03579712, -0.0047454834, 0.0519104, -0.025970459 ], "summary": [ 0.05731201, 0.018066406, -0.0019369125, -0.011039734, -0.005455017, -0.02998352, 0.012008667, -0.047424316, -0.030319214, 0.056610107, -0.01309967, 0.019561768, 0.009887695, -0.022964478, -0.009429932, -0.01675415, -0.015487671, 0.039154053, -0.0028705597, -0.0099105835, -0.00749588, -0.0028476715, -0.019210815, -0.047729492, 0.049072266, -0.023864746, -0.09991455, 0.025558472, 0.0124053955, 0.017974854, 0.028869629, 0.0126953125, 0.021514893, 0.042175293, -0.042633057, 0.02696228, -0.018051147, 0.019180298, 0.008377075, 0.021255493, 0.014297485, -0.011695862, 0.109313965, -0.040740967, 0.037109375, 0.056762695, -0.005908966, -0.064697266, 0.005466461, -0.006549835, 0.008094788, 0.009376526, 0.011688232, 0.0037269592, -0.0016078949, 0.024597168, -0.047546387, -0.04269409, 0.021484375, 0.085632324, 0.03201294, -0.056732178, 0.00655365, -0.05645752, -0.0074768066, -0.015426636, 0.013832092, 0.021453857, 0.04525757, -0.008796692, -0.010604858, 0.040863037, 0.03857422, -0.044006348, -0.0134887695, -0.0013856888, 0.037994385, 0.024978638, -0.0064315796, -0.048034668, 0.06021118, -0.021194458, 0.024368286, 0.0054969788, -0.013893127, -0.013542175, 0.02029419, -0.019302368, -0.036712646, -0.001531601, -0.026412964, -0.02432251, -0.06945801, 0.047790527, 0.034484863, -0.01133728, -0.025894165, -0.059539795, 0.025726318, 0.0041160583, 0.0030059814, -0.02909851, 0.0027008057, 0.015625, 0.034118652, 0.0014667511, -0.062561035, -0.08874512, 0.049682617, 0.041015625, -0.011985779, 0.026382446, -0.025970459, -0.11633301, 0.036071777, 0.09082031, 0.005001068, 0.046661377, 0.060150146, 0.014350891, 0.017089844, 0.0335083, -0.032318115, 0.033355713, 0.012939453, 0.005897522, 0.0056991577, -0.0019321442, -0.050445557, -0.011909485, 0.015602112, 0.05404663, -0.030227661, -0.009437561, -0.059814453, -0.00013065338, -0.022247314, 0.0053215027, -0.006752014, -0.008003235, 0.053497314, -0.036254883, -0.015975952, 0.061035156, -0.0039138794, 0.051940918, -0.0011863708, -0.024261475, 0.010902405, -0.067871094, 0.008934021, -0.05822754, 0.033111572, -0.030929565, 0.02494812, -0.062683105, -0.04937744, -0.010902405, 0.037017822, 0.0047836304, 0.04083252, -0.0048294067, -0.012794495, 0.06878662, 0.026626587, -0.007865906, -0.024734497, 0.0018892288, 0.009666443, -0.029403687, 0.018356323, 0.012428284, 0.032196045, 0.002494812, 0.023529053, 0.004383087, 0.006416321, 0.022460938, 0.0025577545, -0.027740479, -0.02658081, -0.03149414, 0.0051651, 0.0077552795, -0.022857666, -0.01828003, 0.01285553, 0.07519531, 0.043762207, 0.03277588, -0.027114868, -0.03555298, -0.009544373, -0.024505615, -0.025741577, 0.008239746, -0.007896423, 0.019943237, -0.02029419, 0.018707275, 0.013298035, 0.012229919, -0.017868042, 0.0056419373, -0.064819336, -0.008483887, -0.012016296, 0.008010864, -0.026062012, 0.000081419945, -0.00869751, -0.059539795, 0.02230835, -0.015617371, -0.005317688, -0.0026397705, 0.015686035, 0.010017395, 0.011497498, -0.0071029663, 0.013328552, -0.0052604675, 0.0026798248, 0.022537231, 0.0061912537, 0.011299133, -0.0069084167, 0.00806427, 0.033447266, 0.018737793, 0.056610107, -0.020462036, 0.05895996, 0.054901123, -0.017196655, -0.002937317, 0.002155304, -0.02784729, 0.0061912537, 0.03286743, 0.020935059, 0.0010757446, -0.03262329, -0.026657104, 0.008277893, -0.027618408, 0.005344391, -0.024475098, -0.022018433, -0.023849487, 0.029647827, -0.026504517, 0.04156494, 0.0067596436, -0.0004849434, 0.020187378, 0.005203247, 0.009277344, -0.01725769, -0.005970001, 0.0057907104, -0.00881958, -0.00034546852, -0.013076782, -0.03869629, -0.005470276, -0.008354187, -0.008041382, 0.012336731, -0.0084991455, 0.00869751, -0.051696777, 0.024856567, -0.010437012, -0.08026123, -0.035247803, -0.020187378, 0.032318115, 0.027389526, -0.032836914, -0.029403687, 0.0050697327, 0.018463135, -0.019134521, -0.0015449524, 0.008834839, 0.046447754, -0.007587433, -0.027404785, -0.0057373047, 0.008598328, 0.054229736, 0.008110046, -0.015548706, 0.07623291, -0.0059776306, 0.008171082, -0.003276825, 0.008918762, -0.016448975, 0.0066947937, 0.031158447, -0.025726318, 0.01890564, -0.0051651, 0.008277893, 0.0039367676, 0.0007786751, -0.0021820068, -0.024108887, 0.024795532, 0.076171875, 0.015808105, 0.09301758, -0.06896973, -0.06341553, -0.042022705, 0.024795532, -0.05984497, -0.027572632, 0.030929565, 0.03050232, 0.0024490356, -0.0025615692, 0.027572632, -0.029586792, 0.011726379, -0.023040771, 0.010559082, 0.0023937225, 0.007598877, -0.015129089, -0.024154663, -0.0064735413, 0.005771637, -0.009109497, 0.015380859, 0.016418457, 0.0066375732, 0.00749588, 0.054779053, -0.03918457, -0.012359619, 0.003921509, -0.044830322, -0.015899658, -0.026260376, 0.0021915436, -0.05026245, -0.055633545, 0.06274414, -0.017532349, -0.03591919, 0.041046143, -0.0034751892, 0.0020828247, 0.033111572, 0.06237793, 0.009941101, -0.0025749207, 0.04812622, 0.052734375, 0.04660034, -0.088378906, -0.077819824, -0.060058594, 0.0019607544, 0.0029678345, 0.012535095, 0.025665283, -0.008407593, 0.026245117, -0.026382446, -0.011642456, -0.007827759, 0.016448975, 0.028778076, -0.028030396, -0.0014181137, 0.013908386, -0.029449463, -0.023590088, 0.012298584, -0.018966675, 0.060638428, 0.017089844, 0.037109375, 0.0013170242, 0.077941895, 0.0064735413, 0.008934021, -0.032348633, -0.021118164, 0.0005130768, 0.018035889, -0.011100769, -0.0072784424, 0.008110046, -0.08898926, -0.017990112, 0.06378174, 0.0059814453, 0.0104904175, 0.00907135, -0.018951416, 0.050109863, 0.033416748, 0.018951416, 0.004055023, 0.034606934, -0.01828003, 0.015548706, -0.03591919, 0.030685425, -0.0009498596, -0.012588501, -0.048614502, 0.004219055, -0.06347656, 0.013755798, 0.0054359436, 0.045288086, -0.04751587, -0.01802063, 0.0015983582, 0.03225708, 0.0054740906, -0.0027046204, 0.030761719, 0.020324707, 0.014930725, -0.012016296, -0.013160706, -0.022949219, -0.028839111, 0.038757324, -0.009056091, 0.034057617, 0.020507812, -0.027359009, -0.07421875, -0.045898438, 0.011451721, -0.0002913475, 0.011955261, -0.008903503, -0.034423828, -0.051849365, -0.002620697, 0.050048828, -0.003107071, -0.0057907104, 0.045013428, 0.033935547, -0.04046631, 0.04537964, 0.009086609, 0.047424316, 0.030151367, -0.043121338, 0.014945984, -0.025512695, -0.03704834, 0.020401001, 0.027313232, -0.014503479, -0.011207581, 0.0068740845, -0.01651001, 0.026000977, 0.021057129, -0.0056915283, -0.024856567, -0.027450562, 0.022857666, -0.033813477, 0.004081726, 0.018417358, 0.025497437, -0.012451172, -0.018432617, 0.017745972, -0.021896362, -0.05923462, -0.032043457, 0.007965088, -0.07537842, -0.035339355, 0.02154541, -0.018981934, -0.0154953, -0.044128418, 0.046783447, -0.053833008, -0.0178833, 0.012802124, -0.0066986084, 0.03086853, -0.0073547363, -0.048675537, 0.0025539398, -0.029891968, 0.042510986, 0.026275635, -0.04727173, 0.030181885, 0.07110596, 0.024291992, 0.02180481, -0.03427124, 0.04586792, -0.020599365, 0.03717041, -0.00907135, -0.02218628, 0.04220581, -0.05505371, 0.025817871, -0.043762207, -0.002855301, 0.07269287, 0.08886719, -0.015640259, 0.01373291, 0.014457703, -0.010566711, -0.044006348, -0.01473999, 0.0051574707, -0.033569336, 0.038970947, 0.022949219, -0.008598328, 0.030517578, 0.0015096664, 0.008232117, -0.021957397, -0.029067993, -0.032684326, -0.004436493, -0.03250122, 0.0135650635, 0.03074646, 0.030685425, -0.014862061, -0.021331787, 0.0052833557, 0.020339966, -0.03237915, -0.02432251, 0.028533936, 0.025634766, -0.02619934, -0.017105103, -0.010757446, -0.002828598, -0.02949524, -0.010864258, 0.00031614304, 0.048309326, 0.0033855438, 0.030410767, -0.00970459, -0.017501831, 0.032287598, 0.020645142, -0.048461914, -0.055633545, -0.023498535, -0.016342163, -0.03894043, -0.021118164, -0.013374329, -0.040924072, -0.010864258, -0.011871338, -0.02709961, 0.016281128, 0.019485474, 0.049621582, 0.025680542, -0.010375977, -0.08862305, -0.051574707, -0.008636475, 0.0009150505, -0.025909424, -0.022338867, -0.031311035, -0.0099105835, 0.0256958, -0.0070152283, -0.012916565, -0.07110596, -0.0074768066, -0.008262634, 0.004211426, 0.052459717, 0.02998352, 0.022094727, -0.001364708, 0.047454834, 0.02255249, 0.0044288635, -0.06616211, 0.038085938, -0.020843506, 0.038116455, 0.013023376, 0.07519531, -0.034973145, -0.030548096, 0.03427124, -0.009536743, 0.06945801, -0.03967285, 0.020706177, -0.026870728, -0.05596924, -0.022155762, -0.002040863, -0.031433105, 0.022659302, 0.008323669, 0.013076782, 0.022583008, -0.0093688965, 0.041107178, -0.0107421875, -0.0024433136, 0.015838623, -0.0054092407, -0.08502197, -0.087890625, -0.044189453, 0.107055664, -0.01828003, -0.03540039, -0.004333496, -0.019332886, 0.042938232, 0.024398804, 0.03640747, -0.047546387, -0.011260986, -0.00007045269, 0.0010547638, -0.0009407997, -0.014160156, 0.009918213, 0.028152466, -0.0062408447, -0.007549286, -0.041748047, 0.000015616417, -0.041015625, -0.0022335052, 0.017578125, 0.011711121, -0.0602417, -0.064697266, -0.009567261, 0.002986908, -0.039123535, -0.00006943941, 0.021713257, -0.02619934, -0.012718201, -0.0061035156, -0.028045654, -0.0345459, -0.04626465, 0.02558899, 0.023834229, 0.0037212372, 0.048187256, 0.022262573, 0.0042152405, -0.0071258545, 0.015731812, -0.009803772, -0.067871094, 0.010574341, -0.042907715, 0.017700195, -0.0049095154, 0.042144775, 0.031555176, 0.018508911, -0.0099487305, 0.00667572, -0.019439697, 0.0011892319, -0.037902832, 0.0058174133, 0.0088272095, 0.02017212, -0.016281128, 0.0010099411, -0.061676025, 0.009986877, 0.028793335, 0.0028305054, 0.026748657, -0.028640747, 0.024383545, -0.0032978058, 0.018539429, -0.0019779205, 0.028060913, -0.015525818, -0.03540039, -0.043792725, -0.015281677, 0.0390625, -0.015052795, -0.011917114, -0.0020713806, -0.012763977, 0.0015554428, 0.018035889, -0.03173828, 0.011878967, -0.0012493134, 0.03665161, -0.0713501, 0.006690979, 0.019104004, 0.0008955002, -0.0040740967, -0.00762558, -0.02079773, -0.015617371, -0.009895325, 0.0061454773, 0.0063705444, -0.0058670044, 0.02154541, 0.050628662, -0.05911255, 0.0013246536, -0.030822754, 0.04486084, 0.025650024, 0.0051651, -0.014846802, 0.01448822, 0.032470703, -0.023925781, -0.010559082, 0.05130005, -0.028884888, -0.05670166, -0.037231445, 0.019699097, -0.033050537, 0.011360168, -0.016433716, -0.05596924, 0.00730896, -0.051818848, 0.0013809204, -0.014961243, 0.02659607, 0.010070801, 0.032104492, -0.03387451, -0.041168213, 0.012672424, 0.008666992, -0.015419006, -0.017929077, -0.013633728, 0.021453857, 0.015197754, 0.049194336, -0.009162903, -0.0016021729, 0.028961182, -0.0020942688, -0.014770508, 0.020706177, 0.0435791, 0.010093689, -0.022781372, 0.038116455, 0.03353882, 0.04055786, -0.0035991669, 0.014297485, 0.020324707, 0.016326904, 0.014907837, -0.029418945, 0.007751465, -0.002029419, -0.018737793, -0.0022640228, -0.01626587, -0.01828003, 0.007972717, 0.0075912476, -0.05657959, -0.051818848, -0.04296875, -0.003660202, 0.024398804, -0.001209259, 0.006587982, 0.042419434, 0.002658844, 0.025268555, 0.020858765, -0.049804688, -0.003993988, -0.012878418, 0.0023117065, -0.01574707, 0.026489258, 0.039245605, -0.002702713, 0.02368164, -0.005466461, 0.062286377, 0.017929077, -0.018951416, 0.011703491, 0.009567261, 0.006855011, -0.05923462, 0.012268066, -0.03955078, 0.03466797, 0.028381348, 0.044311523, 0.020050049, 0.020370483, -0.034729004, 0.0041503906, 0.00818634, -0.0423584, -0.013328552, -0.01121521, -0.025970459, -0.03878784, 0.022781372, -0.00063323975, -0.002008438, 0.040161133, 0.059020996, 0.0209198, -0.027236938, 0.007423401, 0.034576416, 0.004295349, 0.005844116, -0.018432617, -0.03967285, -0.024291992, 0.030822754, 0.0073242188, -0.030532837, -0.010177612, 0.03289795, -0.022064209, -0.0059776306, 0.0018043518, -0.0067749023, 0.042236328, -0.0074310303, 0.0385437, -0.054992676, 0.02508545, 0.044921875, -0.0056495667, 0.026397705, 0.05218506, 0.016159058, 0.031311035, 0.036071777, 0.008117676, 0.025878906, 0.050476074, -0.02998352, 0.011955261, -0.004840851, -0.004699707, 0.04373169, -0.017715454, -0.03149414, -0.03729248, 0.015182495, 0.010223389, -0.02017212, 0.0019683838, -0.012168884, -0.08251953, -0.011169434, -0.024093628, 0.026672363, -0.06518555, 0.019561768, -0.047302246, -0.026351929, -0.045013428, 0.013626099, 0.014457703, 0.0060424805, 0.023605347, -0.014167786, -0.0127334595, 0.041107178, -0.018569946, 0.024871826, 0.0038795471, -0.049468994, -0.010887146, -0.018478394, 0.038085938, 0.0011844635, -0.029571533, 0.0049438477, 0.006252289, 0.016586304, -0.0069389343, -0.002752304, 0.01675415, -0.012832642, -0.030197144, -0.0036678314, 0.0021743774, -0.016296387, -0.012535095, 0.042663574, 0.010772705, -0.0072784424, 0.023345947, 0.015541077, -0.029281616, -0.013160706, 0.0024280548, -0.06112671, 0.04220581, 0.01612854, -0.009307861, 0.010986328, 0.035095215, -0.010513306, 0.011932373, -0.01335144, -0.004398346, -0.029403687, -0.021408081, -0.0061836243, 0.020599365, 0.031555176, -0.022323608, -0.014930725, 0.019821167, 0.028762817, 0.012496948, -0.040283203, -0.010620117, -0.035614014, 0.0056991577, -0.0032806396, -0.004951477, 0.0059814453, -0.051635742, -0.034454346, 0.042175293, 0.0068130493, -0.028305054, -0.022872925, 0.030654907, -0.017211914, -0.046905518, 0.027709961, -0.011268616, -0.06951904, 0.019943237, -0.028656006, -0.005710602, -0.0713501, -0.03250122, 0.03567505, -0.0155181885, -0.031188965, 0.0065689087, 0.014350891, -0.029251099, 0.006965637, -0.021438599, 0.028457642, 0.0058937073, -0.017150879, 0.04135132, -0.049865723, 0.0309906, 0.03552246, 0.011497498, -0.025939941, -0.0007224083, -0.012779236, 0.06222534, -0.1227417, -0.028167725, -0.07885742, -0.034576416, -0.05267334, -0.02708435, -0.006095886, -0.033172607, 0.024917603, 0.020980835, -0.020690918, 0.015579224, 0.045013428, 0.028030396, 0.010437012, 0.001253128, -0.053588867, 0.040161133, -0.012237549 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1809.10093v2
Pay attention! - Robustifying a Deep Visuomotor Policy through Task-Focused Attention
Pooya Abolghasemi, Amir Mazaheri, Mubarak Shah, Ladislau Bölöni
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
Several recent studies have demonstrated the promise of deep visuomotor policies for robot manipulator control. Despite impressive progress, these systems are known to be vulnerable to physical disturbances, such as accidental or adversarial bumps that make them drop the manipulated object. They also tend to be distracted by visual disturbances such as objects moving in the robot's field of view, even if the disturbance does not physically prevent the execution of the task. In this paper, we propose an approach for augmenting a deep visuomotor policy trained through demonstrations with Task Focused visual Attention (TFA). The manipulation task is specified with a natural language text such as `move the red bowl to the left'. This allows the visual attention component to concentrate on the current object that the robot needs to manipulate. We show that even in benign environments, the TFA allows the policy to consistently outperform a variant with no attention mechanism. More importantly, the new policy is significantly more robust: it regularly recovers from severe physical disturbances (such as bumps causing it to drop the object) from which the baseline policy, i.e. with no visual attention, almost never recovers. In addition, we show that the proposed policy performs correctly in the presence of a wide class of visual disturbances, exhibiting a behavior reminiscent of human selective visual attention experiments. Our proposed approach consists of a VAE-GAN network which encodes the visual input and feeds it to a Motor network that moves the robot joints. Also, our approach benefits from a teacher network for the TFA that leverages textual input command to robustify the visual encoder against various types of disturbances.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1809.10093v2
2018-11-28T23:54:47
2018-09-26T16:06:34
{ "title": [ 0.033935547, 0.0036296844, -0.02192688, -0.045959473, 0.018127441, -0.04058838, 0.0037975311, -0.025634766, -0.012779236, 0.019866943, -0.023651123, 0.014411926, 0.0068893433, -0.023880005, -0.020019531, 0.004383087, 0.007965088, 0.02760315, -0.009254456, -0.028015137, -0.01512146, -0.032958984, 0.037719727, 0.035827637, 0.0064582825, 0.0008196831, -0.13928223, 0.021514893, -0.06896973, -0.02015686, -0.020599365, 0.051513672, 0.0519104, -0.0012731552, -0.005970001, 0.015075684, -0.04321289, 0.017623901, -0.009849548, 0.009086609, 0.012619019, -0.004627228, -0.057617188, -0.019012451, -0.06549072, 0.0031986237, -0.04626465, 0.02078247, -0.0033683777, 0.033447266, 0.016067505, 0.033477783, -0.006401062, 0.059509277, 0.021316528, -0.0022220612, -0.055145264, -0.0010032654, 0.036071777, 0.08068848, 0.018203735, -0.06732178, 0.0178833, -0.037628174, -0.018188477, -0.042755127, -0.030899048, 0.042388916, 0.056793213, 0.02128601, 0.0011072159, 0.0181427, 0.020019531, 0.024505615, -0.036376953, -0.036743164, 0.02998352, 0.020645142, 0.050048828, -0.019317627, -0.00023388863, -0.0345459, 0.046447754, -0.0065078735, -0.020202637, -0.028808594, -0.014572144, -0.005844116, -0.010223389, -0.07891846, -0.0052604675, 0.015914917, -0.0181427, -0.001420021, -0.059173584, -0.031066895, -0.005332947, 0.027404785, -0.0065307617, 0.002658844, -0.034179688, 0.019683838, -0.026382446, -0.016311646, -0.0022563934, -0.0020637512, -0.017745972, -0.014556885, 0.010826111, 0.045196533, -0.024932861, 0.026184082, 0.022460938, 0.01134491, -0.005596161, -0.022705078, -0.023742676, 0.013031006, 0.010063171, 0.010894775, -0.0019950867, 0.0026359558, 0.0033092499, 0.013465881, 0.0287323, 0.028671265, -0.037231445, 0.005592346, 0.03253174, -0.026779175, -0.006919861, 0.07659912, -0.08331299, -0.08074951, -0.054595947, 0.054992676, 0.032562256, 0.0073661804, -0.025390625, -0.008094788, 0.031555176, -0.004901886, 0.0038890839, 0.008895874, -0.025253296, 0.0039749146, 0.05203247, 0.0058898926, -0.05532837, -0.07525635, -0.00315094, 0.0033016205, 0.0054512024, 0.009727478, -0.06323242, 0.009971619, -0.12445068, 0.0072746277, 0.032684326, 0.0031433105, 0.0340271, -0.002275467, -0.014663696, 0.01676941, 0.039886475, 0.0085372925, -0.030685425, 0.023483276, -0.0028953552, 0.05532837, -0.01965332, 0.027420044, -0.033355713, -0.021820068, -0.0044937134, -0.0077400208, 0.0064315796, 0.00037026405, 0.030776978, -0.0040283203, -0.008979797, -0.03479004, 0.021133423, 0.041748047, -0.032165527, -0.047790527, -0.0017318726, -0.021575928, 0.048858643, 0.024932861, -0.042907715, 0.018188477, -0.04748535, -0.06311035, -0.06060791, 0.023651123, 0.0418396, 0.045654297, -0.020690918, 0.03161621, -0.019851685, -0.016448975, -0.0069847107, -0.0055770874, -0.0115356445, -0.031036377, 0.0015954971, 0.020080566, -0.007659912, 0.035858154, 0.033172607, -0.001704216, -0.009056091, -0.013008118, -0.03326416, -0.04916382, 0.0056037903, -0.00472641, -0.010772705, 0.01121521, -0.010955811, -0.0057029724, 0.004020691, 0.024337769, 0.020889282, 0.0037631989, 0.0043182373, -0.028244019, 0.0158844, 0.030639648, 0.028030396, -0.022277832, -0.01309967, -0.0036125183, -0.016235352, -0.030471802, -0.0012664795, -0.018234253, 0.033935547, 0.020828247, 0.0057525635, -0.019058228, 0.010620117, 0.045318604, 0.066833496, -0.013687134, -0.011238098, 0.018295288, 0.0051994324, -0.018310547, 0.027130127, -0.0010223389, 0.07867432, 0.0055770874, 0.010848999, 0.068481445, 0.0076179504, 0.031311035, -0.048736572, 0.027145386, -0.016693115, 0.018753052, 0.022323608, 0.010322571, -0.03286743, 0.0054779053, -0.009544373, 0.02079773, 0.009178162, 0.0064201355, 0.03161621, -0.027008057, 0.012252808, -0.013771057, -0.0035934448, -0.049316406, -0.012275696, 0.017181396, 0.032714844, -0.064941406, -0.012275696, 0.0071640015, 0.03656006, 0.011497498, 0.02128601, 0.024749756, 0.027786255, -0.011444092, -0.020263672, -0.02760315, 0.046020508, -0.0029258728, -0.0019483566, -0.015823364, 0.018539429, -0.031982422, 0.085632324, 0.06512451, -0.009727478, 0.026321411, -0.06100464, 0.011856079, -0.005378723, -0.010932922, 0.016403198, 0.0033493042, 0.029083252, 0.033233643, -0.013031006, 0.007419586, -0.055389404, 0.0015888214, 0.005207062, 0.015266418, -0.04196167, -0.048736572, -0.009552002, -0.015396118, -0.0574646, -0.03704834, 0.024810791, -0.022476196, -0.009048462, -0.02720642, -0.003627777, -0.00944519, -0.043426514, -0.012969971, -0.032409668, 0.03274536, 0.061676025, 0.029449463, -0.02796936, -0.017593384, 0.011291504, 0.021026611, 0.0017814636, 0.010231018, -0.008323669, -0.012863159, 0.017990112, -0.034362793, -0.0017223358, -0.010002136, -0.0095825195, -0.04083252, -0.0033798218, 0.014389038, -0.05343628, -0.0082092285, 0.037628174, -0.027145386, -0.020477295, 0.0126571655, 0.0496521, -0.029708862, -0.005508423, 0.058013916, 0.025146484, 0.007167816, 0.040893555, 0.017303467, 0.014503479, -0.06732178, 0.0045166016, -0.05657959, -0.035614014, -0.00856781, 0.047058105, 0.06994629, -0.05053711, 0.04901123, -0.05215454, -0.0001951456, 0.018234253, -0.007835388, -0.042541504, -0.053955078, -0.014419556, -0.041656494, -0.012519836, 0.004501343, 0.011619568, 0.022003174, 0.0670166, 0.0034713745, -0.01713562, -0.011306763, 0.029464722, 0.012893677, -0.019760132, -0.03540039, -0.06286621, 0.006263733, 0.0015172958, 0.017242432, -0.020935059, -0.041931152, -0.105163574, -0.0023899078, 0.019424438, 0.012908936, -0.015548706, 0.024597168, -0.08850098, 0.048034668, -0.03881836, -0.018722534, 0.023239136, 0.05508423, -0.0024147034, -0.003189087, 0.017318726, -0.01928711, 0.01789856, -0.02835083, -0.070495605, 0.0362854, -0.011604309, -0.037200928, 0.009155273, -0.06591797, -0.020095825, -0.0031604767, -0.0019607544, 0.05795288, 0.0076179504, 0.0045661926, 0.0039901733, -0.0033454895, 0.0041999817, -0.0178833, -0.018966675, -0.017730713, -0.02810669, -0.0061416626, -0.017089844, 0.05657959, 0.0036258698, 0.008079529, -0.046295166, -0.002128601, -0.0262146, 0.026535034, -0.011375427, -0.031341553, -0.00020074844, -0.038604736, -0.017349243, -0.03866577, -0.0075531006, -0.0028972626, -0.029937744, 0.0138549805, -0.0067367554, 0.09802246, 0.0087509155, 0.024032593, 0.011177063, -0.0058288574, -0.0008921623, -0.03967285, -0.004146576, 0.015930176, -0.005554199, 0.0024814606, 0.009468079, -0.026138306, -0.033569336, 0.0029773712, -0.048797607, 0.06542969, 0.016647339, -0.0058898926, 0.0014944077, -0.021911621, -0.016052246, -0.019088745, -0.00035834312, 0.01574707, 0.03527832, -0.018127441, 0.031707764, 0.005542755, -0.0152282715, 0.017974854, -0.090026855, -0.00087213516, 0.009994507, -0.031433105, -0.013137817, -0.027130127, 0.034179688, -0.04397583, -0.039794922, -0.022979736, -0.018692017, -0.010810852, 0.019561768, -0.044647217, -0.017730713, 0.050323486, -0.0008277893, -0.012016296, 0.033325195, -0.00504303, -0.000086426735, -0.02748108, 0.02381897, 0.03277588, 0.02619934, -0.0010890961, 0.032989502, 0.04058838, -0.029449463, 0.03161621, 0.005809784, 0.033843994, -0.014625549, 0.0050697327, 0.004524231, 0.029724121, -0.06088257, 0.050720215, 0.044708252, 0.005718231, -0.09741211, 0.027328491, -0.013763428, -0.019851685, 0.016921997, -0.010414124, 0.009605408, 0.023330688, 0.0014638901, 0.041229248, -0.0062179565, -0.002456665, 0.02772522, -0.0034561157, -0.0113220215, 0.001657486, 0.012107849, 0.0014333725, -0.021408081, 0.039611816, -0.019836426, 0.046051025, -0.0038223267, -0.029586792, 0.008224487, 0.027893066, -0.06036377, 0.01007843, -0.029754639, -0.08093262, -0.05105591, 0.026763916, -0.0021457672, 0.013717651, 0.03656006, -0.013717651, -0.009628296, -0.0070152283, 0.014625549, 0.01776123, -0.03378296, -0.062072754, -0.025848389, -0.02607727, -0.076171875, -0.048095703, -0.037475586, -0.015602112, -0.0042381287, 0.008666992, -0.020568848, 0.018859863, 0.021011353, 0.09716797, 0.036254883, 0.025115967, -0.05444336, 0.076293945, -0.038330078, -0.02281189, 0.03878784, -0.0018949509, -0.01763916, -0.037384033, 0.012428284, -0.0071411133, -0.030181885, -0.056243896, 0.02671814, 0.019378662, 0.011360168, 0.025756836, 0.05065918, 0.026321411, 0.022659302, -0.0055236816, -0.005630493, -0.038269043, -0.0047073364, -0.026504517, 0.04083252, -0.009567261, 0.036834717, 0.05178833, 0.014175415, -0.009002686, -0.006023407, 0.03262329, 0.04031372, -0.04269409, -0.013618469, 0.032714844, -0.042541504, -0.03817749, -0.0011072159, 0.00067424774, 0.030181885, -0.043395996, 0.056793213, 0.008659363, 0.006275177, 0.041778564, -0.017211914, -0.003583908, -0.00907135, 0.0012989044, -0.045684814, -0.07519531, -0.011779785, 0.07946777, -0.022735596, 0.0009493828, 0.0011806488, 0.030349731, 0.026473999, 0.048980713, 0.030258179, 0.0008196831, -0.0019664764, -0.014640808, -0.011978149, -0.024658203, -0.033691406, -0.02470398, 0.021148682, 0.02027893, -0.06640625, 0.017059326, -0.016021729, -0.02998352, -0.007820129, -0.0013256073, 0.0009589195, -0.052520752, 0.02116394, 0.06640625, 0.010848999, 0.03756714, 0.04232788, 0.050048828, 0.01626587, 0.055603027, 0.0042037964, 0.038024902, 0.03857422, -0.03414917, 0.015434265, 0.0062675476, 0.03213501, 0.03186035, -0.001250267, -0.00010865927, 0.014411926, -0.033721924, 0.022979736, -0.005619049, -0.0002951622, 0.010032654, -0.044189453, 0.0008916855, 0.018554688, 0.018157959, 0.010826111, -0.024841309, -0.033569336, -0.0023059845, -0.03173828, -0.04260254, -0.0076828003, -0.041015625, -0.04711914, -0.064453125, 0.039001465, -0.004058838, -0.006034851, -0.011711121, 0.021087646, -0.046813965, 0.031219482, 0.008972168, -0.026290894, -0.025268555, 0.02859497, 0.018966675, 0.023925781, 0.008026123, -0.029205322, -0.00023770332, 0.017105103, -0.021560669, 0.015174866, 0.016067505, 0.0039863586, -0.01361084, -0.015350342, -0.042022705, -0.03186035, 0.003250122, 0.027694702, -0.027694702, -0.037628174, 0.024734497, 0.0012779236, 0.0138168335, 0.02456665, 0.030349731, -0.0036334991, 0.007911682, 0.00687027, 0.014030457, 0.029876709, -0.014923096, 0.007785797, -0.020217896, -0.05307007, 0.019470215, 0.025009155, 0.0045433044, -0.0146865845, 0.034088135, 0.04421997, -0.008964539, -0.007965088, 0.0135650635, 0.053131104, -0.05328369, -0.012001038, -0.015945435, 0.0045166016, -0.030151367, 0.018692017, -0.012886047, -0.017364502, -0.02468872, -0.028076172, -0.025390625, 0.0015096664, 0.01687622, -0.02279663, 0.015625, -0.039031982, -0.024154663, -0.04397583, 0.012168884, -0.016021729, -0.009460449, -0.02116394, 0.007446289, 0.0033836365, 0.023132324, 0.0113220215, -0.013656616, 0.013397217, -0.006046295, -0.025131226, 0.002368927, -0.009094238, 0.009788513, -0.0076446533, -0.009376526, 0.04598999, -0.017562866, -0.012664795, 0.0015974045, -0.03375244, 0.06008911, 0.020599365, 0.03451538, 0.06744385, 0.0158844, -0.025512695, -0.00076436996, -0.02053833, -0.04373169, 0.012512207, -0.0262146, -0.0038890839, -0.023773193, -0.011489868, -0.08557129, 0.005622864, 0.022766113, 0.059143066, 0.016540527, 0.01486969, 0.024291992, -0.021697998, 0.029281616, -0.02229309, 0.06762695, 0.009559631, 0.0022640228, -0.014228821, -0.010185242, 0.029205322, 0.03475952, 0.0124053955, 0.003929138, -0.01737976, 0.008842468, -0.018676758, -0.009132385, 0.033477783, 0.0034446716, -0.01210022, 0.0022220612, 0.07373047, 0.0021743774, 0.04827881, 0.048431396, 0.039367676, -0.042785645, -0.007911682, -0.006000519, 0.006591797, -0.042236328, 0.022872925, 0.05697632, -0.08959961, 0.052947998, -0.0016298294, -0.04168701, -0.04071045, 0.06695557, -0.013931274, -0.01449585, 0.008087158, 0.0005507469, 0.024307251, 0.03503418, 0.016296387, -0.03111267, -0.019378662, 0.00762558, 0.010986328, 0.0026187897, 0.037841797, 0.006034851, -0.0027446747, -0.021453857, -0.0068359375, -0.013015747, 0.04232788, -0.03036499, 0.028381348, -0.020812988, 0.0725708, -0.009284973, -0.036743164, 0.041900635, 0.008331299, -0.071777344, 0.014091492, -0.0016174316, 0.015274048, 0.012901306, 0.046783447, -0.009902954, -0.014717102, -0.020080566, -0.017578125, 0.026687622, 0.051513672, -0.018478394, 0.018692017, -0.046295166, -0.046203613, 0.02432251, -0.05050659, 0.0680542, -0.012809753, 0.014076233, -0.021606445, 0.027023315, 0.038513184, -0.032196045, -0.034362793, 0.007282257, -0.04156494, 0.0035705566, 0.010467529, -0.004699707, 0.008583069, 0.004802704, 0.003107071, 0.04989624, -0.00093507767, 0.0039596558, -0.033966064, -0.09710693, 0.015144348, -0.013969421, 0.03201294, -0.0002939701, -0.04171753, -0.043945312, 0.012779236, 0.032592773, 0.014297485, -0.04144287, 0.04043579, -0.024597168, -0.007095337, 0.00894165, 0.011428833, 0.005142212, 0.026855469, -0.03741455, 0.028442383, -0.01058197, -0.016220093, 0.047851562, -0.03024292, -0.055511475, -0.0025520325, -0.04711914, 0.05114746, 0.035339355, -0.02015686, 0.0037498474, 0.025802612, -0.049804688, -0.009475708, -0.010940552, 0.046173096, -0.016418457, -0.042388916, -0.007068634, 0.023620605, 0.024978638, -0.057128906, -0.047729492, 0.007865906, 0.03439331, -0.008338928, 0.034057617, 0.007129669, 0.015007019, 0.018692017, 0.04486084, 0.0005712509, -0.05908203, -0.025436401, -0.015960693, 0.053649902, 0.03314209, -0.013496399, -0.010223389, 0.013320923, -0.011657715, -0.00008350611, -0.0059661865, 0.010139465, 0.00051403046, -0.0023880005, 0.059692383, -0.006259918, -0.007671356, -0.04916382, 0.021377563, -0.015113831, 0.0033874512, -0.000044703484, 0.025726318, -0.012229919, 0.09350586, -0.029190063, -0.015205383, 0.042297363, 0.034210205, 0.027526855, 0.012458801, 0.00969696, 0.0062561035, 0.003414154, 0.018753052, -0.0076522827, 0.030273438, 0.03274536, -0.009635925, 0.0016469955, -0.034454346, -0.021255493, 0.016967773, -0.019256592, 0.04800415, -0.027389526, -0.0025920868, -0.026901245, -0.044891357, -0.0044517517, 0.032989502, 0.023147583, -0.016311646, -0.049102783, -0.028167725, 0.032165527, -0.015205383 ], "summary": [ 0.06347656, -0.006916046, 0.018661499, 0.017715454, -0.025970459, -0.038482666, 0.015213013, -0.03060913, 0.0042877197, 0.023117065, -0.027755737, 0.02961731, 0.0284729, -0.030639648, 0.024505615, 0.0030136108, 0.011756897, 0.0104599, 0.013374329, -0.013343811, 0.011695862, -0.007091522, 0.02558899, -0.02507019, 0.013145447, -0.027359009, -0.08972168, 0.011985779, -0.023101807, -0.0017204285, 0.010192871, 0.010604858, 0.02532959, -0.010131836, 0.014694214, -0.04675293, -0.004096985, -0.010520935, -0.008361816, 0.013191223, 0.015357971, 0.008781433, -0.004585266, -0.03488159, -0.053619385, 0.03805542, -0.053497314, 0.008049011, 0.014724731, 0.044158936, 0.012191772, 0.022247314, -0.020385742, 0.059692383, 0.0068740845, 0.009300232, -0.07714844, -0.027389526, 0.025650024, 0.12445068, 0.042999268, -0.03918457, -0.025344849, -0.080566406, 0.009735107, -0.012069702, 0.0065956116, 0.01612854, 0.022232056, 0.008148193, 0.018539429, -0.018310547, 0.017669678, 0.01448822, -0.02041626, -0.036865234, 0.019851685, 0.01878357, 0.00793457, -0.005039215, 0.0046157837, 0.023498535, 0.031280518, -0.028686523, -0.009941101, -0.049194336, -0.010307312, -0.0054512024, -0.010917664, -0.011367798, -0.017501831, 0.018051147, -0.02192688, 0.018249512, -0.024917603, -0.028213501, -0.012039185, -0.03756714, 0.01083374, 0.030563354, 0.0519104, -0.06210327, 0.10235596, -0.038146973, -0.0075950623, -0.006542206, 0.0072135925, -0.037597656, 0.0064964294, 0.0071754456, -0.046081543, 0.020019531, 0.011665344, 0.009384155, -0.03466797, 0.0024929047, -0.0037326813, 0.0057678223, -0.01626587, 0.006313324, -0.0209198, 0.017990112, -0.00868988, 0.037384033, -0.0003681183, -0.0008058548, 0.01612854, -0.00017929077, 0.07171631, -0.072143555, -0.0390625, 0.041229248, 0.036376953, 0.013664246, 0.022125244, 0.02243042, 0.0063667297, -0.01663208, -0.0018339157, -0.050476074, 0.0602417, 0.033203125, 0.0037708282, 0.018035889, -0.053710938, 0.043182373, 0.03527832, 0.0037117004, -0.06982422, -0.1184082, 0.040283203, -0.011444092, 0.018356323, 0.013519287, 0.0121154785, -0.03527832, -0.0051879883, -0.02758789, 0.038238525, -0.021469116, 0.06390381, 0.028137207, 0.016067505, 0.042755127, 0.014549255, -0.043640137, -0.037384033, -0.0003244877, 0.0077934265, 0.048706055, -0.007888794, 0.03173828, -0.031921387, -0.008720398, -0.005630493, -0.03970337, -0.0045166016, 0.006980896, 0.013191223, -0.0121154785, 0.0038032532, -0.02760315, 0.011634827, 0.010040283, 0.029663086, -0.0592041, -0.0027580261, -0.004142761, 0.021575928, 0.038879395, -0.050994873, 0.005088806, -0.039154053, -0.015197754, -0.026123047, 0.03741455, 0.023880005, 0.034698486, -0.018951416, -0.012283325, 0.031204224, -0.008171082, 0.01687622, -0.038757324, -0.066101074, 0.010719299, -0.018951416, 0.036102295, -0.044433594, 0.0037879944, 0.029647827, -0.048431396, -0.02607727, 0.035949707, -0.0003812313, -0.026565552, -0.009979248, -0.017486572, -0.001572609, -0.017944336, -0.015838623, 0.02255249, -0.023422241, 0.035339355, -0.013587952, 0.0027999878, -0.016555786, 0.0065345764, 0.005947113, -0.009284973, 0.06781006, -0.0031776428, -0.02859497, 0.000259161, -0.008331299, -0.027877808, 0.0028018951, -0.07470703, 0.048980713, 0.048217773, 0.010902405, 0.00258255, -0.019256592, 0.019638062, 0.0068740845, -0.03942871, -0.012413025, -0.0069465637, -0.03817749, -0.034088135, 0.008880615, 0.01713562, 0.048431396, -0.023605347, 0.012031555, 0.049468994, 0.0007305145, -0.022964478, -0.014205933, 0.0032901764, 0.027267456, -0.02519226, -0.029876709, 0.009635925, -0.015930176, -0.030715942, -0.013031006, -0.022857666, 0.009117126, -0.019165039, 0.013877869, -0.04724121, 0.0053634644, -0.035705566, -0.02947998, -0.05050659, -0.019348145, 0.026748657, 0.02571106, -0.052978516, -0.0055236816, -0.015777588, 0.009429932, -0.01965332, 0.06100464, 0.019104004, -0.0008893013, -0.041992188, 0.03869629, 0.07385254, 0.06970215, 0.019515991, 0.004764557, 0.014213562, 0.002670288, -0.013442993, -0.011634827, 0.021987915, 0.011985779, -0.031555176, -0.026000977, 0.03527832, -0.036834717, 0.0049743652, 0.017593384, -0.025375366, -0.0010919571, 0.06011963, 0.04827881, -0.00566864, -0.017349243, 0.027709961, 0.033416748, 0.10595703, -0.04675293, -0.05706787, -0.011169434, 0.06774902, -0.04522705, -0.016906738, 0.076049805, -0.02279663, -0.002981186, 0.024810791, -0.015281677, -0.039764404, 0.048431396, -0.009513855, -0.040740967, 0.03857422, 0.029388428, 0.047546387, 0.025390625, 0.05606079, -0.00036001205, -0.000042021275, 0.025115967, 0.0007696152, 0.017303467, -0.020141602, 0.058807373, -0.030014038, -0.01260376, 0.027450562, -0.011474609, -0.015640259, -0.0073928833, -0.0028438568, -0.0715332, -0.023834229, 0.027557373, -0.03894043, -0.0018014908, 0.005077362, 0.008003235, -0.022338867, 0.008140564, 0.029556274, 0.0010824203, -0.020324707, 0.02104187, 0.018920898, -0.006465912, -0.055114746, -0.00046777725, -0.026275635, -0.012245178, -0.01727295, 0.052947998, 0.08728027, -0.01600647, 0.095703125, -0.056396484, -0.031158447, -0.016342163, -0.017990112, 0.01663208, -0.02709961, -0.003162384, 0.014656067, 0.024917603, 0.015182495, 0.011077881, 0.019424438, 0.06304932, 0.00010967255, -0.0015010834, 0.03225708, 0.031066895, 0.009994507, -0.008010864, -0.013969421, 0.03842163, -0.02458191, -0.04397583, -0.0012655258, -0.010017395, -0.048919678, 0.012001038, -0.012573242, -0.013748169, 0.055664062, 0.02355957, 0.012771606, -0.039855957, 0.00881958, -0.026519775, -0.019546509, 0.005657196, 0.040527344, 0.026519775, -0.019241333, 0.02909851, 0.0061531067, 0.017425537, -0.02180481, 0.050872803, 0.0143966675, -0.022354126, -0.06161499, 0.023742676, -0.0035438538, -0.009407043, -0.033569336, 0.034118652, 0.04888916, 0.004337311, -0.028686523, -0.024887085, 0.026367188, 0.025787354, -0.015426636, 0.0064964294, 0.011367798, -0.080444336, -0.017654419, 0.00749588, -0.0041999817, 0.07385254, -0.06842041, -0.05227661, -0.0016927719, -0.034118652, -0.00039696693, 0.011276245, -0.035186768, 0.012084961, -0.04147339, -0.021514893, -0.041931152, -0.027908325, 0.011314392, 0.0034694672, 0.024871826, 0.0069122314, 0.09942627, -0.03265381, 0.025665283, 0.057617188, -0.037353516, -0.0026435852, -0.016082764, -0.010261536, 0.009712219, 0.005264282, -0.016845703, -0.02229309, -0.009346008, -0.028961182, -0.005428314, -0.029067993, 0.040863037, -0.028015137, -0.03414917, -0.0012559891, -0.05041504, 0.04840088, -0.033233643, 0.087402344, -0.025863647, -0.019424438, -0.007789612, 0.013755798, 0.004966736, -0.008842468, 0.023391724, -0.031234741, 0.026565552, 0.02078247, 0.0061569214, 0.03439331, -0.015823364, 0.070007324, -0.05203247, -0.0020599365, -0.013038635, -0.00573349, 0.06298828, 0.032836914, -0.0062789917, -0.019729614, -0.009246826, 0.042114258, -0.044677734, -0.02507019, 0.02607727, 0.04244995, -0.0079422, 0.013427734, -0.019134521, 0.023956299, -0.032470703, 0.05078125, 0.021972656, -0.012634277, 0.02027893, 0.006362915, 0.058410645, -0.03866577, -0.025039673, 0.01574707, 0.03805542, -0.026885986, 0.020401001, 0.026367188, 0.032806396, -0.072143555, 0.05432129, -0.021697998, -0.006832123, 0.035369873, 0.043395996, 0.011543274, -0.0152282715, -0.009109497, -0.025115967, -0.018157959, -0.03869629, 0.032836914, 0.030975342, 0.00166893, 0.012466431, -0.003030777, 0.040863037, -0.023773193, 0.015670776, -0.031204224, 0.016479492, -0.044067383, -0.016021729, -0.00009596348, 0.020477295, -0.032470703, -0.02822876, -0.015197754, -0.035583496, -0.023895264, 0.01600647, 0.011810303, 0.011627197, 0.00434494, 0.015449524, -0.0025157928, 0.0006504059, 0.013313293, 0.04449463, -0.06427002, -0.08343506, -0.035949707, 0.0000030398369, -0.04562378, -0.025009155, -0.054473877, -0.038391113, -0.030593872, 0.002565384, -0.031829834, 0.006969452, 0.008102417, 0.084228516, 0.03756714, 0.047729492, -0.06414795, 0.039093018, -0.03475952, 0.013504028, 0.05987549, 0.0005578995, 0.0033683777, -0.012924194, -0.02784729, 0.001958847, -0.042755127, -0.043792725, 0.013496399, 0.024475098, 0.011619568, 0.038635254, 0.04156494, 0.018249512, 0.0026493073, -0.011451721, -0.012313843, -0.013244629, 0.03414917, -0.0063591003, -0.007381439, 0.023468018, 0.038482666, 0.0231781, -0.01260376, -0.036346436, 0.0021648407, 0.04650879, 0.040740967, -0.07373047, -0.012397766, 0.0077400208, 0.016616821, -0.0034122467, 0.0134887695, 0.0036373138, 0.01725769, 0.014411926, 0.021270752, 0.053009033, -0.01789856, 0.02394104, -0.02368164, -0.026306152, -0.012001038, -0.036895752, -0.053955078, -0.10961914, -0.028579712, 0.1081543, -0.0009317398, -0.017349243, -0.001707077, -0.0078125, 0.021530151, 0.02859497, 0.025283813, -0.010116577, -0.029876709, -0.016036987, 0.009307861, -0.025466919, -0.02305603, -0.016281128, -0.039764404, -0.021347046, -0.040252686, -0.014770508, 0.038970947, -0.045806885, -0.026321411, -0.019805908, 0.029190063, -0.038146973, -0.055236816, 0.03527832, -0.016723633, 0.016296387, 0.064331055, 0.027282715, -0.03842163, 0.036376953, -0.023483276, 0.0390625, -0.0075798035, -0.03857422, 0.0647583, -0.019958496, 0.0023956299, 0.04272461, 0.0022258759, 0.0077590942, 0.04067993, -0.021453857, 0.011177063, -0.022369385, -0.003227234, -0.008125305, -0.012741089, 0.0048065186, 0.0049972534, 0.046051025, -0.008636475, -0.03579712, -0.031280518, -0.02708435, -0.032958984, -0.075927734, 0.008117676, -0.057739258, -0.03781128, -0.04711914, -0.00044560432, 0.0016059875, -0.0020427704, -0.01928711, 0.025131226, -0.040924072, 0.0073051453, -0.00037527084, 0.015930176, -0.016952515, 0.075683594, 0.03286743, 0.0034999847, -0.029403687, -0.028213501, -0.007980347, 0.044525146, 0.004623413, 0.005554199, 0.016647339, -0.0064582825, -0.015960693, -0.012634277, -0.009101868, -0.021713257, -0.01727295, 0.017181396, -0.05734253, -0.027786255, -0.011390686, -0.015213013, -0.020446777, 0.029006958, -0.029754639, -0.01449585, 0.010093689, -0.010055542, 0.009857178, 0.032104492, -0.005279541, 0.027679443, 0.0065574646, -0.02909851, 0.02217102, 0.019500732, -0.000045895576, 0.005836487, 0.051086426, 0.022598267, -0.014968872, -0.0026988983, 0.008651733, 0.005744934, 0.0066947937, -0.019302368, 0.015823364, 0.023284912, -0.024368286, -0.014465332, 0.0077209473, -0.011497498, -0.0014486313, -0.024398804, 0.01008606, -0.0041770935, 0.0003054142, -0.022476196, 0.00093126297, -0.01727295, 0.0066986084, 0.009124756, 0.010032654, -0.0069274902, -0.01777649, -0.0036468506, 0.04248047, -0.010787964, 0.0423584, -0.008262634, -0.011795044, 0.014228821, 0.012832642, -0.0011053085, 0.021896362, 0.012229919, -0.000068068504, 0.016479492, 0.035339355, 0.0071105957, -0.024337769, 0.011100769, -0.039855957, -0.022750854, 0.019256592, -0.015296936, 0.008285522, 0.020111084, 0.0082473755, -0.006538391, -0.016830444, -0.054779053, -0.033447266, 0.009643555, 0.016601562, -0.07208252, -0.018005371, -0.05041504, -0.028305054, 0.0061073303, 0.000770092, -0.0055007935, 0.051635742, 0.0056037903, 0.02168274, 0.020553589, -0.033172607, -0.010238647, 0.0049705505, 0.039855957, -0.012001038, 0.0022792816, 0.004032135, 0.00283432, 0.03643799, 0.03111267, 0.013267517, -0.03125, -0.008003235, -0.01852417, 0.0047836304, 0.0045547485, -0.032287598, -0.0024986267, -0.027557373, 0.05215454, 0.027770996, 0.044647217, 0.00027108192, -0.009162903, 0.0051498413, -0.007472992, -0.0012741089, -0.00020360947, -0.013442993, 0.032409668, 0.011947632, -0.018051147, 0.04727173, 0.009155273, -0.03353882, -0.013687134, 0.057769775, 0.00040268898, 0.02015686, 0.040771484, -0.01977539, 0.014595032, 0.03137207, -0.008201599, -0.055114746, -0.047668457, -0.011558533, -0.024627686, -0.02104187, -0.02017212, 0.06072998, -0.025939941, -0.013023376, 0.033111572, -0.021575928, 0.06591797, -0.039031982, 0.025939941, -0.0579834, 0.060058594, -0.003768921, -0.02633667, 0.025863647, 0.024276733, -0.055633545, 0.027359009, 0.026947021, 0.009483337, -0.006252289, 0.014884949, -0.022155762, 0.0041236877, 0.0013141632, -0.0068473816, -0.0027503967, 0.025543213, -0.0021858215, -0.040618896, -0.020477295, -0.021774292, -0.0023422241, -0.0072669983, 0.08343506, -0.025924683, 0.011169434, -0.008087158, -0.0151901245, -0.0090789795, 0.001748085, -0.0014028549, -0.026855469, -0.022125244, 0.030944824, 0.011619568, -0.02784729, 0.054626465, 0.016647339, -0.064697266, 0.07873535, 0.012916565, 0.023971558, -0.033050537, -0.022964478, 0.023590088, 0.018798828, 0.06500244, 0.041656494, -0.033813477, 0.0035972595, -0.0030651093, 0.039855957, -0.0077590942, -0.045562744, 0.054260254, 0.0032367706, -0.022155762, -0.0093307495, -0.0057258606, -0.02709961, 0.014465332, -0.08538818, 0.048461914, -0.027801514, 0.037719727, 0.029159546, -0.01789856, 0.0034713745, 0.026321411, -0.032226562, 0.040496826, -0.025772095, -0.01676941, 0.046417236, 0.0013151169, -0.034210205, 0.019241333, 0.005218506, -0.006755829, -0.0031261444, 0.018814087, -0.04058838, 0.042114258, 0.022888184, -0.04534912, 0.0072517395, 0.010284424, 0.021087646, 0.0060424805, -0.004108429, -0.033325195, -0.014312744, 0.009361267, 0.054504395, 0.012680054, -0.0050086975, -0.008552551, 0.0010643005, 0.06591797, -0.004535675, -0.044006348, 0.0054130554, 0.002067566, -0.036590576, -0.03967285, -0.019073486, 0.029724121, -0.042999268, 0.01852417, 0.0074501038, -0.021728516, -0.03149414, -0.066467285, 0.02758789, -0.013465881, 0.0032043457, 0.018188477, 0.019760132, -0.002067566, 0.08178711, -0.036895752, -0.0050468445, 0.010032654, 0.010803223, 0.009735107, -0.019744873, 0.0146102905, 0.014335632, 0.03945923, 0.04309082, -0.000072062016, 0.051635742, 0.024108887, 0.020065308, -0.007785797, -0.082214355, -0.020126343, -0.015823364, -0.017501831, 0.014564514, -0.043914795, 0.017028809, 0.03555298, -0.059417725, 0.0067253113, 0.014671326, 0.03387451, 0.021713257, 0.016983032, -0.04663086, -0.0043296814, -0.0010128021 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1809.10756v2
An Introduction to Probabilistic Programming
Jan-Willem van de Meent, Brooks Paige, Hongseok Yang, Frank Wood
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL
This book is a graduate-level introduction to probabilistic programming. It not only provides a thorough background for anyone wishing to use a probabilistic programming system, but also introduces the techniques needed to design and build these systems. It is aimed at people who have an undergraduate-level understanding of either or, ideally, both probabilistic machine learning and programming languages. We start with a discussion of model-based reasoning and explain why conditioning is a foundational computation central to the fields of probabilistic machine learning and artificial intelligence. We then introduce a first-order probabilistic programming language (PPL) whose programs correspond to graphical models with a known, finite, set of random variables. In the context of this PPL we introduce fundamental inference algorithms and describe how they can be implemented. We then turn to higher-order probabilistic programming languages. Programs in such languages can define models with dynamic computation graphs, which may not instantiate the same set of random variables in each execution. Inference requires methods that generate samples by repeatedly evaluating the program. Foundational algorithms for this kind of language are discussed in the context of an interface between program executions and an inference controller. Finally we consider the intersection of probabilistic and differentiable programming. We begin with a discussion of automatic differentiation, and how it can be used to implement efficient inference methods based on Hamiltonian Monte Carlo. We then discuss gradient-based maximum likelihood estimation in programs that are parameterized using neural networks, how to amortize inference using by learning neural approximations to the program posterior, and how language features impact the design of deep probabilistic programming systems.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1809.10756v2
2021-10-19T10:56:50
2018-09-27T20:44:23
{ "title": [ -0.040985107, 0.002565384, -0.040771484, -0.06591797, 0.026657104, 0.017837524, -0.049072266, -0.017730713, 0.0034427643, -0.012466431, -0.020401001, 0.018692017, -0.038208008, -0.03878784, -0.008895874, -0.0025043488, -0.009712219, 0.007041931, -0.040008545, -0.039093018, -0.009773254, -0.04989624, 0.014274597, 0.039764404, 0.047424316, -0.021514893, -0.040252686, 0.011108398, -0.03955078, -0.03237915, -0.0104599, 0.019866943, 0.018005371, 0.025390625, 0.04196167, 0.024841309, -0.029968262, 0.018981934, 0.01197052, 0.034942627, -0.015586853, 0.021377563, -0.031402588, -0.03692627, -0.0647583, -0.007156372, -0.075683594, -0.007270813, -0.013252258, 0.064575195, 0.021560669, 0.009254456, -0.036224365, 0.041931152, 0.03161621, -0.023498535, 0.0042915344, -0.031829834, 0.023376465, 0.0904541, 0.018997192, -0.033996582, 0.013900757, -0.025848389, -0.04156494, -0.018341064, -0.011253357, 0.048065186, 0.06555176, 0.0051841736, -0.0345459, 0.017730713, 0.00050258636, 0.025848389, -0.0345459, -0.028778076, 0.061401367, 0.012458801, 0.010513306, 0.0035247803, 0.017318726, -0.0047950745, -0.0046806335, -0.014205933, 0.0047035217, -0.044403076, -0.012001038, -0.0020542145, -0.014015198, -0.055419922, 0.0023708344, 0.04144287, -0.012908936, 0.0025405884, -0.03982544, 0.013702393, -0.018936157, 0.027893066, -0.0042800903, -0.012084961, -0.023147583, 0.021881104, -0.039367676, -0.01033783, -0.012229919, 0.039489746, 0.004096985, -0.04989624, -0.018249512, 0.038146973, 0.003829956, 0.010276794, -0.015014648, 0.007980347, 0.011039734, 0.018493652, -0.0036830902, -0.0052375793, -0.004673004, 0.00806427, -0.011894226, -0.032562256, -0.010093689, -0.029525757, 0.02267456, -0.02848816, -0.06427002, 0.030303955, -0.04626465, 0.042053223, 0.017623901, 0.014709473, -0.10498047, -0.058135986, -0.048461914, 0.025283813, -0.0074882507, 0.0055351257, -0.0023937225, 0.000682354, 0.005355835, -0.03488159, 0.006454468, 0.018753052, 0.006259918, 0.001326561, 0.06323242, 0.0065994263, -0.026184082, -0.014083862, -0.008544922, 0.017791748, 0.045684814, 0.013244629, -0.06750488, 0.00095653534, -0.12866211, -0.0008187294, 0.024978638, 0.018127441, 0.04623413, 0.013328552, -0.011230469, 0.012550354, 0.057617188, -0.010910034, -0.052978516, 0.03765869, -0.0024261475, 0.017196655, -0.034423828, 0.008277893, 0.0211792, -0.008392334, -0.015075684, 0.03213501, 0.057769775, 0.012512207, 0.05114746, -0.017288208, 0.011428833, -0.0032844543, 0.06665039, 0.032714844, -0.06488037, -0.04034424, -0.003168106, -0.031066895, 0.039245605, 0.016296387, -0.017715454, 0.015312195, -0.059906006, -0.043060303, -0.04058838, -0.016281128, 0.020126343, 0.027297974, -0.0078086853, 0.0050468445, -0.015548706, 0.004852295, -0.019454956, 0.027282715, 0.026733398, -0.02067566, -0.008232117, 0.014060974, -0.025878906, 0.062072754, 0.06317139, 0.009346008, -0.04360962, 0.03817749, 0.014602661, -0.059570312, 0.025848389, 0.0006685257, -0.0032100677, 0.00015187263, -0.022216797, -0.009811401, -0.012458801, 0.082214355, 0.008270264, 0.0041503906, 0.0012588501, -0.03845215, 0.050842285, 0.020355225, 0.070373535, -0.043701172, 0.014572144, -0.005504608, -0.013572693, -0.00868988, -0.013877869, 0.027679443, -0.004108429, 0.009346008, 0.00818634, -0.013298035, -0.004295349, 0.03604126, 0.05871582, 0.0061149597, 0.019104004, 0.011207581, 0.02104187, 0.003288269, 0.0619812, 0.03463745, 0.09716797, 0.01737976, 0.0037651062, 0.09124756, 0.01361084, 0.016967773, -0.0008597374, 0.017791748, -0.017303467, -0.0078125, -0.015670776, 0.0018558502, -0.03967285, -0.0020332336, -0.035003662, 0.0007801056, 0.00844574, 0.015029907, 0.028823853, -0.0395813, 0.013656616, -0.027359009, -0.0017528534, 0.0017795563, -0.013313293, 0.026763916, 0.0077400208, -0.07684326, -0.023803711, 0.011772156, 0.021453857, 0.016036987, 0.0062217712, -0.00793457, 0.020217896, -0.005088806, 0.011352539, -0.0135650635, 0.049316406, 0.02909851, 0.023620605, -0.021606445, -0.0028762817, -0.0041885376, 0.062683105, 0.06994629, -0.020202637, 0.03225708, -0.06121826, 0.02835083, 0.034332275, -0.015106201, -0.004306793, 0.045837402, 0.0071640015, 0.03970337, -0.0070381165, 0.007904053, -0.021972656, 0.0385437, 0.0076675415, -0.078308105, 0.0023460388, -0.040802002, 0.024810791, -0.038085938, -0.02204895, -0.006538391, 0.07409668, -0.020751953, -0.033081055, -0.009315491, -0.0031547546, -0.032928467, -0.027297974, -0.03652954, -0.034576416, 0.019577026, 0.037384033, 0.021102905, -0.034057617, -0.008674622, -0.007820129, -0.0004107952, -0.026382446, 0.008834839, -0.025756836, 0.0005636215, -0.007587433, -0.002243042, 0.050323486, -0.055267334, -0.019119263, -0.042114258, 0.0016403198, 0.012054443, -0.029724121, 0.0026855469, 0.04849243, -0.015716553, -0.05899048, 0.02633667, 0.05618286, -0.041107178, 0.001750946, 0.043762207, 0.03414917, -0.026290894, 0.03933716, -0.0037345886, -0.009796143, -0.036254883, -0.025436401, -0.04522705, 0.003967285, -0.03060913, -0.020767212, 0.07965088, -0.06896973, -0.031082153, -0.0154418945, 0.010673523, -0.006919861, 0.037628174, -0.0035324097, -0.019927979, -0.0413208, -0.018203735, 0.002380371, -0.0015592575, -0.022491455, -0.0040512085, 0.08300781, 0.020187378, 0.042510986, 0.0017433167, 0.06100464, -0.010574341, -0.0055007935, -0.01876831, -0.00011372566, 0.0093307495, -0.0014333725, 0.021331787, 0.003484726, -0.04168701, -0.06384277, -0.0099487305, 0.010528564, 0.0024700165, -0.029174805, 0.010421753, -0.043304443, -0.0035648346, -0.021362305, -0.031021118, 0.035125732, 0.06750488, 0.011558533, 0.016143799, 0.009536743, -0.016921997, 0.019744873, -0.038146973, -0.06652832, 0.030883789, 0.0013113022, -0.06488037, -0.013031006, -0.024810791, -0.044036865, -0.020126343, -0.013572693, 0.004096985, 0.035064697, 0.04736328, 0.015670776, -0.04562378, -0.018981934, -0.027999878, -0.02960205, -0.032226562, -0.0035114288, -0.030700684, -0.0021800995, 0.031463623, 0.021591187, 0.004673004, -0.012504578, -0.0043258667, 0.0011930466, 0.03237915, 0.005569458, -0.0181427, 0.005290985, -0.0012807846, -0.012886047, -0.012535095, -0.025436401, -0.008522034, -0.0082092285, 0.019989014, 0.002023697, 0.080078125, 0.0357666, 0.021759033, -0.017501831, -0.009559631, -0.0024795532, -0.03668213, -0.055023193, 0.0045166016, 0.024932861, 0.022750854, 0.018844604, 0.0063705444, 0.012557983, -0.007896423, -0.023086548, 0.0073280334, 0.022399902, 0.010032654, -0.017654419, 0.033416748, -0.021972656, 0.027282715, -0.03741455, 0.02571106, 0.032165527, -0.0041122437, 0.015602112, -0.07080078, 0.009292603, -0.0020618439, -0.13098145, -0.0065956116, -0.0029621124, -0.0025749207, -0.015670776, -0.048858643, 0.013847351, 0.022216797, -0.036712646, -0.001912117, -0.017425537, -0.058135986, -0.020858765, -0.038391113, -0.03414917, 0.06060791, 0.01612854, 0.013389587, 0.015945435, 0.018478394, -0.013206482, -0.058013916, -0.0066719055, -0.03857422, 0.019195557, -0.0501709, -0.0015010834, 0.04586792, -0.028381348, 0.031921387, 0.017868042, 0.04840088, -0.026229858, -0.015556335, 0.01713562, 0.02659607, -0.02053833, 0.019638062, 0.047698975, -0.02571106, -0.06365967, 0.0021629333, -0.010032654, -0.012626648, 0.016448975, 0.00020086765, -0.013130188, -0.005897522, 0.023605347, 0.039398193, -0.016860962, -0.0053596497, 0.02798462, -0.022888184, -0.0017910004, 0.021224976, 0.0143585205, 0.015625, 0.007411957, 0.010810852, 0.013877869, 0.023010254, -0.037750244, -0.027908325, -0.0070114136, 0.023895264, -0.0289917, -0.0041236877, -0.08520508, 0.00466156, 0.0058898926, -0.008049011, -0.02494812, 0.026748657, 0.037384033, -0.046173096, -0.029937744, 0.008598328, 0.025680542, -0.008148193, 0.015960693, -0.058624268, 0.0007176399, -0.0046958923, -0.05496216, -0.03817749, -0.016281128, -0.010223389, 0.018981934, -0.000872612, -0.029586792, 0.015777588, 0.030044556, 0.077941895, 0.048736572, 0.0062408447, -0.06311035, 0.026016235, -0.017089844, -0.022109985, 0.008483887, -0.027862549, -0.014633179, -0.01966858, 0.03656006, -0.028060913, -0.017593384, -0.027145386, 0.01713562, 0.0046691895, 0.05532837, 0.012306213, 0.017486572, 0.026168823, -0.0021076202, 0.011390686, 0.012496948, -0.031707764, -0.052734375, 0.006877899, 0.041290283, 0.022033691, -0.011436462, 0.032104492, 0.045318604, 0.02204895, 0.006340027, -0.003004074, 0.019989014, 0.010108948, -0.025390625, 0.017929077, -0.007858276, -0.011291504, 0.017547607, 0.010032654, 0.04638672, -0.052246094, 0.038024902, 0.010696411, 0.029037476, 0.008476257, -0.048431396, 0.028564453, -0.026260376, 0.032043457, -0.088256836, -0.048309326, -0.008895874, 0.05923462, -0.06506348, 0.005279541, -0.011268616, -0.0007252693, 0.019943237, 0.045959473, 0.033172607, -0.02357483, -0.013824463, -0.026641846, -0.011436462, -0.020629883, -0.061462402, 0.015235901, -0.006427765, 0.046203613, -0.039916992, 0.03253174, -0.05581665, -0.0059051514, 0.007736206, 0.0023212433, 0.015899658, -0.1003418, -0.018814087, 0.021972656, 0.024749756, -0.011779785, -0.038146973, -0.009864807, 0.054595947, 0.048187256, 0.0064735413, -0.004184723, 0.030654907, -0.03491211, -0.011108398, -0.00793457, 0.018249512, -0.029663086, 0.0024814606, 0.002653122, -0.038909912, -0.04159546, 0.021118164, 0.013465881, 0.0027217865, 0.010421753, -0.04522705, 0.003396988, -0.0087509155, 0.00630188, 0.016311646, -0.0021343231, -0.05508423, -0.01309967, 0.0054016113, -0.04522705, 0.03353882, 0.027664185, -0.0007481575, -0.03387451, 0.042816162, -0.02520752, 0.0087890625, 0.01902771, 0.016738892, -0.012031555, -0.003829956, 0.04901123, -0.030181885, 0.03488159, -0.05102539, -0.0001475811, 0.052764893, 0.02720642, -0.041625977, -0.0022258759, -0.004463196, -0.066223145, -0.048065186, 0.010055542, 0.0138549805, -0.016052246, -0.033233643, -0.028244019, -0.0040283203, -0.036193848, 0.0143966675, 0.002035141, -0.03225708, 0.022903442, 0.026000977, 0.0058288574, -0.017929077, 0.014663696, -0.006336212, -0.0052108765, -0.0053710938, -0.012741089, -0.00035476685, -0.0008382797, -0.020889282, -0.008415222, -0.046539307, 0.0042037964, 0.020126343, 0.018157959, -0.006664276, 0.017913818, 0.024139404, 0.0029468536, 0.010658264, 0.0041122437, 0.052825928, -0.033233643, -0.022338867, 0.023666382, -0.010864258, 0.0059776306, 0.0949707, -0.010345459, -0.017837524, -0.062927246, -0.03744507, -0.030807495, -0.002161026, 0.024490356, 0.014472961, 0.029006958, -0.017425537, 0.011009216, 0.012672424, -0.014381409, -0.016586304, 0.021835327, 0.017837524, -0.028503418, 0.015434265, 0.008132935, 0.00065660477, -0.04345703, 0.007320404, -0.0010690689, 0.0010719299, 0.025939941, -0.021713257, 0.0065078735, -0.010444641, -0.040252686, 0.054504395, -0.008071899, -0.014778137, 0.061065674, -0.041137695, 0.044891357, 0.025238037, 0.02861023, 0.043914795, 0.0435791, 0.030838013, 0.0016975403, 0.038726807, -0.0077819824, 0.012519836, -0.013038635, -0.02178955, -0.057373047, -0.028045654, -0.053222656, 0.00573349, 0.01789856, -0.0037231445, -0.012107849, 0.010414124, -0.004737854, 0.003932953, 0.040649414, 0.0012369156, 0.05319214, 0.008644104, -0.009864807, 0.0077934265, 0.023162842, 0.0013542175, 0.030212402, 0.011688232, -0.010009766, -0.027191162, 0.005218506, 0.015586853, 0.0098724365, -0.008277893, -0.030548096, 0.0048828125, -0.04232788, 0.02748108, -0.012397766, 0.041656494, 0.07086182, 0.04244995, 0.019958496, -0.043884277, 0.00522995, -0.017807007, -0.05065918, 0.027328491, 0.02583313, -0.06964111, 0.026794434, -0.037841797, -0.023452759, 0.01687622, 0.029449463, 0.047332764, -0.05432129, -0.050201416, -0.010284424, 0.041748047, 0.0056762695, 0.023223877, -0.036376953, -0.004627228, -0.011421204, 0.03125, 0.014297485, 0.0395813, 0.007926941, 0.02709961, -0.018341064, -0.015167236, 0.014045715, 0.0064315796, -0.006855011, 0.02178955, -0.02796936, -0.004524231, -0.031204224, -0.052856445, 0.021881104, -0.020477295, -0.043945312, -0.020080566, 0.026885986, 0.038848877, 0.045043945, 0.057159424, 0.020736694, -0.03161621, -0.0024986267, -0.06237793, 0.03060913, 0.043640137, -0.017593384, 0.06689453, -0.045532227, -0.038879395, 0.07745361, -0.051116943, 0.056884766, -0.07196045, 0.0053215027, -0.022018433, 0.033966064, 0.01689148, -0.054626465, -0.04055786, -0.02003479, -0.00079345703, -0.014213562, -0.010505676, -0.055511475, -0.034118652, -0.0071868896, 0.024612427, 0.00504303, -0.011390686, -0.0018625259, -0.033691406, -0.07763672, -0.01852417, -0.006816864, 0.016204834, -0.04095459, -0.016616821, 0.019714355, -0.028076172, -0.023773193, -0.025039673, -0.030563354, -0.022537231, -0.019927979, -0.023376465, 0.016403198, 0.02999878, -0.023284912, -0.0075531006, 0.021759033, 0.0038452148, -0.019424438, -0.002035141, 0.0025691986, -0.05117798, -0.012176514, -0.0035686493, -0.014305115, 0.015625, 0.0115737915, -0.017913818, 0.0043907166, 0.011657715, -0.03527832, -0.07659912, -0.022323608, 0.0022773743, -0.015533447, -0.05178833, 0.009117126, 0.030761719, 0.025039673, -0.044921875, -0.012123108, 0.03692627, 0.003036499, -0.01184845, 0.05670166, 0.023162842, 0.010223389, 0.018234253, 0.066467285, -0.0016622543, -0.06921387, -0.033355713, -0.028411865, 0.04046631, 0.060333252, -0.00970459, -0.014533997, 0.046691895, -0.013938904, -0.0088272095, -0.029876709, 0.013328552, -0.014625549, 0.0017795563, 0.02848816, -0.020843506, -0.009124756, -0.050476074, -0.004383087, -0.0044136047, -0.01512146, 0.002046585, 0.01991272, -0.04638672, 0.07598877, -0.012550354, -0.038482666, 0.017745972, 0.017684937, 0.015007019, 0.03048706, -0.028121948, -0.0006713867, -0.012771606, -0.008361816, -0.000446558, 0.019622803, 0.02015686, -0.04208374, 0.0129852295, -0.03338623, -0.023590088, 0.004623413, -0.033691406, 0.039215088, -0.030441284, -0.0064315796, -0.022079468, -0.040405273, -0.0005493164, -0.0017938614, 0.009407043, -0.041870117, -0.036895752, 0.0062713623, 0.04711914, 0.0014257431 ], "summary": [ -0.018600464, -0.010536194, -0.029830933, -0.044952393, -0.047912598, 0.0049209595, -0.0725708, 0.01411438, -0.011528015, -0.031585693, -0.052642822, -0.0024795532, -0.01448822, -0.0284729, 0.058502197, -0.05065918, 0.012191772, -0.015899658, -0.024124146, -0.0357666, 0.033843994, -0.033111572, 0.0010967255, 0.058380127, 0.023666382, -0.018295288, 0.015197754, 0.024337769, 0.03918457, 0.022979736, 0.026504517, -0.06439209, 0.016708374, 0.015296936, 0.0057907104, 0.06384277, 0.010032654, 0.01525116, 0.03302002, 0.004989624, -0.023895264, 0.03173828, 0.007095337, -0.016494751, -0.03277588, -0.01096344, -0.055664062, -0.012954712, 0.011154175, 0.038879395, -0.005508423, 0.039154053, -0.0077552795, 0.022750854, 0.009643555, -0.014572144, 0.028244019, -0.070617676, 0.015220642, 0.0619812, 0.010978699, -0.0073890686, 0.0020122528, -0.05770874, 0.013114929, -0.03137207, -0.02507019, 0.035980225, 0.031402588, 0.01348114, 0.008155823, 0.01499939, -0.00012612343, -0.01361084, -0.037200928, -0.00022387505, 0.059295654, 0.021942139, -0.024810791, -0.006877899, 0.01940918, 0.027908325, 0.03338623, -0.030563354, 0.0013389587, -0.017807007, 0.006126404, -0.0044021606, 0.0128479, -0.0003437996, -0.00504303, 0.05126953, -0.011657715, -0.010864258, -0.01499176, -0.032684326, -0.055419922, -0.008590698, 0.018341064, 0.036743164, -0.012084961, -0.017028809, 0.021881104, -0.033203125, -0.023849487, 0.06137085, 0.017837524, -0.07147217, -0.052703857, -0.008293152, -0.0066375732, -0.061920166, -0.031219482, -0.038513184, -0.0055656433, 0.048461914, -0.0309906, 0.023834229, 0.001912117, 0.036132812, -0.042633057, -0.019821167, -0.020599365, 0.0010652542, 0.03414917, -0.0107803345, -0.0036811829, 0.041412354, -0.02418518, 0.079833984, 0.017074585, -0.01651001, -0.03265381, -0.0017757416, -0.04272461, -0.013420105, -0.01965332, 0.00024700165, -0.002614975, -0.00945282, 0.050933838, -0.021606445, -0.0022010803, 0.052520752, -0.00012046099, 0.022949219, 0.012107849, 0.0345459, 0.012252808, -0.058441162, 0.028259277, -0.008964539, 0.009300232, 0.022659302, -0.037231445, 0.004299164, -0.055847168, 0.015945435, 0.015808105, 0.022399902, 0.012954712, 0.012054443, 0.018249512, 0.048431396, 0.03250122, -0.0115737915, 0.014167786, 0.011436462, -0.0030822754, -0.033111572, -0.027008057, 0.03781128, -0.0025081635, -0.022979736, 0.0003311634, 0.0062217712, 0.005622864, 0.01158905, -0.014305115, 0.044403076, 0.020446777, -0.019485474, 0.028289795, 0.006000519, -0.017303467, -0.03277588, -0.00092697144, 0.004585266, 0.0569458, 0.017944336, 0.0019741058, -0.027160645, -0.027893066, 0.005054474, -0.016113281, -0.013595581, -0.050201416, -0.006591797, -0.014022827, 0.011978149, -0.03640747, 0.028030396, -0.027740479, -0.0024204254, -0.054382324, 0.015426636, -0.02204895, 0.047576904, -0.009597778, 0.028381348, 0.01499939, -0.015289307, -0.024261475, 0.03479004, 0.007534027, -0.038391113, 0.030593872, -0.02192688, 0.010650635, -0.027069092, 0.0012960434, 0.008888245, -0.036743164, 0.039733887, 0.014587402, 0.007701874, -0.028442383, 0.0075683594, 0.04284668, 0.01876831, 0.023956299, -0.010040283, -0.036590576, -0.03375244, -0.036315918, 0.010826111, -0.024459839, -0.03100586, 0.0059890747, 0.03390503, 0.027526855, -0.009124756, -0.007232666, -0.008628845, 0.038879395, 0.01826477, 0.03062439, -0.024139404, -0.010940552, -0.02394104, 0.033233643, -0.005065918, 0.055267334, -0.053375244, 0.014091492, 0.059326172, 0.0028457642, 0.0140686035, 0.0039138794, -0.010467529, -0.001209259, 0.025405884, 0.005958557, 0.0018405914, -0.020996094, -0.013618469, -0.0018081665, -0.0028762817, 0.018936157, -0.034240723, -0.016921997, -0.09051514, -0.029220581, -0.057006836, -0.06286621, -0.023971558, -0.015853882, 0.057891846, -0.018051147, -0.07849121, -0.007534027, -0.0119018555, 0.0013933182, -0.015312195, 0.022842407, -0.008163452, 0.020721436, 0.010795593, 0.01071167, 0.013397217, 0.04296875, 0.0041503906, -0.005771637, 0.018096924, -0.023468018, -0.018325806, -0.020050049, 0.03768921, 0.010375977, -0.01965332, -0.020004272, 0.03616333, -0.035583496, 0.01991272, 0.0013828278, 0.051239014, 0.0110321045, -0.012710571, 0.01638794, 0.01625061, 0.0063705444, 0.054626465, 0.009681702, 0.038208008, -0.008460999, -0.033569336, -0.0047950745, 0.032348633, -0.041046143, -0.020812988, 0.084350586, -0.029586792, 0.010658264, -0.033569336, -0.024551392, -0.051818848, 0.0051498413, -0.014694214, 0.0008802414, -0.014533997, -0.023651123, -0.010437012, -0.03186035, -0.014434814, -0.013023376, -0.007713318, 0.0017786026, -0.012229919, -0.010559082, -0.021499634, 0.012878418, 0.018096924, 0.021606445, -0.022491455, -0.07745361, 0.012123108, 0.04623413, -0.024597168, -0.04083252, 0.021133423, 0.02557373, 0.010482788, -0.050109863, 0.024368286, -0.04626465, -0.007217407, 0.074523926, -0.0014238358, -0.05633545, -0.052825928, 0.02305603, -0.01449585, -0.035339355, -0.06939697, 0.013885498, -0.004436493, -0.007419586, -0.05508423, -0.01991272, 0.015808105, -0.032470703, -0.014503479, 0.016830444, 0.003250122, -0.00178051, 0.02848816, 0.06719971, 0.006412506, 0.0009698868, 0.050048828, 0.038024902, 0.037872314, -0.013397217, 0.015945435, 0.05090332, 0.024597168, 0.053649902, -0.013366699, 0.07910156, -0.021743774, 0.03729248, 0.005268097, 0.061462402, -0.042144775, 0.0057373047, 0.0048942566, -0.020965576, 0.00667572, 0.018798828, -0.025283813, 0.018707275, 0.02734375, 0.011253357, 0.04257202, -0.039367676, 0.059265137, -0.0049934387, -0.012573242, 0.00037384033, 0.0011014938, 0.044036865, -0.036102295, 0.016204834, -0.010238647, 0.0206604, -0.05807495, 0.03363037, 0.030151367, -0.018661499, -0.0713501, -0.014625549, 0.055023193, -0.0041046143, -0.02619934, -0.026565552, -0.015617371, -0.006061554, 0.04067993, 0.0015087128, -0.018371582, -0.033996582, -0.021957397, -0.022033691, -0.011436462, -0.01574707, 0.040893555, 0.0057868958, 0.010864258, 0.01739502, -0.025650024, -0.015365601, 0.005393982, 0.013954163, 0.021499634, -0.0042495728, 0.006816864, 0.011528015, -0.008399963, -0.01701355, -0.027816772, -0.017456055, 0.007385254, 0.052124023, 0.03555298, 0.011741638, 0.049865723, 0.016159058, 0.05368042, 0.030426025, 0.011581421, -0.015899658, -0.03503418, 0.03567505, 0.018157959, 0.03050232, 0.009117126, -0.055664062, 0.008377075, -0.013763428, -0.009567261, 0.004459381, 0.004436493, -0.05130005, -0.0012960434, 0.0017251968, 0.006958008, 0.014228821, 0.027328491, 0.020217896, 0.010276794, -0.021881104, 0.022079468, 0.0029621124, -0.026977539, -0.02859497, 0.030731201, -0.059936523, -0.050720215, 0.012069702, 0.050231934, 0.056030273, -0.023925781, 0.038208008, 0.028442383, -0.017532349, 0.0024166107, -0.0050582886, 0.06549072, 0.0044784546, -0.04812622, -0.013084412, -0.012039185, 0.02279663, -0.0132751465, -0.03894043, 0.051605225, 0.05960083, -0.033355713, -0.014755249, -0.018554688, 0.007411957, -0.080078125, 0.08190918, 0.037902832, -0.00617218, 0.03564453, 0.0066719055, 0.05328369, -0.012229919, -0.01864624, 0.016784668, 0.04714966, -0.03869629, 0.00381279, 0.06121826, -0.005958557, -0.042388916, 0.031829834, -0.007713318, -0.02230835, 0.041381836, 0.018005371, -0.021606445, -0.013130188, -0.0020389557, 0.004673004, -0.04425049, -0.027404785, 0.0074539185, 0.025802612, -0.040222168, -0.04852295, -0.014076233, 0.05758667, 0.00037026405, 0.044158936, 0.006427765, 0.028518677, -0.05130005, 0.0018053055, -0.019424438, -0.007419586, -0.024520874, -0.008155823, -0.030563354, 0.06958008, -0.010261536, 0.009300232, -0.031280518, 0.037078857, 0.005203247, -0.022949219, -0.00066041946, -0.0012111664, 0.05697632, 0.0007543564, 0.062347412, -0.025131226, -0.041381836, -0.013679504, -0.06112671, -0.03050232, -0.08709717, -0.03387451, -0.028182983, 0.027816772, -0.0670166, 0.015052795, -0.0074386597, 0.084228516, 0.030380249, 0.02947998, -0.07476807, -0.0082473755, -0.020843506, 0.024734497, -0.0077590942, 0.03479004, -0.010467529, -0.008918762, -0.016448975, -0.015991211, -0.015472412, -0.061187744, 0.0023612976, 0.015327454, -0.0024871826, 0.029556274, 0.023208618, 0.0054092407, 0.002527237, 0.03152466, 0.016342163, -0.011329651, -0.033935547, 0.03717041, 0.01121521, 0.05117798, 0.00040459633, 0.0032463074, 0.016799927, -0.025619507, 0.0090408325, 0.03201294, 0.016494751, -0.027404785, -0.0032920837, 0.014945984, 0.030700684, 0.0054016113, 0.034118652, -0.0007009506, 0.023544312, 0.008110046, -0.007987976, 0.019714355, -0.0068626404, 0.0017976761, -0.0211792, 0.0054244995, 0.010528564, -0.0109939575, -0.06768799, -0.03555298, -0.017425537, 0.049468994, -0.03488159, -0.04864502, -0.02229309, -0.022232056, 0.022903442, 0.01259613, -0.011795044, -0.061950684, 0.010444641, -0.0034179688, -0.015090942, 0.011711121, -0.026824951, -0.01701355, -0.0017585754, 0.032592773, -0.033569336, 0.04333496, 0.016159058, 0.011245728, -0.020599365, -0.039855957, 0.028686523, -0.075805664, -0.081604004, -0.022628784, -0.010864258, -0.006702423, 0.0071640015, -0.019683838, -0.026123047, 0.015533447, -0.032684326, -0.017974854, -0.0054016113, -0.031433105, -0.00819397, -0.0033607483, 0.021392822, -0.0463562, -0.046417236, 0.018981934, -0.07922363, -0.008140564, -0.0024471283, -0.042297363, 0.034698486, -0.003692627, -0.016921997, 0.04159546, -0.0041160583, -0.007457733, -0.0026741028, -0.0069999695, -0.009132385, 0.022872925, 0.0004093647, 0.012542725, 0.010536194, -0.009857178, 0.0047569275, -0.04522705, 0.066467285, -0.044067383, 0.008834839, -0.013000488, -0.010971069, -0.024124146, 0.0013751984, 0.038360596, -0.039886475, 0.026000977, -0.026062012, -0.0037841797, 0.009994507, 0.03012085, -0.042175293, -0.003873825, -0.031585693, -0.025009155, -0.056274414, -0.009025574, 0.0048599243, 0.049194336, -0.044921875, 0.036895752, -0.014274597, -0.053894043, -0.004360199, -0.016403198, -0.06628418, -0.008026123, -0.0045814514, -0.009498596, 0.015823364, -0.008132935, 0.009864807, 0.0012302399, -0.027023315, 0.02330017, -0.012802124, 0.023376465, -0.003774643, -0.027435303, -0.053894043, -0.012031555, 0.021148682, -0.009559631, 0.024871826, 0.0010852814, -0.00038647652, -0.041290283, 0.05215454, 0.011833191, 0.064575195, -0.0035972595, 0.058776855, -0.00017690659, 0.019882202, -0.05404663, -0.027709961, -0.0055122375, 0.06439209, -0.033569336, -0.029418945, 0.014518738, -0.00806427, -0.008804321, -0.0013170242, 0.0055007935, 0.01777649, 0.020935059, 0.0024108887, -0.015411377, -0.023864746, 0.019622803, -0.010482788, -0.04208374, 0.03704834, -0.006034851, 0.017028809, -0.02116394, -0.030517578, -0.019241333, -0.005004883, 0.019760132, -0.0050811768, 0.021743774, -0.020248413, -0.009246826, 0.0011196136, 0.007865906, 0.017974854, 0.04257202, -0.007888794, 0.018920898, 0.04650879, 0.004005432, -0.011253357, 0.01184845, 0.039978027, 0.01499939, -0.011672974, -0.010314941, 0.0043907166, 0.001493454, -0.064575195, -0.05444336, -0.043151855, 0.0075531006, 0.06149292, -0.07751465, -0.038085938, 0.06677246, -0.010528564, 0.0035953522, 0.048980713, -0.0110321045, 0.047790527, 0.004169464, 0.016464233, -0.011741638, 0.00642395, -0.021362305, -0.010566711, 0.027175903, 0.006958008, 0.0015296936, 0.02357483, 0.0060920715, 0.056243896, -0.040130615, -0.03479004, -0.105529785, 0.021316528, -0.061462402, 0.0043258667, -0.021209717, 0.020339966, 0.018798828, 0.015472412, -0.019577026, 0.0007748604, 0.017745972, 0.012229919, 0.003856659, -0.0099487305, -0.001832962, -0.0033035278, 0.0082473755, -0.0058059692, -0.01828003, 0.050750732, 0.058563232, 0.031219482, -0.0256958, 0.012336731, -0.0036258698, -0.012001038, -0.013473511, 0.03768921, -0.020843506, 0.01864624, -0.010414124, -0.055358887, 0.043395996, 0.006843567, 0.011314392, -0.011108398, -0.0055122375, -0.002084732, 0.021118164, 0.02293396, 0.00793457, 0.026550293, -0.03491211, -0.0043411255, -0.026367188, -0.030776978, -0.019226074, 0.012039185, -0.036132812, -0.0018625259, -0.01777649, 0.042938232, 0.08392334, 0.06262207, -0.03274536, 0.025299072, 0.0637207, -0.017349243, 0.041015625, 0.0016517639, 0.0053215027, 0.019927979, -0.010772705, 0.003522873, 0.041809082, 0.008277893, 0.032806396, -0.0058021545, 0.0016326904, -0.06665039, 0.055999756, -0.02960205, -0.05633545, 0.00040364265, -0.04373169, -0.0013570786, -0.0027179718, -0.020050049, -0.04849243, 0.011550903, -0.028244019, -0.00019717216, 0.018005371, 0.03845215, 0.057037354, -0.060028076, -0.015930176, 0.009536743, 0.06933594, 0.057617188, 0.014282227, 0.0013408661, 0.08935547, -0.0012798309, -0.040527344, -0.09887695, -0.040893555, -0.003829956, 0.083984375, -0.03186035, 0.043273926, 0.04562378, -0.0211792, -0.0552063, 0.049835205, -0.03363037, -0.010505676, 0.043273926, 0.043945312, -0.000685215, 0.0033683777, 0.026382446, -0.029312134, 0.0044174194, -0.048461914, -0.0010566711, -0.0033817291, 0.010246277, 0.000446558, -0.034973145, 0.00037765503, -0.005344391, -0.033569336, -0.034484863, -0.020477295, 0.013008118, 0.032226562, 0.008918762, -0.027526855, 0.057739258, -0.04019165, 0.013893127, -0.029556274, -0.012802124, -0.027404785, -0.0053482056, 0.009559631, -0.004459381, -0.00027418137, 0.019012451, 0.008758545, 0.057006836, 0.015014648, -0.048553467, 0.040100098, 0.007598877, -0.053497314, -0.01109314, -0.0061416626, 0.021743774, -0.04397583, -0.018173218, -0.03567505, -0.040771484, -0.033721924, -0.08618164, 0.007144928, -0.011138916, -0.04537964, 0.039520264, 0.025558472, -0.042785645, 0.07281494, -0.02861023, 0.009544373, -0.0029945374, 0.00074243546, 0.010040283, 0.002588272, 0.021133423, 0.0107803345, -0.060302734, 0.0004041195, 0.035614014, 0.020080566, 0.022445679, -0.050842285, 0.05496216, -0.10284424, -0.0015830994, -0.024810791, -0.007610321, 0.0057144165, -0.061187744, 0.023666382, -0.057891846, -0.011451721, 0.016723633, 0.016784668, -0.030960083, -0.010948181, -0.0075683594, 0.018798828, -0.019897461, 0.010765076 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1809.10788v1
Learning and Acting in Peripersonal Space: Moving, Reaching, and Grasping
Jonathan Juett, Benjamin Kuipers
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
The young infant explores its body, its sensorimotor system, and the immediately accessible parts of its environment, over the course of a few months creating a model of peripersonal space useful for reaching and grasping objects around it. Drawing on constraints from the empirical literature on infant behavior, we present a preliminary computational model of this learning process, implemented and evaluated on a physical robot. The learning agent explores the relationship between the configuration space of the arm, sensing joint angles through proprioception, and its visual perceptions of the hand and grippers. The resulting knowledge is represented as the peripersonal space (PPS) graph, where nodes represent states of the arm, edges represent safe movements, and paths represent safe trajectories from one pose to another. In our model, the learning process is driven by intrinsic motivation. When repeatedly performing an action, the agent learns the typical result, but also detects unusual outcomes, and is motivated to learn how to make those unusual results reliable. Arm motions typically leave the static background unchanged, but occasionally bump an object, changing its static position. The reach action is learned as a reliable way to bump and move an object in the environment. Similarly, once a reliable reach action is learned, it typically makes a quasi-static change in the environment, moving an object from one static position to another. The unusual outcome is that the object is accidentally grasped (thanks to the innate Palmar reflex), and thereafter moves dynamically with the hand. Learning to make grasps reliable is more complex than for reaches, but we demonstrate significant progress. Our current results are steps toward autonomous sensorimotor learning of motion, reaching, and grasping in peripersonal space, based on unguided exploration and intrinsic motivation.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1809.10788v1
2018-09-27T22:39:45
2018-09-27T22:39:45
{ "title": [ -0.0049819946, -0.0030765533, -0.010818481, -0.009185791, 0.0035629272, -0.02557373, 0.023849487, -0.02696228, -0.045684814, 0.035217285, -0.02494812, 0.029647827, -0.016738892, -0.017623901, -0.020706177, -0.0181427, 0.0049972534, 0.02722168, 0.017593384, -0.00024795532, -0.020324707, -0.00077342987, 0.044891357, 0.034332275, 0.022628784, -0.0048217773, -0.15612793, 0.017028809, -0.04522705, -0.014160156, -0.031402588, 0.03817749, 0.024963379, 0.015281677, 0.0021858215, -0.033447266, -0.014198303, 0.0019035339, -0.008041382, 0.027770996, 0.001996994, 0.007949829, -0.07922363, 0.010223389, -0.09106445, -0.0021705627, -0.06665039, 0.0013036728, -0.012527466, 0.013435364, 0.00051927567, 0.042938232, -0.014427185, 0.0368042, 0.008384705, 0.0056648254, -0.06384277, -0.053833008, 0.04220581, 0.092285156, 0.030807495, -0.077819824, 0.0061531067, -0.06286621, -0.023895264, -0.042419434, -0.057678223, 0.028778076, 0.0418396, 0.0084991455, 0.028152466, 0.0018415451, -0.00554657, -0.00793457, -0.03186035, -0.005027771, 0.05819702, 0.042053223, 0.009361267, -0.017745972, -0.0006456375, -0.020950317, 0.0038223267, -0.025131226, 0.010345459, -0.025680542, 0.004421234, -0.009895325, -0.025466919, -0.068115234, -0.018035889, -0.034484863, -0.010124207, -0.010635376, -0.047668457, -0.03451538, -0.049865723, -0.045928955, -0.0008983612, 0.00522995, -0.0062217712, 0.0056533813, -0.020767212, 0.0005311966, 0.006587982, -0.039001465, -0.0078125, -0.033477783, 0.015571594, 0.048675537, -0.058135986, 0.050842285, 0.00932312, 0.05090332, -0.038879395, -0.02709961, -0.030960083, 0.003200531, -0.018829346, 0.04714966, -0.02293396, -0.033355713, 0.011886597, 0.03933716, 0.04763794, 0.03427124, -0.023010254, 0.0036029816, -0.0045700073, 0.01751709, 0.0037384033, 0.03982544, -0.07537842, -0.044708252, -0.049072266, 0.043151855, 0.050048828, 0.004760742, -0.006515503, -0.0016851425, 0.0021324158, -0.023925781, -0.0178833, -0.007827759, 0.03527832, -0.004501343, 0.013023376, 0.010383606, -0.0076141357, -0.037841797, 0.045135498, -0.024429321, 0.011245728, 0.011421204, -0.0057754517, 0.01335144, -0.068603516, -0.003545761, 0.017196655, 0.011619568, 0.03665161, -0.00064611435, -0.021835327, 0.024276733, 0.01991272, 0.0045661926, -0.005973816, 0.019760132, 0.01525116, 0.08068848, -0.008476257, 0.011207581, -0.02633667, -0.014907837, -0.008621216, -0.014282227, 0.015327454, -0.010612488, 0.021499634, -0.012863159, 0.020202637, 0.0037002563, 0.0048828125, 0.048217773, -0.0135269165, -0.06958008, -0.0011587143, -0.07733154, 0.026992798, 0.005355835, -0.034301758, 0.05239868, -0.061706543, -0.029678345, -0.059783936, 0.015670776, 0.037994385, 0.036346436, -0.014671326, 0.01687622, 0.008171082, 0.012565613, 0.00039958954, -0.012649536, 0.009338379, -0.010604858, 0.0040245056, 0.022705078, 0.009170532, 0.019592285, 0.00982666, 0.00028705597, 0.0047454834, -0.038146973, -0.04119873, -0.016143799, 0.018707275, -0.012794495, -0.0047950745, -0.022140503, -0.024261475, -0.023223877, -0.019073486, 0.05883789, -0.0077438354, 0.0030918121, -0.00043606758, -0.017684937, 0.011039734, 0.021255493, 0.015129089, 0.0019836426, 0.0069885254, 0.025268555, -0.021026611, -0.025634766, -0.019592285, 0.021408081, 0.003753662, 0.004173279, 0.0058670044, -0.04727173, 0.010955811, 0.029266357, -0.007926941, -0.030700684, 0.015945435, 0.0009908676, -0.00907135, -0.007156372, 0.05834961, 0.04925537, 0.051361084, 0.06323242, 0.012268066, 0.054534912, -0.0011472702, -0.007850647, -0.006980896, 0.013069153, 0.02079773, 0.025466919, -0.0063095093, 0.025772095, -0.06945801, -0.0037441254, -0.029342651, -0.004623413, 0.01991272, -0.0015792847, 0.031204224, -0.049194336, -0.0015544891, -0.017929077, -0.007820129, -0.037322998, -0.033569336, 0.042419434, 0.0044174194, -0.06384277, -0.024505615, 0.008811951, 0.011627197, -0.009124756, -0.002960205, 0.013893127, 0.021514893, -0.024749756, 0.0028419495, 0.0048675537, 0.052490234, -0.0015697479, -0.005432129, 0.0069236755, 0.010047913, -0.02746582, 0.042144775, 0.070495605, -0.026138306, 0.04458618, -0.035186768, 0.016937256, 0.004776001, 0.007335663, 0.011703491, -0.022979736, 0.0008187294, 0.050872803, -0.014930725, -0.02911377, -0.010604858, 0.01965332, 0.0063552856, -0.03338623, -0.003271103, -0.027908325, 0.018417358, -0.013542175, -0.011810303, -0.012145996, 0.04751587, -0.04473877, 0.01108551, -0.02331543, -0.00011599064, -0.03894043, -0.027175903, -0.011352539, 0.036956787, 0.035125732, 0.05053711, 0.0814209, -0.03289795, -0.010192871, 0.0127334595, -0.008552551, 0.004673004, -0.019454956, -0.03074646, 0.010627747, 0.0007748604, -0.04425049, 0.014129639, -0.028564453, -0.006893158, -0.024551392, -0.024780273, 0.0209198, -0.00793457, -0.012817383, 0.019241333, -0.034362793, -0.025405884, 0.0011730194, 0.05697632, -0.020523071, -0.015235901, 0.05834961, 0.04876709, 0.0059127808, 0.038909912, 0.0385437, 0.029724121, -0.019317627, -0.031951904, -0.06951904, 0.005455017, 0.007091522, 0.03793335, 0.06933594, -0.06286621, 0.011222839, -0.078186035, 0.011886597, 0.021759033, 0.025344849, -0.01235199, -0.052703857, -0.04425049, -0.03277588, -0.03756714, 0.00039815903, -0.03326416, 0.029800415, 0.09667969, -0.0015096664, -0.0016489029, -0.007259369, 0.041046143, 0.018798828, -0.022018433, -0.047088623, -0.03491211, -0.009414673, -0.009864807, 0.008460999, -0.0112838745, -0.0473938, -0.06262207, -0.014717102, 0.021575928, -0.014877319, -0.031433105, 0.016860962, -0.049102783, 0.026931763, -0.019638062, -0.019439697, 0.03277588, 0.124694824, -0.010719299, -0.023239136, 0.016983032, -0.0413208, 0.034210205, -0.0010442734, -0.0552063, 0.028259277, -0.05505371, -0.011314392, 0.019195557, 0.0014457703, -0.027786255, -0.013084412, -0.043304443, 0.0018367767, 0.041931152, 0.049224854, 0.011672974, -0.023483276, -0.0016546249, -0.040924072, -0.010292053, 0.004951477, -0.026245117, -0.024871826, -0.031280518, -0.007980347, 0.015281677, -0.02217102, 0.0012025833, 0.026321411, 0.0015649796, 0.020492554, -0.024780273, 0.00077342987, 0.043640137, 0.011413574, -0.04840088, -0.03515625, -0.002155304, 0.029388428, -0.02128601, 0.0066375732, 0.019699097, 0.044952393, -0.0077590942, 0.0066566467, -0.009536743, -0.025924683, 0.016555786, -0.007949829, -0.06463623, 0.009391785, 0.013328552, -0.016418457, 0.035308838, -0.023773193, -0.0010843277, 0.008644104, -0.030258179, 0.039764404, -0.014526367, -0.003967285, 0.018463135, 0.010498047, -0.04699707, -0.014305115, 0.0026474, 0.046417236, 0.008392334, -0.006111145, -0.03945923, -0.008560181, 0.0019283295, 0.0104904175, -0.06317139, 0.0143966675, 0.005466461, -0.039093018, -0.054473877, -0.017471313, 0.014587402, -0.017990112, -0.023513794, 0.01965332, -0.0021305084, -0.014602661, 0.01713562, -0.030380249, -0.044158936, 0.0473938, 0.013183594, -0.012336731, 0.036102295, -0.040252686, -0.022384644, -0.0256958, 0.04168701, 0.050323486, 0.013168335, 0.018997192, 0.03024292, 0.04550171, -0.018127441, -0.0068740845, 0.0602417, 0.048828125, -0.0047683716, 0.009414673, -0.03515625, -0.037353516, -0.008071899, 0.04031372, -0.000014662743, 0.03390503, -0.061035156, 0.052337646, -0.021438599, -0.022659302, -0.00566864, -0.0041885376, -0.039764404, 0.0016994476, 0.032958984, 0.037322998, 0.0013437271, 0.017318726, 0.02267456, -0.026519775, -0.020706177, 0.0074768066, 0.01612854, 0.0033245087, -0.005138397, 0.019927979, 0.0023040771, 0.061401367, 0.030029297, -0.02078247, 0.024353027, 0.018692017, -0.073791504, -0.017547607, -0.043548584, -0.081848145, -0.046844482, 0.02670288, -0.017456055, -0.0012102127, 0.016281128, -0.009208679, -0.026992798, 0.017059326, -0.010688782, 0.012062073, -0.018325806, -0.037078857, -0.037963867, 0.010002136, -0.080200195, -0.02619934, -0.047607422, -0.020858765, 0.0035037994, -0.0068130493, -0.04550171, 0.0076026917, 0.02923584, 0.10998535, 0.03955078, 0.004436493, -0.08148193, 0.042785645, -0.041809082, 0.008834839, 0.022735596, 0.0030155182, -0.010726929, -0.0014305115, 0.029342651, -0.009361267, -0.016052246, -0.044036865, 0.011512756, -0.02458191, 0.044281006, 0.017318726, 0.042175293, 0.016830444, -0.0035362244, 0.0058631897, 0.010063171, -0.04574585, -0.0102005005, -0.014411926, 0.018585205, -0.046417236, 0.0074424744, 0.01586914, 0.021087646, -0.017868042, 0.0143585205, 0.016021729, 0.02519226, -0.0033302307, 0.047973633, -0.020980835, -0.044128418, -0.020706177, 0.017959595, 0.018737793, 0.052612305, -0.025787354, 0.038238525, -0.019134521, 0.023254395, 0.016784668, -0.01676941, 0.031982422, -0.0047035217, 0.031555176, -0.0736084, -0.070007324, -0.020080566, 0.09423828, -0.04736328, 0.0003156662, 0.01838684, 0.0036792755, 0.027404785, 0.04019165, 0.03475952, -0.031143188, -0.008552551, -0.013076782, -0.022064209, -0.01914978, -0.04071045, 0.0047454834, 0.009178162, 0.033813477, -0.058135986, 0.033081055, -0.0044174194, 0.01197052, -0.027252197, -0.02104187, 0.02128601, -0.045898438, 0.042816162, 0.09625244, -0.024246216, 0.06137085, -0.0048332214, 0.05810547, 0.028686523, 0.037506104, 0.019683838, -0.009094238, 0.018432617, 0.010368347, -0.012702942, 0.0037670135, 0.020629883, -0.02078247, 0.009483337, 0.0014381409, -0.021652222, -0.030151367, 0.025054932, 0.0051002502, 0.016845703, -0.020431519, -0.039154053, 0.015007019, -0.021881104, 0.013870239, 0.017318726, -0.044647217, -0.057159424, -0.021728516, -0.02973938, -0.052642822, 0.049560547, -0.002943039, 0.0012311935, -0.09777832, 0.0079574585, -0.011123657, 0.059295654, -0.031555176, -0.0012369156, -0.051757812, 0.023971558, 0.015220642, 0.0015907288, -0.026489258, 0.008880615, 0.012229919, 0.005130768, 0.021957397, -0.00034189224, -0.007396698, -0.016784668, -0.01751709, 0.054779053, 0.054779053, 0.030426025, -0.005092621, -0.0022583008, -0.0446167, -0.030471802, 0.013336182, 0.013137817, -0.004940033, -0.012809753, 0.050445557, -0.0021572113, -0.0073623657, 0.058410645, 0.009796143, 0.006690979, 0.022491455, -0.009178162, 0.03286743, 0.027511597, -0.016281128, -0.0006351471, -0.021621704, -0.017044067, -0.014839172, 0.023071289, -0.01576233, -0.0137786865, 0.032562256, 0.038513184, 0.005256653, 0.0064468384, 0.0044555664, 0.044555664, -0.01979065, 0.011260986, 0.020706177, 0.0064353943, -0.006641388, 0.050445557, 0.011764526, 0.009643555, -0.047698975, -0.060577393, -0.019317627, 0.015327454, 0.027542114, -0.0012779236, 0.02760315, -0.028167725, 0.018554688, -0.015808105, -0.016815186, -0.020446777, 0.014381409, -0.010795593, -0.03942871, 0.020187378, 0.010910034, 0.026855469, -0.041229248, 0.0019702911, -0.009231567, 0.008552551, -0.0018177032, -0.030181885, 0.00007015467, -0.014595032, -0.0015611649, 0.032043457, -0.018966675, -0.013633728, 0.023788452, -0.046783447, 0.039611816, 0.029571533, 0.016204834, 0.025283813, -0.010871887, -0.0030670166, 0.012535095, -0.006877899, -0.035003662, 0.017181396, -0.05230713, -0.029693604, -0.043395996, -0.032836914, -0.049865723, -0.02029419, 0.011497498, 0.028945923, -0.0026226044, 0.0041122437, -0.011657715, -0.0113220215, 0.04425049, 0.016906738, 0.054260254, 0.0020694733, -0.009925842, 0.0035266876, -0.0054016113, 0.030700684, 0.043914795, 0.0053901672, -0.00061416626, -0.001376152, -0.016342163, -0.018066406, 0.022109985, 0.014373779, 0.013969421, -0.000092983246, -0.00819397, 0.064086914, 0.0028018951, 0.041870117, 0.04208374, 0.049621582, -0.021087646, 0.003320694, -0.0068092346, -0.025421143, 0.0038375854, -0.032928467, 0.0047721863, -0.033050537, 0.037841797, -0.00491333, -0.026657104, -0.03100586, 0.071777344, -0.006378174, -0.028503418, 0.018981934, 0.0048065186, 0.011741638, 0.02859497, 0.040283203, -0.018432617, -0.028396606, -0.009063721, 0.024368286, 0.014671326, 0.03048706, -0.01210022, -0.0039100647, -0.040985107, -0.024017334, -0.013267517, 0.03475952, -0.057769775, 0.02709961, -0.00057792664, 0.068359375, 0.023147583, -0.036499023, 0.031143188, 0.0042152405, -0.024246216, 0.009025574, 0.020263672, 0.020111084, 0.012832642, 0.053131104, 0.003238678, -0.008560181, -0.012413025, -0.021087646, 0.008522034, 0.034362793, -0.015327454, 0.008964539, -0.02696228, -0.02168274, 0.01776123, 0.0067367554, 0.057159424, -0.0146102905, 0.026382446, 0.007545471, -0.01864624, 0.09484863, -0.04827881, -0.06774902, 0.036376953, -0.03439331, 0.025115967, 0.035858154, -0.02494812, 0.032989502, 0.019851685, -0.028305054, 0.062042236, 0.02168274, 0.0065727234, -0.05480957, -0.06542969, 0.024673462, 0.0044517517, 0.0463562, 0.03881836, -0.03579712, -0.052368164, 0.015838623, 0.02935791, 0.03640747, -0.029830933, 0.052978516, -0.029968262, -0.03427124, 0.008506775, -0.0039711, -0.013755798, 0.04650879, -0.03878784, 0.02658081, -0.0038585663, -0.0023269653, 0.0018644333, -0.04321289, -0.011413574, 0.0065727234, -0.03829956, 0.024612427, 0.040802002, -0.008422852, 0.015792847, 0.017807007, -0.030517578, -0.0057411194, 0.004020691, 0.03967285, -0.017471313, -0.027282715, 0.016143799, 0.012336731, 0.032592773, -0.059509277, -0.025405884, -0.007797241, 0.058776855, -0.014953613, 0.05126953, -0.009254456, 0.0044136047, 0.03756714, 0.04425049, -0.00017237663, -0.062561035, -0.006214142, -0.02230835, 0.009094238, 0.022323608, -0.009735107, -0.010498047, 0.012557983, -0.006828308, 0.015563965, 0.030853271, 0.002878189, 0.029800415, -0.002746582, 0.07385254, -0.00844574, -0.0031986237, -0.05380249, 0.03829956, -0.013298035, 0.008102417, -0.0018491745, 0.025604248, -0.008262634, 0.05456543, -0.06604004, -0.0143585205, 0.042388916, 0.015052795, 0.00868988, 0.011169434, 0.0004711151, 0.040161133, -0.0209198, 0.0019702911, 0.018539429, 0.030944824, 0.009025574, -0.025924683, 0.032196045, -0.05114746, -0.027633667, 0.029891968, -0.03479004, 0.03475952, -0.007205963, 0.005619049, -0.0029449463, -0.006389618, -0.00920105, 0.0154953, 0.022323608, -0.064208984, -0.047607422, -0.061431885, 0.056854248, -0.012214661 ], "summary": [ 0.0065345764, -0.021774292, 0.0078125, 0.026138306, -0.045013428, -0.02949524, 0.0042762756, -0.037872314, -0.036193848, 0.027053833, -0.062805176, 0.042175293, 0.013298035, 0.010688782, 0.026901245, -0.04107666, 0.036468506, 0.016479492, 0.06414795, 0.0069236755, 0.017105103, 0.031402588, 0.05078125, 0.059387207, 0.037872314, -0.0017623901, -0.13085938, 0.00415802, 0.016708374, 0.01965332, 0.0006227493, 0.0074501038, -0.013748169, 0.006801605, 0.040283203, -0.04119873, 0.053955078, -0.020126343, -0.010726929, 0.060760498, 0.009864807, -0.0064468384, -0.013267517, -0.05001831, -0.04006958, 0.05078125, -0.05255127, -0.0132369995, 0.008399963, -0.00095558167, -0.020050049, 0.033477783, -0.030807495, 0.0079422, -0.013450623, -0.0059661865, -0.050720215, -0.056121826, 0.023452759, 0.095703125, 0.040863037, -0.041137695, -0.0025978088, -0.060821533, -0.004135132, -0.031143188, -0.024734497, 0.0042266846, 0.016708374, 0.0074310303, 0.03225708, -0.016555786, -0.0066108704, -0.020477295, -0.0473938, -0.011672974, 0.033325195, -0.01524353, -0.029296875, -0.01234436, 0.009765625, 0.009483337, -0.012794495, -0.031082153, 0.007118225, -0.018035889, -0.005718231, -0.010269165, 0.003665924, -0.028457642, -0.02029419, 0.0158844, -0.038970947, 0.010818481, -0.013626099, -0.038513184, -0.024291992, -0.075927734, 0.0076904297, -0.012397766, 0.049224854, -0.035980225, 0.028640747, 0.0006761551, -0.030807495, -0.070495605, 0.037231445, -0.018310547, -0.0027542114, 0.034576416, -0.08013916, 0.043701172, -0.0003812313, -0.00086688995, -0.036712646, -0.0013055801, -0.012794495, -0.0060195923, -0.011566162, 0.014053345, -0.048431396, -0.035949707, -0.0054092407, 0.059448242, 0.03378296, 0.029754639, 0.0038776398, 0.023254395, -0.0078125, -0.02041626, -0.02128601, 0.031188965, 0.01574707, 0.010650635, -0.012939453, 0.014129639, 0.055755615, 0.04574585, 0.0049705505, -0.026916504, 0.02128601, -0.027450562, -0.011566162, 0.024169922, 0.012741089, 0.024597168, -0.0014820099, 0.010002136, 0.007987976, -0.033935547, 0.03677368, -0.01158905, 0.0049972534, -0.016204834, 0.04156494, -0.062927246, -0.0019626617, -0.029525757, 0.045013428, -0.0046195984, 0.03427124, 0.010414124, 0.0042686462, 0.018356323, -0.018753052, -0.013183594, -0.007598877, 0.00080776215, 0.0008916855, 0.008392334, 0.009407043, 0.017913818, -0.080322266, -0.012374878, 0.019882202, -0.032836914, -0.03756714, 0.015167236, 0.0146865845, -0.031341553, 0.019424438, 0.0023345947, 0.00089883804, 0.048980713, 0.057250977, -0.07397461, -0.002084732, -0.06201172, -0.006046295, 0.03265381, -0.04345703, 0.053131104, -0.06689453, 0.015670776, 0.00047826767, 0.04925537, -0.024673462, 0.04598999, -0.0017814636, -0.053833008, 0.037017822, -0.022888184, 0.05001831, -0.017745972, -0.012481689, 0.011360168, -0.010978699, 0.0031089783, -0.01499939, -0.0014410019, 0.005580902, -0.013870239, 0.002500534, -0.046813965, -0.03842163, -0.01940918, 0.023529053, -0.034118652, -0.007270813, -0.039611816, -0.01927185, -0.007785797, -0.0574646, 0.051727295, 0.0061454773, -0.031051636, -0.013938904, -0.021133423, -0.01335907, 0.0005221367, -0.05316162, 0.057281494, 0.007888794, 0.04446411, -0.034973145, -0.022460938, -0.010658264, 0.0037059784, 0.011657715, 0.023010254, 0.020904541, -0.027954102, -0.013999939, 0.027862549, -0.03466797, -0.036254883, 0.0074005127, -0.0022850037, -0.058929443, -0.023498535, 0.06665039, 0.06317139, 0.0077323914, 0.04727173, 0.013465881, 0.03277588, 0.0050086975, -0.027816772, 0.0048179626, -0.004737854, 0.037231445, -0.007610321, -0.056274414, 0.021026611, -0.03479004, -0.0027828217, -0.0032138824, -0.008705139, 0.011398315, -0.014930725, 0.01210022, -0.058288574, -0.02355957, -0.021530151, -0.0093688965, -0.05328369, -0.03744507, 0.042755127, -0.019378662, -0.049743652, -0.010070801, 0.011482239, 0.015235901, -0.006717682, 0.0018777847, 0.0043411255, 0.032928467, 0.020004272, 0.047668457, 0.09753418, 0.07684326, 0.02217102, 0.017547607, 0.0034294128, 0.008491516, -0.012802124, -0.016342163, 0.049926758, -0.020751953, -0.007827759, 0.021362305, 0.027999878, -0.025726318, 0.015045166, 0.022003174, -0.051605225, -0.01727295, 0.046661377, 0.011505127, -0.043640137, 0.0074691772, 0.058441162, 0.023803711, 0.050964355, 0.01020813, -0.037841797, 0.02128601, 0.047058105, -0.008232117, -0.024887085, 0.02468872, -0.03152466, 0.02748108, 0.036621094, -0.0023231506, -0.041412354, 0.062347412, 0.010612488, 0.034301758, 0.0109939575, -0.014472961, 0.052825928, -0.02758789, 0.04360962, 0.012161255, -0.0021648407, 0.011268616, 0.01423645, -0.005290985, -0.006904602, 0.021606445, -0.038116455, -0.014060974, -0.008720398, -0.053100586, 0.020111084, -0.023452759, -0.003068924, 0.010787964, -0.022125244, 0.008872986, -0.017944336, -0.031463623, 0.02268982, 0.020446777, 0.0016765594, 0.03942871, 0.057403564, 0.030136108, 0.0047454834, 0.012634277, 0.03427124, 0.013931274, -0.007423401, -0.05718994, -0.047576904, 0.03857422, 0.006839752, 0.037109375, 0.02923584, -0.008712769, 0.022125244, -0.06896973, -0.004497528, -0.0063476562, 0.008811951, 0.058502197, -0.022903442, -0.03024292, 0.020721436, -0.014045715, 0.030288696, -0.060516357, 0.024353027, 0.0881958, 0.022827148, 0.04168701, 0.039093018, 0.05291748, -0.020324707, -0.016540527, -0.015342712, -0.017440796, -0.029953003, 0.0030994415, 0.018463135, -0.019485474, -0.024215698, -0.017440796, -0.029922485, -0.011520386, 0.007419586, 0.015167236, -0.013252258, -0.0146865845, 0.032958984, -0.04220581, -0.01675415, 0.0049209595, 0.081970215, 0.017105103, -0.04626465, 0.034301758, -0.03213501, 0.025634766, -0.00043821335, 0.024414062, 0.0054512024, -0.045715332, -0.012123108, 0.01701355, 0.042999268, 0.009117126, -0.015197754, -0.046539307, 0.021408081, 0.012512207, 0.047821045, -0.010025024, -0.013648987, 0.006439209, -0.044403076, 0.0051498413, 0.0026168823, -0.031951904, 0.020080566, -0.010772705, 0.019714355, 0.031173706, -0.035888672, -0.0053520203, 0.020492554, 0.00233078, 0.018005371, -0.022979736, 0.016983032, 0.042663574, -0.009132385, -0.07458496, -0.054870605, -0.01637268, 0.04534912, -0.013305664, 0.030319214, 0.03933716, 0.04824829, -0.037353516, 0.0005364418, 0.021728516, -0.03527832, 0.021484375, 0.009552002, -0.13220215, -0.008079529, -0.010345459, -0.014518738, 0.034240723, 0.008338928, 0.008926392, -0.021072388, -0.039123535, 0.036956787, -0.010185242, -0.024505615, 0.007434845, -0.038482666, -0.0011367798, -0.03878784, 0.0748291, 0.019714355, 0.0052452087, 0.006832123, -0.047729492, 0.012107849, -0.019470215, 0.012016296, -0.06274414, -0.01789856, 0.016845703, -0.030639648, -0.009552002, -0.012062073, 0.03265381, -0.013465881, -0.0033626556, -0.017700195, -0.004501343, 0.0066452026, 0.037109375, -0.0017366409, -0.007411957, -0.0051498413, 0.0019340515, -0.0236969, 0.0009293556, 0.013137817, 0.0012340546, -0.005908966, 0.012680054, 0.0022716522, -0.011444092, -0.027709961, 0.061950684, 0.05050659, -0.011947632, 0.024154663, 0.051208496, 0.061035156, 0.0012426376, -0.007671356, -0.04550171, -0.024047852, -0.003353119, 0.000081300735, 0.036712646, 0.012237549, -0.016586304, 0.09112549, -0.05053711, -0.038085938, 0.024520874, 0.07977295, -0.05407715, -0.009536743, 0.013916016, -0.024383545, 0.015686035, -0.043914795, -0.012451172, 0.024276733, -0.00015044212, -0.006465912, -0.009162903, 0.022567749, -0.030227661, 0.026062012, -0.0181427, 0.022994995, 0.013076782, -0.029373169, 0.015220642, 0.01423645, -0.037963867, -0.013839722, -0.023239136, -0.017807007, -0.043121338, 0.01637268, 0.020217896, 0.007698059, -0.021026611, 0.003921509, -0.014251709, 0.021469116, -0.04940796, 0.034179688, -0.055908203, -0.040802002, -0.046447754, -0.0005078316, -0.050628662, -0.021011353, -0.058929443, -0.0519104, -0.012489319, 0.01399231, -0.039489746, 0.009925842, 0.035308838, 0.09643555, 0.025421143, 0.015159607, -0.07800293, -0.0005745888, -0.046447754, 0.029159546, 0.012138367, -0.027313232, -0.035888672, -0.011222839, 0.015853882, 0.029312134, -0.035736084, -0.0018138885, 0.0064811707, -0.0043907166, 0.054901123, 0.027297974, 0.068847656, 0.015510559, -0.010261536, 0.000018537045, 0.0072898865, -0.016799927, 0.027404785, -0.013938904, 0.011154175, -0.054382324, -0.0005888939, -0.007129669, 0.00844574, 0.0028476715, -0.009567261, 0.0031585693, -0.0029563904, -0.023803711, 0.015037537, 0.0016307831, 0.019699097, 0.01525116, 0.048065186, -0.010375977, 0.031280518, 0.019622803, 0.010475159, -0.00907135, 0.017669678, 0.01084137, -0.010307312, 0.006210327, 0.0038776398, 0.0012874603, -0.0793457, -0.083496094, -0.03540039, 0.10784912, -0.019622803, -0.009468079, 0.007827759, -0.03652954, 0.03817749, -0.00034070015, 0.027038574, -0.08331299, -0.038970947, -0.038360596, -0.04321289, 0.018051147, -0.01423645, -0.014678955, 0.0015382767, 0.0141067505, -0.003068924, -0.009750366, 0.025787354, -0.01966858, -0.024414062, -0.027572632, 0.021743774, -0.038208008, -0.015419006, 0.05718994, -0.043426514, 0.034454346, 0.03729248, 0.031234741, -0.050231934, 0.02758789, -0.030441284, 0.0054359436, -0.0070495605, -0.029693604, 0.0181427, 0.0124053955, 0.015357971, -0.00020468235, -0.0073776245, 0.006427765, -0.017089844, 0.0044021606, 0.0022296906, -0.015426636, 0.0178833, -0.042785645, 0.007621765, 0.0234375, -0.008720398, 0.019973755, -0.0027236938, -0.046081543, -0.021469116, -0.00087690353, -0.03112793, -0.04638672, 0.057861328, -0.00843811, 0.016220093, -0.078125, -0.016448975, -0.038909912, 0.05819702, -0.021377563, 0.007686615, -0.01864624, -0.0028305054, 0.02507019, 0.072021484, -0.014465332, -0.0072021484, -0.017929077, -0.006324768, 0.041809082, -0.011207581, -0.013900757, -0.008888245, -0.011688232, 0.013092041, 0.021469116, 0.011123657, 0.012161255, 0.0067329407, -0.029571533, -0.003566742, -0.020935059, 0.012039185, -0.04663086, 0.006542206, 0.009811401, -0.020004272, -0.044006348, 0.093688965, -0.00982666, -0.043884277, 0.047698975, 0.0118637085, 0.048919678, 0.030776978, 0.008911133, 0.019943237, 0.0046424866, 0.02128601, -0.020233154, 0.033721924, -0.009292603, -0.01083374, -0.013404846, 0.0049819946, 0.018325806, 0.0073776245, -0.010879517, 0.061035156, -0.008766174, 0.015281677, -0.020019531, 0.018508911, -0.03112793, -0.0038795471, 0.00617218, 0.008262634, -0.008850098, -0.07489014, 0.0037708282, -0.017684937, 0.015686035, -0.0011749268, -0.00034594536, -0.03173828, 0.00046348572, 0.0031661987, 0.0017404556, 0.013450623, -0.015396118, -0.017547607, -0.0056877136, 0.019744873, 0.04534912, 0.049591064, -0.043823242, -0.016799927, -0.026947021, -0.004016876, -0.008163452, -0.0019893646, 0.018112183, -0.031433105, 0.015083313, 0.031433105, 0.025878906, -0.0014476776, 0.030426025, -0.0056419373, 0.02949524, 0.009239197, -0.06341553, -0.022842407, -0.03515625, -0.0016765594, -0.023345947, -0.068603516, -0.025970459, -0.0073509216, -0.032287598, -0.048706055, -0.011764526, -0.037078857, 0.01713562, -0.01663208, 0.011169434, 0.0051612854, 0.038513184, 0.0039901733, -0.008972168, 0.011764526, -0.019439697, 0.041992188, 0.025161743, -0.01436615, -0.024856567, 0.00067043304, -0.0035476685, 0.0043029785, 0.045196533, 0.022888184, -0.0017213821, 0.016418457, -0.0070762634, 0.007774353, -0.0068359375, -0.012626648, -0.012939453, 0.023376465, -0.013641357, 0.061645508, 0.014442444, 0.02609253, 0.02935791, 0.020950317, 0.03805542, -0.04119873, 0.013557434, -0.030288696, 0.02078247, -0.031051636, -0.02607727, 0.011207581, 0.021591187, 0.0070343018, -0.014427185, -0.0151901245, 0.09460449, 0.0051612854, 0.0031356812, 0.08129883, 0.0009918213, -0.023788452, -0.005847931, 0.048736572, -0.017486572, -0.04055786, -0.0134887695, -0.0050735474, 0.009124756, 0.010444641, 0.00035905838, -0.02243042, 0.003271103, -0.0075187683, -0.03753662, 0.038604736, -0.05328369, 0.015792847, 0.0069274902, 0.026535034, -0.005744934, -0.040008545, 0.026138306, -0.013626099, 0.017242432, 0.0075645447, 0.022415161, 0.040100098, 0.00060749054, 0.026245117, -0.03643799, 0.0071105957, 0.038879395, 0.022583008, -0.0029087067, -0.0014429092, -0.002067566, -0.040618896, 0.0014448166, 0.00021910667, 0.017669678, 0.05154419, 0.08898926, 0.0031356812, 0.029586792, 0.0017709732, -0.03289795, 0.041625977, -0.036590576, -0.016174316, -0.00084877014, 0.019332886, 0.01876831, 0.037231445, -0.044158936, 0.06903076, 0.01234436, -0.08331299, 0.07751465, 0.032226562, 0.029022217, -0.03277588, -0.013755798, 0.041778564, 0.053955078, 0.08691406, 0.05819702, -0.023895264, -0.007850647, 0.016433716, 0.03086853, -0.01751709, -0.037719727, 0.052825928, 0.016143799, -0.020446777, -0.0065193176, -0.018371582, -0.024215698, 0.03591919, -0.013786316, 0.03970337, -0.0039253235, 0.010177612, -0.0056381226, -0.013496399, 0.00027561188, 0.0054969788, -0.023345947, 0.0050582886, 0.007858276, -0.010559082, 0.026138306, 0.026916504, -0.031585693, -0.021331787, -0.027770996, -0.018630981, 0.00041222572, -0.02281189, -0.0024700165, 0.031585693, 0.0463562, -0.01374054, 0.022201538, 0.037017822, 0.011230469, -0.017288208, -0.013671875, -0.007358551, 0.01235199, 0.07116699, 0.032684326, 0.002702713, -0.03753662, 0.008514404, -0.008598328, -0.00674057, -0.0143585205, -0.017211914, 0.0012359619, 0.015151978, -0.036987305, 0.018707275, -0.011054993, 0.0066490173, 0.0079193115, -0.019683838, 0.024414062, -0.039093018, 0.016540527, -0.010131836, -0.025482178, -0.007095337, -0.030303955, -0.01436615, 0.008995056, -0.046966553, 0.03817749, -0.020980835, 0.07305908, -0.015625, -0.040771484, 0.041992188, -0.068359375, 0.02267456, 0.04977417, -0.024398804, 0.005367279, 0.025390625, 0.035339355, -0.0043144226, -0.033996582, 0.01789856, -0.070495605, 0.0037765503, -0.025939941, -0.021453857, 0.03253174, -0.0015649796, -0.017425537, 0.020233154, -0.012107849, 0.021591187, 0.012527466, 0.019073486, 0.00075769424, -0.0057029724, -0.046325684, 0.012901306, 0.009017944 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1812.01665v1
Auto-tuning TensorFlow Threading Model for CPU Backend
Niranjan Hasabnis
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.LG
TensorFlow is a popular deep learning framework used by data scientists to solve a wide-range of machine learning and deep learning problems such as image classification and speech recognition. It also operates at a large scale and in heterogeneous environments --- it allows users to train neural network models or deploy them for inference using GPUs, CPUs and deep learning specific custom-designed hardware such as TPUs. Even though TensorFlow supports a variety of optimized backends, realizing the best performance using a backend may require additional efforts. For instance, getting the best performance from a CPU backend requires careful tuning of its threading model. Unfortunately, the best tuning approach used today is manual, tedious, time-consuming, and, more importantly, may not guarantee the best performance. In this paper, we develop an automatic approach, called TensorTuner, to search for optimal parameter settings of TensorFlow's threading model for CPU backends. We evaluate TensorTuner on both Eigen and Intel's MKL CPU backends using a set of neural networks from TensorFlow's benchmarking suite. Our evaluation results demonstrate that the parameter settings found by TensorTuner produce 2% to 123% performance improvement for the Eigen CPU backend and 1.5% to 28% performance improvement for the MKL CPU backend over the performance obtained using their best-known parameter settings. This highlights the fact that the default parameter settings in Eigen CPU backend are not the ideal settings; and even for a carefully hand-tuned MKL backend, the settings may be sub-optimal. Our evaluations also revealed that TensorTuner is efficient at finding the optimal settings --- it is able to converge to the optimal settings quickly by pruning more than 90% of the parameter search space.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.01665v1
2018-12-04T20:20:29
2018-12-04T20:20:29
{ "title": [ -0.021514893, 0.009101868, -0.028656006, -0.012840271, -0.013557434, -0.0071105957, -0.018508911, -0.023330688, -0.02810669, 0.05303955, 0.007511139, 0.01727295, 0.015548706, -0.034698486, -0.010612488, 0.010719299, 0.02079773, 0.00021588802, -0.0077705383, -0.032836914, 0.003993988, -0.013999939, 0.033111572, 0.04449463, 0.01940918, -0.01727295, -0.072631836, 0.0031471252, -0.02508545, -0.034454346, -0.0008611679, 0.04071045, 0.038391113, 0.001953125, 0.00009185076, 0.011100769, -0.01461792, 0.02142334, 0.0058250427, -0.01247406, 0.017837524, -0.016052246, -0.050842285, -0.02571106, -0.038269043, 0.025360107, -0.04736328, -0.005264282, -0.01914978, 0.023162842, -0.0015306473, 0.022064209, -0.0042152405, 0.051086426, 0.01398468, -0.021697998, -0.009300232, 0.013328552, 0.03286743, 0.022628784, -0.01360321, -0.016021729, 0.026428223, -0.011199951, -0.019256592, -0.024734497, -0.035827637, 0.030334473, 0.060272217, -0.0021324158, -0.018463135, 0.025283813, -0.015235901, 0.025772095, -0.037628174, -0.0053215027, 0.05380249, 0.04348755, 0.024383545, 0.014343262, -0.01448822, -0.06359863, 0.011016846, -0.029312134, 0.0357666, 0.014053345, -0.0075912476, -0.011375427, -0.017654419, -0.023742676, -0.00920105, -0.017166138, -0.006504059, 0.047454834, -0.010025024, -0.02128601, -0.027420044, -0.024093628, 0.04748535, 0.0096206665, 0.007511139, -0.010383606, 0.00013875961, -0.017059326, 0.018554688, 0.022598267, -0.010070801, -0.0045814514, 0.034820557, 0.03024292, -0.022125244, 0.023803711, 0.005180359, -0.02507019, -0.009155273, -0.0181427, -0.017654419, 0.0061683655, 0.030578613, -0.00957489, 0.028198242, 0.018066406, 0.014038086, 0.0035381317, 0.034698486, 0.02822876, -0.02809143, -0.028167725, 0.0055236816, 0.010559082, -0.021850586, 0.060668945, -0.042114258, -0.07312012, -0.060180664, 0.010536194, -0.00674057, 0.011131287, -0.007247925, 0.025482178, 0.036468506, -0.059143066, -0.0103302, 0.0440979, -0.019012451, -0.0022125244, 0.04196167, 0.013839722, -0.034210205, -0.021743774, -0.025131226, 0.018600464, -0.008918762, 0.017715454, -0.021255493, 0.025787354, -0.057037354, -0.0014743805, 0.0055007935, 0.009933472, 0.04321289, 0.021636963, 0.005748749, 0.031280518, 0.038238525, -0.025115967, 0.0007162094, 0.015960693, -0.0026454926, 0.00894928, 0.0024642944, 0.010650635, 0.025558472, -0.02078247, -0.007713318, -0.012863159, -0.0019340515, 0.018661499, 0.026275635, -0.042266846, -0.0109939575, -0.02545166, 0.014678955, 0.03189087, -0.015640259, -0.039642334, 0.017593384, 0.01159668, 0.029174805, 0.032196045, -0.045074463, -0.0004720688, -0.028198242, 0.00008946657, -0.04788208, -0.013092041, 0.009132385, 0.043823242, -0.01637268, 0.0102005005, -0.048614502, 0.0023860931, -0.018035889, 0.008956909, 0.0056152344, -0.035949707, 0.005859375, 0.009628296, 0.007572174, 0.07623291, 0.020309448, 0.025222778, -0.015167236, -0.040802002, -0.018722534, -0.04043579, -0.0118255615, -0.016921997, -0.015182495, -0.0052833557, -0.043945312, 0.0015363693, -0.02154541, 0.021774292, 0.020401001, 0.017822266, -0.010314941, -0.012573242, 0.06604004, 0.019607544, 0.08105469, -0.031234741, 0.024337769, 0.0015220642, -0.027648926, -0.02330017, -0.0021343231, -0.04449463, 0.017745972, 0.047790527, 0.023391724, -0.038238525, 0.01802063, 0.02230835, 0.08673096, 0.016860962, 0.0104904175, 0.0030822754, 0.04888916, 0.02520752, 0.012306213, -0.03164673, 0.06628418, -0.0423584, 0.010536194, 0.06365967, -0.019683838, 0.023284912, -0.03149414, 0.011390686, 0.0014467239, 0.03253174, 0.034820557, 0.0020580292, -0.041229248, 0.05041504, -0.027359009, 0.014923096, -0.029830933, 0.057159424, 0.03741455, -0.048431396, -0.007381439, -0.025436401, -0.009765625, -0.048339844, -0.005104065, 0.026779175, -0.0231781, -0.066467285, -0.01991272, 0.015388489, 0.033111572, -0.0033283234, 0.011985779, -0.045562744, 0.012886047, -0.016204834, -0.031082153, -0.014137268, 0.042663574, 0.013389587, -0.010414124, 0.0001705885, 0.017440796, -0.008224487, 0.1005249, 0.08050537, -0.029663086, 0.026992798, -0.05343628, 0.0014877319, 0.0017337799, -0.02835083, -0.0020580292, 0.041931152, 0.01737976, -0.03756714, -0.045135498, 0.022994995, -0.080566406, 0.0041503906, 0.003660202, 0.0062217712, -0.050964355, -0.06011963, -0.029693604, -0.038024902, -0.07879639, -0.041229248, 0.06939697, -0.006591797, -0.01927185, -0.03778076, -0.016738892, -0.021484375, -0.030700684, -0.022750854, -0.0065574646, -0.003068924, 0.034210205, -0.0029773712, -0.05935669, -0.01424408, 0.017745972, 0.025100708, 0.0012645721, 0.041168213, 0.0040512085, -0.013748169, 0.00242424, -0.0065193176, -0.021652222, -0.040771484, 0.021209717, -0.023025513, 0.014732361, 0.0042152405, 0.007091522, 0.026016235, -0.026168823, -0.010917664, -0.035736084, -0.034118652, 0.02420044, -0.026168823, 0.021408081, 0.008514404, 0.029388428, -0.023956299, -0.006965637, 0.0079956055, -0.033172607, 0.0041046143, 0.019622803, -0.044708252, -0.004951477, 0.0116119385, 0.009475708, 0.02432251, -0.009422302, -0.0053138733, -0.028366089, -0.005771637, -0.0107803345, -0.0075302124, 0.014640808, -0.032287598, -0.058532715, -0.026245117, 0.01689148, 0.016067505, 0.002216339, -0.008735657, 0.07043457, -0.0014591217, -0.0103302, -0.005039215, 0.049835205, 0.0072288513, -0.008010864, -0.024505615, -0.031799316, -0.0005106926, 0.015289307, 0.0077209473, -0.039093018, -0.019805908, -0.074523926, 0.009498596, 0.10211182, -0.0140686035, -0.042907715, 0.05886841, -0.08068848, 0.05596924, 0.042297363, 0.01335907, 0.018737793, 0.023849487, 0.00027894974, -0.035491943, 0.03741455, -0.08203125, 0.024291992, -0.04598999, -0.12371826, 0.030029297, -0.04598999, 0.018371582, 0.021118164, -0.0056762695, -0.025726318, 0.009056091, -0.0017471313, 0.037109375, 0.047912598, -0.0038833618, 0.039794922, 0.016693115, 0.036010742, -0.022781372, -0.008857727, -0.029434204, -0.024154663, 0.032958984, -0.009376526, 0.084228516, 0.005874634, 0.011985779, -0.057678223, -0.0022411346, 0.024215698, 0.024612427, 0.030471802, -0.04269409, -0.023544312, -0.03878784, -0.0038967133, 0.0065994263, -0.011543274, 0.00039815903, -0.023605347, 0.0044555664, -0.029785156, 0.040100098, 0.0256958, 0.029785156, -0.0178833, 0.007209778, 0.03213501, -0.0059394836, -0.04324341, 0.013641357, 0.0072288513, -0.0057144165, -0.0015220642, 0.0035381317, -0.040863037, 0.017837524, -0.022277832, 0.03286743, 0.014144897, -0.010566711, 0.0231781, -0.022033691, -0.0362854, 0.011482239, -0.04849243, -0.010406494, -0.026245117, 0.021270752, 0.030380249, -0.02229309, -0.02079773, 0.009506226, -0.028656006, -0.0126953125, 0.009422302, -0.027770996, -0.029067993, -0.038604736, 0.017181396, -0.020767212, -0.031341553, -0.0006046295, -0.012237549, 0.0051078796, -0.021316528, -0.07330322, -0.031341553, 0.05029297, 0.010406494, 0.04006958, -0.0032978058, 0.012489319, -0.00944519, -0.007041931, 0.020263672, -0.020462036, 0.0073623657, -0.03515625, 0.030212402, 0.032226562, -0.021621704, 0.041656494, 0.0112838745, 0.005683899, 0.0017213821, 0.0087890625, 0.018096924, 0.028381348, -0.05407715, 0.044006348, 0.056030273, -0.014846802, -0.08251953, 0.023498535, 0.0112838745, -0.050994873, 0.018051147, -0.02671814, 0.046447754, 0.07556152, -0.026565552, 0.060760498, -0.025146484, 0.00920105, 0.0043640137, -0.038482666, -0.025100708, -0.019134521, 0.017623901, -0.019943237, -0.016082764, 0.032226562, 0.00046873093, 0.06536865, 0.002149582, -0.016860962, 0.02078247, 0.016098022, -0.012283325, -0.032958984, -0.05670166, -0.028274536, 0.0057144165, 0.005088806, 0.0050468445, 0.0008749962, 0.034820557, 0.0060157776, -0.021759033, -0.0101623535, 0.026031494, -0.011451721, 0.01966858, -0.04550171, -0.018035889, 0.0038337708, -0.0859375, -0.056365967, -0.06274414, -0.0009803772, -0.014846802, 0.009468079, -0.023254395, -0.0033779144, 0.012077332, 0.047607422, 0.017410278, 0.015930176, -0.023117065, 0.018600464, -0.005794525, -0.022644043, -0.029678345, 0.009056091, -0.007835388, -0.049346924, -0.0075263977, -0.008003235, -0.017807007, -0.05508423, 0.020355225, -0.0033168793, 0.0055999756, -0.003955841, 0.0044517517, 0.014442444, -0.010322571, 0.010696411, -0.004486084, -0.034118652, 0.023635864, 0.022262573, 0.062347412, -0.04727173, 0.03543091, 0.050964355, 0.01109314, -0.023712158, -0.033691406, 0.05090332, 0.0044288635, -0.038604736, -0.0010604858, 0.06298828, 0.036132812, -0.025360107, 0.01776123, 0.019256592, 0.016601562, -0.032714844, 0.05230713, -0.06488037, -0.023956299, 0.012214661, 0.011779785, -0.009315491, -0.01184845, 0.014892578, -0.056762695, -0.053344727, -0.022262573, 0.04776001, -0.026748657, -0.03274536, 0.004348755, 0.02067566, 0.00046133995, 0.03970337, 0.008605957, 0.04574585, -0.01486969, -0.017074585, 0.011772156, -0.043182373, -0.036193848, -0.0058135986, 0.0056381226, 0.017349243, 0.008293152, -0.010261536, -0.044433594, -0.012481689, -0.012763977, -0.002691269, 0.020080566, -0.044036865, 0.024398804, 0.07733154, -0.013557434, 0.025985718, 0.0317688, 0.007965088, 0.02420044, 0.055358887, -0.015464783, 0.028289795, 0.042663574, -0.057250977, 0.012809753, -0.0010976791, 0.029006958, -0.012168884, -0.021011353, 0.017181396, -0.00058317184, -0.05935669, 0.015731812, 0.023406982, 0.0053367615, 0.028320312, -0.050323486, 0.050994873, 0.0034046173, -0.02053833, 0.0010147095, -0.061431885, -0.051635742, -0.0016593933, -0.056854248, -0.019592285, 0.024124146, -0.02658081, -0.049194336, -0.029388428, 0.03604126, 0.019546509, 0.012901306, -0.02482605, -0.010040283, -0.049835205, 0.0077056885, 0.012176514, -0.061920166, 0.04248047, -0.03970337, -0.0066833496, 0.036102295, 0.054016113, -0.043945312, 0.00023317337, -0.026947021, -0.046905518, -0.04119873, -0.005580902, -0.0009851456, 0.0048980713, -0.005329132, -0.0028057098, -0.01259613, -0.01902771, 0.012573242, -0.006034851, -0.04510498, 0.038208008, -0.0019550323, 0.016784668, 0.0035591125, 0.059417725, 0.01939392, -0.0087890625, 0.010116577, -0.0345459, 0.01802063, -0.009712219, -0.022384644, -0.022506714, -0.036499023, 0.0028648376, 0.023788452, 0.008293152, -0.014015198, 0.040649414, 0.048431396, -0.032287598, 0.010437012, 0.024047852, 0.06878662, -0.05895996, -0.037994385, -0.028152466, 0.010665894, -0.031036377, 0.03567505, 0.0040893555, -0.028549194, -0.019592285, -0.038238525, -0.032806396, -0.0038585663, 0.044006348, -0.010681152, 0.04525757, -0.041625977, -0.025360107, -0.06359863, 0.010818481, -0.009719849, 0.03692627, -0.023605347, 0.030349731, -0.019210815, -0.019454956, 0.0031013489, -0.0044174194, 0.044647217, 0.025222778, -0.03729248, 0.018203735, -0.040924072, -0.009025574, -0.018951416, 0.010345459, 0.022842407, 0.0079956055, -0.015464783, 0.0021915436, -0.07122803, 0.052368164, 0.022369385, 0.025314331, 0.070251465, 0.024673462, -0.012786865, 0.00027680397, 0.0040740967, -0.011886597, 0.011413574, -0.057250977, -0.0042419434, -0.06112671, -0.008171082, -0.08105469, 0.016723633, -0.015808105, 0.025436401, 0.011016846, 0.005290985, -0.0050964355, -0.016662598, 0.016586304, 0.0006494522, 0.044128418, 0.0335083, 0.018936157, 0.008468628, -0.056121826, 0.015594482, 0.0259552, 0.001364708, 0.021652222, 0.0026836395, -0.01386261, -0.0019264221, 0.010871887, 0.030548096, -0.0044059753, -0.0060195923, -0.004184723, 0.021133423, -0.02708435, 0.022766113, 0.07116699, 0.040863037, -0.035125732, -0.017608643, 0.009132385, 0.0340271, -0.0546875, 0.05645752, 0.08154297, -0.09613037, 0.029754639, -0.028457642, -0.047607422, -0.015701294, 0.04434204, 0.029144287, -0.024642944, 0.025344849, 0.0055503845, 0.008483887, -0.025894165, -0.038757324, -0.044769287, -0.02670288, 0.040893555, 0.043304443, -0.043792725, -0.008644104, 0.0058555603, 0.017028809, -0.012077332, -0.001458168, 0.0005707741, 0.034057617, 0.000050723553, 0.028045654, -0.06982422, 0.07531738, -0.013221741, -0.050109863, 0.040008545, 0.006767273, -0.068725586, -0.0065193176, 0.020233154, 0.04586792, 0.0335083, 0.055267334, -0.00566864, -0.0134887695, 0.009895325, -0.015457153, 0.052612305, 0.03390503, -0.017242432, 0.031402588, -0.048858643, -0.03717041, 0.032684326, -0.04928589, 0.061309814, -0.01977539, 0.02293396, -0.034088135, 0.033081055, -0.0005068779, -0.041656494, -0.01676941, 0.0024757385, -0.028137207, -0.010253906, -0.008216858, 0.009628296, 0.0022640228, -0.012702942, 0.031021118, 0.034210205, 0.003736496, 0.046295166, -0.03878784, -0.06347656, 0.027252197, -0.012069702, 0.04257202, -0.044006348, 0.0019292831, 0.016571045, 0.021820068, -0.03555298, -0.06347656, -0.018371582, -0.0049743652, 0.015838623, -0.013595581, -0.00021660328, -0.014198303, -0.02822876, -0.064331055, -0.03024292, 0.0027656555, -0.03543091, -0.050872803, 0.050445557, -0.0178833, -0.054626465, -0.0057868958, -0.03930664, 0.044067383, 0.04257202, -0.010215759, 0.014205933, 0.023803711, -0.008415222, -0.019302368, 0.014465332, 0.03201294, -0.0017213821, -0.029907227, -0.01550293, 0.027145386, 0.06427002, -0.042175293, -0.0927124, -0.019561768, 0.0236969, 0.0019016266, 0.0670166, -0.019073486, 0.00737381, -0.0026416779, 0.07366943, 0.0031852722, -0.03289795, -0.042999268, -0.041870117, 0.050842285, -0.0005297661, -0.019256592, -0.032684326, 0.009338379, 0.016830444, 0.025039673, 0.036956787, -0.021392822, 0.029647827, -0.017150879, 0.03062439, -0.0090789795, -0.024490356, 0.022964478, 0.01184845, -0.0070114136, 0.022994995, -0.021621704, 0.0072021484, -0.003692627, 0.027267456, 0.04067993, -0.026824951, 0.020965576, 0.026931763, 0.03540039, 0.03744507, -0.012794495, -0.05810547, -0.013748169, 0.005554199, -0.0055503845, 0.018814087, 0.009765625, 0.0002963543, 0.0050964355, 0.019683838, -0.025024414, 0.06008911, -0.017959595, 0.043640137, -0.04928589, 0.0076828003, -0.049438477, -0.009819031, 0.0066184998, 0.0026187897, -0.016586304, -0.006340027, -0.041137695, -0.007472992, 0.0026111603, -0.010467529 ], "summary": [ 0.00484848, 0.0044059753, 0.013893127, 0.0061798096, -0.023132324, 0.023117065, -0.035064697, -0.06591797, -0.008224487, 0.033721924, 0.009979248, -0.01386261, 0.0362854, -0.037200928, 0.015464783, -0.0069847107, 0.022506714, 0.00076436996, 0.006374359, -0.04449463, 0.0015554428, -0.034088135, 0.048461914, 0.037994385, 0.0115737915, -0.026168823, -0.022583008, 0.016860962, 0.0022525787, 0.007598877, 0.025817871, -0.006790161, -0.003824234, 0.020462036, 0.025970459, 0.016983032, 0.00022745132, 0.030181885, 0.046295166, -0.027709961, 0.008621216, 0.0006766319, 0.008560181, -0.041503906, -0.035095215, -0.006942749, 0.018432617, 0.019989014, 0.020126343, -0.028121948, 0.013801575, -0.018539429, 0.022232056, -0.0018558502, -0.02305603, 0.0131073, 0.018630981, -0.011077881, 0.008377075, 0.028411865, 0.00076818466, 0.012435913, 0.005176544, -0.020217896, 0.023422241, -0.029678345, 0.034576416, 0.02067566, -0.0023097992, 0.026504517, 0.03137207, 0.0016727448, 0.0070991516, 0.009094238, -0.034240723, 0.00027227402, 0.036895752, 0.01940918, 0.014724731, 0.009063721, 0.0046424866, -0.05126953, -0.0076522827, -0.015319824, 0.032226562, 0.029769897, -0.005443573, -0.014419556, -0.0143966675, 0.009002686, -0.024505615, -0.045440674, -0.019073486, 0.0597229, 0.015045166, -0.008888245, -0.07159424, -0.1149292, 0.040130615, 0.03173828, 0.091552734, -0.06970215, 0.11029053, -0.017059326, 0.010276794, 0.06933594, -0.016342163, -0.032714844, 0.008415222, 0.0039749146, -0.0024909973, -0.0385437, -0.02684021, -0.05203247, 0.00028896332, 0.009780884, -0.03942871, 0.025405884, 0.023223877, -0.029037476, 0.009384155, 0.040985107, 0.012245178, -0.025619507, 0.0119018555, 0.008102417, 0.0026988983, -0.034240723, 0.009803772, 0.0084991455, -0.025909424, 0.04458618, 0.0074768066, -0.029556274, -0.05670166, -0.01158905, 0.02633667, 0.005138397, 0.014205933, 0.004196167, 0.036956787, -0.0413208, -0.038604736, 0.03982544, -0.018463135, 0.040008545, 0.029571533, -0.008918762, -0.017028809, -0.043182373, -0.0036449432, 0.0012645721, -0.0020694733, 0.0021858215, -0.0010108948, -0.0008993149, -0.030792236, 0.0014686584, 0.003873825, 0.020050049, 0.015388489, 0.0045928955, 0.030670166, 0.06097412, 0.045440674, -0.0038013458, -0.005355835, 0.0042304993, 0.015975952, -0.011795044, 0.0006046295, 0.016601562, 0.02268982, -0.007575989, 0.0018062592, -0.0015039444, -0.017242432, 0.038909912, 0.00021922588, -0.03817749, -0.0004427433, -0.04473877, 0.027114868, 0.017211914, -0.010955811, 0.00415802, -0.0018177032, 0.03250122, 0.030426025, 0.022018433, -0.0690918, -0.0015172958, -0.020324707, 0.05996704, -0.019561768, -0.02330017, -0.04373169, 0.01600647, -0.031799316, -0.021972656, 0.042663574, 0.0074043274, 0.0068855286, -0.037139893, -0.06665039, 0.005962372, -0.016815186, 0.02079773, -0.018966675, 0.014320374, 0.020980835, -0.005218506, -0.008239746, -0.02470398, -0.02720642, -0.025238037, 0.0037384033, 0.018737793, 0.016067505, -0.023040771, -0.0003168583, -0.0009832382, -0.00046300888, 0.017715454, -0.01889038, 0.040649414, -0.025131226, 0.02696228, 0.043273926, 0.012962341, 0.08325195, -0.030197144, -0.01687622, 0.025894165, 0.005718231, 0.002735138, 0.032348633, -0.046173096, 0.016677856, 0.027893066, 0.011672974, 0.013557434, -0.020584106, 0.0027236938, 0.03753662, 0.0000064373016, 0.010673523, 0.007472992, 0.0574646, 0.0087890625, -0.047821045, -0.071777344, 0.056610107, -0.10839844, 0.055755615, 0.02255249, -0.02520752, 0.021972656, 0.05606079, -0.020858765, -0.02330017, 0.01109314, 0.060913086, -0.01979065, -0.0020484924, 0.02128601, -0.008857727, -0.009483337, -0.010406494, 0.021362305, -0.00019311905, -0.08758545, 0.0014276505, -0.034088135, -0.04385376, -0.066467285, -0.008842468, 0.040100098, -0.016845703, -0.066345215, 0.009216309, 0.045166016, -0.027709961, -0.026611328, 0.006210327, -0.058166504, -0.034729004, 0.012718201, -0.03778076, 0.028045654, 0.037841797, 0.043670654, 0.0006303787, 0.008872986, -0.018814087, 0.0113220215, 0.09716797, 0.016464233, 0.004295349, 0.013267517, 0.013221741, 0.036132812, -0.008140564, -0.0024967194, 0.0037727356, 0.041015625, 0.038482666, -0.023468018, 0.0010080338, -0.013458252, -0.034301758, -0.016647339, -0.0154953, 0.057037354, -0.073913574, -0.08087158, -0.046936035, -0.015037537, -0.0914917, -0.03012085, 0.07348633, -0.017211914, -0.010040283, -0.016525269, -0.029968262, -0.019577026, 0.00548172, -0.012008667, 0.011390686, -0.014671326, 0.030181885, 0.002538681, -0.008117676, -0.0491333, 0.016799927, -0.02519226, 0.005973816, 0.042938232, 0.0054092407, 0.008895874, 0.03024292, -0.03062439, -0.008377075, -0.017288208, -0.012580872, 0.0023956299, 0.0055274963, 0.005832672, -0.008415222, 0.02520752, -0.028961182, -0.008491516, -0.053985596, -0.024368286, -0.049682617, 0.011985779, 0.082092285, -0.030273438, -0.027938843, -0.050323486, 0.0018529892, -0.0024738312, -0.028564453, 0.011024475, 0.009483337, -0.027023315, 0.015792847, -0.004878998, 0.020767212, 0.039489746, 0.03616333, 0.01965332, -0.064819336, -0.023010254, -0.035491943, -0.010093689, 0.060699463, -0.023406982, -0.044189453, 0.008598328, 0.021438599, 0.039001465, -0.06365967, -0.000010848045, 0.05770874, 0.01939392, 0.007446289, 0.00012469292, 0.048431396, -0.0050086975, 0.015487671, -0.00017488003, 0.043884277, -0.01109314, -0.014183044, -0.014709473, -0.029296875, -0.012031555, -0.0129852295, 0.0006814003, 0.09307861, -0.037261963, -0.016845703, 0.008453369, -0.00025820732, 0.019836426, 0.06317139, 0.00819397, -0.017913818, 0.03274536, -0.009338379, -0.041778564, 0.0023117065, -0.03060913, 0.03564453, -0.033813477, -0.049072266, 0.0010719299, 0.007827759, -0.004005432, -0.008583069, 0.008483887, -0.004486084, 0.03237915, 0.03729248, -0.00035476685, 0.03152466, -0.03414917, 0.051696777, 0.020874023, 0.015686035, -0.010887146, -0.017242432, 0.007221222, -0.05029297, 0.03778076, 0.026428223, 0.070495605, 0.05960083, -0.032714844, -0.057434082, 0.0011920929, 0.00522995, -0.02949524, 0.0067367554, -0.03149414, 0.026123047, -0.01727295, 0.030319214, 0.0070762634, -0.013252258, -0.019226074, 0.04840088, 0.019165039, -0.020843506, 0.018234253, -0.012969971, 0.013847351, 0.03439331, 0.036193848, 0.020324707, 0.0037822723, 0.0018224716, 0.018676758, 0.014808655, 0.021652222, -0.034301758, 0.016036987, -0.05368042, 0.025177002, 0.011039734, -0.008094788, 0.045440674, -0.021316528, 0.008308411, -0.056518555, 0.014732361, -0.0021972656, -0.026306152, -0.060546875, -0.048706055, 0.022109985, -0.03152466, -0.0018806458, -0.006942749, 0.007499695, 0.01084137, 0.002117157, 0.0011968613, 0.04244995, 0.018493652, 0.012260437, 0.009460449, 0.04547119, -0.008995056, -0.0030174255, -0.025466919, 0.07635498, -0.009346008, -0.08984375, 0.015289307, -0.016647339, 0.061035156, 0.024291992, -0.020462036, 0.05218506, -0.0044136047, -0.0056610107, -0.00484848, -0.05545044, -0.014328003, -0.054748535, 0.00712204, 0.023910522, -0.024612427, 0.0018520355, 0.013504028, 0.049713135, -0.0287323, -0.017669678, 0.012435913, 0.04043579, -0.05923462, 0.025405884, 0.04437256, 0.009162903, -0.09979248, 0.050476074, 0.01940918, -0.018310547, 0.024093628, 0.0035705566, 0.044677734, 0.045013428, -0.030929565, -0.02281189, -0.019805908, -0.033233643, 0.014678955, 0.00440979, -0.01689148, -0.0060195923, -0.015548706, 0.021713257, -0.04006958, 0.037078857, -0.013053894, 0.024505615, -0.010238647, -0.043060303, 0.02609253, 0.037231445, -0.015205383, -0.061920166, -0.008720398, -0.014221191, 0.04800415, -0.027145386, -0.012397766, 0.021240234, -0.01876831, -0.02128601, 0.022003174, 0.0064926147, 0.014541626, 0.0340271, -0.006385803, -0.03237915, 0.006084442, -0.014122009, -0.052825928, -0.03164673, -0.03326416, -0.035003662, -0.017974854, -0.009307861, -0.010055542, 0.0073280334, 0.0059814453, 0.04586792, -0.021408081, 0.038146973, 0.002986908, 0.029052734, 0.001912117, -0.036956787, -0.026229858, 0.025314331, -0.01927185, -0.035705566, 0.0014629364, -0.014831543, -0.0008125305, -0.02708435, -0.005748749, -0.007396698, -0.011657715, -0.0059776306, 0.017654419, 0.004058838, 0.00026082993, -0.009246826, -0.010185242, -0.0079422, 0.059539795, 0.011543274, 0.028060913, 0.040985107, 0.033294678, 0.031280518, -0.034301758, -0.04360962, -0.0076789856, 0.04071045, -0.0032577515, -0.039520264, -0.032836914, 0.050628662, 0.091552734, -0.0032577515, 0.034484863, 0.012779236, -0.010948181, 0.019744873, 0.02507019, -0.016433716, -0.027999878, -0.006351471, -0.008483887, 0.0037155151, -0.022033691, -0.0020198822, -0.08306885, -0.03845215, -0.045959473, 0.028411865, -0.017547607, -0.038757324, 0.029815674, -0.01525116, -0.009155273, 0.039398193, 0.038269043, 0.042114258, -0.013938904, -0.007106781, 0.021606445, -0.044128418, -0.0022525787, -0.015533447, 0.012321472, -0.016983032, 0.0014324188, -0.055419922, -0.00466156, -0.03817749, -0.017700195, -0.01789856, -0.00022900105, -0.04840088, -0.08673096, -0.028900146, -0.010971069, -0.023452759, 0.04916382, -0.023330688, -0.039916992, 0.014907837, -0.051696777, 0.020370483, -0.0018539429, -0.077941895, -0.036834717, 0.008476257, 0.0335083, -0.0006699562, -0.01979065, 0.025360107, -0.037261963, -0.029052734, -0.0023174286, -0.017425537, 0.028396606, -0.020858765, -0.008354187, 0.021957397, -0.0022830963, 0.016967773, -0.028167725, -0.04055786, -0.024871826, 0.016494751, -0.051452637, 0.002111435, 0.03439331, -0.020736694, -0.068481445, -0.005393982, 0.028015137, 0.04486084, -0.0077285767, -0.019683838, 0.0024356842, -0.038848877, -0.020355225, -0.007896423, -0.01600647, 0.019195557, -0.026931763, 0.0019416809, -0.0055236816, 0.024291992, 0.003955841, -0.0004606247, -0.016448975, -0.0060539246, -0.027526855, -0.03225708, -0.024383545, 0.033691406, -0.0067481995, 0.01977539, 0.02067566, -0.039855957, 0.026779175, -0.024459839, -0.018875122, 0.012367249, 0.0068740845, 0.021987915, 0.0026168823, 0.014472961, -0.019943237, 0.0039596558, 0.013412476, -0.026824951, 0.021469116, -0.019500732, -0.013435364, -0.024139404, -0.06530762, 0.013824463, 0.0063476562, 0.001950264, 0.0035514832, 0.009269714, 0.017654419, -0.0045051575, 0.017120361, 0.0042266846, 0.03741455, -0.0011892319, -0.0067634583, 0.0052871704, 0.049957275, 0.0055770874, -0.018463135, -0.031402588, -0.0049705505, -0.0034675598, -0.03515625, -0.004634857, -0.022064209, -0.0008559227, 0.009635925, 0.016433716, -0.028244019, 0.0005302429, -0.03564453, -0.010353088, 0.0046424866, 0.0000936389, -0.026260376, -0.016448975, 0.027496338, 0.0015850067, 0.004043579, 0.021453857, 0.015686035, 0.014762878, -0.03945923, 0.031311035, -0.06097412, 0.0014486313, -0.024475098, 0.028244019, -0.05105591, 0.040802002, -0.005874634, -0.020889282, -0.05154419, 0.024612427, 0.03640747, 0.027755737, 0.0052871704, 0.0020256042, 0.058166504, 0.0055122375, -0.011207581, 0.0029067993, 0.04812622, -0.010185242, -0.036743164, -0.055145264, -0.03918457, -0.037384033, 0.045074463, -0.021575928, 0.0076065063, 0.041809082, 0.0066566467, 0.010314941, 0.0012311935, 0.011352539, 0.0152282715, 0.040924072, 0.07647705, 0.011711121, 0.042755127, -0.04095459, -0.03152466, 0.022232056, -0.011749268, 0.02507019, -0.0007505417, -0.013809204, 0.008522034, -0.027908325, 0.022750854, -0.030517578, -0.018829346, -0.02166748, 0.039154053, 0.015022278, 0.05307007, 0.021438599, -0.016693115, 0.025604248, -0.03286743, 0.004398346, 0.06530762, -0.04901123, 0.095947266, 0.05303955, -0.023651123, 0.010910034, -0.0138549805, -0.03201294, 0.021759033, 0.04876709, 0.029525757, -0.033966064, 0.023071289, -0.015380859, 0.0042495728, -0.02394104, -0.037902832, -0.048217773, -0.029922485, 0.021118164, 0.015037537, -0.035308838, -0.035583496, 0.008155823, -0.042053223, -0.019332886, 0.002620697, 0.008056641, 0.075683594, 0.024307251, 0.027023315, -0.10638428, 0.039764404, -0.005432129, -0.03643799, 0.001364708, 0.025344849, -0.052246094, 0.020370483, 0.028869629, 0.0927124, 0.06939697, 0.037017822, -0.049621582, 0.01638794, 0.09039307, -0.010978699, 0.047698975, 0.028869629, 0.0043144226, 0.0018625259, -0.033325195, -0.0012083054, -0.003068924, -0.0019683838, 0.0022335052, -0.027023315, -0.011665344, -0.044525146, 0.038116455, -0.034606934, -0.0099487305, -0.014808655, -0.035736084, -0.025405884, 0.0038661957, 0.021347046, -0.002614975, 0.039154053, -0.019119263, -0.008453369, 0.024536133, 0.009735107, 0.07574463, -0.0071144104, -0.035858154, -0.00026774406, -0.021011353, 0.05795288, -0.088378906, 0.015396118, 0.035461426, 0.028244019, -0.04815674, -0.06994629, 0.011024475, 0.0061912537, 0.0005455017, -0.032592773, -0.0051460266, -0.029556274, -0.053833008, -0.06542969, -0.05303955, 0.00856781, -0.055664062, 0.011062622, 0.05496216, 0.005317688, -0.023803711, 0.010635376, -0.010902405, 0.024978638, -0.026138306, 0.0031166077, 0.00831604, 0.037506104, -0.019241333, -0.037719727, 0.009712219, 0.004776001, 0.010772705, -0.062286377, -0.0010128021, 0.01777649, 0.021820068, -0.005126953, -0.03152466, 0.064819336, 0.037628174, 0.028198242, 0.048309326, -0.019348145, -0.000049471855, -0.019927979, 0.058502197, -0.0010948181, -0.018859863, -0.07727051, -0.033477783, 0.06213379, -0.028305054, -0.0206604, -0.064575195, -0.00065660477, -0.0029392242, 0.0082473755, 0.0045280457, -0.020507812, -0.02470398, -0.016845703, -0.014144897, 0.006374359, -0.04498291, 0.034210205, 0.0032253265, -0.008773804, 0.005268097, -0.0004336834, -0.01096344, -0.0025959015, 0.02520752, 0.012260437, -0.006958008, -0.0057678223, -0.007949829, 0.026748657, -0.04458618, 0.007133484, -0.0036315918, 0.011230469, 0.002632141, -0.002462387, 0.002231598, -0.0022945404, 0.018966675, -0.01146698, 0.012214661, -0.00340271, 0.072143555, -0.027511597, 0.04876709, -0.020599365, -0.009880066, -0.018127441, 0.032226562, 0.0039043427, -0.008850098, -0.039093018, 0.013824463, -0.01600647, -0.029785156, -0.036010742, -0.005355835 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1812.07211v2
Interpretable Optimal Stopping
Dragos Florin Ciocan, Velibor V. Mišić
math.OC, cs.AI, cs.LG
Optimal stopping is the problem of deciding when to stop a stochastic system to obtain the greatest reward, arising in numerous application areas such as finance, healthcare and marketing. State-of-the-art methods for high-dimensional optimal stopping involve approximating the value function or the continuation value, and then using that approximation within a greedy policy. Although such policies can perform very well, they are generally not guaranteed to be interpretable; that is, a decision maker may not be able to easily see the link between the current system state and the policy's action. In this paper, we propose a new approach to optimal stopping, wherein the policy is represented as a binary tree, in the spirit of naturally interpretable tree models commonly used in machine learning. We show that the class of tree policies is rich enough to approximate the optimal policy. We formulate the problem of learning such policies from observed trajectories of the stochastic system as a sample average approximation (SAA) problem. We prove that the SAA problem converges under mild conditions as the sample size increases, but that computationally even immediate simplifications of the SAA problem are theoretically intractable. We thus propose a tractable heuristic for approximately solving the SAA problem, by greedily constructing the tree from the top down. We demonstrate the value of our approach by applying it to the canonical problem of option pricing, using both synthetic instances and instances using real S&P-500 data. Our method obtains policies that (1) outperform state-of-the-art non-interpretable methods, based on simulation-regression and martingale duality, and (2) possess a remarkably simple and intuitive structure.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.07211v2
2019-12-30T21:18:38
2018-12-18T07:35:01
{ "title": [ 0.005584717, 0.024307251, 0.011688232, -0.026870728, -0.032318115, 0.01322937, -0.03074646, -0.059326172, -0.01889038, -0.0073661804, -0.03930664, 0.0024585724, -0.059051514, -0.0231781, 0.013664246, -0.026901245, 0.038146973, -0.0014410019, -0.020248413, -0.018173218, -0.081848145, 0.008056641, 0.034210205, 0.0019779205, -0.012580872, 0.00793457, -0.03552246, -0.02243042, -0.022064209, -0.04220581, -0.022842407, 0.047668457, 0.0007815361, 0.039154053, 0.0395813, 0.043670654, -0.0079193115, 0.03970337, 0.037139893, 0.02229309, -0.018493652, 0.018844604, -0.06347656, -0.030044556, -0.066223145, -0.0043411255, -0.046417236, 0.0155181885, 0.0027160645, 0.032989502, -0.021896362, -0.032562256, -0.023132324, 0.0524292, 0.01247406, -0.0047454834, -0.012939453, -0.03466797, 0.0023727417, 0.06378174, 0.03375244, -0.01689148, 0.012893677, -0.03781128, 0.019439697, -0.041656494, 0.009880066, 0.041015625, 0.048706055, 0.048797607, -0.019546509, 0.0047035217, 0.024520874, -0.017166138, -0.012786865, 0.00040888786, 0.040130615, 0.031066895, 0.00077676773, -0.026245117, 0.004711151, -0.019683838, -0.0029830933, 0.0021095276, -0.006690979, -0.0087890625, -0.010345459, -0.010688782, -0.049102783, -0.039215088, -0.02229309, 0.047058105, -0.016281128, -0.018066406, -0.068115234, 0.01096344, -0.034332275, -0.022201538, -0.019378662, -0.03152466, -0.05154419, 0.0035476685, -0.05847168, 0.007419586, 0.013580322, 0.0440979, 0.017456055, -0.022781372, -0.007873535, 0.008552551, -0.0057792664, 0.00077724457, 0.006286621, 0.0008163452, 0.05331421, 0.014724731, 0.0012960434, 0.040893555, -0.017150879, 0.027633667, -0.009788513, -0.010177612, 0.030914307, -0.029678345, -0.005168915, -0.027740479, -0.04928589, -0.0023040771, -0.041381836, 0.05895996, -0.00031137466, 0.045532227, -0.10028076, -0.047851562, -0.05050659, 0.0043563843, -0.018737793, -0.008430481, -0.029159546, -0.014556885, 0.038909912, -0.021728516, 0.003742218, 0.010406494, -0.0072784424, 0.028701782, 0.06488037, 0.0018033981, -0.026550293, -0.0647583, -0.0041160583, 0.019042969, 0.03665161, -0.021392822, -0.061645508, -0.030792236, -0.12036133, -0.022842407, 0.027008057, 0.0022449493, -0.011909485, -0.012809753, -0.014793396, -0.052124023, -0.010498047, 0.019515991, -0.0118637085, 0.022583008, 0.009735107, 0.019866943, 0.0022945404, 0.030853271, -0.0053367615, 0.0032787323, 0.015007019, 0.0078125, -0.002357483, -0.019927979, 0.052124023, -0.03967285, 0.017440796, -0.0009303093, -0.010246277, 0.057128906, -0.026397705, -0.051940918, 0.0104599, -0.01537323, -0.001282692, 0.032104492, -0.025131226, 0.025756836, -0.029876709, -0.013961792, -0.035308838, -0.008010864, 0.017349243, 0.029296875, -0.011375427, 0.020904541, 0.0090408325, 0.03186035, -0.019805908, 0.014579773, -0.013328552, 0.0033626556, -0.0052337646, -0.00014233589, -0.0025615692, 0.053375244, 0.053955078, -0.00843811, -0.05307007, 0.047912598, -0.008003235, -0.049987793, 0.010429382, -0.024719238, -0.016723633, -0.017303467, -0.027709961, -0.022567749, -0.017684937, 0.03503418, 0.053009033, -0.018005371, 0.015235901, -0.04449463, 0.078186035, 0.013755798, 0.06793213, -0.023498535, -0.0035095215, -0.0014381409, -0.036254883, -0.0072517395, -0.014450073, 0.03164673, 0.008056641, 0.031555176, 0.008094788, 0.006504059, 0.014640808, 0.016845703, 0.04019165, 0.01725769, 0.032989502, -0.018875122, 0.008834839, -0.024993896, 0.05645752, -0.028045654, 0.061462402, -0.027496338, 0.0016145706, 0.06616211, -0.004558563, -0.011795044, -0.0052490234, 0.040252686, -0.025268555, 0.011932373, 0.014564514, -0.0011863708, -0.021270752, -0.034088135, -0.019744873, 0.012214661, 0.008926392, -0.021713257, 0.024017334, -0.018188477, 0.0035171509, -0.021972656, -0.0058288574, 0.0013923645, -0.027404785, 0.031677246, -0.012313843, -0.049957275, -0.005958557, 0.035888672, 0.046051025, 0.0055389404, 0.029006958, 0.00894165, 0.021255493, -0.024505615, -0.004966736, -0.031341553, 0.04953003, -0.003791809, -0.004257202, -0.015716553, 0.00095272064, -0.028884888, 0.035858154, 0.03100586, -0.011299133, 0.0023670197, -0.07366943, 0.008705139, 0.035095215, -0.031066895, -0.002040863, 0.045532227, 0.03656006, -0.017028809, -0.027191162, 0.0075416565, -0.074645996, -0.012039185, -0.0019464493, -0.040100098, 0.02432251, -0.011520386, 0.024154663, -0.01360321, 0.045654297, 0.05493164, 0.039642334, -0.032928467, -0.031280518, -0.014831543, -0.013214111, -0.020965576, -0.016860962, -0.021362305, -0.09277344, 0.008522034, 0.03024292, -0.042785645, -0.06536865, 0.004886627, 0.012901306, 0.049072266, -0.00522995, 0.0015687943, -0.00349617, 0.007259369, 0.013435364, -0.04925537, 0.008766174, -0.035461426, -0.0028762817, -0.037200928, -0.022216797, 0.0037498474, -0.02267456, -0.009109497, 0.04144287, -0.029281616, -0.047790527, 0.012199402, 0.043273926, -0.016708374, 0.020492554, 0.038238525, 0.04525757, -0.009391785, 0.02558899, 0.013389587, -0.0069084167, -0.08441162, -0.0062789917, -0.052947998, -0.020690918, -0.014099121, 0.021896362, 0.08557129, -0.04751587, 0.017074585, -0.019012451, 0.018569946, -0.0009889603, -0.01184082, 0.018234253, -0.024765015, -0.049926758, -0.01902771, 0.032165527, 0.023254395, 0.025115967, 0.025238037, 0.11138916, -0.023925781, -0.010414124, 0.00019657612, 0.06109619, 0.041870117, -0.030975342, -0.08911133, 0.033050537, -0.027252197, -0.006511688, 0.008018494, 0.026046753, -0.03866577, -0.008071899, 0.006942749, 0.020080566, -0.019989014, -0.024536133, 0.02909851, -0.06213379, 0.024810791, -0.003168106, -0.025817871, 0.021148682, -0.00008845329, 0.000934124, -0.011413574, 0.034454346, -0.061401367, 0.009178162, -0.038726807, -0.0435791, 0.03378296, -0.01625061, -0.044281006, 0.011222839, -0.03378296, -0.03756714, -0.017196655, -0.0041542053, 0.068603516, 0.031311035, 0.018615723, 0.022384644, -0.020904541, 0.019454956, -0.022750854, -0.03665161, -0.0064201355, 0.05041504, 0.037078857, -0.014976501, 0.031799316, 0.0026721954, 0.009994507, -0.06976318, -0.048217773, -0.018157959, 0.017532349, 0.0063552856, -0.038208008, -0.049438477, -0.07421875, 0.0007534027, 0.008651733, -0.024383545, 0.007472992, -0.0023822784, -0.0022621155, -0.012145996, 0.01411438, 0.01777649, 0.016479492, -0.036468506, 0.020736694, 0.0040397644, -0.018753052, 0.0093307495, -0.019241333, -0.018554688, 0.00944519, 0.062072754, -0.013183594, -0.00065755844, -0.01701355, -0.058807373, 0.040374756, 0.008628845, 0.00030064583, -0.015060425, -0.011886597, -0.018218994, 0.024520874, 0.006538391, 0.013122559, 0.024551392, -0.00894165, 0.009765625, -0.02557373, 0.020477295, 0.011520386, -0.03982544, 0.06341553, 0.0012226105, 0.009277344, -0.012237549, -0.016448975, 0.0010643005, -0.015296936, -0.052764893, -0.04144287, -0.0032844543, -0.047821045, 0.0015821457, -0.06161499, -0.07067871, 0.05758667, -0.008850098, -0.017074585, -0.008178711, -0.062438965, 0.018356323, -0.012451172, 0.03302002, -0.018493652, 0.07678223, -0.005973816, -0.009178162, 0.018310547, -0.017318726, -0.013198853, 0.06488037, 0.020889282, 0.013465881, 0.002532959, 0.0046157837, 0.06100464, -0.030441284, 0.04449463, 0.06518555, -0.052642822, -0.04623413, 0.023010254, -0.012237549, -0.02128601, -0.0014266968, -0.035461426, 0.019851685, 0.013870239, 0.037384033, 0.04046631, -0.013198853, 0.004753113, 0.03765869, -0.01260376, -0.027999878, -0.040161133, -0.007167816, 0.030227661, 0.015777588, -0.0075950623, 0.020828247, 0.03765869, 0.058654785, -0.017242432, 0.002811432, 0.011444092, -0.004257202, -0.007511139, -0.056549072, 0.009796143, -0.006587982, 0.0023384094, -0.035888672, 0.028579712, 0.016830444, -0.019134521, -0.018066406, -0.006881714, -0.0015611649, -0.015304565, 0.029907227, -0.033447266, -0.002670288, -0.011276245, -0.068481445, -0.039276123, 0.018997192, 0.009971619, 0.033569336, 0.0010957718, -0.018218994, 0.03829956, 0.026977539, 0.034698486, 0.055786133, -0.0061836243, -0.04031372, 0.04660034, -0.039031982, -0.050720215, 0.051971436, -0.07336426, -0.004425049, -0.029449463, 0.07312012, 0.0005636215, -0.031829834, -0.015045166, 0.025253296, -0.0129470825, 0.07019043, 0.006816864, 0.02909851, 0.025527954, -0.011123657, 0.016204834, 0.014160156, -0.032989502, -0.0056533813, 0.048706055, 0.029678345, -0.004501343, -0.019973755, 0.022399902, 0.032714844, -0.043029785, 0.04095459, 0.008415222, 0.023040771, 0.06555176, 0.0058631897, 0.012931824, -0.030532837, 0.0046920776, 0.02470398, -0.05105591, 0.05368042, -0.03579712, 0.038635254, 0.024398804, 0.0082473755, 0.019989014, -0.025054932, 0.011039734, -0.0078125, -0.0025291443, -0.04345703, -0.07067871, -0.0041389465, 0.062561035, -0.019638062, -0.009002686, -0.010955811, 0.008041382, 0.012237549, 0.057525635, 0.04360962, -0.019882202, -0.0074157715, -0.012794495, -0.0012931824, -0.039367676, -0.07006836, 0.0053482056, -0.050476074, 0.014503479, -0.06542969, 0.06323242, -0.015686035, -0.012001038, -0.0011510849, 0.01576233, -0.019119263, -0.028457642, 0.025222778, 0.03829956, -0.019485474, 0.042053223, 0.027648926, 0.012870789, 0.0078125, 0.04937744, -0.015396118, 0.036315918, 0.035369873, -0.021408081, -0.0309906, 0.0035552979, 0.021835327, 0.0047721863, 0.030044556, 0.008262634, -0.002532959, -0.017059326, 0.000702858, -0.013542175, 0.0046958923, -0.000890255, -0.015960693, 0.0044517517, 0.036865234, 0.0158844, 0.017532349, -0.040771484, -0.011146545, 0.041625977, -0.014038086, -0.007347107, 0.011199951, 0.008880615, 0.0017900467, -0.042114258, 0.08947754, -0.054595947, 0.009674072, 0.012268066, 0.0065994263, 0.007888794, 0.021911621, 0.015022278, -0.037353516, -0.049041748, -0.0063972473, 0.0289917, -0.011024475, -0.017715454, -0.04345703, -0.0027580261, -0.0012722015, -0.047943115, -0.01902771, 0.0064086914, 0.0007247925, 0.0075569153, -0.012275696, -0.018325806, -0.006614685, -0.024093628, 0.023880005, 0.0048217773, -0.03186035, 0.0234375, 0.001996994, 0.009178162, -0.014533997, -0.018920898, -0.008049011, -0.010322571, 0.016784668, -0.027328491, 0.030715942, 0.0051841736, -0.02293396, -0.008140564, -0.0021877289, 0.007221222, 0.018127441, -0.015274048, -0.053009033, 0.016571045, 0.01637268, -0.020050049, -0.019241333, -0.019073486, 0.043395996, -0.0042152405, -0.015556335, 0.028167725, 0.016693115, 0.038635254, 0.059936523, -0.01802063, -0.027160645, -0.025726318, -0.04638672, -0.027191162, -0.02458191, 0.017196655, -0.0061912537, -0.010192871, -0.07702637, -0.04876709, 0.026443481, 0.015670776, 0.014213562, 0.016189575, 0.010482788, -0.057525635, -0.01247406, 0.025665283, 0.005580902, -0.049804688, 0.0037937164, -0.005012512, 0.040740967, -0.032806396, 0.028701782, -0.012466431, -0.024749756, 0.013069153, 0.040802002, 0.012252808, -0.043029785, 0.014251709, -0.045013428, 0.062927246, 0.045532227, 0.0017442703, 0.038330078, 0.00667572, 0.0047683716, 0.011642456, 0.044891357, -0.0071258545, -0.0056037903, -0.062927246, -0.032226562, -0.039916992, 0.00056266785, -0.08355713, -0.019882202, 0.019607544, 0.008796692, 0.019882202, -0.011528015, 0.032287598, 0.008544922, 0.024749756, -0.03643799, 0.04888916, 0.029754639, -0.0023384094, 0.022232056, 0.023834229, -0.03704834, 0.025283813, 0.01713562, 0.0017700195, -0.027069092, -0.01727295, 0.017303467, 0.027297974, 0.0049591064, -0.015914917, -0.0034446716, -0.03643799, -0.008125305, 0.0038490295, 0.018569946, 0.049835205, 0.014175415, 0.010475159, -0.01373291, 0.008102417, 0.01108551, -0.0552063, 0.022399902, 0.0390625, -0.05154419, 0.01689148, -0.03878784, -0.023757935, -0.0067443848, 0.011398315, 0.050964355, -0.03189087, -0.018066406, 0.005382538, 0.028564453, 0.01928711, 0.050811768, -0.025253296, 0.0027751923, -0.014953613, -0.007888794, 0.042236328, 0.019927979, -0.0151901245, 0.010879517, 0.008666992, 0.0037555695, -0.0064735413, 0.04260254, -0.027404785, 0.018676758, -0.015808105, 0.063964844, -0.012237549, -0.031173706, 0.04168701, -0.00756073, -0.049102783, 0.0043144226, 0.032562256, -0.024459839, -0.030883789, 0.024520874, 0.014328003, -0.016662598, -0.09210205, -0.007537842, 0.061798096, 0.00007236004, 0.0006942749, 0.041809082, -0.061645508, -0.022750854, 0.035614014, -0.038757324, 0.030960083, -0.023971558, -0.012863159, -0.04623413, 0.025970459, 0.011413574, -0.04031372, -0.06008911, -0.03036499, 0.012382507, -0.00097322464, -0.0036888123, -0.08905029, -0.031463623, -0.010391235, 0.015525818, -0.011871338, -0.0061149597, 0.025131226, -0.025115967, -0.06878662, 0.0059051514, -0.0045776367, 0.045288086, 0.0050582886, -0.0068969727, -0.03062439, 0.035217285, -0.011444092, -0.02458191, -0.017578125, 0.0005965233, -0.03353882, 0.0016584396, -0.0017137527, 0.011428833, 0.007965088, 0.0770874, 0.07598877, 0.029266357, 0.01309967, 0.004245758, -0.021850586, -0.028793335, -0.0121154785, 0.00025701523, -0.024642944, 0.015335083, 0.03338623, -0.046691895, -0.04473877, 0.038848877, -0.06298828, -0.051239014, -0.036956787, 0.023101807, -0.05014038, -0.04345703, -0.00034880638, 0.027191162, 0.05404663, -0.012748718, -0.044555664, 0.032958984, -0.019515991, -0.0028839111, 0.08679199, 0.031036377, 0.033233643, -0.029510498, 0.019073486, -0.017242432, -0.020690918, 0.013366699, 0.012168884, 0.02545166, 0.02809143, -0.02709961, 0.013900757, 0.009468079, -0.010360718, -0.012481689, 0.016525269, -0.018356323, -0.01360321, 0.0132751465, 0.012397766, -0.035247803, -0.02633667, -0.015304565, 0.050720215, -0.02571106, -0.034301758, 0.012054443, 0.0060157776, -0.029830933, 0.047668457, -0.024124146, -0.00868988, 0.009880066, 0.0109939575, 0.014579773, 0.022506714, 0.016555786, 0.010536194, -0.023788452, 0.017791748, 0.015808105, 0.021560669, 0.008354187, -0.00027918816, 0.037475586, -0.050994873, -0.052215576, 0.010986328, -0.020141602, 0.01651001, -0.028533936, 0.03652954, 0.016052246, -0.050842285, 0.007183075, 0.01235199, 0.018371582, -0.032409668, -0.054656982, 0.044067383, 0.051818848, -0.013092041 ], "summary": [ 0.04837036, -0.004085541, 0.06628418, -0.015380859, -0.039123535, 0.025024414, -0.01676941, -0.07196045, -0.0075683594, -0.035827637, -0.05166626, 0.021026611, -0.08557129, -0.017364502, 0.014785767, -0.0770874, 0.046081543, 0.00969696, 0.02330017, -0.02519226, -0.025238037, 0.016342163, 0.017364502, 0.056915283, -0.012931824, -0.0048217773, 0.043670654, -0.011169434, 0.00002259016, -0.01828003, 0.002319336, -0.005744934, -0.024520874, 0.042510986, 0.03060913, 0.03842163, -0.029037476, 0.06506348, 0.044891357, -0.009643555, -0.003917694, 0.0013799667, 0.009277344, -0.02128601, -0.022979736, 0.006958008, -0.02357483, -0.01651001, -0.0026378632, 0.032470703, 0.006706238, -0.018112183, 0.009315491, 0.02935791, 0.0009212494, 0.010040283, -0.016235352, -0.019882202, 0.0021591187, 0.059631348, 0.028030396, 0.0026741028, -0.0038528442, -0.046539307, 0.042663574, -0.031982422, 0.023391724, 0.020568848, 0.025604248, 0.06707764, 0.03213501, -0.0029392242, 0.04046631, -0.008552551, -0.0028648376, -0.0020980835, 0.02897644, 0.043548584, 0.010620117, -0.013725281, -0.022857666, 0.00025963783, 0.0154953, -0.036956787, -0.017700195, -0.036895752, -0.029052734, 0.011222839, -0.018981934, -0.017349243, -0.03286743, 0.041534424, -0.012329102, -0.037200928, -0.051971436, -0.015541077, -0.022003174, -0.031433105, -0.016204834, -0.0074157715, -0.02709961, -0.015106201, 0.008728027, -0.018295288, -0.0066108704, 0.066345215, 0.0103302, -0.0074539185, -0.0101623535, -0.008056641, 0.012489319, -0.058746338, 0.012557983, -0.05142212, 0.020019531, 0.04156494, 0.036315918, 0.05505371, 0.02381897, 0.027130127, -0.014511108, 0.00037145615, -0.006084442, 0.03717041, -0.025024414, -0.03665161, -0.015220642, 0.019897461, -0.0048103333, 0.083740234, -0.0054969788, -0.013710022, -0.058013916, -0.018310547, -0.04006958, -0.028289795, 0.0031871796, 0.03677368, 0.0008955002, -0.03213501, 0.044433594, -0.005115509, -0.0071258545, 0.039123535, 0.010848999, 0.016433716, 0.021621704, 0.015945435, 0.0049438477, -0.007511139, -0.007358551, -0.0055732727, 0.051116943, -0.04034424, -0.043701172, -0.109802246, -0.06414795, -0.044799805, 0.057495117, -0.04360962, -0.013450623, -0.012466431, -0.009613037, 0.01235199, -0.020324707, 0.013648987, 0.0368042, 0.004840851, 0.01272583, -0.03552246, 0.01737976, 0.026031494, 0.02520752, 0.00084733963, 0.012489319, 0.014862061, -0.0317688, -0.0036964417, 0.017303467, -0.020874023, -0.0019741058, -0.025863647, -0.020767212, 0.03604126, -0.011657715, -0.017471313, 0.013626099, 0.02772522, 0.0011444092, 0.023208618, -0.0087890625, -0.004600525, -0.031021118, 0.0035076141, 0.005317688, 0.04321289, -0.024902344, 0.039855957, -0.01096344, -0.040039062, 0.0032196045, 0.029067993, -0.016677856, 0.018936157, -0.020843506, 0.003063202, -0.011856079, 0.013786316, -0.033996582, 0.022277832, 0.04522705, -0.03189087, -0.05114746, 0.08239746, 0.033050537, -0.025222778, 0.042785645, -0.041168213, -0.0013437271, -0.04083252, -0.007045746, 0.011962891, -0.060180664, 0.032806396, 0.02961731, -0.02053833, -0.01727295, -0.017791748, 0.035125732, -0.009902954, 0.030838013, 0.036865234, -0.053894043, 0.015617371, -0.028579712, -0.016677856, -0.013542175, -0.0362854, 0.038635254, 0.041229248, 0.009025574, -0.0008854866, -0.017547607, 0.009086609, -0.042541504, -0.02243042, 0.029388428, -0.0071792603, -0.017990112, -0.017410278, 0.064331055, -0.014556885, 0.02078247, -0.019058228, 0.018112183, 0.01776123, -0.008712769, -0.012687683, -0.018615723, 0.037841797, -0.029296875, -0.016433716, 0.02229309, -0.023605347, -0.010734558, -0.034729004, 0.011833191, 0.0058517456, 0.02394104, -0.06463623, -0.0034275055, -0.034423828, -0.009216309, -0.06262207, -0.012802124, -0.025863647, -0.016082764, 0.03756714, -0.00011783838, -0.050048828, 0.024017334, 0.08331299, 0.064208984, -0.014823914, 0.022277832, 0.0101623535, -0.002161026, -0.024856567, 0.02104187, 0.022201538, 0.039215088, 0.0043792725, -0.018234253, -0.0070114136, 0.018798828, -0.033813477, -0.025848389, 0.009246826, 0.0001693964, -0.011070251, -0.06262207, 0.023345947, 0.015434265, -0.0423584, 0.02281189, 0.00207901, 0.033447266, -0.024353027, -0.021636963, 0.04043579, -0.08996582, -0.005092621, 0.014137268, 0.007663727, 0.022399902, -0.010345459, 0.012763977, 0.030090332, 0.013023376, 0.04534912, 0.06982422, 0.0030555725, -0.037353516, 0.0017280579, -0.008613586, -0.010108948, 0.013870239, -0.04083252, -0.06427002, -0.007888794, -0.020599365, -0.06311035, -0.045928955, 0.033966064, 0.00844574, 0.034423828, 0.0042686462, 0.04269409, 0.0054092407, -0.02142334, 0.02168274, -0.060150146, -0.014976501, 0.0071640015, -0.009239197, -0.043823242, -0.016433716, -0.0050354004, 0.0017852783, -0.02355957, 0.025848389, -0.02142334, -0.06744385, -0.020477295, -0.023834229, 0.052459717, 0.07751465, 0.015792847, 0.04083252, -0.026565552, 0.012359619, 0.06427002, -0.0016860962, -0.10900879, -0.05770874, -0.043762207, 0.016860962, -0.028549194, 0.0112838745, 0.043029785, 0.005935669, 0.04901123, -0.040771484, -0.012954712, -0.029953003, -0.008956909, 0.05142212, 0.008598328, -0.015090942, 0.01864624, 0.042541504, 0.014877319, 0.022720337, 0.0019254684, 0.12042236, -0.019592285, -0.047821045, 0.03237915, 0.020996094, 0.029830933, -0.031021118, -0.05368042, 0.03668213, -0.035980225, -0.021408081, -0.012809753, 0.0524292, 0.015655518, 0.032196045, -0.02658081, -0.0062179565, 0.009895325, 0.025100708, 0.018478394, -0.020523071, 0.028060913, 0.009468079, -0.0025348663, 0.020492554, -0.103271484, 0.025466919, -0.03668213, 0.017120361, -0.0680542, -0.00491333, -0.06750488, 0.05392456, 0.020523071, -0.029403687, -0.052368164, 0.02394104, -0.0028858185, -0.011543274, -0.020935059, 0.008262634, 0.052459717, -0.0060272217, 0.021530151, -0.022918701, -0.013664246, 0.022567749, -0.03994751, -0.031021118, -0.062164307, 0.014549255, 0.015075684, -0.021621704, 0.02281189, -0.037963867, 0.012199402, -0.105895996, -0.05899048, -0.017852783, 0.010643005, -0.016433716, -0.007888794, -0.05810547, -0.07446289, 0.012138367, 0.0013532639, -0.02357483, -0.00774765, 0.04812622, 0.011894226, -0.017242432, 0.0048713684, -0.009719849, -0.0020866394, -0.0009899139, 0.0009422302, -0.047821045, -0.01335144, 0.024459839, -0.06719971, -0.01876831, 0.023742676, 0.030792236, 0.003124237, -0.010940552, -0.013519287, -0.014022827, 0.0104522705, -0.04220581, -0.028060913, -0.013572693, -0.061584473, 0.059326172, 0.03375244, 0.049743652, -0.02973938, -0.0009531975, -0.004245758, 0.030792236, -0.026901245, -0.004173279, 0.000746727, -0.044647217, 0.010192871, 0.0022201538, 0.021865845, 0.053649902, -0.004211426, 0.051605225, -0.00008261204, -0.0018949509, -0.03982544, -0.0087509155, 0.016616821, 0.009536743, -0.044799805, -0.024902344, 0.03152466, 0.01537323, -0.02128601, -0.0524292, 0.03527832, 0.06274414, 0.03149414, 0.01423645, -0.07043457, 0.042419434, -0.04043579, 0.034179688, 0.031555176, -0.019836426, -0.018798828, 0.068237305, 0.03488159, -0.007904053, -0.004032135, 0.03503418, 0.05596924, -0.037109375, 0.017089844, 0.068359375, -0.026260376, -0.025161743, 0.009056091, -0.013580322, -0.0026474, 0.011886597, 0.01687622, 0.010116577, -0.0074005127, 0.010879517, -0.030227661, -0.017471313, -0.013046265, 0.031555176, 0.041137695, -0.023117065, -0.04373169, 0.018829346, 0.0463562, 0.0031738281, 0.013648987, -0.0109939575, 0.018432617, 0.00086688995, 0.021316528, -0.026687622, -0.02619934, -0.0051612854, -0.03479004, -0.021240234, 0.024047852, 0.014579773, -0.021469116, 0.00071907043, 0.041625977, 0.018692017, 0.010055542, 0.008171082, -0.039611816, -0.01663208, 0.0060806274, 0.017730713, -0.013244629, -0.031036377, -0.011222839, -0.03881836, -0.011772156, -0.014038086, -0.059814453, 0.025466919, -0.02053833, -0.004016876, 0.04257202, 0.01033783, 0.025527954, 0.027130127, 0.0057258606, -0.022766113, 0.037017822, -0.03262329, 0.013465881, 0.006713867, -0.015083313, -0.006389618, 0.019943237, 0.04232788, -0.0051879883, -0.050933838, -0.013175964, 0.041015625, 0.0005044937, 0.070495605, 0.007987976, 0.03253174, 0.03100586, -0.021865845, 0.048034668, 0.021240234, -0.0029506683, 0.016189575, 0.052246094, -0.008605957, 0.016921997, -0.024765015, -0.018585205, -0.0061950684, -0.027694702, 0.040008545, -0.003736496, 0.021896362, 0.043029785, -0.03213501, 0.002571106, -0.018569946, 0.028915405, 0.03741455, -0.031021118, 0.032989502, -0.009162903, 0.03692627, 0.04928589, -0.040802002, 0.02810669, -0.0048599243, -0.014022827, -0.0045318604, -0.024246216, -0.019241333, -0.043182373, -0.013206482, 0.034973145, -0.0038490295, -0.024261475, -0.037109375, -0.004676819, 0.022598267, 0.014160156, 0.0121154785, -0.046783447, -0.0044555664, -0.014007568, -0.015129089, -0.007663727, -0.022750854, -0.023544312, -0.020019531, 0.009361267, -0.06536865, 0.04812622, 0.023483276, 0.020584106, -0.0110321045, 0.023040771, -0.027618408, -0.013832092, -0.020233154, -0.018859863, -0.030517578, -0.0020809174, 0.04360962, 0.0029067993, -0.016708374, 0.052215576, -0.031982422, 0.041503906, 0.005382538, 0.01902771, 0.012283325, 0.020339966, 0.053985596, -0.00038981438, 0.002735138, 0.0038833618, -0.01876831, -0.022277832, -0.003660202, -0.05545044, 0.030563354, -0.02230835, -0.0046844482, 0.0066184998, -0.008842468, 0.023162842, 0.029891968, 0.007030487, 0.012023926, 0.027420044, 0.01725769, -0.019042969, -0.027282715, 0.004272461, 0.020828247, -0.04458618, 0.013168335, -0.055664062, -0.006542206, 0.021270752, 0.027008057, 0.025650024, -0.019561768, 0.010353088, 0.020553589, -0.04559326, 0.023666382, 0.03390503, -0.031585693, -0.058441162, -0.052124023, -0.00945282, -0.042999268, -0.020996094, -0.024902344, -0.005130768, -0.00166893, 0.042022705, 0.012191772, 0.03616333, 0.03062439, -0.06121826, 0.0079422, 0.003036499, -0.010665894, 0.039886475, -0.009887695, 0.00007933378, -0.00074481964, -0.03074646, -0.015464783, -0.005382538, 0.032318115, -0.078308105, 0.0124053955, 0.035217285, -0.0033245087, -0.00894165, -0.0043945312, -0.018173218, 0.0262146, -0.010932922, -0.036315918, -0.0023403168, 0.009506226, -0.052368164, -0.011756897, -0.026657104, 0.03756714, 0.0026760101, -0.027526855, 0.017715454, 0.03842163, 0.030334473, 0.056915283, -0.0029716492, -0.02331543, -0.021987915, -0.013015747, 0.009895325, -0.027694702, -0.036621094, -0.02532959, -0.02180481, -0.010749817, -0.017807007, -0.0033512115, -0.022872925, 0.013267517, 0.04458618, 0.01374054, 0.0012540817, -0.028320312, -0.032104492, 0.013038635, -0.026184082, -0.023651123, -0.052520752, 0.025253296, -0.015991211, 0.055877686, 0.03744507, -0.012962341, 0.032989502, -0.023727417, 0.023162842, -0.051452637, -0.022277832, -0.037231445, 0.050079346, 0.06149292, 0.01109314, 0.0035877228, -0.020370483, 0.017105103, 0.016159058, 0.048461914, -0.014228821, -0.00023853779, -0.008041382, -0.09881592, -0.07342529, -0.059661865, 0.005630493, 0.028335571, -0.06524658, -0.030227661, 0.056762695, -0.009284973, 0.02494812, 0.02961731, -0.014854431, -0.017578125, -0.010398865, 0.053344727, -0.0042381287, 0.048095703, 0.06298828, -0.051116943, -0.0025558472, 0.015686035, 0.034484863, -0.011604309, 0.002653122, 0.03265381, 0.0065231323, -0.040252686, -0.023025513, 0.046081543, -0.043273926, 0.0135650635, 0.0051193237, 0.006958008, 0.0287323, 0.023361206, 0.02255249, -0.006134033, 0.014549255, 0.041870117, -0.07080078, 0.031082153, 0.023345947, -0.02293396, -0.016098022, -0.0004925728, -0.0077934265, 0.037750244, 0.01991272, 0.03878784, -0.028076172, -0.020690918, 0.0061035156, 0.0070228577, 0.01637268, 0.03262329, -0.041015625, -0.02218628, -0.026947021, -0.034240723, 0.015213013, 0.022125244, 0.0037670135, -0.016433716, -0.014862061, -0.015686035, -0.0031776428, 0.0149383545, -0.0082473755, 0.028320312, -0.04446411, 0.05722046, 0.01789856, -0.023513794, 0.016647339, 0.02281189, -0.019729614, 0.011634827, 0.0066604614, 0.03491211, 0.016159058, 0.048309326, -0.028015137, -0.0030651093, 0.008926392, 0.016159058, 0.0284729, -0.004306793, 0.030853271, -0.0031776428, -0.031051636, 0.0047950745, -0.004173279, 0.016601562, 0.04788208, -0.033172607, -0.016708374, -0.023666382, -0.0010738373, -0.0206604, -0.004436493, -0.009117126, -0.043273926, -0.026184082, 0.011436462, 0.032165527, -0.032592773, 0.0078048706, -0.014183044, -0.019470215, 0.006855011, 0.009506226, 0.038208008, -0.0037498474, -0.004196167, -0.033843994, -0.00053691864, 0.038238525, -0.034851074, -0.013946533, -0.013336182, 0.04269409, -0.014884949, -0.06628418, -0.021652222, 0.011619568, 0.019760132, -0.04937744, 0.03012085, 0.03387451, -0.0030994415, 0.052978516, 0.0960083, 0.011199951, 0.015853882, 0.025177002, -0.015380859, -0.0058135986, -0.021865845, 0.009483337, -0.03527832, -0.016296387, -0.0025310516, 0.0007286072, -0.038085938, 0.06542969, -0.020492554, -0.02748108, -0.019180298, -0.0076560974, -0.034088135, -0.0541687, -0.00023400784, 0.040527344, 0.07244873, 0.05441284, 0.030822754, 0.061767578, -0.0848999, 0.019805908, 0.012481689, 0.004837036, 0.0017204285, -0.03149414, 0.025268555, -0.0085372925, -0.010749817, 0.012916565, -0.0052757263, 0.05886841, 0.019424438, -0.040130615, 0.022644043, 0.0104904175, -0.012413025, -0.029327393, -0.027801514, 0.023223877, -0.050872803, 0.015617371, 0.011047363, -0.03479004, -0.022613525, 0.03289795, 0.030685425, -0.03668213, -0.07336426, 0.021652222, -0.0135650635, -0.035583496, -0.017822266, -0.049316406, 0.025405884, -0.033172607, -0.008361816, -0.0079193115, -0.00762558, -0.008895874, 0.03201294, -0.009254456, 0.0063819885, 0.0074272156, 0.012107849, 0.0067214966, 0.010375977, 0.029129028, -0.055847168, -0.017181396, 0.014434814, -0.016235352, 0.020568848, -0.026321411, -0.009246826, 0.02180481, -0.033081055, 0.04055786, -0.00063943863, 0.057769775, 0.010360718, 0.008232117, 0.05682373, 0.011444092, 0.008758545 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1812.09338v3
Position Bias Estimation for Unbiased Learning-to-Rank in eCommerce Search
Grigor Aslanyan, Utkarsh Porwal
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
The Unbiased Learning-to-Rank framework has been recently proposed as a general approach to systematically remove biases, such as position bias, from learning-to-rank models. The method takes two steps - estimating click propensities and using them to train unbiased models. Most common methods proposed in the literature for estimating propensities involve some degree of intervention in the live search engine. An alternative approach proposed recently uses an Expectation Maximization (EM) algorithm to estimate propensities by using ranking features for estimating relevances. In this work we propose a novel method to directly estimate propensities which does not use any intervention in live search or rely on modeling relevance. Rather, we take advantage of the fact that the same query-document pair may naturally change ranks over time. This typically occurs for eCommerce search because of change of popularity of items over time, existence of time dependent ranking features, or addition or removal of items to the index (an item getting sold or a new item being listed). However, our method is general and can be applied to any search engine for which the rank of the same document may naturally change over time for the same query. We derive a simple likelihood function that depends on propensities only, and by maximizing the likelihood we are able to get estimates of the propensities. We apply this method to eBay search data to estimate click propensities for web and mobile search and compare these with estimates using the EM method. We also use simulated data to show that the method gives reliable estimates of the "true" simulated propensities. Finally, we train an unbiased learning-to-rank model for eBay search using the estimated propensities and show that it outperforms both baselines - one without position bias correction and one with position bias correction using the EM method.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.09338v3
2019-10-22T17:53:19
2018-12-21T19:05:15
{ "title": [ 0.005970001, 0.002954483, -0.0079956055, 0.001906395, 0.010375977, -0.028213501, 0.013114929, -0.057525635, 0.028045654, 0.027359009, -0.039520264, 0.0077590942, 0.0051612854, -0.014030457, -0.022155762, -0.012046814, -0.008979797, 0.0181427, -0.017990112, -0.018463135, 0.0021686554, -0.031311035, 0.040283203, 0.026550293, 0.028182983, -0.009918213, -0.024353027, 0.0045433044, -0.007160187, -0.0018548965, 0.010971069, -0.016433716, 0.04067993, -0.024719238, 0.029647827, -0.002922058, -0.05166626, 0.017181396, -0.00022447109, -0.008590698, 0.012893677, -0.014816284, -0.04055786, 0.010894775, -0.036590576, 0.033721924, -0.056762695, -0.029220581, -0.0234375, -0.020645142, 0.01889038, 0.05657959, 0.029083252, -0.020736694, 0.017471313, -0.019515991, -0.014076233, -0.0010509491, 0.04043579, 0.027633667, 0.0056495667, -0.02281189, 0.010353088, -0.02104187, -0.035461426, -0.0262146, 0.043670654, 0.0065193176, 0.052490234, -0.009063721, -0.010307312, 0.057250977, 0.024002075, 0.04119873, -0.078063965, -0.06317139, 0.07922363, 0.017913818, 0.032989502, -0.02810669, 0.003353119, 0.0093307495, -0.04147339, -0.053253174, 0.019180298, -0.06768799, -0.01965332, -0.0025100708, -0.036621094, -0.05456543, -0.008178711, 0.012008667, -0.058654785, 0.005355835, -0.008987427, -0.044067383, 0.007507324, 0.066101074, 0.012275696, -0.013999939, -0.05697632, 0.029312134, -0.08526611, -0.008834839, 0.02017212, 0.009094238, -0.021606445, 0.004634857, 0.030700684, 0.013267517, -0.020874023, 0.03564453, -0.008087158, 0.0060043335, 0.0026454926, 0.005340576, -0.009506226, 0.013534546, -0.0062179565, 0.023468018, -0.0010824203, -0.015106201, 0.019378662, 0.005039215, 0.013504028, -0.0032138824, -0.027542114, 0.006160736, -0.04248047, 0.03567505, 0.030136108, 0.057556152, -0.07879639, -0.068847656, -0.08709717, 0.042053223, -0.006767273, 0.008354187, 0.014450073, -0.016540527, 0.023544312, -0.019104004, 0.013786316, 0.038330078, 0.023483276, -0.0074272156, 0.04525757, 0.007820129, -0.012069702, 0.024765015, -0.04916382, 0.054718018, 0.017150879, -0.017608643, -0.060058594, -0.022583008, -0.10870361, -0.020431519, 0.039733887, -0.011314392, 0.01940918, 0.0015029907, -0.005428314, -0.015899658, 0.0054740906, -0.01411438, -0.035217285, 0.023468018, 0.010772705, 0.022064209, -0.047454834, 0.002960205, 0.018478394, -0.03756714, -0.033416748, 0.009750366, 0.036865234, 0.015037537, 0.014640808, -0.02130127, 0.021987915, -0.00548172, 0.05899048, 0.014907837, -0.05706787, 0.0149002075, 0.005115509, 0.016906738, 0.026443481, 0.00046539307, -0.020828247, 0.03778076, -0.028640747, -0.021560669, -0.01852417, -0.0004427433, 0.010650635, 0.026062012, -0.0026550293, -0.02053833, -0.042388916, 0.027023315, -0.048950195, 0.009712219, -0.0013780594, -0.041900635, 0.0064582825, 0.026992798, -0.048217773, 0.045837402, 0.06756592, 0.006713867, -0.05307007, 0.03881836, 0.0115737915, -0.06878662, 0.029556274, -0.012901306, -0.007965088, -0.040039062, -0.0181427, -0.0005660057, -0.018707275, 0.04776001, 0.0143585205, 0.00019168854, 0.016799927, -0.006965637, 0.072631836, 0.017044067, 0.10229492, -0.047302246, 0.038909912, 0.037963867, 0.0022659302, -0.011070251, -0.001748085, -0.03451538, 0.025512695, 0.0028038025, -0.00756073, 0.010986328, 0.00015091896, 0.050720215, 0.04925537, -0.009284973, 0.006061554, 0.050720215, 0.019195557, 0.045532227, 0.05731201, 0.031463623, 0.024047852, -0.008575439, 0.008293152, 0.0446167, 0.014381409, 0.046722412, -0.04864502, 0.005039215, -0.001209259, 0.04171753, 0.025558472, 0.008804321, -0.020141602, 0.02558899, -0.011116028, 0.0023880005, -0.024887085, 0.04321289, 0.040802002, -0.007980347, 0.006340027, -0.044128418, -0.019165039, -0.031982422, -0.015403748, 0.04232788, 0.0129852295, -0.0670166, -0.010520935, 0.007534027, 0.039642334, -0.016952515, -0.004901886, -0.048095703, 0.027252197, -0.014762878, -0.03515625, -0.055664062, 0.019363403, 0.02746582, -0.005722046, -0.008201599, -0.003818512, -0.009010315, 0.038513184, 0.06793213, -0.02748108, 0.040771484, -0.055725098, 0.006565094, -0.0021419525, -0.0038204193, 0.021255493, 0.025131226, 0.02381897, 0.007835388, -0.012664795, 0.043273926, -0.070739746, 0.009483337, 0.014305115, -0.02053833, -0.02923584, -0.041656494, -0.017562866, -0.03866577, -0.11236572, -0.06149292, 0.09295654, -0.04525757, 0.0019187927, 0.010955811, -0.02305603, -0.049224854, 0.03591919, -0.024978638, 0.03164673, 0.034729004, -0.008155823, 0.02885437, -0.07208252, -0.013198853, -0.0029678345, 0.0052375793, -0.014167786, 0.020187378, -0.008964539, 0.0127334595, 0.007873535, 0.05847168, 0.011512756, -0.056427002, 0.008049011, -0.047912598, 0.004180908, 0.012512207, -0.061462402, -0.0036201477, 0.03564453, -0.039489746, -0.03555298, -0.016967773, 0.041748047, -0.019424438, -0.014045715, -0.0038223267, 0.00459671, -0.020523071, 0.015098572, 0.0077171326, -0.017456055, -0.062072754, -0.018692017, -0.015045166, -0.02204895, -0.0135269165, -0.0021896362, 0.027877808, -0.06414795, -0.027313232, -0.029083252, 0.013061523, 0.027526855, 0.026916504, 0.022247314, -0.019866943, -0.017166138, -0.007183075, -0.007980347, -0.0027770996, -0.03314209, 0.01953125, 0.020187378, 0.042175293, 0.029647827, 0.018829346, 0.005065918, -0.037078857, 0.0072135925, 0.06335449, -0.019363403, 0.006919861, 0.016571045, -0.006214142, -0.015007019, 0.006477356, -0.08105469, 0.0021896362, -0.0070648193, 0.0033302307, -0.04144287, 0.01424408, -0.038391113, -0.0015869141, -0.00819397, -0.040924072, 0.011428833, 0.026504517, 0.020996094, 0.005504608, 0.009963989, 0.010231018, 0.008590698, -0.047332764, -0.06756592, 0.038238525, -0.0309906, -0.029647827, -0.005329132, 0.02482605, -0.04711914, -0.015579224, -0.008178711, 0.029907227, 0.019866943, 0.015342712, 0.012786865, -0.018692017, -0.007858276, -0.03842163, 0.008560181, -0.03555298, -0.06756592, -0.036621094, -0.004512787, 0.0793457, 0.014625549, -0.020645142, -0.05368042, -0.019821167, 0.02017212, 0.029556274, 0.007030487, -0.025756836, -0.015136719, -0.026382446, -0.00079870224, -0.0011043549, -0.01864624, -0.007507324, -0.003873825, 0.013328552, -0.02758789, 0.045013428, -0.001124382, 0.012664795, 0.0064353943, -0.022079468, 0.0335083, -0.021224976, -0.039916992, 0.022506714, 0.016036987, 0.02947998, 0.017578125, -0.0017557144, -0.044830322, 0.022583008, 0.0016803741, -0.033721924, -0.004627228, -0.022140503, 0.015701294, -0.01322937, -0.023269653, 0.016784668, -0.018203735, -0.0042533875, 0.036590576, -0.0034732819, 0.00044083595, -0.056274414, 0.039245605, -0.01777649, -0.10290527, -0.05697632, 0.031341553, -0.024932861, -0.0039787292, -0.06185913, 0.026641846, -0.0066871643, -0.020355225, 0.0055503845, 0.002773285, -0.010795593, -0.004272461, -0.075805664, 0.0138168335, 0.070617676, -0.016723633, 0.03768921, 0.019683838, 0.0037517548, -0.020217896, -0.027740479, 0.016052246, -0.028961182, 0.008705139, -0.002714157, -0.025253296, 0.027618408, -0.009750366, 0.00856781, 0.06536865, 0.0033130646, 0.031982422, -0.0013580322, -0.009742737, -0.022018433, -0.01008606, 0.033477783, 0.011810303, 0.005393982, -0.018035889, 0.027191162, -0.016342163, -0.0015106201, -0.007686615, -0.024490356, 0.0112838745, 0.013198853, 0.029342651, 0.032562256, -0.010520935, -0.0063591003, 0.00086164474, -0.0024585724, -0.030929565, -0.033355713, 0.022033691, 0.0004863739, 0.0067481995, -0.0038375854, -0.04937744, -0.0035972595, -0.005268097, -0.02633667, -0.0135269165, -0.0041275024, -0.051940918, -0.009971619, -0.030380249, -0.04156494, -0.051574707, 0.015701294, -0.035247803, 0.03378296, 0.019424438, 0.0070610046, -0.057403564, 0.04095459, -0.0043296814, 0.0041999817, -0.00067710876, -0.048736572, -0.027023315, -0.02015686, -0.06732178, -0.025558472, 0.017929077, 0.025970459, 0.039886475, -0.016677856, 0.0035057068, 0.0082473755, 0.03744507, -0.0049743652, 0.009597778, -0.02357483, 0.0023117065, -0.015686035, -0.0096206665, -0.06323242, 0.0435791, -0.006996155, -0.011764526, -0.034454346, 0.03842163, -0.021209717, -0.025253296, -0.062408447, 0.015281677, -0.009857178, -0.0046539307, 0.037902832, 0.0680542, 0.021820068, 0.03353882, -0.003200531, 0.012794495, -0.022567749, -0.031280518, -0.014823914, 0.035003662, 0.0075416565, 0.046173096, 0.061309814, 0.0058631897, 0.017547607, -0.034851074, 0.028121948, 0.007896423, -0.023727417, -0.02357483, 0.020950317, -0.028213501, -0.012191772, 0.015945435, -0.008239746, 0.039886475, -0.024230957, 0.031433105, 0.0024280548, 0.010276794, 0.05218506, -0.0010194778, 0.014602661, 0.022460938, -0.0030174255, -0.06124878, -0.01210022, 0.016937256, 0.017822266, -0.05090332, -0.008468628, -0.03427124, -0.028961182, 0.04156494, 0.04421997, 0.03137207, -0.0124435425, -0.039764404, -0.005836487, -0.0021705627, -0.041046143, -0.036956787, -0.0074768066, 0.002626419, 0.019119263, -0.052337646, 0.01586914, -0.021118164, -0.020324707, -0.02468872, -0.009048462, 0.029907227, -0.067871094, -0.0010623932, 0.039978027, 0.01878357, 0.011505127, 0.01550293, 0.026290894, 0.04650879, 0.045318604, 0.015106201, 0.022521973, 0.041107178, -0.015823364, 0.040283203, 0.020736694, 0.040405273, -0.0037059784, -0.0047302246, 0.0011234283, -0.020263672, -0.028823853, 0.03262329, -0.0012798309, -0.038330078, -0.012336731, -0.009506226, 0.0046463013, 0.023010254, 0.017822266, 0.022842407, -0.008850098, 0.0035858154, 0.019226074, -0.017654419, -0.022476196, 0.021499634, 0.0049591064, -0.016815186, -0.06890869, -0.021896362, -0.034423828, 0.017715454, -0.017593384, 0.041870117, -0.034240723, 0.0501709, 0.04940796, -0.07678223, 0.011146545, 0.031463623, 0.029464722, 0.05718994, 0.0014572144, -0.06665039, -0.021209717, -0.04537964, -0.044036865, -0.021392822, 0.050079346, 0.06842041, 0.019119263, 0.0146865845, -0.0146865845, 0.03289795, -0.00466156, 0.02897644, 0.017227173, 0.009635925, 0.045562744, 0.0020523071, 0.00054883957, -0.019927979, 0.04284668, -0.0087509155, 0.0038604736, 0.011314392, -0.01260376, 0.021331787, 0.019851685, 0.044006348, -0.03555298, -0.039764404, -0.00459671, 0.03137207, 0.002796173, 0.026565552, 0.031677246, 0.029388428, 0.06726074, -0.01902771, 0.013191223, 0.026672363, -0.045166016, -0.00198555, -0.004272461, 0.00080156326, -0.033355713, 0.043701172, -0.0013895035, -0.0060539246, -0.053131104, -0.015930176, -0.028503418, 0.009941101, 0.020645142, -0.021209717, 0.013206482, -0.04812622, 0.002336502, -0.058685303, -0.023025513, -0.016342163, 0.044891357, -0.0010099411, -0.030136108, 0.0012407303, -0.0335083, 0.029922485, -0.036102295, -0.02168274, -0.029663086, 0.00004708767, -0.019180298, -0.044128418, 0.019317627, -0.03717041, 0.009529114, 0.023635864, 0.026626587, -0.02041626, 0.010910034, -0.0146102905, 0.043701172, 0.034362793, 0.056732178, 0.0491333, 0.026733398, 0.025268555, 0.017562866, 0.051635742, -0.014808655, -0.020599365, -0.047576904, 0.014709473, 0.0033626556, 0.022766113, -0.0847168, 0.035705566, 0.037506104, 0.020553589, 0.0025234222, 0.010795593, -0.015136719, 0.03567505, 0.037078857, 0.030899048, 0.03894043, 0.020477295, 0.014762878, 0.0044021606, -0.036895752, 0.013771057, 0.02998352, -0.012039185, 0.009094238, -0.008239746, -0.024765015, -0.01878357, 0.0129776, 0.040649414, 0.0062294006, -0.02557373, -0.006038666, 0.05847168, 0.009025574, 0.03842163, 0.04815674, -0.005092621, -0.025863647, -0.027694702, -0.0032901764, 0.024124146, -0.02418518, 0.010917664, 0.04006958, -0.011016846, 0.011131287, -0.024719238, -0.020233154, 0.013420105, 0.0041618347, 0.039733887, -0.06762695, -0.06317139, 0.042938232, 0.026885986, 0.008399963, 0.055511475, -0.020248413, -0.0146484375, -0.023117065, 0.0070724487, 0.007965088, 0.019973755, -0.008331299, 0.04260254, -0.024963379, -0.013771057, 0.018661499, -0.013427734, 0.00774765, 0.01687622, -0.040527344, 0.08099365, -0.0020217896, -0.043884277, -0.008514404, 0.028945923, -0.09625244, -0.014511108, 0.009597778, 0.078125, 0.0647583, 0.06695557, -0.014778137, -0.0158844, 0.05178833, -0.048706055, 0.027236938, 0.08758545, -0.016204834, 0.059631348, -0.012535095, -0.052734375, 0.086120605, -0.0569458, 0.056488037, -0.009437561, 0.017822266, -0.026229858, -0.026016235, 0.06161499, -0.06222534, 0.014289856, -0.012565613, -0.020080566, 0.004016876, 0.00642395, -0.02357483, -0.013572693, -0.013748169, 0.0134887695, 0.010932922, -0.013801575, -0.0018930435, -0.0006508827, -0.017700195, -0.024917603, -0.043518066, -0.0008111, -0.05331421, -0.02809143, -0.0060195923, -0.006504059, 0.024215698, -0.027999878, -0.046844482, -0.010040283, 0.020324707, -0.05987549, 0.019134521, 0.013542175, -0.008232117, -0.025161743, -0.0031051636, -0.01663208, -0.030914307, -0.009300232, 0.01499176, -0.049346924, -0.054229736, -0.0149002075, -0.036865234, 0.043762207, 0.043029785, -0.011054993, -0.009765625, 0.008644104, -0.007926941, -0.015213013, 0.035980225, 0.048828125, -0.019897461, -0.0501709, 0.01084137, 0.041229248, 0.050476074, -0.010040283, 0.021133423, 0.031951904, 0.019485474, 0.00095653534, 0.040374756, 0.018432617, -0.007686615, -0.012329102, 0.024551392, 0.0056533813, -0.020263672, -0.022735596, -0.05203247, 0.038391113, 0.044952393, -0.022705078, -0.0026226044, 0.036590576, 0.015525818, -0.029220581, 0.029678345, -0.0040664673, -0.021759033, 0.010803223, -0.003534317, -0.026550293, -0.057617188, -0.013412476, -0.014602661, 0.003358841, 0.033569336, -0.026138306, 0.010009766, -0.022735596, 0.018753052, -0.0056762695, 0.006000519, 0.027191162, -0.00082731247, 0.033294678, 0.015625, 0.01348114, 0.0060577393, -0.027832031, -0.004207611, 0.022262573, 0.003921509, -0.009895325, 0.013114929, 0.029281616, -0.0035800934, -0.027160645, -0.0021095276, -0.024291992, 0.03152466, -0.028411865, -0.017181396, -0.0037384033, -0.06427002, -0.0053100586, 0.026245117, -0.002670288, -0.059906006, -0.019348145, 0.0040130615, 0.053649902, 0.003660202 ], "summary": [ 0.062927246, 0.036193848, 0.04071045, 0.039489746, 0.0039405823, -0.02885437, 0.039642334, -0.107788086, 0.046295166, 0.002658844, -0.04562378, -0.016479492, 0.01184845, -0.029418945, 0.014656067, -0.021209717, -0.019805908, 0.016082764, 0.016479492, -0.030349731, 0.010292053, -0.045837402, 0.03074646, -0.021026611, 0.033050537, -0.061065674, 0.06890869, 0.0069007874, 0.054992676, 0.03149414, 0.033233643, -0.05230713, 0.009208679, 0.0043945312, 0.032043457, 0.0028705597, 0.012542725, 0.0056915283, 0.024536133, 0.0115737915, 0.009597778, 0.0019741058, 0.0014457703, -0.011680603, -0.02659607, -0.0027599335, 0.016815186, -0.010940552, 0.009925842, -0.04559326, -0.0062179565, 0.01828003, 0.0074005127, -0.03918457, -0.016113281, -0.0052337646, -0.028945923, 0.0059776306, -0.00062417984, 0.052734375, 0.031051636, 0.018005371, -0.0052337646, -0.025985718, -0.020065308, -0.01146698, 0.05432129, -0.0024147034, 0.022949219, -0.014427185, 0.0020275116, 0.03048706, 0.014457703, -0.0047340393, -0.10333252, -0.020889282, 0.06384277, -0.012825012, -0.0012378693, -0.035614014, 0.0076522827, 0.023269653, -0.010978699, -0.044555664, 0.011062622, -0.03491211, -0.015792847, -0.007926941, -0.053833008, -0.025985718, -0.019882202, 0.025848389, -0.08514404, 0.0020332336, -0.009811401, -0.018173218, 0.03829956, 0.048583984, 0.024108887, 0.0020694733, -0.03265381, -0.0105896, -0.044525146, -0.015113831, 0.007610321, 0.0022678375, 0.0027999878, -0.0075645447, 0.026229858, 0.014915466, -0.021697998, 0.029907227, -0.029342651, 0.021743774, -0.0143585205, 0.00970459, -0.047668457, 0.030700684, -0.037353516, 0.0524292, -0.025238037, 0.0044059753, 0.013824463, -0.0068244934, -0.007118225, -0.009750366, -0.018615723, 0.0062675476, -0.010025024, 0.01852417, 0.009094238, 0.020492554, -0.023529053, -0.0025157928, -0.047943115, 0.009246826, -0.003786087, -0.004508972, 0.007537842, -0.011817932, 0.042053223, -0.013374329, 0.016204834, 0.03845215, 0.029937744, -0.011444092, 0.014198303, 0.025741577, 0.0259552, 0.049957275, -0.03564453, 0.038391113, 0.047302246, -0.02267456, -0.10394287, -0.06732178, -0.084106445, -0.018829346, 0.039794922, -0.047851562, 0.021865845, -0.012840271, -0.007633209, -0.028793335, -0.03277588, -0.0049934387, -0.013504028, 0.0010213852, 0.017364502, 0.029830933, -0.016738892, -0.011405945, 0.038146973, -0.010353088, -0.018081665, 0.011444092, -0.0015707016, 0.029159546, 0.02420044, -0.009376526, 0.019104004, -0.026107788, 0.07269287, -0.00013756752, -0.0075263977, 0.0048561096, 0.0045547485, 0.004299164, 0.014678955, 0.010101318, -0.012390137, 0.014450073, -0.0011863708, -0.019104004, 0.029083252, 0.008857727, -0.028778076, 0.0015258789, 0.009269714, -0.05050659, -0.007118225, 0.00016641617, -0.037994385, -0.018707275, -0.04562378, -0.041259766, 0.005191803, 0.030960083, -0.059387207, 0.035583496, 0.05819702, 0.0052452087, -0.043701172, 0.043670654, 0.039093018, -0.07098389, 0.02998352, -0.0009174347, -0.01663208, -0.031097412, -0.008583069, -0.010597229, -0.02444458, 0.05609131, -0.026290894, 0.014984131, -0.015022278, 0.01902771, 0.017028809, 0.014694214, 0.08807373, -0.009757996, 0.05706787, 0.07519531, 0.015823364, -0.006160736, 0.052459717, -0.08892822, 0.026748657, 0.015777588, 0.015396118, 0.028579712, -0.01222229, 0.038635254, 0.029769897, -0.0025482178, 0.006755829, 0.026290894, -0.0037345886, 0.04373169, 0.0446167, 0.037231445, 0.0026378632, 0.011199951, 0.02268982, 0.020401001, 0.0011224747, 0.030380249, -0.052734375, 0.0059814453, -0.0057029724, 0.026443481, 0.005027771, 0.0026435852, 0.0006608963, -0.026779175, 0.0057792664, -0.002105713, -0.00484848, -0.022613525, 0.03262329, 0.003047943, 0.0065307617, -0.05886841, -0.035949707, 0.0010719299, -0.05545044, 0.056762695, 0.0552063, -0.04611206, -0.017837524, 0.015357971, 0.012420654, -0.027648926, 0.005924225, 0.0070648193, 0.011291504, -0.054840088, 0.020843506, 0.012077332, 0.024673462, 0.028961182, -0.008163452, 0.031555176, -0.0035037994, -0.012588501, -0.082092285, -0.015350342, 0.03265381, -0.04888916, -0.03933716, 0.04638672, -0.016357422, 0.025054932, -0.00021612644, 0.034423828, 0.024520874, 0.0061950684, 0.015586853, 0.010391235, -0.001613617, 0.0116119385, 0.023849487, 0.03274536, -0.026229858, -0.04309082, -0.03527832, 0.017303467, -0.076416016, -0.0032043457, 0.11248779, -0.03567505, 0.015945435, 0.00756073, -0.026931763, -0.06488037, 0.052825928, -0.023956299, 0.048339844, -0.02999878, -0.03744507, -0.020492554, -0.04168701, 0.0005507469, 0.0055122375, -0.02772522, 0.0032424927, -0.0074272156, 0.026535034, 0.044128418, 0.06817627, 0.060546875, 0.01033783, -0.010345459, -0.02166748, -0.027572632, -0.021896362, -0.00012362003, -0.032226562, -0.029724121, 0.03982544, -0.032073975, -0.04208374, 0.010345459, -0.009735107, -0.016830444, 0.027008057, -0.02709961, -0.031433105, -0.05291748, 0.04348755, -0.0028514862, -0.002626419, -0.064086914, -0.018478394, -0.020233154, 0.008140564, -0.046020508, 0.023101807, 0.02507019, -0.034454346, 0.013809204, -0.023483276, 0.0064086914, 0.016693115, 0.027160645, 0.07171631, -0.0016708374, 0.022567749, 0.029296875, 0.0045928955, -0.0149383545, -0.014984131, -0.038513184, 0.004383087, 0.04067993, 0.047424316, 0.047851562, 0.016113281, -0.04196167, 0.019638062, 0.07702637, 0.012969971, -0.035614014, 0.0014410019, 0.0008893013, 0.027648926, -0.003900528, 0.047454834, -0.04751587, -0.06695557, -0.0023059845, -0.03189087, 0.0022506714, -0.011199951, 0.033355713, -0.01423645, -0.045410156, 0.011230469, -0.0004646778, 0.050964355, -0.017547607, 0.032165527, -0.0046195984, -0.0075683594, -0.036346436, 0.014732361, 0.021575928, -0.011993408, -0.03729248, -0.018051147, 0.065979004, -0.026229858, -0.01878357, 0.008636475, -0.0027217865, 0.002067566, -0.006023407, 0.010070801, -0.008331299, -0.004333496, -0.022918701, 0.007484436, -0.022644043, -0.072143555, -0.031051636, 0.006088257, 0.027389526, 0.029418945, -0.046783447, -0.062805176, -0.013435364, -0.006000519, 0.006324768, -0.00081825256, -0.013893127, 0.0031585693, -0.04510498, 0.01335144, -0.009231567, -0.013206482, -0.00090551376, 0.053222656, 0.035339355, -0.015823364, 0.042755127, 0.029083252, 0.02482605, 0.045074463, -0.030334473, 0.01461792, -0.0015268326, -0.06939697, 0.008605957, 0.010528564, 0.019699097, 0.016525269, 0.046142578, 0.0259552, -0.03277588, 0.05316162, -0.023651123, -0.018875122, -0.026855469, -0.010688782, -0.020385742, 0.031982422, 0.012374878, 0.026412964, -0.020996094, 0.025177002, -0.0052871704, 0.028015137, 0.0020217896, 0.023468018, 0.008079529, -0.06518555, -0.060028076, 0.027938843, -0.0015192032, -0.0033626556, -0.03012085, 0.018493652, 0.020507812, 0.00011461973, 0.007820129, -0.013435364, 0.010643005, -0.015213013, -0.051574707, 0.033355713, 0.0010910034, -0.02166748, 0.01033783, -0.045684814, 0.018295288, 0.020507812, -0.032958984, -0.0022850037, -0.04309082, -0.028717041, -0.050933838, 0.018692017, 0.013137817, 0.004798889, -0.018615723, 0.08648682, 0.011260986, 0.028686523, -0.023391724, 0.047943115, 0.012008667, 0.016159058, -0.004699707, 0.011428833, 0.019210815, -0.0037460327, 0.0012483597, -0.021957397, -0.01348114, -0.007835388, 0.038330078, -0.03982544, -0.004245758, 0.031051636, -0.03491211, -0.03604126, -0.0385437, 0.02243042, 0.044921875, -0.018585205, -0.025054932, -0.017181396, 0.058807373, 0.012634277, -0.0071372986, -0.019943237, -0.014549255, -0.0068092346, -0.003314972, -0.018844604, -0.016723633, -0.03466797, -0.0040130615, -0.015007019, -0.020980835, -0.048065186, 0.0022354126, -0.020126343, 0.059631348, 0.0035190582, 0.00881958, -0.039764404, 0.037017822, -0.018463135, 0.02130127, -0.02859497, -0.061584473, -0.022979736, -0.016983032, -0.052978516, -0.029266357, -0.028930664, -0.0043296814, -0.0010375977, 0.012435913, 0.010978699, -0.0129470825, 0.029937744, -0.02571106, -0.026062012, 0.0053367615, 0.027633667, -0.074279785, -0.015808105, -0.043884277, 0.041015625, -0.0030670166, 0.0066108704, -0.016616821, 0.03552246, -0.03741455, -0.045318604, -0.061340332, 0.022567749, 0.036895752, -0.028259277, 0.03933716, 0.059448242, 0.034332275, 0.008781433, -0.0022411346, 0.0059776306, 0.003967285, -0.018447876, -0.0009918213, -0.0012397766, 0.048217773, 0.018966675, 0.044830322, 0.0018577576, 0.011108398, -0.02619934, 0.01739502, 0.00831604, -0.010986328, -0.021575928, 0.023864746, 0.01852417, 0.012802124, 0.029846191, -0.0067863464, 0.013771057, 0.0010995865, -0.017822266, 0.0152282715, -0.00094747543, 0.03677368, -0.0009188652, -0.0002770424, 0.04260254, -0.027572632, -0.03375244, 0.007423401, 0.010223389, 0.00881958, -0.05166626, -0.028518677, -0.072753906, -0.050750732, 0.026733398, 0.033294678, 0.019958496, -0.043029785, -0.018447876, -0.027786255, -0.025054932, -0.013931274, -0.031204224, -0.016784668, -0.0003244877, 0.009002686, -0.020080566, 0.014419556, 0.022094727, -0.02897644, -0.018447876, -0.016494751, 0.02885437, -0.062347412, -0.08111572, -0.02558899, -0.0059814453, -0.037841797, 0.011161804, 0.043762207, 0.035827637, 0.02468872, 0.017654419, -0.014175415, 0.0065078735, 0.009178162, -0.008323669, 0.03555298, 0.04748535, -0.0025520325, 0.015930176, 0.014389038, -0.050842285, 0.0044136047, -0.0067863464, -0.04727173, 0.00705719, -0.050201416, 0.01525116, 0.01449585, 0.02217102, 0.008705139, -0.013771057, 0.016052246, 0.0043754578, 0.017089844, -0.017730713, -0.0034103394, 0.005470276, -0.051330566, -0.022949219, -0.00932312, -0.03805542, -0.009048462, 0.030059814, -0.0054512024, 0.023910522, -0.016281128, -0.0011358261, 0.029251099, -0.047546387, -0.0014896393, 0.050598145, 0.040130615, 0.014770508, -0.020843506, -0.058013916, -0.012458801, -0.049316406, -0.002691269, 0.0054512024, 0.03579712, 0.05429077, 0.034423828, -0.0069847107, 0.006511688, 0.057128906, -0.02949524, 0.0104599, 0.021438599, 0.01360321, 0.024490356, 0.011238098, 0.000058054924, 0.0002322197, -0.03918457, -0.03994751, 0.012763977, 0.009277344, 0.012588501, 0.01763916, 0.02355957, 0.026550293, -0.015045166, -0.0034275055, -0.016433716, 0.044189453, -0.009017944, 0.024139404, -0.0071144104, -0.00970459, 0.06976318, 0.0009675026, -0.0004749298, 0.03503418, -0.0033245087, -0.0017490387, 0.002407074, 0.018981934, -0.0054969788, 0.022537231, 0.016204834, -0.003227234, -0.027740479, 0.0065574646, 0.014862061, -0.01940918, 0.01109314, -0.04083252, 0.008468628, -0.007286072, -0.008651733, -0.023803711, -0.02243042, -0.002691269, 0.010749817, -0.009887695, -0.0015211105, 0.029052734, -0.023422241, 0.06451416, -0.05355835, -0.049926758, -0.05847168, -0.0039100647, -0.032714844, -0.02583313, 0.045410156, -0.023773193, 0.0072402954, 0.027816772, 0.02482605, -0.00957489, 0.019439697, 0.014533997, 0.027572632, 0.029953003, 0.029525757, 0.030410767, 0.045715332, 0.04751587, 0.013793945, 0.076293945, 0.013549805, -0.009208679, -0.008476257, 0.0151901245, 0.03552246, 0.0096206665, -0.024459839, 0.056365967, 0.03543091, 0.015686035, -0.012496948, 0.0004324913, -0.054260254, 0.032318115, -0.032928467, 0.07678223, 0.0063209534, -0.025405884, -0.022125244, 0.03390503, -0.05026245, 0.0005865097, 0.04348755, -0.013801575, -0.0039978027, -0.0030784607, 0.040008545, -0.014564514, -0.03488159, -0.013809204, -0.00907135, 0.041259766, 0.0031738281, 0.06762695, 0.04119873, 0.076049805, -0.0063591003, -0.062438965, 0.037902832, -0.043823242, -0.028381348, 0.022918701, -0.0513916, 0.055480957, 0.023757935, 0.024673462, 0.0043945312, -0.03286743, -0.033447266, 0.04244995, 0.028137207, 0.039764404, -0.03540039, -0.02053833, 0.017868042, 0.003271103, 0.016525269, 0.08148193, -0.018676758, 0.0118255615, 0.0009713173, -0.037994385, 0.01651001, -0.0034427643, 0.02255249, 0.024765015, -0.006839752, 0.016067505, 0.020339966, 0.0022964478, 0.022994995, 0.019104004, -0.05923462, 0.05215454, 0.0552063, -0.009643555, -0.0056114197, 0.05783081, -0.055603027, 0.043060303, -0.026031494, 0.08300781, 0.02998352, 0.050628662, -0.03829956, -0.0066375732, 0.040130615, 0.0025672913, 0.046691895, 0.008079529, 0.0035247803, 0.0008816719, -0.0005097389, -0.0029411316, 0.05038452, -0.018417358, 0.06939697, -0.005355835, 0.015975952, -0.0013208389, -0.06262207, 0.03488159, -0.013504028, 0.030853271, -0.027954102, 0.00793457, -0.017700195, 0.0059928894, -0.039733887, -0.013511658, -0.048034668, 0.011756897, -0.017150879, -0.014762878, 0.0072631836, -0.013374329, 0.033966064, -0.047302246, -0.0036621094, -0.010810852, -0.033843994, -0.030944824, 0.06439209, -0.01977539, 0.025741577, -0.064453125, -0.052856445, -0.010322571, 0.072387695, -0.060394287, 0.025024414, 0.008888245, -0.027496338, -0.060424805, 0.023269653, -0.017532349, -0.026809692, 0.0060920715, 0.029953003, 0.006969452, -0.08520508, -0.01651001, -0.01550293, 0.016815186, -0.003074646, -0.011184692, 0.017211914, 0.012023926, -0.019180298, -0.0076789856, 0.022720337, 0.018661499, -0.016342163, -0.047851562, 0.012077332, 0.031951904, 0.048187256, 0.0143585205, 0.09100342, 0.05291748, 0.014083862, 0.0138168335, -0.00340271, 0.00039720535, 0.0023155212, 0.0018253326, 0.04852295, 0.0057754517, -0.039367676, 0.0024032593, -0.02494812, 0.045806885, 0.011680603, -0.039001465, 0.021438599, 0.020523071, -0.018325806, -0.037597656, 0.019165039, 0.03652954, -0.04525757, 0.017547607, 0.0016517639, -0.038116455, -0.07714844, 0.0008764267, -0.022338867, -0.01727295, -0.030044556, 0.0020961761, -0.008773804, -0.05319214, 0.0030574799, -0.009147644, 0.030639648, 0.006126404, -0.017349243, 0.043701172, -0.05328369, 0.029693604, 0.048095703, -0.0034217834, -0.008285522, 0.026046753, 0.006641388, 0.0016946793, -0.00730896, -0.000579834, -0.03048706, -0.044403076, 0.021469116, -0.014602661, 0.008018494, -0.022872925, 0.027679443, 0.031921387, -0.031829834, 0.019302368, 0.02204895, 0.019363403, -0.022125244, 0.034729004, 0.060668945, 0.02406311, 0.0256958 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1904.02063v4
Generalized Variational Inference: Three arguments for deriving new Posteriors
Jeremias Knoblauch, Jack Jewson, Theodoros Damoulas
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG
We advocate an optimization-centric view on and introduce a novel generalization of Bayesian inference. Our inspiration is the representation of Bayes' rule as infinite-dimensional optimization problem (Csiszar, 1975; Donsker and Varadhan; 1975, Zellner; 1988). First, we use it to prove an optimality result of standard Variational Inference (VI): Under the proposed view, the standard Evidence Lower Bound (ELBO) maximizing VI posterior is preferable to alternative approximations of the Bayesian posterior. Next, we argue for generalizing standard Bayesian inference. The need for this arises in situations of severe misalignment between reality and three assumptions underlying standard Bayesian inference: (1) Well-specified priors, (2) well-specified likelihoods, (3) the availability of infinite computing power. Our generalization addresses these shortcomings with three arguments and is called the Rule of Three (RoT). We derive it axiomatically and recover existing posteriors as special cases, including the Bayesian posterior and its approximation by standard VI. In contrast, approximations based on alternative ELBO-like objectives violate the axioms. Finally, we study a special case of the RoT that we call Generalized Variational Inference (GVI). GVI posteriors are a large and tractable family of belief distributions specified by three arguments: A loss, a divergence and a variational family. GVI posteriors have appealing properties, including consistency and an interpretation as approximate ELBO. The last part of the paper explores some attractive applications of GVI in popular machine learning models, including robustness and more appropriate marginals. After deriving black box inference schemes for GVI posteriors, their predictive performance is investigated on Bayesian Neural Networks and Deep Gaussian Processes, where GVI can comprehensively improve upon existing methods.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.02063v4
2019-12-12T15:02:50
2019-04-03T15:31:46
{ "title": [ -0.034820557, -0.0026683807, -0.047912598, -0.07165527, 0.01763916, 0.007007599, -0.037353516, -0.001253128, 0.014533997, 0.010437012, -0.0035037994, 0.009971619, -0.04159546, -0.028244019, -0.042541504, 0.0033397675, 0.003396988, 0.031341553, -0.022537231, -0.032165527, -0.033813477, -0.042877197, 0.04537964, 0.01651001, 0.03527832, -0.008407593, -0.07556152, 0.01448822, -0.04135132, -0.024612427, -0.0023002625, -0.005466461, 0.029708862, 0.016616821, 0.022949219, 0.02520752, -0.04711914, 0.016860962, 0.027252197, -0.008895874, 0.013298035, -0.008201599, -0.023880005, -0.0048942566, -0.05102539, -0.004962921, -0.040283203, -0.00793457, -0.024398804, 0.069885254, 0.011306763, 0.022918701, -0.037261963, 0.07397461, 0.023529053, -0.045532227, -0.003616333, -0.029968262, 0.049072266, 0.07659912, 0.009094238, -0.066345215, 0.018081665, -0.046142578, -0.026123047, -0.030014038, -0.005634308, 0.04714966, 0.019821167, 0.0035495758, -0.0074806213, -0.001004219, -0.009895325, 0.030151367, -0.053741455, -0.019470215, 0.078552246, 0.01928711, 0.012687683, -0.0104599, 0.035217285, -0.017593384, 0.011993408, -0.014533997, 0.016479492, -0.034088135, -0.022583008, -0.0050239563, -0.0259552, -0.060424805, -0.0020141602, -0.019210815, -0.041381836, 0.0335083, -0.015655518, -0.013954163, -0.056274414, -0.014778137, 0.012435913, -0.007091522, -0.013977051, 0.009346008, -0.027069092, -0.0040512085, 0.0073928833, 0.017700195, -0.008460999, -0.05319214, -0.008506775, 0.0309906, -0.010673523, 0.062408447, -0.010185242, -0.010009766, 0.018127441, 0.03741455, -0.0052604675, 0.017654419, 0.012275696, 0.037963867, -0.021270752, -0.044036865, 0.027328491, -0.0035495758, 0.04425049, 0.010261536, -0.054870605, -0.0010728836, -0.04660034, 0.01625061, 0.021240234, 0.037231445, -0.1159668, -0.055664062, -0.047912598, 0.04989624, -0.0028133392, -0.03805542, -0.03137207, 0.020309448, -0.0054855347, -0.02999878, 0.01676941, -0.023880005, -0.014015198, -0.00712204, 0.061065674, 0.016326904, -0.051116943, -0.03491211, -0.0014886856, 0.032928467, 0.056243896, 0.014282227, -0.107299805, -0.018539429, -0.13330078, -0.027816772, 0.016174316, -0.042236328, -0.0003683567, -0.025726318, -0.035003662, 0.0008659363, 0.045654297, 0.030014038, -0.006149292, 0.031280518, 0.016357422, 0.036712646, -0.027633667, 0.014205933, 0.041748047, 0.005531311, -0.013832092, 0.011207581, 0.03111267, -0.03164673, 0.050933838, -0.012786865, 0.0060920715, -0.0056037903, 0.009185791, 0.056152344, -0.05731201, -0.04840088, -0.0053520203, -0.032196045, 0.052459717, 0.009941101, -0.015541077, 0.022018433, -0.08392334, -0.0335083, -0.04647827, 0.01852417, 0.0181427, 0.034576416, -0.009941101, 0.006134033, -0.021102905, -0.026916504, -0.020401001, 0.009124756, -0.022949219, -0.02217102, -0.02508545, 0.020950317, -0.024734497, 0.055023193, 0.062408447, 0.006198883, -0.053527832, 0.055023193, 0.013404846, -0.07159424, 0.018707275, -0.01890564, -0.010215759, -0.0056152344, -0.047821045, -0.011138916, -0.028930664, 0.053375244, 0.015411377, -0.015777588, 0.02017212, -0.03945923, 0.052886963, 0.032104492, 0.04373169, -0.06756592, -0.0014982224, 0.014305115, -0.0005288124, -0.01676941, 0.005317688, 0.02859497, 0.011985779, 0.0072135925, 0.01663208, 0.003271103, -0.010246277, -0.011947632, 0.07067871, -0.007171631, 0.0072021484, -0.020263672, 0.013687134, 0.017471313, 0.06112671, 0.032318115, 0.058288574, -0.0033988953, 0.02168274, 0.08154297, 0.012542725, 0.008018494, -0.012687683, 0.035003662, -0.0062332153, 0.012519836, -0.007446289, 0.016143799, -0.059051514, -0.011436462, -0.030334473, 0.010871887, 0.03326416, -0.016494751, 0.02166748, -0.02178955, 0.0058670044, -0.016998291, -0.004142761, 0.01600647, -0.026306152, 0.009361267, 0.025238037, -0.053497314, -0.012588501, 0.0149002075, 0.05810547, 0.010353088, 0.022613525, -0.02355957, 0.026748657, -0.014892578, -0.0058784485, -0.018615723, 0.056610107, -0.008262634, -0.0033130646, -0.020599365, -0.012786865, -0.021240234, 0.04876709, 0.04559326, -0.008354187, 0.018249512, -0.051757812, 0.031311035, 0.026916504, -0.019180298, 0.001906395, 0.049316406, 0.0016679764, 0.042907715, -0.02381897, -0.017944336, -0.021957397, 0.0149383545, 0.004737854, -0.07006836, -0.011802673, -0.01828003, -0.010765076, -0.043182373, -0.0037517548, 0.032409668, 0.076049805, -0.010246277, -0.029129028, -0.01637268, 0.0022659302, -0.032714844, -0.022567749, -0.032806396, 0.01713562, 0.004421234, 0.03100586, 0.008262634, -0.0826416, -0.049682617, -0.008926392, 0.024108887, -0.017562866, 0.00919342, -0.022323608, 0.016601562, 0.02027893, 0.013145447, 0.045288086, -0.07110596, -0.015235901, -0.05053711, 0.0002450943, 0.028930664, -0.032592773, -0.011253357, 0.037384033, -0.021148682, -0.03665161, 0.010940552, 0.05178833, -0.045898438, -0.004211426, 0.043670654, 0.019638062, -0.02281189, 0.026473999, 0.013961792, -0.00020718575, -0.08441162, -0.0011148453, -0.048461914, -0.032165527, -0.02168274, 0.012542725, 0.07043457, -0.051116943, -0.014411926, -0.038879395, 0.0017404556, 0.019256592, 0.020233154, -0.027999878, -0.044403076, -0.004524231, -0.014945984, -0.0037498474, 0.029403687, -0.013397217, 0.055267334, 0.11755371, -0.013092041, 0.006752014, 0.018417358, 0.05657959, 0.022842407, -0.03768921, -0.04272461, -0.013931274, -0.021194458, -0.012619019, 0.030151367, -0.019638062, -0.033233643, -0.026229858, -0.0015010834, 0.03125, -0.0018386841, -0.026611328, 0.022659302, -0.059906006, 0.05053711, -0.0051574707, -0.017700195, 0.032562256, 0.0546875, -0.024307251, 0.03540039, 0.00087833405, -0.0340271, 0.0045547485, -0.015014648, -0.064819336, 0.04675293, -0.01071167, -0.09240723, -0.016647339, -0.027893066, -0.04547119, -0.041534424, -0.0003786087, 0.046844482, 0.019607544, 0.020767212, 0.002336502, -0.029678345, 0.0017271042, -0.035247803, -0.021957397, -0.01876831, -0.03024292, -0.0060768127, 0.0078086853, 0.060058594, 0.012130737, -0.006538391, -0.025985718, -0.0061531067, 0.006416321, 0.038970947, 0.004432678, -0.033233643, 0.009384155, -0.0031280518, 0.016067505, 0.0041618347, -0.015617371, -0.018234253, -0.0070343018, 0.012336731, -0.029281616, 0.017669678, 0.027801514, 0.0069007874, -0.024368286, -0.015960693, 0.0035438538, -0.026992798, -0.062408447, 0.0073394775, 0.027297974, 0.01826477, -0.023529053, -0.011741638, -0.023345947, 0.012641907, -0.026138306, 0.026947021, -0.007160187, 0.007507324, -0.0027751923, 0.033569336, -0.020584106, 0.01927185, -0.04095459, 0.035064697, 0.009674072, -0.009254456, -0.02041626, -0.042755127, 0.013114929, 0.015655518, -0.085754395, 0.0053253174, 0.012954712, -0.03378296, -0.060150146, -0.036895752, 0.038635254, -0.031829834, -0.011192322, 0.016586304, -0.023025513, -0.042297363, 0.015129089, -0.048980713, -0.013961792, 0.07977295, -0.009506226, -0.008598328, 0.023071289, -0.017700195, -0.030685425, -0.041778564, 0.015525818, -0.02571106, 0.036743164, -0.018081665, -0.0042495728, 0.030441284, -0.020248413, 0.02949524, 0.02067566, 0.04135132, -0.012329102, -0.022888184, -0.0018501282, -0.037078857, 0.019561768, 0.035217285, -0.0034446716, 0.0072746277, -0.035369873, 0.013023376, -0.020233154, -0.0034389496, 0.0048675537, 0.004360199, 0.02204895, 0.0040779114, 0.034423828, 0.035003662, -0.013442993, -0.028259277, 0.010604858, -0.007911682, -0.022262573, 0.012550354, 0.022903442, 0.029846191, 0.0067100525, 0.029342651, 0.015808105, 0.036743164, -0.036865234, -0.0038414001, -0.011138916, 0.009254456, -0.04257202, -0.012123108, -0.0690918, -0.03062439, -0.023880005, 0.013008118, -0.0024166107, 0.019805908, 0.006313324, -0.010482788, -0.021835327, -0.006313324, 0.0045051575, 0.0078048706, 0.013015747, -0.022506714, -0.0051231384, -0.0006623268, -0.03817749, -0.01889038, 0.005783081, -0.036865234, 0.043060303, -0.024276733, -0.028915405, 0.010818481, 0.034942627, 0.066589355, 0.05456543, 0.006828308, -0.053100586, -0.001906395, -0.0054893494, -0.020324707, 0.01889038, -0.026351929, 0.010574341, -0.033599854, -0.01574707, -0.010482788, -0.011802673, -0.050689697, 0.017044067, -0.029464722, 0.04574585, 0.030578613, 0.029006958, 0.034606934, -0.013710022, 0.006439209, 0.013618469, -0.016113281, -0.0385437, 0.041900635, 0.007446289, 0.043304443, 0.014762878, 0.024597168, 0.0029258728, -0.043304443, 0.029876709, 0.029846191, 0.016357422, -0.013473511, -0.005794525, 0.014701843, -0.0066566467, -0.040405273, 0.022064209, 0.009849548, 0.052825928, -0.011833191, 0.055725098, -0.014076233, 0.028060913, 0.039489746, -0.0082473755, 0.009254456, 0.00856781, 0.009384155, -0.066101074, -0.0803833, -0.006664276, 0.08123779, -0.03414917, -0.0021781921, 0.002040863, 0.018447876, 0.023422241, 0.039489746, 0.009849548, -0.021240234, -0.027511597, -0.01864624, -0.021484375, -0.022323608, -0.054595947, 0.029907227, -0.00060272217, 0.023880005, -0.06427002, 0.034423828, -0.06222534, 0.019821167, 0.013885498, -0.00033473969, -0.0015974045, -0.08312988, -0.0017280579, 0.0340271, 0.023330688, 0.011512756, 0.0033111572, 0.01763916, 0.035339355, 0.0418396, 0.018066406, 0.028915405, 0.015838623, 0.00579834, -0.013641357, -0.0074272156, 0.042938232, 0.0026550293, 0.0027103424, 0.0073165894, -0.017837524, -0.05895996, 0.023239136, 0.019744873, -0.0082092285, 0.011878967, -0.047821045, 0.02557373, -0.0037193298, -0.012191772, 0.035858154, 0.0016450882, -0.03137207, -0.0038700104, 0.0025081635, -0.043792725, 0.021102905, 0.014007568, -0.029556274, -0.043029785, 0.04812622, -0.008331299, 0.013145447, -0.0012187958, -0.006626129, -0.04660034, 0.020645142, 0.042877197, -0.05807495, 0.0028839111, -0.009933472, 0.013641357, 0.04373169, 0.020751953, -0.04272461, 0.008155823, -0.03237915, -0.054260254, -0.0041885376, 0.042877197, 0.042297363, 0.003004074, 0.002199173, -0.023101807, 0.026901245, -0.0046691895, 0.031311035, -0.0061569214, 0.009178162, 0.024291992, 0.022216797, 0.012199402, -0.0064468384, 0.013710022, 0.0017290115, -0.001619339, -0.009933472, 0.0014858246, 0.031082153, -0.005092621, 0.014907837, -0.0070648193, -0.03866577, 0.009498596, 0.016052246, 0.020004272, -0.053497314, -0.0065689087, 0.022003174, -0.04953003, 0.009208679, -0.03366089, 0.06329346, -0.0126571655, 0.004425049, 0.023254395, -0.008773804, -0.030853271, 0.058166504, 0.014770508, -0.0028514862, -0.051513672, -0.043426514, -0.026977539, 0.0070648193, 0.0104599, -0.007774353, -0.0040893555, -0.017044067, 0.049194336, -0.011734009, -0.012176514, -0.008026123, 0.016616821, -0.001616478, -0.041931152, -0.0056037903, -0.004501343, -0.020446777, -0.023910522, 0.028518677, 0.03933716, 0.0074806213, 0.012397766, -0.033721924, -0.009124756, -0.006832123, -0.027496338, 0.05456543, -0.010513306, -0.00605011, 0.0625, -0.03817749, 0.049041748, 0.031585693, 0.061950684, 0.049865723, 0.020904541, 0.038757324, 0.016311646, 0.026641846, -0.034210205, 0.036743164, -0.013458252, -0.015541077, -0.047912598, -0.03930664, -0.06970215, -0.022445679, 0.033843994, 0.008865356, -0.008666992, 0.0019483566, 0.0038204193, 0.026611328, 0.065979004, 0.021072388, 0.053833008, 0.046081543, 0.01348114, 0.015716553, -0.010139465, 0.004787445, 0.045166016, 0.006706238, -0.010948181, -0.021438599, -0.014762878, -0.008628845, 0.045959473, 0.012802124, -0.024856567, -0.004760742, -0.046020508, 0.049987793, 0.00869751, 0.06665039, 0.051940918, 0.01725769, -0.0037651062, -0.018432617, -0.01939392, -0.027175903, -0.023757935, -0.004688263, 0.022979736, -0.03933716, 0.003616333, -0.034332275, -0.015113831, -0.02067566, 0.03741455, 0.031082153, -0.067993164, -0.04522705, 0.0058631897, 0.045684814, 0.0087509155, 0.024429321, -0.029678345, 0.010154724, 0.015838623, 0.028076172, 0.013893127, 0.029281616, 0.012748718, 0.032165527, -0.0035896301, -0.04260254, 0.021408081, -0.0058059692, 0.0018625259, 0.041290283, 0.018630981, 0.041625977, 0.014381409, -0.03604126, 0.042816162, -0.0042419434, -0.05630493, 0.010375977, 0.010498047, 0.01927185, 0.0065345764, 0.0657959, 0.031219482, -0.012748718, -0.0418396, -0.03744507, 0.015838623, 0.025497437, -0.030593872, 0.017547607, -0.033233643, -0.032226562, 0.053985596, -0.053985596, 0.07104492, -0.04449463, -0.019607544, 0.009849548, -0.0053520203, 0.04510498, -0.025878906, -0.010574341, -0.024215698, -0.0016555786, -0.0047950745, -0.0016012192, -0.038360596, -0.032470703, 0.00920105, 0.022338867, 0.016693115, 0.0018234253, -0.01084137, -0.03817749, -0.049621582, 0.013053894, 0.004196167, 0.03930664, -0.006942749, -0.0113220215, -0.006427765, 0.00002938509, -0.012062073, -0.02633667, -0.024932861, -0.009712219, -0.031433105, -0.022094727, 0.019927979, 0.024337769, -0.016540527, -0.02684021, 0.014564514, 0.0009279251, -0.016845703, 0.010276794, 0.028762817, -0.045074463, -0.039886475, 0.0016050339, -0.011772156, 0.0501709, 0.018981934, -0.01928711, 0.049957275, 0.0115737915, -0.01878357, -0.010971069, -0.0011634827, 0.013366699, -0.010398865, -0.055786133, 0.0067253113, 0.029800415, 0.03375244, -0.04711914, -0.020492554, 0.025146484, 0.01902771, -0.00061035156, 0.035247803, 0.022537231, -0.016738892, 0.011978149, 0.031219482, 0.0037498474, -0.04156494, -0.007736206, -0.0016593933, 0.036010742, 0.036712646, 0.006958008, -0.020355225, 0.01663208, -0.017913818, -0.0015382767, -0.00907135, 0.00541687, 0.014724731, 0.007106781, 0.0546875, -0.023284912, 0.0069847107, -0.020751953, -0.027053833, 0.012435913, 0.007736206, -0.017074585, 0.008705139, -0.05102539, 0.07434082, -0.0063285828, -0.07745361, 0.036346436, 0.037475586, 0.010681152, 0.037078857, -0.022003174, -0.028915405, -0.0038528442, -0.0067329407, 0.007507324, 0.001543045, 0.010673523, -0.049835205, 0.0068626404, -0.046569824, -0.040771484, -0.0018692017, -0.027572632, 0.035339355, -0.04309082, 0.017532349, -0.02180481, -0.035827637, -0.015144348, 0.037017822, 0.01309967, -0.0569458, -0.036193848, 0.0021438599, 0.0748291, -0.0004632473 ], "summary": [ 0.0006532669, -0.020095825, -0.0126571655, -0.027557373, -0.037231445, -0.011016846, -0.038757324, -0.0012760162, -0.010627747, 0.025390625, -0.080078125, 0.013092041, -0.013031006, 0.009880066, -0.018432617, -0.048858643, 0.009613037, 0.032928467, 0.025283813, -0.035888672, 0.0061149597, -0.023284912, 0.022003174, 0.044769287, -0.0035915375, -0.011459351, -0.0062942505, 0.01638794, 0.004497528, 0.02192688, 0.015975952, -0.025756836, -0.0105896, 0.012840271, 0.058746338, 0.0395813, -0.009986877, 0.034423828, 0.05279541, -0.008621216, -0.012001038, -0.0066452026, 0.051605225, -0.023605347, -0.0073127747, 0.004295349, -0.002878189, -0.008934021, 0.027740479, 0.04067993, -0.0064315796, 0.016021729, -0.008522034, 0.01826477, -0.013900757, -0.04840088, -0.007118225, -0.054351807, 0.042114258, 0.080078125, 0.011856079, -0.05114746, 0.009933472, -0.064331055, 0.014045715, -0.009933472, 0.03933716, 0.027709961, -0.014930725, -0.012771606, 0.016799927, 0.00042247772, -0.008255005, -0.008415222, -0.04660034, -0.011047363, 0.046936035, -0.02330017, 0.00381279, 0.0028915405, 0.003293991, -0.01486969, -0.0113220215, -0.059539795, 0.051696777, -0.021118164, -0.005241394, 0.0011100769, -0.019042969, -0.042999268, -0.0072669983, -0.029220581, -0.06567383, 0.0158844, 0.019226074, -0.06335449, -0.041046143, -0.0059547424, -0.0019950867, 0.008644104, -0.0065727234, -0.005332947, 0.013183594, -0.03201294, -0.011383057, 0.05960083, 0.016799927, -0.06890869, -0.04525757, -0.032165527, -0.008049011, -0.03289795, -0.01725769, -0.019729614, -0.01184082, 0.026947021, -0.010276794, 0.015388489, -0.00093364716, 0.03048706, -0.03326416, -0.0099487305, -0.021118164, 0.0127334595, 0.0087509155, -0.021575928, -0.019241333, 0.049041748, -0.0010461807, 0.03918457, 0.03756714, -0.00035309792, -0.078063965, -0.005264282, -0.051727295, -0.0035705566, 0.025436401, -0.060943604, 0.013305664, -0.012992859, 0.04776001, -0.0101623535, 0.00038552284, 0.031463623, -0.0041923523, 0.030960083, 0.049041748, -0.00014090538, -0.032226562, -0.04324341, -0.045166016, 0.06719971, 0.0680542, -0.02381897, -0.09320068, -0.07092285, -0.07873535, -0.021575928, 0.021972656, -0.053649902, -0.024856567, -0.012779236, 0.009422302, 0.021987915, 0.003982544, 0.01651001, 0.0335083, 0.007926941, 0.007896423, -0.033477783, 0.011100769, 0.014579773, -0.010688782, -0.010505676, 0.008972168, 0.0006918907, -0.034454346, -0.019165039, 0.006389618, 0.035705566, 0.02368164, -0.01953125, -0.019989014, 0.039642334, -0.025665283, -0.0055885315, -0.0112838745, 0.020309448, 0.03894043, 0.018661499, 0.0034980774, -0.017456055, -0.07208252, -0.027404785, -0.004940033, 0.05331421, -0.022857666, 0.023254395, -0.008911133, -0.012336731, 0.0107803345, -0.017288208, 0.00006324053, -0.029647827, -0.079589844, -0.02381897, -0.027130127, 0.022994995, -0.025009155, 0.0039482117, 0.04574585, -0.014465332, -0.047302246, 0.04598999, 0.013580322, -0.01864624, 0.0154800415, -0.008781433, -0.002313614, 0.013557434, -0.039520264, -0.0032577515, -0.06738281, 0.018005371, -0.01651001, -0.0063667297, 0.009262085, 0.018081665, 0.06213379, 0.022766113, 0.07946777, -0.06262207, -0.022537231, 0.012237549, 0.002401352, 0.005004883, 0.04260254, -0.0020332336, 0.034851074, 0.028289795, 0.030441284, 0.0011491776, -0.023712158, -0.034332275, 0.018569946, 0.012207031, 0.029769897, -0.043518066, -0.02645874, -0.025756836, 0.021484375, 0.009056091, 0.049316406, 0.015853882, 0.016830444, 0.027145386, -0.037017822, -0.039123535, -0.031341553, 0.05203247, -0.016098022, 0.008056641, 0.02835083, -0.012809753, -0.048736572, -0.03857422, -0.011756897, -0.022064209, 0.054534912, -0.06817627, -0.010757446, -0.08343506, 0.004550934, -0.008728027, -0.058135986, -0.0049705505, -0.03173828, 0.029418945, 0.015945435, -0.031951904, -0.0025959015, 0.011795044, 0.009223938, -0.014633179, 0.0146102905, 0.014411926, 0.00023686886, -0.025741577, 0.012321472, 0.026260376, 0.0769043, -0.02772522, -0.00932312, -0.017959595, -0.021575928, -0.038970947, -0.076171875, -0.03289795, 0.04812622, -0.06878662, -0.041107178, 0.047424316, -0.019714355, 0.0064735413, -0.008110046, 0.043640137, -0.0211792, 0.01940918, -0.0058021545, -0.060668945, 0.03933716, 0.040130615, 0.009887695, -0.030197144, 0.002456665, 0.012672424, -0.00667572, 0.020019531, 0.06359863, 0.10900879, 0.07965088, -0.023284912, -0.01663208, -0.02293396, -0.026046753, -0.028778076, 0.0053977966, -0.022827148, 0.028701782, -0.0027256012, -0.01725769, 0.005832672, -0.028549194, -0.010154724, -0.0041122437, -0.006011963, 0.0039596558, 0.006679535, 0.009140015, 0.032043457, 0.03515625, 0.02809143, -0.010643005, -0.037475586, -0.04107666, 0.004459381, -0.016204834, 0.004802704, -0.030380249, -0.006942749, 0.019042969, -0.010902405, -0.019378662, 0.015449524, -0.019546509, -0.041778564, 0.031341553, 0.037322998, -0.0011167526, -0.02015686, 0.05722046, 0.028182983, 0.014518738, -0.05987549, -0.021102905, -0.05834961, 0.015899658, -0.03942871, 0.06097412, 0.052215576, 0.013343811, 0.040222168, -0.038269043, -0.0025539398, 0.01386261, -0.03353882, 0.068115234, -0.019256592, 0.013496399, 0.058898926, 0.021240234, 0.04208374, -0.02923584, 0.0284729, 0.08215332, 0.00045371056, 0.056610107, 0.050750732, 0.037902832, -0.0035629272, -0.022399902, -0.02331543, 0.064086914, -0.06994629, -0.03086853, -0.001783371, 0.014862061, 0.0011701584, 0.10534668, -0.028701782, 0.042297363, -0.010803223, 0.012313843, 0.0011444092, -0.048675537, 0.05078125, -0.0143585205, -0.00018882751, 0.018096924, -0.0039405823, 0.019042969, -0.014480591, 0.0012693405, -0.029922485, -0.011421204, -0.020904541, 0.008583069, 0.024932861, 0.029830933, -0.06201172, -0.013885498, 0.0206604, -0.015312195, -0.02268982, 0.02607727, -0.0135650635, 0.034942627, 0.026306152, -0.019836426, 0.0022411346, 0.027328491, -0.0541687, -0.004196167, -0.0418396, -0.04940796, -0.0007715225, -0.010757446, 0.055236816, 0.0027179718, -0.018005371, -0.012672424, -0.017990112, -0.02166748, -0.0070877075, -0.0131073, -0.024475098, 0.020751953, 0.0033054352, 0.0013008118, 0.008628845, -0.0020980835, -0.014274597, 0.03189087, 0.021362305, -0.014778137, 0.0670166, -0.043914795, 0.028701782, 0.077697754, -0.032714844, -0.037597656, -0.025238037, 0.015930176, 0.020950317, 0.022750854, 0.0181427, -0.0579834, 0.012367249, -0.03741455, 0.009353638, 0.023803711, -0.0043182373, -0.025863647, -0.021591187, 0.0082092285, -0.024124146, 0.014778137, 0.0236969, 0.014083862, -0.00579834, 0.010498047, -0.014579773, -0.012290955, 0.018676758, 0.0009012222, 0.014633179, -0.04647827, -0.005470276, 0.017166138, 0.013969421, 0.027938843, -0.013900757, 0.051605225, 0.016403198, 0.0042304993, -0.0061302185, -0.016647339, 0.084106445, 0.05581665, 0.0024681091, -0.010749817, -0.0053863525, 0.0035495758, -0.055877686, -0.043548584, 0.018127441, 0.034301758, 0.0049362183, -0.004047394, -0.07348633, 0.03451538, -0.05496216, 0.033813477, 0.05508423, -0.04006958, 0.04586792, -0.0027942657, 0.037994385, -0.015991211, -0.010345459, 0.0056495667, -0.009689331, -0.018325806, 0.021347046, 0.06890869, -0.004020691, -0.01828003, 0.03050232, 0.01878357, -0.014823914, 0.0016450882, -0.009643555, 0.0032749176, 0.032104492, 0.019439697, 0.010345459, -0.020828247, -0.03491211, -0.0025501251, 0.028625488, -0.037628174, -0.060943604, -0.006877899, 0.040771484, 0.0059051514, 0.01914978, 0.000975132, 0.021591187, -0.054748535, 0.013534546, -0.019546509, -0.005115509, -0.049194336, -0.035095215, -0.018798828, -0.01184845, -0.014343262, 0.020111084, 0.016403198, -0.017105103, -0.029312134, 0.01398468, 0.008842468, -0.016204834, 0.0008158684, 0.038330078, -0.0022716522, -0.020065308, -0.0074882507, -0.034576416, -0.015686035, -0.019882202, -0.013137817, -0.051757812, -0.0023555756, -0.010261536, -0.0368042, -0.007671356, 0.021591187, 0.057800293, 0.018798828, 0.030883789, -0.03817749, -0.04269409, -0.013671875, -0.0020008087, 0.014389038, -0.018417358, -0.012290955, -0.016494751, 0.021194458, 0.0073432922, -0.023757935, -0.03086853, -0.002084732, -0.0362854, 0.046569824, 0.068481445, 0.07647705, 0.028121948, -0.0018520355, 0.021911621, 0.017120361, -0.011230469, -0.023239136, 0.04348755, -0.0073165894, 0.056396484, 0.01285553, -0.012161255, -0.018661499, -0.040649414, -0.004180908, 0.034332275, -0.015960693, -0.019134521, 0.0066108704, -0.014129639, 0.011932373, 0.030548096, 0.035705566, 0.008995056, 0.053894043, -0.0033397675, 0.047821045, 0.005050659, 0.013473511, 0.058135986, 0.008033752, -0.026306152, 0.0014219284, -0.03390503, -0.056396484, -0.052490234, -0.013290405, 0.060943604, -0.018814087, -0.029327393, -0.006389618, 0.008987427, 0.022094727, 0.01689148, -0.017074585, -0.035736084, -0.03765869, 0.010696411, -0.010299683, -0.03591919, -0.013061523, -0.003616333, 0.037475586, 0.0079574585, -0.066589355, 0.012359619, 0.026519775, -0.031585693, 0.02243042, -0.013801575, -0.023620605, -0.072265625, -0.06726074, -0.06628418, -0.0317688, -0.020767212, 0.04046631, -0.017623901, -0.0024223328, 0.031585693, -0.024719238, 0.0317688, -0.00504303, 0.031585693, 0.0368042, -0.006389618, 0.04296875, -0.0007305145, -0.034576416, 0.0039482117, -0.019973755, -0.020385742, -0.009017944, -0.03363037, 0.055633545, -0.0019025803, -0.013389587, 0.040405273, -0.0041885376, -0.037872314, 0.0178833, 0.016708374, -0.042022705, -0.028778076, 0.026824951, -0.022949219, -0.008895874, 0.021560669, 0.0031108856, -0.022247314, -0.024459839, -0.011039734, 0.0158844, 0.009460449, 0.010047913, -0.0027008057, -0.01525116, -0.0023555756, -0.062194824, 0.0005598068, 0.0051879883, 0.037506104, -0.0126571655, -0.0362854, -0.06726074, -0.013015747, -0.049957275, 0.019592285, 0.015899658, 0.008003235, 0.033813477, 0.054992676, 0.024490356, 0.024475098, 0.029449463, -0.021347046, 0.017944336, -0.027709961, -0.012138367, 0.031677246, 0.00094652176, -0.012641907, 0.0020160675, 0.051757812, 0.028152466, -0.0060653687, -0.018554688, 0.03286743, 0.055236816, 0.0022010803, 0.043426514, -0.017150879, 0.019607544, -0.0058631897, 0.042236328, -0.0033130646, -0.035461426, -0.006439209, 0.0010251999, -0.08404541, 0.03164673, -0.02507019, 0.06021118, 0.023208618, 0.0032730103, -0.006137848, 0.028305054, -0.027877808, -0.009811401, 0.003955841, 0.011642456, -0.013397217, -0.0050086975, 0.0007324219, 0.0143966675, -0.0010623932, -0.02734375, -0.009109497, 0.006717682, 0.02720642, -0.019561768, -0.006290436, -0.0063552856, 0.024505615, -0.017166138, -0.022994995, -0.017288208, -0.0028190613, -0.021408081, 0.03543091, -0.0013551712, 0.03237915, -0.0063209534, 0.02885437, -0.026016235, -0.0041999817, -0.03479004, 0.02407837, 0.033477783, 0.03894043, -0.043548584, 0.035064697, 0.003944397, 0.03793335, 0.02810669, 0.0043640137, -0.005191803, -0.018112183, 0.0063476562, 0.012756348, 0.023361206, -0.017364502, 0.062561035, -0.011169434, -0.031158447, -0.061279297, -0.045715332, -0.06072998, 0.03768921, -0.012161255, -0.0044555664, -0.0071487427, 0.010116577, -0.009483337, 0.030960083, 0.0022907257, -0.017745972, 0.014038086, 0.08227539, 0.0036582947, 0.028793335, 0.01360321, -0.020385742, 0.023269653, 0.03253174, 0.01473999, -0.0050201416, -0.026275635, 0.044769287, 0.0053138733, -0.019973755, -0.050048828, -0.0028438568, -0.057891846, 0.039489746, 0.00054740906, 0.050933838, 0.038238525, 0.005634308, -0.021224976, -0.009963989, 0.012954712, 0.040771484, -0.030822754, 0.013168335, 0.008171082, 0.00096178055, -0.016067505, 0.006996155, 0.00080633163, 0.039093018, 0.029220581, 0.027145386, -0.042236328, -0.0057678223, 0.0026836395, -0.0076446533, -0.00818634, 0.01737976, -0.015548706, 0.024154663, 0.00868988, -0.013542175, 0.041259766, 0.008026123, -0.039245605, 0.02029419, 0.040252686, -0.008888245, 0.0026817322, 0.005947113, -0.0012321472, 0.042022705, 0.03277588, 0.025375366, 0.0069084167, -0.024749756, 0.011169434, 0.0137786865, -0.037139893, 0.030593872, 0.005012512, 0.028823853, 0.031463623, 0.027648926, -0.01689148, -0.013519287, 0.06756592, -0.021774292, -0.013313293, 0.015426636, 0.0048561096, -0.011924744, -0.010734558, 0.010070801, 0.022857666, 0.006843567, 0.01737976, -0.008926392, -0.023468018, -0.018325806, -0.042877197, -0.0017290115, -0.003452301, 0.054107666, -0.0715332, 0.0019989014, 0.005180359, 0.045532227, -0.035461426, -0.022018433, -0.005996704, 0.006839752, 0.008850098, 0.027069092, 0.0501709, -0.06072998, -0.0070610046, 0.014854431, 0.07281494, 0.06726074, 0.037078857, -0.011520386, 0.064086914, -0.0084991455, -0.017349243, -0.068603516, -0.022247314, -0.01953125, 0.062927246, 0.00095129013, -0.0017604828, 0.01864624, -0.02104187, -0.028701782, 0.067871094, 0.0037975311, -0.013442993, 0.074401855, 0.04574585, -0.012908936, 0.0074691772, 0.03314209, -0.0077438354, 0.046844482, -0.05126953, 0.0064811707, 0.0758667, -0.0046653748, -0.008293152, -0.0440979, 0.012298584, -0.015579224, 0.030303955, -0.015205383, -0.019042969, 0.046661377, 0.08154297, 0.005138397, 0.0024929047, 0.027679443, -0.06738281, -0.0107803345, -0.012710571, 0.0129470825, -0.0035076141, -0.014373779, 0.017974854, -0.024337769, -0.00054979324, -0.017547607, 0.009017944, 0.030853271, 0.0068893433, -0.00806427, -0.032043457, -0.01335144, -0.009384155, -0.048553467, -0.05834961, 0.040985107, -0.058929443, 0.008422852, -0.015174866, -0.06842041, 0.0074501038, -0.01737976, -0.019058228, 0.009742737, -0.03363037, 0.03540039, -0.004863739, -0.053710938, 0.08880615, -0.0060768127, -0.004234314, -0.011062622, 0.008773804, 0.0022640228, 0.02482605, -0.0011940002, -0.015792847, -0.011459351, 0.017745972, 0.020721436, 0.033233643, 0.0017843246, -0.034301758, 0.025756836, -0.06591797, -0.031402588, -0.044799805, -0.027999878, 0.005252838, -0.024093628, 0.026565552, 0.028808594, -0.03753662, 0.026748657, 0.041503906, 0.06945801, 0.020233154, 0.0052375793, 0.009727478, 0.016174316, -0.0034446716 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1908.08564v1
Intent term selection and refinement in e-commerce queries
Saurav Manchanda, Mohit Sharma, George Karypis
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
In e-commerce, a user tends to search for the desired product by issuing a query to the search engine and examining the retrieved results. If the search engine was successful in correctly understanding the user's query, it will return results that correspond to the products whose attributes match the terms in the query that are representative of the query's product intent. However, the search engine may fail to retrieve results that satisfy the query's product intent and thus degrading user experience due to different issues in query processing: (i) when multiple terms are present in a query it may fail to determine the relevant terms that are representative of the query's product intent, and (ii) it may suffer from vocabulary gap between the terms in the query and the product's description, i.e., terms used in the query are semantically similar but different from the terms in the product description. Hence, identifying the terms that describe the query's product intent and predicting additional terms that describe the query's product intent better than the existing query terms to the search engine is an essential task in e-commerce search. In this paper, we leverage the historical query reformulation logs of a major e-commerce retailer to develop distant-supervised approaches to solve both these problems. Our approaches exploit the fact that the significance of a term is dependent upon the context (other terms in the neighborhood) in which it is used in order to learn the importance of the term towards the query's product intent. We show that identifying and emphasizing the terms that define the query's product intent leads to a 3% improvement in ranking. Moreover, for the tasks of identifying the important terms in a query and for predicting the additional terms that represent product intent, experiments illustrate that our approaches outperform the non-contextual baselines.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1908.08564v1
2019-08-22T19:04:24
2019-08-22T19:04:24
{ "title": [ -0.010009766, 0.004825592, -0.064941406, -0.054901123, 0.0234375, -0.02758789, -0.011413574, -0.0007863045, 0.014526367, 0.045715332, -0.012519836, 0.005531311, 0.022537231, -0.0026073456, -0.055236816, 0.0051956177, -0.0019454956, 0.026016235, -0.02041626, -0.023757935, -0.010131836, -0.014305115, 0.0149383545, 0.0063972473, 0.038604736, -0.03564453, -0.02571106, -0.01675415, -0.0053482056, -0.03173828, -0.0029411316, -0.0015554428, 0.04937744, -0.005870819, -0.00014436245, 0.014755249, -0.015159607, -0.003643036, -0.01083374, 0.014526367, 0.030776978, -0.015464783, -0.053497314, -0.014976501, -0.056732178, 0.030578613, -0.044799805, 0.0010757446, -0.005592346, -0.013824463, 0.01576233, 0.03225708, 0.01727295, 0.0029506683, -0.0021419525, -0.02293396, -0.018157959, -0.019607544, 0.031204224, 0.039886475, 0.038208008, -0.03842163, 0.004398346, -0.00831604, -0.027038574, -0.0038375854, 0.04107666, 0.0025138855, 0.050048828, -0.0025959015, -0.01386261, 0.029067993, 0.025268555, 0.009643555, -0.045135498, -0.01751709, 0.038238525, 0.01184082, 0.046783447, -0.031921387, 0.0021762848, -0.011230469, 0.0016355515, -0.028701782, 0.028396606, -0.022857666, -0.012565613, -0.00881958, -0.02078247, -0.07330322, -0.011039734, 0.0007138252, 0.009025574, -0.018508911, -0.047973633, -0.047668457, 0.0015125275, 0.05618286, -0.0022640228, -0.017929077, -0.024459839, 0.021102905, -0.07196045, -0.0030231476, 0.024902344, 0.024505615, -0.00894928, 0.023361206, 0.051483154, 0.02116394, -0.010749817, 0.051574707, 0.018417358, 0.014411926, -0.026367188, -0.032592773, -0.011077881, -0.00182724, 0.0015792847, 0.0007109642, -0.023864746, -0.027664185, 0.040802002, 0.0096206665, -0.0027370453, -0.009742737, -0.021133423, -0.015525818, -0.017364502, 0.012123108, 0.021636963, 0.07110596, -0.09039307, -0.09429932, -0.091918945, 0.04864502, -0.012321472, 0.0031108856, 0.016784668, -0.016616821, 0.04800415, -0.02368164, -0.00055122375, 0.058654785, 0.027893066, 0.00957489, 0.055267334, -0.003118515, -0.036224365, -0.013801575, -0.018737793, -0.005405426, 0.037261963, -0.022842407, -0.10131836, -0.027542114, -0.119384766, -0.019256592, 0.009109497, -0.033721924, 0.00044369698, 0.0045204163, 0.019363403, -0.033569336, 0.008003235, -0.0011396408, -0.029663086, 0.017715454, 0.011627197, 0.030303955, 0.0026359558, 0.0077705383, -0.0060539246, -0.008049011, -0.011039734, -0.0019989014, 0.053253174, 0.005428314, -0.0046463013, 0.026824951, 0.0151901245, -0.0262146, 0.026992798, 0.010314941, -0.09362793, 0.025222778, 0.012962341, 0.05291748, 0.022079468, 0.00068092346, 0.013694763, 0.039764404, -0.04397583, -0.03643799, -0.009819031, -0.022018433, 0.027404785, -0.0077705383, 0.01939392, 0.008666992, -0.0017700195, 0.002111435, -0.024551392, -0.0043754578, -0.041381836, -0.02810669, -0.019226074, 0.021438599, -0.013717651, 0.06561279, 0.05883789, 0.054504395, -0.07550049, 0.032958984, -0.0021743774, -0.045684814, 0.024429321, 0.010070801, 0.011444092, -0.04031372, 0.014892578, -0.014549255, 0.0206604, 0.07373047, 0.025680542, -0.0052757263, 0.020080566, -0.029403687, 0.07183838, 0.029266357, 0.06817627, -0.03665161, 0.06573486, 0.0692749, 0.0129852295, -0.022583008, 0.0002746582, -0.0413208, 0.009284973, 0.009056091, -0.014091492, 0.00014662743, -0.012649536, 0.031463623, 0.036987305, -0.022460938, 0.003211975, 0.04058838, 0.047576904, 0.03277588, 0.025054932, -0.011512756, 0.054107666, 0.02909851, 0.017593384, 0.039031982, -0.00982666, -0.0045394897, -0.010902405, 0.037078857, -0.01361084, 0.010444641, 0.025939941, 0.0071754456, -0.049316406, 0.025375366, -0.0015115738, 0.02407837, 0.013046265, 0.011512756, 0.012359619, -0.014205933, 0.0010023117, 0.0011472702, 0.010856628, -0.03845215, -0.027191162, 0.028427124, 0.0051002502, -0.05734253, -0.008621216, 0.013969421, 0.043914795, -0.009300232, 0.0021629333, 0.0049552917, 0.02330017, -0.015899658, -0.020355225, -0.010597229, 0.060760498, 0.022277832, 0.0011167526, -0.0062789917, -0.021469116, 0.00021982193, 0.08868408, 0.08325195, -0.04574585, 0.059326172, -0.033935547, 0.018356323, 0.025039673, -0.01348114, 0.020736694, 0.027297974, 0.0368042, 0.025283813, -0.0065612793, 0.02218628, -0.058746338, -0.020828247, 0.008079529, -0.037231445, -0.029678345, -0.038848877, 0.005821228, -0.038604736, -0.051971436, -0.03488159, 0.064819336, -0.05996704, -0.0030021667, -0.021438599, -0.025222778, -0.015838623, -0.011138916, -0.012161255, -0.015342712, 0.012451172, -0.002286911, -0.013618469, -0.077697754, -0.012504578, -0.004627228, 0.012962341, -0.018035889, 0.014198303, -0.03137207, 0.014854431, -0.02168274, -0.022994995, 0.01977539, -0.058135986, -0.0005311966, -0.058135986, 0.025634766, 0.01461792, -0.028015137, 0.0014305115, 0.026657104, -0.018600464, -0.008018494, 0.049194336, 0.06890869, -0.042541504, -0.034240723, 0.0637207, 0.013038635, 0.0043525696, 0.022216797, 0.011314392, -0.0072402954, -0.053253174, -0.01864624, -0.027999878, -0.012054443, -0.017532349, 0.02835083, 0.03656006, -0.042877197, -0.019699097, -0.035186768, 0.0068588257, 0.039764404, -0.010482788, 0.015037537, -0.03086853, -0.0015459061, 0.00096940994, -0.0038070679, 0.027648926, -0.060760498, 0.017333984, 0.011459351, 0.031311035, -0.013374329, 0.007007599, -0.0054779053, -0.008071899, -0.00039482117, 0.031234741, 0.0002360344, -0.008460999, 0.013656616, 0.009109497, -0.03213501, -0.008583069, -0.07287598, 0.011108398, 0.015220642, -0.0057296753, -0.026016235, -0.010177612, -0.07305908, -0.022262573, -0.03729248, -0.03363037, 0.030914307, 0.02571106, -0.009292603, 0.034851074, -0.0146865845, 0.003753662, -0.0158844, -0.033203125, -0.12988281, 0.023025513, 0.026153564, -0.028945923, -0.025436401, -0.056274414, -0.035369873, 0.0022411346, -0.0063972473, 0.058410645, 0.019821167, 0.0028247833, 0.025756836, -0.05380249, -0.015434265, -0.035980225, 0.004398346, -0.0068588257, -0.022994995, 0.003540039, -0.016098022, 0.055603027, 0.011741638, -0.012077332, -0.04147339, -0.012550354, 0.01663208, 0.023788452, -0.00055885315, -0.023208618, -0.009811401, -0.0025730133, -0.0028495789, 0.019302368, 0.0029029846, -0.004146576, -0.012039185, 0.00037932396, -0.018844604, 0.027389526, 0.0073928833, 0.0059013367, -0.008216858, -0.036346436, -0.006919861, -0.021316528, -0.03302002, -0.008460999, 0.054870605, -0.018463135, 0.025985718, -0.020812988, -0.039978027, 0.035369873, -0.0010995865, -0.015434265, -0.015960693, -0.01876831, 0.0032348633, -0.009178162, -0.014930725, 0.014953613, 0.0016517639, -0.0057907104, 0.01940918, 0.007270813, 0.027557373, -0.079711914, 0.003944397, -0.011886597, -0.12609863, -0.045288086, 0.01675415, -0.04449463, -0.028442383, -0.06726074, 0.0070228577, -0.01789856, -0.04421997, 0.009361267, -0.0024909973, -0.03741455, -0.008651733, -0.07513428, -0.017532349, 0.08251953, 0.0047073364, 0.039916992, 0.06750488, 0.010116577, -0.016677856, -0.0099487305, 0.032409668, 0.0063667297, 0.030715942, 0.015129089, -0.026687622, 0.018676758, -0.024490356, 0.034454346, 0.040802002, -0.024627686, 0.028961182, 0.006866455, 0.015571594, 0.019744873, -0.044769287, 0.04434204, 0.05407715, -0.014213562, -0.059753418, 0.022018433, -0.0026454926, -0.008911133, -0.0027809143, -0.04714966, 0.023040771, 0.019485474, 0.028869629, 0.057037354, -0.013549805, -0.012435913, 0.051483154, 0.0019989014, -0.0026435852, -0.029678345, 0.003622055, 0.0395813, 0.0022792816, 0.020080566, -0.031707764, 0.04083252, -0.0028057098, -0.017410278, 0.002374649, 0.0033416748, -0.05831909, -0.018753052, -0.037109375, -0.049743652, -0.026733398, 0.014846802, -0.028442383, 0.03817749, 0.049682617, -0.0059318542, -0.041381836, 0.01171875, 0.057556152, -0.015975952, 0.01852417, -0.06713867, 0.011314392, -0.022323608, -0.06958008, -0.037841797, -0.019729614, 0.009742737, 0.041778564, 0.0025138855, 0.005367279, 0.03201294, 0.008323669, -0.0042648315, 0.059143066, -0.029067993, -0.028213501, 0.06298828, -0.019882202, -0.06896973, 0.029190063, 0.002193451, -0.019714355, -0.05154419, 0.045562744, -0.026733398, -0.023834229, -0.05496216, 0.026184082, -0.018951416, 0.015449524, 0.032928467, 0.036712646, 0.032562256, 0.025131226, -0.0010728836, 0.008399963, -0.04434204, 0.0014743805, -0.034057617, 0.0491333, -0.019500732, 0.012275696, 0.05569458, -0.0042686462, 0.025970459, -0.025054932, -0.019256592, 0.0039520264, 0.024337769, -0.014846802, 0.0065956116, -0.037628174, -0.026275635, 0.0066184998, -0.007293701, 0.066467285, -0.012199402, 0.028366089, -0.01184082, -0.0040893555, -0.0026569366, -0.029556274, 0.030014038, -0.033355713, 0.026672363, -0.040740967, 0.020462036, 0.041900635, -0.01876831, -0.040283203, 0.022064209, -0.018157959, -0.01260376, 0.033691406, 0.050933838, 0.03451538, -0.026428223, 0.0072364807, -0.0019197464, -0.014205933, -0.0146102905, -0.039886475, 0.038513184, 0.0069274902, 0.016708374, -0.050567627, 0.0055274963, -0.039245605, -0.017929077, -0.036468506, -0.0059547424, 0.031280518, -0.04550171, 0.024597168, 0.088256836, 0.02458191, 0.044555664, -0.04421997, 0.039245605, 0.002336502, 0.06347656, -0.010475159, 0.013153076, 0.05609131, -0.05947876, -0.019104004, 0.00078487396, 0.03945923, -0.0016622543, -0.015136719, 0.013336182, -0.024032593, -0.04058838, 0.02355957, -0.020614624, -0.025222778, -0.00048804283, -0.027786255, 0.009765625, -0.001660347, 0.009284973, 0.019500732, -0.0647583, -0.015487671, -0.014541626, -0.025466919, -0.045440674, 0.040222168, 0.0073890686, -0.04925537, -0.062286377, 0.0017166138, -0.011703491, -0.0045280457, -0.00447464, 0.018173218, -0.041534424, 0.04067993, 0.06970215, -0.038360596, 0.0053138733, -0.0067481995, 0.014152527, 0.054107666, 0.020446777, -0.021896362, -0.011451721, -0.030731201, -0.05267334, -0.003232956, 0.0017518997, 0.023544312, 0.023422241, -0.0015611649, -0.059448242, 0.025177002, 0.033966064, 0.04244995, 0.015258789, -0.0013303757, 0.029022217, 0.008956909, 0.011039734, 0.005001068, 0.05331421, 0.028839111, -0.0027160645, -0.0020923615, -0.027557373, 0.013717651, 0.029724121, 0.0044822693, -0.041534424, -0.08721924, 0.0027046204, 0.0045433044, -0.012649536, 0.020736694, 0.027816772, 0.026794434, 0.06567383, -0.006008148, 0.010482788, 0.04458618, -0.030944824, -0.038085938, -0.028823853, -0.0051612854, -0.053710938, 0.04345703, 0.027145386, -0.014183044, -0.032287598, -0.05319214, -0.035491943, -0.0062217712, 0.021499634, 0.021011353, 0.00806427, -0.029876709, 0.022262573, -0.038146973, 0.014472961, -0.008804321, 0.023010254, 0.009780884, 0.008956909, -0.040740967, 0.023666382, 0.022567749, -0.027709961, 0.004776001, -0.008049011, 0.008460999, -0.009757996, -0.05291748, 0.022216797, -0.03253174, -0.027816772, 0.013343811, 0.030960083, -0.04574585, 0.025634766, -0.020751953, 0.061340332, 0.036254883, 0.044281006, 0.06524658, 0.023895264, 0.010253906, 0.011154175, 0.020568848, -0.019042969, -0.005622864, -0.04925537, 0.021270752, -0.015945435, 0.02053833, -0.075683594, 0.026535034, 0.025299072, 0.01625061, 0.0015802383, 0.019378662, 0.022521973, 0.015327454, 0.033813477, -0.030853271, 0.05117798, -0.0020542145, -0.00027251244, 0.0026874542, -0.023330688, 0.014122009, 0.027648926, -0.0079574585, 0.0071907043, -0.04348755, -0.021194458, 0.0020694733, -0.006969452, 0.029663086, -0.005558014, -0.020324707, -0.034301758, 0.013420105, 0.011680603, 0.032470703, 0.019454956, 0.0060539246, -0.0058021545, -0.0075035095, -0.0034828186, -0.0012998581, -0.015319824, -0.0018663406, 0.025466919, -0.013923645, 0.0096588135, -0.038330078, -0.009963989, 0.003484726, 0.0043296814, 0.043914795, -0.06506348, -0.044952393, 0.024230957, 0.031234741, -0.01889038, 0.026062012, -0.038604736, -0.0061035156, -0.012916565, -0.0116119385, -0.003648758, -0.013877869, 0.041259766, 0.035003662, -0.0060577393, -0.036254883, 0.023239136, -0.038146973, 0.0065612793, 0.032287598, 0.004096985, 0.048583984, -0.0059127808, -0.03768921, 0.017318726, 0.00983429, -0.053253174, -0.015205383, 0.04434204, 0.015151978, 0.031799316, 0.06402588, 0.03463745, -0.0039482117, -0.024429321, -0.04940796, 0.017791748, 0.031829834, -0.029373169, 0.033935547, -0.050231934, -0.04611206, 0.040649414, -0.07940674, 0.06262207, -0.027633667, 0.01499176, -0.016967773, -0.0050964355, 0.032958984, -0.04272461, -0.006412506, -0.0026435852, -0.056365967, 0.008888245, -0.015205383, -0.020980835, -0.021759033, -0.012840271, 0.010284424, 0.01586914, -0.011543274, -0.0042419434, -0.019210815, -0.058502197, -0.006816864, -0.011955261, 0.01739502, -0.011642456, -0.006149292, 0.030883789, -0.0121536255, -0.030441284, -0.026275635, -0.027893066, -0.023651123, 0.009056091, -0.033111572, 0.0026550293, 0.012283325, -0.02268982, -0.04034424, 0.03552246, -0.016479492, -0.01927185, -0.011413574, 0.010635376, -0.05090332, -0.029708862, -0.011932373, -0.042022705, 0.026306152, 0.030303955, -0.016036987, -0.00022947788, 0.01625061, -0.025100708, -0.045898438, 0.0043907166, 0.022033691, 0.0053367615, -0.03074646, -0.0016374588, 0.035095215, 0.025726318, -0.045318604, -0.040008545, 0.013595581, 0.016403198, 0.0014781952, 0.044799805, 0.025894165, 0.024108887, -0.007843018, 0.02279663, -0.0017499924, -0.057861328, -0.01838684, -0.031433105, 0.030929565, 0.04525757, -0.008277893, 0.0082092285, 0.046722412, -0.0062446594, -0.0068511963, -0.019195557, 0.018066406, -0.017532349, -0.004676819, 0.020248413, -0.013145447, -0.037139893, -0.054107666, 0.030548096, -0.0058250427, 0.013511658, -0.0072898865, 0.035705566, -0.0152282715, 0.019439697, -0.0028533936, -0.059173584, 0.041656494, 0.01574707, 0.018951416, 0.017059326, 0.012535095, -0.03491211, -0.008514404, 0.020935059, -0.012435913, 0.0362854, 0.011146545, 0.04525757, 0.028900146, -0.008331299, -0.029296875, -0.0048675537, -0.032806396, 0.04373169, 0.010978699, -0.036346436, 0.0287323, -0.022140503, -0.0039482117, 0.015930176, -0.007522583, -0.030792236, -0.03744507, 0.050201416, 0.041870117, -0.00024318695 ], "summary": [ 0.05090332, 0.0058898926, -0.02609253, -0.010482788, 0.011878967, -0.04171753, 0.016921997, -0.04638672, 0.029174805, 0.02468872, -0.02470398, -0.027389526, 0.032958984, -0.016448975, -0.013038635, -0.03677368, -0.00982666, 0.030273438, 0.01525116, -0.020492554, 0.025146484, -0.008415222, 0.00060606, 0.00014603138, 0.033935547, -0.046447754, 0.056121826, -0.036010742, 0.062561035, 0.013183594, 0.034973145, -0.061187744, 0.02734375, -0.029388428, 0.03604126, -0.015945435, 0.023330688, -0.022460938, -0.016616821, 0.04498291, 0.017242432, -0.0052108765, 0.039855957, -0.018722534, -0.0034675598, 0.029510498, -0.0028381348, -0.04425049, 0.013931274, -0.039093018, 0.023345947, 0.00349617, 0.033233643, -0.03704834, -0.035980225, -0.0011806488, -0.0078125, -0.011558533, 0.009147644, 0.028961182, 0.019470215, 0.0020980835, -0.0010128021, -0.028915405, -0.028640747, 0.016708374, 0.0814209, -0.004699707, -0.006290436, -0.01889038, 0.019897461, 0.010597229, 0.004447937, 0.02494812, -0.023422241, -0.021621704, 0.028945923, 0.018112183, 0.031280518, 0.018371582, -0.002374649, 0.04309082, -0.026367188, -0.0519104, 0.016525269, -0.034118652, -0.019378662, -0.004306793, 0.012924194, -0.04598999, 0.0017404556, 0.016143799, -0.037109375, 0.02947998, -0.01360321, -0.039154053, 0.020645142, 0.034423828, -0.004676819, -0.015235901, -0.018966675, -0.014297485, -0.037231445, -0.009239197, 0.029052734, 0.011672974, 0.016067505, 0.007598877, 0.055603027, -0.0057525635, 0.0015897751, 0.094055176, -0.0038204193, 0.0014505386, -0.04360962, 0.040222168, 0.0073394775, -0.035491943, -0.018341064, 0.005405426, -0.022521973, -0.0005517006, 0.034729004, 0.039398193, 0.015090942, 0.016586304, 0.005695343, -0.017440796, 0.03970337, -0.010246277, -0.00043797493, 0.046173096, -0.04449463, -0.05316162, -0.07598877, 0.016082764, -0.005542755, 0.0047721863, 0.047027588, -0.056549072, 0.072143555, 0.006881714, 0.0018873215, 0.072631836, 0.03463745, -0.009460449, 0.008377075, 0.030151367, 0.0054893494, 0.00069093704, 0.027404785, 0.0043907166, 0.06341553, -0.0368042, -0.1081543, -0.06964111, -0.056243896, -0.01675415, 0.012207031, -0.050048828, -0.0034999847, -0.014785767, 0.00049877167, -0.021438599, -0.009155273, -0.003955841, -0.020370483, 0.00012719631, 0.0040512085, -0.023712158, -0.000009059906, 0.005405426, 0.015258789, -0.04711914, -0.01713562, -0.011154175, 0.05117798, 0.035888672, -0.018508911, 0.020309448, 0.0036144257, -0.036956787, 0.057281494, -0.03756714, -0.045440674, 0.06060791, 0.013549805, 0.07562256, -0.014045715, 0.012870789, 0.025985718, 0.04727173, -0.03390503, -0.014816284, -0.00015687943, -0.001666069, 0.01914978, -0.0022945404, 0.016998291, -0.019561768, 0.057281494, 0.009300232, -0.060913086, 0.00026392937, -0.12805176, -0.012634277, -0.025360107, 0.02583313, -0.0143585205, 0.05618286, 0.034057617, 0.044036865, -0.053009033, 0.03390503, 0.044128418, -0.026992798, 0.014694214, 0.000992775, 0.012054443, -0.049194336, 0.028137207, 0.01663208, 0.026138306, 0.0758667, -0.0059547424, -0.0034770966, 0.0035743713, 0.021728516, 0.070373535, 0.041137695, 0.07196045, -0.053710938, 0.1015625, 0.101379395, 0.027816772, 0.010795593, 0.058166504, -0.09301758, 0.015045166, 0.025177002, 0.01600647, 0.038848877, -0.039245605, -0.004447937, 0.035736084, -0.052642822, -0.013511658, 0.023986816, 0.026641846, 0.028656006, -0.03564453, -0.024917603, 0.037017822, -0.02468872, 0.033294678, 0.020309448, 0.00818634, 0.010101318, -0.03878784, 0.028396606, -0.028900146, -0.010292053, 0.017730713, 0.0034370422, -0.014091492, 0.00762558, -0.000875473, 0.0070495605, -0.0069618225, -0.013313293, 0.01727295, -0.012535095, -0.008384705, -0.0491333, -0.0023345947, -0.05999756, -0.061828613, 0.062927246, 0.020187378, -0.056915283, 0.01763916, 0.04748535, 0.014770508, -0.019485474, -0.0019111633, 0.009864807, 0.0017709732, 0.027542114, -0.00021219254, 0.034362793, 0.051879883, 0.017807007, -0.007507324, 0.019302368, -0.050567627, 0.013000488, 0.008766174, 0.013801575, 0.0019950867, -0.013442993, 0.009933472, 0.045318604, -0.020431519, 0.010101318, 0.025756836, 0.017486572, 0.06384277, -0.02633667, -0.008995056, 0.03753662, -0.07287598, -0.027069092, 0.030044556, 0.047943115, -0.003358841, -0.03363037, 0.028198242, 0.030563354, -0.022094727, -0.03918457, 0.03112793, -0.03289795, 0.03643799, -0.013015747, -0.0032463074, -0.032348633, 0.022735596, -0.007881165, -0.021713257, -0.023803711, -0.03591919, -0.06036377, -0.051849365, 0.021347046, -0.011375427, -0.009483337, -0.014343262, -0.032928467, -0.02357483, 0.01890564, -0.022583008, 0.006290436, 0.019683838, -0.055877686, -0.034118652, -0.023147583, 0.0057754517, -0.0029830933, -0.0008234978, -0.0049858093, 0.029281616, 0.006259918, 0.011634827, 0.08081055, 0.066589355, -0.026229858, -0.034851074, 0.060760498, 0.009529114, -0.009773254, 0.007369995, -0.0002939701, -0.032989502, -0.041992188, -0.0005788803, 0.0024547577, 0.012962341, -0.0357666, 0.083862305, 0.04901123, -0.016967773, 0.03503418, -0.059692383, 0.01675415, 0.05126953, -0.017318726, 0.09375, -0.0029087067, -0.009979248, 0.05368042, 0.010223389, 0.03326416, -0.066101074, 0.006061554, 0.009536743, 0.015731812, -0.015449524, 0.053955078, -0.048736572, -0.024139404, -0.05090332, 0.036071777, 0.009841919, -0.033447266, -0.013252258, 0.000039339066, -0.01651001, 0.012390137, -0.0061683655, -0.018005371, -0.014709473, -0.02670288, -0.013206482, -0.02670288, -0.03024292, -0.015640259, -0.03805542, -0.022598267, 0.027572632, 0.011566162, 0.022262573, 0.024810791, 0.013839722, 0.02330017, -0.028045654, -0.0069351196, -0.029708862, 0.0035057068, 0.042236328, -0.019363403, -0.036956787, 0.028411865, -0.0033874512, 0.029769897, 0.0075645447, 0.03326416, 0.01626587, -0.0040740967, 0.028549194, -0.016906738, 0.000008285046, -0.02015686, 0.027130127, 0.014907837, -0.04534912, -0.00013184547, -0.009239197, 0.022232056, 0.041870117, -0.059661865, -0.054840088, 0.0035476685, 0.017074585, 0.009162903, -0.00018191338, -0.009735107, 0.008918762, -0.026153564, 0.01486969, 0.025115967, -0.004283905, -0.018753052, -0.016540527, 0.019699097, -0.032043457, 0.073791504, -0.0068740845, 0.011436462, 0.057556152, -0.06945801, -0.046539307, -0.027999878, -0.04611206, 0.011245728, 0.015945435, 0.0050964355, 0.04953003, 0.016998291, -0.0048217773, -0.008293152, 0.0005054474, -0.034484863, -0.054107666, -0.049835205, -0.005657196, -0.024139404, 0.016830444, -0.021835327, 0.11199951, 0.0034637451, -0.001991272, 0.011253357, 0.045684814, -0.0552063, -0.013130188, -0.006416321, -0.06817627, -0.06414795, 0.0024795532, -0.0028190613, -0.00064229965, -0.05340576, 0.008018494, -0.026000977, -0.05316162, 0.012367249, -0.0034160614, 0.020980835, -0.010429382, -0.047698975, 0.016357422, 0.003692627, -0.013259888, 0.01524353, -0.007522583, 0.011993408, 0.02017212, 0.019470215, 0.026184082, -0.021728516, 0.011520386, 0.0010976791, -0.022232056, -0.016906738, -0.009765625, 0.025802612, 0.0446167, -0.083740234, 0.059417725, 0.015563965, 0.004009247, 0.007965088, 0.0158844, 0.011276245, 0.024841309, -0.0047798157, 0.013893127, 0.047973633, 0.012802124, 0.008575439, -0.020523071, -0.02017212, -0.011711121, 0.014228821, 0.03567505, -0.022094727, 0.004837036, -0.02444458, -0.0015411377, 0.0357666, -0.026870728, -0.03717041, 0.0154418945, 0.023773193, -0.019683838, 0.012870789, -0.026611328, 0.017349243, 0.0181427, -0.016281128, 0.01259613, 0.0024929047, -0.05404663, -0.042419434, 0.00258255, -0.012710571, -0.009803772, 0.0005712509, -0.0056762695, 0.014625549, 0.01448822, -0.017227173, -0.02709961, 0.02204895, 0.012512207, 0.025482178, -0.045196533, -0.09942627, -0.022872925, -0.019042969, -0.055908203, -0.030166626, -0.043823242, -0.011802673, 0.009796143, 0.0005893707, 0.022064209, 0.040618896, 0.016784668, -0.008094788, 0.019454956, -0.0049972534, -0.018295288, 0.0362854, -0.034942627, -0.039215088, 0.040100098, -0.03881836, -0.014892578, -0.030761719, 0.06274414, -0.0040664673, -0.05166626, -0.08569336, 0.016952515, 0.028808594, -0.02204895, 0.06915283, 0.048065186, 0.03237915, 0.019683838, -0.0041236877, 0.01914978, -0.011543274, 0.041107178, -0.042388916, -0.0030403137, 0.03414917, -0.036376953, 0.01776123, 0.014892578, 0.012496948, 0.0008583069, -0.023406982, 0.009429932, 0.032318115, -0.032165527, -0.0011167526, 0.0063095093, -0.0049057007, 0.029571533, -0.021896362, 0.029067993, 0.045043945, -0.039642334, 0.01399231, 0.028137207, -0.014076233, -0.043945312, 0.008651733, -0.029586792, 0.011299133, -0.029281616, 0.05117798, 0.02798462, -0.045837402, -0.02545166, 0.00018274784, -0.0019950867, -0.030776978, 0.03842163, 0.03869629, 0.0317688, -0.07537842, 0.022628784, 0.005672455, -0.020309448, -0.0015525818, -0.014450073, -0.0026683807, 0.0022029877, -0.0069236755, -0.03967285, -0.01234436, 0.040405273, -0.030151367, -0.03643799, -0.046051025, 0.028656006, -0.05014038, -0.028289795, 0.03543091, -0.024169922, 0.03881836, -0.043945312, 0.026489258, -0.019927979, 0.025115967, -0.024429321, -0.01890564, 0.006526947, -0.029449463, 0.008087158, -0.0012292862, 0.036865234, 0.031799316, -0.010635376, 0.0012216568, -0.017654419, 0.0023975372, -0.008712769, -0.033172607, -0.0038700104, -0.018051147, -0.00028157234, 0.011169434, 0.03427124, 0.03060913, 0.0038852692, -0.003156662, -0.00014317036, 0.01322937, -0.017456055, 0.0011320114, 0.004627228, -0.0061149597, -0.066223145, -0.053375244, -0.00043320656, 0.025894165, -0.021636963, -0.025848389, 0.046325684, -0.040161133, -0.027008057, 0.020385742, -0.003982544, 0.030181885, 0.00029802322, 0.023834229, 0.011489868, -0.019882202, -0.015609741, -0.013336182, -0.055664062, -0.005104065, 0.024871826, -0.023483276, 0.0152282715, 0.07232666, 0.00089263916, -0.034729004, 0.050048828, 0.012527466, 0.032470703, 0.011520386, 0.016464233, 0.011917114, 0.0066986084, 0.025436401, -0.013084412, 0.022705078, -0.037139893, 0.014030457, 0.028213501, -0.03567505, 0.013175964, 0.0008239746, -0.005672455, -0.07861328, -0.05731201, -0.019882202, 0.017684937, -0.0112838745, 0.030090332, 0.031143188, 0.00009584427, 0.0947876, -0.0058059692, 0.0066833496, 0.021942139, -0.015045166, 0.0051078796, -0.04119873, 0.012252808, -0.053466797, 0.04385376, 0.007789612, 0.01576233, -0.025131226, -0.021255493, 0.0009303093, -0.036743164, -0.0141067505, 0.006767273, -0.01637268, 0.004825592, 0.00059366226, -0.034210205, 0.01737976, 0.026046753, 0.0052604675, -0.0013971329, -0.0033092499, -0.0070648193, 0.018692017, 0.016082764, -0.018554688, -0.02268982, -0.042419434, -0.003080368, -0.013298035, -0.0065994263, 0.024047852, -0.036621094, 0.021255493, 0.007789612, 0.039520264, -0.045166016, -0.0029315948, 0.010063171, 0.04598999, 0.015434265, -0.026321411, 0.016113281, 0.051605225, 0.024673462, -0.007701874, 0.03213501, 0.012748718, 0.0012559891, -0.02078247, 0.029220581, 0.027252197, 0.002714157, -0.0070343018, 0.051727295, 0.026550293, -0.03869629, 0.033569336, -0.0039787292, -0.0029029846, 0.03152466, -0.04598999, 0.029327393, -0.027862549, -0.025146484, -0.009170532, 0.012481689, -0.023666382, 0.012611389, 0.04385376, -0.011116028, -0.0028152466, -0.013153076, 0.000012278557, -0.00030732155, -0.011390686, 0.00086307526, -0.025054932, 0.02267456, -0.011817932, 0.027282715, 0.035736084, 0.055480957, -0.017868042, -0.022354126, 0.025939941, 0.0052108765, -0.006259918, 0.050750732, -0.009513855, 0.023468018, 0.011489868, 0.027145386, -0.05078125, -0.014770508, 0.0058250427, -0.0037059784, 0.00006842613, 0.06652832, -0.031677246, -0.020614624, 0.023086548, 0.023101807, -0.023529053, 0.010765076, -0.03366089, 0.027252197, -0.017822266, -0.057739258, 0.02116394, -0.03463745, 0.033111572, 0.0061187744, 0.046447754, -0.023620605, 0.02330017, -0.027420044, 0.045532227, 0.04034424, 0.014198303, 0.05343628, 0.017562866, -0.031555176, 0.04196167, 0.020004272, -0.026763916, 0.026412964, 0.026504517, 0.030975342, 0.002128601, 0.0423584, -0.027770996, 0.0071411133, -0.011528015, 0.006565094, 0.0124435425, -0.013305664, -0.007888794, 0.013549805, -0.03363037, -0.006969452, 0.017578125, -0.057800293, 0.025360107, -0.02243042, 0.03289795, 0.010726929, -0.055267334, 0.014213562, 0.007534027, -0.0056152344, 0.01096344, -0.06549072, 0.034240723, 0.01777649, -0.024414062, 0.037231445, -0.024871826, -0.051513672, 0.027862549, -0.0021839142, 0.020950317, -0.005706787, -0.018417358, -0.017745972, 0.008117676, 0.027557373, 0.022064209, -0.033813477, 0.030670166, 0.0029525757, -0.0033397675, -0.019256592, -0.032562256, 0.0287323, 0.04284668, -0.012016296, 0.017074585, 0.023330688, -0.0178833, -0.059570312, 0.013931274, -0.0021419525, -0.030471802, -0.027069092, -0.0011148453, -0.03491211, -0.009941101, -0.024490356, -0.028381348, -0.000040113926, 0.039794922, 0.016403198, -0.033111572, 0.03640747, -0.007446289, -0.04928589, 0.0017738342, -0.0049858093, 0.0047073364, -0.011276245, -0.015151978, 0.0035629272, 0.027633667, -0.008895874, -0.0045166016, 0.034118652, 0.0012664795, 0.017913818, 0.017288208, 0.018493652, 0.003856659, -0.013122559, 0.01940918, 0.0025177002, -0.02053833, 0.000065505505, 0.013214111, 0.0423584, 0.024307251, -0.03479004, 0.022109985, 0.021987915, -0.033691406, -0.043945312, 0.0021190643, 0.026672363, -0.060943604, 0.022064209, -0.018295288, -0.034454346, -0.044952393, -0.06695557, -0.0057029724, -0.0076446533, -0.0473938, 0.013061523, 0.04360962, -0.057403564, 0.0032596588, 0.021575928, 0.0032691956, 0.023147583, -0.01473999, 0.05218506, -0.055847168, 0.06097412, -0.0049591064, -0.0005135536, 0.032043457, -0.005748749, 0.027542114, 0.012283325, 0.06185913, 0.0115356445, 0.02331543, -0.012413025, -0.049926758, -0.02923584, 0.017486572, 0.03112793, -0.018188477, 0.09118652, -0.030654907, 0.008407593, -0.0023880005, -0.0017356873, -0.009132385, -0.017044067, 0.08105469, 0.00027513504, 0.007320404 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2005.05021v5
Prescribing Deep Attentive Score Prediction Attracts Improved Student Engagement
Youngnam Lee, Byungsoo Kim, Dongmin Shin, JungHoon Kim, Jineon Baek, Jinhwan Lee, Youngduck Choi
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.LG
Intelligent Tutoring Systems (ITSs) have been developed to provide students with personalized learning experiences by adaptively generating learning paths optimized for each individual. Within the vast scope of ITS, score prediction stands out as an area of study that enables students to construct individually realistic goals based on their current position. Via the expected score provided by the ITS, a student can instantaneously compare one's expected score to one's actual score, which directly corresponds to the reliability that the ITS can instill. In other words, refining the precision of predicted scores strictly correlates to the level of confidence that a student may have with an ITS, which will evidently ensue improved student engagement. However, previous studies have solely concentrated on improving the performance of a prediction model, largely lacking focus on the benefits generated by its practical application. In this paper, we demonstrate that the accuracy of the score prediction model deployed in a real-world setting significantly impacts user engagement by providing empirical evidence. To that end, we apply a state-of-the-art deep attentive neural network-based score prediction model to Santa, a multi-platform English ITS with approximately 780K users in South Korea that exclusively focuses on the TOEIC (Test of English for International Communications) standardized examinations. We run a controlled A/B test on the ITS with two models, respectively based on collaborative filtering and deep attentive neural networks, to verify whether the more accurate model engenders any student engagement. The results conclude that the attentive model not only induces high student morale (e.g. higher diagnostic test completion ratio, number of questions answered, etc.) but also encourages active engagement (e.g. higher purchase rate, improved total profit, etc.) on Santa.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2005.05021v5
2020-07-01T06:51:20
2020-04-27T02:05:40
{ "title": [ 0.061035156, 0.004722595, 0.0066070557, -0.030044556, -0.0064582825, -0.031021118, -0.0067367554, -0.04373169, -0.0009274483, 0.017532349, -0.042755127, -0.004135132, -0.020431519, -0.029678345, -0.035583496, -0.031341553, -0.0077209473, 0.016815186, -0.018951416, -0.026443481, -0.0020008087, -0.017150879, -0.010757446, -0.01184082, 0.0077667236, -0.004146576, -0.08728027, -0.0027256012, -0.021606445, -0.022506714, -0.0020561218, 0.027236938, 0.04928589, 0.013130188, -0.029769897, 0.037322998, -0.02709961, 0.012161255, -0.0073509216, 0.004261017, -0.001663208, 0.0039405823, -0.033477783, -0.033050537, -0.05102539, -0.016113281, -0.03152466, -0.0071640015, 0.02508545, -0.088012695, -0.014457703, 0.04638672, 0.013847351, -0.008293152, 0.0026378632, 0.048553467, -0.0340271, -0.004386902, 0.017974854, 0.049591064, 0.007850647, -0.0107040405, 0.016052246, -0.034973145, -0.026229858, -0.041290283, -0.0317688, 0.03125, 0.06262207, 0.0075302124, 0.008094788, 0.029876709, 0.0065956116, 0.022384644, -0.051239014, -0.008346558, 0.050811768, 0.01638794, 0.030517578, -0.020690918, -0.0077934265, -0.017074585, 0.030578613, -0.043762207, 0.013626099, -0.024734497, -0.012741089, 0.007774353, -0.010131836, -0.055908203, -0.00019907951, 0.0045394897, -0.031982422, 0.0317688, -0.011299133, -0.057159424, 0.009315491, 0.039398193, -0.007411957, -0.024383545, -0.043823242, 0.024597168, -0.08325195, -0.011009216, -0.0010900497, 0.03616333, -0.012702942, -0.05279541, -0.029022217, 0.01007843, -0.02571106, -0.015945435, 0.007911682, 0.024307251, -0.021102905, -0.02810669, -0.018310547, -0.012634277, -0.032226562, -0.019348145, -0.0063476562, 0.018981934, 0.010231018, -0.0019989014, 0.012069702, 0.020629883, -0.016235352, -0.009376526, 0.004386902, 0.011329651, 0.009155273, 0.05203247, -0.08721924, -0.07208252, -0.07977295, 0.028564453, -0.014961243, 0.012908936, -0.023132324, -0.011634827, 0.044708252, -0.01939392, 0.028640747, 0.01626587, 0.006702423, -0.004547119, 0.024673462, 0.034423828, -0.0047569275, -0.06585693, 0.030548096, -0.028778076, -0.019729614, 0.017684937, -0.044555664, 0.028915405, -0.12414551, 0.049713135, 0.038513184, 0.062561035, 0.064331055, -0.0022792816, -0.038482666, 0.055114746, 0.03466797, -0.0011901855, -0.01159668, 0.030471802, 0.021560669, 0.05050659, -0.0007696152, 0.0028018951, -0.01524353, 0.0020446777, 0.0044517517, 0.007888794, 0.01676941, -0.00008928776, 0.0052261353, -0.011856079, -0.0010318756, -0.024993896, 0.008453369, 0.008483887, -0.0011940002, -0.057525635, -0.01184082, -0.044799805, 0.044189453, 0.019042969, -0.058013916, 0.027542114, -0.0395813, -0.059692383, -0.041381836, 0.0035991669, 0.01927185, 0.008979797, 0.006374359, 0.03881836, -0.010871887, 0.012451172, -0.016403198, 0.030380249, -0.040252686, -0.012954712, -0.008430481, -0.003232956, 0.016921997, 0.03390503, 0.0041046143, -0.013763428, 0.010299683, -0.00843811, -0.026489258, -0.050720215, -0.017333984, -0.031402588, 0.008796692, 0.0022201538, 0.0040893555, 0.021987915, -0.0026836395, 0.0014467239, 0.010047913, 0.03387451, -0.0020179749, -0.004962921, 0.044708252, 0.036102295, 0.032470703, -0.022903442, 0.021835327, 0.002565384, -0.039123535, 0.0048599243, 0.019439697, -0.035980225, -0.00077199936, 0.02911377, 0.018676758, -0.0005464554, 0.012191772, 0.019210815, 0.05178833, 0.0017147064, 0.014755249, -0.008712769, 0.018951416, 0.016036987, 0.02557373, -0.0028266907, 0.0435791, -0.017959595, -0.028137207, 0.06756592, -0.018875122, -0.0061187744, -0.0069847107, 0.01184082, 0.00982666, 0.03353882, 0.010154724, 0.01525116, -0.042144775, -0.020965576, -0.020080566, 0.010185242, -0.015640259, -0.008735657, 0.036956787, 0.008293152, 0.010414124, -0.04321289, -0.013748169, 0.00066947937, -0.054748535, 0.05529785, 0.031173706, -0.042907715, -0.006729126, -0.00073194504, 0.0024490356, -0.0033435822, 0.007888794, 0.016860962, 0.013214111, 0.00667572, -0.019866943, -0.013549805, 0.009307861, 0.024673462, -0.011703491, 0.025863647, 0.060913086, -0.013587952, 0.018661499, 0.035247803, -0.013595581, 0.01939392, -0.0413208, 0.03149414, 0.033721924, 0.0041389465, -0.011833191, 0.05581665, -0.00009256601, 0.010154724, -0.007980347, -0.029785156, 0.04168701, 0.030380249, 0.013160706, 0.066223145, -0.06365967, -0.041046143, -0.015144348, 0.027770996, -0.0151901245, -0.019607544, 0.036254883, 0.011688232, -0.013641357, -0.026657104, 0.0129776, -0.02319336, -0.07293701, -0.0284729, -0.01687622, 0.034301758, 0.047058105, 0.016464233, -0.050750732, -0.0390625, -0.0060272217, 0.012901306, 0.016036987, -0.03479004, -0.016845703, -0.00042891502, 0.017684937, -0.056518555, 0.0023860931, -0.0096206665, -0.033172607, -0.051696777, 0.0009570122, -0.009254456, -0.026000977, -0.008964539, 0.05053711, 0.013847351, -0.0034389496, -0.008857727, 0.041625977, -0.011405945, -0.00932312, 0.017364502, 0.026916504, -0.013336182, 0.07879639, 0.049316406, 0.053375244, -0.061584473, -0.040405273, -0.09429932, -0.016967773, -0.04260254, -0.00055217743, 0.005104065, -0.044189453, -0.029663086, 0.0005106926, 0.0076446533, -0.005519867, 0.01586914, 0.023605347, 0.0032691956, -0.024673462, -0.009941101, 0.03704834, -0.037231445, 0.054901123, -0.058013916, 0.027832031, 0.03665161, 0.009735107, -0.05014038, 0.023635864, -0.012268066, 0.00077724457, -0.010635376, -0.059906006, 0.0262146, 0.015075684, 0.023605347, -0.016601562, -0.038208008, -0.10821533, 0.0034828186, 0.03640747, -0.00086545944, -0.015533447, 0.017593384, -0.024246216, -0.01751709, 0.016433716, -0.022979736, 0.036376953, 0.008224487, 0.014320374, 0.027999878, 0.012397766, 0.025054932, -0.010719299, -0.042785645, -0.03439331, 0.023773193, -0.027526855, -0.028656006, 0.018325806, 0.007888794, -0.01399231, -0.008857727, 0.036468506, 0.07086182, 0.018753052, -0.045074463, 0.054595947, -0.030441284, 0.021072388, -0.0055007935, -0.01486969, -0.0158844, 0.00642395, 0.024047852, -0.023391724, 0.013626099, -0.0019817352, 0.00033020973, -0.014671326, -0.008560181, -0.031219482, 0.029571533, -0.028686523, -0.026550293, -0.010795593, -0.016555786, -0.017196655, -0.027816772, -0.0064888, -0.016235352, -0.018249512, 0.016235352, -0.012779236, 0.10650635, 0.007358551, 0.04888916, 0.01991272, -0.01864624, -0.015075684, -0.044281006, 0.021118164, 0.036315918, -0.005706787, 0.018875122, 0.044799805, -0.0115737915, -0.023452759, -0.0047912598, -0.028244019, 0.027267456, -0.01423645, -0.026870728, 0.018722534, -0.038085938, -0.013153076, -0.0018939972, 0.019363403, -0.007221222, 0.004825592, 0.02633667, 0.015563965, -0.083984375, -0.03640747, 0.015335083, -0.10437012, -0.064331055, 0.02230835, -0.030410767, -0.04611206, -0.022354126, 0.020370483, -0.038970947, -0.009475708, 0.009185791, -0.014038086, 0.05328369, 0.021514893, -0.07849121, 0.004802704, 0.04815674, -0.042541504, 0.0046691895, -0.015411377, 0.01007843, 0.06262207, 0.003326416, -0.018798828, -0.022079468, 0.09979248, -0.027862549, 0.004245758, -0.0070877075, -0.021118164, -0.031951904, 0.027404785, 0.0063285828, -0.02104187, 0.021102905, 0.027999878, 0.055664062, -0.05105591, 0.047973633, 0.046173096, -0.04196167, -0.0463562, 0.0027828217, -0.0033035278, -0.016204834, -0.002714157, 0.00025725365, 0.037841797, 0.040618896, 0.0032787323, 0.017990112, -0.0046691895, -0.022872925, 0.007980347, 0.017028809, -0.020950317, -0.009552002, -0.002565384, 0.026397705, -0.011917114, -0.011482239, -0.02482605, 0.025985718, -0.03274536, -0.030426025, 0.014785767, 0.032836914, -0.080566406, -0.0061302185, 0.004009247, -0.101989746, -0.033966064, 0.014350891, -0.015777588, 0.004322052, 0.041992188, -0.001742363, -0.042907715, -0.001663208, 0.0058059692, -0.006134033, -0.035888672, -0.09234619, -0.020050049, -0.029220581, -0.06390381, -0.0037231445, -0.038604736, -0.040100098, 0.022216797, -0.0014219284, -0.036987305, 0.0074005127, 0.015701294, 0.02923584, 0.02293396, 0.0035247803, -0.022323608, 0.02067566, -0.020812988, -0.0020561218, 0.01676941, 0.008232117, -0.0068740845, -0.020904541, -0.02027893, -0.0029678345, -0.010406494, -0.05444336, 0.01890564, 0.006263733, 0.020889282, 0.00881958, 0.016525269, 0.022583008, 0.033172607, 0.016616821, 0.023468018, -0.031311035, -0.05126953, -0.00038218498, 0.0028514862, 0.037475586, 0.041290283, 0.04446411, 0.051483154, -0.04547119, -0.0066070557, 0.054992676, 0.014831543, -0.011421204, 0.008964539, 0.018203735, -0.026397705, -0.02520752, -0.0020275116, -0.037628174, 0.016998291, -0.04522705, 0.024093628, 0.009376526, 0.0029449463, 0.039764404, -0.012161255, 0.0016508102, 0.02468872, -0.003189087, -0.074401855, -0.08068848, -0.009887695, 0.062164307, -0.0104904175, 0.010116577, 0.04006958, 0.009635925, 0.04046631, 0.05682373, 0.04244995, -0.008041382, 0.0053977966, 0.0256958, 0.019042969, -0.014961243, -0.035369873, -0.060913086, -0.0010175705, 0.021728516, -0.020950317, 0.021621704, -0.020217896, -0.024765015, -0.034332275, -0.053497314, 0.009719849, -0.0635376, -0.019454956, 0.015235901, 0.00031781197, 0.043182373, 0.033233643, 0.07098389, -0.004940033, 0.038238525, 0.004257202, 0.026748657, 0.010444641, -0.031051636, -0.019989014, -0.031021118, 0.026016235, -0.013366699, -0.005458832, 0.010017395, 0.015670776, -0.050964355, 0.021865845, -0.0014772415, -0.02508545, 0.031280518, -0.054260254, -0.011978149, 0.0014038086, 0.05203247, -0.017105103, -0.033111572, -0.021102905, 0.04446411, -0.045074463, 0.026550293, 0.026382446, -0.039611816, -0.034820557, -0.06488037, 0.046569824, -0.014251709, 0.010414124, -0.029083252, 0.023452759, -0.05343628, 0.025726318, -0.00440979, -0.03643799, -0.026062012, 0.025299072, 0.015106201, 0.012687683, 0.007965088, -0.048828125, -0.009971619, 0.010299683, 0.0044898987, 0.029571533, 0.007904053, 0.01663208, -0.006641388, -0.0031032562, 0.0011529922, 0.0018062592, -0.026931763, 0.02027893, 0.0051574707, -0.026275635, 0.026626587, -0.016998291, 0.002298355, 0.018203735, 0.014717102, -0.009597778, 0.01499176, 0.010902405, 0.022766113, 0.0050086975, 0.03781128, 0.026779175, -0.031433105, -0.06329346, -0.013450623, 0.029800415, -0.005680084, -0.01335144, 0.049438477, 0.0149002075, 0.040374756, 0.00067424774, 0.015731812, 0.06329346, -0.015670776, -0.08673096, -0.038238525, 0.015945435, -0.021606445, 0.047912598, -0.0070762634, -0.068603516, -0.004207611, -0.018325806, -0.022354126, -0.0006804466, 0.03137207, -0.023208618, 0.014930725, -0.048797607, -0.056488037, -0.028411865, 0.012840271, -0.024520874, 0.0068473816, -0.031951904, -0.05404663, 0.022476196, 0.015899658, 0.010238647, -0.0435791, 0.04425049, 0.008857727, 0.0028133392, -0.0027427673, 0.012825012, -0.013916016, -0.034942627, 0.02381897, 0.015350342, 0.038604736, -0.068603516, -0.031204224, 0.018539429, 0.06188965, 0.016662598, 0.029464722, 0.002714157, 0.01789856, 0.024108887, -0.00015604496, -0.036712646, -0.016418457, 0.014381409, -0.050628662, 0.0043029785, -0.016601562, -0.006160736, -0.09313965, -0.0015258789, 0.048980713, 0.029327393, 0.012298584, 0.019256592, 0.02128601, -0.024932861, 0.03894043, 0.010612488, 0.079956055, -0.015396118, -0.009902954, 0.005050659, -0.031311035, 0.03591919, 0.035308838, -0.028503418, 0.03161621, -0.04458618, 0.006931305, -0.006378174, -0.02670288, 0.0051460266, 0.0065193176, 0.009185791, -0.0066375732, 0.036743164, 0.009185791, 0.032470703, 0.02470398, 0.024719238, -0.010421753, 0.0016508102, -0.008918762, 0.027008057, -0.0362854, 0.0030097961, 0.057434082, -0.057281494, 0.005012512, -0.020248413, -0.037322998, -0.022827148, 0.04925537, -0.009796143, 0.0060424805, -0.009559631, 0.00957489, 0.028320312, 0.07244873, -0.00038981438, -0.038726807, -0.03753662, -0.003358841, -0.0102005005, -0.005126953, 0.033294678, 0.024291992, -0.0015687943, 0.0036296844, -0.01398468, 0.015731812, 0.015640259, 0.017456055, 0.030715942, -0.03869629, 0.07977295, -0.03363037, -0.032592773, 0.017150879, 0.028167725, -0.095581055, 0.009490967, 0.0025596619, 0.03274536, 0.021636963, 0.044158936, 0.030532837, -0.006412506, -0.012237549, -0.009422302, 0.014297485, 0.044708252, -0.025817871, -0.01977539, -0.01977539, -0.03765869, -0.019424438, -0.060180664, -0.0084991455, -0.028549194, 0.020553589, -0.02079773, -0.010627747, 0.017730713, -0.016281128, -0.017196655, -0.008132935, -0.06274414, -0.006965637, 0.015716553, 0.014022827, -0.031341553, -0.018798828, 0.04257202, 0.008224487, -0.005054474, 0.018325806, 0.00088739395, -0.03793335, 0.029174805, -0.022064209, 0.059661865, -0.0055999756, -0.025146484, -0.039398193, 0.042785645, 0.046295166, 0.005596161, -0.05996704, 0.09039307, -0.00071668625, -0.017242432, 0.017456055, 0.023361206, -0.008018494, -0.0041542053, -0.023666382, 0.008270264, -0.0209198, -0.021484375, 0.054656982, -0.042388916, -0.037261963, -0.0041389465, -0.035827637, 0.06500244, 0.056518555, 0.003282547, -0.014602661, 0.0077667236, -0.019210815, -0.05456543, 0.0013828278, 0.018417358, -0.007751465, 0.00869751, -0.02758789, 0.024810791, 0.035125732, -0.06500244, -0.08660889, -0.014266968, 0.06085205, -0.027816772, -0.00737381, 0.012016296, -0.00038838387, 0.024337769, 0.010726929, -0.0037460327, -0.028747559, -0.010215759, 0.011634827, 0.013374329, 0.008476257, -0.008384705, -0.0021877289, 0.017410278, -0.022857666, -0.009307861, 0.018585205, 0.009918213, 0.0052833557, 0.018844604, 0.054107666, -0.0181427, -0.009117126, -0.046051025, -0.009765625, -0.0027599335, -0.020019531, 0.0146484375, 0.028640747, -0.03878784, 0.09008789, 0.005622864, 0.021072388, -0.01386261, 0.03640747, 0.021438599, 0.023147583, -0.011108398, 0.0072517395, 0.04067993, 0.0021858215, -0.022460938, -0.0025920868, 0.059417725, -0.03451538, -0.055908203, -0.01852417, -0.002603531, -0.0118637085, -0.009216309, 0.03353882, -0.0023555756, -0.00491333, -0.00072288513, -0.032592773, 0.011238098, 0.033111572, 0.010147095, -0.031707764, -0.018554688, 0.0042381287, 0.02494812, -0.0006451607 ], "summary": [ 0.0317688, 0.02558899, 0.036102295, 0.004032135, -0.013000488, -0.0034389496, -0.0044021606, -0.07421875, 0.0107040405, 0.03781128, -0.014816284, -0.009315491, 0.00011372566, -0.027572632, -0.03326416, -0.039093018, -0.02557373, 0.026473999, 0.017562866, -0.033355713, 0.050720215, -0.064208984, 0.014335632, -0.004058838, 0.035491943, -0.05822754, -0.037597656, -0.004184723, 0.014465332, 0.0004901886, 0.02015686, 0.0024433136, 0.028533936, 0.00076436996, -0.042663574, 0.0057296753, -0.0073051453, -0.013427734, -0.01979065, 0.0209198, 0.023269653, 0.010139465, 0.0385437, -0.05053711, -0.0059394836, 0.014381409, 0.020736694, -0.014389038, 0.058685303, -0.034179688, -0.024215698, 0.06274414, -0.008483887, -0.030197144, -0.020065308, -0.0032863617, -0.05328369, 0.024719238, 0.0116119385, 0.04208374, 0.017822266, 0.015945435, -0.012916565, -0.01751709, -0.041412354, 0.009681702, 0.026519775, -0.015838623, 0.080322266, -0.028213501, -0.016952515, 0.055419922, 0.020874023, -0.013534546, -0.038604736, -0.017547607, 0.055633545, 0.0032958984, 0.005634308, -0.017486572, 0.0029201508, -0.014968872, 0.035949707, -0.06561279, 0.02142334, -0.027267456, -0.006664276, 0.011657715, -0.012619019, -0.06085205, -0.016174316, -0.03643799, -0.05819702, 0.015731812, 0.028381348, -0.051971436, 0.012313843, -0.008476257, -0.021240234, -0.06335449, 0.018585205, -0.008522034, -0.06036377, 0.008232117, 0.020339966, 0.052337646, -0.010345459, -0.06347656, -0.012252808, -0.007106781, -0.015525818, -0.011390686, -0.030349731, -0.009986877, -0.0061912537, 0.029037476, -0.030044556, -0.0236969, -0.03378296, 0.006565094, -0.0012712479, 0.03463745, 0.013580322, -0.021118164, 0.014015198, 0.018157959, 0.00843811, -0.038116455, 0.036346436, 0.014816284, -0.0029582977, 0.013008118, -0.02041626, -0.03717041, -0.03086853, -0.000045597553, -0.04373169, -0.0046081543, -0.022720337, -0.019973755, 0.027801514, -0.005428314, 0.031951904, 0.0032367706, -0.012786865, 0.003929138, 0.0087509155, 0.011405945, -0.010902405, -0.032196045, 0.014915466, -0.029525757, 0.0057258606, 0.0039711, -0.040374756, 0.004032135, -0.101257324, 0.039093018, 0.028961182, 0.044952393, 0.042877197, 0.022567749, 0.0060310364, 0.0501709, 0.037139893, -0.035308838, 0.011131287, 0.00067949295, 0.001493454, -0.020111084, 0.0029964447, 0.01966858, 0.00018203259, -0.0062179565, 0.017913818, -0.0084991455, 0.04272461, 0.0067481995, 0.016220093, 0.008155823, -0.022827148, -0.025772095, 0.054534912, -0.019714355, 0.041870117, -0.0054626465, -0.015487671, -0.026260376, 0.020339966, 0.018493652, -0.1027832, 0.02229309, -0.010025024, -0.03314209, 0.02545166, -0.0000590086, -0.02180481, -0.015350342, 0.0070343018, -0.0041999817, 0.031143188, -0.022033691, -0.0041923523, -0.0345459, -0.07122803, -0.048034668, -0.012290955, 0.016708374, -0.0071487427, 0.019042969, 0.020065308, -0.02407837, -0.031555176, 0.07757568, -0.011886597, -0.08581543, 0.011566162, -0.04800415, 0.0071868896, -0.008331299, 0.025604248, 0.06512451, -0.017944336, 0.023132324, -0.027755737, 0.026184082, -0.008155823, 0.044647217, 0.024353027, 0.0284729, 0.0871582, -0.044891357, 0.048797607, 0.039001465, -0.01234436, -0.019165039, 0.0008468628, -0.10803223, 0.016403198, 0.066345215, 0.020187378, -0.0025749207, -0.036590576, -0.027160645, -0.014907837, -0.03451538, 0.009719849, -0.027694702, 0.020889282, 0.051116943, 0.0036087036, 0.010787964, 0.029205322, 0.013114929, -0.012870789, 0.06085205, -0.026275635, -0.004512787, 0.010604858, -0.023147583, 0.004951477, -0.0054740906, 0.00554657, -0.0015945435, -0.023086548, -0.038085938, 0.0077438354, 0.009399414, -0.0038166046, -0.055633545, 0.031463623, 0.048919678, 0.005405426, -0.034179688, -0.021972656, -0.029190063, -0.058013916, 0.048858643, 0.033233643, -0.03125, 0.00081062317, 0.021575928, -0.030410767, -0.011184692, 0.006084442, 0.00522995, -0.012046814, 0.024597168, 0.039276123, 0.037902832, 0.04144287, 0.03552246, -0.0056533813, 0.04144287, 0.015533447, -0.014305115, -0.021316528, 0.0013036728, 0.020828247, -0.020095825, -0.012374878, 0.05053711, 0.014640808, 0.004650116, -0.0068969727, 0.027038574, -0.00919342, 0.02720642, 0.0028648376, -0.025131226, -0.01965332, -0.019042969, 0.040649414, 0.10418701, -0.017852783, -0.040496826, 0.011207581, 0.07006836, -0.01210022, -0.013809204, 0.06365967, -0.0028190613, 0.02986145, 0.0040664673, 0.001159668, -0.05029297, 0.01776123, -0.0137786865, -0.011474609, 0.01461792, 0.040649414, 0.0037174225, -0.0037193298, 0.03100586, 0.0107421875, -0.009002686, 0.020401001, -0.06347656, -0.0056877136, 0.06329346, 0.04321289, -0.03253174, 0.0107421875, -0.037384033, -0.06616211, -0.027450562, 0.022842407, -0.029205322, 0.009162903, -0.02684021, 0.04763794, 0.014526367, -0.0029659271, 0.030319214, 0.023864746, -0.0034236908, 0.009880066, 0.009048462, -0.0012836456, -0.034362793, 0.057250977, 0.045043945, 0.042816162, -0.06866455, -0.07220459, -0.031234741, 0.01927185, -0.025131226, -0.03878784, -0.010520935, 0.0031280518, -0.041625977, 0.0054740906, -0.023391724, -0.04055786, 0.021621704, 0.06390381, 0.02217102, -0.01991272, 0.019042969, 0.02394104, -0.010101318, 0.04928589, -0.05267334, 0.020599365, 0.040771484, 0.013366699, -0.006011963, 0.0062217712, -0.008712769, -0.00793457, 0.0051231384, -0.020812988, 0.014205933, 0.06695557, 0.03161621, -0.045043945, -0.020843506, -0.11199951, -0.017578125, 0.02130127, 0.025848389, 0.011375427, 0.020202637, -0.039642334, 0.040985107, 0.0066070557, -0.006462097, 0.013656616, 0.0061454773, 0.026565552, -0.0055885315, 0.004878998, -0.00050878525, 0.032318115, -0.050964355, 0.009681702, 0.023925781, 0.008865356, -0.0390625, -0.032348633, 0.097839355, -0.0028800964, 0.0008916855, 0.03363037, 0.049621582, 0.008758545, -0.03302002, 0.032318115, -0.012046814, 0.02909851, -0.03161621, -0.0074272156, 0.02243042, -0.062164307, 0.013076782, 0.015060425, -0.011528015, 0.07885742, -0.06378174, -0.044158936, -0.018844604, -0.0035419464, -0.013465881, -0.029571533, 0.009559631, 0.013763428, -0.030960083, -0.008872986, -0.046295166, -0.01928711, 0.0064735413, 0.033996582, 0.038024902, 0.005962372, 0.052825928, -0.000667572, 0.034576416, 0.05532837, -0.013084412, 0.0019569397, -0.01285553, -0.026031494, 0.02760315, 0.030654907, 0.0012359619, -0.004676819, 0.006187439, -0.0118637085, 0.0030326843, 0.022842407, -0.025650024, -0.0041999817, -0.026443481, 0.0011940002, -0.046081543, 0.013580322, -0.0053253174, 0.04763794, -0.0119018555, -0.033081055, 0.025634766, 0.004322052, -0.07965088, -0.00868988, 0.0018758774, -0.057495117, -0.068115234, -0.016921997, -0.0019683838, -0.025756836, -0.006752014, 0.0050086975, -0.0030822754, -0.03125, 0.0031356812, -0.024993896, 0.043395996, 0.005176544, -0.052459717, 0.0137786865, -0.011497498, -0.009506226, 0.02432251, -0.016616821, 0.061584473, 0.05429077, 0.023132324, -0.009513855, -0.05960083, 0.060821533, -0.041412354, -0.019958496, 0.018722534, -0.031219482, -0.017227173, 0.03137207, 0.046417236, -0.0413208, -0.0050086975, -0.0028514862, 0.05496216, -0.030044556, 0.038513184, 0.01209259, -0.011917114, -0.04675293, 0.02911377, -0.038513184, -0.02848816, -0.004032135, 0.0435791, -0.009994507, 0.012046814, 0.026184082, 0.0057525635, -0.035949707, -0.06317139, 0.042022705, 0.0949707, -0.026687622, -0.064941406, -0.024551392, 0.094055176, -0.0074882507, -0.02909851, -0.04586792, -0.007713318, -0.009185791, 0.0035266876, -0.01776123, -0.020614624, -0.017074585, -0.0067214966, 0.006969452, -0.097717285, -0.037872314, 0.0053634644, 0.012161255, 0.017028809, 0.06365967, -0.032989502, -0.032226562, 0.016403198, -0.02961731, -0.0003209114, -0.066711426, -0.12036133, -0.05053711, -0.014427185, -0.028396606, -0.005584717, 0.005378723, -0.017288208, -0.015563965, -0.004989624, -0.009941101, 0.025558472, -0.00048160553, -0.014419556, -0.03387451, 0.014022827, 0.041168213, 0.023040771, -0.03363037, 0.0146484375, 0.022491455, -0.0068893433, 0.005355835, -0.0065727234, 0.014282227, -0.0007762909, -0.023483276, -0.038360596, 0.024047852, 0.027114868, 0.02583313, -0.0004940033, 0.006549835, 0.00466156, -0.014465332, 0.04812622, 0.023605347, 0.0118255615, -0.062805176, 0.06695557, -0.004257202, 0.033966064, 0.010169983, -0.014335632, 0.019515991, 0.013946533, -0.031982422, 0.024993896, -0.012008667, -0.03540039, 0.06088257, 0.026977539, 0.0023403168, -0.016418457, 0.021759033, 0.003900528, 0.009765625, -0.027328491, 0.030227661, 0.0073623657, -0.013366699, -0.018875122, -0.016296387, 0.032043457, -0.030670166, 0.018569946, -0.060455322, -0.066589355, -0.011009216, 0.059265137, -0.0061683655, 0.00680542, -0.0037631989, -0.05633545, 0.037200928, 0.037384033, 0.057678223, -0.05795288, 0.021759033, -0.006378174, 0.0047569275, 0.0057754517, 0.0059394836, -0.07501221, 0.013839722, -0.0052833557, -0.025283813, -0.0010032654, 0.039398193, -0.048095703, -0.02911377, -0.037719727, 0.033355713, -0.060394287, -0.037902832, 0.026550293, -0.052703857, 0.021408081, 0.050354004, 0.018844604, -0.01348114, 0.031097412, -0.015899658, 0.033111572, -0.023330688, -0.015487671, 0.000021278858, -0.015930176, 0.01133728, 0.010978699, 0.00016748905, 0.00674057, 0.007133484, -0.02607727, 0.018218994, 0.015838623, -0.014160156, -0.007007599, -0.006462097, 0.01838684, -0.0107421875, 0.022644043, -0.0104599, 0.03149414, -0.0056419373, -0.0048713684, -0.0058784485, -0.028564453, -0.02709961, -0.046539307, -0.04434204, -0.043121338, 0.020233154, -0.013465881, -0.037322998, -0.0070610046, 0.03866577, -0.015655518, -0.01625061, -0.01676941, -0.009002686, -0.005493164, 0.0001578331, 0.01663208, -0.01977539, 0.018447876, -0.015335083, -0.0042533875, -0.0037441254, 0.0053367615, 0.017929077, -0.014152527, -0.0088272095, 0.029159546, -0.0038661957, -0.006340027, 0.016403198, -0.014282227, 0.021224976, -0.0040359497, -0.026046753, 0.0317688, 0.00013637543, -0.0010023117, 0.0013914108, 0.010124207, -0.036499023, 0.0032577515, 0.03277588, 0.02079773, 0.0032196045, 0.053375244, 0.04071045, -0.059661865, -0.05480957, -0.022781372, 0.04736328, 0.009895325, 0.030639648, 0.05319214, 0.013137817, 0.030090332, 0.049102783, 0.020843506, 0.0357666, 0.018325806, -0.043029785, -0.019729614, 0.012786865, 0.011558533, 0.074523926, -0.009803772, -0.05203247, -0.012123108, -0.037475586, 0.012390137, 0.005241394, 0.004886627, 0.005519867, 0.036132812, -0.069885254, -0.047058105, -0.03540039, -0.0017442703, 0.0071907043, -0.009140015, -0.03164673, -0.043823242, 0.048431396, 0.016998291, 0.0146865845, -0.016326904, 0.018417358, -0.022338867, -0.019699097, 0.03173828, 0.030426025, 0.009109497, -0.010559082, 0.023162842, -0.010955811, 0.038238525, -0.0345459, -0.029205322, 0.0021743774, 0.055633545, 0.033691406, 0.011619568, 0.025253296, 0.020690918, 0.03201294, 0.00029611588, -0.015357971, -0.012290955, 0.030532837, -0.03717041, 0.009140015, -0.01373291, -0.024642944, -0.014122009, 0.019836426, 0.011802673, 0.02130127, -0.004863739, 0.014083862, -0.041778564, 0.008338928, -0.021530151, 0.05987549, 0.021560669, -0.008857727, -0.023483276, 0.036376953, -0.006290436, 0.015731812, 0.03829956, -0.004421234, 0.02268982, -0.001490593, 0.00920105, 0.010932922, -0.042541504, -0.00390625, -0.04272461, 0.023620605, -0.026443481, 0.049713135, -0.006542206, 0.05065918, 0.033721924, -0.013092041, 0.037200928, -0.0104904175, -0.013557434, 0.008285522, 0.016662598, -0.0062942505, 0.011230469, -0.02192688, -0.0087890625, -0.00014710426, -0.024765015, -0.0022907257, 0.02279663, 0.009536743, -0.0017232895, -0.016967773, 0.0054473877, 0.025894165, 0.05014038, 0.0041007996, -0.035186768, -0.0020828247, -0.006626129, -0.023239136, 0.009742737, 0.013656616, 0.017807007, 0.034118652, 0.008872986, 0.013343811, 0.004135132, -0.02368164, 0.017181396, 0.044036865, -0.05328369, 0.02520752, -0.0066947937, -0.027130127, 0.021530151, 0.024307251, -0.05419922, 0.03286743, 0.00024747849, 0.079833984, 0.07635498, 0.075805664, -0.036376953, 0.014266968, 0.060699463, -0.0025596619, 0.07232666, 0.01739502, -0.0025978088, -0.036712646, -0.020431519, 0.002752304, -0.024597168, -0.02456665, 0.007461548, -0.0038032532, -0.046142578, -0.042388916, 0.0013570786, -0.002664566, -0.02355957, 0.022521973, -0.07055664, 0.0071754456, -0.009346008, 0.025665283, -0.025619507, 0.00409317, -0.028320312, 0.030853271, 0.0158844, -0.008880615, 0.018325806, 0.014778137, -0.0022659302, 0.00031495094, -0.03656006, 0.066101074, -0.040405273, -0.0072250366, 0.049987793, 0.0129852295, -0.0012865067, -0.039886475, -0.049041748, 0.07330322, 0.04812622, -0.018234253, 0.0041542053, 0.0055007935, -0.019378662, 0.0007944107, -0.040008545, 0.029937744, -0.013938904, 0.0052757263, 0.030029297, -0.010383606, -0.04284668, -0.0071754456, -0.028244019, 0.015640259, -0.0075531006, 0.025238037, 0.021347046, 0.02923584, 0.021377563, -0.08453369, -0.010154724, -0.031036377, 0.026367188, -0.01739502, 0.0050239563, -0.01776123, 0.0065345764, -0.042388916, 0.012138367, 0.010795593, 0.05114746, -0.025512695, -0.035461426, -0.0030574799, -0.010986328, 0.03414917, 0.059143066, -0.0011425018, -0.03289795, 0.0065231323, -0.011779785, 0.013145447, -0.0062789917, -0.021972656, 0.0024986267, 0.017471313, -0.027145386, -0.031097412, -0.00491333, 0.0059547424, -0.041625977, 0.008026123, -0.016738892, -0.042114258, -0.005504608, -0.04156494, -0.0065078735, -0.010864258, -0.02999878, 0.029083252, 0.017181396, -0.050933838, 0.046295166, -0.010917664, 0.0413208, -0.044952393, -0.01626587, 0.0062789917, 0.01146698, -0.028686523, 0.01525116, 0.024383545, 0.015396118, -0.012298584, 0.016616821, 0.050994873, -0.035369873, -0.0236969, -0.05480957, -0.022247314, -0.035369873, -0.032592773, 0.033172607, 0.015007019, -0.014656067, 0.04156494, -0.005203247, 0.008277893, 0.030914307, -0.009429932, -0.015602112, 0.014533997, -0.025482178, 0.0040130615, 0.022003174 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2005.08129v5
Neural Collaborative Reasoning
Hanxiong Chen, Shaoyun Shi, Yunqi Li, Yongfeng Zhang
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SC
Existing Collaborative Filtering (CF) methods are mostly designed based on the idea of matching, i.e., by learning user and item embeddings from data using shallow or deep models, they try to capture the associative relevance patterns in data, so that a user embedding can be matched with relevant item embeddings using designed or learned similarity functions. However, as a cognition rather than a perception intelligent task, recommendation requires not only the ability of pattern recognition and matching from data, but also the ability of cognitive reasoning in data. In this paper, we propose to advance Collaborative Filtering (CF) to Collaborative Reasoning (CR), which means that each user knows part of the reasoning space, and they collaborate for reasoning in the space to estimate preferences for each other. Technically, we propose a Neural Collaborative Reasoning (NCR) framework to bridge learning and reasoning. Specifically, we integrate the power of representation learning and logical reasoning, where representations capture similarity patterns in data from perceptual perspectives, and logic facilitates cognitive reasoning for informed decision making. An important challenge, however, is to bridge differentiable neural networks and symbolic reasoning in a shared architecture for optimization and inference. To solve the problem, we propose a modularized reasoning architecture, which learns logical operations such as AND ($\wedge$), OR ($\vee$) and NOT ($\neg$) as neural modules for implication reasoning ($\rightarrow$). In this way, logical expressions can be equivalently organized as neural networks, so that logical reasoning and prediction can be conducted in a continuous space. Experiments on real-world datasets verified the advantages of our framework compared with both shallow, deep and reasoning models.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2005.08129v5
2021-05-03T02:06:05
2020-05-16T23:29:31
{ "title": [ -0.032073975, 0.0019454956, -0.04562378, -0.045410156, -0.0072669983, -0.00806427, -0.028625488, -0.0012693405, -0.0068473816, 0.02468872, -0.019470215, -0.015808105, -0.024765015, -0.02734375, -0.025375366, -0.008407593, -0.011314392, 0.024887085, -0.032470703, -0.039489746, -0.008460999, -0.042236328, 0.018997192, 0.013130188, 0.04333496, -0.031555176, -0.1048584, 0.02003479, -0.013435364, -0.015579224, -0.0052108765, -0.00008136034, 0.004638672, 0.03237915, 0.013458252, -0.0018968582, -0.036376953, 0.026977539, 0.01927185, -0.0035076141, 0.025131226, -0.009979248, -0.033081055, -0.038024902, -0.04006958, 0.024719238, -0.048675537, -0.008293152, -0.008590698, 0.038330078, -0.00995636, -0.0018033981, -0.02709961, 0.04788208, 0.026489258, -0.02432251, -0.0390625, -0.027069092, 0.04937744, 0.04827881, 0.008872986, -0.07055664, 0.031402588, -0.04159546, -0.05441284, -0.013648987, 0.015586853, 0.019058228, 0.08441162, -0.028930664, -0.036102295, 0.044921875, 0.009284973, 0.03414917, -0.019943237, -0.04522705, 0.052368164, 0.010002136, 0.020980835, -0.008262634, -0.024093628, 0.0018100739, -0.030136108, -0.045013428, 0.01399231, -0.05444336, -0.0044898987, -0.0025596619, -0.045074463, -0.066589355, -0.0033626556, -0.021865845, -0.036468506, 0.020187378, -0.005039215, -0.03753662, -0.009109497, -0.0062446594, 0.0137786865, -0.025375366, -0.01651001, 0.013923645, -0.040771484, 0.000869751, 0.021148682, 0.018432617, -0.028366089, -0.042633057, 0.006263733, 0.040130615, -0.017242432, 0.024490356, -0.003314972, -0.0033168793, 0.012535095, 0.0022239685, -0.024749756, 0.032806396, 0.01626587, 0.034240723, -0.029556274, -0.0592041, 0.007972717, 0.02015686, 0.057373047, 0.031204224, -0.048614502, 0.028457642, -0.03378296, 0.049621582, -0.014595032, 0.0362854, -0.08081055, -0.071899414, -0.050109863, 0.012046814, 0.0013113022, 0.0015192032, -0.010810852, -0.012458801, 0.036315918, -0.015235901, -0.001033783, 0.03378296, -0.007621765, 0.008422852, 0.07318115, 0.015289307, -0.06878662, -0.07775879, 0.0041236877, 0.02557373, 0.016204834, 0.011367798, -0.043518066, -0.016723633, -0.103393555, -0.02482605, 0.053344727, -0.0011043549, 0.026519775, 0.012580872, 0.0027999878, 0.021942139, 0.060455322, -0.012870789, -0.020980835, 0.03970337, -0.0039749146, 0.02670288, 0.010185242, 0.012908936, 0.013793945, -0.01914978, -0.010154724, -0.0024337769, 0.0418396, 0.013786316, 0.007888794, 0.016601562, 0.018157959, -0.021133423, 0.009231567, 0.026000977, -0.057769775, -0.027496338, -0.014625549, -0.046447754, 0.05041504, 0.0014896393, -0.016204834, 0.036987305, -0.014389038, -0.04333496, -0.04611206, -0.0065078735, 0.048034668, 0.05682373, 0.0023422241, 0.01626587, -0.054351807, 0.01537323, -0.027526855, -0.0101623535, -0.052001953, -0.031158447, -0.017456055, 0.030578613, -0.028625488, 0.04711914, 0.06274414, 0.009300232, -0.016342163, -0.021606445, -0.013877869, -0.07196045, -0.0017185211, -0.0055236816, -0.028213501, 0.0005426407, -0.03253174, -0.0074272156, -0.004322052, 0.05038452, 0.020935059, 0.020446777, -0.0041656494, -0.009162903, 0.025802612, 0.031707764, 0.06555176, -0.04269409, 0.03086853, 0.030166626, 0.009757996, -0.01222229, 0.012306213, -0.012687683, 0.017486572, -0.005432129, 0.0055236816, -0.015151978, -0.001376152, 0.018096924, 0.05822754, 0.011405945, 0.023254395, -0.0067214966, 0.01361084, 0.0025138855, 0.06341553, 0.014450073, 0.06048584, 0.058929443, 0.0059127808, 0.04876709, 0.012207031, -0.008071899, 0.019714355, 0.011184692, -0.002105713, -0.010398865, -0.0058937073, -0.0019817352, -0.051879883, -0.023910522, -0.0463562, -0.002161026, -0.017929077, -0.006275177, 0.033721924, -0.012931824, 0.00868988, -0.03050232, -0.0021877289, -0.019577026, -0.049346924, 0.024917603, 0.045562744, -0.060668945, -0.018844604, 0.0073547363, 0.045288086, 0.007572174, 0.025161743, 0.0077819824, 0.021636963, -0.021697998, -0.021881104, -0.023117065, 0.045196533, 0.044067383, 0.026229858, -0.0051727295, 0.006767273, -0.00022697449, 0.039031982, 0.05307007, -0.020812988, 0.0021648407, -0.02810669, 0.030761719, 0.005355835, -0.016555786, -0.001958847, 0.045898438, 0.010505676, -0.00031208992, -0.026489258, 0.015609741, -0.060058594, 0.00041985512, 0.008262634, -0.037231445, -0.045196533, -0.03479004, -0.021713257, -0.04937744, -0.072387695, -0.0395813, 0.10101318, 0.035858154, -0.024154663, -0.018203735, 0.015823364, -0.028701782, -0.055511475, -0.03756714, -0.022598267, 0.015235901, 0.032318115, 0.017044067, -0.043518066, 0.00038194656, -0.004550934, 0.018569946, -0.0058670044, -0.009559631, -0.024658203, 0.011016846, 0.012016296, -0.022750854, 0.01625061, -0.057739258, -0.013114929, -0.011138916, 0.021957397, 0.013832092, -0.022460938, -0.0037784576, 0.030883789, -0.037750244, -0.008964539, 0.036468506, 0.07965088, -0.02810669, -0.023117065, 0.057434082, 0.047790527, 0.0033187866, 0.03564453, -0.020874023, -0.0021839142, -0.06390381, -0.0030593872, -0.027526855, -0.025405884, -0.004852295, 0.011894226, 0.0501709, -0.064208984, 0.009727478, -0.047729492, 0.016540527, 0.014450073, 0.02017212, -0.0061683655, -0.032287598, -0.036895752, -0.011222839, 0.0115737915, 0.022277832, -0.021087646, 0.0012292862, 0.08673096, -0.011207581, -0.0149002075, 0.024246216, 0.045837402, 0.01701355, -0.031677246, -0.04498291, -0.013595581, -0.015136719, 0.0423584, 0.020111084, -0.00039863586, -0.041168213, -0.07196045, -0.015670776, 0.075683594, 0.009223938, -0.04397583, 0.039398193, -0.070617676, -0.004131317, 0.01259613, -0.019454956, 0.029556274, 0.048828125, -0.008979797, 0.018615723, 0.013465881, -0.02407837, 0.022964478, -0.047851562, -0.09436035, 0.028030396, -0.020111084, -0.01838684, 0.0006785393, -0.04144287, -0.053863525, -0.008422852, 0.007259369, 0.02293396, 0.011383057, -0.009666443, 0.015930176, -0.014343262, -0.023269653, -0.009986877, -0.008857727, -0.004047394, -0.005207062, -0.04168701, -0.029327393, -0.012680054, 0.031555176, -0.021469116, -0.029693604, 0.016998291, 0.0155181885, 0.0418396, 0.014060974, -0.0345459, 0.009399414, -0.036346436, -0.05215454, -0.013420105, -0.050628662, 0.022125244, -0.03390503, 0.015335083, 0.0005903244, 0.028930664, 0.004512787, 0.023269653, -0.004032135, -0.01637268, 0.030075073, -0.016113281, -0.07611084, 0.026641846, 0.034362793, 0.010818481, 0.01876831, -0.023101807, -0.037506104, 0.03704834, -0.037750244, -0.017608643, -0.0118255615, -0.012382507, -0.008804321, 0.0017337799, -0.03048706, 0.017364502, -0.0128479, 0.019195557, 0.013496399, -0.005973816, -0.020233154, -0.057434082, 0.0022144318, 0.00932312, -0.0871582, 0.010231018, 0.023620605, -0.027633667, -0.041381836, -0.05883789, 0.008201599, -0.0035572052, -0.047943115, 0.010902405, -0.020523071, -0.013687134, 0.009277344, -0.047607422, -0.025527954, 0.08459473, 0.006843567, -0.008491516, 0.03643799, -0.0345459, -0.032928467, -0.019577026, 0.015594482, -0.0013532639, 0.042236328, -0.0037822723, -0.0051078796, 0.020019531, -0.025054932, 0.01109314, 0.020843506, 0.0155181885, -0.011482239, 0.011207581, 0.014274597, 0.052825928, -0.05545044, 0.050811768, 0.03265381, -0.019683838, -0.08581543, 0.02658081, -0.0014543533, -0.004383087, 0.025497437, 0.0014247894, 0.015266418, 0.01625061, -0.013168335, 0.01360321, -0.0071983337, -0.03543091, 0.041534424, 0.010543823, 0.007575989, -0.0023784637, -0.011352539, 0.022094727, 0.01776123, 0.008758545, -0.02267456, 0.04257202, -0.017288208, 0.00422287, -0.01020813, -0.011886597, -0.0075187683, 0.009803772, -0.056762695, -0.015403748, -0.025665283, -0.00033020973, -0.011100769, 0.023162842, 0.047210693, 0.011741638, -0.026260376, -0.011528015, 0.075805664, -0.026321411, 0.02053833, -0.051605225, -0.011871338, -0.020599365, -0.05709839, -0.029632568, -0.009635925, 0.0017137527, 0.017547607, -0.0005850792, -0.017745972, 0.02078247, 0.016616821, 0.05340576, 0.06958008, -0.012908936, -0.046020508, 0.044647217, -0.013313293, 0.0035076141, 0.006626129, 0.009628296, 0.003850937, -0.024551392, -0.0053520203, -0.009254456, -0.032958984, -0.07702637, 0.014770508, 0.016860962, 0.00995636, 0.0423584, 0.01878357, 0.03527832, 0.031219482, 0.025405884, 0.024032593, -0.050079346, -0.041778564, -0.0012226105, 0.05340576, 0.022445679, 0.015235901, 0.060638428, 0.027954102, -0.008728027, 0.008926392, 0.013519287, 0.046813965, 0.012878418, -0.028015137, 0.057800293, -0.013626099, -0.004486084, 0.013267517, -0.016601562, 0.04348755, -0.053527832, 0.06060791, -0.04385376, -0.0058059692, 0.011619568, -0.007106781, 0.015213013, -0.010864258, 0.013381958, -0.056243896, -0.045898438, -0.0075416565, 0.06323242, -0.038635254, -0.007545471, 0.009216309, 0.041412354, 0.032287598, 0.037475586, 0.014373779, -0.03869629, -0.012557983, -0.028213501, -0.019439697, -0.020401001, -0.059051514, 0.009376526, -0.015655518, 0.019744873, -0.008659363, 0.008682251, -0.049438477, -0.02017212, -0.0071792603, 0.0039787292, 0.00730896, -0.053710938, 0.009880066, 0.06689453, 0.0023288727, 0.017440796, 0.013153076, -0.01436615, 0.016540527, 0.0357666, -0.0021457672, 0.029525757, 0.025558472, -0.08514404, 0.007167816, -0.007850647, 0.018859863, -0.0149383545, 0.0178833, 0.012023926, 0.0124053955, -0.056793213, 0.018127441, 0.020324707, -0.000005066395, -0.0007276535, -0.03656006, 0.028762817, 0.011489868, 0.0037765503, 0.016067505, -0.033203125, -0.048187256, -0.04019165, -0.013847351, -0.059417725, 0.013267517, -0.008132935, -0.02305603, -0.052093506, 0.035003662, -0.012939453, 0.013572693, -0.012107849, 0.017578125, -0.039154053, 0.006187439, 0.03982544, -0.061065674, 0.027648926, -0.03100586, 0.02810669, 0.042510986, 0.007003784, -0.014945984, 0.0057754517, -0.01966858, -0.057495117, -0.0236969, -0.021133423, -0.006088257, 0.01373291, 0.008544922, -0.05621338, -0.004611969, 0.02432251, 0.0284729, -0.015777588, -0.016586304, 0.022720337, 0.009391785, 0.005252838, -0.018127441, 0.057922363, -0.0132751465, 0.0014514923, 0.013389587, -0.013038635, 0.028305054, -0.03048706, 0.022827148, -0.02029419, -0.040649414, 0.008178711, 0.025817871, 0.030776978, -0.009063721, 0.0040740967, 0.033843994, 0.04425049, -0.013336182, 0.012565613, 0.08068848, -0.032989502, 0.0014829636, -0.016815186, 0.0031051636, -0.04034424, 0.018005371, -0.00983429, 0.0013971329, -0.027694702, -0.06149292, -0.050598145, -0.00019347668, 0.0368042, -0.0040740967, 0.0093688965, -0.064331055, -0.014587402, -0.011100769, 0.013412476, -0.0031585693, 0.016098022, -0.010543823, -0.028274536, 0.02519226, 0.02670288, -0.0026493073, -0.023803711, 0.02267456, 0.014778137, 0.0015478134, 0.023223877, -0.028060913, 0.0002872944, -0.027160645, 0.0027236938, 0.049926758, -0.00068473816, -0.009925842, 0.016723633, -0.040283203, 0.06677246, 0.029083252, 0.05819702, 0.06524658, -0.011695862, 0.0016584396, 0.012969971, -0.0019950867, -0.047943115, 0.024642944, -0.06994629, 0.005432129, -0.054534912, -0.007545471, -0.09197998, -0.0135269165, 0.0289917, 0.021453857, 0.009269714, 0.009277344, 0.03970337, 0.005126953, 0.03656006, -0.04736328, 0.058898926, 0.014862061, 0.02331543, -0.03616333, -0.015853882, 0.017730713, 0.0345459, 0.010757446, 0.014015198, -0.022857666, -0.0020122528, 0.013374329, 0.0096588135, 0.007171631, -0.011795044, 0.000787735, -0.023956299, 0.048217773, 0.026855469, 0.029663086, 0.037902832, 0.045043945, -0.058410645, 0.003484726, 0.016830444, -0.018707275, -0.0010538101, -0.028274536, 0.014015198, -0.027786255, 0.02229309, -0.009407043, -0.02583313, -0.0061950684, -0.00774765, 0.059814453, -0.058654785, -0.023330688, 0.024871826, 0.043701172, -0.01965332, 0.024734497, -0.048614502, 0.00491333, 0.021713257, 0.008178711, -0.017822266, -0.014526367, 0.03817749, 0.031707764, -0.02330017, -0.021896362, 0.008399963, 0.012626648, -0.027526855, 0.017471313, -0.020706177, 0.031173706, -0.010482788, -0.04611206, -0.00060224533, 0.015686035, -0.056488037, 0.005088806, 0.00096797943, 0.06652832, 0.04751587, 0.0692749, -0.0018424988, -0.011680603, 0.0064086914, -0.036102295, 0.074035645, 0.011581421, -0.033172607, -0.00039577484, -0.015792847, -0.025115967, 0.014434814, -0.023132324, 0.04522705, -0.043273926, 0.018157959, -0.02911377, 0.00409317, 0.018936157, -0.049835205, -0.036071777, -0.013130188, -0.025161743, -0.0036182404, -0.005126953, -0.022018433, 0.0014419556, -0.008392334, 0.008651733, 0.040161133, 0.00019693375, -0.008377075, -0.036895752, -0.03387451, 0.03793335, 0.008041382, 0.06945801, 0.015235901, -0.017074585, -0.0026187897, -0.011100769, 0.013046265, 0.002866745, -0.027648926, 0.0025310516, -0.025390625, -0.013076782, 0.026885986, 0.042816162, -0.003753662, -0.009605408, -0.05609131, 0.008178711, -0.02166748, 0.027496338, 0.022781372, -0.014266968, -0.056365967, 0.0059127808, -0.012664795, 0.012626648, -0.021377563, -0.02532959, 0.0079956055, 0.014785767, -0.014480591, -0.025802612, -0.018051147, 0.018661499, -0.028060913, -0.024459839, -0.0044898987, 0.004070282, 0.025787354, -0.07098389, -0.076049805, -0.017562866, 0.046936035, -0.023605347, 0.06854248, 0.023529053, -0.0013685226, 0.004749298, 0.019714355, -0.020126343, -0.011047363, -0.012809753, -0.006378174, 0.019699097, 0.039215088, -0.01360321, -0.013153076, 0.022644043, -0.0062026978, 0.0027561188, 0.024856567, 0.015899658, 0.003929138, -0.00064229965, 0.024124146, -0.026107788, -0.07312012, 0.0102005005, -0.01852417, 0.016937256, 0.050720215, -0.04824829, 0.00073862076, -0.0038166046, 0.047546387, 0.01626587, -0.05279541, 0.033203125, 0.03768921, 0.030014038, 0.057739258, -0.0028076172, -0.05709839, -0.0046539307, 0.0035972595, -0.014022827, -0.0072250366, 0.040985107, -0.0184021, 0.013046265, -0.014312744, -0.056427002, -0.005382538, -0.03466797, 0.037109375, -0.05328369, 0.025970459, -0.012878418, -0.013633728, 0.011421204, 0.006767273, 0.042907715, -0.02229309, -0.055999756, 0.0023765564, 0.04043579, 0.00070905685 ], "summary": [ 0.015014648, 0.004058838, -0.03111267, -0.039489746, -0.010536194, -0.020462036, -0.032470703, -0.00957489, -0.00793457, 0.016738892, -0.062683105, 0.0025253296, -0.00081920624, -0.013793945, 0.011772156, -0.049957275, -0.032287598, 0.041534424, 0.00018107891, -0.0446167, 0.027801514, -0.0703125, -0.007633209, 0.020126343, 0.03829956, -0.042236328, -0.04626465, 0.02859497, 0.033569336, 0.047180176, 0.027359009, -0.04083252, -0.015640259, 0.028961182, -0.0017194748, -0.03479004, -0.01058197, 0.0062026978, 0.024993896, -0.0063438416, 0.026733398, -0.02281189, 0.008621216, -0.044525146, -0.018707275, 0.04525757, -0.009155273, -0.02017212, 0.014099121, -0.00187397, -0.015014648, -0.008338928, -0.01676941, -0.01309967, -0.01828003, -0.0073051453, -0.05630493, -0.008651733, 0.013175964, 0.07324219, 0.037475586, -0.023986816, -0.005115509, -0.0345459, -0.02520752, 0.007419586, 0.09448242, -0.00065755844, 0.029800415, -0.030227661, -0.0077590942, 0.05053711, 0.011024475, 0.0043640137, -0.009513855, -0.031799316, 0.02267456, 0.005886078, 0.012191772, 0.015266418, -0.049316406, 0.0005912781, -0.04208374, -0.049468994, -0.0030136108, -0.013053894, -0.023132324, 0.005710602, -0.030319214, 0.009056091, -0.006904602, -0.0135269165, -0.05368042, 0.04837036, 0.036254883, -0.025970459, 0.0084991455, -0.01638794, 0.020553589, -0.017959595, 0.019073486, -0.026885986, -0.018966675, -0.0058670044, -0.016525269, 0.048095703, -0.0012607574, -0.029403687, -0.005870819, 0.010665894, 0.018859863, -0.040527344, 0.0016832352, -0.02619934, -0.008911133, 0.027877808, 0.006111145, 0.043884277, 0.006755829, 0.034851074, -0.07373047, -0.044677734, -0.012672424, 0.07897949, 0.031677246, 0.01687622, 0.031707764, 0.052001953, -0.039489746, 0.043792725, -0.0074005127, 0.012359619, -0.012138367, -0.0025787354, -0.047973633, -0.018539429, 0.005645752, 0.023605347, 0.01725769, -0.035858154, 0.10131836, 0.0056991577, -0.021087646, 0.08734131, -0.02267456, 0.04727173, 0.038879395, -0.0037994385, -0.033294678, -0.076660156, 0.009391785, -0.0024356842, 0.03768921, -0.0035934448, -0.03491211, -0.06149292, -0.050323486, -0.03414917, 0.047424316, -0.04058838, -0.005050659, 0.018569946, 0.050750732, 0.028747559, 0.024047852, -0.012374878, -0.013259888, 0.0047187805, 0.010810852, 0.0007414818, -0.010826111, 0.047180176, 0.0096588135, -0.039733887, -0.003583908, -0.03149414, 0.06149292, 0.02519226, -0.046936035, 0.074279785, 0.026901245, -0.037139893, 0.023895264, -0.027450562, -0.033416748, 0.004837036, 0.0018520355, 0.012168884, 0.03173828, -0.0040359497, 0.010032654, 0.015792847, 0.03286743, -0.038146973, -0.023544312, -0.031280518, 0.037078857, 0.009796143, -0.0010709763, 0.024139404, -0.013725281, 0.0181427, -0.018722534, -0.033111572, -0.12573242, 0.008743286, -0.03881836, 0.055847168, -0.01927185, 0.03152466, 0.016204834, -0.010627747, -0.01184082, -0.0041122437, 0.0010957718, -0.056854248, 0.040618896, -0.043121338, -0.009895325, -0.029296875, -0.035095215, 0.05999756, -0.058288574, 0.054626465, -0.007583618, 0.0032596588, -0.013473511, 0.016738892, -0.0047569275, 0.022018433, 0.02961731, -0.018569946, 0.070007324, 0.08001709, -0.0030841827, -0.009735107, 0.028717041, -0.03074646, 0.0007252693, 0.018737793, 0.014175415, 0.00095415115, -0.048858643, -0.022079468, 0.025024414, -0.0015611649, 0.015792847, -0.0073165894, -0.012771606, 0.023788452, 0.020599365, 0.01852417, 0.018447876, 0.042938232, -0.0021820068, 0.0076293945, 0.00819397, 0.007583618, 0.014656067, -0.0054397583, 0.0021438599, 0.005558014, -0.008758545, -0.00356102, -0.008331299, -0.070617676, -0.013710022, -0.027954102, 0.019515991, -0.07287598, 0.02267456, -0.009796143, -0.004627228, -0.06365967, -0.032043457, -0.058654785, -0.047302246, 0.06463623, 0.021957397, -0.060577393, 0.0035247803, 0.00919342, 0.04373169, -0.013893127, 0.042999268, 0.054901123, 0.022277832, -0.027359009, -0.0013256073, 0.052459717, 0.03616333, 0.07696533, 0.008354187, 0.031707764, -0.019454956, 0.029083252, -0.016204834, -0.019989014, 0.0118255615, -0.037078857, 0.025756836, 0.062561035, 0.0010347366, -0.012908936, 0.010429382, 0.046051025, 0.018249512, 0.009086609, 0.011299133, 0.0039711, -0.023727417, -0.013694763, 0.016326904, -0.024749756, -0.023147583, -0.021743774, -0.052825928, -0.0015773773, -0.060546875, 0.02532959, 0.101379395, 0.047576904, -0.010246277, 0.023544312, 0.024612427, -0.04434204, 0.019454956, -0.027908325, -0.0023784637, 0.006713867, -0.011528015, 0.008255005, -0.019378662, 0.028259277, -0.0037708282, 0.0016422272, 0.014533997, -0.021850586, 0.012863159, 0.033355713, 0.049438477, -0.023071289, -0.0043411255, -0.018844604, -0.061553955, 0.0146102905, 0.021392822, -0.008796692, 0.010559082, -0.0062675476, 0.015106201, -0.0077056885, -0.0022201538, 0.04650879, 0.027313232, 0.019470215, 0.014663696, 0.036468506, 0.023208618, -0.013710022, 0.018249512, -0.014259338, -0.023727417, -0.07611084, -0.006378174, 0.0015001297, -0.015808105, -0.017120361, 0.008262634, 0.021606445, -0.031555176, 0.035308838, -0.043029785, -0.0011739731, -0.013557434, 0.020706177, 0.10284424, 0.011390686, 0.0041046143, 0.07519531, 0.021469116, 0.034576416, -0.03164673, -0.008171082, 0.05316162, 0.002948761, 0.017074585, 0.023269653, 0.033477783, -0.007080078, -0.01020813, -0.007789612, 0.00096797943, -0.023086548, 0.0022525787, 0.014625549, 0.021057129, 0.009162903, 0.010551453, -0.030227661, 0.056915283, 0.022476196, -0.004234314, 0.019943237, -0.010398865, -0.03387451, 0.058898926, -0.0034675598, 0.006702423, -0.0038070679, 0.028320312, -0.011756897, -0.0022525787, 0.013534546, 0.0012273788, -0.053619385, 0.005756378, 0.013145447, -0.020614624, -0.008369446, -0.016357422, 0.049591064, -0.017303467, 0.0010766983, 0.013694763, 0.03503418, -0.0040740967, -0.008155823, 0.014007568, 0.00012290478, 0.008781433, -0.021850586, 0.00016212463, -0.032989502, -0.03353882, -0.039794922, -0.04324341, -0.035461426, -0.024246216, -0.03729248, -0.008384705, 0.012123108, -0.015991211, 0.050842285, 0.004802704, -0.030776978, -0.00084733963, -0.06506348, -0.023925781, -0.007663727, -0.024505615, 0.026062012, 0.008857727, 0.029251099, 0.0013113022, 0.004432678, -0.024841309, 0.03338623, 0.041992188, -0.032318115, 0.01991272, -0.005077362, -0.050811768, 0.032287598, 0.024291992, 0.016540527, 0.028167725, -0.010658264, -0.022338867, 0.034332275, 0.0042877197, -0.056427002, -0.026046753, -0.0076408386, -0.03152466, -0.03692627, 0.038391113, 0.03555298, 0.0075302124, -0.03173828, -0.035614014, 0.019729614, -0.05545044, -0.034851074, -0.030700684, 0.0048103333, -0.034698486, -0.00932312, 0.008644104, -0.029251099, 0.0037345886, -0.055023193, 0.018615723, -0.015701294, -0.020370483, -0.020355225, -0.019165039, 0.07373047, 0.026748657, -0.034057617, 0.022140503, -0.014953613, 0.041412354, 0.0048332214, 0.0019702911, 0.012313843, 0.005996704, -0.0005836487, 0.001707077, -0.039733887, 0.02255249, -0.037628174, 0.025985718, 0.011932373, -0.015335083, -0.036895752, 0.04058838, -0.015838623, -0.008041382, 0.017501831, 0.0692749, 0.066345215, -0.030899048, 0.012458801, 0.027801514, -0.008102417, -0.038391113, -0.00258255, -0.003932953, -0.015899658, 0.033233643, 0.020202637, -0.011878967, 0.022277832, -0.0038108826, -0.016082764, -0.04586792, -0.04989624, 0.032196045, 0.047607422, -0.0059394836, -0.032440186, -0.033416748, 0.07196045, -0.0015993118, 0.025375366, -0.010665894, 0.03640747, -0.030807495, 0.018127441, 0.0015001297, -0.006969452, 0.007537842, 0.01449585, 0.016662598, 0.0071640015, -0.013954163, -0.014160156, -0.020843506, 0.041900635, 0.027572632, 0.03982544, 0.0098724365, -0.061798096, 0.117248535, 0.0049934387, -0.012481689, -0.06958008, -0.030532837, -0.016830444, -0.048919678, -0.01939392, -0.048065186, -0.052368164, -0.027893066, 0.014335632, -0.02180481, 0.024627686, 0.0077323914, 0.035003662, 0.012588501, 0.0071105957, -0.018371582, 0.0056114197, -0.01222229, 0.009399414, 0.016662598, 0.041259766, 0.021453857, -0.01008606, -0.020492554, -0.015350342, -0.038269043, -0.12866211, -0.0007305145, 0.019958496, -0.028793335, 0.13244629, 0.05130005, 0.030654907, 0.054229736, -0.010986328, 0.014915466, -0.010017395, -0.008995056, -0.035308838, 0.034729004, 0.041168213, -0.003932953, 0.022720337, 0.005115509, -0.013046265, 0.038024902, 0.011138916, 0.03225708, -0.012069702, -0.0072746277, 0.036315918, 0.010223389, -0.008392334, 0.0067329407, -0.008934021, -0.004676819, -0.025863647, -0.034301758, -0.034088135, 0.018127441, 0.00011628866, -0.008605957, 0.029296875, 0.02267456, 0.02230835, -0.03378296, -0.020828247, -0.007259369, 0.027252197, -0.009460449, -0.018356323, 0.004173279, 0.017440796, 0.045135498, 0.011024475, 0.0014343262, -0.0501709, 0.025024414, 0.0107421875, 0.009468079, 0.022323608, -0.032806396, -0.021255493, -0.014411926, 0.00023138523, 0.010040283, -0.041290283, 0.008369446, -0.04727173, 0.009979248, 0.005569458, 0.0074157715, -0.060577393, -0.04800415, -0.011245728, -0.016738892, -0.03677368, 0.054870605, -0.030044556, -0.042388916, 0.016647339, -0.037963867, 0.022109985, -0.025177002, -0.04827881, -0.01184082, -0.0066604614, 0.007369995, 0.013702393, 0.02822876, 0.011383057, -0.008903503, -0.022247314, 0.0069351196, -0.012634277, 0.011779785, -0.034332275, 0.014572144, 0.03024292, 0.037719727, 0.010269165, 0.026992798, 0.019058228, -0.043762207, -0.06384277, 0.02848816, -0.051208496, -0.022415161, 0.004135132, -0.013397217, -0.06561279, 0.013763428, -0.021331787, 0.017349243, -0.024765015, 0.007583618, -0.03466797, -0.0017280579, 0.028213501, -0.031082153, 0.0112838745, -0.017471313, 0.018920898, -0.013618469, 0.009117126, -0.009735107, 0.006450653, -0.048828125, -0.020721436, -0.035369873, -0.0055389404, 0.010414124, 0.057495117, -0.009170532, -0.013671875, 0.024490356, -0.013473511, 0.029220581, -0.012145996, -0.022659302, -0.0049476624, 0.0059547424, 0.02519226, -0.00070858, 0.06890869, -0.007972717, -0.0087890625, 0.024734497, -0.045898438, 0.055633545, -0.023498535, 0.024353027, -0.008087158, -0.033050537, 0.0079574585, 0.032958984, 0.019210815, 0.016220093, -0.031707764, -0.0043792725, 0.036865234, 0.005142212, -0.016036987, 0.053771973, -0.0017366409, 0.01737976, 0.00037884712, 0.05041504, -0.0109939575, -0.034820557, -0.023040771, 0.014724731, -0.011634827, -0.07849121, -0.0028686523, -0.0395813, 0.009086609, 0.024353027, -0.02079773, -0.0758667, -0.023239136, -0.016036987, 0.008262634, 0.0154800415, 0.0037593842, -0.015258789, -0.0044784546, 0.01084137, 0.025314331, 0.0039749146, 0.011665344, -0.013618469, 0.002532959, -0.007247925, 0.032196045, -0.045288086, 0.013839722, 0.012268066, 0.035583496, 0.015609741, -0.02947998, 0.011894226, -0.03062439, 0.0088272095, 0.029434204, 0.034606934, 0.009490967, 0.00605011, -0.007358551, 0.007637024, 0.011459351, 0.0024204254, -0.019638062, 0.08251953, -0.016296387, 0.026412964, -0.020523071, -0.030075073, -0.041503906, 0.034332275, 0.025131226, -0.0012998581, 0.048614502, 0.001335144, 0.045074463, 0.050964355, -0.044189453, -0.027999878, 0.003610611, 0.005001068, 0.016784668, -0.074645996, -0.000029802322, 0.008285522, 0.03475952, 0.037261963, -0.005466461, 0.012741089, -0.008270264, 0.0010547638, 0.02394104, -0.033599854, -0.0690918, 0.042510986, -0.04953003, 0.011077881, 0.03112793, 0.032318115, -0.0026817322, 0.029846191, -0.030578613, 0.02078247, 0.01424408, 0.014762878, -0.0032920837, -0.020126343, -0.021438599, 0.063964844, -0.025527954, -0.015541077, -0.010475159, 0.019836426, -0.043426514, 0.076049805, -0.08081055, -0.025405884, 0.013130188, 0.013328552, -0.056884766, -0.00025439262, -0.035491943, 0.014213562, 0.013175964, -0.03744507, 0.0014371872, -0.018707275, 0.02734375, 0.016464233, -0.007461548, 0.01776123, -0.008049011, 0.021316528, -0.017318726, 0.026519775, -0.047729492, 0.034240723, 0.02658081, -0.022613525, 0.013809204, 0.03778076, -0.0262146, 0.03152466, 0.0015239716, 0.10961914, 0.08465576, 0.070373535, -0.027252197, 0.00995636, 0.0647583, -0.014579773, 0.056610107, 0.016418457, -0.022384644, -0.032806396, 0.010856628, 0.017959595, -0.026107788, 0.012825012, -0.024642944, -0.018920898, -0.0032615662, -0.033416748, -0.020431519, -0.009857178, -0.021438599, 0.029891968, -0.061431885, -0.040527344, 0.009712219, -0.002445221, -0.010383606, 0.030197144, -0.024658203, -0.025177002, 0.033416748, -0.0104599, 0.004108429, -0.027526855, 0.037384033, 0.010482788, 0.024978638, 0.067871094, 0.033050537, -0.038146973, 0.029174805, 0.0032444, 0.038208008, -0.0262146, -0.04788208, 0.031951904, 0.029296875, -0.009025574, 0.013931274, 0.027923584, -0.0077400208, -0.02796936, 0.008987427, 0.004547119, -0.023757935, 0.08483887, 0.007320404, 0.0075798035, -0.04159546, 0.039764404, -0.033111572, -0.00030946732, -0.055358887, 0.0000062584877, -0.027511597, 0.05722046, 0.019515991, -0.026489258, -0.023361206, -0.023239136, -0.045440674, -0.0008049011, -0.022445679, -0.0077171326, 0.026107788, -0.04824829, -0.07501221, -0.013214111, 0.02079773, 0.013404846, -0.02734375, 0.0059432983, -0.013450623, -0.008293152, 0.0018568039, -0.0052948, -0.00079345703, 0.011604309, 0.027755737, 0.042114258, -0.0070343018, -0.028411865, 0.004508972, -0.0018434525, -0.03048706, -0.007724762, 0.021255493, 0.0231781, -0.0231781, -0.003250122, -0.022857666, -0.031188965, -0.09362793, 0.022460938, -0.017684937, 0.002105713, 0.028793335, -0.022766113, 0.00096178055, -0.0030994415, 0.0054092407, 0.023208618, -0.01626587, 0.010894775, 0.0019035339, 0.040618896, -0.00491333, 0.03366089, -0.039794922, 0.0082092285, -0.013519287, -0.0067634583, -0.030136108, 0.024963379, -0.02381897, -0.009140015, -0.013793945, -0.042053223, -0.038757324, -0.03555298, -0.011070251, -0.03137207, 0.033203125, 0.042022705, 0.0006890297, 0.033996582, 0.002998352, -0.007610321, 0.02204895, -0.0039367676, -0.0028476715, -0.027191162, 0.0054512024 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2005.12981v1
Deep Interest with Hierarchical Attention Network for Click-Through Rate Prediction
Weinan Xu, Hengxu He, Minshi Tan, Yunming Li, Jun Lang, Dongbai Guo
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Deep Interest Network (DIN) is a state-of-the-art model which uses attention mechanism to capture user interests from historical behaviors. User interests intuitively follow a hierarchical pattern such that users generally show interests from a higher-level then to a lower-level abstraction. Modeling such an interest hierarchy in an attention network can fundamentally improve the representation of user behaviors. We, therefore, propose an improvement over DIN to model arbitrary interest hierarchy: Deep Interest with Hierarchical Attention Network (DHAN). In this model, a multi-dimensional hierarchical structure is introduced on the first attention layer which attends to an individual item, and the subsequent attention layers in the same dimension attend to higher-level hierarchy built on top of the lower corresponding layers. To enable modeling of multiple dimensional hierarchies, an expanding mechanism is introduced to capture one to many hierarchies. This design enables DHAN to attend different importance to different hierarchical abstractions thus can fully capture user interests at different dimensions (e.g. category, price, or brand).To validate our model, a simplified DHAN has applied to Click-Through Rate (CTR) prediction and our experimental results on three public datasets with two levels of the one-dimensional hierarchy only by category. It shows the superiority of DHAN with significant AUC uplift from 12% to 21% over DIN. DHAN is also compared with another state-of-the-art model Deep Interest Evolution Network (DIEN), which models temporal interest. The simplified DHAN also gets slight AUC uplift from 1.0% to 1.7% over DIEN. A potential future work can be a combination of DHAN and DIEN to model both temporal and hierarchical interests.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2005.12981v1
2020-05-22T04:02:01
2020-05-22T04:02:01
{ "title": [ 0.021911621, 0.01625061, -0.0231781, -0.046966553, 0.01979065, -0.021362305, -0.014022827, -0.019546509, 0.026809692, 0.031799316, -0.031982422, 0.015777588, -0.0024471283, -0.0070228577, -0.034057617, 0.014770508, -0.02067566, 0.033813477, -0.0041999817, -0.03387451, 0.004600525, -0.049102783, 0.05255127, 0.005039215, 0.028915405, -0.064086914, -0.051940918, 0.05090332, -0.026870728, -0.013839722, -0.0025024414, -0.0001231432, 0.0413208, 0.013153076, -0.0064849854, 0.025100708, -0.052947998, 0.029510498, 0.01864624, -0.020965576, 0.014549255, -0.00356102, -0.05532837, -0.044281006, -0.048065186, 0.029174805, -0.052124023, -0.003036499, -0.0099105835, -0.0054855347, 0.012527466, 0.02458191, 0.006877899, -0.030044556, 0.011390686, -0.033935547, -0.036499023, -0.0032253265, 0.043914795, 0.03930664, 0.011276245, -0.044555664, 0.0074043274, -0.024917603, -0.050445557, -0.022903442, 0.021514893, 0.02923584, 0.066223145, -0.01940918, -0.019515991, 0.042663574, 0.005405426, 0.016418457, -0.060638428, -0.006526947, 0.0602417, 0.017822266, 0.038879395, -0.015068054, -0.025344849, -0.022064209, -0.014633179, -0.012229919, 0.024505615, -0.00029969215, -0.02746582, -0.024475098, -0.024612427, -0.07122803, -0.009590149, 0.014595032, -0.017196655, 0.0055236816, -0.03363037, -0.026855469, 0.002073288, 0.059753418, -0.0069999695, -0.008331299, -0.04309082, 0.037200928, -0.074035645, -0.012527466, 0.0038375854, 0.002357483, -0.02394104, -0.026519775, 0.022781372, 0.032348633, -0.011299133, 0.023635864, 0.039154053, 0.046569824, -0.008895874, -0.034118652, -0.009239197, 0.029174805, -0.021835327, 0.04168701, -0.0013818741, -0.018051147, 0.0137786865, -0.0124053955, 0.015205383, -0.007843018, -0.03564453, 0.0016860962, -0.014503479, 0.042663574, 0.011940002, 0.036987305, -0.11138916, -0.064331055, -0.07501221, 0.04083252, -0.02748108, -0.009963989, -0.010932922, 0.013641357, 0.0033397675, -0.033050537, 0.011764526, 0.009056091, 0.03555298, 0.012886047, 0.068847656, -0.00390625, -0.062469482, -0.032836914, 0.008964539, 0.026489258, 0.06713867, -0.035491943, -0.08325195, -0.04989624, -0.1439209, -0.03074646, 0.013221741, -0.02267456, 0.020858765, 0.003648758, 0.009307861, 0.010650635, 0.021209717, -0.012786865, -0.024398804, 0.00856781, 0.013938904, 0.041656494, 0.008903503, -0.0015907288, -0.03289795, -0.034606934, -0.009117126, -0.0073661804, 0.0736084, 0.01499176, 0.010505676, 0.011634827, 0.010536194, -0.026382446, 0.0670166, -0.0021457672, -0.04916382, 0.031433105, -0.00983429, -0.003993988, 0.04660034, -0.00818634, -0.045928955, 0.031829834, -0.06286621, -0.053710938, -0.044036865, -0.0002746582, 0.044311523, 0.024597168, 0.011474609, 0.02078247, -0.029556274, -0.011993408, -0.0131073, 0.011444092, -0.012001038, -0.019577026, -0.020950317, 0.010475159, -0.020217896, 0.070129395, 0.048034668, 0.029632568, -0.03591919, -0.0018863678, -0.0020198822, -0.07366943, 0.03302002, 0.008804321, -0.009124756, 0.012451172, -0.044921875, 0.0078125, -0.029052734, 0.030548096, 0.026107788, 0.0119018555, 0.014862061, -0.02104187, 0.041656494, 0.054718018, 0.01499176, -0.062927246, 0.040252686, 0.00020515919, -0.022994995, -0.0062408447, -0.006828308, -0.014328003, -0.0062789917, 0.02041626, 0.004009247, -0.00447464, -0.008026123, 0.034820557, 0.056365967, 0.023986816, 0.019104004, 0.008712769, 0.014724731, 0.013053894, 0.036254883, 0.024734497, 0.048919678, 0.0013637543, 0.014221191, 0.06964111, 0.015594482, 0.029937744, -0.03668213, 0.020080566, 0.00059223175, 0.027526855, 0.008148193, 0.018157959, -0.07531738, 0.008323669, -0.037109375, -0.013839722, -0.0042266846, 0.014625549, 0.03173828, -0.0019454956, 0.003484726, -0.03857422, 0.022262573, -0.04562378, -0.042907715, 0.02494812, 0.014755249, -0.07305908, -0.021392822, -0.012084961, 0.01424408, -0.0073623657, 0.03717041, 0.00010484457, -0.0002682209, -0.029403687, -0.0012216568, 0.006965637, 0.052612305, 0.04196167, 0.0036067963, 0.0016078949, 0.012802124, 0.0064964294, 0.06866455, 0.04574585, -0.007980347, 0.032836914, -0.010444641, 0.033935547, -0.024093628, 0.01914978, 0.0006494522, 0.043060303, -0.008872986, 0.033233643, -0.00630188, 0.0043792725, -0.03555298, 0.019958496, 0.014923096, 0.0118255615, -0.054138184, -0.05291748, -0.031280518, -0.021606445, -0.07287598, -0.053466797, 0.08465576, -0.06060791, -0.008483887, -0.00983429, -0.03286743, -0.02407837, -0.004337311, -0.023269653, -0.04336548, 0.027526855, 0.033996582, 0.013832092, -0.03591919, 0.008735657, -0.004257202, 0.015312195, -0.008430481, -0.03744507, -0.028579712, 0.016311646, -0.007850647, -0.016815186, 0.010810852, -0.05819702, -0.03302002, -0.03314209, 0.023757935, 0.004108429, -0.03378296, -0.00050258636, 0.046539307, -0.0044059753, -0.022781372, -0.006641388, 0.053344727, 0.020553589, -0.025878906, 0.030929565, 0.046905518, -0.024154663, 0.030075073, 0.01940918, -0.0038204193, -0.080200195, 0.012413025, -0.04574585, -0.029449463, -0.035217285, -0.0037555695, 0.036590576, -0.053985596, -0.02407837, 0.0016880035, -0.0041160583, 0.020889282, 0.0206604, 0.025558472, -0.0074005127, -0.04510498, -0.00083065033, 0.007827759, 0.0050086975, -0.003572464, -0.01763916, 0.044403076, 0.026367188, -0.011756897, -0.020828247, 0.019943237, -0.0030536652, 0.003894806, -0.00440979, -0.044921875, 0.022323608, 0.030349731, 0.001074791, -0.005504608, -0.01651001, -0.13269043, -0.01902771, 0.027664185, 0.028701782, 0.004371643, 0.022583008, -0.081848145, 0.042175293, -0.0368042, -0.013244629, 0.025024414, 0.052886963, 0.009468079, 0.022460938, -0.0128479, 0.019195557, -0.007637024, -0.026351929, -0.060546875, 0.018554688, 0.019470215, -0.054748535, -0.009468079, -0.040100098, -0.052581787, -0.013656616, 0.013946533, 0.08618164, 0.0099105835, -0.02279663, 0.02885437, -0.010879517, 0.015625, -0.019943237, -0.017227173, -0.036315918, -0.0073127747, 0.0021705627, -0.02293396, 0.049224854, -0.017028809, 0.0049209595, -0.058044434, -0.0059547424, -0.011291504, 0.027618408, 0.013755798, -0.055236816, -0.0075187683, -0.05227661, -0.00844574, -0.0012521744, -0.019424438, -0.012313843, -0.0014467239, 0.021026611, -0.013366699, 0.03717041, -0.007858276, 0.017456055, 0.017807007, -0.039855957, 0.014175415, -0.036712646, -0.024002075, 0.034301758, 0.04437256, 0.0090789795, 0.014724731, -0.02243042, -0.035217285, 0.026611328, -0.017974854, -0.035003662, 0.019119263, -0.02645874, -0.0053596497, -0.056518555, 0.0071640015, 0.003932953, 0.028259277, -0.009803772, 0.04348755, -0.012031555, 0.008903503, -0.030578613, 0.013519287, -0.006286621, -0.0960083, -0.007873535, 0.007736206, -0.020965576, -0.029403687, -0.025741577, 0.020599365, -0.03878784, -0.037139893, 0.012062073, -0.005569458, -0.010154724, 0.00014972687, -0.03918457, -0.034301758, 0.07293701, -0.003458023, 0.006713867, 0.0335083, -0.005680084, -0.00065612793, -0.027648926, 0.0023422241, -0.01701355, 0.04623413, -0.01550293, -0.018585205, 0.032409668, -0.03616333, 0.0029392242, 0.023773193, 0.013397217, -0.023742676, 0.0066947937, 0.020889282, 0.07104492, -0.058746338, 0.056427002, 0.014427185, -0.034332275, -0.07366943, 0.0074386597, 0.003156662, 0.0010375977, 0.02281189, -0.010955811, 0.03277588, 0.020324707, -0.00390625, 0.0335083, -0.016815186, -0.03173828, 0.031677246, 0.020904541, 0.012458801, 0.018600464, 0.008583069, 0.038269043, 0.01878357, 0.024963379, 0.003648758, 0.035003662, -0.008651733, -0.037384033, 0.002735138, 0.020523071, -0.020462036, -0.016815186, -0.048858643, -0.082458496, -0.014656067, 0.005584717, -0.0005440712, 0.046447754, 0.04071045, -0.003326416, -0.025970459, -0.012580872, 0.02178955, -0.009414673, -0.007347107, -0.072265625, 0.014854431, -0.018875122, -0.06689453, -0.034118652, -0.0126571655, -0.009017944, 0.024734497, -0.0025253296, 0.003019333, 0.028198242, -0.006752014, -0.002817154, 0.04534912, -0.018341064, -0.040618896, 0.049957275, -0.011558533, -0.028915405, 0.04006958, 0.0054893494, 0.010391235, -0.030029297, 0.0026741028, -0.016677856, -0.028518677, -0.03439331, 0.024536133, -0.011924744, 0.019317627, 0.019683838, 0.059173584, 0.023986816, 0.031188965, 0.0043258667, 0.013427734, -0.022491455, -0.03591919, -0.0059394836, 0.04336548, 0.027160645, 0.021530151, 0.0259552, 0.023712158, -0.004924774, 0.0011320114, 0.02267456, 0.012145996, 0.004940033, -0.019744873, 0.025253296, -0.018325806, -0.013252258, 0.024597168, 0.0035247803, 0.057739258, -0.016067505, 0.07623291, 0.006450653, -0.012649536, 0.037902832, -0.009536743, 0.01537323, -0.008125305, 0.0003373623, -0.07891846, -0.05822754, -0.014678955, 0.050109863, -0.040008545, 0.010185242, 0.0052223206, -0.020446777, 0.03164673, 0.0619812, 0.05279541, 0.000035107136, 0.0016565323, 0.007007599, 0.009689331, -0.026611328, -0.02658081, 0.007827759, 0.01625061, 0.007896423, -0.04525757, -0.018920898, -0.037719727, -0.018432617, -0.03375244, -0.0011386871, 0.013442993, -0.045013428, 0.013786316, 0.07409668, 0.00869751, 0.04598999, 0.037902832, 0.03744507, 0.015380859, 0.035858154, 0.021987915, 0.028442383, 0.007255554, 0.00010085106, 0.049041748, 0.010543823, 0.0017290115, 0.013397217, 0.00065612793, -0.003736496, 0.0030574799, -0.027145386, 0.033477783, 0.018127441, -0.016784668, 0.035827637, -0.042785645, 0.004547119, 0.004798889, 0.014640808, 0.00015544891, -0.0053863525, -0.0084991455, 0.0055885315, -0.03237915, -0.025741577, 0.016281128, -0.032989502, -0.039123535, -0.057434082, 0.010276794, -0.022949219, 0.008338928, -0.0059547424, 0.012542725, -0.038513184, 0.03112793, 0.022247314, -0.018661499, -0.01423645, 0.014274597, 0.016525269, 0.020080566, 0.0077209473, -0.04006958, -0.004398346, -0.009315491, -0.024353027, -0.007633209, 0.016616821, 0.018569946, 0.0031814575, 0.007785797, -0.029342651, 0.019012451, 0.00762558, 0.03277588, 0.011024475, -0.012268066, 0.030212402, 0.003917694, 0.012771606, 0.02720642, 0.019973755, 0.00843811, 0.019515991, 0.005519867, -0.004207611, 0.02494812, 0.028411865, 0.036895752, -0.03552246, -0.049224854, -0.0071983337, 0.028060913, 0.0033435822, 0.006958008, -0.0033779144, 0.02204895, 0.034088135, -0.02218628, -0.006980896, 0.04763794, -0.03741455, -0.0011711121, -0.02911377, 0.012245178, -0.06188965, -0.00982666, -0.01763916, 0.006668091, -0.018737793, -0.070739746, -0.02633667, 0.03253174, 0.03894043, 0.05316162, 0.0725708, -0.07714844, -0.009674072, -0.061950684, 0.0014686584, -0.010292053, 0.013122559, -0.0016345978, 0.009742737, -0.030807495, 0.0016908646, 0.01537323, -0.032836914, 0.025848389, -0.0050735474, -0.018600464, 0.025726318, -0.025787354, 0.018569946, -0.0031318665, 0.0034065247, 0.023422241, 0.0058403015, -0.0038928986, 0.005168915, 0.0008664131, 0.04071045, 0.007926941, 0.06567383, 0.068725586, 0.028793335, 0.0024719238, -0.011665344, -0.013496399, -0.04043579, 0.016662598, -0.055419922, -0.0035152435, -0.041412354, -0.00919342, -0.07672119, -0.00085783005, 0.022918701, 0.034362793, 0.041503906, 0.007736206, 0.026687622, -0.008224487, 0.040130615, 0.0037651062, 0.0597229, 0.0036716461, 0.015266418, 0.011856079, -0.04043579, 0.03302002, 0.035614014, -0.030685425, 0.027236938, -0.02633667, -0.018630981, -0.004901886, -0.00048971176, 0.03475952, 0.025497437, -0.028244019, -0.0036125183, 0.06781006, 0.023864746, 0.06512451, 0.024093628, 0.0026950836, 0.006160736, -0.014984131, -0.024520874, 0.01939392, -0.04373169, 0.020843506, 0.050964355, -0.06237793, 0.016860962, -0.011070251, -0.023468018, -0.019454956, 0.048736572, 0.0037784576, -0.043395996, -0.012413025, 0.016403198, 0.03062439, 0.03753662, -0.004184723, -0.050750732, -0.017623901, -0.006904602, 0.01675415, -0.009475708, -0.00046944618, 0.02267456, 0.04324341, -0.014770508, 0.01423645, 0.007331848, 0.024429321, -0.013023376, 0.0357666, -0.044952393, 0.05404663, 0.0025558472, -0.040649414, 0.026794434, 0.010574341, -0.06866455, -0.0051345825, 0.03302002, 0.038360596, 0.041412354, 0.06185913, 0.009803772, -0.0053596497, -0.012420654, -0.044830322, 0.062072754, 0.018493652, -0.021469116, 0.006969452, -0.008285522, -0.036468506, 0.041870117, -0.030059814, 0.06890869, -0.02998352, 0.020095825, -0.017745972, -0.016326904, 0.042907715, -0.047790527, -0.0022640228, -0.015602112, -0.024841309, -0.0027713776, 0.015151978, -0.014572144, -0.035491943, -0.0038661957, 0.032836914, 0.0018167496, -0.021881104, -0.017456055, 0.0063591003, -0.095458984, 0.010139465, -0.05053711, 0.035308838, -0.021255493, 0.0058517456, 0.0015125275, 0.005092621, -0.0019521713, -0.041992188, -0.027786255, 0.02204895, -0.010620117, -0.08319092, 0.03451538, 0.025497437, -0.008010864, -0.007686615, -0.030441284, -0.012039185, -0.018554688, -0.055755615, 0.058563232, -0.032043457, -0.05999756, -0.034729004, -0.020324707, 0.046173096, 0.037994385, -0.013702393, -0.021224976, 0.013412476, -0.033203125, -0.02609253, 0.010894775, 0.045410156, -0.007972717, -0.030654907, -0.012046814, 0.039031982, 0.017913818, -0.057037354, -0.05911255, 0.014801025, 0.04537964, -0.0064201355, 0.045135498, 0.020309448, 0.017807007, 0.016525269, 0.016189575, 0.012832642, -0.04953003, -0.028839111, -0.027633667, 0.032043457, 0.03378296, -0.0078125, -0.0022029877, 0.03579712, -0.016143799, -0.016525269, -0.0027198792, 0.018478394, 0.0025901794, 0.010398865, 0.04284668, -0.018981934, -0.020080566, 0.003967285, 0.022369385, -0.018859863, 0.0034637451, 0.004951477, -0.0041770935, -0.014099121, 0.054626465, -0.027328491, -0.044281006, 0.012191772, 0.021972656, -0.003030777, 0.0395813, -0.02154541, -0.022064209, 0.0004043579, -0.0044021606, -0.017608643, 0.0129776, 0.044677734, -0.04953003, -0.011802673, -0.027694702, -0.018951416, 0.011161804, -0.027297974, 0.048980713, -0.019577026, -0.017150879, -0.018325806, -0.021499634, -0.020812988, 0.027038574, -0.018554688, -0.051483154, -0.014312744, -0.002527237, 0.04763794, 0.00026798248 ], "summary": [ 0.056610107, 0.01600647, -0.04220581, -0.028701782, 0.013076782, -0.058502197, 0.0019931793, -0.009254456, 0.041259766, 0.016815186, -0.003326416, -0.02178955, 0.036956787, -0.043640137, -0.0041160583, 0.015792847, -0.024383545, -0.025497437, -0.011871338, -0.042816162, 0.009841919, -0.054504395, 0.05029297, -0.026824951, 0.035308838, -0.05291748, -0.010848999, -0.0009021759, 0.021499634, -0.004714966, 0.019927979, 0.011650085, -0.0019836426, -0.009971619, 0.036468506, -0.010375977, -0.04949951, 0.010238647, 0.01876831, -0.011459351, 0.013168335, 0.007106781, 0.06719971, -0.0012178421, -0.006668091, 0.023910522, -0.010650635, -0.03314209, 0.004535675, 0.0006122589, -0.024765015, 0.013572693, -0.018722534, -0.020248413, -0.01134491, -0.03225708, -0.060699463, 0.029785156, 0.021087646, 0.027786255, 0.008811951, -0.0107803345, 0.002046585, -0.017913818, -0.027130127, -0.003791809, 0.06518555, -0.015930176, 0.010307312, 0.004047394, 0.03729248, 0.021102905, 0.03225708, -0.012870789, -0.038085938, 0.007205963, 0.033935547, 0.031173706, 0.019302368, -0.03640747, -0.05810547, 0.021636963, -0.036865234, -0.007320404, -0.0071525574, 0.014198303, -0.04083252, -0.016204834, 0.007827759, -0.0016269684, -0.007987976, 0.016937256, -0.005947113, 0.034454346, 0.0024356842, -0.024993896, -0.027069092, -0.019744873, -0.0129776, -0.0025634766, -0.0071907043, 0.011688232, -0.02470398, -0.0039634705, -0.011428833, -0.026123047, 0.0047721863, -0.02381897, 0.026184082, 0.02130127, -0.031707764, 0.051605225, 0.04107666, 0.020248413, -0.0027694702, -0.005672455, 0.0040740967, 0.05795288, -0.029693604, 0.048797607, 0.011672974, 0.03100586, 0.012557983, -0.032287598, 0.0010414124, -0.0018167496, -0.018096924, -0.029785156, 0.025863647, -0.008651733, -0.01675415, 0.034454346, -0.04058838, -0.008850098, -0.033599854, 0.012214661, -0.021820068, -0.002374649, 0.020050049, -0.049591064, 0.105773926, 0.016586304, 0.007209778, 0.07727051, -0.026290894, 0.0236969, 0.021606445, 0.009643555, -0.03765869, -0.051239014, 0.024124146, -0.020309448, 0.040771484, -0.02619934, -0.06878662, -0.038269043, -0.07965088, -0.010566711, 0.013023376, -0.011749268, 0.016113281, 0.013633728, 0.015083313, 0.02658081, -0.013168335, -0.0059509277, 0.0014591217, -0.0054740906, 0.016143799, 0.0061073303, 0.0007252693, 0.025390625, -0.049194336, -0.017868042, 0.016174316, -0.02027893, 0.00091838837, 0.04095459, 0.004169464, 0.03186035, 0.03237915, -0.025680542, 0.03878784, 0.017837524, -0.043548584, 0.09893799, -0.018432617, 0.0625, 0.02810669, -0.01272583, -0.030456543, 0.030975342, -0.06317139, -0.010894775, -0.038513184, 0.019134521, 0.024902344, 0.033294678, -0.010009766, -0.0038433075, -0.036376953, 0.023208618, -0.027740479, 0.0055656433, -0.03778076, -0.012680054, -0.0040664673, 0.030471802, 0.011276245, 0.023925781, 0.017807007, 0.0055999756, -0.040405273, 0.0030765533, -0.040649414, -0.046936035, -0.0021858215, -0.0054473877, 0.006965637, -0.019226074, -0.0016870499, 0.025100708, 0.006893158, 0.035217285, 0.05444336, -0.017852783, 0.034210205, -0.014038086, 0.066345215, 0.0524292, -0.05621338, -0.05493164, 0.022583008, -0.010360718, -0.052856445, -0.016525269, -0.004119873, -0.031341553, 0.0020275116, 0.05102539, 0.016860962, 0.028839111, -0.02268982, -0.0009822845, 0.028137207, -0.042541504, -0.0035057068, 0.0041923523, -0.057434082, -0.032440186, 0.0058021545, 0.0138549805, 0.03567505, 0.0071868896, -0.026397705, 0.036193848, 0.025985718, 0.027053833, -0.03564453, 0.017227173, 0.006454468, 0.04547119, -0.023635864, 0.02507019, -0.055389404, -0.036132812, -0.024459839, -0.011505127, 0.0035686493, -0.051635742, 0.039215088, 0.0357666, -0.014205933, -0.08538818, -0.03466797, -0.027694702, -0.03555298, 0.05545044, 0.0073127747, -0.070617676, -0.00843811, -0.00466156, -0.00844574, -0.020339966, 0.023101807, -0.038970947, -0.0038146973, -0.0068473816, 0.00013756752, 0.049438477, 0.061920166, 0.013259888, 0.020339966, -0.02519226, 0.0036907196, -0.0028190613, -0.048919678, 0.053100586, -0.021530151, 0.00605011, 0.0024375916, 0.03704834, -0.01890564, 0.0061302185, 0.008728027, 0.0048065186, 0.00894928, 0.010307312, 0.018493652, 0.012969971, -0.040496826, 0.014953613, 0.01576233, 0.0368042, -0.0256958, -0.031982422, -0.027145386, 0.037597656, -0.01763916, 0.0019102097, 0.06124878, -0.005027771, -0.012901306, -0.009338379, 0.0017728806, -0.014373779, -0.014533997, -0.021865845, -0.019134521, -0.0004172325, -0.022766113, -0.018951416, -0.022720337, 0.023513794, -0.0017538071, 0.005672455, 0.009750366, -0.0395813, 0.000022172928, 0.03894043, 0.038269043, -0.015365601, 0.004272461, -0.035583496, -0.03164673, -0.03186035, 0.028198242, -0.020095825, 0.016998291, 0.008796692, 0.010314941, 0.0143966675, -0.036834717, 0.008239746, 0.003730774, 0.025543213, 0.016586304, 0.012809753, 0.010643005, -0.032440186, 0.03164673, 0.009254456, 0.0132751465, -0.070373535, -0.027297974, -0.008216858, -0.005367279, -0.014801025, 0.0007777214, 0.0029754639, -0.017196655, -0.01499176, 0.024642944, 0.0016489029, 0.0024280548, -0.00050735474, 0.058776855, -0.00030589104, -0.027923584, 0.037109375, 0.0002323389, 0.022613525, -0.01914978, 0.0029296875, 0.047973633, -0.00077295303, -0.025299072, -0.012252808, 0.04449463, 0.027313232, 0.005191803, -0.021743774, -0.013473511, 0.0006766319, 0.001540184, -0.0017690659, -0.023162842, -0.041778564, -0.06347656, -0.021347046, 0.035461426, 0.0039520264, 0.03378296, 0.008171082, -0.046661377, 0.082092285, 0.0050315857, 0.015007019, 0.028244019, -0.020019531, 0.0053100586, 0.009643555, -0.010231018, 0.011253357, -0.019714355, -0.020568848, 0.022476196, -0.014503479, 0.066101074, -0.03225708, -0.031280518, 0.020126343, 0.0030059814, 0.024963379, 0.027023315, 0.07897949, -0.029434204, -0.04260254, 0.019500732, 0.027557373, 0.008224487, 0.011428833, -0.02130127, -0.040771484, -0.020889282, 0.013175964, -0.011169434, 0.036895752, -0.01373291, -0.0013046265, -0.09887695, -0.04067993, -0.03302002, -0.019226074, -0.02432251, -0.0061416626, -0.026000977, -0.0859375, 0.009239197, 0.008201599, -0.009666443, -0.011383057, 0.052947998, 0.024276733, -0.01890564, 0.009895325, -0.016555786, 0.008491516, 0.02848816, -0.0006299019, -0.016845703, -0.0048942566, 0.025146484, -0.016067505, 0.07342529, 0.013916016, -0.021972656, 0.011711121, -0.02607727, 0.04257202, 0.049804688, -0.06311035, -0.030792236, -0.035614014, -0.026504517, -0.055114746, 0.052886963, -0.0012817383, 0.072021484, -0.053833008, 0.011398315, -0.00381279, -0.017288208, -0.008369446, 0.008682251, -0.0135650635, -0.054351807, -0.006351471, 0.013496399, 0.0030994415, 0.02760315, -0.024032593, 0.043792725, -0.009460449, -0.013137817, -0.015274048, -0.010948181, 0.09136963, 0.020935059, -0.023376465, -0.0049858093, -0.010444641, 0.011276245, -0.006225586, -0.03363037, 0.01991272, 0.03149414, 0.018981934, 0.022918701, -0.06530762, 0.04135132, -0.01675415, -0.014320374, 0.019500732, -0.045410156, 0.0056915283, -0.023635864, 0.040740967, -0.056610107, -0.005630493, 0.03479004, 0.10321045, -0.04800415, 0.009719849, 0.0368042, -0.03567505, -0.035980225, 0.010513306, -0.017211914, 0.0036582947, 0.04296875, 0.058044434, 0.0067710876, 0.00020134449, -0.028427124, -0.049591064, -0.016799927, -0.05050659, 0.0011901855, 0.020050049, 0.019042969, 0.027938843, -0.018585205, 0.03262329, -0.007751465, -0.031707764, -0.060150146, -0.026016235, -0.012649536, -0.02230835, -0.006668091, -0.0061149597, -0.045440674, -0.009712219, 0.03793335, -0.095947266, -0.048828125, 0.004047394, 0.0060310364, 0.011726379, 0.025131226, 0.06774902, -0.018997192, -0.055603027, 0.028579712, 0.0090408325, -0.025253296, -0.049438477, -0.0032215118, -0.026153564, -0.036193848, -0.012001038, -0.013397217, -0.062469482, -0.008605957, -0.009887695, 0.002544403, 0.06060791, -0.021438599, -0.013572693, 0.06793213, -0.015670776, -0.055267334, 0.049041748, -0.01776123, 0.03488159, -0.031051636, 0.070129395, -0.034423828, -0.031555176, -0.022766113, 0.0029296875, 0.0018777847, -0.032226562, -0.027679443, -0.022079468, 0.004299164, 0.013648987, 0.03314209, 0.0075569153, 0.024337769, 0.0061035156, 0.01411438, -0.00166893, -0.063964844, -0.015335083, -0.015281677, 0.0423584, -0.0024414062, 0.02923584, 0.0022392273, 0.0034389496, -0.0104522705, 0.001996994, 0.009025574, 0.02331543, -0.00995636, 0.004875183, 0.004550934, 0.013298035, 0.035247803, -0.011726379, 0.04257202, 0.020217896, 0.055236816, 0.025360107, -0.008468628, 0.010231018, -0.007850647, -0.014678955, -0.036224365, -0.014533997, -0.06311035, -0.070251465, -0.038909912, 0.080200195, -0.03375244, -0.023620605, -0.03237915, -0.039916992, 0.018157959, 0.022949219, 0.010063171, -0.032684326, 0.026031494, -0.0024356842, -0.010223389, 0.002729416, 0.014472961, -0.024765015, 0.0385437, -0.0051574707, 0.00856781, -0.051849365, 0.0033512115, -0.0039901733, -0.07476807, 0.010467529, 0.007217407, 0.011360168, -0.035064697, 0.05657959, -0.014709473, 0.06262207, 0.08654785, 0.0063209534, 0.0093688965, 0.016159058, 0.014984131, 0.008918762, -0.027420044, -0.007663727, 0.054138184, -0.009788513, -0.0061073303, 0.051361084, 0.036010742, 0.0018529892, 0.039978027, -0.027328491, 0.0025520325, -0.027511597, 0.008865356, -0.0061531067, -0.021636963, -0.0075645447, 0.014160156, 0.032165527, 0.033966064, 0.021270752, -0.014167786, -0.029129028, 0.020263672, -0.051696777, -0.036987305, -0.011390686, -0.007865906, -0.050201416, 0.021636963, -0.03149414, 0.012763977, -0.01689148, 0.0060577393, -0.026184082, 0.011260986, -0.0063285828, 0.012489319, -0.05001831, 0.05935669, 0.03765869, -0.013153076, -0.037353516, -0.013648987, 0.006263733, -0.022567749, -0.02609253, -0.036743164, -0.016357422, -0.019851685, 0.052215576, -0.010124207, 0.0019836426, 0.029708862, -0.014389038, 0.026885986, 0.02267456, -0.044891357, 0.018569946, 0.0051612854, 0.012268066, 0.024307251, -0.0056114197, -0.035339355, 0.01512146, 0.030914307, -0.03173828, 0.037597656, 0.014587402, 0.02305603, 0.015106201, -0.10852051, 0.037200928, 0.0069084167, 0.004169464, 0.0064926147, 0.0014343262, -0.0030822754, -0.007183075, 0.0069618225, 0.0041542053, 0.046936035, -0.033416748, -0.031158447, -0.028762817, 0.01953125, -0.05557251, -0.049560547, 0.0032520294, -0.0073051453, 0.011779785, -0.07495117, 0.016159058, 0.028198242, 0.06161499, 0.04800415, 0.09741211, -0.07476807, -0.012321472, -0.072265625, 0.004711151, 0.015159607, 0.010025024, -0.028121948, -0.010314941, 0.011650085, 0.015144348, 0.013641357, 0.0016489029, 0.031341553, -0.03540039, -0.058410645, 0.06512451, 0.02218628, 0.03756714, 0.011581421, 0.009941101, 0.01979065, -0.0017490387, -0.012794495, -0.044921875, 0.030944824, 0.04144287, -0.020492554, 0.024902344, 0.035888672, 0.018249512, -0.015213013, -0.015960693, -0.009384155, -0.033233643, 0.020584106, 0.016860962, -0.026641846, 0.01309967, -0.037231445, -0.02545166, 0.009605408, 0.04660034, -0.016052246, 0.055114746, 0.00081014633, 0.035125732, -0.020828247, -0.029083252, -0.052490234, -0.01574707, 0.019714355, -0.015235901, 0.020019531, 0.0013656616, 0.0069389343, 0.04916382, 0.0418396, -0.037719727, -0.013084412, 0.05117798, -0.014892578, -0.049072266, 0.012130737, 0.019546509, 0.027633667, 0.031951904, 0.060546875, 0.05114746, 0.058288574, -0.009773254, -0.009414673, 0.05630493, -0.016494751, -0.00920105, 0.03616333, -0.04156494, 0.035736084, 0.012878418, 0.021316528, -0.010658264, -0.015899658, -0.015640259, 0.021820068, 0.032318115, 0.020904541, -0.040649414, 0.004470825, 0.0077171326, 0.002117157, 0.0076789856, -0.030288696, -0.055236816, -0.03274536, -0.031921387, -0.038208008, -0.0031909943, -0.01940918, 0.018478394, -0.010658264, 0.04269409, 0.003358841, 0.003168106, 0.037261963, -0.013801575, 0.033203125, 0.019165039, 0.037841797, 0.02935791, -0.027572632, 0.04208374, 0.015899658, -0.00040245056, 0.024459839, 0.013366699, 0.038604736, 0.047607422, 0.026824951, -0.043029785, -0.0050811768, 0.06549072, -0.029785156, 0.025375366, -0.023147583, -0.005554199, -0.025756836, -0.024215698, 0.0046958923, -0.008659363, -0.0181427, 0.03213501, 0.0050811768, 0.04727173, 0.011962891, -0.08532715, 0.030319214, -0.008056641, 0.03591919, -0.010055542, -0.049713135, 0.03475952, 0.05758667, 0.0032730103, 0.024841309, -0.010444641, -0.05316162, 0.027038574, -0.040893555, -0.024276733, 0.031982422, -0.012809753, -0.030075073, -0.031707764, 0.019927979, 0.00084733963, -0.031677246, 0.006793976, 0.0013875961, 0.033813477, -0.026977539, -0.035736084, 0.025314331, 0.009895325, -0.107666016, 0.012825012, -0.023483276, -0.031402588, 0.0020923615, 0.011260986, -0.009971619, 0.0012559891, -0.008674622, 0.07531738, -0.0032863617, -0.055603027, -0.0027446747, -0.011955261, 0.03878784, -0.027572632, 0.002111435, -0.005508423, 0.018707275, -0.0015163422, -0.039855957, -0.008407593, -0.013549805, 0.0026283264, -0.013046265, -0.036193848, 0.0051460266, 0.010276794, -0.030151367, -0.06518555, 0.026138306, 0.023483276, -0.018539429, -0.027053833, -0.009399414, 0.0052108765, 0.0769043, 0.023529053, 0.026870728, -0.031433105, -0.02104187, 0.005634308, 0.033325195, 0.014579773, -0.030319214, -0.0006685257, 0.023925781, -0.036071777, -0.017745972, 0.0073623657, 0.040740967, -0.016525269, 0.0051574707, 0.037261963, -0.037200928, -0.03918457, -0.0049057007, -0.035064697, -0.0024356842, -0.036010742, 0.000039219856, 0.0103302, -0.06585693, 0.033050537, -0.05996704, -0.0022830963, -0.008758545, 0.018936157, -0.020446777, -0.009307861, -0.00868988, 0.035827637, 0.013710022, 0.001868248, -0.018035889, 0.008666992, 0.03643799, -0.037841797, -0.022766113, 0.0024375916, 0.007106781, -0.02508545, -0.016784668, 0.025802612, -0.027832031, -0.005672455, 0.008728027, -0.05343628, -0.007881165, 0.0036716461, -0.048797607, -0.06585693, 0.05303955, 0.07763672, 0.006954193, 0.041992188 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1808.03737v2
Learning Multi-touch Conversion Attribution with Dual-attention Mechanisms for Online Advertising
Kan Ren, Yuchen Fang, Weinan Zhang, Shuhao Liu, Jiajun Li, Ya Zhang, Yong Yu, Jun Wang
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
In online advertising, the Internet users may be exposed to a sequence of different ad campaigns, i.e., display ads, search, or referrals from multiple channels, before led up to any final sales conversion and transaction. For both campaigners and publishers, it is fundamentally critical to estimate the contribution from ad campaign touch-points during the customer journey (conversion funnel) and assign the right credit to the right ad exposure accordingly. However, the existing research on the multi-touch attribution problem lacks a principled way of utilizing the users' pre-conversion actions (i.e., clicks), and quite often fails to model the sequential patterns among the touch points from a user's behavior data. To make it worse, the current industry practice is merely employing a set of arbitrary rules as the attribution model, e.g., the popular last-touch model assigns 100% credit to the final touch-point regardless of actual attributions. In this paper, we propose a Dual-attention Recurrent Neural Network (DARNN) for the multi-touch attribution problem. It learns the attribution values through an attention mechanism directly from the conversion estimation objective. To achieve this, we utilize sequence-to-sequence prediction for user clicks, and combine both post-view and post-click attribution patterns together for the final conversion estimation. To quantitatively benchmark attribution models, we also propose a novel yet practical attribution evaluation scheme through the proxy of budget allocation (under the estimated attributions) over ad channels. The experimental results on two real datasets demonstrate the significant performance gains of our attribution model against the state of the art.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.03737v2
2018-08-30T01:31:31
2018-08-11T01:58:19
{ "title": [ 0.037902832, 0.009109497, -0.009017944, -0.0178833, 0.01663208, -0.027832031, 0.021591187, -0.03125, -0.025604248, 0.018875122, -0.021026611, 0.024032593, -0.01146698, -0.017868042, 0.0016365051, -0.012535095, -0.010498047, 0.027038574, -0.030883789, -0.030853271, -0.030776978, -0.03781128, 0.032196045, 0.02947998, 0.012001038, -0.0625, -0.04321289, 0.018417358, -0.0034427643, -0.02027893, 0.0039405823, 0.0056114197, 0.043182373, 0.031143188, -0.023132324, 0.011817932, -0.034820557, 0.029220581, 0.0032253265, 0.027038574, 0.017150879, 0.0033111572, -0.043395996, -0.017211914, -0.029708862, 0.005584717, -0.033843994, -0.023284912, -0.0135269165, -0.010482788, 0.024017334, 0.03265381, 0.017150879, 0.012016296, 0.0044403076, -0.036376953, -0.04550171, -0.015151978, 0.03161621, 0.08642578, 0.028457642, -0.03125, -0.010047913, -0.057373047, -0.027770996, -0.024475098, -0.029556274, 0.009284973, 0.0546875, 0.011451721, -0.008544922, 0.006263733, 0.017745972, -0.0035076141, -0.02973938, -0.011001587, 0.06506348, 0.020645142, 0.0011644363, -0.008140564, 0.039489746, 0.026672363, -0.027374268, -0.010604858, 0.019989014, -0.03112793, 0.0048561096, -0.024887085, -0.018798828, -0.066833496, -0.0058403015, 0.020050049, -0.043395996, -0.0015125275, -0.034454346, -0.05130005, 0.002166748, 0.06628418, -0.012557983, -0.03717041, -0.03390503, 0.033050537, -0.089416504, -0.011444092, 0.0065612793, -0.009803772, -0.015136719, -0.011627197, 0.03970337, 0.021194458, -0.028427124, 0.060516357, 0.030944824, 0.030776978, 0.012519836, -0.041015625, -0.027740479, 0.060150146, -0.010299683, 0.04284668, -0.024429321, -0.032714844, 0.0362854, 0.03677368, 0.038970947, 0.029449463, -0.02067566, 0.0039367676, -0.001619339, 0.027313232, -0.011268616, 0.041412354, -0.068481445, -0.076538086, -0.06463623, 0.024963379, -0.013137817, 0.033416748, 0.0025196075, 0.0034446716, 0.0066108704, -0.045196533, -0.0064086914, 0.009307861, 0.031585693, 0.011291504, 0.041046143, -0.0015678406, -0.029647827, -0.025268555, 0.008972168, -0.0024528503, 0.018600464, -0.012901306, -0.034576416, -0.040740967, -0.09350586, -0.025024414, 0.050994873, -0.016204834, 0.010910034, 0.009666443, 0.006614685, 0.040924072, 0.028182983, -0.012397766, 0.007083893, 0.020355225, 0.020324707, 0.027038574, -0.03253174, -0.0022468567, -0.01701355, -0.02104187, -0.011329651, 0.01939392, 0.021469116, 0.036956787, 0.023391724, -0.05380249, 0.012138367, -0.029022217, 0.076293945, -0.010276794, -0.06750488, 0.026382446, -0.028579712, 0.0022335052, 0.06347656, -0.008651733, -0.02684021, 0.020629883, -0.02456665, -0.033843994, -0.035095215, 0.017333984, 0.0034980774, 0.03768921, -0.005355835, -0.0029907227, -0.031829834, -0.003396988, -0.023330688, 0.009986877, -0.03945923, -0.026351929, -0.020492554, 0.012420654, -0.0657959, 0.010269165, 0.06506348, -0.0069122314, -0.03643799, 0.034942627, 0.004928589, -0.04421997, 0.02911377, -0.021697998, -0.01977539, -0.0491333, -0.03326416, 0.002653122, -0.02999878, 0.077941895, 0.012672424, -0.0019264221, -0.0021362305, -0.02078247, 0.02330017, 0.016403198, 0.021209717, -0.014831543, 0.029678345, 0.0087890625, -0.004272461, -0.011451721, -0.022506714, -0.057006836, 0.030410767, 0.03665161, -0.010032654, -0.008529663, -0.0023841858, 0.07977295, 0.05883789, -0.0126571655, -0.017532349, 0.05130005, 0.018722534, 0.021942139, 0.031097412, -0.0020122528, 0.023773193, -0.046691895, 0.019927979, 0.048950195, -0.009788513, -0.011054993, -0.015449524, 0.012924194, 0.017608643, 0.03579712, 0.007385254, 0.017990112, -0.062072754, -0.028045654, -0.042907715, -0.029541016, 0.010322571, -0.016479492, 0.03778076, -0.012069702, 0.0003669262, -0.025726318, 0.035949707, -0.023361206, -0.017562866, 0.01789856, 0.021697998, -0.04638672, -0.020996094, -0.0095825195, 0.029067993, -0.018417358, 0.028366089, 0.017852783, 0.015617371, -0.04055786, -0.02166748, 0.003643036, 0.04937744, 0.035491943, 0.005329132, -0.021270752, 0.027526855, 0.007850647, 0.049926758, 0.05657959, -0.012367249, 0.026947021, -0.035461426, 0.026428223, -0.021972656, 0.013870239, -0.0022354126, 0.028259277, 0.0013618469, -0.013221741, -0.034698486, 0.017623901, -0.033355713, 0.03515625, -0.0062561035, -0.0031757355, -0.09442139, -0.06097412, -0.060760498, -0.04257202, -0.09710693, -0.019577026, 0.07556152, -0.024002075, 0.019744873, 0.017150879, 0.0008249283, -0.05596924, 0.024612427, -0.023422241, -0.0056648254, 0.053863525, 0.03491211, 0.044830322, -0.059509277, -0.015617371, -0.0090408325, 0.03286743, -0.006198883, -0.07354736, -0.023361206, 0.06713867, 0.018920898, 0.005001068, 0.043182373, -0.07293701, -0.024246216, -0.0055503845, -0.013244629, 0.02696228, -0.04724121, -0.022979736, 0.04550171, -0.054870605, -0.025177002, 0.012420654, 0.039611816, 0.023239136, 0.00059366226, 0.0256958, 0.026992798, -0.007926941, 0.040649414, 0.0012550354, 0.0035533905, -0.0736084, -0.019317627, -0.03302002, -0.018875122, -0.036102295, 0.03567505, 0.042907715, -0.009498596, -0.006290436, -0.030197144, -0.009742737, 0.015258789, -0.017944336, -0.019897461, -0.02520752, -0.0018367767, -0.01890564, -0.0016975403, -0.009819031, -0.0043792725, 0.013290405, 0.061798096, 0.024108887, -0.027542114, -0.026779175, -0.00033807755, 0.0011034012, -0.0138168335, -0.0010385513, -0.015029907, -0.007621765, 0.03164673, -0.011764526, -0.011314392, 0.010696411, -0.08502197, -0.018676758, -0.028396606, 0.012542725, -0.037139893, 0.029663086, -0.05203247, 0.0151901245, -0.011253357, -0.0647583, 0.023208618, 0.058624268, -0.0022850037, -0.0045318604, 0.019515991, 0.008476257, -0.0075416565, -0.009498596, -0.01965332, 0.04537964, -0.035949707, -0.07562256, 0.00049352646, 0.020858765, -0.025650024, -0.032409668, -0.009963989, 0.042938232, 0.01121521, 0.013923645, 0.0023956299, -0.018341064, -0.003250122, -0.022140503, -0.017578125, -0.027435303, -0.010383606, 0.039642334, -0.003189087, 0.06512451, -0.0028190613, 0.0005426407, -0.03466797, 0.0045318604, -0.0009317398, 0.044769287, -0.0077552795, -0.031341553, -0.01234436, -0.031799316, -0.01713562, -0.018341064, -0.010757446, -0.010887146, -0.018310547, 0.011688232, -0.004951477, 0.07354736, -0.021438599, -0.0070381165, 0.014060974, -0.013656616, 0.012588501, 0.00062322617, -0.044006348, 0.0037212372, 0.0068206787, -0.024932861, 0.0619812, -0.018478394, -0.034606934, 0.023757935, -0.040893555, -0.01159668, -0.01512146, -0.016723633, 0.022705078, -0.0124053955, -0.023712158, 0.00920105, 0.0014333725, 0.012916565, 0.037261963, -0.018234253, -0.0018339157, -0.02116394, 0.049316406, -0.012557983, -0.06707764, 0.013587952, 0.041534424, -0.06008911, -0.03970337, -0.06774902, 0.031433105, -0.050720215, -0.0039596558, 0.0079574585, 0.0064315796, -0.023773193, -0.012649536, -0.083496094, -0.02822876, 0.07598877, -0.011451721, 0.022491455, 0.022262573, -0.0075416565, -0.0066871643, -0.02935791, 0.017837524, -0.008804321, 0.03250122, -0.004108429, -0.0211792, 0.012557983, -0.019699097, 0.026535034, 0.033050537, 0.02432251, 0.0009045601, -0.011512756, -0.0060043335, 0.03552246, -0.01751709, 0.06112671, -0.001001358, -0.03414917, -0.017074585, -0.005207062, -0.0007915497, -0.006160736, 0.020339966, 0.008491516, 0.01940918, 0.029891968, -0.0124053955, 0.03604126, -0.026138306, -0.021774292, 0.030944824, -0.0054359436, 0.006427765, 0.022064209, -0.014656067, 0.029922485, 0.009140015, 0.009750366, -0.0035209656, 0.011795044, -0.04348755, -0.031433105, 0.010238647, 0.028839111, -0.044799805, -0.008705139, -0.03253174, -0.038482666, -0.047698975, 0.014724731, -0.014373779, 0.04071045, 0.027877808, -0.0060310364, -0.0013933182, -0.005619049, 0.01727295, 0.011100769, -0.029693604, -0.07757568, 0.011924744, -0.010940552, -0.07952881, -0.019638062, -0.031585693, -0.011505127, 0.049468994, -0.0059661865, 0.008415222, 0.02848816, 0.027877808, 0.0072669983, 0.017654419, -0.014381409, -0.011978149, 0.078308105, -0.02230835, -0.033081055, 0.053710938, 0.007217407, 0.023422241, 0.01713562, 0.050567627, -0.03994751, -0.038330078, -0.08325195, 0.03111267, 0.0052948, 0.012702942, 0.055725098, 0.03753662, 0.03274536, 0.023086548, 0.0032291412, 0.0067253113, -0.037719727, -0.01184845, -0.03677368, 0.02470398, -0.012084961, -0.0010137558, 0.0463562, 0.016189575, -0.004814148, 0.004722595, 0.003376007, 0.025421143, 0.048950195, -0.01965332, 0.01360321, -0.014915466, -0.002073288, 0.03842163, -0.021377563, 0.05508423, -0.013320923, 0.046875, 0.024719238, 0.0062026978, 0.015434265, -0.014533997, 0.026107788, -0.023529053, 0.0013246536, -0.060180664, -0.015899658, 0.024169922, 0.009681702, -0.035003662, 0.023834229, -0.020614624, -0.04244995, 0.035736084, 0.032043457, 0.029785156, 0.010223389, -0.031158447, 0.0126953125, 0.01449585, -0.019577026, -0.033325195, -0.0030612946, -0.009735107, 0.0008459091, -0.07550049, 0.0069999695, -0.004234314, -0.03414917, -0.026062012, -0.03439331, 0.030563354, -0.0579834, -0.010101318, 0.051757812, -0.008842468, 0.041137695, 0.011741638, 0.021270752, 0.044708252, 0.022705078, 0.03225708, -0.0098724365, 0.009468079, 0.012504578, 0.045837402, 0.030181885, 0.038360596, -0.01158905, 0.0022029877, -0.00090265274, -0.0038928986, -0.0345459, 0.042053223, 0.009490967, -0.056610107, 0.02809143, -0.027526855, 0.04324341, 0.01146698, -0.01159668, -0.011390686, -0.016708374, -0.024978638, -0.0038814545, -0.02999878, -0.03564453, 0.026641846, -0.03213501, -0.04776001, -0.05368042, 0.005344391, -0.0062446594, 0.01776123, -0.011047363, 0.022445679, -0.045684814, 0.030578613, 0.033447266, -0.02798462, -0.016708374, 0.012504578, 0.016540527, 0.012321472, 0.012054443, -0.060760498, -0.013313293, -0.04876709, -0.03062439, -0.0044441223, 0.04562378, 0.06317139, 0.019012451, 0.01751709, -0.043182373, 0.03366089, 0.01979065, 0.024108887, 0.03643799, 0.012519836, 0.034820557, 0.003019333, 0.0008354187, 0.0035743713, 0.033203125, -0.03213501, 0.018188477, 0.03186035, -0.012680054, 0.0129470825, 0.007019043, 0.023284912, 0.02255249, 0.021774292, -0.00843811, 0.028778076, -0.0030498505, 0.017654419, 0.014556885, 0.023651123, -0.0045204163, 0.035064697, 0.016525269, 0.072265625, -0.038909912, 0.0011749268, -0.03955078, -0.002105713, -0.04925537, 0.038116455, -0.050842285, -0.0032176971, -0.0395813, -0.070007324, -0.013435364, 0.013710022, 0.040130615, 0.043273926, 0.04498291, -0.06536865, -0.03817749, -0.027786255, 0.0046463013, -0.028945923, 0.026947021, -0.0056533813, 0.0013599396, -0.017852783, -0.0030117035, -0.0026607513, -0.041900635, 0.018447876, 0.021743774, 0.013694763, 0.0028381348, -0.019836426, 0.0016822815, -0.019592285, 0.022567749, 0.044769287, -0.0032787323, -0.00059366226, 0.017044067, -0.0034046173, 0.037902832, 0.006641388, 0.059906006, 0.04397583, 0.007843018, -0.028121948, 0.0057258606, 0.010940552, -0.03878784, 0.050994873, -0.07141113, -0.008682251, -0.07196045, -0.028137207, -0.09564209, -0.023376465, 0.031829834, 0.049957275, 0.019058228, 0.017715454, 0.01737976, -0.007873535, 0.02381897, 0.004722595, 0.058776855, 0.0014133453, 0.014625549, -0.014602661, -0.05368042, 0.03564453, 0.045928955, -0.009742737, 0.00003385544, -0.030197144, -0.03427124, 0.011695862, 0.003440857, 0.017211914, 0.014183044, -0.02029419, -0.012664795, 0.040222168, -0.0022525787, 0.051696777, 0.04623413, -0.0206604, -0.017089844, -0.012565613, -0.015014648, 0.0099487305, -0.024978638, 0.0041007996, 0.017700195, 0.022537231, 0.024642944, -0.033477783, -0.039916992, 0.00945282, 0.03881836, 0.015975952, -0.05718994, -0.024337769, 0.030471802, 0.019088745, 0.022232056, 0.03555298, -0.03186035, -0.045074463, -0.04119873, 0.022750854, 0.0019874573, 0.010437012, -0.01687622, 0.024795532, 0.015777588, 0.012504578, -0.0103302, 0.04119873, -0.03778076, 0.030456543, -0.011993408, 0.059570312, 0.010093689, -0.02645874, -0.0009121895, 0.034362793, -0.068359375, 0.029037476, 0.02947998, 0.08648682, 0.06585693, 0.062347412, -0.004688263, -0.013092041, 0.04449463, -0.05227661, 0.010749817, 0.041625977, -0.014678955, -0.0072898865, 0.0037059784, -0.030715942, 0.04006958, 0.0033340454, 0.07684326, -0.005958557, 0.01777649, -0.04309082, -0.025177002, 0.06414795, -0.09539795, -0.0059814453, -0.05407715, -0.017715454, -0.016342163, -0.0262146, -0.018493652, -0.004837036, -0.009101868, 0.014549255, 0.027297974, 0.021820068, 0.019622803, -0.018081665, -0.05718994, 0.027282715, -0.020462036, 0.07244873, 0.023468018, -0.02760315, -0.012481689, 0.0042152405, 0.016448975, -0.01713562, -0.025924683, -0.008903503, -0.0054016113, -0.030761719, 0.0033721924, -0.0026607513, -0.007259369, 0.033477783, 0.028930664, 0.009162903, -0.004501343, -0.045166016, 0.005004883, -0.02760315, -0.03314209, -0.01979065, -0.029754639, 0.005973816, 0.04486084, -0.023544312, 0.00079870224, 0.020751953, -0.03765869, -0.03894043, -0.01474762, 0.0019378662, -0.025054932, -0.027236938, -0.013198853, 0.033843994, 0.019348145, -0.051483154, -0.030792236, 0.01789856, 0.062683105, 0.00010365248, 0.045074463, 0.013580322, 0.015174866, 0.0046539307, 0.023666382, 0.0019483566, -0.033203125, -0.029815674, -0.0026664734, 0.039398193, 0.04421997, -0.01499939, 0.0025959015, 0.031433105, -0.018707275, -0.02180481, 0.017150879, 0.021438599, -0.018478394, 0.026062012, 0.025726318, -0.032836914, -0.060668945, -0.009170532, 0.013214111, -0.019012451, 0.00440979, 0.007007599, 0.0054893494, -0.027328491, 0.053009033, -0.012458801, -0.04309082, 0.02357483, 0.020828247, 0.011871338, 0.022003174, -0.020263672, -0.015823364, 0.006034851, -0.0014162064, -0.0020923615, 0.021636963, 0.048706055, -0.06512451, -0.010887146, -0.07965088, -0.037261963, 0.009460449, -0.033843994, 0.05267334, -0.037231445, 0.0011978149, -0.011962891, -0.008110046, -0.010093689, 0.010131836, 0.017562866, -0.03363037, -0.036743164, -0.019454956, 0.04699707, -0.0041503906 ], "summary": [ 0.09240723, -0.015274048, 0.031707764, -0.0054473877, 0.0025119781, -0.03665161, 0.022827148, -0.047302246, -0.010795593, -0.004058838, -0.013015747, 0.022628784, -0.012542725, -0.03387451, 0.03677368, -0.02557373, -0.012680054, 0.017074585, 0.0023078918, -0.042663574, -0.018920898, -0.053222656, 0.02923584, 0.030807495, 0.017349243, -0.024902344, 0.002023697, 0.002943039, 0.00957489, 0.017288208, 0.011207581, -0.011894226, 0.020584106, -0.017990112, 0.029846191, -0.02557373, 0.022003174, -0.011039734, 0.008384705, 0.016693115, 0.010536194, 0.014602661, 0.03515625, -0.03704834, -0.0030326843, 0.02659607, -0.006324768, -0.037750244, 0.0395813, 0.014663696, 0.007972717, 0.030319214, -0.004261017, 0.027709961, -0.03982544, -0.05456543, -0.056915283, -0.028305054, -0.002073288, 0.09777832, 0.05279541, 0.0057373047, -0.02671814, -0.042419434, -0.034057617, -0.011566162, -0.019592285, 0.007701874, 0.062927246, 0.0029907227, -0.00061941147, 0.02230835, 0.015853882, -0.0102005005, -0.010665894, 0.014839172, 0.05218506, 0.033233643, -0.028793335, 0.0076446533, 0.007659912, 0.019607544, -0.04626465, -0.005809784, -0.006210327, -0.0035095215, -0.01777649, -0.026367188, 0.00033950806, -0.034454346, -0.0074501038, 0.05871582, -0.052703857, 0.008605957, -0.018188477, -0.044067383, 0.004627228, 0.054229736, -0.04397583, -0.036468506, -0.0079956055, 0.010765076, -0.07354736, -0.018676758, -0.017700195, -0.028076172, -0.00623703, 0.009086609, 0.031082153, 0.03390503, -0.025405884, 0.032928467, 0.022140503, 0.03390503, -0.023788452, -0.027999878, -0.031463623, 0.049316406, -0.016342163, 0.055419922, -0.05166626, -0.03277588, 0.01852417, 0.05050659, 0.01701355, 0.008033752, 0.002620697, 0.033569336, 0.030731201, 0.04071045, -0.03741455, -0.0077590942, 0.003118515, 0.006160736, -0.007926941, -0.027526855, -0.012573242, 0.047180176, 0.015571594, -0.02619934, 0.022323608, -0.010154724, 0.018692017, 0.023483276, 0.031402588, 0.005428314, 0.005794525, 0.012809753, -0.0055007935, -0.008895874, 0.034820557, -0.016326904, 0.026046753, -0.008255005, -0.034088135, -0.056671143, -0.045776367, -0.016998291, 0.042907715, -0.009567261, -0.010139465, 0.0013885498, 0.0028858185, 0.0362854, -0.013885498, 0.0062026978, 0.0579834, 0.008880615, 0.0042152405, 0.036224365, -0.049591064, 0.0048103333, -0.0287323, -0.01965332, -0.0112838745, 0.00023424625, -0.022003174, 0.071777344, 0.025131226, -0.047943115, 0.013641357, -0.032104492, 0.09832764, -0.01272583, -0.036621094, 0.049316406, -0.018447876, 0.033599854, 0.046539307, 0.0012779236, 0.00016462803, 0.017715454, 0.014839172, -0.0035247803, -0.021835327, -0.011703491, -0.0021972656, 0.029251099, -0.016235352, -0.015579224, 0.000667572, -0.014526367, -0.0056610107, -0.015602112, -0.0647583, -0.002943039, -0.016571045, 0.029434204, -0.06555176, -0.0079422, 0.057800293, 0.016159058, -0.041931152, 0.037963867, 0.01776123, -0.019210815, 0.016464233, -0.026687622, -0.020385742, -0.041259766, -0.008224487, 0.0070343018, -0.032287598, 0.0892334, 0.024520874, -0.0039253235, -0.0051231384, -0.0056877136, 0.03756714, 0.014030457, -0.00041294098, -0.006095886, 0.02960205, 0.033447266, -0.00182724, -0.003271103, 0.0029258728, -0.08868408, 0.015151978, 0.037506104, 0.010925293, 0.012924194, -0.022766113, 0.057525635, 0.033996582, -0.03048706, -0.012741089, 0.04272461, 0.010505676, 0.03665161, -0.0025634766, -0.0029392242, 0.012390137, -0.07086182, 0.030670166, 0.039123535, -0.016342163, -0.012687683, 0.004207611, -0.0063591003, 0.017105103, 0.021514893, -0.0020999908, -0.0051193237, -0.014305115, -0.064453125, -0.01914978, -0.03677368, 0.022125244, -0.0541687, 0.026184082, -0.028182983, -0.016586304, -0.04071045, 0.019195557, -0.01651001, -0.02671814, 0.024520874, 0.015289307, -0.022354126, -0.017227173, 0.0009741783, 0.0007739067, -0.017593384, 0.016418457, 0.03274536, 0.0115737915, -0.019226074, 0.008399963, 0.05670166, 0.053222656, 0.046844482, 0.014190674, 0.0019311905, 0.044189453, 0.018051147, 0.002193451, 0.037200928, -0.0020961761, -0.0060424805, -0.016113281, 0.031188965, -0.029464722, 0.015029907, 0.006538391, 0.025024414, -0.0036468506, -0.014930725, -0.015525818, 0.006454468, -0.01701355, 0.025924683, 0.001004219, 0.07098389, -0.09161377, -0.0713501, -0.0390625, -0.017028809, -0.067871094, -0.044433594, 0.0960083, -0.005908966, 0.049987793, 0.008407593, 0.013282776, -0.08605957, 0.03149414, -0.01499939, 0.010650635, 0.01777649, -0.005935669, -0.004047394, -0.060394287, -0.011238098, -0.0068511963, 0.01927185, 0.0025844574, -0.08428955, -0.01977539, 0.052703857, 0.009056091, 0.02130127, 0.033599854, -0.073791504, -0.058288574, 0.028152466, 0.0146484375, 0.0146102905, -0.020202637, -0.002910614, 0.014030457, -0.03466797, -0.04458618, 0.033233643, -0.0052261353, 0.051513672, 0.05819702, 0.017608643, 0.039276123, -0.018615723, 0.030227661, 0.0003838539, 0.0004284382, -0.07098389, -0.0087890625, -0.023254395, -0.009422302, -0.025604248, 0.04663086, 0.036315918, -0.0063438416, 0.036743164, -0.042297363, -0.017623901, -0.012458801, -0.0032520294, 0.03390503, -0.019210815, 0.024520874, 0.03842163, 0.0051994324, 0.007850647, 0.032714844, 0.040496826, 0.046539307, 0.02607727, -0.039245605, -0.03982544, -0.005794525, 0.011375427, -0.019424438, -0.009986877, 0.015289307, -0.012825012, 0.03491211, 0.0051841736, 0.011177063, 0.016952515, -0.02255249, -0.040527344, -0.028198242, 0.017547607, -0.013435364, 0.013450623, -0.00749588, 0.0035896301, 0.01625061, -0.055603027, 0.028060913, -0.0057373047, 0.010643005, -0.0040740967, 0.007106781, -0.0184021, -0.028747559, -0.01864624, 0.078430176, 0.04638672, -0.04498291, -0.09265137, -0.009605408, 0.091308594, -0.012252808, -0.04208374, 0.006122589, 0.03869629, -0.021850586, -0.012840271, -0.023101807, 0.018356323, -0.00009959936, -0.006313324, -0.01776123, -0.01071167, -0.005748749, 0.049102783, -0.026977539, 0.014259338, -0.01701355, -0.025939941, -0.05065918, -0.0155181885, -0.0070877075, 0.040222168, 0.022735596, -0.026885986, -0.030593872, -0.05883789, -0.050964355, -0.046813965, -0.010055542, 0.00064849854, 0.0011796951, 0.041534424, 0.014373779, 0.07159424, -0.016479492, 0.023971558, 0.045196533, -0.021530151, -0.008621216, -0.010414124, -0.0045928955, 0.003408432, 0.019744873, -0.022598267, 0.026306152, 0.005317688, -0.03253174, 0.023483276, 0.007858276, -0.024353027, -0.022872925, -0.02973938, 0.003452301, -0.0317688, 0.02217102, -0.0036010742, 0.050842285, -0.016159058, 0.009231567, -0.00818634, -0.009613037, 0.01953125, 0.033996582, -0.0043563843, 0.0041923523, 0.038238525, 0.03527832, -0.032562256, -0.016174316, -0.042907715, 0.054718018, -0.05255127, 0.020126343, -0.003873825, -0.013290405, 0.033355713, -0.0016870499, -0.06008911, 0.0033512115, -0.00088119507, 0.011413574, 0.013244629, -0.01625061, 0.060028076, 0.02420044, 0.007293701, 0.0025863647, -0.037719727, 0.021942139, -0.041381836, 0.007320404, 0.0025348663, -0.017120361, -0.013946533, 0.04434204, 0.049743652, -0.021713257, -0.023239136, 0.050933838, 0.10510254, -0.02041626, 0.026916504, -0.011260986, -0.055633545, -0.0015192032, -0.029190063, 0.019989014, 0.0077171326, 0.024017334, 0.03277588, -0.0014734268, 0.021865845, -0.013320923, -0.041259766, -0.028884888, -0.021972656, 0.0059013367, 0.023284912, -0.007457733, -0.016815186, -0.009101868, 0.038146973, -0.015945435, 0.0019798279, -0.033843994, 0.009613037, -0.031982422, -0.005886078, 0.0061187744, -0.0072402954, -0.006881714, -0.020492554, 0.0030918121, -0.0023937225, -0.0016870499, -0.013046265, -0.0067710876, 0.042785645, -0.008277893, 0.040252686, 0.013648987, -0.030136108, 0.006828308, 0.03881836, -0.049926758, -0.06173706, -0.015365601, -0.013137817, -0.05038452, -0.0063056946, -0.015403748, -0.066589355, 0.0053710938, -0.011772156, 0.0010938644, 0.024002075, 0.012023926, -0.01576233, -0.021591187, -0.002708435, 0.00002270937, 0.056610107, -0.011642456, -0.010406494, 0.029190063, 0.0035686493, 0.016677856, 0.027435303, 0.028656006, -0.034240723, -0.05239868, -0.06335449, 0.016708374, 0.05331421, 0.0074424744, 0.05697632, 0.037322998, 0.017044067, 0.044830322, 0.009742737, 0.0149383545, -0.005908966, -0.052490234, -0.019363403, -0.008255005, 0.04425049, -0.0030536652, 0.04360962, -0.011016846, -0.05090332, 0.014854431, -0.013916016, 0.020980835, 0.047210693, -0.01586914, 0.010032654, 0.066101074, -0.00018692017, 0.07147217, 0.0073776245, 0.030059814, 0.06677246, 0.014640808, 0.050872803, 0.01184845, 0.0021896362, -0.035858154, 0.010864258, -0.041107178, -0.017913818, -0.025558472, -0.027267456, 0.010108948, 0.0055656433, -0.02079773, -0.016189575, -0.022964478, -0.011657715, 0.017501831, 0.018157959, -0.0047454834, -0.0014371872, -0.018478394, 0.0020713806, 0.006832123, -0.027496338, 0.020401001, -0.040130615, -0.007537842, -0.019088745, -0.044891357, -0.017105103, 0.042663574, -0.028137207, -0.05230713, -0.038360596, 0.04058838, -0.010917664, -0.039398193, 0.06109619, -0.058685303, 0.061645508, 0.04321289, 0.025405884, 0.006801605, -0.0050468445, 0.014656067, -0.019500732, -0.022521973, 0.015220642, 0.040496826, 0.014427185, 0.043914795, -0.0032215118, -0.010826111, 0.026107788, 0.0049552917, -0.013160706, 0.00944519, 0.003452301, -0.006587982, 0.006401062, -0.013725281, 0.05807495, -0.012084961, -0.016662598, -0.008201599, 0.00504303, -0.030883789, -0.011672974, -0.002128601, -0.027572632, -0.0041999817, -0.025726318, -0.032409668, 0.016113281, -0.010696411, 0.008529663, 0.007701874, 0.011291504, 0.042907715, -0.002084732, -0.008659363, 0.023361206, -0.010559082, 0.01777649, -0.008323669, -0.0030441284, -0.003929138, 0.0039253235, -0.019119263, 0.0103302, -0.07775879, -0.021728516, 0.00051116943, 0.035583496, 0.048828125, 0.050567627, 0.013641357, -0.02330017, 0.05831909, -0.0038414001, 0.024841309, -0.013298035, 0.035736084, 0.024673462, 0.0061302185, 0.011260986, 0.0063095093, 0.0501709, -0.06713867, 0.009590149, 0.060638428, -0.028030396, 0.015022278, 0.02571106, 0.03765869, -0.02067566, -0.039398193, 0.0028514862, 0.034851074, 0.016860962, 0.025787354, 0.0284729, 0.0013694763, 0.00869751, 0.044281006, 0.019073486, 0.049041748, -0.009605408, -0.0030574799, -0.018157959, 0.026901245, -0.044677734, -0.028305054, -0.03503418, 0.0073165894, -0.009162903, -0.03086853, 0.002199173, 0.00969696, 0.04067993, 0.03186035, 0.08935547, -0.05343628, -0.07678223, -0.000115156174, -0.012069702, -0.016738892, 0.020828247, -0.004814148, 0.015594482, 0.0030574799, -0.003019333, -0.011299133, -0.02810669, 0.018371582, 0.041809082, 0.026855469, 0.025741577, -0.019638062, -0.01676941, -0.014945984, 0.03604126, 0.03265381, -0.011604309, 0.022521973, 0.0018539429, -0.0060768127, 0.017654419, -0.0023956299, 0.018417358, 0.0085372925, -0.03100586, -0.034057617, 0.00009083748, -0.015731812, -0.04949951, 0.0826416, -0.011405945, -0.016952515, -0.040130615, -0.04949951, -0.048614502, 0.00030970573, 0.027938843, 0.012069702, 0.033355713, 0.024719238, 0.0043144226, 0.0014066696, -0.008331299, 0.008865356, 0.0335083, 0.017684937, 0.035217285, -0.034484863, -0.10168457, 0.0056991577, 0.044128418, -0.009338379, -0.0066375732, -0.0011787415, 0.008132935, 0.03552246, -0.039398193, -0.006477356, -0.0049705505, 0.019607544, -0.014335632, 0.03253174, 0.012435913, 0.062805176, 0.024246216, -0.055023193, 0.033477783, -0.0234375, -0.01600647, 0.0519104, -0.024597168, 0.0519104, 0.015960693, 0.06768799, -0.0028419495, -0.03024292, -0.043029785, 0.00024938583, -0.0005311966, 0.037506104, -0.038757324, -0.020401001, 0.023864746, 0.027435303, -0.000115931034, 0.027297974, -0.016860962, -0.023605347, -0.022155762, -0.0023822784, 0.024810791, 0.016983032, -0.02748108, 0.019302368, 0.060577393, 0.026184082, -0.012962341, 0.0513916, -0.034088135, 0.018432617, 0.015167236, 0.040893555, 0.042907715, -0.023864746, 0.009422302, 0.035369873, -0.025375366, 0.03677368, -0.03451538, 0.08099365, 0.085632324, 0.051818848, -0.018341064, 0.011070251, 0.067871094, -0.030014038, 0.023101807, -0.030166626, 0.0026340485, -0.043701172, 0.019607544, 0.022537231, 0.0049438477, 0.039886475, 0.05593872, 0.008277893, 0.01600647, -0.030227661, -0.04852295, 0.045715332, -0.051574707, 0.013458252, -0.064819336, -0.014160156, 0.001045227, -0.03970337, -0.030380249, -0.006679535, -0.02470398, 0.011505127, 0.014038086, 0.008392334, -0.0036945343, 0.0074691772, 0.0049934387, -0.002817154, -0.005935669, 0.062408447, 0.02017212, -0.030136108, 0.025665283, -0.0070228577, 0.023880005, -0.04949951, -0.0390625, 0.0024776459, 0.03277588, -0.072509766, -0.0036354065, -0.022277832, -0.034210205, 0.03488159, -0.028427124, 0.02456665, -0.01939392, -0.03704834, 0.019607544, 0.014640808, -0.027313232, -0.010238647, -0.032836914, -0.026565552, -0.0009150505, -0.004524231, -0.0066375732, 0.024124146, -0.014305115, -0.08496094, -0.03366089, -0.04248047, -0.033081055, -0.018081665, -0.024673462, 0.021911621, 0.005016327, -0.055114746, -0.0022258759, 0.017745972, 0.06188965, 0.0044937134, 0.0028476715, -0.018081665, 0.021194458, 0.034454346, 0.051116943, 0.013595581, -0.05078125, 0.019638062, -0.010467529, 0.048736572, 0.0015869141, -0.04486084, 0.0107040405, -0.00076532364, -0.035247803, -0.049682617, 0.009300232, 0.03363037, -0.040405273, 0.040222168, 0.013450623, -0.034362793, -0.03994751, -0.00033688545, -0.029693604, -0.0146484375, -0.049346924, 0.01663208, -0.005683899, -0.076660156, 0.025161743, 0.019485474, -0.00048613548, -0.014007568, -0.00016248226, 0.02116394, 0.012802124, -0.006248474, -0.020874023, 0.019729614, -0.0058250427, -0.008636475, -0.0002951622, 0.052246094, -0.08880615, -0.04208374, -0.044067383, -0.027801514, 0.03967285, -0.0146102905, 0.028259277, -0.04498291, 0.006614685, 0.0013418198, -0.02909851, -0.0006108284, 0.009101868, -0.007850647, -0.01777649, 0.011642456, 0.01272583, -0.007698059, 0.022338867 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1906.05253v1
Search on the Replay Buffer: Bridging Planning and Reinforcement Learning
Benjamin Eysenbach, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Sergey Levine
cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
The history of learning for control has been an exciting back and forth between two broad classes of algorithms: planning and reinforcement learning. Planning algorithms effectively reason over long horizons, but assume access to a local policy and distance metric over collision-free paths. Reinforcement learning excels at learning policies and the relative values of states, but fails to plan over long horizons. Despite the successes of each method in various domains, tasks that require reasoning over long horizons with limited feedback and high-dimensional observations remain exceedingly challenging for both planning and reinforcement learning algorithms. Frustratingly, these sorts of tasks are potentially the most useful, as they are simple to design (a human only need to provide an example goal state) and avoid reward shaping, which can bias the agent towards finding a sub-optimal solution. We introduce a general control algorithm that combines the strengths of planning and reinforcement learning to effectively solve these tasks. Our aim is to decompose the task of reaching a distant goal state into a sequence of easier tasks, each of which corresponds to reaching a subgoal. Planning algorithms can automatically find these waypoints, but only if provided with suitable abstractions of the environment -- namely, a graph consisting of nodes and edges. Our main insight is that this graph can be constructed via reinforcement learning, where a goal-conditioned value function provides edge weights, and nodes are taken to be previously seen observations in a replay buffer. Using graph search over our replay buffer, we can automatically generate this sequence of subgoals, even in image-based environments. Our algorithm, search on the replay buffer (SoRB), enables agents to solve sparse reward tasks over one hundred steps, and generalizes substantially better than standard RL algorithms.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1906.05253v1
2019-06-12T17:24:03
2019-06-12T17:24:03
{ "title": [ 0.007637024, -0.0072364807, 0.0028762817, -0.035827637, 0.0056762695, -0.010681152, 0.014251709, -0.022384644, -0.021835327, 0.014297485, -0.04324341, 0.022644043, -0.04928589, -0.0031013489, -0.025299072, -0.034057617, 0.0009126663, -0.0031280518, -0.044921875, -0.045440674, -0.00062704086, -0.055664062, 0.017440796, 0.09613037, 0.026168823, 0.034423828, -0.10406494, 0.032592773, -0.043701172, -0.019363403, -0.023147583, 0.0006599426, 0.045318604, -0.009361267, 0.024429321, 0.02571106, -0.030303955, 0.0017881393, 0.0011901855, 0.008285522, 0.008041382, -0.019088745, -0.04925537, -0.035369873, -0.05505371, 0.019302368, -0.04034424, 0.012130737, -0.019607544, 0.0793457, 0.020996094, 0.025436401, -0.0090789795, 0.07141113, 0.027618408, -0.037078857, -0.013626099, -0.03427124, 0.03756714, 0.06652832, 0.025436401, -0.040893555, 0.01109314, -0.026397705, -0.037353516, -0.030914307, 0.014228821, 0.02293396, 0.081726074, 0.0040893555, -0.01953125, 0.043151855, -0.0011510849, 0.02230835, -0.044525146, -0.012779236, 0.057006836, 0.020828247, 0.019805908, -0.012313843, -0.00095129013, -0.015541077, 0.009727478, -0.031707764, 0.008995056, -0.04611206, -0.012969971, 0.0049476624, -0.020004272, -0.0713501, -0.00039315224, -0.0021419525, -0.005504608, 0.0119018555, -0.040222168, -0.023742676, -0.026016235, 0.012207031, 0.017028809, -0.016662598, -0.022476196, 0.01576233, -0.06750488, -0.0026779175, -0.010238647, 0.019332886, 0.0061531067, -0.022583008, -0.0037136078, 0.03366089, -0.024627686, 0.017944336, 0.01209259, 0.014221191, -0.006259918, -0.0055656433, -0.01335144, 0.010749817, 0.0062217712, 0.011352539, -0.017044067, -0.02909851, -0.00002026558, 0.0014953613, 0.029403687, 0.011802673, -0.035858154, 0.010314941, -0.010917664, 0.041900635, 0.009506226, 0.029968262, -0.12164307, -0.09069824, -0.06695557, 0.028793335, -0.00021541119, 0.01651001, -0.01033783, 0.0053863525, -0.0015945435, -0.008331299, 0.017822266, -0.0019512177, 0.03173828, 0.013900757, 0.050628662, -0.008598328, -0.01914978, -0.013656616, -0.027877808, 0.030929565, -0.0017414093, 0.008605957, -0.0057411194, -0.012550354, -0.109375, -0.0031642914, 0.04815674, 0.021865845, 0.0050735474, 0.009880066, 0.015235901, 0.01247406, 0.043914795, -0.017501831, -0.0062789917, 0.02406311, -0.0014925003, 0.04940796, -0.041778564, -0.004005432, -0.035827637, -0.028121948, -0.017822266, 0.005344391, 0.049713135, -0.00623703, 0.007835388, 0.007701874, 0.024017334, -0.010139465, 0.0012550354, 0.046936035, -0.030029297, -0.030151367, -0.0055351257, -0.02494812, 0.03616333, 0.01134491, -0.044952393, 0.04031372, -0.047943115, -0.04827881, -0.04019165, -0.0029182434, 0.021865845, 0.022064209, 0.003232956, 0.014465332, -0.028793335, -0.0029315948, -0.016220093, 0.0070343018, 0.0010528564, -0.029144287, 0.0031642914, 0.021316528, -0.03427124, 0.055114746, 0.056365967, 0.020141602, -0.04876709, 0.048034668, 0.010620117, -0.062805176, 0.023529053, -0.011398315, 0.0075263977, -0.00096702576, -0.01940918, 0.009216309, -0.007904053, 0.030334473, 0.01676941, -0.007659912, -0.0060157776, -0.015304565, 0.0234375, 0.023025513, 0.024169922, -0.02848816, 0.0073661804, 0.023117065, 0.0043640137, -0.035491943, -0.0154953, -0.03387451, 0.03060913, 0.020385742, -0.012069702, -0.011169434, -0.0073127747, 0.0513916, 0.025543213, -0.0044555664, 0.0070724487, 0.022262573, 0.019226074, 0.032806396, 0.04675293, 0.025436401, 0.04055786, 0.023849487, -0.0034732819, 0.040863037, -0.0010385513, 0.015258789, -0.015304565, 0.013458252, 0.0010890961, 0.032470703, 0.011131287, 0.017837524, -0.045898438, 0.020629883, -0.01878357, 0.019424438, 0.00957489, 0.005970001, 0.031707764, -0.005104065, 0.008392334, -0.004924774, -0.00932312, -0.0076560974, -0.024337769, 0.025787354, 0.025222778, -0.055603027, -0.0011892319, 0.0206604, 0.015670776, 0.0012893677, 0.011947632, -0.001991272, 0.0007238388, -0.013687134, -0.017074585, -0.023590088, 0.048461914, 0.0093688965, -0.009544373, -0.011436462, 0.0039405823, -0.026321411, 0.054595947, 0.08294678, -0.03656006, 0.033294678, -0.060577393, 0.017242432, 0.0137786865, -0.024902344, 0.0020999908, 0.028549194, 0.03173828, 0.017059326, -0.016098022, 0.026412964, -0.048034668, -0.00039577484, 0.008712769, -0.019744873, -0.015533447, -0.029586792, 0.022781372, -0.023391724, -0.021972656, -0.016281128, 0.064331055, -0.021865845, -0.008918762, 0.008666992, -0.011817932, -0.022094727, 0.0078086853, -0.02734375, -0.012016296, 0.041107178, 0.020431519, 0.020858765, -0.04449463, -0.005519867, -0.014099121, 0.016540527, -0.010467529, 0.021957397, -0.014732361, 0.0060691833, 0.015380859, -0.043426514, 0.019546509, -0.031341553, -0.014846802, -0.043640137, -0.02470398, 0.017150879, 0.0052223206, -0.009735107, 0.02357483, -0.008407593, -0.003917694, 0.024291992, 0.06866455, 0.0004146099, -0.02029419, 0.05218506, 0.04043579, -0.014297485, 0.0446167, 0.005290985, -0.003610611, -0.066833496, -0.0026931763, -0.042114258, -0.009475708, -0.04208374, -0.003189087, 0.05206299, -0.06335449, -0.011657715, -0.06060791, 0.0015115738, 0.026168823, 0.041290283, 0.020858765, -0.025817871, -0.026870728, 0.0060577393, -0.025268555, 0.03390503, -0.06384277, 0.03387451, 0.08605957, -0.0029850006, -0.03616333, 0.007534027, 0.01789856, 0.015899658, -0.01852417, -0.025405884, -0.04727173, 0.012207031, 0.017807007, 0.0003349781, -0.0036563873, -0.045135498, -0.12536621, -0.016464233, -0.0064811707, 0.007507324, -0.028076172, 0.022247314, -0.04559326, 0.012992859, -0.012931824, -0.046539307, 0.013069153, 0.04675293, 0.013008118, -0.04373169, 0.027801514, -0.066833496, 0.039367676, -0.04525757, -0.06939697, 0.0413208, -0.05984497, -0.04373169, 0.02078247, -0.027236938, -0.03564453, -0.024749756, 0.027374268, 0.04437256, 0.060791016, -0.008842468, 0.052215576, -0.015655518, 0.036346436, -0.031143188, -0.025939941, -0.0231781, 0.0045776367, 0.017044067, -0.01928711, 0.03717041, -0.014221191, 0.0048713684, -0.04650879, -0.00047659874, 0.00995636, 0.013977051, -0.011528015, -0.030853271, 0.019546509, -0.016067505, -0.043884277, -0.025665283, -0.02116394, 0.001127243, -0.04425049, 0.026275635, -0.0060691833, 0.08642578, 0.014335632, 0.010475159, -0.03564453, -0.021972656, 0.011642456, -0.024261475, -0.059814453, -0.008804321, 0.029510498, 0.0062179565, 0.004398346, -0.028640747, -0.04107666, 0.032073975, -0.030883789, 0.0071754456, 0.014602661, -0.011932373, -0.0064086914, -0.012496948, 0.0039253235, -0.009269714, -0.0013656616, -0.006416321, 0.017669678, -0.0052375793, -0.018341064, -0.017852783, 0.016738892, -0.0017604828, -0.08642578, 0.004020691, 0.0129852295, 0.008987427, -0.0005583763, -0.0357666, 0.01966858, -0.008682251, -0.046020508, 0.016418457, -0.019042969, -0.020553589, 0.014251709, -0.036895752, -0.030227661, 0.07684326, -0.0079574585, -0.019546509, 0.046813965, -0.026123047, -0.036132812, -0.018173218, 0.041259766, 0.026504517, 0.0287323, 0.01965332, 0.034362793, 0.059570312, -0.016204834, 0.027908325, 0.049560547, 0.038848877, 0.0037326813, -0.011100769, 0.013824463, 0.025680542, -0.03677368, 0.050811768, 0.025817871, -0.00756073, -0.07537842, 0.018295288, -0.0022068024, 0.002653122, -0.0026950836, -0.018356323, 0.0064735413, 0.002084732, 0.03656006, 0.040527344, -0.017608643, -0.021209717, 0.04928589, 0.02508545, -0.011329651, -0.0138549805, 0.0004143715, 0.040405273, -0.00554657, 0.00066423416, -0.032226562, 0.019683838, -0.014076233, -0.025634766, 0.0007534027, 0.0079956055, -0.047180176, -0.02357483, -0.04840088, -0.008422852, 0.006668091, 0.00056886673, -0.03552246, 0.015945435, 0.023910522, -0.007396698, -0.028121948, 0.009918213, 0.03491211, 0.008148193, -0.025634766, -0.0703125, -0.0009665489, -0.00554657, -0.0692749, -0.03488159, -0.013641357, -0.023529053, 0.03286743, -0.009666443, -0.05316162, 0.009902954, 0.026306152, 0.11621094, 0.06021118, 0.0022411346, -0.07928467, 0.021484375, -0.041931152, -0.020812988, 0.027557373, -0.015586853, -0.016204834, -0.02658081, 0.039733887, -0.0010004044, -0.014930725, -0.040374756, 0.025543213, -0.009101868, 0.04095459, 0.024047852, 0.059020996, 0.03717041, 0.015045166, 0.005592346, 0.010047913, -0.039886475, 0.017166138, -0.032440186, 0.040740967, -0.0069007874, 0.0023880005, 0.025634766, 0.026412964, 0.023895264, -0.013092041, -0.0059776306, 0.0066337585, -0.016357422, -0.02909851, 0.04458618, -0.008682251, -0.01625061, 0.018829346, -0.00018048286, 0.031097412, -0.042816162, 0.0690918, -0.012084961, -0.011764526, 0.034179688, -0.007663727, 0.0036697388, -0.004398346, -0.0034542084, -0.070129395, -0.07421875, -0.032562256, 0.06121826, -0.0423584, -0.021011353, -0.002714157, 0.0057144165, 0.024902344, 0.06878662, 0.059295654, -0.02748108, -0.013938904, -0.0093688965, -0.011741638, -0.031921387, -0.07208252, -0.011489868, -0.02279663, 0.027816772, -0.06378174, 0.062683105, -0.04272461, -0.004470825, 0.013687134, -0.00819397, -0.00012153387, -0.061523438, 0.028457642, 0.04248047, -0.013015747, 0.015563965, 0.026779175, 0.028900146, 0.016098022, 0.0619812, -0.00434494, 0.040130615, 0.038757324, -0.01739502, 0.017059326, 0.008125305, 0.031585693, -0.0005326271, 0.012794495, 0.0067863464, 0.009284973, -0.04220581, 0.032348633, -0.02243042, -0.015716553, -0.007183075, -0.027893066, -0.0040740967, 0.013450623, 0.026947021, 0.027313232, -0.03793335, -0.03692627, -0.015472412, -0.0047950745, -0.043395996, 0.019454956, 0.005962372, -0.008346558, -0.07489014, 0.012825012, -0.03717041, 0.0042915344, 0.0034885406, 0.0066184998, -0.030395508, 0.007949829, 0.052520752, -0.0053710938, 0.025817871, -0.021820068, -0.000019729137, 0.044830322, 0.018798828, -0.056274414, -0.011062622, 0.012168884, -0.038238525, -0.031066895, 0.035736084, 0.017227173, -0.025939941, 0.001666069, -0.036987305, -0.0063171387, -0.013061523, 0.021560669, -0.01499939, -0.012557983, 0.03778076, -0.00018489361, -0.0059013367, 0.005104065, 0.013931274, -0.022247314, 0.0010471344, 0.0063667297, 0.0026302338, 0.014915466, 0.006587982, 0.01071167, -0.0028133392, -0.055603027, 0.0062675476, 0.026351929, 0.010009766, -0.010307312, 0.011413574, 0.03753662, 0.019638062, -0.034973145, -0.0043411255, 0.04534912, -0.04776001, 0.02041626, 0.009498596, -0.0032463074, -0.0052452087, 0.076293945, -0.008865356, -0.004047394, -0.066223145, -0.06008911, -0.02722168, 0.0010385513, 0.022766113, 0.013916016, 0.014221191, -0.022598267, 0.024169922, -0.021743774, -0.020233154, -0.039611816, 0.004005432, -0.0010051727, -0.03414917, 0.044403076, 0.011123657, 0.03488159, -0.03781128, 0.009666443, -0.0070648193, 0.00983429, -0.022567749, -0.049743652, 0.019332886, -0.008934021, -0.025177002, 0.020980835, 0.0011920929, -0.030517578, 0.021850586, -0.041870117, 0.060272217, 0.0362854, 0.0524292, 0.05947876, 0.0064048767, 0.006298065, 0.020706177, 0.024353027, -0.03665161, 0.05886841, -0.07299805, 0.022094727, -0.05239868, -0.028152466, -0.07373047, -0.021148682, 0.03353882, 0.02885437, 0.023757935, 0.0052223206, -0.000032544136, 0.0019140244, 0.044281006, 0.020904541, 0.053100586, 0.02128601, 0.01222229, -0.0031814575, -0.029342651, 0.023391724, 0.03781128, 0.0073013306, -0.011940002, -0.008766174, -0.03491211, 0.009773254, 0.027359009, 0.019210815, 0.020889282, -0.027511597, -0.017364502, 0.03036499, -0.016296387, 0.016448975, 0.05908203, 0.042419434, -0.0072288513, -0.008728027, 0.018997192, -0.018508911, -0.028762817, 0.01979065, 0.036865234, -0.076538086, 0.03555298, -0.0047035217, -0.017913818, -0.014099121, 0.051086426, 0.015419006, -0.05038452, -0.006916046, 0.021224976, 0.019226074, -0.00995636, 0.012832642, -0.023422241, -0.014335632, 0.03253174, 0.0491333, -0.010391235, 0.0569458, 0.008132935, 0.022079468, -0.03390503, -0.0037899017, -0.009315491, 0.043121338, -0.059265137, 0.016967773, -0.039001465, 0.06945801, 0.024597168, -0.027954102, 0.037109375, 0.012184143, -0.06695557, -0.002943039, 0.0064697266, 0.02911377, 0.037597656, 0.057006836, 0.017745972, -0.027526855, -0.0087509155, -0.056518555, 0.008033752, 0.047698975, -0.03186035, 0.021347046, -0.026473999, -0.037231445, 0.0446167, -0.046661377, 0.028121948, -0.03994751, 0.005264282, -0.0036087036, -0.008277893, 0.07171631, -0.054748535, -0.050048828, -0.01184082, -0.025177002, 0.009460449, 0.038208008, 0.0028820038, -0.006881714, 0.016555786, 0.0184021, 0.03704834, -0.0129470825, 0.0011405945, -0.012367249, -0.07910156, -0.020843506, -0.035705566, 0.014587402, -0.019897461, -0.031951904, -0.025100708, 0.030059814, 0.02432251, -0.003894806, -0.048583984, 0.052490234, -0.0012226105, -0.039642334, 0.03161621, 0.036132812, -0.0030956268, 0.028686523, -0.024932861, 0.016952515, -0.0060424805, -0.037139893, 0.02078247, -0.024658203, -0.043518066, -0.01676941, -0.031555176, 0.0099105835, 0.025924683, -0.0013990402, -0.0052604675, 0.032562256, -0.040985107, -0.034057617, 0.0077285767, 0.03503418, -0.0017728806, -0.038360596, 0.010665894, 0.032440186, 0.033721924, -0.042633057, -0.041259766, 0.0143585205, 0.011734009, -0.021469116, 0.07006836, -0.011642456, 0.009269714, 0.04864502, 0.05810547, 0.020599365, -0.054748535, -0.031799316, -0.012779236, 0.037078857, 0.03286743, -0.007385254, -0.021743774, 0.018615723, -0.03189087, 0.014442444, -0.0024814606, 0.0014886856, 0.009788513, -0.014564514, 0.03488159, -0.004398346, -0.01586914, -0.039031982, 0.04046631, -0.020751953, 0.0033435822, -0.0077438354, 0.017227173, -0.0052223206, 0.04144287, -0.038269043, -0.003578186, 0.03503418, 0.036376953, 0.016098022, 0.02798462, -0.027694702, 0.006526947, 0.0034561157, 0.018692017, -0.005874634, 0.03363037, 0.035827637, -0.012878418, 0.00774765, -0.039794922, -0.052825928, 0.02243042, -0.031982422, 0.03036499, -0.03286743, 0.018920898, 0.00080013275, -0.018112183, -0.016616821, 0.03640747, 0.0039520264, -0.05456543, -0.029190063, -0.02961731, 0.06378174, -0.013420105 ], "summary": [ 0.03479004, -0.028030396, 0.057006836, 0.018295288, -0.048583984, -0.005924225, 0.005680084, -0.058135986, -0.036071777, -0.016357422, -0.04296875, 0.016174316, -0.05038452, -0.011856079, 0.03918457, -0.07928467, 0.013809204, -0.029373169, -0.035064697, -0.04385376, 0.0234375, -0.04611206, -0.034210205, 0.1361084, 0.013053894, 0.04800415, -0.06414795, 0.021087646, 0.0076065063, 0.035614014, 0.0038661957, -0.035705566, 0.019897461, -0.029724121, 0.049621582, 0.026382446, -0.0041122437, -0.0013313293, 0.0256958, 0.0010824203, 0.03552246, -0.027679443, 0.030303955, -0.08135986, 0.00034713745, 0.0423584, 0.007205963, -0.0013570786, 0.007858276, 0.1015625, 0.005973816, 0.0035972595, -0.029373169, 0.08947754, -0.008491516, -0.04827881, -0.0006017685, -0.043792725, 0.01802063, 0.033050537, 0.01626587, -0.011070251, 0.009483337, -0.021087646, 0.007835388, -0.008964539, 0.04473877, 0.0016441345, 0.06756592, 0.020889282, -0.0109939575, 0.031677246, -0.005077362, 0.024780273, -0.01234436, -0.015899658, 0.045684814, 0.016571045, 0.0011453629, 0.019515991, -0.040893555, 0.035827637, -0.009468079, -0.026733398, -0.035461426, -0.042236328, -0.03060913, 0.0076179504, 0.0046577454, -0.055755615, -0.013328552, 0.031829834, -0.039031982, 0.025268555, -0.015945435, -0.04269409, -0.010070801, -0.028656006, 0.03756714, 0.0042495728, 0.0076828003, -0.047973633, -0.005622864, -0.006515503, -0.008575439, 0.017990112, 0.023712158, -0.0038547516, 0.0020809174, 0.016418457, -0.015571594, -0.015945435, 0.049438477, 0.005176544, 0.0027160645, -0.04336548, 0.0005297661, 0.05178833, -0.00030183792, 0.013900757, -0.025100708, -0.0038604736, -0.026855469, 0.06976318, 0.018798828, 0.04586792, 0.020629883, -0.004875183, 0.035095215, 0.012886047, -0.0031108856, 0.01096344, -0.044830322, -0.04638672, -0.048553467, 0.00048971176, 0.052947998, 0.0065612793, 0.0075416565, -0.016174316, 0.022247314, 0.010002136, -0.0013370514, 0.012908936, 0.029205322, 0.030914307, 0.018447876, -0.0077056885, -0.0009264946, -0.003396988, -0.0066833496, 0.0041999817, 0.0151901245, -0.014457703, 0.016784668, -0.08337402, -0.068359375, 0.012428284, 0.06500244, 0.021972656, 0.01247406, 0.012573242, 0.025543213, 0.04611206, 0.023971558, -0.025421143, 0.0078125, -0.004383087, -0.0014295578, 0.031921387, -0.017288208, 0.021469116, -0.0055236816, -0.030548096, -0.018753052, -0.030792236, 0.0070648193, -0.0011520386, -0.04244995, 0.037231445, 0.046875, -0.02406311, -0.06890869, 0.051483154, 0.029220581, -0.055877686, -0.026885986, -0.040252686, 0.042053223, 0.015914917, -0.027999878, 0.012763977, -0.0519104, 0.01838684, -0.030853271, 0.002319336, -0.0076904297, 0.027069092, -0.016494751, 0.00003027916, 0.017745972, 0.010154724, -0.00868988, -0.009132385, -0.011238098, -0.025543213, 0.016738892, 0.019973755, -0.022216797, 0.026992798, 0.017349243, -0.0048103333, -0.026626587, 0.019577026, 0.027008057, -0.026031494, 0.053894043, -0.0027008057, -0.0029659271, -0.049438477, -0.010574341, 0.010749817, -0.028747559, 0.057617188, 0.016189575, -0.022521973, -0.0018444061, -0.00006258488, 0.03050232, 0.018218994, -0.022201538, 0.0043182373, -0.011711121, 0.021621704, -0.010299683, -0.015792847, -0.0018081665, -0.041900635, 0.015609741, 0.02909851, 0.014884949, 0.015106201, -0.027160645, 0.011558533, 0.007820129, -0.03967285, -0.015975952, 0.010925293, -0.023254395, 0.042022705, 0.052490234, 0.030029297, -0.007232666, 0.015235901, -0.001329422, 0.017059326, -0.034942627, -0.036102295, -0.0034332275, -0.010238647, 0.013061523, -0.014953613, 0.0006966591, -0.0047798157, -0.004333496, -0.011009216, 0.03274536, 0.038146973, 0.019989014, -0.0423584, 0.004383087, 0.013648987, -0.014930725, -0.014213562, -0.022872925, 0.014152527, -0.053100586, 0.04852295, 0.014282227, -0.022949219, -0.006095886, 0.040893555, 0.016952515, -0.012458801, -0.026275635, 0.013298035, 0.02609253, 0.002796173, 0.010681152, 0.0395813, 0.06384277, -0.020507812, -0.0418396, 0.02696228, 0.0002822876, -0.030761719, -0.012878418, 0.04043579, -0.018753052, -0.013961792, -0.032714844, 0.020111084, -0.024673462, -0.018356323, 0.01838684, 0.018508911, 0.05645752, -0.0021266937, 0.010505676, 0.0018672943, -0.0059547424, 0.00020623207, 0.03591919, 0.055786133, -0.0026454926, -0.0077552795, 0.013748169, 0.041168213, 0.0138168335, 0.0063667297, 0.07757568, -0.024765015, 0.01361084, 0.0317688, -0.033111572, -0.047973633, 0.07952881, -0.032592773, -0.0020618439, 0.002193451, -0.019104004, 0.000028669834, -0.027435303, 0.044128418, 0.00040626526, 0.004283905, 0.0016012192, 0.030166626, -0.0028247833, -0.021499634, 0.0149002075, -0.006916046, -0.004081726, 0.013023376, -0.016601562, -0.031051636, -0.02305603, -0.004306793, 0.06933594, -0.028152466, 0.0066108704, -0.005405426, -0.011528015, 0.047698975, 0.013191223, 0.015090942, 0.039245605, 0.024917603, -0.0035953522, -0.032958984, 0.04498291, 0.008155823, -0.0026302338, -0.08856201, -0.031311035, -0.025772095, 0.0067825317, -0.03201294, 0.037475586, 0.060058594, -0.0149383545, 0.030700684, -0.07946777, -0.0076293945, 0.010559082, 0.025787354, 0.078552246, -0.02748108, 0.0064048767, 0.046295166, -0.017425537, 0.039276123, -0.06878662, 0.04321289, 0.08685303, 0.0038700104, -0.023117065, 0.02960205, 0.011741638, 0.008079529, -0.02986145, -0.033233643, -0.01727295, -0.009262085, -0.0016708374, 0.00076532364, -0.0121154785, -0.029403687, -0.04727173, -0.02017212, -0.041870117, 0.009468079, -0.01184082, -0.0062332153, 0.0066871643, -0.011833191, -0.010765076, -0.057617188, -0.0018863678, -0.01537323, 0.043548584, -0.083984375, 0.054748535, -0.09259033, 0.040649414, -0.04031372, 0.04296875, 0.032226562, -0.037139893, -0.055023193, 0.012451172, 0.020370483, -0.011650085, -0.037139893, 0.028366089, 0.012191772, 0.041503906, -0.0009274483, 0.03062439, 0.0039634705, 0.042114258, -0.024841309, -0.025100708, -0.0008201599, -0.011100769, 0.026794434, -0.025039673, -0.020935059, 0.011306763, -0.02999878, -0.068603516, -0.0039596558, 0.0121154785, 0.01576233, 0.005039215, -0.0025978088, 0.007217407, -0.06488037, -0.07098389, -0.03817749, -0.0413208, 0.022262573, 0.021347046, 0.047332764, 0.034423828, 0.085876465, 0.003698349, 0.0037174225, 0.0022068024, -0.03741455, -0.014350891, -0.00579834, -0.042510986, -0.046173096, 0.04788208, -0.0012664795, -0.04598999, -0.0109939575, -0.060455322, 0.03878784, -0.00093460083, -0.00027775764, -0.0038795471, -0.0154418945, 0.014221191, -0.06939697, 0.018249512, 0.022567749, -0.0038757324, -0.0423584, -0.0044784546, 0.0022068024, -0.022354126, -0.008361816, -0.008956909, 0.014137268, -0.06359863, -0.018875122, 0.01625061, 0.074279785, 0.06945801, -0.02784729, 0.05206299, -0.0018501282, -0.043914795, 0.024841309, -0.01499939, 0.06304932, 0.049438477, 0.004257202, -0.01939392, 0.011169434, -0.0059890747, -0.05303955, -0.03466797, 0.008354187, 0.040496826, 0.029785156, 0.04284668, 0.0055236816, 0.019104004, -0.005306244, 0.08880615, 0.040161133, 0.008850098, -0.01260376, 0.044708252, 0.041503906, -0.025405884, -0.003921509, 0.03881836, 0.07019043, -0.029037476, 0.008888245, 0.048828125, -0.006072998, -0.04864502, 0.028640747, -0.015960693, -0.007434845, 0.021865845, 0.022018433, -0.029129028, -0.033447266, 0.037963867, -0.030044556, -0.024871826, -0.036956787, 0.04776001, 0.06542969, -0.010070801, -0.023529053, -0.014442444, 0.05154419, -0.025878906, -0.006881714, -0.032836914, 0.021636963, 0.0026664734, -0.01234436, 0.02168274, 0.00087690353, -0.06341553, -0.042907715, -0.017990112, 0.064575195, 0.009017944, -0.007019043, -0.048034668, 0.027786255, -0.030685425, 0.016418457, -0.008049011, 0.021469116, 0.018814087, 0.033813477, -0.02909851, -0.056732178, -0.053466797, -0.008338928, -0.057861328, -0.008682251, -0.07067871, -0.07421875, -0.016204834, -0.0012788773, -0.06304932, 0.008361816, 0.002418518, 0.11151123, 0.062408447, 0.038726807, -0.09020996, 0.008743286, -0.022216797, 0.037017822, 0.0038261414, 0.00548172, -0.013946533, -0.010734558, 0.0033817291, 0.015640259, -0.03692627, -0.011199951, -0.0026111603, -0.019454956, 0.05328369, 0.062805176, 0.07952881, 0.028274536, 0.03466797, -0.010986328, 0.00037288666, -0.024627686, 0.039215088, -0.05557251, 0.046661377, 0.0030498505, -0.003124237, 0.018005371, 0.0015563965, -0.019683838, -0.0004541874, -0.004547119, -0.008430481, 0.004825592, 0.005607605, 0.02935791, 0.030853271, -0.019821167, 0.034729004, -0.014511108, 0.002254486, 0.045776367, 0.039764404, 0.017623901, -0.0118255615, 0.055389404, -0.006046295, -0.03652954, -0.00045275688, -0.04446411, -0.027832031, -0.051361084, -0.027053833, 0.042266846, -0.015213013, -0.041534424, -0.030838013, -0.028396606, 0.037322998, 0.014526367, 0.028305054, -0.06201172, -0.043792725, -0.015136719, -0.029418945, -0.005065918, -0.03189087, -0.026519775, -0.00043725967, 0.002614975, -0.032989502, 0.012763977, 0.029769897, -0.020462036, 0.0039100647, -0.016860962, -0.004840851, -0.034088135, -0.0059776306, 0.0041046143, -0.038024902, 0.0045776367, 0.048583984, -0.028076172, -0.02796936, 0.022201538, -0.052764893, 0.0340271, -0.0046577454, -0.03942871, 0.042510986, 0.018081665, 0.015731812, -0.0259552, 0.036193848, -0.0032310486, -0.0017871857, -0.030426025, 0.010597229, -0.030349731, -0.00031018257, -0.05996704, 0.018463135, 0.014953613, -0.012763977, 0.024291992, 0.011672974, -0.018218994, -0.027267456, -0.025558472, 0.00982666, -0.052581787, 0.008270264, 0.009429932, 0.047058105, -0.052246094, 0.0033016205, -0.107177734, -0.006263733, 0.018447876, 0.0061416626, 0.023269653, -0.0096206665, 0.014045715, 0.004798889, 0.010940552, 0.011856079, 0.011230469, 0.009033203, -0.001832962, -0.021820068, -0.0073394775, -0.023208618, -0.022583008, -0.0259552, -0.0073165894, -0.018966675, 0.032958984, -0.006816864, 0.010551453, 0.0037403107, -0.05291748, 0.025390625, -0.05114746, -0.0048294067, 0.008430481, -0.034210205, -0.047729492, 0.017608643, -0.012001038, -0.073913574, -0.0000022053719, 0.027664185, 0.00756073, 0.023345947, 0.005443573, 0.031982422, -0.01876831, -0.008056641, -0.015098572, 0.044403076, 0.0126953125, 0.009880066, 0.015037537, 0.025238037, 0.03378296, -0.036010742, -0.007007599, 0.014793396, -0.013687134, 0.023483276, -0.014350891, 0.009719849, -0.03866577, 0.05053711, 0.022460938, 0.011940002, -0.040100098, -0.05709839, -0.020004272, -0.051757812, 0.037597656, 0.0036716461, 0.030975342, -0.0010948181, -0.018539429, 0.00818634, -0.039093018, -0.0055122375, -0.020599365, -0.0015287399, -0.020996094, 0.057678223, 0.0035114288, 0.03753662, -0.008766174, -0.016906738, -0.013557434, 0.010505676, -0.0013818741, -0.021957397, 0.0155181885, -0.0090789795, -0.005680084, 0.00843811, 0.01637268, -0.006652832, -0.0034103394, 0.00092315674, 0.024475098, 0.036499023, -0.010299683, 0.005596161, -0.029373169, -0.014678955, 0.01991272, 0.0044059753, -0.024368286, 0.067871094, -0.066223145, -0.021453857, -0.059173584, -0.05886841, -0.022781372, -0.04522705, 0.0064735413, -0.032806396, 0.07537842, -0.004600525, 0.021911621, 0.015808105, -0.022888184, 0.023651123, -0.004196167, 0.032348633, -0.010398865, 0.00022566319, 0.007843018, 0.008087158, 0.039245605, 0.0027694702, 0.018447876, 0.023910522, -0.043304443, 0.02784729, 0.012367249, -0.00027680397, -0.0073623657, 0.011146545, -0.033813477, -0.011375427, -0.00541687, 0.022323608, 0.012069702, 0.017791748, -0.0031661987, 0.02218628, 0.020385742, -0.0016222, -0.024551392, 0.020599365, 0.0012550354, -0.046295166, -0.0023059845, 0.026138306, 0.0032081604, 0.002380371, 0.049438477, 0.020263672, -0.00894165, 0.02482605, 0.008621216, -0.0048179626, -0.017486572, -0.006603241, -0.03567505, -0.011024475, 0.019805908, -0.0062561035, -0.004272461, 0.015853882, 0.022216797, 0.020721436, -0.046875, 0.040618896, -0.0031318665, 0.008117676, -0.034240723, 0.017730713, -0.067871094, 0.07141113, 0.004562378, -0.014251709, 0.041259766, 0.012832642, -0.04876709, 0.022781372, 0.025115967, 0.050201416, 0.018753052, 0.025009155, -0.02204895, -0.0060043335, 0.03314209, 0.0011692047, -0.027435303, 0.04626465, 0.0074386597, -0.0078125, -0.022903442, -0.00705719, -0.023345947, -0.007534027, -0.0011768341, -0.048706055, 0.022842407, 0.009933472, -0.031677246, 0.017486572, 0.0035991669, -0.05392456, -0.008010864, -0.03189087, 0.0362854, 0.026428223, -0.023284912, 0.04272461, -0.00020670891, -0.05050659, 0.035003662, -0.019927979, 0.005592346, -0.009468079, -0.022537231, -0.030853271, 0.00023555756, -0.0046653748, 0.04107666, -0.04324341, -0.029922485, 0.04208374, 0.03201294, -0.0070228577, -0.03427124, 0.05368042, 0.021026611, -0.028442383, 0.033477783, 0.04385376, 0.008773804, 0.07873535, -0.027008057, 0.03918457, 0.0014982224, -0.00605011, 0.026733398, 0.021316528, -0.07269287, -0.021118164, -0.014450073, -0.02142334, -0.021240234, 0.0007138252, 0.007522583, 0.020904541, -0.011955261, -0.017730713, -0.0048599243, 0.007587433, -0.016525269, -0.017547607, -0.012557983, 0.029876709, 0.024642944, -0.018173218, -0.0037021637, 0.025665283, 0.006149292, -0.006324768, 0.018432617, -0.052642822, -0.0037670135, 0.058502197, 0.0713501, 0.024276733, -0.017715454, 0.020004272, 0.029174805, 0.031204224, -0.017730713, -0.02017212, 0.014472961, -0.01689148, -0.05895996, 0.012969971, -0.024124146, -0.0034751892, -0.0102005005, -0.022033691, -0.018157959, -0.030334473, 0.017028809, -0.053375244, 0.011947632, -0.0021476746, -0.012069702, -0.013198853, 0.026046753, -0.015060425, 0.029708862, 0.000022947788, 0.06994629, -0.02545166, 0.011383057, 0.03164673, -0.027389526, -0.020309448, 0.026153564, 0.012268066, 0.027923584, 0.007843018, 0.04373169, 0.019866943, -0.005039215, 0.00011473894, -0.036743164, -0.0034923553, -0.014411926, 0.0047912598, 0.0075531006, 0.00484848, -0.008079529, 0.041900635, -0.044799805, -0.0020446777, 0.011512756, -0.024017334, -0.02305603, 0.0184021, 0.0048179626, 0.007736206, 0.018554688 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1906.11247v2
Beyond DAGs: Modeling Causal Feedback with Fuzzy Cognitive Maps
Osonde Osoba, Bart Kosko
cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Fuzzy cognitive maps (FCMs) model feedback causal relations in interwoven webs of causality and policy variables. FCMs are fuzzy signed directed graphs that allow degrees of causal influence and event occurrence. Such causal models can simulate a wide range of policy scenarios and decision processes. Their directed loops or cycles directly model causal feedback. Their nonlinear dynamics permit forward-chaining inference from input causes and policy options to output effects. Users can add detailed dynamics and feedback links directly to the causal model or infer them with statistical learning laws. Users can fuse or combine FCMs from multiple experts by weighting and adding the underlying fuzzy edge matrices and do so recursively if needed. The combined FCM tends to better represent domain knowledge as the expert sample size increases if the expert sample approximates a random sample. Many causal models use more restrictive directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) and Bayesian probabilities. DAGs do not model causal feedback because they do not contain closed loops. Combining DAGs also tends to produce cycles and thus tends not to produce a new DAG. Combining DAGs tends to produce a FCM. FCM causal influence is also transitive whereas probabilistic causal influence is not transitive in general. Overall: FCMs trade the numerical precision of probabilistic DAGs for pattern prediction, faster and scalable computation, ease of combination, and richer feedback representation. We show how FCMs can apply to problems of public support for insurgency and terrorism and to US-China conflict relations in Graham Allison's Thucydides-trap framework. The appendix gives the textual justification of the Thucydides-trap FCM. It also extends our earlier theorem [Osoba-Kosko2017] to a more general result that shows the transitive and total causal influence that upstream concept nodes exert on downstream nodes.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1906.11247v2
2019-07-02T04:18:14
2019-06-26T16:27:01
{ "title": [ -0.008483887, 0.010246277, 0.015281677, -0.030380249, -0.014015198, 0.01625061, -0.03842163, -0.06604004, -0.0003838539, 0.027160645, -0.0054740906, -0.0065231323, -0.0041236877, -0.024414062, -0.04385376, -0.005970001, 0.000890255, 0.021102905, 0.012252808, -0.03326416, -0.015151978, -0.0362854, 0.060699463, 0.023773193, 0.02558899, -0.029830933, -0.093688965, 0.024246216, -0.012756348, -0.018569946, -0.017974854, 0.003616333, 0.051361084, 0.008529663, -0.0234375, -0.045288086, -0.05984497, 0.0131073, -0.024139404, 0.0003466606, 0.0025138855, 0.0030117035, 0.0050582886, -0.043182373, -0.040130615, 0.036865234, -0.060455322, -0.0070343018, -0.040374756, 0.038757324, 0.01373291, 0.014221191, 0.002872467, 0.030548096, 0.0062065125, -0.040222168, -0.05206299, -0.032348633, 0.0385437, 0.06921387, 0.036956787, -0.06262207, 0.0012645721, -0.03930664, -0.02381897, -0.015426636, 0.0025959015, 0.04156494, 0.088134766, -0.0007376671, -0.05871582, 0.04751587, -0.018707275, 0.025817871, -0.053527832, -0.0009975433, 0.06137085, 0.0017461777, 0.008811951, 0.010620117, -0.032226562, 0.01109314, -0.011291504, -0.0068244934, -0.040527344, -0.042144775, -0.03237915, -0.0013799667, -0.04083252, -0.039886475, -0.019592285, 0.0021095276, -0.023025513, -0.008964539, -0.010894775, -0.03829956, -0.012245178, 0.01889038, 0.0050697327, -0.022598267, -0.025161743, 0.011016846, -0.072265625, -0.0012569427, 0.005012512, 0.027893066, -0.02357483, -0.010307312, 0.035064697, 0.040740967, 0.01008606, 0.017578125, 0.014038086, 0.017578125, 0.020095825, -0.004753113, -0.023986816, 0.031921387, -0.01423645, 0.028717041, -0.029846191, -0.04156494, 0.023483276, 0.024963379, 0.024627686, 0.010627747, -0.022583008, 0.015197754, -0.016738892, 0.030944824, -0.017410278, 0.00756073, -0.019836426, -0.0015649796, -0.013145447, 0.009429932, -0.01777649, -0.0043182373, -0.01600647, 0.0058021545, -0.007850647, -0.0079193115, 0.043060303, -0.041625977, 0.05105591, -0.0054626465, 0.042633057, 0.018096924, -0.019302368, -0.024139404, 0.0236969, 0.025299072, 0.025283813, -0.015045166, -0.04135132, -0.009262085, -0.140625, 0.0041923523, 0.015022278, 0.029434204, 0.014457703, 0.006374359, 0.0058021545, 0.0012483597, 0.019348145, 0.00035643578, -0.04220581, 0.020599365, 0.01663208, 0.050964355, -0.005783081, 0.013793945, -0.0062828064, -0.015312195, -0.0074272156, -0.010032654, 0.043640137, 0.00008434057, 0.017730713, 0.011360168, 0.044311523, 0.006801605, 0.027664185, 0.035583496, -0.046539307, -0.042877197, -0.0018968582, -0.00084877014, 0.041534424, 0.004837036, -0.023635864, 0.0038318634, -0.03665161, -0.067871094, -0.0637207, -0.01864624, 0.05441284, 0.019134521, 0.0045661926, 0.040100098, 0.030181885, 0.038208008, -0.047180176, -0.03289795, -0.08148193, -0.023101807, -0.01890564, 0.037628174, 0.009101868, 0.034454346, 0.036376953, -0.00030350685, -0.039154053, 0.025756836, -0.03186035, -0.08453369, 0.03866577, -0.06518555, -0.008720398, -0.042663574, -0.015853882, 0.045898438, -0.05239868, 0.051605225, 0.018615723, -0.0041770935, 0.0023117065, -0.040649414, 0.068603516, -0.004425049, 0.07989502, -0.020523071, 0.0069770813, -0.01687622, 0.011161804, 0.014572144, -0.0020217896, -0.0513916, -0.005218506, 0.01612854, -0.00831604, -0.05178833, -0.016708374, 0.06585693, 0.021865845, -0.009666443, -0.0064735413, 0.054016113, -0.012123108, -0.021972656, 0.07269287, 0.022720337, 0.053955078, 0.047088623, -0.02470398, 0.04827881, -0.030715942, -0.07385254, -0.0030879974, 0.028930664, 0.03173828, -0.046966553, -0.06060791, -0.002029419, -0.02330017, -0.03439331, -0.0013618469, 0.015037537, 0.018310547, -0.03491211, 0.021957397, -0.0065574646, -0.00041246414, -0.044555664, -0.018615723, -0.022140503, -0.013412476, 0.05178833, -0.030685425, -0.08526611, -0.014305115, 0.015579224, 0.079956055, -0.0052719116, 0.001581192, 0.03555298, 0.04043579, -0.04071045, 0.035003662, 0.029190063, 0.046051025, 0.05218506, 0.0056381226, 0.038360596, 0.028320312, 0.0034980774, -0.0077285767, 0.022872925, -0.0027542114, 0.030075073, -0.056884766, 0.047027588, 0.062561035, -0.022857666, -0.017486572, 0.038757324, -0.024490356, 0.018234253, -0.03643799, 0.0007867813, -0.03842163, 0.030639648, 0.013954163, -0.048614502, -0.018630981, -0.025421143, -0.0030651093, -0.016189575, -0.0056648254, 0.018585205, 0.05987549, 0.030410767, -0.037200928, 0.021697998, 0.01928711, -0.02180481, -0.0065994263, -0.033996582, 0.0046539307, 0.0135269165, 0.07128906, 0.032440186, -0.046295166, -0.00605011, 0.009475708, 0.0020332336, -0.015731812, 0.000046908855, -0.027938843, 0.010314941, -0.014015198, -0.02571106, 0.029846191, -0.022613525, -0.020614624, -0.031555176, 0.028808594, 0.013069153, 0.020965576, 0.02331543, -0.007095337, -0.013999939, -0.059326172, 0.024169922, 0.057678223, -0.053222656, 0.024291992, 0.086242676, 0.03161621, 0.01473999, 0.03463745, 0.00333786, -0.0118255615, -0.06329346, 0.0234375, -0.039489746, -0.01991272, -0.049743652, 0.014976501, 0.036315918, -0.047088623, 0.0010147095, -0.055725098, 0.0025749207, 0.027648926, 0.0073242188, 0.032836914, -0.010231018, -0.037902832, 0.011680603, 0.009811401, 0.031066895, -0.06781006, 0.017562866, 0.095458984, -0.014030457, -0.03744507, 0.0028152466, 0.04534912, 0.0395813, -0.0104599, -0.05505371, -0.037078857, -0.021087646, 0.010192871, 0.024734497, -0.013755798, 0.0031223297, -0.05218506, -0.014862061, -0.0013532639, 0.008377075, -0.009239197, -0.001964569, -0.05380249, -0.015960693, -0.052093506, -0.022567749, 0.03390503, 0.011756897, 0.007205963, 0.029693604, 0.006713867, -0.010543823, 0.0010223389, -0.04156494, -0.024108887, 0.026550293, -0.040618896, -0.033203125, 0.021728516, -0.028701782, -0.031921387, -0.02407837, 0.0005302429, 0.026031494, 0.05633545, 0.025161743, 0.033325195, -0.021820068, 0.0127334595, -0.036468506, -0.012031555, -0.005859375, -0.008995056, -0.015579224, -0.024276733, -0.037719727, 0.009513855, -0.01902771, -0.053527832, -0.033477783, -0.017211914, -0.014671326, 0.006198883, -0.038909912, -0.003282547, -0.020645142, -0.051513672, -0.03427124, -0.03479004, 0.017150879, -0.048339844, 0.022918701, 0.0059280396, 0.056732178, 0.035369873, 0.019058228, -0.0143966675, -0.031829834, 0.024719238, -0.0006980896, -0.09320068, 0.0110321045, 0.028778076, -0.016204834, 0.06964111, -0.034698486, -0.012527466, 0.0071372986, -0.05142212, -0.008087158, 0.042297363, 0.02029419, -0.029922485, 0.013946533, 0.006023407, -0.0015802383, -0.007797241, -0.003604889, -0.0003039837, 0.0059890747, 0.0063552856, -0.052886963, 0.01737976, -0.007827759, -0.068847656, 0.001335144, 0.023254395, -0.00484848, -0.059539795, -0.035247803, 0.0051078796, 0.017547607, -0.016235352, 0.032440186, -0.018051147, 0.04724121, 0.013946533, -0.06970215, 0.026657104, 0.06793213, -0.022415161, 0.020614624, 0.018157959, -0.0016508102, 0.013320923, -0.047576904, -0.00932312, -0.03265381, 0.06262207, -0.03756714, 0.0052833557, 0.040008545, -0.00894928, 0.029388428, 0.056884766, 0.05722046, 0.006046295, -0.022125244, 0.0072631836, 0.020492554, 0.0003399849, 0.04336548, -0.010231018, -0.02017212, -0.019607544, 0.0042152405, -0.02420044, -0.015014648, 0.0025119781, 0.0063591003, 0.0024642944, 0.0055999756, 0.03286743, 0.033294678, 0.0076789856, -0.0132369995, 0.027008057, 0.00003415346, 0.009361267, 0.031555176, -0.0020370483, 0.019042969, 0.014511108, 0.022369385, -0.0037574768, 0.050201416, -0.038330078, -0.009033203, 0.0024528503, 0.023147583, -0.044403076, 0.00018429756, -0.04397583, -0.07244873, -0.026763916, 0.01638794, -0.022842407, 0.019607544, 0.0140686035, -0.004135132, -0.01789856, 0.0025119781, 0.022781372, 0.0012607574, 0.005580902, -0.022613525, 0.02949524, -0.024276733, -0.06628418, -0.058746338, -0.06921387, -0.007434845, 0.009475708, 0.035461426, -0.036590576, -0.0017776489, 0.00969696, 0.072265625, 0.04434204, 0.02848816, -0.04144287, 0.034698486, 0.01876831, 0.0056915283, -0.01222229, 0.026901245, 0.01637268, 0.0038490295, -0.012466431, -0.018600464, -0.022506714, -0.055236816, 0.0151901245, -0.02027893, 0.028442383, 0.027862549, 0.03237915, 0.024093628, 0.003408432, 0.011207581, 0.01423645, -0.027282715, -0.032196045, 0.022338867, 0.01360321, 0.022994995, 0.014030457, 0.02041626, 0.01361084, -0.0002734661, 0.024795532, 0.00415802, 0.034484863, -0.040405273, -0.0045204163, 0.043151855, 0.0060691833, -0.02796936, 0.014190674, 0.01914978, 0.016098022, -0.040527344, 0.030380249, -0.020812988, 0.0076522827, 0.018463135, -0.013450623, 0.02748108, 0.011474609, 0.019134521, -0.05645752, -0.056640625, -0.024795532, 0.033599854, -0.041992188, -0.017822266, 0.031402588, 0.06829834, 0.020263672, 0.03793335, 0.030517578, -0.012374878, 0.020751953, -0.012191772, -0.008979797, 0.00434494, -0.049865723, 0.012680054, 0.0440979, 0.0256958, -0.070007324, 0.0038051605, -0.047302246, 0.002462387, -0.013374329, -0.048309326, 0.01235199, -0.066223145, 0.018173218, 0.058013916, -0.015304565, 0.059387207, -0.018310547, 0.009117126, 0.011100769, 0.032409668, 0.0039596558, 0.0070648193, 0.018753052, -0.028900146, -0.0023326874, -0.01876831, 0.024963379, 0.0066070557, 0.0082473755, 0.012527466, 0.026123047, -0.052337646, 0.016311646, 0.019195557, -0.017364502, -0.022125244, -0.0357666, 0.030593872, 0.019622803, 0.001496315, 0.04345703, 0.014877319, -0.02027893, -0.022506714, 0.016815186, -0.04800415, 0.025848389, 0.029327393, -0.016586304, -0.055541992, 0.002023697, -0.025497437, 0.043518066, -0.015701294, -0.002943039, -0.02519226, -0.019622803, 0.054016113, -0.012672424, 0.05807495, -0.0491333, -0.016921997, 0.04232788, 0.03729248, 0.0034122467, -0.0016880035, -0.0044288635, -0.027862549, -0.0057640076, 0.006969452, -0.003698349, 0.011741638, -0.0059318542, 0.0010709763, 0.01675415, 0.012611389, 0.04888916, 0.012924194, -0.033569336, 0.028900146, 0.0056915283, -0.0017929077, 0.029464722, 0.044677734, -0.005630493, 0.023208618, 0.007461548, -0.039123535, 0.009101868, 0.0096588135, -0.0124435425, 0.038238525, -0.019989014, -0.008514404, 0.017654419, -0.005680084, -0.025604248, -0.021118164, 0.018325806, 0.0024032593, -0.035827637, -0.034210205, 0.045440674, -0.043182373, -0.009963989, 0.011772156, 0.0013370514, -0.016403198, 0.072143555, 0.0042037964, -0.0077285767, -0.039978027, -0.056549072, -0.04232788, 0.0034065247, 0.068725586, 0.007965088, 0.059692383, -0.029846191, 0.0049972534, -0.046051025, 0.019699097, -0.020095825, -0.00036883354, -0.0035247803, 0.0065078735, -0.007171631, 0.026412964, 0.0024719238, -0.029327393, 0.016693115, 0.02885437, 0.028564453, -0.022888184, -0.053222656, -0.017028809, 0.027053833, -0.03652954, 0.030212402, -0.037628174, 0.019989014, 0.03741455, -0.0044937134, 0.03387451, -0.007144928, 0.066467285, 0.03640747, 0.058776855, 0.010520935, 0.0021629333, 0.060302734, -0.024749756, 0.010215759, -0.047180176, 0.001584053, -0.05130005, -0.00008773804, -0.06427002, 0.027053833, 0.0068130493, -0.001578331, 0.008079529, -0.012336731, -0.011459351, 0.03353882, 0.02861023, 0.03994751, 0.03189087, 0.024353027, 0.009864807, 0.021118164, 0.017684937, -0.01537323, 0.029815674, 0.030776978, -0.005970001, -0.03186035, -0.04397583, 0.02293396, 0.04626465, -0.0031337738, 0.020080566, 0.008132935, -0.029693604, 0.034332275, 0.013076782, 0.026641846, 0.043029785, 0.038757324, -0.006298065, -0.004962921, 0.0052719116, -0.00856781, -0.02468872, -0.0005249977, 0.02911377, -0.048858643, 0.02532959, -0.014839172, -0.033416748, 0.013343811, 0.022766113, 0.03652954, -0.07659912, -0.03942871, 0.016677856, 0.01940918, -0.0025730133, -0.003742218, -0.033966064, 0.01259613, 0.023361206, 0.012741089, 0.045135498, 0.05606079, 0.009483337, 0.03982544, 0.006713867, 0.039245605, -0.009811401, 0.045532227, -0.056915283, 0.011505127, -0.038269043, 0.0146484375, -0.013534546, -0.040527344, 0.022216797, -0.005706787, -0.022583008, -0.0063934326, 0.017990112, 0.051818848, 0.021530151, 0.05142212, -0.00005787611, -0.017303467, -0.0048332214, -0.04458618, 0.05328369, 0.027740479, -0.015838623, 0.01876831, -0.03970337, -0.035369873, 0.023788452, -0.039276123, 0.04812622, -0.066467285, 0.0064849854, -0.029754639, 0.014099121, 0.016998291, -0.05697632, -0.040161133, -0.02432251, -0.023544312, -0.005092621, -0.030395508, -0.053894043, -0.0067596436, -0.013389587, 0.020950317, 0.02067566, 0.010856628, -0.0016155243, -0.032318115, -0.043121338, 0.030838013, 0.0011901855, 0.06100464, 0.008934021, -0.022918701, -0.027511597, 0.010795593, 0.030029297, -0.017044067, -0.026306152, -0.015350342, -0.042053223, -0.008163452, 0.010505676, 0.016448975, -0.012077332, 0.024780273, -0.013183594, 0.02822876, -0.013282776, 0.022628784, -0.016098022, -0.059783936, 0.0121536255, 0.025772095, -0.045532227, 0.025512695, 0.013458252, 0.009262085, 0.02609253, 0.011489868, -0.020553589, -0.020263672, -0.0034313202, 0.028411865, 0.004470825, -0.02571106, -0.0055122375, 0.019500732, 0.023895264, -0.04537964, -0.07476807, 0.01612854, 0.009803772, -0.008132935, 0.05267334, 0.005126953, 0.013015747, 0.04611206, 0.03086853, 0.0058135986, -0.0496521, -0.029312134, -0.009498596, 0.048675537, 0.02230835, 0.0016727448, -0.05291748, -0.0049209595, -0.00052928925, 0.006668091, 0.03125, -0.0063972473, 0.020462036, 0.010826111, 0.05783081, -0.019546509, -0.012039185, -0.011192322, 0.020904541, 0.0066947937, 0.029327393, -0.012611389, 0.010345459, -0.011489868, 0.054504395, -0.03338623, 0.014175415, 0.025039673, 0.024993896, 0.030166626, 0.030044556, 0.0077400208, 0.032348633, 0.02519226, 0.0011281967, -0.027816772, -0.0045433044, 0.03225708, -0.015464783, -0.02128601, -0.018371582, 0.0018005371, 0.038635254, -0.020141602, 0.054870605, -0.035125732, -0.008491516, -0.036895752, -0.049072266, 0.0062217712, 0.020019531, 0.015777588, -0.034301758, -0.014183044, 0.009796143, 0.04083252, 0.00027513504 ], "summary": [ 0.023910522, -0.0074043274, 0.036315918, -0.019607544, -0.033843994, 0.017944336, -0.02406311, -0.043914795, -0.0062446594, -0.006996155, -0.014312744, -0.0074920654, -0.026611328, -0.0357666, -0.0154953, -0.033416748, 0.011665344, 0.0009918213, 0.0317688, -0.014183044, 0.011474609, 0.0010976791, 0.022827148, -0.0074920654, 0.008850098, -0.03338623, 0.0029506683, -0.006427765, 0.018981934, -0.014213562, 0.0017166138, 0.0076522827, 0.045715332, 0.031677246, -0.076293945, -0.018997192, 0.012138367, -0.01423645, -0.056030273, 0.039276123, 0.0059127808, 0.002614975, 0.037078857, -0.05041504, -0.015380859, 0.031051636, -0.025985718, -0.00018262863, 0.0032100677, 0.036834717, 0.0070495605, 0.007160187, -0.00094890594, 0.07696533, -0.032348633, -0.040618896, -0.07543945, -0.012939453, 0.014701843, 0.08459473, 0.0647583, -0.022537231, -0.02218628, -0.03656006, -0.0062675476, 0.0005660057, 0.033294678, 0.019622803, 0.057769775, 0.0012407303, -0.04034424, 0.02709961, -0.013839722, -0.007827759, -0.045562744, -0.0021266937, 0.028686523, -0.023635864, 0.014282227, 0.008285522, -0.038482666, 0.008239746, -0.06555176, -0.0057029724, -0.0073509216, -0.00050640106, -0.030670166, -0.02319336, -0.028518677, -0.013015747, -0.026260376, -0.017791748, -0.02923584, 0.020050049, -0.023071289, 0.0042381287, 0.017044067, 0.023788452, 0.00091314316, -0.03527832, -0.006713867, -0.00063562393, -0.09851074, 0.014968872, -0.008811951, 0.041168213, 0.005908966, 0.0044403076, 0.010658264, 0.01651001, -0.006664276, -0.007926941, 0.051452637, 0.051879883, -0.018981934, -0.048431396, -0.018829346, 0.061798096, -0.027832031, 0.06335449, -0.008598328, -0.0033016205, -0.026138306, 0.053009033, -0.009246826, 0.0072669983, 0.017868042, 0.006767273, -0.02949524, 0.057556152, -0.0262146, -0.006538391, 0.039642334, 0.034606934, 0.016525269, -0.034362793, -0.015365601, -0.006591797, -0.011726379, 0.022537231, 0.008049011, -0.02381897, 0.033447266, 0.008460999, 0.03652954, 0.035461426, 0.025909424, -0.010101318, -0.0033988953, -0.051513672, 0.035339355, -0.022094727, 0.014663696, -0.005065918, -0.0076065063, -0.024429321, -0.03149414, -0.020141602, -0.0017175674, -0.014083862, 0.05847168, 0.005657196, -0.005214691, 0.030944824, 0.016189575, -0.021057129, -0.02999878, 0.007972717, 0.012413025, 0.025009155, -0.0024986267, -0.023269653, -0.02999878, -0.004234314, -0.009361267, -0.00032544136, 0.00868988, -0.011871338, 0.0050239563, 0.03137207, -0.0007109642, -0.037261963, 0.005706787, 0.011138916, 0.007106781, -0.016601562, 0.0054244995, 0.035491943, 0.015838623, 0.010559082, -0.009765625, -0.019180298, -0.011207581, -0.038757324, -0.021881104, -0.015045166, 0.03616333, 0.0015621185, 0.006664276, 0.022964478, 0.04510498, 0.0035057068, -0.037139893, -0.04537964, -0.09661865, -0.029174805, -0.006340027, 0.023895264, 0.030151367, 0.028564453, -0.0075798035, -0.025817871, -0.009681702, 0.019454956, -0.03994751, -0.051818848, 0.040222168, -0.078430176, -0.0065612793, -0.07696533, 0.0021972656, 0.05923462, -0.026733398, 0.10620117, 0.036376953, -0.017044067, -0.0018157959, -0.014160156, 0.10040283, -0.017181396, 0.09301758, -0.0054473877, -0.027786255, -0.03866577, -0.0078125, 0.01939392, -0.012710571, -0.091308594, 0.007408142, 0.042175293, 0.010215759, -0.037506104, -0.03427124, 0.00907135, -0.000059068203, -0.015960693, 0.015014648, 0.009841919, -0.022003174, -0.021774292, 0.0030727386, 0.016921997, 0.037139893, 0.06549072, 0.0035877228, 0.017929077, -0.03540039, -0.04953003, -0.000105559826, -0.0015354156, 0.031341553, -0.011039734, -0.04473877, 0.00030636787, -0.038146973, -0.069885254, -0.005748749, -0.008308411, 0.08666992, -0.09649658, -0.012161255, -0.046966553, -0.029541016, -0.053375244, -0.030380249, -0.054504395, -0.018814087, 0.06137085, -0.05041504, -0.07305908, -0.0077590942, -0.004764557, 0.051330566, -0.0062675476, 0.023101807, 0.04067993, 0.03744507, -0.009025574, 0.033966064, 0.031707764, 0.023635864, 0.052886963, -0.0024108887, 0.04598999, 0.0018157959, 0.005630493, -0.064697266, 0.0076141357, 0.01108551, -0.023834229, -0.0335083, 0.037017822, 0.016281128, -0.041259766, 0.0034389496, 0.0041770935, 0.013664246, -0.018234253, -0.018432617, -0.03793335, 0.0023536682, 0.02558899, 0.03086853, 0.026489258, -0.01272583, -0.009613037, -0.017608643, 0.038513184, 0.028823853, 0.059143066, 0.09729004, 0.048736572, 0.014266968, 0.024734497, 0.030776978, -0.0657959, 0.023010254, -0.021514893, -0.0062675476, -0.014694214, 0.006587982, -0.031433105, -0.029724121, 0.01586914, 0.00944519, 0.0043640137, 0.0027103424, -0.018432617, -0.03314209, -0.02420044, -0.011741638, -0.02848816, 0.022781372, -0.028427124, -0.016647339, -0.004360199, 0.008918762, -0.0034122467, 0.074279785, 0.015823364, -0.034118652, 0.008110046, -0.016967773, 0.044830322, 0.031921387, -0.029891968, 0.008995056, 0.0803833, 0.0317688, -0.00010049343, 0.021102905, 0.037628174, -0.026290894, -0.062408447, 0.02973938, -0.048614502, 0.0024223328, -0.06945801, 0.08538818, 0.042510986, -0.04724121, 0.072143555, -0.08666992, 0.014778137, 0.072387695, 0.0003657341, 0.058898926, -0.012969971, 0.02368164, 0.06286621, 0.01676941, 0.03741455, -0.033325195, 0.04055786, 0.05328369, -0.009643555, -0.04626465, -0.008110046, 0.031799316, 0.037078857, -0.0015201569, -0.034301758, -0.06585693, -0.053863525, -0.0019245148, 0.03378296, 0.016662598, 0.012390137, 0.04525757, -0.05731201, 0.014450073, 0.021957397, -0.0070877075, -0.0015592575, -0.017501831, -0.008590698, 0.00009000301, -0.024551392, 0.01309967, -0.030471802, 0.024398804, -0.0032043457, -0.004878998, -0.004436493, -0.011817932, -0.04373169, 0.06109619, 0.007911682, -0.046417236, -0.0435791, 0.045440674, -0.025619507, -0.013618469, -0.024276733, 0.031082153, 0.012138367, 0.020706177, -0.0073623657, 0.022888184, 0.0014638901, 0.023651123, -0.032226562, -0.030838013, 0.0012292862, 0.036193848, 0.031082153, -0.0109939575, -0.057678223, 0.0039634705, -0.021621704, -0.08453369, -0.0446167, -0.009231567, -0.055023193, -0.0034809113, -0.038909912, -0.01222229, -0.03793335, -0.02835083, -0.03817749, -0.007209778, 0.02053833, -0.008796692, 0.018798828, 0.008590698, 0.049072266, -0.0010223389, 0.0090789795, 0.006439209, 0.011421204, 0.026824951, 0.028640747, -0.081726074, -0.027297974, 0.0715332, -0.06549072, 0.06311035, -0.01940918, 0.007972717, 0.026611328, 0.01638794, -0.026031494, 0.030303955, -0.015655518, -0.026657104, -0.0058403015, 0.05899048, -0.011260986, -0.00630188, -0.052490234, -0.0104904175, 0.004962921, 0.023468018, -0.007698059, 0.009757996, 0.0015420914, -0.05633545, -0.04046631, 0.006198883, 0.03326416, -0.042907715, 0.015205383, 0.013626099, 0.020446777, 0.006214142, 0.031982422, -0.022216797, 0.08618164, -0.02619934, -0.059631348, 0.03753662, -0.008796692, -0.04776001, 0.033966064, 0.0026550293, 0.03414917, 0.037506104, -0.02243042, -0.028289795, -0.038360596, 0.01763916, -0.062194824, 0.04272461, 0.03149414, -0.0146102905, 0.0395813, 0.030014038, 0.07519531, -0.0047073364, -0.03994751, 0.02017212, 0.032287598, 0.020019531, 0.00623703, -0.019638062, -0.009963989, 0.026397705, 0.00819397, -0.0023880005, 0.002319336, -0.022415161, -0.0007748604, 0.009933472, 0.018356323, 0.01939392, -0.011474609, 0.001543045, -0.04107666, 0.020050049, 0.042236328, 0.02154541, 0.027252197, -0.004146576, 0.04498291, -0.015640259, 0.022598267, -0.034362793, 0.017196655, -0.04095459, -0.0026474, 0.0021095276, 0.0069465637, -0.046325684, -0.018798828, 0.0026016235, -0.06390381, -0.013252258, 0.0012588501, -0.014083862, 0.013282776, -0.008964539, 0.02279663, 0.014602661, -0.033294678, 0.06896973, 0.008003235, 0.009971619, -0.01576233, 0.017028809, -0.022125244, -0.061828613, -0.041870117, -0.1303711, -0.06365967, -0.028320312, 0.04800415, -0.013549805, 0.022140503, -0.010658264, 0.019104004, 0.029312134, 0.016235352, -0.025283813, 0.010467529, 0.032287598, -0.004875183, -0.016815186, 0.019302368, 0.007160187, -0.031311035, -0.037872314, -0.019256592, -0.036315918, -0.091796875, 0.022079468, 0.00026917458, 0.028884888, 0.04598999, 0.024642944, 0.03152466, -0.011695862, 0.006793976, 0.005126953, 0.014579773, -0.00072574615, 0.0491333, -0.03829956, 0.05206299, 0.008834839, 0.01210022, -0.014381409, -0.013336182, 0.012519836, 0.015113831, 0.023223877, -0.014762878, 0.03086853, 0.009941101, 0.005771637, -0.008911133, 0.008392334, 0.01600647, -0.0005540848, -0.037017822, -0.019714355, -0.043945312, -0.0010004044, 0.014457703, 0.0015487671, 0.020767212, 0.056121826, 0.014762878, 0.0048713684, -0.041748047, 0.0017976761, 0.011177063, 0.0124435425, -0.023788452, -0.022125244, 0.03363037, 0.04763794, 0.009414673, 0.0039978027, -0.06414795, 0.026687622, -0.014480591, -0.009155273, 0.04220581, 0.0003581047, 0.0031414032, 0.070495605, 0.009086609, -0.023071289, -0.040893555, -0.014045715, -0.011657715, -0.01625061, 0.003238678, -0.00894165, -0.018188477, 0.0054626465, 0.045806885, -0.017990112, 0.030273438, 0.049835205, 0.012527466, 0.011924744, 0.034851074, 0.009742737, -0.0034484863, 0.0035305023, -0.057617188, -0.00027155876, -0.0016832352, 0.037506104, -0.0024700165, -0.010551453, 0.021774292, 0.0018234253, -0.029403687, -0.0076904297, -0.03543091, 0.003665924, -0.013374329, -0.011169434, 0.04928589, 0.028518677, -0.0052833557, 0.020065308, 0.060455322, -0.029846191, -0.006084442, 0.051849365, 0.036193848, -0.024627686, 0.038726807, 0.035217285, -0.009887695, -0.036987305, -0.06793213, 0.043273926, 0.016983032, 0.0036201477, 0.026855469, -0.028289795, 0.028717041, -0.0178833, 0.06964111, -0.02571106, -0.0022411346, 0.028808594, 0.006641388, 0.01889038, -0.0022277832, 0.0047073364, -0.013938904, 0.017333984, -0.011138916, -0.029205322, 0.022613525, 0.0039978027, 0.019989014, 0.03387451, -0.0115356445, 0.025100708, 0.0015640259, -0.027175903, 0.037963867, -0.008140564, 0.002714157, 0.018478394, 0.031433105, -0.015701294, -0.0069770813, 0.022918701, -0.074401855, 0.00011575222, 0.022918701, -0.023544312, 0.009170532, -0.009506226, -0.015701294, 0.016677856, -0.005065918, -0.014190674, -0.050598145, 0.008522034, -0.053833008, -0.020767212, -0.017425537, 0.05206299, -0.05758667, 0.0049819946, 0.011177063, 0.047821045, -0.008041382, -0.0054893494, 0.017547607, 0.017440796, -0.018188477, -0.045715332, -0.020492554, -0.012893677, 0.036468506, -0.0034484863, 0.04727173, 0.010940552, 0.017684937, -0.009300232, 0.0059890747, 0.0075798035, -0.0021972656, -0.008491516, -0.017456055, 0.013549805, 0.05819702, -0.008911133, -0.008583069, -0.0034446716, 0.016342163, 0.016067505, 0.0030021667, -0.014450073, -0.00016093254, -0.0039520264, 0.005054474, 0.0063209534, -0.013633728, 0.050354004, 0.022415161, 0.018295288, -0.011238098, 0.004005432, 0.033050537, 0.0043144226, 0.047058105, 0.053466797, -0.000027298927, 0.051513672, 0.0016584396, 0.00466156, 0.013397217, -0.06323242, -0.041290283, -0.05215454, -0.006149292, 0.02659607, -0.01928711, -0.039794922, 0.045013428, -0.009994507, 0.00522995, 0.06378174, -0.012550354, 0.024551392, -0.017990112, -0.006286621, -0.011436462, 0.025497437, -0.036834717, 0.018295288, 0.05227661, 0.012168884, -0.019638062, 0.02822876, -0.03994751, 0.031143188, 0.013664246, -0.00051116943, -0.029830933, 0.005783081, -0.026977539, 0.032836914, 0.030136108, 0.034851074, 0.0018186569, -0.00033664703, 0.021408081, -0.017456055, 0.0012292862, 0.0087509155, -0.016571045, -0.0017662048, -0.01676941, 0.048614502, -0.0027275085, -0.00894928, -0.026535034, 0.07446289, 0.019363403, 0.05532837, -0.062927246, -0.040100098, 0.02192688, 0.00044298172, -0.019119263, 0.023345947, -0.022338867, 0.023666382, -0.011001587, -0.04598999, 0.054351807, 0.022750854, 0.018844604, 0.04586792, 0.017868042, 0.039215088, -0.007259369, -0.0154800415, -0.022842407, 0.019897461, -0.031143188, 0.020141602, 0.027572632, -0.0022583008, 0.020217896, 0.018753052, 0.0418396, 0.030914307, 0.03439331, 0.016113281, 0.037078857, 0.04067993, -0.03439331, 0.016967773, 0.03945923, -0.014328003, 0.03866577, 0.024551392, 0.0028018951, 0.013076782, -0.02909851, -0.005970001, 0.019424438, 0.008277893, 0.027328491, -0.052703857, 0.016784668, -0.022918701, 0.011947632, -0.03677368, -0.00522995, -0.007789612, -0.01864624, 0.009277344, -0.014930725, -0.027160645, -0.039611816, -0.011375427, -0.013145447, 0.04473877, 0.032196045, 0.019927979, 0.0046691895, -0.03744507, 0.020950317, 0.011070251, 0.0473938, 0.060638428, 0.0574646, -0.030960083, 0.0234375, -0.018630981, 0.004928589, -0.016464233, -0.004272461, -0.047546387, -0.022277832, -0.01663208, -0.005847931, 0.0016851425, -0.036621094, -0.00730896, 0.0018787384, 0.020050049, -0.018249512, 0.003967285, -0.02293396, -0.011741638, 0.046142578, 0.019699097, -0.03515625, -0.014511108, 0.007534027, 0.0022602081, 0.061279297, 0.00944519, 0.0026302338, -0.008728027, 0.0050811768, 0.005771637, -0.008857727, 0.002878189, 0.00018370152, 0.0034275055, 0.03805542, -0.026443481, -0.036010742, -0.020858765, -0.036224365, -0.004398346, -0.024093628, 0.021438599, 0.012336731, 0.015327454, 0.008148193, -0.0053901672, -0.030014038, 0.00084877014, 0.0069999695, 0.0009317398, 0.0052833557, 0.015731812, -0.03765869, -0.00017273426, -0.012161255, -0.0062217712, 0.06793213, -0.04421997, 0.013313293, 0.018478394, 0.028640747, -0.020629883, -0.019729614, 0.07714844, -0.00995636, -0.0088272095, 0.00982666, -0.032714844, -0.026184082, -0.013801575, -0.010551453, -0.0028533936, 0.041229248, -0.018325806, 0.002254486, 0.027694702, -0.022155762, -0.020187378, 0.031158447, 0.026794434, 0.018157959, -0.012268066, 0.04019165, 0.00080633163, 0.0026378632, -0.0256958, 0.023925781, 0.014434814, -0.006538391, -0.011306763, 0.06213379, -0.019119263, -0.036865234, -0.020202637, -0.045776367, 0.02217102, 0.007331848, -0.008384705, 0.0024738312, 0.025436401, 0.053253174, -0.011817932, 0.02658081 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1906.11994v3
Cascade-BGNN: Toward Efficient Self-supervised Representation Learning on Large-scale Bipartite Graphs
Chaoyang He, Tian Xie, Yu Rong, Wenbing Huang, Junzhou Huang, Xiang Ren, Cyrus Shahabi
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Bipartite graphs have been used to represent data relationships in many data-mining applications such as in E-commerce recommendation systems. Since learning in graph space is more complicated than in Euclidian space, recent studies have extensively utilized neural nets to effectively and efficiently embed a graph's nodes into a multidimensional space. However, this embedding method has not yet been applied to large-scale bipartite graphs. Existing techniques either cannot be scaled to large-scale bipartite graphs that have limited labels or cannot exploit the unique structure of bipartite graphs, which have distinct node features in two domains. Thus, we propose Cascade Bipartite Graph Neural Networks, Cascade-BGNN, a novel node representation learning for bipartite graphs that is domain-consistent, self-supervised, and efficient. To efficiently aggregate information both across and within the two partitions of a bipartite graph, BGNN utilizes a customized Inter-domain Message Passing (IDMP) and Intra-domain Alignment (IDA), which is our adaptation of adversarial learning, for message aggregation across and within partitions, respectively. BGNN is trained in a self-supervised manner. Moreover, we formulate a multi-layer BGNN in a cascaded training manner to enable multi-hop relationship modeling while improving training efficiency. Extensive experiments on several datasets of varying scales verify the effectiveness and efficiency of BGNN over baselines. Our design is further affirmed through theoretical analysis for domain alignment. The scalability of BGNN is additionally verified through its demonstrated rapid training speed and low memory cost over a large-scale real-world bipartite graph.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1906.11994v3
2020-10-27T06:35:53
2019-06-27T23:34:45
{ "title": [ -0.011619568, 0.016067505, -0.04840088, -0.070251465, 0.016296387, 0.0017261505, -0.05041504, -0.0004963875, 0.006916046, 0.01701355, -0.015686035, 0.0070114136, -0.014587402, -0.026870728, -0.015960693, 0.0043029785, 0.0026054382, 0.03829956, 0.0013980865, -0.020645142, -0.024627686, -0.017242432, 0.046966553, 0.031921387, 0.038757324, -0.053894043, -0.036224365, 0.014968872, -0.013877869, -0.023712158, 0.006916046, -0.009384155, 0.056915283, 0.018127441, -0.01285553, 0.0043945312, -0.04711914, 0.005455017, -0.003850937, 0.015464783, 0.015357971, -0.00548172, 0.009063721, -0.05090332, -0.022506714, 0.049957275, -0.06121826, -0.014526367, -0.021621704, 0.05886841, 0.027572632, 0.017913818, -0.008888245, 0.020050049, 0.029052734, -0.037078857, -0.04425049, -0.0038700104, 0.046020508, 0.044708252, 0.017044067, -0.061950684, 0.018447876, -0.0137786865, -0.05618286, -0.019134521, -0.011726379, 0.013580322, 0.08581543, -0.011238098, -0.039886475, 0.031982422, 0.018936157, -0.00409317, -0.09039307, -0.0069770813, 0.0657959, 0.016998291, 0.03265381, -0.056640625, -0.01108551, -0.026016235, -0.035827637, -0.018615723, 0.018692017, -0.0137786865, -0.017120361, -0.01461792, -0.009292603, -0.057373047, 0.006828308, -0.025314331, -0.024612427, 0.035125732, -0.012001038, -0.026901245, -0.00548172, 0.05819702, -0.012390137, -0.01979065, -0.012336731, 0.013069153, -0.034484863, -0.030090332, 0.009567261, -0.006877899, -0.043151855, -0.042877197, 0.00907135, 0.04034424, -0.035583496, 0.010192871, 0.030227661, 0.025543213, 0.003665924, -0.008140564, 0.0077056885, 0.03010559, 0.0048179626, 0.03314209, 0.010848999, -0.009811401, -0.024627686, -0.0034275055, 0.056549072, 0.013664246, -0.044952393, 0.024810791, 0.0026721954, 0.020706177, 0.014221191, 0.04336548, -0.1048584, -0.06451416, -0.056610107, 0.046691895, 0.007987976, -0.0040893555, -0.014404297, 0.0021800995, 0.004611969, -0.024871826, -0.020065308, -0.0034255981, 0.013031006, 0.021469116, 0.057373047, -0.004837036, -0.052581787, -0.03778076, -0.015159607, 0.023498535, 0.03869629, -0.016738892, -0.026473999, -0.02468872, -0.11730957, -0.010810852, 0.02017212, 0.021957397, 0.029144287, 0.003145218, 0.0077552795, 0.040802002, 0.047790527, -0.0085372925, -0.020095825, 0.013648987, -0.0020751953, -0.021560669, -0.007633209, 0.0138168335, 0.014213562, -0.023376465, -0.0039978027, 0.0061416626, 0.031433105, -0.026565552, 0.027877808, 0.029693604, 0.020477295, -0.01890564, -0.021713257, 0.05316162, -0.06958008, 0.00073719025, -0.018371582, -0.012252808, 0.070129395, 0.007183075, -0.047729492, 0.026657104, -0.037994385, -0.033294678, -0.050872803, -0.031066895, 0.025299072, 0.02355957, -0.006275177, 0.029968262, -0.016723633, 0.009117126, -0.03186035, 0.009239197, 0.018569946, -0.033050537, -0.0017061234, 0.012290955, -0.026306152, 0.039855957, 0.06335449, -0.00409317, -0.029785156, -0.0056381226, -0.005592346, -0.07458496, 0.035461426, -0.014602661, -0.0042915344, -0.009147644, 0.0140686035, -0.016204834, 0.005039215, 0.0748291, 0.0062294006, -0.02520752, 0.012420654, -0.035003662, 0.00818634, 0.017486572, 0.02355957, -0.023529053, 0.018875122, 0.0011405945, -0.007572174, -0.020324707, 0.009025574, -0.019546509, 0.01411438, 0.021881104, -0.010826111, -0.019592285, -0.018341064, 0.03942871, 0.047729492, 0.025817871, 0.010482788, 0.007080078, -0.0031166077, 0.007095337, 0.040161133, 0.05142212, 0.044158936, -0.013183594, 0.023468018, 0.06329346, 0.016418457, 0.028182983, -0.041748047, 0.018066406, -0.008888245, 0.06384277, 0.020401001, 0.024002075, -0.04522705, -0.0010910034, -0.015930176, 0.004688263, 0.02999878, 0.0041236877, 0.015548706, -0.029464722, 0.020111084, -0.0010614395, 0.0039024353, -0.046813965, -0.0035057068, 0.011634827, -0.0044898987, -0.068847656, -0.0181427, -0.019622803, 0.008460999, 0.008178711, 0.041534424, -0.046539307, 0.014427185, -0.0032348633, -0.039367676, -0.023651123, 0.040924072, 0.026428223, -0.0056152344, -0.02645874, -0.0211792, 0.013885498, 0.07421875, 0.063964844, -0.01272583, 0.02168274, -0.04534912, 0.017837524, 0.002149582, -0.029541016, 0.0015068054, 0.052764893, 0.042388916, 0.011360168, -0.02168274, 0.023757935, -0.0473938, -0.0062789917, 0.0082092285, -0.013404846, -0.06286621, -0.07989502, -0.01889038, -0.045532227, -0.05380249, -0.029937744, 0.08886719, 0.00078344345, -0.053985596, 0.016235352, -0.003004074, -0.01979065, 0.016830444, -0.038848877, -0.033050537, 0.03164673, 0.022033691, 0.033935547, -0.063964844, 0.0093688965, -0.008758545, 0.01272583, -0.009208679, -0.0033512115, -0.013809204, 0.04360962, 0.046844482, -0.0017061234, 0.031463623, -0.036468506, 0.0067596436, -0.03942871, -0.012489319, 0.039978027, -0.02381897, -0.01713562, 0.0077400208, -0.024368286, -0.028869629, 0.008300781, 0.056518555, 0.004951477, -0.0236969, 0.023330688, 0.05609131, -0.018005371, -0.006504059, 0.015975952, -0.011459351, -0.07299805, -0.025527954, -0.042755127, -0.022735596, 0.006576538, 0.00806427, 0.05783081, -0.030532837, -0.008865356, -0.048706055, -0.021377563, 0.0026950836, -0.0037498474, -0.026275635, -0.042266846, -0.023635864, -0.022659302, -0.03643799, -0.014533997, -0.034118652, -0.0062942505, 0.08062744, 0.006614685, -0.007801056, 0.020431519, 0.02067566, -0.000002026558, -0.02734375, -0.0056114197, 0.011894226, 0.009941101, 0.008743286, -0.0001591444, -0.0070114136, -0.00094652176, -0.09387207, -0.006793976, 0.052124023, -0.0048446655, -0.01638794, 0.018829346, -0.07519531, 0.0018873215, -0.012565613, -0.0259552, 0.03933716, 0.06878662, -0.005050659, -0.0011901855, 0.009651184, -0.013374329, 0.0025463104, -0.008674622, -0.05102539, 0.031433105, -0.01826477, -0.0848999, -0.02218628, 0.024993896, -0.041534424, -0.020401001, 0.004261017, 0.010154724, 0.017288208, 0.005672455, 0.006450653, 0.0181427, 0.00047922134, -0.024902344, 0.00756073, -0.020614624, -0.04598999, -0.014808655, -0.01335907, 0.039764404, 0.015594482, -0.026123047, -0.025344849, -0.022613525, 0.008995056, 0.076049805, 0.011199951, -0.028930664, -0.034576416, -0.019317627, -0.011398315, 0.016174316, -0.016357422, -0.0032100677, -0.033325195, 0.007549286, -0.03225708, 0.003856659, 0.007865906, 0.0038604736, -0.032806396, -0.008056641, 0.023468018, -0.0070343018, -0.06317139, -0.0028381348, 0.031433105, 0.018432617, -0.012298584, -0.014961243, -0.025131226, 0.027374268, -0.024642944, -0.010971069, 0.0038928986, 0.0056266785, -0.02053833, -0.004962921, 0.0060768127, 0.025939941, -0.034942627, -0.033813477, 0.019439697, -0.004310608, -0.01751709, -0.061676025, 0.013687134, -0.0027198792, -0.12225342, -0.038848877, 0.006500244, -0.009002686, -0.024154663, -0.058563232, 0.004863739, -0.01940918, -0.044952393, 0.033172607, -0.01889038, 0.001200676, -0.012771606, -0.07537842, -0.0036621094, 0.046142578, -0.020874023, 0.019592285, 0.023666382, 0.023864746, 0.024627686, -0.023208618, -0.0006213188, -0.03048706, 0.0736084, -0.04067993, -0.03869629, 0.055999756, -0.045196533, 0.014373779, 0.002521515, 0.008842468, -0.032043457, 0.016403198, 0.013008118, 0.014976501, -0.020843506, 0.05947876, 0.015037537, 0.0009636879, -0.077697754, -0.0033016205, 0.022384644, -0.0029964447, 0.01512146, -0.019744873, 0.011619568, 0.032714844, -0.009918213, 0.032562256, -0.0068969727, -0.011352539, 0.03451538, -0.010444641, -0.01348114, 0.01146698, 0.0234375, 0.011802673, -0.0030078888, 0.0020637512, 0.0018529892, 0.03778076, -0.062042236, -0.016555786, -0.00060653687, 0.015701294, -0.03753662, -0.0115356445, -0.041992188, -0.045288086, -0.016220093, -0.0031356812, -0.017456055, 0.040740967, 0.06335449, -0.0056381226, -0.04269409, -0.013946533, -0.0053901672, -0.014556885, -0.0024700165, -0.0597229, -0.026672363, -0.01626587, -0.042785645, -0.0063209534, 0.03378296, -0.011741638, 0.0501709, -0.005214691, -0.0021476746, 0.014602661, 0.046325684, 0.08099365, 0.0067596436, -0.016845703, -0.039367676, 0.02230835, -0.017227173, -0.015792847, 0.0054740906, -0.0028820038, -0.013061523, -0.030807495, -0.0048103333, -0.018051147, -0.02458191, -0.06161499, 0.010574341, 0.010444641, 0.030075073, 0.04373169, 0.03591919, 0.03479004, 0.00674057, 0.0072250366, 0.012321472, -0.029327393, -0.02684021, -0.000013589859, 0.029312134, 0.004852295, 0.040496826, 0.057922363, -0.030776978, -0.031799316, 0.01335144, 0.014221191, 0.03829956, -0.008590698, 0.0040779114, 0.030014038, -0.04421997, -0.06112671, -0.0071487427, -0.00060367584, 0.03781128, -0.024520874, 0.068603516, 0.024368286, 0.00831604, 0.062927246, -0.0021343231, 0.007171631, 0.014915466, -0.00050258636, -0.05935669, -0.08135986, -0.019348145, 0.075683594, -0.0073661804, -0.0105896, 0.008804321, 0.03591919, 0.020935059, 0.0413208, 0.031021118, -0.03515625, -0.0009584427, -0.028625488, -0.015037537, -0.01222229, -0.035858154, 0.036621094, -0.0033016205, -0.012466431, -0.02897644, -0.055755615, -0.051513672, -0.03652954, 0.008300781, 0.002872467, 0.0181427, -0.06542969, 0.029296875, 0.07006836, 0.014289856, 0.0011129379, 0.025970459, 0.0033016205, 0.009933472, 0.03604126, 0.0037555695, 0.033294678, 0.016830444, -0.07147217, 0.03527832, 0.014190674, -0.004043579, 0.008110046, 0.017547607, -0.003648758, 0.008804321, -0.026550293, 0.026687622, 0.0007853508, -0.0033550262, -0.0053977966, -0.03503418, 0.010643005, 0.014129639, -0.0015220642, 0.01108551, -0.03881836, -0.00094509125, -0.011100769, -0.019744873, -0.060943604, 0.01739502, -0.019454956, -0.04937744, -0.04034424, 0.02406311, -0.02583313, -0.013259888, 0.0052757263, -0.0021686554, -0.036193848, 0.01411438, 0.019241333, -0.028518677, 0.011749268, -0.014465332, 0.0059661865, 0.043518066, 0.0055885315, -0.027877808, 0.00054836273, -0.026321411, -0.075927734, -0.061798096, -0.0030593872, -0.0015506744, 0.012245178, -0.002407074, -0.019119263, 0.030075073, 0.0231781, 0.040283203, -0.006477356, -0.0340271, 0.04748535, 0.018859863, 0.014709473, 0.009613037, 0.013641357, -0.012069702, 0.0149383545, 0.021453857, -0.04598999, 0.0070610046, -0.0068359375, 0.014137268, -0.01007843, -0.062316895, 0.007347107, 0.0070877075, 0.013031006, 0.02746582, 0.02519226, 0.030151367, 0.02204895, 0.0054244995, 0.029693604, 0.06011963, -0.05050659, -0.02748108, -0.018829346, 0.016189575, -0.03237915, 0.037872314, -0.051757812, -0.021011353, -0.035949707, -0.0814209, -0.024398804, 0.0048828125, 0.024261475, 0.0496521, 0.01423645, -0.06414795, 0.022491455, -0.02670288, -0.020233154, -0.0440979, 0.04159546, -0.0059051514, -0.023620605, 0.003004074, -0.035583496, -0.00843811, -0.0036201477, 0.026519775, 0.0023899078, -0.024810791, -0.010795593, -0.028869629, 0.023147583, -0.018920898, -0.018447876, 0.03970337, 0.0059928894, 0.011894226, 0.05456543, -0.034576416, 0.046936035, 0.01663208, 0.039916992, 0.02784729, -0.020263672, -0.004951477, 0.0045433044, -0.0011310577, -0.047668457, 0.04953003, -0.06488037, 0.022506714, -0.076049805, -0.01977539, -0.06677246, 0.017730713, 0.021377563, 0.005744934, 0.056274414, 0.003982544, 0.031097412, 0.0051612854, 0.014793396, 0.00617218, 0.04055786, 0.014511108, 0.031982422, -0.026443481, -0.01953125, 0.037231445, 0.032989502, -0.008613586, 0.018615723, -0.017837524, -0.019058228, 0.020889282, 0.034423828, -0.0004708767, -0.011497498, -0.0077438354, -0.039855957, -0.007686615, -0.015205383, 0.0050582886, 0.02633667, 0.03286743, 0.0042304993, -0.011756897, 0.0063171387, -0.01473999, -0.037750244, 0.00868988, 0.03086853, -0.075805664, 0.015487671, -0.004627228, -0.0022945404, 0.005683899, 0.026138306, 0.033691406, -0.062042236, -0.057769775, 0.03237915, 0.041046143, 0.007106781, -0.01525116, -0.036590576, -0.00042510033, 0.0054016113, 0.018051147, 0.00035500526, -0.007537842, 0.008598328, 0.025161743, -0.02658081, -0.020141602, 0.0025424957, 0.015350342, -0.0107803345, 0.044433594, -0.027252197, 0.029846191, 0.0017776489, -0.05432129, 0.011169434, 0.015701294, -0.04748535, -0.020004272, 0.011138916, 0.017410278, 0.054473877, 0.068237305, 0.024902344, 0.010139465, -0.015777588, -0.074523926, 0.023025513, 0.027755737, -0.038757324, 0.033416748, -0.033691406, -0.025756836, 0.02758789, -0.045318604, 0.0463562, -0.03756714, -0.014404297, -0.0069389343, 0.022918701, 0.035339355, -0.037384033, -0.011192322, -0.029815674, -0.050079346, 0.0072746277, -0.018600464, -0.024780273, -0.011054993, -0.018951416, -0.0052948, 0.03161621, -0.031036377, -0.042877197, 0.0013399124, -0.045166016, -0.0030612946, -0.037078857, 0.04385376, 0.0074424744, -0.016189575, -0.0070877075, -0.0115737915, 0.028625488, -0.040008545, -0.033294678, -0.010253906, -0.0131073, -0.047454834, 0.025161743, 0.030456543, -0.020065308, -0.03186035, -0.008224487, -0.0038986206, -0.02949524, 0.0014209747, 0.037506104, -0.04638672, -0.026672363, -0.0045051575, -0.0473938, 0.03555298, 0.011642456, -0.016143799, 0.018508911, -0.015701294, -0.014533997, -0.016357422, 0.021194458, 0.044067383, -0.011779785, -0.038085938, 0.0013513565, 0.039611816, 0.04446411, -0.05899048, -0.020706177, 0.014915466, 0.008865356, -0.0023860931, 0.049041748, 0.02709961, -0.030059814, 0.014709473, -0.041259766, -0.010070801, 0.013008118, -0.07373047, -0.038635254, 0.05822754, 0.039489746, -0.01737976, -0.022323608, 0.05218506, -0.029144287, -0.011314392, 0.012451172, 0.038269043, 0.0024147034, -0.0015268326, 0.009178162, -0.051208496, -0.051757812, -0.00093126297, 0.010955811, -0.0041656494, 0.042541504, -0.025344849, -0.0051345825, -0.009269714, 0.028961182, -0.029800415, -0.043518066, 0.022003174, 0.009689331, 0.0071411133, 0.032562256, -0.02027893, -0.017425537, 0.006729126, -0.010643005, -0.02381897, 0.006980896, 0.045715332, -0.06536865, -0.0071754456, -0.0368042, -0.027557373, -0.048034668, -0.04458618, 0.03604126, -0.06567383, 0.008590698, -0.044189453, -0.015594482, -0.017227173, 0.018081665, -0.015533447, -0.043548584, -0.0059509277, -0.04257202, 0.04815674, -0.0022792816 ], "summary": [ 0.005722046, -0.00074100494, -0.006614685, -0.030273438, -0.024841309, -0.000667572, -0.05203247, -0.015686035, 0.027420044, 0.020385742, -0.036895752, -0.03439331, 0.023345947, -0.03665161, -0.009231567, -0.03942871, -0.018096924, 0.037200928, 0.0020065308, -0.031097412, 0.011367798, -0.037475586, -0.01461792, -0.01398468, 0.037719727, -0.06542969, -0.0049476624, -0.015945435, 0.039794922, 0.024780273, 0.032470703, -0.023117065, 0.029724121, -0.020904541, 0.002796173, -0.052612305, -0.021072388, -0.016448975, -0.0085372925, -0.0011339188, -0.0005722046, 0.0035305023, 0.10571289, -0.054748535, 0.027618408, 0.053833008, -0.026565552, -0.035095215, 0.015670776, 0.02218628, 0.017349243, -0.005104065, -0.005443573, 0.0079574585, -0.0053710938, 0.001326561, -0.095336914, -0.028274536, 0.029937744, 0.08459473, 0.043151855, -0.045410156, -0.013885498, -0.0692749, -0.0004594326, 0.0000037550926, 0.019729614, 0.017501831, 0.033569336, 0.018157959, 0.0013971329, 0.0042037964, 0.038513184, -0.04257202, -0.053588867, 0.034240723, 0.037841797, 0.024642944, -0.0012245178, -0.051208496, -0.0602417, 0.017929077, -0.052825928, -0.03488159, 0.00067424774, -0.007007599, -0.03555298, 0.007575989, 0.0041236877, -0.005340576, 0.004169464, 0.003835678, -0.037841797, 0.07519531, 0.016296387, -0.033050537, -0.043884277, -0.0077285767, -0.004119873, 0.027633667, 0.013313293, -0.012016296, 0.0056762695, -0.027038574, -0.0071640015, -0.025863647, -0.029953003, -0.07861328, -0.00217247, 0.0345459, -0.036132812, -0.013923645, 0.027038574, 0.001996994, -0.034576416, -0.019256592, -0.003440857, 0.027053833, 0.014678955, 0.023712158, 0.010345459, 0.03265381, -0.034210205, 0.0069885254, 0.02180481, 0.035247803, -0.01525116, 0.011131287, -0.0014286041, -0.010917664, -0.002035141, 0.030929565, -0.043945312, -0.0043029785, -0.037384033, 0.003862381, -0.0012655258, 0.013206482, 0.005218506, -0.018966675, 0.082092285, -0.016586304, -0.02305603, 0.060516357, 0.0118255615, 0.01777649, 0.014945984, 0.012023926, -0.012382507, -0.051116943, 0.021392822, 0.041137695, 0.03778076, -0.027679443, 0.013420105, -0.05215454, -0.03314209, -0.017364502, 0.031311035, 0.0073051453, -0.020706177, 0.012290955, 0.05102539, 0.00015747547, 0.0011758804, -0.029510498, -0.00091695786, -0.0033569336, -0.007297516, -0.048065186, 0.021774292, 0.027679443, -0.0018882751, -0.047302246, 0.0056877136, -0.009140015, -0.003921509, -0.038238525, -0.0029201508, 0.046783447, 0.022521973, -0.005279541, -0.04055786, 0.041534424, -0.019104004, 0.02909851, -0.01486969, 0.008117676, 0.043151855, -0.00793457, 0.0053367615, 0.007736206, 0.0005893707, 0.004650116, -0.005115509, -0.011238098, -0.009033203, 0.021759033, -0.015853882, -0.023223877, -0.028625488, 0.04421997, -0.048583984, 0.03387451, 0.013847351, -0.00573349, 0.019317627, 0.016403198, -0.00920105, 0.009407043, 0.026031494, -0.026245117, 0.0065841675, -0.031234741, -0.02168274, -0.07684326, 0.0435791, -0.033599854, 0.0052833557, -0.019439697, 0.014801025, 0.04019165, -0.029937744, 0.053619385, -0.006576538, -0.025527954, -0.002506256, 0.002922058, -0.024520874, 0.013824463, -0.0057678223, -0.0068626404, 0.024169922, 0.03842163, -0.015686035, -0.00026750565, 0.053955078, -0.022918701, 0.019729614, 0.02720642, 0.0020122528, -0.007881165, -0.024093628, 0.038085938, -0.031982422, -0.028411865, 0.006839752, 0.013961792, -0.052215576, -0.00932312, 0.017745972, 0.051361084, 0.014289856, 0.009635925, -0.018951416, 0.04031372, -0.0017280579, 0.025390625, -0.014968872, 0.016708374, -0.0046539307, 0.06500244, 0.030670166, 0.005531311, 0.015090942, -0.047790527, 0.0129776, -0.02243042, -0.011383057, -0.019302368, 0.021652222, -0.029693604, 0.0028629303, -0.052612305, -0.061340332, -0.06719971, 0.0056991577, 0.053253174, -0.00623703, -0.06304932, -0.023803711, -0.027282715, 0.00844574, -0.012390137, 0.025512695, -0.013725281, 0.024032593, -0.017715454, -0.025512695, 0.021972656, 0.024932861, 0.07501221, 0.029174805, 0.005821228, -0.015602112, 0.038269043, -0.03567505, 0.014633179, -0.0009255409, -0.039093018, -0.013648987, 0.020767212, -0.030410767, -0.0056381226, 0.012939453, 0.03137207, 0.057403564, -0.014038086, 0.009414673, -0.008644104, -0.009407043, -0.015914917, 0.01461792, 0.058624268, -0.046173096, -0.06335449, -0.0048103333, 0.009132385, -0.026412964, 0.016494751, 0.064086914, 0.01889038, -0.046051025, 0.039001465, -0.0055732727, -0.0074882507, 0.04434204, -0.03250122, 0.017730713, -0.016021729, -0.0317688, -0.007270813, -0.051727295, 0.04071045, 0.0059661865, -0.0055770874, 0.032043457, -0.052886963, 0.012428284, 0.029418945, 0.07220459, 0.016799927, 0.0050582886, 0.0084991455, -0.008850098, -0.014144897, 0.0033187866, 0.009750366, 0.018356323, -0.021957397, 0.003370285, -0.030670166, -0.014762878, 0.020095825, 0.02407837, 0.007156372, 0.010795593, 0.0052757263, 0.019104004, -0.03024292, -0.00819397, 0.017852783, -0.0135650635, -0.07342529, -0.00041770935, -0.034240723, -0.004787445, 0.00096178055, 0.055145264, 0.036956787, 0.035583496, 0.043395996, -0.058044434, -0.02545166, 0.0017356873, -0.040771484, 0.052337646, -0.030349731, -0.033081055, 0.026062012, -0.022018433, -0.009750366, 0.0040016174, -0.010299683, 0.043762207, 0.005180359, 0.0025177002, 0.014793396, 0.030700684, 0.0024852753, -0.0069122314, -0.0076904297, 0.037628174, -0.0060920715, -0.0112838745, 0.008796692, -0.0020999908, -0.013252258, -0.0026283264, -0.021392822, 0.095947266, -0.000008583069, 0.0029735565, 0.019454956, -0.030792236, 0.027145386, 0.062561035, 0.011741638, 0.019058228, 0.052246094, 0.008216858, -0.026016235, 0.022720337, -0.019622803, -0.0008883476, 0.0048828125, 0.056243896, 0.027542114, -0.031433105, -0.074035645, -0.025619507, 0.09326172, -0.027862549, -0.044952393, 0.016525269, 0.021072388, -0.010955811, -0.008491516, -0.02319336, 0.02822876, 0.011230469, -0.020751953, 0.0079193115, -0.0038490295, -0.04437256, -0.051361084, -0.016906738, -0.04159546, 0.043548584, -0.050079346, -0.041748047, -0.019195557, 0.032287598, 0.03857422, 0.007232666, 0.00036287308, -0.016647339, -0.028945923, 0.02494812, 0.038116455, -0.0026340485, -0.0026836395, 0.016311646, 0.012252808, -0.035980225, 0.014419556, 0.016082764, 0.031951904, 0.015007019, -0.028686523, 0.0025672913, -0.018432617, -0.019302368, 0.008476257, 0.01210022, 0.043395996, 0.02607727, 0.012191772, -0.01574707, 0.008644104, 0.028564453, -0.0847168, 0.0027160645, -0.009643555, -0.024414062, -0.060424805, 0.050079346, 0.048706055, 0.00094509125, -0.07897949, -0.009757996, 0.023742676, -0.051330566, -0.025970459, -0.0078125, 0.01373291, -0.067871094, -0.0769043, 0.0043296814, 0.046417236, 0.006580353, -0.015296936, 0.038116455, -0.006412506, -0.01777649, 0.035003662, -0.02053833, 0.095825195, 0.015625, -0.06549072, 0.04446411, -0.03225708, -0.003917694, 0.033966064, -0.038085938, 0.06048584, 0.07556152, 0.018234253, -0.029922485, -0.07501221, 0.0736084, -0.06210327, -0.018600464, 0.022369385, -0.033966064, -0.0025997162, 0.012924194, 0.006122589, -0.027877808, 0.008216858, 0.0715332, 0.068481445, -0.019500732, 0.02760315, 0.0048599243, -0.036010742, -0.027282715, -0.043914795, 0.026138306, 0.017868042, 0.040374756, 0.0075302124, -0.0023479462, 0.012649536, -0.017669678, -0.025512695, -0.027404785, -0.0079956055, 0.024368286, 0.015899658, -0.01889038, -0.017211914, 0.0072669983, 0.031341553, -0.0059318542, -0.02230835, -0.033172607, 0.0026779175, -0.07312012, 0.009811401, -0.02053833, -0.024291992, -0.04675293, -0.04837036, 0.026153564, 0.0015678406, 0.029769897, -0.042663574, -0.039093018, 0.05847168, 0.053009033, 0.026000977, -0.044921875, -0.017288208, -0.07342529, -0.024673462, 0.0345459, -0.016555786, -0.03778076, -0.044647217, -0.064086914, -0.016571045, 0.0041656494, -0.017181396, 0.029174805, 0.014724731, 0.023025513, 0.011054993, 0.033325195, 0.029678345, 0.01838684, 0.0018758774, -0.033416748, 0.0037288666, -0.02897644, 0.062561035, -0.012519836, 0.028747559, -0.010261536, 0.0121154785, -0.0143966675, 0.010116577, -0.045043945, -0.081848145, -0.00004452467, 0.0446167, -0.026260376, 0.052886963, 0.026565552, 0.017929077, 0.039245605, 0.022247314, 0.031463623, -0.002626419, -0.09631348, -0.029129028, -0.028579712, 0.014663696, 0.03704834, 0.042297363, -0.029724121, -0.041412354, -0.004016876, 0.029541016, 0.016174316, -0.018676758, -0.0024337769, 0.018005371, -0.042297363, -0.03274536, -0.00009548664, -0.036956787, -0.00039887428, 0.03152466, 0.01586914, 0.025558472, 0.015144348, 0.038604736, -0.017333984, -0.015975952, -0.0082092285, -0.027023315, -0.041015625, -0.08856201, -0.044189453, 0.07104492, -0.0019702911, -0.05090332, -0.0005764961, 0.022903442, -0.013183594, 0.03378296, 0.01777649, -0.07067871, 0.05432129, -0.03543091, -0.04458618, 0.024810791, -0.004016876, 0.027877808, -0.0076560974, -0.0119018555, -0.00023257732, -0.05609131, 0.015052795, -0.019744873, 0.0041923523, 0.0035171509, 0.033935547, -0.04812622, -0.052490234, 0.021057129, -0.008422852, -0.049621582, 0.023529053, -0.027801514, -0.017471313, 0.016677856, -0.035003662, 0.026000977, -0.006164551, -0.07470703, 0.050628662, 0.011054993, 0.024414062, 0.022064209, -0.011100769, 0.004989624, 0.0043563843, -0.0074043274, -0.0154418945, -0.013412476, 0.027328491, -0.017074585, -0.008094788, 0.028030396, 0.019866943, -0.0034732819, 0.01386261, -0.0051841736, 0.01876831, -0.022125244, 0.017532349, -0.047943115, -0.02418518, -0.019058228, -0.039215088, -0.027648926, 0.010902405, -0.022323608, -0.010299683, -0.0051193237, -0.008995056, -0.031188965, -0.034301758, 0.008392334, -0.014503479, 0.044281006, 0.0003528595, 0.022918701, 0.014266968, -0.041503906, -0.012863159, 0.0027999878, -0.02128601, -0.045562744, -0.040130615, -0.018081665, -0.021377563, 0.04272461, 0.007865906, 0.0102005005, 0.023391724, 0.009933472, 0.032806396, -0.035949707, -0.015403748, 0.037719727, -0.0042877197, 0.0009636879, 0.012924194, -0.0054626465, -0.017929077, -0.012191772, 0.013427734, -0.05895996, 0.008811951, -0.012580872, -0.0072402954, -0.034240723, -0.05609131, 0.010650635, 0.012046814, 0.005264282, 0.040771484, 0.021118164, 0.016113281, 0.0028305054, 0.004776001, 0.012229919, 0.035308838, -0.03768921, 0.0010967255, -0.037261963, 0.025405884, -0.06677246, -0.052001953, -0.0335083, 0.021453857, 0.004234314, -0.08654785, 0.002090454, -0.015640259, 0.033813477, 0.053955078, 0.046539307, -0.048095703, 0.003112793, -0.0033435822, -0.008171082, -0.040405273, 0.02482605, -0.025756836, -0.0007967949, 0.015327454, -0.014312744, -0.03012085, 0.04421997, 0.026473999, -0.0021152496, -0.032043457, 0.031341553, 0.011009216, 0.013793945, 0.003112793, 0.013755798, 0.028030396, -0.009048462, 0.013885498, 0.006855011, 0.011734009, 0.020645142, 0.020065308, 0.0047302246, -0.007411957, -0.05102539, -0.0041542053, 0.014404297, -0.019515991, -0.037719727, 0.047821045, -0.033416748, -0.004131317, -0.04547119, -0.0362854, -0.016586304, 0.040039062, -0.011207581, -0.02458191, 0.08508301, -0.00090646744, 0.054656982, 0.013496399, -0.07336426, -0.028930664, -0.024368286, 0.04034424, 0.018875122, -0.014251709, -0.019592285, -0.0064888, 0.037872314, -0.0004711151, 0.029647827, 0.01737976, 0.0028133392, 0.020355225, -0.0046043396, -0.016098022, -0.023834229, 0.04147339, -0.018188477, -0.020858765, 0.008232117, 0.005683899, -0.0027256012, -0.005756378, 0.03466797, 0.00077342987, 0.01146698, 0.030380249, -0.0418396, 0.02746582, 0.003452301, -0.012435913, -0.03857422, -0.00063705444, -0.0011501312, 0.032562256, -0.017120361, 0.047576904, -0.09790039, -0.025817871, 0.03857422, -0.0034046173, -0.053833008, 0.024414062, -0.028320312, -0.015357971, -0.0262146, -0.014442444, 0.022369385, -0.007232666, -0.015991211, 0.017578125, -0.0068092346, 0.025039673, 0.008872986, 0.010856628, 0.014427185, 0.026351929, -0.028762817, -0.0037899017, 0.011436462, -0.034820557, 0.012214661, 0.014167786, 0.038146973, -0.011947632, -0.02003479, 0.017852783, 0.08026123, 0.020645142, -0.055389404, 0.026977539, 0.06878662, -0.03262329, 0.062438965, -0.038848877, -0.010925293, -0.011230469, 0.005935669, 0.0284729, -0.010238647, 0.01108551, 0.010414124, -0.023132324, 0.002248764, -0.025100708, 0.0050201416, -0.013542175, -0.03945923, -0.002117157, -0.05722046, -0.056030273, 0.022094727, -0.0037708282, -0.030303955, 0.04800415, -0.029388428, -0.06567383, 0.036834717, -0.015792847, -0.013069153, -0.0037651062, 0.014328003, -0.022613525, -0.002986908, 0.027313232, 0.05432129, -0.024459839, 0.057373047, -0.023376465, 0.04324341, -0.048797607, -0.054595947, 0.03302002, 0.043273926, -0.08392334, 0.034484863, 0.02558899, -0.023330688, -0.047912598, -0.023208618, -0.0040779114, -0.0236969, 0.027008057, 0.030593872, -0.0027313232, -0.018981934, 0.005168915, -0.026138306, 0.004749298, -0.00894928, -0.02154541, 0.024398804, -0.0135269165, -0.03326416, 0.014144897, 0.023788452, 0.037261963, -0.018569946, -0.019500732, -0.017120361, 0.034729004, 0.06011963, -0.018112183, -0.0025959015, 0.02911377, 0.0048942566, 0.0032672882, -0.0055732727, 0.020019531, -0.023910522, -0.00024604797, -0.033569336, -0.016723633, 0.025039673, -0.056488037, -0.038513184, 0.0395813, 0.021606445, -0.010864258, -0.028961182, 0.054534912, -0.0043182373, -0.0052757263, 0.021316528, 0.034332275, -0.0037326813, -0.00007599592, 0.005344391, -0.035705566, -0.07940674, -0.0033683777, -0.015296936, 0.012550354, 0.010658264, -0.02079773, 0.016113281, -0.025787354, 0.00031208992, -0.020858765, 0.043029785, -0.036865234, -0.00434494, -0.002122879, 0.01927185, -0.03918457, 0.027633667, 0.008880615, -0.01966858, -0.015419006, -0.023147583, 0.034332275, -0.014907837, -0.00566864, 0.0011081696, -0.0074272156, -0.043884277, -0.03765869, 0.03137207, -0.049438477, -0.00573349, 0.009689331, -0.010383606, -0.005138397, 0.013916016, -0.009887695, -0.038024902, 0.044921875, -0.014526367, 0.012245178, 0.018432617 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1907.01221v1
Visual analytics for team-based invasion sports with significant events and Markov reward process
Kun Zhao, Takayuki Osogami, Tetsuro Morimura
cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
In team-based invasion sports such as soccer and basketball, analytics is important for teams to understand their performance and for audiences to understand matches better. The present work focuses on performing visual analytics to evaluate the value of any kind of event occurring in a sports match with a continuous parameter space. Here, the continuous parameter space involves the time, location, score, and other parameters. Because the spatiotemporal data used in such analytics is a low-level representation and has a very large size, however, traditional analytics may need to discretize the continuous parameter space (e.g., subdivide the playing area) or use a local feature to limit the analysis to specific events (e.g., only shots). These approaches make evaluation impossible for any kind of event with a continuous parameter space. To solve this problem, we consider a whole match as a Markov chain of significant events, so that event values can be estimated with a continuous parameter space by solving the Markov chain with a machine learning model. The significant events are first extracted by considering the time-varying distribution of players to represent the whole match. Then, the extracted events are redefined as different states with the continuous parameter space and built as a Markov chain so that a Markov reward process can be applied. Finally, the Markov reward process is solved by a customized fitted-value iteration algorithm so that the event values with the continuous parameter space can be predicted by a regression model. As a result, the event values can be visually inspected over the whole playing field under arbitrary given conditions. Experimental results with real soccer data show the effectiveness of the proposed system.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.01221v1
2019-07-02T08:11:16
2019-07-02T08:11:16
{ "title": [ 0.05392456, 0.018859863, 0.026107788, -0.02418518, 0.0209198, -0.02420044, 0.04083252, -0.042419434, -0.013175964, 0.010429382, -0.047729492, 0.02015686, -0.055023193, -0.017944336, -0.040771484, -0.053894043, 0.017456055, -0.027755737, -0.013046265, -0.041534424, -0.0027618408, -0.038604736, 0.061187744, 0.059661865, -0.012527466, 0.026626587, -0.09490967, 0.00040769577, -0.022369385, -0.009529114, -0.022735596, 0.028839111, 0.04434204, -0.04977417, 0.07366943, 0.06390381, -0.03552246, 0.0067825317, 0.011299133, 0.007949829, -0.0115356445, -0.000085413456, 0.012084961, -0.026290894, -0.018661499, 0.023895264, -0.06210327, -0.02067566, -0.04748535, 0.04043579, 0.0049095154, 0.010940552, 0.027435303, 0.060272217, 0.008407593, -0.031799316, -0.040130615, -0.016174316, 0.019195557, 0.070251465, 0.03781128, -0.020614624, -0.0011606216, -0.030944824, -0.02268982, -0.013046265, 0.014831543, 0.033050537, 0.011680603, -0.0113220215, -0.003074646, 0.010139465, -0.007797241, 0.011451721, -0.046569824, -0.010116577, 0.057525635, 0.0146484375, 0.0006480217, 0.0011100769, -0.024765015, -0.048706055, 0.012260437, -0.02571106, 0.012496948, -0.006439209, -0.008239746, -0.006061554, -0.03439331, -0.04156494, -0.024765015, 0.006504059, -0.014251709, -0.014587402, -0.03366089, -0.020263672, -0.024505615, 0.019119263, -0.0019369125, -0.04269409, -0.023925781, 0.028305054, -0.07836914, -0.00024020672, -0.0058517456, 0.05029297, 0.015548706, 0.03591919, 0.013710022, 0.004058838, -0.00843811, -0.003873825, 0.038635254, 0.06890869, 0.0048599243, -0.046447754, -0.025680542, 0.04852295, -0.04067993, 0.049957275, -0.017074585, -0.004840851, 0.010887146, 0.008766174, 0.00048708916, -0.024169922, -0.023025513, 0.012420654, 0.00522995, 0.031433105, 0.005908966, 0.019927979, -0.06994629, -0.043426514, -0.035095215, 0.008003235, -0.005268097, 0.005924225, -0.006099701, -0.014564514, 0.021850586, -0.011268616, 0.025131226, -0.009124756, 0.019927979, -0.020233154, 0.047851562, 0.023986816, -0.0127334595, 0.025466919, 0.004169464, 0.014953613, -0.016815186, 0.027755737, 0.00035524368, 0.026412964, -0.049957275, 0.0030517578, 0.021072388, 0.012084961, 0.00019490719, -0.002483368, 0.0015382767, 0.014549255, 0.02935791, 0.000007987022, -0.0018167496, 0.018249512, 0.016860962, 0.0025157928, 0.007610321, 0.010505676, 0.020584106, -0.03062439, -0.010696411, -0.006706238, 0.03010559, 0.023422241, 0.009994507, 0.0057678223, 0.009239197, -0.016784668, 0.036102295, 0.011398315, -0.0289917, -0.041290283, -0.006214142, -0.029647827, 0.027420044, 0.012557983, -0.010185242, 0.041290283, -0.06951904, -0.0072784424, -0.025375366, -0.01727295, -0.003118515, 0.015213013, 0.012428284, -0.003042221, -0.032470703, 0.007534027, -0.03756714, 0.0317688, 0.0058174133, -0.023132324, 0.0012998581, 0.023162842, -0.042266846, 0.06536865, 0.053649902, 0.021316528, -0.048461914, 0.021469116, 0.02557373, -0.06512451, 0.026611328, -0.02268982, 0.007637024, -0.012992859, -0.03604126, 0.018234253, -0.049804688, 0.012893677, 0.0020065308, -0.0064582825, 0.02267456, -0.020904541, 0.08880615, 0.004058838, 0.13244629, -0.04537964, -0.0032215118, 0.012825012, -0.0031147003, -0.010803223, 0.012260437, -0.01411438, 0.02368164, 0.011978149, 0.008575439, 0.010238647, -0.0051956177, 0.03741455, 0.034729004, -0.013771057, -0.006614685, 0.033569336, 0.006755829, 0.0107040405, 0.021636963, 0.01525116, 0.048187256, -0.006160736, -0.024032593, 0.083740234, -0.005329132, 0.008636475, -0.031311035, 0.04647827, -0.0060310364, 0.037353516, 0.026260376, 0.014305115, -0.014717102, -0.010002136, -0.014167786, 0.0012073517, -0.0034770966, 0.0037879944, 0.022491455, -0.038269043, 0.012825012, -0.006454468, 0.013267517, 0.00014460087, -0.0256958, 0.0022220612, 0.033172607, -0.030944824, 0.011291504, 0.030929565, 0.012359619, -0.021911621, 0.02784729, 0.01876831, -0.011657715, -0.018463135, -0.03414917, -0.0025901794, 0.04296875, 0.029922485, -0.0023727417, 0.0021362305, -0.013092041, 0.008598328, 0.014930725, 0.052703857, -0.012619019, 0.013175964, -0.03186035, 0.020935059, -0.0035934448, 0.009269714, -0.0038890839, 0.046813965, -0.009017944, 0.019470215, -0.009391785, -0.016693115, -0.021697998, -0.0017032623, 0.02911377, -0.025665283, 0.049438477, -0.00869751, 0.033447266, 0.018447876, -0.012107849, -0.028808594, 0.00064849854, -0.0390625, -0.04711914, -0.013000488, -0.027496338, 0.01071167, -0.033843994, -0.01878357, -0.08300781, 0.02168274, 0.06555176, 0.01083374, 0.009666443, 0.052490234, 0.011665344, 0.007472992, -0.011123657, -0.012504578, -0.032348633, -0.033599854, -0.047943115, -0.0008211136, 0.000916481, -0.04168701, -0.043029785, -0.026779175, -0.0054473877, -0.0018472672, -0.013877869, -0.018371582, 0.062927246, 0.0034294128, -0.0060920715, 0.02180481, 0.047332764, -0.016860962, -0.011146545, 0.043121338, 0.043670654, -0.0038986206, 0.054382324, 0.004878998, 0.014335632, -0.06518555, -0.03616333, -0.04058838, -0.013389587, -0.038208008, 0.00088739395, 0.04525757, -0.068115234, -0.009643555, 0.027038574, 0.0029201508, -0.0013389587, 0.0065612793, -0.045135498, -0.04421997, -0.0077590942, -0.03967285, -0.0014305115, -0.0058059692, 0.011795044, 0.032440186, 0.10449219, 0.0013666153, 0.0126953125, 0.00072574615, 0.053344727, 0.005722046, 0.008644104, -0.03616333, 0.021697998, -0.025268555, 0.01184082, 0.0073051453, 0.00730896, -0.0061531067, -0.017288208, -0.011314392, -0.005470276, 0.019317627, 0.009773254, 0.0209198, -0.08325195, 0.090270996, -0.06210327, -0.0028152466, 0.023529053, 0.10803223, -0.006839752, 0.0011425018, 0.0137786865, 0.001953125, -0.0013055801, 0.000062823296, -0.0231781, 0.025436401, -0.038238525, -0.015403748, 0.050109863, -0.08013916, -0.0052986145, -0.015808105, -0.021392822, 0.03829956, 0.020309448, 0.01398468, 0.009437561, 0.0060195923, 0.0054016113, -0.010414124, 0.014251709, -0.035736084, -0.070129395, -0.044891357, -0.039642334, 0.026443481, 0.008026123, -0.021362305, -0.07897949, -0.018447876, 0.0016994476, 0.010246277, 0.013031006, -0.013092041, -0.016647339, -0.0463562, 0.025253296, 0.018447876, 0.0018873215, -0.017700195, 0.019760132, 0.0053596497, -0.03237915, 0.0049209595, -0.0060577393, 0.005508423, -0.012184143, -0.012786865, -0.013145447, -0.021652222, 0.0020713806, -0.0049858093, 0.02458191, 0.006538391, -0.017089844, 0.0025405884, -0.0040664673, 0.0059509277, -0.00289917, 0.006702423, 0.016586304, 0.013908386, -0.015289307, 0.016021729, 0.021514893, 0.024230957, -0.032440186, -0.024978638, 0.03955078, 0.00869751, 0.071777344, -0.07757568, -0.035247803, 0.02407837, -0.13098145, -0.046081543, -0.01209259, 0.0039482117, -0.049346924, 0.02192688, 0.001627922, 0.007457733, -0.029953003, 0.012870789, 0.0019187927, 0.038024902, -0.006374359, -0.042938232, -0.0597229, 0.040222168, -0.019119263, 0.012550354, 0.040802002, -0.024536133, 0.028167725, 0.010826111, 0.030899048, 0.06506348, 0.046417236, 0.02406311, -0.012619019, 0.017028809, -0.02722168, 0.0135650635, 0.044555664, -0.029251099, 0.024002075, 0.018371582, 0.0019369125, 0.013916016, -0.013046265, 0.049865723, 0.0090789795, -0.005367279, -0.04296875, 0.0038604736, -0.04425049, -0.008468628, -0.007205963, 0.006668091, 0.0042762756, -0.008575439, 0.042907715, 0.04058838, -0.006072998, -0.032440186, 0.023925781, 0.033325195, -0.0052337646, -0.0053710938, -0.01612854, 0.038024902, 0.0023899078, 0.03451538, 0.018203735, 0.09564209, -0.014709473, 0.048095703, -0.031829834, -0.01739502, -0.038360596, -0.016433716, -0.02130127, -0.03744507, -0.01335144, 0.00459671, -0.009048462, 0.005722046, 0.020584106, -0.016662598, -0.038848877, 0.023620605, 0.010543823, 0.00008946657, 0.0023097992, -0.04324341, 0.020004272, -0.012451172, -0.035339355, -0.028549194, 0.05807495, 0.018112183, 0.029159546, -0.06390381, -0.03286743, 0.0076179504, 0.024047852, 0.10418701, 0.07220459, 0.01928711, -0.07281494, 0.06976318, -0.009811401, 0.018600464, 0.016677856, 0.031097412, 0.0013971329, 0.0035953522, 0.0027389526, -0.015617371, -0.014587402, -0.019042969, 0.0064811707, -0.04901123, 0.050994873, 0.021118164, 0.059387207, 0.01360321, 0.036743164, -0.012870789, 0.0030059814, -0.02204895, -0.012519836, -0.024536133, 0.043060303, 0.025924683, -0.016326904, -0.010421753, 0.02029419, -0.0008378029, 0.0062408447, 0.007446289, 0.009994507, 0.028869629, 0.012817383, 0.010169983, -0.05834961, -0.02947998, 0.009315491, -0.022079468, 0.02684021, -0.029571533, 0.044769287, 0.014015198, -0.0012636185, 0.03930664, -0.016967773, -0.005382538, -0.028045654, -0.008598328, -0.055419922, -0.072143555, -0.010940552, 0.07336426, -0.024017334, -0.020584106, -0.014450073, 0.02708435, 0.021713257, 0.043029785, 0.0020599365, -0.04055786, 0.017333984, 0.000032126904, -0.02116394, -0.027114868, -0.031799316, -0.014320374, -0.0042877197, 0.007247925, -0.082214355, 0.040130615, -0.008056641, -0.015701294, -0.030929565, 0.012672424, 0.020401001, -0.03225708, 0.019729614, 0.088378906, 0.0155181885, 0.02192688, -0.01852417, 0.009155273, 0.024887085, 0.032073975, 0.0010757446, 0.0033836365, 0.014831543, -0.03262329, -0.0048828125, 0.00029730797, 0.011314392, -0.01689148, 0.014434814, -0.003862381, -0.008476257, -0.021957397, 0.012969971, -0.008460999, -0.0058135986, 0.03390503, -0.050567627, -0.000112593174, 0.018707275, 0.007701874, 0.02960205, -0.02557373, -0.0574646, -0.038482666, 0.0075187683, -0.07043457, -0.0027446747, 0.02508545, -0.062927246, -0.085876465, 0.020690918, -0.002035141, -0.0019779205, -0.04852295, 0.017929077, -0.05883789, -0.011299133, 0.037384033, -0.030822754, 0.045654297, -0.04260254, -0.00299263, 0.035705566, 0.014465332, -0.040802002, -0.012962341, 0.032196045, -0.027557373, -0.025405884, 0.00083065033, -0.0032863617, -0.0127334595, -0.039794922, -0.06390381, -0.0043258667, -0.0027923584, 0.0005145073, 0.046539307, -0.04135132, 0.006164551, -0.0121536255, -0.008926392, 0.022598267, 0.026535034, -0.0103302, 0.010894775, -0.018188477, 0.02204895, 0.06390381, -0.023208618, 0.008514404, 0.010955811, -0.029891968, 0.017852783, 0.027267456, -0.02104187, -0.014915466, 0.01838684, 0.00016880035, -0.015945435, 0.0074691772, -0.011680603, 0.044158936, -0.011062622, 0.031585693, -0.017196655, 0.008049011, -0.049224854, 0.009124756, 0.0034770966, 0.031585693, -0.0357666, -0.014450073, -0.012817383, 0.016815186, 0.015182495, -0.026397705, 0.0049324036, -0.019897461, -0.011672974, -0.0014257431, -0.012496948, -0.05532837, -0.038909912, 0.0047416687, 0.002439499, 0.072143555, 0.039367676, -0.0031375885, -0.009521484, -0.00497818, -0.00042414665, 0.030136108, -0.024032593, -0.018798828, -0.0053520203, -0.0385437, -0.015380859, 0.04498291, 0.04425049, -0.03475952, 0.091674805, -0.013473511, 0.046051025, -0.0038547516, 0.043395996, 0.061584473, 0.0637207, -0.010978699, -0.0058898926, 0.0007004738, -0.030960083, 0.015357971, -0.05307007, -0.01399231, -0.024612427, -0.012039185, -0.072265625, 0.0041885376, 0.035827637, 0.0152282715, 0.00982666, 0.0038146973, 0.00699234, 0.01928711, 0.034454346, 0.024765015, 0.055847168, -0.0107421875, -0.00074863434, -0.014930725, -0.0012683868, 0.039886475, 0.046539307, 0.0072021484, 0.00072336197, -0.0021533966, -0.027038574, -0.0025424957, 0.012565613, 0.028030396, -0.008888245, -0.00982666, -0.015457153, 0.012031555, -0.018295288, 0.02293396, 0.040802002, 0.021316528, 0.012321472, -0.010818481, -0.0041656494, 0.042999268, -0.064086914, 0.07354736, 0.066589355, -0.057006836, 0.016601562, -0.023010254, -0.035369873, -0.02394104, 0.0035324097, 0.047790527, -0.050842285, -0.032470703, 0.020736694, 0.031951904, -0.008117676, 0.035980225, -0.03604126, -0.025680542, -0.055999756, -0.01361084, 0.037078857, 0.04458618, 0.0074653625, 0.047302246, -0.015029907, -0.01159668, -0.0025405884, -0.015617371, -0.03878784, 0.015029907, 0.035095215, 0.0012960434, 0.05178833, -0.008605957, -0.014343262, 0.024246216, -0.01222229, 0.0184021, -0.048034668, 0.006591797, 0.008323669, 0.03918457, 0.006389618, -0.010025024, -0.012634277, -0.039093018, 0.015266418, 0.047454834, -0.023025513, -0.014877319, -0.0005941391, -0.026046753, 0.024490356, -0.0045814514, 0.00762558, -0.0013990402, 0.030288696, -0.029846191, 0.0050697327, 0.047698975, -0.07318115, -0.03137207, 0.0027770996, -0.008010864, -0.0003376007, -0.024810791, -0.061431885, -0.0077400208, -0.0021324158, 0.026046753, 0.032714844, -0.061187744, -0.04260254, 0.032226562, -0.05038452, -0.041290283, -0.054260254, -0.008644104, 0.0033454895, -0.027297974, -0.023712158, 0.011070251, 0.0037574768, 0.011703491, 0.002313614, 0.007320404, -0.031921387, -0.027709961, 0.029022217, 0.031555176, -0.019073486, -0.06100464, -0.04107666, -0.0039138794, -0.044189453, -0.04296875, 0.03881836, -0.019638062, -0.08721924, -0.034210205, -0.02458191, 0.028030396, 0.030685425, -0.015808105, 0.010108948, 0.0262146, -0.035461426, -0.085876465, -0.04248047, -0.031463623, -0.00037765503, -0.035736084, -0.018707275, 0.03286743, 0.010566711, -0.048950195, -0.04547119, 0.020690918, 0.044555664, -0.02532959, 0.06921387, 0.008071899, -0.0047721863, 0.008430481, 0.017990112, -0.007095337, -0.013946533, -0.066711426, -0.05834961, 0.039733887, 0.014503479, -0.009597778, -0.028457642, 0.03149414, 0.0040016174, 0.037597656, -0.007774353, 0.0030059814, 0.0068092346, -0.017364502, 0.048980713, 0.0007996559, -0.011962891, -0.012512207, 0.041259766, -0.026443481, -0.024002075, 0.014091492, 0.020507812, -0.026290894, 0.010765076, -0.01852417, -0.048187256, 0.035461426, 0.046173096, -0.003753662, 0.03262329, 0.014640808, -0.012504578, -0.034942627, 0.017471313, 0.022201538, 0.022506714, -0.0011291504, 0.0040740967, 0.027069092, -0.013366699, -0.06976318, -0.018722534, -0.042541504, 0.017974854, -0.047332764, 0.043121338, -0.013290405, -0.007610321, -0.011299133, 0.013130188, 0.008598328, -0.04928589, -0.017730713, 0.009376526, 0.032714844, 0.010551453 ], "summary": [ 0.083740234, 0.0008664131, 0.06951904, -0.0059890747, 0.002746582, -0.014434814, 0.03387451, -0.056274414, 0.0036239624, -0.0076522827, -0.054229736, -0.012962341, -0.050476074, -0.01902771, -0.03652954, -0.07647705, 0.03881836, 0.0033988953, 0.047180176, -0.020767212, 0.031433105, 0.0050201416, 0.039215088, 0.066223145, 0.018127441, 0.047058105, -0.015991211, 0.011558533, 0.022583008, 0.029571533, 0.012748718, -0.050872803, -0.009384155, -0.014930725, 0.06903076, 0.07098389, 0.0015144348, 0.0044784546, 0.044830322, 0.0024433136, 0.0034179688, -0.002023697, 0.04650879, -0.035858154, -0.018005371, 0.04714966, -0.018234253, -0.0060920715, 0.0023212433, 0.0146865845, 0.0020446777, 0.023712158, 0.019424438, 0.038360596, -0.013954163, -0.022460938, -0.03829956, -0.030883789, -0.006526947, 0.09240723, 0.064575195, 0.014709473, -0.024154663, -0.04940796, -0.015823364, -0.00023841858, 0.024108887, 0.010261536, -0.021865845, -0.023452759, 0.024856567, -0.0073165894, -0.025390625, -0.009010315, -0.023925781, -0.0051574707, 0.021240234, -0.016967773, -0.007774353, 0.03086853, -0.0059776306, -0.057037354, 0.042510986, 0.002040863, -0.007534027, 0.043182373, -0.012962341, -0.016540527, -0.041992188, -0.026824951, -0.033172607, 0.016235352, -0.06500244, -0.00774765, 0.00062799454, -0.028747559, 0.010231018, 0.016464233, -0.012527466, -0.033477783, -0.0076293945, 0.0043640137, -0.036468506, -0.005306244, 0.0060424805, 0.09265137, 0.01713562, 0.021362305, 0.018234253, -0.009757996, 0.026138306, -0.009666443, 0.0019817352, 0.052124023, -0.03982544, 0.015342712, -0.016662598, 0.007259369, -0.05505371, 0.06008911, -0.026992798, 0.0038433075, -0.035125732, 0.031829834, -0.0010938644, -0.0014839172, 0.007217407, 0.022842407, 0.008132935, 0.0026855469, -0.009880066, 0.015731812, -0.017028809, 0.0052452087, -0.017333984, -0.0058250427, 0.004497528, -0.003917694, 0.023376465, -0.027175903, 0.032684326, 0.006061554, 0.010505676, 0.026748657, 0.0236969, -0.0043640137, 0.025756836, 0.029083252, -0.012840271, -0.00381279, 0.0435791, 0.007549286, -0.004558563, 0.030792236, 0.0006184578, 0.0037174225, 0.016616821, -0.020446777, 0.032348633, -0.018814087, -0.019821167, -0.001045227, 0.0026340485, 0.03186035, 0.029907227, -0.001373291, 0.032226562, 0.018692017, 0.011001587, -0.010574341, 0.014419556, 0.0029239655, 0.031555176, -0.014907837, -0.0014019012, 0.0035648346, -0.0059013367, 0.035339355, 0.0015182495, 0.003364563, -0.0022354126, -0.035491943, 0.039489746, -0.003534317, 0.008552551, -0.031707764, 0.0023460388, -0.0027389526, 0.02067566, 0.028900146, -0.03955078, 0.015914917, -0.056274414, 0.0027065277, -0.0011510849, 0.00006520748, -0.017562866, 0.010894775, 0.0023288727, -0.012054443, 0.002878189, -0.010391235, -0.0037384033, -0.018630981, -0.029342651, -0.021240234, -0.0064315796, 0.02659607, -0.05923462, 0.0513916, 0.043182373, 0.0029563904, -0.05065918, 0.049194336, 0.040863037, -0.060424805, 0.04324341, -0.051605225, -0.017562866, -0.033813477, -0.06222534, 0.056365967, -0.09399414, 0.042114258, 0.009460449, -0.02230835, 0.028335571, -0.007873535, 0.11993408, -0.022247314, 0.1595459, -0.044891357, -0.047027588, 0.0053634644, 0.011962891, 0.0090408325, 0.036834717, -0.034851074, 0.024841309, 0.0051460266, 0.009002686, 0.038726807, -0.02041626, 0.014678955, 0.014404297, 0.0076675415, 0.021057129, 0.007598877, -0.023117065, 0.010566711, -0.011436462, -0.0102005005, 0.028076172, -0.046783447, -0.029663086, 0.04916382, 0.011947632, 0.039855957, -0.017074585, 0.042755127, -0.030090332, 0.068725586, 0.05517578, 0.005630493, 0.035095215, -0.017120361, 0.007534027, -0.005176544, 0.0013799667, -0.0028305054, 0.0054969788, -0.075683594, 0.0025138855, -0.045532227, -0.03866577, -0.021209717, -0.019836426, 0.042907715, 0.0028896332, -0.048095703, 0.021591187, 0.03857422, -0.03781128, -0.02458191, 0.027572632, 0.004032135, -0.030960083, -0.0002541542, -0.016281128, 0.025222778, 0.04156494, 0.026626587, -0.017623901, 0.0076065063, -0.016113281, -0.012237549, -0.03466797, 0.037200928, -0.006439209, -0.004047394, 0.00034070015, 0.04248047, -0.02204895, 0.013557434, 0.006668091, 0.025634766, 0.013824463, 0.0043754578, 0.008865356, -0.024765015, -0.007472992, 0.026153564, 0.032318115, 0.04348755, 0.033813477, -0.027648926, 0.021453857, 0.042419434, -0.029312134, -0.03451538, 0.046691895, -0.053100586, -0.033935547, -0.0016403198, -0.050079346, 0.0025157928, 0.025253296, -0.013473511, -0.056030273, -0.0009584427, 0.030029297, 0.0040893555, 0.013496399, 0.059387207, 0.010810852, 0.010658264, -0.0009889603, 0.0049362183, -0.023635864, -0.027511597, -0.033843994, -0.021896362, 0.0078125, -0.02734375, -0.06341553, -0.023071289, 0.008148193, -0.006515503, 0.0052757263, -0.026794434, 0.062347412, 0.010681152, -0.028457642, 0.03842163, 0.021484375, 0.011520386, 0.023101807, 0.052764893, 0.05102539, -0.00484848, 0.03427124, -0.005710602, -0.0014629364, -0.06719971, -0.038391113, -0.0038166046, -0.0038146973, -0.029815674, -0.0012903214, 0.010131836, -0.007850647, 0.0018091202, 0.015945435, -0.0064735413, -0.014045715, -0.014030457, -0.0041503906, -0.025405884, 0.024963379, -0.0038471222, -0.0054626465, 0.0015115738, 0.032165527, 0.032226562, 0.12365723, 0.03778076, 0.08685303, 0.04144287, 0.07989502, -0.037628174, 0.007007599, -0.014343262, 0.03479004, -0.031341553, -0.0024433136, -0.0056037903, 0.026916504, 0.007949829, 0.017440796, -0.028259277, -0.022338867, 0.053649902, 0.032196045, 0.022232056, -0.088012695, 0.12322998, -0.07196045, 0.00041270256, -0.0047721863, 0.095825195, -0.0006890297, -0.038879395, 0.00995636, -0.009109497, 0.03503418, -0.00055885315, 0.051330566, 0.004211426, -0.0018587112, -0.030059814, 0.02319336, -0.026626587, 0.023208618, -0.0033950806, -0.027755737, 0.003528595, -0.015899658, 0.020721436, -0.028320312, 0.013473511, -0.014152527, -0.028625488, 0.021728516, -0.01828003, -0.06866455, -0.016647339, -0.033233643, 0.023956299, 0.010574341, -0.052124023, -0.049987793, 0.00040841103, 0.007633209, -0.0009937286, 0.013511658, -0.015991211, 0.01689148, -0.03692627, 0.044189453, 0.022018433, -0.012023926, -0.013084412, 0.051940918, 0.019836426, -0.023010254, -0.005519867, -0.062316895, 0.012886047, 0.056549072, -0.045806885, -0.050231934, -0.031311035, 0.018829346, 0.00032114983, 0.059387207, 0.019836426, -0.029815674, 0.013999939, 0.0035800934, 0.014884949, 0.040649414, -0.061523438, -0.014183044, -0.015144348, -0.007217407, 0.017593384, 0.0362854, 0.008483887, 0.00422287, -0.041046143, -0.026779175, 0.014457703, 0.033721924, -0.072753906, -0.032806396, 0.02368164, -0.066467285, -0.03164673, 0.004711151, 0.043151855, -0.0029258728, 0.03652954, 0.025054932, 0.05038452, 0.009414673, 0.014160156, -0.004508972, 0.03878784, -0.01574707, -0.03491211, -0.041656494, -0.017929077, -0.032836914, 0.011451721, -0.008323669, 0.009307861, 0.049072266, 0.013092041, 0.011451721, 0.014205933, 0.028045654, -0.010848999, 0.009529114, 0.013206482, -0.011650085, 0.026763916, 0.054260254, -0.009902954, 0.025787354, -0.01776123, 0.04562378, 0.04522705, 0.005050659, 0.017913818, 0.00015091896, 0.0042915344, -0.015640259, -0.01309967, -0.03643799, 0.0059890747, 0.011550903, 0.03552246, -0.016601562, -0.037139893, 0.030471802, -0.028533936, -0.024032593, -0.03253174, 0.026062012, 0.052825928, 0.0047035217, -0.025009155, -0.029754639, 0.044158936, -0.016555786, 0.0435791, 0.00157547, 0.07330322, -0.00491333, 0.052764893, -0.026931763, -0.028198242, -0.007217407, -0.022079468, -0.03579712, 0.002937317, 0.0019416809, 0.0025043488, 0.011436462, 0.014053345, -0.0034160614, 0.0025978088, -0.019989014, 0.0050354004, -0.010169983, 0.032928467, -0.05505371, -0.06945801, -0.012527466, 0.00390625, -0.005836487, 0.0029315948, 0.08355713, -0.019515991, 0.0053634644, -0.082336426, -0.02835083, 0.0236969, 0.013397217, 0.08734131, 0.08642578, 0.02078247, -0.09246826, 0.03475952, -0.013313293, 0.02670288, 0.006465912, 0.03074646, -0.0023860931, 0.009361267, 0.0056648254, -0.017608643, -0.029556274, 0.02268982, 0.0072746277, -0.026565552, 0.04711914, 0.023422241, 0.089782715, 0.015731812, 0.038970947, -0.008323669, 0.0030498505, -0.01423645, -0.018188477, -0.011100769, 0.01209259, 0.04598999, -0.018569946, 0.0065727234, -0.020431519, -0.035003662, 0.04019165, -0.008422852, 0.038208008, 0.019485474, 0.016921997, 0.002286911, -0.03390503, -0.022735596, 0.019256592, -0.025009155, 0.01828003, 0.0069084167, 0.0158844, 0.054870605, 0.020874023, 0.046203613, -0.012893677, -0.0076446533, -0.003622055, -0.023666382, -0.035888672, -0.05154419, -0.0013847351, 0.05117798, -0.00048589706, -0.035980225, -0.034057617, 0.018066406, 0.026031494, 0.006778717, -0.026641846, -0.06549072, 0.01802063, -0.011665344, -0.031143188, 0.006580353, 0.009170532, -0.03427124, 0.039611816, -0.007484436, -0.051208496, -0.000854969, 0.022399902, -0.02571106, -0.023086548, 0.009475708, 0.004055023, -0.013969421, -0.034240723, 0.020996094, -0.019134521, 0.001124382, -0.019363403, -0.007637024, -0.0002323389, 0.0152282715, -0.023208618, -0.0062446594, -0.006134033, -0.033233643, -0.0039901733, 0.007194519, 0.0041923523, 0.046875, 0.00017619133, 0.008720398, -0.026901245, 0.023620605, 0.0046157837, -0.008155823, -0.0006389618, 0.009719849, -0.01966858, 0.04034424, -0.030715942, -0.009147644, 0.017166138, -0.00041508675, 0.0031528473, -0.0065689087, 0.018157959, -0.03768921, -0.014160156, 0.015853882, -0.041107178, -0.04562378, -0.02204895, -0.01675415, 0.0000615716, -0.023406982, 0.016067505, -0.02960205, -0.035827637, 0.024658203, -0.015068054, 0.05709839, -0.014137268, 0.00018692017, 0.018920898, 0.013893127, -0.09161377, -0.023773193, 0.029418945, -0.017974854, -0.041900635, 0.0027618408, 0.017303467, -0.012580872, -0.027450562, -0.035888672, 0.043273926, -0.0115356445, 0.01776123, 0.0138168335, -0.014144897, -0.0075416565, -0.010231018, -0.003774643, 0.023513794, 0.01071167, 0.027374268, 0.0072135925, -0.031463623, -0.020004272, 0.05545044, 0.009346008, 0.026901245, 0.008735657, -0.00869751, -0.00035214424, 0.030334473, -0.013641357, -0.026794434, 0.023498535, -0.00047302246, -0.05065918, 0.01977539, -0.023391724, 0.023727417, -0.0014762878, -0.00076818466, -0.017410278, 0.02861023, -0.017700195, -0.0006008148, 0.006149292, -0.0020332336, -0.013305664, 0.027679443, 0.014640808, -0.0018033981, -0.003982544, -0.046539307, 0.024536133, 0.023010254, -0.024902344, 0.0064964294, -0.036987305, -0.033050537, -0.007858276, -0.00082826614, 0.019973755, 0.0625, -0.0077323914, -0.015335083, -0.01134491, -0.0063819885, 0.00894928, 0.022415161, -0.0006198883, 0.011444092, -0.009651184, -0.048309326, 0.012664795, 0.026245117, 0.066345215, -0.058685303, 0.033966064, 0.020690918, 0.052093506, 0.010757446, -0.017074585, 0.051940918, 0.052124023, -0.02357483, -0.011993408, 0.022064209, -0.013946533, 0.019851685, -0.0023422241, -0.052825928, -0.028930664, -0.057922363, -0.021240234, 0.010406494, -0.003194809, -0.006122589, 0.04510498, -0.0056419373, 0.04159546, 0.037231445, -0.034729004, -0.025604248, 0.015792847, -0.008026123, -0.0059928894, -0.026489258, -0.025924683, 0.023010254, 0.03866577, 0.004753113, 0.0021400452, 0.0036964417, -0.0061836243, -0.005420685, -0.014228821, 0.014785767, -0.0209198, 0.007633209, -0.021499634, 0.010063171, -0.025344849, 0.0050964355, 0.049591064, 0.005710602, 0.041503906, -0.034973145, 0.0060310364, 0.073913574, -0.052459717, 0.07891846, 0.057891846, -0.015586853, -0.0018701553, 0.013916016, -0.032348633, 0.03475952, 0.003528595, 0.04550171, -0.043792725, -0.021438599, -0.011703491, 0.021820068, -0.007419586, 0.03390503, -0.01586914, -0.011390686, -0.04699707, -0.025772095, 0.058410645, 0.0602417, -0.0026950836, 0.011138916, 0.0015411377, -0.008079529, 0.022766113, -0.015312195, 0.030014038, 0.016464233, -0.007827759, 0.010375977, 0.04611206, -0.003829956, 0.026657104, 0.027130127, 0.022766113, 0.033935547, 0.017929077, -0.030380249, 0.0034122467, 0.023757935, -0.011039734, 0.017684937, 0.008743286, -0.017929077, -0.016860962, -0.018341064, -0.031021118, -0.042663574, 0.023406982, 0.038391113, 0.0010528564, 0.019470215, -0.03286743, -0.016693115, 0.02041626, -0.036590576, 0.0059814453, -0.010902405, -0.036132812, -0.0047035217, -0.040649414, -0.0025844574, 0.010032654, 0.02848816, -0.035858154, 0.0011997223, -0.005130768, -0.00081062317, 0.009086609, -0.029006958, 0.014457703, 0.008331299, -0.014511108, -0.02357483, -0.013931274, 0.02104187, -0.020584106, -0.039276123, -0.007255554, 0.029342651, 0.0045814514, 0.025894165, -0.00806427, 0.06842041, 0.0058555603, -0.042144775, 0.029586792, 0.024398804, -0.025238037, -0.066223145, -0.008895874, -0.006214142, -0.03817749, -0.011985779, 0.046081543, 0.005344391, -0.08782959, -0.021881104, -0.040039062, 0.009880066, -0.0033798218, -0.006000519, -0.0014600754, 0.024154663, -0.004058838, -0.11303711, -0.052734375, -0.07623291, 0.008300781, -0.043701172, -0.01687622, 0.018081665, 0.009590149, -0.024154663, -0.010467529, 0.030715942, 0.033233643, 0.010551453, 0.013267517, -0.033172607, 0.001455307, 0.026916504, 0.031707764, 0.016967773, -0.012184143, -0.04248047, -0.040374756, 0.05557251, -0.016342163, -0.032043457, -0.014678955, 0.019515991, -0.042022705, 0.03286743, -0.010948181, 0.029342651, 0.0138549805, -0.019515991, 0.0619812, 0.0051651, -0.041931152, -0.028945923, 0.013572693, -0.022232056, -0.03100586, 0.014831543, 0.007522583, -0.032470703, 0.005252838, -0.020019531, -0.0028266907, -0.018081665, -0.007545471, -0.0025863647, 0.013969421, 0.01600647, 0.0028018951, -0.04232788, -0.0007662773, 0.023986816, 0.014831543, 0.030578613, -0.059661865, 0.022613525, -0.03677368, -0.056243896, -0.037750244, -0.049713135, 0.01687622, -0.055267334, 0.03591919, 0.003627777, 0.019088745, -0.0054473877, -0.0018253326, -0.0345459, -0.066223145, 0.04336548, 0.010154724, -0.010414124, 0.038238525 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1907.04711v1
Data-driven Policy on Feasibility Determination for the Train Shunting Problem
Paulo R. de O. da Costa, J. Rhuggenaath, Y. Zhang, A. Akcay, W. Lee, U. Kaymak
cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Parking, matching, scheduling, and routing are common problems in train maintenance. In particular, train units are commonly maintained and cleaned at dedicated shunting yards. The planning problem that results from such situations is referred to as the Train Unit Shunting Problem (TUSP). This problem involves matching arriving train units to service tasks and determining the schedule for departing trains. The TUSP is an important problem as it is used to determine the capacity of shunting yards and arises as a sub-problem of more general scheduling and planning problems. In this paper, we consider the case of the Dutch Railways (NS) TUSP. As the TUSP is complex, NS currently uses a local search (LS) heuristic to determine if an instance of the TUSP has a feasible solution. Given the number of shunting yards and the size of the planning problems, improving the evaluation speed of the LS brings significant computational gain. In this work, we use a machine learning approach that complements the LS and accelerates the search process. We use a Deep Graph Convolutional Neural Network (DGCNN) model to predict the feasibility of solutions obtained during the run of the LS heuristic. We use this model to decide whether to continue or abort the search process. In this way, the computation time is used more efficiently as it is spent on instances that are more likely to be feasible. Using simulations based on real-life instances of the TUSP, we show how our approach improves upon the previous method on prediction accuracy and leads to computational gains for the decision-making process.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.04711v1
2019-07-10T13:32:14
2019-07-10T13:32:14
{ "title": [ 0.03262329, 0.0044898987, -0.0109939575, -0.011398315, -0.02293396, -0.03616333, 0.033447266, -0.017654419, -0.051971436, 0.019073486, -0.059417725, 0.040374756, -0.0012722015, -0.023101807, 0.040252686, -0.023117065, 0.011817932, 0.01272583, -0.010398865, -0.03161621, 0.0010900497, -0.023956299, 0.010269165, 0.054016113, 0.022735596, -0.00079393387, -0.053619385, -0.032348633, -0.0062179565, -0.03466797, 0.0010061264, 0.03967285, 0.032440186, -0.010261536, 0.033172607, 0.03665161, 0.01626587, -0.0011892319, 0.0071640015, 0.026870728, 0.009338379, -0.0060157776, 0.029464722, -0.007713318, -0.012130737, 0.013023376, -0.023025513, -0.012214661, -0.020935059, 0.0413208, -0.0026435852, -0.014701843, 0.015731812, 0.0597229, 0.00029683113, -0.016433716, -0.034973145, -0.028381348, 0.012237549, 0.019042969, 0.023849487, -0.009559631, 0.036956787, -0.013717651, 0.017028809, -0.055725098, 0.012771606, 0.03668213, 0.08746338, 0.020050049, -0.009414673, 0.05645752, -0.0004312992, 0.08477783, -0.054229736, -0.10247803, 0.08325195, 0.014350891, 0.010971069, 0.012367249, 0.014335632, -0.027404785, 0.032440186, 0.0017614365, -0.03060913, -0.0044898987, -0.0030956268, -0.0016727448, -0.0137786865, -0.042175293, -0.0064315796, 0.08270264, -0.017913818, -0.021728516, -0.03186035, -0.05783081, -0.00036668777, 0.050689697, -0.014511108, -0.029769897, -0.05130005, 0.018875122, -0.07183838, -0.03050232, 0.02885437, 0.043884277, -0.007183075, -0.031219482, 0.01348114, -0.003326416, -0.017959595, 0.00034976006, 0.030410767, -0.012779236, 0.0068206787, -0.010597229, -0.002981186, 0.012672424, 0.004211426, -0.032806396, -0.022155762, -0.011116028, -0.03564453, 0.036071777, 0.012168884, -0.0099105835, -0.015670776, 0.053527832, 0.029708862, 0.01727295, -0.000702858, 0.059509277, -0.06542969, -0.0848999, -0.06060791, 0.014564514, 0.010116577, -0.007736206, 0.010185242, -0.024383545, 0.066467285, -0.022644043, -0.0035057068, 0.064575195, 0.01058197, 0.013015747, 0.034729004, 0.019226074, -0.002937317, -0.028564453, 0.0104599, 0.0046081543, 0.0014476776, 0.00699234, -0.0014295578, -0.022003174, -0.038513184, -0.015838623, 0.052612305, -0.0038776398, 0.045135498, 0.009887695, 0.0010604858, 0.03048706, 0.024398804, -0.025787354, -0.0107040405, 0.005657196, -0.00037503242, 0.057678223, -0.020339966, 0.015144348, -0.030181885, -0.012680054, -0.011566162, -0.01574707, 0.0044898987, 0.010520935, -0.0055007935, -0.002325058, 0.020568848, -0.009498596, -0.044799805, 0.049438477, -0.033477783, -0.04168701, 0.002904892, -0.013824463, 0.024963379, 0.005180359, -0.0021457672, 0.038238525, -0.062805176, -0.04324341, -0.043914795, 0.00907135, -0.000330925, 0.0032634735, -0.004295349, 0.04675293, -0.011756897, 0.044555664, -0.042633057, 0.0418396, 0.011741638, -0.021850586, 0.03137207, -0.00020933151, -0.026901245, 0.03277588, 0.037139893, -0.016845703, -0.005176544, -0.005844116, 0.0036258698, -0.04144287, -0.0077552795, -0.06958008, -0.021499634, -0.012489319, -0.03375244, 0.026611328, -0.049682617, 0.025619507, -0.020645142, 0.030181885, 0.0023021698, 0.016815186, 0.059753418, 0.010932922, 0.14868164, -0.047210693, -0.009803772, 0.040618896, -0.00073862076, -0.009552002, 0.026321411, -0.011482239, 0.039245605, 0.009750366, 0.017303467, -0.045074463, 0.006969452, 0.032073975, 0.024536133, -0.0061950684, 0.0049972534, 0.007286072, 0.0031814575, -0.009719849, 0.121520996, 0.0064849854, 0.025970459, 0.072509766, 0.04058838, 0.011123657, -0.0096206665, -0.006164551, -0.0463562, 0.047180176, 0.026931763, 0.011154175, 0.0093688965, -0.011039734, 0.011276245, -0.014060974, -0.01763916, -0.011306763, -0.027389526, 0.013847351, 0.016281128, -0.053985596, 0.001964569, -0.014427185, -0.09777832, 0.039978027, -0.068725586, 0.06286621, 0.018432617, -0.029800415, -0.00024211407, 0.037841797, 0.059051514, -0.0053100586, -0.009140015, 0.049957275, 0.04486084, -0.0014820099, -0.06384277, -0.030151367, 0.027877808, 0.017715454, -0.017333984, -0.0155181885, 0.0063591003, -0.0030269623, -0.0026817322, 0.08099365, -0.029846191, 0.0135650635, -0.08337402, -0.015045166, 0.03353882, -0.056915283, 0.00894928, -0.012161255, 0.067871094, -0.047027588, -0.015075684, 0.026565552, -0.09362793, -0.014633179, 0.005886078, -0.022201538, 0.005493164, -0.0038051605, -0.0033950806, -0.0063056946, 0.009765625, 0.012802124, -0.021392822, -0.06225586, 0.009376526, -0.036590576, -0.027786255, 0.013534546, -0.034362793, 0.025283813, -0.042022705, -0.011039734, -0.029647827, -0.040130615, -0.08843994, 0.037506104, 0.011268616, 0.039276123, -0.021987915, 0.04397583, -0.017211914, -0.0045280457, -0.040252686, -0.013252258, -0.0020141602, -0.064453125, 0.01436615, -0.04525757, -0.011962891, -0.0211792, 0.011550903, 0.021347046, 0.007205963, 0.014968872, -0.039794922, -0.017333984, 0.0024929047, -0.0008749962, 0.045288086, 0.056793213, 0.021026611, -0.00484848, 0.035308838, 0.03805542, 0.007194519, -0.113708496, -0.026901245, -0.066711426, -0.022354126, -0.032318115, 0.01235199, 0.0031204224, -0.047698975, 0.0019817352, -0.010574341, 0.0126571655, 0.027328491, 0.01637268, 0.025482178, -0.018493652, -0.03668213, -0.007762909, 0.04269409, 0.019943237, -0.014877319, 0.022369385, 0.085876465, 0.012870789, 0.020141602, 0.02520752, 0.040405273, -0.004306793, -0.0104904175, -0.014907837, 0.01008606, -0.02519226, 0.024169922, 0.006729126, -0.033813477, 0.014457703, -0.03866577, 0.0076446533, 0.047851562, -0.020858765, -0.020690918, 0.019104004, -0.0390625, -0.0024757385, 0.019851685, -0.0059890747, 0.035888672, -0.0045318604, -0.013061523, 0.02947998, 0.041534424, -0.03555298, -0.0041618347, -0.035858154, -0.021118164, 0.02557373, -0.019119263, -0.036346436, 0.0178833, -0.017242432, -0.0014686584, -0.028442383, 0.018096924, 0.036865234, 0.055725098, -0.015312195, 0.009147644, 0.029678345, 0.049041748, -0.036010742, -0.0017108917, -0.014228821, 0.018722534, 0.043395996, -0.021240234, 0.04824829, -0.0113220215, 0.013595581, -0.037322998, -0.013702393, -0.009117126, 0.035369873, 0.010177612, -0.031921387, -0.033203125, -0.030227661, 0.004886627, 0.004295349, -0.031097412, 0.007129669, -0.016921997, -0.0022830963, -0.026489258, 0.021347046, 0.0033836365, 0.047790527, -0.0008664131, -0.0035495758, 0.03378296, -0.02583313, -0.05203247, 0.044067383, 0.00042414665, 0.039245605, 0.02017212, 0.016159058, -0.018035889, -0.0057678223, -0.01020813, -0.014831543, 0.013572693, -0.019500732, 0.0022830963, -0.04055786, 0.017913818, 0.011634827, 0.000073611736, -0.04257202, 0.037261963, 0.002861023, 0.025222778, -0.027267456, -0.021133423, 0.031219482, -0.07952881, -0.016540527, 0.0317688, 0.0020503998, -0.017669678, 0.00056409836, 0.006717682, 0.031143188, -0.0039711, 0.0061912537, 0.007457733, -0.0046958923, -0.00957489, -0.047943115, -0.0949707, 0.060455322, 0.008674622, 0.00166893, -0.0079956055, 0.015617371, 0.049957275, -0.019805908, 0.014709473, 0.0039100647, 0.031433105, -0.031799316, -0.0013856888, 0.02708435, -0.020965576, 0.019088745, 0.014732361, 0.052642822, -0.024139404, -0.02357483, 0.025177002, 0.025161743, -0.07647705, 0.029953003, 0.08734131, 0.0039138794, -0.101867676, 0.038269043, -0.01121521, -0.017791748, 0.016342163, -0.000834465, 0.009162903, 0.008628845, 0.039855957, 0.03881836, -0.009925842, -0.03213501, 0.011550903, 0.0009303093, 0.0043907166, -0.031341553, -0.032989502, 0.03149414, -0.0357666, 0.0184021, -0.037506104, 0.06317139, -0.01121521, 0.0149002075, 0.016983032, 0.014526367, -0.019012451, -0.024459839, -0.020645142, -0.044281006, -0.012229919, 0.007293701, -0.011940002, -0.021148682, 0.015914917, 0.023864746, -0.044921875, -0.0077323914, -0.017089844, 0.0053138733, -0.017471313, -0.048675537, -0.033447266, -0.0046310425, -0.07720947, -0.04168701, -0.025482178, 0.021575928, -0.01675415, 0.0047073364, -0.012504578, 0.0155181885, 0.011199951, -0.0064353943, 0.0023231506, 0.0071411133, 0.008674622, 0.034301758, -0.02658081, -0.029006958, -0.018554688, -0.002784729, -0.04309082, -0.03918457, 0.02180481, 0.012260437, -0.0141067505, -0.032989502, 0.0112838745, -0.016174316, 0.020263672, 0.02217102, 0.038879395, 0.020065308, -0.0010261536, -0.010635376, -0.00033640862, -0.03164673, 0.025253296, -0.0072364807, 0.019256592, 0.014312744, 0.0033435822, 0.046783447, -0.007904053, -0.04333496, 0.034729004, 0.0074920654, 0.039123535, 0.010314941, -0.011383057, 0.047912598, 0.01789856, -0.019989014, 0.01777649, -0.007572174, 0.014175415, -0.0423584, 0.017318726, -0.039489746, 0.00793457, -0.0062828064, -0.013504028, 0.0044517517, -0.01789856, 0.011192322, -0.04660034, -0.048706055, 0.00818634, 0.103271484, -0.045288086, -0.013618469, -0.036712646, -0.015419006, 0.03050232, 0.028671265, 0.0019168854, -0.032592773, 0.047851562, 0.0074157715, 0.009017944, 0.0065193176, -0.03338623, -0.010719299, -0.033203125, 0.013328552, -0.023162842, 0.012130737, -0.0096206665, -0.0031356812, 0.0028057098, 0.037261963, 0.0053482056, -0.006011963, 0.031585693, 0.06329346, -0.002784729, 0.0019416809, -0.015594482, 0.022415161, 0.07867432, 0.01953125, 0.015106201, -0.019699097, 0.016220093, -0.0045547485, -0.06604004, -0.011932373, 0.0256958, -0.025283813, 0.039764404, 0.038085938, -0.004447937, -0.07324219, 0.018814087, -0.018661499, 0.0056495667, -0.019683838, -0.021194458, 0.043701172, -0.025360107, -0.0027503967, 0.028366089, -0.033294678, -0.015106201, 0.021697998, -0.007133484, 0.011711121, -0.00969696, 0.009780884, -0.0072746277, 0.011665344, 0.027038574, -0.039215088, -0.018600464, 0.031158447, 0.019561768, 0.013504028, 0.01309967, 0.01727295, -0.034179688, -0.0073776245, -0.0073051453, 0.002822876, 0.016464233, 0.04598999, -0.052947998, -0.0079574585, 0.04928589, -0.030014038, -0.05392456, -0.016830444, -0.029403687, -0.006412506, -0.026275635, 0.00042676926, -0.0011796951, -0.03375244, 0.015213013, 0.02041626, -0.050201416, -0.0126953125, -0.003288269, 0.016052246, 0.003578186, 0.055511475, 0.030517578, -0.005947113, -0.009971619, -0.02192688, 0.061401367, 0.03668213, 0.020401001, -0.014831543, -0.026016235, -0.0074691772, 0.042114258, -0.016784668, -0.04812622, 0.003522873, 0.0134887695, 0.035461426, -0.0423584, -0.024673462, 0.03363037, -0.01146698, -0.047424316, -0.026473999, -0.0027942657, -0.034606934, 0.05609131, 0.0068855286, -0.044403076, -0.03567505, -0.04623413, -0.027999878, 0.010231018, 0.046325684, -0.0059432983, 0.045074463, -0.03225708, -0.011398315, -0.011962891, 0.0082473755, -0.029663086, 0.049072266, -0.007850647, -0.009185791, -0.013595581, -0.01576233, -0.014923096, 0.019180298, 0.02986145, 0.02772522, -0.025024414, 0.033355713, -0.028533936, -0.016540527, -0.0046081543, 0.013206482, 0.029541016, -0.017333984, 0.015144348, 0.03152466, -0.025665283, 0.011634827, 0.035980225, 0.050842285, 0.018630981, 0.010246277, 0.018371582, 0.029830933, -0.0064430237, -0.020980835, -0.009155273, -0.03677368, -0.021240234, -0.037384033, -0.018997192, -0.08166504, 0.022994995, -0.021896362, 0.021362305, 0.061676025, -0.0040626526, 0.06048584, 0.0035495758, -0.027709961, -0.01146698, 0.03390503, -0.011116028, -0.03186035, 0.00774765, 0.030685425, 0.010124207, 0.01878357, 0.02619934, 0.022064209, -0.018508911, -0.018554688, 0.032989502, -0.026794434, 0.028030396, 0.008804321, -0.016052246, -0.0038833618, -0.041168213, -0.02418518, -0.0052452087, 0.034698486, 0.037139893, -0.03387451, 0.027740479, 0.017059326, 0.04296875, -0.08251953, 0.07366943, 0.04650879, -0.05999756, 0.03555298, -0.039367676, -0.050811768, 0.04736328, 0.04574585, 0.03652954, -0.035949707, -0.00484848, 0.014984131, -0.00097322464, 0.003288269, 0.01701355, -0.027267456, -0.017211914, 0.023910522, 0.0025482178, -0.012107849, 0.016113281, 0.016357422, 0.040802002, -0.0052871704, -0.01852417, 0.008270264, -0.045928955, 0.016036987, 0.03668213, -0.027114868, 0.036193848, -0.025756836, -0.039093018, 0.008232117, 0.006336212, -0.035064697, -0.0015096664, -0.0362854, 0.030578613, 0.01953125, 0.045043945, 0.016998291, -0.0047340393, -0.013893127, 0.0004079342, 0.038269043, 0.038391113, -0.014251709, 0.027786255, -0.035980225, -0.03656006, 0.050048828, -0.048614502, 0.014808655, -0.014785767, 0.027282715, -0.06573486, 0.04547119, -0.04916382, -0.036834717, -0.006374359, -0.02760315, -0.011123657, -0.008460999, -0.028945923, -0.0030670166, -0.012573242, -0.012969971, 0.03845215, 0.070617676, 0.014465332, 0.036865234, -0.01928711, -0.035217285, 0.036315918, -0.0012378693, 0.0713501, 0.023605347, -0.01663208, 0.004337311, -0.0006222725, 0.023239136, -0.032104492, -0.039642334, -0.022705078, -0.015419006, -0.046173096, 0.022476196, 0.00969696, -0.0076560974, 0.003929138, 0.0021133423, -0.00049352646, -0.008491516, 0.023880005, 0.04333496, 0.004425049, -0.059692383, -0.0038452148, -0.034973145, 0.0018281937, -0.030258179, -0.007255554, 0.009788513, 0.022140503, -0.008453369, -0.0060424805, -0.0044059753, 0.0053367615, -0.012382507, -0.02809143, -0.048187256, 0.042907715, 0.044799805, -0.03125, -0.08282471, 0.026992798, 0.07122803, -0.038848877, 0.043914795, -0.004085541, -0.0019369125, -0.0010471344, 0.066223145, -0.0015258789, -0.0073928833, -0.024017334, -0.009284973, 0.019592285, 0.007270813, -0.020339966, -0.026519775, 0.009735107, 0.009048462, 0.013618469, -0.021011353, 0.00038838387, -0.0018663406, -0.033081055, -0.010314941, -0.019897461, 0.011871338, 0.0041999817, 0.025024414, -0.019744873, -0.014190674, 0.019958496, 0.0052337646, -0.015556335, 0.0435791, 0.025375366, -0.015197754, 0.014976501, 0.03201294, 0.018341064, 0.0015153885, 0.0004963875, -0.033477783, 0.0027484894, -0.024734497, -0.009490967, -0.02142334, 0.054138184, -0.057678223, -0.028030396, -0.017440796, -0.007419586, -0.0031604767, -0.011924744, 0.053619385, -0.021484375, -0.005378723, -0.0059165955, -0.046142578, 0.02130127, -0.02355957, -0.027053833, -0.0059127808, -0.04373169, 0.012054443, -0.02166748, 0.0024032593 ], "summary": [ 0.038330078, 0.0068893433, 0.022094727, -0.0034694672, -0.017196655, -0.02407837, 0.013435364, -0.044281006, -0.0127334595, 0.008110046, -0.05960083, 0.032714844, -0.007209778, -0.015289307, 0.03918457, -0.03781128, 0.020629883, 0.0019454956, -0.018325806, -0.03817749, 0.00025725365, -0.030288696, -0.00434494, 0.08203125, 0.024780273, -0.052886963, 0.013587952, 0.035827637, -0.0068206787, -0.00258255, 0.02178955, 0.0056610107, 0.015457153, -0.02796936, 0.059295654, -0.030395508, 0.018417358, -0.009941101, 0.016418457, 0.0050315857, 0.0028896332, 0.008850098, 0.054595947, -0.012329102, -0.01876831, 0.024780273, -0.018920898, -0.011558533, 0.013671875, 0.006450653, -0.034301758, -0.03579712, -0.031921387, -0.0030059814, 0.009208679, 0.016693115, -0.026535034, -0.043548584, -0.011222839, 0.04486084, 0.035491943, -0.0036582947, 0.030212402, -0.005870819, -0.020889282, -0.040496826, 0.033172607, 0.026397705, 0.05239868, -0.03881836, -0.0030288696, 0.074035645, -0.0071029663, 0.04119873, -0.050689697, -0.07354736, 0.052764893, -0.035888672, 0.00057554245, 0.03302002, -0.01322937, 0.013519287, -0.019729614, -0.0014867783, -0.0473938, -0.00856781, -0.019500732, -0.0048179626, -0.038085938, -0.0032138824, -0.026229858, 0.021606445, -0.072021484, 0.024841309, 0.014305115, -0.03253174, -0.030853271, -0.026687622, 0.000992775, 0.012321472, 0.018478394, -0.032226562, 0.0063171387, -0.022903442, -0.006816864, 0.06524658, 0.008483887, -0.04046631, -0.009063721, -0.012588501, 0.00079774857, -0.05819702, 0.021636963, -0.053375244, -0.011795044, 0.025680542, 0.033477783, 0.00605011, 0.034606934, -0.059387207, -0.011314392, 0.0024337769, -0.07312012, 0.017852783, 0.018676758, -0.027328491, -0.01348114, 0.087646484, -0.003698349, 0.008003235, -0.007858276, 0.035827637, -0.022232056, -0.022659302, -0.0335083, -0.0030441284, 0.016860962, -0.01524353, 0.029022217, 0.0032844543, 0.007980347, -0.03704834, -0.0135650635, 0.054534912, 0.016113281, 0.0287323, 0.021392822, -0.000087082386, 0.0008611679, 0.0020256042, -0.011459351, -0.027374268, 0.027526855, -0.033813477, -0.031341553, -0.06542969, -0.091430664, 0.004398346, 0.0440979, -0.0043411255, 0.029159546, 0.021636963, 0.016494751, 0.00970459, 0.009887695, -0.04824829, -0.0038890839, -0.0010871887, 0.0013513565, -0.02331543, -0.01360321, 0.034851074, -0.037353516, -0.008506775, 0.011360168, -0.015617371, -0.01448822, 0.030899048, 0.019973755, -0.01928711, 0.022201538, -0.019012451, 0.03668213, 0.041870117, -0.019241333, 0.00944519, 0.0009675026, 0.008666992, 0.008888245, -0.009918213, 0.0103302, 0.039215088, -0.0063095093, -0.027374268, 0.011001587, -0.00944519, -0.020584106, -0.012367249, 0.0057258606, 0.0057144165, 0.023223877, 0.03173828, -0.014373779, -0.00957489, -0.003458023, -0.00070762634, 0.008781433, 0.01461792, -0.045898438, -0.0008802414, 0.044433594, -0.020935059, -0.02406311, 0.012451172, 0.010787964, -0.038116455, 0.0030612946, -0.06567383, 0.0013818741, -0.015838623, 0.0028419495, 0.034118652, -0.038726807, 0.04333496, -0.03427124, 0.055603027, -0.028198242, 0.057525635, 0.015472412, 0.031921387, 0.08117676, -0.03656006, 0.0015668869, 0.058166504, -0.005519867, 0.0010414124, 0.037872314, 0.017791748, 0.022094727, -0.016052246, 0.008659363, -0.02798462, 0.0007305145, 0.03591919, 0.02583313, 0.0023975372, -0.0011920929, 0.011581421, -0.0062332153, 0.017410278, 0.06756592, 0.004299164, 0.01474762, 0.042541504, 0.021942139, -0.006164551, -0.0068969727, -0.0077590942, -0.016113281, -0.011947632, 0.01209259, -0.08288574, -0.02911377, -0.035369873, 0.040649414, -0.0690918, -0.020233154, -0.035308838, -0.027175903, -0.013076782, 0.026107788, -0.05429077, 0.013580322, -0.009155273, -0.11846924, 0.0027046204, -0.038085938, 0.05227661, 0.035736084, -0.042388916, -0.04006958, -0.011886597, -0.01033783, -0.016082764, 0.025726318, -0.02494812, 0.0018978119, -0.031341553, -0.019851685, 0.022369385, 0.03451538, 0.032989502, -0.0073013306, -0.0021305084, 0.0028419495, -0.00016367435, -0.0546875, 0.06524658, -0.019714355, 0.0077171326, -0.054138184, 0.012268066, 0.012168884, -0.044128418, 0.02960205, 0.012367249, 0.072631836, -0.0023555756, 0.020980835, 0.0017175674, -0.046966553, -0.061035156, 0.0032958984, 0.023162842, -0.009925842, -0.004634857, -0.008544922, 0.021728516, -0.0082092285, 0.015853882, -0.0078086853, -0.05126953, -0.031341553, 0.02458191, -0.044128418, 0.005607605, 0.050720215, -0.00072431564, -0.03012085, -0.0018548965, -0.051940918, -0.041259766, -0.043548584, 0.057250977, -0.014892578, 0.005722046, -0.0055389404, 0.04034424, -0.01826477, -0.017059326, 0.0009832382, 0.021118164, 0.011787415, -0.022445679, -0.020004272, 0.0012111664, 0.0018548965, 0.0014657974, 0.03994751, 0.0033664703, 0.009017944, -0.02758789, -0.03173828, 0.038879395, -0.005695343, 0.06756592, 0.051361084, 0.054748535, 0.028625488, -0.017745972, 0.011169434, 0.0032043457, -0.017959595, -0.06414795, -0.020248413, -0.010871887, 0.0027809143, -0.017684937, 0.013633728, -0.011657715, 0.020858765, -0.005214691, -0.02180481, -0.010345459, 0.02822876, -0.00027918816, 0.08581543, 0.007972717, -0.0069847107, 0.03857422, 0.015670776, 0.011260986, -0.035369873, -0.032318115, 0.06323242, 0.008255005, -0.021408081, 0.042938232, 0.0050201416, 0.0025119781, -0.005756378, 0.028274536, -0.009117126, -0.023727417, -0.0011520386, 0.026885986, -0.03640747, -0.028366089, -0.00086927414, -0.014350891, 0.014694214, -0.018676758, 0.011192322, -0.012680054, -0.012634277, 0.035461426, -0.0079422, 0.008338928, 0.036987305, -0.0025539398, 0.016143799, -0.050109863, 0.022079468, -0.06329346, -0.004306793, -0.01625061, -0.009124756, -0.00026583672, -0.0067634583, -0.010917664, -0.012550354, 0.04736328, 0.017028809, 0.04043579, 0.04776001, 0.028945923, 0.0071258545, -0.05206299, 0.0060653687, 0.037841797, 0.033233643, -0.013549805, 0.010688782, 0.01953125, -0.034088135, 0.033416748, -0.01071167, -0.024047852, 0.034210205, -0.05041504, -0.01864624, 0.020751953, 0.017532349, 0.037506104, -0.000910759, 0.00048327446, 0.0118255615, -0.030014038, -0.01109314, 0.044677734, -0.058166504, 0.003238678, -0.021911621, 0.034729004, -0.04156494, -0.019561768, -0.03173828, 0.011550903, 0.043914795, -0.023391724, 0.015792847, -0.0026817322, -0.1026001, 0.01247406, -0.0053863525, 0.04208374, -0.029815674, 0.022109985, -0.0010538101, -0.026260376, -0.007293701, 0.0003068447, 0.0045776367, -0.031341553, -0.010421753, -0.031799316, 0.068603516, -0.013725281, 0.028060913, -0.0690918, -0.023132324, 0.008010864, -0.029220581, -0.016616821, 0.011497498, -0.0071411133, -0.015060425, -0.0025463104, 0.003282547, 0.066711426, -0.0065612793, 0.0385437, 0.027496338, 0.03756714, -0.008094788, 0.039154053, -0.004966736, -0.011016846, -0.0019779205, -0.04046631, -0.038360596, 0.016906738, 0.042907715, 0.009262085, -0.03488159, 0.05871582, 0.015098572, -0.016143799, -0.015396118, -0.09075928, -0.0066871643, -0.064819336, -0.036376953, 0.019012451, -0.032958984, 0.051086426, -0.028808594, 0.094055176, -0.044921875, -0.04748535, -0.023529053, 0.048217773, -0.022384644, 0.012634277, -0.0003414154, 0.026550293, -0.04837036, 0.078430176, 0.008392334, -0.011886597, 0.029022217, 0.003458023, 0.0022716522, 0.02418518, 0.003479004, -0.0048103333, -0.03277588, -0.05114746, -0.028121948, 0.015289307, -0.013259888, -0.027542114, -0.0068511963, 0.04611206, -0.03564453, 0.027145386, -0.016204834, 0.026275635, -0.0007519722, -0.026916504, 0.022750854, 0.03274536, -0.0463562, -0.07305908, 0.0018415451, 0.01876831, 0.06298828, -0.045135498, -0.029693604, 0.023788452, 0.03466797, 0.027008057, -0.0022392273, -0.03967285, 0.030227661, 0.02128601, -0.06640625, -0.104003906, -0.067993164, 0.012084961, -0.064697266, 0.0024375916, -0.057739258, -0.052703857, -0.039276123, 0.0023460388, 0.018997192, 0.030380249, 0.015579224, -0.0031261444, -0.006996155, 0.004257202, -0.00016784668, 0.060516357, -0.03253174, -0.015686035, 0.012397766, -0.005847931, -0.008285522, -0.0071640015, 0.02960205, -0.024215698, -0.025482178, -0.015281677, 0.012748718, 0.011070251, 0.0152282715, 0.009017944, 0.07397461, 0.020721436, -0.021270752, 0.0004172325, 0.023422241, -0.012001038, -0.0015001297, -0.00054836273, -0.03579712, -0.009086609, -0.015792847, 0.08074951, -0.00907135, -0.017089844, 0.047851562, -0.050079346, 0.06854248, 0.015777588, -0.007217407, 0.038604736, 0.03414917, -0.04586792, 0.011352539, -0.00042581558, -0.03366089, 0.006225586, -0.03201294, -0.013305664, 0.039398193, 0.0014276505, -0.019454956, 0.034851074, 0.011512756, 0.015808105, -0.05670166, -0.057891846, -0.018081665, 0.08905029, -0.03930664, -0.030578613, -0.056610107, -0.051239014, 0.014205933, 0.0020484924, -0.037628174, -0.016082764, 0.024978638, -0.008659363, -0.010353088, 0.0000641346, -0.01576233, -0.030471802, 0.022766113, 0.017471313, -0.033843994, 0.018249512, 0.019760132, -0.015716553, 0.012290955, 0.045440674, 0.032806396, -0.007446289, -0.00447464, 0.06726074, -0.012138367, -0.045013428, 0.014923096, -0.00034928322, 0.0015602112, 0.011123657, -0.018218994, 0.016326904, -0.022628784, -0.016860962, 0.0031967163, 0.0022945404, 0.03753662, 0.0021705627, -0.029418945, 0.017059326, -0.031707764, -0.012275696, 0.0010700226, -0.033996582, -0.004962921, -0.007843018, -0.009796143, 0.01838684, 0.008460999, 0.02293396, 0.028305054, 0.0015354156, -0.023971558, -0.03805542, 0.010932922, -0.07055664, -0.026123047, -0.013496399, -0.015419006, -0.011505127, 0.016937256, -0.060821533, -0.028579712, 0.026611328, -0.0010242462, -0.0028877258, -0.047576904, -0.012893677, -0.0034332275, 0.029067993, -0.027114868, -0.0047683716, 0.012969971, 0.030441284, -0.070495605, -0.0016946793, -0.026504517, -0.029129028, -0.079956055, -0.02041626, 0.0034389496, 0.044311523, -0.03475952, 0.0368042, 0.009819031, -0.05606079, 0.011657715, 0.0012483597, -0.06903076, -0.03387451, 0.00004041195, -0.004020691, 0.023208618, 0.028121948, -0.015991211, 0.01889038, 0.023773193, -0.014266968, 0.011734009, 0.025482178, 0.025115967, -0.016357422, -0.049591064, 0.000012457371, 0.02746582, 0.008972168, 0.03463745, 0.010116577, 0.015342712, 0.01977539, -0.029083252, 0.022644043, 0.0048980713, -0.031555176, -0.05987549, 0.0065193176, -0.002729416, -0.004711151, 0.049560547, 0.042388916, -0.05441284, -0.020355225, -0.013664246, -0.009979248, -0.014892578, 0.008529663, -0.03656006, 0.0042152405, -0.031463623, -0.039794922, -0.016784668, -0.0009212494, -0.011352539, -0.008132935, -0.0003528595, 0.012046814, 0.026153564, -0.003004074, 0.0013809204, 0.014709473, 0.026870728, 0.00007933378, -0.04748535, 0.057006836, -0.013366699, 0.007987976, -0.011154175, 0.009727478, 0.046661377, -0.016311646, 0.043792725, 0.046539307, -0.011688232, -0.004852295, 0.023742676, 0.026901245, 0.012825012, -0.020950317, -0.013824463, 0.004508972, 0.025360107, -0.037078857, 0.03363037, -0.0073623657, -0.029571533, -0.06512451, -0.047698975, -0.020019531, 0.06561279, -0.06567383, 0.025009155, 0.0826416, 0.010536194, 0.05911255, 0.028030396, -0.03253174, 0.006023407, 0.03262329, -0.013000488, -0.0368042, 0.017227173, 0.011642456, 0.02619934, 0.04611206, 0.03439331, -0.010650635, -0.0050582886, -0.0059127808, 0.011695862, -0.0021896362, 0.010803223, -0.016799927, 0.0012207031, -0.022079468, -0.03439331, -0.020080566, 0.005859375, 0.03552246, 0.017700195, 0.00016736984, 0.003358841, 0.017211914, 0.02394104, -0.09240723, 0.076416016, 0.009849548, -0.034179688, -0.00907135, -0.017410278, 0.002084732, 0.035888672, 0.0053253174, 0.054473877, -0.055358887, -0.048034668, 0.04244995, 0.015022278, -0.013183594, 0.013061523, -0.019515991, 0.004043579, 0.052856445, 0.005168915, 0.004070282, 0.008041382, -0.0026607513, 0.021728516, 0.0059661865, -0.029922485, 0.035705566, -0.048828125, 0.060302734, 0.037353516, -0.00894165, 0.0002465248, -0.026062012, -0.029937744, -0.009254456, 0.0075035095, -0.011413574, -0.030532837, 0.047729492, 0.029205322, 0.04916382, 0.0657959, -0.003047943, 0.020462036, 0.0042152405, 0.01625061, 0.023132324, 0.0055351257, -0.008346558, 0.010726929, -0.0054016113, -0.008728027, 0.05105591, -0.020507812, 0.04257202, -0.020614624, -0.020385742, -0.0357666, 0.013786316, -0.0284729, -0.0053901672, 0.014221191, -0.07409668, -0.024017334, -0.025177002, -0.035369873, -0.022903442, -0.019439697, -0.049926758, 0.03616333, 0.012664795, -0.025466919, -0.0079956055, 0.01927185, -0.02848816, -0.046722412, -0.016708374, -0.0041275024, -0.024719238, -0.03503418, 0.023895264, 0.0015535355, 0.0513916, -0.043304443, -0.04953003, -0.01309967, 0.05267334, -0.046081543, 0.029510498, 0.02734375, -0.022659302, -0.035247803, -0.0040016174, 0.0018424988, -0.027389526, 0.000008583069, 0.036895752, 0.00046157837, 0.019302368, 0.009300232, -0.012138367, 0.0054016113, -0.031921387, -0.012268066, 0.033172607, 0.00011694431, 0.0034885406, -0.00008356571, 0.010299683, 0.008888245, -0.039978027, -0.02822876, -0.0072021484, 0.013687134, 0.024871826, -0.026367188, -0.02671814, 0.01335907, 0.023864746, -0.012580872, 0.042816162, -0.047332764, 0.0064888, 0.04071045, 0.10614014, 0.030166626, -0.03878784, -0.04360962, -0.036254883, 0.0055389404, -0.021911621, -0.012145996, -0.023086548, 0.01739502, -0.031173706, -0.0007472038, -0.03302002, -0.013381958, -0.03866577, -0.0513916, -0.091552734, -0.03665161, 0.0052337646, 0.002067566, 0.009666443, -0.016479492, -0.029769897, 0.015853882, -0.010696411, -0.024963379, 0.029510498, 0.0037059784, -0.0044517517, -0.017166138, 0.014839172, 0.004940033, 0.01574707, -0.012535095, -0.017196655, 0.018829346, -0.023361206, -0.020248413, -0.021057129, 0.052703857, -0.050964355, -0.047821045, 0.00068616867, -0.01940918, 0.040527344, -0.023208618, 0.077697754, 0.010787964, -0.03012085, 0.039916992, -0.051940918, 0.030319214, -0.024169922, -0.009414673, -0.015380859, -0.01838684, -0.032073975, -0.025863647, 0.016403198 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1907.09065v1
Accelerating Experimental Design by Incorporating Experimenter Hunches
Cheng Li, Santu Rana, Sunil Gupta, Vu Nguyen, Svetha Venkatesh, Alessandra Sutti, David Rubin, Teo Slezak, Murray Height, Mazher Mohammed, Ian Gibson
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG
Experimental design is a process of obtaining a product with target property via experimentation. Bayesian optimization offers a sample-efficient tool for experimental design when experiments are expensive. Often, expert experimenters have 'hunches' about the behavior of the experimental system, offering potentials to further improve the efficiency. In this paper, we consider per-variable monotonic trend in the underlying property that results in a unimodal trend in those variables for a target value optimization. For example, sweetness of a candy is monotonic to the sugar content. However, to obtain a target sweetness, the utility of the sugar content becomes a unimodal function, which peaks at the value giving the target sweetness and falls off both ways. In this paper, we propose a novel method to solve such problems that achieves two main objectives: a) the monotonicity information is used to the fullest extent possible, whilst ensuring that b) the convergence guarantee remains intact. This is achieved by a two-stage Gaussian process modeling, where the first stage uses the monotonicity trend to model the underlying property, and the second stage uses `virtual' samples, sampled from the first, to model the target value optimization function. The process is made theoretically consistent by adding appropriate adjustment factor in the posterior computation, necessitated because of using the `virtual' samples. The proposed method is evaluated through both simulations and real world experimental design problems of a) new short polymer fiber with the target length, and b) designing of a new three dimensional porous scaffolding with a target porosity. In all scenarios our method demonstrates faster convergence than the basic Bayesian optimization approach not using such `hunches'.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.09065v1
2019-07-22T00:48:24
2019-07-22T00:48:24
{ "title": [ -0.024215698, 0.0021896362, -0.051605225, -0.004989624, -0.008934021, -0.029663086, -0.010765076, -0.033996582, -0.016983032, 0.017684937, -0.0015296936, 0.015136719, -0.02420044, -0.026977539, -0.012992859, 0.0054740906, 0.011856079, 0.017868042, -0.023971558, -0.043273926, -0.025619507, -0.04559326, 0.024337769, 0.051757812, 0.031066895, 0.017791748, -0.06768799, 0.011520386, -0.03314209, -0.018447876, -0.010726929, 0.0104904175, 0.048065186, 0.033233643, -0.020111084, 0.019302368, -0.015182495, 0.013496399, -0.003129959, 0.025390625, 0.012588501, 0.0005059242, -0.045043945, -0.0625, -0.034088135, -0.03878784, -0.0042495728, -0.0068969727, -0.03262329, 0.03466797, 0.02229309, -0.011802673, -0.00039863586, 0.034454346, 0.016723633, -0.0231781, -0.0070610046, -0.018707275, 0.046417236, 0.05895996, -0.003643036, -0.05657959, 0.024719238, -0.037597656, -0.00970459, -0.02507019, -0.016815186, 0.041107178, 0.10101318, 0.041931152, -0.030456543, 0.020736694, -0.010757446, 0.036346436, -0.05557251, -0.035003662, 0.06518555, -0.0018758774, 0.019546509, -0.0071792603, -0.021102905, -0.028808594, -0.012969971, -0.02305603, 0.008003235, -0.038085938, -0.029190063, -0.0030021667, -0.009735107, -0.062469482, -0.0031795502, 0.030151367, -0.0006122589, 0.0017366409, -0.050231934, -0.0184021, -0.04260254, -0.020431519, 0.033599854, -0.0008740425, 0.013648987, -0.0074386597, -0.010574341, -0.0059814453, 0.013092041, 0.016708374, -0.013381958, -0.008575439, 0.017486572, 0.03274536, -0.017791748, 0.032470703, -0.015563965, -0.00409317, 0.01626587, 0.015296936, -0.015930176, 0.003873825, -0.002986908, 0.00074243546, 0.005836487, -0.016998291, 0.018493652, 0.013580322, 0.0345459, 0.020095825, -0.04550171, -0.012779236, -0.0309906, 0.010910034, -0.011192322, 0.029708862, -0.06866455, -0.035461426, -0.021209717, 0.021316528, 0.0029010773, -0.0064849854, 0.005130768, -0.010627747, -0.0066337585, -0.013389587, 0.031799316, -0.005847931, 0.015899658, 0.04598999, 0.064453125, -0.04647827, -0.042022705, -0.022369385, -0.055541992, 0.015686035, 0.02166748, 0.008110046, -0.056732178, -0.0093688965, -0.12609863, 0.006462097, 0.039031982, -0.0017118454, 0.004386902, -0.0042037964, -0.0155181885, -0.0015459061, 0.036376953, 0.018585205, -0.010475159, 0.040130615, 0.002231598, 0.06970215, -0.030563354, -0.0036525726, -0.010688782, -0.02456665, -0.023117065, 0.0067253113, 0.037017822, 0.009086609, 0.025283813, -0.025161743, -0.0022735596, -0.025558472, 0.03189087, 0.033172607, -0.05831909, -0.040283203, -0.007843018, -0.021636963, 0.053466797, 0.014884949, -0.020355225, 0.018859863, -0.06048584, -0.048858643, -0.026123047, -0.010520935, 0.010383606, 0.012451172, -0.0021858215, 0.024383545, -0.034606934, 0.0009975433, -0.04446411, 0.029449463, 0.0054244995, -0.029006958, 0.012260437, 0.0038013458, 0.017623901, 0.04446411, 0.026641846, 0.021347046, -0.028076172, -0.0035171509, -0.042266846, -0.058776855, 0.0158844, 0.010047913, 0.009651184, 0.0046844482, 0.0015859604, -0.016952515, 0.019363403, 0.05984497, 0.01600647, -0.008239746, 0.014595032, -0.041229248, 0.055877686, 0.02243042, 0.04989624, -0.042663574, 0.018661499, 0.036743164, 0.03186035, 0.010437012, 0.031021118, -0.023132324, 0.0043678284, -0.0034275055, 0.008132935, 0.01109314, 0.012313843, 0.037384033, 0.024612427, -0.0020942688, 0.026443481, 0.00033473969, 0.026184082, 0.030059814, 0.030517578, 0.030014038, 0.064086914, 0.020950317, 0.02458191, 0.069885254, -0.00023460388, 0.022964478, 0.00548172, 0.022262573, -0.014854431, 0.0309906, 0.016021729, 0.0037059784, -0.009239197, -0.014007568, -0.020095825, 0.0259552, -0.00086307526, 0.021728516, 0.037597656, -0.029937744, 0.00504303, -0.019256592, -0.039123535, -0.03591919, -0.013404846, 0.04660034, -0.025634766, -0.07562256, -0.008476257, 0.014587402, 0.045806885, 0.004951477, 0.012275696, 0.019454956, 0.018798828, -0.012496948, 0.010574341, -0.0025615692, 0.08343506, -0.014007568, -0.016189575, 0.0014429092, -0.016220093, -0.021362305, 0.05810547, 0.07574463, -0.03869629, 0.047454834, -0.05935669, 0.017730713, 0.056427002, -0.04776001, 0.013587952, 0.04119873, 0.028533936, 0.03366089, -0.007408142, 0.026062012, -0.038146973, 0.018127441, 0.01586914, -0.025177002, 0.008575439, -0.026901245, 0.024810791, -0.009338379, 0.018554688, -0.002035141, 0.04840088, -0.010681152, -0.037902832, -0.023956299, 0.011001587, -0.007331848, -0.041870117, -0.031585693, -0.034698486, 0.024093628, 0.0637207, 0.01927185, -0.03857422, -0.062469482, -0.01725769, 0.0020217896, -0.01966858, 0.014587402, -0.03555298, 0.02809143, -0.016067505, -0.04083252, 0.04055786, -0.0602417, 0.009811401, -0.039520264, -0.017486572, 0.028518677, -0.018951416, 0.005924225, 0.009101868, -0.029663086, -0.021484375, 0.016067505, 0.059936523, -0.053894043, -0.014984131, 0.04928589, 0.03302002, -0.0041160583, 0.056793213, -0.000040888786, -0.0033435822, -0.05407715, 0.008926392, -0.06439209, -0.0115737915, -0.0602417, 0.015838623, 0.057006836, -0.027023315, -0.0011949539, -0.051483154, -0.005054474, -0.0038471222, 0.0012836456, -0.032714844, -0.047058105, -0.008735657, -0.03527832, 0.0017347336, 0.013420105, -0.01675415, 0.0016736984, 0.1262207, -0.013900757, -0.0028152466, 0.039215088, 0.039245605, 0.014091492, -0.025405884, -0.022872925, -0.057861328, 0.0036621094, -0.0021095276, 0.017028809, 0.022964478, 0.0012588501, -0.08087158, -0.0090789795, 0.029190063, -0.008239746, -0.014968872, -0.010093689, -0.05496216, -0.0070648193, -0.03378296, -0.0027675629, 0.023361206, 0.07330322, -0.010032654, 0.0024471283, 0.0024757385, -0.013061523, 0.008178711, -0.0082473755, -0.057495117, 0.03845215, -0.03805542, -0.04083252, 0.0051879883, -0.007820129, -0.03564453, -0.015602112, 0.0029640198, 0.057739258, 0.015960693, 0.014457703, 0.011688232, -0.028152466, 0.011413574, -0.017059326, -0.0146865845, -0.013328552, -0.01789856, 0.00034546852, -0.011955261, 0.021087646, 0.023864746, -0.020950317, -0.024627686, -0.015487671, -0.017486572, 0.03353882, -0.012496948, -0.019638062, -0.013458252, -0.019454956, 0.026275635, 0.0024433136, -0.020141602, -0.026885986, 0.007820129, 0.0012865067, -0.028427124, 0.075683594, 0.045562744, 0.009376526, 0.009735107, -0.021606445, 0.012481689, -0.017654419, -0.092285156, 0.013084412, 0.0005764961, -0.0067253113, 0.07495117, -0.03881836, -0.032287598, 0.01890564, -0.10095215, 0.045013428, 0.014190674, 0.011459351, 0.00484848, 0.028457642, -0.031036377, 0.004764557, -0.036010742, 0.008155823, 0.02571106, -0.0029697418, 0.03982544, -0.06616211, 0.0032806396, 0.014457703, -0.11645508, -0.027542114, 0.0013370514, -0.00844574, -0.04989624, -0.033477783, 0.015823364, -0.041107178, -0.039886475, 0.012207031, -0.0084991455, -0.039001465, 0.004173279, -0.05291748, -0.03262329, 0.068603516, 0.0011692047, 0.021560669, 0.020828247, -0.018432617, -0.014381409, -0.049682617, 0.016204834, -0.00074863434, 0.039215088, -0.015357971, 0.014389038, 0.033233643, -0.029708862, 0.050079346, -0.00026082993, 0.006198883, 0.0036067963, 0.007850647, 0.04888916, 0.03753662, -0.02720642, 0.04147339, 0.051116943, -0.016326904, -0.06530762, -0.013900757, -0.017807007, 0.017623901, -0.0049438477, 0.020690918, 0.03579712, -0.013694763, 0.018600464, 0.01676941, -0.024093628, -0.0039711, 0.017700195, -0.0030784607, -0.02494812, -0.006298065, 0.025970459, 0.028182983, 0.009895325, 0.015396118, -0.008277893, 0.036956787, 0.015975952, -0.032562256, 0.006816864, 0.020706177, -0.039794922, -0.004142761, -0.0690918, -0.05532837, -0.025299072, 0.013793945, -0.03366089, 0.037322998, 0.02293396, -0.018417358, -0.009597778, -0.0061187744, 0.056854248, -0.00067949295, 0.021087646, -0.036102295, 0.028289795, -0.003578186, -0.051940918, -0.052368164, -0.014442444, 0.008430481, 0.015068054, -0.003414154, -0.029129028, 0.011917114, 0.008285522, 0.04144287, 0.038604736, -0.008720398, -0.03845215, 0.0032730103, -0.006450653, -0.026321411, -0.005115509, -0.0075035095, -0.0055656433, -0.043395996, 0.00070905685, -0.0065689087, 0.004753113, -0.02973938, 0.010917664, -0.014030457, 0.026885986, -0.029663086, 0.006072998, 0.01878357, 0.010917664, -0.014717102, 0.0070533752, -0.032196045, 0.018066406, -0.0020046234, 0.05569458, -0.015068054, 0.016326904, 0.00233078, 0.012374878, 0.0018577576, -0.004272461, 0.033966064, 0.010429382, -0.03062439, -0.015319824, 0.008392334, -0.020767212, -0.010375977, 0.023880005, 0.007030487, 0.055267334, -0.028137207, 0.066101074, -0.025253296, 0.026565552, 0.002281189, -0.017074585, 0.020004272, -0.037506104, 0.03765869, -0.078186035, -0.08483887, -0.023162842, 0.08843994, -0.047973633, -0.0317688, 0.00365448, 0.043426514, 0.017868042, 0.040771484, 0.041107178, 0.015792847, 0.018249512, -0.005302429, 0.018707275, 0.0033626556, -0.066833496, 0.026245117, -0.01751709, 0.025146484, -0.08459473, 0.040496826, -0.044128418, -0.0039024353, 0.0029468536, -0.015792847, 0.0032157898, -0.07867432, 0.018432617, 0.04171753, 0.005458832, 0.027359009, 0.0018596649, 0.024780273, 0.05026245, 0.052947998, 0.024749756, -0.012069702, 0.041625977, 0.021255493, -0.015975952, -0.032104492, 0.026382446, 0.0067329407, 0.02848816, 0.021591187, 0.03451538, -0.082336426, 0.019348145, 0.04031372, 0.0072746277, 0.008148193, -0.05303955, 0.0126571655, 0.03591919, -0.0018625259, 0.01651001, -0.03314209, -0.018829346, 0.03527832, -0.026947021, -0.019622803, 0.023803711, -0.0020656586, -0.0063438416, -0.04095459, -0.0010604858, -0.018600464, 0.04043579, 0.0000783205, 0.0040893555, -0.028579712, 0.03567505, 0.022476196, -0.040527344, -0.030548096, -0.023086548, -0.0052223206, 0.020095825, 0.02734375, -0.031555176, -0.0061454773, 0.0054626465, -0.029464722, 0.032196045, 0.011474609, 0.0041275024, -0.015701294, -0.0026683807, -0.029754639, 0.038757324, 0.035369873, 0.049041748, 0.049194336, -0.032043457, 0.040252686, 0.01348114, -0.00025701523, 0.0033187866, 0.040618896, -0.01209259, -0.0052261353, 0.013420105, -0.028366089, 0.019210815, -0.016220093, -0.044158936, -0.0014839172, -0.06591797, 0.006855011, -0.0020122528, -0.0071487427, 0.002878189, 0.039764404, 0.024734497, 0.029220581, -0.0016841888, 0.009422302, 0.05960083, -0.024093628, -0.06072998, 0.0015935898, -0.0061302185, -0.014511108, 0.061035156, 0.016220093, -0.05795288, -0.022109985, -0.047698975, -0.042388916, -0.02810669, 0.031707764, -0.0033931732, 0.02696228, -0.001490593, 0.0029850006, -0.009796143, -0.0066604614, -0.022445679, 0.0038013458, -0.0107421875, -0.04586792, 0.02458191, 0.026443481, 0.012626648, -0.033294678, 0.023666382, 0.042816162, 0.006412506, 0.009124756, -0.082214355, -0.013504028, -0.029022217, -0.031234741, 0.032226562, 0.026641846, -0.040924072, 0.03338623, -0.039123535, 0.058288574, 0.013961792, 0.03817749, 0.0385437, 0.015457153, -0.0026454926, 0.009025574, 0.0034866333, -0.033050537, -0.01727295, -0.034210205, 0.0037345886, -0.018798828, -0.00040102005, -0.06329346, 0.023239136, 0.019363403, 0.026397705, -0.010566711, 0.013496399, -0.008239746, 0.002746582, 0.015731812, 0.029937744, 0.05621338, -0.016815186, 0.001991272, 0.026382446, -0.027740479, -0.0040779114, 0.038391113, -0.028015137, 0.0058784485, -0.035491943, 0.004890442, 0.0020275116, -0.005973816, 0.01158905, 0.026550293, -0.0038433075, -0.009674072, 0.06878662, 0.0104599, 0.06335449, 0.0625, 0.002658844, 0.021469116, -0.042053223, -0.010482788, 0.031463623, -0.022720337, 0.036376953, 0.061279297, -0.07611084, 0.019683838, 0.004020691, -0.046844482, 0.0052757263, 0.037719727, 0.03640747, -0.043792725, -0.058441162, 0.030593872, 0.04333496, 0.017318726, 0.01737976, -0.023498535, -0.0021743774, 0.024520874, 0.02619934, 0.00920105, 0.028381348, 0.022918701, 0.005054474, -0.039642334, -0.054107666, 0.01374054, 0.023880005, -0.029388428, 0.025650024, 0.0018882751, 0.039611816, 0.0012340546, -0.03149414, 0.030288696, 0.008590698, -0.06604004, 0.015655518, 0.0053977966, 0.04360962, 0.03945923, 0.08117676, 0.042907715, -0.018203735, -0.033203125, -0.049835205, 0.024459839, 0.028656006, -0.024291992, 0.038909912, -0.044158936, -0.037231445, 0.044128418, -0.05633545, 0.062286377, -0.03778076, -0.0096588135, -0.009971619, 0.016342163, 0.041015625, -0.03894043, -0.043823242, -0.020462036, -0.010414124, -0.0062828064, -0.024780273, -0.042175293, -0.027236938, 0.00015449524, 0.022338867, 0.021560669, -0.009513855, 0.00969696, -0.020019531, -0.0925293, -0.0015554428, 0.0058937073, 0.023010254, -0.016555786, -0.010002136, -0.03036499, 0.022918701, 0.012626648, -0.04638672, -0.02848816, -0.0040397644, -0.018417358, -0.018829346, 0.020309448, 0.022018433, -0.0025119781, 0.021850586, -0.019058228, 0.021057129, -0.0061302185, -0.00079774857, 0.012542725, -0.046203613, -0.020462036, -0.00982666, -0.0038223267, 0.038604736, 0.040863037, -0.009460449, 0.011962891, 0.02960205, -0.03137207, -0.03137207, -0.00541687, 0.027297974, 0.015853882, -0.060913086, 0.02168274, 0.023452759, 0.035980225, -0.037353516, -0.0184021, 0.04067993, 0.021499634, -0.026947021, 0.043548584, 0.027832031, 0.010040283, 0.013175964, 0.04928589, -0.0041236877, -0.050720215, -0.033813477, 0.0039901733, 0.04019165, 0.050567627, 0.0007472038, -0.019256592, 0.033721924, -0.022537231, -0.0010681152, 0.03765869, -0.0060157776, 0.022628784, 0.008644104, 0.054779053, -0.023544312, -0.011627197, -0.016067505, 0.019256592, -0.0056114197, 0.020645142, -0.012298584, 0.016311646, -0.008926392, 0.043670654, -0.0043258667, -0.013168335, 0.014076233, 0.048919678, 0.022842407, 0.046936035, -0.0385437, -0.022216797, 0.015571594, -0.0036849976, -0.018707275, -0.002445221, 0.030761719, -0.01020813, -0.021240234, 0.023834229, -0.04888916, -0.019378662, -0.03024292, 0.028656006, -0.007320404, 0.023742676, 0.021850586, -0.02583313, -0.008972168, 0.006843567, 0.015098572, -0.04147339, -0.06335449, -0.03878784, 0.051483154, -0.0178833 ], "summary": [ 0.00088882446, -0.009757996, -0.025512695, 0.020843506, -0.023406982, -0.021728516, -0.009849548, -0.032104492, -0.0053482056, -0.018203735, 0.0020942688, 0.006465912, -0.025527954, -0.048828125, 0.04650879, -0.03515625, 0.0014371872, 0.01890564, 0.010437012, -0.026184082, 0.035614014, -0.018463135, -0.01725769, 0.0039138794, 0.0032615662, 0.05508423, -0.031219482, -0.0015163422, -0.0041923523, 0.009086609, 0.004272461, -0.032196045, 0.008468628, 0.012252808, -0.0025138855, 0.010177612, -0.0052452087, 0.0076179504, 0.02859497, -0.013999939, 0.025543213, -0.018951416, 0.014205933, -0.0262146, 0.0070610046, -0.027404785, 0.043792725, -0.031585693, -0.00026512146, -0.010101318, -0.0052871704, 0.025024414, -0.011703491, 0.059326172, -0.0063095093, -0.0041923523, -0.010345459, -0.018508911, 0.03564453, 0.0715332, -0.0050239563, -0.039245605, -0.000051677227, -0.08325195, 0.03201294, -0.0056419373, 0.037139893, 0.017700195, 0.032409668, 0.048431396, 0.0008444786, -0.007926941, -0.01776123, -0.0011081696, -0.047210693, 0.005268097, 0.023666382, -0.015419006, 0.00028252602, -0.002412796, -0.018753052, 0.015213013, -0.045135498, -0.07092285, 0.038482666, -0.033172607, -0.023468018, 0.0036792755, -0.007385254, -0.02168274, -0.006668091, 0.044952393, -0.0040283203, -0.0063438416, -0.034729004, -0.034362793, -0.04220581, -0.058898926, 0.048858643, 0.051696777, 0.02508545, -0.032470703, 0.05050659, -0.017333984, 0.004989624, 0.0024738312, 0.0035533905, -0.043304443, 0.005088806, -0.0031719208, -0.028198242, 0.042755127, -0.028579712, -0.05404663, -0.004890442, 0.033569336, -0.013511658, -0.0015439987, 0.025558472, -0.0018053055, -0.010482788, 0.0025844574, 0.0052375793, 0.039794922, 0.026748657, 0.02166748, -0.019607544, 0.0063972473, -0.016693115, 0.03366089, -0.027786255, -0.0020656586, 0.004283905, 0.029876709, 0.0057373047, -0.027313232, -0.017486572, 0.0063056946, 0.027786255, -0.016113281, -0.0028324127, 0.01777649, 0.055511475, 0.007003784, -0.018707275, 0.061553955, 0.041290283, -0.053497314, -0.055999756, -0.045013428, -0.05380249, 0.0027065277, 0.05279541, -0.025863647, -0.07019043, -0.045898438, -0.043792725, -0.0020503998, 0.00762558, -0.044281006, 0.021652222, -0.008369446, -0.011665344, 0.068847656, 0.038604736, 0.0013637543, 0.01374054, 0.022399902, 0.012069702, 0.04345703, -0.027908325, -0.011817932, -0.005382538, -0.01927185, -0.021743774, 0.010971069, 0.009880066, -0.011116028, 0.024765015, -0.0053634644, -0.01109314, -0.023254395, 0.025863647, 0.00076055527, 0.010818481, -0.024169922, 0.00069618225, -0.0062789917, 0.02230835, 0.025558472, -0.026794434, 0.0041999817, -0.047027588, -0.008338928, 0.021835327, -0.0037002563, -0.017745972, -0.025863647, 0.019348145, -0.008903503, -0.050354004, 0.024307251, -0.024337769, 0.04534912, -0.032287598, 0.011756897, 0.0024757385, 0.015930176, -0.018035889, 0.026046753, 0.024887085, 0.0021572113, -0.029693604, 0.0064811707, 0.0076446533, -0.029678345, 0.0770874, -0.00056028366, 0.012161255, -0.02507019, -0.004016876, 0.028198242, -0.010528564, 0.09338379, 0.013069153, -0.030731201, 0.010826111, -0.026168823, 0.08416748, 0.012756348, 0.045806885, -0.03427124, -0.06359863, 0.009162903, 0.018051147, 0.032836914, 0.063964844, 0.008407593, 0.023880005, -0.026672363, 0.017532349, 0.07525635, -0.0062408447, 0.01777649, 0.06549072, 0.010101318, 0.023880005, -0.003238678, 0.00491333, 0.02949524, 0.016220093, 0.022628784, 0.021850586, -0.044952393, 0.024520874, 0.020812988, -0.04937744, 0.029968262, 0.012809753, 0.015380859, -0.028747559, 0.03982544, 0.068603516, -0.026779175, 0.0051116943, 0.006340027, 0.019958496, 0.027267456, 0.015388489, -0.023651123, 0.002029419, -0.03111267, -0.00630188, -0.046875, -0.07556152, -0.082092285, -0.028900146, 0.076293945, -0.023483276, -0.063964844, -0.008460999, 0.0635376, 0.008148193, -0.02458191, -0.007965088, 0.08129883, -0.009521484, -0.031707764, 0.027023315, 0.07043457, 0.113342285, -0.05328369, -0.030288696, -0.018432617, -0.06359863, -0.047302246, 0.0041770935, 0.026565552, 0.00038218498, -0.0069503784, -0.0044822693, 0.035461426, -0.010948181, -0.009170532, 0.0019168854, 0.016403198, -0.016708374, 0.009483337, 0.0058059692, 0.0052948, -0.05130005, 0.018859863, 0.036254883, -0.010192871, 0.06719971, 0.033355713, 0.014671326, 0.04434204, 0.05026245, 0.036743164, 0.048461914, 0.030410767, -0.036712646, -0.0099105835, 0.011779785, 0.00033593178, -0.0368042, -0.022903442, 0.051330566, -0.008872986, -0.00141716, 0.024475098, -0.044158936, -0.010772705, 0.015853882, 0.010055542, -0.010063171, 0.0060539246, -0.010978699, 0.004360199, -0.030090332, -0.0065994263, 0.015625, -0.054016113, -0.006603241, -0.030761719, -0.012176514, 0.001572609, 0.05984497, 0.0008020401, 0.0016298294, -0.012550354, -0.012512207, 0.010635376, -0.0036010742, -0.0027942657, 0.02923584, 0.042144775, 0.017303467, 0.0023021698, 0.019210815, 0.027786255, 0.009468079, -0.035125732, -0.023361206, -0.03643799, 0.030197144, -0.037261963, 0.043151855, 0.0423584, 0.023788452, 0.03704834, -0.032165527, -0.0044441223, -0.015342712, -0.039398193, 0.08227539, -0.0006251335, 0.020629883, 0.052764893, 0.026748657, 0.056762695, -0.04159546, 0.020523071, 0.13134766, -0.004119873, 0.034454346, 0.0692749, 0.04168701, 0.0018444061, -0.03314209, -0.04321289, -0.04019165, -0.04006958, 0.009643555, 0.018463135, 0.032348633, -0.000011861324, 0.025466919, -0.03717041, 0.0051231384, 0.0011730194, -0.01499176, 0.0041770935, -0.029067993, -0.0037326813, -0.010604858, -0.009765625, 0.027297974, 0.019638062, 0.013954163, -0.03982544, 0.011741638, -0.02571106, -0.031402588, -0.0038452148, 0.092163086, 0.022888184, 0.039642334, -0.09375, -0.017608643, 0.049438477, -0.028182983, -0.066345215, 0.010612488, 0.041534424, 0.030014038, 0.0052604675, 0.023986816, -0.043060303, 0.04119873, -0.052337646, -0.03375244, -0.032196045, -0.037963867, 0.025405884, 0.0023517609, 0.017028809, 0.021881104, -0.019638062, -0.04269409, -0.0446167, 0.00009649992, 0.009407043, 0.015068054, -0.0104904175, -0.016494751, -0.030532837, 0.047027588, 0.029342651, -0.008743286, -0.03741455, 0.016555786, 0.0124435425, -0.056488037, 0.06500244, 0.010643005, 0.03024292, 0.052856445, -0.028198242, 0.00233078, 0.004486084, -0.068725586, 0.037750244, -0.028945923, 0.022460938, 0.06347656, -0.011505127, -0.041503906, 0.022201538, -0.051513672, 0.016967773, -0.029251099, -0.009719849, 0.0050086975, -0.040527344, 0.009185791, 0.05407715, -0.013000488, -0.026779175, 0.013092041, -0.00712204, 0.11804199, -0.050567627, 0.01828003, 0.007671356, -0.05960083, -0.035888672, 0.010261536, -0.021316528, -0.0011405945, 0.0037345886, 0.05807495, -0.05239868, 0.020462036, -0.022521973, 0.0010185242, 0.013763428, 0.022201538, 0.0024719238, -0.07128906, 0.0068740845, 0.0004143715, 0.004776001, -0.030883789, 0.0635376, 0.060058594, 0.014305115, 0.029373169, -0.05831909, 0.04537964, -0.03363037, 0.04663086, 0.01763916, -0.005996704, 0.033294678, 0.009361267, 0.058532715, -0.023010254, -0.03692627, 0.06555176, 0.045318604, -0.025375366, -0.0072288513, 0.07611084, -0.032928467, -0.009010315, 0.0031528473, 0.008987427, 0.03894043, -0.030303955, 0.011108398, -0.041931152, -0.022201538, 0.06958008, -0.061035156, 0.0075950623, -0.011413574, -0.023727417, 0.018417358, -0.011894226, -0.009689331, 0.009651184, -0.0013904572, -0.0006599426, -0.017959595, -0.020904541, 0.022125244, -0.017959595, 0.0058174133, 0.0037117004, -0.0046463013, 0.015640259, -0.03289795, -0.025543213, -0.0155181885, 0.030303955, -0.0262146, -0.010307312, 0.035308838, -0.014831543, -0.0055351257, -0.00028181076, -0.006855011, 0.021026611, 0.019454956, 0.0004222393, -0.035339355, 0.017105103, -0.012397766, -0.042144775, -0.05050659, -0.04296875, -0.020904541, -0.022415161, -0.018920898, -0.01625061, 0.0036621094, 0.009811401, 0.020553589, 0.052703857, 0.0026054382, -0.0345459, -0.026443481, -0.0011892319, -0.0022659302, 0.017593384, 0.020202637, 0.0087890625, -0.024261475, -0.02331543, -0.0058937073, -0.007255554, 0.035980225, -0.033813477, -0.0067367554, 0.007713318, -0.0126571655, 0.060638428, -0.0026874542, -0.011306763, 0.00818634, 0.016830444, -0.00548172, 0.031219482, 0.012817383, 0.002439499, 0.032470703, -0.02355957, -0.017227173, -0.0047569275, -0.0032749176, 0.009933472, -0.00014197826, 0.0033874512, 0.0029010773, -0.005722046, -0.028381348, -0.0181427, -0.006958008, 0.022232056, -0.004989624, 0.025177002, 0.020339966, 0.015419006, 0.04119873, 0.011436462, 0.032592773, -0.008674622, 0.0047950745, 0.000682354, -0.003780365, -0.037109375, -0.026306152, 0.007843018, 0.066101074, -0.027420044, -0.044769287, -0.05908203, 0.010108948, 0.020477295, 0.013542175, 0.0044441223, -0.0033111572, -0.0037822723, 0.023498535, 0.011581421, -0.0079422, 0.0058631897, 0.008178711, -0.008087158, -0.016998291, -0.08734131, -0.031921387, 0.039611816, -0.0015449524, -0.024414062, -0.016784668, -0.017929077, -0.014549255, -0.03427124, -0.024459839, -0.06335449, 0.035369873, 0.011039734, -0.0010757446, 0.035491943, 0.016189575, 0.006416321, -0.0284729, -0.0014371872, -0.000054001808, 0.021652222, -0.024276733, 0.020767212, -0.015571594, 0.012428284, 0.000541687, 0.0104904175, -0.040771484, -0.0065956116, 0.044921875, 0.0703125, -0.041534424, -0.010414124, 0.050079346, 0.040618896, -0.038330078, 0.0013437271, -0.0056991577, 0.006500244, 0.034210205, -0.01007843, -0.01977539, 0.015350342, -0.014793396, 0.020843506, -0.035339355, -0.050964355, -0.043792725, 0.009178162, 0.013031006, 0.023025513, 0.025604248, 0.015716553, 0.018157959, -0.02520752, -0.02180481, 0.009918213, 0.008476257, -0.004760742, 0.0065193176, -0.03753662, -0.0060043335, -0.020736694, 0.01461792, 0.031829834, -0.005962372, 0.0034885406, 0.04220581, 0.023727417, 0.03338623, 0.05038452, -0.006587982, 0.017028809, 0.034362793, -0.021774292, 0.05810547, 0.007156372, 0.012290955, 0.012435913, 0.057800293, -0.023345947, 0.003446579, 0.03878784, -0.042907715, 0.033966064, -0.036895752, -0.030334473, -0.02053833, -0.008766174, 0.00066185, 0.014457703, -0.018508911, -0.0071411133, -0.0006656647, -0.0015735626, -0.022476196, 0.015960693, -0.029663086, 0.03164673, 0.0074768066, -0.08947754, 0.004875183, 0.031555176, 0.0017547607, 0.003200531, 0.037506104, -0.05731201, 0.013656616, 0.018615723, 0.014976501, 0.0032520294, 0.0053596497, -0.042633057, 0.015472412, 0.025054932, -0.011543274, -0.023544312, -0.0018663406, 0.006511688, 0.015625, 0.0016937256, -0.024169922, -0.00010037422, 0.023040771, 0.028961182, -0.0044174194, -0.013877869, 0.0024871826, -0.020095825, 0.04168701, -0.06829834, 0.0076904297, -0.032073975, 0.034698486, -0.012550354, 0.04058838, -0.052856445, -0.025878906, 0.0026359558, 0.04269409, 0.026062012, 0.038970947, 0.031066895, 0.009803772, 0.0101623535, 0.017944336, 0.011512756, -0.017623901, 0.023406982, -0.0118637085, -0.02520752, -0.034820557, -0.041137695, -0.011421204, 0.045532227, -0.025558472, -0.023925781, 0.0541687, -0.013618469, 0.004043579, 0.0259552, -0.026794434, 0.04067993, 0.0041503906, 0.021209717, -0.025314331, 0.05267334, -0.01802063, 0.0047721863, 0.05493164, -0.018508911, 0.016815186, -0.04736328, 0.015144348, 0.015960693, -0.03869629, -0.01373291, 0.023208618, 0.029251099, 0.00012362003, 0.08270264, 0.038604736, 0.09863281, 0.013420105, -0.043273926, 0.030075073, -0.024765015, -0.026016235, 0.039154053, -0.023895264, 0.029907227, 0.02709961, 0.015029907, -0.02230835, -0.0042877197, -0.0345459, 0.056365967, 0.0057678223, 0.039764404, -0.06311035, -0.028823853, 0.021362305, 0.0058403015, -0.019012451, 0.018615723, -0.026779175, -0.011459351, -0.0047798157, -0.0050086975, 0.00856781, 0.008613586, -0.013183594, -0.0025749207, -0.014533997, -0.032928467, -0.0074920654, 0.017944336, -0.033569336, 0.031982422, 0.010978699, 0.03768921, 0.041931152, -0.018859863, 0.041046143, 0.021774292, -0.018920898, 0.0473938, -0.018371582, 0.051208496, 0.046173096, 0.052215576, 0.0128479, 0.002916336, 0.04449463, -0.021575928, 0.0002901554, -0.01637268, 0.0052871704, 0.019241333, -0.029800415, -0.0039100647, 0.020645142, -0.014541626, 0.009963989, -0.019226074, -0.015266418, -0.009429932, -0.017501831, 0.012962341, 0.001241684, -0.026016235, -0.05722046, -0.020996094, -0.0055503845, 0.009498596, -0.059936523, -0.015930176, -0.035308838, -0.008232117, -0.016723633, 0.017318726, 0.05593872, -0.015945435, -0.053497314, -0.005519867, 0.023880005, 0.051361084, -0.007286072, 0.00484848, 0.022888184, 0.01524353, -0.023208618, -0.08917236, -0.02658081, -0.028167725, 0.034088135, -0.025115967, 0.025009155, 0.029159546, -0.010025024, -0.01007843, 0.008552551, -0.00059223175, -0.01374054, 0.031463623, 0.009963989, -0.014518738, -0.03866577, 0.00092315674, -0.008056641, 0.022827148, 0.014465332, 0.011787415, 0.005718231, 0.023498535, 0.023742676, -0.03756714, 0.0056266785, -0.018478394, -0.0135269165, 0.015434265, 0.01687622, 0.03010559, 0.07513428, 0.022232056, 0.028869629, 0.001496315, -0.09265137, -0.018356323, 0.01133728, -0.0146865845, 0.0011053085, -0.00027680397, 0.08251953, -0.0036640167, -0.030548096, 0.007068634, 0.03074646, 0.033569336, 0.00868988, -0.029586792, 0.023544312, 0.018737793, -0.07928467, -0.00044941902, -0.0045776367, 0.050567627, -0.019485474, -0.007698059, 0.02670288, -0.018249512, -0.054260254, -0.04598999, -0.017990112, 0.011001587, -0.02583313, 0.019729614, 0.016799927, -0.040405273, 0.054138184, 0.04244995, 0.062316895, -0.020935059, -0.02507019, 0.06427002, -0.02508545, 0.0209198, -0.014839172, 0.018707275, 0.00983429, -0.01751709, 0.0023593903, 0.03201294, -0.018997192, -0.0259552, 0.003490448, -0.01789856, -0.06750488, -0.05633545, 0.044555664, 0.017227173, -0.026504517, 0.05368042, -0.015838623, 0.01939392, -0.04437256, 0.03540039, 0.004878998, -0.02798462, 0.03427124, -0.023529053, 0.01374054 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1711.03676v1
Communicative Capital for Prosthetic Agents
Patrick M. Pilarski, Richard S. Sutton, Kory W. Mathewson, Craig Sherstan, Adam S. R. Parker, Ann L. Edwards
cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
This work presents an overarching perspective on the role that machine intelligence can play in enhancing human abilities, especially those that have been diminished due to injury or illness. As a primary contribution, we develop the hypothesis that assistive devices, and specifically artificial arms and hands, can and should be viewed as agents in order for us to most effectively improve their collaboration with their human users. We believe that increased agency will enable more powerful interactions between human users and next generation prosthetic devices, especially when the sensorimotor space of the prosthetic technology greatly exceeds the conventional control and communication channels available to a prosthetic user. To more concretely examine an agency-based view on prosthetic devices, we propose a new schema for interpreting the capacity of a human-machine collaboration as a function of both the human's and machine's degrees of agency. We then introduce the idea of communicative capital as a way of thinking about the communication resources developed by a human and a machine during their ongoing interaction. Using this schema of agency and capacity, we examine the benefits and disadvantages of increasing the agency of a prosthetic limb. To do so, we present an analysis of examples from the literature where building communicative capital has enabled a progression of fruitful, task-directed interactions between prostheses and their human users. We then describe further work that is needed to concretely evaluate the hypothesis that prostheses are best thought of as agents. The agent-based viewpoint developed in this article significantly extends current thinking on how best to support the natural, functional use of increasingly complex prosthetic enhancements, and opens the door for more powerful interactions between humans and their assistive technologies.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1711.03676v1
2017-11-10T03:19:59
2017-11-10T03:19:59
{ "title": [ -0.015670776, 0.0008339882, -0.044403076, -0.025039673, -0.039031982, -0.018508911, -0.04788208, 0.008659363, -0.03515625, 0.03894043, 0.022918701, -0.0181427, 0.039276123, -0.062927246, 0.017089844, 0.00087213516, 0.0077590942, 0.006275177, -0.0033416748, -0.018829346, -0.0015697479, -0.008522034, -0.020950317, -0.028717041, -0.00039601326, -0.030029297, -0.017456055, 0.0030174255, 0.017913818, -0.0039749146, 0.008651733, -0.0044898987, 0.018249512, 0.0043144226, -0.0049934387, -0.026062012, -0.0021190643, -0.00957489, -0.015487671, 0.025283813, 0.011131287, 0.002166748, -0.0061531067, -0.035858154, -0.016647339, -0.003900528, 0.00048971176, -0.010803223, 0.019836426, 0.031082153, -0.03225708, 0.010543823, -0.03616333, 0.05682373, -0.015457153, -0.019104004, -0.061523438, -0.020080566, 0.005607605, 0.07702637, 0.036071777, 0.014831543, 0.0030708313, -0.05392456, 0.0065841675, -0.007068634, 0.016677856, 0.018249512, 0.04473877, 0.012878418, -0.010391235, 0.009941101, -0.0027618408, -0.0030384064, -0.0044822693, 0.006313324, 0.0013694763, 0.014305115, 0.018447876, -0.012123108, 0.0035705566, -0.010787964, 0.036895752, -0.04574585, 0.024108887, -0.039031982, 0.011627197, 0.0074806213, -0.0048332214, -0.028167725, -0.007259369, 0.08984375, -0.023406982, 0.01071167, -0.035064697, -0.014350891, -0.014389038, 0.018554688, 0.0011396408, -0.0059814453, -0.031433105, -0.02166748, 0.00042796135, -0.042999268, -0.00040578842, 0.018615723, -0.0018939972, -0.011924744, 0.018692017, 0.03729248, -0.02229309, 0.031204224, 0.01966858, 0.028518677, 0.029937744, -0.058288574, -0.06011963, 0.055236816, -0.03427124, -0.00894165, 0.0039863586, 0.0017089844, 0.059906006, -0.016998291, 0.0023593903, 0.018463135, -0.03805542, -0.051971436, -0.011276245, -0.005508423, -0.005657196, 0.05831909, -0.08148193, -0.037506104, -0.035858154, 0.017593384, -0.008766174, -0.017211914, 0.0046539307, -0.02168274, 0.01687622, -0.010688782, 0.021575928, 0.019836426, -0.032714844, 0.0077209473, 0.03189087, 0.036834717, -0.021316528, -0.090026855, 0.031188965, -0.0035896301, -0.02381897, 0.025741577, 0.043273926, 0.018203735, -0.028045654, 0.005088806, 0.05987549, 0.030883789, 0.0073127747, 0.007896423, -0.0047187805, 0.0035095215, 0.013824463, -0.0149002075, 0.0036735535, 0.024627686, 0.013618469, 0.066589355, -0.0059814453, -0.023345947, 0.016235352, -0.021255493, -0.03387451, -0.0037765503, -0.012519836, 0.012046814, 0.037017822, -0.09057617, -0.03302002, -0.037231445, -0.004814148, 0.0069122314, -0.01966858, -0.032104492, -0.0023498535, -0.025177002, 0.03062439, 0.010520935, 0.009063721, 0.044647217, -0.054473877, 0.020996094, -0.045288086, 0.0035438538, 0.010894775, 0.048065186, -0.023590088, 0.012664795, -0.01335144, 0.031280518, -0.021224976, 0.031921387, -0.0058174133, 0.0006117821, 0.0011110306, 0.005420685, -0.013793945, 0.024597168, 0.01689148, -0.029922485, -0.016708374, 0.0044784546, -0.016586304, -0.05230713, -0.007217407, 0.027450562, -0.005153656, 0.0047950745, 0.0020542145, -0.04168701, 0.010879517, 0.055603027, -0.015037537, 0.03475952, -0.03314209, 0.00045251846, 0.0018949509, 0.028717041, 0.036590576, 0.0061302185, -0.015991211, 0.014663696, -0.0023593903, -0.010047913, 0.04333496, -0.04095459, 0.028289795, 0.024215698, 0.0031318665, -0.021270752, 0.015586853, 0.01777649, 0.012924194, 0.0019264221, 0.050323486, -0.019577026, 0.047668457, 0.030776978, 0.034362793, -0.048614502, 0.049041748, -0.0035934448, 0.007850647, 0.041137695, 0.013427734, 0.005367279, -0.013755798, -0.0026664734, 0.016952515, 0.024917603, -0.026763916, 0.0154418945, -0.022567749, -0.0003478527, -0.028152466, 0.0064735413, -0.052612305, 0.027374268, 0.049194336, 0.023529053, 0.0036640167, -0.020339966, 0.012939453, 0.01525116, -0.051483154, 0.033599854, 0.028671265, -0.020767212, -0.0036506653, 0.008728027, 0.048736572, 0.000875473, 0.013893127, 0.072143555, 0.0463562, 0.009033203, -0.014625549, -0.00070667267, 0.044830322, 0.009223938, -0.010536194, 0.014373779, 0.007297516, 0.0069732666, 0.0056037903, 0.030792236, -0.00667572, 0.00920105, -0.034423828, 0.015571594, 0.025878906, -0.011512756, -0.008926392, -0.0064697266, -0.026519775, 0.042755127, 0.019958496, -0.057006836, 0.061462402, 0.1194458, 0.005191803, -0.0015029907, 0.01902771, -0.01033783, 0.020370483, 0.010025024, 0.0036754608, 0.0015335083, 0.096191406, -0.0016555786, -0.00680542, -0.026672363, -0.0032348633, -0.053833008, -0.04348755, -0.033691406, 0.00831604, -0.0061836243, -0.03152466, -0.015220642, -0.057739258, -0.007499695, 0.0129776, 0.0066833496, 0.018707275, 0.0013904572, 0.017440796, 0.0047950745, 0.040496826, -0.055999756, -0.002603531, -0.000849247, 0.04119873, -0.034332275, -0.036712646, -0.01663208, 0.008728027, 0.013511658, -0.01713562, 0.010520935, -0.014190674, -0.0040740967, 0.064941406, 0.033355713, -0.0013198853, 0.03652954, 0.08294678, -0.008346558, 0.01763916, 0.029968262, 0.023803711, 0.00504303, -0.03488159, -0.05770874, 0.0063476562, 0.026107788, -0.013427734, 0.024993896, -0.005130768, -0.01928711, -0.014953613, 0.001627922, -0.023086548, -0.023361206, -0.008224487, -0.035491943, -0.05215454, -0.029953003, 0.050048828, 0.0060310364, 0.044158936, 0.010154724, 0.031158447, 0.0096206665, -0.032196045, -0.03149414, 0.03591919, 0.026473999, -0.0015010834, -0.025314331, -0.027572632, -0.025009155, 0.029708862, 0.013397217, -0.025985718, -0.03152466, -0.058135986, 0.002861023, 0.06378174, -0.012390137, -0.02104187, 0.032348633, -0.03503418, -0.03366089, 0.023132324, -0.021011353, 0.032928467, 0.014419556, -0.018569946, -0.017349243, 0.019165039, -0.060546875, 0.00045013428, -0.026565552, -0.0043640137, 0.018981934, -0.021575928, -0.047424316, 0.023513794, -0.03765869, -0.020568848, -0.033203125, -0.01713562, 0.05053711, 0.015945435, 0.0040740967, -0.008888245, 0.012001038, 0.0015039444, -0.0011291504, 0.035491943, 0.016738892, -0.031555176, -0.0006451607, -0.034729004, 0.031951904, 0.0209198, -0.028457642, -0.035217285, -0.008598328, 0.018585205, 0.008399963, -0.003616333, -0.017089844, 0.0014896393, -0.008468628, -0.057891846, -0.047821045, -0.044311523, 0.024673462, -0.022567749, 0.023666382, 0.01637268, 0.06616211, 0.020629883, 0.046966553, -0.022979736, 0.0023155212, 0.03286743, -0.027755737, -0.021652222, 0.011184692, 0.015357971, 0.029159546, -0.0063323975, 0.009094238, -0.0050697327, 0.0020866394, 0.008644104, -0.009384155, -0.038757324, 0.015365601, -0.011505127, 0.021896362, -0.013023376, 0.005592346, 0.024856567, 0.022094727, 0.02734375, 0.007331848, 0.051818848, -0.049621582, -0.012077332, 0.026290894, -0.0836792, -0.0033817291, 0.02809143, -0.060333252, -0.06866455, -0.037322998, 0.020599365, -0.06329346, -0.016235352, -0.0050315857, 0.0011940002, -0.03656006, 0.021530151, -0.040405273, -0.07684326, 0.04940796, -0.016647339, -0.033325195, -0.0030708313, -0.02557373, 0.0022068024, -0.014411926, 0.033721924, 0.032806396, -0.002576828, -0.008506775, 0.07232666, 0.005378723, 0.0059509277, 0.005874634, 0.058258057, 0.03237915, 0.013572693, 0.0022296906, -0.002828598, 0.0015621185, 0.010475159, 0.037200928, 0.017242432, 0.008071899, -0.031021118, 0.015853882, -0.019836426, -0.039855957, -0.0018033981, -0.0031738281, -0.0015249252, 0.01675415, 0.023452759, 0.03564453, 0.019485474, 0.032989502, 0.031799316, -0.049987793, 0.018096924, 0.0045700073, -0.016677856, -0.043670654, -0.009010315, -0.029373169, -0.014328003, 0.057281494, 0.006538391, 0.031051636, 0.0236969, -0.009490967, -0.018508911, 0.0017976761, -0.02748108, -0.08666992, -0.078125, 0.030426025, -0.009246826, 0.025817871, 0.025924683, -0.00048828125, -0.023971558, -0.008255005, 0.0758667, -0.010902405, 0.039154053, -0.028366089, 0.004501343, -0.018798828, -0.06738281, -0.046203613, 0.0006995201, 0.0256958, -0.0146484375, -0.0055122375, -0.040771484, 0.01361084, 0.021392822, 0.039154053, 0.035125732, 0.018341064, -0.037322998, 0.03527832, -0.025390625, 0.016723633, -0.008758545, -0.003545761, -0.01878357, 0.027557373, 0.0680542, -0.031585693, -0.010826111, -0.02909851, 0.027709961, -0.031234741, 0.07055664, -0.023498535, -0.0154800415, 0.013038635, 0.031555176, -0.00031805038, 0.0024223328, -0.01109314, 0.000028789043, 0.006198883, 0.053344727, 0.0021324158, 0.003791809, 0.060058594, 0.02053833, -0.026229858, 0.01361084, -0.00003629923, 0.01876831, 0.03778076, 0.034851074, -0.024475098, -0.04107666, -0.044830322, 0.008239746, -0.035614014, 0.04525757, 0.019714355, 0.025131226, -0.036071777, -0.02607727, -0.015533447, -0.004634857, 0.021881104, -0.008026123, 0.0184021, -0.019241333, -0.014778137, 0.038879395, 0.050750732, -0.029708862, -0.020111084, -0.05404663, 0.023864746, 0.0062408447, 0.04711914, -0.006958008, -0.029388428, 0.03591919, -0.008407593, -0.017852783, -0.019042969, -0.027282715, -0.011726379, -0.010612488, 0.03253174, 0.017486572, 0.008743286, -0.015960693, 0.009391785, -0.050445557, -0.03289795, 0.060760498, -0.032928467, -0.0064849854, 0.10266113, -0.05130005, 0.073791504, -0.03164673, -0.02104187, 0.016555786, 0.03237915, -0.02456665, -0.04586792, 0.028457642, -0.059661865, -0.027938843, -0.0231781, 0.0017690659, 0.018600464, 0.03024292, 0.021530151, 0.022155762, -0.028366089, 0.014411926, 0.02381897, 0.03463745, -0.028564453, -0.032409668, 0.01158905, -0.02330017, 0.009841919, -0.026473999, -0.053253174, -0.11328125, -0.064086914, -0.03704834, -0.086120605, 0.0078125, -0.053527832, -0.014038086, -0.031311035, 0.049621582, -0.0051116943, 0.029937744, -0.014770508, 0.011817932, -0.020431519, 0.009941101, 0.05038452, -0.08392334, 0.0040626526, -0.04626465, 0.018966675, 0.017730713, 0.0020446777, 0.01953125, -0.005126953, -0.022888184, 0.010856628, 0.06964111, 0.004295349, 0.0019817352, 0.031433105, -0.027908325, -0.03970337, -0.017791748, -0.020599365, 0.023605347, -0.008583069, -0.03189087, 0.008491516, -0.00982666, -0.010185242, 0.016693115, 0.0066833496, -0.00021195412, -0.0038986206, 0.0010051727, -0.0035037994, 0.04006958, 0.0362854, 0.020477295, 0.005168915, -0.039215088, 0.014587402, 0.020492554, -0.004875183, 0.0118255615, 0.061706543, 0.02128601, 0.0050201416, 0.009552002, 0.035736084, 0.020217896, -0.0137786865, 0.0016126633, 0.010147095, -0.0014781952, -0.00818634, 0.042816162, 0.005809784, 0.007850647, -0.036834717, -0.04989624, -0.032226562, -0.013023376, 0.037384033, -0.028259277, -0.009208679, -0.039001465, -0.036010742, 0.04586792, 0.01939392, -0.03262329, 0.005268097, -0.0016422272, -0.0090408325, 0.0033988953, 0.048858643, 0.028076172, -0.020706177, -0.0024318695, -0.0026416779, 0.029449463, -0.008880615, -0.019180298, -0.022598267, -0.020568848, -0.016235352, 0.07293701, 0.0012025833, 0.009117126, 0.071899414, 0.016052246, 0.018814087, 0.025787354, 0.036834717, 0.013954163, 0.012825012, 0.05606079, 0.015289307, 0.0041618347, 0.0050621033, 0.024810791, -0.05419922, -0.016464233, -0.02973938, -0.006755829, -0.08917236, -0.014579773, 0.045532227, -0.02029419, -0.0007276535, -0.018173218, -0.008071899, 0.00017976761, -0.016220093, 0.016571045, 0.0013370514, 0.011947632, 0.0020217896, -0.026626587, 0.0057525635, -0.0019397736, 0.02619934, 0.016845703, 0.007736206, -0.027297974, -0.005504608, 0.024612427, -0.006652832, -0.02281189, -0.0056610107, 0.041900635, -0.032165527, 0.028747559, 0.024993896, 0.016738892, 0.03378296, 0.035003662, 0.0149383545, 0.0007491112, 0.01197052, -0.02017212, -0.016281128, 0.0007109642, 0.032714844, -0.064331055, 0.06768799, 0.015991211, -0.04458618, -0.0069847107, 0.03010559, 0.050567627, -0.010444641, 0.007865906, 0.006008148, 0.018508911, 0.012962341, 0.019699097, -0.059906006, -0.064208984, -0.06732178, -0.02218628, -0.011726379, -0.02192688, 0.016281128, -0.005050659, -0.024734497, -0.027893066, -0.03060913, 0.015350342, -0.08514404, 0.0003490448, 0.06707764, 0.07824707, -0.029129028, -0.029388428, 0.013244629, 0.025161743, -0.07110596, 0.010925293, 0.044952393, -0.0028648376, -0.011077881, 0.057922363, 0.04486084, 0.0023937225, -0.060302734, -0.00023949146, 0.01763916, -0.018325806, 0.0015983582, -0.030044556, -0.02720642, 0.00020647049, -0.0149383545, -0.00079107285, 0.039520264, -0.030654907, 0.035888672, -0.023071289, -0.02142334, -0.00023913383, -0.027145386, -0.020645142, -0.005290985, -0.0050964355, 0.0178833, -0.011680603, -0.055541992, 0.007045746, -0.010139465, -0.002910614, 0.03817749, 0.044128418, 0.082458496, -0.04434204, -0.04135132, 0.073791504, 0.038208008, 0.09918213, -0.016357422, -0.020858765, -0.020431519, -0.0035209656, 0.0038814545, 0.034301758, -0.008834839, 0.020431519, -0.06149292, -0.022003174, -0.013557434, -0.01663208, -0.012489319, 0.043029785, -0.00094127655, 0.03555298, -0.003616333, 0.012649536, -0.043121338, -0.020645142, 0.0062675476, 0.006477356, -0.009628296, -0.028411865, 0.024032593, -0.045776367, 0.0023918152, 0.0076675415, -0.033081055, -0.028442383, -0.0012607574, 0.02960205, -0.04824829, -0.023361206, -0.009208679, 0.0010251999, 0.025268555, -0.04574585, -0.08380127, -0.0021705627, 0.058746338, -0.017364502, -0.020111084, 0.050842285, -0.023544312, -0.04168701, -0.05569458, -0.0546875, 0.012306213, 0.04498291, 0.040649414, 0.026123047, 0.028244019, -0.03225708, 0.035125732, -0.0033912659, -0.026733398, 0.051239014, -0.011489868, -0.00440979, 0.05328369, -0.03286743, 0.05731201, -0.028533936, 0.027023315, -0.020706177, -0.040252686, 0.022735596, 0.014915466, -0.020004272, 0.010948181, -0.042175293, 0.057281494, -0.05859375, -0.07318115, 0.029083252, 0.06982422, -0.041656494, 0.031280518, -0.014968872, 0.00907135, -0.035003662, 0.034576416, 0.02128601, 0.06048584, -0.016723633, 0.033966064, 0.05432129, -0.026916504, -0.029083252, -0.06427002, -0.009796143, 0.01360321, -0.07330322, 0.036743164, -0.04776001, -0.031280518, 0.016540527, 0.031143188, 0.01939392, -0.032073975, 0.010978699, 0.012649536, 0.03375244, 0.0052604675 ], "summary": [ 0.03842163, 0.0003054142, -0.008178711, -0.0015621185, -0.009750366, -0.028427124, 0.019348145, -0.030303955, -0.0048103333, 0.032714844, 0.011734009, -0.015777588, 0.01486969, -0.038085938, -0.01209259, -0.0109939575, -0.013198853, 0.040527344, 0.018585205, -0.02659607, 0.034301758, -0.026382446, -0.04699707, -0.03793335, 0.0064811707, -0.02078247, -0.05819702, -0.006679535, 0.014045715, 0.010955811, 0.0059814453, -0.0036125183, 0.016326904, -0.043762207, 0.03866577, -0.087402344, 0.012207031, -0.027740479, -0.027801514, 0.038360596, 0.011657715, -0.01235199, 0.06274414, -0.04031372, 0.002664566, 0.021453857, 0.009971619, 0.0018072128, 0.04244995, 0.024307251, -0.012901306, 0.04953003, -0.011268616, 0.03793335, -0.02268982, -0.0151901245, -0.035888672, -0.026657104, 0.016845703, 0.06866455, 0.036865234, -0.01247406, 0.0041618347, -0.040863037, 0.0063438416, -0.019729614, 0.029769897, 0.029769897, 0.004886627, -0.009666443, 0.010673523, 0.015136719, 0.011650085, -0.0022201538, -0.03564453, 0.023147583, 0.01763916, 0.014778137, 0.0287323, -0.022964478, -0.008094788, 0.017684937, 0.06237793, -0.06427002, -0.0079574585, -0.0637207, -0.009567261, 0.019332886, 0.0024471283, 0.018051147, -0.01424408, 0.044708252, -0.005268097, 0.027740479, -0.007545471, -0.025238037, -0.009216309, -0.01802063, 0.016311646, 0.019195557, 0.03741455, -0.045959473, 0.077819824, -0.045013428, -0.003030777, 0.04446411, 0.008338928, -0.0680542, -0.005504608, 0.0035095215, -0.025177002, 0.007522583, 0.022964478, 0.012817383, -0.037353516, -0.011352539, -0.003982544, 0.016555786, -0.00919342, 0.014335632, -0.033416748, -0.021026611, 0.035339355, 0.066223145, 0.0040664673, 0.0395813, 0.007663727, -0.045196533, 0.037384033, -0.0053977966, -0.0064353943, 0.029708862, -0.039245605, -0.016464233, -0.049316406, 0.0077934265, 0.008460999, -0.030639648, 0.016189575, -0.043640137, 0.047698975, 0.014854431, 0.020477295, 0.03479004, -0.03010559, 0.0062217712, 0.0021705627, 0.032562256, -0.004058838, -0.041748047, 0.017028809, -0.014572144, -0.006626129, -0.010292053, 0.05480957, -0.033416748, -0.026870728, -0.0006213188, 0.06616211, 0.025238037, 0.031585693, 0.02394104, 0.004711151, -0.012336731, -0.00036501884, -0.048950195, -0.036895752, 0.0069999695, 0.014961243, -0.005302429, 0.028381348, -0.013961792, 0.041625977, -0.009376526, -0.016448975, -0.0116119385, 0.01361084, 0.009025574, 0.015808105, -0.06298828, -0.045043945, -0.037597656, 0.053985596, -0.029266357, -0.022506714, 0.038970947, -0.011177063, 0.029464722, 0.029174805, 0.00016415119, -0.034423828, 0.04800415, -0.043670654, 0.014793396, -0.019210815, -0.017166138, 0.00040650368, 0.0053253174, -0.018035889, 0.016738892, 0.053741455, -0.0035095215, 0.01272583, -0.0070762634, -0.034606934, 0.021713257, -0.010406494, 0.010543823, 0.011550903, 0.014411926, 0.009933472, -0.020889282, -0.0063209534, -0.012084961, -0.027252197, -0.01637268, 0.007507324, 0.0154800415, -0.015213013, -0.013282776, -0.009605408, -0.024475098, -0.011894226, 0.048675537, -0.031036377, 0.01272583, -0.039093018, 0.0030288696, -0.007030487, 0.022918701, 0.01889038, -0.011367798, -0.0129470825, 0.044189453, 0.028640747, 0.0032291412, 0.027877808, -0.06329346, 0.028869629, 0.018569946, 0.011512756, -0.035461426, 0.0031852722, 0.050720215, -0.026367188, 0.0032787323, 0.020584106, -0.005874634, 0.009605408, -0.0025348663, 0.007648468, -0.03955078, 0.04135132, -0.016906738, 0.0015602112, 0.019760132, -0.004627228, -0.038330078, 0.012939453, -0.035003662, 0.034088135, -0.053833008, -0.066467285, 0.020721436, -0.007865906, 0.0064315796, -0.018844604, -0.009025574, -0.031341553, 0.009880066, 0.049621582, 0.0061836243, -0.00023674965, -0.0019435883, -0.009262085, -0.0071525574, -0.034332275, 0.032958984, 0.015007019, -0.013313293, -0.0036392212, -0.007381439, -0.0011386871, -0.019332886, 0.027297974, 0.02468872, 0.028884888, 0.0033836365, 0.05419922, 0.097961426, 0.08850098, 0.0053138733, 0.008995056, 0.015174866, -0.024780273, 0.0079956055, -0.046081543, 0.02041626, 0.013618469, -0.033843994, -0.03543091, 0.03250122, -0.030776978, 0.006565094, 0.018478394, -0.021820068, -0.011177063, 0.05392456, 0.03543091, -0.04220581, 0.04333496, 0.08691406, 0.018615723, 0.046661377, -0.0035190582, -0.02279663, 0.010154724, 0.03652954, 0.025604248, 0.017715454, 0.09863281, -0.010932922, 0.012580872, -0.0020923615, -0.0023498535, -0.06384277, 0.010192871, -0.016799927, -0.00004476309, -0.0005545616, -0.01928711, 0.013130188, -0.011764526, 0.025909424, -0.013175964, -0.005332947, 0.004535675, 0.014015198, 0.0035152435, 0.00894165, 0.0181427, -0.027023315, -0.011405945, -0.020111084, 0.023635864, -0.018844604, 0.0023918152, -0.001619339, -0.005584717, 0.032470703, -0.032714844, -0.004562378, -0.03491211, 0.0107803345, 0.0023555756, 0.019042969, 0.047668457, 0.027175903, 0.029312134, -0.011512756, 0.030258179, 0.030227661, 0.009590149, 0.012168884, -0.045013428, -0.03567505, 0.052001953, -0.014389038, 0.020965576, 0.04800415, -0.0059051514, 0.049468994, -0.0446167, -0.02507019, -0.021652222, -0.016143799, 0.040374756, -0.00048351288, -0.00907135, 0.027755737, 0.03918457, 0.022949219, 0.00048828125, -0.012184143, 0.042388916, -0.0020370483, -0.009086609, 0.031433105, 0.020950317, 0.0012741089, -0.019454956, -0.0014362335, -0.020339966, -0.050750732, 0.015106201, 0.019073486, -0.027664185, 0.03555298, -0.012039185, -0.016738892, 0.06964111, 0.049468994, -0.0014190674, 0.051971436, -0.03164673, 0.010848999, 0.049713135, -0.0064315796, 0.021453857, 0.026245117, -0.037872314, 0.002954483, -0.017730713, -0.030319214, -0.018463135, 0.004901886, 0.0036354065, 0.0059127808, -0.001745224, -0.027618408, 0.011680603, -0.033966064, -0.014465332, -0.013153076, -0.010414124, 0.056762695, -0.008842468, 0.013458252, -0.04852295, -0.005882263, 0.008674622, -0.016540527, 0.029830933, -0.0065193176, -0.06781006, -0.009002686, -0.02267456, 0.0066337585, 0.019592285, -0.047607422, -0.012771606, 0.0063934326, 0.00008237362, 0.0023441315, -0.002456665, -0.026412964, 0.022506714, -0.009719849, -0.047943115, -0.06323242, -0.016448975, 0.025863647, 0.03024292, 0.03930664, 0.027816772, 0.08319092, 0.017410278, 0.022598267, 0.032104492, -0.009971619, 0.014984131, 0.02053833, -0.08746338, 0.0020809174, -0.0015707016, 0.017608643, -0.01864624, 0.008377075, -0.010116577, -0.008522034, 0.017730713, 0.019744873, -0.04333496, -0.021743774, -0.018417358, -0.0057411194, 0.018295288, -0.020629883, 0.0859375, 0.01134491, 0.0006737709, 0.002691269, -0.004814148, -0.071777344, -0.029907227, 0.015792847, -0.10522461, -0.046539307, 0.025741577, -0.082336426, -0.064453125, -0.026794434, 0.023620605, -0.075805664, 0.009025574, -0.011779785, -0.020370483, 0.009254456, 0.021865845, -0.019958496, -0.0009150505, 0.017868042, 0.020370483, -0.025802612, -0.03616333, 0.041503906, 0.0231781, -0.02508545, 0.011581421, -0.052246094, -0.011062622, -0.05404663, 0.026351929, 0.027038574, -0.018371582, -0.052001953, 0.05355835, 0.031341553, -0.030899048, -0.009414673, 0.028808594, 0.034729004, -0.022277832, 0.0010919571, 0.02507019, 0.009170532, -0.045196533, 0.04360962, -0.0032691956, -0.018249512, 0.019485474, 0.024887085, -0.002937317, 0.023971558, -0.00068473816, -0.0065841675, 0.0070648193, 0.022354126, 0.018737793, -0.040618896, -0.012825012, -0.019592285, -0.0071411133, -0.025756836, -0.01802063, 0.038024902, -0.034301758, 0.03955078, -0.019577026, -0.0047416687, 0.015266418, 0.020248413, 0.00308609, -0.006702423, -0.026489258, -0.062561035, -0.049957275, 0.005809784, 0.024093628, 0.05218506, -0.009140015, -0.03010559, 0.00831604, 0.02519226, 0.033813477, 0.02319336, -0.028671265, -0.045135498, -0.022125244, -0.016937256, -0.042114258, -0.032318115, -0.04534912, -0.006652832, -0.03668213, 0.009552002, -0.032165527, 0.023864746, 0.0028591156, 0.0871582, 0.030715942, 0.04071045, -0.055114746, 0.075805664, -0.027008057, 0.035614014, -0.0146865845, -0.013252258, -0.021865845, 0.04272461, 0.06542969, -0.02796936, -0.015731812, -0.035095215, 0.0090789795, -0.001537323, 0.006652832, 0.0010166168, 0.020248413, 0.017486572, -0.013969421, -0.022888184, -0.0052833557, -0.014045715, 0.07336426, 0.00843811, 0.018585205, -0.029327393, 0.01689148, 0.038238525, 0.010772705, -0.02357483, -0.0010547638, 0.014968872, 0.0039749146, -0.021850586, -0.0103302, 0.01663208, -0.0004940033, -0.04147339, 0.0063095093, 0.012741089, 0.012199402, 0.02798462, 0.023925781, -0.055786133, -0.021453857, -0.05368042, -0.018661499, 0.033477783, -0.03652954, 0.03250122, -0.023452759, -0.023971558, -0.00035214424, 0.052093506, -0.009918213, -0.01763916, -0.035888672, 0.004917145, -0.0043411255, 0.02079773, -0.041992188, -0.0041046143, 0.014877319, -0.019958496, -0.024002075, -0.019424438, -0.033050537, -0.016098022, 0.0014533997, 0.03475952, 0.032073975, 0.018066406, 0.000035583973, 0.020950317, -0.04067993, -0.037322998, 0.053344727, -0.044158936, -0.07244873, 0.0309906, -0.041503906, 0.024795532, -0.023590088, -0.033172607, -0.005504608, 0.035064697, -0.056854248, -0.028930664, 0.025817871, -0.061767578, -0.016036987, -0.03869629, -0.017837524, 0.060821533, 0.03186035, 0.02571106, 0.032684326, -0.015151978, 0.030136108, 0.05859375, 0.0289917, -0.044769287, -0.01550293, 0.033966064, -0.016204834, 0.0061187744, -0.01802063, -0.024841309, -0.07543945, -0.068847656, -0.012557983, -0.07354736, 0.018310547, -0.027175903, 0.005458832, -0.061279297, -0.013496399, -0.025314331, 0.021316528, -0.016998291, 0.048309326, -0.012718201, 0.0060043335, 0.020812988, -0.027496338, -0.0030727386, 0.032104492, 0.023025513, 0.0014829636, -0.02331543, 0.02015686, 0.012245178, -0.001783371, 0.00554657, -0.006401062, -0.038146973, -0.054351807, 0.05532837, -0.019012451, -0.021774292, -0.030044556, 0.010528564, 0.01473999, -0.01687622, -0.060791016, -0.00065231323, -0.021713257, -0.03817749, 0.032073975, -0.008468628, 0.013168335, -0.002336502, -0.024261475, -0.008285522, 0.042663574, 0.002571106, -0.01612854, 0.030838013, -0.013999939, 0.019699097, 0.00982666, -0.0041007996, 0.0049438477, 0.013038635, 0.0026245117, -0.020751953, 0.030731201, 0.008422852, 0.030578613, -0.0043907166, -0.027496338, -0.028701782, 0.0104522705, -0.034484863, -0.008811951, 0.020629883, -0.015411377, -0.0022563934, -0.031158447, -0.009803772, -0.034454346, 0.021560669, -0.00881958, -0.00025582314, -0.028869629, -0.038116455, 0.046569824, 0.010871887, 0.0019874573, -0.05532837, 0.022109985, 0.05810547, 0.010765076, 0.066833496, 0.0024375916, -0.014953613, -0.0027656555, -0.014846802, 0.015327454, 0.005016327, 0.043304443, 0.0074691772, -0.025497437, 0.017211914, 0.021377563, 0.031036377, -0.011054993, 0.02859497, 0.0063972473, 0.021942139, 0.0152282715, 0.018981934, -0.013023376, 0.012001038, 0.072021484, -0.0066490173, 0.0040740967, -0.0033340454, 0.0045433044, -0.007972717, -0.04498291, -0.0025672913, -0.02998352, 0.00070619583, -0.02104187, 0.041381836, -0.039367676, -0.009124756, -0.01486969, -0.02029419, 0.028778076, -0.05709839, 0.016281128, -0.02885437, 0.013404846, -0.002576828, -0.040985107, 0.04421997, 0.0012378693, 0.02217102, 0.040649414, 0.022644043, -0.032714844, 0.024261475, 0.03326416, -0.028579712, -0.051116943, -0.048980713, 0.047729492, -0.048797607, 0.05545044, 0.03189087, 0.022903442, 0.015975952, 0.06488037, -0.00017404556, -0.00017929077, 0.037841797, -0.021499634, 0.015037537, 0.0043792725, -0.00995636, 0.003074646, 0.039916992, 0.03125, -0.033172607, 0.034851074, 0.041809082, 0.03363037, -0.025100708, 0.003200531, 0.004486084, 0.016174316, -0.0018701553, -0.0078048706, -0.05645752, -0.0112838745, -0.0009303093, -0.02571106, -0.032287598, -0.08526611, 0.006259918, -0.009231567, -0.030456543, -0.015151978, -0.05996704, 0.049438477, -0.12670898, 0.001791954, 0.057128906, 0.024032593, -0.002521515, -0.011024475, 0.0113220215, 0.02218628, -0.036376953, 0.0062408447, 0.019454956, -0.009796143, 0.008056641, 0.066345215, 0.028747559, 0.032806396, -0.0546875, -0.009216309, -0.0014629364, -0.018112183, -0.0053215027, -0.023345947, -0.0012111664, 0.013656616, 0.020858765, 0.033813477, 0.05606079, -0.05545044, -0.0028858185, 0.0007081032, -0.025863647, 0.0028381348, 0.0077934265, -0.023757935, -0.027679443, -0.0051879883, 0.019363403, 0.02709961, -0.031463623, 0.052001953, 0.003862381, -0.053955078, 0.048065186, 0.059539795, 0.05053711, -0.057861328, -0.017547607, 0.07946777, 0.07446289, 0.121276855, 0.034118652, -0.053100586, -0.031402588, 0.028930664, 0.027008057, 0.034423828, -0.041931152, 0.09240723, -0.004901886, -0.050109863, 0.004512787, 0.0038871765, -0.0107040405, 0.054351807, -0.04244995, 0.03866577, -0.00699234, 0.0052337646, -0.022415161, -0.022323608, 0.04522705, 0.013893127, -0.041748047, 0.0076065063, 0.02305603, -0.012802124, 0.039611816, 0.014015198, -0.018875122, -0.044647217, -0.015838623, -0.017593384, -0.015853882, -0.03579712, -0.0016155243, -0.013648987, -0.010520935, -0.055908203, -0.058135986, 0.015960693, 0.059539795, 0.028884888, -0.03817749, -0.012329102, -0.025222778, -0.005104065, -0.024871826, -0.00868988, -0.0002501011, 0.01802063, 0.02822876, 0.055511475, 0.02444458, -0.03970337, 0.04260254, 0.010505676, -0.054138184, 0.002588272, -0.0055999756, 0.041534424, -0.0059890747, -0.006942749, 0.019134521, -0.04055786, -0.04156494, 0.023651123, -0.063964844, 0.003583908, -0.051330566, -0.012214661, -0.010734558, -0.084350586, -0.00894165, -0.017242432, -0.053833008, 0.022262573, 0.017837524, -0.01083374, -0.027511597, 0.019439697, -0.013946533, 0.010284424, 0.02859497, 0.010253906, 0.05065918, -0.007896423, 0.02519226, 0.022033691, -0.059570312, -0.020599365, -0.06402588, -0.008277893, -0.011558533, -0.018585205, 0.033599854, 0.019760132, 0.010017395, 0.026031494, 0.04168701, 0.07171631, 0.015556335, 0.034454346, 0.027282715, 0.021591187, 0.0040779114 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1711.10558v1
Intent-Aware Contextual Recommendation System
Biswarup Bhattacharya, Iftikhar Burhanuddin, Abhilasha Sancheti, Kushal Satya
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Recommender systems take inputs from user history, use an internal ranking algorithm to generate results and possibly optimize this ranking based on feedback. However, often the recommender system is unaware of the actual intent of the user and simply provides recommendations dynamically without properly understanding the thought process of the user. An intelligent recommender system is not only useful for the user but also for businesses which want to learn the tendencies of their users. Finding out tendencies or intents of a user is a difficult problem to solve. Keeping this in mind, we sought out to create an intelligent system which will keep track of the user's activity on a web-application as well as determine the intent of the user in each session. We devised a way to encode the user's activity through the sessions. Then, we have represented the information seen by the user in a high dimensional format which is reduced to lower dimensions using tensor factorization techniques. The aspect of intent awareness (or scoring) is dealt with at this stage. Finally, combining the user activity data with the contextual information gives the recommendation score. The final recommendations are then ranked using filtering and collaborative recommendation techniques to show the top-k recommendations to the user. A provision for feedback is also envisioned in the current system which informs the model to update the various weights in the recommender system. Our overall model aims to combine both frequency-based and context-based recommendation systems and quantify the intent of a user to provide better recommendations. We ran experiments on real-world timestamped user activity data, in the setting of recommending reports to the users of a business analytics tool and the results are better than the baselines. We also tuned certain aspects of our model to arrive at optimized results.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1711.10558v1
2017-11-28T21:58:52
2017-11-28T21:58:52
{ "title": [ 0.012794495, 0.014190674, -0.04623413, -0.056671143, 0.04360962, -0.012107849, 0.0052719116, -0.010505676, 0.004219055, 0.048065186, -0.022247314, 0.01184082, 0.0060920715, -0.013595581, -0.039367676, 0.016204834, -0.012718201, 0.039367676, -0.02848816, -0.047851562, -0.016067505, -0.05319214, 0.014183044, 0.043518066, 0.01876831, -0.022109985, -0.052703857, 0.029815674, -0.03640747, -0.009628296, -0.008415222, -0.010681152, 0.03475952, 0.016143799, -0.010345459, 0.014457703, -0.070251465, 0.01979065, -0.014862061, 0.026824951, 0.024337769, -0.002779007, -0.051239014, -0.022949219, -0.05999756, 0.02017212, -0.043182373, 0.019302368, -0.015075684, 0.034423828, 0.040649414, 0.020324707, 0.010047913, 0.006626129, 0.022064209, -0.019363403, -0.060180664, -0.0030345917, 0.03591919, 0.032196045, 0.027557373, -0.05493164, 0.032440186, 0.013671875, -0.02999878, -0.011909485, -0.014823914, 0.02281189, 0.045532227, 0.0027694702, -0.014251709, 0.007827759, 0.0107421875, 0.018844604, -0.0340271, -0.017745972, 0.050048828, -0.0036907196, 0.029327393, -0.014289856, -0.033111572, -0.0019683838, -0.014915466, -0.037078857, 0.0046920776, -0.033050537, -0.023147583, -0.003730774, -0.031555176, -0.04373169, -0.008972168, -0.011940002, 0.018157959, 0.038208008, -0.043792725, 0.008911133, 0.030807495, 0.056396484, -0.005542755, -0.048065186, -0.02583313, 0.02130127, -0.08581543, -0.01600647, 0.014793396, 0.040740967, -0.015197754, -0.017089844, 0.012260437, 0.021591187, -0.01499939, 0.018478394, 0.04458618, 0.066467285, -0.028930664, -0.040893555, 0.0043945312, 0.0014371872, -0.03466797, 0.044006348, -0.0022258759, -0.02078247, 0.003250122, -0.0074768066, 0.040893555, 0.009513855, -0.048217773, 0.0068511963, -0.026977539, 0.049804688, 0.019851685, 0.04437256, -0.10681152, -0.07067871, -0.073913574, 0.034606934, -0.01020813, 0.0049057007, -0.00035238266, -0.007598877, 0.026626587, -0.012016296, -0.006111145, 0.04763794, 0.02822876, -0.007926941, 0.03503418, 0.003080368, -0.021209717, -0.012992859, -0.005908966, 0.003932953, 0.034301758, -0.02281189, -0.033721924, -0.014480591, -0.10479736, -0.032989502, 0.015510559, -0.0034427643, -0.0028514862, -0.006801605, 0.022460938, 0.014724731, 0.054260254, 0.014930725, -0.014526367, 0.03062439, -0.002948761, 0.019607544, 0.006011963, 0.027038574, -0.029510498, -0.016738892, 0.0057296753, -0.012031555, 0.03729248, 0.022460938, 0.016281128, 0.020339966, 0.010543823, -0.022918701, 0.033813477, 0.014579773, -0.068603516, -0.0013055801, 0.013793945, 0.019714355, 0.02268982, 0.011100769, -0.0082473755, 0.037109375, -0.03933716, -0.03643799, -0.060821533, -0.016983032, 0.035095215, 0.053131104, -0.016113281, 0.031311035, -0.0007929802, -0.007129669, -0.023880005, 0.0017023087, -0.031799316, -0.0309906, -0.020202637, 0.018157959, -0.008583069, 0.056243896, 0.041992188, 0.02508545, -0.032714844, -0.014144897, -0.00944519, -0.05001831, -0.0051574707, -0.01725769, -0.007972717, -0.0056495667, -0.009925842, -0.00415802, -0.013114929, 0.03189087, 0.035980225, -0.0036144257, 0.012390137, -0.017303467, 0.04724121, 0.029632568, 0.04598999, -0.033843994, 0.024810791, 0.00035881996, -0.021148682, -0.033355713, -0.017868042, -0.007133484, 0.014595032, 0.01727295, -0.00598526, 0.0024280548, 0.008148193, 0.08215332, 0.039001465, -0.016830444, 0.0011825562, 0.05355835, 0.041534424, 0.05834961, 0.046417236, 0.0061950684, 0.040771484, 0.03643799, -0.0052452087, 0.049102783, -0.010940552, 0.030929565, -0.036315918, 0.014930725, -0.0013666153, 0.03643799, 0.033935547, 0.01285553, -0.07336426, 0.017837524, -0.03302002, 0.007282257, -0.015235901, -0.0005431175, 0.041015625, 0.03692627, 0.00027394295, -0.0231781, 0.022354126, -0.04055786, -0.037109375, 0.03189087, 0.023712158, -0.078430176, -0.011436462, -0.01914978, 0.004634857, 0.0053863525, 0.04763794, 0.00031137466, 0.008590698, -0.0013751984, -0.010498047, -0.025634766, 0.03942871, 0.039123535, 0.01789856, -0.004234314, 0.008422852, -0.0066871643, 0.07525635, 0.08239746, -0.041870117, 0.04019165, -0.0496521, 0.011772156, 0.013542175, -0.031234741, -0.015258789, 0.05239868, 0.018844604, -0.0026283264, -0.03881836, 0.015098572, -0.055480957, -0.0132751465, 0.011001587, -0.053833008, -0.031311035, -0.037322998, 0.006362915, -0.042633057, -0.049591064, -0.01965332, 0.13195801, -0.03048706, -0.0033740997, -0.010482788, -0.016601562, -0.047332764, -0.007068634, -0.03265381, -0.05166626, 0.033599854, 0.029296875, 0.01864624, -0.04083252, 0.014640808, -0.0069999695, 0.02192688, -0.017913818, -0.013038635, -0.027175903, 0.03060913, 0.017089844, -0.017074585, 0.017700195, -0.06225586, 0.012779236, -0.05206299, 0.016799927, 0.016494751, 0.016448975, 0.008468628, 0.003982544, -0.011230469, -0.012588501, 0.030319214, 0.06518555, -0.038238525, -0.028579712, 0.051849365, 0.02468872, -0.0073280334, 0.039611816, 0.016983032, 0.016448975, -0.07171631, -0.009437561, -0.044006348, -0.0064735413, -0.024459839, 0.0005378723, 0.0574646, -0.046417236, 0.00062799454, -0.048034668, -0.005607605, 0.0002219677, 0.020462036, 0.0074043274, -0.015586853, -0.014122009, -0.013755798, 0.007286072, 0.010505676, -0.029693604, -0.029510498, 0.04928589, 0.025894165, -0.0067596436, 0.005882263, 0.03765869, -0.007545471, -0.0047416687, -0.0019435883, -0.018463135, 0.0048980713, 0.031677246, 0.010284424, -0.008995056, -0.0005531311, -0.105407715, -0.017990112, 0.02204895, 0.018203735, -0.026062012, 0.019683838, -0.076049805, -0.0036411285, -0.024642944, -0.02859497, 0.04071045, 0.047546387, -0.011222839, 0.034606934, -0.0006570816, 0.00096702576, -0.010276794, -0.029006958, -0.080200195, 0.029266357, 0.0034427643, -0.04232788, -0.022705078, -0.036102295, -0.04876709, -0.0049362183, 0.0024871826, 0.058380127, 0.03451538, 0.01171875, 0.04006958, -0.040496826, 0.009353638, -0.045410156, 0.002357483, -0.006755829, -0.03265381, 0.0076141357, -0.011650085, 0.04425049, 0.03439331, -0.022567749, -0.020614624, 0.013076782, -0.014930725, 0.042999268, 0.0055885315, -0.038085938, 0.0059127808, -0.032043457, -0.030929565, -0.0067749023, -0.017944336, 0.0057640076, -0.026977539, 0.013267517, 0.0016555786, 0.03555298, 0.029296875, 0.010551453, -0.024246216, -0.020645142, 0.010543823, -0.021347046, -0.036865234, -0.009605408, 0.02520752, -0.0236969, 0.056610107, -0.025909424, -0.021392822, 0.035369873, -0.03378296, -0.0025177002, -0.0075302124, -0.02078247, 0.015068054, 0.017822266, -0.011924744, 0.0065841675, -0.019699097, -0.014762878, 0.020446777, -0.0069999695, -0.006790161, -0.06744385, -0.002122879, -0.006340027, -0.13500977, -0.035949707, 0.0033073425, -0.04144287, -0.04437256, -0.05014038, 0.021087646, -0.048034668, -0.04385376, 0.002363205, -0.012367249, -0.041870117, -0.0051574707, -0.07409668, -0.02154541, 0.057769775, -0.006477356, 0.02734375, 0.022766113, 0.00274086, 0.0074005127, -0.008682251, 0.02078247, -0.038970947, 0.06536865, -0.0025901794, -0.013793945, 0.032714844, -0.024887085, -0.00009006262, 0.056365967, 0.00006252527, 0.009346008, -0.005214691, 0.031311035, 0.06124878, -0.05819702, 0.037353516, 0.06768799, -0.038208008, -0.054626465, 0.016662598, 0.0103302, -0.004070282, -0.010879517, -0.03164673, 0.0039367676, 0.0132369995, 0.04168701, 0.04336548, 0.0042800903, -0.009307861, 0.045959473, 0.0030288696, 0.014266968, -0.009140015, 0.008583069, 0.0134887695, 0.005012512, -0.0009417534, -0.028503418, 0.011207581, 0.0064086914, -0.033355713, -0.012069702, 0.0067710876, -0.047668457, 0.0038051605, -0.030929565, -0.05731201, -0.036956787, 0.030426025, -0.02027893, -0.002702713, 0.056030273, 0.0057907104, -0.04562378, 0.011299133, 0.059814453, -0.016326904, 0.00080776215, -0.07751465, 0.0095825195, -0.019821167, -0.04937744, -0.019638062, -0.040649414, -0.04421997, 0.04309082, -0.0013227463, -0.015716553, 0.011482239, 0.014137268, 0.021621704, 0.0552063, -0.008834839, -0.031082153, 0.030303955, -0.027923584, -0.022064209, 0.029006958, 0.0010633469, 0.0062942505, -0.004940033, 0.043029785, -0.026626587, -0.0012369156, -0.050109863, 0.01260376, -0.030517578, 0.023071289, 0.020721436, 0.062042236, 0.023422241, 0.016311646, 0.0071868896, 0.015975952, -0.03488159, -0.016586304, -0.010124207, 0.03677368, 0.009132385, 0.020309448, 0.04534912, 0.013031006, 0.023452759, -0.00623703, -0.012245178, 0.028030396, 0.0022697449, -0.048706055, 0.049591064, -0.010925293, -0.006515503, -0.0018434525, 0.01512146, 0.049194336, -0.056396484, 0.058288574, -0.010246277, 0.017669678, 0.013710022, -0.014816284, 0.018951416, -0.04196167, 0.022964478, -0.06286621, -0.017807007, -0.004096985, 0.02279663, -0.04244995, 0.008544922, 0.016555786, 0.015304565, 0.037506104, 0.04260254, 0.042388916, -0.0004181862, -0.012939453, 0.00020992756, 0.015960693, -0.023971558, -0.022232056, 0.019104004, 0.021087646, 0.0061798096, -0.03692627, -0.028518677, -0.02748108, -0.040618896, -0.011222839, -0.002855301, 0.0102005005, -0.062316895, 0.022979736, 0.05532837, 0.014183044, 0.0178833, 0.0051498413, 0.026321411, 0.02897644, 0.033843994, 0.0234375, 0.011352539, 0.026351929, -0.062561035, 0.02154541, 0.0062408447, -0.009887695, -0.0013685226, 0.023117065, 0.000042021275, -0.009422302, -0.02331543, 0.029251099, -0.004299164, -0.024810791, -0.01600647, -0.02960205, -0.008544922, 0.01828003, 0.036834717, 0.042144775, -0.03741455, -0.03286743, -0.036895752, 0.003917694, -0.07366943, 0.016204834, 0.024475098, -0.017501831, -0.07489014, 0.022369385, -0.034210205, 0.014862061, -0.0057258606, 0.033813477, -0.029418945, 0.03677368, 0.0390625, -0.015052795, -0.0031700134, -0.027786255, 0.003917694, 0.033691406, 0.043151855, -0.018920898, 0.013824463, -0.046081543, -0.052947998, -0.042144775, -0.015090942, 0.00440979, 0.03479004, -0.0025558472, -0.055908203, 0.0029964447, 0.031158447, 0.03378296, 0.0038032532, -0.020080566, 0.021591187, 0.021987915, 0.018966675, -0.019165039, 0.06402588, -0.0015077591, -0.009132385, 0.012481689, -0.028549194, 0.028442383, 0.0040245056, 0.026046753, -0.018539429, -0.064941406, 0.009178162, 0.029953003, 0.010406494, 0.0033798218, 0.00894165, 0.036071777, 0.03881836, -0.019165039, 0.011634827, 0.053741455, -0.042053223, -0.017562866, -0.021408081, -0.001613617, -0.03894043, 0.047851562, 0.007724762, -0.01890564, -0.051239014, -0.056732178, -0.028411865, 0.017715454, 0.021774292, 0.028259277, 0.019104004, -0.033294678, 0.018066406, -0.030441284, 0.005393982, -0.008842468, 0.027130127, 0.005657196, 0.0023918152, -0.03942871, 0.011512756, 0.023666382, -0.03225708, 0.03829956, -0.028671265, -0.024597168, -0.011131287, -0.022125244, 0.04043579, -0.033599854, -0.0035991669, 0.03829956, 0.016906738, -0.015640259, 0.04034424, -0.047302246, 0.04977417, 0.031707764, 0.031707764, 0.049713135, 0.0030326843, 0.01676941, 0.012046814, 0.02204895, -0.032806396, 0.01084137, -0.054016113, 0.0063552856, -0.039123535, -0.009094238, -0.07714844, -0.013618469, 0.036865234, 0.018600464, 0.02923584, 0.00881958, 0.028457642, -0.009918213, 0.028305054, -0.021942139, 0.045013428, 0.031951904, 0.016967773, -0.0463562, 0.0011615753, 0.024841309, 0.030075073, -0.0043640137, 0.023132324, -0.03616333, -0.0055999756, -0.0076293945, 0.009941101, 0.020492554, -0.010726929, -0.020568848, -0.028320312, 0.0152282715, -0.002357483, 0.037322998, 0.020904541, 0.051849365, -0.018966675, 0.012031555, -0.0008277893, -0.00459671, -0.018478394, -0.008361816, 0.041290283, -0.067871094, 0.0345459, -0.0061836243, -0.024047852, -0.022644043, -0.008666992, 0.047088623, -0.07409668, -0.04849243, 0.027145386, 0.03564453, -0.027786255, 0.006252289, -0.042541504, -0.016647339, 0.024215698, 0.025909424, -0.029891968, -0.0256958, 0.015899658, 0.04284668, -0.011489868, -0.014549255, -0.012214661, 0.033447266, -0.05218506, 0.01663208, -0.014808655, 0.012794495, -0.034362793, -0.048553467, 0.022659302, -0.012458801, -0.024536133, -0.018371582, 0.035461426, 0.047332764, 0.03149414, 0.066467285, -0.001411438, -0.01701355, -0.0023765564, -0.027664185, 0.026062012, 0.009689331, -0.03753662, 0.02911377, -0.04232788, -0.022949219, 0.012931824, -0.066101074, 0.0022144318, -0.035125732, 0.0209198, 0.0073280334, -0.016998291, 0.03250122, -0.047027588, -0.00044059753, 0.0049552917, -0.016448975, -0.009376526, -0.0062561035, -0.020568848, -0.034332275, 0.0055236816, 0.037841797, 0.015472412, -0.013519287, -0.01663208, -0.015266418, -0.045440674, -0.004917145, -0.03024292, 0.02746582, -0.039154053, -0.015151978, 0.0024032593, -0.015426636, -0.01348114, -0.025268555, -0.021514893, -0.008735657, -0.02116394, -0.011222839, 0.01361084, 0.026748657, -0.01374054, -0.05230713, 0.02960205, -0.0059051514, -0.025146484, -0.0033683777, 0.021957397, -0.03439331, -0.05355835, -0.018966675, -0.034332275, 0.0068626404, 0.019638062, -0.031280518, -0.004306793, 0.01977539, -0.050933838, -0.06036377, -0.024932861, 0.022720337, -0.013473511, -0.027313232, -0.0101623535, 0.030136108, 0.020217896, -0.070251465, -0.034057617, 0.011238098, 0.06964111, -0.025787354, 0.07342529, 0.022537231, 0.0046920776, -0.009384155, 0.029663086, -0.00003582239, -0.024734497, -0.0039520264, -0.034484863, 0.03213501, 0.06072998, -0.014884949, 0.003698349, 0.045410156, 0.017822266, 0.006122589, 0.02293396, 0.0011329651, 0.016235352, 0.0011997223, 0.032806396, -0.028778076, -0.029785156, -0.039001465, 0.02432251, -0.0037517548, 0.04763794, -0.016174316, 0.01687622, 0.012557983, 0.06976318, -0.0079956055, -0.06304932, 0.03414917, -0.0022068024, 0.009117126, 0.035095215, 0.008872986, -0.042755127, -0.0010194778, -0.0044288635, -0.004989624, -0.005016327, 0.032409668, -0.049224854, -0.005126953, -0.028930664, -0.025161743, -0.05618286, -0.030532837, 0.037384033, -0.033203125, -0.021331787, -0.007820129, -0.05239868, -0.010322571, 0.036590576, -0.02748108, -0.035339355, -0.051483154, 0.024429321, 0.056427002, -0.015991211 ], "summary": [ 0.07623291, 0.018875122, 0.005466461, 0.013900757, 0.010566711, -0.034942627, 0.02722168, -0.06323242, 0.06149292, 0.008842468, -0.09197998, -0.01802063, 0.011711121, -0.0075798035, -0.023666382, -0.045928955, -0.008422852, 0.0037994385, -0.017288208, -0.030563354, 0.03543091, -0.062316895, 0.017745972, 0.06488037, 0.011375427, -0.011306763, 0.022827148, 0.040893555, 0.030914307, 0.0463562, 0.027450562, -0.07879639, 0.004234314, 0.007408142, 0.008666992, -0.041290283, 0.014007568, -0.017745972, 0.020095825, 0.006439209, 0.04019165, -0.016540527, 0.04006958, -0.021987915, 0.01235199, 0.012329102, 0.042419434, -0.033599854, 0.02128601, -0.059570312, 0.011352539, 0.062286377, 0.023895264, -0.045898438, -0.030410767, 0.0075645447, -0.04171753, 0.019454956, 0.030410767, -0.02116394, -0.013084412, -0.04333496, 0.038909912, -0.0006375313, -0.030136108, 0.0022010803, 0.052215576, -0.0073165894, -0.009605408, -0.03945923, 0.028152466, 0.01586914, -0.0011405945, 0.009727478, -0.025680542, -0.007633209, 0.033843994, 0.0074691772, 0.0005912781, 0.0077056885, -0.05517578, 0.03213501, -0.047058105, -0.05645752, -0.006702423, -0.045806885, -0.04208374, 0.016708374, 0.031341553, -0.007095337, 0.0054512024, 0.005584717, -0.0038223267, 0.06921387, 0.0070991516, -0.024963379, 0.029708862, -0.014289856, 0.011543274, -0.034729004, 0.012329102, -0.027801514, -0.059783936, 0.008300781, 0.016586304, 0.078552246, 0.0006890297, -0.011268616, 0.02217102, -0.014297485, 0.008277893, -0.008056641, 0.056671143, -0.00037002563, -0.012611389, -0.011627197, 0.022964478, 0.0440979, -0.011734009, 0.04284668, -0.02835083, -0.0015621185, 0.008430481, 0.024963379, 0.03314209, 0.017654419, 0.0012483597, -0.0028896332, 0.0284729, 0.0038471222, -0.024810791, 0.038635254, -0.015289307, -0.011123657, -0.037475586, 0.00818634, 0.0076026917, -0.0061569214, 0.034454346, -0.036987305, 0.0574646, 0.0034008026, 0.005317688, 0.06958008, 0.034088135, 0.013572693, 0.02482605, 0.008216858, 0.004234314, -0.0143585205, 0.055145264, 0.0043640137, 0.03378296, -0.0124053955, -0.020965576, -0.058441162, -0.013580322, -0.03012085, 0.03277588, -0.031402588, -0.024276733, -0.0022258759, 0.06726074, 0.008102417, 0.01940918, 0.01713562, -0.025802612, -0.011100769, 0.0033931732, -0.05316162, 0.025787354, -0.0040359497, -0.04333496, -0.018112183, 0.026290894, 0.00035524368, 0.031677246, 0.012336731, -0.0340271, 0.05380249, 0.010261536, -0.04498291, -0.010719299, 0.0021743774, -0.019454956, 0.043914795, 0.021499634, 0.0597229, -0.014129639, 0.013824463, 0.012870789, 0.019699097, -0.012580872, -0.016586304, 0.0013875961, 0.01171875, 0.02494812, 0.040802002, -0.005569458, -0.024353027, 0.033721924, -0.011428833, -0.037994385, -0.032165527, -0.13317871, -0.0030097961, -0.041870117, 0.04055786, -0.009864807, 0.02458191, 0.02003479, -0.008811951, -0.045562744, 0.035614014, 0.00497818, -0.033355713, 0.033111572, -0.06970215, -0.0051574707, -0.038848877, -0.02432251, 0.07989502, -0.05316162, 0.034210205, 0.0124053955, -0.0016021729, -0.011680603, 0.010856628, 0.013450623, 0.01335907, 0.035583496, 0.017532349, 0.033996582, 0.057006836, -0.0025577545, -0.03475952, -0.0064468384, -0.08258057, 0.021652222, 0.029907227, -0.006072998, 0.009628296, -0.0096206665, 0.10662842, -0.027404785, -0.0059814453, 0.019470215, 0.07092285, -0.0015544891, 0.064941406, 0.009307861, 0.025177002, 0.001748085, -0.031921387, -0.008483887, 0.030258179, -0.0067710876, 0.023223877, 0.018447876, -0.0018882751, -0.015335083, 0.022994995, 0.039916992, 0.0063591003, -0.023162842, 0.037963867, 0.023742676, 0.030776978, 0.006614685, -0.022888184, 0.008201599, 0.0035991669, -0.004737854, -0.05618286, 0.0146865845, -0.08117676, -0.027862549, 0.032592773, 0.01084137, -0.07513428, 0.0052223206, -0.0048675537, -0.010696411, -0.012580872, 0.04559326, 0.022384644, 0.004989624, 0.012031555, -0.00015473366, 0.027404785, 0.022232056, 0.05441284, 0.008422852, 0.0030956268, 0.024215698, 0.015258789, 0.03152466, 0.013641357, 0.009185791, -0.02029419, -0.022384644, 0.028076172, -0.020324707, -0.009613037, -0.012992859, 0.03112793, 0.011520386, -0.02368164, -0.018798828, 0.004333496, -0.055145264, -0.017211914, 0.023910522, 0.018478394, -0.028625488, -0.022628784, -0.019927979, 0.022354126, -0.049743652, -0.022216797, 0.14672852, -0.006340027, 0.0028438568, -0.0110321045, -0.017700195, -0.061431885, 0.01979065, -0.04006958, -0.044830322, -0.008842468, -0.024856567, -0.041625977, -0.041625977, 0.039886475, 0.0105896, 0.018676758, 0.00023901463, -0.04537964, -0.0020637512, 0.020477295, 0.010498047, 0.0052757263, -0.009231567, -0.051879883, -0.032684326, -0.019500732, 0.016159058, -0.00032901764, 0.036254883, -0.00048351288, 0.008628845, -0.008338928, -0.03778076, 0.03805542, 0.0038414001, -0.01725769, 0.034820557, 0.032989502, -0.010803223, -0.030960083, 0.08831787, 0.025756836, 0.0368042, -0.11035156, -0.02709961, -0.039093018, -0.0055389404, -0.062286377, 0.022415161, 0.031082153, -0.008651733, 0.029144287, -0.07385254, 0.003250122, 0.008621216, 0.03024292, 0.117370605, 0.028839111, 0.0068588257, 0.06866455, 0.03665161, 0.016967773, -0.020874023, -0.04623413, 0.022018433, 0.013130188, 0.01374054, -0.0057029724, 0.043640137, -0.003534317, 0.021896362, -0.009727478, -0.010307312, -0.014251709, -0.0027503967, 0.002067566, -0.048034668, -0.0011434555, -0.0440979, -0.0060157776, -0.025421143, 0.02116394, 0.010223389, -0.0003838539, -0.027664185, -0.00008279085, -0.010185242, -0.026138306, 0.0032215118, 0.031555176, 0.023208618, -0.033996582, -0.00082588196, -0.005844116, 0.015197754, -0.028564453, 0.019470215, 0.01411438, 0.007663727, -0.04510498, -0.01889038, 0.06524658, 0.010269165, 0.010665894, -0.012214661, 0.06555176, -0.020111084, 0.0057258606, 0.02999878, -0.02255249, -0.021362305, -0.019744873, -0.02557373, -0.053955078, -0.016464233, -0.0073127747, -0.009567261, 0.002008438, -0.015991211, -0.004295349, -0.044036865, 0.0020008087, 0.00025057793, 0.016098022, -0.027389526, 0.02168274, 0.0027580261, -0.045074463, -0.006526947, -0.0052490234, -0.016296387, 0.0012817383, 0.005554199, 0.03805542, -0.011238098, 0.051086426, 0.0051231384, 0.048980713, 0.02116394, -0.017410278, 0.040283203, -0.012611389, -0.03604126, 0.025390625, -0.0057373047, -0.012458801, 0.078063965, -0.009963989, -0.023101807, 0.034606934, -0.029022217, -0.035003662, -0.023040771, -0.045959473, 0.0058288574, -0.07281494, 0.019821167, 0.0020503998, 0.042053223, -0.035888672, -0.028381348, 0.01586914, -0.05810547, -0.07116699, -0.028244019, -0.0110321045, -0.08996582, -0.065979004, 0.008216858, -0.013305664, -0.052581787, 0.012626648, 0.023406982, -0.020431519, 0.025604248, -0.005844116, -0.022872925, 0.091430664, 0.017044067, -0.06958008, 0.020263672, -0.021743774, 0.015625, 0.003271103, -0.030578613, 0.015548706, 0.06524658, 0.026535034, 0.005607605, -0.05532837, 0.07904053, -0.018722534, 0.010948181, 0.004776001, -0.0038986206, -0.021011353, 0.061920166, 0.012077332, -0.011405945, -0.0036506653, 0.060546875, 0.113098145, -0.06573486, 0.0022716522, 0.045196533, -0.027404785, -0.03527832, 0.011512756, -0.0020637512, -0.028335571, -0.005580902, 0.023040771, -0.007709503, 0.018203735, 0.03744507, -0.028366089, 0.0012989044, -0.04751587, 0.005657196, 0.049591064, -0.01713562, -0.017364502, 0.021850586, 0.039398193, 0.0039787292, 0.0059127808, -0.03152466, -0.02029419, 0.032226562, -0.029708862, -0.035095215, -0.019302368, -0.054626465, -0.0070266724, 0.016189575, -0.0637207, -0.066101074, 0.03050232, 0.009498596, -0.0041122437, 0.056854248, 0.024353027, -0.030776978, -0.01612854, 0.016921997, -0.0016174316, -0.049194336, -0.101989746, -0.041778564, -0.022598267, -0.064331055, -0.015419006, -0.07476807, -0.08465576, -0.012901306, 0.022277832, -0.011306763, 0.012870789, 0.01348114, 0.009254456, -0.0011777878, -0.000538826, -0.017349243, -0.020004272, -0.028213501, 0.025436401, 0.003616333, 0.020767212, 0.010978699, 0.023910522, 0.050354004, -0.021255493, -0.01689148, -0.03970337, -0.017288208, -0.005443573, -0.0072517395, 0.016067505, 0.040039062, -0.0025634766, 0.013847351, 0.013435364, 0.016326904, -0.01828003, -0.016799927, -0.00018811226, -0.0013713837, 0.023513794, 0.021820068, 0.021728516, -0.018417358, -0.011955261, -0.013442993, 0.02130127, -0.01373291, -0.011116028, -0.034210205, 0.015792847, 0.0041275024, 0.022476196, 0.023727417, -0.021896362, 0.036499023, 0.0078125, -0.011276245, 0.0019044876, 0.03692627, -0.004562378, -0.03744507, 0.010307312, -0.028396606, 0.009269714, -0.03164673, 0.02558899, 0.008857727, -0.04348755, -0.012420654, -0.009521484, 0.019851685, -0.017730713, 0.020401001, 0.020004272, 0.006931305, 0.0016784668, 0.025222778, 0.0048828125, 0.009773254, -0.0101623535, 0.016494751, -0.028961182, 0.023651123, -0.013725281, -0.023498535, -0.072631836, 0.040740967, -0.060546875, -0.028915405, -0.0027503967, -0.0065727234, -0.038146973, -0.04650879, 0.007331848, -0.0051002502, 0.014671326, 0.030136108, -0.029449463, -0.0126953125, 0.013061523, -0.03253174, 0.025985718, -0.023910522, -0.023910522, 0.0209198, 0.0010881424, 0.00065517426, -0.012039185, 0.03579712, 0.0068855286, 0.005680084, -0.028915405, 0.007888794, -0.030426025, -0.0035972595, -0.07879639, 0.027664185, -0.009246826, 0.0115356445, 0.04763794, 0.013755798, -0.009407043, -0.019088745, -0.03564453, 0.009056091, -0.05908203, 0.016067505, 0.02017212, -0.024398804, -0.021194458, 0.00819397, -0.03289795, -0.024047852, 0.025024414, 0.037475586, 0.01576233, -0.025863647, 0.036834717, -0.004650116, 0.047698975, -0.026123047, 0.009773254, 0.002483368, 0.017669678, 0.030853271, 0.012969971, -0.031204224, -0.025726318, -0.008087158, -0.04901123, -0.03387451, 0.067993164, -0.008590698, -0.019378662, 0.029815674, 0.00667572, 0.02029419, 0.030014038, -0.020462036, 0.006149292, -0.022064209, -0.026519775, 0.004722595, 0.030456543, 0.01474762, -0.008880615, -0.0050811768, -0.056854248, 0.01689148, -0.0018539429, 0.022567749, -0.04800415, -0.05078125, 0.006416321, 0.036590576, 0.012489319, 0.0039634705, 0.014259338, 0.011650085, 0.008560181, -0.010635376, -0.0079574585, 0.011528015, -0.016235352, 0.0013742447, -0.014709473, 0.035339355, -0.047210693, -0.02760315, 0.0030441284, 0.0082473755, -0.019607544, -0.036865234, -0.0013475418, 0.0061798096, 0.035491943, 0.013404846, 0.06591797, -0.016143799, -0.009895325, -0.0135650635, 0.0073051453, 0.01940918, 0.0042419434, 0.0047569275, 0.022094727, -0.021911621, 0.039855957, 0.01789856, 0.011108398, 0.0206604, -0.05380249, -0.033233643, 0.00048089027, -0.007904053, 0.04220581, 0.018066406, 0.019439697, -0.005531311, 0.014205933, -0.006916046, -0.017852783, -0.01638794, 0.038208008, 0.004890442, -0.0037879944, -0.013381958, -0.025497437, 0.016998291, 0.002811432, 0.001748085, -0.021820068, -0.021331787, -0.018630981, 0.016143799, 0.03717041, 0.018417358, 0.0051345825, 0.041656494, 0.026763916, -0.0129470825, 0.044525146, -0.0041236877, 0.036956787, 0.051727295, -0.035491943, -0.00071525574, 0.00038409233, 0.010978699, 0.013259888, -0.041870117, -0.031982422, -0.00674057, 0.034606934, -0.0010414124, 0.016052246, -0.042297363, 0.0014095306, 0.00011616945, -0.025146484, 0.001461029, -0.04473877, -0.0029621124, -0.03955078, 0.027374268, 0.013160706, 0.06286621, 0.005027771, 0.011795044, -0.014099121, 0.024642944, -0.010307312, 0.0178833, -0.035308838, 0.021224976, 0.0034160614, 0.02458191, -0.0071983337, -0.014694214, -0.012413025, 0.0036010742, -0.020706177, 0.06549072, -0.058929443, -0.02357483, 0.024230957, 0.013702393, -0.024597168, 0.008773804, -0.029953003, 0.023040771, 0.028152466, -0.034240723, 0.014045715, -0.019180298, 0.025482178, 0.014823914, 0.041870117, 0.036346436, -0.0209198, 0.04083252, -0.021530151, 0.029724121, -0.041534424, 0.009086609, -0.009635925, -0.031311035, 0.013633728, 0.00995636, -0.020477295, 0.026992798, -0.026489258, 0.08380127, 0.053649902, 0.040405273, -0.056152344, 0.002445221, 0.043945312, -0.014778137, 0.06112671, -0.021209717, 0.0004222393, -0.0025558472, -0.023727417, 0.041503906, -0.030899048, 0.004966736, -0.055877686, -0.0026245117, -0.011543274, -0.0070495605, -0.03930664, 0.004714966, 0.0033626556, 0.029556274, -0.035369873, 0.0037117004, 0.005104065, -0.0062065125, -0.028945923, 0.017471313, -0.002243042, -0.0058631897, 0.043792725, -0.01701355, 0.01701355, 0.0021591187, 0.029846191, -0.016494751, -0.013877869, 0.03967285, -0.020324707, -0.029464722, 0.030578613, -0.0037269592, 0.0034713745, -0.020599365, -0.037597656, 0.028427124, 0.015670776, -0.028549194, 0.013465881, 0.019683838, -0.017791748, -0.04849243, 0.048950195, 0.00008678436, -0.0073661804, 0.006072998, 0.014411926, 0.01713562, -0.07659912, -0.021728516, -0.016159058, -0.029785156, -0.008583069, -0.0029258728, -0.034851074, 0.047058105, -0.011680603, -0.10925293, -0.05078125, -0.07141113, -0.016189575, -0.034942627, -0.016311646, 0.0158844, -0.0017051697, -0.024154663, 0.010650635, 0.0635376, 0.07647705, 0.025909424, -0.0007996559, -0.014015198, -0.019699097, -0.007888794, 0.053253174, 0.015083313, -0.003206253, 0.033935547, 0.007633209, 0.033966064, 0.037139893, -0.028060913, 0.016357422, 0.012710571, 0.0026950836, -0.006931305, -0.008132935, -0.0013742447, -0.021148682, -0.011940002, 0.002861023, -0.018829346, -0.021652222, -0.017684937, -0.0075416565, -0.011131287, -0.020263672, 0.0181427, -0.007648468, -0.034423828, 0.051940918, 0.016998291, 0.011688232, -0.016784668, -0.039093018, 0.0284729, -0.061523438, 0.029830933, -0.020523071, 0.009376526, -0.00084781647, 0.0036678314, -0.029785156, 0.019332886, -0.001871109, -0.0013618469, -0.02368164, -0.001452446, -0.07080078, -0.03488159, 0.01965332, -0.00028920174, -0.028274536, 0.033935547, -0.035247803, 0.016571045, 0.007171631, -0.0024051666, -0.0141067505, -0.0008020401, 0.038116455, 0.004459381, 0.013069153 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1802.06416v3
Sim-to-Real Optimization of Complex Real World Mobile Network with Imperfect Information via Deep Reinforcement Learning from Self-play
Yongxi Tan, Jin Yang, Xin Chen, Qitao Song, Yunjun Chen, Zhangxiang Ye, Zhenqiang Su
cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Mobile network that millions of people use every day is one of the most complex systems in the world. Optimization of mobile network to meet exploding customer demand and reduce capital/operation expenditures poses great challenges. Despite recent progress, application of deep reinforcement learning (DRL) to complex real world problem still remains unsolved, given data scarcity, partial observability, risk and complex rules/dynamics in real world, as well as the huge reality gap between simulation and real world. To bridge the reality gap, we introduce a Sim-to-Real framework to directly transfer learning from simulation to real world via graph convolutional neural network (CNN) - by abstracting partially observable mobile network into graph, then distilling domain-variant irregular graph into domain-invariant tensor in locally Euclidean space as input to CNN -, domain randomization and multi-task learning. We use a novel self-play mechanism to encourage competition among DRL agents for best record on multiple tasks via simulated annealing, just like athletes compete for world record in decathlon. We also propose a decentralized multi-agent, competitive and cooperative DRL method to coordinate the actions of multi-cells to maximize global reward and minimize negative impact to neighbor cells. Using 6 field trials on commercial mobile networks, we demonstrate for the first time that a DRL agent can successfully transfer learning from simulation to complex real world problem with imperfect information, complex rules/dynamics, huge state/action space, and multi-agent interactions, without any training in the real world.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1802.06416v3
2018-12-06T12:09:16
2018-02-18T18:03:39
{ "title": [ -0.008781433, 0.0066719055, -0.0059127808, -0.011665344, -0.004749298, -0.008857727, -0.0040664673, -0.031799316, -0.059051514, 0.014831543, -0.0030975342, 0.052886963, -0.04071045, -0.026184082, 0.022369385, -0.018814087, -0.0018997192, -0.016815186, -0.03552246, -0.05026245, 0.03765869, -0.04244995, 0.018798828, 0.11834717, -0.0033054352, -0.0234375, -0.09277344, 0.0362854, -0.056671143, -0.05001831, -0.01626587, 0.057769775, 0.053649902, 0.00047063828, -0.041748047, 0.02142334, -0.037261963, 0.00920105, -0.018432617, 0.024124146, 0.011489868, 0.0012693405, -0.0025405884, -0.008956909, -0.016693115, 0.028823853, -0.051696777, -0.029067993, -0.016067505, 0.07171631, 0.042938232, 0.02822876, 0.01676941, 0.05331421, 0.020828247, -0.029251099, -0.027145386, -0.029159546, 0.030075073, 0.04522705, 0.023590088, -0.031143188, 0.0132369995, -0.018875122, -0.00806427, -0.037902832, 0.018676758, 0.02027893, 0.053833008, 0.018920898, 0.0026378632, 0.02558899, 0.031433105, 0.008895874, -0.061035156, -0.021148682, 0.064697266, 0.014968872, 0.01979065, -0.03918457, 0.022247314, -0.0015277863, -0.007751465, -0.001996994, 0.018753052, -0.015487671, 0.0012683868, -0.025527954, -0.02822876, -0.03652954, -0.012664795, 0.004573822, -0.007659912, 0.022277832, -0.017913818, -0.018554688, 0.00063943863, 0.047454834, 0.011749268, -0.016281128, -0.033996582, -0.006263733, -0.029769897, -0.025009155, -0.013763428, 0.0011920929, -0.019943237, -0.03604126, -0.0048980713, 0.033599854, -0.025253296, -0.01663208, 0.037231445, 0.052825928, -0.0047302246, -0.036895752, -0.0049552917, 0.038208008, -0.0053520203, 0.028747559, -0.016189575, -0.009841919, -0.014961243, -0.009208679, 0.046020508, -0.0016555786, -0.012290955, 0.021347046, -0.0035057068, 0.031921387, -0.005809784, 0.061279297, -0.09283447, -0.10644531, -0.07763672, 0.032287598, -0.016586304, -0.009429932, 0.012413025, -0.017486572, 0.037353516, -0.020690918, -0.019424438, 0.038330078, 0.026245117, 0.012939453, 0.05557251, -0.017562866, -0.043304443, 0.014823914, -0.057128906, 0.06726074, -0.015731812, 0.016647339, 0.01789856, 0.023635864, -0.048034668, -0.010864258, 0.023712158, 0.026626587, 0.019226074, 0.008560181, 0.011795044, 0.07489014, 0.08703613, 0.009002686, -0.023345947, 0.024673462, -0.0007314682, 0.03277588, -0.008049011, -0.0063171387, -0.004371643, -0.020965576, -0.008659363, -0.002216339, 0.035125732, 0.002199173, 0.029922485, -0.025787354, -0.00447464, -0.019821167, 0.0435791, 0.0039138794, -0.02772522, -0.014183044, -0.017227173, -0.021469116, 0.057373047, 0.010391235, -0.06555176, 0.008049011, -0.07672119, 0.00041532516, -0.03869629, -0.0078048706, 0.026260376, 0.030715942, -0.0040664673, 0.028015137, -0.066223145, 0.016540527, -0.0289917, 0.02243042, -0.0077705383, -0.03390503, 0.00013077259, 0.02078247, -0.01537323, 0.038726807, 0.04260254, 0.005065918, -0.035705566, 0.013725281, -0.0065193176, -0.033721924, 0.021591187, -0.020446777, -0.019424438, -0.008964539, -0.0135269165, -0.002401352, -0.02456665, 0.052490234, 0.0060691833, 0.02217102, -0.0021457672, 0.004009247, 0.038604736, 0.03286743, 0.07281494, -0.054016113, 0.0027236938, -0.0025234222, -0.016296387, -0.01524353, -0.010368347, 0.0029067993, 0.0289917, 0.018096924, 0.0015850067, -0.0035057068, -0.010643005, 0.025283813, 0.010131836, -0.029159546, -0.0037403107, 0.023162842, 0.022140503, 0.016799927, 0.043792725, -0.01309967, 0.05114746, -0.022827148, 0.041412354, 0.0413208, 0.0031471252, 0.042053223, -0.037139893, 0.021896362, -0.010803223, 0.037139893, 0.059448242, -0.0038604736, -0.03677368, 0.0011358261, -0.018325806, 0.005355835, 0.007217407, 0.0024223328, 0.019607544, -0.028152466, 0.005908966, 0.0014944077, -0.02217102, -0.038604736, -0.0071907043, 0.018875122, -0.0019292831, -0.047607422, 0.0014839172, -0.0112838745, 0.023971558, 0.0030841827, 0.029953003, -0.041809082, 0.023956299, 0.010467529, 0.011474609, 0.0019779205, 0.06958008, 0.013511658, 0.011817932, -0.025772095, -0.00038194656, -0.01473999, 0.06628418, 0.088134766, -0.029525757, 0.038635254, -0.06555176, 0.0068473816, -0.01058197, 0.007587433, 0.002275467, 0.024002075, 0.026275635, 0.01727295, -0.010032654, 0.030288696, -0.055786133, 0.007041931, 0.0047454834, -0.056396484, -0.034088135, -0.034820557, -0.025421143, -0.03277588, -0.01727295, 0.04586792, 0.10296631, 0.0025501251, -0.04284668, -0.0041122437, -0.0040245056, -0.023864746, -0.01687622, -0.04257202, -0.018997192, 0.013694763, -0.011924744, -0.018493652, -0.06085205, 0.015403748, -0.0036716461, 0.022003174, -0.004436493, 0.024841309, -0.013442993, 0.018539429, 0.020904541, -0.026641846, 0.0036087036, -0.023651123, 0.01197052, -0.03652954, 0.0013113022, 0.025604248, -0.027404785, -0.0010299683, 0.012756348, -0.03842163, -0.036132812, 0.002784729, 0.049865723, -0.020767212, -0.010147095, 0.06085205, 0.037597656, 0.0061187744, 0.01033783, 0.01727295, -0.0076522827, -0.0501709, 0.005794525, -0.053222656, -0.022079468, 0.0032730103, -0.031951904, 0.037261963, -0.07507324, -0.033203125, -0.0063972473, -0.0078125, 0.03338623, 0.04574585, 0.022369385, -0.012176514, -0.010261536, -0.004486084, 0.0005760193, 0.015823364, -0.016464233, 0.0012130737, 0.08135986, -0.017532349, -0.06982422, -0.003742218, 0.010528564, 0.032409668, -0.027633667, -0.04348755, -0.015487671, 0.010116577, 0.031677246, 0.003665924, -0.015457153, 0.015655518, -0.10430908, -0.0056037903, 0.033325195, -0.013916016, -0.023086548, 0.03543091, -0.05090332, 0.017715454, 0.018692017, -0.006511688, 0.011894226, 0.0067253113, -0.010520935, -0.0289917, -0.0061836243, -0.051849365, 0.035369873, -0.046722412, -0.05001831, 0.037597656, -0.018051147, -0.05444336, -0.011184692, 0.023025513, -0.022323608, -0.018676758, 0.009254456, 0.03010559, 0.027359009, -0.02041626, 0.056671143, 0.031463623, 0.012069702, -0.0015859604, 0.008728027, -0.012062073, -0.032684326, 0.005279541, 0.006034851, 0.04562378, 0.020217896, -0.018875122, -0.063964844, -0.03164673, 0.02508545, 0.046051025, 0.04031372, -0.052215576, -0.025985718, -0.05102539, 0.0041999817, -0.018356323, -0.019424438, 0.0018520355, -0.04272461, -0.0024318695, -0.023406982, 0.047790527, -0.018325806, -0.0025863647, 0.00068855286, 0.009971619, 0.016937256, -0.00504303, -0.026107788, -0.0051612854, 0.041625977, -0.0052108765, 0.019348145, -0.0068511963, -0.018157959, 0.030654907, -0.0030708313, -0.011154175, -0.0006766319, -0.023345947, -0.013832092, -0.037719727, 0.02848816, 0.0025234222, 0.019210815, -0.04220581, 0.03439331, -0.013061523, -0.02130127, -0.00447464, 0.030410767, -0.0013771057, -0.07525635, -0.013420105, 0.014701843, -0.008964539, 0.006210327, -0.054779053, 0.013587952, -0.0101623535, -0.041412354, 0.008171082, -0.018493652, 0.016571045, 0.0061302185, -0.05328369, -0.016693115, 0.044433594, 0.016403198, 0.018310547, 0.02017212, 0.007865906, -0.0005297661, 0.004737854, 0.025817871, -0.0044898987, 0.0345459, -0.0023174286, 0.007019043, 0.06561279, -0.02859497, -0.018218994, 0.03741455, 0.06112671, -0.047698975, -0.0077285767, 0.042114258, 0.016204834, -0.02305603, 0.044830322, 0.021392822, -0.013801575, -0.07159424, -0.035125732, -0.007843018, -0.0099105835, -0.0012598038, -0.011917114, 0.015319824, 0.009246826, 0.020690918, 0.0385437, -0.003276825, 0.0044441223, 0.014030457, -0.013038635, -0.019714355, -0.006954193, 0.02583313, -0.00016200542, -0.008514404, 0.029724121, -0.020889282, 0.068725586, -0.062927246, 0.020492554, 0.008033752, 0.021865845, -0.018920898, -0.015197754, -0.06451416, 0.033294678, -0.008605957, 0.014411926, -0.027832031, 0.0071640015, 0.028945923, -0.023376465, -0.036621094, 0.028335571, 0.040100098, 0.003900528, -0.0440979, -0.09887695, 0.0027980804, -0.012802124, -0.05557251, -0.02947998, 0.008964539, -0.0005354881, 0.0184021, -0.02909851, 0.0011129379, 0.020904541, 0.041107178, 0.05718994, 0.04006958, -0.021316528, -0.028625488, 0.018859863, -0.014335632, -0.033325195, 0.018707275, 0.016052246, -0.00049829483, -0.019836426, 0.021697998, -0.043670654, 0.007896423, -0.021255493, 0.0024662018, -0.02192688, 0.033996582, -0.010345459, 0.041259766, 0.013710022, 0.033325195, 0.035186768, 0.012207031, -0.026626587, -0.03540039, 0.022384644, 0.09466553, -0.03186035, 0.008224487, 0.018798828, 0.030548096, 0.0234375, -0.009521484, 0.01247406, -0.004814148, -0.0012760162, -0.03744507, 0.027389526, 0.0033512115, -0.0047302246, 0.017410278, -0.0024681091, 0.02748108, -0.025421143, 0.09429932, -0.011108398, -0.020141602, 0.045806885, 0.017944336, 0.0014772415, -0.0128479, -0.00541687, -0.04827881, -0.036102295, -0.005317688, 0.008773804, -0.02670288, -0.002658844, -0.017959595, -0.010887146, 0.033569336, 0.053619385, 0.04574585, -0.04937744, -0.016677856, -0.0054244995, -0.014862061, -0.030838013, -0.042907715, 0.0008649826, -0.024856567, 0.014213562, -0.014343262, 0.027572632, -0.059143066, 0.030410767, 0.028533936, -0.0039253235, -0.0068473816, -0.044067383, 0.041137695, 0.040374756, -0.01576233, -0.0012197495, 0.042053223, 0.0028572083, 0.01689148, 0.04788208, 0.007583618, 0.02217102, 0.043914795, -0.070251465, 0.055145264, 0.02330017, 0.019592285, -0.022735596, 0.0032653809, -0.016952515, -0.016189575, -0.027816772, 0.04437256, 0.02720642, -0.064086914, 0.031951904, -0.04296875, 0.0070610046, 0.025512695, 0.02293396, 0.017852783, -0.03579712, -0.02859497, 0.001405716, -0.0206604, -0.0058555603, 0.020904541, 0.0079956055, -0.010192871, -0.058502197, 0.006538391, -0.051757812, -0.0073928833, 0.007835388, 0.005748749, -0.023880005, 0.016067505, 0.062927246, 0.008003235, -0.017807007, -0.0010881424, 0.014152527, 0.029724121, 0.008033752, -0.050109863, 0.0013008118, -0.011054993, -0.04525757, -0.047302246, -0.002445221, -0.0018253326, 0.007259369, 0.0011386871, 0.011741638, 0.013687134, -0.009803772, 0.027938843, 0.037963867, -0.046081543, 0.040283203, 0.017410278, 0.030441284, 0.00079107285, 0.031951904, -0.022460938, 0.012519836, 0.029434204, 0.01096344, 0.025756836, -0.005607605, -0.00623703, 0.04714966, -0.030563354, 0.029434204, 0.011116028, -0.011100769, -0.0033874512, 0.026016235, 0.023757935, 0.0064353943, 0.008529663, 0.013458252, 0.03741455, -0.022003174, 0.0051956177, -0.004173279, -0.0035648346, -0.020401001, 0.044708252, -0.020446777, -0.0052986145, -0.04940796, -0.040161133, -0.012527466, 0.015914917, 0.032287598, 0.015357971, 0.03237915, -0.043151855, 0.024429321, -0.033721924, 0.012519836, -0.008140564, -0.0056495667, 0.0018167496, 0.008041382, -0.012001038, 0.03564453, 0.012145996, -0.034576416, 0.004386902, -0.015808105, 0.011413574, -0.035308838, 0.0002822876, 0.009239197, -0.00818634, 0.0041923523, 0.02609253, -0.011734009, 0.008758545, 0.013893127, -0.03189087, 0.02017212, 0.010437012, 0.038482666, 0.058624268, 0.045562744, -0.0051078796, 0.002412796, 0.021011353, -0.028671265, 0.03656006, -0.055267334, -0.013946533, -0.07244873, -0.022705078, -0.09753418, 0.024047852, -0.016159058, 0.034942627, 0.055847168, 0.006198883, 0.070495605, 0.015609741, 0.037261963, -0.037322998, 0.07757568, 0.03552246, 0.026184082, -0.029281616, 0.021118164, 0.012359619, 0.02330017, 0.004550934, 0.033935547, 0.0077934265, -0.024429321, 0.016235352, 0.009269714, 0.006954193, -0.02319336, -0.015991211, -0.030899048, 0.05670166, -0.0023708344, 0.013656616, 0.071777344, 0.025787354, 0.032989502, -0.05154419, 0.0143966675, 0.009994507, -0.0725708, 0.06298828, 0.053649902, -0.0927124, 0.030563354, 0.0045394897, -0.008056641, 0.016738892, -0.0005993843, 0.05105591, -0.09088135, -0.052886963, 0.042816162, 0.016677856, -0.03378296, -0.0033779144, -0.03491211, -0.019943237, 0.040924072, 0.03955078, -0.03475952, -0.0026416779, 0.012954712, 0.018295288, -0.01424408, -0.007762909, 0.006706238, 0.016159058, 0.001329422, 0.033477783, -0.060455322, 0.011695862, 0.036254883, -0.028671265, 0.0143585205, 0.010902405, -0.021453857, -0.016143799, -0.011528015, 0.05456543, 0.017211914, 0.04309082, -0.017822266, -0.04196167, 0.0039596558, -0.026885986, 0.05429077, 0.056884766, -0.018753052, 0.017990112, -0.044433594, -0.046905518, 0.028762817, -0.0259552, 0.048828125, -0.035461426, 0.0014181137, -0.01210022, -0.0078125, 0.031143188, -0.035095215, -0.016433716, -0.029403687, -0.0032863617, -0.0034294128, 0.0028820038, -0.01574707, -0.0062561035, 0.023880005, 0.024353027, 0.045928955, -0.017456055, -0.011474609, 0.0038032532, -0.08514404, 0.018829346, -0.054779053, 0.044311523, -0.023727417, -0.01676941, -0.011260986, 0.008377075, 0.026138306, -0.046722412, -0.036865234, 0.00554657, 0.033111572, -0.030807495, 0.03665161, 0.052124023, 0.021865845, 0.05783081, 0.021224976, 0.01612854, 0.0057258606, -0.009407043, 0.036956787, -0.026565552, -0.058441162, -0.021591187, -0.05090332, 0.024429321, 0.009849548, -0.020233154, -0.010818481, 0.022094727, -0.036468506, -0.03881836, -0.00025749207, 0.03164673, -0.016098022, -0.037322998, 0.0012130737, 0.017715454, 0.021896362, -0.04257202, -0.045684814, 0.0028457642, 0.032073975, -0.010421753, 0.036743164, -0.016738892, -0.0061912537, 0.014320374, 0.056030273, 0.025680542, -0.030014038, -0.066345215, 0.0019493103, 0.08135986, 0.024795532, -0.019638062, -0.03326416, 0.02029419, -0.01486969, 0.0055885315, 0.005531311, 0.0075035095, 0.01675415, -0.0013151169, 0.07128906, -0.008132935, 0.013595581, 0.013557434, 0.011245728, -0.014343262, 0.021743774, -0.003376007, -0.0054779053, 0.0019664764, 0.024719238, -0.026687622, -0.013801575, 0.028900146, 0.014022827, 0.014320374, 0.015640259, -0.015106201, -0.008460999, 0.019836426, 0.0079193115, -0.024887085, 0.017105103, 0.033691406, -0.031555176, -0.0016946793, -0.060546875, -0.04638672, 0.021697998, -0.030151367, 0.031097412, -0.040985107, 0.0077705383, -0.0047721863, -0.0435791, -0.020462036, 0.0028133392, -0.023757935, -0.039886475, -0.03543091, -0.04800415, 0.03857422, -0.0075416565 ], "summary": [ 0.03265381, -0.013114929, 0.008460999, 0.009147644, -0.03778076, -0.028411865, 0.000016987324, -0.017562866, -0.068359375, -0.0012817383, 0.00047063828, 0.02520752, -0.039367676, -0.04498291, 0.06311035, -0.049835205, -0.011482239, 0.00674057, -0.020614624, -0.05630493, 0.027359009, -0.05279541, 0.0043525696, 0.08026123, 0.01461792, -0.016540527, -0.101745605, 0.05340576, -0.01939392, 0.008361816, -0.000626564, 0.03451538, 0.014320374, -0.004131317, -0.008338928, -0.0033340454, -0.021957397, 0.005710602, -0.011505127, 0.026168823, 0.03378296, 0.006591797, 0.06591797, -0.017593384, 0.00674057, 0.021224976, 0.0041236877, -0.027435303, 0.00907135, 0.035949707, 0.02130127, 0.026290894, -0.0034599304, 0.045013428, -0.0005412102, 0.0028495789, -0.03515625, -0.030776978, 0.025878906, 0.064086914, 0.024536133, -0.018798828, -0.007537842, -0.053131104, 0.00014042854, -0.015182495, 0.020904541, -0.006664276, 0.04638672, 0.0042533875, -0.009262085, 0.009506226, 0.0041503906, -0.017288208, -0.015533447, 0.009460449, 0.055847168, 0.035980225, -0.035461426, -0.009300232, -0.017089844, 0.007545471, 0.02229309, -0.021408081, -0.024749756, -0.023986816, -0.016983032, 0.0014858246, -0.025924683, 0.0005054474, -0.015357971, 0.052368164, -0.08465576, 0.03262329, 0.04095459, -0.039276123, -0.011856079, 0.011978149, 0.0236969, 0.023498535, -0.028396606, -0.02166748, 0.0013494492, -0.034942627, -0.028305054, 0.0011205673, -0.0055160522, -0.03149414, -0.017425537, 0.024215698, -0.036621094, -0.059570312, 0.043151855, 0.013534546, -0.011405945, -0.03161621, -0.0072746277, 0.066345215, -0.012794495, 0.022354126, -0.011878967, 0.026992798, -0.020935059, 0.029067993, 0.008338928, 0.009223938, 0.018112183, -0.016479492, 0.03186035, 0.007881165, 0.0042152405, 0.05230713, -0.05267334, -0.048950195, -0.066467285, -0.00026106834, 0.016448975, -0.024612427, 0.012641907, -0.028030396, 0.063964844, -0.014518738, -0.061553955, 0.056488037, 0.014801025, 0.04486084, 0.037750244, -0.025238037, -0.012931824, 0.0008072853, -0.058135986, 0.047210693, -0.004787445, 0.0077819824, 0.035339355, -0.009689331, -0.0077667236, -0.01158905, 0.034454346, 0.010627747, 0.00077342987, 0.02520752, 0.078552246, 0.07891846, 0.08074951, -0.017349243, -0.048980713, 0.00831604, -0.0029277802, 0.0017700195, -0.026870728, -0.00080156326, 0.003528595, -0.018508911, -0.006996155, -0.0017242432, -0.013916016, 0.038909912, 0.022888184, -0.027023315, -0.007873535, -0.040130615, 0.04171753, -0.00023210049, 0.022750854, -0.034576416, -0.027908325, -0.042022705, 0.048583984, 0.014839172, -0.064941406, -0.009841919, -0.04019165, 0.027175903, -0.039031982, -0.022781372, -0.0047569275, 0.026824951, -0.018432617, -0.0055999756, -0.031677246, 0.009552002, -0.008087158, 0.016204834, -0.019851685, 0.0016403198, -0.007522583, 0.0149002075, -0.030715942, 0.02798462, 0.023834229, 0.018188477, -0.028778076, -0.026260376, 0.0112838745, -0.015174866, 0.012413025, -0.04537964, -0.008522034, -0.041992188, 0.0055351257, 0.030853271, -0.035583496, 0.04663086, 0.009994507, -0.0017271042, -0.024429321, 0.01033783, 0.018035889, 0.0149002075, 0.031234741, -0.0012674332, -0.03466797, 0.025756836, 0.009521484, -0.013442993, 0.023406982, -0.062347412, 0.0395813, 0.029281616, 0.010292053, 0.01586914, -0.0129776, 0.020324707, -0.036956787, -0.034973145, 0.0046920776, 0.0005078316, -0.005630493, 0.0038776398, 0.020996094, -0.016448975, 0.027450562, -0.033294678, 0.03164673, 0.024765015, -0.008262634, 0.018829346, -0.010856628, 0.008911133, 0.007205963, 0.016845703, 0.029708862, -0.0065231323, -0.032043457, -0.011917114, -0.024475098, -0.019561768, -0.0047416687, -0.0024795532, 0.030578613, -0.051574707, -0.012313843, -0.030700684, -0.024353027, 0.014724731, -0.039916992, 0.022216797, 0.020385742, -0.023223877, -0.007911682, -0.004764557, -0.008331299, -0.0043640137, 0.031204224, -0.0132751465, 0.015556335, 0.00081539154, 0.03677368, 0.05508423, 0.07324219, 0.005268097, 0.01727295, -0.0029087067, -0.021652222, -0.01235199, 0.03982544, 0.08453369, -0.038391113, 0.016860962, -0.039978027, -0.0011396408, -0.038970947, 0.0061073303, 0.017547607, 0.00440979, 0.04309082, 0.005077362, 0.010681152, 0.008979797, -0.038391113, 0.015975952, 0.026687622, 0.0002837181, -0.005836487, -0.011756897, -0.0062675476, 0.017227173, 0.007537842, 0.05065918, 0.12841797, 0.016860962, -0.01625061, 0.0059776306, -0.0011873245, -0.048095703, 0.017715454, -0.04360962, -0.02330017, -0.009689331, -0.025985718, -0.031829834, -0.019332886, 0.013542175, -0.0011034012, -0.011138916, 0.014305115, -0.003753662, 0.0054855347, 0.014144897, 0.060821533, -0.041503906, -0.010848999, 0.02067566, -0.022506714, -0.005138397, 0.028457642, 0.0024967194, -0.0051994324, 0.0055122375, -0.0051994324, -0.034576416, -0.031051636, 0.013175964, 0.0074043274, -0.0077819824, 0.02078247, 0.04824829, 0.0038967133, -0.017288208, -0.0028419495, 0.02670288, -0.017166138, -0.064208984, 0.02166748, -0.0357666, 0.00022828579, -0.028884888, 0.003742218, 0.022994995, -0.043304443, 0.011039734, -0.011024475, -0.00030970573, 0.02772522, 0.04034424, 0.08331299, -0.0067977905, -0.0046806335, 0.05307007, 0.0016517639, 0.02772522, -0.033416748, 0.009925842, 0.030975342, -0.024795532, -0.07977295, -0.016311646, 0.024475098, 0.048797607, 0.009292603, -0.027114868, 0.004512787, -0.0019798279, 0.017593384, -0.0014572144, 0.055664062, 0.016235352, -0.036743164, -0.053222656, 0.067993164, -0.006931305, -0.005821228, 0.020721436, -0.013534546, 0.013000488, 0.046722412, 0.01486969, 0.017318726, -0.0023422241, 0.04144287, -0.056884766, 0.03302002, -0.055389404, 0.026260376, -0.033691406, 0.04647827, 0.009597778, -0.014633179, -0.041259766, 0.0017337799, 0.050994873, -0.008857727, -0.032318115, 0.030426025, 0.013664246, 0.013587952, -0.042510986, 0.048950195, 0.09234619, 0.008598328, 0.021026611, -0.00002783537, -0.00034189224, -0.0287323, -0.009559631, -0.003774643, -0.0020618439, 0.046203613, -0.049438477, -0.059906006, -0.024368286, 0.02609253, 0.0135269165, 0.055389404, -0.042053223, -0.010009766, -0.037719727, 0.0023880005, -0.0289917, -0.03265381, -0.0033035278, 0.005317688, 0.038208008, -0.0029697418, 0.059387207, -0.030441284, 0.008476257, 0.06439209, -0.01939392, 0.0034389496, 0.002111435, -0.042114258, 0.005001068, 0.043823242, 0.03262329, -0.015602112, 0.009414673, -0.019042969, 0.030700684, 0.025299072, -0.06774902, 0.0075263977, -0.04348755, -0.005935669, -0.079589844, 0.0501709, -0.012649536, 0.06542969, -0.062927246, 0.0013694763, -0.006095886, -0.06719971, -0.005065918, -0.008468628, 0.0069389343, -0.05886841, -0.015899658, 0.0044441223, 0.034179688, 0.024795532, -0.02420044, 0.035858154, 0.0029201508, -0.024627686, 0.007575989, -0.02519226, 0.1048584, 0.031677246, -0.033081055, 0.037078857, -0.03100586, 0.049102783, -0.01071167, -0.015701294, 0.030151367, 0.0041885376, 0.019577026, 0.016845703, -0.03668213, 0.0059051514, -0.03262329, 0.035614014, 0.022628784, -0.018829346, -0.01626587, 0.014472961, 0.052490234, -0.06072998, -0.013252258, 0.09082031, 0.067993164, -0.03491211, -0.000017523766, 0.013366699, -0.0043258667, -0.05834961, -0.025604248, -0.011123657, -0.005607605, 0.0440979, 0.03286743, 0.009017944, -0.0102005005, -0.016815186, -0.025283813, -0.018875122, -0.029937744, 0.0014486313, 0.028259277, -0.016647339, -0.0071144104, 0.018096924, 0.02911377, -0.015052795, 0.0071144104, -0.0345459, 0.05758667, -0.06964111, 0.047943115, 0.0026054382, -0.010375977, -0.035736084, -0.048706055, -0.016326904, 0.05444336, 0.012161255, -0.0012874603, -0.04348755, -0.0037288666, 0.0052375793, -0.013168335, 0.0018205643, 0.009819031, 0.021255493, 0.030471802, -0.05596924, -0.08642578, 0.038116455, -0.024902344, -0.034362793, -0.025405884, -0.018493652, -0.029006958, 0.0044441223, 0.0030612946, 0.011238098, 0.032470703, 0.028533936, 0.043182373, 0.032470703, -0.011734009, -0.046447754, 0.027542114, 0.0015707016, 0.017715454, 0.0074882507, 0.018356323, 0.020858765, 0.025131226, 0.0141067505, -0.034362793, -0.01991272, -0.050109863, -0.021575928, 0.039093018, -0.016571045, 0.033233643, 0.04348755, 0.0020637512, 0.03286743, 0.028335571, 0.011772156, -0.0087509155, -0.046173096, 0.010414124, 0.05206299, -0.0002937317, -0.014129639, -0.033203125, 0.031051636, 0.032104492, -0.025558472, 0.0044403076, -0.034179688, -0.029067993, -0.037750244, 0.012527466, 0.037200928, 0.029129028, 0.04925537, 0.0042533875, 0.011184692, 0.029556274, 0.05908203, 0.009880066, -0.03756714, 0.027191162, 0.0009083748, -0.022460938, -0.016479492, -0.021514893, -0.028518677, -0.030181885, -0.022705078, 0.021087646, -0.005420685, -0.039978027, -0.028778076, -0.024932861, 0.06185913, -0.00052785873, 0.008743286, -0.08862305, -0.018753052, 0.0010557175, -0.033813477, -0.003211975, -0.0118637085, -0.044403076, 0.03933716, 0.010429382, -0.014190674, 0.008476257, 0.010643005, 0.015823364, -0.010070801, 0.024124146, -0.0015468597, 0.0039253235, -0.015670776, 0.041870117, -0.0047035217, -0.0067596436, 0.053985596, -0.02935791, -0.014442444, 0.015930176, -0.015701294, 0.010940552, -0.010810852, -0.07672119, 0.021118164, 0.012840271, 0.01448822, -0.023727417, -0.008544922, -0.012397766, -0.030883789, -0.0154800415, 0.0141067505, -0.004486084, -0.046295166, -0.0008854866, -0.010284424, 0.023849487, -0.0102005005, 0.024246216, 0.01524353, 0.0049438477, -0.013618469, 0.0026226044, 0.009857178, 0.011482239, 0.0006184578, 0.009231567, 0.013343811, -0.08111572, 0.0041007996, -0.046844482, 0.011795044, -0.010795593, 0.034423828, -0.0044403076, -0.03074646, 0.03302002, 0.028701782, -0.010154724, 0.017456055, 0.021026611, -0.0049057007, -0.020477295, -0.045776367, 0.004814148, -0.010002136, -0.011543274, -0.037353516, -0.037139893, -0.021697998, 0.045898438, -0.017318726, 0.05783081, 0.023345947, -0.04623413, 0.024307251, 0.005180359, -0.057250977, 0.012390137, 0.012283325, 0.01008606, 0.014587402, -0.005306244, -0.064941406, 0.014343262, 0.055755615, 0.028839111, 0.03277588, 0.015640259, -0.015716553, 0.05883789, -0.005382538, 0.014022827, 0.023162842, -0.022201538, 0.008666992, 0.027328491, 0.016998291, 0.012260437, 0.023986816, 0.01008606, 0.023742676, 0.020446777, 0.036956787, -0.015060425, 0.01676941, -0.044830322, -0.0098724365, -0.0079956055, 0.026153564, -0.03125, -0.043029785, 0.022644043, 0.0012273788, 0.015975952, 0.019561768, 0.034698486, -0.051849365, -0.015899658, 0.00869751, -0.025665283, -0.011741638, -0.02368164, -0.00774765, -0.00957489, 0.07733154, 0.024505615, -0.011817932, 0.010871887, -0.0016965866, -0.02027893, 0.0099105835, 0.0019359589, 0.057891846, 0.008880615, 0.0075798035, 0.04675293, 0.0107421875, -0.0035438538, 0.024230957, -0.018432617, -0.014221191, 0.004169464, 0.019851685, 0.032928467, -0.0014619827, -0.024230957, 0.024658203, 0.014976501, 0.0112838745, -0.029067993, 0.058929443, -0.02545166, -0.058929443, -0.07324219, -0.068847656, -0.041992188, 0.01701355, -0.042114258, -0.018508911, 0.08526611, -0.008766174, 0.068481445, 0.030899048, -0.032806396, -0.03543091, 0.007659912, 0.013420105, 0.01411438, -0.03515625, 0.000151515, -0.020233154, 0.025299072, 0.011482239, 0.027618408, 0.037139893, 0.007663727, 0.010002136, -0.012535095, -0.0062179565, -0.0715332, 0.03253174, -0.020111084, 0.04611206, 0.013847351, 0.034118652, 0.052368164, -0.006454468, 0.072021484, -0.047790527, 0.01676941, 0.029891968, -0.05960083, 0.08050537, 0.031799316, -0.05215454, 0.025405884, 0.016021729, -0.02583313, 0.059417725, 0.015617371, 0.042907715, -0.084106445, -0.026748657, 0.016860962, -0.011177063, -0.03515625, -0.04031372, -0.039001465, -0.032440186, 0.023208618, 0.012046814, -0.044281006, -0.00092840195, 0.010856628, 0.001156807, 0.005241394, 0.012176514, 0.008460999, 0.008995056, 0.013664246, 0.02609253, -0.050628662, 0.005256653, 0.05770874, 0.00018072128, 0.021835327, 0.032073975, 0.004272461, 0.051727295, -0.03869629, 0.05682373, 0.04937744, 0.02809143, -0.041503906, -0.0095825195, 0.057495117, -0.00705719, 0.011009216, -0.013038635, -0.021224976, -0.061279297, -0.001335144, 0.005836487, -0.019760132, 0.024642944, 0.018447876, -0.012710571, 0.0006608963, -0.0211792, -0.024963379, 0.012886047, -0.034729004, 0.0107421875, -0.058532715, -0.03060913, 0.036712646, 0.048309326, -0.003255844, 0.056427002, 0.012321472, -0.060760498, 0.054595947, -0.025344849, 0.0042381287, 0.016296387, -0.03817749, -0.000082969666, -0.040893555, 0.03881836, -0.047698975, -0.026763916, -0.01828003, 0.027877808, 0.03793335, -0.018005371, -0.018005371, 0.050964355, 0.03894043, -0.06842041, 0.043670654, 0.04660034, 0.010169983, 0.029846191, -0.008331299, 0.014205933, 0.0008201599, 0.0007133484, 0.04647827, 0.0028076172, -0.055664062, -0.0047416687, -0.036010742, 0.014526367, -0.027069092, -0.013397217, 0.019744873, -0.0021324158, -0.027145386, -0.047210693, -0.007545471, -0.004886627, 0.0010881424, -0.0446167, -0.018371582, 0.0038833618, 0.025268555, -0.023422241, -0.037597656, 0.01928711, 0.022003174, -0.008735657, -0.0064811707, -0.019042969, -0.01461792, 0.046569824, 0.05355835, 0.01626587, -0.015319824, -0.037200928, 0.014305115, 0.09625244, -0.007358551, -0.03540039, -0.0037517548, 0.0032653809, -0.05029297, 0.0074043274, -0.008842468, 0.01071167, 0.00166893, -0.0048599243, 0.046691895, -0.005710602, -0.010757446, 0.03564453, -0.0027713776, -0.019302368, -0.005680084, 0.0026340485, -0.023391724, -0.010238647, 0.018951416, -0.0115737915, 0.0025577545, -0.007751465, 0.00617218, 0.0012359619, -0.008041382, -0.01737976, 0.004989624, 0.014190674, 0.002910614, 0.009468079, 0.023635864, 0.02507019, -0.054260254, 0.0036735535, -0.095825195, -0.03363037, -0.039611816, -0.030456543, -0.0019550323, -0.020324707, 0.019256592, 0.043792725, -0.016204834, 0.0057144165, 0.006965637, 0.0018796921, -0.004627228, 0.0101623535, 0.027511597, 0.0027599335, 0.01600647 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1810.02422v3
Simulator Predictive Control: Using Learned Task Representations and MPC for Zero-Shot Generalization and Sequencing
Zhanpeng He, Ryan Julian, Eric Heiden, Hejia Zhang, Stefan Schaal, Joseph J. Lim, Gaurav Sukhatme, Karol Hausman
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Simulation-to-real transfer is an important strategy for making reinforcement learning practical with real robots. Successful sim-to-real transfer systems have difficulty producing policies which generalize across tasks, despite training for thousands of hours equivalent real robot time. To address this shortcoming, we present a novel approach to efficiently learning new robotic skills directly on a real robot, based on model-predictive control (MPC) and an algorithm for learning task representations. In short, we show how to reuse the simulation from the pre-training step of sim-to-real methods as a tool for foresight, allowing the sim-to-real policy adapt to unseen tasks. Rather than end-to-end learning policies for single tasks and attempting to transfer them, we first use simulation to simultaneously learn (1) a continuous parameterization (i.e. a skill embedding or latent) of task-appropriate primitive skills, and (2) a single policy for these skills which is conditioned on this representation. We then directly transfer our multi-skill policy to a real robot, and actuate the robot by choosing sequences of skill latents which actuate the policy, with each latent corresponding to a pre-learned primitive skill controller. We complete unseen tasks by choosing new sequences of skill latents to control the robot using MPC, where our MPC model is composed of the pre-trained skill policy executed in the simulation environment, run in parallel with the real robot. We discuss the background and principles of our method, detail its practical implementation, and evaluate its performance by using our method to train a real Sawyer Robot to achieve motion tasks such as drawing and block pushing.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.02422v3
2021-01-27T21:59:18
2018-10-04T20:59:35
{ "title": [ 0.012275696, -0.011375427, -0.016220093, -0.04055786, -0.013023376, -0.021911621, -0.004234314, -0.008079529, -0.0023441315, 0.025177002, -0.010368347, 0.031799316, -0.014190674, -0.0309906, -0.01663208, 0.010398865, 0.0041542053, 0.026428223, -0.0055618286, -0.041778564, -0.034454346, -0.056488037, 0.061309814, 0.074035645, 0.015838623, -0.0020065308, -0.12634277, 0.01776123, -0.060272217, -0.02760315, -0.015182495, 0.035583496, 0.013031006, 0.028701782, -0.0052108765, 0.047821045, -0.015716553, 0.033233643, 0.02720642, 0.014198303, 0.023956299, -0.0030002594, -0.0435791, -0.043792725, -0.03086853, 0.007068634, -0.038635254, -0.0178833, -0.014541626, 0.070129395, 0.026824951, 0.019012451, -0.005531311, 0.015655518, 0.023803711, -0.030090332, -0.050872803, 0.007358551, 0.028289795, 0.09686279, 0.0045433044, -0.025939941, -0.007949829, -0.062316895, -0.0058021545, -0.04559326, -0.059570312, 0.043914795, 0.082336426, 0.02494812, -0.015777588, 0.014305115, -0.019332886, 0.042144775, -0.038391113, -0.01739502, 0.034332275, 0.024169922, 0.02848816, 0.016601562, -0.006210327, -0.037353516, 0.02998352, -0.0020179749, -0.019104004, -0.026321411, -0.0064582825, 0.009407043, -0.018371582, -0.03930664, -0.012039185, 0.010231018, 0.006336212, 0.017288208, -0.014839172, -0.042144775, -0.025787354, -0.016189575, 0.028793335, -0.021911621, 0.01826477, -0.0026550293, -0.054595947, 0.009849548, -0.008613586, 0.007019043, -0.004070282, -0.023345947, 0.0036773682, 0.024536133, -0.032714844, 0.00006484985, 0.002696991, 0.00065898895, 0.01184082, 0.008514404, -0.015136719, -0.0062713623, -0.010559082, -0.012779236, -0.01637268, -0.006313324, 0.02734375, 0.005138397, 0.024871826, 0.0070533752, -0.025238037, -0.019195557, -0.00085639954, 0.009559631, -0.0052337646, 0.0546875, -0.03213501, -0.058288574, -0.04675293, 0.020751953, -0.00030946732, -0.012374878, -0.03375244, 0.025970459, 0.0047950745, -0.017028809, -0.010932922, -0.012794495, 0.012840271, 0.0075645447, 0.035217285, 0.010528564, -0.03366089, -0.035186768, -0.02192688, 0.029541016, -0.0037078857, -0.0006570816, -0.01889038, -0.017868042, -0.117614746, 0.020217896, 0.08166504, 0.031188965, 0.05722046, 0.01109314, -0.03515625, -0.0011339188, 0.019760132, -0.038970947, -0.01171875, 0.04522705, 0.004951477, 0.08514404, -0.029083252, 0.012260437, -0.034240723, 0.008026123, -0.006248474, 0.0051460266, -0.009300232, -0.039154053, 0.04046631, -0.03289795, -0.0003106594, 0.0015134811, -0.01651001, 0.044769287, -0.038970947, -0.031555176, -0.029052734, -0.06652832, 0.06463623, -0.01411438, -0.0011081696, 0.028533936, -0.034088135, -0.06060791, -0.014907837, 0.007575989, -0.0076675415, 0.023147583, -0.003293991, 0.008865356, -0.028564453, -0.046447754, -0.00041294098, 0.014503479, 0.022232056, -0.05722046, 0.00072193146, -0.0009813309, -0.0014429092, 0.04208374, 0.040618896, 0.00844574, -0.029769897, -0.012634277, -0.027801514, -0.04348755, 0.013641357, -0.027313232, -0.00944519, -0.026809692, 0.03201294, -0.019607544, 0.012321472, 0.050476074, -0.009887695, 0.014259338, -0.0034065247, -0.010398865, 0.05053711, 0.004398346, 0.09051514, -0.039642334, -0.0357666, -0.017990112, -0.003917694, 0.0005249977, -0.0012626648, -0.006313324, 0.01651001, 0.009933472, -0.0028476715, -0.0011072159, 0.014373779, 0.06518555, 0.06323242, 0.005580902, -0.009017944, 0.037109375, 0.026016235, 0.022521973, 0.066223145, 0.00579834, 0.038391113, 0.002981186, 0.028137207, 0.027023315, 0.013870239, 0.005214691, -0.020584106, 0.017929077, 0.007797241, 0.034362793, -0.0028800964, 0.0143585205, -0.029281616, 0.04083252, -0.010360718, 0.02709961, -0.019577026, 0.05319214, 0.025909424, -0.047302246, -0.008758545, -0.0046195984, -0.011138916, -0.02418518, -0.039276123, 0.045288086, -0.008529663, -0.048828125, -0.006958008, 0.023880005, 0.0151901245, 0.005783081, 0.004310608, 0.00497818, 0.0107040405, 0.02355957, -0.0110321045, -0.01777649, 0.043548584, -0.011413574, -0.04611206, 0.029388428, 0.0010519028, -0.03439331, 0.068115234, 0.08099365, -0.035980225, 0.040008545, -0.035736084, 0.008560181, -0.00007766485, -0.01878357, 0.01259613, 0.025421143, 0.056488037, 0.0041275024, -0.015007019, 0.02545166, -0.064453125, -0.030685425, 0.0041618347, -0.00248909, -0.03894043, -0.04244995, 0.010124207, -0.020248413, -0.006580353, 0.0030841827, 0.05569458, 0.0030670166, -0.0049362183, -0.0017375946, 0.031051636, -0.044921875, -0.024169922, -0.027389526, 0.010192871, 0.02734375, 0.04168701, 0.03741455, -0.034179688, 0.014755249, -0.006752014, 0.0042915344, 0.00089120865, 0.014945984, -0.0024795532, -0.028671265, 0.016738892, -0.003768921, 0.018554688, 0.010887146, 0.015151978, -0.06585693, -0.028839111, 0.013450623, -0.027420044, -0.00037050247, 0.03527832, -0.013900757, -0.019119263, 0.028045654, 0.051849365, -0.026184082, -0.013313293, 0.043762207, 0.013519287, 0.0013170242, 0.04699707, 0.004589081, 0.008651733, -0.068237305, 0.002418518, -0.04534912, -0.035064697, -0.035064697, 0.019760132, 0.08074951, -0.057617188, 0.044036865, -0.084350586, -0.038909912, -0.018920898, 0.042419434, 0.039489746, -0.018218994, -0.014122009, 0.0063323975, 0.017929077, 0.012542725, -0.039886475, -0.031066895, 0.09454346, -0.012130737, 0.010787964, 0.027526855, 0.031234741, 0.0067253113, -0.02279663, -0.05050659, -0.056640625, 0.012794495, 0.008384705, -0.014778137, 0.03262329, -0.006549835, -0.10424805, -0.01625061, -0.027801514, 0.0064888, -0.014434814, -0.012641907, -0.025939941, 0.016113281, -0.021270752, -0.02998352, 0.02835083, 0.04660034, 0.017578125, -0.03527832, 0.06890869, -0.094177246, 0.024139404, 0.004951477, -0.07080078, 0.034851074, -0.012359619, -0.03439331, -0.020874023, 0.020477295, -0.035614014, -0.023208618, -0.01058197, 0.064208984, 0.049743652, 0.023910522, 0.024917603, -0.0022735596, 0.04260254, -0.041229248, -0.021621704, -0.008850098, 0.003107071, 0.0423584, -0.015899658, 0.009086609, -0.0074691772, 0.008834839, -0.015159607, -0.005180359, -0.04284668, 0.016204834, -0.021606445, -0.012802124, -0.003332138, -0.03125, -0.0017709732, -0.026916504, -0.015670776, -0.011833191, -0.005847931, 0.024719238, -0.015701294, 0.08996582, 0.031463623, 0.031799316, -0.0008983612, -0.02810669, 0.013687134, -0.027755737, -0.062927246, 0.021240234, -0.04663086, 0.023040771, 0.02041626, -0.013549805, -0.043273926, -0.0039405823, -0.080078125, 0.07598877, 0.04888916, 0.008583069, -0.03527832, -0.009117126, 0.021377563, 0.011207581, -0.027359009, -0.031204224, 0.017486572, 0.0044288635, -0.00522995, -0.040618896, 0.0039482117, 0.0019388199, -0.10168457, -0.030807495, 0.010696411, 0.018859863, -0.0021762848, -0.04348755, 0.013900757, 0.017578125, -0.047424316, 0.017745972, 0.0044670105, -0.021347046, 0.0036621094, -0.022994995, -0.07122803, 0.06323242, -0.025390625, -0.001950264, 0.019256592, -0.017333984, -0.0033893585, -0.02104187, 0.01828003, -0.00289917, 0.03036499, -0.003982544, 0.015716553, 0.05706787, -0.019699097, 0.022659302, 0.017990112, 0.039916992, -0.02810669, -0.0059928894, 0.047027588, 0.03503418, -0.024627686, 0.019332886, 0.032165527, 0.0073127747, -0.060546875, -0.0014162064, -0.019973755, -0.029327393, 0.023406982, 0.011222839, 0.02861023, 0.021057129, 0.0013160706, 0.048950195, -0.013389587, -0.031066895, 0.02897644, 0.016601562, -0.026290894, -0.00075244904, 0.0028305054, 0.033111572, -0.003932953, 0.031097412, -0.0005145073, 0.0814209, -0.04360962, 0.010498047, 0.00806427, 0.019927979, -0.015174866, -0.020385742, -0.054382324, 0.005859375, 0.0154953, 0.00028204918, -0.015365601, 0.019119263, 0.03503418, 0.004825592, -0.056427002, -0.00080013275, -0.059661865, 0.013511658, -0.028457642, -0.051605225, -0.022857666, -0.011894226, -0.03894043, -0.035827637, -0.042510986, -0.03857422, -0.021072388, 0.00014173985, -0.042999268, -0.00079488754, 0.027557373, 0.09338379, 0.02078247, 0.0079574585, -0.052337646, -0.0034885406, -0.01878357, 0.00010931492, -0.030059814, -0.008384705, -0.04019165, -0.0049591064, 0.05831909, -0.0035800934, -0.0015525818, -0.042755127, -0.005290985, -0.025756836, 0.03515625, 0.0151901245, 0.019073486, 0.01966858, -0.027572632, 0.027694702, 0.008155823, -0.031585693, 0.008018494, 0.031677246, 0.035369873, -0.01676941, 0.006668091, 0.024475098, 0.0154418945, -0.003900528, 0.010955811, 0.009864807, 0.029785156, -0.007835388, -0.0104599, 0.0418396, -0.01600647, -0.016723633, 0.023452759, 0.012359619, 0.028152466, -0.040649414, 0.047698975, 0.005455017, 0.025909424, 0.044311523, -0.019454956, -0.0015926361, 0.0051727295, -0.015319824, -0.0657959, -0.057678223, -0.020401001, 0.035980225, -0.015312195, -0.0011501312, -0.018829346, -0.054473877, 0.041503906, 0.023742676, 0.048217773, -0.026062012, -0.03225708, 0.0025730133, -0.0039482117, -0.013092041, -0.032958984, -0.014533997, 0.005783081, -0.0014743805, -0.02897644, -0.032104492, -0.034301758, -0.020141602, -0.0020503998, 0.021591187, -0.0231781, -0.045532227, 0.042816162, 0.039276123, 0.016143799, 0.0031757355, 0.029251099, 0.017654419, 0.012260437, 0.042633057, 0.006324768, 0.052947998, 0.01802063, -0.029037476, 0.013061523, -0.0044784546, -0.0052871704, 0.025024414, 0.021591187, 0.0058898926, 0.02279663, -0.035217285, 0.017456055, 0.002986908, -0.0067825317, -0.0059509277, -0.037261963, 0.022903442, 0.014091492, -0.0049552917, -0.01386261, -0.029830933, -0.062469482, -0.006084442, -0.048675537, -0.03289795, 0.016571045, -0.05316162, -0.015274048, -0.045288086, 0.05508423, -0.04562378, -0.021850586, 0.014129639, 0.010238647, 0.006122589, 0.01020813, 0.030517578, -0.045318604, 0.043945312, -0.03439331, 0.0032253265, 0.03640747, 0.04034424, -0.055023193, -0.005886078, -0.02067566, -0.03277588, -0.006134033, 0.02796936, 0.012016296, 0.0075569153, -0.0051345825, -0.027786255, -0.012825012, 0.013374329, 0.020095825, 0.008811951, -0.0362854, 0.056915283, -0.009933472, -0.018371582, -0.019821167, -0.006351471, -0.011512756, -0.008377075, 0.009109497, 0.003194809, 0.012489319, -0.023880005, -0.029205322, 0.03466797, 0.0073394775, -0.0005283356, 0.028121948, -0.014884949, -0.017730713, 0.018966675, 0.023925781, -0.041900635, -0.01285553, -0.02029419, 0.056488037, -0.04940796, -0.037506104, -0.0158844, -0.010238647, -0.028457642, 0.08270264, -0.00048589706, -0.049865723, -0.038330078, -0.038391113, -0.0044822693, 0.029769897, 0.022445679, 0.0069274902, 0.041900635, -0.058044434, -0.017181396, 0.0015230179, -0.018554688, -0.032348633, 0.029693604, -0.006839752, -0.024902344, -0.006916046, -0.016036987, 0.017059326, -0.02418518, 0.0051612854, -0.01386261, -0.014953613, 0.0010910034, -0.041046143, 0.019439697, -0.01524353, -0.026000977, 0.02154541, -0.000027656555, -0.03842163, 0.017578125, -0.03475952, 0.064331055, 0.040740967, 0.053771973, 0.03353882, 0.0076560974, -0.002105713, 0.023529053, -0.0066833496, -0.04647827, 0.016983032, -0.0435791, -0.014266968, -0.052947998, -0.031066895, -0.057128906, 0.0107421875, -0.0061187744, -0.02468872, 0.06201172, -0.025726318, 0.02154541, 0.022583008, 0.028244019, 0.02218628, 0.021560669, 0.025650024, 0.005718231, -0.014060974, 0.0024280548, 0.011352539, 0.0262146, 0.018585205, 0.020050049, 0.018234253, -0.012428284, 0.0074691772, -0.006542206, 0.0289917, -0.031555176, -0.028808594, -0.027954102, 0.04321289, -0.027908325, 0.013175964, 0.07421875, 0.031555176, -0.031311035, -0.012931824, 0.02458191, 0.003353119, -0.010650635, 0.029144287, 0.056854248, -0.08459473, 0.04852295, 0.011299133, -0.04360962, -0.01828003, 0.060668945, -0.00068855286, -0.051239014, 0.0099487305, 0.027145386, 0.0126571655, -0.0038967133, 0.030960083, -0.036712646, -0.042236328, 0.010383606, 0.03741455, -0.021118164, 0.043914795, 0.016479492, 0.02961731, 0.013420105, 0.024276733, 0.014450073, 0.049224854, 0.0056762695, 0.033081055, -0.06817627, -0.00095033646, 0.05041504, -0.00869751, -0.010215759, 0.048614502, -0.061157227, 0.03314209, -0.033233643, 0.064086914, 0.024749756, 0.06628418, 0.021484375, -0.01651001, 0.0045700073, -0.026031494, 0.003211975, 0.037139893, -0.02130127, -0.009613037, -0.048858643, -0.053649902, -0.0057029724, -0.07104492, 0.026107788, -0.050231934, -0.0054855347, -0.020004272, 0.014717102, 0.03842163, -0.04232788, -0.07659912, -0.025054932, 0.020553589, -0.011726379, 0.01423645, -0.02734375, -0.0040283203, 0.0009889603, 0.022857666, 0.01852417, -0.0059547424, 0.017242432, -0.03552246, -0.0881958, 0.018203735, -0.0019464493, 0.040771484, -0.006336212, -0.02720642, -0.011062622, 0.007621765, -0.011062622, -0.020355225, -0.025115967, 0.010940552, -0.002023697, -0.04043579, -0.00064468384, -0.0010309219, -0.005630493, 0.030044556, 0.009284973, 0.022232056, 0.0014162064, -0.02217102, 0.042907715, -0.015792847, -0.068359375, -0.01285553, -0.022827148, 0.02760315, 0.009536743, -0.003686905, -0.007598877, 0.026046753, -0.017684937, -0.008796692, 0.0066490173, 0.03604126, -0.014511108, -0.010238647, -0.016052246, 0.028076172, 0.04977417, -0.037475586, -0.091430664, -0.01071167, -0.008262634, 0.007183075, 0.02381897, 0.0007109642, -0.009048462, -0.004463196, 0.048675537, 0.0030136108, -0.023773193, -0.016311646, 0.01928711, 0.04849243, 0.038513184, -0.008903503, -0.026260376, -0.0044288635, -0.003578186, -0.034210205, -0.002456665, 0.02128601, -0.04510498, 0.0234375, 0.008354187, -0.019210815, -0.027755737, -0.022888184, -0.014945984, -0.00004386902, -0.0027389526, -0.0028476715, 0.02947998, -0.043426514, 0.022537231, -0.020843506, 0.0070877075, 0.03817749, 0.02305603, 0.028686523, 0.012741089, -0.006324768, 0.021499634, -0.021347046, -0.005645752, 0.010879517, 0.0149002075, 0.010055542, -0.016159058, 0.01638794, -0.07891846, -0.0077209473, -0.06173706, -0.044403076, 0.051696777, 0.01991272, -0.01096344, 0.025390625, -0.004032135, 0.013038635, 0.011116028, 0.013755798, -0.0016584396, -0.03793335, -0.010009766, 0.005168915, -0.023086548 ], "summary": [ 0.058776855, -0.02319336, 0.055267334, 0.014595032, -0.03765869, -0.0181427, 0.0362854, -0.03475952, -0.05908203, 0.019134521, -0.013061523, 0.043121338, -0.018249512, -0.025634766, 0.055480957, -0.032806396, -0.00724411, 0.042266846, 0.026382446, -0.03366089, 0.03878784, -0.03378296, 0.013191223, 0.051818848, 0.036499023, 0.0038604736, -0.12243652, 0.037963867, -0.008514404, 0.014755249, 0.011543274, 0.0040664673, 0.013946533, 0.03503418, -0.04058838, 0.010192871, -0.024597168, 0.017868042, -0.0040664673, 0.03845215, 0.022735596, -0.008964539, -0.018966675, -0.01651001, -0.044555664, 0.032928467, -0.024459839, 0.018234253, -0.0074539185, 0.045074463, 0.028320312, 0.017501831, 0.0023670197, 0.054382324, -0.00046253204, -0.01109314, -0.050872803, -0.0076789856, 0.016143799, 0.10345459, 0.036895752, 0.008888245, -0.034088135, -0.08111572, 0.017959595, -0.0132369995, -0.011581421, 0.020645142, 0.017059326, -0.0030288696, 0.010726929, -0.010238647, 0.009666443, -0.014007568, 0.0012598038, -0.0033397675, 0.02420044, 0.030838013, -0.007167816, 0.006298065, -0.03729248, -0.0211792, 0.013023376, -0.012565613, -0.04989624, -0.025497437, -0.01676941, 0.017196655, -0.013198853, -0.021102905, -0.018066406, 0.033294678, -0.032958984, 0.018920898, -0.021331787, -0.013504028, -0.034729004, -0.046691895, 0.04949951, 0.023666382, 0.04360962, -0.048736572, 0.048675537, -0.004058838, -0.020889282, -0.008842468, 0.020751953, -0.041381836, -0.0072250366, 0.0036258698, -0.044891357, 0.022277832, 0.01612854, 0.00083112717, -0.020263672, -0.0015478134, 0.0034503937, -0.0029621124, -0.011405945, -0.029144287, -0.03616333, 0.035003662, -0.01902771, 0.038604736, 0.029083252, 0.040985107, 0.04425049, -0.03302002, 0.045928955, -0.02659607, -0.019454956, 0.042175293, 0.026428223, -0.01096344, -0.0047683716, 0.0017614365, 0.035614014, -0.011947632, 0.0010261536, 0.0069885254, 0.019821167, -0.0043792725, -0.025024414, 0.01512146, -0.029586792, 0.014282227, 0.014595032, 0.00390625, -0.025360107, -0.043884277, -0.026641846, 0.018875122, -0.026184082, -0.021072388, 0.046539307, -0.05355835, -0.05999756, 0.009025574, 0.09240723, 0.042510986, 0.045898438, 0.03314209, 0.0035057068, 0.02470398, 0.030014038, -0.06311035, -0.019866943, 0.025924683, -0.0050201416, 0.059814453, -0.035949707, 0.016220093, -0.03503418, 0.0028076172, -0.014122009, -0.017349243, -0.028182983, 0.005619049, 0.045410156, -0.024002075, -0.0029830933, -0.007881165, 0.041015625, 0.016189575, 0.025558472, -0.06555176, -0.03439331, -0.07183838, 0.07208252, 0.004638672, -0.06512451, -0.0034675598, -0.041046143, -0.007873535, 0.0058021545, 0.023834229, -0.01449585, 0.014038086, -0.00075244904, -0.011413574, 0.0072746277, -0.04171753, -0.004398346, 0.02394104, -0.010131836, -0.041168213, 0.005622864, -0.015289307, -0.03366089, 0.032989502, 0.029296875, 0.018051147, -0.029144287, -0.007118225, -0.0017137527, -0.043792725, 0.0004911423, -0.009246826, -0.0038871765, -0.0284729, 0.029815674, -0.010818481, -0.008506775, 0.026672363, -0.042755127, -0.0050849915, -0.025817871, 0.015533447, -0.021697998, 0.018081665, 0.040618896, -0.020385742, -0.02178955, -0.02645874, -0.014289856, 0.0049095154, 0.01675415, -0.054779053, 0.02671814, 0.032073975, 0.008338928, 0.005432129, 0.010124207, 0.07891846, 0.021560669, 0.0029888153, -0.00048327446, 0.029266357, -0.042785645, -0.027053833, 0.05279541, 0.008338928, 0.01966858, -0.020629883, 0.020202637, 0.0231781, 0.006011963, -0.024368286, -0.0034236908, -0.020263672, 0.01902771, -0.038024902, -0.045654297, 0.007873535, -0.04989624, 0.013824463, -0.020141602, -0.007358551, -0.019561768, 0.013633728, 0.03253174, -0.026412964, -0.020263672, -0.04159546, -0.009353638, -0.027450562, -0.04989624, 0.048034668, 0.045074463, -0.03591919, 0.0033226013, 0.01109314, 0.018981934, -0.008621216, 0.042236328, 0.027664185, 0.008277893, -0.0231781, 0.024719238, 0.0073509216, 0.035888672, -0.00869751, 0.0013113022, 0.0046043396, 0.010353088, -0.04434204, 0.068115234, 0.066467285, -0.03186035, 0.012207031, -0.010025024, 0.0034599304, -0.032043457, -0.015701294, 0.020599365, -0.02961731, 0.035095215, 0.014755249, 0.017578125, 0.006137848, -0.024307251, 0.033691406, 0.012290955, 0.05758667, -0.035858154, -0.037963867, 0.008491516, 0.023605347, 0.00052547455, 0.050628662, 0.03567505, -0.0013780594, -0.01713562, 0.014076233, -0.0015830994, -0.026062012, 0.022476196, -0.02255249, 0.031555176, 0.0022716522, 0.006893158, 0.004219055, -0.024795532, -0.009346008, 0.007881165, -0.008712769, 0.01625061, -0.0061035156, 0.019317627, -0.009239197, 0.07922363, 0.029327393, -0.0024108887, 0.03744507, 0.00831604, -0.039154053, 0.04827881, -0.009498596, 0.00051641464, 0.01828003, 0.008399963, -0.03805542, -0.028747559, 0.026733398, -0.0041236877, -0.041229248, 0.037017822, 0.03756714, -0.03149414, -0.02067566, 0.045318604, 0.015617371, 0.0051994324, -0.046936035, -0.010681152, -0.047729492, -0.0053520203, -0.02319336, 0.009559631, 0.05859375, -0.049468994, 0.07220459, -0.07714844, -0.02456665, -0.02268982, 0.04989624, 0.08416748, 0.00032424927, 0.013389587, 0.055786133, 0.046691895, 0.029067993, -0.0054779053, -0.015686035, 0.029006958, 0.01763916, -0.016357422, 0.01689148, 0.010513306, 0.0008201599, -0.022109985, -0.011405945, -0.045959473, -0.031158447, -0.01222229, -0.0075149536, 0.054382324, 0.029800415, 0.005367279, -0.052459717, 0.02381897, 0.0028476715, -0.0014801025, -0.0034618378, 0.0001282692, 0.011367798, 0.016433716, -0.007858276, 0.019927979, -0.040893555, 0.042266846, -0.06738281, 0.0748291, -0.111816406, 0.016464233, -0.041503906, 0.028717041, 0.009269714, -0.03274536, -0.003955841, 0.014411926, 0.026672363, -0.02281189, -0.031829834, -0.007774353, 0.032989502, 0.0020217896, -0.008331299, 0.018096924, 0.034851074, 0.0059165955, -0.009803772, -0.015350342, -0.0072250366, -0.0287323, 0.012054443, 0.010597229, 0.024719238, 0.03845215, -0.019485474, -0.027450562, -0.0044670105, -0.024124146, -0.021087646, 0.00072431564, -0.016052246, 0.01889038, -0.012901306, -0.039001465, -0.05923462, -0.022354126, 0.030395508, 0.004310608, 0.026809692, 0.026504517, 0.07281494, -0.008399963, 0.014640808, 0.02470398, -0.024398804, -0.007545471, -0.011444092, -0.02279663, -0.017654419, -0.007843018, 0.0061798096, 0.016708374, 0.012390137, 0.0031585693, -0.00982666, -0.012458801, 0.015853882, 0.030014038, -0.024765015, -0.037475586, -0.038879395, 0.08728027, -0.02722168, 0.056854248, -0.068603516, -0.026153564, 0.019210815, -0.02722168, -0.0076942444, -0.017242432, 0.0037078857, -0.05041504, -0.028930664, -0.009429932, 0.048950195, -0.0010709763, -0.006389618, 0.012763977, 0.016296387, -0.03970337, 0.012687683, 0.0072250366, 0.008201599, -0.0050582886, -0.020385742, -0.07244873, 0.003042221, 0.035491943, -0.014289856, -0.008850098, 0.03074646, 0.0028076172, 0.011238098, 0.019897461, -0.034210205, -0.0044403076, -0.03024292, 0.057861328, 0.056274414, -0.0132369995, -0.013633728, 0.03540039, 0.06707764, -0.039886475, -0.02078247, 0.0357666, 0.02355957, -0.028900146, 0.00037884712, 0.053466797, 0.0044441223, -0.050354004, 0.029296875, -0.059509277, -0.010093689, 0.04711914, 0.038757324, -0.023071289, -0.06008911, 0.03543091, 0.020385742, -0.01260376, -0.04055786, 0.016052246, 0.051849365, -0.023117065, -0.039031982, 0.014717102, 0.06573486, 0.009384155, -0.016525269, -0.0019779205, 0.028686523, -0.045898438, 0.015655518, -0.013694763, 0.0009775162, 0.0072021484, -0.041931152, -0.030822754, 0.027633667, 0.035308838, -0.018051147, -0.023513794, 0.02243042, -0.015823364, -0.0067749023, -0.010093689, 0.018875122, -0.026123047, 0.040863037, -0.049591064, -0.0574646, 0.008682251, -0.016296387, -0.041534424, -0.016738892, -0.046844482, -0.05307007, -0.00907135, 0.008880615, -0.037200928, -0.0054130554, 0.024261475, 0.092041016, 0.053253174, 0.026123047, -0.07873535, -0.049102783, -0.013450623, 0.017196655, 0.015312195, 0.009361267, -0.013389587, -0.012893677, -0.0010347366, -0.005104065, 0.008331299, -0.018371582, -0.03665161, -0.03024292, 0.012077332, 0.022399902, 0.06317139, -0.011230469, -0.02027893, 0.013870239, -0.014884949, -0.008140564, 0.030914307, 0.036743164, 0.045562744, -0.027389526, 0.0085372925, -0.016647339, 0.014709473, -0.004081726, -0.01625061, 0.045562744, -0.010887146, -0.064453125, -0.017684937, 0.0031833649, -0.0026512146, 0.028442383, 0.024093628, -0.008911133, 0.01977539, -0.010597229, 0.012939453, 0.03491211, -0.013839722, -0.013801575, -0.03564453, -0.013381958, -0.058532715, -0.020233154, -0.06173706, -0.033233643, -0.03225708, 0.04208374, -0.019866943, -0.025314331, -0.03201294, -0.05718994, 0.03778076, 0.013710022, 0.024871826, -0.06896973, -0.012290955, -0.02116394, -0.028182983, 0.015235901, -0.011390686, -0.009254456, -0.024490356, 0.0008907318, 0.026153564, 0.004627228, -0.002910614, 0.03253174, -0.006286621, 0.025054932, -0.008781433, 0.010772705, -0.026977539, 0.023620605, -0.032714844, -0.010108948, 0.09020996, -0.00056028366, -0.0010728836, 0.028747559, 0.008979797, 0.024459839, -0.013801575, -0.050598145, 0.024230957, 0.0032997131, -0.012245178, 0.03137207, 0.017974854, 0.0031356812, 0.004135132, -0.0088272095, -0.0035362244, -0.023880005, 0.0021438599, -0.020584106, -0.014205933, 0.016601562, 0.023483276, 0.019989014, -0.022277832, 0.002571106, -0.04385376, -0.032043457, -0.03213501, -0.061920166, -0.009094238, -0.06994629, 0.022277832, -0.03375244, 0.0231781, -0.07775879, 0.0052604675, 0.015098572, -0.0052108765, 0.013656616, -0.024597168, 0.016464233, 0.014022827, 0.023376465, 0.015686035, 0.013221741, 0.0129852295, 0.016723633, -0.0690918, -0.021606445, -0.0034561157, 0.009010315, 0.019165039, -0.01612854, -0.0075912476, 0.039031982, -0.028900146, -0.0015745163, -0.007255554, -0.044433594, 0.008987427, -0.012016296, -0.043914795, -0.0007176399, -0.006298065, -0.027832031, 0.010734558, -0.0154418945, -0.014350891, 0.0034828186, 0.002046585, 0.03277588, 0.040771484, -0.021865845, -0.043029785, 0.07080078, 0.062805176, 0.0028705597, 0.02029419, -0.039520264, 0.014549255, 0.030838013, 0.011398315, 0.01612854, 0.015548706, -0.0020427704, -0.0013284683, 0.03479004, 0.0048980713, 0.012802124, 0.018981934, 0.014625549, 0.058441162, 0.006904602, -0.014122009, -0.03878784, 0.0063934326, 0.019958496, 0.005493164, 0.0023269653, -0.03186035, 0.007522583, -0.042938232, -0.031311035, 0.03842163, -0.021148682, -0.04055786, -0.002916336, -0.0045700073, -0.008392334, 0.06365967, 0.016952515, -0.009300232, 0.031036377, -0.007980347, -0.0035896301, -0.00258255, 0.021560669, -0.0013570786, 0.0050582886, -0.023834229, 0.015106201, 0.020065308, 0.019424438, -0.029281616, -0.0039901733, 0.021377563, 0.041625977, 0.01828003, 0.02029419, -0.0028362274, -0.027130127, -0.0030231476, 0.016296387, 0.00907135, -0.024108887, 0.020568848, -0.009185791, -0.080566406, -0.040039062, -0.07537842, -0.017532349, -0.06072998, 0.015335083, -0.054382324, 0.097473145, -0.02645874, 0.010185242, 0.07092285, -0.040527344, 0.08581543, -0.033935547, 0.004764557, 0.031082153, -0.0736084, -0.02557373, -0.01158905, 0.014060974, 0.016525269, 0.037994385, 0.013435364, 0.020553589, 0.023361206, -0.028671265, -0.02217102, -0.052337646, 0.03491211, -0.0284729, -0.0158844, -0.014984131, 0.009864807, 0.018676758, 0.007522583, 0.0011472702, 0.015388489, 0.028686523, -0.0054855347, -0.0045433044, 0.0032367706, 0.030319214, -0.07714844, 0.029434204, 0.028045654, -0.017044067, 0.0017576218, 0.080444336, -0.012687683, 0.008476257, 0.032287598, -0.0018367767, -0.014732361, 0.030380249, 0.016937256, -0.028045654, -0.033477783, -0.004623413, -0.003446579, -0.0016994476, 0.02368164, 0.02619934, -0.017608643, 0.009590149, 0.021331787, -0.016464233, 0.05508423, -0.01461792, 0.02671814, -0.053009033, -0.031951904, 0.0635376, 0.009170532, 0.017669678, 0.032104492, 0.034820557, 0.066833496, -0.034454346, 0.0814209, 0.07922363, 0.058441162, -0.010055542, 0.0057258606, 0.06756592, -0.022613525, 0.0368042, -0.015655518, -0.00907135, -0.060699463, -0.020751953, 0.005405426, -0.037322998, -0.002439499, 0.019927979, -0.050842285, 0.009056091, -0.01687622, -0.009407043, -0.006389618, -0.01159668, -0.017684937, -0.04336548, -0.028778076, 0.042144775, 0.05441284, 0.012817383, 0.06384277, 0.015167236, -0.054748535, 0.076171875, -0.00023055077, 0.0031032562, -0.014694214, -0.03866577, 0.014549255, 0.008491516, 0.048614502, 0.005241394, -0.034179688, 0.023895264, 0.010093689, 0.017227173, -0.027740479, -0.037597656, 0.055725098, 0.020629883, -0.07678223, 0.04156494, 0.015670776, 0.0070610046, 0.07281494, -0.06762695, 0.025421143, -0.0012397766, 0.00070619583, 0.022262573, -0.018051147, -0.026290894, 0.0060195923, -0.040100098, 0.012512207, -0.0010442734, -0.018371582, 0.020324707, 0.027297974, -0.059814453, -0.001077652, -0.014808655, 0.012741089, 0.004623413, -0.02178955, -0.0121536255, 0.020874023, 0.024597168, -0.0151901245, 0.008483887, 0.035217285, -0.002483368, -0.011886597, -0.02583313, -0.02557373, -0.0063209534, 0.051605225, 0.05895996, 0.022094727, -0.040405273, 0.029129028, 0.021499634, 0.0063476562, 0.0048446655, -0.012832642, 0.00041937828, -0.004459381, -0.02468872, -0.041656494, -0.009552002, 0.018936157, -0.043395996, 0.017349243, 0.0015258789, -0.014595032, -0.03390503, 0.0131073, -0.0395813, 0.004852295, -0.00053167343, -0.0013103485, -0.00995636, -0.033721924, 0.026947021, -0.009056091, 0.025604248, 0.017730713, -0.02659607, 0.033233643, -0.06451416, 0.029373169, 0.015258789, 0.0119018555, 0.012535095, 0.004245758, 0.03640747, 0.02015686, 0.011604309, 0.005306244, -0.0519104, -0.011779785, -0.07556152, -0.028701782, 0.0053863525, 0.002357483, 0.0017261505, 0.044830322, -0.014152527, 0.02470398, -0.023727417, 0.029220581, 0.019180298, -0.0041160583, 0.0037136078, -0.024215698, -0.00064992905 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1810.03044v3
Artificial Intelligence for Diabetes Case Management: The Intersection of Physical and Mental Health
Casey C. Bennett
q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Diabetes is a major public health problem in the United States, affecting roughly 30 million people. Diabetes complications, along with the mental health comorbidities that often co-occur with them, are major drivers of high healthcare costs, poor outcomes, and reduced treatment adherence in diabetes. Here, we evaluate in a large state-wide population whether we can use artificial intelligence (AI) techniques to identify clusters of patient trajectories within the broader diabetes population in order to create cost-effective, narrowly-focused case management intervention strategies to reduce development of complications. This approach combined data from: 1) claims, 2) case management notes, and 3) social determinants of health from ~300,000 real patients between 2014 and 2016. We categorized complications as five types: Cardiovascular, Neuropathy, Opthalmic, Renal, and Other. Modeling was performed combining a variety of machine learning algorithms, including supervised classification, unsupervised clustering, natural language processing of unstructured care notes, and feature engineering. The results showed that we can predict development of diabetes complications roughly 83.5% of the time using claims data or social determinants of health data. They also showed we can reveal meaningful clusters in the patient population related to complications and mental health that can be used to cost-effective screening program, reducing the number of patients to be screened down by 85%. This study outlines creation of an AI framework to develop protocols to better address mental health comorbidities that lead to complications development in the diabetes population. Future work is described that outlines potential lines of research and the need for better addressing the 'people side' of the equation.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03044v3
2019-05-10T18:59:06
2018-10-06T19:59:56
{ "title": [ 0.018844604, 0.006919861, -0.019714355, -0.049041748, 0.017242432, -0.019439697, 0.00077342987, -0.020217896, -0.031677246, 0.04257202, -0.027938843, 0.00592041, 0.03125, -0.033691406, -0.01474762, -0.0067825317, 0.011886597, 0.01309967, 0.0033130646, -0.018157959, 0.006450653, -0.022659302, 0.050842285, 0.022537231, -0.00029468536, 0.011810303, -0.09472656, -0.014549255, -0.06210327, -0.06854248, -0.017440796, 0.07299805, 0.01348114, -0.0017776489, 0.021255493, 0.0050621033, -0.011878967, 0.011367798, 0.009864807, -0.006881714, 0.018005371, -0.02998352, -0.026184082, -0.0021591187, -0.015464783, 0.007843018, -0.05117798, -0.024658203, 0.01020813, 0.024856567, 0.016418457, 0.01134491, 0.0019397736, 0.0109939575, -0.0068626404, -0.008270264, -0.025009155, -0.02798462, 0.049102783, -0.0030651093, -0.010864258, -0.07489014, 0.06365967, -0.0075798035, -0.044830322, -0.02331543, -0.02355957, 0.015136719, 0.08111572, -0.00907135, 0.0016975403, 0.038848877, 0.012504578, 0.018417358, -0.04360962, -0.03439331, 0.04727173, 0.01878357, 0.04260254, -0.020233154, -0.006793976, -0.018508911, 0.0206604, -0.035980225, 0.013130188, -0.025253296, -0.0012083054, -0.003479004, -0.015945435, -0.022415161, -0.0077552795, 0.00049829483, -0.013748169, 0.021209717, -0.00541687, -0.036956787, 0.017059326, 0.0395813, 0.010299683, -0.012870789, -0.010345459, -0.002872467, -0.023468018, -0.019699097, 0.01864624, 0.054260254, -0.0002837181, -0.016479492, -0.011634827, 0.015625, -0.024002075, -0.020507812, 0.01184845, -0.02166748, 0.0040740967, -0.0057640076, -0.013786316, 0.025924683, 0.024108887, 0.013793945, 0.011604309, -0.016799927, 0.0020389557, 0.028366089, 0.02407837, 0.016403198, -0.04421997, 0.012817383, -0.027679443, 0.03945923, -0.011634827, 0.04748535, -0.070495605, -0.07928467, -0.051361084, 0.017089844, -0.0023097992, -0.0069847107, 0.0030136108, -0.004131317, 0.03074646, -0.018936157, 0.017166138, 0.04232788, -0.036193848, 0.011734009, 0.045654297, 0.00039863586, -0.040008545, -0.06958008, -0.02420044, -0.0062294006, 0.010848999, 0.023590088, -0.06359863, 0.027755737, -0.090270996, 0.010887146, -0.005428314, 0.009056091, 0.053131104, 0.011680603, -0.0065956116, 0.01461792, 0.054504395, -0.019958496, -0.040283203, 0.023910522, 0.0058021545, 0.039215088, -0.00012469292, -0.011306763, 0.0074310303, -0.0013952255, -0.0058555603, 0.010650635, 0.01083374, -0.008392334, 0.012573242, -0.038757324, -0.046325684, -0.05026245, -0.04638672, 0.039031982, -0.05227661, -0.0049743652, -0.00071287155, 0.01953125, 0.049560547, -0.0030765533, -0.026794434, 0.0051841736, -0.057800293, -0.039001465, -0.039245605, 0.004047394, 0.025039673, 0.03314209, -0.0063934326, 0.021499634, -0.04837036, 0.022262573, -0.031707764, 0.009719849, -0.025054932, -0.007827759, -0.010688782, 0.04144287, -0.034179688, 0.05429077, 0.039154053, -0.010520935, -0.0076828003, -0.027740479, 0.00050878525, -0.058410645, -0.020401001, -0.0050315857, -0.03677368, -0.0138168335, -0.052764893, -0.020324707, -0.008232117, 0.023361206, 0.02331543, 0.019805908, -0.007507324, -0.024261475, 0.045074463, 0.013298035, 0.048980713, 0.004562378, 0.0046081543, 0.01209259, -0.024337769, -0.01876831, 0.02029419, -0.019363403, 0.023803711, 0.018432617, 0.0057792664, -0.025390625, 0.023406982, 0.038757324, 0.045654297, 0.000050783157, 0.006576538, 0.010673523, 0.049926758, 0.03010559, 0.03277588, -0.009460449, 0.056640625, 0.030075073, 0.021972656, 0.046966553, -0.021316528, -0.0236969, -0.0046577454, -0.003124237, 0.019851685, 0.028656006, 0.0024528503, 0.016708374, -0.0317688, 0.024230957, -0.019546509, 0.031341553, -0.026489258, 0.020202637, 0.038269043, 0.018310547, -0.00037789345, 0.018966675, 0.0046844482, -0.027954102, -0.019866943, 0.011764526, 0.013008118, -0.02407837, 0.009895325, 0.015182495, 0.051086426, -0.00052785873, 0.018692017, 0.027496338, 0.021133423, 0.0013151169, -0.031066895, -0.02142334, 0.026535034, 0.03112793, 0.0058937073, -0.010093689, 0.03375244, 0.0016832352, 0.050445557, 0.083984375, -0.033447266, 0.03564453, -0.08660889, 0.0010309219, 0.030532837, -0.03930664, -0.012336731, 0.015808105, -0.0090408325, 0.026428223, -0.012809753, -0.036376953, 0.009468079, 0.060760498, 0.016738892, -0.010635376, 0.0040512085, -0.024169922, -0.017669678, 0.0004196167, -0.058746338, -0.03201294, 0.008255005, -0.00067281723, -0.021759033, -0.01411438, 0.01083374, -0.005207062, -0.04248047, -0.010757446, 0.0029468536, 0.0031490326, 0.052856445, 0.020477295, -0.056396484, 0.0019931793, 0.03668213, 0.04046631, 0.0014629364, 0.031082153, -0.009086609, -0.033935547, -0.008171082, 0.02798462, -0.011947632, -0.043060303, 0.0074043274, -0.025604248, 0.0040893555, 0.00381279, -0.020980835, 0.005680084, 0.009353638, -0.015731812, -0.041503906, -0.015457153, 0.035125732, -0.028152466, 0.010627747, 0.019592285, 0.027313232, -0.021591187, 0.07080078, 0.027359009, 0.03286743, -0.017990112, -0.008071899, -0.087402344, -0.00012886524, -0.02796936, 0.022232056, 0.035949707, -0.05706787, -0.0013971329, -0.03793335, 0.0016336441, 0.022842407, 0.02067566, -0.019104004, -0.022598267, -0.018081665, -0.023635864, 0.035247803, 0.010520935, 0.020767212, 0.0062179565, 0.09362793, -0.0079193115, -0.028381348, -0.0015172958, 0.03933716, 0.026657104, -0.010643005, -0.040985107, -0.03414917, 0.007293701, 0.03387451, 0.0063591003, -0.03778076, 0.01789856, -0.13220215, 0.008476257, 0.07550049, 0.0035209656, -0.031097412, 0.05114746, -0.060760498, 0.02319336, 0.03250122, -0.0012960434, 0.037261963, 0.058258057, -0.027313232, 0.022216797, -0.0066833496, -0.00730896, -0.01210022, 0.0058174133, -0.0713501, 0.010543823, -0.003419876, -0.0121154785, 0.023727417, -0.04309082, -0.0087509155, 0.015472412, -0.02166748, 0.061431885, 0.020111084, 0.022583008, 0.0047035217, -0.042419434, 0.0046463013, -0.0390625, -0.021087646, -0.055358887, -0.0067596436, 0.0035152435, -0.027420044, 0.05206299, -0.041992188, 0.027328491, -0.05441284, -0.00894928, 0.021209717, 0.016052246, 0.005645752, -0.013305664, -0.023117065, -0.026031494, -0.04055786, -0.010948181, -0.0084991455, 0.020095825, -0.036010742, 0.00957489, -0.015823364, 0.042999268, 0.0003156662, 0.034179688, -0.05218506, -0.014526367, 0.0061035156, -0.037017822, -0.0009665489, -0.00969696, -0.004119873, -0.011657715, 0.05886841, -0.014801025, -0.03314209, 0.02722168, -0.032562256, 0.016998291, 0.00016701221, -0.005947113, -0.018493652, -0.006324768, 0.0020503998, 0.00033140182, -0.00004953146, -0.0046958923, -0.014221191, 0.02192688, -0.03326416, -0.066467285, -0.029388428, 0.008460999, -0.12017822, -0.070617676, 0.021942139, -0.087402344, -0.07940674, -0.050445557, 0.0069999695, -0.07055664, -0.021606445, 0.008430481, -0.009643555, 0.019104004, -0.019195557, -0.072631836, -0.032928467, 0.049957275, -0.021697998, 0.02078247, 0.0015888214, 0.012802124, -0.006565094, -0.01272583, 0.021621704, 0.00048422813, 0.007873535, -0.02003479, -0.024093628, 0.0335083, -0.032836914, 0.02128601, 0.00049448013, 0.0022392273, -0.015899658, 0.011703491, 0.041503906, 0.050079346, -0.03326416, 0.047698975, 0.0418396, -0.02897644, -0.07019043, -0.024978638, 0.0070495605, -0.039276123, 0.0046844482, -0.027633667, 0.015777588, 0.04763794, 0.018218994, 0.07171631, 0.0003066063, 0.0060272217, -0.008560181, -0.03125, -0.009986877, 0.0005283356, 0.009780884, -0.016311646, 0.0016527176, 0.009124756, -0.012512207, 0.055267334, 0.0022239685, 0.00054359436, 0.008216858, 0.019500732, -0.040771484, -0.024841309, -0.051971436, -0.011116028, -0.035217285, 0.028305054, 0.0017175674, -0.016906738, 0.040496826, 0.013832092, -0.041534424, -0.0047721863, 0.04031372, -0.00869751, 0.005065918, -0.0579834, 0.011787415, -0.021469116, -0.09692383, -0.0473938, -0.020370483, 0.012802124, 0.019119263, 0.0033397675, -0.0143585205, 0.017089844, 0.017028809, 0.043914795, 0.044921875, -0.008880615, -0.046295166, 0.027008057, -0.018829346, -0.026748657, -0.0008831024, 0.028457642, -0.003271103, -0.039245605, 0.0019683838, -0.03677368, -0.009475708, -0.08099365, 0.024642944, 0.018630981, 0.019012451, 0.010848999, -0.0018043518, 0.018707275, 0.009857178, 0.008338928, -0.007865906, -0.046295166, 0.006134033, 0.0008535385, 0.047424316, -0.050323486, -0.01550293, 0.055603027, 0.028213501, 0.0066490173, 0.0062713623, -0.013130188, 0.04269409, 0.009895325, -0.023880005, 0.0446167, -0.036987305, -0.030517578, -0.008956909, -0.0019521713, 0.030899048, -0.042541504, 0.027282715, -0.04171753, 0.014183044, -0.004825592, -0.017242432, 0.01890564, -0.01725769, 0.023117065, -0.03314209, -0.0055732727, 0.0011034012, 0.0037937164, -0.020645142, -0.0072364807, 0.007587433, 0.021636963, 0.05105591, -0.008285522, -0.044433594, -0.020309448, 0.014862061, 0.010147095, -0.005088806, 0.006072998, -0.017974854, -0.0034561157, -0.03643799, 0.007522583, -0.013427734, -0.027267456, -0.04244995, -0.022766113, -0.0074501038, 0.00024962425, 0.012924194, -0.05319214, 0.02053833, 0.061645508, -0.0034828186, 0.017913818, -0.0023231506, 0.005016327, 0.039154053, 0.034729004, -0.003627777, -0.00932312, 0.027542114, -0.04348755, 0.030029297, 0.017837524, 0.0546875, -0.01007843, -0.026763916, -0.008338928, -0.037963867, -0.027069092, 0.022521973, -0.01763916, 0.012145996, 0.011657715, -0.040283203, 0.009757996, -0.022476196, -0.01625061, 0.000106692314, -0.059539795, -0.041290283, 0.026031494, -0.039001465, 0.01802063, -0.000518322, -0.027435303, -0.014526367, -0.070373535, -0.0047340393, -0.013793945, 0.0013389587, -0.022903442, 0.074035645, -0.014373779, 0.012504578, 0.015960693, -0.064086914, 0.0017547607, 0.0073013306, 0.016448975, 0.028823853, 0.008354187, -0.03173828, -0.0014667511, -0.030471802, -0.056121826, -0.043823242, 0.0033302307, -0.012863159, 0.022964478, -0.018341064, -0.03366089, -0.0385437, -0.0059890747, 0.011268616, 0.0006213188, -0.054382324, 0.014953613, -0.014045715, -0.0058403015, 0.014442444, 0.041168213, 0.033355713, -0.011199951, -0.0015535355, -0.047729492, 0.03955078, -0.011619568, 0.0116119385, -0.011505127, -0.045806885, 0.0016756058, 0.028121948, 0.0006351471, -0.021148682, 0.03781128, 0.044677734, 0.008285522, -0.027038574, 0.02168274, 0.068237305, -0.06311035, -0.04095459, -0.044555664, -0.005744934, -0.046783447, 0.044158936, 0.0017795563, -0.04449463, -0.0287323, -0.040008545, -0.029342651, 0.009529114, 0.031066895, 0.015716553, 0.06124878, -0.03955078, -0.010253906, -0.04849243, 0.013908386, 0.0023269653, 0.0034065247, -0.022781372, -0.0044174194, 0.0028076172, 0.030075073, -0.023254395, -0.018981934, 0.039855957, 0.042907715, 0.0038795471, 0.011199951, -0.035614014, -0.025924683, -0.03643799, -0.00472641, 0.037475586, 0.011657715, -0.04425049, 0.01361084, -0.023330688, 0.063964844, 0.027511597, 0.026321411, 0.052764893, 0.064086914, 0.04284668, 0.007286072, 0.055145264, 0.008300781, -0.0059432983, -0.05303955, 0.010910034, -0.013061523, 0.006336212, -0.074523926, 0.0021476746, 0.030593872, 0.05807495, -0.01852417, 0.030838013, 0.009727478, 0.0029830933, 0.06500244, -0.0030822754, 0.095214844, 0.0013008118, -0.010665894, -0.009811401, 0.023223877, 0.0005784035, 0.015022278, 0.019638062, 0.033966064, -0.0007119179, -0.0045433044, -0.01007843, 0.0024852753, 0.024765015, -0.03152466, -0.011436462, -0.0054130554, 0.021224976, -0.017044067, 0.00046873093, 0.0597229, 0.07714844, -0.058410645, 0.003030777, 0.030197144, 0.00094747543, -0.0056915283, -0.011062622, 0.06665039, -0.07904053, 0.045806885, -0.010314941, -0.048583984, -0.018661499, 0.04647827, 0.0073890686, -0.023803711, -0.015167236, 0.030349731, 0.019470215, 0.037078857, 0.02192688, -0.03955078, -0.016693115, 0.030029297, 0.0032234192, -0.026977539, -0.0063476562, 0.02998352, 0.05117798, -0.009391785, -0.0015974045, -0.008735657, -0.0042266846, -0.032104492, 0.02192688, -0.00035738945, 0.039154053, -0.03994751, -0.057495117, 0.017852783, -0.014167786, -0.019866943, -0.030929565, 0.010665894, 0.006614685, 0.02482605, 0.06506348, 0.019897461, 0.0062675476, -0.025543213, -0.007888794, 0.03768921, 0.021118164, -0.027160645, 0.017288208, -0.04711914, -0.035736084, 0.0098724365, -0.055389404, 0.04824829, -0.009033203, 0.008384705, -0.006526947, -0.0052719116, 0.04031372, -0.02468872, -0.024917603, -0.0061073303, -0.039916992, -0.0046157837, 0.021514893, -0.014091492, 0.0062065125, -0.005252838, -0.006881714, -0.004371643, 0.025741577, 0.016464233, -0.05130005, -0.042419434, 0.043640137, 0.02053833, 0.055511475, 0.023620605, -0.036956787, -0.037963867, 0.024291992, 0.026885986, 0.020263672, -0.051635742, 0.080566406, -0.010757446, -0.009315491, -0.01386261, -0.00617218, -0.034423828, -0.0635376, 0.010871887, -0.0016202927, -0.03253174, -0.010696411, 0.008888245, -0.011672974, -0.05407715, -0.020935059, -0.023330688, -0.011688232, 0.020019531, -0.013549805, 0.0005016327, 0.022491455, -0.023651123, -0.02696228, -0.008804321, 0.017120361, -0.027374268, -0.011924744, -0.030014038, 0.04043579, 0.05215454, -0.061035156, -0.11126709, -0.0138168335, 0.05517578, -0.015411377, 0.038116455, -0.0002837181, 0.0021629333, 0.043304443, 0.0335083, 0.0059432983, -0.04269409, -0.046661377, -0.05606079, 0.06958008, 0.033294678, -0.028793335, -0.014045715, 0.038330078, 0.012535095, 0.004776001, 0.0022029877, -0.0287323, 0.001458168, 0.0035171509, 0.012992859, 0.008743286, -0.020248413, 0.010932922, 0.015335083, -0.010772705, 0.020462036, -0.03756714, 0.017974854, -0.0011577606, 0.03805542, -0.010559082, -0.045288086, 0.04284668, 0.043701172, 0.00957489, 0.031921387, -0.0054512024, -0.028427124, -0.01701355, -0.017166138, -0.0033359528, -0.012817383, 0.06072998, -0.07745361, -0.010696411, -0.021316528, -0.040222168, -0.00079870224, -0.033447266, 0.03314209, -0.044128418, 0.016586304, -0.03643799, -0.010406494, 0.017654419, 0.025741577, 0.036712646, -0.0054359436, -0.048980713, -0.0014486313, 0.023345947, -0.024124146 ], "summary": [ 0.06365967, -0.0048713684, 0.03152466, -0.076049805, -0.007045746, 0.0025939941, -0.023910522, -0.024734497, -0.022109985, 0.027130127, 0.0062026978, 0.016983032, 0.014663696, -0.042999268, 0.013542175, -0.010772705, -0.009140015, 0.020355225, 0.03765869, -0.023223877, 0.041625977, -0.041290283, 0.041107178, 0.0057754517, -0.01777649, -0.03173828, -0.074157715, 0.026382446, -0.06677246, -0.04196167, -0.015930176, 0.09112549, -0.014228821, -0.0064697266, 0.057128906, 0.018981934, 0.022399902, -0.0068130493, 0.040008545, -0.0087890625, 0.035186768, -0.014892578, 0.103149414, -0.027328491, 0.035888672, 0.041229248, 0.008171082, -0.04135132, 0.036956787, -0.0008029938, 0.00042438507, -0.01020813, -0.006996155, -0.031555176, -0.031921387, 0.009689331, 0.016845703, -0.01977539, 0.04373169, -0.044006348, -0.021118164, -0.046020508, 0.041381836, 0.002506256, -0.04849243, 0.008720398, 0.044403076, 0.0039711, 0.0569458, -0.0569458, -0.025253296, 0.05380249, 0.0022678375, 0.012771606, -0.0075950623, -0.026031494, 0.0071868896, -0.018325806, 0.027404785, 0.019363403, -0.031066895, -0.01777649, 0.03781128, -0.06112671, -0.0042648315, -0.019073486, -0.017730713, 0.0069351196, 0.0005674362, -0.009422302, -0.02017212, -0.0287323, 0.0042800903, 0.05215454, 0.023956299, -0.037597656, 0.031433105, 0.025115967, 0.008003235, -0.0025405884, 0.013977051, -0.03665161, 0.017349243, -0.01272583, -0.007129669, 0.07678223, -0.005558014, -0.029525757, -0.006011963, 0.013755798, 0.004348755, -0.071899414, 0.008522034, -0.024795532, -0.0071754456, 0.020385742, 0.001253128, 0.03842163, 0.0054740906, 0.028717041, 0.0006542206, 0.021911621, -0.0385437, 0.033813477, 0.0113220215, 0.011657715, 0.005428314, 0.006816864, -0.05810547, 0.03668213, -0.003780365, 0.015182495, 0.03756714, 0.013900757, -0.008758545, -0.019332886, 0.02885437, -0.03286743, 0.0013570786, 0.014312744, 0.03149414, -0.04727173, -0.032470703, 0.040161133, -0.030700684, 0.006389618, 0.027709961, 0.015991211, -0.027114868, -0.040252686, 0.025680542, -0.023406982, 0.053985596, -0.0082092285, -0.11450195, -0.029708862, -0.085754395, 0.029678345, -0.025650024, -0.043060303, 0.054595947, 0.019577026, 0.014160156, 0.02659607, 0.024932861, -0.033325195, -0.04675293, -0.004234314, 0.026794434, -0.0018749237, 0.02885437, -0.010498047, 0.032592773, 0.0035648346, 0.00004082918, 0.008483887, 0.0037345886, -0.06970215, 0.0038433075, -0.026733398, -0.036590576, -0.028045654, -0.086120605, 0.036376953, -0.061279297, 0.09667969, 0.0077171326, 0.1071167, 0.011711121, 0.007286072, -0.020553589, 0.019195557, -0.034942627, -0.045959473, -0.039215088, 0.027954102, 0.029296875, 0.032470703, -0.0022907257, 0.012901306, 0.008132935, 0.037628174, -0.038024902, -0.008361816, -0.040222168, -0.0030117035, -0.0031089783, 0.02961731, -0.035461426, 0.03149414, 0.041992188, -0.010765076, -0.03817749, 0.039520264, 0.0039749146, -0.046905518, -0.009490967, -0.0036849976, -0.03237915, -0.002210617, -0.044311523, -0.002948761, -0.026626587, 0.04763794, 0.015197754, -0.0059127808, -0.021362305, -0.028884888, 0.011642456, -0.009353638, 0.027572632, 0.03930664, -0.039794922, -0.030014038, -0.027435303, 0.012413025, 0.030731201, -0.055236816, 0.005908966, 0.03503418, 0.019210815, 0.0073661804, -0.0335083, -0.03189087, -0.0015001297, -0.051513672, -0.0011634827, -0.0077781677, -0.008422852, 0.0022850037, 0.011199951, -0.014167786, 0.014053345, 0.0385437, 0.0062789917, 0.020233154, -0.008834839, -0.048614502, 0.056152344, -0.02368164, 0.01675415, -0.010803223, -0.031433105, 0.021850586, -0.01197052, -0.001373291, 0.0012741089, 0.012794495, -0.02822876, -0.024047852, 0.019561768, 0.006008148, 0.0033817291, -0.011734009, 0.009101868, -0.0026950836, -0.042785645, 0.008399963, 0.043701172, -0.0046081543, 0.015716553, 0.04623413, 0.020996094, -0.013534546, -0.0036907196, 0.012664795, 0.0030822754, 0.007396698, 0.013572693, 0.029647827, 0.031036377, 0.041625977, 0.016326904, 0.0022010803, 0.05343628, 0.00065374374, 0.05331421, 0.042175293, -0.0068626404, 0.011695862, -0.010612488, 0.01247406, 0.0065841675, -0.023101807, -0.02166748, 0.018417358, -0.03540039, 0.03265381, 0.011856079, -0.099731445, 0.088012695, 0.07537842, 0.00074338913, 0.044952393, -0.0008234978, -0.026626587, 0.0057525635, 0.02104187, -0.009498596, -0.011199951, 0.019210815, 0.0076828003, -0.01626587, 0.012886047, 0.020935059, -0.011169434, -0.009887695, -0.0073890686, -0.016998291, -0.020401001, -0.022384644, -0.02319336, -0.03277588, 0.06561279, 0.020690918, 0.028259277, 0.018188477, 0.046875, -0.007537842, -0.04623413, -0.010070801, 0.04940796, -0.029785156, -0.013671875, -0.027694702, -0.001947403, 0.011375427, 0.0036830902, -0.074523926, -0.012504578, 0.03488159, -0.03479004, -0.05441284, 0.018157959, 0.0054397583, 0.0023937225, 0.04486084, 0.045196533, 0.025268555, -0.017852783, 0.055725098, 0.017440796, 0.011940002, -0.058807373, -0.028198242, -0.05267334, -0.00756073, -0.048095703, 0.08081055, 0.038085938, -0.07910156, 0.039489746, 0.045440674, 0.03164673, 0.10522461, 0.018371582, 0.027999878, 0.009124756, -0.020629883, 0.0146865845, 0.049957275, 0.013633728, 0.010223389, -0.007987976, 0.06506348, -0.030792236, -0.025146484, 0.018051147, 0.04748535, 0.051818848, -0.0076904297, -0.06585693, -0.02784729, -0.0059127808, 0.042663574, 0.002462387, -0.0014190674, 0.046173096, -0.08605957, -0.032806396, 0.04534912, -0.004787445, -0.0005970001, -0.00484848, -0.014472961, 0.0028495789, 0.01512146, -0.002960205, 0.033081055, 0.028305054, 0.013412476, 0.059753418, 0.0048217773, 0.061676025, -0.021850586, -0.017944336, 0.035308838, -0.014587402, 0.02607727, -0.018371582, 0.034484863, -0.041107178, 0.034332275, 0.019485474, -0.025741577, 0.02708435, -0.010803223, 0.028701782, -0.00039434433, -0.023071289, -0.012008667, -0.024734497, -0.016403198, -0.025436401, -0.037384033, 0.028900146, -0.004486084, 0.038330078, -0.0067863464, -0.007167816, -0.030380249, 0.014816284, 0.026107788, -0.009979248, 0.023147583, -0.009414673, 0.016433716, -0.016189575, -0.013374329, -0.024459839, -0.008872986, 0.0016050339, 0.017684937, 0.030288696, 0.008308411, 0.07543945, -0.026184082, 0.016815186, -0.008544922, -0.0075302124, 0.0038318634, -0.030563354, 0.009643555, -0.01751709, 0.0051498413, -0.00004208088, 0.014953613, 0.0002734661, 0.003709793, -0.016662598, -0.021133423, 0.00020086765, 0.00004684925, -0.014411926, -0.036071777, -0.060302734, 0.039245605, -0.0031013489, 0.06549072, -0.019958496, -0.048706055, 0.02748108, -0.02128601, -0.099609375, -0.0637207, 0.013725281, -0.11236572, -0.073913574, 0.018875122, -0.014350891, -0.031311035, -0.02670288, 0.02708435, -0.007850647, -0.0046424866, 0.027359009, -0.014350891, 0.09832764, -0.014907837, -0.060699463, -0.010299683, -0.027633667, -0.023132324, 0.018844604, -0.020065308, 0.08050537, 0.058624268, -0.00029563904, -0.02784729, -0.07611084, 0.045135498, -0.070617676, 0.002008438, 0.021987915, -0.024124146, 0.0021209717, -0.00031924248, 0.021514893, -0.008712769, 0.0008740425, 0.04248047, 0.08428955, -0.026779175, 0.010154724, 0.0033092499, -0.017593384, -0.041290283, -0.001001358, -0.0015296936, -0.023132324, 0.039642334, 0.02760315, -0.030960083, -0.0068206787, 0.0072631836, -0.006225586, 0.0178833, -0.018997192, -0.031097412, -0.01574707, 0.008087158, 0.019927979, 0.0014629364, -0.014045715, -0.00027608871, -0.022445679, -0.0049934387, 0.028503418, -0.010620117, -0.016403198, -0.002790451, 0.016143799, -0.038330078, -0.04711914, -0.029785156, 0.06100464, -0.006187439, 0.023529053, 0.009811401, -0.05807495, -0.020355225, 0.0074005127, 0.009033203, -0.014381409, 0.06591797, 0.019744873, 0.003189087, -0.024002075, -0.013404846, -0.01701355, -0.03665161, -0.008117676, 0.0016069412, -0.022018433, -0.010063171, -0.010856628, -0.009490967, -0.008720398, 0.015991211, 0.023925781, 0.0029182434, 0.021331787, -0.013938904, -0.043121338, -0.015068054, -0.02116394, -0.014915466, -0.005760193, -0.02229309, -0.02760315, 0.040924072, -0.031555176, -0.019378662, -0.051605225, -0.016967773, 0.030670166, 0.010055542, 0.009490967, 0.00907135, 0.002193451, 0.021011353, 0.028030396, 0.017318726, -0.008354187, -0.05819702, 0.009162903, 0.01197052, -0.0010557175, -0.029800415, 0.030975342, 0.0053100586, 0.006263733, 0.03479004, -0.05105591, 0.0259552, 0.045806885, -0.0513916, 0.062927246, 0.033935547, 0.014823914, 0.032470703, -0.001405716, 0.012649536, 0.019195557, 0.004295349, 0.0024585724, -0.01084137, 0.011940002, -0.02558899, -0.015556335, -0.020690918, -0.008590698, -0.032562256, -0.011047363, -0.0013399124, -0.015426636, 0.018463135, 0.0035686493, 0.040740967, 0.01121521, 0.015136719, -0.0126571655, -0.047058105, -0.019210815, 0.050720215, -0.0009784698, 0.000105559826, 0.015327454, -0.01374054, -0.024124146, -0.021331787, -0.0016183853, -0.0046920776, -0.032409668, -0.0020694733, -0.03378296, -0.002811432, -0.00051021576, 0.032684326, -0.057556152, -0.045013428, 0.016540527, -0.026947021, -0.016983032, 0.024414062, -0.007896423, -0.034332275, 0.01234436, -0.037872314, 0.0015459061, -0.008277893, -0.053222656, 0.08898926, 0.020858765, 0.022964478, 0.0005774498, -0.044921875, -0.032714844, -0.048797607, 0.042236328, 0.00006771088, -0.0014696121, 0.058563232, -0.031585693, -0.025512695, -0.008026123, -0.011390686, 0.009597778, -0.007843018, -0.012756348, -0.0060920715, -0.0026416779, -0.006954193, -0.02180481, -0.0024642944, -0.02519226, -0.0018939972, -0.05130005, -0.033172607, -0.032592773, -0.024047852, 0.00035858154, 0.07598877, 0.027236938, -0.0056610107, -0.007411957, -0.026626587, 0.0066184998, 0.027770996, 0.015777588, 0.0044937134, 0.010551453, -0.016494751, 0.00920105, -0.026657104, -0.035491943, -0.07861328, -0.015991211, -0.02960205, 0.06137085, -0.028900146, -0.0027656555, 0.01826477, -0.03363037, 0.010147095, 0.005744934, -0.01651001, -0.01739502, 0.011222839, 0.015975952, -0.0039787292, -0.015609741, -0.003376007, -0.0045547485, 0.005519867, -0.031585693, 0.031402588, -0.0004851818, 0.04525757, -0.05529785, -0.0043525696, -0.021484375, 0.040740967, 0.0067749023, -0.035736084, -0.028915405, 0.008155823, -0.02381897, -0.0395813, -0.039489746, 0.05215454, -0.04385376, -0.07537842, -0.035491943, 0.027542114, -0.023284912, 0.011688232, 0.011779785, -0.067993164, 0.02067566, -0.05429077, 0.009857178, -0.02104187, 0.008018494, 0.0075263977, 0.016342163, -0.00522995, 0.015777588, -0.038146973, -0.024093628, 0.052124023, -0.010917664, -0.010848999, -0.035705566, 0.032196045, 0.013999939, -0.029296875, -0.005596161, 0.0038471222, 0.038360596, 0.024368286, -0.0020065308, -0.0019292831, -0.021743774, 0.011627197, 0.0010890961, 0.002878189, -0.0049934387, 0.011436462, 0.0037384033, 0.010116577, 0.018875122, 0.017791748, -0.02468872, -0.024459839, 0.036254883, 0.04385376, -0.008811951, 0.054260254, 0.024124146, 0.014732361, -0.008216858, -0.038085938, -0.027832031, -0.032989502, 0.0041275024, 0.011512756, 0.010108948, 0.008834839, 0.013954163, 0.03451538, 0.0068893433, 0.037322998, 0.040802002, 0.0211792, 0.060821533, -0.0019893646, 0.0068626404, -0.0023460388, -0.008155823, -0.02217102, 0.018417358, -0.022262573, 0.046661377, 0.014007568, 0.02859497, 0.018356323, -0.053253174, 0.009979248, -0.044189453, 0.01663208, 0.0019216537, 0.027404785, 0.00084638596, 0.022583008, 0.038757324, 0.019195557, 0.013473511, -0.013748169, 0.025741577, 0.0024909973, -0.023040771, 0.023788452, 0.0051727295, -0.02583313, 0.03274536, 0.012016296, -0.03515625, 0.0184021, 0.010292053, 0.043151855, -0.027679443, -0.025741577, 0.014198303, 0.02015686, -0.0014886856, -0.013473511, -0.035888672, 0.010040283, 0.022354126, -0.021972656, 0.014457703, -0.023239136, 0.0016183853, -0.014251709, 0.02859497, 0.02104187, -0.006504059, 0.0597229, 0.006427765, 0.032196045, -0.018081665, 0.0018224716, -0.016738892, -0.017211914, 0.00415802, -0.0036792755, -0.004524231, -0.011878967, 0.024978638, 0.013877869, 0.022476196, 0.051605225, -0.0065231323, 0.024337769, 0.0027484894, 0.0009531975, 0.027770996, 0.02507019, 0.004840851, -0.00022876263, -0.028884888, -0.010543823, -0.0084991455, -0.01776123, 0.025009155, -0.05114746, 0.0056877136, -0.003162384, -0.017364502, -0.002784729, 0.012893677, 0.008285522, -0.040130615, -0.03945923, 0.013343811, 0.052825928, -0.033843994, 0.010009766, -0.028640747, -0.028198242, -0.026153564, 0.03363037, 0.027038574, -0.041015625, 0.004802704, 0.009155273, 0.053344727, 0.04486084, 0.050354004, -0.049621582, -0.043426514, 0.042297363, 0.05441284, 0.016616821, -0.038970947, 0.095947266, 0.022323608, -0.043670654, -0.00063085556, -0.0044822693, -0.04815674, -0.07318115, 0.04067993, -0.018539429, -0.03062439, -0.0069274902, 0.005744934, 0.018417358, -0.0042533875, -0.022140503, -0.006126404, -0.0289917, -0.01751709, 0.00037622452, 0.0021400452, 0.033935547, -0.040100098, -0.03768921, -0.020355225, -0.016403198, -0.01235199, -0.015419006, -0.019821167, 0.020019531, 0.035003662, -0.031585693, -0.03515625, -0.0044898987, -0.00598526, -0.0053977966, -0.039520264, -0.029525757, -0.046081543, 0.049804688, 0.01939392, -0.0011167526, -0.0011510849, -0.04763794, -0.002374649, 0.040252686, -0.013572693, -0.011398315, -0.012527466, 0.01966858, -0.048614502, -0.029464722, -0.008468628, 0.028503418, -0.027023315, 0.020965576, 0.0002682209, -0.026641846, -0.053466797, 0.051513672, -0.06451416, 0.011566162, 0.0087890625, -0.043701172, -0.016693115, -0.0340271, 0.006290436, -0.036743164, -0.051574707, 0.0061798096, 0.0115737915, -0.015731812, 0.034332275, -0.010025024, -0.016616821, 0.018096924, -0.047210693, -0.0178833, -0.07092285, 0.073913574, -0.0836792, -0.062561035, -0.001288414, -0.036834717, -0.024520874, -0.026397705, 0.016799927, -0.034362793, 0.016906738, -0.00078201294, -0.0024967194, 0.021194458, 0.015960693, 0.002029419, 0.015335083, -0.013183594, 0.02406311, -0.0013532639, -0.011459351 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1810.04118v1
Semi-supervised Deep Reinforcement Learning in Support of IoT and Smart City Services
Mehdi Mohammadi, Ala Al-Fuqaha, Mohsen Guizani, Jun-Seok Oh
cs.NI, cs.AI, cs.LG
Smart services are an important element of the smart cities and the Internet of Things (IoT) ecosystems where the intelligence behind the services is obtained and improved through the sensory data. Providing a large amount of training data is not always feasible; therefore, we need to consider alternative ways that incorporate unlabeled data as well. In recent years, Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) has gained great success in several application domains. It is an applicable method for IoT and smart city scenarios where auto-generated data can be partially labeled by users' feedback for training purposes. In this paper, we propose a semi-supervised deep reinforcement learning model that fits smart city applications as it consumes both labeled and unlabeled data to improve the performance and accuracy of the learning agent. The model utilizes Variational Autoencoders (VAE) as the inference engine for generalizing optimal policies. To the best of our knowledge, the proposed model is the first investigation that extends deep reinforcement learning to the semi-supervised paradigm. As a case study of smart city applications, we focus on smart buildings and apply the proposed model to the problem of indoor localization based on BLE signal strength. Indoor localization is the main component of smart city services since people spend significant time in indoor environments. Our model learns the best action policies that lead to a close estimation of the target locations with an improvement of 23% in terms of distance to the target and at least 67% more received rewards compared to the supervised DRL model.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.04118v1
2018-10-09T16:47:25
2018-10-09T16:47:25
{ "title": [ 0.0060768127, 0.016616821, -0.040618896, -0.05050659, 0.03656006, -0.036376953, -0.00066518784, -0.007293701, -0.031219482, 0.018936157, -0.039978027, 0.009925842, -0.0101623535, -0.021392822, -0.017333984, -0.026443481, 0.0024852753, -0.017745972, -0.043060303, -0.036712646, 0.008399963, -0.03274536, 0.021255493, 0.06842041, 0.023788452, -0.007904053, -0.09906006, 0.018234253, -0.04333496, -0.032684326, -0.00831604, 0.023071289, 0.052459717, 0.016296387, -0.030212402, 0.0056266785, -0.052246094, 0.024932861, -0.014030457, 0.014221191, 0.026275635, -0.012329102, -0.018249512, -0.025985718, -0.021377563, 0.031402588, -0.052520752, -0.022003174, -0.025024414, 0.041168213, 0.029037476, 0.04473877, -0.0077171326, 0.02142334, 0.027755737, -0.019851685, -0.0129470825, -0.045196533, 0.04333496, 0.058288574, 0.021011353, -0.058807373, 0.018722534, -0.021774292, -0.027954102, -0.031433105, 0.017120361, 0.02041626, 0.0625, -0.007045746, -0.0007095337, 0.038513184, 0.0030841827, 0.032562256, -0.054901123, -0.035064697, 0.08062744, 0.030471802, 0.0076675415, -0.01322937, 0.008796692, -0.017669678, 0.017593384, -0.0051116943, 0.017791748, -0.013893127, -0.005744934, -0.030563354, -0.03189087, -0.041046143, -0.0025920868, -0.022888184, -0.0345459, 0.030822754, 0.006515503, -0.033111572, -0.03640747, 0.009140015, 0.008934021, -0.0014781952, -0.023208618, 0.017715454, -0.03540039, -0.01612854, 0.0040893555, 0.008453369, -0.008514404, -0.039001465, 0.0035762787, 0.022415161, -0.03729248, 0.020401001, 0.027389526, 0.023391724, -0.018829346, -0.02708435, -0.010551453, 0.0009737015, 0.015731812, 0.003660202, -0.009521484, -0.01777649, 0.0074882507, 0.026611328, 0.045684814, 0.029678345, -0.018249512, -0.002735138, 0.0018930435, 0.018615723, 0.010612488, 0.04751587, -0.117248535, -0.1003418, -0.07720947, 0.042175293, -0.028549194, 0.013397217, 0.018341064, 0.003643036, 0.031204224, -0.045074463, -0.029800415, 0.070007324, 0.027648926, 0.0046195984, 0.04711914, -0.002040863, -0.032470703, -0.012786865, -0.015777588, 0.0065307617, 0.015045166, 0.0048294067, -0.0055274963, 0.013076782, -0.086242676, -0.011726379, 0.012191772, 0.012359619, 0.01386261, 0.0064315796, 0.007762909, 0.061309814, 0.08654785, -0.008041382, -0.01210022, 0.03036499, 0.0013380051, 0.06903076, -0.02986145, -0.019348145, -0.029434204, -0.02482605, -0.024002075, 0.004043579, 0.043060303, 0.040771484, 0.013153076, -0.038909912, -0.0074691772, -0.03414917, 0.041625977, 0.011734009, -0.04058838, -0.016571045, 0.010391235, 0.016189575, 0.042297363, 0.020065308, -0.06506348, 0.017303467, -0.056884766, -0.032348633, -0.03704834, 0.0012779236, 0.034484863, 0.03665161, 0.0010881424, 0.01574707, -0.020446777, -0.010116577, -0.037231445, 0.010971069, -0.031982422, -0.04788208, -0.009376526, 0.012580872, -0.050231934, 0.056030273, 0.049682617, 0.0011386871, -0.03414917, 0.002506256, 0.028945923, -0.02935791, 0.029205322, -0.007911682, -0.019012451, -0.017318726, -0.03475952, -0.013656616, -0.017730713, 0.055999756, 0.019821167, 0.012641907, -0.0054779053, -0.009811401, 0.042541504, 0.021362305, 0.058563232, -0.0317688, 0.014953613, 0.009384155, -0.010169983, -0.024765015, -0.022460938, -0.017166138, 0.020187378, 0.026916504, -0.011230469, -0.020980835, 0.0041656494, 0.062469482, 0.0055274963, -0.008453369, 0.0059890747, 0.028198242, 0.017044067, 0.036499023, 0.05130005, 0.017715454, 0.054016113, 0.0042762756, -0.0041007996, 0.048919678, -0.012557983, 0.013343811, -0.008049011, -0.012031555, 0.016326904, 0.0036067963, 0.015579224, -0.0010023117, -0.074401855, 0.011413574, -0.02130127, 0.009056091, 0.016296387, 0.010246277, 0.029388428, -0.005138397, 0.0015382767, 0.0025234222, 0.013595581, -0.021392822, -0.015342712, 0.009895325, 0.0069732666, -0.05126953, 0.0021419525, -0.0017471313, 0.044525146, 0.0020771027, 0.028915405, -0.017700195, 0.022155762, 0.000004053116, 0.0013036728, -0.028671265, 0.03656006, 0.0042304993, -0.014503479, -0.008895874, 0.014816284, -0.033416748, 0.061584473, 0.13354492, -0.051940918, 0.05456543, -0.07849121, -0.0028457642, 0.012641907, -0.027999878, 0.005760193, 0.042053223, 0.02658081, 0.023376465, -0.0047683716, 0.029449463, -0.054656982, 0.01663208, 0.012878418, -0.038208008, -0.02784729, -0.041625977, -0.017364502, -0.03265381, -0.05130005, 0.0024604797, 0.075805664, 0.017288208, -0.023498535, -0.0045928955, 0.0084991455, -0.025222778, -0.025665283, -0.028259277, -0.032989502, 0.03265381, 0.021194458, 0.02911377, -0.026489258, 0.034698486, -0.016021729, 0.026519775, -0.0031929016, 0.0006246567, -0.01586914, -0.007133484, 0.018096924, -0.028869629, 0.0104522705, -0.013877869, -0.011245728, -0.048553467, -0.012245178, 0.01348114, -0.0035095215, -0.0014648438, 0.026657104, -0.011360168, -0.03540039, 0.014228821, 0.054779053, -0.003025055, -0.007080078, 0.033813477, 0.04348755, -0.008049011, 0.0038776398, 0.022247314, -0.010223389, -0.05834961, -0.0050964355, -0.03604126, 0.0042419434, -0.021820068, -0.044525146, 0.013893127, -0.056762695, -0.030014038, -0.019744873, -0.025543213, -0.012382507, 0.05130005, 0.004901886, -0.01322937, -0.03161621, -0.014564514, 0.005016327, 0.016403198, -0.0236969, -0.0032920837, 0.07775879, 0.01158905, -0.025497437, -0.011131287, 0.028717041, 0.010444641, -0.014663696, -0.026763916, -0.044006348, 0.029953003, 0.042816162, 0.008308411, 0.009048462, -0.009689331, -0.14038086, -0.029754639, 0.022277832, 0.023284912, -0.029876709, 0.023773193, -0.05432129, 0.015014648, -0.01171875, -0.026794434, 0.019699097, 0.034851074, 0.024642944, -0.016860962, 0.035003662, -0.04321289, 0.033325195, -0.05206299, -0.05706787, 0.035705566, -0.027557373, -0.05706787, -0.002122879, -0.020690918, -0.030426025, -0.030395508, 0.0047340393, 0.028717041, 0.049346924, 0.002313614, 0.030471802, 0.022521973, 0.012710571, -0.022537231, 0.009552002, -0.0015048981, -0.041992188, 0.0048980713, 0.0048599243, 0.047576904, 0.04058838, -0.021469116, -0.049346924, -0.012397766, 0.018936157, 0.034576416, 0.022583008, -0.044158936, -0.0069503784, -0.03829956, -0.005962372, -0.005130768, 0.001996994, -0.002161026, -0.038024902, 0.0009646416, -0.018081665, 0.048583984, -0.011016846, 0.004512787, -0.015914917, -0.026016235, 0.028305054, -0.013458252, -0.07714844, 0.0132369995, 0.053527832, -0.014518738, 0.012634277, -0.014183044, -0.034851074, 0.039245605, -0.005142212, -0.025314331, -0.017181396, -0.024505615, -0.007896423, -0.01852417, 0.015266418, -0.0014858246, 0.019454956, -0.01739502, 0.03338623, -0.009780884, -0.015716553, -0.026000977, 0.010597229, 0.005340576, -0.11138916, -0.026855469, 0.024963379, -0.013633728, -0.0023765564, -0.050872803, 0.04348755, -0.0317688, -0.026184082, 0.005630493, -0.012168884, -0.015655518, 0.010353088, -0.039886475, -0.05441284, 0.07281494, 0.0051651, 0.0046195984, 0.03878784, 0.014343262, -0.0035305023, -0.016464233, 0.0013885498, 0.009849548, 0.042175293, -0.0055236816, -0.017593384, 0.048828125, -0.03225708, 0.015960693, 0.0043754578, 0.06011963, -0.051605225, -0.015213013, 0.0073242188, 0.0073394775, -0.037231445, 0.04623413, 0.027389526, -0.010322571, -0.06744385, 0.016159058, 0.005844116, -0.01474762, 0.004047394, -0.02999878, 0.03375244, 0.043182373, 0.005115509, 0.07055664, -0.009147644, 0.010314941, 0.028198242, -0.026626587, -0.006111145, 0.010971069, 0.021530151, -0.009635925, -0.010253906, 0.019363403, -0.015449524, 0.0552063, -0.06304932, 0.014785767, 0.012176514, 0.0093307495, -0.028793335, -0.026321411, -0.071899414, -0.011207581, -0.011039734, 0.020233154, -0.008361816, -0.005821228, 0.027496338, -0.02760315, -0.027328491, 0.036071777, 0.06781006, 0.0069274902, -0.03161621, -0.08917236, -0.0063934326, -0.004085541, -0.061706543, -0.027709961, -0.0071983337, 0.006843567, 0.018447876, -0.012649536, -0.0043678284, 0.041381836, 0.03060913, 0.060821533, 0.045776367, -0.013671875, -0.050689697, 0.06036377, -0.014480591, -0.010688782, 0.01914978, 0.02923584, 0.0026378632, -0.0317688, 0.008598328, -0.023864746, -0.008979797, -0.035064697, 0.0008459091, -0.013900757, 0.022415161, 0.036132812, 0.07519531, 0.012062073, 0.03765869, 0.031158447, 0.0093307495, -0.027359009, -0.039733887, 0.008087158, 0.072143555, -0.0068359375, 0.019561768, 0.013000488, 0.021713257, -0.002506256, 0.0002644062, 0.029144287, 0.01398468, -0.028625488, -0.01360321, 0.025604248, 0.0037956238, -0.03479004, 0.008224487, 0.019699097, 0.019363403, -0.015716553, 0.08068848, -0.049346924, -0.024093628, 0.018081665, 0.0041122437, 0.007003784, -0.006778717, 0.022323608, -0.077819824, -0.04119873, -0.020858765, 0.036346436, -0.035339355, -0.010864258, 0.010292053, -0.010658264, 0.044647217, 0.03845215, 0.03869629, -0.038879395, -0.031982422, -0.015457153, -0.013938904, -0.01512146, -0.046051025, 0.0041770935, -0.030197144, 0.02130127, -0.050445557, 0.038757324, -0.030334473, -0.0023498535, 0.033935547, 0.0074539185, -0.017105103, -0.05999756, 0.024749756, 0.03201294, -0.0059509277, -0.010375977, 0.0037498474, -0.011070251, 0.028121948, 0.04336548, 0.0021896362, 0.030197144, 0.031677246, -0.029846191, 0.019851685, 0.0025901794, 0.029067993, -0.0063438416, -0.0053482056, 0.0039100647, -0.0055236816, -0.042053223, 0.028335571, -0.011482239, -0.040405273, 0.014854431, -0.018798828, 0.0018377304, 0.015777588, 0.027633667, 0.004924774, 0.0072250366, -0.04925537, -0.017410278, -0.0055007935, -0.0069236755, -0.013397217, -0.004547119, -0.003238678, -0.059387207, 0.042541504, -0.06903076, -0.0149002075, 0.0030708313, -0.0005583763, -0.013809204, 0.012252808, 0.022338867, -0.046081543, -0.0059776306, 0.020843506, 0.035308838, 0.04196167, -0.009918213, -0.055358887, 0.00013053417, -0.008331299, -0.04434204, -0.06958008, -0.019882202, -0.011039734, 0.012077332, 0.004047394, -0.0051651, 0.029006958, -0.006679535, 0.023162842, 0.03390503, -0.03074646, 0.03604126, 0.0076141357, 0.009841919, -0.011367798, 0.020706177, 0.013671875, -0.01902771, -0.0051727295, 0.0002411604, 0.032287598, 0.0004117489, 0.01209259, 0.019927979, -0.06506348, 0.021026611, 0.016464233, 0.016601562, -0.016494751, -0.008850098, 0.03378296, -0.021728516, -0.01512146, -0.0028038025, 0.06732178, -0.05819702, 0.0090789795, -0.02104187, 0.0042762756, -0.042907715, 0.06878662, -0.033966064, -0.012550354, -0.06365967, -0.058624268, -0.028213501, 0.015167236, 0.045135498, 0.021881104, 0.052215576, -0.057525635, 0.01876831, -0.030136108, -0.002840042, -0.009033203, 0.01725769, 0.0076675415, 0.0022659302, -0.030715942, 0.0020637512, -0.0006942749, 0.002281189, 0.033416748, 0.002281189, -0.029800415, 0.01878357, -0.034606934, 0.0061531067, 0.0020999908, -0.02835083, 0.041168213, -0.03289795, 0.022491455, 0.044158936, -0.04336548, 0.030288696, 0.0079956055, 0.03717041, 0.041534424, 0.034729004, 0.037353516, 0.001367569, 0.012367249, -0.017684937, 0.005882263, -0.061279297, -0.06604004, -0.07171631, -0.038970947, -0.060821533, -0.037109375, -0.0011310577, 0.019363403, 0.048187256, 0.00089788437, 0.039642334, 0.0010299683, 0.0033416748, -0.02458191, 0.031951904, 0.0236969, 0.01727295, -0.0026226044, -0.0010080338, 0.0209198, 0.0236969, -0.003042221, 0.03466797, -0.007949829, -0.003578186, 0.009544373, 0.0029945374, 0.015266418, -0.03451538, -0.017501831, -0.029922485, 0.071777344, 0.0014877319, 0.028244019, 0.070495605, 0.061553955, -0.031433105, -0.028259277, 0.029815674, -0.024353027, -0.033935547, 0.02003479, 0.018066406, -0.06323242, 0.04260254, -0.0018577576, -0.011497498, -0.01512146, 0.045928955, 0.015487671, -0.0473938, -0.018005371, 0.028213501, 0.024642944, -0.009399414, 0.017333984, -0.050811768, -0.040924072, -0.0076408386, 0.037719727, -0.034576416, 0.0073661804, 0.017440796, 0.03173828, -0.024261475, 0.011405945, -0.014663696, 0.04815674, -0.041229248, 0.018692017, -0.042236328, 0.014373779, 0.03302002, -0.020736694, 0.010665894, 0.0124053955, -0.02659607, 0.019317627, 0.02394104, 0.029373169, 0.018081665, 0.027801514, -0.020339966, -0.03942871, 0.009536743, -0.048309326, 0.037628174, 0.04248047, -0.0335083, 0.0045394897, -0.028656006, -0.03314209, 0.029769897, -0.024093628, 0.05340576, -0.033813477, 0.0048217773, -0.014289856, 0.0055618286, 0.038116455, -0.061279297, -0.022201538, -0.022323608, -0.009887695, -0.0016202927, 0.031799316, 0.00831604, -0.021911621, 0.027450562, 0.03704834, 0.03302002, -0.0007081032, -0.015510559, -0.020141602, -0.04660034, 0.010986328, -0.04083252, 0.049591064, 0.0041999817, -0.011528015, -0.009132385, 0.0012483597, -0.011383057, -0.041412354, -0.013389587, -0.033233643, -0.002040863, -0.01386261, 0.009239197, 0.023330688, 0.0038318634, 0.015403748, 0.015823364, 0.0070762634, -0.006996155, 0.0096588135, 0.0234375, -0.050720215, -0.041931152, -0.001578331, -0.035369873, 0.042022705, 0.023620605, 0.0076065063, 0.0035953522, 0.0340271, -0.011039734, -0.020477295, 0.010795593, 0.029266357, 0.01675415, -0.04196167, -0.006038666, 0.028656006, 0.032440186, -0.05029297, -0.04458618, 0.012306213, 0.050689697, -0.0075149536, 0.05126953, -0.020141602, -0.0073623657, 0.057800293, 0.060394287, 0.023529053, -0.04498291, -0.047576904, -0.008285522, 0.061828613, 0.04623413, -0.016082764, -0.010322571, 0.030838013, -0.0064468384, 0.02368164, -0.004207611, -0.022125244, 0.017654419, -0.018005371, 0.022750854, 0.0064430237, 0.003917694, -0.0056114197, 0.01940918, -0.0131073, 0.027435303, -0.012008667, 0.004306793, 0.002904892, 0.04510498, -0.0385437, -0.051513672, 0.06750488, 0.027435303, 0.019958496, 0.014526367, -0.00080537796, -0.006175995, -0.017654419, -0.0043678284, -0.00021958351, 0.010299683, 0.031082153, -0.037353516, 0.017059326, -0.04724121, -0.04220581, -0.013961792, -0.048461914, 0.04260254, -0.048980713, 0.008270264, -0.009590149, -0.024429321, -0.012062073, 0.0063819885, -0.0004940033, -0.03137207, -0.046417236, -0.043395996, 0.040649414, -0.016036987 ], "summary": [ 0.04751587, 0.027572632, 0.010032654, -0.006412506, 0.012001038, -0.02545166, -0.0026168823, -0.06072998, -0.020736694, 0.012237549, -0.024291992, -0.0044822693, -0.005302429, -0.046905518, 0.028152466, -0.035858154, 0.011421204, -0.008735657, -0.015113831, -0.04510498, 0.015106201, -0.044067383, -0.0002808571, 0.05886841, 0.016571045, 0.000790596, -0.05014038, 0.016326904, -0.010314941, 0.0259552, 0.012435913, -0.019958496, 0.019592285, 0.0012454987, -0.0032577515, -0.037475586, -0.039611816, 0.00970459, -0.007221222, 0.0047721863, 0.03527832, -0.007881165, 0.05706787, -0.024856567, 0.0026416779, 0.026107788, 0.006729126, -0.026779175, -0.0026054382, 0.012504578, 0.02746582, 0.033447266, -0.0029296875, 0.0048179626, 0.012565613, 0.01826477, 0.008346558, -0.03842163, 0.026397705, 0.04107666, 0.00983429, -0.027008057, 0.0124435425, -0.022369385, -0.019515991, -0.017440796, 0.023498535, 0.014968872, 0.021606445, -0.027786255, 0.0107421875, 0.01802063, -0.0020694733, 0.02067566, -0.038269043, -0.018692017, 0.058410645, 0.025054932, -0.016738892, -0.0038776398, 0.015640259, 0.025222778, 0.031585693, -0.011146545, -0.013290405, -0.0124053955, -0.004169464, -0.03677368, -0.044067383, -0.0013494492, -0.025009155, -0.019226074, -0.10412598, 0.05734253, 0.057037354, -0.02180481, -0.034179688, -0.018112183, -0.009849548, 0.030029297, -0.046325684, 0.008895874, 0.006088257, -0.021560669, -0.015075684, 0.024551392, -0.00090026855, -0.05343628, -0.0052452087, 0.013626099, -0.039794922, -0.011413574, 0.01525116, -0.008049011, -0.04360962, -0.01512146, -0.0034637451, 0.0051193237, 0.012481689, -0.010437012, -0.03074646, -0.011192322, 0.009239197, 0.04953003, 0.013290405, 0.014671326, 0.013381958, 0.005302429, 0.024612427, -0.009819031, -0.020401001, 0.041870117, -0.055725098, -0.047790527, -0.051940918, 0.005710602, -0.032348633, -0.01209259, 0.024841309, -0.029388428, 0.08355713, -0.03451538, -0.04083252, 0.10601807, 0.025604248, 0.028152466, 0.0038776398, 0.008361816, 0.020477295, -0.022369385, 0.026794434, -0.025131226, 0.033691406, 0.0028572083, 0.016418457, -0.041107178, 0.0020008087, -0.03970337, 0.015449524, -0.034454346, 0.01260376, 0.015205383, 0.040283203, 0.10095215, 0.0713501, -0.015792847, -0.0063209534, 0.0064430237, 0.0073394775, 0.043914795, -0.0069351196, -0.026290894, -0.032348633, -0.024230957, -0.01876831, -0.006816864, -0.013214111, 0.0569458, 0.028015137, -0.053253174, -0.018981934, -0.042663574, 0.08929443, -0.019515991, 0.0047950745, 0.0059432983, 0.010871887, 0.05053711, 0.013023376, 0.029403687, -0.050720215, -0.009796143, -0.0236969, 0.001121521, -0.036590576, 0.006603241, 0.0013570786, 0.035949707, -0.020446777, -0.0044937134, 0.022277832, -0.015045166, 0.02809143, -0.024536133, -0.032440186, -0.008857727, -0.007675171, 0.016967773, -0.07867432, 0.015182495, 0.042816162, -0.020401001, -0.019927979, -0.030136108, 0.04534912, 0.004722595, 0.0042800903, -0.044158936, -0.016708374, -0.02293396, -0.018478394, -0.0012359619, -0.04244995, 0.050354004, 0.016403198, 0.012390137, -0.018920898, 0.010032654, 0.042755127, 0.010681152, 0.04550171, -0.0057373047, -0.018249512, 0.0042152405, -0.012718201, -0.017990112, -0.021392822, -0.054016113, 0.033233643, 0.048217773, 0.0070495605, 0.009712219, 0.0063056946, 0.067993164, -0.010848999, -0.019805908, 0.019592285, 0.019744873, -0.0135269165, 0.034729004, -0.023162842, 0.023483276, 0.026672363, -0.01701355, -0.011192322, 0.047180176, -0.02456665, -0.0056152344, 0.011924744, -0.019866943, 0.03262329, -0.015716553, -0.0002696514, -0.004135132, -0.06518555, -0.006095886, -0.006336212, 0.003288269, 0.027496338, -0.027999878, 0.0027942657, -0.0032844543, -0.006603241, -0.043823242, -0.02508545, -0.020690918, -0.030303955, 0.036010742, 0.0010385513, -0.048339844, 0.0011577606, -0.0020046234, -0.022537231, -0.010826111, 0.035858154, 0.006881714, 0.008094788, 0.014373779, 0.0071029663, 0.0211792, 0.05343628, -0.025527954, -0.033721924, -0.008834839, 0.013008118, -0.039764404, 0.011314392, 0.10333252, -0.044647217, 0.019851685, -0.036621094, -0.000497818, -0.021697998, -0.017105103, 0.00447464, 0.0115356445, 0.017501831, 0.011894226, 0.02319336, -0.003118515, -0.009254456, 0.039154053, 0.03744507, 0.019927979, -0.00058841705, -0.027297974, -0.02772522, 0.0309906, -0.033111572, 0.00308609, 0.11834717, 0.038116455, 0.011962891, 0.027008057, 0.0058784485, -0.072631836, 0.03640747, -0.026977539, 0.01776123, 0.011077881, -0.012840271, 0.026290894, 0.0051231384, 0.034088135, -0.011306763, -0.018493652, 0.005844116, -0.03579712, -0.0073776245, 0.019866943, 0.045135498, -0.022903442, 0.012916565, 0.01171875, -0.06317139, 0.003227234, -0.0076408386, -0.002855301, 0.0040016174, -0.00497818, 0.024032593, -0.00699234, -0.015777588, 0.029220581, 0.009056091, 0.014953613, 0.02609253, 0.030929565, 0.019180298, -0.01676941, 0.009109497, 0.027877808, -0.012817383, -0.07336426, -0.0033836365, -0.023208618, -0.00068855286, -0.030334473, -0.015335083, -0.011108398, 0.004776001, 0.0018377304, -0.019165039, -0.024261475, -0.02532959, 0.033447266, 0.09790039, 0.004047394, -0.021392822, 0.041992188, 0.014923096, 0.039855957, -0.048675537, -0.0039711, 0.035736084, 0.012016296, -0.03152466, -0.01979065, 0.030853271, 0.010864258, 0.0023517609, -0.013496399, -0.032592773, -0.0044898987, 0.035491943, 0.009391785, 0.006942749, 0.0184021, -0.08660889, -0.03555298, -0.0060272217, 0.036621094, -0.0069389343, 0.007583618, -0.010108948, 0.02330017, 0.013679504, -0.026245117, 0.0021686554, 0.006587982, 0.07147217, -0.05819702, 0.0635376, -0.05545044, 0.040222168, -0.056152344, 0.04107666, 0.006702423, 0.010948181, -0.053375244, -0.0021095276, 0.030090332, 0.0030288696, -0.022842407, 0.008598328, 0.008857727, 0.025939941, -0.00066900253, 0.011253357, 0.02381897, 0.0076446533, -0.027816772, 0.003768921, 0.011154175, -0.07299805, 0.015563965, 0.027908325, 0.012123108, 0.08746338, -0.06744385, -0.061279297, -0.010025024, 0.045196533, 0.013954163, 0.03479004, -0.029693604, -0.0069732666, -0.038146973, -0.0053100586, -0.0054779053, -0.007423401, 0.0025978088, 0.0013828278, 0.027786255, -0.01725769, 0.043823242, -0.015426636, 0.03213501, 0.062561035, -0.033447266, 0.03527832, -0.0036754608, -0.050079346, 0.044952393, 0.045715332, -0.004737854, 0.0072898865, -0.011650085, -0.028366089, 0.034698486, 0.011367798, -0.068237305, -0.028518677, -0.040374756, -0.005088806, -0.055389404, 0.022567749, -0.015777588, 0.07110596, -0.01689148, 0.011932373, 0.0014820099, 0.00869751, -0.03390503, -0.008758545, 0.015083313, -0.08190918, -0.03805542, 0.013259888, 0.05078125, 0.048217773, -0.014228821, 0.06726074, -0.012268066, -0.014083862, -0.002313614, -0.027297974, 0.043182373, 0.015106201, -0.050750732, 0.001709938, -0.009361267, 0.042297363, 0.007873535, 0.00274086, 0.017608643, 0.033111572, 0.019744873, 0.016326904, -0.010284424, 0.05770874, -0.016082764, 0.01537323, 0.021881104, -0.012054443, 0.015945435, 0.020324707, 0.06768799, -0.026779175, -0.030776978, 0.037200928, 0.01902771, -0.022903442, 0.01612854, 0.029769897, -0.0013237, -0.040100098, 0.01727295, 0.0118637085, 0.017913818, -0.008323669, 0.006072998, 0.022262573, 0.025238037, 0.022827148, -0.023651123, -0.00054979324, 0.01158905, -0.02986145, -0.045288086, -0.0076942444, 0.004890442, 0.008758545, -0.0418396, -0.026275635, 0.019226074, -0.036956787, 0.035095215, -0.060455322, 0.012557983, 0.0070381165, 0.006401062, -0.054901123, -0.054901123, -0.027267456, 0.02029419, -0.0002808571, 0.027862549, -0.020065308, -0.04763794, -0.020019531, -0.028289795, 0.022232056, 0.00843811, 0.05392456, 0.04296875, -0.05441284, -0.0748291, -0.031402588, -0.0022850037, -0.03555298, 0.000065505505, -0.036895752, -0.06982422, 0.003206253, -0.011001587, -0.015556335, 0.032409668, 0.03591919, 0.058013916, 0.013977051, -0.0025520325, -0.0519104, 0.021057129, -0.024887085, 0.032287598, -0.0036144257, 0.03086853, -0.016143799, -0.013549805, -0.00074338913, -0.00013923645, 0.0014448166, -0.023529053, -0.052520752, -0.024169922, 0.008735657, 0.06695557, 0.09197998, -0.020904541, 0.04837036, 0.02758789, 0.014213562, 0.0011758804, -0.06921387, 0.0060157776, 0.048065186, 0.023239136, 0.012954712, -0.0049324036, -0.001493454, -0.028305054, 0.003982544, 0.035003662, 0.010307312, -0.028457642, 0.018966675, -0.024307251, 0.031066895, -0.00970459, 0.04272461, 0.016952515, 0.015617371, 0.06542969, 0.023422241, -0.026275635, -0.0011606216, 0.031341553, -0.0010080338, -0.0040397644, 0.016799927, 0.008544922, -0.06616211, -0.05303955, -0.030288696, 0.056732178, -0.01537323, -0.02609253, -0.0004439354, -0.033691406, 0.032562256, -0.012924194, -0.022949219, -0.055908203, -0.049346924, -0.023406982, -0.035736084, -0.012870789, -0.017227173, -0.0029315948, 0.013763428, 0.015670776, -0.0152282715, 0.0059394836, 0.018798828, 0.015472412, 0.0022144318, 0.02331543, -0.038879395, -0.04425049, -0.06100464, -0.046844482, 0.00881958, -0.052215576, 0.027542114, -0.045776367, -0.020187378, 0.005683899, -0.02142334, 0.0032081604, -0.006412506, -0.05041504, 0.050048828, -0.021591187, 0.028533936, 0.0031909943, -0.030593872, 0.003824234, 0.010169983, -0.027877808, -0.009086609, -0.06463623, 0.002456665, -0.023880005, 0.018875122, -0.009338379, 0.0317688, 0.037261963, 0.016586304, 0.031555176, -0.04928589, -0.018478394, 0.027130127, 0.00066661835, -0.028442383, 0.0036830902, 0.024002075, -0.05987549, 0.024673462, -0.09088135, -0.021026611, 0.017074585, 0.03378296, 0.024810791, -0.036834717, 0.010101318, 0.002702713, 0.0107040405, 0.059661865, 0.043182373, 0.018096924, -0.05407715, -0.039276123, 0.0104522705, 0.0064888, -0.032043457, -0.08532715, -0.037353516, -0.052520752, 0.044128418, 0.016967773, 0.054534912, 0.074157715, -0.037384033, 0.022781372, 0.03375244, -0.0028209686, 0.032470703, -0.0028896332, -0.022903442, -0.015808105, 0.010734558, -0.0345459, -0.0132751465, 0.018371582, 0.012626648, 0.023635864, 0.031280518, 0.014213562, 0.05102539, -0.022064209, 0.014526367, 0.028396606, 0.011787415, -0.028411865, 0.0037078857, 0.004058838, -0.023483276, 0.017608643, -0.0052261353, 0.03527832, 0.010269165, 0.02734375, -0.000099658966, 0.029678345, -0.012199402, 0.029769897, -0.012397766, 0.010818481, -0.049102783, -0.026351929, 0.019439697, -0.0008869171, 0.009460449, -0.0090789795, 0.02407837, -0.04260254, -0.010848999, 0.0127334595, -0.01612854, -0.013160706, 0.0124053955, 0.0014305115, 0.028656006, -0.005493164, -0.012535095, -0.016296387, 0.011146545, 0.010551453, 0.013465881, -0.018356323, 0.041229248, 0.0044937134, -0.00038599968, 0.015113831, 0.012214661, 0.03970337, -0.038604736, 0.028900146, 0.022033691, -0.024795532, 0.015113831, -0.0121154785, 0.0023155212, -0.0031986237, 0.021652222, 0.038330078, -0.00712204, 0.006378174, -0.012184143, 0.024978638, -0.014907837, -0.0881958, -0.054870605, -0.05935669, -0.011268616, 0.020080566, -0.038360596, -0.024612427, 0.07745361, -0.0035877228, 0.06768799, -0.0044441223, -0.06085205, -0.05697632, -0.0073890686, 0.06768799, 0.012619019, 0.018569946, -0.023086548, -0.017669678, 0.03036499, 0.031982422, 0.0033779144, 0.010505676, -0.0043563843, 0.031555176, 0.0062675476, -0.02949524, -0.07598877, 0.024398804, -0.050964355, 0.08227539, 0.028747559, 0.04284668, 0.046447754, 0.029342651, -0.008903503, -0.040283203, 0.03390503, -0.021362305, -0.030212402, 0.01676941, -0.024856567, 0.0027942657, 0.03353882, -0.0016431808, -0.013771057, 0.033172607, 0.03262329, 0.029281616, -0.039276123, 0.00070238113, 0.015525818, 0.0023841858, -0.043914795, 0.032836914, -0.04321289, -0.05279541, -0.0385437, -0.00919342, -0.019378662, 0.0072021484, 0.019744873, 0.022201538, -0.030166626, 0.023406982, -0.01083374, 0.01361084, -0.029708862, 0.015411377, -0.05508423, -0.0008058548, 0.017089844, -0.01020813, 0.016921997, 0.029724121, -0.00566864, 0.031234741, 0.034057617, 0.048919678, 0.028152466, -0.004184723, -0.079956055, -0.012001038, 0.07318115, -0.013679504, 0.030517578, -0.014335632, -0.022018433, -0.061187744, -0.013252258, -0.0021400452, -0.01890564, -0.007167816, 0.040222168, -0.01914978, -0.01210022, -0.039093018, 0.0016727448, -0.020370483, -0.02015686, 0.014663696, -0.049957275, -0.03164673, 0.025344849, 0.03451538, 0.022079468, 0.029769897, 0.014198303, -0.005569458, 0.060943604, 0.0075645447, 0.015777588, 0.0028896332, -0.0079193115, -0.0132751465, -0.010803223, 0.049621582, 0.019989014, -0.032348633, 0.018325806, -0.0099105835, 0.019454956, -0.010559082, -0.0064468384, -0.02619934, 0.01210022, -0.011802673, 0.0067634583, 0.02130127, 0.004573822, 0.02607727, 0.041046143, 0.018844604, -0.014007568, 0.04852295, 0.0340271, -0.031951904, -0.067871094, -0.0037727356, -0.012069702, 0.051086426, -0.01612854, -0.0037403107, 0.04019165, -0.0057792664, -0.0005764961, -0.02154541, 0.017044067, 0.013214111, 0.0056381226, -0.010017395, -0.034454346, 0.02420044, 0.02166748, -0.052612305, -0.022125244, 0.013267517, 0.06359863, 0.00039744377, 0.0012264252, -0.058044434, -0.016540527, 0.07519531, 0.074157715, 0.024810791, -0.024658203, -0.017822266, 0.014015198, 0.10229492, 0.0013713837, -0.052246094, -0.0026798248, 0.006980896, -0.019638062, 0.0006098747, -0.03286743, -0.028305054, -0.0036678314, -0.029434204, -0.004184723, 0.016693115, 0.024749756, -0.0031375885, -0.0062446594, -0.0099105835, 0.0012149811, 0.011695862, -0.0065307617, -0.019683838, 0.035186768, -0.029449463, 0.02508545, 0.032470703, -0.011726379, 0.03717041, -0.028900146, 0.043182373, 0.028656006, 0.014541626, -0.0030670166, 0.007575989, 0.0059165955, 0.0032444, -0.03857422, -0.0121536255, -0.070495605, -0.003818512, -0.062683105, -0.036468506, 0.031677246, -0.020568848, -0.012390137, 0.047424316, -0.04837036, 0.007648468, 0.029525757, -0.0038013458, 0.000032901764, 0.008666992, -0.035461426, 0.001461029, 0.0020008087 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1810.11921v2
AutoInt: Automatic Feature Interaction Learning via Self-Attentive Neural Networks
Weiping Song, Chence Shi, Zhiping Xiao, Zhijian Duan, Yewen Xu, Ming Zhang, Jian Tang
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Click-through rate (CTR) prediction, which aims to predict the probability of a user clicking on an ad or an item, is critical to many online applications such as online advertising and recommender systems. The problem is very challenging since (1) the input features (e.g., the user id, user age, item id, item category) are usually sparse and high-dimensional, and (2) an effective prediction relies on high-order combinatorial features (\textit{a.k.a.} cross features), which are very time-consuming to hand-craft by domain experts and are impossible to be enumerated. Therefore, there have been efforts in finding low-dimensional representations of the sparse and high-dimensional raw features and their meaningful combinations. In this paper, we propose an effective and efficient method called the \emph{AutoInt} to automatically learn the high-order feature interactions of input features. Our proposed algorithm is very general, which can be applied to both numerical and categorical input features. Specifically, we map both the numerical and categorical features into the same low-dimensional space. Afterwards, a multi-head self-attentive neural network with residual connections is proposed to explicitly model the feature interactions in the low-dimensional space. With different layers of the multi-head self-attentive neural networks, different orders of feature combinations of input features can be modeled. The whole model can be efficiently fit on large-scale raw data in an end-to-end fashion. Experimental results on four real-world datasets show that our proposed approach not only outperforms existing state-of-the-art approaches for prediction but also offers good explainability. Code is available at: \url{https://github.com/DeepGraphLearning/RecommenderSystems}.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.11921v2
2019-08-23T19:51:41
2018-10-29T01:56:25
{ "title": [ 0.014144897, 0.0022716522, -0.011817932, -0.058685303, 0.022277832, 0.0018692017, -0.026672363, -0.024383545, -0.013633728, 0.025039673, -0.0155181885, 0.001832962, -0.029769897, -0.01826477, -0.036468506, -0.010772705, 0.0054893494, 0.0050315857, -0.021743774, -0.032348633, -0.016464233, -0.0362854, 0.037475586, 0.008682251, 0.037261963, -0.0390625, -0.091430664, 0.037963867, -0.029571533, -0.013198853, -0.0061187744, 0.004055023, 0.025527954, 0.053009033, -0.030685425, 0.018051147, -0.025924683, 0.03387451, 0.009635925, 0.02746582, 0.01927185, -0.011047363, -0.029037476, -0.035247803, -0.03378296, 0.0259552, -0.06500244, -0.03643799, -0.0010280609, -0.008636475, 0.009284973, 0.025024414, -0.0039749146, 0.012901306, 0.009880066, -0.019088745, -0.042114258, 0.020553589, 0.04473877, 0.07873535, 0.009712219, -0.064453125, 0.0184021, -0.058441162, -0.057250977, -0.028198242, -0.034362793, 0.026321411, 0.06085205, -0.0056495667, -0.012008667, 0.037017822, 0.0032901764, 0.017669678, -0.04776001, -0.011451721, 0.080444336, 0.028518677, 0.026382446, -0.018371582, 0.014945984, -0.0033836365, -0.031158447, -0.018569946, 0.021896362, -0.035949707, -0.0107421875, -0.011962891, -0.030838013, -0.06781006, -0.01399231, -0.020446777, -0.025985718, 0.014930725, -0.019927979, -0.037506104, -0.031951904, 0.011276245, 0.0077819824, 0.014770508, 0.0020618439, -0.004863739, -0.012321472, -0.024795532, 0.013008118, 0.018951416, -0.007408142, -0.012519836, 0.014480591, 0.028656006, -0.01675415, 0.0010328293, 0.01966858, 0.009933472, 0.012390137, 0.010345459, -0.0017061234, 0.03555298, 0.0023345947, 0.04168701, -0.016113281, -0.0129776, -0.0061416626, -0.001543045, 0.013717651, -0.01953125, -0.025787354, 0.01272583, -0.016693115, 0.011436462, -0.02003479, 0.04751587, -0.062561035, -0.06585693, -0.06323242, 0.033447266, 0.019454956, 0.010612488, -0.0020275116, -0.01675415, 0.015579224, -0.011421204, 0.00006198883, -0.013793945, 0.0049819946, 0.028686523, 0.052124023, -0.010116577, -0.046539307, -0.060546875, -0.0040359497, -0.0033626556, 0.024734497, 0.0058555603, -0.02243042, 0.0037555695, -0.09454346, -0.010101318, 0.025741577, 0.013961792, 0.009651184, -0.0053710938, -0.022338867, -0.0088272095, 0.027633667, 0.0010890961, -0.03137207, 0.025009155, 0.004360199, 0.041046143, -0.016082764, 0.025772095, -0.003929138, -0.002796173, -0.0051574707, 0.00035214424, 0.042266846, 0.041900635, 0.014678955, 0.0048599243, 0.03692627, -0.01890564, 0.044311523, 0.02708435, -0.047729492, -0.011657715, -0.014060974, -0.026535034, 0.0496521, 0.002231598, -0.037750244, 0.04019165, -0.058410645, -0.014602661, -0.051605225, -0.0118637085, 0.022918701, 0.036987305, -0.009094238, 0.020065308, -0.028259277, -0.010292053, -0.0317688, 0.00026130676, -0.04248047, -0.0435791, -0.020370483, 0.020462036, -0.011909485, 0.029220581, 0.047698975, -0.011581421, -0.015342712, 0.012512207, -0.013839722, -0.054901123, 0.043914795, -0.03427124, -0.0063934326, -0.012901306, -0.00907135, -0.011116028, -0.008224487, 0.058898926, -0.0017089844, 0.009857178, -0.021133423, -0.017486572, 0.00969696, 0.03074646, 0.052642822, -0.03744507, -0.004688263, 0.019424438, -0.0034332275, -0.02848816, -0.02658081, -0.025985718, 0.02116394, 0.022232056, -0.019500732, -0.0027389526, -0.022476196, 0.0289917, 0.051574707, 0.028900146, -0.0022010803, 0.019973755, 0.030517578, 0.033325195, 0.056854248, 0.03186035, 0.058288574, -0.01322937, 0.010765076, 0.0713501, -0.006713867, -0.0006699562, -0.02178955, 0.014282227, -0.009506226, -0.005558014, -0.003616333, -0.002735138, -0.022506714, 0.018295288, -0.002696991, 0.023727417, -0.017303467, 0.030578613, 0.033477783, 0.021820068, 0.006351471, -0.010513306, -0.010261536, -0.046020508, -0.006290436, 0.033111572, -0.013244629, -0.0869751, -0.028198242, -0.0028324127, 0.02709961, -0.001159668, 0.038635254, -0.001534462, 0.017196655, -0.040893555, -0.0016736984, 0.011558533, 0.05041504, 0.042144775, 0.007797241, 0.011779785, 0.007987976, 0.006198883, 0.064941406, 0.078186035, -0.042938232, 0.047973633, -0.01828003, 0.023132324, 0.0034694672, -0.016403198, 0.010391235, 0.023071289, 0.0046806335, 0.025802612, -0.017303467, 0.029541016, -0.07495117, 0.00013673306, 0.003955841, 0.016586304, -0.08758545, -0.0770874, -0.014915466, -0.030517578, -0.028457642, -0.0074768066, 0.103759766, -0.028274536, -0.035827637, -0.0088272095, -0.01713562, -0.031799316, -0.012901306, -0.034820557, -0.04321289, 0.03186035, 0.014183044, 0.01537323, -0.05984497, 0.0068206787, -0.019744873, 0.008056641, -0.0071983337, -0.008018494, -0.023727417, 0.0064926147, 0.028701782, -0.023071289, 0.042510986, -0.02166748, 0.009635925, -0.045166016, -0.003873825, 0.033203125, -0.026184082, 0.0008864403, 0.01007843, -0.040893555, -0.033935547, 0.028884888, 0.056793213, 0.005794525, -0.0073280334, 0.05731201, 0.05307007, -0.0016231537, 0.04925537, 0.037475586, 0.013870239, -0.08679199, -0.02420044, -0.062164307, -0.0006685257, -0.045013428, -0.02772522, 0.045837402, -0.043518066, -0.025115967, -0.025512695, -0.016326904, -0.005748749, 0.018554688, -0.0047340393, -0.020187378, -0.019226074, -0.0209198, 0.011886597, 0.021194458, -0.037475586, -0.012954712, 0.109802246, -0.0046424866, 0.023162842, 0.032562256, 0.045288086, -0.01285553, -0.026412964, -0.034210205, -0.03475952, 0.018463135, 0.044158936, 0.022735596, -0.013343811, 0.000008285046, -0.13781738, -0.025375366, 0.013076782, -0.00459671, -0.044067383, 0.026275635, -0.05630493, 0.015853882, -0.017868042, -0.03930664, 0.043884277, 0.04333496, 0.007232666, 0.026000977, 0.036224365, -0.017959595, -0.007537842, -0.021102905, -0.090148926, 0.028930664, -0.026550293, -0.033691406, -0.004749298, -0.020965576, -0.040771484, -0.0034217834, 0.000600338, 0.0013418198, 0.03353882, 0.014289856, -0.008598328, -0.0129470825, -0.012901306, -0.029403687, -0.026046753, -0.010116577, -0.02319336, 0.0075187683, 0.014877319, 0.031219482, 0.04119873, -0.011405945, -0.018737793, -0.011550903, -0.012138367, 0.029312134, 0.000047266483, -0.03286743, -0.011138916, -0.011749268, -0.022338867, -0.032318115, -0.0048179626, -0.0004887581, -0.0026855469, 0.007610321, -0.01687622, 0.06555176, -0.007843018, 0.009567261, 0.0158844, -0.03668213, 0.0077323914, -0.029388428, -0.05734253, 0.022659302, 0.056549072, -0.019973755, 0.022842407, -0.027908325, -0.0119018555, 0.02961731, -0.045684814, -0.007820129, -0.027709961, 0.010185242, -0.028015137, 0.021118164, -0.012245178, 0.0063095093, 0.033813477, 0.035308838, 0.037353516, -0.0022068024, -0.029800415, -0.070739746, 0.026824951, -0.0088272095, -0.11376953, -0.021530151, -0.00422287, 0.007461548, -0.029525757, -0.036712646, 0.0061912537, 0.01826477, -0.03277588, 0.0018472672, -0.015235901, -0.008728027, -0.033050537, -0.06365967, -0.017471313, 0.066833496, 0.0036144257, 0.048614502, 0.04824829, -0.013908386, -0.02128601, -0.013908386, 0.006465912, 0.010238647, 0.061676025, 0.0027999878, -0.033416748, 0.05819702, -0.04360962, 0.036468506, 0.015357971, 0.05706787, -0.010787964, -0.00856781, -0.01020813, 0.0024032593, -0.0022449493, 0.049835205, -0.00038456917, -0.0027160645, -0.054656982, 0.032318115, 0.008148193, -0.018203735, 0.027038574, 0.02104187, -0.0008945465, 0.031707764, -0.022460938, 0.015029907, -0.017593384, -0.0041236877, 0.045013428, -0.0015115738, -0.014404297, 0.028213501, 0.032104492, 0.02557373, 0.005962372, 0.015075684, 0.010009766, 0.024871826, -0.021362305, -0.037750244, -0.006500244, 0.024673462, -0.03213501, -0.007904053, -0.049102783, -0.060272217, -0.022399902, -0.0009908676, -0.01184845, 0.03717041, 0.028045654, -0.009407043, -0.02418518, 0.0029792786, 0.018051147, 0.003419876, -0.0017461777, -0.050689697, -0.025009155, -0.026229858, -0.049591064, -0.022018433, 0.0035095215, 0.004863739, 0.028015137, 0.00047039986, -0.028671265, 0.017837524, 0.021820068, 0.09509277, 0.06085205, -0.008811951, -0.09362793, 0.023666382, -0.014625549, -0.0284729, 0.041168213, -0.005077362, 0.017669678, -0.0033073425, 0.025680542, -0.031677246, -0.03967285, -0.04751587, 0.027236938, 0.024414062, 0.0345459, 0.019821167, 0.049957275, 0.032958984, 0.003282547, 0.010040283, 0.014694214, -0.03842163, -0.0039787292, 0.0015497208, 0.039916992, -0.012191772, 0.011100769, 0.03201294, 0.013504028, -0.03704834, 0.019119263, 0.026855469, 0.032470703, -0.0075683594, -0.025878906, 0.036010742, -0.037109375, -0.01612854, 0.02067566, 0.007926941, 0.057861328, -0.04473877, 0.07897949, -0.012145996, 0.004600525, 0.023468018, -0.011245728, -0.0010213852, -0.02217102, 0.009765625, -0.080078125, -0.059570312, -0.02154541, 0.060028076, -0.037475586, -0.0079422, 0.0032806396, -0.013412476, 0.0065994263, 0.048065186, 0.02658081, -0.0011720657, 0.0026931763, -0.024261475, -0.0049095154, -0.024169922, -0.058807373, 0.05090332, -0.008285522, 0.007926941, -0.0020885468, -0.033355713, -0.08276367, 0.0019330978, -0.006713867, -0.007457733, -0.00086402893, -0.07244873, -0.0021095276, 0.041503906, 0.00982666, 0.01600647, 0.027008057, 0.041168213, 0.010658264, 0.033355713, 0.010467529, 0.024673462, 0.013252258, -0.016098022, 0.053527832, -0.011772156, 0.0019989014, -0.0031585693, 0.03274536, 0.00048613548, 0.0395813, -0.055786133, 0.043548584, 0.022903442, -0.030258179, 0.016296387, -0.048309326, 0.02810669, 0.027420044, 0.010223389, 0.0047721863, -0.026275635, -0.032409668, -0.042907715, -0.017929077, -0.09729004, 0.032196045, -0.04083252, -0.029556274, -0.035827637, 0.019317627, -0.0135269165, 0.013938904, 0.0074043274, 0.0036334991, -0.03213501, 0.014709473, 0.03062439, -0.003900528, -0.0037174225, -0.017349243, -0.005695343, 0.017837524, 0.030471802, -0.024795532, -0.0012559891, -0.0023975372, -0.04977417, -0.04626465, -0.005176544, -0.006664276, -0.0017290115, -0.00020229816, -0.008766174, 0.016036987, -0.027832031, 0.023712158, -0.002029419, -0.018508911, 0.034301758, 0.011482239, -0.0060195923, -0.016235352, 0.049316406, -0.016036987, 0.003227234, 0.0107421875, 0.009902954, 0.010093689, -0.015205383, 0.00015294552, 0.02017212, -0.043060303, -0.00039887428, 0.0181427, 0.0016498566, -0.012329102, -0.004558563, 0.008224487, -0.030166626, 0.0015506744, -0.0015850067, 0.08050537, -0.048187256, -0.02961731, -0.022583008, 0.0027542114, -0.039916992, 0.055755615, -0.034179688, -0.031036377, -0.028717041, -0.07537842, -0.021957397, 0.0010490417, 0.029281616, 0.045196533, 0.0060043335, -0.07904053, -0.016860962, -0.01096344, -0.010231018, -0.00008267164, 0.006904602, 0.010124207, -0.012413025, 0.008224487, -0.007209778, 0.010856628, -0.012245178, 0.021484375, -0.021484375, -0.026657104, 0.020706177, -0.031158447, 0.026489258, -0.04953003, 0.0052871704, 0.029830933, 0.028244019, -0.00806427, 0.051696777, -0.055541992, 0.06555176, 0.01083374, 0.038513184, 0.040649414, -0.004096985, -0.024398804, -0.0029315948, 0.024734497, -0.05303955, 0.0289917, -0.061279297, 0.03591919, -0.05291748, 0.0011253357, -0.060424805, -0.00021469593, 0.034851074, 0.021942139, 0.038269043, 0.013626099, 0.018920898, 0.008865356, 0.0077934265, 0.015464783, 0.036254883, 0.000092089176, 0.020629883, -0.018203735, -0.009979248, 0.028182983, 0.03656006, 0.029159546, -0.015731812, -0.023712158, -0.00048041344, 0.015449524, 0.025299072, -0.00084352493, -0.0042152405, 0.0059051514, -0.022918701, 0.04348755, 0.003145218, 0.04901123, 0.038269043, 0.041015625, -0.027114868, -0.015106201, -0.010757446, -0.0103302, -0.018661499, -0.008735657, 0.045684814, -0.087524414, 0.0034008026, 0.0012683868, -0.005428314, -0.02104187, 0.024734497, 0.040252686, -0.04812622, -0.018371582, 0.031677246, 0.041412354, -0.021591187, -0.01184845, -0.04800415, -0.008224487, 0.006832123, 0.0058135986, 0.011329651, 0.0077209473, 0.0206604, 0.014839172, -0.01576233, -0.020095825, 0.000187397, 0.033233643, -0.009651184, 0.031219482, -0.03955078, 0.04269409, -0.01727295, -0.03967285, 0.014709473, 0.0107803345, -0.07495117, -0.015464783, 0.07043457, 0.059661865, 0.084106445, 0.093811035, -0.004928589, 0.017120361, 0.017852783, -0.0680542, 0.05319214, 0.024932861, -0.030838013, 0.0001052022, -0.0362854, -0.04083252, -0.0020198822, -0.02154541, 0.061706543, -0.022476196, -0.0012025833, -0.024291992, -0.014640808, 0.057495117, -0.046142578, -0.020126343, -0.038513184, -0.029129028, -0.012680054, 0.0059280396, -0.010475159, -0.01675415, 0.005859375, 0.017562866, 0.019973755, -0.0057678223, -0.0036811829, -0.021911621, -0.06500244, 0.0035266876, -0.011230469, 0.042541504, -0.022598267, -0.026443481, -0.022323608, 0.0021419525, 0.027618408, -0.03302002, -0.0446167, 0.0019760132, -0.011802673, -0.04156494, 0.008110046, 0.03149414, -0.016952515, -0.012992859, -0.035980225, 0.0104904175, -0.03414917, -0.036346436, 0.013496399, -0.03765869, -0.02104187, -0.014915466, -0.022399902, 0.023422241, 0.034179688, -0.007549286, 0.02229309, -0.0051574707, -0.0104904175, 0.0036773682, 0.014274597, 0.033172607, -0.028305054, -0.04071045, 0.018157959, 0.016296387, 0.040893555, -0.054870605, -0.042266846, -0.020462036, 0.012634277, 0.013832092, 0.059661865, 0.013946533, -0.014877319, 0.014457703, -0.004837036, 0.0046310425, -0.00730896, -0.027801514, -0.0013904572, 0.045074463, 0.045074463, -0.016647339, -0.012084961, 0.028335571, -0.023849487, -0.014350891, 0.007598877, 0.042816162, 0.0105896, 0.021697998, 0.037963867, -0.05911255, -0.01184082, -0.018035889, 0.0031909943, 0.00248909, 0.031951904, -0.014907837, 0.00091409683, -0.01638794, 0.0793457, -0.013206482, -0.012382507, 0.015396118, -0.006225586, 0.026275635, 0.042785645, 0.0054740906, -0.023910522, 0.0052719116, -0.0095825195, -0.0154418945, 0.002122879, 0.021942139, -0.050750732, -0.005176544, -0.047180176, -0.025039673, -0.03942871, -0.038208008, 0.045806885, -0.023147583, -0.005897522, -0.011329651, -0.049835205, -0.005176544, 0.006149292, 0.0029258728, -0.037902832, -0.02722168, 0.024734497, 0.03387451, -0.0041046143 ], "summary": [ 0.05041504, -0.001909256, 0.01209259, -0.008468628, -0.0070877075, -0.033935547, -0.018997192, -0.052490234, 0.04840088, 0.0002052784, -0.054901123, 0.005722046, 0.015449524, -0.02053833, -0.0044898987, -0.024307251, -0.0154418945, 0.039886475, 0.010940552, -0.030181885, -0.0011434555, -0.035461426, 0.01651001, -0.0038051605, 0.022949219, -0.024978638, -0.014945984, 0.036712646, 0.012451172, 0.023544312, 0.012527466, -0.026123047, -0.0035037994, 0.02861023, -0.0023422241, 0.046691895, 0.00006514788, 0.030776978, 0.04550171, -0.027282715, 0.014053345, -0.018218994, 0.038482666, -0.07611084, -0.014984131, 0.075927734, -0.029663086, -0.007785797, 0.02911377, -0.056732178, -0.004196167, 0.043121338, 0.0055885315, -0.018508911, -0.008415222, 0.0013237, -0.038848877, 0.003282547, 0.038909912, 0.06750488, 0.0062561035, -0.043121338, -0.0039749146, -0.08502197, -0.011360168, -0.017715454, 0.0154953, 0.022109985, 0.023361206, 0.00058460236, 0.0030460358, 0.028167725, -0.014579773, -0.0013151169, -0.036376953, 0.024932861, 0.030197144, 0.014472961, 0.0099487305, -0.00050497055, -0.035705566, 0.015960693, -0.041259766, -0.035369873, 0.0042152405, -0.012023926, -0.022598267, -0.005405426, -0.02609253, -0.017150879, -0.009300232, -0.021636963, -0.051971436, 0.05215454, 0.019805908, -0.012283325, 0.037231445, 0.032562256, 0.016494751, -0.0051612854, 0.015342712, -0.039886475, -0.014274597, -0.016143799, -0.00045967102, 0.04458618, 0.012084961, -0.0032196045, 0.0151901245, 0.015113831, -0.0030708313, -0.020050049, 0.017471313, 0.028778076, -0.001786232, -0.019348145, -0.032318115, 0.07733154, -0.01687622, 0.08258057, -0.000647068, 0.018096924, -0.04220581, 0.0059432983, 0.022857666, -0.014503479, -0.0005607605, 0.026626587, -0.027542114, 0.07104492, -0.020629883, 0.0050964355, -0.028182983, -0.0053253174, -0.052215576, -0.029190063, -0.0073432922, 0.011856079, -0.0036296844, -0.012496948, 0.019241333, -0.037109375, -0.013305664, 0.030288696, 0.018966675, 0.009971619, 0.018737793, 0.014709473, 0.006801605, -0.026916504, 0.0181427, -0.032226562, 0.06262207, -0.0178833, -0.04244995, -0.08135986, -0.004005432, -0.058532715, 0.02746582, -0.060791016, 0.027526855, -0.003545761, 0.0124435425, 0.026916504, -0.024108887, 0.017074585, -0.0129776, -0.0034103394, 0.021499634, 0.0096206665, 0.012084961, -0.017944336, 0.013175964, -0.015312195, -0.00084400177, 0.018554688, 0.040100098, 0.01838684, 0.006816864, 0.02784729, 0.0035858154, -0.028503418, 0.07104492, -0.027709961, -0.04159546, 0.07824707, -0.0011930466, 0.06768799, 0.020401001, 0.001209259, -0.01473999, 0.022964478, 0.00598526, -0.012489319, -0.008430481, -0.036499023, 0.01436615, -0.008132935, -0.000048160553, -0.00079250336, 0.01878357, 0.011207581, -0.0063171387, -0.027313232, -0.08868408, 0.0004746914, -0.020523071, 0.037750244, -0.008712769, 0.03378296, 0.016357422, -0.026565552, -0.021087646, 0.029037476, 0.017608643, -0.046142578, 0.026947021, -0.031341553, -0.028411865, -0.011314392, -0.059753418, 0.037475586, -0.04763794, 0.04776001, 0.0060157776, 0.016189575, -0.019363403, 0.015945435, 0.018493652, 0.040374756, 0.01247406, -0.031677246, 0.038330078, 0.028717041, -0.0050468445, -0.004261017, 0.023773193, -0.059814453, 0.016983032, 0.025894165, 0.000323534, -0.022216797, -0.041900635, 0.027389526, 0.008216858, 0.030395508, 0.023361206, 0.013061523, -0.010765076, 0.0059318542, 0.040222168, 0.02104187, 0.02268982, -0.027511597, 0.033294678, 0.039520264, 0.0002439022, -0.009391785, -0.032073975, 0.012542725, 0.0036010742, 0.019546509, -0.0014734268, 0.013404846, -0.038208008, -0.016174316, -0.03451538, -0.04324341, -0.00223732, -0.01651001, 0.019439697, -0.014579773, -0.011604309, -0.02027893, -0.008964539, -0.08135986, -0.009025574, 0.0385437, -0.011795044, -0.051940918, -0.0181427, 0.0033626556, 0.04812622, -0.011169434, 0.008934021, 0.007865906, 0.040008545, -0.021224976, 0.057525635, 0.073913574, 0.047332764, 0.076049805, 0.019729614, 0.037750244, 0.0036182404, 0.020004272, -0.0178833, 0.008964539, -0.011909485, -0.02192688, 0.03527832, 0.040649414, -0.02748108, 0.011627197, -0.0009455681, 0.041015625, 0.016052246, 0.018112183, 0.0016975403, -0.009506226, -0.039794922, -0.022338867, 0.045043945, 0.07556152, -0.048950195, -0.044189453, -0.05307007, 0.034179688, -0.0703125, -0.047424316, 0.10461426, -0.039520264, 0.010520935, -0.009407043, -0.039764404, -0.059448242, 0.03387451, -0.012496948, -0.029785156, -0.018188477, -0.006679535, -0.02368164, -0.0032863617, 0.048095703, -0.0066490173, -0.006652832, 0.014480591, -0.045196533, 0.0018930435, 0.047546387, 0.047851562, 0.0074806213, 0.015838623, -0.029525757, -0.03390503, -0.015808105, 0.008575439, -0.0011672974, -0.037872314, -0.013587952, 0.04067993, -0.018447876, -0.008216858, 0.002462387, 0.01096344, 0.06262207, 0.006778717, 0.02142334, 0.06567383, -0.024139404, 0.042755127, 0.038208008, 0.016662598, -0.08483887, -0.008964539, -0.06335449, -0.0027389526, -0.04626465, 0.0103302, 0.010940552, -0.039794922, 0.031097412, -0.021240234, -0.0104904175, -0.00035476685, 0.023742676, 0.12347412, 0.02748108, -0.0014829636, 0.05984497, 0.028045654, -0.011856079, 0.03048706, -0.06149292, 0.03677368, 0.048309326, 0.038391113, -0.0025596619, 0.012382507, -0.049072266, -0.009262085, 0.041229248, -0.00554657, 0.0013227463, 0.013832092, -0.002708435, -0.017547607, -0.0055618286, -0.05630493, -0.008964539, 0.009353638, 0.010803223, -0.0065727234, 0.00084638596, -0.0385437, 0.024841309, -0.009216309, -0.0115737915, 0.02645874, 0.04119873, 0.03237915, -0.019760132, 0.033233643, -0.006095886, 0.0034236908, -0.023239136, 0.022491455, 0.014549255, -0.027267456, -0.040252686, 0.0061912537, 0.05895996, -0.010681152, -0.012207031, 0.017074585, 0.028015137, 0.0028800964, -0.018966675, 0.031677246, 0.0073280334, 0.008087158, -0.013397217, -0.032196045, -0.017242432, -0.011054993, 0.019241333, -0.02104187, -0.017028809, -0.0040740967, -0.027664185, -0.061798096, -0.0079574585, -0.010498047, 0.04486084, 0.015975952, -0.039794922, -0.028533936, -0.08483887, -0.0037441254, -0.023727417, 0.003194809, -0.006626129, 0.0065231323, 0.025634766, -0.015296936, 0.0826416, -0.0027542114, 0.03363037, 0.0715332, -0.02519226, -0.004486084, -0.0059776306, -0.024490356, 0.030258179, 0.022857666, -0.010925293, 0.056671143, 0.00970459, -0.002571106, 0.014411926, 0.01625061, -0.042541504, -0.015808105, -0.036621094, -0.032440186, -0.07299805, 0.048614502, 0.010063171, 0.07946777, -0.03994751, 0.007987976, 0.009376526, 0.00053834915, -0.03326416, -0.010002136, 0.009429932, -0.048828125, -0.00920105, -0.017913818, -0.0020122528, -0.007789612, -0.011360168, 0.018844604, -0.030136108, -0.02645874, -0.023529053, -0.0113220215, 0.08331299, -0.021255493, -0.05230713, -0.0073013306, -0.024993896, 0.020523071, 0.023391724, -0.018493652, 0.013977051, 0.056365967, 0.019317627, -0.00063991547, -0.033081055, 0.07489014, -0.026428223, -0.015716553, 0.038146973, -0.04324341, -0.028137207, 0.0053253174, 0.044006348, -0.063964844, 0.00051403046, 0.066589355, 0.09326172, -0.038726807, 0.023910522, 0.0112838745, -0.01777649, -0.046203613, -0.0026836395, -0.0017156601, -0.020965576, 0.022644043, 0.033203125, 0.013801575, 0.040374756, -0.018096924, -0.02571106, -0.011978149, -0.049224854, 0.030303955, 0.044830322, 0.028884888, 0.012535095, -0.037841797, 0.033843994, 0.02696228, -0.007637024, 0.036010742, 0.0002348423, -0.011940002, -0.043029785, -0.007434845, 0.020477295, -0.017807007, -0.02420044, -0.019348145, -0.018173218, -0.005794525, 0.007671356, 0.0044059753, 0.015014648, 0.02532959, -0.008811951, 0.006263733, -0.026306152, 0.014862061, 0.0044555664, -0.014671326, -0.058807373, 0.018966675, -0.019622803, -0.04345703, -0.024047852, -0.013801575, -0.047607422, -0.0008196831, -0.000011205673, -0.00592041, 0.009864807, -0.0015506744, 0.006801605, 0.0008878708, -0.016708374, -0.021591187, -0.019744873, -0.012275696, 0.00023519993, 0.020217896, 0.0005311966, 0.009521484, -0.02041626, -0.0032615662, -0.0069122314, -0.056427002, -0.057373047, 0.017181396, 0.026245117, 0.0063934326, 0.066589355, 0.07269287, 0.012580872, 0.003484726, 0.02557373, 0.02330017, -0.018447876, -0.03100586, 0.009437561, 0.005947113, -0.001086235, 0.016281128, 0.032226562, -0.017303467, -0.030197144, -0.0059547424, 0.009361267, 0.019180298, 0.0047416687, -0.032165527, 0.02027893, 0.042297363, 0.0019416809, 0.03527832, -0.0074005127, 0.007751465, 0.023132324, -0.00031471252, 0.036895752, 0.032104492, 0.03250122, -0.019943237, 0.00021338463, -0.0024375916, -0.022338867, -0.06604004, -0.043792725, -0.024780273, 0.021377563, -0.011802673, -0.037597656, -0.021148682, -0.036590576, 0.04925537, 0.042999268, 0.05899048, -0.048797607, 0.012924194, -0.0023670197, -0.0020198822, -0.0064926147, -0.01626587, 0.003873825, -0.02104187, -0.012908936, 0.013999939, -0.056671143, 0.012359619, -0.022003174, -0.04699707, 0.02897644, 0.0082092285, -0.0054855347, -0.04421997, 0.022644043, -0.0021839142, -0.0036468506, 0.036834717, 0.00024867058, 0.04940796, -0.0013399124, 0.014167786, -0.0067977905, -0.032043457, 0.030776978, 0.05432129, 0.00819397, -0.007167816, 0.00024461746, 0.014259338, -0.0027236938, 0.00018918514, -0.003932953, -0.0026245117, 0.013679504, 0.0037555695, -0.02230835, -0.00007921457, 0.0418396, 0.05908203, -0.00070762634, -0.02319336, -0.012992859, -0.015838623, -0.0082473755, -0.028564453, -0.02571106, 0.007259369, -0.05682373, -0.019699097, -0.017852783, -0.055145264, -0.001115799, 0.038757324, -0.025665283, 0.015037537, -0.042297363, -0.017456055, 0.01436615, 0.037750244, -0.004634857, 0.029373169, -0.004623413, -0.014144897, 0.02368164, -0.04360962, -0.0030879974, -0.025009155, -0.00070619583, 0.0008058548, -0.010574341, 0.006954193, 0.029327393, 0.015525818, -0.010940552, 0.058166504, -0.034698486, 0.014854431, 0.0038833618, 0.030273438, 0.03265381, -0.013786316, -0.018218994, 0.009590149, 0.030319214, -0.02494812, 0.012687683, 0.019744873, -0.0038547516, 0.033355713, 0.017547607, 0.049621582, -0.02508545, -0.039031982, -0.0069503784, 0.052978516, 0.02130127, 0.023132324, -0.020507812, -0.006668091, 0.007671356, 0.007083893, -0.010398865, 0.048980713, -0.015899658, 0.0046157837, -0.015640259, 0.025268555, -0.02583313, -0.009765625, -0.009803772, 0.009254456, -0.016494751, -0.07720947, -0.0019035339, 0.000028133392, 0.036346436, 0.057006836, 0.050445557, -0.05392456, -0.031204224, -0.031158447, -0.008087158, -0.024719238, 0.03439331, -0.014320374, 0.0062217712, 0.0032844543, -0.011512756, -0.005569458, 0.009231567, 0.016799927, 0.012649536, -0.015823364, 0.0368042, -0.012901306, 0.0026474, 0.003293991, 0.074401855, 0.04623413, -0.004749298, 0.020812988, -0.013885498, 0.009719849, 0.011955261, -0.014541626, 0.008125305, 0.053131104, 0.04559326, -0.039123535, -0.02746582, -0.017913818, -0.033721924, 0.011543274, -0.00894165, -0.029571533, -0.01965332, -0.017150879, -0.035186768, 0.034240723, 0.0034561157, -0.019256592, 0.11602783, -0.0048065186, 0.010543823, -0.02368164, -0.070739746, 0.037902832, -0.0063552856, 0.020996094, 0.00881958, 0.012611389, -0.064086914, 0.022338867, 0.03829956, -0.015068054, 0.014930725, -0.038879395, 0.01071167, 0.04714966, -0.031799316, -0.029953003, -0.0040512085, 0.025131226, -0.04623413, 0.048461914, 0.052337646, 0.08514404, -0.041137695, -0.04168701, 0.02935791, 0.0046539307, -0.042755127, 0.046539307, -0.028060913, 0.018829346, 0.016357422, 0.005153656, -0.01512146, 0.012359619, -0.010696411, 0.009346008, 0.004096985, 0.046081543, -0.03363037, -0.013626099, 0.018829346, 0.026885986, -0.010498047, -0.0044441223, -0.036743164, -0.018661499, -0.043548584, -0.036346436, 0.010414124, 0.0016565323, 0.00920105, 0.03604126, -0.0113220215, 0.04473877, 0.005004883, 0.029464722, -0.0005941391, 0.02911377, -0.08154297, 0.06536865, 0.020751953, -0.02520752, 0.027770996, 0.031921387, -0.055908203, 0.030380249, 0.015686035, 0.084228516, 0.07757568, 0.059661865, -0.04876709, 0.014266968, 0.06915283, -0.011016846, 0.06976318, -0.013893127, -0.0107040405, -0.023880005, 0.0022087097, -0.00065279007, 0.01725769, 0.0018577576, 0.051696777, -0.030059814, 0.014205933, -0.040039062, 0.026626587, -0.03111267, -0.028259277, 0.004589081, -0.061340332, -0.011138916, -0.010726929, -0.010116577, -0.013641357, 0.0034103394, -0.045135498, 0.003047943, 0.0051651, -0.013069153, 0.0062675476, -0.022445679, -0.048980713, -0.004348755, 0.0178833, 0.041015625, 0.060699463, -0.015098572, 0.031433105, 0.0149002075, 0.010444641, -0.07537842, -0.053863525, 0.02078247, 0.026016235, -0.07537842, 0.012840271, -0.0007081032, -0.027053833, -0.047973633, 0.004432678, -0.014259338, -0.024002075, -0.014663696, 0.010063171, 0.024276733, -0.06549072, -0.020996094, -0.009498596, -0.028793335, -0.0049972534, -0.0006136894, -0.013153076, 0.03286743, -0.0026874542, -0.040771484, -0.02230835, -0.026046753, -0.022781372, -0.018096924, -0.022537231, 0.043823242, 0.024917603, -0.038909912, 0.03186035, 0.034179688, 0.03274536, 0.0043754578, -0.013671875, 0.0062065125, -0.0039863586, -0.036743164, 0.026779175, -0.007736206, -0.02217102, -0.0026855469, -0.011619568, 0.036010742, 0.006160736, -0.039642334, 0.0017528534, 0.0059814453, -0.025115967, -0.054504395, 0.012191772, 0.037017822, -0.029174805, 0.028915405, 0.008178711, -0.046966553, -0.023117065, 0.056854248, 0.008834839, -0.03387451, -0.028167725, 0.004585266, -0.02420044, -0.017929077, -0.01663208, -0.028549194, 0.044555664, -0.018432617, -0.017868042, 0.017532349, -0.043823242, 0.0016679764, 0.035888672, 0.023040771, -0.0078125, -0.018051147, -0.0021076202, 0.05847168, -0.087890625, -0.055755615, -0.020111084, 0.00013422966, -0.03439331, -0.042999268, 0.058166504, 0.017211914, -0.04837036, 0.042633057, -0.03164673, 0.012641907, 0.0039482117, -0.0060653687, -0.02520752, 0.026809692, 0.05343628, -0.011268616, 0.021575928 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1903.06669v3
Stay Ahead of Poachers: Illegal Wildlife Poaching Prediction and Patrol Planning Under Uncertainty with Field Test Evaluations
Lily Xu, Shahrzad Gholami, Sara Mc Carthy, Bistra Dilkina, Andrew Plumptre, Milind Tambe, Rohit Singh, Mustapha Nsubuga, Joshua Mabonga, Margaret Driciru, Fred Wanyama, Aggrey Rwetsiba, Tom Okello, Eric Enyel
stat.AP, cs.AI, cs.LG
Illegal wildlife poaching threatens ecosystems and drives endangered species toward extinction. However, efforts for wildlife protection are constrained by the limited resources of law enforcement agencies. To help combat poaching, the Protection Assistant for Wildlife Security (PAWS) is a machine learning pipeline that has been developed as a data-driven approach to identify areas at high risk of poaching throughout protected areas and compute optimal patrol routes. In this paper, we take an end-to-end approach to the data-to-deployment pipeline for anti-poaching. In doing so, we address challenges including extreme class imbalance (up to 1:200), bias, and uncertainty in wildlife poaching data to enhance PAWS, and we apply our methodology to three national parks with diverse characteristics. (i) We use Gaussian processes to quantify predictive uncertainty, which we exploit to improve robustness of our prescribed patrols and increase detection of snares by an average of 30%. We evaluate our approach on real-world historical poaching data from Murchison Falls and Queen Elizabeth National Parks in Uganda and, for the first time, Srepok Wildlife Sanctuary in Cambodia. (ii) We present the results of large-scale field tests conducted in Murchison Falls and Srepok Wildlife Sanctuary which confirm that the predictive power of PAWS extends promisingly to multiple parks. This paper is part of an effort to expand PAWS to 800 parks around the world through integration with SMART conservation software.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.06669v3
2019-11-06T03:06:34
2019-03-08T08:26:07
{ "title": [ -0.0022583008, 0.0063095093, -0.00059890747, -0.0006070137, -0.008926392, -0.02178955, 0.019927979, -0.0501709, -0.036468506, -0.024246216, -0.05908203, 0.022094727, -0.08148193, -0.029281616, -0.0034484863, -0.08087158, -0.0008735657, 0.02658081, -0.016677856, -0.029907227, 0.0028915405, -0.055877686, -0.0009703636, 0.027145386, 0.043701172, -0.058502197, -0.07373047, 0.037231445, -0.0127334595, -0.01727295, -0.008384705, 0.033599854, 0.027389526, 0.008514404, 0.016082764, 0.018188477, -0.007637024, 0.015350342, 0.011703491, 0.0053253174, 0.0016107559, 0.0027065277, -0.038360596, -0.005207062, -0.037139893, 0.0036525726, -0.04574585, 0.0012397766, -0.011924744, 0.07122803, 0.023132324, 0.0031929016, 0.030227661, 0.07739258, -0.009895325, -0.02885437, -0.04144287, 0.011558533, 0.043121338, 0.046813965, 0.005886078, -0.054504395, 0.008468628, -0.05847168, -0.017456055, -0.019332886, 0.044647217, 0.015357971, 0.039276123, -0.015434265, 0.0046539307, 0.04824829, 0.0028324127, 0.01612854, -0.040893555, -0.023345947, 0.035064697, 0.016113281, 0.024978638, 0.0027828217, -0.02545166, -0.03579712, -0.0010261536, -0.014892578, -0.005382538, -0.010734558, -0.008926392, 0.014808655, -0.029312134, -0.034240723, -0.017562866, 0.046447754, -0.009483337, -0.017608643, -0.04498291, -0.02758789, 0.034698486, 0.04824829, -0.011688232, -0.07098389, -0.020339966, 0.028137207, -0.12176514, 0.01675415, -0.010169983, 0.023208618, 0.0052604675, -0.005218506, -0.015327454, 0.025527954, -0.029037476, 0.004081726, 0.011306763, 0.01737976, -0.039489746, -0.009033203, -0.015899658, -0.036834717, 0.0020065308, -0.010261536, 0.005531311, 0.003156662, 0.02204895, -0.021774292, 0.045410156, 0.0053138733, -0.04345703, -0.0015850067, -0.013755798, 0.05218506, 0.0026760101, 0.04345703, -0.07446289, -0.0949707, -0.083984375, 0.00579834, -0.02357483, -0.0065231323, -0.026672363, 0.00945282, -0.010269165, -0.02079773, 0.026016235, -0.008934021, 0.038146973, -0.023269653, 0.043182373, 0.02670288, -0.019317627, -0.011421204, 0.03375244, 0.01838684, 0.020706177, -0.012107849, -0.0067634583, -0.04751587, -0.02758789, -0.04171753, 0.048858643, -0.046020508, 0.023010254, -0.0011672974, -0.015052795, -0.010925293, -0.021270752, 0.008598328, -0.0032672882, 0.009246826, 0.00843811, 0.02230835, -0.0107803345, -0.035827637, -0.028167725, -0.014312744, -0.012863159, 0.02508545, -0.015045166, 0.017715454, 0.07513428, -0.076538086, -0.032348633, -0.024307251, 0.08166504, 0.008598328, -0.037017822, -0.03942871, 0.0047302246, -0.0118255615, 0.035705566, 0.0028820038, -0.019729614, 0.022521973, -0.04309082, -0.00548172, -0.023590088, 0.012039185, 0.003929138, 0.037109375, -0.014793396, -0.025924683, -0.043701172, 0.026306152, -0.025527954, 0.04083252, -0.006679535, -0.026168823, 0.0026664734, 0.027908325, 0.007534027, 0.08294678, 0.03213501, 0.021316528, -0.031951904, 0.023376465, -0.018676758, -0.105407715, -0.00374794, -0.032440186, 0.0054359436, -0.022705078, -0.003572464, 0.027938843, -0.023513794, -0.008384705, -0.026397705, 0.031829834, -0.0025920868, 0.0071907043, 0.007820129, 0.043426514, 0.06085205, -0.06365967, 0.03845215, 0.042236328, -0.008682251, -0.019714355, -0.0020828247, 0.0026111603, 0.018722534, 0.018493652, 0.01109314, -0.024154663, -0.009674072, 0.021087646, 0.037719727, -0.01574707, 0.0053215027, 0.030563354, 0.012542725, 0.008285522, 0.06021118, 0.007820129, 0.041229248, 0.029693604, 0.007713318, 0.055511475, -0.015029907, 0.038604736, -0.038513184, -0.01676941, 0.0011558533, -0.0064430237, 0.022766113, -0.017547607, -0.043121338, -0.0126953125, -0.014762878, 0.0061836243, 0.015037537, -0.008781433, 0.031066895, -0.024871826, 0.015159607, -0.00623703, -0.015731812, -0.030822754, -0.013786316, 0.02281189, 0.021636963, -0.046020508, 0.01285553, 0.04196167, 0.021636963, -0.008232117, 0.0013313293, 0.04257202, 0.013320923, -0.015777588, -0.055541992, -0.02494812, 0.03579712, 0.00793457, -0.015777588, -0.030349731, -0.002904892, -0.009941101, 0.03152466, 0.048461914, -0.026916504, -0.0006957054, -0.07965088, -0.0074157715, 0.007675171, -0.037109375, 0.00969696, -0.00806427, 0.03643799, 0.031143188, -0.018035889, -0.0206604, -0.0051651, 0.006843567, 0.015533447, -0.054260254, 0.019989014, 0.021591187, 0.0054473877, 0.0037174225, 0.028121948, 0.038604736, 0.0137786865, -0.011009216, -0.00598526, -0.022903442, 0.0026817322, -0.0046424866, -0.03970337, -0.018325806, -0.05557251, 0.023880005, 0.03387451, -0.037628174, -0.047546387, 0.0026416779, 0.0057029724, 0.04537964, -0.017974854, 0.04196167, -0.02357483, -0.023803711, -0.03475952, -0.020187378, 0.0009160042, -0.040496826, -0.0075645447, -0.08874512, 0.011413574, -0.0059928894, -0.0014848709, -0.016067505, 0.049072266, 0.011047363, -0.013824463, -0.026916504, 0.017333984, 0.0010681152, 0.011634827, -0.004512787, 0.00011014938, -0.02243042, 0.0770874, 0.013298035, 0.024734497, -0.051208496, -0.013893127, -0.06939697, -0.009727478, -0.042114258, 0.019348145, 0.05404663, -0.09063721, 0.01979065, -0.045806885, 0.0096588135, 0.05203247, 0.042541504, -0.031463623, -0.044708252, 0.035369873, -0.016555786, -0.01234436, -0.019989014, 0.018203735, -0.0008392334, 0.06982422, 0.01159668, 0.02633667, 0.005962372, 0.031982422, -0.021865845, -0.0024032593, -0.0007100105, -0.036224365, -0.022994995, 0.015380859, 0.012634277, -0.026275635, -0.038726807, -0.059539795, -0.0054244995, 0.031829834, -0.015960693, -0.034057617, 0.00409317, -0.05819702, -0.040008545, -0.03286743, -0.013626099, 0.03945923, -0.006580353, 0.02456665, -0.018707275, 0.018920898, -0.03567505, -0.0041160583, -0.029815674, 0.0043640137, 0.03817749, -0.013885498, -0.085754395, 0.02017212, -0.01965332, 0.006122589, -0.023025513, 0.0028762817, 0.018463135, 0.017242432, -0.02218628, 0.009002686, 0.024765015, -0.009963989, 0.007434845, -0.00083112717, -0.051239014, -0.018692017, -0.061431885, -0.023529053, 0.0206604, 0.011299133, 0.010528564, -0.022109985, 0.023635864, -0.02722168, 0.019699097, -0.00091409683, -0.050231934, 0.026809692, -0.029083252, 0.0029945374, -0.028411865, -0.003074646, 0.0049057007, 0.021102905, 0.0067749023, -0.012710571, 0.0007214546, -0.005508423, 0.0040016174, -0.0055770874, -0.0151901245, 0.0034637451, -0.0005874634, -0.046875, -0.013717651, -0.023956299, -0.024749756, 0.055389404, -0.0132751465, -0.009338379, -0.010192871, -0.058044434, 0.061309814, 0.013267517, -0.007801056, 0.028945923, -0.009796143, -0.02053833, 0.0051231384, -0.02772522, 0.0076293945, 0.031433105, 0.0033626556, -0.008880615, -0.02017212, -0.00233078, 0.014709473, -0.091918945, -0.01235199, 0.012268066, -0.0284729, 0.00005954504, -0.03012085, 0.016571045, -0.015304565, -0.014251709, -0.010925293, -0.0049743652, 0.0061035156, -0.00333786, -0.044555664, -0.045043945, 0.068847656, -0.017059326, -0.010986328, 0.016189575, 0.0011558533, -0.045196533, -0.00044894218, 0.019332886, -0.044708252, 0.00843811, 0.0054130554, 0.007381439, 0.037017822, -0.038604736, 0.0013332367, 0.007385254, 0.017105103, -0.02571106, 0.0017986298, 0.035827637, 0.052368164, -0.009895325, 0.04208374, 0.020050049, -0.018463135, -0.04611206, 0.004611969, -0.02494812, -0.026504517, -0.0035152435, -0.011421204, -0.033843994, 0.017654419, 0.05267334, 0.07928467, -0.018951416, 0.02255249, 0.034118652, -0.022201538, -0.027954102, -0.0335083, 0.010864258, 0.024475098, -0.016983032, 0.019088745, -0.02494812, 0.05493164, -0.01928711, 0.0032653809, -0.00014579296, 0.008171082, -0.084106445, -0.025802612, -0.049224854, -0.0077667236, -0.012298584, 0.0206604, -0.03579712, -0.01171875, 0.045928955, -0.020065308, -0.023620605, -0.017242432, 0.04522705, -0.0034179688, 0.015174866, -0.07183838, 0.05999756, -0.017684937, -0.10534668, -0.07098389, 0.025878906, 0.033172607, 0.012496948, -0.014640808, -0.03378296, 0.0118255615, 0.0070762634, 0.060028076, 0.0062675476, 0.009803772, -0.021347046, 0.030166626, -0.0340271, -0.026245117, 0.02923584, -0.00008171797, -0.01651001, -0.04071045, 0.03100586, -0.010551453, -0.023635864, -0.034423828, 0.025466919, -0.0056915283, 0.020812988, 0.01789856, 0.039123535, 0.019515991, 0.015075684, -0.0020313263, -0.0021572113, -0.04977417, 0.05166626, -0.013473511, 0.039489746, -0.0061912537, 0.010238647, 0.056274414, 0.0052223206, -0.014343262, 0.013618469, 0.0023555756, 0.02142334, 0.00044369698, -0.044281006, 0.031921387, -0.03338623, -0.010124207, -0.0065078735, -0.034698486, 0.027633667, -0.057006836, 0.042419434, -0.008422852, 0.0236969, 0.04208374, 0.0025920868, 0.032104492, 0.00084400177, 0.011955261, -0.045166016, -0.059539795, 0.017120361, 0.039001465, -0.023422241, 0.00075149536, 0.007843018, 0.015701294, 0.035858154, 0.031463623, 0.004852295, 0.000069856644, -0.0262146, 0.014526367, -0.003370285, -0.042785645, -0.05923462, -0.025726318, -0.0010061264, 0.02330017, -0.0524292, 0.085876465, -0.041107178, 0.026184082, -0.0074386597, 0.013511658, -0.0009083748, -0.071777344, 0.0134887695, 0.043762207, 0.0206604, -0.005508423, 0.017715454, 0.013458252, 0.048553467, 0.027450562, 0.01737976, 0.0034866333, 0.021560669, -0.024002075, 0.0075569153, -0.014137268, 0.02355957, 0.016082764, 0.016174316, 0.014137268, 0.012031555, -0.057739258, 0.017456055, -0.011390686, -0.014656067, 0.011299133, -0.032958984, 0.0065307617, 0.0066223145, 0.0014734268, 0.016952515, 0.015838623, -0.0043296814, 0.03994751, -0.0067749023, 0.009857178, -0.03491211, -0.0016622543, -0.023513794, -0.06274414, -0.008262634, -0.028182983, -0.016021729, -0.011985779, 0.032104492, -0.0062713623, 0.016448975, 0.047546387, -0.046966553, 0.015625, -0.0103302, 0.0052757263, 0.043670654, 0.03503418, -0.055480957, -0.014144897, 0.019622803, -0.028076172, -0.022964478, 0.0053977966, -0.0022010803, 0.001996994, -0.0065727234, -0.06903076, -0.028762817, 0.03945923, 0.02949524, 0.00027823448, -0.028900146, 0.026565552, 0.0022716522, -0.0012588501, 0.024551392, 0.057678223, -0.02468872, 0.020492554, 0.013320923, -0.0084991455, 0.0552063, -0.029678345, -0.021392822, 0.029083252, -0.019866943, 0.018859863, 0.003993988, -0.020050049, -0.024719238, 0.024795532, 0.033996582, -0.027069092, -0.0024414062, -0.005847931, 0.058929443, -0.060333252, -0.03250122, -0.0064964294, 0.010749817, -0.011436462, 0.04473877, 0.008056641, -0.02758789, -0.03262329, -0.030517578, -0.033935547, 0.0002810955, 0.024993896, 0.006198883, 0.020446777, 0.02809143, 0.014198303, -0.040161133, -0.002319336, -0.049926758, 0.009635925, -0.0072784424, 0.011558533, 0.022705078, -0.011802673, 0.007785797, -0.034240723, 0.010269165, 0.040161133, 0.0044021606, 0.041534424, -0.07519531, -0.01234436, -0.01763916, -0.030410767, 0.047851562, -0.007587433, 0.0061683655, 0.038360596, -0.011886597, 0.02104187, -0.014221191, 0.051330566, 0.024108887, 0.049987793, 0.03503418, 0.001750946, -0.029556274, -0.033233643, -0.044433594, -0.056030273, -0.0006842613, 0.000992775, 0.008598328, -0.022827148, -0.018173218, 0.036956787, 0.010620117, 0.02003479, 0.00007414818, 0.0026454926, 0.032043457, 0.03579712, 0.037628174, 0.050842285, -0.0053520203, 0.02053833, -0.021820068, -0.056854248, 0.034973145, 0.038757324, -0.003232956, -0.0027179718, -0.040985107, -0.03387451, -0.006664276, -0.008651733, 0.026260376, -0.011505127, -0.026611328, -0.020324707, 0.029403687, -0.007583618, 0.019454956, 0.052825928, 0.030929565, 0.0184021, -0.035491943, -0.0009608269, -0.011543274, -0.004055023, -0.013954163, 0.027435303, -0.02960205, 0.038360596, -0.02947998, -0.041534424, 0.018875122, 0.050476074, -0.018035889, -0.033477783, -0.025405884, -0.011772156, 0.03048706, 0.060546875, 0.026489258, -0.0046424866, -0.015113831, 0.0071487427, 0.027389526, 0.018661499, 0.045776367, -0.018463135, 0.05380249, 0.0093688965, -0.03567505, 0.005970001, -0.040283203, 0.032989502, 0.04837036, 0.02734375, 0.04434204, -0.0013046265, -0.04107666, -0.012428284, 0.02758789, -0.048675537, -0.029464722, -0.003944397, -0.030075073, -0.014770508, 0.041625977, 0.032165527, -0.0035858154, -0.076049805, -0.022155762, 0.0018510818, 0.08404541, -0.0021572113, 0.03201294, -0.037628174, -0.06585693, 0.05795288, 0.0032405853, 0.10821533, -0.030929565, 0.006412506, -0.03515625, 0.013648987, 0.0060691833, -0.030395508, -0.0234375, -0.01838684, -0.0121154785, -0.02279663, -0.046722412, -0.021652222, -0.019088745, -0.026321411, 0.047607422, 0.028015137, -0.01626587, 0.004169464, -0.012290955, -0.117004395, -0.015022278, -0.02520752, 0.0124053955, 0.020019531, -0.021347046, -0.015022278, 0.01878357, 0.0017137527, -0.008026123, 0.0019550323, -0.00111866, -0.03616333, -0.037597656, 0.024673462, 0.034606934, -0.005012512, 0.0009946823, -0.000007987022, -0.0016469955, -0.0075035095, -0.02583313, 0.048980713, 0.0035915375, -0.07543945, -0.022521973, -0.015365601, -0.0012998581, -0.002822876, -0.01348114, 0.02267456, 0.007411957, -0.014640808, -0.03591919, 0.00010573864, 0.0049362183, -0.0124053955, -0.034606934, -0.012237549, 0.036193848, 0.01890564, -0.047180176, -0.030090332, 0.017074585, 0.057495117, -0.05419922, 0.040893555, -0.013175964, 0.03982544, 0.05847168, 0.08929443, 0.021133423, -0.08630371, -0.042785645, -0.016647339, 0.038970947, 0.022247314, -0.0039482117, -0.012908936, 0.014190674, -0.011672974, 0.008934021, 0.007255554, -0.019119263, 0.016616821, -0.008934021, 0.03756714, -0.0057907104, 0.0090408325, -0.034729004, 0.045013428, -0.014282227, 0.007797241, 0.018539429, 0.021026611, 0.0036697388, 0.05456543, 0.004108429, -0.018615723, 0.019760132, 0.03894043, 0.023376465, 0.07098389, -0.014953613, -0.028671265, -0.027038574, 0.028778076, 0.012168884, 0.04937744, -0.009788513, -0.0060157776, 0.021697998, -0.058410645, -0.04296875, 0.050109863, -0.0074768066, 0.020751953, -0.033416748, 0.025009155, -0.019821167, -0.00945282, 0.010139465, 0.014945984, 0.037719727, -0.055725098, -0.014533997, -0.023910522, 0.043182373, 0.0007405281 ], "summary": [ 0.039916992, -0.007820129, 0.016174316, 0.024673462, -0.028152466, -0.034210205, 0.025741577, -0.05630493, 0.0126571655, -0.019866943, -0.039978027, 0.013694763, -0.04525757, -0.044555664, 0.026168823, -0.04647827, -0.00027155876, 0.026657104, 0.00982666, -0.024520874, 0.0067710876, -0.025756836, 0.0107040405, 0.008865356, 0.026733398, -0.055877686, -0.0121536255, 0.014533997, 0.0027275085, -0.018081665, 0.004348755, 0.030349731, -0.0058670044, 0.0317688, 0.032287598, 0.035064697, -0.004322052, 0.023498535, 0.035095215, 0.011741638, 0.020080566, -0.007801056, 0.030212402, -0.0042304993, -0.0025348663, 0.012771606, -0.0018758774, -0.03704834, 0.000037908554, 0.038085938, 0.03353882, -0.0014343262, 0.01977539, 0.07287598, 0.002122879, 0.008056641, -0.008583069, -0.01335907, 0.01689148, 0.07598877, 0.0034599304, 0.00004529953, -0.013664246, -0.10003662, -0.016479492, -0.011222839, 0.06976318, 0.021011353, -0.0079422, -0.043823242, 0.017028809, 0.035980225, 0.013198853, -0.0385437, -0.011543274, 0.0143966675, -0.0070114136, -0.006252289, 0.028289795, -0.015617371, -0.02218628, -0.033996582, 0.021209717, -0.014305115, -0.039733887, -0.027023315, -0.01965332, 0.018432617, -0.0062561035, -0.029556274, -0.027770996, 0.015777588, -0.052856445, 0.032165527, 0.011238098, -0.034454346, 0.022644043, 0.0018796921, -0.019165039, -0.04067993, 0.032165527, -0.023635864, -0.021652222, -0.002292633, -0.04067993, 0.022781372, 0.024719238, -0.008140564, -0.036987305, 0.022964478, -0.022781372, -0.066223145, 0.032043457, 0.015029907, -0.067871094, -0.019470215, 0.018127441, -0.049346924, -0.0024032593, -0.042022705, -0.01361084, 0.008552551, 0.0104522705, -0.010726929, 0.02633667, -0.0015172958, -0.021713257, 0.0002696514, -0.0013008118, 0.023376465, -0.0023651123, 0.019134521, -0.03149414, -0.038482666, -0.042236328, -0.022735596, 0.010246277, 0.007659912, -0.011993408, -0.0026416779, 0.009353638, -0.02558899, -0.02029419, -0.007080078, 0.060668945, -0.05319214, 0.005252838, 0.07067871, 0.02519226, 0.040496826, 0.060394287, 0.027877808, 0.02961731, -0.025604248, 0.044311523, -0.09539795, 0.028808594, -0.053771973, 0.07696533, -0.030212402, 0.015205383, -0.0018959045, 0.0030784607, 0.027664185, 0.005264282, -0.014022827, 0.005317688, -0.005214691, 0.0005931854, 0.04244995, -0.02911377, -0.020828247, -0.04260254, -0.00667572, -0.0029315948, -0.0009522438, -0.042999268, 0.042541504, 0.09326172, -0.08935547, -0.052856445, -0.035369873, 0.11529541, -0.013343811, 0.013282776, -0.038391113, 0.012763977, -0.030014038, 0.012863159, 0.011199951, -0.0054016113, 0.01461792, -0.043884277, 0.009147644, -0.00957489, 0.005542755, 0.0018463135, 0.02633667, -0.005558014, -0.026382446, -0.000333786, 0.0105896, -0.010803223, -0.0009908676, -0.05706787, -0.012939453, -0.012954712, 0.016830444, -0.06359863, 0.038269043, 0.047943115, -0.023422241, -0.051208496, 0.037597656, 0.028747559, -0.06112671, -0.0041007996, -0.029953003, 0.02128601, -0.025848389, 0.0075302124, 0.03213501, -0.024307251, 0.0030975342, -0.047668457, 0.021759033, -0.03677368, 0.011352539, -0.025375366, 0.02532959, 0.0335083, -0.009284973, 0.02168274, 0.02494812, -0.024536133, -0.032348633, -0.009017944, -0.06506348, 0.019454956, 0.055755615, 0.029220581, 0.028457642, -0.044799805, -0.07940674, 0.0541687, -0.056488037, -0.022659302, -0.016860962, -0.01966858, 0.0027313232, 0.06512451, -0.016998291, 0.02053833, -0.020629883, -0.012397766, 0.036346436, -0.014984131, 0.0033683777, 0.008331299, -0.008796692, -0.006504059, -0.015609741, 0.0058898926, -0.02166748, -0.052612305, -0.057373047, -0.015335083, -0.010269165, 0.042633057, -0.08758545, 0.011993408, -0.010131836, 0.0019512177, -0.023406982, -0.008972168, -0.050628662, 0.009399414, 0.009643555, -0.019134521, -0.039276123, 0.0048446655, 0.038208008, -0.020324707, -0.022994995, 0.021118164, 0.0031967163, -0.023727417, -0.030075073, -0.005355835, 0.041015625, 0.06036377, 0.017822266, -0.024749756, 0.004863739, -0.011779785, -0.0005803108, 0.015197754, 0.041534424, -0.015541077, -0.0079193115, -0.014678955, -0.00033211708, -0.01663208, -0.03250122, 0.016448975, -0.02330017, 0.015045166, 0.008338928, -0.0029315948, 0.008163452, -0.023025513, 0.05130005, 0.008811951, 0.026779175, -0.0657959, -0.028411865, -0.06524658, 0.00036907196, -0.032287598, 0.03668213, 0.059387207, -0.0625, 0.020690918, 0.0025806427, -0.03466797, -0.051635742, 0.05203247, 0.0046043396, -0.0435791, 0.008285522, -0.0017299652, -0.0385437, -0.021133423, 0.04827881, 0.005783081, 0.016204834, -0.006603241, 0.01373291, -0.013053894, 0.0011520386, 0.034332275, -0.009895325, 0.009986877, 0.00856781, -0.066345215, -0.052337646, 0.011039734, -0.01663208, 0.028259277, -0.03137207, 0.058135986, 0.03225708, -0.06225586, 0.009239197, -0.014350891, -0.020385742, 0.056243896, -0.035827637, -0.03173828, -0.044433594, 0.032714844, 0.0340271, 0.018066406, -0.07147217, -0.04849243, -0.042999268, -0.010978699, -0.00071668625, 0.049468994, 0.043426514, -0.028442383, 0.048736572, -0.026367188, 0.00010538101, 0.016326904, 0.009124756, 0.019058228, -0.007724762, 0.003566742, 0.0051879883, 0.038482666, 0.021209717, 0.04135132, 0.022384644, 0.080078125, 0.007888794, 0.030212402, 0.062042236, 0.036865234, -0.02571106, -0.017425537, 0.02166748, -0.047973633, -0.02684021, 0.05206299, 0.027770996, 0.0027217865, 0.0045547485, -0.043395996, -0.036254883, 0.043823242, 0.011764526, -0.0012769699, -0.006248474, -0.014480591, -0.015686035, 0.011909485, -0.0050621033, 0.03845215, -0.051208496, 0.016998291, -0.013717651, 0.02003479, -0.058288574, 0.020751953, -0.038757324, 0.094055176, 0.036071777, 0.00907135, -0.09387207, 0.012496948, 0.02418518, 0.00011187792, -0.05230713, -0.025482178, -0.00012910366, -0.0057868958, 0.028564453, -0.017700195, 0.033294678, -0.015686035, -0.008857727, -0.0027046204, -0.026687622, -0.03475952, -0.06072998, -0.030578613, -0.045959473, 0.014640808, -0.036987305, -0.042175293, -0.002298355, -0.0093688965, 0.023406982, -0.0061569214, -0.025619507, 0.0047073364, -0.0552063, 0.039794922, -0.023849487, -0.0051994324, -0.004962921, 0.104003906, 0.011985779, -0.009773254, -0.003873825, -0.02810669, 0.010673523, -0.0038337708, -0.004146576, 0.012863159, 0.02619934, -0.06994629, -0.050231934, 0.014930725, -0.0028839111, -0.013336182, 0.016021729, 0.009567261, -0.035858154, 0.009025574, 0.035827637, -0.03012085, -0.007904053, 0.04156494, -0.025939941, -0.015296936, 0.029800415, -0.007904053, -0.0046195984, 0.026519775, -0.010055542, -0.027114868, -0.026626587, -0.0034618378, -0.0032405853, -0.07757568, -0.023590088, 0.023620605, -0.028518677, -0.020233154, -0.030975342, 0.038970947, -0.027709961, 0.008895874, 0.0072135925, -0.0011672974, 0.01537323, -0.010650635, -0.029800415, -0.0602417, 0.019500732, 0.0065841675, 0.025009155, -0.029510498, 0.05529785, 0.013397217, -0.014053345, -0.027404785, -0.07714844, 0.002855301, -0.056427002, 0.020507812, 0.005180359, -0.015701294, 0.018371582, -0.015274048, 0.04486084, -0.030700684, -0.020233154, 0.026565552, 0.03567505, 0.008270264, -0.0041503906, 0.022644043, -0.00013053417, -0.02017212, 0.028717041, -0.016616821, -0.010879517, 0.025772095, 0.028152466, -0.039245605, -0.0070495605, 0.036590576, 0.00059366226, -0.0050468445, -0.013458252, -0.0066490173, -0.006565094, -0.013053894, 0.008010864, 0.026626587, 0.03665161, -0.004623413, 0.012931824, -0.051940918, 0.006259918, -0.02746582, 0.012138367, -0.038238525, -0.035491943, -0.06524658, -0.05834961, -0.0045166016, 0.038269043, 0.019927979, -0.01486969, -0.032714844, -0.0051460266, -0.000957489, -0.011779785, -0.00003415346, -0.019714355, 0.0062065125, 0.024475098, -0.0022220612, -0.06359863, 0.024230957, -0.03086853, -0.032806396, -0.05102539, 0.007850647, 0.008728027, -0.025009155, 0.00040721893, -0.026611328, 0.024291992, -0.00023710728, 0.05142212, 0.01625061, 0.0056114197, -0.037994385, 0.0149002075, -0.037994385, 0.0262146, 0.02229309, -0.03277588, -0.020462036, -0.0018806458, -0.00095415115, 0.015808105, -0.033416748, -0.062408447, 0.016708374, 0.024139404, 0.0340271, 0.064575195, 0.044799805, 0.013954163, -0.008636475, -0.0075035095, -0.0012578964, -0.009727478, 0.027740479, 0.015548706, 0.022140503, -0.0036945343, 0.012893677, 0.072753906, -0.035339355, -0.07922363, 0.087524414, -0.0013980865, 0.08520508, -0.02154541, -0.025390625, 0.025894165, -0.00022423267, -0.008735657, 0.01235199, -0.028839111, 0.02130127, -0.029403687, -0.015853882, 0.006931305, -0.011817932, 0.028625488, -0.0028057098, 0.022247314, 0.049682617, 0.002281189, -0.03579712, -0.074645996, -0.01828003, 0.07550049, 0.009437561, -0.01285553, -0.016357422, -0.0027580261, 0.024536133, -0.016281128, -0.041931152, 0.020431519, -0.007457733, 0.012664795, 0.008628845, -0.004837036, -0.02017212, -0.0119018555, -0.018005371, 0.00028514862, 0.011192322, 0.0018177032, -0.004550934, 0.0041999817, 0.021469116, 0.0340271, -0.014724731, -0.05316162, -0.05987549, -0.02670288, 0.017608643, -0.07501221, 0.012535095, -0.033569336, 0.015419006, 0.024902344, -0.025482178, 0.0067100525, -0.0064048767, 0.00036096573, -0.0024280548, 0.0012817383, 0.010971069, 0.029907227, -0.03616333, 0.012916565, -0.03225708, 0.020309448, 0.005470276, -0.010276794, 0.0033359528, -0.015731812, -0.018829346, 0.019378662, -0.0413208, 0.0013437271, 0.011680603, 0.047607422, -0.016448975, 0.0011196136, 0.02949524, -0.005191803, -0.046447754, 0.0042304993, 0.023513794, -0.040649414, 0.006729126, -0.06652832, -0.00043845177, 0.00434494, 0.018829346, 0.021591187, -0.0137786865, 0.014015198, 0.015014648, 0.015991211, 0.02494812, 0.005695343, 0.006008148, 0.0231781, -0.04107666, -0.0075263977, -0.0025253296, -0.023208618, -0.0690918, -0.04373169, -0.036865234, 0.046142578, -0.028335571, -0.051940918, -0.006980896, -0.013145447, 0.01939392, -0.020339966, -0.019317627, -0.013633728, -0.015556335, -0.006996155, 0.021881104, -0.0013570786, -0.03439331, 0.01374054, 0.022125244, -0.04220581, 0.037872314, -0.015716553, -0.017684937, 0.074523926, -0.007106781, 0.027862549, 0.009788513, 0.019699097, 0.015464783, 0.018096924, 0.011482239, -0.014259338, 0.025405884, 0.017807007, 0.037628174, -0.03741455, -0.024551392, -0.015945435, 0.016281128, -0.0029792786, 0.08331299, -0.0071868896, -0.021514893, -0.035736084, -0.049102783, 0.0035552979, -0.005138397, 0.00094652176, 0.030853271, 0.007007599, 0.059173584, 0.0769043, 0.010513306, -0.0018444061, -0.02279663, -0.0057029724, -0.0039138794, 0.055755615, 0.023925781, 0.006214142, 0.020263672, 0.027374268, 0.012893677, -0.032928467, -0.053222656, 0.0018062592, -0.0138168335, 0.038482666, -0.012878418, 0.036499023, 0.05432129, 0.0077552795, 0.015556335, 0.02684021, 0.018737793, 0.012397766, 0.00086545944, 0.055114746, -0.008834839, 0.0048103333, 0.07159424, 0.00945282, -0.019836426, -0.024047852, -0.058013916, -0.03289795, -0.00422287, 0.02885437, 0.00090026855, 0.033966064, 0.027069092, 0.0030555725, -0.027389526, 0.036132812, -0.009727478, -0.0056915283, 0.038909912, -0.021347046, 0.050323486, -0.012359619, -0.062805176, -0.00053834915, -0.016998291, -0.06921387, 0.02835083, 0.048980713, -0.020843506, 0.0119018555, 0.00022017956, 0.010696411, 0.008705139, -0.023712158, -0.006134033, -0.024887085, 0.016937256, -0.011634827, 0.01776123, -0.01008606, 0.030776978, 0.050231934, 0.008201599, -0.020751953, 0.0026187897, 0.00081539154, 0.009811401, 0.03186035, -0.029464722, -0.0013246536, -0.009735107, -0.014343262, 0.017227173, -0.025939941, 0.017074585, 0.021072388, 0.016082764, -0.02609253, -0.017791748, -0.0064468384, 0.02558899, 0.011802673, 0.05517578, -0.025680542, -0.03186035, -0.03527832, -0.0146102905, 0.008506775, 0.0124435425, -0.0068740845, 0.034576416, 0.040863037, 0.00025773048, 0.0035266876, -0.016601562, 0.035064697, 0.029388428, 0.0065956116, 0.047424316, 0.007965088, -0.017562866, 0.0000513196, 0.019104004, -0.045013428, -0.001200676, 0.03074646, -0.04675293, -0.010757446, -0.0035057068, -0.011421204, -0.0006160736, -0.01902771, -0.026290894, -0.01197052, 0.013694763, 0.011169434, -0.010261536, -0.023117065, -0.0026245117, 0.013504028, 0.034484863, 0.03741455, -0.018630981, -0.015327454, -0.019180298, -0.009788513, -0.023666382, 0.011367798, 0.033172607, -0.057678223, -0.0075683594, 0.017364502, 0.018310547, -0.035125732, 0.0066986084, -0.0013504028, -0.011924744, 0.02607727, -0.04421997, 0.0035305023, 0.0076942444, -0.074645996, -0.066345215, -0.03338623, -0.010368347, 0.027755737, -0.035064697, 0.0019283295, 0.004196167, 0.023712158, -0.025024414, -0.0074882507, -0.0039405823, 0.0055236816, -0.06738281, 0.038726807, 0.022964478, -0.002450943, -0.0053367615, -0.0027484894, -0.0065574646, -0.01121521, -0.024383545, 0.023773193, 0.010520935, -0.048797607, -0.034332275, 0.00340271, -0.028182983, -0.008171082, -0.030181885, 0.012908936, 0.0143585205, -0.019515991, -0.0032310486, 0.011756897, 0.027786255, -0.036102295, -0.053466797, -0.008003235, 0.007709503, 0.0035896301, -0.016296387, 0.0059051514, 0.047729492, 0.03387451, -0.043914795, 0.023025513, -0.045166016, 0.039031982, 0.09008789, 0.14038086, 0.036254883, -0.10064697, -0.06359863, -0.043151855, 0.021652222, -0.036132812, -0.015258789, -0.03717041, 0.0101623535, -0.04598999, 0.018463135, 0.005378723, -0.003917694, 0.02885437, -0.019378662, 0.017318726, -0.031280518, 0.035339355, -0.03945923, 0.013572693, -0.02204895, -0.016708374, 0.005054474, 0.013183594, -0.03189087, 0.032073975, 0.015525818, -0.007381439, 0.0033855438, 0.011634827, 0.014450073, 0.006088257, 0.011230469, -0.018798828, -0.027694702, 0.015457153, 0.027877808, 0.047027588, -0.0056266785, -0.033111572, 0.038757324, -0.10406494, 0.0019741058, -0.034423828, -0.036254883, 0.040283203, 0.0006046295, -0.015296936, 0.016738892, -0.010559082, 0.022354126, 0.007507324, 0.025650024, -0.025360107, 0.02911377, -0.017501831, 0.009483337, 0.0143966675 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1911.05146v2
HyPar-Flow: Exploiting MPI and Keras for Scalable Hybrid-Parallel DNN Training using TensorFlow
Ammar Ahmad Awan, Arpan Jain, Quentin Anthony, Hari Subramoni, Dhabaleswar K. Panda
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PF
To reduce training time of large-scale DNNs, scientists have started to explore parallelization strategies like data-parallelism, model-parallelism, and hybrid-parallelism. While data-parallelism has been extensively studied and developed, several problems exist in realizing model-parallelism and hybrid-parallelism efficiently. Four major problems we focus on are: 1) defining a notion of a distributed model across processes, 2) implementing forward/back-propagation across process boundaries that requires explicit communication, 3) obtaining parallel speedup on an inherently sequential task, and 4) achieving scalability without losing out on a model's accuracy. To address these problems, we create HyPar-Flow --- a model-size/-type agnostic, scalable, practical, and user-transparent system for hybrid-parallel training by exploiting MPI, Keras, and TensorFlow. HyPar-Flow provides a single API that can be used to perform data, model, and hybrid parallel training of any Keras model at scale. We create an internal distributed representation of the user-provided Keras model, utilize TF's Eager execution features for distributed forward/back-propagation across processes, exploit pipelining to improve performance and leverage efficient MPI primitives for scalable communication. Between model partitions, we use send and recv to exchange layer-data/partial-errors while allreduce is used to accumulate/average gradients across model replicas. Beyond the design and implementation of HyPar-Flow, we also provide comprehensive correctness and performance results on three state-of-the-art HPC systems including TACC Frontera (#5 on Top500.org). For ResNet-1001, an ultra-deep model, HyPar-Flow provides: 1) Up to 1.6x speedup over Horovod-based data-parallel training, 2) 110x speedup over single-node on 128 Stampede2 nodes, and 3) 481x speedup over single-node on 512 Frontera nodes.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1911.05146v2
2020-02-19T15:16:53
2019-11-12T21:07:42
{ "title": [ -0.024093628, 0.010040283, -0.09118652, -0.043762207, 0.0065956116, -0.032470703, -0.028152466, 0.011856079, -0.013679504, 0.018737793, -0.016098022, -0.01361084, 0.020095825, -0.05621338, 0.0070152283, -0.018798828, -0.002855301, 0.0018548965, -0.032226562, -0.035247803, -0.011131287, -0.053710938, 0.003982544, 0.06744385, 0.02444458, 0.003490448, -0.11444092, 0.016799927, -0.035614014, -0.028900146, -0.0022945404, 0.055603027, 0.039276123, 0.021621704, -0.036071777, 0.005138397, -0.027542114, 0.019607544, 0.009925842, -0.010543823, -0.007797241, 0.015548706, -0.01374054, -0.051849365, -0.01802063, -0.0040283203, -0.048828125, -0.025238037, -0.0046653748, 0.07318115, -0.0038146973, 0.0034561157, -0.029464722, 0.028198242, 0.030014038, -0.010559082, -0.0057754517, 0.012924194, 0.04095459, 0.03225708, -0.010040283, -0.03463745, 0.019088745, -0.05380249, -0.012611389, -0.002855301, -0.029708862, 0.02494812, 0.07910156, 0.008956909, -0.04043579, 0.020889282, 0.0023326874, 0.0027542114, -0.044006348, -0.02659607, 0.06774902, 0.019348145, 0.0058517456, -0.025970459, -0.014335632, -0.022644043, 0.013504028, -0.013053894, -0.008842468, 0.008911133, -0.03439331, -0.006816864, -0.031707764, -0.013511658, -0.011222839, -0.030914307, -0.033050537, 0.030807495, 0.014122009, -0.032928467, -0.043273926, -0.058044434, 0.034576416, 0.017181396, 0.030197144, -0.028442383, 0.014587402, 0.001291275, 0.017715454, -0.003107071, -0.017303467, -0.023849487, 0.022964478, 0.021606445, -0.036010742, 0.009010315, 0.0002696514, -0.03842163, 0.010604858, 0.015090942, 0.008972168, 0.019210815, 0.02583313, 0.021987915, 0.02861023, 0.019638062, 0.02760315, 0.013038635, 0.022506714, 0.025100708, -0.039215088, -0.036895752, -0.02418518, 0.030044556, -0.015289307, 0.026870728, -0.060668945, -0.042541504, -0.057281494, 0.014175415, -0.019943237, 0.024505615, 0.0003631115, -0.00724411, 0.051727295, -0.039154053, -0.04006958, 0.025604248, -0.0017089844, 0.00932312, 0.053222656, 0.011886597, -0.06384277, -0.03982544, 0.0020198822, 0.0119018555, -0.0034008026, 0.029312134, -0.02331543, 0.029449463, -0.093933105, 0.0016784668, 0.006828308, 0.010406494, 0.072753906, 0.03894043, 0.015808105, 0.07989502, 0.08081055, -0.051727295, -0.000097990036, 0.0024795532, -0.0067596436, 0.0024147034, -0.02078247, 0.006210327, 0.02418518, -0.026123047, 0.0022201538, 0.022644043, -0.0023212433, -0.0013980865, 0.02923584, -0.02079773, 0.0021820068, -0.020141602, -0.006351471, 0.03591919, -0.018920898, -0.0053749084, -0.006427765, -0.03060913, 0.020233154, -0.013496399, -0.015312195, 0.046936035, -0.016296387, -0.027160645, -0.027450562, 0.0110321045, -0.0032196045, 0.026245117, -0.011940002, 0.0001629591, -0.052734375, 0.017059326, -0.042938232, 0.030822754, -0.020828247, -0.021072388, -0.014389038, 0.0309906, -0.03857422, 0.05908203, 0.038330078, 0.008552551, -0.017242432, -0.050109863, 0.009590149, -0.039794922, 0.032318115, 0.002910614, -0.003786087, -0.011459351, -0.039520264, 0.022445679, -0.017532349, 0.015289307, -0.019439697, 0.0033912659, -0.005130768, 0.0019226074, 0.008262634, 0.025497437, 0.066223145, -0.036987305, 0.023757935, 0.021957397, -0.0015478134, -0.0231781, 0.033416748, -0.046783447, 0.016708374, 0.028549194, 0.0024547577, -0.0073242188, -0.0019721985, 0.01928711, 0.04473877, -0.013000488, 0.0026474, 0.010009766, 0.03277588, -0.020187378, 0.01637268, -0.019058228, 0.07159424, -0.017364502, 0.038269043, 0.042236328, -0.005458832, 0.004638672, -0.008201599, -0.019729614, 0.024887085, 0.04284668, -0.017456055, 0.04272461, -0.07098389, 0.037750244, -0.03375244, 0.0058517456, -0.009735107, 0.04473877, 0.041229248, -0.039764404, 0.01586914, 0.0231781, -0.018127441, -0.04937744, -0.00032615662, 0.0025520325, 0.0019378662, -0.034484863, -0.03314209, -0.007713318, 0.009979248, -0.017166138, 0.033569336, -0.004257202, 0.0129470825, -0.041900635, -0.020721436, 0.012496948, 0.036621094, 0.041168213, 0.023132324, -0.013809204, 0.03829956, 0.014953613, 0.0736084, 0.062194824, -0.005493164, 0.018325806, -0.032409668, 0.004699707, -0.022354126, -0.0073127747, 0.0045318604, 0.026412964, 0.029556274, -0.032348633, -0.03604126, 0.032165527, -0.072143555, 0.0107421875, 0.01247406, -0.0056762695, -0.03326416, -0.054779053, -0.029953003, -0.015335083, -0.051513672, -0.011817932, 0.05630493, -0.012573242, 0.0058898926, -0.040985107, 0.0024490356, -0.025894165, -0.03552246, -0.028198242, -0.018081665, 0.025390625, 0.05407715, 0.01399231, -0.05532837, -0.028793335, 0.005706787, 0.033447266, 0.0040779114, -0.006290436, 0.011230469, 0.02494812, 0.06072998, 0.021957397, 0.010986328, -0.011924744, -0.0016593933, -0.024230957, 0.027191162, 0.005344391, -0.010475159, 0.022140503, 0.011566162, -0.020370483, -0.019958496, -0.009925842, 0.026107788, 0.0034942627, 0.01687622, -0.003358841, 0.021087646, -0.035247803, 0.036254883, -0.000028371811, -0.015258789, -0.066101074, -0.0063552856, -0.045043945, -0.013404846, -0.01259613, 0.008346558, 0.027374268, -0.024871826, -0.012870789, -0.018234253, -0.015182495, 0.0048179626, 0.0008363724, 0.009468079, -0.028671265, -0.02407837, -0.0067443848, -0.0022525787, 0.010154724, 0.0076026917, -0.00019276142, 0.08239746, -0.01902771, 0.003211975, -0.0065345764, 0.052093506, 0.0104904175, 0.010253906, -0.05126953, -0.03137207, 0.0014543533, -0.0017852783, -0.011390686, -0.025558472, -0.015281677, -0.05996704, -0.005012512, 0.13061523, -0.0055274963, -0.051818848, 0.06298828, -0.050476074, -0.017623901, 0.077819824, -0.010696411, 0.0057907104, 0.042388916, -0.02104187, -0.009300232, -0.0025520325, -0.022201538, 0.021453857, -0.038360596, -0.08392334, 0.021392822, -0.033721924, -0.005607605, -0.023147583, 0.066711426, -0.059265137, -0.002035141, 0.0021038055, 0.03463745, 0.025466919, -0.014045715, 0.019210815, 0.026641846, 0.02456665, -0.012496948, -0.028381348, -0.045959473, 0.0044021606, 0.004962921, 0.010597229, 0.027328491, 0.012428284, 0.015220642, -0.037200928, 0.011375427, 0.03338623, 0.03338623, 0.01637268, -0.01222229, -0.0005993843, -0.01637268, 0.027038574, 0.040161133, -0.023483276, -0.008285522, 0.018859863, 0.011413574, -0.040374756, 0.016342163, 0.008720398, 0.03186035, -0.02330017, -0.02067566, 0.021759033, -0.030883789, -0.014709473, 0.018203735, -0.0184021, 0.049316406, -0.041534424, 0.0041542053, -0.07696533, 0.020080566, -0.033111572, 0.030593872, 0.03857422, 0.00087451935, 0.00009995699, -0.0143585205, 0.0028743744, 0.008041382, -0.027328491, -0.030731201, -0.041625977, 0.035705566, -0.05215454, -0.046539307, 0.011917114, -0.005722046, -0.022827148, -0.045440674, 0.019073486, -0.013282776, -0.01939392, -0.056030273, 0.029968262, -0.022140503, -0.01826477, 0.023269653, -0.00793457, 0.054534912, 0.012016296, -0.0692749, -0.0034389496, 0.060455322, 0.0132751465, 0.015930176, 0.015930176, 0.034698486, -0.028213501, -0.00919342, 0.0026836395, -0.037231445, -0.0070877075, -0.029449463, 0.03967285, 0.046020508, -0.019104004, 0.016189575, 0.018676758, 0.020843506, -0.020706177, 0.02053833, 0.054534912, 0.053741455, -0.07458496, 0.023010254, 0.07562256, -0.0087890625, -0.10443115, 0.011245728, 0.026016235, -0.029388428, 0.016830444, -0.0027160645, 0.021652222, 0.05960083, -0.022750854, 0.018493652, -0.036071777, -0.03060913, 0.009895325, 0.0024299622, -0.009048462, 0.015350342, 0.024154663, 0.029312134, -0.0065956116, 0.044311523, 0.008308411, 0.03967285, -0.009651184, -0.018066406, 0.0014076233, 0.02444458, -0.026168823, -0.044799805, -0.058898926, -0.024978638, 0.016983032, -0.0058250427, 0.0209198, 0.017730713, 0.025543213, -0.010414124, -0.015670776, 0.01966858, 0.030197144, 0.008605957, -0.019256592, -0.06695557, -0.007381439, 0.011856079, -0.04751587, -0.029067993, -0.01927185, -0.02420044, 0.019332886, -0.026535034, 0.014549255, 0.010620117, 0.03555298, 0.03894043, 0.030258179, 0.0067367554, -0.04397583, -0.007068634, -0.026031494, -0.00034546852, 0.0181427, -0.01499176, -0.002696991, -0.011451721, 0.004501343, 0.0012044907, -0.03414917, -0.07513428, 0.016159058, 0.038330078, 0.017227173, 0.01739502, -0.017959595, 0.011444092, 0.01335144, 0.012275696, -0.0042533875, -0.024215698, -0.013679504, 0.026473999, 0.042938232, -0.00021767616, 0.02520752, 0.016082764, 0.034423828, -0.04711914, 0.0063705444, 0.056518555, 0.0149383545, -0.039031982, 0.00032043457, 0.00970459, -0.025863647, -0.0036411285, 0.0209198, -0.014862061, 0.03363037, -0.015777588, 0.043518066, -0.027069092, -0.0020542145, 0.01574707, 0.0059165955, 0.02330017, 0.004196167, 0.02027893, -0.079833984, -0.093688965, -0.05697632, 0.08282471, -0.023132324, -0.04333496, 0.01361084, -0.02192688, 0.009223938, 0.044067383, 0.0287323, 0.010681152, 0.012931824, 0.0073013306, 0.008857727, -0.02217102, -0.027236938, 0.0052757263, -0.009994507, -0.017990112, -0.027328491, -0.02848816, -0.023635864, -0.03643799, -0.03768921, -0.0037059784, 0.023284912, -0.016723633, -0.006500244, 0.06555176, 0.0062332153, 0.03527832, 0.038635254, 0.0035381317, 0.0067749023, 0.024765015, 0.006919861, 0.016693115, 0.026245117, -0.028900146, 0.02268982, 0.02494812, 0.02406311, 0.012397766, -0.0025978088, -0.00030088425, -0.007762909, -0.016296387, 0.013153076, -0.00554657, -0.01537323, 0.01725769, -0.036132812, 0.025756836, 0.009109497, -0.011703491, -0.019515991, -0.032196045, -0.065979004, -0.01675415, -0.04788208, -0.029205322, -0.005874634, -0.052947998, -0.040039062, -0.0038032532, 0.035095215, 0.012237549, 0.021011353, -0.015625, -0.032409668, -0.03173828, 0.00340271, 0.006160736, -0.014549255, -0.021606445, 0.0045547485, 0.012062073, -0.01399231, 0.01739502, -0.041625977, -0.013412476, -0.019485474, -0.045806885, -0.026519775, 0.016494751, 0.016448975, 0.005508423, 0.0058403015, 0.008010864, -0.016525269, -0.024169922, 0.019348145, -0.043426514, -0.021896362, 0.026062012, -0.012313843, 0.012863159, 0.013542175, 0.025543213, -0.0015573502, 0.011360168, 0.005970001, -0.034179688, 0.030639648, -0.02835083, -0.011360168, 0.011405945, -0.076538086, 0.036254883, 0.019180298, 0.015945435, 0.0107040405, -0.0008149147, 0.038482666, -0.0076141357, 0.0007362366, 0.014022827, 0.09490967, -0.08337402, 0.009567261, -0.024368286, 0.013999939, -0.052978516, -0.024673462, -0.000036537647, 0.022277832, -0.027282715, -0.058410645, -0.028961182, -0.015457153, 0.025665283, 0.016098022, 0.011444092, -0.021713257, 0.025009155, -0.05001831, -0.019454956, -0.02897644, 0.02319336, -0.024383545, -0.012939453, 0.043273926, -0.055603027, -0.002922058, -0.0101623535, 0.040649414, 0.007461548, -0.040802002, 0.039916992, -0.023757935, 0.01687622, -0.012619019, 0.026763916, 0.021713257, -0.0047340393, -0.023605347, -0.031158447, -0.021942139, 0.054534912, 0.03945923, 0.020904541, 0.058746338, 0.010925293, -0.0019550323, 0.0068969727, -0.043670654, -0.02067566, 0.041046143, -0.025253296, -0.032104492, -0.08123779, -0.06210327, -0.04953003, 0.00024008751, -0.010047913, 0.027816772, 0.013092041, -0.0008573532, 0.0031871796, 0.021896362, -0.00014531612, 0.013290405, 0.036254883, 0.02519226, 0.0028133392, 0.01676941, -0.0141067505, 0.022979736, 0.03994751, -0.011039734, 0.009468079, 0.0038909912, -0.03036499, 0.015792847, 0.0051116943, 0.026367188, -0.030166626, -0.013343811, -0.027236938, 0.014602661, 0.0009613037, 0.015396118, 0.042510986, 0.049316406, -0.045440674, 0.00024211407, 0.017501831, 0.04537964, -0.044952393, 0.05239868, 0.060913086, -0.04336548, 0.014755249, 0.0026683807, -0.03515625, 0.0058021545, 0.042419434, 0.033691406, -0.048706055, -0.0211792, 0.02796936, 0.016967773, 0.026123047, -0.008132935, -0.0446167, -0.04537964, 0.023422241, 0.0357666, -0.042785645, -0.010101318, 0.01927185, 0.029418945, 0.04534912, 0.024261475, 0.010734558, 0.027923584, 0.036071777, 0.044769287, -0.031051636, 0.03161621, 0.02319336, -0.029342651, 0.023513794, 0.03274536, -0.04156494, 0.009109497, 0.0004172325, 0.07513428, 0.024002075, 0.07183838, -0.008331299, 0.00085639954, 0.029266357, -0.013511658, 0.023910522, 0.033172607, -0.0362854, -0.027114868, -0.0056495667, -0.026824951, 0.011131287, -0.038146973, 0.018661499, 0.017318726, -0.0035858154, -0.050628662, 0.041046143, 0.021499634, -0.08276367, -0.004058838, -0.03024292, -0.042022705, 0.025848389, 0.032958984, -0.0055503845, -0.0078048706, -0.0027599335, 0.022262573, 0.024169922, 0.009986877, 0.042663574, -0.030456543, -0.035736084, -0.0050201416, -0.0030155182, 0.03866577, -0.029342651, 0.0022583008, -0.015548706, 0.02331543, -0.008148193, -0.010757446, -0.002609253, 0.04727173, -0.0309906, -0.043701172, 0.02218628, 0.017700195, -0.034973145, -0.07922363, -0.044189453, -0.014778137, -0.042938232, -0.026672363, 0.0473938, -0.0037155151, -0.07165527, -0.0019025803, -0.0524292, 0.03451538, 0.000623703, -0.012611389, -0.0072364807, 0.016693115, -0.018127441, 0.03463745, 0.017791748, 0.040985107, -0.042907715, -0.049041748, -0.039855957, 0.04751587, 0.057159424, -0.0012865067, -0.08654785, 0.04989624, 0.017150879, 0.011054993, 0.08081055, -0.0076293945, 0.01977539, 0.00011104345, 0.064697266, 0.019897461, -0.0262146, -0.044769287, -0.040161133, 0.07122803, 0.010971069, -0.030395508, -0.011779785, 0.033935547, -0.010772705, -0.009567261, 0.027862549, -0.0056533813, -0.016555786, 0.021896362, 0.017150879, -0.023727417, -0.037231445, -0.024337769, -0.006248474, 0.022598267, 0.054138184, -0.03491211, 0.031951904, -0.006340027, 0.024887085, 0.020904541, -0.043304443, 0.038970947, 0.04031372, 0.028564453, 0.0009007454, -0.009269714, -0.034851074, -0.004760742, -0.014160156, -0.018325806, 0.0116119385, 0.02027893, -0.014953613, 0.0073890686, -0.014427185, -0.044403076, -0.0013217926, -0.046813965, 0.064941406, -0.0637207, 0.041625977, -0.052642822, 0.029876709, 0.0054626465, 0.033843994, -0.04257202, 0.008460999, -0.03869629, -0.010734558, 0.011665344, -0.024353027 ], "summary": [ -0.019973755, 0.001531601, -0.06427002, -0.033843994, -0.021896362, -0.013771057, -0.047546387, 0.009239197, 0.012046814, 0.016616821, -0.0027370453, -0.013824463, 0.023162842, -0.047546387, 0.016723633, -0.0019006729, 0.0084991455, 0.008201599, 0.016143799, -0.036254883, 0.009864807, -0.04168701, 0.024795532, 0.07171631, -0.00818634, 0.014312744, -0.043518066, 0.04171753, -0.041625977, -0.009338379, 0.004043579, 0.03744507, 0.041534424, -0.007701874, -0.025299072, -0.01234436, 0.0044937134, 0.002319336, 0.0028858185, -0.0064315796, 0.019561768, -0.015960693, 0.034576416, -0.029327393, 0.014579773, 0.00013577938, 0.020690918, -0.038269043, 0.035705566, 0.08892822, -0.02128601, 0.0042419434, -0.05328369, 0.048187256, 0.0074882507, -0.019012451, -0.014717102, -0.0063819885, 0.011329651, 0.046661377, 0.00029349327, 0.002746582, -0.0022449493, -0.036499023, 0.005302429, -0.017623901, 0.00065755844, 0.029968262, 0.07019043, -0.0020370483, -0.049194336, 0.037597656, 0.0030841827, 0.004585266, -0.047943115, 0.006893158, 0.035064697, 0.022232056, 0.013587952, -0.0143966675, -0.032073975, -0.028137207, 0.016036987, -0.012039185, -0.019851685, 0.005756378, -0.036224365, -0.0033626556, -0.007522583, 0.008598328, -0.002614975, -0.034484863, -0.015930176, 0.06573486, 0.020263672, -0.024902344, -0.07244873, -0.12756348, 0.06286621, 0.032073975, 0.049560547, -0.052490234, 0.041931152, 0.0077667236, -0.008834839, -0.022857666, -0.03366089, -0.038604736, 0.012519836, 0.040802002, -0.033172607, -0.033172607, 0.016525269, -0.015617371, -0.006137848, -0.010322571, 0.00831604, 0.052337646, 0.012374878, 0.040283203, 0.015853882, 0.043121338, -0.0038032532, 0.04006958, -0.0051193237, 0.0030937195, 0.004940033, -0.049835205, -0.017501831, 0.019073486, -0.023132324, 0.016403198, -0.0127334595, 0.0020561218, -0.022277832, -0.009109497, 0.0088272095, 0.022781372, 0.034423828, -0.011421204, 0.024414062, -0.044525146, -0.028869629, 0.049346924, 0.013687134, 0.035614014, 0.039215088, -0.0010328293, -0.047821045, -0.04650879, 0.006111145, 0.0077400208, 0.011451721, 0.01876831, -0.020202637, -0.008407593, -0.041137695, -0.011581421, 0.0017089844, -0.0016975403, 0.07861328, 0.024398804, 0.011497498, 0.09863281, 0.04611206, -0.02897644, -0.0016374588, -0.014503479, 0.0020313263, -0.02508545, -0.008735657, -0.0017347336, 0.010063171, -0.0023880005, 0.023468018, 0.027648926, -0.04421997, 0.01210022, 0.049865723, -0.0395813, -0.020904541, -0.028305054, 0.010917664, 0.020751953, -0.009475708, -0.0057754517, 0.005455017, -0.0033302307, 0.0068893433, 0.0028419495, -0.0065307617, 0.029678345, -0.021530151, 0.006000519, -0.034454346, -0.0005173683, -0.03527832, 0.0236969, -0.031143188, 0.00064754486, 0.013694763, 0.023147583, -0.014404297, 0.010681152, -0.0473938, 0.01586914, -0.011520386, 0.025009155, -0.024734497, 0.03778076, 0.011680603, -0.003522873, -0.015289307, -0.009490967, 0.030227661, 0.014167786, 0.040039062, -0.000746727, 0.017745972, 0.01486969, -0.0121536255, 0.03491211, -0.01928711, 0.017349243, -0.01638794, -0.002067566, -0.020248413, 0.01058197, -0.009277344, 0.0017499924, 0.04437256, -0.0010719299, 0.03768921, 0.0070495605, 0.012237549, 0.015159607, 0.053833008, -0.07904053, -0.00011950731, 0.041015625, 0.024749756, 0.020904541, -0.02986145, -0.03567505, -0.0047912598, -0.012748718, 0.011314392, -0.030075073, -0.0021438599, -0.043762207, -0.014717102, -0.041656494, 0.0491333, -0.045715332, 0.035308838, 0.018997192, 0.0041389465, -0.020645142, -0.012504578, 0.008132935, 0.01927185, 0.038757324, -0.02909851, 0.041046143, -0.066833496, -0.0018310547, -0.028060913, -0.006752014, 0.01071167, -0.017547607, 0.015914917, -0.023971558, 0.012275696, -0.015655518, -0.052886963, -0.055786133, 0.004207611, 0.010795593, 0.022125244, -0.044067383, -0.0017242432, 0.022247314, -0.008377075, -0.015464783, 0.025482178, 0.021102905, -0.0076065063, 0.006679535, 0.012191772, 0.059265137, 0.05291748, 0.01612854, 0.010269165, 0.007499695, 0.023727417, 0.0008840561, 0.05493164, 0.040130615, -0.013053894, -0.0023174286, 0.014785767, 0.009712219, -0.023513794, -0.02053833, -0.0029010773, -0.009254456, 0.024612427, -0.010246277, -0.014465332, -0.00066280365, -0.06976318, -0.02670288, 0.038238525, 0.05218506, -0.007911682, -0.02243042, -0.015403748, 0.04446411, -0.029541016, -0.027679443, 0.041625977, 0.0024795532, 0.01651001, -0.020980835, 0.0060806274, -0.0259552, -0.007083893, -0.022079468, 0.0060653687, -0.021392822, -0.0044021606, -0.032226562, -0.053344727, -0.019210815, 0.008384705, 0.005382538, 0.012054443, 0.028167725, 0.01713562, 0.013252258, 0.07287598, 0.015289307, 0.0001770258, 0.025466919, -0.028884888, 0.0113220215, 0.012008667, 0.01763916, 0.020828247, 0.01625061, -0.004737854, -0.006679535, -0.006389618, 0.012145996, -0.003162384, 0.05041504, 0.020080566, -0.029785156, 0.011238098, -0.070495605, 0.022994995, 0.0040512085, -0.0368042, -0.081848145, 0.022644043, -0.023162842, -0.016052246, -0.031204224, 0.040405273, 0.027053833, -0.009414673, 0.012237549, -0.010879517, -0.01374054, 0.03640747, -0.006313324, 0.04147339, -0.024658203, -0.001832962, 0.02166748, -0.016143799, -0.008598328, 0.021972656, -0.0049934387, 0.09741211, -0.0033836365, 0.011566162, -0.0063438416, 0.08685303, 0.020721436, 0.02319336, -0.051971436, 0.01411438, -0.028152466, -0.00018703938, 0.009017944, -0.04525757, -0.05090332, -0.00434494, -0.011764526, 0.09661865, -0.025741577, -0.04055786, 0.030838013, -0.0029792786, -0.021728516, 0.08984375, -0.005405426, 0.010169983, -0.020690918, 0.0015268326, -0.018753052, -0.017089844, -0.022720337, -0.014503479, -0.042541504, -0.041656494, -0.009712219, -0.016998291, 0.017715454, -0.019210815, 0.060424805, -0.009979248, 0.031921387, 0.0037555695, 0.012763977, -0.016555786, -0.018249512, 0.027694702, 0.04525757, 0.001953125, 0.012763977, -0.028137207, -0.021469116, 0.0027656555, -0.00919342, -0.0017900467, 0.0005726814, 0.011375427, -0.013381958, -0.022918701, -0.0003156662, 0.03643799, 0.031799316, -0.0057258606, 0.01991272, -0.010398865, -0.0062828064, 0.023162842, 0.050842285, -0.0129852295, -0.0037517548, 0.061553955, 0.03286743, -0.031188965, -0.013450623, -0.023529053, 0.029632568, -0.007381439, -0.009925842, 0.011016846, -0.020126343, 0.0018358231, 0.003490448, -0.0022697449, 0.09674072, -0.10028076, 0.032165527, -0.07519531, 0.018859863, 0.03488159, -0.014785767, 0.029449463, -0.020584106, -0.011657715, -0.057281494, 0.038604736, 0.0056114197, 0.0056877136, -0.056121826, -0.05230713, 0.04397583, -0.0569458, -0.029144287, 0.013450623, -0.0021209717, -0.014099121, -0.06085205, 0.005420685, 0.024124146, -0.022094727, -0.023147583, 0.01448822, -0.00091695786, -0.03366089, 0.045898438, 0.0011835098, 0.05166626, 0.015113831, -0.04321289, -0.0059127808, 0.003238678, -0.02949524, 0.0035915375, -0.050476074, 0.039154053, 0.036315918, -0.005680084, -0.0033302307, -0.08465576, 0.0062942505, -0.058746338, 0.03289795, 0.040252686, -0.021942139, 0.0009126663, -0.009307861, 0.019195557, -0.047912598, 0.005458832, 0.036712646, 0.05996704, -0.053649902, 0.010269165, 0.055511475, -0.023162842, -0.050811768, 0.019241333, 0.0072517395, -0.009552002, 0.053527832, 0.011604309, 0.025527954, 0.024536133, -0.028625488, -0.017684937, -0.035827637, -0.049804688, 0.006336212, 0.028015137, -0.014457703, -0.0031166077, 0.0146865845, 0.06097412, -0.004585266, 0.030303955, 0.010475159, 0.05935669, -0.011421204, -0.0006284714, 0.0015678406, 0.011444092, 0.009597778, -0.07946777, -0.04083252, 0.016784668, 0.07385254, -0.038879395, 0.003709793, 0.044189453, -0.012916565, 0.000041604042, -0.008476257, 0.02268982, 0.023971558, 0.016677856, -0.018249512, -0.05618286, 0.02796936, 0.020095825, -0.023498535, -0.025680542, -0.0703125, -0.066345215, -0.019241333, -0.008956909, 0.0023460388, 0.015975952, 0.007751465, 0.030212402, 0.026809692, -0.015335083, -0.050750732, -0.017807007, -0.026062012, 0.007896423, -0.008720398, -0.02027893, -0.02734375, -0.0067977905, 0.007484436, 0.004688263, -0.023895264, -0.06854248, 0.0058174133, 0.009117126, 0.025283813, 0.03869629, 0.030059814, 0.023101807, 0.019088745, 0.02734375, 0.011161804, 0.0038108826, -0.039916992, 0.027938843, 0.02520752, 0.0025291443, 0.02003479, 0.024627686, 0.026687622, -0.09210205, 0.007904053, 0.07849121, 0.010139465, -0.04296875, 0.012527466, -0.026779175, 0.013687134, 0.0104522705, 0.048736572, -0.00081920624, 0.03704834, 0.04916382, 0.004333496, 0.023956299, 0.009757996, 0.028396606, 0.00025343895, 0.0074806213, 0.0049362183, -0.013847351, -0.07305908, -0.11608887, -0.039489746, 0.120666504, -0.0030460358, -0.024932861, 0.004558563, -0.028442383, 0.0051612854, 0.02619934, 0.010795593, -0.009590149, 0.0010929108, -0.010848999, -0.014282227, -0.00440979, -0.0065727234, -0.03286743, 0.0020580292, -0.029541016, 0.003835678, -0.047576904, 0.0035133362, -0.050811768, -0.030960083, 0.021972656, 0.011672974, -0.009239197, -0.03302002, 0.043640137, 0.0046310425, 0.019515991, 0.07623291, -0.027572632, 0.0015449524, -0.0069885254, -0.012283325, 0.03161621, -0.043426514, -0.035369873, 0.015357971, -0.0030136108, -0.019210815, 0.0010461807, 0.005958557, -0.0007791519, -0.0025405884, 0.003627777, -0.0024929047, -0.040100098, 0.006969452, 0.005821228, -0.029556274, 0.015335083, 0.018112183, 0.01374054, 0.0036029816, 0.021896362, -0.040985107, -0.019805908, 0.0044136047, -0.0287323, -0.019683838, -0.010070801, 0.0020484924, 0.02671814, 0.023147583, -0.019805908, 0.050354004, 0.011871338, -0.06100464, -0.009788513, -0.024658203, 0.020111084, -0.017089844, 0.0021572113, -0.01184082, 0.020721436, -0.02255249, -0.015930176, -0.011184692, -0.012886047, -0.0087509155, -0.032592773, -0.011123657, -0.0017232895, -0.006225586, 0.030899048, 0.00554657, 0.030761719, -0.010551453, -0.048614502, 0.017211914, -0.05404663, -0.0017223358, 0.03262329, 0.00030612946, 0.006626129, 0.025939941, 0.018463135, -0.018310547, 0.0044517517, 0.018249512, -0.06311035, 0.0025177002, -0.0058021545, -0.035308838, 0.0181427, -0.01828003, 0.0010910034, 0.019119263, -0.008575439, 0.012290955, -0.010696411, 0.023956299, -0.0039901733, -0.024017334, -0.0072402954, 0.040100098, -0.037628174, -0.0074691772, -0.017730713, 0.031402588, -0.04067993, -0.056427002, -0.0063438416, 0.003047943, -0.0036449432, -0.048339844, 0.013000488, 0.012901306, 0.006095886, 0.0463562, 0.041748047, -0.004951477, 0.04284668, -0.006454468, -0.03289795, -0.027908325, 0.011878967, -0.023208618, -0.021820068, 0.07733154, -0.04812622, 0.006790161, 0.026947021, 0.020736694, -0.008972168, -0.04827881, 0.03161621, -0.005302429, 0.032562256, -0.022628784, 0.04257202, -0.0044059753, 0.027832031, -0.02368164, -0.033294678, -0.0061035156, 0.014945984, 0.024414062, -0.030151367, 0.01991272, 0.005241394, -0.008628845, -0.015853882, -0.071899414, -0.019256592, 0.020019531, -0.0052833557, -0.086242676, -0.088134766, -0.059051514, -0.013801575, 0.010192871, -0.05130005, -0.035888672, 0.029037476, -0.008995056, -0.027633667, 0.028640747, -0.02218628, 0.049438477, -0.015144348, 0.021820068, -0.008041382, 0.05633545, -0.01146698, -0.01878357, 0.038970947, -0.016342163, 0.018157959, 0.021987915, -0.029708862, 0.041137695, -0.028549194, 0.023361206, -0.023132324, -0.001783371, -0.018234253, 0.025756836, 0.026947021, 0.048583984, -0.0031204224, 0.008201599, 0.029586792, -0.026046753, -0.0051841736, 0.06970215, -0.03274536, 0.07824707, 0.045928955, -0.015357971, 0.017227173, 0.027389526, -0.026062012, 0.013877869, -0.0034542084, 0.06604004, -0.048217773, -0.042114258, 0.029846191, 0.014289856, -0.023406982, 0.011550903, -0.03451538, -0.04776001, 0.015289307, 0.033416748, -0.04043579, -0.011306763, 0.016204834, 0.010482788, 0.04788208, 0.013702393, 0.03768921, 0.009773254, 0.070007324, 0.046813965, -0.03262329, 0.0073127747, 0.0256958, -0.0050621033, 0.006965637, 0.035003662, -0.028198242, 0.03768921, 0.01512146, 0.09338379, 0.033813477, 0.07421875, -0.026748657, 0.0079956055, 0.07531738, 0.031066895, -0.014884949, -0.01626587, -0.022445679, -0.027023315, -0.0017223358, 0.018325806, -0.0050964355, -0.028717041, -0.023361206, 0.022537231, 0.024261475, -0.057922363, 0.07757568, -0.06512451, -0.07092285, 0.045135498, -0.0012178421, -0.038085938, 0.031158447, 0.047088623, -0.010498047, 0.024002075, -0.015625, -0.02999878, 0.015144348, -0.0044937134, 0.029678345, -0.012619019, -0.0044288635, -0.040863037, 0.0093688965, -0.005065918, -0.007549286, -0.007030487, 0.019439697, 0.016952515, -0.017700195, -0.009979248, 0.0074157715, 0.019104004, -0.033843994, -0.054016113, 0.036010742, 0.022994995, -0.024291992, -0.06402588, -0.014457703, -0.018737793, -0.036254883, 0.0026721954, 0.03692627, 0.00086402893, -0.013008118, 0.014633179, -0.036865234, 0.00554657, -0.022216797, -0.00166893, 0.00017488003, 0.031341553, -0.009056091, 0.037750244, 0.029266357, 0.031585693, -0.05441284, -0.06097412, 0.015823364, 0.022842407, 0.059295654, 0.03564453, -0.032684326, 0.05142212, -0.042999268, 0.026550293, 0.058044434, -0.03567505, 0.010215759, -0.0029735565, 0.080322266, 0.022018433, -0.037078857, -0.043701172, -0.046905518, 0.034729004, 0.01361084, -0.014915466, -0.018341064, 0.047210693, -0.006088257, -0.016708374, 0.05368042, -0.02330017, -0.00491333, 0.017425537, 0.022125244, -0.024383545, -0.028030396, 0.02017212, -0.029891968, 0.015556335, 0.012763977, -0.025115967, 0.0087890625, -0.025558472, 0.0073394775, 0.021209717, -0.00141716, -0.017486572, 0.019958496, 0.021408081, -0.037841797, -0.012123108, -0.011756897, 0.009048462, -0.034729004, -0.019317627, -0.04650879, 0.018554688, -0.015335083, -0.035461426, 0.033233643, -0.046142578, -0.009559631, -0.04260254, 0.021636963, -0.061035156, 0.047668457, -0.011520386, 0.0206604, 0.023925781, 0.0019464493, -0.0015583038, 0.016830444, -0.014457703, 0.008621216, -0.016174316, 0.0028934479 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1911.07605v4
Commit2Vec: Learning Distributed Representations of Code Changes
Rocìo Cabrera Lozoya, Arnaud Baumann, Antonino Sabetta, Michele Bezzi
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.LG
Deep learning methods, which have found successful applications in fields like image classification and natural language processing, have recently been applied to source code analysis too, due to the enormous amount of freely available source code (e.g., from open-source software repositories). In this work, we elaborate upon a state-of-the-art approach to the representation of source code that uses information about its syntactic structure, and we adapt it to represent source changes (i.e., commits). We use this representation to classify security-relevant commits. Because our method uses transfer learning (that is, we train a network on a "pretext task" for which abundant labeled data is available, and then we use such network for the target task of commit classification, for which fewer labeled instances are available), we studied the impact of pre-training the network using two different pretext tasks versus a randomly initialized model. Our results indicate that representations that leverage the structural information obtained through code syntax outperform token-based representations. Furthermore, the performance metrics obtained when pre-training on a loosely related pretext task with a very large dataset ($>10^6$ samples) were surpassed when pretraining on a smaller dataset ($>10^4$ samples) but for a pretext task that is more closely related to the target task.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1911.07605v4
2021-11-17T16:53:07
2019-11-18T13:23:57
{ "title": [ -0.039093018, -0.024673462, -0.05706787, -0.088256836, 0.0074882507, 0.002670288, -0.052368164, 0.040100098, 0.014152527, 0.01828003, -0.03488159, 0.015541077, -0.015777588, -0.008460999, -0.023345947, 0.0017547607, 0.00018644333, 0.011657715, -0.021697998, -0.037139893, -0.014518738, -0.024368286, 0.05505371, 0.04159546, 0.039398193, -0.032165527, -0.04156494, 0.03274536, -0.022918701, -0.025558472, -0.0047950745, -0.0027923584, 0.035064697, 0.034423828, -0.037017822, 0.002828598, -0.03112793, 0.01272583, -0.010276794, 0.033233643, 0.032989502, -0.004463196, 0.0036296844, -0.051940918, -0.014312744, 0.025436401, -0.05569458, -0.038879395, -0.004459381, 0.016738892, 0.018173218, 0.044891357, -0.0028839111, 0.02658081, 0.0155181885, -0.030563354, -0.031799316, -0.00045847893, 0.0357666, 0.068481445, 0.018188477, -0.050964355, 0.018203735, -0.02973938, -0.053588867, -0.018447876, 0.018737793, 0.011451721, 0.04547119, -0.029525757, -0.009292603, 0.033172607, 0.0012998581, 0.00724411, -0.037200928, -0.012641907, 0.05343628, 0.008201599, 0.018585205, -0.005908966, 0.018920898, 0.009292603, -0.0046463013, -0.0064468384, 0.01158905, -0.03173828, -0.0104904175, -0.026168823, -0.045074463, -0.05847168, -0.0090789795, 0.0033130646, -0.04837036, -0.0041618347, -0.008125305, -0.01676941, -0.011146545, 0.03475952, -0.014755249, -0.019729614, -0.03515625, 0.030899048, -0.042236328, -0.019958496, 0.009422302, 0.0016403198, -0.014518738, -0.035491943, 0.0013198853, 0.04208374, -0.036315918, 0.032318115, 0.0034008026, -0.003206253, 0.0066452026, 0.013046265, -0.012687683, 0.024139404, 0.0016183853, 0.028686523, -0.0032978058, -0.02720642, -0.017654419, -0.000032186508, 0.038726807, -0.004016876, -0.04925537, 0.02748108, -0.0045394897, 0.009544373, -0.0055503845, 0.047332764, -0.079711914, -0.07128906, -0.052459717, 0.041503906, -0.030883789, -0.002828598, -0.021347046, 0.01991272, -0.023117065, -0.023727417, 0.019012451, -0.02658081, 0.009857178, 0.026779175, 0.06451416, -0.0076789856, -0.049926758, -0.02859497, -0.033966064, 0.019744873, 0.030044556, 0.00046133995, -0.03640747, -0.023025513, -0.09161377, -0.01626587, 0.030883789, 0.00043201447, 0.008888245, -0.01739502, 0.000002682209, 0.019805908, 0.021606445, 0.030319214, -0.008003235, 0.00680542, 0.011543274, 0.025558472, -0.031799316, 0.00019848347, 0.037902832, -0.0024700165, -0.0154418945, 0.01725769, 0.008666992, 0.029876709, 0.021026611, -0.023086548, 0.014755249, -0.026779175, 0.009811401, 0.05429077, -0.042877197, -0.019332886, 0.007534027, -0.014625549, 0.026763916, 0.009803772, -0.016311646, 0.03552246, -0.031402588, -0.04437256, -0.036712646, 0.0010232925, 0.018844604, 0.05444336, -0.0054969788, -0.011245728, -0.04650879, 0.001420021, -0.018676758, 0.021652222, -0.026779175, -0.009643555, -0.035247803, 0.03543091, -0.036987305, 0.046295166, 0.06463623, 0.0054855347, -0.03881836, 0.037231445, 0.004436493, -0.07299805, 0.011108398, -0.031021118, 0.005882263, -0.02079773, -0.004852295, 0.038085938, 0.0012168884, 0.023498535, 0.014877319, -0.011352539, 0.0021400452, -0.026123047, 0.023986816, 0.0151901245, 0.06185913, -0.04373169, 0.04522705, 0.022705078, -0.004711151, -0.039855957, -0.0041236877, -0.055145264, 0.0146865845, 0.03942871, -0.014175415, -0.013618469, -0.028701782, 0.024169922, 0.053649902, 0.033416748, 0.013595581, 0.024932861, 0.00831604, 0.02432251, 0.046173096, 0.01638794, 0.038208008, -0.036834717, 0.01159668, 0.05117798, 0.006793976, -0.021316528, -0.016464233, 0.032684326, 0.0060653687, -0.013557434, -0.022201538, 0.0055236816, -0.061523438, 0.028121948, -0.036956787, 0.0077781677, -0.018173218, 0.018341064, 0.042816162, 0.003692627, 0.01965332, 0.007507324, 0.02357483, 0.02017212, -0.011039734, -0.0042800903, 0.029022217, -0.039489746, -0.028839111, 0.005428314, 0.022445679, -0.014404297, 0.032409668, 0.00919342, -0.017608643, -0.0859375, -0.015022278, 0.0018253326, 0.04800415, 0.053741455, 0.003818512, 0.008987427, 0.007232666, 0.009231567, 0.12207031, 0.09466553, -0.056427002, 0.054626465, -0.030532837, 0.010925293, 0.014518738, -0.046569824, 0.005554199, 0.061767578, 0.03677368, -0.013366699, -0.049682617, 0.033721924, -0.06744385, -0.016464233, 0.0058937073, -0.008529663, -0.06854248, -0.06518555, 0.003932953, -0.048736572, -0.046569824, -0.025970459, 0.06781006, -0.0012617111, -0.02229309, 0.009300232, 0.0059814453, -0.01612854, 0.005355835, -0.03186035, -0.013168335, 0.032958984, 0.0357666, 0.036132812, -0.04397583, -0.019378662, -0.015777588, 0.010696411, -0.013191223, -0.0005030632, -0.025253296, 0.0071144104, 0.022567749, -0.0050201416, 0.02960205, -0.026870728, -0.0034618378, -0.075805664, 0.015159607, 0.012786865, -0.04928589, -0.02218628, 0.05340576, -0.029159546, -0.021652222, 0.0058059692, 0.047424316, 0.010185242, -0.015930176, 0.016494751, 0.03741455, -0.023345947, 0.028030396, 0.020553589, 0.001405716, -0.06359863, -0.020904541, -0.040649414, -0.014328003, -0.0053710938, -0.0011491776, 0.062683105, -0.012611389, -0.021728516, -0.036315918, -0.0076675415, 0.010360718, -0.0072288513, 0.0018520355, -0.027267456, -0.025405884, -0.01637268, 0.0014104843, 0.011787415, -0.027542114, -0.009635925, 0.093688965, -0.0129470825, -0.01777649, 0.03768921, 0.021652222, -0.0009937286, -0.022155762, -0.0068626404, -0.03253174, 0.011695862, 0.010498047, -0.0020389557, 0.011192322, -0.013679504, -0.09234619, -0.012077332, 0.037353516, 0.01777649, -0.019119263, 0.036315918, -0.06939697, 0.03173828, 0.0027561188, -0.014060974, 0.022903442, 0.051849365, 0.021057129, -0.0038452148, 0.02961731, -0.04159546, 0.0069465637, -0.04534912, -0.12646484, 0.024597168, -0.046813965, 0.008918762, 0.007160187, -0.036499023, -0.055023193, 0.004299164, -0.0040512085, 0.054382324, -0.0012369156, 0.011695862, 0.0029258728, -0.024169922, -0.0034599304, -0.0368042, -0.012939453, -0.0043182373, -0.040740967, 0.02130127, 0.0020599365, 0.05001831, 0.048858643, -0.023742676, -0.023529053, -0.0026550293, 0.013969421, 0.016647339, 0.007987976, -0.029891968, 0.0018758774, 0.0061569214, 0.0074539185, 0.013069153, -0.020462036, -0.009689331, -0.0032444, 0.0068893433, -0.020751953, 0.012336731, 0.043884277, 0.0032310486, -0.016815186, -0.02319336, 0.018829346, -0.017913818, -0.060302734, 0.0014839172, 0.01991272, 0.01524353, -0.012001038, 0.0131073, -0.022247314, 0.012962341, -0.00060272217, -0.0027770996, -0.0059661865, -0.008377075, -0.012145996, 0.000259161, 0.008773804, -0.0052108765, 0.007572174, 0.004196167, 0.01109314, 0.0010986328, -0.029342651, -0.030075073, 0.011352539, -0.01751709, -0.09246826, -0.016235352, 0.0206604, -0.019042969, -0.02229309, -0.059814453, 0.031951904, -0.022598267, -0.019012451, 0.024108887, -0.016525269, -0.011619568, 0.004043579, -0.06402588, -0.0019330978, 0.07623291, 0.013656616, 0.00283432, 0.032104492, -0.0073242188, -0.031585693, -0.02633667, 0.026535034, 0.0040359497, 0.02470398, -0.014297485, -0.013771057, 0.03048706, -0.039367676, 0.049224854, 0.00066661835, 0.019058228, -0.009010315, -0.0031089783, 0.02758789, 0.0049858093, -0.033599854, 0.046325684, 0.028564453, -0.021636963, -0.07165527, -0.0019817352, 0.003288269, 0.013824463, 0.0045204163, -0.0061531067, 0.03753662, 0.015434265, 0.0038204193, 0.028503418, -0.007965088, 0.010559082, 0.049743652, -0.011390686, -0.0074386597, 0.014701843, 0.028503418, 0.008399963, 0.000063955784, 0.019638062, -0.008575439, 0.02619934, -0.0231781, -0.030853271, -0.0033626556, 0.018569946, -0.03665161, -0.0011081696, -0.047210693, -0.020645142, -0.01991272, 0.009300232, -0.023117065, 0.01802063, 0.0435791, -0.017501831, -0.005378723, -0.0060768127, 0.043884277, -0.01084137, 0.027282715, -0.052490234, -0.019638062, 0.019363403, -0.066345215, -0.02633667, -0.022872925, -0.01651001, 0.026763916, -0.013374329, -0.037200928, 0.017181396, 0.01638794, 0.10003662, 0.040039062, 0.0027828217, -0.0770874, 0.04272461, -0.009269714, 0.016433716, 0.0009899139, 0.009918213, 0.011894226, -0.013504028, -0.0052871704, -0.011650085, -0.030212402, -0.007003784, 0.032714844, 0.007007599, 0.036468506, -0.005996704, 0.052947998, 0.026519775, -0.015182495, 0.030166626, 0.015602112, -0.031585693, -0.009849548, 0.032043457, 0.050598145, -0.03173828, 0.0287323, 0.028137207, 0.013679504, -0.022109985, -0.0024490356, 0.04135132, 0.001789093, -0.022064209, 0.0027637482, 0.025924683, -0.03326416, -0.01902771, 0.008903503, 0.0061416626, 0.050872803, -0.02468872, 0.06359863, -0.010116577, 0.018112183, 0.026947021, -0.0056266785, 0.009979248, -0.025375366, 0.014533997, -0.04046631, -0.0770874, -0.0027980804, 0.04977417, -0.0038051605, 0.0006427765, -0.00081443787, 0.019836426, 0.038726807, 0.022018433, 0.008087158, -0.014915466, -0.02999878, -0.018096924, -0.005088806, -0.013282776, -0.06738281, -0.0029449463, -0.01083374, 0.029769897, -0.008766174, 0.023757935, -0.07611084, 0.003074646, -0.011199951, -0.012870789, 0.014930725, -0.08929443, -0.008682251, 0.064575195, 0.04824829, 0.009346008, 0.0017089844, 0.006729126, 0.0052108765, 0.050231934, -0.015914917, 0.032043457, 0.031173706, -0.06439209, -0.027832031, 0.008590698, 0.020141602, -0.01348114, 0.027648926, 0.026428223, -0.011108398, -0.063964844, 0.034179688, 0.031280518, 0.004951477, 0.0022792816, -0.048583984, 0.016189575, -0.017227173, 0.0211792, -0.0020580292, -0.040374756, -0.03466797, -0.031555176, -0.017471313, -0.07489014, 0.032562256, -0.027130127, -0.0368042, -0.043884277, 0.01977539, -0.023727417, 0.0025691986, 0.013282776, -0.006374359, -0.033996582, -0.013084412, 0.041168213, -0.03186035, 0.047332764, -0.025146484, 0.013336182, 0.05493164, 0.01864624, 0.011001587, 0.007331848, -0.049835205, -0.046447754, -0.068237305, -0.026748657, -0.012382507, 0.045196533, -0.012962341, -0.030395508, 0.0061569214, -0.0033130646, 0.023468018, 0.009735107, -0.024520874, 0.031280518, -0.0026474, -0.011474609, 0.00881958, -0.00007802248, -0.00025510788, 0.016220093, -0.008720398, 0.0024471283, 0.023605347, -0.0035266876, -0.00087213516, 0.009986877, -0.055664062, -0.003622055, 0.028076172, 0.026306152, -0.005332947, -0.0046844482, 0.035491943, -0.009361267, 0.013412476, 0.003435135, 0.080444336, -0.052825928, 0.015716553, 0.021881104, 0.017929077, 0.0035800934, 0.039398193, -0.021011353, 0.0048103333, -0.04550171, -0.027740479, -0.024795532, 0.0071792603, 0.020843506, 0.00007849932, 0.049957275, -0.06518555, -0.01210022, -0.009269714, -0.02720642, -0.043640137, 0.013809204, -0.0037155151, -0.0155181885, 0.047576904, -0.007835388, -0.0046081543, -0.014984131, 0.02166748, 0.0014781952, -0.0077171326, 0.021148682, -0.015281677, 0.019500732, -0.023864746, -0.031066895, 0.034240723, -0.0028839111, 0.0054092407, 0.019210815, -0.017669678, 0.051849365, 0.029632568, 0.060455322, 0.056488037, -0.0067214966, -0.007648468, 0.006099701, -0.022994995, -0.054351807, 0.037017822, -0.04345703, -0.009346008, -0.06530762, -0.03201294, -0.08331299, -0.014129639, 0.022033691, 0.025375366, 0.015731812, 0.011734009, 0.020584106, 0.018096924, 0.038909912, -0.023727417, 0.04727173, 0.0501709, 0.027954102, -0.013175964, -0.012016296, 0.013381958, 0.021469116, 0.013923645, 0.013336182, 0.026992798, -0.028137207, 0.00069856644, 0.049316406, 0.022750854, -0.012329102, 0.0038814545, -0.028152466, 0.01007843, -0.019729614, 0.02142334, 0.066345215, 0.039916992, -0.013931274, -0.016143799, 0.013175964, -0.029647827, -0.0138168335, -0.010673523, 0.021942139, -0.06677246, 0.025314331, -0.0049972534, -0.0052757263, 0.005317688, 0.006652832, 0.050445557, -0.058135986, -0.027069092, 0.009277344, 0.0440979, -0.01928711, -0.021972656, -0.03955078, -0.0025959015, 0.05368042, 0.03475952, -0.02520752, 0.0028209686, 0.009033203, 0.016021729, -0.012672424, -0.014808655, 0.010147095, 0.037628174, -0.0063209534, 0.027267456, -0.044830322, 0.03656006, -0.020996094, -0.022521973, -0.0017929077, 0.0042800903, -0.07501221, -0.017745972, 0.05596924, 0.030639648, 0.037902832, 0.0748291, 0.009597778, -0.009429932, -0.014328003, -0.045959473, 0.037353516, 0.014312744, -0.034698486, 0.014251709, -0.031921387, -0.027282715, 0.031463623, -0.027542114, 0.06097412, -0.059661865, 0.01878357, -0.012641907, 0.009567261, 0.03744507, -0.04550171, -0.038604736, -0.0041542053, -0.027267456, -0.0049819946, -0.007160187, -0.027420044, -0.030838013, -0.020736694, 0.03225708, -0.008224487, 0.000049591064, 0.008979797, -0.023162842, -0.06976318, 0.0059013367, -0.043182373, 0.053619385, -0.027938843, -0.0054779053, -0.0026988983, -0.0031871796, 0.0044822693, -0.020904541, -0.038909912, 0.01737976, -0.019607544, -0.047424316, 0.0057640076, 0.0067977905, -0.032287598, -0.031799316, -0.06915283, 0.017929077, -0.032958984, -0.013496399, 0.023208618, -0.04916382, -0.018432617, -0.003118515, -0.018356323, 0.049957275, 0.04788208, -0.008041382, 0.039398193, -0.0010309219, -0.018218994, 0.017303467, 0.020202637, 0.040802002, -0.009399414, -0.0713501, 0.017349243, 0.045715332, 0.066223145, -0.01335907, -0.003665924, 0.043426514, -0.0019311905, 0.0049934387, 0.049560547, 0.015296936, -0.007411957, 0.01979065, 0.023773193, 0.016601562, -0.03640747, -0.024795532, -0.0090408325, 0.03213501, 0.050720215, -0.00013685226, -0.015388489, 0.047302246, -0.03414917, -0.018096924, 0.009902954, -0.017028809, -0.01687622, 0.012458801, 0.010932922, -0.017410278, -0.03112793, -0.052947998, 0.024261475, 0.016555786, 0.078308105, -0.015357971, 0.01210022, 0.0287323, 0.10974121, -0.0079193115, -0.055358887, 0.021575928, 0.03378296, 0.019638062, 0.06561279, -0.04284668, -0.04925537, -0.0067596436, -0.011314392, -0.018005371, 0.0045166016, 0.023422241, -0.038970947, 0.0014743805, -0.022262573, -0.037475586, -0.027557373, -0.025939941, 0.030685425, -0.060455322, 0.018478394, -0.02507019, -0.022491455, -0.01763916, 0.014450073, 0.024230957, -0.057281494, -0.03213501, 0.0060310364, 0.07220459, -0.0012178421 ], "summary": [ 0.00843811, -0.024963379, -0.04156494, -0.04373169, -0.0418396, -0.0154800415, -0.042816162, 0.014465332, 0.028503418, 0.0040626526, -0.03387451, -0.022537231, -0.016052246, -0.027038574, 0.0146484375, -0.036865234, 0.029922485, -0.018997192, 0.02571106, -0.014266968, 0.0031795502, 0.0059814453, 0.057281494, -0.035369873, 0.03503418, -0.08721924, 0.039245605, 0.00006407499, 0.05935669, 0.016479492, 0.03717041, -0.046295166, 0.020401001, 0.0059776306, -0.0047454834, 0.007774353, -0.000043570995, 0.003211975, -0.00061893463, 0.034729004, 0.028579712, -0.0154953, 0.09375, -0.054718018, 0.008979797, 0.06518555, -0.0211792, -0.021896362, -0.0036849976, -0.0007991791, 0.008872986, 0.019378662, 0.016418457, -0.0014925003, -0.010826111, -0.0036411285, -0.083740234, 0.022094727, 0.01663208, 0.10168457, 0.046051025, -0.025848389, -0.025146484, -0.06274414, -0.040496826, -0.007133484, 0.03729248, -0.012466431, 0.01512146, -0.036102295, 0.027557373, 0.020339966, 0.038269043, -0.050689697, -0.019485474, 0.06939697, 0.0024814606, 0.07672119, 0.041656494, -0.068847656, 0.0007119179, 0.027709961, 0.034454346, -0.028045654, -0.018432617, -0.03982544, -0.021194458, -0.0021953583, -0.009178162, -0.00012803078, -0.002603531, 0.061950684, -0.042175293, 0.01676941, 0.01537323, -0.030395508, -0.033996582, -0.027786255, -0.0075187683, 0.0071411133, -0.012771606, 0.013870239, -0.016159058, -0.011360168, -0.030578613, 0.01638794, 0.013084412, -0.023040771, -0.015975952, 0.021331787, -0.035980225, -0.032104492, 0.0039596558, -0.045440674, -0.0024433136, 0.02532959, 0.0016317368, 0.013656616, 0.022216797, -0.0084991455, -0.033325195, 0.0077285767, 0.0019044876, -0.03062439, 0.019332886, 0.0045166016, 0.014968872, -0.014976501, 0.023132324, 0.011123657, -0.00289917, 0.0027427673, -0.015022278, -0.0028018951, -0.017562866, 0.00712204, -0.01953125, -0.023040771, -0.014701843, -0.0035095215, -0.004962921, -0.007221222, 0.020812988, -0.009788513, 0.019378662, 0.039031982, 0.015792847, 0.00031399727, -0.0037822723, -0.03955078, 0.021438599, -0.034423828, 0.04031372, 0.0017557144, -0.03378296, -0.05444336, -0.021591187, -0.028060913, 0.049621582, -0.02180481, 0.03515625, -0.018981934, -0.021591187, 0.042938232, -0.008010864, 0.025344849, -0.005432129, -0.0028800964, 0.009986877, -0.005493164, -0.020370483, 0.007095337, 0.04486084, -0.007965088, -0.01184082, -0.0059776306, -0.029785156, 0.010063171, 0.02368164, -0.019088745, 0.005619049, -0.027450562, -0.010749817, 0.04031372, -0.039123535, 0.016952515, -0.0107040405, 0.031585693, 0.023117065, 0.0008225441, 0.019134521, 0.012580872, 0.007247925, 0.0007352829, -0.03741455, -0.012420654, -0.0020275116, 0.021835327, -0.026885986, 0.016937256, -0.004676819, -0.0017776489, -0.0012836456, 0.0020713806, -0.015792847, 0.010726929, -0.0073547363, 0.015838623, -0.029312134, 0.016662598, 0.043670654, 0.011329651, -0.0513916, 0.07946777, 0.017501831, -0.009651184, 0.0110321045, -0.047546387, 0.026062012, -0.026046753, 0.02897644, 0.07421875, -0.01184082, 0.017059326, -0.0027236938, -0.0009899139, -0.014297485, 0.0034427643, 0.030044556, -0.005027771, 0.07196045, -0.009292603, 0.058685303, 0.025299072, -0.028533936, -0.007411957, -0.015075684, -0.089660645, -0.017288208, 0.070739746, 0.025314331, 0.030471802, -0.036132812, -0.04562378, 0.101135254, 0.06982422, 0.02571106, -0.029647827, -0.013084412, -0.0020771027, 0.0013952255, -0.02330017, 0.03363037, -0.04196167, -0.015731812, 0.035583496, 0.0032310486, -0.016204834, 0.010650635, -0.011192322, 0.010543823, -0.026901245, -0.01713562, -0.0073051453, -0.006298065, -0.011802673, 0.014549255, 0.0017843246, -0.005367279, -0.025482178, 0.012145996, -0.007686615, -0.007282257, -0.010299683, 0.03741455, -0.014724731, -0.013877869, 0.0025463104, 0.0042381287, -0.020004272, -0.015792847, 0.006942749, -0.039642334, -0.020904541, 0.029296875, 0.018936157, -0.023498535, -0.013648987, 0.00017595291, 0.06149292, 0.041381836, 0.07122803, 0.030700684, 0.0057029724, -0.005130768, 0.03640747, 0.06903076, 0.04067993, -0.037597656, 0.012031555, 0.03744507, 0.023101807, -0.009178162, -0.022766113, 0.008544922, 0.032409668, 0.02507019, 0.004699707, 0.012138367, 0.021911621, -0.045043945, 0.0056762695, 0.02885437, 0.079711914, -0.057434082, -0.054779053, -0.015899658, 0.044311523, -0.033477783, -0.0056762695, 0.04800415, -0.010551453, -0.021209717, 0.019760132, -0.0069999695, -0.0074691772, 0.032470703, -0.017288208, 0.017089844, -0.019882202, -0.0022182465, -0.0071868896, -0.030303955, 0.014060974, 0.0024795532, -0.0031547546, 0.0061416626, -0.00057554245, 0.004852295, -0.006591797, 0.049957275, 0.023223877, 0.004524231, 0.005176544, -0.035095215, -0.040985107, 0.021865845, -0.01133728, -0.033966064, -0.021697998, 0.05847168, -0.03427124, -0.0045433044, 0.0003607273, -0.0010585785, 0.012161255, -0.0037631989, -0.004890442, 0.0077819824, -0.03933716, 0.026535034, 0.03439331, 0.02444458, -0.06390381, -0.050872803, -0.033447266, -0.021408081, 0.021499634, 0.02104187, 0.049468994, 0.026855469, 0.031402588, -0.05178833, -0.008872986, -0.008911133, -0.033996582, 0.088256836, -0.0004723072, -0.015792847, 0.04525757, 0.009719849, 0.015106201, -0.017837524, -0.014625549, 0.054382324, 0.00008535385, -0.011199951, 0.05911255, -0.012504578, -0.012268066, -0.0289917, 0.03527832, 0.0007972717, -0.007972717, 0.036224365, -0.00491333, 0.0016355515, -0.0021076202, -0.0519104, -0.026321411, 0.0423584, 0.009887695, 0.025680542, -0.0009937286, -0.015235901, -0.009773254, 0.017288208, 0.014045715, 0.024734497, 0.0058517456, 0.037109375, -0.046966553, 0.01586914, -0.031982422, -0.022369385, -0.0126953125, -0.02268982, 0.0019445419, -0.016937256, 0.0236969, 0.0006337166, 0.017318726, -0.030456543, -0.006259918, -0.012931824, 0.020217896, -0.019104004, 0.023071289, -0.030303955, 0.01222229, -0.019866943, -0.018569946, -0.016952515, 0.021774292, -0.018798828, 0.0463562, -0.0045776367, -0.020111084, 0.029525757, -0.055419922, -0.031173706, -0.0149002075, -0.01121521, -0.012672424, 0.017089844, -0.036315918, 0.0065727234, -0.0074386597, 0.018936157, 0.046447754, -0.03277588, -0.007820129, 0.044006348, 0.013168335, -0.03781128, -0.027328491, 0.024642944, 0.026290894, -0.023452759, -0.017593384, 0.021606445, -0.0055389404, -0.013557434, -0.028137207, 0.017105103, 0.04486084, -0.09020996, 0.051574707, -0.00762558, -0.025436401, 0.07519531, -0.028442383, -0.04449463, -0.0068588257, -0.0064201355, -0.030471802, 0.02015686, 0.016738892, 0.05444336, -0.006450653, -0.028717041, 0.0046310425, -0.033721924, -0.019989014, -0.0046081543, 0.00021445751, -0.036315918, 0.019058228, 0.031036377, -0.012054443, -0.038391113, -0.030380249, 0.058563232, -0.047546387, 0.013572693, 0.031036377, -0.03366089, 0.11071777, -0.012626648, -0.083862305, 0.030975342, -0.040924072, 0.0154800415, 0.03668213, 0.0005931854, 0.027069092, -0.014183044, -0.020645142, -0.0128479, -0.0075912476, -0.0119018555, -0.05050659, -0.024368286, 0.004550934, -0.038909912, 0.020248413, -0.022994995, 0.030548096, -0.031829834, 0.002784729, 0.030929565, 0.055480957, -0.066345215, 0.013999939, 0.053741455, 0.01424408, -0.07861328, 0.03527832, 0.022079468, -0.01576233, -0.006538391, 0.027679443, -0.014602661, 0.024429321, 0.010093689, -0.043823242, -0.019882202, -0.001039505, 0.042938232, 0.036193848, -0.026031494, -0.026931763, -0.016693115, 0.056274414, -0.03591919, 0.048675537, -0.014694214, 0.04107666, -0.029022217, 0.0036888123, 0.007293701, 0.013069153, -0.0413208, -0.027069092, -0.013145447, 0.009246826, -0.0236969, 0.018798828, -0.0052604675, 0.011360168, 0.007873535, 0.0046310425, 0.005367279, -0.032989502, 0.001914978, 0.016113281, -0.006965637, -0.048858643, -0.055389404, 0.0018339157, -0.033233643, -0.0029964447, -0.008674622, -0.020935059, -0.0256958, -0.026184082, -0.036865234, 0.020355225, 0.038635254, 0.09942627, 0.03286743, 0.0060157776, -0.07385254, 0.019760132, -0.028060913, 0.043273926, -0.025344849, 0.04260254, -0.014221191, 0.005683899, 0.0051193237, -0.007835388, -0.029434204, -0.02305603, 0.031280518, 0.018112183, 0.011772156, -0.0048599243, 0.028793335, 0.021591187, -0.020980835, 0.050872803, 0.012466431, -0.00806427, 0.0064735413, 0.052459717, 0.011680603, -0.011375427, 0.057403564, 0.07336426, -0.03225708, -0.042877197, -0.006137848, 0.033843994, 0.017532349, -0.035125732, 0.00067186356, 0.007587433, -0.020004272, -0.010299683, 0.0019760132, -0.029464722, 0.010620117, 0.0011320114, -0.023071289, 0.02420044, 0.035369873, 0.009101868, -0.020141602, 0.017562866, 0.009887695, 0.0011463165, 0.0018701553, -0.054351807, 0.00944519, 0.043273926, 0.013801575, -0.01134491, -0.015167236, 0.005760193, 0.041656494, -0.0126953125, -0.035949707, -0.03390503, 0.020996094, 0.012268066, 0.0006747246, 0.0033721924, -0.042938232, -0.060028076, -0.0024299622, 0.024993896, 0.001531601, 0.021713257, -0.027709961, 0.0010356903, -0.05392456, -0.0021324158, 0.00073957443, -0.024810791, -0.03781128, 0.030075073, -0.013801575, 0.02998352, -0.015014648, 0.028320312, 0.017913818, 0.019729614, 0.0020217896, -0.05154419, 0.009468079, -0.023712158, -0.024932861, 0.008552551, -0.0028324127, 0.04168701, 0.04336548, 0.033294678, 0.0059013367, -0.022781372, -0.0024719238, 0.022659302, 0.04473877, -0.037841797, -0.019943237, 0.02609253, -0.052734375, 0.00034332275, 0.006866455, -0.025299072, 0.002779007, -0.0026512146, -0.017929077, -0.038970947, 0.016937256, -0.03237915, -0.029067993, -0.033233643, 0.022384644, -0.02168274, -0.030883789, 0.0018959045, 0.025360107, -0.013763428, -0.060333252, 0.023803711, 0.01625061, 0.04547119, -0.0009536743, 0.0041923523, 0.01373291, -0.014694214, 0.03967285, 0.01675415, -0.051940918, -0.017349243, -0.064697266, -0.026916504, -0.032226562, 0.07043457, -0.029663086, 0.027008057, 0.019805908, -0.03137207, 0.014633179, 0.006877899, -0.045410156, 0.003944397, -0.025604248, -0.057647705, 0.013977051, 0.0037269592, -0.077941895, 0.02722168, 0.033599854, 0.0102005005, 0.007331848, 0.01386261, 0.029510498, -0.008255005, -0.035980225, -0.0045318604, 0.03881836, 0.013191223, 0.06085205, 0.004928589, 0.019210815, 0.042999268, 0.03744507, 0.035583496, 0.060913086, -0.038269043, 0.04714966, 0.05053711, 0.049346924, 0.024642944, 0.0087890625, -0.008422852, 0.049438477, -0.0340271, 0.005218506, 0.0045280457, -0.009864807, 0.012962341, -0.015365601, 0.04534912, -0.013702393, -0.036865234, -0.018157959, -0.03741455, -0.032043457, 0.029830933, -0.020401001, -0.020645142, 0.06518555, -0.06347656, -0.02178955, 0.04248047, 0.021438599, -0.013801575, -0.025177002, 0.03186035, 0.025741577, 0.022079468, -0.0067977905, 0.0038528442, -0.009117126, 0.021835327, 0.022827148, 0.0075035095, -0.00894165, 0.033569336, 0.02067566, 0.004753113, -0.0062561035, -0.07080078, -0.036071777, 0.00969696, -0.047821045, -0.04373169, 0.045684814, -0.005622864, -0.064819336, -0.059661865, -0.06304932, -0.040527344, -0.028182983, 0.026367188, -0.007850647, 0.054382324, -0.0072631836, 0.044128418, 0.029052734, -0.051879883, -0.035247803, -0.011787415, 0.10900879, 0.040100098, -0.036621094, -0.016052246, -0.021942139, 0.017547607, 0.030792236, 0.03805542, 0.042663574, -0.015037537, 0.034942627, 0.013114929, -0.024612427, -0.06451416, 0.038513184, -0.036254883, -0.025299072, -0.013587952, 0.00472641, 0.012580872, 0.018341064, 0.019760132, 0.012672424, 0.010139465, -0.02420044, -0.02003479, -0.01725769, -0.012138367, -0.0357666, -0.018066406, -0.0059509277, 0.015914917, -0.0090789795, 0.009521484, 0.05065918, -0.015670776, 0.010955811, 0.0029964447, 0.020446777, -0.026870728, -0.028579712, -0.06530762, -0.016235352, -0.016693115, -0.032104492, -0.020401001, -0.07421875, 0.0018110275, 0.0047187805, 0.03842163, -0.008155823, -0.011024475, 0.024124146, -0.0053749084, 0.03466797, 0.0054473877, 0.016555786, 0.00012540817, -0.018569946, 0.026626587, 0.010795593, -0.009933472, 0.017242432, 0.03845215, 0.041381836, 0.094055176, 0.086364746, 0.008743286, 0.04925537, 0.03829956, -0.03149414, 0.0345459, -0.004753113, -0.0010766983, -0.029953003, -0.011100769, -0.0024719238, 0.011978149, -0.01763916, 0.06463623, -0.061431885, -0.010292053, -0.028671265, 0.024551392, -0.049560547, 0.0256958, 0.0035190582, -0.040283203, 0.015731812, -0.0107803345, -0.023010254, -0.053619385, -0.038330078, -0.028274536, 0.047546387, -0.024795532, 0.0026874542, 0.036712646, -0.022323608, -0.033233643, 0.04714966, 0.0059776306, 0.09411621, -0.028442383, -0.027038574, 0.04006958, 0.00617218, 0.023071289, -0.032226562, -0.0440979, 0.028579712, 0.032348633, -0.06506348, 0.013801575, -0.004524231, -0.039276123, -0.06329346, -0.029449463, -0.0054473877, -0.049591064, 0.017410278, 0.024993896, -0.043151855, 0.033477783, 0.021759033, -0.004558563, 0.044891357, 0.0015277863, -0.01727295, 0.05203247, -0.0036315918, -0.024032593, 0.026260376, 0.017822266, 0.01878357, -0.023834229, -0.04724121, -0.015457153, 0.037506104, 0.018707275, -0.013687134, 0.059539795, 0.055236816, 0.028121948, 0.029418945, -0.013969421, -0.050628662, -0.0357666, 0.038848877, 0.033477783, 0.016677856, -0.008010864, 0.0184021, 0.008796692, 0.026123047, -0.0146484375, -0.028259277, 0.008338928, 0.009933472, -0.06378174, -0.029251099, 0.01638794, -0.031921387, -0.038116455, 0.036193848, 0.011878967, -0.008895874, -0.026794434, -0.072631836, 0.048675537, -0.013809204, -0.001783371, 0.03213501, 0.023925781, 0.015686035, 0.083862305, 0.0028324127, 0.009231567, -0.0041007996, -0.013954163, 0.034820557, -0.010292053, 0.008018494, -0.013748169, -0.011711121, -0.01586914, 0.0044555664, -0.0065193176, 0.01902771, -0.012283325, 0.00409317, -0.015510559, -0.009887695, -0.08520508, -0.037719727, 0.0209198, -0.04586792, 0.010108948, -0.02960205, 0.011657715, 0.016677856, 0.002576828, 0.035247803, -0.02557373, 0.026733398, 0.024963379, 0.018798828, 0.018249512 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1911.08089v2
"The Human Body is a Black Box": Supporting Clinical Decision-Making with Deep Learning
Mark Sendak, Madeleine Elish, Michael Gao, Joseph Futoma, William Ratliff, Marshall Nichols, Armando Bedoya, Suresh Balu, Cara O'Brien
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
Machine learning technologies are increasingly developed for use in healthcare. While research communities have focused on creating state-of-the-art models, there has been less focus on real world implementation and the associated challenges to accuracy, fairness, accountability, and transparency that come from actual, situated use. Serious questions remain under examined regarding how to ethically build models, interpret and explain model output, recognize and account for biases, and minimize disruptions to professional expertise and work cultures. We address this gap in the literature and provide a detailed case study covering the development, implementation, and evaluation of Sepsis Watch, a machine learning-driven tool that assists hospital clinicians in the early diagnosis and treatment of sepsis. We, the team that developed and evaluated the tool, discuss our conceptualization of the tool not as a model deployed in the world but instead as a socio-technical system requiring integration into existing social and professional contexts. Rather than focusing on model interpretability to ensure a fair and accountable machine learning, we point toward four key values and practices that should be considered when developing machine learning to support clinical decision-making: rigorously define the problem in context, build relationships with stakeholders, respect professional discretion, and create ongoing feedback loops with stakeholders. Our work has significant implications for future research regarding mechanisms of institutional accountability and considerations for designing machine learning systems. Our work underscores the limits of model interpretability as a solution to ensure transparency, accuracy, and accountability in practice. Instead, our work demonstrates other means and goals to achieve FATML values in design and in practice.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1911.08089v2
2019-12-07T03:42:06
2019-11-19T04:28:47
{ "title": [ -0.0027332306, 0.0064926147, -0.038757324, -0.05984497, 0.017700195, -0.020996094, -0.025741577, -0.030639648, -0.0034542084, 0.01713562, -0.020751953, 0.014205933, -0.011871338, -0.024902344, -0.034210205, 0.0052948, -0.0008354187, 0.033691406, 0.003955841, -0.027282715, -0.0256958, -0.028198242, 0.05883789, 0.05203247, 0.026000977, -0.02394104, -0.1005249, 0.023757935, -0.06768799, -0.050598145, -0.017425537, 0.05456543, 0.033477783, 0.030929565, -0.016601562, 0.023452759, -0.046203613, 0.033294678, 0.0154418945, -0.008918762, 0.019470215, -0.01210022, -0.028121948, -0.0597229, -0.040008545, 0.018478394, -0.07495117, -0.030319214, -0.014518738, 0.03237915, 0.025512695, 0.026473999, 0.002275467, 0.042114258, 0.012313843, -0.020568848, -0.033050537, -0.025268555, 0.039764404, 0.06732178, 0.024169922, -0.082458496, 0.024536133, -0.03353882, -0.048034668, -0.018478394, -0.011985779, 0.016204834, 0.09265137, 0.012382507, -0.02243042, 0.038024902, 0.0024604797, -0.001742363, -0.05847168, -0.0014123917, 0.04046631, 0.018676758, 0.0385437, -0.03894043, 0.013122559, -0.027877808, 0.016418457, -0.0057296753, 0.0013885498, -0.01751709, -0.014678955, -0.017333984, -0.030395508, -0.04953003, -0.0014247894, -0.02861023, -0.009292603, 0.0019950867, -0.00982666, -0.04156494, -0.030578613, 0.0003607273, 0.009933472, 0.0034179688, -0.011764526, 0.010238647, -0.029541016, -0.020874023, -0.0015516281, 0.022735596, -0.024017334, -0.060058594, -0.012306213, 0.037261963, -0.024246216, -0.004337311, 0.009635925, -0.037261963, 0.024490356, 0.030944824, 0.00094747543, 0.037353516, 0.034942627, 0.024963379, 0.0031986237, -0.02999878, 0.01828003, 0.030776978, 0.021362305, -0.0028057098, -0.048034668, 0.0040016174, -0.048065186, 0.056854248, 0.0018196106, 0.034454346, -0.10272217, -0.08404541, -0.06021118, 0.029388428, -0.017181396, -0.0098724365, -0.008758545, -0.0009832382, 0.015975952, -0.024291992, -0.004966736, 0.018951416, -0.024475098, 0.015655518, 0.05496216, -0.016540527, -0.058929443, -0.036621094, -0.047607422, 0.0061454773, 0.023223877, 0.015853882, -0.06149292, 0.015419006, -0.12548828, 0.0020885468, 0.005405426, 0.006839752, 0.03164673, 0.008277893, -0.0054969788, 0.019348145, 0.06088257, -0.024475098, -0.04953003, 0.027832031, -0.00046348572, 0.030349731, -0.026885986, 0.01651001, 0.0010728836, -0.01374054, -0.0152282715, 0.004081726, 0.023849487, 0.02041626, 0.011619568, -0.0054626465, -0.0012702942, -0.0262146, 0.0069084167, 0.050323486, -0.035980225, -0.0036678314, 0.007255554, -0.0019254684, 0.03753662, 0.0021095276, -0.053009033, 0.03878784, -0.016616821, -0.05267334, -0.048339844, -0.030792236, 0.044036865, 0.02835083, -0.009262085, 0.028564453, -0.009414673, -0.015007019, -0.018661499, -0.005302429, -0.017044067, -0.023330688, -0.021087646, 0.0140686035, -0.04034424, 0.046569824, 0.06210327, 0.022033691, -0.045440674, 0.0054740906, 0.007030487, -0.041656494, 0.026626587, -0.021881104, -0.017410278, -0.017364502, -0.04562378, 0.016708374, -0.027618408, 0.046325684, 0.021514893, 0.010772705, 0.008468628, -0.028381348, 0.05593872, 0.021392822, 0.06768799, -0.03286743, 0.0024604797, 0.007873535, -0.018463135, -0.013221741, 0.0046691895, 0.019195557, 0.009216309, 0.0017232895, 0.005458832, -0.007789612, 0.002023697, 0.03652954, 0.059539795, 0.014846802, 0.011138916, 0.007118225, 0.015731812, 0.002910614, 0.055633545, 0.011260986, 0.064208984, 0.034606934, 0.014129639, 0.040039062, 0.0070610046, 0.007133484, -0.0075149536, 0.01197052, -0.01663208, 0.028839111, 0.015289307, 0.016326904, -0.04650879, 0.0060195923, -0.03842163, 0.0033454895, 0.0056762695, 0.022903442, 0.032806396, -0.04269409, 0.011962891, 0.002275467, 0.0052337646, -0.012413025, -0.018722534, 0.012252808, 0.00415802, -0.04840088, -0.010475159, -0.0064201355, 0.031188965, 0.007537842, 0.019058228, -0.019210815, 0.02671814, 0.00013816357, -0.014221191, -0.026046753, 0.0234375, 0.024993896, -0.0066223145, -0.003522873, 0.028701782, -0.016952515, 0.05807495, 0.10089111, -0.040649414, 0.04083252, -0.07446289, 0.0062828064, 0.013008118, -0.033111572, 0.0023040771, 0.017684937, -0.0012817383, 0.02760315, -0.019470215, -0.011184692, -0.015426636, 0.046569824, 0.001367569, -0.022888184, -0.038116455, -0.050994873, -0.016296387, -0.028808594, -0.04815674, -0.0012378693, 0.067871094, 0.00076150894, -0.011459351, -0.026245117, 0.0184021, -0.03665161, -0.032440186, -0.029541016, -0.022003174, 0.020446777, 0.04916382, 0.01953125, -0.042419434, -0.030548096, 0.010520935, 0.016983032, -0.013267517, 0.028656006, -0.024215698, -0.012031555, 0.0065231323, 0.005897522, 0.015525818, -0.03475952, 0.003774643, -0.0309906, 0.00053977966, 0.034179688, -0.036590576, -0.00025343895, 0.022369385, -0.030441284, -0.046966553, 0.013511658, 0.036590576, -0.011329651, 0.013961792, 0.018005371, 0.023895264, -0.02609253, 0.026763916, 0.01071167, 0.0069999695, -0.015655518, -0.015579224, -0.04724121, -0.0010719299, -0.004676819, -0.00043463707, 0.04660034, -0.076538086, 0.0076065063, -0.044311523, -0.013542175, 0.012413025, 0.047424316, 0.0015029907, -0.024887085, -0.038635254, -0.014884949, -0.011779785, 0.013130188, -0.039978027, -0.0012683868, 0.07519531, 0.0010786057, -0.014923096, -0.016555786, 0.051239014, 0.0057792664, 0.023117065, -0.010414124, -0.02722168, 0.014801025, 0.0073242188, 0.02607727, -0.016799927, -0.0057792664, -0.10028076, -0.014572144, 0.06213379, 0.0038814545, -0.020462036, 0.016708374, -0.06689453, 0.010169983, 0.013618469, 0.0014314651, 0.030090332, 0.06378174, -0.01146698, 0.04788208, -0.0063209534, 0.015411377, 0.0070228577, -0.014755249, -0.118774414, 0.018630981, -0.01789856, 0.0022563934, -0.002040863, -0.019515991, -0.06298828, 0.007980347, 0.008277893, 0.045166016, 0.0385437, 0.0029201508, 0.039611816, -0.025482178, 0.013893127, -0.035003662, -0.014778137, -0.047607422, -0.0066375732, -0.00080013275, -0.024993896, 0.059143066, -0.031097412, 0.023773193, -0.022109985, -0.014923096, -0.00017952919, 0.044128418, 0.004180908, -0.021636963, -0.01928711, -0.016418457, -0.021850586, -0.020370483, -0.017333984, -0.00333786, -0.02861023, 0.015975952, -0.0046195984, 0.046173096, 0.01058197, 0.028808594, -0.0064697266, -0.0236969, 0.0209198, -0.043182373, -0.025970459, 0.026382446, 0.025985718, 0.008728027, 0.016189575, -0.01663208, -0.036376953, 0.024337769, -0.031021118, 0.01020813, 0.0009393692, 0.001288414, -0.0045394897, -0.010887146, -0.024017334, 0.025222778, -0.020996094, 0.0287323, -0.009773254, 0.003967285, -0.022628784, -0.06665039, -0.012786865, 0.0029125214, -0.11834717, -0.047424316, 0.035827637, -0.08001709, -0.061157227, -0.07055664, 0.03366089, -0.078125, -0.02180481, 0.004508972, -0.023986816, 0.010726929, -0.0036087036, -0.052490234, -0.022567749, 0.056640625, 0.007598877, 0.013534546, 0.019805908, -0.00907135, -0.01260376, -0.03262329, 0.011428833, 0.008094788, 0.026535034, -0.001663208, -0.0059013367, 0.02607727, -0.024642944, 0.013595581, 0.0037174225, 0.03677368, -0.020843506, -0.009223938, 0.03781128, 0.034973145, -0.028747559, 0.04019165, 0.009590149, 0.006454468, -0.08288574, -0.0061187744, 0.017120361, 0.0010528564, 0.018737793, -0.024139404, 0.03515625, 0.03982544, 0.001335144, 0.051513672, -0.012466431, -0.030136108, 0.003900528, -0.009475708, -0.008071899, 0.0065994263, 0.015731812, 0.009017944, -0.013595581, 0.031097412, -0.007369995, 0.042907715, -0.031585693, -0.041625977, 0.023895264, 0.037475586, -0.04498291, -0.01725769, -0.047027588, -0.04928589, -0.01008606, -0.0036582947, -0.0018024445, 0.017974854, 0.02557373, -0.0041656494, -0.02557373, -0.0042495728, 0.05517578, 0.005214691, -0.020523071, -0.05682373, 0.012321472, -0.033325195, -0.04458618, -0.0413208, -0.0005168915, 0.000028192997, 0.036712646, -0.0030899048, -0.02230835, 0.018997192, 0.02456665, 0.060302734, 0.04815674, -0.02810669, -0.06530762, -0.007003784, -0.031051636, -0.01890564, 0.021636963, 0.0015592575, -0.005142212, -0.02192688, 0.008361816, -0.02810669, -0.027801514, -0.0491333, 0.03439331, 0.0029792786, 0.02720642, 0.027496338, 0.04638672, 0.033996582, 0.008995056, 0.025466919, 0.013267517, -0.032989502, -0.057617188, 0.007888794, 0.03933716, -0.0014314651, 0.008148193, 0.034820557, 0.011421204, -0.023956299, 0.023117065, 0.015426636, 0.03314209, -0.014656067, -0.008964539, 0.019470215, -0.041748047, -0.041992188, -0.0057144165, 0.0023479462, 0.04083252, -0.05340576, 0.06591797, -0.038909912, -0.012466431, 0.027404785, 0.0035171509, -0.00019955635, -0.008331299, 0.021255493, -0.03918457, -0.05404663, -0.011764526, 0.039001465, -0.024505615, -0.011047363, 0.018951416, 0.038970947, 0.03378296, 0.04598999, 0.026016235, -0.014045715, 0.016464233, -0.005378723, -0.0033130646, -0.011871338, -0.04876709, 0.020980835, -0.0115356445, 0.013961792, -0.05126953, -0.013320923, -0.06335449, -0.025283813, 0.005016327, -0.010139465, 0.02268982, -0.0519104, 0.022064209, 0.06768799, -0.020629883, 0.03604126, -0.0014238358, 0.017959595, 0.017044067, 0.058685303, -0.006175995, 0.036956787, 0.03289795, -0.046539307, 0.0030956268, 0.0073127747, 0.04525757, 0.012519836, -0.0010290146, 0.013244629, -0.020111084, -0.042175293, 0.02470398, 0.0015411377, -0.017913818, 0.032836914, -0.056243896, 0.008110046, 0.016647339, -0.0062026978, 0.016464233, -0.03503418, -0.006713867, 0.018005371, -0.032348633, -0.029037476, 0.034240723, -0.0012788773, -0.022201538, -0.07421875, 0.0068130493, -0.019180298, 0.003019333, -0.014770508, 0.030715942, -0.038970947, 0.019058228, -0.019607544, -0.056518555, -0.0049095154, 0.01399231, 0.020645142, 0.033966064, -0.0014839172, -0.06414795, -0.0069999695, -0.0037765503, -0.055114746, -0.04296875, 0.019821167, 0.012138367, -0.009643555, -0.010696411, -0.03579712, -0.008010864, 0.017791748, 0.025253296, -0.0055160522, -0.038909912, 0.02319336, 0.013793945, 0.019592285, 0.0025310516, 0.039733887, 0.008712769, -0.007774353, 0.0035743713, -0.039794922, 0.027038574, -0.012786865, 0.022628784, -0.016799927, -0.055664062, 0.012817383, 0.025299072, 0.012649536, -0.01626587, 0.008026123, 0.03817749, 0.020019531, -0.03012085, -0.001291275, 0.06585693, -0.05065918, -0.046142578, -0.0023708344, 0.005504608, -0.021347046, 0.051116943, -0.015304565, -0.049102783, -0.024017334, -0.04058838, -0.032836914, -0.006439209, 0.015449524, 0.01713562, 0.0418396, -0.03100586, 0.011489868, -0.044128418, -0.003370285, 0.014549255, -0.022994995, -0.004432678, -0.019241333, 0.026611328, 0.029312134, 0.009979248, -0.050750732, 0.038330078, 0.0027198792, -0.0084991455, -0.002658844, -0.014831543, 0.015602112, -0.043792725, -0.005744934, 0.038360596, 0.026031494, -0.029220581, 0.036743164, -0.02319336, 0.0592041, 0.0317688, 0.044281006, 0.0435791, 0.0181427, 0.036193848, 0.0030822754, -0.0039596558, -0.033935547, 0.011413574, -0.04324341, 0.008087158, -0.03579712, -0.007446289, -0.066711426, -0.0036830902, 0.050933838, 0.050689697, -0.0005245209, 0.02609253, 0.03137207, 0.005466461, 0.064697266, -0.026947021, 0.08276367, 0.05984497, 0.016662598, 0.016571045, 0.015823364, -0.025924683, 0.011131287, -0.0036563873, 0.03933716, -0.017471313, -0.004131317, 0.0040512085, 0.019821167, 0.0031318665, 0.0016307831, 0.007675171, -0.022781372, 0.029144287, -0.012145996, 0.030456543, 0.050689697, 0.046661377, -0.021881104, 0.00077819824, 0.0047302246, -0.020812988, -0.009414673, -0.012290955, 0.032043457, -0.070251465, 0.028823853, -0.004020691, -0.024520874, -0.01058197, 0.04736328, 0.0075302124, -0.031173706, -0.034851074, 0.017440796, 0.03768921, 0.03338623, 0.0051841736, -0.03527832, -0.010971069, 0.035888672, 0.036346436, -0.015579224, 0.009925842, 0.018432617, 0.013977051, -0.010726929, -0.025314331, -0.0031471252, 0.05215454, -0.039978027, 0.028396606, 0.003376007, 0.041046143, -0.008087158, -0.03665161, 0.01713562, 0.008583069, -0.062469482, -0.0020599365, 0.023864746, 0.0033454895, -0.008987427, 0.054229736, 0.022857666, -0.025787354, -0.04534912, -0.03463745, 0.005870819, 0.040405273, -0.042999268, -0.0009264946, -0.026565552, -0.038116455, 0.024246216, -0.035614014, 0.06463623, -0.047058105, -0.013519287, -0.0036525726, 0.024230957, 0.033325195, -0.018371582, -0.030670166, -0.010803223, -0.016418457, -0.012588501, 0.009544373, -0.029006958, -0.035095215, 0.011016846, 0.024932861, 0.013259888, -0.004272461, -0.026916504, -0.041290283, -0.051483154, 0.043121338, -0.012756348, 0.0725708, -0.007873535, -0.01512146, -0.03817749, 0.019210815, 0.017913818, 0.0008740425, -0.036376953, 0.053985596, -0.017684937, -0.045074463, 0.03277588, 0.025405884, -0.016662598, -0.046173096, 0.0038852692, -0.003900528, -0.0132369995, -0.0048599243, 0.02810669, -0.041931152, -0.029815674, -0.0011577606, -0.032440186, 0.033050537, 0.028823853, -0.008056641, 0.017105103, 0.016845703, -0.00894928, -0.022857666, 0.0023345947, 0.038024902, -0.014572144, -0.051574707, -0.006439209, 0.03540039, 0.026901245, -0.052825928, -0.0692749, 0.026062012, 0.027816772, -0.00024306774, 0.049713135, -0.014526367, -0.010322571, 0.03515625, 0.052612305, 0.015602112, -0.048065186, -0.048339844, -0.030410767, 0.060394287, 0.034240723, -0.007701874, -0.022384644, 0.027770996, -0.023773193, -0.0071907043, 0.008598328, 0.0039138794, 0.00818634, 0.0088272095, 0.04748535, 0.00070619583, -0.018096924, -0.010261536, 0.016342163, -0.012054443, 0.022644043, -0.010536194, 0.004360199, -0.008865356, 0.058135986, -0.03048706, -0.032196045, 0.04763794, 0.02734375, 0.021835327, 0.035491943, -0.023864746, -0.003545761, 0.010467529, -0.030929565, -0.021316528, -0.020614624, 0.06665039, -0.06689453, -0.020385742, -0.046325684, -0.04385376, -0.015914917, -0.02961731, 0.034118652, -0.019439697, 0.016204834, -0.025543213, -0.009841919, 0.002866745, 0.023376465, 0.027008057, -0.013298035, -0.05517578, -0.023391724, 0.043670654, -0.022460938 ], "summary": [ 0.00032043457, -0.0047683716, 0.006385803, 0.013008118, -0.01966858, 0.00017762184, -0.018066406, -0.045837402, -0.012390137, -0.015487671, -0.053100586, -0.020523071, -0.0446167, -0.025512695, 0.004009247, -0.08312988, 0.0075569153, 0.028259277, 0.043182373, -0.013031006, 0.015289307, -0.0184021, 0.04647827, 0.02281189, 0.030197144, 0.005859375, -0.07421875, 0.042022705, 0.01625061, 0.03390503, 0.008148193, -0.037963867, 0.019882202, 0.029129028, -0.0067825317, 0.0046539307, 0.00086069107, 0.0041770935, 0.011199951, 0.01158905, 0.036987305, -0.020385742, 0.09729004, -0.0362854, 0.036865234, 0.04421997, -0.0013952255, -0.031188965, -0.02015686, 0.0045928955, 0.027801514, -0.02355957, 0.013702393, 0.04647827, -0.030471802, -0.027313232, -0.009025574, 0.00856781, 0.017807007, 0.032104492, 0.003643036, -0.0005850792, 0.012741089, -0.028778076, -0.0038909912, -0.00001168251, 0.062927246, 0.005138397, 0.060638428, 0.011642456, -0.005317688, 0.05126953, 0.027359009, -0.014984131, -0.052886963, -0.016479492, 0.033691406, -0.0070495605, 0.010948181, -0.046722412, 0.050689697, 0.005672455, 0.022155762, 0.024368286, -0.035308838, 0.013801575, 0.004322052, -0.036865234, 0.0023403168, -0.004432678, -0.018585205, 0.036071777, -0.001247406, 0.028182983, -0.013839722, -0.016159058, -0.011367798, -0.02947998, 0.021102905, -0.009567261, -0.006587982, -0.021072388, -0.027664185, 0.009460449, -0.011047363, 0.058685303, 0.0149383545, -0.026046753, -0.027786255, -0.0019836426, -0.011451721, -0.06890869, 0.00724411, -0.058288574, 0.0058059692, 0.04776001, 0.0132369995, 0.018066406, 0.028915405, -0.010765076, -0.014732361, 0.002439499, -0.014297485, 0.08526611, -0.02835083, 0.00049829483, 0.029052734, -0.01373291, -0.023376465, 0.050567627, 0.003124237, -0.021408081, -0.052459717, 0.034210205, -0.008644104, -0.026351929, 0.03942871, -0.006580353, -0.00983429, -0.011253357, 0.026321411, 0.00894165, -0.016525269, 0.012046814, -0.037750244, 0.032409668, 0.009544373, -0.0042533875, -0.014411926, -0.0206604, -0.028518677, -0.01033783, 0.02859497, 0.01424408, -0.058441162, 0.004322052, -0.09838867, 0.046936035, -0.013221741, 0.013305664, 0.04135132, 0.023498535, 0.041168213, 0.04562378, 0.0009236336, -0.02986145, -0.046722412, -0.019378662, -0.00034284592, -0.043518066, -0.022216797, 0.03186035, -0.0024490356, -0.017730713, 0.015510559, -0.010520935, -0.026733398, 0.007972717, 0.0024089813, -0.028930664, -0.020568848, -0.041625977, -0.038482666, 0.039733887, -0.021636963, -0.0050354004, 0.022827148, 0.066467285, 0.01828003, 0.02468872, -0.025314331, -0.020584106, 0.009735107, -0.0035076141, -0.0018281937, -0.018844604, -0.029769897, 0.0033874512, -0.026504517, -0.020828247, 0.016693115, 0.040496826, -0.040283203, -0.014717102, -0.064697266, 0.000934124, -0.009613037, 0.02381897, -0.038360596, 0.028244019, 0.021606445, -0.016738892, -0.026916504, 0.036987305, 0.024902344, -0.01776123, 0.00094127655, -0.016189575, -0.010185242, -0.04626465, -0.010063171, -0.008163452, -0.018051147, 0.047821045, -0.046295166, 0.016235352, 0.00920105, 0.015312195, 0.07476807, -0.0074005127, 0.18737793, -0.055664062, 0.011238098, 0.028579712, -0.010055542, -0.026809692, -0.009346008, -0.10058594, 0.012123108, 0.059661865, 0.0044937134, 0.047058105, -0.02583313, 0.0075149536, 0.03668213, 0.024765015, 0.029067993, -0.015991211, 0.0012741089, 0.012039185, 0.026443481, -0.02748108, 0.02609253, 0.0104599, -0.01727295, 0.02456665, -0.035491943, -0.034606934, 0.0143585205, -0.01826477, 0.011802673, 0.010047913, -0.00598526, 0.003627777, -0.015197754, -0.019165039, -0.01914978, -0.018203735, -0.02319336, -0.008255005, 0.039520264, -0.015182495, 0.011955261, 0.029006958, -0.028060913, -0.01828003, -0.010765076, 0.0000988245, 0.0005764961, -0.0069274902, -0.027877808, -0.032714844, -0.015808105, -0.0070724487, 0.01008606, 0.004016876, 0.034301758, 0.010887146, -0.00041604042, -0.024673462, 0.007549286, -0.002248764, -0.031143188, 0.018539429, -0.007621765, -0.038757324, 0.051879883, 0.056640625, -0.032592773, 0.01247406, 0.021865845, 0.011505127, -0.049591064, 0.009033203, -0.013877869, 0.024246216, -0.014976501, 0.014266968, 0.008720398, -0.037902832, 0.047668457, 0.061920166, 0.00642395, 0.07055664, -0.056549072, -0.0552063, -0.008735657, 0.028579712, -0.016738892, 0.03375244, 0.059051514, 0.0064697266, 0.027557373, -0.009979248, 0.018081665, -0.05545044, 0.022094727, -0.01020813, -0.038482666, -0.01914978, 0.0077590942, -0.06402588, -0.024520874, 0.012077332, 0.02029419, 0.023239136, -0.0014343262, 0.07714844, 0.011405945, -0.030151367, 0.03338623, -0.009559631, -0.013870239, 0.018463135, -0.07574463, 0.013687134, -0.006542206, -0.0022029877, 0.02279663, -0.0256958, 0.027526855, 0.015457153, -0.06359863, -0.01727295, -0.010383606, 0.0041656494, 0.06762695, -0.009346008, 0.010269165, -0.028366089, 0.038726807, 0.016967773, 0.0064964294, -0.04360962, -0.057495117, -0.016983032, 0.02128601, -0.011436462, 0.058166504, 0.043395996, -0.025299072, 0.06542969, -0.0496521, -0.0031318665, 0.014511108, 0.003955841, 0.09625244, 0.003232956, -0.037109375, 0.0473938, 0.012458801, 0.009407043, -0.010437012, -0.01676941, 0.050933838, 0.0042152405, 0.033111572, 0.012832642, 0.060424805, -0.005706787, 0.016647339, -0.0067596436, -0.001121521, -0.016235352, 0.00844574, -0.0034255981, 0.0035305023, 0.048828125, -0.04550171, -0.015098572, 0.011810303, 0.025741577, 0.0075187683, 0.0075149536, -0.018218994, 0.039093018, 0.0030593872, -0.012435913, 0.022079468, -0.01776123, -0.010261536, 0.0071868896, -0.029388428, -0.0064048767, -0.023483276, -0.030807495, -0.07043457, -0.00095176697, -0.054595947, 0.0619812, 0.053710938, -0.011230469, -0.015151978, 0.017532349, -0.013336182, 0.006313324, 0.024414062, 0.021865845, -0.0012731552, 0.042022705, 0.01360321, -0.018447876, 0.0041656494, -0.021743774, -0.038146973, 0.03189087, 0.01285553, 0.08557129, 0.009521484, -0.017669678, -0.038208008, 0.0004131794, 0.028167725, 0.014564514, 0.008529663, 0.00869751, 0.006717682, -0.008674622, -0.00894928, 0.024642944, -0.019424438, 0.006538391, 0.0287323, 0.0289917, -0.020706177, 0.018508911, -0.004547119, 0.039123535, 0.03656006, -0.019943237, -0.004096985, -0.03274536, 0.00554657, 0.027786255, 0.013496399, 0.009735107, 0.007827759, 0.010650635, -0.014793396, 0.011154175, 0.014930725, -0.02104187, 0.004070282, 0.00045728683, 0.0026283264, -0.021591187, 0.0029335022, 0.014907837, 0.013656616, -0.0036792755, -0.025390625, 0.021865845, -0.045684814, -0.066101074, -0.04058838, -0.00969696, -0.08679199, -0.047424316, 0.005722046, -0.07763672, -0.06347656, -0.044281006, 0.01663208, -0.09295654, -0.01033783, 0.0068855286, -0.017730713, 0.079711914, 0.015182495, -0.058380127, 0.0078086853, -0.02444458, 0.008117676, -0.0019454956, -0.05328369, 0.045684814, 0.07965088, -0.0039405823, 0.008506775, -0.042053223, 0.013206482, -0.05001831, 0.0046653748, 0.039031982, -0.026565552, 0.008361816, 0.04458618, 0.0015668869, 0.0014019012, -0.0005340576, 0.04348755, 0.07183838, -0.05105591, -0.004917145, 0.0552063, -0.020980835, -0.04824829, 0.021133423, -0.0051879883, -0.04232788, 0.025802612, 0.018920898, 0.012931824, 0.050842285, -0.013763428, 0.026901245, -0.0057029724, -0.06210327, -0.045074463, -0.0017175674, -0.008903503, 0.011123657, 0.011833191, 0.006549835, -0.0033664703, -0.033416748, -0.03161621, -0.015541077, -0.020370483, -0.025039673, -0.010017395, 0.0039100647, 0.008415222, -0.026611328, -0.020217896, -0.020950317, -0.00058698654, -0.006706238, -0.0036468506, 0.024856567, 0.016448975, -0.019561768, 0.0014247894, -0.005168915, 0.045440674, 0.013832092, -0.031158447, -0.07269287, -0.015602112, -0.017425537, -0.08569336, -0.038360596, -0.06854248, -0.021453857, -0.034301758, 0.01838684, -0.018295288, 0.019165039, 0.0005774498, 0.015434265, 0.05441284, 0.0006928444, -0.056671143, -0.031341553, -0.049713135, 0.016998291, 0.026153564, -0.03704834, -0.030136108, -0.007534027, 0.021194458, 0.024124146, -0.030822754, -0.018005371, 0.003232956, 0.02217102, 0.006576538, 0.0033340454, 0.01852417, 0.008644104, 0.007358551, -0.0029029846, 0.0027179718, 0.014427185, 0.011871338, 0.0012540817, -0.020446777, 0.064697266, 0.00014829636, -0.015777588, 0.017974854, 0.019515991, -0.019424438, 0.0138549805, -0.020324707, -0.026641846, 0.032073975, -0.011253357, -0.0025405884, -0.054382324, 0.004989624, 0.02067566, 0.006477356, 0.03768921, 0.006816864, -0.002494812, 0.015060425, 0.027648926, -0.009681702, 0.009178162, 0.0014686584, 0.0132369995, -0.026016235, -0.03869629, 0.01084137, 0.02305603, 0.017608643, 0.002708435, -0.008399963, -0.019104004, -0.0005598068, 0.012397766, -0.026824951, -0.004337311, 0.015533447, -0.006046295, -0.019958496, -0.027236938, 0.007926941, 0.0067710876, 0.02017212, 0.00082206726, -0.014472961, -0.047698975, 0.0065078735, -0.018814087, 0.01625061, -0.02508545, -0.011314392, -0.066101074, -0.042388916, -0.02053833, -0.034973145, -0.0012130737, 0.046203613, -0.014228821, -0.058807373, 0.026382446, -0.051605225, 0.038970947, -0.018157959, -0.04425049, -0.06945801, 0.0024642944, 0.02999878, 0.054870605, 0.0043945312, 0.03326416, -0.025253296, -0.012306213, 0.0076789856, 0.02293396, -0.01285553, -0.005302429, 0.0011034012, 0.062561035, 0.027633667, -0.01826477, -0.012245178, -0.009941101, -0.03829956, -0.021438599, -0.0010795593, -0.022415161, 0.005241394, -0.0011072159, -0.01448822, -0.020874023, -0.019866943, -0.028427124, -0.017150879, 0.015205383, 0.038330078, 0.0044288635, 0.0076560974, -0.016693115, -0.05545044, -0.025222778, -0.012214661, 0.008049011, -0.050109863, 0.007659912, -0.09399414, -0.025726318, 0.011413574, -0.017959595, -0.05404663, -0.022705078, -0.0018529892, 0.026779175, -0.0036582947, -0.00340271, -0.010787964, 0.0028419495, 0.008094788, 0.0014505386, -0.04559326, 0.03164673, -0.012832642, -0.0051574707, 0.0262146, 0.008735657, -0.0046424866, 0.0047721863, 0.008552551, -0.008613586, 0.023498535, -0.010246277, -0.017715454, -0.027740479, -0.013114929, 0.0037269592, 0.021484375, -0.02470398, -0.0053100586, -0.018981934, 0.00096845627, 0.05783081, -0.05657959, -0.024246216, 0.025238037, -0.01914978, -0.04522705, -0.0043945312, 0.030395508, 0.00031161308, -0.0027179718, 0.004016876, -0.032196045, 0.025268555, 0.0026550293, 0.008995056, -0.021911621, -0.000022351742, -0.03012085, -0.005596161, -0.0066986084, -0.020614624, 0.035858154, -0.016540527, -0.027435303, -0.03225708, -0.014167786, 0.012039185, 0.076293945, 0.053588867, 0.0023078918, -0.0132751465, -0.03152466, 0.007621765, 0.026473999, -0.0017967224, -0.010925293, 0.0010948181, -0.06604004, 0.056152344, 0.024841309, 0.07788086, -0.066711426, -0.0031414032, 0.03353882, 0.05090332, -0.005970001, -0.027572632, -0.040283203, 0.004047394, 0.05886841, -0.017852783, -0.0018424988, 0.0021018982, 0.026290894, 0.004032135, -0.039855957, -0.018676758, -0.028808594, -0.032714844, 0.008399963, 0.033447266, -0.014305115, 0.060913086, -0.005378723, 0.0262146, 0.07269287, -0.047454834, 0.051727295, -0.001408577, 0.058563232, 0.0020542145, 0.04397583, 0.00088596344, -0.03567505, 0.02709961, 0.032348633, -0.011474609, 0.0009741783, 0.015571594, 0.03100586, -0.045837402, -0.013618469, -0.07489014, 0.01550293, -0.038085938, 0.04107666, 0.0034732819, -0.010803223, 0.076416016, 0.031433105, 0.053588867, -0.06304932, 0.049835205, 0.009475708, -0.0023345947, -0.023605347, -0.008087158, -0.02508545, -0.019897461, 0.013961792, 0.003868103, 0.055358887, 0.007865906, 0.06317139, -0.05419922, -0.04006958, 0.017242432, 0.017822266, -0.023483276, 0.021499634, -0.012809753, 0.022201538, 0.049621582, -0.018203735, 0.03475952, 0.03414917, 0.024932861, 0.0032997131, -0.004928589, 0.014007568, -0.0018901825, 0.023086548, -0.0068130493, 0.015670776, -0.016448975, 0.0154953, -0.013320923, -0.018722534, 0.015609741, -0.00044059753, -0.033233643, 0.013595581, -0.00034499168, 0.036712646, -0.01727295, 0.07269287, -0.018722534, 0.011627197, -0.009994507, 0.026168823, 0.00021469593, -0.015213013, -0.009086609, -0.019195557, -0.019546509, 0.0043907166, 0.004425049, -0.021240234, 0.007270813, -0.026382446, 0.025299072, -0.025924683, -0.010864258, -0.036224365, -0.01864624, 0.045837402, -0.046569824, 0.0013208389, 0.008666992, 0.055419922, -0.026412964, -0.01637268, -0.025970459, -0.000001847744, -0.013427734, 0.012924194, 0.019760132, -0.02670288, -0.08276367, 0.03213501, 0.009498596, 0.07849121, 0.029266357, -0.0038471222, -0.0065841675, 0.003419876, 0.0027122498, -0.025817871, -0.011558533, 0.020950317, -0.01612854, -0.057922363, 0.041931152, 0.030227661, -0.04421997, -0.10650635, 0.041900635, -0.043762207, -0.02911377, -0.00032830238, 0.010070801, -0.022460938, -0.009887695, -0.004043579, -0.047912598, -0.0016880035, 0.014053345, 0.016586304, -0.042266846, 0.0362854, -0.026245117, -0.08831787, -0.021728516, -0.011672974, -0.024246216, -0.07952881, 0.006214142, -0.010261536, 0.017211914, 0.0053367615, -0.06945801, 0.067871094, 0.0070495605, 0.020263672, -0.011390686, -0.057678223, -0.0023555756, 0.037109375, 0.06274414, 0.022506714, -0.04034424, -0.04812622, -0.025375366, 0.020507812, 0.009300232, -0.014823914, 0.016983032, 0.05709839, -0.042175293, -0.012565613, -0.0062026978, 0.011375427, -0.0084991455, 0.0022335052, 0.014564514, -0.024047852, 0.002231598, 0.032470703, -0.0017251968, -0.0032691956, -0.010429382, 0.0043563843, -0.023880005, -0.013252258, 0.02633667, 0.011886597, 0.0023765564, -0.014419556, -0.0032138824, 0.013954163, -0.01676941, -0.0015220642, -0.02458191, 0.03201294, -0.03616333, -0.000644207, -0.01940918, 0.04208374, -0.07647705, -0.05895996, -0.06689453, -0.019454956, -0.05407715, -0.025115967, 0.00008904934, -0.055145264, 0.02645874, -0.0041999817, -0.034301758, 0.02911377, -0.0032787323, 0.011451721, -0.005683899, -0.0053634644, 0.0056152344, -0.01676941, 0.0061531067 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2002.05149v6
Self-explaining AI as an alternative to interpretable AI
Daniel C. Elton
cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, stat.ML, I.2.1; I.2.m
The ability to explain decisions made by AI systems is highly sought after, especially in domains where human lives are at stake such as medicine or autonomous vehicles. While it is often possible to approximate the input-output relations of deep neural networks with a few human-understandable rules, the discovery of the double descent phenomena suggests that such approximations do not accurately capture the mechanism by which deep neural networks work. Double descent indicates that deep neural networks typically operate by smoothly interpolating between data points rather than by extracting a few high level rules. As a result, neural networks trained on complex real world data are inherently hard to interpret and prone to failure if asked to extrapolate. To show how we might be able to trust AI despite these problems we introduce the concept of self-explaining AI. Self-explaining AIs are capable of providing a human-understandable explanation of each decision along with confidence levels for both the decision and explanation. For this approach to work, it is important that the explanation actually be related to the decision, ideally capturing the mechanism used to arrive at the explanation. Finally, we argue it is important that deep learning based systems include a "warning light" based on techniques from applicability domain analysis to warn the user if a model is asked to extrapolate outside its training distribution. For a video presentation of this talk see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Py7PVdcu7WY& .
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2002.05149v6
2020-07-02T19:03:24
2020-02-12T18:50:11
{ "title": [ -0.02444458, -0.0004911423, -0.023269653, -0.04373169, -0.014274597, -0.00018966198, -0.005256653, -0.016418457, -0.029510498, 0.015029907, -0.00299263, -0.010498047, -0.03640747, -0.034088135, -0.027328491, -0.016571045, 0.011802673, 0.030914307, 0.0044822693, -0.025894165, -0.015777588, -0.013763428, 0.045288086, 0.024887085, 0.021057129, -0.0519104, -0.06488037, 0.009689331, -0.013420105, -0.031341553, -0.0010919571, -0.001127243, 0.028884888, 0.029296875, -0.007320404, 0.024383545, -0.018615723, 0.020889282, 0.002822876, 0.012451172, -0.001616478, 0.0022258759, -0.020812988, -0.03543091, -0.021194458, 0.0093307495, -0.05432129, -0.013824463, -0.021514893, 0.036895752, 0.011169434, 0.017547607, -0.0055770874, 0.035949707, 0.020706177, -0.020111084, 0.002073288, -0.030395508, 0.029403687, 0.008514404, 0.014678955, -0.044830322, 0.04119873, 0.014770508, -0.031921387, -0.034240723, -0.0019779205, 0.02015686, 0.051605225, 0.013114929, -0.013259888, 0.019805908, 0.018981934, 0.00484848, -0.05734253, -0.024429321, 0.066223145, 0.013450623, 0.028427124, -0.049957275, 0.018630981, -0.027053833, 0.00730896, -0.01020813, 0.012413025, -0.01651001, 0.0033016205, -0.009269714, -0.039001465, -0.061462402, -0.0058631897, -0.014205933, -0.015296936, 0.004207611, -0.03552246, -0.018966675, -0.010810852, 0.0023765564, 0.00050640106, -0.020690918, -0.03060913, 0.013755798, -0.019134521, -0.02154541, 0.012756348, 0.02420044, -0.018234253, -0.03765869, -0.006462097, 0.033477783, -0.02468872, 0.009460449, 0.026107788, -0.01600647, 0.0064811707, 0.014678955, -0.0002399683, 0.031219482, 0.012062073, 0.054351807, -0.0067977905, -0.044281006, 0.03527832, 0.033355713, 0.020996094, 0.015396118, -0.05050659, -0.012031555, 0.049957275, 0.02758789, -0.0059509277, 0.03918457, -0.080444336, -0.08654785, -0.03579712, 0.031951904, -0.002204895, -0.016937256, -0.027557373, 0.0044136047, 0.015899658, -0.028518677, 0.0075035095, 0.010475159, -0.042785645, -0.012626648, 0.055023193, 0.022064209, -0.045410156, -0.06829834, -0.02178955, 0.015899658, 0.007259369, 0.018569946, -0.014228821, 0.019363403, -0.10003662, -0.0053977966, 0.02708435, 0.0340271, -0.0014514923, 0.0023231506, -0.0022792816, 0.0073127747, 0.05130005, -0.0049819946, -0.013931274, 0.020141602, 0.012229919, 0.010131836, 0.015472412, 0.016479492, 0.0012178421, -0.0005106926, 0.0073928833, -0.008781433, 0.0017375946, -0.0028800964, 0.015205383, -0.0026893616, 0.0070762634, -0.021316528, -0.012039185, 0.06262207, -0.06976318, 0.006954193, -0.007472992, 0.025527954, 0.041107178, 0.0090408325, -0.048614502, 0.04269409, -0.048065186, -0.008132935, -0.05102539, -0.006729126, 0.008026123, 0.043426514, -0.019378662, 0.020401001, -0.03805542, 0.036315918, -0.052886963, -0.00076532364, -0.03842163, -0.023330688, -0.01537323, 0.03781128, -0.027572632, 0.06036377, 0.059143066, 0.021087646, -0.044281006, 0.022338867, -0.006011963, -0.070373535, 0.004512787, -0.018157959, -0.028366089, -0.040008545, -0.015174866, -0.022857666, 0.0026302338, 0.06274414, 0.031829834, 0.018234253, 0.003490448, -0.0149002075, 0.07763672, 0.046081543, 0.08728027, -0.07696533, 0.061645508, 0.0012979507, -0.024765015, -0.021987915, -0.01802063, -0.036224365, -0.001376152, 0.047790527, 0.002450943, -0.017562866, -0.006401062, 0.0076446533, 0.06945801, 0.014190674, 0.018508911, -0.0051727295, 0.008300781, -0.0032043457, 0.06201172, -0.009307861, 0.067993164, 0.028030396, -0.009674072, 0.056488037, 0.012237549, -0.017425537, -0.005783081, 0.02619934, -0.0048980713, 0.04067993, 0.007545471, 0.022613525, -0.06274414, 0.019012451, -0.035369873, 0.010505676, -0.0131073, 0.007545471, 0.034332275, -0.0066871643, 0.008171082, -0.009422302, -0.0015392303, -0.008735657, -0.019317627, 0.016036987, 0.027816772, -0.05206299, 0.013702393, 0.009513855, 0.009864807, 0.0069351196, 0.032043457, 0.00869751, 0.021987915, 0.034240723, -0.032226562, -0.0017414093, 0.058776855, 0.03137207, 0.03491211, -0.021148682, -0.003211975, 0.004283905, 0.03213501, 0.058929443, -0.026382446, 0.010643005, -0.0680542, 0.015853882, 0.02458191, -0.011886597, 0.0039634705, -0.0023555756, 0.008834839, 0.02494812, -0.022613525, 0.0063476562, -0.082458496, -0.006839752, 0.0029945374, -0.04019165, -0.01108551, -0.03591919, -0.0074157715, -0.03842163, -0.030532837, 0.0002977848, 0.107055664, 0.011962891, -0.02822876, -0.017608643, -0.0022697449, -0.030548096, -0.015945435, -0.038024902, -0.028579712, 0.0015716553, 0.0345459, -0.007183075, -0.061309814, -0.0134887695, 0.0155181885, 0.034057617, -0.016082764, 0.02482605, -0.015823364, 0.010627747, 0.016403198, -0.008972168, 0.020111084, -0.041900635, 0.021255493, -0.046936035, 0.010574341, 0.00957489, -0.0101623535, -0.015975952, 0.026824951, -0.026275635, -0.031158447, 0.010810852, 0.050872803, -0.059936523, 0.0033454895, 0.04208374, 0.02772522, -0.012863159, 0.053619385, 0.0076789856, 0.02418518, -0.047210693, -0.0006175041, -0.058135986, -0.03100586, -0.0048179626, -0.0018501282, 0.029464722, -0.026565552, -0.01121521, -0.027832031, -0.00042581558, 0.006160736, -0.0010309219, -0.0018920898, -0.03479004, -0.029083252, -0.014846802, 0.0048179626, 0.032196045, -0.024780273, 0.031158447, 0.07775879, 0.018081665, -0.024383545, -0.012702942, 0.025131226, 0.012641907, -0.031921387, -0.035491943, -0.0039863586, -0.0073509216, 0.042144775, 0.011634827, -0.02720642, 0.021713257, -0.10681152, -0.004146576, 0.045318604, -0.003320694, -0.04486084, 0.03704834, -0.085876465, 0.011268616, -0.016326904, -0.02319336, 0.029769897, 0.027130127, -0.015579224, 0.003868103, 0.007209778, -0.043029785, 0.0072288513, -0.019699097, -0.13623047, 0.016220093, -0.015792847, -0.0026721954, -0.019943237, -0.003036499, -0.05343628, -0.0023860931, 0.008041382, 0.04849243, 0.045074463, 0.003824234, 0.0446167, -0.03378296, 0.01436615, -0.030929565, -0.002216339, -0.0057640076, -0.02609253, -0.0015659332, -0.020950317, 0.03387451, 0.028945923, -0.008743286, -0.031799316, -0.020339966, -0.040374756, 0.03161621, -0.014335632, -0.03253174, -0.028320312, -0.034820557, -0.041625977, 0.0049209595, -0.0126571655, 0.023757935, -0.054748535, 0.0030288696, -0.0084991455, 0.013877869, -0.012374878, 0.0060806274, -0.03640747, -0.016555786, 0.004749298, -0.0076560974, -0.057250977, -0.02418518, 0.02708435, -0.01966858, 0.05142212, -0.033355713, -0.043121338, 0.042114258, -0.0368042, -0.0057792664, -0.0036716461, 0.0037441254, 0.009010315, 0.021606445, -0.029556274, 0.008468628, -0.03652954, 0.022766113, 0.004699707, -0.004550934, 0.009552002, -0.07244873, -0.007820129, 0.010887146, -0.10888672, -0.024536133, 0.009170532, -0.045806885, -0.029251099, -0.06573486, 0.020370483, -0.052246094, -0.044311523, -0.009422302, -0.020065308, 0.0032463074, -0.0116119385, -0.06732178, -0.04324341, 0.06719971, -0.027511597, 0.0012893677, 0.056671143, -0.024795532, -0.031433105, -0.016952515, 0.020889282, 0.041137695, 0.025375366, 0.003435135, -0.040527344, 0.04345703, -0.04638672, 0.012969971, 0.021118164, -0.018127441, -0.0046958923, 0.022247314, -0.022827148, 0.03173828, -0.023376465, 0.05392456, 0.035095215, -0.031234741, -0.046661377, 0.050689697, -0.015602112, -0.048095703, 0.03375244, 0.009216309, 0.006340027, 0.02532959, -0.0052490234, 0.055786133, -0.010536194, 0.008522034, 0.025482178, -0.015312195, -0.034820557, -0.008468628, 0.02835083, 0.013420105, 0.016281128, 0.002910614, 0.0069503784, 0.043914795, -0.02418518, -0.0027484894, 0.00021278858, 0.0037670135, -0.014312744, 0.015686035, -0.05529785, -0.040863037, -0.0368042, 0.015045166, -0.007545471, 0.021591187, 0.022125244, -0.013870239, -0.025283813, 0.011116028, 0.028366089, 0.00040912628, 0.0014562607, -0.055114746, -0.0075531006, -0.028015137, -0.07183838, -0.046051025, -0.010948181, 0.020401001, 0.005607605, 0.009063721, -0.027679443, 0.02961731, 0.015281677, 0.07647705, 0.05279541, -0.011528015, -0.048431396, 0.0715332, -0.026382446, -0.02067566, 0.02255249, -0.01940918, -0.0066604614, -0.03378296, 0.024765015, -0.016983032, -0.008583069, -0.05807495, 0.030166626, -0.024917603, 0.065979004, 0.0065841675, 0.0035362244, 0.027160645, 0.008796692, 0.010231018, 0.008308411, -0.031188965, 0.004634857, -0.00056123734, 0.06732178, -0.03302002, 0.014457703, 0.024383545, 0.031173706, 0.008232117, -0.021102905, 0.030151367, 0.0032157898, -0.010627747, 0.005027771, 0.028457642, -0.035125732, -0.028274536, 0.0032691956, 0.009407043, 0.051483154, -0.06707764, 0.05697632, -0.00008165836, 0.000300169, 0.019073486, -0.0037765503, 0.03488159, -0.011314392, 0.024917603, -0.06311035, -0.035949707, -0.008468628, 0.021316528, -0.02418518, 0.0009264946, 0.020706177, 0.01838684, 0.025939941, 0.05722046, 0.034301758, -0.019439697, 0.028030396, -0.016571045, -0.012908936, -0.016174316, -0.044952393, 0.012298584, -0.014831543, 0.020996094, -0.04522705, 0.047576904, -0.04901123, 0.031097412, 0.0043678284, -0.028305054, 0.026565552, -0.06414795, 0.040161133, 0.09106445, -0.025726318, 0.05029297, 0.015449524, 0.014556885, 0.022247314, 0.039489746, -0.0042648315, 0.03640747, 0.009864807, -0.034729004, -0.013717651, -0.0029449463, 0.033721924, 0.036834717, 0.007205963, 0.026794434, 0.014282227, -0.042907715, 0.016693115, 0.010795593, 0.013641357, 0.013504028, -0.049713135, 0.002817154, 0.02670288, 0.025283813, 0.027038574, -0.0496521, -0.04660034, -0.018295288, -0.023590088, -0.04840088, 0.01763916, 0.0049972534, -0.013969421, -0.052642822, 0.01411438, -0.018554688, 0.0042304993, -0.0017194748, 0.015449524, -0.029785156, 0.016738892, 0.044158936, -0.037322998, 0.0016174316, -0.028869629, -0.003484726, 0.044128418, 0.028625488, 0.005821228, 0.013458252, -0.0042495728, -0.059265137, -0.023468018, -0.0019626617, -0.018432617, -0.0025978088, -0.0050201416, -0.037963867, -0.03778076, 0.020187378, 0.014129639, -0.0045204163, -0.0552063, 0.035949707, 0.017913818, 0.026290894, -0.009155273, 0.03225708, -0.010101318, 0.00082731247, 0.026931763, -0.0206604, 0.027801514, -0.01965332, 0.0038986206, -0.003479004, -0.047607422, 0.0076942444, 0.016311646, 0.0079956055, -0.0022830963, -0.008308411, 0.030288696, 0.009284973, -0.018615723, 0.016326904, 0.091674805, -0.060150146, -0.01979065, -0.030593872, -0.000008225441, -0.03387451, 0.031311035, -0.017028809, -0.022888184, -0.023361206, -0.04034424, -0.021728516, -0.0063552856, 0.013542175, 0.012390137, 0.019256592, -0.037078857, -0.007282257, -0.030075073, 0.0084991455, -0.025497437, 0.03656006, -0.010681152, -0.011634827, 0.0045661926, 0.0002090931, -0.0019359589, -0.03564453, 0.029418945, 0.04473877, 0.027877808, 0.009994507, -0.047454834, -0.008880615, -0.045562744, -0.019592285, 0.040222168, 0.038970947, -0.024536133, 0.033416748, -0.03768921, 0.0637207, 0.0049591064, 0.023391724, 0.028366089, 0.04953003, 0.035491943, -0.02760315, 0.030303955, -0.015640259, 0.029800415, -0.0803833, -0.00023078918, -0.07116699, -0.007484436, -0.08831787, -0.024032593, 0.016220093, 0.022323608, 0.024261475, 0.002861023, 0.020523071, 0.0035743713, 0.039978027, 0.033416748, 0.06750488, 0.013458252, 0.0026054382, -0.013786316, -0.016784668, 0.014205933, 0.031036377, 0.012771606, 0.023651123, -0.009674072, -0.0317688, 0.03277588, 0.007270813, 0.021957397, -0.051361084, -0.026504517, -0.04272461, 0.003484726, -0.019866943, -0.010551453, 0.06222534, 0.058502197, -0.016906738, -0.014312744, 0.029342651, -0.025497437, -0.005542755, -0.03579712, 0.022659302, -0.07232666, 0.026687622, 0.0044517517, -0.025009155, -0.031433105, 0.03164673, 0.042938232, -0.019989014, 0.007751465, 0.026351929, 0.029067993, -0.007003784, -0.0064697266, -0.04434204, -0.010749817, 0.0006122589, 0.004753113, 0.00072431564, -0.0118637085, 0.018493652, 0.031585693, 0.004085541, -0.011436462, -0.001291275, 0.023223877, -0.03656006, 0.022506714, -0.006793976, 0.030563354, -0.03552246, -0.049804688, 0.017807007, 0.003484726, -0.05166626, -0.009162903, 0.026382446, 0.026504517, 0.004699707, 0.06359863, 0.0017766953, -0.023162842, -0.028717041, -0.006313324, 0.053741455, 0.016235352, -0.03253174, 0.01876831, -0.031585693, -0.022567749, 0.03704834, -0.0013923645, 0.070373535, -0.024963379, 0.00472641, -0.027572632, 0.029312134, 0.013793945, -0.04034424, -0.029266357, -0.007713318, 0.022705078, -0.017715454, 0.010551453, -0.025619507, -0.010147095, 0.022079468, 0.025375366, 0.040802002, 0.009605408, -0.0031833649, -0.0491333, -0.038024902, 0.048858643, 0.02116394, 0.06414795, 0.0017490387, -0.0063705444, -0.014083862, 0.020065308, -0.018188477, -0.018203735, -0.026794434, 0.020217896, -0.025161743, -0.00032162666, -0.0025043488, 0.015075684, -0.01651001, 0.011810303, -0.03945923, 0.03503418, -0.01914978, 0.01071167, 0.030853271, -0.026489258, -0.04699707, 0.0034255981, -0.040252686, 0.039794922, 0.017852783, -0.035827637, 0.0131073, 0.0045814514, -0.028121948, -0.022109985, -0.011314392, 0.026947021, -0.012794495, -0.04321289, -0.010169983, 0.014984131, 0.033966064, -0.066833496, -0.0826416, 0.00022602081, 0.045928955, 0.0022659302, 0.09136963, 0.007598877, 0.010765076, -0.013046265, 0.009857178, -0.01020813, -0.026275635, -0.028839111, 0.0032367706, 0.029403687, 0.053375244, -0.015655518, -0.0084991455, 0.0234375, -0.00605011, 0.0039634705, 0.01158905, 0.010803223, 0.02015686, 0.0035381317, 0.030258179, -0.04144287, -0.020477295, -0.025939941, 0.0124435425, 0.0015087128, 0.03375244, -0.013084412, 0.013252258, 0.00011634827, 0.08306885, -0.021850586, -0.062408447, 0.036468506, 0.038024902, 0.0023002625, 0.058898926, -0.01058197, -0.041870117, -0.0072631836, 0.020248413, 0.00081539154, 0.017822266, 0.016952515, -0.011703491, 0.017974854, -0.06707764, -0.05709839, -0.032836914, -0.02368164, 0.027404785, -0.053894043, 0.022720337, -0.033294678, -0.015823364, 0.011100769, 0.0309906, 0.022399902, 0.00046133995, -0.06323242, -0.021697998, 0.0317688, -0.029891968 ], "summary": [ 0.024291992, -0.01159668, 0.018417358, 0.021224976, -0.022872925, -0.01977539, 0.054840088, -0.03845215, -0.060760498, -0.0065574646, -0.025650024, 0.0062713623, -0.05569458, -0.034179688, 0.026290894, -0.07800293, 0.014579773, 0.017044067, 0.04107666, -0.007419586, 0.001543045, -0.0021781921, 0.054260254, 0.022338867, 0.008018494, -0.0206604, -0.01713562, 0.023956299, 0.026306152, 0.016494751, 0.021636963, -0.052215576, 0.003572464, 0.002023697, 0.01739502, 0.027328491, 0.02619934, 0.009307861, 0.01184845, 0.038208008, 0.01473999, -0.020248413, 0.083740234, -0.06384277, 0.038909912, 0.02798462, 0.00894165, -0.06726074, 0.0049819946, 0.046844482, 0.015029907, -0.020050049, -0.00007981062, 0.028060913, -0.013595581, -0.018676758, -0.0073661804, -0.06726074, 0.009346008, 0.037963867, 0.04711914, -0.011230469, 0.0039634705, -0.015304565, -0.031219482, 0.0032482147, 0.037841797, -0.023391724, 0.02268982, -0.027755737, -0.008148193, 0.040893555, 0.023529053, -0.025619507, -0.0072898865, -0.021347046, 0.048217773, 0.020935059, -0.006958008, -0.015960693, 0.049682617, -0.054138184, -0.0021038055, 0.008049011, 0.009269714, 0.003929138, 0.015579224, -0.009941101, 0.008232117, 0.0036563873, -0.006275177, -0.027755737, -0.0178833, 0.05441284, 0.001288414, -0.02722168, -0.010879517, -0.033599854, 0.015007019, 0.013504028, -0.01083374, -0.031036377, 0.0062026978, -0.02017212, -0.0046691895, 0.049346924, 0.01537323, -0.07714844, -0.021270752, -0.009284973, -0.02418518, -0.0022335052, -0.007865906, -0.08544922, 0.031097412, 0.03942871, -0.0051651, 0.050872803, 0.0390625, -0.00032544136, -0.016662598, -0.008392334, 0.009544373, 0.019119263, 0.039215088, 0.016036987, -0.010429382, 0.0031719208, 0.07006836, 0.06390381, -0.01259613, -0.010223389, -0.019989014, -0.038970947, -0.0463562, -0.023391724, -0.022064209, 0.018096924, 0.014282227, -0.009544373, 0.033233643, -0.026184082, 0.012237549, 0.031585693, -0.040771484, -0.005569458, 0.015342712, 0.016082764, -0.009719849, -0.036346436, 0.00071668625, -0.02268982, 0.022018433, -0.0074501038, -0.016036987, -0.026168823, -0.057495117, -0.0104522705, 0.03781128, 0.018173218, -0.0047683716, 0.010696411, 0.029067993, 0.043823242, 0.0284729, 0.001121521, -0.030319214, -0.00004863739, 0.016693115, -0.07305908, 0.048065186, -0.0029468536, -0.057525635, -0.025146484, 0.027755737, -0.009933472, -0.015777588, -0.0018625259, -0.0104904175, 0.014144897, -0.01473999, -0.057861328, -0.044403076, 0.022583008, -0.03253174, 0.06225586, -0.031585693, 0.041412354, 0.025512695, 0.0007891655, -0.052642822, 0.04159546, 0.004096985, 0.0066337585, -0.035369873, -0.027740479, 0.0058517456, 0.031707764, -0.03062439, 0.017669678, -0.010604858, 0.04144287, -0.02758789, -0.009300232, -0.115112305, 0.028518677, -0.045043945, 0.054473877, -0.021560669, 0.033996582, 0.04547119, 0.0077705383, -0.06124878, 0.046966553, 0.014190674, -0.028030396, 0.04336548, -0.011741638, -0.042907715, -0.017959595, -0.03918457, 0.012741089, -0.051208496, 0.079589844, -0.0044517517, 0.019973755, -0.00756073, 0.025009155, 0.060455322, 0.042297363, 0.07122803, -0.08215332, 0.051818848, 0.0020656586, -0.04937744, -0.021133423, -0.004508972, -0.061828613, 0.011047363, 0.073791504, 0.023971558, -0.005672455, -0.021255493, -0.009094238, 0.019577026, 0.021911621, 0.024398804, -0.02609253, -0.021270752, -0.052459717, 0.05343628, -0.05279541, 0.06109619, -0.042938232, 0.0060768127, 0.044403076, 0.0035552979, 0.008071899, -0.0036811829, -0.023544312, -0.0005173683, 0.031021118, 0.018203735, 0.011054993, -0.051849365, -0.03869629, -0.05581665, -0.049804688, 0.017044067, -0.030807495, 0.030395508, -0.039215088, -0.011520386, -0.03805542, -0.013076782, -0.060516357, -0.04034424, 0.054992676, -0.0021686554, -0.061523438, 0.02658081, 0.01550293, -0.011375427, -0.014762878, 0.027648926, 0.02659607, 0.0128479, 0.039154053, 0.023468018, 0.068359375, 0.053741455, 0.05645752, 0.035980225, 0.0029792786, 0.007320404, 0.030197144, -0.0103302, 0.025497437, 0.013145447, -0.0043258667, -0.06402588, 0.033813477, 0.008560181, -0.0049591064, 0.023376465, 0.0034999847, 0.042266846, 0.0037212372, -0.005634308, 0.021072388, -0.061553955, -0.011619568, 0.002161026, 0.0121536255, -0.019866943, -0.038391113, -0.011878967, 0.01789856, -0.015548706, 0.03970337, 0.09814453, 0.03768921, 0.04486084, 0.01020813, 0.030731201, -0.06652832, 0.027709961, -0.020614624, -0.054595947, -0.0035438538, 0.0060157776, -0.040039062, -0.009742737, -0.0031204224, 0.0051498413, 0.00067043304, 0.0015773773, 0.030532837, 0.0047912598, -0.0047836304, 0.040771484, -0.0020046234, 0.01197052, 0.018737793, -0.053649902, 0.021759033, -0.004383087, 0.021759033, -0.015129089, -0.03704834, 0.016952515, -0.038970947, -0.04510498, 0.006515503, -0.015357971, -0.03277588, 0.06359863, 0.040008545, -0.012077332, -0.014213562, 0.033691406, -0.010139465, -0.03326416, -0.1005249, 0.014755249, -0.009979248, -0.05355835, -0.046722412, 0.019760132, 0.03378296, -0.050964355, 0.056365967, -0.022232056, -0.003211975, 0.009391785, 0.0076179504, 0.06768799, -0.012161255, -0.020858765, 0.029724121, 0.01222229, 0.018112183, -0.026550293, -0.013511658, 0.021987915, 0.0008029938, -0.027282715, -0.0262146, 0.046447754, 0.029418945, 0.0029830933, -0.037200928, 0.03829956, -0.03768921, 0.05899048, 0.004512787, -0.040100098, 0.062347412, -0.058380127, -0.024978638, 0.008285522, 0.0046920776, -0.000644207, 0.003730774, -0.035491943, 0.04196167, -0.018035889, -0.011367798, 0.004047394, -0.011276245, 0.004135132, -0.022415161, -0.001077652, -0.017150879, 0.027740479, -0.027175903, -0.008132935, -0.010055542, 0.012542725, -0.024169922, -0.04296875, 0.080444336, -0.011726379, 0.011482239, 0.04208374, 0.029632568, 0.002998352, -0.031097412, 0.05090332, 0.013000488, 0.020202637, -0.0065689087, -0.007896423, 0.028808594, -0.021972656, 0.045806885, 0.0042533875, 0.00044488907, 0.03451538, -0.049224854, -0.058776855, -0.04675293, -0.047790527, 0.001832962, -0.012077332, -0.013511658, -0.03717041, -0.04849243, -0.07098389, -0.02394104, 0.0053100586, 0.043304443, -0.013000488, 0.031799316, 0.021057129, 0.008171082, -0.038848877, 0.013916016, 0.03933716, -0.0103302, 0.01550293, -0.010055542, -0.010345459, -0.0020694733, 0.032592773, -0.0034942627, 0.023452759, -0.011192322, -0.039215088, 0.038635254, -0.008415222, -0.036956787, -0.031433105, -0.014968872, 0.00027441978, -0.037872314, 0.018005371, 0.01689148, 0.039611816, 0.0034427643, -0.029678345, 0.010887146, -0.029266357, -0.014060974, -0.02368164, 0.009742737, -0.026550293, -0.015029907, 0.0053253174, -0.0385437, 0.0076141357, -0.07354736, 0.044525146, -0.072631836, -0.032806396, -0.014282227, -0.036895752, 0.10809326, 0.013130188, -0.056915283, 0.036895752, -0.044525146, 0.031555176, -0.0010433197, -0.00793457, -0.021591187, -0.014793396, 0.0211792, 0.027679443, 0.027404785, -0.022109985, 0.012313843, -0.019485474, 0.031158447, -0.04626465, 0.021972656, -0.020889282, 0.042419434, -0.04724121, -0.0033874512, 0.021774292, 0.06500244, -0.033050537, -0.0005903244, 0.047729492, 0.0013570786, -0.051361084, 0.04498291, -0.032440186, -0.047546387, 0.044952393, 0.080322266, -0.0027828217, 0.01727295, -0.04626465, -0.012535095, -0.02633667, -0.02003479, 0.023880005, 0.026611328, -0.0368042, -0.027908325, 0.003314972, 0.053100586, 0.0036525726, 0.019454956, 0.012260437, 0.026412964, -0.06964111, 0.0069885254, 0.0017433167, 0.0029335022, -0.016708374, -0.03387451, -0.0057411194, 0.024002075, -0.0076293945, -0.006198883, 0.011291504, 0.024642944, -0.007484436, 0.0066719055, -0.0008158684, 0.0024490356, 0.024353027, 0.032714844, -0.04220581, -0.06274414, -0.07562256, -0.014808655, -0.033447266, -0.0079574585, 0.001707077, -0.023284912, -0.022079468, -0.012313843, -0.025909424, 0.020568848, 0.016723633, 0.054351807, 0.0020256042, -0.00598526, -0.0513916, -0.0030384064, -0.035125732, 0.014167786, 0.05731201, -0.004512787, 0.02230835, 0.010261536, 0.0149383545, -0.022979736, -0.022705078, -0.030731201, -0.0067710876, 0.008552551, 0.0025157928, 0.0037136078, 0.0005760193, 0.0017709732, 0.009048462, 0.02720642, 0.011962891, -0.014167786, -0.00051021576, 0.01977539, 0.021652222, 0.0050468445, -0.014282227, -0.0126571655, 0.010612488, -0.017532349, 0.015571594, 0.023040771, 0.010093689, 0.0059051514, 0.012466431, 0.022079468, 0.05923462, 0.009033203, 0.058654785, 0.040374756, 0.031433105, 0.01902771, 0.01689148, -0.022583008, -0.016647339, 0.004901886, -0.014595032, 0.006175995, -0.0010900497, 0.009284973, -0.009140015, -0.04034424, 0.0014696121, -0.011260986, 0.030044556, -0.02180481, 0.009391785, 0.034088135, 0.014465332, 0.021347046, 0.014854431, -0.028289795, 0.01121521, -0.024047852, -0.00076532364, -0.0037841797, -0.016815186, 0.01600647, -0.001253128, 0.0047073364, -0.016052246, 0.0032653809, 0.014335632, 0.031707764, 0.00944519, -0.020507812, 0.018325806, -0.05380249, -0.012458801, -0.0007901192, -0.046691895, 0.0082473755, 0.09283447, 0.013595581, 0.013755798, 0.017654419, 0.0109939575, 0.0022945404, -0.025436401, -0.018417358, 0.019165039, 0.0038890839, 0.023162842, 0.014045715, 0.003156662, 0.0036354065, 0.0016508102, -0.020111084, 0.0028133392, -0.007965088, 0.008079529, -0.040283203, 0.025741577, 0.004886627, 0.08734131, 0.047912598, -0.011383057, -0.040740967, -0.015411377, 0.008796692, -0.03314209, -0.0152282715, 0.02079773, -0.014198303, -0.009490967, -0.030456543, -0.020889282, -0.026046753, 0.015197754, -0.00015830994, 0.02116394, 0.0035514832, -0.024658203, 0.009681702, -0.002336502, 0.0053596497, -0.048828125, -0.016311646, -0.030975342, 0.022735596, -0.050964355, -0.005050659, -0.00680542, 0.008728027, -0.0113220215, -0.03363037, -0.025466919, 0.050567627, 0.01889038, 0.04333496, 0.012634277, -0.013908386, 0.019943237, -0.02998352, -0.04296875, 0.044891357, 0.008117676, 0.019577026, -0.024230957, 0.015808105, -0.015403748, -0.006164551, 0.028182983, -0.04626465, 0.0026569366, 0.0009794235, 0.031341553, -0.028518677, -0.01852417, -0.0069999695, 0.0289917, 0.016052246, 0.022094727, -0.016433716, 0.01586914, -0.057617188, 0.0128479, -0.005470276, 0.06161499, -0.042510986, -0.015823364, -0.046783447, 0.013755798, -0.041778564, -0.020370483, -0.010437012, 0.0059547424, 0.014457703, -0.028961182, -0.0041160583, -0.02305603, 0.009674072, -0.007484436, 0.014915466, -0.0029964447, -0.018081665, -0.028564453, -0.037719727, 0.0038146973, 0.004699707, -0.021697998, -0.05001831, 0.09136963, -0.02357483, 0.0014095306, -0.017074585, 0.013549805, 0.022720337, 0.005783081, 0.026046753, -0.029342651, 0.0058670044, -0.015403748, 0.021942139, -0.0046577454, 0.019226074, 0.016174316, -0.01914978, 0.014205933, 0.024612427, 0.04156494, -0.013504028, 0.004421234, 0.0050086975, 0.037231445, -0.008911133, -0.027648926, 0.0029315948, 0.06036377, -0.019104004, -0.033966064, -0.050689697, -0.045288086, -0.016143799, -0.018692017, 0.023239136, -0.047912598, 0.07019043, -0.018844604, -0.013916016, 0.013069153, -0.032470703, 0.05291748, -0.022750854, 0.049468994, 0.012435913, 0.010978699, -0.031921387, -0.021392822, 0.023544312, -0.0043296814, 0.048675537, 0.016189575, -0.026000977, 0.057617188, -0.008331299, -0.015541077, -0.09454346, -0.013626099, -0.060180664, -0.0066490173, -0.016815186, 0.013618469, 0.025100708, 0.038604736, 0.011894226, 0.010292053, 0.034454346, -0.0011014938, 0.009399414, -0.02973938, -0.016082764, -0.002298355, 0.005580902, 0.021469116, -0.011161804, 0.019882202, 0.06744385, 0.053009033, 0.008995056, 0.05871582, 0.017623901, -0.012535095, -0.030563354, -0.022521973, -0.044952393, -0.0046653748, 0.029342651, -0.022720337, -0.005683899, -0.03778076, 0.01448822, -0.014564514, 0.008262634, 0.015686035, -0.032806396, 0.04623413, -0.051849365, 0.025756836, -0.024856567, -0.0054397583, -0.004211426, -0.027023315, -0.001294136, 0.02458191, -0.006816864, 0.024551392, 0.005138397, 0.01474762, -0.00040221214, 0.0037441254, -0.030670166, -0.0046081543, 0.008712769, -0.01499176, 0.04901123, -0.0107803345, -0.032806396, -0.02760315, 0.029708862, 0.033721924, 0.03793335, 0.07067871, 0.032714844, -0.029037476, 0.010253906, -0.023223877, -0.0011005402, -0.05029297, -0.0031795502, 0.03375244, -0.009849548, 0.012245178, 0.008079529, 0.038391113, -0.012130737, 0.039093018, 0.007881165, -0.027389526, 0.047454834, 0.021057129, -0.02848816, -0.028182983, 0.045654297, 0.06518555, 0.042938232, 0.11846924, 0.05404663, -0.00504303, -0.0061531067, 0.05609131, -0.016220093, -0.026245117, -0.025161743, 0.058380127, 0.022338867, -0.023757935, 0.018447876, 0.023483276, -0.017105103, 0.010551453, 0.011100769, 0.01965332, -0.007144928, 0.061157227, 0.030899048, -0.0063056946, -0.004878998, 0.04043579, -0.05557251, 0.016418457, -0.04232788, 0.008735657, 0.030258179, 0.018112183, -0.0025558472, -0.021453857, 0.01902771, 0.010673523, 0.017837524, -0.023254395, -0.04046631, 0.022659302, 0.024368286, -0.0385437, -0.07470703, 0.037719727, 0.023529053, 0.03100586, 0.025039673, -0.03918457, -0.013191223, 0.0013179779, 0.020950317, 0.0087509155, -0.0046844482, -0.0077171326, 0.025222778, 0.058013916, 0.02180481, -0.03643799, 0.019592285, 0.004535675, -0.029586792, -0.030853271, -0.00365448, 0.019439697, -0.030731201, 0.017211914, -0.005859375, -0.049713135, -0.022109985, -0.028015137, 0.013069153, -0.0035438538, -0.022735596, 0.023468018, -0.0022220612, -0.02154541, 0.074157715, -0.00207901, -0.024490356, -0.007041931, 0.026855469, 0.0005736351, 0.039886475, -0.013114929, -0.02809143, 0.001791954, -0.0096206665, 0.002023697, 0.018844604, 0.044281006, -0.064086914, -0.024673462, -0.06530762, -0.03451538, 0.016235352, -0.0065345764, 0.022323608, -0.040161133, 0.016662598, 0.004573822, -0.021942139, 0.029327393, 0.020355225, 0.040618896, 0.042236328, -0.021270752, 0.02796936, -0.0006828308, -0.02217102 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2002.10870v2
AMP Chain Graphs: Minimal Separators and Structure Learning Algorithms
Mohammad Ali Javidian, Marco Valtorta, Pooyan Jamshidi
cs.AI, cs.DS, cs.LG, stat.ML
We address the problem of finding a minimal separator in an Andersson-Madigan-Perlman chain graph (AMP CG), namely, finding a set Z of nodes that separates a given nonadjacent pair of nodes such that no proper subset of Z separates that pair. We analyze several versions of this problem and offer polynomial-time algorithms for each. These include finding a minimal separator from a restricted set of nodes, finding a minimal separator for two given disjoint sets, and testing whether a given separator is minimal. To address the problem of learning the structure of AMP CGs from data, we show that the PC-like algorithm (Pena, 2012) is order-dependent, in the sense that the output can depend on the order in which the variables are given. We propose several modifications of the PC-like algorithm that remove part or all of this order-dependence. We also extend the decomposition-based approach for learning Bayesian networks (BNs) proposed by (Xie et al., 2006) to learn AMP CGs, which include BNs as a special case, under the faithfulness assumption. We prove the correctness of our extension using the minimal separator results. Using standard benchmarks and synthetically generated models and data in our experiments demonstrate the competitive performance of our decomposition-based method, called LCD-AMP, in comparison with the (modified versions of) PC-like algorithm. The LCD-AMP algorithm usually outperforms the PC-like algorithm, and our modifications of the PC-like algorithm learn structures that are more similar to the underlying ground truth graphs than the original PC-like algorithm, especially in high-dimensional settings. In particular, we empirically show that the results of both algorithms are more accurate and stabler when the sample size is reasonably large and the underlying graph is sparse.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2002.10870v2
2020-08-04T20:38:42
2020-02-24T18:14:14
{ "title": [ -0.03933716, 0.00026655197, -0.06542969, -0.06317139, 0.010551453, 0.012619019, -0.05593872, 0.0026779175, -0.009590149, 0.026321411, -0.004852295, 0.020751953, -0.029403687, -0.024398804, -0.01348114, 0.004310608, 0.0060043335, 0.01576233, -0.013999939, -0.013458252, -0.052520752, -0.008956909, 0.038238525, 0.044128418, 0.001914978, 0.00472641, 0.005054474, -0.0006289482, -0.016662598, -0.014862061, -0.000954628, -0.028320312, 0.052978516, 0.022476196, -0.004825592, 0.032958984, -0.039001465, 0.021606445, 0.0036811829, 0.016693115, 0.02355957, -0.0112838745, 0.0000564456, -0.03378296, -0.020477295, 0.005268097, -0.038726807, -0.028335571, -0.022628784, 0.029205322, 0.002243042, 0.028778076, -0.030792236, 0.045440674, 0.014862061, -0.03390503, -0.025161743, -0.01713562, 0.036193848, 0.1015625, 0.017211914, -0.034484863, -0.008270264, -0.043914795, -0.05480957, -0.0071144104, -0.0135650635, 0.022903442, 0.06958008, -0.0141067505, -0.024261475, 0.02696228, 0.014541626, 0.03451538, -0.05822754, -0.02607727, 0.054351807, 0.019119263, 0.03845215, -0.031677246, 0.008514404, 0.0003118515, -0.02809143, -0.027175903, 0.03125, -0.02130127, -0.018356323, -0.018798828, -0.011131287, -0.0340271, -0.004611969, 0.018478394, -0.0033435822, 0.013343811, -0.022567749, -0.022369385, -0.016647339, 0.0032138824, 0.008117676, -0.0030765533, 0.006111145, -0.0095825195, -0.007045746, -0.01586914, 0.009185791, 0.032684326, -0.0019989014, -0.03579712, 0.013336182, 0.024337769, -0.0060691833, 0.048736572, -0.00082302094, 0.013648987, 0.013252258, 0.006126404, -0.015594482, 0.031066895, -0.0032577515, 0.044647217, 0.0042419434, -0.013549805, -0.0017061234, 0.004863739, 0.012496948, 0.0062408447, -0.034210205, 0.0039482117, -0.021331787, 0.011749268, 0.020309448, 0.033843994, -0.08721924, -0.03717041, -0.031188965, 0.04574585, 0.032226562, -0.006454468, -0.008361816, 0.015045166, 0.0036449432, -0.03189087, -0.018447876, -0.012924194, -0.006111145, 0.049316406, 0.0579834, -0.039489746, -0.041137695, -0.052215576, -0.046661377, 0.003862381, 0.034484863, -0.0032348633, -0.0657959, -0.010406494, -0.1373291, -0.0033836365, 0.020401001, 0.013328552, 0.031036377, -0.004814148, -0.03213501, 0.030975342, 0.074279785, -0.017044067, -0.02003479, 0.04473877, 0.025970459, 0.06088257, -0.013809204, 0.015174866, 0.01902771, 0.007286072, -0.018829346, 0.0044937134, 0.05709839, -0.035339355, 0.014877319, 0.0259552, 0.008216858, 0.0028858185, -0.050689697, 0.06329346, -0.07385254, -0.007068634, -0.0050086975, 0.00034594536, 0.058380127, -0.0030269623, -0.012718201, 0.010482788, -0.027496338, -0.041259766, -0.030151367, -0.0032520294, 0.05596924, 0.04171753, 0.009925842, -0.019760132, -0.07080078, 0.00687027, -0.059753418, 0.081848145, 0.0647583, -0.04623413, 0.017166138, -0.013496399, -0.0501709, 0.028656006, 0.06695557, -0.010887146, -0.03604126, 0.01852417, 0.012710571, -0.041168213, 0.0062713623, 0.011985779, -0.0071907043, 0.002412796, -0.00749588, -0.03552246, 0.0062332153, 0.05117798, 0.015625, -0.005054474, -0.017181396, -0.03451538, -0.013885498, 0.02532959, -0.0007953644, 0.010139465, 0.026626587, 0.017715454, -0.019989014, -0.011528015, -0.022994995, 0.020446777, -0.007534027, 0.004753113, -0.0013933182, 0.009628296, -0.022277832, 0.013710022, 0.06347656, 0.0030841827, 0.009399414, 0.021591187, -0.00052690506, 0.015777588, 0.06945801, 0.060668945, 0.04159546, 0.05770874, -0.0042495728, 0.072631836, -0.0043525696, 0.04498291, -0.035125732, 0.0055885315, -0.01789856, 0.029312134, 0.015731812, 0.011009216, -0.014816284, 0.01600647, 0.0035362244, 0.033843994, 0.008293152, 0.031555176, 0.01210022, -0.0236969, 0.014892578, -0.014297485, -0.03503418, -0.01966858, -0.0019197464, 0.007419586, 0.001868248, -0.06488037, -0.008323669, 0.012542725, 0.043762207, 0.0046195984, 0.023284912, -0.022872925, 0.023742676, 0.0025348663, -0.0005297661, -0.0003759861, 0.045135498, 0.03942871, 0.019256592, -0.008712769, -0.010055542, 0.020217896, 0.06640625, 0.08898926, -0.04574585, 0.046539307, -0.06185913, 0.010948181, 0.025512695, -0.04071045, 0.0012025833, 0.04989624, 0.06048584, -0.0032310486, -0.028182983, -0.013191223, -0.027999878, -0.009925842, -0.015602112, -0.04067993, -0.06591797, -0.056732178, -0.013183594, -0.06414795, -0.039764404, -0.001502037, 0.08166504, -0.012878418, -0.049835205, 0.025177002, 0.0047187805, -0.030075073, 0.032714844, -0.041259766, -0.0071983337, 0.03012085, 0.014717102, 0.011772156, -0.0848999, -0.033355713, -0.0028743744, 0.020584106, -0.019683838, 0.008384705, -0.018356323, -0.0063552856, 0.021377563, -0.028717041, 0.020019531, -0.03564453, 0.0011100769, -0.044708252, -0.026245117, 0.018920898, -0.014099121, -0.008102417, 0.027282715, -0.022857666, -0.016952515, 0.051574707, 0.07635498, -0.017318726, -0.022415161, 0.059814453, 0.0368042, -0.009208679, 0.009757996, -0.00005018711, -0.017669678, -0.023956299, -0.011383057, -0.03955078, -0.0062561035, -0.0039482117, -0.0016698837, 0.07287598, -0.054382324, -0.0013389587, -0.013549805, -0.004058838, -0.0065193176, 0.01398468, 0.009056091, -0.031143188, -0.008491516, -0.0010557175, -0.023544312, 0.0067977905, -0.0143966675, 0.0061302185, 0.07141113, 0.0030460358, -0.007926941, 0.02420044, 0.023712158, -0.000992775, -0.02394104, -0.0030517578, -0.023239136, 0.010108948, 0.0009422302, 0.010192871, 0.010986328, -0.018920898, -0.07513428, -0.0065078735, 0.016845703, 0.008598328, -0.0025730133, 0.00818634, -0.05407715, -0.001036644, -0.03125, -0.015899658, 0.04196167, 0.085876465, -0.0018749237, 0.011787415, 0.02079773, -0.02281189, 0.008377075, -0.0055160522, -0.042663574, 0.032073975, -0.000018715858, -0.07067871, -0.025909424, -0.009742737, -0.029220581, -0.021026611, -0.06298828, 0.004398346, 0.01184082, 0.052856445, 0.019622803, 0.023147583, -0.02796936, -0.0048179626, -0.012931824, -0.01007843, -0.01184845, -0.0027942657, -0.0112838745, 0.036346436, 0.024917603, -0.007572174, -0.044555664, -0.017929077, 0.00008827448, 0.02722168, -0.00844574, -0.013061523, -0.018417358, -0.03375244, -0.010894775, -0.006095886, -0.034240723, 0.00088071823, -0.016052246, 0.011940002, -0.016616821, 0.023101807, -0.007972717, 0.0048179626, -0.039245605, 0.002603531, 0.0209198, -0.015640259, -0.05596924, -0.0010566711, 0.041107178, 0.03466797, -0.024291992, -0.020385742, -0.037750244, 0.023757935, -0.02609253, -0.0030345917, 0.0090408325, 0.022583008, -0.019378662, 0.019714355, -0.034820557, 0.013793945, -0.00957489, 0.020965576, 0.039215088, -0.01184845, 0.0124435425, -0.05606079, 0.044311523, -0.0046958923, -0.09588623, 0.009628296, 0.018875122, -0.0058555603, -0.035369873, -0.04736328, 0.027664185, -0.010284424, -0.026885986, 0.014389038, -0.0062561035, -0.027404785, 0.0006661415, -0.055999756, -0.04248047, 0.05911255, -0.014816284, -0.014045715, 0.013298035, -0.014022827, -0.031982422, -0.033569336, -0.0077056885, -0.029373169, 0.03878784, -0.03201294, -0.035369873, 0.023117065, -0.026824951, -0.0053634644, 0.037078857, -0.0064926147, 0.003320694, 0.013427734, 0.0011100769, 0.034576416, -0.0013027191, 0.06237793, -0.0009031296, -0.013710022, -0.052764893, 0.011100769, -0.0036239624, -0.02319336, 0.02418518, 0.011070251, 0.05279541, 0.04244995, -0.025512695, 0.031585693, -0.0068511963, 0.0064468384, 0.02545166, -0.041625977, -0.0044784546, 0.020233154, 0.005115509, -0.0008945465, 0.0011291504, -0.0009946823, 0.0109939575, 0.042175293, 0.0034732819, -0.046020508, 0.009132385, 0.028564453, -0.0154418945, 0.009086609, -0.046875, -0.027328491, -0.021942139, -0.010284424, -0.0181427, 0.01902771, 0.0016698837, 0.00028920174, -0.04675293, 0.010917664, 0.008865356, 0.013320923, 0.000102460384, -0.0256958, -0.024856567, -0.018600464, -0.06555176, -0.027923584, -0.025939941, -0.025344849, 0.020385742, -0.000518322, -0.011703491, 0.024032593, 0.031829834, 0.076538086, 0.024505615, -0.007774353, -0.048675537, 0.052642822, -0.032196045, -0.040802002, 0.039398193, -0.013893127, -0.022094727, -0.048797607, 0.014465332, -0.018051147, -0.005844116, -0.050750732, -0.017593384, 0.019622803, 0.023498535, 0.023086548, 0.03475952, 0.021118164, -0.022415161, 0.02003479, 0.0051727295, -0.057617188, 0.0036239624, 0.036102295, 0.038146973, -0.04272461, 0.026519775, 0.06365967, 0.014915466, -0.023666382, -0.008583069, 0.018707275, 0.035217285, -0.02267456, 0.03074646, -0.0008149147, -0.034423828, -0.034698486, 0.0053215027, 0.0042266846, 0.037078857, -0.041748047, 0.040740967, 0.021743774, -0.0030021667, 0.06109619, -0.007347107, -0.016159058, 0.019088745, -0.00022888184, -0.08093262, -0.08618164, -0.049041748, 0.08642578, -0.034332275, -0.018676758, -0.0076904297, 0.009262085, 0.010719299, 0.03543091, 0.04147339, -0.026016235, 0.0121154785, -0.033111572, -0.00013697147, -0.000998497, -0.053253174, 0.021514893, 0.00082826614, 0.021011353, -0.011459351, -0.019897461, -0.07733154, -0.0076065063, -0.005001068, 0.015266418, 0.0023880005, -0.06719971, 0.010475159, 0.043548584, 0.028579712, 0.010765076, -0.02960205, -0.004802704, 0.01914978, 0.042541504, -0.01626587, 0.026275635, 0.023803711, -0.046691895, 0.006134033, -0.0050621033, 0.0059890747, -0.01309967, 0.025039673, -0.0027809143, -0.011039734, -0.04763794, 0.025283813, -0.009796143, -0.016342163, 0.013641357, -0.053985596, 0.01424408, -0.014350891, 0.006629944, 0.0049705505, 0.0035591125, -0.0031738281, 0.036834717, -0.026168823, -0.009147644, 0.004562378, -0.01348114, -0.044921875, -0.06689453, 0.044769287, -0.017181396, -0.005970001, -0.0074157715, 0.011329651, -0.04788208, 0.028930664, 0.03363037, -0.033966064, -0.0057678223, -0.02999878, 0.0043640137, 0.034423828, 0.024139404, -0.015052795, -0.00006997585, -0.021713257, -0.05029297, -0.02281189, 0.0012540817, -0.004753113, 0.008529663, -0.0048294067, -0.007320404, 0.02720642, -0.015731812, 0.031219482, -0.004009247, -0.008224487, 0.031280518, 0.020019531, 0.024291992, 0.0006761551, 0.0054092407, 0.010887146, -0.014122009, 0.008476257, -0.05911255, 0.001086235, 0.019729614, 0.0077209473, 0.023864746, -0.042907715, 0.01524353, 0.020629883, 0.01612854, 0.0054244995, 0.02166748, 0.03717041, 0.020980835, -0.017471313, 0.022583008, 0.045959473, -0.049987793, -0.03768921, -0.04058838, -0.016586304, -0.0758667, 0.061676025, -0.0024166107, -0.0103302, -0.038482666, -0.09820557, -0.037719727, -0.0102005005, 0.05496216, 0.05670166, 0.049041748, -0.048614502, 0.017745972, 0.002298355, -0.009513855, -0.0154418945, 0.03036499, 0.021224976, -0.022491455, -0.008613586, -0.012329102, 0.0231781, -0.06817627, 0.011802673, -0.020751953, 0.0060653687, -0.034576416, -0.00006169081, 0.014579773, -0.025756836, -0.04638672, 0.038970947, 0.0090408325, -0.03062439, 0.062347412, -0.035247803, 0.06585693, 0.0066566467, 0.054870605, 0.030166626, -0.022994995, 0.0029087067, 0.00793457, -0.0055160522, -0.041748047, 0.015991211, -0.04550171, -0.013687134, -0.062408447, -0.015289307, -0.064453125, -0.018234253, 0.026260376, 0.007457733, 0.010147095, 0.013465881, 0.02255249, -0.016464233, 0.046905518, -0.022491455, 0.059570312, -0.0067977905, -0.0031738281, -0.021957397, 0.021011353, 0.014923096, 0.034301758, 0.021072388, -0.0056991577, -0.007030487, -0.0066108704, 0.017456055, 0.017852783, 0.006351471, -0.025314331, -0.0029296875, -0.04159546, 0.027404785, 0.0020771027, 0.06402588, 0.031143188, 0.027664185, 0.03491211, -0.038482666, -0.023269653, 0.0013179779, -0.026779175, 0.014343262, 0.055145264, -0.045806885, 0.032318115, -0.034484863, -0.02684021, 0.0052108765, -0.0025100708, 0.04525757, -0.08520508, -0.06567383, 0.02293396, 0.050811768, -0.014907837, 0.04147339, -0.028823853, -0.027542114, 0.00012385845, 0.03439331, 0.0025939941, 0.033050537, 0.016525269, 0.048095703, -0.06964111, -0.018066406, 0.012382507, -0.00806427, -0.0049552917, 0.030715942, -0.05987549, 0.018676758, 0.012176514, -0.036193848, 0.036346436, 0.0013513565, -0.05795288, 0.023391724, -0.018051147, 0.043548584, 0.0736084, 0.07537842, 0.016433716, 0.022003174, 0.023239136, -0.05847168, 0.018005371, 0.026733398, -0.026824951, 0.04159546, -0.041809082, -0.040649414, 0.046722412, -0.059173584, 0.07519531, -0.03552246, -0.0025749207, -0.026306152, 0.025802612, 0.03152466, -0.061584473, -0.026245117, -0.022216797, -0.018630981, -0.0031719208, -0.023223877, -0.052703857, -0.01914978, 0.0013198853, 0.0345459, 0.014045715, -0.011734009, -0.01134491, -0.02355957, -0.056793213, -0.0072288513, -0.027557373, 0.031951904, -0.012313843, -0.007144928, -0.009849548, 0.0036182404, -0.0058250427, -0.060546875, -0.017105103, -0.025512695, -0.021636963, -0.038757324, 0.00085258484, -0.0031108856, -0.023132324, 0.024765015, 0.020019531, 0.014198303, -0.01171875, -0.01802063, 0.012809753, -0.046844482, -0.002571106, -0.0066833496, -0.031051636, 0.023117065, 0.029220581, -0.026550293, 0.02519226, 0.013847351, -0.0440979, 0.0047340393, -0.025161743, 0.026657104, -0.025909424, -0.03463745, 0.013755798, 0.034484863, 0.024215698, -0.05947876, 0.013000488, 0.014823914, 0.02166748, -0.008605957, 0.07055664, 0.035980225, -0.009628296, -0.023468018, 0.016738892, -0.01272583, -0.02281189, -0.048736572, -0.031982422, 0.02041626, 0.014282227, 0.002527237, -0.03942871, 0.03857422, -0.016204834, 0.0096206665, 0.029388428, -0.00040745735, 0.022277832, -0.004711151, 0.04324341, -0.013496399, -0.022979736, 0.030715942, -0.004016876, -0.0017528534, 0.008033752, -0.015586853, -0.0073547363, -0.025283813, 0.029678345, -0.019073486, -0.02947998, 0.039154053, 0.016647339, 0.03237915, 0.032836914, -0.009140015, 0.0009784698, 0.0033550262, -0.01108551, -0.016571045, -0.012428284, 0.0051727295, -0.006298065, -0.017074585, 0.016723633, -0.016860962, -0.04067993, -0.02949524, 0.053100586, -0.050811768, 0.002696991, -0.062072754, -0.027252197, -0.015037537, 0.014793396, 0.0015926361, -0.03302002, -0.03503418, -0.046081543, 0.05407715, -0.008720398 ], "summary": [ -0.031463623, 0.0026454926, -0.044799805, 0.012634277, -0.028717041, -0.0041160583, -0.034210205, -0.02456665, -0.02897644, 0.017318726, -0.0030288696, 0.033111572, -0.018234253, -0.024795532, 0.029373169, -0.010444641, 0.0049705505, -0.009086609, -0.02986145, -0.033081055, 0.0051956177, -0.02017212, -0.03225708, 0.037231445, 0.0113220215, 0.031463623, 0.005580902, 0.01965332, 0.023742676, 0.040130615, 0.016220093, -0.06878662, -0.004524231, 0.039367676, 0.017822266, 0.024734497, 0.018722534, 0.010818481, 0.028961182, 0.029388428, 0.0044403076, -0.015266418, 0.07867432, -0.0124053955, 0.029693604, 0.00856781, -0.007545471, -0.06286621, -0.005207062, 0.024093628, -0.007659912, 0.024887085, -0.018585205, 0.030258179, -0.00094509125, -0.01675415, -0.039978027, -0.010124207, 0.015594482, 0.048095703, 0.024505615, -0.0137786865, -0.0076904297, -0.023880005, -0.014099121, -0.0023651123, 0.009231567, -0.0051956177, 0.05343628, 0.012557983, -0.01033783, 0.023391724, 0.0033817291, 0.020980835, -0.048858643, -0.024673462, 0.060699463, 0.015808105, 0.0059394836, -0.015052795, -0.008285522, 0.050994873, -0.014152527, -0.061828613, 0.033447266, -0.032928467, -0.018920898, -0.01083374, -0.023666382, 0.01725769, -0.014823914, -0.0104522705, 0.0034770966, 0.006450653, 0.0020332336, -0.028274536, -0.004180908, -0.014381409, 0.024215698, 0.007926941, 0.020202637, -0.04043579, 0.015563965, -0.021087646, -0.018814087, 0.00047516823, 0.027130127, -0.05328369, -0.013328552, 0.0015687943, -0.041992188, 0.042510986, -0.020843506, -0.043914795, 0.021316528, 0.03237915, -0.024108887, 0.06536865, 0.014450073, 0.052520752, -0.024017334, 0.005088806, -0.06008911, 0.08135986, -0.032684326, -0.02230835, 0.02746582, 0.031921387, -0.018173218, 0.028884888, -0.0024223328, -0.009666443, -0.023864746, 0.017700195, -0.007083893, -0.009605408, 0.048736572, -0.02458191, 0.007820129, -0.005680084, 0.064941406, -0.019744873, -0.03955078, 0.03466797, -0.008857727, 0.04296875, 0.023101807, 0.0034008026, -0.020553589, -0.05404663, 0.01235199, 0.0016536713, 0.03463745, -0.023788452, -0.062438965, -0.05215454, -0.07739258, 0.006111145, 0.008285522, -0.014144897, 0.021057129, -0.012931824, -0.028045654, 0.038360596, 0.0014791489, -0.010864258, 0.020996094, 0.011856079, 0.026382446, 0.011138916, 0.03314209, 0.022125244, 0.00793457, 0.012710571, 0.008468628, -0.024261475, 0.020645142, -0.062042236, -0.030929565, 0.08312988, 0.021575928, -0.024124146, -0.12005615, 0.043060303, -0.07702637, 0.03656006, -0.0076675415, 0.07043457, 0.05343628, 0.008140564, 0.027069092, -0.017349243, -0.012290955, 0.021697998, -0.011230469, 0.004146576, 0.0057029724, 0.021362305, -0.0021915436, -0.056854248, -0.037597656, 0.035705566, -0.039154053, 0.08111572, 0.044067383, -0.0014686584, 0.02949524, -0.0065994263, -0.061706543, 0.012321472, 0.05307007, -0.015777588, -0.039123535, 0.031799316, 0.034210205, -0.03567505, 0.040283203, -0.0037460327, -0.019760132, -0.0077400208, -0.013053894, -0.03918457, -0.024902344, 0.07836914, 0.008132935, 0.008743286, -0.03540039, 0.011070251, -0.013961792, 0.012001038, 0.0021038055, 0.02557373, 0.004535675, 0.03414917, 0.008346558, 0.004043579, 0.022369385, -0.05053711, 0.015899658, 0.023483276, 0.034942627, 0.060455322, -0.008995056, -0.024246216, 0.039733887, -0.033447266, 0.021240234, -0.024032593, -0.032684326, -0.016998291, 0.03189087, 0.026733398, 0.022598267, 0.048187256, -0.015701294, 0.026168823, -0.028244019, 0.03918457, -0.045654297, 0.0073051453, -0.016159058, 0.037384033, 0.04916382, -0.011665344, -0.0015068054, -0.017105103, 0.02330017, 0.017364502, 0.04949951, -0.040161133, -0.032287598, -0.066589355, 0.017120361, -0.021377563, -0.12438965, 0.017852783, -0.033355713, 0.037139893, 0.044128418, -0.019454956, -0.013580322, -0.00083112717, -0.025772095, -0.011253357, 0.009399414, -0.029571533, 0.013031006, 0.01083374, 0.001663208, 0.050048828, 0.04800415, 0.027252197, 0.036865234, -0.025741577, -0.015716553, 0.018844604, -0.0057792664, 0.028747559, -0.003955841, -0.0025138855, -0.031021118, 0.04168701, 0.016174316, -0.032440186, 0.0073623657, 0.050750732, 0.050445557, -0.022338867, -0.018951416, -0.027709961, -0.01826477, -0.036956787, 0.020935059, 0.015914917, -0.035125732, -0.01158905, -0.019119263, 0.017288208, 0.0011291504, 0.039215088, 0.08276367, 0.047576904, -0.03805542, 0.052093506, 0.009689331, -0.03289795, 0.04989624, -0.03704834, -0.013214111, 0.019943237, -0.021606445, -0.03427124, -0.070495605, -0.03894043, 0.0009088516, 0.018127441, 0.0036678314, 0.0009293556, 0.005809784, 0.007774353, 0.05593872, -0.013404846, 0.014205933, 0.0031642914, -0.014381409, 0.033050537, -0.040252686, 0.015899658, -0.01486969, -0.0058288574, -0.019729614, -0.027069092, -0.013000488, 0.056793213, 0.01977539, -0.000088989735, 0.022720337, 0.08227539, 0.023040771, -0.011772156, 0.010772705, 0.027694702, -0.005054474, -0.032958984, -0.04736328, -0.024642944, 0.002714157, 0.012229919, 0.061767578, 0.06124878, -0.0019741058, 0.035736084, -0.020904541, 0.0059928894, 0.02670288, -0.045684814, 0.05291748, -0.030334473, 0.0051727295, 0.018829346, -0.03665161, 0.0038146973, -0.047973633, 0.015426636, 0.07678223, 0.013366699, 0.020095825, 0.04537964, 0.026107788, -0.0107421875, -0.015930176, -0.0040359497, 0.01386261, -0.027648926, -0.04083252, -0.005050659, 0.03161621, -0.024597168, 0.046875, -0.015823364, 0.005897522, 0.021896362, -0.0009880066, 0.01689148, -0.017730713, -0.004020691, 0.015419006, -0.021774292, 0.033477783, 0.015602112, 0.012832642, -0.014976501, 0.037231445, -0.051086426, -0.016586304, -0.014533997, 0.04257202, 0.011665344, -0.012107849, -0.06726074, -0.0143966675, 0.0670166, -0.0034713745, -0.024032593, -0.01939392, -0.015808105, 0.014839172, 0.039398193, -0.03869629, 0.025894165, 0.0036773682, -0.019012451, -0.0008249283, -0.035888672, -0.04562378, -0.06085205, -0.018829346, 0.0041389465, 0.03338623, -0.034179688, -0.039520264, -0.012329102, -0.03375244, 0.011917114, -0.0070762634, -0.017501831, -0.025405884, -0.05999756, -0.018722534, 0.01939392, -0.036712646, 0.02406311, 0.026855469, 0.010826111, -0.005531311, -0.023895264, -0.056671143, 0.015296936, -0.01965332, -0.0038337708, 0.034576416, -0.0038089752, -0.020523071, -0.0041770935, 0.012413025, 0.040405273, -0.031143188, 0.019683838, -0.041748047, 0.018371582, 0.021118164, -0.023666382, -0.0046043396, 0.0013360977, -0.008705139, 0.004699707, 0.011314392, -0.006290436, 0.008300781, -0.0037574768, -0.016067505, 0.0076828003, -0.024032593, -0.013000488, -0.00080776215, 0.010284424, -0.038879395, -0.011672974, 0.027908325, -0.0018882751, 0.024215698, -0.03765869, 0.052246094, 0.0070152283, 0.006591797, 0.0037956238, -0.010604858, 0.064941406, 0.0005598068, -0.04031372, -0.015914917, -0.01739502, 0.010848999, -0.013786316, -0.059051514, 0.01184845, 0.033569336, -0.019317627, -0.0073776245, -0.09802246, 0.03982544, -0.060394287, -0.0014410019, 0.011688232, -0.003019333, -0.0058174133, 0.054901123, -0.004863739, 0.018096924, -0.00017797947, 0.012428284, 0.046173096, -0.021530151, 0.018218994, 0.0062026978, -0.012962341, -0.021865845, 0.02432251, -0.03189087, -0.08758545, 0.034210205, 0.06732178, 0.019363403, 0.062805176, -0.041046143, 0.011833191, -0.029647827, 0.0019083023, 0.017349243, 0.0050354004, -0.024261475, -0.009017944, 0.0052986145, 0.038848877, -0.002166748, 0.006214142, -0.002822876, 0.0062561035, -0.0032348633, -0.018035889, 0.0005712509, 0.02279663, -0.001704216, -0.017974854, -0.03164673, 0.037078857, -0.0049362183, -0.0037631989, 0.0029506683, 0.029418945, -0.018356323, 0.05895996, -0.03451538, -0.015670776, -0.01399231, 0.03149414, -0.020248413, -0.012573242, -0.052520752, -0.02696228, -0.097229004, -0.036712646, -0.07159424, -0.023040771, -0.024368286, 0.015975952, -0.03704834, 0.011962891, 0.027053833, 0.07299805, 0.013999939, 0.025253296, -0.0546875, -0.002691269, -0.049102783, 0.043395996, 0.0051078796, 0.03640747, -0.03338623, -0.0018186569, 0.027954102, 0.011184692, 0.0014457703, -0.10797119, -0.034423828, -0.0026111603, 0.0031147003, 0.032409668, -0.028762817, 0.015129089, -0.029846191, 0.032287598, 0.013221741, -0.035369873, 0.023956299, 0.015808105, 0.002374649, -0.025817871, 0.014808655, 0.027511597, -0.012512207, -0.0395813, 0.0029735565, 0.005908966, 0.017349243, -0.011650085, 0.0007596016, 0.0045776367, -0.008140564, -0.031188965, 0.0023479462, -0.010116577, 0.0005879402, 0.011367798, -0.015731812, 0.066467285, -0.0044174194, 0.07446289, -0.0010890961, -0.012763977, 0.055389404, -0.034820557, -0.06970215, -0.03842163, -0.025817871, 0.045715332, -0.026184082, -0.022476196, -0.016326904, -0.04434204, 0.0066490173, 0.022521973, 0.019485474, -0.039215088, 0.006088257, -0.021972656, -0.012214661, -0.007926941, -0.028701782, -0.02305603, 0.019454956, 0.015777588, -0.025619507, 0.011451721, 0.017700195, -0.0074501038, -0.014404297, 0.014282227, 0.0014457703, -0.064331055, -0.07824707, -0.034698486, 0.043792725, -0.052734375, 0.015151978, -0.046417236, 0.024749756, -0.001707077, -0.030838013, -0.0023956299, -0.032440186, -0.037322998, -0.012123108, -0.02168274, 0.011543274, -0.031219482, 0.0013694763, 0.0010576248, -0.033325195, -0.029525757, 0.006587982, -0.023529053, 0.03930664, -0.035736084, -0.010009766, 0.040863037, -0.02229309, -0.010116577, 0.013374329, 0.021865845, -0.0010299683, 0.008743286, 0.009963989, -0.011039734, -0.030471802, 0.005153656, 0.0012073517, -0.031799316, 0.02204895, -0.031097412, 0.015853882, -0.004043579, -0.026443481, -0.024871826, -0.031463623, 0.0058555603, -0.023162842, 0.017059326, -0.031707764, 0.00007504225, -0.011787415, 0.0070381165, -0.04458618, -0.011734009, -0.03704834, 0.00067710876, 0.0068969727, -0.017089844, 0.015007019, 0.048950195, 0.0073165894, 0.0446167, 0.048309326, -0.06652832, 0.016021729, -0.021743774, -0.0029621124, 0.02267456, 0.012054443, 0.017837524, 0.001086235, -0.008354187, 0.014411926, -0.0062713623, 0.020309448, -0.06695557, 0.004055023, 0.03591919, 0.013793945, -0.0011463165, -0.03414917, -0.0017967224, 0.023071289, 0.014465332, 0.032958984, 0.018493652, 0.022949219, 0.033294678, -0.02760315, 0.023147583, 0.02116394, -0.035186768, -0.04812622, -0.03857422, 0.014015198, -0.03543091, 0.017318726, 0.017837524, -0.022125244, 0.0020694733, -0.08337402, 0.0040740967, -0.006790161, 0.03778076, 0.054504395, 0.041778564, -0.032928467, 0.028930664, 0.0184021, -0.03390503, -0.016662598, 0.013427734, 0.0059814453, -0.018356323, 0.043701172, -0.024169922, 0.043121338, -0.05319214, -0.02293396, -0.01977539, 0.0059432983, -0.010093689, -0.009864807, 0.022018433, -0.03375244, -0.009742737, 0.0043754578, 0.03540039, -0.039154053, 0.004497528, 0.027770996, 0.050750732, -0.010856628, 0.028884888, -0.02178955, 0.0005106926, 0.027664185, -0.00035858154, 0.022659302, -0.023773193, 0.019577026, -0.028915405, -0.054870605, -0.05731201, -0.029769897, -0.014251709, 0.024246216, -0.026321411, -0.02859497, 0.050567627, 0.00044584274, 0.026504517, 0.032714844, -0.03527832, 0.005718231, -0.007118225, 0.0031833649, -0.021240234, -0.05026245, 0.020568848, 0.023544312, 0.041625977, 0.06124878, -0.020812988, 0.013381958, -0.0037193298, 0.047698975, -0.015594482, -0.024551392, -0.07159424, 0.017990112, -0.05255127, 0.021255493, 0.0076675415, 0.0058517456, 0.035095215, 0.015563965, 0.08380127, -0.048828125, 0.019500732, 0.012619019, -0.019470215, 0.018478394, -0.014762878, 0.043060303, -0.008377075, -0.0259552, -0.008071899, 0.0524292, -0.010147095, 0.032836914, -0.09979248, -0.022888184, 0.0076789856, 0.013458252, -0.041931152, 0.0435791, -0.020858765, -0.0046920776, -0.0058174133, -0.026657104, 0.015205383, 0.028167725, 0.044677734, 0.0051841736, -0.02027893, 0.020004272, 0.009727478, 0.017944336, 0.008651733, 0.027511597, -0.07116699, 0.020568848, 0.015426636, -0.0211792, 0.021148682, 0.0071525574, -0.015686035, 0.021621704, -0.044830322, 0.06768799, 0.07678223, 0.057495117, -0.032562256, 0.026687622, 0.09326172, 0.0002360344, 0.027145386, -0.023880005, -0.015594482, 0.02671814, -0.023330688, -0.012771606, 0.043395996, -0.044677734, 0.033294678, -0.03173828, 0.009132385, -0.0062675476, 0.005012512, -0.02571106, -0.0047416687, -0.022277832, -0.029281616, -0.047180176, 0.0118637085, 0.007507324, -0.031982422, 0.023025513, -0.027862549, -0.038879395, 0.0005259514, 0.00141716, 0.037200928, -0.008491516, -0.083740234, -0.002210617, -0.004627228, 0.025375366, 0.02520752, -0.009933472, 0.02368164, 0.031555176, 0.0070381165, -0.05883789, -0.042999268, 0.05432129, 0.049987793, -0.0463562, -0.008102417, -0.010215759, -0.038024902, 0.01083374, 0.046447754, 0.008407593, -0.012863159, 0.026412964, 0.019073486, -0.0058555603, -0.019485474, 0.026351929, -0.043945312, 0.017242432, -0.024047852, -0.0028877258, 0.047943115, 0.0446167, -0.041259766, 0.025787354, -0.029220581, -0.024993896, -0.0038928986, -0.03756714, 0.003780365, 0.017150879, 0.04269409, -0.008834839, 0.032348633, 0.0035743713, 0.0047950745, -0.009246826, -0.014060974, 0.00856781, -0.030380249, -0.021102905, 0.017196655, -0.01626587, 0.006958008, -0.038146973, 0.015701294, 0.0149383545, -0.013626099, -0.008735657, -0.030090332, 0.0055770874, -0.042785645, -0.024261475, -0.000910759, 0.009185791, -0.023391724, 0.012901306, 0.018676758, -0.022277832, -0.033203125, 0.029220581, -0.046325684, 0.002281189, -0.048797607, 0.0052833557, -0.014480591, -0.076171875, 0.025314331, -0.00868988, 0.055236816, -0.024810791, -0.043182373, 0.039123535, -0.022079468, 0.021530151, 0.029830933, 0.026519775, -0.021484375, -0.024612427, -0.01914978, 0.019805908, -0.014709473, -0.038269043, -0.016571045, 0.010223389, -0.055999756, -0.013954163, 0.05126953, -0.038208008, -0.013069153, -0.020202637, -0.0501709, 0.010719299, 0.012168884, 0.03845215, -0.040863037, 0.062316895, -0.009857178, 0.032562256, 0.034820557 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2003.09301v2
Distributed and Democratized Learning: Philosophy and Research Challenges
Minh N. H. Nguyen, Shashi Raj Pandey, Kyi Thar, Nguyen H. Tran, Mingzhe Chen, Walid Saad, Choong Seon Hong
cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Due to the availability of huge amounts of data and processing abilities, current artificial intelligence (AI) systems are effective in solving complex tasks. However, despite the success of AI in different areas, the problem of designing AI systems that can truly mimic human cognitive capabilities such as artificial general intelligence, remains largely open. Consequently, many emerging cross-device AI applications will require a transition from traditional centralized learning systems towards large-scale distributed AI systems that can collaboratively perform multiple complex learning tasks. In this paper, we propose a novel design philosophy called democratized learning (Dem-AI) whose goal is to build large-scale distributed learning systems that rely on the self-organization of distributed learning agents that are well-connected, but limited in learning capabilities. Correspondingly, inspired by the societal groups of humans, the specialized groups of learning agents in the proposed Dem-AI system are self-organized in a hierarchical structure to collectively perform learning tasks more efficiently. As such, the Dem-AI learning system can evolve and regulate itself based on the underlying duality of two processes which we call specialized and generalized processes. In this regard, we present a reference design as a guideline to realize future Dem-AI systems, inspired by various interdisciplinary fields. Accordingly, we introduce four underlying mechanisms in the design such as plasticity-stability transition mechanism, self-organizing hierarchical structuring, specialized learning, and generalization. Finally, we establish possible extensions and new challenges for the existing learning approaches to provide better scalable, flexible, and more powerful learning systems with the new setting of Dem-AI.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2003.09301v2
2020-10-14T10:14:41
2020-03-18T08:45:10
{ "title": [ -0.0289917, 0.019195557, -0.046966553, -0.04849243, 0.03213501, -0.005180359, -0.008888245, -0.012413025, -0.028640747, 0.03149414, -0.0049934387, 0.0064048767, -0.032226562, -0.02609253, -0.043182373, -0.011238098, -0.015068054, 0.03262329, -0.015052795, -0.024154663, -0.02281189, -0.03692627, 0.037353516, -0.0009050369, 0.04446411, -0.01235199, -0.10345459, 0.010818481, -0.036987305, -0.03540039, -0.013076782, 0.022415161, 0.0385437, 0.01626587, -0.0184021, -0.032073975, -0.04852295, 0.0037231445, -0.03894043, 0.033691406, -0.010040283, -0.0005197525, -0.026397705, 0.00027918816, -0.058654785, -0.00868988, -0.059661865, 0.0060539246, -0.03250122, 0.061523438, 0.009651184, 0.016662598, -0.01966858, 0.044036865, 0.033721924, -0.030883789, -0.009407043, -0.012168884, 0.041229248, 0.037506104, 0.007587433, -0.05065918, 0.03149414, -0.01335907, -0.040252686, -0.015617371, -0.025436401, 0.022613525, 0.06695557, -0.010543823, -0.014320374, 0.010917664, 0.017333984, 0.006290436, -0.039001465, -0.013145447, 0.050109863, 0.009750366, 0.040863037, -0.029556274, -0.028839111, 0.01965332, -0.012878418, -0.03994751, 0.005809784, -0.046051025, -0.030670166, -0.0011310577, -0.023391724, -0.054626465, 0.0038223267, 0.012176514, 0.0005159378, 0.025756836, -0.028823853, -0.0115737915, -0.007881165, 0.04864502, 0.00466156, -0.01802063, -0.041534424, 0.03161621, -0.08203125, -0.008148193, -0.009773254, 0.00374794, -0.003276825, -0.015335083, -0.0049095154, 0.04840088, -0.025161743, 0.026245117, 0.007144928, 0.010223389, -0.0095825195, -0.014160156, -0.031921387, 0.009880066, 0.014907837, -0.0014638901, 0.006717682, -0.009849548, 0.0047416687, 0.0069732666, 0.009284973, 0.0059013367, -0.036193848, -0.02746582, 0.010498047, 0.020309448, 0.008583069, 0.052520752, -0.09625244, -0.090148926, -0.060638428, 0.051116943, -0.037322998, -0.0027236938, -0.02142334, -0.013641357, -0.00023841858, -0.0072364807, 0.03543091, 0.0062026978, -0.0004348755, 0.00014972687, 0.059631348, -0.01109314, -0.05770874, -0.024963379, -0.038482666, 0.041290283, 0.034362793, -0.0023040771, -0.026138306, 0.0011892319, -0.10870361, -0.014732361, 0.023101807, 0.011306763, 0.034057617, 0.029205322, 0.01953125, 0.043792725, 0.07611084, -0.027664185, -0.0146484375, 0.020111084, 0.008766174, 0.032165527, -0.027572632, 0.012298584, 0.013786316, -0.0043907166, -0.010520935, 0.019210815, 0.040771484, -0.010955811, 0.01852417, 0.017822266, 0.009536743, -0.009757996, 0.015304565, 0.03491211, -0.036895752, -0.043884277, -0.0064582825, -0.035888672, 0.049041748, 0.0043945312, -0.046936035, 0.042236328, -0.051727295, -0.040283203, -0.053833008, -0.012428284, 0.021591187, 0.027420044, -0.0069007874, 0.017059326, -0.04663086, 0.009857178, -0.051483154, 0.028320312, -0.018753052, -0.012626648, -0.018493652, 0.029312134, -0.015487671, 0.051208496, 0.048919678, 0.013427734, -0.028823853, -0.017120361, 0.0023117065, -0.021118164, 0.0014820099, -0.026138306, -0.015144348, -0.012268066, -0.029678345, 0.009689331, -0.021484375, 0.033203125, 0.0077590942, 0.009902954, -0.0014009476, -0.01928711, 0.04724121, 0.020721436, 0.09875488, -0.047973633, 0.026672363, 0.027175903, 0.003868103, -0.03366089, -0.006126404, -0.039978027, 0.030151367, 0.017227173, -0.010910034, -0.011711121, -0.0071754456, 0.031433105, -0.0032691956, -0.044433594, 0.013267517, 0.0015897751, -0.008773804, -0.024642944, 0.06112671, 0.013702393, 0.056152344, 0.042053223, -0.011672974, 0.042907715, 0.012779236, 0.0031166077, -0.030853271, 0.018112183, -0.004878998, 0.0069770813, -0.017944336, 0.015808105, -0.046142578, -0.0014591217, -0.033355713, 0.0096588135, 0.0036621094, 0.008560181, 0.03086853, -0.015686035, 0.013336182, -0.010536194, -0.017669678, 0.013244629, -0.016403198, 0.034057617, 0.003025055, -0.05206299, -0.030822754, -0.014656067, 0.01876831, -0.0042915344, 0.0004930496, 0.011634827, 0.026733398, -0.0524292, 0.011947632, -0.029922485, 0.041992188, 0.0074768066, -0.005393982, 0.009460449, 0.024520874, -0.03265381, 0.091918945, 0.09576416, -0.046844482, 0.03982544, -0.04260254, 0.015853882, 0.02218628, -0.03277588, 0.0062294006, 0.016693115, 0.023239136, 0.03302002, -0.021972656, -0.0055503845, -0.024627686, 0.020065308, 0.0073242188, -0.035308838, -0.022262573, -0.049316406, 0.00983429, -0.048828125, -0.03366089, -0.007633209, 0.064331055, -0.023834229, -0.026885986, -0.002149582, -0.011909485, -0.022338867, -0.010269165, -0.022781372, 0.011222839, 0.023376465, 0.06011963, 0.022903442, -0.05380249, -0.035980225, 0.014846802, 0.013694763, -0.004924774, -0.003019333, -0.005508423, 0.03048706, 0.028427124, -0.008674622, 0.043151855, -0.037261963, 0.016723633, -0.053894043, -0.007949829, 0.021240234, -0.009727478, -0.012123108, 0.016036987, -0.019424438, -0.016555786, 0.018630981, 0.07659912, -0.008857727, -0.03604126, 0.005142212, 0.027511597, -0.039276123, 0.066711426, -0.010848999, 0.021606445, -0.015991211, -0.030014038, -0.03616333, -0.0016698837, -0.014732361, -0.027389526, 0.032592773, -0.047332764, -0.025436401, -0.037902832, -0.02142334, 0.0030536652, 0.01878357, -0.021255493, -0.027114868, -0.03491211, -0.028121948, 0.00042796135, -0.008003235, -0.018661499, -0.010818481, 0.061767578, -0.00007176399, -0.04348755, -0.012237549, 0.023925781, 0.011871338, 0.004470825, -0.000041663647, -0.027496338, 0.00274086, -0.017791748, 0.0056991577, -0.00806427, -0.020874023, -0.07055664, -0.005973816, 0.0635376, -0.012756348, -0.028167725, 0.021835327, -0.04916382, -0.013648987, 0.024490356, -0.021621704, 0.026992798, 0.036102295, -0.018554688, 0.021514893, -0.013786316, -0.015899658, 0.004501343, -0.050720215, -0.11077881, 0.025909424, -0.03466797, -0.0029850006, 0.013618469, -0.047088623, -0.050048828, -0.0054512024, -0.00730896, 0.052124023, 0.032348633, 0.01789856, 0.014411926, -0.027755737, 0.00096940994, -0.03363037, -0.0013141632, 0.0019197464, -0.047058105, -0.051361084, -0.020523071, 0.018859863, 0.03643799, -0.045959473, -0.051849365, 0.0013637543, 0.0011348724, 0.04724121, -0.009269714, -0.02255249, 0.0009226799, -0.027938843, 0.00029873848, 0.019607544, -0.025848389, 0.00010550022, -0.048309326, 0.007385254, -0.025466919, -0.0074501038, -0.0010681152, 0.0038013458, -0.035339355, 0.00037646294, 0.014526367, -0.023025513, -0.043304443, -0.022354126, 0.042236328, 0.017196655, 0.026046753, -0.008872986, -0.027816772, 0.030014038, -0.0064888, -0.03414917, 0.008003235, 0.012145996, 0.002210617, 0.055755615, -0.04864502, 0.00573349, -0.052642822, 0.042388916, -0.008796692, 0.014930725, -0.07421875, -0.06951904, -0.009437561, -0.012672424, -0.117126465, -0.054840088, 0.0050582886, -0.029769897, -0.060791016, -0.056365967, 0.006214142, -0.0042152405, -0.033599854, 0.03414917, -0.030975342, 0.000323534, 0.01651001, -0.04852295, -0.0023097992, 0.07019043, -0.013580322, -0.01285553, 0.043670654, -0.01890564, -0.0016288757, -0.05227661, 0.018615723, 0.01902771, 0.031463623, -0.0051612854, -0.0018291473, 0.026229858, -0.016723633, 0.020721436, 0.05343628, -0.0061798096, 0.017868042, 0.002691269, 0.016815186, 0.009460449, -0.034240723, 0.04046631, 0.042633057, -0.017959595, -0.07373047, 0.014572144, -0.0013313293, 0.013626099, 0.039642334, -0.009971619, 0.025222778, -0.0011129379, -0.0065460205, 0.042236328, 0.0013008118, -0.017227173, 0.024230957, -0.00806427, -0.016235352, 0.0065612793, 0.032714844, 0.026473999, 0.013092041, -0.02935791, -0.033599854, 0.008399963, -0.018447876, -0.032562256, -0.0028018951, 0.017440796, -0.02078247, 0.011245728, -0.035003662, -0.056549072, -0.028198242, 0.009124756, -0.009399414, 0.023330688, 0.0076026917, -0.009552002, -0.04510498, 0.046203613, 0.014350891, 0.014785767, 0.0016651154, -0.027313232, 0.0046195984, -0.0019245148, -0.073791504, -0.03253174, -0.044036865, -0.013885498, -0.004673004, 0.005290985, -0.017303467, 0.0115356445, 0.017608643, 0.040374756, 0.034729004, -0.013519287, -0.016189575, 0.035827637, 0.00083732605, -0.004711151, 0.0014019012, 0.026916504, -0.002752304, -0.016586304, -0.026290894, -0.026184082, -0.02444458, -0.061584473, 0.04159546, 0.0029678345, 0.03375244, 0.015342712, 0.024749756, 0.031082153, -0.009422302, 0.018463135, 0.010124207, -0.04269409, -0.016540527, 0.022277832, 0.058654785, -0.020568848, 0.0012149811, 0.030593872, 0.024963379, 0.009353638, 0.007091522, -0.0048332214, 0.0038795471, 0.025390625, 0.041625977, -0.012901306, -0.07342529, -0.03463745, -0.0042304993, 0.016494751, 0.068847656, -0.055847168, 0.06732178, -0.012039185, -0.0039634705, 0.014518738, -0.019699097, 0.023513794, -0.031188965, 0.021316528, -0.07116699, -0.059417725, -0.021774292, 0.045928955, -0.03640747, 0.009902954, 0.00096178055, 0.0072898865, 0.019927979, 0.053833008, 0.056610107, -0.012016296, 0.011810303, -0.014320374, 0.002216339, -0.014503479, -0.0440979, -0.0048446655, 0.00014984608, 0.032440186, -0.061279297, 0.05331421, -0.06274414, 0.02267456, -0.019577026, -0.02520752, 0.025177002, -0.089660645, 0.0030288696, 0.07904053, 0.011528015, 0.045166016, -0.014457703, 0.010269165, 0.012619019, 0.06506348, -0.0031776428, 0.030639648, 0.026245117, -0.053253174, -0.012664795, -0.0067596436, 0.036834717, -0.004688263, 0.026016235, 0.013191223, -0.0038757324, -0.06378174, 0.034179688, 0.028045654, -0.005340576, -0.0007419586, -0.061065674, -0.0036640167, -0.0071029663, 0.028778076, 0.01121521, -0.037719727, -0.040252686, -0.008110046, -0.027542114, -0.03186035, 0.03253174, -0.007663727, -0.03152466, -0.062316895, 0.028915405, -0.009521484, 0.014289856, -0.001572609, 0.025970459, -0.03591919, 0.019088745, 0.032318115, -0.03289795, -0.01739502, -0.02243042, 0.019622803, 0.02722168, 0.013580322, -0.0014925003, 0.014945984, -0.012718201, -0.06274414, -0.042877197, 0.014297485, -0.008041382, 0.011672974, -0.017181396, -0.037872314, -0.0070495605, -0.010505676, 0.009101868, 0.032165527, -0.03756714, 0.026351929, 0.006919861, 0.0037994385, -0.0021362305, 0.02645874, -0.03353882, 0.017166138, 0.023117065, 0.032348633, 0.025985718, -0.01259613, -0.00011378527, -0.007633209, -0.029129028, 0.0056648254, 0.025482178, 0.009887695, -0.027862549, 0.020553589, 0.023498535, 0.030822754, -0.0016365051, -0.005607605, 0.049957275, -0.0051879883, -0.01979065, -0.009994507, 0.0016832352, -0.022598267, 0.048675537, -0.017593384, -0.025741577, -0.038757324, -0.056640625, -0.030639648, 0.0015869141, 0.014160156, 0.035461426, 0.031921387, -0.020080566, 0.023910522, 0.0063667297, -0.017715454, -0.06738281, 0.014533997, 0.0071754456, -0.014450073, 0.0340271, 0.0030460358, 0.0068359375, -0.03967285, 0.025527954, -0.010032654, -0.002796173, -0.02708435, 0.00055122375, 0.032806396, -0.038909912, -0.005302429, 0.025177002, 0.04034424, -0.060180664, 0.018936157, -0.037597656, 0.07165527, 0.023361206, 0.05001831, 0.023956299, 0.00881958, 0.026947021, 0.010047913, 0.026016235, -0.031402588, 0.016662598, -0.048431396, -0.032928467, -0.08642578, -0.034454346, -0.070251465, -0.01828003, -0.005256653, 0.008651733, -0.005970001, 0.0050354004, 0.0025196075, 0.0027942657, 0.031951904, 0.014717102, 0.052612305, -0.051849365, -0.021347046, -0.008476257, 0.03338623, 0.022964478, 0.03302002, 0.0032978058, 0.01574707, -0.02192688, -0.013656616, -0.005264282, 0.04248047, -0.014442444, -0.013946533, 0.01687622, -0.03250122, 0.04147339, -0.0022087097, 0.03277588, 0.0513916, 0.03086853, 0.037017822, -0.0413208, -0.008735657, 0.018295288, -0.025283813, 0.010620117, 0.048583984, -0.04498291, 0.0030002594, -0.026229858, -0.030166626, 0.022903442, 0.024627686, 0.045837402, -0.054901123, -0.045532227, -0.013259888, 0.050720215, 0.0158844, 0.030288696, -0.03152466, -0.019515991, 0.016098022, 0.051727295, -0.024871826, 0.026672363, 0.0077400208, 0.03189087, -0.05053711, -0.015823364, -0.009757996, 0.018493652, -0.054260254, 0.016403198, -0.043518066, 0.0006532669, 0.021469116, -0.022064209, 0.023483276, 0.011985779, -0.026992798, 0.017486572, 0.012634277, 0.058441162, 0.04434204, 0.08520508, 0.029693604, -0.033599854, 0.015586853, -0.05456543, 0.015052795, 0.04751587, -0.035369873, 0.021987915, -0.03945923, -0.02784729, 0.01991272, -0.043701172, 0.018173218, -0.055267334, 0.01625061, -0.003019333, 0.013420105, 0.032287598, -0.04876709, -0.03164673, -0.00045776367, -0.028335571, -0.018157959, -0.010498047, -0.015213013, -0.005996704, -0.014060974, 0.020080566, 0.021240234, -0.005908966, -0.027816772, -0.027282715, -0.07330322, 0.0069732666, -0.026107788, 0.031402588, 0.0054512024, -0.013175964, -0.010284424, -0.018859863, 0.013214111, 0.0024986267, -0.027526855, -0.0033035278, -0.040405273, -0.0049972534, -0.0036735535, 0.02357483, -0.007572174, 0.0011348724, -0.03869629, 0.030441284, -0.015472412, 0.00070858, 0.024505615, -0.070129395, 0.0006079674, 0.013389587, -0.035491943, 0.041290283, 0.0491333, -0.011077881, 0.016479492, 0.0065689087, -0.04196167, -0.03842163, 0.008674622, 0.0357666, 0.0049591064, -0.052825928, 0.014717102, 0.025238037, 0.008491516, -0.055267334, -0.026412964, 0.026123047, 0.03704834, -0.00068569183, 0.0546875, 0.021469116, -0.021713257, -0.022720337, 0.015640259, 0.0009069443, -0.023086548, -0.010032654, -0.019729614, 0.019332886, 0.06488037, -0.0015125275, -0.014419556, 0.041503906, 0.008781433, -0.007980347, 0.023162842, -0.025421143, 0.0022640228, 0.009635925, 0.03466797, -0.013504028, -0.0033626556, -0.058502197, -0.012954712, 0.01109314, 0.027709961, -0.0181427, 0.021026611, -0.023422241, 0.07775879, -0.03237915, -0.0395813, 0.025436401, 0.055725098, -0.0033435822, 0.06555176, -0.07336426, -0.0037765503, 0.007785797, -0.0059661865, -0.010169983, -0.012680054, 0.04550171, -0.005970001, 0.002521515, -0.017318726, -0.052124023, -0.044555664, -0.04598999, 0.021728516, -0.030685425, 0.011688232, 0.0042686462, -0.011756897, -0.012779236, 0.014465332, 0.0016317368, -0.046783447, -0.05178833, -0.002035141, 0.049560547, -0.014968872 ], "summary": [ -0.013824463, 0.011482239, -0.017318726, 0.0126571655, -0.017074585, -0.026397705, -0.020751953, -0.03463745, -0.022140503, 0.04776001, -0.016677856, 0.04043579, -0.020187378, 0.0024318695, -0.018753052, -0.030258179, 0.00088119507, 0.028747559, 0.055633545, -0.01361084, 0.027816772, -0.00932312, 0.064208984, 0.02394104, 0.008392334, 0.042938232, -0.11175537, 0.030151367, -0.0079574585, 0.014785767, -0.00094652176, 0.0009598732, 0.014518738, 0.0053901672, -0.009178162, -0.02178955, 0.012886047, -0.00605011, -0.04623413, 0.074279785, 0.006515503, -0.0028133392, 0.04473877, -0.0146484375, 0.0037269592, 0.015991211, 0.017303467, -0.0041656494, 0.02368164, 0.033416748, -0.013549805, 0.018173218, -0.018371582, -0.0082473755, -0.008255005, -0.0096588135, 0.009460449, -0.048736572, 0.034729004, 0.0104904175, -0.0000333786, -0.03086853, 0.017150879, -0.038116455, -0.014549255, 0.015075684, 0.016296387, -0.00020968914, 0.000320673, -0.0025577545, 0.0061149597, -0.017990112, 0.038391113, -0.025131226, -0.03427124, -0.00919342, 0.04840088, -0.005844116, -0.002149582, -0.04260254, -0.022476196, 0.020233154, 0.0005531311, -0.08227539, 0.020095825, -0.053466797, -0.015068054, 0.010108948, -0.018661499, -0.019165039, -0.014091492, 0.014282227, -0.06719971, 0.042053223, 0.019317627, -0.0131073, 0.0063171387, -0.040985107, 0.038604736, 0.030029297, -0.014518738, -0.022537231, 0.002828598, -0.010475159, -0.023040771, 0.014823914, 0.0021686554, -0.035003662, -0.01890564, 0.025772095, -0.019989014, -0.049621582, 0.0012779236, -0.029556274, 0.0010032654, -0.001159668, -0.031204224, 0.070251465, 0.0070724487, 0.039031982, -0.021957397, 0.012397766, 0.016067505, 0.04034424, 0.007926941, 0.03540039, 0.02557373, -0.04989624, 0.08337402, -0.042755127, -0.01537323, 0.036224365, -0.048828125, -0.015319824, -0.021316528, 0.011009216, 0.00039601326, 0.009971619, 0.035491943, -0.04348755, 0.052581787, 0.010147095, 0.021469116, 0.042816162, -0.02835083, 0.008773804, 0.028076172, 0.002046585, -0.03277588, -0.027374268, -0.041229248, 0.035705566, 0.012138367, -0.0052719116, 0.0026302338, -0.058532715, -0.04827881, -0.024307251, 0.056640625, -0.0064811707, 0.031066895, 0.041168213, 0.031433105, 0.08331299, 0.07910156, -0.04788208, -0.003358841, 0.0011587143, 0.0018453598, -0.05670166, 0.023666382, 0.033447266, 0.008354187, -0.044158936, 0.010063171, -0.027008057, 0.009506226, 0.003917694, -0.025390625, 0.020706177, 0.008888245, -0.03652954, -0.025024414, 0.015434265, -0.024139404, 0.00374794, -0.011741638, 0.0034751892, 0.03692627, -0.002588272, -0.0067710876, 0.0028190613, -0.025527954, 0.015670776, -0.040283203, -0.011993408, 0.0054779053, 0.03933716, -0.023880005, -0.0005478859, -0.00043535233, 0.029251099, -0.017990112, -0.0031719208, -0.09436035, 0.033996582, -0.03439331, 0.054748535, -0.006969452, 0.011436462, -0.0026950836, -0.025405884, 0.014808655, -0.02015686, 0.00969696, 0.0033912659, 0.03741455, -0.03552246, -0.007369995, -0.022232056, -0.008178711, 0.04107666, -0.05114746, 0.044158936, 0.0262146, 0.008079529, -0.024017334, 0.0075569153, 0.062164307, 0.016174316, 0.06628418, -0.023910522, 0.026611328, 0.07489014, 0.013084412, -0.03543091, -0.012786865, -0.10040283, 0.0423584, 0.05078125, 0.009979248, 0.003900528, -0.022994995, -0.0053749084, -0.05230713, -0.020202637, 0.020523071, -0.016815186, -0.07171631, -0.06829834, 0.04510498, -0.002609253, 0.03829956, 0.043914795, -0.035705566, 0.012519836, -0.011108398, -0.03604126, -0.0075683594, 0.005004883, 0.018447876, 0.016860962, -0.027694702, 0.03225708, -0.068847656, 0.004425049, -0.008239746, 0.00187397, 0.010681152, -0.031433105, 0.019119263, 0.008781433, -0.005794525, -0.06616211, -0.07196045, -0.00969696, -0.025787354, 0.062194824, 0.022033691, -0.053009033, -0.014289856, -0.022109985, -0.02104187, -0.015563965, 0.040130615, 0.04486084, 0.010665894, -0.017440796, 0.02154541, 0.03414917, 0.044647217, 0.02053833, -0.003829956, 0.017929077, 0.00983429, -0.01586914, -0.008865356, 0.076171875, -0.009284973, -0.0066719055, -0.033447266, 0.008743286, -0.043914795, 0.002916336, -0.00016021729, 0.011100769, 0.015022278, 0.0054779053, -0.0065612793, -0.017868042, -0.042175293, -0.011642456, 0.023132324, 0.04837036, 0.008460999, -0.035064697, 0.020690918, 0.038360596, 0.017288208, 0.04815674, 0.087768555, 0.028503418, 0.0015516281, 0.0074272156, 0.015289307, -0.04534912, 0.011314392, -0.025741577, 0.019699097, 0.0009317398, -0.00983429, -0.015930176, -0.037750244, 0.007965088, 0.0054359436, 0.004737854, 0.017837524, 0.012275696, 0.036193848, 0.042907715, 0.07293701, 0.0049057007, -0.0053520203, -0.015403748, -0.012077332, 0.01020813, 0.0062408447, 0.012130737, -0.027770996, 0.019577026, -0.024993896, -0.017456055, -0.012802124, 0.051696777, 0.0124435425, -0.0052948, 0.008354187, 0.013710022, -0.0178833, -0.036376953, 0.06088257, 0.0020160675, 0.01399231, -0.032348633, -0.007865906, -0.027648926, 0.039276123, -0.039398193, 0.0070991516, 0.017669678, -0.007621765, 0.047698975, -0.050872803, -0.03390503, -0.019058228, 0.0042381287, 0.056793213, -0.018737793, -0.01727295, 0.025634766, -0.0033226013, 0.008407593, -0.016830444, -0.007751465, 0.025405884, -0.0014047623, -0.045318604, -0.01651001, 0.038085938, 0.025909424, 0.024673462, 0.0008482933, 0.020217896, -0.010818481, 0.0017681122, -0.018310547, -0.025863647, 0.044769287, -0.06188965, -0.006641388, 0.014099121, 0.014503479, 0.012901306, -0.0015983582, -0.020950317, 0.03656006, 0.015655518, -0.0031795502, 0.0143585205, -0.003709793, 0.031799316, -0.011657715, -0.0012798309, -0.0070266724, 0.00012755394, -0.029815674, 0.04815674, 0.0008649826, -0.030197144, -0.006538391, 0.035064697, -0.015014648, -0.006526947, 0.0007658005, 0.02029419, 0.047332764, 0.014770508, 0.009391785, -0.021087646, 0.015945435, 0.03677368, -0.044677734, 0.01084137, 0.03527832, -0.02583313, -0.037963867, -0.033050537, -0.062927246, 0.036987305, -0.088012695, -0.07904053, -0.023468018, -0.0066871643, -0.009147644, -0.013183594, -0.00016880035, 0.0038928986, -0.056854248, -0.009002686, 0.020889282, -0.012626648, 0.017364502, -0.021011353, 0.026931763, -0.0256958, -0.008621216, -0.03286743, 0.0152282715, 0.02720642, -0.043670654, 0.017333984, 0.0057640076, -0.06451416, -0.008575439, 0.047546387, 0.03564453, -0.0206604, -0.012863159, -0.03086853, 0.02154541, -0.007858276, -0.048736572, -0.012207031, 0.003818512, -0.005554199, 0.008308411, 0.008041382, -0.012786865, 0.014785767, 0.0034751892, -0.055664062, 0.037231445, -0.09118652, -0.06500244, -0.039123535, -0.012550354, -0.057861328, -0.06414795, 0.01449585, 0.010795593, -0.017166138, -0.021713257, 0.02709961, 0.0015687943, -0.010070801, 0.028182983, -0.02609253, 0.11608887, 0.046813965, -0.0036888123, 0.017318726, -0.03189087, -0.020004272, -0.03237915, -0.006652832, 0.011192322, 0.004421234, -0.01058197, 0.013977051, -0.02053833, 0.008155823, -0.022964478, 0.015052795, 0.03111267, -0.024368286, -0.0045394897, 0.027633667, 0.023834229, -0.007820129, -0.0046539307, 0.03866577, 0.05078125, -0.04714966, 0.018814087, 0.029708862, -0.017654419, -0.044921875, 0.020370483, -0.012321472, -0.032958984, 0.06616211, 0.028213501, -0.0030822754, 0.0256958, -0.017501831, 0.0043640137, -0.0135650635, -0.044036865, -0.036468506, 0.01638794, -0.020431519, 0.0079956055, 0.038024902, 0.04360962, -0.01939392, -0.012718201, -0.033447266, 0.03756714, -0.04449463, 0.004562378, 0.03302002, 0.012565613, -0.025665283, -0.024353027, 0.011108398, -0.031707764, -0.028839111, 0.012832642, 0.0143585205, 0.024871826, -0.052520752, -0.018676758, -0.010894775, 0.07080078, -0.0018539429, 0.047576904, -0.028335571, -0.020324707, -0.037078857, 0.0065193176, -0.07128906, -0.02218628, -0.06021118, -0.05368042, -0.041778564, 0.0075950623, -0.029724121, 0.00868988, 0.011772156, 0.079711914, -0.00024485588, 0.02999878, -0.04727173, 0.01184082, -0.029174805, 0.024169922, 0.020965576, 0.017822266, 0.0018291473, 0.018341064, 0.016036987, -0.010437012, -0.030288696, -0.079833984, -0.01058197, 0.018966675, -0.01133728, 0.077697754, 0.057891846, 0.015434265, 0.025909424, 0.023452759, 0.0028305054, -0.0093688965, -0.042541504, 0.031066895, 0.07312012, -0.020736694, -0.043548584, 0.0015325546, 0.02897644, 0.03366089, -0.01852417, -0.031234741, -0.02508545, 0.026489258, 0.029251099, -0.023254395, -0.011131287, 0.007091522, 0.02998352, 0.025146484, 0.024276733, 0.02003479, 0.0056991577, 0.03579712, -0.00415802, 0.02418518, -0.027526855, -0.0009407997, -0.010047913, -0.0119018555, -0.05456543, -0.051696777, -0.029968262, 0.07220459, -0.008148193, -0.018035889, -0.0060653687, -0.037506104, 0.006290436, 0.0059127808, -0.004585266, -0.04458618, 0.02684021, -0.01977539, -0.024551392, -0.004272461, -0.023910522, -0.055877686, -0.0209198, 0.01763916, -0.0014781952, 0.038513184, 0.014526367, 0.018737793, -0.006752014, -0.0044937134, 0.0006632805, -0.046813965, -0.06616211, -0.01751709, -0.020095825, -0.024291992, 0.03488159, -0.024215698, -0.013168335, 0.022460938, -0.02885437, 0.011268616, -0.029632568, -0.020645142, -0.030014038, -0.0087509155, 0.041931152, 0.0045776367, -0.027191162, 0.017913818, -0.020843506, -0.029052734, 0.01109314, -0.030563354, 0.0031375885, -0.076293945, 0.024383545, 0.021072388, 0.01626587, 0.019821167, -0.00894165, -0.022216797, -0.024093628, -0.03253174, -0.02444458, -0.06567383, 0.00932312, -0.03149414, 0.029388428, -0.07775879, -0.009613037, -0.054840088, 0.055236816, -0.025817871, -0.0011234283, -0.01159668, -0.0082092285, 0.029708862, -0.017959595, -0.03591919, 0.01977539, 0.0335083, -0.028335571, -0.0052871704, 0.009971619, 0.004085541, -0.028427124, -0.026687622, -0.03265381, -0.014762878, -0.021453857, 0.05291748, -0.028396606, -0.004386902, 0.008422852, -0.039886475, -0.0052986145, 0.026550293, -0.03967285, -0.0027275085, 0.0015144348, -0.022369385, 0.041137695, 0.033691406, -0.04763794, 0.032592773, 0.025878906, 0.05041504, 0.038970947, 0.007411957, 0.03289795, 0.019683838, 0.034973145, -0.007209778, 0.047332764, 0.004047394, -0.018188477, 0.0011014938, -0.00995636, -0.02130127, 0.027694702, -0.019088745, 0.056152344, 0.0121154785, -0.0045318604, -0.027923584, 0.026275635, -0.05078125, -0.0496521, 0.014877319, 0.0018367767, 0.0013589859, -0.038208008, 0.008705139, -0.00749588, 0.009017944, 0.03475952, 0.032196045, 0.0031547546, 0.0034713745, 0.019195557, -0.042663574, -0.052947998, 0.004951477, -0.008407593, -0.012184143, 0.099853516, -0.020767212, 0.006095886, 0.01953125, -0.0032043457, -0.062805176, -0.008033752, -0.0040245056, 0.07672119, 0.041015625, 0.0024318695, 0.025817871, 0.0043945312, 0.0018939972, -0.018753052, -0.035369873, 0.015068054, 0.051940918, 0.009643555, 0.0050086975, 0.009407043, -0.026260376, -0.02218628, 0.004432678, 0.019104004, -0.037902832, 0.047424316, 0.0012254715, -0.051361084, -0.03878784, -0.06225586, -0.019317627, 0.0087890625, -0.00069856644, -0.0107421875, 0.019180298, -0.0023612976, -0.02180481, 0.024139404, -0.04840088, 0.03805542, -0.0124053955, -0.07476807, -0.034332275, -0.03778076, 0.055877686, 0.024749756, 0.036621094, 0.010101318, 0.019332886, 0.034240723, -0.0051574707, 0.0050697327, 0.018539429, -0.012290955, -0.06298828, 0.035339355, -0.039520264, 0.061401367, 0.046661377, 0.033111572, 0.016860962, 0.008399963, 0.058166504, -0.039245605, 0.0036849976, 0.052734375, 0.014732361, 0.009727478, 0.02027893, 0.059631348, -0.028533936, -0.010566711, -0.02720642, 0.076416016, -0.0026626587, 0.06298828, -0.05609131, -0.025009155, -0.022094727, 0.017074585, -0.035461426, -0.011833191, -0.049621582, -0.026870728, 0.0154800415, 0.024887085, -0.035980225, -0.026473999, 0.004234314, 0.00093603134, -0.024505615, 0.015403748, -0.047180176, 0.042266846, -0.06555176, 0.019592285, -0.03286743, -0.02960205, 0.022033691, -0.012298584, 0.026748657, 0.018051147, 0.031188965, 0.039764404, 0.0042495728, 0.05670166, 0.058135986, 0.03970337, -0.020095825, -0.0037078857, 0.089538574, -0.041137695, 0.0024738312, 0.015777588, -0.017105103, -0.06774902, 0.012992859, 0.021697998, -0.036590576, 0.031082153, 0.008460999, -0.03173828, 0.012390137, -0.014816284, -0.03503418, -0.008583069, -0.0007915497, 0.021392822, -0.029296875, -0.01789856, -0.0017547607, -0.030349731, -0.024993896, 0.05923462, -0.033416748, -0.021194458, 0.049835205, -0.013717651, -0.0057144165, -0.018539429, -0.012237549, 0.019882202, 0.010269165, 0.06304932, 0.049682617, -0.010574341, 0.032958984, 0.011047363, 0.003206253, -0.057739258, -0.029251099, 0.0064849854, 0.039733887, 0.007774353, -0.021621704, 0.004749298, -0.016967773, -0.02104187, -0.018218994, 0.026504517, -0.022598267, 0.039031982, 0.055358887, -0.01876831, -0.0060577393, 0.016433716, -0.03100586, 0.0625, -0.017410278, 0.0085372925, 0.0015592575, 0.0039367676, -0.041259766, -0.036590576, 0.014671326, 0.023605347, 0.0211792, -0.033813477, 0.0026607513, 0.0070495605, 0.009788513, -0.022842407, -0.01890564, 0.012176514, 0.0038700104, 0.012641907, -0.03387451, 0.016555786, -0.020935059, -0.024261475, -0.011672974, -0.021362305, 0.006717682, 0.017227173, 0.028045654, 0.041992188, 0.040985107, -0.022415161, 0.02973938, 0.025131226, -0.018447876, -0.013664246, 0.020828247, 0.01399231, -0.0023727417, 0.009513855, 0.036376953, -0.047729492, -0.008232117, -0.027267456, -0.023925781, -0.00023651123, 0.006954193, 0.008728027, 0.0072021484, -0.031341553, 0.037261963, -0.024261475, 0.017868042, -0.024032593, 0.0013666153, -0.010475159, 0.01411438, -0.027954102, 0.005332947, -0.025604248, 0.0012893677, 0.013244629, -0.009208679, 0.018096924, -0.026870728, 0.032806396, -0.018859863, -0.0287323, -0.10986328, -0.030776978, -0.0056495667, -0.034057617, 0.019042969, 0.03265381, -0.018600464, 0.023895264, 0.03137207, 0.06173706, 0.022750854, 0.029647827, 0.0068206787, -0.005092621, 0.00831604 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2003.10412v1
What is Normal, What is Strange, and What is Missing in a Knowledge Graph: Unified Characterization via Inductive Summarization
Caleb Belth, Xinyi Zheng, Jilles Vreeken, Danai Koutra
cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
Knowledge graphs (KGs) store highly heterogeneous information about the world in the structure of a graph, and are useful for tasks such as question answering and reasoning. However, they often contain errors and are missing information. Vibrant research in KG refinement has worked to resolve these issues, tailoring techniques to either detect specific types of errors or complete a KG. In this work, we introduce a unified solution to KG characterization by formulating the problem as unsupervised KG summarization with a set of inductive, soft rules, which describe what is normal in a KG, and thus can be used to identify what is abnormal, whether it be strange or missing. Unlike first-order logic rules, our rules are labeled, rooted graphs, i.e., patterns that describe the expected neighborhood around a (seen or unseen) node, based on its type, and information in the KG. Stepping away from the traditional support/confidence-based rule mining techniques, we propose KGist, Knowledge Graph Inductive SummarizaTion, which learns a summary of inductive rules that best compress the KG according to the Minimum Description Length principle---a formulation that we are the first to use in the context of KG rule mining. We apply our rules to three large KGs (NELL, DBpedia, and Yago), and tasks such as compression, various types of error detection, and identification of incomplete information. We show that KGist outperforms task-specific, supervised and unsupervised baselines in error detection and incompleteness identification, (identifying the location of up to 93% of missing entities---over 10% more than baselines), while also being efficient for large knowledge graphs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2003.10412v1
2020-03-23T17:38:31
2020-03-23T17:38:31
{ "title": [ -0.025680542, 0.0014104843, -0.0625, -0.08508301, 0.0137786865, -0.009963989, -0.054840088, 0.01576233, -0.04248047, 0.0116119385, -0.034698486, 0.04510498, -0.03866577, -0.01461792, -0.018585205, -0.025238037, 0.00057172775, 0.05960083, -0.004119873, -0.018554688, -0.038909912, -0.021820068, 0.044311523, 0.038604736, 0.0098724365, -0.02420044, -0.015045166, 0.035095215, -0.03152466, -0.030670166, -0.015792847, -0.017868042, 0.030960083, 0.0011024475, 0.018737793, -0.039794922, -0.03201294, 0.007385254, 0.006465912, 0.0050621033, 0.0061798096, 0.0023021698, 0.04107666, -0.06341553, -0.019805908, 0.0602417, -0.07269287, -0.0061950684, -0.002035141, 0.021133423, -0.010749817, 0.023422241, -0.02357483, 0.027664185, 0.008010864, -0.030593872, -0.030212402, -0.054260254, 0.034698486, 0.059570312, 0.019683838, -0.07940674, 0.01914978, -0.028442383, -0.026000977, -0.030914307, -0.028579712, 0.020874023, 0.05581665, 0.0067863464, -0.008728027, 0.03894043, 0.026351929, 0.0047340393, -0.03540039, -0.025650024, 0.038879395, -0.010314941, 0.03074646, -0.024429321, -0.008613586, 0.004398346, -0.04284668, -0.02999878, 0.015853882, -0.03262329, -0.011779785, -0.0046539307, -0.037384033, -0.043029785, -0.0049209595, -0.052490234, -0.023406982, 0.04159546, -0.013839722, -0.018371582, 0.032562256, 0.042510986, 0.0034980774, -0.02519226, -0.0072746277, 0.0023708344, -0.042022705, -0.00881958, 0.031204224, 0.0056877136, -0.04486084, -0.018875122, 0.040252686, 0.045654297, -0.018951416, 0.022720337, 0.021774292, -0.014930725, 0.027511597, -0.027053833, -0.041503906, 0.06500244, 0.01751709, 0.04058838, -0.029220581, -0.022094727, -0.008712769, 0.025421143, -0.009513855, -0.013511658, -0.008010864, 0.015823364, 0.00082302094, 0.012840271, 0.015716553, 0.0569458, -0.08496094, -0.0960083, -0.06100464, 0.04550171, -0.004299164, -0.027008057, -0.019088745, 0.023788452, -0.023345947, -0.03338623, 0.012329102, -0.030303955, 0.014289856, 0.021224976, 0.057891846, -0.024978638, -0.044036865, -0.06341553, 0.00063991547, 0.0037174225, 0.033325195, -0.023727417, -0.07904053, -0.023498535, -0.14038086, 0.00014901161, 0.031021118, -0.0036754608, 0.020721436, 0.015396118, -0.012710571, 0.0063285828, 0.033691406, -0.015365601, 0.019439697, 0.023239136, 0.0020275116, 0.028656006, -0.035339355, 0.026138306, 0.015205383, -0.0115356445, 0.001868248, -0.0025978088, 0.0038890839, -0.035461426, 0.0050239563, 0.018753052, 0.013069153, -0.010879517, -0.052246094, 0.07183838, -0.097351074, 0.013656616, -0.011276245, 0.004016876, 0.064331055, -0.025283813, 0.014411926, 0.034210205, -0.027511597, -0.03366089, -0.030929565, -0.0236969, 0.03302002, 0.014930725, 0.0005745888, -0.011482239, -0.02267456, 0.008079529, -0.03677368, 0.010437012, -0.0031204224, -0.02571106, -0.008033752, 0.013214111, -0.036712646, 0.04244995, 0.07116699, 0.01574707, -0.066101074, 0.048461914, 0.012992859, -0.051605225, 0.022659302, -0.011489868, -0.0104599, 0.0023097992, 0.0023326874, -0.010566711, 0.011886597, 0.05517578, 0.03717041, -0.015075684, 0.011680603, -0.0446167, 0.051879883, 0.019042969, 0.036254883, -0.037628174, 0.007255554, 0.016845703, -0.020614624, -0.01864624, -0.03274536, -0.012329102, 0.00037264824, 0.009864807, -0.004966736, -0.01713562, -0.0115356445, 0.018508911, 0.042510986, -0.012962341, 0.0066337585, 0.005756378, -0.0090789795, 0.01386261, 0.059509277, 0.0670166, 0.02557373, 0.062469482, -0.007522583, 0.061767578, 0.03765869, 0.030517578, -0.021453857, 0.03314209, -0.015853882, -0.00018787384, -0.011726379, 0.010932922, -0.060302734, 0.021240234, -0.004798889, 0.027282715, 0.020523071, -0.02116394, 0.007633209, 0.0048713684, 0.014160156, 0.032989502, 0.004940033, -0.0101623535, -0.017944336, 0.0054397583, 0.00012814999, -0.03286743, 0.0073432922, 0.034210205, 0.05215454, 0.0057373047, 0.011131287, -0.017700195, 0.01386261, -0.003271103, -0.029327393, -0.011512756, 0.033477783, 0.050842285, 0.0057525635, -0.0011091232, 0.008903503, -0.0024719238, 0.028701782, 0.038208008, -0.0039520264, 0.010604858, -0.055114746, 0.02923584, 0.03640747, -0.033935547, 0.005466461, 0.004890442, 0.04547119, 0.013397217, -0.044128418, -0.019638062, -0.042907715, -0.017868042, -0.0018892288, -0.024642944, -0.029663086, -0.029006958, 0.014312744, -0.03845215, -0.023132324, -0.036987305, 0.045043945, -0.009963989, -0.03173828, -0.013504028, 0.012687683, -0.021636963, -0.041778564, -0.02520752, -0.018844604, 0.007194519, -0.00630188, -0.0069236755, -0.07086182, 0.025985718, -0.0124053955, 0.016540527, -0.01977539, 0.010536194, -0.041290283, -0.0007472038, -0.008651733, -0.020507812, 0.022277832, -0.036956787, 0.00831604, -0.049865723, 0.066345215, 0.0119018555, -0.033355713, 0.02104187, 0.009376526, -0.020553589, -0.010795593, -0.0034122467, 0.06842041, -0.034210205, -0.02407837, 0.05731201, 0.030899048, 0.0016851425, 0.02003479, 0.029724121, 0.008918762, -0.029266357, -0.022323608, -0.033050537, -0.008796692, 0.0045814514, -0.0256958, 0.024520874, -0.03894043, 0.0043411255, -0.0848999, -0.019821167, -0.02432251, 0.033569336, -0.005718231, -0.04257202, -0.0009551048, -0.0023994446, -0.01777649, 0.02532959, -0.05355835, 0.01838684, 0.10571289, 0.0065231323, -0.0068511963, 0.043029785, 0.018371582, 0.00048589706, -0.036865234, -0.04949951, -0.030319214, -0.0028076172, -0.019515991, -0.000030577183, -0.009986877, -0.0057373047, -0.06506348, 0.012130737, 0.009513855, -0.016708374, -0.031829834, 0.015007019, -0.05895996, 0.02633667, -0.0062294006, -0.022277832, 0.03668213, 0.070373535, -0.00894165, 0.028762817, -0.012992859, 0.015640259, -0.014503479, -0.000104248524, -0.07672119, 0.014045715, 0.010643005, -0.036315918, -0.0007557869, -0.043884277, -0.02810669, -0.0024166107, -0.052856445, 0.015602112, 0.04156494, 0.06488037, -0.011238098, -0.038146973, -0.010978699, -0.055725098, 0.002527237, -0.009780884, -0.022247314, -0.016143799, -0.023666382, 0.029525757, 0.0016880035, -0.0060920715, -0.004814148, -0.007835388, 0.011917114, 0.026977539, 0.0063705444, -0.025344849, -0.0137786865, 0.012237549, -0.033050537, 0.04373169, -0.020065308, 0.006340027, -0.06726074, 0.021255493, -0.04269409, 0.047668457, 0.0022888184, 0.031021118, -0.05908203, -0.017303467, 0.025726318, -0.01537323, -0.06439209, 0.0049591064, 0.04876709, 0.0016174316, 0.03515625, -0.030334473, -0.02709961, 0.022964478, -0.019577026, -0.024536133, 0.025146484, -0.0126953125, 0.025558472, 0.016082764, -0.029144287, -0.024490356, -0.028793335, 0.013183594, 0.008255005, -0.0018396378, -0.031951904, -0.05697632, -0.011634827, 0.005050659, -0.12219238, -0.040496826, 0.001953125, -0.022949219, -0.008384705, -0.072509766, 0.020507812, -0.04321289, -0.060272217, -0.006084442, -0.016906738, 0.04449463, 0.009757996, -0.08203125, 0.0026016235, 0.06750488, 0.026229858, 0.007511139, 0.050445557, -0.01210022, -0.027679443, -0.051116943, 0.019943237, 0.023025513, 0.0006175041, -0.012306213, -0.019088745, 0.0079956055, -0.01838684, 0.032958984, 0.0036849976, -0.02923584, 0.015487671, 0.015792847, -0.019363403, 0.005420685, -0.013786316, 0.03817749, 0.032073975, -0.0209198, -0.03302002, 0.052734375, 0.002155304, -0.028640747, 0.027130127, -0.0137786865, 0.0345459, 0.04107666, -0.013465881, 0.049591064, -0.02305603, -0.01525116, 0.05316162, 0.019851685, -0.01914978, -0.000875473, 0.012504578, 0.049041748, 0.0046653748, 0.026916504, -0.002298355, 0.061035156, -0.054382324, 0.002008438, -0.015411377, 0.003944397, -0.04574585, 0.024520874, -0.018585205, -0.054992676, -0.047302246, 0.021347046, -0.011856079, 0.039916992, 0.018157959, 0.009437561, -0.04800415, 0.0066566467, 0.011505127, 0.011657715, -0.0078086853, -0.041809082, -0.004501343, -0.021316528, -0.03353882, -0.04852295, -0.019470215, -0.005126953, 0.005268097, 0.008338928, -0.017715454, 0.019256592, 0.021011353, 0.06890869, 0.0052719116, 0.0053749084, -0.024353027, 0.0501709, -0.034332275, 0.012687683, 0.03866577, -0.005680084, 0.0052337646, -0.016036987, -0.030410767, 0.007007599, -0.0054244995, -0.023101807, 0.0074501038, -0.012672424, 0.04345703, 0.014373779, 0.039611816, 0.030151367, -0.030075073, 0.008079529, -0.021377563, -0.034088135, 0.035247803, 0.036132812, 0.04449463, -0.01272583, 0.0020141602, 0.04727173, 0.0065727234, -0.0033988953, 0.017211914, -0.008964539, 0.02217102, 0.006034851, 0.017242432, 0.0068893433, -0.05606079, -0.032348633, -0.013801575, 0.016021729, 0.059509277, -0.049438477, 0.054138184, -0.015945435, -0.0009560585, 0.0076560974, -0.012466431, 0.022750854, -0.003917694, 0.02444458, -0.039916992, -0.040100098, -0.019561768, 0.03475952, -0.035491943, 0.0034389496, 0.0012388229, 0.02394104, 0.03768921, 0.015991211, 0.03262329, -0.042236328, -0.0259552, -0.018447876, -0.013420105, 0.010047913, -0.038360596, 0.009849548, 0.007888794, 0.008857727, -0.05429077, -0.00274086, -0.048431396, -0.013427734, -0.015914917, -0.0022029877, 0.0055885315, -0.059295654, 0.04055786, 0.07647705, 0.015258789, 0.039855957, -0.034973145, 0.012969971, 0.009712219, 0.049468994, -0.012466431, 0.026489258, 0.055023193, -0.053131104, -0.0039711, 0.0036392212, 0.017059326, -0.013710022, 0.074645996, 0.00022602081, 0.019622803, -0.062805176, 0.03390503, 0.022476196, 0.015075684, -0.026473999, -0.042297363, 0.030776978, -0.026382446, 0.0010738373, 0.026260376, 0.0024051666, -0.01184845, 0.021026611, 0.00868988, 0.005645752, 0.017822266, 0.021499634, -0.04660034, -0.062316895, 0.005596161, 0.0070877075, 0.022201538, -0.008361816, 0.019836426, -0.05593872, 0.0069618225, 0.043670654, -0.05581665, 0.066467285, -0.022750854, 0.010635376, 0.071899414, 0.019363403, -0.025802612, -0.0072784424, 0.003370285, -0.029190063, -0.025360107, -0.022994995, -0.018417358, 0.024002075, -0.009681702, -0.032196045, -0.045959473, -0.013542175, 0.0036315918, -0.037475586, -0.028152466, 0.04119873, 0.015914917, 0.039764404, 0.006416321, 0.033691406, 0.009140015, -0.010124207, 0.013320923, -0.03857422, 0.014297485, 0.029251099, 0.033569336, 0.015029907, -0.042114258, -0.0071868896, 0.036193848, 0.0057754517, 0.0012321472, 0.01737976, 0.033477783, 0.06994629, -0.03591919, -0.008125305, 0.0289917, -0.004638672, 0.0018396378, -0.024978638, 0.0025844574, -0.057006836, 0.048736572, -0.008216858, 0.006061554, -0.039001465, -0.060638428, -0.023742676, 0.00092601776, 0.011581421, 0.0069847107, 0.007820129, -0.04788208, 0.011581421, -0.014205933, -0.007030487, -0.03640747, 0.03933716, 0.0055007935, 0.014823914, -0.009971619, -0.015991211, 0.018127441, -0.036865234, 0.0184021, 0.01576233, -0.01134491, 0.019729614, -0.0357666, 0.008163452, -0.01852417, -0.016967773, 0.013954163, 0.02406311, -0.03189087, 0.028198242, -0.043640137, 0.06652832, 0.03488159, 0.061187744, 0.008346558, 0.005027771, 0.049713135, 0.016784668, 0.0068626404, -0.026168823, 0.01625061, -0.029067993, 0.013755798, -0.025619507, -0.010681152, -0.06530762, 0.01374054, 0.038970947, 0.022140503, 0.0051612854, 0.014518738, 0.013496399, 0.024230957, 0.037322998, 0.013877869, 0.059936523, 0.0017223358, 0.003774643, 0.004600525, 0.0070724487, -0.0015363693, 0.03515625, 0.020126343, 0.0077400208, -0.038909912, -0.024505615, 0.019866943, 0.018615723, -0.00504303, -0.00057697296, 0.0014390945, -0.050445557, 0.0057678223, -0.0041007996, 0.020568848, 0.0020370483, 0.022415161, -0.0154800415, 0.019012451, -0.021453857, -0.028533936, -0.013420105, -0.043426514, 0.028869629, -0.09411621, 0.013542175, -0.015182495, -0.0070991516, 0.0010881424, 0.032226562, 0.04638672, -0.06161499, -0.024551392, 0.009086609, 0.020233154, 0.00491333, 0.033599854, -0.022949219, -0.0035152435, -0.027267456, -0.020706177, 0.040527344, 0.03564453, 0.02746582, 0.021072388, 0.003932953, -0.04840088, 0.009628296, 0.0067443848, 0.0037670135, 0.027145386, 0.02394104, 0.03262329, -0.024520874, -0.037109375, 0.02357483, -0.0016527176, -0.046295166, -0.027114868, 0.049987793, 0.035583496, 0.039093018, 0.08905029, 0.027557373, 0.0055007935, -0.018035889, -0.031799316, 0.024612427, 0.048065186, -0.030471802, -0.010261536, -0.04171753, -0.047607422, -0.002380371, -0.035095215, 0.06762695, -0.02218628, -0.0107803345, -0.029724121, 0.039489746, 0.018569946, -0.0284729, -0.028030396, -0.012870789, -0.032318115, -0.023406982, -0.021499634, -0.030807495, 0.011444092, -0.037750244, -0.00737381, 0.016036987, 0.022216797, -0.008804321, -0.050598145, -0.024383545, 0.04345703, 0.005329132, 0.0914917, -0.0009293556, -0.0034542084, -0.023101807, 0.016036987, -0.02418518, -0.036468506, 0.003534317, -0.027114868, -0.03857422, -0.028427124, 0.03277588, 0.015617371, -0.008018494, -0.0026226044, -0.020355225, 0.018356323, -0.014816284, 0.028747559, 0.026611328, -0.0602417, 0.02268982, 0.022842407, -0.032287598, 0.06549072, -0.004814148, -0.015670776, 0.013023376, 0.015930176, -0.024856567, -0.03753662, -0.0049057007, 0.014533997, -0.008079529, -0.019897461, 0.013763428, 0.01550293, 0.025604248, -0.059692383, -0.062438965, -0.0146102905, 0.012123108, 0.021148682, 0.084106445, -0.0040283203, 0.001206398, -0.010147095, 0.043701172, 0.00031280518, -0.044647217, -0.021011353, -0.034240723, 0.03567505, 0.029968262, -0.0024528503, -0.014129639, 0.038970947, 0.009422302, 0.010406494, 0.0385437, -0.027511597, 0.0057792664, -0.005104065, 0.013427734, -0.013442993, -0.039489746, -0.033172607, 0.009140015, 0.010910034, 0.03768921, -0.026824951, 0.022232056, -0.003856659, 0.037506104, -0.04058838, -0.026535034, 0.025268555, 0.028701782, -0.0031051636, 0.057250977, -0.016494751, -0.008796692, -0.010734558, 0.001709938, -0.016326904, 0.0051002502, 0.050445557, -0.012710571, 0.011161804, -0.033996582, -0.018035889, -0.0060424805, -0.039367676, 0.04852295, -0.0022716522, -0.008758545, -0.004508972, -0.008850098, 0.014091492, 0.02558899, 0.030288696, -0.03274536, -0.013053894, 0.023986816, 0.027297974, -0.0038146973 ], "summary": [ -0.03112793, -0.05038452, -0.022415161, -0.046539307, -0.07562256, 0.030334473, -0.08850098, 0.02909851, -0.0064353943, 0.023071289, -0.064453125, 0.03845215, -0.006893158, 0.010848999, 0.010826111, -0.04812622, 0.026947021, 0.03845215, 0.05355835, -0.018356323, 0.019638062, -0.0075035095, 0.05847168, 0.04901123, -0.013221741, 0.007511139, 0.06317139, 0.01876831, -0.012672424, -0.0021533966, 0.006591797, -0.033966064, 0.023132324, 0.025878906, -0.015777588, -0.007259369, -0.003271103, -0.011558533, -0.018798828, 0.055908203, 0.020843506, -0.01878357, 0.1005249, -0.057495117, 0.020706177, 0.06768799, -0.034057617, -0.03744507, 0.030944824, 0.015914917, -0.011764526, 0.030426025, -0.016662598, -0.010513306, -0.0184021, -0.0149383545, -0.021865845, -0.027679443, 0.018981934, 0.020584106, -0.0047836304, -0.04486084, 0.02558899, -0.018463135, -0.025558472, -0.011734009, 0.055267334, -0.0071144104, -0.001543045, -0.045410156, 0.011474609, 0.038085938, 0.032958984, -0.015792847, -0.032562256, 0.00036501884, 0.0019445419, 0.0072784424, 0.02418518, -0.031677246, -0.004634857, 0.03186035, -0.0048942566, -0.033172607, -0.0004911423, -0.023422241, -0.022354126, -0.011039734, -0.025894165, 0.006641388, -0.024536133, -0.02168274, -0.05078125, 0.06359863, 0.022018433, -0.012321472, -0.01777649, -0.0076179504, -0.024002075, -0.03112793, 0.026168823, -0.012802124, -0.025039673, -0.0040740967, 0.013015747, 0.040985107, -0.037078857, -0.051116943, 0.037261963, 0.01689148, 0.0023937225, -0.0042686462, 0.014099121, -0.021774292, 0.01146698, 0.0059928894, -0.010421753, 0.07183838, 0.010681152, 0.044036865, -0.027145386, -0.0029182434, -0.028778076, 0.00166893, -0.014038086, -0.031204224, -0.013633728, 0.041900635, 0.03491211, -0.03286743, -0.0051612854, 0.045288086, -0.0070877075, -0.02305603, -0.033721924, 0.02229309, -0.006439209, 0.010757446, 0.0014696121, -0.0064582825, -0.018341064, -0.01663208, 0.007709503, -0.009025574, 0.050994873, 0.04534912, 0.02557373, -0.014526367, 0.0061073303, -0.027450562, 0.016479492, -0.01838684, 0.04458618, -0.040161133, -0.076538086, -0.08807373, -0.089782715, -0.019363403, 0.048187256, -0.041290283, -0.028442383, -0.0065689087, -0.014587402, 0.005531311, -0.019638062, 0.011779785, 0.041015625, 0.0073547363, -0.011680603, -0.05722046, -0.044799805, 0.070617676, 0.01838684, -0.045318604, -0.003932953, -0.016525269, -0.011581421, -0.029754639, -0.020019531, 0.101867676, 0.062072754, -0.015731812, -0.07092285, 0.06359863, -0.013946533, 0.021820068, -0.003566742, -0.001408577, 0.030975342, 0.009254456, -0.011451721, 0.03842163, -0.007926941, 0.003068924, 0.008071899, -0.034240723, 0.015991211, -0.0020942688, 0.008102417, -0.021057129, 0.022415161, 0.004207611, -0.02645874, 0.009101868, -0.0501709, -0.018508911, -0.013465881, 0.012832642, -0.06829834, 0.027282715, 0.050567627, -0.00068950653, -0.058258057, 0.042816162, 0.03579712, -0.06036377, 0.010467529, -0.0110321045, 0.018447876, -0.019866943, 0.033050537, 0.019882202, -0.000069499016, 0.02961731, -0.005168915, 0.026016235, -0.036376953, 0.0090789795, -0.012939453, 0.024810791, -0.012924194, 0.00076293945, 0.01096344, 0.032958984, -0.0008854866, 0.00541687, 0.019683838, -0.029556274, 0.004562378, 0.009819031, 0.02709961, -0.016860962, -0.037902832, -0.032043457, 0.042419434, -0.018295288, 0.0013284683, -0.008964539, -0.028213501, 0.020843506, 0.03363037, 0.035736084, -0.0035934448, 0.050964355, -0.017868042, 0.005874634, -0.0038051605, 0.025512695, -0.013580322, 0.0069084167, -0.011505127, -0.0178833, 0.0052375793, -0.021453857, 0.009590149, -0.014656067, 0.002840042, -0.0070610046, 0.0104904175, -0.018676758, -0.008117676, -0.06347656, 0.008766174, 0.013648987, -0.049346924, -0.012832642, 0.006439209, 0.01260376, 0.002105713, -0.013389587, -0.00381279, 0.0012407303, 0.027282715, -0.0017576218, 0.027511597, 0.0059890747, 0.02305603, 0.010375977, -0.014701843, 0.029541016, 0.037017822, 0.05505371, 0.006690979, 0.021514893, -0.027420044, 0.019104004, -0.029251099, -0.021575928, 0.018508911, -0.03213501, 0.011169434, 0.06011963, 0.008041382, -0.0053977966, 0.023269653, -0.010650635, 0.026992798, 0.013404846, 0.0075798035, -0.04446411, -0.0014476776, -0.0010166168, 0.010620117, 0.061279297, -0.039642334, -0.035095215, 0.00844574, 0.025344849, 0.010986328, 0.020629883, 0.07122803, -0.0073051453, -0.03643799, 0.013656616, -0.0047073364, -0.018493652, 0.014289856, -0.024902344, -0.03564453, -0.021224976, -0.04296875, -0.03338623, -0.035369873, 0.08081055, -0.0039596558, 0.0051460266, 0.004749298, 0.017318726, -0.019134521, -0.022506714, 0.0025501251, 0.0053520203, 0.007904053, -0.0027217865, -0.043395996, -0.0025081635, 0.057678223, -0.01499939, -0.00806427, 0.017318726, 0.0016670227, -0.018478394, -0.019088745, 0.013023376, 0.024246216, -0.029876709, 0.011146545, 0.025619507, 0.01084137, -0.020446777, -0.015853882, 0.041870117, -0.023117065, -0.06964111, -0.00064468384, -0.039794922, 0.0079422, -0.017669678, 0.04525757, 0.01713562, 0.02696228, 0.05532837, -0.089782715, -0.01789856, -0.00086927414, -0.028457642, 0.07751465, -0.019195557, 0.040649414, 0.05947876, -0.005077362, 0.027648926, -0.03378296, 0.020736694, 0.10449219, -0.014060974, -0.01209259, 0.076416016, 0.008979797, 0.012435913, -0.050567627, -0.03768921, -0.016036987, -0.029464722, -0.029708862, -0.0031394958, 0.014762878, 0.008430481, 0.026000977, -0.024230957, -0.029083252, 0.013664246, 0.01272583, 0.0008420944, -0.021728516, 0.037322998, -0.032043457, -0.035339355, 0.0446167, -0.0017738342, 0.016616821, -0.002855301, -0.003189087, 0.0063591003, -0.021881104, -0.00077676773, -0.0075187683, 0.0044288635, 0.018844604, -0.021438599, -0.021469116, 0.022277832, -0.04925537, -0.01637268, -0.02809143, 0.010131836, 0.015716553, 0.057922363, -0.017059326, -0.027038574, 0.015037537, -0.043121338, 0.010856628, 0.0071868896, -0.05053711, -0.02973938, -0.011077881, -0.035095215, 0.041137695, -0.06262207, -0.033111572, -0.025543213, -0.017684937, 0.007926941, -0.010345459, -0.012939453, -0.018707275, -0.02708435, 0.008979797, 0.03463745, -0.027282715, -0.0033779144, 0.0075035095, 0.021591187, -0.019546509, 0.029525757, -0.02027893, 0.026565552, -0.03250122, -0.004081726, 0.038391113, 0.010620117, -0.060699463, -0.012626648, 0.045410156, 0.0076179504, -0.0067214966, -0.0021839142, -0.009254456, 0.022415161, 0.017578125, -0.031433105, -0.010810852, -0.01890564, 0.01701355, -0.018508911, 0.013343811, -0.012252808, 0.0098724365, -0.028396606, -0.022460938, 0.01675415, -0.03869629, -0.04547119, -0.0025310516, -0.0074272156, -0.07495117, -0.07946777, -0.040283203, -0.010231018, 0.024307251, -0.03881836, 0.023147583, -0.06088257, -0.061645508, -0.021881104, -0.024520874, 0.12548828, 0.039764404, -0.055541992, 0.070129395, -0.034088135, -0.026672363, 0.009864807, -0.024398804, -0.00035572052, 0.015182495, 0.004459381, 0.01864624, -0.011512756, -0.00957489, -0.014274597, -0.019180298, 0.002960205, -0.018127441, 0.038024902, -0.008865356, -0.0418396, 0.01586914, 0.009140015, 0.009918213, 0.034576416, -0.012290955, 0.017959595, 0.021331787, -0.016220093, -0.0124435425, 0.02279663, 0.0012893677, -0.051361084, 0.025131226, 0.0009007454, -0.029174805, 0.026947021, 0.007358551, 0.02746582, -0.02168274, -0.044952393, 0.050872803, 0.05456543, 0.0062026978, 0.0076675415, -0.0032634735, 0.06237793, -0.0035362244, -0.02456665, -0.018447876, 0.0069084167, -0.04888916, -0.023391724, 0.0077285767, 0.022399902, -0.09112549, -0.025390625, 0.0104522705, 0.029006958, -0.042510986, 0.022384644, -0.012573242, 0.005004883, 0.0017786026, -0.01146698, -0.0052986145, 0.010566711, 0.024856567, 0.02935791, -0.04434204, -0.07531738, -0.03717041, -0.000688076, -0.036010742, -0.001876831, -0.054534912, -0.062805176, -0.012786865, 0.006591797, 0.003004074, -0.0039024353, 0.011894226, 0.027572632, 0.0047416687, 0.01802063, 0.0022144318, 0.009407043, -0.059051514, 0.038757324, 0.02810669, -0.06335449, -0.028244019, 0.0009608269, -0.02973938, 0.062164307, -0.027313232, -0.028564453, -0.012237549, 0.010314941, 0.033325195, 0.04559326, 0.035888672, 0.022613525, -0.022628784, 0.023834229, -0.008033752, -0.0126571655, 0.021636963, 0.04159546, -0.00522995, 0.045684814, -0.004486084, 0.022125244, 0.0025310516, -0.0067253113, 0.00459671, -0.0039863586, 0.004722595, -0.00983429, -0.0055389404, 0.043029785, -0.035858154, -0.042541504, -0.008338928, -0.032836914, 0.0023555756, -0.008735657, -0.0040664673, 0.0132751465, 0.022521973, 0.058898926, 0.0014152527, 0.0012187958, 0.058288574, -0.018707275, -0.040802002, -0.008483887, -0.010047913, 0.019989014, -0.02178955, -0.027862549, -0.035888672, -0.019058228, 0.03555298, -0.0062294006, 0.010749817, -0.04949951, -0.03857422, -0.017059326, -0.00057792664, 0.009262085, -0.021530151, 0.008804321, 0.02204895, 0.0082092285, -0.03579712, -0.014976501, 0.02973938, -0.019760132, -0.011817932, 0.02583313, -0.00040459633, -0.015960693, -0.020202637, 0.021759033, 0.00083065033, -0.000869751, -0.018371582, -0.03363037, -0.012420654, 0.023422241, -0.036743164, -0.027664185, 0.016189575, -0.095703125, 0.008728027, -0.039916992, -0.0149002075, 0.015449524, 0.04006958, 0.015350342, 0.053833008, -0.055389404, 0.001964569, 0.009712219, 0.07342529, -0.091308594, 0.01259613, 0.0284729, 0.0059394836, 0.016723633, 0.026229858, 0.071777344, -0.027877808, 0.0093688965, 0.050048828, 0.039245605, -0.026107788, 0.029464722, -0.0129852295, -0.013702393, -0.008712769, -0.01789856, 0.018157959, 0.0072135925, 0.012413025, 0.004611969, -0.013786316, 0.0078125, -0.028076172, 0.034088135, 0.014923096, 0.026916504, 0.024017334, -0.011924744, 0.04437256, 0.02104187, -0.025482178, -0.012901306, -0.038757324, -0.05996704, -0.062927246, 0.076538086, -0.00087690353, -0.0064849854, -0.0038471222, -0.035949707, 0.00014412403, -0.013908386, -0.010810852, 0.042816162, -0.016311646, -0.0072364807, 0.016113281, 0.0022277832, -0.018447876, 0.0014238358, 0.018692017, -0.05230713, 0.016113281, 0.036315918, 0.072265625, -0.07513428, -0.050445557, -0.011833191, 0.049957275, 0.0024147034, 0.06591797, 0.028076172, 0.01991272, 0.09338379, -0.03289795, 0.03152466, -0.0018787384, -0.020812988, 0.027175903, -0.02494812, 0.018508911, -0.039093018, 0.024795532, -0.047332764, 0.024093628, -0.020889282, -0.027709961, 0.013031006, -0.026550293, -0.024841309, -0.009223938, -0.03881836, -0.022781372, 0.012550354, 0.010284424, -0.020462036, -0.021224976, 0.04812622, -0.007507324, -0.0044517517, 0.003660202, -0.0345459, 0.01675415, -0.039245605, -0.010726929, -0.015792847, 0.017349243, -0.0037441254, 0.017913818, 0.013977051, -0.035064697, 0.03253174, 0.026824951, 0.050567627, -0.03225708, 0.025619507, -0.00046014786, 0.03945923, 0.012077332, 0.0001295805, -0.024002075, -0.03286743, 0.0023441315, 0.005622864, 0.00623703, -0.029190063, 0.017700195, -0.005012512, -0.029220581, -0.03729248, -0.024246216, -0.030517578, 0.05493164, -0.022140503, -0.018692017, 0.024795532, 0.0041999817, -0.025115967, 0.04776001, -0.032409668, 0.039123535, -0.0011196136, -0.0021209717, -0.026306152, 0.0057754517, -0.0016536713, 0.008491516, 0.0435791, 0.022064209, 0.0034503937, 0.030670166, -0.013465881, 0.035003662, -0.0055656433, -0.02394104, -0.046081543, 0.03817749, -0.0574646, -0.020950317, 0.027450562, 0.025482178, -0.055541992, -0.012481689, 0.037078857, 0.03173828, -0.019134521, -0.017974854, -0.03201294, -0.0118637085, 0.017929077, -0.066101074, -0.016815186, -0.007499695, 0.010879517, 0.08276367, 0.028366089, 0.020065308, -0.06185913, -0.016860962, -0.018417358, -0.0025043488, -0.0017547607, 0.052520752, -0.035003662, 0.0024604797, -0.029891968, -0.061950684, 0.026016235, -0.04284668, 0.031143188, 0.026565552, -0.0021839142, 0.009613037, 0.024810791, 0.0040283203, 0.02859497, 0.027572632, -0.03665161, 0.001947403, -0.033325195, -0.030212402, 0.014175415, 0.0024967194, 0.029846191, -0.024047852, 0.09326172, 0.082214355, 0.059448242, 0.057281494, -0.020629883, 0.0024814606, 0.087402344, -0.001953125, -0.027893066, -0.03414917, -0.011276245, -0.047332764, -0.023544312, 0.0029125214, -0.046539307, -0.010169983, 0.043121338, -0.040222168, 0.0009255409, -0.036346436, 0.007347107, -0.037384033, -0.006969452, 0.024749756, -0.054473877, -0.009162903, 0.0021514893, -0.017913818, -0.03942871, 0.021087646, -0.031951904, -0.034606934, 0.009552002, 0.029525757, 0.031280518, -0.051513672, -0.032714844, 0.050933838, 0.06021118, 0.090270996, 0.028793335, 0.0121536255, 0.027282715, 0.025665283, -0.035827637, -0.088012695, 0.010070801, -0.020523071, 0.0118637085, -0.043792725, 0.006668091, -0.004283905, -0.023590088, -0.012420654, 0.024551392, 0.012191772, -0.014785767, 0.044433594, -0.0014705658, -0.032104492, 0.055847168, 0.022262573, -0.015319824, 0.021209717, -0.014411926, -0.0054969788, 0.0032482147, 0.0357666, -0.039733887, -0.01109314, -0.017181396, -0.011734009, 0.0025348663, -0.010406494, 0.0027370453, 0.023590088, 0.029052734, -0.028579712, 0.008659363, 0.010269165, 0.01524353, 0.034576416, 0.00919342, -0.03326416, -0.027191162, -0.020187378, 0.031463623, -0.005130768, 0.0034713745, -0.021499634, -0.010124207, 0.009239197, -0.00046753883, 0.0053977966, -0.01637268, 0.03567505, -0.016784668, -0.014953613, 0.008300781, 0.021102905, -0.020141602, 0.0011520386, 0.018615723, -0.042144775, -0.040863037, -0.015670776, -0.039215088, 0.015991211, -0.00881958, -0.038208008, 0.016433716, -0.051361084, -0.021957397, -0.04196167, -0.016860962, -0.009460449, -0.001294136, -0.003376007, -0.01625061, 0.015510559, 0.010002136, 0.009231567, 0.017578125, -0.021408081, 0.013702393, 0.05105591, -0.020584106, -0.0234375, -0.02885437, 0.026626587, -0.0463562, -0.014190674, 0.05355835, 0.008804321, -0.03869629, 0.024124146, -0.03326416, 0.01637268, -0.003686905, 0.020324707, -0.04849243, 0.06524658, 0.045288086, -0.0023956299, 0.034606934 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.01770v2
What's Sex Got To Do With Fair Machine Learning?
Lily Hu, Issa Kohler-Hausmann
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG
Debate about fairness in machine learning has largely centered around competing definitions of what fairness or nondiscrimination between groups requires. However, little attention has been paid to what precisely a group is. Many recent approaches to "fairness" require one to specify a causal model of the data generating process. These exercises make an implicit ontological assumption that a racial or sex group is simply a collection of individuals who share a given trait. We show this by exploring the formal assumption of modularity in causal models, which holds that the dependencies captured by one causal pathway are invariant to interventions on any other pathways. Causal models of sex propose two substantive claims: 1) There exists a feature, sex-on-its-own, that is an inherent trait of an individual that causally brings about social phenomena external to it in the world; and 2) the relations between sex and its effects can be modified in whichever ways and the former feature would still retain the meaning that sex has in our world. We argue that this ontological picture is false. Many of the "effects" that sex purportedly "causes" are in fact constitutive features of sex as a social status. They give the social meaning of sex features, meanings that are precisely what make sex discrimination a distinctively morally problematic type of action. Correcting this conceptual error has a number of implications for how models can be used to detect discrimination. Formal diagrams of constitutive relations present an entirely different path toward reasoning about discrimination. Whereas causal diagrams guide the construction of sophisticated modular counterfactuals, constitutive diagrams identify a different kind of counterfactual as central to an inquiry on discrimination: one that asks how the social meaning of a group would be changed if its non-modular features were altered.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.01770v2
2020-06-04T22:54:18
2020-06-02T16:51:39
{ "title": [ -0.009414673, -0.0065956116, -0.024780273, 0.00021576881, -0.026107788, -0.024108887, 0.017303467, -0.010948181, -0.0029659271, 0.02192688, -0.030639648, -0.01828003, -0.012054443, -0.024429321, -0.01651001, -0.040771484, -0.005847931, 0.060943604, 0.0340271, -0.0064430237, -0.017791748, -0.0055885315, -0.004550934, -0.043823242, 0.0036334991, -0.020751953, -0.021484375, -0.008293152, 0.012901306, -0.011299133, 0.0003566742, -0.016143799, 0.027114868, 0.028823853, -0.02658081, 0.028030396, -0.055480957, 0.04034424, 0.015541077, -0.023223877, 0.010696411, -0.015792847, -0.022705078, -0.009971619, -0.057861328, -0.014778137, -0.0014514923, 0.021621704, 0.00014746189, -0.013656616, 0.0006146431, 0.0006375313, 0.012420654, 0.043701172, 0.0053520203, 0.03552246, -0.006336212, -0.020736694, 0.020065308, 0.0032463074, -0.010887146, -0.006504059, 0.04196167, -0.024368286, 0.024963379, -0.021133423, 0.013198853, 0.03326416, 0.041107178, 0.033325195, -0.0023403168, -0.01637268, 0.027954102, 0.0032596588, 0.017181396, -0.03024292, -0.0019035339, 0.026763916, 0.020187378, -0.018829346, -0.026397705, -0.0026054382, 0.0010633469, 0.0038871765, -0.038482666, 0.00078105927, -0.028030396, 0.011917114, -0.032836914, -0.003326416, -0.0115737915, 0.03527832, -0.052886963, 0.043029785, 0.004802704, -0.016906738, -0.035614014, -0.0129852295, -0.044403076, -0.020874023, -0.05239868, 0.02267456, -0.06762695, -0.0033683777, 0.014945984, 0.0045776367, 0.015052795, -0.0418396, 0.012466431, 0.0023078918, -0.040283203, 0.054718018, 0.0020198822, 0.028152466, -0.011566162, -0.020187378, -0.034973145, 0.0028038025, -0.021011353, -0.009429932, -0.0017251968, -0.014533997, 0.024398804, 0.021102905, 0.022994995, 0.014907837, -0.027557373, -0.01259613, -0.031982422, 0.023910522, 0.005596161, 0.056732178, -0.0793457, -0.053771973, -0.06561279, -0.009407043, 0.0018291473, -0.027374268, -0.01966858, 0.00022888184, -0.013328552, -0.006877899, 0.015388489, -0.029525757, -0.013267517, -0.007499695, 0.047973633, 0.011253357, -0.019836426, 0.00087976456, -0.044555664, 0.09240723, -0.04071045, 0.04348755, 0.015548706, 0.029586792, -0.06896973, 0.026794434, 0.052612305, 0.052764893, 0.059906006, 0.022323608, 0.018859863, 0.04736328, 0.03353882, -0.043823242, -0.03955078, 0.02406311, 0.01071167, 0.005130768, 0.0036525726, 0.022918701, -0.005340576, 0.0039596558, 0.0058135986, -0.006000519, 0.0390625, 0.025222778, -0.018234253, 0.019821167, 0.00674057, -0.04446411, -0.0129776, -0.0033569336, -0.062561035, -0.055358887, 0.019439697, 0.040039062, 0.031707764, 0.017990112, 0.014312744, -0.0032978058, -0.040924072, -0.058410645, -0.025817871, 0.030517578, 0.012680054, 0.018463135, -0.0020542145, 0.026733398, 0.0075569153, 0.021652222, 0.008338928, -0.02659607, -0.042541504, -0.003528595, -0.014923096, 0.030075073, -0.058166504, 0.0035324097, 0.03756714, -0.06555176, -0.0234375, 0.06585693, 0.01675415, -0.040802002, -0.0062675476, -0.04220581, 0.0021076202, -0.060394287, 0.027236938, 0.011070251, -0.011100769, 0.041046143, 0.0021839142, 0.03274536, -0.0021591187, 0.011421204, 0.076538086, 0.012565613, 0.14038086, -0.019714355, 0.011695862, 0.06982422, -0.028915405, -0.040130615, -0.0046653748, -0.023071289, 0.054748535, 0.05014038, 0.0020523071, -0.02507019, -0.02897644, -0.0041122437, 0.04055786, 0.01802063, 0.0115737915, -0.011856079, -0.0025043488, -0.0029754639, 0.039245605, -0.013198853, 0.034973145, -0.047943115, -0.010665894, 0.06665039, 0.001625061, 0.00083112717, 0.0028209686, 0.048736572, -0.008613586, 0.029312134, 0.023361206, 0.0028438568, 0.017028809, -0.02798462, -0.0012378693, -0.019317627, -0.028793335, 0.01727295, 0.020950317, -0.055603027, -0.0016794205, 0.0074539185, -0.0047454834, 0.003929138, -0.00016784668, 0.005332947, -0.017593384, -0.008384705, -0.012641907, -0.043792725, 0.01361084, 0.00712204, 0.052612305, 0.03479004, 0.04736328, 0.0049743652, 0.00094127655, -0.015716553, 0.01499176, 0.03866577, -0.0031604767, 0.038848877, 0.03994751, -0.0059890747, 0.017044067, 0.07873535, -0.05596924, 0.02911377, -0.05621338, -0.00002104044, 0.027740479, -0.04324341, 0.0069236755, 0.021392822, 0.025497437, -0.009399414, -0.0059280396, 0.03656006, -0.05404663, 0.051116943, 0.023910522, 0.03756714, -0.011665344, -0.024230957, -0.0012321472, 0.029663086, -0.008041382, -0.007873535, 0.07800293, 0.02633667, -0.011314392, -0.016921997, 0.0121154785, -0.055908203, -0.03274536, -0.018585205, 0.0128479, -0.017837524, -0.0054779053, -0.015007019, -0.02432251, 0.0028915405, 0.005504608, 0.004386902, 0.00036358833, 0.052764893, 0.0045051575, -0.044128418, -0.0000410676, 0.0079574585, -0.009796143, -0.014343262, 0.03857422, -0.039154053, -0.05279541, 0.01121521, -0.026947021, 0.0051879883, 0.003408432, 0.0062026978, -0.007987976, -0.026672363, 0.021652222, -0.006576538, -0.00008201599, 0.032958984, 0.050323486, -0.023040771, 0.038848877, 0.012008667, -0.009529114, -0.037719727, 0.023162842, -0.07269287, -0.031921387, -0.020492554, -0.022247314, 0.020385742, -0.001824379, -0.018127441, -0.0011110306, 0.0033683777, -0.021514893, 0.0015506744, -0.018035889, -0.047210693, 0.026260376, -0.019302368, 0.006046295, -0.023498535, 0.053253174, 0.025299072, 0.0715332, 0.01574707, 0.017059326, -0.002128601, 0.042907715, -0.0013198853, -0.02810669, -0.017669678, 0.0023155212, -0.010353088, -0.0028152466, 0.004295349, -0.033416748, -0.0024547577, -0.066833496, 0.016464233, 0.04522705, 0.021820068, 0.011352539, 0.032226562, -0.05239868, 0.06512451, 0.0012598038, 0.0047798157, 0.015960693, 0.046569824, -0.010314941, -0.02041626, 0.046936035, -0.042938232, 0.018661499, -0.021240234, -0.048614502, -0.005569458, -0.033599854, 0.024597168, -0.003025055, 0.06085205, -0.04748535, -0.003370285, -0.00063180923, -0.0284729, 0.035491943, 0.0040779114, -0.011642456, 0.0440979, 0.0181427, -0.016311646, 0.003791809, -0.025039673, -0.022155762, -0.01309967, -0.026016235, 0.026245117, 0.005744934, -0.012397766, -0.00035524368, -0.016403198, 0.0064468384, 0.028442383, -0.0047454834, 0.0017776489, -0.022277832, -0.005771637, -0.0491333, 0.010505676, -0.053375244, 0.0017328262, -0.004623413, 0.038513184, -0.012245178, 0.056274414, 0.03149414, 0.051208496, -0.014907837, 0.028396606, 0.033843994, -0.0154953, -0.02130127, 0.010406494, 0.025970459, 0.0031433105, 0.0011816025, 0.02684021, -0.002878189, -0.0059280396, 0.029541016, -0.010368347, -0.007797241, 0.009407043, 0.0077400208, 0.00085401535, -0.0024299622, 0.048828125, -0.06506348, -0.01928711, 0.020324707, 0.0287323, -0.023010254, -0.083618164, -0.051605225, 0.022415161, -0.1274414, -0.0713501, 0.013656616, -0.04827881, -0.088134766, 0.0022850037, 0.013824463, -0.030441284, -0.0010786057, 0.023620605, -0.0023612976, 0.05065918, 0.044525146, -0.057739258, -0.022827148, 0.012962341, -0.03253174, -0.07220459, 0.00819397, -0.0047187805, 0.007041931, -0.0067253113, 0.023025513, 0.0076560974, 0.020874023, -0.025466919, 0.012062073, 0.02279663, -0.029464722, 0.028930664, -0.033325195, 0.00029492378, -0.040618896, -0.00042772293, 0.040985107, 0.030471802, 0.01461792, 0.015586853, 0.05810547, -0.014144897, -0.022903442, 0.011169434, -0.0040397644, -0.099731445, 0.008460999, 0.028305054, 0.041809082, 0.101623535, -0.017791748, 0.064697266, -0.0060653687, -0.04953003, 0.016174316, 0.020614624, 0.011856079, 0.027618408, -0.036102295, 0.036071777, -0.018966675, -0.0099105835, -0.009544373, 0.06085205, 0.0044174194, 0.012390137, 0.017700195, 0.008964539, -0.025634766, -0.03186035, 0.00043463707, -0.0317688, -0.037902832, -0.007194519, -0.011703491, 0.033935547, -0.0065956116, 0.004512787, -0.02746582, -0.003894806, 0.010498047, 0.00856781, 0.02609253, -0.032073975, 0.0031280518, -0.04458618, -0.019042969, -0.038330078, 0.006385803, 0.006134033, 0.004917145, 0.006614685, -0.033416748, 0.015014648, -0.04638672, -0.016448975, 0.018936157, -0.019622803, -0.025482178, -0.027267456, -0.0090789795, -0.02810669, 0.025375366, -0.012664795, -0.01184082, -0.033325195, 0.053466797, -0.043670654, -0.044006348, -0.08319092, 0.0340271, 0.0040664673, 0.039794922, 0.052001953, 0.0057754517, 0.033477783, 0.025314331, -0.008796692, -0.025634766, -0.0127334595, 0.030761719, 0.035614014, 0.07525635, 0.00579834, 0.036224365, 0.05731201, 0.035247803, -0.045288086, -0.053771973, 0.07733154, -0.004447937, -0.060943604, 0.024780273, -0.022979736, -0.043151855, -0.059753418, -0.006729126, -0.018676758, 0.034484863, 0.02053833, 0.007724762, -0.002199173, -0.017044067, 0.014579773, -0.0016489029, 0.0032348633, 0.007457733, -0.0047035217, -0.028167725, -0.018249512, 0.018051147, 0.0009689331, -0.012283325, -0.025253296, -0.00299263, 0.016418457, -0.0047454834, 0.015037537, -0.0045394897, -0.015007019, 0.052490234, -0.0446167, -0.02041626, 0.0034065247, -0.036865234, -0.0007429123, -0.022613525, 0.018188477, 0.006542206, 0.0011119843, -0.015335083, 0.010169983, -0.01348114, 0.0005955696, 0.016860962, -0.052246094, -0.033203125, 0.025848389, 0.0132751465, -0.00024533272, -0.044921875, -0.023529053, 0.046203613, 0.015052795, -0.015304565, -0.019256592, -0.011199951, 0.036712646, 0.033172607, -0.014213562, 0.04925537, -0.0033416748, -0.033447266, 0.0079422, -0.0015468597, -0.029586792, 0.013923645, -0.03302002, 0.013420105, -0.019882202, -0.022232056, 0.0069274902, 0.022903442, 0.020477295, 0.019058228, -0.037750244, 0.0034236908, 0.042022705, -0.025802612, -0.020309448, 0.014846802, -0.00073575974, -0.025619507, -0.03491211, 0.043792725, 0.029174805, 0.028869629, -0.044647217, -0.0051727295, -0.055908203, 0.025924683, -0.010856628, -0.025115967, -0.03894043, 0.036468506, 0.023712158, -0.012504578, 0.015617371, -0.08734131, -0.022460938, -0.005596161, -0.03274536, -0.022644043, 0.027282715, 0.02079773, -0.018249512, 0.006259918, 0.042755127, -0.0076522827, -0.05404663, 0.010299683, -0.02609253, -0.044311523, 0.022918701, -0.0067634583, 0.0064926147, 0.02885437, 0.03414917, 0.0110321045, 0.0038032532, 0.011497498, -0.061065674, 0.020355225, 0.037872314, 0.025238037, -0.009178162, -0.03475952, 0.0059013367, 0.029022217, -0.003929138, 0.031036377, 0.021621704, 0.029876709, 0.09277344, 0.03994751, 0.04763794, 0.107543945, -0.033355713, -0.03656006, -0.02319336, -0.01007843, -0.05340576, 0.0072364807, 0.012916565, -0.017227173, -0.008224487, -0.024383545, -0.027862549, 0.0016126633, 0.028366089, -0.051849365, -0.007785797, 0.0024108887, 0.0143966675, -0.018615723, 0.00579834, 0.013084412, 0.03781128, -0.012672424, -0.04534912, -0.017105103, 0.010787964, 0.028579712, -0.026473999, -0.0022525787, 0.023101807, -0.028793335, 0.027404785, -0.054901123, -0.014572144, -0.026000977, 0.023468018, 0.018936157, 0.024047852, -0.054473877, 0.010848999, -0.023712158, 0.05630493, -0.010147095, 0.0073928833, -0.006706238, 0.015716553, -0.00096940994, -0.0070533752, -0.036254883, -0.015136719, 0.039611816, -0.05429077, 0.03579712, 0.011199951, -0.014183044, -0.07354736, 0.00006055832, 0.06121826, -0.005886078, 0.019119263, -0.010955811, 0.008834839, 0.026046753, 0.0042495728, 0.014038086, 0.0023670197, 0.022766113, -0.0033950806, -0.045166016, 0.042236328, -0.012275696, 0.022781372, 0.05041504, 0.0070610046, 0.04272461, -0.0657959, 0.034698486, 0.048706055, -0.0005712509, 0.011505127, 0.012077332, -0.009742737, -0.042236328, -0.02772522, -0.006515503, 0.039916992, 0.004207611, 0.00025200844, 0.0020427704, 0.0006709099, 0.015510559, -0.0010232925, 0.004058838, 0.035125732, -0.019836426, 0.030822754, -0.015136719, -0.045898438, -0.012161255, 0.050445557, 0.022720337, 0.01033783, 0.004547119, 0.0012016296, 0.018508911, 0.052246094, 0.005847931, -0.045440674, 0.013397217, 0.034851074, -0.035186768, 0.01939392, -0.030151367, 0.014678955, 0.014884949, 0.042175293, 0.024276733, -0.0044555664, 0.018737793, -0.0019350052, 0.028198242, -0.008728027, 0.06817627, 0.014381409, -0.018081665, 0.045684814, 0.007736206, -0.043884277, 0.054626465, -0.005748749, 0.060913086, 0.023010254, 0.07305908, 0.0007214546, 0.006713867, 0.018539429, 0.017929077, 0.042907715, 0.04156494, 0.010147095, 0.029586792, -0.019699097, -0.033233643, 0.04864502, -0.005130768, 0.066467285, -0.004009247, 0.011367798, -0.05154419, 0.0028095245, -0.009536743, -0.062347412, 0.025848389, -0.071777344, -0.028381348, -0.0049819946, 0.015586853, -0.0010023117, -0.014450073, -0.027389526, 0.029525757, 0.008872986, 0.021133423, 0.06298828, -0.03579712, -0.019042969, 0.03604126, 0.046020508, 0.078430176, -0.0031318665, -0.023788452, 0.010971069, 0.012062073, 0.030090332, -0.025039673, -0.047546387, 0.029022217, -0.0039634705, -0.01574707, 0.0079574585, 0.016906738, -0.025665283, -0.06222534, 0.01033783, -0.0127334595, -0.012123108, 0.0062179565, 0.0049743652, -0.008506775, -0.07006836, 0.0032901764, -0.05255127, -0.008743286, 0.0030937195, -0.010734558, -0.027008057, 0.0024909973, -0.025604248, -0.05316162, 0.0107421875, 0.042022705, -0.016464233, -0.031463623, -0.0037212372, 0.024658203, 0.05996704, -0.015701294, -0.015686035, 0.015319824, 0.034057617, -0.029937744, 0.037841797, -0.0054969788, 0.049438477, 0.023986816, 0.064819336, 0.0038833618, -0.05340576, -0.03186035, -0.019226074, 0.029769897, -0.021865845, -0.040496826, 0.009155273, 0.023651123, -0.03878784, -0.013587952, 0.0046195984, -0.013587952, -0.010948181, 0.010826111, 0.008804321, -0.009719849, -0.016586304, 0.014389038, -0.024749756, 0.0006942749, -0.008224487, -0.016433716, -0.008453369, -0.04272461, 0.025344849, 0.055145264, 0.0040664673, -0.0005645752, 0.007980347, 0.047088623, 0.0035305023, 0.028015137, -0.05014038, -0.0209198, -0.0138168335, 0.047424316, -0.017318726, -0.022705078, -0.012207031, 0.028656006, -0.10070801, -0.039398193, 0.001203537, -0.0006427765, -0.0035324097, -0.068725586, 0.053833008, -0.031585693, -0.006324768, 0.040985107, -0.005935669, 0.060913086, 0.04849243, -0.060058594, -0.052337646, 0.0030822754, -0.02748108 ], "summary": [ 0.025146484, -0.012527466, -0.011383057, -0.028076172, -0.030731201, -0.017028809, -0.0016927719, 0.01436615, 0.02079773, 0.008003235, -0.01939392, -0.016098022, 0.02835083, -0.028411865, 0.0023231506, -0.01373291, -0.013961792, 0.070373535, 0.034240723, -0.025787354, -0.013259888, -0.0155181885, -0.02279663, -0.09118652, 0.02758789, -0.06628418, 0.019622803, 0.0032672882, 0.042633057, 0.006385803, 0.017684937, -0.010215759, 0.01209259, 0.018600464, -0.024490356, -0.039611816, -0.014663696, 0.011367798, -0.023498535, 0.023040771, 0.012626648, -0.019515991, 0.010314941, -0.031219482, -0.030288696, 0.009391785, 0.011672974, 0.011123657, 0.0309906, 0.014450073, 0.022384644, 0.026062012, 0.018493652, 0.048217773, -0.019729614, 0.000600338, -0.043670654, -0.037994385, 0.008178711, 0.055755615, 0.05529785, -0.013893127, -0.0051460266, -0.00920105, 0.012367249, -0.038513184, 0.030654907, 0.022903442, 0.024856567, 0.017944336, 0.013648987, 0.028274536, -0.0002425909, -0.016159058, -0.0011081696, 0.012512207, 0.007068634, -0.020202637, 0.008544922, 0.007209778, -0.022384644, 0.00049972534, -0.014816284, -0.010444641, -0.03591919, 0.0099105835, -0.030044556, -0.014053345, -0.005214691, 0.014793396, 0.0041885376, -0.013763428, 0.003742218, 0.02998352, 0.01676941, -0.03869629, -0.011100769, 0.002407074, 0.0063285828, -0.0178833, -0.029205322, -0.0014925003, -0.060638428, -0.017578125, -0.0082473755, -0.02911377, 0.0046844482, -0.018539429, 0.012611389, 0.023635864, -0.04385376, 0.0184021, 0.009002686, -0.0037212372, -0.022247314, -0.029296875, -0.048065186, 0.041107178, 0.0073013306, -0.011978149, -0.030578613, -0.023254395, -0.008255005, 0.058563232, 0.0048217773, 0.010826111, 0.008972168, 0.008995056, -0.021942139, 0.040161133, -0.008575439, -0.00073957443, 0.008911133, -0.011177063, -0.023468018, -0.02734375, -0.025848389, -0.033172607, -0.04647827, 0.00573349, -0.025604248, -0.008720398, 0.07336426, -0.048187256, -0.055114746, -0.00046253204, 0.01789856, 0.020126343, -0.02861023, -0.030578613, -0.008430481, 0.012245178, 0.020095825, -0.01499176, -0.028930664, 0.0036468506, -0.04989624, 0.010902405, -0.025360107, 0.018798828, 0.023330688, 0.009933472, -0.005115509, 0.024169922, 0.016464233, -0.031036377, -0.012619019, 0.013214111, -0.0027713776, -0.052703857, 0.0025615692, 0.05142212, -0.0027828217, -0.0009880066, 0.020233154, -0.01335907, 0.0042686462, -0.061553955, -0.035217285, 0.05319214, 0.016433716, -0.029373169, -0.115722656, 0.06329346, -0.0770874, 0.0010585785, 0.017578125, 0.06921387, 0.035064697, -0.00046253204, 0.092041016, -0.024734497, -0.059417725, -0.009216309, 0.006793976, -0.0020446777, -0.011100769, -0.02658081, 0.0073280334, 0.025909424, 0.07727051, -0.0055618286, -0.008232117, -0.05178833, -0.08850098, -0.029800415, -0.0057258606, 0.008552551, -0.0647583, 0.010040283, 0.050964355, -0.035369873, -0.054107666, 0.0803833, 0.028900146, -0.060028076, 0.025360107, -0.019638062, 0.012130737, -0.06652832, 0.013206482, -0.0012931824, -0.022369385, 0.06640625, -0.018692017, -0.014831543, 0.013702393, 0.018798828, 0.047912598, 0.0006532669, 0.11468506, -0.060302734, 0.014717102, 0.056030273, 0.010597229, 0.013519287, 0.051452637, -0.031158447, 0.019454956, 0.018676758, 0.0287323, -0.030929565, -0.039367676, -0.01828003, 0.039733887, 0.008628845, 0.0039863586, -0.00049495697, -0.047180176, -0.05709839, 0.05508423, -0.017456055, 0.040527344, 0.00699234, -0.0061149597, 0.020614624, 0.0010700226, -0.033325195, 0.008598328, 0.025405884, 0.024795532, 0.03894043, -0.020507812, 0.024719238, 0.024047852, -0.07543945, -0.029556274, -0.057159424, 0.014549255, -0.05657959, 0.010650635, -0.06781006, -0.002040863, -0.047607422, 0.0043945312, 0.019927979, -0.0023765564, 0.024536133, -0.012390137, -0.042053223, 0.0022792816, -0.018737793, 0.022460938, 0.001996994, 0.057678223, 0.03125, 0.017471313, -0.038726807, -0.013885498, -0.00038695335, 0.017120361, 0.017990112, -0.018127441, 0.010917664, 0.010673523, -0.011695862, -0.042633057, 0.04940796, -0.014701843, 0.012748718, -0.032104492, 0.030090332, 0.019699097, -0.016235352, 0.011131287, -0.010955811, 0.015396118, 0.0017633438, -0.014709473, -0.016281128, -0.020492554, 0.009414673, 0.046447754, 0.025619507, 0.026351929, 0.011474609, 0.02154541, 0.064819336, 0.062561035, 0.051330566, 0.080444336, 0.01713562, 0.00655365, -0.0010938644, 0.004463196, -0.057373047, 0.013343811, -0.023895264, -0.018737793, -0.01979065, 0.012245178, 0.00082302094, -0.024108887, 0.0037593842, 0.01727295, -0.0064849854, 0.007648468, -0.00031900406, -0.0064926147, -0.03036499, 0.011627197, -0.01701355, 0.0064849854, 0.007419586, 0.038879395, -0.059387207, 0.0027446747, 0.013168335, -0.006767273, 0.012336731, -0.015220642, -0.03363037, 0.008041382, 0.014945984, 0.006500244, 0.041809082, 0.008972168, 0.051208496, 0.042633057, -0.00983429, -0.0038776398, 0.028701782, -0.00019586086, -0.051483154, -0.009185791, -0.043823242, -0.0045776367, -0.010147095, 0.02079773, 0.018447876, -0.0062828064, 0.02130127, -0.032928467, 0.000015258789, 0.015151978, 0.0019445419, 0.023666382, -0.025665283, 0.010261536, 0.01940918, 0.013442993, -0.0024681091, -0.00023269653, -0.011985779, 0.055664062, 0.0069618225, -0.003917694, 0.026763916, 0.0362854, 0.0059280396, -0.0003979206, 0.018829346, -0.005924225, -0.042236328, 0.02229309, 0.01727295, 0.0093307495, -0.009216309, 0.0076026917, -0.049835205, -0.0034751892, 0.030776978, 0.037017822, 0.00012350082, -0.057159424, 0.07244873, -0.055480957, 0.0070114136, 0.013595581, 0.02835083, -0.00060892105, 0.0040626526, 0.018630981, -0.0052261353, 0.012374878, -0.015365601, -0.012557983, 0.0076522827, -0.012046814, -0.005542755, -0.022628784, 0.05609131, -0.010429382, -0.0009498596, 0.005519867, -0.04373169, -0.009651184, -0.010818481, -0.021209717, 0.047790527, -0.009887695, 0.009635925, -0.028152466, 0.02545166, -0.011688232, 0.040496826, 0.020233154, -0.02670288, 0.048919678, -0.03604126, 0.023010254, -0.02494812, 0.0015678406, 0.03567505, -0.026351929, 0.04937744, -0.0069236755, 0.017303467, -0.02748108, 0.0050315857, -0.03112793, 0.0010824203, -0.011749268, 0.03567505, -0.013053894, 0.025665283, -0.0014505386, 0.05218506, 0.014915466, 0.011940002, 0.045684814, -0.015350342, -0.039886475, 0.02456665, -0.0034999847, -0.010284424, 0.055389404, 0.006587982, -0.01159668, 0.010620117, 0.009231567, -0.018875122, 0.011161804, 0.008079529, 0.013946533, -0.013191223, -0.010391235, 0.018508911, -0.04397583, -0.008956909, -0.016052246, 0.04837036, 0.00037765503, -0.0859375, -0.053710938, 0.0151901245, -0.11206055, -0.08996582, 0.021118164, -0.013725281, -0.026519775, -0.0071411133, 0.061065674, -0.035217285, 0.020446777, 0.013954163, -0.032318115, 0.09466553, 0.04953003, -0.043792725, 0.056427002, -0.024276733, -0.0013809204, -0.05102539, -0.01348114, 0.022857666, 0.022064209, -0.0021400452, -0.008529663, 0.00044846535, 0.00053834915, -0.029769897, -0.01663208, 0.008155823, -0.022262573, 0.046569824, -0.013870239, 0.030883789, -0.0103302, -0.039276123, 0.019897461, -0.0040512085, 0.044769287, 0.009590149, 0.027389526, -0.022613525, 0.03970337, -0.015449524, -0.0045166016, -0.037994385, -0.00017499924, 0.03363037, -0.011001587, 0.037231445, -0.010917664, -0.017532349, -0.005554199, -0.028915405, 0.028808594, 0.0115737915, 0.006931305, 0.012763977, -0.05230713, 0.020126343, -0.020263672, 0.04434204, -0.021331787, 0.020126343, -0.039978027, -0.023803711, 0.02671814, 0.04425049, -0.044158936, -0.008529663, 0.00096559525, -0.0005660057, -0.06524658, 0.020843506, -0.0026741028, 0.009994507, 0.0017652512, 0.020492554, -0.02760315, -0.008987427, -0.016418457, 0.012702942, 0.039733887, 0.008880615, 0.0042495728, -0.050720215, -0.051818848, -0.03970337, -0.061431885, -0.015022278, -0.021942139, 0.04498291, -0.017745972, 0.0047073364, -0.008041382, 0.042236328, 0.031311035, 0.019744873, -0.019210815, 0.0058135986, -0.0033454895, 0.0047683716, 0.005264282, 0.006378174, -0.00806427, -0.01687622, -0.01071167, -0.014213562, -0.032714844, -0.066101074, 0.02029419, -0.021209717, 0.025894165, 0.054107666, 0.01828003, 0.027038574, 0.0009613037, -0.015335083, -0.010437012, -0.015731812, 0.045715332, 0.01953125, 0.04660034, 0.0035991669, 0.020446777, 0.057800293, 0.011581421, -0.023376465, -0.021087646, 0.015655518, 0.020584106, -0.038513184, 0.05041504, -0.0390625, -0.0022697449, -0.008666992, 0.038635254, 0.018875122, 0.06112671, 0.052581787, 0.021911621, -0.013000488, -0.025177002, 0.015853882, -0.005077362, -0.005279541, 0.006038666, -0.012840271, 0.035858154, -0.011222839, 0.017318726, -0.009025574, -0.0032043457, -0.045166016, -0.027908325, 0.08178711, -0.021743774, 0.013595581, -0.0029563904, -0.053222656, 0.07696533, -0.054016113, -0.030853271, 0.028762817, -0.04928589, -0.015213013, -0.0099487305, 0.016479492, 0.07574463, -0.043701172, -0.0552063, -0.01586914, 0.007217407, -0.02696228, 0.047180176, -0.04562378, -0.068725586, -0.0015926361, -0.05987549, -0.027709961, -0.028503418, -0.022323608, 0.016723633, 0.027328491, -0.0569458, 0.016967773, -0.016601562, -0.024429321, 0.035369873, -0.017868042, 0.017578125, 0.04168701, -0.011451721, 0.017333984, 0.018707275, 0.0043182373, 0.00680542, -0.022109985, 0.011497498, -0.040283203, 0.0020713806, 0.026260376, 0.026306152, 0.00818634, 0.04397583, 0.018341064, 0.02571106, 0.01586914, 0.032470703, -0.006954193, -0.016540527, 0.021347046, -0.018859863, -0.07739258, -0.008903503, 0.012420654, 0.043121338, -0.044433594, -0.00085258484, -0.05987549, 0.01071167, -0.013031006, -0.031951904, 0.037353516, 0.004711151, 0.010375977, 0.0021858215, -0.0035076141, -0.04336548, -0.0073928833, 0.016464233, -0.046081543, -0.054107666, -0.014511108, -0.015274048, 0.024551392, -0.006011963, 0.008331299, -0.021270752, -0.04928589, -0.0028209686, -0.046020508, -0.022354126, 0.037078857, -0.009666443, -0.027053833, 0.008003235, 0.0032653809, -0.057678223, 0.013870239, 0.03048706, -0.041412354, -0.010108948, 0.02470398, -0.0069274902, -0.037231445, -0.025146484, -0.0184021, 0.012924194, -0.022018433, 0.024261475, -0.04345703, 0.010795593, 0.02935791, 0.0062332153, -0.00092983246, 0.07788086, -0.034820557, -0.009437561, 0.022750854, 0.042541504, -0.0012702942, -0.008850098, 0.022445679, 0.014060974, -0.011405945, -0.03778076, -0.014083862, -0.0009264946, 0.022994995, -0.013183594, -0.00063085556, -0.02923584, -0.0112838745, -0.053894043, 0.008476257, 0.03189087, 0.0014953613, -0.027450562, -0.04940796, 0.02368164, 0.01084137, 0.033843994, -0.014465332, 0.00059604645, -0.00045609474, -0.032440186, 0.03729248, -0.050964355, 0.028671265, 0.0037593842, 0.018661499, 0.008308411, -0.029678345, 0.007133484, -0.032287598, -0.0046463013, 0.025344849, 0.007980347, 0.0044555664, 0.0018844604, 0.010154724, 0.0002527237, -0.009384155, -0.041137695, -0.023620605, 0.0541687, -0.032409668, -0.00071907043, -0.045166016, -0.036499023, -0.007709503, 0.014152527, 0.00076150894, -0.040130615, 0.042999268, -0.007827759, -0.031158447, 0.061584473, -0.039611816, 0.08123779, -0.014862061, -0.040008545, -0.031311035, 0.012519836, 0.0011234283, 0.00032520294, 0.04916382, 0.045135498, -0.047607422, 0.046325684, -0.011116028, 0.0262146, 0.016342163, -0.037597656, -0.061187744, 0.04272461, -0.045898438, 0.004322052, 0.017608643, 0.023880005, 0.000049114227, 0.0012226105, 0.10870361, -0.05441284, -0.011207581, -0.004337311, 0.008552551, 0.0026931763, -0.012893677, 0.03414917, 0.017562866, 0.00944519, -0.021713257, 0.053955078, 0.026000977, 0.04159546, -0.03149414, 0.0023269653, -0.008583069, 0.0047721863, -0.009765625, 0.015640259, -0.028427124, -0.022460938, -0.014526367, -0.02166748, 0.01776123, 0.016616821, -0.008781433, -0.012802124, 0.026901245, -0.0050849915, 0.0049362183, 0.036712646, -0.00299263, 0.024169922, -0.0069770813, -0.016830444, 0.008529663, -0.0038166046, -0.01828003, 0.014160156, -0.025878906, 0.039215088, -0.0385437, 0.070373535, 0.077941895, 0.08874512, -0.0068740845, 0.025405884, 0.05493164, -0.009773254, 0.01576233, 0.05239868, 0.016662598, 0.004673004, 0.000036776066, -0.01285553, 0.042663574, 0.047454834, 0.07714844, -0.0395813, -0.034454346, -0.03881836, 0.0047569275, -0.017105103, -0.0036067963, 0.016220093, -0.095825195, 0.024963379, -0.013809204, -0.0104522705, -0.07165527, -0.00034856796, -0.020080566, -0.013763428, 0.013015747, 0.009475708, 0.0034275055, -0.033966064, 0.0071640015, 0.006252289, 0.055114746, 0.07867432, 0.04434204, -0.021057129, 0.0007352829, 0.024154663, 0.017486572, 0.02142334, -0.03729248, 0.082214355, -0.021759033, -0.05630493, 0.007881165, -0.0062065125, -0.029556274, 0.008354187, -0.032440186, 0.018112183, -0.015899658, 0.021453857, 0.0039520264, -0.0022640228, -0.049804688, 0.00819397, -0.051940918, -0.0006928444, 0.0014181137, 0.022445679, -0.00068998337, 0.040893555, 0.002456665, -0.05316162, 0.002878189, 0.0010900497, 0.012069702, -0.060394287, 0.015327454, -0.017730713, 0.025314331, -0.028900146, -0.025100708, 0.026473999, 0.01576233, 0.021331787, -0.030029297, -0.0340271, -0.029418945, 0.017303467, 0.013885498, 0.010215759, 0.005634308, 0.0134887695, 0.022476196, 0.00029301643, -0.028900146, -0.025344849, -0.01852417, -0.027313232, -0.07611084, -0.02255249, 0.01235199, 0.024017334, -0.04699707, 0.009239197, -0.016036987, -0.021560669, -0.08673096, 0.017486572, -0.09686279, 0.035980225, -0.008613586, -0.038208008, -0.0076179504, -0.07104492, 0.0044517517, 0.0033245087, -0.02154541, 0.012969971, 0.022537231, 0.018432617, -0.011108398, 0.007881165, -0.0154953, -0.011924744, -0.025619507, 0.0007867813, -0.041412354, 0.044525146, -0.042144775, -0.030838013, -0.036895752, -0.035705566, 0.0017585754, -0.028427124, 0.0022583008, -0.065979004, 0.05206299, -0.021347046, 0.007083893, 0.041229248, 0.01272583, 0.011764526, 0.00466156, -0.001499176, 0.021881104, 0.00075769424, 0.011672974 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.01855v3
Aligning Superhuman AI with Human Behavior: Chess as a Model System
Reid McIlroy-Young, Siddhartha Sen, Jon Kleinberg, Ashton Anderson
cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly intelligent---in some cases, achieving superhuman performance---there is growing potential for humans to learn from and collaborate with algorithms. However, the ways in which AI systems approach problems are often different from the ways people do, and thus may be uninterpretable and hard to learn from. A crucial step in bridging this gap between human and artificial intelligence is modeling the granular actions that constitute human behavior, rather than simply matching aggregate human performance. We pursue this goal in a model system with a long history in artificial intelligence: chess. The aggregate performance of a chess player unfolds as they make decisions over the course of a game. The hundreds of millions of games played online by players at every skill level form a rich source of data in which these decisions, and their exact context, are recorded in minute detail. Applying existing chess engines to this data, including an open-source implementation of AlphaZero, we find that they do not predict human moves well. We develop and introduce Maia, a customized version of Alpha-Zero trained on human chess games, that predicts human moves at a much higher accuracy than existing engines, and can achieve maximum accuracy when predicting decisions made by players at a specific skill level in a tuneable way. For a dual task of predicting whether a human will make a large mistake on the next move, we develop a deep neural network that significantly outperforms competitive baselines. Taken together, our results suggest that there is substantial promise in designing artificial intelligence systems with human collaboration in mind by first accurately modeling granular human decision-making.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.01855v3
2020-07-14T17:57:37
2020-06-02T18:12:52
{ "title": [ 0.029785156, 0.026947021, 0.0022506714, -0.0069618225, 0.019866943, -0.035980225, 0.04434204, -0.055023193, -0.028503418, 0.04437256, -0.014701843, 0.00012129545, 0.023544312, -0.013809204, -0.037994385, -0.0052108765, 0.010902405, 0.013938904, 0.015235901, -0.021255493, -0.004337311, -0.02935791, 0.05328369, 0.03149414, 0.038146973, -0.03050232, -0.09466553, 0.0051841736, -0.021530151, -0.030776978, -0.0065231323, 0.02507019, 0.054534912, 0.0078048706, -0.036224365, -0.010688782, -0.016937256, 0.0045700073, -0.039978027, 0.02154541, -0.0062828064, -0.0058403015, -0.059326172, -0.019439697, -0.064086914, 0.013061523, -0.052978516, 0.01638794, -0.027450562, 0.027923584, 0.017730713, 0.014457703, 0.017089844, 0.017471313, 0.010612488, -0.008216858, -0.022583008, -0.029510498, 0.038146973, 0.042633057, 0.01940918, -0.056518555, 0.020446777, -0.025390625, -0.04788208, -0.015151978, -0.0362854, 0.020889282, 0.050933838, -0.0025672913, -0.010688782, 0.004196167, 0.012542725, 0.012367249, -0.030471802, -0.019546509, 0.038879395, 0.0357666, 0.04171753, -0.027160645, 0.018341064, -0.035095215, 0.02658081, -0.0138168335, 0.007949829, -0.01675415, -0.0005412102, -0.0009965897, -0.031463623, -0.026901245, -0.009536743, 0.031677246, -0.0036621094, -0.01977539, -0.030410767, -0.027008057, -0.009590149, 0.014564514, 0.029205322, -0.001291275, -0.014701843, -0.0040130615, -0.012130737, -0.017044067, 0.016738892, 0.03253174, -0.02859497, -0.053344727, -0.020080566, 0.029968262, -0.025146484, -0.03274536, 0.04321289, 0.004497528, 0.012184143, -0.022079468, -0.006374359, 0.060943604, 0.014198303, 0.05645752, 0.01210022, -0.0053367615, 0.015274048, 0.019180298, 0.018600464, 0.019989014, -0.0395813, -0.029296875, 0.0029563904, 0.024749756, -0.008285522, 0.040924072, -0.05770874, -0.07598877, -0.046020508, 0.034576416, 0.010215759, 0.0023040771, -0.022949219, 0.021408081, 0.024856567, -0.02607727, 0.015899658, 0.019180298, -0.014038086, -0.014701843, 0.050933838, -0.0011100769, -0.03793335, -0.02482605, -0.04119873, 0.024307251, -0.02192688, 0.032958984, 0.011703491, 0.02230835, -0.09375, 0.01133728, 0.04699707, 0.053497314, 0.024475098, 0.008453369, -0.0007009506, 0.027008057, 0.04714966, -0.0066337585, -0.014289856, 0.025924683, 0.015686035, 0.018737793, 0.021133423, 0.001578331, 0.023208618, -0.0051116943, -0.008239746, -0.009262085, 0.0019264221, -0.0309906, 0.017837524, -0.005722046, -0.001707077, -0.012573242, -0.03652954, 0.06677246, -0.039001465, -0.03527832, -0.018920898, -0.02168274, 0.048583984, 0.0029697418, -0.0635376, 0.01725769, -0.05758667, -0.038238525, -0.03768921, -0.011672974, 0.018814087, 0.014556885, -0.008338928, 0.0390625, -0.009483337, -0.020111084, -0.009895325, -0.021438599, -0.019561768, -0.04385376, -0.00920105, 0.022018433, -0.03451538, 0.04748535, 0.038330078, 0.012626648, -0.014854431, -0.011108398, -0.0096588135, -0.06311035, -0.0070648193, -0.00059080124, -0.015594482, -0.0060310364, -0.047546387, -0.013587952, -0.008644104, -0.0069351196, -0.009101868, 0.023147583, -0.0031490326, -0.002653122, 0.053375244, 0.027420044, 0.101501465, -0.03744507, 0.038909912, 0.020721436, -0.011405945, -0.024551392, -0.0025405884, -0.039031982, 0.014533997, 0.029525757, 0.003610611, -0.024337769, 0.0041885376, 0.017532349, 0.016983032, -0.0345459, 0.0084991455, 0.006336212, 0.011833191, -0.0019874573, 0.051879883, 0.006454468, 0.06903076, 0.02722168, 0.0013895035, 0.057159424, 0.0034008026, 0.013572693, -0.025161743, 0.019195557, 0.002538681, 0.03753662, -0.0008172989, 0.021453857, -0.045318604, 0.015007019, -0.033996582, 0.0015296936, -0.0073242188, 0.033233643, 0.030380249, -0.044708252, 0.0070610046, -0.020935059, -0.018661499, -0.012870789, -0.011047363, 0.025817871, 0.026519775, -0.06137085, -0.008842468, -0.00038599968, 0.033599854, 0.012557983, 0.024002075, 0.023254395, 0.034118652, 0.008422852, -0.044158936, -0.021881104, 0.04498291, 0.023742676, -0.0005197525, -0.015686035, -0.010650635, -0.005443573, 0.033447266, 0.08093262, -0.033477783, 0.013847351, -0.090148926, -0.0024280548, 0.014595032, -0.03253174, 0.0146865845, 0.017684937, 0.027496338, 0.01398468, -0.033172607, 0.015792847, -0.074035645, -0.010574341, 0.017456055, -0.016693115, 0.010185242, -0.016113281, 0.010673523, -0.0010766983, -0.034179688, 0.0015420914, 0.034698486, -0.019958496, 0.0023117065, -0.026123047, 0.0039138794, -0.017044067, -0.035186768, -0.020477295, -0.0067253113, 0.025802612, 0.051452637, 0.02998352, -0.05822754, -0.013206482, 0.02029419, 0.038513184, -0.020492554, 0.037902832, -0.0262146, -0.022247314, -0.022903442, -0.020980835, 0.015220642, -0.043823242, 0.016403198, -0.044708252, -0.0042037964, 0.009849548, -0.022216797, -0.003692627, 0.024475098, -0.0069885254, -0.024673462, -0.004070282, 0.054229736, -0.03955078, -0.023025513, 0.040008545, 0.031036377, -0.015426636, 0.059143066, 0.011894226, 0.019058228, -0.030044556, -0.02494812, -0.05783081, 0.0001616478, -0.012145996, 0.008262634, 0.036865234, -0.045837402, 0.0037727356, -0.043151855, -0.011627197, 0.008354187, 0.017166138, -0.003835678, -0.029647827, -0.00054216385, -0.011024475, 0.009994507, 0.020584106, -0.017745972, 0.010612488, 0.091552734, 0.0011148453, -0.018356323, 0.0037174225, 0.0357666, 0.009651184, -0.01626587, -0.037841797, -0.035491943, 0.0049743652, -0.0016927719, -0.0023670197, -0.03137207, -0.005569458, -0.11260986, 0.013092041, 0.031341553, 0.013618469, -0.019439697, 0.047698975, -0.07421875, 0.05947876, -0.015258789, -0.008911133, 0.036254883, 0.027236938, -0.011550903, 0.01259613, 0.0027427673, -0.022323608, -0.0035552979, -0.022918701, -0.10101318, 0.020385742, -0.025756836, -0.0076522827, 0.016525269, -0.020950317, -0.029510498, 0.012512207, 0.00027608871, 0.05001831, 0.028366089, -0.012260437, 0.03466797, 0.008102417, 0.014251709, -0.0074768066, 0.0043754578, -0.012802124, -0.016342163, -0.0060424805, -0.032684326, 0.034820557, -0.0038986206, -0.008842468, -0.0418396, -0.026000977, -0.024963379, 0.04083252, -0.0047454834, -0.03479004, -0.046539307, -0.044189453, -0.04650879, -0.024719238, -0.0078125, 0.019256592, -0.045135498, 0.010810852, -0.00504303, 0.049438477, 0.016036987, 0.013793945, -0.036468506, -0.0030651093, 0.027435303, -0.00064229965, -0.074279785, -0.00067281723, -0.002149582, -0.012435913, 0.018341064, -0.013877869, -0.044158936, 0.033325195, -0.011459351, 0.039001465, 0.020339966, 0.00006407499, -0.0010414124, 0.025421143, -0.023101807, -0.009124756, -0.026046753, 0.019042969, 0.01940918, -0.007144928, 0.048065186, -0.06414795, -0.0033950806, 0.0010967255, -0.11022949, -0.04663086, -0.0016469955, -0.031433105, -0.06756592, -0.0098724365, 0.011619568, -0.027893066, -0.023147583, 0.013298035, -0.02456665, 0.006378174, -0.0039787292, -0.06317139, 0.0027446747, 0.05026245, -0.010955811, -0.0024585724, 0.050872803, -0.005115509, -0.018585205, -0.0082092285, 0.0149002075, 0.054473877, 0.016098022, 0.0057411194, -0.027740479, 0.036224365, -0.041290283, 0.007789612, 0.026016235, 0.009788513, -0.015556335, 0.007041931, 0.040771484, 0.037872314, -0.031982422, 0.034851074, 0.041503906, -0.0055656433, -0.0715332, 0.006000519, -0.026550293, -0.087524414, 0.020187378, 0.0055389404, 0.013084412, 0.05734253, 0.005279541, 0.10369873, -0.022491455, -0.025772095, 0.020507812, 0.03277588, -0.04510498, -0.01033783, 0.03173828, 0.06585693, -0.016693115, 0.02053833, -0.020507812, 0.0524292, 0.007282257, -0.022033691, 0.022842407, 0.0262146, -0.0574646, -0.018981934, -0.03918457, -0.052947998, -0.038146973, 0.0019483566, -0.015312195, 0.033813477, 0.02394104, -0.005420685, -0.032043457, 0.015136719, 0.028411865, 0.0075149536, -0.025680542, -0.068481445, 0.023864746, -0.020568848, -0.050079346, -0.0435791, 0.045776367, 0.026611328, 0.043670654, -0.03756714, -0.02279663, 0.025665283, 0.024215698, 0.06719971, 0.042114258, -0.0042877197, -0.046966553, 0.024002075, -0.03503418, -0.018417358, 0.008171082, 0.008598328, -0.011009216, -0.046051025, 0.013412476, -0.01876831, -0.022720337, -0.031463623, 0.041015625, -0.0067596436, 0.068237305, -0.021362305, 0.0063972473, 0.030075073, -0.005130768, 0.0051116943, -0.0018815994, -0.033569336, 0.010185242, 0.012283325, 0.055999756, -0.04373169, -0.0071105957, 0.027008057, 0.03515625, 0.014122009, -0.013633728, 0.0034980774, 0.018737793, -0.004753113, 0.019485474, -0.0045204163, -0.07501221, -0.027893066, -0.023391724, -0.015022278, 0.02822876, -0.09399414, 0.053741455, -0.040252686, -0.006000519, 0.016937256, -0.010009766, 0.032562256, -0.008125305, 0.027282715, -0.052368164, -0.07556152, -0.013214111, 0.07446289, -0.02407837, -0.024490356, -0.004688263, 0.029525757, 0.03390503, 0.031463623, 0.018508911, -0.03111267, 0.030944824, -0.003982544, -0.0060310364, -0.000014483929, -0.035369873, -0.012908936, -0.008995056, 0.007434845, -0.06451416, 0.04840088, -0.019973755, -0.006755829, -0.009254456, -0.014808655, 0.04348755, -0.06173706, 0.011375427, 0.07800293, -0.0072669983, 0.033111572, -0.00617218, 0.013053894, 0.042175293, 0.034942627, 0.012916565, -0.0032100677, 0.01158905, -0.018234253, -0.006378174, 0.01146698, 0.053863525, 0.01348114, -0.001991272, 0.024734497, 0.00026011467, -0.043823242, 0.028884888, 0.021911621, 0.008346558, 0.021255493, -0.0592041, 0.023910522, 0.0015497208, -0.017471313, 0.03062439, -0.027770996, -0.03829956, -0.0013475418, -0.005012512, -0.024627686, -0.0021953583, 0.014053345, -0.024353027, -0.105529785, 0.0046043396, -0.0039749146, 0.0129776, -0.035705566, 0.036834717, -0.04107666, 0.017410278, 0.04144287, -0.04107666, 0.02407837, -0.017623901, 0.0038909912, 0.04446411, 0.03250122, -0.035339355, 0.00060272217, 0.0016822815, -0.030151367, -0.022491455, 0.0039634705, -0.01399231, 0.0020141602, -0.021469116, -0.06896973, -0.064208984, 0.029434204, 0.019638062, -0.024932861, -0.06616211, -0.0013952255, -0.008453369, -0.009597778, 0.01461792, 0.06555176, -0.0137786865, 0.0054473877, 0.01890564, -0.0002667904, 0.04800415, -0.011749268, 0.004863739, 0.008918762, -0.068237305, 0.021194458, 0.016082764, 0.005996704, -0.018661499, 0.02520752, 0.044067383, -0.00053310394, 0.0057029724, 0.025924683, 0.07965088, -0.049957275, 0.0068092346, -0.014297485, 0.003742218, -0.049743652, 0.0385437, 0.011039734, 0.0045204163, -0.04272461, -0.03451538, -0.032196045, -0.009483337, 0.04876709, 0.0011310577, 0.055725098, -0.042114258, -0.041992188, -0.014778137, 0.006061554, -0.025650024, -0.024505615, 0.0001718998, 0.015426636, 0.039398193, 0.047302246, -0.010505676, -0.01802063, 0.020187378, 0.002243042, 0.012168884, -0.0030155182, 0.008811951, 0.0038833618, -0.01828003, -0.011520386, 0.045440674, -0.003780365, -0.023452759, 0.013031006, -0.06085205, 0.048339844, -0.0027675629, 0.05340576, 0.061767578, 0.0657959, 0.021057129, -0.013061523, 0.008872986, -0.02746582, -0.0002682209, -0.059417725, 0.009597778, -0.015304565, 0.0032634735, -0.07336426, 0.014884949, 0.032592773, 0.05105591, -0.01473999, 0.018112183, 0.010948181, -0.0023765564, 0.059631348, -0.020812988, 0.07733154, 0.03253174, 0.0029850006, 0.009010315, -0.02848816, 0.028533936, 0.056518555, 0.024887085, -0.024505615, -0.010223389, -0.006931305, 0.0019216537, -0.003435135, 0.021697998, -0.026565552, -0.011451721, -0.015975952, 0.02279663, -0.017562866, 0.015319824, 0.0546875, 0.07116699, -0.02909851, -0.0013513565, 0.012870789, -0.027801514, -0.016662598, -0.004627228, 0.049468994, -0.089904785, 0.053222656, -0.011947632, -0.044921875, -0.030471802, 0.055541992, 0.023025513, -0.023880005, -0.022018433, 0.052001953, 0.017150879, 0.015686035, 0.013725281, -0.04977417, -0.039215088, -0.02859497, 0.018676758, -0.0075187683, 0.007423401, -0.007659912, 0.040771484, -0.009559631, -0.0018901825, -0.020248413, 0.014678955, -0.04989624, 0.024307251, -0.020477295, 0.018630981, 0.024917603, -0.028839111, 0.0077934265, 0.017333984, -0.029281616, 0.010444641, -0.00491333, 0.019134521, 0.046875, 0.074279785, 0.019882202, -0.0066223145, -0.019226074, -0.031402588, 0.04675293, 0.0066719055, -0.025543213, 0.01184845, -0.035583496, -0.017181396, 0.02734375, -0.013076782, 0.05557251, -0.033355713, 0.0016794205, 0.0019130707, -0.01625061, 0.059570312, -0.034240723, -0.023864746, -0.02357483, 0.0011072159, -0.014007568, -0.009277344, -0.026184082, 0.0064353943, 0.012252808, 0.021118164, 0.047576904, 0.009498596, 0.0062789917, -0.03137207, -0.060699463, 0.021835327, -0.0087890625, 0.042999268, -0.006362915, -0.02357483, -0.020690918, 0.007881165, 0.008705139, -0.0011787415, -0.03768921, 0.019515991, -0.02470398, -0.02407837, 0.004463196, 0.0034332275, -0.0042037964, 0.030014038, -0.063964844, 0.037872314, -0.019119263, -0.011497498, 0.03567505, -0.0124053955, -0.07434082, -0.014945984, -0.0317688, 0.019805908, 0.009376526, -0.02192688, 0.035186768, 0.011543274, -0.029037476, -0.019714355, -0.007369995, 0.021652222, -0.0030708313, -0.055389404, 0.011123657, 0.014045715, 0.039031982, -0.026992798, -0.042816162, 0.01235199, 0.041656494, 0.02192688, 0.059265137, -0.013511658, 0.0034065247, -0.0025615692, 0.029434204, 0.00970459, -0.037506104, -0.027664185, -0.015670776, 0.052978516, 0.048950195, -0.02293396, 0.011772156, 0.021652222, -0.005458832, 0.02128601, -0.0138549805, -0.009651184, 0.015411377, -0.0103302, 0.0340271, -0.00920105, -0.005947113, -0.014038086, 0.045196533, -0.02178955, -0.01158905, -0.003686905, 0.011207581, -0.009162903, 0.030227661, -0.019226074, 0.005554199, 0.005870819, 0.023727417, 0.014099121, 0.035369873, -0.034332275, 0.0011968613, 0.004009247, 0.044525146, -0.0019760132, 0.05303955, 0.012283325, 0.011764526, 0.025100708, -0.04360962, -0.064819336, -0.015258789, -0.028930664, 0.03250122, -0.023040771, 0.020950317, -0.016540527, 0.0014867783, 0.007751465, 0.026779175, 0.055236816, -0.014060974, -0.042266846, -0.02519226, 0.0423584, -0.019897461 ], "summary": [ 0.037994385, 0.022705078, 0.03326416, 0.0059318542, -0.030075073, -0.013748169, -0.030334473, -0.06976318, 0.005203247, 0.042877197, -0.055786133, -0.013664246, 0.027374268, -0.0005016327, -0.02532959, -0.038391113, 0.0181427, 0.011131287, 0.042236328, -0.031311035, 0.008453369, -0.037750244, 0.07171631, 0.037750244, 0.069885254, -0.025238037, -0.12200928, 0.049102783, 0.011871338, 0.027954102, 0.0079422, -0.0022258759, 0.02468872, 0.0066871643, -0.017730713, 0.0023021698, 0.035369873, -0.014251709, -0.008514404, 0.027008057, 0.003435135, 0.00919342, 0.03201294, -0.03390503, -0.014549255, 0.02670288, -0.005344391, -0.02381897, 0.03189087, -0.060028076, 0.0041007996, 0.027175903, 0.024902344, -0.029266357, -0.02722168, 0.00349617, -0.022445679, -0.042297363, 0.026306152, 0.043670654, 0.013999939, -0.02456665, 0.009513855, -0.052459717, -0.050231934, 0.010025024, -0.015052795, -0.031677246, 0.03945923, -0.03463745, 0.0037574768, 0.0022964478, 0.0107421875, -0.0010766983, -0.02142334, -0.034332275, 0.033569336, -0.005870819, -0.006958008, 0.0109939575, 0.0006971359, -0.012367249, 0.002532959, -0.035308838, -0.007041931, -0.024353027, -0.018722534, -0.0010643005, -0.023513794, 0.010215759, -0.032073975, 0.0005044937, -0.023101807, 0.03010559, -0.0017404556, -0.015777588, -0.001004219, -0.047943115, 0.017150879, -0.013839722, 0.013381958, -0.028579712, 0.0044937134, 0.004753113, -0.0004427433, 0.047424316, 0.0037727356, -0.10443115, -0.050354004, -0.0141067505, -0.03390503, -0.059570312, -0.011940002, -0.043762207, 0.014343262, 0.05911255, -0.0074920654, 0.056793213, 0.009536743, 0.07696533, -0.014205933, 0.027114868, -0.044555664, 0.07788086, 0.020446777, 0.048706055, 0.01966858, -0.010757446, 0.009506226, 0.01878357, -0.021057129, 0.023849487, -0.014091492, -0.019622803, -0.042236328, -0.010353088, 0.03137207, -0.0037956238, -0.0033721924, -0.01889038, 0.059906006, 0.0028629303, -0.010055542, 0.030044556, -0.020553589, 0.021896362, 0.018539429, -0.0050964355, -0.008605957, 0.008575439, -0.013954163, -0.023162842, -0.011459351, 0.018737793, 0.015396118, -0.009140015, -0.046447754, 0.00035881996, 0.04348755, 0.031021118, 0.03881836, 0.017944336, 0.020690918, 0.030212402, -0.0079956055, -0.016677856, -0.022857666, -0.012496948, 0.010467529, -0.083618164, 0.038146973, 0.03125, 0.032684326, -0.015037537, 0.024475098, -0.019302368, 0.010818481, -0.012290955, -0.0076065063, 0.033843994, 0.017349243, -0.024047852, -0.02368164, 0.024612427, 0.0068511963, -0.0013589859, -0.019607544, -0.014595032, 0.027740479, -0.0009007454, -0.041168213, 0.02053833, -0.019134521, -0.024978638, -0.00390625, -0.008026123, 0.022994995, 0.014945984, -0.009063721, 0.011047363, 0.030426025, -0.013168335, -0.024124146, -0.029586792, -0.087768555, -0.020248413, -0.0335083, 0.015075684, -0.03967285, 0.0211792, 0.018585205, -0.019226074, -0.024459839, 0.027130127, 0.018569946, -0.030853271, -0.004486084, -0.030426025, -0.029815674, 0.018661499, -0.06173706, 0.03286743, -0.094177246, -0.017944336, -0.048187256, 0.0118255615, -0.00737381, 0.030960083, 0.029907227, 0.023468018, 0.09301758, -0.041992188, 0.044830322, 0.00086450577, -0.017349243, -0.009162903, 0.011054993, -0.099365234, 0.009414673, 0.04840088, 0.007633209, -0.02458191, -0.016952515, 0.034240723, -0.023742676, 0.0034179688, 0.011543274, 0.021530151, -0.0009870529, 0.02784729, -0.009407043, -0.0069389343, 0.040863037, -0.004600525, -0.027420044, 0.048309326, -0.0051460266, 0.0008416176, 0.008506775, 0.009231567, 0.0054016113, 0.016296387, 0.0034370422, 0.007850647, -0.03286743, -0.0033988953, -0.015525818, -0.004764557, 0.00028777122, -0.0079422, 0.015731812, -0.04940796, -0.0053100586, -0.052856445, -0.016738892, -0.042907715, -0.01461792, 0.030166626, 0.030410767, -0.056884766, 0.0014343262, 0.004776001, -0.030227661, -0.014663696, 0.038726807, 0.00995636, -0.001449585, 0.022323608, -0.0038318634, 0.027664185, 0.028152466, 0.039031982, -0.0026626587, 0.00012493134, -0.006252289, -0.00011354685, -0.036621094, 0.044281006, -0.011276245, -0.0005235672, -0.049346924, 0.021194458, 0.008613586, -0.027862549, 0.020629883, 0.033233643, 0.046081543, -0.021362305, -0.006706238, 0.032318115, -0.072021484, -0.01586914, 0.020996094, 0.06378174, -0.014221191, -0.014205933, 0.007789612, 0.04333496, 0.009544373, 0.021453857, 0.045074463, -0.050689697, -0.0038051605, -0.009925842, -0.028198242, -0.010139465, 0.0063438416, -0.008659363, -0.015975952, -0.005870819, -0.02017212, 0.0046691895, -0.021591187, 0.0491333, -0.010482788, 0.002714157, 0.0030460358, 0.08569336, 0.018417358, 0.00217247, 0.0012664795, -0.025054932, -0.034332275, -0.011383057, -0.037872314, 0.0050621033, -0.005001068, -0.0025787354, -0.014083862, -0.0014266968, -0.0036354065, -0.0043296814, -0.012321472, 0.05203247, 0.011680603, -0.008522034, 0.006149292, 0.054840088, 0.00045990944, -0.011306763, 0.07672119, 0.01524353, 0.028686523, -0.0927124, -0.046661377, -0.03878784, 0.0051460266, -0.04232788, 0.027023315, 0.033081055, -0.015060425, 0.057434082, -0.061065674, -0.00894165, -0.01146698, 0.024902344, 0.07904053, -0.003232956, 0.050201416, 0.06173706, 0.043914795, 0.044555664, -0.024841309, 0.0073928833, 0.077941895, 0.002040863, -0.006904602, 0.009002686, 0.049804688, 0.015403748, -0.009849548, -0.02658081, 0.019378662, -0.0095825195, 0.0019226074, -0.008094788, -0.041412354, 0.042266846, -0.07458496, -0.008918762, -0.0027770996, 0.03189087, 0.01739502, 0.0309906, -0.050689697, 0.0881958, -0.02645874, -0.0042648315, 0.022857666, -0.005050659, -0.00920105, -0.005355835, -0.009109497, -0.00894928, -0.0018234253, -0.019515991, -0.01586914, 0.0009860992, -0.03933716, 0.006298065, 0.0068206787, 0.042144775, 0.0013780594, 0.02319336, -0.0050735474, 0.015777588, 0.01864624, 0.012176514, 0.018798828, 0.036102295, 0.019973755, -0.020370483, 0.02078247, 0.018829346, -0.026947021, 0.012168884, -0.023391724, -0.00057411194, 0.018707275, -0.06561279, -0.03475952, -0.04147339, -0.022476196, 0.019363403, -0.0020751953, -0.013290405, -0.04525757, -0.037872314, -0.049346924, -0.07720947, -0.0113220215, 0.0121154785, 0.04058838, 0.031829834, 0.028442383, 0.07891846, 0.0049057007, 0.028427124, 0.011894226, 0.01374054, 0.038482666, 0.003479004, -0.023223877, 0.0034255981, 0.004875183, 0.0096206665, -0.00023543835, 0.0015325546, -0.030715942, 0.015686035, -0.008155823, -0.007888794, 0.015777588, -0.0236969, -0.0035419464, -0.051086426, 0.037872314, 0.0051193237, 0.023117065, -0.034942627, -0.011474609, -0.003894806, -0.024414062, -0.05419922, 0.006038666, -0.0041503906, -0.06439209, -0.027542114, 0.005584717, 0.023101807, -0.0021705627, -0.0014266968, 0.03652954, 0.00027012825, -0.01537323, 0.014091492, -0.022506714, 0.09222412, 0.01651001, -0.035247803, 0.012184143, -0.034179688, 0.019470215, -0.023361206, -0.0065727234, 0.0026302338, 0.029373169, -0.0073165894, -0.014572144, -0.004852295, 0.029022217, -0.038848877, -0.0084991455, 0.0005440712, -0.020202637, 0.0146865845, 0.011909485, 0.017715454, -0.019989014, -0.004421234, 0.034362793, 0.03488159, -0.019302368, -0.0011787415, 0.028045654, 0.009056091, -0.03137207, 0.021621704, -0.03717041, -0.07739258, 0.027572632, 0.06365967, 0.034118652, 0.0579834, -0.021743774, 0.024902344, -0.01436615, -0.049591064, 0.010414124, 0.08190918, -0.042510986, -0.05569458, 0.006034851, 0.07562256, -0.061157227, 0.036956787, -0.046844482, 0.06573486, 0.0029621124, -0.0049209595, 0.047454834, 0.022628784, -0.018737793, -0.02798462, -0.012580872, -0.023727417, -0.00008100271, -0.009307861, -0.012580872, 0.03375244, 0.008483887, -0.02960205, -0.011413574, 0.023208618, 0.0149002075, 0.0132751465, -0.03842163, -0.054840088, -0.019256592, -0.01828003, -0.011474609, 0.004486084, 0.05630493, 0.01524353, 0.014602661, -0.03918457, -0.023269653, -0.0077667236, 0.042236328, 0.066467285, 0.009887695, 0.021560669, -0.025634766, -0.040740967, -0.059753418, 0.0020503998, 0.022338867, -0.037750244, -0.022033691, -0.019515991, 0.047973633, 0.0077590942, -0.024032593, -0.0064811707, 0.028182983, 0.005645752, 0.036956787, -0.019485474, 0.018829346, 0.015609741, 0.02268982, 0.00573349, 0.016403198, -0.014785767, -0.03463745, -0.013793945, 0.03213501, -0.004447937, -0.014228821, 0.010498047, 0.027420044, 0.0010290146, 0.02859497, -0.02218628, 0.048858643, -0.031036377, 0.025283813, -0.0013399124, -0.0289917, -0.027694702, 0.0048217773, -0.0037002563, 0.0029888153, -0.012008667, 0.03665161, -0.00422287, -0.02168274, 0.028579712, -0.0005745888, 0.01109314, 0.007068634, 0.0014619827, -0.028701782, -0.060028076, 0.0037651062, 0.053253174, 0.019470215, -0.016647339, -0.024536133, 0.013000488, 0.013618469, 0.0031661987, -0.01776123, -0.05682373, 0.046173096, -0.013946533, -0.018234253, 0.023284912, -0.01838684, -0.063964844, 0.02949524, 0.004299164, -0.05529785, 0.06604004, 0.03805542, 0.00028038025, 0.010765076, -0.0005106926, 0.017318726, -0.046203613, -0.03665161, -0.00036144257, -0.030456543, -0.006412506, 0.021957397, -0.02684021, -0.007255554, -0.006603241, -0.015472412, -0.01776123, -0.050964355, -0.017105103, -0.014015198, 0.0043411255, 0.028411865, 0.00121212, -0.027145386, 0.029815674, -0.043395996, -0.003545761, 0.008399963, 0.006385803, 0.017456055, -0.008354187, -0.010551453, 0.039245605, 0.0034179688, -0.007621765, 0.016098022, -0.019683838, -0.0055236816, -0.022079468, 0.0065956116, -0.07067871, -0.002286911, -0.0060043335, 0.004673004, -0.08258057, -0.037109375, -0.019012451, 0.012741089, -0.031799316, 0.05441284, -0.0050849915, -0.03704834, 0.029174805, -0.010986328, 0.05758667, -0.00019264221, 0.0024299622, 0.030410767, -0.0066490173, -0.013366699, 0.0036888123, 0.009857178, -0.0056037903, -0.037628174, -0.040740967, -0.044708252, 0.041137695, 0.0020618439, -0.018539429, -0.002412796, -0.010116577, 0.0284729, -0.06878662, -0.017089844, -0.017456055, -0.021392822, -0.03414917, 0.0309906, 0.027282715, -0.030212402, 0.008354187, 0.0020198822, 0.007297516, 0.06640625, 0.004573822, 0.037994385, -0.023651123, -0.07366943, 0.017990112, 0.019836426, -0.0010786057, -0.0006184578, -0.0010385513, 0.011329651, 0.00434494, -0.0040664673, -0.006412506, 0.042938232, -0.008270264, 0.025512695, 0.010955811, 0.02961731, -0.041778564, -0.037750244, 0.03866577, 0.04525757, -0.017425537, 0.0019779205, -0.0035514832, -0.01701355, 0.05532837, -0.013168335, 0.08734131, -0.047668457, -0.08929443, -0.018081665, 0.009864807, 0.010612488, -0.072265625, -0.021392822, -0.025375366, 0.0869751, 0.092285156, -0.036865234, 0.046020508, 0.0049819946, -0.017074585, -0.017562866, 0.046295166, 0.053527832, 0.010147095, 0.0011491776, 0.035736084, 0.018981934, 0.007144928, -0.0011415482, -0.028778076, -0.006713867, 0.027542114, 0.010688782, -0.0317688, -0.010948181, 0.0047416687, 0.033355713, -0.019577026, -0.049743652, -0.018005371, -0.0025310516, 0.0033950806, -0.022506714, -0.0011386871, -0.018875122, -0.0053253174, 0.06048584, -0.0070648193, 0.023391724, 0.04171753, 0.009170532, 0.040740967, 0.013961792, -0.0027637482, -0.032958984, 0.035980225, 0.029785156, -0.00093221664, 0.016571045, -0.01727295, 0.011734009, 0.04675293, 0.016357422, -0.00299263, 0.029022217, 0.001824379, 0.012168884, -0.03125, -0.0020484924, -0.08459473, 0.014335632, -0.046447754, 0.048095703, 0.014083862, 0.03704834, 0.0234375, 0.029006958, 0.0031700134, 0.010124207, 0.024932861, 0.008384705, -0.0073127747, 0.015350342, 0.035827637, -0.026611328, 0.025390625, -0.0029411316, -0.045654297, 0.051849365, 0.017562866, 0.058563232, -0.035736084, -0.032989502, 0.060699463, 0.0055999756, -0.016357422, -0.0027236938, -0.045776367, -0.0014705658, 0.043884277, -0.009666443, -0.019058228, -0.039093018, 0.013450623, 0.024734497, -0.030761719, 0.03274536, -0.024780273, 0.014907837, -0.030593872, 0.029342651, -0.06890869, 0.0552063, 0.02078247, -0.017242432, 0.0345459, 0.010040283, -0.022415161, 0.03552246, -0.0015220642, 0.04360962, 0.07946777, 0.046295166, -0.039978027, 0.014373779, 0.05709839, -0.017730713, 0.07141113, -0.014793396, 0.005027771, -0.0093307495, -0.01939392, 0.030899048, 0.0026664734, 0.0017166138, 0.0045318604, -0.042755127, -0.006008148, -0.00440979, -0.008041382, -0.02041626, 0.01890564, -0.010276794, -0.037200928, -0.003080368, 0.010986328, -0.0040740967, -0.044158936, 0.04031372, -0.012176514, -0.042114258, 0.048095703, -0.017807007, 0.010482788, -0.0012140274, -0.049926758, -0.0050811768, -0.015350342, 0.03479004, 0.041290283, -0.010147095, -0.028289795, 0.049591064, -0.0023536682, -0.044128418, -0.013404846, 0.052337646, 0.0046653748, -0.037353516, 0.015403748, 0.0043563843, -0.011276245, -0.006008148, -0.048583984, 0.007987976, -0.019638062, 0.01878357, 0.055236816, 0.01889038, -0.09509277, -0.008712769, -0.02619934, 0.02166748, -0.033935547, -0.01159668, 0.015838623, 0.022506714, -0.015808105, -0.06347656, -0.03668213, -0.037872314, 0.013977051, -0.052459717, 0.039978027, -0.009025574, 0.02104187, -0.0069732666, 0.046844482, 0.034210205, 0.020690918, 0.04006958, -0.018493652, -0.04107666, -0.03552246, 0.021011353, 0.019897461, 0.020233154, 0.007904053, -0.010025024, -0.014808655, 0.04446411, -0.023803711, -0.037475586, 0.008865356, 0.010902405, -0.06713867, -0.0069999695, -0.0013875961, 0.0101623535, -0.012466431, -0.00459671, 0.011627197, -0.025314331, -0.03503418, -0.0068359375, 0.049072266, -0.045684814, -0.055480957, 0.0055122375, 0.008872986, -0.012359619, -0.032043457, -0.017990112, 0.023147583, -0.018371582, -0.0036621094, 0.015899658, -0.016174316, 0.014717102, 0.012184143, 0.04562378, 0.032348633, -0.016494751, 0.068115234, 0.0362854, 0.009284973, -0.02268982, -0.08068848, -0.025100708, -0.064086914, -0.040008545, 0.026611328, -0.022949219, 0.012229919, -0.0074806213, 0.0138168335, 0.036102295, -0.0022506714, 0.05783081, 0.021331787, -0.0063819885, 0.0345459, -0.008811951, 0.003818512 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.02854v14
Analogical proportions
Christian Antić
cs.LO, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SC
Analogy-making is at the core of human and artificial intelligence and creativity with applications to such diverse tasks as proving mathematical theorems and building mathematical theories, common sense reasoning, learning, language acquisition, and story telling. This paper introduces from first principles an abstract algebraic framework of analogical proportions of the form `$a$ is to $b$ what $c$ is to $d$' in the general setting of universal algebra. This enables us to compare mathematical objects possibly across different domains in a uniform way which is crucial for AI-systems. It turns out that our notion of analogical proportions has appealing mathematical properties. As we construct our model from first principles using only elementary concepts of universal algebra, and since our model questions some basic properties of analogical proportions presupposed in the literature, to convince the reader of the plausibility of our model we show that it can be naturally embedded into first-order logic via model-theoretic types and prove from that perspective that analogical proportions are compatible with structure-preserving mappings. This provides conceptual evidence for its applicability. In a broader sense, this paper is a first step towards a theory of analogical reasoning and learning systems with potential applications to fundamental AI-problems like common sense reasoning and computational learning and creativity.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.02854v14
2023-02-28T16:47:25
2020-06-04T13:44:36
{ "title": [ 0.03161621, 0.008705139, 0.0071105957, -0.013595581, -0.024169922, -0.023910522, -0.0055007935, -0.039978027, 0.0031166077, 0.040740967, -0.03326416, -0.011787415, 0.026672363, -0.013633728, 0.012321472, -0.002746582, 0.03656006, 0.032562256, 0.03439331, -0.010749817, -0.038757324, 0.028182983, 0.016418457, 0.024307251, 0.009757996, -0.009796143, 0.015335083, -0.021362305, 0.034820557, 0.007293701, 0.0034008026, -0.02633667, 0.008308411, -0.008163452, 0.012420654, -0.01991272, -0.0046157837, -0.017608643, -0.017089844, 0.041656494, 0.009109497, -0.012054443, 0.00440979, -0.05178833, -0.030197144, -0.03744507, 0.047454834, 0.008880615, 0.024810791, 0.03314209, -0.002155304, -0.04675293, -0.012123108, 0.035705566, -0.008026123, -0.015426636, -0.024993896, -0.0017004013, 0.026519775, -0.046691895, -0.03390503, -0.025726318, 0.07531738, 0.013343811, -0.019180298, -0.027877808, -0.043304443, 0.03010559, 0.0758667, -0.014213562, -0.04522705, 0.0011110306, -0.01574707, -0.025604248, 0.017425537, -0.003660202, 0.006095886, 0.012374878, 0.0049362183, 0.009384155, -0.05126953, 0.017700195, -0.061401367, -0.023239136, -0.020233154, -0.006855011, -0.003189087, -0.015991211, 0.0031852722, -0.070495605, 0.0039711, 0.018539429, -0.046081543, 0.020584106, -0.006210327, -0.03125, 0.011062622, -0.006690979, -0.022064209, -0.043945312, 0.0037975311, -0.0259552, -0.028335571, -0.0026226044, -0.003112793, -0.014221191, 0.010795593, -0.014694214, 0.03994751, 0.04144287, -0.013313293, 0.07519531, -0.0066490173, -0.026290894, 0.0067100525, 0.02407837, -0.015449524, 0.059173584, -0.0126571655, 0.0062332153, -0.008453369, -0.0058250427, 0.042938232, 0.009376526, -0.010498047, 0.000048041344, -0.012687683, -0.04067993, 0.08581543, 0.006679535, -0.054138184, 0.045288086, -0.0748291, -0.084228516, -0.038909912, -0.02420044, -0.070739746, -0.052520752, -0.019622803, -0.00096559525, 0.0040130615, -0.008621216, 0.0692749, 0.0018358231, 0.012702942, 0.046081543, 0.02720642, 0.0011482239, 0.0041923523, -0.016357422, 0.011016846, 0.0023822784, -0.014137268, 0.06524658, -0.065979004, 0.060424805, -0.103637695, 0.042419434, -0.005622864, 0.066467285, 0.0025558472, -0.020523071, -0.005882263, -0.0020065308, -0.017456055, 0.016296387, 0.03427124, 0.012382507, -0.0024375916, 0.08782959, -0.015533447, -0.016204834, -0.027923584, -0.008285522, -0.025497437, 0.0022296906, -0.020523071, -0.031677246, 0.019210815, 0.0155181885, -0.0046043396, -0.048980713, -0.064575195, 0.037200928, -0.0040664673, -0.08227539, 0.009384155, -0.049072266, 0.01197052, 0.010368347, 0.024429321, 0.011108398, 0.01625061, 0.0062789917, -0.027511597, -0.03567505, -0.013450623, 0.0030441284, -0.01977539, 0.04156494, -0.023284912, 0.03668213, 0.014633179, -0.011108398, -0.029174805, 0.026809692, -0.0010442734, 0.029937744, -0.009185791, 0.050201416, 0.022537231, -0.021835327, -0.01676941, -0.018737793, -0.010726929, -0.040100098, -0.009819031, -0.037872314, -0.0058288574, -0.0004544258, 0.020767212, 0.0362854, -0.027542114, 0.05847168, 0.009162903, 0.0017127991, -0.008682251, -0.020965576, -0.0006132126, 0.028030396, 0.0076179504, -0.021209717, 0.009490967, 0.028060913, -0.012451172, 0.015602112, 0.03451538, 0.051635742, -0.012260437, -0.0090408325, 0.012184143, 0.046447754, 0.005832672, 0.008766174, 0.051239014, 0.045562744, 0.05871582, -0.022247314, -0.018600464, 0.00064611435, 0.05996704, -0.01159668, 0.016525269, -0.019226074, -0.0060920715, 0.021362305, 0.011512756, 0.032165527, -0.06518555, 0.07220459, -0.025299072, 0.07208252, 0.044036865, 0.013252258, -0.03353882, -0.03363037, -0.02432251, -0.0052986145, -0.009490967, -0.033233643, 0.037963867, 0.01184082, -0.011253357, -0.028793335, -0.0056152344, -0.02809143, -0.04748535, 0.03515625, -0.012878418, -0.040618896, 0.025604248, 0.046661377, 0.0026283264, 0.015327454, 0.0031318665, 0.016693115, -0.007106781, 0.037872314, -0.017211914, -0.017166138, 0.036376953, 0.0149002075, -0.024932861, 0.040100098, 0.047698975, -0.010734558, 0.03048706, 0.013725281, -0.0009274483, -0.017486572, 0.017044067, 0.037902832, -0.008728027, -0.0005874634, -0.016830444, 0.028945923, 0.0012731552, -0.026229858, -0.021530151, -0.046783447, 0.016540527, 0.043670654, 0.0362854, -0.02758789, 0.05340576, 0.012870789, 0.018447876, 0.025421143, 0.015792847, 0.007160187, 0.08898926, 0.019348145, -0.007507324, -0.045196533, 0.01134491, -0.044403076, -0.0690918, -0.030715942, -0.010467529, -0.023986816, 0.011779785, -0.056549072, -0.03387451, -0.13208008, 0.008911133, -0.023025513, -0.0055732727, -0.0056762695, -0.0061149597, 0.026901245, 0.022323608, 0.0015859604, 0.017578125, -0.04888916, 0.05731201, -0.028778076, -0.038238525, 0.028869629, 0.02986145, 0.018463135, -0.031982422, -0.03100586, 0.0008845329, 0.012550354, 0.07763672, 0.021636963, -0.026367188, 0.04547119, 0.09277344, -0.030532837, -0.015655518, -0.020202637, -0.06762695, -0.031280518, 0.046722412, -0.028533936, -0.008995056, -0.01309967, 0.005382538, 0.019851685, -0.021972656, 0.00055933, -0.016418457, 0.0015258789, -0.022094727, 0.009536743, -0.038482666, -0.06878662, 0.021209717, -0.035186768, 0.00041127205, 0.0002732277, 0.033691406, 0.0005364418, 0.034484863, -0.016921997, -0.016525269, 0.03062439, 0.04901123, 0.05026245, -0.022705078, -0.045654297, -0.021652222, -0.021911621, 0.02204895, 0.016159058, 0.021621704, -0.0051498413, -0.03842163, -0.028884888, 0.070007324, 0.013801575, -0.011276245, 0.021194458, -0.0826416, -0.03237915, 0.0037555695, -0.012741089, 0.009628296, 0.05331421, -0.04071045, 0.039978027, 0.016647339, 0.0000075101852, -0.0063667297, 0.012283325, -0.009414673, 0.0027561188, -0.023712158, 0.018218994, 0.01928711, -0.0140686035, -0.013542175, -0.008155823, -0.011207581, -0.037506104, 0.03717041, 0.041748047, -0.045837402, -0.026245117, -0.021713257, -0.05581665, -0.009162903, -0.06100464, -0.039520264, -0.018341064, -0.044189453, 0.026519775, -0.030319214, 0.009292603, -0.04119873, -0.0134887695, -0.027648926, -0.019760132, -0.042144775, -0.013519287, 0.006843567, -0.040893555, -0.024902344, 0.0049743652, -0.04324341, 0.020523071, -0.05407715, 0.008605957, -0.023971558, -0.0055274963, -0.01625061, 0.02017212, 0.010894775, 0.033355713, 0.043518066, 0.025863647, -0.024887085, -0.021896362, -0.0619812, 0.00356102, 0.030975342, 0.003660202, 0.0037269592, -0.05340576, -0.048950195, 0.08508301, -0.015640259, -0.013877869, -0.005542755, -0.027038574, -0.0070495605, 0.038269043, -0.02357483, -0.005329132, 0.04046631, -0.014656067, 0.034942627, -0.02619934, 0.021987915, 0.00009286404, -0.07598877, 0.007183075, 0.022918701, 0.016571045, -0.017822266, -0.0005722046, 0.029418945, -0.0053482056, -0.008430481, -0.015899658, -0.027954102, 0.04034424, 0.040283203, -0.01525116, -0.0418396, -0.0002670288, -0.0034980774, -0.03527832, -0.008354187, -0.07672119, -0.024734497, -0.020858765, 0.03945923, 0.0037708282, -0.01374054, -0.0044136047, 0.016983032, -0.0095825195, -0.028182983, 0.05886841, -0.04296875, 0.015296936, -0.01777649, -0.020751953, 0.05279541, 0.020065308, 0.03881836, 0.032073975, -0.018707275, 0.014839172, -0.00028419495, -0.010894775, -0.019805908, -0.03253174, -0.019897461, -0.016571045, -0.0023860931, 0.006767273, 0.03640747, 0.016143799, -0.022613525, 0.010276794, 0.023834229, -0.044799805, -0.0017375946, 0.02230835, -0.04949951, -0.019348145, -0.021148682, -0.037139893, 0.022827148, 0.0826416, 0.010192871, 0.024551392, 0.055755615, 0.0141067505, 0.021057129, -0.0061149597, -0.017745972, -0.06317139, -0.011528015, -0.013061523, -0.0128479, 0.02357483, 0.021987915, 0.013938904, -0.040374756, -0.010322571, -0.03164673, -0.02609253, 0.05496216, 0.003019333, -0.004436493, -0.017807007, -0.018112183, -0.02758789, -0.013298035, -0.005645752, -0.033966064, 0.0067481995, -0.076293945, 0.0005002022, -0.036590576, 0.030212402, 0.048583984, 0.006477356, -0.04147339, -0.056884766, 0.03665161, -0.012283325, -0.019744873, -0.054779053, 0.003255844, -0.013771057, 0.015281677, -0.015556335, 0.00015437603, -0.064331055, 0.015472412, -0.008239746, 0.021636963, 0.004497528, -0.00737381, 0.00944519, 0.0072898865, 0.00982666, 0.0088272095, -0.014450073, 0.03363037, 0.008766174, 0.060516357, 0.016494751, -0.009460449, -0.004207611, 0.011672974, 0.0039482117, -0.023895264, -0.0016260147, -0.036132812, 0.02468872, 0.011436462, 0.048309326, 0.020507812, -0.018112183, 0.008605957, 0.023025513, 0.02128601, -0.009017944, -0.0009822845, 0.004032135, 0.034576416, 0.024719238, -0.0005617142, -0.00010728836, -0.01007843, -0.02935791, -0.034576416, -0.066589355, 0.0004930496, 0.047454834, -0.012687683, -0.041900635, -0.013145447, 0.048034668, -0.041259766, 0.03515625, -0.0031776428, -0.03475952, 0.082214355, -0.06402588, -0.0287323, 0.0209198, -0.03552246, 0.02557373, -0.03616333, 0.008850098, 0.050079346, -0.011894226, 0.025405884, 0.014541626, 0.002571106, 0.029632568, 0.005332947, 0.0032138824, 0.03668213, 0.082458496, -0.07006836, 0.033721924, 0.019454956, 0.008018494, 0.04586792, 0.031036377, 0.007419586, -0.02494812, -0.0058555603, 0.016342163, 0.004459381, -0.005722046, -0.007003784, -0.018493652, 0.016220093, 0.007797241, -0.013687134, 0.0035552979, 0.007820129, 0.05230713, 0.038024902, -0.0048065186, -0.042510986, 0.008560181, -0.012077332, 0.024536133, -0.0030555725, -0.061828613, -0.072631836, -0.035125732, -0.02368164, -0.059448242, 0.035583496, 0.005836487, -0.015792847, 0.004863739, 0.043792725, 0.0012788773, 0.026901245, -0.008811951, 0.0012626648, -0.014602661, 0.034820557, 0.023498535, -0.037139893, -0.048217773, -0.030807495, 0.009437561, -0.026382446, 0.046569824, -0.012786865, -0.0023345947, -0.04574585, 0.00016522408, 0.06762695, 0.04714966, 0.055786133, 0.014160156, -0.020690918, -0.033294678, 0.00013518333, -0.010772705, 0.0126953125, 0.02746582, -0.05947876, 0.021011353, -0.012199402, -0.02078247, -0.0009460449, 0.04660034, -0.011161804, -0.031280518, 0.0093688965, -0.07330322, 0.042022705, -0.013748169, -0.00078964233, 0.032409668, -0.020935059, 0.023925781, 0.026168823, 0.03213501, -0.020996094, 0.006099701, -0.01586914, 0.029312134, -0.010368347, -0.021713257, 0.047088623, -0.0014305115, -0.021621704, -0.038024902, 0.004432678, -0.0074424744, 0.032989502, -0.024932861, -0.034698486, -0.027542114, -0.01689148, -0.002916336, -0.014801025, 0.019470215, -0.024887085, 0.019348145, -0.081604004, -0.056365967, 0.05807495, 0.0023479462, -0.005542755, 0.033447266, -0.012283325, -0.03564453, 0.02268982, 0.013954163, 0.01210022, 0.008377075, 0.01335907, 0.017547607, -0.022232056, 0.027999878, -0.037902832, 0.0034751892, -0.0061836243, -0.030075073, 0.021972656, -0.01411438, 0.050476074, 0.03579712, -0.0049705505, 0.0025253296, -0.015449524, -0.017929077, -0.011711121, -0.0473938, -0.017303467, -0.015022278, -0.0062065125, -0.040649414, 0.01335144, -0.061462402, -0.024139404, -0.020751953, -0.032470703, -0.049224854, -0.024887085, 0.041656494, -0.00011152029, 0.0038223267, -0.009643555, 0.01789856, -0.017028809, -0.012634277, -0.05496216, 0.03302002, 0.005290985, 0.024749756, -0.039886475, -0.0501709, 0.001461029, 0.03062439, -0.00047540665, 0.018188477, 0.020599365, -0.009292603, 0.052947998, -0.015716553, -0.010147095, 0.03201294, 0.017715454, -0.012168884, 0.013877869, 0.056732178, 0.0030899048, -0.013198853, -0.02178955, 0.011047363, 0.010040283, 0.0076522827, 0.0061302185, -0.011444092, -0.004421234, -0.014816284, 0.009803772, 0.006603241, 0.013847351, 0.007896423, 0.05670166, -0.020568848, 0.052978516, -0.0039634705, -0.06768799, -0.0121536255, 0.05142212, 0.059936523, 0.032684326, -0.04260254, -0.01651001, -0.017364502, -0.043121338, 0.009140015, -0.014633179, 0.050720215, 0.0044059753, 0.0048332214, 0.009902954, -0.009124756, -0.0008816719, -0.04248047, 0.00089120865, 0.019851685, -0.0317688, 0.030517578, -0.0058250427, 0.0104599, 0.018478394, 0.03048706, 0.041870117, -0.0262146, 0.042541504, 0.020904541, 0.07208252, 0.004096985, -0.009292603, -0.033294678, 0.0088272095, 0.029266357, 0.017288208, -0.014167786, 0.006752014, -0.02192688, 0.005718231, 0.004611969, -0.003610611, -0.0075187683, -0.022613525, 0.007408142, -0.018798828, -0.0056266785, -0.005367279, -0.004890442, -0.025375366, -0.016433716, 0.02041626, -0.0053710938, 0.0057258606, -0.008026123, -0.032409668, -0.041381836, 0.062438965, 0.00894165, 0.037384033, 0.050842285, -0.050323486, -0.022979736, 0.07305908, 0.034057617, 0.12249756, 0.047607422, -0.0062561035, 0.005054474, 0.032714844, -0.029449463, -0.009544373, -0.019882202, 0.07824707, -0.00008684397, 0.014305115, -0.0034999847, 0.0025806427, -0.018188477, 0.009864807, 0.0023174286, 0.05029297, -0.024795532, 0.002243042, 0.008003235, 0.008255005, -0.014480591, -0.0069885254, 0.025268555, -0.00075387955, -0.014213562, -0.026184082, 0.014602661, 0.000620842, -0.0018014908, -0.057739258, -0.00932312, 0.0014667511, -0.0017795563, -0.029281616, -0.003047943, 0.006690979, 0.0703125, -0.02557373, -0.07183838, 0.0036182404, 0.005065918, -0.012908936, 0.071777344, 0.04272461, 0.021743774, -0.0574646, 0.028793335, -0.036895752, 0.014533997, 0.0060577393, 0.020324707, 0.030700684, 0.0049591064, -0.026473999, 0.001452446, 0.0044059753, -0.0073776245, 0.017150879, -0.024780273, -0.03515625, -0.01322937, -0.02355957, 0.025405884, 0.017990112, -0.012199402, -0.011871338, -0.011260986, 0.0030384064, 0.0016517639, 0.015365601, -0.018081665, -0.027008057, 0.08294678, -0.06021118, -0.033416748, 0.021835327, 0.027114868, -0.016860962, 0.029174805, -0.008956909, 0.022781372, -0.01184845, 0.020248413, 0.046173096, 0.044708252, -0.044708252, 0.023010254, 0.040252686, -0.08538818, -0.03463745, -0.014099121, -0.02456665, 0.0440979, 0.006664276, -0.009185791, 0.059936523, -0.013587952, 0.0038757324, -0.005630493, 0.031921387, -0.010299683, -0.002735138, 0.023376465, -0.01134491, 0.008651733 ], "summary": [ 0.02041626, -0.037506104, 0.019607544, 0.011459351, -0.06591797, -0.007965088, -0.0020618439, -0.0234375, 0.019897461, 0.05154419, -0.022399902, 0.01309967, 0.030151367, 0.0009498596, -0.0154418945, 0.008888245, 0.004802704, 0.038391113, 0.029159546, -0.019256592, 0.0076560974, -0.020553589, 0.010467529, 0.034118652, 0.018295288, -0.03994751, 0.011497498, 0.009231567, 0.046691895, 0.021408081, 0.014907837, -0.029586792, 0.026931763, -0.02079773, -0.0053482056, -0.065979004, 0.004547119, -0.02281189, -0.05142212, 0.043151855, 0.03125, -0.009590149, 0.015960693, -0.017242432, -0.0088272095, -0.00060367584, 0.0435791, 0.0025539398, 0.019363403, 0.027496338, -0.025543213, -0.0041885376, -0.02230835, 0.040283203, -0.015213013, -0.038726807, -0.03326416, -0.022033691, 0.026809692, 0.0004775524, 0.0049705505, -0.03137207, 0.016693115, 0.0050735474, -0.027282715, -0.0014486313, -0.025939941, -0.0058937073, 0.056365967, -0.016357422, -0.009841919, 0.024993896, 0.030929565, -0.0073127747, 0.024261475, -0.031799316, 0.037902832, 0.036193848, -0.0048446655, 0.0043144226, -0.025161743, 0.025756836, 0.0049858093, -0.06585693, 0.008399963, -0.046203613, -0.014526367, 0.012916565, -0.03668213, -0.025466919, -0.02268982, -0.019592285, -0.072265625, 0.023162842, 0.04043579, -0.035614014, -0.023010254, -0.04534912, 0.021484375, 0.00035977364, 0.019805908, -0.04434204, 0.040161133, -0.018127441, -0.015388489, -0.007408142, 0.012466431, -0.04812622, 0.00035476685, 0.026428223, -0.0289917, 0.027160645, 0.013175964, -0.02909851, 0.017410278, 0.036834717, -0.009521484, 0.08929443, 0.016235352, 0.055541992, -0.01625061, -0.014656067, 0.024398804, 0.051818848, 0.00970459, 0.043701172, 0.0042495728, -0.05154419, 0.07745361, 0.022201538, -0.004447937, 0.016662598, -0.048431396, -0.045043945, -0.051086426, -0.0017080307, -0.008232117, -0.03125, 0.0042800903, -0.01676941, 0.008506775, -0.0061187744, 0.054992676, 0.03265381, -0.040252686, 0.022399902, 0.013175964, 0.01625061, -0.021911621, -0.05807495, 0.0010156631, -0.027435303, 0.0064888, 0.0064811707, -0.03414917, -0.00042915344, -0.070129395, 0.019515991, 0.013755798, 0.029846191, -0.008911133, 0.007587433, 0.019363403, 0.016952515, 0.01108551, -0.0038795471, -0.0032157898, 0.007331848, 0.008598328, 0.012626648, 0.010253906, 0.024917603, -0.031555176, -0.027236938, -0.016326904, -0.040130615, 0.00409317, -0.045806885, -0.023513794, 0.06744385, 0.018051147, -0.024673462, -0.08459473, 0.044433594, 0.0056991577, -0.015853882, -0.003929138, -0.062347412, 0.02545166, -0.013763428, 0.023468018, 0.04953003, -0.006046295, 0.020843506, -0.01008606, -0.0231781, -0.07824707, -0.020462036, -0.03704834, 0.03857422, 0.027816772, -0.00048971176, -0.016281128, -0.033966064, -0.10394287, 0.0058403015, -0.019515991, 0.040252686, -0.07324219, 0.023406982, 0.050201416, -0.027236938, -0.045654297, 0.035064697, 0.011695862, -0.06738281, 0.048980713, -0.018005371, -0.0040512085, -0.048858643, -0.038208008, 0.053649902, -0.0703125, 0.04675293, -0.028930664, 0.02041626, -0.039978027, 0.020751953, -0.027893066, 0.036224365, 0.002691269, -0.005168915, 0.0037937164, 0.03616333, -0.01687622, 0.0029640198, 0.004234314, -0.031341553, 0.0082473755, 0.020217896, 0.018066406, 0.014335632, -0.023483276, -0.014053345, 0.019882202, 0.05001831, 0.05117798, -0.016098022, -0.024353027, 0.007865906, 0.02519226, 0.022338867, 0.018234253, 0.006313324, -0.0050735474, 0.023254395, -0.00050115585, 0.011459351, -0.041412354, 0.04550171, 0.0071640015, 0.026382446, 0.0002810955, 0.009796143, 0.019638062, -0.0345459, -0.014007568, -0.02027893, -0.0067749023, -0.02911377, 0.028533936, -0.020980835, -0.015266418, -0.07873535, -0.061523438, -0.00843811, -0.032409668, 0.056427002, 0.020690918, -0.07299805, 0.015167236, 0.055419922, -0.006793976, -0.016693115, -0.0028877258, -0.008277893, -0.026016235, 0.0077781677, 0.058380127, 0.046783447, 0.030563354, 0.037597656, 0.01826477, 0.03793335, 0.020904541, -0.027496338, -0.046905518, -0.010955811, 0.036376953, -0.03552246, -0.005622864, 0.05328369, -0.021438599, 0.018936157, -0.019134521, 0.013404846, -0.041168213, -0.0020961761, -0.008758545, -0.042236328, 0.00054597855, 0.036102295, 0.038879395, 0.049560547, -0.010437012, -0.016998291, -0.009719849, 0.056640625, -0.016571045, 0.013412476, 0.08746338, 0.014381409, 0.007896423, 0.0035953522, 0.01512146, -0.05429077, 0.02861023, -0.02885437, 0.032684326, -0.016357422, -0.05142212, -0.026412964, -0.047943115, -0.050811768, -0.0026988983, -0.006881714, 0.0113220215, -0.02508545, -0.00522995, 0.020874023, 0.02923584, 0.012031555, 0.0050849915, -0.04385376, -0.002664566, -0.008598328, 0.018951416, 0.009101868, 0.041809082, 0.012771606, -0.025970459, -0.021255493, 0.012123108, 0.0051727295, 0.03967285, 0.006515503, -0.028411865, 0.024353027, 0.035064697, -0.049713135, -0.0013599396, 0.016464233, -0.041992188, -0.046020508, 0.022445679, -0.01902771, 0.02406311, -0.050567627, -0.016708374, -0.005783081, -0.029129028, -0.012962341, -0.0014266968, -0.014266968, -0.016647339, 0.020263672, 0.06689453, -0.0082092285, -0.002336502, 0.03967285, 0.019454956, 0.054351807, -0.04864502, 0.02885437, 0.045440674, 0.0016021729, -0.01335907, -0.0063323975, 0.0496521, 0.019180298, 0.0023441315, -0.03189087, -0.0033435822, -0.027816772, 0.0033912659, 0.018478394, -0.0073051453, -0.0046653748, 0.001042366, -0.034057617, 0.08880615, 0.046173096, 0.023757935, 0.048736572, -0.078308105, 0.05480957, 0.0068244934, 0.008216858, 0.036865234, -0.021377563, -0.0040893555, 0.0118255615, -0.014167786, 0.0012245178, -0.03366089, -0.013511658, -0.012672424, 0.0071640015, -0.02217102, -0.011222839, 0.0008997917, 0.011154175, 0.0045280457, -0.008468628, -0.03778076, 0.004673004, -0.009490967, 0.055786133, -0.079956055, -0.027923584, -0.02305603, -0.044006348, -0.030181885, -0.015235901, 0.0006251335, -0.0007982254, -0.02658081, -0.04269409, -0.00390625, -0.021728516, 0.021255493, -0.01574707, -0.05670166, 0.0069732666, -0.03488159, 0.00025701523, -0.014137268, -0.0035152435, -0.021850586, 0.008071899, -0.043151855, 0.023620605, -0.035461426, 0.024459839, -0.020568848, -0.034454346, -0.052520752, 0.045684814, 0.0071029663, -0.0104904175, 0.022628784, -0.012237549, -0.020690918, -0.0055389404, 0.0032672882, -0.03289795, 0.017974854, -0.015342712, -0.018539429, 0.0262146, -0.036193848, 0.047668457, -0.04626465, -0.009605408, 0.0008535385, -0.012390137, 0.01259613, 0.012336731, 0.028808594, 0.01675415, -0.014442444, 0.012519836, 0.028015137, -0.056030273, -0.022109985, 0.010353088, -0.08508301, -0.028274536, 0.013664246, 0.010261536, 0.02407837, 0.0037212372, 0.02633667, 0.035705566, 0.011245728, -0.016082764, -0.03918457, 0.16186523, 0.045928955, -0.015594482, 0.023223877, -0.035003662, 0.022262573, -0.038909912, -0.023162842, 0.0077438354, -0.004676819, -0.0015106201, 0.01651001, -0.0435791, -0.019439697, -0.025253296, 0.04840088, -0.015777588, -0.018936157, 0.039367676, -0.044006348, -0.03137207, -0.008880615, 0.013168335, 0.023284912, 0.03717041, 0.018325806, 0.022201538, -0.010505676, -0.016342163, 0.0046081543, 0.007129669, -0.008636475, -0.04522705, 0.027938843, 0.036224365, -0.029571533, 0.021194458, -0.00016438961, 0.010871887, -0.019073486, 0.010215759, 0.02961731, 0.038879395, -0.041992188, -0.047576904, -0.0040626526, 0.07147217, -0.007633209, -0.0011463165, -0.006225586, 0.027496338, -0.054107666, 0.00969696, 0.00066518784, -0.004169464, -0.015457153, -0.03375244, -0.0035247803, -0.002910614, 0.0039100647, -0.0067825317, -0.0098724365, 0.04727173, -0.0023288727, 0.011230469, -0.016464233, -0.020629883, -0.0079574585, 0.0019073486, 0.02897644, -0.012466431, -0.049591064, -0.002691269, -0.043762207, -0.021911621, -0.035064697, -0.0060043335, -0.042022705, -0.003376007, -0.039764404, -0.009559631, 0.008888245, 0.036315918, 0.0043525696, 0.028900146, -0.006275177, -0.022232056, -0.024291992, 0.028030396, -0.014122009, 0.0051727295, -0.009262085, -0.013092041, -0.019363403, 0.016571045, -0.023254395, -0.05734253, 0.030960083, -0.010169983, 0.024002075, 0.04373169, 0.04574585, 0.016525269, -0.0024280548, 0.0041999817, -0.0065841675, -0.019332886, 0.025436401, 0.012428284, 0.05319214, -0.038635254, -0.0181427, -0.0067367554, 0.004108429, 0.011802673, -0.006626129, -0.014205933, -0.012809753, -0.0090408325, 0.03781128, 0.015045166, -0.03149414, -0.025146484, -0.024810791, 0.012054443, -0.009056091, -0.037872314, 0.015640259, -0.0038719177, -0.03314209, 0.0018129349, -0.007965088, 0.004386902, 0.00548172, -0.009124756, -0.052978516, -0.06585693, -0.05230713, 0.08300781, -0.017105103, -0.060821533, -0.023620605, 0.010894775, -0.014854431, 0.007369995, -0.04159546, -0.054779053, 0.09222412, -0.025543213, -0.029418945, 0.020706177, -0.021514893, -0.019744873, -0.011428833, 0.0030097961, 0.007194519, -0.011405945, 0.0141067505, -0.025390625, 0.0018644333, -0.0015954971, -0.0014762878, 0.0072898865, 0.02406311, 0.05532837, -0.06878662, 0.042236328, 0.03668213, 0.0006008148, -0.021560669, 0.023498535, -0.02709961, 0.011871338, -0.022598267, -0.0209198, 0.03704834, 0.023422241, 0.045196533, 0.0076141357, -0.025863647, 0.005924225, -0.043182373, 0.019714355, -0.008918762, 0.0007286072, 0.03265381, -0.014770508, -0.013923645, 0.032196045, 0.015220642, 0.0016098022, 0.014083862, -0.035736084, 0.0053520203, 0.003873825, -0.00623703, -0.03503418, 0.03250122, 0.006690979, -0.029922485, -0.05065918, -0.013328552, 0.000095009804, -0.0017547607, -0.021636963, 0.025222778, -0.030166626, 0.0115737915, 0.018173218, 0.037872314, -0.021835327, 0.021972656, -0.013755798, -0.012649536, 0.04119873, -0.040740967, -0.009262085, -0.04034424, -0.01776123, -0.0064888, -0.0126953125, 0.0137786865, 0.06274414, 0.007282257, -0.019851685, 0.0010967255, 0.015792847, 0.0206604, -0.0036773682, -0.04699707, 0.032684326, -0.0116119385, -0.022994995, 0.014984131, -0.022247314, -0.016784668, -0.026107788, 0.0035037994, -0.048675537, 0.030975342, -0.015731812, 0.002878189, 0.015777588, -0.006160736, 0.0107040405, 0.02217102, 0.0063323975, 0.0116119385, 0.0035324097, -0.0149002075, 0.051239014, 0.0040130615, -0.012496948, 0.037475586, 0.0211792, 0.002796173, -0.011199951, 0.012306213, -0.019348145, 0.056030273, -0.012573242, -0.006755829, -0.04196167, -0.04348755, -0.016342163, -0.03314209, 0.030395508, 0.021774292, 0.050598145, -0.014915466, -0.045532227, -0.027954102, -0.009063721, 0.02557373, -0.031402588, -0.012207031, -0.032958984, 0.074645996, 0.044189453, 0.0038089752, -0.0046539307, -0.0012693405, 0.01701355, -0.0037212372, 0.038879395, -0.033233643, 0.00057029724, -0.021270752, 0.015579224, -0.003293991, 0.0056114197, 0.0050849915, -0.009277344, -0.0042800903, 0.024520874, 0.010543823, -0.03942871, -0.028152466, -0.04196167, -0.012786865, -0.014122009, -0.021453857, -0.032592773, 0.061401367, -0.020614624, -0.050994873, -0.059387207, -0.050872803, -0.0435791, 0.009178162, -0.009803772, -0.024612427, 0.048583984, -0.009239197, 0.012107849, 0.035736084, -0.03842163, 0.01626587, 0.00091838837, -0.029846191, 0.010482788, -0.048583984, -0.053131104, 0.023834229, 0.047332764, 0.00207901, 0.013504028, -0.0015716553, -0.014770508, 0.03753662, -0.02444458, -0.008468628, -0.014190674, 0.003227234, -0.028182983, 0.025421143, 0.02722168, 0.042114258, 0.007835388, 0.016235352, 0.026107788, 0.0038700104, -0.010322571, 0.027572632, 0.05117798, -0.04046631, -0.021957397, 0.09869385, -0.032684326, -0.015808105, -0.023864746, 0.035125732, -0.015213013, 0.041625977, -0.048034668, -0.045898438, -0.003698349, 0.024261475, 0.018295288, 0.03353882, -0.040496826, -0.0011024475, -0.03010559, -0.058502197, 0.03286743, 0.018417358, 0.02104187, 0.013900757, -0.033050537, 0.003501892, -0.011940002, 0.010047913, -0.05001831, 0.006565094, -0.019210815, -0.02168274, 0.024490356, -0.027267456, 0.017440796, 0.0015983582, 0.059539795, 0.003194809, -0.0010757446, 0.07421875, 0.07556152, 0.062042236, -0.027420044, 0.013092041, 0.08453369, -0.00881958, 0.054107666, -0.053894043, -0.011383057, -0.060913086, 0.022247314, 0.04534912, -0.020812988, 0.05621338, -0.01020813, -0.018508911, -0.019348145, -0.046905518, -0.011550903, -0.013442993, -0.0043411255, 0.030578613, -0.085632324, -0.00047707558, -0.0018367767, 0.040283203, -0.020111084, 0.0000022053719, -0.020095825, 0.020263672, -0.006511688, 0.045166016, 0.024765015, -0.048828125, 0.030654907, 0.07397461, 0.05255127, 0.11437988, 0.03302002, -0.017562866, 0.029541016, 0.027267456, -0.0118255615, -0.016113281, -0.050201416, 0.09490967, 0.035827637, -0.024093628, 0.034942627, 0.035614014, 0.010437012, 0.03213501, -0.02255249, 0.021499634, -0.009437561, 0.06384277, 0.023666382, -0.028625488, 0.027679443, 0.04144287, -0.008529663, 0.037750244, -0.039489746, 0.0038719177, -0.00349617, 0.041992188, -0.05871582, -0.07910156, -0.047332764, -0.027786255, 0.030685425, -0.009841919, -0.009506226, 0.0064849854, 0.02911377, -0.024780273, -0.0670166, 0.016998291, -0.009490967, 0.039855957, -0.008224487, -0.04232788, -0.008903503, 0.0116119385, 0.031707764, 0.020324707, -0.034973145, 0.018310547, -0.0011606216, 0.033172607, -0.010009766, -0.02519226, 0.009101868, -0.005016327, -0.044403076, -0.003545761, -0.024459839, 0.002325058, -0.050323486, -0.010124207, -0.043426514, -0.03475952, -0.036499023, 0.009902954, -0.021011353, 0.0020008087, -0.014434814, 0.007408142, -0.017089844, -0.021774292, 0.0446167, -0.042022705, -0.0670166, 0.039764404, 0.031173706, -0.011245728, 0.008872986, 0.022338867, -0.0022563934, -0.0026569366, 0.031799316, 0.021530151, 0.042816162, -0.054382324, 0.029632568, 0.033050537, -0.06890869, -0.023513794, -0.002981186, -0.024978638, 0.018051147, -0.007171631, -0.0055236816, 0.018844604, 0.003250122, 0.02909851, 0.00699234, 0.048034668, 0.01828003, 0.0030231476, -0.016906738, -0.0031929016, 0.0034561157 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.04001v2
Real-Time Model Calibration with Deep Reinforcement Learning
Yuan Tian, Manuel Arias Chao, Chetan Kulkarni, Kai Goebel, Olga Fink
eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.LG
The dynamic, real-time, and accurate inference of model parameters from empirical data is of great importance in many scientific and engineering disciplines that use computational models (such as a digital twin) for the analysis and prediction of complex physical processes. However, fast and accurate inference for processes with large and high dimensional datasets cannot easily be achieved with state-of-the-art methods under noisy real-world conditions. The primary reason is that the inference of model parameters with traditional techniques based on optimisation or sampling often suffers from computational and statistical challenges, resulting in a trade-off between accuracy and deployment time. In this paper, we propose a novel framework for inference of model parameters based on reinforcement learning. The contribution of the paper is twofold: 1) We reformulate the inference problem as a tracking problem with the objective of learning a policy that forces the response of the physics-based model to follow the observations; 2) We propose the constrained Lyapunov-based actor-critic (CLAC) algorithm to enable the robust and accurate inference of physics-based model parameters in real time under noisy real-world conditions. The proposed methodology is demonstrated and evaluated on two model-based diagnostics test cases utilizing two different physics-based models of turbofan engines. The performance of the methodology is compared to that of two alternative approaches: a state update method (unscented Kalman filter) and a supervised end-to-end mapping with deep neural networks. The experimental results demonstrate that the proposed methodology outperforms all other tested methods in terms of speed and robustness, with high inference accuracy.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.04001v2
2020-06-09T12:25:49
2020-06-07T00:11:42
{ "title": [ -0.03817749, 0.008888245, -0.025375366, -0.038848877, 0.008155823, -0.0021209717, -0.035827637, -0.046966553, -0.0020980835, 0.011474609, -0.03250122, 0.01134491, -0.04699707, -0.009292603, -0.029067993, -0.008995056, 0.005870819, 0.0007710457, -0.026397705, -0.048614502, 0.004802704, -0.04257202, 0.04257202, 0.101501465, 0.039733887, -0.009094238, -0.121520996, 0.045318604, -0.051971436, -0.0021648407, -0.02027893, 0.0013637543, 0.04864502, 0.034057617, -0.02923584, 0.055023193, -0.037139893, 0.019866943, 0.013412476, 0.011894226, 0.04095459, -0.022384644, -0.030395508, -0.028060913, -0.033416748, 0.02067566, -0.032440186, -0.015266418, -0.03878784, 0.08288574, 0.033691406, 0.013397217, -0.013626099, 0.070251465, 0.036071777, -0.034332275, -0.023742676, -0.025009155, 0.04156494, 0.0736084, 0.013320923, -0.045715332, 0.0040016174, -0.029541016, -0.03741455, -0.022583008, -0.0050086975, 0.009857178, 0.09100342, 0.021347046, -0.017745972, 0.04916382, -0.013420105, 0.019622803, -0.05380249, -0.0184021, 0.07342529, 0.0096588135, 0.0016622543, -0.0034484863, 0.043762207, -0.0016241074, 0.025512695, 0.009109497, 0.0012340546, -0.02229309, -0.002796173, -0.033050537, -0.042297363, -0.066101074, -0.013549805, -0.019348145, -0.03692627, 0.026443481, -0.020462036, -0.01701355, -0.035949707, 0.013206482, 0.009277344, 0.005302429, 0.00058603287, 0.00554657, -0.027420044, -0.02368164, 0.012519836, 0.022369385, -0.02078247, -0.01676941, 0.021743774, 0.03652954, -0.01424408, 0.024856567, -0.0005698204, -0.0047340393, 0.008377075, 0.0054855347, -0.013664246, 0.019210815, 0.016860962, 0.02166748, -0.021194458, -0.032104492, 0.027404785, -0.0056533813, 0.028167725, -0.0012226105, -0.026275635, -0.021362305, -0.05670166, 0.03955078, -0.0141067505, 0.038208008, -0.06451416, -0.07635498, -0.04763794, 0.031097412, -0.008987427, -0.0017385483, -0.010925293, 0.0053520203, 0.015274048, -0.027832031, -0.00046539307, 0.0062675476, 0.011779785, 0.028808594, 0.058288574, -0.013244629, -0.05508423, -0.027954102, -0.028335571, 0.011604309, 0.013427734, 0.0154800415, 0.008872986, 0.013183594, -0.07116699, -0.02130127, 0.021347046, 0.02696228, 0.020202637, 0.0016794205, 0.0061454773, 0.024749756, 0.0703125, -0.0051841736, -0.028625488, 0.020339966, -0.0076179504, 0.043182373, -0.03262329, 0.02355957, -0.028915405, -0.030960083, -0.01335144, -0.0042648315, 0.013618469, 0.01939392, 0.031311035, -0.036132812, 0.018173218, -0.003332138, 0.032470703, 0.0569458, -0.029632568, -0.06500244, -0.0078048706, -0.03643799, 0.0647583, 0.02545166, -0.070007324, -0.002658844, -0.056365967, -0.0385437, -0.055847168, -0.013214111, 0.042755127, 0.03366089, -0.012634277, 0.030334473, -0.050689697, 0.018005371, -0.049682617, 0.02507019, -0.015060425, -0.022094727, -0.007347107, 0.022918701, -0.03326416, 0.03729248, 0.059326172, 0.004398346, -0.03363037, 0.025985718, 0.006465912, -0.05230713, 0.00894928, -0.020523071, -0.01638794, -0.013053894, -0.04156494, 0.0035991669, -0.011207581, 0.070129395, 0.013175964, 0.009742737, -0.007160187, -0.011451721, 0.05807495, 0.013267517, 0.09326172, -0.046081543, -0.0065307617, 0.005596161, -0.0021629333, -0.020126343, -0.010734558, -0.008369446, 0.020996094, 0.014778137, -0.0047073364, 0.005657196, -0.020385742, 0.031921387, 0.037078857, 0.008087158, 0.01071167, 0.015609741, 0.018844604, 0.028030396, 0.052734375, 0.035614014, 0.059295654, 0.004020691, 0.02029419, 0.055999756, 0.014038086, 0.014457703, -0.011024475, 0.020874023, -0.0030651093, -0.0121154785, -0.0074043274, -0.00011211634, -0.04876709, 0.015823364, -0.031433105, 0.012466431, -0.0018119812, 0.018035889, 0.044036865, -0.012138367, 0.0046653748, -0.0076904297, -0.013656616, -0.022903442, -0.016525269, 0.027664185, 0.0012807846, -0.059906006, 0.0009813309, -0.000092089176, 0.03933716, 0.015060425, 0.01966858, 0.00054979324, 0.03237915, -0.00062179565, 0.0070114136, -0.030303955, 0.051574707, -0.00970459, -0.011543274, -0.014984131, 0.0065574646, -0.043151855, 0.062683105, 0.089538574, -0.02960205, 0.03149414, -0.0692749, 0.008216858, 0.0069274902, -0.029586792, -0.0020122528, 0.039794922, 0.02230835, 0.0059814453, -0.015342712, 0.043640137, -0.06506348, 0.020004272, -0.0020523071, -0.04647827, -0.048675537, -0.062805176, -0.0146102905, -0.054656982, -0.07196045, -0.011932373, 0.07165527, -0.014892578, -0.024520874, 0.0020999908, -0.005420685, -0.028717041, 0.0010547638, -0.03604126, 0.00094366074, 0.036071777, 0.038269043, 0.03125, -0.034820557, -0.028671265, -0.015197754, -0.0074424744, -0.016860962, 0.050872803, -0.015136719, -0.016235352, 0.011314392, -0.020767212, 0.03086853, -0.0211792, -0.018615723, -0.04638672, 0.017074585, 0.023788452, 0.0019407272, -0.0037670135, 0.02708435, -0.03375244, -0.025726318, 0.035736084, 0.05441284, -0.0423584, -0.008285522, 0.043395996, 0.014297485, -0.026382446, 0.0066604614, 0.0009083748, -0.013801575, -0.057495117, -0.0043907166, -0.023498535, -0.018051147, 0.0031814575, -0.010932922, 0.07470703, -0.05230713, -0.0036678314, -0.027297974, -0.014633179, -0.009918213, 0.023498535, -0.0060272217, -0.02746582, -0.0231781, -0.011772156, -0.0018501282, 0.021759033, -0.020629883, 0.031188965, 0.076660156, 0.009460449, -0.0009241104, -0.003293991, 0.04486084, -0.001036644, -0.013153076, -0.012832642, 0.007396698, 0.019470215, 0.032928467, -0.010322571, 0.015182495, 0.011459351, -0.1315918, -0.024169922, 0.0044136047, 0.0032405853, -0.032104492, 0.010574341, -0.04269409, 0.023529053, -0.0135650635, -0.02973938, 0.01789856, 0.01638794, 0.014968872, -0.0027751923, 0.014190674, -0.050994873, 0.026031494, -0.054840088, -0.07220459, 0.041748047, -0.055725098, -0.03488159, 0.002231598, -0.0023117065, -0.04849243, -0.021621704, 0.025253296, 0.041656494, 0.041046143, -0.00052690506, 0.035491943, -0.01537323, 0.018630981, -0.030914307, -0.020736694, -0.0234375, 0.0016231537, 0.0032653809, -0.003364563, 0.04220581, 0.0134887695, 0.004512787, -0.050567627, -0.027572632, -0.0015487671, 0.028396606, 0.01676941, -0.033355713, -0.014884949, -0.017715454, -0.012039185, -0.03366089, -0.032714844, -0.014915466, -0.026931763, 0.016906738, -0.008644104, 0.085632324, 0.009880066, 0.014030457, 0.011428833, 0.008285522, 0.04107666, -0.030960083, -0.05419922, 0.05117798, 0.04156494, 0.007270813, -0.021224976, -0.0071411133, -0.035064697, 0.02645874, -0.0057144165, 0.009727478, -0.018325806, -0.014289856, 0.014312744, 0.028564453, -0.015701294, 0.005493164, -0.019882202, 0.022460938, 0.002500534, 0.00052309036, 0.0006494522, -0.037902832, 0.0065956116, 0.0025119781, -0.092285156, -0.0064582825, 0.023010254, -0.006286621, -0.008842468, -0.06311035, 0.034088135, -0.018127441, -0.03579712, 0.011329651, -0.026229858, -0.036468506, -0.0131073, -0.07397461, -0.005558014, 0.076538086, 0.024108887, 0.013641357, 0.023544312, -0.0015449524, -0.012893677, -0.047454834, 0.016448975, -0.0033473969, 0.015823364, -0.027786255, 0.011650085, 0.065979004, -0.034698486, 0.006954193, 0.052215576, 0.06414795, -0.025741577, -0.011909485, 0.020706177, 0.034088135, -0.0211792, 0.04067993, 0.0036506653, -0.025558472, -0.06311035, 0.01600647, -0.0008749962, 0.01335144, 0.008651733, -0.01600647, 0.028823853, 0.011299133, 0.021881104, 0.035614014, -0.016616821, -0.00067186356, 0.03152466, -0.0053520203, -0.019241333, -0.0069122314, 0.0206604, 0.012939453, 0.0135650635, 0.022628784, -0.0043144226, 0.0368042, -0.03704834, 0.013473511, -0.017868042, 0.00137043, -0.033050537, -0.01171875, -0.064819336, -0.00033259392, 0.007896423, 0.0048561096, -0.03387451, 0.012504578, 0.03173828, -0.025894165, -0.031311035, 0.015670776, 0.016860962, -0.018203735, 0.006263733, -0.053131104, 0.012557983, -0.026947021, -0.059631348, -0.049041748, -0.012550354, 0.030807495, 0.035980225, 0.015319824, -0.021133423, 0.023635864, 0.039764404, 0.06793213, 0.045196533, -0.022369385, -0.056365967, 0.0209198, -0.010131836, -0.025665283, 0.0063095093, -0.0024204254, -0.01499176, -0.045928955, 0.005378723, -0.0022220612, -0.008163452, -0.002861023, 0.032958984, -0.014968872, 0.05758667, -0.04156494, 0.035247803, 0.027770996, -0.00020599365, 0.025466919, 0.011734009, -0.036346436, -0.026824951, 0.013061523, 0.03604126, -0.00020051003, 0.018981934, 0.022201538, 0.012451172, -0.01687622, -0.0015602112, 0.027938843, 0.0066986084, -0.013183594, -0.0019416809, 0.022262573, -0.004295349, -0.030273438, 0.013809204, 0.0234375, 0.03466797, -0.031463623, 0.092163086, -0.043029785, 0.0026073456, 0.025482178, -0.0016946793, -0.0071411133, -0.025863647, 0.010940552, -0.0637207, -0.070495605, -0.021026611, 0.043395996, -0.016036987, -0.007408142, 0.009788513, 0.00008195639, 0.031402588, 0.0579834, 0.051971436, -0.028915405, -0.015625, -0.011703491, -0.017410278, -0.022003174, -0.06707764, 0.0082092285, -0.014671326, 0.028015137, -0.028549194, 0.039489746, -0.0690918, 0.022018433, 0.005695343, -0.005580902, 0.0066490173, -0.06500244, -0.00026249886, 0.036315918, -0.009437561, 0.021881104, 0.018661499, 0.01524353, 0.027053833, 0.051757812, -0.0019989014, 0.04647827, 0.029205322, -0.025344849, 0.0068855286, 0.0028247833, 0.032196045, 0.0052986145, 0.00349617, 0.01335907, -0.0004184246, -0.03765869, 0.031311035, 0.020202637, -0.04272461, 0.025024414, -0.045654297, 0.00970459, 0.010810852, 0.027023315, 0.011779785, -0.019821167, -0.024536133, -0.012748718, -0.010826111, -0.037963867, 0.01612854, -0.0090408325, 0.00623703, -0.029830933, 0.013259888, -0.048919678, 0.02482605, 0.020858765, -0.010948181, -0.014556885, 0.027664185, 0.01108551, -0.02166748, -0.014656067, -0.0028495789, 0.0022735596, 0.024002075, 0.034606934, -0.07092285, -0.0052833557, -0.00036525726, -0.042999268, -0.039978027, -0.0055122375, 0.010818481, -0.0035209656, -0.0012998581, -0.043792725, 0.01979065, 0.0039367676, 0.015609741, -0.00094127655, -0.010520935, 0.044158936, 0.018539429, 0.030792236, 0.008369446, 0.023864746, -0.0047340393, -0.0032100677, 0.008743286, -0.019561768, 0.035949707, -0.0017910004, 0.0008363724, 0.027648926, -0.04083252, 0.021728516, 0.016296387, 0.0020751953, -0.037719727, 0.013336182, 0.034057617, -0.006839752, -0.008110046, -0.016052246, 0.046569824, -0.020721436, -0.009086609, 0.002506256, -0.00030374527, -0.024642944, 0.05203247, -0.030715942, -0.030563354, -0.046081543, -0.04486084, -0.021972656, 0.012130737, 0.015357971, 0.017532349, 0.02633667, -0.06738281, 0.0033397675, -0.0035591125, -0.006816864, -0.0016365051, 0.0045051575, 0.0016355515, -0.022644043, 0.009117126, 0.016433716, 0.011558533, -0.016586304, 0.02482605, 0.0118255615, -0.026290894, 0.039276123, -0.045562744, 0.008956909, -0.0184021, -0.015945435, 0.04119873, -0.0037441254, -0.020889282, 0.013763428, -0.033447266, 0.061523438, 0.023345947, 0.03111267, 0.05517578, 0.036865234, 0.017120361, -0.0075912476, -0.011520386, -0.031051636, 0.025177002, -0.043151855, 0.003665924, -0.051879883, -0.021865845, -0.07885742, 0.017913818, 0.013542175, 0.032348633, 0.039093018, 0.0011177063, 0.028121948, 0.007297516, 0.042877197, 0.0084991455, 0.059753418, 0.04260254, 0.024414062, 0.021011353, -0.042236328, 0.0054779053, 0.040527344, -0.0017662048, 0.013519287, 0.0007686615, -0.027557373, 0.018295288, 0.01826477, 0.0010194778, -0.0067367554, -0.01576233, -0.037322998, 0.064819336, -0.002588272, 0.035339355, 0.06726074, 0.039123535, -0.008422852, -0.027679443, 0.013168335, -0.021820068, -0.040527344, 0.018615723, 0.02319336, -0.080444336, 0.038726807, -0.013671875, -0.016815186, -0.007797241, 0.053100586, 0.024032593, -0.050628662, -0.019119263, 0.019454956, 0.028915405, 0.013946533, 0.02368164, -0.03555298, -0.023590088, 0.036132812, 0.06011963, -0.037353516, 0.0034103394, 0.008522034, 0.019454956, -0.0011701584, 0.009521484, 0.019332886, 0.05392456, 0.006843567, 0.027648926, -0.0602417, 0.03024292, 0.004257202, -0.022247314, 0.0088272095, 0.026306152, -0.08538818, 0.007965088, 0.01776123, 0.04248047, 0.05441284, 0.07684326, 0.012718201, -0.0051994324, 0.0017786026, -0.052764893, 0.035949707, 0.021087646, -0.031341553, -0.0034446716, -0.025482178, -0.035888672, 0.040893555, -0.026260376, 0.08074951, -0.043395996, -0.0013036728, -0.018966675, 0.008117676, 0.024353027, -0.06738281, -0.0030708313, -0.035247803, -0.009597778, 0.01676941, 0.028366089, -0.0062446594, -0.00048279762, 0.031921387, 0.0107421875, 0.062805176, -0.009643555, -0.0047950745, -0.010673523, -0.08331299, -0.004802704, -0.045684814, 0.022384644, -0.020889282, -0.024551392, -0.027526855, 0.005760193, 0.009689331, -0.025650024, -0.01927185, -0.003112793, -0.024612427, -0.05392456, 0.018005371, 0.01612854, -0.018508911, 0.004886627, -0.016860962, 0.003446579, -0.022628784, -0.0039024353, 0.033172607, -0.04058838, -0.053222656, -0.0024166107, -0.04055786, 0.038604736, 0.022613525, -0.014122009, 0.007820129, 0.039916992, -0.03942871, -0.012557983, -0.016799927, 0.025878906, -0.015060425, -0.06530762, 0.0004324913, 0.028564453, 0.038513184, -0.034942627, -0.05328369, 0.025894165, 0.030670166, -0.017333984, 0.03488159, 0.0067825317, -0.007369995, 0.043823242, 0.036987305, 0.017333984, -0.043823242, -0.034088135, -0.0008573532, 0.06768799, 0.061767578, -0.01991272, 0.0011672974, 0.04171753, -0.023880005, 0.006210327, 0.0107421875, -0.024810791, 0.013572693, -0.0027198792, 0.050231934, -0.0011129379, 0.03186035, -0.008796692, 0.0013093948, -0.007091522, 0.0073242188, -0.015510559, 0.0033493042, -0.023910522, 0.034179688, -0.016738892, -0.009048462, 0.021697998, 0.02458191, 0.030029297, 0.033203125, -0.042022705, -0.015823364, 0.0049095154, -0.010276794, -0.012290955, -0.00076055527, 0.021102905, -0.020721436, 0.0005326271, -0.037384033, -0.045532227, -0.010421753, -0.05331421, 0.039245605, -0.016296387, 0.010444641, -0.0045051575, -0.0076942444, -0.011375427, 0.0018758774, 0.019927979, -0.039215088, -0.042999268, -0.045806885, 0.044647217, -0.010345459 ], "summary": [ 0.0024547577, -0.0013160706, -0.00096702576, -0.022018433, -0.027404785, 0.0054397583, -0.05105591, -0.051971436, -0.046203613, 0.008216858, -0.008132935, 0.01574707, -0.030334473, -0.035614014, 0.03942871, -0.05114746, 0.027694702, 0.0019302368, 0.003458023, -0.042938232, 0.0234375, -0.011734009, -0.014732361, 0.09552002, 0.006816864, 0.0014009476, -0.037078857, 0.012718201, 0.007598877, 0.039886475, 0.016189575, -0.04849243, 0.006340027, 0.036224365, -0.007286072, 0.025848389, -0.024841309, 0.03479004, 0.023452759, 0.011054993, 0.023666382, -0.008201599, 0.060668945, -0.015235901, 0.005531311, 0.025772095, 0.0020885468, -0.017791748, 0.0026016235, 0.062805176, 0.0032520294, 0.0049476624, -0.025924683, 0.09106445, -0.008529663, -0.019088745, 0.001909256, -0.01727295, 0.007598877, 0.05319214, 0.005695343, -0.0049324036, 0.000035703182, -0.04638672, -0.016067505, -0.035369873, 0.0121536255, 0.013206482, 0.055145264, -0.015319824, -0.019515991, 0.058288574, -0.006401062, 0.010032654, -0.04623413, -0.053955078, 0.06573486, -0.047180176, -0.026489258, 0.02609253, 0.034301758, 0.027175903, 0.015625, 0.022277832, -0.016921997, 0.01689148, -0.006793976, -0.026443481, -0.022018433, -0.00793457, -0.025756836, 0.021759033, -0.028244019, 0.0036621094, 0.0045166016, -0.0345459, -0.026855469, -0.041534424, 0.018661499, 0.007987976, 0.039154053, -0.062805176, 0.050872803, -0.023513794, -0.008369446, 0.026290894, -0.010765076, 0.0062789917, 0.014587402, 0.024765015, 0.00063705444, -0.04220581, -0.04559326, -0.047088623, -0.004108429, 0.056121826, -0.02357483, 0.021652222, 0.0041503906, 0.007045746, -0.008308411, 0.039642334, -0.03390503, 0.02734375, 0.008605957, 0.011276245, 0.016708374, -0.0029697418, 0.010047913, 0.000746727, -0.028381348, 0.010261536, 0.02168274, 0.0076179504, -0.006038666, -0.006126404, 0.059661865, 0.010498047, 0.04550171, -0.036376953, 0.056030273, -0.00040960312, -0.028930664, 0.042419434, 0.008728027, 0.021957397, 0.017181396, 0.021484375, -0.009506226, -0.0024032593, -0.0048446655, 0.019729614, 0.024902344, -0.012054443, -0.006187439, -0.05923462, -0.048980713, -0.018447876, 0.059814453, -0.0059661865, 0.0063438416, -0.0067634583, -0.018096924, 0.039215088, 0.019760132, 0.005176544, 0.01927185, 0.012626648, -0.0031261444, 0.029632568, -0.034729004, -0.002729416, -0.052764893, 0.0037059784, 0.008155823, 0.017074585, -0.021987915, 0.011627197, -0.0031147003, 0.012588501, 0.018630981, -0.017303467, -0.0035858154, 0.037994385, 0.030059814, -0.067871094, 0.010345459, 0.00051546097, 0.028945923, 0.033111572, -0.027740479, -0.018325806, -0.013092041, -0.028366089, -0.008926392, 0.04928589, -0.052764893, 0.03378296, -0.029144287, -0.015174866, -0.019729614, 0.021499634, -0.013748169, 0.00944519, -0.05429077, 0.011436462, -0.018493652, 0.040771484, -0.000852108, 0.035217285, 0.028793335, -0.0037899017, -0.04650879, 0.047668457, -0.0028095245, -0.05859375, 0.017547607, -0.05935669, -0.046142578, -0.009941101, -0.091430664, 0.06237793, -0.11260986, 0.04989624, 0.012832642, -0.03112793, 0.010765076, -0.024230957, 0.052856445, -0.020431519, 0.067871094, -0.022216797, -0.009567261, 0.006126404, 0.006023407, -0.0027656555, 0.0513916, -0.047698975, 0.032958984, 0.038604736, 0.016815186, 0.005306244, -0.020935059, 0.026123047, -0.037506104, -0.041870117, 0.0070877075, -0.00017595291, 0.006587982, 0.022201538, 0.02557373, -0.0036411285, 0.020858765, 0.028366089, 0.0041542053, 0.019821167, -0.007003784, 0.03152466, 0.0053863525, 0.010688782, -0.012702942, -0.0016698837, 0.027282715, -0.012794495, 0.023345947, -0.03274536, 0.002193451, 0.0096206665, -0.022735596, -0.031677246, 0.02406311, -0.008430481, 0.0049819946, -0.011230469, -0.0758667, 0.0031375885, -0.0074653625, 0.027267456, 0.023880005, -0.033935547, -0.014427185, -0.011940002, 0.033172607, -0.007041931, 0.020248413, 0.023712158, 0.038085938, -0.0043678284, 0.038757324, 0.042144775, 0.0770874, -0.015090942, -0.004917145, 0.0019311905, -0.05557251, -0.031829834, 0.020553589, 0.04269409, -0.01777649, 0.0077552795, -0.0027503967, 0.01474762, 0.0061035156, -0.024337769, 0.023605347, 0.01084137, -0.0025482178, 0.02784729, 0.036132812, 0.038360596, -0.038635254, 0.058013916, 0.020629883, 0.057556152, -0.033843994, -0.034576416, 0.004814148, 0.048675537, 0.017486572, 0.03161621, 0.0993042, -0.003025055, -0.0017786026, 0.022659302, -0.013656616, -0.04473877, 0.046081543, -0.020355225, 0.013725281, 0.017150879, -0.012001038, 0.028915405, -0.0090408325, 0.030029297, -0.010276794, 0.00062179565, -0.018844604, 0.0892334, 0.0067825317, -0.034332275, -0.0052452087, -0.03817749, 0.0037002563, 0.02609253, -0.010887146, -0.029632568, 0.011451721, -0.01751709, 0.010284424, 0.022415161, -0.00579834, 0.0021533966, -0.02998352, 0.025863647, -0.0023593903, -0.051513672, 0.044647217, 0.06121826, -0.0041046143, -0.012084961, 0.00944519, 0.006401062, -0.034362793, -0.07788086, 0.023513794, -0.022033691, -0.023803711, -0.010246277, -0.005672455, 0.04031372, -0.026397705, 0.01864624, -0.027557373, -0.013954163, -0.04498291, 0.03086853, 0.054748535, -0.0049476624, 0.016204834, 0.036010742, 0.016937256, 0.021728516, -0.011077881, 0.0155181885, 0.09954834, -0.012779236, 0.04562378, 0.07232666, 0.025802612, 0.00037431717, -0.05734253, -0.034240723, 0.0256958, -0.03866577, 0.01928711, 0.0019311905, -0.030578613, 0.023376465, -0.016021729, -0.03060913, 0.016860962, 0.011444092, -0.005130768, -0.0031719208, -0.016036987, 0.02708435, 0.0038871765, -0.015174866, 0.024414062, -0.0056915283, 0.031433105, -0.0513916, 0.011993408, -0.04901123, 0.0061302185, -0.023117065, 0.023345947, 0.021392822, -0.010421753, -0.029083252, -0.019424438, 0.043395996, 0.014717102, 0.0014324188, 0.059631348, 0.017227173, 0.023391724, -0.028503418, 0.0067367554, 0.016571045, 0.018157959, -0.022521973, -0.0211792, -0.025924683, -0.028427124, 0.018661499, 0.0021438599, 0.03439331, 0.011245728, -0.0058784485, -0.01184845, -0.040008545, -0.015640259, 0.040283203, 0.015548706, -0.01727295, -0.036376953, 0.004108429, 0.03451538, -0.03213501, -0.0045280457, -0.035247803, 0.07141113, 0.03274536, -0.010482788, 0.10443115, -0.021850586, 0.012390137, 0.03152466, 0.008239746, 0.018753052, 0.010444641, -0.05984497, -0.00046491623, 0.014381409, -0.024032593, -0.054016113, 0.029922485, -0.00030827522, -0.018936157, 0.024932861, 0.057128906, -0.014434814, -0.020767212, -0.002653122, -0.0020198822, 0.04547119, -0.0016241074, 0.0022506714, -0.026748657, -0.030303955, 0.008781433, -0.03491211, -0.026916504, -0.0011730194, -0.0126571655, -0.03643799, -0.029922485, 0.02760315, 0.024490356, 0.04196167, -0.031173706, 0.053741455, -0.020767212, -0.02998352, 0.009162903, -0.018310547, 0.0289917, -0.016937256, -0.074279785, 0.020812988, -0.011184692, 0.05166626, 0.04815674, -0.08642578, -0.00982666, 0.0692749, -0.008163452, 0.025817871, -0.042999268, 0.016723633, -0.022445679, 0.084106445, 0.039886475, -0.0101623535, -0.0019721985, 0.060150146, 0.02859497, -0.01033783, -0.017227173, 0.0340271, 0.018295288, 0.0124053955, 0.012435913, -0.015052795, 0.00057172775, -0.010070801, 0.004169464, 0.003736496, 0.022506714, 0.021911621, 0.020980835, 0.04046631, -0.0052108765, 0.0063476562, -0.022201538, -0.026351929, -0.0022850037, 0.03387451, 0.005756378, -0.031677246, -0.01473999, 0.010566711, 0.029586792, -0.0028324127, 0.048339844, 0.024414062, 0.078063965, -0.08270264, 0.061157227, -0.01134491, 0.0018968582, -0.010597229, -0.02381897, -0.018295288, 0.030380249, 0.020324707, -0.016983032, -0.0137786865, 0.032958984, -0.012718201, 0.0041503906, -0.008598328, 0.0031528473, 0.015403748, 0.025650024, -0.038391113, -0.056243896, -0.0054397583, 0.005455017, -0.049468994, -0.03466797, -0.04663086, -0.021362305, -0.009101868, 0.010261536, -0.008148193, 0.01914978, 0.008987427, 0.02709961, 0.026351929, 0.018096924, -0.023956299, -0.00008952618, 0.00642395, -0.0025177002, -0.01939392, -0.013191223, -0.015731812, 0.011878967, 0.009925842, -0.010772705, -0.0027370453, 0.021362305, 0.004589081, -0.02444458, 0.017959595, -0.05319214, 0.05065918, 0.0093307495, -0.012619019, 0.0003554821, -0.001326561, -0.004524231, 0.033447266, 0.0026779175, 0.034362793, -0.0004606247, 0.029403687, 0.0060806274, -0.039031982, -0.082092285, 0.016067505, 0.05706787, 0.007724762, -0.022399902, -0.05618286, 0.03125, 0.06958008, 0.02079773, 0.051696777, -0.0140686035, 0.008781433, 0.031066895, 0.0340271, -0.025939941, 0.007446289, 0.0048332214, -0.0055236816, -0.0068244934, -0.015609741, 0.0048561096, -0.05041504, -0.095336914, -0.0146102905, 0.11242676, -0.0031394958, -0.034362793, -0.03604126, -0.011375427, -0.0047912598, -0.0024490356, -0.015365601, -0.012573242, -0.021743774, -0.023803711, -0.019210815, -0.0043640137, -0.013595581, -0.017410278, 0.02381897, 0.026977539, -0.023925781, 0.03475952, 0.035858154, 0.03314209, -0.012710571, -0.02961731, -0.0069503784, -0.06378174, -0.05178833, -0.019500732, -0.023284912, 0.007865906, 0.076660156, -0.026138306, 0.03112793, 0.021881104, -0.0076828003, 0.013427734, -0.010726929, -0.02166748, -0.03375244, -0.021499634, 0.028945923, 0.027648926, 0.0008826256, 0.023117065, -0.0030002594, -0.04537964, 0.005996704, 0.017501831, -0.019180298, 0.015396118, -0.017837524, 0.052856445, -0.0033855438, 0.008430481, -0.0012865067, -0.023101807, -0.024749756, 0.0018901825, 0.0116119385, -0.034484863, 0.01423645, -0.006919861, 0.02748108, -0.0446167, -0.024978638, -0.06365967, 0.014312744, 0.011665344, 0.012779236, -0.0044517517, -0.021087646, -0.019073486, -0.027420044, 0.048095703, -0.023117065, -0.0036563873, 0.013900757, 0.0309906, -0.012969971, 0.012641907, 0.0022201538, -0.012931824, -0.005508423, -0.015144348, -0.012062073, 0.030838013, 0.002368927, -0.0013942719, 0.044189453, -0.028839111, 0.006526947, 0.01777649, 0.014320374, 0.02078247, 0.010749817, 0.023956299, -0.024215698, 0.042541504, -0.016479492, -0.012840271, 0.03878784, -0.056854248, 0.025360107, -0.0022621155, -0.007850647, -0.0038795471, -0.016036987, -0.0036525726, 0.009963989, 0.0033435822, -0.06262207, 0.023529053, 0.013496399, -0.118774414, -0.007865906, -0.04119873, 0.015686035, -0.003929138, -0.013267517, -0.025756836, 0.00497818, -0.025680542, 0.044006348, 0.0082473755, -0.014060974, -0.028442383, 0.005794525, 0.0056533813, -0.011711121, 0.0076522827, -0.013557434, 0.033203125, -0.011993408, -0.02583313, -0.013511658, -0.020309448, -0.017532349, 0.033233643, -0.012550354, -0.026245117, 0.023773193, -0.01676941, -0.0052337646, 0.00819397, 0.0059890747, 0.020614624, -0.014884949, 0.048095703, -0.009002686, 0.009155273, -0.024353027, 0.015930176, 0.013519287, 0.028213501, -0.015457153, 0.011482239, 0.019485474, 0.027359009, -0.007926941, -0.04473877, -0.03768921, -0.0007300377, 0.044281006, -0.013801575, -0.012756348, -0.0115356445, 0.024658203, 0.012641907, -0.091308594, -0.057006836, -0.06829834, -0.021392822, 0.039398193, -0.038909912, -0.019958496, 0.074645996, -0.02116394, 0.031097412, 0.082336426, -0.024932861, 0.047912598, 0.00082731247, 0.03213501, 0.011253357, -0.016540527, -0.0072669983, -0.000030398369, 0.020889282, 0.012413025, 0.016159058, -0.0066719055, 0.019317627, 0.03152466, -0.021347046, -0.034301758, -0.02015686, 0.05038452, -0.038238525, 0.0970459, 0.033569336, 0.028060913, 0.0496521, 0.03656006, 0.046783447, -0.061920166, 0.025222778, 0.005847931, 0.008079529, 0.027236938, -0.009567261, 0.00082302094, 0.039916992, 0.023620605, -0.023483276, 0.058776855, 0.087402344, -0.015144348, -0.0152282715, 0.051818848, -0.024673462, -0.013916016, 0.01838684, -0.0062026978, -0.029678345, -0.0040626526, 0.031433105, 0.011154175, -0.008224487, -0.011634827, -0.028060913, -0.018707275, 0.011428833, 0.04055786, -0.003698349, 0.07147217, 0.003227234, 0.013679504, -0.11102295, 0.028778076, -0.017547607, -0.015914917, -0.0049743652, 0.028579712, -0.041290283, 0.011352539, 0.0496521, 0.03717041, 0.04046631, 0.04925537, -0.01449585, 0.015289307, 0.037750244, -0.010009766, 0.012916565, -0.023406982, 0.006549835, -0.030029297, -0.01928711, -0.0068740845, 0.013282776, -0.017318726, 0.052337646, -0.051513672, -0.012535095, -0.06854248, 0.070739746, -0.07287598, -0.037322998, 0.010322571, -0.0770874, -0.027450562, 0.018417358, 0.011001587, -0.015281677, -0.013679504, -0.011138916, -0.0048103333, 0.012588501, 0.029144287, 0.06744385, -0.021987915, -0.029251099, 0.025756836, 0.005279541, 0.07421875, -0.04446411, -0.016143799, 0.00039672852, 0.017608643, 0.012214661, -0.044006348, -0.017578125, 0.000521183, 0.026351929, -0.049041748, -0.0003736019, 0.006717682, -0.022415161, 0.00073194504, 0.022979736, 0.0074653625, -0.024841309, 0.064575195, -0.0071372986, -0.0013113022, -0.021987915, 0.019836426, -0.045806885, 0.0064430237, -0.021530151, 0.0053482056, -0.025177002, 0.03277588, -0.046295166, -0.044952393, -0.00059080124, 0.016586304, -0.005508423, -0.06890869, 0.0049972534, 0.0077705383, 0.045440674, 0.029281616, -0.013168335, 0.058441162, -0.01651001, -0.0077590942, -0.020477295, 0.012908936, 0.027069092, -0.011421204, 0.066467285, -0.010406494, -0.039367676, -0.022445679, 0.00894165, 0.056732178, -0.003189087, -0.03353882, -0.028305054, -0.011192322, 0.0034122467, -0.01008606, 0.012039185, -0.017166138, -0.019989014, 0.007751465, 0.026184082, -0.001868248, -0.014015198, -0.0028209686, -0.017837524, 0.004627228, -0.023117065, -0.0035381317, 0.021591187, -0.03250122, -0.0073776245, 0.024261475, 0.06854248, -0.037384033, -0.026153564, 0.051483154, -0.03540039, -0.0035762787, 0.0017089844, 0.006084442, -0.0038452148, -0.009277344, 0.019241333, 0.045288086, -0.030715942, -0.003932953, -0.047912598, -0.018051147, -0.05947876, -0.032287598, 0.027023315, -0.00025367737, -0.008529663, 0.069885254, -0.03970337, 0.005783081, -0.0058898926, -0.021240234, -0.017623901, 0.0034446716, 0.0036621094, -0.032348633, 0.00687027 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.04599v6
Disparate Impact of Artificial Intelligence Bias in Ridehailing Economy's Price Discrimination Algorithms
Akshat Pandey, Aylin Caliskan
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG
Ridehailing applications that collect mobility data from individuals to inform smart city planning predict each trip's fare pricing with automated algorithms that rely on artificial intelligence (AI). This type of AI algorithm, namely a price discrimination algorithm, is widely used in the industry's black box systems for dynamic individualized pricing. Lacking transparency, studying such AI systems for fairness and disparate impact has not been possible without access to data used in generating the outcomes of price discrimination algorithms. Recently, in an effort to enhance transparency in city planning, the city of Chicago regulation mandated that transportation providers publish anonymized data on ridehailing. As a result, we present the first large-scale measurement of the disparate impact of price discrimination algorithms used by ridehailing applications. The application of random effects models from the meta-analysis literature combines the city-level effects of AI bias on fare pricing from census tract attributes, aggregated from the American Community Survey. An analysis of 100 million ridehailing samples from the city of Chicago indicates a significant disparate impact in fare pricing of neighborhoods due to AI bias learned from ridehailing utilization patterns associated with demographic attributes. Neighborhoods with larger non-white populations, higher poverty levels, younger residents, and high education levels are significantly associated with higher fare prices, with combined effect sizes, measured in Cohen's d, of -0.32, -0.28, 0.69, and 0.24 for each demographic, respectively. Further, our methods hold promise for identifying and addressing the sources of disparate impact in AI algorithms learning from datasets that contain U.S. geolocations.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.04599v6
2021-05-03T20:35:37
2020-06-08T13:51:03
{ "title": [ 0.032928467, 0.031677246, -0.02696228, -0.006965637, 0.013092041, -0.052612305, 0.05923462, -0.030014038, -0.01524353, 0.0625, -0.07635498, 0.008125305, 0.02571106, -0.006214142, -0.021392822, -0.032562256, -0.0035552979, 0.03265381, 0.01965332, -0.014404297, -0.002779007, -0.018997192, 0.026565552, 0.00026607513, 0.020645142, -0.012390137, -0.038604736, -0.016845703, 0.0017757416, -0.03363037, 0.0034236908, 0.009979248, 0.002981186, 0.02166748, 0.011169434, 0.057769775, -0.04171753, 0.051239014, 0.037353516, -0.021347046, 0.033599854, -0.012321472, -0.058776855, 0.0047683716, -0.035003662, -0.020584106, -0.015037537, 0.00081539154, 0.012954712, -0.015197754, 0.004722595, 0.018814087, 0.01449585, 0.06567383, -0.021728516, -0.0012130737, -0.030929565, 0.008636475, 0.013092041, -0.015220642, 0.00034332275, 0.0119018555, 0.04397583, 0.016815186, -0.035217285, -0.04058838, -0.011291504, 0.01713562, 0.0635376, -0.0039520264, 0.01638794, 0.044006348, -0.020004272, 0.0345459, -0.06451416, -0.04876709, 0.05706787, 0.0027542114, 0.014678955, 0.012283325, 0.0024356842, -0.0009069443, -0.020431519, -0.0013389587, -0.03552246, -0.018051147, -0.011680603, -0.008171082, -0.03375244, -0.048614502, -0.0058288574, -0.005329132, -0.0670166, 0.03277588, -0.0066452026, -0.04663086, 0.017044067, 0.0793457, -0.004009247, -0.0158844, -0.050811768, 0.009063721, -0.0602417, -0.025024414, 0.034698486, -0.011421204, -0.0034065247, 0.008102417, 0.04864502, 0.012138367, -0.037200928, 0.075927734, -0.0017690659, -0.01965332, 0.0019607544, -0.022125244, -0.03616333, 0.037841797, 0.0036640167, 0.0023784637, -0.0030708313, 0.0028648376, 0.025619507, -0.0007510185, 0.012481689, 0.0046958923, -0.021377563, -0.031677246, 0.009918213, 0.03982544, -0.03479004, 0.035736084, -0.042236328, -0.06109619, -0.03543091, -0.0055236816, 0.020874023, -0.032318115, -0.007385254, 0.0010185242, 0.026031494, -0.01184082, 0.012817383, 0.020477295, -0.021865845, 0.018432617, 0.006454468, 0.00080633163, 0.032836914, -0.02520752, -0.054534912, -0.0052375793, 0.011962891, 0.012306213, 0.012008667, 0.007843018, -0.034362793, 0.0034732819, 0.012832642, 0.0047683716, 0.03829956, -0.0017824173, -0.029312134, 0.01626587, 0.020767212, 0.0048179626, 0.0006952286, 0.030059814, -0.004562378, -0.0011386871, -0.03744507, 0.022369385, -0.010887146, -0.019119263, 0.00056123734, 0.003129959, -0.0023937225, -0.0013246536, 0.017623901, -0.041259766, -0.018508911, -0.017089844, 0.008285522, 0.020721436, -0.08947754, 0.026565552, -0.0010976791, 0.077941895, 0.03567505, 0.006954193, 0.033843994, -0.0031642914, -0.05517578, -0.005760193, -0.030380249, 0.01902771, -0.038848877, 0.012878418, -0.015487671, 0.012557983, -0.025436401, 0.04046631, -0.0368042, 0.0385437, -0.014076233, -0.019515991, 0.013885498, 0.015914917, -0.054351807, 0.042297363, 0.047302246, -0.02444458, -0.02822876, 0.03817749, 0.033813477, -0.05130005, -0.0028877258, -0.032958984, -0.00843811, -0.03967285, 0.010444641, 0.008918762, 0.0107421875, 0.05026245, -0.0034332275, 0.045043945, -0.0061035156, 0.017089844, 0.1005249, 0.019882202, 0.15673828, -0.04623413, 0.019989014, 0.013908386, -0.05529785, -0.011871338, -0.033691406, -0.017333984, -0.002161026, 0.044158936, 0.0184021, -0.03918457, 0.0040740967, 0.025344849, 0.005039215, -0.043823242, 0.0051994324, -0.0024585724, 0.030944824, 0.0135650635, 0.05645752, -0.023605347, 0.041900635, 0.040374756, 0.030410767, 0.029312134, -0.043518066, 0.006088257, -0.04058838, 0.026763916, 0.0030727386, 0.030975342, 0.045776367, -0.008735657, -0.01184082, -0.029769897, -0.03652954, -0.0020008087, -0.028305054, -0.017669678, 0.04437256, 0.0025749207, -0.0070610046, -0.026260376, -0.044921875, -0.04348755, -0.057525635, 0.052490234, -0.017303467, -0.05831909, -0.0023117065, 0.03677368, 0.024597168, -0.0029907227, 0.0054512024, 0.0015716553, 0.019454956, 0.014701843, -0.070373535, -0.05078125, -0.010101318, 0.03652954, -0.03173828, 0.0041999817, 0.02607727, -0.021102905, -0.00034832954, 0.121032715, -0.03982544, 0.026550293, -0.12072754, -0.021865845, 0.0050582886, -0.017456055, 0.016021729, 0.0022735596, 0.038360596, -0.012031555, -0.0037937164, 0.036468506, -0.101501465, -0.02204895, 0.00002682209, -0.05795288, 0.01826477, -0.007671356, -0.016571045, -0.008773804, -0.03253174, 0.009460449, 0.057128906, -0.00086688995, -0.00818634, -0.039215088, -0.00724411, -0.035369873, -0.030914307, -0.019241333, 0.008430481, 0.0023727417, 0.01033783, -0.0030937195, -0.070617676, -0.015083313, 0.023651123, 0.027893066, 0.0036640167, 0.051452637, 0.01260376, -0.04019165, 0.004272461, 0.015701294, -0.020996094, -0.004470825, 0.029693604, -0.02305603, -0.0056991577, 0.0031738281, -0.009315491, 0.020874023, -0.0068130493, -0.024551392, -0.010871887, -0.024368286, 0.03604126, -0.023895264, -0.006248474, -0.018844604, 0.019439697, -0.048431396, 0.036621094, 0.024841309, -0.0028953552, -0.034362793, 0.0033035278, -0.061431885, -0.015060425, -0.014175415, -0.034088135, -0.025009155, -0.056671143, -0.021118164, 0.02861023, 0.00066185, -0.024230957, 0.025939941, -0.034179688, -0.05456543, 0.016906738, -0.034423828, 0.017700195, -0.01335144, 0.036590576, -0.0022335052, 0.064575195, 0.01146698, -0.040374756, -0.021957397, 0.014411926, -0.00048971176, -0.011123657, -0.0010957718, -0.04812622, -0.008323669, 0.012138367, -0.005542755, -0.0099487305, 0.03201294, -0.070617676, 0.006591797, 0.017150879, -0.015586853, -0.014541626, 0.023788452, -0.059143066, 0.02532959, -0.016601562, 0.0024852753, 0.028259277, 0.01586914, 0.00014853477, 0.006374359, 0.029647827, -0.014541626, 0.011398315, -0.039154053, -0.03086853, 0.0056991577, -0.004550934, -0.022064209, 0.008758545, -0.0028686523, -0.016098022, -0.010818481, -0.0018291473, 0.038330078, 0.031677246, -0.009002686, -0.0065193176, 0.031677246, 0.033996582, -0.012390137, -0.012382507, -0.05606079, -0.014732361, 0.004447937, -0.021347046, 0.052093506, -0.01461792, 0.033172607, -0.09466553, -0.012252808, 0.023452759, 0.0234375, 0.013183594, -0.0073165894, -0.020950317, -0.07409668, -0.011558533, -0.005344391, -0.018600464, 0.016174316, -0.013900757, 0.015914917, -0.025314331, 0.028549194, 0.021713257, 0.05609131, -0.010627747, 0.02558899, 0.019256592, -0.014884949, -0.021087646, 0.007171631, -0.019729614, -0.013534546, 0.060546875, -0.0019798279, -0.03161621, 0.005393982, -0.0181427, 0.012649536, -0.006298065, -0.013771057, -0.004009247, -0.037475586, -0.015602112, 0.03805542, -0.016281128, -0.013404846, 0.016967773, 0.010398865, 0.048339844, -0.054870605, -0.016342163, 0.0287323, -0.08380127, -0.05041504, 0.0138549805, -0.007133484, -0.013015747, 0.007980347, 0.053863525, -0.055389404, 0.009780884, 0.009414673, -0.003227234, 0.012176514, 0.024093628, -0.040374756, -0.027740479, 0.03604126, -0.009017944, -0.020050049, 0.022247314, 0.007068634, -0.010650635, -0.0021476746, 0.038513184, 0.0262146, 0.00390625, -0.008331299, -0.022109985, 0.030944824, -0.043701172, 0.051239014, -0.0146102905, -0.03756714, -0.0041122437, 0.027389526, 0.026824951, 0.030136108, -0.018249512, 0.050445557, 0.040161133, -0.02784729, -0.06286621, -0.017105103, 0.0044670105, -0.06341553, 0.039001465, -0.021972656, 0.02468872, 0.06561279, -0.01828003, 0.07110596, 0.001791954, 0.01612854, 0.014640808, -0.028961182, -0.015991211, -0.008460999, 0.008338928, -0.007949829, -0.018814087, -0.009941101, -0.039733887, 0.048736572, -0.010108948, 0.007259369, 0.011940002, 0.01789856, -0.026062012, -0.002752304, -0.03643799, -0.024459839, -0.07330322, 0.022155762, 0.015670776, 0.02305603, 0.049346924, 0.0022010803, -0.031234741, -0.023712158, 0.013847351, -0.00088739395, -0.003419876, -0.06109619, -0.016937256, -0.026168823, -0.08300781, -0.06072998, -0.034729004, 0.034240723, -0.013252258, 0.0025806427, 0.03060913, 0.033416748, 0.03048706, 0.009017944, 0.005722046, -0.0129852295, -0.00024294853, 0.049591064, -0.0435791, -0.0116119385, 0.0069618225, -0.02923584, -0.038146973, -0.04095459, 0.034240723, 0.0035476685, -0.037902832, -0.05883789, 0.038146973, 0.01713562, 0.026550293, 0.012817383, 0.014945984, 0.022827148, 0.023223877, -0.0049362183, 0.0068473816, -0.044555664, -0.006290436, -0.018554688, 0.031921387, -0.025650024, 0.032806396, 0.033233643, -0.00038909912, -0.022720337, -0.030563354, 0.035980225, -0.005592346, 0.0020751953, -0.026367188, 0.055389404, 0.019577026, -0.02848816, 0.025985718, 0.001405716, 0.020370483, 0.004135132, 0.0034313202, -0.06756592, -0.011192322, -0.010444641, 0.0019521713, 0.027877808, 0.011764526, 0.025817871, -0.024139404, 0.0042381287, 0.02520752, -0.014144897, -0.017364502, -0.015731812, -0.010063171, -0.0015668869, 0.027694702, 0.0211792, 0.005947113, -0.022079468, 0.028793335, -0.0051002502, 0.0020828247, 0.010894775, -0.03643799, -0.0030441284, -0.018585205, 0.016159058, -0.027191162, 0.03137207, 0.004081726, -0.02822876, -0.0002539158, -0.027130127, 0.03515625, -0.048614502, 0.00091934204, 0.04043579, -0.041778564, 0.017120361, -0.01083374, 0.014831543, 0.059387207, 0.03753662, 0.004749298, -0.035705566, 0.016830444, -0.012298584, 0.053833008, 0.017440796, 0.055145264, 0.01890564, -0.0069465637, 0.008735657, 0.010520935, -0.043395996, 0.035186768, 0.030075073, -0.0020542145, 0.008460999, -0.032318115, 0.04095459, -0.0032444, 0.007434845, 0.008918762, -0.034729004, -0.013008118, 0.022262573, -0.024734497, 0.01612854, -0.007610321, -0.019760132, -0.027313232, -0.07446289, 0.00945282, 0.014274597, 0.014129639, -0.040496826, 0.038024902, -0.043060303, 0.03338623, -0.001613617, -0.06329346, 0.0039367676, 0.029556274, 0.016647339, 0.048706055, 0.02330017, -0.061431885, -0.022094727, 0.016433716, -0.05407715, -0.046142578, 0.0077056885, -0.0069618225, -0.002254486, -0.015007019, -0.055755615, -0.019439697, 0.0007696152, 0.025390625, -0.004119873, -0.0231781, 0.0104599, 0.0021705627, 0.045928955, 0.032196045, 0.017196655, 0.040130615, 0.0027332306, 0.01285553, -0.0390625, 0.01940918, 0.030288696, 0.033599854, -0.027114868, -0.07470703, 0.00831604, 0.032440186, 0.0236969, -0.008575439, 0.019485474, 0.01939392, -0.029266357, 0.015602112, 0.03173828, 0.07702637, -0.055755615, -0.062805176, -0.02784729, -0.02041626, -0.042175293, 0.05215454, 0.028579712, -0.052947998, -0.024230957, -0.01638794, -0.022445679, -0.008178711, 0.011238098, -0.012237549, 0.030700684, -0.048583984, -0.04324341, -0.059509277, -0.006511688, -0.006008148, 0.03982544, -0.019851685, -0.012939453, 0.0030288696, -0.044006348, 0.04244995, -0.007865906, 0.0067825317, -0.0073623657, -0.025039673, -0.013511658, -0.07647705, 0.016189575, -0.024124146, 0.024337769, 0.0026798248, 0.02279663, -0.055603027, -0.023590088, -0.0124053955, 0.07299805, -0.010360718, 0.03390503, 0.023727417, 0.03652954, -0.003479004, 0.00037026405, 0.05203247, -0.00818634, 0.0005021095, -0.04953003, -0.015899658, -0.034484863, -0.014801025, -0.07965088, 0.019683838, -0.013595581, 0.030075073, 0.0011005402, 0.01574707, 0.0284729, 0.0049819946, 0.0033512115, -0.032440186, 0.05227661, 0.0016040802, 0.0023517609, -0.005680084, -0.034820557, -0.0013580322, 0.025177002, -0.017837524, 0.052246094, 0.012962341, 0.008712769, -0.0027122498, -0.04156494, 0.030029297, -0.020004272, -0.009254456, 0.008964539, 0.046691895, -0.0042877197, 0.047027588, 0.059539795, 0.015357971, -0.03479004, -0.017669678, 0.0030441284, 0.04916382, -0.041107178, 0.03387451, 0.06124878, -0.022384644, 0.034973145, -0.024093628, -0.06536865, 0.019378662, 0.018463135, 0.021011353, -0.019332886, -0.051208496, 0.018844604, 0.024719238, 0.066589355, 0.020401001, -0.039520264, -0.041137695, 0.0024700165, -0.015914917, -0.024459839, -0.007911682, 0.03366089, 0.044799805, 0.02760315, 0.020935059, -0.000500679, 0.005962372, 0.008140564, 0.033843994, 0.0054855347, 0.054595947, -0.03137207, -0.040771484, 0.0063552856, 0.0062713623, -0.049713135, 0.00006771088, 0.026184082, 0.029312134, 0.01802063, 0.0519104, -0.0015411377, 0.0010757446, -0.008766174, 0.01423645, 0.041931152, 0.0625, -0.0098724365, 0.020141602, -0.005241394, -0.031311035, 0.052490234, 0.005012512, 0.072631836, 0.0035572052, 0.007068634, -0.030349731, -0.00035738945, -0.005241394, -0.029937744, -0.005001068, -0.022491455, 0.02532959, -0.013427734, -0.03289795, -0.056152344, -0.011558533, -0.00970459, 0.048858643, 0.018798828, 0.0037403107, 0.047973633, -0.032104492, -0.023498535, -0.024505615, -0.0019683838, 0.027069092, 0.02267456, -0.058776855, -0.050567627, 0.022659302, 0.034606934, 0.032684326, -0.013496399, 0.038909912, -0.027069092, 0.007194519, -0.007282257, 0.002527237, -0.015205383, -0.003929138, 0.013511658, 0.015686035, -0.01600647, 0.014320374, 0.012008667, 0.0025291443, -0.06738281, -0.007255554, -0.045898438, -0.024459839, -0.0035820007, -0.043548584, -0.0077552795, -0.007194519, -0.03668213, -0.03616333, 0.008560181, 0.054504395, -0.03656006, -0.02243042, -0.039764404, 0.025039673, 0.030975342, -0.05404663, -0.066467285, 0.0040245056, 0.08734131, -0.016082764, -0.017684937, 0.034088135, -0.010322571, -0.036743164, -0.006351471, -0.023208618, 0.005794525, -0.007446289, -0.010223389, 0.047912598, 0.017166138, -0.044403076, 0.02519226, 0.009880066, -0.025848389, -0.002456665, 0.035095215, -0.006099701, 0.006477356, 0.00749588, 0.035064697, -0.021850586, -0.038330078, 0.031677246, 0.024490356, -0.016586304, 0.013969421, -0.016708374, 0.00592041, 0.0053634644, 0.026367188, -0.020202637, -0.04559326, 0.047454834, 0.05130005, -0.0031223297, 0.043701172, 0.010643005, -0.012702942, -0.02355957, -0.0041007996, 0.024597168, -0.0027751923, 0.0015487671, -0.0028209686, 0.012077332, -0.048461914, -0.02519226, 0.049041748, -0.008529663, 0.0071144104, -0.07244873, 0.03768921, -0.05709839, -0.018569946, 0.024734497, 0.02406311, 0.041503906, 0.014198303, -0.01953125, -0.05206299, 0.01713562, -0.0149002075 ], "summary": [ 0.038513184, 0.026153564, 0.0053710938, -0.0033359528, 0.027755737, -0.04638672, 0.051605225, -0.04260254, 0.016433716, 0.057128906, -0.07104492, 0.028839111, 0.0146484375, 0.0074386597, -0.031204224, -0.022888184, 0.012489319, 0.032287598, 0.0289917, -0.022201538, -0.0146102905, -0.017730713, 0.008781433, 0.010902405, 0.007007599, -0.0016975403, -0.0024700165, 0.018341064, -0.027282715, -0.0066070557, 0.0056991577, 0.0053749084, -0.0027828217, 0.028274536, 0.0056419373, 0.030395508, -0.026062012, 0.03604126, 0.024475098, 0.004535675, 0.06402588, -0.037841797, -0.036743164, -0.009315491, -0.019897461, -0.0017433167, 0.047790527, -0.0012407303, 0.011428833, -0.033416748, 0.026763916, 0.050689697, 0.03387451, 0.010772705, -0.019515991, 0.012565613, 0.013160706, -0.023071289, 0.0041236877, -0.028961182, -0.0128479, 0.00024187565, 0.04421997, 0.034729004, -0.057159424, -0.019729614, 0.0368042, 0.00548172, 0.018966675, -0.048675537, 0.018554688, 0.042175293, -0.010536194, 0.009742737, -0.055267334, -0.008773804, 0.06274414, -0.011405945, -0.018341064, 0.013946533, 0.017990112, 0.0017681122, -0.039520264, 0.024658203, -0.04623413, -0.004184723, -0.004310608, -0.02822876, -0.032836914, -0.011528015, -0.018051147, -0.028015137, -0.06555176, 0.033172607, 0.036712646, -0.04498291, 0.0033016205, 0.04296875, -0.020645142, -0.005470276, -0.01600647, -0.006439209, -0.01449585, -0.025360107, 0.017425537, 0.004245758, -0.0103302, -0.009719849, 0.020889282, 0.0132751465, -0.025726318, 0.037475586, 0.016555786, 0.0099105835, -0.05319214, -0.037200928, -0.022216797, 0.013328552, 0.009223938, -0.013710022, -0.02230835, 0.0079422, 0.002565384, 0.020202637, 0.02784729, 0.03010559, 0.004142761, -0.027999878, -0.0028247833, 0.044891357, -0.013595581, -0.02230835, -0.026641846, 0.0026550293, -0.020263672, -0.02520752, 0.008979797, -0.023864746, 0.0020980835, 0.0006914139, 0.039642334, -0.0234375, 0.0012454987, 0.03250122, -0.0069007874, 0.024978638, -0.01512146, -0.00021111965, 0.03768921, -0.0009188652, -0.02067566, -0.027816772, 0.056793213, 0.007106781, -0.040161133, 0.00031280518, -0.017044067, 0.0019340515, -0.041625977, -0.028259277, 0.026916504, -0.0032844543, -0.0037670135, 0.038909912, 0.028884888, 0.011627197, 0.005332947, 0.015014648, 0.004558563, -0.045318604, -0.0027561188, 0.035217285, -0.00059223175, -0.022827148, 0.010276794, 0.005748749, 0.00065660477, 0.035736084, 0.022369385, -0.06286621, -0.031982422, -0.036346436, 0.046905518, 0.005592346, -0.08734131, 0.068847656, 0.025024414, 0.1361084, -0.0009975433, 0.0054855347, 0.0574646, 0.008262634, -0.05987549, -0.0072784424, 0.012512207, 0.030319214, -0.054595947, -0.0066947937, 0.0009059906, -0.004673004, 0.051635742, -0.010215759, -0.0023078918, -0.030548096, -0.060302734, -0.02619934, -0.0044403076, 0.019973755, -0.08355713, 0.014060974, 0.04864502, -0.040100098, -0.055664062, 0.111206055, 0.08166504, -0.020187378, 0.031341553, -0.020706177, 0.014373779, -0.049316406, 0.034942627, 0.035888672, 0.016143799, 0.07562256, -0.032409668, -0.0009665489, -0.002691269, 0.011276245, 0.056549072, -0.017486572, 0.1348877, -0.024475098, -0.0074501038, 0.033355713, -0.022537231, -0.010215759, -0.031188965, -0.025436401, 0.017227173, 0.027862549, 0.019088745, -0.022964478, -0.023880005, 0.016845703, -0.033233643, -0.03982544, -0.0063476562, 0.000098109245, -0.017456055, 0.0035648346, 0.0284729, -0.014389038, 0.008323669, 0.0042762756, -0.0045166016, 0.012550354, -0.023254395, -0.015914917, -0.0062713623, 0.014892578, 0.005744934, -0.018447876, -0.0013284683, -0.014289856, 0.0102005005, -0.05770874, -0.0044403076, -0.0044441223, 0.0033912659, -0.0715332, 0.014915466, -0.008636475, -0.008811951, -0.05822754, -0.03527832, -0.030548096, -0.017547607, 0.026992798, -0.00522995, -0.056488037, 0.006008148, 0.025970459, -0.045684814, -0.0012159348, 0.014564514, -0.019424438, -0.01739502, 0.033477783, -0.00881958, -0.03225708, -0.025344849, 0.03225708, -0.04638672, 0.050628662, 0.009841919, -0.032440186, -0.051361084, 0.13220215, -0.043304443, 0.045898438, -0.08319092, 0.0012388229, 0.032470703, -0.043701172, 0.009353638, 0.015197754, 0.02357483, 0.010765076, 0.012184143, -0.02520752, -0.027572632, -0.021331787, 0.0012302399, -0.040924072, -0.0082092285, -0.001540184, -0.041809082, -0.0072135925, -0.016906738, 0.04714966, 0.05215454, -0.023132324, 0.006801605, -0.01576233, -0.015380859, -0.022705078, 0.011161804, -0.0024909973, 0.0074310303, -0.00014555454, -0.0146865845, -0.012718201, -0.015388489, 0.014450073, -0.003250122, -0.016693115, 0.009727478, 0.051574707, -0.0006084442, -0.028198242, 0.016159058, 0.013954163, 0.012916565, 0.023452759, -0.009529114, 0.007835388, -0.0069236755, 0.00067710876, -0.036621094, 0.029693604, -0.013420105, -0.019241333, -0.023147583, -0.012718201, 0.019195557, -0.009315491, 0.0048103333, -0.046905518, 0.0107040405, -0.06726074, 0.060302734, 0.025405884, 0.0036811829, -0.0680542, -0.021575928, -0.04647827, 0.013748169, -0.03463745, -0.012031555, -0.012702942, -0.052612305, -0.014625549, 0.04812622, -0.017410278, 0.015197754, 0.02911377, 0.02645874, -0.017990112, 0.04522705, 0.018981934, 0.037261963, 0.030426025, 0.02532959, 0.0065727234, 0.07208252, 0.0028648376, -0.03845215, -0.0002465248, 0.0124435425, 0.009727478, -0.019683838, -0.017547607, -0.035064697, -0.016586304, 0.0084991455, -0.0067214966, 0.018981934, 0.06994629, -0.04586792, -0.018814087, 0.003501892, 0.00274086, -0.0066375732, 0.0040397644, -0.058502197, 0.033325195, -0.036224365, -0.002998352, 0.03527832, -0.003414154, 0.02267456, 0.010864258, 0.017074585, -0.00076675415, -0.0031490326, -0.03567505, 0.015808105, -0.0026874542, -0.02355957, -0.013130188, 0.025650024, -0.0026988983, 0.014373779, 0.0038642883, 0.040283203, 0.024505615, 0.03274536, -0.022705078, -0.018844604, 0.04244995, 0.049682617, -0.020706177, -0.0055236816, -0.0019779205, -0.010887146, 0.01838684, -0.013549805, -0.010673523, 0.018234253, -0.03173828, -0.07269287, -0.015716553, 0.002632141, -0.0056877136, -0.011955261, -0.0023860931, -0.0022296906, -0.0670166, 0.02420044, -0.012001038, -0.007835388, 0.011604309, 0.039001465, 0.015670776, -0.031402588, 0.0042381287, 0.030731201, 0.035491943, 0.025680542, 0.0368042, 0.02279663, 0.006324768, -0.019882202, 0.009338379, 0.026550293, -0.0030784607, 0.011756897, 0.0003118515, -0.02407837, 0.012161255, 0.021255493, -0.030685425, 0.0010948181, -0.022842407, 0.0063705444, -0.0501709, 0.015075684, 0.023040771, 0.002368927, -0.032592773, 0.008300781, 0.0045051575, 0.06121826, -0.08459473, -0.027648926, 0.025680542, -0.10656738, -0.0597229, 0.0058403015, 0.05718994, 0.037261963, 0.018127441, 0.068603516, 0.0034561157, 0.0112838745, 0.0048294067, -0.018325806, 0.047576904, 0.0110321045, -0.030883789, -0.018188477, -0.0056266785, 0.031051636, 0.011222839, -0.017608643, 0.024536133, 0.053863525, 0.008476257, 0.022476196, 0.00021123886, 0.04525757, -0.024627686, -0.012649536, 0.026794434, -0.04107666, 0.021514893, -0.0018606186, -0.012809753, -0.009841919, 0.013336182, 0.029769897, 0.056121826, -0.017349243, 0.021240234, 0.028442383, -0.01727295, -0.041412354, 0.0016460419, -0.018081665, -0.031829834, 0.035125732, -0.017486572, 0.0096206665, 0.027862549, 0.004917145, 0.040130615, -0.013839722, -0.013313293, 0.033477783, 0.013648987, 0.00020205975, 0.030426025, -0.0030403137, 0.025634766, -0.022201538, -0.006729126, -0.052856445, 0.0056419373, -0.00945282, -0.016647339, -0.0027484894, -0.005744934, -0.0028476715, -0.014801025, -0.022628784, 0.0034503937, -0.03253174, 0.011352539, 0.0063095093, 0.03881836, 0.00029563904, -0.037506104, 0.016082764, 0.000051498413, 0.024169922, 0.036224365, -0.00048184395, -0.04550171, -0.01713562, -0.00969696, -0.055755615, -0.03427124, 0.0059432983, 0.015838623, -0.025878906, -0.0037193298, 0.038604736, 0.021347046, 0.019424438, 0.0075149536, -0.02166748, 0.0075531006, 0.015312195, 0.040649414, -0.06524658, 0.030151367, 0.028213501, -0.036987305, -0.053619385, -0.0036697388, 0.045074463, 0.016311646, -0.052825928, -0.046844482, 0.03062439, 0.024780273, 0.043823242, 0.050323486, 0.04736328, 0.022949219, 0.033233643, -0.041290283, 0.009017944, -0.020233154, 0.003982544, -0.076049805, -0.02558899, -0.011268616, 0.014984131, 0.04031372, -0.034606934, -0.034057617, 0.01449585, 0.003019333, 0.046295166, -0.0034599304, -0.02809143, 0.047088623, 0.113342285, 0.007091522, 0.0680542, 0.03186035, 0.016296387, 0.07556152, -0.021911621, -0.015357971, -0.026428223, -0.018051147, -0.021011353, 0.01776123, -0.004470825, 0.009361267, -0.030319214, -0.017211914, 0.0052337646, 0.002401352, -0.00970459, -0.029708862, -0.025405884, 0.0063171387, 0.029022217, -0.012321472, -0.030075073, -0.036468506, 0.006832123, -0.025177002, -0.013389587, 0.03781128, -0.018844604, -0.032440186, 0.0059051514, -0.0031700134, -0.019744873, 0.018066406, 0.010414124, -0.042633057, 0.0045700073, -0.043151855, 0.02796936, -0.057159424, -0.054351807, -0.023101807, -0.06124878, -0.010864258, 0.01260376, -0.009651184, 0.059020996, 0.02029419, 0.00919342, -0.02949524, -0.006389618, 0.0023651123, 0.04385376, -0.008453369, 0.013977051, 0.041290283, -0.026306152, 0.016067505, 0.005176544, -0.0021190643, 0.0059776306, 0.009429932, 0.01626587, -0.01411438, -0.015037537, 0.026504517, 0.009300232, 0.02998352, 0.0129852295, 0.007648468, 0.008598328, 0.018585205, 0.0129776, 0.0048561096, 0.002418518, 0.0054016113, 0.005493164, -0.05090332, -0.034057617, -0.028961182, -0.005191803, -0.0103302, 0.049835205, 0.0023708344, 0.0034618378, 0.0043525696, -0.035491943, -0.017822266, 0.01777649, 0.027282715, -0.0024528503, -0.0020542145, -0.037109375, 0.00333786, -0.0008945465, -0.058013916, -0.10772705, -0.022994995, -0.039489746, 0.032684326, 0.013313293, -0.021362305, 0.051361084, -0.0064964294, 0.039367676, -0.030578613, 0.04837036, 0.029556274, 0.014709473, 0.034942627, 0.048034668, -0.00440979, -0.018630981, 0.024291992, 0.026123047, -0.006565094, 0.0069236755, 0.024536133, 0.049621582, -0.045410156, -0.080200195, 0.0048675537, 0.037597656, 0.047790527, -0.007610321, -0.017456055, 0.0058555603, -0.041870117, 0.012397766, 0.0049743652, 0.048187256, -0.024902344, -0.029953003, -0.013130188, -0.0057373047, -0.02607727, 0.04812622, 0.020629883, -0.035217285, -0.034118652, 0.0029315948, 0.001083374, -0.029205322, -0.00047898293, -0.024414062, 0.031921387, -0.028152466, -0.05758667, -0.048339844, -0.040985107, -0.001036644, 0.051818848, -0.00068950653, -0.012908936, 0.013954163, -0.09729004, 0.026412964, 0.008155823, -0.024612427, -0.02684021, -0.040985107, 0.03338623, -0.034301758, 0.025482178, 0.0143966675, 0.03656006, -0.009803772, 0.007331848, -0.039886475, -0.062194824, 0.017700195, 0.03805542, -0.006855011, 0.013305664, 0.002363205, 0.026931763, 0.0052452087, -0.007873535, 0.02532959, -0.013404846, 0.0143966675, -0.024337769, -0.07519531, -0.060791016, -0.051879883, 0.012908936, 0.017654419, -0.042907715, -0.009857178, 0.033966064, -0.0020484924, 0.03201294, 0.030914307, -0.029769897, -0.03982544, 0.013931274, -0.008346558, 0.005168915, -0.0044517517, -0.026641846, 0.005065918, 0.02760315, 0.010871887, 0.025802612, 0.00042295456, 0.024765015, 0.015380859, -0.049102783, 0.00034832954, -0.046966553, -0.0011920929, -0.02079773, 0.07757568, -0.0069122314, 0.04916382, 0.07537842, -0.017089844, 0.07507324, -0.08807373, -0.007209778, 0.03768921, -0.028961182, 0.034606934, -0.00013411045, 0.026107788, 0.013442993, -0.0068092346, -0.02607727, 0.06451416, -0.034606934, 0.048919678, -0.06060791, -0.08874512, -0.0022239685, 0.04284668, -0.01184082, 0.027816772, -0.031204224, -0.03326416, 0.0020656586, 0.0033226013, -0.017700195, -0.0041389465, -0.004016876, 0.030258179, 0.05038452, 0.03756714, 0.0074501038, -0.0054969788, 0.04208374, 0.036590576, -0.012207031, -0.0024223328, -0.0018558502, -0.016952515, -0.001950264, 0.013336182, 0.0018835068, 0.025268555, 0.006679535, 0.0070381165, 0.030044556, 0.05102539, -0.037841797, 0.018203735, -0.0030326843, 0.0071258545, 0.06506348, -0.0044059753, -0.020812988, -0.014335632, 0.021865845, 0.01461792, 0.024597168, -0.0025997162, 0.016647339, -0.013069153, -0.0053138733, -0.026000977, 0.002286911, -0.02330017, -0.0034236908, 0.020248413, -0.05279541, 0.035888672, 0.008140564, 0.011413574, -0.04714966, 0.0054626465, -0.00042653084, 0.029327393, 0.014274597, -0.011634827, 0.01499939, -0.01033783, -0.01751709, -0.035949707, 0.004371643, 0.016342163, 0.046051025, -0.07574463, -0.049926758, 0.020645142, 0.0625, 0.023651123, -0.022491455, 0.06365967, 0.002779007, 0.0000166893, -0.000030219555, 0.009284973, -0.007320404, 0.03579712, 0.012268066, 0.037506104, -0.012718201, 0.050598145, 0.0058670044, 0.0039749146, -0.038909912, 0.003238678, -0.020690918, -0.027374268, -0.03125, -0.02079773, 0.0040130615, 0.003643036, -0.039276123, -0.043945312, 0.011169434, 0.04058838, -0.017807007, -0.048706055, -0.009475708, 0.011299133, 0.0028476715, -0.028366089, 0.014160156, 0.047698975, 0.051818848, -0.0096206665, -0.032165527, -0.014572144, -0.04321289, 0.0059776306, 0.013587952, 0.006072998, -0.0069389343, 0.010917664, -0.0038604736, 0.027313232, -0.008583069, -0.024337769, 0.016799927, 0.013961792, -0.049072266, -0.040222168, 0.031402588, 0.0026721954, -0.034057617, 0.009895325, -0.027267456, -0.054016113, -0.02798462, 0.030944824, -0.016464233, -0.0052719116, -0.009727478, -0.01687622, -0.008224487, -0.024047852, 0.0018177032, -0.039245605, -0.039855957, 0.024902344, 0.030303955, -0.0137786865, 0.028762817, 0.0010261536, 0.003982544, -0.006259918, -0.028671265, -0.0009202957, -0.0309906, 0.054534912, -0.072631836, -0.012039185, -0.06384277, -0.042938232, 0.09100342, -0.00970459, 0.022720337, -0.039154053, 0.026397705, 0.013160706, -0.017333984, 0.026306152, 0.00592041, 0.020111084, 0.04019165, -0.036712646, -0.05456543, -0.011634827, -0.026321411 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.06323v1
Surveys without Questions: A Reinforcement Learning Approach
Atanu R Sinha, Deepali Jain, Nikhil Sheoran, Sopan Khosla, Reshmi Sasidharan
cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
The 'old world' instrument, survey, remains a tool of choice for firms to obtain ratings of satisfaction and experience that customers realize while interacting online with firms. While avenues for survey have evolved from emails and links to pop-ups while browsing, the deficiencies persist. These include - reliance on ratings of very few respondents to infer about all customers' online interactions; failing to capture a customer's interactions over time since the rating is a one-time snapshot; and inability to tie back customers' ratings to specific interactions because ratings provided relate to all interactions. To overcome these deficiencies we extract proxy ratings from clickstream data, typically collected for every customer's online interactions, by developing an approach based on Reinforcement Learning (RL). We introduce a new way to interpret values generated by the value function of RL, as proxy ratings. Our approach does not need any survey data for training. Yet, on validation against actual survey data, proxy ratings yield reasonable performance results. Additionally, we offer a new way to draw insights from values of the value function, which allow associating specific interactions to their proxy ratings. We introduce two new metrics to represent ratings - one, customer-level and the other, aggregate-level for click actions across customers. Both are defined around proportion of all pairwise, successive actions that show increase in proxy ratings. This intuitive customer-level metric enables gauging the dynamics of ratings over time and is a better predictor of purchase than customer ratings from survey. The aggregate-level metric allows pinpointing actions that help or hurt experience. In sum, proxy ratings computed unobtrusively from clickstream, for every action, for each customer, and for every session can offer interpretable and more insightful alternative to surveys.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.06323v1
2020-06-11T10:41:07
2020-06-11T10:41:07
{ "title": [ 0.011306763, 0.006767273, -0.019180298, -0.017456055, 0.028839111, -0.023452759, 0.017288208, -0.046691895, -0.008483887, -0.0045814514, -0.038391113, 0.009048462, -0.09008789, -0.020706177, -0.042388916, -0.038269043, -0.008880615, 0.018829346, -0.051849365, -0.04058838, -0.029693604, -0.05429077, 0.00919342, 0.038391113, 0.0209198, 0.022720337, -0.08569336, 0.027374268, -0.04788208, -0.0035896301, -0.022247314, -0.009025574, 0.016540527, 0.037109375, 0.011222839, 0.025375366, -0.048706055, 0.03704834, 0.015106201, 0.0055503845, 0.005329132, 0.00049734116, -0.030670166, -0.043884277, -0.06549072, 0.011779785, -0.05331421, 0.0043525696, -0.027618408, 0.043914795, 0.018737793, 0.035614014, -0.0113220215, 0.050842285, 0.01965332, -0.02909851, -0.0019207001, -0.030181885, 0.04647827, 0.03552246, -0.013282776, -0.057159424, 0.03692627, -0.032348633, -0.031311035, -0.021392822, -0.010299683, 0.031311035, 0.05883789, 0.027908325, -0.012054443, 0.015625, 0.0049552917, 0.021652222, -0.055786133, -0.012931824, 0.05557251, 0.0103302, 0.024597168, -0.026794434, -0.013656616, -0.009681702, -0.019760132, -0.024307251, -0.007293701, -0.039215088, -0.02708435, -0.010612488, -0.03390503, -0.07470703, -0.007007599, -0.012496948, -0.04660034, 0.027023315, -0.0074691772, -0.026535034, -0.0023288727, 0.046569824, -0.0019836426, -0.016616821, -0.040985107, 0.040740967, -0.0769043, -0.004310608, 0.016418457, 0.023239136, -0.023513794, -0.019973755, 0.023849487, 0.04876709, 0.008781433, 0.03540039, 0.0088272095, 0.019714355, 0.0012655258, -0.0048217773, -0.018157959, 0.010314941, -0.0072669983, 0.017471313, -0.012802124, -0.022109985, 0.032073975, -0.0069503784, 0.028320312, 0.02368164, -0.029342651, -0.032196045, -0.019607544, 0.03729248, -0.0020179749, 0.028640747, -0.06237793, -0.05783081, -0.037078857, 0.02305603, -0.023391724, 0.006793976, -0.00020813942, -0.0077781677, 0.019424438, -0.029876709, -0.013282776, 0.015449524, 0.059570312, 0.0051574707, 0.04916382, -0.014328003, 0.0010814667, 0.010848999, -0.03805542, 0.029525757, 0.02482605, 0.011657715, -0.06085205, 0.02017212, -0.14416504, 0.024276733, 0.025741577, 0.029083252, 0.01576233, -0.0033302307, -0.013626099, 0.04196167, 0.08325195, 0.010192871, -0.0068588257, 0.03866577, 0.0074043274, 0.05630493, -0.024505615, 0.005355835, 0.0096588135, -0.009101868, -0.016601562, 0.009628296, 0.047698975, 0.023880005, 0.040008545, -0.05999756, 0.013763428, -0.008560181, 0.033843994, 0.05380249, -0.047454834, -0.034606934, 0.0032634735, -0.007068634, 0.044677734, 0.016998291, -0.03741455, 0.014274597, -0.044769287, -0.052246094, -0.027359009, -0.013580322, 0.025177002, 0.037475586, -0.0074157715, -0.0069236755, -0.026382446, 0.0033874512, -0.038085938, 0.02798462, 0.019424438, -0.025375366, -0.00026512146, 0.0031852722, -0.061279297, 0.056549072, 0.07873535, 0.021194458, -0.07067871, 0.05050659, 0.027374268, -0.08459473, 0.03225708, -0.0002039671, -0.0046310425, 0.0042266846, -0.008682251, -0.016921997, -0.02218628, 0.046173096, 0.013824463, -0.027740479, 0.0036411285, -0.051971436, 0.04284668, 0.00059986115, 0.07281494, -0.005504608, 0.012641907, 0.019348145, 0.0031471252, -0.024002075, 0.015075684, -0.020065308, 0.020050049, 0.010879517, -0.00642395, 0.0063934326, -0.0013208389, 0.0657959, 0.06286621, 0.015457153, 0.01309967, 0.01612854, 0.009063721, -0.0036563873, 0.08135986, 0.043029785, 0.068481445, 0.057128906, 0.023223877, 0.068603516, -0.0050239563, 0.010948181, -0.0014724731, 0.007858276, -0.006641388, -0.017913818, -0.011054993, 0.0016307831, -0.048065186, -0.0075569153, -0.01687622, 0.008117676, 0.0036849976, -0.004722595, 0.0390625, 0.0065956116, 0.014373779, 0.01158905, -0.014503479, -0.0039634705, -0.004573822, 0.008613586, 0.028121948, -0.046875, -0.01689148, 0.012489319, 0.04269409, 0.0070762634, 0.017410278, 0.02709961, 0.018554688, -0.018814087, -0.014762878, -0.011314392, 0.048828125, 0.01574707, -0.013999939, -0.0030403137, -0.012481689, -0.014190674, 0.042755127, 0.06878662, -0.04168701, 0.026870728, -0.037017822, 0.008979797, 0.03366089, -0.038024902, 0.0074157715, 0.00075387955, 0.017669678, 0.041503906, -0.0036678314, -0.011817932, -0.018447876, 0.038085938, 0.0064888, -0.03338623, -0.031951904, -0.043395996, -0.0020046234, -0.040802002, -0.026870728, 0.0063819885, 0.08526611, -0.00881958, -0.041046143, -0.00032806396, -0.010757446, -0.027801514, -0.006385803, -0.035308838, -0.014823914, 0.011962891, 0.045410156, 0.014221191, -0.043304443, -0.014968872, 0.008270264, 0.011955261, -0.009170532, 0.017578125, -0.016906738, -0.022079468, 0.0020198822, -0.0072517395, 0.025421143, -0.02532959, -0.011550903, -0.048065186, -0.0024757385, 0.018920898, -0.00013446808, -0.010391235, 0.039978027, -0.031280518, -0.036743164, 0.013961792, 0.072021484, -0.03451538, -0.019317627, 0.036712646, 0.0335083, -0.01600647, 0.029205322, 0.017868042, 0.0036449432, -0.07775879, -0.014633179, -0.041534424, -0.015571594, -0.027908325, 0.008110046, 0.07476807, -0.043304443, -0.0023441315, -0.056427002, -0.0012731552, 0.0017490387, 0.033935547, -0.0024700165, -0.021499634, -0.010818481, -0.0071640015, -0.008621216, 0.013847351, -0.032806396, 0.034698486, 0.0892334, 0.006008148, 0.013618469, 0.0070228577, 0.053894043, -0.004611969, -0.00932312, -0.028884888, -0.015052795, 0.0072021484, 0.035217285, 0.022232056, 0.019607544, 0.0019035339, -0.09289551, -0.03842163, 0.0001732111, 0.008590698, -0.020050049, 0.006832123, -0.03201294, 0.0065078735, -0.005214691, -0.037506104, 0.02357483, 0.0335083, -0.0014123917, 0.012466431, 0.02003479, -0.023147583, 0.02583313, -0.037200928, -0.04421997, 0.03314209, -0.021621704, -0.06341553, -0.0010356903, -0.0184021, -0.050964355, -0.04650879, 0.0034446716, 0.051849365, 0.04660034, 0.026931763, 0.033813477, -0.026412964, 0.013038635, -0.026382446, -0.01676941, -0.05645752, -0.015670776, -0.0423584, -0.013381958, 0.04107666, -0.0040664673, 0.0041236877, -0.025848389, -0.019638062, -0.030593872, 0.0017490387, -0.023513794, -0.023742676, 0.008354187, -0.0027065277, -0.020019531, -0.025299072, -0.030456543, -0.0013551712, -0.047332764, 0.0070724487, -0.021484375, 0.021453857, 0.02279663, 0.00919342, -0.0036067963, 0.011695862, 0.016311646, -0.025650024, -0.030090332, 0.015945435, 0.045318604, 0.0102005005, 0.046051025, -0.018707275, -0.008666992, 0.020950317, -0.021438599, -0.04385376, 0.010238647, 0.000831604, -0.012039185, 0.01600647, -0.015357971, 0.014472961, -0.01878357, 0.014007568, 0.029159546, 0.008323669, 0.0071105957, -0.076416016, -0.010482788, 0.010498047, -0.1459961, -0.04043579, 0.0032958984, 0.014541626, -0.01625061, -0.035888672, 0.036499023, -0.012069702, -0.043884277, 0.012138367, -0.007686615, -0.066101074, -0.021575928, -0.07098389, -0.045684814, 0.07574463, -0.008277893, 0.007461548, 0.049102783, -0.040802002, -0.043945312, -0.01914978, 0.00907135, 0.0149002075, 0.03466797, 0.009643555, 0.02116394, 0.04598999, -0.015777588, 0.018585205, 0.029541016, 0.028060913, -0.023956299, 0.0028514862, 0.0256958, 0.023742676, -0.028396606, 0.034301758, 0.035614014, -0.0036563873, -0.07092285, 0.019241333, -0.025909424, -0.012298584, 0.021896362, 0.01953125, 0.017471313, -0.0013370514, -0.0028820038, 0.007621765, -0.02319336, -0.018432617, 0.034088135, 0.0042877197, 0.0020370483, 0.0047721863, -0.003955841, 0.0289917, 0.020889282, -0.03970337, -0.018722534, 0.008049011, -0.01802063, -0.01763916, -0.015945435, 0.006465912, -0.045837402, -0.0035800934, -0.05911255, -0.051239014, -0.035003662, 0.0038414001, -0.012641907, 0.021987915, 0.024398804, -0.024902344, -0.027023315, -0.0075950623, 0.013313293, -0.011413574, 0.013427734, -0.044952393, 0.025360107, -0.034484863, -0.04498291, -0.04269409, -0.0013952255, 0.0042915344, 0.035003662, 0.0043411255, -0.018676758, 0.025222778, 0.021606445, 0.051879883, 0.046936035, -0.013931274, -0.039245605, 0.008361816, -0.017547607, -0.0138168335, 0.011436462, -0.0051116943, -0.0013933182, -0.024505615, 0.007896423, -0.015068054, -0.026351929, -0.017074585, 0.025878906, 0.01121521, 0.048095703, -0.013328552, 0.028076172, 0.033935547, 0.015853882, 0.015533447, 0.010437012, -0.020355225, -0.028961182, 0.01878357, 0.053131104, 0.023590088, -0.010017395, 0.004787445, 0.01638794, -0.001159668, -0.010284424, 0.020690918, -0.010292053, 0.014442444, -0.010444641, 0.041503906, -0.021255493, -0.021270752, 0.006969452, 0.0017766953, 0.029418945, -0.074279785, 0.078552246, 0.0058631897, 0.0010871887, 0.029525757, -0.02168274, 0.0135269165, 0.0022697449, 0.001124382, -0.058166504, -0.049560547, 0.0064964294, 0.0491333, -0.044158936, -0.007408142, -0.018173218, -0.002500534, 0.022720337, 0.037597656, 0.009063721, -0.0027809143, -0.0035476685, -0.0052337646, -0.013343811, -0.018356323, -0.054901123, 0.014404297, 0.011169434, 0.045776367, -0.072265625, 0.035858154, -0.04559326, 0.0023269653, -0.0013513565, -0.005466461, 0.00630188, -0.07141113, -0.005886078, 0.017074585, 0.007633209, 0.010910034, -0.012176514, 0.018508911, 0.014175415, 0.04019165, -0.0023536682, 0.0236969, 0.02571106, -0.030532837, -0.008987427, -0.033569336, 0.03353882, 0.007774353, 0.020462036, 0.01360321, 0.034576416, -0.07879639, 0.026153564, -0.0008420944, -0.008171082, -0.0027236938, -0.044006348, -0.0033359528, 0.004005432, 0.011726379, 0.021942139, 0.012504578, -0.024612427, 0.002544403, -0.0023822784, -0.02734375, -0.00019109249, 0.010192871, -0.021560669, -0.012878418, 0.033325195, -0.03604126, -0.0005507469, 0.03652954, 0.00730896, 0.0013628006, 0.016143799, 0.023513794, -0.034851074, -0.01713562, -0.0084991455, 0.01600647, 0.015991211, 0.010154724, -0.038482666, -0.008598328, 0.004627228, -0.051635742, -0.023880005, 0.022735596, 0.011947632, -0.017288208, 0.009460449, 0.0234375, 0.054748535, -0.03778076, 0.03050232, 0.025177002, -0.012588501, 0.04269409, 0.019165039, 0.011543274, -0.024978638, 0.009521484, -0.025848389, -0.010559082, 0.0053863525, 0.0154418945, 0.006626129, 0.0047569275, 0.017944336, -0.030471802, -0.043304443, -0.000041604042, 0.032073975, 0.013214111, -0.027359009, 0.038269043, 0.04006958, 0.026855469, -0.045074463, -0.019058228, 0.028076172, -0.034576416, -0.027862549, -0.017745972, -0.02293396, -0.038482666, 0.07055664, 0.0016384125, -0.038757324, -0.030838013, -0.058624268, -0.024139404, 0.0055770874, 0.022872925, 0.013084412, 0.033203125, -0.008491516, 0.03866577, -0.001958847, -0.008781433, -0.006061554, 0.017578125, 0.012435913, -0.034454346, 0.010856628, 0.013748169, 0.022018433, -0.057403564, 0.014823914, -0.0033454895, 0.0070648193, -0.0036697388, -0.04360962, 0.0031604767, -0.0034599304, -0.033355713, 0.029388428, -0.008857727, -0.019210815, 0.04434204, -0.06072998, 0.05682373, 0.04348755, 0.055847168, 0.039123535, 0.03086853, 0.04840088, 0.015388489, 0.022521973, -0.019348145, -0.0020141602, -0.033050537, -0.028182983, -0.053741455, -0.015335083, -0.07879639, -0.007297516, 0.025009155, 0.008140564, 0.025634766, -0.0066604614, 0.009971619, 0.013664246, 0.030654907, 0.040039062, 0.045898438, 0.0070114136, -0.014381409, -0.004535675, -0.0013065338, -0.00006151199, 0.028778076, -0.012390137, 0.020843506, -0.04220581, -0.01977539, 0.0055160522, 0.010322571, 0.011306763, 0.01158905, -0.02015686, -0.025238037, 0.03640747, -0.023376465, 0.033081055, 0.080200195, 0.04257202, 0.0044136047, -0.041290283, 0.0056419373, -0.023529053, -0.018066406, 0.012687683, 0.028961182, -0.080322266, 0.03717041, -0.008636475, -0.03289795, 0.013450623, 0.033081055, 0.034118652, -0.042053223, -0.04446411, 0.011169434, 0.03665161, 0.025848389, 0.031921387, -0.03491211, -0.016860962, 0.015289307, 0.037963867, -0.005695343, 0.032806396, 0.0056877136, 0.029037476, -0.042175293, -0.005302429, 0.016159058, 0.025131226, -0.008201599, 0.02645874, -0.0713501, 0.07147217, -0.0049438477, -0.04748535, 0.03781128, 0.007980347, -0.10412598, 0.0069389343, 0.0112838745, 0.030929565, 0.04425049, 0.07373047, 0.047180176, -0.024810791, -0.023605347, -0.057556152, 0.009567261, 0.026657104, -0.030670166, 0.03488159, -0.03201294, -0.039367676, 0.070495605, -0.027618408, 0.08123779, -0.031280518, -0.00020492077, -0.012649536, -0.013977051, 0.06640625, -0.051635742, -0.009422302, -0.03479004, 0.008911133, 0.001791954, 0.021224976, -0.033691406, 0.009559631, 0.03314209, 0.007396698, 0.061279297, -0.024795532, -0.018127441, -0.005001068, -0.06530762, -0.035888672, -0.05532837, 0.002910614, -0.025985718, -0.011741638, -0.022384644, 0.009979248, 0.010543823, -0.026626587, -0.018447876, -0.002231598, -0.03665161, -0.03652954, 0.015640259, 0.019424438, -0.012260437, 0.003458023, -0.011940002, 0.0023708344, -0.012008667, -0.02809143, 0.00002771616, -0.010108948, -0.053771973, -0.038330078, -0.012229919, -0.0069007874, 0.02557373, -0.0077934265, 0.0069999695, 0.004085541, 0.0003168583, -0.027816772, 0.0041618347, 0.036254883, -0.026672363, -0.03729248, 0.008483887, 0.02684021, 0.0234375, -0.0715332, -0.0385437, -0.0076942444, 0.05050659, -0.027297974, 0.075805664, 0.00894165, 0.01424408, 0.04888916, 0.05783081, 0.016235352, -0.06640625, -0.00969696, 0.0022354126, 0.039764404, 0.04647827, -0.015014648, -0.008483887, 0.015113831, -0.007843018, 0.0018377304, 0.007865906, -0.0008163452, -0.00038909912, 0.005207062, 0.035461426, -0.011711121, -0.01411438, -0.034698486, -0.00024724007, 0.0056915283, -0.008605957, -0.0003437996, 0.020217896, -0.04446411, 0.05316162, -0.017990112, -0.02053833, 0.03213501, 0.022750854, 0.01991272, 0.03668213, -0.025558472, 0.008163452, 0.018203735, -0.0051612854, -0.007724762, 0.006286621, 0.047821045, -0.027801514, 0.0024852753, -0.053863525, -0.061065674, -0.021713257, -0.03753662, 0.030944824, -0.0062065125, 0.0181427, 0.010124207, -0.034942627, 0.0007176399, 0.0022239685, 0.027862549, -0.042755127, -0.032928467, -0.011161804, 0.044158936, 0.0006284714 ], "summary": [ 0.04244995, -0.01612854, 0.014656067, -0.019882202, -0.037017822, -0.0050582886, -0.002943039, -0.027328491, 0.029708862, -0.008255005, -0.078308105, -0.012138367, -0.020004272, -0.00749588, 0.0068244934, -0.06335449, -0.004108429, 0.031143188, 0.004764557, -0.021728516, -0.001783371, -0.021835327, -0.015029907, 0.026641846, 0.054901123, 0.019210815, -0.010238647, 0.022323608, 0.055114746, 0.061187744, 0.034942627, -0.0982666, -0.008956909, 0.0021896362, 0.033966064, 0.0026168823, -0.017456055, 0.022827148, 0.024276733, -0.016098022, 0.030761719, -0.005420685, 0.04071045, -0.064453125, -0.00409317, 0.08569336, -0.03994751, -0.021972656, 0.0034923553, 0.011306763, -0.023254395, 0.040161133, -0.025283813, 0.015541077, 0.0029888153, -0.0184021, -0.05114746, -0.013977051, 0.043762207, 0.05718994, 0.018035889, -0.04550171, -0.0000641942, -0.054382324, -0.013023376, -0.028289795, 0.06072998, 0.018966675, 0.048675537, -0.021377563, -0.0115737915, 0.046875, 0.018478394, -0.010063171, 0.0018625259, -0.0005707741, 0.051940918, 0.04748535, -0.012825012, 0.0020141602, -0.029800415, 0.0141067505, -0.012779236, -0.03930664, -0.006942749, -0.0063209534, -0.0236969, -0.0039863586, -0.007659912, -0.00012207031, 0.0061569214, 0.024551392, -0.07720947, 0.052825928, 0.04248047, -0.0317688, 0.038879395, 0.022399902, 0.00111866, -0.041168213, -0.0063591003, -0.019470215, -0.051330566, 0.0069999695, 0.038635254, 0.0090408325, -0.023712158, -0.010620117, 0.06439209, 0.0029945374, 0.0009918213, 0.09197998, 0.011299133, 0.03994751, -0.035949707, -0.03692627, -0.05227661, 0.050201416, -0.025527954, 0.048553467, -0.00079107285, 0.025375366, 0.02279663, 0.023529053, 0.0050964355, 0.03427124, 0.012420654, -0.06573486, -0.02748108, 0.03869629, -0.01751709, -0.012214661, -0.03387451, 0.006904602, -0.009056091, -0.025466919, -0.021987915, -0.0018672943, -0.0031814575, -0.021728516, 0.041015625, 0.0057792664, 0.026306152, 0.04928589, 0.10253906, 0.0053100586, -0.006378174, 0.0140686035, 0.052886963, 0.032196045, 0.03994751, -0.03881836, 0.020080566, 0.013786316, -0.0619812, -0.012702942, -0.060455322, -0.0011177063, 0.010894775, -0.011131287, 0.016647339, -0.0112838745, 0.010116577, 0.054534912, 0.018127441, 0.018432617, 0.0000371933, 0.000078976154, 0.008918762, 0.08013916, -0.010108948, -0.0072288513, -0.011306763, -0.016738892, -0.025146484, -0.018707275, 0.0014915466, 0.03378296, 0.021102905, -0.035064697, -0.009033203, -0.038604736, 0.049468994, 0.0033817291, -0.004737854, -0.011291504, 0.012275696, 0.021194458, -0.01033783, 0.033996582, 0.0020828247, 0.024505615, -0.033233643, -0.009460449, 0.0013637543, 0.03253174, 0.010185242, 0.04107666, 0.012939453, -0.05368042, 0.038208008, 0.016418457, -0.05947876, -0.0063552856, -0.074523926, -0.042999268, -0.00920105, 0.017486572, -0.047912598, 0.022979736, 0.027633667, -0.0054473877, -0.055358887, 0.09094238, 0.029785156, -0.060333252, 0.041503906, -0.08062744, -0.02709961, -0.059692383, -0.01852417, 0.059814453, -0.06604004, 0.08081055, -0.01008606, -0.005355835, 0.003824234, 0.022827148, 0.049987793, 0.016281128, 0.08734131, -0.047668457, 0.08538818, 0.07220459, 0.002040863, -0.0027122498, 0.02067566, -0.080200195, 0.0035896301, 0.03552246, 0.008529663, 0.01234436, -0.028274536, 0.04763794, -0.0026779175, -0.04562378, -0.012413025, 0.03894043, 0.0006322861, 0.031311035, -0.001115799, 0.00015747547, 0.013580322, 0.017532349, -0.0001835823, 0.040374756, -0.016143799, 0.0064430237, -0.0423584, 0.018066406, 0.008300781, -0.0006046295, 0.014228821, -0.00907135, 0.016952515, -0.009971619, 0.04711914, 0.03869629, 0.021347046, -0.030776978, -0.010429382, -0.023834229, 0.007419586, -0.015701294, -0.028656006, -0.0317688, -0.010826111, 0.032989502, 0.0001887083, -0.033081055, -0.0074653625, 0.030059814, 0.030639648, -0.00054359436, -0.0027751923, 0.0115737915, 0.028930664, 0.0143585205, 0.023040771, 0.026626587, 0.031188965, 0.03363037, -0.0055274963, 0.03503418, 0.00054883957, -0.006263733, -0.026611328, -0.01171875, 0.0067481995, -0.027404785, 0.0146102905, 0.034942627, -0.023132324, 0.0030403137, 0.00036931038, 0.00025439262, 0.0026512146, 0.015235901, 0.012382507, -0.020507812, 0.0033454895, 0.046203613, 0.017547607, 0.02885437, -0.051361084, -0.020614624, -0.030548096, 0.004184723, -0.05697632, -0.0056419373, 0.10888672, -0.035247803, -0.011459351, -0.0077285767, -0.054382324, -0.037475586, 0.04425049, -0.0284729, -0.0068969727, 0.01146698, -0.025772095, -0.016036987, -0.04763794, 0.015563965, -0.0015354156, 0.030014038, -0.004032135, -0.025741577, -0.027557373, -0.006427765, -0.004081726, -0.042999268, 0.0140686035, -0.015419006, -0.07519531, -0.021697998, 0.030532837, -0.01927185, 0.025863647, -0.00566864, 0.043426514, 0.0042304993, -0.0016565323, 0.055511475, 0.028060913, -0.005622864, 0.005508423, 0.034362793, 0.008583069, -0.018127441, 0.032318115, 0.032806396, 0.020263672, -0.109680176, -0.01939392, -0.046691895, -0.021331787, -0.015449524, -0.028549194, 0.012214661, 0.07623291, -0.011436462, -0.059417725, -0.040771484, -0.0949707, -0.008407593, 0.08227539, -0.0077934265, -0.03161621, 0.044128418, -0.015037537, 0.016296387, -0.013832092, 0.04168701, 0.018463135, 0.03741455, 0.009391785, 0.033935547, -0.011734009, -0.02558899, -0.015266418, 0.036193848, -0.01991272, 0.008666992, 0.035736084, -0.016082764, 0.028579712, 0.040740967, -0.094055176, -0.021118164, 0.0054016113, 0.031219482, 0.033721924, 0.006790161, -0.019042969, 0.06524658, 0.006881714, 0.00091314316, 0.0039520264, 0.031982422, 0.017562866, -0.021530151, 0.0046424866, -0.0069503784, 0.0070114136, -0.02619934, 0.047821045, 0.029647827, -0.03137207, -0.05947876, 0.0062561035, 0.068847656, 0.02809143, -0.01737976, 0.0103302, -0.009719849, -0.0019874573, -0.019943237, -0.027450562, 0.033050537, 0.008369446, 0.004196167, 0.005016327, -0.044708252, -0.059539795, -0.037322998, -0.024642944, 0.026000977, -0.004814148, -0.032806396, -0.043182373, -0.017059326, 0.020599365, 0.021484375, 0.014137268, -0.0018320084, -0.024887085, -0.029220581, -0.030776978, -0.021835327, -0.018249512, 0.021881104, 0.023162842, 0.032714844, 0.0032196045, 0.0181427, 0.021255493, 0.043060303, 0.0036811829, -0.018722534, -0.0053482056, -0.019836426, -0.013908386, 0.012535095, 0.053222656, -0.030288696, 0.056518555, 0.014381409, 0.0078125, 0.023483276, 0.0541687, -0.09051514, -0.020431519, -0.03277588, -0.0036125183, -0.04196167, 0.024780273, 0.009719849, 0.042541504, -0.03173828, -0.0019359589, 0.019256592, -0.030471802, -0.03793335, -0.022338867, 0.002735138, -0.06707764, -0.050445557, -0.014213562, 0.01651001, 0.004928589, 0.007537842, 0.039916992, -0.016189575, -0.015472412, -0.011054993, -0.0050621033, 0.014251709, -0.027740479, -0.070129395, 0.017913818, 0.0064430237, -0.018600464, 0.06088257, -0.0004734993, 0.03488159, 0.019989014, -0.00086545944, 0.014007568, -0.02368164, 0.018753052, -0.04437256, -0.0022888184, 0.023376465, -0.015235901, 0.0048065186, 0.05911255, 0.0058403015, 0.015274048, -0.012588501, 0.0869751, 0.07098389, -0.023895264, -0.0037555695, 0.017608643, -0.009918213, -0.026916504, -0.0181427, 0.015464783, -0.048034668, 0.0028266907, -0.005466461, -0.009284973, 0.041534424, 0.01008606, 0.0038375854, -0.021194458, -0.027908325, 0.025405884, 0.029266357, -0.008605957, -0.042510986, -0.026367188, 0.050476074, 0.0028152466, -0.058929443, -0.04977417, -0.019241333, 0.012176514, -0.015220642, -0.018569946, -0.032104492, -0.0317688, -0.02670288, 0.00024914742, -0.048858643, -0.03265381, 0.008514404, -0.0024204254, 0.023040771, 0.010375977, -0.026306152, -0.019836426, 0.033050537, 0.022125244, 0.014312744, -0.006111145, -0.068847656, 0.0234375, -0.02330017, -0.052581787, -0.030563354, 0.02432251, -0.018829346, 0.00096845627, -0.025650024, 0.0010004044, 0.000112235546, 0.045562744, 0.040618896, -0.005844116, 0.013389587, -0.0021820068, -0.01889038, -0.030380249, 0.017364502, 0.036224365, -0.024978638, -0.0045433044, 0.026916504, 0.05050659, -0.017456055, -0.008056641, 0.011375427, -0.0062065125, -0.008895874, 0.021331787, 0.009361267, 0.07574463, 0.0051193237, 0.013206482, -0.0043525696, 0.013954163, -0.0063476562, -0.0014410019, -0.02293396, 0.001042366, 0.040740967, 0.008293152, 0.0033740997, -0.027542114, -0.020431519, 0.004020691, 0.011505127, 0.008560181, 0.00014698505, 0.010002136, -0.0011358261, 0.04626465, -0.020706177, 0.03643799, 0.014526367, -0.0028934479, 0.043548584, -0.005420685, 0.05218506, 0.007736206, 0.014877319, -0.017654419, 0.018188477, -0.0018062592, -0.001584053, -0.031188965, 0.018844604, 0.023162842, -0.019454956, -0.023849487, -0.0036621094, -0.013694763, -0.030273438, 0.008865356, 0.026306152, -0.051483154, 0.012329102, 0.0446167, 0.018035889, -0.0061187744, -0.016784668, -0.015319824, -0.014907837, 0.012161255, 0.005104065, -0.0054893494, -0.0059394836, -0.010353088, -0.0138168335, -0.017562866, 0.0011043549, 0.012580872, -0.034240723, -0.049560547, -0.006122589, -0.02078247, -0.021743774, 0.01537323, 0.0020561218, -0.018844604, 0.026428223, -0.013381958, -0.00014305115, -0.015449524, 0.011375427, 0.03866577, -0.025985718, -0.010971069, -0.024261475, 0.008872986, 0.00017797947, 0.0017299652, -0.03060913, 0.0036067963, 0.009231567, -0.016921997, -0.0154418945, -0.0009045601, 0.050109863, -0.0032787323, -0.013694763, 0.027511597, 0.011199951, 0.014564514, 0.011520386, 0.0118637085, -0.007030487, -0.012306213, 0.019119263, -0.024215698, -0.034973145, 0.010726929, -0.02116394, -0.0061187744, -0.0007572174, 0.013458252, -0.021865845, -0.021606445, -0.006149292, 0.029891968, 0.022033691, -0.015777588, -0.013298035, -0.010147095, 0.030517578, 0.008430481, 0.02041626, -0.06506348, -0.03881836, -0.020309448, 0.025802612, 0.026351929, 0.0501709, 0.003030777, -0.02470398, 0.043304443, -0.050109863, 0.0028495789, -0.00008994341, 0.04977417, 0.015991211, -0.008453369, -0.0184021, 0.0018939972, 0.0054244995, -0.022445679, -0.010696411, 0.0034713745, -0.0040740967, 0.022399902, 0.034729004, -0.016143799, 0.02407837, -0.04623413, -0.0056991577, 0.019470215, -0.0137786865, -0.032714844, 0.004257202, -0.006839752, 0.029953003, -0.030838013, -0.036376953, 0.006454468, 0.050445557, -0.009025574, -0.02772522, 0.010108948, -0.050933838, 0.029876709, 0.014839172, -0.023071289, -0.019088745, -0.035583496, 0.005012512, -0.024276733, 0.026184082, -0.00031137466, 0.031921387, -0.060150146, -0.0635376, 0.025817871, -0.022949219, 0.008270264, 0.0059814453, 0.033233643, 0.055786133, -0.029418945, 0.0016365051, 0.041015625, -0.058746338, -0.011817932, 0.020019531, 0.024520874, 0.01260376, -0.08251953, -0.021759033, 0.009994507, 0.056915283, -0.003320694, 0.008155823, -0.0054512024, -0.038757324, 0.01638794, 0.0231781, -0.004219055, 0.018249512, -0.017044067, 0.03274536, 0.06518555, -0.0041618347, 0.010383606, -0.0060691833, 0.004207611, -0.018676758, 0.002702713, -0.00060272217, -0.014930725, -0.010749817, 0.036834717, 0.02394104, 0.006690979, 0.0859375, -0.005317688, 0.014053345, 0.029251099, -0.01739502, 0.064086914, 0.03225708, 0.01235199, -0.014038086, 0.01524353, 0.026443481, -0.023910522, 0.008972168, -0.008087158, 0.059539795, -0.03515625, -0.00084114075, 0.049560547, -0.010955811, -0.031799316, -0.030548096, 0.03237915, -0.059143066, 0.05444336, 0.020126343, 0.042053223, 0.040374756, 0.0126571655, 0.059661865, -0.05026245, 0.0007972717, 0.02986145, -0.008659363, 0.0038089752, 0.03970337, -0.036132812, 0.0054397583, 0.019104004, -0.023513794, 0.06939697, -0.012580872, 0.066711426, -0.05886841, -0.07849121, 0.04800415, 0.028915405, 0.015686035, -0.0058403015, -0.029083252, -0.027740479, -0.015258789, -0.015701294, 0.0065612793, 0.014213562, 0.01512146, 0.017028809, 0.038726807, 0.050720215, 0.0069351196, 0.04699707, 0.0036773682, 0.022003174, -0.067871094, 0.080078125, 0.05810547, -0.014167786, 0.029449463, 0.04647827, -0.03451538, 0.03463745, 0.04324341, 0.06903076, -0.0025939941, 0.022644043, -0.030517578, -0.027267456, 0.025222778, 0.0062026978, -0.009124756, -0.008728027, -0.0076828003, -0.042297363, -0.0013246536, 0.0012903214, 0.0049819946, -0.0065460205, 0.057006836, -0.01586914, -0.009140015, -0.0058555603, -0.040649414, 0.035308838, -0.010574341, -0.008140564, -0.023254395, 0.026351929, 0.02658081, 0.04812622, -0.043670654, 0.011672974, 0.016571045, -0.0076293945, 0.03781128, -0.02709961, 0.015716553, 0.005748749, -0.02619934, -0.039978027, -0.033325195, 0.009140015, -0.013015747, -0.03451538, -0.0017747879, 0.03253174, 0.0027980804, -0.008117676, -0.010505676, 0.060638428, 0.0041770935, -0.091552734, 0.028396606, 0.014640808, -0.0060157776, 0.029296875, -0.029342651, 0.0019283295, -0.000831604, -0.060424805, 0.0013113022, 0.0062332153, -0.033294678, -0.040252686, -0.031799316, -0.034606934, 0.025009155, 0.0018634796, -0.012466431, 0.031433105, -0.013244629, -0.045928955, -0.029586792, -0.019622803, -0.022979736, -0.05001831, 0.010345459, -0.0023117065, 0.0068740845, -0.016067505, 0.039215088, 0.03366089, 0.060913086, 0.01876831, 0.013679504, -0.014183044, -0.0126571655, -0.009986877, 0.029830933, -0.0013494492, -0.009811401, -0.031402588, 0.032165527, 0.028259277, 0.020462036, -0.010749817, -0.008728027, 0.020339966, -0.026611328, 0.012313843, 0.017181396, 0.018951416, -0.0056266785, -0.01398468, 0.036834717, -0.011009216, -0.046295166, -0.04055786, -0.005050659, -0.0040397644, -0.011169434, 0.0066223145, 0.036834717, -0.035491943, 0.05126953, 0.0077934265, 0.0075683594, -0.012687683, -0.021606445, 0.022338867, 0.0034637451, 0.02696228, -0.0017175674, 0.012763977, -0.000647068, 0.014717102, 0.006160736, 0.018814087, -0.022598267, 0.0005750656, -0.069885254, -0.015670776, -0.040405273, -0.039215088, 0.04168701, 0.007534027, -0.017730713, 0.04598999, -0.027572632, -0.0070228577, 0.036193848, -0.035858154, -0.039123535, 0.035003662, 0.0836792, 0.023773193, 0.024963379 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.06444v2
Learning compositional models of robot skills for task and motion planning
Zi Wang, Caelan Reed Garrett, Leslie Pack Kaelbling, Tomás Lozano-Pérez
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
The objective of this work is to augment the basic abilities of a robot by learning to use sensorimotor primitives to solve complex long-horizon manipulation problems. This requires flexible generative planning that can combine primitive abilities in novel combinations and thus generalize across a wide variety of problems. In order to plan with primitive actions, we must have models of the actions: under what circumstances will executing this primitive successfully achieve some particular effect in the world? We use, and develop novel improvements on, state-of-the-art methods for active learning and sampling. We use Gaussian process methods for learning the constraints on skill effectiveness from small numbers of expensive-to-collect training examples. Additionally, we develop efficient adaptive sampling methods for generating a comprehensive and diverse sequence of continuous candidate control parameter values (such as pouring waypoints for a cup) during planning. These values become end-effector goals for traditional motion planners that then solve for a full robot motion that performs the skill. By using learning and planning methods in conjunction, we take advantage of the strengths of each and plan for a wide variety of complex dynamic manipulation tasks. We demonstrate our approach in an integrated system, combining traditional robotics primitives with our newly learned models using an efficient robot task and motion planner. We evaluate our approach both in simulation and in the real world through measuring the quality of the selected primitive actions. Finally, we apply our integrated system to a variety of long-horizon simulated and real-world manipulation problems.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.06444v2
2021-05-05T03:00:32
2020-06-08T20:45:34
{ "title": [ -0.010620117, -0.0040016174, -0.02658081, -0.030349731, -0.0045204163, -0.021316528, -0.030090332, -0.013679504, -0.01739502, 0.020446777, -0.02456665, 0.003282547, -0.02456665, -0.018600464, -0.02180481, -0.027755737, 0.00006330013, 0.01701355, -0.032989502, -0.033721924, 0.014183044, -0.032196045, 0.015174866, 0.06964111, 0.04864502, -0.01777649, -0.1315918, 0.032318115, -0.04333496, -0.020233154, -0.011657715, 0.018539429, 0.025375366, 0.0025367737, 0.026290894, -0.031463623, -0.026016235, 0.008399963, -0.010215759, 0.0042037964, 0.024490356, -0.017410278, -0.07141113, -0.00096416473, -0.06744385, 0.019500732, -0.06756592, 0.003211975, -0.029159546, 0.053863525, 0.016204834, 0.034576416, -0.0058403015, 0.07183838, 0.023162842, -0.023040771, -0.04953003, -0.003194809, 0.05316162, 0.06311035, 0.0055999756, -0.06100464, 0.0034923553, -0.040222168, -0.034210205, -0.029296875, -0.043182373, 0.018615723, 0.03152466, -0.020965576, -0.005748749, 0.0101623535, 0.0015659332, 0.028945923, -0.03050232, -0.03527832, 0.0635376, 0.037139893, 0.01474762, -0.006149292, 0.016464233, 0.011520386, 0.010368347, -0.0340271, 0.0046691895, -0.06878662, 0.00217247, 0.0058631897, -0.042663574, -0.06536865, -0.0118255615, 0.021865845, -0.029907227, 0.0069122314, -0.039215088, -0.017181396, -0.023986816, -0.02432251, 0.030197144, -0.012207031, 0.019058228, -0.010856628, 0.0061187744, -0.008956909, 0.012023926, 0.01864624, 0.017868042, -0.030136108, 0.008026123, 0.009414673, -0.042877197, 0.03616333, 0.018096924, -0.0018177032, -0.023284912, -0.00724411, -0.003314972, 0.015914917, 0.016815186, 0.021102905, -0.028198242, -0.022979736, 0.009384155, 0.023925781, 0.017364502, 0.023849487, -0.0011577606, -0.018066406, 0.030944824, -0.005344391, -0.0121154785, 0.06036377, -0.076416016, -0.0869751, -0.047546387, 0.048828125, 0.008377075, -0.017120361, -0.034942627, 0.01689148, 0.0074920654, -0.011833191, 0.016082764, 0.0017547607, 0.008872986, 0.004299164, 0.05496216, 0.012184143, -0.055725098, -0.041137695, 0.008155823, 0.02394104, -0.011367798, 0.0015001297, 0.009147644, -0.012268066, -0.081848145, -0.0017995834, 0.043121338, 0.023101807, 0.037384033, 0.014198303, 0.0076904297, 0.0075645447, 0.037017822, -0.03289795, -0.022735596, 0.020599365, 0.0028057098, 0.046051025, -0.0036373138, 0.01159668, -0.04660034, -0.022872925, -0.015068054, -0.01600647, 0.030395508, 0.0042381287, 0.002532959, 0.021835327, 0.013511658, -0.014282227, 0.007820129, 0.036834717, -0.040771484, -0.05883789, -0.0067596436, -0.052947998, 0.057769775, -0.00075531006, -0.013191223, 0.029067993, -0.02772522, -0.039001465, -0.029144287, -0.007408142, 0.011482239, 0.020965576, -0.005756378, 0.016418457, -0.046447754, 0.00008362532, -0.015335083, 0.023223877, 0.004283905, -0.031707764, -0.0009851456, 0.02279663, -0.029449463, 0.068603516, 0.048095703, 0.037628174, -0.036956787, -0.0057373047, -0.0034828186, -0.06921387, 0.012237549, -0.022262573, -0.028549194, -0.0234375, -0.045410156, -0.007293701, -0.02281189, 0.041992188, 0.012008667, 0.013053894, -0.005935669, -0.005924225, 0.028717041, 0.03439331, 0.03994751, -0.058685303, 0.03466797, 0.039855957, 0.00045323372, -0.011306763, -0.0036334991, -0.007423401, 0.0047416687, 0.007511139, -0.009338379, 0.010948181, 0.016967773, 0.054626465, 0.07019043, 0.012390137, 0.00116539, 0.0115737915, -0.018417358, 0.007610321, 0.07086182, 0.01789856, 0.03164673, 0.024429321, -0.0037288666, 0.03918457, -0.0053596497, -0.02520752, -0.018356323, 0.010604858, 0.030212402, -0.01889038, -0.024993896, 0.00096178055, -0.04940796, 0.027709961, -0.023864746, 0.02041626, 0.004310608, 0.016677856, 0.027130127, -0.012374878, -0.0021686554, -0.028503418, 0.009635925, -0.010360718, -0.032958984, 0.039855957, 0.040740967, -0.07128906, 0.0002169609, 0.0022850037, 0.053009033, 0.008506775, 0.012252808, -0.011726379, 0.028427124, -0.016967773, 0.0077285767, -0.015823364, 0.055419922, -0.0021476746, 0.009437561, -0.007095337, 0.0046043396, -0.032073975, 0.070739746, 0.11395264, -0.052459717, 0.04864502, -0.055999756, 0.0048599243, 0.0016880035, -0.019607544, -0.00036597252, 0.013786316, 0.044128418, 0.017288208, -0.025390625, 0.0077819824, -0.04486084, -0.012542725, 0.023590088, 0.0060806274, -0.028411865, -0.040039062, 0.019805908, -0.0067214966, -0.030822754, -0.018341064, 0.046142578, -0.023788452, 0.02494812, 0.006652832, -0.004749298, -0.041748047, 0.0028533936, -0.015716553, -0.014305115, 0.026046753, 0.036346436, 0.027145386, -0.049713135, 0.0017967224, -0.0023593903, 0.02017212, -0.0031776428, -0.00041484833, -0.007762909, 0.004283905, 0.021972656, -0.018814087, 0.01876831, -0.022781372, 0.0079574585, -0.0692749, -0.0007362366, -0.0000121593475, 0.020370483, -0.009635925, 0.011428833, -0.017044067, -0.003578186, 0.027008057, 0.0670166, -0.03564453, -0.02468872, 0.046722412, 0.018630981, -0.0063591003, 0.02041626, 0.016418457, 0.005443573, 0.003894806, -0.0028057098, -0.04937744, 0.0005068779, -0.004058838, 0.017700195, 0.06390381, -0.06549072, 0.026245117, -0.0637207, -0.013092041, 0.009239197, 0.0262146, 0.013015747, -0.028244019, -0.03265381, -0.0025959015, -0.004852295, 0.012672424, -0.0546875, 0.010299683, 0.06774902, 0.020935059, 0.0063552856, 0.01864624, 0.016860962, -0.014213562, -0.019378662, 0.0034294128, -0.016540527, 0.00090551376, 0.00749588, 0.00844574, -0.036315918, -0.034576416, -0.08282471, 0.004119873, 0.01991272, 0.022109985, -0.026062012, 0.046691895, -0.056365967, 0.005050659, -0.016799927, -0.03665161, 0.026855469, 0.0647583, 0.00024414062, -0.002298355, 0.034942627, -0.044128418, 0.004005432, -0.0060157776, -0.07702637, 0.052520752, -0.07220459, -0.0423584, 0.03152466, -0.041107178, -0.020080566, -0.032196045, -0.0054969788, 0.013969421, 0.029388428, 0.014205933, 0.0033168793, -0.005706787, 0.0045166016, -0.02532959, -0.015533447, -0.011047363, -0.047546387, 0.002752304, -0.009208679, 0.04373169, 0.034454346, -0.017471313, -0.018569946, 0.01234436, -0.0126953125, 0.031051636, -0.013496399, -0.023666382, 0.019943237, -0.006061554, -0.032592773, -0.011169434, -0.004753113, 0.016784668, -0.019485474, 0.0056419373, 0.0026741028, 0.018539429, -0.0040016174, 0.017913818, -0.028533936, -0.035095215, 0.020812988, -0.030090332, -0.07763672, 0.016464233, 0.029647827, -0.019210815, 0.03086853, -0.018508911, -0.030197144, 0.027755737, -0.029724121, 0.025848389, 0.009216309, 0.0029182434, -0.006866455, 0.015075684, -0.023086548, -0.0154418945, 0.007949829, 0.038757324, 0.0051345825, 0.000079512596, -0.012496948, -0.045562744, -0.004360199, -0.0015239716, -0.09655762, -0.0039024353, 0.010543823, 0.004673004, -0.0059776306, -0.031707764, 0.02760315, -0.02784729, -0.041412354, 0.014427185, -0.01826477, -0.013259888, 0.016738892, -0.03540039, -0.029678345, 0.07220459, -0.005168915, -0.026306152, 0.04623413, -0.0021800995, 0.015930176, -0.008026123, 0.0023994446, 0.008300781, 0.049865723, -0.0067329407, -0.011451721, 0.05718994, -0.035369873, 0.025054932, 0.04019165, 0.06677246, -0.023590088, -0.009300232, -0.031097412, -0.008804321, -0.03213501, 0.054351807, 0.033111572, -0.0105896, -0.07885742, 0.057434082, -0.012367249, -0.0017528534, 0.024490356, -0.0026111603, 0.0048065186, -0.007183075, -0.003042221, 0.01953125, -0.0093688965, -0.031829834, 0.0362854, 0.0340271, -0.023330688, -0.027450562, 0.0016222, 0.045440674, -0.0073013306, 0.0023860931, -0.03765869, 0.029678345, -0.008369446, -0.0143966675, 0.005836487, 0.006023407, -0.023483276, 0.009376526, -0.053466797, -0.05984497, -0.035949707, 0.029449463, -0.0067596436, 0.0026626587, 0.03387451, 0.010902405, -0.04421997, 0.011505127, 0.035339355, 0.0057907104, -0.028289795, -0.07751465, 0.015174866, 0.0011377335, -0.07598877, -0.04647827, -0.055999756, -0.034362793, 0.027145386, 0.008285522, -0.057891846, 0.0056762695, 0.026428223, 0.11907959, 0.06048584, 0.0066833496, -0.07678223, 0.03555298, -0.049102783, -0.013595581, 0.02281189, 0.007762909, -0.019729614, -0.040283203, 0.032104492, -0.010383606, -0.0115356445, -0.034851074, 0.016921997, -0.01626587, 0.032836914, 0.0014686584, 0.031799316, 0.024765015, -0.0007009506, 0.011474609, 0.00818634, -0.045532227, 0.030197144, -0.008865356, 0.048614502, -0.022979736, 0.021057129, 0.03665161, 0.016723633, 0.012329102, -0.00687027, 0.014923096, 0.022491455, -0.034118652, 0.0038394928, 0.023330688, -0.0647583, -0.03829956, -0.0026111603, -0.0044021606, 0.039886475, -0.045959473, 0.06903076, -0.012939453, -0.020828247, 0.017654419, -0.005176544, 0.008598328, -0.0107421875, -0.00068330765, -0.062805176, -0.08337402, -0.016235352, 0.09814453, -0.032989502, -0.015235901, -0.007709503, -0.003435135, 0.039398193, 0.036132812, 0.04940796, -0.06781006, 0.00063562393, -0.032806396, -0.03125, 0.014411926, -0.043945312, -0.000001847744, -0.029937744, 0.010261536, -0.03186035, 0.04333496, -0.059143066, 0.032958984, -0.019058228, 0.008705139, 0.00712204, -0.032043457, 0.054718018, 0.10638428, -0.002571106, 0.054626465, 0.0034809113, 0.019454956, 0.018234253, 0.040649414, -0.0073165894, 0.04727173, 0.022964478, -0.028381348, 0.047088623, 0.00011497736, 0.018737793, -0.0005559921, -0.0017347336, 0.0008702278, 0.008934021, -0.038604736, 0.019760132, -0.0127334595, 0.010910034, -0.010231018, -0.02822876, 0.014572144, 0.021057129, 0.013839722, -0.0026416779, -0.046569824, -0.049438477, -0.014122009, -0.026672363, -0.020904541, 0.017578125, -0.019165039, -0.01374054, -0.07019043, -0.0065727234, -0.039093018, -0.00032949448, 0.0074882507, 0.023910522, -0.016448975, 0.030151367, 0.013923645, -0.030288696, 0.012268066, -0.011962891, 0.005378723, 0.04006958, 0.03591919, -0.03010559, -0.0032081604, 0.0011348724, -0.053741455, -0.0463562, 0.025604248, 0.007320404, -0.014701843, -0.023529053, -0.04071045, -0.026138306, -0.017562866, 0.0039482117, 0.0002539158, -0.024414062, 0.02432251, -0.00920105, -0.022125244, 0.005882263, -0.015571594, -0.0059394836, 0.010177612, -0.01209259, 0.03753662, 0.022857666, 0.0028438568, 0.0077400208, 0.013931274, 0.0018930435, -0.016204834, 0.042388916, 0.005012512, -0.0138549805, 0.013679504, 0.034942627, 0.03302002, 0.0059661865, 0.009925842, 0.0657959, -0.03286743, 0.01550293, -0.011421204, -0.0022144318, -0.039733887, 0.06149292, -0.010406494, -0.011001587, -0.058135986, -0.05847168, -0.036193848, -0.00049448013, 0.03173828, -0.0056991577, 0.0126953125, -0.03930664, 0.0069732666, -0.010627747, -0.009292603, -0.053527832, -0.005580902, -0.010429382, -0.040863037, 0.062683105, 0.032989502, 0.022766113, -0.022109985, 0.014457703, 0.008163452, -0.004009247, 0.014816284, -0.044006348, 0.012107849, -0.009971619, -0.012428284, 0.04083252, -0.027923584, -0.007331848, -0.009521484, -0.025466919, 0.052703857, 0.042633057, 0.054718018, 0.039520264, 0.0026054382, 0.0055122375, 0.022445679, 0.0004169941, -0.039886475, 0.008674622, -0.055877686, -0.014663696, -0.04019165, -0.012565613, -0.073791504, -0.018295288, 0.01776123, -0.012886047, 0.028625488, -0.008293152, -0.0064582825, 0.022232056, 0.038757324, 0.017578125, 0.023025513, -0.028717041, 0.016357422, -0.035461426, -0.04434204, 0.04547119, 0.042907715, 0.009750366, -0.0030231476, -0.0060043335, -0.016296387, 0.010131836, 0.01864624, 0.0022239685, -0.023971558, 0.0047569275, -0.032226562, 0.049468994, -0.015365601, 0.014129639, 0.0690918, 0.05331421, -0.022262573, -0.024124146, 0.031555176, -0.02078247, -0.004436493, -0.00083589554, 0.02331543, -0.05328369, 0.035095215, 0.003868103, -0.02243042, -0.03591919, 0.04736328, 0.016693115, -0.041381836, -0.02053833, 0.05404663, 0.022079468, 0.0151901245, 0.014442444, -0.03869629, -0.0013151169, 0.028335571, 0.014183044, -0.019729614, 0.0116119385, 0.04626465, 0.027908325, -0.03955078, -0.019561768, -0.0071525574, 0.012237549, -0.04751587, 0.018432617, -0.04055786, 0.028625488, -0.0052948, -0.03579712, 0.017868042, -0.006412506, -0.022583008, -0.014480591, 0.006576538, 0.0574646, 0.0715332, 0.082458496, 0.004562378, -0.0126953125, 0.02861023, -0.04840088, 0.044647217, 0.028381348, -0.022125244, 0.015258789, -0.034423828, -0.0496521, 0.047790527, -0.056793213, 0.080444336, -0.04269409, -0.00042176247, -0.020843506, 0.0026931763, 0.04638672, -0.031585693, -0.036346436, -0.036956787, 0.0065689087, 0.009712219, 0.013259888, -0.0037288666, 0.04043579, 0.041046143, -0.00459671, 0.076538086, 0.020355225, 0.009765625, -0.037628174, -0.06921387, 0.022338867, -0.008766174, 0.049835205, -0.012145996, -0.033203125, -0.033477783, 0.012298584, 0.028930664, -0.0023212433, -0.052520752, 0.03543091, -0.0064468384, -0.0055770874, -0.012916565, 0.008331299, -0.017929077, -0.00019347668, -0.011505127, 0.023208618, -0.019424438, 0.0077285767, 0.038970947, -0.0335083, -0.04257202, 0.0015115738, -0.03463745, 0.036865234, 0.01272583, -0.020050049, 0.0041618347, 0.027618408, -0.06036377, -0.008674622, -0.019470215, 0.024963379, -0.003932953, -0.021316528, 0.0128479, 0.035369873, 0.056915283, -0.040496826, -0.024002075, -0.005241394, -0.0024585724, -0.0058670044, 0.060668945, 0.011764526, 0.00068712234, 0.0051345825, 0.022064209, -0.0075187683, -0.029403687, -0.012496948, 0.0041007996, 0.0126571655, 0.041931152, -0.013244629, 0.0103302, 0.017745972, -0.026519775, 0.010093689, 0.024047852, -0.009017944, 0.0018720627, -0.006839752, 0.006679535, -0.01878357, -0.01449585, -0.05633545, 0.0077171326, 0.011352539, 0.044555664, -0.016677856, 0.025634766, 0.007045746, 0.074035645, -0.011650085, -0.029037476, 0.046020508, 0.032073975, 0.025238037, 0.011329651, -0.008262634, -0.022872925, -0.018997192, 0.041015625, 0.006175995, 0.046905518, 0.018707275, 0.019256592, 0.029052734, -0.039886475, -0.035064697, 0.0009236336, -0.028717041, 0.03164673, -0.02281189, 0.009086609, 0.004310608, -0.020080566, -0.00047683716, 0.03289795, 0.018310547, -0.037597656, -0.030197144, 0.006465912, 0.056121826, -0.012069702 ], "summary": [ 0.07598877, 0.011909485, 0.017242432, -0.0033397675, -0.012718201, -0.042938232, 0.018188477, -0.047790527, -0.011558533, 0.029830933, -0.055847168, 0.030883789, 0.023803711, 0.0012559891, 0.024612427, -0.022277832, 0.025634766, 0.034240723, 0.04537964, -0.011299133, 0.012130737, 0.0017757416, 0.0060577393, 0.05831909, 0.038635254, 0.033111572, -0.13391113, 0.0014047623, -0.003129959, 0.011489868, 0.0041236877, 0.016143799, -0.013801575, -0.0013608932, 0.051483154, -0.006324768, 0.046295166, -0.004623413, 0.025054932, 0.028808594, 0.023666382, -0.011512756, -0.040039062, -0.014595032, -0.057250977, 0.03137207, -0.029174805, 0.020370483, 0.017913818, 0.04248047, -0.009628296, 0.019683838, -0.029632568, 0.022994995, -0.013504028, -0.039855957, -0.03729248, -0.03164673, 0.045135498, 0.07019043, 0.0011711121, -0.05706787, -0.0025634766, -0.08239746, 0.0010957718, -0.027191162, -0.0011358261, 0.025421143, 0.02671814, 0.00051641464, 0.019470215, 0.021316528, -0.01586914, 0.018081665, -0.038482666, -0.002603531, 0.025039673, 0.024612427, -0.0038375854, 0.024642944, -0.00491333, 0.0075683594, -0.0008158684, -0.07293701, 0.020080566, -0.07159424, 0.008468628, 0.013305664, -0.012886047, -0.012969971, -0.02027893, 0.012413025, -0.0368042, 0.03668213, 0.004196167, -0.03262329, -0.009353638, -0.06274414, 0.04434204, 0.026657104, 0.08660889, -0.09069824, 0.11968994, -0.033325195, -0.018630981, 0.0115737915, 0.048583984, -0.009857178, 0.0066452026, -0.008201599, -0.04272461, 0.041931152, 0.021606445, -0.0098724365, -0.005218506, 0.02142334, 0.0053100586, 0.03781128, -0.011291504, 0.024719238, -0.038269043, 0.0119018555, -0.023406982, 0.036499023, -0.001996994, 0.005924225, 0.014945984, -0.0039901733, 0.043060303, 0.0016937256, -0.018539429, 0.027389526, -0.013557434, -0.031951904, -0.03390503, -0.014884949, 0.041809082, 0.014129639, 0.008804321, -0.020736694, 0.01374054, 0.011199951, -0.008758545, 0.007835388, -0.003484726, 0.0056762695, 0.021392822, 0.013977051, -0.02281189, 0.0025596619, -0.015090942, 0.013885498, -0.006275177, -0.00868988, 0.049438477, -0.044189453, -0.00598526, -0.010978699, 0.048980713, 0.0012111664, 0.020492554, 0.027450562, 0.0284729, 0.0110321045, -0.0004925728, -0.050445557, -0.004425049, 0.007858276, 0.0029010773, 0.03164673, 0.0036201477, 0.028305054, -0.033325195, -0.018127441, -0.0048980713, -0.024841309, 0.012611389, 0.021560669, 0.015686035, -0.014320374, 0.006340027, -0.0062446594, 0.03451538, 0.009376526, -0.0015974045, -0.053131104, -0.024017334, -0.042755127, 0.05670166, 0.008583069, -0.020812988, 0.0013742447, -0.008178711, 0.034301758, 0.0012636185, -0.006477356, -0.028686523, 0.017318726, -0.012191772, -0.05493164, 0.036895752, -0.010856628, 0.018203735, 5.9604645e-8, -0.014457703, 0.013290405, -0.007850647, 0.01399231, 0.020141602, 0.028915405, 0.00957489, 0.0014839172, -0.008415222, -0.014953613, -0.030212402, -0.011955261, 0.036865234, -0.006088257, -0.0012578964, -0.032592773, 0.012924194, 0.004432678, -0.021713257, 0.065979004, 0.03125, -0.018615723, -0.0052604675, -0.006958008, 0.03189087, 0.020309448, -0.011039734, -0.007980347, -0.026641846, 0.026870728, -0.027923584, -0.018157959, -0.011230469, 0.0033168793, 0.017440796, 0.027328491, 0.02444458, 0.016403198, -0.013534546, 0.012466431, 0.010055542, -0.023590088, 0.00023210049, -0.006454468, -0.032318115, -0.022399902, 0.044677734, 0.005168915, 0.032165527, 0.009742737, -0.0032958984, 0.031219482, 0.015808105, -0.025146484, 0.021911621, -0.013084412, 0.011146545, -0.054748535, -0.040924072, 0.005744934, 0.0102005005, -0.005672455, 0.023162842, 0.008125305, 0.017837524, -0.004322052, 0.0050849915, -0.06512451, -0.013595581, -0.072509766, -0.05368042, -0.030776978, -0.038238525, 0.088134766, 0.01675415, -0.072509766, -0.0079574585, 0.00008326769, 0.011894226, -0.0039978027, 0.02519226, 0.017807007, 0.020828247, -0.013465881, 0.054504395, 0.05279541, 0.059783936, 0.003944397, -0.012573242, 0.039978027, 0.00242424, -0.034851074, -0.034729004, 0.06414795, -0.032714844, 0.00017023087, -0.018692017, 0.023117065, -0.029830933, 0.01625061, 0.009124756, -0.03326416, -0.0011873245, 0.02758789, 0.01675415, -0.012794495, -0.0087890625, 0.04446411, 0.03942871, 0.08105469, -0.00541687, -0.025344849, 0.024291992, 0.0871582, 0.013122559, 0.014007568, 0.037200928, -0.058654785, 0.04248047, 0.016281128, -0.028442383, -0.042297363, 0.060699463, 0.017105103, 0.000995636, 0.037597656, 0.020858765, 0.032440186, -0.012916565, 0.030319214, 0.0019721985, -0.008560181, 0.0027122498, 0.018188477, 0.0029392242, -0.004508972, 0.014160156, 0.0036907196, 0.003282547, -0.0060195923, 0.052520752, -0.043029785, 0.0022029877, 0.0068855286, 0.029388428, 0.014152527, -0.03173828, -0.031036377, -0.026916504, 0.0026130676, 0.012023926, -0.021438599, 0.029327393, 0.0050201416, -0.017456055, -0.045288086, 0.0340271, 0.041168213, -0.0008187294, -0.05444336, -0.04260254, -0.032958984, 0.015716553, -0.03237915, 0.04043579, 0.06335449, -0.04397583, 0.09039307, -0.095458984, -0.016983032, -0.0074653625, 0.029388428, 0.040130615, -0.01373291, 0.04611206, 0.050109863, 0.042755127, 0.05154419, -0.015960693, 0.045532227, 0.088378906, 0.013626099, 0.019363403, 0.011909485, 0.05014038, 0.0017528534, -0.016189575, -0.05529785, -0.011390686, -0.015342712, -0.024932861, 0.015281677, 0.009338379, -0.020339966, -0.0018005371, -0.028884888, -0.027816772, 0.041809082, 0.0143966675, 0.0013084412, -0.004425049, 0.019927979, -0.020355225, -0.026504517, 0.0060195923, 0.041625977, 0.022613525, -0.06188965, 0.04663086, -0.04537964, 0.005580902, 0.003824234, 0.027954102, 0.028762817, -0.046020508, -0.046142578, 0.02418518, 0.006248474, 0.00944519, -0.026229858, -0.009559631, -0.024124146, 0.029510498, 0.022644043, -0.022979736, 0.02960205, 0.013305664, -0.026550293, -0.012886047, 0.009605408, -0.038726807, 0.007549286, -0.00044178963, -0.015457153, 0.041381836, -0.04147339, -0.042388916, -0.0015058517, -0.02999878, 0.008552551, -0.0209198, -0.005016327, 0.007270813, -0.044952393, -0.01108551, -0.014022827, -0.01651001, 0.016448975, 0.02444458, 0.023239136, 0.003145218, 0.05255127, -0.014373779, 0.020141602, 0.027679443, -0.017288208, 0.018173218, 0.016647339, -0.093444824, -0.012741089, -0.0029640198, -0.014602661, 0.01574707, -0.011482239, 0.01146698, -0.023605347, -0.03741455, 0.06100464, -0.009902954, -0.03152466, -0.0066604614, -0.07122803, 0.038970947, 0.0009236336, 0.07043457, -0.0395813, -0.0236969, 0.014205933, -0.06762695, -0.0041885376, -0.035461426, 0.019439697, -0.06304932, -0.022018433, 0.0015096664, 0.025405884, 0.024353027, -0.017501831, 0.035186768, -0.010017395, -0.017730713, -0.0020980835, -0.006839752, 0.029083252, 0.034057617, 0.0017127991, -0.036590576, 0.012313843, 0.0143585205, -0.047424316, 0.015541077, 0.028945923, 0.02822876, 0.029800415, 0.0026226044, -0.014663696, 0.022506714, -0.016830444, 0.02003479, 0.041992188, -0.01826477, -0.0059890747, 0.0066337585, 0.09857178, -0.055603027, -0.041137695, 0.02116394, 0.03781128, -0.01663208, 0.0025405884, 0.032470703, 0.007713318, -0.040649414, 0.053833008, -0.048919678, -0.018920898, 0.04574585, 0.059539795, -0.03677368, -0.0317688, 0.010734558, -0.013320923, -0.021865845, -0.029373169, 0.029510498, 0.052612305, -0.03302002, -0.010879517, 0.011138916, 0.07397461, -0.026687622, 0.0022125244, -0.025741577, 0.065979004, -0.014099121, 0.024261475, 0.019088745, -0.007965088, -0.046875, -0.029312134, -0.0058784485, -0.04812622, -0.0054626465, 0.0036773682, 0.012260437, -0.012748718, 0.00894165, 0.005748749, -0.025360107, -0.008872986, 0.032104492, 0.014289856, -0.014282227, -0.064575195, -0.047302246, 0.014183044, -0.047912598, -0.019607544, -0.04248047, -0.016326904, -0.022354126, -0.013618469, -0.025146484, 0.029174805, 0.03414917, 0.11273193, 0.049957275, 0.0019454956, -0.10253906, -0.019119263, -0.009033203, -0.006416321, 0.027755737, -0.030410767, -0.011413574, -0.0011377335, 0.014015198, -0.010604858, -0.00491333, -0.019119263, -0.014152527, -0.039001465, 0.031341553, 0.03390503, 0.066223145, 0.01361084, -0.013298035, -0.026931763, -0.01146698, -0.02557373, 0.06689453, -0.045684814, -0.015213013, -0.015914917, -0.01902771, -0.032287598, 0.007980347, -0.03665161, 0.025802612, 0.022903442, 0.003534317, -0.0048179626, -0.00026226044, 0.0019950867, -0.011360168, 0.0031433105, 0.034729004, -0.0075035095, 0.029129028, 0.025360107, 0.015388489, 0.06414795, -0.011024475, 0.013969421, -0.037078857, -0.013343811, -0.01576233, -0.034576416, -0.03967285, -0.031677246, -0.004837036, 0.06237793, -0.021240234, -0.021957397, -0.030593872, -0.019195557, 0.024963379, 0.04232788, 0.044067383, -0.094177246, 0.0043029785, -0.018554688, -0.032165527, 0.0065460205, -0.045654297, -0.032592773, -0.051696777, 0.01423645, -0.019226074, 0.048034668, 0.01576233, 0.0104904175, 0.015457153, -0.0037460327, -0.004398346, -0.02079773, -0.012588501, 0.010894775, -0.04650879, -0.00015771389, 0.05279541, 0.016098022, -0.025283813, 0.03024292, -0.021499634, 0.038360596, -0.0054397583, -0.03274536, 0.053131104, -0.019546509, -0.013679504, 0.0037975311, 0.033447266, -0.0070610046, 0.0357666, -0.03491211, 0.0013933182, -0.037200928, 0.0044059753, -0.033813477, 0.011352539, 0.03137207, 0.032440186, 0.008049011, -0.020446777, -0.01499939, -0.033843994, -0.023651123, -0.019302368, -0.047607422, 0.011703491, -0.031402588, 0.03253174, -0.057769775, -0.0074653625, -0.066223145, 0.015640259, 0.012756348, 0.023925781, 0.01802063, -0.018661499, 0.033477783, 0.009979248, 0.014701843, 0.021514893, 0.03338623, 0.0024471283, -0.036590576, -0.049835205, -0.009796143, -0.016921997, -0.013412476, -0.017822266, 0.020492554, 0.015098572, 0.013542175, -0.010665894, 0.0044822693, -0.027908325, -0.019989014, -0.007320404, -0.017044067, -0.04849243, 0.015342712, -0.015159607, -0.0340271, 0.035705566, -0.031341553, -0.01687622, 0.01158905, -0.0146484375, 0.043701172, 0.02217102, -0.026824951, -0.015579224, 0.025741577, 0.006855011, 0.009338379, 0.020111084, -0.00223732, -0.0021648407, 0.036895752, 0.010650635, 0.030303955, 0.028915405, 0.0024795532, 0.024230957, 0.030181885, 0.017410278, 0.020690918, -0.002527237, -0.011352539, 0.039916992, 0.026123047, 0.009033203, -0.043121338, -0.035705566, -0.0044059753, -0.022323608, 0.038146973, -0.028518677, 0.014785767, -0.01953125, -0.022506714, 0.017700195, 0.0035152435, -0.010398865, -0.02746582, 0.001786232, -0.01727295, 0.029434204, 0.056030273, 0.025039673, -0.008842468, -0.019500732, -0.022781372, 0.00086688995, 0.027832031, -0.008277893, 0.0124053955, -0.019454956, 0.03881836, 0.025146484, 0.004322052, 0.0014543533, -0.016738892, -0.0058174133, 0.03540039, 0.011253357, 0.033599854, 0.008674622, -0.031555176, -0.012207031, 0.013381958, 0.009147644, -0.041046143, -0.020507812, -0.015975952, -0.09906006, -0.05291748, -0.056640625, -0.0027160645, -0.025466919, -0.021224976, -0.036315918, 0.031097412, -0.021453857, -0.023422241, 0.061431885, -0.029129028, 0.078430176, -0.02331543, 0.0047035217, 0.008621216, -0.034240723, -0.029205322, 0.02268982, 0.050628662, 0.026321411, 0.009925842, -0.031188965, 0.03515625, -0.0061454773, -0.028640747, -0.01713562, -0.014770508, 0.024658203, -0.011444092, 0.049835205, 0.014839172, 0.066711426, 0.021331787, 0.016494751, -0.00491333, -0.015960693, 0.012023926, 0.025741577, -0.007270813, 0.025909424, 0.027999878, -0.018005371, 0.00655365, 0.029083252, -0.023757935, -0.02545166, 0.057495117, 0.012207031, 0.0062026978, 0.01625061, 0.016586304, 0.001127243, 0.02482605, 0.010719299, -0.0418396, -0.008483887, 0.011375427, -0.017654419, -0.0074310303, -0.01701355, 0.04434204, -0.023010254, -0.004047394, 0.021881104, -0.039855957, 0.075683594, -0.06463623, 0.020004272, -0.02720642, 0.05493164, 0.028381348, -0.015701294, 0.04498291, 0.019927979, -0.03173828, 0.018096924, 0.018997192, 0.04562378, 0.049591064, 0.049865723, 0.0013465881, 0.012664795, 0.006855011, -0.008033752, 0.009902954, 0.0052757263, 0.0031471252, -0.02444458, -0.025665283, -0.004096985, -0.0037117004, 0.011810303, 0.048217773, -0.022598267, -0.041534424, 0.009765625, -0.052337646, 0.025756836, 0.043304443, -0.025375366, -0.055725098, -0.026535034, 0.02935791, 0.045898438, -0.0065307617, 0.0368042, 0.015808105, -0.04650879, 0.07098389, 0.027770996, 0.032562256, -0.049438477, -0.021072388, 0.056793213, 0.05126953, 0.091552734, 0.037231445, -0.05319214, -0.0024337769, 0.00982666, 0.0418396, -0.019927979, -0.05480957, 0.048858643, 0.036071777, -0.027770996, 0.014450073, 0.015655518, -0.017501831, 0.025039673, -0.055145264, 0.032440186, -0.013908386, 0.03338623, 0.030654907, 0.0018415451, -0.034423828, 0.01461792, -0.02482605, 0.019821167, -0.030654907, -0.021362305, 0.015975952, -0.0022335052, -0.035369873, -0.008453369, 0.0154800415, 0.015716553, -0.013847351, -0.009712219, -0.014640808, 0.039367676, 0.03842163, -0.017547607, 0.02748108, 0.019256592, -0.021484375, 0.0005645752, -0.04006958, -0.06781006, -0.027938843, 0.06958008, 0.04953003, 0.030334473, -0.0101623535, 0.04159546, 0.02558899, 0.05230713, 0.023712158, -0.04537964, 0.063964844, 0.01739502, -0.049224854, -0.0066223145, -0.01285553, 0.02986145, -0.00945282, -0.0018920898, 0.030059814, -0.018432617, -0.011878967, 0.0061798096, -0.001420021, 0.0005540848, 0.00031971931, -0.006465912, -0.007156372, -0.015792847, 0.031829834, -0.0034980774, 0.024810791, 0.027511597, -0.023269653, 0.04119873, -0.06008911, 0.05895996, 0.01411438, -0.0023880005, 0.03768921, 0.012512207, 0.053375244, 0.013244629, 0.042816162, 0.026794434, -0.037597656, 0.01838684, 0.0022850037, -0.017120361, 0.026931763, 0.015220642, -0.020004272, 0.04119873, -0.024398804, 0.013900757, -0.003019333, 0.002696991, 0.009376526, 0.0029582977, -0.006351471, -0.018508911, -0.010383606 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.07906v2
Fair Influence Maximization: A Welfare Optimization Approach
Aida Rahmattalabi, Shahin Jabbari, Himabindu Lakkaraju, Phebe Vayanos, Max Izenberg, Ryan Brown, Eric Rice, Milind Tambe
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.LG
Several behavioral, social, and public health interventions, such as suicide/HIV prevention or community preparedness against natural disasters, leverage social network information to maximize outreach. Algorithmic influence maximization techniques have been proposed to aid with the choice of "peer leaders" or "influencers" in such interventions. Yet, traditional algorithms for influence maximization have not been designed with these interventions in mind. As a result, they may disproportionately exclude minority communities from the benefits of the intervention. This has motivated research on fair influence maximization. Existing techniques come with two major drawbacks. First, they require committing to a single fairness measure. Second, these measures are typically imposed as strict constraints leading to undesirable properties such as wastage of resources. To address these shortcomings, we provide a principled characterization of the properties that a fair influence maximization algorithm should satisfy. In particular, we propose a framework based on social welfare theory, wherein the cardinal utilities derived by each community are aggregated using the isoelastic social welfare functions. Under this framework, the trade-off between fairness and efficiency can be controlled by a single inequality aversion design parameter. We then show under what circumstances our proposed principles can be satisfied by a welfare function. The resulting optimization problem is monotone and submodular and can be solved efficiently with optimality guarantees. Our framework encompasses as special cases leximin and proportional fairness. Extensive experiments on synthetic and real world datasets including a case study on landslide risk management demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed framework.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.07906v2
2020-12-15T21:39:06
2020-06-14T14:08:10
{ "title": [ -0.0034446716, 0.008743286, -0.009231567, -0.035064697, 0.011634827, -0.0030231476, -0.0053367615, -0.035095215, -0.040252686, 0.029144287, -0.015655518, 0.022201538, -0.020263672, -0.02204895, -0.0206604, -0.005847931, -0.026397705, 0.031707764, -0.019760132, -0.04309082, -0.022781372, -0.06756592, 0.035614014, -0.015029907, 0.023406982, -0.03289795, -0.05883789, 0.0054130554, -0.034210205, -0.032989502, -0.007522583, 0.034179688, 0.045959473, 0.00983429, 0.0090408325, 0.026809692, -0.036834717, 0.02027893, -0.0063552856, 0.030929565, -0.006362915, 0.01701355, -0.03845215, -0.018569946, -0.055114746, -0.022125244, -0.039978027, -0.013298035, -0.022918701, 0.07122803, 0.035583496, 0.012283325, 0.002691269, 0.044799805, 0.022354126, -0.017791748, 0.0018310547, -0.029067993, 0.02142334, 0.0463562, 0.018310547, -0.032287598, 0.014816284, 0.0034160614, -0.030288696, -0.021743774, 0.016479492, 0.031341553, 0.039215088, -0.00007432699, -0.0015001297, 0.027053833, 0.032226562, 0.037078857, -0.05731201, -0.04336548, 0.06085205, 0.028121948, 0.027282715, -0.026184082, -0.037109375, -0.021835327, -0.034576416, -0.0068588257, -0.02168274, -0.022125244, -0.028411865, -0.000118255615, -0.0056114197, -0.021530151, -0.0023460388, 0.022735596, 0.017211914, 0.029830933, -0.02067566, -0.007045746, -0.0024166107, 0.08312988, -0.00957489, -0.03375244, -0.040283203, 0.029022217, -0.08148193, -0.018203735, -0.0134887695, -0.007598877, 0.016708374, 0.018478394, -0.009178162, 0.038360596, -0.017532349, 0.0030384064, 0.029937744, 0.08972168, -0.0062217712, -0.050933838, -0.020553589, 0.016174316, -0.0552063, 0.029968262, -0.02029419, -0.004306793, 0.015319824, -0.013870239, -0.0027217865, -0.007030487, -0.021957397, -0.026931763, -0.027557373, 0.034423828, 0.0033607483, 0.020446777, -0.06237793, -0.03552246, -0.026489258, 0.019714355, -0.022140503, 0.004432678, 0.0048446655, -0.024291992, 0.010726929, 0.0007429123, 0.050567627, -0.000042378902, 0.046173096, 0.016540527, 0.075683594, -0.025741577, -0.027557373, 0.012611389, -0.067993164, 0.08917236, 0.036987305, -0.0028266907, -0.044647217, -0.034057617, -0.117492676, -0.018295288, 0.043701172, -0.0046310425, 0.018875122, 0.024765015, 0.017211914, 0.009498596, 0.04324341, -0.021362305, -0.035949707, 0.029708862, 0.0072746277, 0.07989502, -0.03186035, 0.012374878, -0.022094727, 0.0055236816, -0.006690979, 0.0075149536, 0.051940918, 0.0052833557, 0.032440186, -0.05618286, -0.010406494, -0.01335907, 0.031799316, 0.024032593, -0.060272217, -0.029571533, -0.0047798157, -0.023223877, 0.039916992, 0.0028018951, -0.032836914, 0.0362854, -0.044311523, -0.049713135, -0.06726074, -0.01852417, 0.04397583, 0.048797607, -0.009376526, 0.032287598, -0.003856659, -0.0053215027, -0.02609253, -0.002073288, -0.002313614, -0.036895752, -0.007408142, 0.013710022, -0.01209259, 0.028884888, 0.04925537, 0.0021324158, -0.049072266, 0.027313232, -0.010734558, -0.02180481, 0.042541504, 0.0030097961, 0.0013618469, 0.004173279, -0.0008459091, -0.014343262, -0.01574707, 0.054138184, -0.014221191, 0.0023231506, 0.0043563843, -0.017501831, 0.05923462, 0.014289856, 0.11834717, -0.04534912, 0.022857666, 0.03857422, 0.019195557, -0.010292053, 0.0013408661, -0.026733398, 0.017547607, 0.0043907166, 0.004501343, -0.031066895, 0.0021190643, 0.059509277, 0.013153076, -0.015060425, 0.0035095215, 0.028320312, 0.046173096, 0.008392334, 0.04925537, -0.0064849854, 0.056640625, -0.024429321, 0.050476074, 0.05606079, 0.00048542023, 0.027740479, -0.024719238, 0.036987305, -0.01966858, 0.0025672913, -0.005504608, -0.0035858154, -0.028030396, -0.020980835, -0.043762207, -0.0057296753, -0.017440796, 0.011367798, 0.041503906, -0.02784729, 0.005886078, -0.016082764, -0.028549194, -0.03289795, -0.015258789, 0.035247803, 0.0036640167, -0.0715332, -0.0138549805, 0.00036168098, 0.021896362, -0.0005431175, 0.028030396, 0.045074463, 0.012840271, -0.005748749, 0.015670776, -0.0135650635, 0.040100098, 0.030151367, -0.0047454834, 0.022277832, 0.041625977, -0.012634277, 0.02734375, 0.06011963, -0.012786865, 0.034698486, -0.0690918, 0.026153564, 0.032348633, -0.015655518, -0.0010881424, 0.030212402, 0.009231567, 0.02331543, -0.008224487, -0.023223877, -0.008430481, 0.007598877, -0.004951477, -0.08538818, -0.016235352, -0.028884888, -0.0064468384, -0.055633545, -0.020370483, 0.03338623, 0.030426025, 0.010513306, -0.06359863, 0.013252258, 0.009963989, -0.011421204, -0.02355957, -0.030319214, -0.020751953, 0.025558472, 0.050994873, 0.034423828, -0.040374756, -0.011062622, 0.01108551, -0.0028934479, -0.007209778, 0.0051498413, -0.007507324, -0.004257202, 0.015823364, -0.0071372986, 0.015472412, -0.03967285, 0.017578125, -0.058502197, 0.01486969, 0.012573242, 0.012329102, 0.023986816, -0.003458023, -0.014266968, -0.062042236, 0.00051927567, 0.03955078, -0.006000519, 0.018692017, 0.037384033, 0.032806396, -0.012817383, 0.060699463, -0.012680054, -0.0048065186, -0.06750488, -0.004470825, -0.03149414, -0.030761719, -0.03704834, 0.0021438599, 0.07513428, -0.05831909, -0.0040779114, -0.023086548, -0.0062561035, -0.004749298, 0.0030174255, -0.030853271, -0.02835083, -0.0028972626, -0.032806396, -0.004283905, -0.01663208, 0.011161804, -0.010757446, 0.09185791, 0.009819031, 0.01965332, 0.019989014, 0.039245605, -0.006515503, -0.01902771, -0.031433105, 0.04171753, -0.01576233, 0.0012130737, -0.0059890747, 0.03378296, 0.028289795, -0.032806396, -0.008377075, 0.021408081, 0.016403198, 0.0118255615, 0.007762909, -0.05783081, 0.032226562, -0.017822266, -0.008399963, 0.046844482, 0.024093628, -0.0017576218, 0.041870117, 0.017669678, -0.009269714, -0.018707275, -0.025863647, -0.027923584, 0.03466797, -0.022918701, -0.09234619, 0.00076675415, -0.012290955, -0.02482605, -0.028564453, -0.043640137, 0.011108398, 0.01159668, 0.048675537, -0.013137817, 0.0035877228, -0.024490356, -0.012512207, -0.0158844, -0.023925781, -0.03366089, -0.027038574, 0.011634827, 0.05355835, 0.028945923, -0.0035037994, -0.070617676, -0.051116943, -0.020141602, 0.01789856, 0.008895874, -0.021591187, -0.038909912, -0.058563232, -0.007850647, 0.0009627342, -0.01751709, -0.0022354126, -0.034973145, 0.0073776245, -0.017486572, 0.026672363, 0.009788513, 0.014259338, -0.013977051, 0.009170532, 0.036621094, -0.01725769, -0.046569824, 0.019546509, 0.022766113, 0.017562866, 0.028930664, -0.009613037, -0.008354187, -0.004875183, -0.041290283, 0.0013484955, 0.0181427, 0.018722534, -0.015312195, 0.0052490234, -0.030456543, 0.045654297, -0.055755615, -0.009170532, 0.0552063, -0.011245728, 0.013282776, -0.044677734, 0.009727478, 0.0011863708, -0.12121582, -0.010620117, -0.016723633, -0.01928711, -0.030761719, -0.02809143, -0.003824234, -0.020721436, -0.048065186, -0.006565094, -0.009048462, -0.020248413, 0.008110046, -0.06463623, -0.029525757, 0.06774902, -0.03967285, -0.002210617, 0.009223938, 0.0007805824, -0.013076782, -0.048339844, 0.002456665, -0.030303955, 0.042633057, -0.042541504, 0.008628845, 0.02734375, -0.018569946, 0.0009713173, 0.031921387, 0.032073975, -0.023468018, -0.010421753, 0.039794922, 0.039093018, -0.011390686, 0.041656494, 0.014976501, -0.016937256, -0.04928589, -0.011001587, -0.0018939972, 0.00061655045, 0.020095825, -0.008705139, 0.008735657, 0.017211914, 0.0024223328, 0.029159546, -0.021255493, -0.016342163, 0.02355957, -0.011169434, 0.00096416473, 0.018875122, -0.00087070465, 0.030715942, 0.0024642944, -0.01234436, -0.051849365, 0.004020691, -0.0046539307, -0.012199402, -0.022415161, -0.018981934, -0.03503418, -0.0036773682, -0.054504395, -0.0770874, -0.041229248, 0.016662598, 0.0011281967, 0.03668213, 0.013938904, -0.025222778, -0.037261963, 0.02015686, 0.029647827, -0.00724411, 0.019073486, -0.04333496, 0.018432617, -0.011878967, -0.03640747, -0.036499023, -0.021835327, -0.025177002, 0.0008702278, -0.011314392, 0.0138168335, 0.038604736, 0.0065345764, -0.018157959, 0.027770996, -0.022827148, -0.0010728836, 0.056488037, -0.028518677, -0.020889282, 0.020629883, 0.0007929802, -0.025360107, -0.029281616, 0.01777649, -0.014328003, -0.027679443, -0.039764404, 0.028808594, -0.024368286, 0.051513672, 0.043182373, 0.071899414, 0.034332275, 0.03994751, -0.009971619, 0.01802063, -0.039916992, -0.018493652, -0.020385742, 0.060455322, 0.0005021095, -0.008171082, 0.05480957, 0.032165527, -0.01033783, 0.0007324219, 0.0012264252, 0.017166138, 0.026412964, -0.009132385, 0.015914917, -0.0037078857, -0.021072388, 0.030044556, 0.0029563904, 0.036193848, -0.01184845, 0.032287598, 0.029632568, 0.0067100525, 0.025131226, -0.02708435, 0.041778564, 0.004299164, 0.014335632, -0.054718018, -0.01486969, 0.007133484, 0.02532959, -0.052001953, 0.013671875, -0.012199402, -0.0017738342, 0.01864624, 0.021102905, -0.0124053955, 0.030166626, -0.017440796, 0.0015039444, 0.011856079, -0.024002075, -0.046966553, 0.018203735, 0.026260376, 0.035064697, -0.04714966, 0.022033691, -0.06866455, -0.0054016113, 0.01134491, -0.015716553, 0.0020046234, -0.08666992, -0.005012512, 0.00491333, 0.0063667297, -0.0027275085, -0.00944519, -0.007835388, 0.02645874, 0.038635254, -0.0049743652, 0.028778076, 0.009124756, -0.022583008, 0.012413025, -0.023147583, 0.018997192, 0.0020542145, 0.030654907, 0.011474609, 0.032928467, -0.074035645, 0.013252258, -0.01689148, 0.01436615, -0.006046295, -0.03414917, -0.00894165, 0.05331421, 0.021942139, 0.02748108, 0.019363403, -0.04373169, -0.039398193, -0.0026817322, -0.08465576, 0.012084961, 0.0021076202, -0.043029785, -0.020950317, 0.036102295, -0.0041923523, 0.025665283, 0.0013723373, 0.0034751892, -0.044189453, 0.04434204, 0.033599854, -0.055908203, -0.024230957, 0.012763977, 0.019561768, 0.034088135, 0.015899658, -0.003786087, -0.0044174194, -0.022903442, -0.064819336, -0.03567505, 0.010482788, -0.009651184, 0.012542725, -0.01184845, -0.017410278, 0.015205383, 0.008743286, 0.030517578, 0.04675293, -0.050231934, 0.030059814, 0.024765015, 0.0259552, 0.006755829, 0.062683105, -0.019958496, 0.0030326843, 0.04043579, -0.027801514, 0.016418457, -0.023849487, -0.021102905, -0.007896423, -0.033721924, 0.0103302, 0.015182495, 0.007621765, -0.0058784485, 0.026641846, 0.023117065, 0.025512695, 0.007873535, 0.003124237, 0.05407715, -0.02609253, -0.08148193, 0.014724731, -0.0068359375, -0.0011301041, 0.05871582, 0.025299072, -0.05847168, -0.012428284, -0.047424316, -0.025619507, 0.00018620491, 0.022766113, 0.008201599, 0.023223877, -0.055633545, -0.018066406, -0.0038280487, -0.010757446, -0.010688782, 0.009681702, 0.015007019, -0.025527954, -0.012512207, 0.013679504, 0.026489258, -0.0435791, -0.027359009, -0.03729248, 0.0065231323, -0.028717041, -0.0127334595, 0.030563354, -0.020996094, -0.032806396, 0.061584473, -0.019134521, 0.018829346, 0.07940674, -0.026901245, 0.02784729, 0.036743164, 0.056854248, 0.035736084, 0.036224365, 0.050201416, 0.022857666, 0.020309448, -0.019088745, 0.02935791, -0.03955078, -0.015716553, -0.05847168, -0.020645142, -0.08520508, 0.0033073425, 0.015686035, 0.015106201, -0.02923584, 0.017593384, 0.0054016113, -0.0036907196, 0.0592041, -0.036193848, 0.06555176, 0.01928711, -0.010345459, -0.029647827, 0.028060913, 0.007003784, 0.029647827, 0.015037537, 0.01499176, -0.03845215, -0.02116394, 0.0015010834, 0.026779175, 0.0033855438, 0.0074882507, -0.015342712, -0.025985718, 0.030349731, 0.011634827, 0.033355713, 0.058441162, 0.021453857, 0.029190063, -0.0435791, 0.0020160675, 0.0030021667, -0.053894043, 0.04147339, 0.062286377, -0.07879639, 0.035308838, -0.040985107, -0.039733887, 0.022598267, -0.025131226, 0.054748535, -0.10229492, -0.093566895, -0.010848999, 0.050445557, 0.006839752, 0.04449463, -0.030670166, -0.028289795, -0.018341064, 0.03161621, 0.018569946, 0.02722168, -0.029968262, 0.044281006, -0.016830444, 0.010055542, -0.0062942505, 0.020248413, -0.04522705, 0.015205383, -0.019714355, 0.003189087, 0.016021729, -0.027694702, 0.027404785, -0.0017614365, -0.028549194, 0.020507812, -0.03338623, 0.04446411, 0.044708252, 0.049041748, 0.0038204193, -0.015899658, 0.016998291, -0.051879883, 0.04135132, 0.03353882, -0.011688232, 0.056793213, -0.050476074, -0.040649414, 0.061523438, -0.046051025, 0.06304932, -0.017089844, 0.0034103394, -0.012336731, -0.017044067, 0.05609131, -0.048736572, 0.004020691, -0.018753052, 0.0027179718, -0.0098724365, -0.010429382, -0.04788208, -0.0181427, -0.0029411316, 0.027999878, 0.010513306, -0.012702942, -0.021408081, -0.017730713, -0.05834961, -0.013252258, -0.032684326, 0.02671814, -0.013473511, -0.023223877, -0.0060691833, -0.0055770874, 0.017440796, -0.052856445, -0.03918457, -0.05480957, -0.02281189, -0.034179688, 0.0045394897, -0.004863739, -0.009391785, 0.039398193, 0.010467529, 0.016235352, -0.0051460266, -0.0006966591, 0.0030574799, -0.025009155, -0.042541504, -0.0025119781, -0.04425049, 0.007572174, 0.009651184, -0.037994385, 0.03869629, -0.019607544, -0.044677734, -0.037475586, 0.004386902, 0.035888672, -0.030227661, -0.061553955, 0.03277588, 0.024810791, 0.029815674, -0.031799316, -0.029220581, 0.02760315, 0.0068740845, 0.020080566, 0.034057617, 0.0063819885, -0.019119263, 0.0040283203, 0.004928589, 0.0049209595, -0.03439331, -0.027450562, -0.01474762, -0.001821518, 0.025100708, 0.028442383, -0.047027588, 0.0065231323, 0.005130768, 0.0076446533, 0.0082473755, -0.0036849976, -0.007843018, -0.011062622, -0.0023097992, -0.040985107, -0.0027275085, -0.0017700195, -0.0041542053, -0.0022449493, 0.008041382, 0.00283432, 0.006401062, -0.022521973, 0.06793213, -0.005645752, -0.021743774, 0.005203247, 0.034973145, 0.0019340515, 0.06933594, -0.04852295, -0.011238098, 0.010597229, 0.0060653687, -0.01663208, 0.00623703, 0.021469116, -0.00020265579, -0.008613586, -0.010314941, -0.051849365, 0.050628662, -0.021652222, 0.03640747, -0.04348755, 0.02218628, -0.02722168, -0.034057617, 0.0026988983, 0.019180298, 0.03765869, -0.03149414, -0.052856445, -0.039764404, 0.06048584, -0.0042877197 ], "summary": [ 0.04837036, 0.011169434, 0.011207581, -0.011047363, -0.015197754, -0.021713257, -0.017974854, -0.028015137, -0.04916382, 0.035705566, -0.030578613, 0.045715332, -0.017593384, -0.011405945, 0.03265381, -0.009231567, -0.026687622, 0.037139893, 0.010536194, -0.050231934, 0.022827148, -0.06591797, 0.024475098, -0.026229858, -0.00013029575, -0.00642395, 0.021484375, -0.008964539, -0.003955841, -0.024124146, 0.004310608, 0.024765015, 0.008224487, 0.037384033, -0.017486572, -0.031143188, -0.017791748, 0.031158447, -0.0028877258, 0.03387451, -0.0066375732, 0.019210815, 0.029220581, -0.030792236, -0.0027770996, -0.030212402, 0.016342163, -0.0209198, 0.009124756, -0.013771057, 0.006980896, 0.025863647, 0.019561768, -0.00258255, -0.027450562, 0.0030994415, -0.0102005005, 0.0047340393, 0.007217407, 0.034973145, -0.0051345825, 0.016586304, -0.0033016205, -0.019577026, 0.0006093979, -0.00944519, 0.035308838, 0.0009860992, 0.0069351196, -0.006210327, 0.025741577, 0.010047913, 0.04043579, 0.000582695, -0.026947021, -0.0024871826, 0.050048828, 0.037322998, -0.00093603134, -0.020874023, -0.059387207, -0.011543274, -0.031951904, -0.039733887, -0.024383545, -0.015777588, -0.025482178, 0.01537323, 0.017196655, 0.015899658, -0.0040740967, 0.024505615, 0.008384705, 0.03656006, 0.0048103333, -0.018234253, 0.061462402, 0.07940674, 0.0021629333, -0.012214661, -0.008110046, -0.026779175, -0.009231567, -0.033203125, -0.0418396, -0.044189453, 0.050445557, 0.015838623, -0.039794922, 0.028717041, -0.04824829, -0.03741455, 0.050476074, 0.062805176, -0.03878784, -0.050842285, -0.0009570122, 0.019485474, -0.047790527, 0.0012569427, 0.01474762, 0.038085938, 0.009376526, 0.028244019, -0.047729492, -0.013008118, -0.0027999878, -0.033691406, 0.021713257, 0.004699707, -0.018356323, 0.0038414001, -0.031311035, -0.017913818, -0.015945435, -0.008644104, -0.024963379, -0.04119873, 0.008331299, -0.021820068, 0.0105896, 0.015716553, 0.07366943, -0.0032653809, 0.033569336, 0.005001068, 0.028198242, 0.0035743713, -0.004890442, 0.014045715, -0.007850647, 0.05899048, 0.037261963, -0.02104187, -0.04119873, -0.07244873, -0.06677246, -0.03390503, 0.053985596, -0.03164673, 0.0067481995, 0.02166748, 0.0345459, 0.037017822, 0.033996582, -0.033294678, 0.00920105, 0.016815186, 0.005279541, 0.036010742, -0.014831543, 0.02796936, -0.014007568, -0.017120361, -0.016906738, -0.028381348, -0.009666443, -0.012062073, 0.0007581711, -0.009735107, 0.0073127747, -0.020980835, -0.022155762, 0.03866577, -0.02720642, -0.014907837, 0.002199173, 0.008659363, 0.009918213, -0.0003399849, -0.0032520294, 0.03366089, -0.03857422, 0.016403198, -0.031829834, 0.00207901, -0.034423828, 0.02355957, -0.025238037, 0.01586914, 0.037994385, -0.022460938, -0.0011491776, -0.0435791, -0.090270996, -0.026397705, -0.015823364, 0.02973938, 0.00092458725, -0.011421204, 0.012039185, -0.022033691, -0.030059814, 0.041748047, -0.03479004, -0.031799316, 0.02017212, -0.06304932, -0.029632568, -0.05407715, -0.028305054, 0.017044067, -0.06512451, 0.08862305, 0.020996094, -0.032226562, -0.004371643, -0.032287598, 0.056152344, -0.05758667, 0.11785889, 0.031951904, -0.038970947, 0.027236938, 0.023651123, -0.0062065125, 0.007648468, -0.041748047, 0.042663574, 0.0075798035, 0.006587982, 0.0039138794, -0.03933716, 0.010276794, 0.0039520264, 0.012649536, 0.008483887, -0.00522995, 0.018157959, 0.009857178, -0.006702423, -0.02104187, 0.026275635, -0.05734253, 0.0413208, 0.020065308, -0.027923584, 0.001420021, 0.0065994263, -0.0052604675, 0.007255554, -0.018447876, 0.006275177, -0.017822266, 0.01586914, -0.084472656, -0.020217896, -0.03552246, 0.019973755, -0.0597229, 0.016830444, -0.04473877, -0.018478394, -0.031677246, -0.030227661, -0.0496521, -0.040740967, 0.066833496, -0.00037431717, -0.05255127, -0.0039405823, -0.0011644363, 0.024551392, -0.013908386, 0.053222656, 0.06011963, 0.005241394, -0.03543091, -0.0021381378, 0.0035552979, 0.01852417, 0.025024414, -0.042907715, 0.052764893, 0.010047913, -0.028305054, -0.016220093, 0.01876831, 0.0016326904, -0.013015747, -0.029067993, 0.033996582, 0.008369446, -0.0039901733, -0.0049209595, -0.021942139, -0.04031372, 0.033477783, 0.020629883, -0.056671143, 0.03540039, 0.054016113, 0.03286743, -0.021881104, 0.02720642, 0.0037822723, 0.0027675629, 0.032928467, 0.020111084, 0.077819824, 0.07928467, 0.031188965, -0.019485474, 0.022628784, 0.007408142, -0.044158936, 0.02708435, -0.039398193, -0.016021729, -0.017044067, 0.01386261, -0.021865845, -0.03225708, 0.008026123, 0.021392822, -0.0032405853, 0.0014028549, -0.021636963, -0.0060768127, -0.016494751, 0.0035305023, 0.024932861, -0.0031833649, -0.040618896, -0.00869751, -0.010276794, 0.012321472, 0.0016746521, 0.033691406, 0.023651123, -0.03488159, -0.009963989, -0.03050232, 0.002571106, 0.0037345886, 0.031280518, 0.036865234, 0.013717651, 0.047576904, -0.028503418, 0.03805542, -0.01209259, -0.017822266, -0.08258057, -0.0256958, 0.015960693, -0.012397766, -0.02835083, 0.053619385, 0.042388916, -0.042785645, 0.044921875, -0.009384155, -0.006816864, 0.035369873, 0.00024747849, 0.004611969, -0.030593872, 0.07244873, 0.013122559, -0.00031352043, -0.016204834, 0.04776001, 0.00025200844, 0.12609863, 0.0010232925, 0.06323242, 0.06011963, 0.07989502, -0.009223938, 0.0008468628, -0.043701172, 0.029388428, -0.026473999, 0.0053253174, -0.009269714, 0.04397583, 0.03781128, 0.032043457, -0.04663086, 0.017074585, 0.02571106, 0.038360596, -0.0107040405, -0.008232117, 0.014808655, -0.0015468597, 0.011680603, 0.039916992, -0.0037345886, 0.002702713, 0.014137268, -0.008399963, 0.0048675537, -0.021194458, 0.0006079674, 0.074523926, 0.019866943, -0.006969452, -0.07684326, -0.0017995834, 0.02319336, 0.011138916, -0.028518677, -0.043548584, 0.0041923523, -0.015808105, 0.04360962, -0.028686523, 0.048614502, 0.008049011, -0.010414124, -0.014541626, 0.0016717911, -0.032043457, -0.009742737, -0.0003027916, -0.0010099411, 0.0519104, -0.039154053, -0.06402588, -0.027359009, -0.021072388, 0.03488159, 0.01638794, -0.00023365021, -0.055023193, -0.072143555, -0.0020503998, 0.026473999, -0.014289856, 0.011367798, 0.03451538, 0.03414917, -0.0234375, -0.015113831, -0.008720398, 0.037109375, -0.004917145, -0.0056915283, 0.029083252, -0.0067100525, -0.017791748, 0.002122879, -0.000030636787, 0.026657104, 0.034240723, 0.0028152466, -0.013511658, 0.0009851456, -0.0025691986, -0.016357422, -0.007713318, -0.0048980713, -0.013442993, -0.034332275, 0.02067566, 0.030395508, 0.005138397, -0.0413208, -0.015281677, 0.019561768, 0.001578331, -0.04788208, -0.034362793, 0.008605957, -0.07470703, -0.040039062, 0.005458832, -0.028244019, 0.007484436, -0.03591919, 0.013267517, -0.026992798, -0.019500732, -0.016662598, -0.028869629, 0.13085938, 0.042266846, -0.030288696, 0.0034675598, -0.027236938, -0.034606934, -0.03918457, -0.046447754, 0.05038452, 0.064086914, -0.01713562, 0.016052246, -0.06427002, 0.05508423, -0.06317139, 0.038757324, 0.0058670044, -0.019989014, -0.055541992, 0.047821045, 0.036376953, -0.053619385, -0.014671326, 0.09515381, 0.08685303, -0.04888916, -0.0011301041, 0.060546875, -0.019638062, -0.059631348, -0.014968872, 0.0012979507, -0.0017137527, 0.013587952, 0.010429382, 0.0016956329, 0.01676941, 0.0009007454, -0.00046658516, -0.021087646, -0.03616333, 0.034606934, 0.04788208, 0.0030765533, 0.018325806, -0.017654419, 0.07409668, -0.011222839, -0.03930664, -0.0413208, -0.0256958, -0.0013570786, -0.026000977, 0.0053634644, -0.0038051605, -0.029907227, -0.0099487305, -0.011924744, -0.016311646, -0.053497314, 0.009544373, -0.0023345947, 0.039611816, -0.019515991, -0.005695343, 0.00856781, 0.007965088, 0.021652222, 0.03225708, 0.0051231384, -0.04296875, -0.0031318665, -0.00945282, -0.040740967, -0.029846191, -0.052978516, -0.050811768, -0.019836426, 0.0043678284, -0.0047035217, 0.020065308, -0.0042877197, -0.028442383, -0.003004074, -0.008369446, 0.0041885376, -0.014976501, -0.031143188, 0.021011353, 0.020339966, 0.008171082, -0.009216309, 0.008155823, 0.020401001, -0.00844574, -0.050994873, -0.0793457, 0.015625, 0.0035171509, 0.031951904, 0.10253906, 0.06561279, 0.03753662, 0.013290405, -0.024810791, 0.008476257, -0.024017334, 0.021606445, -0.03933716, 0.007007599, 0.0052719116, -0.016448975, 0.028518677, -0.005771637, -0.018493652, 0.0016870499, -0.000023841858, 0.00655365, 0.02645874, 0.004245758, 0.000726223, 0.041503906, 0.0015640259, 0.046936035, 0.0079422, 0.029922485, 0.051116943, -0.03778076, 0.038085938, 0.017532349, 0.021896362, -0.015533447, 0.03475952, 0.015625, -0.001452446, -0.012557983, 0.012252808, 0.0067443848, -0.0070152283, -0.014579773, -0.0064849854, -0.033599854, -0.016143799, 0.009735107, -0.013580322, -0.016159058, 0.0049362183, -0.028152466, -0.0061950684, 0.027526855, -0.0009212494, -0.035186768, -0.011314392, 0.0067749023, 0.004760742, -0.014343262, 0.0109939575, -0.014343262, -0.016326904, -0.00016844273, -0.017242432, 0.0069885254, -0.0637207, -0.09124756, -0.05038452, -0.0064048767, -0.05368042, 0.020385742, -0.042663574, -0.0012483597, 0.013580322, -0.031555176, -0.00013041496, -0.03125, -0.03665161, 0.01675415, -0.032470703, 0.008605957, 0.034210205, 0.021621704, 0.011688232, 0.040374756, -0.046295166, -0.015449524, -0.022415161, 0.059906006, -0.027160645, -0.02545166, 0.00843811, 0.002155304, 0.0154418945, 0.02619934, 0.0423584, 0.010284424, -0.01991272, 0.02961731, -0.05001831, -0.02999878, -0.00349617, 0.014587402, 0.010551453, 0.035125732, -0.04977417, 0.024719238, 0.023620605, -0.019226074, 0.018661499, 0.008338928, -0.005214691, -0.049560547, -0.010597229, 0.036468506, 0.036712646, -0.012840271, -0.02053833, -0.007217407, 0.004108429, -0.036132812, -0.041107178, -0.06347656, -0.03717041, -0.025665283, 0.07946777, -0.014480591, -0.025924683, 0.0026760101, -0.021408081, -0.0005440712, -0.013923645, -0.015182495, -0.001616478, -0.01360321, -0.015464783, 0.021209717, 0.040222168, -0.064331055, 0.017166138, 0.05154419, -0.05105591, 0.04269409, -0.009239197, 0.021774292, 0.0027046204, -0.054138184, 0.016189575, 0.023712158, 0.018203735, -0.009986877, 0.0009012222, -0.0031909943, 0.0033721924, 0.0007138252, -0.010940552, 0.011802673, 0.012435913, -0.020339966, 0.01763916, 0.020980835, -0.02949524, -0.019104004, 0.049560547, 0.019226074, -0.011734009, -0.029525757, -0.005748749, -0.003376007, 0.0065689087, -0.0036582947, 0.020523071, 0.019332886, 0.019378662, -0.003282547, -0.008087158, -0.021697998, 0.035003662, -0.010070801, -0.02003479, 0.0029678345, -0.0021381378, 0.022705078, -0.016433716, -0.019744873, -0.026275635, 0.013473511, -0.02848816, 0.026123047, 0.03201294, -0.03668213, 0.0005836487, 0.049346924, 0.011299133, 0.031097412, 0.05618286, 0.021774292, -0.01361084, 0.029876709, 0.051605225, 0.0005135536, 0.015037537, 0.052520752, 0.027648926, 0.0050964355, -0.0067825317, 0.043701172, -0.03262329, -0.040130615, -0.047088623, -0.040802002, -0.016021729, -0.008903503, -0.0068855286, -0.005886078, 0.00409317, 0.017349243, 0.010879517, 0.0262146, -0.014343262, -0.02017212, 0.021224976, -0.00970459, -0.0023880005, -0.052978516, 0.032592773, 0.00032138824, 0.026473999, 0.025421143, 0.039855957, 0.0012216568, -0.0026378632, 0.019500732, -0.010894775, -0.011756897, -0.058166504, 0.015327454, -0.041503906, 0.0140686035, 0.018066406, 0.01876831, 0.010185242, -0.0395813, 0.14379883, -0.07043457, -0.012832642, 0.028640747, -0.03894043, 0.041290283, 0.021392822, -0.0038414001, 0.0079422, -0.019973755, -0.03286743, 0.08251953, -0.06933594, 0.07977295, -0.09375, -0.06958008, -0.0259552, 0.027160645, -0.054260254, 0.024490356, -0.032684326, -0.035736084, -0.035888672, 0.0049209595, 0.008010864, -0.0059280396, -0.04949951, 0.039886475, -0.013679504, 0.04650879, -0.025665283, 0.016799927, -0.06402588, 0.011169434, -0.025543213, -0.0079422, 0.059692383, -0.0022506714, 0.0065460205, 0.02911377, 0.02142334, 0.042785645, -0.043273926, 0.0063438416, 0.021224976, 0.016906738, -0.04034424, 0.005874634, 0.03387451, -0.0016841888, 0.01828003, 0.023605347, 0.0012407303, 0.013664246, -0.021560669, -0.0049934387, 0.015731812, -0.026290894, 0.0105896, -0.019607544, -0.014122009, -0.026367188, 0.0008330345, -0.021591187, -0.009346008, 0.010643005, -0.0519104, 0.012382507, 0.0010557175, -0.012336731, -0.08319092, 0.005306244, -0.037078857, -0.019012451, -0.009521484, 0.0014829636, 0.02798462, -0.011047363, -0.06933594, 0.024276733, 0.007423401, 0.064208984, -0.004878998, -0.02619934, 0.01474762, -0.00907135, 0.008018494, -0.059783936, -0.03225708, -0.025115967, 0.0057640076, -0.078125, 0.019897461, -0.0017747879, -0.029937744, 0.0051574707, 0.057159424, -0.013923645, 0.008399963, -0.010498047, 0.028762817, 0.024871826, -0.058410645, -0.011123657, -0.042022705, -0.023834229, -0.025238037, -0.004310608, 0.015045166, 0.018203735, -0.018493652, -0.051116943, -0.013931274, -0.018966675, -0.014190674, -0.021194458, -0.008987427, 0.022994995, 0.027053833, -0.027526855, -0.0073890686, 0.032043457, 0.036376953, 0.0019445419, -0.02406311, -0.017974854, -0.0017604828, 0.040802002, 0.029220581, 0.008087158, -0.032165527, 0.009269714, -0.0095825195, -0.0057525635, 0.0059890747, -0.0032634735, -0.013626099, 0.00592041, -0.013893127, 0.0070152283, 0.02268982, -0.0031833649, -0.018936157, -0.01914978, -0.022598267, -0.03967285, -0.028045654, -0.030639648, 0.0030822754, -0.0066223145, -0.00072431564, -0.013450623, 0.03074646, -0.026031494, -0.00036978722, 0.017364502, -0.0040016174, -0.017486572, 0.012916565, 0.023544312, 0.020050049, -0.005657196, -0.03704834, 0.041900635, 0.0017242432, -0.022705078, -0.0032863617, 0.052642822, -0.0025024414, -0.046020508, -0.018005371, -0.045776367, 0.06121826, -0.0026245117, 0.01361084, -0.068725586, 0.036895752, -0.0184021, -0.03060913, 0.0075912476, 0.021316528, -0.0093688965, -0.002729416, 0.0032901764, -0.012207031, -0.0017089844, 0.002603531 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.08828v1
Explainable AI for a No-Teardown Vehicle Component Cost Estimation: A Top-Down Approach
Ayman Moawad, Ehsan Islam, Namdoo Kim, Ram Vijayagopal, Aymeric Rousseau, Wei Biao Wu
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
The broader ambition of this article is to popularize an approach for the fair distribution of the quantity of a system's output to its subsystems, while allowing for underlying complex subsystem level interactions. Particularly, we present a data-driven approach to vehicle price modeling and its component price estimation by leveraging a combination of concepts from machine learning and game theory. We show an alternative to common teardown methodologies and surveying approaches for component and vehicle price estimation at the manufacturer's suggested retail price (MSRP) level that has the advantage of bypassing the uncertainties involved in 1) the gathering of teardown data, 2) the need to perform expensive and biased surveying, and 3) the need to perform retail price equivalent (RPE) or indirect cost multiplier (ICM) adjustments to mark up direct manufacturing costs to MSRP. This novel exercise not only provides accurate pricing of the technologies at the customer level, but also shows the, a priori known, large gaps in pricing strategies between manufacturers, vehicle sizes, classes, market segments, and other factors. There is also clear synergism or interaction between the price of certain technologies and other specifications present in the same vehicle. Those (unsurprising) results are indication that old methods of manufacturer-level component costing, aggregation, and the application of a flat and rigid RPE or ICM adjustment factor should be carefully examined. The findings are based on an extensive database, developed by Argonne National Laboratory, that includes more than 64,000 vehicles covering MY1990 to MY2020 over hundreds of vehicle specs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.08828v1
2020-06-15T23:47:19
2020-06-15T23:47:19
{ "title": [ -0.03945923, -0.020477295, -0.012176514, -0.04824829, -0.049041748, 0.009292603, -0.046173096, -0.00907135, -0.03479004, -0.010437012, -0.04269409, 0.016235352, -0.018814087, -0.03060913, 0.058135986, -0.029174805, 0.012031555, 0.014007568, 0.0018825531, -0.013214111, -0.03100586, -0.0025978088, 0.034057617, 0.0357666, 0.025558472, 0.008506775, -0.07727051, 0.0006341934, 0.0016527176, -0.0042419434, -0.0016899109, -0.0033187866, -0.01260376, -0.023010254, 0.091918945, 0.04107666, -0.014022827, 0.044067383, 0.07446289, -0.041290283, -0.007671356, 0.0018577576, -0.020385742, -0.024765015, -0.030700684, 0.017669678, -0.06817627, 0.0088272095, 0.010955811, 0.031341553, -0.0026626587, 0.004005432, 0.0034217834, 0.010475159, -0.0063819885, -0.027435303, -0.03466797, -0.012435913, 0.03488159, 0.00010538101, 0.0066184998, -0.034118652, 0.040618896, -0.014144897, -0.022766113, -0.03466797, 0.0020809174, 0.028366089, 0.048950195, -0.00894928, 0.007457733, 0.042510986, 0.012329102, 0.029373169, -0.034729004, -0.09277344, 0.06732178, -0.023086548, 0.008995056, 0.005382538, -0.01876831, -0.00051403046, 0.005821228, -0.012634277, -0.028686523, -0.014663696, -0.018188477, 0.010414124, -0.06317139, -0.030944824, -0.038360596, 0.004688263, -0.050689697, -0.010528564, -0.012001038, -0.02658081, 0.0149002075, 0.05618286, 0.001077652, -0.018310547, -0.004535675, -0.002494812, -0.029571533, -0.029144287, 0.038757324, 0.021362305, 0.007209778, 0.012313843, 0.035003662, -0.0045776367, -0.029052734, 0.06677246, -0.0051078796, -0.050994873, 0.020599365, 0.023284912, -0.031463623, 0.04812622, 0.031219482, 0.033721924, -0.011657715, -0.0129776, 0.008514404, 0.025421143, 0.027755737, -0.004196167, -0.02947998, 0.01637268, 0.018249512, 0.061553955, -0.028839111, 0.033721924, -0.017440796, -0.08276367, -0.05432129, -0.0048561096, 0.004386902, 0.008071899, 0.011619568, -0.009849548, 0.02482605, -0.008918762, 0.031036377, 0.040924072, -0.0012588501, -0.01586914, 0.052764893, 0.040252686, -0.032989502, -0.053466797, 0.01600647, 0.046661377, 0.02659607, -0.007068634, -0.062286377, -0.03201294, -0.105651855, -0.002828598, 0.033813477, -0.009231567, 0.03186035, 0.01171875, -0.0035381317, 0.032684326, 0.06365967, -0.033447266, 0.013847351, 0.030975342, 0.012458801, 0.03591919, 0.04324341, -0.024795532, -0.035247803, -0.015640259, -0.00856781, -0.012672424, 0.009338379, 0.021377563, 0.0058517456, -0.043426514, -0.010108948, -0.024398804, 0.008903503, 0.022460938, -0.062927246, -0.02381897, -0.015823364, -0.0064086914, 0.06317139, -0.004219055, 0.018707275, 0.008979797, -0.059387207, -0.016571045, -0.022720337, 0.013313293, -0.027404785, 0.022659302, -0.010772705, -0.0017967224, -0.060913086, 0.038635254, -0.0104599, 0.045135498, 0.020141602, 0.00014948845, -0.00084733963, 0.023849487, -0.06072998, 0.07836914, 0.0803833, 0.04006958, -0.06573486, 0.041625977, 0.047210693, -0.10028076, -0.00944519, -0.027633667, -0.04296875, -0.042114258, -0.017684937, -0.05154419, -0.019515991, 0.05987549, 0.017562866, 0.05682373, -0.010154724, 0.0007519722, 0.06298828, 0.058410645, 0.06530762, -0.037384033, 0.01675415, 0.039794922, -0.0027999878, -0.005847931, 0.01789856, 0.004486084, 0.011138916, 0.0038661957, 0.0011711121, 0.0012550354, 0.0075302124, 0.05834961, 0.053649902, 0.00056648254, 0.0013952255, 0.028915405, 0.017410278, 0.0039749146, 0.09631348, -0.02381897, 0.049224854, 0.05319214, 0.011802673, 0.024353027, -0.015319824, 0.005859375, -0.0115737915, 0.013923645, 0.0020141602, 0.013130188, 0.043548584, -0.0044136047, -0.004184723, 0.039794922, 0.023452759, 0.05239868, -0.042633057, 0.018539429, 0.027175903, 0.06451416, 0.007972717, -0.021026611, -0.070739746, -0.0013456345, -0.042388916, 0.038482666, 0.020568848, -0.05230713, 0.009490967, 0.049468994, 0.056488037, -0.0071144104, 0.0036296844, 0.014480591, 0.029266357, 0.008239746, -0.05050659, -0.011749268, 0.052642822, 0.01789856, 0.005001068, -0.032165527, 0.034179688, -0.0017871857, -0.0035057068, 0.07531738, -0.030715942, 0.032714844, -0.09259033, 0.006790161, 0.032684326, -0.035491943, 0.023742676, -0.006034851, 0.020355225, -0.006893158, -0.023361206, 0.053833008, -0.11395264, -0.0007724762, 0.0035209656, -0.005569458, -0.031707764, -0.037017822, -0.01828003, -0.017044067, -0.032348633, 0.00025439262, 0.028625488, -0.028518677, -0.006011963, -0.0095825195, -0.022720337, -0.01550293, 0.0013742447, -0.013549805, -0.029220581, 0.008834839, 0.026473999, -0.018478394, -0.0635376, -0.0072364807, 0.0035476685, 0.032226562, -0.010810852, 0.017562866, -0.01776123, -0.007030487, 0.0016956329, 0.025222778, 0.0035800934, -0.013015747, 0.031585693, -0.035461426, -0.014984131, 0.007663727, -0.060516357, -0.000026106834, 0.025894165, -0.0082473755, -0.023254395, -0.039031982, 0.036865234, -0.03717041, -0.01826477, -0.005180359, 0.020568848, -0.037353516, 0.01675415, 0.03753662, -0.0009422302, -0.043426514, 0.0011415482, -0.0395813, -0.03616333, 0.019943237, -0.032196045, 0.00642395, -0.053955078, -0.013626099, -0.03149414, -0.018493652, -0.029464722, 0.037750244, 0.018218994, -0.01386261, -0.03363037, -0.016342163, 0.004245758, -0.0024318695, -0.010726929, 0.0004775524, 0.053375244, 0.03488159, 0.02166748, 0.023788452, -0.010009766, -0.022537231, -0.04626465, -0.012016296, -0.024673462, 0.007068634, 0.005847931, -0.0030155182, -0.048736572, -0.012031555, -0.09820557, 0.03918457, 0.0104904175, 0.019012451, 0.004753113, 0.01309967, -0.04171753, 0.017242432, -0.013511658, -0.009460449, 0.034423828, 0.02609253, 0.011360168, -0.0048294067, 0.0231781, -0.031051636, -0.002035141, -0.025100708, -0.05596924, 0.0317688, -0.029174805, -0.047058105, 0.014930725, -0.001373291, -0.028549194, -0.04736328, -0.0005669594, 0.055755615, 0.034423828, -0.0009031296, -0.015853882, -0.058380127, 0.023468018, -0.07409668, -0.021270752, -0.035583496, 0.012832642, 0.03338623, -0.026229858, 0.05911255, -0.021697998, 0.038208008, 0.0095825195, -0.010169983, -0.020462036, -0.001698494, -0.0047912598, -0.030914307, 0.0016641617, 0.014579773, -0.051574707, -0.0040397644, -0.019622803, 0.021194458, -0.0446167, 0.015548706, -0.019058228, 0.016159058, -0.00016856194, 0.027633667, 0.017654419, -0.009132385, -0.0047035217, -0.020614624, -0.024215698, 0.018585205, -0.010498047, -0.0058250427, 0.041503906, -0.031188965, -0.035705566, 0.015312195, -0.049835205, 0.026184082, 0.0038032532, -0.005458832, 0.012077332, 0.023498535, -0.0259552, -0.02168274, -0.0035896301, 0.019332886, -0.0058174133, 0.006916046, 0.04296875, -0.026901245, -0.014503479, 0.031829834, -0.06506348, -0.0070724487, -0.009147644, 0.0019235611, -0.016464233, -0.0041389465, 0.014625549, -0.036071777, -0.04321289, 0.028030396, 0.017044067, -0.034698486, -0.045684814, -0.07330322, -0.08850098, 0.05102539, -0.019119263, 0.053863525, 0.01977539, 0.002981186, -0.015167236, -0.013458252, 0.009124756, 0.0115737915, 0.010902405, -0.003250122, 0.023742676, 0.05545044, -0.032073975, 0.019424438, 0.0059661865, 0.019989014, -0.029678345, 0.02204895, -0.0259552, 0.020477295, -0.039489746, 0.07556152, 0.022903442, -0.027359009, -0.06591797, 0.024673462, -0.0008177757, -0.04788208, 0.037109375, 0.025421143, -0.0013103485, 0.034576416, -0.00016236305, 0.014968872, -0.004348755, 0.04058838, 0.02003479, -0.062805176, -0.0036716461, -0.001657486, 0.009162903, -0.02130127, 0.0059776306, 0.00920105, -0.0077400208, 0.059509277, -0.019973755, 0.021026611, -0.010353088, -0.004310608, -0.00091314316, -0.017913818, -0.039031982, 0.0070343018, -0.0037403107, -0.024749756, -0.013648987, 0.058013916, 0.03866577, 0.009689331, -0.028656006, -0.008224487, 0.043670654, 0.0065689087, -0.02456665, -0.09033203, 0.018661499, -0.039031982, -0.087768555, -0.07183838, -0.027694702, 0.011924744, -0.0009946823, 0.0051727295, -0.019958496, 0.017074585, 0.031799316, 0.04437256, 0.045196533, 0.017868042, -0.035949707, 0.055908203, -0.023498535, -0.01058197, 0.00040555, 0.02494812, -0.0070343018, -0.023651123, 0.024917603, -0.014709473, -0.005332947, -0.026687622, 0.018585205, -0.017288208, 0.02909851, -0.029525757, 0.013076782, 0.0075912476, 0.029327393, -0.0071640015, -0.0035858154, -0.04321289, 0.037597656, -0.020706177, 0.065979004, -0.027130127, -0.0010271072, 0.01210022, 0.02154541, -0.04043579, 0.009613037, 0.020553589, 0.030059814, 0.0074424744, -0.025665283, 0.056884766, 0.029312134, -0.006942749, 0.025604248, 0.02330017, 0.018966675, -0.07055664, 0.035095215, -0.0181427, -0.0013036728, 0.018432617, -0.0051078796, 0.018112183, 0.0047340393, 0.00052309036, -0.009857178, -0.07019043, 0.0096206665, 0.056671143, 0.0015649796, -0.007156372, -0.032226562, 0.03756714, 0.029907227, 0.017700195, -0.006591797, -0.02583313, 0.027755737, -0.0053863525, -0.01133728, 0.00793457, -0.012748718, -0.0057296753, -0.01828003, 0.0015478134, -0.039794922, 0.03265381, -0.024169922, 0.030288696, -0.015991211, -0.016525269, 0.06347656, -0.039978027, -0.00014662743, 0.0871582, -0.018371582, 0.027374268, -0.022323608, 0.013343811, -0.0016870499, 0.041748047, -0.02658081, 0.011016846, 0.034484863, -0.037017822, 0.018112183, 0.0072669983, 0.027709961, 0.0074539185, 0.015701294, 0.0124435425, 0.019500732, -0.04336548, 0.03164673, 0.043121338, 0.014259338, 0.0058937073, -0.04751587, 0.045135498, 0.006511688, -0.009895325, -0.01373291, -0.012367249, -0.041931152, 0.027664185, -0.026443481, 0.027496338, 0.0062332153, -0.0132369995, -0.02822876, -0.029815674, -0.009986877, -0.0043678284, 0.003396988, 0.010047913, 0.0340271, -0.017791748, 0.003250122, 0.012237549, -0.027954102, 0.012168884, 0.0026302338, 0.0127334595, 0.036315918, 0.0016860962, -0.050872803, -0.00011664629, 0.002216339, -0.044189453, -0.030563354, 0.011703491, 0.0036792755, 0.015731812, -0.03353882, -0.028320312, -0.008308411, 0.016693115, 0.03036499, 0.025405884, -0.068481445, 0.013511658, 0.0024757385, 0.03781128, 0.025009155, 0.023483276, 0.026443481, 0.009857178, 0.0206604, -0.043701172, 0.030853271, -0.011917114, -0.013198853, -0.028778076, -0.02822876, -0.007736206, 0.013313293, -0.021453857, -0.011192322, 0.0002104044, 0.02279663, -0.036071777, -0.0007519722, 0.0036945343, 0.08135986, -0.06518555, -0.02885437, -0.019622803, 0.005214691, -0.054901123, 0.03274536, 0.023712158, -0.0062065125, -0.031707764, -0.0340271, -0.029815674, -0.007133484, 0.02947998, -0.007282257, 0.02053833, -0.0501709, -0.055664062, -0.03643799, -0.005264282, -0.014472961, 0.032073975, -0.014266968, -0.0061912537, 0.013717651, -0.0064964294, -0.0046844482, -0.00033903122, 0.02810669, 0.028900146, -0.017745972, 0.042663574, -0.054779053, -0.014549255, -0.035308838, 0.0016698837, 0.025360107, 0.025543213, -0.01977539, 0.023132324, -0.010681152, 0.04208374, 0.021621704, 0.02166748, 0.026290894, 0.04196167, 0.009422302, -0.0011234283, 0.00017929077, -0.019638062, 0.02583313, -0.070007324, -0.0044670105, -0.031921387, -0.015274048, -0.09674072, -0.03125, 0.042510986, 0.052703857, 0.0018119812, 0.002161026, 0.026641846, 0.008216858, 0.005531311, -0.0029563904, 0.06335449, 0.033111572, 0.022415161, -0.019104004, 0.00084400177, -0.0066986084, 0.0018014908, 0.0024490356, 0.02960205, -0.02041626, 0.017440796, 0.010856628, -0.016143799, 0.019744873, -0.012245178, 0.016830444, -0.003932953, 0.031097412, -0.009635925, -0.0029830933, 0.060668945, 0.024108887, 0.0039749146, -0.034210205, 0.03286743, -0.00011861324, -0.057617188, 0.033721924, 0.04006958, -0.06817627, 0.036590576, -0.026260376, -0.03994751, 0.014884949, 0.034606934, 0.016708374, -0.021087646, -0.0043525696, 0.03149414, 0.010375977, 0.03692627, -0.026641846, -0.017211914, 0.0030879974, 0.04763794, 0.019622803, -0.008262634, 0.023986816, 0.016860962, 0.037475586, 0.060760498, -0.0021629333, 0.016616821, 0.01461792, 0.009666443, 0.03427124, 0.007511139, 0.011421204, -0.030807495, -0.040740967, -0.0019102097, -0.0015926361, -0.0090789795, -0.036499023, -0.0067253113, 0.011734009, 0.022872925, 0.05984497, 0.015419006, 0.011909485, -0.023895264, -0.025177002, 0.047973633, 0.025802612, -0.010520935, -0.016906738, -0.021942139, -0.04336548, 0.026824951, -0.0009012222, 0.08074951, 0.005706787, -0.00491333, -0.046905518, 0.019699097, 0.0105896, -0.048675537, -0.018051147, -0.03616333, 0.018936157, -0.010116577, 0.00466156, -0.036010742, -0.027557373, -0.00081920624, 0.038391113, 0.020339966, 0.031585693, 0.045715332, -0.02758789, -0.009559631, 0.039764404, -0.00054836273, 0.08227539, -0.00080537796, -0.025634766, -0.024658203, 0.010124207, 0.027648926, -0.017486572, -0.035827637, 0.010025024, -0.017364502, -0.014656067, -0.02279663, -0.030410767, -0.023956299, 0.019180298, 0.031829834, 0.02255249, -0.013648987, 0.008552551, 0.0013513565, -0.02720642, -0.022384644, -0.0024738312, -0.024002075, -0.008995056, 0.022720337, -0.0075950623, 0.009117126, 0.018341064, -0.028793335, -0.038208008, -0.017425537, 0.01637268, 0.0035419464, -0.010948181, -0.022613525, 0.031585693, 0.048675537, -0.046417236, -0.0769043, -0.025680542, 0.011276245, 0.027572632, 0.03552246, 0.025039673, 0.008850098, -0.06286621, -0.03933716, -0.01499939, -0.001701355, -0.002450943, 0.009292603, 0.015106201, 0.064086914, -0.015457153, 0.03338623, 0.045806885, -0.022964478, -0.0036449432, 0.008598328, -0.04208374, -0.0036907196, 0.005241394, 0.008232117, 0.0019302368, -0.015701294, 0.035247803, 0.0049934387, 0.0015468597, -0.005634308, -0.003768921, -0.00031113625, -0.026306152, 0.03656006, 0.005218506, -0.057525635, 0.02973938, 0.064086914, 0.008728027, 0.039916992, -0.01751709, -0.0569458, -0.031707764, 0.021362305, 0.01146698, 0.019134521, -0.017913818, 0.048675537, 0.03488159, -0.0049057007, -0.052581787, 0.034179688, -0.02658081, 0.016952515, -0.034362793, 0.030654907, -0.009483337, -0.011383057, 0.027282715, 0.029373169, 0.049591064, 0.029266357, -0.051483154, 0.0069007874, 0.018096924, -0.02760315 ], "summary": [ -0.038360596, -0.028686523, -0.0023765564, -0.00050640106, -0.053863525, 0.0034255981, -0.040496826, -0.022109985, -0.022628784, -0.020568848, -0.03479004, 0.025680542, -0.06640625, -0.022232056, 0.024215698, -0.06137085, 0.00041413307, 0.011482239, 0.0038795471, -0.012840271, -0.0030651093, -0.021820068, 0.004463196, -0.008728027, 0.04119873, 0.011680603, -0.07952881, 0.03656006, 0.0049057007, 0.040802002, 0.00058603287, -0.039123535, -0.0013208389, -0.021438599, 0.06048584, 0.056762695, 0.0013446808, 0.00003528595, 0.07171631, -0.04345703, 0.012786865, -0.005718231, 0.02482605, -0.023834229, -0.026657104, 0.0435791, -0.042755127, -0.010040283, 0.051483154, -0.008872986, 0.0043296814, 0.026885986, 0.005382538, -0.018112183, -0.028442383, -0.028320312, -0.01184082, -0.008705139, 0.01399231, 0.015899658, 0.010070801, 0.0024356842, 0.017562866, -0.0178833, -0.003419876, -0.019119263, 0.09289551, 0.006931305, 0.03100586, 0.01335144, 0.018753052, 0.04623413, 0.011734009, -0.011024475, -0.022033691, -0.023620605, 0.04562378, -0.020462036, 0.004989624, 0.0026359558, 0.0027770996, 0.015029907, 0.03277588, -0.024871826, 0.0011539459, 0.005340576, -0.009399414, -0.012001038, -0.042816162, -0.011680603, -0.038848877, 0.0027503967, -0.057922363, 0.032318115, -0.0042686462, 0.0032138824, 0.037841797, 0.06524658, 0.0016679764, -0.016662598, -0.011672974, -0.02128601, -0.028396606, -0.037841797, -0.009605408, 0.04446411, 0.015159607, 0.01083374, 0.031021118, -0.0075263977, -0.0027332306, 0.04736328, -0.031341553, -0.04864502, -0.017562866, 0.060760498, -0.008605957, -0.0096206665, 0.0084991455, -0.002954483, -0.004146576, 0.036834717, 0.024520874, 0.007987976, -0.0054473877, 0.016403198, 0.016723633, -0.046539307, -0.046447754, 0.074523926, -0.03579712, -0.020095825, 0.047576904, 0.008163452, -0.0037269592, -0.053863525, 0.029174805, -0.016448975, 0.021697998, -0.04827881, 0.048339844, 0.0003373623, -0.0154953, 0.03768921, 0.039245605, -0.006515503, 0.025741577, 0.042175293, 0.0087509155, 0.011985779, 0.014144897, 0.04156494, 0.035003662, 0.002708435, -0.09991455, -0.047088623, -0.076660156, 0.003829956, 0.030731201, -0.042663574, -0.0025367737, -0.0206604, 0.013290405, 0.0625, 0.025283813, 0.022827148, 0.009544373, 0.0017766953, 0.0074806213, 0.018936157, -0.006298065, 0.0012435913, -0.026779175, 0.004463196, -0.0029029846, 0.008583069, -0.026519775, 0.010795593, 0.03768921, -0.045440674, 0.004837036, -0.018096924, 0.039520264, 0.027572632, -0.050476074, 0.005619049, 0.00034451485, 0.03729248, 0.045959473, -0.012397766, 0.03668213, 0.001791954, -0.054382324, 0.007736206, -0.020751953, 0.012138367, -0.025848389, 0.011276245, -0.018203735, -0.022079468, -0.04171753, 0.050994873, -0.03668213, 0.034423828, -0.0005259514, 0.0059547424, 0.00756073, 0.024963379, -0.081848145, 0.020141602, 0.06939697, -0.0077171326, -0.07110596, 0.089904785, 0.05718994, -0.04748535, 0.0014877319, -0.030761719, -0.031082153, -0.057373047, -0.013595581, -0.0075683594, -0.021087646, 0.10571289, -0.017410278, 0.03112793, 0.002614975, 0.034240723, 0.07287598, 0.02128601, 0.09552002, -0.072021484, -0.014274597, 0.06750488, 0.025634766, -0.0022411346, 0.042419434, -0.03768921, 0.046417236, 0.0061073303, -0.010108948, 0.043426514, -0.0440979, 0.017440796, 0.0256958, -0.033172607, -0.016540527, 0.028808594, 0.03137207, 0.058380127, 0.04321289, 0.01713562, 0.019302368, -0.0053977966, 0.042816162, 0.023162842, -0.013893127, 0.019424438, -0.037597656, -0.0015792847, 0.0041503906, -0.035003662, -0.0035762787, -0.037353516, 0.0446167, -0.0013637543, 0.05996704, 0.040649414, -0.019348145, -0.026916504, -0.013877869, 0.05215454, -0.006160736, -0.06945801, -0.12219238, -0.057159424, -0.0004544258, 0.071899414, -0.022994995, -0.09576416, 0.031555176, 0.050598145, -0.040100098, -0.005306244, 0.011695862, -0.020828247, -0.03781128, 0.04623413, -0.032989502, -0.011116028, 0.033294678, -0.01939392, -0.049591064, 0.023773193, -0.027954102, -0.028839111, -0.012023926, 0.023666382, 0.0070381165, -0.0010719299, -0.024536133, 0.028579712, 0.009300232, -0.03604126, 0.024337769, -0.0034770966, 0.036102295, 0.0011692047, -0.0007863045, 0.043182373, -0.07513428, -0.009056091, -0.014205933, 0.016220093, -0.020690918, -0.035614014, -0.024002075, 0.0038394928, -0.00012779236, 0.044311523, 0.07055664, -0.047607422, -0.0074806213, 0.033691406, -0.053100586, -0.029159546, 0.06652832, -0.021011353, -0.016418457, -0.007675171, -0.015068054, -0.030822754, -0.03866577, 0.007858276, 0.00092220306, 0.002691269, 0.013031006, -0.00010210276, 0.0072898865, -0.01826477, 0.0138549805, 0.08074951, 0.008834839, -0.0038986206, 0.007896423, -0.02432251, 0.012268066, 0.012535095, -0.014312744, 0.0070533752, 0.0047302246, -0.006767273, -0.028533936, -0.024291992, 0.019927979, -0.009780884, 0.0006146431, -0.017364502, 0.008644104, -0.059448242, 0.0053901672, 0.025680542, -0.008728027, -0.019454956, 0.01058197, -0.035095215, -0.010421753, -0.0032215118, -0.031280518, 0.015312195, -0.010406494, -0.003458023, 0.005859375, -0.029876709, -0.05621338, 0.002960205, 0.032226562, -0.014038086, 0.017196655, 0.0025482178, 0.0070152283, 0.0071792603, 0.0024795532, 0.008277893, 0.050750732, 0.052246094, 0.053344727, 0.051879883, -0.026382446, -0.059448242, -0.051971436, 0.025512695, 0.014930725, -0.016159058, -0.019058228, -0.007972717, -0.011741638, -0.0019454956, -0.008514404, -0.0014982224, 0.0071144104, -0.004421234, 0.015686035, -0.026672363, 0.0056915283, 0.020584106, 0.0032749176, -0.0021877289, 0.025100708, -0.022872925, 0.02482605, -0.016677856, 0.010856628, -0.034423828, -0.006591797, -0.045959473, 0.031433105, 0.010482788, -0.039520264, -0.057159424, 0.026184082, -0.018661499, 0.0126953125, -0.025802612, 0.0046195984, 0.020095825, -0.008056641, 0.008384705, -0.05065918, -0.008644104, 0.011123657, -0.042114258, -0.03036499, -0.030166626, 0.022109985, 0.04159546, -0.007446289, 0.026779175, -0.01209259, 0.0128479, -0.0020122528, 0.028533936, 0.0061912537, 0.009178162, -0.008026123, -0.0070381165, 0.05657959, 0.0009317398, 0.0057678223, 0.0063591003, -0.025314331, -0.001912117, -0.007911682, 0.03149414, -0.0141067505, 0.0013217926, 0.006816864, 0.015640259, 0.043701172, -0.031082153, -0.021820068, 0.00055503845, -0.03314209, -0.008102417, -0.017211914, 0.006752014, -0.018188477, 0.025146484, -0.023803711, -0.018035889, -0.0011110306, 0.036132812, -0.0011768341, -0.02305603, -0.023345947, -0.019454956, 0.050598145, -0.02482605, 0.06677246, -0.03289795, -0.004135132, 0.008277893, 0.05859375, -0.052947998, -0.023361206, 0.026824951, -0.084472656, -0.040100098, -0.014328003, 0.050323486, -0.0026016235, 0.025772095, 0.030685425, -0.02897644, -0.031433105, 0.03366089, 0.009025574, -0.0418396, -0.027526855, -0.072021484, -0.040496826, 0.0074157715, -0.003293991, 0.040161133, -0.024490356, 0.019805908, 0.05279541, -0.0030956268, -0.008712769, -0.0055007935, 0.01222229, -0.031082153, 0.039520264, 0.027572632, -0.006046295, -0.0069007874, 0.052215576, -0.0011167526, -0.0011234283, 0.0140686035, 0.04333496, 0.037902832, -0.020339966, 0.034057617, -0.011520386, 0.0066871643, -0.072143555, -0.012130737, 0.014144897, -0.046966553, 0.02809143, 0.015991211, -0.034301758, 0.024154663, -0.008056641, -0.021484375, -0.011222839, -0.0058631897, -0.02772522, -0.023361206, -0.0045051575, 0.021881104, 0.015625, 0.005443573, -0.010429382, 0.0009794235, -0.03378296, 0.0423584, -0.054138184, 0.03845215, -0.010169983, -0.025894165, 0.007419586, -0.027557373, 0.0131073, -0.03878784, 0.007987976, -0.025177002, -0.0069732666, 0.054473877, -0.0016441345, 0.0068588257, -0.008270264, -0.002954483, 0.037384033, 0.0340271, -0.02166748, -0.052093506, -0.008399963, -0.00730896, -0.00472641, -0.040283203, 0.006362915, -0.014968872, -0.02267456, -0.018096924, 0.011627197, 0.0043296814, 0.025787354, -0.010002136, 0.033325195, 0.0017251968, -0.016708374, -0.009742737, 0.027832031, -0.008049011, -0.039245605, 0.019958496, -0.012832642, -0.017669678, -0.005672455, -0.027175903, 0.0033626556, -0.023757935, -0.004924774, 0.009490967, 0.011581421, -0.030029297, -0.014579773, 0.00087976456, 0.006286621, -0.007965088, 0.009994507, -0.027770996, 0.012992859, -0.030303955, 0.014038086, -0.028625488, 0.007095337, -0.030319214, -0.0118255615, -0.053863525, 0.029586792, 0.032592773, 0.022964478, -0.018753052, -0.058258057, 0.052856445, 0.095947266, -0.0022506714, 0.0340271, 0.019165039, -0.015014648, 0.010658264, 0.00084352493, -0.006706238, -0.026809692, -0.039733887, -0.020446777, 0.023788452, -0.033111572, 0.019958496, -0.025558472, -0.04360962, 0.030914307, 0.063964844, -0.02746582, -0.026626587, -0.028442383, 0.02859497, 0.023971558, 0.018005371, 0.0003736019, -0.03729248, 0.0058403015, -0.02557373, -0.034362793, 0.015335083, -0.01109314, -0.014511108, 0.01626587, 0.0038318634, -0.033569336, 0.013496399, 0.005214691, 0.00843811, -0.042388916, 0.009132385, 0.006565094, -0.019714355, -0.072021484, -0.008239746, -0.026184082, 0.0034637451, -0.017974854, 0.0082473755, -0.0067253113, 0.039398193, -0.028274536, 0.020095825, 0.01234436, -0.023254395, 0.018707275, -0.01008606, 0.02420044, -0.004135132, 0.015213013, 0.007896423, -0.010375977, -0.0209198, 0.016342163, 0.033843994, -0.020431519, -0.018371582, -0.005558014, 0.05911255, -0.008163452, -0.0005569458, 0.0038414001, 0.0014219284, 0.020248413, 0.042755127, 0.007419586, 0.026000977, 0.0013027191, 0.015716553, -0.024551392, -0.033691406, -0.06036377, 0.011856079, -0.0014019012, -0.015609741, 0.0657959, -0.030319214, -0.0023345947, -0.01676941, 0.012069702, -0.0047073364, 0.043518066, 0.020858765, 0.0042915344, -0.009391785, -0.014572144, 0.011512756, -0.053955078, -0.017562866, -0.05557251, -0.004928589, -0.0019950867, 0.06011963, -0.0012636185, -0.009094238, 0.043518066, 0.0035972595, 0.034851074, -0.0041275024, 0.0021686554, 0.022216797, -0.004096985, -0.0024757385, 0.038146973, 0.029678345, 0.0317688, -0.004558563, -0.006969452, -0.044006348, 0.060546875, -0.035888672, -0.013923645, 0.013923645, 0.003440857, 0.006603241, 0.023803711, -0.03265381, -0.06161499, 0.010231018, -0.014038086, -0.0715332, 0.022125244, -0.04586792, 0.021469116, 0.050354004, -0.019210815, -0.00070667267, 0.012252808, -0.014205933, 0.03274536, 0.022994995, -0.0065727234, -0.01727295, -0.011650085, 0.0022888184, -0.0435791, -0.017578125, -0.028335571, -0.022262573, -0.066711426, -0.056365967, -0.037628174, -0.034240723, 0.031402588, 0.03289795, 0.011955261, 0.018173218, -0.0067367554, -0.053710938, -0.011169434, 0.041107178, -0.0022449493, 0.039154053, -0.05419922, 0.08288574, -0.06817627, 0.0030975342, -0.021530151, 0.015060425, 0.00041222572, 0.02696228, -0.023391724, -0.0090789795, -0.013580322, 0.04095459, 0.004261017, -0.008239746, 0.00687027, 0.039367676, 0.017166138, -0.01309967, -0.036102295, -0.013130188, 0.00023341179, -0.028320312, -0.041168213, -0.02809143, -0.02571106, -0.009880066, 0.029434204, -0.022659302, 0.013946533, 0.047546387, 0.00085926056, 0.02897644, -0.0032615662, -0.048736572, -0.0024433136, 0.027130127, 0.027282715, 0.0069732666, 0.014060974, 0.0118637085, -0.034088135, 0.025482178, -0.0027389526, 0.024139404, -0.04525757, 0.040100098, 0.020950317, -0.030899048, -0.04534912, -0.034423828, 0.0574646, -0.034698486, 0.06665039, 0.020874023, 0.04168701, 0.04989624, -0.02444458, 0.103393555, -0.080322266, 0.008956909, 0.008918762, -0.031402588, 0.041625977, 0.02407837, 0.0038414001, 0.014640808, -0.018875122, -0.04095459, 0.05984497, 0.019515991, 0.022735596, -0.022842407, -0.033813477, -0.029785156, 0.024871826, 0.044311523, -0.010688782, -0.010307312, 0.037231445, 0.06756592, -0.023773193, 0.024780273, 0.023742676, 0.03994751, 0.018341064, 0.079956055, 0.027175903, 0.033813477, 0.03289795, 0.062042236, 0.025131226, 0.007335663, -0.02696228, 0.02168274, -0.02923584, 0.0022945404, 0.004524231, 0.04043579, -0.0007996559, -0.020950317, 0.074523926, 0.045684814, 0.06903076, -0.012062073, 0.026611328, 0.046966553, 0.0075798035, 0.030670166, -0.014854431, 0.004386902, -0.019943237, -0.013595581, 0.013244629, 0.009628296, 0.023925781, 0.043029785, -0.028579712, -0.0036296844, -0.024093628, 0.021362305, -0.032836914, -0.014297485, 0.012390137, -0.032440186, -0.03970337, 0.008880615, -0.011932373, -0.046051025, -0.02230835, -0.0287323, 0.0048713684, -0.0076904297, 0.023880005, 0.021484375, -0.016479492, 0.005886078, 0.03012085, 0.010803223, 0.07556152, -0.009674072, -0.034301758, 0.022369385, -0.004009247, 0.04498291, -0.03427124, -0.05316162, 0.022613525, 0.05038452, -0.036132812, 0.012756348, 0.012901306, -0.0007123947, 0.07720947, 0.015342712, 0.026260376, 0.007118225, -0.0030059814, 0.0031929016, -0.016799927, 0.017196655, -0.004299164, 0.0021362305, -0.016571045, -0.0031223297, 0.0055618286, 0.05621338, -0.0043678284, -0.0005097389, -0.018981934, 0.0128479, 0.008544922, 0.015419006, -0.048614502, -0.001376152, 0.015144348, 0.039093018, -0.0074386597, 0.014755249, 0.03274536, -0.01083374, 0.01876831, -0.018539429, 0.02859497, -0.0149002075, -0.05316162, -0.042938232, -0.017593384, 0.029724121, -0.00043344498, 0.03817749, 0.008514404, 0.03692627, -0.015899658, 0.029510498, 0.03161621, -0.052612305, -0.033416748, 0.009567261, -0.0036087036, -0.04827881, 0.012611389, -0.03149414, -0.01776123, -0.057922363, 0.054992676, -0.024673462, -0.013000488, -0.07714844, 0.0023460388, -0.023071289, -0.07122803, -0.046142578, -0.006061554, 0.036254883, -0.04977417, -0.008728027, 0.0037059784, -0.008956909, -0.020721436, 0.018585205, -0.010063171, -0.01361084, -0.0013141632, -0.02368164, -0.0009965897, 0.023330688, 0.026123047, -0.041412354, -0.060913086, 0.04244995, -0.02218628, -0.011268616, -0.0039978027, 0.031585693, 0.049591064, 0.013877869, 0.016586304, 0.05496216, 0.019927979, 0.053131104, -0.01084137, 0.0073776245, 0.010810852, -0.020401001 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.09428v1
Response by the Montreal AI Ethics Institute to the European Commission's Whitepaper on AI
Abhishek Gupta, Camylle Lanteigne
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG
In February 2020, the European Commission (EC) published a white paper entitled, On Artificial Intelligence - A European approach to excellence and trust. This paper outlines the EC's policy options for the promotion and adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) in the European Union. The Montreal AI Ethics Institute (MAIEI) reviewed this paper and published a response addressing the EC's plans to build an "ecosystem of excellence" and an "ecosystem of trust," as well as the safety and liability implications of AI, the internet of things (IoT), and robotics. MAIEI provides 15 recommendations in relation to the sections outlined above, including: 1) focus efforts on the research and innovation community, member states, and the private sector; 2) create alignment between trading partners' policies and EU policies; 3) analyze the gaps in the ecosystem between theoretical frameworks and approaches to building trustworthy AI; 4) focus on coordination and policy alignment; 5) focus on mechanisms that promote private and secure sharing of data; 6) create a network of AI research excellence centres to strengthen the research and innovation community; 7) promote knowledge transfer and develop AI expertise through Digital Innovation Hubs; 8) add nuance to the discussion regarding the opacity of AI systems; 9) create a process for individuals to appeal an AI system's decision or output; 10) implement new rules and strengthen existing regulations; 11) ban the use of facial recognition technology; 12) hold all AI systems to similar standards and compulsory requirements; 13) ensure biometric identification systems fulfill the purpose for which they are implemented; 14) implement a voluntary labelling system for systems that are not considered high-risk; 15) appoint individuals to the oversight process who understand AI systems well and are able to communicate potential risks.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.09428v1
2020-06-16T18:16:51
2020-06-16T18:16:51
{ "title": [ 0.000040650368, 0.006340027, -0.008132935, 0.051940918, -0.011001587, -0.036956787, 0.06774902, -0.015258789, -0.004711151, 0.046936035, -0.06298828, 0.0036258698, 0.03604126, -0.008026123, -0.024505615, -0.03942871, -0.0021953583, 0.051879883, 0.050598145, 0.006477356, 0.0036888123, 0.036315918, -0.010047913, -0.044952393, 0.041534424, 0.054016113, -0.04348755, 0.004436493, -0.034332275, -0.03967285, 0.010101318, 0.02230835, 0.01826477, 0.029724121, -0.047546387, 0.0037937164, -0.0018110275, 0.011604309, 0.0036468506, 0.013374329, 0.023895264, -0.0084991455, 0.05496216, 0.01071167, 0.038482666, -0.021469116, 0.03579712, -0.022872925, 0.011497498, 0.035461426, 0.009338379, 0.022857666, 0.0082092285, 0.0071372986, -0.010421753, -0.021606445, 0.000344038, -0.02130127, 0.015533447, -0.018356323, -0.016479492, 0.0006914139, 0.03314209, 0.015899658, -0.0034217834, -0.026977539, -0.03479004, 0.009780884, 0.029083252, 0.033233643, 0.025344849, -0.014511108, 0.0067100525, 0.02381897, -0.073791504, -0.02760315, 0.010955811, -0.03451538, 0.041046143, -0.004245758, 0.0072669983, -0.021240234, -0.010108948, -0.0014152527, -0.029464722, -0.020721436, -0.0057640076, 0.0077781677, -0.031463623, -0.023025513, -0.03466797, 0.012466431, -0.036621094, -0.01701355, -0.020004272, -0.031677246, 0.018585205, 0.044952393, 0.0035266876, -0.011497498, -0.021850586, -0.01586914, -0.054229736, -0.01348114, 0.006252289, -0.005470276, 0.022354126, 0.0018358231, 0.0027694702, -0.0012140274, -0.04736328, 0.031829834, 0.0038814545, -0.008979797, 0.01222229, -0.014663696, -0.032287598, 0.028503418, -0.0067367554, -0.01260376, -0.01499939, -0.0016775131, 0.043151855, 0.04827881, 0.0048332214, 0.024383545, -0.0141067505, -0.02885437, 0.03164673, -0.031066895, -0.0073547363, 0.04559326, -0.008361816, -0.039489746, -0.034057617, 0.01637268, 0.021820068, 0.021102905, -0.0035057068, -0.019882202, 0.046691895, 0.011940002, 0.004009247, 0.014663696, -0.04397583, 0.011413574, 0.041870117, 0.0020389557, -0.05166626, -0.017913818, -0.00085401535, -0.020889282, -0.0051574707, 0.048065186, -0.0070724487, 0.009063721, 0.023284912, -0.0071640015, 0.038726807, -0.0037231445, 0.04156494, 0.02758789, 0.027755737, 0.03250122, 0.028015137, -0.037994385, -0.04373169, 0.002620697, 0.016021729, 0.07659912, -0.010131836, -0.007820129, 0.0052719116, 0.040130615, -0.0051727295, 0.0061302185, -0.026748657, -0.036071777, -0.001203537, 0.052612305, 0.042114258, 0.003200531, -0.10058594, 0.07067871, -0.0070495605, -0.039245605, 0.026901245, 0.031463623, -0.0009946823, 0.034820557, -0.009674072, 0.008842468, 0.0022735596, -0.022994995, -0.027938843, 0.018005371, -0.037597656, 0.037994385, -0.024505615, -0.02116394, 0.003648758, 0.038970947, -0.028945923, 0.018829346, -0.03479004, 0.001991272, 0.009109497, 0.028076172, -0.03173828, 0.0259552, 0.037750244, 0.010314941, -0.025909424, -0.016906738, -0.0014715195, -0.034423828, -0.017791748, -0.046844482, -0.0103302, -0.03878784, -0.021484375, 0.028289795, -0.04135132, 0.0034942627, -0.014831543, 0.03567505, 0.005153656, 0.024887085, 0.0579834, 0.035888672, 0.09765625, -0.05041504, 0.05557251, 0.039489746, -0.022628784, 0.0055656433, 0.019134521, -0.017333984, 0.0063171387, 0.03112793, -0.00088882446, 0.011062622, 0.006965637, 0.03616333, 0.045440674, 0.041778564, 0.032226562, -0.0029964447, 0.025909424, -0.05328369, 0.022354126, -0.06573486, 0.09301758, 0.0070877075, 0.0068626404, 0.016418457, -0.013053894, -0.024490356, 0.000500679, 0.013809204, 0.010879517, 0.0034389496, 0.0017461777, 0.014945984, -0.070617676, 0.015571594, -0.0073661804, 0.017471313, 0.0043563843, -0.02406311, 0.017318726, 0.023590088, 0.024490356, 0.026229858, -0.022949219, 0.02494812, -0.009552002, -0.013000488, 0.007865906, 0.0074424744, 0.027420044, 0.021560669, 0.01499939, -0.003660202, 0.041778564, 0.003967285, 0.013198853, 0.03201294, -0.029571533, -0.018539429, 0.021560669, 0.013160706, -0.04046631, 0.008621216, 0.009117126, -0.012504578, -0.002210617, 0.06488037, -0.014160156, -0.031341553, -0.1038208, -0.016204834, -0.01914978, -0.0262146, 0.014778137, 0.014434814, 0.029891968, -0.028915405, -0.023956299, 0.014625549, -0.07873535, -0.04257202, 0.021316528, -0.0014286041, -0.011398315, -0.049713135, -0.04663086, 0.01965332, -0.072143555, -0.0113220215, 0.06750488, 0.025268555, 0.005531311, -0.041381836, 0.028579712, -0.03567505, -0.03213501, -0.014198303, 0.008880615, -0.036071777, -0.03277588, -0.049835205, -0.08026123, -0.02456665, 0.018417358, 0.024841309, 0.014175415, 0.0569458, 0.00055885315, -0.0423584, -0.00365448, 0.012283325, -0.027770996, -0.024642944, 0.014778137, -0.032440186, 0.019042969, -0.017623901, -0.031158447, 0.034454346, -0.009559631, 0.0010623932, -0.013504028, -0.009780884, 0.02507019, -0.032287598, -0.0072631836, 0.018722534, 0.021911621, -0.023391724, 0.052337646, 0.034057617, 0.040222168, -0.06890869, -0.0670166, -0.051116943, -0.0030879974, -0.0037631989, 0.0046958923, -0.017822266, 0.024230957, -0.011360168, 0.012481689, -0.028015137, -0.027374268, -0.033294678, -0.02015686, -0.029174805, 0.008110046, -0.015556335, -0.0022182465, -0.009559631, 0.020385742, -0.021148682, 0.02243042, 0.0138168335, -0.00982666, -0.02897644, 0.0423584, 0.020004272, 0.040008545, 0.0053520203, 0.015930176, -0.022827148, -0.0049819946, -0.026443481, -0.043029785, 0.030975342, -0.058624268, 0.014511108, 0.023376465, -0.0025787354, -0.011650085, 0.00051259995, -0.04208374, 0.04949951, 0.029693604, -0.0012159348, 0.05496216, -0.040527344, 0.0073242188, 0.009635925, 0.04623413, -0.05340576, -0.021606445, -0.011451721, -0.049713135, 0.0037345886, -0.05053711, 0.04309082, 0.0022602081, 0.06274414, -0.05569458, -0.021743774, -0.03314209, 0.00041365623, 0.016601562, 0.0435791, -0.0045280457, -0.0029067993, 0.012535095, -0.045837402, 0.019424438, -0.0010442734, -0.030593872, -0.010345459, -0.030776978, -0.020812988, 0.015060425, -0.041992188, -0.00082683563, 0.02746582, -0.019485474, 0.013427734, -0.004283905, -0.042541504, 0.011276245, -0.037597656, -0.034240723, 0.057159424, -0.07788086, 0.0037994385, -0.04244995, 0.042663574, -0.033813477, 0.011276245, 0.03579712, 0.06555176, -0.033599854, 0.051849365, 0.05895996, -0.021575928, 0.0289917, 0.025436401, -0.040374756, -0.011558533, 0.07141113, 0.019866943, 0.006187439, -0.030059814, -0.00076007843, 0.04171753, 0.012313843, 0.0154800415, 0.0065994263, -0.013252258, -0.027359009, 0.008033752, -0.014404297, 0.019699097, -0.020111084, 0.019180298, 0.042816162, -0.02192688, -0.008666992, 0.013763428, -0.045776367, -0.03552246, -0.008781433, -0.050323486, -0.03656006, -0.01209259, 0.009429932, -0.04852295, -0.0050697327, -0.013282776, -0.002105713, 0.052490234, 0.0035648346, 0.016036987, -0.058807373, -0.031433105, 0.013679504, -0.039520264, 0.024017334, 0.043304443, 0.014961243, 0.03555298, 0.012275696, 0.03225708, 0.019958496, 0.0079956055, -0.0028839111, 0.03112793, -0.057525635, 0.028533936, -0.023269653, -0.064453125, -0.0026435852, 0.036743164, 0.03756714, 0.04336548, -0.03186035, -0.0019454956, 0.05618286, -0.013404846, -0.040802002, 0.009468079, -0.007911682, -0.096069336, 0.03475952, 0.027618408, 0.011528015, 0.05307007, -0.015304565, 0.07147217, -0.025344849, -0.0074501038, 0.00157547, 0.014541626, -0.023147583, -0.021865845, -0.0135269165, 0.028549194, -0.023788452, 0.047790527, -0.014564514, 0.038635254, 0.0082092285, -0.023025513, 0.001502037, 0.026809692, -0.005077362, -0.006542206, -0.0059776306, -0.044189453, -0.050720215, 0.00010251999, 0.0058937073, 0.046051025, -0.03250122, 0.000086307526, 0.007423401, 0.016082764, -0.004184723, 0.0368042, -0.009239197, -0.0011386871, 0.01625061, -0.041137695, -0.045074463, -0.03640747, -0.027450562, 0.0082473755, 0.00010621548, 0.016174316, 0.00045251846, 0.032226562, 0.0026626587, -0.017044067, 0.021148682, -0.003862381, -0.014762878, 0.041900635, -0.0076065063, 0.0178833, -0.041503906, -0.009216309, -0.024795532, -0.0036258698, 0.013305664, -0.007972717, -0.0287323, -0.057861328, 0.031066895, 0.03491211, 0.055847168, 0.009002686, -0.040618896, 0.02180481, 0.01953125, 0.012435913, 0.0020999908, -0.012550354, -0.034698486, 0.038604736, 0.040130615, 0.010604858, 0.035583496, 0.043762207, 0.014984131, -0.025253296, -0.0067634583, 0.027191162, 0.0057792664, -0.026641846, 0.047607422, -0.009208679, 0.024520874, -0.0256958, 0.015579224, 0.04815674, 0.032440186, 0.024246216, 0.026824951, -0.06726074, -0.019622803, -0.011474609, 0.01210022, -0.0071411133, -0.009277344, 0.0036315918, 0.020050049, -0.028060913, 0.034576416, 0.013450623, 0.00818634, -0.0146484375, -0.06060791, 0.043670654, -0.005012512, -0.01713562, -0.05255127, -0.0031986237, 0.03265381, -0.027923584, -0.027893066, -0.018066406, -0.03265381, -0.025680542, -0.08483887, 0.0019397736, 0.007827759, 0.03942871, 0.02607727, 0.008644104, -0.00037002563, -0.017364502, 0.037963867, -0.023361206, -0.0010251999, 0.06378174, -0.0692749, 0.03555298, -0.0044822693, -0.025039673, 0.031036377, 0.025909424, -0.027038574, -0.02897644, 0.016189575, 0.0107803345, 0.0046157837, 0.0013971329, 0.014831543, 0.024414062, -0.015808105, 0.025726318, -0.033325195, -0.00422287, 0.0058517456, 0.0018024445, 0.059936523, -0.02029419, -0.016052246, 0.06951904, -0.029327393, -0.065979004, 0.011489868, -0.034362793, -0.0135269165, 0.044799805, -0.020095825, 0.016357422, -0.0035209656, -0.021697998, -0.011672974, -0.035827637, -0.0004312992, -0.019561768, -0.008201599, -0.003917694, 0.020462036, -0.0048675537, 0.0099487305, -0.002418518, -0.016860962, -0.02053833, 0.020950317, -0.0019407272, 0.002664566, 0.0017347336, -0.019958496, -0.013092041, 0.017944336, -0.016204834, -0.025390625, -0.01991272, -0.034240723, 0.0064926147, -0.015312195, -0.03805542, -0.050720215, -0.0054359436, 0.020309448, -0.087768555, -0.04638672, -0.015045166, -0.0014076233, 0.009544373, -0.049621582, 0.047821045, 0.03289795, -0.05130005, -0.004764557, -0.06329346, 0.014694214, -0.021102905, -0.029968262, -0.006542206, -0.043792725, 0.011520386, 0.01625061, 0.0061798096, 0.023239136, 0.002040863, 0.03250122, 0.007751465, 0.010917664, 0.011993408, 0.07757568, -0.05795288, -0.0619812, -0.037841797, -0.002714157, -0.09088135, -0.04055786, 0.050567627, -0.0045280457, 0.017074585, -0.046417236, -0.011039734, 0.014060974, 0.046875, 0.0011167526, 0.041412354, -0.052368164, -0.0017728806, -0.05441284, 0.008598328, 0.014343262, 0.028030396, -0.029418945, 0.025115967, -0.014160156, -0.012817383, -0.020111084, -0.0015287399, 0.040222168, 0.014198303, 0.012901306, 0.023483276, 0.027389526, -0.011795044, -0.019577026, 0.01574707, 0.069885254, -0.0048675537, -0.03475952, -0.01737976, 0.041381836, 0.03564453, 0.0046920776, 0.018600464, 0.02116394, 0.021072388, -0.000054895878, -0.0053634644, 0.045013428, -0.01159668, 0.013145447, -0.030715942, 0.043182373, 0.04562378, 0.011650085, -0.0713501, -0.032562256, 0.09320068, 0.016143799, -0.0039138794, 0.023086548, 0.0010051727, -0.013725281, -0.0090789795, 0.016326904, 0.035949707, 0.0025234222, -0.034362793, 0.042266846, 0.016479492, 0.00067949295, 0.023101807, -0.003156662, 0.028503418, -0.04437256, 0.023925781, 0.03488159, -0.035217285, -0.028274536, -0.017456055, 0.021713257, -0.033416748, -0.06536865, -0.047912598, -0.048706055, 0.04598999, 0.016403198, -0.031341553, 0.03643799, 0.030410767, 0.025100708, 0.0031604767, 0.01234436, 0.0121154785, -0.010231018, 0.024002075, 0.017349243, -0.030532837, -0.060943604, 0.041290283, 0.011947632, 0.009475708, 0.018676758, 0.00983429, 0.0075531006, 0.031585693, -0.006877899, -0.025146484, -0.030822754, 0.018753052, 0.009841919, -0.007457733, -0.0009689331, 0.0021896362, 0.009300232, 0.0019226074, 0.0109939575, -0.030731201, 0.037384033, -0.02670288, 0.016998291, -0.0104522705, 0.060760498, -0.01033783, -0.024124146, 0.0115356445, 0.02305603, -0.053588867, 0.008285522, 0.009735107, 0.027832031, -0.03665161, 0.070129395, 0.0031719208, -0.008216858, -0.047180176, 0.056396484, -0.004196167, 0.03652954, -0.001004219, 0.002243042, 0.0076675415, 0.0056877136, 0.043029785, 0.05105591, 0.07940674, 0.0104522705, 0.038330078, -0.0132369995, -0.051239014, 0.0061836243, -0.04598999, 0.05215454, -0.010787964, 0.041259766, -0.010795593, -0.03277588, -0.035003662, 0.0024986267, -0.008003235, 0.03643799, 0.04348755, 0.043151855, 0.046966553, -0.0637207, -0.012573242, 0.055877686, 0.0758667, 0.064331055, 0.08203125, 0.013839722, 0.004299164, 0.03265381, -0.059448242, -0.020812988, -0.0029354095, 0.055877686, -0.01626587, -0.025177002, -0.005874634, 0.0070724487, -0.022750854, -0.072753906, 0.0035438538, -0.012275696, -0.03491211, 0.024307251, 0.0004284382, 0.014266968, -0.08544922, 0.0023422241, -0.01335144, -0.011169434, -0.023864746, -0.0038795471, -0.013725281, 0.042999268, -0.032409668, -0.015686035, 0.013061523, 0.019195557, -0.0033168793, -0.03717041, 0.014373779, -0.026824951, 0.041992188, -0.031402588, -0.09063721, 0.0023097992, 0.031585693, 0.015823364, 0.028244019, -0.000310421, 0.019897461, -0.036956787, 0.019348145, -0.002450943, -0.028411865, 0.03652954, 0.0151901245, 0.06524658, 0.022338867, -0.06542969, 0.049591064, -0.00092077255, -0.041931152, -0.0009870529, -0.012268066, -0.0105896, -0.010925293, 0.0011177063, 0.023956299, -0.00019490719, -0.017608643, 0.019317627, 0.0042381287, -0.034362793, -0.016540527, 0.0019102097, -0.0017652512, -0.026138306, 0.03262329, 0.024734497, -0.0017995834, 0.01727295, 0.005680084, 0.037628174, -0.028182983, 0.019866943, -0.028457642, 0.0132369995, 0.020584106, 0.020019531, 0.017501831, -0.020858765, 0.019546509, 0.0029029846, -0.0625, -0.048858643, -0.018615723, -0.026672363, -0.012626648, -0.045837402, 0.050964355, 0.009170532, 0.016311646, 0.03387451, 0.013290405, 0.033050537, 0.076538086, -0.053527832, -0.045654297, -0.03366089, -0.03112793 ], "summary": [ -0.007144928, 0.023605347, -0.0070343018, 0.09124756, -0.0008211136, -0.035614014, 0.09991455, -0.060424805, 0.0037231445, 0.03692627, -0.022659302, 0.028625488, 0.017837524, -0.015792847, -0.00737381, -0.0063552856, 0.014915466, -0.006996155, 0.0435791, 0.0023403168, 0.004257202, 0.017028809, 0.05014038, -0.088378906, 0.050964355, -0.046722412, -0.016403198, 0.026931763, -0.03149414, -0.008460999, 0.013160706, 0.012428284, 0.036987305, 0.01966858, -0.06842041, -0.04248047, 0.0054893494, -0.0049362183, -0.041656494, 0.026641846, 0.034423828, -0.019577026, 0.115234375, -0.01625061, 0.056152344, 0.016036987, 0.04046631, -0.079711914, 0.016433716, 0.020828247, 0.03652954, -0.0033626556, 0.02748108, -0.014335632, -0.025619507, -0.040802002, -0.023620605, -0.061706543, 0.010223389, 0.051330566, 0.033233643, -0.0345459, 0.00919342, -0.021881104, -0.0053253174, -0.018188477, 0.00856781, 0.011779785, 0.009429932, 0.018753052, 0.017684937, -0.0044822693, 0.009231567, -0.0395813, -0.028289795, 0.02671814, -0.0077781677, 0.0030155182, 0.022232056, -0.017227173, -0.004398346, -0.005443573, 0.009460449, -0.024795532, -0.029830933, -0.03466797, -0.0044288635, -0.0014333725, -0.01637268, 0.012374878, -0.014045715, -0.014778137, -0.047912598, 0.06732178, 0.033325195, 0.0014266968, -0.033111572, 0.0037670135, 0.024932861, 0.05078125, -0.020507812, -0.012840271, -0.0033550262, -0.030395508, 0.00016415119, 0.0892334, 0.028152466, -0.018173218, -0.005748749, -0.034118652, -0.0034713745, -0.0340271, 0.04425049, -0.016616821, -0.045013428, 0.009147644, 0.039093018, -0.038360596, 0.00737381, -0.013305664, -0.04736328, -0.02406311, 0.0062942505, 0.03967285, 0.025466919, 0.01876831, 0.01499176, 0.0032672882, 0.04309082, -0.05038452, -0.032287598, 0.04837036, 0.021728516, -0.019317627, -0.024047852, 0.01121521, 0.016723633, 0.022323608, -0.0043945312, -0.025024414, 0.053894043, 0.010787964, -0.0069389343, 0.041809082, 0.013053894, 0.01386261, 0.028640747, 0.022216797, 0.016036987, -0.021759033, 0.018707275, -0.024093628, 0.014457703, 0.019577026, -0.021316528, -0.035217285, 0.017715454, -0.035736084, 0.027999878, -0.0362854, 0.0602417, 0.027679443, 0.023361206, 0.04269409, 0.026184082, -0.04815674, -0.03793335, 0.016952515, 0.0013275146, -0.016342163, -0.029052734, 0.030426025, -0.030715942, -0.0026798248, 0.010848999, -0.006832123, -0.022415161, -0.013679504, -0.003501892, 0.021606445, 0.036499023, -0.022720337, -0.040618896, 0.05999756, -0.0030269623, 0.039123535, -0.00032377243, 0.04586792, 0.0019159317, 0.02482605, -0.033416748, 0.0118637085, -0.020553589, -0.04522705, -0.032409668, -0.011505127, -0.03451538, -0.013687134, -0.027679443, 0.05706787, 0.0423584, -0.018157959, -0.010803223, -0.049682617, -0.07122803, -0.031311035, -0.021636963, 0.03062439, -0.06994629, 0.0055389404, 0.049591064, -0.021835327, -0.033813477, 0.02923584, 0.024520874, -0.01586914, 0.02166748, -0.028778076, -0.01247406, -0.032226562, -0.01651001, 0.035125732, -0.039093018, 0.029464722, -0.030807495, 0.023025513, -0.011116028, 0.014205933, 0.048095703, 0.030151367, 0.07098389, -0.039764404, 0.048034668, 0.062927246, -0.0013513565, -0.018661499, 0.014060974, -0.05432129, 0.018569946, 0.03201294, 0.035949707, 0.028808594, 0.021575928, 0.027862549, 0.0030078888, -0.010398865, 0.050994873, -0.020462036, 0.003320694, -0.014183044, -0.02482605, -0.015640259, 0.05166626, -0.03050232, 0.009971619, 0.0340271, -0.010284424, -0.030059814, -0.029144287, -0.012420654, 0.03604126, -0.04006958, -0.06549072, 0.0124053955, -0.07171631, 0.009284973, -0.013153076, 0.013877869, 0.0000615716, -0.017990112, 0.028518677, 0.019104004, 0.0015964508, -0.00422287, -0.027114868, -0.01890564, -0.024307251, 0.01977539, 0.02671814, -0.015533447, 0.02357483, 0.028915405, -0.011054993, -0.015899658, 0.04333496, -0.013427734, -0.022750854, 0.00944519, -0.027862549, -0.021255493, 0.041809082, -0.015731812, -0.03390503, 0.0065078735, -0.010810852, -0.031433105, -0.04727173, 0.045928955, -0.0053215027, -0.032165527, -0.054779053, 0.0017404556, -0.038269043, -0.0013599396, 0.0042419434, 0.051513672, 0.041046143, -0.0058059692, 0.0064849854, 0.002002716, -0.02456665, -0.033172607, -0.00031805038, -0.04031372, 0.027053833, -0.0103302, 0.0038986206, 0.0062789917, -0.004962921, 0.04901123, 0.08618164, 0.010894775, 0.022537231, -0.007095337, 0.008979797, -0.058532715, 0.014221191, -0.023284912, -0.040893555, 0.0043907166, 0.006008148, -0.021194458, -0.016983032, -0.026107788, -0.006652832, 0.0025634766, 0.0016517639, 0.061157227, -0.009994507, -0.07513428, -0.021560669, -0.015777588, -0.0102005005, 0.017044067, -0.0043563843, -0.064331055, 0.036743164, -0.015007019, 0.020462036, 0.007751465, 0.012779236, 0.0028591156, -0.044677734, 0.006526947, 0.001791954, -0.032073975, 0.034118652, -0.0037631989, -0.022766113, -0.029037476, 0.09851074, 0.026367188, 0.071777344, -0.074645996, -0.09753418, -0.04421997, 0.0024166107, -0.005050659, -0.01134491, 0.0017910004, -0.0007185936, -0.005142212, -0.022750854, -0.024597168, -0.00022816658, 0.023910522, 0.054504395, -0.0013542175, -0.0008583069, 0.007858276, 0.036102295, 0.026641846, -0.009117126, -0.02305603, 0.028518677, 0.0010328293, 0.021850586, 0.004753113, 0.072753906, 0.0027809143, 0.047424316, -0.007575989, 0.021270752, -0.029449463, 0.0063705444, -0.011230469, -0.039367676, 0.02861023, -0.058410645, 0.003250122, 0.07836914, -0.014457703, -0.022781372, -0.016952515, -0.031433105, -0.011657715, 0.029632568, 0.006336212, 0.040039062, 0.019882202, 0.008155823, 0.008132935, 0.011314392, -0.017486572, -0.013168335, 0.00063085556, -0.0413208, -0.009498596, -0.019241333, -0.0059013367, 0.011161804, -0.0071983337, -0.011886597, 0.009048462, -0.024551392, 0.029403687, 0.011009216, 0.056915283, -0.0262146, -0.045135498, 0.009147644, -0.0569458, 0.03466797, 0.02645874, -0.050231934, -0.021881104, -0.028808594, -0.048095703, 0.030349731, -0.07678223, -0.0027999878, -0.0019073486, -0.007129669, 0.00579834, 0.0013780594, -0.023025513, 0.0037670135, -0.019882202, -0.006664276, 0.00819397, -0.028289795, 0.0014677048, -0.0003311634, 0.029876709, -0.011795044, -0.0038032532, 0.0362854, 0.030563354, 0.018035889, 0.018249512, 0.010101318, -0.0042915344, 0.015235901, 0.010917664, -0.012664795, 0.031677246, -0.008522034, 0.022415161, -0.010734558, -0.0067253113, 0.017425537, 0.0011997223, 0.0045204163, -0.016662598, -0.0016746521, -0.027328491, 0.011001587, -0.008514404, 0.021026611, -0.016952515, 0.004886627, 0.0053253174, 0.105651855, -0.030441284, -0.0042762756, 0.015029907, -0.0736084, -0.04888916, -0.030014038, -0.03982544, -0.030548096, -0.0063056946, -0.013595581, 0.004722595, -0.016815186, -0.027877808, -0.009750366, 0.047607422, 0.033447266, -0.019927979, -0.021530151, 0.014122009, 0.026657104, -0.048461914, 0.016281128, 0.074523926, -0.028503418, -0.015388489, -0.023895264, -0.06640625, -0.010604858, -0.06237793, -0.052368164, -0.006942749, -0.04321289, 0.024627686, -0.07086182, -0.041656494, -0.042816162, 0.004776001, 0.027877808, 0.03930664, -0.030929565, 0.0018625259, 0.076293945, -0.028381348, -0.024429321, 0.009719849, -0.035461426, -0.07525635, 0.0005059242, 0.037628174, -0.031158447, 0.026138306, 0.022109985, 0.04837036, -0.0052223206, -0.050567627, -0.024871826, 0.019882202, -0.0071144104, -0.034362793, -0.015068054, 0.033294678, 0.0007581711, 0.0206604, -0.007621765, -0.00015711784, 0.02835083, -0.038909912, -0.0028572083, 0.006374359, 0.004020691, -0.000600338, 0.02571106, -0.06463623, -0.05557251, -0.014862061, 0.017791748, 0.07574463, 0.0085372925, -0.034576416, 0.016586304, 0.004722595, 0.059539795, 0.02558899, -0.051116943, -0.086364746, 0.0025806427, -0.004119873, -0.007896423, -0.023864746, -0.0127334595, 0.0158844, -0.053497314, 0.020111084, -0.016860962, 0.04727173, -0.00076532364, 0.036834717, 0.013504028, 0.025131226, -0.035705566, 0.107421875, 0.0023441315, 0.022323608, -0.033050537, 0.011291504, -0.020492554, 0.0048179626, 0.013679504, -0.005630493, -0.039245605, -0.06008911, 0.018112183, 0.02279663, 0.009796143, 0.048950195, 0.047851562, 0.028076172, 0.05899048, 0.0073242188, 0.008560181, -0.008842468, -0.051116943, -0.0016307831, 0.023345947, 0.011772156, 0.010353088, 0.04864502, 0.0029888153, -0.032318115, -0.0030727386, 0.01776123, 0.011077881, 0.026977539, 0.01586914, 0.0051956177, 0.0066947937, -0.0014467239, 0.027435303, 0.0211792, 0.023239136, 0.01348114, 0.0045318604, -0.048034668, -0.0055274963, -0.016311646, -0.012535095, 0.012435913, -0.017730713, -0.001159668, -0.03744507, -0.042510986, -0.021987915, 0.054473877, -0.012542725, -0.027038574, -0.039489746, 0.0018291473, -0.027496338, -0.0036735535, -0.038635254, 0.038635254, 0.028656006, -0.0234375, -0.0049934387, -0.0076789856, -0.012626648, 0.005607605, -0.04434204, -0.014663696, -0.03024292, 0.008201599, 0.041015625, -0.006095886, -0.0058517456, -0.0077438354, 0.011688232, -0.03692627, -0.06640625, -0.019622803, -0.04232788, -0.0115356445, 0.01828003, -0.0104904175, -0.011802673, 0.02218628, -0.030044556, 0.023117065, -0.020141602, -0.020874023, -0.034179688, -0.011375427, 0.003768921, -0.011672974, -0.022140503, 0.03475952, -0.042053223, -0.012275696, 0.0025539398, -0.0050849915, 0.02708435, -0.026779175, -0.00945282, 0.0070877075, -0.016174316, 0.01940918, 0.029052734, 0.009307861, -0.024795532, -0.006477356, 0.025802612, -0.017333984, -0.042541504, 0.015449524, -0.025772095, -0.006324768, -0.033477783, -0.0032081604, -0.01914978, 0.010360718, 0.0259552, 0.014419556, 0.006855011, 0.023147583, -0.016357422, -0.034973145, -0.00097084045, 0.015640259, -0.024169922, -0.015838623, 0.022521973, 0.024490356, -0.008911133, -0.03186035, -0.052734375, -0.032073975, -0.06921387, 0.056152344, 0.009742737, 0.0040626526, -0.035064697, -0.02067566, 0.020706177, -0.07885742, -0.021697998, 0.02368164, 0.008636475, 0.003993988, -0.016403198, 0.033447266, 0.04043579, -0.028656006, -0.015510559, -0.024215698, 0.017028809, -0.021270752, -0.03817749, -0.04724121, -0.0060691833, -0.004142761, 0.019546509, -0.02720642, 0.005355835, -0.00566864, 0.02583313, 0.00920105, -0.0236969, -0.0047454834, 0.05947876, -0.03564453, -0.07312012, -0.03060913, 0.019042969, -0.03427124, -0.026397705, 0.0059432983, -0.07128906, 0.03387451, -0.016616821, -0.0007581711, 0.03189087, 0.04638672, 0.020812988, 0.08746338, 0.006072998, 0.016677856, 0.032226562, -0.0063171387, -0.006450653, -0.0016584396, 0.011489868, 0.031982422, 0.00137043, 0.032592773, -0.014930725, 0.017059326, 0.020904541, -0.037353516, -0.01713562, -0.017105103, 0.06707764, 0.03778076, -0.010681152, 0.0040245056, 0.021774292, 0.0028953552, -0.025405884, -0.018554688, 0.032318115, 0.03390503, -0.012771606, 0.0034370422, 0.01424408, 0.032470703, -0.010406494, -0.028533936, -0.0008239746, -0.02949524, 0.009277344, -0.00819397, -0.00067806244, -0.019165039, -0.020767212, -0.030944824, 0.034606934, 0.017959595, -0.020767212, 0.027633667, -0.00007909536, -0.006263733, 0.009407043, 0.00047373772, 0.004749298, 0.0061149597, -0.020217896, 0.0013532639, -0.028198242, -0.03451538, 0.004863739, 0.024108887, 0.005645752, 0.027664185, -0.026290894, 0.025680542, 0.031585693, -0.061401367, -0.010017395, 0.0019388199, 0.0146865845, -0.0048980713, 0.007091522, 0.0019950867, -0.015838623, 0.03451538, 0.039916992, -0.0023975372, -0.010276794, 0.04650879, -0.032684326, 0.025817871, -0.03640747, -0.024963379, 0.056030273, 0.011909485, -0.0040664673, -0.023895264, 0.024841309, 0.029144287, 0.038269043, -0.03326416, 0.010482788, 0.0009484291, 0.006580353, -0.028305054, 0.0015192032, -0.008293152, -0.0016736984, 0.014831543, -0.0009150505, 0.018676758, -0.00831604, -0.04058838, 0.009025574, 0.019195557, 0.06665039, -0.025543213, 0.0793457, -0.055664062, 0.0064582825, -0.04953003, 0.019180298, -0.033325195, -0.027023315, 0.009178162, 0.010520935, -0.05456543, 0.013305664, -0.022918701, 0.025527954, 0.025268555, 0.030136108, -0.035705566, -0.011726379, 0.054138184, -0.000018060207, 0.0025901794, -0.003168106, -0.008125305, -0.016525269, 0.018630981, 0.031219482, 0.036376953, 0.08660889, 0.05593872, 0.016098022, 0.043029785, -0.005268097, -0.049194336, -0.007698059, -0.03314209, 0.09283447, -0.027709961, 0.03225708, -0.035491943, -0.0127334595, -0.008583069, 0.027526855, -0.0052223206, 0.034179688, 0.04763794, 0.012611389, 0.026565552, -0.034423828, -0.014556885, -0.0025501251, 0.023269653, 0.030929565, 0.084350586, -0.019760132, 0.017837524, 0.012374878, -0.014427185, -0.04840088, -0.003528595, 0.01600647, 0.0079956055, -0.041809082, 0.032836914, 0.0345459, -0.022476196, -0.038635254, 0.03250122, -0.017868042, -0.012084961, 0.052978516, 0.003742218, 0.008972168, -0.023742676, 0.0012102127, 0.01576233, -0.003856659, -0.031829834, -0.018875122, 0.011177063, 0.05718994, -0.036315918, 0.013076782, -0.013427734, 0.011642456, -0.03829956, -0.072509766, 0.05480957, -0.025680542, 0.028137207, -0.010887146, -0.02571106, 0.0026760101, 0.004245758, -0.0009431839, 0.014953613, -0.00020754337, 0.023101807, 0.008712769, -0.0017271042, -0.0062408447, -0.017288208, 0.02861023, 0.024414062, 0.060913086, 0.008232117, -0.041656494, 0.036132812, -0.019424438, -0.04421997, -0.012321472, -0.00819397, 0.03326416, -0.021697998, 0.009490967, 0.045776367, -0.04144287, -0.032470703, 0.037750244, 0.050048828, -0.041900635, -0.02645874, 0.004486084, -0.011528015, -0.0054969788, -0.028182983, -0.010124207, -0.00035762787, 0.0027484894, 0.0013389587, -0.003665924, -0.025283813, -0.0053253174, -0.0060691833, -0.022232056, 0.03274536, 0.011856079, 0.03643799, -0.02218628, 0.045440674, 0.046722412, -0.0256958, -0.08062744, -0.021850586, -0.04135132, 0.010261536, -0.04724121, 0.053253174, 0.02796936, 0.02243042, 0.029174805, 0.014137268, 0.058563232, 0.096069336, -0.066833496, -0.037475586, -0.01826477, -0.038757324 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.14662v1
The State of AI Ethics Report (June 2020)
Abhishek Gupta, Camylle Lanteigne, Victoria Heath, Marianna Bergamaschi Ganapini, Erick Galinkin, Allison Cohen, Tania De Gasperis, Mo Akif, Renjie Butalid
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG
These past few months have been especially challenging, and the deployment of technology in ways hitherto untested at an unrivalled pace has left the internet and technology watchers aghast. Artificial intelligence has become the byword for technological progress and is being used in everything from helping us combat the COVID-19 pandemic to nudging our attention in different directions as we all spend increasingly larger amounts of time online. It has never been more important that we keep a sharp eye out on the development of this field and how it is shaping our society and interactions with each other. With this inaugural edition of the State of AI Ethics we hope to bring forward the most important developments that caught our attention at the Montreal AI Ethics Institute this past quarter. Our goal is to help you navigate this ever-evolving field swiftly and allow you and your organization to make informed decisions. This pulse-check for the state of discourse, research, and development is geared towards researchers and practitioners alike who are making decisions on behalf of their organizations in considering the societal impacts of AI-enabled solutions. We cover a wide set of areas in this report spanning Agency and Responsibility, Security and Risk, Disinformation, Jobs and Labor, the Future of AI Ethics, and more. Our staff has worked tirelessly over the past quarter surfacing signal from the noise so that you are equipped with the right tools and knowledge to confidently tread this complex yet consequential domain.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.14662v1
2020-06-25T19:00:41
2020-06-25T19:00:41
{ "title": [ -0.0050849915, -0.0067825317, -0.029403687, -0.018661499, -0.028305054, -0.014678955, -0.0056037903, 0.0038833618, 0.008224487, 0.016860962, -0.06060791, -0.00080013275, 0.060577393, -0.029724121, 0.021331787, -0.019058228, 0.01109314, -0.0056533813, 0.025314331, -0.012840271, -0.03656006, -0.0015983582, 0.053619385, -0.06866455, 0.046020508, 0.00793457, -0.06124878, -0.0001654625, -0.002664566, -0.028381348, 0.009864807, 0.048706055, 0.010444641, 0.044311523, -0.025756836, 0.062194824, -0.020889282, 0.026901245, 0.016601562, -0.003967285, 0.01838684, -0.020706177, -0.010688782, -0.042999268, -0.014122009, 0.0152282715, 0.008003235, 0.00687027, 0.021408081, 0.016021729, 0.024368286, 0.015960693, 0.0178833, 0.03704834, -0.01083374, -0.009147644, 0.0053901672, 0.006652832, 0.03744507, -0.055480957, -0.066101074, -0.005645752, 0.051361084, -0.0011463165, -0.00021648407, -0.037902832, -0.05114746, 0.02067566, 0.01789856, 0.022583008, 0.020309448, -0.03326416, 0.0007863045, 0.03253174, -0.041809082, -0.043273926, 0.013710022, 0.009880066, 0.02494812, 0.008682251, -0.035736084, -0.013961792, 0.010002136, -0.061309814, 0.00040721893, -0.024230957, -0.01399231, 0.009178162, 0.026565552, -0.003025055, -0.006668091, 0.017990112, -0.024505615, 0.062805176, -0.020065308, -0.007751465, 0.051361084, 0.07891846, -0.011222839, -0.013412476, -0.053131104, -0.0075950623, -0.057556152, -0.0063056946, 0.027648926, 0.012626648, 0.0066452026, -0.07879639, -0.005783081, -0.011650085, -0.045928955, 0.059020996, 0.06021118, -0.029251099, 0.018798828, -0.031280518, 0.02015686, 0.047302246, 0.004886627, -0.018249512, -0.0059547424, 0.009307861, 0.030044556, 0.03074646, 0.022872925, 0.026916504, -0.021713257, -0.033843994, 0.024154663, 0.011428833, -0.025253296, 0.045654297, -0.083984375, -0.06982422, -0.03994751, 0.005104065, -0.02243042, 0.025009155, 0.0020542145, 0.0029315948, -0.018951416, -0.013145447, 0.044952393, -0.0020942688, -0.017974854, 0.0032310486, -0.00007247925, 0.033691406, 0.040618896, -0.017532349, -0.032836914, 0.0066070557, -0.008529663, 0.03768921, 0.009887695, -0.003255844, -0.005554199, -0.008384705, 0.057556152, 0.007663727, 0.061157227, 0.001947403, 0.0085372925, 0.06768799, 0.054504395, -0.027267456, -0.0541687, 0.013183594, 0.015220642, 0.041137695, 0.018600464, -0.004497528, -0.009681702, -0.015335083, -0.026733398, -0.02619934, -0.044128418, -0.003200531, 0.035461426, 0.0031967163, -0.030944824, -0.04144287, -0.048461914, 0.031143188, 0.011024475, -0.03338623, -0.0019006729, -0.02067566, -0.0067367554, 0.0056381226, -0.03189087, 0.033477783, -0.029129028, -0.004283905, -0.035339355, 0.00409317, -0.010284424, 0.020401001, -0.00919342, -0.023788452, -0.039245605, 0.06317139, -0.03717041, 0.060577393, 0.0047798157, 0.014778137, 0.02293396, 0.015838623, -0.0206604, 0.03375244, 0.0154953, -0.021972656, 0.0071907043, -0.018325806, 0.0016803741, -0.04284668, -0.039367676, -0.048858643, 0.0069999695, -0.029953003, -0.015487671, 0.083618164, -0.026870728, -0.011550903, 0.021255493, 0.037200928, 0.011833191, 0.0027618408, 0.1060791, -0.0002090931, 0.10650635, -0.03829956, 0.06768799, 0.024551392, -0.06518555, -0.017730713, 0.015487671, -0.02355957, 0.0035591125, 0.054992676, 0.006828308, 0.020858765, -0.036590576, 0.008766174, 0.068359375, 0.018951416, 0.015586853, 0.017318726, 0.007843018, -0.0066719055, 0.045654297, -0.0017404556, 0.05319214, 0.012481689, 0.0014562607, 0.0357666, -0.03338623, -0.045837402, -0.0017290115, 0.024658203, 0.01914978, -0.011238098, 0.0047187805, -0.0038089752, -0.03729248, 0.0045776367, 0.0015668869, 0.034851074, -0.008735657, -0.015281677, 0.014343262, 0.01574707, -0.014724731, 0.03265381, 0.014053345, -0.017089844, -0.028396606, 0.007347107, -0.033111572, 0.000603199, 0.0077209473, 0.011878967, 0.037231445, 0.0027809143, 0.016479492, 0.020095825, 0.037384033, 0.006614685, -0.029525757, -0.012191772, 0.020980835, 0.032470703, -0.007156372, -0.011703491, 0.01461792, -0.0059394836, 0.0149002075, 0.042907715, 0.009552002, -0.03201294, -0.10620117, 0.012130737, -0.01625061, 0.018692017, 0.018936157, 0.029556274, 0.027267456, -0.01751709, 0.005680084, 0.021118164, -0.047454834, -0.0127334595, 0.015396118, 0.022338867, -0.024002075, -0.05130005, -0.012451172, 0.014091492, -0.06274414, -0.020309448, 0.0690918, 0.03387451, 0.034851074, -0.052337646, 0.025390625, -0.042877197, -0.04824829, -0.010169983, -0.011230469, -0.016418457, -0.030029297, -0.04598999, -0.06414795, 0.01184082, 0.002855301, 0.035980225, 0.007484436, 0.12524414, 0.0030899048, -0.08270264, -0.04095459, -0.00042939186, -0.023849487, 0.0016679764, 0.02394104, -0.037200928, -0.0060157776, 0.010223389, -0.019515991, -0.0020999908, -0.0024471283, -0.008682251, -0.023895264, -0.008003235, 0.015670776, -0.015617371, 0.01083374, 0.036224365, 0.028717041, -0.019943237, 0.04031372, 0.025787354, 0.023605347, -0.05215454, -0.051727295, -0.051940918, -0.023376465, -0.00040864944, 0.0026054382, 0.011566162, -0.01058197, -0.0029144287, 0.0016336441, -0.007686615, -0.021026611, -0.009338379, -0.025268555, -0.050811768, -0.02154541, -0.03010559, -0.006095886, -0.005168915, 0.043151855, -0.00084400177, 0.041137695, 0.020874023, -0.02861023, 0.0016908646, 0.0040512085, 0.010848999, -0.0054130554, 0.016967773, -0.010574341, -0.0017871857, 0.031402588, -0.0075683594, -0.0026435852, 0.000770092, -0.080444336, 0.0016994476, -0.0032367706, -0.030776978, -0.014709473, -0.025878906, -0.03878784, -0.015899658, -0.02154541, -0.018737793, 0.04385376, -0.010475159, -0.015129089, 0.03262329, 0.030654907, -0.028366089, -0.016983032, -0.021896362, -0.039093018, 0.005355835, -0.032836914, 0.022979736, 0.019973755, 0.036956787, -0.030471802, 0.0040779114, 0.0069770813, -0.025939941, -0.0046195984, -0.027633667, 0.0036449432, 0.012428284, -0.022720337, -0.021133423, -0.00017011166, -0.024108887, -0.0146484375, -0.016159058, -0.044311523, -0.0027313232, -0.0076675415, -0.014694214, -0.030838013, 0.01625061, -0.0017318726, 0.009613037, 0.0050964355, -0.020248413, -0.0039482117, -0.042999268, -0.024841309, 0.028915405, -0.047210693, 0.013771057, -0.028945923, 0.021209717, -0.029251099, 0.0040740967, 0.027435303, 0.032104492, 0.008781433, 0.028930664, 0.015670776, -0.008720398, 0.009063721, -0.000071406364, -0.06530762, 0.02671814, 0.016342163, 0.029067993, -0.023651123, -0.025741577, -0.0068244934, 0.03213501, -0.01713562, -0.0053100586, -0.0054893494, -0.03729248, -0.023239136, 0.023086548, 0.023666382, 0.007045746, -0.006702423, -0.008659363, -0.0056648254, -0.013008118, 0.002954483, -0.006099701, -0.06500244, 0.012298584, 0.015556335, -0.08294678, -0.056243896, -0.01928711, 0.028030396, -0.09484863, 0.004322052, -0.029327393, -0.008453369, 0.0569458, -0.001329422, -0.0317688, -0.021865845, -0.024719238, -0.020263672, -0.016555786, 0.024719238, 0.021606445, 0.019119263, 0.008422852, 0.019699097, 0.04547119, 0.015060425, -0.014404297, -0.003446579, 0.022705078, -0.038879395, 0.018875122, -0.0027503967, -0.057037354, -0.0010509491, 0.02758789, 0.005050659, 0.07879639, -0.08135986, 0.007545471, 0.101135254, 0.0036087036, -0.09106445, 0.061157227, -0.014884949, -0.1227417, -0.0041160583, 0.036834717, -0.013206482, 0.07043457, 0.021316528, 0.08520508, -0.018630981, -0.009155273, 0.013420105, 0.011550903, 0.015655518, 0.0051994324, -0.012924194, 0.0127334595, -0.001162529, -0.034454346, -0.021942139, 0.037750244, 0.03366089, 0.003768921, 0.010345459, -0.012580872, -0.03173828, -0.060058594, -0.019989014, 0.006832123, -0.023468018, -0.010292053, 0.018844604, 0.0063095093, 0.036132812, 0.025756836, -0.0335083, -0.019180298, -0.0008249283, -0.022109985, 0.04046631, -0.02015686, -0.03451538, -0.026229858, -0.05871582, -0.040405273, 0.014480591, 0.039764404, 0.004306793, 0.0053138733, 0.0049972534, 0.034088135, -0.011520386, -0.021652222, 0.013000488, -0.012313843, 0.0052871704, 0.04336548, -0.00005173683, 0.018249512, -0.03768921, -0.010604858, -0.01928711, -0.023468018, -0.010910034, 0.006477356, -0.015655518, -0.013198853, 0.023345947, -0.01576233, 0.06201172, -0.0025081635, 0.004142761, 0.017501831, 0.025146484, 0.002532959, 0.011260986, -0.039093018, -0.008239746, -0.040985107, 0.019577026, -0.009986877, 0.050354004, 0.012611389, 0.027191162, -0.033294678, -0.00970459, 0.041290283, 0.00022006035, -0.05316162, 0.010292053, 0.027114868, 0.010604858, 0.004245758, 0.023498535, 0.019363403, 0.012214661, -0.031829834, 0.04598999, -0.034210205, -0.010238647, 0.027359009, 0.010932922, -0.0037441254, 0.016571045, -0.009155273, 0.010978699, -0.045318604, 0.029327393, 0.004699707, 0.0385437, -0.011672974, 0.006702423, 0.072143555, -0.041412354, 0.014846802, -0.037750244, 0.04763794, 0.041778564, -0.040222168, -0.024017334, -0.035064697, -0.020858765, -0.04071045, -0.061553955, -0.0037345886, -0.0085372925, 0.027359009, 0.045532227, -0.022491455, -0.035003662, -0.010116577, 0.03237915, 0.0038585663, 0.0107421875, 0.0859375, -0.05480957, 0.07702637, 0.015159607, 0.0005850792, 0.011482239, 0.039916992, -0.012336731, -0.013954163, 0.030059814, -0.020233154, -0.037963867, -0.003616333, 0.0015382767, 0.026535034, -0.010475159, 0.021728516, -0.026992798, -0.00843811, 0.012275696, 0.0028572083, 0.018295288, -0.005104065, -0.029251099, 0.022354126, -0.010185242, 0.0035591125, -0.026382446, -0.03161621, -0.058532715, 0.042114258, -0.034423828, 0.028045654, 0.01928711, -0.022903442, -0.00017046928, -0.021850586, 0.046539307, -0.016845703, -0.007949829, -0.0038928986, 0.006580353, -0.009429932, 0.0075302124, -0.004535675, -0.04156494, -0.021347046, 0.008262634, 0.009231567, -0.0006146431, 0.011886597, -0.028137207, -0.010063171, -0.0019006729, -0.036987305, -0.036895752, 0.04324341, 0.008010864, -0.018234253, -0.0256958, -0.057861328, -0.055419922, -0.011161804, -0.007835388, -0.0012578964, -0.06378174, -0.0013618469, 0.0026130676, 0.0053863525, 0.0022449493, 0.026779175, 0.027236938, -0.023345947, 0.0003941059, -0.060455322, 0.019454956, 0.008255005, -0.030670166, 0.012504578, 0.010093689, -0.01600647, 0.04232788, 0.0019779205, 0.056549072, 0.0064048767, 0.0340271, -0.009674072, -0.0077705383, 0.043823242, 0.052825928, -0.10559082, -0.02911377, -0.018676758, 0.008056641, -0.06939697, -0.043762207, 0.047332764, 0.0062179565, 0.0036964417, -0.008979797, -0.014122009, -0.007587433, 0.0079193115, -0.055847168, 0.0034713745, -0.026382446, -0.017929077, -0.026977539, 0.024093628, -0.0062942505, 0.023132324, -0.040374756, -0.0072021484, 0.004802704, 0.0062713623, -0.014183044, 0.0068626404, 0.043395996, 0.030929565, 0.016738892, 0.013549805, 0.008842468, -0.020584106, -0.0055007935, 0.016403198, 0.006591797, 0.0064582825, 0.003446579, -0.027832031, -0.055541992, 0.027130127, -0.0018644333, 0.019058228, 0.018173218, 0.0075263977, 0.01361084, 0.0009703636, -0.012168884, -0.010101318, 0.048614502, -0.040374756, 0.060058594, 0.03125, 0.005908966, -0.09503174, 0.010932922, 0.07598877, -0.0017633438, 0.0067634583, 0.010635376, -0.0035419464, -0.03930664, 0.011711121, -0.018035889, 0.035736084, 0.020095825, -0.019546509, 0.0118637085, 0.0034656525, -0.0019989014, 0.021438599, 0.021865845, 0.017074585, 0.011413574, 0.020812988, 0.04385376, -0.034057617, -0.01184845, -0.06536865, 0.03353882, -0.040863037, -0.07733154, -0.0075912476, -0.05517578, 0.02142334, 0.032073975, -0.024124146, 0.036102295, 0.041168213, 0.006549835, 0.014099121, -0.000024735928, 0.019180298, -0.027069092, 0.048736572, 0.031143188, -0.033447266, -0.003194809, 0.059326172, 0.01991272, -0.015510559, 0.0075302124, 0.02798462, 0.0012025833, 0.02192688, 0.01789856, -0.03656006, -0.0345459, 0.04699707, 0.019424438, -0.041870117, -0.03555298, 0.022537231, 0.0017681122, 0.022506714, -0.004421234, -0.03164673, 0.03656006, -0.02458191, 0.028549194, -0.012329102, 0.06390381, -0.037139893, -0.028015137, 0.030395508, -0.00868988, -0.01373291, 0.003774643, 0.029251099, 0.051208496, -0.015411377, 0.049102783, -0.0023708344, -0.019088745, -0.020141602, 0.023864746, 0.021743774, 0.012687683, -0.009094238, 0.02192688, -0.009605408, 0.0016374588, 0.05886841, 0.0032482147, 0.0519104, 0.054382324, 0.049682617, -0.022567749, -0.02897644, 0.019927979, -0.048828125, 0.036193848, 0.0023326874, 0.042022705, 0.024841309, 0.049560547, -0.018356323, -0.014564514, 0.054107666, 0.035186768, 0.05923462, 0.021118164, 0.048736572, -0.041290283, -0.015037537, 0.044952393, 0.040008545, 0.06933594, 0.029876709, 0.0040397644, 0.014762878, 0.025909424, -0.015823364, -0.0345459, -0.017150879, 0.025634766, -0.0134887695, -0.019805908, -0.013038635, -0.0053482056, -0.019714355, -0.037353516, 0.0068206787, -0.00012290478, -0.028198242, 0.013702393, 0.031921387, 0.026947021, -0.13232422, -0.00806427, -0.025512695, -0.0075035095, -0.03817749, -0.005970001, -0.0019168854, 0.02748108, -0.009216309, -0.0013723373, 0.016555786, 0.026809692, -0.034484863, -0.031051636, -0.01007843, -0.012008667, 0.005306244, -0.066101074, -0.07910156, 0.008811951, 0.089782715, -0.0055236816, 0.023971558, -0.016357422, 0.00022184849, -0.012939453, 0.015625, -0.0069465637, -0.006416321, 0.05102539, 0.024765015, 0.0060653687, 0.013786316, -0.03805542, 0.027008057, -0.023803711, -0.015235901, 0.0025234222, 0.005191803, -0.017471313, 0.0023765564, 0.0028018951, 0.018188477, -0.0023021698, -0.018005371, 0.035247803, -0.00007480383, -0.008644104, 0.0057907104, -0.03189087, -0.0062789917, -0.019882202, 0.018341064, 0.019134521, -0.049560547, 0.0075416565, 0.02078247, 0.017059326, 0.050109863, 0.001947403, -0.0619812, -0.005634308, 0.0026016235, 0.017684937, -0.0038528442, -0.008926392, -0.024612427, -0.00068092346, -0.024307251, -0.036865234, 0.022872925, -0.016098022, 0.007873535, -0.07312012, 0.05340576, -0.008140564, -0.0029468536, 0.020767212, 0.023803711, 0.034454346, 0.024093628, -0.04647827, -0.013458252, 0.01739502, -0.02381897 ], "summary": [ -0.0059928894, -0.04837036, 0.0060577393, 0.0057411194, -0.026824951, -0.015853882, 0.039916992, -0.019073486, 0.024505615, -0.0069503784, -0.07977295, 0.038330078, -0.016021729, 0.0011062622, 0.02720642, -0.02381897, -0.012580872, 0.005306244, -0.0027770996, -0.03164673, 0.004142761, -0.062286377, 0.03564453, -0.05050659, 0.04916382, -0.029891968, -0.06488037, 0.053344727, -0.00000846386, 0.016174316, 0.028396606, -0.025177002, 0.03451538, 0.05255127, -0.08459473, 0.01953125, -0.017150879, 0.010276794, 0.0004901886, 0.006198883, 0.026016235, -0.02709961, 0.05819702, 0.014442444, -0.0051879883, 0.016677856, 0.006336212, -0.029067993, 0.037841797, 0.010955811, 0.026947021, 0.030731201, 0.012397766, 0.012939453, -0.006565094, 0.022232056, 0.018936157, -0.0035476685, 0.027954102, -0.014038086, -0.017852783, 0.017456055, 0.012687683, 0.00027179718, -0.0073661804, -0.03894043, 0.029037476, 0.017364502, -0.03164673, 0.0066604614, 0.04901123, -0.004917145, 0.019638062, -0.04815674, -0.02041626, 0.02998352, -0.016082764, -0.013435364, 0.027282715, -0.024520874, -0.0059509277, 0.012954712, -0.006416321, 0.0052833557, -0.049438477, -0.0024356842, -0.014839172, -0.0034275055, 0.020431519, 0.0026798248, -0.017593384, 0.033843994, -0.0054893494, 0.046966553, -0.007080078, -0.009735107, 0.0072784424, 0.043151855, 0.011123657, 0.0152282715, -0.012641907, -0.024551392, -0.03125, -0.02583313, 0.0037975311, 0.06933594, -0.018081665, -0.11218262, -0.01537323, 0.0012016296, -0.0047950745, -0.0039520264, 0.032440186, -0.024139404, -0.013160706, 0.026779175, 0.03225708, 0.0062942505, 0.009208679, 0.009399414, -0.026031494, 0.024215698, 0.039794922, -0.011459351, 0.0038776398, 0.04046631, 0.004497528, -0.05343628, -0.00040125847, 0.014129639, 0.0066223145, 0.008934021, -0.026931763, -0.041931152, -0.053100586, -0.008102417, 0.03314209, 0.028579712, 0.010467529, 0.0046081543, 0.039031982, -0.030639648, -0.00466156, 0.025863647, -0.015777588, -0.029846191, -0.00030755997, 0.04486084, 0.025497437, 0.02267456, -0.0050582886, 0.00081062317, 0.0158844, -0.012458801, -0.011695862, -0.057281494, 0.000070393085, -0.019866943, 0.022842407, -0.039855957, 0.04815674, 0.035614014, 0.07873535, 0.054779053, 0.06188965, -0.031158447, -0.08270264, -0.009757996, 0.015899658, -0.020050049, 0.020004272, 0.04598999, 0.013153076, 0.016220093, 0.0082092285, -0.014335632, -0.005191803, -0.020370483, -0.0029067993, -0.0090789795, -0.035339355, -0.06738281, -0.08917236, 0.03152466, -0.025283813, 0.060668945, -0.009223938, 0.026901245, 0.029373169, -0.005428314, -0.03503418, 0.03062439, -0.018859863, -0.02532959, 0.0009737015, -0.021697998, 0.0072364807, -0.021270752, -0.0047187805, 0.01902771, 0.03778076, 0.027755737, -0.029830933, -0.036010742, -0.0881958, -0.014343262, -0.027450562, 0.034484863, -0.034179688, 0.0129852295, 0.027954102, -0.066345215, -0.028884888, 0.07763672, 0.028762817, -0.037231445, 0.0031394958, -0.028884888, 0.013587952, -0.02130127, -0.006248474, 0.07324219, -0.04525757, -0.031280518, -0.0055160522, -0.0077819824, 0.0037574768, 0.0056419373, 0.07208252, 0.008460999, 0.1081543, -0.049591064, 0.013687134, 0.017425537, -0.0025978088, 0.0054779053, -0.008560181, -0.08026123, 0.007549286, 0.052246094, 0.00233078, 0.012283325, -0.03652954, -0.00028443336, -0.028274536, -0.018447876, 0.0063476562, -0.010505676, 0.020568848, -0.011199951, 0.061676025, -0.04647827, 0.060791016, -0.024627686, 0.0015363693, 0.03378296, -0.062805176, -0.09552002, 0.024978638, 0.0018730164, 0.03652954, -0.07519531, -0.03289795, -0.013900757, -0.054260254, 0.009300232, -0.009254456, 0.0031490326, -0.011878967, -0.014656067, 0.028656006, 0.016326904, -0.0010986328, 0.0003874302, -0.013259888, 0.015174866, -0.018432617, 0.0063095093, 0.021224976, -0.005382538, 0.0015439987, -0.03314209, 0.0032596588, -0.00050115585, 0.031234741, 0.0055618286, 0.041656494, 0.026245117, -0.016326904, -0.008705139, 0.022583008, 0.0069847107, -0.030975342, -0.0075531006, -0.00843811, -0.024139404, -0.025939941, 0.0137786865, 0.0107040405, -0.023040771, -0.05871582, 0.01864624, -0.003528595, -0.017333984, 0.013381958, -0.015319824, 0.022476196, 0.003862381, 0.011047363, 0.0035381317, -0.03353882, 0.02330017, -0.0047798157, -0.006893158, -0.006088257, -0.029144287, -0.022445679, 0.0069732666, -0.0135269165, 0.047088623, 0.068847656, -0.040374756, 0.0005707741, -0.015426636, -0.018829346, -0.034088135, 0.007030487, -0.014022827, -0.016784668, 0.02758789, -0.014884949, 0.004753113, -0.024795532, 0.007167816, -0.006259918, 0.0284729, 0.0064086914, 0.052947998, 0.01033783, -0.025558472, 0.043823242, 0.0060043335, -0.0017108917, 0.016357422, -0.032440186, -0.020751953, 0.028167725, 0.001001358, -0.027908325, 0.000047028065, 0.006542206, -0.028442383, 0.0010595322, -0.021713257, 0.010406494, 0.01979065, 0.005264282, -0.034179688, -0.013122559, -0.05206299, 0.03277588, 0.009735107, 0.009384155, -0.082092285, -0.01777649, -0.008018494, 0.0022697449, -0.045562744, -0.011047363, 0.0063667297, 0.016357422, -0.0024204254, -0.02470398, -0.018432617, -0.024597168, 0.0038146973, 0.061157227, -0.009819031, 0.013397217, 0.04232788, 0.0015211105, 0.016189575, -0.01626587, 0.016311646, 0.07562256, 0.0045166016, -0.018554688, -0.008087158, 0.044403076, 0.02658081, 0.0178833, -0.033172607, 0.017410278, -0.02519226, 0.0146484375, -0.006389618, -0.024978638, 0.028884888, -0.043060303, -0.0042800903, 0.021484375, 0.008834839, -0.0037345886, -0.02798462, -0.018875122, 0.028060913, 0.0006933212, -0.012336731, 0.020812988, -0.070251465, -0.009986877, 0.006576538, -0.049102783, 0.0054130554, -0.0003874302, -0.058502197, -0.023025513, -0.017654419, 0.00078582764, 0.0046539307, -0.0059280396, 0.011154175, -0.0076942444, 0.014205933, -0.011985779, 0.0087509155, -0.004348755, 0.02130127, -0.029846191, 0.005630493, -0.00573349, -0.022705078, 0.006462097, 0.027893066, -0.03479004, 0.007850647, -0.007484436, -0.035583496, 0.035736084, -0.05596924, -0.004512787, 0.022628784, 0.011375427, -0.02999878, -0.004337311, -0.013496399, 0.05050659, 0.0039138794, -0.027832031, -0.013092041, -0.006263733, 0.008453369, 0.03062439, 0.035583496, -0.0039596558, 0.037353516, -0.017578125, 0.035736084, 0.0395813, 0.0064086914, 0.02104187, -0.025604248, 0.047576904, 0.026779175, -0.00033020973, 0.049713135, -0.070251465, 0.011291504, -0.030197144, -0.013587952, 0.056518555, -0.00003683567, -0.020401001, -0.003868103, -0.0014562607, 0.009780884, -0.0039749146, -0.013572693, 0.05001831, 0.032348633, -0.011924744, 0.01739502, -0.0018053055, -0.04824829, -0.0068206787, 0.009208679, -0.06707764, -0.03881836, 0.014732361, -0.05609131, -0.003686905, -0.04043579, 0.048980713, -0.064941406, 0.0023288727, -0.03793335, -0.030807495, 0.07232666, 0.022079468, -0.034118652, 0.015342712, -0.025161743, 0.057128906, -0.02166748, 0.030761719, 0.059570312, 0.03982544, 0.00073099136, -0.01776123, 0.0039901733, 0.034240723, -0.04949951, -0.023147583, 0.008468628, -0.029418945, 0.004207611, -0.022979736, -0.050750732, -0.017303467, 0.021469116, 0.04888916, 0.028427124, -0.03982544, -0.003768921, 0.06781006, 0.0035362244, -0.0692749, -0.0029697418, -0.003660202, -0.04852295, 0.016326904, 0.03048706, -0.03353882, 0.0073432922, 0.009056091, 0.008430481, -0.04144287, 0.009231567, 0.034942627, 0.022247314, -0.03704834, -0.007858276, 0.014923096, 0.062072754, -0.0030841827, -0.0055885315, -0.03842163, 0.009849548, -0.032562256, 0.018615723, -0.014190674, -0.017822266, -0.029815674, -0.0065689087, 0.022079468, -0.0491333, -0.06185913, 0.0058021545, 0.0009212494, 0.055145264, 0.0209198, -0.04751587, 0.013145447, 0.02029419, 0.11022949, 0.018966675, -0.022079468, -0.10168457, -0.053588867, -0.0045814514, -0.051483154, -0.012641907, 0.020339966, 0.008323669, -0.039855957, -0.014823914, 0.0181427, 0.06488037, 0.005908966, 0.0030384064, -0.015701294, 0.007911682, 0.004501343, 0.09338379, -0.015449524, 0.0040664673, -0.012718201, 0.0069389343, -0.021957397, -0.01991272, 0.021774292, -0.016555786, 0.0043258667, 0.035491943, 0.0158844, -0.013442993, 0.042114258, -0.044067383, 0.02848816, -0.0032081604, 0.04949951, 0.0026988983, -0.002910614, -0.022979736, -0.030670166, -0.03503418, 0.030441284, -0.027893066, 0.04244995, 0.009346008, -0.050842285, -0.08148193, -0.00019919872, 0.0473938, -0.019882202, -0.0042152405, 0.014045715, -0.00983429, 0.0009536743, -0.032073975, 0.022766113, 0.0034255981, -0.00031876564, 0.06707764, 0.052520752, -0.0017137527, -0.06488037, 0.029724121, -0.000057041645, -0.016082764, 0.0129470825, -0.028579712, -0.023345947, -0.078552246, -0.011680603, 0.052520752, 0.033203125, -0.0034236908, 0.004322052, 0.0066070557, -0.045562744, 0.01689148, -0.068603516, 0.0552063, 0.022247314, -0.0030574799, -0.031097412, -0.054260254, -0.014968872, -0.020889282, -0.06573486, -0.01008606, -0.055755615, 0.04736328, 0.05441284, 0.0030326843, -0.025634766, -0.027023315, 0.024108887, -0.016433716, -0.04171753, 0.02835083, -0.0418396, 0.037017822, -0.0022525787, -0.006111145, 0.034729004, 0.011054993, -0.013206482, -0.033599854, -0.013557434, -0.054595947, -0.049102783, -0.006855011, 0.013130188, -0.0049552917, -0.030075073, 0.01939392, -0.049865723, -0.0030059814, -0.008148193, -0.03225708, 0.026046753, -0.013046265, -0.007045746, 0.005428314, -0.02760315, 0.015380859, -0.017700195, 0.0056991577, -0.047698975, 0.00881958, -0.00843811, 0.019638062, -0.013038635, 0.003818512, -0.014801025, -0.0036792755, -0.022598267, 0.0009975433, 0.0056266785, 0.026489258, 0.027755737, 0.02909851, -0.0033035278, -0.02658081, -0.041107178, -0.039855957, 0.014305115, 0.01058197, -0.040893555, 0.0032806396, -0.008255005, -0.00737381, 0.0126571655, -0.05090332, -0.05154419, -0.03866577, -0.05621338, 0.037628174, -0.006252289, 0.019851685, -0.031311035, -0.0073547363, 0.010734558, -0.04776001, -0.06317139, 0.016143799, 0.0015869141, 0.031555176, 0.025299072, -0.0003888607, -0.00000846386, -0.01651001, 0.024398804, -0.049926758, 0.021987915, -0.0020103455, -0.011543274, -0.013923645, -0.035980225, -0.0009784698, 0.022598267, -0.013328552, 0.055358887, 0.0041503906, 0.031707764, 0.023330688, -0.011672974, 0.02772522, 0.04550171, -0.064697266, -0.012046814, -0.027496338, 0.0085372925, -0.057647705, -0.018875122, 0.043060303, 0.0053520203, 0.0047073364, -0.04373169, 0.010284424, -0.001991272, 0.007041931, 0.013427734, 0.0057029724, -0.007904053, 0.014289856, 0.012336731, 0.0045928955, 0.007572174, -0.030181885, 0.00033020973, 0.057037354, 0.0057296753, 0.024276733, -0.03878784, 0.025726318, 0.008850098, 0.021255493, 0.014724731, -0.00063085556, 0.03366089, -0.011962891, -0.0018100739, 0.02218628, 0.020843506, 0.0023994446, 0.002319336, -0.013977051, 0.002023697, 0.017089844, -0.00868988, -0.033081055, -0.032196045, -0.010826111, 0.05090332, -0.015296936, -0.021911621, 0.005218506, 0.022109985, -0.0012893677, -0.0031604767, -0.009094238, -0.017532349, -0.033233643, 0.000018298626, 0.032409668, 0.0010910034, 0.014541626, 0.0047836304, 0.014915466, 0.011856079, -0.012992859, -0.020843506, 0.00081920624, 0.0072135925, 0.012260437, 0.038482666, -0.00831604, -0.040527344, 0.028396606, -0.0021839142, 0.035308838, -0.007873535, 0.0009059906, 0.022338867, -0.012283325, -0.0034236908, -0.057891846, -0.00032639503, -0.045440674, 0.0289917, 0.033477783, 0.02658081, 0.015899658, 0.048431396, 0.025360107, 0.009971619, 0.020858765, -0.027908325, 0.0713501, -0.057678223, -0.027786255, 0.04736328, 0.028305054, 0.03427124, -0.015731812, 0.0033187866, 0.009849548, 0.04937744, -0.062408447, -0.016326904, 0.005340576, 0.017242432, -0.021911621, 0.017654419, -0.0335083, -0.041992188, 0.011932373, 0.02557373, -0.014060974, -0.008995056, -0.027053833, 0.0074005127, -0.038513184, 0.034240723, -0.05697632, 0.057037354, -0.08959961, 0.010955811, -0.040740967, 0.0054740906, -0.026870728, -0.01499939, 0.025283813, -0.003206253, -0.009971619, 0.00674057, 0.048034668, 0.05697632, 0.0006246567, 0.048858643, -0.04055786, 0.00093984604, 0.014823914, 0.033081055, 0.048034668, 0.025054932, 0.025375366, 0.03933716, -0.022262573, -0.012542725, 0.07128906, 0.058044434, 0.088134766, 0.013366699, 0.02748108, -0.014274597, -0.011054993, -0.020111084, -0.0076522827, 0.054473877, -0.0018482208, 0.048950195, -0.015014648, 0.01675415, -0.020935059, 0.009025574, 0.014320374, 0.052764893, 0.056762695, 0.015640259, 0.013946533, -0.02720642, -0.013198853, -0.0181427, 0.0012893677, 0.031463623, 0.085876465, -0.016021729, 0.007499695, 0.036834717, -0.009994507, -0.047546387, -0.027648926, 0.046936035, 0.036102295, -0.03765869, 0.03390503, 0.052581787, 0.0037212372, 0.005847931, -0.034118652, 0.008285522, -0.017669678, 0.02557373, 0.013893127, 0.025772095, -0.078186035, -0.0054244995, -0.012023926, -0.020477295, -0.050720215, 0.007949829, 0.03945923, 0.011985779, 0.006603241, -0.0033664703, 0.01826477, 0.03048706, -0.003780365, -0.07476807, 0.009132385, -0.04071045, 0.007965088, -0.029006958, -0.10888672, 0.027709961, 0.06878662, -0.011238098, -0.0077285767, -0.032073975, -0.002008438, 0.06567383, 0.033996582, 0.011962891, -0.03125, 0.013587952, -0.011291504, 0.06939697, 0.038635254, -0.04144287, 0.015853882, 0.026260376, 0.0032806396, -0.0335083, -0.040802002, 0.0317688, -0.049224854, 0.009857178, 0.013175964, -0.03265381, -0.0038814545, -0.0014133453, -0.0033493042, -0.0028457642, 0.0034008026, -0.0009522438, 0.0037651062, -0.013496399, 0.034179688, 0.026153564, -0.025772095, -0.015312195, 0.018234253, 0.009033203, 0.024261475, -0.008232117, -0.06298828, -0.03366089, -0.00054597855, 0.036590576, -0.004711151, -0.012191772, -0.06945801, 0.0057411194, -0.027542114, -0.04586792, -0.016555786, -0.072387695, 0.030288696, -0.013633728, 0.03314209, 0.04055786, 0.029968262, 0.013214111, 0.024032593, -0.00957489, 0.028808594, -0.018844604, -0.012565613, -0.02507019, -0.01977539 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2006.15826v1
Towards Learning-automation IoT Attack Detection through Reinforcement Learning
Tianbo Gu, Allaukik Abhishek, Hao Fu, Huanle Zhang, Debraj Basu, Prasant Mohapatra
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
As a massive number of the Internet of Things (IoT) devices are deployed, the security and privacy issues in IoT arouse more and more attention. The IoT attacks are causing tremendous loss to the IoT networks and even threatening human safety. Compared to traditional networks, IoT networks have unique characteristics, which make the attack detection more challenging. First, the heterogeneity of platforms, protocols, software, and hardware exposes various vulnerabilities. Second, in addition to the traditional high-rate attacks, the low-rate attacks are also extensively used by IoT attackers to obfuscate the legitimate and malicious traffic. These low-rate attacks are challenging to detect and can persist in the networks. Last, the attackers are evolving to be more intelligent and can dynamically change their attack strategies based on the environment feedback to avoid being detected, making it more challenging for the defender to discover a consistent pattern to identify the attack. In order to adapt to the new characteristics in IoT attacks, we propose a reinforcement learning-based attack detection model that can automatically learn and recognize the transformation of the attack pattern. Therefore, we can continuously detect IoT attacks with less human intervention. In this paper, we explore the crucial features of IoT traffics and utilize the entropy-based metrics to detect both the high-rate and low-rate IoT attacks. Afterward, we leverage the reinforcement learning technique to continuously adjust the attack detection threshold based on the detection feedback, which optimizes the detection and the false alarm rate. We conduct extensive experiments over a real IoT attack dataset and demonstrate the effectiveness of our IoT attack detection framework.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.15826v1
2020-06-29T06:12:45
2020-06-29T06:12:45
{ "title": [ -0.017456055, 0.004852295, -0.04220581, -0.010154724, 0.021835327, -0.03479004, 0.019210815, -0.021011353, -0.0814209, 0.03189087, -0.022277832, 0.034942627, -0.021835327, -0.02017212, -0.0008740425, -0.027069092, -0.016479492, 0.025177002, -0.014213562, -0.031585693, 0.015434265, -0.039031982, 0.03942871, 0.027786255, 0.02772522, 0.0009832382, -0.081604004, 0.0063819885, -0.027893066, -0.04647827, -0.0055503845, 0.028121948, 0.03717041, 0.038604736, -0.0368042, 0.013175964, -0.032440186, 0.030975342, -0.00894165, 0.029205322, 0.010101318, -0.004173279, 0.019500732, -0.0053100586, -0.012718201, 0.047576904, -0.06591797, -0.031707764, -0.008018494, 0.05102539, 0.03152466, 0.034851074, -0.0052223206, 0.027297974, 0.023452759, -0.0335083, -0.032562256, -0.020965576, 0.044158936, 0.07385254, 0.019622803, -0.05291748, 0.016708374, -0.04751587, -0.010406494, -0.023757935, 0.04220581, 0.02709961, 0.052490234, 0.0031604767, 0.0017356873, 0.039978027, 0.010131836, 0.032348633, -0.05215454, -0.05053711, 0.07824707, 0.0010519028, 0.012931824, -0.0041542053, 0.00082206726, -0.028045654, 0.008201599, -0.0007214546, 0.011528015, -0.01071167, -0.0063705444, -0.010681152, -0.033294678, -0.04397583, -0.011390686, -0.024108887, -0.008270264, 0.018569946, -0.015579224, -0.015403748, -0.024337769, 0.0043678284, 0.023254395, -0.014183044, -0.02394104, 0.02166748, -0.05545044, -0.0039138794, -0.00083589554, 0.019577026, 0.03253174, 0.0071258545, -0.0012407303, 0.004299164, -0.039001465, 0.035217285, 0.0013341904, 0.0007786751, -0.027542114, -0.011940002, -0.012199402, -0.008003235, 0.018371582, 0.0030765533, -0.027130127, -0.04321289, 0.016357422, 0.020889282, 0.03527832, 0.018508911, -0.020553589, -0.0071792603, 0.01789856, 0.025131226, 0.0033779144, 0.041229248, -0.09863281, -0.08648682, -0.06341553, 0.035095215, 0.0020561218, 0.020584106, 0.012031555, -0.00459671, 0.042510986, -0.0236969, -0.018798828, 0.051849365, 0.02482605, 0.011962891, 0.045196533, -0.016906738, -0.014053345, -0.024291992, -0.014175415, 0.0101623535, -0.011245728, 0.024963379, 0.00084400177, 0.023635864, -0.06506348, -0.0056762695, 0.02923584, 0.00995636, 0.035491943, 0.0053520203, -0.023361206, 0.035827637, 0.068847656, -0.0063095093, -0.0013246536, 0.03665161, 0.0052261353, 0.035217285, -0.019088745, -0.013839722, -0.0042381287, -0.02357483, -0.012748718, 0.0050086975, 0.040039062, 0.036987305, 0.0027942657, -0.030929565, 0.013313293, -0.024749756, 0.030838013, 0.018539429, -0.048065186, -0.027938843, 0.0043945312, 0.002588272, 0.05050659, 0.005126953, -0.04611206, 0.00983429, -0.054901123, -0.021774292, -0.044433594, 0.011016846, 0.016143799, 0.045196533, -0.019195557, 0.012321472, -0.029724121, 0.02420044, -0.04663086, 0.024032593, -0.023956299, -0.024307251, -0.00223732, 0.014526367, -0.04232788, 0.045715332, 0.057678223, 0.0070533752, -0.038604736, -0.00072193146, 0.016693115, -0.028945923, 0.021392822, -0.02041626, 0.0013399124, -0.022415161, -0.026626587, 0.0018510818, -0.010887146, 0.024765015, 0.030014038, 0.011985779, -0.016693115, -0.020706177, 0.059814453, 0.022125244, 0.054351807, -0.035369873, 0.05130005, 0.019866943, -0.012191772, -0.036346436, -0.048309326, -0.05718994, 0.021270752, 0.05407715, -0.015602112, -0.0037765503, -0.014625549, 0.031951904, 0.025482178, -0.03253174, -0.0127334595, 0.03994751, 0.00015068054, 0.02671814, 0.04714966, 0.03375244, 0.0501709, 0.016601562, -0.0071029663, 0.05355835, 0.003211975, 0.044067383, -0.047180176, 0.00819397, 0.0017910004, 0.0152282715, 0.006996155, 0.0041618347, -0.045532227, 0.0076522827, -0.003583908, 0.017303467, 0.009063721, -0.0053253174, 0.03781128, -0.0055122375, 0.009773254, 0.024902344, 0.0011587143, 0.0019521713, -0.00598526, -0.0037822723, 0.018249512, -0.023803711, -0.017974854, -0.0060806274, 0.030090332, -0.0048713684, 0.01058197, 0.009269714, 0.023284912, -0.029159546, 0.0018415451, -0.0024471283, 0.049621582, 0.032287598, 0.0030269623, 0.010047913, -0.0038471222, -0.013046265, 0.061309814, 0.097717285, -0.024520874, 0.038116455, -0.0793457, 0.0023040771, 0.00048565865, -0.014007568, -0.001127243, 0.0046691895, 0.0067596436, 0.018554688, -0.025909424, 0.013847351, -0.06402588, 0.010910034, 0.0034694672, -0.012123108, -0.052124023, -0.06286621, -0.009208679, -0.03149414, -0.044067383, 0.0017051697, 0.077819824, -0.016815186, -0.0036754608, -0.008346558, -0.0112838745, -0.04095459, -0.01727295, -0.02458191, -0.023788452, 0.042877197, 0.03338623, 0.046539307, -0.036834717, 0.01763916, -0.0024585724, 0.023910522, -0.013206482, 0.033325195, -0.022506714, -0.020263672, 0.004219055, -0.044403076, 0.003326416, -0.015777588, -0.033569336, -0.056365967, -0.022201538, 0.016784668, -0.012771606, -0.028198242, 0.051361084, -0.023406982, -0.012489319, 0.009056091, 0.064453125, -0.03756714, -0.033325195, 0.0072898865, 0.014945984, -0.01979065, 0.034576416, 0.03149414, 0.015510559, -0.045318604, -0.041900635, -0.043151855, 0.004722595, 0.0032806396, -0.027435303, 0.033477783, -0.053619385, -0.0259552, -0.050048828, -0.019760132, 0.00081682205, 0.0513916, -0.016784668, -0.0340271, -0.02281189, -0.026245117, -0.019454956, -0.009284973, -0.017196655, -0.0013084412, 0.08569336, -0.0069999695, -0.008407593, 0.013679504, 0.045196533, 0.0057907104, 0.016799927, -0.005596161, -0.04928589, 0.013916016, 0.033935547, 0.004425049, -0.001876831, 0.01007843, -0.10736084, -0.025650024, 0.006877899, 0.016952515, -0.034088135, 0.014198303, -0.032043457, -0.0005221367, 0.005306244, -0.030593872, 0.010101318, 0.035064697, 0.022201538, -0.01675415, 0.032470703, -0.029022217, 0.034942627, -0.05331421, -0.06109619, 0.036895752, -0.04586792, -0.027694702, 0.013572693, -0.021362305, -0.01928711, -0.021484375, -0.0022964478, 0.016403198, 0.057128906, 0.01473999, 0.038085938, 0.01411438, 0.015731812, -0.023269653, 0.0082473755, -0.017623901, -0.05154419, -0.0069122314, 0.006866455, 0.043640137, 0.04473877, -0.018493652, -0.047546387, -0.012893677, 0.01876831, 0.03302002, 0.023956299, -0.048461914, -0.020462036, -0.039855957, -0.029281616, -0.015235901, -0.02029419, 0.0025119781, -0.028381348, 0.0135650635, -0.001865387, 0.06262207, -0.017532349, -0.002368927, -0.019866943, -0.024017334, 0.0018033981, -0.0104522705, -0.04522705, -0.023529053, 0.04360962, -0.028244019, 0.0357666, -0.010284424, -0.023254395, 0.03894043, -0.0044670105, -0.006111145, -0.0013570786, -0.01637268, -0.01083374, 0.022247314, -0.011131287, -0.010223389, 0.004421234, 0.0126953125, 0.016723633, -0.003376007, -0.03930664, -0.05432129, 0.00097465515, 0.0021877289, -0.13293457, -0.037902832, 0.022338867, -0.052642822, -0.014060974, -0.06506348, 0.032836914, -0.020828247, -0.015617371, -0.017807007, -0.017349243, -0.011787415, 0.005874634, -0.076049805, -0.008010864, 0.06866455, -0.010269165, 0.0034008026, 0.018936157, -0.0014715195, -0.008865356, -0.035491943, 0.003900528, -0.0017023087, 0.0064353943, -0.025772095, -0.009475708, 0.052337646, -0.03741455, 0.027313232, -0.00031757355, 0.029418945, -0.019195557, 0.006679535, 0.006477356, -0.0032367706, -0.043670654, 0.057495117, 0.028884888, -0.019851685, -0.08654785, 0.015045166, -0.0051612854, -0.035888672, 0.011230469, 0.0079574585, 0.008544922, 0.03540039, 0.005207062, 0.05215454, -0.012741089, 0.016143799, 0.022399902, -0.03086853, -0.024108887, -0.005382538, 0.023162842, -0.0038280487, -0.008415222, 0.02017212, -0.02053833, 0.057373047, -0.031204224, 0.0039138794, 0.014144897, 0.016494751, -0.04510498, -0.02760315, -0.062072754, 0.021499634, -0.0075263977, 0.0115737915, -0.023849487, -0.0068740845, 0.037109375, -0.010696411, -0.030197144, 0.016113281, 0.05682373, -0.00289917, -0.006401062, -0.07800293, -0.011917114, 0.00793457, -0.06512451, -0.0236969, -0.003566742, 0.02116394, 0.020050049, -0.018478394, -0.02305603, 0.025024414, 0.03375244, 0.091674805, 0.05215454, 0.005176544, -0.053649902, 0.058746338, -0.012298584, -0.016174316, 0.017913818, 0.011299133, -0.0019664764, -0.010932922, 0.020523071, -0.030303955, 0.0018863678, -0.017532349, 0.017105103, -0.03552246, 0.042633057, -0.020614624, 0.049835205, 0.018005371, -0.007820129, 0.024810791, 0.006034851, -0.036895752, 0.011749268, 0.03010559, 0.06665039, -0.043640137, 0.03805542, 0.025772095, 0.010292053, -0.011726379, -0.029907227, 0.050933838, -0.0064086914, -0.028961182, -0.026565552, 0.037139893, -0.034210205, -0.022735596, 0.005710602, 0.006008148, 0.028793335, -0.040771484, 0.060028076, -0.03086853, -0.026809692, 0.029586792, 0.012504578, -0.0044555664, 0.004005432, 0.007320404, -0.066101074, -0.030426025, -0.01058197, 0.039215088, -0.04800415, -0.014663696, -0.018218994, -0.01737976, 0.02885437, 0.049621582, 0.029937744, -0.010040283, -0.031433105, -0.010269165, -0.0026435852, -0.043182373, -0.033477783, 0.0035114288, -0.02293396, 0.029693604, -0.051452637, 0.044921875, -0.035247803, 0.009986877, 0.014465332, 0.020187378, -0.016799927, -0.05731201, 0.024612427, 0.044525146, 0.0051651, -0.009651184, 0.003145218, 0.01184082, 0.03289795, 0.03753662, 0.0079956055, 0.019424438, 0.018066406, -0.017822266, 0.023895264, 0.01727295, 0.035491943, -0.00063180923, 0.016571045, 0.0010032654, 0.0018815994, -0.04156494, 0.03363037, 0.025222778, -0.017288208, 0.01828003, -0.030044556, 0.035247803, 0.00059890747, -0.015182495, 0.005306244, -0.03186035, -0.032318115, 0.018096924, -0.034484863, 0.0050468445, 0.015930176, -0.007091522, -0.017623901, -0.060577393, 0.020004272, -0.039611816, -0.0057296753, 0.0003476143, 0.02357483, -0.015510559, 0.025802612, 0.04953003, -0.03439331, 0.000269413, 0.003074646, 0.033477783, 0.054260254, 0.0009946823, -0.034057617, -0.010139465, -0.00030827522, -0.064086914, -0.068847656, -0.008781433, -0.014656067, -0.011924744, -0.008544922, -0.020950317, 0.024154663, -0.0014352798, 0.01576233, 0.043182373, -0.02848816, 0.034423828, -0.0046691895, -0.0135269165, 0.017333984, 0.012878418, -0.0005464554, 0.0039863586, 0.0044822693, -0.02180481, 0.014091492, -0.008972168, -0.012565613, 0.005962372, -0.028366089, 0.005924225, 0.016555786, 0.01600647, -0.030395508, 0.013290405, 0.049316406, -0.016525269, 0.015357971, 0.002407074, 0.07672119, -0.036865234, -0.008430481, -0.0077705383, 0.0044059753, -0.013427734, 0.07537842, -0.020889282, -0.023880005, -0.052124023, -0.064331055, -0.033935547, 0.018936157, 0.040740967, 0.029846191, 0.055908203, -0.034851074, 0.033203125, -0.00724411, -0.025939941, -0.047058105, 0.008590698, 0.0060539246, 0.014450073, 0.024642944, 0.00025510788, 0.013908386, -0.04055786, 0.024429321, 0.0020828247, -0.011711121, 0.009338379, -0.035003662, 0.013938904, -0.027114868, -0.037750244, 0.035217285, 0.019317627, -0.005748749, 0.06317139, -0.049346924, 0.040740967, 0.03753662, 0.015083313, 0.02998352, 0.008239746, 0.030471802, 0.003578186, -0.017227173, -0.021987915, 0.012908936, -0.07745361, -0.021896362, -0.06536865, -0.018798828, -0.07006836, -0.011306763, -0.00365448, 0.014404297, 0.019500732, 0.00579834, 0.03704834, 0.0020942688, 0.033935547, -0.055145264, 0.039886475, 0.022125244, 0.014053345, -0.009780884, -0.011787415, 0.022628784, 0.022354126, -0.0036640167, 0.034057617, 0.009048462, -0.009857178, -0.000074863434, 0.005470276, 0.016586304, -0.018585205, -0.013710022, -0.009468079, 0.06542969, 0.018600464, 0.016677856, 0.05303955, 0.070617676, -0.02809143, -0.028381348, 0.019897461, -0.025817871, -0.0033245087, -0.0037517548, 0.019104004, -0.038391113, 0.050201416, -0.0059432983, -0.022125244, -0.03756714, 0.06591797, -0.013084412, -0.018676758, 0.0058898926, 0.014213562, 0.023040771, 0.03213501, 0.035125732, -0.027435303, -0.035064697, -0.01864624, 0.033599854, -0.016601562, 0.034454346, 0.013313293, 0.033294678, -0.072265625, 0.021514893, -0.024002075, 0.048736572, -0.074157715, 0.0045166016, -0.09692383, 0.041900635, -0.0034751892, -0.03152466, 0.040863037, -0.013725281, -0.022445679, -0.00440979, 0.051971436, 0.041900635, 0.03817749, 0.04156494, -0.008300781, -0.043640137, 0.04144287, -0.054534912, 0.010383606, 0.045898438, -0.026473999, 0.017196655, -0.022247314, -0.03878784, 0.058654785, -0.016159058, 0.08502197, -0.021942139, -0.0036678314, -0.04397583, 0.006790161, 0.034698486, -0.08441162, 0.026031494, -0.06274414, 0.00447464, -0.014175415, 0.008934021, -0.010124207, -0.007671356, 0.016159058, 0.03262329, 0.033599854, -0.018051147, -0.017532349, -0.023376465, -0.03024292, 0.004348755, -0.039611816, 0.033813477, -0.021240234, -0.014503479, -0.005748749, -0.0036258698, -0.007888794, -0.053466797, -0.016998291, -0.037231445, -0.0034275055, -0.026657104, 0.012184143, 0.024398804, -0.012886047, 0.0116119385, 0.013015747, 0.008216858, -0.009170532, -0.0021743774, 0.047973633, -0.034942627, -0.059265137, -0.009651184, -0.032440186, 0.04663086, 0.030197144, -0.009017944, -0.0067443848, 0.039520264, -0.024230957, -0.010406494, 0.0129776, 0.04714966, -0.01777649, -0.03390503, 0.0063095093, 0.06097412, 0.044067383, -0.03366089, 0.01436615, 0.02583313, 0.035064697, -0.0028629303, 0.063964844, -0.0079956055, 0.010902405, 0.030426025, 0.06982422, 0.021392822, -0.06530762, -0.05255127, -0.007987976, 0.058685303, 0.06518555, -0.01033783, -0.015991211, 0.03062439, 0.010093689, 0.012168884, -0.00932312, -0.03125, -0.0032691956, -0.005443573, 0.022445679, 0.004425049, 0.014564514, -0.0041236877, 0.044006348, -0.0058174133, 0.038482666, -0.020477295, 0.009536743, 0.025436401, 0.031082153, -0.018325806, -0.06542969, 0.060150146, 0.023986816, 0.020629883, 0.03074646, -0.021713257, -0.02255249, -0.023757935, -0.00026988983, 0.014541626, 0.0129470825, 0.017425537, -0.026611328, 0.015304565, -0.03955078, -0.042938232, -0.028930664, -0.03744507, 0.03225708, -0.0236969, 0.0077819824, -0.005214691, -0.0137786865, -0.011459351, 0.021972656, 0.016204834, -0.01890564, -0.037872314, -0.027389526, 0.059906006, -0.02029419 ], "summary": [ 0.01499176, 0.016815186, -0.018127441, 0.04940796, 0.01763916, -0.04333496, 0.037200928, -0.0713501, -0.04626465, 0.03463745, -0.032470703, 0.026428223, 0.016235352, -0.023498535, 0.039367676, -0.024246216, -0.0016956329, 0.014045715, 0.013320923, -0.01889038, 0.013420105, -0.0007390976, 0.01222229, 0.01725769, -0.0046844482, 0.03265381, -0.0077056885, 0.0042915344, -0.0019054413, 0.008735657, 0.0029258728, -0.011756897, 0.010658264, 0.058654785, -0.06744385, -0.036010742, -0.0062179565, 0.023635864, -0.026672363, 0.055145264, 0.04309082, 0.00308609, 0.13659668, -0.032470703, 0.04067993, 0.058898926, -0.0093307495, -0.06665039, 0.03338623, 0.028793335, -0.0006456375, 0.021118164, -0.011161804, -0.029037476, -0.0024909973, -0.045196533, -0.016998291, -0.009643555, 0.040222168, 0.012069702, -0.013786316, -0.041625977, 0.03274536, -0.029754639, 0.007572174, -0.009101868, 0.11907959, -0.00014984608, -0.020568848, -0.020523071, 0.035827637, 0.035064697, 0.022079468, 0.00223732, -0.038726807, -0.054229736, 0.056427002, -0.019638062, -0.0051651, -0.014953613, -0.0011901855, -0.013809204, 0.0140686035, -0.0098724365, -0.0060577393, -0.011352539, -0.0041275024, -0.012336731, -0.022415161, -0.013404846, -0.02999878, -0.01826477, -0.040130615, 0.027938843, 0.030151367, -0.02684021, -0.019302368, -0.05911255, 0.037078857, 0.011756897, -0.018310547, -0.031051636, -0.017791748, -0.012565613, -0.008842468, 0.019714355, 0.039978027, -0.0012283325, 0.005760193, -0.008674622, -0.03692627, 0.044189453, -0.017501831, 0.0051841736, -0.07684326, 0.007648468, -0.016494751, -0.041381836, -0.013366699, 0.011375427, -0.055145264, -0.01940918, 0.023483276, -0.017150879, 0.028320312, 0.022750854, 0.020065308, -0.020629883, 0.031585693, -0.024108887, 0.004096985, 0.036834717, -0.040252686, -0.016921997, -0.037506104, 0.010246277, 0.03668213, 0.031097412, 0.023376465, -0.025924683, 0.07611084, -0.017730713, -0.059936523, 0.07904053, 0.035125732, 0.056121826, 0.013038635, -0.025054932, 0.029510498, -0.025634766, -0.0044937134, -0.029312134, 0.017410278, 0.016189575, 0.020019531, -0.0012207031, 0.0418396, -0.007648468, -0.008773804, -0.042663574, 0.03488159, -0.0067443848, -0.029907227, 0.048919678, 0.03463745, 0.0044555664, 0.03111267, 0.02305603, 0.00868988, 0.017578125, 0.0011320114, -0.0037288666, -0.0178833, -0.028579712, -0.005695343, -0.007621765, 0.023529053, 0.055389404, -0.0047721863, -0.013801575, 0.001086235, -0.044830322, 0.055419922, -0.025634766, -0.02267456, 0.007835388, 0.009216309, 0.052337646, 0.028823853, 0.00856781, 0.004306793, -0.021942139, -0.044128418, 0.050231934, -0.012825012, 0.013511658, -0.026443481, 0.025283813, -0.02130127, -0.030410767, 0.006931305, 0.011367798, -0.01979065, 0.01763916, -0.056854248, -0.00068712234, -0.01864624, 0.018753052, -0.020004272, 0.02494812, 0.044555664, 0.00869751, -0.033203125, 0.0008845329, 0.016021729, 0.012535095, 0.0134887695, -0.055847168, 0.0017309189, -0.012046814, -0.026931763, 0.03543091, -0.05050659, 0.018341064, 0.043670654, 0.0178833, -0.025344849, 0.008850098, 0.09240723, 0.026275635, 0.008018494, -0.029846191, -0.0032176971, -0.021636963, -0.028778076, -0.01889038, -0.040740967, -0.087646484, 0.017562866, 0.06933594, -0.0010652542, 0.010665894, -0.040924072, -0.005874634, -0.018951416, -0.06402588, -0.024261475, 0.03225708, -0.027740479, 0.011749268, 0.005584717, -0.0003607273, 0.03125, -0.029907227, -0.00033140182, 0.028076172, 0.009689331, 0.05734253, -0.048187256, 0.032165527, -0.011230469, 0.013618469, 0.02520752, -0.016311646, 0.009399414, -0.025802612, 0.03878784, 0.014434814, 0.014289856, -0.041259766, 0.009819031, -0.011932373, 0.011230469, 0.026306152, -0.034179688, 0.0134887695, 0.008834839, -0.013870239, 0.010604858, 0.004814148, -0.029830933, -0.02999878, -0.029541016, -0.0054397583, 0.028549194, 0.016342163, 0.021118164, -0.0211792, 0.03201294, 0.083984375, 0.07116699, 0.03756714, 0.021240234, -0.00015223026, 0.005619049, 0.005958557, -0.018157959, 0.018173218, 0.023788452, -0.03366089, -0.0055656433, 0.03277588, -0.044647217, 0.033569336, 0.0040893555, -0.013221741, -0.008132935, 0.01374054, -0.00018489361, -0.008331299, -0.0496521, 0.021224976, 0.019943237, 0.015548706, -0.010070801, -0.020950317, -0.0151901245, 0.024154663, 0.020065308, 0.038360596, 0.062408447, 0.014328003, 0.043640137, 0.01184845, 0.0030517578, -0.06640625, 0.0048980713, -0.017593384, -0.017074585, 0.014198303, -0.02885437, -0.006793976, -0.023132324, 0.072021484, -0.0040664673, 0.022323608, -0.0028896332, 0.03225708, -0.0074272156, -0.012840271, 0.009941101, -0.039001465, -0.011978149, 0.0039787292, -0.06518555, -0.018951416, -0.019454956, 0.009857178, -0.014968872, -0.02861023, 0.041748047, -0.010696411, -0.017532349, 0.017410278, 0.049835205, -0.017059326, -0.014892578, 0.015426636, 0.031555176, -0.022018433, 0.031463623, 0.0569458, 0.027816772, -0.052734375, -0.07116699, -0.031463623, 0.008262634, 0.02520752, -0.011688232, 0.021453857, -0.003967285, -0.01713562, -0.02029419, -0.01309967, -0.009025574, 0.01939392, 0.04107666, -0.022506714, 0.012413025, 0.0119018555, -0.016723633, -0.004573822, 0.0035057068, 0.014587402, 0.07623291, -0.023452759, -0.002325058, 0.04159546, 0.041656494, 0.011268616, 0.004802704, -0.019714355, -0.040618896, -0.01373291, 0.008102417, 0.0005965233, 0.02192688, 0.019104004, -0.03555298, -0.043884277, 0.0029888153, 0.021270752, -0.008644104, -0.0017690659, -0.010810852, 0.026168823, 0.020385742, -0.011474609, 0.00006300211, 0.026901245, 0.038513184, -0.04421997, 0.055725098, -0.04031372, 0.04824829, -0.033813477, 0.052520752, 0.022369385, -0.018676758, -0.05480957, 0.008270264, 0.011306763, 0.02859497, -0.008621216, 0.032928467, 0.0026855469, 0.016494751, -0.028945923, 0.020568848, 0.047210693, 0.0019521713, -0.0020580292, 0.0024166107, 0.0074386597, -0.07434082, -0.020141602, 0.014625549, -0.02027893, 0.08087158, -0.06921387, -0.048950195, -0.0009074211, 0.032165527, 0.03225708, 0.034362793, -0.017700195, -0.020355225, -0.051116943, -0.014892578, -0.025787354, -0.004032135, -0.0061569214, 0.040802002, 0.034423828, 0.010681152, 0.07220459, -0.047210693, 0.0011148453, 0.04748535, -0.027145386, -0.010414124, 0.015060425, -0.0463562, -0.014022827, 0.0390625, -0.041625977, 0.040618896, 0.00035524368, -0.0024471283, 0.018875122, 0.0019521713, -0.018066406, -0.04284668, -0.036590576, -0.017120361, -0.018737793, 0.04727173, -0.021270752, 0.07446289, -0.010475159, -0.053741455, 0.020721436, -0.081848145, -0.038635254, -0.02178955, 0.002658844, -0.05923462, -0.042388916, 0.015068054, -0.029373169, 0.03152466, -0.051696777, 0.04812622, -0.036987305, -0.007259369, -0.040008545, -0.02243042, 0.05911255, 0.015075684, -0.04849243, 0.038024902, -0.0068740845, 0.026779175, 0.012336731, -0.04824829, 0.01701355, 0.04135132, -0.025344849, -0.009117126, -0.07220459, 0.017486572, -0.06542969, 0.018112183, 0.01550293, -0.018829346, 0.057403564, -0.037841797, 0.038024902, -0.028030396, -0.008110046, 0.05657959, 0.03439331, -0.019058228, 0.01826477, 0.016616821, -0.0026416779, -0.039398193, -0.0029678345, 0.020599365, -0.035125732, 0.010543823, 0.013839722, -0.0115737915, 0.04486084, 0.0096206665, 0.010185242, 0.0061836243, 0.00031971931, -0.014930725, -0.016937256, -0.01878357, -0.0146102905, 0.019866943, -0.025756836, -0.021987915, -0.0011415482, -0.03366089, 0.056396484, -0.046569824, 0.016159058, 0.027053833, 0.013328552, -0.045959473, -0.04852295, -0.011352539, 0.06317139, 0.021713257, -0.0066604614, -0.02218628, -0.029403687, 0.029418945, -0.01576233, 0.028213501, -0.026473999, 0.06542969, 0.00983429, -0.0309906, -0.10498047, -0.07366943, 0.017303467, -0.029632568, 0.0016174316, -0.02027893, -0.027420044, -0.040893555, -0.008361816, -0.002117157, 0.028167725, 0.035888672, 0.058135986, 0.013771057, 0.020599365, -0.034210205, 0.024124146, -0.012191772, -0.015594482, -0.0021839142, 0.00730896, -0.0047187805, -0.00012648106, 0.0335083, -0.029922485, 0.013557434, 0.024276733, -0.018508911, -0.028167725, 0.029891968, -0.03704834, 0.04168701, -0.012687683, -0.0066566467, -0.010253906, -0.0079956055, -0.038726807, 0.05569458, 0.0146484375, 0.059051514, -0.04348755, 0.03793335, -0.003484726, -0.028884888, -0.028839111, -0.0256958, 0.061035156, -0.021194458, -0.048217773, -0.030197144, 0.033325195, 0.010185242, -0.016799927, 0.029525757, 0.009597778, 0.003791809, 0.036834717, 0.0029296875, 0.0047302246, 0.0010356903, 0.023971558, -0.0037784576, 0.005378723, 0.03366089, 0.001326561, -0.03930664, -0.038391113, -0.02760315, 0.04437256, -0.018508911, -0.030914307, -0.03488159, -0.01071167, 0.027786255, -0.0018119812, -0.01108551, -0.007320404, -0.053375244, -0.009124756, -0.00655365, -0.0129470825, 0.009933472, -0.005874634, -0.022735596, 0.0023155212, -0.026901245, 0.0048332214, 0.035705566, 0.0055999756, 0.013038635, 0.028686523, -0.034088135, -0.027114868, -0.041809082, -0.018096924, -0.020980835, -0.04925537, 0.037902832, -0.008773804, -0.01890564, 0.013908386, -0.016571045, 0.009880066, -0.0057411194, -0.04232788, 0.043518066, 0.007091522, 0.017700195, 0.0035533905, -0.0059127808, -0.013725281, -0.014518738, 0.00907135, 0.001748085, 0.023651123, 0.01071167, -0.019332886, 0.00308609, 0.03567505, 0.010726929, 0.01222229, -0.010437012, 0.03262329, 0.0007266998, 0.059783936, 0.00048446655, 0.06384277, -0.007949829, 0.007911682, -0.0018377304, -0.026901245, 0.030090332, -0.045288086, -0.014007568, 0.0015296936, 0.022415161, 0.007358551, -0.011474609, 0.021713257, -0.0138168335, 0.010139465, 0.022018433, 0.03955078, 0.008384705, -0.012901306, 0.006511688, 0.003435135, -0.009468079, -0.046295166, -0.08544922, -0.037872314, -0.05871582, 0.01864624, -0.008544922, -0.017791748, 0.040527344, -0.002904892, 0.0033512115, 0.0519104, -0.024215698, 0.022064209, -0.010986328, -0.03137207, 0.02319336, -0.049743652, -0.031219482, 0.010894775, 0.013763428, -0.035858154, -0.00056648254, 0.022979736, 0.0050697327, -0.001627922, -0.02217102, -0.004020691, 0.02961731, 0.01701355, -0.019439697, 0.022766113, 0.01890564, -0.029815674, 0.03488159, 0.00008827448, 0.044525146, 0.0075950623, -0.009376526, -0.03353882, -0.0026550293, -0.02494812, 0.03643799, -0.016677856, -0.0073394775, -0.037628174, -0.041229248, 0.011222839, 0.00088357925, 0.016189575, 0.02041626, 0.035339355, -0.0619812, -0.009757996, 0.026290894, -0.027297974, -0.0127334595, -0.019226074, 0.02859497, 0.057037354, 0.022888184, -0.010574341, -0.012130737, 0.010932922, 0.033935547, -0.0061683655, -0.04550171, 0.019165039, 0.02609253, 0.028167725, -0.00434494, 0.0146865845, 0.029006958, -0.003250122, 0.039367676, 0.015365601, 0.0017948151, 0.014579773, 0.019165039, -0.03262329, -0.02217102, -0.023849487, 0.030227661, -0.0065574646, -0.04711914, -0.014533997, 0.009468079, -0.008613586, -0.09942627, -0.05682373, -0.055023193, -0.009819031, -0.023773193, -0.012832642, -0.016738892, 0.018234253, 0.010437012, 0.030975342, 0.01461792, -0.029922485, -0.0635376, -0.0039138794, 0.018844604, 0.02053833, -0.024520874, -0.032440186, 0.001531601, 0.021087646, -0.004447937, 0.034179688, 0.009269714, 0.024017334, 0.00065231323, -0.015541077, -0.023361206, -0.02961731, 0.04220581, -0.0016460419, 0.05340576, 0.04196167, 0.031341553, 0.012123108, 0.020843506, 0.033111572, -0.03173828, 0.011329651, -0.014221191, -0.001086235, 0.005897522, -0.0017080307, 0.022537231, 0.01651001, -0.00009256601, -0.011390686, -0.030593872, 0.06451416, 0.0009899139, 0.002872467, 0.05831909, 0.0017185211, 0.0022735596, -0.012268066, -0.0038394928, -0.03692627, -0.029464722, -0.013198853, 0.014923096, -0.018951416, -0.010971069, -0.0015125275, -0.01083374, -0.07745361, 0.021499634, -0.034301758, 0.058898926, -0.07720947, -0.002166748, -0.09942627, -0.0002579689, 0.021224976, -0.0019226074, 0.03048706, 0.011108398, 0.035369873, 0.022476196, 0.09509277, 0.031951904, 0.047943115, -0.0072135925, -0.053710938, -0.028045654, 0.079833984, -0.044403076, -0.011123657, 0.029205322, -0.0024852753, -0.008956909, 0.0016231537, 0.0013999939, 0.043548584, 0.023956299, 0.070373535, -0.0049438477, -0.019515991, -0.06188965, 0.00013756752, -0.029006958, -0.05041504, 0.08709717, -0.10144043, -0.0070877075, -0.0049972534, 0.016174316, -0.018875122, 0.027709961, -0.015266418, -0.0023479462, 0.02722168, -0.009170532, 0.006149292, -0.015419006, 0.012748718, -0.0069999695, -0.0043525696, 0.037597656, 0.00932312, -0.022125244, 0.012588501, -0.014137268, 0.018249512, -0.038269043, 0.0085372925, -0.0395813, -0.012535095, -0.050354004, 0.040618896, 0.015899658, -0.006412506, 0.033843994, 0.06616211, 0.0024414062, 0.01235199, -0.007610321, 0.037963867, -0.025024414, -0.035308838, -0.0037593842, -0.038604736, 0.03665161, 0.011520386, -0.008850098, 0.023025513, 0.03314209, -0.022033691, -0.012184143, 0.025802612, 0.023620605, -0.011077881, -0.05255127, 0.006462097, 0.046539307, 0.0368042, 0.009757996, 0.09429932, 0.058013916, 0.011550903, -0.0004553795, 0.04107666, -0.030548096, 0.0088272095, 0.0413208, 0.087402344, 0.017700195, -0.053100586, -0.02015686, -0.016143799, 0.058898926, 0.014328003, -0.033294678, -0.019241333, 0.035491943, 0.0077934265, 0.0032520294, -0.03353882, -0.042938232, -0.038757324, -0.008079529, -0.010734558, 0.03225708, 0.004131317, 0.032287598, 0.03286743, -0.018844604, 0.036254883, -0.036499023, -0.0062065125, 0.026046753, -0.03378296, -0.026611328, -0.041503906, 0.043640137, 0.011817932, 0.008125305, -0.015777588, 0.021743774, 0.0012435913, -0.011047363, -0.013679504, 0.010681152, -0.005432129, 0.027572632, -0.017700195, 0.002904892, -0.05380249, 0.00043439865, -0.042114258, -0.02281189, 0.022125244, 0.0065956116, -0.02017212, 0.022109985, -0.017868042, 0.019012451, 0.012519836, 0.038635254, 0.041870117, -0.029541016, -0.0056991577, 0.018249512, -0.0074806213 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2008.03920v3
Do ideas have shape? Idea registration as the continuous limit of artificial neural networks
Houman Owhadi
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG, 62J02, 68T01, 62M45
We introduce a GP generalization of ResNets (including ResNets as a particular case). We show that ResNets (and their GP generalization) converge, in the infinite depth limit, to a generalization of image registration variational algorithms. Whereas computational anatomy aligns images via warping of the material space, this generalization aligns ideas (or abstract shapes as in Plato's theory of forms) via the warping of the RKHS of functions mapping the input space to the output space. While the Hamiltonian interpretation of ResNets is not new, it was based on an Ansatz. We do not rely on this Ansatz and present the first rigorous proof of convergence of ResNets with trained weights and biases towards a Hamiltonian dynamics driven flow. Our constructive proof reveals several remarkable properties of ResNets and their GP generalization. ResNets regressors are kernel regressors with data-dependent warping kernels. Minimizers of $L_2$ regularized ResNets satisfy a discrete least action principle implying the near preservation of the norm of weights and biases across layers. The trained weights of ResNets with $L^2$ regularization can be identified by solving an autonomous Hamiltonian system. The trained ResNet parameters are unique up to the initial momentum whose representation is generally sparse. The kernel regularization strategy provides a provably robust alternative to Dropout for ANNs. We introduce a functional generalization of GPs leading to error estimates for ResNets. We identify the (EPDiff) mean fields limit of trained ResNet parameters. We show that the composition of warping regression blocks with reduced equivariant multichannel kernels (introduced here) recovers and generalizes CNNs to arbitrary spaces and groups of transformations.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2008.03920v3
2022-10-27T18:01:18
2020-08-10T06:46:43
{ "title": [ -0.011016846, -0.0027503967, -0.011451721, -0.0002360344, 0.0020999908, -0.019042969, 0.016433716, -0.04171753, -0.011016846, 0.039093018, -0.023361206, 0.0034713745, -0.022888184, -0.0067253113, -0.0592041, -0.006690979, 0.0012302399, 0.015541077, -0.012710571, -0.028396606, -0.017623901, -0.043670654, 0.052825928, 0.009109497, 0.044830322, -0.05291748, -0.07507324, 0.008529663, -0.026062012, -0.027648926, -0.0009012222, 0.010604858, 0.037109375, 0.02444458, 0.00007534027, -0.005634308, -0.039367676, 0.031921387, 0.014198303, 0.0016155243, 0.009712219, -0.006614685, -0.025604248, -0.035339355, -0.03491211, 0.020889282, -0.052734375, -0.008132935, -0.013061523, 0.0073776245, 0.012619019, 0.01928711, -0.008636475, 0.030212402, 0.006389618, -0.01966858, -0.04864502, -0.033416748, 0.036132812, 0.08502197, 0.05078125, -0.052124023, 0.013633728, -0.042755127, -0.030441284, -0.02330017, 0.004016876, 0.026535034, 0.072753906, 0.03024292, 0.006565094, 0.032684326, 0.00983429, 0.021514893, -0.03213501, -0.019424438, 0.050994873, 0.025131226, 0.041137695, -0.01878357, -0.008110046, -0.050811768, 0.0036563873, 0.0023994446, -0.010406494, -0.0059814453, -0.021759033, -0.0029449463, -0.039154053, -0.05291748, -0.0121154785, -0.016036987, -0.020950317, -0.0017089844, -0.023666382, -0.02255249, -0.0004105568, 0.024810791, -0.005718231, -0.0062828064, -0.013847351, 0.0023918152, -0.027404785, -0.01739502, 0.029907227, 0.033294678, -0.028869629, -0.058624268, 0.0234375, 0.027404785, 0.010025024, 0.017456055, 0.029541016, -0.0067977905, 0.012741089, 0.014533997, 0.007247925, 0.048095703, 0.024993896, 0.04840088, -0.024032593, -0.03942871, 0.030227661, -0.005180359, 0.047546387, 0.021499634, -0.048553467, 0.0044555664, -0.025177002, 0.019927979, -0.0012226105, 0.03451538, -0.088134766, -0.07043457, -0.054260254, 0.036315918, -0.010215759, 0.012557983, -0.007637024, -0.0009498596, 0.03012085, -0.005332947, 0.025863647, -0.0028934479, 0.0017156601, 0.015197754, 0.062805176, -0.011734009, -0.051757812, -0.043182373, -0.0062561035, 0.009353638, 0.029586792, -0.010475159, -0.05407715, -0.025604248, -0.12512207, -0.024368286, 0.031951904, -0.010093689, 0.030761719, 0.009422302, -0.02432251, 0.0009460449, 0.024353027, -0.006511688, -0.009857178, 0.020874023, 0.010284424, 0.059326172, -0.0053100586, 0.0026950836, -0.022369385, -0.014671326, -0.018920898, 0.000039815903, 0.05596924, -0.030197144, -0.0018177032, 0.019714355, 0.010665894, -0.0206604, -0.041992188, 0.048339844, -0.085998535, -0.009971619, -0.017837524, -0.009841919, 0.09259033, -0.021194458, -0.010322571, 0.015304565, -0.06427002, -0.070617676, -0.060180664, 0.018814087, 0.02357483, 0.03274536, -0.0040740967, 0.052612305, -0.06512451, -0.020950317, -0.007091522, 0.005760193, -0.03189087, -0.025512695, -0.03100586, 0.040283203, -0.025436401, 0.04168701, 0.04901123, 0.010177612, -0.049591064, 0.036468506, 0.00043988228, -0.06097412, 0.05114746, -0.018188477, -0.0055351257, -0.01676941, -0.04058838, 0.021575928, -0.031219482, 0.045684814, 0.03353882, 0.0025501251, -0.012374878, -0.038269043, 0.042388916, 0.032440186, 0.0368042, -0.00592041, -0.018676758, -0.0022335052, -0.00027227402, -0.030960083, -0.012702942, -0.033111572, 0.035186768, 0.014259338, 0.0020561218, -0.012435913, -0.001709938, 0.019607544, 0.052001953, 0.011276245, 0.018692017, 0.008392334, 0.018234253, 0.013313293, 0.078552246, 0.015792847, 0.041870117, 0.02822876, 0.022506714, 0.049438477, -0.03225708, -0.017044067, -0.012306213, 0.003967285, 0.014266968, 0.00029730797, 0.0054397583, 0.0076408386, -0.051086426, -0.010688782, -0.03878784, -0.01725769, -0.019058228, 0.020004272, 0.046081543, -0.021453857, 0.0020332336, -0.035217285, -0.038116455, -0.025985718, -0.041168213, 0.05883789, 0.007446289, -0.08001709, -0.022491455, 0.0021018982, 0.017105103, 0.002439499, 0.0259552, 0.001704216, 0.021362305, -0.0013999939, -0.018035889, -0.02545166, 0.035247803, 0.037872314, 0.01902771, -0.0072402954, 0.026672363, -0.005874634, 0.050231934, 0.038238525, -0.01486969, 0.027954102, -0.053497314, 0.03378296, 0.022644043, -0.022613525, 0.008987427, 0.026290894, 0.0014467239, 0.022628784, -0.027023315, -0.004825592, -0.05987549, -0.00198555, 0.005142212, -0.03567505, -0.014541626, -0.030258179, 0.0024719238, -0.028747559, -0.025970459, 0.001241684, 0.04736328, 0.01146698, -0.054504395, -0.013046265, 0.0022125244, 0.0061035156, -0.04937744, -0.0440979, -0.0027198792, 0.002998352, 0.056884766, -0.014778137, -0.056610107, -0.06210327, 0.014587402, -0.004348755, -0.00818634, 0.018173218, -0.015052795, 0.016845703, 0.0236969, 0.012001038, 0.030944824, -0.038269043, 0.0027866364, -0.062438965, 0.017333984, 0.013145447, -0.014198303, 0.0027008057, 0.017593384, -0.030349731, -0.043151855, 0.011238098, 0.045196533, 0.006958008, -0.0015830994, 0.04336548, 0.043060303, -0.008262634, 0.01927185, 0.003856659, -0.012626648, -0.054351807, 0.011917114, -0.037384033, -0.027770996, -0.03125, -0.011436462, 0.03564453, -0.046020508, -0.006465912, -0.051696777, -0.010749817, -0.006843567, 0.020874023, -0.016830444, -0.043426514, -0.022018433, -0.020324707, -0.008071899, 0.013290405, -0.027359009, 0.023834229, 0.088012695, 0.000047028065, -0.016235352, -0.010681152, 0.0524292, 0.019470215, -0.02407837, -0.03225708, -0.035491943, 0.007205963, 0.005207062, 0.011268616, -0.0065231323, -0.037231445, -0.088012695, -0.0014419556, 0.045776367, -0.014602661, -0.044921875, 0.034423828, -0.06286621, 0.02671814, -0.006477356, -0.019302368, 0.03314209, 0.058135986, -0.015777588, 0.015426636, 0.0031375885, -0.029312134, 0.00050878525, 0.0073890686, -0.11242676, 0.008850098, 0.0067710876, -0.018875122, -0.020248413, -0.019515991, -0.054138184, -0.0030918121, -0.018463135, 0.036315918, 0.029815674, 0.02381897, -0.0016593933, -0.042144775, -0.0072631836, -0.043670654, -0.010116577, -0.03439331, -0.04562378, -0.020202637, -0.0050239563, 0.07281494, 0.012741089, -0.003124237, -0.033813477, -0.019180298, 0.0050697327, 0.017425537, 0.003572464, -0.0345459, -0.01108551, -0.008583069, -0.006828308, -0.02067566, -0.006389618, -0.0070877075, 0.0007457733, 0.01007843, -0.015342712, 0.019958496, 0.027786255, 0.006477356, -0.0032539368, -0.032989502, -0.00030374527, -0.024932861, -0.08306885, 0.025009155, -0.00844574, 0.013542175, 0.0390625, -0.01612854, -0.031402588, 0.009422302, -0.04272461, 0.007423401, -0.0043296814, 0.0074005127, -0.019989014, 0.027389526, -0.015701294, -0.0050697327, -0.005519867, 0.013298035, 0.018814087, -0.00034093857, -0.022003174, -0.07104492, -0.010482788, 0.010192871, -0.12335205, -0.021499634, 0.01084137, -0.01876831, -0.021347046, -0.03149414, 0.010032654, 0.0007095337, -0.032806396, 0.009681702, -0.028396606, 0.005378723, -0.006072998, -0.05441284, -0.023605347, 0.062683105, -0.00868988, 0.005680084, 0.0418396, -0.012451172, -0.031829834, -0.013809204, 0.017532349, 0.023010254, 0.015991211, 0.01687622, -0.018157959, 0.044921875, -0.05432129, 0.02708435, -0.009857178, 0.024841309, -0.031677246, 0.007575989, 0.0066490173, 0.014328003, -0.019882202, 0.048614502, 0.020629883, -0.009811401, -0.066345215, 0.010292053, 0.008964539, 0.017501831, 0.008102417, 0.002943039, 0.022979736, 0.0063705444, 0.0104522705, 0.023544312, -0.007671356, -0.001578331, 0.03112793, -0.027526855, 0.005329132, 0.0043525696, 0.01071167, -0.0012655258, 0.014381409, 0.013435364, -0.0015335083, 0.024932861, -0.017532349, -0.024414062, -0.0085372925, 0.0006198883, -0.05291748, -0.008285522, -0.06488037, -0.064941406, -0.036743164, 0.013877869, -0.012489319, 0.047454834, 0.03652954, -0.0032444, -0.031433105, 0.00062179565, 0.013046265, 0.0041885376, -0.010795593, -0.05999756, -0.007156372, -0.018508911, -0.050109863, -0.024841309, 0.021011353, 0.011764526, 0.03717041, -0.013717651, -0.0065612793, 0.0209198, 0.017105103, 0.040130615, 0.053100586, -0.020111084, -0.050872803, 0.04626465, -0.03390503, -0.040008545, 0.0058631897, -0.010467529, -0.026779175, -0.05569458, 0.007980347, 0.00031661987, -0.011955261, -0.056396484, 0.0077209473, -0.01725769, 0.023269653, 0.027923584, 0.03842163, 0.02394104, -0.0002605915, 0.010124207, 0.009429932, -0.0184021, -0.008529663, 0.02482605, 0.010551453, 0.045440674, -0.016860962, 0.03286743, 0.035003662, 0.01309967, 0.026412964, -0.015899658, 0.036499023, 0.016967773, 0.008033752, -0.004470825, -0.07904053, -0.031555176, 0.0057411194, -0.027435303, 0.059631348, -0.030883789, 0.08673096, -0.021255493, -0.025756836, 0.01234436, 0.004055023, 0.026550293, -0.01727295, 0.020050049, -0.070495605, -0.06048584, -0.026229858, 0.06573486, -0.03414917, 0.023452759, 0.0053710938, -0.019927979, 0.03213501, 0.046661377, 0.012252808, -0.025344849, 0.008453369, -0.001499176, -0.009376526, -0.025772095, -0.03930664, 0.017684937, 0.01763916, 0.006591797, -0.05432129, -0.027618408, -0.060394287, -0.037475586, -0.046783447, -0.00059843063, 0.004989624, -0.047698975, 0.03262329, 0.09033203, 0.010681152, 0.060272217, 0.00022804737, 0.04071045, 0.020248413, 0.03439331, 0.018096924, 0.02017212, 0.019134521, -0.028244019, 0.012634277, 0.010658264, 0.025436401, 0.024246216, 0.039886475, 0.012786865, 0.02520752, -0.051330566, 0.037139893, 0.0050315857, -0.00856781, 0.025024414, -0.052520752, 0.019042969, -0.020050049, -0.017486572, 0.02861023, -0.06994629, -0.0073776245, 0.009162903, -0.030853271, -0.040649414, 0.04168701, 0.0105896, -0.030349731, -0.030776978, 0.010009766, -0.009986877, -0.00027894974, 0.0047187805, -0.003025055, -0.040771484, 0.015296936, 0.051879883, -0.0440979, -0.018966675, -0.0027980804, 0.020736694, 0.03768921, -0.014343262, 0.0033035278, -0.004005432, 0.01638794, -0.032562256, 0.008995056, 0.023086548, 0.0041999817, -0.016967773, 0.009773254, -0.030044556, 0.027145386, 0.020751953, 0.04248047, -0.0056991577, -0.010604858, 0.021224976, 0.02494812, 0.0395813, -0.0042877197, 0.016357422, 0.018936157, -0.011512756, 0.008934021, -0.066467285, 0.009063721, 0.013122559, 0.022506714, 0.0034732819, -0.027893066, -0.00844574, 0.021957397, 0.010513306, 0.004840851, 0.016067505, 0.019622803, 0.025177002, 0.0035324097, 0.010848999, 0.062286377, -0.022415161, -0.029190063, -0.026824951, -0.005470276, -0.05722046, 0.031463623, -0.0013494492, -0.0093307495, -0.026351929, -0.074035645, -0.020584106, 0.01574707, 0.024993896, 0.036895752, 0.035308838, -0.09295654, -0.008636475, -0.017181396, -0.019973755, -0.012268066, 0.0061454773, 0.015037537, -0.012168884, 0.011291504, 0.0030059814, -0.01348114, 0.003458023, 0.028015137, 0.024658203, -0.007965088, 0.04168701, -0.03765869, -0.0041503906, -0.02217102, -0.030380249, 0.03805542, 0.0028877258, -0.034454346, 0.027313232, -0.0026512146, 0.06549072, 0.020523071, 0.05355835, 0.042999268, 0.0052337646, 0.0107040405, 0.004081726, 0.03253174, -0.03326416, 0.0032634735, -0.053619385, -0.009292603, -0.068359375, -0.01234436, -0.05645752, 0.0085372925, -0.00097084045, 0.04058838, -0.0074043274, 0.014350891, 0.01612854, -0.027633667, 0.06524658, -0.030593872, 0.070739746, -0.015716553, 0.00044822693, -0.010917664, -0.0070495605, 0.026229858, 0.031204224, 0.009185791, 0.012771606, -0.021820068, -0.03062439, 0.020004272, 0.022598267, -0.00056934357, -0.00070238113, -0.0006747246, -0.030334473, 0.04208374, 0.0024223328, 0.050354004, 0.044769287, 0.029922485, 0.0002875328, -0.028717041, -0.01725769, 0.0018081665, -0.015213013, -0.00907135, 0.049560547, -0.05633545, 0.0056495667, -0.016494751, -0.030807495, -0.017791748, 0.0090789795, 0.028961182, -0.081848145, -0.05279541, 0.008987427, 0.041168213, 0.0047950745, 0.013687134, -0.049468994, -0.008285522, 0.014205933, 0.028305054, -0.010795593, -0.0115737915, 0.021575928, 0.018981934, -0.027420044, -0.057647705, 0.026489258, -0.0053977966, -0.0068244934, 0.027709961, 0.012214661, 0.023162842, -0.0206604, -0.039154053, -0.0036697388, 0.0038375854, -0.040527344, -0.013267517, 0.027664185, 0.048217773, 0.059417725, 0.08129883, 0.020339966, -0.010498047, 0.001830101, -0.05343628, 0.030273438, -0.0041503906, -0.029449463, 0.0000371933, -0.026046753, -0.018112183, 0.027938843, -0.0103302, 0.06744385, -0.0390625, -0.012451172, -0.017425537, 0.02407837, 0.044921875, -0.038085938, -0.03326416, -0.018814087, -0.04232788, -0.0055999756, -0.01725769, -0.0050964355, -0.014450073, -0.0039405823, 0.025390625, 0.029754639, 0.01852417, 0.0040397644, -0.03857422, -0.057891846, 0.026473999, -0.01576233, 0.06359863, -0.0335083, -0.007843018, -0.016799927, 0.00642395, 0.029266357, -0.004600525, -0.051483154, 0.039245605, -0.01940918, -0.06793213, 0.015716553, -0.0017938614, -0.022079468, 0.029556274, -0.0914917, 0.021408081, -0.019897461, -0.008811951, 0.014320374, -0.038391113, -0.03378296, -0.008224487, -0.012680054, 0.026885986, 0.031219482, -0.016647339, 0.049835205, 0.0030574799, -0.027862549, 0.01576233, 0.015838623, 0.048461914, -0.008575439, -0.033294678, 0.00869751, 0.03353882, 0.04043579, -0.04989624, -0.044799805, 0.010734558, 0.010627747, -0.0077934265, 0.046539307, 0.0013456345, 0.016220093, 0.062561035, 0.015991211, 0.01424408, -0.06945801, -0.02772522, -0.019134521, 0.042877197, 0.048187256, -0.00046801567, -0.012840271, 0.02507019, -0.01902771, 0.012039185, -0.024032593, 0.024398804, 0.01108551, -0.012863159, 0.027389526, -0.016342163, -0.028900146, -0.052001953, -0.01991272, 0.026382446, 0.03475952, -0.026016235, 0.037353516, -0.027496338, 0.07611084, -0.012832642, -0.026229858, 0.020950317, 0.045410156, 0.0011548996, 0.042144775, -0.039154053, -0.020614624, -0.0038909912, -0.0026874542, -0.0053901672, 0.01713562, 0.015075684, -0.018585205, 0.008224487, -0.02041626, -0.037902832, -0.03643799, -0.030517578, 0.026107788, -0.050720215, 0.004299164, -0.048919678, -0.029510498, 0.007118225, 0.015266418, 0.05722046, -0.021606445, -0.04425049, -0.040649414, 0.06072998, -0.017562866 ], "summary": [ -0.02911377, -0.011604309, 0.021194458, 0.056274414, -0.054534912, 0.01197052, -0.0052108765, -0.05532837, 0.02116394, 0.03036499, 0.0031318665, -0.0030212402, 0.0006790161, -0.02607727, -0.022750854, -0.012611389, 0.038726807, -0.026824951, 0.003440857, -0.023010254, -0.015548706, -0.013938904, 0.076660156, 0.04260254, -0.01259613, 0.013641357, -0.022109985, 0.007888794, -0.033172607, -0.008712769, 0.0022468567, 0.01486969, 0.019012451, 0.02748108, -0.031143188, 0.006713867, -0.026367188, 0.022415161, 0.015945435, 0.020126343, 0.017150879, -0.012298584, 0.051940918, -0.05154419, -0.018371582, 0.05239868, -0.0044441223, 0.008255005, 0.0060310364, 0.03289795, 0.013908386, 0.039916992, -0.006839752, 0.0026569366, 0.0017089844, -0.018661499, -0.046936035, -0.034301758, 0.023910522, 0.11004639, 0.02659607, -0.018447876, -0.024871826, -0.09020996, 0.005153656, 0.0027179718, 0.027297974, 0.012664795, -0.0072250366, -0.00060367584, 0.021499634, -0.0033416748, 0.0002603531, 0.018188477, -0.020111084, -0.0056495667, 0.049987793, 0.0435791, -0.010299683, 0.01159668, 0.07458496, -0.022567749, 0.06713867, -0.028671265, 0.023651123, -0.012863159, 0.005142212, -0.0049934387, -0.00617218, -0.0020618439, -0.0073127747, -0.027267456, -0.083618164, 0.06903076, 0.047058105, -0.050354004, -0.053771973, -0.08050537, 0.0099487305, 0.04434204, 0.03869629, -0.054504395, 0.11199951, -0.018432617, 0.009483337, 0.0079422, -0.010765076, -0.070495605, 0.014045715, 0.007472992, -0.028579712, 0.0054016113, -0.017868042, -0.015853882, -0.02645874, 0.031036377, -0.007575989, -0.0013666153, -0.0051231384, 0.022460938, -0.026733398, 0.013427734, 0.0057144165, 0.021606445, -0.0368042, -0.03555298, -0.0001333952, -0.0041999817, -0.0063285828, 0.0128479, -0.00048160553, 0.03540039, -0.0340271, -0.022476196, -0.044189453, 0.0042304993, -0.024795532, -0.0031108856, -0.02293396, 0.00019216537, 0.040130615, -0.015327454, -0.007583618, 0.00003248453, 0.0134887695, 0.045074463, 0.030715942, -0.007965088, -0.037719727, -0.060821533, 0.015342712, -0.006919861, 0.01586914, 0.007484436, -0.0115356445, -0.0647583, 0.011436462, -0.06048584, 0.05432129, -0.041656494, 0.02494812, -0.004261017, -0.015899658, -0.0035800934, -0.014450073, -0.025604248, -0.0023231506, 0.010009766, -0.003326416, 0.03744507, -0.049560547, 0.013763428, -0.0060272217, 0.009010315, -0.00018179417, 0.010574341, -0.0072364807, -0.014518738, -0.0234375, 0.06298828, 0.051086426, -0.0146102905, -0.040496826, 0.050323486, 0.0013170242, -0.045532227, -0.020431519, -0.014373779, 0.06555176, -0.0025405884, -0.021942139, -0.019866943, -0.05456543, 0.036987305, -0.019363403, 0.033447266, -0.043426514, 0.038879395, -0.029800415, -0.03265381, 0.025177002, -0.02734375, 0.009460449, -0.026855469, -0.096069336, 0.002714157, -0.032287598, 0.023956299, -0.03086853, -0.01146698, 0.028289795, -0.023880005, -0.034606934, 0.047210693, -0.009765625, -0.025238037, 0.034240723, -0.030853271, -0.015655518, -0.026916504, -0.023086548, 0.022476196, -0.05999756, 0.032165527, 0.0011835098, 0.021347046, -0.026443481, 0.0181427, 0.054901123, -0.002708435, 0.07696533, -0.020111084, -0.06048584, 0.009788513, -0.0017576218, -0.0009031296, 0.021026611, -0.012901306, 0.04748535, 0.01259613, 0.03086853, 0.03314209, -0.012031555, -0.013145447, 0.046417236, -0.0018453598, 0.0077209473, -0.018966675, -0.010635376, -0.007663727, 0.07537842, -0.019210815, 0.025344849, -0.037872314, 0.049682617, -0.00077724457, -0.025177002, -0.0146102905, -0.013710022, 0.021972656, -0.0040626526, -0.0107803345, 0.022399902, -0.013755798, -0.053009033, -0.04763794, -0.05117798, -0.059509277, -0.0023727417, -0.018295288, 0.037994385, -0.050689697, -0.005039215, -0.050598145, -0.06970215, -0.03137207, -0.01651001, 0.044677734, 0.044769287, -0.038269043, 0.016983032, -0.0132369995, -0.016860962, 0.0046653748, 0.03262329, 0.016738892, 0.0127334595, 0.06109619, 0.023406982, 0.082336426, 0.06994629, 0.023330688, 0.035247803, -0.00566864, 0.013206482, 0.008201599, -0.022766113, 0.010566711, 0.018615723, -0.05078125, -0.0289917, 0.032104492, -0.047943115, -0.00004374981, 0.007881165, 0.009521484, 0.019348145, 0.0072135925, 0.0069503784, -0.017486572, -0.0021743774, 0.0024261475, 0.020187378, 0.09979248, -0.08081055, -0.06604004, -0.02470398, 0.017181396, -0.012619019, 0.012008667, 0.04827881, 0.0095825195, -0.0018520355, 0.002204895, 0.0052871704, -0.02848816, 0.015960693, -0.013916016, 0.0015096664, -0.029785156, -0.032562256, -0.041900635, -0.08453369, 0.00032639503, 0.011528015, 0.031402588, 0.020965576, -0.03253174, 0.021652222, 0.042022705, 0.081604004, 0.03050232, 0.004558563, -0.015403748, -0.059051514, -0.015335083, 0.019180298, -0.0066108704, -0.029556274, -0.023391724, 0.06298828, -0.01512146, -0.0037899017, -0.006515503, -0.013214111, 0.018737793, 0.014732361, -0.042999268, -0.017608643, -0.066345215, -0.04763794, 0.010307312, -0.043701172, -0.018569946, 0.03616333, -0.022338867, -0.01977539, 0.009284973, 0.05343628, 0.04058838, -0.023773193, 0.03515625, -0.032470703, 0.0023117065, 0.035339355, -0.009117126, 0.025421143, -0.038726807, -0.055633545, 0.00059223175, -0.0051994324, 0.019500732, -0.003452301, 0.02557373, 0.084350586, -0.010604858, 0.025344849, 0.058685303, 0.04248047, -0.0020065308, -0.012687683, -0.020889282, 0.005970001, -0.047912598, -0.014266968, 0.027297974, 0.02229309, -0.016082764, 0.0602417, -0.03463745, 0.059906006, 0.0016069412, 0.01108551, 0.006587982, 0.00032663345, 0.0032958984, 0.04925537, -0.011459351, 0.0060157776, 0.02015686, 0.013702393, 0.008552551, 0.0059165955, 0.02696228, 0.0014810562, -0.0075531006, -0.024002075, 0.010231018, -0.0018663406, -0.033081055, -0.025939941, 0.04864502, -0.03326416, -0.012962341, 0.011833191, -0.016357422, 0.029190063, 0.023010254, -0.014289856, 0.010429382, 0.031311035, -0.036071777, 0.0066833496, -0.0060806274, -0.031982422, -0.028961182, -0.027038574, -0.05496216, 0.009155273, -0.053741455, -0.020629883, 0.017715454, 0.027923584, 0.024002075, -0.0025520325, 0.006034851, 0.032928467, -0.00078964233, 0.017333984, 0.04360962, -0.016143799, -0.0046424866, 0.008720398, 0.018920898, -0.041259766, -0.020492554, -0.0076293945, 0.000729084, 0.03527832, 0.010299683, 0.008415222, 0.027130127, -0.030532837, -0.003786087, 0.009902954, 0.021774292, -0.002904892, -0.015914917, -0.07122803, 0.039367676, -0.016906738, -0.017562866, -0.009094238, -0.014045715, 0.0075912476, -0.024459839, 0.01725769, 0.030517578, -0.014434814, -0.005130768, 0.008056641, -0.005542755, -0.029937744, -0.028808594, 0.008132935, 0.014312744, -0.05444336, -0.037963867, 0.04385376, -0.012466431, -0.0075912476, -0.050354004, 0.07513428, -0.034698486, 0.02720642, 0.010787964, -0.019927979, 0.054901123, 0.015945435, -0.056396484, 0.017715454, 0.011100769, 0.00031399727, -0.0057868958, -0.05947876, 0.035064697, 0.051483154, -0.0030899048, 0.017456055, -0.03765869, 0.005001068, -0.0435791, 0.01889038, 0.04144287, -0.030212402, -0.007167816, 0.0077285767, 0.06488037, -0.058624268, -0.02217102, 0.0042152405, 0.010467529, 0.0017518997, 0.022705078, 0.014732361, 0.000018715858, -0.018753052, 0.027389526, 0.0044136047, -0.023635864, 0.038330078, 0.01763916, 0.017120361, 0.035186768, -0.017227173, 0.0017976761, -0.04525757, -0.0030136108, 0.0077819824, -0.019622803, -0.025863647, 0.0013904572, 0.018173218, 0.03427124, -0.00036978722, -0.0026187897, 0.008552551, 0.0099105835, -0.0047683716, -0.03353882, 0.03024292, 0.030319214, -0.049621582, -0.04031372, -0.027008057, -0.0076789856, -0.017166138, 0.010009766, 0.009971619, 0.006175995, -0.044403076, -0.015716553, -0.016967773, 0.05508423, -0.04647827, 0.03933716, -0.011955261, -0.017715454, 0.019226074, -0.049865723, -0.010597229, -0.015083313, 0.027252197, -0.032684326, 0.041259766, -0.013595581, -0.019210815, 0.00033402443, 0.008811951, 0.046661377, 0.043029785, 0.012496948, -0.049560547, -0.033996582, -0.02003479, -0.025512695, -0.00046253204, -0.012840271, -0.033294678, -0.05014038, 0.0036315918, -0.00015187263, -0.02746582, -0.05706787, 0.0052986145, -0.0016851425, -0.007335663, 0.056396484, 0.048095703, 0.023529053, 0.014457703, -0.003446579, 0.0095825195, 0.005558014, 0.017547607, -0.0010547638, -0.027740479, 0.06335449, -0.004550934, 0.034851074, -0.025360107, -0.047027588, 0.045837402, -0.008705139, 0.050109863, 0.017120361, 0.02079773, -0.05343628, -0.054718018, 0.016296387, 0.030822754, -0.0236969, 0.053863525, 0.02154541, -0.0206604, 0.026992798, 0.030029297, 0.05126953, -0.0067443848, -0.0068588257, 0.048309326, -0.031829834, -0.055999756, -0.08483887, -0.037475586, 0.100097656, -0.00687027, -0.049346924, 0.00806427, 0.01637268, 0.025268555, -0.006389618, -0.014503479, -0.015205383, -0.056640625, -0.0027942657, -0.015052795, -0.012138367, -0.015426636, -0.021499634, 0.056884766, 0.0027236938, 0.0018062592, -0.053863525, 0.0055122375, -0.05102539, -0.02670288, 0.016906738, 0.005130768, 0.00069618225, -0.030090332, 0.038360596, -0.01852417, 0.019577026, 0.013771057, -0.038635254, -0.008491516, -0.0015249252, -0.02973938, 0.016662598, -0.02748108, 0.009407043, 0.00806427, -0.029296875, 0.014808655, 0.007865906, 0.011619568, 0.0109939575, 0.021347046, -0.045532227, -0.007888794, -0.059692383, 0.010887146, 0.0028686523, -0.030029297, -0.041290283, 0.011375427, 0.052581787, 0.013999939, -0.040740967, 0.010284424, 0.030853271, -0.0345459, -0.022415161, 0.02508545, -0.015434265, -0.0022449493, -0.031143188, 0.035064697, -0.050567627, -0.014480591, -0.0026016235, -0.00037264824, 0.002796173, 0.02709961, 0.0069847107, -0.05456543, -0.052246094, 0.07989502, 0.055603027, -0.012107849, -0.060943604, -0.012626648, -0.007331848, -0.042785645, -0.044525146, -0.031463623, 0.024963379, 0.014518738, 0.05053711, 0.017913818, 0.014251709, 0.010643005, -0.034210205, 0.022659302, -0.057617188, 0.013130188, 0.01576233, -0.0119018555, -0.011199951, -0.015670776, 0.012619019, -0.00466156, -0.02861023, 0.00086069107, -0.03778076, 0.0020446777, 0.030853271, 0.03967285, 0.053894043, 0.029251099, -0.0044822693, 0.03729248, 0.021896362, 0.0031471252, -0.011169434, 0.0044021606, -0.012145996, -0.0013074875, -0.003293991, 0.05130005, -0.006565094, -0.008621216, -0.0385437, 0.023345947, -0.043701172, -0.03289795, -0.021759033, -0.005718231, 0.0070152283, -0.026229858, 0.002368927, 0.019973755, 0.03100586, -0.008155823, 0.045715332, -0.11340332, -0.0692749, -0.027679443, -0.021331787, -0.023651123, 0.030014038, -0.03390503, -0.07128906, 0.038208008, -0.036376953, -0.02279663, 0.007247925, 0.011917114, 0.0042648315, -0.026901245, 0.04324341, 0.006023407, 0.016784668, 0.0024662018, -0.0029315948, 0.012123108, -0.008956909, 0.0015354156, -0.01108551, 0.016586304, 0.029586792, 0.019592285, -0.03652954, -0.019210815, -0.0146865845, -0.0068969727, -0.008926392, -0.015472412, -0.0129852295, 0.0030460358, 0.014350891, -0.040161133, -0.031982422, -0.03579712, -0.01008606, 0.064453125, -0.04812622, -0.013496399, 0.05316162, -0.01096344, -0.0046195984, 0.0060539246, -0.020980835, 0.021224976, 0.012008667, -0.0011577606, -0.006072998, 0.0063438416, -0.053131104, 0.026184082, 0.04168701, -0.011383057, 0.028244019, 0.04547119, -0.020812988, 0.014289856, 0.00422287, 0.0007634163, -0.040985107, 0.018417358, -0.018859863, 0.01399231, 0.022979736, 0.035369873, -0.00059604645, -0.009391785, 0.05886841, -0.02279663, -0.0052490234, 0.020507812, -0.012496948, 0.025619507, -0.008285522, 0.060302734, 0.008552551, 0.0030155182, -0.029403687, 0.050476074, 0.00078582764, 0.034698486, -0.05911255, 0.0019741058, -0.023727417, 0.012168884, -0.028060913, -0.003320694, -0.038208008, 0.01424408, 0.019515991, -0.03074646, 0.013252258, -0.021865845, 0.008918762, -0.012367249, 0.0070648193, -0.01361084, 0.039886475, 0.0158844, 0.025756836, 0.026550293, -0.026916504, -0.002746582, -0.022460938, -0.027252197, 0.0030326843, 0.010513306, -0.017608643, 0.019897461, 0.02319336, 0.03378296, 0.04333496, 0.04888916, -0.0054130554, 0.0104522705, 0.020507812, -0.010635376, -0.002286911, -0.078125, -0.027267456, -0.07373047, 0.015792847, 0.03805542, -0.024658203, -0.015975952, 0.0005106926, -0.0077209473, 0.0002644062, -0.028686523, -0.015808105, -0.009635925, -0.03024292, 0.036346436, -0.060272217, -0.03994751, 0.015716553, 0.001408577, -0.027832031, 0.032592773, -0.033966064, -0.04550171, 0.018066406, 0.032806396, 0.05227661, -0.040802002, -0.009994507, 0.032928467, 0.03805542, 0.07897949, -0.004184723, -0.03869629, 0.010818481, -0.017486572, 0.06188965, -0.002231598, -0.03604126, 0.018157959, 0.006290436, -0.03277588, 0.01838684, 0.025863647, 0.0008020401, 0.033477783, -0.024337769, 0.023223877, -0.009155273, 0.009490967, -0.0012359619, 0.018981934, -0.024032593, 0.0002682209, -0.009025574, -0.041381836, -0.04272461, -0.0054092407, -0.0059318542, 0.043060303, 0.00019824505, 0.040802002, 0.027755737, 0.025634766, -0.052886963, -0.020477295, -0.009963989, 0.03552246, 0.04144287, -0.0079193115, 0.01121521, 0.016662598, 0.0032424927, 0.011489868, -0.001083374, 0.005455017, 0.011734009, 0.019927979, 0.02746582, 0.007843018, -0.024032593, 0.00067043304, -0.004333496, 0.053497314, -0.004989624, -0.02684021, -0.0012655258, -0.00047373772, -0.048828125, -0.037078857, -0.009353638, 0.0036773682, -0.039764404, 0.01158905, -0.0010080338, -0.029754639, -0.022064209, -0.017959595, -0.03250122, 0.024871826, 0.017623901, -0.012176514, 0.021896362, -0.01965332, 0.05670166, -0.011779785, 0.072753906, -0.032714844, -0.037872314, 0.025772095, -0.055847168, 0.016479492, 0.031311035, -0.02545166, -0.02104187, 0.037078857, -0.021224976, 0.008262634, -0.0657959, 0.016342163, -0.1048584, -0.028945923, -0.0289917, -0.0074539185, 0.01133728, -0.057891846, 0.026519775, 0.005290985, -0.050842285, 0.0104904175, 0.013641357, -0.00020217896, -0.010765076, 0.017745972, -0.012168884, -0.0036315918, 0.0062026978 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2008.07343v4
Artificial Intelligence in the Battle against Coronavirus (COVID-19): A Survey and Future Research Directions
Thanh Thi Nguyen, Quoc Viet Hung Nguyen, Dung Tien Nguyen, Samuel Yang, Peter W. Eklund, Thien Huynh-The, Thanh Tam Nguyen, Quoc-Viet Pham, Imran Razzak, Edbert B. Hsu
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG
Artificial intelligence (AI) has been applied widely in our daily lives in a variety of ways with numerous success stories. AI has also contributed to dealing with the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, which has been happening around the globe. This paper presents a survey of AI methods being used in various applications in the fight against the COVID-19 outbreak and outlines the crucial role of AI research in this unprecedented battle. We touch on areas where AI plays as an essential component, from medical image processing, data analytics, text mining and natural language processing, the Internet of Things, to computational biology and medicine. A summary of COVID-19 related data sources that are available for research purposes is also presented. Research directions on exploring the potential of AI and enhancing its capability and power in the pandemic battle are thoroughly discussed. We identify 13 groups of problems related to the COVID-19 pandemic and highlight promising AI methods and tools that can be used to address these problems. It is envisaged that this study will provide AI researchers and the wider community with an overview of the current status of AI applications, and motivate researchers to harness AI's potential in the fight against COVID-19.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2008.07343v4
2022-03-17T03:53:20
2020-07-30T11:11:55
{ "title": [ -0.02192688, -0.0011873245, -0.04901123, -0.052490234, 0.026245117, -0.016326904, -0.0017633438, -0.0052108765, -0.030029297, 0.043121338, -0.01675415, 0.015045166, 0.004009247, -0.018417358, -0.03652954, -0.0013580322, 0.004211426, 0.018936157, 0.0003156662, -0.01928711, 0.0020828247, -0.038146973, 0.05657959, 0.04763794, 0.031204224, -0.044769287, -0.06756592, -0.013679504, -0.04284668, -0.059417725, -0.02217102, 0.06463623, 0.045166016, 0.007637024, -0.017868042, 0.020370483, -0.059906006, 0.029525757, -0.020080566, 0.007896423, 0.0031909943, 0.00016570091, -0.025482178, -0.015808105, -0.03842163, 0.0072135925, -0.078063965, -0.000031888485, -0.0017204285, 0.027435303, 0.019058228, 0.023071289, -0.0154800415, 0.01939392, 0.018127441, -0.023788452, -0.015731812, -0.011878967, 0.033203125, 0.032958984, -0.0051345825, -0.03753662, 0.027435303, -0.005886078, -0.0569458, -0.021820068, -0.03869629, 0.017089844, 0.07470703, -0.008583069, -0.0056610107, 0.047088623, 0.00894928, 0.032562256, -0.067993164, -0.051116943, 0.059753418, -0.0026168823, 0.034210205, -0.00920105, -0.019058228, -0.036346436, 0.02368164, 0.0004093647, -0.022155762, -0.021820068, -0.021255493, 0.0014095306, -0.022598267, -0.050628662, -0.0035552979, 0.0006928444, -0.02798462, 0.02671814, -0.015609741, -0.011528015, -0.0016231537, 0.037994385, 0.009521484, -0.0017976761, -0.009132385, 0.0038700104, -0.04864502, -0.024887085, 0.0069770813, 0.06665039, 0.008308411, -0.015014648, -0.018707275, 0.014221191, -0.015312195, -0.021636963, 0.02406311, -0.020370483, -0.0021533966, 0.010246277, 0.0060424805, 0.017791748, 0.024780273, 0.019836426, -0.008148193, -0.034973145, 0.032318115, 0.010177612, 0.030151367, 0.016433716, -0.04623413, -0.018371582, 0.007896423, 0.036315918, -0.004863739, 0.03656006, -0.10253906, -0.09790039, -0.059783936, 0.032165527, 0.017944336, -0.0069618225, 0.01524353, 0.0050964355, 0.025299072, -0.038208008, -0.00043344498, 0.042633057, -0.026519775, -0.009361267, 0.05307007, -0.008010864, -0.04864502, -0.021987915, -0.053466797, 0.00945282, 0.028671265, 0.006668091, -0.04699707, 0.012969971, -0.091918945, -0.015037537, 0.005054474, 0.014228821, 0.030960083, 0.011238098, -0.007587433, 0.003967285, 0.053131104, -0.023468018, -0.022872925, 0.026275635, 0.008842468, 0.03717041, -0.003665924, 0.02368164, -0.0023231506, -0.0039482117, -0.009269714, -0.020370483, 0.03543091, 0.020187378, 0.018188477, -0.002046585, -0.0007381439, -0.03463745, 0.0029144287, 0.061340332, -0.054229736, -0.022369385, -0.009124756, -0.017578125, 0.066711426, 0.004737854, -0.047607422, -0.003025055, -0.049743652, -0.04055786, -0.035095215, -0.010269165, 0.022323608, 0.027252197, -0.012161255, 0.0071868896, -0.050445557, -0.008125305, -0.030548096, 0.019378662, 0.0030345917, -0.035736084, 0.001452446, 0.03201294, -0.03189087, 0.06365967, 0.042114258, 0.020248413, -0.028198242, -0.0068969727, 0.008781433, -0.060516357, 0.02482605, -0.00052404404, -0.019119263, -0.00970459, -0.049835205, -0.010147095, -0.028015137, 0.026031494, 0.0071372986, 0.010353088, -0.00504303, -0.023391724, 0.051818848, 0.02407837, 0.10406494, -0.027252197, 0.03387451, 0.009536743, -0.022384644, -0.019821167, -0.022140503, 0.008712769, 0.0045204163, 0.012168884, 0.008888245, -0.020645142, 0.0022010803, 0.02128601, 0.06304932, 0.008346558, 0.017593384, 0.008468628, 0.018463135, 0.018188477, 0.030975342, 0.018127441, 0.07043457, 0.03012085, 0.006893158, 0.07312012, -0.01889038, 0.0074043274, -0.01826477, 0.0023155212, -0.0012817383, 0.0077705383, 0.020751953, -0.008758545, -0.048187256, 0.008590698, -0.03604126, 0.0053215027, 0.0054512024, 0.007041931, 0.039154053, -0.025543213, -0.002325058, 0.0042381287, -0.0077171326, -0.016082764, -0.024047852, 0.014266968, -0.00036740303, -0.029006958, -0.00035095215, 0.021102905, 0.031402588, -0.0012407303, 0.02684021, -0.001821518, 0.013771057, -0.004623413, -0.03375244, -0.028060913, 0.037109375, 0.024505615, 0.0014514923, -0.024307251, 0.025375366, 0.0025424957, 0.060516357, 0.09490967, -0.028182983, 0.036743164, -0.0826416, 0.009552002, 0.0058631897, -0.024780273, 0.009048462, 0.014266968, -0.006790161, 0.027297974, -0.02331543, -0.0010709763, -0.055145264, 0.033691406, 0.0038661957, -0.030548096, -0.010925293, -0.043640137, -0.016845703, -0.033081055, -0.06262207, -0.0138549805, 0.04562378, 0.000688076, -0.024398804, -0.031585693, 0.019546509, -0.012039185, -0.046020508, -0.03387451, -0.012207031, 0.022460938, 0.0569458, 0.016403198, -0.040924072, 0.0076446533, 0.008399963, 0.0209198, -0.015792847, 0.03677368, -0.01890564, -0.03250122, 0.012893677, 0.006038666, -0.0005450249, -0.03265381, 0.009155273, -0.024490356, 0.009727478, 0.025970459, -0.042175293, -0.0039749146, 0.028182983, -0.03475952, -0.047790527, -0.005947113, 0.041748047, -0.018539429, -0.0041503906, 0.008613586, 0.032470703, -0.02798462, 0.048339844, 0.013420105, 0.021453857, -0.019699097, -0.01689148, -0.061462402, -0.013008118, -0.0035266876, 0.014022827, 0.028274536, -0.058380127, -0.0013475418, -0.021224976, -0.00048804283, 0.018569946, 0.01725769, -0.032196045, -0.041870117, -0.010543823, -0.036132812, -0.005329132, 0.007522583, -0.017654419, 0.014160156, 0.083740234, 0.006126404, -0.025802612, -0.0020046234, 0.02519226, 0.004497528, -0.016174316, -0.0010843277, -0.017745972, 0.01373291, -0.0004143715, 0.011878967, -0.026824951, 0.004070282, -0.11450195, 0.013282776, 0.047546387, -0.005306244, -0.03186035, 0.019165039, -0.060760498, 0.011421204, 0.0011997223, 0.0030441284, 0.03857422, 0.05279541, -0.017440796, 0.034820557, -0.008338928, -0.006111145, -0.016189575, -0.0059318542, -0.10809326, 0.020706177, -0.021224976, -0.002691269, 0.0041923523, -0.036010742, -0.044158936, -0.002916336, -0.012626648, 0.048614502, 0.03378296, 0.015579224, 0.018234253, -0.010879517, 0.018875122, -0.035583496, -0.004711151, -0.03970337, -0.008674622, -0.011993408, -0.030883789, 0.06237793, -0.023269653, 0.01991272, -0.035461426, -0.017684937, 0.005302429, 0.021636963, 0.020706177, -0.04498291, -0.005973816, -0.028045654, -0.025238037, 0.0037326813, -0.005279541, 0.0038585663, -0.042877197, 0.009605408, -0.023925781, 0.021942139, 0.022567749, 0.01600647, -0.0035953522, -0.011604309, 0.0093688965, -0.033294678, -0.048187256, 0.011123657, -0.008621216, -0.0033779144, 0.039215088, -0.0043029785, -0.017120361, -0.004020691, -0.030395508, 0.038330078, 0.00182724, 0.00050497055, -0.014404297, 0.001329422, -0.024429321, 0.03060913, -0.023971558, 0.012794495, -0.0015125275, 0.0030555725, -0.00818634, -0.048797607, 0.0038051605, 0.008743286, -0.09844971, -0.056274414, 0.007965088, -0.053833008, -0.0725708, -0.038330078, 0.022384644, -0.038726807, -0.027328491, 0.017440796, -0.026473999, -0.0088272095, -0.009742737, -0.052337646, -0.03793335, 0.050079346, -0.006439209, 0.014945984, 0.04046631, -0.010696411, -0.0048828125, -0.012290955, 0.030319214, 0.039642334, 0.019302368, 0.012794495, -0.014633179, 0.058135986, -0.037994385, 0.0026988983, 0.01612854, 0.029663086, -0.026916504, -0.0010643005, -0.0034255981, 0.018920898, -0.024139404, 0.042144775, 0.04248047, -0.016860962, -0.05532837, 0.015808105, -0.004802704, -0.033843994, 0.013450623, -0.010612488, 0.006752014, 0.032196045, 0.021575928, 0.083618164, -0.015991211, 0.014556885, 0.010299683, -0.018234253, -0.03338623, -0.013877869, 0.03253174, 0.014472961, -0.009002686, 0.02659607, -0.0178833, 0.0519104, -0.005996704, -0.00258255, 0.0036506653, 0.012054443, -0.017242432, -0.018157959, -0.0703125, -0.03704834, -0.025238037, 0.0051193237, 0.0058021545, 0.015625, 0.052856445, -0.0011262894, -0.0440979, -0.013267517, 0.040802002, -0.012969971, 0.004211426, -0.06854248, 0.014335632, -0.016586304, -0.06689453, -0.055755615, -0.043121338, -0.00223732, 0.0032424927, -0.0021305084, 0.011436462, 0.034973145, 0.013343811, 0.039093018, 0.036102295, -0.028945923, -0.042419434, 0.02659607, -0.029022217, -0.036499023, -0.010047913, 0.00016129017, -0.035980225, -0.039123535, 0.029830933, -0.018920898, -0.017700195, -0.054840088, 0.028030396, -0.0030097961, 0.04385376, 0.0055770874, 0.022064209, 0.0154418945, 0.022476196, 0.0154953, 0.0029449463, -0.024261475, -0.046691895, 0.014213562, 0.0647583, -0.024765015, -0.006450653, 0.039001465, -0.0003323555, 0.00003385544, 0.007118225, 0.008758545, 0.024932861, 0.0012969971, -0.007041931, 0.03781128, -0.025283813, -0.040771484, -0.0067710876, 0.012573242, 0.034820557, -0.06124878, 0.05819702, -0.03665161, -0.009635925, 0.011871338, -0.0062713623, 0.006088257, -0.02545166, 0.01675415, -0.04916382, -0.0501709, 0.0020561218, 0.050720215, -0.034484863, -0.0020694733, -0.0074501038, 0.00075006485, 0.014289856, 0.04119873, 0.008415222, 0.008987427, 0.030014038, -0.007472992, -0.0018920898, -0.029815674, -0.019470215, 0.012680054, -0.016494751, 0.014251709, -0.045715332, -0.011871338, -0.052825928, -0.02104187, 0.0045166016, 0.0073051453, 0.028549194, -0.06323242, 0.0029296875, 0.07434082, -0.01007843, 0.022994995, -0.033966064, 0.011688232, 0.017333984, 0.05432129, -0.015319824, 0.025863647, 0.03778076, -0.046325684, -0.030151367, 0.013015747, 0.04373169, 0.024749756, 0.018432617, 0.017959595, -0.023117065, -0.03741455, 0.03567505, 0.0059928894, -0.023498535, 0.046020508, -0.06573486, 0.0075798035, -0.012413025, -0.011756897, -0.0101623535, -0.028793335, -0.04248047, 0.018661499, -0.044036865, -0.0010356903, 0.010276794, -0.020553589, -0.04220581, -0.061279297, 0.0262146, 0.00071668625, 0.0031280518, -0.012619019, 0.021102905, -0.058410645, 0.019317627, 0.014350891, -0.07775879, 0.01914978, -0.02444458, 0.015266418, 0.05230713, 0.022781372, -0.053833008, -0.008033752, -0.0038013458, -0.068359375, -0.028182983, 0.02658081, 0.012840271, -0.015609741, -0.025817871, -0.030227661, -0.019134521, -0.004962921, 0.022232056, 0.017654419, -0.053466797, 0.010147095, 0.007083893, 0.0047073364, 0.019195557, 0.048919678, -0.013763428, 0.008483887, 0.018081665, -0.030014038, 0.02116394, -0.0026874542, 0.00036406517, 0.0022907257, -0.06161499, 0.017425537, 0.019500732, 0.0018520355, 0.0068626404, 0.013938904, 0.040649414, 0.012367249, 0.017242432, 0.0340271, 0.07720947, -0.061187744, -0.022445679, -0.00390625, -0.015899658, -0.049346924, 0.060150146, 0.0044288635, -0.016113281, -0.043548584, -0.028915405, -0.033081055, 0.009780884, 0.036499023, 0.026016235, 0.073791504, -0.016067505, 0.010047913, -0.023422241, 0.00541687, -0.005695343, -0.0038204193, 0.006526947, 0.044281006, -0.016571045, 0.025405884, -0.018585205, -0.014549255, 0.027923584, 0.019241333, 0.0037574768, 0.009231567, -0.025787354, 0.0006766319, -0.036346436, -0.028289795, 0.04522705, 0.017822266, -0.038635254, 0.04248047, -0.016403198, 0.07458496, 0.036224365, 0.05050659, 0.058044434, 0.017608643, 0.020004272, -0.007896423, 0.016555786, -0.031204224, 0.024261475, -0.057495117, 0.01940918, -0.053649902, -0.0068626404, -0.084228516, 0.012519836, 0.017852783, 0.032226562, -0.00111866, 0.026809692, 0.012748718, -0.00025844574, 0.07354736, 0.0129776, 0.075805664, 0.026748657, 0.0066947937, -0.014343262, -0.005207062, 0.008766174, 0.028640747, 0.003358841, 0.028030396, -0.015838623, 0.0104904175, -0.01828003, -0.00027370453, 0.010978699, -0.032287598, -0.002040863, -0.007751465, 0.016418457, -0.028274536, 0.007217407, 0.05633545, 0.085510254, -0.027023315, -0.00013506413, 0.017181396, -0.0034065247, -0.0036754608, -0.022918701, 0.047027588, -0.06427002, 0.023071289, -0.018325806, -0.042297363, -0.03149414, 0.061309814, 0.013687134, -0.03491211, -0.011047363, 0.007888794, 0.033081055, 0.018463135, 0.008354187, -0.036132812, -0.016342163, 0.008407593, 0.038360596, -0.012214661, 0.012359619, 0.0017738342, 0.07019043, -0.049835205, -0.004337311, -0.013267517, 0.00207901, -0.05883789, 0.014976501, -0.03527832, 0.048858643, -0.016616821, -0.052459717, 0.024307251, -0.016098022, -0.051452637, -0.03024292, 0.051208496, 0.014282227, -0.0008482933, 0.06088257, 0.016967773, -0.019454956, -0.044677734, -0.015914917, 0.033233643, 0.055480957, -0.020690918, 0.031311035, -0.035888672, -0.030151367, 0.045440674, -0.022583008, 0.08251953, -0.03677368, -0.0011100769, -0.008056641, 0.024353027, 0.023544312, -0.054351807, -0.021316528, -0.013061523, 0.006965637, -0.041412354, -0.027236938, -0.03253174, -0.034484863, 0.0042686462, 0.06500244, 0.019500732, -0.005744934, -0.0069999695, -0.03286743, -0.056854248, -0.0034980774, -0.02545166, 0.02720642, -0.022064209, -0.017623901, -0.021057129, 0.00009769201, 0.00028657913, -0.019897461, -0.03274536, 0.010871887, -0.013809204, -0.005367279, -0.008735657, 0.0029563904, -0.024169922, -0.03225708, -0.025222778, 0.010482788, -0.03567505, -0.0005130768, 0.03616333, -0.015464783, -0.061462402, -0.019989014, -0.026885986, 0.025115967, 0.0073776245, -0.031402588, 0.0005464554, 0.030883789, -0.033203125, 0.0011558533, -0.011207581, 0.044799805, -0.043029785, -0.04675293, -0.0074882507, 0.02986145, 0.03616333, -0.05532837, -0.052703857, 0.0050315857, 0.039123535, -0.006248474, 0.045684814, 0.019683838, 0.026611328, 0.021392822, 0.037963867, 0.005531311, -0.081970215, -0.052825928, -0.028060913, 0.055419922, 0.054534912, -0.016143799, -0.005748749, 0.041534424, -0.0040779114, 0.008369446, 0.016189575, -0.00258255, 0.018051147, -0.0032024384, 0.039245605, -0.009147644, -0.032928467, 0.004146576, 0.033172607, -0.008308411, 0.016067505, -0.009002686, 0.0009417534, -0.003774643, 0.038360596, -0.022659302, -0.07342529, 0.06994629, 0.053131104, 0.004623413, 0.061431885, -0.02545166, -0.027313232, -0.003929138, 0.0039978027, -0.00944519, 0.009101868, 0.019042969, -0.010551453, 0.0030021667, -0.013313293, -0.05206299, 0.013572693, -0.0418396, 0.02911377, -0.015411377, 0.012931824, -0.008995056, -0.0025596619, 0.00084733963, 0.036590576, 0.03338623, -0.02204895, -0.042144775, -0.03137207, 0.057678223, -0.009712219 ], "summary": [ 0.015174866, -0.0071525574, -0.0021514893, 0.004333496, -0.0013189316, -0.01626587, 0.04324341, -0.026290894, 0.0065574646, 0.046539307, -0.02305603, 0.009063721, 0.019058228, -0.013679504, -0.018478394, -0.00944519, 0.0211792, 0.016494751, 0.034729004, -0.015319824, 0.0025806427, -0.015686035, 0.04171753, 0.024414062, 0.0317688, -0.049713135, -0.06933594, 0.02319336, -0.024932861, -0.0043945312, 0.0050315857, 0.032592773, 0.022598267, -0.0011930466, -0.0066070557, 0.012939453, -0.035308838, -0.00064373016, -0.016281128, 0.028259277, 0.028335571, -0.008888245, 0.13745117, -0.022018433, 0.034057617, 0.0029678345, 0.030975342, -0.041381836, 0.035888672, -0.040985107, 0.0057792664, 0.010009766, 0.014701843, -0.043151855, -0.01436615, 0.019805908, 0.02407837, -0.018295288, 0.035064697, -0.06298828, -0.036224365, -0.026397705, 0.06008911, 0.021987915, -0.021911621, -0.007537842, -0.02407837, 0.009536743, 0.013557434, 0.0051116943, 0.027420044, -0.004459381, -0.00655365, -0.0044174194, -0.025970459, -0.02293396, 0.032348633, -0.02041626, 0.011222839, 0.015686035, -0.0013227463, 0.01953125, 0.012229919, -0.0054779053, -0.036834717, -0.012969971, -0.0121536255, -0.015136719, -0.013504028, -0.018661499, -0.036315918, -0.03265381, -0.08959961, 0.06829834, 0.05432129, -0.0053634644, -0.010719299, -0.03540039, 0.049102783, 0.024795532, 0.018432617, -0.05480957, 0.020217896, -0.019302368, -0.030380249, 0.10223389, 0.037200928, 0.014099121, -0.022476196, -0.017349243, 0.006477356, -0.08728027, 0.03918457, -0.043945312, -0.024536133, 0.0340271, 0.048736572, 0.0026741028, 0.017364502, 0.011207581, -0.028518677, -0.0029716492, 0.015731812, -0.00006479025, 0.047790527, 0.038116455, -0.01071167, -0.013168335, 0.058563232, 0.058929443, -0.024673462, -0.01889038, -0.042633057, -0.043182373, -0.03475952, -0.021240234, 0.013252258, -0.027435303, 0.042236328, -0.027252197, 0.06750488, -0.002603531, -0.0023708344, 0.08154297, -0.03201294, -0.031021118, 0.004634857, 0.05206299, 0.0048675537, 0.0056915283, -0.0006341934, -0.0020961761, 0.029342651, -0.01448822, -0.0066947937, -0.030548096, 0.007522583, -0.00881958, 0.002336502, -0.011413574, 0.029312134, 0.020950317, 0.024291992, 0.015670776, 0.037384033, -0.03741455, -0.04598999, 0.0046920776, 0.0026130676, -0.056243896, 0.005115509, 0.042114258, 0.012313843, -0.007160187, 0.024719238, -0.013069153, 0.0066184998, 0.02128601, -0.023376465, 0.021469116, 0.016830444, -0.047210693, -0.058258057, 0.042388916, -0.0050582886, 0.010864258, -0.001865387, 0.018218994, 0.0317688, 0.0025234222, -0.011199951, -0.008453369, -0.040008545, 0.010284424, 0.0029678345, 0.01247406, -0.025283813, 0.021347046, -0.0021476746, -0.019012451, 0.009269714, -0.011100769, -0.0044517517, -0.033233643, -0.072509766, -0.020492554, -0.021499634, 0.023895264, -0.04714966, 0.009490967, 0.046722412, -0.022857666, -0.039611816, 0.017715454, 0.01586914, 0.0017690659, 0.0047302246, -0.021591187, -0.035858154, -0.028244019, -0.05331421, 0.020309448, -0.07507324, 0.014709473, -0.019180298, 0.0154953, -0.022003174, 0.0026340485, 0.009643555, -0.00077295303, 0.05178833, 0.012199402, 0.028518677, 0.043304443, -0.015449524, -0.022445679, -0.033081055, -0.09777832, 0.0070343018, 0.046081543, 0.023590088, -0.038391113, -0.0501709, -0.0287323, 0.017288208, 0.013267517, 0.015113831, 0.004924774, 0.006969452, 0.016845703, 0.0041656494, -0.006832123, 0.032806396, 0.024780273, -0.014305115, 0.036956787, -0.041168213, -0.0073890686, -0.008262634, -0.008728027, 0.0052375793, -0.03125, 0.023117065, -0.030456543, -0.02633667, -0.016860962, -0.0047302246, 0.00818634, 0.011253357, -0.04574585, 0.008666992, -0.02432251, -0.025939941, 0.010482788, -0.020309448, -0.00623703, -0.01725769, 0.018737793, 0.007156372, -0.0025997162, -0.0026893616, 0.010063171, -0.022399902, -0.016113281, 0.03479004, 0.0011920929, -0.0029087067, -0.0027313232, 0.022018433, 0.023590088, 0.048461914, 0.024276733, 0.0043525696, -0.015159607, 0.03552246, -0.019943237, -0.042388916, 0.048034668, -0.009544373, -0.019119263, -0.0005726814, 0.028076172, -0.042816162, 0.021209717, 0.01977539, -0.031982422, -0.026535034, 0.036834717, 0.02973938, -0.014404297, -0.029815674, 0.06173706, -0.022262573, 0.02848816, -0.04916382, -0.07244873, -0.020248413, -0.013092041, -0.07165527, -0.049072266, 0.024795532, -0.010154724, -0.015327454, -0.008987427, -0.005329132, -0.019927979, -0.0068473816, -0.0041656494, -0.031799316, -0.0011339188, -0.0072784424, -0.003440857, 0.004459381, 0.0637207, -0.004753113, 0.0031204224, 0.0026664734, 0.07861328, 0.0056648254, -0.06542969, 0.00068855286, 0.07476807, -0.02130127, 0.008865356, -0.01361084, 0.021865845, -0.0012426376, 0.0051231384, -0.03250122, 0.009880066, -0.008232117, -0.034698486, -0.042175293, 0.026550293, 0.014152527, 0.018707275, 0.040985107, -0.008491516, 0.01007843, -0.03768921, 0.06750488, -0.0006766319, -0.00137043, -0.06707764, 0.021270752, -0.029403687, 0.009185791, -0.07824707, 0.04119873, 0.035186768, -0.05783081, 0.03173828, 0.00012874603, 0.018875122, 0.055908203, 0.011474609, 0.037872314, -0.010673523, 0.014656067, 0.026763916, 0.019760132, 0.019744873, -0.019134521, 0.024810791, 0.051757812, 0.0024261475, 0.027664185, 0.011810303, 0.064575195, 0.0024528503, -0.002981186, -0.032409668, 0.021636963, -0.019165039, 0.0041885376, -0.008148193, -0.017196655, 0.02911377, -0.021896362, -0.01361084, 0.05230713, 0.019012451, -0.011940002, 0.013420105, -0.032318115, 0.047576904, 0.019577026, -0.012786865, 0.033203125, 0.00077819824, -0.031677246, 0.03967285, -0.041015625, 0.017105103, -0.04598999, 0.0059127808, 0.0077323914, -0.0028858185, -0.0236969, 0.017364502, 0.026062012, 0.004676819, 0.020889282, 0.033447266, -0.025299072, 0.068481445, -0.014213562, 0.032409668, -0.010124207, -0.03112793, -0.005882263, -0.028915405, -0.0211792, -0.022598267, -0.017623901, -0.027496338, -0.018371582, -0.026168823, 0.00894165, -0.036346436, 0.020492554, 0.01651001, 0.018127441, -0.036346436, 0.022125244, -0.031143188, 0.052001953, 0.02935791, 0.005077362, 0.02619934, -0.010757446, 0.004917145, 0.0016651154, 0.015914917, -0.0234375, -0.034484863, -0.036071777, 0.037719727, 0.038879395, -0.026245117, 0.011985779, -0.038360596, 0.0027065277, 0.0052490234, -0.014251709, 0.001414299, 0.011131287, 0.0007805824, -0.013679504, -0.005504608, -0.024047852, 0.020019531, -0.044921875, -0.02633667, -0.02520752, -0.037506104, 0.054107666, -0.010253906, 0.09643555, -0.011299133, -0.04269409, 0.009880066, 0.0023269653, -0.03881836, -0.009422302, 0.0087890625, -0.062408447, -0.04824829, 0.0008468628, -0.025405884, -0.040405273, -0.03677368, 0.021713257, -0.025238037, -0.020095825, 0.014122009, -0.029556274, 0.09588623, 0.030639648, -0.05618286, 0.050079346, -0.049682617, 0.03048706, 0.009559631, 0.009384155, 0.011024475, 0.029205322, 0.020431519, 0.015853882, 0.01914978, 0.015716553, 0.0008568764, -0.008934021, 0.029083252, -0.031921387, -0.019012451, 0.029647827, 0.03692627, -0.021850586, -0.0058555603, 0.047576904, 0.07495117, -0.036071777, -0.012794495, 0.066589355, -0.00340271, -0.03338623, 0.02861023, -0.041381836, -0.051116943, 0.00015461445, 0.03479004, -0.058288574, -0.012138367, 0.059661865, 0.019104004, -0.02432251, -0.00008404255, 0.0012741089, 0.019836426, -0.049560547, -0.029190063, 0.043182373, 0.04562378, -0.017456055, -0.0018501282, -0.047058105, 0.04550171, -0.032684326, 0.020751953, -0.003124237, -0.017669678, 0.022583008, -0.04296875, -0.020065308, -0.0023593903, 0.000005066395, -0.0037345886, 0.031036377, 0.0041160583, 0.01612854, -0.010650635, 0.010978699, -0.0076828003, 0.13684082, 0.014678955, -0.0362854, -0.10296631, -0.0006098747, 0.019714355, -0.024230957, -0.027023315, -0.0647583, -0.030532837, -0.058013916, -0.016433716, 0.006252289, 0.035247803, 0.0053520203, 0.033569336, 0.043029785, -0.017501831, -0.05307007, 0.019302368, -0.010375977, -0.01007843, -0.06719971, 0.012496948, -0.05380249, -0.020492554, 0.026870728, -0.012588501, -0.021697998, -0.056640625, 0.025619507, 0.022384644, 0.001537323, 0.0047187805, 0.014411926, 0.00038576126, 0.03640747, -0.012588501, -0.0068359375, -0.02519226, 0.020065308, -0.023223877, 0.0814209, -0.061065674, -0.013038635, -0.0037708282, -0.0016031265, -0.04800415, 0.022827148, 0.016098022, 0.008201599, 0.01234436, -0.029129028, 0.04928589, 0.054901123, -0.05697632, 0.0026931763, 0.029159546, -0.01965332, 0.06945801, 0.06124878, 0.009727478, -0.056365967, 0.02029419, 0.0037136078, -0.0034656525, -0.006263733, -0.009010315, -0.018447876, -0.0362854, -0.014274597, 0.044006348, -0.0045166016, -0.031280518, -0.055786133, -0.03930664, -0.014312744, 0.004081726, -0.033081055, 0.050201416, 0.045288086, 0.021026611, 0.034851074, -0.004638672, -0.016601562, -0.0034866333, -0.013809204, -0.009262085, -0.048858643, -0.05090332, 0.049743652, -0.06665039, -0.015007019, 0.005443573, 0.024368286, -0.017562866, -0.040496826, 0.037200928, -0.032714844, 0.013885498, -0.04248047, -0.024856567, -0.015716553, 0.028701782, -0.051696777, -0.010635376, 0.018737793, -0.046661377, -0.053833008, -0.008155823, 0.004550934, 0.014862061, -0.012039185, 0.033050537, -0.060699463, 0.015701294, 0.0065612793, -0.005596161, -0.004508972, 0.014587402, -0.026168823, 0.026428223, -0.020431519, 0.005130768, -0.034820557, -0.0072669983, 0.009483337, 0.05105591, -0.026260376, 0.037506104, 0.0033435822, -0.018569946, -0.018493652, -0.029586792, -0.0128479, -0.014633179, 0.018600464, -0.008140564, 0.021865845, -0.009681702, -0.03930664, -0.029388428, -0.06286621, 0.032989502, -0.013877869, 0.019226074, -0.013877869, -0.012748718, -0.019927979, -0.0062675476, -0.037017822, -0.032714844, -0.032989502, 0.0063819885, 0.0112838745, 0.037963867, -0.038635254, 0.007507324, -0.024032593, -0.016830444, 0.013977051, -0.018249512, -0.08294678, -0.02494812, -0.016296387, -0.04159546, 0.021575928, 0.046447754, -0.060150146, 0.005268097, 0.05380249, -0.012626648, 0.0022449493, -0.004295349, -0.015670776, -0.003232956, -0.08569336, 0.015609741, 0.00843811, 0.014572144, 0.04336548, -0.035095215, 0.014572144, 0.008415222, 0.02267456, 0.016189575, 0.08465576, -0.056427002, -0.015327454, -0.040740967, 0.014915466, -0.0690918, 0.00566864, -0.005092621, 0.00032424927, -0.021209717, -0.000936985, -0.0067977905, -0.020812988, 0.017120361, 0.015388489, 0.062316895, 0.061401367, 0.0052108765, 0.026641846, -0.011276245, 0.019943237, -0.02935791, 0.024963379, 0.07373047, 0.003206253, 0.045013428, -0.036865234, 0.024337769, 0.019729614, 0.013191223, 0.012779236, -0.0066947937, 0.029418945, -0.0038528442, -0.035949707, 0.02268982, -0.005722046, 0.0579834, -0.016601562, 0.0022239685, 0.039123535, 0.029205322, 0.0026416779, 0.012268066, 0.00806427, -0.001572609, 0.0074272156, -0.015686035, -0.0034313202, -0.029266357, 0.048980713, -0.011566162, -0.0069465637, -0.039276123, -0.04626465, -0.009140015, 0.041656494, -0.017868042, -0.030960083, 0.02772522, 0.008140564, 0.005794525, 0.045562744, 0.0075035095, 0.013793945, -0.0039482117, -0.034942627, 0.0035552979, -0.05508423, -0.011741638, 0.016952515, 0.03137207, -0.0070266724, 0.044708252, -0.0018167496, 0.0043907166, 0.0046806335, -0.027175903, 0.003698349, -0.047454834, 0.013504028, -0.023910522, 0.010986328, 0.012031555, -0.013504028, 0.025405884, 0.024871826, -0.017852783, -0.00003862381, 0.042938232, 0.045043945, 0.0044898987, 0.0022449493, 0.020843506, -0.041229248, -0.0126953125, 0.048706055, -0.019500732, -0.0046157837, 0.028930664, 0.042144775, -0.032470703, 0.030471802, 0.009597778, 0.007663727, -0.047088623, -0.009544373, -0.03527832, -0.01158905, 0.020996094, -0.00024819374, -0.005039215, -0.026031494, -0.003440857, 0.026153564, -0.051849365, 0.043395996, -0.025802612, 0.040405273, -0.08215332, 0.0072746277, -0.047668457, -0.0073165894, -0.03555298, -0.025558472, 0.0010719299, -0.006198883, -0.0063667297, -0.023223877, 0.05810547, 0.047332764, 0.024856567, 0.06298828, -0.020843506, 0.023544312, 0.0006542206, 0.016159058, 0.013069153, 0.023468018, 0.01940918, -0.0038719177, -0.02684021, -0.002111435, 0.011062622, 0.038146973, 0.06359863, -0.03366089, -0.015808105, -0.02609253, 0.0058174133, -0.041656494, 0.01096344, 0.018814087, -0.07055664, 0.00011509657, 0.010719299, 0.008003235, -0.04220581, 0.015670776, -0.028182983, -0.006515503, 0.00024938583, 0.010879517, 0.032318115, -0.029037476, -0.04876709, 0.028427124, 0.006702423, 0.06726074, 0.044036865, -0.027740479, 0.015083313, 0.0113220215, -0.003036499, -0.030426025, -0.025177002, 0.057250977, 0.010009766, -0.058685303, 0.041229248, 0.043640137, -0.01663208, -0.07373047, -0.027191162, -0.023117065, -0.02217102, 0.024215698, 0.03375244, 0.01966858, -0.06304932, -0.004211426, 0.009223938, 0.011299133, -0.023498535, -0.008491516, 0.021957397, 0.049072266, -0.035217285, 0.016326904, -0.01838684, -0.0049705505, -0.020202637, -0.040222168, 0.009521484, -0.0011997223, 0.022583008, -0.015975952, -0.050720215, 0.010955811, 0.024780273, -0.012245178, 0.0041542053, -0.017456055, 0.010879517, 0.044067383, 0.0284729, -0.00024986267, -0.034057617, -0.013809204, -0.023620605, 0.062408447, 0.03387451, -0.03930664, 0.03161621, 0.0390625, -0.04107666, -0.023651123, -0.02418518, 0.04876709, -0.035491943, -0.0020046234, -0.011878967, -0.064575195, -0.0007882118, 0.04083252, 0.030517578, -0.02394104, 0.0024681091, -0.019485474, -0.012619019, 0.011367798, -0.034362793, -0.017486572, -0.06512451, 0.054016113, 0.02468872, 0.012542725, -0.017364502, 0.021331787, -0.022857666, -0.021728516, -0.00041103363, -0.007293701, -0.016220093, 0.008110046, -0.028396606, 0.0051651, 0.0052757263, -0.045288086, 0.017608643, -0.033691406, 0.00995636, -0.012527466, 0.027175903, 0.033172607, 0.017868042, 0.01398468, 0.017730713, 0.028823853, 0.009941101, -0.02067566, 0.019439697, -0.0020446777, -0.0017089844 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2008.10086v3
Learning Models of Individual Behavior in Chess
Reid McIlroy-Young, Russell Wang, Siddhartha Sen, Jon Kleinberg, Ashton Anderson
cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
AI systems that can capture human-like behavior are becoming increasingly useful in situations where humans may want to learn from these systems, collaborate with them, or engage with them as partners for an extended duration. In order to develop human-oriented AI systems, the problem of predicting human actions -- as opposed to predicting optimal actions -- has received considerable attention. Existing work has focused on capturing human behavior in an aggregate sense, which potentially limits the benefit any particular individual could gain from interaction with these systems. We extend this line of work by developing highly accurate predictive models of individual human behavior in chess. Chess is a rich domain for exploring human-AI interaction because it combines a unique set of properties: AI systems achieved superhuman performance many years ago, and yet humans still interact with them closely, both as opponents and as preparation tools, and there is an enormous corpus of recorded data on individual player games. Starting with Maia, an open-source version of AlphaZero trained on a population of human players, we demonstrate that we can significantly improve prediction accuracy of a particular player's moves by applying a series of fine-tuning methods. Furthermore, our personalized models can be used to perform stylometry -- predicting who made a given set of moves -- indicating that they capture human decision-making at an individual level. Our work demonstrates a way to bring AI systems into better alignment with the behavior of individual people, which could lead to large improvements in human-AI interaction.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2008.10086v3
2022-06-15T21:44:30
2020-08-23T18:24:21
{ "title": [ 0.052825928, 0.012084961, 0.018112183, 0.005252838, -0.01309967, -0.039031982, 0.023223877, -0.046325684, -0.020843506, 0.031341553, -0.044067383, 0.0058250427, -0.0061836243, -0.021514893, -0.019592285, -0.014953613, 0.017974854, 0.0063285828, 0.002910614, -0.019210815, -0.01461792, -0.0112838745, 0.034484863, 0.03768921, 0.032714844, -0.016235352, -0.079956055, -0.00018501282, 0.017791748, -0.01876831, -0.0029716492, 0.0034484863, 0.037231445, 0.010444641, -0.0234375, 0.010147095, -0.020980835, 0.015533447, -0.018630981, -0.005458832, 0.005302429, 0.0011987686, -0.03479004, -0.0066108704, -0.056396484, 0.0026226044, -0.023544312, 0.010795593, -0.03024292, 0.022033691, 0.0059432983, 0.0037765503, 0.020812988, 0.037750244, 0.00712204, -0.013618469, -0.012702942, -0.044006348, 0.03677368, 0.02734375, 0.004776001, -0.041900635, 0.03161621, -0.03677368, -0.047912598, -0.03643799, -0.043182373, 0.018844604, 0.038269043, -0.037200928, -0.007286072, 0.0037956238, 0.0038986206, 0.02835083, -0.050231934, -0.05166626, 0.06100464, 0.0072021484, 0.008285522, -0.021972656, 0.0143966675, -0.03414917, -0.0027637482, -0.013290405, 0.003835678, -0.011703491, 0.014038086, -0.0055656433, -0.030273438, -0.02885437, -0.010223389, 0.03668213, -0.0068969727, -0.0040626526, -0.050750732, -0.013839722, -0.008125305, -0.0062713623, 0.019561768, -0.04714966, -0.04031372, 0.017990112, -0.06652832, 0.0056381226, 0.02079773, 0.0033187866, -0.0033874512, -0.045654297, -0.016616821, 0.019607544, -0.050720215, 0.0076408386, 0.029663086, 0.021896362, 0.0052490234, -0.029129028, -0.033935547, 0.052124023, -0.011505127, 0.058410645, 0.010681152, 0.00007891655, 0.012336731, 0.02798462, -0.00010216236, 0.024337769, -0.027648926, -0.03338623, -0.010932922, 0.006828308, -0.015991211, 0.062927246, -0.040008545, -0.0619812, -0.030334473, 0.008972168, 0.013137817, -0.011222839, -0.04434204, 0.024230957, 0.020965576, -0.022338867, 0.017318726, -0.0007519722, -0.010299683, -0.004814148, 0.038391113, 0.014320374, -0.018951416, -0.023254395, -0.024368286, 0.03741455, -0.040008545, 0.024658203, 0.030258179, 0.011688232, -0.080566406, 0.010528564, 0.07128906, 0.058502197, 0.042419434, 0.004322052, -0.017715454, 0.023635864, 0.017929077, 0.0010700226, -0.0059814453, 0.025619507, 0.0069122314, 0.015960693, 0.009628296, -0.025924683, 0.00712204, -0.020324707, -0.004501343, 0.016937256, -0.026153564, -0.0015687943, 0.019226074, -0.013725281, 0.0096206665, -0.018753052, -0.048583984, 0.052520752, -0.01184082, -0.08416748, -0.01348114, -0.057647705, 0.044067383, 0.019927979, -0.047332764, 0.012481689, -0.06829834, -0.04837036, -0.031951904, 0.042663574, 0.027832031, 0.049072266, 0.010124207, 0.010696411, -0.017990112, -0.011108398, -0.014595032, -0.005897522, 0.005203247, -0.061431885, 0.01008606, -0.0029277802, -0.031311035, 0.05291748, 0.037353516, 0.014472961, -0.016433716, -0.0134887695, -0.007820129, -0.06939697, -0.010429382, -0.030319214, -0.014419556, -0.0099487305, -0.03161621, -0.0030059814, -0.035980225, -0.016357422, -0.01676941, 0.028366089, -0.0027332306, 0.007434845, 0.021072388, 0.042297363, 0.051818848, -0.03982544, 0.040130615, 0.0045394897, -0.012336731, -0.023529053, 0.009063721, -0.07501221, 0.033081055, 0.04574585, -0.0053634644, -0.013298035, 0.0066833496, 0.036071777, 0.025390625, 0.016860962, 0.019165039, 0.0051651, -0.01247406, -0.005630493, 0.059570312, 0.016189575, 0.055908203, 0.026473999, 0.0035152435, 0.07055664, 0.00793457, 0.009483337, -0.040740967, 0.04989624, 0.002210617, 0.043273926, 0.012672424, 0.009056091, -0.022415161, -0.00434494, -0.029174805, -0.0007266998, -0.007183075, 0.016525269, 0.008544922, -0.071899414, 0.015914917, -0.040405273, -0.039154053, 0.0029182434, -0.03314209, 0.045654297, 0.046142578, -0.05407715, -0.0013561249, 0.024887085, 0.034179688, 0.009216309, 0.009376526, 0.05319214, 0.034118652, 0.003993988, -0.036590576, -0.027282715, 0.03463745, 0.027160645, 0.0014781952, 0.00063323975, -0.009216309, -0.005153656, 0.033569336, 0.08880615, -0.04260254, 0.009666443, -0.087646484, -0.01789856, 0.014404297, -0.041931152, -0.008049011, 0.04837036, 0.048461914, -0.0066604614, -0.04498291, 0.0000667572, -0.058013916, -0.033416748, 0.025817871, 0.035461426, -0.013679504, -0.018951416, 0.0048103333, 0.021148682, 0.011672974, 0.015075684, -0.00365448, -0.025131226, -0.02142334, -0.005836487, -0.019500732, 0.010147095, -0.020874023, -0.008895874, -0.0014438629, 0.02583313, 0.019943237, 0.029907227, -0.07373047, -0.00066185, 0.021621704, 0.042266846, -0.007896423, 0.031433105, -0.014160156, -0.017654419, -0.010437012, -0.042938232, 0.011154175, -0.036254883, -0.0022525787, -0.039520264, -0.03225708, -0.009803772, -0.012680054, -0.027252197, 0.03829956, -0.00233078, -0.019165039, 0.014297485, 0.07232666, -0.07525635, -0.030975342, 0.056488037, 0.029586792, 0.000027656555, 0.055603027, 0.03778076, 0.03463745, -0.05947876, -0.037353516, -0.08294678, -0.0018949509, -0.008178711, 0.018295288, 0.043426514, -0.06768799, 0.008804321, -0.03189087, 0.026504517, 0.024139404, 0.030349731, 0.005683899, -0.040222168, -0.00894928, -0.0039367676, 0.027023315, 0.010925293, -0.022003174, 0.008026123, 0.08239746, 0.018478394, 0.013450623, 0.0003068447, 0.050048828, -0.0076179504, -0.01448822, -0.03100586, -0.011177063, -0.00072193146, 0.012741089, -0.017654419, -0.005947113, -0.018341064, -0.093322754, 0.008049011, 0.028503418, 0.004989624, -0.030944824, 0.064575195, -0.06390381, 0.040405273, 0.0033397675, -0.03274536, 0.02809143, 0.028762817, 0.005908966, -0.019485474, 0.036590576, -0.038116455, 0.012763977, -0.02784729, -0.056152344, 0.033081055, -0.05783081, -0.004299164, 0.04147339, -0.0154418945, -0.023895264, -0.01008606, -0.0040245056, 0.03161621, 0.039489746, 0.012619019, 0.022109985, 0.01234436, 0.018081665, -0.01777649, 0.0084991455, -0.008766174, -0.012863159, 0.017501831, -0.032684326, 0.06109619, 0.014503479, -0.02217102, -0.047027588, -0.0115737915, -0.01637268, 0.051208496, -0.0073776245, -0.029159546, -0.03390503, -0.047607422, -0.044433594, -0.018203735, -0.04244995, 0.029220581, -0.006336212, 0.024017334, 0.002910614, 0.050354004, 0.0031375885, 0.02218628, -0.044128418, 0.0093307495, 0.038757324, -0.008934021, -0.054473877, 0.00024533272, -0.0014104843, -0.02909851, 0.04699707, -0.0099487305, -0.0262146, 0.021942139, -0.033050537, 0.01789856, 0.00060272217, -0.022125244, 0.014022827, 0.00058174133, -0.032470703, -0.00076293945, -0.007820129, 0.021514893, -0.0054016113, 0.001452446, -0.0025959015, -0.044067383, -0.0023460388, -0.0063705444, -0.07562256, 0.004245758, 0.011123657, -0.011779785, -0.04067993, -0.0037002563, -0.000010550022, 0.0065612793, -0.03640747, 0.015411377, -0.0138168335, -0.015022278, -0.022354126, -0.079833984, -0.006565094, 0.038208008, -0.015731812, 0.018508911, 0.040374756, -0.036346436, 0.002576828, 0.014945984, 0.02027893, 0.057922363, 0.052001953, 0.0069847107, -0.0077438354, 0.015449524, -0.024047852, 0.036102295, 0.0019721985, 0.0046920776, -0.008033752, 0.021392822, 0.03704834, 0.028442383, -0.009567261, 0.037963867, 0.02670288, -0.015296936, -0.0317688, 0.0014572144, -0.047607422, -0.06896973, 0.010658264, 0.024108887, 0.009246826, 0.04257202, 0.004196167, 0.058624268, -0.019378662, -0.05203247, 0.015426636, 0.03857422, -0.024124146, -0.019348145, -0.017028809, 0.058166504, -0.024963379, -0.027999878, -0.05441284, 0.02027893, 0.018203735, -0.0446167, 0.047058105, 0.03387451, -0.05429077, 0.0027599335, -0.02545166, -0.06463623, -0.05331421, 0.026901245, -0.028930664, 0.0027446747, 0.01272583, 0.00027942657, -0.04043579, 0.02293396, -0.0005502701, 0.006286621, -0.02998352, -0.06842041, -0.011680603, -0.0048828125, -0.07879639, -0.030822754, 0.018936157, 0.0064468384, 0.04119873, -0.03982544, -0.054473877, -0.004295349, 0.06842041, 0.11187744, 0.043823242, 0.0030593872, -0.06567383, -0.01374054, -0.010574341, -0.005947113, -0.003320694, 0.0052871704, 0.00042176247, -0.02168274, 0.0126953125, -0.01600647, -0.0090789795, -0.02558899, 0.007511139, -0.021224976, 0.036956787, -0.0073776245, 0.024856567, 0.030670166, 0.009727478, 0.014472961, 0.008422852, -0.030792236, 0.0071105957, 0.0022468567, 0.06262207, -0.014930725, -0.003648758, 0.037506104, 0.035827637, 0.017944336, -0.010749817, -0.008277893, 0.031082153, -0.000015497208, 0.018310547, 0.01928711, -0.066711426, -0.008758545, -0.012557983, -0.026397705, 0.02494812, -0.08807373, 0.023788452, -0.0050086975, -0.014450073, 0.05206299, 0.0062026978, 0.01727295, 0.05029297, -0.0010089874, -0.05319214, -0.054656982, 0.0072898865, 0.054016113, -0.020950317, -0.01763916, -0.0049552917, 0.020446777, 0.020645142, 0.01928711, 0.009140015, -0.031677246, 0.018112183, -0.017211914, 0.004348755, 0.0102005005, -0.036346436, -0.016540527, 0.028823853, 0.016967773, -0.061920166, 0.03842163, 0.0045280457, -0.018844604, -0.019577026, 0.0038661957, 0.03414917, -0.059906006, 0.018722534, 0.07501221, 0.0030670166, 0.014846802, -0.012924194, -0.00699234, 0.04055786, 0.014404297, 0.003232956, -0.009170532, 0.0104904175, -0.035461426, -0.026489258, -0.002614975, 0.03479004, 0.013595581, -0.0074882507, 0.023162842, 0.0056419373, -0.043029785, 0.0071258545, -0.003200531, 0.017929077, 0.015274048, -0.050476074, 0.033813477, 0.0016040802, -0.018203735, 0.016586304, -0.04119873, -0.01663208, 0.028045654, -0.023162842, -0.006996155, 0.007835388, -0.009094238, -0.014389038, -0.09301758, 0.01448822, 0.008872986, 0.020629883, -0.049224854, 0.048217773, -0.033325195, 0.0053215027, 0.04812622, -0.041290283, 0.040161133, -0.024093628, 0.008903503, 0.04611206, 0.015914917, -0.04257202, -0.0054969788, 0.012634277, -0.029266357, -0.016357422, 0.00894928, -0.0079956055, -0.012832642, 0.00068330765, -0.043670654, -0.016998291, -0.0024585724, 0.014450073, 0.006942749, -0.02911377, 0.025436401, -0.009536743, -0.015525818, 0.014312744, 0.055847168, -0.023071289, 0.009399414, 0.017425537, 0.009849548, 0.030197144, 0.024261475, 0.014762878, 0.022613525, -0.046020508, -0.0011348724, 0.02267456, 0.01322937, -0.024002075, 0.041229248, 0.035186768, 0.009765625, 0.009590149, 0.018508911, 0.076171875, -0.02053833, 0.0044021606, -0.01776123, -0.0074768066, -0.037719727, 0.054901123, 0.0059318542, 0.00065135956, -0.048736572, -0.026550293, -0.027313232, -0.015090942, 0.04711914, -0.036987305, 0.032348633, -0.05239868, -0.047851562, -0.02319336, 0.020568848, -0.008346558, 0.0058403015, -0.022140503, -0.037872314, 0.026229858, 0.045684814, 0.019622803, -0.035491943, -0.0064353943, -0.020614624, 0.020019531, -0.021881104, 0.026138306, 0.0074310303, -0.00069236755, -0.016708374, 0.032409668, -0.010154724, -0.00043916702, 0.004337311, -0.043304443, 0.048034668, 0.01826477, 0.036712646, 0.050354004, 0.03488159, -0.0068244934, 0.00724411, 0.0034236908, -0.021560669, 0.0234375, -0.072265625, 0.022735596, -0.029708862, 0.0016641617, -0.11230469, -0.0005836487, 0.033447266, 0.009399414, 0.01953125, -0.010185242, 0.01939392, -0.010253906, 0.021743774, -0.006729126, 0.040649414, -0.015731812, -0.0008125305, -0.023498535, -0.036621094, 0.047973633, 0.050628662, 0.01902771, -0.014564514, 0.034606934, -0.017425537, 0.027572632, -0.008140564, 0.028640747, -0.03765869, -0.0028438568, -0.017944336, 0.0066490173, -0.005001068, -0.013389587, 0.04373169, 0.047729492, -0.015312195, 0.0031089783, 0.019104004, 0.002796173, -0.037017822, 0.018432617, 0.03817749, -0.057861328, 0.041290283, -0.013053894, -0.030700684, -0.02619934, 0.067871094, 0.025878906, -0.006565094, 0.032073975, 0.045928955, -0.012199402, -0.01108551, 0.052581787, -0.022918701, -0.03744507, -0.015289307, -0.0032157898, 0.008590698, 0.05770874, 0.04159546, 0.0287323, -0.024993896, -0.0055274963, -0.016342163, -0.0009365082, -0.049835205, 0.016830444, -0.034118652, 0.046417236, 0.020629883, -0.034423828, 0.0018377304, 0.025161743, -0.03765869, 0.01838684, -0.032806396, 0.062561035, 0.09112549, 0.07507324, 0.00010532141, -0.0045433044, 0.04937744, -0.039733887, 0.03756714, -0.0022258759, -0.026611328, -0.0082473755, -0.02798462, -0.01876831, 0.026397705, -0.01600647, 0.048309326, -0.022888184, 0.022033691, -0.021026611, -0.025741577, 0.03781128, -0.032073975, -0.017028809, -0.0362854, -0.0574646, 0.019256592, -0.0058631897, -0.023468018, 0.03112793, -0.0061950684, -0.040527344, 0.05343628, 0.009300232, 0.035339355, -0.023712158, -0.040527344, 0.030975342, 0.00094270706, 0.055389404, -0.0072021484, -0.030014038, -0.008033752, 0.005886078, 0.026687622, -0.012771606, -0.049468994, 0.01210022, 0.012840271, -0.020568848, -0.0054359436, -0.009437561, -0.02418518, -0.020248413, -0.014053345, 0.0058517456, -0.025299072, -0.054382324, 0.066101074, 0.01852417, -0.12841797, -0.038848877, -0.020065308, 0.0019683838, 0.009277344, -0.026535034, 0.0262146, 0.009765625, -0.031829834, -0.027770996, -0.010543823, 0.0061035156, 0.0044136047, -0.033416748, 0.00079488754, 0.019226074, 0.06939697, -0.030838013, -0.020309448, 0.00019848347, 0.04928589, -0.0030155182, 0.06311035, -0.003610611, -0.0018949509, -0.007247925, 0.01713562, -0.015686035, -0.006313324, -0.007247925, 0.0042877197, 0.040008545, 0.01789856, -0.044647217, 0.016525269, 0.01184082, -0.023391724, 0.01612854, -0.0075035095, 0.0037765503, 0.015106201, -0.0023040771, 0.027954102, -0.029693604, -0.015090942, -0.017837524, 0.04083252, -0.016494751, 0.003583908, -0.013168335, 0.0068130493, -0.01158905, 0.029205322, -0.027557373, 0.017929077, 0.0008621216, 0.033233643, 0.010696411, 0.037475586, -0.025344849, 0.015144348, 0.0119018555, 0.039031982, 0.026016235, 0.061645508, 0.00868988, 0.013496399, 0.028030396, -0.0770874, -0.040649414, -0.029144287, -0.031433105, 0.039794922, -0.050323486, 0.024383545, -0.02935791, 0.005744934, 0.008476257, 0.011909485, 0.039855957, -0.043121338, -0.009399414, -0.0025501251, 0.04232788, 0.006629944 ], "summary": [ 0.070129395, 0.0077323914, 0.058685303, 0.007472992, -0.027633667, -0.019546509, -0.0059318542, -0.078125, 0.0015029907, 0.03677368, -0.028244019, 0.01776123, 0.0033817291, -0.008346558, -0.012870789, -0.020828247, 0.018081665, 0.007534027, 0.040161133, -0.025222778, 0.0020561218, -0.028289795, 0.061157227, 0.0031204224, 0.06536865, -0.03326416, -0.08337402, 0.03744507, 0.035217285, 0.040039062, 0.014709473, -0.033477783, 0.02293396, 0.011688232, -0.053253174, -0.012680054, 0.00007480383, -0.0031852722, -0.02507019, 0.019607544, 0.009124756, 0.010215759, 0.01713562, -0.036956787, -0.02456665, -0.000045657158, 0.023117065, -0.006576538, 0.032196045, -0.045318604, 0.013549805, 0.033569336, 0.024597168, -0.033966064, -0.030044556, -0.0020008087, -0.019500732, -0.052215576, 0.02279663, 0.05645752, 0.018005371, -0.0463562, 0.017822266, -0.051849365, -0.03768921, -0.002960205, -0.027023315, -0.015129089, 0.05065918, -0.022567749, -0.0046195984, -0.0025024414, -0.018753052, 0.010643005, -0.0259552, -0.013671875, 0.04333496, -0.007434845, -0.015838623, 0.039367676, 0.0036907196, -0.037719727, 0.01802063, -0.033355713, -0.00111866, -0.026260376, -0.0007200241, 0.0008368492, -0.025634766, 0.01285553, -0.03753662, -0.00031876564, -0.015090942, 0.030426025, -0.009513855, 0.0020503998, -0.005329132, -0.047302246, 0.014923096, -0.008277893, 0.0012264252, -0.025665283, -0.0070991516, 0.0023784637, 0.017303467, 0.068847656, 0.008110046, -0.06500244, -0.020828247, -0.028686523, -0.013084412, -0.034332275, 0.038238525, 0.006000519, 0.00088739395, 0.0052108765, 0.0066223145, 0.070617676, -0.018295288, 0.09411621, 0.007987976, 0.030899048, -0.024520874, 0.06414795, -0.0138168335, 0.02684021, 0.015266418, -0.045288086, 0.0055732727, 0.0076789856, -0.029907227, 0.027908325, 0.039520264, 0.003332138, -0.014198303, -0.013442993, 0.054138184, -0.0018749237, -0.012138367, 0.023483276, 0.028457642, -0.026107788, -0.015548706, 0.023422241, -0.022033691, -0.0069465637, 0.013381958, 0.011009216, -0.008087158, 0.014022827, -0.0041999817, -0.016098022, -0.02885437, 0.021942139, 0.025482178, 0.0011634827, -0.055847168, 0.017578125, 0.06072998, 0.048431396, 0.033111572, 0.017410278, 0.009811401, 0.048339844, 0.027908325, -0.020843506, 0.0017185211, 0.005027771, 0.009880066, -0.056549072, 0.036621094, -0.0038890839, 0.036376953, -0.0031032562, 0.0020523071, -0.003314972, -0.020614624, -0.006137848, 0.006095886, 0.0069389343, 0.0112838745, -0.022491455, -0.032104492, 0.039245605, 0.009773254, -0.0073051453, -0.02923584, -0.044281006, 0.03274536, -0.009437561, -0.039367676, 0.02734375, -0.038879395, -0.03640747, -0.00605011, 0.016937256, 0.019607544, 0.036956787, -0.0039520264, 0.0073928833, 0.058898926, -0.048217773, 0.0024032593, -0.04071045, -0.0836792, -0.04083252, -0.0368042, -0.0070266724, -0.0184021, 0.022247314, 0.0126953125, -0.020187378, -0.014305115, 0.021453857, 0.005619049, -0.028549194, -0.02217102, -0.013420105, -0.007865906, 0.011398315, -0.032562256, 0.0011510849, -0.040008545, -0.026016235, -0.05014038, 0.015930176, -0.013763428, 0.033477783, 0.009231567, 0.018508911, 0.08074951, -0.025131226, 0.05178833, 0.006275177, -0.01259613, -0.004337311, 0.006668091, -0.11279297, 0.010108948, 0.046447754, 0.0031719208, -0.0063934326, -0.02015686, 0.021911621, -0.02986145, 0.012748718, 0.018539429, 0.0038394928, 0.011260986, 0.054260254, -0.0054855347, -0.0010213852, 0.024749756, -0.009552002, -0.02407837, 0.0473938, -0.017486572, -0.011260986, -0.016357422, 0.017349243, 0.003944397, 0.008674622, 0.0047683716, 0.0121154785, -0.041412354, 0.01537323, -0.026733398, -0.009483337, 0.00028300285, 0.005832672, 0.0036087036, -0.072387695, -0.009628296, -0.047454834, -0.035827637, -0.030014038, -0.036224365, 0.04815674, 0.03640747, -0.049224854, 0.035247803, 0.012626648, -0.012924194, -0.007789612, 0.057525635, 0.014144897, -0.010375977, 0.038208008, 0.0042877197, 0.036010742, 0.018417358, 0.05657959, 0.0104599, 0.009773254, 0.027053833, 0.011634827, -0.027404785, 0.038146973, -0.0074310303, -0.026855469, -0.041015625, 0.014472961, 0.0022888184, -0.03262329, 0.005672455, 0.020111084, 0.034729004, 0.0017280579, -0.0056991577, -0.006778717, -0.028442383, -0.02104187, 0.019302368, 0.0848999, -0.02293396, -0.02418518, -0.004890442, 0.050628662, 0.011955261, 0.031951904, 0.060028076, -0.08666992, -0.010566711, -0.013763428, -0.05606079, -0.0025863647, 0.024520874, -0.010101318, 0.0021400452, -0.007926941, -0.0064697266, 0.009033203, -0.01474762, 0.07281494, -0.0047912598, 0.0028743744, 0.0021190643, 0.061523438, 0.00484848, -0.029129028, -0.01247406, -0.017349243, -0.011642456, 0.0013532639, -0.025619507, -0.021835327, -0.0069847107, -0.010612488, -0.017623901, -0.011123657, 0.020507812, -0.002204895, -0.005115509, 0.056243896, 0.029708862, -0.018585205, -0.00894928, 0.072387695, 0.005203247, -0.008392334, 0.08068848, 0.03741455, 0.046813965, -0.09686279, -0.0758667, -0.043121338, 0.026428223, -0.04232788, 0.03778076, 0.040618896, -0.06298828, 0.061767578, -0.046081543, 0.0061798096, 0.016433716, 0.049560547, 0.054473877, -0.008399963, 0.042633057, 0.049743652, 0.032928467, 0.018875122, 0.0075187683, -0.0002373457, 0.077697754, 0.007095337, 0.0042915344, 0.02104187, 0.029006958, 0.0032787323, -0.027496338, -0.039123535, 0.01096344, 0.0011825562, 0.027267456, -0.009483337, -0.016189575, 0.06317139, -0.101379395, -0.03213501, -0.036193848, 0.044067383, 0.009590149, 0.028182983, -0.03491211, 0.09655762, -0.011070251, -0.017059326, 0.018692017, 0.02192688, 0.017456055, -0.028045654, 0.004638672, -0.005241394, 0.010520935, -0.011497498, -0.020202637, 0.0056915283, -0.023422241, -0.000916481, 0.0016546249, 0.031463623, 0.00818634, 0.02229309, 0.00014162064, 0.033477783, 0.013076782, -0.0012283325, 0.014472961, 0.0541687, 0.029800415, -0.0038414001, 0.022079468, 0.03186035, -0.045166016, 0.016723633, -0.01550293, -0.02418518, 0.034576416, -0.076660156, -0.028579712, -0.0209198, -0.048553467, 0.0015821457, -0.028900146, -0.0050735474, -0.016448975, -0.044555664, -0.055511475, -0.061767578, -0.0138168335, 0.01739502, 0.03363037, 0.04232788, 0.030807495, 0.05331421, 0.022369385, 0.017425537, -0.0082473755, 0.023590088, 0.04989624, 0.017150879, -0.03265381, -0.021194458, 0.016067505, -0.02192688, 0.015556335, -0.006866455, -0.02722168, 0.017120361, -0.013435364, 0.0012512207, -0.007965088, -0.04510498, 0.004562378, -0.044555664, 0.029449463, -0.02494812, 0.054595947, -0.013519287, -0.026855469, 0.016357422, -0.012275696, -0.078186035, -0.009552002, -0.016464233, -0.07849121, -0.053588867, -0.02458191, 0.007045746, -0.048828125, 0.03829956, 0.006134033, 0.0012149811, -0.011047363, 0.0047798157, -0.01474762, 0.07409668, -0.0013113022, -0.046447754, -0.00806427, -0.018859863, 0.008132935, -0.0010843277, 0.030700684, 0.006462097, 0.018814087, 0.022827148, -0.019439697, 0.00023305416, 0.044891357, -0.017456055, -0.006198883, 0.0059547424, -0.016540527, 0.0066223145, -0.0016260147, -0.016067505, -0.016830444, 0.002456665, 0.03866577, 0.062286377, -0.020233154, 0.0012903214, 0.024627686, -0.006385803, -0.014808655, 0.019104004, -0.04034424, -0.06738281, 0.02684021, 0.054901123, 0.030532837, 0.04348755, -0.020950317, 0.011436462, -0.03289795, -0.05303955, 0.029083252, 0.09899902, -0.04812622, -0.040161133, 0.014411926, 0.09741211, -0.041503906, 0.0022144318, -0.0541687, 0.005554199, 0.05041504, -0.039031982, 0.02583313, 0.01108551, -0.030807495, -0.021942139, -0.004638672, -0.060913086, -0.0289917, 0.0137786865, -0.00041270256, 0.022369385, -0.009635925, -0.009986877, -0.01033783, 0.013885498, 0.0005645752, 0.027313232, -0.035583496, -0.032714844, -0.023132324, -0.036834717, 0.0013132095, -0.0003414154, 0.061706543, 0.004169464, 0.014129639, -0.028823853, -0.02267456, -0.006511688, 0.05328369, 0.08984375, -0.0035057068, 0.02720642, -0.035736084, -0.01739502, -0.062194824, 0.025131226, -0.0039634705, -0.016479492, -0.041259766, -0.016281128, 0.026275635, 0.0135650635, -0.019989014, -0.0060272217, 0.01473999, 0.0026435852, 0.035614014, -0.032196045, 0.005592346, 0.0056610107, -0.0037975311, 0.0010566711, 0.015083313, -0.015602112, -0.013786316, -0.0045776367, -0.00066041946, -0.014701843, -0.004081726, 0.0030708313, 0.0059814453, -0.014884949, 0.018798828, 0.0068244934, 0.03152466, -0.011268616, 0.030075073, -0.008682251, -0.042755127, -0.018951416, 0.0028953552, 0.005039215, 0.016860962, -0.006439209, 0.029678345, 0.0039043427, -0.011177063, 0.022781372, -0.01133728, 0.013679504, 0.0030002594, -0.00027132034, -0.036590576, -0.04699707, 0.012290955, 0.043518066, 0.0013494492, -0.018707275, -0.02532959, 0.0038928986, 0.009719849, 0.011100769, -0.040649414, -0.029327393, 0.05709839, -0.0009255409, -0.00035715103, 0.009757996, 0.003238678, -0.083984375, 0.038330078, -0.0010604858, -0.03552246, 0.039001465, 0.041229248, -0.017562866, 0.008354187, -0.005016327, 0.010856628, -0.042816162, -0.045776367, -0.011405945, -0.05947876, 0.0033569336, 0.026412964, -0.024856567, -0.00724411, 0.020904541, -0.019836426, -0.017990112, -0.02633667, -0.013542175, -0.0008111, -0.017410278, 0.02734375, 0.053863525, -0.057434082, 0.03753662, -0.010360718, 0.0054969788, 0.0022354126, -0.0061035156, 0.015991211, -0.0146102905, -0.017608643, 0.029754639, 0.0076026917, -0.0034046173, 0.024154663, -0.022735596, -0.016616821, -0.016693115, 0.021484375, -0.056274414, -0.006175995, 0.018493652, -0.017578125, -0.08892822, -0.048828125, -0.0067214966, -0.010269165, -0.032409668, 0.08300781, 0.0020713806, -0.035339355, 0.054779053, -0.011016846, 0.04574585, -0.021881104, 0.0016345978, 0.01876831, 0.00044560432, 0.0067100525, 0.0018339157, 0.01399231, -0.009941101, -0.0061416626, -0.005836487, -0.038879395, 0.030075073, 0.0004119873, -0.026062012, -0.0016736984, 0.00026011467, 0.025283813, -0.054229736, -0.012718201, -0.0007185936, -0.016601562, -0.041137695, 0.018814087, 0.06173706, -0.023834229, -0.010475159, 0.0037441254, -0.004055023, 0.036132812, 0.010536194, 0.019729614, 0.04135132, -0.06378174, 0.02003479, 0.010406494, 0.019699097, -0.013298035, -0.028198242, 0.0017681122, -0.031585693, 0.008850098, -0.021499634, 0.07556152, -0.0051498413, 0.03111267, 0.020431519, 0.033996582, -0.028015137, -0.016220093, 0.033996582, 0.04244995, -0.019180298, -0.0073242188, 0.0026741028, -0.014556885, 0.047180176, 0.0019426346, 0.08001709, -0.07598877, -0.093322754, 0.0068893433, 0.010597229, 0.037322998, -0.05001831, -0.003200531, -0.005672455, 0.028686523, 0.074523926, -0.02810669, 0.042419434, 0.0033626556, -0.035858154, -0.010818481, 0.017501831, 0.07476807, 0.020584106, 0.022018433, 0.011192322, 0.0062217712, -0.01626587, 0.026504517, -0.012138367, -0.027740479, 0.010635376, 0.010093689, -0.022079468, -0.0132751465, -0.008872986, 0.02633667, -0.003168106, -0.01121521, -0.019866943, 0.0231781, -0.0035686493, 0.0048675537, -0.0005540848, -0.0209198, -0.005706787, 0.040863037, 0.024093628, -0.0012254715, 0.040405273, -0.0014257431, 0.035705566, 0.038269043, -0.032562256, -0.021942139, 0.0029945374, 0.026901245, 0.008613586, -0.0043678284, -0.029373169, 0.015144348, 0.049438477, 0.02973938, -0.01776123, 0.0413208, -0.011138916, 0.0026245117, -0.0029449463, 0.0030021667, -0.072631836, 0.011833191, -0.03062439, 0.019195557, 0.001039505, 0.033355713, 0.019226074, 0.015701294, 0.021987915, 0.0074005127, 0.0054130554, -0.0038223267, 0.003921509, 0.0031852722, 0.009162903, 0.0069236755, 0.023895264, 0.0014867783, -0.03353882, 0.017532349, 0.025543213, 0.052734375, -0.03857422, 0.009101868, 0.040283203, -0.0018453598, -0.047821045, 0.005630493, -0.05267334, -0.025527954, -0.010482788, -0.027740479, 0.00078487396, -0.024795532, 0.0057907104, 0.01637268, -0.046661377, 0.02053833, -0.017929077, 0.00091028214, -0.029296875, 0.032714844, -0.0619812, 0.040252686, -0.0061950684, -0.0256958, 0.037719727, 0.00006318092, -0.02116394, 0.0118255615, 0.028060913, 0.04144287, 0.08013916, 0.06536865, -0.012825012, 0.017807007, 0.033203125, -0.025436401, 0.06921387, -0.013534546, -0.011146545, -0.040985107, 0.014846802, 0.042663574, -0.0027713776, 0.042144775, 0.00073575974, -0.02633667, -0.021850586, -0.000936985, -0.011688232, -0.0008239746, 0.010635376, -0.028121948, -0.042419434, -0.01637268, 0.018005371, 0.046813965, -0.015174866, 0.041229248, -0.010971069, -0.050048828, 0.037200928, -0.0154800415, 0.013923645, 0.0013599396, -0.01725769, 0.0003437996, -0.0039482117, 0.040771484, 0.022460938, -0.02142334, -0.034057617, 0.057495117, 0.0059509277, -0.030014038, -0.022781372, 0.0680542, 0.0053901672, -0.044952393, 0.03665161, 0.03286743, 0.009307861, 0.0013217926, -0.038024902, 0.004875183, -0.015472412, -0.011360168, 0.061706543, 0.030319214, -0.11804199, -0.025817871, -0.01373291, 0.0018482208, -0.030792236, -0.0151901245, 0.04437256, 0.025924683, -0.03277588, -0.014778137, -0.02949524, -0.021743774, 0.015716553, -0.050872803, 0.02218628, -0.0008072853, 0.024658203, -0.011222839, 0.044525146, 0.024734497, 0.034851074, 0.02609253, 0.0104522705, -0.024734497, 0.0038661957, 0.021057129, 0.045043945, 0.018127441, -0.025421143, -0.0012741089, 0.013175964, 0.04598999, 0.007549286, -0.03149414, 0.008384705, 0.009979248, -0.037597656, -0.012954712, 0.0028762817, 0.027786255, -0.0029621124, -0.014160156, 0.0023975372, -0.062316895, -0.008773804, -0.0013904572, 0.04837036, -0.052001953, -0.05001831, 0.0035095215, 0.006210327, -0.017440796, -0.02999878, -0.0064735413, 0.014732361, -0.029418945, -0.0070724487, 0.008110046, -0.01399231, -0.006385803, -0.005306244, 0.02029419, 0.025238037, 0.00365448, 0.057006836, 0.038238525, -0.018096924, -0.0011377335, -0.101257324, -0.0039100647, -0.090148926, -0.034484863, 0.026870728, 0.006881714, -0.008010864, 0.003894806, 0.022659302, 0.020385742, 0.008781433, 0.030639648, -0.008422852, 0.013717651, 0.016601562, -0.00046372414, 0.012939453 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2109.00103v1
Automatic non-invasive Cough Detection based on Accelerometer and Audio Signals
Madhurananda Pahar, Igor Miranda, Andreas Diacon, Thomas Niesler
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS
We present an automatic non-invasive way of detecting cough events based on both accelerometer and audio signals. The acceleration signals are captured by a smartphone firmly attached to the patient's bed, using its integrated accelerometer. The audio signals are captured simultaneously by the same smartphone using an external microphone. We have compiled a manually-annotated dataset containing such simultaneously-captured acceleration and audio signals for approximately 6000 cough and 68000 non-cough events from 14 adult male patients in a tuberculosis clinic. LR, SVM and MLP are evaluated as baseline classifiers and compared with deep architectures such as CNN, LSTM, and Resnet50 using a leave-one-out cross-validation scheme. We find that the studied classifiers can use either acceleration or audio signals to distinguish between coughing and other activities including sneezing, throat-clearing, and movement on the bed with high accuracy. However, in all cases, the deep neural networks outperform the shallow classifiers by a clear margin and the Resnet50 offers the best performance by achieving an AUC exceeding 0.98 and 0.99 for acceleration and audio signals respectively. While audio-based classification consistently offers a better performance than acceleration-based classification, we observe that the difference is very small for the best systems. Since the acceleration signal requires less processing power, and since the need to record audio is sidestepped and thus privacy is inherently secured, and since the recording device is attached to the bed and not worn, an accelerometer-based highly accurate non-invasive cough detector may represent a more convenient and readily accepted method in long-term cough monitoring.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2109.00103v1
2021-08-31T22:44:56
2021-08-31T22:44:56
{ "title": [ -0.0026569366, 0.010475159, -0.031829834, -0.04647827, 0.014045715, -0.0018405914, -0.017501831, -0.037078857, -0.019805908, 0.050109863, -0.024139404, 0.0072784424, 0.0048179626, -0.015701294, -0.04397583, -0.01777649, -0.008178711, 0.00012278557, -0.033325195, -0.032928467, 0.013206482, -0.050933838, 0.028747559, 0.040863037, -0.027313232, 0.019836426, -0.0317688, 0.0016918182, -0.03781128, -0.03387451, -0.01940918, 0.017532349, 0.054901123, 0.0446167, -0.08288574, 0.030960083, -0.09051514, 0.04336548, -0.027252197, 0.023086548, 0.029403687, -0.016952515, -0.0061798096, -0.01928711, -0.01399231, 0.029251099, -0.03543091, -0.014877319, -0.030654907, 0.022857666, 0.023834229, 0.017349243, 0.010971069, 0.0087890625, 0.016693115, -0.028457642, -0.024154663, 0.035858154, 0.027938843, 0.019165039, -0.001083374, -0.0048942566, 0.0016841888, 0.0051078796, -0.030548096, -0.016235352, -0.048675537, 0.024810791, 0.054626465, -0.017196655, -0.010414124, 0.015197754, 0.0006260872, 0.018814087, -0.049865723, -0.00932312, 0.05682373, 0.006336212, 0.03286743, -0.013847351, 0.0062828064, -0.0033874512, 0.040893555, -0.022033691, 0.04650879, -0.020431519, -0.0068473816, -0.005115509, -0.035827637, -0.047821045, -0.01423645, -0.016860962, -0.037322998, 0.003704071, -0.0044555664, -0.029876709, 0.00982666, 0.033294678, -0.008895874, -0.025894165, -0.010551453, 0.0033054352, -0.03756714, -0.017593384, 0.01121521, 0.039733887, -0.002855301, -0.043701172, -0.009971619, 0.001001358, -0.033294678, 0.0025558472, 0.0029621124, -0.014595032, -0.03253174, -0.0040893555, -0.0025577545, -0.043914795, 0.024627686, -0.0395813, -0.008018494, -0.032958984, 0.036193848, 0.0026607513, 0.017959595, 0.009353638, -0.03704834, -0.021438599, -0.025512695, 0.04309082, 0.020126343, 0.021087646, -0.10748291, -0.05682373, -0.062805176, 0.025100708, 0.019363403, -0.017410278, -0.015052795, 0.0030994415, 0.020950317, -0.026565552, -0.010772705, 0.02508545, 0.01550293, -0.007888794, 0.044311523, -0.0025901794, -0.038879395, -0.013130188, -0.027786255, 0.02519226, 0.0357666, -0.000015437603, -0.07067871, 0.016952515, -0.113342285, -0.0030555725, -0.0067443848, 0.0033302307, 0.021270752, -0.0115737915, -0.027557373, 0.025299072, 0.051818848, 0.0032138824, -0.0043182373, 0.035888672, 0.020965576, 0.0057296753, 0.03753662, 0.034942627, 0.042053223, -0.016601562, -0.0022907257, -0.027679443, 0.020523071, 0.033355713, 0.035095215, -0.052856445, -0.011474609, -0.016418457, 0.041900635, 0.016433716, -0.07244873, -0.024810791, 0.005882263, 0.024108887, 0.051879883, 0.016815186, -0.03793335, 0.017547607, -0.02619934, -0.013656616, -0.016586304, -0.049987793, 0.013130188, -0.011077881, -0.011878967, 0.018234253, -0.030517578, 0.016113281, -0.01864624, 0.01902771, 0.020217896, -0.03338623, 0.005168915, 0.022872925, 0.03527832, 0.060028076, 0.021118164, 0.010360718, -0.028366089, 0.0032367706, -0.015068054, -0.049438477, 0.028656006, 0.019561768, -0.032043457, 0.009757996, -0.073791504, -0.038238525, -0.04135132, 0.02558899, 0.008888245, -0.024047852, 0.010154724, -0.02935791, 0.029129028, 0.010047913, 0.061309814, -0.02268982, -0.007419586, -0.014984131, -0.004459381, -0.014793396, -0.027389526, -0.0064201355, 0.029327393, 0.004535675, 0.0018959045, -0.01751709, 0.0050315857, 0.051452637, 0.008277893, -0.020614624, 0.02218628, 0.01260376, 0.009597778, 0.007797241, 0.02104187, 0.0007991791, 0.046905518, 0.0036506653, -0.03881836, 0.066467285, 0.0053482056, 0.01838684, -0.061309814, 0.013389587, 0.011779785, -0.007835388, -0.024551392, -0.008071899, -0.026992798, 0.00630188, -0.0058555603, 0.0061187744, 0.003955841, 0.023666382, 0.013168335, -0.034240723, 0.009414673, 0.034301758, -0.0033950806, -0.015716553, 0.007698059, -0.0017280579, 0.008903503, -0.019058228, -0.020324707, 0.014007568, 0.01725769, -0.010017395, -0.0029258728, -0.021713257, 0.017089844, -0.001241684, -0.013053894, -0.028244019, 0.020599365, 0.04046631, -0.0031089783, 0.008338928, 0.018707275, 0.0023040771, 0.00085544586, 0.07122803, -0.029022217, 0.022827148, -0.09197998, 0.0022583008, 0.013549805, -0.019058228, -0.0049934387, 0.00095129013, -0.0073165894, 0.047027588, -0.0028820038, -0.020812988, 0.002248764, 0.08288574, 0.016937256, -0.054473877, -0.0184021, -0.03390503, -0.023590088, -0.038757324, -0.072631836, -0.023147583, 0.02204895, -0.0390625, -0.015075684, -0.020568848, -0.006187439, -0.005065918, -0.014717102, -0.011856079, -0.004940033, 0.015274048, 0.07287598, 0.04321289, -0.018218994, 0.041259766, 0.023910522, 0.0055732727, -0.004875183, -0.004714966, -0.010040283, -0.00065135956, 0.007411957, 0.013793945, -0.00024461746, -0.042419434, 0.0018558502, -0.011894226, 0.0082092285, 0.01928711, -0.0715332, -0.012374878, 0.027252197, -0.048736572, -0.02456665, -0.040496826, 0.041015625, 0.02305603, -0.015472412, -0.010818481, 0.04446411, -0.031036377, 0.07476807, 0.016616821, 0.0317688, -0.010108948, -0.020935059, -0.07318115, 0.0051612854, -0.02230835, 0.013336182, 0.05493164, -0.07891846, -0.0049858093, -0.02684021, 0.0021896362, 0.015174866, 0.023849487, -0.0435791, -0.053649902, -0.029830933, -0.05606079, -0.015686035, -0.029388428, 0.0052833557, -0.002571106, 0.11279297, 0.018707275, 0.024429321, -0.015914917, 0.096191406, -0.010757446, 0.0041236877, -0.030670166, -0.064941406, 0.012588501, 0.027862549, 0.013580322, 0.021591187, -0.018844604, -0.103881836, -0.01083374, 0.045074463, -0.011184692, -0.036254883, 0.045440674, -0.04257202, 0.02293396, 0.041992188, -0.019195557, 0.022842407, 0.074035645, -0.0015068054, 0.0335083, 0.025299072, 0.0047836304, 0.01977539, -0.020050049, -0.051086426, 0.035614014, -0.021499634, -0.065979004, -0.004501343, -0.023239136, -0.01826477, -0.012084961, -0.014472961, 0.040161133, 0.03262329, 0.021026611, 0.008277893, -0.036590576, 0.0046463013, -0.041656494, 0.00070667267, -0.033691406, 0.002002716, 0.01701355, -0.034240723, 0.057525635, -0.026275635, 0.012374878, -0.03656006, -0.008918762, 0.040161133, 0.053497314, 0.039855957, -0.03366089, -0.018081665, -0.006187439, -0.038726807, 0.009010315, -0.008605957, -0.007873535, -0.045654297, 0.011291504, -0.009338379, 0.044403076, -0.0032901764, -0.00070142746, -0.0211792, -0.025619507, 0.013977051, -0.004760742, -0.07928467, -0.01979065, -0.017196655, -0.0040512085, 0.020080566, -0.0016384125, -0.013465881, -0.017211914, -0.017486572, 0.044769287, -0.008979797, -0.030075073, 0.009056091, 0.01878357, -0.02104187, -0.031188965, 0.01927185, 0.009239197, -0.022567749, 0.029830933, -0.04296875, -0.058929443, -0.026473999, 0.0060539246, -0.06488037, -0.031982422, 0.022140503, -0.046325684, -0.048553467, -0.036956787, 0.010696411, -0.0050964355, -0.017364502, 0.014884949, 0.008934021, -0.08746338, -0.027313232, -0.075805664, -0.05529785, 0.0793457, 0.010047913, 0.044708252, 0.001868248, -0.00070858, 0.011131287, -0.009086609, 0.023971558, -0.014144897, 0.04208374, -0.010414124, -0.033599854, 0.0423584, -0.023071289, -0.007297516, 0.039398193, 0.029312134, -0.0017547607, -0.0066375732, 0.009613037, 0.013343811, 0.01876831, 0.054992676, -0.0033740997, -0.02961731, -0.022964478, -0.017929077, -0.016403198, -0.013031006, -0.010803223, -0.008369446, 0.000053465366, 0.006931305, 0.038024902, 0.044067383, -0.0072288513, 0.009307861, 0.02609253, -0.02684021, -0.021728516, -0.018859863, 0.024795532, 0.017242432, -0.0029067993, 0.013671875, -0.041229248, 0.027145386, 0.011383057, -0.025360107, 0.005882263, 0.009773254, -0.03668213, -0.017501831, -0.059509277, -0.07336426, -0.06225586, 0.029769897, 0.00043272972, -0.0027637482, 0.022766113, 0.024871826, -0.0602417, 0.008842468, 0.06585693, -0.021850586, 0.00945282, -0.05819702, 0.00856781, -0.014144897, -0.086242676, -0.04260254, -0.06542969, -0.028884888, 0.034820557, 0.007545471, -0.031311035, 0.007434845, 0.016220093, 0.041381836, 0.045440674, -0.04324341, -0.07556152, -0.027450562, -0.03564453, -0.0002772808, 0.029815674, 0.019119263, -0.00020241737, -0.012207031, 0.022064209, -0.019927979, 0.012825012, 0.014137268, 0.007698059, -0.03781128, 0.013725281, -0.033935547, 0.060272217, 0.0020046234, -0.0012655258, 0.004852295, 0.009399414, -0.040527344, -0.0024738312, 0.013336182, 0.035125732, -0.030548096, 0.0048599243, 0.03555298, 0.009460449, 0.013511658, -0.013786316, 0.0104904175, 0.011955261, -0.0010204315, -0.014831543, 0.035369873, -0.023788452, -0.047180176, -0.015014648, -0.003414154, 0.027145386, -0.055908203, 0.043151855, -0.0155181885, 0.007472992, 0.026351929, -0.0043945312, -0.009864807, -0.027160645, 0.007659912, -0.060699463, 0.0062332153, 0.026321411, 0.00027418137, -0.041015625, 0.016952515, -0.0044288635, 0.006111145, 0.015510559, 0.028686523, 0.00056123734, 0.039367676, -0.011138916, 0.00819397, 0.014053345, -0.037963867, -0.014839172, 0.00894928, 0.004673004, -0.005092621, -0.07019043, 0.0027427673, -0.049041748, -0.018508911, -0.0022850037, 0.02507019, -0.0035324097, -0.064697266, 0.022720337, 0.037902832, 0.028839111, -0.0073623657, -0.027435303, 0.026031494, 0.035064697, 0.032928467, 0.022705078, -0.0026683807, 0.03491211, -0.04876709, 0.007381439, 0.0067253113, 0.026290894, -0.020599365, 0.039154053, 0.0014123917, 0.0020942688, -0.0524292, 0.0284729, 0.03439331, 0.01991272, -0.0087509155, -0.035369873, 0.017959595, -0.006084442, -0.027191162, 0.019897461, -0.017227173, -0.017410278, 0.0049057007, -0.007270813, -0.013175964, 0.007171631, 0.020599365, -0.021972656, -0.053527832, 0.025863647, -0.03564453, -0.012969971, 0.01020813, 0.022399902, -0.0028648376, 0.018203735, 0.02999878, -0.072387695, 0.01725769, -0.016159058, 0.014160156, 0.050842285, 0.015930176, -0.04034424, -0.012756348, 0.029754639, -0.03881836, -0.01235199, 0.04925537, 0.022735596, -0.06048584, -0.019927979, -0.05633545, -0.015411377, 0.0032215118, 0.008987427, 0.017852783, -0.021652222, 0.029159546, 0.0079422, 0.027938843, -0.0028095245, -0.0023288727, 0.021484375, -0.003610611, 0.008705139, -0.02909851, 0.022827148, -0.008361816, 0.017562866, 0.006149292, -0.046020508, 0.009407043, 0.019515991, 0.0138168335, -0.02104187, -0.00894928, 0.03982544, -0.0032958984, -0.015220642, -0.0030155182, 0.06518555, -0.055511475, -0.026428223, -0.0066947937, 0.009803772, -0.01576233, 0.05368042, -0.009025574, -0.0075149536, -0.034698486, -0.062408447, -0.039916992, 0.010322571, 0.049926758, 0.028198242, 0.046142578, -0.0463562, 0.016601562, -0.03286743, -0.0019483566, -0.007751465, 0.019165039, 0.0096206665, 0.033477783, -0.03604126, -0.0021743774, 0.013298035, -0.037353516, 0.018615723, -0.016021729, 0.0055732727, -0.019317627, 0.011779785, 0.016021729, -0.047821045, -0.023025513, 0.029907227, 0.039978027, -0.010498047, 0.08807373, -0.050323486, 0.033447266, 0.015975952, 0.05355835, 0.052947998, 0.007797241, -0.0072517395, 0.00554657, -0.028442383, -0.05368042, -0.023773193, -0.050994873, -0.021469116, -0.050842285, -0.001540184, -0.057250977, 0.024108887, -0.018630981, 0.038360596, -0.008850098, 0.018829346, 0.017868042, -0.016677856, 0.04434204, -0.02670288, 0.07116699, -0.009773254, -0.007835388, -0.0006198883, 0.028045654, 0.017730713, 0.02810669, -0.005630493, 0.037017822, -0.0027675629, 0.0010719299, -0.031188965, -0.0018634796, 0.055999756, -0.025863647, -0.019577026, 0.00025629997, 0.062408447, 0.0047798157, 0.039978027, 0.064331055, 0.067993164, -0.021026611, -0.020233154, 0.013427734, 0.01838684, 0.0036754608, -0.0009741783, 0.06085205, -0.054138184, 0.039794922, -0.011314392, -0.048583984, -0.025024414, 0.05834961, -0.011955261, -0.059143066, 0.0004825592, 0.009651184, 0.0066719055, 0.0062942505, 0.015525818, -0.026779175, -0.01058197, 0.019821167, 0.032470703, -0.018463135, -0.024154663, -0.00001680851, 0.04385376, -0.021194458, 0.019500732, -0.00548172, 0.017959595, -0.0435791, 0.014846802, -0.020492554, 0.023620605, -0.037384033, -0.051605225, -0.0052719116, 0.00056552887, -0.032806396, -0.045410156, 0.1161499, 0.023498535, -0.010124207, 0.04067993, 0.020324707, -0.025238037, -0.047698975, -0.01234436, 0.020050049, 0.012046814, -0.019836426, 0.0069618225, -0.03894043, -0.03277588, 0.009819031, -0.01878357, 0.05718994, -0.07171631, -0.005344391, -0.048095703, 0.048583984, -0.019577026, -0.045288086, -0.023147583, -0.036987305, 0.02986145, -0.035614014, -0.031433105, -0.033050537, -0.013870239, -0.0058937073, 0.04525757, 0.024276733, -0.0104522705, -0.026535034, -0.018432617, -0.020477295, -0.0016870499, -0.024856567, 0.037902832, 0.004562378, -0.010604858, -0.024459839, -0.009300232, 0.0019931793, 0.011253357, -0.011497498, 0.00067710876, -0.048583984, -0.037139893, 0.0056495667, 0.002670288, -0.027526855, -0.03390503, -0.0019407272, -0.010345459, -0.026611328, -0.0026302338, 0.026687622, -0.029678345, -0.085998535, -0.014625549, -0.046966553, 0.032836914, 0.031951904, -0.013023376, -0.007534027, 0.03289795, -0.03074646, -0.042816162, -0.0090408325, 0.02960205, -0.023223877, -0.036499023, -0.0023765564, 0.02696228, 0.013725281, -0.06347656, -0.025878906, 0.008331299, 0.07562256, -0.031219482, 0.020553589, 0.031463623, 0.023910522, 0.012046814, 0.017532349, -0.0011558533, -0.07244873, -0.040130615, -0.020004272, 0.03970337, 0.050964355, -0.008758545, 0.012573242, 0.049713135, -0.0062561035, 0.0013208389, 0.007575989, -0.021713257, -0.007408142, -0.000047028065, 0.019424438, 0.0019025803, -0.009429932, -0.019180298, 0.055419922, 0.0053367615, 0.024887085, 0.00548172, 0.014251709, 0.01864624, 0.06677246, 0.0138168335, -0.03842163, 0.06750488, 0.0053482056, 0.05255127, 0.00024485588, 0.03665161, -0.01612854, -0.011474609, -0.007286072, 0.00055885315, 0.0041770935, 0.03060913, -0.031585693, 0.0043754578, -0.038970947, -0.037078857, -0.008399963, -0.03765869, 0.043518066, 0.017105103, -0.0066947937, 0.029693604, -0.023727417, 0.0069236755, 0.011947632, 0.025772095, -0.009384155, -0.054779053, -0.04638672, 0.037139893, -0.022232056 ], "summary": [ 0.03286743, 0.01083374, -0.009483337, -0.028762817, 0.0009202957, -0.025238037, -0.017227173, -0.042907715, 0.012542725, 0.0143585205, -0.030212402, -0.0012617111, 0.000289917, -0.027618408, 0.011039734, -0.023864746, -0.0030212402, -0.019592285, -0.017425537, -0.034973145, 0.017074585, -0.031036377, 0.016479492, 0.021377563, -0.012428284, 0.019088745, 0.024032593, 0.007850647, -0.010551453, -0.0018501282, 0.00023055077, 0.00944519, 0.0357666, 0.07574463, -0.109558105, 0.039764404, -0.085510254, 0.05392456, -0.009643555, 0.013702393, 0.040618896, -0.015960693, 0.068359375, -0.049743652, 0.018951416, 0.037017822, 0.011116028, -0.03765869, 0.005241394, -0.01512146, 0.034606934, 0.02305603, 0.030136108, -0.04522705, -0.00856781, 0.0023212433, -0.037475586, 0.03189087, 0.0054855347, 0.024154663, 0.00818634, 0.010406494, -0.012176514, 0.0026874542, -0.038116455, -0.02053833, 0.01928711, 0.0025577545, 0.02796936, -0.041778564, 0.009986877, 0.04071045, -0.0005121231, -0.003189087, -0.03741455, -0.009231567, 0.054626465, 0.002029419, -0.009246826, -0.014434814, 0.04586792, 0.03753662, 0.053131104, -0.008773804, 0.021896362, -0.00957489, -0.0058555603, -0.024047852, -0.011329651, -0.001619339, -0.01864624, -0.04611206, -0.042907715, 0.051513672, 0.04095459, -0.03918457, -0.0054893494, -0.033416748, -0.0041656494, 0.0008597374, 0.005290985, -0.03363037, 0.023208618, -0.01083374, 0.014144897, 0.04446411, 0.004550934, -0.07269287, -0.013595581, -0.018447876, -0.040771484, 0.014450073, -0.019332886, -0.06793213, -0.021072388, 0.01953125, 0.008399963, -0.022323608, 0.04232788, -0.060760498, -0.0035629272, -0.0017728806, 0.023391724, 0.045318604, 0.014350891, 0.03817749, -0.0069503784, -0.044158936, -0.009384155, 0.04196167, 0.0284729, 0.000233531, -0.091552734, -0.02230835, -0.062805176, -0.0002822876, 0.06384277, -0.02671814, -0.0079193115, -0.0077171326, 0.05593872, -0.0256958, -0.06524658, 0.05822754, -0.0040512085, 0.015975952, 0.0077819824, 0.013946533, 0.010665894, -0.026123047, -0.019210815, 0.021957397, 0.04336548, -0.0053977966, -0.05581665, -0.010139465, -0.05581665, -0.00000834465, -0.012016296, -0.021865845, 0.032104492, -0.02293396, -0.022964478, 0.05618286, 0.0129776, 0.028182983, 0.010681152, 0.011680603, 0.009841919, -0.06402588, 0.03289795, 0.05429077, 0.064086914, -0.024398804, 0.004676819, -0.04208374, -0.012672424, 0.05154419, 0.038269043, -0.07067871, -0.04034424, -0.042266846, 0.05657959, -0.009391785, -0.032958984, -0.0068359375, -0.0077667236, 0.03668213, 0.03475952, 0.008155823, -0.0209198, 0.009208679, -0.020996094, 0.024108887, 0.021560669, -0.025634766, -0.06274414, -0.034454346, -0.028274536, 0.005870819, 0.017837524, 0.011314392, 0.017593384, 0.0026397705, -0.017623901, 0.008483887, 0.0010099411, 0.008178711, 0.03942871, 0.037078857, -0.010360718, -0.021759033, -0.031707764, 0.024902344, -0.004917145, -0.017990112, 0.01335907, 0.011238098, -0.039520264, 0.019897461, -0.044891357, -0.059326172, -0.052459717, 0.025253296, 0.024856567, -0.01612854, 0.0018348694, -0.012062073, 0.03515625, -0.004508972, 0.02494812, -0.0038814545, -0.043273926, -0.024368286, -0.00097322464, 0.010551453, 0.016799927, -0.034210205, 0.034179688, 0.019195557, 0.014328003, -0.013763428, -0.017105103, 0.048339844, -0.040100098, -0.042297363, 0.014564514, -0.004348755, -0.017440796, 0.009185791, -0.010765076, -0.007091522, 0.030654907, -0.027328491, -0.057739258, 0.049072266, -0.0069274902, 0.008018494, -0.035858154, 0.0030136108, 0.009567261, -0.0062561035, -0.019226074, -0.012306213, 0.0072288513, -0.02885437, -0.0040359497, -0.0135650635, -0.0032978058, -0.008842468, 0.007007599, -0.048675537, 0.0065231323, 0.043792725, -0.0063667297, -0.0055236816, -0.007331848, -0.0048103333, 0.011360168, 0.006679535, -0.022918701, 0.013374329, -0.030059814, -0.006614685, -0.013069153, -0.031707764, 0.005756378, 0.02331543, -0.023605347, 0.023132324, 0.0038146973, 0.06323242, 0.0072288513, 0.0038089752, 0.027679443, 0.02330017, -0.053466797, 0.03717041, -0.00068616867, -0.038757324, -0.04916382, 0.01838684, -0.019012451, -0.005428314, 0.0025424957, 0.011054993, -0.012130737, 0.022583008, 0.028320312, -0.039886475, 0.038208008, 0.088012695, 0.02128601, 0.016937256, -0.023666382, -0.044708252, -0.028030396, 0.010223389, -0.04171753, -0.023162842, 0.033355713, -0.040527344, 0.024002075, -0.023406982, -0.012916565, -0.045806885, 0.01008606, -0.0034217834, -0.020202637, 0.001285553, 0.048187256, 0.028274536, 0.02355957, 0.0736084, 0.033447266, -0.0007510185, 0.015182495, -0.0075683594, 0.022872925, 0.003791809, 0.049591064, 0.03378296, -0.016174316, -0.0059928894, -0.03677368, 0.031341553, 0.026138306, 0.01222229, -0.09869385, -0.011329651, 0.023223877, -0.058044434, -0.03543091, -0.029434204, -0.010467529, 0.04095459, 0.024780273, -0.019958496, 0.044189453, -0.052978516, 0.07556152, 0.022109985, 0.031951904, -0.031341553, -0.059631348, -0.041107178, 0.010719299, -0.01512146, 0.0357666, 0.04699707, -0.041290283, 0.03982544, -0.04586792, -0.013549805, 0.0047836304, 0.022079468, 0.0063056946, -0.05581665, -0.027435303, -0.014434814, -0.046051025, -0.053649902, 0.027740479, -0.014472961, 0.07055664, 0.011581421, 0.04156494, -0.022476196, 0.10736084, -0.0154953, 0.02217102, -0.02494812, -0.062194824, 0.011756897, 0.01574707, 0.006374359, 0.03164673, -0.023269653, -0.060546875, -0.02746582, 0.042541504, -0.004562378, -0.011497498, 0.034423828, -0.008262634, 0.008125305, 0.07159424, -0.014907837, 0.015235901, 0.029937744, 0.01499939, 0.0073547363, 0.03137207, 0.01687622, 0.009216309, -0.021362305, 0.012489319, 0.019332886, -0.036987305, -0.027175903, -0.0009012222, 0.048217773, -0.007091522, -0.01576233, 0.030044556, -0.0059013367, 0.017333984, -0.005317688, -0.0011796951, -0.026123047, 0.004333496, -0.03161621, -0.011749268, -0.032714844, 0.015129089, 0.042755127, -0.032043457, 0.021057129, -0.026931763, 0.00079250336, -0.04788208, -0.012336731, 0.044799805, 0.022659302, 0.03842163, -0.019439697, -0.017501831, -0.013847351, 0.0013790131, 0.018035889, -0.01637268, -0.020095825, -0.0038452148, 0.02519226, -0.029708862, 0.0692749, -0.017745972, 0.00009661913, 0.040618896, -0.030014038, -0.0032348633, 0.017242432, -0.07672119, -0.0211792, -0.016693115, 0.03125, -0.02998352, 0.011161804, -0.0211792, 0.004901886, 0.014762878, 0.017120361, -0.017333984, -0.054626465, 0.018325806, -0.020690918, 0.016662598, -0.043304443, 0.066711426, -0.009384155, -0.066223145, 0.047576904, -0.08404541, -0.037353516, -0.036346436, 0.008331299, -0.037994385, -0.048431396, 0.02571106, -0.022369385, -0.027694702, -0.019836426, 0.039642334, -0.0023384094, 0.01763916, 0.016448975, 0.008476257, -0.03137207, -0.0010414124, -0.047668457, -0.023040771, 0.016052246, 0.041656494, 0.015777588, -0.053649902, 0.022659302, 0.045318604, 0.009971619, 0.02470398, -0.059539795, 0.018478394, -0.04208374, -0.028717041, 0.01222229, -0.02519226, -0.0008587837, 0.0035552979, 0.0513916, -0.026428223, -0.016403198, 0.044891357, 0.04067993, 0.029846191, 0.019317627, -0.024612427, -0.0126571655, -0.0062179565, -0.022979736, -0.006362915, 0.014007568, 0.013198853, 0.021499634, -0.017791748, -0.019119263, 0.032440186, -0.02684021, -0.024368286, -0.011817932, 0.02772522, 0.03540039, -0.027572632, -0.0137786865, 0.026351929, 0.043151855, -0.022705078, 0.034088135, -0.043029785, 0.01285553, -0.021484375, -0.022094727, -0.0023422241, 0.011978149, -0.016174316, -0.03894043, -0.029174805, -0.042236328, -0.031143188, 0.0051956177, 0.009666443, 0.0011968613, -0.017929077, 0.013114929, -0.02017212, 0.010574341, 0.043395996, 0.0078086853, -0.025024414, -0.05999756, -0.0025463104, -0.017242432, -0.054718018, -0.014205933, -0.07159424, -0.06945801, 0.014930725, 0.01071167, -0.027053833, 0.026855469, 0.00308609, 0.014404297, 0.034606934, -0.049804688, -0.08166504, -0.070495605, -0.022445679, 0.03668213, 0.02406311, 0.0039100647, 0.016601562, 0.012306213, 0.011413574, -0.03515625, 0.0051651, -0.0035533905, -0.018371582, -0.009025574, -0.0131073, -0.0149383545, 0.030944824, -0.010620117, -0.0115356445, 0.0055389404, -0.0020484924, -0.013000488, 0.021133423, 0.033111572, 0.0050239563, 0.015640259, -0.002691269, 0.009376526, -0.00774765, 0.018249512, -0.017959595, 0.00082445145, -0.010681152, -0.0075035095, -0.021392822, 0.03439331, 0.020126343, -0.04724121, -0.004890442, -0.0014095306, -0.0072250366, 0.0013055801, 0.004917145, -0.012527466, 0.014587402, 0.039093018, -0.003932953, -0.054473877, -0.008934021, -0.030029297, -0.028839111, -0.0028381348, 0.016448975, 0.0007958412, -0.013908386, -0.0043144226, -0.012382507, -0.024642944, -0.00447464, 0.0025291443, -0.041778564, 0.032104492, -0.0124435425, 0.006538391, 0.01335144, -0.03656006, 0.008079529, -0.00674057, 0.015090942, -0.023880005, -0.03652954, -0.03692627, 0.009880066, -0.043182373, -0.010482788, 0.026809692, -0.016830444, -0.044708252, -0.048553467, -0.017608643, 0.0076408386, -0.036010742, -0.015625, -0.0038547516, 0.00919342, 0.018035889, -0.012779236, -0.021560669, 0.0026245117, -0.034576416, -0.016098022, -0.004722595, 0.01399231, 0.0051574707, -0.0000064969063, 0.0231781, -0.008041382, -0.027053833, -0.00415802, 0.018676758, 0.03955078, -0.03289795, 0.000062942505, 0.04260254, -0.0045051575, -0.007820129, 0.01651001, 0.03213501, 0.0051841736, 0.00793457, 0.017166138, -0.0019216537, -0.027069092, -0.0017023087, 0.018753052, -0.01625061, 0.021209717, -0.059570312, -0.001991272, 0.01499176, 0.014205933, 0.031066895, -0.03186035, -0.007904053, -0.050994873, 0.032165527, 0.0066947937, 0.027893066, 0.011688232, -0.025558472, -0.031707764, -0.012313843, -0.0008044243, -0.03378296, 0.016555786, 0.04208374, 0.026473999, -0.015281677, 0.0075149536, -0.03378296, 0.01838684, 0.010673523, 0.009971619, -0.01878357, -0.0020179749, 0.033569336, 0.0018692017, 0.027328491, -0.004989624, -0.062683105, 0.013587952, -0.0075531006, 0.0073776245, -0.028335571, 0.0131073, 0.025756836, 0.060943604, -0.0007209778, -0.012062073, -0.004386902, 0.046722412, 0.036010742, -0.0057754517, -0.017745972, 0.023590088, -0.02935791, -0.0020122528, 0.0071411133, 0.057006836, -0.04333496, -0.014465332, -0.006916046, 0.03366089, -0.00013399124, 0.011756897, -0.017333984, -0.01739502, -0.0075263977, -0.07696533, -0.008041382, -0.0023765564, 0.03515625, 0.038879395, 0.0501709, -0.03869629, -0.01033783, -0.02897644, -0.0039901733, 0.0070228577, 0.007358551, 0.0017356873, 0.0592041, -0.02015686, -0.020385742, 0.017547607, -0.008651733, -0.0023231506, -0.0423584, -0.026168823, -0.020446777, 0.045196533, 0.044830322, -0.0715332, 0.02696228, 0.028030396, 0.08013916, -0.013206482, 0.07751465, -0.019714355, 0.02142334, 0.03010559, 0.019454956, 0.024520874, -0.016906738, 0.009162903, 0.0154953, -0.06500244, -0.04156494, -0.010505676, -0.005142212, -0.05532837, -0.028060913, -0.0231781, 0.016082764, 0.030776978, -0.032318115, 0.016494751, 0.00051021576, 0.017715454, 0.026672363, -0.023880005, -0.0048980713, -0.061767578, 0.034484863, -0.0146865845, -0.019134521, 0.043670654, 0.047332764, -0.030426025, 0.014633179, 0.010154724, 0.043823242, 0.03543091, 0.035125732, -0.018753052, -0.035827637, 0.036956787, -0.054992676, 0.016021729, 0.015113831, 0.07299805, 0.046142578, 0.047790527, 0.01889038, 0.030929565, 0.016601562, -0.025054932, 0.008590698, 0.03390503, 0.0047035217, 0.03250122, 0.018463135, -0.014167786, 0.029891968, 0.014404297, -0.03970337, 0.006008148, 0.06365967, 0.0056610107, -0.041137695, 0.050567627, -0.0102005005, -0.020965576, -0.032043457, -0.011627197, -0.03274536, -0.017333984, 0.029022217, 0.0066986084, -0.017364502, -0.05029297, -0.027648926, 0.008262634, 0.005596161, 0.03250122, -0.0018606186, 0.032989502, -0.011222839, 0.024291992, -0.028442383, 0.03744507, -0.013519287, -0.020645142, 0.0061836243, 0.033050537, -0.03744507, 0.0035686493, 0.13647461, 0.022460938, -0.02406311, 0.037384033, -0.020187378, -0.009109497, -0.046295166, 0.040863037, 0.0024356842, -0.036499023, 0.0025615692, -0.020019531, -0.031158447, 0.016983032, -0.023132324, 0.016693115, 0.039398193, -0.077819824, -0.022323608, -0.05569458, 0.053955078, -0.09979248, 0.016235352, -0.011604309, -0.06121826, 0.06124878, -0.013870239, -0.029800415, -0.05911255, 0.017227173, -0.015380859, 0.012588501, 0.03479004, -0.021743774, -0.009262085, 0.014732361, 0.034423828, -0.0061149597, -0.021743774, 0.043884277, -0.0071029663, -0.0345459, -0.012992859, -0.004737854, 0.02015686, 0.030517578, 0.0010328293, 0.040374756, -0.04156494, -0.047851562, 0.0016412735, -0.0039138794, -0.02949524, -0.031341553, -0.010238647, 0.0070762634, -0.029907227, 0.0061569214, 0.03479004, 0.004699707, -0.07476807, -0.012557983, -0.02633667, 0.028884888, -0.0063095093, -0.0030231476, -0.009567261, 0.037719727, -0.033233643, -0.05215454, -0.004535675, 0.009254456, -0.0140686035, -0.03363037, 0.00040364265, 0.0051612854, 0.010643005, -0.040924072, 0.041381836, 0.014122009, 0.086120605, -0.032196045, -0.019454956, 0.024551392, 0.034698486, 0.0390625, 0.046844482, 0.005718231, -0.07501221, -0.041992188, -0.02947998, 0.032470703, 0.010673523, -0.038269043, 0.029129028, 0.06970215, -0.053588867, -0.019241333, -0.0023956299, 0.023422241, -0.02960205, 0.0037956238, 0.0149383545, -0.016799927, -0.03302002, -0.016448975, 0.015731812, 0.009307861, 0.027511597, -0.0038204193, 0.012466431, 0.009773254, 0.078430176, 0.03050232, 0.029373169, 0.019882202, -0.035614014, 0.066833496, -0.053009033, 0.05090332, 0.010391235, 0.013908386, -0.0062675476, 0.0023231506, 0.008430481, 0.0496521, -0.07952881, -0.027679443, -0.07904053, -0.011207581, -0.019424438, -0.033081055, 0.039093018, 0.014442444, -0.011390686, 0.053527832, -0.028869629, 0.02482605, -0.00078582764, 0.021102905, -0.006084442, -0.014335632, -0.028762817, 0.01222229, 0.013671875 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2109.08267v2
CompilerGym: Robust, Performant Compiler Optimization Environments for AI Research
Chris Cummins, Bram Wasti, Jiadong Guo, Brandon Cui, Jason Ansel, Sahir Gomez, Somya Jain, Jia Liu, Olivier Teytaud, Benoit Steiner, Yuandong Tian, Hugh Leather
cs.PL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PF
Interest in applying Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques to compiler optimizations is increasing rapidly, but compiler research has a high entry barrier. Unlike in other domains, compiler and AI researchers do not have access to the datasets and frameworks that enable fast iteration and development of ideas, and getting started requires a significant engineering investment. What is needed is an easy, reusable experimental infrastructure for real world compiler optimization tasks that can serve as a common benchmark for comparing techniques, and as a platform to accelerate progress in the field. We introduce CompilerGym, a set of environments for real world compiler optimization tasks, and a toolkit for exposing new optimization tasks to compiler researchers. CompilerGym enables anyone to experiment on production compiler optimization problems through an easy-to-use package, regardless of their experience with compilers. We build upon the popular OpenAI Gym interface enabling researchers to interact with compilers using Python and a familiar API. We describe the CompilerGym architecture and implementation, characterize the optimization spaces and computational efficiencies of three included compiler environments, and provide extensive empirical evaluations. Compared to prior works, CompilerGym offers larger datasets and optimization spaces, is 27x more computationally efficient, is fault-tolerant, and capable of detecting reproducibility bugs in the underlying compilers. In making it easy for anyone to experiment with compilers - irrespective of their background - we aim to accelerate progress in the AI and compiler research domains.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2109.08267v2
2021-12-22T13:33:39
2021-09-17T01:02:27
{ "title": [ -0.07232666, -0.016799927, -0.046691895, -0.04876709, 0.00014185905, 0.006088257, -0.03994751, 0.0012216568, 0.012435913, 0.025650024, -0.019744873, 0.021713257, 0.002254486, -0.028411865, -0.028564453, 0.01576233, -0.01675415, 0.016815186, -0.051086426, -0.04876709, 0.0058135986, -0.06604004, 0.026916504, 0.050476074, 0.045196533, -0.05029297, -0.083618164, 0.011116028, -0.04699707, -0.047332764, -0.012702942, 0.04598999, 0.041107178, 0.02432251, -0.026321411, 0.034698486, -0.04837036, 0.023773193, -0.0058517456, 0.0038528442, 0.023254395, -0.0064582825, -0.037902832, -0.0066947937, -0.03503418, 0.008743286, -0.054748535, -0.011734009, -0.0062942505, 0.018875122, 0.02784729, 0.01713562, 0.0067329407, 0.04135132, 0.00894165, -0.01979065, 0.0116119385, -0.0024700165, 0.024215698, 0.046569824, 0.01876831, -0.020095825, 0.024871826, 0.006919861, -0.013809204, -0.019119263, -0.032928467, 0.027816772, 0.07867432, 0.021026611, -0.022567749, 0.008270264, -0.0034656525, 0.01121521, -0.03744507, -0.015159607, 0.0390625, -0.0030021667, 0.03829956, -0.0071029663, 0.0061073303, -0.016662598, 0.014457703, -0.017745972, 0.022994995, -0.00548172, -0.017944336, -0.013824463, -0.04260254, -0.053100586, -0.009788513, 0.0066337585, -0.010726929, -0.032043457, -0.039398193, -0.02722168, -0.0289917, -0.011917114, 0.022613525, 0.0035533905, 0.01676941, -0.0020446777, -0.003250122, -0.011695862, -0.002439499, 0.037750244, 0.0012149811, 0.0055503845, -0.002981186, 0.024536133, -0.022705078, 0.010627747, 0.0047340393, 0.007194519, -0.020568848, -0.011833191, -0.0043792725, -0.00969696, 0.008453369, 0.009803772, -0.0024814606, -0.025924683, 0.022918701, 0.0006623268, 0.04208374, 0.029190063, -0.038848877, -0.019088745, -0.019699097, 0.033447266, 0.012283325, 0.046173096, -0.0970459, -0.090270996, -0.0625, 0.03656006, 0.007381439, 0.010864258, -0.0003707409, 0.0066871643, 0.020370483, -0.017791748, 0.012336731, 0.019302368, 0.0021972656, 0.013008118, 0.07098389, -0.0021648407, -0.05834961, -0.043701172, -0.02406311, 0.018203735, 0.022628784, -0.026763916, -0.044036865, -0.02230835, -0.13562012, 0.0066871643, 0.029052734, 0.025421143, 0.0118637085, 0.020874023, -0.0028572083, -0.0059051514, 0.046813965, 0.00573349, -0.030899048, 0.018432617, 0.006641388, 0.0256958, -0.012580872, 0.0028686523, 0.0038013458, -0.017181396, -0.017486572, 0.008773804, 0.016036987, 0.008872986, 0.015220642, -0.015899658, -0.000034451485, -0.029190063, 0.00308609, 0.044891357, -0.054473877, -0.025665283, 0.004085541, -0.027740479, 0.04321289, 0.0028038025, -0.010688782, 0.02810669, -0.050750732, -0.021972656, -0.053894043, -0.020385742, 0.029327393, 0.029281616, -0.011756897, 0.03729248, -0.033050537, 0.01146698, -0.048858643, 0.0154800415, -0.015914917, -0.03552246, -0.015213013, 0.0206604, -0.029693604, 0.03945923, 0.04800415, 0.022277832, -0.045013428, 0.024780273, -0.007637024, -0.049194336, 0.007949829, 0.018875122, 0.0077552795, 0.0023345947, -0.010139465, -0.00969696, 0.03201294, 0.03149414, 0.007396698, 0.01651001, -0.0055236816, -0.014274597, 0.035217285, 0.033355713, 0.046875, -0.050323486, 0.036315918, 0.025650024, -0.001531601, -0.029205322, -0.0061073303, -0.02885437, 0.0020656586, 0.025436401, 0.0077552795, -0.0259552, -0.010612488, 0.0056877136, 0.07556152, 0.0055351257, 0.007949829, 0.010360718, 0.030334473, 0.034576416, 0.039093018, 0.0045928955, 0.05419922, -0.015235901, 0.021331787, 0.042999268, 0.0037841797, 0.011619568, 0.008171082, 0.0047721863, 0.0013027191, 0.015388489, -0.005153656, 0.026138306, -0.061462402, 0.021331787, -0.011276245, 0.034210205, 0.021148682, 0.0023040771, 0.035064697, -0.022003174, 0.01928711, -0.007335663, -0.044799805, -0.042114258, -0.0015583038, 0.028640747, -0.002506256, -0.07446289, -0.0012674332, -0.006866455, 0.041992188, 0.0031394958, 0.023361206, -0.0005645752, 0.008964539, -0.019470215, -0.012786865, -0.0104599, 0.047576904, 0.036315918, 0.024673462, -0.013160706, -0.0049209595, 0.0035915375, 0.11462402, 0.08831787, -0.036224365, 0.047912598, -0.047698975, 0.00242424, 0.014457703, -0.030914307, -0.007041931, 0.026885986, 0.0057411194, 0.007797241, -0.021392822, 0.02041626, -0.061676025, -0.00035858154, 0.012168884, -0.012878418, -0.044952393, -0.060638428, -0.012451172, -0.04647827, -0.07550049, -0.031982422, 0.07141113, -0.003648758, -0.027938843, -0.007835388, 0.007949829, -0.019561768, -0.018051147, -0.036132812, -0.011169434, 0.034820557, 0.031829834, 0.032592773, -0.06427002, -0.016662598, -0.0054092407, 0.02670288, -0.020858765, 0.021850586, -0.016860962, 0.0048332214, 0.023498535, 0.013916016, 0.011909485, -0.040863037, 0.004348755, -0.04071045, 0.007637024, 0.008583069, -0.03552246, 0.025817871, 0.0066833496, -0.01109314, -0.035247803, 0.012290955, 0.049438477, 0.005924225, -0.004142761, 0.034454346, 0.03845215, -0.014755249, 0.023666382, 0.002653122, 0.002149582, -0.010803223, -0.016464233, -0.04901123, -0.0039634705, -0.01360321, 0.008621216, 0.046691895, -0.0362854, -0.01966858, -0.042999268, -0.007522583, 0.013168335, -0.006324768, 0.01158905, -0.01525116, -0.038024902, -0.0013446808, 0.0072135925, 0.029785156, -0.03955078, -0.004600525, 0.119628906, -0.0043563843, 0.0036621094, 0.0038700104, 0.051483154, 0.011039734, -0.0071983337, -0.0513916, 0.012062073, -0.0017967224, 0.016326904, 0.0012102127, -0.02078247, 0.008338928, -0.07373047, 0.00033545494, 0.05343628, 0.0004041195, -0.027999878, 0.015731812, -0.0769043, 0.024139404, -0.018493652, 0.0043640137, 0.033081055, 0.026672363, 0.007534027, 0.015075684, 0.011146545, -0.031341553, 0.005367279, -0.049835205, -0.10961914, 0.041900635, -0.027191162, -0.034851074, -0.02848816, 0.0112838745, -0.06726074, -0.0039787292, -0.036193848, 0.025222778, 0.038116455, 0.039031982, 0.005207062, -0.0093688965, 0.0041389465, -0.027755737, -0.013687134, 0.02734375, -0.021957397, 0.03982544, 0.004470825, 0.03010559, 0.06149292, -0.025436401, -0.015403748, -0.0016021729, 0.014564514, 0.029830933, 0.007659912, -0.03302002, 0.0047683716, 0.00035333633, 0.015403748, 0.014083862, -0.012359619, -0.0048675537, -0.015579224, -0.0008893013, -0.027679443, 0.019119263, 0.039642334, 0.008270264, -0.024398804, -0.024597168, 0.01473999, -0.036865234, -0.044281006, -0.0002732277, 0.022872925, 0.02897644, -0.03604126, 0.0013961792, -0.030899048, 0.012870789, -0.023101807, 0.02331543, 0.049743652, 0.0010118484, -0.02178955, 0.0064735413, -0.014709473, 0.010383606, -0.051574707, 0.000300169, -0.006717682, 0.008232117, 0.0013494492, -0.055358887, 0.008110046, -0.0005426407, -0.10321045, -0.037261963, 0.009338379, -0.010383606, -0.02633667, -0.0289917, 0.01486969, -0.0070495605, -0.016494751, 0.006713867, -0.01826477, -0.0287323, 0.0040016174, -0.055603027, -0.0317688, 0.088378906, -0.017959595, 0.0013427734, 0.023605347, 0.009231567, -0.012504578, -0.02861023, 0.017425537, -0.0135269165, 0.03250122, -0.013580322, -0.041168213, 0.024612427, -0.031799316, 0.022369385, -0.00041127205, -0.002735138, -0.021347046, 0.014343262, 0.0017156601, 0.01663208, -0.033996582, 0.056732178, 0.02456665, -0.01977539, -0.07824707, 0.007835388, 0.0045700073, -0.029159546, 0.018829346, -0.025299072, 0.008880615, 0.024749756, 0.010070801, 0.06085205, -0.025283813, 0.008155823, 0.023803711, -0.021255493, -0.031585693, -0.0014657974, 0.037902832, 0.007949829, -0.015823364, 0.039855957, -0.016860962, 0.063964844, -0.008178711, -0.026000977, 0.015213013, 0.024780273, -0.050689697, -0.018096924, -0.074157715, 0.0047454834, -0.012283325, 0.018096924, -0.017532349, 0.012374878, 0.04135132, -0.0075416565, -0.00995636, -0.020309448, 0.052886963, -0.0014419556, 0.016555786, -0.040008545, 0.006839752, 0.010864258, -0.056152344, -0.05053711, -0.015823364, 0.004940033, 0.0035419464, -0.0056991577, -0.020401001, 0.029434204, 0.016525269, 0.072753906, 0.030853271, -0.010238647, -0.05508423, 0.037322998, -0.0066833496, -0.045410156, 0.015701294, 0.012191772, -0.013954163, -0.039886475, 0.014259338, -0.022109985, -0.010940552, -0.032409668, 0.02355957, -0.012748718, 0.038360596, -0.010246277, 0.032592773, 0.02218628, 0.024536133, -0.005493164, -0.0014028549, -0.041809082, 0.0041885376, -0.027999878, 0.06726074, -0.052856445, 0.052886963, 0.058135986, 0.0009622574, -0.026062012, -0.014007568, 0.051757812, 0.020599365, -0.056152344, -0.037139893, 0.020462036, -0.021148682, -0.023132324, -0.0031490326, -0.007446289, 0.038635254, -0.029449463, 0.047332764, 0.0005879402, 0.018569946, 0.020553589, -0.012199402, 0.029037476, -0.012001038, 0.020965576, -0.052581787, -0.044403076, -0.014808655, 0.046051025, -0.028244019, -0.012435913, -0.0149002075, 0.007545471, 0.021469116, 0.04034424, 0.028427124, -0.0027370453, -0.010276794, -0.015602112, -0.0015220642, -0.026977539, -0.05328369, -0.005115509, -0.009628296, 0.025650024, -0.05117798, 0.03994751, -0.06573486, -0.010734558, 0.014663696, -0.012123108, 0.019866943, -0.091918945, 0.007411957, 0.05014038, 0.0073890686, -0.0045280457, 0.006980896, 0.026153564, 0.032073975, 0.048583984, 0.00076436996, 0.017349243, 0.0440979, -0.042144775, 0.02355957, 0.008155823, 0.030273438, -0.006980896, 0.019714355, 0.011207581, 0.002193451, -0.057403564, 0.015853882, 0.04019165, 0.009811401, 0.022994995, -0.04824829, 0.03491211, 0.022277832, -0.01727295, -0.005455017, -0.023239136, -0.042297363, 0.0050239563, -0.030334473, -0.023666382, 0.010360718, -0.028121948, -0.024520874, -0.070251465, 0.00223732, -0.011581421, 0.003604889, -0.011161804, 0.025039673, -0.036499023, 0.027786255, 0.037017822, -0.055236816, 0.0132751465, -0.02229309, -0.0025691986, 0.057373047, 0.05279541, -0.009239197, 0.005092621, -0.0057258606, -0.05117798, -0.04522705, -0.0284729, -0.03225708, 0.011413574, -0.012077332, -0.027404785, -0.025512695, -0.001200676, 0.025726318, -0.022491455, -0.03677368, 0.03012085, 0.0028972626, 0.0019950867, 0.010009766, 0.045898438, 0.0011854172, 0.004852295, 0.009422302, -0.026931763, 0.011238098, -0.024017334, -0.01876831, -0.0020580292, -0.08856201, 0.029037476, 0.009483337, 0.025314331, 0.0041542053, 0.011734009, 0.043060303, 0.0014429092, 0.020248413, 0.015899658, 0.090026855, -0.0736084, -0.016616821, 0.001991272, 0.0065345764, -0.013282776, 0.04647827, -0.0028057098, -0.0029563904, -0.043121338, -0.050445557, -0.03668213, 0.00037908554, 0.033569336, 0.016616821, 0.038757324, -0.010253906, 0.018707275, -0.023361206, -0.021453857, -0.0670166, -0.009353638, -0.018844604, -0.01071167, 0.06359863, 0.020507812, -0.003730774, -0.00932312, 0.020065308, 0.019317627, -0.012901306, 0.025222778, -0.037139893, 0.0014638901, -0.04675293, -0.028137207, 0.040618896, 0.03503418, -0.042541504, 0.03982544, -0.030517578, 0.07006836, 0.014472961, 0.03753662, 0.059326172, 0.02381897, 0.0090408325, -0.014389038, 0.012260437, -0.029449463, 0.0184021, -0.040740967, 0.0048675537, -0.048553467, -0.017547607, -0.047912598, 0.0065460205, 0.02204895, 0.033721924, -0.0029716492, 0.028686523, 0.014160156, 0.0053634644, 0.043121338, -0.015975952, 0.06628418, 0.03463745, 0.010894775, 0.0058135986, -0.0012016296, 0.013908386, 0.02507019, 0.007888794, 0.00079345703, -0.0118255615, -0.024780273, -0.00491333, 0.016815186, 0.031463623, -0.04144287, -0.037750244, -0.034118652, 0.033599854, -0.012435913, 0.037017822, 0.06726074, 0.047546387, -0.016220093, -0.013801575, -0.0052948, -0.023849487, -0.033203125, 0.021636963, 0.028503418, -0.057891846, 0.042785645, -0.01411438, -0.028457642, -0.029571533, 0.017791748, 0.03463745, -0.053771973, -0.035186768, 0.028915405, 0.040618896, -0.0033893585, -0.003490448, -0.027664185, -0.017333984, 0.027374268, 0.046813965, -0.010986328, 0.033050537, 0.0045700073, 0.021514893, -0.009246826, -0.027816772, 0.008956909, 0.0054092407, 0.004802704, 0.020111084, -0.02507019, 0.03567505, -0.04095459, -0.040649414, 0.011634827, -0.0019683838, -0.055419922, -0.027770996, 0.06536865, 0.051849365, 0.02709961, 0.06185913, 0.0070343018, -0.017166138, 0.02609253, -0.029266357, 0.02041626, 0.029556274, -0.028945923, 0.04623413, -0.03942871, -0.03729248, 0.04989624, -0.05130005, 0.055358887, -0.052825928, 0.015701294, -0.026565552, 0.051605225, 0.011543274, -0.05050659, -0.03866577, -0.016159058, 0.0074386597, -0.016143799, -0.0000037550926, -0.012367249, -0.019195557, -0.0014591217, 0.03439331, 0.012786865, -0.0012245178, 0.01335907, -0.04067993, -0.087890625, 0.006816864, -0.0115737915, 0.027755737, -0.02468872, -0.0006570816, 0.008644104, -0.0134887695, -0.027389526, -0.06323242, -0.021209717, -0.033691406, -0.017150879, -0.013282776, 0.0048179626, 0.00554657, -0.024291992, -0.018569946, -0.06976318, 0.031951904, -0.038482666, 0.01739502, 0.04031372, -0.031219482, -0.055603027, 0.01928711, -0.035705566, 0.042388916, 0.0090408325, -0.008285522, -0.0044441223, 0.028915405, -0.025741577, -0.017547607, 0.018417358, 0.050964355, -0.016494751, -0.0770874, 0.018859863, 0.03778076, 0.06335449, -0.024307251, -0.021728516, 0.033935547, 0.0026798248, -0.010131836, 0.04196167, 0.039001465, 0.0014371872, 0.008041382, 0.03161621, -0.002483368, -0.047546387, -0.028579712, -0.037078857, 0.012512207, 0.044189453, -0.0035648346, -0.015930176, 0.037353516, -0.030075073, 0.01134491, 0.0022411346, -0.021697998, 0.0107421875, -0.01586914, 0.0031337738, -0.020431519, 0.0066452026, -0.009651184, -0.009796143, 0.013786316, 0.027542114, -0.024139404, 0.007335663, -0.012077332, 0.06719971, -0.00085783005, -0.047546387, 0.03149414, 0.030334473, 0.025527954, 0.030517578, -0.03086853, -0.043945312, -0.029251099, 0.00082969666, -0.003665924, -0.0051727295, 0.010757446, 0.003490448, 0.02861023, -0.01184845, -0.050323486, 0.02709961, -0.02281189, 0.031463623, -0.040649414, 0.022857666, -0.039733887, -0.0015182495, -0.0046081543, 0.044677734, 0.004135132, 0.011062622, -0.0803833, -0.028900146, 0.045166016, -0.046295166 ], "summary": [ -0.06628418, -0.03375244, -0.025146484, -0.01890564, -0.048980713, 0.022506714, -0.069885254, -0.0034599304, 0.041168213, 0.01878357, -0.02911377, 0.013473511, -0.023651123, -0.014892578, -0.0011024475, -0.01121521, -0.01499939, -0.02822876, -0.057495117, -0.052520752, 0.03253174, -0.074279785, -0.00843811, 0.054748535, 0.024765015, -0.012519836, -0.009361267, 0.011123657, -0.0017490387, 0.002811432, 0.010307312, -0.025115967, 0.020568848, 0.013702393, -0.010795593, 0.012863159, -0.029632568, 0.0019350052, -0.0047187805, 0.018310547, 0.019561768, 0.00459671, -0.021148682, -0.013916016, -0.023086548, -0.021560669, -0.0017929077, -0.021957397, 0.031280518, -0.028564453, 0.014923096, -0.012863159, 0.012008667, 0.018035889, -0.03111267, 0.036743164, 0.004627228, -0.033111572, -0.0024318695, 0.010749817, 0.016937256, 0.018035889, 0.025848389, 0.024383545, 0.0042877197, -0.0033779144, -0.004146576, 0.006626129, 0.057006836, 0.036865234, 0.006462097, 0.005016327, -0.00957489, -0.01965332, -0.031951904, -0.0058784485, 0.029708862, -0.013938904, -0.0070152283, 0.012527466, 0.013717651, 0.041229248, 0.005329132, -0.03161621, 0.011817932, -0.0015039444, -0.016357422, -0.019363403, -0.041046143, -0.02520752, -0.031555176, 0.018096924, -0.054504395, -0.03225708, -0.00031971931, -0.047943115, -0.046020508, -0.07299805, 0.030273438, 0.022460938, 0.04812622, -0.06100464, 0.06317139, -0.0065994263, -0.03274536, 0.018722534, 0.04156494, 0.05429077, -0.010116577, 0.013748169, -0.032470703, -0.006755829, -0.004901886, 0.000006198883, -0.04510498, 0.013793945, -0.0015039444, -0.015602112, -0.014541626, 0.007385254, -0.0059013367, 0.022628784, 0.020553589, 0.035705566, 0.02746582, 0.051940918, 0.01651001, -0.059570312, 0.01474762, 0.044281006, 0.01675415, 0.0018177032, -0.030944824, -0.027313232, -0.050628662, -0.007659912, 0.013717651, -0.040405273, 0.012535095, 0.024398804, 0.012008667, -0.021850586, 0.008766174, 0.010894775, 0.021652222, 0.055541992, 0.034820557, -0.029067993, -0.024047852, -0.021057129, -0.025848389, 0.00057554245, 0.009033203, -0.041412354, 0.008270264, -0.04537964, -0.06774902, 0.018951416, 0.04095459, 0.030090332, 0.014656067, 0.008323669, 0.010505676, 0.03515625, 0.0473938, -0.00037622452, -0.036468506, 0.0066452026, 0.0073776245, -0.030517578, 0.0070495605, 0.02961731, 0.011657715, -0.03829956, -0.018661499, -0.01914978, -0.007118225, 0.021347046, -0.0049591064, -0.023269653, 0.004535675, -0.029937744, 0.0032634735, 0.024993896, -0.011436462, -0.049072266, 0.0071640015, -0.038238525, 0.051086426, 0.0072402954, 0.017700195, -0.006980896, -0.028152466, -0.00944519, -0.012962341, 0.019378662, -0.026809692, 0.025985718, -0.025726318, 0.0030097961, 0.060272217, 0.016296387, -0.017089844, -0.021743774, -0.04046631, -0.012870789, 0.0022087097, 0.0096206665, -0.030303955, -0.0021152496, 0.021316528, -0.041748047, -0.015220642, 0.054748535, -0.014160156, -0.04309082, 0.00077438354, 0.040130615, 0.027755737, 0.011054993, 0.036224365, -0.009933472, 0.030395508, 0.013397217, -0.0029411316, 0.0014734268, -0.024353027, 0.0021533966, 0.015640259, 0.015548706, 0.0029411316, -0.0079574585, 0.01991272, 0.029067993, -0.009941101, -0.011756897, 0.024002075, -0.0635376, -0.0004618168, 0.048614502, 0.023040771, 0.0054893494, -0.023498535, -0.0028972626, 0.0713501, 0.024246216, 0.010940552, 0.015686035, 0.022201538, 0.044128418, -0.01084137, -0.00166893, 0.015991211, -0.041381836, 0.0009036064, 0.02267456, 0.00021469593, -0.00045394897, 0.021316528, -0.004890442, 0.010025024, 0.01763916, -0.02015686, 0.009338379, 0.024398804, -0.013633728, 0.025375366, 0.02357483, 0.015556335, -0.02067566, -0.0017766953, -0.05114746, -0.008621216, 0.00053596497, -0.068603516, -0.015899658, -0.01373291, 0.03591919, -0.016143799, -0.030670166, 0.012336731, -0.003446579, 0.026031494, -0.012123108, 0.03643799, 0.042144775, 0.015670776, 0.014053345, -0.0038604736, 0.05911255, 0.04586792, 0.058135986, 0.031402588, -0.015136719, 0.026473999, 0.024124146, 0.099365234, 0.06652832, -0.0053977966, 0.01424408, 0.012817383, 0.007320404, -0.022766113, -0.014022827, 0.006580353, 0.013877869, 0.0011739731, 0.014350891, 0.02230835, 0.03173828, -0.048034668, -0.0002348423, 0.015991211, 0.039367676, -0.016143799, -0.043304443, -0.018508911, 0.0032157898, -0.08105469, -0.064086914, 0.062438965, 0.005554199, -0.019348145, 0.011192322, -0.01424408, -0.030349731, 0.037353516, -0.021606445, 0.005607605, 0.004989624, -0.020111084, -0.010818481, -0.039764404, -0.027740479, -0.0061416626, -0.001244545, 0.0018692017, 0.009384155, 0.011474609, 0.016174316, 0.037506104, 0.020721436, -0.013175964, -0.033172607, -0.03414917, 0.035369873, 0.015670776, 0.0074806213, 0.008377075, 0.035339355, -0.03314209, -0.030517578, -0.02897644, 0.021972656, 0.0061073303, 0.03112793, 0.03390503, -0.009208679, 0.024963379, -0.045715332, 0.027526855, 0.029434204, -0.0038700104, -0.028274536, -0.01789856, -0.038726807, 0.022949219, -0.02128601, 0.02104187, 0.0184021, 0.01977539, -0.00003427267, -0.005420685, -0.0067825317, -0.00040984154, -0.03149414, 0.06945801, 0.0020580292, -0.019638062, 0.044006348, 0.0014791489, 0.028930664, -0.042144775, 0.0016450882, 0.1451416, -0.0004413128, 0.06341553, 0.044769287, 0.07873535, 0.0024356842, -0.013145447, -0.07324219, 0.048553467, -0.022354126, -0.00063848495, -0.012329102, -0.0060539246, 0.039611816, -0.01210022, -0.026489258, 0.032684326, 0.028442383, -0.015686035, 0.033111572, -0.06524658, 0.048553467, -0.006591797, -0.004283905, 0.0116119385, -0.025527954, 0.009185791, 0.00233078, -0.0056762695, -0.014602661, 0.00043988228, -0.03643799, -0.026519775, 0.02432251, -0.030395508, -0.004470825, -0.041290283, 0.10015869, -0.020904541, 0.0116119385, -0.035858154, 0.052490234, 0.012458801, 0.07122803, 0.004585266, -0.025787354, 0.015525818, -0.04159546, -0.00945282, 0.07965088, -0.030532837, 0.11175537, 0.040985107, -0.02645874, 0.10687256, -0.08251953, -0.017120361, -0.0026664734, -0.0024471283, -0.00012350082, -0.011367798, -0.01576233, 0.013336182, -0.02609253, 0.012054443, 0.020004272, -0.016830444, -0.003112793, -0.0028152466, 0.015365601, -0.02557373, 0.027496338, 0.012084961, 0.025604248, 0.07110596, -0.026550293, -0.0045394897, -0.016403198, -0.0128479, 0.029678345, 0.019241333, 0.057556152, -0.09161377, 0.02482605, -0.020996094, -0.010620117, 0.018234253, -0.014099121, 0.018798828, -0.000872612, -0.021316528, -0.01625061, 0.027618408, 0.0184021, -0.023925781, -0.029556274, -0.021697998, 0.026351929, 0.0096206665, -0.051940918, -0.021957397, 0.010734558, -0.074279785, -0.05392456, -0.008636475, 0.05255127, -0.00806427, 0.00019478798, 0.030532837, 0.013412476, 0.006668091, 0.013587952, -0.0029850006, 0.009979248, 0.030136108, -0.044281006, -0.011703491, 0.011672974, 0.021759033, -0.013954163, -0.03286743, 0.052124023, 0.033081055, 0.007926941, 0.0027313232, -0.054656982, 0.031082153, -0.04824829, -0.018127441, -0.008972168, -0.019210815, 0.035003662, -0.03173828, -0.00983429, -0.02027893, 0.016540527, 0.040893555, 0.04550171, -0.027709961, 0.015129089, 0.050720215, -0.0010232925, -0.05050659, -0.008323669, 0.0045394897, -0.030410767, 0.028182983, 0.018463135, -0.017211914, 0.014122009, -0.016601562, -0.031219482, -0.034576416, 0.012992859, 0.020706177, 0.014076233, -0.053253174, -0.025131226, 0.046051025, 0.04736328, -0.03253174, 0.011642456, -0.045837402, 0.031066895, -0.0030384064, -0.030426025, 0.033599854, 0.009307861, -0.0023841858, -0.040405273, -0.010475159, 0.03125, 0.020248413, -0.015045166, -0.007575989, 0.00025820732, 0.020828247, -0.011993408, 0.033050537, -0.027313232, 0.06188965, 0.0057792664, 0.011817932, -0.04699707, 0.0016870499, 0.0062713623, -0.043823242, -0.032073975, -0.08734131, -0.014450073, -0.027511597, 0.012840271, -0.011787415, 0.039764404, 0.0035476685, 0.042663574, 0.005771637, -0.006980896, -0.023452759, 0.014030457, 0.017364502, -0.026763916, -0.013130188, 0.0070343018, -0.010139465, -0.017364502, -0.012466431, -0.019927979, -0.023895264, -0.0154800415, 0.007965088, 0.0010652542, 0.0022125244, -0.003583908, 0.04647827, 0.008766174, 0.0110321045, -0.0072746277, -0.007610321, -0.01701355, 0.0149383545, -0.0050468445, 0.04269409, -0.041381836, 0.040222168, 0.031982422, -0.031707764, -0.06121826, 0.02444458, 0.05303955, 0.038208008, -0.06774902, -0.04940796, 0.03475952, 0.01007843, -0.010917664, 0.00013530254, -0.05267334, 0.0039405823, 0.015930176, -0.026733398, 0.03488159, -0.0036411285, 0.015113831, 0.0012798309, 0.04815674, 0.028320312, 0.0065345764, -0.03793335, -0.016189575, -0.042755127, -0.0077438354, 0.0047035217, -0.039520264, 0.0010557175, -0.021469116, 0.018569946, 0.017669678, 0.016571045, -0.018997192, 0.017211914, 0.01713562, 0.018951416, 0.0016517639, -0.030288696, -0.051940918, -0.004119873, 0.018218994, -0.060424805, 0.06311035, 0.020309448, 0.0038757324, 0.0137786865, -0.013435364, 0.026550293, -0.067993164, -0.04714966, 0.021728516, -0.032928467, -0.011314392, 0.02557373, -0.014968872, -0.004558563, 0.045837402, -0.0423584, 0.0034732819, 0.02923584, 0.00015437603, -0.02192688, -0.031402588, 0.027816772, -0.014549255, -0.0055503845, 0.028884888, -0.008613586, -0.060760498, -0.006580353, 0.013153076, 0.048614502, -0.027175903, -0.016143799, 0.034820557, 0.0041160583, -0.0059890747, -0.027923584, -0.0021743774, -0.014572144, 0.03111267, -0.017089844, 0.035308838, -0.024505615, -0.043914795, -0.0018920898, -0.003189087, -0.005886078, -0.035614014, 0.01638794, 0.011306763, 0.0065994263, 0.012420654, -0.020095825, -0.0028247833, -0.009513855, 0.021759033, -0.029327393, -0.00029301643, -0.0102005005, 0.040008545, 0.04425049, 0.014793396, 0.0027275085, -0.019866943, -0.09527588, -0.111572266, -0.1138916, 0.093444824, 0.014526367, 0.030517578, -0.013465881, -0.015213013, 0.018875122, -0.036254883, -0.03744507, 0.039520264, -0.009788513, -0.021377563, 0.043518066, 0.016311646, -0.014816284, 0.009376526, 0.012130737, -0.042297363, 0.0061454773, -0.0003182888, -0.0056152344, -0.000518322, -0.06878662, 0.014183044, 0.030136108, 0.026016235, 0.032440186, -0.027801514, 0.023406982, -0.0018806458, 0.031066895, 0.005016327, 0.095703125, -0.04876709, -0.034362793, 0.0056610107, 0.03213501, -0.003019333, -0.027130127, 0.021636963, 0.0023765564, 0.0060424805, -0.038330078, -0.004146576, -0.02116394, 0.013092041, 0.025299072, 0.046905518, 0.048858643, 0.045013428, -0.010696411, -0.017593384, -0.054626465, -0.041412354, -0.022949219, -0.005882263, 0.10205078, 0.040008545, -0.022705078, 0.025619507, 0.013763428, 0.016098022, -0.0071907043, 0.034606934, -0.008087158, -0.008506775, -0.05316162, 0.04751587, -0.0044937134, 0.08868408, -0.059265137, 0.0047683716, 0.0044670105, 0.0435791, 0.00806427, -0.004436493, -0.0085372925, 0.0011062622, 0.012489319, -0.004463196, 0.037353516, -0.003829956, 0.039154053, -0.016464233, -0.03375244, -0.052093506, -0.042999268, -0.016784668, 0.0039863586, -0.0068130493, -0.034729004, 0.040924072, -0.012718201, 0.024932861, 0.07080078, -0.047210693, -0.008613586, -0.029891968, 0.040771484, 0.01424408, 0.01914978, -0.023513794, -0.010734558, 0.029708862, -0.008598328, 0.02973938, 0.02192688, -0.045288086, 0.0015039444, -0.021728516, 0.048339844, -0.045410156, -0.052978516, -0.020629883, 0.0234375, 0.00970459, 0.023590088, 0.021392822, 0.008094788, 0.0070533752, 0.0041618347, 0.009170532, -0.008773804, 0.00667572, 0.01625061, 0.005596161, -0.014701843, 0.033996582, 0.019210815, -0.03353882, 0.0058059692, -0.003206253, 0.035705566, -0.02809143, -0.023498535, 0.009262085, 0.017562866, -0.0069351196, -0.0043792725, -0.017440796, -0.06317139, 0.017669678, 0.045166016, -0.030960083, 0.020370483, 0.0033512115, 0.02607727, 0.016174316, -0.012535095, 0.0062713623, -0.018112183, 0.022201538, 0.029541016, -0.015052795, 0.00573349, -0.034179688, -0.016998291, -0.00015628338, 0.02355957, -0.00970459, -0.006263733, 0.08703613, 0.054779053, 0.059448242, 0.054107666, -0.020996094, 0.023422241, 0.059539795, -0.017715454, 0.027130127, 0.0016880035, 0.017959595, 0.036712646, -0.031921387, 0.018707275, 0.021972656, 0.026916504, 0.038024902, -0.037719727, 0.020751953, -0.04147339, 0.04034424, -0.062286377, -0.0018043518, 0.006755829, -0.029876709, 0.012397766, -0.016784668, -0.018310547, -0.029525757, 0.010940552, -0.039154053, 0.021881104, -0.0025119781, 0.017486572, 0.041503906, -0.03338623, -0.022140503, 0.025482178, 0.011924744, 0.06060791, -0.033813477, -0.002603531, 0.053833008, 0.011711121, -0.023712158, -0.14465332, -0.027526855, -0.035888672, 0.070251465, -0.037231445, 0.0065345764, -0.00315094, -0.04333496, -0.058532715, -0.089416504, 0.014526367, -0.04257202, 0.031951904, 0.037475586, -0.0053520203, -0.029037476, 0.018814087, -0.023742676, 0.039215088, -0.004383087, -0.0004620552, 0.0024700165, 0.03036499, -0.007472992, -0.018203735, 0.01210022, -0.001206398, -0.02746582, -0.050201416, 0.006095886, 0.01071167, 0.038360596, -0.0068130493, -0.008850098, 0.037139893, 0.02104187, -0.0018291473, 0.004814148, 0.028839111, 0.009643555, 0.01939392, 0.010772705, -0.0054473877, -0.024459839, -0.008796692, -0.016586304, -0.011390686, 0.00062942505, -0.016983032, 0.0014886856, 0.026687622, -0.05038452, 0.0146484375, 0.016998291, -0.031341553, -0.022903442, -0.021270752, -0.049987793, -0.020080566, -0.014968872, 0.031158447, -0.03213501, 0.0057296753, 0.001033783, 0.00034451485, -0.0099487305, -0.02468872, 0.047912598, 0.041870117, 0.010871887, -0.046051025, 0.0018978119, 0.028823853, -0.038909912, -0.026184082, -0.051605225, -0.018173218, 0.00052165985, -0.0004413128, -0.025680542, -0.021621704, 0.014480591, 0.009674072, 0.055633545, -0.028305054, -0.011375427, -0.03640747, 0.010894775, -0.052215576, 0.024002075, -0.032043457, 0.009338379, 0.010032654, 0.024459839, -0.014526367, 0.027664185, -0.023757935, -0.012199402, -0.003063202, -0.02458191 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2109.09190v2
Harnessing the Power of Ego Network Layers for Link Prediction in Online Social Networks
Mustafa Toprak, Chiara Boldrini, Andrea Passarella, Marco Conti
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.LG
Being able to recommend links between users in online social networks is important for users to connect with like-minded individuals as well as for the platforms themselves and third parties leveraging social media information to grow their business. Predictions are typically based on unsupervised or supervised learning, often leveraging simple yet effective graph topological information, such as the number of common neighbors. However, we argue that richer information about personal social structure of individuals might lead to better predictions. In this paper, we propose to leverage well-established social cognitive theories to improve link prediction performance. According to these theories, individuals arrange their social relationships along, on average, five concentric circles of decreasing intimacy. We postulate that relationships in different circles have different importance in predicting new links. In order to validate this claim, we focus on popular feature-extraction prediction algorithms (both unsupervised and supervised) and we extend them to include social-circles awareness. We validate the prediction performance of these circle-aware algorithms against several benchmarks (including their baseline versions as well as node-embedding- and GNN-based link prediction), leveraging two Twitter datasets comprising a community of video gamers and generic users. We show that social-awareness generally provides significant improvements in the prediction performance, beating also state-of-the-art solutions like node2vec and SEAL, and without increasing the computational complexity. Finally, we show that social-awareness can be used in place of using a classifier (which may be costly or impractical) for targeting a specific category of users.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2109.09190v2
2022-06-28T17:43:11
2021-09-19T18:49:10
{ "title": [ 0.009429932, 0.010314941, -0.029327393, -0.028030396, 0.018356323, -0.008216858, -0.004184723, -0.03390503, -0.01789856, 0.035736084, 0.019866943, 0.005130768, 0.0069503784, -0.027557373, -0.03277588, 0.01889038, -0.017822266, 0.05831909, 0.0015850067, -0.032714844, -0.0074501038, -0.053649902, 0.05633545, 0.0021438599, 0.037475586, -0.054626465, -0.03338623, 0.003929138, -0.0075798035, -0.011749268, 0.00434494, -0.01309967, 0.04284668, 0.04019165, -0.038726807, 0.00088071823, -0.06036377, 0.023544312, -0.007827759, 0.006412506, 0.00021278858, 0.012252808, -0.0079193115, -0.03866577, -0.03414917, 0.026046753, -0.06506348, -0.016784668, 0.000009417534, 0.011177063, 0.012062073, 0.031799316, -0.012428284, 0.0016698837, 0.005897522, -0.030212402, -0.045196533, -0.027526855, 0.03253174, 0.054656982, 0.036071777, -0.04800415, 0.005771637, -0.014984131, -0.06347656, -0.0014858246, 0.0065612793, 0.014205933, 0.064819336, -0.032989502, -0.03729248, 0.031921387, 0.008888245, 0.013168335, -0.04321289, -0.021347046, 0.060699463, 0.013710022, 0.01600647, -0.007369995, -0.037200928, 0.0010995865, -0.056671143, -0.018463135, 0.027038574, -0.0019254684, -0.038757324, -0.009475708, -0.035461426, -0.036071777, -0.0053596497, -0.018234253, 0.007575989, 0.0023117065, -0.009414673, -0.030883789, -0.010559082, 0.042297363, 0.0023937225, -0.033996582, -0.030395508, 0.030776978, -0.09069824, -0.005088806, 0.01525116, 0.024261475, -0.025680542, -0.030700684, 0.020111084, 0.02482605, -0.009796143, 0.029052734, 0.0028648376, 0.030639648, -0.014831543, -0.0073661804, -0.021362305, 0.01361084, -0.009590149, 0.036071777, -0.0020866394, -0.013061523, -0.012512207, 0.011268616, 0.04058838, 0.0137786865, -0.034240723, 0.027770996, -0.028930664, 0.026168823, 0.01586914, 0.04559326, -0.107666016, -0.07952881, -0.08154297, 0.047668457, 0.0031433105, -0.002664566, -0.022903442, 0.02848816, -0.004020691, -0.03744507, 0.0019874573, 0.0020046234, 0.012825012, 0.010353088, 0.055358887, -0.008338928, -0.0625, -0.020767212, -0.011604309, 0.019943237, 0.021011353, -0.013412476, -0.021957397, -0.025268555, -0.08483887, -0.028213501, 0.02796936, -0.0019216537, 0.015602112, 0.011550903, 0.0050468445, 0.0041007996, 0.029449463, -0.025390625, -0.033569336, 0.018035889, 0.009017944, 0.046081543, -0.021606445, -0.01096344, 0.014022827, -0.017562866, -0.021209717, 0.008483887, 0.055236816, 0.006843567, 0.0034313202, -0.014862061, -0.004081726, -0.020614624, 0.029846191, 0.018875122, -0.07019043, 0.014877319, -0.002708435, -0.013839722, 0.052215576, -0.02494812, 0.008422852, 0.040893555, -0.04925537, -0.044281006, -0.02609253, 0.0033397675, 0.051239014, 0.03062439, 0.014968872, -0.0029067993, -0.029205322, -0.01222229, -0.033416748, 0.012672424, -0.018127441, -0.029922485, -0.012756348, 0.014144897, 0.0055160522, 0.061187744, 0.022216797, 0.011604309, -0.013626099, 0.00038146973, -0.013137817, -0.05834961, 0.017364502, -0.032684326, -0.01637268, -0.016616821, -0.052124023, 0.005241394, -0.028213501, 0.032928467, 0.03503418, -0.013671875, 0.006401062, -0.034851074, 0.02168274, 0.022903442, 0.018005371, -0.014549255, 0.03491211, 0.01423645, -0.0035495758, -0.02998352, -0.0084991455, -0.03390503, 0.019256592, 0.01687622, -0.0033721924, -0.036102295, -0.012893677, 0.027770996, 0.005443573, -0.03390503, 0.012390137, 0.02015686, 0.036376953, 0.02607727, 0.05279541, 0.013153076, 0.044769287, 0.013641357, 0.032104492, 0.050567627, 0.005218506, 0.02949524, -0.0357666, 0.015792847, 0.005001068, 0.027236938, 0.007080078, 0.008239746, -0.05303955, 0.010986328, -0.028900146, 0.003753662, -0.008262634, 0.020309448, 0.041137695, 0.0004284382, 0.0061187744, 0.0027256012, 0.020202637, -0.03491211, -0.016220093, 0.004005432, 0.0072898865, -0.050628662, -0.02243042, 0.0030269623, 0.03930664, -0.0034656525, 0.017059326, 0.004108429, 0.016296387, -0.039123535, 0.00056123734, -0.00856781, 0.04107666, 0.06185913, 0.01890564, 0.008514404, 0.0119018555, 0.010528564, 0.068725586, 0.047027588, -0.012062073, 0.029876709, -0.034210205, 0.034454346, 0.017837524, -0.017333984, -0.0066566467, 0.034973145, -0.009284973, 0.022979736, -0.035064697, -0.03164673, -0.0071372986, 0.016235352, -0.0017118454, -0.066345215, -0.048065186, -0.033935547, -0.022598267, -0.061279297, -0.053649902, 0.0072135925, 0.0814209, -0.04208374, -0.017700195, -0.0209198, -0.019515991, -0.018661499, -0.0181427, -0.02142334, -0.0058403015, 0.020858765, -0.0031814575, -0.00045013428, -0.081726074, -0.032165527, -0.005077362, 0.026321411, -0.021270752, -0.012664795, -0.025466919, 0.017654419, 0.0011720657, -0.005218506, 0.024795532, -0.05569458, 0.005680084, -0.044006348, 0.001253128, 0.018737793, -0.023849487, 0.007888794, 0.010116577, -0.00415802, -0.021224976, 0.024765015, 0.07659912, -0.03439331, -0.041229248, 0.06750488, 0.04498291, 0.00409317, -0.004589081, 0.013679504, -0.024597168, -0.044036865, 0.006626129, -0.01411438, -0.021499634, -0.0019741058, -0.0028495789, 0.04812622, -0.045806885, -0.027496338, -0.03970337, 0.0048980713, 0.024032593, 0.025970459, -0.011962891, -0.039764404, 0.0028457642, -0.012458801, -0.01889038, 0.0037612915, -0.019805908, 0.00066041946, 0.095458984, 0.006000519, -0.006290436, 0.017196655, 0.022720337, -0.0074920654, -0.013511658, -0.0104522705, -0.052124023, 0.01676941, -0.0017871857, -0.0029582977, 0.017562866, -0.0061454773, -0.10491943, -0.011680603, 0.031311035, 0.00349617, -0.012008667, 0.01739502, -0.07727051, 0.012931824, -0.032043457, -0.008674622, 0.016723633, 0.07318115, -0.022521973, 0.019317627, -0.021530151, 0.016448975, 0.008735657, -0.01889038, -0.055908203, 0.02911377, 0.009925842, -0.07598877, -0.019866943, -0.005947113, -0.02279663, -0.010261536, -0.007709503, 0.04196167, 0.040740967, 0.0050697327, 0.014305115, 0.008293152, 0.014953613, -0.026306152, -0.011116028, -0.03817749, -0.06304932, -0.010856628, 0.009994507, 0.064819336, 0.030822754, -0.0039711, -0.058654785, -0.010307312, 0.010864258, 0.051452637, 0.018493652, -0.043182373, -0.022384644, -0.03665161, -0.019897461, 0.018325806, -0.0020580292, -0.010795593, -0.0102005005, 0.0063552856, -0.021118164, 0.04812622, 0.030639648, -0.0043792725, -0.030975342, -0.011177063, 0.03024292, -0.008995056, -0.0871582, 0.013931274, 0.032318115, 0.017196655, 0.020828247, -0.0087890625, -0.03677368, 0.025497437, -0.0035533905, -0.030960083, 0.030044556, -0.01486969, 0.0012712479, 0.0010519028, 0.0008177757, 0.01007843, -0.041870117, -0.0335083, -0.0011758804, 0.017166138, -0.040893555, -0.07910156, -0.0090408325, -0.015701294, -0.11444092, -0.048675537, -0.019424438, -0.026000977, -0.035217285, -0.03640747, 0.0030994415, -0.028808594, -0.058746338, 0.011817932, -0.024734497, 0.052093506, 0.019226074, -0.07098389, 0.016586304, 0.05368042, -0.012313843, 0.0054359436, 0.029220581, 0.01222229, -0.0021438599, -0.020721436, 0.013465881, -0.024398804, 0.043273926, -0.008758545, 0.00087976456, 0.040008545, -0.02470398, -0.011024475, 0.061920166, 0.01928711, -0.0035896301, 0.004058838, 0.03805542, 0.06311035, -0.042510986, 0.04534912, 0.011100769, -0.024246216, -0.0690918, 0.005844116, -0.013389587, -0.013381958, 0.033050537, -0.009407043, 0.029006958, 0.012802124, -0.003545761, 0.05621338, -0.0026512146, -0.0010385513, 0.037322998, -0.016479492, 0.0035057068, -0.0010032654, 0.0007519722, -0.0018234253, 0.005016327, 0.018508911, 0.0058517456, 0.02458191, -0.027526855, -0.051635742, 0.01991272, 0.043029785, -0.038360596, -0.020950317, -0.05441284, -0.07244873, -0.018447876, 0.007549286, -0.012992859, 0.020477295, 0.062072754, -0.0090408325, -0.039855957, -0.0019760132, 0.045440674, -0.016967773, 0.002691269, -0.07220459, -0.017868042, 0.0028820038, -0.06567383, -0.019638062, 0.023620605, 0.0049324036, 0.03488159, -0.011787415, -0.018081665, 0.020477295, 0.018447876, 0.051727295, 0.029846191, -0.026947021, -0.042236328, 0.029373169, 0.0022182465, -0.033172607, 0.009941101, 0.012992859, 0.013008118, -0.03012085, -0.0135269165, -0.026535034, -0.023284912, -0.046081543, 0.016555786, -0.010253906, 0.04055786, 0.03692627, 0.06829834, 0.027893066, 0.0055274963, 0.011672974, 0.01902771, -0.027801514, -0.0027008057, 0.004928589, 0.034423828, -0.0007195473, 0.034301758, 0.06555176, 0.010910034, 0.00409317, -0.014709473, 0.014030457, 0.023376465, -0.0060768127, -0.014190674, 0.03277588, -0.028366089, -0.03942871, 0.0013141632, -0.0046043396, 0.03451538, -0.037322998, 0.0690918, -0.029754639, -0.012939453, 0.016952515, -0.008773804, 0.005657196, -0.024368286, 0.018753052, -0.059051514, -0.049713135, -0.005924225, 0.03652954, -0.021911621, -0.0061569214, 0.013938904, 0.021987915, 0.02432251, 0.047607422, 0.03768921, 0.020111084, -0.03265381, -0.008651733, -0.0005030632, -0.03942871, -0.04348755, 0.0023212433, 0.015625, 0.017196655, -0.03829956, -0.0030784607, -0.058746338, -0.023452759, -0.01210022, -0.016098022, 0.023223877, -0.060943604, 0.052856445, 0.091796875, 0.011077881, 0.052825928, 0.01914978, 0.03387451, 0.015472412, 0.022979736, 0.023910522, 0.014656067, 0.0074653625, -0.0335083, 0.015090942, 0.009391785, 0.013542175, -0.010276794, 0.053619385, 0.010986328, 0.021835327, -0.07421875, 0.033416748, 0.0005683899, 0.021026611, -0.029937744, -0.02520752, -0.0023059845, 0.010055542, 0.010902405, -0.0024986267, -0.037506104, -0.024551392, -0.009979248, -0.034729004, -0.01979065, 0.024215698, -0.014320374, -0.052124023, -0.054351807, 0.03390503, -0.014442444, -0.010925293, -0.003118515, 0.012786865, -0.032226562, 0.016342163, 0.05218506, -0.025405884, 0.03100586, -0.03414917, -0.0015916824, 0.05508423, 0.019699097, -0.01436615, 0.0048332214, -0.055603027, -0.04248047, -0.030807495, 0.021942139, 0.031799316, 0.03466797, 0.0027122498, -0.013038635, 0.028930664, -0.01889038, 0.034118652, -0.0010032654, 0.00983429, 0.019714355, -0.00056123734, -0.010444641, 0.022079468, 0.052612305, -0.041381836, 0.029678345, 0.03753662, -0.04244995, 0.03930664, 0.007671356, 0.019302368, -0.014442444, -0.07104492, 0.01637268, 0.01133728, -0.0042495728, 0.011100769, 0.017807007, 0.021026611, 0.024871826, -0.008399963, 0.00868988, 0.05178833, -0.034820557, 0.019088745, -0.021408081, 0.0032367706, -0.091308594, -0.003818512, 0.0071525574, 0.04864502, -0.048339844, -0.050079346, -0.044647217, 0.0131073, 0.04763794, 0.01222229, 0.0657959, -0.049835205, -0.010368347, -0.047027588, 0.0054779053, -0.03933716, 0.036468506, -0.0026130676, -0.011741638, -0.031311035, 0.004398346, 0.003025055, -0.029510498, 0.033233643, -0.00072813034, -0.0031433105, -0.011726379, -0.046203613, 0.019851685, -0.0016880035, -0.019424438, 0.026916504, -0.016418457, 0.013587952, 0.023452759, -0.040039062, 0.029907227, 0.020431519, 0.06463623, 0.039886475, 0.0027713776, 0.010940552, 0.0104904175, 0.015167236, -0.040283203, 0.02217102, -0.057769775, 0.0045700073, -0.055389404, -0.009597778, -0.08306885, 0.0084991455, 0.021484375, 0.03479004, 0.05090332, 0.002275467, 0.03543091, 0.012496948, 0.05630493, 0.031982422, 0.087646484, -0.0018787384, 0.023834229, -0.021850586, -0.025527954, 0.03036499, 0.031234741, -0.01537323, 0.022338867, -0.0035915375, -0.025344849, 0.009132385, 0.02482605, 0.010894775, -0.006454468, -0.0024909973, -0.03152466, 0.057678223, 0.0031642914, 0.039245605, 0.03668213, 0.043060303, 0.008163452, -0.024749756, -0.00021266937, 0.0049324036, -0.022628784, 0.0069389343, 0.043945312, -0.054870605, 0.014419556, -0.03515625, -0.0181427, 0.015281677, 0.023284912, 0.034973145, -0.054534912, -0.052825928, 0.014564514, 0.04071045, 0.009231567, 0.019180298, -0.043670654, -0.05279541, -0.017654419, 0.038024902, -0.034179688, 0.0071792603, 0.022033691, 0.071777344, -0.024246216, -0.0063705444, -0.0018777847, -0.027008057, -0.028671265, 0.023040771, -0.019699097, 0.039978027, 0.028884888, -0.043518066, 0.028717041, 0.0032577515, -0.020431519, -0.009918213, 0.00819397, 0.07354736, 0.053466797, 0.0647583, 0.019622803, -0.022399902, 0.0041618347, -0.063964844, 0.03869629, 0.04144287, -0.016815186, 0.01600647, -0.038635254, -0.04727173, 0.030654907, -0.04626465, 0.060333252, -0.0473938, 0.025665283, -0.0020179749, -0.002313614, 0.031188965, -0.059143066, -0.013717651, -0.0016269684, -0.015563965, -0.012687683, -0.045135498, -0.03338623, -0.01876831, -0.015213013, 0.024230957, 0.024246216, 0.003829956, -0.0038776398, -0.013450623, -0.07775879, 0.005455017, -0.04425049, 0.03930664, -0.031204224, -0.00466156, 0.0048675537, 0.0022525787, -0.0049858093, -0.053131104, -0.030548096, -0.018676758, -0.0027065277, -0.052337646, 0.01209259, 0.008995056, -0.011787415, -0.014778137, 0.03274536, -0.010444641, -0.005622864, 0.009963989, 0.030639648, -0.04006958, -0.033966064, -0.007499695, -0.022521973, 0.030197144, 0.011154175, -0.011764526, 0.023147583, 0.0039901733, -0.01399231, -0.017608643, 0.0033187866, 0.02722168, 0.006839752, -0.035217285, 0.0023078918, 0.05050659, 0.04699707, -0.0519104, -0.003452301, 0.016296387, 0.045837402, -0.0076026917, 0.027770996, 0.021591187, -0.008674622, 0.0013751984, 0.02029419, 0.0090408325, -0.04498291, -0.06237793, -0.040100098, 0.028656006, 0.032165527, 0.010154724, -0.052246094, 0.02859497, 0.008857727, -0.005355835, 0.022232056, -0.004699707, 0.009727478, -0.0032863617, 0.010604858, -0.02986145, -0.016708374, 0.031707764, 0.016677856, -0.0057373047, 0.05621338, -0.025238037, -0.0063056946, 0.02394104, 0.013580322, -0.008522034, -0.061340332, 0.040496826, 0.033569336, 0.010910034, 0.06604004, -0.021057129, -0.048614502, 0.00793457, -0.015792847, -0.030960083, -0.01991272, 0.036193848, -0.039398193, -0.010604858, 0.01838684, -0.035583496, -0.010261536, -0.027297974, 0.020599365, -0.048187256, 0.008979797, -0.038726807, -0.0007953644, -0.008911133, 0.01977539, 0.009468079, -0.028701782, -0.019485474, -0.014434814, 0.046325684, -0.015335083 ], "summary": [ 0.08520508, 0.0055885315, 0.026763916, -0.018325806, -0.0022563934, -0.032318115, 0.00868988, -0.05340576, 0.024993896, -0.0060272217, -0.0037651062, -0.019760132, 0.021072388, -0.05178833, 0.024810791, -0.032318115, -0.0015830994, 0.039215088, 0.030334473, -0.020950317, -0.0019216537, -0.027435303, 0.04031372, -0.0017652512, 0.018051147, -0.053863525, 0.090270996, 0.005466461, 0.049957275, 0.027923584, 0.02355957, -0.0592041, 0.031982422, 0.032043457, -0.06304932, -0.03253174, -0.01234436, 0.0066070557, -0.034606934, 0.038024902, 0.0016374588, 0.0023212433, 0.09436035, -0.087646484, 0.01725769, 0.062805176, -0.020812988, -0.027145386, 0.015731812, -0.036956787, -0.012191772, 0.028808594, 0.012962341, -0.033966064, -0.030319214, -0.047607422, -0.029144287, 0.0020637512, 0.019897461, 0.047943115, 0.002620697, -0.018753052, 0.0010375977, -0.033050537, -0.035217285, -0.020690918, 0.036712646, 0.025146484, 0.004737854, -0.04547119, -0.0064582825, 0.04534912, 0.003145218, 0.0053863525, -0.012619019, 0.013206482, 0.029571533, 0.016784668, 0.005405426, 0.015159607, -0.07727051, -0.002084732, -0.07550049, -0.047790527, 0.008407593, -0.008514404, -0.041992188, 0.014289856, 0.015914917, -0.024963379, 0.010169983, -0.023101807, -0.006137848, 0.035888672, 0.016555786, -0.05319214, 0.057769775, 0.066101074, -0.012496948, -0.05102539, -0.0087890625, -0.018936157, -0.07287598, -0.0075912476, 0.014503479, 0.04550171, -0.011306763, 0.0047302246, 0.019958496, 0.0124053955, 0.0075531006, -0.013587952, 0.015655518, 0.032440186, -0.015304565, -0.010864258, -0.014053345, 0.017562866, -0.03643799, 0.035980225, 0.00069761276, 0.01499939, -0.029342651, 0.043121338, -0.0043525696, -0.0010070801, -0.0021953583, 0.027694702, -0.034301758, -0.007762909, -0.006477356, 0.043670654, -0.029037476, -0.011383057, -0.045806885, -0.0034751892, 0.054138184, -0.0075416565, 0.00037622452, 0.015342712, 0.0062026978, -0.029830933, -0.004798889, 0.0070495605, 0.02722168, 0.009391785, 0.013183594, 0.0037574768, 0.019470215, 0.0050468445, -0.022094727, -0.0003902912, 0.033569336, -0.05441284, -0.0032539368, -0.07897949, -0.042510986, -0.032562256, 0.053833008, -0.021347046, 0.07891846, -0.010475159, -0.050689697, 0.032287598, -0.037475586, 0.002878189, -0.029785156, 0.00019013882, 0.0020103455, -0.06536865, 0.05319214, -0.019226074, -0.007255554, -0.03552246, 0.0105896, -0.006336212, 0.03189087, 0.012863159, -0.008346558, 0.017028809, 0.0028648376, -0.024475098, 0.037322998, 0.0017414093, -0.019729614, 0.03704834, 0.02885437, 0.021148682, -0.017990112, -0.0015068054, 0.08001709, 0.0647583, -0.0069389343, -0.04309082, 0.007965088, 0.011505127, 0.031585693, 0.019836426, 0.018127441, 0.000039935112, 0.02835083, -0.016098022, -0.026382446, -0.0073890686, -0.09222412, -0.031173706, -0.014785767, 0.022705078, 0.027801514, 0.011917114, -0.0039024353, -0.030914307, 0.0048561096, 0.02557373, -0.014205933, -0.03074646, 0.035369873, -0.06921387, -0.006198883, -0.030975342, -0.0063056946, 0.056762695, -0.03189087, 0.054382324, 0.0035953522, -0.016555786, 0.0008034706, -0.008995056, -0.005634308, 0.015487671, 0.023086548, -0.0053749084, 0.01373291, -0.0031394958, -0.016693115, 0.0103302, 0.06945801, 0.0046424866, 0.017562866, 0.0074310303, 0.022384644, 0.013114929, -0.03869629, -0.027709961, -0.0019159317, 0.0052108765, 0.054718018, -0.03363037, 0.0077552795, 0.037200928, 0.009216309, -0.008415222, 0.0071372986, -0.018112183, -0.013679504, 0.029708862, 0.022918701, 0.023544312, -0.031677246, -0.0007853508, -0.000071942806, 0.0004837513, -0.01940918, 0.0035572052, 0.0101623535, -0.044555664, 0.014770508, -0.0013093948, 0.0158844, -0.04586792, 0.011940002, -0.009803772, -0.013420105, -0.036834717, -0.0065574646, -0.053863525, -0.03793335, 0.050750732, 0.0138168335, -0.04159546, -0.006893158, 0.008392334, 0.017105103, -0.011886597, 0.034576416, 0.026641846, 0.01776123, -0.014205933, 0.02758789, 0.021713257, 0.025024414, 0.023529053, -0.009941101, 0.027923584, -0.0007109642, -0.010398865, 0.0056381226, -0.023773193, 0.021331787, -0.021316528, -0.004886627, 0.055023193, -0.00027799606, -0.023361206, 0.0068511963, 0.029327393, 0.0070152283, 0.0151901245, 0.00157547, -0.038513184, 0.03729248, 0.017654419, 0.010612488, -0.009132385, -0.011390686, -0.0015802383, -0.021255493, -0.004096985, -0.0026512146, 0.046966553, 0.068847656, -0.04534912, 0.012763977, 0.01625061, -0.014953613, -0.041900635, 0.053985596, -0.011665344, -0.041107178, 0.005844116, -0.052093506, -0.04421997, -0.043762207, 0.052886963, -0.017227173, 0.022369385, 0.000333786, -0.04498291, -0.0031547546, 0.053710938, 0.0236969, -0.010345459, 0.008720398, -0.066223145, 0.005554199, -0.02619934, -0.0008687973, 0.00094509125, 0.00006598234, 0.031951904, -0.018234253, 0.0029449463, 0.016860962, 0.02230835, 0.08496094, 0.009529114, -0.060424805, 0.0881958, 0.10272217, 0.01184845, 0.021240234, 0.016036987, -0.0008044243, -0.0670166, -0.027053833, -0.0044021606, -0.028060913, 0.012771606, -0.0046081543, 0.025650024, -0.02017212, -0.006790161, -0.041992188, 0.005050659, 0.0063438416, 0.043701172, 0.05795288, -0.022750854, 0.013122559, 0.020736694, 0.004360199, 0.0005354881, 0.0038013458, -0.02243042, 0.05227661, 0.024154663, 0.022109985, 0.018661499, 0.0118637085, 0.0033817291, -0.029037476, -0.008468628, -0.03982544, 0.002161026, 0.02935791, -0.0032806396, 0.014427185, 0.018035889, -0.062805176, -0.035858154, -0.02217102, 0.01876831, 0.016601562, -0.002336502, -0.030944824, 0.06719971, -0.02104187, -0.012619019, 0.0003876686, 0.064697266, 0.025741577, -0.017532349, 0.006942749, 0.02708435, 0.007789612, -0.0104522705, 0.015167236, 0.023086548, 0.018737793, -0.06768799, -0.041137695, 0.082458496, -0.016235352, -0.016815186, -0.013252258, 0.027267456, -0.016723633, -0.003047943, -0.028366089, 0.051818848, 0.018814087, -0.0030059814, -0.0009975433, 0.0019207001, -0.06964111, 0.011726379, -0.002073288, 0.009788513, 0.043914795, -0.05380249, -0.03894043, -0.011329651, -0.013656616, 0.022964478, 0.03152466, -0.04525757, -0.030960083, -0.051513672, 0.0017356873, -0.0012207031, -0.011787415, -0.01108551, 0.03866577, 0.03225708, -0.020233154, 0.039154053, 0.008094788, 0.0062408447, 0.032409668, -0.010719299, 0.04043579, 0.023788452, -0.08526611, 0.014961243, 0.00016331673, 0.03366089, 0.0059127808, 0.007572174, -0.038238525, 0.017181396, 0.012718201, -0.042175293, 0.018692017, -0.010437012, -0.023925781, -0.012954712, 0.05178833, -0.011695862, 0.02482605, -0.044799805, 0.007286072, 0.017456055, -0.027450562, -0.042755127, -0.010032654, -0.007858276, -0.070739746, -0.041381836, -0.029434204, -0.030654907, -0.039276123, -0.0071983337, 0.03552246, -0.058288574, -0.028289795, 0.010391235, -0.028411865, 0.12768555, 0.03652954, -0.030731201, 0.029434204, -0.039031982, 0.008544922, -0.0035762787, -0.013023376, 0.05065918, 0.043029785, 0.004272461, -0.019866943, -0.05758667, 0.06707764, -0.0552063, 0.031188965, 0.00737381, -0.009712219, -0.017730713, 0.047973633, 0.040252686, -0.0016794205, -0.016021729, 0.06842041, 0.08355713, -0.037597656, -0.0064811707, 0.05279541, -0.022506714, -0.026809692, 0.026367188, -0.01576233, -0.020706177, 0.009788513, 0.030853271, -0.006465912, 0.009971619, 0.014846802, -0.007091522, -0.020080566, -0.026031494, 0.028396606, 0.027877808, -0.012809753, -0.023727417, -0.02619934, 0.036376953, -0.0018415451, -0.0015029907, -0.0039482117, -0.02432251, -0.010955811, -0.057647705, 0.0068473816, 0.030471802, -0.035217285, -0.03994751, 0.022827148, -0.05960083, -0.003276825, -0.014335632, -0.013893127, 0.03112793, 0.023666382, -0.004798889, 0.005039215, -0.0024795532, 0.021270752, 0.020553589, -0.046447754, -0.08215332, -0.038024902, -0.008132935, -0.04650879, 0.0022830963, -0.019317627, -0.056610107, 0.009086609, -0.006175995, -0.018463135, 0.017822266, 0.013595581, 0.016845703, -0.039794922, 0.014602661, 0.008262634, -0.008773804, 0.0010728836, -0.023406982, 0.02279663, -0.0019197464, 0.015571594, -0.026367188, -0.015914917, -0.0035438538, -0.045410156, -0.052581787, 0.006313324, 0.034484863, -0.0006532669, 0.061462402, 0.054351807, 0.013931274, -0.014266968, 0.0023326874, 0.026794434, -0.020263672, 0.0022945404, 0.021270752, 0.00048279762, 0.004901886, 0.06713867, 0.07141113, -0.026504517, -0.01727295, -0.04135132, 0.033721924, 0.020614624, -0.05493164, -0.02192688, 0.010559082, 0.0040626526, -0.014465332, 0.017868042, -0.021835327, 0.008132935, 0.041229248, 0.002571106, -0.0031051636, 0.03967285, -0.0047035217, -0.017807007, 0.0075912476, -0.016113281, 0.010147095, -0.035186768, -0.03616333, 0.013931274, 0.029663086, 0.00289917, 0.0036754608, -0.007091522, -0.0088272095, 0.010246277, 0.014411926, 0.0063285828, 0.026519775, -0.052978516, -0.016693115, 0.00843811, -0.034973145, -0.0060043335, -0.03262329, 0.014343262, 0.013336182, 0.023925781, -0.0357666, -0.00349617, -0.018325806, -0.026519775, -0.024734497, 0.022964478, -0.038879395, -0.061431885, -0.002216339, -0.03982544, 0.005405426, 0.07104492, -0.00674057, -0.012397766, 0.0019245148, -0.01852417, 0.0068206787, -0.027297974, -0.059173584, 0.039733887, 0.0058135986, 0.011177063, 0.028884888, 0.03591919, 0.0008111, 0.029006958, -0.032196045, -0.013084412, -0.047698975, 0.013000488, -0.05368042, 0.009506226, 0.00793457, 0.02949524, 0.037231445, -0.018600464, 0.011749268, -0.012420654, -0.017868042, -0.00078344345, -0.023712158, 0.008522034, -0.017471313, -0.0034866333, -0.05328369, -0.012969971, -0.02658081, -0.008155823, -0.012374878, 0.05239868, -0.0024051666, -0.029876709, 0.008041382, 0.014907837, 0.017684937, -0.003282547, 0.0013418198, -0.012802124, -0.005508423, 0.0074882507, 0.024917603, -0.036346436, -0.03274536, -0.028762817, -0.022476196, -0.010559082, 0.061309814, -0.032989502, -0.01436615, 0.009292603, -0.057281494, -0.0032787323, -0.006767273, -0.0043182373, -0.02468872, -0.0010843277, -0.0052871704, 0.030334473, 0.014038086, -0.02583313, 0.021911621, 0.018722534, -0.047576904, -0.00095129013, 0.01399231, -0.014480591, -0.057800293, -0.04864502, -0.0088272095, 0.00043582916, -0.016601562, 0.03829956, 0.033691406, 0.00415802, 0.032165527, 0.0048294067, 0.027297974, 0.037322998, -0.021820068, 0.039489746, -0.02192688, 0.034088135, -0.07446289, -0.07080078, 0.009880066, 0.07409668, -0.010986328, -0.014953613, 0.007858276, 0.021606445, 0.03982544, 0.0061912537, 0.087768555, -0.035583496, -0.029403687, -0.018417358, 0.01751709, 0.027236938, 0.040863037, -0.008514404, -0.031341553, -0.06210327, 0.0055160522, 0.0047073364, -0.0034999847, 0.015426636, -0.03503418, -0.016571045, 0.0013122559, 0.043670654, 0.024353027, 0.005809784, -0.006729126, 0.03640747, -0.00969696, 0.036071777, 0.006313324, 0.02470398, 0.0135269165, 0.025878906, 0.023498535, 0.012275696, -0.04244995, -0.004322052, 0.020553589, -0.0041122437, -0.02885437, 0.06329346, -0.0026721954, -0.006839752, -0.014190674, -0.027450562, -0.046295166, 0.009429932, 0.052886963, -0.00004005432, 0.07647705, 0.009109497, 0.025100708, 0.041809082, 0.0051116943, 0.02947998, 0.029724121, -0.021865845, -0.024398804, -0.0033569336, 0.033447266, 0.0014677048, 0.031921387, 0.014564514, 0.00843811, 0.0019073486, -0.021133423, 0.042510986, 0.02859497, -0.045196533, -0.03540039, 0.03778076, -0.055023193, 0.021881104, 0.040039062, 0.034118652, -0.019073486, -0.029846191, 0.074401855, -0.026412964, -0.015716553, 0.057617188, -0.01713562, 0.023544312, 0.024902344, 0.0044059753, -0.01524353, 0.006313324, -0.020904541, 0.055389404, 0.024520874, 0.05722046, -0.01789856, -0.000010311604, 0.01739502, 0.015686035, -0.019119263, -0.029281616, -0.049468994, -0.060943604, -0.010391235, 0.024810791, -0.03451538, -0.033172607, -0.015701294, 0.028381348, -0.045684814, -0.011558533, -0.007205963, -0.016418457, -0.04522705, 0.007457733, -0.020019531, 0.045074463, 0.00067806244, -0.033569336, 0.037597656, 0.015602112, -0.024108887, 0.019317627, -0.00705719, 0.07543945, 0.07904053, 0.06323242, -0.036254883, 0.010131836, 0.059906006, -0.014732361, 0.038726807, 0.0070114136, 0.0016355515, -0.01247406, -0.024475098, -0.0003938675, -0.001247406, -0.00013160706, 0.015731812, -0.023849487, 0.017944336, -0.0103302, -0.024169922, -0.03463745, -0.018341064, 0.03137207, -0.041900635, -0.024902344, 0.017364502, -0.0040397644, -0.022994995, 0.0496521, -0.010719299, -0.049865723, 0.043060303, -0.012779236, 0.0079193115, -0.0132751465, -0.045013428, 0.00060749054, 0.0046577454, 0.050323486, 0.023086548, -0.032226562, 0.001865387, 0.034088135, 0.010940552, -0.036254883, -0.040527344, 0.06121826, 0.03543091, -0.07165527, 0.016494751, 0.014770508, -0.017990112, -0.0602417, 0.07714844, -0.040924072, -0.0079956055, -0.023544312, 0.035003662, 0.010139465, -0.028305054, -0.0061798096, -0.025558472, -0.015777588, -0.01399231, -0.012718201, 0.02079773, -0.008171082, -0.01953125, -0.0597229, -0.031433105, -0.01626587, -0.010101318, -0.019378662, -0.0004811287, 0.02418518, 0.02659607, -0.04458618, 0.048980713, 0.019104004, 0.06008911, -0.013801575, -0.054748535, 0.016937256, -0.029541016, 0.013671875, -0.000351429, -0.011741638, -0.005039215, -0.05657959, -0.045928955, 0.05130005, -0.02519226, -0.031921387, -0.041015625, 0.012779236, -0.012489319, 0.016418457, 0.013198853, 0.032440186, 0.021499634, -0.008857727, 0.04333496, -0.04031372, -0.027313232, 0.048461914, -0.0126953125, 0.002904892, 0.03050232, -0.029541016, -0.012802124, -0.000043272972, -0.019592285, 0.0033073425, -0.030532837, -0.008346558, 0.003921509, 0.008285522, 0.03942871, 0.004425049, -0.047607422, 0.014289856, -0.022781372, -0.002357483, -0.025558472, 0.0158844, -0.060638428, -0.013069153, -0.029220581, -0.033569336, -0.034240723, -0.029830933, 0.035064697, -0.014572144, -0.009109497, 0.035186768, -0.015235901, -0.0022830963, 0.028030396, 0.026168823, -0.021499634, 0.045013428, 0.04107666, 0.0289917, 0.016586304 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2109.10312v2
Example-Driven Model-Based Reinforcement Learning for Solving Long-Horizon Visuomotor Tasks
Bohan Wu, Suraj Nair, Li Fei-Fei, Chelsea Finn
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
In this paper, we study the problem of learning a repertoire of low-level skills from raw images that can be sequenced to complete long-horizon visuomotor tasks. Reinforcement learning (RL) is a promising approach for acquiring short-horizon skills autonomously. However, the focus of RL algorithms has largely been on the success of those individual skills, more so than learning and grounding a large repertoire of skills that can be sequenced to complete extended multi-stage tasks. The latter demands robustness and persistence, as errors in skills can compound over time, and may require the robot to have a number of primitive skills in its repertoire, rather than just one. To this end, we introduce EMBER, a model-based RL method for learning primitive skills that are suitable for completing long-horizon visuomotor tasks. EMBER learns and plans using a learned model, critic, and success classifier, where the success classifier serves both as a reward function for RL and as a grounding mechanism to continuously detect if the robot should retry a skill when unsuccessful or under perturbations. Further, the learned model is task-agnostic and trained using data from all skills, enabling the robot to efficiently learn a number of distinct primitives. These visuomotor primitive skills and their associated pre- and post-conditions can then be directly combined with off-the-shelf symbolic planners to complete long-horizon tasks. On a Franka Emika robot arm, we find that EMBER enables the robot to complete three long-horizon visuomotor tasks at 85% success rate, such as organizing an office desk, a file cabinet, and drawers, which require sequencing up to 12 skills, involve 14 unique learned primitives, and demand generalization to novel objects.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2109.10312v2
2022-09-19T04:20:27
2021-09-21T16:48:07
{ "title": [ 0.036254883, -0.007980347, 0.0026474, -0.02368164, 0.0158844, -0.020355225, 0.022583008, -0.031158447, -0.031143188, 0.018310547, -0.022857666, 0.014884949, -0.023040771, -0.021118164, -0.01914978, -0.040283203, 0.003107071, 0.03765869, -0.0014257431, -0.018218994, -0.010353088, -0.0259552, 0.03656006, 0.06604004, 0.03100586, 0.033447266, -0.16381836, 0.0317688, -0.058380127, -0.013809204, -0.019210815, 0.019592285, 0.02279663, -0.002407074, 0.031341553, -0.015586853, -0.011817932, 0.008842468, 0.016906738, -0.007843018, 0.017730713, -0.010635376, -0.04812622, -0.029693604, -0.053100586, 0.025375366, -0.05831909, -0.0047073364, -0.02645874, 0.06890869, 0.005264282, 0.040802002, -0.02809143, 0.065979004, 0.019897461, -0.054779053, -0.036621094, -0.032348633, 0.04321289, 0.076416016, 0.021896362, -0.05731201, 0.0062332153, -0.051818848, -0.0287323, -0.04220581, -0.014122009, 0.031143188, 0.06640625, 0.008766174, -0.01461792, 0.045074463, -0.011772156, 0.037109375, -0.06744385, -0.035064697, 0.09234619, 0.015510559, -0.008506775, 0.0058784485, 0.0020961761, -0.0071868896, 0.007675171, -0.024490356, -0.0032920837, -0.038879395, -0.010391235, -0.0060310364, -0.03970337, -0.05569458, -0.017227173, -0.0021419525, -0.035583496, 0.016174316, -0.025268555, -0.02407837, -0.040740967, -0.0079193115, -0.0031471252, 0.025772095, -0.015159607, 0.0020503998, 0.015380859, -0.027664185, -0.0027160645, 0.008865356, -0.012252808, -0.036712646, -0.0027503967, 0.018829346, -0.031982422, -0.013618469, 0.023483276, 0.017684937, -0.005771637, -0.03555298, -0.026000977, 0.03741455, 0.015342712, 0.017532349, -0.027954102, -0.037384033, 0.01474762, 0.020263672, 0.040740967, 0.02154541, -0.018463135, -0.0005812645, 0.02154541, 0.011184692, -0.007068634, 0.030731201, -0.057769775, -0.044952393, -0.026733398, 0.029708862, 0.028701782, 0.0018672943, -0.009490967, -0.00053834915, 0.0029296875, -0.014503479, -0.020477295, -0.0066108704, 0.025772095, 0.02746582, 0.06365967, -0.015281677, -0.040740967, -0.032287598, -0.03253174, 0.04727173, 0.019958496, -0.0109939575, -0.055236816, -0.016082764, -0.12915039, 0.0047187805, 0.024612427, 0.0115356445, 0.0018672943, 0.019897461, 0.018508911, 0.0105896, 0.031143188, -0.027435303, -0.008666992, 0.02154541, 0.0082473755, 0.0703125, -0.0234375, 0.01247406, -0.027801514, -0.0023937225, -0.013214111, 0.0146865845, 0.013763428, -0.007888794, 0.0211792, -0.017105103, 0.012619019, -0.014198303, 0.002532959, 0.03338623, -0.014091492, -0.06750488, -0.022598267, -0.062927246, 0.083862305, 0.003932953, -0.06311035, 0.0076179504, -0.038757324, -0.036865234, -0.064575195, 0.0036754608, 0.04348755, 0.05050659, -0.02255249, 0.020629883, -0.021575928, 0.0028095245, -0.014442444, 0.0076522827, -0.0061073303, -0.017471313, -0.0054779053, 0.013504028, 0.0010299683, 0.041107178, 0.028076172, 0.019714355, -0.03048706, 0.016677856, -0.0013246536, -0.03591919, 0.02468872, -0.005493164, -0.012748718, -0.0044517517, -0.017745972, -0.00037407875, -0.00025129318, 0.04107666, -0.011520386, 0.005504608, -0.012763977, -0.015304565, -0.0007266998, 0.028518677, 0.0289917, -0.030731201, -0.0043144226, -0.0007247925, -0.016860962, -0.031982422, -0.033203125, -0.016815186, 0.017730713, 0.017059326, -0.012306213, -0.008796692, -0.009918213, 0.04159546, 0.024475098, -0.0072402954, -0.0044555664, 0.009643555, -0.023544312, -0.008407593, 0.07788086, 0.029800415, 0.050048828, 0.03186035, 0.0047721863, 0.044006348, 0.013954163, 0.02357483, -0.022277832, 0.0015459061, -0.0001488924, 0.008560181, 0.008201599, -0.0011148453, -0.04360962, -0.0038108826, -0.014976501, 0.011627197, 0.018661499, -0.0088272095, 0.022659302, -0.02746582, 0.012817383, -0.027374268, -0.025726318, -0.01914978, -0.010314941, 0.03125, 0.025100708, -0.06573486, 0.005054474, 0.014823914, 0.03439331, 0.008392334, -0.000702858, 0.024429321, 0.038757324, 0.027114868, 0.022354126, -0.0098724365, 0.050689697, -0.008552551, -0.003736496, 0.013252258, -0.006942749, -0.036621094, 0.030975342, 0.078430176, -0.038635254, 0.05014038, -0.06365967, 0.020706177, 0.03503418, -0.031463623, 0.009170532, -0.0024490356, 0.018753052, 0.045837402, -0.012825012, 0.0022182465, -0.046417236, -0.009597778, 0.017745972, 0.02909851, -0.03439331, -0.054138184, 0.02923584, -0.005844116, -0.05178833, -0.05621338, 0.062408447, -0.022506714, 0.0022144318, -0.002784729, -0.010475159, -0.021911621, -0.0047035217, -0.02961731, -0.0029335022, 0.043304443, 0.044830322, 0.04144287, -0.043518066, -0.013084412, 0.0019664764, 0.015602112, -0.010765076, 0.031219482, -0.016647339, 0.0058555603, 0.0062675476, -0.03677368, 0.026260376, -0.02468872, -0.015640259, -0.0413208, -0.013282776, 0.021881104, 0.006385803, -0.014282227, 0.008407593, -0.015914917, -0.03387451, 0.028579712, 0.06384277, -0.024276733, 0.0017766953, 0.07147217, 0.028625488, 0.010894775, 0.02986145, 0.048980713, 0.012626648, -0.07116699, -0.028884888, -0.05722046, 0.007484436, -0.021102905, 0.0119018555, 0.05279541, -0.060058594, 0.023071289, -0.032073975, -0.007221222, 0.024551392, 0.021453857, -0.0019493103, -0.023376465, -0.02130127, -0.003074646, 0.0027637482, 0.03656006, -0.05038452, 0.03894043, 0.077941895, 0.014785767, 0.01146698, 0.00034713745, 0.046813965, -0.0021457672, -0.015449524, -0.029220581, -0.0154953, 0.0135650635, 0.0126953125, -0.01675415, 0.009849548, 0.0008134842, -0.123413086, -0.017028809, -0.020492554, 0.028289795, -0.00749588, 0.021606445, -0.054626465, 0.0284729, -0.029067993, -0.037902832, 0.022506714, 0.060699463, -0.0038909912, -0.019317627, 0.014289856, -0.031280518, 0.027694702, -0.017990112, -0.064941406, 0.042510986, -0.067871094, -0.033294678, 0.009033203, -0.03765869, -0.03552246, -0.039398193, 0.015060425, 0.03845215, 0.05960083, 0.0056495667, 0.042663574, 0.0039787292, 0.042999268, -0.031585693, -0.042297363, -0.048431396, -0.014442444, -0.008972168, -0.008796692, 0.029159546, -0.015342712, 0.01512146, -0.023254395, 0.006832123, -0.026977539, 0.025772095, 0.00017166138, -0.05154419, -0.0006480217, -0.011581421, -0.029281616, -0.042144775, -0.00434494, 0.00035643578, -0.03213501, 0.006504059, -0.007522583, 0.08074951, -0.01020813, 0.0018205643, -0.0074691772, -0.04083252, -0.004627228, -0.027816772, -0.043792725, 0.0010089874, 0.008216858, 0.01436615, 0.027053833, -0.015563965, -0.018630981, 0.001458168, -0.03338623, 0.012214661, 0.0010910034, -0.026794434, 0.009124756, 0.0075683594, 0.011169434, -0.030029297, 0.012878418, -0.009170532, -0.008117676, 0.0056762695, -0.046844482, -0.020721436, -0.015655518, 0.0024814606, -0.072143555, 0.014289856, 0.0070152283, -0.011100769, -0.0055236816, -0.042114258, 0.027359009, -0.028060913, -0.045715332, 0.0076789856, -0.024383545, 0.0048294067, 0.014434814, -0.045166016, -0.0063972473, 0.05279541, 0.023788452, 0.0028266907, 0.04046631, -0.009773254, 0.0093307495, -0.02758789, 0.011993408, 0.021240234, 0.035369873, 0.00010609627, 0.0020198822, 0.065979004, -0.024505615, -0.00756073, 0.051116943, 0.054595947, -0.018692017, -0.014297485, 0.003353119, 0.0025043488, -0.02357483, 0.046447754, 0.020477295, -0.008224487, -0.050811768, 0.028671265, -0.016815186, -0.019424438, -0.002735138, -0.0052604675, -0.021453857, 0.013648987, 0.026763916, 0.041137695, -0.014572144, -0.014816284, 0.038848877, 0.026672363, -0.028213501, -0.00856781, 0.03668213, 0.032958984, 0.000875473, 0.030075073, -0.00504303, 0.050567627, -0.023849487, -0.007045746, -0.010948181, 0.0071868896, -0.05999756, -0.017868042, -0.043304443, -0.0345459, 0.006263733, 0.0015563965, -0.037902832, 0.022720337, 0.036315918, 0.00058078766, -0.043823242, 0.014656067, 0.022399902, 0.001115799, -0.019302368, -0.06329346, -0.014350891, -0.016998291, -0.05895996, -0.022491455, -0.016433716, -0.0020942688, 0.03152466, 0.010276794, -0.0552063, 0.017974854, 0.032562256, 0.13256836, 0.04660034, -0.014060974, -0.08392334, 0.03378296, -0.02519226, -0.028747559, 0.025268555, -0.021087646, -0.023040771, -0.02508545, 0.018310547, -0.004737854, -0.019058228, -0.06274414, 0.015258789, -0.025497437, 0.038726807, 0.03491211, 0.06347656, 0.03555298, -0.00016081333, 0.011772156, 0.010719299, -0.0368042, 0.026748657, -0.009613037, 0.061035156, -0.025970459, 0.0093307495, 0.02142334, 0.023345947, 0.0055389404, 0.007183075, 0.00945282, 0.013549805, -0.0054092407, 0.013191223, 0.0028686523, -0.011703491, -0.02255249, 0.015289307, 0.025360107, 0.03201294, -0.026046753, 0.08862305, 0.008956909, -0.016738892, 0.07232666, 0.007881165, -0.02166748, 0.010665894, -0.028625488, -0.06628418, -0.06903076, -0.024169922, 0.06439209, -0.04385376, -0.024780273, -0.004470825, 0.0038394928, 0.031341553, 0.040130615, 0.057373047, -0.032348633, -0.02947998, -0.017349243, -0.0036945343, -0.0051727295, -0.043426514, -0.0154800415, 0.0054092407, 0.0077171326, -0.10638428, 0.038146973, -0.014007568, -0.029800415, -0.016845703, -0.025650024, 0.004901886, -0.061950684, 0.028045654, 0.055480957, -0.015960693, 0.03201294, 0.041656494, 0.027114868, 0.020690918, 0.035186768, 0.007797241, 0.03652954, 0.028137207, -0.029006958, 0.0385437, 0.0038032532, 0.013267517, -0.0104599, 0.014663696, -0.010055542, 0.011070251, -0.037017822, 0.033935547, -0.0058059692, -0.009216309, -0.0018730164, -0.038391113, -0.010940552, 0.010215759, 0.03363037, 0.013198853, -0.034423828, -0.031921387, -0.027755737, -0.025650024, -0.064819336, 0.045135498, -0.013618469, -0.036590576, -0.06286621, 0.0035858154, -0.037353516, 0.0063705444, -0.0044136047, 0.0024414062, -0.04763794, 0.020095825, 0.019897461, -0.0118637085, -0.020599365, 0.029846191, 0.023925781, 0.025222778, -0.012390137, -0.025146484, -0.0043640137, 0.009185791, -0.052581787, -0.014419556, 0.041381836, 0.013038635, -0.0152282715, -0.017181396, -0.014877319, -0.01335144, -0.011878967, 0.017181396, -0.012641907, -0.03302002, 0.027770996, 0.0048561096, 0.0014820099, 0.02456665, -0.0059547424, -0.0056381226, 0.008995056, -0.0060539246, -0.005844116, 0.02418518, -0.011169434, 0.016448975, 0.008590698, -0.035247803, 0.009643555, 0.03704834, 0.0046691895, -0.0079422, 0.01977539, 0.033355713, -0.01084137, -0.012420654, -0.007904053, 0.04269409, -0.03302002, 0.021759033, -0.0061035156, -0.0008921623, -0.026016235, 0.042633057, 0.0016756058, -0.0017766953, -0.0413208, -0.03744507, -0.026916504, -0.0050964355, 0.034851074, -0.01638794, 0.010009766, -0.033172607, -0.017868042, -0.051116943, 0.0035305023, -0.030654907, 0.0009250641, -0.010498047, -0.036468506, 0.019882202, 0.022918701, 0.021484375, -0.025894165, 0.0049209595, -0.011604309, -0.008453369, -0.0037670135, -0.041168213, 0.012107849, -0.00459671, -0.01852417, 0.044403076, -0.028915405, 0.005207062, 0.017028809, -0.032562256, 0.044281006, 0.014404297, 0.05154419, 0.024230957, -0.0044898987, -0.009391785, 0.012908936, 0.022827148, -0.04046631, 0.020202637, -0.050598145, -0.00032663345, -0.06488037, -0.026184082, -0.064208984, -0.0026950836, -0.015777588, 0.0385437, 0.04156494, -0.0029239655, 0.006149292, 0.014015198, 0.05340576, 0.04043579, 0.06982422, 0.010795593, 0.020126343, -0.024169922, -0.003282547, 0.03314209, 0.032958984, -0.011619568, 0.03253174, -0.027420044, -0.015579224, 0.018173218, -0.00843811, 0.020950317, -0.01209259, -0.026992798, -0.03137207, 0.060943604, 0.0018539429, 0.017288208, 0.043670654, 0.05050659, -0.034820557, -0.0017433167, 0.025878906, -0.021133423, -0.046966553, 0.028549194, 0.032073975, -0.099975586, 0.042175293, 0.019348145, -0.013923645, -0.019012451, 0.0635376, 0.004146576, -0.03753662, -0.0040626526, 0.015060425, 0.020523071, 0.019836426, 0.019042969, -0.027709961, -0.0234375, 0.018554688, 0.02885437, -0.012145996, 0.027053833, 0.023239136, -0.006313324, -0.02645874, 0.0013418198, -0.00045657158, 0.06506348, -0.04019165, 0.011817932, -0.04046631, 0.064331055, 0.03137207, -0.022827148, 0.03805542, 0.01171875, -0.055847168, 0.015068054, -0.0070610046, 0.032989502, 0.037017822, 0.058380127, 0.0004246235, -0.020950317, -0.0028762817, -0.043426514, 0.009529114, 0.045715332, -0.022994995, 0.020050049, -0.03567505, -0.04220581, 0.03366089, -0.04425049, 0.0440979, -0.057525635, 0.014144897, -0.010108948, 0.031463623, 0.038330078, -0.04550171, -0.0703125, -0.00894165, -0.032836914, 0.022018433, 0.031829834, -0.014297485, -0.0021438599, 0.018249512, -0.014205933, 0.045562744, 0.005996704, -0.02368164, -0.01309967, -0.0385437, 0.019607544, -0.03265381, 0.0552063, 0.005065918, -0.023513794, -0.038208008, 0.009353638, 0.018951416, -0.0146484375, -0.030166626, 0.015731812, -0.013259888, -0.020492554, 0.015434265, 0.03152466, 0.0026836395, 0.03451538, -0.05859375, 0.025283813, -0.017547607, -0.015449524, 0.046447754, -0.021377563, -0.025222778, -0.0014677048, -0.0112838745, 0.039215088, -0.0016145706, -0.0069122314, -0.01184082, 0.014663696, -0.043792725, -0.02670288, 0.0065307617, 0.037231445, -0.0024757385, -0.0046043396, 0.0041122437, 0.021072388, 0.03640747, -0.058166504, -0.032226562, -0.014572144, 0.0039520264, -0.020324707, 0.07098389, -0.002046585, 0.0058898926, 0.029220581, 0.054382324, 0.0064697266, -0.032470703, -0.021530151, 0.022918701, 0.07232666, 0.04751587, -0.020431519, -0.0008831024, 0.014091492, -0.03302002, 0.0019226074, 0.010513306, 0.0057029724, 0.010566711, 0.000046253204, 0.0418396, 0.002401352, -0.023284912, -0.005710602, 0.012680054, 0.002779007, 0.033203125, -0.012939453, -0.006198883, 0.002729416, 0.05291748, -0.027511597, 0.019561768, 0.027664185, 0.009002686, 0.0345459, 0.009162903, 0.0010318756, 0.012260437, 0.0037841797, 0.012069702, -0.0009717941, 0.024490356, 0.028915405, -0.0012016296, 0.009391785, -0.08404541, -0.029525757, -0.011627197, -0.033691406, 0.03152466, -0.030212402, 0.0012226105, -0.0059127808, -0.036102295, -0.012031555, 0.051818848, 0.019195557, -0.034484863, -0.030685425, 0.012245178, 0.058502197, -0.030899048 ], "summary": [ 0.01878357, 0.0012731552, -0.011199951, 0.014602661, -0.016921997, -0.025802612, -0.00712204, -0.02720642, -0.043029785, 0.011001587, -0.022277832, -0.0050621033, -0.004119873, -0.0209198, 0.028213501, -0.06036377, 0.020935059, 0.05117798, 0.06689453, -0.0119018555, -0.01335144, -0.004009247, 0.045440674, 0.050079346, 0.059783936, -0.0058174133, -0.1138916, 0.009819031, 0.011177063, 0.0043945312, 0.02128601, 0.011161804, 0.008651733, -0.026611328, 0.046173096, -0.024841309, -0.002216339, -0.0036907196, 0.011154175, 0.005256653, 0.017456055, -0.008087158, -0.0010480881, -0.02746582, -0.025283813, 0.020690918, -0.014503479, -0.014175415, 0.013587952, 0.027252197, -0.020446777, -0.0028438568, -0.04006958, 0.044830322, -0.0090408325, -0.032562256, -0.013618469, -0.0501709, 0.044555664, 0.07727051, 0.0036697388, -0.050689697, -0.02130127, -0.08099365, 0.0012702942, -0.01309967, -0.02999878, 0.038269043, 0.0390625, -0.011802673, -0.000849247, 0.013000488, 0.00050640106, 0.0038814545, -0.031677246, 0.0062179565, 0.026107788, 0.038146973, 0.0003631115, -0.010101318, 0.00970459, 0.056762695, -0.00484848, -0.06072998, 0.023849487, -0.05419922, -0.009803772, -0.0038528442, -0.01914978, -0.026016235, -0.031585693, 0.034423828, -0.07244873, 0.04284668, 0.0017213821, -0.013031006, -0.009986877, -0.062164307, 0.06915283, 0.0435791, 0.060028076, -0.08898926, 0.10015869, -0.005886078, -0.020584106, -0.027954102, -0.0060539246, -0.02029419, 0.017547607, 0.034332275, -0.046813965, 0.0044059753, 0.009109497, 0.0002168417, -0.0026187897, -0.040374756, -0.037322998, 0.034484863, -0.0015478134, -0.020736694, -0.01586914, 0.029647827, -0.03161621, 0.09741211, 0.0028057098, 0.03894043, 0.033355713, -0.032562256, 0.032043457, -0.05218506, -0.004447937, 0.049591064, -0.040405273, -0.018508911, -0.028579712, 0.024673462, 0.015525818, -0.020065308, 0.01361084, -0.03805542, 0.035247803, -0.0049743652, -0.00073480606, 0.04107666, 0.0013418198, 0.028015137, 0.031402588, 0.00030088425, -0.023834229, -0.034851074, -0.015640259, 0.0231781, -0.011047363, -0.011619568, 0.038360596, -0.040283203, -0.022583008, 0.000010192394, 0.059295654, 0.009780884, 0.038635254, 0.015403748, 0.0020599365, 0.019744873, -0.009185791, -0.028305054, -0.0073661804, 0.008903503, 0.010513306, 0.08544922, -0.028762817, 0.013999939, -0.024353027, -0.0033779144, -0.022369385, -0.008071899, 0.023849487, 0.022399902, 0.006252289, -0.016662598, -0.016036987, -0.03189087, 0.00579834, -0.013893127, -0.00730896, -0.028457642, -0.032318115, -0.030517578, 0.06323242, 0.010978699, -0.04083252, -0.010185242, -0.011940002, 0.0040397644, -0.015640259, 0.030822754, 0.010887146, 0.05609131, -0.022918701, -0.05267334, 0.047332764, 0.012306213, -0.015106201, -0.008140564, -0.08544922, 0.00065279007, -0.023376465, 0.022445679, -0.020462036, 0.03643799, 0.029174805, 0.01374054, -0.03427124, 0.010383606, 0.013694763, -0.019821167, 0.018508911, 0.013435364, -0.0035057068, -0.024429321, -0.019088745, -0.0022640228, -0.030929565, 0.035369873, 0.012237549, 0.0016584396, -0.021606445, 0.006164551, 0.019424438, 0.025939941, -0.0025901794, -0.0053901672, -0.028930664, 0.028198242, -0.0045814514, -0.019760132, -0.0063285828, -0.030807495, 0.041992188, 0.03152466, -0.000009179115, 0.006511688, -0.025238037, 0.03567505, -0.025299072, -0.060333252, -0.017059326, 0.027877808, -0.057891846, -0.0032672882, 0.0463562, 0.036712646, -0.0007362366, 0.05545044, -0.034057617, 0.012359619, -0.019515991, -0.016021729, -0.014297485, 0.009674072, 0.01008606, -0.011154175, -0.0033187866, -0.0037822723, -0.054138184, 0.0009889603, 0.0016174316, 0.01890564, 0.020309448, -0.032562256, 0.024276733, 0.012878418, -0.0059051514, 0.00060272217, -0.0022449493, -0.02696228, -0.040039062, 0.017578125, 0.038360596, -0.00459671, 0.0011558533, 0.05218506, 0.00680542, -0.0066490173, -0.010398865, 0.021453857, 0.0033092499, 0.007545471, 0.027038574, 0.030899048, 0.050201416, 0.02078247, 0.016342163, 0.0034599304, 0.000957489, -0.008773804, -0.011146545, 0.034973145, -0.0070266724, -0.023727417, -0.009750366, 0.0065574646, -0.050628662, 0.009216309, 0.017471313, -0.05316162, -0.022232056, 0.04724121, 0.009216309, -0.03111267, -0.0037231445, 0.057922363, 0.04638672, 0.10058594, 0.013710022, -0.025756836, 0.025894165, 0.08898926, 0.020462036, -0.012969971, 0.040252686, -0.022781372, 0.021209717, 0.041931152, -0.0040626526, -0.0491333, 0.08770752, -0.008529663, 0.006866455, 0.016601562, 0.0071525574, 0.024307251, 0.00036787987, 0.027664185, -0.0055236816, -0.013206482, 0.007434845, 0.05883789, 0.011886597, -0.01525116, 0.028182983, -0.04119873, -0.008430481, 0.015716553, -0.015548706, -0.015396118, -0.004722595, -0.011497498, 0.020248413, 0.010002136, -0.010986328, 0.011932373, -0.026397705, 0.0546875, 0.022613525, -0.053741455, 0.025512695, 0.04736328, -0.024246216, -0.010688782, 0.02305603, 0.0013418198, -0.011871338, -0.040771484, -0.0073242188, -0.019363403, -0.02067566, 0.0023460388, 0.025650024, 0.04147339, -0.039367676, 0.068603516, -0.05697632, -0.028320312, -0.003704071, 0.025772095, 0.1274414, 0.008377075, -0.037475586, 0.07104492, 0.008369446, 0.030456543, -0.06793213, 0.004966736, 0.041168213, 0.0435791, 0.028030396, 0.002817154, 0.04144287, -0.017486572, 0.015022278, 0.024490356, -0.042419434, -0.015991211, 0.01235199, 0.009651184, 0.02558899, -0.013496399, -0.02468872, -0.041381836, -0.042541504, 0.03878784, 0.01637268, -0.0019836426, 0.01576233, 0.003145218, -0.007297516, -0.04168701, 0.0018148422, 0.062438965, 0.02519226, -0.07501221, 0.046661377, -0.039154053, 0.030059814, -0.014137268, -0.022720337, 0.014968872, -0.051940918, -0.012870789, 0.01940918, 0.0058517456, -0.014160156, -0.015289307, -0.00674057, 0.025756836, 0.03302002, 0.027053833, 0.016082764, 0.0072784424, 0.025253296, -0.032409668, 0.0024871826, -0.0045433044, -0.05529785, -0.023910522, -0.016586304, -0.013946533, 0.013153076, -0.05316162, -0.0155181885, 0.0036945343, 0.0026741028, 0.013458252, -0.00982666, -0.018081665, 0.0032978058, 0.0050468445, -0.051239014, -0.031173706, 0.0054016113, 0.010887146, 0.036315918, 0.026931763, 0.023880005, 0.110961914, 0.0054779053, 0.025924683, 0.046020508, -0.064086914, -0.008705139, -0.011642456, -0.05722046, 0.007926941, 0.036468506, 0.006931305, -0.0007081032, 0.0012454987, 0.0008339882, 0.0038604736, 0.0072631836, -0.022766113, 0.012252808, -0.02508545, 0.006427765, -0.034820557, 0.025054932, -0.036499023, 0.054748535, -0.029373169, -0.027999878, 0.009735107, -0.028518677, 0.017044067, -0.006877899, 0.015670776, -0.03201294, 0.014175415, 0.010765076, 0.07080078, 0.03515625, -0.017745972, 0.06774902, -0.041809082, -0.05090332, 0.033355713, -0.0054855347, -0.008995056, 0.044891357, -0.020568848, 0.013702393, 0.014518738, -0.0029850006, -0.045684814, 0.015388489, 0.039794922, 0.024612427, -0.0070381165, -0.023986816, -0.01386261, 0.026504517, -0.042541504, 0.068115234, 0.032806396, -0.0022354126, -0.0038814545, 0.026473999, 0.058013916, -0.031463623, -0.028945923, -0.0007982254, 0.009613037, -0.03591919, 0.025863647, 0.064941406, -0.0068092346, -0.03994751, 0.04510498, -0.039978027, -0.014587402, 0.012176514, 0.033599854, -0.008659363, -0.018112183, 0.03768921, -0.0234375, -0.004776001, -0.042388916, 0.0070762634, 0.064941406, -0.020858765, -0.029663086, 0.015541077, 0.053710938, -0.024124146, -0.017227173, -0.014015198, 0.022155762, -0.012893677, -0.02104187, 0.022155762, 0.029922485, -0.07128906, -0.03717041, -0.0017738342, -0.02960205, -0.009674072, 0.008651733, -0.0131073, 0.001707077, -0.02709961, -0.0059547424, -0.023834229, 0.033569336, -0.009887695, 0.03652954, -0.039764404, -0.053100586, -0.011161804, -0.009208679, -0.051116943, -0.022201538, -0.08294678, -0.07128906, -0.01184082, 0.0032100677, -0.05014038, 0.0075950623, 0.0112838745, 0.1385498, 0.05126953, 0.03488159, -0.08581543, 0.011779785, -0.0435791, 0.007698059, 0.034606934, -0.027297974, -0.029525757, -0.02897644, 0.023986816, 0.011428833, -0.033447266, -0.046966553, -0.005405426, 0.011680603, 0.030090332, 0.058502197, 0.04067993, 0.028320312, 0.014450073, 0.009529114, -0.011054993, -0.013221741, 0.027023315, 0.020248413, 0.06915283, -0.013809204, 0.025665283, 0.013053894, 0.014541626, -0.016296387, -0.00075769424, 0.033935547, 0.0154418945, -0.06335449, -0.008880615, -0.0013408661, -0.0074043274, -0.0032291412, 0.02029419, -0.010910034, 0.016403198, 0.013122559, 0.0758667, 0.03756714, -0.026260376, 0.049072266, -0.0010385513, -0.023788452, -0.015335083, -0.0395813, -0.057128906, -0.08294678, -0.027175903, 0.06982422, 0.0028495789, -0.027908325, -0.010566711, -0.036987305, 0.010925293, 0.038146973, 0.014831543, -0.038970947, -0.012321472, -0.013923645, -0.035125732, -0.024719238, -0.023239136, -0.00844574, 0.012832642, 0.0024261475, -0.028701782, 0.0044517517, 0.02444458, -0.005153656, -0.030792236, 0.020629883, -0.012832642, -0.018630981, -0.025405884, 0.017974854, 0.00712204, 0.010017395, 0.014228821, -0.0014791489, -0.014228821, 0.027542114, -0.017242432, -0.0009589195, 0.00034856796, -0.042510986, 0.03286743, -0.030029297, 0.0067863464, 0.016342163, 0.02067566, 0.008331299, 0.03173828, -0.03137207, -0.009353638, -0.06915283, 0.045166016, -0.041625977, 0.010223389, -0.027053833, 0.025115967, 0.032073975, -0.011062622, -0.020248413, -0.032684326, -0.021850586, -0.03250122, -0.06414795, 0.007587433, -0.03552246, -0.025619507, -0.03555298, 0.025878906, -0.009155273, -0.01675415, -0.004257202, 0.03149414, 0.011459351, 0.017364502, -0.019042969, 0.023529053, -0.03314209, 0.060424805, 0.009819031, -0.006259918, -0.0051841736, -0.015586853, -0.003435135, 0.014945984, -0.017501831, -0.0037956238, 0.02407837, -0.006088257, 0.003271103, -0.011619568, 0.022476196, -0.001964569, -0.04220581, 0.01272583, -0.019302368, -0.033843994, 0.011260986, -0.015419006, -0.03274536, 0.04559326, 0.0068626404, -0.023712158, 0.015945435, -0.002292633, 0.028457642, 0.04348755, 0.0018615723, 0.04714966, -0.011489868, 0.021713257, -0.007633209, 0.054351807, 0.0041999817, 0.0024814606, 0.009590149, 0.015914917, -0.008285522, -0.0068588257, -0.00032687187, 0.0146484375, 0.0032348633, -0.0031833649, -0.021713257, 0.020401001, -0.04647827, -0.009712219, 0.017730713, 0.003458023, -0.008720398, -0.03692627, -0.008911133, -0.017028809, 0.019866943, -0.01777649, 0.011177063, 0.011749268, -0.0031375885, -0.0069007874, -0.005332947, -0.006996155, -0.030654907, 0.0012426376, -0.005508423, 0.026046753, 0.036865234, 0.026473999, -0.011222839, -0.01171875, -0.009933472, 0.0007777214, -0.004989624, -0.04647827, 0.012702942, -0.006122589, 0.04446411, 0.00009959936, 0.013412476, -0.0128479, -0.038391113, -0.021820068, 0.023727417, 0.04840088, -0.020370483, -0.002922058, -0.02331543, -0.0056266785, 0.012428284, -0.035491943, -0.020690918, 0.012390137, -0.0044555664, -0.044647217, -0.028823853, -0.050689697, -0.0362854, 0.0038490295, -0.011222839, -0.027267456, 0.05682373, -0.0129776, -0.013977051, 0.026306152, -0.05911255, 0.056427002, -0.018173218, -0.015144348, 0.017593384, -0.010231018, -0.046936035, -0.0058135986, 0.040283203, -0.010475159, 0.019851685, -0.032989502, -0.014221191, 0.015930176, 0.02444458, -0.04095459, -0.04321289, 0.012046814, -0.067993164, 0.055114746, 0.04034424, 0.05984497, 0.005970001, 0.031463623, -0.0013542175, 0.005142212, 0.021026611, -0.040496826, -0.0038795471, 0.02279663, 0.011108398, -0.058166504, 0.05609131, 0.042114258, -0.026916504, -0.037597656, 0.072143555, -0.004333496, 0.0013875961, 0.03729248, 0.021530151, -0.0018339157, 0.016357422, 0.024658203, -0.024246216, -0.012893677, -0.006248474, -0.011512756, 0.010124207, 0.026153564, 0.03475952, -0.030410767, -0.021240234, 0.0007305145, -0.017242432, 0.055541992, -0.04623413, 0.01713562, -0.032714844, 0.03781128, 0.005592346, -0.0067443848, 0.03149414, 0.021133423, -0.028869629, 0.019973755, 0.057525635, 0.05807495, 0.07366943, 0.057922363, -0.017532349, 0.012710571, 0.06665039, -0.01727295, 0.017822266, 0.014427185, -0.0029735565, -0.045684814, -0.014953613, -0.018798828, 0.006477356, -0.013145447, 0.07196045, -0.03765869, 0.021026611, 0.004547119, -0.026947021, -0.0076408386, 0.030548096, -0.003955841, -0.0054512024, -0.039855957, 0.034332275, 0.06427002, 0.011245728, 0.041900635, 0.020370483, -0.035614014, 0.06323242, -0.02494812, -0.017471313, -0.004714966, -0.002521515, -0.008934021, 0.002691269, 0.027709961, 0.047424316, -0.03616333, 0.01713562, 0.0072021484, 0.030426025, -0.0129470825, -0.042510986, 0.037322998, 0.026504517, 0.002714157, -0.014907837, 0.0028686523, -0.002840042, 0.055847168, -0.089904785, 0.06323242, -0.023254395, 0.01550293, 0.0018224716, -0.018539429, -0.013557434, -0.006137848, -0.019165039, 0.023162842, 0.0036029816, -0.02507019, -0.008995056, -0.0087509155, -0.007381439, -0.030715942, 0.019500732, 0.033813477, -0.029083252, -0.03643799, 0.02418518, 0.01776123, 0.03741455, -0.0076408386, 0.038909912, 0.015090942, 0.01335144, 0.0135269165, -0.0036354065, -0.045166016, -0.0031757355, 0.04937744, 0.052368164, 0.028198242, -0.032592773, 0.031677246, 0.018203735, 0.057678223, -0.00308609, -0.060760498, 0.03289795, -0.015357971, -0.076049805, -0.0049934387, -0.021347046, 0.027557373, -0.0007071495, -0.019760132, 0.022994995, -0.03668213, -0.009223938, -0.028533936, -0.0085372925, 0.010604858, 0.025161743, -0.02532959, 0.025314331, 0.0057258606, 0.05114746, -0.015808105, 0.01939392, 0.020141602, -0.016937256, 0.036956787, -0.04989624, 0.036499023, 0.028305054, -0.00049972534, 0.005622864, 0.012641907, 0.015411377, -0.0019245148, -0.008872986, 0.018173218, -0.056488037, -0.04083252, -0.013656616, -0.023040771, -0.0067443848, -0.04446411, 0.0413208, 0.016143799, -0.013694763, 0.02067566, 0.026016235, 0.030044556, 0.014183044, 0.019104004, 0.026306152, 0.011039734, -0.014640808 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2109.11542v1
ADVERSARIALuscator: An Adversarial-DRL Based Obfuscator and Metamorphic Malware SwarmGenerator
Mohit Sewak, Sanjay K. Sahay, Hemant Rathore
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Advanced metamorphic malware and ransomware, by using obfuscation, could alter their internal structure with every attack. If such malware could intrude even into any of the IoT networks, then even if the original malware instance gets detected, by that time it can still infect the entire network. It is challenging to obtain training data for such evasive malware. Therefore, in this paper, we present ADVERSARIALuscator, a novel system that uses specialized Adversarial-DRL to obfuscate malware at the opcode level and create multiple metamorphic instances of the same. To the best of our knowledge, ADVERSARIALuscator is the first-ever system that adopts the Markov Decision Process-based approach to convert and find a solution to the problem of creating individual obfuscations at the opcode level. This is important as the machine language level is the least at which functionality could be preserved so as to mimic an actual attack effectively. ADVERSARIALuscator is also the first-ever system to use efficient continuous action control capable of deep reinforcement learning agents like the Proximal Policy Optimization in the area of cyber security. Experimental results indicate that ADVERSARIALuscator could raise the metamorphic probability of a corpus of malware by >0.45. Additionally, more than 33% of metamorphic instances generated by ADVERSARIALuscator were able to evade the most potent IDS. If such malware could intrude even into any of the IoT networks, then even if the original malware instance gets detected, by that time it can still infect the entire network. Hence ADVERSARIALuscator could be used to generate data representative of a swarm of very potent and coordinated AI-based metamorphic malware attacks. The so generated data and simulations could be used to bolster the defenses of an IDS against an actual AI-based metamorphic attack from advanced malware and ransomware.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2109.11542v1
2021-09-23T10:50:41
2021-09-23T10:50:41
{ "title": [ -0.008087158, 0.024002075, -0.03353882, -0.049835205, 0.010169983, 0.008796692, -0.04522705, -0.030349731, -0.054748535, 0.050445557, 0.028884888, 0.004436493, -0.012641907, -0.028686523, -0.015823364, -0.01525116, -0.0044059753, 0.043823242, 0.007858276, -0.028823853, -0.0027122498, -0.03100586, 0.024978638, 0.005760193, -0.005092621, -0.032226562, -0.025665283, -0.016677856, -0.008087158, -0.03152466, -0.008354187, 0.031402588, 0.038909912, -0.017944336, -0.0031738281, -0.022064209, -0.0513916, 0.032165527, 0.008399963, -0.036834717, 0.006752014, -0.0006389618, -0.022201538, 0.009010315, -0.042816162, 0.022567749, -0.062286377, -0.02619934, -0.011962891, 0.05883789, 0.011375427, 0.002494812, -0.0075531006, 0.057495117, 0.015159607, -0.016601562, -0.033477783, 0.042938232, 0.033477783, 0.064086914, 0.017456055, -0.027175903, -0.010719299, -0.025772095, -0.0044937134, -0.02911377, -0.030212402, 0.03164673, 0.03741455, 0.00028920174, 0.011512756, 0.016296387, 0.030288696, -0.0049743652, -0.013916016, 0.0027484894, 0.0259552, 0.034454346, 0.04058838, -0.023513794, 0.020126343, -0.027145386, 0.031433105, 0.01423645, 0.019927979, 0.025497437, -0.011810303, -0.021057129, -0.017196655, -0.040893555, 0.0030212402, -0.007183075, -0.011550903, 0.013687134, -0.008369446, -0.035064697, -0.00655365, -0.019210815, 0.01473999, -0.007472992, -0.016815186, 0.013320923, -0.017745972, -0.0038070679, 0.007446289, 0.036102295, -0.0012350082, 0.0013532639, -0.002729416, 0.009223938, -0.023147583, -0.012298584, 0.01928711, 0.011444092, -0.015419006, -0.021316528, -0.018035889, 0.008972168, 0.0045776367, 0.016021729, 0.007987976, 0.0027942657, 0.062927246, -0.054534912, 0.0256958, 0.020706177, -0.047576904, -0.040283203, -0.0014972687, 0.025161743, -0.0063209534, 0.044036865, -0.08508301, -0.07067871, -0.055999756, 0.023010254, -0.0013217926, -0.004737854, 0.0072364807, -0.018753052, 0.037078857, -0.019622803, -0.009109497, 0.03741455, 0.0058937073, 0.0009441376, 0.045013428, 0.014549255, -0.020462036, -0.015640259, -0.026794434, 0.023162842, -0.0002708435, 0.02609253, -0.0020160675, -0.0039367676, -0.053649902, -0.011512756, 0.027770996, -0.0043945312, 0.01991272, 0.0049591064, 0.015731812, 0.040039062, 0.06781006, -0.014549255, -0.0024414062, 0.023422241, 0.006668091, 0.023880005, -0.009155273, 0.0020503998, 0.006275177, -0.024551392, -0.01576233, -0.011650085, -0.0030059814, 0.016540527, 0.02218628, -0.009170532, 0.0054626465, -0.021469116, 0.0146865845, 0.02798462, -0.07281494, -0.0014591217, 0.0010442734, 0.00774765, 0.05770874, -0.007144928, 0.0013618469, -0.00017368793, -0.029510498, -0.011116028, -0.032470703, -0.00491333, 0.013320923, 0.030151367, -0.012802124, 0.0038108826, -0.06451416, 0.03213501, -0.06750488, 0.026535034, -0.025100708, -0.021362305, -0.017044067, 0.035736084, -0.034179688, 0.03781128, 0.04788208, 0.00157547, -0.037261963, 0.01424408, 0.012641907, -0.051483154, -0.02810669, -0.019226074, -0.006526947, 0.001115799, -0.0138549805, -0.004119873, -0.0090789795, -0.020996094, 0.056884766, 0.033813477, 0.0012817383, -0.006919861, 0.10522461, 0.032043457, 0.06222534, -0.044311523, 0.05102539, 0.014907837, -0.017089844, -0.037475586, -0.042419434, -0.09918213, 0.0023841858, 0.06628418, 0.010818481, 0.007091522, 0.0087890625, 0.030059814, 0.093933105, -0.037475586, 0.0036468506, 0.029556274, 0.004886627, 0.0015525818, 0.027709961, 0.017654419, 0.03829956, 0.058258057, 0.004096985, 0.040252686, -0.01828003, 0.020568848, -0.033447266, -0.0096206665, 0.0067749023, 0.026855469, 0.015930176, 0.016174316, -0.047698975, -0.019302368, -0.012992859, 0.019866943, 0.016677856, -0.011817932, 0.024795532, -0.027313232, 0.022155762, -0.00440979, -0.025985718, -0.0007352829, -0.009483337, 0.0066108704, 0.046051025, -0.031341553, -0.0005927086, -0.003326416, 0.033477783, -0.0047416687, 0.03967285, 0.017303467, 0.031219482, -0.013404846, -0.053955078, -0.0031166077, 0.031402588, 0.070739746, 0.032226562, -0.007911682, 0.00067567825, 0.030532837, 0.07147217, 0.044921875, -0.0014162064, -0.0101623535, -0.043823242, 0.0060768127, -0.03515625, 0.013221741, -0.00069475174, -0.0030403137, 0.025161743, 0.015258789, -0.03286743, -0.013496399, -0.05496216, -0.020523071, 0.015434265, -0.022201538, -0.018936157, -0.050323486, -0.0015611649, -0.041870117, -0.06854248, -0.03125, 0.06695557, 0.0009822845, -0.030685425, 0.0023059845, -0.0015993118, -0.008003235, 0.0044021606, -0.032684326, -0.045440674, 0.020980835, 0.016952515, -0.0005750656, -0.038391113, 0.008903503, 0.0040626526, 0.018798828, -0.006385803, 0.022705078, -0.02508545, -0.03591919, 0.010528564, -0.023742676, 0.00081920624, 0.0006608963, 0.0012216568, -0.014343262, -0.007144928, 0.016342163, -0.051757812, 0.0021686554, 0.014297485, -0.03250122, -0.016616821, -0.004837036, 0.052764893, -0.004085541, -0.013870239, 0.020935059, 0.026000977, -0.0134887695, 0.04135132, 0.045166016, 0.05041504, -0.0046081543, -0.057403564, -0.06933594, 0.015350342, 0.010276794, 0.05545044, 0.07659912, 0.0038146973, 0.010498047, -0.047729492, 0.0041046143, 0.023773193, -0.041381836, 0.009475708, -0.02519226, -0.051513672, -0.028259277, 0.0055160522, -0.0016031265, -0.01927185, -0.008003235, 0.048065186, 0.010803223, -0.02319336, -0.0034160614, 0.012283325, -0.004825592, 0.021713257, 0.010673523, 0.027435303, -0.008422852, 0.012535095, -0.014717102, -0.006996155, 0.034240723, -0.06112671, 0.0018339157, 0.012008667, -0.0031032562, -0.011695862, -0.0071868896, -0.040161133, -0.050109863, -0.001616478, -0.02230835, 0.019073486, 0.029144287, 0.020324707, 0.003282547, 0.01499939, -0.0054130554, 0.010635376, -0.047973633, -0.07897949, 0.020248413, -0.022384644, 0.0019235611, 0.0065956116, -0.02180481, -0.011383057, 0.0062217712, -0.010932922, 0.046447754, 0.018585205, -0.010421753, 0.020721436, 0.010360718, 0.0010089874, -0.0027580261, -0.010360718, -0.016967773, -0.0446167, -0.019226074, 0.0010433197, 0.03363037, 0.056396484, -0.022521973, -0.019592285, -0.016845703, -0.0017929077, 0.0362854, 0.037231445, -0.04748535, -0.021850586, -0.04525757, -0.005569458, -0.0116119385, -0.0096206665, 0.016525269, 0.002565384, 0.008071899, -0.0012273788, 0.018829346, -0.014427185, 0.016433716, -0.05239868, -0.015563965, 0.019943237, -0.013519287, -0.046539307, -0.0079422, -0.0048179626, -0.014038086, 0.038879395, -0.020889282, -0.035736084, 0.031311035, -0.045043945, 0.022750854, 0.03668213, 0.006275177, -0.006877899, -0.017547607, -0.018188477, 0.022079468, -0.041625977, -0.020523071, 0.0015115738, -0.001698494, -0.009567261, -0.045684814, 0.006454468, 0.0038471222, -0.064819336, -0.008598328, 0.0124053955, -0.034576416, -0.047302246, -0.059539795, 0.004184723, -0.024856567, -0.04324341, 0.027130127, 0.0045280457, -0.0029506683, -0.00040864944, -0.069885254, -0.013908386, 0.066711426, -0.042510986, 0.012962341, 0.0132751465, -0.016311646, -0.0413208, -0.025131226, -0.006137848, -0.009651184, -0.0036907196, -0.008476257, -0.039764404, 0.031982422, -0.023803711, 0.016464233, 0.021118164, 0.017944336, -0.018371582, -0.007545471, -0.0064430237, 0.008323669, -0.021270752, 0.04837036, 0.013008118, -0.017028809, -0.06286621, 0.033081055, 0.0068473816, -0.02420044, 0.025466919, -0.025344849, 0.040252686, 0.058624268, -0.015106201, 0.03427124, -0.0071754456, 0.0018558502, 0.00021672249, -0.030563354, -0.0340271, -0.041625977, 0.0099105835, 0.003862381, -0.015899658, 0.030517578, -0.004184723, 0.054718018, -0.015686035, -0.029144287, 0.016174316, 0.056610107, -0.06488037, -0.019866943, -0.023803711, -0.005378723, 0.0012273788, 0.019439697, -0.036254883, 0.013038635, 0.02420044, -0.0075302124, -0.010673523, -0.01777649, 0.022827148, -0.0007863045, 0.022628784, -0.035461426, 0.011192322, -0.0041770935, -0.06378174, -0.040374756, 0.009025574, 0.00712204, 0.009666443, -0.017425537, -0.013504028, 0.032806396, 0.028259277, 0.07598877, 0.060546875, -0.014228821, -0.06506348, 0.043884277, -0.013374329, -0.023208618, 0.0023860931, 0.03955078, -0.0211792, -0.035369873, 0.007671356, -0.026473999, -0.024047852, -0.03982544, 0.02708435, 0.014381409, 0.021835327, 0.015296936, 0.031402588, 0.027496338, -0.012870789, -0.004383087, -0.0034008026, -0.03930664, 0.028503418, 0.0014486313, 0.03756714, -0.042144775, 0.024017334, 0.027236938, 0.007030487, -0.021713257, -0.015411377, 0.030776978, -0.0027751923, -0.010536194, 0.027786255, 0.016159058, -0.06161499, -0.03277588, -0.008781433, 0.015159607, 0.034606934, -0.060180664, 0.018951416, -0.0005764961, 0.012763977, 0.034973145, -0.004508972, 0.022247314, 0.022094727, 0.011917114, -0.042907715, -0.028717041, 0.016677856, 0.04006958, -0.030548096, -0.00844574, -0.013633728, 0.011299133, 0.022521973, 0.019744873, -0.00705719, 0.045196533, -0.031051636, 0.0033397675, 0.02696228, -0.030258179, -0.061553955, -0.022659302, -0.02722168, 0.01991272, -0.0017824173, 0.06536865, -0.051849365, 0.025680542, -0.028778076, 0.011985779, -0.0102005005, -0.05303955, 0.0095825195, 0.04824829, 0.02355957, 0.017578125, 0.0015926361, 0.01940918, 0.037994385, 0.04360962, 0.004764557, 0.018966675, 0.031402588, -0.021362305, -0.007434845, -0.011161804, 0.011009216, -0.0031280518, 0.04360962, 0.011833191, 0.020202637, -0.06726074, 0.02116394, 0.0335083, 0.01789856, 0.042816162, -0.07141113, 0.0140686035, -0.00014317036, 0.005176544, 0.005996704, -0.020690918, -0.032836914, 0.027191162, -0.022003174, 0.012237549, -0.012390137, -0.005138397, -0.09484863, -0.024169922, 0.044067383, 0.05419922, -0.017990112, -0.020629883, 0.008995056, -0.06173706, 0.026168823, 0.031234741, -0.035888672, -0.01977539, -0.01109314, 0.010421753, 0.009117126, 0.01109314, -0.032928467, 0.004306793, -0.03314209, -0.017059326, -0.03186035, -0.016784668, -0.00007915497, 0.03125, -0.052093506, -0.0072364807, -0.002527237, -0.02935791, 0.008110046, 0.005695343, -0.051086426, -0.019256592, 0.013214111, 0.017349243, 0.05429077, 0.06317139, -0.02659607, 0.0335083, 0.033721924, -0.005142212, 0.030319214, -0.047454834, -0.037994385, 0.020462036, -0.031585693, 0.026535034, 0.016998291, -0.012214661, -0.0357666, 0.020355225, 0.025665283, -0.023208618, 0.03781128, -0.010635376, 0.05895996, -0.004207611, -0.0110321045, -0.010131836, 0.004825592, -0.01953125, 0.08984375, 0.007286072, -0.014427185, -0.05142212, -0.080200195, -0.03149414, 0.004753113, 0.04510498, 0.040740967, 0.03805542, -0.034729004, 0.036132812, -0.03778076, -0.039367676, -0.055908203, 0.004623413, -0.008872986, 0.02935791, 0.07727051, -0.035949707, -0.022827148, -0.013313293, 0.03994751, 0.04144287, 0.0010900497, 0.038513184, -0.05078125, -0.018234253, -0.05154419, -0.029846191, 0.011978149, 0.050079346, -0.03466797, 0.0657959, -0.024383545, 0.060668945, -0.0016031265, 0.059539795, 0.028900146, 0.0090408325, 0.012908936, -0.0016651154, -0.010787964, -0.04321289, 0.038482666, -0.05343628, 0.020721436, -0.06964111, -0.009979248, -0.095458984, 0.0146484375, 0.010894775, 0.03604126, -0.02671814, 0.020370483, 0.028564453, 0.018463135, 0.04647827, -0.044952393, 0.06781006, -0.0010299683, -0.010864258, -0.01675415, -0.026290894, 0.039642334, 0.044799805, 0.00440979, 0.000060915947, -0.03326416, -0.031463623, 0.010391235, 0.03390503, 0.00074005127, -0.030899048, -0.0104599, -0.05392456, 0.009552002, -0.015625, 0.025314331, 0.059173584, 0.053253174, 0.03753662, -0.02204895, 0.0026016235, -0.036132812, -0.020614624, -0.0011701584, 0.012962341, -0.0021800995, 0.037231445, -0.04220581, -0.042144775, -0.044525146, -0.011009216, 0.017211914, -0.06829834, -0.038085938, 0.037963867, 0.02470398, 0.01864624, -0.012886047, -0.038269043, -0.033416748, -0.018753052, 0.015022278, -0.0026454926, 0.00818634, -0.0022296906, 0.0074806213, -0.01979065, -0.01638794, 0.0064926147, 0.032714844, -0.025009155, 0.01171875, -0.027633667, -0.009147644, -0.0154800415, -0.04336548, 0.004333496, 0.0069847107, -0.0178833, -0.03555298, 0.027786255, 0.068481445, 0.06341553, 0.07623291, 0.030944824, -0.009536743, 0.0423584, -0.028808594, 0.02067566, 0.054870605, -0.03604126, 0.010238647, -0.010139465, -0.020462036, 0.038238525, -0.03353882, 0.035064697, 0.0027923584, 0.030349731, -0.019714355, 0.01033783, 0.043701172, -0.0637207, 0.005973816, 0.012504578, 0.013793945, -0.015640259, 0.0030326843, -0.034118652, -0.038513184, -0.007762909, 0.059692383, -0.0012483597, 0.007896423, 0.024414062, -0.025787354, -0.032073975, 0.0010404587, -0.011604309, 0.028671265, -0.019378662, -0.011451721, -0.033721924, 0.02772522, -0.00094747543, -0.0042266846, -0.0012464523, 0.0047073364, -0.038909912, -0.020553589, 0.0023479462, -0.005558014, -0.023010254, 0.010475159, -0.034240723, 0.03704834, -0.03363037, 0.016571045, 0.045288086, -0.00548172, -0.0791626, -0.008850098, -0.024139404, 0.036987305, -0.010284424, -0.019058228, 0.019439697, 0.020141602, -0.031921387, 0.07623291, 0.044799805, 0.091552734, -0.038909912, -0.07043457, 0.023666382, 0.033599854, 0.06161499, -0.012107849, 0.0069236755, 0.028778076, 0.03366089, -0.017791748, 0.06390381, 0.00598526, 0.018997192, 0.037353516, 0.04937744, 0.0082092285, -0.064575195, -0.057891846, -0.019439697, 0.03579712, 0.025909424, -0.012840271, -0.03878784, 0.032470703, -0.0010375977, 0.036499023, 0.01914978, -0.04269409, 0.04949951, -0.018630981, 0.059051514, -0.007167816, 0.043914795, -0.009315491, 0.06161499, -0.0018167496, 0.07122803, -0.0026245117, 0.0132751465, 0.054595947, 0.053466797, -0.030136108, -0.078063965, 0.061920166, 0.05621338, -0.01121521, 0.05706787, -0.021194458, -0.011856079, -0.029571533, 0.01637268, 0.0017166138, 0.009407043, -0.008003235, 0.04071045, 0.053253174, -0.024337769, -0.047180176, -0.032409668, -0.037506104, 0.04067993, -0.04067993, 0.02281189, -0.026229858, -0.008407593, 0.012451172, 0.037597656, 0.02406311, 0.019042969, -0.064086914, -0.011383057, 0.029083252, -0.028823853 ], "summary": [ 0.007232666, -0.00074243546, 0.02633667, -0.005619049, -0.028884888, 0.01725769, -0.029083252, -0.058654785, -0.043395996, 0.029525757, 0.014778137, 0.011314392, -0.014320374, -0.032470703, 0.040374756, -0.026687622, 0.002796173, 0.037902832, 0.04373169, -0.0033550262, 0.0076675415, 0.014190674, 0.007259369, -0.027038574, -0.005126953, -0.04147339, -0.008911133, 0.00674057, 0.009315491, 0.014022827, 0.006175995, 0.014167786, 0.03164673, -0.023895264, -0.022506714, -0.049987793, -0.020614624, 0.003004074, -0.016479492, -0.02229309, 0.016601562, 0.015357971, 0.07305908, 0.023040771, 0.0048332214, 0.046722412, -0.034851074, -0.06222534, 0.042388916, 0.07104492, -0.0004286766, -0.009719849, -0.037719727, 0.009178162, 0.0034866333, -0.013122559, -0.030914307, 0.026763916, 0.025131226, 0.06427002, 0.014923096, 0.009246826, -0.023223877, -0.053619385, 0.034057617, -0.02645874, 0.027755737, 0.032470703, -0.004295349, 0.033172607, 0.028137207, -0.0037326813, 0.04006958, -0.031097412, 0.00283432, 0.0099105835, 0.02633667, 0.019515991, 0.00217247, -0.027801514, 0.036193848, -0.00894928, 0.04446411, -0.010353088, 0.02015686, 0.022949219, -0.008911133, -0.02204895, 0.0020370483, -0.02192688, -0.015823364, -0.04373169, 0.008361816, 0.027420044, 0.010505676, -0.036193848, -0.027252197, -0.05859375, 0.03942871, 0.033813477, 0.027862549, -0.04434204, 0.042785645, -0.026290894, -0.023773193, 0.059539795, 0.025253296, -0.016738892, -0.031143188, -0.0037784576, -0.015541077, -0.042419434, -0.02583313, -0.028823853, -0.017105103, 0.022384644, -0.011520386, 0.013008118, 0.009147644, 0.019439697, -0.0035381317, 0.03012085, 0.048706055, -0.05203247, 0.017990112, 0.017913818, -0.021942139, -0.050231934, 0.016342163, -0.027252197, -0.023590088, 0.02885437, 0.009552002, 0.01940918, 0.0025138855, 0.0008292198, 0.031951904, 0.036895752, 0.053344727, -0.029373169, 0.07458496, -0.0017824173, -0.018005371, 0.079589844, -0.016601562, 0.018829346, 0.007820129, 0.012428284, -0.00705719, -0.036743164, 0.008346558, -0.040527344, 0.02633667, 0.016113281, 0.03781128, -0.02885437, 0.048431396, -0.016799927, 0.0076446533, -0.034484863, 0.040771484, -0.01109314, -0.013389587, 0.09881592, 0.057281494, 0.0022850037, 0.030776978, 0.015182495, 0.007411957, 0.0289917, -0.025665283, 0.0044059753, -0.013191223, -0.02432251, -0.02027893, -0.013008118, -0.0012702942, 0.01020813, 0.034301758, -0.034118652, -0.0131073, -0.037200928, 0.050445557, -0.009429932, -0.048065186, 0.035583496, -0.01184082, 0.03970337, 0.06890869, -0.00015759468, 0.008682251, -0.050811768, -0.0023345947, 0.042663574, 0.0037593842, 0.0016622543, -0.033355713, 0.036621094, -0.023086548, -0.06463623, -0.025863647, 0.035705566, -0.07763672, -0.0008711815, -0.099121094, -0.0055656433, -0.025161743, 0.051116943, -0.056365967, -0.0058555603, 0.03756714, -0.057281494, -0.012420654, 0.028717041, 0.014389038, -0.027450562, -0.007671356, -0.020874023, 0.013137817, -0.030517578, -0.007881165, 0.0005803108, -0.028915405, -0.005596161, 0.03994751, 0.025054932, -0.042144775, 0.004096985, 0.080322266, 0.026748657, 0.038726807, -0.0038795471, 0.028930664, -0.01776123, -0.05203247, -0.042663574, -0.028045654, -0.11260986, 0.0075149536, 0.09320068, -0.010322571, 0.024963379, -0.05831909, 0.013824463, -0.0006904602, -0.03640747, -0.017211914, 0.037017822, -0.06384277, -0.023513794, 0.026443481, 0.004814148, 0.015823364, 0.04623413, -0.018005371, 0.022857666, -0.030410767, -0.022354126, -0.025421143, 0.007572174, 0.02166748, 0.020996094, 0.0014476776, 0.013214111, 0.0019073486, -0.047576904, 0.0062828064, -0.0033931732, 0.0035915375, -0.0418396, 0.026229858, -0.0066375732, 0.02279663, -0.0032482147, -0.05178833, 0.011787415, -0.041870117, 0.010551453, 0.04269409, -0.0048713684, -0.0021457672, 0.0008072853, -0.035308838, -0.0071029663, 0.055145264, 0.03640747, -0.011482239, -0.009117126, 0.017959595, 0.048706055, 0.03555298, 0.05581665, 0.04711914, 0.0046463013, 0.006336212, 0.014930725, 0.047332764, 0.00881958, 0.040100098, -0.06640625, -0.021057129, 0.017089844, -0.08135986, 0.023452759, -0.004184723, -0.02053833, -0.03515625, 0.04446411, 0.0132751465, -0.047058105, -0.016082764, 0.0011177063, 0.025497437, 0.072631836, -0.052093506, -0.057128906, -0.008850098, 0.018081665, -0.03286743, -0.015655518, 0.06518555, 0.014762878, 0.021224976, -0.003736496, 0.0071105957, -0.04751587, 0.027709961, -0.010139465, -0.035003662, 0.0032405853, 0.011260986, -0.04058838, -0.0121154785, 0.0061950684, 0.012046814, -0.0022029877, 0.011138916, 0.020248413, 0.00932312, -0.037902832, 0.059936523, 0.018844604, -0.016174316, 0.06097412, -0.015914917, -0.010559082, -0.022369385, 0.0024051666, -0.047180176, -0.013214111, 0.019256592, -0.023742676, -0.032592773, 0.026824951, 0.028625488, 0.023925781, 0.0149383545, 0.01902771, 0.050689697, -0.01474762, 0.051361084, 0.053100586, 0.047424316, -0.0009832382, -0.06774902, -0.074523926, 0.06665039, -0.01852417, 0.06210327, 0.06781006, 0.01675415, 0.03366089, -0.05166626, -0.0045280457, 0.014404297, -0.023803711, 0.06774902, 0.011695862, -0.04208374, 0.016448975, 0.026855469, 0.025421143, -0.0056533813, -0.012123108, 0.050933838, 0.008308411, 0.0070228577, 0.036468506, 0.011543274, -0.018722534, 0.007335663, 0.013633728, 0.02470398, -0.019042969, -0.008102417, -0.022079468, 0.023788452, 0.057739258, 0.005092621, -0.034240723, 0.003227234, 0.01838684, 0.008766174, -0.01576233, -0.02130127, -0.0037021637, 0.015640259, -0.008728027, 0.013832092, -0.013809204, 0.027786255, -0.011505127, 0.021133423, -0.022567749, 0.014457703, -0.045898438, 0.010696411, -0.00056552887, -0.008895874, 0.002866745, -0.0048179626, 0.056030273, 0.002073288, 0.016586304, -0.010383606, 0.03363037, -0.011833191, -0.0014286041, 0.023757935, 0.028045654, -0.013923645, 0.0027008057, 0.00030517578, 0.0053901672, -0.041259766, -0.015838623, 0.0075187683, -0.012458801, 0.06842041, -0.05834961, -0.046936035, -0.0023269653, -0.003156662, 0.009094238, 0.021514893, -0.04815674, 0.0033092499, -0.07763672, 0.0068473816, 0.008728027, -0.0067634583, 0.0029087067, 0.056762695, 0.026321411, -0.005874634, 0.023498535, -0.029907227, 0.025177002, -0.018508911, -0.005405426, 0.034576416, 0.01210022, -0.05899048, -0.009101868, 0.022476196, -0.03086853, 0.018356323, -0.010070801, -0.038604736, 0.047668457, -0.016204834, 0.00340271, 0.045288086, -0.008415222, -0.04260254, -0.042633057, 0.0463562, -0.0054092407, 0.01878357, -0.041625977, -0.023590088, 0.014640808, -0.054656982, -0.021591187, -0.026489258, 0.009033203, -0.057891846, -0.022567749, 0.013626099, -0.009529114, -0.013793945, -0.03164673, 0.012886047, -0.006965637, -0.0014429092, 0.012527466, 0.0030727386, 0.031402588, -0.0140686035, -0.04534912, 0.008285522, 0.0054779053, -0.03479004, 0.036865234, -0.028335571, 0.013786316, 0.0028762817, -0.01373291, -0.009544373, -0.020629883, -0.022979736, -0.033447266, 0.0033493042, 0.023010254, -0.013069153, 0.008094788, 0.018066406, 0.057525635, -0.026290894, -0.018753052, 0.014968872, 0.037506104, -0.022857666, 0.02204895, 0.014350891, 0.0126953125, -0.052337646, 0.032440186, -0.0031280518, -0.036224365, 0.042907715, 0.04257202, 0.0309906, 0.046783447, -0.022598267, -0.007850647, -0.01235199, -0.015930176, 0.009216309, -0.008544922, -0.015106201, -0.015808105, 0.0016298294, 0.034332275, -0.017501831, 0.022979736, 0.0047912598, 0.058410645, -0.029342651, 0.017623901, 0.0024871826, 0.015487671, -0.038726807, -0.038116455, -0.020828247, 0.06732178, 0.0012731552, -0.0005517006, -0.027893066, 0.023635864, 0.014732361, 0.00894928, -0.0015058517, -0.034454346, 0.011558533, 0.02748108, -0.026535034, -0.06549072, -0.010025024, -0.0046463013, -0.048919678, -0.019012451, 0.018829346, -0.0052261353, -0.021392822, -0.022781372, -0.026153564, 0.018707275, 0.02696228, 0.085998535, 0.05581665, 0.014724731, -0.076538086, 0.02293396, -0.029312134, 0.0234375, 0.0045433044, 0.020477295, -0.0038261414, -0.00522995, 0.020751953, -0.012413025, -0.034301758, -0.030700684, 0.005836487, 0.024627686, 0.020599365, 0.036834717, 0.03543091, 0.020507812, -0.032592773, 0.0034923553, 0.0085372925, -0.03201294, 0.019836426, 0.022720337, 0.024154663, -0.04397583, 0.0038757324, 0.012901306, 0.0018234253, -0.010765076, -0.032409668, 0.016479492, -0.023498535, 0.0044937134, 0.0001116395, 0.0154418945, -0.029052734, -0.029647827, -0.012916565, 0.01713562, 0.0072898865, -0.0025157928, -0.019744873, 0.007129669, 0.025039673, 0.031677246, -0.008956909, 0.029266357, 0.03778076, 0.003856659, -0.03616333, -0.017456055, 0.008010864, 0.024017334, -0.0074157715, -0.017105103, -0.008270264, -0.033081055, 0.024459839, 0.0074424744, -0.011619568, 0.000026524067, -0.007587433, 0.001991272, 0.004776001, -0.01914978, -0.050048828, -0.022872925, -0.06842041, 0.015823364, 0.038757324, 0.04937744, -0.021209717, 0.025848389, -0.031311035, 0.01586914, -0.012290955, -0.022125244, -0.06561279, -0.0068511963, -0.019042969, -0.0027866364, 0.008155823, 0.013916016, -0.015090942, 0.033569336, -0.043548584, 0.043548584, 0.019119263, 0.009735107, -0.033599854, -0.034484863, -0.013877869, 0.02027893, 0.01965332, 0.019546509, 0.003025055, -0.038146973, 0.0101623535, 0.0074043274, -0.015548706, 0.021881104, -0.03387451, 0.01776123, -0.021438599, 0.015701294, -0.0068626404, 0.03112793, -0.020309448, 0.0138168335, 0.01373291, 0.025787354, -0.046142578, 0.011138916, -0.052520752, 0.01461792, 0.05831909, 0.033569336, 0.013153076, -0.001791954, -0.026519775, -0.023590088, -0.019363403, 0.021636963, -0.007408142, -0.01423645, -0.04812622, 0.02734375, -0.02760315, -0.004322052, -0.02017212, -0.0026893616, -0.06750488, -0.010620117, -0.010986328, -0.061340332, -0.022705078, 0.07977295, -0.027908325, 0.015960693, 0.027694702, -0.021957397, 0.027893066, -0.0045051575, -0.041107178, -0.012413025, 0.01574707, 0.0014915466, 0.051818848, 0.0022449493, -0.05734253, 0.03768921, 0.048095703, -0.027175903, 0.0055351257, -0.028900146, -0.034088135, 0.007785797, 0.01889038, 0.0006451607, 0.019744873, 0.0033359528, -0.032196045, 0.026641846, 0.022369385, -0.024612427, 0.013755798, -0.012580872, 0.023986816, 0.013641357, 0.0010576248, -0.019485474, 0.036254883, -0.0068130493, 0.05496216, -0.016159058, -0.013656616, -0.018447876, -0.08666992, 0.00038671494, 0.0073051453, 0.03704834, 0.07672119, 0.07366943, 0.007713318, 0.039733887, 0.0034751892, -0.029647827, -0.01499939, -0.036224365, 0.0019893646, 0.04989624, 0.062469482, 0.017700195, -0.034484863, 0.0014295578, 0.025909424, 0.03765869, -0.0038871765, 0.06414795, -0.019851685, -0.018692017, -0.048309326, 0.00011950731, -0.0059814453, 0.06341553, -0.013496399, 0.04171753, 0.0073509216, 0.027496338, -0.0017948151, 0.023773193, -0.00023829937, 0.0052108765, 0.025222778, -0.01828003, -0.01928711, -0.020324707, 0.07373047, -0.007534027, -0.016281128, -0.06463623, -0.04736328, -0.07318115, 0.042236328, -0.0066871643, -0.010185242, 0.02230835, 0.010185242, 0.040771484, 0.011108398, -0.0020580292, -0.061157227, 0.022827148, 0.014152527, -0.005645752, 0.0046577454, -0.021362305, 0.0063323975, 0.032989502, -0.009178162, 0.02659607, -0.03894043, 0.0104599, -0.0088272095, -0.009788513, -0.014053345, -0.064697266, 0.0077934265, -0.04260254, 0.0045318604, -0.0064964294, 0.02973938, 0.013168335, 0.022964478, 0.08135986, -0.02911377, -0.0047187805, -0.01713562, 0.023117065, -0.025375366, -0.021530151, 0.04724121, 0.0055160522, -0.008071899, -0.027877808, -0.037506104, -0.013885498, 0.028366089, -0.05038452, -0.013664246, 0.0072402954, 0.017425537, -0.007904053, 0.004600525, -0.040618896, -0.037841797, -0.059265137, -0.0022563934, -0.006340027, -0.01625061, -0.012321472, -0.015037537, -0.0032920837, 0.017425537, 0.0052604675, 0.055511475, 0.0032653809, 0.014755249, -0.070739746, -0.027267456, 0.019973755, -0.016815186, 0.0143966675, 0.012046814, 0.03564453, 0.0062789917, 0.04849243, 0.085632324, 0.046966553, 0.04360962, -0.022705078, -0.019882202, 0.077697754, -0.021560669, 0.011268616, -0.01033783, -0.016342163, -0.03466797, 0.019958496, 0.019622803, 0.033813477, 0.024978638, 0.0010871887, 0.020111084, 0.04043579, -0.029251099, -0.008728027, -0.0055389404, -0.05444336, 0.05895996, -0.008415222, 0.053253174, -0.019958496, 0.029006958, -0.024032593, -0.02305603, -0.007183075, 0.051605225, 0.0039100647, -0.007987976, 0.010620117, -0.008979797, 0.016921997, -0.011726379, -0.009490967, 0.0395813, 0.0059890747, -0.0028495789, -0.01423645, 0.041412354, -0.026321411, -0.04067993, 0.011100769, 0.034088135, 0.011405945, -0.01991272, -0.0038108826, -0.004386902, -0.013580322, 0.037902832, -0.04031372, 0.03933716, -0.017974854, 0.008155823, 0.042419434, 0.007801056, -0.07904053, -0.024505615, 0.022155762, 0.017425537, -0.014816284, -0.0026626587, 0.016967773, 0.042663574, -0.014015198, 0.05908203, 0.035064697, 0.05380249, -0.052764893, -0.07434082, 0.008178711, 0.04171753, 0.04107666, 0.009216309, 0.0657959, 0.06542969, 0.04776001, 0.00818634, 0.020828247, -0.02911377, 0.0287323, 0.077941895, 0.07659912, 0.022018433, -0.08251953, -0.053466797, -0.008338928, 0.04260254, 0.007587433, -0.022506714, -0.029129028, 0.032440186, -0.015419006, 0.01524353, 0.004272461, -0.042266846, 0.003232956, -0.0066184998, 0.02935791, 0.008522034, -0.00019574165, 0.039611816, 0.03967285, -0.018005371, 0.04675293, -0.0087509155, -0.011009216, 0.046203613, -0.005672455, -0.020126343, -0.06011963, 0.049194336, 0.037078857, -0.005180359, -0.016494751, -0.005455017, -0.00037813187, -0.0027046204, 0.012748718, 0.022491455, 0.01864624, -0.043548584, 0.013870239, 0.00995636, -0.035186768, -0.031051636, -0.041748047, -0.044067383, 0.029785156, -0.019104004, 0.017715454, 0.023162842, 0.012611389, 0.02720642, 0.021331787, 0.026824951, 0.05291748, -0.031219482, 0.0015735626, 0.0022792816, -0.0137786865 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2109.14878v1
Accelerating Fully Connected Neural Network on Optical Network-on-Chip (ONoC)
Fei Dai, Yawen Chen, Haibo Zhang, Zhiyi Huang
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.LG
Fully Connected Neural Network (FCNN) is a class of Artificial Neural Networks widely used in computer science and engineering, whereas the training process can take a long time with large datasets in existing many-core systems. Optical Network-on-Chip (ONoC), an emerging chip-scale optical interconnection technology, has great potential to accelerate the training of FCNN with low transmission delay, low power consumption, and high throughput. However, existing methods based on Electrical Network-on-Chip (ENoC) cannot fit in ONoC because of the unique properties of ONoC. In this paper, we propose a fine-grained parallel computing model for accelerating FCNN training on ONoC and derive the optimal number of cores for each execution stage with the objective of minimizing the total amount of time to complete one epoch of FCNN training. To allocate the optimal number of cores for each execution stage, we present three mapping strategies and compare their advantages and disadvantages in terms of hotspot level, memory requirement, and state transitions. Simulation results show that the average prediction error for the optimal number of cores in NN benchmarks is within 2.3%. We further carry out extensive simulations which demonstrate that FCNN training time can be reduced by 22.28% and 4.91% on average using our proposed scheme, compared with traditional parallel computing methods that either allocate a fixed number of cores or allocate as many cores as possible, respectively. Compared with ENoC, simulation results show that under batch sizes of 64 and 128, on average ONoC can achieve 21.02% and 12.95% on reducing training time with 47.85% and 39.27% on saving energy, respectively.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2109.14878v1
2021-09-30T06:54:55
2021-09-30T06:54:55
{ "title": [ -0.019714355, -0.004951477, -0.024658203, -0.031982422, 0.015205383, -0.014167786, 0.006702423, -0.012336731, -0.007701874, 0.042114258, -0.013008118, 0.009811401, 0.021194458, -0.017730713, -0.022750854, -0.00042676926, 0.0146484375, 0.000893116, 0.0066375732, -0.017364502, -0.013671875, -0.019577026, 0.07952881, 0.029220581, 0.009422302, -0.0463562, -0.07043457, 0.0037631989, -0.04815674, -0.049987793, -0.010429382, 0.05758667, 0.049072266, 0.03010559, -0.05380249, -0.003566742, -0.056365967, 0.033996582, -0.013069153, -0.013328552, 0.009773254, 0.0038909912, 0.0015039444, -0.038391113, -0.0025367737, 0.024215698, -0.060943604, -0.022766113, -0.014205933, 0.03201294, 0.022094727, 0.036102295, 0.0057373047, 0.058807373, 0.0073165894, -0.028808594, -0.0140686035, -0.015823364, 0.0390625, 0.04611206, 0.006679535, -0.043823242, 0.017730713, -0.02709961, -0.001660347, -0.009811401, 0.01260376, 0.023452759, 0.043121338, 0.027114868, -0.019241333, 0.0061302185, -0.022964478, 0.03427124, -0.027175903, -0.010803223, 0.028045654, 0.0032100677, 0.031311035, 0.018585205, 0.0023021698, -0.013130188, -0.0066070557, -0.02444458, 0.027526855, -0.024017334, -0.012321472, -0.010749817, -0.043395996, -0.054718018, -0.020935059, 0.017868042, -0.002735138, -0.03086853, -0.049926758, -0.005012512, -0.039123535, -0.03491211, 0.03668213, 0.029693604, 0.029632568, -0.02885437, 0.023864746, -0.018234253, 0.030792236, 0.027267456, -0.013313293, -0.046173096, 0.026672363, 0.0135269165, -0.012039185, 0.054351807, 0.012619019, -0.013023376, -0.010665894, -0.029312134, -0.00894165, -0.007736206, 0.013404846, -0.009757996, -0.01701355, -0.035095215, 0.0030460358, -0.006855011, 0.046905518, 0.020935059, -0.042175293, 0.027313232, -0.022201538, 0.032562256, 0.011367798, 0.03213501, -0.11566162, -0.08380127, -0.08319092, 0.03643799, 0.0033245087, 0.028060913, 0.03112793, -0.025436401, 0.08404541, -0.040161133, -0.055267334, 0.087402344, -0.019210815, -0.010284424, 0.043640137, 0.019607544, -0.046081543, -0.027175903, -0.047210693, 0.030090332, 0.006580353, 0.008087158, -0.017990112, 0.009025574, -0.0793457, -0.024124146, 0.0058631897, 0.006210327, 0.03869629, 0.025802612, 0.004787445, 0.04135132, 0.07019043, -0.021560669, -0.024459839, 0.027252197, -0.0014324188, 0.0090789795, -0.009521484, 0.010314941, 0.0036296844, -0.03237915, -0.013412476, 0.0015230179, 0.01739502, -0.0052986145, 0.009254456, -0.020874023, -0.0019407272, -0.037384033, -0.034484863, 0.049224854, -0.05807495, -0.016723633, -0.01020813, -0.0008111, 0.06896973, 0.0045051575, -0.051971436, 0.0019273758, -0.03704834, -0.06286621, -0.049835205, 0.0027675629, 0.035339355, 0.028244019, -0.00920105, 0.06262207, -0.06866455, 0.005329132, -0.031402588, 0.022918701, 0.004535675, -0.028320312, -0.0025157928, 0.022537231, -0.007572174, 0.03677368, 0.026107788, -0.013267517, -0.006286621, -0.004196167, -0.021331787, -0.07141113, 0.001329422, 0.0005917549, 0.0057373047, -0.009933472, 0.019226074, -0.010772705, 0.042144775, 0.029922485, 0.0259552, 0.02482605, -0.006866455, -0.01676941, 0.06378174, 0.034942627, 0.06842041, -0.04019165, 0.012832642, 0.014625549, 0.0075912476, -0.0052261353, 0.00223732, -0.0051078796, 0.018798828, 0.009902954, -0.0038261414, -0.042663574, 0.0028381348, 0.054138184, 0.027038574, -0.013267517, 0.00680542, 0.028305054, 0.01537323, -0.009254456, 0.0657959, -0.0002567768, 0.06604004, 0.031463623, 0.032592773, 0.034729004, 0.034942627, 0.040100098, -0.03591919, 0.02519226, -0.00040483475, 0.09161377, 0.01889038, 0.04421997, -0.05441284, 0.0031700134, -0.03387451, -0.00074625015, 0.006324768, 0.013961792, 0.036071777, -0.028945923, -0.005355835, -0.030700684, -0.04977417, -0.048614502, -0.015808105, 0.046203613, -0.027069092, -0.057159424, -0.012741089, 0.01247406, 0.043426514, -0.00058841705, 0.031219482, 0.004558563, 0.013923645, -0.015106201, -0.021697998, -0.032989502, 0.032958984, 0.01739502, -0.0009717941, 0.009391785, -0.009338379, -0.0026168823, 0.046966553, 0.072631836, -0.015197754, 0.019638062, -0.070739746, 0.0060272217, -0.010551453, -0.020935059, 0.001168251, 0.0034236908, -0.008087158, 0.0024585724, -0.021347046, -0.002445221, -0.04537964, 0.04156494, 0.005077362, -0.045135498, -0.02305603, -0.03488159, -0.019424438, -0.053588867, -0.0637207, -0.025817871, 0.07904053, 0.00868988, -0.0059318542, -0.017166138, 0.013336182, -0.029159546, -0.03842163, -0.036315918, -0.03866577, 0.047088623, 0.044891357, 0.030197144, -0.029388428, 0.009651184, -0.0012512207, 0.024612427, 0.0016508102, -0.015808105, -0.020263672, 0.019729614, 0.041015625, 0.01361084, -0.0005245209, -0.056671143, -0.013931274, -0.022460938, -0.008392334, 0.013824463, -0.055145264, -0.004180908, 0.03475952, -0.011962891, -0.025787354, 0.030303955, 0.021759033, -0.027069092, 0.010437012, 0.047302246, -0.0012311935, 0.00078344345, 0.033996582, 0.012611389, 0.010223389, -0.043518066, -0.026672363, -0.03781128, -0.012969971, -0.006099701, -0.029251099, 0.027633667, -0.052246094, -0.026046753, -0.022338867, -0.015686035, -0.006290436, 0.017410278, 0.0065460205, -0.028717041, -0.03729248, -0.017196655, 0.007911682, 0.017318726, -0.013961792, -0.0040397644, 0.053894043, -0.015586853, -0.03930664, -0.034301758, 0.041931152, 0.017807007, 0.018493652, -0.021957397, -0.01914978, 0.002544403, 0.005760193, -0.004562378, 0.0025672913, -0.014251709, -0.07672119, -0.014083862, 0.0592041, 0.0050468445, -0.030075073, 0.023361206, -0.052703857, 0.008880615, 0.019195557, 0.0018835068, 0.018936157, 0.057525635, -0.027374268, 0.028457642, -0.002193451, -0.009796143, 0.013442993, -0.01322937, -0.09863281, 0.020507812, -0.0093688965, -0.014930725, -0.032562256, 0.031829834, -0.06829834, -0.0031089783, 0.007987976, 0.041900635, 0.038391113, -0.0047073364, 0.028701782, 0.0025997162, 0.019363403, -0.020324707, -0.021697998, -0.008476257, -0.018432617, 0.013504028, 0.003501892, 0.046173096, 0.033966064, 0.0025482178, -0.04434204, -0.01108551, 0.027069092, 0.041534424, 0.024169922, -0.02810669, -0.029022217, -0.038848877, -0.0035305023, 0.002254486, -0.013557434, -0.0025939941, -0.01751709, 0.008926392, -0.030136108, 0.03048706, 0.033477783, 0.009170532, -0.011604309, -0.0051116943, 0.03050232, -0.019973755, -0.051513672, 0.028045654, 0.0096588135, 0.03375244, -0.010185242, -0.0038890839, -0.06008911, 0.030395508, -0.014411926, 0.0019388199, 0.021484375, -0.023117065, -0.001326561, 0.000059604645, -0.0184021, -0.016448975, -0.0146102905, -0.0030117035, 0.0043907166, -0.00844574, -0.015670776, -0.0038700104, 0.04034424, -0.01058197, -0.04107666, -0.007785797, 0.014434814, -0.009147644, -0.022003174, -0.072387695, 0.02180481, -0.015090942, -0.04559326, 0.028274536, -0.005771637, -0.00894928, 0.00004553795, -0.05984497, -0.031951904, 0.07128906, -0.005996704, 0.016357422, -0.014625549, 0.02609253, 0.0024318695, -0.019622803, 0.004432678, -0.055023193, 0.026931763, -0.046051025, -0.03137207, 0.038848877, -0.048980713, 0.02217102, -0.008239746, -0.014144897, -0.0149383545, 0.014122009, 0.0019817352, 0.016479492, -0.032196045, 0.05734253, 0.035858154, -0.03515625, -0.04916382, 0.0093688965, -0.011154175, -0.011062622, 0.0385437, -0.035308838, 0.056274414, 0.035888672, -0.008514404, 0.056915283, -0.016967773, 0.017120361, 0.036346436, -0.036071777, -0.036376953, -0.025115967, 0.019546509, -0.010917664, -0.005405426, 0.032196045, -0.014007568, 0.06008911, -0.044769287, -0.0025157928, 0.021713257, 0.011428833, -0.0015048981, -0.03515625, -0.084472656, 0.013450623, 0.03918457, -0.009109497, -0.027374268, 0.035308838, 0.04840088, 0.012023926, -0.04598999, -0.0020523071, 0.041137695, -0.022949219, 0.023422241, -0.050994873, -0.0031356812, -0.019515991, -0.048858643, -0.025558472, 0.01927185, -0.00283432, 0.03289795, -0.024856567, -0.013175964, -0.0013179779, 0.0143585205, 0.046661377, 0.026794434, 0.0040130615, -0.0390625, 0.017959595, 0.0026512146, -0.0038414001, 0.0050315857, 0.030166626, 0.0051002502, -0.03616333, -0.01763916, -0.0078125, 0.008628845, -0.04949951, 0.0042800903, -0.015563965, 0.021133423, -0.020446777, 0.023468018, 0.009147644, 0.02279663, 0.028167725, 0.0211792, -0.031677246, -0.048309326, 0.011314392, 0.05328369, -0.014671326, 0.015548706, 0.035339355, 0.022613525, -0.008041382, -0.009567261, 0.04260254, 0.02267456, -0.032928467, -0.013374329, 0.019180298, -0.023406982, -0.028869629, 0.0049095154, -0.0072364807, 0.051757812, -0.025665283, 0.05340576, -0.044403076, -0.011550903, -0.0021324158, -0.0018825531, 0.010398865, -0.018600464, 0.016113281, -0.06347656, -0.0657959, -0.021957397, 0.053985596, -0.025268555, -0.020019531, 0.01600647, 0.042175293, -0.0010175705, 0.056732178, 0.020706177, 0.01852417, 0.03010559, -0.005302429, 0.006500244, -0.020385742, -0.037719727, 0.007965088, -0.030258179, 0.004749298, -0.04888916, -0.00078487396, -0.04196167, -0.020843506, -0.02407837, 0.0010213852, -0.011421204, -0.050231934, 0.007610321, 0.041809082, 0.013183594, 0.023910522, 0.048065186, 0.008880615, 0.0042037964, 0.020965576, -0.011528015, 0.06262207, -0.0061187744, -0.03778076, 0.04449463, 0.010108948, 0.03326416, -0.0008254051, 0.00014257431, -0.0049057007, 0.0090789795, -0.023544312, 0.01689148, 0.0138168335, 0.022140503, 0.02331543, -0.051727295, 0.022506714, 0.008995056, -0.0071144104, -0.0047569275, -0.05657959, -0.02508545, 0.053833008, -0.050689697, 0.009536743, 0.02532959, -0.022964478, -0.036743164, -0.025436401, 0.01687622, 0.007209778, 0.0019187927, -0.016098022, 0.018188477, -0.023269653, 0.033599854, 0.03286743, -0.058380127, -0.02507019, -0.0032310486, 0.024169922, 0.021942139, 0.013534546, -0.043273926, 0.006126404, 0.0077781677, -0.04598999, -0.043304443, 0.0018978119, -0.010498047, -0.017074585, -0.0022907257, -0.025772095, 0.0063209534, -0.0018320084, 0.021514893, 0.009048462, -0.020431519, 0.032562256, 0.0054512024, 0.015571594, -0.008834839, 0.04522705, 0.005279541, -0.0068473816, 0.0018062592, -0.022354126, 0.008460999, -0.039611816, -0.0074882507, -0.051208496, -0.07879639, 0.016937256, 0.0038375854, 0.015808105, 0.00497818, 0.016143799, 0.042419434, 0.006084442, -0.005004883, 0.010971069, 0.06719971, -0.05142212, -0.017959595, 0.0014333725, 0.015045166, -0.009529114, 0.00086927414, -0.01953125, -0.0026721954, -0.019134521, -0.066711426, -0.038726807, 0.014968872, 0.041046143, 0.034179688, 0.062072754, -0.05319214, 0.00920105, -0.020080566, -0.009712219, -0.03289795, 0.026443481, -0.006706238, -0.0004208088, 0.010650635, -0.020706177, 0.025268555, -0.0082092285, 0.018814087, -0.0072898865, -0.034698486, 0.0074157715, -0.055755615, 0.019439697, -0.0064086914, -0.03677368, 0.03326416, -0.010627747, 0.0015125275, 0.03152466, -0.042236328, 0.040039062, 0.033294678, 0.068847656, 0.07720947, 0.008125305, 0.006591797, 0.012496948, 0.0046157837, -0.031707764, -0.011482239, -0.05218506, -0.024551392, -0.059417725, -0.01864624, -0.029006958, 0.009666443, -0.018005371, 0.059661865, -0.0063056946, 0.028549194, 0.005432129, -0.00198555, 0.070007324, -0.010185242, 0.08959961, -0.0025310516, 0.011184692, -0.026062012, 0.026489258, 0.0087509155, 0.017501831, -0.004005432, 0.03933716, 0.0010290146, -0.017654419, 0.017410278, 0.010437012, 0.02470398, -0.00025439262, -0.016998291, -0.012031555, 0.076660156, 0.022857666, 0.05227661, 0.047607422, 0.046295166, -0.03466797, -0.017608643, 0.006828308, 0.022277832, -0.040405273, 0.03652954, 0.06335449, -0.0836792, 0.024047852, -0.010627747, -0.0317688, -0.03137207, 0.04574585, 0.015281677, -0.042541504, -0.010597229, 0.035217285, 0.028167725, -0.013061523, -0.0014352798, -0.036010742, 0.015541077, 0.052520752, 0.010520935, -0.0025672913, -0.0011901855, 0.02494812, 0.024536133, 0.020553589, 0.009513855, -0.00017428398, 0.050933838, 0.0046081543, 0.014060974, -0.041381836, 0.046875, 0.03149414, -0.031799316, 0.013534546, 0.032592773, -0.071899414, 0.010398865, 0.019119263, 0.064575195, 0.032684326, 0.05734253, 0.00031018257, -0.02355957, 0.033721924, -0.032806396, 0.03253174, 0.05432129, -0.04949951, 0.012054443, -0.023880005, -0.038360596, 0.026428223, -0.044708252, 0.056884766, -0.03643799, 0.01424408, -0.020843506, 0.01876831, 0.003944397, -0.031829834, -0.011184692, -0.02444458, -0.0385437, -0.0016841888, 0.0020446777, 0.00762558, -0.015434265, -0.00091028214, 0.03845215, 0.024353027, 0.0012187958, 0.00687027, -0.015312195, -0.064331055, 0.036010742, -0.026443481, 0.055236816, -0.025146484, -0.024291992, -0.017669678, -0.01184082, -0.0019426346, -0.01374054, -0.009155273, -0.030853271, -0.036590576, -0.03677368, 0.01612854, -0.0032958984, -0.027694702, 0.0064048767, -0.060394287, 0.029129028, -0.016723633, -0.0541687, 0.030578613, -0.018066406, -0.030807495, -0.016830444, -0.029067993, 0.016113281, 0.047424316, -0.0031394958, -0.002023697, 0.017181396, -0.006362915, 0.011772156, 0.033477783, 0.06323242, -0.012580872, -0.018875122, -0.013961792, 0.04269409, 0.048461914, -0.058135986, -0.06561279, -0.010414124, 0.03881836, 0.009399414, 0.05758667, 0.023330688, 0.020889282, -0.03250122, 0.04434204, -0.012245178, -0.04660034, -0.06286621, -0.032836914, 0.04714966, 0.020553589, -0.005207062, -0.037841797, 0.013412476, -0.0013523102, 0.02658081, 0.0005617142, 0.013824463, 0.0070114136, -0.019378662, 0.04272461, -0.0033931732, -0.01789856, 0.0030078888, -0.009117126, 0.019256592, 0.045837402, -0.055114746, 0.027618408, 0.0015535355, 0.025131226, -0.017349243, -0.052947998, 0.07086182, 0.043640137, 0.02520752, 0.026153564, -0.014846802, -0.027862549, -0.021255493, -0.009155273, -0.0060920715, 0.0049972534, 0.028335571, -0.011962891, 0.015396118, 0.0045928955, -0.07055664, 0.01461792, -0.038391113, 0.021820068, -0.062561035, 0.062927246, -0.03451538, -0.0015497208, -0.010307312, -0.00459671, -0.018447876, -0.02520752, -0.061920166, -0.049316406, 0.02911377, -0.024246216 ], "summary": [ -0.003993988, -0.014144897, 0.0033226013, 0.0059280396, -0.03250122, -0.006248474, -0.007888794, -0.02923584, 0.008476257, 0.027893066, -0.017227173, -0.004081726, 0.02809143, -0.033233643, 0.012420654, -0.011985779, 0.01725769, 0.0007338524, 0.025177002, -0.022232056, 0.005142212, -0.011856079, 0.059051514, 0.011398315, -0.0087890625, -0.06732178, -0.048736572, -0.0010967255, -0.005592346, -0.012420654, -0.0124053955, 0.059051514, 0.023040771, 0.0317688, -0.060668945, -0.05215454, -0.028121948, 0.009170532, -0.029006958, 0.029922485, 0.006099701, 0.007183075, 0.065979004, -0.014930725, 0.001288414, 0.044677734, -0.034606934, -0.024383545, -0.0064353943, 0.004360199, 0.0069236755, 0.030151367, 0.010154724, 0.023895264, 0.00032496452, 0.009941101, -0.043914795, 0.0023860931, 0.0033550262, 0.06524658, 0.029296875, -0.0017299652, -0.005470276, -0.028030396, 0.010261536, 0.0073776245, 0.05126953, 0.0064430237, 0.034179688, 0.010253906, -0.022506714, 0.02520752, -0.022598267, -0.00042247772, -0.009277344, 0.011253357, 0.017974854, -0.0077781677, -0.0043525696, 0.02897644, -0.032165527, 0.022033691, -0.034973145, -0.03289795, -0.02218628, -0.03652954, -0.026901245, 0.0050086975, -0.012458801, 0.0007047653, -0.024993896, 0.046966553, -0.021072388, -0.00856781, -0.021652222, -0.010421753, -0.043273926, -0.080444336, 0.04815674, 0.0501709, 0.08685303, -0.08227539, 0.10107422, -0.02722168, 0.0021705627, 0.029830933, -0.021560669, -0.06829834, 0.012557983, 0.012031555, -0.008239746, 0.015098572, -0.003129959, -0.041992188, -0.03265381, 0.024871826, 0.02418518, -0.020751953, 0.008331299, 0.00258255, -0.00289917, 0.022460938, -0.055877686, 0.019165039, 0.013946533, 0.0025177002, 0.018630981, 0.020492554, -0.0068855286, 0.048095703, -0.021652222, 0.0008087158, 0.0038528442, -0.01084137, -0.032714844, -0.032470703, 0.0052490234, 0.04345703, 0.03668213, -0.039642334, 0.10223389, -0.037872314, -0.08618164, 0.111083984, -0.0077819824, 0.024261475, 0.015274048, 0.010124207, -0.013473511, -0.022872925, -0.033966064, 0.02357483, 0.014595032, -0.010719299, 0.009124756, -0.021850586, -0.023162842, -0.01689148, 0.0071640015, -0.00072288513, 0.046142578, 0.046051025, 0.027328491, 0.06854248, 0.060424805, -0.06210327, -0.008522034, 0.0037708282, 0.0041656494, -0.03186035, 0.000688076, 0.021530151, 0.02305603, -0.018585205, 0.008308411, -0.011688232, -0.0027809143, 0.015327454, -0.0014705658, -0.027389526, -0.03189087, -0.053497314, -0.013114929, 0.00756073, -0.008811951, 0.019546509, -0.024429321, 0.0065193176, 0.03186035, 0.0026931763, -0.034210205, 0.02027893, -0.004348755, -0.04135132, -0.035827637, 0.021957397, 0.007091522, 0.042266846, -0.019119263, 0.01928711, -0.0065574646, -0.029052734, 0.0025863647, -0.0065841675, -0.06756592, -0.021957397, -0.025131226, 0.013442993, 0.0032978058, -0.01008606, -0.0026569366, -0.06008911, 0.022628784, -0.014007568, -0.043121338, -0.058807373, 0.0014247894, -0.028884888, 0.015640259, -0.03515625, 0.03479004, 0.0031490326, 0.011634827, 0.040130615, 0.017837524, 0.011520386, -0.021331787, 0.008361816, 0.050231934, 0.034484863, 0.010803223, -0.038848877, 0.0069236755, 0.034942627, -0.007972717, 0.0067634583, 0.025283813, -0.0053253174, 0.01524353, 0.026916504, 0.013702393, -0.024597168, -0.029937744, 0.03265381, -0.01838684, 0.0058898926, 0.025222778, 0.0008497238, -0.030731201, -0.061706543, 0.022827148, -0.010368347, 0.0574646, 0.03338623, 0.0065841675, 0.021514893, 0.008544922, 0.003250122, 0.020492554, 0.014213562, 0.004840851, 0.032165527, 0.0017566681, 0.0146865845, -0.048217773, -0.020828247, -0.013633728, -0.0039043427, 0.021728516, -0.033691406, 0.0137786865, -0.050231934, -0.01689148, -0.052368164, -0.09301758, -0.051483154, -0.02571106, 0.06781006, -0.046875, -0.06390381, 0.008453369, 0.028900146, -0.0038909912, -0.016921997, 0.027038574, 0.03515625, -0.012634277, 0.002029419, -0.0075569153, 0.02017212, 0.038208008, 0.030517578, -0.01360321, 0.027679443, 0.008224487, -0.011077881, 0.008468628, 0.032196045, 0.002872467, -0.015174866, -0.009414673, 0.029724121, -0.028915405, -0.0009365082, 0.006755829, -0.010848999, 0.000813961, -0.007194519, 0.0028209686, -0.008560181, -0.017807007, 0.061462402, 0.019577026, 0.009162903, -0.0335083, -0.035186768, -0.030197144, 0.0071907043, -0.044128418, 0.018554688, 0.038604736, 0.04925537, 0.02166748, -0.011459351, 0.032165527, -0.041107178, -0.031463623, -0.0209198, 0.010734558, 0.013397217, 0.02482605, 0.028396606, 0.004890442, 0.029281616, 0.014450073, -0.0072364807, 0.020767212, -0.048980713, 0.0009937286, 0.019042969, 0.044525146, 0.042510986, -0.010795593, -0.054840088, -0.023925781, 0.0048103333, -0.04437256, 0.025268555, -0.06555176, -0.023422241, 0.023239136, -0.027893066, -0.013900757, 0.06347656, 0.009986877, 0.008613586, 0.028121948, 0.052734375, -0.003610611, -0.018157959, 0.036102295, 0.036102295, 0.032928467, -0.06274414, -0.047180176, -0.033721924, -0.014152527, 0.0075263977, -0.006252289, 0.012252808, -0.011451721, -0.0011138916, -0.0049324036, -0.021728516, -0.0031261444, 0.009437561, 0.076416016, 0.00043225288, -0.027160645, 0.04385376, 0.034851074, 0.01701355, -0.02784729, -0.054229736, 0.0029354095, -0.0029277802, -0.038269043, -0.024017334, 0.02267456, 0.028518677, 0.017044067, 0.009780884, -0.003850937, -0.02772522, -0.01878357, 0.006210327, 0.0007843971, -0.0413208, 0.022415161, -0.04055786, 0.036102295, 0.010093689, -0.0060920715, -0.005634308, 0.0065460205, -0.019851685, 0.051940918, -0.018310547, 0.012550354, 0.0579834, -0.011703491, 0.000027954578, -0.003627777, 0.011062622, -0.0070648193, 0.02116394, -0.03692627, -0.008331299, -0.027252197, 0.02017212, -0.04434204, 0.10858154, -0.07397461, 0.000099122524, 0.038391113, 0.06781006, -0.008003235, -0.038604736, 0.020477295, 0.028213501, 0.026062012, 0.0007266998, -0.011749268, -0.0026569366, -0.043395996, 0.0025920868, -0.007911682, -0.017791748, 0.05014038, -0.03640747, -0.042297363, -0.0065956116, 0.04208374, 0.0022449493, 0.02571106, -0.012283325, -0.0020503998, -0.033325195, 0.0025558472, 0.028244019, -0.017852783, 0.0031166077, 0.02909851, 0.019805908, -0.029006958, -0.0000019073486, 0.02507019, 0.040618896, 0.057739258, -0.032440186, 0.011383057, -0.025161743, -0.048187256, 0.037872314, 0.0019273758, 0.072631836, -0.06317139, 0.03363037, -0.02558899, -0.010879517, 0.02709961, -0.022903442, 0.0015468597, -0.025741577, 0.000620842, -0.030029297, 0.004261017, -0.018539429, 0.027008057, -0.028656006, -0.00078868866, 0.006729126, -0.032226562, 0.022399902, 0.03289795, -0.0059432983, -0.016830444, -0.0105896, -0.014587402, 0.05618286, 0.0062446594, -0.02281189, 0.033111572, 0.024017334, -0.03253174, 0.028640747, -0.0062789917, 0.07006836, 0.009239197, -0.033325195, -0.026870728, -0.027893066, 0.039489746, -0.0044784546, -0.0463562, 0.06536865, 0.03765869, 0.005329132, -0.029388428, -0.11895752, 0.01939392, -0.08544922, -0.045532227, 0.016464233, -0.03805542, 0.035095215, -0.012107849, -0.014129639, -0.0036182404, 0.002779007, 0.03036499, 0.04232788, -0.032287598, 0.029830933, 0.03149414, -0.048675537, -0.025466919, -0.004787445, -0.015312195, 0.009513855, 0.064575195, 0.0035266876, 0.045043945, 0.01638794, -0.03491211, -0.022888184, -0.056793213, -0.017730713, 0.038116455, 0.026382446, -0.03692627, -0.031280518, -0.005706787, 0.051818848, -0.014862061, 0.008384705, -0.02746582, 0.047912598, -0.04360962, 0.009185791, 0.024887085, 0.002670288, 0.03881836, -0.055541992, -0.058563232, 0.047546387, 0.050933838, -0.033813477, -0.004547119, 0.04949951, 0.02645874, 0.036224365, 0.0025348663, -0.034332275, 0.06774902, 0.0050621033, 0.013938904, -0.043151855, -0.00049209595, -0.006099701, -0.03427124, -0.017669678, -0.034301758, -0.029434204, -0.0018587112, -0.00868988, -0.007217407, 0.012229919, -0.014160156, -0.01436615, 0.047851562, -0.013832092, -0.04949951, -0.045013428, 0.005592346, 0.00031900406, -0.005428314, -0.008514404, -0.02029419, -0.023071289, 0.0033359528, -0.0063095093, 0.022018433, -0.051605225, -0.014312744, -0.023864746, 0.033966064, 0.004837036, 0.004142761, -0.008460999, 0.01826477, 0.021865845, 0.014541626, -0.0034999847, -0.0047683716, 0.037231445, 0.0362854, 0.033203125, 0.020996094, 0.025772095, -0.0030269623, -0.028625488, -0.010940552, 0.036102295, 0.011222839, -0.05014038, 0.0077552795, 0.011772156, -0.0073661804, -0.014183044, 0.006965637, -0.010734558, 0.004558563, -0.013328552, 0.05456543, -0.037231445, -0.04031372, 0.016036987, 0.012512207, -0.015853882, -0.0027275085, -0.0033721924, -0.037200928, -0.07354736, -0.03277588, 0.06365967, -0.0035533905, -0.054260254, -0.0059280396, 0.01675415, -0.005470276, 0.048583984, 0.02330017, 0.023239136, 0.01953125, -0.00007849932, 0.0082092285, -0.017486572, -0.0055274963, -0.012687683, -0.008277893, -0.0036697388, -0.040008545, -0.017196655, 0.025878906, -0.040405273, -0.029434204, 0.031402588, -0.019500732, -0.014160156, -0.049102783, 0.009887695, 0.011886597, -0.0064849854, 0.087768555, -0.03390503, -0.061401367, -0.00819397, -0.03845215, 0.043762207, -0.054870605, -0.0647583, 0.016433716, 0.010635376, 0.025054932, 0.018325806, -0.015167236, 0.0054359436, -0.0041122437, 0.009346008, -0.0206604, 0.008964539, 0.04425049, -0.006668091, -0.013221741, 0.043792725, 0.03488159, -0.01777649, -0.01737976, -0.048614502, 0.021194458, 0.049804688, -0.051483154, -0.009391785, 0.018478394, -0.04220581, -0.017105103, 0.009002686, -0.034057617, -0.013656616, 0.0073280334, 0.007171631, 0.030319214, 0.015167236, 0.00030207634, -0.003074646, -0.015159607, -0.021713257, 0.011291504, 0.014755249, -0.026504517, -0.015106201, -0.026672363, -0.005596161, 0.022567749, -0.013053894, -0.048736572, -0.025390625, -0.039093018, 0.011306763, -0.011276245, 0.012908936, 0.020309448, -0.02078247, 0.007820129, 0.002664566, -0.022628784, 0.0109939575, -0.014640808, -0.027618408, -0.005886078, 0.021652222, -0.023956299, -0.0050582886, 0.016571045, -0.026275635, -0.0007019043, -0.014785767, -0.020858765, -0.06604004, -0.05178833, -0.007980347, 0.010604858, -0.0015535355, 0.029785156, 0.013832092, 0.018859863, 0.012016296, -0.0027313232, 0.0065727234, 0.04522705, -0.023391724, -0.037994385, 0.0046539307, 0.039276123, -0.0102005005, -0.056488037, 0.0017471313, -0.00052690506, 0.016189575, -0.06866455, 0.008277893, 0.01876831, 0.047943115, 0.048309326, 0.07788086, -0.05279541, 0.0024318695, 0.028518677, -0.02557373, -0.026794434, 0.016647339, 0.0018186569, -0.009605408, 0.041778564, -0.024749756, 0.012069702, 0.04135132, -0.0018901825, -0.027145386, -0.034606934, 0.021453857, -0.01007843, 0.031799316, 0.031982422, 0.004764557, 0.0134887695, -0.023635864, 0.027389526, -0.006225586, -0.008613586, 0.008346558, 0.035217285, 0.05340576, 0.02822876, 0.0069618225, 0.038513184, 0.015289307, -0.0054130554, -0.021362305, 0.019485474, 0.017410278, -0.057922363, -0.042907715, -0.057647705, 0.025497437, 0.039733887, -0.030075073, 0.017974854, 0.022994995, 0.021347046, 0.027130127, 0.02720642, 0.012535095, -0.022872925, 0.037200928, 0.0023555756, 0.020507812, -0.0143585205, 0.0090789795, -0.019210815, 0.025375366, -0.027877808, 0.06149292, 0.0135650635, -0.04446411, 0.008735657, 0.034576416, -0.00046229362, 0.0015230179, 0.0048942566, -0.015930176, 0.09240723, 0.048034668, 0.08502197, 0.014633179, 0.002374649, -0.0044288635, -0.015319824, -0.004634857, 0.04144287, -0.070007324, 0.0791626, 0.030197144, -0.036621094, -0.005264282, 0.00737381, -0.013671875, 0.0070762634, 0.059570312, 0.00844574, -0.035888672, 0.026290894, 0.0362854, -0.010414124, -0.019363403, -0.016952515, -0.04208374, 0.029556274, 0.052246094, -0.026138306, 0.008491516, -0.03894043, 0.02458191, -0.0015773773, 0.042510986, 0.0345459, 0.01171875, 0.05429077, 0.043884277, 0.032470703, -0.054718018, 0.024871826, 0.058898926, -0.0013608932, 0.030059814, 0.046905518, -0.013870239, 0.0574646, -0.009803772, 0.08721924, 0.06750488, 0.04486084, -0.05682373, -0.0002939701, 0.10058594, -0.022155762, 0.016983032, 0.0016260147, -0.00969696, -0.015426636, -0.00970459, -0.0075035095, 0.0043296814, -0.0052986145, 0.053771973, -0.045074463, -0.01260376, -0.028213501, 0.00869751, -0.05935669, 0.008911133, 0.019180298, -0.06463623, -0.052978516, 0.011909485, 0.024398804, 0.013702393, 0.029785156, -0.022903442, -0.012214661, 0.036865234, -0.014419556, 0.03652954, -0.0018596649, -0.01386261, 0.0034122467, -0.02633667, 0.05593872, -0.036834717, -0.037628174, -0.0037250519, 0.0017795563, 0.0016441345, -0.035003662, 0.007980347, -0.02835083, -0.021560669, -0.0524292, -0.03237915, -0.0446167, -0.04928589, -0.008590698, -0.06311035, 0.02835083, -0.013710022, -0.04837036, 0.024642944, -0.015075684, 0.012527466, -0.006164551, -0.016433716, 0.019088745, 0.027450562, 0.0047454834, -0.0036449432, 0.03945923, -0.022888184, 0.0090408325, 0.0126571655, 0.024002075, -0.017349243, -0.008354187, -0.010307312, 0.02607727, 0.051849365, -0.027709961, -0.021148682, -0.010025024, 0.00390625, 0.01259613, 0.026245117, -0.0015974045, 0.022872925, 0.025634766, 0.036132812, 0.0050735474, -0.03475952, -0.048675537, -0.020812988, 0.064575195, -0.022857666, -0.013618469, -0.06561279, -0.01423645, -0.0065078735, -0.02355957, 0.017486572, -0.0027160645, -0.04272461, 0.0075569153, 0.001832962, -0.0053253174, -0.04586792, -0.016357422, -0.05038452, 0.032348633, 0.035003662, -0.039154053, 0.027450562, -0.022094727, 0.012245178, -0.0030345917, 0.025146484, 0.018081665, 0.022521973, 0.028503418, -0.0362854, -0.01449585, 0.00982666, -0.011009216, 0.0065345764, 0.016998291, 0.030471802, 0.0011806488, -0.037994385, 0.0039253235, -0.024047852, -0.06378174, -0.01689148, -0.032196045, -0.022598267, -0.049987793, 0.062347412, 0.0473938, -0.01713562, -0.0033226013, -0.0042762756, 0.0038032532, -0.004875183, -0.0032424927, -0.0597229, 0.0038547516, -0.00043606758 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1407.2845v1
XML Matchers: approaches and challenges
Santa Agreste, Pasquale De Meo, Emilio Ferrara, Domenico Ursino
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
Schema Matching, i.e. the process of discovering semantic correspondences between concepts adopted in different data source schemas, has been a key topic in Database and Artificial Intelligence research areas for many years. In the past, it was largely investigated especially for classical database models (e.g., E/R schemas, relational databases, etc.). However, in the latest years, the widespread adoption of XML in the most disparate application fields pushed a growing number of researchers to design XML-specific Schema Matching approaches, called XML Matchers, aiming at finding semantic matchings between concepts defined in DTDs and XSDs. XML Matchers do not just take well-known techniques originally designed for other data models and apply them on DTDs/XSDs, but they exploit specific XML features (e.g., the hierarchical structure of a DTD/XSD) to improve the performance of the Schema Matching process. The design of XML Matchers is currently a well-established research area. The main goal of this paper is to provide a detailed description and classification of XML Matchers. We first describe to what extent the specificities of DTDs/XSDs impact on the Schema Matching task. Then we introduce a template, called XML Matcher Template, that describes the main components of an XML Matcher, their role and behavior. We illustrate how each of these components has been implemented in some popular XML Matchers. We consider our XML Matcher Template as the baseline for objectively comparing approaches that, at first glance, might appear as unrelated. The introduction of this template can be useful in the design of future XML Matchers. Finally, we analyze commercial tools implementing XML Matchers and introduce two challenging issues strictly related to this topic, namely XML source clustering and uncertainty management in XML Matchers.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1407.2845v1
2014-07-10T16:14:11
2014-07-10T16:14:11
{ "title": [ -0.03475952, 0.00018393993, -0.047943115, -0.06878662, 0.027053833, 0.0072135925, -0.038757324, 0.0025749207, -0.0011796951, 0.029327393, -0.015716553, -0.006504059, 0.0055274963, -0.017684937, -0.049957275, -0.007209778, -0.005153656, 0.026504517, -0.027511597, -0.040649414, 0.008125305, -0.044647217, 0.021194458, 0.023803711, 0.05633545, -0.078125, -0.026290894, 0.02130127, 0.0034389496, -0.030319214, 0.0037384033, -0.005455017, 0.06222534, 0.007827759, -0.032989502, 0.029342651, -0.043273926, 0.008079529, -0.03805542, 0.028808594, 0.034210205, -0.02180481, -0.020462036, -0.014297485, -0.025848389, 0.018798828, -0.02696228, -0.022842407, -0.011566162, 0.024169922, 0.015319824, -0.00019097328, -0.0063705444, 0.035827637, 0.010757446, -0.02671814, -0.018951416, 0.003528595, 0.018417358, 0.059448242, 0.04147339, -0.008743286, 0.007156372, -0.0055007935, -0.055603027, -0.017044067, 0.01574707, 0.010978699, 0.06463623, -0.038238525, -0.030792236, 0.04232788, -0.02406311, -0.0048446655, -0.033416748, 0.018295288, 0.052856445, 0.0030212402, 0.015258789, -0.00096940994, 0.00554657, -0.001663208, -0.0020828247, -0.026107788, 0.036132812, -0.021514893, -0.0046463013, -0.013694763, -0.048034668, -0.07348633, -0.013580322, 0.009529114, -0.029953003, -0.009918213, -0.03656006, -0.015625, -0.004688263, 0.031433105, -0.01914978, -0.032318115, -0.015357971, 0.013412476, -0.037200928, -0.022872925, 0.0026283264, 0.05102539, 0.0057754517, 0.01979065, 0.022644043, 0.022384644, -0.009674072, 0.03479004, 0.027313232, 0.017745972, -0.014694214, -0.009819031, -0.000043690205, -0.001420021, 0.004585266, 0.0058250427, -0.016433716, -0.033111572, -0.014053345, -0.02947998, 0.021942139, -0.026123047, -0.045440674, 0.026657104, -0.0058288574, 0.015159607, 0.013450623, 0.045013428, -0.08331299, -0.0725708, -0.056121826, 0.034942627, 0.000038921833, -0.008155823, 0.0022010803, -0.0082092285, 0.016952515, -0.017700195, 0.008544922, 0.024215698, 0.0016613007, 0.027069092, 0.06732178, -0.027435303, -0.06536865, -0.02859497, -0.04309082, 0.0129852295, 0.033447266, -0.01737976, -0.028381348, -0.039276123, -0.116882324, -0.028961182, 0.039276123, 0.002998352, -0.008834839, 0.010299683, 0.02027893, -0.030029297, 0.014053345, 0.0022716522, -0.01512146, 0.023330688, 0.00020885468, 0.034301758, -0.032073975, 0.048980713, 0.013496399, -0.014472961, -0.007499695, -0.012519836, 0.043670654, 0.013076782, 0.005680084, 0.018539429, 0.023513794, -0.015838623, 0.017623901, 0.030059814, -0.0927124, 0.0020599365, 0.02432251, 0.04421997, 0.01828003, 0.019714355, 0.008224487, 0.03765869, -0.03237915, -0.019805908, -0.026504517, -0.031585693, 0.02432251, 0.02268982, 0.0012340546, -0.014076233, -0.061340332, 0.021835327, -0.033050537, 0.032440186, 0.04840088, -0.025360107, 0.0064849854, 0.0035419464, -0.03967285, 0.04574585, 0.06439209, 0.015075684, -0.054229736, 0.028778076, 0.0032463074, -0.062316895, 0.02456665, -0.009536743, 0.013633728, -0.026947021, -0.019378662, -0.0036411285, -0.0037117004, 0.04437256, -0.012420654, 0.026473999, -0.006286621, 0.000079751015, 0.036071777, 0.030639648, 0.086120605, -0.059936523, 0.058166504, 0.037475586, -0.0082473755, -0.03326416, -0.018554688, -0.035949707, -0.0013246536, 0.019744873, -0.0075302124, -0.011062622, -0.028900146, 0.014144897, 0.019119263, -0.005290985, 0.027740479, 0.009277344, 0.010726929, 0.032440186, 0.012031555, 0.019363403, 0.05618286, -0.012504578, -0.02482605, 0.06561279, 0.016052246, 0.039916992, -0.03765869, 0.040527344, -0.0034446716, 0.04827881, 0.008361816, 0.025619507, -0.031402588, 0.024673462, 0.0008368492, 0.034118652, 0.005554199, 0.022323608, 0.023147583, 0.0052261353, 0.005203247, -0.0012149811, 0.054626465, 0.020874023, -0.004055023, -0.011878967, 0.028839111, -0.034698486, -0.011116028, 0.0048828125, 0.0058784485, -0.008476257, 0.021881104, -0.01878357, -0.0051574707, -0.01751709, -0.0018825531, -0.023086548, 0.037628174, 0.061431885, 0.02166748, 0.0007266998, 0.017074585, -0.008331299, 0.092285156, 0.061584473, -0.042785645, 0.046905518, -0.040618896, 0.023971558, 0.046417236, -0.036193848, 0.010414124, 0.0413208, 0.018737793, 0.029525757, -0.009979248, 0.026229858, -0.05130005, 0.00011521578, 0.009628296, -0.04547119, -0.016738892, -0.048828125, 0.00819397, -0.046844482, -0.046142578, -0.043395996, 0.06726074, -0.044952393, -0.03756714, 0.018981934, -0.02670288, -0.011497498, 0.017654419, -0.029846191, -0.007091522, 0.0048065186, -0.017211914, -0.017593384, -0.08648682, -0.017501831, -0.0036468506, 0.028961182, -0.0076179504, 0.021087646, -0.0104904175, -0.0009522438, 0.029190063, -0.026367188, 0.010635376, -0.03363037, 0.028793335, -0.087768555, 0.004562378, 0.023071289, -0.015991211, -0.013511658, 0.021408081, -0.014076233, -0.004787445, 0.023925781, 0.078186035, -0.035461426, -0.051513672, 0.048217773, 0.052947998, -0.013290405, 0.04449463, 0.021469116, 0.021347046, 0.007045746, -0.043518066, -0.054260254, 0.026779175, -0.0124435425, -0.027664185, 0.055725098, -0.02230835, -0.056427002, -0.009513855, 0.00009423494, -0.005680084, -0.0031280518, -0.020828247, -0.04324341, -0.008201599, -0.018844604, 0.007068634, 0.013534546, -0.029556274, 0.013069153, 0.031463623, 0.041534424, 0.005722046, 0.013092041, 0.0038547516, -0.01309967, -0.017593384, 0.013877869, -0.021362305, -0.0004954338, 0.00374794, 0.0064468384, 0.0071792603, 0.00017368793, -0.076049805, -0.006538391, 0.020996094, -0.0028038025, -0.030807495, 0.016723633, -0.063964844, -0.01914978, -0.015548706, -0.029327393, 0.031341553, 0.031921387, -0.0059432983, 0.031234741, 0.015174866, -0.025283813, 0.0027637482, -0.036895752, -0.11340332, 0.021621704, -0.019226074, 0.00598526, -0.0027275085, -0.029876709, -0.057678223, -0.014755249, -0.002866745, 0.053497314, 0.024475098, -0.000019967556, 0.019424438, -0.014854431, 0.0008068085, -0.012550354, -0.029449463, 0.0013742447, -0.021209717, 0.016159058, -0.0024204254, 0.008857727, 0.034362793, -0.019638062, -0.017105103, 0.008644104, 0.005264282, 0.025253296, 0.018203735, -0.043945312, 0.0071907043, -0.004299164, -0.00025701523, 0.021957397, 0.00014615059, -0.0077590942, 0.005592346, 0.009002686, -0.02357483, 0.00023424625, 0.034210205, 0.0045394897, -0.026672363, -0.01940918, 0.0038490295, -0.02848816, -0.033111572, -0.010147095, 0.038238525, -0.009712219, 0.009140015, 0.00009530783, -0.0395813, 0.032714844, 0.0066452026, -0.025894165, -0.0079956055, 0.004928589, -0.005504608, 0.03250122, -0.012039185, 0.00491333, -0.02949524, -0.0056877136, 0.020614624, 0.009880066, -0.0040664673, -0.0680542, 0.0016202927, 0.003320694, -0.13232422, -0.04336548, 0.01260376, -0.007835388, -0.02357483, -0.05014038, 0.02784729, -0.025802612, -0.036193848, 0.028289795, -0.0112838745, -0.022583008, -0.011260986, -0.090148926, -0.019943237, 0.07183838, 0.0034065247, 0.028289795, 0.04058838, 0.0054244995, -0.02229309, -0.027038574, 0.020126343, -0.022491455, 0.037719727, -0.012031555, -0.043060303, 0.018951416, -0.03491211, 0.03302002, 0.009094238, 0.00016987324, -0.003353119, 0.0015287399, 0.016860962, 0.009086609, 0.006580353, 0.04815674, 0.0037498474, -0.028121948, -0.027435303, 0.0032958984, -0.0060806274, -0.010765076, 0.012321472, -0.02279663, 0.02659607, 0.012428284, 0.023849487, 0.07409668, -0.012008667, 0.011039734, 0.034454346, -0.018478394, -0.026992798, -0.021148682, 0.023483276, 0.016693115, -0.009231567, 0.036132812, -0.030456543, 0.03668213, -0.0075035095, -0.045135498, 0.014556885, 0.03765869, -0.024108887, -0.0007572174, -0.05895996, -0.02923584, -0.027023315, 0.014457703, -0.02897644, 0.036712646, 0.017669678, 0.0016622543, -0.03579712, 0.013916016, 0.01979065, 0.0034427643, 0.036224365, -0.026473999, 0.027526855, -0.011169434, -0.055908203, -0.029388428, -0.01525116, 0.012382507, 0.06365967, -0.0024433136, -0.030792236, 0.012336731, 0.018630981, 0.04385376, 0.048431396, -0.010574341, -0.042510986, 0.035949707, -0.009750366, -0.01159668, 0.008934021, 0.014541626, 0.0009665489, -0.014312744, 0.014572144, -0.028076172, -0.026428223, -0.05432129, 0.035308838, -0.010559082, 0.058746338, 0.024993896, 0.033355713, 0.031799316, -0.013717651, -0.023269653, 0.0042419434, -0.037017822, 0.053253174, -0.032928467, 0.022537231, -0.04498291, 0.014266968, 0.04284668, 0.026885986, 0.0007529259, -0.01638794, 0.0015707016, 0.0021686554, -0.0053977966, 0.034240723, 0.004005432, -0.06530762, -0.038635254, -0.00014817715, 0.024810791, 0.06335449, -0.04724121, 0.04699707, -0.035583496, 0.014823914, -0.0012645721, -0.024490356, 0.03692627, -0.04864502, 0.04345703, -0.07006836, -0.052764893, -0.01928711, 0.04748535, -0.042541504, -0.010353088, -0.009300232, -0.0007882118, 0.017791748, 0.0345459, 0.02885437, -0.0026836395, -0.013320923, -0.010978699, 0.0049705505, -0.025894165, -0.046844482, 0.0039482117, 0.0039043427, 0.013381958, -0.0072517395, 0.011146545, -0.09320068, -0.00019359589, 0.014427185, 0.001162529, -0.009536743, -0.08258057, 0.019622803, 0.037475586, 0.008308411, 0.0029945374, -0.017364502, 0.014930725, 0.06329346, 0.04815674, 0.0090789795, 0.011550903, 0.016677856, 0.0013017654, 0.0017223358, -0.004386902, 0.015174866, -0.01637268, 0.03201294, 0.005947113, 0.000808239, -0.07165527, 0.037719727, 0.06567383, 0.010681152, 0.02355957, -0.066101074, 0.013961792, -0.003534317, 0.007873535, 0.02696228, -0.033233643, -0.019500732, -0.014144897, 0.0060195923, -0.038330078, 0.033813477, 0.028366089, -0.052764893, -0.06341553, 0.02456665, 0.013023376, -0.004852295, -0.010276794, 0.039886475, -0.039886475, 0.05633545, 0.024810791, -0.032592773, -0.0065078735, 0.01322937, 0.013771057, 0.054626465, 0.018722534, -0.06274414, 0.003643036, -0.031021118, -0.057678223, -0.059814453, -0.035064697, 0.0068244934, 0.032989502, 0.001789093, -0.040863037, -0.0057754517, -0.016601562, 0.023513794, -0.027526855, -0.008110046, 0.023620605, 0.019866943, 0.0036334991, 0.022064209, 0.026245117, 0.021652222, 0.005744934, -0.002090454, -0.010955811, 0.018463135, -0.010215759, -0.010726929, -0.037109375, -0.05847168, 0.01612854, 0.0062217712, -0.0065345764, 0.027359009, 0.034606934, 0.02293396, 0.10882568, 0.00013244152, 0.027160645, 0.041412354, -0.017166138, -0.053497314, -0.0075302124, 0.010551453, -0.016616821, 0.04046631, -0.035461426, -0.043273926, -0.024108887, -0.06817627, -0.037109375, 0.0013437271, 0.02079773, 0.035308838, 0.009773254, -0.023529053, 0.041137695, -0.029632568, 0.000076413155, -0.018173218, 0.009635925, 0.005050659, -0.0052490234, 0.004283905, 0.018295288, 0.025863647, -0.039916992, 0.04067993, 0.010154724, -0.028427124, 0.007484436, -0.06402588, 0.0087890625, -0.032104492, -0.04748535, 0.02406311, 0.02999878, -0.025283813, 0.06109619, -0.02949524, 0.046813965, 0.0071487427, 0.061950684, 0.018478394, -0.010253906, 0.025390625, 0.01209259, 0.005180359, -0.048950195, -0.001285553, -0.038604736, 0.014122009, -0.030838013, 0.0036201477, -0.0692749, 0.010650635, 0.037994385, 0.024093628, 0.022003174, 0.010559082, 0.029922485, -0.017578125, 0.03060913, -0.007598877, 0.055786133, 0.005302429, -0.0137786865, -0.009849548, 0.009346008, 0.012084961, 0.028823853, 0.005622864, 0.009559631, -0.014709473, -0.015029907, -0.0054130554, 0.01927185, 0.017211914, -0.0020103455, 0.00843811, -0.032104492, 0.052246094, -0.0014648438, 0.041748047, 0.06097412, 0.029937744, 0.03741455, -0.045837402, -0.0056381226, -0.013763428, -0.01600647, -0.020584106, 0.0289917, -0.05014038, -0.013175964, -0.03201294, -0.0012331009, -0.028579712, 0.040374756, 0.02128601, -0.02609253, -0.026947021, 0.006351471, 0.039794922, 0.024002075, 0.040100098, -0.02923584, -0.0044898987, -0.0046081543, 0.0141067505, 0.0032730103, 0.018249512, 0.013214111, 0.04815674, 0.01902771, -0.034729004, 0.025421143, -0.014266968, 0.02809143, 0.035339355, 0.0011100769, -0.0010681152, -0.04559326, -0.042999268, -0.01260376, -0.006225586, -0.030944824, -0.040863037, 0.05166626, 0.05606079, 0.07183838, 0.088012695, 0.03353882, -0.0038719177, 0.010192871, -0.05215454, 0.047027588, 0.011207581, -0.035247803, 0.0027828217, -0.04425049, -0.031799316, 0.008880615, -0.064819336, 0.019760132, -0.047576904, 0.000954628, -0.0126571655, 0.026184082, 0.039916992, -0.058776855, -0.0501709, 0.00015413761, -0.033935547, -0.007335663, 0.00028848648, -0.02973938, -0.039764404, -0.02166748, 0.025360107, -0.007408142, -0.021514893, 0.0022602081, -0.0040893555, -0.068237305, -0.02255249, -0.048736572, 0.01121521, -0.0736084, -0.018325806, -0.028045654, -0.032409668, 0.0038719177, 0.006603241, 0.0029125214, -0.057403564, -0.06530762, -0.042633057, 0.00818634, 0.019363403, -0.035064697, -0.06414795, 0.017929077, -0.015914917, -0.033416748, -0.0045547485, -0.00422287, -0.03781128, -0.039001465, -0.020904541, -0.033081055, 0.00881958, 0.023590088, -0.018035889, 0.022872925, 0.021987915, -0.04824829, 0.00092840195, -0.010551453, 0.039855957, -0.0042152405, -0.059448242, 0.018753052, 0.04046631, 0.048461914, -0.030639648, -0.014167786, 0.027526855, 0.010284424, 0.0031032562, 0.07171631, -0.015716553, -0.02116394, 0.009101868, 0.027313232, 0.010673523, -0.027694702, 0.006252289, -0.037902832, 0.02468872, 0.05203247, -0.013259888, -0.0101623535, 0.04321289, 0.009460449, -0.00756073, 0.005428314, -0.022201538, -0.009262085, 0.006095886, 0.008255005, -0.023254395, -0.012260437, 0.008514404, 0.07067871, -0.032592773, 0.03149414, -0.029663086, -0.0039100647, 0.026855469, -0.008224487, -0.02734375, -0.042022705, 0.028121948, 0.036468506, 0.007472992, 0.037597656, -0.02670288, -0.007888794, -0.016555786, -0.0031795502, 0.0023956299, -0.001335144, 0.0046157837, -0.00844574, 0.009353638, -0.003019333, -0.025634766, -0.042114258, -0.042510986, 0.053375244, -0.02053833, -0.01878357, -0.011642456, -0.031234741, -0.017715454, 0.015129089, -0.0027542114, -0.05029297, -0.03375244, -0.016235352, 0.055664062, -0.00027418137 ], "summary": [ 0.0026340485, -0.000007927418, -0.028503418, -0.0069351196, 0.010299683, -0.021850586, -0.016098022, -0.015129089, 0.03277588, 0.039215088, -0.012420654, -0.024139404, 0.033233643, -0.026168823, -0.019165039, -0.012802124, 0.006134033, 0.015319824, 0.012062073, -0.027679443, 0.024673462, -0.018676758, 0.0011959076, 0.025604248, 0.04260254, -0.057128906, 0.052093506, 0.015510559, 0.05392456, 0.019119263, 0.03149414, -0.04067993, 0.032226562, -0.00491333, -0.0069084167, -0.0014419556, 0.0033493042, -0.02684021, -0.024154663, 0.022476196, 0.0362854, -0.018371582, 0.044891357, -0.0075035095, 0.022628784, -0.014045715, 0.026489258, -0.040802002, 0.029220581, -0.021392822, -0.030639648, -0.025558472, -0.019241333, -0.016326904, -0.019195557, 0.00932312, -0.010101318, -0.0026302338, -0.02204895, 0.040161133, 0.01977539, 0.030227661, 0.004901886, -0.0032596588, -0.0463562, 0.0042762756, 0.07952881, -0.033294678, 0.076171875, -0.01725769, -0.017791748, 0.06573486, -0.027999878, -0.038085938, 0.0041275024, 0.043395996, 0.042419434, 0.027023315, -0.01449585, 0.0256958, 0.035095215, -0.029693604, 0.044158936, -0.052490234, 0.044799805, -0.018859863, 0.0029335022, 0.0007162094, -0.03289795, -0.03967285, -0.027267456, 0.034576416, -0.06707764, -0.008766174, -0.017120361, -0.00970459, 0.0026931763, 0.034851074, -0.021347046, -0.023529053, -0.015449524, -0.003835678, -0.017868042, -0.022903442, -0.011985779, 0.042938232, 0.016708374, 0.024871826, 0.04373169, 0.0032901764, 0.017227173, 0.04269409, 0.041046143, 0.006389618, -0.042236328, -0.0041999817, 0.013061523, -0.0030727386, -0.008384705, -0.00023078918, -0.05102539, -0.0023422241, -0.027938843, -0.0015525818, -0.00046277046, -0.01424408, 0.03201294, 0.012359619, -0.009651184, 0.024536133, -0.010948181, 0.010246277, 0.015930176, 0.025527954, -0.018493652, -0.0077590942, 0.02029419, -0.026626587, 0.013923645, -0.056427002, 0.072753906, 0.030960083, 0.002500534, 0.02243042, -0.006011963, 0.026565552, 0.029693604, -0.0046577454, -0.034729004, -0.034729004, -0.031982422, 0.019515991, 0.030685425, -0.048736572, -0.039001465, -0.1015625, -0.10662842, -0.009124756, 0.056396484, -0.0026855469, -0.02293396, 0.0037403107, 0.044067383, 0.0035877228, -0.007446289, 0.014282227, 0.008651733, -0.004787445, 0.007587433, 0.025985718, -0.010467529, 0.064819336, 0.0006136894, -0.044708252, -0.01386261, -0.050323486, 0.021728516, -0.0038833618, -0.026931763, 0.036376953, 0.009048462, -0.043395996, -0.03665161, 0.009643555, -0.074279785, 0.05670166, 0.034851074, 0.117370605, -0.009605408, 0.014007568, 0.080566406, -0.0007276535, -0.032714844, 0.015220642, 0.027679443, -0.012763977, -0.037475586, -0.015716553, -0.0033721924, -0.03677368, -0.07800293, 0.04171753, -0.028839111, 0.03845215, -0.0033092499, 0.015716553, -0.0031318665, 0.05380249, -0.032684326, 0.020339966, 0.051818848, -0.006225586, -0.056274414, 0.036224365, -0.005870819, -0.07067871, 0.031097412, -0.041290283, -0.0018129349, -0.06149292, -0.0107421875, 0.0143966675, -0.0309906, 0.061279297, -0.015808105, 0.043670654, -0.020339966, 0.05001831, 0.021347046, 0.057861328, 0.034362793, -0.035949707, 0.008666992, 0.04421997, -0.0026168823, -0.0035629272, 0.011962891, -0.05114746, 0.0059928894, 0.017227173, -0.0030097961, -0.046875, -0.044830322, -0.0021762848, -0.028518677, 0.010818481, 0.015487671, 0.0124435425, -0.028366089, 0.0033683777, 0.0057754517, 0.018005371, 0.03579712, -0.06744385, -0.03765869, 0.052246094, -0.048553467, -0.007030487, -0.010612488, 0.022827148, -0.008308411, 0.03555298, 0.03970337, -0.0044898987, 0.059417725, 0.0045776367, 0.064453125, 0.026901245, -0.01386261, 0.0096206665, 0.0011339188, -0.02128601, 0.007160187, -0.033081055, -0.01763916, 0.028198242, 0.011192322, -0.004673004, 0.029388428, -0.016220093, 0.004753113, 0.011856079, -0.026428223, -0.013374329, 0.023376465, -0.033172607, -0.010368347, -0.00003862381, 0.029190063, 0.009986877, -0.00037908554, 0.05831909, 0.009544373, 0.034606934, 0.027786255, -0.018295288, -0.00365448, -0.011390686, -0.0060157776, -0.007820129, -0.010536194, 0.03579712, 0.03225708, -0.045837402, 0.018432617, 0.0036830902, 0.0050621033, 0.03878784, 0.022232056, 0.000497818, -0.06695557, -0.028549194, 0.012763977, 0.014381409, 0.001250267, -0.034179688, -0.002040863, 0.03161621, 0.027557373, 0.042144775, 0.059814453, 0.018417358, -0.025436401, 0.023010254, 0.008216858, -0.018066406, 0.024902344, -0.02432251, -0.015388489, -0.025970459, -0.07220459, -0.0814209, -0.08013916, -0.0073890686, -0.012016296, 0.024307251, 0.009963989, 0.004436493, -0.007419586, -0.012878418, 0.028762817, -0.016433716, 0.019241333, 0.00038170815, 0.013320923, -0.06378174, 0.0017757416, -0.010368347, 0.026611328, 0.013145447, -0.00793457, 0.026153564, 0.0050964355, 0.035095215, 0.05154419, -0.038482666, -0.020904541, 0.07745361, 0.040130615, 0.004627228, 0.060333252, 0.008964539, 0.024856567, 0.007598877, -0.04876709, -0.028152466, 0.041809082, -0.011070251, 0.0029067993, 0.03778076, 0.022399902, -0.0039901733, -0.03479004, -0.002008438, -0.0079956055, -0.008621216, 0.016479492, -0.031173706, 0.029296875, 0.032714844, 0.008728027, 0.028533936, 0.01309967, 0.01939392, -0.020339966, 0.05331421, 0.003627777, 0.04067993, -0.035308838, -0.024780273, -0.026565552, 0.0491333, -0.021987915, -0.0231781, -0.005153656, -0.0021877289, -0.00023174286, 0.04638672, -0.028320312, -0.0077705383, -0.0072021484, 0.011795044, -0.001666069, 0.007858276, -0.040893555, -0.002412796, -0.0043296814, -0.017700195, 0.025299072, -0.047912598, 0.026931763, 0.006931305, 0.023345947, -0.017486572, 0.00071287155, -0.060455322, -0.019729614, -0.0065193176, -0.041900635, 0.044952393, 0.054840088, -0.01537323, -0.004447937, 0.013458252, 0.015541077, 0.034301758, -0.021484375, -0.006511688, -0.0016498566, -0.015701294, -0.022003174, -0.014373779, -0.02330017, -0.0024681091, 0.00009614229, 0.026565552, -0.0079956055, -0.012466431, 0.028305054, -0.024795532, 0.017089844, 0.021362305, 0.0010623932, -0.0069236755, -0.0047721863, -0.010177612, 0.033416748, 0.019958496, 0.05279541, 0.06329346, -0.014533997, -0.008369446, 0.041015625, 0.0110321045, -0.06359863, -0.04660034, 0.052947998, 0.032043457, 0.041809082, -0.025650024, -0.01486969, -0.035614014, 0.03161621, 0.0018978119, 0.015686035, -0.022644043, 0.041656494, -0.011245728, -0.05657959, 0.060546875, -0.002111435, -0.020828247, -0.01876831, -0.0068626404, -0.013893127, -0.0026435852, 0.03656006, -0.009094238, 0.0335083, -0.015945435, 0.013618469, 0.016403198, 0.03286743, -0.055389404, -0.010139465, 0.009819031, -0.09698486, -0.06866455, 0.002374649, 0.03857422, 0.023834229, -0.0068092346, 0.039093018, 0.012908936, -0.009498596, 0.016418457, -0.02734375, 0.091552734, 0.028259277, -0.06213379, 0.04638672, -0.025634766, 0.025314331, -0.015472412, -0.00484848, 0.021194458, 0.00075626373, 0.0335083, 0.0069389343, -0.04348755, 0.016418457, -0.020126343, -0.057495117, 0.027191162, -0.03265381, 0.020004272, 0.010025024, -0.004245758, -0.0025539398, 0.00018012524, 0.023406982, 0.052001953, 0.0026874542, 0.018371582, -0.0034809113, -0.03286743, 0.008834839, -0.0029277802, -0.0066108704, -0.01612854, -0.0031490326, 0.010986328, -0.03225708, 0.016983032, 0.042907715, -0.000082194805, -0.015258789, 0.0030498505, -0.011077881, -0.0016679764, -0.022033691, -0.031982422, 0.0053138733, 0.008605957, -0.02368164, 0.04373169, -0.04119873, 0.022155762, -0.032287598, -0.029144287, -0.003145218, 0.018585205, -0.052459717, -0.0289917, -0.0066947937, -0.0060653687, -0.01889038, 0.008239746, -0.029220581, -0.011474609, -0.010398865, 0.007835388, 0.0008611679, -0.0033912659, 0.029724121, 0.017059326, 0.013519287, -0.019332886, -0.0063209534, -0.031677246, -0.052825928, -0.024856567, -0.05227661, -0.034179688, 0.0069770813, 0.027648926, -0.037109375, 0.023223877, -0.009269714, 0.05871582, 0.025604248, 0.021987915, -0.04977417, 0.02279663, -0.015563965, 0.04168701, -0.046203613, 0.037872314, -0.034820557, -0.016433716, -0.0068893433, 0.0118637085, -0.033599854, -0.070617676, 0.015060425, 0.011779785, 0.0068740845, 0.042633057, 0.01928711, 0.019943237, -0.015808105, -0.045837402, -0.016921997, -0.025970459, 0.11102295, -0.0569458, -0.0030555725, -0.00081300735, -0.009902954, 0.006576538, 0.0018520355, -0.015808105, 0.0069465637, -0.009841919, -0.0027999878, 0.004650116, 0.06866455, -0.0289917, -0.047943115, -0.02267456, -0.01737976, 0.014076233, 0.028945923, -0.009010315, -0.019195557, -0.034942627, 0.033843994, -0.028259277, -0.021377563, 0.048919678, -0.016036987, 0.03111267, -0.031799316, -0.01612854, -0.017700195, 0.018997192, -0.0435791, -0.036254883, -0.037597656, -0.017959595, 0.002603531, -0.008743286, -0.00315094, -0.03768921, 0.010292053, -0.023239136, -0.020690918, 0.018173218, -0.039916992, -0.039093018, -0.04135132, -0.00340271, 0.047729492, -0.013999939, -0.033447266, -0.013267517, 0.021911621, 0.01991272, -0.04547119, -0.020202637, -0.004219055, -0.0067443848, -0.046936035, -0.0041885376, 0.000019133091, -0.02923584, 0.058441162, 0.042236328, -0.028701782, 0.02027893, -0.005344391, 0.058258057, -0.040283203, -0.019592285, 0.039733887, -0.004180908, 0.009994507, 0.023712158, -0.0128479, -0.056732178, 0.012069702, 0.03894043, 0.060302734, -0.012519836, -0.026367188, 0.01776123, 0.019119263, 0.022460938, 0.024856567, -0.014389038, 0.0037021637, -0.0030918121, 0.013725281, -0.034851074, -0.008201599, 0.037078857, -0.017959595, -0.074279785, 0.02230835, -0.0073661804, 0.006175995, -0.035614014, 0.012619019, -0.027893066, 0.042236328, -0.0068473816, -0.012138367, 0.008728027, 0.060699463, 0.017303467, 0.036193848, 0.015396118, -0.016098022, 0.012565613, -0.043029785, -0.030441284, -0.024780273, -0.057159424, -0.042541504, 0.08251953, -0.01889038, -0.017669678, -0.0031032562, -0.04852295, 0.0038585663, -0.03314209, -0.0051345825, -0.012199402, 0.015731812, 0.033325195, 0.043029785, 0.004886627, -0.0033798218, 0.0135650635, 0.018478394, -0.028656006, 0.03567505, -0.053894043, -0.024993896, -0.07965088, -0.023468018, -0.000934124, 0.009269714, -0.01928711, 0.070373535, 0.042510986, 0.005580902, 0.14257812, 0.02507019, 0.045288086, 0.019378662, 0.0022850037, -0.011787415, -0.01033783, 0.029586792, -0.0395813, -0.014976501, -0.028945923, -0.011024475, -0.008010864, -0.034973145, 0.003036499, -0.039398193, -0.017410278, 0.015052795, -0.01928711, 0.024475098, 0.00141716, 0.0035133362, 0.002231598, 0.011436462, -0.027450562, 0.00078868866, 0.021331787, 0.03817749, 0.042022705, 0.026031494, 0.0087509155, 0.02809143, 0.00617218, -0.043548584, 0.02670288, -0.043151855, 0.025405884, -0.025131226, -0.02670288, -0.027359009, 0.044067383, -0.026733398, 0.015327454, -0.00087213516, 0.03753662, 0.0154953, -0.009361267, -0.037322998, -0.041534424, 0.043518066, 0.0067634583, -0.054870605, -0.03289795, -0.0259552, 0.00035881996, 0.008621216, 0.028549194, -0.002916336, 0.011528015, 0.046691895, 0.021072388, -0.045654297, 0.046813965, -0.011909485, -0.007610321, -0.0368042, -0.049835205, -0.002281189, -0.033233643, -0.04537964, -0.023849487, 0.030441284, -0.008453369, -0.021377563, 0.033294678, -0.00072050095, 0.007820129, -0.010444641, 0.010902405, -0.0037460327, 0.009529114, -0.043823242, -0.04135132, 0.027160645, -0.025665283, 0.036315918, 0.0042037964, 0.048797607, 0.036254883, -0.047058105, 0.029846191, -0.054779053, -0.016921997, 0.010543823, -0.007095337, -0.036499023, -0.028747559, 0.07904053, -0.05517578, -0.014961243, 0.015655518, -0.009803772, 0.023117065, 0.030700684, 0.0035419464, 0.013504028, -0.024291992, 0.0076560974, 0.003107071, 0.015991211, -0.020828247, -0.003419876, -0.0017557144, -0.020584106, 0.028961182, 0.0546875, 0.028121948, 0.070007324, 0.027496338, -0.01222229, 0.021453857, -0.06829834, 0.048614502, 0.038208008, 0.02670288, -0.029907227, -0.022491455, -0.03237915, 0.009941101, -0.009178162, 0.027572632, -0.007068634, -0.013381958, 0.057525635, 0.07757568, 0.0758667, -0.010620117, 0.034301758, 0.06665039, -0.014205933, 0.03314209, -0.024246216, -0.01826477, -0.032073975, -0.027297974, 0.008071899, -0.04437256, -0.046081543, -0.0262146, -0.0345459, 0.009811401, -0.0017414093, 0.034210205, -0.023803711, 0.0043563843, -0.04788208, 0.01776123, -0.04623413, 0.003332138, 0.048461914, -0.005680084, -0.022857666, -0.03466797, 0.013290405, -0.025512695, -0.0107421875, 0.014945984, -0.007286072, 0.00522995, 0.022918701, 0.012886047, 0.059539795, -0.020645142, -0.050201416, -0.016143799, -0.025466919, 0.027557373, 0.009788513, 0.0011062622, -0.01360321, -0.02734375, -0.046875, 0.03616333, 0.03955078, -0.02545166, -0.093566895, 0.064819336, -0.034454346, -0.023590088, 0.008094788, -0.015472412, -0.017578125, -0.039398193, -0.0127334595, -0.036193848, -0.0256958, 0.03326416, 0.0070991516, 0.011581421, 0.050689697, -0.026000977, 0.00037264824, -0.0032844543, 0.0072746277, -0.014129639, -0.025344849, -0.008682251, 0.022705078, 0.027679443, 0.0035743713, -0.0017566681, 0.021972656, -0.035888672, 0.017440796, 0.022918701, -0.013641357, 0.0042037964, 0.0070343018, 0.031921387, 0.0054626465, -0.026184082, 0.05319214, -0.03579712, -0.028808594, -0.003124237, 0.0053100586, -0.0137786865, 0.012069702, -0.009765625, -0.025497437, -0.0020809174, 0.0022583008, -0.021499634, 0.021026611, -0.0038433075, -0.03866577, -0.028244019, 0.038116455, 0.07116699, -0.054656982, -0.024902344, -0.010299683, -0.01197052, 0.011695862, -0.049682617, -0.032806396, -0.009757996, -0.016647339, 0.016113281, -0.0141067505, -0.020858765, -0.0054092407, 0.0046081543, -0.023803711, 0.024093628, 0.016494751, 0.01927185, -0.05670166, 0.04107666, 0.013267517, 0.064331055, 0.021377563, -0.05508423, -0.030654907, 0.060913086, -0.00039291382, -0.03213501, -0.019897461, 0.01272583, 0.008232117, 0.013221741, -0.004924774, -0.02456665, 0.017578125, -0.005760193, 0.00868988, 0.017562866 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1509.03977v1
Optimization of anemia treatment in hemodialysis patients via reinforcement learning
Pablo Escandell-Montero, Milena Chermisi, José M. Martínez-Martínez, Juan Gómez-Sanchis, Carlo Barbieri, Emilio Soria-Olivas, Flavio Mari, Joan Vila-Francés, Andrea Stopper, Emanuele Gatti, José D. Martín-Guerrero
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG
Objective: Anemia is a frequent comorbidity in hemodialysis patients that can be successfully treated by administering erythropoiesis-stimulating agents (ESAs). ESAs dosing is currently based on clinical protocols that often do not account for the high inter- and intra-individual variability in the patient's response. As a result, the hemoglobin level of some patients oscillates around the target range, which is associated with multiple risks and side-effects. This work proposes a methodology based on reinforcement learning (RL) to optimize ESA therapy. Methods: RL is a data-driven approach for solving sequential decision-making problems that are formulated as Markov decision processes (MDPs). Computing optimal drug administration strategies for chronic diseases is a sequential decision-making problem in which the goal is to find the best sequence of drug doses. MDPs are particularly suitable for modeling these problems due to their ability to capture the uncertainty associated with the outcome of the treatment and the stochastic nature of the underlying process. The RL algorithm employed in the proposed methodology is fitted Q iteration, which stands out for its ability to make an efficient use of data. Results: The experiments reported here are based on a computational model that describes the effect of ESAs on the hemoglobin level. The performance of the proposed method is evaluated and compared with the well-known Q-learning algorithm and with a standard protocol. Simulation results show that the performance of Q-learning is substantially lower than FQI and the protocol. Conclusion: Although prospective validation is required, promising results demonstrate the potential of RL to become an alternative to current protocols.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1509.03977v1
2015-09-14T07:52:00
2015-09-14T07:52:00
{ "title": [ 0.005645752, 0.011955261, -0.01876831, -0.026062012, 0.0017194748, -0.0048179626, -0.020965576, -0.032196045, -0.04248047, 0.030593872, -0.016998291, 0.010429382, -0.014595032, -0.034088135, -0.007789612, -0.033325195, 0.019866943, 0.022888184, -0.009933472, -0.0040016174, 0.011108398, 0.0037975311, -0.0062026978, 0.04510498, -0.008407593, 0.06793213, -0.113464355, 0.014221191, -0.050201416, -0.025253296, -0.011634827, 0.033416748, 0.008857727, -0.029174805, 0.041259766, 0.008903503, -0.014259338, 0.017623901, 0.013305664, 0.008842468, 0.007698059, -0.0032672882, 0.0513916, -0.028152466, 0.013290405, 0.022567749, -0.04812622, -0.05999756, -0.013900757, 0.074157715, 0.030838013, -0.0061798096, 0.018112183, 0.07299805, 0.014083862, -0.023162842, 0.00869751, -0.056030273, 0.041625977, 0.013412476, -0.016723633, -0.043273926, 0.032409668, -0.022659302, -0.025634766, -0.021743774, -0.036956787, 0.0040130615, 0.08178711, 0.013015747, -0.016586304, 0.03869629, 0.010650635, 0.023880005, -0.030960083, -0.020568848, 0.058258057, 0.023788452, 0.0066337585, -0.0044174194, 0.0046081543, -0.012420654, -0.013206482, -0.010848999, 0.008911133, -0.024291992, 0.0017852783, 0.001420021, -0.0496521, -0.064941406, -0.03152466, 0.000018298626, -0.04534912, -0.023086548, -0.027664185, -0.031677246, -0.027694702, -0.016082764, 0.020935059, 0.008972168, 0.007083893, -0.016494751, 0.0149002075, -0.01763916, 0.004673004, 0.0027580261, 0.0031318665, -0.020217896, 0.014083862, 0.020614624, -0.022323608, 0.024795532, 0.014083862, 0.0047721863, 0.023635864, -0.030883789, -0.034484863, 0.043792725, 0.0135269165, 0.00233078, 0.0036773682, -0.0060157776, 0.025100708, 0.0132369995, 0.015449524, 0.018829346, -0.03074646, -0.015838623, -0.04324341, 0.072509766, 0.0028209686, -0.0026340485, -0.0423584, -0.03274536, -0.035949707, -0.008522034, 0.00084495544, 0.019180298, 0.0035629272, -0.019012451, 0.04458618, -0.02003479, -0.012992859, 0.032592773, -0.0008625984, 0.03149414, 0.02722168, -0.017364502, -0.02848816, -0.039031982, -0.042816162, 0.01486969, -0.001083374, 0.015510559, -0.02760315, 0.013938904, -0.09240723, 0.03579712, 0.020950317, 0.019378662, 0.03289795, 0.0104522705, -0.004547119, 0.046051025, 0.08251953, -0.024429321, 0.003944397, 0.03692627, 0.014228821, 0.028121948, 0.020645142, -0.0013856888, 0.045318604, -0.037506104, -0.016021729, 0.0004646778, 0.0335083, 0.03741455, -0.0076446533, -0.03475952, 0.008453369, -0.027893066, 0.0021896362, 0.010574341, -0.014823914, -0.06719971, 0.00756073, -0.015899658, 0.05114746, 0.021224976, -0.05517578, 0.0060272217, -0.015129089, -0.02696228, -0.039794922, 0.006969452, 0.029266357, 0.04611206, -0.028762817, 0.0019779205, -0.044158936, 0.017852783, -0.03149414, 0.039916992, 0.022583008, -0.0368042, 0.013626099, 0.006580353, -0.039093018, 0.028808594, 0.05065918, -0.0064430237, 0.004508972, -0.017929077, 0.012458801, -0.055725098, 0.02279663, 0.01991272, -0.0017461777, 0.0012874603, -0.011238098, -0.022827148, -0.008308411, 0.012283325, -0.033935547, 0.013824463, -0.02078247, 0.0028896332, -0.020889282, 0.0053367615, 0.09240723, 0.03060913, -0.005104065, -0.000374794, -0.014099121, -0.008468628, 0.004917145, 0.012123108, 0.024414062, 0.0096206665, -0.003818512, -0.010902405, 0.0047035217, 0.04119873, 0.029632568, 0.020690918, 0.022262573, 0.012413025, -0.004688263, -0.010169983, 0.058532715, 0.0031909943, 0.02960205, 0.02470398, -0.0048446655, 0.05493164, -0.02633667, 0.032806396, -0.034729004, 0.008117676, -0.0055236816, 0.031311035, 0.06774902, -0.010536194, -0.06488037, 0.031341553, -0.04043579, -0.007987976, -0.02848816, 0.017089844, 0.040039062, 0.0033416748, 0.008293152, -0.022369385, -0.05090332, 0.004142761, -0.019439697, 0.037872314, 0.0018939972, -0.035217285, -0.010414124, 0.032989502, 0.06072998, -0.0029296875, -0.0030937195, 0.037475586, 0.033966064, -0.008132935, 0.017913818, -0.022567749, 0.037963867, -0.029067993, -0.014091492, -0.0011339188, 0.008422852, -0.048187256, 0.013183594, 0.055023193, -0.02281189, 0.024490356, -0.09490967, 0.0028495789, 0.016921997, -0.03152466, 0.005180359, -0.006351471, -0.0135269165, 0.018508911, -0.004802704, 0.020324707, -0.06719971, 0.052612305, 0.00068616867, -0.025970459, -0.021865845, -0.05557251, -0.027709961, -0.018325806, -0.057861328, 0.01876831, 0.018692017, -0.003370285, -0.004798889, -0.0013122559, 0.014442444, -0.026000977, -0.028457642, -0.012275696, 0.008201599, 0.030578613, 0.04586792, 0.048736572, -0.04107666, 0.022064209, 0.0063591003, 0.022369385, -0.0059318542, 0.054016113, -0.009773254, -0.04598999, -0.033966064, -0.047668457, -0.0076293945, -0.021209717, 0.025619507, -0.025421143, -0.04144287, 0.0041122437, 0.064575195, 0.012329102, -0.041229248, 0.0067443848, -0.041748047, 0.045532227, 0.0151901245, -0.0129470825, 0.052215576, 0.032684326, -0.006362915, 0.0074424744, 0.035583496, 0.02935791, 0.020339966, -0.040924072, -0.028808594, -0.0715332, -0.0078125, -0.008384705, -0.01777649, 0.023468018, -0.06555176, -0.024856567, -0.018615723, 0.0067710876, 0.027755737, 0.05947876, 0.07312012, 0.0028095245, -0.014976501, 0.034332275, 0.028701782, 0.030853271, -0.04837036, 0.027313232, 0.08526611, -0.0041236877, 0.0051498413, 0.004497528, 0.042877197, 0.010513306, -0.008514404, -0.04232788, 0.03604126, -0.0006546974, 0.020858765, -0.005962372, -0.028533936, 0.0068511963, -0.07318115, 0.0017375946, 0.043060303, -0.0066108704, -0.029541016, 0.03677368, -0.016937256, 0.012512207, 0.031097412, -0.02444458, 0.0032653809, 0.0041503906, -0.020645142, 0.008125305, -0.01889038, 0.009841919, 0.023071289, -0.048095703, -0.045440674, 0.015777588, -0.024505615, -0.007209778, 0.035339355, -0.028457642, -0.0068359375, -0.007621765, -0.031585693, -0.0017681122, 0.06414795, 0.041931152, 0.02999878, 0.024017334, 0.035217285, -0.028884888, -0.0181427, -0.075805664, -0.02810669, -0.043884277, -0.028518677, 0.064453125, -0.02468872, 0.025024414, -0.07904053, -0.008018494, 0.0055351257, 0.017532349, -0.01361084, -0.0095825195, -0.007534027, -0.05053711, -0.040130615, -0.030975342, -0.0206604, 0.001124382, -0.010231018, 0.018341064, 0.009666443, 0.111206055, -0.032226562, 0.0046920776, -0.018753052, 0.012672424, -0.011749268, -0.036895752, 0.017440796, -0.003376007, 0.033416748, -0.0035247803, 0.014945984, -0.0034770966, -0.025939941, 0.01828003, -0.0008459091, 0.003583908, 0.0019702911, 0.000032365322, -0.008361816, -0.020980835, 0.013366699, 0.035888672, -0.01259613, -0.0340271, 0.0038871765, 0.014709473, -0.040008545, -0.073913574, -0.021972656, 0.012893677, -0.092163086, -0.03427124, 0.045837402, -0.04550171, 0.02935791, -0.07543945, 0.025314331, -0.017242432, -0.03744507, -0.009994507, -0.0018091202, 0.0061912537, 0.0045661926, -0.044677734, -0.049041748, 0.047088623, -0.013450623, -0.00088071823, 0.014305115, 0.0061798096, 0.0034484863, -0.015296936, 0.00844574, 0.0053482056, 0.030838013, -0.015563965, 0.039276123, 0.02848816, 0.0021896362, -0.022399902, 0.06628418, 0.045806885, -0.012802124, -0.0030708313, 0.055877686, 0.041259766, -0.03173828, 0.04425049, 0.049468994, -0.043395996, -0.057922363, -0.042053223, -0.018234253, -0.042510986, 0.014343262, 0.0033092499, 0.034210205, 0.049957275, -0.0021839142, 0.05517578, -0.0037250519, 0.0012617111, -0.004348755, -0.05343628, -0.010124207, 0.0039482117, 0.012886047, -0.0073547363, -0.007621765, 0.0065574646, -0.045013428, -0.007396698, 0.024856567, -0.038360596, -0.00028896332, 0.013839722, -0.05831909, -0.036254883, -0.03161621, -0.0016651154, -0.011474609, -0.004875183, -0.015838623, -0.008239746, 0.04660034, -0.01449585, -0.053771973, 0.021392822, 0.028884888, -0.01939392, -0.015068054, -0.08807373, -0.0132369995, -0.0037250519, -0.0826416, -0.035247803, -0.06921387, -0.01751709, 0.008888245, 0.015090942, -0.04458618, -0.008865356, 0.03640747, 0.08123779, 0.06726074, 0.016815186, -0.062408447, -0.016342163, -0.039520264, -0.008766174, 0.013931274, 0.0032730103, -0.02268982, -0.015426636, 0.035369873, -0.0041275024, -0.018310547, -0.049621582, 0.02482605, -0.03527832, 0.0602417, 0.024459839, 0.015716553, 0.040283203, 0.013847351, 0.044281006, 0.013519287, -0.025238037, -0.030303955, 0.03845215, 0.06573486, -0.010887146, -0.01335144, 0.049987793, 0.028121948, 0.01828003, -0.002401352, -0.011131287, 0.026611328, 0.008262634, -0.017547607, 0.032409668, -0.0065841675, -0.017211914, 0.018234253, -0.034118652, 0.018875122, -0.03390503, 0.02909851, -0.021850586, 0.00970459, 0.013206482, -0.008895874, 0.003698349, -0.010650635, 0.009132385, -0.016860962, -0.029281616, 0.034851074, 0.021514893, -0.011795044, -0.016067505, -0.037475586, 0.022460938, 0.037750244, 0.031311035, 0.023254395, -0.047088623, -0.03152466, -0.010948181, -0.013847351, -0.028656006, -0.037078857, 0.00055885315, -0.026016235, 0.019348145, -0.051971436, 0.018447876, -0.0057373047, -0.019744873, -0.012962341, -0.02218628, 0.0127334595, -0.059448242, 0.014953613, 0.027618408, -0.02746582, 0.008544922, 0.011672974, 0.009559631, 0.026153564, 0.046173096, -0.008430481, 0.036865234, 0.022720337, -0.027511597, 0.021026611, -0.010414124, 0.024246216, 0.0014009476, 0.008178711, 0.0052948, 0.02571106, -0.051452637, 0.03326416, 0.021530151, -0.0079956055, -0.011634827, -0.024368286, 0.02545166, -0.013000488, -0.0073127747, 0.007671356, -0.03778076, -0.022766113, -0.0012817383, -0.043121338, -0.047180176, 0.012367249, -0.034606934, -0.02456665, -0.057006836, 0.03427124, -0.037902832, -0.0132369995, -0.0046310425, 0.02330017, -0.025360107, 0.021621704, 0.014816284, -0.090026855, 0.0056915283, 0.011405945, 0.04034424, 0.021728516, -0.012908936, -0.08569336, -0.01184082, -0.018600464, -0.051635742, -0.0592041, 0.025650024, 0.021972656, -0.002046585, 0.015838623, -0.009963989, -0.027664185, -0.0076446533, 0.013420105, 0.00630188, -0.020553589, 0.062286377, 0.0036754608, 0.018981934, 0.0022602081, 0.038146973, 0.004673004, 0.009307861, 0.013587952, -0.022521973, 0.0084991455, 0.031433105, 0.0234375, -0.0064353943, -0.012809753, -0.007270813, 0.03353882, 0.008522034, -0.0026855469, 0.010688782, 0.035186768, 0.0131073, -0.010391235, 0.0009050369, 0.060943604, -0.05657959, -0.057495117, -0.045440674, -0.0262146, -0.05419922, 0.07342529, -0.0008049011, -0.050354004, -0.027832031, -0.05130005, -0.019699097, -0.010139465, 0.03149414, -0.0116119385, 0.009742737, -0.05633545, -0.014282227, -0.0071258545, -0.01977539, -0.06329346, -0.00038456917, -0.0009832382, 0.009025574, 0.0692749, -0.0042686462, 0.025482178, -0.025558472, -0.010536194, -0.02003479, -0.0046653748, -0.0107421875, -0.003112793, 0.010536194, -0.01966858, -0.009666443, -0.0016241074, 0.017547607, -0.033111572, 0.027496338, -0.049987793, 0.03768921, 0.03540039, 0.0030956268, -0.001127243, -0.002532959, 0.014076233, 0.018569946, 0.017913818, -0.019638062, 0.024139404, -0.07409668, 0.03439331, -0.028915405, -0.00025105476, -0.0637207, -0.0008201599, 0.035186768, 0.028503418, 0.008682251, 0.012718201, 0.012031555, 0.009765625, 0.053375244, 0.0059013367, 0.06222534, 0.046813965, -0.01864624, 0.03137207, 0.017196655, 0.004688263, 0.012275696, -0.0016870499, 0.02760315, 0.0035896301, 0.0050239563, 0.011016846, -0.026870728, 0.026672363, -0.020431519, 0.0043411255, -0.0011558533, 0.057434082, -0.005504608, 0.035247803, 0.06347656, 0.043060303, -0.03515625, -0.0181427, 0.02128601, -0.016677856, -0.0362854, 0.011482239, 0.054260254, -0.09313965, 0.051452637, -0.008506775, -0.021560669, -0.0026836395, 0.064697266, -0.0021705627, -0.026290894, -0.000869751, 0.013748169, 0.0056915283, 0.047424316, 0.02772522, -0.021118164, -0.038238525, -0.0062179565, 0.019897461, -0.0129852295, 0.05871582, 0.025177002, 0.04296875, -0.049224854, -0.019622803, -0.013755798, -0.033416748, -0.08795166, 0.024795532, 0.0067100525, 0.030029297, 0.0034332275, -0.028900146, 0.030212402, 0.005832672, -0.029663086, 0.022216797, -0.013893127, -0.018081665, 0.009246826, 0.04647827, 0.051483154, -0.0019416809, -0.06359863, -0.032562256, -0.025909424, 0.030181885, -0.010543823, 0.016311646, -0.012413025, -0.030090332, 0.04324341, -0.03111267, 0.01902771, -0.042236328, 0.012313843, -0.017532349, -0.016403198, 0.04119873, -0.03302002, -0.030303955, -0.023330688, -0.03302002, 0.022644043, 0.064697266, -0.00022149086, -0.015777588, 0.023208618, -0.0013113022, 0.03845215, -0.04257202, -0.0056533813, -0.004261017, -0.025619507, -0.048309326, -0.038146973, -0.008781433, -0.013717651, -0.014030457, 0.008377075, -0.0041503906, 0.014442444, -0.04647827, -0.044006348, -0.030914307, 0.021362305, -0.020629883, 0.006793976, 0.024093628, -0.0036334991, -0.0032844543, 0.086120605, -0.0059280396, 0.005783081, -0.03338623, 0.0067253113, -0.019378662, -0.034820557, -0.031921387, -0.037902832, -0.0061302185, 0.024017334, 0.0138168335, -0.03829956, 0.047576904, -0.0044898987, -0.044647217, -0.013168335, 0.013305664, -0.001707077, -0.023910522, 0.014923096, 0.040985107, 0.064575195, -0.00074863434, 0.0035362244, 0.012542725, 0.00034570694, -0.010894775, 0.016204834, -0.011169434, -0.01864624, 0.018341064, 0.04647827, -0.002122879, -0.02015686, -0.07305908, -0.0121536255, 0.064575195, 0.021026611, -0.008232117, -0.053253174, 0.0067253113, 0.010238647, -0.014160156, -0.020339966, 0.029342651, -0.021697998, 0.0016155243, 0.037200928, -0.016494751, -0.012931824, 0.014289856, 0.031951904, -0.0042762756, 0.04989624, -0.00035119057, -0.010620117, 0.049835205, 0.07348633, -0.04434204, 0.035247803, 0.03555298, 0.013404846, 0.022354126, 0.0035629272, -0.00466156, 0.04937744, 0.016326904, -0.014251709, -0.021697998, -0.021469116, 0.059906006, -0.03845215, -0.027282715, -0.004081726, -0.04437256, -0.0037784576, -0.010322571, 0.020706177, -0.050079346, 0.024932861, -0.018920898, -0.024917603, 0.014221191, 0.011367798, 0.043762207, -0.03250122, -0.0016708374, -0.00043344498, 0.043792725, 0.0019550323 ], "summary": [ 0.025665283, 0.0038642883, 0.006526947, 0.0047416687, -0.011291504, -0.011856079, 0.009307861, -0.039276123, -0.021240234, 0.04244995, 0.01789856, 0.001499176, -0.0020122528, -0.040863037, -0.010955811, -0.02545166, 0.0061683655, 0.02128601, -0.007247925, -0.0039138794, 0.0259552, -0.0024032593, -0.035125732, 0.032684326, -0.02571106, 0.059051514, -0.06982422, 0.015533447, -0.039489746, -0.02067566, -0.0057373047, 0.049713135, -0.005329132, -0.001865387, 0.019973755, -0.034210205, -0.0023403168, 0.010513306, 0.014312744, 0.017807007, 0.03161621, -0.018005371, 0.107421875, -0.06665039, 0.05014038, 0.051818848, -0.0070724487, -0.06213379, 0.021331787, 0.06591797, 0.028152466, 0.0021095276, 0.012313843, 0.06561279, -0.0076179504, -0.010917664, 0.008407593, -0.052459717, 0.0076026917, 0.029418945, 0.008262634, -0.006378174, 0.005432129, -0.023361206, 0.009155273, -0.0062713623, 0.018814087, 0.014137268, 0.03765869, 0.023971558, -0.0032997131, 0.012123108, 0.0057144165, -0.01020813, -0.01878357, -0.016525269, 0.042999268, -0.008522034, -0.026062012, 0.011001587, 0.02935791, 0.021148682, -0.013206482, -0.008026123, -0.0029315948, -0.011039734, -0.0069503784, -0.0129852295, -0.04421997, -0.016067505, -0.033172607, 0.016464233, -0.057739258, -0.0011672974, -0.0015478134, -0.03387451, -0.00919342, -0.053527832, 0.013999939, -0.0020561218, 0.05114746, -0.060058594, 0.04675293, 0.0015439987, -0.014198303, 0.036468506, 0.0335083, -0.00037240982, -0.0075302124, -0.011177063, -0.021774292, -0.008758545, 0.040771484, -0.03060913, 0.019973755, -0.0178833, 0.00894928, 0.07495117, 0.024810791, 0.0032367706, 0.013977051, 0.04736328, -0.0027751923, -0.0023670197, -0.0004005432, 0.022598267, 0.0017652512, -0.040985107, -0.018951416, 0.040252686, -0.01676941, -0.023498535, 0.046783447, 0.038238525, 0.01751709, -0.019638062, 0.006832123, 0.011352539, 0.020339966, -0.028823853, 0.040039062, -0.017486572, -0.024124146, 0.038085938, 0.0067214966, 0.055541992, 0.010429382, -0.02784729, -0.007003784, -0.03253174, -0.043273926, -0.001704216, 0.026794434, 0.0022010803, -0.06439209, 0.006214142, -0.06689453, 0.04156494, -0.01600647, -0.0056495667, 0.0418396, 0.02027893, -0.0060920715, 0.061035156, 0.047332764, -0.041992188, 0.0262146, 0.010498047, 0.014701843, -0.010765076, 0.013069153, 0.010238647, 0.05633545, -0.008338928, 0.0031661987, 0.0006942749, 0.007698059, 0.03994751, 0.009674072, -0.03503418, 0.0032577515, -0.024887085, 0.043823242, 0.0057525635, 0.04397583, -0.07342529, -0.006843567, -0.023742676, 0.024032593, 0.025894165, -0.07318115, -0.0140686035, -0.0069084167, -0.036895752, -0.033935547, 0.003332138, -0.01499176, 0.021133423, -0.03137207, 0.036132812, 0.022506714, 0.031921387, -0.018875122, 0.021972656, -0.0018148422, -0.0016822815, 0.011314392, 0.007896423, -0.012367249, 0.01574707, 0.024505615, -0.0041007996, -0.005138397, -0.012870789, -0.006416321, -0.0362854, 0.014083862, 0.03111267, 0.01499939, 0.013259888, 0.0023326874, -0.020050049, -0.003332138, 0.014503479, -0.03756714, -0.0061836243, -0.02784729, 0.0027503967, -0.03616333, -0.033691406, 0.105041504, 0.07824707, -0.013137817, 0.012145996, -0.022399902, -0.0075416565, 0.012557983, -0.0016403198, 0.012176514, 0.010192871, 0.015037537, -0.02166748, -0.014221191, 0.013214111, 0.011581421, -0.0027580261, 0.013671875, 0.004245758, -0.030288696, -0.008270264, 0.04336548, 0.016906738, 0.025405884, 0.020263672, -0.010406494, 0.039794922, -0.03491211, -0.02609253, -0.0022792816, -0.007987976, 0.015022278, 0.007881165, 0.0064964294, 0.0005912781, -0.060943604, 0.024780273, -0.01473999, -0.003501892, -0.015342712, 0.005596161, 0.026138306, -0.005645752, 0.010787964, -0.06298828, -0.048614502, -0.039245605, -0.008934021, 0.04498291, 0.030426025, -0.05493164, -0.004135132, 0.050720215, 0.0158844, -0.005340576, -0.025177002, 0.011543274, 0.004508972, 0.009506226, 0.05130005, 0.014213562, 0.059539795, -0.032348633, -0.00749588, -0.003004074, 0.019073486, -0.067871094, -0.03274536, 0.04763794, -0.0013618469, -0.01373291, -0.08984375, 0.009841919, 0.0061683655, -0.034118652, 0.026885986, -0.028015137, 0.0007982254, 0.0362854, 0.02130127, -0.0071868896, 0.0017213821, 0.06933594, 0.021514893, 0.037475586, -0.0058135986, -0.039764404, -0.012901306, 0.035003662, -0.0158844, 0.04748535, 0.042419434, -0.02822876, -0.0025978088, 0.002571106, -0.0054512024, -0.031677246, 0.01210022, -0.0113220215, 0.022323608, 0.025848389, 0.026779175, 0.023590088, -0.033935547, -0.0004286766, 0.010673523, 0.010688782, -0.0006532669, 0.059753418, -0.0038700104, -0.042297363, -0.013977051, -0.07281494, -0.00029921532, 0.024291992, -0.0022010803, -0.005382538, -0.042907715, 0.011985779, 0.045318604, 0.009597778, -0.03878784, 0.015571594, -0.05407715, 0.08343506, -0.01473999, -0.060028076, 0.081970215, 0.071899414, -0.053131104, 0.01663208, 0.059448242, 0.01348114, 0.028518677, -0.06112671, -0.03062439, -0.05142212, 0.0048980713, -0.045043945, -0.017684937, 0.027313232, -0.04449463, 0.0028820038, -0.008049011, -0.0077590942, -0.010246277, 0.055999756, 0.089782715, 0.00040960312, 0.0012073517, 0.053222656, 0.025390625, 0.037078857, -0.013938904, 0.026809692, 0.08520508, -0.006263733, 0.012649536, 0.035339355, 0.036956787, 0.00028538704, -0.019485474, -0.030914307, 0.056365967, -0.018478394, -0.01146698, 0.0016469955, -0.00018966198, -0.0043258667, -0.002861023, -0.014732361, 0.020874023, 0.0000011920929, -0.002752304, 0.0063171387, 0.0052719116, -0.019897461, 0.023986816, -0.019683838, 0.019363403, -0.052734375, -0.004459381, 0.0064888, 0.013092041, -0.033447266, 0.0012235641, -0.03933716, 0.014404297, 0.0067214966, -0.016738892, -0.0027332306, 0.033325195, -0.030929565, 0.0066871643, 0.0022602081, -0.019302368, -0.037994385, 0.042388916, 0.02067566, 0.010757446, 0.032348633, 0.014160156, -0.020095825, -0.021453857, -0.075805664, -0.016845703, -0.025100708, -0.0234375, 0.043060303, -0.026000977, 0.0078125, -0.060058594, 0.010032654, 0.023010254, 0.011680603, -0.0118255615, 0.002357483, 0.01171875, -0.030410767, -0.042816162, -0.053497314, -0.03050232, -0.00046753883, 0.030960083, 0.037139893, 0.024398804, 0.11798096, -0.0057640076, 0.01777649, 0.046020508, -0.02067566, -0.058624268, -0.026550293, 0.009216309, -0.024841309, 0.034606934, 0.026290894, -0.011238098, 0.020217896, 0.0066184998, -0.013374329, 0.040863037, -0.028137207, 0.008148193, -0.008552551, 0.012062073, -0.028182983, 0.013893127, 0.022277832, -0.013160706, -0.028503418, -0.018463135, 0.01473999, -0.03640747, -0.07196045, -0.03111267, 0.01763916, -0.09173584, -0.05581665, -0.006137848, 0.018096924, 0.07501221, -0.025360107, 0.039154053, 0.009384155, -0.041015625, -0.027664185, -0.004142761, 0.00844574, 0.004096985, -0.029891968, -0.027633667, -0.010292053, -0.008781433, -0.0031051636, -0.0070152283, 0.014450073, 0.03677368, -0.003458023, 0.01826477, -0.01828003, 0.036499023, -0.032226562, 0.06213379, 0.01689148, 0.0014047623, -0.04611206, 0.0871582, 0.03152466, 0.003862381, -0.014450073, 0.06335449, 0.06323242, -0.032592773, 0.012245178, 0.0637207, -0.032958984, -0.052856445, -0.016357422, -0.009124756, -0.035949707, -0.009628296, 0.015205383, -0.03491211, 0.011444092, 0.06384277, 0.007881165, -0.02746582, -0.00073099136, -0.01272583, -0.02420044, -0.021469116, -0.020050049, 0.0011692047, 0.005947113, -0.011619568, -0.018722534, -0.02583313, -0.010047913, -0.010269165, -0.036376953, 0.014183044, 0.032928467, -0.033355713, -0.041809082, -0.016082764, 0.03225708, 0.023025513, -0.031585693, -0.014587402, 0.020401001, 0.012390137, -0.0118255615, -0.019256592, 0.019836426, 0.011672974, 0.011772156, -0.030700684, -0.07330322, -0.018951416, -0.021606445, -0.057800293, -0.028579712, -0.07519531, -0.0491333, -0.013793945, 0.024902344, -0.043792725, -0.01612854, 0.039276123, 0.09069824, 0.026779175, 0.029556274, -0.056427002, -0.041137695, -0.035949707, 0.013450623, -0.0022029877, -0.0030269623, -0.028656006, -0.0036792755, 0.007583618, 0.010726929, -0.031402588, -0.029251099, 0.036132812, -0.009994507, 0.05053711, 0.030136108, 0.057678223, 0.037597656, 0.007572174, 0.047576904, 0.019500732, 0.005142212, -0.052703857, 0.058685303, 0.04421997, 0.022903442, -0.030181885, 0.017547607, 0.01108551, 0.0054130554, 0.015655518, -0.02999878, 0.018554688, 0.036224365, -0.027191162, 0.020431519, 0.03479004, -0.013298035, 0.016448975, -0.018203735, 0.0040130615, 0.016662598, 0.0023670197, -0.020004272, -0.0038776398, -0.0027427673, -0.025634766, -0.019546509, -0.013946533, -0.0039978027, -0.006439209, -0.022460938, 0.019744873, 0.003042221, 0.011947632, -0.019607544, -0.02999878, 0.022567749, 0.026977539, 0.023956299, 0.03652954, -0.041778564, -0.04586792, -0.0064888, -0.006072998, -0.013786316, -0.017913818, -0.030914307, 0.013298035, 0.022705078, -0.036254883, 0.03173828, 0.014282227, -0.0082473755, 0.005847931, -0.012702942, 0.0032215118, -0.066467285, -0.023788452, -0.017288208, -0.03161621, -0.032440186, 0.00079488754, -0.019378662, -0.00032806396, 0.037475586, -0.03277588, 0.008262634, 0.0065231323, -0.022033691, 0.033111572, -0.009849548, 0.013160706, 0.006336212, 0.014572144, -0.007583618, 0.008613586, -0.021347046, 0.01689148, 0.031143188, 0.01386261, -0.03414917, -0.015899658, 0.025650024, -0.018630981, 0.008850098, 0.0041389465, -0.048431396, -0.026275635, -0.021057129, -0.02381897, -0.066345215, 0.03050232, -0.01084137, -0.009819031, -0.050842285, 0.015556335, -0.048706055, 0.0053482056, 0.00035333633, 0.0002541542, -0.018722534, -0.014778137, 0.011230469, -0.043914795, 0.017623901, 0.021118164, 0.029083252, 0.00021278858, -0.02003479, -0.0637207, -0.0066184998, -0.044036865, -0.04623413, -0.062042236, 0.031982422, 0.02027893, 0.020126343, 0.022277832, 0.0004723072, 0.031555176, -0.013534546, 0.009757996, 0.014465332, 0.0038528442, 0.04534912, -0.0007901192, -0.009010315, 0.009719849, 0.019241333, -0.014266968, 0.008895874, 0.012145996, -0.02192688, 0.028335571, 0.010520935, 0.032104492, -0.028274536, 0.01058197, -0.018356323, 0.03866577, 0.001162529, -0.0021152496, 0.009925842, 0.0013189316, 0.029678345, -0.018707275, -0.012397766, -1.7881393e-7, 0.016571045, -0.09649658, -0.056488037, -0.0070152283, -0.032470703, 0.059265137, -0.0021953583, -0.07849121, -0.0013990402, -0.024154663, 0.0055732727, 0.0019216537, -0.004322052, -0.01109314, 0.0066871643, -0.022216797, 0.018173218, 0.0149002075, -0.027191162, -0.06311035, -0.004508972, -0.01158905, 0.01612854, 0.078308105, 0.011657715, 0.024261475, -0.021438599, -0.028915405, -0.016098022, 0.014526367, 0.007789612, -0.001036644, 0.017028809, -0.0109939575, 0.029846191, -0.010047913, 0.03277588, -0.05621338, -0.01486969, -0.018844604, 0.045532227, 0.034942627, -0.03503418, -0.03491211, -0.012260437, 0.048553467, 0.0076293945, -0.00019621849, -0.008148193, 0.007675171, -0.039215088, 0.026535034, -0.007446289, -0.005054474, 0.009651184, 0.053710938, 0.007461548, 0.013404846, 0.009124756, 0.017425537, 0.0018482208, 0.016342163, 0.012687683, 0.014701843, 0.03829956, 0.054138184, -0.007484436, 0.028121948, 0.025146484, -0.03488159, 0.008110046, 0.0077400208, 0.035858154, -0.0004916191, 0.030334473, 0.038085938, -0.056274414, -0.013748169, -0.03753662, 0.020477295, -0.02305603, 0.05532837, 0.026428223, 0.025650024, 0.028320312, 0.042816162, 0.007827759, -0.012763977, 0.026519775, 0.01576233, -0.041656494, 0.054534912, 0.04837036, -0.038024902, 0.046447754, -0.009162903, -0.03881836, 0.04272461, 0.06781006, -0.009094238, -0.021087646, 0.005722046, -0.011161804, 0.006137848, 0.048797607, 0.02935791, -0.030166626, -0.034454346, -0.022109985, 0.0072135925, 0.011001587, 0.041259766, 0.01133728, 0.0034942627, -0.05014038, -0.04559326, -0.0011825562, -0.030227661, -0.05496216, 0.02078247, -0.0049095154, 0.0057411194, 0.062561035, -0.0008907318, 0.032440186, 0.015991211, 0.027801514, 0.056671143, -0.041931152, -0.00856781, 0.025268555, 0.060333252, 0.01789856, 0.016036987, -0.021743774, -0.0070343018, -0.047546387, -0.019699097, -0.005970001, 0.005241394, -0.004173279, 0.019012451, 0.033355713, -0.015525818, -0.010826111, -0.044921875, -0.009506226, 0.0055236816, -0.020507812, 0.0012893677, 0.023284912, -0.022216797, -0.027679443, -0.016296387, 0.031463623, 0.06713867, -0.015853882, 0.0018587112, -0.0014219284, -0.011405945, 0.012832642, -0.048583984, -0.016525269, 0.0072135925, -0.0016069412, -0.111328125, -0.033294678, -0.057006836, 0.016571045, -0.020217896, 0.045440674, -0.0046157837, 0.02859497, -0.062286377, -0.032409668, -0.014923096, 0.04800415, 0.010543823, 0.0029087067, 0.027374268, -0.0034694672, 0.013885498, 0.13903809, 0.0063476562, 0.017669678, -0.020980835, 0.008758545, 0.0035362244, -0.03704834, -0.02848816, -0.030548096, -0.013214111, -0.0008907318, -0.004348755, 0.011436462, 0.014038086, -0.01134491, -0.03970337, -0.020141602, -0.00919342, -0.015487671, -0.042510986, 0.011436462, 0.007331848, 0.024612427, 0.00566864, 0.023742676, 0.048797607, 0.012382507, -0.023895264, -0.03125, -0.020584106, -0.016204834, 0.06756592, 0.05328369, 0.012359619, -0.037261963, -0.06793213, -0.024658203, 0.05871582, -0.0005955696, -0.018127441, -0.04815674, 0.01449585, -0.020370483, -0.029342651, -0.021820068, 0.02960205, -0.047851562, 0.013122559, 0.026885986, -0.008636475, -0.030273438, 0.00894165, 0.008804321, 0.0000962019, 0.015136719, 0.0090789795, -0.017181396, 0.016494751, 0.062469482, -0.052764893, 0.08203125, -0.019866943, -0.021652222, 0.017181396, -0.038238525, -0.007671356, 0.08770752, 0.042755127, -0.010848999, -0.02229309, -0.005077362, 0.05392456, -0.041870117, -0.05407715, -0.009216309, -0.06677246, -0.009765625, -0.01398468, -0.008895874, -0.034484863, 0.05419922, 0.038238525, -0.011230469, 0.040130615, 0.010467529, 0.04067993, 0.019866943, -0.008590698, -0.019256592, -0.0037937164, -0.0020694733 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1511.01411v6
Learning in Auctions: Regret is Hard, Envy is Easy
Constantinos Daskalakis, Vasilis Syrgkanis
cs.GT, cs.AI, cs.CC, cs.LG
A line of recent work provides welfare guarantees of simple combinatorial auction formats, such as selling m items via simultaneous second price auctions (SiSPAs) (Christodoulou et al. 2008, Bhawalkar and Roughgarden 2011, Feldman et al. 2013). These guarantees hold even when the auctions are repeatedly executed and players use no-regret learning algorithms. Unfortunately, off-the-shelf no-regret algorithms for these auctions are computationally inefficient as the number of actions is exponential. We show that this obstacle is insurmountable: there are no polynomial-time no-regret algorithms for SiSPAs, unless RP$\supseteq$ NP, even when the bidders are unit-demand. Our lower bound raises the question of how good outcomes polynomially-bounded bidders may discover in such auctions. To answer this question, we propose a novel concept of learning in auctions, termed "no-envy learning." This notion is founded upon Walrasian equilibrium, and we show that it is both efficiently implementable and results in approximately optimal welfare, even when the bidders have fractionally subadditive (XOS) valuations (assuming demand oracles) or coverage valuations (without demand oracles). No-envy learning outcomes are a relaxation of no-regret outcomes, which maintain their approximate welfare optimality while endowing them with computational tractability. Our results extend to other auction formats that have been studied in the literature via the smoothness paradigm. Our results for XOS valuations are enabled by a novel Follow-The-Perturbed-Leader algorithm for settings where the number of experts is infinite, and the payoff function of the learner is non-linear. This algorithm has applications outside of auction settings, such as in security games. Our result for coverage valuations is based on a novel use of convex rounding schemes and a reduction to online convex optimization.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1511.01411v6
2016-04-06T17:55:25
2015-11-04T17:39:30
{ "title": [ 0.0087509155, -0.0053215027, -0.012481689, -0.031951904, 0.00014150143, -0.014450073, 0.03253174, -0.014205933, 0.0033721924, 0.019897461, -0.08050537, 0.0051460266, -0.004306793, -0.0017881393, -0.050201416, -0.053741455, 0.009315491, 0.021453857, -0.013885498, -0.011520386, -0.04034424, -0.014228821, 0.032592773, -0.0032424927, 0.06317139, -0.005908966, -0.103881836, 0.017562866, 0.032836914, 0.010101318, 0.01914978, -0.032318115, 0.040374756, -0.018554688, 0.040405273, 0.024093628, -0.035858154, 0.012702942, 0.0011262894, 0.0032978058, 0.021575928, -0.018096924, -0.0947876, -0.029586792, -0.06921387, 0.027038574, -0.055999756, 0.009048462, -0.017608643, 0.04260254, 0.029632568, -0.022079468, 0.02407837, 0.05517578, -0.007583618, -0.04598999, -0.004085541, -0.0035514832, 0.02192688, 0.010292053, 0.0043411255, -0.004459381, 0.027832031, 0.0019817352, -0.021820068, 0.001625061, 0.04244995, 0.03564453, 0.064819336, 0.0027828217, -0.0357666, 0.029022217, 0.024291992, 0.028900146, -0.055389404, -0.05142212, 0.06402588, 0.017959595, 0.03314209, -0.026504517, -0.01727295, -0.04034424, -0.033966064, -0.018859863, 0.016357422, -0.00063085556, -0.023345947, -0.007881165, -0.016174316, -0.02381897, -0.018508911, 0.018356323, 0.03366089, -0.016921997, -0.06585693, -0.010307312, -0.013793945, 0.025177002, 0.013908386, -0.022659302, -0.062042236, 0.039978027, -0.10900879, 0.0095825195, 0.00025844574, -0.030822754, -0.0001398325, 0.0026512146, 0.018951416, 0.03994751, -0.04058838, 0.060150146, 0.014457703, 0.0029029846, 0.016204834, -0.028915405, -0.026184082, 0.041290283, -0.0013532639, 0.020095825, -0.008018494, -0.02671814, 0.03186035, 0.04336548, 0.027572632, 0.031707764, -0.038146973, -0.017242432, -0.0019493103, 0.021392822, 0.0046653748, 0.05456543, -0.083984375, -0.0793457, -0.050628662, 0.02848816, 0.01184082, 0.007911682, 0.006603241, 0.0043258667, 0.031555176, -0.03744507, 0.0043754578, 0.037353516, 0.027252197, 0.029022217, 0.03793335, -0.014854431, -0.02128601, -0.023254395, -0.035736084, 0.027374268, -0.0093688965, 0.006866455, -0.02508545, 0.00020754337, -0.13085938, 0.023468018, 0.057006836, 0.039886475, 0.018539429, -0.010757446, -0.03527832, 0.056854248, 0.04812622, 0.03475952, 0.016708374, 0.033721924, 0.011100769, 0.039611816, 0.0037250519, -0.03060913, -0.027618408, -0.012649536, -0.010345459, 0.014328003, 0.03427124, 0.022399902, 0.023880005, -0.04071045, -0.012512207, -0.01689148, 0.02470398, 0.018127441, -0.066589355, -0.03225708, -0.012435913, -0.015029907, 0.0692749, -0.01423645, -0.018936157, 0.017028809, -0.038848877, -0.06774902, -0.021057129, 0.0009908676, 0.03277588, 0.019699097, 0.009033203, 0.0060577393, -0.05895996, 0.009941101, -0.03012085, 0.023391724, 0.017547607, -0.036499023, 0.0069503784, 0.011634827, -0.046142578, 0.05859375, 0.060272217, 0.0107421875, -0.06542969, 0.05581665, 0.032165527, -0.053741455, 0.0035762787, 0.013145447, 0.0046043396, 0.01235199, -0.004550934, -0.03366089, 0.0113220215, 0.03604126, 0.0039901733, 0.04650879, -0.02519226, 0.008758545, 0.032928467, 0.037475586, 0.042999268, -0.021118164, 0.023834229, 0.0127334595, -0.010131836, -0.018997192, 0.006095886, -0.04043579, 0.027694702, 0.03074646, -0.004524231, -0.018753052, 0.004310608, 0.059692383, 0.011474609, -0.01586914, 0.01739502, 0.022705078, 0.039611816, 0.015296936, 0.029693604, 0.0063705444, 0.053863525, 0.02482605, 0.013801575, 0.057373047, -0.029052734, -0.013160706, -0.03479004, 0.020812988, -0.0062828064, 0.055145264, 0.027709961, 0.014213562, -0.024276733, 0.004722595, -0.037261963, 0.0063972473, -0.023971558, 0.034851074, 0.04534912, -0.014183044, 0.007118225, 0.022003174, -0.017044067, 0.0047454834, -0.051574707, 0.028259277, 0.014923096, -0.020904541, -0.012016296, 0.028030396, 0.039154053, -0.00969696, 0.015319824, -0.0022335052, 0.01979065, -0.0345459, -0.019683838, -0.0023670197, 0.03479004, 0.044677734, -0.006000519, 0.00067424774, 0.018463135, 0.00096178055, 0.041168213, 0.059692383, -0.021148682, 0.01890564, -0.05105591, 0.011741638, 0.018875122, -0.022079468, 0.009803772, 0.02947998, 0.043151855, -0.0075416565, -0.019760132, 0.023040771, -0.062927246, -0.0043907166, 0.0054779053, 0.008628845, -0.004360199, -0.035583496, 0.026306152, 0.006965637, 0.010810852, 0.010902405, 0.033996582, -0.006290436, -0.026992798, -0.017120361, 0.00095129013, -0.019515991, -0.042907715, -0.023956299, 0.034454346, 0.004219055, 0.0015611649, -0.00089883804, -0.08502197, -0.05456543, 0.021102905, 0.021484375, 0.0030174255, 0.01184845, -0.016555786, -0.02583313, -0.00894928, -0.024032593, -0.011734009, -0.030929565, -0.014625549, -0.056884766, -0.017501831, -0.0033569336, 0.0031909943, -0.0020217896, 0.034332275, 0.008087158, -0.037200928, -0.012054443, 0.032165527, -0.025604248, 0.025970459, 0.040863037, 0.01121521, -0.018829346, 0.04498291, 0.027389526, 0.0054893494, -0.05697632, -0.017211914, -0.057159424, -0.017089844, -0.0050468445, -0.0259552, 0.023101807, -0.06854248, -0.039978027, -0.027038574, -0.0056495667, 0.015975952, 0.047912598, 0.011672974, -0.037994385, -0.013465881, -0.009185791, 0.0005841255, 0.0126571655, -0.027038574, -0.00016987324, 0.04510498, 0.0032138824, -0.034698486, -0.010238647, 0.008857727, 0.010986328, -0.0072898865, -0.0055236816, -0.034332275, -0.008522034, -0.0018186569, 0.014038086, 0.015838623, -0.017242432, -0.05996704, -0.013160706, 0.043518066, -0.010215759, -0.023803711, 0.020126343, -0.061309814, 0.039245605, -0.008666992, -0.010375977, 0.026275635, 0.036743164, 0.019042969, -0.01361084, 0.025344849, -0.029525757, 0.0048599243, -0.03250122, -0.058502197, 0.025390625, -0.03793335, -0.03878784, 0.021896362, -0.013328552, -0.039215088, -0.01889038, -0.025131226, 0.02204895, 0.036712646, 0.023208618, -0.00033426285, -0.009292603, 0.007686615, -0.028137207, 0.019332886, -0.02645874, -0.0637207, -0.023132324, -0.022964478, 0.084228516, 0.011260986, -0.013320923, -0.07104492, -0.035095215, 0.01574707, -0.0027618408, -0.014450073, -0.00868988, -0.023651123, -0.033996582, -0.034423828, -0.00057029724, -0.0146484375, 0.014678955, -0.05343628, 0.010894775, -0.021011353, 0.03527832, 0.008552551, 0.03375244, -0.03149414, -0.006500244, 0.0069999695, -0.026473999, -0.012397766, 0.0043907166, 0.012077332, -0.016235352, 0.070129395, -0.028900146, -0.044921875, 0.027923584, -0.052886963, 0.0032081604, -0.015792847, -0.017807007, 0.016662598, 0.012611389, -0.028060913, 0.003522873, -0.005153656, 0.0031204224, 0.07006836, -0.009757996, 0.034118652, -0.010665894, 0.019256592, 0.0135650635, -0.11352539, -0.04586792, 0.044311523, -0.062683105, -0.037994385, -0.06286621, 0.02520752, -0.04486084, -0.010635376, -0.014465332, 0.002046585, -0.04071045, 0.02029419, -0.050964355, -0.026489258, 0.0625, -0.0074157715, -0.021972656, -0.003780365, -0.015670776, -0.0418396, -0.014190674, 0.027420044, -0.037719727, 0.009887695, -0.004802704, 0.040863037, 0.029220581, -0.008628845, 0.010223389, 0.016021729, 0.009185791, -0.017837524, 0.016738892, 0.04336548, 0.022262573, 0.012481689, 0.0435791, 0.01574707, -0.011192322, -0.024795532, -0.013961792, -0.02859497, -0.026550293, 0.0124435425, 0.017028809, 0.0012712479, 0.007095337, 0.016296387, 0.030181885, 0.00038909912, -0.018966675, 0.013046265, 0.018737793, -0.020935059, -0.039398193, 0.009811401, 0.02508545, 0.0018529892, -0.0019607544, 0.00041294098, 0.032043457, -0.03552246, -0.011779785, -0.006175995, 0.017044067, -0.07696533, -0.0004837513, -0.012626648, -0.08679199, -0.06451416, 0.034454346, 0.004169464, 0.016555786, 0.023269653, -0.00006181002, -0.04248047, 0.0053253174, 0.0009946823, 0.010437012, -0.007583618, -0.05117798, 0.013420105, -0.03149414, -0.062347412, -0.04449463, -0.0076789856, 0.006263733, 0.03326416, -0.008430481, -0.02029419, 0.021652222, 0.019927979, 0.030395508, 0.013290405, -0.016693115, -0.031951904, 0.0041046143, -0.0129776, -0.018203735, 0.024047852, -0.008781433, 0.0036754608, -0.0000059604645, 0.004131317, -0.03152466, -0.016540527, -0.06210327, 0.05105591, -0.013648987, 0.041046143, 0.02154541, 0.037902832, 0.043151855, -0.0049934387, -0.0017137527, 0.0074806213, -0.03286743, 0.008430481, 0.003868103, -0.0029201508, 0.004421234, -0.013938904, 0.015686035, 0.009246826, 0.024124146, -0.01209259, -0.00756073, -0.0001322031, 0.009460449, -0.010917664, 0.012428284, -0.03866577, -0.025360107, 0.0076560974, -0.010620117, 0.034851074, -0.039642334, 0.079711914, -0.054718018, -0.035491943, 0.012397766, 0.008605957, -0.018157959, -0.0012407303, 0.012771606, -0.054626465, -0.04196167, 0.00029993057, 0.04135132, -0.014602661, -0.0037269592, 0.005355835, -0.027923584, 0.045715332, 0.03704834, 0.03074646, -0.04473877, -0.02015686, 0.0014505386, -0.0067749023, -0.0067481995, -0.026794434, -0.020477295, 0.0035190582, 0.025909424, -0.06945801, 0.072753906, -0.011398315, 0.019439697, -0.018005371, -0.01158905, 0.01777649, -0.072509766, -0.00066947937, 0.05255127, 0.015083313, 0.022827148, -0.0023784637, 0.01637268, 0.04788208, 0.03933716, 0.006378174, 0.005958557, 0.028671265, -0.04071045, -0.00390625, -0.024810791, 0.03353882, 0.011795044, 0.017578125, 0.007896423, 0.026290894, -0.068481445, 0.02848816, -0.0044441223, -0.02078247, -0.01348114, -0.02583313, 0.02130127, 0.023284912, -0.0146865845, 0.013092041, -0.061401367, 0.00061893463, 0.041107178, -0.060150146, -0.013847351, 0.023864746, -0.0473938, -0.03945923, -0.061828613, 0.048065186, -0.010818481, 0.0037288666, -0.016693115, 0.032592773, -0.028045654, 0.016189575, 0.021713257, -0.03289795, -0.0018424988, -0.0013189316, 0.010429382, 0.047790527, 0.0023841858, -0.03793335, -0.0044288635, -0.03012085, -0.03262329, -0.013160706, 0.010879517, 0.009689331, 0.026885986, -0.002811432, -0.017852783, 0.018341064, -0.032196045, 0.015777588, -0.0038757324, -0.010643005, 0.012756348, -0.011184692, 0.0031814575, 0.0010890961, 0.0004940033, 0.007774353, -0.008338928, 0.0059814453, -0.027572632, 0.017089844, 0.004211426, -0.012390137, 0.015007019, -0.04034424, 0.004096985, 0.013397217, -0.005859375, -0.01020813, 0.05731201, 0.035705566, 0.034088135, -0.0026741028, 0.019332886, 0.064575195, -0.033599854, -0.021774292, -0.004875183, -0.009185791, -0.02279663, 0.060455322, 0.020080566, -0.008293152, -0.037475586, -0.060424805, -0.039276123, -0.0025691986, 0.03616333, -0.008071899, 0.01676941, -0.041015625, -0.0025119781, -0.03186035, -0.0007891655, -0.017166138, 0.026367188, -0.0072250366, -0.045715332, 0.021987915, -0.00015962124, 0.029632568, -0.037750244, 0.021957397, 0.0065307617, -0.013214111, -0.0206604, -0.056274414, 0.012191772, -0.03466797, -0.0009303093, 0.049438477, 0.028167725, -0.03277588, 0.042816162, -0.028060913, 0.046051025, 0.027618408, 0.02067566, 0.029541016, 0.0181427, 0.014060974, 0.018920898, 0.023010254, -0.0135269165, 0.007080078, -0.06939697, 0.011459351, -0.038024902, -0.015182495, -0.081604004, -0.014389038, 0.032287598, 0.033996582, 0.0019550323, 0.005607605, 0.017410278, -0.009857178, 0.03640747, -0.034423828, 0.05630493, 0.027389526, -0.011917114, 0.0074272156, 0.014167786, -0.0121536255, 0.02508545, 0.006351471, 0.03668213, -0.030456543, -0.033691406, -0.0037498474, 0.008171082, 0.015975952, 0.004722595, -0.014556885, -0.020706177, 0.015403748, -0.014526367, 0.018310547, 0.052490234, 0.050750732, -0.016967773, -0.0059051514, 0.006298065, 0.02053833, -0.045684814, 0.027328491, 0.06121826, -0.052520752, 0.023406982, -0.04348755, -0.05480957, 0.051605225, 0.05444336, 0.0026779175, -0.05154419, -0.038360596, 0.015014648, 0.014152527, 0.04650879, 0.040740967, -0.0140686035, -0.023376465, -0.0074386597, 0.009895325, 0.023880005, 0.058898926, -0.001666069, 0.050109863, -0.0345459, -0.015579224, -0.014846802, -0.00349617, -0.03955078, 0.031982422, -0.009407043, 0.09362793, 0.0023765564, -0.035736084, 0.010948181, 0.038848877, -0.09899902, 0.0053749084, 0.0021572113, 0.026870728, -0.007457733, 0.017349243, -0.02027893, -0.03363037, 0.015571594, -0.028335571, 0.0048980713, 0.07092285, 0.0088272095, 0.052124023, -0.045196533, -0.05215454, 0.05441284, -0.00006169081, 0.117004395, 0.012382507, -0.0041046143, -0.010116577, -0.021850586, 0.07055664, -0.04559326, -0.02078247, -0.016098022, -0.037261963, -0.009284973, -0.016098022, -0.027297974, -0.015083313, -0.02684021, 0.005874634, 0.004924774, 0.016723633, 0.028045654, -0.047302246, -0.044830322, 0.012336731, 0.0017786026, 0.043945312, -0.01423645, -0.019348145, 0.0036697388, -0.0002040863, 0.033935547, -0.034179688, -0.049682617, -0.0043182373, -0.0015449524, -0.047851562, 0.00982666, -0.016418457, -0.016952515, 0.00894165, 0.04196167, 0.0007510185, -0.005756378, -0.023971558, 0.020721436, -0.026748657, -0.048828125, -0.0206604, -0.02456665, 0.029205322, 0.042816162, -0.01663208, -0.013931274, -0.00025367737, 0.012756348, -0.009651184, 0.02947998, 0.052490234, -0.045318604, -0.040222168, 0.0154800415, 0.035705566, 0.043884277, -0.037078857, 0.0039749146, 0.006111145, 0.054992676, 0.029037476, 0.03414917, -0.0049972534, -0.0345459, -0.011161804, -0.02217102, -0.0012588501, -0.00289917, -0.010925293, -0.0028839111, 0.027526855, 0.03164673, -0.01512146, 0.0010404587, 0.0043678284, -0.0019607544, 0.008163452, 0.03286743, -0.013458252, 0.007041931, -0.004989624, 0.031707764, -0.01448822, -0.052459717, -0.02255249, 0.038208008, -0.019958496, 0.0030612946, 0.0007343292, 0.02923584, 0.002248764, 0.041931152, -0.04168701, -0.02293396, 0.016784668, 0.051574707, -0.006011963, 0.061767578, -0.0013141632, 0.01448822, -0.026916504, 0.0099105835, 0.018249512, 0.025421143, 0.0018796921, -0.026000977, 0.03491211, -0.045074463, -0.04510498, 0.05819702, -0.0019702911, 0.013961792, -0.059387207, 0.03930664, -0.05114746, -0.013168335, 0.0013818741, 0.022445679, 0.057922363, -0.04989624, -0.0003437996, -0.0037517548, 0.07092285, 0.0059547424 ], "summary": [ 0.047058105, -0.0058174133, 0.020462036, -0.016723633, -0.023880005, -0.022857666, 0.007041931, -0.03982544, -0.010498047, 0.017364502, -0.045715332, 0.04714966, -0.030227661, -0.005203247, -0.0033283234, -0.053344727, 0.020568848, 0.013427734, 0.021911621, -0.020462036, -0.016174316, -0.015716553, 0.019210815, 0.022323608, 0.053344727, -0.0017232895, -0.044128418, 0.0011339188, 0.04916382, 0.028671265, 0.029022217, -0.032226562, 0.0209198, -0.006225586, 0.015945435, -0.011238098, -0.0017662048, -0.001288414, -0.004600525, 0.023284912, 0.012023926, -0.009307861, -0.04660034, -0.028030396, -0.052886963, 0.03466797, -0.041809082, 0.001364708, -0.011276245, 0.023376465, 0.0036354065, -0.039367676, 0.002565384, 0.042541504, -0.0037612915, -0.044006348, -0.023590088, -0.017318726, -0.0073432922, 0.03869629, 0.059051514, 0.034851074, -0.0069465637, 0.028549194, -0.0020542145, 0.007949829, 0.08081055, -0.015731812, 0.029067993, 0.030578613, 0.013061523, 0.0074768066, 0.019439697, -0.001326561, -0.051818848, -0.009559631, 0.05496216, 0.008613586, -0.002538681, -0.018936157, 0.0039520264, -0.021331787, -0.014450073, -0.04196167, 0.022445679, -0.020187378, -0.016220093, 0.0076293945, 0.0001951456, 0.005882263, -0.019454956, 0.010978699, 0.020431519, 0.0073623657, -0.024414062, -0.016357422, 0.008506775, 0.016906738, 0.018203735, -0.0017623901, -0.03277588, -0.011276245, -0.01889038, -0.013824463, -0.026138306, -0.01751709, 0.037078857, 0.01687622, -0.010253906, 0.0047798157, -0.039031982, 0.024765015, 0.043701172, -0.004085541, 0.019058228, -0.021575928, -0.006515503, 0.06707764, 0.002008438, -0.007858276, -0.0076141357, -0.00010561943, 0.0077819824, 0.06738281, 0.009712219, 0.03765869, 0.0158844, -0.0418396, 0.03074646, 0.014678955, -0.010681152, 0.0048980713, -0.04788208, -0.023788452, -0.027282715, -0.01651001, 0.025894165, -0.018630981, 0.0138168335, -0.024429321, 0.04257202, -0.01348114, 0.011299133, 0.04269409, 0.06616211, 0.029968262, 0.02947998, 0.0007762909, 0.0070343018, 0.010177612, -0.008773804, 0.025146484, -0.006706238, 0.0021572113, -0.026611328, -0.033935547, -0.109802246, 0.020721436, 0.06695557, 0.02381897, 0.004337311, -0.031143188, -0.00365448, 0.052825928, 0.018081665, 0.041534424, 0.016052246, 0.008956909, 0.012992859, 0.0121154785, 0.032287598, -0.03793335, -0.039794922, -0.012458801, -0.009963989, 0.0178833, 0.020355225, 0.021026611, 0.0053367615, -0.07220459, -0.047576904, -0.043518066, 0.0051498413, -0.009567261, -0.045837402, -0.03164673, -0.026229858, 0.0002644062, 0.07556152, -0.0017318726, -0.007221222, -0.018997192, -0.02293396, 0.0031166077, 0.0060424805, -0.002910614, 0.006122589, 0.026321411, 0.005832672, -0.045166016, -0.038513184, 0.01374054, -0.046447754, 0.025177002, -0.005302429, -0.039916992, 0.0026245117, 0.006134033, -0.06982422, 0.019577026, 0.0440979, -0.0027198792, -0.05203247, 0.079956055, 0.072143555, -0.02709961, 0.017562866, 0.001701355, 0.012428284, -0.01184845, 0.013763428, -0.028671265, -0.0060424805, 0.041046143, 0.007320404, 0.035095215, -0.020965576, 0.0284729, 0.07489014, 0.013259888, 0.09918213, -0.01727295, -0.048828125, -0.015945435, -0.012886047, -0.015579224, -0.018096924, -0.078125, 0.040863037, 0.046936035, 0.013748169, -0.010063171, -0.04574585, 0.0027770996, 0.0074768066, -0.0037631989, 0.0049934387, 0.0021190643, -0.010536194, 0.0008401871, 0.02658081, -0.00248909, 0.040161133, 0.017990112, -0.012382507, 0.044006348, -0.031158447, -0.031982422, -0.011024475, -0.002588272, 0.0068626404, 0.0021457672, 0.0008802414, 0.0072364807, 0.0064201355, -0.0524292, -0.02859497, -0.05670166, -0.017715454, -0.0039367676, 0.03665161, -0.0713501, 0.0079422, -0.0062179565, -0.05657959, -0.037384033, -0.030639648, 0.030685425, 0.023529053, -0.036376953, 0.0039901733, 0.03564453, 0.026779175, -0.010345459, 0.01600647, -0.0010414124, 0.012001038, -0.009170532, 0.010482788, 0.06628418, 0.057769775, 0.040649414, -0.008560181, -0.00074863434, -0.0073623657, 0.010421753, -0.07904053, 0.016586304, -0.0013666153, -0.02684021, -0.041992188, 0.039367676, 0.012382507, -0.01763916, 0.020828247, 0.02255249, 0.024719238, 0.0070991516, 0.016143799, 0.024139404, -0.04852295, 0.004753113, 0.019226074, 0.08441162, -0.0340271, -0.04006958, 0.011177063, 0.05480957, 0.04006958, 0.07727051, 0.052703857, 0.020126343, -0.04824829, 0.035064697, -0.0016374588, -0.017044067, 0.032836914, -0.033691406, -0.00021445751, -0.006511688, -0.037506104, -0.023834229, -0.061676025, 0.007850647, 0.00969696, 0.021438599, 0.020126343, 0.013420105, 0.012535095, -0.007255554, 0.03665161, 0.029342651, -0.010047913, -0.019683838, -0.062347412, -0.04034424, -0.046203613, -0.017654419, 0.028747559, -0.044433594, 0.05606079, 0.02784729, -0.035980225, 0.026809692, -0.00037765503, 0.030654907, 0.051849365, 0.061157227, 0.02532959, -0.010673523, 0.06512451, 0.016311646, 0.029312134, -0.08874512, -0.06011963, -0.038757324, 0.0065956116, -0.0146484375, -0.008903503, 0.007843018, 0.010017395, -0.0068511963, -0.055877686, -0.022842407, -0.043823242, 0.026977539, 0.061187744, -0.0067710876, 0.028671265, 0.037261963, 0.0056610107, -0.011505127, 0.010627747, -0.017974854, 0.06945801, 0.008422852, -0.031555176, 0.035186768, -0.0020370483, -0.00039100647, -0.032928467, 0.0077705383, 0.025177002, -0.034423828, -0.050720215, 0.005256653, 0.048309326, -0.031799316, 0.076416016, -0.033050537, 0.015052795, 0.02041626, 0.015457153, -0.0071525574, -0.009902954, 0.01133728, 0.0071792603, -0.008094788, 0.010276794, -0.007232666, 0.027786255, -0.051483154, 0.03289795, -0.054382324, 0.013374329, -0.06365967, 0.048675537, 0.013046265, -0.0259552, -0.052642822, 0.010627747, 0.054901123, -0.034973145, -0.03564453, -0.05053711, -0.008415222, -0.018676758, 0.039031982, -0.06896973, 0.014381409, 0.0014867783, -0.017028809, -0.019134521, -0.008155823, -0.062042236, -0.0034332275, 0.023971558, 0.032684326, 0.04473877, -0.027709961, -0.08203125, -0.03768921, 0.031402588, 0.02961731, -0.00730896, 0.015487671, -0.03942871, -0.06921387, -0.046081543, -0.021148682, -0.044769287, 0.017715454, -0.020996094, 0.03665161, 0.0013160706, 0.013183594, -0.012542725, 0.017120361, 0.039611816, -0.031707764, -0.02960205, -0.0035037994, -0.01777649, -0.0016098022, 0.002483368, 0.046905518, -0.004550934, 0.0035915375, -0.04437256, 0.015777588, -0.017929077, -0.024230957, -0.024551392, -0.008155823, 0.02482605, -0.0035953522, 0.0075149536, -0.0024585724, 0.006450653, -0.013870239, 0.01574707, 0.0063095093, 0.055145264, -0.014091492, 0.044799805, 0.0045280457, -0.03955078, -0.039489746, 0.02722168, -0.010955811, 0.015991211, -0.03237915, 0.061676025, -0.015716553, 0.021774292, -0.004550934, -0.0053634644, -0.012817383, 0.025253296, -0.006713867, -0.0118637085, 0.0152282715, 0.008094788, -0.02885437, -0.05630493, 0.058410645, 0.025741577, 0.008201599, 0.019561768, -0.0793457, -0.01966858, -0.053863525, 0.06109619, 0.036315918, 0.008323669, -0.009849548, 0.07354736, 0.030319214, 0.0016546249, -0.0056495667, 0.033599854, 0.05508423, 0.0019035339, 0.019546509, 0.01537323, -0.008216858, -0.018844604, -0.0058059692, -0.051849365, -0.028961182, 0.041168213, 0.04168701, 0.0044174194, -0.009216309, 0.01134491, 0.00053596497, -0.0050621033, -0.015640259, 0.044006348, 0.06915283, -0.015029907, -0.049621582, 0.0005784035, 0.052520752, -0.005088806, -0.02784729, -0.05026245, -0.019439697, -0.055419922, 0.0055389404, -0.010734558, -0.026062012, -0.054595947, -0.05142212, 0.0031700134, -0.03253174, 0.0025901794, -0.008476257, -0.014907837, -0.0005784035, -0.029693604, 0.03918457, -0.023147583, 0.008178711, -0.0023059845, 0.035186768, 0.00030183792, -0.012954712, 0.014198303, -0.04321289, -0.047729492, -0.04095459, 0.024459839, 0.009414673, 0.026565552, -0.016189575, 0.021942139, 0.016906738, 0.013458252, -0.021408081, 0.01890564, 0.013191223, 0.00919342, 0.0023727417, -0.013839722, 0.01763916, -0.0015983582, 0.012527466, -0.01171875, 0.0023937225, -0.0045928955, 0.0075187683, -0.037078857, -0.094177246, 0.024475098, 0.025405884, -0.0033226013, 0.059417725, 0.020950317, 0.041229248, -0.024749756, 0.022079468, 0.019866943, -0.01701355, 0.009902954, 0.012252808, -0.027648926, -0.012466431, -0.047607422, -0.018707275, 0.011207581, -0.0289917, 0.045562744, -0.026748657, 0.020370483, 0.04522705, -0.019821167, 0.013076782, -0.004688263, 0.013549805, 0.044708252, -0.018188477, 0.028121948, 0.01776123, 0.056427002, 0.025024414, -0.0579834, 0.018630981, 0.005443573, 0.02255249, 0.013168335, -0.0019521713, -0.05529785, -0.02659607, -0.0058021545, 0.044555664, -0.018997192, -0.024627686, -0.020080566, -0.06137085, 0.03201294, -0.0022449493, 0.05596924, -0.036346436, -0.05319214, -0.02494812, -0.00062036514, 0.013442993, -0.036315918, -0.04562378, -0.0024547577, 0.03137207, -0.084472656, 0.09887695, 0.05697632, 0.012374878, -0.013977051, 0.013656616, -0.006828308, -0.04196167, -0.045806885, -0.011985779, 0.0030708313, -0.03466797, 0.043701172, -0.00843811, -0.020263672, 0.029434204, -0.011978149, 0.017120361, -0.008468628, -0.021392822, 0.03881836, -0.017089844, 0.028656006, 0.059295654, -0.024887085, 0.01600647, 0.018661499, 0.006664276, 0.011550903, -0.03024292, 0.003063202, -0.04272461, 0.00042510033, 0.032348633, 0.029800415, -0.010925293, 0.025970459, -0.017837524, -0.0002925396, -0.022003174, -0.01448822, -0.07965088, 0.027160645, -0.020599365, -0.019683838, -0.044128418, 0.02796936, -0.036834717, -0.012557983, -0.0048179626, 0.021896362, -0.023208618, -0.010398865, 0.008956909, -0.010810852, -0.011245728, 0.04345703, 0.029190063, 0.017318726, -0.04058838, -0.08050537, -0.002111435, -0.023483276, -0.018218994, -0.055908203, -0.044433594, -0.0127334595, 0.056274414, 0.0056266785, 0.019866943, 0.05987549, -0.046661377, 0.010772705, -0.0104599, 0.008262634, 0.008392334, 0.0025920868, 0.004623413, 0.0008921623, -0.06311035, -0.022827148, -0.0042495728, 0.0012178421, 0.006275177, 0.047851562, -0.026245117, -0.020599365, 0.0033187866, 0.04296875, -0.009124756, 0.024795532, -0.039123535, 0.0066719055, 0.019851685, 0.006008148, -0.013336182, 0.014663696, 0.01802063, 0.03741455, -0.009757996, -0.01651001, 0.012260437, 0.010437012, 0.013580322, 0.083862305, 0.013656616, -0.025817871, -0.044921875, -0.017242432, -0.0075645447, -0.022628784, -0.007873535, -0.017089844, -0.008033752, 0.010299683, -0.00022828579, 0.026748657, -0.0076446533, -0.035003662, 0.004650116, 0.014007568, 0.0055999756, 0.030914307, 0.006126404, 0.020141602, -0.02848816, -0.015975952, -0.02067566, 0.021896362, -0.013442993, 0.00038838387, 0.024002075, -0.02999878, 0.04083252, 0.023406982, 0.03604126, -0.023345947, 0.012641907, -0.012680054, 0.032989502, 0.044830322, -0.025726318, -0.036193848, 0.015197754, 0.087768555, 0.0078086853, 0.008628845, 0.029052734, 0.009605408, -0.061187744, -0.046936035, -0.036621094, -0.035186768, 0.0102005005, -0.01260376, -0.00932312, -0.020111084, 0.01965332, -0.0059013367, 0.0019607544, 0.020233154, -0.04586792, -0.04147339, -0.03414917, 0.0390625, -0.040740967, 0.047912598, 0.023956299, 0.008491516, 0.036865234, 0.0032806396, 0.023910522, -0.02078247, 0.0015554428, 0.021881104, -0.045166016, 0.01285553, -0.027526855, -0.0077819824, -0.028289795, 0.016677856, 0.006641388, 0.022644043, 0.018447876, -0.017669678, 0.02935791, -0.020111084, -0.004600525, 0.033081055, 0.00308609, 0.025619507, 0.027954102, 0.00023174286, 0.016693115, 0.006462097, -0.030410767, 0.08984375, 0.020980835, 0.040039062, -0.06549072, -0.02722168, -0.003408432, 0.010444641, -0.005218506, 0.02986145, -0.022644043, -0.025680542, -0.02999878, -0.008804321, 0.037261963, 0.06439209, -0.0099487305, 0.06756592, 0.0067977905, 0.028518677, -0.02053833, -0.010879517, -0.024658203, 0.02684021, -0.018585205, 0.066589355, 0.0058631897, -0.021820068, 0.01737976, 0.025009155, -0.06311035, 0.03086853, 0.019134521, 0.019058228, 0.014656067, 0.013458252, -0.050842285, -0.0029754639, 0.04159546, -0.014846802, 0.028167725, -0.007572174, 0.021865845, 0.003419876, -0.008163452, 0.005672455, 0.036895752, 0.033325195, 0.076293945, 0.0023441315, -0.0023899078, -0.010025024, -0.019042969, -0.0036678314, -0.014595032, 0.015159607, -0.027130127, -0.030166626, 0.021911621, 0.033721924, -0.07281494, -0.010093689, -0.014656067, -0.036987305, -0.0076293945, -0.011634827, -0.026641846, -0.021255493, 0.033996582, -0.02041626, 0.036010742, 0.02861023, 0.029510498, -0.017868042, 0.026107788, -0.0101623535, 0.018356323, -0.061767578, -0.040496826, -0.022277832, 0.0390625, -0.054534912, 0.013061523, -0.0038166046, -0.015670776, 0.06915283, 0.07269287, 0.027526855, 0.012016296, -0.0076904297, 0.008712769, 0.022247314, -0.09454346, -0.02381897, -0.032409668, -0.013465881, 0.002872467, 0.008331299, -0.018844604, 0.030197144, 0.017730713, -0.025894165, 0.03375244, 0.017669678, -0.034240723, -0.006248474, 0.019897461, 0.022964478, 0.06100464, 0.008026123, 0.04928589, -0.0075416565, -0.027786255, 0.004119873, 0.029174805, 0.0022716522, -0.01939392, 0.020355225, 0.008995056, 0.01108551, 0.010177612, 0.019973755, -0.015701294, 0.0014648438, -0.0032787323, -0.017913818, -0.003698349, -0.0055732727, -0.021636963, -0.014099121, 0.0073127747, -0.028076172, -0.04727173, -0.017974854, -0.04385376, -0.017959595, -0.042755127, -0.048675537, -0.0024852753, 0.0017738342, -0.01133728, -0.029907227, 0.0513916, -0.03640747, -0.015151978, -0.044006348, 0.045013428, -0.034057617, 0.0048713684, -0.008239746, 0.041931152, -0.02029419, 0.053527832, -0.020736694, 0.020507812, 0.012512207, 0.045288086, 0.014320374, 0.0066337585, 0.046661377, -0.048919678, -0.03515625, 0.05392456, -0.019119263, 0.03338623, -0.030151367, 0.015533447, 0.019927979, -0.015220642, 0.010955811, 0.04071045, 0.02545166, -0.028457642, -0.0068588257, 0.0046844482, 0.057769775, 0.0036888123 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1805.07874v2
GSAE: an autoencoder with embedded gene-set nodes for genomics functional characterization
Hung-I Harry Chen, Yu-Chiao Chiu, Tinghe Zhang, Songyao Zhang, Yufei Huang, Yidong Chen
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.GN
Bioinformatics tools have been developed to interpret gene expression data at the gene set level, and these gene set based analyses improve the biologists' capability to discover functional relevance of their experiment design. While elucidating gene set individually, inter gene sets association is rarely taken into consideration. Deep learning, an emerging machine learning technique in computational biology, can be used to generate an unbiased combination of gene set, and to determine the biological relevance and analysis consistency of these combining gene sets by leveraging large genomic data sets. In this study, we proposed a gene superset autoencoder (GSAE), a multi-layer autoencoder model with the incorporation of a priori defined gene sets that retain the crucial biological features in the latent layer. We introduced the concept of the gene superset, an unbiased combination of gene sets with weights trained by the autoencoder, where each node in the latent layer is a superset. Trained with genomic data from TCGA and evaluated with their accompanying clinical parameters, we showed gene supersets' ability of discriminating tumor subtypes and their prognostic capability. We further demonstrated the biological relevance of the top component gene sets in the significant supersets. Using autoencoder model and gene superset at its latent layer, we demonstrated that gene supersets retain sufficient biological information with respect to tumor subtypes and clinical prognostic significance. Superset also provides high reproducibility on survival analysis and accurate prediction for cancer subtypes.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1805.07874v2
2018-12-28T20:53:26
2018-05-21T02:37:54
{ "title": [ -0.040161133, 0.012619019, -0.06921387, -0.062408447, 0.01902771, -0.0045547485, -0.061431885, -0.008171082, 0.0038204193, 0.02822876, 0.0032978058, 0.009338379, 0.00039958954, -0.0284729, -0.02835083, 0.02909851, -0.0017328262, 0.026519775, -0.018554688, -0.036346436, -0.029754639, -0.04360962, 0.04647827, 0.041229248, 0.025802612, -0.03829956, -0.07940674, 0.029006958, -0.048431396, -0.030303955, -0.017059326, 0.033813477, 0.043884277, 0.04385376, -0.048675537, -0.026870728, -0.060913086, 0.030517578, -0.013214111, 0.002840042, 0.016784668, -0.0027275085, 0.02067566, -0.050323486, 0.00705719, 0.030410767, -0.045135498, -0.062561035, -0.008460999, 0.017242432, 0.01927185, 0.025802612, -0.011955261, 0.034210205, 0.017532349, -0.013885498, -0.005592346, -0.0038604736, 0.043884277, 0.043914795, 0.017700195, -0.05355835, 0.022277832, -0.02217102, -0.035064697, 0.0046653748, -0.020111084, 0.03756714, 0.05255127, -0.002040863, -0.033477783, 0.0041122437, -0.02571106, 0.008506775, -0.07739258, 0.03717041, 0.047668457, 0.016098022, 0.030776978, -0.02142334, 0.04534912, 0.010887146, 0.017303467, 0.0102005005, 0.008628845, -0.008560181, -0.021224976, -0.034576416, -0.014656067, -0.05105591, -0.00592041, -0.008903503, 0.0131073, 0.016296387, -0.034484863, -0.028701782, -0.0074386597, 0.007801056, -0.00008100271, 0.0031166077, 0.014419556, -0.019561768, 0.020019531, -0.026687622, 0.0115356445, 0.01651001, -0.017318726, -0.031036377, 0.010658264, 0.038757324, -0.012542725, 0.023376465, 0.00907135, -0.02720642, 0.014213562, 0.030807495, 0.011642456, 0.03237915, 0.021530151, 0.022140503, -0.0076904297, -0.018463135, 0.0054626465, 0.008453369, 0.028335571, 0.009262085, -0.029327393, -0.00598526, -0.054534912, 0.04437256, -0.0032043457, 0.03643799, -0.045410156, -0.071899414, -0.04748535, 0.0357666, 0.00007665157, -0.005973816, -0.009086609, 0.02229309, -0.01335907, -0.038208008, -0.005847931, -0.01663208, 0.011222839, 0.024902344, 0.07598877, -0.019485474, -0.055786133, -0.016616821, -0.037841797, 0.04925537, 0.056915283, 0.01309967, -0.09259033, -0.0104599, -0.12609863, -0.015029907, -0.0022964478, -0.023406982, 0.015930176, -0.011154175, -0.037139893, -0.035583496, 0.011383057, 0.0015916824, -0.017791748, 0.034606934, 0.02192688, 0.032958984, -0.028869629, 0.0039596558, 0.058929443, 0.014419556, -0.021484375, 0.010009766, 0.029525757, -0.020584106, 0.02734375, 0.013633728, 0.011054993, -0.017608643, 0.009048462, 0.040985107, -0.0597229, 0.0046157837, -0.004840851, 0.009429932, 0.04373169, 0.0043678284, -0.041137695, 0.039886475, -0.04296875, -0.047851562, -0.0385437, -0.009567261, 0.028945923, 0.026138306, -0.0063171387, 0.007419586, -0.013168335, -0.018997192, -0.014122009, 0.015052795, 0.028503418, -0.026687622, -0.0037193298, -0.005264282, 0.003332138, 0.04046631, 0.026123047, 0.0025520325, -0.009681702, -0.009269714, -0.012870789, -0.05102539, 0.011070251, -0.013076782, -0.013046265, 0.02810669, -0.045318604, -0.0044670105, -0.024719238, 0.033599854, -0.012176514, -0.016830444, -0.0018539429, -0.042266846, -0.0046195984, 0.013504028, 0.040496826, -0.046661377, 0.035491943, -0.020523071, -0.016220093, -0.01007843, -0.0129470825, -0.016784668, -0.008041382, 0.017089844, 0.014404297, -0.03048706, -0.031066895, -0.018157959, 0.09124756, 0.02532959, 0.002193451, -0.010353088, 0.011054993, 0.05432129, 0.03048706, 0.04397583, 0.031280518, -0.02897644, 0.009353638, 0.04953003, 0.009231567, 0.014503479, -0.017211914, 0.0027008057, 0.0008659363, 0.055786133, -0.0040664673, 0.029724121, -0.031799316, -0.011924744, -0.027389526, 0.011238098, -0.00856781, 0.016662598, 0.047027588, 0.0048828125, 0.0052757263, 0.019470215, 0.054260254, -0.05444336, -0.02116394, -0.00083589554, -0.021911621, -0.05368042, -0.008270264, -0.0044670105, 0.017547607, 0.0061416626, 0.06488037, -0.012794495, -0.008308411, -0.005962372, -0.034301758, -0.009162903, 0.04119873, 0.04748535, 0.0036563873, -0.010406494, 0.015167236, 0.009391785, 0.09887695, 0.04650879, -0.01687622, 0.03161621, -0.026031494, 0.028625488, 0.002286911, -0.019973755, 0.018295288, 0.016967773, 0.032196045, 0.029266357, -0.025680542, 0.011131287, -0.054107666, 0.0082473755, 0.015327454, -0.0076408386, -0.044311523, -0.054473877, -0.010070801, -0.03616333, -0.038330078, -0.04647827, 0.091674805, -0.007881165, -0.047851562, -0.011566162, 0.0016870499, -0.02027893, -0.023361206, -0.03918457, -0.034484863, 0.028778076, -0.005783081, -0.0011548996, -0.05307007, -0.006729126, -0.021530151, 0.021011353, -0.017181396, 0.020446777, -0.013298035, 0.017471313, 0.01828003, -0.009864807, 0.030899048, -0.03656006, 0.013069153, -0.04724121, 0.020431519, 0.027297974, -0.05117798, 0.017913818, 0.014480591, -0.02607727, -0.029663086, -0.0031337738, 0.041625977, -0.03540039, -0.024765015, 0.03729248, 0.016098022, -0.025619507, 0.020339966, 0.029205322, -0.005645752, -0.036712646, -0.0236969, -0.055236816, -0.011138916, -0.020553589, -0.00011384487, 0.099365234, -0.053863525, -0.00034594536, -0.026382446, -0.020584106, -0.020629883, -0.0014858246, -0.02420044, -0.03274536, -0.01751709, -0.032470703, 0.011802673, 0.027893066, -0.026611328, 0.029937744, 0.046966553, 0.011810303, 0.0005927086, 0.00089359283, 0.025604248, -0.0023002625, -0.017990112, 0.0044288635, -0.028671265, 0.0033473969, 0.021713257, 0.01838684, 0.0005970001, -0.0012588501, -0.09918213, -0.01725769, 0.056732178, -0.015777588, -0.029953003, 0.021240234, -0.04196167, 0.014266968, 0.016098022, -0.0028095245, 0.020431519, 0.07977295, -0.01146698, 0.018936157, 0.008552551, -0.017974854, 0.019348145, -0.02079773, -0.0869751, 0.031463623, -0.032958984, -0.048553467, -0.009773254, 0.0030975342, -0.06188965, 0.0036830902, -0.011131287, 0.054382324, 0.024658203, 0.009788513, -0.0003528595, -0.013465881, 0.0146865845, -0.024612427, -0.04522705, -0.032684326, -0.013397217, 0.027770996, 0.0151901245, 0.036224365, 0.008804321, -0.0007901192, -0.05206299, -0.026046753, 0.0040016174, 0.024002075, -0.00623703, -0.024459839, -0.008781433, -0.011550903, -0.021347046, -0.01197052, -0.014556885, -0.0017900467, -0.02180481, 0.015914917, -0.00843811, 0.019622803, 0.038330078, 0.024627686, -0.05053711, -0.032104492, 0.008361816, -0.050842285, -0.03439331, -0.004737854, 0.05227661, -0.008155823, -0.01789856, -0.021865845, 0.002784729, 0.014915466, -0.019134521, 0.02973938, -0.019073486, -0.020736694, -0.007709503, -0.010658264, -0.012954712, 0.001909256, 0.0024585724, 0.011711121, -0.0102005005, 0.009414673, -0.0057640076, -0.06210327, 0.008773804, 0.0134887695, -0.10021973, -0.024871826, 0.010345459, -0.049682617, -0.051727295, -0.044036865, 0.02848816, -0.03845215, -0.009460449, 0.0025749207, -0.009780884, -0.032409668, -0.022720337, -0.07067871, -0.033203125, 0.07720947, 0.021499634, 0.031219482, 0.01878357, 0.0017900467, 0.010475159, -0.045043945, 0.0031738281, -0.012107849, 0.05392456, -0.016983032, -0.02027893, 0.03289795, -0.032714844, 0.02128601, -0.0138549805, -0.0013589859, -0.019836426, 0.001830101, 0.03527832, 0.010314941, 0.030838013, 0.03543091, -0.018295288, -0.036254883, -0.012382507, -0.029373169, 0.012519836, 0.0262146, 0.01210022, -0.019989014, 0.025375366, 0.0046577454, 0.019989014, 0.042114258, -0.0055122375, 0.009895325, 0.025238037, -0.04360962, -0.015281677, 0.02935791, 0.03390503, -0.0028839111, -0.0013685226, 0.022384644, 0.017669678, 0.04208374, -0.014183044, -0.03866577, 0.0020122528, 0.036468506, -0.041900635, -0.0102005005, -0.05291748, -0.034454346, -0.036102295, 0.011795044, -0.016052246, 0.03616333, 0.010559082, -0.004009247, -0.034210205, 0.012313843, 0.02470398, 0.010116577, 0.013641357, -0.021743774, -0.0020713806, -0.018035889, -0.025436401, -0.024505615, -0.010231018, -0.04272461, 0.03387451, -0.004032135, -0.05126953, 0.010131836, 0.021270752, 0.09918213, 0.04650879, -0.016281128, -0.10089111, -0.0066566467, 0.0047454834, -0.023971558, -0.011428833, -0.018692017, -0.0036525726, -0.028167725, -0.00868988, -0.014656067, -0.010772705, -0.011566162, 0.0038490295, -0.004535675, 0.059387207, 0.017410278, 0.055236816, 0.019012451, 0.005214691, 0.00064229965, 0.0024147034, -0.036468506, -0.028701782, 0.017059326, 0.042938232, -0.039154053, 0.028320312, 0.03982544, -0.01058197, -0.026824951, 0.020065308, 0.017044067, 0.037902832, -0.032196045, -0.014274597, 0.013214111, -0.0077056885, -0.03805542, 0.025527954, 0.036987305, 0.054779053, -0.025466919, 0.041168213, -0.04019165, 0.007980347, 0.01374054, -0.015472412, 0.006954193, -0.0075149536, 0.029220581, -0.09112549, -0.07849121, -0.028625488, 0.07897949, -0.036590576, -0.020950317, -0.0017023087, -0.008079529, -0.00806427, 0.032592773, 0.036590576, 0.012802124, -0.035003662, -0.03805542, -0.011482239, -0.026229858, -0.05883789, 0.009742737, 0.020370483, 0.0071487427, -0.030578613, 0.015151978, -0.10180664, -0.003452301, -0.0019426346, -0.021697998, -0.0028934479, -0.085754395, 0.0030975342, 0.026153564, -0.0019760132, 0.024749756, -0.013961792, 0.034301758, 0.033172607, 0.044708252, 0.013893127, 0.024490356, 0.0184021, 0.0030937195, 0.022369385, -0.030319214, 0.023040771, 0.023147583, 0.029159546, 0.013183594, 0.044067383, -0.080078125, 0.0181427, 0.046661377, 0.030227661, 0.029678345, -0.06555176, 0.02293396, -0.023483276, -0.021240234, 0.005908966, -0.012199402, -0.044036865, -0.014503479, -0.016113281, -0.0491333, 0.031677246, 0.0053520203, -0.025146484, -0.033996582, -0.007434845, 0.0003914833, 0.0043754578, -0.0061187744, 0.034057617, -0.017456055, 0.035491943, 0.019866943, -0.057769775, -0.009185791, 0.0051002502, 0.011169434, 0.03857422, -0.0009083748, -0.044311523, -0.006904602, 0.002614975, -0.049316406, -0.048095703, 0.013328552, 0.0039749146, -0.0052833557, 0.017410278, -0.0037574768, 0.02897644, 0.0079574585, 0.038208008, 0.011665344, 0.0008354187, 0.07281494, -0.001950264, -0.0090789795, 0.00042438507, -0.002532959, 0.0076828003, 0.0019836426, -0.0040893555, -0.04055786, -0.0066871643, -0.0003142357, 0.015464783, -0.016418457, -0.10028076, 0.016601562, 0.0072631836, 0.018463135, 0.014678955, 0.027404785, 0.025115967, 0.037506104, -0.012054443, 0.012062073, 0.0446167, -0.037628174, -0.029693604, 0.0020141602, 0.024032593, 0.0030231476, 0.06317139, -0.022109985, -0.032348633, -0.030014038, -0.066223145, -0.02293396, 0.002401352, 0.018661499, 0.04852295, 0.023788452, -0.006679535, 0.03555298, -0.003917694, -0.009941101, -0.043701172, 0.02760315, 0.004634857, -0.006099701, -0.008224487, -0.0149002075, -0.005645752, -0.019241333, 0.025421143, 0.010520935, -0.007789612, -0.009506226, -0.041137695, -0.0061798096, -0.03942871, 0.00084352493, 0.028717041, 0.03878784, -0.037109375, 0.026489258, -0.027755737, 0.05569458, -0.00042891502, 0.07196045, 0.06210327, 0.028152466, -0.00047826767, -0.0028076172, 0.011604309, -0.048828125, 0.0030345917, -0.041381836, 0.012809753, -0.051330566, -0.0056915283, -0.045532227, 0.048065186, -0.008033752, 0.0036392212, 0.011962891, -0.00434494, -0.003255844, 0.007221222, 0.041870117, 0.019836426, 0.03945923, 0.026901245, 0.004535675, 0.0060691833, -0.014389038, 0.009277344, 0.033111572, 0.0039978027, 0.0044898987, -0.03363037, -0.018249512, 0.009208679, 0.0071983337, 0.017456055, -0.034484863, -0.024368286, -0.040618896, 0.027236938, -0.011199951, 0.023742676, 0.05923462, 0.03060913, 0.007972717, -0.008705139, 0.0061950684, -0.048065186, -0.03439331, -0.0025100708, 0.028625488, -0.079833984, 0.03475952, -0.024459839, -0.011299133, -0.029037476, 0.03781128, 0.025024414, -0.0446167, -0.045562744, 0.025024414, 0.05722046, 0.022705078, 0.008346558, -0.034454346, -0.016555786, -0.0024204254, 0.019439697, 0.009727478, 0.039733887, 0.03213501, 0.005432129, 0.017227173, -0.034362793, 0.025299072, 0.03164673, 0.0072135925, 0.032592773, 0.012184143, 0.023223877, -0.007987976, -0.04019165, -0.00007301569, 0.019729614, -0.06359863, -0.012130737, 0.02267456, 0.027618408, 0.048797607, 0.07885742, 0.016342163, 0.0021362305, -0.004283905, -0.053985596, 0.033172607, 0.03050232, -0.019500732, 0.025375366, -0.051452637, -0.05065918, 0.031463623, -0.047332764, 0.07110596, -0.037841797, -0.011795044, 0.0013818741, 0.0010490417, 0.044952393, -0.049957275, -0.034301758, -0.009017944, -0.02633667, -0.0014734268, 0.0022010803, -0.019943237, -0.045410156, -0.005584717, 0.028427124, 0.008560181, -0.008201599, 0.008331299, -0.01763916, -0.103271484, -0.0082092285, -0.034332275, 0.03086853, -0.019561768, 0.010612488, -0.018661499, -0.01474762, 0.008583069, -0.02130127, -0.0049591064, -0.0049095154, -0.06933594, -0.040527344, 0.025756836, 0.01612854, -0.0368042, -0.025604248, -0.020095825, -0.00022184849, -0.035491943, -0.031707764, 0.05895996, -0.019638062, -0.05340576, -0.011238098, -0.009277344, 0.04650879, 0.007881165, -0.0061912537, 0.04171753, 0.008666992, -0.007537842, -0.0000693202, 0.008171082, 0.018341064, -0.02532959, -0.04888916, 0.022567749, 0.03918457, 0.057769775, -0.055023193, -0.01411438, 0.013511658, -0.00078725815, -0.0042495728, 0.061798096, 0.010322571, -0.013175964, 0.032592773, 0.0126571655, 0.010910034, -0.033416748, -0.054656982, -0.057891846, 0.043670654, 0.017974854, 0.007545471, -0.062286377, 0.034179688, 0.018707275, 0.011833191, 0.01725769, -0.00881958, 0.026916504, -0.0036239624, 0.048980713, -0.009498596, -0.029937744, 0.005970001, 0.016357422, -0.011512756, 0.011421204, -0.021881104, -0.0035419464, -0.02128601, 0.019317627, -0.024383545, -0.04095459, 0.04385376, 0.03201294, 0.02079773, 0.037322998, -0.022384644, -0.016326904, -0.005607605, -0.027908325, -0.017486572, -0.02609253, 0.032562256, -0.018325806, 0.014183044, -0.028549194, -0.043701172, 0.01423645, -0.031234741, 0.045837402, -0.053710938, 0.030029297, -0.035858154, -0.026779175, 0.00012612343, 0.019683838, 0.021331787, -0.025009155, -0.046081543, -0.03768921, 0.045654297, -0.026916504 ], "summary": [ 0.006298065, 0.012962341, -0.04159546, -0.03704834, 0.01612854, -0.013511658, -0.043548584, 0.003742218, 0.0020389557, 0.029205322, 0.0048446655, -0.02482605, 0.026153564, -0.048797607, 0.000043570995, -0.0073928833, 0.013908386, -0.015357971, 0.009925842, -0.023132324, 0.016983032, -0.020370483, 0.028900146, 0.01977539, 0.00025963783, -0.0519104, -0.019317627, 0.0524292, -0.019485474, 0.009338379, 0.0037193298, 0.020126343, 0.004386902, 0.026992798, -0.025390625, -0.0031032562, 0.0059509277, 0.017242432, 0.016555786, 0.00048041344, -0.0024547577, 0.017868042, 0.10192871, -0.09240723, 0.03717041, 0.059326172, -0.031585693, -0.07678223, -0.009292603, -0.0022525787, -0.023025513, -0.013542175, -0.01222229, 0.012916565, -0.012031555, -0.015914917, -0.03955078, -0.03652954, 0.027389526, 0.022964478, 0.013465881, -0.060821533, 0.023406982, -0.036346436, -0.034301758, 0.0068626404, 0.01638794, -0.003993988, 0.036315918, -0.02935791, -0.017654419, 0.029846191, 0.020523071, -0.026901245, -0.04309082, 0.06756592, -0.007949829, 0.06121826, 0.03277588, -0.054901123, 0.04550171, 0.043945312, 0.054016113, 0.0012369156, -0.018753052, -0.00041389465, -0.005268097, -0.03845215, -0.017333984, -0.015411377, -0.018630981, -0.0047035217, -0.045959473, 0.03765869, 0.01576233, -0.043151855, -0.0006303787, 0.001200676, -0.019989014, 0.006713867, 0.035369873, -0.0552063, 0.051086426, -0.03704834, -0.0017967224, 0.05014038, -0.018096924, -0.040405273, 0.002609253, 0.017303467, 0.00248909, -0.058563232, 0.00023329258, -0.07489014, -0.004348755, 0.03137207, 0.0025081635, 0.026443481, 0.042266846, -0.001159668, 0.01626587, 0.040802002, -0.042388916, -0.024139404, 0.0135269165, -0.0069389343, -0.01499176, 0.013366699, -0.06210327, 0.0692749, 0.014335632, 0.025161743, 0.003742218, -0.046173096, -0.06878662, -0.02418518, -0.016708374, -0.013366699, 0.0077819824, -0.007820129, 0.029724121, -0.041625977, -0.009536743, 0.037200928, 0.0053253174, 0.04043579, 0.027313232, -0.004337311, -0.010940552, -0.050323486, 0.013145447, -0.0022087097, 0.06213379, -0.008399963, -0.09979248, -0.057128906, -0.046844482, -0.028366089, 0.008277893, -0.07318115, 0.018554688, -0.0027923584, -0.01411438, 0.0031108856, -0.0039863586, -0.0023956299, -0.0140686035, 0.007484436, 0.024627686, -0.079833984, 0.039733887, 0.009117126, 0.118896484, -0.024780273, -0.012397766, -0.030654907, 0.03302002, 0.012176514, -0.017196655, 0.028457642, 0.010879517, -0.029129028, 0.013160706, 0.009971619, -0.030273438, 0.026916504, -0.009170532, 0.01574707, 0.04232788, -0.012557983, -0.004047394, 0.0135650635, -0.016067505, -0.0066337585, -0.00009381771, 0.007858276, 0.010543823, 0.030029297, -0.018127441, -0.026138306, 0.06390381, -0.0066719055, 0.02229309, 0.002998352, -0.04067993, 0.008132935, -0.017715454, -0.00061511993, -0.023086548, 0.01701355, 0.016860962, -0.03643799, 0.0041389465, -0.011657715, 0.0023536682, -0.0069389343, 0.0057296753, -0.024261475, -0.02709961, -0.00051164627, -0.040985107, 0.0124435425, -0.049438477, 0.01663208, 0.0006837845, 0.017089844, -0.006729126, -0.004386902, 0.025863647, 0.010528564, 0.034179688, -0.022262573, 0.033203125, -0.047058105, -0.05935669, 0.014816284, 0.0073661804, 0.009338379, -0.036590576, 0.036315918, 0.025985718, 0.0025482178, -0.027374268, -0.0390625, 0.09436035, 0.061645508, 0.021575928, -0.037475586, 0.013397217, 0.044677734, -0.026443481, -0.00035357475, 0.021621704, -0.033569336, 0.017547607, 0.031951904, 0.025741577, 0.008094788, 0.014099121, -0.00013494492, 0.004333496, 0.059753418, -0.0126571655, 0.029968262, 0.0029659271, -0.01626587, -0.0047073364, -0.0020141602, -0.00983429, -0.0050468445, -0.0008072853, -0.03616333, -0.010444641, 0.008117676, 0.058563232, -0.025299072, -0.033111572, -0.006034851, 0.019515991, -0.008522034, -0.014663696, -0.029953003, -0.015899658, -0.006706238, 0.045928955, -0.011795044, 0.005558014, -0.0021915436, 0.013175964, 0.062042236, 0.06347656, 0.03451538, 0.017532349, 0.0057792664, 0.0035324097, 0.012077332, -0.0030269623, 0.008529663, 0.011924744, -0.020202637, -0.018936157, 0.039001465, -0.018493652, 0.007183075, 0.01058197, 0.025100708, -0.026626587, 0.04525757, 0.020843506, -0.01828003, -0.01008606, 0.015274048, 0.03164673, 0.07940674, -0.038208008, -0.028945923, -0.03173828, 0.047332764, 0.016952515, 0.013870239, 0.103149414, 0.018585205, -0.014060974, -0.035949707, 0.007888794, -0.0496521, -0.022857666, -0.029830933, 0.008903503, 0.0016412735, -0.029632568, -0.008026123, -0.02053833, 0.012252808, -0.0036773682, -0.015655518, -0.003118515, 0.04525757, 0.012550354, -0.016662598, 0.02609253, 0.029907227, 0.025039673, 0.027816772, -0.0050239563, -0.019958496, 0.01612854, -0.003736496, 0.00920105, 0.009025574, -0.0015602112, -0.008201599, -0.0051841736, 0.0138168335, 0.0018787384, -0.044769287, 0.0013561249, 0.052490234, -0.0022621155, -0.018325806, 0.01763916, 0.019195557, -0.01084137, -0.019561768, -0.013389587, -0.04156494, -0.009208679, -0.0071868896, 0.023101807, 0.06744385, -0.040252686, 0.046081543, -0.019714355, -0.012260437, 0.00094509125, 0.0022354126, 0.04876709, -0.010955811, 0.011100769, 0.036895752, 0.008056641, 0.026290894, 0.004425049, 0.028579712, 0.0023460388, 0.0035076141, 0.0068893433, 0.028198242, 0.0060539246, -0.0129776, -0.007648468, 0.02809143, 0.011856079, -0.0029277802, 0.009597778, 0.00043296814, 0.015777588, -0.035247803, -0.05050659, -0.028427124, 0.03253174, 0.05291748, 0.025787354, 0.015052795, -0.04083252, 0.021331787, -0.004627228, 0.0033416748, -0.01222229, 0.0256958, 0.008285522, 0.00381279, -0.0007162094, 0.02619934, 0.025375366, -0.044433594, 0.016052246, 0.02784729, -0.031433105, -0.056121826, -0.02003479, 0.06903076, -0.005405426, -0.0138549805, 0.016723633, 0.08428955, -0.0413208, -0.029953003, 0.007881165, 0.0044898987, 0.013748169, 0.001250267, -0.028671265, -0.037597656, -0.008842468, 0.016235352, 0.0016174316, 0.013145447, -0.0008611679, -0.008323669, -0.045410156, -0.026885986, -0.0063285828, 0.042175293, -0.021316528, 0.004371643, -0.030319214, -0.04559326, 0.018859863, 0.038238525, -0.026107788, -0.0047340393, 0.02911377, 0.02558899, -0.035827637, 0.008285522, 0.050231934, 0.053466797, 0.0012712479, -0.04196167, -0.008674622, -0.036499023, -0.022232056, 0.016448975, 0.04736328, 0.030014038, -0.058776855, 0.004055023, -0.033203125, 0.030975342, 0.03149414, -0.00017130375, -0.029586792, -0.021087646, -0.021652222, -0.046875, 0.050048828, 0.0023536682, 0.04522705, -0.04296875, -0.013877869, 0.0060920715, 0.0055389404, -0.0501709, -0.029830933, 0.01436615, -0.09136963, -0.073913574, 0.021484375, -0.043182373, -0.008659363, -0.03543091, 0.045196533, -0.047180176, 0.010009766, -0.029052734, -0.02154541, 0.065979004, 0.004634857, -0.055114746, 0.059661865, -0.03137207, 0.041168213, 0.018707275, -0.023635864, 0.06628418, 0.08734131, -0.030685425, -0.038330078, -0.00009816885, 0.018844604, -0.08911133, -0.022109985, -0.007331848, -0.015686035, -0.01927185, 0.0020942688, 0.04321289, -0.041656494, -0.0009613037, 0.031280518, 0.020874023, 0.028533936, 0.013900757, -0.01626587, -0.03286743, 0.024017334, -0.023345947, -0.014411926, -0.018295288, 0.04675293, 0.05822754, 0.046905518, 0.022872925, -0.047332764, -0.029312134, -0.011169434, -0.00504303, 0.030822754, 0.013313293, -0.021621704, -0.03387451, -0.012962341, 0.017440796, -0.025924683, 0.0143585205, -0.0059661865, 0.040863037, -0.066101074, -0.023147583, 0.029296875, 0.05291748, -0.035858154, -0.017089844, 0.003238678, -0.022644043, -0.033935547, -0.009597778, -0.009628296, 0.03955078, -0.019302368, 0.041931152, -0.016784668, 0.0005874634, 0.04751587, 0.02848816, -0.020889282, -0.032684326, 0.027359009, -0.004348755, -0.019851685, -0.025131226, -0.018295288, -0.052886963, -0.0075187683, -0.010955811, -0.067993164, -0.008728027, -0.017333984, 0.05618286, 0.008651733, 0.009780884, -0.07196045, -0.061523438, -0.015266418, 0.014579773, -0.03918457, -0.001086235, -0.050048828, -0.035705566, -0.01576233, 0.0127334595, -0.030548096, -0.059265137, -0.00258255, 0.0259552, -0.00077819824, 0.052490234, 0.031463623, 0.016494751, 0.015205383, 0.012504578, 0.0028514862, -0.006038666, -0.024154663, 0.005645752, 0.0087890625, 0.016143799, 0.0053138733, 0.038238525, 0.0057411194, -0.04650879, 0.009155273, 0.017074585, 0.01828003, -0.005420685, -0.03387451, 0.0116119385, 0.013534546, -0.008766174, 0.029937744, -0.00056886673, 0.025222778, 0.027511597, -0.055480957, -0.013252258, 0.057128906, -0.01852417, -0.028564453, 0.0206604, -0.013404846, 0.030471802, -0.083984375, -0.06781006, -0.056274414, 0.078308105, -0.02670288, -0.037109375, 0.01689148, -0.018859863, 0.011489868, -0.01701355, -0.031982422, -0.01687622, -0.047058105, -0.023986816, -0.034423828, -0.005207062, -0.018859863, 0.016494751, 0.020690918, -0.009017944, 0.006401062, -0.041625977, -0.031311035, 0.0014333725, 0.019012451, 0.02142334, -0.014854431, -0.046875, -0.049682617, -0.037597656, -0.029281616, -0.03866577, -0.0028495789, 0.016220093, 0.014389038, 0.013381958, -0.01625061, -0.000017821789, -0.012992859, -0.00459671, 0.05090332, -0.026641846, 0.028778076, 0.014190674, -0.012680054, 0.0069084167, 0.0357666, -0.06335449, 0.003326416, 0.021133423, 0.02355957, 0.014251709, -0.045928955, 0.026626587, -0.038970947, 0.012237549, -0.0034828186, -0.016464233, -0.032165527, 0.0000615716, -0.012954712, -0.009979248, 0.045928955, 0.016113281, 0.017456055, -0.059143066, -0.044555664, -0.014450073, 0.019699097, -0.0146484375, 0.044189453, -0.008155823, 0.02684021, -0.058135986, -0.103637695, -0.02911377, 0.06298828, 0.029205322, -0.015930176, -0.03668213, -0.017181396, -0.0126953125, -0.01576233, -0.02545166, -0.01979065, 0.011352539, 0.0028972626, 0.018218994, 0.005794525, -0.016784668, 0.04458618, -0.0074920654, 0.031051636, -0.031433105, 0.0054969788, 0.010238647, -0.055786133, -0.095947266, -0.023483276, -0.015060425, -0.023254395, -0.023071289, -0.017059326, -0.008468628, 0.027374268, -0.0093307495, 0.039093018, -0.05001831, -0.06903076, 0.005756378, 0.024871826, 0.013259888, 0.044036865, 0.02166748, -0.0056610107, 0.097473145, 0.013793945, 0.020019531, 0.03945923, 0.011009216, -0.059265137, -0.0078125, 0.03161621, 0.008056641, 0.006706238, -0.0008044243, -0.052642822, 0.023834229, -0.06011963, 0.01108551, -0.03062439, -0.011764526, 0.024658203, -0.01235199, 0.035980225, 0.030960083, -0.01927185, -0.03765869, -0.01838684, -0.0032024384, -0.009483337, 0.012207031, 0.052703857, -0.039489746, 0.0029697418, -0.020339966, 0.013511658, 0.030670166, 0.010917664, -0.0031204224, -0.024154663, -0.021057129, -0.037597656, 0.017501831, 0.032409668, 0.05883789, -0.04309082, 0.01486969, 0.041137695, 0.045684814, -0.0178833, 0.030883789, 0.023345947, 0.029647827, -0.018356323, -0.014335632, 0.0033454895, -0.03878784, 0.016235352, -0.006969452, -0.0126571655, -0.030639648, -0.027938843, -0.014984131, 0.07159424, -0.03250122, -0.030288696, 0.070251465, -0.006210327, 0.022766113, 0.00035357475, -0.033843994, 0.0025501251, 0.0056533813, 0.055725098, 0.0073432922, 0.0118255615, -0.034332275, -0.0009937286, 0.025848389, -0.0103302, 0.03881836, -0.01637268, -0.002325058, 0.035186768, -0.010505676, -0.015136719, -0.05697632, 0.014945984, -0.049591064, -0.010879517, -0.007537842, -0.0028686523, -0.0055351257, -0.013031006, 0.038635254, -0.0010881424, 0.0055656433, -0.004863739, 0.0039138794, -0.0048599243, 0.010864258, -0.013122559, 0.018463135, -0.0076179504, -0.021499634, 0.052947998, 0.034576416, 0.022583008, -0.0262146, -0.00554657, 0.030593872, 0.017196655, 0.010513306, 0.019760132, -0.021636963, -0.020370483, 0.003227234, -0.029541016, 0.030288696, 0.06707764, 0.070373535, -0.021209717, 0.040649414, -0.008430481, 0.01436615, 0.029190063, 0.033447266, 0.027420044, -0.00333786, -0.0035552979, -0.0050735474, -0.016464233, -0.0044403076, 0.023269653, -0.0022716522, 0.003358841, 0.007205963, 0.047729492, 0.074523926, 0.1005249, -0.005622864, 0.027542114, 0.03375244, -0.00749588, 0.023742676, -0.011962891, 0.012680054, -0.03314209, -0.015777588, 0.019714355, -0.015136719, 0.042388916, 0.04360962, -0.007297516, 0.017578125, -0.01373291, -0.01940918, -0.00041151047, -0.031066895, 0.024597168, -0.040130615, -0.054504395, 0.009902954, 0.01374054, -0.012161255, -0.056610107, -0.052825928, 0.0076179504, -0.05227661, -0.015823364, 0.015808105, 0.0063667297, -0.03262329, -0.0010881424, -0.01751709, 0.048706055, -0.024215698, -0.0055122375, 0.020141602, 0.022537231, -0.012107849, -0.012939453, 0.00083494186, 0.04360962, -0.0048332214, -0.011054993, 0.03463745, 0.049591064, -0.022644043, -0.06976318, 0.029510498, -0.014373779, -0.029678345, 0.01651001, 0.03778076, 0.010498047, -0.036102295, -0.006580353, -0.00014519691, 0.0020446777, -0.051696777, -0.027313232, 0.060424805, -0.012016296, 0.014122009, 0.014625549, -0.007648468, -0.029296875, -0.04168701, -0.024963379, -0.0031375885, 0.008804321, 0.03665161, -0.019882202, -0.0037059784, 0.020935059, -0.012176514, 0.037384033, 0.015396118, -0.074279785, -0.04458618, 0.040100098, 0.032104492, 0.029800415, 0.014518738, -0.08343506, -0.040405273, 0.027313232, -0.037384033, -0.00013840199, -0.08148193, 0.01914978, -0.0070724487, -0.008483887, -0.007572174, 0.005973816, -0.0068626404, -0.007785797, 0.011360168, -0.022125244, -0.023040771, 0.031829834, 0.014213562, -0.023147583, -0.014511108, -0.0032176971, -0.02268982, -0.014411926, -0.0071258545, -0.006576538, 0.05630493, -0.011978149, -0.0340271, 0.036865234, -0.030395508, 0.015930176, 0.033416748, -0.028396606, -0.024612427, 0.002204895, -0.010787964, 0.061309814, -0.029144287, 0.0028953552, 0.008613586, -0.019470215, 0.0023059845, -0.024673462, 0.048217773, -0.0066375732, -0.0021648407, 0.037597656, -0.008850098, 0.03314209, -0.014266968, 0.07055664, -0.0112838745, 0.028640747, 0.0021858215, 0.013206482, 0.014572144 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1811.00839v2
ATP: Directed Graph Embedding with Asymmetric Transitivity Preservation
Jiankai Sun, Bortik Bandyopadhyay, Armin Bashizade, Jiongqian Liang, P. Sadayappan, Srinivasan Parthasarathy
cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SI
Directed graphs have been widely used in Community Question Answering services (CQAs) to model asymmetric relationships among different types of nodes in CQA graphs, e.g., question, answer, user. Asymmetric transitivity is an essential property of directed graphs, since it can play an important role in downstream graph inference and analysis. Question difficulty and user expertise follow the characteristic of asymmetric transitivity. Maintaining such properties, while reducing the graph to a lower dimensional vector embedding space, has been the focus of much recent research. In this paper, we tackle the challenge of directed graph embedding with asymmetric transitivity preservation and then leverage the proposed embedding method to solve a fundamental task in CQAs: how to appropriately route and assign newly posted questions to users with the suitable expertise and interest in CQAs. The technique incorporates graph hierarchy and reachability information naturally by relying on a non-linear transformation that operates on the core reachability and implicit hierarchy within such graphs. Subsequently, the methodology levers a factorization-based approach to generate two embedding vectors for each node within the graph, to capture the asymmetric transitivity. Extensive experiments show that our framework consistently and significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art baselines on two diverse real-world tasks: link prediction, and question difficulty estimation and expert finding in online forums like Stack Exchange. Particularly, our framework can support inductive embedding learning for newly posted questions (unseen nodes during training), and therefore can properly route and assign these kinds of questions to experts in CQAs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1811.00839v2
2018-11-06T14:25:49
2018-11-02T12:45:16
{ "title": [ -0.02810669, -0.0017004013, -0.05206299, -0.055603027, 0.010139465, 0.007827759, -0.021881104, -0.004787445, 0.015586853, 0.0012140274, -0.025314331, 0.012741089, -0.020126343, -0.024429321, -0.025253296, -0.0052719116, -0.0138168335, 0.051208496, -0.010261536, -0.035461426, -0.03451538, -0.04727173, 0.0362854, 0.035888672, 0.029678345, -0.03881836, -0.015777588, -0.014190674, -0.012207031, -0.035247803, -0.00894928, 0.0076522827, 0.04711914, 0.023651123, -0.0020599365, 0.025131226, -0.056152344, 0.012069702, 0.0026397705, 0.0027866364, 0.011276245, -0.0018110275, -0.0029315948, -0.042175293, -0.040405273, 0.017654419, -0.041168213, -0.0061950684, -0.046905518, 0.049346924, 0.028244019, 0.011138916, -0.018310547, 0.06451416, 0.04107666, -0.0069274902, -0.025634766, -0.019515991, 0.042510986, 0.059631348, 0.03765869, -0.054840088, 0.022888184, -0.003238678, -0.031677246, -0.03805542, -0.015556335, 0.042999268, 0.053741455, -0.0029067993, -0.01927185, 0.020477295, 0.0141067505, 0.0017337799, -0.07611084, 0.020492554, 0.03945923, 0.012931824, 0.039245605, -0.041931152, 0.006038666, -0.0045166016, -0.02218628, -0.025787354, 0.017501831, -0.039764404, -0.02658081, -0.01449585, -0.0035190582, -0.02619934, -0.006603241, 0.029373169, 0.022277832, 0.018707275, -0.04714966, -0.0051994324, -0.015701294, 0.044799805, -0.0074768066, 0.011795044, -0.030197144, 0.015235901, -0.02911377, -0.03756714, 0.017318726, -0.020385742, -0.041381836, -0.029800415, 0.041107178, 0.05206299, -0.026779175, 0.06726074, 0.014022827, 0.016220093, 0.016555786, -0.00086450577, -0.015640259, 0.056640625, 0.01159668, 0.059570312, -0.00006335974, -0.023590088, -0.012748718, 0.0029850006, 0.025390625, -0.0014352798, -0.03277588, 0.013412476, -0.016937256, -0.00365448, 0.009857178, 0.056488037, -0.0635376, -0.055755615, -0.045562744, 0.043029785, -0.03326416, 0.0069236755, -0.021316528, 0.023773193, -0.008270264, -0.042053223, 0.01902771, 0.0050964355, -0.014297485, 0.03137207, 0.0597229, -0.01876831, -0.0619812, -0.046081543, -0.033935547, 0.022079468, 0.039764404, -0.0063972473, -0.053497314, 0.0036029816, -0.14038086, 0.0075263977, 0.020339966, 0.026931763, 0.026611328, 0.018844604, 0.0029659271, 0.018951416, 0.06384277, -0.0259552, -0.022842407, 0.023086548, 0.00818634, 0.06842041, -0.014381409, 0.023284912, -0.00076818466, 0.013420105, 0.0026779175, -0.004058838, 0.037719727, -0.030838013, 0.017578125, 0.011505127, 0.009468079, -0.020935059, -0.02961731, 0.046020508, -0.05999756, 0.010391235, -0.008514404, -0.018218994, 0.035461426, -0.00881958, -0.0057296753, 0.049316406, -0.05819702, -0.04031372, -0.049591064, -0.0039138794, 0.031280518, 0.03277588, 0.0009860992, 0.0065612793, -0.03555298, -0.020950317, -0.031982422, 0.03277588, 0.026321411, -0.039215088, -0.0033874512, -0.009017944, -0.022949219, 0.058776855, 0.05392456, 0.0055122375, -0.044830322, 0.014892578, 0.0011358261, -0.05029297, 0.0048828125, -0.0128479, -0.00048732758, -0.009262085, -0.023269653, -0.0038070679, -0.009918213, 0.015716553, 0.030426025, -0.022842407, 0.024963379, -0.043640137, 0.051330566, 0.0073394775, 0.049072266, -0.043426514, -0.001543045, -0.009864807, 0.0048675537, -0.015975952, -0.0062408447, -0.038085938, 0.0154800415, 0.007873535, 0.0018787384, -0.015159607, 0.0042800903, 0.051361084, 0.056121826, -0.014595032, 0.0022087097, 0.03640747, -0.0019798279, 0.046936035, 0.06890869, 0.03729248, 0.017410278, -0.0013866425, -0.022369385, 0.050811768, 0.012382507, 0.043823242, -0.044036865, 0.018829346, -0.014198303, 0.033203125, 0.0050849915, 0.0073013306, -0.041900635, -0.0009274483, -0.029663086, 0.006084442, 0.02609253, -0.0016889572, 0.023040771, -0.033691406, 0.009475708, 0.02619934, 0.018249512, -0.03427124, -0.022613525, 0.0043945312, -0.008171082, -0.053710938, -0.0041885376, 0.0052986145, 0.046539307, 0.006122589, 0.039154053, 0.004219055, 0.022018433, -0.0037212372, -0.018005371, -0.02909851, 0.020507812, 0.064086914, 0.00072813034, 0.010597229, 0.01878357, 0.0073890686, 0.07885742, 0.07104492, -0.026992798, 0.03213501, -0.04397583, 0.019760132, 0.028671265, -0.033996582, -0.0032405853, 0.04498291, 0.043518066, 0.01675415, -0.017730713, -0.0098724365, -0.023498535, -0.018188477, 0.0048599243, -0.028839111, -0.029190063, -0.05606079, -0.00014436245, -0.04800415, -0.04534912, -0.029312134, 0.07635498, -0.04171753, -0.030960083, 0.0141067505, -0.011016846, -0.017944336, 0.031677246, -0.03378296, -0.042388916, 0.035888672, -0.0015449524, 0.0051841736, -0.05050659, 0.008468628, -0.022598267, 0.026351929, -0.0070610046, 0.0073776245, -0.000038087368, 0.008560181, 0.036254883, 0.022109985, 0.009590149, -0.033843994, 0.012069702, -0.057861328, 0.0121536255, 0.025009155, -0.045288086, 0.012878418, 0.024627686, -0.030822754, -0.03048706, 0.01512146, 0.07165527, -0.017333984, -0.01737976, 0.061309814, 0.062561035, -0.008712769, 0.010635376, 0.0023727417, -0.013015747, -0.054779053, -0.02848816, -0.033843994, -0.026016235, 0.001698494, 0.016204834, 0.07519531, -0.015487671, -0.008583069, -0.047698975, -0.016494751, -0.0013380051, -0.007637024, -0.0036334991, -0.032928467, -0.022766113, -0.020324707, -0.012390137, 0.0037326813, 0.0010786057, 0.0019035339, 0.06335449, -0.0069084167, 0.0034008026, 0.03753662, 0.025909424, 0.0019006729, -0.009864807, 0.004234314, -0.035980225, 0.01071167, 0.011489868, 0.009811401, 0.00008010864, 0.0073051453, -0.1116333, -0.0063323975, 0.068725586, -0.0066070557, -0.022201538, 0.01626587, -0.04623413, 0.009361267, 0.0042877197, -0.010856628, 0.03805542, 0.062561035, 0.013298035, 0.022583008, 0.03289795, -0.018463135, 0.010612488, -0.018371582, -0.057128906, 0.037109375, -0.026321411, -0.07800293, -0.026184082, 0.002040863, -0.03765869, -0.008926392, 0.0011262894, 0.027145386, 0.030090332, 0.010360718, 0.012580872, -0.011413574, 0.0026302338, -0.030395508, -0.020492554, 0.0018339157, -0.022476196, -0.023208618, 0.0050239563, -0.021026611, 0.045013428, -0.030715942, -0.031158447, -0.015411377, 0.023727417, 0.06463623, 0.015487671, -0.023895264, -0.02230835, -0.00049209595, -0.015434265, 0.009597778, -0.026748657, 0.0041999817, -0.03994751, 0.015899658, -0.023956299, 0.020004272, 0.01574707, 0.013900757, -0.04095459, -0.039916992, 0.008049011, -0.025238037, -0.07623291, -0.005012512, 0.05831909, 0.0035133362, -0.017074585, -0.007881165, -0.012702942, 0.015365601, -0.006038666, -0.014762878, 0.018173218, 0.012893677, -0.021820068, 0.01966858, -0.0033988953, 0.024932861, -0.045043945, -0.023880005, 0.023162842, -0.0031261444, 0.025634766, -0.06225586, 0.030410767, -0.012710571, -0.1003418, -0.032440186, 0.011581421, -0.03338623, -0.045654297, -0.033569336, 0.02281189, 0.0010089874, -0.01525116, 0.018676758, -0.0054626465, -0.03555298, -0.0062408447, -0.09320068, -0.008712769, 0.08459473, -0.0000860095, 0.015357971, 0.034606934, -0.016815186, 0.0033626556, -0.011497498, 0.011230469, -0.004383087, 0.09844971, -0.001824379, -0.0071411133, 0.018295288, -0.022109985, 0.030838013, 0.023712158, -0.014411926, 0.00983429, 0.006412506, 0.02229309, 0.036895752, -0.025177002, 0.02255249, 0.034240723, -0.033203125, -0.04675293, 0.005619049, 0.020401001, -0.006134033, 0.008918762, -0.03933716, 0.032348633, 0.028762817, 0.017318726, 0.06750488, -0.0006322861, -0.025558472, 0.021942139, 0.00466156, -0.009307861, 0.01701355, 0.031311035, 0.026489258, 0.0016307831, -0.013061523, -0.025161743, 0.0022773743, -0.007545471, -0.032836914, -0.0066566467, 0.009635925, -0.03652954, -0.001414299, -0.062316895, -0.024780273, -0.026565552, 0.016281128, -0.03579712, 0.021102905, 0.020309448, -0.000119924545, -0.041809082, 0.002817154, 0.03250122, -0.0021324158, 0.021713257, -0.023345947, 0.022262573, -0.016998291, -0.041290283, -0.029159546, -0.009262085, -0.033599854, 0.042297363, 0.009063721, 0.00592041, 0.02407837, 0.01876831, 0.04006958, 0.014091492, -0.008964539, -0.01171875, 0.068725586, 0.014091492, -0.036987305, 0.010093689, 0.0009460449, 0.006702423, -0.04156494, -0.025787354, -0.025238037, -0.011772156, -0.038208008, -0.003227234, 0.0038909912, 0.05065918, 0.030853271, 0.050231934, 0.026306152, -0.0073280334, 0.005004883, 0.0099487305, -0.02760315, -0.024139404, 0.03704834, 0.028869629, -0.003545761, 0.027328491, 0.050201416, 0.007801056, -0.029922485, 0.010025024, 0.016693115, 0.027862549, -0.0005021095, -0.005428314, 0.015014648, -0.03591919, -0.016983032, 0.020751953, 0.016433716, 0.066589355, -0.023483276, 0.048553467, -0.009208679, 0.022460938, 0.034210205, -0.020874023, 0.0002655983, -0.0072250366, 0.01713562, -0.064331055, -0.09075928, -0.01914978, 0.09326172, -0.03149414, 0.0038166046, -0.010879517, 0.0098724365, 0.014450073, 0.07055664, 0.034606934, -0.02885437, 0.026519775, -0.010398865, -0.0073280334, -0.026000977, -0.045928955, 0.037078857, -0.0048179626, 0.0025672913, 0.0052223206, -0.031433105, -0.099243164, -0.0056152344, -0.0035476685, -0.02407837, 0.030807495, -0.08392334, -0.004711151, 0.049987793, 0.0073928833, 0.026351929, 0.0064086914, 0.00021505356, 0.043640137, 0.02406311, 0.021240234, 0.0017709732, 0.0049591064, -0.04711914, 0.028549194, 0.004257202, -0.00043559074, 0.00944519, 0.025848389, 0.0027313232, 0.0015201569, -0.026855469, 0.020736694, 0.012283325, 0.017303467, -0.0028152466, -0.050933838, -0.0063438416, 0.012031555, 0.011711121, 0.013160706, -0.01524353, -0.04977417, -0.01725769, -0.007369995, -0.035186768, 0.016098022, 0.0035953522, -0.053619385, -0.039123535, 0.026641846, -0.01826477, -0.0113220215, 0.0131073, 0.0038013458, -0.028930664, 0.030166626, 0.026321411, -0.017105103, -0.008018494, -0.018447876, -0.008781433, 0.034454346, 0.04159546, -0.018966675, 0.0029296875, -0.019515991, -0.062927246, -0.049468994, 0.0093307495, 0.004070282, 0.0033683777, -0.0016384125, -0.006668091, 0.026245117, 0.0008735657, 0.039489746, 0.008232117, -0.019714355, 0.048950195, 0.0049858093, 0.0005455017, 0.006313324, -0.0033092499, 0.007205963, -0.008010864, -0.00466156, -0.076171875, 0.035247803, -0.005256653, -0.004432678, 0.035125732, -0.042541504, 0.018005371, 0.025558472, 0.0041885376, 0.02230835, 0.037872314, 0.03414917, 0.0118637085, 0.003856659, 0.03781128, 0.043884277, -0.058258057, -0.016983032, 0.012390137, 0.02645874, -0.018218994, 0.030593872, -0.017578125, -0.011054993, -0.04067993, -0.07501221, -0.028839111, -0.006187439, 0.030197144, 0.029144287, 0.025741577, -0.060638428, 0.0039749146, -0.020324707, -0.01826477, -0.03805542, 0.042907715, 0.005821228, -0.0259552, 0.010223389, -0.020385742, 0.008102417, -0.036376953, 0.038604736, -0.0038318634, -0.01663208, -0.012527466, -0.007118225, 0.02420044, -0.018173218, -0.03137207, 0.039611816, -0.006816864, -0.0037078857, 0.054229736, -0.020019531, 0.035736084, 0.017822266, 0.077941895, 0.049621582, 0.017105103, 0.0234375, 0.005996704, 0.03488159, -0.04711914, 0.036895752, -0.04196167, 0.022033691, -0.052490234, -0.010520935, -0.087524414, 0.029327393, 0.025405884, 0.024169922, 0.016693115, 0.009780884, 0.032348633, 0.004272461, 0.022781372, -0.019882202, 0.05529785, 0.015792847, 0.017944336, -0.02243042, -0.024337769, 0.022033691, 0.043701172, -0.00009679794, -0.006690979, 0.018112183, -0.02810669, -0.006706238, 0.042816162, 0.030044556, -0.03692627, -0.025619507, -0.04043579, -0.00012290478, -0.031799316, 0.029724121, 0.06842041, 0.013999939, 0.021011353, -0.024765015, 0.008850098, -0.033721924, -0.021438599, -0.014419556, 0.039031982, -0.05178833, 0.007980347, -0.05645752, -0.008270264, -0.004009247, -0.008323669, 0.06585693, -0.08099365, -0.07824707, 0.0046157837, 0.064819336, -0.0036449432, -0.0018053055, -0.050231934, -0.01852417, -0.01953125, 0.008216858, 0.0015897751, -0.014579773, 0.002286911, 0.05657959, -0.013626099, -0.04058838, 0.01763916, -0.021530151, 0.009567261, 0.037139893, 0.0010795593, 0.030334473, 0.015205383, -0.030578613, 0.029708862, 0.013870239, -0.040405273, -0.006904602, 0.0058250427, 0.015312195, 0.077819824, 0.08734131, 0.0513916, 0.029846191, -0.018356323, -0.06311035, 0.023971558, 0.040008545, -0.03201294, 0.026290894, -0.04135132, -0.04031372, 0.017471313, -0.051330566, 0.0390625, -0.036132812, 0.0047454834, -0.01512146, 0.021850586, 0.02357483, -0.04260254, -0.004081726, -0.0076904297, -0.042785645, -0.005012512, -0.0048713684, -0.036834717, -0.011375427, -0.011695862, 0.0013904572, -0.0033111572, -0.0037612915, -0.03427124, -0.010047913, -0.033813477, 0.0007929802, -0.043273926, 0.057128906, -0.014205933, -0.0026283264, -0.029663086, 0.0009460449, -0.0018901825, -0.02368164, -0.00299263, -0.010009766, -0.06970215, -0.037628174, 0.010887146, -0.000045657158, -0.019851685, -0.017242432, 0.014503479, 0.013908386, -0.014724731, 0.0020256042, 0.016540527, -0.062561035, -0.0022850037, 0.00032806396, -0.03878784, 0.042877197, 0.04473877, -0.0287323, 0.047027588, -0.014030457, -0.046081543, 0.0018825531, -0.008033752, 0.029754639, 0.0103302, -0.05291748, 0.024597168, 0.049987793, 0.056854248, -0.025177002, -0.0036506653, 0.03515625, -0.02130127, -0.020248413, 0.05316162, 0.02357483, -0.004135132, 0.015403748, 0.017807007, 0.0000269413, -0.04196167, -0.04638672, -0.049041748, 0.018692017, 0.027236938, -0.0040016174, -0.04699707, 0.038330078, -0.00021147728, 0.01499939, 0.010665894, -0.009010315, 0.015533447, -0.014335632, 0.033355713, -0.016220093, -0.020736694, -0.0062561035, 0.026992798, -0.01637268, 0.026306152, -0.022567749, -0.005996704, 0.007926941, 0.021347046, -0.03768921, -0.04498291, 0.04534912, 0.024353027, 0.010002136, 0.03161621, -0.010810852, 0.0008840561, 0.0033874512, -0.015258789, -0.025497437, -0.022201538, 0.03668213, -0.04244995, -0.004306793, -0.011650085, -0.033355713, 0.016448975, -0.043151855, 0.051361084, -0.044921875, 0.0129852295, -0.039611816, -0.017150879, -0.018188477, 0.0026626587, -0.010131836, -0.04067993, -0.040924072, -0.04272461, 0.03010559, -0.0062179565 ], "summary": [ 0.041809082, -0.016357422, 0.0016260147, -0.0077438354, -0.02494812, -0.025650024, 0.032348633, 0.004398346, 0.035949707, -0.014671326, -0.03152466, -0.003168106, -0.013954163, -0.033203125, 0.0060691833, -0.020629883, -0.0021743774, 0.051361084, 0.019485474, -0.025604248, 0.008796692, -0.018554688, -0.005996704, 0.039642334, 0.009498596, 0.0025672913, 0.07366943, -0.03237915, 0.047332764, 0.009162903, 0.0140686035, -0.05706787, 0.016845703, 0.002084732, 0.011352539, -0.020202637, -0.039093018, 0.009529114, 0.006668091, 0.0044021606, 0.014892578, -0.015289307, 0.047607422, -0.055664062, -0.0025863647, 0.0032634735, 0.023712158, 0.0009937286, 0.02897644, 0.010169983, -0.014129639, -0.011230469, -0.030776978, 0.027267456, -0.007007599, 0.018005371, -0.028305054, -0.059509277, 0.03677368, 0.05267334, 0.032104492, -0.055419922, 0.0181427, -0.022918701, 0.002111435, -0.014045715, 0.037506104, -0.00011497736, 0.034973145, -0.010124207, -0.005672455, 0.031463623, 0.017547607, -0.014968872, -0.046936035, 0.018859863, 0.018875122, 0.021438599, 0.0116119385, -0.019302368, -0.008125305, 0.037750244, -0.07110596, -0.052001953, 0.03286743, -0.018753052, -0.016540527, -0.01399231, -0.0079422, 0.008918762, -0.012435913, 0.015419006, -0.042388916, 0.05319214, 0.0029945374, -0.01928711, 0.017364502, 0.019592285, 0.0032653809, 0.01272583, -0.0029582977, -0.02406311, -0.013626099, -0.01737976, 0.0058135986, -0.03137207, -0.056762695, -0.052246094, 0.042510986, 0.0769043, -0.019378662, 0.016677856, 0.0019035339, -0.011383057, 0.0062217712, 0.016586304, -0.025756836, 0.072265625, 0.01058197, 0.061706543, 0.018753052, 0.033966064, -0.020950317, 0.0010471344, -0.004600525, 0.01600647, -0.00016272068, -0.01826477, -0.035217285, -0.007911682, -0.02519226, 0.039398193, 0.05038452, 0.004310608, -0.016113281, -0.006538391, -0.020980835, -0.039367676, -0.03062439, 0.043426514, 0.00017619133, -0.08123779, -0.0077819824, 0.023483276, -0.017593384, 0.062561035, 0.03994751, -0.024047852, -0.038970947, -0.07635498, -0.007286072, -0.012283325, 0.02720642, -0.041229248, -0.06854248, -0.052459717, -0.10345459, -0.0055122375, 0.036468506, -0.011520386, 0.0010147095, 0.036621094, 0.0513916, 0.009819031, 0.029464722, -0.08178711, -0.030166626, 0.010726929, -0.0018167496, 0.040863037, -0.02078247, 0.022766113, -0.02027893, -0.008430481, -0.005558014, -0.0045776367, 0.001247406, -0.031555176, -0.006713867, 0.078186035, 0.022399902, -0.031921387, -0.050598145, 0.024719238, -0.019592285, 0.03152466, -0.0345459, -0.030731201, 0.03060913, -0.031555176, 0.03289795, 0.04284668, -0.023284912, -0.022964478, 0.0017442703, 0.0021686554, 0.0025253296, -0.013336182, 0.012634277, -0.01285553, 0.0077209473, -0.011199951, -0.014808655, 0.029434204, -0.04522705, -0.0009188652, -0.02003479, -0.00036644936, 0.024963379, 0.035125732, 0.009437561, -0.0049324036, -0.019546509, 0.019256592, -0.021606445, -0.05529785, 0.010726929, -0.048339844, 0.0019464493, -0.054748535, 0.0029468536, 0.036956787, -0.020004272, 0.058135986, 0.02330017, -0.019897461, 0.008079529, -0.016220093, 0.054718018, -0.0019369125, 0.04171753, -0.018295288, 0.02078247, 0.038909912, 0.004962921, 0.0051879883, 0.041809082, -0.043182373, 0.025100708, 0.016052246, 0.02279663, -0.00642395, -0.0013036728, 0.031951904, 0.009132385, 0.009567261, 0.033050537, -0.01020813, -0.027267456, 0.026779175, 0.011497498, 0.018859863, -0.008300781, 0.016052246, -0.015640259, 0.004547119, 0.014640808, 0.0703125, -0.042755127, -0.0033073425, -0.013397217, -0.029144287, -0.0018568039, -0.019317627, 0.025009155, -0.0625, 0.012168884, -0.009117126, 0.04309082, -0.05291748, -0.00843811, -0.0657959, -0.009086609, 0.018615723, 0.009742737, -0.03982544, -0.03994751, 0.014823914, -0.019195557, -0.0076026917, 0.0032424927, 0.00025105476, 0.027877808, -0.009063721, 0.008529663, 0.04421997, 0.037322998, 0.015342712, 0.016082764, 0.025527954, 0.022125244, 0.054138184, -0.0019044876, 0.058166504, -0.02796936, 0.0030078888, -0.023223877, 0.033477783, -0.015777588, 0.0006303787, -0.02355957, 0.03640747, 0.017730713, -0.012794495, 0.0031528473, 0.029373169, 0.018341064, 0.017150879, 0.023071289, -0.015235901, 0.019805908, 0.009857178, 0.021850586, 0.040283203, -0.015991211, -0.04046631, -0.003917694, 0.020095825, -0.0546875, -0.007369995, 0.07623291, -0.022918701, 0.024871826, 0.042907715, -0.00071144104, -0.059265137, 0.08227539, -0.015838623, -0.024459839, 0.010986328, -0.06149292, -0.05505371, -0.03692627, 0.0051498413, -0.021774292, 0.008041382, 0.018493652, -0.052734375, 0.022384644, 0.07110596, 0.09100342, -0.02520752, -0.01802063, -0.02130127, 0.013305664, -0.010467529, -0.0026607513, 0.020492554, -0.01914978, 0.008491516, -0.012054443, -0.047943115, -0.009536743, 0.00630188, 0.05065918, -0.029434204, -0.019363403, 0.0713501, 0.06439209, 0.00085020065, -0.010131836, 0.014060974, -0.021530151, -0.08557129, -0.014663696, -0.0023880005, -0.03765869, -0.0023727417, 0.040496826, 0.007896423, 0.05154419, 0.0028247833, -0.054351807, -0.019470215, 0.01146698, -0.041931152, 0.06817627, -0.030029297, 0.044158936, 0.053985596, -0.01713562, 0.032318115, -0.01411438, 0.060302734, 0.052734375, -0.005126953, 0.042999268, 0.057556152, 0.05166626, -0.017364502, 0.021118164, 0.023925781, -0.039764404, -0.025924683, 0.01007843, 0.0027866364, -0.007835388, 0.019729614, -0.028839111, -0.041046143, 0.0758667, 0.00818634, 0.00894928, 0.01675415, -0.02923584, 0.022598267, 0.0077171326, 0.0019044876, 0.025939941, -0.016311646, 0.031677246, -0.0088272095, 0.016860962, -0.009361267, -0.01701355, -0.032989502, 0.004257202, 0.012870789, -0.0038223267, -0.026245117, -0.010513306, 0.016677856, -0.029647827, 0.0009331703, -0.02267456, 0.008361816, 0.003211975, 0.027435303, -0.015899658, -0.002023697, 0.0051612854, -0.04159546, 0.0040397644, 0.046936035, -0.007446289, -0.013999939, -0.005065918, -0.092041016, 0.06463623, -0.078186035, -0.049987793, -0.02519226, 0.00039672852, 0.06536865, 0.00021982193, -0.0058517456, -0.057678223, -0.05657959, -0.0032596588, 0.007209778, -0.011932373, -0.003414154, 0.008651733, 0.02015686, -0.031463623, 0.06774902, -0.012039185, 0.03152466, -0.0022945404, -0.02130127, 0.035003662, 0.0014038086, -0.06732178, -0.0012331009, 0.077941895, 0.015670776, -0.034698486, 0.006462097, -0.0075149536, 0.01499176, 0.062347412, -0.076293945, -0.011436462, -0.027450562, -0.0037555695, -0.008087158, 0.026824951, 0.0046081543, 0.006389618, -0.038269043, -0.040496826, 0.016143799, 0.027038574, -0.057769775, 0.0036525726, -0.0056152344, -0.046722412, -0.037872314, -0.000330925, -0.00274086, -0.012176514, -0.0016880035, 0.044921875, -0.009521484, 0.0028743744, 0.0073127747, -0.015533447, 0.09484863, -0.0127334595, -0.08514404, 0.044281006, -0.017547607, 0.018112183, 0.03277588, -0.040527344, 0.007827759, 0.04220581, 0.024215698, 0.013809204, -0.020996094, 0.035095215, 0.0044784546, 0.03189087, -0.008491516, 0.0051841736, 0.027053833, 0.038330078, -0.02923584, 0.036895752, -0.0033740997, 0.01675415, 0.062927246, -0.024780273, -0.004058838, 0.04748535, -0.024765015, -0.011528015, 0.043884277, 0.036590576, 0.006298065, 0.010871887, -0.026657104, 0.042633057, 0.046539307, -0.0057754517, 0.0012025833, -0.00056886673, -0.037017822, 0.030731201, 0.06555176, -0.01676941, -0.011405945, 0.019683838, 0.07116699, 0.005252838, -0.03503418, -0.03302002, -0.013389587, -0.048706055, -0.0031337738, -0.00065231323, 0.004299164, -0.020690918, -0.017196655, 0.010498047, 0.003692627, -0.008674622, -0.026351929, -0.017684937, 0.05407715, 0.012039185, 0.05380249, -0.031463623, -0.017486572, 0.024749756, 0.007385254, 0.0038642883, -0.035369873, 0.008781433, -0.022232056, -0.027801514, -0.028259277, -0.062408447, -0.0713501, -0.006855011, 0.029067993, 0.037719727, 0.01612854, 0.02809143, -0.008926392, -0.028701782, 0.012214661, 0.036834717, 0.049468994, 0.020431519, 0.011268616, 0.0058631897, 0.032104492, 0.02217102, 0.0042381287, -0.035217285, -0.011634827, -0.040740967, -0.054656982, -0.018249512, 0.050476074, -0.004814148, 0.05899048, 0.05596924, 0.021072388, 0.011451721, 0.023757935, 0.013793945, 0.0102005005, -0.04272461, 0.024795532, -0.0020198822, 0.029907227, -0.0023441315, 0.046020508, -0.0033359528, -0.028961182, 0.010314941, 0.0075416565, 0.02670288, -0.007698059, -0.022277832, 0.033843994, 0.013496399, -0.011558533, 0.029373169, -0.0118255615, 0.034484863, 0.031677246, 0.010375977, -0.010192871, 0.03427124, 0.017028809, -0.0052490234, 0.0013494492, 0.010261536, -0.009605408, -0.03149414, -0.068237305, -0.027633667, 0.08355713, 0.005329132, -0.024841309, -0.026565552, 0.003955841, 0.038269043, 0.06542969, 0.04260254, -0.07183838, 0.058685303, 0.014915466, -0.0013360977, -0.002325058, -0.0077705383, 0.00920105, 0.019042969, -0.0008940697, -0.012367249, -0.03869629, 0.025390625, -0.019088745, -0.009651184, -0.041259766, 0.05834961, -0.042022705, -0.051208496, 0.03616333, -0.0496521, 0.019073486, 0.028900146, -0.02357483, -0.016525269, -0.015281677, -0.018676758, 0.009048462, -0.038238525, -0.06561279, 0.032562256, -0.037963867, 0.0069007874, 0.032684326, 0.024597168, 0.024856567, 0.053985596, -0.060455322, -0.00042200089, 0.005973816, 0.06112671, -0.040252686, -0.019943237, 0.02178955, -0.01713562, 0.004837036, -0.00793457, 0.032836914, -0.013710022, -0.019042969, 0.0046157837, -0.013183594, -0.0033836365, -0.018798828, -0.03137207, -0.0041389465, 0.037109375, -0.038238525, -0.011741638, 0.034362793, -0.014801025, 0.0064048767, -0.008491516, 0.016433716, -0.009117126, 0.004436493, -0.0011062622, 0.011634827, -0.0036525726, 0.009147644, -0.050598145, -0.0052375793, -0.04724121, -0.019699097, -0.030807495, 0.0028839111, 0.015045166, 0.048187256, 0.027313232, 0.036132812, 0.059020996, -0.042236328, 0.015609741, 0.0023899078, 0.01474762, 0.056518555, -0.012649536, -0.00016736984, -0.008766174, -0.008346558, -0.043182373, -0.0008125305, 0.028945923, -0.056488037, 0.017181396, 0.030975342, 0.0016946793, 0.021438599, 0.0016345978, -0.0068740845, 0.037017822, -0.023254395, 0.06616211, 0.048431396, 0.024291992, 0.026428223, 0.0033493042, 0.0395813, -0.008575439, -0.014778137, 0.007904053, -0.008224487, 0.041656494, -0.050323486, -0.04397583, 0.00856781, 0.028518677, -0.017440796, -0.046569824, 0.009963989, -0.014122009, 0.007972717, 0.041900635, 0.040374756, -0.023147583, 0.022537231, -0.008781433, -0.006916046, -0.0146865845, 0.014793396, -0.0037822723, -0.008872986, 0.04019165, 0.0021591187, 0.0048103333, -0.016815186, 0.026428223, -0.023071289, -0.009155273, -0.006137848, 0.018463135, 0.028305054, -0.0061569214, -0.034942627, 0.009475708, 0.00299263, 0.010986328, 0.0385437, 0.0042686462, 0.03225708, 0.030731201, 0.03314209, -0.0088272095, -0.012428284, 0.041625977, 0.01727295, 0.024917603, -0.0028533936, 0.07116699, -0.02607727, -0.0039138794, -0.038604736, -0.037872314, -0.036102295, 0.022109985, 0.008796692, -0.0050086975, 0.032958984, -0.005004883, 0.0137786865, 0.059906006, -0.076171875, 0.02720642, -0.019958496, -0.006706238, 0.011054993, -0.027755737, -0.029678345, 0.029190063, 0.038116455, -0.01902771, 0.023101807, 0.018127441, -0.03186035, -0.016479492, 0.038238525, 0.007675171, -0.06161499, -0.0015010834, -0.03604126, -0.00013911724, -0.0067977905, 0.04397583, 0.016479492, -0.04815674, 0.04598999, -0.025054932, -0.016082764, 0.0056495667, -0.032318115, -0.01197052, -0.0019874573, -0.003873825, -0.051879883, -0.05480957, 0.011665344, 0.011352539, -0.0019435883, 0.057739258, -0.025009155, -0.023422241, -0.01651001, 0.01826477, -0.0063056946, 0.0104904175, -0.05822754, -0.026641846, -0.05441284, -0.04977417, 0.010795593, -0.018203735, 0.027191162, 0.07006836, -0.014846802, 0.020187378, 0.017807007, -0.053771973, 0.015617371, 0.03149414, -0.04574585, 0.048980713, 0.04232788, -0.018478394, 0.039093018, 0.028411865, -0.015914917, 0.043029785, -0.040374756, 0.03756714, 0.09185791, 0.09436035, 0.036743164, 0.052703857, 0.0028743744, -0.017150879, 0.030731201, 0.0017328262, -0.0048294067, 0.011703491, -0.0340271, -0.0158844, 0.022979736, -0.018325806, 0.06793213, -0.029251099, 0.030258179, -0.024673462, -0.016616821, -0.03289795, -0.030258179, 0.045532227, -0.0340271, -0.039855957, 0.02166748, 0.024841309, -0.04852295, 0.033691406, -0.0077323914, -0.052124023, 0.029846191, 0.004447937, -0.011787415, -0.0076179504, 0.05050659, -0.0009236336, 0.0035686493, 0.06677246, -0.0067443848, -0.019058228, 0.02444458, 0.028839111, -0.017349243, -0.06359863, -0.01940918, 0.022491455, 0.019577026, -0.06335449, 0.039276123, 0.019500732, -0.018722534, -0.039794922, 0.03338623, -0.010879517, -0.008163452, 0.03756714, -0.013038635, -0.03186035, 0.012489319, 0.023712158, -0.03277588, 0.01259613, 0.015296936, -0.011817932, 0.078063965, -0.011222839, -0.04486084, -0.008888245, -0.019515991, -0.025100708, 0.040740967, -0.00605011, 0.0012111664, 0.015899658, 0.023635864, -0.017089844, -0.0076293945, 0.002462387, 0.0038108826, -0.024169922, -0.011131287, 0.017913818, -0.010757446, 0.06524658, -0.016555786, -0.01007843, -0.018463135, -0.012626648, 0.007633209, 0.024963379, 0.004463196, -0.017150879, -0.022506714, 0.005844116, -0.025268555, -0.01386261, 0.0284729, -0.03111267, -0.03274536, 0.0072517395, -0.04043579, -0.028869629, -0.013122559, 0.017227173, -0.0011358261, -0.0011234283, -0.0026454926, -0.0025920868, -0.022079468, -0.005607605, 0.015327454, -0.01776123, 0.018112183, 0.0014009476, -0.0132751465, 0.028900146, 0.0021133423, 0.015777588, 0.008384705, 0.036712646, -0.0064048767, -0.023971558, -0.024765015, 0.057739258, -0.022827148, -0.042419434, -0.01626587, -0.009895325, 0.019851685, -0.036346436, 0.036193848, 0.004524231, -0.011558533, 0.020996094, 0.019760132, 0.014533997, 0.008140564, -0.0035991669, -0.0033035278, 0.007926941, 0.054992676, -0.014717102, 0.013214111 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1811.09782v1
Alternating Loss Correction for Preterm-Birth Prediction from EHR Data with Noisy Labels
Sabri Boughorbel, Fethi Jarray, Neethu Venugopal, Haithum Elhadi
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG
In this paper we are interested in the prediction of preterm birth based on diagnosis codes from longitudinal EHR. We formulate the prediction problem as a supervised classification with noisy labels. Our base classifier is a Recurrent Neural Network with an attention mechanism. We assume the availability of a data subset with both noisy and clean labels. For the cohort definition, most of the diagnosis codes on mothers' records related to pregnancy are ambiguous for the definition of full-term and preterm classes. On the other hand, diagnosis codes on babies' records provide fine-grained information on prematurity. Due to data de-identification, the links between mothers and babies are not available. We developed a heuristic based on admission and discharge times to match babies to their mothers and hence enrich mothers' records with additional information on delivery status. The obtained additional dataset from the matching heuristic has noisy labels and was used to leverage the training of the deep learning model. We propose an Alternating Loss Correction (ALC) method to train deep models with both clean and noisy labels. First, the label corruption matrix is estimated using the data subset with both noisy and clean labels. Then it is used in the model as a dense output layer to correct for the label noise. The network is alternately trained on epochs with the clean dataset with a simple cross-entropy loss and on next epoch with the noisy dataset and a loss corrected with the estimated corruption matrix. The experiments for the prediction of preterm birth at 90 days before delivery showed an improvement in performance compared with baseline and state of-the-art methods.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1811.09782v1
2018-11-24T07:47:01
2018-11-24T07:47:01
{ "title": [ -0.03213501, 0.0072288513, -0.030410767, -0.02859497, 0.0042762756, 0.009262085, -0.017059326, -0.014289856, -0.0078086853, 0.043884277, -0.0079574585, 0.008224487, 0.022705078, -0.041992188, -0.033172607, 0.000029861927, 0.038116455, 0.0063171387, 0.017929077, -0.008659363, 0.0019836426, -0.0051727295, 0.04840088, 0.0680542, -0.0011510849, 0.032165527, -0.055603027, 0.0049324036, -0.010894775, -0.008377075, -0.010955811, -0.009895325, 0.041625977, -0.0041999817, -0.015586853, 0.024520874, -0.04714966, 0.029266357, -0.0033245087, 0.009284973, -0.005203247, 0.0046043396, 0.049316406, -0.034973145, 0.0022907257, 0.049926758, -0.064575195, -0.03741455, -0.040985107, -0.0053863525, 0.01210022, 0.013427734, 0.02947998, 0.03604126, 0.009613037, -0.008651733, 0.011749268, -0.00969696, 0.053497314, -0.014419556, -0.028259277, -0.038146973, 0.041107178, -0.0039024353, -0.0030784607, -0.023773193, -0.01689148, 0.016479492, 0.068237305, 0.028640747, -0.0035171509, 0.029800415, 0.021026611, 0.00724411, -0.054107666, 0.004535675, 0.066345215, 0.048950195, 0.017654419, -0.04107666, 0.032409668, 0.016098022, 0.06890869, -0.01108551, 0.031204224, -0.010040283, -0.0066337585, -0.011398315, -0.040100098, -0.039794922, -0.015075684, -0.019104004, -0.054016113, 0.019363403, 0.013847351, -0.038238525, 0.008926392, 0.041534424, 0.010055542, -0.03363037, -0.039001465, 0.029678345, -0.1105957, 0.0056495667, 0.020690918, -0.008613586, -0.034973145, -0.029708862, 0.05819702, 0.04385376, -0.015403748, 0.06222534, -0.019104004, -0.045959473, 0.006336212, 0.07006836, 0.004550934, -0.015266418, 0.017349243, -0.000099003315, -0.04953003, -0.051757812, 0.0046424866, 0.011428833, 0.03778076, -0.020385742, -0.017456055, 0.04812622, -0.105041504, 0.0625, 0.039245605, 0.019699097, -0.0692749, -0.04348755, -0.06213379, 0.015403748, 0.016555786, 0.010101318, -0.02067566, 0.0073051453, 0.031173706, -0.038116455, -0.020935059, 0.018600464, 0.009719849, 0.01725769, 0.025421143, -0.0054740906, -0.015464783, -0.030349731, -0.03164673, 0.013687134, 0.020355225, -0.0024108887, -0.08691406, -0.024551392, -0.09515381, -0.009597778, 0.007572174, -0.025344849, 0.026321411, -0.014045715, -0.016098022, 0.003080368, 0.0024490356, 0.01158905, -0.043762207, 0.021209717, 0.027175903, 0.002910614, 0.0032482147, -0.0026683807, 0.032318115, -0.012794495, 0.0024757385, 0.009498596, 0.01586914, -0.018478394, 0.01940918, -0.012535095, -0.002664566, -0.025299072, -0.043304443, 0.03778076, -0.072509766, 0.006187439, -0.0021858215, 0.0059280396, 0.032226562, -0.019241333, 0.010757446, 0.043945312, -0.021316528, -0.03753662, -0.027648926, 0.004875183, -0.009437561, 0.01727295, -0.024917603, 0.013961792, -0.03994751, 0.023712158, -0.03778076, 0.015350342, -0.033050537, -0.027420044, -0.007511139, 0.012451172, -0.05230713, 0.048553467, 0.043884277, -0.0075950623, -0.050872803, 0.041534424, 0.04522705, -0.05895996, 0.029907227, 0.005378723, -0.038970947, -0.03942871, -0.06744385, -0.0054512024, -0.042388916, 0.047851562, 0.020950317, -0.022598267, 0.017547607, -0.031707764, 0.035461426, -0.021621704, 0.06439209, -0.0018796921, -0.018432617, -0.049865723, -0.04257202, -0.01876831, -0.03314209, -0.005001068, 0.011924744, 0.040618896, -0.013824463, -0.018966675, -0.0061683655, 0.057739258, 0.029968262, 0.0054969788, 0.008934021, 0.03439331, -0.009628296, 0.012481689, 0.0793457, 0.015327454, 0.011810303, 0.034301758, -0.009498596, 0.04547119, -0.05999756, -0.014297485, -0.014633179, -0.028167725, 0.026321411, -0.009490967, 0.013206482, -0.014076233, -0.053344727, -0.018173218, -0.030303955, -0.005104065, 0.009674072, -0.0058021545, 0.01309967, -0.028274536, 0.013969421, -0.023529053, -0.048187256, 0.006401062, -0.006000519, 0.025405884, 0.008804321, -0.04257202, -0.0045433044, 0.03189087, 0.048828125, -0.017318726, -0.011833191, -0.027740479, 0.02204895, -0.0132369995, -0.036987305, -0.041046143, -0.0010051727, 0.037017822, 0.0042915344, -0.03314209, 0.038604736, -0.010902405, 0.018585205, 0.030334473, 0.0041046143, 0.008483887, -0.033203125, 0.027709961, 0.017684937, 0.0022468567, -0.016494751, 0.019439697, -0.034820557, 0.036132812, -0.022781372, -0.023788452, 0.0024776459, 0.046722412, 0.012870789, 0.023376465, -0.061584473, -0.047454834, -0.021118164, -0.00070858, -0.02067566, 0.012107849, -0.017730713, 0.033996582, -0.009712219, 0.015853882, 0.0435791, 0.009529114, -0.025924683, -0.00001180172, 0.0021629333, 0.015472412, 0.00018191338, 0.0045394897, -0.07647705, -0.021026611, -0.0013046265, 0.01309967, -0.011619568, 0.07922363, -0.016555786, -0.038482666, -0.032348633, 0.0060691833, 0.00060272217, -0.010925293, -0.0024909973, -0.08081055, 0.003686905, -0.008377075, -0.064697266, -0.0051879883, 0.060760498, -0.012794495, -0.049194336, 0.026351929, 0.027862549, -0.0026054382, 0.039123535, 0.010765076, -0.018249512, -0.010009766, 0.047454834, 0.010810852, 0.016937256, -0.017959595, -0.03265381, -0.06939697, -0.0058898926, -0.010368347, -0.018249512, 0.037200928, -0.048583984, -0.0050811768, -0.01977539, -0.01687622, -0.0061798096, 0.034301758, 0.0034389496, -0.021347046, 0.0005712509, 0.011138916, 0.012367249, 0.009841919, 0.002401352, 0.04095459, 0.043273926, 0.02130127, -0.019561768, -0.04675293, 0.014503479, 0.015579224, -0.007896423, -0.028457642, -0.023849487, -0.03036499, -0.0054244995, 0.0037975311, 0.010734558, 0.007789612, -0.017959595, -0.002811432, 0.06072998, -0.025405884, -0.041107178, 0.037994385, -0.04901123, 0.01637268, 0.026184082, 0.00051403046, 0.02720642, 0.03265381, -0.009231567, 0.027496338, -0.0009636879, 0.008224487, -0.009689331, -0.01171875, -0.08050537, 0.03274536, -0.023727417, -0.038513184, -0.0042533875, 0.0023231506, -0.043884277, 0.00057935715, -0.00044202805, 0.06036377, 0.038269043, 0.00031018257, 0.0390625, -0.019165039, 0.020141602, -0.038635254, 0.00040006638, -0.043182373, -0.010879517, -0.011505127, -0.01864624, 0.052856445, -0.0209198, 0.0028533936, -0.020431519, -0.019378662, 0.0033779144, 0.042388916, -0.03213501, -0.025482178, -0.027999878, 0.0090789795, -0.007797241, 0.020523071, -0.03942871, -0.01109314, -0.037078857, 0.015960693, -0.019439697, 0.07574463, 0.010284424, 0.020568848, -0.02835083, 0.019485474, 0.0077781677, -0.042053223, 0.034606934, 0.009017944, 0.012557983, 0.017242432, 0.009559631, 0.00042319298, 0.0059013367, -0.011795044, -0.012237549, 0.036956787, -0.014320374, -0.021728516, 0.022583008, -0.031555176, -0.010261536, 0.037353516, -0.023880005, -0.030807495, 0.011932373, 0.022628784, 0.0050849915, -0.099487305, -0.042755127, 0.013572693, -0.13720703, -0.07305908, 0.026687622, -0.06707764, -0.05102539, -0.061523438, -0.0035858154, -0.015304565, -0.02520752, 0.017868042, 0.006515503, 0.0059051514, 0.0058784485, -0.053497314, -0.017150879, 0.045654297, -0.0074386597, 0.025527954, -0.0045394897, 0.006061554, 0.055267334, -0.03189087, 0.0018482208, -0.026550293, 0.07946777, -0.01939392, -0.024093628, 0.055267334, -0.022644043, 0.004573822, 0.015457153, 0.06994629, -0.029067993, -0.018630981, 0.0078125, -0.013122559, -0.007858276, 0.058624268, 0.019500732, -0.038879395, -0.023925781, -0.026184082, -0.025161743, -0.024383545, 0.007411957, 0.0054740906, 0.006340027, 0.015640259, 0.030700684, 0.038909912, 0.00687027, -0.0041656494, -0.018585205, -0.056915283, 0.015777588, 0.035705566, 0.0011844635, -0.024108887, 0.012573242, 0.027893066, 0.019241333, 0.04626465, -0.045288086, 0.011260986, 0.0028438568, 0.018432617, -0.0110321045, -0.03225708, -0.057891846, -0.019485474, -0.020355225, 0.020477295, 0.007286072, 0.009788513, -0.01625061, 0.0118637085, -0.048217773, 0.038360596, -0.014038086, 0.001367569, 0.020080566, -0.012893677, -0.0021018982, 0.013137817, -0.05053711, -0.025558472, -0.05203247, 0.00008106232, 0.036254883, 0.0044136047, 0.009605408, 0.0057868958, 0.034576416, -0.0024223328, 0.036590576, -0.014968872, -0.013549805, -0.020111084, 0.0065231323, -0.047180176, 0.03286743, -0.000104248524, -0.002878189, -0.017868042, 0.008956909, -0.040039062, -0.00982666, -0.014801025, 0.027053833, -0.025817871, 0.06530762, -0.0015535355, 0.0090789795, 0.022125244, 0.017456055, 0.022079468, 0.027542114, -0.028396606, -0.055847168, 0.008399963, -0.00497818, 0.016525269, 0.008049011, 0.010894775, 0.016830444, -0.031585693, 0.006828308, 0.029052734, 0.00182724, 0.020736694, -0.0074806213, 0.014122009, -0.017440796, -0.0054016113, 0.0184021, -0.018859863, 0.038635254, -0.011062622, 0.005077362, -0.058776855, 0.029785156, 0.029830933, 0.0069236755, 0.016235352, 0.02508545, 0.011947632, -0.060455322, -0.029571533, 0.02722168, 0.04296875, -0.039489746, 0.0013866425, -0.012390137, 0.018661499, 0.056640625, 0.017654419, 0.016296387, 0.015602112, -0.05859375, 0.020553589, 0.025665283, -0.027145386, -0.03060913, -0.00032186508, 0.007221222, -0.0030918121, -0.010803223, -0.041046143, -0.042022705, -0.02848816, -0.036010742, -0.022842407, 0.041503906, -0.060150146, -0.036254883, 0.01361084, 0.018249512, 0.0057678223, -0.034729004, 0.0027256012, 0.030288696, 0.024505615, 0.0024547577, -0.0050354004, 0.019042969, -0.056274414, 0.010673523, 0.03149414, 0.025817871, -0.010627747, 0.0064926147, -0.010848999, -0.034057617, -0.004425049, 0.01473999, 0.024505615, -0.008491516, 0.006011963, -0.03967285, 0.029205322, 0.02128601, -0.0102005005, 0.03262329, -0.029846191, -0.007396698, 0.017944336, -0.02104187, -0.02758789, 0.031311035, -0.009963989, -0.06365967, -0.0077705383, -0.0010871887, 0.020996094, -0.015640259, 0.006336212, 0.028762817, -0.021194458, -0.0061416626, 0.05529785, -0.05935669, 0.017578125, -0.042877197, 0.0063209534, 0.009155273, 0.020645142, -0.074279785, -0.02027893, -0.0075912476, -0.040283203, -0.040222168, 0.03125, 0.028793335, -0.0025424957, 0.038970947, -0.038360596, 0.013313293, 0.027359009, 0.03652954, -0.030685425, 0.03842163, 0.054626465, 0.016052246, 0.015213013, 0.029006958, 0.027252197, 0.020385742, 0.010940552, -0.0010309219, -0.056274414, 0.02293396, 0.04046631, 0.061401367, -0.04034424, -0.045288086, -0.02381897, 0.0435791, 0.001704216, -0.0032043457, 0.037994385, 0.043518066, 0.00006181002, 0.020050049, 0.01083374, 0.06488037, -0.020599365, -0.05657959, -0.01939392, 0.02607727, -0.009025574, 0.057434082, -0.025894165, -0.051086426, -0.010910034, -0.030471802, -0.03552246, -0.0011329651, 0.019821167, 0.00068092346, 0.00844574, -0.026000977, 0.011001587, -0.037017822, -0.008705139, -0.04083252, 0.01499939, -0.005443573, 0.002319336, 0.0004708767, -0.014785767, 0.013442993, -0.05166626, -0.010597229, 0.022994995, 0.039154053, -0.013641357, -0.030471802, -0.020950317, -0.035858154, -0.019348145, 0.008239746, 0.032684326, -0.024856567, 0.046447754, -0.013572693, 0.03933716, 0.00056505203, 0.04458618, 0.014564514, 0.014289856, 0.00447464, -0.014167786, -0.0043563843, -0.032073975, -0.00869751, -0.028015137, 0.0027275085, -0.010406494, 0.004386902, -0.08276367, 0.015281677, 0.032989502, 0.049987793, -0.009155273, 0.015159607, 0.022598267, 0.029968262, 0.04537964, -0.020751953, 0.06781006, 0.037994385, -0.0070152283, -0.012069702, 0.03866577, 0.012298584, 0.018753052, 0.003129959, 0.03591919, 0.00096559525, -0.035949707, 0.027999878, 0.0012989044, 0.0032157898, -0.005760193, -0.005428314, -0.042388916, 0.077697754, 0.014671326, 0.023422241, 0.04724121, 0.021057129, 0.0053253174, -0.04067993, 0.0051498413, -0.011558533, -0.013786316, -0.011245728, 0.038085938, -0.040985107, 0.028152466, -0.026031494, -0.020004272, 0.011558533, 0.04449463, 0.024536133, -0.05999756, -0.004234314, 0.01449585, 0.008323669, 0.005050659, 0.03967285, -0.029037476, -0.041534424, -0.00434494, 0.019256592, -0.013458252, 0.028823853, 0.019302368, 0.007686615, -0.0022449493, 0.0018672943, 0.028793335, 0.0067443848, 0.023498535, 0.031677246, -0.05508423, 0.0072250366, -0.008903503, -0.031433105, 0.010894775, 0.0006299019, -0.008163452, -0.0005917549, 0.037902832, 0.055236816, -0.005531311, 0.036224365, -0.0064353943, -0.023239136, 0.007911682, -0.010574341, -0.00762558, 0.030654907, -0.024398804, 0.0069007874, -0.0023269653, -0.03466797, 0.04925537, -0.04940796, 0.038330078, -0.05722046, -0.0060653687, -0.059509277, 0.06088257, -0.014846802, -0.028167725, -0.02027893, -0.036712646, -0.0546875, -0.009315491, -0.01525116, -0.0013580322, -0.055999756, -0.051849365, 0.05166626, -0.030548096, -0.015129089, 0.0077667236, -0.01776123, -0.023986816, -0.012878418, -0.022735596, 0.026733398, -0.028015137, 0.0048446655, -0.0345459, 0.0047721863, 0.009223938, -0.017303467, 0.005138397, -0.050994873, -0.04840088, -0.075927734, 0.016036987, 0.029327393, -0.03125, -0.058013916, 0.04977417, -0.027389526, -0.020339966, -0.00018203259, 0.023712158, -0.033966064, -0.04534912, -0.0071525574, -0.050445557, 0.0357666, 0.022445679, 0.005138397, -0.023010254, 0.024002075, -0.0053863525, -0.058563232, 0.0050811768, 0.009651184, -0.008552551, -0.056732178, 0.013999939, 0.029037476, 0.07281494, 0.018127441, -0.030258179, 0.049224854, -0.031585693, -0.017730713, 0.0463562, 0.008094788, -0.0069618225, 0.029342651, 0.021102905, 0.018844604, -0.022460938, -0.058685303, -0.04373169, 0.0059051514, 0.0287323, -0.008003235, -0.02583313, 0.051208496, -0.016815186, -0.02709961, -0.008705139, 0.013145447, -0.011047363, 0.010009766, 0.035736084, -0.017044067, -0.051757812, -0.026138306, 0.013763428, 0.012832642, 0.017700195, -0.0015850067, 0.013465881, -0.007537842, 0.05090332, -0.031829834, -0.002922058, 0.03149414, -0.016021729, 0.045959473, 0.009269714, 0.056884766, 0.02368164, 0.002981186, -0.03479004, -0.019500732, -0.031402588, 0.090270996, -0.08642578, -0.0287323, -0.0418396, -0.019927979, 0.00983429, -0.014099121, 0.03869629, -0.04043579, 0.008003235, -0.043395996, -0.02041626, -0.01058197, 0.028671265, -0.00699234, -0.032043457, -0.058807373, -0.103393555, 0.03604126, -0.024139404 ], "summary": [ -0.017471313, 0.007873535, -0.034118652, -0.025360107, -0.010215759, -0.0073394775, -0.03753662, -0.015777588, -0.019882202, 0.014038086, -0.0047912598, 0.01222229, -0.015426636, -0.04788208, 0.031829834, -0.035095215, 0.030853271, 0.016357422, 0.047912598, -0.0019044876, 0.008773804, 0.0029563904, 0.046844482, 0.059753418, 0.00025582314, 0.04333496, -0.009544373, 0.015022278, 0.007434845, 0.03692627, 0.013114929, -0.06329346, 0.027755737, -0.011474609, -0.0076065063, 0.014282227, -0.019256592, 0.011375427, -0.0057411194, 0.018371582, -0.00047016144, 0.011444092, 0.09753418, -0.05343628, 0.015136719, 0.061584473, -0.023498535, -0.0385437, -0.002521515, -0.025405884, 0.019165039, 0.0060043335, 0.025512695, -0.013893127, -0.00894928, 0.005191803, -0.03277588, -0.004787445, 0.03125, 0.026733398, -0.0013971329, -0.041107178, 0.01524353, -0.016143799, -0.03366089, -0.017074585, -0.008384705, -0.009552002, 0.06311035, -0.003736496, 0.017044067, 0.043640137, 0.007724762, -0.0009908676, -0.052825928, 0.027938843, 0.056854248, 0.04724121, -0.0027923584, -0.022567749, 0.057617188, 0.03729248, 0.057861328, -0.036132812, 0.03062439, -0.030014038, 0.0077400208, -0.029434204, -0.027114868, -0.017913818, -0.017593384, -0.026000977, -0.06008911, 0.042236328, 0.024459839, -0.026397705, 0.0007176399, 0.032714844, -0.01586914, -0.009529114, -0.02494812, 0.009246826, -0.050994873, -0.008644104, 0.0007185936, -0.026062012, -0.03137207, -0.050842285, 0.020858765, 0.03894043, -0.034729004, 0.018844604, -0.033477783, -0.08117676, 0.0031490326, 0.09625244, 0.0074920654, -0.014839172, 0.02772522, -0.013572693, -0.041748047, 0.0034637451, -0.018203735, 0.011833191, 0.008735657, -0.014274597, 0.0041885376, 0.02255249, -0.06738281, 0.039215088, 0.015289307, 0.02218628, -0.019927979, 0.010635376, -0.038879395, -0.006629944, 0.02078247, -0.00063943863, 0.014625549, -0.004398346, 0.03463745, -0.035064697, -0.047912598, 0.04458618, -0.03262329, 0.024597168, 0.011650085, -0.0037670135, -0.019622803, -0.064575195, -0.0037517548, -0.025482178, 0.057861328, -0.0054130554, -0.07702637, -0.039398193, -0.024978638, -0.015090942, -0.027893066, -0.0635376, 0.014175415, -0.015419006, 0.011978149, -0.010345459, -0.03768921, 0.015975952, -0.06210327, -0.0012645721, 0.013847351, -0.031829834, 0.043395996, -0.016296387, 0.01902771, 0.014823914, 0.030700684, 0.018188477, -0.005897522, -0.0015077591, 0.01890564, -0.0236969, -0.008026123, -0.04269409, -0.024749756, 0.03378296, -0.023803711, 0.0073776245, 0.011352539, 0.020690918, -0.00032949448, 0.008674622, 0.018234253, 0.026153564, -0.014556885, -0.006549835, -0.023895264, 0.0075302124, -0.011260986, 0.021774292, -0.035369873, -0.005367279, 0.009994507, 0.0032157898, -0.0042304993, -0.0031204224, -0.07147217, 0.006259918, -0.02003479, 0.030212402, -0.047424316, 0.013191223, 0.02468872, -0.014984131, -0.025253296, -0.006603241, 0.03012085, -0.034057617, 0.01953125, 0.01008606, -0.01777649, -0.012191772, -0.047058105, -0.0006656647, -0.050323486, 0.048187256, 0.017349243, 0.028457642, -0.003200531, 0.018157959, 0.058502197, 0.007865906, 0.047851562, -0.02684021, 0.010360718, -0.055236816, -0.056488037, 0.007335663, -0.015716553, -0.037017822, 0.000035345554, 0.058410645, 0.021835327, -0.015625, -0.019134521, 0.037139893, 0.020614624, 0.0031700134, 0.009597778, 0.017456055, -0.027938843, 0.021469116, 0.011421204, 0.033691406, 0.011016846, 0.0146484375, -0.0035247803, 0.02709961, -0.038360596, -0.01637268, 0.022247314, -0.022872925, 0.008666992, -0.02848816, 0.007335663, -0.019851685, -0.0035896301, -0.05126953, -0.029708862, -0.020935059, -0.012023926, -0.024978638, 0.027023315, -0.020706177, -0.0035037994, -0.034332275, -0.059265137, -0.0076065063, -0.029418945, 0.04144287, 0.009490967, -0.029891968, 0.013824463, 0.049224854, 0.002588272, -0.0158844, -0.006164551, -0.018692017, -0.019439697, 0.02166748, -0.03540039, 0.005630493, -0.00037002563, 0.049102783, 0.014022827, -0.03277588, 0.060546875, 0.0138168335, -0.044830322, 0.001660347, 0.024642944, -0.028045654, -0.018356323, 0.046203613, 0.019332886, -0.016662598, -0.019180298, 0.009689331, -0.024932861, 0.020584106, -0.007255554, -0.05303955, 0.026321411, 0.056915283, 0.0184021, 0.115234375, -0.0592041, -0.0491333, -0.00076675415, 0.052581787, 0.051208496, 0.026031494, -0.0060768127, 0.054840088, 0.03289795, 0.010612488, 0.05593872, -0.026824951, -0.00819397, -0.00084495544, -0.014205933, 0.003993988, 0.005382538, -0.014968872, -0.02760315, 0.012016296, 0.0055389404, 0.0036640167, 0.0040893555, 0.09814453, 0.0069618225, -0.06286621, -0.02218628, 0.033691406, -0.029312134, 0.020095825, 0.00356102, -0.058258057, 0.0146484375, -0.00067424774, -0.062927246, -0.0054855347, 0.044555664, -0.02458191, -0.043670654, 0.052642822, -0.024780273, 0.04660034, 0.07824707, 0.019332886, -0.008636475, -0.001742363, 0.012123108, 0.031829834, 0.009857178, -0.0154418945, -0.054138184, -0.02482605, 0.032226562, -0.004058838, -0.01953125, 0.024368286, -0.04449463, 0.011238098, -0.016296387, -0.00032663345, -0.015197754, 0.038146973, 0.07965088, 0.011444092, -0.00036168098, 0.052246094, 0.033935547, 0.013702393, 0.0019416809, -0.034179688, 0.0060577393, 0.042114258, -0.0259552, -0.03579712, -0.005706787, 0.005432129, -0.0071144104, 0.012001038, -0.015670776, -0.021987915, 0.018600464, 0.008308411, 0.006362915, -0.002401352, -0.01361084, -0.03616333, 0.058441162, 0.0044136047, -0.0034275055, 0.037506104, -0.02357483, 0.03527832, 0.0345459, 0.0032043457, 0.023269653, 0.019042969, -0.006958008, 0.0055618286, -0.0026340485, -0.018478394, -0.0058898926, -0.010025024, -0.009986877, 0.00944519, -0.007663727, -0.0020885468, 0.010047913, 0.006832123, -0.027938843, -0.0016145706, 0.022979736, 0.048309326, -0.039794922, -0.01828003, 0.015144348, -0.010322571, -0.021148682, -0.010650635, -0.0028209686, -0.014694214, -0.014228821, 0.020690918, -0.018447876, 0.005748749, -0.009559631, -0.04385376, 0.013534546, -0.016311646, 0.0015144348, 0.010231018, -0.013801575, 0.008163452, -0.001244545, 0.03237915, -0.022918701, 0.023956299, -0.04510498, -0.015716553, -0.013175964, 0.041259766, -0.014099121, 0.08905029, 0.031463623, 0.019866943, 0.024856567, 0.0070533752, 0.007888794, -0.02281189, 0.011604309, 0.002254486, 0.038635254, 0.02029419, -0.03656006, 0.016433716, -0.009475708, 0.004962921, 0.018676758, -0.006198883, -0.0134887695, -0.02798462, 0.0069465637, -0.06072998, 0.040924072, 0.018325806, 0.032836914, -0.039611816, -0.020233154, 0.03552246, -0.05984497, -0.08251953, -0.05090332, 0.012763977, -0.11035156, -0.08746338, 0.027496338, -0.01876831, -0.024719238, -0.05316162, 0.03062439, -0.016784668, -0.006538391, 0.034576416, -0.013267517, 0.059448242, 0.00077676773, -0.040039062, 0.0018529892, -0.041625977, -0.000067830086, 0.0035305023, -0.057891846, 0.066589355, 0.09716797, 0.0012569427, -0.020263672, -0.079711914, 0.075927734, -0.064575195, 0.0033493042, 0.04824829, -0.02558899, -0.00093889236, 0.013702393, 0.06347656, -0.046447754, -0.021148682, 0.03881836, 0.04446411, 0.01386261, 0.030075073, -0.013587952, -0.014831543, 0.0043411255, -0.028549194, -0.003490448, -0.021621704, 0.021911621, 0.023406982, -0.028808594, -0.0022716522, 0.033935547, -0.0066452026, -0.012069702, -0.040618896, -0.0049705505, 0.008804321, 0.013969421, 0.0016641617, -0.019546509, 0.014213562, 0.0044441223, 0.04751587, 0.033203125, 0.056732178, -0.06506348, 0.021530151, -0.013366699, 0.007068634, -0.012435913, -0.061279297, -0.047973633, 0.04849243, 0.035003662, -0.015434265, -0.00093603134, -0.0040397644, -0.019592285, 0.00920105, -0.011695862, -0.014923096, -0.008628845, 0.023147583, -0.004486084, -0.0234375, -0.022277832, 0.0048713684, -0.044891357, -0.026107788, -0.06970215, -0.035095215, -0.0050735474, 0.008346558, -0.0087509155, 0.010429382, -0.004863739, -0.021270752, 0.0012350082, -0.014190674, -0.00868988, -0.053894043, -0.006549835, -0.025558472, 0.00009185076, -0.01600647, -0.015792847, -0.003522873, 0.025894165, -0.032958984, -0.013832092, -0.026153564, 0.012687683, 0.0007596016, 0.034210205, -0.013656616, -0.015510559, 0.011871338, 0.021743774, 0.04309082, 0.022338867, 0.0023002625, -0.0892334, 0.032592773, 0.006801605, 0.03189087, 0.0042266846, 0.013557434, 0.0030937195, -0.04675293, 0.0001693964, 0.042877197, -0.011177063, -0.0031318665, -0.0051574707, 0.00043821335, 0.03677368, -0.013999939, 0.037506104, 0.0025100708, 0.01121521, 0.032592773, 0.00116539, -0.030075073, 0.039093018, 0.048980713, 0.011886597, -0.016326904, 0.03945923, -0.006000519, -0.049865723, -0.052734375, -0.008743286, 0.0657959, -0.01234436, -0.022506714, 0.005077362, 0.012329102, 0.06237793, 0.0018320084, 0.011955261, 0.0017518997, -0.06262207, 0.026550293, 0.025802612, -0.0116119385, -0.016204834, -0.0054244995, -0.018112183, -0.006717682, 0.018554688, -0.050231934, -0.012390137, -0.004940033, -0.010826111, 0.002210617, 0.028900146, -0.04449463, -0.06573486, -0.0060424805, -0.027832031, -0.016494751, -0.01687622, -0.0016260147, -0.048065186, 0.01033783, -0.04788208, 0.019836426, -0.008918762, -0.06222534, 0.008728027, 0.020385742, 0.03918457, -0.0023918152, -0.02003479, 0.008384705, -0.04925537, 0.0022144318, 0.0054512024, -0.036590576, -0.003616333, -0.0357666, 0.0017461777, 0.020980835, -0.0082092285, 0.014312744, 0.0052719116, -0.0036964417, 0.017700195, 0.0524292, -0.013626099, 0.022537231, 0.025436401, -0.02418518, -0.05050659, 0.03010559, 0.008880615, 0.018325806, -0.0099105835, 0.014556885, 0.010429382, -0.013931274, -0.057922363, 0.04248047, -0.0067253113, 0.024047852, -0.036865234, 0.008560181, -0.0061454773, -0.029190063, -0.036346436, -0.0014772415, 0.0015058517, -0.007320404, -0.003692627, 0.038970947, 0.015792847, -0.005836487, 0.018173218, -0.028198242, 0.017959595, 0.002193451, 0.021957397, -0.057006836, 0.0236969, 0.014251709, -0.0013408661, -0.011199951, 0.033599854, 0.0146865845, -0.040283203, 0.0121154785, 0.02885437, -0.054534912, 0.044189453, 0.031799316, 0.07879639, -0.045806885, -0.04119873, -0.004016876, 0.05105591, 0.00566864, 0.04714966, 0.035369873, 0.048736572, -0.060028076, 0.042510986, 0.04486084, 0.042114258, -0.03817749, -0.059936523, -0.017654419, 0.051513672, -0.009063721, -0.04888916, -0.0039138794, -0.034362793, 0.030029297, -0.020004272, 0.0044898987, -0.0053138733, 0.00687027, -0.025131226, 0.012710571, -0.03100586, -0.009002686, -0.016143799, 0.0054092407, -0.019210815, -0.0065612793, -0.010391235, 0.0036735535, 0.032684326, 0.011680603, 0.016281128, -0.040008545, 0.006198883, 0.010574341, -0.0073928833, 0.0059013367, -0.015571594, -0.0017118454, -0.023452759, -0.024215698, 0.035217285, -0.0012893677, 0.023635864, 0.06121826, -0.0021629333, 0.015075684, -0.022994995, 0.015068054, -0.022521973, -0.019592285, 0.025497437, -0.004348755, -0.019821167, -0.029342651, 0.02583313, -0.0020580292, -0.041046143, -0.04147339, -0.043029785, -0.00075674057, 0.007835388, -0.0028266907, 0.016693115, 0.04827881, 0.001405716, 0.030715942, 0.022445679, -0.0025978088, 0.011947632, 0.031677246, 0.0715332, -0.00025892258, -0.0018463135, 0.021072388, -0.024490356, 0.014785767, 0.029037476, 0.021133423, 0.05630493, 0.005340576, 0.038360596, -0.025558472, -0.022766113, -0.05038452, 0.040161133, -0.03262329, 0.03665161, 0.018005371, 0.031341553, 0.046295166, 0.015388489, -0.0038795471, -0.01411438, 0.022201538, -0.04537964, -0.00390625, -0.03149414, -0.024932861, -0.011657715, 0.0066566467, -0.0036029816, 0.003824234, -0.009063721, 0.0317688, 0.03265381, -0.029586792, 0.035705566, -0.020355225, -0.00053167343, -0.026473999, -0.0021533966, -0.037200928, -0.0052604675, 0.024520874, -0.009109497, -0.00217247, -0.02885437, 0.0234375, -0.029571533, 0.018936157, -0.007610321, 0.038726807, 0.03189087, 0.059173584, 0.025726318, -0.057891846, 0.0021820068, 0.008407593, -0.017349243, 0.011024475, 0.019714355, 0.0061836243, 0.02204895, 0.005760193, 0.059020996, 0.008773804, 0.025772095, -0.051940918, -0.013366699, 0.04916382, 0.008384705, -0.0138168335, 0.016845703, -0.0127334595, -0.053985596, 0.008460999, 0.0046577454, 0.008552551, -0.013092041, 0.03741455, -0.061035156, 0.0066184998, -0.053833008, 0.040649414, -0.062438965, -0.014175415, 0.015655518, -0.046447754, -0.024291992, -0.026931763, -0.02494812, 0.0015974045, -0.012580872, -0.05682373, 0.02368164, -0.0049858093, -0.008399963, 0.0050964355, -0.010101318, 0.026184082, -0.01725769, 0.005809784, 0.026916504, 0.015655518, -0.009063721, -0.0000045895576, 0.010421753, 0.0030956268, -0.039031982, -0.0006136894, -0.02633667, -0.011627197, -0.07397461, 0.023330688, 0.023864746, -0.04135132, -0.0847168, 0.041503906, -0.027648926, -0.020065308, 0.016082764, 0.05340576, 0.010017395, -0.01574707, 0.0033874512, -0.029830933, 0.013458252, -0.03842163, 0.007335663, -0.03765869, 0.052886963, -0.01876831, -0.02709961, 0.00016212463, 0.007820129, -0.019470215, -0.064453125, 0.021392822, 0.019699097, 0.058532715, 0.04257202, 0.008277893, 0.05834961, -0.04446411, 0.007785797, -0.006175995, -0.051605225, -0.036621094, 0.04647827, 0.038879395, 0.019561768, 0.0037117004, -0.07446289, -0.05432129, 0.036499023, -0.005847931, -0.027023315, -0.02067566, 0.04537964, -0.031829834, -0.021759033, -0.016983032, 0.04699707, -0.008224487, -0.000975132, 0.010520935, -0.059539795, -0.036895752, -0.025787354, -0.0129470825, 0.009513855, 0.000500679, -0.013458252, 0.013946533, -0.033599854, 0.028671265, -0.011756897, 0.06060791, -0.006626129, -0.051605225, 0.063964844, -0.04434204, 0.06286621, 0.045928955, 0.02758789, -0.05053711, -0.022109985, -0.04901123, 0.08081055, -0.101745605, -0.07281494, -0.015449524, 0.014060974, -0.012001038, -0.010574341, 0.034057617, -0.03253174, -0.013847351, -0.02394104, -0.043182373, 0.015472412, -0.0104904175, -0.02482605, -0.03237915, 0.01524353, -0.089660645, -0.013977051, 0.024398804 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1901.00811v2
From exploration to control: learning object manipulation skills through novelty search and local adaptation
Seungsu Kim, Alexandre Coninx, Stephane Doncieux
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
Programming a robot to deal with open-ended tasks remains a challenge, in particular if the robot has to manipulate objects. Launching, grasping, pushing or any other object interaction can be simulated but the corresponding models are not reversible and the robot behavior thus cannot be directly deduced. These behaviors are hard to learn without a demonstration as the search space is large and the reward sparse. We propose a method to autonomously generate a diverse repertoire of simple object interaction behaviors in simulation. Our goal is to bootstrap a robot learning and development process with limited information about what the robot has to achieve and how. This repertoire can be exploited to solve different tasks in reality thanks to a proposed adaptation method or could be used as a training set for data-hungry algorithms. The proposed approach relies on the definition of a goal space and generates a repertoire of trajectories to reach attainable goals, thus allowing the robot to control this goal space. The repertoire is built with an off-the-shelf simulation thanks to a quality diversity algorithm. The result is a set of solutions tested in simulation only. It may result in two different problems: (1) as the repertoire is discrete and finite, it may not contain the trajectory to deal with a given situation or (2) some trajectories may lead to a behavior in reality that differs from simulation because of a reality gap. We propose an approach to deal with both issues by using a local linearization of the mapping between the motion parameters and the observed effects. Furthermore, we present an approach to update the existing solutions repertoire with the tests done on the real robot. The approach has been validated on two different experiments on the Baxter robot: a ball launching and a joystick manipulation tasks.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1901.00811v2
2020-11-16T09:21:35
2019-01-03T16:46:27
{ "title": [ -0.01512146, -0.0011043549, 0.00019657612, -0.007980347, 0.0056266785, -0.02305603, 0.03488159, -0.02331543, -0.024719238, 0.017059326, -0.010475159, 0.017105103, -0.03161621, -0.015853882, -0.033447266, -0.021743774, -0.0026435852, 0.033843994, -0.00472641, -0.024139404, -0.0061683655, -0.033050537, 0.019058228, 0.01966858, 0.046173096, -0.024215698, -0.13513184, 0.028045654, -0.03488159, -0.02456665, -0.0077323914, 0.028640747, 0.034179688, 0.018875122, -0.0017032623, -0.027740479, -0.0121154785, 0.0038795471, -0.030715942, 0.051605225, 0.0035858154, 0.0022945404, -0.07885742, 0.010169983, -0.08642578, -0.009849548, -0.05230713, 0.017929077, -0.026519775, 0.02104187, 0.0027866364, 0.021987915, -0.021438599, 0.03189087, 0.022857666, 0.0016756058, -0.038085938, -0.017532349, 0.04425049, 0.059783936, 0.009536743, -0.051361084, 0.0079193115, -0.046173096, -0.010025024, -0.040924072, -0.025634766, 0.04324341, 0.043121338, 0.004245758, 0.0045394897, 0.016845703, -0.017791748, 0.018844604, -0.043273926, -0.010398865, 0.058166504, 0.03012085, 0.0146102905, -0.0061683655, -0.0055656433, -0.019882202, -0.013244629, -0.033203125, 0.01725769, -0.032196045, -0.014877319, 0.000043272972, -0.010665894, -0.055755615, -0.005180359, 0.00434494, -0.00011008978, 0.020828247, -0.049468994, -0.023284912, -0.025390625, -0.033325195, 0.03390503, 0.0065841675, 0.016830444, -0.019119263, 0.012649536, -0.010231018, -0.002632141, -0.024154663, 0.018630981, -0.050750732, 0.0031661987, 0.02407837, -0.06335449, 0.083618164, 0.02619934, 0.023071289, -0.008758545, -0.016555786, -0.021255493, 0.032470703, -0.0005993843, 0.024810791, -0.0043792725, -0.0116119385, 0.0026950836, 0.02772522, 0.0066719055, 0.010116577, -0.02204895, -0.01322937, 0.026046753, -0.006298065, -0.027145386, 0.04534912, -0.041931152, -0.06317139, -0.03062439, 0.037109375, 0.0030937195, -0.0033454895, -0.012107849, -0.0065193176, -0.0002605915, 0.009590149, 0.024246216, -0.022003174, 0.030593872, -0.0048217773, 0.03466797, 0.011138916, -0.029037476, -0.010528564, 0.021865845, 0.0029582977, 0.010910034, 0.007091522, -0.013916016, -0.0002887249, -0.08935547, -0.006477356, 0.029159546, 0.0026283264, 0.0357666, 0.0015001297, -0.013885498, 0.019500732, 0.03289795, -0.016799927, -0.0040245056, 0.026321411, 0.011512756, 0.06945801, -0.015808105, 0.020828247, -0.033935547, -0.018844604, -0.013206482, -0.01235199, 0.04626465, -0.0013961792, 0.027893066, 0.00023770332, 0.016418457, 0.010025024, 0.057647705, 0.016906738, -0.020187378, -0.06097412, -0.019119263, -0.064331055, 0.05532837, 0.0011873245, -0.038024902, 0.03378296, -0.059692383, -0.0385437, -0.04647827, 0.030685425, 0.0062026978, 0.034210205, -0.010650635, 0.0025234222, -0.045837402, -0.0052452087, -0.003709793, 0.01448822, 0.025817871, -0.023010254, 0.0019760132, 0.015029907, -0.0041160583, 0.050109863, 0.028656006, 0.013397217, -0.027511597, 0.01260376, -0.021011353, -0.06573486, 0.027801514, 0.0034294128, 0.0042648315, -0.0047035217, -0.011566162, -0.017364502, 0.0026950836, 0.045654297, 0.017410278, 0.0004799366, -0.011329651, -0.026519775, 0.008888245, 0.02798462, 0.0014848709, -0.015686035, 0.008796692, 0.01890564, -0.009902954, -0.02822876, -0.02331543, -0.017532349, 0.024261475, 0.029800415, -0.007484436, -0.01436615, -0.004016876, 0.033721924, 0.030044556, -0.017562866, -0.0031318665, 0.014884949, -0.0057373047, -0.00033068657, 0.058166504, 0.042297363, 0.05014038, 0.055664062, 0.0004246235, 0.05859375, -0.011260986, 0.00058555603, -0.017822266, 0.015571594, 0.003610611, -0.013145447, 0.00919342, 0.006198883, -0.036621094, 0.021514893, -0.003452301, 0.013938904, 0.0039520264, 0.02784729, 0.020431519, -0.05328369, 0.011634827, -0.004032135, -0.006919861, -0.021499634, -0.020187378, 0.026687622, 0.023101807, -0.05822754, -0.0005750656, 0.025619507, 0.056427002, -0.004928589, 0.030944824, 0.012611389, 0.018218994, -0.041137695, -0.00066518784, 0.01802063, 0.07281494, -0.00944519, -0.0028762817, -0.019805908, -0.0020065308, -0.019561768, 0.053344727, 0.08343506, -0.047210693, 0.042114258, -0.04650879, 0.013206482, 0.005092621, -0.0075416565, 0.026733398, -0.020706177, 0.016479492, 0.037719727, -0.006111145, 0.00907135, -0.03942871, 0.028823853, 0.0018100739, -0.0060424805, -0.0259552, -0.04522705, 0.018737793, -0.021194458, -0.04815674, -0.046417236, 0.03741455, -0.031143188, -0.011192322, -0.0015525818, -0.014640808, -0.016708374, -0.0027446747, -0.01914978, 0.00907135, 0.035980225, 0.0791626, 0.06359863, -0.025115967, -0.023712158, 0.01461792, -0.0008883476, -0.009140015, -0.007888794, -0.027374268, 0.010192871, -0.003353119, 0.0023822784, 0.032714844, -0.05355835, -0.0003671646, -0.020004272, -0.025878906, 0.023529053, -0.021102905, -0.013336182, 0.010482788, -0.043273926, -0.0093307495, 0.017562866, 0.06555176, -0.011428833, -0.017593384, 0.051605225, 0.026000977, -0.0050849915, 0.041809082, 0.025497437, 0.024047852, 0.0026550293, -0.016494751, -0.062927246, -0.0015687943, -0.006980896, -0.0030384064, 0.04171753, -0.06274414, -0.0066337585, -0.05303955, -0.0019083023, 0.0079193115, 0.044921875, 0.01309967, -0.03741455, -0.024902344, -0.0058288574, -0.029708862, 0.008888245, -0.053649902, 0.027282715, 0.07867432, -0.00008511543, -0.010414124, 0.00082683563, 0.027160645, 0.0116119385, -0.0006799698, -0.021194458, -0.049743652, 0.007511139, -0.016159058, 0.0051651, -0.00868988, -0.028213501, -0.09197998, -0.00907135, -0.030075073, 0.0016584396, -0.024887085, 0.0069084167, -0.0513916, 0.03463745, -0.043945312, -0.03225708, 0.017364502, 0.10882568, -0.0033626556, -0.03152466, 0.033447266, -0.042663574, 0.025161743, -0.004940033, -0.07141113, 0.020965576, -0.048461914, -0.032409668, 0.028442383, -0.047088623, -0.023635864, -0.011146545, -0.017105103, 0.034820557, 0.062683105, 0.025512695, 0.011604309, -0.020568848, 0.019470215, -0.045959473, -0.009933472, -0.029556274, -0.051940918, -0.02330017, -0.0017147064, 0.042816162, 0.021026611, -0.014465332, -0.032806396, 0.004081726, -0.009742737, 0.025604248, -0.008659363, -0.019866943, 0.0115356445, -0.011520386, -0.01914978, 0.0034885406, -0.015777588, 0.0017738342, -0.034301758, 0.007144928, -0.017837524, 0.059051514, 0.011276245, -0.0018930435, 0.013580322, -0.019714355, 0.0022602081, -0.011428833, -0.075927734, 0.009132385, 0.011207581, -0.025390625, 0.052947998, -0.049041748, -0.017944336, 0.006690979, -0.066833496, 0.04107666, 0.009895325, 0.0052757263, -0.00091028214, 0.006713867, -0.014266968, -0.027557373, 0.02180481, 0.03149414, 0.01285553, -0.0062179565, -0.01386261, -0.014976501, -0.016799927, 0.008506775, -0.09234619, -0.008987427, 0.002790451, -0.009269714, -0.018493652, -0.042419434, 0.020858765, -0.034057617, -0.049926758, 0.01826477, -0.0035800934, -0.005672455, 0.025054932, -0.020645142, -0.03668213, 0.06567383, 0.013504028, -0.018829346, 0.04272461, -0.03942871, -0.026428223, -0.011383057, 0.02999878, 0.03237915, 0.025390625, 0.026885986, -0.0008945465, 0.04763794, -0.022827148, 0.038330078, 0.033569336, 0.03878784, 0.0063705444, -0.0032405853, -0.03781128, -0.002275467, -0.020889282, 0.04989624, 0.01285553, 0.014160156, -0.06732178, 0.06048584, -0.025436401, -0.0129776, 0.03125, 0.0011825562, -0.010375977, -0.0073661804, 0.0066070557, 0.03741455, -0.028366089, -0.020095825, 0.024795532, 0.000026524067, -0.01574707, -0.01486969, -0.003030777, 0.03778076, 0.0021820068, -0.001285553, -0.020065308, 0.03378296, -0.013832092, -0.02166748, 0.0015125275, 0.009422302, -0.0715332, 0.0038318634, -0.035980225, -0.10021973, -0.056518555, 0.031829834, -0.012168884, 0.009857178, 0.028839111, -0.012924194, -0.022750854, 0.00617218, 0.003435135, 0.0022945404, 0.0015649796, -0.0390625, -0.019348145, -0.0043792725, -0.07897949, -0.03161621, -0.04498291, -0.026107788, 0.01058197, 0.004638672, -0.038146973, -0.0063438416, 0.048675537, 0.12841797, 0.021606445, 0.010803223, -0.07977295, 0.021362305, -0.046417236, -0.03164673, 0.05078125, -0.007713318, -0.015151978, -0.016921997, 0.045043945, -0.020935059, -0.022247314, -0.03829956, 0.019943237, -0.0059814453, 0.011230469, -0.0026836395, 0.05041504, 0.024337769, 0.0054740906, -0.01864624, 0.003528595, -0.042236328, 0.03970337, -0.051361084, 0.023071289, -0.054901123, 0.00843811, 0.008178711, 0.034942627, -0.015068054, -0.0001000762, 0.032562256, 0.004119873, -0.012931824, 0.0008382797, 0.023376465, -0.030380249, -0.017425537, 0.007827759, -0.0022125244, 0.03692627, -0.0446167, 0.0491333, 0.022247314, 0.018753052, 0.03555298, -0.020355225, 0.015380859, -0.0041885376, -0.009780884, -0.08294678, -0.08154297, -0.031799316, 0.10028076, -0.04510498, -0.015945435, -0.0072021484, -0.024627686, 0.03201294, 0.04055786, 0.040222168, -0.064208984, -0.018569946, -0.02305603, -0.037384033, -0.0021400452, -0.061706543, -0.010009766, -0.014572144, 0.018295288, -0.05609131, 0.04611206, -0.049041748, 0.013366699, -0.015571594, -0.027832031, 0.002067566, -0.08068848, 0.014930725, 0.056365967, 0.005569458, 0.032409668, -0.0068473816, 0.051849365, 0.03149414, 0.04336548, 0.021606445, -0.0076942444, 0.022644043, 0.00831604, 0.015945435, -0.003850937, 0.010772705, 0.02192688, 0.022033691, -0.0010585785, 0.030319214, -0.03237915, 0.032226562, -0.0020503998, -0.004295349, -0.0010938644, -0.044036865, 0.013435364, 0.0003771782, 0.0064926147, -0.0022792816, -0.05883789, -0.04336548, 0.004512787, -0.05618286, -0.039794922, 0.052856445, -0.039520264, -0.006919861, -0.10882568, 0.007080078, -0.03274536, 0.03375244, -0.03086853, 0.0087890625, -0.046020508, 0.008590698, 0.019104004, -0.009605408, 0.008865356, 0.000020205975, 0.005760193, 0.035949707, 0.0049552917, -0.029830933, -0.010856628, 0.021759033, -0.03894043, -0.0044136047, 0.026748657, -0.00039076805, -0.021987915, 0.00440979, -0.0262146, -0.010696411, -0.002368927, 0.014511108, 0.012901306, -0.010124207, 0.045715332, 0.012504578, 0.00831604, 0.014160156, 0.013450623, -0.041168213, 0.017578125, 0.022857666, 0.05328369, -0.0077590942, 0.0014028549, -0.0070762634, -0.00012743473, -0.023254395, -0.011482239, 0.01965332, -0.0015153885, -0.0012083054, 0.022033691, 0.022644043, 0.032043457, 0.00030899048, 0.0001155138, 0.059173584, -0.020553589, 0.00381279, 0.009971619, -0.013458252, -0.017700195, 0.084106445, 0.00083208084, -0.015068054, -0.066223145, -0.0670166, -0.025924683, -0.0006637573, 0.03250122, 0.012016296, 0.0045814514, -0.01727295, 0.03390503, -0.019042969, 0.00082683563, -0.043914795, 0.004673004, -0.0012331009, -0.00484848, 0.013015747, 0.015205383, 0.028030396, -0.03967285, 0.024154663, -0.006099701, -0.00548172, 0.00061511993, -0.03439331, 0.015914917, -0.037353516, -0.02229309, 0.016799927, 0.027709961, -0.036895752, 0.02986145, -0.033050537, 0.06488037, 0.03677368, 0.057006836, 0.029342651, -0.021743774, -0.0007824898, 0.028289795, -0.009735107, -0.04989624, 0.008918762, -0.05822754, -0.0154800415, -0.045654297, -0.02494812, -0.06573486, -0.024337769, 0.01574707, 0.0011463165, 0.036346436, -0.003873825, -0.010124207, 0.03793335, 0.055725098, 0.07147217, 0.0418396, -0.040252686, -0.0066604614, -0.018325806, -0.018417358, 0.04864502, 0.04522705, -0.008110046, 0.00818634, -0.022888184, -0.017578125, -0.0037708282, 0.019088745, 0.0048294067, 0.02041626, 0.010101318, -0.011070251, 0.07421875, 0.0056037903, 0.04598999, 0.056396484, 0.031341553, -0.013023376, -0.02168274, 0.006958008, 0.004524231, -0.0017995834, -0.008842468, 0.02494812, -0.032226562, 0.017242432, -0.00655365, -0.018920898, -0.00756073, 0.07989502, -0.0022850037, -0.029800415, 0.008666992, 0.031097412, 0.015640259, 0.026107788, 0.006084442, -0.02947998, 0.009056091, 0.02508545, 0.007820129, 0.019226074, 0.02645874, 0.024795532, -0.0051651, -0.054779053, -0.032196045, -0.017303467, 0.037017822, -0.057678223, 0.01763916, -0.02268982, 0.064941406, 0.010818481, -0.029571533, 0.011459351, 0.005619049, -0.045654297, 0.00007915497, 0.021835327, 0.05734253, 0.047973633, 0.081848145, 0.0051612854, -0.017456055, 0.009986877, -0.029891968, 0.012458801, 0.0501709, -0.018234253, 0.017044067, -0.025131226, -0.039520264, 0.045654297, -0.012535095, 0.08312988, -0.025650024, 0.0138549805, 0.008850098, -0.03781128, 0.076293945, -0.022155762, -0.034729004, 0.0058517456, -0.016693115, 0.0057754517, 0.019195557, -0.008171082, 0.014160156, 0.025238037, -0.0014696121, 0.06561279, 0.023086548, 0.00894165, -0.03543091, -0.052703857, 0.047943115, 0.00028061867, 0.068481445, 0.003627777, -0.041931152, -0.038604736, 0.005809784, 0.0541687, -0.010009766, -0.059814453, 0.014419556, -0.0000011920929, -0.009567261, -0.000998497, 0.021530151, -0.01184082, 0.01309967, -0.07116699, 0.043548584, -0.024932861, -0.0061416626, 0.031280518, -0.049072266, 0.021011353, 0.016677856, -0.016021729, 0.04232788, 0.013305664, -0.01687622, 0.028335571, -0.0016622543, -0.025634766, -0.0048179626, -0.0012817383, 0.0085372925, -0.015411377, -0.00957489, -0.004070282, 0.03744507, 0.03604126, -0.057739258, -0.046081543, 0.005252838, 0.03488159, -0.0041656494, 0.07720947, -0.03878784, -0.021469116, 0.03213501, 0.055725098, 0.01335144, -0.033966064, -0.015426636, -0.0020446777, 0.02418518, 0.02961731, -0.012435913, -0.02230835, 0.006954193, -0.017349243, 0.0041236877, 0.016326904, 0.01737976, 0.014823914, -0.0002374649, 0.04638672, -0.029006958, -0.014373779, -0.03074646, 0.056610107, -0.011924744, 0.018218994, -0.0061683655, 0.02418518, 0.002412796, 0.038635254, -0.032409668, -0.008262634, 0.033050537, 0.028671265, 0.035125732, -0.008743286, 0.0042877197, 0.012168884, 0.0014276505, 0.015098572, 0.0064201355, 0.02154541, -0.0033035278, 0.007221222, 0.0048065186, -0.021362305, -0.026687622, -0.003967285, -0.03237915, 0.037475586, -0.017837524, -0.0011520386, 0.0005145073, -0.011947632, -0.003665924, 0.0345459, 0.026321411, -0.013473511, -0.044036865, -0.01071167, 0.051483154, -0.02949524 ], "summary": [ 0.015899658, -0.0077819824, 0.0026931763, 0.011917114, -0.029785156, -0.02583313, -0.02267456, -0.031555176, -0.047088623, 0.007255554, -0.011405945, 0.038879395, -0.022949219, -0.022201538, 0.054718018, -0.0501709, 0.012870789, 0.030776978, 0.03378296, -0.012451172, 0.03125, -0.0010404587, 0.011878967, 0.11651611, 0.053771973, -0.029373169, -0.070739746, 0.013885498, 0.004020691, 0.0046577454, 0.010261536, 0.011268616, 0.011131287, -0.012916565, 0.040283203, -0.0058021545, 0.03387451, -0.019760132, -0.00440979, 0.0541687, 0.03378296, -0.029144287, 0.012428284, -0.047607422, -0.01612854, 0.04232788, -0.0042800903, 0.0071487427, -0.009315491, 0.03286743, -0.005882263, -0.0035991669, -0.02645874, 0.007797241, 0.0027942657, -0.016601562, -0.06298828, -0.033172607, 0.023010254, 0.083496094, 0.028793335, -0.035064697, -0.013259888, -0.057037354, 0.02709961, -0.015777588, -0.034942627, 0.03112793, 0.02355957, 0.02772522, 0.014793396, -0.022094727, -0.012802124, 0.017501831, -0.031402588, 0.011192322, 0.038391113, 0.0395813, -0.020233154, 0.0070381165, 0.008331299, 0.009864807, 0.005859375, -0.015914917, -0.02128601, -0.024642944, 0.0014219284, 0.009010315, -0.003791809, 0.016189575, -0.017120361, 0.06286621, 0.0025920868, 0.00012660027, -0.03970337, -0.005508423, -0.028411865, -0.061828613, 0.023712158, 0.026687622, 0.052581787, -0.060333252, 0.09680176, -0.020629883, -0.012527466, 0.0049819946, 0.03881836, -0.047302246, -0.014526367, -0.005203247, -0.044891357, 0.026138306, 0.018310547, 0.007850647, -0.03866577, -0.032928467, -0.010765076, 0.004966736, -0.0140686035, 0.0033416748, -0.014053345, 0.03579712, 0.0068092346, 0.011207581, -0.017410278, 0.020446777, 0.024276733, -0.07824707, 0.06323242, -0.055358887, -0.05606079, 0.04168701, 0.07067871, -0.004016876, 0.0026073456, 0.010917664, 0.044128418, -0.007499695, -0.0027217865, -0.004135132, -0.009628296, -0.00015115738, -0.008560181, -0.0014133453, 0.004951477, 0.014167786, 0.02545166, -0.006378174, -0.0008034706, 0.008506775, -0.035858154, 0.019378662, -0.017684937, 0.003572464, 0.07293701, -0.024017334, 0.010147095, -0.0011320114, 0.04473877, 0.028640747, 0.0031776428, 0.0021457672, 0.00037884712, -0.016601562, -0.020462036, -0.023239136, -0.010063171, 0.007255554, 0.008300781, 0.054595947, 0.027435303, 0.030960083, -0.018371582, -0.027832031, -0.016998291, -0.060058594, -0.004425049, -0.0027542114, -0.0030651093, -0.021850586, -0.0015010834, -0.022094727, -0.037231445, 0.0309906, 0.008705139, -0.058258057, -0.036193848, -0.045928955, 0.043273926, 0.00806427, -0.034454346, 0.0231781, -0.04724121, 0.0011577606, -0.00983429, 0.024017334, -0.037017822, 0.0309906, -0.023483276, -0.020690918, 0.038848877, -0.01927185, 0.0062294006, -0.011909485, -0.022323608, -0.017791748, -0.0028495789, 0.0045433044, -0.0496521, 0.039398193, 0.034942627, -0.014480591, -0.02357483, 0.0491333, 0.033294678, -0.050598145, 0.027618408, 0.0024871826, -0.004371643, -0.02104187, 0.0029468536, -0.015113831, -0.027755737, 0.042022705, 0.037872314, -0.014984131, -0.0057792664, -0.015777588, 0.06921387, -0.006427765, 0.021987915, 0.0021915436, -0.017288208, 0.019515991, -0.0072631836, 0.0027751923, 0.015838623, -0.03652954, 0.02166748, 0.021011353, 0.024536133, -0.0018100739, -0.02758789, 0.006034851, -0.016357422, -0.016830444, 0.004989624, -0.0069847107, -0.0440979, -0.018218994, 0.029541016, -0.0007481575, 0.02734375, 0.028549194, -0.015533447, 0.017501831, -0.0019950867, -0.035827637, 0.01914978, -0.016708374, 0.029144287, -0.04168701, -0.046844482, 0.0056037903, 0.011886597, -0.024642944, 0.006549835, -0.0020370483, 0.016326904, -0.017990112, -0.0066986084, -0.070495605, -0.01914978, -0.046661377, -0.01235199, -0.049560547, -0.060668945, 0.06689453, 0.03591919, -0.051361084, -0.0075416565, 0.011177063, 0.030761719, -0.015350342, 0.028656006, 0.0011310577, -0.0018587112, -0.03100586, 0.040985107, 0.06762695, 0.068603516, -0.006000519, -0.011207581, 0.011772156, -0.0061187744, -0.027832031, -0.0015163422, 0.052337646, -0.047210693, -0.0015468597, -0.0011100769, 0.028411865, 0.00983429, -0.028869629, 0.021636963, -0.025024414, -0.007801056, 0.024002075, 0.010650635, 0.006969452, -0.038848877, 0.029632568, 0.05154419, 0.057769775, 0.030426025, 0.0072250366, 0.04840088, 0.088012695, 0.024490356, -0.0014410019, 0.0914917, -0.0060424805, 0.020507812, 0.014480591, -0.011856079, -0.058502197, 0.047912598, -0.027282715, 0.0149383545, 0.011764526, -0.003353119, 0.0016431808, -0.0385437, -0.009094238, 0.011222839, -0.007987976, -0.0052375793, 0.028198242, 0.006565094, -0.03881836, 0.01902771, 0.019973755, -0.011604309, 0.016860962, 0.027175903, -0.045776367, -0.0051231384, -0.012435913, 0.044647217, 0.022521973, -0.020263672, -0.002149582, -0.027770996, 0.02609253, 0.019134521, -0.04168701, 0.017929077, 0.056732178, -0.012016296, -0.014694214, 0.0491333, 0.02420044, 0.021575928, -0.03010559, -0.052947998, -0.038208008, 0.03842163, -0.034606934, 0.04144287, 0.038360596, -0.03741455, 0.05493164, -0.054260254, -0.004890442, 0.014190674, 0.01802063, 0.06427002, -0.007549286, -0.0234375, 0.03186035, 0.02571106, 0.026641846, -0.020309448, 0.012672424, 0.06311035, 0.007472992, 0.037902832, 0.026443481, 0.056549072, -0.005680084, -0.012428284, -0.02331543, 0.024154663, -0.013824463, -0.0025863647, 0.012641907, -0.022369385, -0.042785645, -0.018951416, -0.017959595, 0.0050735474, 0.012413025, 0.006942749, 0.00068855286, 0.008476257, 0.0002361536, -0.0002053976, -0.01878357, -0.0013217926, 0.017486572, 0.035186768, -0.07196045, 0.060302734, -0.0848999, 0.030899048, -0.023422241, 0.009895325, 0.020736694, -0.0357666, -0.013267517, 0.0146865845, 0.011581421, 0.0009279251, -0.010772705, 0.018585205, 0.0090789795, 0.020126343, 0.01159668, -0.029815674, -0.014442444, 0.025924683, -0.05053711, -0.0065956116, 0.022506714, -0.0368042, 0.053588867, -0.008232117, 0.0050354004, 0.031097412, -0.04776001, -0.009567261, 0.022460938, 0.01828003, -0.0085372925, 0.018585205, -0.02168274, 0.04748535, 0.0063667297, -0.014762878, -0.03338623, -0.00995636, 0.020202637, -0.0013179779, 0.010154724, 0.0037250519, 0.04562378, -0.022033691, 0.02015686, 0.044891357, -0.03894043, -0.015205383, -0.009300232, -0.0496521, -0.0024681091, -0.00793457, 0.009460449, 0.038513184, 0.015205383, 0.008850098, -0.026000977, -0.02230835, 0.019485474, 0.014427185, 0.0035953522, -0.03338623, -0.010169983, 0.038024902, -0.007865906, 0.029800415, -0.0069465637, -0.0055122375, 0.011741638, 0.00089645386, -0.020095825, -0.022155762, 0.024291992, -0.070739746, -0.017074585, 0.027389526, 0.024032593, 0.021209717, -0.0029888153, 0.03741455, 0.0126953125, -0.0025844574, 0.008720398, -0.0107040405, 0.034057617, 0.0096206665, -0.03781128, -0.0110321045, -0.0008029938, 0.0423584, 0.00046348572, 0.001745224, 0.009811401, 0.027282715, 0.02897644, 0.021408081, 0.012168884, 0.027267456, -0.000300169, 0.03817749, 0.044403076, -0.022888184, 0.014045715, 0.009033203, 0.0597229, -0.026443481, -0.028915405, 0.03112793, 0.039215088, -0.02658081, -0.002571106, 0.08087158, -0.006542206, -0.037719727, 0.022750854, -0.0004451275, 0.008171082, 0.02368164, 0.027755737, -0.04156494, -0.029037476, 0.053619385, -0.035339355, -0.03729248, 0.0007839203, 0.025726318, 0.034332275, -0.07299805, -0.03277588, 0.044769287, 0.07910156, 0.0037994385, -0.028778076, -0.011024475, 0.0043792725, -0.0025501251, -0.0064964294, -0.0003068447, -0.003660202, -0.056030273, -0.029067993, -0.017227173, 0.010566711, -0.015098572, 0.03955078, -0.009002686, -0.053344727, -0.0073928833, -0.01158905, -0.016174316, 0.032165527, 0.055603027, 0.02861023, -0.011650085, -0.06866455, 0.0010938644, 0.016906738, -0.052856445, -0.03768921, -0.06640625, -0.046020508, -0.024658203, -0.015853882, -0.016815186, -0.001045227, 0.039123535, 0.10626221, 0.04373169, 0.02418518, -0.086120605, -0.009300232, -0.039154053, -0.010574341, 0.024291992, -0.028213501, -0.035827637, -0.029266357, 0.026824951, 0.017990112, -0.040374756, 0.02166748, 0.008682251, -0.006587982, 0.03942871, 0.008926392, 0.08947754, 0.019119263, -0.03967285, -0.01448822, -0.010131836, -0.029693604, 0.10083008, -0.005218506, 0.020004272, -0.054351807, -0.00705719, -0.016418457, 0.009613037, 0.0030555725, -0.010765076, 0.0015964508, -0.02017212, -0.009292603, -0.04144287, 0.02784729, 0.006038666, -0.0079193115, 0.016540527, -0.014160156, -0.005004883, 0.008453369, 0.017730713, 0.045898438, -0.012329102, 0.020187378, -0.02053833, 0.0051002502, -0.021514893, -0.019180298, -0.08874512, -0.057891846, -0.024597168, 0.084350586, -0.032806396, -0.029159546, -0.0011548996, -0.052978516, 0.046539307, 0.017211914, 0.047088623, -0.09082031, 0.015617371, -0.017349243, -0.022338867, 0.030075073, -0.036010742, -0.016052246, -0.031402588, 0.01576233, -0.032165527, 0.038848877, 0.015777588, 0.017211914, -0.004589081, -0.0037651062, 0.021194458, -0.008506775, -0.0019626617, 0.055023193, -0.04953003, 0.03793335, 0.029876709, 0.013885498, -0.025161743, 0.0287323, -0.017532349, 0.03048706, -0.0104599, -0.015777588, 0.032165527, -0.00056934357, -0.00023627281, 0.03225708, -0.0031166077, 0.0013065338, -0.010391235, 0.002790451, -0.009338379, -0.01979065, 0.018585205, -0.028244019, -0.0017604828, 0.027359009, 0.035217285, 0.018814087, -0.016098022, -0.022857666, -0.05517578, -0.020599365, -0.019058228, -0.04309082, 0.024780273, -0.04345703, 0.024353027, -0.08013916, -0.046783447, -0.07006836, 0.028961182, -0.008094788, 0.02709961, -0.00056552887, -0.020706177, 0.039367676, -0.003047943, 0.06530762, -0.0051116943, 0.0020694733, 0.036468506, 0.012245178, -0.04675293, -0.010025024, 0.05831909, 0.015068054, -0.02482605, -0.037384033, -0.0552063, -0.0072250366, -0.011352539, -0.015136719, -0.015327454, -0.038757324, 0.0044555664, -0.04159546, -0.013809204, 0.0035438538, -0.007865906, -0.02557373, 0.018753052, -0.028030396, -0.009979248, 0.006752014, -0.009902954, 0.04977417, -0.003982544, -0.01235199, 0.0032596588, 0.001572609, 0.011260986, -0.0077667236, 0.038330078, 0.02784729, 0.003786087, 0.01600647, 0.012428284, 0.060913086, 0.007835388, -0.015060425, 0.009086609, 0.047943115, 0.019607544, 0.019973755, 0.002609253, -0.003868103, 0.05886841, 0.016433716, 0.01852417, -0.042877197, -0.028686523, -0.0075531006, -0.004219055, 0.036010742, -0.013130188, 0.03933716, -0.031173706, -0.016616821, 0.021484375, -0.0040740967, -0.007827759, -0.04232788, -0.006122589, 0.009994507, 0.057373047, 0.06542969, 0.0017166138, 0.022598267, 0.0018196106, 0.025863647, 0.010101318, 0.04135132, -0.056274414, -0.007183075, -0.019454956, 0.0025730133, 0.002439499, 0.018371582, -0.0054512024, 0.00064611435, -0.009689331, 0.036468506, 0.0021266937, -0.014968872, -0.041290283, -0.0005745888, 0.044067383, -0.0014972687, 0.03353882, -0.0007777214, 0.005645752, -0.028656006, -0.057556152, -0.015670776, -0.038116455, 0.008216858, -0.037719727, 0.007881165, -0.033111572, 0.057647705, -0.014770508, -0.005001068, 0.033294678, -0.046722412, 0.05444336, -0.018936157, -0.043884277, -0.019821167, -0.022247314, -0.050842285, 0.039916992, 0.051635742, -0.00642395, 0.015365601, -0.0054969788, 0.005882263, 0.03765869, -0.021743774, -0.03338623, -0.054718018, 0.020904541, -0.055511475, 0.0076675415, -0.016799927, 0.014442444, 0.04849243, 0.009635925, 0.06048584, -0.039886475, 0.020446777, -0.0035896301, -0.021469116, 0.028244019, 0.016098022, -0.02911377, 0.02003479, 0.007183075, -0.023849487, -0.009841919, 0.06542969, 0.022659302, 0.010375977, 0.076293945, -0.025650024, -0.015655518, -0.04727173, 0.023117065, -0.0154418945, -0.021148682, -0.0016880035, 0.0027561188, 0.017044067, 0.048217773, 0.028778076, -0.035583496, -0.008026123, -0.021881104, -0.025558472, 0.06604004, -0.046722412, 0.022094727, -0.0050354004, 0.016967773, 0.005680084, -0.014678955, 0.036895752, -0.004180908, 0.00086545944, 0.021514893, -0.006904602, 0.081970215, 0.05444336, 0.059326172, -0.0063972473, 0.0033435822, 0.051696777, 0.0018444061, 0.017166138, 0.0024490356, -0.004863739, -0.011772156, -0.0095825195, -0.009994507, 0.023345947, -0.018951416, 0.04333496, 0.000685215, 0.013893127, -0.012237549, -0.033111572, 0.0262146, -0.007621765, -0.009429932, -0.023666382, 0.009841919, 0.031799316, 0.07019043, -0.0104522705, 0.075927734, 0.026992798, -0.059783936, 0.07098389, 0.008888245, 0.015655518, -0.010032654, -0.07183838, 0.03250122, -0.005874634, 0.07043457, 0.026855469, -0.037841797, 0.009605408, 0.011276245, 0.016433716, -0.056396484, -0.04260254, 0.015853882, 0.036590576, -0.01133728, -0.02746582, -0.015007019, -0.016174316, 0.06262207, -0.03756714, 0.0569458, -0.016708374, -0.002401352, 0.046661377, 0.018127441, -0.058624268, 0.0041656494, -0.0206604, 0.001458168, -0.040893555, -0.025909424, 0.055664062, -0.0007081032, -0.050048828, 0.0030345917, -0.020523071, -0.0065727234, -0.014442444, -0.027877808, 0.01928711, 0.00034213066, 0.056365967, -0.004837036, -0.021194458, -0.001461029, -0.031219482, -0.008018494, 0.006893158, -0.03213501, -0.0015506744, 0.023712158, 0.07727051, 0.012237549, -0.038879395, 0.01626587, 0.03189087, 0.011871338, 0.018859863, -0.008651733, 0.015274048, 0.009033203, -0.046539307, 0.024887085, -0.040405273, 0.0357666, -0.0006055832, -0.031829834, 0.031143188, -0.009521484, -0.0021915436, 0.0004644394, 0.0062294006, -0.004425049, -0.013290405, 0.011619568, -0.0040245056, -0.0069770813, 0.029525757, 0.012290955, 0.05303955, -0.02885437, -0.026794434, 0.04550171, -0.024765015, 0.0088272095, -0.0082092285, -0.026626587, 0.04055786, 0.04269409, 0.064453125, -0.015037537, 0.029464722, 0.041503906, -0.058135986, 0.0039367676, -0.07739258, -0.021636963, 0.012641907, 0.00793457, -0.012435913, 0.043792725, -0.02053833, 0.021270752, -0.001162529, 0.0012960434, 0.022903442, 0.0096206665, 0.06604004, -0.03010559, 0.0071411133 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1905.02691v1
Learned human-agent decision-making, communication and joint action in a virtual reality environment
Patrick M. Pilarski, Andrew Butcher, Michael Johanson, Matthew M. Botvinick, Andrew Bolt, Adam S. R. Parker
cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
Humans make decisions and act alongside other humans to pursue both short-term and long-term goals. As a result of ongoing progress in areas such as computing science and automation, humans now also interact with non-human agents of varying complexity as part of their day-to-day activities; substantial work is being done to integrate increasingly intelligent machine agents into human work and play. With increases in the cognitive, sensory, and motor capacity of these agents, intelligent machinery for human assistance can now reasonably be considered to engage in joint action with humans---i.e., two or more agents adapting their behaviour and their understanding of each other so as to progress in shared objectives or goals. The mechanisms, conditions, and opportunities for skillful joint action in human-machine partnerships is of great interest to multiple communities. Despite this, human-machine joint action is as yet under-explored, especially in cases where a human and an intelligent machine interact in a persistent way during the course of real-time, daily-life experience. In this work, we contribute a virtual reality environment wherein a human and an agent can adapt their predictions, their actions, and their communication so as to pursue a simple foraging task. In a case study with a single participant, we provide an example of human-agent coordination and decision-making involving prediction learning on the part of the human and the machine agent, and control learning on the part of the machine agent wherein audio communication signals are used to cue its human partner in service of acquiring shared reward. These comparisons suggest the utility of studying human-machine coordination in a virtual reality environment, and identify further research that will expand our understanding of persistent human-machine joint action.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1905.02691v1
2019-05-07T16:53:48
2019-05-07T16:53:48
{ "title": [ -0.010513306, 0.00623703, -0.052886963, -0.009490967, 0.013916016, -0.05239868, 0.02848816, -0.0032672882, -0.0385437, 0.022125244, -0.01852417, 0.012710571, -0.005355835, -0.021636963, -0.004573822, -0.024734497, 0.0074920654, 0.030197144, -0.011268616, -0.026412964, -0.006111145, -0.019592285, 0.020828247, 0.049041748, 0.046813965, -0.0020580292, -0.14099121, 0.036071777, -0.025878906, -0.0027885437, -0.0101623535, 0.012313843, 0.027862549, 0.0070648193, -0.018997192, -0.017547607, -0.032287598, 0.0132369995, -0.022827148, 0.013748169, 0.023742676, -0.02796936, -0.025039673, -0.016235352, -0.04232788, 0.04107666, -0.054504395, -0.010887146, -0.008865356, 0.038146973, 0.0037403107, 0.03314209, -0.00258255, 0.034851074, 0.018966675, -0.024002075, -0.022445679, -0.027755737, 0.04925537, 0.042999268, -0.0033798218, -0.058441162, 0.021575928, -0.04269409, -0.0231781, -0.02507019, -0.01687622, 0.009651184, 0.070251465, 0.017059326, -0.015808105, 0.020019531, 0.012252808, 0.014884949, -0.036956787, -0.0033550262, 0.025924683, 0.022415161, 0.044006348, -0.027938843, -0.03173828, -0.02279663, 0.008483887, -0.0463562, 0.02784729, -0.040100098, -0.0072135925, 0.007167816, -0.040802002, -0.052337646, -0.0030002594, -0.005306244, -0.022521973, -0.00944519, -0.043182373, -0.03564453, -0.030258179, -0.0013446808, 0.016784668, -0.0039100647, -0.019729614, 0.024841309, -0.05114746, -0.010681152, -0.00056648254, 0.001707077, -0.010353088, -0.010688782, 0.004486084, 0.021881104, -0.032348633, 0.03152466, -0.013694763, -0.022583008, -0.01184082, -0.021530151, -0.060943604, 0.035736084, 0.021362305, 0.028717041, 0.017532349, -0.0104522705, -0.001458168, 0.03451538, 0.037750244, 0.03869629, -0.035064697, -0.016860962, -0.0011291504, 0.035461426, 0.0025157928, 0.05126953, -0.11456299, -0.08972168, -0.06604004, 0.0345459, 0.013343811, 0.010353088, -0.0051460266, 0.010513306, 0.017120361, -0.010925293, 0.027114868, 0.021270752, 0.008544922, 0.013641357, 0.0423584, -0.0018253326, -0.03189087, -0.055847168, -0.010154724, 0.020568848, -0.028915405, 0.013404846, 0.039489746, -0.00038218498, -0.072509766, -0.0027866364, 0.07672119, 0.044708252, 0.030166626, 0.010124207, -0.011878967, 0.010505676, 0.037139893, -0.024780273, -0.007030487, 0.026931763, 0.014053345, 0.06341553, 0.0016489029, -0.023513794, -0.014030457, -0.014984131, -0.014671326, 0.0023326874, 0.0035877228, 0.0014352798, 0.013175964, -0.0067481995, -0.02319336, -0.03829956, 0.00020265579, 0.023864746, -0.018844604, -0.01109314, -0.019836426, -0.056610107, 0.03793335, -0.005340576, -0.050048828, 0.06188965, -0.016983032, -0.058502197, -0.030548096, 0.010658264, 0.019058228, 0.026535034, -0.0096206665, 0.010437012, -0.06222534, -0.023162842, -0.012466431, 0.00055646896, 0.014160156, -0.07006836, 0.016342163, 0.009307861, -0.03111267, 0.04815674, 0.036376953, 0.010826111, -0.031021118, 0.00843811, -0.00004887581, -0.040161133, 0.010505676, -0.016235352, -0.014091492, -0.045562744, -0.020004272, -0.00034046173, -0.0073623657, 0.03237915, 0.0017652512, 0.029266357, -0.017501831, 0.0014896393, 0.036590576, 0.033935547, 0.056030273, -0.040405273, 0.022766113, 0.024261475, -0.024642944, -0.028274536, -0.01991272, -0.017562866, 0.0149002075, 0.02746582, -0.0029907227, -0.03942871, 0.01373291, 0.053955078, 0.010726929, -0.01864624, 0.006866455, 0.019546509, 0.008239746, 0.00541687, 0.05886841, 0.001291275, 0.053009033, 0.04269409, -0.0037841797, 0.051849365, -0.021453857, -0.01360321, -0.03161621, 0.012718201, 0.009513855, -0.012863159, 0.020950317, -0.008262634, -0.051483154, 0.012039185, -0.054656982, -0.017745972, -0.0017080307, 0.019500732, 0.028152466, -0.062347412, -0.00440979, -0.01953125, -0.021606445, -0.032440186, -0.041259766, 0.054504395, 0.028930664, -0.05621338, -0.012451172, 0.0073432922, 0.03475952, -0.00242424, 0.018157959, 0.047973633, 0.033111572, -0.0463562, 0.0057373047, -0.004512787, 0.057434082, 0.01285553, 0.004673004, 0.004611969, 0.008430481, -0.02520752, 0.022262573, 0.09008789, -0.0340271, 0.035369873, -0.099487305, 0.014770508, 0.023605347, -0.033966064, 0.01322937, -0.026168823, 0.024475098, 0.030273438, -0.019561768, -0.009391785, -0.03845215, 0.033325195, 0.008522034, -0.056365967, -0.007156372, -0.011108398, -0.014533997, -0.035217285, -0.054504395, 0.0079193115, 0.045440674, -0.017578125, -0.010643005, -0.021255493, -0.00026845932, -0.013000488, -0.029571533, -0.024612427, -0.0010232925, 0.049346924, 0.039001465, 0.053222656, -0.03326416, -0.0026283264, 0.0015563965, 0.012145996, -0.0035476685, -0.012878418, -0.019226074, -0.008544922, 0.0026054382, -0.048614502, 0.009300232, -0.027862549, 0.0024719238, -0.056488037, -0.012817383, 0.020217896, 0.006702423, -0.009384155, 0.0158844, -0.01953125, -0.009895325, 0.004787445, 0.058044434, -0.019821167, -0.031143188, 0.054595947, 0.03137207, -0.00061511993, 0.045410156, 0.009429932, 0.014122009, -0.04638672, -0.0011997223, -0.04144287, -0.0043640137, -0.020980835, 0.009483337, 0.044769287, -0.059906006, 0.027709961, -0.06427002, -0.012390137, -0.0007596016, 0.028640747, 0.0026245117, -0.018569946, -0.021026611, -0.010902405, 0.0064582825, 0.0052833557, -0.008262634, -0.006790161, 0.091796875, 0.013671875, -0.008239746, -0.030792236, 0.045837402, 0.012954712, -0.017959595, -0.053863525, -0.025558472, 0.003004074, 0.0025539398, -0.0062026978, -0.014015198, -0.011566162, -0.09503174, 0.00598526, 0.016555786, 0.0018672943, -0.03640747, 0.041900635, -0.053649902, 0.01965332, 0.010345459, -0.03302002, 0.027236938, 0.06793213, -0.024414062, 0.0000911355, 0.0012998581, -0.029159546, 0.0018901825, -0.00087451935, -0.10644531, 0.029312134, -0.046722412, -0.01512146, 0.017105103, -0.034454346, -0.03387451, -0.010231018, 0.010848999, 0.053863525, 0.03945923, -0.008857727, 0.035980225, 0.006828308, 0.02822876, -0.019821167, -0.007785797, -0.029800415, -0.029953003, -0.020019531, -0.039123535, 0.053466797, -0.01977539, 0.002904892, -0.027618408, 0.010261536, -0.002281189, 0.01966858, -0.006717682, -0.037750244, 0.016845703, -0.0050086975, -0.06451416, -0.03567505, 0.0064888, 0.03378296, -0.040496826, 0.0036945343, 0.010406494, 0.042633057, 0.011604309, 0.022460938, -0.004711151, -0.02909851, 0.01210022, -0.030349731, -0.045959473, 0.02545166, -0.000008583069, -0.0020561218, 0.07965088, -0.019012451, -0.029571533, 0.024353027, -0.026000977, 0.003660202, 0.014099121, -0.0128479, 0.0037937164, 0.0053520203, -0.017974854, -0.008453369, -0.0101623535, 0.007534027, 0.019805908, -0.007118225, -0.035980225, -0.04296875, -0.03817749, 0.014694214, -0.12005615, -0.032928467, 0.008911133, -0.04550171, -0.028060913, -0.030136108, 0.004142761, -0.04675293, -0.040496826, -0.007637024, -0.009490967, -0.0127334595, 0.003932953, -0.026870728, -0.05239868, 0.06085205, -0.0074653625, -0.030136108, 0.055877686, -0.021133423, -0.0044898987, -0.011390686, 0.045043945, 0.08001709, 0.0078086853, 0.0231781, 0.020370483, 0.04748535, -0.018844604, -0.013397217, 0.07989502, 0.024612427, 0.014640808, 0.0026512146, 0.017303467, 0.024887085, -0.037322998, 0.0435791, 0.027053833, -0.0051574707, -0.07080078, 0.018096924, -0.00077438354, -0.035705566, -0.0052452087, -0.03842163, 0.015594482, 0.049957275, 0.009735107, 0.0814209, -0.012832642, -0.016586304, 0.008453369, -0.006679535, -0.024398804, -0.003932953, 0.0017786026, 0.019760132, -0.0032138824, 0.031982422, -0.02470398, 0.063964844, -0.011520386, 0.0135269165, 0.0066566467, 0.00091934204, -0.05886841, 0.003534317, -0.027954102, -0.09484863, -0.052734375, 0.028869629, -0.0041160583, 0.0053520203, 0.033416748, 0.006023407, -0.04248047, 0.017929077, 0.042816162, 0.002204895, -0.022949219, -0.06677246, -0.00087451935, -0.015991211, -0.060821533, -0.037231445, -0.01777649, -0.027282715, 0.02368164, -0.0015239716, -0.06201172, 0.011543274, 0.040374756, 0.14245605, 0.05480957, 0.013710022, -0.078063965, 0.026809692, -0.034057617, 0.0042762756, 0.0075149536, 0.002325058, -0.0071029663, -0.02911377, 0.022521973, -0.013076782, -0.022201538, -0.009780884, 0.053771973, -0.024917603, 0.05630493, -0.021011353, 0.05596924, 0.03201294, -0.005958557, 0.016403198, 0.00032544136, -0.030853271, 0.028686523, 0.005672455, 0.018447876, -0.016555786, 0.0034866333, 0.040649414, 0.017944336, 0.021484375, -0.004070282, 0.00004607439, 0.031219482, -0.00084638596, -0.00944519, 0.012710571, -0.044281006, -0.012779236, 0.026260376, -0.0025100708, 0.053771973, -0.0012025833, 0.074279785, -0.023727417, -0.029846191, 0.029006958, 0.007972717, 0.00040841103, -0.00036239624, 0.010032654, -0.025665283, -0.03564453, 0.019195557, 0.028686523, -0.030593872, 0.006324768, -0.027114868, -0.0048980713, 0.043792725, 0.04333496, 0.031677246, -0.038635254, 0.0004992485, -0.013381958, -0.016311646, -0.0021820068, -0.039398193, -0.018188477, -0.014564514, 0.021469116, -0.028579712, 0.038116455, -0.036254883, 0.01121521, -0.03100586, 0.01473999, 0.011924744, -0.038116455, 0.011779785, 0.060821533, 0.020263672, 0.015022278, -0.0020923615, 0.01876831, 0.02319336, 0.026229858, 0.0013847351, 0.009979248, 0.02760315, -0.059326172, 0.017654419, -0.0042152405, 0.012306213, -0.003063202, 0.02079773, 0.008346558, 0.01828003, -0.0513916, 0.028503418, 0.026763916, -0.009086609, 0.0023994446, -0.036315918, 0.024093628, 0.041503906, 0.004447937, 0.00957489, -0.051361084, -0.056793213, -0.030426025, -0.030212402, -0.047424316, 0.0026741028, -0.012931824, -0.024932861, -0.12963867, 0.013504028, -0.026733398, 0.011894226, -0.03878784, 0.027709961, -0.057739258, 0.0052604675, 0.067993164, -0.010429382, 0.046844482, -0.04058838, -0.00844574, 0.052856445, 0.030532837, -0.025558472, -0.00049877167, 0.0006046295, -0.03466797, -0.00087451935, 0.0038604736, -0.008407593, 0.0118637085, -0.01486969, -0.068847656, -0.036834717, 0.016082764, 0.007572174, -0.006122589, -0.025009155, 0.010795593, -0.022125244, -0.03439331, 0.0034370422, 0.0077819824, -0.0014600754, 0.0029392242, -0.015625, 0.0070610046, 0.045532227, -0.006866455, -0.002035141, 0.016464233, -0.034301758, 0.012184143, 0.023910522, -0.019439697, -0.022918701, 0.027526855, 0.034240723, -0.029052734, -0.00024008751, 0.013557434, 0.060577393, -0.036834717, 0.02267456, -0.004310608, -0.003255844, -0.03189087, 0.04827881, 0.023376465, 0.00969696, -0.043395996, -0.038085938, -0.022094727, 0.0032463074, 0.022644043, 0.0034809113, 0.035339355, -0.019134521, -0.005672455, -0.012451172, -0.00083875656, -0.031707764, -0.012832642, -0.0017700195, 0.010055542, 0.04019165, 0.024261475, 0.018737793, -0.018203735, 0.020004272, -0.006515503, -0.007129669, -0.022918701, -0.03314209, 0.021408081, -0.0063705444, -0.019302368, 0.031555176, -0.012817383, -0.035217285, 0.0025615692, -0.036376953, 0.06982422, 0.031463623, 0.03845215, 0.04360962, 0.009780884, -0.015289307, 0.008903503, 0.010635376, -0.04586792, 0.010375977, -0.05630493, 0.014472961, -0.030059814, -0.014160156, -0.07519531, -0.0066833496, 0.026672363, 0.014907837, 0.014663696, -0.0037250519, -0.006011963, 0.0019721985, 0.023971558, 0.019561768, 0.033233643, -0.004432678, -0.009544373, -0.01108551, 0.015464783, 0.011138916, 0.027297974, 0.006713867, 0.029312134, -0.014221191, -0.020355225, 0.010696411, -0.00073480606, 0.015777588, -0.0013504028, -0.012069702, -0.015640259, 0.04397583, -0.011932373, -0.0020771027, 0.062194824, 0.054504395, -0.04067993, -0.00016760826, 0.03955078, -0.0017976761, -0.030395508, 0.02180481, 0.03942871, -0.054229736, 0.046844482, -0.0039978027, -0.046447754, -0.00674057, 0.062561035, 0.021072388, -0.050964355, 0.006298065, 0.042999268, -0.00043535233, -0.0087890625, 0.023880005, -0.04034424, -0.03756714, 0.012413025, 0.018981934, -0.039642334, 0.011360168, 0.037384033, 0.027862549, -0.034576416, -0.00856781, -0.02659607, 0.035461426, -0.06185913, 0.02458191, -0.030929565, 0.057006836, 0.011672974, -0.03829956, 0.02267456, 0.005039215, -0.03277588, 0.002445221, -0.0026474, 0.0035552979, 0.01348114, 0.03604126, -0.011299133, -0.01701355, -0.019882202, -0.025878906, 0.042907715, 0.022201538, -0.018692017, 0.020751953, -0.043823242, -0.033996582, 0.012702942, -0.033966064, 0.05166626, -0.037384033, -0.016113281, -0.010192871, 0.0074424744, 0.051330566, -0.024551392, -0.044311523, -0.019180298, -0.03878784, 0.0012283325, 0.01411438, -0.009559631, 0.03845215, -0.013000488, -0.03866577, 0.028259277, 0.014854431, -0.005268097, -0.03253174, -0.05987549, 0.019348145, -0.001294136, 0.048797607, -0.0015697479, -0.04147339, -0.034332275, 0.014274597, 0.03024292, 0.023452759, -0.03704834, 0.059570312, -0.0034389496, -0.015281677, 0.0151901245, 0.008392334, -0.0021152496, 0.0074157715, 0.03112793, 0.0034427643, -0.007472992, 0.016860962, 0.03314209, -0.0046310425, -0.082458496, -0.0011358261, -0.027008057, 0.014442444, -0.0014162064, -0.033477783, 0.018234253, 0.007511139, -0.031585693, -0.018356323, -0.0065460205, 0.021072388, -0.014808655, -0.033233643, 0.006965637, 0.002922058, 0.0317688, -0.050079346, -0.064819336, -0.02029419, 0.040374756, 0.0116119385, 0.03149414, 0.008270264, -0.023834229, -0.034729004, 0.0093307495, -0.00831604, -0.024429321, -0.037872314, -0.01953125, 0.042785645, 0.032592773, -0.018127441, 0.0051345825, 0.031311035, -0.014457703, 0.002105713, -0.023727417, -0.0009217262, -0.00012516975, -0.018966675, 0.02507019, -0.0037193298, 0.0032958984, -0.021621704, 0.012336731, 0.0010910034, 0.0074882507, -0.0058670044, 0.014442444, -0.020080566, 0.031555176, -0.025146484, -0.0043296814, 0.02911377, 0.039764404, 0.015838623, 0.04989624, -0.014350891, -0.0078048706, -0.014053345, 0.037963867, 0.01878357, 0.06317139, 0.018569946, -0.024658203, 0.027618408, -0.063964844, -0.033233643, -0.02999878, -0.020111084, 0.021713257, -0.007499695, 0.0067443848, 0.004295349, -0.016845703, 0.0056915283, 0.042236328, 0.05215454, -0.04147339, -0.006416321, 0.027938843, 0.05923462, -0.005077362 ], "summary": [ 0.043640137, -0.0041885376, 0.010749817, 0.031280518, -0.011184692, -0.038513184, 0.043823242, -0.040252686, -0.008705139, 0.038635254, -0.033111572, -0.011955261, 0.025558472, -0.012229919, -0.012145996, -0.035217285, -0.027786255, 0.06402588, 0.052246094, -0.019485474, 0.029586792, -0.025802612, -0.0023345947, 0.0029411316, 0.049957275, -0.0049438477, -0.103149414, 0.0028018951, 0.04815674, 0.04095459, 0.020095825, -0.04989624, 0.043060303, -0.06161499, -0.0055885315, -0.06286621, -0.016235352, -0.029830933, -0.058441162, 0.029754639, 0.03652954, -0.009567261, 0.015914917, -0.050231934, -0.044433594, 0.052856445, -0.006965637, 0.011634827, 0.01701355, -0.0066184998, -0.0067329407, 0.00093078613, -0.0029678345, -0.009979248, -0.020263672, -0.010803223, -0.02067566, -0.03439331, 0.02192688, 0.03692627, 0.009300232, -0.0385437, 0.013313293, -0.03463745, 0.0070495605, -0.015899658, 0.04336548, 0.017242432, 0.017929077, 0.004837036, 0.023117065, 0.009063721, -0.00907135, -0.012199402, -0.020523071, -0.004425049, 0.042877197, 0.016860962, -0.025009155, 0.02078247, -0.030792236, -0.025054932, 0.0012302399, -0.05770874, 0.009597778, -0.04864502, -0.0050811768, 0.03286743, -0.015335083, 0.004131317, -0.015991211, -0.01626587, 0.02128601, 0.017089844, -0.02281189, -0.031219482, -0.016326904, -0.016937256, 0.013824463, 0.024795532, 0.0014305115, -0.014457703, 0.019256592, -0.02708435, -0.0063667297, 0.03164673, 0.028656006, -0.0039749146, 0.005241394, 0.0026130676, -0.014297485, 0.037261963, 0.005130768, -0.015098572, -0.032073975, -0.03149414, -0.04562378, 0.039276123, 0.01322937, 0.02192688, 0.0035743713, 0.010643005, 0.013412476, 0.0637207, 0.014831543, 0.054260254, 0.009552002, -0.042877197, -0.0059814453, -0.0054473877, -0.006832123, 0.030731201, -0.018157959, -0.011642456, -0.043823242, -0.003528595, 0.030776978, -0.019989014, 0.033294678, -0.029830933, 0.034118652, -0.0078125, 0.011024475, 0.038848877, -0.013214111, -0.002286911, 0.0057678223, 0.01335144, -0.003025055, 0.005542755, -0.030563354, 0.0028953552, -0.02067566, 0.00069999695, 0.07678223, -0.031341553, -0.021728516, -0.01663208, 0.0914917, 0.03805542, 0.03475952, 0.0068893433, -0.020187378, -0.0020503998, -0.0042266846, -0.015304565, -0.013793945, 0.015640259, 0.009140015, -0.03567505, 0.013671875, 0.03881836, 0.0067214966, -0.014183044, 0.010437012, -0.025482178, -0.00089120865, 0.032592773, -0.0031261444, -0.018356323, -0.027572632, -0.04449463, 0.0129776, -0.010643005, 0.022262573, -0.016143799, 0.001121521, -0.02558899, -0.004398346, 0.016555786, -0.025650024, 0.054534912, -0.025360107, 0.028793335, -0.028533936, 0.004135132, -0.00969696, 0.021957397, -0.037017822, -0.00089120865, 0.019378662, -0.0040664673, -0.013290405, -0.015991211, -0.06262207, -0.028930664, -0.006362915, 0.0076942444, -0.008506775, -0.0023651123, 0.008178711, -0.027557373, 0.012756348, -0.033416748, -0.023040771, -0.01751709, -0.0064964294, -0.011955261, 0.004989624, -0.009750366, -0.009384155, 0.02003479, -0.029663086, -0.002418518, -0.034851074, 0.008850098, -0.023468018, 0.02330017, 0.002281189, 0.032165527, 0.03366089, -0.029418945, 0.006336212, 0.0048332214, -0.02923584, -0.008148193, -0.022262573, -0.046936035, 0.009002686, 0.040802002, -0.00054359436, -0.012763977, -0.014472961, 0.05734253, -0.06188965, -0.038635254, 0.006942749, 0.030975342, -0.008171082, 0.0289917, 0.036376953, -0.0026683807, 0.02557373, 0.033599854, -0.013038635, 0.012298584, -0.056121826, -0.07366943, 0.025497437, -0.0062026978, 0.02532959, -0.068603516, -0.013420105, 0.00030088425, -0.03265381, -0.029434204, -0.024749756, -0.023834229, 0.032440186, -0.048065186, 0.012840271, -0.0463562, -0.009307861, 0.012031555, -0.022521973, -0.07171631, -0.018005371, 0.037017822, 0.024902344, -0.03302002, 0.007789612, -0.007183075, 0.016677856, -0.009353638, 0.055755615, 0.027450562, 0.0036849976, -0.01625061, 0.05206299, 0.05908203, 0.04940796, 0.0011167526, 0.0033245087, 0.019546509, 0.03161621, -0.011520386, -0.03250122, 0.0418396, -0.0010919571, -0.016113281, -0.04055786, 0.027679443, -0.025558472, 0.013557434, 0.033721924, -0.017791748, 0.025131226, 0.03161621, 0.007457733, 0.023132324, -0.057769775, 0.036956787, 0.0178833, 0.010498047, -0.0048828125, -0.009788513, -0.007701874, 0.023513794, -0.014778137, 0.013763428, 0.05114746, 0.0129852295, 0.03579712, 0.0053596497, 0.022125244, -0.048706055, 0.014854431, -0.01423645, -0.029815674, 0.0068206787, 0.012397766, -0.009750366, -0.0010595322, 0.042266846, -0.003435135, -0.0012922287, 0.00028443336, -0.02545166, -0.00881958, -0.006263733, 0.0096588135, -0.0071792603, 0.011131287, -0.013648987, -0.017074585, -0.015640259, -0.013931274, -0.010612488, -0.017562866, 0.0158844, -0.0040245056, 0.009765625, -0.015464783, 0.008369446, 0.040130615, 0.0065956116, -0.0030536652, 0.06463623, 0.07354736, 0.0035171509, 0.017868042, -0.0047721863, -0.035949707, -0.051879883, 0.040649414, -0.01424408, -0.002588272, -0.045318604, 0.022644043, 0.050628662, -0.038604736, 0.080566406, -0.07513428, -0.017730713, -0.020767212, 0.031921387, 0.049591064, 0.0010843277, -0.0059509277, 0.026046753, 0.01939392, -0.0056152344, 0.013397217, -0.035736084, 0.1038208, -0.0073394775, 0.018707275, 0.024047852, 0.05618286, 0.009605408, -0.0335083, -0.06463623, -0.012794495, -0.016586304, -0.026824951, 0.00021529198, -0.0075416565, -0.04269409, -0.028305054, -0.023040771, 0.020568848, 0.022598267, -0.0079193115, 0.046081543, -0.026473999, 0.074523926, 0.033050537, -0.0056037903, -0.008430481, 0.071777344, -0.021759033, -0.020980835, -0.025619507, -0.011398315, 0.019577026, 0.0028629303, 0.018508911, 0.0058403015, -0.026824951, -0.014801025, 0.021316528, 0.002483368, 0.0055503845, 0.0041999817, 0.0048103333, 0.050048828, 0.0047187805, -0.010932922, 0.010009766, 0.04107666, 0.017105103, 0.0025119781, -0.0049858093, 0.0015354156, -0.04626465, -0.0051231384, -0.020065308, 0.008369446, 0.025146484, -0.054534912, -0.023040771, 0.020965576, 0.01612854, -0.00011485815, 0.01864624, -0.028518677, 0.041656494, -0.004463196, -0.052215576, -0.038513184, -0.007232666, 0.031707764, -0.011497498, 0.03277588, 0.018447876, 0.054718018, -0.02217102, 0.007293701, 0.09020996, -0.06707764, -0.021575928, 0.00074005127, -0.09442139, 0.014778137, -0.016021729, -0.0074768066, 0.09765625, -0.01096344, -0.022247314, 0.014144897, -0.03488159, 0.0028362274, 0.0075302124, -0.03463745, 0.00086307526, -0.06335449, 0.014198303, -0.02658081, 0.07525635, -0.002325058, -0.047546387, 0.010955811, -0.09423828, -0.029312134, -0.024261475, 0.008087158, -0.047821045, 0.0053901672, -0.0058250427, -0.02746582, -0.054016113, 0.0013446808, 0.010093689, -0.03112793, 0.0015048981, 0.019882202, -0.019088745, 0.017913818, 0.029571533, 0.0010700226, -0.017303467, -0.010246277, 0.022644043, -0.033966064, 0.035247803, 0.0057029724, 0.025772095, 0.0059394836, 0.0206604, 0.05419922, 0.006336212, -0.00043153763, 0.03579712, 0.034362793, -0.008430481, -0.03579712, 0.048431396, 0.022994995, -0.011123657, -0.00092840195, 0.051879883, 0.040039062, -0.013420105, 0.011100769, 0.0042800903, 0.015197754, -0.035064697, 0.012275696, 0.0014429092, 0.002149582, 0.01838684, -0.0007839203, 0.011398315, 0.02381897, -0.0027942657, 0.0141067505, -0.010856628, -0.02709961, 0.016189575, 0.026885986, -0.021820068, -0.04284668, -0.028198242, 0.044067383, -0.026138306, 0.037506104, -0.040985107, 0.056518555, -0.0011711121, 0.025543213, 0.024017334, -0.004714966, -0.045684814, -0.035064697, 0.00011354685, -0.048583984, -0.03540039, 0.014144897, 0.008003235, 0.009498596, -0.01763916, 0.015777588, 0.0034046173, 0.012374878, 0.036254883, 0.0317688, -0.019134521, -0.031829834, -0.030578613, -0.011756897, -0.029953003, -0.019454956, -0.0826416, -0.044006348, -0.020431519, 0.019897461, -0.046661377, 0.018127441, 0.025131226, 0.12695312, 0.032928467, 0.02407837, -0.06689453, 0.04827881, -0.052734375, 0.022964478, 0.018875122, -0.011207581, -0.016555786, -0.0064315796, 0.032073975, 0.009788513, -0.0435791, -0.03717041, 0.045410156, 0.017715454, 0.014427185, 0.0036182404, 0.057128906, 0.026763916, -0.009841919, -0.016571045, -0.0064697266, -0.015129089, 0.06311035, 0.0016965866, -0.0121536255, -0.010147095, -0.022232056, -0.02229309, 0.0047912598, 0.0073928833, 0.029312134, 0.0017662048, 0.02281189, -0.026107788, 0.007911682, 0.0021362305, -0.023498535, -0.023986816, 0.027252197, -0.006931305, 0.004878998, 0.043548584, 0.05105591, -0.026443481, -0.047790527, 0.0011501312, 0.006095886, -0.00051259995, -0.016067505, 0.0027828217, -0.044311523, -0.073791504, -0.034332275, 0.07873535, -0.022583008, -0.042541504, -0.0340271, -0.010986328, 0.013137817, 0.023162842, -0.024551392, -0.06439209, 0.08502197, -0.0065193176, -0.04083252, 0.015296936, -0.015426636, -0.04776001, -0.034576416, 0.0027942657, -0.03274536, 0.033294678, 0.03338623, -0.008224487, -0.019348145, 0.014602661, 0.008338928, -0.023269653, -0.04928589, 0.0033130646, -0.0007300377, -0.017684937, 0.008018494, 0.010368347, 0.011688232, 0.029205322, -0.014877319, 0.0024356842, 0.015266418, -0.024276733, 0.033416748, -0.009635925, 0.0063209534, 0.019973755, 0.016998291, 0.0036354065, 0.010116577, -0.018035889, 0.010269165, 0.016464233, -0.009147644, -0.027114868, 0.0029697418, 0.05090332, 0.008102417, -0.0016536713, 0.009124756, -0.0040893555, -0.06878662, -0.089660645, 0.013504028, -0.10699463, -0.023010254, -0.0011358261, -0.0032463074, -0.08746338, 0.008644104, -0.05682373, -0.015960693, -0.013801575, 0.049926758, -0.007785797, -0.011604309, 0.024856567, -0.0018196106, 0.035888672, 0.0070648193, 0.009529114, 0.021774292, -0.0014314651, -0.0065956116, 0.014053345, -0.0012311935, -0.0052452087, -0.04751587, -0.06341553, -0.06817627, 0.073791504, -0.02810669, -0.08453369, -0.047180176, 0.010101318, -0.005054474, -0.006160736, -0.02029419, -0.00056791306, -0.033294678, -0.06390381, 0.023269653, -0.011230469, 0.008293152, -0.006225586, -0.030166626, 0.020126343, 0.02053833, -0.018371582, -0.05480957, 0.042236328, -0.021911621, 0.019058228, -0.0035133362, -0.010429382, -0.0037078857, 0.0022029877, 0.011207581, -0.030731201, 0.007987976, -0.00095272064, 0.043029785, -0.018951416, 0.0513916, -0.030731201, 0.008705139, -0.06616211, -0.020507812, 0.014434814, 0.049865723, -0.022659302, -0.010009766, 0.0025577545, -0.026382446, 0.00983429, -0.018554688, 0.012199402, 0.005012512, -0.032989502, 0.065979004, -0.010643005, -0.024230957, -0.05987549, 0.012168884, 0.046417236, 0.064208984, 0.066467285, -0.017120361, 0.05883789, -0.011329651, -0.035217285, -0.025177002, 0.03161621, 0.023971558, 0.023010254, -0.0048713684, 0.028686523, -0.002122879, 0.0109939575, -0.0102005005, -0.02798462, -0.027130127, 0.037994385, 0.04333496, -0.018051147, -0.016235352, -0.026397705, 0.03955078, 0.0065307617, -0.042999268, -0.014205933, -0.008972168, 0.0077667236, -0.044036865, 0.0039787292, -0.033477783, 0.0012636185, 0.013969421, 0.0079956055, -0.045532227, 0.038391113, -0.019927979, -0.0018377304, 0.06616211, -0.04901123, 0.045196533, -0.05239868, -0.008239746, -0.022903442, -0.008888245, 0.021270752, -0.010810852, 0.025009155, 0.0070381165, 0.029968262, 0.0068359375, -0.000685215, 0.018554688, -0.038482666, 0.010871887, -0.02583313, 0.012176514, -0.010192871, 0.02986145, 0.021560669, 0.027999878, 0.01499176, 0.04421997, 0.003686905, 0.008338928, 0.048339844, -0.0025234222, -0.02848816, 0.060394287, 0.0051994324, 0.014328003, 0.06652832, 0.02418518, -0.05886841, 0.035247803, 0.029052734, 0.041137695, -0.045135498, 0.019714355, 0.027008057, -0.008918762, -0.03387451, -0.04360962, -0.05847168, -0.006816864, 0.018600464, -0.01838684, -0.020202637, -0.056243896, -0.0040397644, -0.0023555756, 0.019744873, 0.033325195, -0.044677734, 0.064941406, -0.05178833, 0.02659607, -0.030960083, 0.04928589, -0.0015592575, -0.021011353, 0.053894043, 0.00919342, -0.029678345, 0.021881104, 0.02230835, 0.006515503, 0.022506714, 0.019256592, -0.05014038, 0.004322052, 0.0053901672, -0.010421753, 0.07348633, -0.009788513, 0.0008535385, -0.013404846, -0.0035820007, 0.022018433, 0.007133484, 0.029037476, 0.020599365, -0.058044434, -0.025131226, -0.013313293, 0.010253906, 0.018447876, 0.0059547424, -0.07196045, -0.041015625, -0.028060913, 0.028671265, 0.06414795, -0.011039734, 0.080078125, 0.014373779, -0.09057617, 0.06341553, -0.024215698, -0.023834229, -0.004032135, -0.01348114, -0.026824951, -0.005367279, 0.033355713, 0.04736328, -0.043762207, -0.0042381287, 0.021835327, 0.033416748, 0.035095215, -0.027862549, 0.070373535, 0.012016296, -0.034698486, 0.037475586, 0.05303955, 0.011291504, 0.007858276, -0.03540039, 0.00459671, -0.024047852, -0.0030574799, 0.020523071, 0.0146865845, -0.05230713, 0.00014352798, -0.031311035, -0.019515991, -0.01625061, -0.027496338, 0.026733398, 0.01802063, -0.049560547, -0.034729004, -0.022064209, -0.009681702, -0.00919342, -0.0033683777, -0.02180481, 0.008033752, 0.0065078735, -0.04421997, -0.02178955, -0.011856079, 0.046051025, 0.0073623657, -0.04196167, -0.010627747, -0.024902344, 0.028961182, 0.000035464764, 0.008529663, -0.005203247, -0.001159668, 0.024658203, 0.05230713, -0.0015926361, -0.034973145, 0.017730713, -0.0014152527, -0.058135986, 0.00089502335, -0.04751587, 0.0043792725, -0.025405884, -0.016937256, 0.025558472, 0.008270264, -0.0027446747, -0.00007581711, -0.034210205, -0.0009598732, -0.02822876, -0.0060424805, -0.0154800415, -0.056884766, 0.014762878, 0.02130127, 0.005680084, -0.006374359, -0.014472961, 0.03010559, -0.0017871857, 0.022323608, -0.030975342, 0.0025177002, 0.041107178, 0.021606445, 0.06750488, -0.01374054, 0.016723633, 0.02746582, -0.0690918, -0.023757935, -0.083740234, -0.032928467, 0.007686615, 0.0048446655, 0.007411957, 0.06378174, -0.018371582, 0.017059326, 0.013221741, 0.07458496, -0.020080566, 0.03692627, 0.03289795, 0.019042969, 0.016311646 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1905.06987v1
Learning from Context: Exploiting and Interpreting File Path Information for Better Malware Detection
Adarsh Kyadige, Ethan M. Rudd, Konstantin Berlin
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Machine learning (ML) used for static portable executable (PE) malware detection typically employs per-file numerical feature vector representations as input with one or more target labels during training. However, there is much orthogonal information that can be gleaned from the \textit{context} in which the file was seen. In this paper, we propose utilizing a static source of contextual information -- the path of the PE file -- as an auxiliary input to the classifier. While file paths are not malicious or benign in and of themselves, they do provide valuable context for a malicious/benign determination. Unlike dynamic contextual information, file paths are available with little overhead and can seamlessly be integrated into a multi-view static ML detector, yielding higher detection rates at very high throughput with minimal infrastructural changes. Here we propose a multi-view neural network, which takes feature vectors from PE file content as well as corresponding file paths as inputs and outputs a detection score. To ensure realistic evaluation, we use a dataset of approximately 10 million samples -- files and file paths from user endpoints of an actual security vendor network. We then conduct an interpretability analysis via LIME modeling to ensure that our classifier has learned a sensible representation and see which parts of the file path most contributed to change in the classifier's score. We find that our model learns useful aspects of the file path for classification, while also learning artifacts from customers testing the vendor's product, e.g., by downloading a directory of malware samples each named as their hash. We prune these artifacts from our test dataset and demonstrate reductions in false negative rate of 32.3% at a $10^{-3}$ false positive rate (FPR) and 33.1% at $10^{-4}$ FPR, over a similar topology single input PE file content only model.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1905.06987v1
2019-05-16T18:36:55
2019-05-16T18:36:55
{ "title": [ -0.011512756, -0.011688232, -0.03805542, -0.051330566, 0.017730713, -0.02067566, -0.0033512115, 0.012870789, -0.027908325, 0.029922485, -0.034210205, 0.026733398, -0.0049552917, -0.00869751, -0.012084961, -0.01663208, -0.0050964355, 0.046569824, 0.009429932, -0.022842407, 0.0040779114, -0.02607727, 0.04940796, 0.004875183, 0.019561768, -0.038604736, -0.009422302, -0.010215759, -0.018936157, -0.040008545, -0.0071754456, 0.024108887, 0.045074463, 0.0065078735, -0.008300781, 0.014305115, -0.055755615, 0.025222778, -0.0067367554, -0.0013923645, 0.010223389, -0.002298355, 0.017807007, -0.006664276, -0.005874634, 0.042236328, -0.062683105, -0.037475586, -0.017868042, 0.042755127, 0.03137207, 0.013420105, 0.0061569214, 0.037139893, 0.0069999695, -0.053009033, -0.0435791, 0.03152466, 0.036468506, 0.062805176, 0.034606934, -0.031951904, -0.00034213066, -0.031097412, -0.009529114, -0.047302246, 0.0012073517, 0.04397583, 0.0158844, -0.0008916855, 0.010986328, 0.020202637, 0.0066719055, -0.018951416, -0.061584473, 0.031097412, 0.030975342, -0.013130188, 0.04067993, -0.053375244, -0.02041626, -0.022735596, -0.0014457703, 0.005138397, 0.013504028, 0.025344849, -0.020462036, -0.013069153, -0.023971558, -0.031188965, -0.0071983337, 0.016067505, 0.030822754, -0.0012493134, -0.05493164, -0.004535675, -0.011146545, 0.01259613, -0.005607605, -0.03970337, -0.030273438, 0.037261963, -0.0847168, 0.0032043457, 0.01448822, 0.03970337, 0.0070152283, -0.03274536, -0.020385742, -0.0045204163, -0.048980713, 0.0149383545, -0.004486084, -0.018188477, -0.027450562, 0.02909851, 0.013595581, -0.022369385, 0.026870728, -0.0095825195, 0.014312744, -0.018035889, 0.023666382, 0.016601562, 0.022506714, 0.0154953, -0.04751587, -0.013793945, -0.019210815, 0.06286621, 0.014709473, 0.025344849, -0.11328125, -0.07281494, -0.06951904, 0.024642944, 0.003850937, -0.001750946, -0.0047302246, 0.009597778, 0.009635925, -0.034301758, -0.007888794, 0.027328491, 0.008178711, -0.015792847, 0.051605225, 0.009094238, -0.03778076, 0.010444641, -0.031829834, 0.038604736, 0.008972168, 0.002254486, -0.031829834, 0.0028591156, -0.10437012, -0.016937256, 0.024230957, 0.010177612, 0.00806427, 0.008369446, 0.010910034, -0.012069702, 0.035461426, -0.008285522, -0.00818634, 0.02494812, 0.010375977, 0.012573242, -0.011550903, 0.0052948, -0.0141067505, -0.014541626, -0.010101318, 0.004070282, 0.043426514, 0.01927185, 0.014297485, 0.03439331, 0.03274536, -0.019256592, 0.04159546, 0.013069153, -0.06732178, -0.013710022, -0.000995636, -0.009338379, 0.060668945, -0.021774292, -0.010299683, 0.022216797, -0.043121338, -0.02909851, -0.027557373, 0.006378174, -0.0011768341, 0.03665161, -0.0131073, -0.0044670105, -0.024459839, 0.009246826, -0.037750244, 0.013015747, -0.017547607, -0.03152466, -0.008483887, 0.016403198, -0.006626129, 0.033416748, 0.0335083, 0.014266968, -0.024597168, -0.017349243, -0.022491455, -0.030715942, 0.0019550323, -0.00793457, -0.011741638, 0.002620697, -0.043548584, 0.0050582886, -0.014328003, 0.03164673, -0.00699234, 0.019622803, -0.0056533813, 0.0016021729, 0.031463623, 0.037719727, 0.088256836, -0.06774902, 0.04421997, 0.008613586, -0.013298035, -0.044555664, -0.03729248, -0.09490967, 0.009254456, 0.049743652, 0.0060157776, -0.011550903, -0.01927185, 0.0010633469, 0.060150146, -0.034240723, -0.010932922, 0.026062012, 0.012931824, 0.030654907, 0.016967773, 0.017349243, 0.04421997, 0.011756897, -0.007965088, 0.039031982, -0.0005698204, 0.02558899, -0.028442383, 0.008163452, 0.012489319, 0.046051025, 0.006855011, 0.03652954, -0.05505371, -0.014717102, -0.028778076, 0.0015163422, 0.0206604, -0.018096924, 0.030456543, -0.02709961, 0.0026359558, 0.008346558, 0.019836426, -0.023269653, -0.009552002, 0.008407593, 0.016433716, -0.04586792, -0.023635864, -0.036071777, 0.0075187683, -0.0009918213, 0.036468506, 0.015914917, 0.028839111, -0.035736084, -0.031280518, 0.001420021, 0.0395813, 0.06958008, 0.015129089, 0.0003323555, -0.020843506, 0.028182983, 0.14025879, 0.079833984, -0.041259766, 0.054534912, -0.05053711, 0.0073623657, 0.016662598, -0.041992188, -0.0014505386, 0.038085938, 0.023712158, 0.00969696, -0.028259277, 0.022338867, -0.05050659, -0.008918762, -0.0037612915, -0.030380249, -0.06524658, -0.06781006, -0.017990112, -0.05456543, -0.09259033, -0.018493652, 0.055877686, -0.04257202, -0.0057678223, -0.002363205, -0.017105103, -0.0135269165, -0.009994507, -0.02178955, -0.019348145, 0.028366089, 0.050201416, 0.037322998, -0.037963867, -0.008468628, 0.0037784576, 0.0061569214, -0.0061798096, 0.0038452148, -0.020080566, -0.0038700104, 0.0029964447, -0.015556335, 0.00289917, -0.04034424, -0.0046691895, -0.040161133, -0.0073661804, 0.033966064, -0.06842041, -0.024993896, 0.035003662, -0.032989502, -0.011108398, -0.006175995, 0.059417725, -0.003686905, -0.02911377, -0.009567261, 0.02722168, -0.04055786, 0.047973633, 0.028457642, 0.017623901, -0.009628296, -0.04953003, -0.055541992, 0.01499939, -0.0032672882, 0.009185791, 0.068237305, -0.032958984, -0.0032348633, -0.04324341, 0.00076007843, 0.024780273, 0.0051651, 0.031219482, -0.013656616, -0.03137207, -0.0043945312, 0.004196167, 0.008216858, -0.04196167, -0.00970459, 0.09020996, 0.01399231, 0.0013141632, 0.040496826, 0.016708374, -0.015014648, -0.020202637, 0.0013399124, -0.00422287, 0.007949829, 0.029388428, -0.0009303093, -0.011802673, 0.016616821, -0.10900879, -0.014572144, 0.009635925, 0.0023765564, -0.032073975, 0.020233154, -0.049682617, -0.015525818, -0.009674072, -0.035217285, 0.015434265, 0.044525146, 0.032318115, -0.0022354126, 0.027679443, 0.0017824173, 0.008232117, -0.046051025, -0.105163574, 0.020019531, -0.029251099, -0.013793945, -0.006313324, -0.017959595, -0.04421997, 0.0055274963, -0.011436462, 0.032928467, 0.05267334, 0.01574707, 0.015899658, 0.008056641, 0.02696228, -0.029678345, 0.004875183, -0.031311035, -0.06652832, -0.021911621, -0.011894226, 0.06378174, 0.035491943, -0.022262573, -0.01953125, 0.0064735413, 0.003967285, 0.039093018, 0.006626129, -0.040649414, -0.009994507, -0.014442444, 0.012031555, -0.0030708313, -0.015457153, 0.0010871887, -0.008613586, 0.00041365623, -0.01828003, 0.006515503, 0.013916016, 0.0007071495, -0.023254395, -0.015357971, 0.0039634705, -0.014129639, -0.053894043, -0.020874023, 0.019515991, -0.018356323, 0.045166016, -0.015235901, -0.027267456, 0.03149414, -0.017547607, 0.0011997223, 0.008407593, -0.014442444, 0.015823364, 0.015007019, -0.02923584, -0.010108948, -0.015670776, 0.015510559, 0.004508972, 0.0047798157, 0.001253128, -0.049957275, 0.011352539, 0.0008511543, -0.08886719, -0.020385742, 0.021102905, -0.03363037, -0.014038086, -0.050445557, 0.031433105, -0.023712158, -0.02633667, 0.004890442, -0.01713562, -0.014297485, -0.014572144, -0.06561279, -0.012557983, 0.063964844, -0.0038166046, 0.029876709, 0.02142334, -0.0043411255, -0.033172607, -0.028778076, 0.020874023, -0.0071411133, -0.004749298, -0.0121154785, -0.01953125, 0.04446411, -0.038360596, 0.0211792, 0.01071167, 0.0004761219, -0.0030994415, 0.015090942, -0.0059280396, 0.027648926, -0.037231445, 0.04638672, 0.016998291, -0.033172607, -0.062805176, 0.03125, -0.0077171326, -0.021438599, 0.00052547455, -0.0030765533, -0.0057373047, 0.0073547363, 0.037078857, 0.04650879, -0.00026726723, -0.0044288635, 0.00097465515, -0.0027751923, -0.022033691, -0.017333984, 0.033111572, 0.01914978, -0.018920898, 0.03164673, -0.020721436, 0.018463135, -0.0018854141, -0.059051514, 0.016845703, 0.035949707, -0.027420044, -0.0019817352, -0.058929443, -0.0015869141, -0.021194458, 0.020568848, -0.022903442, 0.024520874, 0.033843994, -0.0009522438, -0.019378662, 0.0044174194, 0.050231934, -0.0024032593, 0.0076522827, -0.062316895, -0.03604126, 0.008308411, -0.06591797, -0.021865845, -0.042999268, -0.033355713, 0.027236938, -0.008659363, -0.030197144, 0.015296936, 0.032592773, 0.10266113, 0.04458618, 0.002412796, -0.07757568, 0.04019165, -0.019683838, -0.024505615, 0.02619934, -0.007286072, -0.0033569336, -0.005645752, 0.031036377, -0.029327393, -0.012413025, -0.013931274, 0.025863647, -0.029541016, 0.054901123, -0.003320694, 0.066589355, 0.022994995, -0.020431519, 0.012969971, -0.0049476624, -0.031158447, 0.023529053, 0.027664185, 0.04458618, -0.06097412, 0.01675415, 0.044647217, 0.01411438, 0.0115356445, -0.019989014, -0.000202775, 0.0059814453, -0.0073280334, -0.0066108704, 0.03100586, -0.03643799, -0.03869629, -0.009918213, 0.023101807, 0.0335083, -0.050598145, 0.018295288, -0.0068092346, 0.025665283, 0.042266846, -0.0057525635, 0.02041626, -0.004600525, 0.015075684, -0.049835205, -0.043762207, 0.009216309, 0.047912598, -0.026397705, -0.002822876, -0.01965332, -0.004173279, 0.029769897, 0.043548584, 0.03665161, 0.01828003, -0.019500732, 0.009246826, 0.023117065, -0.029541016, -0.04699707, -0.009490967, 0.0063552856, 0.018127441, -0.022033691, 0.027145386, -0.056640625, 0.0042266846, 0.012138367, -0.0113220215, -0.009597778, -0.08300781, 0.017562866, 0.028884888, -0.011039734, 0.007911682, -0.01008606, 0.04058838, 0.038330078, 0.04421997, 0.014465332, 0.0023040771, 0.0309906, 0.0051727295, 0.0031986237, 0.009864807, -0.00039958954, 0.021438599, 0.04269409, 0.0085372925, -0.0059661865, -0.019973755, 0.033477783, 0.029220581, -0.012268066, 0.0047798157, -0.04522705, 0.01902771, -0.0029678345, 0.00381279, 0.027450562, -0.026367188, -0.017837524, -0.0014686584, -0.011764526, -0.0077552795, 0.011238098, 0.0046653748, -0.04208374, -0.056762695, -0.0013332367, -0.0067253113, -0.0030574799, -0.012039185, 0.028015137, -0.033599854, 0.020050049, 0.060180664, -0.023727417, 0.024871826, -0.02809143, 0.0025844574, 0.053466797, 0.041534424, -0.018844604, -0.00030112267, -0.01751709, -0.04208374, -0.051086426, 0.008720398, -0.010772705, 0.009353638, -0.016677856, -0.012573242, 0.015975952, 0.00058698654, 0.020889282, 0.021896362, -0.034179688, 0.02104187, 0.012031555, -0.0005669594, 0.02406311, 0.026550293, -0.018722534, 0.022842407, 0.014060974, -0.020980835, 0.022155762, -0.009925842, -0.0031414032, -0.0012712479, -0.070373535, 0.0124435425, 0.009819031, 0.0082092285, 0.0067481995, 0.0029354095, 0.028884888, 0.026428223, 0.020355225, 0.015007019, 0.072509766, -0.03125, 0.0034770966, 0.011260986, 0.014305115, 0.0105896, 0.08337402, -0.014968872, -0.006526947, -0.06414795, -0.05697632, -0.027816772, 0.007282257, -0.00030183792, 0.014213562, -0.003692627, -0.0143966675, 0.051727295, -0.04107666, -0.0129470825, -0.04360962, 0.025115967, -0.014022827, -0.013435364, 0.017044067, -0.0181427, 0.024383545, -0.043914795, 0.028900146, -0.009902954, -0.0002142191, -0.0124053955, -0.022354126, 0.018127441, -0.03579712, -0.017669678, 0.016967773, 0.025817871, -0.039916992, 0.020187378, -0.014427185, 0.051727295, 0.048431396, 0.055786133, 0.045959473, -0.00035309792, 0.03149414, 0.016067505, -0.010017395, -0.029403687, 0.038208008, -0.05331421, 0.017562866, -0.058013916, -0.022476196, -0.083496094, -0.0017127991, 0.027450562, 0.036132812, 0.009635925, 0.0055618286, 0.021102905, 0.014884949, 0.03982544, -0.015205383, 0.057891846, 0.028945923, 0.0009880066, -0.006095886, -0.030685425, 0.035308838, 0.04159546, 0.0024108887, 0.016525269, -0.0022907257, -0.019989014, -0.010734558, 0.0158844, 0.029693604, -0.04067993, -0.0101623535, -0.029571533, 0.05239868, 0.0082473755, 0.024780273, 0.06097412, 0.06518555, 0.00881958, -0.038391113, 0.01777649, -0.01953125, -0.0039482117, -0.015975952, 0.021774292, -0.028121948, 0.040893555, -0.014328003, -0.029296875, -0.03466797, 0.03652954, 0.026550293, -0.045928955, -0.023513794, 0.057403564, 0.02281189, -0.012168884, 0.016937256, -0.025756836, -0.031234741, -0.0184021, 0.03463745, -0.0025672913, 0.039031982, -0.0048065186, 0.016647339, 0.011306763, -0.003665924, -0.0065956116, 0.05041504, -0.011100769, 0.036499023, -0.033996582, 0.012542725, -0.030731201, -0.043792725, 0.01701355, -0.012680054, -0.0054016113, -0.044433594, 0.055999756, 0.040252686, 0.03048706, 0.07495117, 0.022903442, -0.011016846, -0.0028915405, -0.011711121, 0.018829346, 0.03942871, -0.015525818, 0.0357666, -0.026123047, -0.036193848, 0.060546875, -0.037200928, 0.07952881, -0.032348633, 0.026992798, -0.005756378, -0.010856628, 0.04135132, -0.05795288, 0.0027866364, 0.0011072159, 0.009376526, -0.03363037, -0.046936035, -0.02204895, -0.039794922, -0.015792847, 0.07067871, 0.011360168, 0.018997192, 0.006504059, -0.032287598, -0.024414062, 0.023742676, -0.016403198, 0.062561035, -0.046691895, -0.016220093, -0.022003174, -0.011657715, 0.0066184998, -0.0013284683, -0.009651184, -0.015899658, -0.04434204, -0.020202637, -0.0024738312, 0.005001068, -0.028549194, -0.019958496, -0.03616333, 0.03152466, -0.03274536, 0.005718231, 0.048950195, -0.02961731, -0.05227661, -0.00038337708, -0.023223877, 0.04348755, 0.026519775, -0.0077209473, 0.0009202957, 0.028778076, -0.023757935, 0.019943237, 0.027297974, 0.06036377, -0.018478394, -0.04159546, 0.02104187, 0.041625977, 0.07946777, -0.032073975, 0.009857178, 0.00025629997, -0.0043640137, -0.03149414, 0.08935547, 0.006099701, 0.026367188, 0.01586914, 0.096191406, 0.0231781, -0.07348633, -0.055389404, -0.04815674, 0.036743164, 0.042175293, -0.0034980774, -0.020950317, 0.046417236, -0.008163452, 0.00982666, -0.029846191, 0.0017910004, 0.015098572, -0.009757996, 0.05102539, -0.0054397583, 0.013496399, -0.05883789, 0.08380127, -0.004966736, 0.05984497, -0.01210022, 0.040252686, 0.06008911, 0.0385437, 0.0026283264, -0.031829834, 0.008056641, 0.02041626, 0.015731812, 0.0340271, -0.040405273, -0.031204224, 0.011741638, -0.0040016174, -0.015701294, 0.010322571, 0.03604126, -0.036132812, -0.01876831, -0.040252686, -0.02368164, 0.0022678375, -0.009963989, 0.03765869, -0.023864746, -0.017791748, -0.017532349, -0.039886475, -0.017807007, 0.03778076, -0.01058197, -0.0418396, -0.03869629, -0.0020217896, 0.065979004, -0.018188477 ], "summary": [ 0.031951904, -0.0036354065, 0.005710602, -0.007461548, -0.031311035, -0.01576233, -0.016799927, -0.034698486, -0.033172607, 0.01776123, -0.034729004, 0.027557373, -0.033996582, -0.03048706, 0.042114258, -0.04800415, -0.014442444, 0.07342529, 0.049957275, -0.00031232834, 0.0010519028, -0.00617218, 0.0069999695, -0.042022705, 0.0042304993, -0.030075073, 0.02456665, 0.013450623, 0.000048816204, -0.0064353943, 0.00920105, 0.020629883, 0.0134887695, -0.010971069, 0.033935547, 0.017593384, 0.01096344, 0.009719849, 0.045318604, -0.012077332, 0.019561768, -0.0005865097, 0.079833984, -0.022827148, 0.006969452, 0.06161499, -0.027130127, -0.044952393, 0.023239136, 0.03955078, 0.007896423, -0.030639648, -0.0017232895, -0.016799927, -0.007789612, -0.049591064, -0.060821533, -0.00459671, 0.0067481995, 0.09991455, 0.058624268, 0.0005722046, -0.04055786, -0.04849243, 0.016555786, -0.018676758, -0.0075645447, 0.02798462, 0.006904602, -0.0099105835, 0.017471313, -0.005531311, -0.005104065, -0.06524658, -0.03842163, 0.07574463, -0.003868103, -0.017807007, 0.0018701553, -0.041503906, -0.04083252, 0.025024414, -0.05279541, -0.037200928, 0.006843567, -0.0011835098, -0.028198242, -0.010261536, -0.016174316, -0.020690918, -0.027053833, -0.00065755844, 0.00434494, 0.012268066, -0.025894165, -0.011146545, 0.001162529, -0.019012451, 0.023498535, -0.029052734, 0.013450623, -0.021697998, -0.044158936, 0.013648987, 0.0073890686, 0.023590088, 0.04598999, -0.03652954, -0.015899658, -0.030654907, -0.044555664, 0.011138916, -0.008415222, -0.041534424, -0.027999878, 0.05319214, 0.01864624, -0.020339966, 0.0027332306, -0.027908325, -0.004714966, 0.011550903, 0.01474762, 0.03213501, 0.01939392, 0.034698486, -0.003118515, -0.018737793, -0.07348633, 0.054992676, 0.030731201, -0.0079422, -0.06665039, 0.03149414, -0.04534912, -0.013656616, 0.019226074, -0.010269165, 0.008613586, -0.01626587, 0.040985107, -0.02368164, -0.031433105, 0.04348755, 0.02104187, 0.010414124, 0.029312134, 0.026016235, -0.018005371, 0.018035889, 0.010925293, 0.022125244, 0.030960083, -0.01626587, -0.0099105835, -0.04953003, -0.016738892, -0.023986816, 0.024887085, -0.021499634, 0.018981934, 0.000017940998, 0.012992859, 0.015052795, 0.01727295, -0.01675415, -0.004611969, -0.00060653687, 0.0077934265, -0.013465881, 0.002609253, 0.026382446, -0.014213562, -0.005130768, 0.019729614, -0.006324768, 0.0029296875, 0.0546875, -0.0021095276, 0.0038661957, 0.023422241, -0.031677246, 0.042419434, -0.00013768673, -0.06311035, 0.01689148, -0.010635376, 0.032165527, 0.056427002, -0.016342163, 0.038269043, -0.019622803, -0.019485474, -0.01876831, 0.0335083, 0.011871338, -0.051635742, -0.007949829, 0.0024681091, -0.02015686, 0.03878784, -0.008392334, -0.015258789, -0.0009031296, -0.016189575, -0.035217285, 0.0075645447, -0.013008118, -0.025115967, 0.018432617, 0.017730713, -0.00029706955, -0.035064697, -0.0026435852, -0.008216858, -0.0395813, 0.011077881, -0.016967773, 0.001036644, 0.00459671, -0.024108887, 0.012535095, -0.050231934, 0.023895264, -0.039215088, 0.038146973, -0.017486572, 0.05279541, 0.060333252, 0.01739502, 0.15478516, -0.06536865, 0.015731812, 0.007675171, -0.004257202, -0.029403687, 0.0024929047, -0.14013672, 0.01386261, 0.07305908, 0.03012085, 0.02784729, -0.04623413, -0.037200928, 0.05255127, -0.03564453, -0.015640259, -0.004009247, -0.026443481, -0.0109939575, 0.01737976, -0.018051147, 0.019714355, -0.04876709, 0.008178711, 0.010612488, 0.025772095, -0.0052375793, -0.02482605, 0.034423828, 0.016036987, 0.07421875, 0.0045814514, 0.048339844, -0.029006958, -0.048461914, -0.010559082, -0.017150879, 0.02406311, -0.06048584, 0.018035889, -0.016433716, 0.0023097992, -0.0062828064, -0.007369995, -0.03475952, -0.0028324127, -0.009490967, 0.022872925, -0.03515625, -0.019989014, -0.03274536, 0.011077881, -0.0014286041, 0.035064697, 0.007583618, 0.02947998, -0.012649536, -0.02418518, 0.0423584, 0.018707275, 0.07965088, 0.034240723, -0.0124053955, 0.030288696, 0.034088135, 0.0619812, 0.0035953522, -0.0026741028, -0.033416748, 0.005340576, 0.022064209, -0.05239868, -0.0032920837, -0.001461029, 0.048919678, 0.029403687, -0.013366699, -0.00054073334, 0.0059013367, -0.04397583, -0.017303467, 0.0074272156, 0.013847351, -0.06762695, -0.046142578, -0.03729248, 0.010566711, -0.07745361, 0.009849548, 0.089660645, -0.009185791, 0.033935547, 0.012649536, 0.0025634766, -0.045928955, 0.03616333, -0.007331848, -0.028121948, 0.018722534, 0.008399963, 0.019165039, -0.02407837, 0.033111572, 0.010177612, 0.0031757355, 0.015609741, 0.025878906, 0.025405884, -0.006412506, 0.05126953, -0.009315491, -0.015068054, 0.016235352, -0.064208984, -0.012802124, -0.018127441, 0.011726379, -0.085632324, -0.059631348, 0.09069824, -0.031921387, -0.015701294, -0.001657486, 0.0034809113, 0.008995056, 0.018066406, -0.011810303, -0.011352539, -0.045013428, 0.024124146, 0.06072998, 0.03125, -0.029266357, -0.08239746, -0.041656494, 0.031082153, 0.026504517, 0.034973145, 0.0395813, 0.026367188, 0.05404663, -0.083984375, -0.022262573, -0.030441284, -0.019729614, 0.054473877, -0.0020942688, -0.010299683, 0.020935059, 0.030212402, 0.018127441, 0.0009889603, -0.028244019, 0.07611084, 0.012504578, 0.038757324, 0.09844971, 0.018676758, -0.044830322, -0.023910522, 0.03427124, -0.00050497055, -0.016220093, 0.01576233, 0.0049057007, 0.015731812, 0.0006918907, -0.019607544, -0.04385376, -0.01828003, 0.013694763, -0.00944519, 0.00945282, -0.021499634, -0.0020313263, -0.00039315224, -0.031173706, 0.0034751892, 0.021865845, 0.053955078, -0.013404846, 0.044769287, 0.008003235, 0.0017299652, -0.0524292, 0.02558899, 0.012916565, 0.012031555, -0.018112183, -0.015457153, 0.06451416, -0.048065186, -0.017684937, -0.026626587, 0.014266968, 0.008987427, 0.011505127, 0.006450653, 0.03842163, 0.00554657, 0.00081443787, 0.00642395, -0.024459839, -0.060943604, -0.032318115, -0.006717682, -0.0041160583, 0.032165527, -0.05203247, -0.0010175705, 0.017181396, 0.033233643, 0.048950195, 0.02331543, -0.017532349, -0.0020523071, 0.0067710876, 0.0044403076, -0.016067505, -0.014099121, 0.012229919, 0.049438477, 0.027313232, -0.007572174, -0.008613586, -0.0007710457, 0.008003235, 0.009628296, -0.016723633, -0.0031967163, 0.007949829, -0.07598877, -0.027801514, 0.01360321, 0.0022792816, 0.03225708, 0.014389038, -0.029937744, 0.041290283, 0.020446777, -0.05078125, -0.004928589, -0.008529663, 0.014228821, -0.027496338, -0.00970459, -0.0014715195, 0.016189575, 0.012420654, -0.03527832, 0.01436615, -0.052215576, -0.026931763, 0.007408142, 0.005619049, -0.026733398, -0.009941101, 0.0011062622, 0.023406982, -0.0067367554, -0.014778137, 0.016586304, 0.02645874, -0.001698494, 0.012374878, -0.008125305, 0.014846802, -0.04559326, -0.052642822, -0.030090332, -0.031829834, -0.0019245148, 0.052001953, -0.078125, 0.0052337646, -0.023117065, -0.009971619, 0.021102905, -0.099243164, -0.036987305, -0.042266846, -0.01638794, 0.035491943, -0.044708252, 0.017791748, -0.02128601, -0.005756378, -0.020614624, 0.021011353, 0.023544312, 0.06121826, -0.047058105, 0.015151978, 0.02911377, -0.010444641, -0.059326172, 0.019058228, 0.01939392, -0.03564453, -0.009132385, 0.006259918, -0.009788513, 0.05722046, 0.017364502, -0.0034122467, -0.012382507, -0.060638428, -0.015686035, 0.042510986, -0.016448975, 0.0032253265, 0.027786255, 0.044158936, -0.025558472, 0.04434204, -0.026031494, -0.0043411255, 0.018066406, -0.05899048, 0.0050811768, 0.03768921, -0.0058670044, -0.017944336, -0.020889282, 0.012557983, -0.007671356, 0.011489868, -0.021728516, -0.0068359375, 0.014007568, 0.029586792, 0.004558563, -0.04574585, 0.04449463, 0.03237915, -0.045562744, -0.06939697, -0.03302002, 0.0051879883, -0.031280518, -0.008285522, -0.04043579, -0.05340576, -0.014427185, -0.023788452, -0.0063705444, 0.020126343, 0.04397583, 0.08746338, 0.04727173, -0.0058517456, -0.093444824, 0.0052719116, -0.044067383, 0.021362305, -0.008865356, -0.00554657, -0.026412964, 0.0029506683, 0.017715454, 0.0047721863, -0.012298584, -0.026443481, 0.009284973, -0.009475708, 0.019378662, 0.020004272, 0.042388916, 0.01828003, -0.036865234, 0.043945312, -0.013412476, -0.021911621, 0.03540039, 0.074523926, 0.03387451, -0.039276123, -0.014297485, 0.0118637085, 0.012306213, -0.014633179, -0.008865356, 0.012046814, -0.0013837814, -0.007648468, -0.019882202, 0.004085541, 0.025558472, 0.0018939972, 0.030471802, -0.005405426, 0.002368927, 0.022155762, -0.045715332, 0.058258057, 0.019165039, 0.05886841, -0.010147095, -0.0005879402, 0.047546387, -0.017715454, -0.028900146, -0.032928467, -0.0019607544, 0.051940918, -0.017242432, -0.0154418945, -0.066101074, -0.053955078, 0.019836426, 0.048187256, 0.03338623, -0.0037326813, 0.041259766, 0.019546509, 0.015670776, -0.025238037, -0.0064735413, 0.00095033646, -0.0016269684, -0.0010681152, -0.040802002, -0.020935059, 0.05114746, 0.005859375, -0.002231598, 0.0074424744, -0.015068054, -0.046722412, -0.050476074, -0.029693604, -0.0013933182, -0.008331299, -0.007183075, 0.026901245, -0.0006928444, 0.008766174, 0.00053071976, -0.012268066, -0.012641907, 0.01802063, -0.020599365, 0.0028095245, -0.019042969, 0.04852295, 0.015655518, 0.014671326, -0.01637268, 0.0024223328, 0.0046958923, 0.020370483, -0.025741577, -0.026611328, -0.0042877197, 0.05883789, -0.010063171, -0.02230835, 0.0178833, -0.00015366077, 0.0030403137, 0.024719238, -0.00084877014, 0.00944519, 0.004611969, -0.015556335, -0.042541504, -0.0010404587, -0.020645142, 0.0073051453, 0.0019874573, 0.003932953, 0.00881958, -0.017303467, -0.015945435, 0.0095825195, -0.007106781, 0.019866943, -0.014915466, 0.006351471, -0.00016498566, 0.038146973, -0.043884277, -0.017959595, -0.025146484, 0.016860962, -0.003414154, -0.022354126, -0.0042419434, 0.027893066, -0.047790527, 0.013473511, 0.013122559, -0.046966553, 0.00038647652, 0.019943237, -0.05706787, -0.03173828, 0.004459381, -0.020706177, 0.019882202, -0.02357483, -0.046813965, 0.015350342, 0.018859863, -0.010536194, 0.04486084, -0.029586792, 0.03289795, 0.030670166, -0.034423828, 0.029052734, 0.036590576, 0.035095215, 0.015327454, -0.02180481, 0.0104904175, 0.04827881, 0.001209259, -0.004611969, 0.050994873, -0.0016498566, 0.01576233, -0.040771484, 0.024612427, 0.014282227, 0.06774902, -0.0859375, -0.015838623, -0.04260254, -0.064941406, -0.00258255, -0.018569946, 0.0033626556, 0.015357971, -0.00044584274, 0.005329132, 0.04360962, -0.011489868, -0.016586304, -0.03439331, 0.027801514, -0.018569946, -0.008125305, 0.017456055, -0.056121826, 0.0035572052, -0.008361816, -0.008033752, -0.0035057068, -0.0059051514, 0.027450562, -0.023361206, 0.009361267, -0.020004272, 0.07208252, 0.013381958, 0.03567505, -0.029434204, -0.031021118, 0.020233154, 0.042816162, 0.031036377, -0.02558899, 0.0138549805, -0.009666443, -0.006061554, 0.0074768066, -0.033599854, -0.010818481, 0.08557129, -0.0039405823, -0.024963379, -0.05303955, -0.05419922, -0.064819336, 0.023483276, 0.009063721, 0.006084442, -0.015602112, 0.00843811, -0.008407593, 0.023284912, -0.019073486, -0.014823914, 0.012794495, 0.0029659271, -0.011978149, 0.00983429, -0.030654907, 0.008155823, 0.047943115, 0.0206604, -0.0005350113, 0.004081726, 0.018478394, 0.0056877136, -0.014556885, -0.013954163, -0.055999756, 0.046295166, -0.032684326, 0.029678345, 0.032318115, 0.03491211, 0.0020313263, 0.008926392, 0.0418396, -0.04159546, 0.0032653809, 0.0056648254, 0.011138916, -0.034942627, -0.0031909943, 0.015396118, -0.01965332, -0.007820129, -0.0032138824, -0.022521973, 0.012245178, 0.05783081, -0.034088135, -0.01158905, 0.06378174, -0.0009365082, -0.032287598, 0.0060920715, -0.017868042, -0.024658203, -0.0181427, 0.0009508133, 0.02255249, 0.060333252, -0.0065994263, 0.0008254051, 0.072021484, 0.015670776, 0.008399963, 0.066101074, 0.040740967, 0.036743164, 0.009407043, -0.0062065125, 0.0058174133, -0.020050049, 0.023880005, 0.003856659, 0.03112793, 0.010398865, 0.04916382, 0.06878662, 0.03164673, 0.03665161, -0.058410645, 0.006061554, 0.04272461, 0.021377563, 0.03933716, -0.026748657, 0.002231598, -0.023727417, -0.004470825, 0.01109314, 0.025421143, 0.0051956177, 0.07366943, -0.013191223, 0.03567505, -0.010169983, -0.03866577, -0.02130127, -0.015350342, 0.06414795, -0.025527954, 0.045684814, -0.025115967, -0.019882202, -0.04458618, -0.015312195, -0.035064697, 0.040252686, -0.004837036, 0.00043416023, 0.015838623, -0.010520935, 0.00020229816, 0.0053977966, -0.010139465, 0.061828613, -0.04019165, -0.0029716492, 0.028152466, 0.024627686, 0.0043678284, -0.055267334, -0.018341064, 0.013206482, 0.008979797, -0.023986816, -0.014511108, -0.02658081, -0.03640747, -0.039215088, -0.02166748, 0.020385742, -0.034973145, 0.03744507, 0.031921387, 0.006828308, -0.08886719, -0.0056114197, -0.0022182465, 0.032470703, -0.004787445, 0.008087158, -0.021987915, 0.04067993, 0.0029411316, 0.008010864, 0.028289795, 0.03036499, -0.031555176, -0.023452759, 0.006385803, 0.03375244, 0.060668945, -0.014884949, 0.061309814, 0.017150879, 0.004585266, -0.02508545, 0.057861328, 0.0063972473, 0.026046753, 0.034454346, 0.08093262, 0.012084961, -0.040039062, -0.028137207, 0.021835327, 0.053710938, 0.02330017, -0.03050232, 0.017425537, 0.040039062, -0.044891357, -0.012130737, -0.041931152, 0.032958984, -0.018798828, -0.0029411316, 0.046966553, -0.019363403, 0.028137207, -0.05130005, 0.02268982, 0.0049972534, 0.01373291, -0.00068855286, 0.027267456, 0.010528564, 0.049438477, 0.018234253, 0.0093307495, -0.009796143, -0.0045433044, 0.034606934, -0.056396484, -0.0026435852, 0.0013103485, 0.0018644333, -0.00094890594, -0.0007739067, 0.01146698, 0.050872803, -0.048614502, -0.016601562, -0.05029297, -0.026916504, -0.046691895, -0.034729004, 0.0262146, -0.035125732, 0.014678955, 0.015701294, 0.003730774, 0.020095825, 0.010101318, -0.01701355, -0.013923645, 0.019332886, 0.05517578, -0.0023937225, 0.012237549 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1905.08352v2
Robust sound event detection in bioacoustic sensor networks
Vincent Lostanlen, Justin Salamon, Andrew Farnsworth, Steve Kelling, Juan Pablo Bello
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS
Bioacoustic sensors, sometimes known as autonomous recording units (ARUs), can record sounds of wildlife over long periods of time in scalable and minimally invasive ways. Deriving per-species abundance estimates from these sensors requires detection, classification, and quantification of animal vocalizations as individual acoustic events. Yet, variability in ambient noise, both over time and across sensors, hinders the reliability of current automated systems for sound event detection (SED), such as convolutional neural networks (CNN) in the time-frequency domain. In this article, we develop, benchmark, and combine several machine listening techniques to improve the generalizability of SED models across heterogeneous acoustic environments. As a case study, we consider the problem of detecting avian flight calls from a ten-hour recording of nocturnal bird migration, recorded by a network of six ARUs in the presence of heterogeneous background noise. Starting from a CNN yielding state-of-the-art accuracy on this task, we introduce two noise adaptation techniques, respectively integrating short-term (60 milliseconds) and long-term (30 minutes) context. First, we apply per-channel energy normalization (PCEN) in the time-frequency domain, which applies short-term automatic gain control to every subband in the mel-frequency spectrogram. Secondly, we replace the last dense layer in the network by a context-adaptive neural network (CA-NN) layer. Combining them yields state-of-the-art results that are unmatched by artificial data augmentation alone. We release a pre-trained version of our best performing system under the name of BirdVoxDetect, a ready-to-use detector of avian flight calls in field recordings.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1905.08352v2
2019-10-30T01:31:33
2019-05-20T21:25:48
{ "title": [ -0.022903442, 0.0079956055, -0.03390503, -0.021728516, 0.020111084, -0.0031318665, -0.017944336, -0.0413208, 0.011985779, 0.03152466, -0.0047836304, 0.014053345, 0.009590149, -0.029205322, -0.04031372, 0.010978699, -0.011375427, 0.021316528, 0.00020766258, -0.0335083, 0.022018433, -0.052520752, 0.048065186, 0.011756897, 0.020965576, 0.0011425018, -0.06896973, -0.0010719299, -0.02420044, -0.02267456, -0.01727295, 0.017562866, 0.05999756, 0.048309326, -0.0670166, 0.004688263, -0.06317139, 0.03527832, -0.01638794, 0.023132324, 0.029876709, -0.018981934, 0.015541077, -0.008956909, -0.000111579895, 0.025268555, -0.01576233, -0.030456543, -0.029968262, 0.020568848, 0.03515625, 0.02746582, 0.016113281, 0.00868988, 0.030181885, -0.013710022, -0.021743774, -0.0029087067, 0.038269043, 0.046875, 0.008544922, -0.036071777, 0.01638794, -0.007835388, -0.020202637, -0.013946533, 0.025665283, 0.028259277, 0.015083313, -0.032714844, -0.006214142, 0.00957489, -0.0017652512, 0.024459839, -0.01687622, -0.030532837, 0.05419922, 0.01008606, 0.02835083, -0.01084137, -0.0040016174, -0.025787354, 0.037963867, -0.016113281, 0.015289307, -0.027160645, -0.0009737015, 0.0024642944, -0.036499023, -0.03579712, -0.01612854, 0.0124053955, -0.0075950623, -0.008972168, -0.040863037, -0.009208679, 0.0008816719, 0.046539307, -0.022827148, -0.02746582, -0.015975952, 0.022354126, -0.0546875, -0.024337769, -0.0015792847, 0.03378296, -0.022109985, -0.059509277, -0.0039711, 0.03274536, -0.03213501, -0.023757935, -0.0070381165, -0.00004786253, -0.025039673, 0.03515625, 0.01374054, -0.029953003, 0.01386261, -0.0008955002, 0.0030384064, 0.0026283264, -0.0049324036, -0.013450623, 0.015434265, -0.015777588, -0.02545166, -0.009757996, -0.028900146, -0.0045204163, 0.029190063, 0.038330078, -0.09088135, -0.044006348, -0.066223145, 0.04244995, 0.03677368, 0.000620842, 0.009819031, -0.010269165, 0.022476196, -0.0027942657, 0.0007185936, 0.03125, 0.007331848, -0.031799316, 0.0647583, 0.034729004, -0.07092285, -0.0074539185, 0.009391785, 0.08258057, 0.03668213, -0.010559082, -0.05117798, -0.039794922, -0.09265137, -0.032196045, 0.030929565, -0.0335083, 0.01852417, 0.0032806396, -0.018692017, 0.01525116, 0.0039596558, 0.01222229, -0.012237549, 0.02684021, 0.007507324, 0.015548706, -0.0022258759, 0.03616333, 0.009811401, 0.007858276, 0.0071105957, -0.011047363, 0.030700684, 0.0059814453, 0.04824829, -0.015144348, -0.023345947, -0.020385742, 0.050354004, -0.0023097992, -0.06262207, -0.0124435425, 0.006462097, 0.021972656, 0.042419434, 0.00623703, -0.013084412, 0.0345459, -0.023086548, -0.032165527, -0.0592041, -0.018737793, 0.022644043, 0.023651123, -0.030761719, 0.032348633, -0.06768799, 0.030456543, -0.04888916, 0.04660034, 0.005657196, -0.008972168, 0.0042419434, 0.029388428, 0.009849548, 0.042266846, 0.036193848, 0.016647339, -0.011619568, -0.06121826, -0.030441284, 0.00012493134, -0.008392334, -0.0063095093, -0.032073975, 0.005958557, -0.062805176, -0.0021762848, -0.022598267, 0.030212402, 0.014572144, -0.006591797, 0.0101623535, -0.030426025, 0.040283203, 0.008705139, 0.0769043, -0.04168701, 0.001159668, -0.014556885, 0.008361816, -0.006980896, -0.0011758804, -0.014892578, 0.022842407, 0.0072021484, -0.008804321, -0.028793335, -0.01953125, 0.029159546, -0.002653122, -0.032928467, 0.0074920654, 0.02029419, 0.017593384, 0.017044067, 0.028823853, -0.011642456, 0.042297363, -0.019241333, 0.0006289482, 0.039031982, -0.0028896332, 0.008972168, -0.02558899, 0.0033035278, 0.016113281, -0.0026340485, 0.00077724457, -0.006416321, -0.03074646, -0.019073486, -0.017105103, -0.008110046, 0.013442993, 0.023162842, 0.012931824, -0.059387207, 0.0071792603, 0.024398804, -0.004863739, 0.004173279, -0.015045166, 0.007659912, 0.01033783, -0.037963867, -0.033355713, -0.00504303, 0.007331848, -0.004886627, 0.0074424744, -0.029785156, 0.03237915, -0.035705566, -0.013404846, -0.0231781, 0.035461426, 0.04776001, 0.020507812, -0.003528595, -0.011253357, -0.0041046143, 0.034423828, 0.085754395, -0.041290283, 0.03656006, -0.07397461, -0.009552002, 0.03881836, -0.03591919, -0.0030994415, -0.018447876, 0.0007791519, 0.03262329, -0.025024414, -0.011695862, -0.03503418, 0.026672363, 0.009086609, -0.041870117, -0.02619934, -0.040802002, 0.0008740425, -0.039215088, -0.015640259, 0.03390503, 0.03805542, -0.005744934, 0.004425049, -0.017501831, -0.0032310486, -0.025970459, -0.044525146, -0.018814087, -0.029891968, 0.02720642, 0.05404663, 0.033599854, -0.018692017, 0.0184021, 0.006690979, 0.00995636, -0.000808239, -0.012573242, -0.025634766, 0.014678955, 0.023880005, -0.013053894, 0.014198303, -0.007396698, 0.013427734, -0.043395996, 0.011619568, 0.008041382, -0.036621094, 0.018188477, 0.011306763, -0.029785156, -0.021347046, 0.013938904, 0.0579834, -0.0053253174, -0.02319336, 0.037597656, 0.03527832, -0.014007568, 0.044189453, 0.026794434, 0.009246826, -0.068359375, -0.026428223, -0.050231934, 0.00038981438, -0.027954102, -0.007545471, 0.055145264, -0.0692749, -0.024459839, 0.003993988, 0.007461548, 0.02519226, 0.030166626, -0.022140503, -0.04660034, -0.0068092346, -0.042510986, -0.009887695, -0.009010315, -0.018310547, -0.0034866333, 0.10333252, 0.0053215027, 0.04824829, 0.025650024, 0.045288086, -0.018966675, -0.029510498, -0.03366089, -0.06341553, -0.017654419, -0.0009255409, 0.025421143, 0.0118637085, -0.046875, -0.042175293, -0.019134521, 0.079711914, 0.016159058, -0.018432617, 0.031234741, -0.042816162, -0.00868988, 0.028549194, -0.005001068, 0.01676941, 0.037628174, 0.008270264, -0.002445221, 0.0060195923, -0.016311646, 0.03781128, -0.047607422, -0.028213501, 0.038269043, 0.011177063, -0.07470703, -0.02180481, -0.031311035, -0.025985718, -0.01727295, 0.020462036, 0.013755798, 0.020614624, -0.0368042, 0.0065193176, 0.0030899048, -0.016403198, -0.009208679, 0.008010864, 0.0059318542, -0.021713257, 0.010276794, -0.021560669, 0.00983429, 0.017211914, -0.02746582, -0.02166748, -0.009529114, 0.011489868, 0.03805542, 0.012687683, -0.042144775, -0.0008711815, -0.00028038025, -0.038146973, 0.0052986145, -0.03668213, -0.0019874573, -0.019226074, 0.018112183, 0.0011510849, 0.020080566, 0.023605347, -0.0042762756, -0.022964478, -0.029830933, -0.0077171326, -0.02583313, -0.049438477, -0.023422241, 0.012580872, -0.029296875, -0.010948181, -0.007972717, -0.037261963, 0.013938904, -0.014831543, 0.061645508, 0.002298355, -0.020401001, 0.022155762, 0.017059326, -0.028656006, -0.030700684, 0.0011749268, 0.0036029816, 0.007083893, 0.0015459061, -0.037750244, -0.03274536, -0.01071167, -0.0039100647, -0.087646484, -0.0033359528, 0.00856781, -0.06707764, -0.013801575, -0.07763672, -0.000161767, -0.025115967, -0.052764893, -0.0035114288, -0.015266418, -0.028320312, -0.0031738281, -0.05984497, -0.021591187, 0.07232666, -0.0001308918, 0.01965332, 0.020828247, 0.0069389343, -0.0073051453, -0.020599365, 0.007621765, -0.025421143, 0.027114868, -0.023742676, 0.015617371, 0.054473877, -0.02798462, 0.0082092285, 0.023269653, 0.0096206665, -0.0026016235, -0.008995056, 0.04156494, 0.04006958, 0.024520874, 0.062805176, -0.02722168, -0.023361206, -0.028213501, -0.031082153, -0.012664795, -0.005302429, -0.0027046204, -0.022277832, 0.025558472, 0.011634827, 0.026306152, 0.06225586, 0.001458168, 0.015365601, 0.0031375885, -0.056732178, -0.009300232, 0.012870789, 0.03479004, -0.025177002, -0.0054893494, 0.034118652, -0.024963379, 0.054870605, -0.024414062, -0.015365601, 0.020431519, 0.0362854, -0.01235199, -0.0107421875, -0.060821533, -0.055664062, -0.035491943, 0.017288208, -0.008140564, 0.012886047, 0.019210815, 0.016494751, -0.043640137, 0.008857727, 0.0713501, -0.000096559525, 0.022018433, -0.025604248, 0.028671265, 0.01197052, -0.03778076, -0.027145386, 0.022613525, 0.007762909, 0.05380249, -0.03201294, -0.047821045, -0.0040740967, 0.018371582, 0.09918213, 0.061523438, -0.027450562, -0.10699463, -0.034240723, -0.035491943, -0.02709961, 0.032440186, 0.023620605, -0.0005207062, -0.022247314, 0.044647217, -0.026977539, -0.013931274, 0.025054932, 0.024978638, -0.034210205, 0.04537964, -0.040893555, 0.044677734, 0.007068634, -0.02720642, 0.011695862, 0.0116119385, -0.05065918, 0.034240723, -0.008560181, 0.020721436, -0.041503906, 0.026550293, 0.0647583, 0.002204895, -0.008850098, 0.018218994, 0.000042557716, 0.06402588, -0.015083313, 0.0033283234, 0.00831604, -0.068603516, -0.030685425, 0.0017728806, 0.010025024, 0.068725586, -0.021224976, 0.07611084, 0.012336731, 0.007423401, 0.043426514, 0.010314941, -0.0047073364, -0.036621094, -0.005432129, -0.08654785, -0.07574463, -0.015686035, 0.09362793, -0.04095459, -0.020462036, 0.0010414124, 0.052001953, 0.016571045, 0.017486572, 0.0041503906, 0.06011963, -0.053497314, -0.020187378, 0.0046195984, -0.045135498, -0.040985107, 0.004714966, 0.034118652, 0.007801056, -0.025909424, 0.009719849, -0.06524658, -0.014343262, -0.008255005, 0.010002136, -0.0023956299, -0.06210327, 0.007633209, 0.03390503, 0.046173096, -0.016799927, -0.013038635, 0.019927979, 0.01020813, 0.035461426, 0.007965088, 0.022445679, 0.03543091, -0.07672119, 0.028533936, 0.011871338, 0.019256592, 0.012878418, -0.0059051514, 0.0023326874, -0.015548706, -0.008300781, 0.015205383, 0.042388916, 0.06854248, -0.005947113, -0.04309082, 0.0065307617, 0.0073051453, -0.0009832382, 0.028152466, 0.00012946129, -0.033477783, -0.0044517517, 0.029052734, -0.028289795, -0.018127441, 0.031021118, -0.030792236, -0.04333496, -0.00013959408, -0.029144287, -0.006439209, 0.000097215176, 0.0012512207, -0.020004272, 0.019332886, 0.036712646, -0.066589355, 0.02885437, -0.006843567, 0.0031013489, 0.057556152, 0.019226074, -0.006252289, -0.007598877, 0.047546387, -0.048736572, -0.021728516, 0.023895264, -0.008621216, -0.03994751, -0.0048103333, -0.044921875, 0.00687027, 0.027832031, 0.028076172, 0.015960693, -0.017440796, 0.046844482, 0.016204834, 0.021850586, -0.00223732, -0.00071525574, 0.027450562, -0.009750366, -0.010360718, -0.058380127, 0.025939941, 0.009429932, 0.024398804, 0.0020217896, -0.07727051, 0.02230835, 0.017745972, 0.00630188, -0.0049095154, 0.014556885, 0.045837402, -0.028244019, -0.020935059, 0.0037174225, 0.033081055, -0.061645508, 0.0030937195, 0.010871887, 0.018600464, 0.009765625, 0.05392456, -0.03390503, -0.0013217926, -0.034851074, -0.074035645, -0.02760315, 0.009284973, 0.033477783, 0.028701782, 0.02470398, -0.033721924, 0.032592773, -0.028381348, 0.0014533997, -0.034088135, 0.0018405914, 0.008743286, 0.0146865845, 0.0025024414, 0.024475098, -0.0031147003, -0.013877869, 0.023834229, 0.004585266, -0.006954193, 0.012023926, 0.0021839142, 0.022079468, -0.045196533, -0.030517578, 0.038482666, 0.033477783, -0.018234253, 0.055999756, -0.031585693, 0.03753662, 0.03262329, 0.038269043, 0.048065186, 0.008659363, 0.006713867, 0.0041503906, -0.016586304, -0.044158936, -0.0385437, -0.062927246, -0.027633667, -0.036956787, 0.004760742, -0.043670654, 0.0079193115, 0.00021994114, 0.015991211, -0.0048179626, 0.00592041, 0.028259277, -0.032043457, 0.01725769, -0.051116943, 0.037475586, -0.04107666, -0.0031776428, -0.035308838, 0.0035152435, 0.051971436, 0.030258179, 0.005683899, 0.00008004904, -0.03189087, 0.0033855438, 0.012382507, -0.012718201, 0.020431519, -0.0074539185, -0.0061836243, -0.012184143, 0.058166504, -0.0032901764, 0.03668213, 0.041931152, 0.029953003, 0.07299805, -0.057647705, -0.0062217712, 0.0025939941, 0.00025057793, -0.015296936, 0.021606445, -0.04611206, 0.016998291, -0.006832123, -0.008331299, -0.04296875, 0.05505371, -0.01638794, -0.064331055, 0.004058838, 0.014564514, 0.01876831, -0.0025234222, 0.026046753, -0.027954102, -0.012138367, -0.014762878, 0.0158844, 0.010566711, -0.010818481, -0.012496948, 0.02607727, -0.03286743, -0.018569946, -0.005870819, 0.012229919, -0.032287598, 0.018829346, -0.032928467, 0.050689697, -0.030349731, -0.044830322, 0.033569336, -0.015235901, -0.036132812, -0.029342651, 0.06439209, 0.007030487, 0.022506714, 0.03414917, -0.012832642, -0.040374756, -0.0027542114, -0.043945312, 0.015686035, 0.037506104, -0.016433716, 0.02368164, -0.040100098, -0.039916992, 0.03704834, -0.029830933, 0.050445557, -0.0491333, 0.0050582886, -0.06149292, 0.046661377, 0.005329132, -0.0725708, -0.008773804, -0.04525757, -0.035858154, 0.00047659874, -0.032684326, -0.047058105, -0.04055786, -0.019821167, 0.020141602, -0.0022640228, -0.018234253, -0.00762558, -0.0138168335, -0.076416016, -0.056610107, -0.04071045, -0.015792847, 0.017822266, -0.025817871, -0.030273438, -0.037628174, 0.0010099411, 0.06173706, 0.009185791, -0.008354187, -0.092285156, -0.05227661, 0.0019569397, 0.0035991669, -0.024658203, -0.01586914, 0.012908936, -0.007118225, -0.01889038, -0.0027389526, 0.05227661, -0.03363037, -0.076171875, -0.008743286, -0.015731812, 0.04055786, 0.006351471, -0.0069274902, -0.007648468, 0.05239868, -0.052886963, -0.024475098, -0.019561768, 0.031280518, -0.0030727386, -0.051086426, 0.013977051, 0.027664185, 0.02407837, -0.059051514, -0.000013828278, 0.026168823, 0.06317139, -0.03805542, 0.05606079, -0.0090789795, 0.017333984, 0.08312988, 0.07598877, 0.025726318, -0.08947754, -0.05227661, -0.049072266, 0.032562256, 0.037139893, 0.001250267, -0.037200928, 0.032440186, 0.0034770966, 0.0048599243, 0.004360199, -0.033813477, -0.011833191, -0.015991211, 0.020370483, 0.0011854172, 0.004798889, -0.03869629, 0.008712769, 0.0070991516, 0.02217102, -0.013504028, 0.010124207, -0.0034770966, 0.056854248, 0.018707275, -0.0446167, 0.041748047, 0.006252289, 0.0496521, -0.019302368, 0.024032593, -0.015403748, -0.008232117, 0.005168915, -0.00075531006, 0.013687134, 0.04144287, -0.030654907, 0.015609741, -0.036743164, -0.003435135, -0.006580353, -0.01776123, 0.020126343, -0.021621704, -0.01474762, -0.028045654, -0.021087646, -0.018936157, 0.018310547, 0.0050354004, -0.04208374, -0.042755127, -0.054748535, 0.03387451, -0.00687027 ], "summary": [ 0.043304443, -0.017944336, 0.009750366, -0.040863037, -0.01335144, -0.030380249, 0.0031414032, -0.01763916, 0.03137207, 0.024414062, -0.05331421, 0.0074920654, -0.02949524, -0.015838623, -0.005104065, -0.03186035, 0.012321472, 0.039855957, 0.042816162, -0.027053833, 0.01838684, -0.025314331, 0.022979736, 0.01576233, 0.012008667, -0.002986908, -0.07476807, 0.014572144, -0.0030384064, 0.006881714, -0.008224487, 0.0042152405, 0.025619507, 0.05142212, -0.048553467, 0.009544373, -0.0446167, 0.03933716, 0.013809204, 0.01928711, 0.037322998, -0.018127441, 0.08874512, -0.03543091, 0.035339355, 0.038085938, 0.02760315, -0.045074463, 0.009498596, 0.041107178, 0.021087646, -0.020736694, 0.009742737, -0.012138367, -0.010032654, -0.018203735, -0.010940552, -0.02545166, 0.030532837, 0.02746582, -0.009292603, -0.035064697, 0.02722168, -0.04876709, -0.022644043, 0.0077705383, 0.053497314, -0.0012683868, -0.018005371, -0.052490234, 0.01234436, 0.006965637, 0.00141716, -0.021911621, -0.011550903, -0.032043457, 0.03265381, -0.029388428, 0.0010528564, -0.021057129, 0.026641846, -0.022720337, 0.03552246, -0.020751953, -0.03475952, -0.038513184, 0.00038266182, 0.019332886, -0.036193848, -0.017242432, -0.038909912, -0.03173828, -0.054504395, 0.035705566, -0.0025520325, -0.0069465637, -0.0077209473, -0.027374268, 0.0034732819, -0.0039863586, 0.0112838745, -0.031188965, 0.0060920715, -0.0022125244, -0.003440857, 0.03945923, -0.038909912, -0.062561035, 0.03262329, 0.027313232, -0.008293152, -0.019973755, -0.014343262, -0.07086182, -0.020553589, 0.06530762, 0.0345459, -0.030792236, 0.032043457, -0.02468872, -0.0032863617, 0.045288086, -0.022659302, -0.014640808, 0.020889282, 0.0098724365, 0.011886597, -0.034332275, -0.007205963, 0.033477783, 0.021850586, 0.015716553, -0.06921387, -0.02053833, -0.06097412, -0.0018882751, 0.07397461, -0.0000051259995, 0.042999268, -0.027511597, 0.052886963, -0.012321472, -0.043670654, 0.053375244, 0.022918701, -0.0017213821, 0.045074463, 0.020050049, -0.034698486, -0.0022029877, 0.026107788, 0.072143555, 0.06237793, -0.01939392, -0.0059661865, -0.07952881, 0.019577026, -0.05810547, 0.028015137, -0.0647583, 0.01449585, -0.014709473, -0.00041341782, 0.043823242, -0.01776123, 0.04812622, 0.033203125, -0.01499939, -0.002822876, -0.078552246, -0.0026359558, 0.03237915, 0.03265381, -0.005680084, 0.0340271, -0.0024471283, -0.006629944, 0.07159424, 0.032989502, -0.035461426, -0.018920898, -0.044036865, 0.06750488, -0.017074585, -0.034088135, -0.0075683594, 0.019622803, 0.05355835, 0.006046295, 0.016174316, 0.031097412, -0.0038528442, 0.0034332275, 0.02015686, -0.0055503845, -0.032196045, -0.029434204, 0.0042495728, -0.037597656, -0.008430481, -0.03338623, 0.012046814, -0.0129852295, 0.0031032562, -0.04522705, 0.024734497, -0.027435303, 0.034240723, 0.003211975, 0.018005371, -0.004798889, -0.028884888, 0.016021729, -0.07122803, -0.022750854, 0.021850586, 0.021453857, -0.06726074, -0.03100586, -0.02784729, -0.04437256, 0.044128418, -0.089416504, 0.042114258, 0.009056091, 0.0038337708, -0.005016327, 0.0022392273, 0.03439331, 0.0051002502, 0.06414795, -0.040924072, -0.010253906, -0.00217247, 0.012893677, 0.014709473, 0.05239868, -0.041931152, 0.015945435, 0.022735596, 0.016998291, -0.048706055, -0.03881836, 0.01171875, -0.016220093, -0.0058937073, 0.027404785, -0.0034313202, 0.004951477, 0.034820557, 0.0317688, -0.0048332214, 0.00006181002, -0.036132812, 0.024673462, 0.0014743805, -0.031280518, 0.018997192, 0.018966675, -0.043395996, 0.011505127, -0.041290283, -0.007671356, -0.017562866, 0.021118164, -0.05303955, 0.0259552, 0.001950264, 0.016708374, -0.03010559, 0.0046691895, -0.022476196, -0.013717651, -0.0024375916, -0.01991272, -0.0034217834, -0.008728027, -0.00015962124, 0.018615723, -0.016433716, 0.00043654442, 0.038238525, 0.012916565, -0.01914978, 0.01335144, -0.013130188, 0.01058197, -0.019821167, -0.03366089, 0.0007572174, 0.012184143, 0.04135132, 0.016921997, -0.020187378, 0.0068893433, 0.0047187805, 0.02961731, 0.049560547, -0.021713257, -0.012565613, -0.027389526, -0.020309448, -0.0012235641, -0.051452637, 0.0027656555, -0.011047363, -0.008399963, 0.02180481, 0.017868042, -0.012702942, -0.048461914, 0.013679504, -0.0024051666, 0.03845215, -0.04940796, -0.06109619, 0.003238678, -0.0018234253, -0.001786232, 0.03137207, 0.06616211, -0.0051651, -0.00055885315, -0.023666382, -0.019134521, -0.037963867, -0.0077400208, -0.0284729, -0.017028809, 0.004299164, -0.020950317, -0.0048675537, -0.027755737, 0.037963867, 0.017105103, 0.0009832382, 0.014770508, -0.008049011, -0.000038325787, 0.021820068, 0.051086426, -0.012184143, -0.013824463, -0.0067596436, -0.01651001, -0.023513794, 0.05255127, -0.006416321, -0.018554688, 0.018096924, 0.01838684, -0.010025024, -0.029052734, -0.003408432, -0.010612488, 0.043060303, 0.030899048, -0.014099121, -0.0015964508, -0.06591797, 0.049438477, 0.016113281, 0.0012617111, -0.078430176, -0.0065307617, -0.02104187, 0.0074386597, -0.043151855, -0.019439697, 0.019226074, -0.008720398, 0.007293701, -0.027816772, -0.022735596, -0.040740967, 0.021652222, 0.040252686, 0.0010414124, -0.009635925, 0.02029419, 0.019821167, 0.016525269, 0.005958557, 0.00041365623, 0.05215454, 0.009780884, 0.03439331, 0.058013916, 0.01777649, -0.03265381, -0.025527954, 0.020843506, -0.06976318, -0.04083252, 0.0072288513, 0.036224365, -0.014472961, -0.049682617, 0.009361267, -0.042053223, 0.07922363, -0.009025574, -0.00573349, 0.007896423, 0.0041618347, -0.0063934326, 0.05899048, -0.002275467, 0.0121536255, -0.0206604, 0.021224976, -0.048706055, 0.008834839, -0.04949951, 0.029190063, -0.03616333, 0.033477783, 0.015670776, 0.044311523, -0.03878784, -0.025497437, 0.04373169, -0.008041382, -0.0048942566, 0.045776367, 0.0047035217, -0.020751953, -0.06390381, -0.013153076, 0.034576416, -0.004547119, 0.010597229, -0.021087646, 0.00045990944, -0.0015468597, 0.02130127, 0.0077934265, -0.0395813, 0.045532227, -0.040130615, -0.0113220215, -0.017028809, 0.009529114, 0.036895752, -0.01423645, 0.006416321, -0.013557434, -0.00881958, -0.0056495667, -0.007659912, -0.014282227, -0.0003323555, 0.034454346, 0.038604736, 0.0002501011, 0.03555298, -0.036499023, 0.009338379, 0.0446167, -0.057128906, -0.041748047, -0.020202637, -0.031585693, -0.028244019, 0.010139465, -0.026245117, -0.011505127, 0.013000488, -0.0010347366, 0.009941101, 0.019439697, 0.009422302, -0.036499023, -0.03213501, 0.025436401, -0.030685425, 0.014762878, -0.014434814, 0.050750732, -0.008918762, -0.02508545, -0.001291275, -0.07696533, 0.030822754, 0.04949951, -0.023147583, 0.014213562, 0.01625061, 0.021102905, -0.010131836, 0.02305603, -0.054779053, 0.041656494, -0.010482788, -0.00920105, -0.0048599243, -0.0012731552, 0.010101318, 0.0073280334, -0.05493164, -0.02986145, 0.0072517395, 0.019012451, 0.011756897, -0.028366089, 0.008758545, 0.010902405, 0.004058838, 0.0007157326, -0.051727295, 0.020599365, -0.03540039, 0.010803223, 0.033081055, -0.03250122, 0.01927185, -0.01184082, -0.012565613, -0.002937317, 0.0041275024, 0.038604736, 0.047454834, 0.059295654, 0.021759033, -0.045196533, -0.00074386597, -0.012565613, -0.018707275, -0.02281189, -0.023376465, -0.00020182133, 0.039215088, 0.027069092, 0.029891968, 0.018493652, -0.009338379, -0.039245605, 0.015182495, 0.0104522705, -0.015457153, -0.01966858, -0.013305664, 0.017959595, 0.0104599, -0.0030975342, 0.037872314, -0.026672363, 0.040527344, -0.0073127747, 0.025680542, -0.0077934265, -0.0032253265, -0.045806885, -0.056854248, -0.009468079, -0.025634766, -0.011489868, 0.010955811, 0.0009851456, -0.02508545, -0.004611969, 0.008575439, 0.0025196075, -0.019348145, 0.06964111, 0.0184021, -0.0005493164, -0.05618286, 0.028930664, -0.028686523, -0.017425537, -0.034423828, 0.032409668, -0.014770508, 0.0015907288, -0.02722168, -0.03994751, -0.002576828, 0.028442383, 0.09979248, 0.0362854, -0.01184082, -0.13098145, -0.0725708, -0.031066895, -0.0056266785, 0.022994995, -0.023025513, -0.0143966675, -0.00737381, 0.035003662, -0.02130127, -0.0043792725, -0.011634827, -0.03201294, -0.0284729, 0.018829346, -0.0010089874, 0.0131073, -0.00920105, 0.006465912, -0.0038986206, 0.00030446053, -0.02897644, 0.025848389, -0.05142212, 0.00018846989, -0.029205322, 0.024871826, 0.036254883, -0.03805542, -0.06750488, 0.027374268, 0.027923584, 0.050048828, -0.021865845, -0.017669678, 0.004306793, -0.01928711, 0.000015377998, 0.0209198, -0.016479492, 0.031555176, 0.010375977, 0.037994385, 0.019622803, -0.0012454987, 0.06542969, 0.030883789, -0.026016235, 0.04562378, -0.02217102, -0.06304932, -0.09088135, -0.03656006, 0.0904541, -0.015365601, -0.043548584, 0.013702393, 0.027023315, -0.012908936, -0.026382446, -0.03527832, 0.050689697, -0.019500732, -0.009094238, -0.000038802624, -0.010269165, -0.025848389, -0.03213501, 0.029220581, -0.0007147789, 0.021774292, -0.0001796484, -0.018478394, -0.010887146, 0.015350342, 0.021255493, 0.0008249283, -0.06585693, -0.046417236, -0.005329132, 0.035217285, -0.051879883, -0.00053834915, 0.017456055, -0.027908325, 0.026535034, -0.03527832, 0.012397766, 0.0031547546, -0.05227661, -0.008621216, -0.015525818, 0.0015163422, 0.050048828, -0.02746582, 0.022949219, -0.012252808, -0.00054359436, -0.004611969, -0.011985779, 0.03048706, -0.0000046491623, -0.024978638, 0.03463745, -0.013130188, -0.0071525574, 0.06008911, 0.044769287, -0.01576233, -0.029220581, 0.062805176, -0.060272217, -0.05343628, 0.022857666, -0.009017944, -0.0011968613, 0.0031414032, -0.020812988, 0.0013227463, -0.0025749207, 0.00415802, 0.012191772, -0.026763916, 0.014854431, -0.0446167, 0.0093688965, 0.00217247, 0.009689331, -0.0061073303, -0.02571106, -0.033599854, -0.0064926147, 0.01914978, -0.014656067, 0.0033569336, 0.024780273, 0.013793945, -0.0032863617, 0.013420105, 0.018417358, 0.045898438, -0.0076828003, 0.021728516, -0.02166748, -0.00096797943, 0.020202637, -0.011650085, -0.03543091, 0.0058250427, -0.01360321, 0.007156372, -0.0039711, -0.00831604, -0.009536743, 0.026382446, 0.028198242, 0.035339355, 0.017730713, -0.07489014, 0.01725769, 0.013923645, 0.0074539185, -0.03302002, 0.008552551, 0.018966675, -0.08148193, 0.013381958, -0.008544922, 0.035369873, -0.01675415, -0.022399902, -0.032928467, 0.028045654, -0.012283325, -0.0075149536, -0.026367188, -0.014953613, 0.01108551, -0.08380127, 0.015975952, 0.017410278, 0.013580322, 0.050354004, 0.048217773, -0.028167725, 0.026123047, -0.015914917, -0.0027008057, -0.01838684, 0.017150879, -0.021621704, 0.020095825, 0.013168335, -0.013877869, -0.019943237, 0.0027217865, 0.005508423, 0.015022278, -0.013366699, 0.04244995, 0.035217285, 0.024871826, 0.0024051666, 0.025604248, 0.016159058, 0.004299164, 0.032592773, 0.01826477, -0.0423584, 0.012145996, 0.021255493, -0.036865234, -0.008644104, -0.041046143, -0.025299072, -0.00059843063, -0.04928589, -0.029418945, -0.019439697, -0.0049476624, -0.028305054, -0.0019798279, -0.025604248, 0.014770508, 0.024734497, 0.0068473816, -0.023040771, 0.08099365, -0.012123108, 0.030426025, -0.013900757, -0.06896973, 0.027908325, -0.007194519, -0.03744507, 0.0030651093, -0.049957275, -0.049468994, 0.046691895, 0.055603027, 0.009552002, -0.009902954, -0.025924683, 0.021194458, 0.012458801, -0.008964539, -0.008399963, -0.026626587, 0.04296875, -0.0143585205, 0.053527832, 0.017990112, 0.04675293, 0.021011353, 0.045562744, 0.060516357, -0.032928467, 0.006248474, 0.030670166, -0.016555786, -0.00014865398, 0.007144928, 0.009361267, -0.024246216, -0.012756348, -0.0027256012, -0.04321289, 0.060058594, 0.027862549, -0.01939392, 0.022903442, 0.015991211, 0.0077171326, -0.024658203, 0.008026123, -0.03201294, -0.028930664, -0.034179688, -0.012145996, -0.007713318, -0.037841797, -0.010215759, 0.0069503784, 0.019195557, 0.010307312, 0.014907837, 0.0053634644, 0.035583496, 0.035980225, -0.02861023, 0.053741455, -0.0015745163, -0.016937256, 0.03942871, 0.034423828, -0.025177002, 0.017059326, 0.076538086, 0.018951416, 0.01927185, 0.015426636, -0.043060303, -0.0058631897, 0.027877808, -0.004711151, 0.013755798, -0.024230957, -0.019744873, -0.02999878, 0.013534546, 0.032684326, 0.017532349, 0.049926758, 0.0340271, -0.011741638, -0.017364502, -0.066467285, 0.029693604, -0.056121826, -0.027786255, 0.046325684, -0.08709717, -0.028533936, 0.0071144104, -0.022888184, -0.009475708, -0.016983032, -0.035247803, 0.018005371, 0.016845703, -0.038513184, 0.012176514, 0.020690918, -0.08441162, -0.088134766, -0.035003662, -0.041137695, 0.0132369995, -0.042877197, -0.0056381226, -0.0070495605, 0.0074272156, 0.04949951, 0.009918213, 0.046325684, -0.06124878, -0.06359863, 0.03366089, 0.030639648, -0.0065231323, -0.016799927, -0.079956055, 0.019882202, -0.030380249, -0.00983429, 0.068359375, 0.023132324, -0.07495117, -0.018951416, 0.00982666, 0.02998352, -0.035583496, -0.019927979, -0.012001038, 0.047210693, -0.048675537, -0.037597656, -0.020248413, 0.01663208, 0.0079193115, -0.014762878, -0.025161743, 0.015335083, 0.02017212, -0.055511475, -0.017227173, 0.009292603, 0.07684326, -0.048736572, 0.018432617, -0.009765625, 0.02671814, 0.094055176, 0.090026855, 0.018844604, -0.066589355, -0.010276794, -0.024398804, 0.07104492, 0.0041275024, -0.05114746, -0.0022029877, 0.015716553, -0.029693604, 0.0064888, 0.02331543, 0.002626419, 0.016052246, -0.019638062, 0.0259552, -0.020889282, -0.0018339157, -0.009857178, -0.005783081, -0.0034675598, 0.0029029846, 0.006969452, -0.004650116, -0.015014648, 0.06994629, 0.024291992, -0.023590088, 0.037506104, -0.0065307617, 0.053466797, -0.03289795, 0.061950684, -0.027542114, -0.0368042, -0.0050849915, 0.04107666, 0.024169922, 0.007507324, -0.03842163, 0.031707764, -0.09350586, 0.009765625, -0.01676941, -0.013038635, -0.004611969, -0.038909912, -0.0009288788, -0.02897644, -0.0020980835, 0.007736206, -0.01902771, 0.0062026978, -0.0256958, 0.0118637085, -0.07824707, -0.015914917, 0.023590088 ] }